CACTI
OF THE SOUTH WEST TEXAS, NEW MEXICO, OKLAHOMA, ARKANSAS, AND LOUISIANA
by Del Weniger
CACTI OF THE SOUTHWE...
503 downloads
3509 Views
25MB Size
Report
This content was uploaded by our users and we assume good faith they have the permission to share this book. If you own the copyright to this book and it is wrongfully on our website, we offer a simple DMCA procedure to remove your content from our site. Start by pressing the button below!
Report copyright / DMCA form
CACTI
OF THE SOUTH WEST TEXAS, NEW MEXICO, OKLAHOMA, ARKANSAS, AND LOUISIANA
by Del Weniger
CACTI OF THE SOUTHWEST
NUMBER FOUR
The Elma Dill Russell Spencer Foundation Series
Echinocereus lloydii.
Cacti of the Southwest Texas, New Mexico, Oklahoma, Arkansas, and Luosiana
By D E L W E N I G E R
U N I V E R S I T Y
O F
T E X A S
P R E S S
AU S T I N
&
L O N D O N
Standard Book Number 292–70000–8 Library of Congress Catalog Card No. 78–104326 All rights reserved Printed by Brüder Hartmann, Berlin, West Germany
To Ellen Schultz Quillin
CONTENTS
Acknowledgments . Introduction .
.
.
.
.
What Is a Cactus? .
.
. .
.
. .
.
. .
. . .
Genus Peniocereus.
. .
.
.
.
.
Genus Acanthocereus . .
.
.
.
.
.
Genus Ariocarpus .
.
Genus Pediocactus.
. .
Genus Epithelantha.
. .
. .
. .
. .
. .
. .
.
. .
.
. .
.
. 55 .
.
. .
.
. 57
.
. .
.
.
. .
.
. .
. .
. 95 . 100
.
. 103
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
107
Genus Mammillaria. . . . . Key to the Mammillarias, page 112
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
110
Genus Opuntia . . . . . Key to the Opuntias, page 162
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
159
.
.
.
.
.
. 10
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Glossary .
.
.
.
.
8
63
.
.
.
.
3
Genus Echinocactus . . . . . . . . . . . . . Key to the Echinocacti, page 65 .
.
.
.
xi .
.
x
6o
.
.
.
. .
.
.
.
. .
.
.
.
. .
.
.
.
. .
.
.
.
Genus Lophophora .
.
.
.
. .
.
.
.
. .
.
.
.
. .
Genus Echinocereus Engelmann . . Key to the Echinocerei, page 11 .
.
. .
Key to the Genera of the Cacti. .
Genus WTzlcoxia .
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
. 241
Index of Scientific Names .
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
. 243
Index of Common Names . .
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
. 248
ACKNOWLEDGMENTS
Support for this study was graciously provided by a grant-in aid for research from the Society of the Sigma Xi. Appreciation is expressed to Our Lady of the Lake College which granted me time for the study and made available certain facilities for growing and photographing the plants. Gratitude is also expressed to many individuals who contrib uted in various ways to the completion of the present study. First among them is Mrs. Roy W. Quillin (Ellen D. Schulz) who gave constant encouragement and advice and the use of books from her fine library on the Cactaceae. Dr. E. F. Castetter of the Biology Department of the University of New Mexico contrib uted valuable information and some specimens from New Mexi co. He also arranged for the preparation and housing of my collection of important specimens gathered in this study. Num bering over seven hundred specimens of cacti, this collection is, as a result of his interest, permanently deposited in the herbarium of the University of New Mexico. The cacti of the following herbaria were studied in their en tirety, thanks to the help of the staffs and especially of the per sons mentioned here: the United States National Museum of the Smithsonian Institution, Dr. Jason R. Swallen and Dr. Velva Rudd being particularly helpful; the New York Botanical Gar den; the Missouri Botanical Garden in St. Louis; The Univer sity of Texas; Southern Methodist University, with appreciation to Dr. Lloyd Shinners; the University of New Mexico and Dr.
Castetter, as already mentioned; and the University of Colorado. Many others provided valuable information and aid of one kind or another. Appreciation goes to Dr. Barton H. Warnock of Sul Ross College; Drs. Claude W. Gatewood and Bruce Blauch, then of Oklahoma State University; Mr. Charles Po laski of Oklahoma City; Mr. Homer Jones and Mr. P. M. Plim mer of Alpine, Texas; Mr. Clark Champie of Anthony, New Mexico; Mr. Fred Nadolney, Mr.-Prince Pierce, and Mr. and Mrs. Earl Newhouse of Albuquerque, New Mexico; Mr. Horst Kuenzler and Mr. Dennis Cowper of Belen, New Mexico; Mr. L. J. Holland, Mr. and Mrs. S. L. Heacock, and Mrs. Ethel B. Karr, all of Colorado; Mr. and Mrs. Walter Hems of Rogers, Arkansas; Miss Lorene Martin of the Arkansas State Plant Board; Dr. T. M. Howard, Mr. Kim Kuebel, and Mr. H. C. Law son of San Antonio, Texas; Mr. Glenn Spraker of Houston, Texas; Sr. Orton Cerna of Rosita, Coahuila, Mexico; and Sr. Romo Ruiz of Musquiz, Coahuila, Mexico. Mr. Larry Nichols and Mr. Gibbs Milliken aided the writer in making some of the photographs. The photograph of Lophophora williamsii var. echinata was made by Mr. David Smith. The chromatographs mentioned in the text were run by my students, Misses Vicki Perez, Rosemary Drake, and Ethel Mat thews in the Biology Department of Our Lady of the Lake Col lege.
INTRODUCTION
Portrayed among the ancient stone carvings of Mexico, woven through the legends of that land, and central in the seal of the nation itself is the strange thick stem or the spiny jointed bush of the cactus. These plants must have been ever present for the people of that land, interesting to them and of some significance to their lives as far back as we can know. How strange to re alize then that this fantastic group of plants had never been seen by anyone in the so-called civilized world until after Columbus discovered America. Yet this must be true; for, except for two or three small, inconspicuous, and very uncactus-like species found in places even more unknown to early travelers in the jungles of Madagascar and Ceylon, the cacti grow nat urally only in the Western Hemisphere. They are as American as corn, tomatoes, tobacco, or potatoes. So they must have been seen—and felt—by the conquista dors who drove their horses across America in search of gold. No doubt these men paid little attention to the native flora as they passed, but the cacti they would have noticed for at least two reasons. How could they have failed to see the huge thick ets of these devilish plants which blocked their paths to the envisioned gold and which they had to learn to respect? And when, wandering in the arid expanses, they grew hungry and had nothing else to eat, they must quickly have learned from the Indians to spot the cactus species whose fruits were succulent and sweet to the taste. We can imagine the stories they told about these outlandish plants of the New World. These accounts must have spread very rapidly, for we already have in The Herball or Generall Historie of Plantes, by John Gerarde, published in London in 1597, the descriptions and woodcut illustrations of four cacti. Gerarde names them as fol lows: “The Hedgehogge Thistle,” which is clearly seen from the picture to be a Melocactus from the Caribbean area, “The Torch or Thornie Euphorbium,” which is easily recognized to be a Cereus, “The Thornie Reede of Peru,” another Cereus, and “The
Indian Fig Tree,” obviously a giant Opuntia. This is already an array of cacti from widely separated parts of Central and South America. Soon there followed explorers who were more directly in terested in the flora of the New World. These early explorers took living specimens of the cacti home to Europe, not only because of their uniqueness, but because they would survive the long sea voyages when other plants, except in the seed stage, would not. They could even be transported all the way without the prohibitive weight of soil on their roots. Early botanists, beginning to study these plants, faced a prob lem. Since the plants had been totally unknown in the Old World until this time, there were no words for them at all in classical Greek or Latin. Like John Gerarde, the botanists often thought of these plants, because of their spininess, as new sorts of thistles, and so the Greek word for thistle, Kaktos, became somehow applied to them. This has become our cactus of today. There were soon expeditions of botanists just to study the new plants of America. An example was the Ruiz and Paron expedition of 1777 to 1787. This expedition to Peru was com missioned by the King of Spain and encompassed ten years of exploring in most difficult terrain; Spain spent upon the ven ture twenty million pesetas. Thousands of plant specimens were sent back, with cacti among them. The interest in these strange plants grew and soon amounted to a “cactus craze.” The extent of the “craze” is hard for us to comprehend today. By 1800 businesses were being set up by French, Belgian, and German importers to sell quantities of the plants sent by professional collectors maintained in Central and South America. Societies and wealthy enthusiasts commissioned collectors to travel to America and bring them newer and yet more strange species. Extensive collections were soon formed, grown at great pains in greenhouses. About 1830 the Duke of
xii
Bedford had such a collection of cacti at Woburn Abbey. Other famous collectors in England were the Duke of Devonshire and the Reverend Mr. H. Williams of Hendon. This cultivation of the cacti must at first have been a very expensive, very genteel hobby, open only to the rich; the plants had to be expensive after having been shipped all the way from the wilds of the Western Hemisphere, and the resources neces sary to keep them alive in the climate of most of Europe before the advent of gas and electric heat must have been great. The greenhouse full of cacti may well have been one of the few warmed buildings for miles around on freezing winter nights. Borg has pointed out that the cultivation of cacti has paralleled the cultivation of orchids in many ways, and this is easy to un derstand, since these are two of the most exotic groups of plants which can be found. But the cultivation of the cacti became the common man’s hobby much more easily than did that of the orchids. With botanical associations and importers putting out long lists of available species, cacti became cheap and available in Europe in large numbers. Soon many a humble home had at least a few of these peculiar plants in a window somewhere. We like to think of this as wonderful and of these cherished cacti as beau tiful, but we must admit that even then they were not univer sally appreciated. Dickens, for instance, must have had an active aversion to them. While attesting to the broadness of the interest in cacti, his description of Paul Dombey’s nurse, Mrs. Pipchin, reveals his dislike for them, for he wrote of her, “Among her failings was a fondness for cactus. In the window of her parlor were half a dozen specimens writhing round bits of lath like hairy serpents.” Perhaps Dickens was sensing something cunning and insidious in these cacti, which events proved was there. They were early grown in southern Europe, and it was found that they could be grown without protection in outdoor gardens in southern Italy, Spain, Sicily, and Greece, on the Riviera, and, of course, all along the southern shore of the Mediterranean. In these areas are still today some of the finest cactus gardens in the world, with beautiful, hundred-year-old specimens to be seen. But once introduced into the Mediterranean area, certain of the Opuntias, the hardiest and most easily spread of cacti, found the hot, arid region too much to their liking and so escaped from cultivation and established themselves as permanent res idents of the area. These cacti have now spread through many Mediterranean countries. Though the time required to accom plish this was actually comparatively short, man’s memory is even shorter, for so completely are they already accepted as a normal part of the flora that in many areas one finds hardly a resident who realizes that his ancestors could not have known these immigrants. Sometimes one even sees cacti in pictures and movies supposedly reconstructing the time of Christ and the Roman Empire, or in otherwise accurate portrayals of classic Greek times. In one other place cacti escaped like this and became one of
cacti of the southwest
the worst plant scourges ever known. This was in Australia, where several Opuntias, in the absence of their natural enemies and in an arid situation exactly to their liking, took over mil lions of acres and rendered them useless for anything else. Much money and effort was spent in discovering how to control these cacti in Australia, and the effort has been largely successful. They have been eliminated from huge areas and are being kept in check in others. But these two instances of cacti escaping and invading new areas are the exceptions. Usually, when taken from their nat ural haunts, the cacti survive only under very precise condi tions and when great care is lavished upon them by their grow ers. Almost none of them can survive unaided even when only transplanted from one state to another within the United States. Within the Americas, where they are at home, cacti as a group are very widespread. They range from Alberta and Brit ish Columbia in Canada on the north to Patagonia, toward the tip of South America on the south. Their greatest development in both numbers and diversity is in two areas, one along the Tropic of Cancer in Mexico and the other near the Tropic of Capricorn in South America. While flourishing the most in the American deserts, they are far from restricted to these places. Special forms are found in tropical rain forests; others abound along the seashores of the Gulf of Mexico, the Caribbean, and the Pacific Ocean; while some thrive in mountain forests and a few are at home on bleak mountain slopes to as high as fourteen thousand feet. There are also some forms which abound on the Great Plains all the way into Canada, and within the United States it is said that indigenous cacti have been found growing in every state except Maine, Hawaii, and Alaska, although in many states they are so rare and inconspicuous that their presence is unsuspected by most residents. This picture of far-ranging cacti is misleading if one thinks of any single form as so far-flung. This is the range of the group, which is a huge and diverse aggregation. It is probably fruitless to try to estimate the number of cactus forms that exist, because new publications are constantly adding new-found forms to the list, as well as realigning those already known. But it is said that there are well over three thousand known species in all. Of these, almost none range across from one America to the other. A very few species, considered broadly, may range practically across a continent, and some few cover large expanses of one or the other of the Americas, but the much more usual situation is for each species to inhabit a range measured in a few hundred square miles or less. It is very common for a species to inhabit only a certain valley or mountain range, and there are numerous forms so restricted in habitat that two or three Texas-sized ranches will contain them all. As we have seen, the cacti which excited the first interest and touched off the first cactus craze were the huge and spectacular Central and South American forms. The cacti of the United States were hardly known until later. Early botanists on the east coast of the United States found only two or three very
introduction
inconspicuous and uninteresting little prickly pears which they dutifully recorded and no one got excited about. As they pushed west, they found little else until they got beyond the Mississippi River. But once they began to explore the West, the study of U.S. cacti began. The first great student of U. S. cacti was the famous botanist Dr. George Engelmann. He made his headquarters at the Mis souri Botanical Garden, the remarkable early botanical center in St. Louis, and studied the specimens and descriptions sent in by botanists on the early governmental surveys through the West. These botanists—such as Wislizenus, Wright, Bigelow, Parry, and Poselger—were the heroes of early cactus studies in the United States, and some of their names will be met with later, since Engelmann acknowledged his debt to them by some times naming cacti after them. They must have been hardy souls, riding on long treks with expeditions such as the Mexican Boundary Survey, the Pacific Railroad Survey, Pike’s expedi tion, and others; and one must admire their stamina, gathering cacti all day on the trail, then, while the others rested, making their records and descriptions and packing up specimens of these unpleasant-to-handle plants to send back to Engelmann. Their routes took them through the heart of the cactus country of the West, and we are amazed at the number of plants found only in places almost inaccessible even a hundred years later, which they located and recorded so long ago. Beginning in about 1846, Engelmann started publishing the results of these expeditions. He faced the herculean task of list ing and describing a huge population of cacti almost unknown before to the world. He coined names for the multitude of forms, worked out something of their relationships, and pre sented descriptions and some of the finest botanical illustrations ever made for any plants. Although his material was sometimes incomplete and so his descriptions were sometimes deficient, he gave us the first information we have of approximately twothirds of the U. S. cacti, information so remarkably accurate that in a few cases it has taken us almost a hundred years to verify it. Modern concepts have sometimes revised his ideas of the relationships between the forms, but almost never have we found him in error when he told where a plant grew or what it looked like. The next effort at studying the cacti of the United States was made by the great botanist John M. Coulter. In 1894 he began publishing a major work on the cacti of North America. Mostly he built on the foundation laid down by Engelmann, with the benefit of much more material collected since Engelmann’s time, but he added little really new to what was already known. It is indicative of the difficulty of studying cacti that he is said to have given up the study of this group in disgust and spent the rest of his life with other plant groups after misidentifying a cactus he had earlier named himself. About the same time as Coulter’s study, a large, general work on cacti was being produced in the German language by Karl Schumann. He did firsthand work on the cacti of the then In
xiii
dian Territory and the Canadian River area, but did not travel widely in the United States, and so his work has limited value for us today in the study of U. S. cacti. A major project on cacti was then undertaken by the Car negie Institute. Dr. N. L. Britton and Dr. J. N. Rose, with the support of that institution, undertook to list and describe all the cacti of the world. They traveled widely throughout the Americas and visited the European collections, and as a result published a four-volume work, The Cactaceae, in 1919 to 1923. Their work had probably the greatest effect of anything ever published on the study of cacti as well as on the growing pop ularity of these plants. They greatly revised the classification of the group, adding a multitude of new genera and species, and their beautiful volumes, with fine color illustrations, were widely circulated, giving many people, especially in the United States, their first knowledge of the beauty of the cacti. Even today, most people still think of cacti strictly in the terms of the Britton and Rose accounts. No new attempt to encompass all of the cacti in one large study was made for many years. The task had become just too big. But the great German student of cacti, Curt Backeberg, did not flinch at the challenge, and in 1958 he brought out the first volume of a new world-wide survey, Die Cactaceae. It was completed shortly before his death and comprises six large vol umes of fine descriptions, with many good pictures of the cacti of the world. It is truly a monumental work. But the great diversity of the cacti and the fact, already men tioned, that the majority of them are limited to areas which are very small (often single mountain ranges or river valleys), when set against the huge expanse covered by the group as a whole, make it very difficult for any major flora or all-inclusive cactus work to be useful on a local level. Who wants to carry the four volumes of Britton and Rose or the six of Backeberg to the Big Bend of Texas or the mountains of Peru? And if these works were to give really detailed accounts of the cacti found in all of such areas, exactly the information which the local student needs, they would become encyclopedic in size. This fact ex plains the numerous regional publications on cacti, both articles in journals and separate books. If one is to understand the local cacti, he must refer to these publications, done by people on the scene who have studied the larger picture and then sought out and portrayed the details of the local forms he sees about him. This book is intended to be such a regional guide. In the United States there has long been a tendency to break down the treatment of cacti into state studies. States are artifi cial areas and their boundaries have nothing to do with plant distribution, but it has been impossible to ignore them. The pres ent study, however, includes the cacti of five states: Arkansas, Louisiana, Oklahoma, Texas, and New Mexico. These five states make up a unit much more logically considered, cactuswise, than any one of them alone, and a unit for whose cacti there has never been a complete guide. While lists of cactus species and some good descriptions are found in the floras of the respective
xiv
states (as for instance those of Wooton and Standley for New Mexico) and many articles concerning various cacti in this re gion are scattered all through the literature, there has been only one complete work on cacti within this area: Texas Cacti, by Ellen D. Schulz (Mrs. Roy Quillin) and Robert Runyon. This was published in 1930, covered only the cacti of Texas, and is now out of print. The need for such a guide for these five states seems, there fore, clear. While the cacti of the far Southwest have been dealt with in numerous publications—Stockwell and Brezzeale’s Ari zona Cacti of 1933, Baxter’s California Cacti of 1935, Boisse vain and Davidson’s Colorado Cacti of 1940, Benson’s The Cacti of Arizona of 1950, and Earle’s Cacti of the Southwest of 1963—none of these covered more than those few forms of cacti which happened to extend their range into our area from the West. And where the cacti of this five-state area have been written about in journals or magazines it has usually been done by students who lived and worked in the far West or even in Europe, and who wrote of our cacti after brief trips through this vast area or from secondhand accounts. The cacti of this area have not lacked a detailed treatment because they were fewer in number or less diverse than those of the far Southwest. If anything, they may have presented too great a challenge just because of their number. I have found some professional botanists who believed, probably because of the greater size and conspicuousness of the Arizona species plus the greater publicity they have received, that the greatest specia tion in the United States occurs in the far Southwest. Actually, this is not true. Texas alone presents more species of cacti than all of the rest of the United States combined. L. Benson lists 60 cactus species in Arizona. California is said to have about 20 natives; and New Mexico, about 50. On the other hand the number of separate species listed here for our five-state area is 119. Earle, the most recent writer on the cacti of the Southwest, lists 121 forms, counting varieties as well as separate species for all of California, Arizona, Colorado, Utah, Nevada, and west ern New Mexico. Within our area we find 172 different forms. Within Texas alone can be found 106 species and 142 recogniz able forms. The present work, then, lists all of the forms of cacti presently known to be growing within the five states: Arkansas, Loui siana, Oklahoma, Texas, and New Mexico. They are listed by their recognized scientific names, and immediately following (in every case where such exist) are given all of the common names which could be discovered, by which the cactus is known in various localities, including the Spanish and sometimes the Indian names. Spellings of these common names show the local variations found in the literature. A description of the whole cactus plant, not meant to be te dious but made full enough to be useful for the serious student, is then given. This description is patterned on the original one of the species, but it takes into account other descriptions by more recent students plus our own observations and so may be
cacti of the southwest
broader than the original in the case of quantitative characters and may add information not covered in the original. Following this is outlined the known range of natural distribu tion for the cactus. This is given in rather general terms, partly because there is still more to be learned about the spread of some of these plants and partly because it is not meant to be a guide telling exactly which mountain slope will provide the collector with the cactus he wants. The publication of such specific infor mation all too often has meant that the slope is bare of any cacti at all the next year. There are no laws protecting cacti in any of the states covered in this study, and the conservation of our cacti is a real problem today. While this work gives no in accurate or misleading information about where the various cacti are to be found, the exact locations of specific populations are not usually given. Any cactus hunter worthy of the title of “cactophile,” once given the general territory where the plant grows, might rather search out the prize himself. Next follows a discussion of each cactus listed. This is a gathering together of any remarks I might have on anything unusual or especially interesting about the cactus. Included under remarks also, because these are purely my own opinions after studying the plants and the literature upon them, are sug gestions concerning its relationship to its fellows, with restate ment of the specific characters which distinguish it from its closest relatives. These relationships are very complex, and the concepts of them have been almost constantly changing throughout the study of the cacti, as can be quickly traced by looking at the synonymy in almost any listing. In an attempt to avoid making this part another series of synonym lists in fine print—or a dry, dead discussion of dead names-this synonymy is presented as a historical account of the vicissitudes through which individ ual cactus forms, individual plant names, and the ideas of in dividual students went from their discovery and their first statements until the present. Such a historical approach to this material has not been made before, and it can enable us to understand much about the science of botany and about men, as well as about cacti. Of course, the material is much simplified and rendered as nontechnical as possible. Nevertheless an at tempt is made to evaluate fairly, from the vantage point of the present, each important author's arguments and to assign his proposal its proper place in the history of the cactus being dis cussed. Lastly, each cactus form is illustrated by a full-color pho tograph of the plant, in most cases in bloom. A few of these photographs were made in the plant's natural location, but in most cases this proved to be impractical. Most cacti bloom only a few days out of the year, and it was obviously impossible to be in a canyon of the Texas Big Bend, on the Wichita Moun tains of Oklahoma, on an Indian reservation in northwest New Mexico, and on an Ozark slope in Arkansas on precisely the days when each cactus chose to bloom. Much effort, therefore, has gone into the work of locating the various forms in the
introduction
wild, then bringing them in and growing them in such con genial environments that they have bloomed, so that they could be pictured at the right moment. Unless otherwise stated, I made all photographs myself. The soils and backgrounds visible in the pictures are, there fore, not usually the natural environments of the plants. In fact, the colors of these have often been chosen to contrast with and make as clearly visible as possible the spines and other charac ters of the cacti. This means that no conclusion about the en vironments of these plants can be drawn from these pictures. While some readers may consider this a drawback, it should be remembered that most of these cacti use protective coloration and camouflage. Pictures of them in their natural habitats, while of value to the ecologist, usually show little detail of the plants, if they are visible at all. An extreme illustration of this diffi culty would be the case of Mammillaria nellieae Croiz., where the whole plant is usually totally covered by the moss which grows with it in its rock crevice; a picture of it in loco would show only the flower apparently blooming on the moss and would be useless in illustrating what the cactus is really like. In the verbal description of the flower parts, I was confront ed with the choice of employing standardized color names, such as those given in A Dictionary of Color by Maerz and Paul, or of using more general terms which would be meaningful to the average reader. I decided on the latter course in the belief that what would be gained in preciseness by the use of terms from A Dictionary of Color would be counterbalanced by the incon
xv
venience of having to consult this reference work in a library in order to determine what was meant by the shade names used. Although as full as possible a rendering of the beauty of the flowers is an aim of these pictures, this is not their only goal. It is hoped that they may also convey a real concept of the plant body itself and of the spine character; sometimes the flower is shown at less than full angle because of this other aim. In organizing this presentation, one of the biggest problems was the delineation of the genera. The widest possible range of opinions is held today by the different authorities in the field on the limits of the genera in the Cactaceae. It seems that the present extent of the knowledge of the cacti does not enable anyone to give as definite a list of cactus genera as can be made for many other plant groups. There are several very different systems of genera, each very logical in the light of a certain set of assumptions. I have attempted to re-evaluate these in the light of the latest research available. The work of Dr. Boke at Oklahoma University and results of our own chromatographic studies seem particularly important here. The resulting align ment of the genera is in no case a new one, but in some cases favors one previous proposal and in some another. Within the genera no attempt has been made to organize the species into tribes or sections, since this sort of thing—as, for instance, various proposals for the genus Opuntia—seems still to be based on conjecture, and I find little newer and more solid evidence for any of the various contradictory proposals already made.
P L AT E S
Measurements given in the photograph captions are the plant body sizes of the specific plants pictured and do not, unless otherwise stated, include flowers. In most cases this size is smaller than the maximum size achieved by the species.
Echinocereus viridiflorus var. viridiflorus. Larger plant 21/4 inches tall.
Echinocereus viridiflorus var. cylindricus. 41/4 inches tall.
Echinocereus viridiflorus var. standleyi. 4 inches tall.
1
Echinocereus davisii. 1 inch tall.
Echinocereus chloranthus var. chloranthus. Young plant (left): mature plant, 4 inches tall (right).
Echinocereus chloranthus var. neocapillus. 31/2 inches tall.
2
Echinocereus chloranthus var. neocapillus. Immature plant (center), 11/4 inches tall, flanked by mature specimens.
Echinocereus russanthus. 41/2 inches tall. (above, right) Echinocereus caespitosus var. caespitosus. The white-spined “Lace Cactus,” 3 inches tall.
Echinocereus caespitosus var. caespitosus. The brown-spined “Brown-Lace Cactus,” 5 inches tall.
3
Echinocereus caespitosus var. minor. Largest stem pictured, 2 inches tall.
4
Echinocereus caespitosus var. perbellus. 2 inches tall.
Echinocereus melanocentrus. 2 inches tall. (above, left) Echinocereus caespitosus var. purpureus. 31/3 inches tall.
Echinocereus fitchii. 21/4 inches tall.
5
Plate 6 (above, left) Echinocereus baileyi. White-spined. 41/4 inches tall. (above, right) Echinocereus baileyi. Brown-spined, clustering. Largest stem pictured, 21/4 inches tall. (below) Echinocereus albispinus. Tallest stem pictured, 2 inches high.
Plate 7 (opposite) (above, left) Echinocereus pectinatus var. wenigeri. Stem 41/2 inches tall. (above, right) Echinocereus pectinatus var. rigidissimus. 6 inches tall. (below, left) Echinocereus chisoensis. 7 inches tall. (below, right) Echinocereus pectinatus var. ctenoides (right) and Echinocereus caespitosus var. caespitosus (left). Note typical ovary and fruit coverings.
7
Echinocereus pectinatus var. ctenoides. 3 inches tall.
8
Echinocereus dasyacanthus var. dasyacanthus. Yellow-flowered. 101/2-inch stem.
Echinocereus dasyacanthus var. dasyacanthus. Pink-flowered. 12-inch stem.
Echinocereus dasyacanthus var. hildmanii. Stem 5 inch tall.
9
Echinocereus roetteri. 43/4 inches tall.
10
Echinocereus lloydii. 12 inches tall.
Echinocereus triglochidiatus var. triglochidiatus. 8 inches tall.
11
Echinocereus triglochidiatus var. octacanthus. Stems 41/4 inches tall.
(below, left) Echinocereus triglochidiatus var. gonacanthus. 4 inches tall. (below, right) Echinocereus triglochidiatus var. coccineus. 61/2 inches tall.
12
Echinocereus coccineus var. conoides. 8 inches tall.
Echinocereus polyacanthus var. rosei. 8 inches tall.
Echinocereus polyacanthus var. neo-mexicanus. 41/2 inches tall.
13
Echinocereus stramineus. Clump, 30 inches in diameter.
Echinocereus enneacanthus var. carnosus. Tallest stem 8 inches high.
14
Echinocereus enneacanthus var. enneacanthus. Clustered stems, 13 inches across.
Echinocereus fendleri var. rectispinus. Tallest stem pictured, 8 inches high. (above, left) Echinocereus fendleri var. fendleri. Stem 53/4 inches tall.
Echinocereus dubius. Tallest stem 9 inches high. Two specimens of Lophophora williamsii in right foregrounds.
15
Echinocereus papillosus var. angusticeps. Tallest stem pictured, 3 inches high. (above, right) Echinocereus papillosus var. papillosus. Sprawling stems, 2 inches high.
