Studies in Surface Science and Catalysis 111 CATALYST DEACTIVATION 1997
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
Studies in Surface Science and Catalysis A d v i s o r y E d i t o r s : B. D e l m o n and J.T, Yates Vol. 111
CATALYST DEACTIVATION 1997 Proceedings of the 7th International Symposium Cancun, Mexico, October 5-8, 1997 Editors
C.H. Bartholomew Brigham Young University, Provo, U.S.A. G.A. Fuentes A. Metropolitana-lztapalapa University, Mexico, Mexico
1997 ELSEVIER A m s t e r d a m m Lausanne m N e w York m O x f o r d - - S h a n n o n - - S i n g a p o r e - - Tokyo
ELSEVIER SCIENCE B.V. Sara Burgerhartstraat 25 P.O. Box 211, 1000 AE Amsterdam, The Netherlands
ISBN 0-444-82603-3 91997 Elsevier Science B.V. All rights reserved. No part of this publication may be reproduced, stored in a retrieval system or transmitted in any form or by any means, electronic, mechanical, photocopying, recording or otherwise, without the prior written permission of the publisher, Elsevier Science B.V., Copyright & Permissions Department, P.O. Box 521, 1000 AM Amsterdam, The Netherlands. Special regulations for readers in the U.S.A.- This publication has been registered with the Copyright Clearance Center Inc. (CCC), 222 Rosewood Drive, Danvers, MA 01923. Information can be obtained from the CCC about conditions under which photocopies of parts of this publication may be made in the U.S.A. All other copyright questions, including photocopying outside of the U.S.A., should be referred to the copyright owner, Elsevier Science B.V., unless otherwise specified. No responsibility is assumed by the publisher for any injury and/or damage to persons or property as a matter of products liability, negligence or otherwise, or from any use or operation of any methods, products, instructions or ideas contained in the material herein. This book is printed on acid-free paper. Printed in The Netherlands
CONTENTS
Preface
xiii
Review Articles (Plenary and Award Lectures) Roles of Acidity and Pore Structure in the Deactivation of Zeolites by Carbonaceous Deposits (Plenary lecture) M. Guisnet, P. Magnoux, and D. Martin Impact of Sulfur on Three-Way Automotive Catalyst Performance and Catalyst Diagnostics (Plenary lecture) D. D. Beck
21
Solid State Reactions in Catalysts: An Approach to Real Active Systems and their Deactivation (Founders award lecture) B. Delmon
39
Coke Formation in Catalytic Processes: Kinetics and Catalyst Deactivation (Founders award lecture) G. F. Froment
53
Catalyst Deactivation: How We Cannot Yet Subvert Nature (Maxted award lecture) J. B. Butt
69
Catalyst Deactivation: Opportunity amidst Woe (Maxted award lecture) E. E. Petersen
87
Topical Articles (Oral and Poster Presentations) Carbon Deposition and Coking The Relationship Between Metal Particle Morphology and the Structural Characteristics of Carbon Deposits R. T. K. Baker, M. S. Kim, A. Chambers, C. Park and N. M. Rodriguez
99
Self-Poisoning and Aging of Pd-Ag/AI~O~ in Semi-Hydrogenation of 1,3Butadiene: Effects of Surface Inhomogeneity Caused by Hydrocarbonaceous Deposits A. Sarkany
111
Influence of the Support on the Deactivation of Nickel Zeolite Catalysts During the Conversion of Phenylacetylene E. D. Gamas and I. Schifier
119
Activation and Deactivation of the Zeolite Ferrierite for Olefin Conversions K. P. de Jong, H. H. Mooiweer, J. G. Buglass and P. K. Maarsen
127
Deactivation of Ferrierite during the 1-Butene Skeletal Isomerization R. A. Comelli, Z. R. Finelli, N. S. Ffgoli and C. A. Querini
139
vi
Alcohol Dehydration Reactions as Chemical Precursors for Coke Formation and Acidity Probes in Tungstated Zirconia Catalysts G. Larsen, E. Lotero, M. Nabity, L. Petkovic and C. A. Querini
147
Determination of Coke Deposition on Metal Active Sites of Propane Dehydrogenation Catalysts P. Praserthdam, T. Mongkhonsi, S. Kunatippapong, B. Jaikaew and N. Lim
153
Chemicals
The Role of Coke Deposition in the Conversion of Methanol to Olefins over SAPO-34 D. Chen, H. P. Rebo, K. Moljord and A. Holmen
159
Deactivation and Regeneration of Alkane Dehydrogenation Catalysts S. D. Jackson, J. Grenfell I. M. Matheson, S. Munro, R. Raval and G. Webb
167
A Novel Mechanism of Catalyst Deactivation in Liquid Phase Synthesis Gas-to DME Reactions X. D. Peng, B. A. Toseland and R. P. Underwood
175
Activity, Selectivity and Coking of Bimetallic Ni-Co-Spinel Catalysts in Selective Hydrogenation Reactions. J. C. Rodrfguez, C. Guimon, A. J. Marchi, A. Borgna and A. Monz6n.
183
Stability and Regeneration of Supported PtSn Catalysts for Propane Dehydrogenation C. L. Padr6, S. R. de Miguel, A. A. Castro and O. A. Scelza.
191
Deactivation and Shape Selectivity Effects in Toluene Nitration over Zeolite Catalysts J. M. Smith, H. Liu and D. E. Resasco
199
Regeneration of VPMeO Catalysts for n-Butane Oxidation by Means of Mechanochemical and Barothermal Treatments V. Zazhigalov, A. Kharlamov, J. Haber, J. Stoch, V. Yaremenko, L Bacherikova, L. Bogutskaya
207
Environmental
Sulfur Tolerance of Cu- and H-Mordenite Zeolite Catalysts for the Reduction of NO by Hydrocarbons M. H. Kim, L-S. Nam and Y. G. Kim
213
Deactivation of Cu-ZSM-5 during Selective Catalytic Reduction of NO by Propane under Wet Conditions A. Marffnez, S. A. G6mez and G. A. Fuentes
225
o~
VII
H-Mordenite Deactivation during the SCR of NOx. Adsorption and Diffusion of Probe Molecules on Fresh and Deactivated Catalysts E. E. Mir6, L. Costa, J. M. Dereppe and J. O. Petunchi
231
Deactivation of Pt/Alumina Catalysts for the Hydrodechlorination of 1,1,1Trichloroethane K. A. Frankel, B. W.-L. Jang, G. W. Roberts, J. J. Spivey
239
Understanding Claus Catalyst Deactivation Mechanisms" Optimization of Alumina Using Physico-chemical Parameters C. N~dez and J.-L. Ray
251
Deactivation by Poisoning and the Improvement of Three Way Catalysts for Natural Gas-Fueled Engines T. Tabata, H. Kawashima and K. Baba
259
Deactivation of Manganese-Cerium Oxide Catalysts during Wet Oxidation of Phenol P. Oelker, A. Bernier, P. Ruiz, B. Delmon and P. lsnard
267
Modeling and Kinetic Studies Coke Deactivation of Hydrotreating Catalysts: A Variable Site Model F. E. Massoth
275
On the Metal Deposition Process during Hydrodemetallation of VanadylTetraphenylporphyrin J. P. Janssens, R. M. de Deugd, A. D. van Langeveld, S. T. Sie and J. A. Moulijn
283
Coke Formation in Fluid Catalytic Cracking M. A. den Hollander, M. Makkee and J. A. Moulijn
295
Mathematical Modeling of Deactivation by Coke Formation in the Cracking of Gasoil H. S. Cerqueira, E. C. Biscaia Jr. and E. Falabella S.-Aguiar
303
Catalyst Decay by Simultaneous Sintering and Poisoning: Effects of Intraparticle and Interfacial Gradients M. Chocron, N. Amadeo and M. Laborde
311
A Model for Catalyst Deactivation in Industrial Catalytic Reforming L. M. Rodrfguez Otal, T. Viveros Garcia and M. Sdnchez Rubio
319
Petroleum Effects of the Metal-Metal Interactions on the Stability of Pt-Re/A1,0cC1 Reforming Catalysts J. Barbier, P. Marecot and C. L. Pieck
327
Temperature Programmed Oxidation of Deactivated Pt/Nb,O, Catalysts D. A. G. Aranda, J. C. Alfonso, R. Frety and M. Schmal
335
viii Effects of Sulfidation of Mo Nitride and CoMo Nitride Catalysts on Thiophene HDS S.-K. lhm, D.-W. Kim and D.-K. Lee
343
Catalyst Deactivation by Metals and Coke During Hydrodemetallation M. Nu~ez, E. G6mez, C. Suarez and E. Carmona
351
Deactivation of Pt-Sn/A1,O, Catalysts by Coking: Influence of the Preparation Method. G. Corro, P. Marecot and J. Barbier
359
New Developments in FCC Catalyst Deactivation by Metals: Metals Mobility and the Vanadium Mobility Index (VMI) L. T. Boock, J. Deady, T. F. Lim and G. Yaluris
367
Stability of an FCC Catalyst Matrix for Processing Gas Oil with Resid P. Gamero M., C. Maldonado M., J. C. Moreno M., O. Guzman M., E. Mojica M. and R. Gonzalez S.
375
Kinetics of Coke Combustion during Temperature-Programmed Oxidation of Deactivated Cracking Catalysts C. L. Minh, C. Li and T. C. Brown
383
Activity, Selectivity and Deactivation of Y Zeolite: A Compromise in Fluid Catalytic Cracking Catalysts C. Maldonado M., P. Gamero M., F. Hernandez B., J. A. Montoya F., J. Navarrete, J. A. Toledo A., A. Vazquez R. and A. Vargas
391
M/H-MFI Catalyst Deactivation and Reaction Kinetics for n-Octane Transformation J. Papa, F. Santos, M. J. Becerra, G. Giannetto, F. Yanez and L. Garcia
399
Isobutane Alkylation with C, Olefins: Low Temperature Regeneration of Solid Acid Catalysts with Ozone C. A. Querini, E. Roa, C. L. Pieck and J. M. Parera
407
Influence of Chloride during Coke Burning of a Naphtha Reforming Catalyst Coked in a Commercial Cycle M. C. Rangel, M. N. M. Barbosa, C. L. Pieck and N. S. Figoli
415
Deactivation of Pt-Au/A1,O, Catalysts Prepared by Surface Redox Reaction: Effects of Sulfur and Coke Deposition G. Espinosa, G. Del Angel J. Barbier, P. Marecot and L Schifier
421
Nature of Coke Formed from Tri-isopropylbenzene Over USY Zeolites with Different Rare Earth Content C. A. Henriques, E. Falabella S.-Aguiar, M. L. Murta Valle, S. Varela and J. L. F. Monteiro
427
Differential Effect of Coke Burning with Oxygen or Ozone on Pt-Re Interaction in Pt-Re/A1,O, C. L. Pieck and J. M. Parera
433
ix Hydrodesulfurization of Dibenzothiophene on a Nitrided Supported Molybdena-Alumina Catal st M. Nagai, Y. Goto, H. Sasuga and S. Omi
439
Poisoning Industrial Evaluation of Selective Hydrogenation Catalyst Poisoning B. Didillon, J. Cosyns, C. Cameron, D. Uzio, P. Sarrazin, J. P. Boitiaux
447
The Mechanism of Metal Poisoning by Cyclic Deactivation in Fluid Cracking Catalysts F. Hern6ndez, R. Garcfa de Le6n, E. M6gica, J. C. Moreno, R. Gonz61ez and E. Garciafigueroa
455
AFM and XPS Studies of Thiophene and 1-Butanethiol Deactivation of Pd/AI~O, Model Catalysts During 1,3-Butadiene Hydrogenation K.-H. Lee, R. Catani, R. Miglio and E. E. Wolf
463
Sulfur Poisoning of Nickel-based Hot Gas Cleaning Catalysts in Synthetic Gasification Gas J. Hepola and P. Simell
471
Effects of H~S on Bifunctional Catalysts C. Flego, L. Galasso, S. Vidotto and G. Faraci
479
Performance of Ni/AI~O, Pellets Poisoned by Thiophene D. Rusic and S. Zrncevic
487
Study of the Simultaneous Deactivation by Coke and Sulfur of Naptha Reforming Catalysts Using a Bifunctional Test Reaction A. Borgna, T. F. Garetto and C. R. Apesteguia
495
Syngas Conversion Deactivation and Attrition of Iron Catalysts in Synthesis Gas N. B. Jackson, A. K. Datye, L. Mansker, R. J. O'Brien and B. H. Davis
501
Temperature-Programmed Reaction Study of Carbon Transformations on Iron Fischer-Tropsch Catalysts During Steady-State Synthesis S. A. Eliason and C. H. Bartholomew
517
Deactivation of Iron-based Catalysts for Slurry Phase Fischer-Tropsch Synthesis A. P. Raje, R. J. O'Brien, L. Xu and B. H. Davis
527
Effects of Reduction and Regeneration Conditions on the Activity of CuOZnO Catalysts C. E. Quincoces, N. E. Amadeo and M. G. Gonz6lez
535
Effects of Promoters and Supports on Coke Formation on Pt Catalysts during CH, Reforming with CO~ S. M. Stagg and D. E. Resasco
543
Ni-based Catalysts for Methane Conversion with Carbon Dioxide. Catalyst Pellet Deformation Induced by Coking and Gasification L. A. Rudnitsky
551
Carbon Formation from Decomposition of CH, on Supported Ni Catalysts R. LCdeng, M. Barr~-Chassonnery, M. Fathi, O. A. Rokstad and A. Holmen
561
On Limitations of Regenerating an HZSM-5 Catalyst for the MTG Process A. T. Aguayo, A. G. Gayubo, J. M. Ortega, A. L. Mor6n and J. Bilbao
567
Thermal Degradation Asymptotic Behavior during Sintering of Supported Catalysts G.A. Fuentes and E. Salinas-Rodriguez
573
Sintering and Redispersion of Supported Metals: Perspectives from the Literature of the Past Decade C. H. Bartholomew
585
The Existence of an Unusual Reversible Deactivation Phenomenon Associated with Preferential Surface Segregation in Bimetallic Systems R. T. K. Baker, A. Chambers, C. Park and N. M. Rodriguez
593
Vaporization-Assisted Degradation of High Temperature Combustion Catalysts J. G. McCarty, K.-H. Lau and D. L. Hildenbrand
601
Deactivation by Sintering and Coking of Sol-Gel NiO-AI~O,-TiO~ Hydrogenation Catalysts J. C. Rodrfguez, T. Viveros and A. Monz6n
609
Sintering of Ni/SiO~ Catalysts Prepared by Impregnation and DepositionPrecipitation during CO Hydrogenation G. Martra, H. Swaan, C. Mirodatos, M. Kermarec and C. Louis
617
Techniques An Experimental Protocol for Studying Kinetics and Catalyst Deactivation: Application to Heptane Reforming on Pt-Re/AI~O, K. Liu, S. C. Fung, T. C. Ho and D. S. Rumschitzki
625
Characterizing the Framework Demetallation of Environmentally Relevant Zeolites Using IR, NMR and Neutron Diffraction Techniques M. T. Paffett, J. Szanyi, R. M. Jacubinas, K. C. Ott, R. Von Dreele, C. D. Hughes and W. L. Earl
639
xi Study of the Deactivation of an HY Zeolite Pellet Using 129XeNMR Spectroscopy and ~H NMR Imaging T. Domeniconi, J.-L. Bonardet, M.-A. Springuel-Huet, J. Fraissard and J.-M. Dereppe
647
AFM Study of Carbon Formation on a Manganese Oxide Catalyst N. Batina, L. M. Ioffe and Y. G. Borodko
655
Novel Regeneration Method for Deactivated Noble Metal Catalysts L. A. Camacho, C. Park and N. M. Rodriguez
665
Estimation of Reversible and Irreversible Coke by Transient Experiments M. Larsson, N. Henriksson and B. Andersson
673
Deactivation Studies of Ni/AI~O, ZSM-5 Catalysts: Effect of Nickel Incorporation J. R. Grzechowiak, A. Masalska, L. Kepinski and J. Rynkowski
681
Author Index
687
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
xiii
PREFACE We are pleased to present the Proceedings of the 7th International Symposium on Catalyst Deactivation held in Cancun, Mexico on October 5-8, 1997. This 3-day symposium continued in the tradition of the high-quality symposia on Catalyst Deactivation held previously in North America (Berkeley and Evanston) and Belgium (Antwerp and Ostend); it featured 7 plenary and award lectures, 60 oral presentations, and over 20 poster papers. Most of the papers presented at the symposium are contained in this volume. Catalyst Deactivation 1997 focused on 9 key topical areas: carbon deposition and coke formation, chemicals, environmental catalysis, modeling, petroleum processing, poisoning, syngas conversion, techniques, and thermal degradation. All of these areas were well represented at the meeting; moreover, several review articles were presented that provide perspectives on new research and development thrusts. The strong participation by authors and attendees provides evidence that the field of Catalyst Deactivation (despite its rather morbid connotation) is alive, well and growing. An innovation this year was the presentation of Founders Awards to Professors Alexis T. Bell, Benard Delmon, and Gilbert F. Froment who organized the first four symposia in this series and Maxted awards to Professor John B. Butt and Eugene E. Petersen for their important contributions to the field of Catalyst Deactivation. The proceedings of the meeting are organized with six review and award articles at the front of the volume followed by topical articles in alphabetical order by topic. Under each topical area a keynote, 5-6 oral, and 2-3 poster papers of 12-14, 8-10, and 6 pages each follow in that order. A list of authors is provided at the end of the book. It should be emphasized that all of the papers were ranked and reviewed by members of Scientific Committee, whose names are listed on the page following. In most cases authors were asked to respond with a revision of their paper. Papers were also carefully edited, and more than 20 papers were largely rewritten and retyped by the Editors and their staff. We are grateful to the members of the Scientific committee for their help in the difficult task of selecting from submitted contributions, the papers assembled here and for their dedicated efforts in reviewing and in some case partly editing the manuscripts. We also thank our secretarial/editorial staff (especially Melissa Ellis, Beth Graham, Allyson Kauwe, Miriam CanalLee, Matthew Reynolds, and Lance Woolley) for many hours spent in assembling and correcting manuscripts and our wives for their patience regarding time spent away from our families. CALVIN H. BARTHOLOMEW GUSTAVO A. FUENTES
Brigham Young University Universidad A. Metropolitana-Iztapalapa
xiv
SCIENTIFIC COMMITTEE MEMBERS DR. CARLOS R. APESTEGUIA Instituto de Investigaciones en Catalisis y Petroquimica (INCAPE) PROFESSOR DADY B. DADYBURJOR West Virginia University DR. SHUN C. FUNG Exxon Research & Engineering Co. DR. JAN J. LEROU E. I. Du Pont De Nemours & Co., Inc. DR. JON G. MCCARTY SRI International PROFESSOR JACOB A. MOULIJN Delft University of Technology DR. JAMES. J. SPIVEY Center for Process Research, Research Triangle Institute PROFESSOR EDUARDO E. WOLF University of Notre Dame
9
Elsevier Science B. V. All rights reserved
Catalyst Deactivation 1997 C.H. Bartholomewand G.A. Fuentes, editors
R o l e s o f Acidity and Pore Carbonaceous Deposits
Structure
in the
D e a c t i v a t i o n o f Zeolites by
M. Guisnet, P. Magnoux and D. Martin Laboratoire de Catalyse en Chimie Organique, CNRS - Universit6 de Poitiers UMR 6503, Chimie 7, 40, avenue du Recteur Pineau, 86022 Poitiers Cedex, France Tel.: (33) 5.49.45.39.05 - Fax: (33) 5.49.45.34.99- E-mail:
[email protected]
Deactivation of zeolite acid catalysts during hydrocarbon transformations is mainly due to the formation and the retention inside the pores of heavy secondary products. The effects of pore structure of zeolites and of their acidity on the rate of formation of these carbonaceous compounds, on their composition and on their deactivating effect are examined. The roles of strength and density of active acid sites (often protonic sites) are generally limited in comparison to the roles played by size and shape of cavities (or channel intersections) and by the size of their apertures. The formation of carbonaceous compounds (coke) and the deactivation that they cause are clearly shape selective processes. Their formation occurs through a nucleation-growth pathway. In the range of temperatures of refining and petrochemical processes nucleation is due to trapping in the cavities of coke precursors. Condensation and hydrogen transfer reactions are involved both in the formation of coke precursors and in their growth. Four modes of deactivation can be distinguished : (1) limitation or (2) blockage of the access of the reactant to the active sites of a cavity in which one coke molecule is located, due to steric reasons or to a competition for adsorption between reactant or coke molecules and (3) steric limitation or (4) blockageof the access of the reactant to the active sites of cavities or of channels in which no coke molecule is located. The deactivation of monodimensional zeolites and of zeolites with trap cavities (large cavities with small apertures) only occurs through Modes 3 and 4, hence is very rapid. With the other types of zeolites, deactivation passes successively from Mode 1 to Mode 4 as the coke content increases; Modes 3 and 4 are due to the coke molecules which overflow onto the outer surface of zeolite crystallites.
1. INTRODUCTION Zeolites have replaced corrosive and polluting acids (H2SO4,A1C13, chlorinated alumina) or less acidic solids (e.g. silica alumina) as catalysts in many refining and petrochemical processes [ 1-2] and should substitute for them in the synthesis of fine and specialty chemicals [3-5]. The choice of zeolite catalysts is firstly due to their remarkable acid properties. Indeed the density and the strength of their acid sites can be varied on a large scale and can thus be adjusted to the desired catalytic reactions. Redox components can be easily introduced in the pores of acid zeolites in a well dispersed form, which leads to bifunctional catalysts which are of great interest for catalyzing transformations requiring successive acid and redox sites
(hydroisomerization, hydrocracking, etc). The high thermostability of zeolites is another characteristic which renders them particularly attractive for processes requiring repetitive regeneration steps at high temperatures such as FCC. Another major advantage of zeolites is their well defined pore structure, with apertures and cavities of approximately the size of organic molecules. Therefore, the selectivity of these molecular sieves depends not only on the intrinsic properties of the active sites but also on the pore structure. This so called shape selectivity of zeolites has stimulated research on the synthesis of new molecular sieves and brought about the development of various commercial processes, e.g. selectoforming, dewaxing, toluene disproportionation into paraxylene, etc. [6]. Separation processes based on these molecular sieve properties of zeolites (e.g. separation of iso and n-alkanes) have also been developed [7]. There are different reasons for deactivation of zeolite catalysts during the commercial processes: a. Poisoning of the active sites either by feed components and impurities or by carbonaceous deposits, b. Limited access of the reactant to the active sites due to partial or complete blockage by carbonaceous deposits or by extraframework species resulting from dealumination etc., c. Framework alteration, d. Sintering of supported metals (in bifunctional catalysts). Carbonaceous deposits are the principle cause of zeolite deactivation in processes involving hydrocarbon conversions. Firstly they can poison active sites or block their access. Secondly, their removal, which is carried out through oxidative treatment at high temperatures, has detrimental effects i.e., dealumination and degradation of the zeolite and sintering of supported metals. In most commercial processes the cost of catalyst deactivation is very high. Hence, facilitating catalyst stability and optimizing regeneration have become at least as important as controlling the activity and the selectivity. Therefore, while industrial laboratories try to find technical solutions, academic laboratories should establish the conceptual background indispensible to the understanding of the concomitant problems. This latter activity is largely carried out in the case of zeolite catalysts owing to the development of an efficient method for determining the composition of the carbonaceous deposits responsible for their deactivation [8]. Indeed, contrary to what is found with conventional catalysts, the carbonaceous compounds, being formed in pores of molecular size, are not very bulky; hence they can be identified and their distribution quantitatively established by GC/MS coupling. The aim of this paper is to show how pore structure and acidity of zeolites determine the rate of formation of carbonaceous deposits, their composition, their location and their deactivating effects. The characteristics of active acid sites and of the pore structures of the zeolites used in this work will be presented first.
2. THE ORIGIN OF ACTIVITY AND SELECTIVITY OF ACID ZEOLITES 2.1. Acid sites and activity In the transformation of hydrocarbons via acid catalysis, the activity, stability and selectivity of zeolites are obviously determined to a large extent by the characteristics of the acid sites, i.e. chemical structure, strength, density and accessibility. For skeletal
transformations of hydrocarbons, the rate depends essentially on the Br~insted acidity [9], as shown by the good correlations found between the concentration of Br6nsted acid sites and the rate of various reactions, e.g. cumene dealkylation [ 10], xylene isomerization [ 11 ], toluene and ethylbenzene disproportionation [ 13], and n-hexane cracking [ 14]. Apparently, isolated Lewis acid sites are not active in these reactions. However it is well known that Lewis acid sites located in the vicinity of protonic sites can increase the latter's strength and consequently their activity [15]. Thus in HEMT zeolites (Figure 1), an IR band corresponding to OH groups with very strong acidity appears at 3600 cm 1 in samples mildly dealuminated by steaming. These hydroxyl groups would correspond to a zeolite OH of high vibrational frequency interacting with cationic extraframework aluminium (EFAL) species located in sodalite cages. The corresponding protonic acid sites are at least 3 times more active for mxylene transformation than those which do not interact with EFAL species [16]. The acid sites (Lewis and/or Br~nsted) and base sites, e.g. oxygen atoms of the framework, can participate together (acid-base bifunctional catalysis) in various reactions such as cis-trans and double-bond-shift isomerization of alkenes [9]. While the OH groups in amorphous aluminosilicates are terminal, those of zeolites are primarily bridging, which explains their stronger acidity [17]. Furthermore, it is well recognized that the number of neighboring aluminium atoms (hence of OH groups) determines the strength of a given acid site, the strongest acid sites corresponding to isolated OH groups [18]. The minimum strength that the acid sites must have in order to be active depends very much on the reaction considered [9]. Generally the more difficult the reaction (hence the lower its rate) the greater the minimum acid strength required for its catalysis [19]. Thus, the difficult n-hexane cracking requires very strong acid sites (able to retain pyridine adsorbed above 520~ while the very facile skeletal isomerization of 2,2- and 2,3-dimethylbutenes can be catalyzed by very weak acid sites (able to retain pyridine adsorbed above 220~ [19]. Another parameter, the distance between acid sites, could play a role in bimolecularreactions (e.g. hydrogen transfer [20,21 ]), most probably because their catalysis involves several acid sites. The location of protonic sites in the zeolite pores can also affect the catalytic activity. Indeed, some of the sites can be inaccessible by the reactant (e.g. OH groups located in the sodalite cages of Y and EMT zeolites) or accessible with difficulty. 2.2. Pore structure of zeolites Zeolite structure types are described in the well-known Atlas of Zeolite Structure Types [22]. They can be classified into three categories depending on the number of oxygen atoms (or of Al+Si) in the pore apertures. Small pore zeolites (openings of 3.5-4.5 A formed by tings of 8 oxygen atoms) such as A zeolite (LTA) and erionite (ERI) can sorb only linear aliphatic molecules. Those with average pore size (4.5-6.0 A, 10 oxygen atoms) such as ZSM5 (MFI) can sorb branched aliphatic compounds and alkyl monoaromatics while those with large pores (6.0-8.0 A, 12 oxygen atoms) such as zeolites Y (FAU) and EMT can accept very bulky compounds. Zeolites with more than one pore system are classified according to the aperture of the largest pore e.g. offretite (OFF) is classified as a large pore zeolite.
2.9 x 5.7 A
Iii~~ i i!ii!i~ lii iiiiiilI
~~--~ 6.3 A
615 x 7.0 A
Ii. . .i. .~1 lii!!!!iiii . . . .!!! ... I
l I i!iiii!i!!ii I liii~!!!i!ii!!iiiiiiiiiiI t!iiil!iiiiir!i!lli!iiiiiiiii~
a) FAU (Y)
b) MOR
d) EMT
hypercage
c) OFF
hypocage
13A
e) M H Figure 1
f) ERI
g) LTA (A)
Schematic representation of the pore structure of various 'zeolites with large pore apertures 9FAU (Y), MOR, OFF, EMT, with average pore apertures: MFI (ZSM5), with small pore apertures: ERI, LTA (A).
Other structural parameters can play an important role in catalytic reactions: a. The existence of cages or channel intersections (in which the acid sites are located) and their size and shape. See for instance in Figure 1 the supercages of Y zeolites, the hypercages and hypocages of EMT zeolites, the large cages of ERI, and the channel intersections of MFI. b. The dimensionality of the pore system accessible to a given molecule. The pore system of Y zeolites is tridimensional, that of MOR is monodimensional for organic molecules (they can access only to the large channels) and bidimensional for nitrogen and ammonia which have access to the large and small channels, c. The existence of secondary porosity such as mesopores created during the dealumination of zeolites. Thus mesopores created in the crystallites of mordenites can render tridirectional the circulation of organic molecules [23]. As most of the acid sites are located in pores of molecular size the rate and the selectivity of catalytic reactions depend not only on the intrinsic properties of the sites but also on the pore structure. A zeolite catalyst selects the reactant or the product by their ability to diffuse to and from the active sites (reactant and product selectivity). Steric constraints in the environment of the sites limit or inhibit the formation of intermediates or transition states (restricted transition state selectivity) [24,25]. The strong polarizing interaction between zeolite crystallites and adsorbed molecules leads to an unusually high concentration of the reactants in the pores. This concentration effect causes an enhancement of the rates of bimolecular reaction steps over monomolecular reaction steps [26].
3. RATE OF F O R M A T I O N OF CARBONACEOUS DEPOSITS Carbonaceous deposits result from the transformation of reactants, reaction products, impurities of the feed, etc., on acid sites through various successive bimolecular steps: condensation, hydrogen transfer, etc. Therefore, their rate of formation depends on the following parameters which usually affect the rate of catalytic reactions, namely: a. The nature of the reactants and products, b. The operating conditions: temperature, pressure, concentration of the reactants, c. The characteristics of the acid sites: chemical structure, strength, density and number, d. The characteristics of the zeolite pore structure and especially the size and shape of the cavities (or channel intersections) in which are located the acid sites and which can therefore be considered as mieroreaetors. However, carbonaceous compounds have the peculiarity of being non desorbed products, hence must be retained inside the zeolite pores or on the outer surface of the crystallites. This retention is due to the strong adsorption of the carbonaceous compounds on acid sites and/or to their low volatility. It may also be due to their molecular size being greater than the pore aperture (causing trapping in the cavities or at channel intersections). Therefore, the rate of formation can depend on various parameters such as 9 a. The strength of the acid sites. The stronger the acid sites the less reversible the adsorption of the carbonaceous compounds, b. The characteristics of the diffusion pathway of organic molecules. The longer and the narrower this diffusion pathway the more difficult the desorption of bulky carbonaceous compounds,
c. The difference between the size of the cavities and the size of the pore apertures. Indeed the greater the difference the easier the trapping. However, while from these general considerations it is clear that both acidity and pore structure of a zeolite affect the rate of formation of carbonaceous compounds (other factors being held constant), it is generally impossible to quantify the effect of each of these parameters because of the difficulty in obtaining zeolite samples with identical acidities and with different pore structures or vice-versa. Having said that, some examples are given below which illustrate within these limitations the respective roles of acidity and of pore structure. Effects of acidity on coking rates have been generally investigated using a series of large pore zeolite catalysts: HY [27,28], HEMT [29], HMOR [30], cracking catalysts [31,32], etc., with different framework Si/A1 ratios. For example, the initial rates of coke formation from propene were determined over a series of commercial HY samples (Table 1) under the following conditions : fixed bed reactor, 450~ Ppropcne= 30 kPa, Pnitrogen = 70 kPa, 0.72 g of propene introduced per gram of zeolite per hour. With the more dealuminated samples (framework Si/A1 ratios from 16 to 100) the coking rate is roughly proportional to the density of the protonic sites (Figure 2) with turnover frequency (TOF) values in the range of 6 - 8 h 1. This quasi constant value of TOF can be related to the similarity in strength of the isolated OH groups of these zeolites [18]. The slightly greater TOF value found for the most dealuminated sample could be due to the large amount of the extraframework aluminium atoms (Table 1) in this sample [27]. Values three times lower are found for the non isolated sites (hence weaker sites) of the less dealuminated samples. Inaccessibility of part of the protonic sites (located in the sodalite cages)of these slightly dealuminated zeolites [16] is also responsible for the low TOF values.
Table 1 Characteristics of the commercial HY samples (from PQ zeolite) used in the formation of coke from propene at 450~ [27]. Unit cell formula
NEFAL/U.C.
700
Nao.4H38.sA139.2S i 152.80384
9.6
4.3
600
N ao.4H35.8A136.2S i 155.80384
6.1
16.5
560
Nao.3Hll.oAlll.3Si180.70384
2.4
Name
(Si/A1)fram.
CBV 500
3.9
CBV 500 D CBV 720
Na (ppm)
CBV 740
19.3
100
N ao.o5H9.45A19.5S i 182.50384
0.1
CBV 780
30
300
Nao.15H6.05A16.28i185.80384
0.0
Nao.5nl.4All.9Sil90.10384 10.0 CBV 760 100 1000 (Si/A1)f~am.: atomic framework Si/AI ratio, NEFAL/U.C.:number of extraframework aluminium atoms per unit cell.
7
..--00
/
0 Figure 2
'
I
10
'
;
"
;
'
;
20 30 40 Nn+/U.C. Coke formation from propene at 450~ over a series of commercial HY zeolites [27]. Initial rates of coke formation as a function of the number of protonic sites per unit cell (Nn+/u.c.).
Similar results were obtained for a series of HEMT samples prepared by steaming of a NH4EMT zeolite (framework Si/A1 ratios from 4 to 70). However under identical conditions the TOF values for coke formation were found to be 3 times higher with HEMT samples than with HY samples [29], which can be related to the stronger acidity of the protonic sites of the HEMT zeolites [ 16]. This large difference in TOF values could also be due to differences in the pore systems of Y and EMT zeolites. However this seems unlikely, as the sizes of the pore apertures are quite similar; moreover, a lower rate of coking would be expected with EMT owing to the presence of hypocages (Figure 1). On the other hand, in the case of 5A zeolites the very rapid formation of coke is due to the presence of trapping cavities (0~ cages of 11.4 A with pore apertures of only 4.2 A (Figure 1)). Thus, coke formation from propene at 350~ is 20 times faster with a 5A zeolite [33] than with an HZSM5 zeolite (Si/A1 = 15) [34], despite the fact that the acid sites of this latter zeolite are much stronger than those of the 5A zeolite, i.e., HZSM5 retains ammonia adsorbed above 400~ whereas in the case of 5A zeolites no ammonia is retained above 300~ Coke formation from compounds such as alkanes, which do not lead directly to coke was also investigated. As coking is successive to the main reaction the selectivities (e.g. the ratio of rates of coking and of the main reaction) are important to consider as well as conversion. This was carried out [28] for n-heptane cracking at 350~ over two series of dealuminated Y samples, the first one prepared by steaming of a NH4NaY zeolite (hence with a large amount of extraframework aluminium (EFAL) species), whereas the second resulted from treatment with a dilute HC1 solution of the samples of series 1 (in order to eliminate the EFAL species without modifying the framework composition). Figure 3 shows that for both series the selectivity to coke passes through a maximum for a certain value of the theoretical concentration of protonic sites. EFAL species have a promoting effect on the selectivity, particularly with the less dealuminated samples. This promoting effect is most likely due to an enhancement of the acid strength of framework Brrnsted sites owing to their interaction
with the EFAL species. Indeed a new IR band appears at 3600 c m "1 in the less dealuminated samples [ 16], which corresponds to very strong acid sites (able to retain pyridine adsorbed above 450~ This confirms the positive effect of the acid strength of zeolites on the rate of coke formation. n-Heptane cracking was also carried out at 450~ over four protonic zeolites with different pore structures [8]. The degree of protonic exchange was chosen so that the initial cracking activities were similar. The initial coking/cracking rate ratio was found to be close to 1 for HERI and HMOR, 4 times lower for HY and 1,000 times lower for HZSM5. The large selectivity to coke of the first two zeolites was attributed to rapid blockage of coke precursors in their trap cavities (HERI) or in their monodimensional channels (HMOR) [8]. On the other hand the very slow rate of coking found with HZSM5 cannot be explained by the single effect of its pore structure. This pecularity is due rather to the 5 to 8 times lower density of these acid sites. Indeed, as was indicated in Section 2 the rate of bimolecularreactions such as those involved in coke formation (especially hydrogen transfer) is extremely dependent on the acid site density. In agreement with that observation, close values of the coking/cracking ratios are found with HZSM5 and with a dealuminated HY zeolite having similar densities of strong acid sites [8].
16, 12-
d'8-
~
,,
0
'
0
Figure 3
l
10
r
'
s o
;
"
;
'
;
'
:
20 30 40 50 Nn+/U.C. Coke formation during n-heptane cracking at 350~ over dealuminated HY zeolites. Ratio (mk/rnc) of the amounts of n-heptane transformed into coke and into desorbed products for 70 min reaction as a function Of NH+/U.C., the number of protonic sites per unit cell. (a): samples with a large amount of extraframework aluminium atoms; (b): samples with a small amount.
However, while acidity can play an important role in the selectivity to coke, the results obtained by Rollmann and Walsh [35] during the transformation of an equimolar mixture of nhexane, 3-methylpentane, 2,3-dimethylbutane, benzene and toluene over a large series of zeolites demonstrate that in this case the size of the pore apertures is the determining parameter. Indeed, the selectivity to coke (expressed by the ratio between the amount of coke
formed and that of alkane converted) is approximately 1 with all large-pore zeolites, 0.1 with medium pore zeolites and 0.05 with small-pore zeolites [35].
4.
COMPOSITION FORMATION
OF
CARBONACEOUS
DEPOSITS
AND
MODE
OF
The effects of zeolite structure and acidity on "coke" composition are more pronounced at high rather than at low reaction temperatures. 4.1. Low temperature coke Thus, at 120~ irrespective of zeolite composition and structure, the H/C ratio of carbonaceous compounds is close to that of reactants, which indicates that these compounds result mainly from condensation reactions. At 120~ the carbonaceous compounds formed on HY, HZSM5 [34] and 5A [36] zeolites from propene, are branched aliphatic or alicyclic hydrocarbons (no aromatics are observed). Olefin oligomerization is the main reaction involved in their formation. Most of these compounds are located inside the zeolite pores, as less than 5 % of them can be recovered through a direct soxhlet extraction of the coked zeolite samples with methylene chloride. With large-and intermediate-pore zeolites (HY, HZSM5) carbonaceous compounds are retained inside the zeolite pores because of their low volatility (their boiling point is much higher than the reaction temperature (Table 2)), whereas, with the 5A zeolite the retention of these branched compounds is due to their steric blockage in the large ct cages (11.4 A) with small apertures (4.2 A).
Table 2 Composition of the carbonaceous deposits formed from propene at 120~ with HY, HZSM5 and 5A zeolites. Atomic H/C nr ni +
Cy
Branching Size (A)
USHY
HZSM5
5A
1.8
2.0
2.0
25-40
10-35
6, 9, 12, 15, 18,21
4, 3, 2,1 ,0
2, 1, 0
2, 1, 0
1.5
0.25
1.1
6.0 x 25-40
4.3 x 10-35
6 x 9-25
bp76o (~ 350-530 175-490 60-340 no: number of carbon atoms; ni + Cy" number of unsaturated bonds + cyclic compounds; Branching: ratio between the number of protons of CH3 groups and that of CH2 + CH groups.
Differences observed in the number of carbon atoms, in the extent of branching and in the chemical nature of carbonaceous compounds trapped in the zeolite pores result mainly from differences in size of the cavities (or of the channel intersections) and from the differences in the strength or in the density of the acid sites. Indeed, differences in pore structure combined with differences in acidity affect the rate of the main reaction (oligomerization) relative to side
10 reactions, e.g. cracking, isomerization and hydrogen transfer. As is the case with coking rates it is often difficult to discriminate between the effects of the pore structure and acidity, both having at times the same effect. Thus, the lower rate of hydrogen transfer on HZSM5 compared to HY (compounds with more than one unsaturated bond or cyclic compounds are not observed with the former zeolite) can be explained either by the smaller size of the space available near the acid sites: (8.5 A for the channel intersections of HZSM5 against 13 A diameter for the Y supercages) or by the 10 fold lower density of the acid sites for HZSM5. The explanation of differences in reaction and coking rates for 5A zeolite and other zeolites is more simple. In this case the quasi absence of secondary transformations of propene oligomers (no cracking and practically no isomerization and hydrogen transfer) on 5A is clearly related to the very weak acidity of this zeolite, while the presence inside the pores of 5A of relatively volatile compounds (e.g. C6 branched alkenes) is due to the impossibility of desorbing these branched compounds from this small pore size zeolite.
4.2. High temperature coke While at low temperatm'es the composition of carbonaceous deposits formed in acid zeolites is extremely dependent on the reactant, this is no longer the case at high temperatures (i.e. the temperature range of most of the refining and petrochemical processes). Thus, with HZSM5 at 450~ methylpyrenes are the main components of the coke (1.5-3.0 wt %) formed from propene, toluene and a propene-toluene mixture. However, different reaction pathways are involved in the formation of methylpyrenes from these different reactants: Pathway 1 from toluene and Pathway 2 from both the toluene-propene mixture and propene [37]. The fact that with both pathways methylpyrenes are the main coke components, suggests that the pore structure rather than the acidity plays a determining role in the growth of coke precursors.
Pathway
Pathway 2:
1:
2C3 =
ol
~ C6=
~
isom
AaJk~C,
HT
A alk: aromatic alkylation ; DC: dehydrogenative coupling ; trans: transalkylation ; isom: isomerization ; HT: hydrogen transfer ; ol: oligomerization ; alk: alkylation ; cycl: cyclization.
The essential role of the pore structure was confirmed by investigating as a function of time-on-stream the formation of coke during n-heptane cracking at 450~ over various zeolites (HY, HOFF, HMOR, HZSM5 and HERI), with similar initial cracking activities. C3 and C4 were the major products for all the zeolites, the olefin/alkane ratio being smaller than 1, which indicates secondary transformations of olefinic cracking products into non-desorbed products (coke): coking is consecutive to n-heptane cracking.
11
The composition of coke depends both on time-on-stream (hence on the coke content) and on the zeolite [8]. With all the zeolites carbonaceous compounds are initially formed inside the zeolite pores and, except for mordenite, are soluble in methylene chloride after dissolution of the zeolite in a hydrofluoric acid solution. The yield in soluble coke decreases with increasing coke content. The analysis of the soluble part of coke by GC/MS shows that the size and the degree of aromaticity of the coke components increase with coke content (see for example in Table 3 the change in the amount of the various coke families found with HZSM5 as a function of coke content).
Table 3 Distribution of the main families of coke components (wt %) during n-heptane cracking at 450~ over HZSM5 as a function of total coke content. (wt %) 1.0 3.5 4.5 7.0 Coke families - ~
~
~
'--Rx
0.7
(CnH2n-6)
0.3
(CnH2n-14)
~
~---R
3.0
(CnH2n-12)
~
R
0.5
(CnH2n-16) ~ R (CnH2n-22) Insoluble coke
-
-
1.0
0.5
2.2
1.9
1.3
4.6
For similar coke contents the composition of coke strongly depends on the pore system of the zeolite, i.e., coking is a shape-selective process. At low coke contents, the major components are alkylbenzenes in HZSM5 and HERI, alkylnaphthalenes or fluorenes in HOFF, alkylbenzopyrenes in USHY and very polyaromatic compounds (insoluble in methylene chloride) in HMOR. At high contents, the coke components are polyaromatic in all zeolites. However, the molecules of components soluble in methylene chloride are very different as they take the size and shape of the cavities or of the channel intersections [38], as is shown in Figure 4. Whatever the coke content soluble coke molecules are trapped in cages
12 (or at channel intersections). Indeed their molecular size is between that of the pore apertures and the cages [8].
i
b)
Figure4
Location of the main coke molecules formed at high coke contents in the pores of a) HZSM5 (methylpyrene) and b) ERI (methylchrysene).
With all the zeolites (except mordenite), insoluble coke molecules result from the condensation of soluble coke molecules. Indeed insoluble coke molecules are not directly formed and the amount of soluble coke molecules passes through a maximum (Figure 5). Coke formation occurs therefore according to the following scheme :
n-heptane ~
1
2 alkenes ~ + alkanes
soluble coke ~
insoluble coke
Alkenes resulting from n-heptane cracking (Step 1) are transformed into soluble coke molecules which are trapped in cages and pores. Soluble coke molecules are transformed into
13 insoluble molecules(Step 3), that according to TEM analysis [39], overflow onto the outer surface of the zeolite crystallites and into the inner mesopores created by dealumination. Several reactions: alkylation, cyclization and hydrogen transfer could be involved in Steps 2 and 3.
n k
1.6"
la) HYI
O 9
9
ln~ Ib)HZSM5I 0.8--
1.20.60.8A
w
.4"
v
0.4-
0.2"
0, 0.0r 0
Figure 5
9
o
o
~._J
n
z~
9149
i
n
n m
8
n
m m
m
mm
12 %C 16
0.
'
~ 0
'
' 2
4
: ' 6 %C ~
Change in the concentration of soluble (e) and insoluble (O) coke molecules (nk, 1020g"1) as a function of the percentage of coke formed during n-heptane cracking at 450~ on HY (a) and on HZSM5 (b).
However, the existence of another mode of formation of insoluble coke molecules, the dehydrogenative coupling of polyaromatic species located in adjacent cavities has recently been proposed to explain the high selectivity to insoluble coke of HY [27] and HEMT [29] zeolites with high framework Si/A1 ratios (hence with low acid site densities and low coking activities (Figure 6)). This dehydrogenative coupling of soluble coke molecules was demonstrated by the decrease in the H/C ratio of coke and by the large increase in the percentage of insoluble coke caused by the treatment of a coked HY sample with a nitrogen flow at the coking temperature (450~ for a long time (6 hours). The relative significance of the two modes of growth of coke molecules is determined by the residence time of coke molecules in the zeolite pores. Indeed, the longer this time, the greater is the probability of coupling between the molecules of coke or coke precursors, which explains the high selectivity to insoluble coke of zeolites with low coking activities [38]. This dehydrogenative coupling could also explain the very high selectivity to insoluble coke found with HMOR, the residence time of coke precursors in the channels of this monodimensional zeolite being very long [8]. When different types of zeolite pores are accessible to the reactant, the formation of coke (reaction + retention)can occur preferentially in one of them. This was shown in the case of coking from n-heptane on H-Offretite [40], a zeolite consisting of rectilinear cyclindral channels (diameter 6.3/~) interconnected through gmelinite cages (apertures of 3.6 x 5.2 A
14 25
28
-N
,o
HY 4 %
24-
I
HEMT 4
20""
-
,c %
20,,-,,,i
~15-or.,r HY 100 n .=. ~10-
ID
216-
0t
O
;s12 . 73
9
5"
4 | |
0
Figure 6
5
10
15
|
%C
| |
20
|
9
0d
25
,
0
.-j
4
: . : .....
8
:.
12 16 20 24 28 %C
Formation of insoluble coke from propene at 450~ over (a) HY and (b) HEMT zeolites with low and high framework Si/A1 ratios as a function of the total amount of coke.
diameter). The first molecules of coke which are formed are alkylnaphthalenes and fluorenes, (Families 1 and 2), i.e. non bulky and highly volatile compounds which, consequently, cannot be retained in the large channels. These coke molecules are therefore formed and trapped in the grnelinite cages (Figure 7). Table 4 shows that they transform into alkylphenanthrenes and alkylchrysenes (Families 3 and 4) and then into insoluble coke molecules. The compounds of Family 4 (Figure 7), too bulky to be entirely located in the gmelinite cages, overflow into the large channels. This location of coke molecules was confirmed by comparing the adsorption of n-hexane which has access to both gmelinite cages and large channels, to that of methyl-pentane which has access only to the large channels [41 ].
5. D E A C T I V A T I N G
EFFECTS
OF COKE MOLECULES:
MODES
OF
DEACTIVATION Thanks to the method developed for establishing the composition of coke it is possible to express the deactivation as a function of the number of coke molecules, which obviously gives more information on the mode of deactivation than an expression involving a function of total coke content. The deactivating effect of the coke molecules (their toxicity) depends very much on zeolite acidity and structure, even when the initial activities of the zeolite are similar. Thus, during n-heptane cracking at 450~ the number of coke molecules which causes complete deactivation was found for HY and HZSM5 to be close to the number of strong acid sites (i.e. active sites [8]) while it was 7-8 times smaller for HMOR and HERI (Table 5). Therefore deactivation of HMOR and HERI is probably due to blockage (by coke) of the access of the
15 Table 4 Formation of carbonaceous deposits (coke) during n-heptane cracking at 450~ over HOFF. Distribution of the main families of coke components as a function of the coke content. (wt %) ~ e 0.8 1.5 2.3 4.5 10 Coke families ~~---
R
0.4
(CnH2n-12)
~
R
0.4
(CnH2n-16)
~
R
0
1.0
1.0
1.0
1.0
0
0.5
0.6
1.0
4.5
0
0
0.7
2.5
5.0
(CnH2n-18)
~
R
(CnH2n-24)
Insoluble coke
Stv--. --
j
l gmelinit~ cage
9 large annels
a) b) c) Figure 7 Formation and growth of coke molecules in the pores of HOFF during n-heptane cracking at 450~ (a) naphthalene, (b) methylphenanthrene and (c) methylchrysene.
16 reactant to the acid sites. This blockage is furthermore confirmed by adsorption experiments
[8]. Table 5 Toxicity of coke molecules: number of strong acid sites that one coke molecule renders inactive. A: initial values ; B: values at complete deactivation. A
B
USHY
5
1.3
HMOR
25
7.5
HMFI
0.25
1.0
HERI
30
7.0
The effects of pore structure on coke toxicity can also be quantitatively elucidated by comparing the number of sites that one coke molecule renders initially inactive (for this estimation it was supposed that all the acid sites had the same cracking activity): less than one for HZSM5 (0.25), 5 for HY and more than 25 for HMOR and HERI (Table 5). While the very high toxicity of coke molecules found for these last two zeolites is typical for pore blockage, the average value found for HY is most likely due to the heterogeneity in acid strengths of this zeolite. Coke molecules are preferentially formed on the strongest (hence the more active) acid sites and thus preferentially deactivate these sites [8]. The creation of a secondary porosity can significantly decrease the toxicity of coke molecules. This has been shown for the transformation of methanol into short-chain alkenes over HMOR catalysts i.e. the toxicity of coke molecules is more than 10 times lower in dealuminated samples, as mesopores created by dealumination allow a quasi-tridirectional diffusion of organic molecules [23]. This positive effect of mesopores was also observed in liquid phase alkylation of toluene with 1-heptene [42]. The wide-ranging effects of pore structure on coke toxicity lead us to define four modes of deactivation (Figure 8) instead of the two (site coverage and pore blockage) which are generally proposed. Thus, deactivation could be due to : (1) Limitation of the access of the reactant to the active sites of a cage or a channel intersection in which a coke molecule is located, (2) Blockage of this access, (3) Limitation or (4) blockage of the access of the reactant to the active sites of cavities, of channel intersections or of parts of channels in which no coke molecules are located. In Modes 1 and 2 the limitation or the blockage is due to chemical reasons i.e., the coke molecules are (1)reversibly or (2) quasi-irreversibly adsorbed on the acid sites (site poisoning or site coverage) and/or to steric reasons: the diffusion of reactant molecules through the cavity or the channel intersection is (1) limited or (2) blocked. With these modes the toxicity of the coke molecules is low as only the sites located in the cavity or at the channel intersection, often only one site, are partially (Mode 1) or totally (Mode 2) deactivated. In Modes 3 and 4 the limitation or the blockage is due only to steric reasons; the diffusion of reactant molecules to the acid sites of the inner pores is (3) limited or (4) blocked. With these modes the toxicity of the coke molecules is very high, as a large number of active sites are generally located in these inner pores. The effects of the pore structure on the toxicity of coke molecules can be explained by differences in the significance of the modes of deactivation from one zeolite to another : a. With tridimensional zeolites having no trap cavities (large cages with small apertures) deactivation at low coke contents occurs through Mode 1 then Mode 2 ; at high coke contents deactivation occurs through Modes 3 and 4, caused by coke molecules overflowing onto the outer surface of the crystallites (Figure 8). Therefore, when the acid sites are of similar strength as in the case of HZSM5, the greater the coke content the higher the toxicity of coke molecules.
17
.......
17
/ Mode 1
Figure 8
Mode 2
Mode 3 Mode 4 Schematic of the four possible modes of deactivation by carbonaceous deposits in HZSM5.
