Business Organizations and Collaborative Web: Practices, Strategies and Patterns Kamna Malik U21Global Graduate School, Singapore Praveen K. Choudhary HCL Technologies, India
Senior Editorial Director: Director of Book Publications: Editorial Director: Acquisitions Editor: Development Editor: Production Editor: Typesetters: Print Coordinator: Cover Design:
Kristin Klinger Julia Mosemann Lindsay Johnston Erika Carter Mike Killian Sean Woznicki Jennifer Romanchak and Natalie Pronio Jamie Snavely Nick Newcomer
Published in the United States of America by Business Science Reference (an imprint of IGI Global) 701 E. Chocolate Avenue Hershey PA 17033 Tel: 717-533-8845 Fax: 717-533-8661 E-mail:
[email protected] Web site: http://www.igi-global.com/reference Copyright © 2011 by IGI Global. All rights reserved. No part of this publication may be reproduced, stored or distributed in any form or by any means, electronic or mechanical, including photocopying, without written permission from the publisher. Product or company names used in this set are for identification purposes only. Inclusion of the names of the products or companies does not indicate a claim of ownership by IGI Global of the trademark or registered trademark. Library of Congress Cataloging-in-Publication Data Business organizations and collaborative web: practices, strategies and patterns / Kamna Malik and Praveen K. Choudhary, editors. p. cm. Includes bibliographical references and index. Summary: “This book delves into identifying specific business processes and their linkage with the collaborative Web, while understanding the related implications for individuals, organizations and society”--Provided by publisher. ISBN 978-1-60960-581-0 (hbk.) -- ISBN 978-1-60960-582-7 (ebook) 1. Information technology--Management. 2. Web 2.0. 3. Internet. 4. Online social networks. I. Malik, Kamna, 1967- II. Choudhary, Praveen, 1974- III. Title. HD30.2.B8784 2011 658.4’03802854678--dc22 2011001301
British Cataloguing in Publication Data A Cataloguing in Publication record for this book is available from the British Library. All work contributed to this book is new, previously-unpublished material. The views expressed in this book are those of the authors, but not necessarily of the publisher.
Editorial Advisory Board Mark Esposito, Grenoble Graduate School of Business, France D. P. Goyal, MDI Gurgaon, India Jeffrey Henderson, Grenoble Graduate School of Business, France Wing Lam, U21Global Graduate School, Singapore Vijay V. Mandke, NIIT University, India Lukas O. Ritzel, IMI University Centre / Prasena, Switzerland K. S. Subramanian, IGNOU, India Lloyd C. Williams, Institute of Transformative Thought and Learning, USA
List of Reviewers James Braman, Towson University, USA Rommert J.Casimir, Tilburg University, Netherlands Vatcharaporn Esichaikul, Asian Institute of Technology, Thailand Mark Espistos, Grenoble Graduate School of Business, France Arhlene Flowers, Ithaca College, USA D. P. Goyal, MDI Gurgaon, India Jeffrey Henderson, Grenoble Graduate School of Business, France Ronan Jouan de Kervenoael, Sabanci University, Turkey and Aston University, UK Wing Lam, U21Global Graduate School, Singapore Lukas O. Ritzel, IMI University Centre, Switzerland Eva Soderstrom, University of Skövde, Sweden Malathi Sriram, SDM Institute for Management Development, India R. Todd Stephens, AT&T Corporation, USA Jakub Stogr, Charles University, Prague Lloyd C. Williams, Institute of Transformative Thought and Learning, USA
Table of Contents
Preface . ...............................................................................................................................................xiii Section 1 Towards Collaborative Web Chapter 1 Towards a Characterization of the Developmental Environment of Web Applications and its Business Implications................................................................................................................... 1 Pankaj Kamthan, Concordia University, Canada Chapter 2 Web 2.0: Integration Model with Electronic Commerce....................................................................... 18 R. Todd Stephens, AT&T, USA Chapter 3 Entrepreneurship and Growth in Knowledge Economy........................................................................ 31 Julie Vardhan, Manipal University, Dubai Section 2 Collaborative Applications in Business Chapter 4 Collaborative Journalism: Networks, News Media and the Public Sphere........................................... 48 Saayan Chattopadhyay, University of Calcutta, India Chapter 5 Using Virtual Communities to Involve Users in E-Service Development: A Case Study..................... 61 Eva Söderström, University of Skövde, Sweden Jesper Holgersson, University of Skövde, Sweden