Echinocereus pentalophus. Stems approximately 3/4 inch in diameter.
16
Wilcoxia poselgeri. Single upright stem, 12 inches long. Echinocereus papillosus var. papillosus on ground. (above, left) Echinocereus blanckii. Stem pictured, 101/2 inches long.
Echinocereus berlandieri. Tallest stems pictured, 4 inches high.
17
Peniocereus greggii. Flowers 27/8 inches in diameter. (below, left) Acanthocereus pentagonus. Flower 61/2 inches long, including ovary and tube. (below right) Echinocactus horizonthalonius var. curvispina. 6 inches in diameter.
18
Echinocactus texensis. 6 inches in diameter. (above, left) Echinocactus horizonthalonius var. moelleri. 7 inches in diameter.
Echinocactus asterias. 21/2 inches in diameter.
19
Echinocactus uncinatus var. wrightii. 8 inches tall. (above, left) Echinocactus wislizeni. 14 inches in diameter.
Echinocactus whipplei. 3 inches in diameter.
20
Echinocactus mesae-verdae. 13/4 inches in diameter.
(below, left) Echinocactus brevihamatus. 4 inches tall. (below, right) Echinocactus scheeri. 21/2 inches tall.
21
Echinocactus tobuschii. 25/8 inches in diameter.
(below, left) Echinocactus setispinus var. hamatus. 7 inches tall. (below, right) Echinocactus setispinus var. setaceus. 10 inches tall.
22
Echinocactus sinuatus. 5 inches diameter. Echinocactus hamatacanthus. 12 inches in diameter. (below, left) Echinocactus bicolor var. schottii. 4 inches in diameter. (below, right) Echinocactus flavidispinus. 2 inches in diameter.
23
24
Echinocactus intertextus var. intertextus. When collected, 23/4 inches in diameter.
Echinocactus intertextus var. intertextus. Same plant after 1 year of cultivation. 27/8 inches in diameter.
Echinocactus intertextus var. dasyacanthus. 23/4 inches in diameter.
Echinocactus erectocentrus var. pallidus. 21/2 inches in diameter.
Echinocactus mariposensis. Green-flowered. 15/8 inches in diameter.
Echinocactus conoideus. 3 inches in tall.
Echinocactus mariposensis. Pink-flowered. 17/8 inches in diameter.
25
Plate 26 (above, left) Ariocarpus fissuratus. 35/8 inches in diameter. (above, right) Lophophora williamsii var. williamsii. Largest stem 3 inches in diameter. (below) Lophophora williamsii var. echinata. Largest stem 21/2 inches in diameter.
Plate 27 (opposite) (above, left) Pediocactus simpsonii var. simpsonii. 3 inches in diameter. (above, right) Pediocactus knowltonii. 1 inch in diameter. (below, left) Pediocactus papyracanthus. 2 inches tall. (below, right) Epithelantha micromeris. 11/2 inches in diameter.
26
27
Mammillaria scheeri. 6 inches in diameter.
Mammillaria scolymoides. 31/4 inches in diameter.
Mammillaria echinus. Stem 21/4 inches in diameter.
28
Mammillaria sulcata. 41/8 inches in diameter.
Mammillaria ramillosa. 31/4 inches in diameter.
29
Mammillaria macromeris. Young plant, not yet clustered. 3 inches tall.
(below, left) Mammillaria runyonii. 4 inches in diameter. (below, right) Mammillaria similis. Typical small plant; diameter 3 inches.
30
Mammillaria similis. Old plant in full bloom. Diameter 12 inches.
Mammillaria vivipara var. vivipara. 21/4 inches in diameter.
31
32
Mammillaria vivipara var. arizonica. 3 inches in diameter.
Mammillaria fragrans 21/4 inches in diameter.
Plate 32 (opposite) (above, left) Mammillaria vivipara var. radiosa. 2 inches in diameter. (above, right) Mammillaria vivipara var. neo-mexicana. Large stem 21/4 inches in diameter. (below, left) Mammillaria vivipara var. borealis. 2 inches in diameter. (below, right) Mammillaria vivipara var. neo-mexicana. Young plants, showing juvenile spination on sides of stem and mature spines at the tips. Larger plant 2 inches in diameter.
33
Plate 35 (opposite) (above) Mammillaria dasyacantha and tuberculosa, growing together. (below left) Mammillaria duncanii. Showing root formation. Spiny portion of the stem 1 inch tall. (below right) Mammillaria duncanii. Same plant, with fruit, after 3 months’ cultivation.
Mammillaria tuberculosa. Main stem 35/8 inches tall.
34
Mammillaria dasyacantha. Plant pictured, 3 inches in diameter.
35
Mammillaria albicolumnaria. Plant pictured, 27/8 inches in diameter.
36
Mammillaria varicolor. Largest stem 12/3 inches in diameter. (below, left) Mammillaria hesteri. 4 inches tall. (below, right) Mammillaria nellieae. Blooming plant, 1 inch in diameter.
37
Mammillaria roberti. Largest stem 13/8 inches in diameter.
Mammillaria sneedii. Blooming stem 3/4 inch in diameter.
38
(above, left) Mammillaria leei. Plants in garden cultivation. Clusters 4 to 6 inches in diameter. (above, right) Mammillaria leei. Typical root formation. Large clump, 41/4 inches across. (below, left) Mammillaria pottsii. Largest stem, 11/3 inches across. M. lasiacantha var. denudata in foreground. (below, right) Mammillaria lasiacantha var. lasiacantha. Stem 1 inch in diameter.
39
Mammillaria lasiacantha var. denudata. Stem 2 inches in diameter.
Mammillaria multiceps. Cluster of stems, 41/8 inches across.
40
Mammillaria microcarpa. 2 inches tall.
Mammillaria wrightii. Stem 13/16 inches in diameter.
41
Mammillaria wilcoxii. Stem 17/8 inches in diameter.
Mammillaria heyderi var. heyderi. 41/3 inches across.
Mammillaria heyderi var. applanata. 4 inches across.
Plate 43 (opposite)
42
(above) Mammillaria heyderi var. hemisphaerica. 31/2 inches across. (below) Mammillaria meiacantha. 4 inches across.
43
Mammillaria sphaerica. Main plant, with offsets, 43/4 inches across.
Opuntia stricta. Plant pictured 26 inches tall.
Opuntia engelmannii var. engelmannii. Pad 12 inches long.
44
Opuntia engelmannii var. texana. Largest pads pictured, 8 inches wide.
Opuntia engelmannii var. alta. Red-flowered. Blooming pads, 51/2 inches across.
45
Opuntia engelmannii var. flexispina. Main pad 101/2 inches wide. White spots are cochineal insects.
Opuntia engelmannii var. alta. White-flowered. Flower 31/8 inches across.
46
Opuntia engelmannii var. cacanapa. Largest pad shown, 7 inches across.
Opuntia engelmannii var. aciculata. Largest pad 62/3 inches across. (above) Opuntia engelmannii var. dulcis. Largest pad 8 inches in diameter. This plant grew for many years in an urn by the entrance to the Old Trail Driver’s Museum in San Antonio.
Opuntia engelmannii var. subarmata. Main pad 12 inches across.
47
Opuntia engelmannii var. linguiformis. Blooming pad 16 inches long. White spots are cochineal insects.
(below, left) Opuntia chlorotica. Plant about 22 inches tall. (below, right) Opuntia tardospina. 9 inches tall.
48
Opuntia rufida. Largest pad pictured, 7 inches long. (above, left) Opuntia spinosibacca. Largest pad pictured, 53/4 inches long.
Opuntia macrocentra. Largest pad pictured, 6 inches long.
49
Opuntia gosseliniana var. santa-rita. 15 inches tall. (below, left) Opuntia strigil. Largest pad pictured, 73/4 inches long. (below, right) Opuntia atrispina. Largest pad pictured, 6 inches across.
50
(above) Opuntia phaeacantha var. major. Largest pad shown, 8 inches across. (below) Opuntia phaeacantha var. nigricans. Old 6-inch pad sprawling; and new, sprouting 4-inch pads.
(above, left) Opuntia leptocarpa. Shown in fruit. Plant 15 inches tall. (below, left) Opuntia leptocarpa in foreground and Opuntia engelmannii var. texana in background.
51
Opuntia phaecantha var. brunnea. Wide-open flowers, 3 inches across.
52
Opuntia cymochila. Largest pad pictured, 4 inches across. (above, left) Opuntia phaeacantha var. camanchica. Largest pad pictured, 41/3 inches long.
Opuntia phaeacantha var. tenuispina. Pads 9 inches long.
53
Opuntia compressa var. humifusa. Largest pad pictured, 3 inches across.
Opuntia compressa var. macrorhiza. Pad 4 inches long, blooming.
Opuntia compressa var. microsperma. Largest pad pictured, 3 inches long.
54
Opuntia compressa var. fusco-atra. Two specimens from the same locality. Largest pad on stunted plant, 21/4 inches long; largest pad on vigorous plant, 5 inches long.
Opuntia compressa var. fusco-atra. An abnormal form known as O. macateei. Open flower 2 inches across. Opuntia compressa var. grandiflora. Largest pad pictured, 51/4 inches long.
Opuntia compressa var. allairei. Largest pad pictured, 61/4 inches long.
55
Opuntia compressa var. stenochila. Largest pad pictured, 4 inches across.
Opuntia ballii. Pad 21/3 inches across.
Opuntia pottsii. 61/2 inches tall, exclusive of fruits.
56
Opuntia plumbea. Pad 21/4 inches long.
Opuntia drummondii. Largest pad pictured, 3 inches long.
Opuntia fragilis. Clump 61/2 inches across.
Opuntia sphaerocarpa. In winter condition. Largest pad pictured, 31/4 inches across.
57
Opuntia rhodantha var. rhodantha. Yellow flowered. 61/2 inches tall.
58
Opuntia rhodantha var. spinosior. Larger pad pictured, 41/2 inches long.
Opuntia rhodantha var. rhodantha. Pink flowered. 8 inches tall.
Opuntia polyacantha. Typical, heavily spined. Largest pad pictured, 4 inches long.
Opuntia polyacantha. With spines few and short. Largest pad pictured, 55/8 inches long.
Opuntia hystricina. Upright pad, 4 inches long.
Opuntia arenaria. Largest pad pictured 23/4 inches long.
Opuntia grahamii. Pictured clump, 7 inches across.
59
Opuntia Stanlyi. Largest joint pictured, 4 inches long. (below, left) Opuntia schottii. Pictured joints, each 2 inches long. (below, right) Opuntia clavata. Largest joints pictured. 11/2 inches in diameter.
60
Opuntia imbricata var. arborescens. Branch white ripe fruits. Main pictured. 11/4 inches in diameter. Opuntia imbricata var. viridiflora. Pictured plant 15 inches tall.
(above, left) Opuntia imbricata var. arborescens. Section of the main stem pictured, 11/4 inches in diameter. (below, left) Opuntia imbricata var. vexans. Branch with ripe fruits. Largest fruit pictured, 15/8, inches in diameter.
61
Opuntia spinosior. Largest stem pictured, 1 inch in diameter.
62
Opuntia whipplei. In winter condition, 10 inches tall.
Opuntia davisii. Largest branch pictured, 5/8 inch in diameter.
Opuntia tunicata. Plant pictured, 13 inches across.
63
Opuntia leptocaulis. Main stem pictured, 1/4 inch in diameter.
64
Opuntia kleinei. Plant pictured, 4 feet tall.
CACTI OF THE SOUTWEST
What Is a Cactus?
B
efore going directly into the description of the various cacti we might pause to consider, for those who have not con cerned themselves about these things before, how a cactus differs from other plants, what is so special about it, and what are some of the problems the uniqueness of its form and physiology bring to it in its natural situation and to us if we desire to raise it. It is harder to say exactly what a cactus is and how it differs from other plants than one might think. It is obvious that a cactus is a unique plant, with special problems. Imagining how it got that way, learning how to recognize it when we see it, and understanding its adaptations to its special problems—each of these presents us with special difficulties. The origin of the cactus family remains almost completely a mystery. We are balked here by the fact that there are no fossils of any cacti. So anxious have we been for such evidence that there have been several remains grasped hopefully as being cac tus fossils, but all these, such as the famous one optimistically christened Eopuntia douglassii Chaney, have since proved not to be connected with the cacti at all. The most primitive and least cactus-like forms that we know are the members of the genus Pereskia, still alive, flourishing, and all-cactus, giving us no clear clues as to how they got that way. This leaves us with only theories based on comparative anatomy studies to satisfy us. Mostly because of certain flower characteristics, it is quite often assumed that cacti are related to the Rose Family. From here one can go as far as his imagination chooses to range, pre suming with some that the roses of the West Indies changed in order to adapt to more arid conditions and so gave rise to the Pereskias and through them to all cacti. This is an enchanting story, and I am sure that the cactophiles are pleased with the idea that their favorites might be descendants of the rose, but I am not so certain that the rose enthusiasts are as sympathetic to
the idea of appending the cacti to their queen of the flowers. Most agree that the cacti are a young group, maybe 20,000 years old, and an equally big problem is how they could have developed their extreme and fantastic adaptations in such a comparatively short time. Be that as it may, the cacti are here, and one needs to know how to recognize them. This task is complicated by the fact that most of the obvious characters by which one thinks to recog nize them are shared by some plant or other somewhere in the world. This is true of such things as large, fleshy stems, vicious spines, and reduction of leaves, which to an amateur mean cac tus every time. There are other plants showing all of these char acteristics, some of them to almost the extent the cacti do. It is a failure to recognize this fact that accounts for the pop ular articles, nursery ads, and many “cactus plantings,” contain ing mention or actual specimens of completely unrelated plants under the banner of cactus. Although they show some at least of the above characteristics, it must be stated that such things as yuccas, agaves, century plants, sotol, and so on, are not cacti at all, but extremely modified members of the Lily Family. Ocotillo and allthorn are individual residents of the desert com munity showing some of the same adaptations, but belonging to other plant families. Then there is the whole multitude of Afri can plants paralleling the cacti in almost every feature of stem, rib, spine, and leaf, but all belonging to the huge, world-wide genus Euphorbia which also includes such plants as the Poin settia. We sometimes speak of all these other plants as succu lents, setting up the categories of cacti and succulents—although the cacti are also succulent, since the word merely means “fleshy.” How then do you tell a cactus? There is no easy way to do it without close observation of details and something of a bota
4
nist’s eye. However, a cactus is always a dicot, and its two seed leaves will distinguish it at once from all those members of the Lily Family so often called cacti, since they are monocots and have only one seed leaf. Then, a feature which all cacti have and share with no other plant is the structure called the areole. All cacti have areoles quite liberally scattered over the surface, and usually arranged in rows or spirals in the most conspicuous places. These are round to elongated spots from 1/16 to sometimes well over 1/2 inch in greatest measurement; their surfaces are hard, rough, uneven, and brown or blackish or else covered with white to brown or blackish wool. These areoles are now considered to be the equivalent of complex buds, and it is from these that what ever spines the cactus possesses grow. These spines, since they come from these areoles, are always arranged in clusters, which is another feature not found on other spiny plants, whose spines are produced singly from some source other than an areole. Beyond this, for the actual features separating cacti from all other plants, one has to look to the flower. Certain rather tech nical features of the flower are cited, such as its having sepals and petals numerous and intergrading, its having an inferior ovary with one seed chamber and having one single style with several stigma lobes. The key to understanding why the cactus is such a strange plant is the understanding of its major problem and how it solves it. This is its water problem. Most plants are great spendthrifts when it comes to water. They stand with their roots in unfailing water supplies from streams or from moisture stored in the soil between rains; and they constantly absorb quantities of water, which they use and then pass on out through their leaves into the atmosphere. This passage of water through the typical plant is so great that we call it the transpiration stream and can best think of such plants as constantly flowing fountains of water. If there is too little water available near them such plants normally solve the prob lem by developing extra long roots which go where the water is, and if this fails they dry out and die. But the cactus is typically a resident of the desert or else of habitats where, for one reason or another, the water supply is practically nonexistent at least part of the time. It may be because of inadequate rainfall or because the soil is too coarse or too thin to hold much water. So the cactus has a water problem which it solves in its own way. The cactus disdains to put out the extreme root systems, often drilling fifty feet deep, used by other desert plants to find the precious water which enables them to stay alive. Instead it sits and waits for the infrequent showers which ultimately do come, even in the desert, or for the rainy season. And when moisture does come the plant is ready. Its finely branching roots absorb water rapidly when it is available, and in a short time it has taken in a large amount. But there will be another drought to come, when it may be able to take in little if any water for weeks or months, so it stores this bonanza of water to the limit
cacti of the southwest
of its capacity, and its adaptations for great water-storing ca pacity form the basis for the most obvious peculiarity of the cactus. The commonest and most simple means of storing water found in these plants is by the enlarging of the stem into a thick, fleshy column or even a round ball. A cactus adapted this way be comes literally a water-filled column or ball, actually, in large specimens, a barrel of water-from which comes the common term, “barrel cactus.” The interior of such a cactus is not a re servoir of pure water into which you could dip a ladle, as car toons sometimes show the thirsty prospector doing, but a mass of soft tissue permeated with water. Except for the supporting framework necessary in larger species, that interior is of about the consistency of a melon’s watery pulp. When rain comes it fills to the maximum with water, and in times of drought this reserve is gradually reduced. Thus, the cactus stem swells and shrinks according to the water supply, and there is always an arrangement of ribs or tubercles which make this change in bulk possible without the whole stem alternately caving in or splitting open. In a number of the cacti where adaptations for clambering up trees, camouflage in thickets, or something else limits the thick ness or size of the stems, the root may become the water-storage organ instead. In these cacti the root may become a carrot-like taproot weighing up to fifty pounds (in the extreme case of an old Peniocereus greggii specimen) or a cluster of tubers (as found on Wilcoxia poselgeri and some of the Opuntias). The cactus, then, is a plant which solves the problem of in sufficient water in its habitat by storing large amounts of water within its tissues, and this explains its succulent consistency and bloated stem. Due to this habit it is internally among the softest, most delicate of plants. But standing there as almost literally a column or barrel of water in the middle of the thirsty desert brings problems requir ing still further adaptations, giving us the other remarkable characteristics of a cactus. Since the cactus may have to survive for weeks or months on the moisture it has within it, it cannot afford to be a spendthrift with water like other plants. It has to give up a little at all times to stay alive, but it must sacrifice the smallest possible amount and protect its precious store against the dryness of the desert air which would otherwise evaporate it all in a matter of hours. For this reason the leaves of a cactus are reduced or eliminat ed altogether. After all, leaves are for the purpose of increasing the evaporative and light-absorbing surface of the plant, and the cactus needs to reduce the evaporative surface to a mini mum, while certainly, in the glaring desert, it need not spread out its surface after light. Therefore, the more strictly a desert dweller it is, the more completely the leaves tend to be reduced or absent and the green stems to take over their functions. Then, its compact form is covered with a thick, waxy epidermis which is impervious to water, and even its stomata are equipped with means to reduce moisture loss. There is great variation in the
what is a cactus?
tenacity with which individual cacti hold water, with the most extreme desert forms said to release up to six thousand times less water in a given moment than an ordinary plant of the same weight. The thick, dry, protective covering of the cactus is so decep tive to us that we seldom think of the soft, delicate, watery in terior which it protects, but we may be sure the thirsty denizens of the desert, where water is life itself, are ever conscious of it. They would eat the plant immediately just for the water, if they could get at it. So the cactus has had to add protection against all the living water-seekers which surround it, and this gives yet another of its peculiarities. The almost universal solution of the cactus to this problem is to cover itself with an armament of spines. The succulent flesh is entirely covered with a system of spines so sharp and danger ous and so perfectly spreading and interlacing that neither the browsers nor the rodents can get their teeth between them to bite into the plant. The spines are never poisonous, and one can’t ascribe maliciousness to a plant for having them. They are there as necessary protection for the otherwise most delicate, most defenseless member of the desert community. It should help one to understand the spiny thing to realize that in the desert, when an injury or a malformation leaves a space wide enough for the jaws of a rabbit or even a mouse to get between the spines and start working, the cactus is soon eaten entirely. If one goes out on the desert and cuts all of the spines off a cactus, it usually disappears overnight. Ranchers have long ago learned to profit by this fact, and in some areas, by merely burning the spines off the huge prickly pears, provide their cattle with tons of free, succulent forage. The water problem, then, is directly respon sible for the soft make-up of a cactus and indirectly responsible for its hard, waxy exterior and its often unpleasant but also fascinating array of spines. The cactus faces another closely related problem. Its habitats are usually extreme in their heat and the intensity of their light. The temperature on a south-facing, rocky desert slope reaches almost unbelievable heights on a summer afternoon. Even the desert reptiles are said to avoid the sun in which the extreme desert forms of cactus have to stand all day. How can they survive this baking heat and searing light? Of course many cacti could not, and these grow only in the shade of thickets or trees, but the ones which stand and take it are said to depend on their own spines for shade. The spines achieve their shading effect, somewhat after the manner of a lath-house cover, by breaking the radiation up into moving strips of endurable duration. These forms also protect the ex posed surface, especially the tender growing area at the top, with a covering of wool or hair, usually white and reflective. One can fairly well judge how extreme a desert situation a species comes from and how much sun it can stand by looking at how extensively this wool is developed or how complete the spine shading is. With no tender leaves, the compact body of the cactus, with
5
in its spiny envelope, is thus remarkably well protected against any of the natural forces or living enemies of its habitat, and it can survive in places where only the hardiest persist. Yet it has one more major problem to surmount. It must reproduce itself. And to do this it must usually produce a flower. Some of the cacti avoid this at all but the most favorable times, and depend instead upon very well-developed vegetative reproduction, but sooner or later all have to bloom. Now, a flower is an amazingly complex structure of ex tremely delicate parts. Flowering is a time when the plant must open and expose for the generating touch the most precious centers of its being. It is a time of vulnerability, and not even the cactus has succeeded in armoring the flower. It may swathe the bud in spines and wool, but when the moment comes it must expose the flower to the cruel desert situation as unprotected as any rose or lily. This presents another immense problem for the cactus and its way of solving it gives us both the wonderful beauty for which the flower is famous, and the extreme fleetingness of the flower which exasperates us. The cactus flower is almost always renowned for its size and beauty, which are said to be for the purpose of attracting in sects or other flying forms across the arid distances to pollinate it. At any rate it does not seem to be beautiful for our benefit, because the flower usually lasts so short a period and blooms at such an unfavorable time that we hardly ever catch a glimpse of it and it usually is “born to blush unseen and waste its sweetness on the desert air.” Most cacti have flowers which open in the worst heat of the day, usually for only a few hours, and then are closed and fad ing before the cool of the evening begins. It is as though the plant waits until the heat of the day drives most of its enemies under the protection of some shade to unfold these tender mor sels which it cannot otherwise protect. Thus, in most forms, the flower has its brief life, the reproductive act is completed by the insects which scorn the heat, and the life spark is already down within the spiny ovary before the desert cools, so that its thirsty tribes find only wilted petals for their evening meals. Many tropical and a few of our U. S. cacti reverse this sched ule entirely and open their gigantic, wonderfully fragrant flow ers at night to be pollinated by night-flying insects or in a few cases by bats. In most cases these species produce their flowers on tall, spiny stems where no ordinary enemy could reach them anyway, but they fade as quickly as the others, and are usually only sadly wilted remains by dawn. Only the saguaro, whose flowers are inaccessible to almost any enemy, and some other forms protected by especially long, vicious spines seem able to enjoy the luxury of longer lasting flowers. The cactus fruit, which follows the flower, is usually protect ed at first by spines or wool, and grows to become a berry with numerous small seeds. In some cases this dries up and the seeds are allowed to scatter, but in many species the ripe berry be comes fleshy and at the same time loses its spines or rises out of its wool covering. Here is probably the only part of a cactus
6
purposely left unprotected. It is never poisonous, and it ranges from sour to very sweet in different species. It is snapped up and carried off by animals and birds who finally get a meal from the cactus, but who pay for it by scattering the seeds far and wide. Some of the sweetest of these fruits are relished by humans. Those of the Opuntias are called “tunas”; and the “strawberry cactus” (of which there are several species) bears this common name because the flavor of the red fruits suggests that of strawberries. In all of its stages, then, the cactus is admirably adapted for survival in an arid environment, with all of these special fea tures accentuated to the extreme in the forms inhabiting the more severe desert regions and less markedly developed in those of less extreme situations. But these same wonderful features which make the cactus so successful in the desert bring their own problems with them, limiting it in important ways even in its natural environment and making the tough desert thing one of the most vulnerable of plants when brought out of the desert into cultivation. Its very life, we have seen, depends upon the large amount of water stored within it as watery pulp. But this brings also the greatest danger to the cactus. Everyone knows how easily bruised and how quickly rotting is the watery flesh of melons and other soft fruits. A sharp blow or a gash through the pro tective covering of such structures causes a breakdown of the soft tissues which often spreads like wildfire throughout, leav ing the whole thing a putrid, rotten mass. This is because such soft, nutrient-filled tissues form the perfect media for the growth of bacteria and all sorts of fungi. The interior of even the toughest cactus is just as vulnerable to fungi. It survives because this tender core is surrounded by the tough, fungus-resistant epidermis. The cactus is only safe when this forms an unbroken barrier covering not only the stem but the roots of the plant. But the slightest injury, any break in this epidermis, may let in a fungus, and if one gets in before the plant can repair the break with scar tissue and starts growing in the interior, the outwardly invincible old cactus will be attacked from within. It will then be quickly permeated by the fungus and will collapse into a foul, oozing thing—often literally overnight. For this reason any injury is a greater dan ger to a cactus than to most plants, especially if it has been removed from the desert, where fungi are not as numerous, to a more damp climate where they abound. But the fungi often gain entrance to our cacti in a more subtle way. The epidermis on the roots of these plants is necessarily thinner than that on the stems, and it is in constant contact with the fungus-populated soil. If there is very little rainfall or the soil is open and fast-draining, all will probably be well, but if there are periods of continuous rainfall, or if the soil is close-packed and remains for any time water-saturated, then the normally hard, dry, and impervious epidermis of the roots becomes wet through and softened, and loses its impermeability to the fungi. The defense barrier is dissolved, and almost any
cacti of the southwest
cactus whose roots lie in waterlogged soil for over twenty-four hours or so will be invaded and reduced in about that much longer to stinking carrion. This is the fate of most cacti taken in from the desert and planted in heavy yard soil in a more rainy region or else in a pot which is watered every day along with the geraniums. In general, cacti must have abundant water now and then to replenish their stored supply, but they must not stand in stagnant water at any time. We have also seen how the cactus survives not only by storing water but by being miserly with it and giving off a transpira tion stream of up to several thousand times less volume than other plants. When other plants are wide-open, gushing foun tains, the cactus is a dribbling faucet with extra safeguards on all the water exits of its body. This means survival in the des ert, but brings problems even there and may mean death in the moisture-laden atmosphere of your garden. Plant physiologists tell us that the transpiration stream must flow unceasingly in any active plant. If the flow ceases the plant must go dormant—as some plants do in winter or severe drought—or die. They also tell us that the rate of transpiration is directly proportional to the rate of the plant’s life processes, including its growth. Relating this to cacti, we find that, having to restrict their transpiration to a minimum to conserve their stored water, the cacti are limited thereby to very slow life processes and growth as compared with other plants. When looking at a large old cactus one should appreciate the time it took, at this reduced rate, to achieve its bulk. While there is much variation, with the more extreme desert forms, naturally the most slow-grow ing, the variations exist even in these according to their imme diate situation. It is often said that a saguaro cactus one foot tall will be about twenty-five years old, and a barrel cactus one foot in diameter between twenty and forty years old. I have in my own garden a fine specimen of Echinocactus ingens, a per fect ball just over twelve inches in diameter, which was planted at the old Shiner Cactus Garden in Laredo, Texas, as a seed, forty-five years ago. It has grown its whole life in a good situation in a plant bed, and while the species might grow somewhat faster in its native haunts in Mexico, its growth has been very nearly typical. Nor is a smaller cactus necessarily younger. I have heard it said that a peyote button two inches in diameter is ten years old. The rates of growth vary from species to species, but almost no cactus is over a fraction of an inch tall at the end of its first year, and they all must have long periods of time to achieve their potential size. The amount of water vapor in the atmosphere around a plant also affects the amount of water it will transpire. The dry air of arid regions literally drags the water out of the plants, and desert species, including cacti, have to guard their water ardent ly against this evaporative pull. On the other hand, the water loaded air of humid regions is reluctant to take up more water, and the plants living in the regions must lay themselves wide open in order to promote the life-giving flow and often live
what is a cactus?
less than the maximum span because of their inability to transpire enough water. Imagine the problem, then, of that cactus you brought home from the desert and planted in your nice moist yard. Adapted to hoarding its water, with its stomata small and guarded by various means against the pull of the dry desert air, what can it do in the humid air where it is now? It cannot open and lay its moisture out for the humid air. This is not its way. And since this air does not pull water out of its deep recesses, the flow will be less than it would be in the desert, so your cactus, which you thought would respond with prodigious growth to your kindness in bringing it into the moisture, may actually suffer and grow poorly because it cannot transpire and carry on its life processes here. We have also mentioned the adaptations of the cactus which enable it to live in the extreme heat and light of the desert. These may also bring severe problems to a cactus. The flesh of most cacti is more or less shaded and protected by the spines and a covering of wool or hair. In the forms which grow in extremely exposed places this covering may be developed to protect against temperatures of well over 100 degrees Fahrenheit and some of the most intense light radiation found on earth. The outer tissues themselves, and even the life processes of some of these species are adapted to such extremes. It seems, for instance, that some of these cacti cannot even be gin photosynthesis until the temperature reaches 75 degrees or higher. Everything in them is adjusted for high heat and light intensities. All this is fine and necessary in the desert, but what about the problems of such a cactus when you bring it home? You want to keep it in your nice cool dark house or your nice shaded garden, and you can’t understand why it does not grow, or why,
7
if it does, it becomes all grotesque and spindly. Don’t you see that in such a situation it cannot get light and heat enough through all of its defenses to activate its high-set thermostat and stimu late its growth processes properly? Air-conditioning has marked the end of many a cactus dish-garden because the plants can hardly carry on photosynthesis, in the coolness we maintain, even in a window, and when this is coupled with what is for them little better than darkness, they may not be able to manu facture enough food even to stay alive. We have seen some of the remarkable adaptations which make cacti so fascinating and have tried to understand the problems these changes are meant to meet, as well as the special problems they can generate for cactus-growers. Successful cac tus culture consists of recognizing these problems and helping the cactus meet them naturally. One does not have success with cacti by removing them from all their natural problems. More cacti in cultivation have been killed by too much kindness than by anything else. These are tough plants by nature, and all they ask is that the conditions around them remain within the ranges, rather severe by our standards, for which they are adapted. It is well to recall that there are cacti adapted for almost every sort of environment, from shady rain forest to extreme desert exposure. All of the problems of growing cacti mentioned above are less critical for those plants adapted to less severe conditions, and these can be grown much more easily than the more restricted ones; some of them can be treated quite a lot like other plants. But these are generally the less spiny, less suc culent forms which are, therefore, the ones less fascinating to most of us. It is perhaps unfortunate, but unavoidable, that to grow pitahayas and barrels and other remarkable types one has to simulate to a fair degree the extreme environments of their hot, arid homes.