The situation is more complex when the acid sites are of different strength as is the case with HY zeolites. Indeed the strongest acid sites and hence the most active are the first deactivated with a consequently high toxicity of the coke molecules at low coke content [8]. b. With monodimensional zeolites such as HMOR or with zeolites containing trap cavities such as HERI the deactivation occurs only through Modes 3 and 4. In the case of HMOR, at very low coke contents, one coke molecule located in a large channel (most likely at one intersection of this channel with the narrow pores inaccessible to the organic molecules) is able to limit or block the access of the reactant to all the active sites located in the channel, with consequently a high toxicity of the coke molecules. This high toxicity is also observed with HERI because the coke molecules initially formed, trapped in the cages near the outer surface of the crystallites, limit or block the access of the reactant to the active sites of the inner cages [8]. 6.
CONCLUSIONS
The acidity and pore structure of zeolites play significant roles in their deactivation by carbonaceous deposits ("coke"). This is not surprising, as the formation of coke involves reactions catalyzed by acid sites located inside the pores and also requires the retention of coke molecules by adsorption on the acid sites or by condensation or by steric blockage in the pores. Although it is often difficult to estimate quantitatively and separately the impacts of the acidity and of pore structure, it is clear that it is the latter characteristic which plays the greater role. The development of a method for establishing the composition of zeolite coke has led to significant progress in the understanding of the modes of coking and deactivation of zeolites
18 and more generally of porous catalysts. At high temperatures (> 300~ coking can be considered as a nucleation-growth process. The key step is the trapping of heavy product molecules in the micropores (nucleation). This trapping occurs in cavities or at channel intersections. Obviously, this process is favoured more and more as the difference between the sizes of the pore openings and of the cages increases. Identical reactions are generally involved in the nucleation and growth steps i.e. auto or inter condensation of coke precursors such as alkenes, alkylaromatics and polyaromatics and hydrogen transfer. Four modes of deactivation can be distinguished. The first one corresponds to a limitation of the access of the reactant to the active sites of a cage or of a channel intersection in which is located a coke molecule, the second one to complete blockage of this access. This limitation or this blockage may be due to the adsorption of coke molecules on the acid sites or to steric reasons. The other two modes correspond to steric limitation (Mode 3) or blockage (Mode 4) of the access of the reactant to the active sites of cavities or of channels in which no coke molecules are located. The deactivating effects of coke molecules increase from Mode 1 to Mode 4. The relative significance of these modes of deactivation depends on the degree of coking and on the zeolite pore structure. The deactivation of monodimensional zeolites and of zeolites with trap cavities (large cages with small apertures) only occurs through Modes 3 and 4. These zeolites, which are consequently very sensitive to coke, could be used as catalysts only in processes in which coke formation is very slow (e.g. bifunctional catalysis). For other types of zeolites, at low coke content deactivation occurs through Mode 1 then through Mode 2, while at high coke contents Modes 3 and 4 are predominant owing to coke overflowing onto the outer surface of the crystallites.
REFERENCES 1. J.A. Rabo, Zeolite Chemistry and Catalysis, ACS Monograph 171, American Chemical Society, Washington, 1976. 2. I.E. Maxwell and W.H.J. Stork, in Introduction to Zeolite Science and Practice, H. van Bekkum et al. (Eds.), Studies in Surface Science and Catalysis, Elsevier, Amsterdam, Vol. 58 (1991) 571. 3. P.B. Venuto, Microporous Materials, 2 (1994) 69. 4. W.F. Hotlderich, in Zeolites : Facts, Figures, Future, P.A. Jacobs and R.A. van Santen (eds.), Studies in Surface Science and Catalysis, Elsevier, Amsterdam, Vol. 49 (1989) 69. 5. G. Perot and M. Guisnet, J. Mol. Catal. 61 (1990) 173. 6. N.Y. Chen, W.E. Garwood and F.G. Dwyer, in Shape Selective Catalysis in Industrial Applications, Marcel Dekker, Inc., New-York and Basel (1989). 7. J.A. Johnson and A.R. Oroska, in Zeolites as Catalysts, Sorbents and Detergent Builders, H.G. Karge and J. Weitkamp (eds.), Studies in Surface Science and Catalysis, Elsevier, Amsterdam, Vol. 46 (1989) 451. 8. M. Guisnet and P. Magnoux, Appl. Catal. 54 (1989) 1. 9. M.R. Guisnet, Acc. Chem. Res., 23 (1990) 392. 10.P.A. Jacobs, H.E. Leeman, J.B. Uytterhoeven, J. Catal. 33 (1974) 17. 11.J.W. Ward, R.C. Hansford, J. Catal. 13 (1969) 154. 12.T. Aonuma, M. Sato, T. Shiba, Shokubai 5 (1963) 274. 13.H.G. Karge, K. Hatada, Y. Zhang, R. Fiedorow, Zeolites 3 (1983) 13. 14.J.W. Ward, J. Catal. 10 (1968) 34. 15.C. Mirodatos and D. Barthomeuf, J. Chem. Soc. Chem. Commun. (1981) 39. 16. S. Morin, unpublished results. 17.J.A. Rabo and G.J. Gajda, in Guidelines for Mastering the Properties of Molecular Sieves ; D. Barthomeuf et al. (Eds.), NATO ASI Series B, Plenum Press, New-York and London, 221 (1990) 273. 18.D. Barthomeuf, Mater. Chem. Phys. 17 (1987) 49.
19
19. G. Bourdillon, C. Gueguen, and M. Guisnet, Appl. Catal. 61 (1990) 123. 20.W-C. Cheng and K. Rajagopalan, J. Catal. 119 (1989) 354. 21 .E. Jacquinot, F. Raatz, A. Macedo and Ch. Marcilly, in Zeolites as Catalysts, Sorbents and Detergent Builders, H.G. Karge and J. Weitkamp (eds.), Studies in Surface Science and Catalysis, Elsevier, Amsterdam, 46 (1989) 115. 22.Atlas of Zeolite Structure Types, Zeolites 12 (1992). 23.N.S. Gnep, Ph. Roger, P. Cartraud, M. Guisnet, B. Juquin and Ch. Hamon, C.R. Acad. Sci., 309 (1989) 1743. 24.P.B. Weisz, V.J. Frilette, R.W. Maatman and E.B Mower, J. Catal. 1 (1962) 307. 25.S.M. Csicsery, J. Catal. 19 (1970) 394 and J. Catal. 23 (1971) 124. 26.J.A. Rabo, P.D. Bezman and M.L. Poutsma, Proceedings of the Symposium on Zeolites, Szeged, Acta Physica et Chemica 24 (1978) 39. 27.K. Moljord, P. Magnoux and M. Guisnet, Appl. Catal. A : General 122 (1995) 21. 28.Q.L. Wang, G. Giannetto and M. Guisnet, J. Catal. 130 (1991) 471. 29. G.A. Doka Nassionou, Ph.D. Thesis, Poitiers (1997). 30.H.G. Karge, in Introduction to Zeolite Science and Practice, H. van Bekkum et al. (Eds.), Studies in Surface Science and Catalysis, Elsevier, Amsterdam, Vol. 58 (1991) 531. 31. K. Rajagopalan and A.W. Peters, J. Catal. 106 (1987) 410. 32.T. Ino, S. A1-Khataff, Appl. Catal. A: General 142 (1996) 5. 33.M. Misk, G. Joly, P. Magnoux and M. Guisnet, Zeolites 16 (1996) 265. 34.B. Dimon, P. Cartraud, P. Magnoux and M. Guisnet, Appl. Catal. A: General, 101 (1993) 351. 35.L.D. Rollmann and D.E. Walsh, J. Catal. 56 (1979) 139. 36. Y. Boucheffa, C. Thomazeau, P. Cartraud, P. Magnoux, M. Guisnet and S. Jullian, Ind. Eng. Chem. Research, accepted for publication. 37.P. Magnoux, F. Machado and M. Guisnet, In New Frontiers in Catalysis, L. Guczi et al. (Eds.), Proceedings of the 10th International Congress on Catalysis, Budapest (1993) 435. 38.M. Guisnet, P. Magnoux and K. Moljord, in Deactivation and Testing of HydrocarbonProcessing Catalysts, P.O'Connor et al. (Eds.), ACS Symposium Series 624, ch. 5 (1996) 77. 39.P. Gallezot, C. Leclercq, M. Guisnet and P. Magnoux, J. Catal. 117 (1989) 100. 40. P. Magnoux, M. Guisnet, S. Mignard and P. Cartraud, J. Catal. 117 (1989) 495. 41. S. Mignard, P. Cartraud, P. Magnoux and M. Guisnet, J. Catal. 117 (1989) 503. 42.P. Magnoux, A. Mourran, S. Bernard and M. Guisnet, Proceedings of the D.G.M.K. Conference "Catalysis on Solid Acids and Bases", J. Weitkamp and B. Lticke (eds.) (1996) 49.
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
9 Elsevier Science B.V. All rights reserved Catalyst Deactivation 1997 C.H. Bartholomew and G.A. Fuentes, editors
21
Impact of Sulfur on Three-Way Automotive Catalyst Performance and Catalyst Diagnostics D. D. Beck GM Research and Development Center 30500 Mound Rd. Warren, M148090 USA In an effort to reduce emissions from mobile sources to help address acute ozone nonattainment problems, the State of California adopted a Low Emission Vehicle/Clean Fuel program in 1990. Low Emission Vehicles, or LEVs, are designed to meet significantly stricter HC, CO and NOx standards than vehicles sold in the remainder of the U.S., and are designed to operate on a strictly controlled reformulated fuel to achieve low emissions over the vehicle's lifetime. One of the characteristics of this fuel is a low sulfur content, which averages 30-40 ppm or less. Data provided by the Auto Oil Air Quality Research Program and other studies were instrumental in the development of the low emission properties of this fuel, and vehicle manufacturers now use this fuel in the development, calibration, and certification process for Low Emission Vehicles sold in California. Such vehicles may also be introduced federally through a national low emission vehicle program or by individual states adopting the California program, but there is concern that the low emission benefits obtained in California may not be achieved federally because of the variability in fuel properties, including sulfur content, which may be present in concentrations as high as 1000 ppm. This has caused increased interest on the impact of sulfur on the performance of automotive catalysts, particularly catalyst systems which will be used in Low Emission Vehicles. The impact of sulfur on catalyst oxygen storage is also of interest, due to the requirement of an on-board catalyst performance diagnostic which uses the loss of catalyst oxygen storage as an indicator of catalyst deterioration. This paper will review both laboratory and vehicle studies performed at GM and elsewhere which focus on the impact of sulfur on the performance and oxygen storage capacity of catalyst systems which are anticipated to be used in low emissions vehicles, and notably catalysts which incorporate palladium, and compare the magnitude of these impacts to those observed on earlier generation automotive catalyst systems. This paper will also review how these observations are consistent with conclusions obtained from fundamental studies of the interaction between sulfur-containing gas species in vehicle exhaust and the catalytic and oxygen storage sites in the catalyst.
1. I N T R O D U C T I O N All commercially produced gasoline blends which are intended for vehicle use contain organo-sulfur compounds in concentrations ranging from several parts per million (ppm) to 1000 ppm [1]. These compounds are present in the crude oil feedstocks [2] and can be partially removed by a hydrodesulfurization process in refining [3,4]. Removal of nearly all of the sulfur from gasoline is not always economical due to a number of factors including the variability in feedstock properties and the cost of deep hydrodesulfurization (HDS)
22 processing (HDS catalysts must be periodically regenerated or replaced since they are deactivated by coke and sintering in use). An example of the variability in sulfur content of regular octane grade gasolines in different markets of the U.S. is shown in Figure 1. Fuels in some urban areas are now required to conform to stricter specifications under the Reformulated Federal Gasoline (RFG) program, but even under the more strict phase of this program to be implemented later, the sulfur concentration in these fuels can be as high as 500 ppm [5]. Thus, the sulfur content of RFG fuels will not be controlled to the same strict specifications of California Phase II fuels, which began distribution in March of 1996 and which require refinery product not to exceed 30-40 ppm and retail product not to exceed 80 ppm sulfur.
E"
1,400
-
I/
1,~00 . . . . . ~' 1,000- . . . . ~)
tT
High Average
t!'
L~ ....
1....................... ~---I ...................
800 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
8 ~
,.
o---.-t-.-'-i-,-.-,-/,-.-,-.-,-.-,-.-,-.-,l:.-,-i-,Figure 1. Sulfur levels in federal fuels (results of the AAMA fuel survey conducted during the Winter of 1994). Sulfur compounds in gasoline are converted during combustion primarily into sulfur dioxide, and given the proper conditions can further react over the emission control catalyst to form hydrogen sulfide, carbonyl sulfide or even sulfurous and sulfuric acid [6]. For threeway catalyst applications, the exhaust air/fuel ratio is controlled near the stoichiometric point such that carbonyl sulfide and the acids are not favored. Although emission of hydrogen sulfide has been noticeable with the increase in the ceria content in these catalysts over the last two decades, methods to suppress the emission of hydrogen sulfide have been successfully employed. Generally, though, sulfur dioxide is of an emissions concern because it has been demonstrated to deactivate vehicle exhaust catalysts. Laboratory and vehicle
23
studies were carried out to first investigate the effects of sulfur on Pt and Pd oxidation catalysts in the 1970's [6-8], and on Pt-Rh three-way catalysts from the late 1970's until present [9-26]. These studies and discussions of the mechanism responsible for sulfur poisoning of vehicle emission catalysts has been discussed previously [ 18]. When the State of California adopted requirements that vehicle manufacturers introduce Low Emission Vehicles (LEVs) in 1990, increased attention was placed on ways to achieve rapid activation of the catalytic converter including the use of Pd lightoff catalysts to comply with the very strict hydrocarbon standards for these vehicles. The use of Pd in such applications is considered attractive because of its ability to catalyze the oxidation of hydrocarbons at temperatures significantly below those of catalysts containing Pt, Rh or both, and because of the high temperature durability of Pd which is needed as these catalysts are close-coupled to the exhaust manifold for fast lightoff. However, earlier generation Pd catalysts have been found to be more severely affected by sulfur than other noble metal catalysts, leading to concerns of greater sulfur impacts on emission control systems on LEVs than on less strictly regulated Tier 0 or Tier 1 vehicles (Table 1). Therefore, the anticipated emissions benefit derived from the sale of LEVs federally might be at least partially compromised. However, continued developments in Pd catalyst formulations have improved their high temperature durability, as well as NOx activity and tolerance for sulfur poisoning [27-29]. These improvements, coupled with better optimization of the emission control system in low emission vehicles, offer hope that such vehicles may achieve in actual use the low emission standards for which they were designed. In this paper, then, we will discuss results of some investigations of the impact of sulfur on catalysts which are anticipated to be used in low emission vehicles, and compare the results with similar studies using earlier generation catalysts. We shall also discuss how these observations are consistent with what is known from fundamental studies about the interactions between sulfur and the individual catalyst components. Table 1 Emission Standards for Federal and California Low Emission Vehicles. (Passenger Car Category, Standards at 50,000 miles, in g/mi) THC Federal Tier 0 Federal Tier 1 California Transitional Low Emission (TLEV) California Low Emission (LEV) California Ultra-Low Emission (ULEV)
0.41 0.41
NMHC or NMOG*
CO
NOx
0.25
3.4 3.4
0.4
0.125
3.4
0.4
0.075
3.4
0.2
0.040
1.7
0.2
1.0
* Non-methane hydrocarbons or non-methane organic gases. In addition to the adoption of a Low Emission Vehicle/Clean Fuel program, the California Air Resources Board (CARB) has adopted regulations which call for comprehensive on-board monitoring of seven components and/or events related to emissions of exhaust, fuel, and air conditioning heat-transfer agents for vehicles sold in California. This legislation is called "On-Board Diagnostics-Phase II" or "OBD-II" [30]. These systems were installed on all vehicles sold in California in the 1996 model year. The Environmental
24 Protection Agency (EPA) has adopted similar regulations. One of the parameters to be monitored by the OBD-II system is catalytic converter performance. Performance which falls below an acceptable level defined by the regulations must be identified as malfunctioning by activation of an indicator lamp and storage of a fault or trouble code in the engine control module which can be read by a service technician through a serial link provided in the vehicle. When the fault code is set, it can only be cleared during servicing. The definition of a malfunctioning converter depends on the emissions category of the vehicle and has involved a gradual phase-in of standards, but generally requires identification of a failed converter when it exceeds 1.5x the applicable HC standard. Current catalyst diagnostic systems use conventional oxygen sensors placed in front of and behind each catalyst to infer catalyst efficiency from a measure of catalyst oxygen storage [31-33]. There has been much discussion about the advantages and disadvantages of this strategy, including continued discussion about the validity of the correlation between catalyst oxygen storage and catalyst performance [33]. For example, it has been demonstrated that non-Ce containing catalysts as well as close coupled small volume catalysts which have been operated at very high temperatures can be mis-diagnosed as failing by the dual oxygen sensor method when they in fact easily meet emission standards [34]. This is an example of an incorrect diagnosis event which could lead to an undesirable high number of warranty replacements. To minimize the risk of such events, the dual oxygen sensor method of catalyst monitoring continues to be further developed and improved to minimize incidences which can give rise to incorrect diagnosis of the converter. It is well known that organo-sulfur compounds present in the fuel can react with the ceria and alumina components of the catalyst to form sulfites and sulfates, [18 and references therein] thereby interfering with the ability of the catalyst to easily store or release oxygen. Laboratory studies have been conducted which indicate that the presence of sulfur dioxide in relatively low concentrations can result in near complete loss of oxygen storage capacity in production three-way catalysts [35,36], which can influence the OBD-II catalyst monitoring system. Under specific conditions, it may also be possible to poison the exhaust-side noble metal element in the post-catalyst oxygen sensor, which has been observed to retard the response of the sensor to rapid changes in air/fuel ratio. The net result from the inability of the post-catalyst oxygen sensor to quickly respond to these changes is that the signal is mistaken for that of a good converter, even if the emissions exceed the standard due to converter failure. Since the dual oxygen sensor method of catalyst monitoring depends on the measurement of oxygen storage capacity of the monitored catalyst or catalysts and any connection to actual HC conversion performance is inferred, any variable which can impact either the oxygen storage capacity of the catalyst and/or the measurement device is expected to impact the reliability of the method. This is of particular concern for low emission vehicle classes for which the OBD-II catalyst monitor must be able to detect small changes in the emissions performance in order to identify when the levels exceed 1.75x the applicable FTP standard. Using a low emission vehicle as an example, the OBD-II system must be able to detect and indicate failure of the catalyst system when the HC conversion efficiency falls below an average of--93% on an FTP test, assuming typical engine-out hydrocarbon levels [34]. Thus, any variable which may have a relatively small impact on emissions performance and/or the OBD-II catalyst monitor may potentially cause incorrect diagnosis. For a California LEV operating in California there are a number of factors which can influence these measurements. Fuel is not expected to be a significant factor, however, since the regulations for phase II reformulated gasoline should result in state-wide distribution of low sulfur content unleaded gasoline with relatively uniform properties. Conversely, for a California LEV operating outside California, fuel properties vary widely, including sulfur content, thus presenting a potentially significant influence on the emissions performance and the OBD-II catalyst monitor in these vehicles [37]. In this paper, then, we will also briefly discuss a number of laboratory and vehicle studies which address the extent and nature of the impact of sulfur on both catalyst performance and on OBD-II.
25
2. LABORATORY STUDIES ON THE INTERACTION BETWEEN SULFUR IN VEHICLE EXHAUST AND VARIOUS CATALYST COMPONENTS As mentioned above, sulfur originating from organo-sulfur compounds in the fuel reaches the catalytic converter chiefly in the form of SO/. Previous laboratory studies led to the conclusion that SO 2 inhibits catalytic activity in commercial three-way catalysts primarily under fuel-rich, oxygen-poor conditions, and particularly over Pt and Pd catalysts [9-11 ]. This is consistent with data showing that sulfur inhibits steam reforming and water-gas shift reactions which play an important role in the removal of CO and hydrocarbons under fuelrich conditions [11-12]. It has been shown that in catalysts with high levels or ceria, these two reactions are promoted, but in the presence of sulfur, these two reactions are even more severely inhibited than if the ceria was not present [ 18,26], suggesting a strong interaction between sulfur and the ceria component, which we will discuss later in this section. A number of surface science studies have been conducted which have shown that SO 2 adsorbs dissociatively on noble metal surfaces, forming adsorbed oxygen atoms and sulfur atoms: SO2(g ) --
SO2(ads)
"-
S (ads) + 2 0
(ads)
(1)
Whereas the oxygen atoms react with reducing species such as CO, H 2 or hydrocarbons at elevated temperatures, the adsorbed sulfur atoms are very strongly bound by comparison and can only react with an excess of oxygen present in the gas phase at temperatures greater than those required to remove the adsorbed oxygen, or they can react with hydrogen at even higher temperatures (sometimes as high as 700~ to form HzS. It follows, then, that a coverage of sulfur atoms on a noble metal surface is most favored under fuel-rich conditions, leading to the observation that sulfur poisoning is most prominent under fuel-rich conditions. Even early vehicle studies have shown that the importance of sulfur poisoning was dependent on the air/fuel calibration [4-6]. Laboratory studies also suggested that very small amounts of sulfur in exhaust could lead to significant impacts on catalyst performance [18]. For example, studies of SO 2 dissociation on well-characterized noble metal surfaces showed that relatively small surface coverage of adsorbed sulfur, on the order of 0.1 monolayer, could effectively block nearly all of the noble metal surface from adsorbing other reactant molecules such as H 2 or CO. This was attributable to a strong electronic effect of adsorbed sulfur in the donation of electron density to the noble metal surface, with the result being the inhibition of adsorption of other gas phase species [38,39]. Over the last two decades, the ceria content in catalyst formulations was increased, resulting in an increased H2S emissions. New studies were performed to investigate H2S formation over three-way catalysts and ways to control it. These studies showed that significant amounts of sulfur were stored in the catalyst under oxygen-neutral or oxygen-rich conditions, and were then released during fuel-rich excursions [21]. In oxygen-rich, or lean conditions, storage involves the interaction between sulfur dioxide in the gas phase and the base metal oxides in the catalyst to form sulfate and sulfites on the surface of their particles [18]: SO 2 +
1/2 02 = SO 3
(2)
3 SO 3 + A1203 = A12(SO4) 3
(3)
2 S O 3 + CeO 2= Ce(SO4) 2
(4)
3 SO 2 + 6 C e O 2 = C e 2 ( 5 0 4 ) 3 + 2 C e 2 0 3
(5)
The noble metals may assist in this process, since they are well known for catalyzing the oxidation of sulfur dioxide to sulfur trioxide species in an oxygen-rich environment
26
[ 1,14,15]. Fundamental studies have shown that SO 2 adsorbs strongly on alumina and other base metal oxides, which may be an intermediate step to the formation of surface aluminum sulfates. These sulfate species are favored between 600 and 800 ~ C, which is a typical operating range for an exhaust three-way catalyst [22,23]. Most of the storage, however, may involve interaction with ceria to form cerium sulfate and sulfite species, as it has been demonstrated that there is a direct correlation between the cerium content in catalysts and the amount of sulfur stored [24]. Operation under fuel-rich conditions following a prolonged period of operation in oxygen-rich conditions can lead to a rapid release of an undesirable amount of H2S, leading to an exhaust odor problem. Inhibition of this rapid release has been addressed by several strategies. One strategy involves sintering of the ceria particles in early stages of catalyst formulation to decrease the active ceria surface area and thus decrease their capacity for sulfate storage. A second strategy involves incorporation of a sulfur scavenging agent such as nickel or copper, which reacts with gas phase H2S in fuel-rich conditions to form nickel or copper sulfide. In subsequent oxygen-rich conditions, the sulfide compound is oxidized to form gas phase SO 2 and nickel or copper sulfate [24-26]. Finally, we note from very early studies of oxidation catalysts that in oxygen-rich environment and in the presence of water, any sulfur trioxide which is formed from the oxidation of sulfur dioxide can react further to form sulfurous and sulfuric acids, which can further react with alumina to form aluminum sulfate [40] which is stable from 100~ to 650~ Decomposition of this compound at higher temperatures or even interaction of the acid species with alumina can result in formation of surface acid sites which are very active for the oxidation of alkane hydrocarbons, as observed in oxygen-rich conditions when sulfur is present in the exhaust gas [24]. Formation of these surface acid sites in the catalyst, however, can lead to coking [41]. As the need for more effective emission controls became evident through the Clean Air Act Amendments of 1990, attention turned to the use of Pd catalysts to achieve rapid activation, or lightoff, during the early phase of the FTP test, where most of the hydrocarbon emissions are produced. Concerns have arisen, however, concerning the particular sensitivity of Pd catalysts to sulfur poisoning and a sulfur "memory" effect. Of the noble metals used in three-way automotive catalysts, Pd is most likely to exist in an oxide form [42], at least under oxygen-rich conditions, leading to the possible formation of a Pd sulfite or sulfate. In addition, it has also been suggested that Pd in the metallic form is uniquely capable of storing sulfur atoms in the bulk of the metal particle, which would also provide a rational explanation for the sensitivity to sulfur poisoning and memory effects. Indeed, surface science studies have provided evidence for such a phenomenon [43]. In summary, these concerns about Pd catalysts have led to a number of studies comparing its sensitivity to sulfur poisoning to that of other noble metals, as well as further development of ways to reduce this sensitivity, as we will discuss in the following section. 3. T H E I M P A C T OF SULFUR ON PALLADIUM L I G H T O F F CATALYSTS L A B O R A T O R Y STUDIES In this section we will discuss an example of recent laboratory work on the impact of sulfur on palladium catalysts formulations compared to other noble metal formulations. The laboratory studies discussed here have been performed using an apparatus which simulates the exhaust gas generated from a vehicle under several operating modes. The simulated exhaust gas is then heated to a controlled level and directed to a sample core taken from a commercial automotive converter. Quantitative analysis of pollutant and other gas species (CO, HC, NOx, CO 2 and 02) is performed using gas bench analyzers prior to and following the catalyst sample to determine the conversion efficiency for HC, CO and NOx. One of the tests used in analyzing catalyst performance involves a determination of the temperature at which the catalyst becomes active (sometimes called a lightoff temperature). A second test involves varying the average air/fuel ratio to determine the performance of the
27
catalyst as a function of gas stoichiometry, which we designate as an air/fuel sweep test. A third analysis involves operation of the catalyst at a constant temperature while varying the sulfur concentration to determine its impact. The reactor used to generate these tests as well as a more complete description of the tests has been discussed elsewhere [44]. We will first compare the results of tests conducted on Pd and Pt/Rh formulations. Both catalysts were obtained as commercial products in 1993, the Pd formulation with a loading of roughly 0.29%, and the P t ~ h formulation with a loading of 0.13 wt. % Pt, 0.0093 wt. % Rh. Both formulations contained about the same amount of ceria. Sample cores were taken from whole monolith converters of each formulation. Each sample core was aged using a laboratory reactor to an equivalent of 30,000 to 50,000 miles aging on a vehicle. The impact of sulfur on catalyst lightoff was determined first. For these tests, the catalyst sample temperature was varied from 100~ to 600~ using a constant rate of temperature increase. The sulfur level was held constant during the generation of each lightoff curve, and this was repeated using several different sulfur levels representative of the field. The effects of sulfur dioxide on lightoff at stoichiometry of the thermally aged 0.29 % Pd catalyst are shown in Figure 2. Catalyst lightoff profiles were obtained for sulfur levels simulating 0 to 450 ppm in fuel. Each test was followed by a temperature excursion to 700 ~ C in order to restore the catalytic activity to a level equivalent to 0 ppm sulfur in the feedstream. The results consistently show an increase in lightoff temperature, and therefore decreases in activities to remove HC, CO and NOx as the sulfur content in the feedstream is increased. The increase in the lightoff temperatures of HC and CO is non-linear with increasing sulfur concentration such that most of the increase in the lightoff temperature occurs at the lowest
100
Pd Catalyst
t
r
50 r. ! ' - t [ I ".:! }- I/."i
v
0 r (D o uJ tO O3
> 0 0
0
Pt-Rh Catalyst
-++~--~-:.--~ "
-
1"-15oppm I --- 300 ppm I --- 450 ppm
t ...... 0 p p m a f t e r 4 5 0 p p m
100
! |
1
/
.,-.-,--..'...,..,+ .................
50 co
+0I
O0
,~..... i . . . . . . .
....
20'() ..............300
NSx.] 400
Temperature (C)
500 200
300
400
500
Temperature (C)
Figure 2. Impact of sulfur on lightoff profiles of aged Pd and Pt/Rh commercial catalysts determined in a laboratory study.
28 sulfur levels corresponding to 0 to 150 ppm, while a smaller increase in the lightoff occurs with further increase in the SO 2 concentration from 150 ppm to 450 ppm Typical of a Pd catalyst of this generation, the NOx activity is markedly lower than HC or CO, and adding even small amounts of SO 2 results in the failure to reach the 50% conversion efficiency over the temperature range tested. Although not indicated in this figure, the magnitude of the effect of SO 2 on lightoff activity is larger than the effect of the thermal aging procedure on activity. The thermal aging procedure used in this study has been found to generally cause a 30-35~ increase in CO and HC lightoff temperature, while the impact of a sulfur increase form 0 ppm to 450 ppm results in an increase of 40-50~ in CO and HC lightoff temperature. Similar lightoff tests performed with the Pt/Rh catalyst are also shown in Figure 2. Note again that the HC, CO and NOx lightoff temperature increases as the sulfur content in the feedstream is increased. The magnitude of the increase in lightoff is on the order of 35 ~ as the SO 2 content is increased from 0 ppm to 450 ppm, somewhat smaller than for Pd, but the magnitude of the impact is non-linear in the same way as the Pd catalyst. Although not indicated in this figure, the impact of increasing the sulfur level from 0 to 450 ppm is roughly comparable to the effect of the thermal aging treatment used in this study. We note in comparing the two catalyst technologies for the case with no sulfur present in the feedstream, Pd holds a clear advantage over Pt/Rh for reducing cold-start alkene hydrocarbon and CO emissions; this is one of several reasons why Pd-based catalyst technology is used in closecoupled converter applications. The non-linear relationship between the SO 2 concentration and the magnitude of the impact on hydrocarbon performance for Pd and Pt-Rh based catalysts is characteristic of the effect of sulfur on monolithic three-way catalysts observed in previously reported laboratory [ 18] and vehicular studies (Figure 3) [20]. Both studies show that as the sulfur content is increased, the degradation in the lightoff or warmed-up emissions increases at a high rate initially, but becomes more gradual at higher sulfur levels, suggesting that very small amounts of sulfur in the exhaust can have a significant effect on emissions. This is consistent with our earlier discussion of surface science data showing that low surface coverages of SO 2 can inhibit the adsorption of other gas phase species such as CO, NOx or HC on noble metal surfaces. For all of the aged catalysts, additional lightoff tests were performed with no SO 2 in the feedstream following the lightoff experiment using 450 ppm SO 2. The results (dashed lines in Figure 2) show a decrease in the lightoff temperatures from the 450 ppm SO 2 experiment for both Pd and Pt-Rh type catalysts, but only partial recovery of activity (relative to the catalyst prior to exposure to SO2) has taken place with the Pd catalyst, whereas nearly complete recovery of the original activity has taken place with the Pt-Rh catalyst. This irreversible sulfur poisoning has been observed elsewhere for Pd catalysts in particular [20,41 ]. It has been suggested that this apparent irreversibility under typical catalyst operating temperature (400-600~ is related to a direct reaction between SO 2 and supported Pd metal, perhaps leading to the formation of a surface PdS-like species on the surface of the Pd particles [43]. However, as stated earlier, evidence of the ability of sulfur atoms to migrate into the bulk of Pd metal has been found recently, a phenomenon not observed for other noble metals. Additional tests with both aged catalysts were performed in which the net stoichiometry was scanned from a net reducing feedstream (A/F = 14.1) through stoichiometry (A/F = 14.6) to a net oxidizing feedstream (A/F = 15.1) at a constant temperature of 500~ During this test, a cycling amplitude of +0.3 A/F and a cycling frequency of 2.0 Hz was used. This A/F ratio sweep test closely models the exhaust of a late model 3.8 L V-6 engine operating under closed-loop control, and was used to determine the impact of sulfur on catalyst activity as a function of feedstream stoichiometry by first collecting data using no sulfur in the feedstream, and then repeating with 450 ppm sulfur in the feedstream. Figure 4 shows that in the oxidative, or "lean" exhaust environment between mean A/F ratios of 15.1 to 14.7, the presence of SO 2 results in a slight decrease in the conversion efficiency for HC, CO and NOx. Below a value of 14.7, the presence of sulfur results in a slight decrease in the CO act-
29 iii
im
E
o~
O
-i-
022 0.18 0.14 3.0
E
o~
2.6
~, . . . . . . . . . . . .
~~
I
=.c o ~. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
NMHC o .............o .............<>-I
I
--
I CO
|
O
II 1.8 0.75 i--
/
Z
...........
E1............El ............r ' i
Io i I
O
0
........0
~
.............
I
I
I " Three fuel set I I |
NOx D
0.55 0.45
0
I I I I 100 200 300 400 Sulfur Concentration (ppm)
500
Figure 3. Impact of fuel sulfur on vehicle emission performance in an FTP test for a 1989 model year vehicle. ivity which continues until a rich extreme of 14.1 in A/F ratio. The effect of SO 2 on the conversion efficiencies of HC and NOx, however, is significant below an A/F ratio of 14.7 and increases with decreasing mean A/F until the "rich" extreme of 14.1 is reached. Thus, the degree of the impact of sulfur on HC and NOx conversion efficiency is greatest under stoichiometric and "rich" operating conditions. The maximum impact of 450 ppm SO 2 in terms of breakthrough in HC and NOx occurs at a mean A/F ratio of 14.3 to 14.2. At this point, the HC breakthrough increases by 600-700% while the NOx breakthrough increases by 400-500%. This behavior has been observed in other laboratory studies [26] and is consistent with suggestions that SO 2 poisons the noble metal surface under rich conditions [18]. In the case of the thermally aged 0.13% Pt, 0.0093% Rh production catalyst (Figure 4), the effect of adding 450 ppm SO 2 is generally similar to the Pd catalyst in that the HC and NOx conversion efficiencies are significantly decreased in rich conditions, while the CO conversion efficiency is only moderately decreased under rich conditions. With no sulfur present, propylene conversion efficiency is slightly lower for the Pd catalyst in comparison to the Pt-Rh catalyst in lean or stoichiometric conditions, but higher for the Pd catalyst under rich conditions. This hydrocarbon activity advantage of Pd over Pt-Rh under rich conditions
30 0 ppm s
0 o 100 ~ {m i_~
LU(_ 90 1 ._o (/) > 80 = 100 oo 50
....'"i:;..._...........
HC
'
|
0 ppm s Pt/Rh Catalyst
.......................
"" ,'"" 450 ppm S
50
0
Pd Catalyst
|
0 ppm S ..-77:7:'"'"
.-~
0 ppm****S o...... ~."" s
CO
.,.ooo*
'"'":'45~ ppm S -
-
I
.
.
.
B"
ttt ttt~ttt
~f3
,
v
v
..-'"'450 ppm S .
l
...b ppm s ....... ; .....
.
,
,
..... ",,. 0 ppm S
NOx
~ ~%~
.
14.4 14.8 Mean A/F Ratio
NOx
"Qq,.....
.............. "'O~.o 450 ppm S %,,.:...
..'" .............. :::. ..'" 450 ppm S 14
HC
.-;"" 450 ppm S
* ~. . . . ***-**:Z- ~
-
"
15.2
14
.
.
,
.
.
.
n
"'.'::':':'.%
14.4 14.8 Mean A/F Ratio
15.2
Figure 4. Impact of sulfur on performance of aged Pd and Pt/Rh commercial catalysts under warmed-up conditions as a function of air/fuel ratio. is completely lost when 450 ppm S O 2 is present in the feedstream. This phenomenon becomes a disadvantage when sulfur is removed from the feedstream, since the Pd catalyst does not recover all of its original activity, but the Pt-Rh catalyst does. With an increase in the sulfur content in the gas feedstream, the consequent decrease in the NOx activity of the Pd catalyst was larger than the Pt-Rh catalyst. This result is consistent with the reported relative resistance of Rh to sulfur poisoning [ 13-18]. Further tests with the Pd catalyst showed that the deterioration in HC and NOx performance at stoichiometry and at 600~ due to sulfur is fully reversible when the sulfur concentration is increased from 15 ppm to 75 ppm and returned to 15 ppm. However, the deterioration of HC and NOx performance that occurs when the sulfur concentration is increased from 15 ppm to 450 ppm is not completely reversed when the sulfur level is subsequently reduced to 15 ppm unless the catalyst is operated at or above 700~ (Figure 5). The impact of sulfur on warmed-up HC efficiency was minimal for operation above 700~ at either rich or stoichiometric conditions, which again is consistent with our findings that sulfur species can be removed from noble metal surfaces by reaction above this temperature under both oxygen-rich and oxygen-poor conditions. To summarize the laboratory data comparing Pd and Pt/Rh commercial catalysts, we found that an increase in the sulfur content in simulated exhaust results in a loss of both lightoff and warmed-up activity. The lightoff activity of the Pd is generally better than the Pt-Rh catalyst regardless of the sulfur content in the feedstream. Under warmed-up conditions, the loss of activity for HC, CO and NOx in the presence of sulfur was greater under slightly rich conditions than under lean conditions for both Pd and Pt-Rh catalysts,
31
100
Recovery of Activity at Stoichiometry
80 6O 0-.9. v
r t(1)
, .,,..
r UJ tO
(9
> tO
4O 20 0
'00tL- [l 80 60
L !!.--L-- W:" CI
Recovery of Activity in Rich Conditions .
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Ox
.
o
500 C 500 C 600 C 700 C no sulfur no sulfur no sulfur no sulfur 500 C 550 C 650 C 450 ppm no sulfur no sulfur sulfur
Figure 5. Reversibility of performance in Pd catalysts as a function of operating temperature and stoichiometry. while the magnitude of the impact on HC and NOx activity under warmed-up stoichiometric conditions was significant greater for the Pd catalyst than for the Pt-Rh catalyst. The change in the relative impact as a function of air/fuel ratio observed from these tests predicts that engine management can significantly influence the resulting magnitude of the sulfur impact on the emission control system, as discussed in the next section. Finally, it was found that the effect of SO 2 on the activity of the Pd catalyst was partly irreversible under the conditions used in this study, while the effect on Pt-Rh was completely reversible. Part of the irreversible poisoning is attributed to a reaction between SO 2 and Pd. Although the impact of sulfur on Pd catalyst performance as shown by these data is dramatic, recent advances in Pd catalyst technology have led to improvements in resistance to sulfur poisoning. Figure 6 shows a comparison between the catalyst used in the study just mentioned and a more recently developed Pd catalyst formulation having the same metal
32
-~
450
co
0
100
Improved pd Formulation
.
O
,-"
0-~
50
x
g 0
--
0
10
- - -
I
20
I
"
30
!
40
'
50
Time (minutes) Figure 6. Comparison of sulfur impact on two Pd catalyst formulations. loading. In both cases, cores from both catalysts were aged to an equivalent level and analyzed on the laboratory reactor system under constant temperature and using the same simulation of a mean air/fuel ratio of 14.6 with a cycling amplitude of _+0.3 air/fuel units and a cycling frequency of 2 Hz. The initial activity of the newer formulation is higher than the earlier generation formulation, and the impact of 450 ppm sulfur is smaller. This improved activity as well as improved resistance to sulfur poisoning can be attributed to the use of promoters and stabilizers such as zirconia and lanthana, as well as improvements in washcoat processing. Some of these improvements have been discussed in the literature recently and involve incorporation of sulfur "guards" or scavengers, as well as modifications to the ceria and the ceria-Pd interface [29]. 4. T H E I M P A C T OF S U L F U R ON A D V A N C E D A U T O M O T I V E C A T A L Y S T S : R E C E N T V E H I C L E STUDIES A number of vehicle studies have been conducted recently on the impact of sulfur on emissions, and recent emphasis has been placed on determining whether newer technology catalysts and emission control systems can be devised with greater tolerance to sulfur poisoning, particularly in light of increased strictness on emission standards. Although we will not be able to include all of the studies conducted recently, we will discuss some examples from the literature. As mentioned previously, there has been particular concern about the sensitivity of Pd and therefore Low Emission Vehicle (LEV) catalyst systems to sulfur poisoning. Indeed, studies of LEV candidate systems compared to earlier technology catalysts appears to verify these concerns (Table 2) [45]. According to these results, LEV catalysts on the whole perform better than earlier generation catalysts when operated on the
33 Table 2 Impact of Sulfur on Low Emission Vehicle Catalysts. Sulfur Level
Catalyst Efficiency (Warmed-Up Conditions, at Stoichiometry) HC (%) CO (%) NOx(%)
Car 1:2 converters, Pt/Rh lightoff and Pt/Rh underbody 40 ppm S 99.7 96.9 300 ppm S 98.5 93.3 600 ppm S 96.1 83.8
88.1 81.5 86.1
Car 2:1 converter, underbody, Pd front monolith, Pt/Rh rear monolith 40 ppm S 97.8 97.4 300 ppm S 94.5 81.6 600 ppm S 93.3 80.5
88.9 69.7 66.8
Car 3:1 converter, underbody, Pd front monolith, Pt/Rh rear monolith 40 ppm S 98.7 85.6 300 ppm S 96.0 77.8 600 ppm S 94.5 79.9
95.4 86.6 79.6
Fleet average from a set of 1989 model year vehicles: 40 ppm S 91.4 81.6 71.8 300 ppm S 89.3 74.1 69.3 600 ppm S 89.0 72.0 67.0 Note: all catalysts aged on an engine dynamometer to simulate 100,000 miles before testing. low sulfur content fuel (40 ppm S), but increases in the sulfur content result in larger relative decreases in catalyst HC efficiency for the LEV catalysts. The magnitude of the sulfur impact varies among the three vehicles, which have different catalyst configurations as described in the table. As discussed later in this section, the extent of the sulfur impact is vehicle and system dependent. Other studies have also been conducted recently that indicate that Pd catalysts may be more sensitive to sulfur poisoning. One recent study compared several catalyst technologies including Pd and Pt/Rh catalysts [28]. Part of the data from that study is summarized in Table 3. At stoichiometry, the performance of the Pd catalyst is less impacted than the Pt/Rh catalyst. Although this result differs from the laboratory studies mentioned earlier, it may be partly attributable to 1) different washcoat technologies being used for the two formulations and 2) the same aging conditions being used for the two technologies (it is well known that Pd and P t ~ h catalysts respond differently to the same laboratory or engine dynamometer aging condition. When tested using a fuel-rich condition with little sulfur present, the Pd catalyst was more active than Pt/Rh, but as the sulfur content was increased, performance deteriorated more rapidly for the Pd catalyst than for the Pt/Rh catalyst. The engine control systems used in this recent study [28] were operated in a fuel-rich mode during the initial warm-up phase of the federal test procedure (FTP), where most of the hydrocarbon emissions are emitted from the tailpipe, which is consistent with the observation that Pd is more severely deteriorated by sulfur than Pt/Rh. Other studies have been performed to compare how catalyst technologies and indeed entire vehicle emission systems respond to increased levels of fuel sulfur [46-48]. For some test vehicles, catalyst HC performance was particularly affected by fuel sulfur when Pd was involved in the catalyst. In other studies using TLEVs a distinct advantage of Pd catalysts
34 Table 3 Impact of Fuel Sulfur on Three-Way Catalyst Performance (warmed-up conversion efficiency at conditions shown during exposure to sulfur at the concentrations shown). Catalyst
Sulfur Level (ppm)
Reaction Condition
HC (%)
CO (%)
NOx (%)
Pd
14 90 500
stoichiometric
96 95 95
95 94 94
94 90 88
Pd
14 90 500
fuel-rich
73 71 59
37 24 12
94 65 43
Pd/Rh
14 90 500
stochiometric
96 94 93
95 87 82
93 86 80
Pd/Rh
14 fuel-rich 54 32 94 90 55 30 92 500 56 28 91 Note: Both catalysts operating at 450 C. Both catalysts had been aged on an engine dynamometer to simulate -50,000 miles. for the reduction of HC emissions was observed under all conditions, although high sulfur fuels caused significant deterioration in CO and NOx activity. Low temperature aging coupled with high sulfur exposure resulted in particularly poor performance for Pd catalysts when compared to P d ~ h and Pt/Rh catalysts [49]. For nearly all of these studies, the authors concluded that the extent of the sulfur effect was greatly influenced by the engine management strategy. Furthermore, the results suggest that emissions could be improved by advances in the emission control system technology. On the basis of these studies, it was also stated that some newly developed catalysts may have less sensitivity to sulfur than earlier generation Pt/Rh and Pd/Rh catalysts (Table 4). The resulting improvements observed in vehicle studies are consistent with laboratory tests mentioned earlier indicating greater sulfur tolerance in newer technology catalysts employing multilayer washcoats, sulfur "guards" and promoters and stabilizers. Table 4 Reduction in Vehicle Emissions Resulting From Reduction in Fuel Sulfur over Three Different Catalyst Technologies (Average Results Using Three Different Vehicles, European Test Procedure) Catalyst Technology CT 1 (Production Pt/Rh) CT2 (Pd/Rh, new technology) CT3 (same as CT2, but increased metal loadings)
HC (g/mi) CO (g/mi) NOx (g/mi) 0.010 0.007 0.015
Note: Results from reduction in fuel sulfur from 397 to 100 ppm.
0.117 0.140 0.030
0.043 0.030 0.030
35
To summarize, recently published vehicle studies suggest that Pd-only catalysts may under some conditions and in some vehicle applications be more sulfur-sensitive than Pt/Rh, Pd/Rh or Pt/Pd/Rh catalysts. However, recent improvements in Pd-containing catalyst technology may lead to better tolerance to sulfur poisoning, but improvements in catalyst performance and in sulfur tolerance may also depend on the vehicle and its emission control system properties. 5. T H E I M P A C T OF S U L F U R ON OBD-II C A T A L Y S T M O N I T O R There have also been some concerns about the impact of fuel sulfur on the operation and durability of on-board diagnostics (OBD-II) which are now required on all light and medium duty vehicles and which must assess the performance of a number of emission controls on the vehicle, including the catalytic converter system and oxygen sensors. Converter performance which falls below an acceptable level defined by the regulations must be identified as malfunctioning by activation of an indicator lamp and storage of a fault or trouble code in the engine control module (ECM) which can be read via access to the vehicle's assembly line data link (ALDL). When the fault code is set, it can only be cleared during servicing. The regulatory agencies have advocated the use of two conventional oxygen sensors placed in front of and behind each catalyst or catalyst system to determine catalyst efficiency [31-33]. This measurement method uses the air/fuel ratio "dithering" activity detected in the post-catalyst sensor either in an absolute way or relative to the dithering activity in the pre-catalyst sensor as an indication of loss of catalyst performance. Other data suggest that this measurement is correlatable to the relative oxygen storage capacity of the catalyst and not to catalyst hydrocarbon conversion efficiency directly [3334]. It has also been demonstrated that this measurement can be significantly affected by a variety environmental and operational conditions which cannot be controlled or are difficult to use as enabling criteria for measurement. This results in a high variability in the oxygen storage measurement itself, particularly for severely aged or damaged catalysts which are near the diagnostic failure criteria, which in turn can lead to a probability of misdiagnosis. One of the factors which can influence the measurable amount of oxygen storage is the sulfur content in the fuel, which in the form of sulfur dioxide in exhaust can react with the oxygen storage component in the catalyst (ceria) as we have mentioned in an earlier section. Some early studies which examined the impact of sulfur on the titratable oxygen storage in a catalyst showed a dramatic impact [35,36], although such studies were conducted in a laboratory using small cores from a production catalysts. The significance of the sulfur impact on OBD-II has been discussed elsewhere [50] and there is considerable disagreement about the extent of its expected impact in the field. Although few vehicle studies have been conducted [37,50,51 ], the available data verify sulfur can affect the OBD-II catalyst monitor, although such studies conclude that only catalysts which have been severely aged or have seen severe service may be susceptible to significant degradation by sulfur on oxygen storage capacity, as shown in the example data in Figure 7 [51 ]. Such catalysts perform adequately using a fuel with relatively low sulfur content, and thus should not be diagnosed as having failed, but when operated on a higher sulfur content fuel, they are diagnosed as having failed by the OBD-II system. Since these situations are not expected to occur until OBD-II equipped vehicles accumulate a high level of mileage (above 50,000 to 100,000 miles), and since improvements and modifications continue to be made in the OBD-II systems themselves, it is not known whether a significant number of these situations will occur in the field. However, there is also concern about the direct impact of sulfur on the operation of oxygen sensors, since they in part depend on the catalytic action of a Pt electrode which is exposed to the exhaust gas. Under certain operating conditions, it may be possible for the sulfur to poison the operation of the sensor itself, and thus interfere with the measurement of oxygen storage [51 ]. All of these issues continued to be studied.
36
"F: Maximum ::~ Value Im
-O ..,
(O 0
=E'E x 0 a)=E
"0
C
..,
(n
U)" -;" Cl Minimum Ill Value 0 0
9. . . .
e, .....
I. . . . .
200
,I .
.
400
.
.
600
.
.
800
1000
Fail Threshold
Sulfur Content in Fuel (ppm) Figure 7. Impact of sulfur on the OBD-II catalyst monitor in a production Transitional Low Emission Vehicle (TLEV). 6. SUMMARY In this discussion, a few examples of recent studies of the sulfur impact on performance of three-way catalysts and on catalyst oxygen storage have been discussed. Although this is not important in such locations as California or Japan where there are strict controls on the sulfur content in fuel, it is important in locations where the sulfur content in fuel is not strictly controlled and where advanced emission control standards have been adopted or are being considered. Although the use of Pd is one of the chief strategies for achieving rapid catalyst activation and for achieving improved HC activity, there is concern about its sensitivity to sulfur poisoning. Recent improvements in Pd and other catalyst technologies have resulted in improved sulfur tolerance, but the bulk of the data suggests the magnitude of the sensitivity of a catalyst to sulfur may depend heavily on how the catalyst is integrated with the vehicles' emission control system and engine management strategy. There are also concerns about the impact of sulfur on OBD-II systems and particularly on catalyst oxygen storage and the sensors used to measure oxygen storage capacity. The available vehicle data indicates sulfur can affect the measurement of oxygen storage capacity and thus impact the proper diagnosis of a converter, but only for severely aged converters. Since OBD-II is still in relative infancy, and it is anticipated that these systems will be improved over the next decade, additional studies will be needed to verify the extent and significance of the sulfur impact on catalyst performance and on OBD-II systems.
37 REFERENCES
1.