Key to the Genera of the Cacti
T
he keys which are given here and before the discussion of each major genus are based as far as possible on the vegetative characters of adult individuals, but it appears to be impossible to construct workable keys for the cacti based on these alone. It was found necessary to refer in some cases to the flowers or fruits and sometimes even to the seeds. This means that the keys will be less than satisfactory in certain seasons and will not identify most juvenile forms at all. Those using the keys will need to have before them very nearly complete adult specimens of the living plants. The keys are artificial and are my own. They are binomial keys, presenting a series of choices between two alternatives. In use, one reads the first choice (1 a) and compares the specimen in question with the description. If the description at 1 a fits the specimen, he then proceeds to the number given at the end of the description and repeats the process there. If the descrip tion at 1 a does not fit the specimen, then the user abandons 1 a and moves on to 1 b, which is the alternate choice. If the spe cimen matches 1 b, then he moves to the number given at the end of 1 b, and so on. When this process is followed carefully with a mature plant from our area, it should lead to a descrip tion after which a plant name and page number is given. This is the name of the specimen in hand and the discussion of it will start on that page. If at any point the specimen does not fit either the a or b choice one has arrived at, there are two pos sible explanations. Either the user has already made a wrong choice somewhere earlier in the process, or else the cactus he has is not included in this key. Careful reconsideration of all choices should show which is the case. If the user cannot choose between alternatives by studying his specimen, he may have to secure a more mature or more complete example in order to key the form.
1a. Stems of mature plants ribbed-that is, the surfaces of the stems covered with vertical or sometimes spiraling ridges which may be completely uninterrupted, undulate, or sometimes almost com pletely interrupted by grooves between the areoles, but which are never, on mature stems, rows of completely separate tubercles—2. 2a. Plants possessing spines—3. 3a. Stems of plants upright, prostrate, or clambering, with ma ture stems more than twice as long as they are thick; the flowers produced on the sides of the stems, with the ovary surfaces spiny; the fruit remaining fleshy and indehiscent or sometimes splitting open laterally—4. 4a. Stems not more than about 6 times as long as they are thick, not over 24 inches long, upright or prostrate, but not clambering, often caespitose; the flowers produced from a rupture of the stem epidermis just above an areole —Genus Echinocereus (see key on page 11). 4b. Stems when mature at least 8 to sometimes 100 times as long as they are thick, on old specimens becoming more than 24 inches long, upright or clambering, never caespitose; the flowers produced from within a spine areole—5. 5a. Stems 1/4 to 1 inch in diameter; spines 1/32 to 1/4 of an inch long; roots tuberous—6. 6a. Stems 1/4 to 5/8 of an inch thick; ribs 8; spines to 1/4 or 3/8 of an inch long; roots clustering tubers; flowers purplish with short tubes and opening during the day —Genus Wilcoxia (see page 55). 6b. Stems 1/2 to 1 inch thick; ribs 3 to 6; spines 1/32 to 1/8 of an inch long; root a single extremely large taproot; flowers mostly white with long tubes and opening at night —Genus Peniocereus (see page 57). 5b. Stems 2 to 4 inches in diameter; spines 3/8 to 2 inches long; roots fibrous—Genus Acanthocereus (see page 60). 3b. Stems of plants upright, never more than twice as tall as they are thick; the flowers produced at the apex of the stem,
key to the genera of the cacti with the ovary surface scaly or sometimes with hair, but never spiny; the fruit opening basally or laterally —Genus Echinocactus (see key on page 65). 2b. Plants spineless—7. 7a. Flowers large and yellow with red centers; ovary scaly —Genus Echinocactus (see key on page 65). 7b. Flowers small and pinkish; fruit never having spines or scales —Genus Lophophora (see page 95). lb. Stems of plants smooth or else tubercled—that is, covered with nipple-like projections which may be arranged in spiral rows and which may overlap due to their length, but which are never confluent to form raised ribs—8. 8a. Plants a fraction of an inch to about 6 inches tall; stems depressed, hemispherical, or columnar, but never jointed; the spines straight or hooked but never barbed glochids; the ovaries and fruits naked or with only a few scales on them—9.
9 9a. Plants spineless —Genus Ariocarpus (see page 100). 9b. Plants spiny—10. 10a. Fruit becoming dry and splitting open —Genus Pediocactus (see page 103). 10b. Fruit remaining fleshy and not splitting open—11. 11a. Flowers produced in the axils of the tubercles —Genus Mammillaria (see key on page 112). 11b. Flowers produced from the tips of the tubercles —Genus Epithelantha (see page 107). 8b. Plants several inches to sometimes 6 or more feet tall; stems jointed; at least some of the spines barbed glochids; the ovary naked or spiny —Genus Opuntia (see key on page 162).
Genus Echinocereus Engelmann
T
he Echinocerei make up one of the largest genera of cacti, both in number of different species and in number of individu als found growing in the area of this study. Many of its mem bers are collected and grown by cactus fanciers all over the world as great favorites because of the beauty of their flowers as well as of the plants themselves. The name of the genus is composed of two words: echinos, meaning spiny, which refers to the very spiny covering of the typical members of this genus, and cereus, which means “wax candle,” a reference to the stately appearance of the stems of the upright species. The Echinocerei are oval, conical, or cylindrical cacti, always with ribbed stems. The vertical ribs of some species are more or less divided into swellings which may be called warts or tuber cles, but these are never completely separated from one another as in some other genera, so the ribs are always an outstanding character of them all. These cacti are usually very spiny, as their name implies, and these spines may be straight or curved, but are never hooked, as is common in some other groups. The stems of Echinocerei are always low as compared with many of their relatives. Most of them are well under twelve inches long when mature, and the few in the Southwest which sometimes surpass that do not usually exceed twenty-four inches long. These stems are erect in most species, but in a few they lie partly or entirely prostrate upon the ground. The plant body of some species remains a single, unbranched stem throughout life. Others cluster or branch sparingly only when very old; but many regularly form clusters of stems al most from the start. In some these clusters are made up of only a few stems, but in a few of them one plant may with age be come a huge, caespitose clump of as many as a hundred or more stems, These stems are never divided into joints however.
The flowers of this genus are borne on the ribs at the spine bearing areoles, developing just above the uppermost spines of the areoles, where they literally burst through the epidermis of the stem. They may be produced from almost any point on the stem, different species bearing them high or low, but most com monly they appear on the sides of the stems a little below the tips. The flowers are usually very large and beautiful, so beautiful that many fanciers pick one or another species in this genus as the most beautiful of our native cacti. However, a few of the Echinocerei have small and inconspicuous greenish flowers. The petals of some species remain only partly open, making the flowers funnel-shaped, while those of others open very widely. A perianth tube is always present. The outer surface of the ovary is always spiny and sometimes woolly as well. The stigma lobes are always green on all of our species. The fruits produced by these cacti are always fleshy, thin skinned, and often edible. Those of some species are considered delicacies. Something of their character may be imagined from the fact that a number of them are known by the common name of “strawberry cacti.” These fruits are also spiny, but the spines become loosened as the fruits mature, and may be easily brushed off. The members of the genus Echinocereus inhabit a wide belt of the North American continent from Utah and Wyoming south throughout most of northern Mexico to a little beyond the lati tude of Mexico City, and from central Oklahoma and Texas on the east to the Pacific on the west. ‘Within this huge area more than eighty species have been described by various authorities, but many of these so intergrade that later students have combined various ones. The result is that almost every book or article on this genus has at least a slightly different method of listing them, depending upon the taxonomic philosophy of the writer as well
genus Echinocereus engelmann
as upon his knowledge of these cacti. This has caused much con fusion, and makes it necessary for us to deal with many authors and names in order to know exactly what plant we have before us. I will attempt to make or follow no formal classification of the species within the genus because it is too large a group and we have in the area of this study only a minority of the forms which would have to be considered in such a classification. In stead, I will group the species in a purely artificial series ac cording to their most obvious characteristics, while concentrat ing upon describing the various forms properly and calling them, in the light of the most recent knowledge, by their proper names. The Echinocerei grow mostly in exposed places on dry slopes and hills in the full strength of the southwestern sun. Only a few of them prefer the shade of bushes and trees. With this sun loving characteristic and their inability to tolerate excess mois ture remembered, most of them are rather easily cultivated and are, therefore, popular among collectors. They have a wide range of tolerance of cold, those of the north being very resistant, while many of those of Mexico perish by freezing when brought farther north.
KEY TO THE ECHINOCEREI 1a. Stems upright or sprawling, comparatively thick, being two inches or more thick when mature—2. 2a. Having all three of the following characters: areoles always 1/2 inch or less apart; ribs always more than 10; radial spines always more than 12—3. 3a. Flowers small, 1 to 11/2 inches long and less than that in width, yellow, yellow-brown, or pinkish-red in color—4. 4a. Areoles elongated; central spines 0 to 3 in number, arranged in a vertical row, and 1 inch or less in length on mature plants—5. 5a. Plant globose to short-cylindric; radials 1/4 of an inch or less long—6. 6a. Ribs 12 to 18; radials 16 to more than 20; plant 2 inches or more tall when mature—7. 7a. Spines varicolored red, brownish, or purplish-red and white —E. viridiflorus var. viridiflorus. 7b. Spines yellowish —E. viridiflorus var. standleyi. 6b. Ribs 6 to 9; radials 8 to 12; plant about 1 inch tall when mature —E. davisii. 5b. Plant cylindrical; radials to 1/2 inch long —E. viridiflorus var. cylindricus. 4b. Areoles broad oval to round; centrals 3 to 12 in number and not standing in a straight vertical row, but instead spreading outward from the center of the areole—8. 8a. Radials 12 to 23; ribs hardly tuberculate; centrals 3 to 5 in number on mature plants —E. chloranthus var. chloranthus.
11 8b. Radials 30 or more; ribs markedly tuberculate; centrals 5 to 12 on mature plants—9. 9a. Centrals to only 1/2 inch long; immature plants having flexible hairs instead of spines; flowers greenish-yellow to bronze and with a glossy surface —E. chloranthus var. neocapillus. 9b. Centrals 3/4 to 11/4 inches long; immature plants having rigid spines from the first; flow ers pale pinkish or brownish-red and with a dull surface —E. russanthus. 3b. Flowers large and showy, 2 to 5 inches or more in length and width, yellow to purple in color—10. 10a. Flower tube with long, cobwebby wool and hairlike, bristly spines; spines not recurved against the plant body—11. 11a. Longest radial spines 3/8 of an inch or less—12. 12a. Central spines 0 to 2, porrect and if more than one, then arranged in a strict vertical row—13. 13a. Centrals usually missing and 1/8 inch or less long when present—14. 14a. Size of mature plant stems 3 to 12 inches tall by 2 to 31/2 inches thick; flower 3 to 5 inches long and nearly as wide, petals 30 to 50, stigma lobes 8 to 22—15. l5a. Radial spines 15 to 36—16. 16a. Spines white to gray or reddish, often with dark tips, but not with the outer parts of the spines conspicuously shiny purplish or black so as to give the plant a shiny blackish aspect —E. caespitosus var. caespitosus. 16b. Outer parts of the spines bright, shiny, purplish or black, giving the plant a conspicuous blackish appearance —E. caespitosus var. purpureus. 15b. Radial spines 12 to 15 —E. caespitosus var. perbellus. 14b. Size of mature plant stem to only 3 inches tall and 1 inch thick; flowers small, to only 2 inches long and 13/4 inches wide, petals to only 20 in number and stigma lobes to only 8 —E. caespitosus var. minor. 13b. One black central 3/16 to 1/4 of an inch long al ways present —E. melanocentrus. 12b. Centrals 3 to 7 and not in a strict vertical row, but spreading —E. fitchii. 11b. Longest radial spines 3/8 to 1 inch—17. 17a. Stems usually caespitose; areoles more than 1/8 of an inch long, having no central spines over 3/8 of an inch long—18. 18a. Radials 5/8 to 1 inch long; flower rose-red —E. baileyi. 18b. Radials 3/16 to 1/2 inch long; flower pale pinkish —E. albispinus. 17b. Stems usually simple; areoles 1/8 of an inch or less long, having at least the main central spines 3/8 of an inch or more long on mature areoles —E. chisoensis.
12
cacti of the southwest 10b. Flower tube with short wool and rigid spines—19. 19a. Spines of the plant body strictly pectinate and re curved against the plant body; areoles oval to elongated—20. 20a. Centrals 2 to 3 in a vertical row; radials slender to medium stout, white to purplish or pinkish and the plant often banded with color, but spines of individual areole not variegated—21. 21a. Flower purple with white zone and green center —E. pectinatus var. wenigeri. 21b. Flower orange-yellow with green center —E. pectinatus var. ctenoides. 20b. Centrals none; radials stout; spines of individual areoles variegated grays or tans and red —E. pectinatus var. rigidissimus. 19b. Spines of plant body spreading outward instead of being pectinate; areoles oval to round—22. 22a. Radial spines 15 to 25; areoles 1/8 to 3/8 of an inch apart; flower 3 to 51/2 inches long—23. 23a. Radials 16 to 25 and to 1/2 inch long; plant simple or sparingly branched —E. dasyacanthus var. dasyacanthus. 23b. Radials 15 or 16 and to only 3/8 of an inch long; plant caespitose —E. dasyacanthus var. hildmanii. 22b. Radial spines 10 to 15; flower 2 to 3 inches long; areoles 5/16 to 1/2 inch apart —E. roetteri (in part). 2b. Never having all three of the characters listed under 2a or, in other words, having any one or more of the three following characters: areoles more than 1/2 inch apart; ribs less than 10; radials less than 12—24. 24a. Flowers scarlet-red and lasting up to 4 or 5 days, with the petals firm and their edges entire—25. 25a. Ribs 5 to 9; radial spines 2 to 9; centrals 0 or 1—26. 26a. Spines greatly flattened and usually channeled or furrowed—27. 27a. Spines extremely heavy—28. 28a. Central spine absent; radials 2 to 6; areoles 7/8 to 11/2 inches apart —E. triglochidiatus var. triglochidiatus. 28b. One central present in at least part of the areoles; radials 6 to 8; areoles 1/4 to 3/4 of an inch apart —E. triglochidiatus var. gonacanthus. 27b. Spines slender to medium thickness; radials 5 to 7; centrals 0 to 1 —E. triglochidiatus var. hexaedrus. 26b. Spines round or practically so and slender to medium in thickness —E. triglochidiatus var. octacanthus. 25b. Ribs 7 to 15; radial spines 7 to 16; centrals 1 to 6—29. 29a. Plant clustering densely into dome-shaped masses of equal, short stems not usually over 6 inches tall—30. 30a. Centrals 1 to 5; areoles 3/16 to 3/8 of an inch apart; largest central round —E. coccineus var. coccineus. 30b. Centrals 3 to 5; areoles 5/16 to 5/8 of an inch apart; largest central flattened —E. coccineus var. conoideus. 29b. Plant clustering sparingly to form flat clumps of unequal stems up to 18 inches tall—31. 31a. Centrals several—32.
32a. Ribs 8 to 11; radials 7 to 12; centrals usually 3 or 4 and variable in length from 3/4 to over 2 inches long; all spines round and medium thickness to heavy, whitish to ashy purplish-gray or reddish in color—33. 33a. Ovary tube with long, flexible hair —E. polyacanthus var. polyacanthus. 33b. Ovary tube with sparse and short wool —E. polyacanthus var. rosei. 32b. Ribs 11 to 15; radials 8 to 16; centrals 4 to 6; spines round and white, yellow, or reddish-yellow in color —E. polyacanthus var. neo-mexicanus. 31b. Central 1 —E. mojaviensis. 24b. Flowers purple or yellow with red centers and delicate, lasting only 1 or 2 days, with petals soft and more or less emarginate—34. 34a. Spines opaque; flesh medium to dark or gray-green—35. 35a. Mature spines opaque and varicolored or variegated with shades of brown, gray, and white streaking at least some of them; radials 5 to 12; centrals 1 to 3—36. 36a. Stems more or less flaccid, wrinkled, with broad, somewhat tuberculate ribs; central spine 1, long and curving upward —E. fendleri var. fendleri. 36b. Stems firm and not wrinkled; ribs narrow and not markedly tuberculate; central spines 1 to 3, the main one porrect and straight —E. fendleri var. rectispinus. 35b. Mature spines opaque but not variegated or varicolored; radials 14 to 17; centrals 2 to 8—37. 37a. Lowest radials as long as the lateral ones in the are ole; fruits 11/4 to 2 inches long —E. lloydii. 37b. Lowest radials shorter than the laterals; fruits 1/2 to 7/8 of an inch long —E. roetteri (in part). 34b. Spines translucent to some degree; flesh light or medium green—38. 38a. Areoles 1/2 to 11/2 inches apart; ribs only slightly tuber culate on mature stems; flowers purple—39. 39a. Ribs 11 to 13; areoles 1/2 to 3/4 of an inch apart; plant forming a large, regular, hemispherical clump from a single root center; flowers 4 to 5 inches long —E. stramineus. 39b. Ribs 7 to 10; areoles 3/4 to 11/2 inches apart; plant forming an irregular, sprawling, or prostrate clump, often with adventitious roots; flowers 11/2 to 3 inches tall—40. 40a. Stems extremely flabby; becoming prostrate and to 30 inches long; flower with 20 to 35 inner petals in several series and 10 to 12 stigma lobes —E. enneacanthus var. carnosus. 40b. Stems sprawling, more or less flabby, and to 15 inches or so in maximum length; flower with 10 to 15 inner petals in one row and 8 to 10 stigma lobes—41. 41a. Stem to 23/4 inches thick, comparatively firm and upright; radials 1/4 to 5/8 of an inch long and straight; areoles 1/4 to 1 inch apart —E. enneacanthus var. enneacanthus. 41b. Stems 3 to 4 inches in diameter, flabby, and
genus Echinocereus engelmann semiprostrate; radials 3/4 to 11/2 inches long, often curving; areoles 1 to 11/2 inches apart —E. dubius. 38b. Areoles 3/8 to 1/2 inch apart; ribs extremely tuberculate; flowers yellow with red centers —E. papillosus var. papillosus. lb. Stems prostrate and slender, being 1/2 to 11/2 inches thick—42. 42a. Central spine present on all or most areoles and 3/8 to 2 inches long—43. 43a. Stems to only 4 inches long; central spine 3/8 of an inch long; flower yellow with red center; ribs markedly tuberculate —E. papillosus var. angusticeps. 43b. Stems 6 to 14 inches long; central spine 1/2 to 2 inches long; flower purple—44. 44a. Central spine 1/2 to 2 inches long, dark in color, and somewhat aimed and curved downward; flower with a dark reddish-purple throat and narrow, pointed petals —E. blanckii. 44b. Central spine 1/2 to 11/2 inches long, yellowish-brown, porrect or turning upward; flower with a white throat —E. berlandieri (in part). 42b. Central spine usually missing, and if present on occasional areoles only 1/4 of an inch or less in length—45. 45a. Radial spines 4 to 6 and some of them 1/4 to 11/4 inches long; flower with white throat and narrow, pointed petals —E. berlandieri (immature or stunted growth form). 45b. Radial spines 3 to 6 and only 1/16 to 1/4 of an inch long; flower with white throat and broad, blunt-tipped petals —E. pentalophus.
Echinocereus viridiflorus Eng. “Green-Flowered Torch Cactus,” “Green-Flowered Pitaya,” “Nylon Cactus,” “New Mexico Rainbow Cactus” Description Plate 1 stems: Single or forming small clusters of up to about half a dozen heads. Each stem is spherical to columnar, varying in the different forms from a sphere or cone only an inch or so across to a column as much as 8 inches tall by as much as 3 inches in diameter. The surface is light green to yellowish green in color. There are 13 to 15 low ribs with shallow verti cal grooves between them. There are definite grooves crossing the ribs between the areoles, giving them a somewhat tuber culate appearance. areoles: Small, narrow oblong to very elongated, up to about 3/8 of an inch apart on mature parts of the stem. Young areoles are covered with short, white felt, but old areoles lose this and become bare except for a small tuft of wool just above the spines of each areole where a flower has developed. spines: There are 12 to more than 20 radial spines which radiate evenly around the areole. They are straight and rigid, and lie flat upon the surface of the plant or sometimes re curve back toward the grooves between the ribs. The longer
13
ones sometimes interlock with those of the adjacent areoles. They vary in size from very small, very weak upper ones which are bristle-like and only 1/16 of an inch long to lateral and lower ones 1/4 of an inch long in one variety and 1/2 inch long in another. There is great variation in the coloring of these radial spines. They may all be purplish-red or yellow or whitish, but the most typical pattern is for the upper and lower ones in each areole to be white while the lateral ones are reddish—although an occasional specimen displays ex actly the reverse pattern. Sometimes individual spines may be white, tipped with red. All of these variations may some times occur on the same plant, often in zones, giving the plant a banded appearance. There is most typically one central spine, much thicker and more rigid than the radials and standing erect in the center of the areole. This spine sometimes is curved upward toward its tip and is usually about 1/2 inch long, although in one form it may be up to 1 inch long. This spine may be white with a reddish tip, half and half, or all purplish-red except for a white base. Sometimes one or even two auxiliary central spines, much shorter (only 1/16 to 3/16 of an inch long) but otherwise identical to the first, may be present, in which case the two or three centrals are arranged in a perfect vertical row. On the other hand, the areoles of many plants lack the central entirely. All the spines have bulbous bases. flowers: Small, lemon-yellow or straw-color, this often approaching chartreuse or occasionally being suffused with brown and then bronzy. These flowers are about 1 inch long by 3/4 of an inch in diameter, produced on old areoles on the sides of the stem, usually midway between the base and the top although sometimes even lower. The outer petals are linear, brownish in the midline with lemon-yellow or char treuse edges. The inner petals are longer and become a little broader toward the tips which are more or less rounded. These inner petals are lemon-yellow to straw, usually with somewhat darker green in the midline. The edges are all en tire. The stamens show the same colors. The style is some what longer than the stamens and crowned by 6 to 10 dark green, rather fat stigma lobes. Each areole of the ovary has short white wool and 4 to 12 white spines up to 1/4 of an inch long. fruits: These are 3/8 to 1/2 of an inch long, egg-shaped, and greenish in color, and have white wool and white spines upon them. Range. From eastern Wyoming and eastern Colorado south through eastern New Mexico to the vicinity of El Paso, Texas, and southeast through the Guadalupe Mountains into the Big Bend of Texas. Remarks. E. viridiflorus is famed as the most northerly of the Echinocerei. It grows on the bleak prairies and the foothills of eastern Wyoming and Colorado in spite of cold and extreme conditions which would kill most cacti. A few times it has been
14
reported from extreme western Kansas and the Panhandle of Oklahoma, but these reports were mostly fifty or more years ago. If it is not extinct in those areas, it is very rare today. It still may be found occasionally in the Texas Panhandle and in northeastern New Mexico, which is its type locality. The most westerly report of it seems to be just a few miles west of Santa Fe, New Mexico. Over this whole northern area of its range the cactus is a small, squat, egg-shaped, withdrawing plant, hiding as best it can in the sparse grass and practically invisible during the win ter when it is greatly shrunken. The whole plant is seldom over 2 or 3 inches tall in this area. Neither does it produce conspicu ous flowers to give away its position in the spring. The flowers are small and greenish-yellow, and even these are borne low on the plant rather than at the top. These northern plants usually have long, up-curving central spines, but their radials tend to be shorter than those of their southern relatives. This northern form seems to he the plant Engelmann had before him which he called E. viridiflorus var. minor. He stated correctly that this variety grows from around Santa Fe, New Mexico, north eastward. South of Santa Fe the species is seen again past Socorro and Roswell, New Mexico, into the Guadalupe Mountains and at El Paso. It then becomes common east and south into the Big Bend area of Texas. But all of the southern plants studied show some differences from their northern relatives. These differ ences have been considered significant enough from the very beginning to warrant separate variety designations. Much of the confusion in the minds of cactophiles and, therefore, in their accounts of this species and the closely related species Echino cereus chloranthus has been due to a failure to distinguish and understand these varieties. The southern forms of E. viridiflorus are quite commonly displayed and even sold today under the name of E. chloranthus.
Echinocereus viridiflorus var. viridiflorus (Eng.) Description Plate 1 stems: As the species except that it is spherical to conical, growing occasionally to about 5 inches high by as much as 3 inches in diameter, but usually much smaller. Usually cluster ing. areoles: As the species. spines: As the species, except that the centrals are often missing entirely and never observed over 1/2 inch long. flowers: AS the species, except that they are usually lemon yellow in color and more rarely brownish than in the other forms, with the petals somewhat rounded at the ends. fruits: As the species. Range. From eastern Wyoming and eastern Colorado through
cacti of the southwest
eastern New Mexico to the vicinity of Santa Fe, which seems to be the southern and western limit of its range. It occurs from there east into the Oklahoma and Texas panhandles and is found occasionally in the high plains of extreme northwestern Texas, but this form does not appear to come down into southwest Texas. Remarks. This is the more hardy northern form of the Species. Small and comparatively insignificant as it is, anyone who has been abroad in its range would be amazed to know how many specimens he has stepped over as it hides in the grass. It takes a real Search to locate the plant, but it can easily be grown in northern gardens where most other cacti do not survive. With its clustering habit it soon presents an attractive little clump of heads with varicolored spines.
Echinocereus viridiflorus var. cylindricus (Eng.) Rümpl. Description Plate 1 stems: Similar to the species except that it is cylindrical and grows to at least 8 inches tall by 3 inches in diameter. Seldom and sparingly clustering. areoles: As the species. spines: As the species, except that the radials number 14 to 24, their maximum length to 1/2 inch; and the centrals num ber 0 to 3 in a vertical row, the main central growing to a maximum length of 1 inch on some plants. On many plants, however, the main central may be entirely missing or no longer than the 1/16 to 3/16-inch auxiliary centrals. flowers: As the species, except that they are more often brownish in color and the petals are more sharply pointed. fruits: As the species. Range. Common from the area of Socorro and Roswell, New Mexico, southeast through the Guadalupe Mountains into Tex as. The writer was surprised to find a stand of this variety near Mosquero, in northeastern New Mexico, which marks a great extension of its range northward. In Texas it ranges through the Davis Mountains into the Big Bend. Remarks. This is E. Viridiflorus as it appears in its southern range, a much more robust form, with radial spines about twice as long as and more interlocking than those of the northern form. Its central spines are extremely variable. Almost any col lection from the Big Bend will show some plants with only five or six single centrals 3/16 to 1/8 of an inch long scattered over the whole stem, a few with no centrals at all, and others with regularly 2 or 3 centrals per areole arranged in a single vertical row. The specimens from the Hueco and Guadalupe mountains sometimes lack centrals also but more often show a single cen tral like the species except usually to 1 inch long and curving. Thousands of these large, columnar specimens, usually dis
genus Echinocereus engelmann
tinctly reddish of spine and bronze of flower, are shipped by dealers out of the Texas Big Bend every year. They are so ob viously different from the little northern form that, since the name E. viridiflorus without variety qualification is usually ap plied to the northern form, these are usually distributed under the name of E. chloranthus. However, this southern variety was recognized as a distinct form long ago when it was named E. viridiflorus var. cylindricus by Engelmann. Coulter, failing to apply Engelmann’s name to it, renamed it Cereus viridiflorus var. tubulosus, basing his description on specimens from Brew ster County, Texas. Both men recognized its distinctness from E. chloranthus, a distinction which has become blurred in some more recent accounts. This variety of this cactus was once one of the most common in the Big Bend region. I have been told by older collectors of beds of these cacti extending over many acres in Brewster County, Texas, in which the cacti often stood almost too close for one to walk among them. Their numbers seemed inexhausti ble. There are few such stands left today, however, mostly due to the destruction wrought by the cactus dealers whose crews have for years been bringing them out by the truckloads to languish and die in dime-store bins and novelty-shop cactus assortments. I have been on some ranches in the area whose owners have allowed no cactus digging, and there they still grow in quantity; but only a few years ago I watched three big truckloads of them come out as another of these ranches was opened up and swept clean of cacti, and so they appear to be doomed to elimination as surely as the more rare species of the area.
Echinocereus viridiflorus var. standleyi (B. & R.) Orcutt Description Plate 1 stems: Similar to the species except becoming cylindrical and growing to about 4 inches tall, while seldom clustering. areoles: As the species. spines: As the species, except that they are a clear, rather translucent yellow, becoming sometimes whitish when old. flowers As the species. fruits: As the species. Range. South central New Mexico. Remarks. This was described as a species by Britton and Rose, but since they had not seen it flower and their description was very incomplete, it was long uncertain what the plant’s rela tionship really was. After having seen numerous specimens throughout their development and in bloom, I feel certain that it is a form of E. viridiflorus, as Orcutt has already suggested. I cannot distinguish its flowers from those of the species by any essential feature. It is close to the variety cylindricus in the cylindrical shape of its stems and in the character of its centrals,
15
but its radial spines are shorter and more like those of variety viridiflorus. This leaves it distinct from these other forms only by the clear yellow color of its spines. This is a doubtful char acter to base even a variety upon, and it surely will not support its being listed as a separate species. It may be that it does not even warrant varietal status, but I list it separately here since anyone reading the literature will be anxious to know what the plant referred to so incompletely by almost all authors actually is.
Echinocereus davisii Houghton Description Plate 2 stems: Globular or nearly so and very small. This is a dwarf plant, 1/2 to 11/4 inches tall when mature. Stems occur singly as far as is known. There are 6 to 8 ribs on this tiny stem, which are rather high and broken into nearly completely separated tubercles. The color of the flesh is dark green. areoles: Narrow oval to elongated and 1/8 to 3/16 of an inch long, having very little if any wool upon them, even when young. spines: White, with the tips or sometimes the outer one-half dark brown. These spines are all radials and are 8 to 13 in number. The upper ones are shortest, slender, round, and ‘Is to 1/4 of an inch long, while the laterals are longer, stouter, usually flattened, and 3/8 to 5/8 of an inch long. The spines are straight or often somewhat curved and recurved back against the plant. flowers: Straw-yellow, about 1 inch long, not opening widely. The outer petals are narrow with midlines reddish to umber and the edges yellowish. They are pointed and entire. The inner petals are straw-yellow, and linear to slightly broadened above, with the tips sharply pointed. The fila ments are green, the anthers light yellow. The style is light green and is crowned by 5 light green, heavy, curving stigma lobes. The ovary has about 12 white spines to 1/4 of an inch long on each areole, but no wool. fruits: Oval, about 3/8 of an inch long, apparently remaining green. Range. Found on only a few limestone summits a few miles south of Marathon, Brewster County, Texas. Remarks. This is one of the two dwarf cacti of Brewster Coun ty, Texas, and it is remarkable that it grows on the same few hills as the other, Mammillaria nellieae. It even grows in the same situation as that other, underneath the moss in the crevices of the limestone ledges. The tiny plant is rarely visible at all because of its mossy protection, and only sends its flowers up briefly above this layer. It is a real hands-and-knees effort to search for these diminutive plants in the expanse of the Texas hills. The best effort will be useless unless one is on the right
16
hills, and these are restricted to two or three ranches near Mara thon. One would think that the little cactus would be secure in its very limited range, but that is not the case. After Houghton described this plant in 1931 and others wrote about it, collectors and dealers went straight to the spot and brought out hundreds of specimens. This continued for some years, and most collec tions then sported some of these attractive little novelties. In this way the wild population was reduced steadily until more recently the area in which they grow has come into the hands of owners who allow no one to dig cacti at all. This is fortunate for the survival of the species, but the plant has become more and more rare in collections, and its value on the market has now become rather high. The problem here, again, is to place this cactus properly in respect to its relatives, and as always this cannot be done with absolute certainty or to please everyone. A. D. Houghton des ignated it a separate species when he first described it, but W. T. Marshall soon considered its similarities to E. viridiflorus too great and called it E. viridiflorus var. davisii. Anyone may take his choice of these arrangements, since it is a matter of evalua tion of similarities and differences which all can see. I choose to leave it distinct from E. viridiflorus because it differs from that plant in rib and spine number and spine length, as well as in size. Of perhaps more importance to me in deciding to re gard it as a separate species are the facts that the petals of its flowers are more pointed than those of E. viridiflorus, and that it has no wool on the ovary areoles while the other does. This matter of wool or no wool has been made the basis for separat ing others of this genus into entirely different sections, and so it certainly seems significant enough here to separate species. Although tiny in size, E. davisii is not short-lived, as one might expect. I have seen a series of specimens collected ten years ago and grown all this while by a collector who knows how to care for her plants. They have bloomed most years, but have hardly increased in size in all this time.
Echinocereus chloranthus (Eng.) Rümpl. “Green-Flowered Torch Cactus,” “Green-Flowered Pitaya” Description Plate 2 stems: Cylindrical, up to 10 inches high by 3 inches thick, occasionally, but not often, producing one or two branches from the main stem. There are 12 to 18 ribs which are low and definitely tuberculate at the areoles, with broad, shallow furrows between the ribs and between the tubercles. The color of the surface is pale green. areoles: Oval to circular in shape and rather large. The young areoles have much short white or yellowish wool. This gradually disappears with age so that old areoles are almost or quite bare except for the floral areole just above the spines
cacti of the southwest
which remains as a persistent tuft of wool. The areoles are up to 1/4 of an inch apart on the mature sides of the stems. spines: There are 12 to 38 radial spines which radiate evenly all around the areole. They are straight and rigid, and inter lock with those of adjacent areoles. They may recurve back toward the plant slightly on some specimens, but when young they spread out from the plant before they assume their strictly radiating mature position. The upper 4 to 6 of them are short and weak, 1/4 of an inch or less in length. There is a gradual increase in size going around the areole, the laterals being about 1/2 inch long and the lower ones sometimes longer, even up to 3/4 of an inch. The upper radials are usually white, while the laterals and lower ones vary greatly in color, some times being white, yellowish, purple-red, or even variegated with white or light bases and the rest of the spine red. There is great variation in the centrals in this species. On the typical form there are 3 to 6 centrals on mature areoles. These spread from the center of the areole and are not ar ranged in a straight line. They are stout and rigid, somewhat translucent, and usually somewhat curved. A typical areole on a typical mature plant will have 1 or 2 upper centrals which are only 1/4 to 1/2 inch long and point upward. These are usually red or white with red tips. Then there will usually be 2 centrals spreading laterally, straight or curved, about 3/4 of an inch long and all red or red with whitish or yellowish bases. Below this is one long central pointing downward and often curved, which is almost always lighter colored, white sometimes with a reddish tip, stout, rigid, and 3/4 to 11/4 inches long. Some plants have an extra central or two besides these. Young plants do not grow their centrals at all until they are 4 inches or so in height, adding them gradually after that, so that it is easy to find good-sized plants with none or with only a couple of centrals. All of the spines have bulbous bases, but the bases of the radials are usually covered, until they are very old, by the wool of the areole. flowers: Funnel-shaped, not opening widely, 1 inch in diam eter by about 11/4 inches long, very dark green or yellowish green. The outer petals have brownish midlines and green edges. The inner petals are dark green in the midlines with lighter edges, but are often suffused with brown. The petals are linear, not broadening throughout their lengths, the edges entire, and the tips sharply pointed. The filaments are light green and the anthers cream-colored. The pistil is long, green, and ends in 8 dark green stigma lobes. The areoles of the ovary have white wool and white spines about 1/4 to 1/2 inch long upon them. These flowers are produced on the sides of the stems, usually from one-half to two-thirds of the way to the top, but sometimes lower. fruits: Small, greenish, very spiny. They are usually about 1/2 inch long and almost spherical. Range. A small area of southern New Mexico in Luna and Dona Ana counties, specifically from Cook’s Peak and near
genus Echinocereus engelmann
Rincon through the Organ and the Franklin mountains into Texas and Mexico. In Texas occurring in scattered mountain areas from El Paso east about as far as Van Horn, apparently being limited to El Paso and Hudspeth counties, except for a separate variety isolated in Brewster County. Remarks. This cactus was first described by Engelmann in 1856. Typically, it is a beautiful, tall, and slender column of long, rigid, varicolored spines, these partly obscuring the surface of the stem and spreading in all directions, giving the plant an interesting unkempt appearance in contrast to the usual preci sion of armament of other Echinocerei. It has small green, yel low-green, or bronze-green flowers produced on the sides of the stems, very similar to those of E. viridiflorus. This is a compara tively localized form, however, growing in the mountains from about a hundred miles northwest of El Paso to about the same distance southeast of that city. E. chloranthus is one of those cacti which are very difficult to distinguish from their relatives, and I find for more confusion among cactus fanciers about it than about any other mem ber of this genus. Somehow the names of this and the previous species were exchanged in popular usage in west Texas many years ago, and even some dealers’ lists offer them reversed in this way. In addition, another species has been entirely lost for many years by being included under this one. The striking similarity of E. chloranthus to E. viridiflorus is the main cause of the confusion. It is easy enough to distinguish between the typical E. viridiflorus var. viridiflorus, the north ern cactus, and E. chloranthus. The northern plant is very small and squat, has elongated areoles with either no central spine or only 1 per areole, and has flowers with rounded petal tips. E. chloranthus, on the other hand, is tall and slender, has up to 5 spreading centrals not in a row, rounded areoles, and sharply pointed petals. These differences are plain enough, and the widely different ranges of the two, separated by almost half the length of New Mexico, makes it easy to regard them as very separate forms. But the trouble lies with the form of E. viridiflorus called variety cylindricus by Engelmann, which grows in the same range as E. chloranthus and on into the Big Bend. This variety is typically cylindrical also, but somewhat stouter than E. chlo ranthus, with elongated areoles and with 1 to 3 centrals in a straight row. These two are close, but they can be told apart by the shape and size of the areoles and the difference in number, length, and arrangement of the central spines on mature speci mens. Immature specimens are much alike, but can be recognized by their areoles. After one has learned to recognize the two forms the possi bility of confusion is not yet over, because the names used for them have not remained standard. Marshall and T. M. Bock have proposed the combining of E. viridiflorus and E. chloran thus entirely as synonyms. Backeberg, on the other hand, chooses to combine this form with the other as E. viridiflorus var. chlo
17
ranthus. Future study may bring a combination of some sort, but there can be no more than conjecture about what the proper relationship of the two is, without new evidence, which is not yet at hand. In the meantime, it seems, any conscientious student of cacti will have to look very carefully at areoles and spines and come to know this interesting little cactus.
Echinocereus chloranthus var. chloranthus (Eng.) Description Plate 2 stems: As the species, except growing to only about 8 inches tall. areoles: As the species, except to only about 3/8 of an inch apart. spines: As the species, except always spiny and never hairy, the radials only 12 to 23 in number, and the centrals only 3 to 6 in number. flowers: As the species. fruits: As the species. Range. Extreme southern New Mexico in Luna and Dona Ana counties, into El Paso and Hudspeth counties, Texas, and on into Mexico. Remarks. This is the typical form of the species, but it has a restricted range, and far fewer people have seen it than suppose they have.
Echinocereus chloranthus var. neocapillus Weniger Description Plate 2 stems: Cylindrical, up to 10 inches high and 21/2 inches thick. It is usually single, but occasionally branches above the ground. It has 12 to 18 ribs, low, with distinct tubercles. The color is pale or yellowish-green. areoles: Oval, about 3/16 of an inch long, covered with much white or yellowish wool when young, bare when old except for a very small tuft which usually remains at the upper end of the areole where the flower is produced. The areoles are up to 1/4 of an inch apart. spines: There are 30 to 38 straight, slender radial spines. These radiate evenly around the areole, being often so crowd ed that they touch their neighbors most of their lengths, and they interlock with spines from other areoles. The upper ones are very slender and often only 1/8 of an inch long. From this the length increases around the areole, with laterals being up to 1/2 inch long and the lower ones only slightly shorter. They are clear translucent yellow or chalk-white, all of an areole being the same color, this usually forming bands of yellow and white on the older plants. There are 5 to 10 cen tral spines, all heavier and straight. They spread in all direc
18
tions from the crowded center of the areole. The uppermost ones are 1/8 to 1/4 of an inch long, and slender, while the rest of them are heavier and 1/4 to 3/4 of an inch long. They may be all translucent yellow, often with a reddish tip, or oc casionally all reddish. All spines have bulbous bases. Imma ture plants or new branches have no spines at all, but have instead a thick covering of white, very fine, flexible hairs from 1/4 to 1/2 inch long, about 40 hairs to the areole. When the plant is 1 to 2 inches tall spines begin appearing at the tip of the stem. The juvenile hairs can often be seen on the bases of older specimens. flowers: Apparently identical with those of the species. fruits: Similar to those of the species. Range. A very small area including only two ranches 5 to 10 miles south of Marathon, Texas. Remarks. This cactus was noticed by A. R. Leding in 1932, and he published an article on it in the Journal of Heredity in August, 1934, which included pictures of it. At that time he called attention to the unusual form of the juveniles, which are covered with long white hairs instead of spines, but he did not distinguish between the mature form of the plant and the typi cal E. chloranthus or state whether the typical form has hairs when young. He did say that comparison of plants from differ ent localities and the discovery of whether the hairy condition is inherited might show that the form deserves specific or at least varietal rank. This article by Leding was reprinted in the October-Novem ber, 1942, number of the Cactus and Succulent Journal of America, with an added note by the author, but no new con clusions were drawn. The immature plants of this variety are very striking, having no rigid spines at all, but being covered with much long white hair which is 1/4 to 1/2 inch long and produced usually 40 or so hairs to each areole. This hair is their only armament until the plants become about 11/2 inches high. At that size they sud denly begin producing the regular armament of yellow or white spines as described above. The bases of plants 11/2 to as much as 4 inches high will often show a belt of this white wool, with the typical spines above, but this hair is gradually replaced by normal Spines. The spines of adults of this form are very similar to those of E. chloranthus, but not identical. There are 30 or more radials where the typical form has only 12 to 23. These very numerous radials obscure the surface of the stem much more than do those of the typical form. Also, the centrals of this variety are more numerous and shorter. But the major difference between the two is in the juvenile stage. The young plants of typical E. chlo ranthus never have hairs at all, but are covered from the be ginning with rigid spines. There is no possibility of confusing the two in this stage. E. chloranthus var. neocapillus is found growing in a very restricted range encompassing some hills from about 5 to about
cacti of the southwest
10 miles south of Marathon. Where undisturbed the plants grow in quite great numbers, but they have been removed al most entirely from much of their range. Fortunately, some of them are upon ranchland which is closed to all cactus digging, and so they still survive. Since the nearest occurrence of the typical E. chloranthus is about 150 miles northwest, there is little danger of confusing these two in the field. The many more spines, as well as the spine color and the areole shape easily set this variety off from E. viridiflorus var. cylindricus.
Echinocereus russanthus Weniger Description Plate 3 stems: Cylindrical, up to about 10 inches tall and 21/2 inches thick. These stems almost always branch to form clusters of up to a dozen stems. They have 13 to 18 ribs, which are low and narrow with indistinct tubercles. The color of the surface is medium green. areoles: Round at first, then broadly oval. About 1/8 of an inch long, with white wool when young, situated from 1/8 to 3/8 of an inch apart. spines: All spines are very slender and somewhat flexible. There are 30 to 45 slender to very slender and bristle-like radial spines, which are very crowded and which interlock with those of adjacent areoles, giving the plant a very dense spine cover. There is a tuft of small ones at the summit (up per edge) of the areole, which are only 3/16 to 1/4 of an inch long. Moving laterally around the areole the radials become longer, the lower laterals being 1/2 to 5/8 of an inch long. All radials are white or straw-colored. There are 7 to 12 central spines spreading in all directions from bulbous bases. The up per ones are small, similar to the larger radials in size. The lower ones are from 3/4 to 11/4 inches long, though still slen der and rather flexible. While there is a complete gradation of spine sizes from the smallest radial to the largest central, the centrals are distinguished from the radials not only by their position but also by their color, having at least the tip, often the upper half, and sometimes the whole spine reddish or purplish in color. flowers: About 1 inch long, funnel-shaped, not opening widely and so only about 1/2 inch in diameter. They are rust red in color sometimes with darker midlines. All segments are linear in shape, with the ends somewhat pointed, but not sharply so. The bases of all segments are lighter and the cen ter of the flower is greenish. The stamens are pale yellow. The style is long and yellowish. There are 8 to 10 green stigma lobes. fruits: About 1/2 inch long, oval to almost spherical. They are covered with clusters of slender white spines, 10 to 12 on each areole.
genus Echinocereus engelmann
Range. A small area of southwestern Brewster County, Texas, including the northern part of the Chisos Mountains and the country northwest of these to just past Study Butte, but not seen as far west as Terlingua or south to the Rio Grande. Remarks. I have often found it rewarding to examine the thousands of specimens which the Texas dealers in cacti have in their bins. Even a slight variation stands out when it is lying among dozens of its supposed fellows. Several times I have found in such places something new to me and have been able to trace it back to its location and discover what it was. In piles of E. viridiflorus var. cylindricus from the Texas Big Bend we repeatedly found one or two unusual specimens with far too many and too long and flexible spines to be that cactus. Usually the assortment was being sold as E. chloranthus, but the bulk of them were clearly the Big Bend forms of E. viridiflorus. These few obviously different specimens were all that could be seen to explain the confusion of names. These unusual specimens did have the round or oval areoles of E. chloranthus, and noting their long central spines I assumed at first that they were that cactus. They have been going under that name for a long time. But when I saw the actual E. chloranthus, which does not grow at all in the Big Bend, it was obvious that the two plants were really very different. All authorities have given the radial count for E. chloranthus as between 12 and 23, while this cac tus has 30 to at least 45. That cactus has 3 to 6 centrals which are up to 3/4 of an inch long, while this one has 7 to 12 which are up to as much as 11/4 inches long. Such differences as these have usually been deemed sufficient to distinguish varieties in this group, and I thought at first that this would prove to be a Big Bend variety of E. chloranthus. But when the plants bloomed the new one presented a flower different in most respects from that of the other cactus. These flowers are smaller, with more narrow and linear petals, and are rust or russet-red in color. No flower of E. chloranthus ever approaches the color or the texture of these flowers, which are also the smallest I have seen on any Echinocereus. On E. chlo ranthus the flowers are yellow to brown or occasionally almost chocolate brown in color, but never with any reddish coloring, and their petals are firm, opaque, and glossy to the point of being almost waxy. On this Big Bend plant there is no green in the flower beyond the greenish center, the rest of the petals being essentially pale reddish, and these petals are soft, thin, somewhat translucent, and dull of surface instead of glossy. There is no mistaking the two plants when in flower, and these being so different, it seems clear that here is a species entirely separate from E. chloranthus. Once having concluded this, I cast around for what the cac tus might have been named, but in all of the species and vari eties listed for this group in the U. S. I have found no description of this cactus. I did discover Engelmann’s description of a cactus from
19
northern Mexico which seemed almost identical to this one. It was his E. longisetus. His only statement about the flowers of that cactus was “flower… said to be red.” When I saw that the type locality of his plant was in the Santa Rosa Mountains, which form the lower end of a continuous mountain chain of which the Chisos Mountains, where our cactus grows, is the northern end, I immediately thought that the two might be the same species and that it might range over this whole mountain chain. Following up this idea, several of us made trips into these difficult mountains of northern Mexico. We observed and col lected E. longisetus in its type locality, where it grows in clusters of up to thirty sprawling stems, each up to 12 inches long. On the many plants observed we found the radial number always 16 to 21 per areole and the centrals up to 2 inches long. These differences alone indicate that the plants are not the same. And when the true E. longisetus bloomed, there was no further question. It presented beautiful rotate flowers 2 to 21/2 inches in diameter, claret in color with white centers. They looked like a more reddish version of the E. berlandieri flowers, surely as different from the flowers of our Chisos Mountain plant as could be. We were unable to locate E. longisetus growing north of its type locality in the Sierra de Huacha or Sierra del Carmen ranges, and assume that it does not grow up into Texas. Neither did we find our cactus growing south of the northern slope of the Chisos Mountains. I assume, therefore, that these two sepa rate species occupy only their respective escarpments of this large mountain system. E. russanthus is left, therefore, as what appears to be a sepa rate species which, however, has always been thrown in with E. chloranthus. It occupies its own small range, where that cactus never grows, and is actually a much more beautiful plant than most of its close relatives.
Echinocereus caespitosus Eng. “Lace Cactus,’ “Purple Candle,” “Classen’s Cactus” Description Plate 3 stems: Spherical when very young, quickly becoming oval and then, when mature, cylindrical. These stems occasionally, in some locations, grow to 12 inches tall and 31/2 inches thick, but the typical adult size is 4 to 8 inches tall by 2 to 21/2 inches thick. There is a form which never exceeds 3 inches tall and one inch thick. A plant may remain a single, erect stem all of its life, while its neighbor a few feet away may offset and branch to form a cluster of a dozen or so upright stems. This clustering habit is so common as to provide the basis for the name. There are 10 to 19 ribs which are narrow and definite and divided into distinct tubercles. The flesh is dark green.