"National Fuel Surveys: Gasoline and Diesel Fuel, Winter 1994", American Automobile Manufacturers Association, 1995. 2. H.V. Drushel, Am. Chem. Soc., Div. Pet. Chem., Prepr., 15(2) (1970) C13. 3. O. Weisser and S. Landa, Sulfide Catalysts, Their Properties and Applications, Pergamon Press, New York, 1973. 4. C.N. Satterfield, AIChE J., 21 (1975) 209. 5. EPA Final Rule on Regulation of Fuels and Fuel Additives: Standards for Reformulated Gasoline, Federal Register Notice, July 20, 1994, p. 59FR36944. 6. K.C. Taylor, Ind. Eng. Chem., Prod. Res. Dev., 50 (1976) 264. 7. J.C. Summer, Env. Sci. Tech., 13 (1979) 321. 8. H.C. Yao and J. Yu, J. Catal., 36 (1975) 266. 9. J.C. Summers and K. Baron, J. Catal., 53 (1979) 380. 10. W. B. Williamson, H. S. Gandhi, M. E. Heyde and G. A. Zawacki, SAE Paper No. 790942 (1979). 11. G. J. Joy, G. R. Lester and F. S. Molinaro, SAE Paper No. 790943 (1979). 12. J. C. Schlatter and P. J. Mitchell, Ind. Eng. Chem., Prod. Res. Dev., 19 (1980) 288. 13. U. Kohler and H.W. Wassmuth, Surf. Sci., 126 (1983) 448. 14. O. K. T. Wu and R. P. Burns, Surf. Int. Anal., 3 (1981) 29. 15. M. L. Burke and R. J. Madix, Surf. Sci., 194 (1988) 223. 16. R. C. Ku and P. Wynblatt, Appl. Surf. Sci., 8 (1981) 250. 17. St. Astegger and E. Bechtold, Surf. Sci., 122 (1982) 491. 18. D. D. Beck, M. H. Krueger and D. R. Monroe, S AE Paper No. 910844 (1991). 19. R. L. Furey and D. R. Monroe, SAE Paper No. 811228 (1981). 20. W. J. Koehl, J. D. Benson, V. R. Burns, R. A. Gorse, Jr., A. M. Hochhauser, J. C. Knepper, W. R. Leppard, L. J. Painter, L. A. Rapp, R. M. Reuter and J. A. Rutherford, Effects of Gasoline Sulfur Level on Exhaust Mass and Speciated Emissions: The Question of Linearity - Auto/Oil Air Quality Improvement Program, SAE Paper No. 932727 (1993). 21. A. F. Diwell, C. Hallett and J. R. Taylor, SAE Paper No. 872163 (1987). 22. A. V. Deo, I. G. Dalla Lana and H. W. Habgood, J. Catal., 21 (1971) 2710. 23. A. Datta, R. G. Cavell, R. M. Tower and Z. M. George, J. Phys. Chem., 89 (1985) 443. 24. H. G. Henke, J. J. White and G. W. Denison, SAE Paper No. 872134 (1987). 25. J. C. Summers, J. F. Skowron and W. B. Williamson, SAE Paper No. 920558 (1992). 26. D. R. Monroe, M. H. Krueger, D. D. Beck and M. J. D'Aniello, Jr., Stud. Surf. Sci. Catal., 71 (1991) 593. 27. H. Muraki, SAE Paper No. 910842 (1991). 28. J. C. Summers, J. F. Skowron and M. J. Miller, SAE Paper No. 930386 (1993). 29. P. Burke, Presented to the American Chemical Society Fall National Meeting, August 1996, Orlando, FL. 30. California Code of Regulations, Section 1968.1, Title 13, Adopted September 14, 1989, Effective Sept. 26, 1990. 31. W. B. Clemmens, M. A. Sabourin, and T. Rao, SAE Paper No. 900062 (1990). 32. J. W. Koupal, M. A. Sabourin, and W. B. Clemmens, SAE Paper No. 910561 (1991). 33. J. S. Hepburn and H. S. Gandhi, SAE Paper No. 920831 (1992). 34. G. B. Fisher, J. R. Theis, M. V. Casarella and S. T. Mahan, SAE Paper No. 931034 (1993). 35. D. D. Beck, J. W. Sommers and C. L. DiMaggio, Appl. Catal. B: Environmental, 11 (1997) 273. 36. D. D. Beck, D. R. Monroe, C. L. DiMaggio and J. W. Sommers, SAE Paper No. 952416 (1995). 37. D. D. Beck, T. W. Silvis and S. T. Mahan, SAE Paper No. 941054 (1994). 38. C. R. Apesteguia, C. E. Brema, T. F. Garetto, A. Borgna and J. M. Parera, J. Catal., 89
38 (1984) 52. 39. J. M. MacLaren, J. P. Pendry and R. M. Joyner, Surf. Sci. Lett., 165 (1986) L80. 40. W. W. Decker and J. R. West (eds.), The Manufacture of Sulfur Acid, Robert Krieger Publishing Company, Huntington, New York, 1974. 41. D. D. Beck and J. W. Sommers, Stud. Surf. Sci. Catal., 96 (1995) 721. 42. R. J. Farrauto, J. K. Lampert, M. C. Hobson and E. M. Waterman, Appl. Catal. B: Environmental, 6 (1995) 263. 43. C. L. DiMaggio and D. D. Beck, "Interaction Between Sulfur and Pd Surfaces", Surf. Sci. Lett (submitted). 44. D. D. Beck, M. H. Krueger, D. R. Monroe, D. J. Upton and J. M. Lendway, SAE Paper No. 920099 (1992). 45. F. S. Gerry, R. A. Gorse, Jr., W. J. Bandy, D. D. Beck, V. Bums, H. Doherty, G. Herwick and J. Rutherford, CRC Sulfur/OBD-II Laboratory Research Program: Executive and Technical Final Reports, Coordinating Research Council Report No. 602 (1997). 46. P. Beckwith, P. J. Bennett, C. L. Goodfellow, R. J. Brisley and A. Wilkins, SAE Paper No. 940310 (1994). 47. P. J. Bennett, P. Beckwith, S. D. Bjordal and C. L. Goodfellow, SAE Paper No. 961901 (1996). 48. S. D. Bjordal, C. L. Goodfellow, P. Bennett and P. Beckwith, SAE Paper No. 961902 (1996). 49. J. E. Thoss, J. S. Rieck and C. J. Bennett, SAE Paper No. 970737 (1997). 50. L. H. Browning and C. B. Moyer, SAE Paper No. 952422 (1995). 51. D. D. Beck and W. A. Short, SAE Paper No. 952424 (1995).
9
Elsevier Science B. V. All rights reserved
Catalyst Deactivation 1997 C.H. Bartholomewand G.A. Fuentes, editors
39
Solid State Reactions in Catalysts: A n A p p r o a c h to Real Active Systems and t h e i r Deactivation
Bernard Delmon Universit6 catholique de Louvain, Unit6 de catalyse et chimie des matrriaux divisrs, Place Croix du Sud, 2/17, B- 1348 Louvain-la-Neuve (Belgium).
Solid state reactions are involved in many stages of catalyst life, from preparation to deactivation. Reactions taking place at the catalyst surface during catalysis may relate to those occurring during preparation. They are the origin of several deactivation processes. The present contribution is aimed at enlarging the concept of deactivation by solid state reactions by considering all those involved in the bulk and surface over the entire life of the catalyst. The main example will be that of the behaviour of molybdenum oxides in selective oxidations. It will be shown that the formation of shear planes explains (i) the activation of MoO3 to the very flexible structure of the active suboxide (Mo18052 or Mo8023), (ii) the exceptional catalytic activity of these two intermediary oxides and (iii) the deactivation due to the formation of Mo4Oll. This conclusion concerning the similitude of solid state reactions at various stages of catalyst life can be extended to molybdates of various metals and other catalysts active in selective oxidation. This suggests that a comprehensive view of the whole catalyst life may enable a better control of useful catalytic properties. The beneficial role of spillover oxygen, adequate supports, or the advantage of alternate reduction and oxidation stages in the industrial process (e.g. the so-called "riser" reactor) are, among others, examples of useful, practical applications which emerge when this comprehensive view is adopted.
1.
INTRODUCTION
This contribution will address some issues which are not examined usually in meetings on catalyst deactivation. We will look at catalyst deactivation in a broader context, namely the modifications that solid catalysts (and probably also homogeneous ones!) continuously undergo while they are acting catalytically under reaction conditions. As underlined in our previous contributions, this is particularly relevant when solid-state reactions are considered, because solids have a sort of memory (1,2). Their transformations at a given moment are strongly influenced by the whole succession of conditions they have been subjected to. If we adopt this global view, another question arises. Catalysts, as they work in catalytic reactors, are just the intermediary product of a solid state reaction chain which starts with preparation and activation, before the catalysts is contacted with the feed, and is followed by deactivation and, ultimately, "death". The question is: what are the relationships among solid-state reactions occurring during the initial activation, catalytic reaction and deactivation?
40 For many catalysts, the technical challenge is not only attaining higher activity or better selectivity, but also achieving more resistance to ageing and deactivation. The second goal is even predominant in the case of steam reforming catalysts, some water-gas-shift catalysts, and methanation catalysts, especially in coal gasification. And the demands on catalysts are increasingly more severe. Even in hydrotreating, which had been a long-time work horse of catalysis, extreme activity and selectivity are now necessary for producing fuels increasingly less harmful to the environment. Selective oxidation (SO) is coming to the forefront of catalysis. For paraffins, activity and selectivity are crucial to the success of SO processes. Let us consider a classical example, the selective oxidation of butane to maleic anhydride (MAA). The best catalysts give, let us say, 70% selectivity to MAA in laboratory experiments. In fixed bed tubular reactors, it may take up to two weeks for freshly prepared catalysts to reach optimal activity and selectivity. But until recently, the selectivity in industrial reactors declined progressively to less than 55% over a period of 2 to 3 months, and many plants reported even 45% selectivity to MAA. It is now known that almost all these changes involve solid state reactions. This clearly suggests that maintaining high performance demands stimulating favourable reactions leading to selective phases and repressing those causing deactivation. In the previous case (SO to MAA), both activation and deactivation are reactions of solids with butane and oxygen. They are necessarily linked to each other. Hence, it follows that an effort aimed at maximising the active and selective phase must take into account all solid-state reactions from preparation to death. Making an analogy with ordinary kinetics, the problem is to maximise an intermediate product in a system of consecutive reactions. As regards the catalysts active in the reaction of butane to MAA, the beautiful work of J.C. Volta et al. gives clues to the activation reactions (3,4). A challenge is now to disentangle the solid state phenomena leading to deactivation. The above line of thought suggests that, where solid state reactions and deactivation are concerned, a closer look at the active state of the catalyst is absolutely necessary. This is done in this contribution. This comprehensive approach is probably not as important when other causes of deactivation are concerned, namely poisoning and coke formation. Nevertheless, in pursuing a comprehensive approach, it should be remembered that the various types of deactivation processes occurring in a given catalyst are far from independent. This conclusion is strongly supported by the fact that a large proportion of the authors in the series of Symposia on Catalyst Deactivation had to consider the coming into play, simultaneously, of more than one process, in the deactivation phenomena they described. These processes often belonged to different categories (coking, poisoning or solid state transformation). In this contribution, we shall first provide a backdrop by addressing the role of chemical structure in the working catalyst and the problem posed by the fact that the real working catalyst largely escapes physico-chemical characterisation. The subsequent section presents in detail the behaviour of MoO3 in selective oxidation catalysis. This is a relatively simple illustrative example of the comprehensive approach which is necessary for correctly understanding the problem and correlatively finding practical solutions. In the last section, a few examples are outlined where the approach presented earlier can be used with profit.
2.
SOLID STATE R E A C T I O N S IN W O R K I N G CATALYSTS
Scientists are now convinced that high activity and selectivity demand that the catalytically active atoms be in a very precise coordination. Well defined geometrical arrangements of surface
41 metal and oxygen atoms are certainly necessary in selective oxidation (especially in the case of the butane to maleic anhydride reaction, where 7 oxygen atoms must be extracted almost simultaneously from the vanadium phosphate lattice in a concerted mechanism). In hydrotreating, the hydrogenation sites consist of molybdenum atoms in a special coordination at the edges of MoS2 (a threefold coordinatively-unsaturated Mo). The hydrodesulfurization sites are very likely made of an ensemble of 2 Mo vicinal atoms in two different coordination environments. Nevertheless, the fundamental approach to heterogeneous catalysis still rests heavily on correlations between catalytic properties on the one hand and the coordination of surface atoms in the metal, oxide or sulfide phases as prepared by the experimenter. The control of this coordination is exerted via the choice of matrices with a selected structure, the use of grafted organo-metallic compounds of known configuration, or innumerable special fabrication techniques. This approach is observed to be unsuccessful in the vast majority of cases, because it is based on the implicit assumption that catalyst surface is not modified under reaction conditions. Actually, the surfaces of catalysts undergo continuous changes. The coordination achieved at the preparation stage is extensively modified under reaction conditions. Considering any given point of the surface, this coordination varies cyclically under the influence of the dynamics of the catalytic reaction. This may bring about changes in the course of time. It should be remarked incidentally that very few methods have been envisaged to achieve control of coordination at a later stage of catalyst life, namely when the catalyst is in a state closer to the functioning form. The mere adsorption of molecules modifies the atomic arrangement at the surface of solids. This was mentioned by Boreskov and other groups more than 20 years ago (5-7). Later, surface science experiments demonstrated this unequivocally. Adsorption brings about a reconstruction of surfaces. Many examples concerning metals have been published (8,9). The changes concern the coordination of a large proportion of surface atoms (often all of them). One or two layers below the surface are also affected. More profound changes in the coordination of surface atoms must occur when catalytic surfaces are contacted with reacting molecules. These changes are also demonstrated in surface science experiments on metals. When deactivation by solid state reactions is considered, the structure or, more precisely, the dynamic (one could say "wobbly") structural arrangement of the working catalyst, may be the starting point of further solid-state reactions. It should be emphasised that catalysis is a dissipative phenomenon occurring at surfaces (in the sense of the so-called "irreversible thermodynamics"). Energy is continuously dissipated. This facilitates the movement of surface atoms. This explains why loose or flexible structures form during the catalytic process. The excess free energy of these structures and the corresponding high reactivity make them inevitably excellent precursors for new, more stable, phases. These phases of higher stability are likely to be less active. The consequence is that the changes occurring continuously in the dynamic state trigger a part of, if not all of, the solid state reactions that lead to deactivation. At first glance, the above remarks do not seem to bring much new insight. In the field of oxidation, it has always been considered that the reduction-oxidation state of the working catalyst determined the rate of the deactivation due to solid-state processes. It was widely recognised, in particular, that progressive reduction of a catalytic phase during the successive catalytic cycles could lead to deactivation by loss or segregation of components. The nuance introduced by the above brief analysis is that the reactions and mechanisms determining activity and selectivity may be the same as those triggering deactivation. This justifies the present attempt to undertake a comprehensive approach. Selective catalytic oxidations provide examples which can illustrate this
42 new approach. This is the reason why a substantial part of this work deals with this group of reactions.
3. MoO3 AS O X I D A T I O N C A T A L Y S T : T H E S T A R T I N G O X I D E , T H E WORKING CATALYST, THE DEACTIVATED STRUCTURE
3.1.
General mechanism
Molybdenum oxide is present, together with molybdates of various metals (e.g. iron, cobalt or bismuth), in many selective oxidations catalysts (e.g. catalysts for oxidation of olefins and oxidative dehydrogenation of alcohols). Structurally, much is known concerning MOO3. Its catalytic activity has been extensively investigated. It will serve here as an illustration of the close relationships between the mechanisms explaining catalytic activity and deactivation. In doing so, account will be taken of results presented during the previous Symposium on Deactivation (10). In a sense, this section constitutes a logical continuation of this previous work. The catalyst as prepared by precipitation and calcination is fully oxidised (MOO3). Structurally, it consists of corner-sharing octahedra (Fig. 1a). The conventional picture of Fig. lb will be used for representing these MoO6 octahedra in several figures. Let us recall that the catalytic cycle in selective oxidation consists in a reduction of the catalyst by the hydrocarbon and the subsequent reoxidation by molecular oxygen. In the case of the so-called aUylic oxidation, e.g. propene to acrolein, 2 atoms of oxygen from the catalyst are used, one for removing 2 hydrogen atoms from the olefin, and the other one for forming the unsaturated aldehyde: Reduction: CH2 = CH - CH3 + MonO3n --~ CH2 = CH - CHO + H20 + MonO3n-2
(1)
Oxidation: MonO3n-2 + 02 --~ MonO3n
(2)
a
b
Figure 1. MoO6 octahedra in MoO3 (in the full 2-dimensional structure, each O atom is shared between 2 octahedra). The distortion of the real structure (a) is not shown in the conventional representation (b). Q Mo atom, O O atom
43
3.2.
Structural aspects
The octahedra in MoO3 can also adopt an arrangement different from that of Fig. 1. By losing one oxygen, they form edge-sharing pairs. The cyclic reduction-reoxidation of the surface of MoO3 therefore corresponds to the cyclic transformation of twin adjacent pairs of corner-sharing octahedra losing 2 oxygen atoms to form 2 adjacent pairs of edge-sharing octahedra. This is represented in Fig. 2.
c.2:c.-c. 3
CH2 = CH- CliO
..2o
| o2 Figure 2. Schematic representation of the cyclic reduction/oxidation of twin pairs of MoO6 octahedra between the comer and the edge-sharing arrangements (Boxes represent MoO6 octahedra with sharing of oxygen atoms at comers for MoO 3 or edges for MOO2). The figure is not completely accurate, because it cannot take into account the fact that the arrangements are not perpendicular to the main axes of the lattice. It turns out that the reduction by the olefin is more rapid than the reoxidation by 02 when pure MoO3 is used under ordinary oxidation conditions (this is suggested by the thickness of the arrows in Fig. 2). This occurs in spite of the fact that oxygen is in stoichiometric excess with respect to the selective oxidation. This imbalance in the kinetics results in a reduction of the surface of MOO3, which triggers a reduction in the bulk. Recent results obtained by Gai and Boyes (see Gai, ref. 11) show that a flexible structure which constitutes the most active and selective phase could be Mo18052. This is slightly reduced compared to MOO3; the presence of oxygen vacancies permits a smooth reduction-oxidation cycle. In Mo18052, two oxygens are removed out of three in some oxygen rows (one row out of 18). Each missing atom corresponds to replacing one comer-sharing arrangement of octahedra by one edge-sharing link. Thus, in Mo18052, this occurs for one Mo atom of the structure out of 18. Fig. 3a and 3b represent schematically the structure of fully oxidised MoO3 and MO18052. Considering in a general way the sub-oxides MoO3_x, the edge-sharing pairs assemble in shear planes going obliquely across the structure, as suggested by the arrows in Fig. 3. This is very close to our finding that the active structure might be Mo8023, which we detect in substantial quantities after work in catalysts having reached a high activity, and protected from overreduction thanks to the action of spillover oxygen during the catalytic reaction (12). Mo18052 and Mo8023 do not seem to differ very much in their behaviour in reduction and reoxidation.
44 If the reoxidation to MoO3 (Fig. 1) is too slow, further reduction occurs, leading t o other suboxides of molybdenum. These are less selective catalytically. Although not proven unequivocally, these suboxides are more difficult to reoxidise in the bulk (especially the ultimate term of the series, MO4Oll). This brings about a deactivation difficult to reverse. As will be mentioned later, the deactivation effect is still more catastrophic in binary oxides (molybdates) than in MOO3. Fig. 3 strikingly illustrates the fact that exactly the same reaction mechanism is responsible for activation (transforming MoO3 to Mo18052 or Mo8023) and deactivation (Mo18052 or Mo8023 to Mo4Oll represented in Fig. 3c). Generally speaking, avoiding deactivation implies that the reduction and reoxidation rates of Fig. 1 are perfectly balanced. Our contribution in a previous symposium on Catalyst Deactivation was to show that spillover oxygen produced by a "Donor" (e.g. Sb204) could re-establish this balance (10). Another possible strategy would be to exert an adequate strain to the catalytic oxide lattice to stabilise the loose, unstable state. This is probably the action that TiO2 supports exert on V6013 islands (13-15) and this could explain the unique role of TiO2 (anatase) in V205/TiO2 catalysts active in the oxidation of o-xylene to phthalic anhydride. I Ix3 b(l IX3 [x~ ~ ~ Ix3 ~
e
I~ ~ cx3~ cx3~ lx~~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ I I IXi IX] IXI IXI IXI 1XI IX] IX] [Xl IXl IXl IX] 1Xl 1x] IX] IX] I I [ X ] IXl IX] IX] I ~ IX] IX] Ix]
3.3.
Mesoscopic
changes
The fact that the really active oxides, namely Mo18052 or Mo8023, correspond [XI ~ t~ ~ I~ ~ ~ 1 to loose, flexible structures, in which I ~ ~ ~ ~ g~ ~ ~ t~ ~ some small domains continuously change M~ 3 ~-- their structural arrangement, has still ~I q ~ other consequences than just the I = , = N IX! ~ I ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ i ~ ~ ~x~ ~ structural modifications outlined above. g~ ~ a ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ t~ ~ a ~ ~ I We have postulated that the continuous I IX] I IX] IXI IX] IX:] IX] IXI IX] IX] =.~a iX] IXI ~a ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ 1 ~ ~ I changes between corner-sharing and b 1 IX] ~z,a IX] I>q IX] IXI IX] IXI IX] ~ IXI ~ t edge-sharing arrangements of MoO6 IX] IX] I IX] IXl IX] I ~ IX] IXl IXI IXl ~ IX! I I IX] r IXI IXI IX] IX] IXI IXI IXI IXI I IX] IXl octahedra could permit the progressive IX] IXl txBa IXI IX11XI IXI I,X] IX] IXl t~x= IX] I reconstruction of the surface withmhopeI IX] IXI I IX] IXI IX] IX] IXl IX] IXI IX] =~x= IXI fullymthe consequence that the number ~__ 18Mo "columns" ~_ ~ of active sites would increase. We Mo1aOc;9 (or Moa 09-~, with 8 columns) therefore predicted that the topography of the surface of MoO3 should undergo I ix=x= IXl I IX] =,:=a = ~ a IXI tXi ix=x= =a=~ IX] I IX] =,a~ I changes at the nanometer or micrometer I IX] I IX] = = a z.=xs IX] I IXI scale ("mesoscopic" scale) in catalytic IXI =~x= IX] I ~ r r I c I-IX] =~=a =xma IXI I IX] =mix. conditions where the loose, unstable R lXl I IXI r =':=a IXI I I =xmq ix=x= IXI ! IX] =xma r structure exists. Our experiments show I I IXI ==a ~cmx= IXI I IXI ~ ~=,a IX] I IXl DaDqf =z,~ ]XI I that. At the micrometer scale, steps appear on MoO3 crystallites (12,16). At the nanometer scale, in addition, the M~ surface develops fractures or, more Figure 3. Schematic representation of the structure of precisely, pits (17). This takes place only MOO3, Mo18052 and Mo4Oll. The same inaccuracy as in Fig. 2 impairs the present picture. The shear planes in when the dynamic, loose structure is Mo18052 and Mo4Oll are represented by the oblique maintained. Spillover oxygen maintains arrows. (Boxes with an "X" represent MoO5 octahedra), the catalyst active (i.e. in the dynamic
45 state) in conditions where the kinetic imbalance between reduction and oxidation would reduce MoO3 in the absence of spillover oxygen. This is possible because oxygen is always in excess in the gas phase as long as the reaction is selective and does not give too large amounts of complete oxidation products (H20 and CO2). This allowed a comparison and produced this striking result. Although our analysis of the dynamic phenomenon is not as complete as that involving changes in structure, we can speculate on the results obtained. This analysis strongly suggests another relation between the "life" of the real working catalyst and deactivation. To understand this relationship, we need a more detailed representation of the structure. This is presented in Fig. 4. A better understanding of the structure of MoO3 is obtained by comparing the relatively crude model of Fig. 3 and a more accurate one (Fig. 5). This latter figure makes 010~ netolane the MoO6 octahedra more apparent than in ~'Fig.. 4, and shows a shear plane (18). Returning to Fig. 4, the (010) face is totally non selective in the oxidation (100) netplane of olefins, producing only CO2 and H20. In addition, when crystalMO lographically perfect, this face has poor activity O (12,17). The active sites are situated on the (100) faces. Pits formed during the catalytic reaction are ~,, visible when looking at the (101) surface (nameMolybdenum trioxide, MoO 3 ,,~, ly looking vertically from the top in Fig. 4: this is Figure 4. Perspective view of the lattice of MoO3 (Balsac catalogue),
shown in Fig. 6). The pits (Fig. 6b) are holes or small crevices, the walls of which are composed of (100) planes (or other planes nearly perpendicular to the (101) face). The creation of pits does not occur under our reaction conditions in the absence of spillover oxygen, namely under conditions where MoO3 is overreduced (Fig. 6a). This can be understood when looking at Fig. 3 which shows that Mo4Oll, for example, has no twin pairs of comersharing octahedra. The dynamic reduction-reoxidation process presented schematically in Fig. 2 cannot take place in this case. The strong covalent links in the twin pairs of edge-sharing octahedra rigidify the structures. Incidentally, when looking at Fig. 5, it is apparent that shear planes contain more Mo-O-Mo bonds per unit volume, this suggesting intuitively that they make the structure less flexible.
46
o
b%
qB
i Figure 5. Representation of the layered structure of MOO3_x seen from the side. The shear structure shown (b) suggests that this induces the formation of steps or corrugations in the layers (18).
The discovery that pits form, namely at near-surface zones (we speculate the pits are about 5 nm deep) raises questions concerning deactivation. It is known that Mo-containing oxidation catalysts are mechanically fragile. Pit formation may trigger a fragmentation of MOO3, and consequently initiate deactivation by mechanical decay. But we must emphasise that this is still speculative. If this were the case, a second type of solid state reaction (admittedly linked to the first) would be involved both in activation (extension of (110) faces thanks to pit formation) and deactivation, supporting our view that the solid state reactions leading to the creation of catalytic sites (the creation of pits), permitting a steady state catalytic process and causing deactivation, are similar or identical.
3.4.
Possible consequences, possible remedies For many reasons, but principally in view of the fact that the highly efficient industrial ironmolybdate based catalysts for the oxidation of methanol to formaldehyde are composed of several phases and contain a very large amount of MoO3 besides Fe2(MoO4)3, we wondered whether MoO3 contributes significantly to the selective reaction. In view of our previous experiments, it could have been speculated that MOO3, by itself, is overreduced in the methanol-air mixture, and therefore deactivates quickly. We therefore tested MoO3 mechanically mixed with a-Sb204. Table 1 shows that, at 500~ the performance (at the laboratory scale) is equivalent to that of the industrial Fe2(MoO4)3-MoO3 catalyst (19). We attribute this spectacular result to the fact that the addition of a-Sb204 strongly retards the solid state reaction leading to deactivation of MOO3, very likely keeping the MoO3 surface in a higher oxidation state, thanks to spillover oxygen produced by aSb204.
Table 1 Activity of MoO3 and a MoO3 + a-Sb404 mixture (MM) in the selective reaction of methanol to formaldehyde (formaldehyde ~r conversion, and selectivity). Temperature ~
Yield % MM MoO 3
Conversion % MM MoO 3
350 42.4 60.5 42.3 82.0 400 68.1 67.8 68.8 78.6 500 93.5 63.8 94.0 82.1 Gas feed: methanol 6.5%, oxygen 19.6%, nitrogen 73.9%, gas hourly MoO3 174 mg + a-Sb204 174 mg; MoO3 174 mg. (19)
Selectivity % MM MoO 3 100 73.8 99.0 86.3 99.5 77.7 space velocity 26,220 h -1, MM:
47
Fr-e',...sh r t o O 3 - U
(Middle
o.f
the
crys:tal)
.8O0
.6O0
400
0
L:~Q
r~~.::~i~]ii!~-~. ~ + S b 2 0 4 .~,
Figure 6.
~
403
a ~"t, e r
600
r e a c : t, I or~
(. c,d.qe ..... r "~ ,. . . . .
. ....
(contact) pictures of (a) pure MOO3, (b) M o O 3 in an (~-Sb204 mixture ((z-Sb204
crystallites are not visible because they were swept away by the AFM tip) after the catalytic reaction (T 420 ~ isobutene:O2:He = 1:2:7; 3 hr). The pure sample is unchanged after the reaction with the isobutene - 02 - He mixture. The addition of a-Sb204 to MoO3 does not alter the surface of MoO 3 before the reaction (17). There is good reason to believe that similarly interesting effects could be observed with molybdates of various metals, which are widely used as selective oxidation catalysts. The postulated solid state reactions of MoO3 can serve as a relevant model for the phenomena occurring in these catalysts. The structures of many molybdates are very similar to that of MOO3, including the possible presence of shear planes (for a rich source of information on this, see, for example, several chapters in Ref. 20). Although activation, catalytic reaction and deactivation mechanisms have not been studied in as much detail as those concerning MOO3, analogies are apparent.
48 With respect to structural changes in molybdates, we examined Fe2(MoO4)3 in a previous Symposium of this series (1). Too deep of a reduction of the "active state of the catalyst" leads to deactivation by segregation to MoO3 and FeMoO4. In a catalyst maintained at a higher level of oxidation (in our case, by using spillover oxygen), selectivity is much better and segregation does not occur. In terms of the mesoscopic changes, the main cause of deactivation of the Fe2(MoO4)3 based catalysts for the oxidation of methanol to formaldehyde is the formation of fines which progressively plug the reactor (21,22), a phenomenon probably linked to a formation of pits similar to those occurring in MOO3. The conclusion concerning the close similarity of solid state reactions explaining the selective catalytic action of certain phases and at the same time their deactivation should not be viewed negatively. On the contrary, the very positive aspect is that this concept should serve to focus future research on the fundamental problem, namely protecting the loose, dynamic state, keeping it "wobbly". This can be accomplished through relatively minor measures, like creating some 80 epitaxy, adequate doping or the use of spillover species and probably other means. A laboratory 60 result justifies this point of view. We selected #, BiPO4 to produce spillover oxygen and compared the behaviour of pure Fe2(MoO4)3 ~o over a long run with that of a sample containing BiPO4 introduced by impregnation of 0,,-Fe2(MoO4)3 (Fig. 7). The stabilising effect by 20 80 this route on Fe2(MoO4)3 is not of long enough duration to produce a practical catalyst, but this example shows that ageing can be made less rapid. More generally, this strongly suggests g 65 J that lines of research based on the identity of "'o--.--r o,... solid-state processes in the various stages of catalyst life are relevant to the problem of catalyst deactivation. 0 " I I 0
20
z,O
60
80
Figure 7. Comparison of activity and selectivity 4 . A BRIEF L O O K AT O T H E R of FeE(MoO4)3 (8.1 meg-1) (O) with the same SIMILAR CASES catalyst impregnated with BiPO4 (19 wt.%) (O) in the oxidation of methanol to formaldehyde. BiPO4 alone is completely inactive (Fe2(MoO4)3 The above discussion, centered on MOO3, weight 350 mg in both cases; T = 280~ highlights the role of reduction in deactivation. CH3OH:O2:N2 = 4.90:2.38:92.72 (vol.); feed Other types of solid-state reactions may take rate 50 cm 3 mm-1), place in a catalyst under working conditions. An instructive case concerns mixtures of t~-Sb204 and Fe2(MoO4)3. A strong synergy between these phases is observed in the selective oxidation of isobutene to methacrolein (23,24). No detectable mutual contamination of the surface of the partners, nor solid state reaction occurs during the first few hours of contact with the reacting gases. But additional phases appear after a few days (FeSbO4 and MOO3) leading to new synergies with the remaining unreacted phases, namely Fe2(MoO4)3 and a-Sb204 (25,26). In these experiments, the formation of the 4-phase system
49 corresponds to an activation stage. Because nucleation of the new phases plays a crucial role in the kinetics of the solid state transformation, the overall surface area of the catalyst is increased. There is a possibility that a longer experiment would show further rearrangements and, possibly, a loss of surface area corresponding to deactivation. The 4-phase system clearly needs further investigation. Nevertheless, the example suggests at this stage that solid state reactions leading to new phases could play a role in the deactivation of selective oxidation catalysts and that the phenomenon could be narrowly related to the genesis of phases which interact synergetically with each other in catalysis. A recent example also highlights a deactivation which is clearly related to the formation of a new phase. This concerns the oxidative dehydrogenation of propane to propene. Mg2V207 reacts with the donor of spillover oxygen tx-Sb204 to make MgSb206 which has low activity (27). The transformations of vanadium phosphate ("VPO") catalysts active in the oxidation of butane of maleic anhydride can also trigger interesting speculations. Recently, the evolution of VPO phases over several hours of contact with reacting mixtures of butane and oxygen has been magnificently described (3). This is very important, in view of the fact mentioned in the introduction that the catalysts gain activity and selectivity during this period. It is a pity that adequate detailed studies of the deactivation period have not yet been published. This would permit a comparison. However, we would like to risk a speculation with respect to the phenomena and their consequences. The fact that a strong deactivation occurs, with a dramatic loss of selectivity, strongly suggests that the reactions initiated during the activation stage do continue. An optimum balance in the cooperation of the various phases probably occurs after some time on run, and further evolution is probably detrimental. A pertinent question can then be answered: why is the so-called "riser" technology in butane oxidation so attractive? In this technology, a discontinuous regime is established in which the vanadium phosphate catalyst is alternatively contacted with butane, which gets oxidised (while the catalyst gets reduced) and in this technology, a discontinuous regime is established in which the vanadium phosphate catalyst is alternatively contacted with butane, which gets oxidised (while the catalyst gets reduced) and with oxygen. The reoxidation step in this cycle could perhaps bring back the catalyst to a phase composition just slightly before the optimum (similar to that at the end of the activation stage). The other part of the cycle, namely the contact with butane, is probably terminated just after the optimum. This is just mere speculation, but a solid state chemist could find it reasonable. It has been repeatedly postulated that various phases in VPO catalysts are in epitaxy with each other. Direct experiments have failed to prove this postulate. But we can reason that the key to success for the "riser" technology is that nuclei of all the useful phases are kept during the reduction-oxidation cycle. The fact the X-ray diffraction indicates these phases in small quantities might have been mistaken for epitaxy. Very likely, these nuclei would be in close contact (if not really epitaxy) and enable a harmonious cyclic operation.
5.
CONCLUSIONS AND O U T L O O K
The speculative remarks we make here are aimed primarily at suggesting perspectives based on the theme of the present contribution, namely (i) that there is continuity in the solid state reactions taking place during activation, catalytic work and deactivation, and (ii) that we can take advantage of this continuity to achieve both more selective reactions and to limit the inconvenience of deactivation.
50 The line of reasoning we have outlined above can certainly be applied to other cases. Some work in progress suggests that the problem of loss of active material in selective ammoxidation catalysts (e.g. TeO2 in MoTe catalysts) can be approached similarly (28). This might also be the case of bismuth-promoted palladium catalysts for the selective oxidation of glucose to gluconic acid (29). Work carded out in other laboratories especially with heteropolyacid points in the same direction. This general approach can also be taken in the case of hydrotreating catalysts. Just to cite one example, the "life" of the MoS2 sulfide crystallites in hydrotreating certainly explains both activity and loss of surface area, this in turn leading to deactivation (30). In conclusion, we propose that solid-state reactions occurring at all stages of catalyst life should be placed in a comprehensive frame. There are many proofs that these solid state reactions are identical or similar. Funding of practical solutions to improved activation, better catalyst performance in terms of activity and selectivity and longer catalyst life can be justified more easily if the corresponding problem is put in the general perspective we propose.
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS
The author thanks Dr. P. Ruiz for his advice during the preparation of this manuscript.
REFERENCES
1. 2.
3. 4. 5. 6. 7. 8. 9. 10. 11. 12. 13. 14. 15. 16.
B. Delmon, P. Grange, in "Catalyst Deactivation" (B. Delmon, G.F. Froment, eds.) Elsevier, Amsterdam, 1980, 507-543. B. Delmon, P. Grange, in "Progress in Catalyst Deactivation" (J.L. Figueiredo, ed.) (NATO Advanced Study Institute Series, Series E, no. 54), Martinus Nijhoff, The Hague, 1982, pp. 231-280. C.J. Kiely, A. Burrows, S. Sajip, G.J. Hutchings, M.-T. Sananes, A. Tuel, J.C. Volta, J. Catal., 162 (1996) 31. J.C. Volta, Catal. Today, 32 (1996) 29. G.K. Boreskov, Kinet. Katal., 21 (1980), 15. F.J. Barry, D.J. Smith, J. Catal., 88 (1984), 107. B. Delmon, J. Mol. Cat., 59 (1990), 179. M.A. Van Hove, in "The Nature of the Surface Chemical Bonds" (T.N. Rodin, G. Ertl, eds.), North Holland, Amsterdam, 1979, pp. 277-311. G. Somorjai, M.A. Van Hove, Progr. Surf. Sci., 30 (1989), 201. B. Delmon, in "Catalyst Deactivation 1994" (B. Delmon, G.F. Froment, eds) Elsevier, Amsterdam, 1994, pp 113-128 P.L. Gai-Boyes, Catal. Rev. - Sci. Eng., 34 (1992) 1. E.M. Gaigneaux, P. Ruiz, B. Delmon, Catal. Today, 32 (1996) 37. T. Machej, M. Remy, P. Ruiz, B. Delmon, J. Chem. Soc. Faraday Trans., 1990, 86, 715722. T. Machej, M. Remy, P. Ruiz, B. Delmon, J. Chem. Soc. Faraday Trans., 1990, 86, 723730. T. Machej, P. Ruiz, B. Delmon, J. Chem. Soc. Faraday Trans., 1990, 86, 731-738. B. Delmon, Chimia, 51 (1997) 31.
51 17. E. Gaigneaux, E.E. Wolf, P. Ruiz, B. Delmon (6th Iketani Conf., Tokyo, Nov. 25-27, 1996), accepted, Appl. Suf. Sci. 18. "Molybdenum. An outline of its chemistry and uses" (E.R. Braithwaite, J. Haber, eds.), Elsevier, Amsterdam, 1994. 19. R. Castillo, K. Dewaele, P. Ruiz, B. Delmon, Appl. Catal. A, accepted. 20. Solid State Chemistry in Catalysis (R.K. Grasselli, J.F. Brazdil, eds.), ACS Symp. Series 279, Am. Chem. Soc., Washington, D.C., 1985. 21. N. Burriesci, F. Garbassi, N. Petrera, G. Petrini, N. Pernicone, in "Catalyst Deactivation" (B. Delmon, G.F. Froment, eds.), Elsevier, Amsterdam, 1980, pp. 115-126. 22. N. Pernicone, Catal. Today, 11 (1991) 85. 23. X.L. Xiong, L.T. Weng, B. Zhou, B. Yasse, E. Sham, L. Daza, F. Gil-Llambias, P. Ruiz, B. Delmon, in "Preparation of Catalysts V" (G. Poncelet, P. Grange, P.A. Jacobs, B. Delmon, eds.) Elsevier, Amsterdam, 1991, pp. 537-546. 24. Y.L. Xiong, R. Castillo, Ch. Papadopoulou, L. Daza, J. Ladriere, P. Ruiz, B. Delmon, in "Catalyst Deactivation 1991" (C.H. Bartholomew and J.B. Butt, eds.) Elsevier, Amsterdam, 1991, pp. 425-432. 25. L.E. Cadus, F.J. Gotor, D. Acosta, J. Naud, P. Ruiz, B. Delmon, Solid State lonics, 1993, 63-65, 743-747. 26. L.E. Cadus, Y.L. Xiong, F.J. Gotor, D. Acosta, J. Naud, P. Ruiz, B. Delmon, in "New Developments in Selective Oxidation Ir' (v. Cort6s CorberS.n, S. Vic Bell6n, eds) Elsevier, Amsterdam, 1994, pp 41-54 27. S.R.G. Carraz~in, C. Peres, M. Ruwet, P. Ruiz, B. Delmon, Proc. XIIth Int. Symp. Reactivity of Solids, Hamburg, Preprints, 5PO 304, submitted for publication. 28. S. Zeyss, P. Ruiz, B. Delmon, submitted. 29. M. Wenkin, R. Touillaux, P. Ruiz, B. Delmon, M. Devillers, Appl. Catal. A, 148 (1996) 181. 30. B. Delmon, Bull. Soc. Chim. Belg., 1995, 104, 173-187.
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
~ Elsevier Science B.V. All rights reserved Catalyst Deactivation 1997 C.H. Bartholomew and G.A. Fuentes, editors
53
C o k e F o r m a t i o n in Catalytic Processes: Kinetics and Catalyst D e a c t i v a t i o n G.F. FROMENT Laboratorium voor Petrochemische Techniek Universiteit Gent Krijgslaan 281 9000 Gent, Belgium.
1.
INTRODUCTION
In spite of its far reaching industrial implications catalyst deactivation by coke formation has been studied with insufficient depth and rigor. A better understanding of the interaction between the hydrocarbons and the catalytic sites leading to coke formation and a more detailed modeling of its rate might contribute to the development of catalysts generating less coke and/or less subject to deactivation. To reach this goal it has to be kept in mind that the study of coke formation and the associated catalyst deactivation is not different from the study of any catalytic process; coke is formed through one or more reactions, involving intermediates also acting in the "main" reactions. The influence of the coke on the reaction(s) causing catalyst deactivation is then naturally dealt with in terms of the real variables and the elementary steps. Presently this is still done in an empirical way by multiplying the rate of the main reaction(s) by a deactivation function which is often related to time, tO =fit)
(1)
where e.g. j'( t) = e -at
although it would be preferable to relate it to the true deactivating agent, coke itself : tp =f(Cc)
(2)
where e.g. f ( C c ) = e -ace
An exponential function of the coke content has been derived for a variety of processes [De Pauw & Froment, 1975; Dumez & Froment, 1976; Hatcher, 1985; Beirnaert et al, 1994]. The approach symbolized by (1) is easier since it does not require measuring the coke content of the catalyst, as (2) does. However, measurement of coke content is no longer a problem; adequate equipment has been developed that permits the simultaneous study of the main reaction(s) and coke
54 formation, namely an electrobalance with or without recycle of the products and the TEOM [Beirnaert et al, 1994; Chen et al, 1996]. The shortcomings of the approach symbolized by (1) have been extensively discussed [Froment, 1976]. Briefly, if coke is not measured, the deactivation of the coking reaction itself can not be accounted for, so that (1) is really a very biased equation. This approach cannot predict the coke profile in a reactor, although the knowledge of this profile in an industrial reactor is of key importance for the operation of the catalyst regeneration. When the coke content of the catalyst is measured a distinction can be made between the deactivation function for the main reaction, CpA,and that for the coking reaction Cpcdefined by : FA - " FA(DA
(3)
= rc%Pc
(4)
and rc
where rA~ and rc ~ are the initial rates, i.e. the rates at zero coke content. These are modeled in terms of the Hougen and Watson approach, accounting for the competitive adsorption of the reacting components and coke. Any progress in understanding the effects of coke on the rates of the reactions beyond the empirical level of the type of equation (2) requires more information on the structure of the coke and of the catalyst. In other words: is the effect of coke limited to the coverage of sites? Or can it grow to a size blocking the pores? What is the pore size distribution of the catalyst? Are the pores interconnected? The present paper aims at reviewing progress in the modeling of coke formation and catalyst deactivation along the lines set in Table 1, although it stresses to a large extent the kinetic formulation, an area in which considerable progress has been achieved. Table 1. Classification of phenomena occurrin~ in coke formation at various levels. Micro-level Phenomena 1) Uniform sites coverage (+ growth) 2) Clusters of uniform sites coverage (+ growth) 3) Sites of different nature coverage + migration Meso-level 1) Pores 2) Networks of pores
coverage + growth + pore blockage + diffusion in the structure
Macro-level Reactor
+ flow + mass & heat transfer
55
2. C O K E F O R M A T I O N ON T H E M I C R O - L E V E L : S I T E C O V E R A G E AND COKE GROWTH
2.1. Rate equations for simple, ideal cases For a simple reaction A ~ B occurring on single sites and with the reaction between adsorbed species as the rate determining step the classical Hougen & Watson approach leads to [Froment & Bischoff, 1990]:
Ct_Cc
l kACtKA( Ca - ~ )
ra =
=r
C,
(5)
1 + K AC A + KBC B
and for the rate of irreversible site coverage by coke formed out of A (parallel coking)
rcl = Ctr s =
kcCtKACA
C t --Ccl Ct
1 + K AC A -~- K s C e
=
rpr~
(6)
where KA is replaced by KB in the numerator of (6) and KACA in the denominator by KBCB when the coke precursor is formed out of B (consecutive coking). The coke precursor is defined as the first of the components in the coking sequence which is irreversibly adsorbed. The rate of coke formation is related to the rate of irreversible fractional site coverage, rs, through:
rc = e~CtMcr~ = dC~ dt
(7)
provided there is no multilayer growth of the coke. For a given gas phase concentration integration of (7) yields:
(8)
Cc = 6 C t M c ( 1 - e x p ( - r ~ revealing that ~ in the empirical relation (1) is not a constant. Also, q)A =rPc = e x p ( - r ~
C~
= 1 - ~
~Mc
(9)
For dual site reactions the relation between {p and Cc is non linear. Even with single site reactions a non linear relation would be obtained if there were a distribution in the strength of the sites. The deactivation functions {PAand {Pc would not be identical if a different number of sites were involved in the main and in the coking reaction.
56
2.2. Catalyst deactivation by site coverage simultaneous with coke growth The main reaction is affected only through the site coverage. For given PA, PB.... the following formula was derived by Beeckman & Froment [1979] for the deactivation function of the main reaction: ~Pa : e x p ( - r o t )
(10)
When the coke grows through some polymerization process at a rate rp which is independent of the degree of polymerization: (11)
r
+
r:
(1_ exp(_rOt) )
(12)
,Mr~
9A differs from 9c and is no longer a linear function of the coke content Cc. Whereas 9A is a measure of the coverage and always decreases, 9c may exceed one, depending upon the value of the ratio rp~ ~ Only when all the coke molecules have the same size can 9c be directly related to the site coverage.
2.3 Rate equations for complex industrial processes In steam reforming for synthesis gas production from natural gas on a Ni/alumina catalyst, coke is mainly formed by the cracking of hydrocarbons. For a methane feed the main reactions and the coking reactions can be represented by: CH4 + H20 ~ C H 4 + 21120 ~
CO + 3 H 2
(13)
C 0 2 + 4H2
CO + 1-120 ~ C02 + 112 CH 4 ~ C + 2H 2
(14)
Fig. 1 represents the reaction mechanism involved in H 2, CO and CO2-production derived by Xu and Froment [1989] and by Snoeck and Froment [1997] for coke formation. In the steam reforming sequence (2) - (9), leading to CO, the rate determining step is (8), in the sequence (2) - (7), leading to CO 2 it is step (7), in the water gas shift step (10). In the coking sequence (2) - (3) - (4) - (12) - (13) the rate determining step is the first H-abstraction, (3). By way of example the following rate equation for the formation of CO was obtained by Xu and Froment [ 1989]:
'k' Ken, "KH~o( rco
-
P~Pco )
H, K1 ( Pn~~ 2 p2n"~ 1+ KcoPco + Kn, pn' + Ken, Pen' + Kn~o Pn2 )
(15)
57
Through an analogous procedure Snoeck and Froment [ 1997] obtained the following equation for the coke production by methane cracking 9 kn re=
KCH4Pen,
- kzKcKn2 Cc~,.i "P2H2
(1+ ~cCc~,,. + KcCc~,.,. p~,'~ + ~c,, pc,, )
(16)
2
where CCNi,f is the coke content of a further evolution of C-1 in Fig. 1, to be defined below.
IH2OI
I CH4 ]
Ol+l
| +l _.,+ 1 H2-l ~
IL
2H+I
+ O-I
CH4-I
| CH3-I + H-l |
I
CH2-I + H-l o-,
|
O-I
H-I + CO2-I
r
|
|
CH-I +
H-I
CH20-I + l /
CHO-I + H-l
| CO-/+ H-l
O-I
QI"
(~)
CO2-1 + l
--O+l
+l
Figure 1. Reaction mechanism of the conversion of methane into H 2, CO, CO 2 and coke Clearly the rate equation for the cracking of methane, i.e. for the coke formation is not fundamentally different from that of one of the main reactions (12). What remains to be done is to link the coke content of the catalyst to the rate of the main reactions. Thereby a specific aspect of coke formation on Ni/alumina catalysts has to be accounted for, namely whisker formation. The rate equation (16) is not directly applicable because it contains the concentration of coke adsorbed on the Ni-surface, which is not accessible, just like Celia.l, CH_1.... The latter are eliminated through adsorption-isotherms in favor of the measurable gas phase partial pressures PCH4, Pn2, but this is not possible for coke. What is done in the derivation of (5) and (6), where the same problem is already encountered, is to manipulate the expressions so as to factor out the Ccl, thus yielding the
58 ratio ( C t - C c l ) / C t , defined as the deactivation function [Froment & Bischoff, 1990]. This cannot be done here because of an additional complication: carbon segregates on the side of the Ni-particle facing the gas, where its concentration is represented by CcNif, dissolves in the Ni, diffuses through it and precipitates at the rear of the particle, lifting it 'progressively from the alumina support, thus leading to a whisker carrying the Ni-parficle at its top. This was also accounted for by Snoeck and Froment [1997] who obtained an implicit rate equation for r c containing the diffusivity of carbon in Ni and the saturation concentration of carbon in Ni, assuming that the supersaturation is low. Therefore, at steady state there is no deactivation. The latter is only observed when the Ni is encapsulated by coke growing on coke, but the modeling of this aspect remains to be developed. Chemical processes encountered in petroleum refining are far more complex than steam reforming. The feedstocks are complex mixtures of hydrocarbons of various types each of which is converted along intricate pathways. So far these processes have been modeled in terms of lumps. In catalytic cracking the 3-lump and the 10-lump model [Nace et al, 1971; Jacob et al, 1976] are still widely used although the lumps are based on boiling ranges rather than on chemical nature. These models contain in general only one deactivation function of an empirical nature for the reactions of the various lumps. In their study of the catalytic cracking of n-hexane on a US-Y-zeolite in an electrobalance with recycle Beimaert et al, [1994] derived an empirical deactivation function of the type (2) for the various reactions, but with different o~-values, as illustrated in Table 2 for the isomerizations. Table 2 Estimated r
of the deactivation functions of some isomerizations in n-hexane cracking.
Product
r
95 % confidence interval
2-Me-pentane
1.65
1.44 < tz < 1.83
3-Me-pentane
1.76
1.51 < r < 2.02
2,3-di-Me-butane
1.81
1.57 < 0~ < 2.04
2,2-di-Me-butane
2.62
2.36 < tx < 2.89
Coke
0
Note that the coke formation itself is not deactivated. This is probably due to the growth of coke, which is not hampered yet in this zeolite with its relatively large pore size, unlike that observed on ZSM-48 [Froment et al, 1990]. Fig. 2 shows a reaction scheme for the cracking of n-hexane on a US-Y-zeolite, illustrating again how the main reactions and the coke formation are closely related and involve similar reactions [Froment, 1996]. The monomethylpentanes and also the dimethylbutanes are rigorously lumped, since the equilibrium between the components is rapidly established. The alkylation of nC 6 and its isomers leads to a lump C k which cracks or cyclicizes and dehydrogenates into aromatics and into coke, either directly or through alkylation of the aromatics. The network contains 5 reacting components involved in 14 reactions belonging to 6 types (4 for the main reactions, 2 for the coke formation) so that 6 rate coefficients have to be determined. If all the reactions occur on the same type of sites and involve the same number of sites all the rate equations have the same denominator and the number of adsorption equilibrium constants amounts to 14 (3 for the hexane isomers, 6 for the saturated C 3 to C 5 molecules and their corresponding olefins, 1 for the Ck-lump and 1 for the aromatics lump). When the deactivation is expressed in terms of an
59 exponential function with respect to the coke content, 6 additional parameters are introduced, one for each type of reaction, excluding the coke formation which is not deactivated. H2,
Cl,
C2, C3
M e - C~
C~ + C3
C~
diMe - C7
(6)
(3)
(I)
n - Ca
(8)
(7) (2)
M e -C s
diMe - C(
(9)
(10)
Ck
(13)
(12)
(11) C7 +
Ck.~
(14)
coke
Aromatics
Figure 2. Molecular reaction scheme for the catalytic cracking of n-hexane. c~
C~ + H 2, C I, C2, C3
(4)
Me- C;
MeCs + C~.
C; + C;
(6) 1
(7)
1(8)
(2)
Me-C;
(3)
diMe- C~
diMe - C4 + C~ (IO)
(9) 1
(5)
n-C6T~ C, +n-C~
(11)
(14)[
(12)
diMe-C:
(13)
c~ (15)I
(c;), + (c;). (= coke) (16)]
[ (17)
Aromatics
Figure 3. Reaction network in terms of elementary steps of carbenium-ion chemistry for the catalytic cracking of n-hexane. Clearly, applying this "molecular" approach to the cracking of a complex mixture like vacuum gas oil is an impossible task: the number of parameters would be overwhelming. Indeed, even in a homologous series of n-paraffins each molecule reacts at a different rate; the rate coefficient for the disappearance of the molecule increases with chain length.