20
areoles: Small, rather oval, and quite woolly when young, becoming greatly elongated vertically and bare of wool when older. These areoles are 1/8 to 3/16 of an inch long and almost touching on shrunken, dormant plants, but up to 3/16 of an inch apart on active, well-watered ones. spines: There are 12 to 36 rigid but slender radial spines. They radiate evenly, lying almost flat over the surface of the plant. Crowded around the elongated areole in this flat po sition, they look, on each side of it, much like the teeth of a comb, and so are often described as being pectinate. Those at the top of the areole are very tiny, often almost bristle like and only 1/32 to 1/8 of an inch long. The lateral ones are robust and 3/16 to 5/16 of an inch long. The lower 1 to 3 are somewhat smaller again. The spines of adjacent clusters may interlock on the longer spined forms, but do not reach each other on the shorter spined individuals. These spines may be pure white, white with brown tips, yellowish with brown tips, or all brown, or, in one form, have the outer half of each spine shining black or purplish. The plant may be some what banded by variations in these colors, but the spines of any single areole are never variegated. Most commonly there is no central spine, but on many spe cimens in some locations one can find areoles with 1 central standing straight out or 2 centrals, one above the other in the center of the areole. An occasional plant will have such cen trals on the majority or even all of its areoles. These centrals are stout and firm, but only 1/32 to 1/8 of an inch long. flowers: Very large and colorful on all but the dwarf form, being 2 to 5 inches tall and 2 to 4 inches in diameter, and brilliant purple or rose pink. The flower tube is covered with white, cobwebby wool to at least 1/4 of an inch long and clusters of 10 to 14 very fine, hairlike, white, gray, or black spines, 1/4 to 3/4 of an inch long. Above these the outer seg ments of the flower lengthen gradually, with greenish or brownish midlines and pink edges. The petals, of which there are 30 to at least 50, arise from usually narrow reddish or reddish-brown bases (which may, however, be bright green instead) to broaden to 1/4 of an inch or more wide above. This upper part of each petal is purple or rose-pink. Its edges are more or less ragged and often notched. The tips vary from erose and rather blunt to almost entire and definitely pointed. The filaments are reddish at the bases, fading above; the anthers, cream-colored. The style is long and reddish or pink ish, crowned by 8 to 22 large, dark green stigma lobes. The dwarf form has the same flower but with a marked reduction in size and number of almost all flower aspects. fruits: Egg-shaped or almost spherical, covered with the slender spines and wool of the ovary. It remains green until it dries and splits open by one or two vertical slits. Range. As Engelmann stated, this is the most eastern of the Echinocerei. Found in hilly, mostly limestone regions from near Ponca City to near Durant, Oklahoma, on the northeast, and
cacti of the southwest
from there on south to the edge of the coastal plain just west of the Brazos River. Industry and Cat Spring, Texas, mark its southeastern limit. From this line—which, as Engelmann ob served, approximately parallels the 96th longitude—it occurs wherever the proper conditions are found throughout central and western Oklahoma and into southeastern Colorado, as well as over all of northwestern Texas and into a little of eastern New Mexico. The southern limit of its range runs west through Texas just south of San Antonio to Eagle Pass, where it dips into Mexico; from there it curves northwest past the vicinity of Sonora and Big Spring, Texas, to just east of Carlsbad and Roswell, New Mexico. Although it occurs in only widely scat tered locations in eastern New Mexico, its western limit runs approximately from Carlsbad north into eastern Colorado. Remarks. The lace cactus is probably one of the most collect ed, most fancied, and best known of all cacti. Almost anyone the world over who grows cacti has this plant, and it is often the favorite of the collection. The high regard in which it stands, is well earned by the beauty of the plant body with its truly lacy spines and the exquisiteness of its flowers, which are pro duced in profusion by a healthy plant. This cactus is wellknown because it is very widespread in range and so prolific in its natural habitats as to be readily available to any dime store or nursery which wants to stock it. Furthermore, it is tolerant of the rigors of cactus culture after it is in the collec tion. It is the common cactus of two-thirds of Oklahoma and all of central Texas. It is not found everywhere in this wide area, but the right sort of limestone or gypsum hill often supports a population of literally hundreds of individuals. The fact that this cactus has been so commonly seen has not, as one might have hoped, made for less confusion concerning it. Even yet a variety of names are bantered back and forth and each new work on cacti still is unable to make an air-tight case for what the plant really is and what its official name should be. Knowing this, I have made special effort to study thousands of specimens from all possible locations within its range, and have growing before me specimens from each general area in which it is found. Several quirks of history make for two major problems in dealing with this cactus, and each leads to its own type of con fusion. I will attempt here to give as simple an account as pos sible of what has happened in the past in order to evaluate the conflicting views which exist today about E. caespitosus. The plant was undeniably studied by Engelmann, who wrote up several very complete and detailed descriptions of it be tween 1848 and 1856. He originated the name Echinocereus caespitosus for his cactus. But Terscheck had in 1843 named a plant from Mexico Echinocactus reichenbachii. His description was very incomplete and could, as many have since pointed out, fit any one of several cacti in more than one genus. It is very doubtful whether the two names would ever have been associated at all except that Prince Salm-Dyck, in 1844,
genus Echinocereus engelmann
referred to some plants in European collections as Echinopsis pectinata var. reichenbachiana. He wrote Engelmann about the possibility that these might be the same as Engelmann’s plant, and Engelmann mentioned this speculation in one account of E. caespitosus. Early writers to and including Coulter all used Engelmann’s name, E. caespitosus, which is the earliest name with an indis putably adequate description, for the plant. Things might have remained this way and all would have known what plant they were talking about, but in 1893 F. A. Haage, Jr., changed Ter scheck’s useless Echinocactus reichenbachii to Echinocereus reichenbachii, and later Britton and Rose adopted this as the name they used when referring to our cactus. It is true that by the rules of nomenclature the earliest name applying to a plant must be used, but Terscheck’s description does not any more link his name to this plant than to a dozen others, while Prince Salm-Dyck’s usage of the name as a vari ety of E. pectinatus leads definitely away from our plant. It would therefore seem that the resurrection of Terscheck’s name and the adoption of it for our plant was probably not required by the rules. It has certainly led to continuing confusion since that time. But once done, Britton and Rose’s beautiful and popular books carried the name E. reichenbachii so well into general use that what cactus E. caespitosus actually was has been forgotten by almost everyone. Yet any serious student coming across this name so definitely set forth by Engelmann would have to do something with it. Some merely regarded it as a synonym of the other, but others tried to prove that there were two separate plants for the two names. And here the confusion had its second effect and led to the second large problem encountered in un derstanding this cactus. Engelmann pinpointed the eastern range of this cactus almost exactly when he said it corresponded to the 96th meridian, and he very well indicated the western extent of its range in south Texas when he said it goes no farther west than the San Pedro (Devil’s) River. But he badly underestimated the extent of its range northward and westward in the northwestern quadrant of its area when he said it occurred only to about the 100th meridian and the Canadian River. In a later note he did add that it grew from the Arkansas River to Saltillo, which exactly corrects the range northward, but he did not ever seem to know that it occurs west of the 100th meridian. Actually, the plant is found well past the western edge of the Texas and Oklahoma panhandles to the last hills east of the Pecos River in New Mexico. Now, as one might expect, over the huge extent of this range from east to west and north to south there are certain gradients of characteristics in this cactus. And since Engelmann apparently had only eastern specimens to examine—his type came from the farthest southeastern location where it grows— his descriptions are definitely slanted toward the characters most commonly found in the eastern populations and do not
21
allow for extremes found commonly only in specimens from the part of the range he did not know existed. For example, eastern specimens almost always have 20 to 30 radial spines and only extremely rarely—I estimate from my experience maybe in one plant out of a thousand—does one find fewer than 20 radials. Yet in the plants from far western Oklahoma, north western Texas, New Mexico, and Colorado, while radial counts of 12 to 32 are found, many localities have a vast majority showing fewer than 20 radials and only a rare plant with more than 20. Throughout central Oklahoma we find all numbers from 12 to 32 commonly on the same hillside. Also, western plants usually have less wool on the growing stem areoles and shorter spines than eastern ones. There are other less obvious gradients as well. So when students who took the name E. reichenbachii for the common eastern forms began to notice the lower spine numbers, shorter spines, and smaller amount of wool of the far north western forms, they tended to think they had in these north western plants something worthy of a name. Britton and Rose made up some new names such as E. perbellus for these forms, but others, by a strange reversal, called them E. caespitosus. Boissevain and Davidson seem to have initiated this in their work on the Colorado cacti, and others have followed them. Backeberg, in a 1941 article, made a case for a plant from the Wichita Mountains of Oklahoma as being the true E. caespito sus because of its extreme amount of clustering, but in his later works has placed that plant correctly as a form of E. baileyi. However, he still keeps E. caespitosus as separate from E. reichenbachii, saying that the spine clusters of adjacent areoles on E. caespitosus do not intertwine, while those of E. reichen bachii do. I have checked this character specifically at dozens of locations all over the range of these cacti, and have found growing together, wherever there is a large population of plants, specimens with spines interlocking and specimens with spines not interlocking. Coulter made this variation clear many years ago, saying that on E. caespitosus, “Spines may or may not interlock.” It seems obvious, therefore, that we have one definite species with a very large range over which there is gradation. The species description in respect to spine number and so forth is, therefore, broadened in order to include specimens from the part of the range Engelmann did not see. The only question really remaining is which of the two proposed names is legiti mate, and since I cannot honestly tell whether Terscheck meant this cactus by his Echinocactus reichenbachii, while it is ob vious that Engelmann did with his Echinocereus caespitosus, I use that name here. Engelmann noticed that the spine color of individual speci mens of this cactus varied from pure white to chestnut-brown or rosy. He called the brown ones E. caespitosus var. castaneus. This would be the form called by collectors the “brown lace.” Later an attempt was made to transfer this variety to E. pecti natus, a related species, and then to equate it with E. pectinatus
22
var. rubescens. However, other characters such as the long wool and the hairlike spines of the flower tube quickly distinguish it from E. pectinatus and show this sort of combination to be in error. The fact that almost any large population of E. caespito sus studied shows a complete range of colors from white to brown with all sorts of intermediates, and each local popula tion varying only in proportionate numbers of the various colors, indicates that the color of individual plants is only a simple genetic character and not worthy of varietal name at all. At one time members of the Oklahoma cactus society collect ed and studied large numbers of these cacti from the Arbuckle Mountains of that state, where this species is very common. In doing this they found several specimens which bloomed with yellowish instead of violet flowers and one plant with white flowers. For these specimens they proposed the variety names aureiflora and albiflora, respectively. There is no report of these flower colors being seen again, and they are not listed as true varieties. If we can look beyond all this confusion, we have in this species a beautiful cactus, the lace cactus, white to brown in spine color, which is deservedly a favorite of all. It is most easily confused with E. pectinatus. Sometimes individual plants of the two are very hard to tell apart by spine and stem char acters, although the spines of E. caespitosus are typically not so extremely pressed against the plant nor quite so heavy as those of the other. But for absolute identification of the two one must sometimes wait for the flowers to appear. There are various differences here, the most obvious being that—on the flower tube and remaining on the fruit—E. caespitosus has much long wool and extremely thin, flexible, hairlike spines up to 3/4 of an inch long, while E. pectinatus has shorter wool and com paratively thick, rigid spines up to only 3/8 of an inch long.
Echinocereus caespitosus var. caespitosus (Eng.) Description Plates 3, 7 stems: As the species. areoles: As the species. spines: As the species, except that it has 15 to 36 radial spines which are usually long enough to interlock with those of ad jacent areoles. In most of its range only a very rare plant has the radials fewer than 20 in number. However in the ex treme northwestern part of the range individuals with 15 to 20 radials become the majority in some populations. flowers: As the species. fruits: As the species. Range. From approximately the 96th parallel in Texas and Oklahoma west to near Del Rio, Big Spring, and Amarillo in Texas and throughout central and western Oklahoma to the base of the Oklahoma Panhandle, but hardly if at all entering
cacti of the southwest
the Oklahoma Panhandle itself. The most northwesterly records of this form we have are Alabaster Caverns, Woodward, and Shattuck, Oklahoma, and Sanford and Palo Duro Canyon in Texas. Remarks. I take this to be the typical form of the species. It is the form discovered and described by Engelmann, from specimens taken in southeast Texas, as E. caespitosus. It is the form of the species which clusters the most, the name applying well for this reason. It is also the largest form the species assumes. I have broadened the spine count included in this variety from Engelmann’s 20 to 30 radials because in populations over the whole of the range given above we find occasional individ uals exceeding his limits in both maximum and minimum to the extent we have indicated. Specimens with the lower num bers make up a larger proportion of the population the farther northwest one goes, but individuals falling entirely within his range of spine numbers are found all the way to the edge of the area we have indicated. I feel the plants over this wide area comprise one form varying in a continuous gradient from south east to northwest. I consider it the typical variety. Those seg ments of this species which vary from this typical variety I list as separate varieties.
Echinocereus caespitosus var. minor Eng. Description Plate 4 stems: As the species, except that it is very much smaller, apparently reaching a maximum of only 3 inches tall and 1 inch in diameter. areoles: As the species. spines: As the species, except that no centrals have been seen. flowers: Small for the group, being 2 inches tall and 11/2 to 13/4 inches in diameter. They are pale lavender-pink in color, and are otherwise as those of the species, except that the petals are smaller and only 15 to 25 in number, and the stigma lobes 8 in number. fruits: As the species, except smaller. Range. Known only from the vicinity of Stockdale, Wilson County, Texas. Remarks. Engelmann thought it necessary to set this dwarf form of the lace cactus apart as a variety, and so it seems to be. The diminutive size of its body is striking and the reduction of its flower parts from the typical numbers is consistent. Warning should be given, however, that not every small lace cactus discovered is this variety. Engelmann spoke about how precocious E. caespitosus is in blooming, and it is not unusual to find a 2-inch specimen of the typical variety in bloom. In certain areas, notably around the granitic region of Llano and Ink’s Lake, Texas, are found many clusters of very small stems. These, however, all bloom with the typical huge, many-petaled
genus Echinocereus engelmann
purple flowers, and when grown in the garden will in time take on full stem size. The cactus meant by variety minor is different in that it does not grow larger in any situation, and its flowers are small, with only around 20 petals as opposed to the 30 to 50 of the typical form of the species. Engelmann gave no range or location for his dwarf form. We have encountered it only in Wilson County, Texas, where it grows in some fields in rather dense stands.
Echinocereus caespitosus var. perbellus (B. & R.) Description Plate 4 stems: As the species, except that it is not over 4 inches tall, with ribs numbering 13 to 15. areoles: As the species. spines: As the species, except that the total radial number is only 12 to 15 and the central spine is always missing. flowers: As the species, except that they are not as large as the flowers of the species sometimes become. They are usually about 2 inches tall and wide. fruits: As the species. Range. The type locality is Big Spring, Texas. Individuals are found occasionally, associated with typical E. caespitosus popu lations north of this point in Texas, along the western edge of Oklahoma as far as Majors County, west into New Mexico as far as the Pecos River, and on into Colorado. A pure popula tion of the form, unmixed with any other, has been found only near Muleshoe, Bailey County, Texas. Remarks. This is at best a doubtful variety, and certainly not a separate species. Its existence at all as a separate entity would probably never have been advocated except for that unfortu nate failure of Engelmann to have Specimens from the north western part of its range when he drew up his description of E. caespitosus. Limited as he was to specimens from the east, he gave as the radial number for his species 20 to 30, which is the number on almost all examples found in central Oklahoma and Texas. But even here a rare plant will show 15 to 20 or more than 30 radials, giving us a hint that his spread is too narrow. This fact was apparently not realized for many years. So when Britton and Rose were confronted with small speci mens from Big Spring, Texas, with only 12 to 15 radials, they immediately set up a new species, calling it E. perbellus, al though all of its other characters which they listed equaled those of E. caespitosus. Later authorities appear to have seen no specimens of this form except the originals, and the species has stood as Britton and Rose described it until this time. In this study I have made great effort to collect this species in its type locality and to study it. Two extensive collecting
23
trips into the Big Spring area netted numerous specimens of E. caespitosus with radials from 17 to 24 in number, but not those with the 12 to 15 of Britton and Rose. Finally, on a third ex tensive search of the area we collected two specimens, both small plants identical to the previous ones, but both with 12 to 15 radials. We had apparently re-collected E. perbellus at last. But in the process we had established that specimens with fewer than 20 radials but more than 15 were common in the area, as they are in the surrounding countryside. We began to suspect that intermediates could be found linking these two numbers entirely and that we had no separate species here after all. Later collections throughout northwest Texas, western Okla homa, eastern New Mexico, and Colorado established that the range of radial numbers throughout the area was 12 to 30, the most common being 17 to 26, these latter numbers appearing in the populations at almost any good location. At one location in Majors County, Oklahoma, we found specimens with radial counts as low as 12 and as high as 23. This was the same location where Caryl, in 1935, reported the first collection of E. perbellus in Oklahoma. But what we had here was no separate population of a separate form, but instead just some specimens of E. caespitosus with the lower extreme of spine number, mixed with typical specimens. At this discovery we were ready to follow Mrs. Lahman, no doubt the greatest student of Oklahoma cacti, who also in 1935 wrote, “In the meantime, I have crossed E. perbellus from my list of Oklahoma cacti until I find someone who really knows what it is.” We had about decided that Britton and Rose’s taxon had arisen out of Engelmann’s failure to realize the scope of his species and that it should be entirely relegated to the synonymy. This may still be the case, and the name may yet be dropped, but since then we have discovered a population of cacti in Bailey County, Texas, near Muleshoe, in which all of several dozen plants examined have 12 to 14 radials and no centrals. These bloomed with flowers typical, although small for the species, and have no other obvious character to distinguish them from that species. Since this is a pure population of this form, perhaps it should be recognized after all. It certainly cannot be considered a separate species, and may be only a clone. In the meantime, in the complete absence of any experi mental evidence concerning any of the relationships of these plants, the most logical way to treat it so that it will not be lost and will be available for future study is to call it a variety of the species.
Echinocereus caespitosus var. purpureus (Lahman) “Black Lace” Description Plate 5 stems: As the species, except that it is smaller in maximum size and clusters more sparingly.
24
areoles: As the species. spines: 14 to 22 radials and 0 to 3 centrals, as the species, except that the outer part of each spine is shiny purplish or glistening black in color. flowers: As the species, except that they are always purple in color. There were 12 stigma lobes on all specimens seen. fruits: As the species. Range. The Wichita and Glass (Gloss) mountains of western Oklahoma. Remarks: This cactus was found at Medicine Park, Oklahoma, on the eastern edge of the Wichita Mountains, and described by Mrs. Lahman, who studied the cacti of Oklahoma extensively. It is very rare and has been seldom seen again. Mr. Charles Po laski of Oklahoma City, who has the finest private collection of cacti I have seen, supplied the first specimen of it which I had the privilege to study. This specimen came from the Glass Mountains about 100 miles north of the type locality at Medi cine Park. Mr. Polaski, who grew up in the Wichita Mountains near Medicine Park says he has never seen it there, and I have searched the type locality without finding either it or any form of E. caespitosus. A large area of Medicine Park is now under the waters of Lake Lawtonka, and perhaps it grew in this now flooded area. The Glass Mountain plants show the strikingly beautiful, purple-black coloring of the spines described by Mrs. Lahman. They show all of the other characters of her plant, except that the variation of radial spines is from 14 to 22, which raises the maximum number 4 spines beyond her report. This does not seem significant in the light of the variations in spine number we have already seen in this group. The large flower is as she describes, a very beautiful deep meadow violet, except that the throat may be reddish instead of green as she described it. This also seems unimportant, since we find other specimens of E. caespitosus with flowers with either green or reddish throats. The stigma lobes on all specimens seen were 12 in number, which is strikingly regular for this group. An evaluation of all the characters of this plant seems to show only the dark coloration of the spines to distinguish it from the typical E. caespitosus. Everything else falls within the known range of the species, when it is interpreted in the broad way made necessary by including specimens of all its range. This spine color does not seem sufficient grounds for considering it a separate species, so I place it here as a variety. Whether even this is justified remains to be determined after further study. The coloring of the plant body is very beautiful, and so con spicuous as to prompt special exclamations when it is seen in a collection. We have no other cactus with this striking colora tion. It is so dark that the term, “black lace,” arises spontane ously for it. Even this shows how closely it is related to the more common lace cactus. Unfortunately it is very rare. Much ranchland must be covered to discover a single specimen. It would be a good cactus to be distributed by the trade.
cacti of the southwest
Echinocereus melanocentrus Lowry Description Plate 5 stems: Almost spherical to oval when young, becoming cylindrical. Single, or when very old, sometimes branching to include two or three side-branches. Each stem may reach a maximum of about 61/2 inches tall and about 2 inches thick. There are 10 to 13 ribs of definite, confluent tubercles. The surface color is very deep green. areoles: Practically touching to 1/8 of an inch apart. They are oval when young to elongated when old, and woolly at first, becoming bare. spines: There are 17 to 20 slender radial spines lying pectinate close to the plant surface. The upper ones are only 1/32 to 1/16 of an inch long, the lateral ones gradually lengthening to a maximum in the lower laterals of 1/4 to 1/8 of an inch. The lowermost spines are somewhat shorter again. Spines of ad jacent clusters may or may not interlock. There is one central spine on each areole standing out, perpendicular to the plant body, or turned slightly upward. It is straight and slender, like the radials and rises from a bulbous base, black or mahogany in color. It is 3/16 to 3/8 of an inch long. flowers: 2 to 3 inches across and tall. They are showy rose pink in color, with reddish centers. The petals are almost linear or slightly broadening over their upper parts, their ends more or less ragged. They recurve greatly as the flower ages, leaving it open extremely wide by the second day. The style is pink ish, the stigma lobes green and 12 or 13 in number. The ovary has on it cobwebby wool and very black or brown and white, very slender, flexible, hairlike spines 1/4 to 1/2 inch long. fruits: Unknown. Range. Very localized in sections of Jim Wells and Kleberg counties, Texas. Remarks: E. melanocentrus is one of those rare little cacti we find growing in extremely localized situations here and there. It is found under the extremely heavy brush of the small amount of uncleared territory there is left around Alice and Kingsville, Texas. Even here it is only found in certain spots. Much of this territory is in ranches where the owners are extremely jealous of their rights to keep outsiders out, and so few had seen this cactus until recently. Perhaps this is fortunate, because at the same time that this keeps the plant out of the public eye it preserves it in its natural setting. But the ranchers are using clearing devices and now spraying with brush-killing chemicals more and more, so the plant is not safe in any case. A few Texas dealers have found an accessible location and in the past few years I have seen possibly a hundred of the plants being distributed. This species is very similar to E. caespitosus in general ap pearance. It looks much like that other species with one con spicuous black central stuck on each areole. However, E. caes pitosus does not grow anywhere within over 100 miles of the
genus Echinocereus engelmann
location of E. melanocentrus, and the general aspect of the flowers of the two plants are somewhat different. The flowers of E. melanocentrus are apparently identical to those of E. fitchii, and there are other similarities to this species found farther west in south Texas, but the two will hardly be confused, since E. fitchii has 3 to 7 spreading centrals instead of only one, and its radials are not pectinate. E. melanocentrus is a little known specialty of an area which, having none of the more common representatives of this group, boasts its own
Echinocereus fitchii B. & R. Description Plate 5 stems: Upright and usually single, sometimes putting out only 1 or 2 side-branches when very old. These stems are to 6 inches tall and 2 inches thick, medium to dark green in color, having 10 to 14 ribs of low, confluent tubercles. areoles: Round when young, becoming oval on the sides of the plant. They are small in size, almost touching to 3/16 of an inch apart, and woolly when young, becoming bare. spines: There are 20 to 25 radial spines which are white with brown tips to tan with reddish-brown or black tips. They are slender and not pectinate, but spreading outward somewhat from the plant surface. The uppers are very short, the lower laterals becoming 1/4 to 3/8 of an inch long. There are 3 to 7 slender central spines which are the same color as the ra dials, rising from slightly bulbous bases, 1/8 to 3/16 of an inch long and spreading to the sides instead of standing out in one row. flowers: Large and showy, pink, always with dark bur gundy centers. They are about 21/2 inches tall and 2 to 4 inches across. The flower tube possesses much cobwebby wool and 10 to 17 hairlike, yellowish or white, dark-tipped spines to 1/2 inch long. There is much variation in petal shape, as there is in this whole group. They run from linear to spatulate, and the ends are blunt or pointed, ragged or entire. Usually the petals recurve when the flower is completely open. The long style is pink, and there are 12 or 13 green stigma lobes. The flowers are fragrant. fruits: Spherical to oval, 1/2 to 1 inch long. They remain green and covered with white wool and spines. Range. Along the Rio Grande and away from it only a few miles from near Rio Grande City northwest past Laredo to not quite as far upstream as Eagle Pass, Texas. Remarks. E. fitchii seems to be an immigrant to us from Mexico, appearing as it does just along a stretch of the Rio Grande, but it appears not to be widespread in north Mexico either. I have collected paralleling its whole range about 50 miles within Mexico without seeing one specimen of the plant that far south.
25
It does occur in Mexico, and there are other forms farther down in that country whose relationship to this must be close, but within our own territory it has only a tenuous foothold on gravelly hillsides overlooking the Rio Grande. Much of its ter ritory was flooded by the huge Falcon Lake, and it is now pos sible to collect this cactus literally from the boat, when that lake is high. It is found to the northwestern edge of Webb County, but hardly farther in that direction, its range stopping almost too abruptly to believe, about 30 miles below the lowermost collection point of E. caespitosus. E. fitchii is easily distinguished from the other cacti of this group by the fact that its spines spread outward instead of lying neatly pectinate. This is a slight difference, but apparently a sufficient one, as one never hears this cactus called a lace cactus. Its numerous spreading centrals also distinguish it. Its spines are arranged very nearly like those of E. dasy acanthus, and it does look much like a small, delicate version of that cactus, but every other character is different, and no one should confuse them. It also shows a superficial similarity to E. pectinatus, but, besides the differences in the spines, the flowers are different. The ovary with its wool and hairlike, flexible spines is entirely unlike that of E. pectinatus, which lacks the long wool and has rigid spines. There is much variation in the spine colors of E. fitchii, as indicated in the description, but all spines on any plant are the same, so there is no banding. The difference is from individual to individual. The extreme on one side is almost pure white, with only pale brown tips on the spines; the plant of the oppo site extreme has spines all tan or honey-colored below, with the outer half of each spine red-brown or black. Most plants in between these extremes present a sort of salt and pepper appear ance over-all. The species is easy to grow and presents beautiful flowers. These flowers vary remarkably, however, in size and petal char acters; there is hardly any variation in their fine, delicate coloring.
Echinocereus baileyi B. & R. Description Plate 6 stems: Globose or oblong at first, becoming cylindrical with age. They sometimes remain single, but usually form clusters which may become very dense with up to 30 stems when old. Individual stems measure up to 8 inches tall and 31/2 inches thick. They are medium green in color, with ribs narrow and somewhat tuberculate. areoles: Oval when young, and very woolly, becoming elongated when older. They usually become bare when very old, but may for a long time have a mass of dirty white or tawny wool at the upper edge of the areole, and some plants
26
have been seen on which the areoles remained rimmed with wool. They are 1/8 to 1/4 of an inch apart. spines: There are 12 to 28 slender but rigid radial spines which are not pectinate, but spreading outward from the plant and interlocking with those of adjacent areoles. The upper ones are very small and weak, the lateral ones become progressively longer until the lower laterals are 5/8 to 1 inch long. There are 0 to 5 centrals, these often very small, some times only 1/8 to 3/16 of an inch long, but on those plants with well-developed centrals they may be 1/4 to 3/8 of an inch long. When there are several centrals they spread from crowded bases almost lined up vertically in the middle of the areole. The spines vary in color from pure white to yellowish, straw to rust-brown, or even rosy reddish, but all on any given plant will be the same color, giving a fine variety of colors in most stands of the species. flowers: Large and showy, 2 to 3 inches tall and 21/4 to 31/2 inches in diameter. They are fuchsia in color. The petals arise from narrow red bases and their upper parts are broad and fuchsia in color, with the ends ragged or erose. The stamens are very short, and the style is short for the group. There are 10 to 21, but most commonly 10 to 12, dark green stigma lobes. The ovary surface is covered with a great deal of long white wool and also has 5 to 15 hairlike, white to rusty spines 1/4 to 3/8 of an inch long on each areole. fruits: Egg-shaped, 3/8 to 1/2 of an inch long. They remain green and covered with wool and bristles until they dry and split open laterally to scatter the seeds. Range. Apparently restricted to the Wichita Mountains of southwestern Oklahoma. Remarks. This is one of the most attractive of the Echinocerei, yet it is very restricted in its range and, therefore, is not so well known as some of its relatives. It is an inhabitant of the unique granitic region of southwest Oklahoma comprising the Wichita Mountains. There have been occasional reports of its having been collected outside these mountains in adjacent areas of Oklahoma and even in nearby Texas, but those reports which it has been possible to check have all proved to deal with E. caes pitosus instead. As one enters the Wichita Mountains from the east, near Lawton, Oklahoma, E. baileyi is found immediately, growing in beautiful stands, often of hundreds of plants to gether, upon the undisturbed granite-strewn slopes and ledges. It is found in profusion almost throughout the Wichita Moun tains Wildlife Refuge and north of it a few miles, then north west to Quartz Mountain and its attendant hills. The last of this mountain chain on the northwest is Granite Mountain, arising all alone above the town of Granite, Oklahoma. All over this huge pile of red granite, in the crevices of the main mass and in between the huge boulders, are clumps of E. baileyi, but be yond this, as in every other direction from these mountains, stretch the ordinary hills and plains of Oklahoma, where E. caespitosus takes over.
cacti of the southwest
E. baileyi is easily distinguished from its relatives by the pro fusion and length of its spines. These cover the whole plant and stand out from its surface in all directions, giving it a distinctly unkempt appearance when compared with the majority of the Echinocerei. Only E. longisetus from far-off northern Mexico has such long and unruly spines, and those are extremely slender and flexible, while these of E. baileyi are strong and rigid. The flowers of E. baileyi are similar in many ways to those of the lace cactus, but are not quite as big and flamboyant, and are rose-red rather than purple. When a whole population of this cactus is viewed on any good mountainside in its range, it presents a remarkable selec tion of spine colors. There is no variation on the individual plants and, therefore, no banding at all; but individual plants vary greatly from each other in color, the range of colors run ning from pure white through yellowish, tan, brown, and rusty to rose-red. The effect of all these colors together in a thick stand is very attractive. Also presented is quite a variation in number and length of radial spines, from as few as 12 to as many as 28, and the longest of these from as little as 5/8 of an inch on some plants to as much as 1 inch on others. Central spine number varies also, from none on some plants to 5 on the most heavily armed ones. All of these variations, with the exception of the radial num ber, seem to present gradients through the range, the majority of the plants in the east being white or light color and averaging shorter spines and fewer centrals, while on the western edge of the range at Granite, the majority are rusty or reddish, have spines averaging longer, and usually have several centrals in each areole. One cannot set up ranges for these variations with in the over-all range, however. These are only averages. For instance, the darkest colored, rosy-tipped spines I have seen were on a plant growing within inches of a pure white neighbor near Medicine Park, at the eastern edge of the range, while the shortest spines I measured were on a white individual on far western Granite Mountain. These variations thus appear to be the result of simple quantitative inheritance within one major unit population. Britton and Rose first named and described this cactus. Un fortunately they had the benefit of only a few specimens to examine, brought to them by Mr. Bailey; and, therefore, they had no concept of the actual limits of the species’ characters. This fact has caused much confusion, especially since most more recent students have apparently seen no more representative series of the plant than they did, and so have attempted to fol low Britton and Rose’s too narrow description. Backeberg, for instance, goes to quite some trouble, apparently in order to agree with Britton and Rose who say the plant has no centrals, to try to make a case that on older areoles the spines arising in the middle of the young areoles all finally assume radial positions. This is unfortunate, as on every mountainside, even among the predominantly central-less specimens of the east, there is an occasional plant with a distinct central or two, and in the
genus Echinocereus engelmann
west the vast majority of plants have 2 to 5 unmistakable cen trals up to 3/8 of an inch long. Similarly, Britton and Rose give “about 16” as the number of radials, while the number actually varies from 12 to 28. In the description given above I have broadened the limits to include the whole range of characters found in studying the whole population over its entire known range. This seems the only way to understand it as the continuous entity that it is. Probably because of Britton and Rose’s too limited descrip tion, attempts have been made to segregate parts of this popula tion as separate species. Mrs. Lahman, noticing specimens which did not conform to the original description, described and at tempted to set off E. oklahomensis, distinguished by having 20 to 24 radials only 5/8 of an inch long and 0 to 2 centrals. She also set up E. longispinus, with 14 to 16 radials up to 1 inch long. Specimens with both these sets of characters are easily found on almost any undisturbed slope in the Wichita Moun tains, and it does not seem that they deserve even varietal des ignation. They just represent two extremes of the plant, unknown to Britton and Rose. A more recent attempt has been made by Backeberg to break up the species. In an article in 1941, attempting to show that there was a difference between E. caespitosus and E. reichen bachii, he turned to some white, very greatly clustering speci mens of E. baileyi sent him from Oklahoma and described them as the true E. caespitosus, rediscovered after all this time. He was impressed by the dense clusters of these specimens and thought Engelmann must have meant something like this in using the name he did for his plant. It is, however, obvious that Backeberg’s specimens could not be Engelmann’s E. caespitosus, since nothing like the Oklahoma plant grows within hundreds of miles of Industry, Texas, which was the type locality of E. caespitosus. It is equally obvious to anyone knowing Oklahoma cacti that Backeberg’s photo of his plant showed only a short stemmed, clustering specimen of E. baileyi. Backeberg, in his more recent work, Die Cactaceae, has recognized this, and now calls this plant E. baileyi var. caespitosus. It seems unnecessary to maintain even this varietal distinction, as everywhere in the Wichita Mountains the whole range of variation exists togeth er, from single-stemmed, tall specimens to greatly clustering plants. The largest cluster I myself have counted had 30 stems 5 to 6 inches tall, and grew less than two feet from a plant, identical in every respect except that it was a full 8 inches tall and showing signs of old age without offering to ever become more than a single stem. Backeberg has also set up a set of varieties based almost en tirely on spine color, as follows: E. baileyi var. brunispinus having long, chestnut-brown spines; variety flavispinus with soft and pale yellow spines; variety albispinus (Lahman) Backe berg having white spines; and variety roseispinus having long but soft spines, rose at the tips. This sort of thing appears to be useless in a case of quantitatively varying characters in which there are all possible intermediates. We could as well have eight
27
varieties on color basis as four, once this sort of thing is started. If one can look beyond the minor differences, he will see whole hillsides of granite boulders in the crevices of which grow beautiful spiny columns and clusters of columns, from as red as the rocks themselves to as white as the snow which covers them here in the winter. This is E. baileyi, one of only two or three cacti unique to Oklahoma, and surely one of which the state can be proud. It is also necessary to report here what appears to be an even more rare and remarkable variant of this variable species. Years ago Oklahoma’s outstanding cactophiles, Mr. and Mrs. Charles Polaski, discovered a strange cactus on Headquarters Moun tain, near Granite, Oklahoma. Only one individual was found, and much searching of the mountain has never revealed another. But Mr. Polaski is an expert at cactus culture, and he has propa gated this individual vegetatively for many years by grafting. He most kindly gave me a cutting of it, as he has to others. The plant presents real peculiarities. The grafted cuttings have become cylindrical, clustering from the base, some stems up to 2 inches thick. The surface is in very indistinct ribs com posed of almost separate tubercles. The areoles have 15 to 20 short, spreading, whitish spines, but are more remarkable for having, besides the spines, a mass of fine, white wool. The whole plant remains covered with this woolly development, under the spines. I puzzled over my cutting of this plant for a number of years, while I tried to persuade it to bloom, but it finally died without responding that much to my care. In 1965, Curt Backeberg described this form as a new species, calling it Echinocereus mariae, and with his article is a photo graph of its bloom, which appears much like the typical E. baileyi flower. What actually is this plant? After much reflection, I feel that this individual specimen found upon Headquarters Mountain is only an aberrant, atypical individual of E. baileyi, which grows in its typical form all over the mountain. Note that the spines are much like those of E. baileyi in everything except length-they are shorter. Note also that the growing tip of E. baileyi has the same sort of woolly areoles, the wool later, with maturity, falling off. Add to this the fact that the ribs in the growing tip of E. baileyi are, as in most cacti, markedly tuberculate, only flattening out later; that Backeberg’s photo shows a flower in no visible character contrasting with those of this species; and that the grafted cuttings greatly surpass the 2.3 centimeters maximum he gives for the stem diameter of the original specimen, and approach the typical stem size of E. baileyi. Notice that all of these unique characters of this cactus can be interpreted as a retention of juvenile or immature form. This makes it seem that we have here a plant retarded in some way, and the flower, when it was finally seen, not being unique, I feel it should be considered an atypical individual of E. baileyi. I therefore do not list this as a separate species here. This decision is also influenced by the following consideration. It
28
does not seem proper to erect new species upon only one in dividual, and I understand that this plant was never re-col lected. If the modern concept of the species as a population had been followed in the past, numerous names based upon one atypical specimen only would never have been proposed, and the study of cacti would be much simpler. While the knowledge of this specimen and its existence for all these years in several collections stands as a fitting tribute to the surpassing abilities of Mr. and Mrs. Polaski in collecting and culturing cacti, it seems the one individual can hardly constitute a formal taxon.
Echinocereus albispinus Lahman Description Plate 6 stems: Densely clustering. Individual stems are cylindrical arid 3 to 6 inches tall, while to only 1 inch thick, with 12 to 14 narrow, tuberculate ribs. areoles: Oval, very woolly when young. The wool persists for a long time, but very old areoles are bare. spines: 14 to about 20 radial spines, not pectinate against the plant surface but deflected evenly outward all around the areole. They are very slender, the uppers the shortest, being only 3/16 of an inch or so long, while the laterals are from 3/8 to 1/2 inch long. There are no centrals. All spines are pure white, or sometimes white with light brown, translucent tips. flowers: Very pale pink or rose-pink, 11/2 to 21/2 inches tall and 1/4 to 3 inches in diameter. They usually open very widely so that the petals are curved backward. These petals arise from very narrow, brownish bases and broaden only slightly to a maximum width of only 1/4 of an inch. The upper parts of the petals are whitish-pink. The upper edges of the petals are very ragged, but they are pointed at the apex. The Style is white, and there are 7 to 11 light green stigma lobes. The ovary surface has much white wool and clusters of 12 or more hairlike spines up to 1/4 of an inch long, in shades of white, grays, tans, browns, to black. These flowers are usually produced below the apex of the plant and may appear well down the sides of the stems. fruits: Almost spherical, 1/2 to 3/4 of an inch across, green, said to be edible. They split open when ripe. Range. The type locality of this species is near Medicine Park, Oklahoma, in the eastern end of the Wichita Mountains. It had not been found outside of the type locality until, during this study, it was collected on a single granite ridge a few miles northwest of Tishomingo, in Johnston County, Oklahoma. Remarks. When Mrs. Lahman made her study of the cacti of the Wichita Mountains, she spoke of most of her new forms as variations of E. baileyi, even while giving several of them new species names. But two forms which she discovered she set apart
cacti of the southwest
most definitely from that species. After listing her five varia tions of the E. baileyi species, she then said, “Also there are two others which appear to be separate species and are here de scribed as E. purpureus and E. albispinus.” We have seen that her E. purpureus was in fact separate from the E. baileyi vari eties, since it appears instead to be a form of E. caespitosus. Therefore I would assume that her E. albispinus is accurately set off from E. baileyi also, instead of being just the white form of that plant. The cactus which fits her description will not be confused with E. baileyi by any observer who sees it in a living condi tion. Its spines are shorter, and while they are not pectinate, they stand out around the areole evenly at the angle found on some specimens of E. caespitosus. It has the manicured appear ance of that species and none of the disheveled look of E. baileyi. In fact, it is much nearer in appearance to a long spined E. caespitosus than to a short-spined E. baileyi. Even from Mrs. Lahman’s photograph this is clear. However, it seems distinct from both. Its mature stems are more slender as well as shorter than those of either of the others, and its flowers are different. They are smaller and the most pale in color of any related Echinocereus. The exaggerated way in which they open back until the petal tips almost touch the outside of the ovary is also unique, as well as the low position on the stem from which the flowers usually, but not always, sprout. E. albispinus is probably the most rare of Oklahoma cacti. We have seen no evidence that this cactus has actually been observed alive by any student since Mrs. Lahman until this time. Her description and photos of it are usually reprinted without any elaboration. Backeberg, however, quickly assumed that she referred to the common white-spined E. baileyi, and so appro priated her name for his series of color-dictated varieties, making it E. baileyi var. albispinus. Not only does this sort of variation based on color alone seem ill-founded, but the use of this name in this way ignores the already-mentioned differences which set this plant off from all the E. baileyi forms. Thanks to the aid of Drs. Bruce Blauch and Claude Gatewood (until recently of the Oklahoma State University), we have collected a number of specimens of a cactus which fits Mrs. Lahman’s description very well. We feel that it is distinct from any other and stands best as a separate species between E. baileyi and E. caespitosus. It was truly surprising when this cactus turned up on a single one of the many granite ridges near Tishomingo, Oklahoma. The area in which the plant grows in that location is only a few acres and the total population is probably no more than 100 plants. This is fully 100 miles from the type locality of E. albi spinus or from any known collections of E. baileyi. E. caespito sus grows in profusion not many miles away, but is not found associated with this plant. This is one of those surprising turns of distribution found so often in cacti.
genus Echinocereus engelmann
Echinocereus chisoensis Marshall Description Plate 7 stems: Columnar, to 8 inches tall, but remaining rather slen der, the greatest diameter seen being two inches. They are almost always simple, but may, very rarely, branch above the ground. They have 13 to 16 ribs composed of very distinct tubercles almost completely separated from each other by broad valleys. The color of the surface is deep green or bluish green. areoles: Very small for the group, being about 1/8 of an inch or less across. They are circular and woolly at first, be coming oval and naked when older. These areoles are about 1/4 of an inch apart. spines: There are 10 to 15 very slender radial spines which radiate evenly around the areole and lie almost parallel to the plant body. They are white or gray below with the upper part red-brown or maroon. The uppermost ones are very small, only 1/16 to 1/8 of an inch long, and bristle-like. The lateral ones are progressively longer, until the lower laterals are 1/4 to 3/4 of an inch long. There are also 1 to 4 central spines. One is porrect or nearly so and 1/4 to 5/8 of an inch long, while the others are more or less spreading and shorter. They are all very slender and straight, from bulbous bases. They are black or dark red-brown, usually with whitish bases. flowers: Rose in color, with reddish centers, about 21/2 inches long, but never opening widely, and so only 1 to 2 inches in diameter. The petals are long and these would be big flowers of 3 or more inches across if they opened back, but the petals remain almost perfectly upright. They are ob long, the bases deep red and the upper parts rose, with entire, pointed tips. The pistil is short and white. The stigma is com posed of 10 small, green lobes. The surface of the ovary has some white wool and clusters of 8 to 14 white to brownish, hairlike spines. fruits: Elongated, 1 to 13/8 inches long and about 1/2 inch in diameter. They are red and fleshy when ripe, but covered with wool and bristles. When older they become dry and split open. Range. Restricted to the Chisos Mountains within the Big Bend National Park, Brewster County, Texas. Remarks. This cactus was first described by Marshall in 1940. It is an obscure species, perhaps best described as retiring in both habitat and appearance. Even among those living and working at the Big Bend National Park, it is mostly unknown. The reasons for its remaining so little known are clear. It hides shielded in the middle of clumps of brush and never seems to dare to expose itself on ledges or open spaces. Among the stems of protecting bushes its small, upright column is well camouflaged and so is seldom seen. Even its flowers are striking ly reserved for an Echinocereus. They are as large as many of
29
the flamboyant ones, but discreetly remain almost closed even during the few hours of the afternoon when they are open at all, showing only the pale rose color of the outer petal surfaces. There is bright color within them, but it is deep in the center where only the bees see it and it attracts no one else. Although almost unknown, the cactus is not rare in its area. Marshall spoke of examining over three hundred specimens, and I found it easy to locate dozens of them, once I knew how to search for them. The relationships of the plant to other Echinocerei are dif ficult at best to determine. Marshall discussed its similarity to some forms of E. fendleri, but concluded that they were only superficial. On the other hand, characters of the ovary surface, rib and areole arrangement, and spine form all relate it more closely to E. pectinatus or E. caespitosus than to E. fendleri. E. chisoensis is a delicate cactus, rarely seen, but a unique resident of the Big Bend National Park, where it is, fortunately, protected and so should be with us long after many of its more flamboyant relatives are decimated through a combination of conspicuousness and lack of protection.
Echinocereus pectinatus var. wenigeri Benson “Comb Hedgehog” Description Plate 7 stems: Single, or sometimes in old specimens 2 or 3 to one plant. They are egg-shaped to stoutly cylindrical, growing to 10 inches tall and 31/2 inches thick. Rows of distinct but con fluent tubercles make up shallow ribs on the stems. The number of ribs on Texas plants is 13 to 18. areoles: Broadly oval and woolly when growing at the tip of the plant, but becoming narrowly oval or elongated and bare when older, on the sides of the stem. These areoles are from almost touching to 3/16 of an inch apart. spines: There are 15 to 20 radial spines which are pectinate, spreading over the surface of the plant, the laterals actually to some extent recurved back into the grooves between the ribs. They are medium strength to rather heavy and very rigid. The upper ones are most slender and short and the laterals longer, to between 3/8 and 1/2 inch. There are 2 or 3 central spines standing in a vertical row in the center of each areole. They are stout, but very short, only 1/16 to 1/8 of an inch long. All spines are white with pinkish or purplish tips. flowers: Very large and striking in appearance, 3 to 5 inches tall and broad. The outer one-half or less of each oblong, broad, blunt petal is lavender pink in color. Below that is an expanse of white extending to the narrow bases of the petals, which are green. This gives a unique, three-colored flower, pink around the edges with a distinct white zone making up
30
sometimes half of the flower, followed by a greenish center. The stigma is whitish and supports 9 to 12 large, dark green stigma lobes. The ovary surface bears some short, white wool and 6 to 18 rigid spines, white or white with dark brown tips and measuring to 3/8 of an inch long. fruits: Spherical or nearly so, about 1 inch in diameter. Fleshy at first, becoming bronze or brown in color, after which they dry and split open. Range. A local form of a Mexican species encountered only occasionally in Texas, from Del Rio on the east to just beyond Sanderson on the west, in a strip not over twenty miles wide along the Rio Grande. It is not reported from the Big Bend in Texas, but has been reported from the southern edge of New Mexico, although the report has not been confirmed. Remarks. The species E. pectinatus grows widely in Mexico, but can be regarded as established in only two areas of the U. S. It is well represented in Arizona, one form coming from that state into the extreme southwest corner of New Mexico as well; and the form just described is rare but can be found in a limited strip of Texas from Del Rio to Sanderson. Strangely, it seems to be missing in the wide expanse of the border between these locations. This leaves the Texas form of it isolated from the rest. It is never common even in that area. A full day’s tramping over the hills just north of the Rio Grande in the vicinity of the lower Pecos and Devil’s rivers will yield at best one or two specimens, if the searcher has good eyes and better luck. The Texas range of the cactus begins just west and south of the southwesternmost range of E. caespitosus and extends west just to the beginning of E. dasyacanthus. It is sandwiched between these its two closest relatives. The Texas specimens of this cactus have some differences from the typical specimens from Mexico, namely, fewer ribs; more oval, more woolly, and more widely spaced areoles; whiter spine coloring; and a lower maximum number of both radial and central spines, as well as heavier spines. At first, I did not distinguish it from the Mexican E. pectinatus, but after I became familiar with the Texas plants and after I had studied literally hundreds of Mexican specimens coming from that country through our Texas cactus dealers, and had collected the plant in various parts of Mexico myself, without finding one specimen to match ours, I became convinced that we have here our own distinct form. L. Benson erroneously refers my specimens of variety ctenoides from Mexico to this variety and so credits me wrongly with having collected the variety in Mexico as well as in Texas. The cactus may well be Hooker’s E. pectinatus var. texana, but there is no way to know, and, therefore, that name has not been recognized by any recent writers. L. Benson finally de scribed and typified the form, naming it after the author. I feel it deserves varietal rank, as he indicated. E. pectinatus var. wenigeri can easily be distinguished from E. dasyacanthus because its radials are rigidly recurved and
cacti of the southwest
appressed to the surface of the plant instead of spreading out ward, and because its centrals are very short, and are always in one vertical line instead of being longer and spreading out ward. The typical Mexican E. pectinatus is actually much closer to E. dasyacanthus than is variety wenigeri. It is equally easy to distinguish from the typical E. caespitosus, which also has more outward-standing, finer spines, and often no centrals at all. But some specimens of E. caespitosus have very nearly as recurved radial spines and 1 or 2 short centrals in the middle of the areole. It is then very hard to distinguish the two by the plant body alone. But if one has the opportunity and patience to observe the flowers of the two the distinction is obvious: E. pectinatus presents a flower tube with short wool and short, rigid spines, while E. caespitosus always has long wool and long, flexible, hairlike spines on its flower. The white zone is also always present in the flower of E. pectinatus, while the flower of the other always lacks it, since its darker purple petals deepen to a reddish or greenish center.
Echinocereus pectinatus var. rigidissimus (Eng.) Rümpl. “Arizona Rainbow Hedgehog,” “Cabeza del Viejo” Description Plate 7 stems: Thick columnar to 8 inches tail and 4 inches thick. They may be single or rarely branched, with 18 to 23 narrow, tuberculate ribs. areoles: Elongated, and from practically touching to 1/4 of an inch apart. spines: There are 15 to 23 radial spines which are pectinate and recurved to lie fiat on the surface of the plant. They are very heavy and rigid. The upper spines of each areole are small and a translucent tan, amber, or gray. The laterals and lower spines are to 5/8 of an inch long, tan or amber, amber with red tips, or sometimes all red. The plant usually presents a banded appearance due to successions of these spine colors. There are no central spines. flowers: Identical to those of previous form except the outer parts of the segments fuchsia and often having 13 stigma lobes. fruits: As those of the previous form. Range. Extreme southwest New Mexico and south Arizona into Sonora, Mexico. Remarks. This is now regarded as a variety of E. pectinatus. It presents the same large, white-zoned flowers and the same general appearance, being, however, distinguished from the typical form of the species by its heavier spines and its larger stem size. The spines are always all radials, and are the longest and heaviest of this species. They interlock, and the plant body is usually hidden under this thick, rigid armament lying flat
genus Echinocereus engelmann
upon it. This seems also to be the only one of this group to present a variegation of the spine color on a single areole. Typi cally, the upper, smaller spines of each areole are lighter, while the lower ones are more or less red. These characters make it easily distinguishable from the other varieties of the species. It will be noticed that the pattern of coloration of the spines is almost the same as those of E. viridiflorus. Because of this I have seen this cactus confused by beginners with large, robust, short-spined specimens of E. viridiflorus var. cylindricus of the Big Bend in Texas. If closer observation does not clear up this error, the big purplish flower is surely a surprise when it ap pears where the little greenish one was expected. The flower of variety rigidissimus is identical with that of the species. It seems, however, to be a more prolific bloomer when cared for, and so is a great favorite of growers. Numer ous photographs of this plant in its glory with many of the striking flowers open at once have been printed in various books and magazines. This cactus seems to be limited in its natural range to the mountains of the southwest corner of New Mexico and south eastern Arizona, coming up out of Mexico in only that one area. Coulter once stated that it was found in west Texas, but this seems doubtful. It is a beautiful form, just managing to enter the corner of our area.
Echinocereus pectinatus var. ctenoides (Eng.) Description Plates 7, 8 stems: Single or sometimes clustering to half a dozen stems, each heavily cylindrical and to 6 inches tall by 3 inches in diameter, having 15 or 16 ribs greatly interrupted by tubercles. areoles: As the species. spines: As the species except that the radial number is only 14 to 22 and the centrals always number 2 to 4. The spines are white with very light brown tips. The plants are never purplish or banded with color. flowers: A large and showy orange-yellow, 21/2 to 4 inches long and wide. The petals are almost linear to narrowly spatulate, the ends erose. The upper part of each petal has a bright orange midline. The lower one third of each petal is green, and the center bright green. The style is greenish white, and there are 13 dark green stigmas. The outer ovary surface has a little short white wool and 14 to 16 short, rigid spines, which are white with dark brown tips, per areole. fruits: 1/2 to 11/8 inches in diameter, spherical or egg-shaped. They are green, turning to greenish-brown when ripe, and covered with short wool and rigid spines which, however, become deciduous when the fruit ripens.
31
Range. Given originally as from Eagle Pass to the Pecos in Texas and south to near Santa Rosa, Coahuila, Mexico. It is said to exist westward in Mexico into Chihuahua. Apparently it is now extinct in Texas. Remarks. It is a real indication of the thoroughness of the early collectors and of Engelmann’s studies that this plant was col lected and described over one hundred years ago. I am per suaded that none of the more recent students of cacti since Coulter have seen it at all, but this has not kept them from writing about it, and so the confusion is extensive, as can be ex pected. Engelmann described the cactus in detail and pictured it well, including the flower. He had specimens from Bigelow, collected at Eagle Pass and near Santa Rosa, Coahuila, and those of Wright, collected by the lower Pecos River, which is not far from Eagle Pass. He stated that the plant “looked distinct enough from C. dasyacanthus,” and then he stated that “the flowerless plant so closely resembles C. pectinatus that it can hardly be distinguished from it except by the fewer ribs.” In spite of this, later students have, probably because of its yellow flowers, tried to link this with E. dasyacanthus, and in their enthusiasm they have published some pictures of several different forms under this name. Backeberg finally grew bold enough to come out and call the cactus E. dasyacanthus var. ctenoides. In making this study, we recognized that this plant was one of the least known of all in our area and needed clearing up more than almost any other, so we early made attempts to col lect and study it. For four years we made field trips regularly to the Eagle Pass vicinity and the area of the lower Pecos River looking for it. In this time I believe that I myself covered al most every undisturbed acreage along the Rio Grande from below Eagle Pass to the Pecos looking for this cactus, and it is not now to be found. We believe the form is now extinct on the north side of the Rio Grande—if indeed Engelmann meant to imply that it was on this side of the river in the first place. Still wanting to find out what the plant really was, we then extended our field trips into the adjacent part of Coahuila, working down toward the Santa Rosa Mountains, which was the other location where Engelmann reported the plant as grow ing. We found nothing for many miles below Eagle Pass, but in the rugged mountains northwest of Santa Rosa (now called Ciudad Muzquiz) we suddenly found stands of small, white Echinocerei almost exactly like E. pectinatus, except for their whiter spines. We noted that they were much more inclined to cluster than any E. pectinatus we had seen, and then, noting the regularly 15 or 16 ribs and 2 to 4 centrals, we began to hope that we had found ctenoides. When the plants bloomed, they presented large, light-orange flowers, and we had our con firmation. It is obvious, as it should have been from Engelmann’s de scription and his illustrations, that this is a form of E. pectina
32
tus. It bears no characters half so close to E. dasyacanthus, ex cept the flower color, and we now know that that species has flowers ranging from yellow to magenta. With this we have the parallel situation of E. pectinatus with flowers from orangeyellow to fuchsia. The question of whether this cactus should even remain listed as a separate variety will doubtless now become the order of business. We do not separate the yellow, pink, and magentaflowered strains of E. dasyacanthus this way. But it seems that this plant has other consistently maintained characters setting it off from its species: such as its greater clustering tendency, its smaller size, its fewer ribs, and so forth. We apparently are faced here with the first cactus form ren dered extinct from our area of the United States in the past hundred years. Very much of the land around Eagle Pass is farmed and the majority of the range areas which look undis turbed have actually been cleared in one way or another in the past, so this is not really surprising. But may we take warning from this and cherish our other cacti found in limited areas more actively?
Echinocereus dasyacanthus Eng. “Texas Rainbow Cactus,” “Golden Rainbow Hedgehog,” “Yellow-Flowered Pitaya” Description Plate 9 stems: Oval at first, soon becoming cylindrical. They grow to a maximum of 14 inches tall and 4 inches thick. These stems often remain single, but old plants quite often branch to form several heads. They have 12 to 21 narrow, tuberculate ribs. areoles: Round and with tan wool at the growing tip of an active stem, becoming oval or elliptical and bare when older. They are 1/8 to 3/8 of an inch apart. spines: There are 15 to 25 radial spines per areole, all spread ing outward at various angles from the surface of the plant and interlocking with those of adjacent areoles, so that the plant surface is heavily covered by them. They are rigid and of medium thickness, the upper ones very short and the lat erals to 1/2 or even 5/8 of an inch long. There are also 2 to 5 robust centrals usually 1/8 to 1/2 inch long, but occasionally 3/4 or even 1 inch long. These centrals stand spreading in all directions from the center of the areole, and are not lined up in a vertical row. All spines are white, yellowish, or tan, with their tips reddish or rust-brown. The variations in color shades are often found in zones up and down an individual plant, giving the typical specimen distinct bands of color, although some specimens are of one unvarying color and so are not banded at all. flowers: Very large and showy. 3 to 51/2 inches long and
cacti of the southwest
wide, in colors they range from yellow through pink to violet and magenta. The very long petals are spatulate, with the ends ragged and variously notched or pointed. Their bases are green. The style is long and white. There are 12 to 22 large, deep green stigma lobes. The long flower tube has some short wool and 7 to 18 rigid spines to 1/2 inch long and pure white to white with reddish tips upon each areole. fruits: Spherical, 1 to 2 inches in diameter. They are covered with spines until ripe, when these become deciduous and the fruit becomes red-brown or purplish. Range. Southeastern New Mexico through southwestern Texas and the Big Bend. On the east it extends to near Sanderson and Fort Stockton, and into the Guadalupe Mountains of Texas. It follows these mountains a short distance north into New Mex ico. It is common in the Big Bend and around El Paso, Texas. It has been said to extend west all the way into Arizona, but I cannot verify this. Remarks. E. dasyacanthus is the largest member of this group, the most robust in every feature. It likes to stand unprotected by the shade of any other plant on the thin soil of rocky slopes, where its thick spine cover gives it protection from the severe elements as well as from all enemies. A colony of fine old plants on a Big Bend hillside, many of them to at least a foot tall and varying from almost white to reddish or rusty brown, often banded with these colors, is a proud and handsome sight. They bloom with huge flowers, often opening well down on the sides of the plants. These flowers come in all shades from pale yellow to reddish, pink, and even deep magenta. It seems obvious that no varieties can be set up within this species on the basis of flower color. Other variations found within the limits of this species, such as banding or lack of banding with color, do not seem any more significant. Miss Clover set up the name E. steereae for the whitish, nonbanded, violet-flowered population found in the Chisos Mountains of the Big Bend, but this does not seem warranted. Rumpler tried to make this E. pectinatus var. steereae, but the radials are not pectinate, nor are the areoles elongated. If made a variety, it would have to be E. dasyacantha var. steereae, as Backeberg lists it, but even this does not seem supportable since we would have only the flower color to distinguish it. Whether or not the limits of this species have been drawn widely enough is another question. Coulter found a cactus some where in southeastern New Mexico which he called E. dasy acanthus var. neo-mexicanus (note that this is not the same as Wooton’s E. neo-mexicanus). Coulter described his plant as hav ing areoles 3/8 to 9/16 of an inch apart, with stouter, “spreading radials and 4 stout centrals and larger seeds.” He apparently did not see the flowers of this plant. No one has since been sure what this cactus of Coulter’s really was, and the name should probably be eliminated, since it seems impossible to know. Most have found it irresistible to speculate, however, and I would add my own theory. Coulter
genus Echinocereus engelmann
did not know that E. dasyacanthus could have any flower color except yellow. He even used this flower color to key this plant from its relatives. So he automatically set both the species and his variety of it off from all of its red or purple-flowered relatives and apparently never thought to compare characters between the two groups he had set up, yellow-flowered and purple-flowered. Since we now know that this division will not stand, when we disregard flower color, we find that the characters of his E. dasyacanthus var. neo-mexicanus and those of the red-flowered E. roetteri are practically identical. Re membering that they are similar enough so that Engelmann had first called E. roetteri by the name of E. dasyacanthus var. minor, and that Coulter did not know the flower color of his variety, I find it likely that his variety neo-mexicanus was nothing but E. roetteri. Beyond this sort of speculation we cannot go. Benson decided to combine E. dasyacanthus with E. pectina tus as a variety of that other species, and since by the rules of nomenclature, one must use an earlier variety name for such a combination if one exists, he calls our cactus E. pectinatus var. neo-mexicanus in place of E. dasyacanthus. Even in doing this, he commented that this was unfortunate, and so it surely is, as it would leave us for our most well-known rainbow cactus only an obscure name which refers to no one knows what for sure. It seems that the species is distinct enough from E. pectinatus anyway, and the combination need not be made in the first place.
Echinocereus dasyacanthus var. dasyacanthus (Eng.) Description Plate 9 stems: As the species. areoles: As the species, except always round. spines: As the species, except that the centrals are not seen less than 3/8 of an inch long. flowers: As the species. fruits: As the species. Range. Southeastern New Mexico and southwestern Texas east to the Guadalupe and Davis mountains and to near Sanderson, Texas. From these areas it ranges into Mexico. It is also said to range west into Arizona, but I have been unable to confirm this definitely. Remarks. This is the common, typical form of the species which is so widely appreciated by almost everyone who looks at cacti at all. It is a dominant part of almost every collection from western Texas or southern New Mexico. However, most speci mens grown in gardens come from along the highways instead of from farther south in the nearly inaccessible mountains along the Rio Grande, and so most people see only yellow-flowered individuals.
33
There is actually a gradient of flower color in the wild popu lation. Nearly all plants growing in New Mexico and around El Paso bloom yellow or orange-yellow. In the Big Bend of Texas pink is more common; and in the lower and eastern part of the Big Bend red and purplish are almost the rule. The full range of colors is found south and west of Sanderson, with some populations there being almost entirely magenta. I saw a beautiful collection of over one hundred local specimens in a rock garden in Sanderson in which all the range of colors were blooming together, but with yellow the most rare. Each speci men I have seen has presented only one color of flower, but Marshall reported seeing a specimen bloom with yellow and purple flowers simultaneously.