60 The only way out is to express the transformation of the molecules in terms of the elementary steps of carbenium-ion chemistry: protonation, H- and Me-shifts, protonated cyclo-propane-type isomerization, 13-scission ... [Froment, 1996]. In Fig. 3 the cracking of n-hexane is represented in terms of the single event approach introduced by Froment and co-workers [Baltanas et al 1989; Vynckier and Froment, 1991; Froment, 1991; Svoboda et al, 1995]. Excluding CH3 + and primary carbenium ions which are far less stable than secondary and tertiary carbenium ions, leads to 17 rate coefficients for paraffin cracking in general and 26 adsorption equilibrium constants, therefore a total of 43 parameters, which is more than the 26 parameters in the molecular model. The superiority of the single event approach becomes evident when mixtures have to be dealt with. The rate coefficients of the elementary steps of the carbenium ions may be assumed to be independent of the chain length, so that the number of parameters does not increase for complex mixtures, unlike what happens with the molecular approach. Analogous assumptions are made within the naphthenes- and aromatics-families so that the total number of parameters entering in the kinetic modeling of the cracking of a vacuum gas oil and the associated coke formation is of the order of 40 to 50. It should be added here that these huge reaction networks have to be generated by computer [Baltanas & Froment, 1985]. Booleans relation matrices were used to describe the molecules and carbenium ions. Since a component analysis of a vacuum gas oil is not entirely feasible some lumping is inevitable but the rate coefficients for the reactions between the lumps can be constructed from those of the single events entering in the reactions of the components of the lump [Vynckier & Froment, 1991 ]. 2.4. Clusters of uniform sites For multi-site reactions a site is only active when it is surrounded by the required number of vacant sites. The probability of such a configuration decreases as more sites become irreversibly covered. Also, certain reaction steps are only possible when the sites are covered by a specific set of molecules. These aspects are not accounted for in the phenomenological approach introduced in Section 2.1. Beeckman et al. [ 1987], pursuing work by Nam and Froment [ 1987], developed an approach accounting explicitly for the topology of a cluster of sites occupied by reacting species. Using probability calculus they derived expressions for % and qu in terms of the degree of coverage, co. When the coking reaction and the main reaction involve more than one site the deactivation function develops a dependence on the number of sites in the cluster. Both reactions now become structure sensitive. When the number of sites required by the coking reaction is higher than that of the main reaction a high metal dispersion- a small cluster size - decreases the selectivity for coke formation. Such a trend is well known in metal supported catalysis. The selectivities of the various main reactions can also be influenced as illustrated by Fig. 4. The topological model provides guidelines for optimizing the cluster size so as to achieve maximum selectivity for the main reaction and a maximum resistance to coke formation. 2.5. Sites of different nature: Dual function catalysts The catalytic reforming of naphtha and the hydrocracking of heavy oil fractions are based on dual-function catalysts. These contain a metal component (Pt, Pt~e, Pt/Sn in reforming, Pt, Pd, Ni/Mo in hydrocracking) and an acidic component, (alumina in reforming, alumina or zeolite Y in hydrocracking). (De)hydrogenation occurs on the metal component, isomerizations and cracking on the acid component. In dual-function catalysis species formed on one type of site have to move to the other before the next step of the reaction sequence can take place. Evidently, proximity of both types of sites is required, although it has been shown that even a physical mixture of the two catalyst components can achieve the desired result. As sites are being covered by coke produced by side reactions the rate of the reactions decreases, but since the distance between sites remaining active increases, an additional effect has to be accounted for. Singh and Froment [1997] recently developed a probabilistic model for the deactivation of a dual function catalyst by coke formation accounting for reaction and surface migration. The reaction sequence was the isomerization of n-
61
into i-pentane on Pt/alumina, studied in an isothermal tubular reactor by De Pauw and Froment [1975] and represented schematically in Fig. 5 in which ~ stands for Pt-sites, x for acid alumina sites and coke is formed on x-sites only. All the reactions are assumed to occur on single sites. 1.0
0.8
0.6
% (dual) (single) 0.,
q)A
0.2
N=2
;
oj2
.~=3 ,..,
0:,
o.~
N..4
~=5
o.B
(.O Figure 4. Evolution of the ratio of rates of the main reactions on dual and single sites with degree of surface coverage by coke. i-C5
n-C5
n-Cs.o"
-- n-C~.o" i i
,_
n-Cs.'r i ,
T
C
- i-C~.'r i !
T
,
i-C~.a
-'- i-Cs" o"
i i
C
Figure 5. Schematic representation of a process consisting of various adsorptions, desorptions, reactions and migrations. A square grid of x and o-sites was selected with only one site on each node of the grid. The migrating species randomly chooses its direction upon encountering a site which is covered already by a reacting component or by coke. Each migration step is limited to the adjacent site only. The expected distance for the migration of n-C5-- can be written:
L1
=(1-Ps''/dPs,,)
(17)
62 where d(A) is the length of a segment and Pf~s is the conditional probability that a site encountered by n-C: is a free x-site. A similar formula is derived for L2, the distance of migration of i-C5 =, with replacing:. The conditional probability Pewscan be written 9
p., , =
P//,~P~ + Po/oPo + P//,P, + Po/,P~ + Pd/,P,
(18)
where Pf/,, Po/~ are the probabilities that a ~-site is free or occupied and Pf/~, Po/~, Pd/~ are the probabilities that a x-site is free, occupied by the reacting species or by coke and, therefore, deactivated. The probability that a site randomly located on the catalyst surface is a x-site e.g. is given by: where Ct is the total concentration of both ~- and x-sites and C,, is the total concentration of x-sites. The probability that this x-site is free is given by: p, = C,~
(19)
ct P:/, = ~
(20)
and the probability that it is occupied by the reaction species:
Po,,
Cc~" + C/c~ -
-
(21)
The probability of a x-site being deactivated by site coverage is calculated from [Beeckman & Froment, 1979]"
Pd/, = [1-- exp(--r~
(22)
Assuming coke formation from i-Cs--only, the parameters were estimated from the data of De Pauw and Froment [ 1975]. Fig. 6 shows the evolution with the coke content of the migration distances in a point of the reactor where the partial pressure of n-pentane has decreased from its inlet value of 0.757 atm to a value of 0.675. Initially, i.e. at zero coke content L~ and L 2 amount to 3.31 and 2.47 ]k respectively. The migration distances vary with the coke content as a consequence of two opposing effects: the coverage of x-sites by coke formed from i-C5-- that increases L l and L 2 and the deactivating effect of coke on the reaction n-C:x ---) i-C:x that decreases the coverage of x-sites by i-Cs--, thus reducing L 1 and L 2. The magnitude of the variations of L 1 and L 2 depends on the local concentrations of n-C 5 and i-C 5 in the reactor. 3. COKE F O R M A T I O N ON THE MESO-LEVEL The case of site coverage and coke growth was already discussed in Section 2.2. Coke can grow to a size sufficient to block even mesopores [Levinter, 1967]. Since there is no preferential location for the coverage of a site and the subsequent blockage of the pore Beeckman & Froment [ 1979] used a probabilistic approach. The deactivation function is nothing but the probability that a
63 site is still active, q) equals the product of the conditional probability S that the site is not covered with P, the probability that it is accessible: = PS
(23)
,,~
I- I
%
.,,,~
~
2,
o
o.ooG$ o.r
o.ooIs
o.o(3:1 o.co2s
o.o~3 0.0035 o.oG4
coke content (gcoke/g,,) Figure 6. Evolution of migration distances L~ and L 2 with coke content on a dual function catalyst.
When the growth of the coke is instantaneous, which is the case when in (12) rp~ > 8CtMRs ~ in other words when the rate determining step in the coking sequence is the production of the coke precursor, all the coke has the same size, determined by the pore diameter. Blockage of the pore causes coke profiles even when there are no concentration gradients of the reacting species. Also, q)A : ( P C "
In the more general case when the potential rate of polymerization is of the same order of magnitude as the potential rate of site coverage, two periods have to be distinguished: a first ranging from t = o to t = tb, the time required to reach a size sufficient to block the pore and during which only site coverage and cokes growth occur and a second, starting at t = t b, during which blockage occurs and the deactivation also depends upon the site density, as shown in Fig. 7. It is very questionable if a single pore is sufficiently representative for a catalyst particle in which the pores are interconnected. Beeckman and Froment [1979] modeled a particle of an amorphous catalyst in terms of a Bethe tree, which is a branching structure without closed loops. The type of tree they considered has a coordination number of three, while the pores are characterized by two stochastic variables: their length and their diameter. The probability P in (23) now becomes a much more complex function. The model was applied to a meso-macro porous structure representative of a chromia-alumina catalyst used in butene dehydrogenation and for single site coking and instantaneous growth of coke. CpAthen equals (Pc but their value drops to zero long before all the sites are covered with coke, because of pore blockage. The approach was applied to the butene dehydrogenation data of Dumez and Froment [1976] by Matin et al [1986]. Beeckman and Froment [ 1982] also extended the approach to account for diffusional limitations. For consecutive coking a saddle-like coke profile through the particle was predicted.
64
,oo\
1.00
~
parameter
: o" L - 0.80
- 0.60
0.40
0.20
0.00 -
0.00
i
i
0.16
i
i
i
i
032 0.48 x I0=
i
1
0.64
!
tO.O0
0.80
cc Figure 7. Averaged deactivation function for the main reaction as a function of averaged coke content for several site densities ~ in a single ended pore with length L. A Bethe-tree is a particular case of more general networks considered in percolation theory. Sahimi and Tsotsis [ 1985] applied percolation theory and Monte Carlo simulation to deactivation in zeolites, approximated by a simple cubic lattice. Beyne and Froment [1990, 1993] applied percolation theory to reaction, diffusion and deactivation in the real ZSM-5 lattice. The finite rate of growth was described in terms of a polymerization mechanism. Pore blockage was reached in this small pore zeolite. It also affects the path followed by the diffusing molecules that becomes more tortuous, so that the effective diffusivity has to be expressed in terms of the blockage probability.
0.75
~
.
i
~.
0.5 0.25
00
........
0.02
'
'
' 0.04i
,
,
. 0.06
A
Cc (kg coke/kg cat) Figure 8. Variation of (q)A)d and (tpc)d with the coke content for consecutive coking in a ZSM-5 particle. Fig. 8 illustrates the variation of (q)A)d and ((pc)d with the coke content for consecutive coking. The index d indicates that, besides deactivation, diffusional limitations also affect the rate of transformation of A. The steep drop in activity corresponds to a coke content at which the
65
percolation threshold has been reached. Curves of this shape have been reported in the literature [Dejaifve et al, 1981]. Recently Gottifredi and Froment [ 1997] dealt with reaction, diffusion and coke formation in a catalyst particle, mainly focusing on the derivation and application of approximate but accurate formulae for the calculation of transport fluxes and deactivation functions. In the case of parallel coking and an exponential deactivation function the time behavior profile of the rate of the main reaction can be represented as in Fig. 9. Whereas for short times the highest rate is observed at the surface, with increasing reduced time, x, an internal maximum develops, the location of which shifts towards the center of the particle. Indeed, for parallel coking the coke content is always highest at the surface, since the diffusion limitation leads to a concentration profile of A which decreases towards the center of the particle. The deactivating effect of the coke is strongest at the surface. Inside the particle the coke content is lower and the rate is less affected so that a maximum in rA~ develops. The figure is similar to that derived by Froment and Bischoff (1961) for deactivation by coke formation in a tubular reactor without diffusional limitations inside the catalyst particles, however.
rA~
h2o- 1O0
Figure 9. Time behavior of the profile of the effective rate of the main reaction inside a catalyst particle for parallel coking. 4. THE MACRO-LEVEL:
DEACTIVATION IN A REACTOR
Beyne and Froment [ 1993] simulated a tubular reactor with plug flow and diffusional limitations inside the catalyst for the process discussed already in Section 3. The main reaction is of the type A ~ B and coke is formed through a polymerization mechanism from a site covered by coke
66 precursor onwards. Transport, site coverage and blockage in the ZSM-5 catalyst is dealt with through percolation theory and effective medium approximation. Fig. 10 shows how for parallel coking the prof'lle of the effective rate of reaction of A through the reactor evolves with time. Initially the highest effective rate (the rate in the presence of diffusional limitations) is located at the inlet, but as time evolves a maximum develops that moves downstream through the reactor. For parallel coking the coke content of the catalyst is always highest at the inlet of the reactor and that is where the rate of disappearance of A is more affected, leaving a larger fraction of A to be converted in downstream zones as the run length increases. Such a wave does not develop with consecutive coking. As shown in Fig. 11 in such a case and pure A feed the coke content increases through the reactor, thus enhancing the importance of the upstream zone. With increasing time a smaller fraction of the reactor is participating in the reaction. Such a behavior was predicted by Froment and Bischoff [ 1961], but without including diffusional limitations inside the catalyst particle.
0.75
..............
r* A,, e l f '0.5 r A,, o f f
1:=0 z=0
0.25
0
0
0.4
0.8
1.2
z(m)
i.6
Z
Figure 10. Evolution with time of the effective rate profile of the main reaction in a plug flow reactor. Parallel coking. Diffusion-limited process on a ZSM-5 type catalyst. 5. C O N C L U S I O N S Studies of catalyst deactivation by coke formation should be conducted along the lines followed in the study of the main reactions of the process. By doing so advantage can be taken from the analogy between steps pertaining to both the main- and coking reaction pathways. The insight gained by such an approach will also permit one to distinguish between the deactivating effect of coke on various types of reaction and to model the evolution of the selectivity in terms of the increasing coke content. Catalyst deactivation has such an impact on the design and operation of plants that studies along the approach outlined here are fully justified. They should be an integrated part of the process development.
67
\
:
t (iO
si)
i
t
:
!
i
i
i
i
0.75
i
i
i
9
1
1
i
i
!
i ......................
i ...........................
!
r
A,
A, e l f
elf
I
0.5
1
:.
I t=0
I Z=0 0.25 ....................
.........................
| ,
.
,
i
l
o.s
: i
,
.
,
I
t
: ,
i
.
,
i
t.$
i
i
|
t
2
zfa~ Figure 11. Evolution with time of the effective rate prof'de of the main reaction in a plug flow reactor. Consecutive coking. Diffusion limited process on a ZSM-5 type catalyst.
REFERENCES Baltanas M.A., K.K. Van Raemdonck, G.F. Froment and S. Mohedas, L & E.C. Res. 28, 899910, 1989. Baltanas M.A. and G.F. Froment, Comp. Chem. Engng. 9, No. 1, 71, 1985. Beeckman J.W. and G.F. Froment, L & E.C. Fund. 18, 245-256, 1979. Beeckman J.W. and G.F. Froment, Chem. Eng. Sci. 35, 805, 1980. Beeckman J.W. and G.F. Froment, L & E.C. Fund. 21,243-250, 1982. Beeckman J.W., In Sik Nam and G.F. Froment, Catalyst Deactivation. B. Delmon & G.F. Froment (Eds), Elsevier Sci., Amsterdam, 1987. Beirnaert H.C., R. Vermeulen and G.F. Froment, Proc. 6th Int. Congress on Cat. Deact. 1994. Eds. B. Delmon & G.F. Froment. Studies in Surf. Sci. and Catalysis, 88, 97-112, Elsevier Sci., 1994. Beyne A.O. and G.F. Froment, Chem. Eng. Sci., 45, 2089-2096, 1990. Beyne A.O. and G.F. Froment, Chem. Eng. Sci., 48, 550, 1993. Chen D., A. Gronwald, H.P. Rebo, K. Moljard and A. Holmen, Appl. Catal. A, 137, 11-18, 1996. Dejaifve P., A. Auroux, P.C. Gravelle, J.C. Vedrine, Z. Gabelica and E. Derouane, J. Catal. 70, 123, 1981. De Pauw R.P. and G.F. Froment, Chem. Eng. Sci., 80, 789, 1975. Dumez F. and G.F. Froment, L & E.C. Proc. Des. & Devpt. 15, 291, 1976. Froment G.F., Proc. 6th Int. Congr. Cat. 1, 10-31, Chem. Soc. London, 1976. Froment G.F., Rev. Inst. Fran~ais du P~trole, 46, 491, 1991. Froment G.F., Chemreactor-13, June 1996, Novosibirsk. Froment G.F. and K.B. Bischoff, Chemical Reactor Analysis and Design, 2nd Ed., 1990, J. Wiley, N.Y. Froment G.F. and K.B. Bischoff, Chem. Eng. Sci., 16, 189, 1961. Froment G.F., J. De Meyer and E.G. Derouane, J. of Catal., 124, 391, 1990. Gottifredi J.C. and G.F. Froment, Chem. Eng. Sci., 1997.
68 Hatcher W.J., Ind. Eng. Chem. Prod. Res. & Devpt., 24, 10-15, 1985. Jacob S.M., B.E. Gross, F.E. Voltz and V.W. Weeckman, A.LCh.E.J., 22, 701-713, 1976. Levinter M.E., G.M. Panchenkov and M.A. Tanatarow, Int. Chem. Eng. 1, 23, 1967. Marin G.B., J.W. Beeckman and G.F. Froment, J. of Catal., 97, 416, 1986. Nam I.S. and G.F. Froment, J. of Catal., 108, 271-282, 1987. Reyes S.C. and L.E. Scriven, I & E.C. Res., 30, 71,1991. Sahimi M. and T.I. Tsotsis, J. Catal., 96, 552, 1985. Singh S. and G.F. Froment, Kinetics of Her. React. & Dynamics of Surfaces, Eds. G.F. Froment & K.C. Waugh, Elsevier, 1997. Snoeck J.W. and G.F. Froment, J. Catal., 1997. Svoboda G.D., E. Vynckier, B. Debrabandere and G.F. Froment, L & E.C. Res., 34, 22, 25282530, 1995. Vynckier E. and G.F. Froment, Kinetics & Thermodynamic Lumping, Eds. G. Astarita & S.I. Sandier, Elseviers, Amsterdam, 1991. Xu J. and G.F. Froment, A.L Ch.E.J., 35, 88, 1989. NOTATION concentration of reacting species, kmol/mag coke content of catalyst, kg coke/kg cat total concentration of active sites, kmol/kg cat.h rate coefficient, kmol/kg cat.h adsorption equilibrium constant, m3g/kmol or bar~ migration distances,/~ molecular weight of coke, kg/kmol partial pressure of component i, bar probability that a site is accessible rate of reaction of A, kmol/kg cat.h rate of coke formation, kg coke/kg cat.h rate of growth of coke, kg coke/kg cat.h fractional rate of site coverage, h-1 probability that an accessible reaction site is active time, h
C A, C B
Cc Ct k K A ' "'" L I , L 2 , ..
Mc Pi P rA rC rp rs
S t GREEK
LETTERS
(%)d'(%)d G CO
deactivation constant conversion factor, kmol coke/kmol sites deactivation function for main and coking reaction deactivation functions in the presence of diffusional limitations (de)hydrogenation sites in dual function catalyst isomerization sites in dual function catalyst degree of surface coverage
9
Elsevier Science B.V. All rights reserved
Catalyst Deactivation 1997 C.H. Bartholomew and G.A. Fuentes, editors
69
Catalyst Deactivation: How We Cannot Yet Subvert Nature John B. Butt Department of Chemical Engineering, Northwestem University, Evanston, IL 60208 USA This paper in many ways presents the author's 35 year encounter with catalyst deactivation in various forms and disguises. It is a combination of personal experience with historical development and scientific progression. Overall developments are surveyed, and in a way how they impacted one worker in the field. Old results are reported in an historical context, but some new ones are also given. There are some lessons: 1) It is impossible to understand catalyst deactivation without knowing the chemistry of the reactions and the catalysts involved. 2) It is impossible to understand catalyst deactivation without knowing something about the interactions of reaction and mass transport kinetics. 3) It is impossible to understand catalyst deactivation without knowing something about chemical reaction and chemical reactor dynamics. Number 3) above renders us into the uncomfortable realm of unsteady-state phenomena - we must realize that this is quite long-term as well as short-lived. "Even with Chee-Chee's help as a translator, I couldn't keep track o f it all."
1. INTRODUCTION "A long, long time ago, in a Galaxy far, far away ..." starts off George Lucas' classic STAR WARS trilogy. Sometimes I feel the same way about what we are here to discuss. In some ways, through the years of experience, I think that this whole business of catalysis, and of catalyst deactivation, reflects something of a " ... long, long time ago ... ". Yet, by our very presence, it is not; the arenas of inquiry are solid and growing, so I will claim that we are very much in the present. In fact, detailed studies of catalysis, and especially of catalyst deactivation, belong pretty much to the 20th Century. How much will this extend to the 21st? Thus far it is true that " ... he who ignores history has to learn it all over again...". In this sense, please allow some personal recollections. I did my PhD Dissertation on the use of alumina as a catalyst (don't laugh; this was 1956), particularly as applied to the dehydration and dehydrogenation of alcohols. Since methanol was uncooperative, and propanol too complicated (pre any good chromatography), I settled upon man's most beloved compound - ethanol. The first thing I found out, after two years of struggle in building a recycle reactor (maybe a predecessor of a modem CSTR), was that the alumina at about 300 ~ or so was super at removing water from ethanol, giving lots of ethylene and small other bits of strange things. I also found out, though, that the alumina became fired after a while and the ethylene yields decreased substantially. What was this? I mean, this is a chemical reaction and chemical reactions do what chemical reactions are supposed to do! Maybe it was obvious that something else than ethanol, water and ethylene was involved, but I guess I was blind to anything else at the time. Let us revisit 1956. Wheeler had published his great paper on deactivation and diffusion in 1955 far too soon for it to penetrate into the dusky laboratories of Yale University. Professor Herman
70 Pines had done much work on properties of alumina and modifications thereof as catalysts - but that was chemistry, not chemical engineering. In justification, if for no other reason, I would like to ask how many chemical engineers in 1956 read the JOURNAL OF THE AMERICAN CHEMICAL SOCIETY? Zero might be close. The first thing I had to learn was " ... what is a Lewis Acid ... "? That meant I had to read some chemistry - really serious stuff. Then I found out that the term "alumina" does not define a specific, unalterable substance. To say "alumina" is like saying "people". At that time Professor Pines was perhaps 60+ years and I was 20+; he was in Evanston and I in New Haven; however the measure of the man is that he was kind enough to spend much time in correspondence to explain to me all those papers in JACS and to tell me what a Lewis Acid is - and maybe even a Lewis Base. I did learn, though, that what the "alumina" did to the ethanol depended upon the "alumina". As Professor Burwell told me much later, and which I think I understand only now, " ... these are not compounds, they are materials ... ". Any catalyst, defined as you like in chemical terms, is a MATERIAL, not a well-defined chemical substance. It is therefore subject to any number of events, physical or chemical, that can alter its behavior. My old work with ethanol employed a commercial alumina, HARSHAW A1-0104 | and I had no idea as to the exact chemical composition. When I started making my own alumina, things became clearer because I could observe, at the least, different appearing materials resulting from variations in preparation - thus, maybe not all the same stuff!.. (This is not to denigrate HARSHAW; their alumina was a respected and widely used material, but it was a MATERIAL). Where does all this little bit of history lead us? It is certainly not just to say that some materials called "alumina" can catalyze the dehydration of ethanol to produce ethylene. It is to say that product distributions with the various alumina preparations were different, and changed in different ways as the time of operation increased. In the long run the lesson learned from this work was to recognize, however imperfectly that catalysts are materials, they undergo solid state transformations, they are subject to chemical attack from feed stream impurities, they suffer thermal stress, maybe they are susceptible to cancer- at any event, most of them eventually die. It's like a medical history: why and how?
2. SOME BACKGROUND I think, personally, that it is impossible to understand catalyst deactivation in its many forms and disguises without knowing first off about diffusion and reaction in catalyst particles, and knowing about chemical reactor analysis. The Laws of Nature make all diffusion-controlled reactions want to look like first-order, however complicated their real kinetics might be. As a good catalyst designer one likes to utilize all the interior surface of the material; this strategy may end up with operation close to diffusion control, but not always. From this we have many lessons; for example in the areas of reforming and hydrotreating catalysis. It is, though, in this proximity to optimization of the use of materials where we seem to become perplexed when deactivation inevitably occurs. One of the worst maxims, repeated in almost every introductory physical chemistry text is that" ... a catalyst is a substance that can promote the rate of a chemical reaction without itself being changed ...". That is like saying that L. Borgia is now a Saint. Catalysts do chemistry, for sure, but they HAVE chemistry as well. But, like Lucretia, they are fairly complicated. Maybe the best way to start here is with a good empirical observation of VOORHIES [ 1], who noted that in the deactivation of various catalysts used for petroleum processing the activity history was well tracked by an expression of the form: (Activity) = A ( t f = a
(1)
71 By now this basic formulation has had many interpretations. For example: (Activity) has been used to refer to coke-on-catalyst, amine index of the material, reference to conversion in some specific chemical test; who knows what else. The value of n, reported in various studies as ranging from 0 to 12, has been represented to indicate diffusion control (0.5) up to essentially " ... we don't know what is going on here ...(12) ... ". The factor A is a proportionality constant specific to catalyst, operating conditions and chemical reaction. Voorhies' model, based on time-on-stream observations, is obviously not general, but it is a good place to start.
3. O N E W A Y TO L O O K AT IT A reasonable and useful definition of activity is: Activity = (Rate of reaction of Main Reactant)/(Rate at t = 0) = a
(2)
which fits in with the Voorhies relationship. If one is allowed this latitude, then it is possible to try exploring a complex set of kinetics, such as the hydrogenation of benzene on Ni or Pt. This reaction generally is known to be described by the rate equation: (3)
(Rate)B7 = (kPHPBz)/(1 + KBzPBz) at low hydrogen partial pressures. If we take a literal interpretation of eqn. 2, then one can write:
(4)
(Rate)Bz = (a)(kPuPBz)/(1 + KBzPBz)
Then, all that is necessary is to take care of a. That tums out not easy to do because, like Lucretia, a is a product of chemistry. We probably can guess, knowing about catalysts, that a starts at unity, and eventually goes to zero. How it does so, and at what rate, all depends on the chemistry of the reaction, the chemistry of a, and the reaction conditions. There are few general rules.
4. S O M E IDEAS A B O U T "a"
Many ideas come to mind when one tries to think about this elusive variable. Professor Petersen and I wrote a book about it, and we thought we really had an idea. Unfortunately, the older I get, the more fleeting the idea seems. However, I do think that we can pin down the elusive a in some cases. One case is deactivation by poisoning. This is because the catalyst is subject to a specific chemical deactivation; thus for the classical academic reaction A --+ B we have a parallel scheme such as A+S-+B+S
(Main Reaction, k)
P + S--+P.S
(Deactivation Reaction, kd)
where P is a poison, S some active catalytic site, and P.S the poisoned (deactivated) site. Following simple kinetics in each case and utilizing the definition of a in eqn. (2) we have rA = -kCgCs - -k_CAa
(Main)
72 r,~r
=
(Deactivation)
-k,CpC~ -kdCra =
or, for the deactivation (da/dt) = -kuC~
(5)
where it is assumed that the rates of both the main and deactivation reactions are dependent upon a. We are not limited to first order kinetics so that more generally it is possible to have a deactivation rate equation of the form (da/dt)
=
-lq(Cp)m(a)w
(6)
with m and w the orders with respect to poison and current activity, respectively. For example, sulfur poisons platinum and nickel pretty much in accord with the kinetics of eqn (5). In cases of deactivation by coke formation we may also have a parallel mechanism in which A is the coke precursor (these are limiting cases, of course). Correspoonding deactivation rate equations follow from development similar to that for eqns (5) and (6). Let us now retreat into another classical result, that of Bohart and Adams [2], that sort of indirectly addresses the parallel poisoning mechanism above. They really did not have catalyst poisoning in mind, rather adsorption in fixed beds, but the situation is analogous in many respects. With parallel poisoning (or coke formation) there can develop activity waves - interior regions of active and inactive catalyst that pass through the bed - and the entire process is unsteady state. Such waves are shown in Figure 1; however the observer standing at the bed exit measuring conversion vs. time of reactor operation
1.0
(a)
1.0
t---~
(b)
Deactivated
_
T
Q.
J~~eakthrough
o" 0 . 5
Quasi - Steady-State
Position
Time
Figure 1. (a) Bohart-Adams poisoning wave profiles, and (b) Conversion-time behavior for a sharp profile. would not know that there was a wave going through the bed until it reached the end, and then might be very confused. A very simple and elegant example of this has been provided some years ago by Froment and Bischoff[3]. Here we take a reaction, parallel in deactivation, and examine the evolution of activity within the bed. One sees in Figure 2 the evolution of an activity maximum that develops and passes through the bed, and a puzzling maximum conversion that comes and goes with time-on-stream Now this does not correspond exactly with the Bohart-Adams analysis, but in reality it is not all that different. In fixed-bed catalyst deactivation, there are waves of all kinds.
73
Length
Time
Figure 2. Rate surface for a parallel deactivation model. Now Bohart and Adams and Froment and Bischoff were concemed mostly with isothermal conditions in their studies. What if we have an exothermic reaction? In that case there will be thermal waves as well as concentration waves. Here there can be a sharp reaction front, riding the concentration wave as it were, giving a very pronounced thermal wave, almost like a spike, passing through the bed. An example of this, taken from our studies with benzene hydrogenation on supported Ni (Weng, Eigenberger and Butt [4]) is shown in Figure 3.
!
--e--140
P --- I 0 0 1-
!
!
!
!
G3
180 -
.
(o)
meosured
--e--
colculoted
i40
- ' ~ -
~
|t
w
2
!
w
(b).
meosurld colculoted 1
-
~
N
=--- I O 0
1-
60
-
60 --
20
G3
;--
I
I
inert
I
-~:
..
I
active
-.. i
~;:
4t
-
20
5 !
inert-~t
I
1
inert
:I~
I
octive
!
N: i n e r t - - ~
Figure 3. Profile simulation for hydrogenation of benzene in a nonisothermal fixed-bed. It should be remembered that these thermal waves can be large enough to cause catalyst sintering, thus activating another mechanism of deactivation. Did the observer at the end of the bed see any evidence of deactivation? Of course not, because the active reaction zone was actually confined to a small part of the bed, conversion is very good there, and until the thermal wave passes out of the end of the reactor, there is no evidence as to what is going on. Then immediately conversion goes to zero and the unprepared observer may find it necessary to seek some other sort of employment.
74 5. THE ROLE OF DIFFUSION There was a brief mention earlier about the role of diffusion in all this, and indeed it is very important. Mass transport can well limit the rate of main reaction-transformations, but it can also limit the rate of deactivation, particularly in parallel mechanisms of both poisoning and coking reactions. Diffusion/reaction has been a favorite topic for a long time, but many forget one simple thing: mass transfer is FIRST ORDER. Complicated reactions that are first order are often diffusion obscured. Poisoning or parallel coking reactions, however, are often first order. One can bring forward many more complicated schemes, particularly with coking reactions, but we do not try to do that now. How does diffusion influence the course of deactivation? This is fairly simply stated in the literature, but it depends upon the mechanism of deactivation and the extent of diffusional resistance. If we have a strong poison, one that is very rapidly taken up on the catalyst surface, pore diffusion often controls the overall rate and there is "pore mouth poisoning". If there is one not so strongly controlled by diffusion, then we have "uniform poisoning". If there is a substance that penetrates completely to the mid of the catalyst particle, then we have "core poisoning". All of these are very different, as shown in Figure 4. "Uniform Poisoning" is probably the best example. Let us assume that we
Pore Mouth
I
I
Pore Center
Pore Mouth
Figure 4. Distributions of foulant in the catalyst pore. have already a diffusion-controlled reaction (or near one, for a good catalyst designer); then Effectiveness Factor = rl = tanh r
(7)
But, this is not enough, since the reaction is subject to poisoning. We assume that the reaction is of a case where the intrinsic activity is related to fraction unpoisoned, thus: a=f
(8)
and that value should be used for the first-order rate constant of the unpoisoned rate constant.
75
Thus, for the poisoned case we obtain (9)* We can now get the activity as a function of fraction poisoned as before,
a
=
(O'~(tanh(r
r
(10)
Eqn (10) is obtained by taking kf as the rate constant for the poisoned catalyst. This is an important result, and is shown in Figure 5 for a range of parameters. One sees the linear variation of a with f for uniform poisoning at low ~, and significant variations from linearity for larger ~. Note that in the latter case a is higher at a given value of f
. o ~ r------t
i
" .~
r-------T
T
0.6
0.4
0.2 O
0
0.2
0.4
0.6
"0.8
1.0
Fraction Poisoned, I - f
Figure 5. Decrease in activity for different types of poisoning. (a) Uniform poisoning, low e; (b) Uniform, high o; (c-e) Core poisoning, increasing o; (f-g) Pore-mouth poisoning. Pursuing an analysis similar to that for the uniform poisoning case one can obtain for activity in the case of pore mouth poisoning ap = [tanh(fr162
[ 1 + (1-f)r162
1
(11)
For core poisoning, one obtains ao = [tanh(fr162
(12)
where ap and ac are acfm'ties for pore mouth and core poisoning, respectively. The important message in this treatment is that the apparent activity of a pellet can vary greatly with the type of poisoning taking place if diffusion rates influence the overall reaction rate. In fact, " dpis defined here as the ratio = L(2k/rD)1/2,where L is the diameter of the pellet, k is a first-order rate constant, r is the radius of the pellet, and D is some effective diffusion coefficient. Effective diffusion parameters are another thought altogether,but beyond the scope of the present discussion.
76 the activity relationship to (l-f) can be anywhere in the scale range 0-1 depending upon the extent of diffusion and the type of poisoning, as shown in Figure 5. There have been many approaches to this problem; our discussion above has concentrated on poisoning as the mechanism mostly because of space limitations in a presentation such as this, however it is important to recall the work of Masamune and Smith [5] treating examples of coke formation in diffusion-limited pellets according to both parallel and series mechanisms. They solved the appropriate conservation equations numerically and were able to demonstrate in some detail the evolution of coke as well as activity profiles within the pellet as a function of time of operation. The types of profiles they demonstrated for both parallel and series coke formation mechanisms, and their evolution with time, are shown in Figure 6 for ~ = 5, in the region of significant diffusional limitation; the profiles are indeed steep. Note that the parallel mechanism leads to profiles akin to pore mouth poisoning, 2.0
1.8
~, 1.6 8 1.4
" " :
"
I.O 0 . 8 ~
0.8 0.6 0.4 0.2
0
0.6 f 0.4 0.2 0
1.2 1.0
1.0
f I 0.5 0
0.5
1.0 0.8 0.6 0.4 0.2 0
I
1.0 0.8 0.6 0.4 0.2 0
0.5 0 0.5
Figure 6. Profiles for self-fouling, parallel and series mechanisms. and the series mechanism to profiles suggestive of core poisoning. Of course, at lower values of the Thiele Modulus these steep gradients will level out and the pellet, for either mechanism of coking, will become more uniformly deactivated. The inclusion of the time of operation by Masamune and Smith strongly indicates the unsteady-state nature of deactivation, was recognized in the early work of Voorhies. The time scales and corresponding real times-on-stream are discussed by Butt and Petersen [6]. A final topic we shall mention concerning the deactivation of isothermal pellets is the effect of nonuniform distribution of the active ingredient within the pellet. It has been known for sometime that this is possible - wittingly or unwittingly. This is particularly so for metals supported on porous oxides, e.g., alumina. We will take one simple example, the analysis of Shadman-Yazdi and Petersen [7] for self-fouling by a series mechanism in which the concentration of catalytic material was highest on the exterior of the pellet and fell to zero at the center according to the equation
~(~) = a0~5
(13)
where a0 is the activity at the exterior of a spherical pellet, ~ is the dimensionless radius, and 6 a distribution parameter. We normalize the distribution such that
77
~.o1 a ( ~ ) d ~
which yields
= 1
k = k~(a)(~)
(14)
where k~ is the average rate constant. The rate of reaction at any time, OB, is given by r(0B) = Vo~kaCa0rl
(15)
which reduces to r(0) = VpskaCA0n
(16)
where V is pellet volume, p, the surface area per unit volume, 1] the effectiveness factor of the unfouled catalyst, and the apparent activity of the pellet. Values of and 1"1 as a function of the Thiele Parameter ~ are shown in Figure 7 for two differing distributions. Here ~ is defined as (Lpsk/D) v2 and 0B as k~CA0t. These results indicate that distributing the active ingredient towards the exterior improves the resistance of the catalyst to poisoning if a series mechanism operates, since both the effectiveness factor and average activity are higher with higher loadings near the surface (dotted line). One might expect the opposite to be the case for a parallel mechanism, and in general intuition serves us well for these simple models, c.f other early work of Corbett and Luss [8] and Becker and Wei [9]. There have been many studies since then. Experimental verification of such analyses for parallel poisoning has been reported by Au et al. [ 10]. It should be remembered, however, that intuition concerning distributions may not serve one well in selectivity problems involving complicated sequences of reactions.
1.0
/N
0.6
s
0.4
,5
I-"---.._
-------4.__'_
I
'
I , l
I
~.o < e
0.2
0
I
,
It
I,I
,
I'Otr ~ ~ - - . ,o
0.81.. 0.6
.e_>
0.4
----o(~) = 3
0.211
, I~l~l 0.40.6
i
' , ',,
,
'
"~ ~ . . . ~-~
I
I 2
L
* 4
, I 6
810
Thiele Porometer: 6
Figure 7. Deactivation for nonuniform impregnation, series mechanisms.
78 6. SOME EXPERIMENTS A considerable amount of experimental information has been obtained for diffusion-reactiondeactivation in pellets by the use of so-called "single pellet diffusion reactors". These come in two forms: the first, originally developed by Balder and Petersen [11] ("Petersen's Pellet Poisoner"), relies upon the analysis of concentrations of reactants and their variation with time; the second, from Kehoe and Butt [12] ("Kehoe's Katalyst Killer") involves measurement of temperature profiles within the pellet and their variation with time. The first is useful for deactivation in isothermal systems; the second, at the expense of more complexity, can be used for both isothermal and nonisothermal systems. It is not possible to go into a long discussion of these systems here, but some discussion of the more simple reactor, for isothermal systems, will be useful as an example. The isothermal diffusion reactor provides a means for measuring the composition of the reaction mixture at the center of the pellet and near the external face. The reactor is designed to
R..ct..t. ~ Co_
R.=,..,. ~ Co-
r
I
I
X+AX
c,o..c,o.. I
X*AX
(a)
(b)
Figure 8. Comparison of Thiele-Zeldovich model (a), with the single pellet diffusion reactor (b).
mimic the original Thiele-Zeldovich model of diffusion and reaction in a porous pellet, and a comparison of the model with the reactor is shown in Figure 8. In the reactor the centerplane chamber contains no catalyst thus the concentration gradient is forced to zero, which corresponds to the mid-point of the pellet in the model, L. Now, when deactivating pellets are studied, the centerplane concentration will change with time, as shown in Figure 9. C(O,O)
Progressive
c(t z, t) c(t s , i) t:O
~ I 0
0
C(O, I)
Dim,nsionless Distance Into Pore. F : X / L
Figure 9. Changes in certerplane concentration with progressive deactivation.
79 Information on deactivation can be obtained by defining a dimensionless centerplane concentration: n = [~(z, 1)-qt(0,1)]/[ 1-~)(0,1)]
(17)
where ~(z,1) and ~(0,1) are centerplane concentrations at times x and zero, respectively. ~ is useful because it can be measured without explicit reference to time, and because analytical expressions can be derived from various pore poisoning models as those discussed above. For example, for uniform fouling one can obtain U~= [ 1/cosh(r
1/cosh~)]/[ 1-1/cosh~]
(]8)
and since we know the relationship between and f, then can be represented directly as a function of ft. Other relationships can be obtained, for example, for pore mouth poisoning, and then a simple comparison of f, or , behavior with fl gives a good idea of what is going on. An example is shown in Figure 10 for deactivation in the hydrogenolysis of cyclopropane on Pt/alumina. It is easy to see that this deactivation is somewhere intermediate between pore mouth and uniform fouling. To read a little more from the result, one might infer that the cyclopropane, rather than some product, is responsible for the deactivation. Obviously, by combinations of experiments at different conditions and with different particle dimensions, one might be able to identify a rather comprehensive picture of the deactivation sequence involved in this reaction system. This method has subsequently been refined in the work of Hegedus and Petersen [ 13]. 1.0 L
,
,
,
,
'~ : 3.2 Exper,mentol Doto _
0 . 8 ~
0.6 ~ - ~ h ~ <0>
0
0
P~176 0.2
I 0.4
0
[ 0.6
O~
1.0
Figure 10. Comparison of experiment with uniform and pore-mouth poisoning. In practice, however, many reactions involve significant heats of reaction, and analysis based on assumption of isothermality is only approximate. In principle, a concentration decrease in the pellet is always accompanied by a temperature change unless the reaction is absolutely thermally neutral. An estimate of the maximum influence of nonisothermality can be obtained from the relationship of Prater [ 14] (AT)max = (-AH) (Do~)Co/K~
(19)
where Co is the reactant concentration at the external surface of the pellet, D~r the effective diffusion coefficient within the partite, and Kar some effective thermal conductivity of the particle. Now, these thermal effects can indeed be important. Figure 11 shows some results from the hydrogenation of benzene on a Ni/kieselguhr catalyst in a single pellet reactor at various
80 concentrations of benzene in the feed and at several different flow conditions. The conditions of the experiment are specific, of course, but one can see that intraparticle temperature gradients of 4050~ are not unusual. One would have to conclude that much of the original theory of reaction/diffusion/deactivation developed on the basis of isothermal theory might have to be rethought (and much of it has been). Sagara et al. [15] redid the work of Masamune and Smith using similar kinetic/deactivation models, but admitting for intraparticle temperature effects. The results are difficult to describe simply because the parameterization of the analysis increases significantly. We now have activation energy parameters for both main and deactivation reactions, as well as a quantity normally termed the Prater Number: 13= (-~-t)D,~Co/I~frTo
(20)
However, it is apparent from the results of Sagara et al., and from subsequent experiments that nonisothermality has a profound influence upon the development of intraparticle profiles in the presence of deactivation, as will be seen below.
Ioo-
~
I O0 - ~ -
~
T,*C 8 0
SL/mi,
.
4
" ' -
13.o3"t,_ -
6
3.90
I00 _lcl
1:3.48~"
80 . -
.
i
Bulk 1.0
i
0.8
t.
1
i
1
0.6 0.4 = r/r 0
t
I
0.2
0
Figure 11. Intemal and extemal temperature profiles for benzene hydrogenation in a single pellet reactor. One of the nice things about thermal measurements in a single pellet reactor is that they allow one to observe transients. The transient behavior of particles upon initiation of a poison-influenced reaction provides a particularly good example of this. Figure 12 shows some results. These again are for the benzene hydrogenation poisoned by thiophene and show the responses for three catalysts of differing initial activity levels. Benzene and hydrogen are introduced to the catalyst (remember these are all single pellet experiments) at time zero and 200~ The maximum activity catalyst, (A), shows the development of an internal temperature that grows to about 210~ from the initial 100~ in about 15 min. The 40% activity catalyst, (B), attains an internal temperature of about 165~ on the same basis, but the steady state time, 15 min is the same. Even the low activity, (C), catalyst, at 15%, appears to approach steady state within the same time frame, with an observed temperature of
81 135~ vs. the start at 100~ Thus we have a significant effect of the level of activity upon the magnitude of intraparticle temperatures, but not upon the time response. None of this behavior shows up in the Prater Number. The key to understanding time response comes from a detailed solution of the transient heat transfer equation. The dimensionless time will take the form (Lee et al. [16]): KenC/pC0(r0)2 = 1
(21)
where t is the characteristic time of response for the system and p the catalyst density. It is tempting to conclude, then, that the level of deactivation under transient conditions significantly affects the magnitude of the change (we look here at temperature; presumably concentration would be similar), but has minor effects on time scale. This needs more study. Not shown here, but of importance, is the fact that the magnitude of the ratio (K~dDon) is very significant in determining both the level of deactivation and the thermal response of individual catalyst pellets. Particularly for exothermic reactions, this will define where the final intraparticle exotherm resides, and since it is a ratio of quantities, it is difficult to discern the contribution of individual factors in general. This is shown in detailed calculations by Lee et al. Finally, here, one can look at intraparticle waves. A close look at Figure 12 shows that there are certain maxima ("hot spots") in the thermal profiles that develop and then disappear as steady state is
:
,.ovL- t
[ o.o
o
o
Figure 12. Effect of deactivation on startup transients for benzene hydrogenation. approached. In fact, there are all sorts of thermal waves that have been observed in transients with particles subject to deactivation. Some of these start at the pellet exterior, migrate to the interior and then remain there. Others, as shown in the results of Figure 12, stay close to the exterior of the pellet, and so on. The motion of these transient hot spots has been found to be a strong function of the Damkohler Number of the system. This is defined as noND~ = Rd(k~a)Co
(22)
where 110 is an overall effectiveness factor as defined by Carberry [ 17], 1% is the observed rate of reaction, kga the mass transfer coefficient extemal to the catalyst pellet surface, and Co the reactant concentration. Results of this for experiments with benzene hydrogenation are shown in Figure 13.
82
6 .c ,,,,r | 4 E I-
01.0 0.8
0.6
0.4
0.2
0
Figure 13. Variations in hot spot migration patterns on startup. One sees that there are really wandering hot spots dependent upon the parameters of the reaction system. I prefer to think of these as various types ofthennal waves within the partide. There is one interesting fact; however the transients set up operation, and however one obtains steady state, under deactivation conditions, with time, most pellets follow the Voorhies correlation, more or less. In view of the catalyst particle transients, it is not then unusual that one might look for waves in reactor operation, our final topic.
7. DEACTIVATION IN FIXED BEDS
We have already touched upon this topic in a qualitative manner in mentioning the work of Bohart and Adams and Bischoff and Froment. It is may be worth some additional effort to consider the origin of these results while minimizing as best we can the exposure to deadly equations. Wheeler and Robell [18] were the first to make use of the Bohart-Adams model which, as we have said, was developed for a fixed-bed adsorption problem. They used the adsorption model to establish the shape and motion of the poison profiles (c.f. Figure 1) within the bed and then essentially solved a reaction/deactivation problem based on these profiles (in their case a simple first order system). However, it was also necessary to specify how the reaction rate constant, k, varied with the concentration of poison on the catalyst. In the simplest case we can choose a linear relationship (nonselective poisoning) as they did and write = a = 1- Cp/Cp,tot
(23)
where ko is the initial first order rate constant, C~ is the concentration of poison on the catalyst, and Cp,tot is a limiting capacity of the catalyst for poison, where a = 0. Upon solution of the conservation equations one obtains the relationship between reactant concentration and position/time-on-stream At the bed exit, L ln(CL/Co= (-ko/lqd~)ln{1-exp(-Nt0/0t)+exp[Nt(1-0/0t)] }
(24)
83
where Nt = (kadsL/V) is the number of adsorption transfer units in the reactor, 0t = pBCp,totL/Mv(Cp, g)o is the ratio of the total capacity of the catalyst in the bed for poison to the rate of introduction of poison, v the feed velocity, OB catalyst bulk density, M molecular weight of poison and (Cp,g)o entering concentration of poison in the gas (fluid) phase. This result was also generalized by writing eqn (23) in terms of the selective poisoning model of Wheeler [ 19], giving an equation for conversion too long to be comfortable on these pages, and further generalized by Haynes [20] for diffusion-controlled poisoning. It should be recognized, however, that useful as these resuks may be, they do not represent a solution to the simultaneous reaction/deactivation problem but a superposition of the chemical events on the deactivation events. Thus the poison waves are always the result of the BohartAdams theory. The next step, of course, is to write a unified model, as was done by Froment and Bischoff. Again we deal with a one-dimensional, plug flow, isothermal reactor, but here treat the case of deactivation by coke formation where either the reactant or the product is the coke precursor. Using the notation of the original work, the conservation equation for reactant A, mole fraction x, is 0x/0"t = -(s
(25)
x = (F/epAf~dp)0, z = w/dp , Z = W/dp where F is the feed rate in mass/time, e reactor void fraction, dp catalyst particle diameter, f~ total reactor cross section, 0 time, W reactor length, PA mass density of reactant A, OBbulk density of the catalyst and rA the rate of reaction of A. The rate of deactivation is proportional to the amount of coke on the catalyst and is slow compared to the rate of the main reaction, and rates of main and coking reactions are first order, in the latter dependent upon either reactant or product precursor, whatever the case may be. Now we still have to specify a relationship between the coke (poison) on the catalyst and the catalyst activity. Several relationships were considered in the original work; our illustration is based on an exponential relationship between activity and coke concentration k_g = (k_A)o(a)
(26)
a = exp(-ot2C,)
(27)
where ct2 is an experimentally determined scaling factor. When the time scale of deactivation is slow compared to the main reaction, initial coke is zero and the reactant is the precursor one can obtain a relatively simple analytical solution x = { 1+exp(-ot2bq_)[exp(az)- 1] }-1
(28)
exp(-cz2Cc) : { 1+exp(-az)[exp(ot2bvl_)- 1]}-1
(29)
with a and b groupings of reactor parameters, ~pBdpP(k_A)0~ and ~'~pAt~dpP(k_A,d)0/F, respectively. When the coke formation is via a predominant reactant precursor, the coke concentration on catalyst generally decreases with reactor length regardless of the relationship between Cc and a; conversely, for product coke precursor coke on catalyst increases with reactor length. In the real world there is very likely a mix of the two mechanisms; for a dose of reality see the work of Dumez and Froment [21 ] on n-butene dehydrogenation. The nature of these coke profiles helps one to understand the wave motion illustrated in Figure 2. Under initial conditions no coke is present and the reaction rate will be highest at the entrance of
84 the bed where the reactant concentration is highest. On the other hand, the rate of coke formation and deactivation will also be highest where the reactant precursor concentration is highest, so the entrance to the bed will also deactivate at the highest rate. Following the progression with time, it is not difficult to understand, then, that the preferential bed entrance deactivation leads to a higher concentration of reactant (precursor) penetrating deeper into the bed and the subsequent development of an activity wave as shown. It is notable that in Figure 2 the final condition shown, with activity highest at bed exit, is exactly the opposite from initial conditions with highest activity at entrance. There is a Table in the text of Butt and Petersen (Table 10-2, Ch. 10) listing ten substantial studies of isothermal fixed bed deactivation up through about 1989 (some of the studies involving multiple references themselves). While I have not attempted an accurate count, there must be on the order of 5-10 publications of various sorts on this topic in each of the past six years, so we by now have a substantial literature to build upon, even if all the problems have not been resolved. Deactivation-induced wave motion can be very prominent in nonisothermal-nonadiabatic reactors, as seen in Figure 3. The simulation of these reactors is a much more difficult problem than isothermal cases, for while often a plug flow model is adequate for mass conservation equations alone if selectivity functions or very short beds are not involved, in the energy conservation equation bed thermal conductivities are often large enough that a dispersion term is needed. This is particularly so in deactivation problems where steep gradients, moving with time as in Figure 3, are encountered. Short of writing another paper there is not much to be gained by going into a detailed discussion of conservation relations and deactivation equations for the nonisothermal case. A typical development is that of Weng et al., and there are many others similar. One prominent feature of the analysis of fixed-bed reactor deactivation is the (unavoidable) large number of parameters involved, at least thirteen or so without including pore diffusion effects and not counting kinetic constants of the reaction and deactivation rate equations. These thirteen parameters, of course, are not all equal in their influence (or, in the Orwellian sense "... all parameters are equal but some are more equal than others ...") and include very sensitive quantities such as wall heat transfer coefficient, bed effective thermal conductivity, and thermal terms related to heats of reaction and activation energies. Aside from trying to cope with the large number of parameters, most workers have struggled somewhat with methods for numerical solution of this type of problem. That also is another story all by itself. Some approaches have included a variable space-step method (Eigenberger and Butt [22]) and collocation (Carey and Finlayson [23], Kam and Hughes [24]). There still seems to be a good distance to go in this area, but with the advent of powerful desktop machines, computer time seems not so precious a commodity as it was not too long ago.
8. CONCLUSIONS It should be apparent by now that, following the "lessons" provided in the Abstract, indeed the three areas of chemistry, reaction and mass/heat transport kinetics, and unsteady-state analysis all play important roles in the understanding of catalyst deactivation. Unfortunately, few of us are blessed with expertise in all of these areas, so there is some compartmentalization in the literature of this field. Fundamental knowledge of poisoning, particularly of metal surfaces, and its relation to surface 'site' geometry has been increased greatly via techniques such as IR and XPS, but it is still a long way, for example, from the operating conditions of an XPS machine to a commercial hydrogenation reactor. Significant strides, however, have been made in recent years in bridging this gap. Similarly, our knowledge of oxide catalysts is much advanced from even a decade ago, but the end of the road is yet not in sight. Advancing as well is our understanding of the many mechanisms of coke formation, but these are so reaction/catalyst-specific that we shall for the foreseeable future still find it necessary to
85 determine individual correlations between coke on catalyst and catalyst activity. This is especially so because in long operating-cycle processes such as hydrotreating the nature of the coke changes with time-on-stream. Solid state transformations like sintering or phase changes, which we have only mentioned in this report, remain probably the least well understood of the mechanisms of deactivation. One would hope that the next decade will see advances here comparable to those made with respect to poisoning in the last. As a first estimate, it would appear that most combinations of deactivation mechanism and intraparticle transport processes have been investigated, at least theoretically. We still would benefit from additional experimental studies in this area, especially in systems where thermal effects are of importance. We also tend to forget that sometimes important physical properties such as porosity and effective diffusivity change significantly with time-on-stream. The basics of such studies, however, are well-established from work dating back even twenty plus years, as seen here, so unfortunately research of this kind is probably not considered very glamorous. In addition, although the topic has not been discussed here, more work on reaction/diffusion/deactivation in biochemical systems, in many instances similar to that done for chemical systems, is much needed and is an important area for future study. Reactor modeling for reactions subject to deactivation would stand at approximately the same stage of development as the intraparticle problem. The large number of parameters and the parametric sensitivity involved in detailed models makes Occam's razor look a little bit rusty. The difficulty doesn't just go away, though, and in this sense we are truly not able to subvert nature. Concern with the development of super-efficient computational algorithms seems to have diminished in view of hardware developments in recent years, although the use of series mixing cell sequences as a reactor model basis has not been exploited as much as it could have been. Of course, the parameterization still does not go away. Again, applications to biochemical systems will be an important area in the future. Overall, I have enjoyed my journey through the mountains, valleys, plains and deserts of catalyst deactivation. The combinations of physical/chemical phenomena are almost unique, the chemistry often complex and somewhat obscure, and the modeling problems formidable. Who could ask for anything more? REFERENCES 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. 6. 7. 8. 9. 10. 11 12. 13. 14. 15. 16. 17.