Echinocereus dasyacanthus var. hildmanii Arendt Description Plate 9 stems: Ovate to tapering cylindrical, single at first but soon clustering to at least 6 or 8 stems, each of these to 10 inches tall and 3 inches in diameter. The flesh is dark green, and the stems have 12 to 16 very tuberculate, narrow ribs. areoles: Round to oval, woolly when young, then bare. They are 3/16 to 1/4 of an inch apart. spines: 15 or 16 radials to 3/8 of an inch long, white or gray at the bases with maroon or brownish tips. There are 3 to 5 centrals 1/8 to 5/16 of an inch long, from the same color as the radials to completely maroon or dark red-brown. The spines do not band the plant with color. flowers: 4 inches tall, 31/2 inches across, deep orange-yellow, with 15 to 19 stigmas. Otherwise they are as the species. fruits: Not observed. Range. The Davis and Apache mountains of west Texas to near Pecos, Texas. Remarks. This form is very close to E. dasyacanthus, yet is suf ficiently distinct from it to be set apart from it even by ama teurs who don’t have any name for it. It is never a rainbow, having no banding of colors. The fewer spines do not cover its body so entirely, so the dark green flesh is always visible. Although the individual stems are smaller, the cactus is defi nitely a clustering one. I have actually yet to see an unbranched specimen, and the largest I have seen had 8 stems loosely clumped in a cluster well over a foot in diameter. This sort of growth is never seen in the typical E. dasyacanthus. Yet the flowers of the two are almost indistinguishable, and the other character dif ferences between them are so minor that it seems no more than a variety. Since Arendt described it in 1892, it has, probably, not been seen by any student until now. Schumann did not mention it, and Britton and Rose seem to have confused it with E. fendleri
34
var. bonkerae, in which Backeberg followed them. It should be noted that their description when discussing the plant is of spec imens collected in the Santa Catalina Mountains of Arizona, and so not of this plant. Arendt described it definitely as a Texas cactus. It is a rare form, and limited to the Davis and Apache mountains and the hills northeast of them to near the Pecos River.
Echinocereus roetteri (Eng.) Rümpl. Description Plate 10 stems: Single, at first rather egg-shaped, but becoming cylin drical, up to 6 inches tall and about 3 inches in diameter. The surface is bluish or grayish-green, and there are 10 to 13 ribs which are composed of definite tubercles. areoles: Oval or sometimes round, with some tan wool when young, but naked when old. These areoles are 1/4 to 1/2 inch apart. spines: There are 8 to 15 radial spines, the variation due to the plant’s frequent addition of very tiny bristle-like radials at the top of the areoles. These upper radials are only 1/8 to 3/16 of an inch long. The lateral radials are of medium thick ness, straight, and up to 1/2 inch long. The lowermost radial is a little shorter and weaker than the laterals. There are also 2 to 5 centrals which are stout and straight, 3/8 to 1/2 inch long, and spreading in all directions. All the spines are opaque and ashy brown or almost maroon, with the tips blackish, and their bases are bulbous. flowers: Brilliant purplish in color, but only 2 to 3 inches long and not opening widely. fruits: Almost round to elongated egg-shaped, and small, being only 1/2 to 7/8 of an inch long. Range. Originally given by Engelmann as from El Paso, Texas, south in the sand hills, and said by Coulter to range from there west into Arizona and south into Chihuahua. But the only records in recent times have been from southeastern New Mexico. Remarks. This is a very obscure and difficult cactus. It has been surrounded by confusion from the beginning. Engelmann first described it as E. dasyacanthus var. minor, but later withdrew that connection and called it Cereus roetteri. Coulter probably studied it more thoroughly than anyone else, having at hand plants from Texas, Arizona, and Chihuahua. Britton and Rose seem to have been misled by Engelmann’s first linking of the plant with E. dasyacanthus. Their specimen collected at El Paso is a tiny thing only 11/2 inches tall, which seems to have no cen trals at all, and appears to be a seedling of E. dasyacanthus. Their specimen from Arizona has 1 or 2 very short centrals, apparently in a row, and appears to be one of the E. pectinatus group. At any rate, since I have seen living plants of E. roetteri,
cacti of the southwest
their preserved specimens do not seem to me to be this plant. This may explain why their description of the cactus is erro neous in several respects. More recently Backeberg has realized the close relationship of this cactus with E. lloydii, and combines these two, calling that other cactus E. roetteri var. lloydii. It does seem obvious that these latter two are closely related. How closely is not clear. However, on the basis of the very few specimens of this rare cactus I have seen, I feel it is too soon to combine them. E. roetteri seems to be a much smaller, noncluster ing form with other vegetative characters strikingly similar to the more robust E. lloydii. But the flowers and fruits of E. roetteri are very much smaller than those of the other, and its flowers show none of the firm, lasting characters of the claretcup group, which those of E. lloydii display. E. roetteri is today an extremely rare cactus. The few known specimens recently collected all have come from southern New Mexico. It is surprising that with the large amount of recent study of Arizona cacti this one has not been reported there since Coulter. It is not so surprising that it is not seen around El Paso, which is its type locality, since the real estate, farming, and military developments there have already greatly reduced several much more common species of the area. For this reason it appears that it cannot be found in Texas today, surviving only farther west, in less disturbed areas.
Echinocereus lloydii B. & R. Description Plate 11 stems: Simple at first, but clustering and branching slowly to form clumps of up to about six stems when old, the single stems attaining a large size before clustering. Mature stems grow to 12 inches high and as much as 41/2 inches thick, and are cylindrical and bright green to gray-green in color. The ribs are 11 to 13 in number, broad, interrupted, and extremely tuberculate, being formed of broad thickenings at the areoles. There are deep furrows running down the sides of the ribs be tween these broad bases of the tubercles. The vertical furrows between adjacent ribs on the older parts of the stem are the deepest I have seen on any Echinocereus, being up to at least 3/4 of an inch deep. areoles: Medium to large, oval to circular, with much white wool when young, but becoming practically bare with age. They are 1/2 to 5/8 of an inch apart. spines: When mature all ashy-gray to reddish-gray, but when young and growing they are a brilliant purplish-red, this color often remaining for many years on the tips of the spines. All spines are of medium stoutness, round, and straight from bulbous bases. There are 14 to 17 radial spines, the lower and lateral ones being 1/2 to occasionally 7/8 of an inch long. The upper radials are very much more slender, and much
genus Echinocereus engelmann
shorter-down to 1/4 of an inch long. There are 4 to 8 cen tral spines identical to the larger radials standing perpen dicular to the stem and spreading slightly from the crowded center of the areole. flowers: Large and very beautiful, usually being 3 inches long and 2 to 31/2 inches in diameter. There is much variation in their color. They are most commonly scarlet, but I have specimens with petals coral-pink instead. The outer petals are greenish in the midline with entire edges and pointed tips. The inner petals are long, spatulate, with entire edges al though these are sometimes somewhat notched at the tips. There are 9 to 14 green stigma lobes. The filaments are pink ish, the anthers extremely small and pinkish or rose in color. The ovary tube bears some white wool and clusters of 7 to 12 firm, reddish spines which are almost equivalent in arrange ment to those on the stem areoles, except that they are more slender. fruits: Egg-shaped and 11/4 to 2 inches long. They are dense ly covered with spines; when the fruit is ripe, these spines loosen fairly easily, but do not seem to fall unless brushed off. The ripe fruit is greenish-orange in color and fleshy. Range. Known only from the type locality, Tuna Springs, Texas, which is about 20 miles east of Fort Stockton in Pecos County. Remarks. This cactus was named by Britton and Rose in 1922 from plants collected by Mr. F. E. Lloyd, in his honor. Mr. Lloyd collected many cacti in the area around Tuna Springs, and there was no other label of location on his plants but that. Tuna Springs has not existed as a town and is not on most Texas maps, so during all these years it has been impossible for interested people to go and find this cactus. The long period of time in which the plant has been lost has not been com pletely unfortunate, because this has meant that no one has collected it. Consequently it has grown undisturbed and rather commonly in its small area, when most of our rare species whose locales have been known are nearing extinction. But re cently the fact that Tuna Springs was once a stagecoach stop a short way east of Fort Stockton has become known, and deal ers have been rapidly bringing out the plants. Its continued survival under these conditions is doubtful. This is a heavy-stemmed, clustering Echinocereus possessing an interesting set of characteristics, which make it unique. In areoles, spines, and stem shape it is very close to the scarletflowered E. triglochidiatus-E. polyacanthus-E. coccineus group, and its flowers show certain similarities to these (such as in the pink anthers). Yet there are definite differences from these and the flowers are more purplish and less waxy or long lasting than those of the claret cups, making it appear rather intermediate between those and the purple-flowered groups. The theorists will surely play with this one, but in the mean time, it is a rare and beautiful Texas cactus recently rediscovered.
35
Echinocereus triglochidiatus Eng. “Claret-Cup Cactus,” “Strawberry Cactus,” “King’s Cup Cactus” Description Plates 11, 12 stems: Globular to cylindrical in shape with 5 to 9 broad, rounded ribs having wide, shallow grooves between them. These stems may be from 3 to 18 inches in maximum length by 21/2 to 41/2 inches thick. The surface of the stems is very soft, often markedly wrinkled, and from dark to pale green in color. These stems cluster in different numbers in different varieties, usually producing fewer than a dozen heads, but in one form an old plant occasionally becomes a large mat of up to around 50 heads. In all cases, however, the stems are loosely and irregularly clustered, a plant being made up of various-sized stems, standing or partly reclining in an irregular clump. areoles: Circular, varying greatly in size within the species from no more than 1/8 of an inch to sometimes over 1/4 of an inch in diameter. They also vary in distance from one another. The areoles always have much white wool when young, but usually become bare in age. spines: Yellowish or red when growing, becoming opaque, ashy-gray to almost black when old. They vary within the species in number, size, and shape, the range being as follows: radials from 2 to 9 in number and centrals 0 or 1, all these variously from 3/8 to 21/2 inches long, from rather slender to very thick, rounded to greatly flattened, angular, or channeled, as well as either straight or curved. flowers: 2 to 23/4 inches long and 1 to 11/2 inches in dia meter, rigid, waxy, and remarkable among the cacti for their persistence, often staying open for several days and nights. The stiff, blunt petals are scarlet-red or orange-red from nar row green or whitish bases. The stamens are as long as or slightly longer than the petals, with filaments greenish be low, becoming fuchsia above. The anthers are very tiny and fuchsia. They are about the same length as the style, so that they sometimes partly enclose the stigma, which has 5 to 11 green lobes. The ovary surface has small areoles upon it, each with a fleshy scale-like segment, a little white wool, and 2 to 6 slender, white, or white-tipped brown spines. fruits: Varying within the species. They are round or oval and from 3/4 to 1/2 inches in largest measurement, somewhat tuberculate to practically smooth, with some spines which usually become deciduous with ripening. In color they are from green to green with a pinkish cast or else bright red when ripe. Range. Taken as a species, this plant ranges over a very wide area from near Kerrville in central Texas, west through all of the Texas Big Bend to near El Paso, then north through central New Mexico into Colorado and northwestern Arizona. Remarks. There has probably been more confusion about E.
36
triglochidiatus than about any other Echinocereus. It is mostly due, I believe, to the fact that this name is the oldest among the red-flowered Echinocerei. Because of this the descriptions given under the name have been broadened from time to time to include every new form which has been put with it in com bination. This process has gone on until the extreme is reached by L. Benson’s description in the Cacti of Arizona, where he describes E. triglochidiatus as having stems from 8 to 24 inches high and spines from as few as 3 to as many as 16 per areole. This sort of description is obviously drawn up to include every thing in the red-flowered Echinocereus group. It really has little to do with the E. triglochidiatus as it was described by Engelmann. Since we have all degrees between these two ex tremes in the literature, it is not hard to see why the confusion is so great. There will never be anything but confusion here until we see how this problem came about. There exists a whole series of Echinocerei all of which have flowers similar in that their firm, long-lasting petals are scar let-red with no blue pigments in them and their stamens light magenta. They are often called the “claret cups” because of this remarkable flower coloration. The shape of the flower and its parts is essentially the same in all of these forms, with the only difference between their flowers being minor variations in the proportions of some of the floral parts. In size, manner of growth, and details of stem and spines, however, these forms show easily as much variation as is found between many other recognized cactus species, and far more than between some. To give a general description broad enough to encompass all of them is almost to repeat the broad charac teristics of the entire clustering, sparsely ribbed group of Echi nocerei. This problem has caused disagreement as to how to treat these forms from the very start. On the one hand, there have been authorities who have described them all as separate species because of their diversity of stem and spine characters; on the other hand some have placed most of them together as varieties within large species groupings because of their flower similari ties. A few have even proposed uniting them all into one large, variable species complex. Almost every authority has his own system at least slightly different from every other, often with different names for the same plants—and sometimes the same author has changed his system from publication to publication. All of this makes E. triglochidiatus one of the most difficult groups of cacti to understand. Synonymous names are often taken to mean different plants, and on the other hand, doubtful combinations have been made where some definite characters or other have been overlooked. This has led to the reporting of some of these forms from areas, and even from states, where they do not really occur. On the basis of this sort of thing, several of them have been almost lost sight of altogether. It has even been maintained by some that they cannot really be dis tinguished at all, but intergrade entirely. After much observation of the plants in their habitats and
cacti of the southwest
after study of available herbarium materials and the literature on them, I have concluded that, once erroneous and incomplete descriptions and doubtful records based on these are eliminated, most of the major forms long ago described in this group do exist within definite ranges and can be distinguished by constant characters. What are they then? Most of them are too widespread to be clones. Several of them are found in identical or very similar environments in overlapping ranges, and I have seen them pre serve their distinctive characters perfectly in the uniform en vironments of gardens and greenhouses. Therefore, they do not seem to qualify as ecotypes or environmental modifications of a single taxon. This leaves their differences as rather clearly genetic, and the crucial questions here would be: What are their genetic relationships? Are they close enough genetically to be varieties or distinct enough, after all, to be species? But these are the questions no one can yet answer, because of a twofold lack. First, there is no standard degree of genetic relationship, at least in cacti, one side of which is a variety and the other side of which is a species. The thing has just not been worked out to this degree as yet. And, more important, we know noth ing so far concerning the genetic relationships of the Echino cerei. There has been absolutely no biosystematic research re ported upon them; not even chromosome numbers are known for these forms. So at the present time no one can say cate gorically from any research data that these are either species or varieties. Any decision is a purely arbitrary, philosophical one. So we continue to get different treatments of these forms de termined entirely by each author’s concept of species. This ac counts for the highly confusing spectacle we have today of two leading authorities on cacti so completely at odds that while Benson regards the claret cups all as varieties of one vastly en larged species, Backeberg treats them just as confidently as separate small species. It is still no more than a philosophical argument. Faced with the necessity of taking a stand on this question, I am following a middle course. It seems clear that some of these forms are too close to be totally separate species. I am, therefore, following Benson in listing as varieties under the species name, E. triglochidiatus, all those forms which are close enough to the typical form that their inclusion does not cause the original species description to be altered basically. But I agree with Backeberg that the lumping of everything with the one characteristic of a firm, long-lasting flower into one species is unnecessary, and so I am leaving separate from that species all of those forms whose vegetative characters are so far re moved from the original, typical form that their inclusion would cause the species to become something basically different from the original. This decision, like any made at this time about this group, is arbitrary, and we look forward to the day when some one will be able to give us experimental evidence to decide these questions.
genus Echinocereus engelmann
From this position, then, we move on to discover and under stand the varieties of this fine species.
Echinocereus triglochidiatus var. triglochidiatus (Eng.) Description Plate 11 stems: Clustering or branching only slowly to form small clumps often of no more than two or three stems, with an apparent maximum of a dozen or so stems per plant. The stems are of unequal lengths and loosely clustered, each one cylindrical, dark green, and usually somewhat wrinkled, the largest being up to about 8 inches high and about 3 inches in diameter. There are usually 7 ribs, but occasionally there may be 6 or 8, and they are broad, with slight swellings at the areoles and with very shallow grooves between them. areoles: Circular, but not large for the group, with white wool persisting on them, 7/8 to 11/2 inches apart, these being the more widely spaced areoles found in this group. spines: Ashy-gray to almost black, from 1/2 to 21/2 inches long. They are very stout, most of them being about 1/8 of an inch in diameter for most of their lengths. They have very much enlarged bases and are very flattened or angled, with distinct ridges or grooves running the length of the spines, the top surfaces of them even being concave in most cases. Some of the spines are straight, but some of them at least are curved, in every specimen I have seen. There are 2 to 6 spines to an areole, all of them radials, but a fair share of the areoles on any plant usually have the 3 spines from which comes the name of the plant. flowers: As the species, except to 11/4 inches long; the petals broadest at the tips and very blunt. fruits: Oval or egg-shaped, 1 to 11/4 inches long and 3/4 to 1 inch in diameter. They are tuberculate. Fruits I have watch ed remained green until about January, when they rotted without coloring. The areoles were on the upper ends of long, broad tubercles about 1/8 of an inch wide at the top and 1/2 inch wide at their bases. Each areole possessed a pinkish, fleshy scale and 2 to 5 stout, persistent spines which showed under magnification the same angled, channeled, and twisted character as the plant’s major spines. Britton and Rose, as well as Boissevain, have described the fruits as red, with deciduous spines, but it is worth remembering that these au thors had already combined this with other forms known to have red fruits, so their descriptions may be of those other forms. There is no description of the fruits of this form by earlier authorities before the confusion of combinations had begun to enter the picture. Range. Northern New Mexico from near the upper Pecos River west to just beyond the Arizona boundary and north into Col
37
orado. Its southern limit seems to be near Albuquerque, New Mexico. Remarks. In the process of combination which has been prac ticed the form originally described by Engelmann as E. triglo chidiatus—with its stems only up to 8 inches high and its spines very long, very heavy, greatly angled, and all radials—has al most been lost sight of, as witnessed by the fact that its range is often given today as being from Arizona throughout New Mexico and trans-Pecos Texas. When the form originally cir cumscribed by Engelmann is considered, however, I find it to be the form described above, and this specific cactus has a def inite range much less wide than is often ascribed to it, due to the inclusion of other forms under the too-broad descriptions. When this is once understood, the confusion vanishes. The easternmost report of this plant is still Engelmann’s report of it on the Gallinas River just east of the upper Pecos, which would be near Las Vegas or Anton Chico, New Mexico, and the westernmost report of it from Fort Defiance, just within upper Arizona. It seems most common about the mountain slopes from Albuquerque to the Gallup area of New Mexico and north from there into south-central Colorado. Coulter cites a supposed collection of it in Texas by Wislizenus in 1846, and on the strength of that places its range as extending that far into Texas, but it is significant that Engelmann in 1856, having worked over Wislizenus’ material, did not mention any collections of it in Texas. This one Texas report may have led later students to mistake for it variety octacanthus, which does grow widely in Texas, and may be the reason for the survival of the idea that it grows in Texas. In much collecting throughout far west Texas and in lower New Mexico, I have never seen it growing there, nor found anyone who had, in spite of the fact that thousands of plants have been shipped out of Texas erroneously called by this name. The plant is a handsome cactus, one of New Mexico’s finest. It is very hardy, and its dark green looks its best half buried in a snowbank. It is, of course, most beautiful in the spring when it has its fiery red flowers. Their character, shared with the other red-flowered Echinocerei but unique among other cacti, of staying open for several days and nights at a time, makes the plant a favorite of all.
Echinocereus triglochidiatus var. gonacanthus (Eng.) B. & R. “Claret-Cup Cactus,” “King’s Cup Cactus” Description Plate 12 stems: Cylindrical, clustering very slowly and sparingly, usually only 2 or 3 stems to a plant and the most I have seen in one cluster being 6. Each stem has 7 to 9 ribs which are somewhat rounded, with shallow grooves between them and with distinct, rounded swellings of the ribs at the areoles. There are two separate populations of this form identical ex
38
cept for size. In the widespread northwestern population the stems are only 3 to 6 inches high and to about 21/2 inches thick, but there is a localized population restricted to the vicinity of the White Sands National Monument, where the stems grow to a maximum of at least 18 inches tall by 41/2 inches thick. areoles: These are very large for the group, 1/4 to 3/8 of an inch in diameter, with a great deal of wool when young, but losing much of it with age. They are about 1/4 to 3/4 of an inch apart. spines: The spines of this cactus are most striking. They are as heavy as or heavier than those of variety triglochidiatus, and there are more of them. At least some of them are always curved, bent, and twisted, and they are conspicuously angled, ridged, and furrowed—the largest ones often having 6 or 7 flattened surfaces and deep grooves. They are yellowish, mottled or tipped with black, when young, and then gray to almost black when old. There is commonly one very heavy central spine which usually has 6 or 7 angles, and is curved and twisted, 1 to 21/2 inches long, and around 1/8 of an inch thick. There are 6 to 8 radial spines, the lower 7 radiating fairly evenly and being the shortest of the spines. The upper radial is usually about equal to the central spine and may be even longer. It is often mistaken for a second central because of its size. flowers: As the species, except that they are larger, being about 21/2 inches long, with the petals widening more gradu ally from their narrow bases and their tips not as broad as those of the plant’s relatives. The ovary surface has slender white bristles at least 1/2 inch long upon it. fruits: Unreported by anyone except Earle, who describes them as spiny, globose, and green with a pink blush. Range. This cactus is always rare, and is found in a compara tively small area around Zuni and Gallup, New Mexico, ex tending from there to just within Arizona and into the south western corner of Colorado around Cortez and Dolores. There is also a separate population of the variety in southern New Mexico, where it grows in the White Sands region between the San Andres and Sacramento mountains. Remarks. This is a very beautiful cactus, yet one rarely seen. Its spines are very remarkable and set it off from any of its relatives. They are heavy enough to be worthy of some massive barrel cactus. It is closest to variety triglochidiatus, but the spines are always much more numerous and much more ridged, grooved, and flattened. Since its discovery, the study of this cactus has gone through a history of confusion. It was named by Engelmann; and, at first, Coulter followed in keeping it distinct. But later Coulter and Nelson broadened their description of it to include charac ters of variety triglochidiatus, and they were followed in this by others. Plants with fewer ribs and spines were then called by
cacti of the southwest
this name, and of course when plants which were really variety triglochidiatus were called E. gonacanthus, the supposed range of variety gonacanthus was enlarged. Britton and Rose then took the step which logically followed from the blurring of distinctions between the two plants and placed E. gonacanthus for the first time as a variety of the other. Different combina tions were also made. Boissevain and Davidson, in their Colo rado Cacti, picture and describe a cactus collected near Corte, Colorado, which appears to be this form, but which they call E. coccineus var. octacanthus. This confuses the cactus with that very different cactus from a far-off part of Texas. But even today the idea persists that E. gonacanthus occurs in Texas. This seems to be a perfect example of what happens when details of stem and spine structure are regarded as insignificant, for this is a constant form occurring in a definite, small range, which any person interested in cacti would want to be able to identify and refer to specifically. Yet, because of the confu sion, I have found typical specimens of it, collected near its type locality, in herbaria under four different names. It is probably best considered as only a variety of the larger species, but unless it is kept distinct no order will be possible in this group. Throughout its range in northwest New Mexico and Colorado variety gonacanthus grows as a small plant with stems only to about six inches tall, precocious only in its spination. But there is a strange quirk in its range and its response to a different environment. A cactus was collected long ago by Wooton at the White Sands area of southern New Mexico, which had 7 radial spines and one much-flattened central, and which he, therefore, called E. gonacanthus. I have seen this specimen, and in its preserved state it certainly could pass for our plant. However, its occur rence so far from the ordinary range of the variety seems strange and might make us doubt that it is our plant. Our doubts are increased when we find that the White Sands cactus grows to a majestic 18 inches tall by 41/2 inches in thickness, making it probably the largest Echinocereus in our Southwest. I went into the study of this White Sands cactus with these doubts. I studied the cacti growing in their natural habitat. They have been fairly common and are still to be found here and there within the White Sands National Monument, but they have for the most part been eliminated in the rest of their territory, which lies mostly within the military’s missile range, from wide areas of which the vegetation seems to have been systematically eliminated. After observing numerous specimens of the cactus I was forced to conclude that they are identical to the much smaller va riety gonacanthus in every respect but stem size and I won dered how one could explain the great difference in size alone. Fortunately this question was answered when cactophile friends in both Albuquerque and Colorado showed me what had happened to specimens of the White Sands cacti which they had brought out and planted in their gardens. In each case, during one year in their gardens, stems 12 inches or more tall when
genus Echinocereus engelmann
collected had shrunk to half that size or sometimes even smaller, and then had proceeded with the slow, limited growth and branching seen in the northern wild population. Obviously, we have at the White Sands a local population of variety gonacanthus isolated some way in a very unusual hab itat which enables it to grow to sizes it cannot match or even maintain anywhere else. This makes it probably the most re markable example of environmental effect upon growth of any cactus within our area. Except for this, the variety is a smaller, heavy-spined cactus, a rare and beautiful resident of the northwest corner of our area, where it grows in small clumps under the cedar trees on the higher, sandy hills.