A.Voorhies, Jr., Ind. Eng. Chem. 37 (1945) 318. G.Bohart and E. Adams, J. Am. Chem. Soc. 42 (1920) 523. G.F.Froment and K.B. Bischoff, Chem. Eng. Sci. 10 (1961) 189; 17 (1962) 105. H.S.Weng, G. Eigenberger and J.B. Butt, Chem. Eng. Sci. 30 (1975) 1341. S.Masamune and J.M. Smith, AIChE J. 12 (1966) 384. J.B.Butt and E.E. Petersen, "Activation, Deactivation and Poisoning of Catalysts", Academic Press, Inc., 1988. F.Shadman-Yazdi and E.E. Petersen, Chem. Eng. Sci. 27 (1972) 227. W.E.Corbett, Jr. and D. Luss, Chem. Eng. Sci. 29 (1974) 1473. E.R.Becker and J. Wei, J. Catal. 46 (1977) 372. S.S.Au, J.S. Dranoffand J.B. Butt, Chem. Eng. Sci. 50 (1995) 3801. J.R.Balder and E.E. Petersen, Chem. Eng. Sci. 23 (1968) 1287. J.P.G.Kehoe and J.B. Butt, AIChE J. 18 (1972) 347. L.L.Hegedus and E.E. Petersen, Catal. Rev. - Sci. Eng. 9 (1974) 245. C.D.Prater, Chem. Eng. Sci. 8 (1958) 284. M.Sagara, S. Masamune and J.M. Smith, AIChE J. 13 (1967) 1226. J.W.Lee, J.G. Butt and D.M. Downing, AIChE J. 24 (1978) 212. J.J.Carberry, "Chemical and Catalytic Reaction Engineering", McGraw-Hill, Inc., 1976.
86 18 19. 20. 21 22. 23 24.
A.Wheeler and A.J. Robell, J. Catal. 13 (1969) 299. A.Wheeler, Adv. Catal. 3 (1950) 307. H.W.Haynes, Jr., Chem. Eng. Sci. 25 (1970) 1615. F.J.Dumez and G.F. Froment, Ing. Eng. Chem. Process Des. Dev. 15 (1976) 291. G.Eigenberger and J.B. Butt, Chem. Eng. Sci. 31 (1976) 681. G.F.Carey and B.A. Finlayson, Chem. Eng. Sci. 30 (1975) 587. E.K.T.Kam and R. Hughes, Chem. Eng. J. 18 (1979) 93.
~ Elsevier Science B.V. All rights reserved Catalyst Deactivation 1997 C.H. Bartholomew and G.A. Fuentes, editors
87
Catalyst Deactivation: Opportunity amidst Woe Eugene E. Petersen Department of Chemical Engineering University of California, Berkeley, CA 94720
I would like to thank the organizing committee of 7 th ISCD for awarding John Butt and me the Maxsted Award for our joint authorship of the book, Activation, Deactivation and Poisoning of Catalysts. The collaboration between John and me was both educational and satisfying for me and it is noteworthy to mention that our personal friendship has survived the collaboration. My goal xn this talk is certainly not to summarize the topics in the book as that would be neither possible nor appropriate. Rather, as the title suggests, I would like to look at one aspect of the subject the importance of which I have a rather well-developed bias. This has to do with the utilization of reaction and deactivation data together to determine reaction rate and deactivation rate expressions as well as to design reactors. First let's review the situation facing anyone wanting to use the deactivation technology. For most chemical reactions, we will have at best only incomplete rate information available to be interpreted in terms of a theoretical framework that is overly flexible and undersensitive diagnostically. Superimposed upon this we usually have insufficient deactivation data to be interpreted in terms of a theoretical framework having the same shortcomings as the kinetic rates of the main chemical reactions. We face a situation somewhat similar to that depicted in Samuel Hoffenstein"s quip: Little by little we subtract Faith and fallacy from fact, The illusory from the true, And starve upon the residue. Perhaps this characterization is a bit pessimistic, but it emphasizes how important it is for the reactor designer to know the limitations of the theoretical framework in which his data must be interpreted. The main theme of this talk explores an example of the use of deactivation information to learn more about the kinetics of the main reaction. This idea is not new. Noteworthy is the pioneering paper of Herrington and Rideal [ 1] who demonstrated theoretically that a main reaction requiting more than one surface site loses activity faster than proportional to the number of unpoisoned sites, i.e., poisoning one quarter of the surface sites reduces the number of multiple site ensembles by more than twenty-five per cent. The number of six-site ensembles falls off very rapidly with the extent of poisoning. Their paper is all the more remarkable because the numerical work was done before the availability of digital computers. Accordingly, the relationship they found was based upon a relatively small section of a (111) plane surface. Never-the-less, their results are qualitatively correct.
88 Catalyst developers experience woe in their quest to find a practical catalyst owing to the very general tendency of catalysts to deactivate during use onstream. To live with this phenomenon, a developer must know the time scale of the deactivation process in order to know what kind of reactor to use. If development schedules permit, the developer may even have the luxury of making a detailed study of the deactivation process in the laboratory or in a pilot plant to find conditions to increase the life of the catalyst on stream. I have always been impressed by the success that an intelligent engineer can achieve with limited data when it is supplemented by an undefinable intuition and insight and a few model calculations. This works largely because the magnitude of the reactor design integral is not terribly sensitive to the exact shape of the rate function so long as it has approximately the right general shape. As a consequence one can often use a lumped parameter to approximate a phenomenon in place of the detailed parameter behavior. For example, in some cases it is possible to replace an array of several similar parallel chemical reactions by a single reaction of averaged properties. The trick is to choose the parameters of the single reaction to behave close enough to the real system to be useful. The chosen parameters would then be designated as lumped parameters. Of course a word of caution in using this approach is that one must constantly check the results against experimental data because lumps are not fundamental quantities. A rather nice story to serve as a case in point is the work of Weekman and his co-workers [2] at Mobil to describe the behavior of fixed, moving and fluidized bed reactors to catalytically crack feed streams under deactivating conditions. Both the main reaction and the deactivation reaction are exceextingly complex and to describe them precisely is well beyond our knowledge to date. The woe is that these processes are industrially very important and must be used to produce gasoline. So it is prudent and necessary to try to describe them as well as possible in the absence of complete information. The approach of Weekman and his co-workers was to assume that the array of chemical compounds in the gas-oil feed fraction can be lumped as a single chemical identity which under cracking conditions forms chemical products; gasoline (C5)-----410~ F and other fractions consisting of Ca's, dry gas and coke. The deactivation process must also be handled as a lumped process. Most descriptions are of the Voorhies type that relates activity as inversely related to the coke content. Care must be exercised in making this assumption because very definitive experiments have demonstrated that coke per se is not the deactivating substance but rather specific compounds, such as organic bases, cause deactivation. Useful lumping results when the specific deactivating compounds are produced approximately in proportion to the coke. Now we make the assumption that the rate of chemical reaction under deactivating conditions can be expressed as the product of two quantities: a rate expression for an unpoisoned catalyst and a proportionality constant which is defined as the activity. This is the so called separable form proposed by Szepe and Levenspiel [3]. Accordingly, if we say that the deactivation rate is proportional to the reaction rate, or more specifically, the rate of change in activity is proportional to the activity, then we arrive at an exponential decay in activity with time of the form activity = exp(-kdt)
,
(1)
where kd is the deactivation rate constant which must be evaluated for feedstocks, reactor conditions, catalyst used and a whole host of variables specific to a particular cracking operation. This is the Mobil approach to commercial deactivating reactors and it apparently works well when attention is focused upon the lumping parameters and their meaning. I would like, now, to review in a limited way some work of some of my former students and
89 myself-- Larry Jossens, Bruce Isaacs and in particular Mike Pacheco--- to try to understand the role that rhenium plays on the platinum catalyst used to reform naphtha streams. I believe that the study of the deactivation process offers some opportunities to understand both the main reaction and the deactivation reactions better.
4r•
r. d.s. ~
Fouled Sextet
lie
~
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Main Reoction
"It" Figure 1. Six-site fouling mechanism as a parallel pathway to the main reaction mechanism (* represents a metal site) Ref [4]. Reproduced by permission of Academic Press, Inc.
The deactivation process on this catalyst consists of progressive dehydrogenation, isomerization and polymerization on the metal catalytic sites [4] with paraffinic and aromatic molecules both contributing to the loss of catalytic activity. We start with a mechanism involving a paraff'mic molecule sorbed on the surface losing hydrogen atoms in a series of reversible dissociative steps. The multiply-bound molecule then reacts in a Rideal-Ely type mechanism that initiates the site-consuming polymerization process. Specifically, the methylcyclohexane loses all 11 of the hydrogens in the ring and the dehydrogenated surface species reacts with toluene by the process depicted on Figure 1. The main reaction is similar to other proposed mechanisms [5]. If we assume that the reaction between the surface bound molecule and toluene is rate determining step, we arrive at the expression shown in Equation 2 for the deactivation kinetics.
dSt _6ktK6S6 [MCHI[TOL] dt = [H2]~t
(2)
where St is the number of unfouled sites and So is the number of vacant sites. To use this equation to get a general relationship for how the activity changes with time requires that some relationship between St and Sv be established. In kinetic studies of the main reaction, product inhibition was proportional to toluene concentration to the - 8 9power. This leads to
St - K5Sv[TOL]~ .
(3)
90 Substitution of Equation 3 into Equation 2 reveals that the time derivative of St is proportaional to St6. Integration for constant concentrations and temperature and a boundary condition of St=Sto at t=0 yields
st = (1 + kt)Sto
(4)
where
k = 30kIS5~ K~[TOLI[H2I~
(5)
Since the main reaction is assumed to require one site, the left side of Equation 4 is equal to the activity and 1
Activity = a = (1 + kt)-~
(6)
At this point it should be emphasized that one cannot legitimately carry out the above integration unless the concentrations of all species are held constant throughout the deactivation process. This can be accomplished easily for a reaction involving one independent stoiehiometric equation by varying the flow rate to the reactor to keep one concentration constant [6]. In the case of more than one independent stoichiometric equation, maintaining constant concentrations is a difficult control problem. We can now compare Equations 5 and 6 with the data on the dehydrogenation of methylcyclohexane to toluene over a P t - A1203 catalyst shown in Figure 2 where the abscissa has been scaled with the corresponding k values for each experiment. The slope of the line becomes approximately proportional to the -0.2 power after an induction period characteristic of Equation 6, but at longer times on stream the data systematically deviates from the model line with an increasing slope. In keeping with the interpretation that led to Equation 4, we infer from this that the order of the deactivation process decreases with time on stream. This is consistent physically with the deactivation process using fewer sites as time passes. To explore this kind of behavior more quantitatively, we extend the model to allow deactivation using two, three, four and five sites mechanisms. This model takes the mathematical form
dSt
6
=- k so
(sv)Cm-D
(7)
m"-2
If we now define the following dimensionless quantities:
Sv _ number of vacant sites St _ number of active sites - St - number of'active sites ' f -- S t o - number of active sites initially T - - 5 k 6 v 6 t , k m = Amexp ( ~Tm ) Substituting these quantities into Equation 7, we get
d'-'t = - 5 m=2
(A.) ~
~,rn-6fmexp
RT
(8)
91 ~
L0
- ..... I
........
I
........
I
........
I
........
9
9
O
9
t>
O
a
,~q:>
| A
o..1
Model
(C) <J
o
o 01,"1 I J
C, 0 a
j J I
B v |
MCH Tol.
352
352
352 352 351
12
,105
1.5
1'
413
2.3
32
19 12 2
1' 1'
405 405 220
18
T
405
18 18
I ,o ~
,~'
11 34
4OO
o o.1 . . . . . . . . .
(mio ] )
18
34
377 352
H,
........
I ,o'
403 405
-a.-~~ "
2.5 4.6
O~
I ,o ~
J
:8
I ..J
~ 9
........
I ,d
I
-
9 #~
30. 33. 45. 150.
........
--
........
J j J
o~v 9 9 ~ I ,0 4
j j J
........
, ,o s
Fouling Time, k t Figure 2. Fouling data for dehydrogenation of methylcyclohexane to toluene over a platinum-alumina catalyst Ref [4]. Reproduced by permission of Academic Press, Inc.
I0.~ =i,=-
._>
X = _>B kcal/mol
9
I0 - I -
~ >,
o 0
1 ~,~
_
:
I0 :z 1
-
3
basis: 4 0 0 " C
: :_
0 I 0 -I
--
Empirical Correlation - - Multiplel Model -
3
~
I J___ 10 3
I01
"~ 10 5
.~ 107
Fouling Time, kft Figure 3. Comparison of multiplet model with empirical fouling correlation for values of A. Ref [6]. Reproduced by permission of Academic Press, Inc.
Finally, we assume that .for all values of m (9)
( E r a - E6) = A(6 - m)
(i0)
Equation 9 assumes that the product of the pre-exponential factor and the activity for all multi-site reactions are equal. Differences in the rates of the multi-site reactions obtain from
92 the values of their respective activation energies. The assumption of Equation 9 minimizes the number of adjustable parameters. Equation 10 is equivalent to saying that each bond to the catalyst surface lowers the activation energy by an amount )~. Figure 3 shows several solutions to Equation 8 subject to the assumptions of Equations 9 and 10 for various values of ,k. A value somewhere between 2 and 3 kcal/mol has the approximate shape of the empirical correlation. Although this value of ~ is smaller than expected for the interaction energy per bond to the metallic surface, it is influenced by the assumption of Equation 9. A reasonable conclusion from this figure is that the multiplet model which is physically sensible also has the fight quantitative order of magnitude and effect. Of course one could play with Equations 9 and 10 to modify the assumptions to get a better fit, but in my opinion, as it stands, it lends support and utility to the idea that the deactivation process involves ensembles of sites containing progressively fewer sites as the deactivation process continues. When the numbers of six-site ensembles is large, the deactivation process proceeds rapidly, but as a rather small amount of surface sites are covered, the population of six-site ensembles decreases disproportionately much faster and further deactivation must proceed by parallel reactions involving ensembles containing fewer than six-sites. It is well known in refinery practice that sulfiding a P t - Al203 catalyst results in a more stable although somewhat less active catalyst. If it is assumed that the sulfiding simply deactivates single platinum atoms on the surface, the multiplet theory can easily account for the behavior. I
IO 0
"'
a o = O.G '
o....
= - 9, - -
I
..,,..
Im i
im i.
i
i
l
i . . . . . .
I
,,...., ~
~ " ' w
,,ram
--
- "='1-- ~,..~,/Empiricol
Correlation
IO-I
. ..,.,.,
o o --0.1
U
10-2 (kf)ptoS = 2 0 x (kf )Pt + Re S
0 0
10 -3
....
I I 0 -I
l
[,.. I01
!
1. 10 3
%, %" %"
.1
I I0 5
l
.,--
10 7
Dimensionless Fouling Time ( k f . t ) Figure 4. Typical fouling data for sulfided reforming catalysts. Shaded symbolsmPt, open symbols---Pt-Re Ref [7]. Reproduced by permission of Academic Press, Inc.
Sulfiding, therefore, reduces the activity of the catalyst for the main reaction and at the same time stabilizes the catalyst by reducing the number of six-site ensembles and, most importantly, it reduces the initial rate of deactivation because now it can occur only by a mechanism involving fewer active sites which is a slower process. In so doing note that by reducing the number of six-site ensembles before any deactivation takes place on stream results in a decrease in the deactivation rate at any given activity level as compared with the unsulfided catalyst. For a main reaction involving only one surface site, the activity itself is a measure of the number of unpoisoned active active centers on the surface. But the distribution of deactivated sites in a catalyst that has been sulfided is different than a catalyst deactivated by a six-site mechanism--the former being essentially a deactivation involving fewer than six
93
10-3
I
I
I
? ..=. 0
E
c 0
L
== v
10 . 4
U "10 0
n
E e) 0
10. 5
I-
Y I n t i m a t e Mixture A Physical Mixture 9Bimetallic
t:}
n,, 10 . 6 I 0 -I
I I00
! I01
! 102
I
03
Reaction Time (min) Figure S. Deactivation profiles for Pt and Pt-Re catalysts. Ref [7]. Reproduced by permission of Academic Press, Inc.
site.. As a consequence, at any comparable activity level, the number of remaining six-site ensembles is always greater for the unsulfided catalyst. Figure 4 shows how sulfiding affects the kinetic behavior of Pt-A1203 and P t - R e A l 2 0 3 catalysts when compared with a fresh unsulfided P t - A1203 catalyst. The activity of the P t - Re catalyst is reduced much more than the Pt catalyst with the same H2S treatment. As stated above, both catalysts are stabilized and their corresponding decay constants are reduced. "Significantly, the sulfided P t - Re catalyst's decay constant is 20 times smaller than the sulfided Pt catalyst. Integration of Equation 7 assuming that the initial activities are 0.6 and 0.1, respectively, for the Pt and P t - Re catalysts, yields the solid lines on Fig.ure 4. This figure may be misleading because time on the abscissa is dimensionless. A pomon of these data on a real time axis is shown on Figure 5. On this figure we compare the activitytime characteristics of the sulfided Pt and P t - Re catalysts. These curves clearly show the enormous stability of the P t - Re catalyst that is not so apparent in the dimensionless form. These data show that physical mixtures of R e - Al203 and P t - Al203 do not give the same deactivation behavior as a P t - ReAl203 catalyst. In fact the physical mixture is indistinguishable from the P t - A1203 catalyst alone. This point is made to demonstrate that our data do not support a proposed theory that Re in the bimetallic catalyst acts as a scavenger for deactivation precursers. These stu~es on the role of rhenium in the bimetallic reforming catalyst can be summarized on Figure 6. The PtAl203 catalyst appears to deactivate during its initial period by a mechanism involving six surface sites. As the deactivation progresses, the apparent order decreases to a value somewhere between two and three as shown on the figure. Sulfiding the PtAl203 catalyst results in an initial loss of activity but stabilizes the catalyst by lowering the magnitude of its decay constant by greatly reducing deactivation by a six-site mechanism. A similar but more pronounced effect is observed with the P t - ReAl203 catalyst. To me this, perhaps over-simplistic, interpretation gives us a way of thinking about how to improve the stability of catalysts by trying to understand the mechanisms by which they deactivate and try to interfere
94 with these processes in order to slow them down. I believe these kinds of approaches are often overlooked by many who are preoccupied by the woes of catalyst deactivation-- maybe a situation related to the yin and the yang of traditional Chinese cosmology. It is always satisfying when a theory that evolves from the interpretation of data explains an observed phenomenon that was not used in its development. Such is the case of using the multiplet theory to explain shape of the characteristic temperature-time curves for constant conversion in an industrial reactor. That is, to compensate for the inevitable decrease in conversion that would result as the catalyst in a reactor deactivates onstream, and operator raises the inlet temperature to maintain constant conversion. These curves are of three types: A curve whose slope that monotonically increases with time, a curve whose slope monotonically decreases with time and a curve whose slope decreases with time and then increases after passing through a inflection point. The last shape is very common. An elementary analysis of the problem that follows reveals that it is not easy to explain the inflection point in the curve. Jo ~
,.
~
J
I
I
\ % = 1.0
~,9
-
u
-I
v ~ ~ ~
---
!
~
AlexA
fresh Pt/AI 20
-----
io-Z
I
_
~
I
I
I
~\d:?_
~
\
Single-order Model ' Mult=ple-order Model
io-~
!
I I I Io z io 3 io 4 Dimensionless Fouling Time, k d , t
io o
I
io ~
'il ~'= I io 5
I
io 6
I
Figure 6. Dimensionless fouling curves for Pt and Pt-Re catalysts for the dehydrogenation of methylcyclohexane. Ref [7]. Reproduced by permission of Academic Press, Inc.
A well-stirred reactor illustrates the general behavior of deactivating systems. The usual design equation for such a reactor shown in Equation 10, = a.Vk.(To)C
where: v = volumetric flow rate C o - inlet concentration of reactant C e - outlet concentration of reactant a , = separable form of activity for main reaction V - reactor volume kn(T) - rate constant for main reaction at T q - o r d e r of the main reaction with respect to the limiting reactant.
(II)
95 Equation 11 can be rearranged to the form
k,.,(T) ankn(To)
Xr - -
(1 - x e ) q D a
(12)
where: x.
-
(Co - c D I C o
D a - Vk,~(To)Cqo-1/v, a DamkOhler number. The only variable on right-hand side of Equation 12 is the conversion, Xe, which is to remain constant by raising the inlet temperature of the feed mixture as a function of time. Therefore, the right-hand side of Equation 11 is a constant. But initially the left-hand side of Equation 11 is equal to one because the initial activity, an, is by definition unity. It follows, then, that the left-hand side of Equation 11 is not only constant but it is equal to one and remains equal to one throughout the deactivation process. If we replace the activity of the catalyst, a,~, by og'~, where og is the fraction of the sites that are active (not deactivated) and n is number of sites used by the main reaction and substitute the Arrhenius form for the rate constant in terms of the activation energy into the left-hand side of Equation 12, we get
oLnexp Y = 1
(13)
where:
Y - ,y.,.,(e/(l+ e ) ) e - (T-
To)IT,,)
% - E,URTo
En - activation energy for the main reaction. If we treat the deactivation reaction in a manner similar to that used previously, we get dog d"t
=
ogmkm(T)C~'
(14)
where a m is the activity for the deactivation reaction assuming that m sites are involved. Substituting the Arrhenius form for km in Equation 13 and simplifying we get
, ~da
= og"%xp(eY)
(15)
where: e - E m / E n and r - nkm(To)CPo(1 - Xe)Pt Using Equation 13 to eliminate a in Equation 15 yields 9
dY = exp(6Y) dr
(16)
96 where:
')
(17)
What we seek from Equation 16 is shape of the O versus T curve which would reflect the inlet temperature vs time curve. An efficient way of doing this is to look at the sign of the second derivative, d20/dr 2. Differentiating Equation 16 yields
1+0 The only term in Equation 17 that can be negative is enclosed in brackets which we will define here for convenience as A. In terms of real quantities
A = 7n
(E.~
En
m-
n
1
2T ) + 7nTo
(19)
There are three possible cases: A < 0: The slope of the T vs t curve increases monotonically (positive curvature). A = 0: The slope of the T vs t curve is constant. A > 0: The slope of the t vs t curve decreases monotonically (negative curvature). l.x~king at the quantifies in A, we observe they are all constants except m, n, and T. If we assume that the mechanisms of the main reaction and the deactivation reaction remain constant, then T is the only quantity that varies. The term 2T/"/nTo has normal values of about 0.1, i.e. T/To changes from 1 to about 1.2 during the entire period of deactivation and 7n is of the order of 20. If E m / E n ~ 2 - 4, m ~ 0 - - 5 and n ~ 1 - 2; then temperature variation in the 2T/%.,To is most unlikely to cause a change in the sign of the second derivative. Hence the often observed inflection in the T vs t curve is difficult to explain unless we allow the value of m to change with time. But in the early part of this paper we observed apparent changes in value of m with progressive deactivation. Accordingly, if we substitute the multiplet deactivation model into the theory, clearly there is opportunity for an inflection point because m - 1/n starts out at about 5 and decreases to about 2 and at the same time Em increases. Figure 8 shows the shape of Y vs r for various values of the ratio of the activation energy for deactivation to the activation energy of the main reaction. The model has the inherent characteristics to give the inflection point. It is not surprising that similar modeling of a plug flow reactor gives a similar result. Although the details are well beyond what I want to present here, suffice it to show that the results of the T vs t of a plug flow reactor are shown and compared to a typical T vs t for a commercial hydrodesulfurization reactor in Figure 9. Superimposed are the corresponding single-order deactivation models.
97 ,5.0
v
I
v
I
I
'1',
I
"
v i Vl , i v | i i v v- i i r i Bosi.....~s: T o 6 2 3 K ( 3 5 0 " C , 6 6 2 " F )
i
J'l
i
i
v v i
4.0
_
5.0
_
~ E , . ,5 ,c.,,,.,.,
|
| +
v 1 v i
/
aE 9 3~ kc.,/..o,
I
/
/
i X T y p i c o I HDS d a l o I . E . C . ( 1 9 8 1 ) Torero. Hornsberger ond B r i d ~ s ~ x
h~ O . I C
/
iii
iI
_
| >c 2.0
3
E
>-
o.o~
4
1.0
0
.g_ 0
I
1
1
~
0.2
0.4
i
l
O
50
0.6
I00
150
Dimensionless
200 Time,
250
5OO
k d ( T O ) 9!
T
Figure 8. Characteristicplot for a multiplet model in a CSTR. Ref [9]. Reproducedby permissionof Academic Press, Inc.
Figure 9. Typical T versus t curve for various kinetic models and a commercialI-IDSreactor. Ref [9]. Reproduced by permissionof AcademicPress, Inc.
Few people involved with catalysis find deactivation process anything but undesirable, more likely a nuisance, except for a few of us who play with the phenomenon as a part of.their livelihood. The main message in this paper is that those stuck with a catalystthat deactivates under operating conditions might profitably spend a little time trying to understand something about the mechanism of process. The rewards can be anything between marginally better design information to a whole new way of thinking about the catalytic process that leads to better catalyst design. I am sure that many of you are aware that the bimetallic reforming catalyst evolved as the result of an experiment using rhenium on the catalyst as a possible means to suppress sintering. The enhanced stability of the sufided form to deactivation by coke was a serendipitous result. These fortuitous events have led the way to a whole series of bimetallic and even trimetallic catalysts with increasingly superior deactivation properties. The work discussed herein is an a p o s t e r i o r i explanation of the enhanced stability for the P t - ~ catalyst based upon the idea that a well distributed sulfided Re surface sites markedly reduce the number of six-site ensembles---the ensembles that contribute to rapid initial deactivation. The result is in itself important for an understanding of the deactivation of this important industrial catalyst. But more important, it may serve as a model to understand the deactivation of of other supported metal catalysts to carry out other hydrocarbon reactions where polymerization type processes cause deactivation.
NOMENCLATURE a -- activity of catalyst for the reaction of MCH to TOL. an -- separable activity for main reaction. Am = preexponenti.al factor for the m th reaction. Co - concentration of reactoant entering reactor. Ce - concentration of reactoant leaving reactor. D a - Damkohler Number, see Equation 12. Em = activation energy for the m th main reaction. En =- activation energy for the n th deactivation reaction. f _= fraction of surface sites that are active, see Equation 7. [H2] = hydrogen concentration k defined by Equation 5. k,~ - deactivation rate constant, see Equation 1.
98
km =-- deactivation rate constant for m th reaction kt -- deactivation rate constant MCH to TOL reaction K5 ----- equilibrium constant for inhibition MCH to TOL reation. K 6 ------equilibrium constant for dehydrogenation of MCH on surface. [MCH] - methylcyclohexane concentration. m is subscript pertaining to a deactivation reaction. n is subscript pertaining to a main reaction. St - number of active (unpoisoned) sites on surface at time=t. Sto =- number of active (unpoisoned) sites on surface at time=0. Sv -= number of vacant sites on surface at time=t. t - time on stream for deactivation. [TOL] - toluene concentration. v - volumetric flow rate to the reactor. X e - (Co - O e ) / G o , the conversion in the reactor. Y - 7 n O / ( 1 - O), see Equation 13. a n - activity for an n th order surface main reaction. a m -- activity for a n n t h order surface deactivation reaction. c
-
E~/E,,
v 7A ~5 A
-- defined by Equation 7. - defined by Equation 7. -- bond energy to surface. -- see Equation 16. -- see Equation 19. 0 = ( T - T o ) / T o , a dimensionless temperature. 7 - E/l~o, an Arrhenius Number.
REFERENCES 1. E . E G : Herrington and E.K. Rideal, Trans. Faraday Soc.40 (1944) 505. 2. J.B. Butt and E.E. Petersen, Activation, Deactivation and Poisoning of Catalysts, Academic Press, 1988. 3. S. Sz6pe and O. Levenspiel, Chem. React. Eng., Proc. Eur. Symp.. 4th, 1968. 4. M. A Pacheco and E. E. Petersen, J. Catalysis 86 (1984)75. 5. B.C. Gates, J.R. Katzer and G.C.A. Schuit, Chemistry of Catalytic Processes, McGraw-Hill, 1979. 6. E.E. Petersen and M.A. Pacheco, ACS Syrup. Series 237 (1984) 363. 7. M. A Pacheco and E. E. Petersen, J. Catalysis 88 (1984) 400. 8. M. A Pacheco and E. E. Petersen, J. Catalysis 96 (1986) 499. 9. M. A Pacheco and E. E. Petersen, J. Catalysis 98 (1986) 380.
9
Elsevier Science B. V. All rights reserved
Catalyst Deactivation 1997 C.H. Bartholomewand G.A. Fuentes, editors
99
The R e l a t i o n s h i p B e t w e e n Metal Particle M o r p h o l o g y and the Structural Characteristics of C a r b o n Deposits R. T. K. Baker a, M. S. Kim b, A. Chambers a, C. Park a and N. M. Rodriguez a aDept, of Chemistry, Northeastern University, Boston, MA 02115. bDept, of Chemical Engineering, Myong Ji University, Kyonggi-do, Korea 449-728.
The understanding of the factors controlling the deposition of carbonaceous solids resulting from the decomposition of hydrocarbons over metal particles has a considerable impact on a number of commercial processes including: catalytic steam reforming of methane, catalytic reforming and systems involving carbon monoxide disproportionation reactions. The highest catalytic activity for carbon deposition is exhibited by iron, cobalt and nickel, and alloys containing these metals. During the past few years we have pursued a program designed to achieve conditions where it is possible to control the catalytic properties of a given metal by inducing perturbations to the reactive surfaces of the crystallites. One of the consequences of such an action is to enable one to alter the catalytic reactivity in such a fashion so as to optimize the performance for a desired reaction pathway, while simultaneously suppressing the rate of detrimental side reactions, such as encapsulating forms of carbon deposition. Our strategy has centered around a study of the effect of introducing selected adatoms into the host metal and using the decomposition of ethylene to probe the manner by which the chemistry of the various faces of the crystallites is modified. In this paper a discussion of the information obtained from the use of a combination of controlled atmosphere and high resolution transmission electron microscopy techniques to study the impact of metal particle morphology on the characteristics of the carbon deposit will be given.
1. I N T R O D U C T I O N It should be recognized that the potential for carbon deposition exists in many systems in which hydrocarbons or carbon monoxide undergo decomposition over heated metal surfaces. Several reviews have highlighted the complex nature of carbonaceous deposits (1-6), which can be divided into three main types: amorphous, filamentous and graphitic shell-like structures. During a traditional routine analysis of a spent catalyst, these three forms of carbon would not be necessarily distinguished, but merely referred to collectively as "coke". Available evidence indicates that the amorphous carbon component is formed via condensation and polymerization reactions and this material originates from thermal processes. It is conceivable that a significant amount of hydrogen is retained in the deposit, however, as the temperature is raised dehydrogenation reactions will tend to reduce the hydrogen content. There is now a general consensus that the formation of the filamentous and graphitic forms of carbon require the participation of a catalytic entity. During the reaction, the metal particles adopt well defined geometries with the carbon-containing gas molecules being adsorbed and decomposed on certain faces of the metal, this process being followed by diffusion of carbon atoms through the catalyst particle
100 to precipitate at another set of faces in the form of a fibrous structure. It is well established that carbon diffusion through the particle is the rate determining step in the growth process. Depending on the chemical nature of the catalyst and the conditions at which the reaction is performed, assorted filamentous structures with various morphologies and different degrees of crystallinity can be produced (7,8). While the rudiments of the mechanism for the formation of the graphitic shell-like deposit have not received the same attention as that devoted to the generation of carbon f'llaments it is probable that many of the steps outlined above are also operative in the growth of this form of carbon (9,10). The major difference between the characteristics of the two catalytically formed types of deposit may lie in the number of the faces that perform the dissociative chemisorption of hydrocarbons compared to those that only allow for the carbon precipitation mode. The modification of the catalytic behavior of a given metal by the addition of controlled amounts of other metals has been used extensively in order to alter both the activity and selectivity as well as to control the deactivation of active surfaces with respect to poisoning and deactivation due to carbon deposition (11-15). It is the understanding of this latter aspect that has eluded researchers in this area and presents challenges to the various mechanisms that have been proposed to account for carbon deposition on metal surfaces. McCarty and coworkers (16,17) used temperature programmed reaction techniques to establish the existence of several forms of carbon on deactivated nickel catalysts. From these studies graphitic oveflayers and filamentous carbon growths were identified as being the most prevalent types associated with metals. The graphitic form of deposit tends to encapsulate the particle surface in contact with the reactant gas and thus normally results in rapid deactivation of the catalyst. In contrast, filamentous carbon is produced by a process in which carbon diffuses through the particle and precipitates at the rear faces, thereby leaving the exposed faces free to undergo continued reaction. The net result of this behavior is that the catalyst system can accumulate large amounts of carbon and maintain activity for prolonged periods of time (18). It is now being recognized that the incorporation of controlled amounts of certain non-metallic atoms into metals, which have hitherto been regarded as poisons, can actually function as catalyst promoters. This approach is predicated on the assumption that the poison atoms are preferentially chemisorbed on sites that are active for undesirable reactions, while those sites which perform the desired reactions are preserved in an unadulterated state (19,20). Previous work from this laboratory (21-23) has demonstrated that either pretreatment or continuous addition of 5 to 10 ppm H2S to iron, nickel or cobalt undergoing reaction with ethylene had a significant impact on the catalytic activity of these metals, particularly with respect to the enhancement in yields of carbon filaments. We have extended this investigation to cover the influence of chlorine on the same reactions (24). Careful poisoning with chlorine has been found to be a very effective method of altering the activity and selectivity of catalysts and it has been suggested that such behavior could in part be attributable to induced electronic perturbations in the metal (25). In catalytic reforming, the chlorine content derived from the metal precursor salt is thought to be directly related to the amount of carbon that accumulates on the catalyst (26). 2. E X P E R I M E N T A L 2.1. Materials Bimetallic powders consisting of combinations of iron, nickel, cobalt and were prepared by coprecipitation of the respective metal carbonates from metal solutions, Fe(NO3)3 9H20 (98%, Fisher Scientific), Co(NO3)2.6H20 (99% Scientific), Ni(NOa)E.6H20 (99% Fisher Scientific) and Cu(NO3)2 2.5H20 (99.2%,
copper nitrate Fisher Fisher
101 Scientific) using ammonium bicarbonate at room temperature and a pH of about 9.0, followed by oxidation to metal oxides and finally, reduction in 10% hydrogen/helium at 500 ~ for 20 h, as described previously (27). The reduced catalyst was cooled to room temperature under helium, then passivated by a 2% air/helium mixture for 1.0 h and stored in sealed containers. X-ray diffraction analysis was performed on all of the bimetallic powders at room temperature and only peaks corresponding to metallic iron, nickel, cobalt and copper were evident in these samples. It should be recognized, however, that upon heating to 600~ the phase diagrams for these mixed metal systems shows that in all cases alloy formation occurs. Pure iron, nickel, cobalt and copper powders were also prepared according to the above procedure. The gases used in this study, carbon monoxide (99.99%), hydrogen (99.999%), helium (99.99%) and ethylene (99.5%) were obtained from MG Industries and were used without further purification. Approximately 50 mg of each sample of all these powders were initially given a reduction treatment in 10% H2/He at 500~ and then reacted in a horizontal flow reactor system in the presence of either ethylene/hydrogen (4:1) or carbon monoxide/hydrogen (4:1) mixtures at temperatures over the range 450 to 800~ for a period of 2.0 h. Gas flow rates were maintained at 100 cc/min and regulated with MKS mass flow controllers. At the conclusion of each experiment the solid carbon product was carefully removed from the quartz reactor, weighed and then stored for subsequent structural analysis. In a final series of experiments, iron-nickel powder was reacted in the presence of ethylene/hydrogen (4:1) at temperatures in excess of 800~ in order to investigate the formation of shell-like deposits that are known to form under these conditions.
2.2 Techniques The details of the structural characteristics of individual constituents in the various carbon deposits were obtained by examination of a number of specimens from each experiment in a JEOL 100 CX transmission electron microscope that was fitted with a high resolution pole piece, capable of 0.18 nm lattice resolution. Suitable transmission specimens were prepared by applying a drop of an ultrasonic dispersion of the deposit in iso-butanol to a carbon support film. In many cases the solid carbon product was found to consist entirely of filamentous structures. Variations in the width of the filaments as a function of both catalyst composition and growth conditions were determined from the measurements of over 300 such structures in each specimen. In certain samples evidence was found for the existence of another type of carbonaceous solid, a shell-like deposit in which metal particles appeared to be encapsulated by graphitic platelet structures. Selected area electron diffraction studies were performed to ascertain the overall crystalline order of the carbon filaments and the shell-like materials produced from the various catalyst systems. The controlled atmosphere electron microscopy (CAEM) experiments were carried out in a modified JEOL 2000EXII TEM instrument (28). This instrument is equipped with a custom designed environmental cell, which accommodates a heating stage. With this arrangement it is possible to continuously observe changes in the appearance of a specimen as it undergoes reaction in a gas environment at temperatures up to 1000~ The dynamic events occurring during the reaction are captured on video-tape and replayed later for detailed analysis. We estimate that the point-to-point resolution achieved on the TV monitor is of the order of 0.4 nm under sufficiently stable conditions. A recent development with the technique is the capability of performing in-situ electron diffraction analysis of supported small particles to establish the chemical state of the reacting specimen (29). This technique was used to determine the morphological characteristics of both the pure metal and bimetallic particles supported on single crystal graphite surfaces. The samples used in these experiments were prepared by two methods: (a) single metal/graphite specimens were made by evaporation of the metal in the form of a wire from a tungsten
102 filament at 10 -6 Torr onto transmission sections of single crystal graphite; (b) graphite supported bimetallic specimens were produced by introducing the components mixed in the desired ratio onto the substrate medium, as an atomized spray from an aqueous solution of the respective metal nitrates. Prior to reaction in the hydrocarbon environment both these types of systems were pretreated in 1 Torr hydrogen at 400~ for 3 hours.
3. RESULTS AND DISCUSSION 3.1.
Dynamic Behavior of Graphite Supported Metal Particles
When samples of either the pure metals or bimetallics dispersed on single crystal graphite were examined in the CAEM following the initial treatment in hydrogen it was evident that the evaporated films had undergone nucleation to form discrete particles that were of the order of 2 nm in diameter and tended to adopt a spherical shape. When such specimens were subsequently heated in either 2.0 Torr ethylene/hydrogen or carbon monoxide/hydrogen mixtures some dramatic changes in both size and morphology were observed. For example, in the presence of an ethylene/hydrogen (4:1) mixture at temperatures approaching 500~ particles of iron-nickel started to undergo reconstruction from a globular to a square form. This aspect is shown in the schematic diagram, Figure 1a, which taken under reaction conditions. In experiments where the temperature was raised to temperatures in excess of 750~ these particles were observed to gradually transform and adopt a hexagonal morphology. Inspection of copper-iron particles when heated in a CO/H2 (4:1) reactant revealed that in this case, the particles acquired a rectangular morphology as the specimen temperature was increased to 475~ Figure lb. In a further example, coppercobalt particles exhibited a somewhat fascinating transformation when the system was heated to 525~ in an ethylene/hydrogen (4:1) mixture, the initial spherical-shaped particles transforming into well-defined fiat hexagonal-shaped crystallites, as seen in Figure l c. It should be mentioned that even on continued heating up to 650~ no carbonaceous deposits were formed at the very low pressures at which the CAEM experiments were performed with these particular gas mixtures.
(a)
(b)
(c)
Figure 1. Schematic representation of the observed morphological characteristics of various bimetallic particles during interaction with selected gas environments. (a) an Fe-Ni (5:5) particle undergoing reaction in C2Hn/H2 (4:1) at 500~ (b) a Cu-Fe (2:8) particle heated to 475~ in the presence of CO/H2 (4:1), and (c) a Cu-Co (1:3) particle treated in C2H4/H2 (4:1) at 525~ It was significant to find that in many of these systems the geometric shapes of the particles were not retained when the specimen was slowly cooled to room temperature and the reactant gas flow switched off. Based on these studies it is clear that under reaction
103 conditions metal particles can adopt well-defined faceted forms that are dependent not only on the nature of the supporting medium, but also chemical composition of the reactant gas. Experimental evidence indicates that it is highly probable that many of these features would not be revealed in a post-reaction electron microscopic examination, since the strength of the metal/support interaction is not always maintained in the absence of a reactant gas and particles appear to relax to the more energetically favorable form of a sphere under these circumstances. 3.2. Influence of metal particle morphology on the structural characteristics of carbon filaments.
Transmission electron microscopy examinations of the solid carbon produced from the interaction of ethylene/hydrogen or carbon monoxide/hydrogen with a number of pure metals and bimetallics containing copper mixed with iron, cobalt and nickel revealed that the deposit consisted almost entirely of filamentous carbon when such reactions were performed at temperatures up to 650~ The amount of solid material produced from the growth of this type of deposit is generally quite high and the presence of the carbon structure serves as a means of "freezing" the shape of the catalyst particle in its reactive state even when the specimen is cooled to room temperature and the reactant gas mixture removed from the system. This aspect can be seen very clearly in the set of electron micrographs, Figures 2 to 4, where the original shapes of the particles shown in the corresponding set of diagrams, Figures 1a to lb are preserved during the catalytic growth of carbon filaments.
lOOnm Figure 2. Appearance of a carbon filament and the associated "diamond" shaped Fe-Ni (5:5) catalyst particle after heating to 600~ in CzH4]H2 (4" 1) at 600~ Inspection of the conformational characteristics of the filaments produced from these three catalyst systems shows that in all three cases, the growth occurs from more than one face of the metal particle. Filaments generated from the interaction of copper-iron with C2H4/H2 (4:1) and iron-nickel particles with CO/H2 (4:1) grow via a hi-directional mode and tend to exhibit a high degree of crystalline order. In contrast, the structures created from the reaction of C2H4/H2 (4:1) with the hexagonal shaped copper-cobalt crystallites are multidirectional with several filaments emanating from a single catalyst particle. As with the previous systems, these carbon structures were also found to be highly crystalline in nature.
104
Figure 3. Appearance of a carbon filament generated from the interaction of Cu-Fe (2:8) with a CO/H2 (4:1) mixture at 600~ Note the geometric shape of the catalyst particle. . . . .
172~.-'.
:~ 9 '='~"
.~i~"'~ ~ ~ . .
.
:~'~,~
lOOnm Figure 4. Appearance of multi-directional filaments formed at the faces of an hexagonalshaped Cu-Co (1:3) particle after reaction in C2H4/H2 (4:1) at 575~
105 In a further series of experiments the filaments formed from these three catalyst systems were studied by high resolution transmission electron microscopy. From the lattice fringe images it was apparent that the structures consist of graphite platelets that are oriented in various directions with respect to the filament axis. A schematic representation showing the structural relationships between the catalyst particles and the precipitated graphite platelets formed during the growth of the filaments from the three systems is presented in Figure 5. It is apparent from these models that in the case of copper-iron/C2H4/H2 (4:1), Figure 5(a), the graphite platelets constituting the filaments adopt a "herring-bone" arrangement and under these circumstances two faces of the catalyst particle are responsible for the dissociation chemisorption of the hydrocarbon and four faces that participate in the precipitation of graphite. When the filaments are produced from the interaction of iron-nickel particles with CO/H2 (4:1), Figure 5b, the graphite platelets are stacked in the form of a "deck of cards" and examination of the associated catalyst particle suggests that at least four faces are involved in the decomposition of the reactant gases and precipitation of graphite occurs at only two faces. Finally, when C2Hn/H2 (4:1) is allowed to react with copper-cobalt several filaments are generated from each particle and the individual structures exhibit identical characteristics where the graphite platelets are aligned in a direction parallel to that of the face where the carbon precipitation step occurs, Figure 5c. Once again, it is possible that in this system there are two faces of the catalyst particle involved in the hydrocarbon adsorption and decomposition reaction and another set of six faces that are responsible for carbon deposition.
a
b
c
Figure 5. Schematic representation of the different arrangements of graphite platelets generated from the three systems shown in Figures 2 to 4, respectively. 3.3.
Formation of graphitic shell-like deposits on iron-nickel particles at >800~
Transmission electron microscope examination of the solid carbon produced on ironnickel after reaction in C2H4/H2 (4: I) revealed the existence of two types of material; carbon filaments and another type of carbonaceous solid, a shell-like deposit in which metal particles appeared to be encapsulated by graphitic platelet structures, Figure 6. This latter form tended to predominate at 825~ Close inspection of many examples of the shell-like deposit failed to reveal any definite correlation between the width of a given catalyst particle and that of the surrounding graphite structure. Inspection of the metal particles showed that they adopted a faceted outline, which showed a close correspondence to that of the carbon deposit that was generated at the catalyst surfaces. High resolution studies revealed that the platelets were very thin, as evidenced by the fact that it was possible to frequently observe the morphological features of the underlying substrate through the graphitic structures. It was also apparent that as one scanned across any of the platelets the electron density remained
106 relatively constant, suggesting that these structures were flat rather than spheroidal in nature. A further feature of note was the finding that the lattice fringes of the deposit were oriented in a direction parallel to the faces of the catalyst particles associated with these platelet structures and had a spacing of 0.34 nm, indicative of a highly graphitic material.
/
200nm ~ - , r
". . . .
~
........
~"~
Figure 6. Electron micrograph showing the shell-like appearance of graphite deposits that encapsulate iron-nickel particles when heated at temperatures of about 825~ in a C~Hn/H2 (4:1) mixture. As mentioned previously, the key steps and factors controlling the growth of the carbon filaments on metal particles are well understood. The range of crystalline order of the carbon deposit generated at the precipitating faces of the particle is controlled to a large degree by the extent of wetting exhibited between the metal and graphite. However, the geometric alignment of the precipitated graphite platelets in the filament structure as well as their degree of crystalline perfection is ultimately determined by the crystallographic orientation of the metal faces in contact with the solid carbon deposit (30-32). While the basics of the formation of the graphitic shell-like deposit have not received the same attention as that devoted to generation of carbon filaments it is probable that many of the steps outlined for the growth of these structures are also operative in the growth of the shell-like form of carbon. In recent years there have been reports of the existence of graphite shell-like structures on supported nickel and cobalt particles following reaction in CO at temperatures over the range 400 to 650~ (9,33). It was claimed that carbon "shells" were the exclusive form of deposit when hydrogen was not present in the gas phase (9). Furthermore, it was stressed that the thickness of the shell surrounding the metal appeared to reach a limiting thickness of about 30 graphite layers at which point the particles were deactivated. This
107 observation leads to the conclusion that the growth of graphite layers was not occurring from the surface of the metal, however, no alternative mechanism was suggested (9). One of the major features to emerge from the present work is the finding that no definite correlation exists between the thickness of the graphitic apron and the size of the associated catalyst particle. A further aspect revealed from this investigation is that the metal particles adopt a well defined faceted structure that appear to function as a template for the growth of graphite platelets. Previous work has indicated that during carbon deposition reactions, catalyst particles acquire well defined crystallographic orientations, where some of the faces will exclusively decompose the hydrocarbon whereas others will only precipitate carbon since they are unable to dissociate carbon-carbon bonds (34).
graphite platelets
(a)
(b)
Figure 7. Schematic rendition of a possible growth mechanism of the shell-like graphite deposits, where the catalyst particle shape changes, but the overall volume remains constant.
a
b
Figure 8. Schematic rendition of a possible growth mechanism of the shell-like graphite deposits, where the catalyst material undergoes a wetting and spreading action with the platelet structures and the particle is progressively depleted in size as the reaction proceeds.
108 Based on the observations of the current investigation we suggest two possible models that should be considered to account for the formation of the graphitic shell-like deposits. The first, which is outlined in the schematic diagram, Figure 7, assumes that during the graphite precipitation step the catalyst particles undergoes a progressive transformation in shape, whilst at the same time maintaining a constant volume. This condition is forced on the system since carbon is being continuously formed on the hydrocarbon decomposing faces, followed by dissolution and diffusion through the particle and eventually precipitating as rigid graphite platelets at other faces. Since the precipitation step imposes a constraint on the particle geometry at any given point in time, the only way for the process to continue in an uninterrupted manner is for the particle to progressively shrink in width in order to accommodate this restriction. A variation on this theme is presented in the model, Figure 8, where the only difference is that in this case, reorganization of the catalyst particle is accompanied by an overall decrease in volume. Indeed, the establishment of a strong interaction of the metal with the edges of the carbon will be manifested by a wetting and spreading action of material along the graphite edge regions. Under these circumstances, it is possible that the volume of the particle is progressively decreased due to the loss of metal as it leaves a monolayer coverage on the graphite edge regions and the catalyst particle can readily conform to the geometric limitations imposed by the platelet structures.
ACKNOWLEDGMENTS Financial support for this work was provided by the Department of Energy, Basic energy Sciences Grant No. DE-FG02-93ER14358.
REFERENCES
1. 2. 3. 4. 5. 6. 7. 8. 9. 10. 11. 12. 13. 14. 15.
L . J . E . Hofer, in "Catalysis" (P. H. Emmett, Ed.) Reinhold Publ. Co. 4 (1956) 373. H.B. Palmer, and C. F. Cullis, in "Chemistry and Physics of Carbon" (P. L. Walker, Jr., Ed.) Marcel Dekker, New York, 1 (1965) 265. J. R. Rostrup-Nielsen, "Steam Reforming Catalysts", Tekorisk Forlay A/S (Danish Technical Press), 1975. D.L. Trimm, Catal. Rev.-Sci. Eng. 16 (1977) 155. R. T. K. Baker, and P. S. Harris, in "Chemistry and Physics of Carbon" (P. L. Walker, Jr., and P. A. Thrower, Eds.) Marcel Dekker, New York, 14, (1978) 83. C.H. Bartholomew, Catal. Rev.-Sci. Eng. 24 (1982) 67. Baker, R. T. K. in "Carbon Fibers Filaments and Composites" (J. L. Figueiredo et al. Eds.) NATO ASI Series, Kluwer Academic Publ. Dordrecht, 177 (1990) 405. N . M . Rodriguez, J. Mater. Sci. 8 (1993) 3233. P.E. Nolan, D. C. Lynch, and A. H. Cutler, Carbon 32, (1994) 477. N. M. Rodriguez, M. S. Kim, F. Fortin, I. Mochida, and R. T. K. Baker, Appl. Catal. in press. J. H. Sinfelt, Accounts of Chem. Res. 10 (1977) 15. W. M. H. Sachtler, and R. A. van Santen, Adv. Catal. 26 (1977). 69 V. Ponec, Adv. Catal. 32 (1983) 149. M. J. Kelley, and V. Ponec, Prog. Surf. Sci. 11 (1981) 139. J. H. Sinfelt, "Bimetallic Catalysts", an Exxon Monograph, John Wiley & Sons, New York, (1983).
109 16. J. G. McCarty, and H. Wise, J. Catal. 57 (1979) 406. 17. J. G. McCarty, P. Y. Hou, D. Sheridan, and H. Wise, in "Coke Formation on Metal Surfaces" ACS Symposium Series 202 (L. J. Albright and R. T. K. Baker eds.) Washington D.C. (1982) p. 253. 18. N. M. Rodriguez, M. S. Kim, and R. T. K. Baker, J. Phys. Chem 98 (1994) 13108. 19. J. R. Rostrup-Nielsen, in "Catalyst Deactivation" (C. H. Bartholomew and J. B. Butt Eds.) Elsevier Sci. Publ. Amsterdam, p.85 (1991). 20. J. R. Rostrup-Nielsen, J. Catal. 85 (1984) 31. 21. M.S. Kim, N. M. Rodriguez, and R. T. K. Baker, J. Catal. 143 (1993) 449. 22. W. T. Owens, N. M. Rodriguez, and R. T. K. Baker, Catal. Today, 21 (1994) 3. 23. W. T. Owens, M. S. Kim, N. M. Rodriguez, and R. T. K. Baker, in "Catalyst Deactivation 1994", (B. Delmon and G. F. Froment, Eds.) Elsevier Sci. Publ. Amsterdam, p.191 (1994). 24. A. Chambers and R. T. K. Baker, J. Phys. Chem. in press 25. X. Wu, B. C. Gerstein, and T. S. King, J. Catal. 135 (1992) 68. 26. R. J. Verderone, C. L. Pieck, M. R. Sad, and J. M. Parera, Appl. Catal. 21 (1986) 239. 27. J. H. Sinfelt, J. L. Carter, and D. J. C. Yates, J. Catal. 24, (1972) 283. 28. N. M. Rodriguez, S. G. Oh, W. B. Downs, P. Pattabiraman, and R. T. K. Baker, Rev. Sci. Instrum. 61 (1990) 1863. 29. N. M. Rodriguez, S. G. Oh, R. A. Dalla-Betta, R. T. K. and Baker, J. Catal. 157 (1995) 676. 30. M. Audier, A. Oberlin, M. Oberlin, M. Coulon, and L. Bonnetain, Carbon 19 (1981) 217. 31. R. T. Yang, J. P. and Chen, J. Catal. 115 (1989) 52. 32. M. S. Kim, N. M. Rodriguez, and R. T. K. Baker, J. Catal. 134 (1992) 253. 33. M. Audier and M. Coulon, Carbon 23, (1985) 317. 34. N. M. Rodriguez, A. Chambers, and R. T. K. Baker, Langmuir 11 (1995) 3862.