Echinocereus triglochidiatus var. octacanthus (Muehlenpf.) Marshall “Strawberry Cactus,” “Claret-Cup Cactus” Description Plate 12 stems: Branching or clustering to form clumps, of from 2 or 3 to sometimes as many as 50 stems in some old plants. The stems are globular to cylindrical, bright green or pale, yellowgreen, and plump, with shiny surfaces. They are of varying heights and somewhat loosely clustered within the clump. There is a distinct but gradual increase in the maximum size of the plants from one end of its range to the other, the sterns hardly ever exceeding 5 inches in height in the northern part of the range, but often standing 9 to 12 inches high in the southern part, particularly in the eastern Big Bend and along the Devil’s River. They are always comparatively thick, the largest ones being 41/2 inches in diameter. They have 5 to 9 wide, shallow ribs with slight enlargements at the areoles, but with no—or only slight—cross-furrows between areoles. areoles: Round, about 3/16 of an inch across, and 3/8 to 11/4 inches apart. At first they have much short white wool on them, but later they become bare and are entirely filled by the swollen bases of the spines. spines: All spines on this plant are slender or medium in thickness, actually measuring from only 1/32 to 1/16 of an inch in diameter, always round and straight or nearly so, and having very bulbous bases. When young they are yel lowish, often with distinct red streaks and shadings, especial ly toward the bases. When old they may remain yellowish or darken to gray or almost black. The amount of darkening seems to depend upon how much sun they get: I have col lected plants from sunny ledges which had almost black spines, only to have the new spines remain yellowish or gray when grown with some shade. There are 3 to 9 radials, very nearly equal in size on any areole, or with the upper ones only slightly smaller. They are from 1/2 to 11/4 inches long. There may be one central spine standing out at a right angle
39
to the stem, 5/8 to 11/2 inches long, round and scarcely any heavier than the radials, but many plants lack the central entirely. flowers: As the species, except for the following limitations: they are smaller, being only 11/2 to 2 inches tall, with the petals short and blunt; the ovary tube has almost no wool, but has clusters of 2 to 6 slender spines up to 1/2 inch long; the stigma lobes are 5 to 8 in number and light green. fruits: Round, smooth, red, edible berries about 3/4 to 11/2 inches in diameter. They have a few spines which soon fall off, leaving them naked by the time they are ripe. Range. A band of territory about 100 miles wide from central Texas west through the Big Bend, perhaps to near El Paso. Spe cifically, the northeastern limit of this strip is just east of the Colorado River near Lampasas, Texas, the southeastern limit about Kerrville, Texas. From there it is found quite commonly westward past junction and Del Rio. The northern edge of the range proceeds on south of Fort Stockton to the Davis Moun tains, while the southern limit, after dropping into Mexico at Del Rio, takes in all of the Big Bend. The western limit of the range is not so definitely known, due to confusion of the names and incompleteness of the older records. The most western strictly verifiable reports seem to be from Presidio County on the south and near El Paso on the north. Remarks. This plant was first named Echinopsis octacanthus in 1848 by Muehlenpfordt, from a plant collected by Dr. F. Roemer in Texas. In 1849 Engelmann described the same Texas plant and named it Cereus roemeri. Muehlenpfordt had in the meantime named an entirely different New Mexico plant Cereus roemeri, and from here on one can anticipate confusion. In 1896 Coulter wrote of a plant fitting this description, calling it Cereus octacanthus, but stating that it occurred from extreme southwestern Texas around El Paso northwestward through New Mexico into Utah. It seems impossible now to guess what plant he was referring to. But from this time on it was assumed that Echinocereus octacanthus, as Britton and Rose called it, occurred in New Mexico. Perhaps the reason lies in the coincidence of both a Texas plant and a different New Mexico plant having been given the same name, Cereus roemeri, and in the superficial similarity between the Texas plant and a Colo rado and New Mexico cactus called E. coccineus. To add to the confusion, Boissevain and Davidson, in their Colorado Cacti, mistook for variety octacanthus both variety gonacanthus, a primarily Colorado cactus which can have the same number of ribs and spines but which is vastly different in most other de tails, and E. mojaviensis, another similar species which reaches from the West into the corner of Colorado, and called their amalgamation of these two E. coccineus var. octacanthus. As a start in putting the confusion straight, I will say that I have not seen a plant definitely known to be from either Colo rado or New Mexico having the combination of characters set
40
out in the early, carefully circumscribed descriptions and out lined above for this plant. I believe it to be entirely a Texas cactus, except for an extension into northern Mexico. A further confusion was building, however. In 1856 Engel mann created a name, E. paucispinus, for a Texas form with 5 to 7 ribs and 3 to 6 round, slender radials. This form he said usually lacked a central, but might have an occasional round, porrect one. It was soon noticed that the rib and spine numbers of the new E. paucispinus matched those of the New Mexico E. tri glochidiatus, which also lacks centrals. Soon the differences be tween the two were overlooked, and the Texas plant was being spoken of as E. triglochidiatus. However, when both plants are seen together the difference between them is obvious. The color and surface of the stems are very different. The spines of the socalled E. paucispinus are always round and not more than 1/16 of an inch thick-truly insignificant on the broad ribs; while those of E. triglochidiatus are always greatly flattened, ridged or even grooved, and twice to four times as thick-easily the most striking thing about that plant. On these characteristics alone it is easy to separate them. As I have found no real intermediate between these two plants to confuse them, I have also found no specimens of either of them growing in that wide expanse separating the New Mexico E. triglochidiatus from the Texas E. paucispinus. There is about 200 miles between their known ranges. However, this difference in ranges means that few people have seen them to gether and realized the difference, with the result that in Texas this plant is almost entirely known under the name of the other. Britton and Rose are largely responsible for this con fusion, since they united the two, but even in doing so they stated their opinion that E. paucispinus should perhaps be re stored for the Texas plants. And they did us the service of picturing side by side a true E. triglochidiatus var. triglochid iatus and the Texas plant, even though their Texas specimen appears to be a badly damaged variety octacanthus. And here we may have a clue to unravel some more of the confusion. In erecting the species E. paucispinus, the Texas form with fewer ribs, fewer but round spines, and no central spine, Engelmann appears to have merely set apart and given a name to the lower end of variety octacanthus’ range of variations. For a long time I have tried to keep the two separate, but it just cannot be done. Too many times, on too many hills, the whole range of characters from 5 to 9 ribs, 3 to 9 radials, and 1 or no central have been found growing happily together. The flowers and fruits appear to be identical, and it seems that the two must be combined entirely. So we have, when we see the whole picture, variety octa canthus, an entirely or at least primarily Texas cactus which was once called E. roemeri and so was confused with the true E. roemeri of New Mexico and Colorado. Then those of its in dividuals with fewer ribs and spines were called E. paucispinus
cacti of the southwest
and immediately confused with the very different New Mexico form, variety triglochidiatus. In the extreme northeastern part of its range, variety octa canthus is a small cactus with stems only 3 to 5 inches high, one of the weakest growths of any in this group. However, in this area it is adjusting to the wettest habitat any of the redflowered Echinocerei succeed in colonizing, and this may be the price. But around Sabinal and Uvalde, Texas, one begins to come across clumps of this cactus much more robust in size of the stems. These specimens grow larger as one goes west through Del Rio, Langtry, and Sanderson, until from Del Rio west to south of Marathon and Alpine one occasionally finds majestic clumps with massive stems to at least 12 inches tall. This ap pears to be the plant’s response to the more arid conditions of this part of its range. If we are correct in our interpretation of the immense effect of the White Sands area’s conditions on variety gonacanthus, then we should not be surprised at a simi lar though less extreme and more gradual effect of the environment on this related cactus. The spines in this western area are more uniformly dark gray, which one would expect, due to the more general exposure to the sun here. I was gratified to find that a specimen taken from a canyon south of Alpine, where it was shaded most of the day, had the same light, reddish-yellow spines as those growing under the shade of the eastern junipers, although it stood almost 10 inches high, completely overshadowing its eastern counterpart in size. Variety octacanthus is definitely more resistant to rot than most others in this genus. I have seen plants of it growing and healthy beside rotted plants of E. enneacanthus and E. caespi tosus, where their ranges all meet around Sabinal, Texas. For this reason it would probably be a better cactus for use in eastern gardens than many others of the genus.
Echinocereus triglochidiatus var. hexaedrus (Eng.) Boissevain & Davidson Description stems: Few in the clump, each 4 to 6 inches high and 2 to 21/2 inches in diameter, with 6 obtuse ribs having wide, shallow grooves between them. areoles: Only 1/16 to 1/8 of an inch in diameter, which makes them among the smallest in this group. They are about 1/2 to 5/8 of an inch apart, and woolly when young. spines: Slender, with bulbous bases, and distinctly angular or flattened. Each areole usually has 6 radial spines, but En gelmann says one specimen had 7 and another 5. The lower radials are the shortest spines, being 3/8 to 7/8 of an inch long, and yellowish-red in color. The upper radials are longer, about 5/8 to 11/8 inches long, stouter, and darker in color.
genus Echinocereus engelmann
The central spine is missing, although there may be one, and Engelmann mentions finding one plant with two centrals. The centrals are 7/8 to 13/8 inches long and definitely flattened, but not very thick. flowers: Unknown. fruits: Unknown. Range. Known only from about 15 miles west of Zuni, New Mexico. Remarks: This cactus was described by Engelmann from plants collected by Bigelow in 1853. No one has reported seeing it since that time. Coulter described it many years later from Bigelow’s preserved specimens. The writer has not seen these, so the description given above is a combination of Engelmann’s and Coulter’s. It is hardly possible to do more than guess about the real relationships of this cactus to the other forms it resembles, since we know so little about it; so I merely list it as did the only two authorities who had it before them. Since then various authors have given it as a form of one or the other related species, but little can be proved. I do find in the U. S. National Herbarium one specimen col lected by Standley in the Tunitcha Mountains of New Mexico, not far north of Zuni, which fairly well fits Engelmann’s de scription of E. hexaedrus. It was labeled by Standley as E. pau cispinus, but that is doubtful, since it has the very flattened spines which E. paucispinus (var. octacanthus) does not have, and it was collected very far from that plant’s area in Texas. It could be the only collection of variety hexaedrus since the type. It would be a real service for someone to rediscover and study this cactus, if it still exists.
Echinocereus coccineus Eng. “Aggregate Cactus,” “Bunch-Ball Cactus,” “Turk’s Head Cactus,” “Heart Twister,” “Red-Flowered Hedgehog Cactus” Description Plates 12, 13 stems: This cactus always consists of a cluster of short, equalsized stems tightly packed to form a dense, hemispherical mass 1 to 6 feet in diameter and containing, in old specimens, up to several hundred heads. Each head or stem is from only 2 to 6 inches high and up to about 21/2 inches in diameter, with 8 to 11 ribs which are either practically straight or often composed of pronounced tubercles or projections on the tips of which the areoles are found. areoles: These are large, circular to more or less oval in shape, and only 3/16 to 1/2 inch apart—the closest areoles
41
among the clustering, few-ribbed Echinocerei. They are woolly when young, becoming bare. spines: All spines on one variety of this cactus are slender to medium in thickness, often almost bristle-like, straight, and round. In color they are white, gray-white, or straw; some times the centrals are brownish when new. On the other form of the species the central is stouter, darker, and definitely flattened. Due to the closeness of the areoles and the length of the spines, the general appearance is of a mass of whitish bristles, from which fact comes the common name, “hedge hog cactus.” There are 8 to 12 radial spines, 1/4 to 11/8 inches long, which all more or less stand out from the stem of the plant, the upper ones being the shorter ones. There are also 1 to 4 centrals: in the one variety, these are always round, very slender to medium in thickness, 3/8 to 13/4 inches long, and standing out nearly perpendicular to the stem; in the other variety the main central is flattened, a little stouter, directed downward, and 1 to 3 inches long. flowers: Deep crimson to orange-red in color, around 11/2 to 2 inches long and opening from 1 to 2 inches in diameter. The stamens are fuchsia and shorter than the petals. The stigma lobes are green and 6 to 12 in number. The tube sur face has white wool and 8 to 11 slender white spines, 1/4 to 1/2 inch long, in each areole. fruits: Red, juicy, with deciduous bristles. Range. Growing in a wide territory from Colorado south past Raton, New Mexico, down along the upper Pecos River to about even with Santa Fe and Albuquerque, and from there west into Arizona and Utah. Remarks. The “bunch-ball cactus” was among the first col lected in our area and is distinctive enough, with its slender, round spines and its manner of growing as a tight, perfectly regular ball of stems that it has not been so much confused with others of the group as some. However, it also has had too many names applied to it. Engelmann first called it E. coccineus, and then, later, because of a change of genus name, he called it Cereus phoeniceus. He also had once named a plant Mammil laria aggregata, which he did not describe in any detail. Coulter, assuming correctly that this was our cactus, called our plant Cereus aggregatus. Later authorities got back to the first definite name, E. coccineus, until, in an attempt to combine this cactus with others by reducing it to a variety, L. Benson found it nec essary to rename it yet again as E. triglochidiatus var. melana canthus, resurrecting for it an obscure varietal name once coined by Engelmann but ignored since as referring to no form really distinct from the species. There has been much confusion of E. triglochidiatus var. octa canthus with E. coccineus because they both have round spines. Since the two do not grow at all in the same areas, the differ ences between them have been easily overlooked, but they are
42
very different plants, with hundreds of miles and other forms separating their ranges, and when they are closely compared it is hardly possible to confuse them.
Echinocereus coccineus var. coccineus (Eng.) Description Plate 12 stems: As the species, except that the ribs undulate by having definite and pronounced tubercles at the areoles. areoles: As the species, except that they are to only 3/8 of an inch apart. spines: As the species, except that all spines are round, the centrals all slender, spreading, and to only 7/8 of an inch long. flowers: As the species, except that the stigma lobes number only 6 to 8. fruits: As the species. Range. As the species. Remarks. This is the typical form of the species. It was appar ently very common in northern New Mexico at one time, grow ing equally well under the trees on the lower mountains and in grassy valleys, forming huge mounds of dozens of stems. It has been a great favorite in that area because of the beauty of the large, symmetrical clumps it forms, its brilliant flowers, and its hardiness. For this reason many plants were dug up, and most of them were allowed to languish and die in boxes and planters. As a result it is now much easier to find it growing in gardens of the cities of that area than on the range, and one has to search long in remote spots to find an old specimen rounded up into a massive hemisphere. All one usually finds in any easily accessible place are young specimens of only a few heads, which give little clue to the magnificent things they could become if left unmolested.
Echinocereus coccineus var. conoideus Eng. “Beehive Cactus” Description Plate 13 stems: 3 to 6 inches high, 2 to 21/2 inches in diameter, the tips being markedly smaller in diameter, this giving them a coni cal shape. When old, they form large, rounded mounds of 30 to 40 nearly equal stems, somewhat similar to but larger in individual stem size than those of the typical species form. There are 9 to 11 ribs on each stem, which are almost straight with at most very small swellings at the areoles and with rather deep furrows between them. areoles: Large, woolly when young, later almost bare, 1/4 to 1/2 inch apart.
cacti of the southwest
spines: There are 9 to 12 slender radial spines which are very uneven, the upper 2 or 3 being only 1/4 to 1/2 inch long, while the lateral and lower ones are larger, up to 11/8 inches long. They are all round, with enlarged bases, and are white to straw-colored. There are 3 or 4 central spines. The upper ones are as the radials in shape and color and not much if any longer than the longest radials. The lower central, however, is directed downward, instead of standing perpendicular to the stem, and is usually somewhat curved. This lower central is a little stouter than the other spines, although still slender for the group, and different from the other spines on the areole in being definitely flattened, often to the point of being quadrangular. It is darker in color, often being yellowish with a brown base, or else ashy-gray. It is 1 to 3 inches long. flowers: These are a little larger than some in this group, being about the same length and color, but opening all of 2 inches in diameter, and there are 9 to 12 green stigma lobes. fruits: As the species. Range. From along the upper Pecos River in north central New Mexico north into southern Colorado and west into Arizona. Remarks. Variety conoideus is very close to variety coccineus, and there seems more justification for uniting these two, as Brit ton and Rose suggested but did not do, than any of the other forms listed here. Boissevain and Davidson stated that transi tional forms existed between these two but kept them as sepa rate species, a position which seems hard to maintain. However, the typical forms of the two are so different that it seems there must be some distinction made between them, so we are going back to Engelmann’s first opinion and placing this plant once again as a variety of the other. Variety conoideus has the longer spines and less tuberculate ribs, with more widely separated areoles, and it is a larger, more robust plant in general. In par ticular, the long, flattened, and darker central spine serves to identify it quickly. The plant was first named Cereus roemeri by Muehlenpfordt, but Engelmann did not seem certain about Muehlenpfordt’s de scription; and besides he had in the meantime applied the name roemeri to the Texas cactus we know as E. triglochidiatus var. octacanthus, so he was obliged to rename this New Mexico cactus. He used the name Cereus phoeniceus var. conoideus, and later, when he decided to elevate it to species rank, Cereus conoideus. Muehlenpfordt’s description seems very clear, how ever, and his name, being the oldest, is the one which should be used if the plant is treated as a species. The Texas plant cannot go under this name. But since the plant we are considering seems much more ac curately placed as a variety, by the rules of nomenclature it must carry the first varietal name applied to it. This is quite clearly Engelmann’s variety conoideus. Most of what was said about the growth habits of E. coc cineus would apply to this cactus as well, except that it seems to grow in higher mountains and on more rocky locations. This
genus Echinocereus engelmann
one has also been gathered from the field too widely and is now hard to find growing wild.
Echinocereus polyacanthus var. rosei (Wooton & Standley) “Red-Goblet Cactus,” “Pitahaya” Description Plate 13 stems: This is another cactus forming flat, loose clumps of unequal stems. The clumps may become large, with up to 50 stems, but this is rare and they are usually smaller, with only a dozen or fewer heads. Each stem is cylindrical, but some what tapering over almost the whole length toward the smal ler, rather pointed tip. They grow to at least 10 inches long and 4 inches thick at the base, when in ideal situations, but remain much smaller in poor environments. The color is a lighter or paler green than some of its relatives. The number of ribs is variable, from 9 to 11, these broad with very shal low grooves between them on the older parts of the stems, but sharp with fairly prominent tubercles or swellings at the areoles and deep, narrow grooves between them at the tips. areoles: This plant has probably the most conspicuous are oles of the group. When young they are about 1/4 of an inch across, circular, bulging outward, with much white or yel lowish wool covering the bases of the new spines. As they get older they become more typical, nearly flat, and lose much of their wool. They are from 3/8 to 1 inch apart. spines: The spines of this cactus are undoubtedly the most vari able in size of any in the group. I have seen plants with large centrals over 2 inches long and other plants with no spines over 1/2 inch long. In spite of this variation, the spines are constant in being straight, of medium stoutness, and always round. There are 7 to 10 radials 3/8 to 1 inch long, radiating, the lower ones usually almost twice as long as the upper ones. There are 3 to 5 centrals on mature plants. Young seedlings always have only 1 central per areole, and in some mature specimens occasional areoles will have only the 1 central, but this is never typical of the whole mature plant. These cen trals may be 1/2 to 2 inches long, depending upon the speci men, but they are always round, from somewhat enlarged bases, and spreading at various angles from the areole. All spines are reddish, ashy-gray, or occasionally dark, purplishgray, with the centrals usually somewhat darker than the radials. flowers: Variable in color, including tints from pale red to orange, these often in the same flower. These shades are unique among the firm, long-lasting flowers of this group. Other wise the flowers are typical of the group, 11/2 to 21/2 inches long, with short, rigid petals broadening and blunt at the ends. They have fuchsia stamens and the stigma lobes number 7 to 10. On the ovary are brownish or yellowish spines, 1/8
43
to 5/8 of an inch long, with reddish tips, plus some short wool. fruits: 3/4 to 1 inch long, greenish-purple when ripe, with deciduous spines. Range. From Mexico northward over west Texas and much of New Mexico, into southern Colorado and southeastern Arizona. The northeastern limit of the known range is near San Antonio, Texas, and so far as is known the northern edge of the range runs past Rocksprings, Texas, to the Davis Mountains and then turns sharply north through the Guadalupe Mountains into New Mexico, where it follows the Pecos River, goes past Las Vegas, New Mexico, and along the eastern edge of the moun tains into Colorado. The range seems to come back south out of Colorado east of the Continental Divide, and does not cross this demarcation until near Lordsburg, New Mexico, where it moves into southeast Arizona. Remarks: E. polyacanthus var. rosei is the most common redflowered Echinocereus throughout southern New Mexico and far southwest Texas. It is easily found on the lower slopes of the Franklin and Organ mountains and in similar places west into Arizona. It is less common but may be found occasionally in the mountains of central New Mexico and north into Colo rado. It is even less common, but has also been collected in the Texas Big Bend and the Davis and Guadalupe mountains. Its eastern limit is hard to establish, as occasional specimens which must be referred to this species have turned up in widely sepa rated places over a very large area. I have a living specimen with very short spines but otherwise typical from near Rocksprings, Texas, and there is in the U.S. National Herbarium a specimen labeled as collected by Tourney at San Antonio in 1897, but I cannot find it growing in the area now. Because of the variability of its spines and its very wide range this cactus has been widely confused with others of its relatives. In northern New Mexico and Colorado it is sometimes mistaken for E. coccineus, from which it can be distinguished by the facts that it never grows in the compact, dome-shaped clusters nor has such slender spines as that plant, or for E. coccineus var. conoideus, from which it can be told by the fact that its spines are never flattened as is the lower central of that plant. In Texas its immature growth and certain stunted, atypical speci mens have been called E. triglochidiatus var. octacanthus, in spite of the fact that Engelmann in his early description was so thorough that he mentioned that the immature plants have only 1 central per areole. The atypical forms can be distinguished by the fact that they have more ribs than variety octacanthus. Engelmann did leave room for confusion to enter by giving two slightly varying descriptions for the plant he named E. polyacanthus. His original description was of plants collected in Chihuahua, Mexico, by Wislizenus. This was a narrow de scription of a very localized cactus found only there. It is unique for the whole group of scarlet-flowered Echinocerei in having long wool on the flower tube. In his later writings En
44
gelmann used the same name, but broadened the description somewhat, as well as the range. In the later descriptions he said the cactus was a common plant at El Paso, and did not mention the long wool on the flower. Since no specimens have ever been collected at El Paso or anywhere in the U.S. with this long wool, its seems clear that, after further study, Engelmann meant to include all of this form, whether having long or short wool, under this name. Coulter took it this way, and so included in the range of the species New Mexico and Arizona. Wooton and Standley returned to restricting E. polyacanthus to the local Chihuahuan form, and set up the New Mexico rep resentatives having only short wool as two new species, E. rosei and E. neo-mexicanus. Britton and Rose faced the problem of relating these forms. Dr. Rose made the famous trip to the type locality of E. poly acanthus at Cosihuiriachi, Chihuahua, and collected specimens there, establishing to their satisfaction that the original type specimens were actually different from our forms, at least in having the long wool on the flower tube. They, therefore, fol lowed Wooton and Standley in their names, E. rosei and E. neo-mexicanus, for the two U.S. forms which lack this unique character. Since then no one has used the name E. polyacanthus for any U.S. cactus except Benson, who ignores the distinction and calls the plants of New Mexico and Arizona E. triglochidiatus var. polyacanthus. Helia Bravo, in her book, Las Cactaceas de Mexico, has a good illustration of the true E. polyacanthus. It seems necessary to follow most recent students in separating the U.S. forms in some way from the unique Chihuahuan cac tus, which must carry the name E. polyacanthus. But it seems equally true that the U. S. forms are very close to it, close enough so that Engelmann had justification in lumping them all together. The best way to show the whole picture appears to be by regarding the U. S. forms as varieties of the species. Our common cactus of such wide range in the U. S. then becomes E. polyacanthus var. rosei.
cacti of the southwest
flowers: As those of variety rosei, except usually smaller and of burnt-orange to yellow coloring. The petals are not as wide as those of the other variety and are, as Wooton put it, “almost acute,” if one emphasizes the almost. fruits: As those of variety rosei. Range. Fairly common around Las Cruces, New Mexico, and found occasionally at least to Socorro, in central New Mexico. Remarks. This plant is very close to the previous variety, but is easily recognized by the more numerous ribs and the more numerous, lighter colored, and more slender spines. Where variety rosei presents a gray or purplish-gray appearance, the spine covering of variety neo-mexicanus is always yellowish, and sometimes strikingly so. It does not appear to be a separate species, but it does definitely appear to stand in some way dis tinct from the other more widespread form. Collections made around Las Cruces are easily divisible into the two types. This is a beautiful cactus, usually large and impressive in growth, with the long-lasting flowers which make it a favorite. Near El Paso and Las Cruces, in the few areas which have been too remote for the casual collector or which have been in some way protected, there are still to be seen whole slopes dotted with the clumps of tall heads covered in April and May with beautiful goblet-shaped flowers, and here and there within the cities transplanted clumps are to be seen gracing yards and gar dens most beautifully. Variety neo-mexicanus is cold-resistant and would be a good garden cactus in other colder areas, except that it is definitely a desert form and so must be protected from moisture more carefully than some of the other species of this group. It is worth mentioning, for the sake of any hobbyist who might be growing the plant inside to protect it from the winter dampness of their areas, that this cactus, like many other winterhardy forms, must have some cold during the winter in order to trigger the blooms. In south Texas I have seen plants which had grown for several years without a suggestion of a flower bloom profusely for the first time after the stimulus of one of those freezes which are so destructive to southern cacti.
Echinocereus polyacanthus var. neo-mexicanus (Standley) Description Plate 13 stems: As those of variety rosei, except to only about 3 inches thick and having 11 to 15 ribs. areoles: As those of variety rosei, but closer, being 3/8 to 5/8 of an inch apart. spines: Radial spines variable in number from 8 to 16, but usually 10 to 13. These are slender; straight; round; white, straw, or yellow; and to 5/8 of an inch long. The spreading centrals number 4 to 6 on mature plants, and are straight, round, slender, and usually 3/4 to 11/4 inches long. In color they are yellowish below with the outer parts or the tips reddish or blackish.
Echinocereus enneacanthus Eng. “Strawberry Cactus,” “Pitaya” Description Plate 14 stems: 3 to 30 inches long and 11/2 to 4 inches thick, and cylindrical, tapering somewhat over the last one-third of the length to a rather pointed tip. These stems grow in loose clusters of a few to as many as 100 in a large plant. New stems multiply as side branches at or just above the ground level, so their first growth tends to be lateral, after which they turn upward. This results in all of the stems around the edges of a large clump being long and curving, the lower
genus Echinocereus engelmann
part often lying flat on the ground and the upper part stand ing erect. In color they are bright green, and the flesh of the plant is soft, even flabby, giving them a more or less wrin kled appearance and causing them to appear actually with ered in very dry periods or in the winter. There are 7 to 10 ribs on each stem, which are low and broad with shallow grooves between them and with slight to rather pronounced tubercles or swellings at the areoles. areoles: Circular, about 1/8 of an inch in diameter, with much gray wool on them when young, some of which re mains on the older areoles. These are placed 1/4 to 11/2 inches apart on mature stems. spines: All spines on this plant are rigid and slender to fairly stout, rise from enlarged bases, and are light-colored, being white to straw-colored or very light brown. All spines are distinctly translucent, having a horny appearance with age. When very young and while still growing, the spines are a delicate pink color which fades quickly as they mature. There are 7 to 12 white radial spines radiating evenly, straight or slightly curved back toward the stem, but varying greatly in length and thickness. The upper ones tend to be shortest, only 1/4 to 5/8 of an inch long, while the lateral and lower ones are usually longer—1/2 to as much as 1 inch long. There is one stout central spine standing perpendicular to the surface of the stem or slightly deflexed. It has a very bulbous base and is round and white when young, but becomes darker, espe cially toward the base, and more or less flattened when old. On immature tips this central is very little longer than the radial spines, but with age it usually continues to grow, be coming heavier and longer, up to 11/4 or even 2 inches long. Many plants are found with 2 extra central spines above this main one, these spreading upward and remaining shorter. flowers: Large and beautiful, opening widely, 2 to 3 inches in height and about the same in diameter, purple-red in color. There are 10 to 20 short outer petals with brownishgreen centers and pinkish, crinkled edges. The inner petals are in 1 to 3 rows, 12 to 35 in number and oblong, linear, or spatulate in shape. The edges of these petals are entire or toothed, and the tips pointed or blunt. The stamens are much shorter than the petals, the filaments greenish, and the anthers yellow. The style is white, the stigma lobes green, long and slender, 8 to 12 in number. The tube of the flower has white wool and white bristle-like spines up to 1/2 inch long upon it. fruits: About 1 inch long, almost spherical, greenish to brownish or purplish, with bristle-like spines which fall off easily. The flesh of the fruit is edible and very delicious. Range. Along the Rio Grande from near that river’s mouth to the Big Bend. It has seldom been found west of the Pecos River or more than 50 miles north of the Rio Grande in any area. However, there have been isolated reports of it from near San Angelo, Kerrville, San Antonio, and Raymondville, Texas,
45
which would mark the northern and eastern extremes of its range. Coulter says it occurs west of Texas into Arizona, but I have found no record of it ever having been collected in New Mexico. Remarks. This is the common Echinocereus of a wide area of the lower Rio Grande Valley. It is found occasionally farther west, but only becomes common near Del Rio. It is very com mon from the Devil’s River to Eagle Pass, large clumps of it dotting the gravelly ground on the low hills just north of the Rio Grande wherever these hills have not been cleared. It is so common as to be a pest at Laredo and for about 50 miles north and east of there, with clumps under almost every bush on whatever of the range is well-drained and has not yet been cleared. The practice of “rooting” or “chaining” the range with large machinery in order to clear out the brush seems to do away with this, as well as with most other small cacti, although it merely does a favor to the large Opuntias of the region, whose pads are scattered by the machines and immediately take root as new plants. The result is that you now have to hunt for unspoiled range where the pitayas still are allowed to grow and the giant Opuntias have not taken over. Below Laredo this cactus is found commonly to near Rio Grande City, but below there it is found only rarely. E. enneacanthus was noticed and collected on the very early survey of the Rio Grande area by Wislizenus, and named by Engelmann in 1848. It is a distinct form which has seldom been confused with any other. However, there seem to be more or less distinct varieties within its population, which are listed below. When its clusters are covered with dozens of its large, lively colored flowers (usually during April), the species is a beautiful cactus, appreciated by almost everyone. It is most appreciated by those who take its common name of strawberry cactus liter ally, for the greenish-brown fruits have a flavor very similar to strawberries. Where it grows profusely the fruits are actually gathered, the spines brushed off, and the flesh eaten with cream and sugar. This cactus is fairly hardy, being able to stand a temperature considerably below freezing, but it cannot stand excess moisture. If it is in some way protected from winter rains and allowed to wither in dryness during the winter, it can live quite far north of its natural range. Then, when moisture is given to it again in the spring, the reward will be quick appearance of many large flowers.
Echinocereus enneacanthus var. enneacanthus (Eng.) Description Plate 14 STEMS: As the species, except that they grow to only about 12 inches long, 23/4 inches thick, and are much less flabby, with only slight tubercles at the areoles.
46
areoles: As the species, except that they are to only 1 inch apart. spines: As the species. flowers: As the species, except with only 10 to 15 outer petals and only 12 to 15 inner petals in one row. These petals are oblong or linear in shape, with edges entire and tips pointed. There are only 8 to 10 stigma lobes. fruits: As the species. Range. As the species. Remarks. This is the typical variety of the species which is common over all of its range. Its smaller stems to only 12 inches long are prostrate for only the first part of their length, and the plant tends to form rather tidy, firm clumps.
Echinocereus enneacanthus var. carnosus (Rümpl.) K. Schumann Description Plate 14 stems: Becoming at least 16 and sometimes as much as 30 inches long by 3 to 4 inches in diameter. These very flabby stems grow out laterally from the cluster and when large lie fully prostrate on the ground, only the very tips turning up ward. There are 8 or 9 broad ribs on each stem, with rather pronounced tubercles. areoles: 3/4 to 11/2 inches apart. spines: There are 8 or 9 radials, the uppers only 3/8 of an inch long (often missing entirely), and the laterals 1/2 to 3/4 of an inch long. There is