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
~
Elsevier Science B.V. All rights reserved
Catalyst Deactivation 1997 C.H. Bartholomewand G.A. Fuentes, editors
111
Self-Poisoning and A g i n g of Pd-Ag/A1203 in S e m i - H y d r o g e n a t i o n o f 1,3Butadiene: Effects o f Surface Inhomogeneity Caused by H y d r o c a r b o n a c e o u s Deposits A. Sarkany Institute of Isotopes of the Hungarian Academy of Sciences, H-1525, Budapest, Hungary Effects of hydrocarbonaceous deposits have been investigated in hydrogenation of 1,3butadiene over Pd-Ag/ALO3 catalysts. Studies on the effect of various treatments on selfpoisoned samples revealed very different behavior of the surface deposits. Because of hydrogen's low surface fugacity, hydrogen treatment was not sufficient to remove surface species at T<373 K. Vacuum or 02 treatment increased the activity of the self-poisoned samples. The observation has been interpreted in terms of surface restructuring of the firmly held species. Deliberate poisoning - amount of deposits 1-20 mg/gcat- increased the selectivity of n-butane formation. Presence of deposits seems to decrease the effective surface concentration of butadiene. The results have been interpreted as slow diene transport allowing saturation of n-butenes on a certain fraction of sites. 1. INTRODUCTION Pd-based catalysts are widely used in selective hydrogenation of acetylene in ethene or butadiene in C4 alkene cuts [1]. The objective of hydrogen addition is to decrease the concentration of these highly unsaturated hydrocarbons to ppm level without the hydrogenation of alkenes. Because of low HJHC ratios and the high reactivity of acetylene (diene), formation of oligomers and surface deposits is almost inevitable in these processes. Considerable attention has been focused on the understanding of the surface composition of the working surface and the role of hydrocarbonaceous materials in the hydrogenation process. Surface oligomers [2-6] and various multiply bonded so-called spectator species [79] are proposed to participate in formation and stabilization of reacting sites [10], and in altering hydrogen-storing and hydrogen-transfer capacities [ 11,12]. They seem to modify the strength of diene (acetylene) complexation relative to alkene, alter the intrinsic selectivity of acetylene hydrogenation and create hydrogen transfer sites on the support [2,4,11,12]. The present paper investigates the effect of hydrocarbonaceous materials on hydrogen addition using gas phase hydrogenation of 1,3-butadiene as probe reaction. Two different types of deposit formation were tested: (i) initial stage of deposit formation which occurs during self-poisoning and (ii) aged stage when the catalyst is deliberately covered with oligomers. 2. EXPERIMENTAL
2.1. Catalyst preparation and characterization Catalysts used in the present study are listed in Table 1. Pd-Ag supported catalysts (Catalyst A, C and D) were prepared using low surface area alpha alumina.(A13980-T and
112 A1 1008-T, respectively). The support was impregnated with a solution of Pd(NO3)2 and AgNO3. The precursor was dried at 370 K overnight and reduced in stream of hydrogen at 723 K. Pd and Ag content of the precursors were determined by X-ray fluorescence. Table 1 Catalysts prepared and results of characterization Cat. wt%Pd A 0.11 C 1 D 1 Pd powder
wt%Ag 0.17 0.5 0
S(BET) 4 5.5 5.2 7.7
Vp(cc) 0.27 0.3 0.3 -
CO (umol/gcat) 0.44 3.5 12.1 183
Palladium powder was prepared by mixing solutions of PdC12 and hydrazin and adding solution of NH,OH. The sample was carefully washed and treated in 02 at 523 K in order to stabilize the sample. The reduced precursors were characterized by CO (H2) adsorption measurements performed in a small reactor attached to a quadrupole mass spectrometer and UHV system. The reduced samples were saturated with CO (H2) at 298 K (1.33 kPa CO), the reactor was then evacuated (10 "3Pa) and the next thermal desorption test was applied. The experimental setup was also used to follow hydrogen and hydrocarbon desorption from aged catalysts. The carbon content of the poisoned samples (self-poisoning and deliberate poisoning at T>373 K in diene or acetylene)was measured by TPO (1.3 kPa 02, flow and/or static systems, respectively; CO2 (m/z=44) and CO (m/z=28) were detected by mass spectrometer (AEI MS 20 and Balzers QMG 511). DSC thermograms (Perkin Elmer DSC-4) were recorded in 02 stream (40 K/min ramp from ambient to 773 K). Formation of Pd-Ag alloy (Cat. C) and the presence of PdCx phase after poisoning were analyzed by X-ray diffraction. CuKa X-ray powder diffractograms were recorded with a Guinier camera equipped with curved quartz monocromator. 2.2 Conditions of hydrogenation Hydrogenation of 1,3-butadiene (BD) was tested in a static circulation system (batch reactor) of 0.165 dm 3 total volume attached to a high vacuum system [13]. Gas circulation was accomplished with a pump driven with solenoid coils. The pumping speed at atmospheric pressure was 2.52 dm3/min. Hydrogen was purified by diffusion through Pd-Ag thimbles. Deuterium (99.7 %) was purchased from Linde. Diene was distilled prior to use and stored in a bulb. It contained 0.12 % cis-2-butene which was considered in the calculation of the activity and the selectivity values. The experiments were performed at 284 K in the presence of 1.33 kPa BD and only 2.99 kPa H2 to facilitate poisoning of Pd sites. Selectivity was defined in accordance with previous papers [3,13]; rate of product formation was divided with the rate of diene consumption. All through the text conversion refers to transformation of butadiene. Rate is given in %/min units. Conversion was measured as a function of time; in each experiment the initial rate was calculated from the inlet and the first two analysis at <5% conversions, subsequent rate was determined from the next three measurements and we also presented an "average"value calculated from the last point and the inlet composition. Transformation of BD was measured up to 55 % conversion. The catalysts were aged by performing successive hydrogenations. Between activity tests standard regeneration treatment was applied unless otherwise stated. The standard treatment consisted of the following steps: first the hydrocarbon was frozen out in a liquid N2 trap, and next the hydrogen partial pressure was increased to 3.3 kPa and circulated at 284 K for 20 min. After that the reactor was separated from the pumping part, the liquid nitrogen trap
113
was removed, the hydrogen-hydrocarbon mixture was evacuated from the pumping part and finally the hydrogen was removed from the reactor tube before beginning a new experiment. 3. RESULTS Successive experiments performed at 284 K with H/BD=2.2 mixtures resulted in severe poisoning of the reaction sites in spite of hydrogenation (standard treatment) between the experiments. Typical results measured on Cat. A are presented in Fig. 1.
lO01
E v
lOt
~f
A B
I 1_
+'
C D '
E
+_
'
+ 1
0
n 11 0".'011
lllli'i+llllI, I IIII|
h.
tl.
" "I Jl w3
9
================================
10
20
Successive experiments
30
Figure 1. Rate of BD consumption in successive runs (H/BD=2.2, T=284 K, 54.3 mg cat). Between rtms Cat. A was hydrogenated at 284 K with the exception of the experiments indicated by the arrows. A: O5 treatment at 388 K, B: evacuation at 383 K, C: H2 at 371 K for 40 min, D: H~ at 429 K for 10 min, E: evacuation at 403 K for 10 min. Symbols: o initial rate; FI subsequent rate; O "average". Under the reported conditions the activity stabilized at about 1% of the initial value. Replacement of H2 with D2 (D2 in Fig. 1) decreased the rate of hydrogen addition, and for self-poisoned (stabilized) samples R"/R~ for consumption of butadiene was observed to be 2.3-2.4 at 284 K. 02 (arrow A) or vacuum (arrow B) treatment at T<413 K of the selfpoisoned samples increased the hydrogenation activity as shown in Fig. 1. Smaller effects were observed upon H2 treatments (arrows C and D). Similar aging curves were observed with other catalysts. The selectivities of n-butanes over Cat A and C were initially less than 0.05% at 40-55% conversion and were not affected by the above treatments. Over Cat D and Pd powder 0.5-1% n-butane appeared in the first experiments but their selectivities gradually decreased with aging. The hydrocarbon content of the samples were measured after H2 treatment at 298 K. The C/CO,d, ratios measured (the number of successive runs are in brackets) are as follows: Cat. A (5) 3.3, Cat. B (31) 5.8, Cat. C (5) 2.7. After '5-10 successive experiments further aging of the self-poisoned samples was slow; therefore we deliberately poisoned our aged catalysts with acetylene and diene in the absence of H2 at T>373 K. Typical results for Cat. A are presented in Figure 2; results for Cat. C are in Table 2. As shown in Figure 2 poisoning at T>373 K first increases the hydrogenation activity. A further interesting feature of the experiments is that after deliberate poisoning the n-butane selectivity, S(nB)%, gradually increases and reaches 4-5% over Cat A (Figure 2), 10-11%
114
A~
B
C
D
m
E 0.1 O
IB..
ill
0.01 6 II1 v
o .................. j,,,,,,, .....
...... IIIIII.
10 30 50 Number of successive experiments Figure 2. Effect of diene poisoning on hydrogenation activity (Hz/BD=2.2, T=284 K, 51.4 mg Cat. A). A: evacuation at419 K; B: acetylene treatment at 433 K for 4 hr; C: BD at 455 K for 17 hr and D: BD at 492 K for 17 hr. Table 2 Hydrogenation of 1,3-butadiene and 1-butene over Cat. C (10.3 mg cat, 1.33 kPa HC and 3 kPa H2, T=284 K) Exp
EBD(kJ/mol)
RI-B/RBD
R"/RD(BD)
R"/RD(nB) S(nB)%
5-11
46+13.2
3.2-2.8
2.2-2.4
-
0.04
39-48 49-53* 57-63 65-72 77-87 91-100
41+6.6 40 n.m. n.m. 33+3.3 22+5.4
0.96-0.71 n.m. n.m. n.m. 0.18-0.26 0.09-0.12
1.6-1.48 1.52 1.48-1.52 1.5-1.32 1.46-1.35 n.m.
1.2-1.1 1.35 1.16-1.21 1.28-1.06 1.22-1.20 n.m.
6.5-7.5 6.6 8.2 6.3 9.9-7.6 11.1
=,_
m
5-11, self-poisoning; (38) acetylene (409 K, 17 hr); (56) acetylene (423 K, 15 hr); (65) H2 (467 K, 12 hr); (76) BD (461 K, 16.5 hr); (90) BD (488 K, 19 hr); n.m.: not measured; *experiments at 302 K
115 Table 3 Deposit formation from 1,3-butadiene over Pd catalysts (8-10.5 kPa BD). S(nB)% was measured at 284 K (HJBD=2.2, 1.33 kPa BD). Catal.
T/K
Cat. A Cat C.
t/hour
487 407 446 489 407 487* Cat. D 407 443 489 Pd-black 391 433 *-acetylene treatment
1.5",
H/C
21 21 21 18 21 21 21 21 18 67 21
1.38 1.32 1.31 1.26 1.32 1.15 1.12 1.11 1.03 1.12
mol C/gcat
mg dep/~cat
S(nB)%
1.1xl0 4 1.7x10 4 2.4xl 0 .4 3.2x 10-4 1.7X10-4 5.0xl 0 4 1.5xl 0 -3 2.0x10 3 1.8x10 -3 5.9x10 -4 1.6x10 -3
1.4 2.3 3.1 5.1 2.3 6.1 20.3 26.5 24.2 7.8 20.9
4.7 1.7 n.m. 6.7 1.7 8.8 10.1 15.3 13.5 n.m. n.m.
p/i
QMS: H2x1072 / / / ~ ~ I I
g 1.o ._~
I
l
r
--= 0.5
I
5 .......
373
573 T/K
773
773
9
4..i
~.~ ~ ~
--
\
9#"
I 373
X
I
I
573 T/K
,
I
-,,.
I
773
Figure 3. TPD of hydrogen over Cat. C 1- Figure 4. DSC thermograms in 02 (40 regenerated sample (02 at 623 K and H2 at K/min). 1-Pd black (393 K, 4 hr); 2 Cat. C 713 K); 2- after BD poisoning at 489 K for (489 K, 18 hr); 3-Cat C. (489 K, 18 hr) after 18 hr (see Table 3). He at 675 K 4-Pd black (433 K, 21 hr) and 5Cat. D (489 K 18 hr). over Cat. C and 10-15% over Cat D (Tables 2 and 3). The presence of foulant decreases the consumption of 1-butene to a greater extent than hydrogenation of diene; the RI_B/RBDratios are included in Table 2. Over Cat A R,.B/RBDis 2.1 and 0.11 in experiments 9-10 and 59-60, respectively. The activation energy of hydrogenation (BD consumption) also decreases (see Table 2). Over Cat. A the following values are observed (number of run in brackets): 48+8 (27-30), 36+6 (42-45) and 32+4 kJ/mol (55-58). After these experiments the carbon content of the samples was 1.1 mg/gcat on Cat A and 7.4 mg/gcat on Cat C.
116 Data on the formation of carbonaceous materials from diene and acetylene over 373 K and selectivity of n-butane in butadiene hydrogenation (H2/BD=2.2, 1.33 kPa BD, 284 K) are collected in Table 3. The hydrogen content of the deposits was calculated from the amount of the self-hydrogenated products in the gas phase. Reaction of 1,3-butadiene was accompanied with formation of n-butenes whereas in reaction of acetylene 1,3-butadiene was the principal product. Hydrogen content of the deposits was also measured by TPD technique. Desorption of H2 is presented in Figure 3 measured on Cat. C before (1) and after BD poisoning at 489 K for 18 hr (2). Typical DSC curves with diene poisoned catalysts are presented in Figure 4. Over Pd black a single exothermic peak appears between 408-498 K. Over supported samples the high temperature peak (Tmax553-573 K) can be attributed to oligomers on support sites. XRD measurements were performed with Cat C, D and Pd powder treated with butadiene (4-8 kPa) at 453-473 K for 4-17 hr. The diffraction pattern for Cat C has not indicated any convincing changes in the position of Pd-Ag diffractions. Solution of carbon in Pd (Cat D. and Pd powder) resulted in an expansion of the Pd lattice. XRD lines attributable to PdCx phase could be discerned at theta values: "19.538, "22.718, "33.117, *39.763, "41.999. It is intriguing that the dissolution of carbon in Pd was accompanied with only trace CH4 formation. 4. DISCUSSION In the present experiments two rather different stages of catalyst poisoning are reported as indicated by the amount of hydrocarbon left on the surface in course of self-poisoning and after deliberate poisoning with butadiene or acetylene at T>373 K. After 5-8 experiments the hydrogenation activity reached steady state and the hydrocarbon coverage (number of carbon atoms on CO chemisorption sites) was 3.3-5.8 on Cat. A and 2.7 on Cat. C. The deliberate poisoning in the presence of butadiene and acetylene above 373 K further increased the amount of deposit and after completing the experiments it reached 1.1 mg/gcat over Cat. A and 7.4 mg/gcat over Cat. C. Assuming a density of oligomers of ca. 0.8 g/ml at 294 K, the thickness of hydrocarbon layer over BET surface corresponds to about 0.3 nm on Cat. A and 1.7 nm over Cat. C. At such a high hydrocarbon loading the metal surface (or a fraction of it) cannot be reached directly from the gas phase and thus the transport hindrance of the reactants cannot be avoided. The self-poisoning experiments have confirmed that hydrogen treatment at 284 K between the experiments is not sufficient to restore the initial activity. We assume that hydrogen's low surface fugacity is the main reason that the surface is covered by multiply bonded species [9-12] which are "end attached" (butylidyne, 3-butenylidyne) or "flat lying" over metal atoms (di-sigma, quad-sigma, di-sigma/pi) although formation of surface oligomers cannot be entirely disclosed [8]. Formation of C8 oligomers was not detected in our hydrogenations. This result however does not exclude the limited formation of high molecular weight oligomers and their presence on Ag sites or on the support. After 5-6 runs the activity usually stabilized at about 1% of the initial activity. We assmne that the working sites involve Pd atoms of low coordination number on which the accumulation of deposits is prevented by the ease of hydrogen dissociation. This assumption is supported by the rate of diene hydrogenation and the sticking coefficient for hydrogen which are higher on the more open (110) than on the (111) surfaces of Pd [ 14,15]. One of the intriguing observations of the present experiments is that hydrogen treatment of the self-poisoned catalysts (see arrows C and D in Figure 1) is less effective in the regeneration of the active surface than for example the vacuum treatment. In principle both 02 and vacuum treatments facilitate hydrogen loss, desorption and/or surface polymerization in the adsorption phase. We assume that the above processes result in restructuring of the surface hydrocarbons on the metal sites creating thereby sites for hydrogen dissociation. Although our assumption requires spectroscopic verification the TPO measurements have shown that formation of CO2 starts around 373 K but the amount of CO2 desorbed is only
117 about 2-3% of total hydrocarbon coverage. The activity increase is apparently connected with small changes in the concentration of free surface sites. In separate measurements (selfpoisoned Cat. C. heated up to 477 K in a reactor attached directly to quadrupole mass spectrometer) desorption of hydrogen, diene and n-butenes could be detected. Selfhydrogenation or reversal of sigma bonded species into pi-olefin bonded ones are the possible routes for the formation of these hydrocarbons. One might also propose that formation of carbon atoms and their migration into the Pd lattice during high temperature evacuation or hydrocarbon treatments above 373 K provide a route to site regeneration. Formation of PdCx (x<0.15)supersaturated carbon solution in course of deliberate poisoning could be unambiguously detected with Cat D and Pd powder [16,17]. However, absorption of carbon might not be significant in Pd-Ag alloys. In fact, in Cat C we could not detect any PdCx phase. Deliberate poisoning at T>373 K produces unsaturated surface deposits (Table 3) present both on metal particles and support. The molC/gcat values in Table 3 (compare Cat C and D) show that the presence of Ag inhibits formation of deposits. Over both Pd black and Cat D the H/C ratio is less than over Pd-Ag samples. As evidenced by DSC thermograms a significant part of the foulant is present on the support. In contrast to the samples used in acetylene hydrogenations in the present DSC thermograms an initial endothermic peak indicative of the evaporation of low molecular weight oligomers was not observed. Treatment of fouled samples in He decreased the intensity of the high temperature DSC peak which can be interpreted as the evaporation of the oligomers from support sites (compare (2) and (3) in Figure4). Inspection of Figure 2 shows that the presence of oligomers does not result in drastic loss of hydrogenation activity. Actually after the first acetylene or diene poisoning experiments the hydrogenation activity was higher than after self-poisoning. Upon repeated poisoning the activity decreased (see arrows C and D in Figure 2) due to the accumulation of deposits on the catalyst. We assume that the onset of transport control appears in this region. The effect of deposits on the distribution of n-butenes was not significant. Accumulation of deposits apparently markedly affects the formation of n-butane. The selectivity of n-butane increases gradually after diene treatments and finally reaches 5.5 % over Cat. A (Figure 2) and 10-11% over Cat. C (Table 2) which is a tremendous increase if one considers that in the self-poisoning experiments at low conversions (<5%) n-butane can not be detected at all and at 50-65% conversions its selectivity is still less than 0.05%. In previous studies on hydrogenation of acetylene in ethene it has been concluded [2,4] that ethane forms mainly from acetylene but with time on stream due to activation of some special sites hydrogenation of ethene takes place even in the presence of acetylene. Returning to the present study the hydrogenation rate of 1-butene was observed to decrease to a larger extent than the hydrogenation of diene (see R,_JRBD in Table 2). Over fresh catalyst C the above ratio is about 4.5-4.2. After self-poisoning (experiments 9-11) the observed ratio is 3.2-2.8. On catalyst poisoned deliberately by BD and acetylene treatments the ratio is only 0.09-0.12 (experiments 92-95). Similar results were observed over Cat A. This suppression of 1-butene hydrogenation assures that in the presence of butadiene n-butane will not form in any appreciable amount from n-butenes desorbed into the gas phase. It requires further investigations to decide whether the decreasing R,_B/R~D ratio is the consequence of a very different flux (transport rate) of diene and 1-butene through the oligomers (which is unlikely) or that surface sites are less available for 1-butene due to its small complexation strength as observed over self-poisoned Pd-Ni/Nb205 catalysts [ 18]. The drastic increase of n-butane selectivity upon diene or acetylene treatments at T>373 K suggests formation of some special sites on the initially highly selective surface which favor over-hydrogenation of butadiene. Our TPD measurements show (Figure 3) that the foulant supplies only a very limited amount of hydrogen at 284 K. It is tempting to attribute n-butane forming sites to Pd atoms modified by subsurface carbon atoms. It is not obvious, however, why these sites are not present after vacuum treatment of the self-poisoned samples at T>423 K. Formation of n-butane can be accounted for if one assumes that the
118 formation of this product is controlled by transport limitation rather than by the appearance of some special sites which have excellent hydrogen availability and favor the formation of carbene type intermediates. The latter species are proposed precursors in the reaction route leading to n-butane [5]. The appearance of transport limitation is supported by the significant decrease of the apparent activation energy of hydrogenation both over Cat. A (from 48 kJ/mol to 32 kJ/mol) and over Cat. C (from 46 kJ/mol (self-poisoned sample) to 22 kJ/mol. Replacement of hydrogen with deuterium only slightly affected the rate of n-butane formation: R"/RDwas observed to be 1.1-1.2 for n-butane formation and 2.4-1.3 for diene hydrogenation. The results might be interpreted in such a way that due to transport control equilibrium effects compensate for kinetic effects. We assume that the oligomer film itself induces inhomogeneity in the working of the reaction sites. As a consequence of slow diene transport through the oligomers the surface fugacity of diene becomes low, consequently, nbutenes formed by hydrogen uptake are not readily displaced by diene molecules on a certain fraction of sites. Apparently, there is sufficient hydrogen on these sites. One would expect that the solubility of hydrogen in the oligomer layer is less than that of diene [ 19]. It is not clear however how these unknown values are compensated by the transport (diffusion) coefficients and how these values are affected if the oligomers are high molecular weight molecules.
Acknowledgments: The financial support of the Grant OTKA (T 017047 and T 019128) is gratefullyacknowledged. REFERENCES 1. 2. .
4. 5. 6. 7. 8. 9. 10. 11. 12. 13. 14. 15. 16. 17. 18. 19.
J-P. Boitiaux, J. Cosyns, M. Derrien and G. Leger, Hydrocarbon Processing, (1985)51. W.T. McGown, C. Kemball, D.A. Whan and M.S. Scurrel, J.Chem. Soc. Faraday Trans. I., 73 (1977) 632. A. Sarkany, A.H. Weiss, T. Szilagyi and P. Sandor, Appl. Catal., 12 (1984) 373. A. Sarkany, A.H. Weiss and L. Guczi, Appl. Catal., 12 (1984) 373. M. Primet, M. E1 Azhar and M. Guenin, Appl. Catal., 58 (1990) 241. S.D. Jackson and N.J. Casey, J.C.S. Faraday Trans., 91 (1995) 3269. T.P. Beebe and J.T. Yates, Jr., J. Am. Chem. Soc., 108 (1986) 663. T.J. Campione and J.G. Ekerdt, J. Catal., 102 (1986) 64. M.A. Chesters, C. Cruz, P. Gardner, E.M. McCash, P. Pudney, G. Shadid and N. Sheppard, J.Cem. Soc. Faraday Trans., 86 (1990) 2757. I. Yasumori, S. Moriki, I. Kojima and Y. Inoue in Proc. 6th Intern. Congr. Catal., London 1976, The Chemical Society, London, Vol.1, 1977, p. 139. S.J. Thomson and G. Webb, J. Chem. Soc., Chem. Commun., (1976) 526. A.S. A1-Ammar and G. Webb, J. Chem. Soc. Faraday Trans., I, 74 (1978) 1900. A. Sarkany, G. Stefler and J.W. Hightower, Appl. Catal. A, 127 (1995) 966. J. Massardier, J.C. Bertolini and A. Renouprez, in Proc. 9th Int. Congr. Catal., Calgary, Vol.3, 1988, p. 122. R.J. Behm, K. Christmann and G. Ertl, Surf. Sci., 99 (1980) 320. J. Stachurski and A. Frackiewicz, J. Less Comm. Met., 108 (1985) 249. S. Ziemecki, G. Jones, D. Swartzfager, J. Less Comm. Met., 131 (1987) 157. A. Sarkany, Z. Schay, Gy. Stefler, L. Borko and J.W. Hightower, Appl. Catal. A, 124 (1995) L181. R.H. Perry and C.H. Chilton (eds.), Chemical Engineer's Handbook, 5th Ed. McGraw-Hill Publ., New York, 1974.
~
Elsevier Science B.V. All rights reserved
Catalyst Deactivation 1997 C.H. Bartholomew and G.A. Fuentes, editors
119
I n f l u e n c e o f the S u p p o r t o n the D e a c t i v a t i o n o f N i c k e l Z e o l i t e Catalysts D u r i n g the C o n v e r s i o n o f P h e n y l a c e t y l e n e E.D. Gamas, and I. Schifter Gerencia Transformaci6n de Energ6ticos, Subdirecci6n de Protecci6n Ambiental Instituto Mexicano del Petr61eo, Eje Central L~izaro CS_rdenas 152, Col. San Bartolo Atepehuacan M6xico, D.F., 07730 M6xico The low-temperature (20~ deactivation by coke of zeolite-supported nickel catalysts was studied. Using the hydrogenation of phenylacetylene as a model reaction, channel dimension was found to affect both the loss of catalyst activity and the distribution of nickel particles on the active surface; activity was found to decrease in the following order: ZSM5>HUSY>Hmordenite. Selectivity'curves as well as temperature-programmed reduction runs show that the majority (95%) of the nickel particles is deposited on the outside of the channel network of HZSM5 support while for Hmordenite and HUSY supports the majority of the nickel is found inside the channels. In spite of coke being formed at low reaction temperature, temperatures as high as 790~ were required for its removal. Both Hmordenite and HZSM5 also contained substantial quantities of reactive coke that burned at lower temperature, while the HUSY contained substantial quantities of high-temperature coke. 1. I N T R O D U C T I O N One of the major problems in the operation of industrial catalytic processes is the loss of activity and selectivity due to the deactivation of the catalysts by coke. It is also a well known fact that "coke" represents a combination of different carbonaceous materials whose structure depends on the operation conditions of the reaction and on the nature of the catalyst itself. Although most processes involving catalyst deactivation by coke operate at temperatures above 300~ it is also possible to have catalyst deactivation by coke formation even for reactions that occur at ambient temperatures (20~176 [ 1,2]. The nature of coke formed at low temperature must be expected to vary in nature from that of coke formed at higher temperatures. It is generallyagreed that coke is formed via polymerization of reactions of unsaturated hydrocarbons chains. In order to test the influence of steric effects, the effects of acidity and the location of the supported metal, in this work the hydrogenation of phenylacetylene was used to study the deactivation by coke of nickel catalysts based on zeolite supports. Three zeolites were chosen as supports: ZSM-5, ultrastable Y and mordenite; all three zeolites were in their acid form. The ZSM-5 sample (Surface area = 402 m2/g, SiO2/A1203 = 42) was synthesized following procedure #23 outlined by Argauer and Landlot [3]. The USY sample used was a CP100-35 zeolite from Valfour USA (Surface area - 600 m /2 g , SiO2/A1203 = 6.5). Mordenite was obtained from purified samples of a natural mordenite from Tamaulipas, M6xico (Surface area - 495 mE/g, SiO2/AI203 = 5.91). The low temperature reaction as presented in this study yields carbonaceous deposits that required temperatures as high as 790~ for their removal from the catalysts. Nickel seems to be located in the intemal channels as well as on the surface of the supports.
120 Studies of catalysts deactivation by coke are abundant in the literature; most of them are usually conducted at high temperatures (around 500~ using metal catalysts supported on oxides with low surface area such as silica, aluminas or silica-alumina [2 and references therein]. The deactivation by coke of zeolite catalysts has also been studied and such studies have mostly been done for high temperature reactions such as the conversion of n-hexane or the isomerization of xylenes [2,4]. However, low temperature coke formation (20-25~ combining the effect of high acidity and size specificity for a high coking component such as nickel, has not yet been considered from the point of view of the presence of compounded effects of crystalline structure and location of metal particles. 2. E X P E R I M E N T A L Nickel was deposited by impregnation of zeolite powders using the incipient wetness method with a 3% wt solution of Ni(NO3) 2 96H20 (Baker Analyzed). The solids were dried at 100~ in air for 24 hours and calcined in flowing air (2.4 l/h) at 500~ for 2 hours; the nickel content of all samples was 2.5% wt. Before reaction the catalysts were prereduced in flowing hydrogen (2.0 I/h) at 500~ for 2 hours. Conversion of phenylacetylene [Merck, 97.8% wt] was conducted in a continuous microreactor system using 0.05 g of catalyst at a temperature of 20~ and atmospheric pressure. The feed consisted of hydrogen (1.8 1/min) saturated with liquid phenylacetylene at a temperature of 12~ (3.40x10-~ g-mole/h of phenylacetylene). The solids were characterized by X-ray diffraction using a Siemmens D-500 diffractometer equipped with a copper anode and a nickel filter. The deposition of carbon was studied by thermogravimetric analysis (TGA) using a Perkin-Elmer 1700 TGA analyzer. For the TGA runs the sample was heated at 10~ in air (2.0 l/h) from ambient temperature (20~ to 850~ the procedure was repeated to eliminate the effect of adsorbed water. The effect of the support on the reducibility of nickel was measured by temperatureprogrammed reduction (TPR). Samples were pretreated in air at 10~ from ambient temperature to 500~ After purging the lines with helium and cooling the reactor, the reduction process was initiated from ambient temperature to 1000~ at heating rate of 10~ in a flow of 2.0 1/min of 5.0% wt hydrogen in argon. The consumption of hydrogen by the sample was evaluated in a Gow Mac 550 gas chromatograph equipped with a thermal conductivity detector. 3. R E S U L T S AND D I S C U S S I O N Structural characterization of the solids by X-ray diffraction showed that the materials ZSM-5 and USY zeolites studied had a high crystallinity, while a mordenite structure was observed for the natural zeolite; traces of clinoptilolite were observed in this sample. The reaction studied follows the stoichiometric path shown below:
~ ~ ~ . ~ C-- CH "j H2
-- CH2 CH+
CH2- CH3
The results of catalyst testing runs are shown in Figures 1 and 2. With a critical molecular size of 0.5-0.55 nm for all three molecules involved in the reaction [5], the influence of pore dimensions is clearly seen as nickel deposited on a ZSM-5 support (average channel size of 0.55 nm [6]) does not deactivate rapidly, while nickel supported on USY zeolite (average channel size of 0.77 nm [6]) and nickel on mordenite (average channel size of 0.68 nm [6] )
121
have lower initial conversions and deactivate rapidly. Given the low reaction temperature (low molecular excitation) the possibility of having a dynamic molecular diameter for molecular diffusion of reactant into the channels of the zeolites cannot be expected.
40.00 NV[ES
30.00 20.00 10.00
-
Ni/HMor~,~ 0.00
~
T
_ "
i
10
0
-
9
-
20
-
30
40
Time, min Figure 1. Conversion of phenylacetylene for nickel supported on ZSM5, USY and mordenite zeolites.
15.00 O A
10.00
5.00
A
A
-
-
[]
0.00 0
v
A w
m
m
--
9"
10
.
tin, v
A
A
m
m
m
_
~
20
_ytmZSM_...~ Ni/USY m
m
30
40
Time, min Figure 2. Selectivity ratio of styrene to ethylbenzene during phenylacetylene.
the conversion
of
Due to the close match of molecular size of reactants and products with the size of the channels for the supports used, it should be expected that for the smaller-pore ZSM-5 support the reaction takes place outside of the channel network, while for larger-pore USY and mordenite the reaction is more likely to take place inside the channels and cages where the acid sites are not only of stronger acidity but their population is also greater; this results in a greater coke producing activity in comparison with that of external acid sites. The ZSM-5
122 support exerts therefore a reactant selectivity to diffusion which is reflected in the low deactivation observed (see Figure 1). The loss of activity due to coke deposition also has an effect upon the selectivity of the reaction. As seen in Figure 2, for the ZSM5 support a constant selectivity ratio styrene/ethylbenzene is observed; this is consistent with the conversion vs. time curve in Figure 1, which remains almost constant independent of the amount of coke deposited. The constant ratio styrene/ethylbenzene of approximately 2.7 indicates that, for Ni/ZSM5, 75% of the molecules of phenylacetylene go through a single step of adsorption on hydrogenation sites (nickel sites) located on the external surface of the zeolite, i.e., the greater amount of nickel particles are deposited on the outside of the cavities of the crystalline support. The temperature-programmed reduction (TPR) curve for Ni/ZSM5 is given in Figure 3. Four main peaks of hydrogen consumption are seen (maxima at 440, 558, 676 and 1020~ respectively); the first peak (maximum at 440~ corresponds to a typical reduction of supported nickel oxide [7], i.e., supported nickel oxide present on the outer surface of the zeolite. The ratio of areas for the peak with a maximum at 440~ with respect to the peaks observed above 550~ is 1.58; thus, the TPR data suggest that over 50% of the nickel oxide is located on the external surface of the support. One can conclude therefore that the TPR peaks at temperatures above 500~ may correspond to the reduction of nickel particles located inside the cavities of the zeolite, some in the channels and some in the cages of the structure. This conclusion is supported by the observation that the peaks attributed to the reduction of nickel oxide are mostly found at temperatures above 500~ for zeolites with the greater channel opening (Figures 4 and 5). The larger size of the cavities should facilitate nickel nitrate diffusion into the cavities for mordenite and USY. Concerning the distribution of supported nickel either inside or outside the zeolitic structure, Jaeger et al., [8] reported experimental evidence by X-ray Photoelectron Spectroscopy that metal phases in reduced ionexchanged zeolites form preferentially inside the zeolite matrix. Delaffose [9] reported the deposition of nickel inside Faujasite channels and gives a correlation between Ni +2 location at the acid sites of the zeolite (via X-ray Diffraction studies) and the reducibility of the Ni § cation. However, neither of these two papers report quantitatively the extent of the reducibility of nickel via TPR. The similarly large deactivation effect caused by coke deposition for nickel supported on mordenite and on USY zeolitic materials is clearly seen in Figure 1. A basic difference between these two materials is the effect observed on the selectivity ratio styrene/ethylbenzene (see Figure 2). Although both materials have nearly the same deactivation profile, the high selectivity observed in Figure 2 for Ni/mordenite is probably due to shape selectivity. Since USY zeolite consists of supercages and windows while mordenite consists of pores and supercages connected in a straight line [4,10], the availability of alternative exits for reaction products in Ni/USY probably explains its lower selectivity. Moreover, the channels of mordenite only allow one-way molecular traffic. In addition, since the reaction follows a sequential stoichiometric path and given the higher intricacy of the structure~ of USY with respect to that of Mordenite, in terms of residence time, a molecule of phenylacetylene is more likely to proceed through a full completion of the hydrogenation stoichiometry since the probability of hitting a hydrogenation site is higher for the USY than for the mordenite support. Another aspect is the effect of the loss of population of the more active hydrogenation sites associated with nickel in USY compared to those of nickel in the Mordenite channels [9]. The shape of the TPR curves for Ni/mordenite and Ni/USY (Figures 4 and 5) provides evidence that NiO is reducible only at high temperatures, a behavior which is not characteristic of nickel oxide supported on low surface area carders [7]. The conclusion is that for zeolites the majority of nickel particles is located inside the crystalline structure of the supports. This is also supported by the results of coke deposition as studied by TGA. As seen in Tables 1 to 3, the total amount of coke found for each catalyst sample explains the deactivation curves in Figure 1 only if the structural aspect is considered. Nickel supported on USY contains 4.5 times more coke than nickel supported on ZSM5 and 2.6 times more
123 coke than nickel supported on mordenite; however, both Ni/USY and Ni/mordenite deactivate at the same rate. The coke deposited in mordenite is adequate to cause blockage of the parallel channels while for Ni/USY a larger amount of coke is necessary to block all possible 1.2
o -~
0.8 0.6 0.4 0.2 0 -0.2
i
! i i
0
400
200
600
800
1000
1200
Temperature, ~
Figure 3. Temperature-Programmed Reduction pattern for Ni/ZSM-5. 1 0.8 0.6
I
0.4 0.2
o i
-0.2
! 0
200
400
600
800
1000
1200
1400
Temperature, *C
Figure 4. Temperature-Programmed Reduction pattern for Ni/USY. exits in the faujasite structure. For Ni/ZSM5, since the reaction takes place on the external surface of the support where the acidity is low and the promotion of coke-forming polymerization reactions does not occur, a smaller quantity of coke is expected. The relatively large amount of high temperature coke seen for Ni/USY (see Table 2) provides evidence that the acid sites located in the interior of the structure catalyze polymerization reactions that form coke. The low temperature coke, formed at a reaction temperature of 20~ is expected to be promoted by nickel present on the external surface and by the low acidity external sites for Ni/mordenite and also for Ni/ZSM5 (Tables 1 and 3). Table 1. Coke deposition from TGA runs for Ni/mordenite. Temperature, ~
Amount of Coke, m ~ m l ~ ,
Relative % of Total
150-300 300-500 500-790 150-790
3.16 1.60 0.58 5.33
59.14 29.91 10.95
124 Table 2. Coke deposition from TGA runs for Ni/USY. Temperature, ~
Amount of Coke, mg/mg~.,
Relative % of Total
150-300 300-500 500-790 150-790
2.90 1.55 9.17 13.61
21.27 11.36 67.37
Table 3. Coke deposition from TGA runs for Ni/ZSM5. Temperature, ~
Amount of Coke, m ~ / m ~
Relative % of Total
150-300 300-500 500-790 150-790
1.21 1.27 0.33 3.02
40.07 42.04 17.89
1.00
0.80 O
-
0.60 0.40 0.20 -
0.00 0
I
I
I
I
I
I
200
400
600
800
1000
1200
Temperature, ~ Figure 5. Temperature-Programmed Reduction pattern for Ni/Mordenite.
1400
125 4. C O N C L U S I O N S Effects of crystalline structure and acidity differentiate the catalytic behavior of ZSM5, USY and mordenite zeolites. Compounded with the nature of the support, the location of nickel particles leads to very peculiar behaviors in the formation of low-temperature coke during the hydrogenation of phenylacetylene. The principal differences in the high temperature deactivation are determined by the size specificity of the zeolitic supports, and by the high acidity available to the reactant molecules, especially for the USY support. The contribution of nickel to coke formation at low temperatures occurs mainly at the internal surface of Ni/mordenite and Ni/USY and at the external surface of Ni/ZSM-5. This conclusion is supported by the TPR patterns as well as by the relative values of low, intermediate and high temperature coke for each individual support.
REFERENCES
1.
J.A. Montoya, J.C. Rodriguez, I. Schifter, A. Monzon and T. Viveros, in B. Delmon and G.F. Froment, "Catalyst Deactivation", Studies in Surface Science and Catalysis, V88, pp. 531-536, Elsevier Science, B.V., 1994. 2. P.A. Sermon, M.S.W. Vong and M. Matheson, International Symposium on Deactivation and Testing of Hydrocarbon Conversion Catalysts, pp. 370-373, Div. of Petroleum Chem., Inc., 210 t" National Meeting, ACS, Chicago, IL, August 20-25, 1995. 3. R.J. Argauer and G.R. Landolt, U.S. Patent 3702886, assigned to Mobil Oil Corp. (1972). T. Masuda and K. Hashimoto, ibid pp. 359-364. 5. B.C. Gates, Catalytic Chemistry, John Wiley and Sons, Inc. 1982 6. R. Szostak, Handbook of Molecular Sieves, Van Nordstrand Reinhold, NY (1992) 7. E.D. Gamas-Castellanos, Ph.D. Dissertation, Dept. of Chemical Engineering, University of Houston, May 1996. 8. N.I. Jaeger, P.Ryder and G. Schulz-Ekloff, in P.A. Jacobs et al. (Editors) Structure and Reactivity by Zeolites, p. 299, Elsevier Scientific Pub. B.V. (1984). 9. D. Delafosse, in B. Imelik et al. (Editors) Catalysis by Zeolites, p. 235, Elsevier Scientific Pub. B.V. (1980). 10. G.K. Boreskov and Kh. Minachev, Applications of Zeolites in Catalysis, AKADEMIAI KIADO, Budapest, 1979. .
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
~
Elsevier Science B.V. All rights reserved
Catalyst Deactivation 1997 C.H. Bartholomewand G.A. Fuentes, editors
127
A c t i v a t i o n and D e a c t i v a t i o n o f the Zeolite Ferrierite for Olefin C o n v e r s i o n s
Krijn P. de Jong, Henk H. Mooiweer, John G. Buglass and Paul K. Maarsen Shell International Oil Products B.V., Shell Research and Technology Centre, Amsterdam P.O. Box 38000, Amsterdam, The Netherlands E-mail: [email protected]
Conversion of olefins over the zeolite Ferrierite (FER) has been investigated in the temperature range 300 to 500~ Fast irreversible adsorption of butenes at 350~ completely filling the micropores, is observed using a microbalance. In the skeletal isomerization of butenes at that temperature, rapid initial coke build up is observed which slows down after 100 hours on stream. In the same time period the yield of isobutene produced from 1-butene increases while by-product formation, i.e. oligomers, is reduced. Fresh FER leads to extensive scrambling of a 13C-label during butene isomerization as deduced from GC/MS experiments, whereas spent FER does not give rise to scrambling. Carbonaceous deposits play an important role in modeling for activation/deactivation of FER for olefin conversion. These deposits are initially involved in oligomerization and cracking reactions and their aromatisation leads to coverage of the external surface of the crystallites m as deduced from XPS and TEM data m thus blocking pores and leading to a slow overall deactivation. The stability of FER in olefin processing is further demonstrated for olefin aromatisation at 500~ 1. INTRODUCTION Hydrocarbon conversions over zeolite catalysts play a major role in oil and petrochemical processes. Catalytic cracking and hydrocracking using FAU (zeolite Y) based catalysts were introduced in the 1960's, paraffin isomerization based on MOR around 1970, while shape selective conversions where MFI has an important role evolved around 1980 [1]. In these processes, paraffin and aromatics conversion are predominant. Olefin conversions using zeolites are more demanding since severe catalyst deactivation can occur due to rapid coke formation. With the advent of reformulated gasoline, however, the necessity to convert olefins is growing [ 1-3]. Prime examples are (i) skeletal isomerization of normal olefins to iso-olefins as feedstock for ether manufacture, (ii) alkylation of aromatics with light olefins e.g. to convert benzene, (iii) paraffin alkylation with olefins, (iv) aromatisation of gasoline olefins to enhance octane
128 quality. Low temperature (100--250~ conversion of olefins, notably oligomerization and alkylation, is made possible by involving cracking reactions to clean up the pore system [4] or to operate at very low olefin concentrations to prevent formation of deposits [5], respectively. Processing of olefins in the temperature range of say 300-500~ at high partial pressures of olefins is even more difficult. Skeletal isomerization of olefins and aromatisation of olefins are examples of desired reactions in this temperature range. Following the work of Grandvallet et al. [6] the zeolite FER has attracted much attention for the conversion of normal butenes to isobutene. Reviews in this area have underlined that FER displays unique selectivities to isobutene [7,8]. Studies of a broad range of zeolites with differences in acidity and pore structure have revealed that for this reaction shape selectivity prevails in enhancing isomerization over oligomerization [8-11 ]. The pore system of FER is unique in limiting oligomerization and aromatisation reactions while allowing isomerization reactions. The characteristics of the FER catalyst are very important however, of which acidity is one. Work by Xu et al. [12] and Pellet et al. [ 13] has indicated that a high Si/A1 ratio, the absence of extra-framework aluminum and a high crystallinity are all beneficial for enhancing selectivity to isobutene. Recent work has elucidated that the key to the isomerization of butenes over FER may lie in the subtle effects of carbonaceous deposits inside the unique pore system of the zeolite. It has been shown by Mooiweer et al. [ 14] that the pores of FER are largely filled with carbonaceous deposits under reaction conditions. An extensive study by Xu et al. [15] has shown that at 420~ olefinic deposits are converted to aromatic and polyaromatic material in FER. Seo et al. [16] have elegantly shown that coke deposits lead to higher selectivities for butene isomerization over oligomerization. Guisnet et al. [17,18] have made an intriguing proposal that coke deposits facilitate isomerization of normal butene by opening up a reaction path that circumvents primary carbenium ions. The deposits, which are either of an aliphatic [17] or of an aromatic nature [18], give rise to tertiary carbenium ions, thus enabling isomerization of butenes via alkylation, methyl shift and cracking [17]. Build up of coke thus gives rise to higher selectivities to isobutene since initial conversion involve dimerisation and cracking giving rise to products other than isobutene. In this paper we contribute to clarifying the role of coke in the activation/deactivation of FER for olefin conversions with emphasis on butene isomerization. To this end we establish the nature of the coke deposits by adsorption/desorption measurements. Furthermore, the isotopic scrambling for butene isomerization is determined in support of the Guisnet mechanism. Finally, slow deactivation of FER by coke is studied as this limits the ultimate lifetime of the catalysts. Details of the coke deposits in spent catalysts are revealed using electron microscopy and X-ray excited Photo-electron Spectroscopy. 2. EXPERIMENTAL Ferrierite zeolite samples in their acidic form were prepared in-house or obtained from a commercial supplier. The properties of the base materials are summarized in Table 1. For testing purposes, the zeolite powders were shaped into small particles
129 (30-80 mesh). Catalytic tests were carried out using 5 grams of catalyst diluted with an equal volume of SiC particles in a fixed-bed down-flow gas phase reactor. The off-gas composition was determined by gas chromatography (GC). For butene isomerization experimems 1-butene (99.5% pure) was used as feedstock without dilution at a total pressure of 1.2 bar. The results reported here have been obtained at 350~ and a weight hourly space velocity of 2 kg(butenes)/(kg of catalysVhr). Table 1 Basic data of Ferrierite samples Catalyst code
Si/A1 ratio (at/at)
Source
MPV
MPV
LS-FER
9
Toyo Soda
n.d.
n.d.
HS-FER
57
In house synthesis
0.13
1.4
Notes: n.d. = not determined
MPV is Micropore Volume determined with liquid nitrogen assuming a density of 0.808 g/ml. For olefin aromatisation experiments we used an FCC gasoline (22 %w aromatics and 28 %w olefins) with a boiling range of 85-175~ at process conditions of 500~ and 20 bar total pressure. For the latter reaction the feed and product were analyzed by GC and PIONA-GC (liquid product, TLP). Adsorption and desorption studies were carried out using HS-FER in a static atmosphere using an automated vacuum balance system. The pressure was increased stepwise by dosing with pure 1-butene. A subsequem dose was admitted when the pressure was stable, typically after 1 hour. Similarly, desorption was carried out stepwise. A mechanistic study of butene isomerization was carried out using 13C labelled butene, 13CH2=CH-CH2-CH3 and a GC-MS set up. The GC injector was equipped with a narrow glass tube containing 20 mg of powdered FER catalyst. In a typical experiment a butene sample (1 ktl, 0.9 bar) is injected, the products are separated by GC and then individually analyzed by mass spectrometry (MS) (Kratos Concept). Fresh and spent (but still active for butene isomerization) HS-FER was used for these experiments. Experiments were carried out at a catalyst temperature of 350~ Following extraction with toluene and pentane, the amount of aromatic coke has been determined by Pyrolysis Combustion Mass Spectrometric Element analysis (PCME). In the PCME technique the catalyst was first heated to pyrolyse the coke followed by combustion and determination of the remaining aromatic coke. The structure of the total
130 coke deposits after extraction was studied using X-ray excited Photo-electron Spectroscopy (XPS) with a Kratos XSAM 800 instrument. C/Si signal intensity ratios were thus obtained. Various Electron Microscopy (EM) techniques were used. High resolution Scanning Electron Microscopy (HRSEM) was performed on a Jeol 6000F instrument, operated at 25 kV. High resolution microstructural imaging and Selected Area Diffraction (SAD) were carded out using a Philips EM400T Transmission Electron Microscopy (TEM) instrument operated at 100 kV. Finally, nanoanalysis of surface coke deposits was performed using a VG HB501 Dedicated Scanning Transmission Electron Microscopy (D-STEM) instrument operated at 100 kV. The latter microscope was equipped with a Parallel Electron Energy Loss Spectroscopy (PEELS) facility which permits the efficient detection of carbon and identification of its form, e.g. amorphous or graphitic. % 1OO
80
\ n n i B m ~ ~ n - C4= c o n v e r s i o n (~
60
40
r
20
0
i-C4=yield (~ wof)
0
~JUi~lm~muW m I 200
n 400
C5§ y i e l d (*/owof)
I
I
600
800
T i m e on s t r e a m
I
1000
I
1200
(h)
Figure 1. Skeletal isomerization of 1-butene using HS-FER as catalyst. Product yields and n-butene conversion vs Time on-stream. 3. RESULTS
3.1. Catalytic experiments The stability of FER catalysts for butene isomerization has been studied extensively. In Fig. 1 a typical example of the long term activity and selectivity development of HS-FER is shown. During the first 100 h, a fast drop in the n-butenes conversion is observed which is related to the strong drop in the production of oligomers (C5+),
131 Yield
100
(~ /r
',
90
0 .Gr'" //A
~,
80
Cs+-yield, MFI A
Cs-,--yield , FER
z/
A 70
\
0 _~ 0
60
,
Aromatics,FER '1~, "\
50
0 x
0
0
O \
~'. x x .-~x
40 30
Aromatics, MFI 0
,
I
20
,
I
40
,
I
60
,
I
80
,
I
100
,
I
120
,
140
Time on s t r e a m (h)
Figure 2. FCC gasoline aromatization stability of ferrierite ans ZSM-5.
Butenes 100 Adsorpt ion (mg/g FER)
DESORPTION
80
60
40-
20-
2 0
1
0
200
400
,
I
600
Butenes pressure (mm Hg)
Figure 3. Vacuum balance adsorption/desorption of 1-butene on HS-FER at 350~
800
132 mainly consisting of dimers. Note that the yield of isobutene increases as has been noted before [12,13,15]. Beyond 100 hours on stream, a slow decrease in overall activity is observed but still the isobutene yield increases while the C 5+ yield continues to decline. The yield of isobutene reaches a maximum around 800 hours whereafter it starts to decline slowly. Following this long catalytic test (1280 hours) the carbon content of the catalyst was determined by PCME amounts to be 9.1%w. Aromatisation of olefins as present in FCC gasoline was carried out over both HS-FER and MFI (Si/A1 = 140 at/at). The results with FER (Fig. 2) show a constant production of aromatics at a relatively stable liquid (C5+) yield. For MFI the aromatisation activity initially surpasses that of FER but a strong decline is observed with the former catalyst.
Label
distribution
100
0
80
(*/,)
no label, mass 5 6
[]
1 label, m a s s 57
0
2 label,mass 58
I
3 label ,mass 59
~
Aromatic 1
....... iiiiiiiiiiiil !:!:i:i:i:i:i ii!iiiiiiiiii .............
4o 20
.......
.:.:.:.:.:.:.
...........! i
~i~i~i~!~i~i~ i i lili i i
,
........
iiiiiiiiiiiii i
F r e s h FER
___________-a H S- FER
o
....... .:.:.:.:.:.:.
:!:!:!:!:!:!:
t%/
(*/,)
7t/ o~//~
ii!iiiiiiii ............
LS-FER 8
iiiiiii
6O
c a r b o n cc oo nn tt ee rn t
il/
t~
iiiiiiiiiiiii :i:!:!:i:i:i
iiiiiii i i
0
............ i
....
9
o
S p e n t FER
. . . .
,
10100' Run t i m e (h)
Figure 4. 13C-label distribution for iso-
Figure 5. PCME carbon content of
butene as obtained from 13C-labelled 1butene with a fresh and a spent high Si FER catalyst.
spent FER vs time on stream.
3.2. Adsorption/desorption experiments Experiments in the temperature range 50-350~ on HS-FER showed rapid adsorption of 1-butene whereas desorption takes place to a very limited extent only. A typical plot of an adsorption followed by desorption experiment is shown in Fig. 3. Data were obtained at 350~ which is the reaction temperature of the catalytic
133
experiments (Fig. 1). Clearly, the adsorption of butenes on FER is irreversible in the temperature range studied.
3.3. Isomerization experiments with labelled 1-butene The mass spectrum of the GC/MS experiment with an empty reactor provided us with the fragmentation pattern of 13C-labelled 1-butene. Subsequently, isomerization experiments were carried out using fresh and spent HS-FER catalysts. The MS spectra corrected for the fragmentation pattern of the butene in question provided us with the label distribution in butenes. In Fig. 4 the results of the label distribution for isobutene, as obtained from isomerization at 350~ over the catalysts, are displayed. The scrambling of 13C over isobutene as observed with the fresh HS-FER after correction for natural abundance of 13C, is close to the values expected from complete (statistical) scrambling. Clearly, with the spent Ferrierite catalyst, which is still active for butene isomerization, scrambling has not taken place either in isobutene, or in the other butenes. Very similar results were obtained using 13C-labelled isobutene instead of
1-butene.
2.5
XPS C/Si r a t i o ( a t / a t )
/ surface coking
10
/I/ /
1.5
00~ 9 9
....//
9
0.5 ....
0
i
I
2
,
channel
4
/' 9 // / /
9
0
Figure 6. Variation of the XPS C/Si ratio as a function of carbon content (PCME) in various spent FER catalysts. Theoretical curves for channel filling and surface coking are included.
/
filling ~
i
6
a
I
8 Aromatic
i
i
10
i
12
carbon (*/.wt)
3.4. Characterization of carbonaceous deposits The build up of carbon deposits as a function of time on stream is shown in Fig. 5. The data were obtained at 350~ and WHSV of 2 kg/(kg 9h) for both LS-FER and HS-FER. Ferrierite having higher aluminum content is more prone to coke deposition in line with a faster deactivation (data not shown). The PCME data indicate that the H/C ratio of the aromatic coke decreased with time on stream (from 0.4 to 0.2 at/at).
134 For a variety of spent FER catalysts the C/Si signal intensity ratio was determined by XPS (Fig. 6). The experimental data points were compared with predicted values (dotted lines) obtained from the theory developed by Sexton et al. [19]. This theory gives a description of the attenuation of the Si signal due to carbon deposition inside the pores (channel filling, weak attenuation) followed by carbon built up at the external surface of the zeolites (surface coking, strong attenuation). For all coke contents the XPS C/Si intensity ratio is above the line expected for channel filling only. Above a carbon content of 6 %w, surface coking predominates. Electron microscopy was used to provide more details on the nature of the coke deposits as well as their location. HRSEM reveals the HS-FER crystallites to be platelets, typically 250 nm in size, with a mean thickness of only 20 nm. For a spent HS-FER containing 9.1%w of coke TEM photographs are displayed in Fig. 7. Careful inspection of the FER platelets reveals that they are bordered by a layer of amorphous material (labelled) which is probably coke. Also at the edge of the platelets there are layers of similar width (picture corresponds to a view down the (100) surfaces as determined by a selected area diffraction study). This suggests that all the external surfaces, both porous and non-porous, contain a layer of coke. To confirm that the amorphous layers indeed consist of carbonaceous material, PEELS spectra were collected which closely resemble that of the amorphous carbon film supporting the sample crystallites. With samples containing less carbon (below 7 %w), TEM does not reveal a coke layer at the surface of the crystallites, but rather reveals discrete coke clusters of 1.0-1.5 nm. 4. DISCUSSION From the adsorption/desorption experiments (Fig. 3) it appears that butene adsorbs irreversibly on FER in the relevant temperature range for butene isomerization. Since the heat of adsorption of butenes in silicon-rich FER is estimated to be 10 kcal/mol, desorption should be facilitated at about 350~ The low rate of desorption at 350~ proves, therefore, that butenes have reacted to higher molecular weight material, presumably oligomers, inside the pores of FER. From the results shown in Fig. 3 it is estimated that at 350~ about 90 mg of hydrocarbons per gram of FER core are adsorbed. Taking the micropore volume of FER as 0.13 ml/g (Table 1), the apparent density of the hydrocarbons is 0.69 g/ml, assuming complete filling of the micropores. Note that the density of liquid n-butenes is 0.60 ml/g, while that of methylheptenes is 0.71 g/ml [20]. In view of the irreversibility of the adsorption of butenes in combination with the apparent density, it is strongly suggested that butene oligomers are formed inside the pore entrance. In contrast to this model, Xu et al. [ 15] have suggested that the apparent high density of butenes adsorbed in FER is
135
~ - . ~ , . i
" ~i~r ~.~;..ii ~~ ~ ~ ~ . ~ ~.~
9
9
~
";
o
~
i.
o~. ,(
Figure 7. TEM images of spent HS-FER (9.1 wt% carbon). (A) Close to <100> and (B) imaged edge-on (the external coke layers on (100) surfaces are labelled).
136 due to butenes entering the 8-membered pore, whereas nitrogen m used to determine the micropore volume m cannot enter these pores. Given, however, the similar molecular dimensions of butene and nitrogen, this seems highly unlikely. Moreover, the pore volume determined by N2 is in good agreement with the theoretical pore volume on basis of the pore structure (0.15 ml/g). In summation, the 10- and 8-membered pores must be (almost) completely filled with butene oligomers following adsorption of the monomer. Although aliphatic coke (butene oligomers) fills up the pores immediately, the buildup of aromatic coke occurs much more slowly (Fig. 5). Combining the results of Figs. 3 and 5 reveals that from a pool of aliphatic material a slow transformation to aromatic coke takes place. This transformation is relatively fast during the first 100 hours, slowing down thereafter. GC/MS experiments using labelled butene show that extensive scrambling occurs with a fresh FER catalyst (Fig. 4). Since the adsorption measurements show that pores fill with oligomers on a short time scale relative to the time scale of the isomerization experiments, it is concluded that oligomerization is accompanied by cracking at this initial stage. This explains the scrambling: oligomerization, methyl shifts and cracking will give rise to a statistical distribution of the labelled carbon over the product molecules. In the case of spent FER, however, scrambling is no longer observed (Fig. 4). Apparently, the isomerization reaction takes place without the possibility of labelled carbons being exchanged between molecules. In our view two aspects play a role, viz. the absence of strong acid sites and the occurrence of 'fixed' coke after a longer time on stream. The strong acid sites initially catalyze cracking of oligomers, which 'mobilize' coke deposits. Slow aromatisation of coke inhibits the possibility of cracking as a mechanism for coke removal. It is essential to recognize that the initial activation of FER for butene isomerization is accompanied by a drop in C 5+ production and is thus a more 'label selective' mechanism. During the initial period larger molecules can escape from the pores of FER, thus giving rise to large amounts of C5+ products. Later, the 'fixed' coke restricts escape of larger molecules from the pores. The slow deactivation of FER after 100 h on stream (Fig. 1) is now addressed. In view of the above results, we propose that slow aromatisation of the carbonaceous deposits takes place both inside the pores and at the external surface of the crystallites. The density of the aromatic coke is higher than that of the initially formed aliphatic coke, thus allowing slightly more hydrocarbons to enter the pores. The pores would then fill until butenes can no longer enter them to isomerize. Ultimately, coke will block internal and external surfaces, the first signs of which appear in Figs. 6 (above 6 %w coke) and 7. For the catalyst containing 9.1%w coke (Fig. 7) estimates from XPS and TEM indicate that the coverage of the FER crystals by coke is around 50% with a layer thickness of 1-2 nm.
137 The key to the success of FER in olefin conversion resides with the fact that carbonaceous deposits quickly form without blocking the catalytic action. According to Guisnet et al. [17] the deposits in fact assist the catalysis. Aromatisation of the coke being slow is crucial to preventing ultimate pore blocking. Even under conditions where aromatisation of olefins occurs quickly (Fig. 2) it is Clear that FER is stable. Under these conditions of high temperature, restricting the conversion of mono-aromatics to polyaromatics is most likely the key to enhancing catalyst stability. ACKNOWLEDGMENTS
The authors express their gratitude to Dr. Herman P.C.E. Kuipers for stimulating discussions and to Dr. Andreas K. Nowak for critically reviewing the manuscript. REFERENCES
1.
2. 3. 4. 5. 6. .
8.
9. 10.
11. 12. 13. 14.
J.E. Naber, K.P. de Jong, W.H.J. Stork, H.P.C.E. Kuipers and M.F.M. Post, in: J. Weitkamp, H.G. Karge, H. Pfeifer and W. Holderich (eds.), 'Zeolites and Related Microporous Materials: State of the Art 1994', Elsevier, Amsterdam, p. 2197. I.E. Maxwell and J.E. Naber, Catalysis Letters, 12 (1992) 105. K.P. de Jong, W. Bosch and T.D.B. Morgan, in: A. Frennet and J.-M. Bastin (eds.), 'Catalysis and Automotive Pollution Control III', Elsevier, Amsterdam, 1995, p. 15. N.Y. Chen, W.E. Garwood and F.G. Dwyer, 'Shape selective catalysis in industrial applications', Marcel Dekker, New York, 1989, p. 67. K.P. de Jong, C.M.A.M. Mesters, D.G.R. Peferoen, P.T.M. van Brugge and C. de Groot, Chem. Eng. Sci., 51 (1996) 2053. P. Grandvallet, K.P. de Jong, H.H. Mooiweer, A.G.T.G. Kortbeek and B. Kraushaar-Czarnetzki, European Patent 501,577 (1992) to Shell. A.C. Butter and C.P. Nicolaides, Catal. Today, 18,(1993)443. J. Houzvicka and V. Ponec, Catal. Rev., Sci.-Eng., submitted. J. Houzvicka and V. Ponec, J. Catal., in press. P. Meriaudeau, T. Vu Anh, H. Le Van and C. Naccache, in: H.Chon, S.-K. Ihm and Y.S. Uh (eds.), 'Progress in Zeolite and Microporous Materials', Elsevier (1997), Amsterdam, p. 1373. G. Seo and H.S. Jeong, Catal. Lett., 36 (1996) 249. W.-Q. Xu, Y.-G. Yin, S.L. Suib, J.C. Edwards and C.-L. O'Young, J. Phys. Chem., 99 (1995) 9443. R.J. Pellet, D.G. Casey, H.-M. Huang, R.V. Kessler, E.J. Kuhlman, C.-L. O'Young, R.A. Sawicki and J.R. Ugolini, J. Catal., 157 (1995)423. H.H. Mooiweer, K.P. de Jong, B. Kraushaar-Czarnetzki, W.H.J. Stork and B.C.H.
138
15. 16. 17. 18.
19. 20.
Krutzen, in: J. Weitkamp, H.G. Karge, H. Pfeifer and W. Holderich (eds.), 'Zeolites and Related Microporous Materials: State of the Art 1994', Elsevier, Amsterdam, p. 2327. W-Q. Xu, Y.-G. Yin, S.L. Suib and C.-L. O'Young, J. Phys. Chem., 99 (1995) 758. G. Seo, H.S. Jeong, D.-L. Jang, D.L. Cho and S.B. Hong, Catal. Lea., 41 (1996) 189. M. Guisnet, P. Andy, N.S. Bnep, C. Travers and E. Benazzi, J. Chem. Soc., Chem. Commun. (1995) 1685. M. Guisnet, P. Andy, N.S. Bnep, C. Travers and E. Benazzi, in: H.Chon, S.-K. Ihm and Y.S. Uh (eds.), 'Progress in Zeolite and Microporous Materials', Elsevier (1997), Amsterdam, p. 1365. B.A. Sexton, A.E. Hughes and D.M. Bibby, J. Catal., 109 (1988) 126. CRC Handbook of Physics and Chemistry, 73rd Edition.
~ Science B.V. All rights reserved Catalyst Deactivation 1997 C.H. Bartholomew and G.A. Fuentes, editors
139
Deactivation o f Ferrierite during the 1-Butene Skeletal Isomerization R.A. Comelli, Z.R. Finelli, N.S. Figoli, C.A. Querini Instituto de Investigaciones en Cat~ilisis y Petroquimica- INCAPE (FIQ-LrNL, CONICET). Santiago del Estero 2654. 3000 - Santa Fe, Argentina The influence of temperature, 1-butene partial pressure, weight hourly space velocity (WHSV), and pretreatment conditions on the activity, selectivity and stability of ferrierite during the 1-butene skeletal isomerization has been studied in order to understand the process of coke formation. Coke is characterized by temperature-programmed oxidation (TPO) and Fourier transform-infrared diffuse reflectance spectroscopy (DRIFTS). The catalytic behavior is strongly affected by the intrinsic properties of the zeolite, showing a significant deactivation associated with coke formation. The operational conditions, such as temperature, 1-butene partial pressure and WHSV, play an important role in the amount of coke produced, the temperature being the most important factor affecting the amount of coke. These conditions also modify the nature of the coke. A significant fraction of coke burns at temperaturehigher than 600~ 1. INTRODUCTION The skeletal isomerization of n-butenes is an attractive route for the production of isobutene which is an important raw material for the synthesis of methyl tert-butyl ether (MTBE), currently used as a major booster of the octane number for reformulated gasoline. Amorphous materials such as halogen-modified aluminas are active in the n-butene skeletal isomerization (1). Environmental and stability considerations do not favor the usage of these catalysts. Zeolites also might catalyze this isomerization if both acidity and pore size are suitable to achieve desirable activity and selectivity (2-4). Ferrierite, a small pore zeolite, is of current interest since it shows exceptional selectivity for the 1-butene skeletal isomerization (5). The ferrierite structure (6) has a two-dimensional pore system with tenmembered tings (4.2 x 5.4 A) intersected by eight-membered rings (3.5 x 4.8 A). This pore structure is related to the high isobutene selectivity and is more important than the acidity, as has been recently reported (7). The ferrierite is one of the best catalysts known for this reaction, due to a very good selectivity. However, initial selectivity to isobutene is low (8), and the catalyst displays better performance alter some time-on-stream when coke has been deposited. This behavior has been related to the presence of two kinds of active sites (9), the external acid sites which are non-selective sites for skeletal isomerization and the internal acid sites selective for this reaction. A monomolecular mechanism is reported over the latter sites, while a bimolecular mechanism occurs over the non-selective acid sites (10). The deactivation and coke formation over ferfierite was recently related to the crystallinity degree of the zeolite (9). In this study, coke formation on ferrierite during the 1-butene skeletal isomerization was investigated. The influence of temperature, 1-butene partial pressure, WHSV, and pretreatment conditions on the activity, selectivity and stability was analyzed in order to understand the process of coke formation. The coke was characterized by TPO and DRIFTS. 2. EXPERIMENTAL Ammonium ferrierite was provided by TOSOH, Japan (sample number HSZ-720NHA, Lot N ~ D 1-51). The SIO2/A1203 molar ratio was 17.8, with Na20 < 0.05% and K20 < 0.1%.
140 The crystalline structure was characterized by X-ray diffraction (XRD) using a RichSeifert Iso-Debyeflex 2002 diffractometer. Radiation was Cu K(~, filtered with Ni; the diffraction spectrum range was 0 < 2( < 60 ~ The catalytic behavior during the 1-butene skeletal isomerization reaction was studied using a continuous flow fixed-bed quartz tubular reactor operated at atmospheric pressure. For the test, 500 mg of catalyst sieved to 35-80 mesh were heated in a nitrogen stream (60 ml min -~) from 25~ to 550~ in 30 min and held at this value for 30 min. Some samples were pretreated in nitrogen saturated with water or in hydrogen streams. After heating, the samples were cooled to reaction temperature; then a nitrogen stream and pure 1-butene were fed for 180 min. The reactants and reaction products were analyzed by on-line gas chromatography, using a 30-m-long, 0.54-mm-O.D. GS-Alumina (J&W) megabore column, operated isothermally at 100~ From these data, catalytic activity, selectivity to isobutene, and isobutene yield, were calculated on a carbon basis. The catalytic activity is expressed as n-butene conversion. For this calculation the three isomers of n-butene are grouped together; this consideration is based on the fact that the isomerization of 1-butene to 2-butene rapidly reaches the equilibrium via double-bond migration under reaction conditions. TPO analysis of used catalysts was performed using specially designed equipment (11) in order to improve both sensitivity and resolution. The unit converted the carbon dioxide generated during coke combustion to methane, using a nickel catalyst. The methane was then continuously analyzed with a flame ionization detector. The experiments were performed using a 6% oxygen in a nitrogen stream (20 ml min-~), heating the sample at 12~ min -~. The sample weight was about 0.01 g. In order to obtain additional characterization of the coke deposited on the catalyst, DRIFTS measurements were performed using a SHIMADZU 8101M spectrometer. Coked samples were diluted to 5% in KBr. 3. RESULTS AND DISCUSSION The catalytic performance of ferrierite during the 1-butene isomerization at reaction temperatures between 300 and 430~ was determined. Figure 1-A displays the catalytic activity (expressed as n-butene conversion) and the selectivity to isobutene. A similar qualitative behavior is observed at any temperature: a high activity with low isobutene selectivity is reached after a short time on-stream, and then a rapid decrease in activity takes place, with an increase in the isobutene selectivity. By increasing temperature, catalytic activity increases and stability improves, while the selectivity to isobutene decreases. Figure 1-B shows the isobutene yield at several temperatures. The higher the reaction temperature, the larger the isobutene yield and the higher the stability. The effect of the 1-butene partial pressure over the catalytic behavior of ferrierite at 350~ can be seen in Figures 2-A and 2-B. These experiments were carried out at atmospheric pressure, and the 1-butene partial pressure was modified by changing the nitrogen flow rate. The same qualitative behavior that was observed when changing the temperature is observed when changing the 1-butene partial pressure. By decreasing the 1butene partial pressure, catalytic activity increases and stability improves, while the selectivity to isobutene decreases slightly, as shown in Figure 2-A. The lower the 1-butene partial pressure, the larger the isobutene yield and yield stability (see Fig. 2-B). The effect of the 1-butene partial pressure on the catalytic performance is less noticeable than the temperature effect. The effect of the WHSV was also studied by modifying the 1-butene flow rate and maintaining at the same 1-butene partial pressure. These results, shown in Figures 3-A and 3B, are similar to those obtained by changing the 1-butene partial pressure. At low 1-butene space velocities, higher conversion and yield are obtained with lower isobutene selectivity. At all operational conditions a high n-butene conversion and poor isobutene selectivity was observed at short time on-stream, followed by a decrease in conversion and an increase in the isobutene selectivity with increasing time on-stream. This behavior is similar to data previously reported (8-10). Our results show a decrease in the isobutene yield at short times
141 on-stream, as also found previously (9) when the silicon to aluminum ratio is low. The morphology, crystallinity and pore size distributions of ferrierite change when the silicon to aluminum ratio decreases (9). Comparing the X-ray diff action pattern of our sample with those showed by Xu et al. (9), it was found that the ferrierite used in our study was similar to their sample having the lowest crystallinity, although the silicon to aluminum ratio of both samples were different. Therefore, the initial decrease in both activity and isobutene yield, shown in Figures 1-3, can be explained because of the low crystallinity of our sample. .<
30
100
~- 8O k.i .J .1
.<
400"C
..J t, >. u.I z, l I--
w 6O a z <
z 040
20
430"C 380"C
no 10 0 r
.1
350~
2O
z 0
300"C
0
0
40
80
120
160
0
200
0
40
80
120
160
T I M E , min
TIME, min
200
Figure 1. (A) n-Butene conversion (solid lines) and selectivity to isobutene (dashed lines) as a function of time on-stream at different temperatures. (B) isobutene yield at different temperatures. Pica= = 0.14 atm; WHSV = 0.184 h -]. IO0
30
;;;;;'1
_Nso
..~ d
U .i ..J
~eo a z <
0.10 atm
0.08 atm .i
0.10 atm
z20 0
0.14 a t m
0.14 albrn O0
40
80
120
TIME, min
160
200
0
0
I
I 40
I
810
I
_
I 120
_
|
I 160
!
200
TIME, min
Figure 2" (A) n-Butene conversion (solid lines) and selectivity to isobutene (dashed lines) as a function of time on-stream at different 1-butene partial pressure. (B) isobutene yield at varied 1-butene partial pressure. T = 350~ WHSV =0.184 h l. Moreover, it has been reported that the presence of Na ions in the zeolite structure is detrimental to isomerization reactions since they contribute to channel blocking, limiting the diffusion ofbutene molecules, while coke buildup causes the isobutene yield to decrease with
142 time on-stream (9). Deactivation due to channel blocking by sodium cannot be neglected in our case because sodium was detected by elemental analysis. However, since the sodium content in our sample is rather low, it can be expected that this effect may not be very important. The increase in isobutene selectivity with time-on-stream is a particular property of the ferrierite. This zeolite has two types of active sites: the external sites (on the external surface of the zeolite crystallites) which are non-selective for skeletal isomerization and the internal sites (inside the zeolite pores) which are selective for this reaction (9). The changes observed on the selectivity have been associated with modifications of pore shapes through coke deposition that favor reactions involving small molecules, such as n-butene to isobutene isomerization (8). More recently, it has been reported that a bimolecular mechanism takes place at the non-selective acid sites, while a monomolecular mechanism occurs on the selective sites (10), the coke deposition being necessary in order to poison, block, and modify the non-shape selective acid sites. The catalytic performance of ferrierite during 1-butene skeletal isomerization is essentially unchanged as pretreatment conditions are varied. The initial heating step was made in nitrogen, nitrogen saturated with water, or hydrogen streams; a slightly lower n-butene conversion and isobutene yield was only observed when hydrogen was used.
100 1
30
A
*~
0.184 1/h .m
jm -~
P"
w60 u)
Q~
....::::.;-'.'.e....e-_lr~i'":'::.~ ....
9 ...... ~ ........
) . . . . . . R ' l " .-.-. . .
:;:"
a Z < z40
~
.
. _
0 289
0.104 1/11
1/11
1/11
d
,,-I, ~
0.184 1/h
W Z
0.289 1;11
m 0
_m lO
0.104 1~
w
~'20 0
0
" 0
.-akin 40
80 120 TIME, rain
160
200
00
i_
I
40
n
!
I
!
80 120 TIME, min
I
I
160
!
200
Figure 3. (A) n-Butene conversion (solid lines) and selectivity to isobutene (dashed lines) as a function of time-on-stream at different WHSV. (B) isobutene yield as a function of time onstream at different WHSV. T = 350~ Plc4= = 0.14 atm The amount of coke deposited on the ferrierite at the end of the catalytic test reaches levels between 5.7 and 9.1% for different temperatures, 1-butene partial pressures, and WHSV, as can be seen in Figures 4A-C. Upon increasing the temperature, the amount of coke reaches a maximum at 380~ Increasing the WHSV increases the amount of coke deposited. Lowering the 1-butene partial pressure, decreases the amount of coke formed. The high amount of coke formed under the different operational conditions studied could be related with the capacity of the ferrierite sample to form coke on the external acid sites where dimerization followed by cracking can take place. According to these results, coke is formed by a parallel mechanism, i.e., coke is formed from the 1-butene. The relationship between the amount of coke and both the space velocity (WHSV) and the 1-butene partial pressure points towards such a coking mechanism. When the space velocity is increased, the n-butene
143 conversion decreases, and therefore the average n-butene concentration along the reactor is higher. In these experiments, the higher the n-butene concentration, the higher the amount of coke. Similar results are obtained when increasing the partial pressure of 1-butene. Therefore, coke formation correlates with n-butene concentration. This indicates that coke formation follows a parallel mechanism.
10
.-~
9
uJ I--
8
0 0 uJ
7
10
A
10
~..-
0 0
e"
J
6 5
t
I
300
I
I
I
I
i
350
t
I
I
TEMPERATURE, ~
I
t
400
I
~
I
I
0.08
I
I
0.10
I
I
0.12
I
t
0.14
!
I-BUTENE PARTIAL PRESSURE, atm
5
0.06
0.14
0.22
0.30
WHSV, 1/!1
Figure 4. Coke content on catalysts; (A) as a function of reaction temperature, P1c4= = 0.14 atm; WHSV = 0.184 hl; (B) as a function of 1-butene partial pressure at T=350~ WHSV = 0.184 hl; (C) as a function of WHSV; T = 350~ Pica= = 0.14 atm. The influence of temperature on the amount of coke is quite complex. It involves the competition between n-butene adsorption, coke formation and cracking of adsorbed molecules. The n-butene conversion increases when the temperatm'e is increased in the 300430~ range, but the selectivity decreases because the amount of C1-C3 products is higher. Therefore, one possible explanation for the observed decrease in the amount of coke at 400~ (compared to 380~ is the higher cracking activity. Another possibility is that the coke deposition rate at 400~ is higher than that at 380~ but fast pore mouth plugging occurs and as a consequence, the total amount of coke is lower. However, since the stability is improved at the higher temperature (see Figs. 1A-B), the former explanation seems to be the correct one. This means that the acidity of ferrierite is adequate to crack the adsorbed molecules without a significant oligomerization of such compounds, in the upper range of temperature studied. In fact, it can be expected that at lower reaction temperature and as a consequence of a lower cracking activity, oligomer formation on the outer site where bimolecular mechanism takes place, leads to a fast coke deposition and therefore a pore mouth plugging occurs. This results in a lower stability and lower coke formation at 300 ~ than at 380~ (see Figures 1 and 4). Figure 5 shows the TPO profiles for the catalysts after reaction at different temperatures. These TPO show two well defined peaks. The first peak is between 250~ and 400~ and the second one is at very high temperatures, between 550 and 750~ As reaction temperature increases, the coke that bums at high temperatures increases, while that burning at low temperatures, decreases. The second peak most likely comes from the reorganization of the coke that occurs during the TPO at temperatures higher than the reaction temperature. After the reaction the catalysts are light gray. One experiment was carried out by heating a coked catalyst up to 450~ in a 6% O2/N 2 stream. After this treatment the catalyst was black. This indicates that above the reaction temperature the coke modifies its nature, changing its structure to an aromatic one. The first peak in the TPO can be related to coke with an aliphatic structure, and the second peak to coke that was reorganized into an
144 aromatic structure. The higher the reaction temperature, the higher the proportion of this type of coke. However, as discussed below, coke aromatization also occurs during reaction at high temperature. It is expected that the regeneration of this catalyst is severely complicated by the presence of this coke that bums at high temperatures. In order to characterize the coke deposited on catalysts after reaction, DRIFTS measurements were made on the used catalysts, as well as
300"C 350"C
~"
380"C
~'
4oo*c
~ 3~o'c
o
~'~
400"C
0
200
400
600
800
TEMPERATURE, *C
Figure 5. TPO profiles of ferrierite samples tested at different reaction temperatm'es. the fresh ferrierite. Little information about coke can be obtained below 1250 cm l , mainly because strong bands characteristic of the ferrierite appear. Other characteristic bands of the fresh catalyst are centered at about 1633, 3649 and 3738 cm "l. The ones above 3500 cm l are associated with different hydroxyl groups. Coked samples obtained either at 300 and 350~ or at different WHSV, showed some differences from the fresh catalyst in the region corresponding to OH vibrations. The band centered at about 3738 cm 1 disappears while the intensity of the band centered at 3649 cm -l decreases upon increasing either WHSV or temperature - conditions under which the amount of coke deposited increases, as shown in Fig. 4. According to data previously reported (12,13), bands centered at about 3650 and 3740 cm" correspond to different hydroxyl stretching vibrations. More recent data (9) suggest that bands at 3742 and 3601 cm" on ferrierite are related to hydroxyl groups of terminal silanol and hydroxyl groups associated with the framework silicon and aluminum ions, respectively. Considering our results, the disappearance of the band at 3738 cm l could be associated with the deactivation of non-selective acid sites which takes place at short time-on-stream, while the band at 3649 cm -l could be related to the selective acid sites and its intensity decreases as the amount of coke increases. Other bands in the DRIFTS spectra centered at about 1387, 1411, 1508, 1616, 2875 and 2930 cm -l allow characterization of coke. The behavior is qualitatively similar when increasing either WHSV or temperature. A slight increase in the intensity of bands at 1387 and 1411 c m l is observed while the band at 1508 crnl is resolved into two bands centered at about 1502 and 1512 cml; the other bands do not show significant changes. Bands at about 1620 cm l are assigned to C=C stretching vibrations of butenes (14, 15). Bands in the 1370-1394 cm l [assigned to CH3 and CH2 bending vibrations (13)] and 2870-2930 cm l [assigned to CH3 and CH2 stretching vibrations (16)] regions correspond to oligomers (15), while a band at 1520 cm" has been assigned to C=C stretching vibration in aromatics (9,14). Considering these assignments, our results for 300 and 350~ and different WHSV show the presence of oligomers on the surface, in accordance with the
145 TPO results, and a low aromaticity of the coke. Furthermore, the increase in the intensity of the band at about 1510 cm l as reaction temperature increases indicates a higher proportion of coke having aromatic nature, in accordance with data previously reported (9). 4. CONCLUSIONS The catalytic behavior of ferrierite during the 1-butene skeletal isomerization is strongly affected by the intrinsic properties of the zeolite, showing a significant deactivation associated with coke formation. The operational conditions (mainly temperature rather than 1-butene partial pressure and WHSV) play an important role in the amount of coke produced. Moreover, these conditions also modify the nature of the coke, i.e., the proportion of coke burning at low and high temperatures. A significant fraction of coke bums at temperatures higher than 600~ suggesting that regeneration should be carefully studied. 5. ACKNOWLEDGMENTS The authors greatly thank JICA (Japan International Cooperation Agency) for their assistance to this project. We acknowledge TOSOH for the provision of a ferrierite sample. REFERENCES
.
.
.
6. ,
8.
9. 10. 11. 12. 13. 14. 15. 16.
A.C. Butler and C.P. Nicolaides, Catal. Today, 18 (1993) 443. S.M. Yang, D.H. Guo, J.S. Lin and G.T. Wang, Zeolites and Related Microporous Materials: State of the Art 1994 (J. Weitkamp, H.G. Karge, H. Pfeifer and W. H/51derich, Eds.), Studies in Surface Science and Catalysis, Vol. 84, p. 1677, Elsevier Science B.V., Amsterdam, 1994. M.W. Simon, W.-Q. Xu, S.L. Suib and Ch.-L. O'Young, Microporous Materials, 2 (1994) 477. L.H. Gielgens, I.H.E. Veenstra, V. Ponec, M.J. Haanepen and J.H.C. van Hooff, Catal. Lett., 32 (1995) 195. H.H. Mooiweer, Eur. Pat. N ~ 0 574 994 A1, (1993). W.M. Meier and D.H. Olson, Atlas of Zeolites Structure Types, 3rd Edition, p. 98, Butterworth-Heinemann, London, 1992. G. Seo, H.S. Jeong, S.B. Hong and Y.S. Uh, Catal. Lea., 36 (1996) 249. W.-Q. Xu, Y.-G. Yin, S.L. Suib and Ch.-L. O'Young, J. Phys. Chem., 99 (1995) 758. W.-Q. Xu, Y.-G. Yin, S.L. Suib, J.C. Edwards and Ch.-L. O'Young, J. Phys. Chem., 99 (1995) 9443. P. Meriaudeau, R. Bacaud, L. Ngoc Hung and Anh. T. Vu, J. Mol. Catal. A: Chemical, 110 (1996) L 177. S.C. Fung and C.A. Querini, J. Catal., 138 (1992) 240. J.P. Blitz and S.M. Augustine, Spectroscopy, 9(8) (1994) 28. J. Datka, Z. Sarbak and R.P. Eischens, J. Catal., 145 (1994) 544. A.K. Ghosh and R.A. Kydd, J. Catal., 100 (1986) 185. C. Flego, Y. Kiricsi, W.O. Parker and M.G. Clerici, Appl. Catal. A: General, 124 (1995) 107. A.G. Gayubo, J.M. Arandes, A.T. Aguayo, M. Olazar and J. Bilbao, Ind. Eng. Chem. Res., 32 (1993) 588.
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
9
Elsevier Science B. V. All rights reserved
Catalyst Deactivation 1997 C.H. Bartholomewand G.A. Fuentes, editors
147
A l c o h o l D e h y d r a t i o n Reactions as C h e m i c a l P r e c u r s o r s for C o k e F o r m a t i o n and A c i d i t y Probes in T u n g s t a t e d Z i r c o n i a Catalysts Gustavo Larsen a, Edgar Lotero a, Mark Nabity a, Lucia Petkovic a and Carlos A. Querini b aDepartment of Chemical Engineering, University of Nebraska-Lincoln, NE 68588-0126 blNCAPE, Universidad Nac. del Litoral, CC 93, Santa F6 (3000), Argentina The temperature-programmed desorption of low-molecular weight alcohols was studied over tungstated zirconia and acidic zeolites. Tungstated zirconia (WZ) acids have less tendency to deactivate due to carbon deposition and to form oligomeric products. Proton exchange is also less important in WZ. 1. I N T R O D U C T I O N Tungstated zirconia (WZ) catalysts have been proposed as viable candidates for alkane isomerizations, especially those heavier than C4 [ 1]. In this work, alcohol dehydrations were used to rank the acidity of WZ with respect to that of HY zeolite, and to evaluate the ability of these catalysts to resist coking during a reaction that yields an olefin molecule as the primary product. The results from temperature-programmed reaction and infrared spectroscopy studies allowed us to gain some insight into the relative stability of WZ. The higher stability of WZ with respect to sulfated zirconia is an interesting feature [2,3]. A bimolecular mechanism appears to be responsible for the alkane isomerization activity of both WZ and SZ [4,5], but several observations concerning the kinetic behavior of WZ and SZ lead to the belief that carbenium ion-like intermediates in WZ ought to be relatively shortlived [6]. The key issue is that oligomeric species are expected to undergo either B-scission (isomerization) or further condensation to form high molecular weight coke precursors. Thus, the reason why we chose to study a set of alcohol dehydration reactions (with and without deuterium labeling) is that these species are excellent precursors for carbenium-like surface intermediates. In addition, information regarding the acidity of WZ catalysts can also be obtained by such chemical probes. Temperature-programmed reaction and oxidation experiments (TPReac and TPO) and diffuse reflectance infrared spectroscopy (DRIFTS) were used to study the products, and the type and amount of coke formed upon TPReac. 2. E X P E R I M E N T A L
The alcohols used were 1-propanol and tert-butanol (with and without deuteration of the hydroxyl group) from Aldrich | The preparation of WZ (W content: 6 wt%) is described elsewhere [2]. In brief, the catalyst is obtained by aqueous incipient wetness impregnation of hydrous zirconia with a solution containing the appropriate amount of ammonium metatungstate. The sample is subsequently calcined at 1096 K for one hour under flowing air. EXAFS measurements carried out at the National Synchrotron Light Source [7] showed that the WZ sample has an average W-O coordination number and distance of 4.7 and 1.69/~ respectively. The surface area of the calcined material is 36 m2/g. XRD reveals that a small amount of monoclinic zirconia was formed upon calcination. The Y-zeolite catalyst was
148 purchased from Aldrich @in the NH4 + form. The HY sample was prepared by calcination of NH4Y at 873 K for 2 hours in situ, prior to both DRIFTS and TPReac experiments. The WZ sample (150 mg catalyst bed) and the HY reference were calcined in situ prior to the TPReac experiments. The air flow was switched to pure helium and the cell purged for about 15-20 min. prior to injection of 15 l.tl alcohol (liq.) at the reactor inlet at 298 K. An MKS residual gas analyzer was used to follow a total of 16 different m/e values. For simplicity, out of the 16 rn/e values chosen we only show those that gave detectable signals. Our choice of m/e fragments was based on the assumption that the catalysts could only produce water, unreacted alcohol, olefins (both monomer from dehydration and heavier oligomers), aldehydes (for 1-propanol only) and ethers. Representative m/e ratios for each species were then selected from the available literature [8] After alcohol injection the cell was purged for another 15 min. to remove most of the reversibly adsorbed material prior to ramping the temperature at a 3.1 K/min rate under mass-flow controlled He. The final temperature for all TPReac runs was 773 K, but only the useful T-ranges are shown. The DRIFrS studies were carried out at different temperatures on a Nicolet 20 SXB FTIR spectrometer equipped with a commercial DRIFTS catalytic chamber and associated hardware from Spectratech| The DRIFTS cell is a temperature-controlled flow-through reactor. Upon calcination, samples were cooled to room temperature under nitrogen. Subsequently, 25 microliters (liq.) of the chosen alcohol were injected and spectra were collected at 373, 473, 623 and 773 K during the heating cycle. A spectral resolution of 4 cm -1 was used. Temperature-programmed oxidation (TPO) experiments were carried out on samples which had been exposed to the tert-butanol TPReac cycle. In order to measure the low coke content on the catalysts used in this study, a highly sensitive TPO method was employed. Our TPO setup converts the CO2 produced during coke oxidation to CH4, by means of a Ni catalyst. The CH4 is then continuously monitored with a flame ionization detector. This improves both sensitivity and resolution. Details of the technique have been reported earlier [9]. The TPO analyses are done using under 30cc/min of 3% O2/N2 , while ramping the temperature at 12 K/min. Sample weight was variable, depending upon the anticipated carbon content of each sample in order to improve the reliability of the method.
3. RESULTS AND DISCUSSION
. ,...4
HY wz
%C 1.07 0.50
fnq b
t t
't ,!
t
/ f s
~ I
r~ e,i
8
"~
I
400
9
HY'
I
600
o
I
9
800
Temperature (K) Fig. 1" TPO of HY and WZ catalysts after t-BuOH TPReac.
Figure 1 shows the TPO results for both HY and WZ upon TPReac with tert-butanol. The blank zirconia support (not shown) gave a total carbon content of 0.25%. Apart from the lower carbon content that may well be due to a lower ability of WZ to retain the alcohol molecules prior to the temperature ramp, perhaps the most salient feature is the larger tendency of the zeolite to form larger relative amounts of apparently "harder" coke. If we arbitrarily assign the low- and hightemperature contributions to the TPO curves to soft and hard coke respectively, it is clear that the zeolite retains a larger fraction of the latter. In fact, a small but significant amount of methanized CO2 was still being detected when the TPO experiment was terminated around 900 K. In order to understand why the zeolite may, under the experimental conditions employed in this work, retain more carbonaceous residues at higher temperatures than WZ, it was necessary to follow a large number of m/e signals during the TPReac
149
experiments to understand the types of olefins and coke precursors formed during the desorption with reaction process. Tert-butanol and 1-propanol were chosen because a marked difference in reactivity between the two alcohols was expected a priori. Transition metal oxides may also catalyze the formation of ketones or aldehydes by oxidative dehydrogenation providing they have a significant number of basic/acid site pairs [10]. With both HY and WZ, the alcohol dehydration to ether and oxidative dehydrogenation pathways were essentially negligible.
d c
b
a
1600 Wavenumbers (cm-1)
1400
1(~oo Wavenumbers (cm-1)
1~,0o
Figure 2. DRIFTS spectra in the coke region Figure 3. DRIFTS spectra in the coke retion of WZ upon tea-butanol exposure, a) 373, on HY upon tert-butanol exposure, a) 373, b) b) 473, c) 623 and d) 773 K. 473, c) 623 and d) 773 K. Figures 2 and 3 show the DRIFTS spectra in the so-called "coke region". The 1580-1600 cm -1 band has been assigned to 8(C-H) vibrations of hydrogen-deficient carbonaceous polyethene- or aromatic-type residues [ 11], and has also been referred to as the "hard coke" band [12,13]. The band around 1540 cm -1 has been assigned to polyphenylene structures, whereas that at 1470 cm -1 is due to paraffmic species [11,14]. The olefinic CC stretching frequency is observed in the 1600-1650 cm -1 range [14]. Interestingly, both catalysts show evidence for both olef'm formation at low temperatures (1600-1650 cm -1 signal) and aliphatic species (1470 cm -1) which progressively yield coke signals at 1580 and 1550 cm -1 for HY and WZ respectively. The DRIFTS results with 1-propanol presented the same trend (not shown), with olefinic CC stretching signals evolving toward broad coke bands around 1590 and 1540 cm -1 for HY and WZ respectively. Clearly, the end result for deposition of carbonaceous residues upon exposure of WZ to alcohols appears to differ from that of HY. Coke residues formed from alcohols on HY are characterized by the observation of hard coke bands very similar to those formed after alkane cracking [ 12,15]. Figures 4 and 5 show the tert-butanol TPReac results over the WZ and HY catalysts respectively. The m/e = 59 is the most important alcohol fragment. The WZ catalyst is characterized by desorption with reaction to olefins almost exclusively (m/e values of 41 and 55). The ratio of masses 41 to 55 is consistent with the isobutene MS pattern throughout the whole tert-butanol TPReac spectrum over WZ. In heavier olefins (e.g., octenes), the m/e = 55 is the dominant fragment, which would have made extensive oligomerization easily detectable. On the other hand, the HY catalyst showed a richer tea-butanol TPReac pattern. Olefin oligomerization over HY was also evident by the asymmetry of the m/e 41 and 55 peaks. Note that if the two signals were only due to isobutene, we should expect them to follow exactly the same trend. However, Fig. 5 shows that m/e = 55 becomes more
150
..-"'"'"......
./ \ J ......'"
290
310
330
350
Temperature I I~lvin
370
39O
300
400
500 Temperature I Kelvin
600
700
Figure 4. TPReac of tert-butanol over WZ. Figure 5. TPReac of tert-butanol over HY. M/e = 59 (xl0, solid line), 18 (o), 55 (--) and M/e = 69 (x5, fdled triangles), 18 (long 41 (triangles). dashes), 55 (x5, x), 115 (xl0, solid), 41(--), 65 (xl0, o) and 59 ( x 5 , ) . .. ~
]
",
.-'."
i
t t
',.
" l
' !
d
j
300
I
J
350
400
1
450 Temperature I Kelvln
,
500
l
I~
.............................
550
Figure 6. TPReac of 1-propanol over WZ. M/e = 18 (solid line), 41 (o), 31 (dashed).
350
400
450 Temperature I Kelvln
500
550
Figure 7. TPReac of 1-propanol over HY. M/e = 41 (long dashes), 31 (10x, short dashes), 55 (xl0, solid), 69 (xl0, triangles) and 18 (squares).
important at higher temperatures, which is in agreement with the idea that heavier unsaturated hydrocarbons are formed at higher temperatures. A number of other heavier olefm masses were followed to conf'Lrm such conclusion. Another interesting feature is the observation of a detectable m/e = 65 signal (cyclopentadienyl cation) in the HY TPReac pattern which suggests that condensed carbon nuclei are formed and even detected in the gas phase. Such an m/e fragment was not observed in WZ. This observation is also consistent with our TPReac results on alcohol dehydration over H-Mordenite [7]. The evolution of the rn/e = 65 signal with temperature in HY coincides with the appearance of the coke band around 1580 cm -1 (see figures 3 and 5). The idea is that both release of oligomers to the gas phase and retention of oligomeric residues (coke precursors, see TPO results above) are less significant in WZ than in acidic zeolites, and that the residue formed at high temperatures in WZ (1550 cm -1 DRIFTS band) is more easily eliminated by TPO. One plausible explanation is that the broad 1550 cm -1 band that appears on WZ upon heating the catalyst with preadsorbed tbutanol arises from many chemically non-equivalent soft coke residues, rather than from polyphenylene structures. Alternatively, if the 1550 cm -1 band in WZ is indeed due to
151
polyphenylene fragments, the latter must be more easily subjected to oxidation than conventional hard coke. Based on an extensive literature search, we found no precedent that this should be the case, although this hypothesis cannot be entirely ruled out at this point. A small m/e = 115 signal was detected on the TPReac of t-butanol over HY which is tentatively assigned to the formation of small amounts of ether. In Figures 6 and 7 we report m/e values detected during TPReac of 1-propanol over WZ and HY respectively. A much larger proportion of the alcohol desorbs without reaction over WZ, due to the lower reactivity of primary alcohols with respect to t-BuOH for dehydration to olefins. No evidence for aldehyde formation (oxidative dehydrogenation) was found for either WZ or HY, consistent with the hypothesis that such a reaction pathway would require the presence of acid-basic site pairs [ 10]. Once again, masses 55 and 69 are more representative of olefin oligomers (Fig. 7). It is interesting to note again the shift toward higher temperatures for olefin oligomeric masses with respect to m/e = 412 (allyl cation, the most important propene and isobutene fragment) during TPReac of the primary alcohol. In general, WZ tends to retain water much less than HTY at higher temperatures. We have previously observed that both 1- and 2propanol release water over WZ at essentially the same time as the m/e = 41 signal [7]. The WZ is a Lewis acid upon calcination at 1096 K. It appears that water of reaction does not hydrate such sites upon alcohol dehydration. Nevertheless, there is still the question of whether some water is sti!l present at the WZ surface and if so, how reactive it would be toward isotopic exchange. 2
20
1.8
18
1.6
16
1.4
14
1.2
12
1
10 ",o
0.8
...,, 9 ,~.~176 9
0
~
o" ........... 9
. o.
9....
8
9
o
6
~
0.6 0.4
4
0.2
2
0 300
I
I
350
400
I
I
450 500 Temperature I Kelvin
I
0
,
'l
'".....
...................................... I
i
I
t
550
Tem~wu~l~
Figure 8. Ratio of masses 41/42 for the tert- Figure 9. Ratio of masses 41/42 for the tertBuOH TPReac experiments 9 Solid: t-BuOH, BuOH TPReac experiments. Solid: t-BuOH dashed: t-BuOD. HY dashed: t-BuOD. WZ Figures 8 and 9 show the ratio of masses 41/42 observed during TPReac of tert-butanol and deuterium-hydroxyl labeled tea-butanol. In principle, if there were no H+/D§ exchange (and if both masses were due to the same product molecule) we should see a constant 41/42 ratio. On the other hand, if the deuterium ion exchanges with surface sites responsible for the dehydration reaction, one should expect incorporation of D atoms into the hydrocarbon skeleton (in this case, into the allyl cation olefinic fragment which is common to both olefin monomers and oligomers). Looking at the solid lines in both Figs. 8 and 9 (unlabeled tertbutanol), it is apparent that both fragments may not belong to a single chemical species. Nevertheless, a few interesting observations can be made in regards to the experiment with tert-BuOD. In the temperature range where m/e 69 and 55 become important in the TPReac
152 of t-BuOH over HY (oligomeric masses, 450-500 K, see Fig. 5), the 41/42 ratio with tertBuOD follows an opposite trend to that observed in the tert-BuOH run. Note that due to the protic nature of HY, we expect alcohols to undergo facile H+/D§ exchange [16]. The residence time of the olefin oligomers that manage to desorb from zeolite pores is expected to be larger than that of isobutene. Hence, the larger proportion of HDC=CH-CH2 § (or H2C=CD-CH2 § in products is believed to be due to secondary species, namely olefin oligomers. A similar behavior has been observed in H-Mordenite [7]. In WZ, the smaller 41/42 ratio observed with tert-BuOD suggests that deuteration and proton exchange indeed occur rapidly prior to isobutene formation. These observations are in qualitative agreement with those of other m/(m+ 1) pairs. 4. C O N C L U S I O N In summary, tungstated zirconia solid acids are more resistant to carbon deposition in alcohol dehydration than HY. The products of this reaction are good olefin precursors and can be used as chemical probes for deactivation from conventional polymerization of carboncontaining molecules. The nature of the coke deposits is also different for the two catalysts, judging from both DRIFTS and TPO observations, these being more easily removable in WZ. This particular issue deserves further study. Reactive desorption is faster in WZ than HY, which in principle suggests that tungstated zirconia is more acidic than HY. This cannot be stated uniquivocally because readsorption phenomena may also play a role. Both WZ and HY catalyze the H+/D+ exchange of product olefins. ACKNOWLEDGMENTS We thank the donors of the Petroleum Research Fund (American Chemical Society, Grant 31067-AC5) for generous support. REFERENCES
1. 2. 3. 4. 5. 6. 7. 8. 9. 10. 11. 12. 13. 14. 15. 16.
S.L. Soled, W. E. Gates and E. Iglesia, U. S. Patent 5,422,327 (1995). G. Larsen, E. Lotero, S. Raghavan, R. D. Parra and C. A. Querini, Appl. Catal. Gral., 139 (1996) 201. G. Larsen and L. M. Petkovic, Appl. Catal. A: Gral, 148 (1996) 155. G. Larsen and L. M. Petkovic, J. Mol. Catal. A: Chem. 113 (1996) 517. V. Adeeva, G.D. LeiandW. M.H. Sachtler, Appl. Catal. A:Gral. 118(1994)Lll. E. Iglesia, D. G. Barton, S. L. Soled, S. Miseo, J. E. Baumgartner, W. E. Gates, G. A. Fuentes and G. D. Meitzner, Proc. 1 lth Int. Congr. on Catal., J. W. Hightower and W. N. Delgass, Eds., Elsevier Sci. Publ., 1996, p. 533. G. Larsen, E. Lotero, L. M. Petkovic and D. S. Shobe, J. Catal., submitted. A. Cornu and R. Massot, Compilation of Mass Spectral Data, Vol. 1, 2nd Ed., Heyden, London, 1975. S.C. Fung and C. A. Querini, J. Catal. 138 (1992) 240. G. A. M. Hussein, N. Sheppard, M. I. Zaki, and R. B. Fahim, J. Chem. Soc. Far. Trans. 1 85 (1989) 1723. H. G. Karge, W. Niel3en and H. Bludau, Appl. Catal. A: Gral. 146 (1996) 339, and references cited therein. D. G. Blackmond, J. G. Goodwin, Jr. and J. E. Lester, J. Catal. 78 (1982) 34. H. G. Karge and E. Boldingh, Catal. Today 3 (1988) 53. J. P. Lange, A Gutsze, J. Allgeier and H. G. Karge, Appl. Catal. 45 (1988) 345. C. Li, Y-W. Chen, S-J. Yang and R-B. Yen, Appl. Surf. Sci. 81 (1994) 465. F. Haase and J. Sauer, J. Amer. Chem. Soc., 117 (1995) 3780.
9
Elsevier Science B.V. All rights reserved
Catalyst Deactivation 1997 C.H. Bartholomewand G.A. Fuentes, editors
D e t e r m i n a t i o n of Coke Deposition on Metal Active Sites o f Propane D e h y d r o g e n a t i o n Catalysts P.Praserthdam*, T.Mongkhonsi, S.Kunatippapong, B.Jaikaew and N.Lim Petrochemical Engineering Laboratory, Department of Chemical Engineering, Faculty of Engineering, Chulalongkorn University, Bangkok 10330 THAILAND. e-mail : [email protected] Sn and alkali metals (Li, Na and K) can reduce coke covering on the Pt active site of a propane dehydrogenation catalyst, Pt/y-A1203. The role of the alkali metals is to increase excess mobile electrons of the catalyst surface. Sn and Sn-alkali metal promoted catalysts show higher excess mobile electrons than unpromoted ones. The excess mobile electrons enhance hydrogen spillover on the catalyst surface, thus reducing the amount of coke deposits.
I. INTRODUCTION Coking is a common deactivation mode in hydrocarbon conversion processes, involving the deposition of carbonaceous materials on the catalyst surface. Materials deposit may include elemental carbon, high molecular weight polymer and polycyclic aromatics [1,2]. Coke formation involves the metallic and acidic functions of the catalyst with the steps of dehydrogenation, condensation, alkylation and cyclization [3]. The structure of coke is rather complex, containing several different growth forms, which can be grouped into amorphous, filamentous and graphitic platelets [4-6]. The surface on which coke is deposited and their effects on coking can also vary widely. Most metallic catalysts are supported and the metal, the support and metal-support interaction can affect the coking. The thermodynamics of the dehydrogenation reaction of propane to propene are such that it is desirable to operate at high temperature and low pressure. But these conditions are the conditions that favour coke formation. Therefore, there are many attempts trying to improve the performance of the present catalyst, based on Pt/y-A1203, and to develop new catalyst compositions that yield the desired results. Sn and alkali metals are examples of promoter that can increase catalyst resistance to coking [7-11 ]. In the present work, the effect of Sn and the alkali metals (Li, Na and K) is presented. The main objective is to clarify their role in enhancing coking resistance of the resulting catalyst.
2. EXPERIMENT
Pt/y-A1203 (0.3wt%Pt), Pt-Sn/y-Al203 (0.3wt%Pt, 0.3wt%Sn), Pt-Sn-Li/y-A1203 (0.3wt%Pt, 0.3wt%Sn, 0.6wt%Li), Pt-Sn-Na/y-A1203 (0.3wt%Pt, 0.3wt%Sn, 0.6%wtNa), and
154 Pt-Sn-K/T-AI203 (0.3wt%Pt, 0.3wt%Sn, 0.6wt%K) were used in the research. The catalysts were prepared by a conventional dry impregnation method using H2PtCI6, SnCI2 and alkali metal nitrates as salt precursors. All chemicals used are normally analytical grade. Coked catalyst was prepared from the dehydrogenation reaction of C3Hs to C3H6. 0.1 mg of the catalyst was packed in a quartz reactor. 20% C3Hs, balanced with N2 was used as reactant gas. To study the effect of HE, H2 was mixed with the reactant gas at a Hydrogen/Hydrocarbon (H/HC) ratio equal to 1. All gas reactants were supplied by Thai Industrial Gas Co.Ltd. and were passed through oxygen and moisture traps before entering the reactor. The reaction was performed at near atmospheric pressure with gas hourly space velocity (GHSV) 25000 hr-1. Temperature programmed oxidation (TPO) was performed by burning the obtained coked catalyst in 1%02 in an He atmosphere. The heating rate was 10~ CO2 produced was measured using a gas chromatograph equipped with a TCD and an on-line gas sampling valve. To measure the amount of metal active sites, a CO adsorption technique was used. In the case of fresh or coked samples, the measurement was performed by monitoring the amount of CO adsorbed at room temperature. The % active site covered by coke was defined as (active site lost due to coke coverage)/(active site of fresh catalyst) x 100 The electrical conductivities of all catalyst samples were measured using a Philips PM 6303 automatic RCL meter. The catalyst was first ground to a fine powder and packed into a die. Then the sample was reduced with H2 for 1 hour. At the end of the reduction period, the powder was pressed at 13.3 MPa for 5 min. The measurement was performed under these condition. This measurement was used only for qualitative guidance.
3. R E S U L T S A N D D I S C U S S I O N
3.1. Temperature programmed oxidation and metal active site measurement Figure 1 shows the TPO profiles of 0.3%Pt/y-AI203, 0.3%Pt-0.3%Sn/y-AI203 and 0.3%Pt0.3%Sn-0.6%Li/y-A1203 catalysts. Each sample shows a TPO peak around 460~ In addition, a small peak around 100~ was observed for all catalysts used in this work. For the same operating conditions, the amount of coke deposit can be arranged in the following order: Sn-promoted > unpromoted > Sn-Li-promoted. However, when based on propane conversion, the following order was found ; unpromoted > Sn-promoted > Sn-Li-promoted. Sn-Na- or Sn-K-promoted catalysts also have less coke than unpromoted and Sn-promoted. BET surface area and metal active site measured by CO adsorption of the promoted and unpromoted fresh catalysts are shown in Table 1. The addition of Sn significantly reduced the Table 1 BET surface area and metal active site Surface area (m2/g cat) Catalyst 316 y-Al203 366 0.3%Pt/y-A1203 351 0.3%Pt-0.3%Sn/T-AI203 282 0.3%Pt-0.3%Sn-0.6%Li/y-A1203 289 0.3 %Pt-0.3 % Sn-0.6%NaJ~/-A12O3 304 0.3 %Pt-0.3 % Sn-0.6%K/y-Al2O3
Metal active site (site/$ cat) 1.63 x 10 is 0.73 x 10 is 1.17 x 10 Is 1.53 x 10 is 1.50 x 10 Is
155
number of surface Pt atom. In this case, more than half of the surface Pt atoms disappear. However, the incorporation of the alkali metals can the increase number of surface Pt atoms again. The percentage of metal active site covered by coke is shown in Figure 2. The figure demonstrates that in the low reaction temperature region ,i.e. < 550~ Sn does reduce coke deposits on the metal active site. At higher reaction temperatures, however, adding only Sn does not yield any benefit. The addition of alkali metals to Sn-promoted catalysts significantly increases the metal surface available in both low and high reaction temperature regions. 12000 ~Pt =i - - Pt-Sn ~i 9000-. . . . Pt-Sn-Li ---- Pt-Sn-Na .~ 6000 -Pt-Sn-K
/ ta~/ I I
li !
O 3000-0
' 0
- ;--- ,
100 200
,
,
300 400 500 Temp. (C)
- 9 --600
700
Figure 1 Effect of Sn and alkali metals on TPO spectra. Reaction Temperature 600~
.•100 80
~ 60
, ,-~~'"
~ 40t
1/
--Pt-A1203
"~
"/
--- -Pt- - -Sn/AI203 - - -----
~9 2 o
O450
500
550 Temp. (C)
600
650
Figure 2 Total coke deposited on the metal active site of various catalysts at different reaction temperatures. H/HC = 0 The effect of hydrogen partial pressure on % active site covered by coke is shown in Figure 3. For Pt/?-A1203 catalyst, H2 decreases coke deposits only in the initial period. On the other hand, on Sn or Sn-Na promoted samples, higher H2 pressure results in less coke on the metal active sites throughout the reaction period. This underlines the role of Sn and the alkali metals in enhancing the activity of H2 in the coke elimination process. It should be noted here that coke can cover a fraction of the metal active sites, in accordance with the literature [12,13].
156 ~100
-
O O
8
0
-
-
~
.i
~ 60--'
g O
9 40 -~i 9~
-
9-~ 20 o "< 0 0
...
I 100
pt.
H/HC=
1
"-- Pt-Sn 9H/HC = 0 -'- Pt-Sn" H/HC = 1 --,- Pt-Sn-Na 9H/HC = 0 -.- Pt-Sn-Na" H/HC = 1 I I 200 300 Time (min)
400
Figure 3 Coke deposit on the metal active site of 0.3%Pth/-A1203, 0.3%Pt-0.3%Sn/~/-A1203 and 0.3%Pt-0.3%Sn-0.6%Na/~/-A1203 catalysts at reaction temperature 500~ H/HC = 0,1. 3.2 Electrical conductivity Table 2 shows electrical conductivity data of the catalysts and the support. A is the electrical conductivity of alumina. B is the electrical conductivity of Sn and alkali metals promoted alumina. C is the electrical conductivity of Pt catalyst while !) is the electrical conductivity of Pt-Sn catalyst. E is the electrical conductivity of Pt-Sn-Alkali metals catalyst. The data shows that the addition of metal to alumina increases electrical conductivity. The addition of Sn to Pt catalyst augments electrical conductivity approximately three times. Further incorporation of the alkali metals results in an order of magnitude further increases. Since electrical conductivity reflects the mobility of electrons in the bulk solid (14), the data in Table 2 can be used to compare the amount of mobile electrons in each sample. Table 3 shows the amount of excess mobile electrons (in conductivity unit) of the catalysts shown in table 2. The value (B-A) is the electrical conductivity of 0.3wt%Sn added to ~-A1203 support. The value (D-C) is the electrical conductivity of 0.3wt%Sn added to 0.3%Pt/7-A1203 catalyst. If Sn does not have any electronic effect on the Pt site, the value (B-A) should be equal to the value (D-C). The calculation, however, clearly indicates that 0.3wt%Sn loaded on 0.3%Pt/~/A1203 catalyst does provide more mobile electrons to the catalyst than its presence on ~/-A1203 support. The addition of alkali metals also shows an interesting result. The value (E-D) is the increase in electrical conductivity of 0.3%Pt-0.3%Sn/~/-A1203 after 0.6wt% of the alkali metals was added. The result demonstrates that the alkali metals greatly increase the amount of the excess mobile electrons in the bulk catalysts. By decreasing the amount of coke, Sn functions by creating an ensemble effect and forming a solid solution with Pt in electron-rich Pt sites [15]. The proposed synergistic model for Sn addition is exhibited in Figure 4. The presence of Sn on Pt surface results in a dilution in the number of large active ensembles of Pt. Thus, it is more difficult for coke molecules to deposit on the metal surface. In addition, Sn also provides some additional electron to Pt site. Not only do the alkali metals not only act as electron donors to Pt [16], but their addition also decreases the acidity of the catalyst, which results in less coke forming on the support. Moreover, the alkali metals also promote hydrogen spillover, which can eliminate some coke already formed on the metal site. The alkali metals also act as textural promoters by reducing
157
Pt-Sn alloy formation. The synergistic mechanism model for Sn and the alkali metal addition are shown in Figure 5. Table 2 Electrical conductivity data of catalysts and support Code Catalyst Electrical conductivity (Ohm 1c m "l ) A ]r 2.15 X 10 .6 B 0.3%Sn/~/-A1203 3.05 x 10.6 0.6%Li/~-A1203 5.58 x 10-6 0.6%Na/y-A1203 5.23 x 10.6 0.6%K/7-A1203 4.04 x 10-6 C 0.3%Pt/)'-A1203 3.25 x 10.6 D 0.3%Pt-0.3%Sn/),-A1203 9.43 x 10.6 E 0.3%Pt-0.3%Sn-0.6%Li/~/-A1203 20.3 x 10.6 0.3%Pt-0.3%Sn-0.6%Na/~/-A1203 26.6 x 10.6 0.3%Pt-0.3%Sn-0.6%K/~{-A1203 74.7 x 10.6 Table 3 Amount of excess mobile electrons on the surface of bulk catalysts (in conductivity units) Equations excess mobile electrons Catalysts (Ohm-1 c m "1)
(D-C) (E-D) (E-D) (E-D)
0.3%Pt-0.3%Sn/qt-A1203 0.3 %Pt-0.3 % Sn-0.6%Li/~/-A12 O3 0.3 %Pt-0.3 %Sn-0.6%Na/7-Al2 O3 0.3 %Pt-0.3 % Sn-0.6%K/y-AlE O3
-
(B-A) (B-A) (B-A) (B-A)
5.28 7.44 14.1 63.4
x 10-6 x 10.6 x 10.6 x 10.6
C--C
C--C I C [ e-
I C
Hi
'/-A1203 Figure 4 Synergistic mechanism model for Sn addition C--C
I
C
C
I
C--C
C--C
I H/e
I
I
C
e-
fiL
~,-A1203 Figure 5 Synergistic mechanism model for Sn and alkali metal (A) addition
HI
158 4. CONCLUSIONS Test results reveal that the addition of only Sn or Sn + alkali metals (Li, Na and K) can reduce coke covering on Pt active sites of propane dehydrogenation catalyst, Pth/-Al203. Sn reduces the coke coverage area on the metal active site by creating an ensemble effect and providing additional electrons to Pt atoms. The role of the alkali metals is to increase excess mobile electrons of the catalyst surface and reduce Pt-Sn alloy formation. Sn and Sn-Alkali metal promoted catalysts show higher excess mobile electrons than the unpromoted ones. The additional excess mobile electrons enhance hydrogen spillover on the catalyst surface, thus, reducing the amount of coke deposits on the catalyst surface.
REFERENCES
1. F.Caruso, E.L.Jablonski, J.M.Graw and J.M.Parera, Appl. Catal., 51 (1989) 195. 2. B.C.Gates, J.R..Katzer and G.C.Schuit, Chemistry of Catalytic Processes, McGraw Hill, New York, 1979. 3. J.M.Parera, R.J.Venderone and C.A.Querini in Catalyst Deactivation 1987, B.Delmon and G.F.Froment (eds.), p 135, Amsterdam, 1987. 4. H.B.Palmer and C.F.Cullis, Chemistry and Physics of Carbons (vol. 1) p265, Dekker, New York, 1965. 5. R.T.K.Baker and P.S.Harris, Chemistry and Physics of Carbons (vol. 14) p83, Dekker, New York, 1978. 6. B.W.Gainey, U.S. Energy Research and Development Admin. Report. GA-A13982, UC77. 7. J.Barbier in B.Delmon and G.F.Froment (eds.), Catalyst Deactivation 1987 p135, Amsterdam, 1987. 8. J.Barbier, P.Marecot, N.Martin, L.Elassal and R.Maurel in Catalyst Deactivation 1987, B.Delmon and G.F.Froment (eds.),p135, Amsterdam, 1987. 9. R.D.Corright and J.A.Dumesic, J.Catal., 157 (1995) 576. 10. O.A.Barias, A.Holmen and E.A.Blekkan, J.Catal., 158 (1996) 1. 11. S.de Migues, A.Castro, O.Scelza, J.L.G.Fierro and J.Sorin, Catal. Lett., 36 (1996) 201. 12. J.Barbier, G.corro, P.Marecot, J.P.Bournonville and J.P.Frank, React. Kinet. Catal. Lett., 28 (1985) 245. 13. J.Barbier, E.Churin, J.M.Parera and Riviere, React. Kinet. Catal. Lett., 29 (1985) 323. 14. F.W.Sears, M.W.Zemansky and H.D.Yound, University Physics, 5th ed. p784, AddisonWesley Publishing Company 1981. 15. R..Burch, J. Catal., 71 (1981) 348. 16. J.Oudar, in J. Oudar (ed.), Deactivation and Poisoning of Catalysts, New York, Dekker, 1986.
9 Elsevier Science B.V. All rights reserved Catalyst Deactivation 1997 C.H. Bartholomew and G.A. Fuentes, editors
159
T h e R o l e o f C o k e D e p o s i t i o n in the C o n v e r s i o n o f M e t h a n o l to Olefins over SAPO-34 De Chen a, Hans Petter Rebo a, Kjell Moljord b and Anders Holmen ~ aDepartment of Industrial Chemistry, Norwegian University of Science and Technology (NTNU), N-7034 Trondheim, Norway. bSINTEF Applied Chemistry, N-7034 Trondheim, Norway. The conversion of methanol and dimethyl ether (DME) to olefins (MTO and DTO) over SAPO-34 has been studied using a Tapered Element Oscillating Microbalance (TEOM). The effect of coke formation in the MTO reaction was investigated by coking SAPO-34 to desired coke levels using different probe molecules before exposing the catalyst to methanol. Mainly internal coke was obtained when using propene, while mainly external coke was obtained when using a Ca component too large to enter the pores of SAPO-34. The coke formed from oxygenates, referred to as active coke, promoted olefin formation, while the coke formed from olefins, referred to as inactive coke, only had a deactivating effect. The role of DME during MTO was studied by comparing the MTO and DTO reactions at different coke levels. Apparently, olefins are formed via DME, and the diffusion of DME, which is affected by coke, plays a role in the conversion of methanol to olefins in MTO. The yield of olefins during the MTO reaction was found to go through a maximum as a function of both time and amount of coke. This is partly due to promotion by active coke formed initially, while further coke formation led to deactivation, probably by pore blocking. 1. INTRODUCTION The catalytic conversion of methanol to lower olefins (MTO) is a potential route for converting natural gas to chemicals. The small pore silicoaluminophosphate molecular sieve SAPO-34, which is an isomorph of cabazite [1 ], is a promising catalyst for obtaining high selectivities of ethene and propene from methanol [2, 3]. Many investigations have recently been devoted to the study of the effect of the reaction conditions on the activity and selectivity of SAPO-34 [4,5], and examination of the MTO reaction mechanism [6]. However, most of the experiments have been carried out at 100% methanol conversion due to the very active catalyst. Furthermore, the catalyst deactivates very rapidly due to coke formation, making it difficult to decouple the kinetics of the main reactions from the coke forming reactions. The effect of coke deposition on the activity and selectivity during MTO over SAPO-34 is therefore still not obvious. The Tapered Element Oscillating Microbalance (TEOM) reactor has recently been applied to study deactivation of zeolite catalysts [7,8]. The main advantage of the TEOM reactor is that all gases in the reaction mixture are forced to flow through the catalyst bed as in a conventional fixed-bed reactor. Coupled with on-line gas chromatography, the catalyst activity, selectivity and coking rate can be measured simultaneously as a function of the amount of coke on the catalyst. Hence, the TEOM represents a unique way of studying the effect of coke deposition in detail. The present work deals with the effects of coke deposition in the MTO reaction over SAPO-34 using the TEOM reactor. The effects of the external and internal coke on the activity and selectivity on SAPO-34 are studied by controlled coke formation from
160
different probe molecules. The role of dimethylether (DME) in the reaction network, was studied by comparing the results from conversion of methanol with the results from DME. 2. E X P E R I M E N T A L The reactions were carried out in a TEOM reactor where the weight of the catalyst bed is continuously recorded. The setup is similar to that described previously [8]. The methanol flow was controlled by a liquid flow controller while DME and propene were fed using gas flow controller. The MTO and DTO reactions were carried out at 425~ WHSV=417 h "I and a methanol or DME partial pressure of 8 kPa, with helium as diluent. One DTO experiment was also performed at WHSV=600 h -1 to keep the residence time identical to those from the MTO experiments. Such high space velocity and low partial pressure were used to avoid non-uniform coke distribution through the catalyst bed, and to keep the conversion well below 100% to minimize secondary reactions of olefins. SAPO-34 with a unit cell composition of (Si2.86Al17.49PIs.66)O72 and an average crystal size of 0.25 m was obtained from SINTEF-Oslo. A detailed description of the preparation and characterization of the catalyst can be found elsewhere [9]. The sample was calcined in a quartz reactor at 550~ for 6 hours in diluted air (10% O2). About 5 mg (dry basis) of calcined SAPO-34 was installed in the TEOM reactor and dried in situ at 500~ for 3 hours. Due to rapid catalyst deactivation, the MTO reaction was studied using 1 minute interrupted pulses with GC analysis taken after 1 minute. The time between each pulse was 40 minutes, allowing completion of the GC analysis. It has been found by preliminary experiments that the aging in helium did not significantly influence the coke formation and deactivation. The Cl to C6 hydrocarbons, methanol and DME were analyzed with a HP 5890 GC using a GC-Q capillary column (30 m, 0.543 mm). The amount of water formed was calculated from the mass balance. The yield of olefins was defined as: y=l- XMeOH XDME-XH20, where x is the weight fraction of each reaction component. Additional experiments with controlled coke formation were performed in order to study the effect of coke nature and location on the MTO reaction. Internal coke was obtained using propene while external coke was obtained using i-butene produced from i-butanol, iButanol was introduced by switching to a carrier gas saturated in thermostated bottles containing the liquid. After the desired coke content was reached by using propene or ibutene/i-butanol, methanol or DME was introduced at the standard MTO conditions. The pore volume of fresh and coked catalysts was determined gravimetrically by TPD of catalyst samples saturated with water at room temperature. 3. R E S U L T S AND DISCUSSION 3.1. Coke formation
A space velocity of 417 h -1 always gave a methanol conversion less than 60%. Since methanol was converted not only to olefins but also to DME and water, the yield of olefins was relatively low (maximum yield 16 wt%) at these conditions. This, combined with low catalyst loading (5 mg dry SAPO-34), allowed us to assume uniform coking through the catalyst bed. Interestingly, as coke was formed during MTO over SAPO-34, the yield of olefins went through a maximum at a coke content of about 7 wt% (Fig. 1). When DME was used as the reactant with a similar residence time, the yield of olefins increased only slightly with coke formation and went through a maximum at about 5 wt% coke (Fig. 1). The initial and maximum reaction rates and coking rates for the different reactants are presented in Table 1. The coke formation with time on stream is shown in Figure 2. The MTO and DTO initial reaction rates were identical, but the maximum MTO rate was three times higher than the maximum DTO rate. Olefin distributions were almost identical for MTO and DTO. These results indicate that methanol and DME are probably converted to olefins through the same reaction mechanism. However, the DME conversion can be retarded by such effects as slower diffusion into the pores of SAPO-34 compared with methanol. Experiments with SAPO-34 of different crystal sizes have confirmed that
161
DME diffusion limits the DME conversion. The selectivities of olefins were identical and independent of crystal size for both methanol and DME conversion [ 10]. Table 1 Reaction and coking rates over SAPO-34 Sel coke,ini2 Reactant r ini. 1,3 r max. 1 r coke, ini. r coke, max mol/g,h mol/~,h g/g,h g/~,h wt% 1.15 4.60 0.37 0.82 2.26 Methanol 1.14 1.44 0.38 2.46 DME 0.05 0.02 0.92 Propene 1) Reaction rate based on oxygenates conversion calculated on a CH2 basis [3] at WHSV=417 h 1 for methanol, 600 h ~ for DME and 417 h1 for propene. 2) Selectivity to coke=deposited coke(g)/hydrocarbons formed(g). 3) Initial data was obtained from the first pulse.
16
16
.-,o. "-'12
312
e-
r ~
8
" o o
8
-~ 4 >-
o
o
4
g o "13 .-.
O
0
4
8
12
16
Coke (wt%) Figure 1.Yield of olefins versus coke content during : 9 MTO; A: DTO at WHSV: 417 h-l; 9 : DTO at WHSV: 600 h-1;e:MTO after 3.5 wt% coke from propene.
,
0
v
5
10
15
.
.
.
.
.
20
25
30
Time on Stream (rain)
35
Figure 2. Coke formation with time on stream: m:MTO; o:MTO after 0.63 wt% coke from ibutanol; 0 : propene; A:DTO at WHSV=417 h -~" *: DTO at WHSV=600 h -1.
Similar coking rates and coke selectivities were found for methanol and DME conversion, while the coking rate was about twenty times higher and the initial selectivity was two times higher than for propene conversion. Figure 2 shows an increased coking rate during DTO as a result of lower space velocity or higher conversion. Interestingly, it can be seen that the coking rate at low coke content (< 8 wt%) is much higher than at higher coke content during DTO, while the significant decrease in the coking rate was observed at much higher coke contents (> 13 wt%) during MTO. This might be explained by pore blocking by coke and by a lower rate of reactant DME diffusion at high coke contents. The influence of methanol diffusion during MTO is less important, probably due to the smaller molecular size of methanol in comparison to DME. Studies on SAPO-34 of different crystal sizes [10] have shown that the effectiveness factor decreases significantly with coking during the DTO reaction. In contrast to the results obtained at higher conversions [11], the initial coking rate during relative low propene conversion was about twenty times lower than during the
162 methanol and DME conversions. This indicates that secondary reactions and coke formation from olefins in the gas phase are less important in the presence of oxygenates during the MTO reaction. 3.2. Effect of external coke
The SAPO-34 external surface is relatively large for the small crystal material used in this study. The role of the external surface in the MTO reaction is quite interesting but not clear. Coke deposition on HZSM-5 during methanol conversion was reported to occur essentially on its external surface [12]. Whether coke deposition during MTO on small crystals of SAPO-34 occurs in the same way is less clear. Experiments with controlled coke formation at the external surface were performed using i-butanol as a probe molecule. i-Butanol will dehydrate to i-butene on acidic sites on the external surface, but i-butanol and i-butene are too large to enter the pores of SAPO-34. Therefore, i-butene is a potential coke precursor on those external acidic sites. 20
The coking rate from i-butanol/i-butene was found to be rather low, and only 0.2 wt% o~ coke was formed when SAPO-34 was --16 exposed to i-butanol at a partial pressure of 1.2 kPa for 90 min at 425~ The formation of i-butene was confirmed by GC analysis. .E 12 tim After further exposing this sample to ibutanol at 460~ for 1 h, the coke content 0 .-8 increased to 0.63%. Furthermore, hydroo carbons heavier than C6 and aromatics were "13 absent in the products during MTO and DTO. This suggests that the acidic sites at the external surface are rather weak. If the external acidic sites are strong enough, a nonselective reaction is expected. Since similar 0 4 8 12 16 coking behavior was found for precoked Coke (wt%) samples and samples that had not been pretreated (Fig. 2), it follows that the coke Figure 3. Yield of olefins as function of formed during MTO at 425~ is formed precoke content from i-butanol during MTO: mainly in the intemal pores. However, it =: 0 wt%; e: 0.63 wt%; A:l.5 wt%. should be noted that the ethene to propene ratio increased more rapidly with coking at high coke content (Fig. 5), while the yields of olefins decreased rapidly with coking (Figs. 1 and 3). This indicates extemal coke formation at high coke content, probably occurring from growth of coke molecules originating from intemal active sites. Figures 3 and 6b illustrate that a small amount of coke formed from i-butanol/i-butene slightly increases the yield of olefins and the methanol to DME ratio during MTO. The DME yield was 3 wt% lower for the 0.63 wt% precoked sample compared with the sample without pretreatment for almost all coke levels (2 - 15 wt%). This additional DME is obviously formed at the external surface of fresh SAPO-34 during MTO. However, the role of DME formed at the external surface during the MTO reaction does not seem to be very significant. When the catalyst was exposed to i-butanol at 500~ the coke formation was relatively fast. 1.5 wt% coke was deposited during 10 minutes. The formation of olefins from methanol was lower for this precoked sample. This is probably due to n-butene formation, originating from i-butene isomerization at 500~ n-Butene probably forms inactive coke in the pores or at the pore openings, which results in significant deactivation.
163 12
r.,
~1.6
: I
1.2
8
.m LIE n
0
o
o
IX.
i.#..
"o
4
o 0.8
(11
>.
t-
t-
uJ 0.4 0
5 Coke
10
15
(wt%)
Figure 4. Yield of olefins versus coke content during DTO for different coke contents obtained from propene: &: 0 wt%; ":2.4 wt%; e: 4.7 wt%.
0
4
8
Coke
12
16
(wt%)
Figure 5. Ethene to propene ratio versus coke content during:MTOovercatalysts: (":fresh; *: 4.2 wt% from propene; o: 0.63 wt% and 0: 1.5 wt% from i-butanol); A:DTO.
3.3. Active and inactive coke The effect of coke deposition on the MTO reaction is rather complex. Coke was found to influence not only the external DME formation, but also the DME conversion taking place internally during MTO. However, the effect of coke deposition on the DTO reaction is much more simple and allows us to focus on the effect of intracrystalline coke on the DME conversion. The amount of methanol formed from DME at DTO reaction conditions is quite small since methanol formation requires water produced from olefin formation. Thus, the DTO reaction model appears to be straightforward: DME diffuses into the pores and is converted to olefins on the acidic sites in the cavities of SAPO-34. Figure 1 shows that the DME conversion increased slightly with coke formation up to about 5 wt% coke. Coke appears to have a promoting effect besides a deactivating effect on the reaction forming olefins. A number of reaction mechanisms reviewed by Froment et al. [13] have been proposed for the MTO reaction over zeolites. Although the reaction mechanism is still a matter of debate, one can assume that some kind of surface species which takes part in the reaction is formed on the active sites. Methoxy compounds in coke during methanol conversion on HZSM-5 and H-mordenite have been confirmed by NMR measurements [14]. Formation of such surface species causes mass increase, but the complete weight increase was ascribed to coke in the present work. The surface species formed can react with oxygenates to form olefins, hence creating a promoting effect. Accordingly, if larger amounts of these species are formed the rate of olefin formation is higher. Nevertheless, it must be noted that another type of coke is simultaneously formed from the olefins, when the active coke reacts with oxygenates to form olefins. Although the apparent maximum reaction rate is only 1.3 times higher than the initial rate, the net promoting effect of coke is probably larger than observed, if the deactivating effect is eliminated. A set of experiments with DTO and MTO on SAPO-34 precoked with propene were performed at 425~ to determine the role of coke formed from olefins. Due to a low propene coking rate, it was necessary to use a relatively high propene partial pressure (>30 kPa) to reach coking rates similar to those used for MTO. It is important to keep the time on stream (TOS) similar for the desired coke amounts obtained in both methanol and
164 propene conversion, since TOS might also influence the nature of coke. Propene is expected to form mainly intracrystalline coke in similar locations as in MTO or DTO. The yield of olefins over this precoked sample was lower compared to a fresh sample for the same coke content in DTO (Fig. 4) and in MTO (Fig. 1). This indicates that the nature of the coke formed from oxygenates is different from the coke formed from olefins, and that the coke formed from olefins is inactive for the MTO and DTO reactions.
4o
I
12
(a)
0
(b)
E u
LU
2zo
r~
6
0
0
-a
0 C:
~_1o
3
,e.., (D i
0
4
I
8 C o k e ('r
0
I
12
16
0
4
Coke
8
12 (wt%)
16
Figure 6. Yield of DME (a) and methanol to DME ratio (b) with coke formation after precoking with i-butanol to different levels:" 0 wt%; e: 0.63 wt%; &: 1.5wt%.
Another possible explanation for the lower conversion over precoked SAPO-34 is that the coke formed from propene would be of such a nature that it would result in a more significant decrease in the void space of the cavities. This was examined by porosity experiments using water adsorption. The pore volume found by the saturation of water for a fresh SAPO-34 was 0.30 cm3/g, which is in good agreement with literature data [15]. Although this volume is a bit larger than what was found from nitrogen adsorption (0.26 cm3/g), it is a useful parameter to specify the relative volume changes. The pore volume was found to be 0.21 cm3/g for 3.14 wt% coke during MTO, while it was 0.20 cm3/g for 3.1 wt% coke during propene conversion. The difference in pore volume was quite small, and it can be concluded that the lower activity of precoked SAPO-34 is mainly caused by the inactive nature of coke formed from olefins. Therefore, the coke in the MTO and DTO should be divided in two categories: Inactive coke formed from olefins having a deactivating effect and active coke formed from oxygenates having a promoting effect. The activity at different coke contents depends on the ratio of active to inactive coke. 3.4. Effect of coke on the ethene to propene ratio
The ethene to propene ratio is an important parameter in the MTO reaction. It is shown in Figure 5 that this ratio increases with coke formation. For similar coke contents, the ethene to propene ratio was almost identical for coke formed from both oxygenates and propene. This indicates that the ethene to propene ratio depends only on the coke content, regardless of the nature of coke. It has been found that the ethene to propene ratio was also
165
independent of the crystal size and the transition-state shape selectivity seems to be important in product selectivities. A detailed discussion about the effect of coke formation on the shape selectivity on SAPO-34 is given elsewhere [10]. However, a higher ethene selectivity by deposition of inert material in the pores to reduce the pore volume can be expected. 3.5. Effects of coke on D M E diffusion and conversion
The methanol to DME ratio was found to increase with coke formation on the catalysts (Fig. 6b). This ratio was quite far from the ratio at chemical equilibrium, which was calculated at 425~ to be 0.47. The deviation from chemical equilibrium ratio was found to be larger at higher coke contents and on the externally precoked samples. This indicates that the methanol conversion to DME is not fast enough to reach equilibrium, probably due to the moderate external acidity of SAPO-34 and partly also due to the effect of diffusion of DME at the higher coke contents. MTO can be considered a simple sequence reaction: Methanol~ D M E ~ olefins For low coke contents, the yield of olefins increased (Fig. 1) while the DME yield decreased with coke formation, even for the samples modified by external coking (Fig. 6a), where the effect of external surface was eliminated. The observed decrease in DME yield with coke formation for externally coked samples corresponds with a mechanism where DME is formed, diffuses and is converted in the catalyst pores. The diffusion of DME is expected to largely influence the olefin formation in the pores. The DME diffusivity decreased with coke formation, and the difference in activity with the amount of coke formed on SAPO-34 between MTO and DTO can then be explained by DME diffusion. Furthermore, the decrease in DME diffusivity has the opposite effect for DTO and MTO. Lower diffusivity decreases the DME concentration in the pores in DTO, hence reducing the olefin formation, while it increases the DME concentration in MTO, thereby promoting the formation of olefins. Obviously coke formation has both negative and positive effects during MTO. The positive effects are promotion by active coke and decrease in the DME diffusivity, and the negative effect is poisoning of the active sites resulting in MTO deactivation. The observed yields of DME or olefins at different coke contents represent the net result from negative and positive effects. At high coke contents, the deactivating effect which might be due to pore blocking, was dominant. This resulted in increased DME yield and decreased olefin yield. The increased DME yield is explained by faster deactivation for DME conversion to olefins rather than by DME formation from methanol. 4. CONCLUSIONS The effect of coke formation during the MTO reaction over SAPO-34 at 425~ summarized as follows:
can be
1. Methanol is converted to DME both externally and internally over SAPO-34. The DME formation at the external surface was not significant, probably due to the relatively weak external acidity of SAPO-34. The formation of DME at the external surface gave a slightly lower rate for olefin formation. The methanol to DME ratio found from experiments was far from equilibrium. 2. The coke, which was recorded as the total mass increase in the TEOM reactor, can be divided into active coke formed from oxygenates and inactive coke formed from olefins. The active coke promotes the conversion to olefins and could in fact represent the true surface intermediate of the reaction. 3. Coke reduces the DME diffusivity, which enhances the formation of olefins. 4. The coke formation enhances the ethene formation. The ethene to propene ratio increased with intracrystalline coke content, regardless of the nature of coke.
166 ACKNOWLEDGMENTS
The authors thank the Norwegian Research Council and Norsk Hydro ASA for supporting this work, and Terje Fuglerud, Norsk Hydro for fruitful discussions. REFERENCES
1. 2. 3. 4. 5. 6. 7. 8. 9. 10. 11. 12. 13. 14. 15.
N.Y. Chen, W.E., Catal. Rev. -Sci. Eng. 28 (1986) 185. B.V. Vora, T.L. Marker, P.T. Barger, H.E. Fullerton, H.R. Nilsen, S. Kvisle, T. Fuglerud, Stud. Surf. Sci. Catal., 107 (1997) 87. A.N. Ren6, P.J.J. Tromp, H.N. Akse, Ind. Eng. Chem. Res., 34 (1995) 3808. J. Liang, H. Li, S. Zhao, W. Guo, R. Wang, M. Ying, Appl. Catal. 64 (1990) 31. A.J. Marchi, G.F. Froment, Appl. Catal., 71 (1991) 139. I.M. Dahl, S. Kolboe, J. Catal., 149 (1994) 458. F. Hershkowitz, P.D. Madiara, Ind. Eng. Chem. Res., 32 (1993) 2969. D. Chen, A. Gronvold, H.P. Rebo, K. Moljord, A. Holmen, Appl. Catal., 137 (1996) L1. R. Wendelbo, D. Akporiaye, A. Anderson, I.M. Dahl, H.B. Mostad, T. Fuglerud, in preparation. D. Chen, H.P. Rebo, K. Moljord, T. Fuglerud, A. Holmen, in preparation. A. Gronvold, K, Moljord, T. Dypvik, A. Holmen, Stud. Surf. Sci. Catal., 81, 1994, 399. P. Dejaifve, A. Auroux, P.C. Gravelle, J.C. Vtdrine, Z. Gabelica, E.G. Derouane, J. Catal., 70 (1981) 123. G.F. Froment, W.J.H. Dehertog, A.J. Marchi, Catalysis (Royal Society of Chemistry), 9 (1992) 1. E.G. Derouane, J.P. Gilson, J.B. Nagy, Zeolites, 2 (1982) 42. T. Ishihara, H. Takita, Catalysis (Royal Society of Chemistry), 12 (1995) 21.
9
Elsevier Science B. V. All rights reserved
Catalyst Deactivation 1997 C.H. Bartholomewand G.A. Fuentes, editors
167
D e a c t i v a t i o n and R e g e n e r a t i o n o f A l k a n e D e h y d r o g e n a t i o n Catalysts S. D. Jackson*, J. Grenfell, I. M. Matheson l, S. Munro 2, R. Raval 2, and G. Webb I ICI Katalco, R T and E Group, PO Box 1, Billingham, Cleveland TS23 1LB, UK 1 Dept. of Chemistry, The University, Glasgow, G12 8QQ, Scotland, UK 2 Leverhulme Centre for Innovative Catalysis, Liverpool University, Liverpool L69 3BX, UK
A study of the deactivation and regeneration of a Pt/alumina catalyst used for propane dehydrogenation has shown that initially the deposit is made up of C-1 fragments, which age to form polycyclic aromatics. Both surface hydrogen and carbon can exchange with the gas phase; however, some of the carbon cannot be removed from the metal function by treatment in oxygen at 873 K. As the catalyst ages it becomes increasingly selective to propene, indicating that the carbonaceous deposit has a major role in defining the selectivity and the activity of the catalyst.
1. INTRODUCTION The dehydrogenation of light alkanes to their respective alkene is an established technology [1-4]. The catalytic systems are based either on Pt/alumina or chromiaJalumina. The process conditions are typically atmospheric pressure and high temperature. This is to ensure a satisfactory yield of the alkene as the systems are run at, or near, equilibrium. However, as is common with high temperature hydrocarbon processes, all of the catalytic systems have a wellknown propensity to lay down carbon, indeed all the commercial systems have a regular regeneration sequence to ensure sustained activity [ 1-3]. Hence the nature and reactivity of the carbonaceous deposit is important with respect to optimization of the regeneration cycle. We have also shown previously that the carbonaceous deposit has a role in the generation of selectivity within the Pt/alumina system [5]. To determine the nature and reactivity of the deposit during the course of the reaction, we have used 13C and 2H labeled propane and propene in conjunction with FTIR and GCMS analysis of the surface deposit. We have also investigated the efficacy of the regeneration process in terms of its ability to remove the deposit and to reestablish the activity/selectivity profile of the catalyst. By using this combination of techniques we have been able to specify the nature and reactivity of the deposit in the first few seconds of the catalyst life, during the time-on-stream and at the point before regeneration. 2. E X P E R I M E N T A L Two reactor systems were used in this study. Pulsed reaction studies were performed in a dynamic mode using a pulse-flow microreactor system [6], in which the catalyst sample was placed in a glass-lined stainless steel tube, in a vertical position, inside a furnace. Using this system the catalysts (typically 0.3 - 0.5 g) could be reduced in situ in flowing 5% H2/N2 (50 cm 3 min -1) by heating to 873 K at 10 K min 1 and then holding at this temperature for 0.25 h. After reduction had ceased the catalyst was maintained, at the desired temperature, in flowing helium
168 (70 cm 3 min-1). The reaction gases were admitted by injecting pulses of known size (typically 0.18 cm 3, 0.101 MPa) into the helium carrier-gas stream and hence to the catalyst. A typical reaction cycle was reduction (H2/N2)/reaction (C3H8 pulses)/regeneration (02 pulses). The pulsing of oxygen was continued until no carbon oxides could be detected and the exit oxygen equaled the inlet. Adsorption, desorption, and reaction were followed using a GC. Continuous flow reaction studies were performed in a 0.101 MPa flow microreactor with the gas stream exit the reactor being sampled by on-line GC. The catalyst sample was placed in a glass-lined stainless steel tube, in a horizontal position between two quartz wool plugs, inside a furnace. Using this system the catalysts (typically 0.3 - 0.5 g) could be reduced in situ in flowing 5% H2/N2 (50 cm 3 min -1) by heating to 873 K at 10 K min 1 and then holding at this temperature for 0.25 h. After reduction had ceased the flow was switched to propane (50 cm 3 min "1) and the first analysis taken after 3 min, subsequent analyses were taken every 9 min. Catalyst regeneration was performed by flushing the reactor with N2 at temperature before switching the flow to 5% O2/N2. The system was held under 5% O2/N 2 at temperature until no CO2 was detected in the reactor effluent. The catalyst could be cycled through this process of reduction, reaction, and regeneration. The infrared spectra were obtained using a commercial FTIR spectrometer (Mattson Centauri). The studies were performed in transmission mode, with the catalyst in the form of a pressed disc, using an environmental cell where the temperature, pressure, and gas composition could all be controlled [7]. All spectra were recorded at 4 cm l resolution with the co-addition of 300 scans using an MCT detector. The catalyst used throughout this study was a 0.65% w/w Pt/alumina prepared by impregnation of ),-alumina with chloroplatinic acid. The dried sample was calcined in air at 823 K for 3 h.
3. RESULTS/DISCUSSION A catalyst was subjected to a series of 11 reaction cycles where the number of propane pulses was increased by one on each cycle; hence, in cycle 1, only one pulse of propane was passed over the catalyst, while cycle 10 had ten pulses of propane passed over the catalyst. Cycle 11 was a repeat of cycle 1 with only one pulse of propane passed over the catalyst. The data indicated that changes were occurring with respect to the amount of carbon deposited and the ability of the oxygen to remove it effectively. In Figure 1 it can be seen that the amount of carbon deposited increases with amount of propane passed over the catalyst; however, the amount of carbon removed by the oxygen treatment at 873 K, although increasing, increases at a slower rate. Also it can be seen that the O:Pt ratio decreases from 2 initially to 0.7 indicating incomplete reoxidation. Note that although the metal particle sinters between cycle 1 and cycle 2 the O:Pt ratio does not change, as it is measuring a bulk oxidation. Therefore the residual carbon species, which are not removed by the oxygen treatment at 873 K, are affecting the ability of the Pt crystallite to reoxidize. The effect is also seen in a change in the activity/selectivity profile of the catalyst with cycle number (Figure 2). It can be seen that the catalyst loses activity but gains in selectivity with each cycle, again reinforcing that the oxygen treatment at 873 K does not restore the catalyst to its original state. A fresh catalyst was reduced and subjected to pulses of [2-13C]C3H8 as the propane feed and the product gases analyzed by GCMS. Initially the catalyst produces solely methane as a gas
169 RATIO 10 9
9
9
?
2
0
,
,
4
,
9
~
,
6 CYCLE NO.
_
~ ............. ,* , ,-F-.....
8
10
12
C:Pt DEP C:Pt BURN O:PT __m
o
.... $---
Figure 1. Ratios of (1) deposited carbon, (2) carbon removal, and (3) oxygen consumed per available Pt in pulse experiments.
2E+18 o
"o 1.5E+18 O L__ n
o
1E+18
t-O
E <
5E+17
2
m CH4/10 D
3
4
C2H4 m
5 6 7 Cycle No. C2H6 m
8
9
C3H6 m
10
C3H8
Figure 2. Variation of Pulse 2 activity/selectivity with cycle number. phase product. In this situation the ratio of [13C]CH4"[12C]CH4 was found to be 1:2 indicating complete fracture of the propane to C-1 fragments and indicating a common surface intermediate. Hence the surface species has a C:H ratio of less than 1:2. When a labeled pulse was followed by a nonlabelled pulse an exchange process was observed (Table 1) such that 8.3% of the carbon- 13 that was deposited in the first pulse was removed by the second pulse. The typical time between pulses was 0.25 h. After the catalyst had been subjected to 12 pulses, with pulses 1, 10, and 11 labeled with carbon-13, aliquots of oxygen were passed over the catalyst. The CO and CO2 produced from each oxygen pulse was analyzed by mass spectrometry and a 12C'13C ratio determined. If full surface mixinghad occurred the 12C:13C ratio would be 11.7:1, if no mixing had occurred then the ratio could be either 89:1 or 2:1. The first oxygen pulse removed
170 9.7 ~tmol C and had a 12C:13C ratio of 11.3. As the final propane pulse only contained carbon-12 and deposited 15.5 ~tmol C, then, in the absence of surface mixing, the 12C:13Cratio should have been 89:1. Indeed the lowest 12C'13Cratio observed in the CO and CO2 was 10:1 and the highest was 22.4" 1 (Figure 3). These results indicate that there is mixing of the carbon on the surface. FTIR analysis of the surface deposit confirmed the absence of adsorbed C-3 species at temperatures above 673 K. Table 1 Exchange between surface carbon species Pulse Amount of Amount of C Amount of 13C C.]H8(a) deposited (b) deposited [2-13C]C3H8 9.2 12.6 4.2 C3H8 11.2 11.3 --C3H~ 11.2 10.7 --(a) units, lxmol propane (b) units, lxmol C
12C:13Cfor methane 2:1 33"1 89"1
Amount of 13C exchanged --0.4 0.0
When a catalyst, which was not fully reduced, was subjected to pulses of [2-13C]C3H8, it was found that methane, carbon monoxide and carbon dioxide were all produced. However when the isotope ratio of each of the components was examined it was found that the CO had a 12C:13C of 1:1, while the CO2 and the CH4 had a 12C:13C ratio of 2:1. This is a surprising result yet it indicates that the route to CO2 does not go through CO, and suggests that the totally fragmented propane yields either CH4 or CO2. To achieve a 1"1 ratio it is likely that the propane has split into a C-2 fragment and a C-1 fragment with the C-1 species being retained by the surface. If the C-1 fragment was to enter the gas phase, as any of the observed components, the isotope ratios could not be obtained. The C-2 fragment is then converted to CO. This behavior suggests that site responsible for this reaction sequence is different from the metallic site and that obtained during regeneration, when the 12C:13Cratio is the same for all the gas phase species at 2:1. To study the influence of hydrogen with respect to carbon laydown and to determine whether isotope exchange occurred, a catalyst was reduced in [2H]H2 and aliquots of a 1:1 [2H]C3H8/[1H]C3H8 passed over it at 873 K at 0.25 h intervals. The only gas phase product de-
O I-,< rY "-7 (.) ..
2O
15
10
d
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
OXYGEN PULSE NUMBER
Figure 3. Removal of surface residues such as carbon dioxide.
171 tected was methane; the results with respect to hydrogen balance and carbon laydown are shown in Figure 4. It can be seen that the [1H]hydrogen (protium) balance for each pulse is negative indicating loss of protium to the surface. However the [2H]hydrogen (deuterium) balance is positive for the first four pulses indicating that the catalyst has retained deuterium from the reduction, even though the catalyst was swept with helium for 0.5 h at 873 K after the end of the reduction. The effect of this retained deuterium was to reduce to zero the carbon laydown from the first pulse. Note that this effect is specific to a deuterium reduction, carbon laydown is detected from the first pulse of propane after reduction in protium [5]. Therefore, rather surprisingly, there is a kinetic isotope effect in the laydown of carbon in this system. In subsequent pulses, as the amount of free surface hydrogen decreased, the amount of carbon deposition increased. Analysis of the methane is shown in Table 2. The table also contains data from a catalyst that was reduced in hydrogen and was subjected to sequential pulses of [2H]C3H8 and [1H]C3H8. As can be seen the first pulse reveals the presence of retained hydrogen, however the methane produced from the second pulse has a higher level of d2 and d3 species than the methane from the first pulse. Given that the carbon-13 exchange experiments indicated that 8% of the deposit could be removed by a subsequent pulse, it is likely that the enhanced yield of d2 and d3 methane during the second pulse represents that proportion of the deposit from the initial pulse that can exchange. 80
o9
6O
O u
40
0~_ ~ 20 o ~_ 0 I -20
-40
I
I
1
2
I
I
3 4 PULSE NUMBER
.B AC PROTI LARABON NUM C E BALANCE .
I
5
"DEUTERIUM BALANCE I[
Figure 4. C/H balance. A catalyst and the alumina support were run through 100 cycles of reduction/reaction /regeneration in a continuous flow reactor, where the time on each segment was reduction 6 min, reaction 1 min, and regeneration 6 min. At the end of this sequence the oxidized catalyst and support were cooled and extracted with acetone. A yellow/brown deposit found just below the reaction zone in the reactors was also dissolved in acetone. The solutions were analyzed by GCMS and were found to contain a range of polycyclic aromatics. The principal polyaromatic produced in the reactor containing the Pt/A1203 catalyst was pyrene (C16H10), followed by methyl pyrene (CI7H12). The polyaromatics produced in the reactor containing the alumina gave
172 Table 2 Distribution of isotopic methanes Ca) Pulse % CD 4 % CDaH 1. C3Hs/C3D8 64 30 2. C3Hs/C3D8 22 41 3. C3Hs/C3D8 10 34 4. C3Hs/C3D8 7 29 5. C3Hs/C3D8 5 21 1. C3Ds(b) 2 12 2. C3HsCb) 2 15 (a) Catalyst reduced in deuterium at 873 K. (b) Catalyst reduced in protium at 873 K.
% CD2H2 5 34 43 43 36 42 45
% CDH,3 0 3 13 20 39 22 22
% CH 4 0 0 0 1 0 22 16
rise to a similar range of compounds, although the principal compound was perylene (C20H12), but the quantities produced were lower by an order of magnitude. Therefore although the support has a low level of activity, it is the metal that is the primary source of these compounds. It is clear from the molecular formula and the addition of C-1 fragments that these compounds are not formed from C-3 units but are built up by the addition of C-1 units. In agreement with the isotopic labeling experiments which indicated complete destruction of the C-3 unit. Therefore the reactive C-1 units identified above combine over a period of time (< 1 min under continuous flow conditions) to form highly unreactive polycyclic aromatics. It is likely that these are the species retained by the catalyst, even through the regeneration cycle, and hence limit the extent of reoxidation. Samples of the support and catalyst were subjected to propane (2020 Pa) at various temperatures in the FTIR environmental cell. By 673 K the principal bands observable are those due to carboxylate and aromatic species (Table 3). Bands due to C-H stretch were not observed, and the intensity of the bands obtained from the catalyst sample was greater than those from the alumina by approximately a factor of 2.5. Once again there is a similarity between the species present on the alumina and those on the catalyst but with the amounts being significantly higher on the catalyst. Table 3 Infra-red spectral assignments .Sample alumina 1660 1543 Pt/alumina 1558 Assignment carboxylate
Frequency cm -1 1500 1440 1500 1440
aromatic/ aromatic/ aromatic/ carboxylate carboxylate carboxylate
1325
1184
carbonate
carbonate
Although the polycyclic aromatics detected by GCMS would give strong C-H stretch bands in the gas phase [8], if they were adsorbed with the ring system parallel to the surface then the intensity may be below detection limits. However the FTIR spectra also revealed carbonate and carboxylate species on the alumina surface. These species will also contribute to the differential between the carbon retained by the catalyst and that removed under regeneration.
173 A catalyst was subjected to 2883 cycles of reduction/reaction/regeneration in a continuous flow identical to those detailed earlier. At the end of 500, 1000, 1500, and 2883 cycles the catalyst was reduced, exposed to 10 pulses of propane, and reoxidized. Each pulse was analyzed and the reaction products fitted against a model of the principal reactions. The results are shown in Table 4.
Table 4 Analysis of reaction products
C3H6+H2 1 3.48 10 13.34 1 4.08 10 10.71 1 6.91 10 15.42 1 12.56 10 15.07 6000 hl, Temp. 873 K.
% of Propane reactin~ to 3C+4H2 40.45 21.29 27.10 16.31 29.37 18.85 16.30 7.30
2CH4+C 8.60 0.00 1.69 0.00 4.56 0.00 1.72 0.00
% C2H4 reacting CHa+C2H4 17.22 13.72 7.55 5.40 12.37 8.82 9.51 8.77
to C2H6 100 60.54 100 27.10 91.44 37.89 33.67 12.63
Clearly the main carbon deposition reaction is C3H8 ---->3C + 4H2, while the hydrogenolysis reaction, C3H8 ---->2CH4 + C, is only of importance in the early stages of the catalyst life. It can also be observed that the formation of ethane is sensitive to the amount of hydrogen produced in the system. These results indicate that there are sites, which adsorb propane, and catalyze C-H and C-C bond breaking. However these sites are only slowly deactivated. Therefore the carbon deposited on them is either easily removed by the regeneration treatment, or the carbon may diffuse away from the site. 4. CONCLUSIONS The deactivation and regeneration of a Pt/alumina catalyst used for the dehydrogenation of propane has been studied. Initially the deposit is made up of identical C-1 fragments having a C:H ratio of 1:1 or 1:2, with the overall carbon deposition reaction being represented by C3H8 ---> 3C + 4H2. The carbon deposition reaction represented by C3H8 ---> 2CH4 + C is only of importance early in the reaction cycle. As well as the C-1 species the carbonaceous deposit also contains polycyclic aromatics, that are formed by ageing of the C-1 species. These compounds are formed principally on the metal but a small amount can be formed by the support. FTIR analysis of the deposit also indicates the presence of carbonate species. Approximately 8% of the carbon deposited can exchange with the gas phase after 0.25 h, no exchange is observed at later times. Therefore the exchangeof carbon is limited to the C-1 fragments. With increasing carbon deposition the O:Pt ratio obtained during regeneration decreases implying that some of the carbon is resistant to removal from the metal function by treatment in oxygen at 873 K. Removal of isotopically labeled carbonaceous deposit from the surface reveals that there is surface mixing of carbon deposited at different times. The hydrogen associated with the deposit can exchange with both the surface and gas phase in both the fresh and aged forms. With time on stream and with increasing reaction cycle the catalyst becomes increasingly selective to propene,
174 indicating that the carbonaceous deposit has a major role in defining the selectivity as well as the activity of these catalysts.
REFERENCES
1. 2. 3. 4. 5.
6. 7. 8.
G. Homady, F. Ferrel, and G. Mills, Adv. Petrol. Chem. Refin., 4 (1961) 451. Phillips Ltd., US Patent 4,536,196 (1985). UOP Ltd., US Patent 4,716,143 (1986). P. Biloen, F. M. Dautzenberg, and W. H. M. Sachtler, J. Catal., 50 (1970) 77. S.D. Jackson, J. Grenfell, I. M. Matheson and G. Webb, in "Catalyst Deactivation 1994", Studies in Surface Science and Catalysis Vol. 88, Eds. B. Delmon and G. F. Froment, p.297 (1994). S.D. Jackson, P. Leeming, and J. Grenfell, J. Catal., 150 (1994) 170. S Munro, P