Chapter 6 Emerging Web Tools and Their Applications in Bioinformatics........................................................... 76 Shailendra Singh, PEC University of Technology, India Amardeep Singh, Punjabi University, India Chapter 7 Collaborative Web for Natural Resources Industries............................................................................. 90 Nikhil Chaturvedi, SAP Asia Pte. Ltd., Singapore Chapter 8 Optimizing Collaborative E-Commerce Websites for Rural Production Using Multi Criteria Analysis.............................................................................................................. 102 Z. Andreopoulou, Aristotle University of Thessaloniki, Greece T. Koutroumanidis, Democritus University of Thrace, Greece B. Manos, Aristotle University of Thessaloniki, Greece Chapter 9 Online Grocery Provision Resistance: Understanding Urban (Non)Collaboration and Ambiguous Supply Chain Environments ..................................................................................... 120 Ronan de Kervenoael, Sabanci University, Turkey & Aston University, UK Burcin Bozkaya, Sabanci University, Turkey Mark Palmer, University of Birmingham, UK Chapter 10 Applying Game Mechanisms to Idea Competitions............................................................................ 144 Florian Birke, Technical University Braunschweig, Germany Maximilian Witt, Technical University Braunschweig, Germany Susanne Robra-Bissantz, Technical University Braunschweig, Germany Section 3 Organizational Aspects of Collaborative Web Chapter 11 Dynamic Co-Opetitive Network Organization Supported by Multi Agent Architecture.................... 165 Paolo Renna, University of Basilicata, Italy Chapter 12 The Influence of Collaborative Web on Knowledge Management, Organizational Structure and Culture in Knowledge Intensive Companies . .............................................................. 184 Kathrin Kirchner, Friedrich Schiller University Jena, Germany Mladen Čudanov, University of Belgrade, Serbia
Chapter 13 Virtual Reality and Identity Crisis: Implications for Individuals and Organizations.......................... 202 Archana Tyagi, University of Business and International Studies Geneva, Switzerland Section 4 Blending Real and Virtual Worlds Chapter 14 Virtual Worlds for Collaborative Meetings.......................................................................................... 221 Arhlene A. Flowers, Ithaca College, USA Kimberly Gregson, Ithaca College, USA Chapter 15 Collaborative Virtual Business Events: Potential and Challenges . .................................................... 245 Roma Chauhan, Institute for Integrated Learning in Management, India Ritu Chauhan, Jamia Hamdard, India Chapter 16 Augment Your Business Reality with New Age Web Tools................................................................ 261 Lukas Ritzel, IMI University Centre, Switzerland Compilation of References ............................................................................................................... 282 About the Contributors .................................................................................................................... 313 Index.................................................................................................................................................... 319
Detailed Table of Contents
Preface . ...............................................................................................................................................xiii Section 1 Towards Collaborative Web The Web is fast evolving as a strong collaborative medium, with more and more individuals adopting it in their personal and social life. This trend is so pervasive that it is imperative for business organizations to integrate collaborative web Web tools into their businesses. This section, with the help of three chapters takes the reader through different dimensions that need to be considered for weaving the collaborative web Web with business for better business and economic growth. Chapter 1 Towards a Characterization of the Developmental Environment of Web Applications and its Business Implications................................................................................................................... 1 Pankaj Kamthan, Concordia University, Canada This chapter provides a conceptual characterization of multiple directions of web Web evolution, relationships between these directions, and their implications towards business organizations. The consequences of a commitment to these directions are considered with the support of examples and/or empirical studies as appropriate. Chapter 2 Web 2.0: Integration Model with Electronic Commerce....................................................................... 18 R. Todd Stephens, AT&T, USA In a few years, having a standard Electronic Commerce site will be as passé as having an information only site today. Organizations must progress to the next level in order to have a viable business model in the future. In this chapter, the author takes a look at how organizations can integrate Web 2.0 technology into their current electronic commerce environment. This chapter reviews several different examples where organizations have added Web 2.0 to their environment and are succeeding in transforming themselves.
Chapter 3 Entrepreneurship and Growth in Knowledge Economy........................................................................ 31 Julie Vardhan, Manipal University, Dubai The objective of this chapter is to highlight recent advances in our several understandings which underpin the creation of knowledge, the iterative knowledge loops, the knowledge economy itself, and the range of technologies used by the entrepreneurs leading towards knowledge diversification, specialization, and optimization, resulting into growth of the overall economy. Section 2 Collaborative Applications in Business This section outlines the collaborative applications of the current form of webWeb, and also provides a brief peek into the future growth and directions of development of the next generation of webWeb. The set of seven chapters included in this section is a distillate of research and experience of the authors in diverse set of industries and functional domains. Chapter 4 Collaborative Journalism: Networks, News Media and the Public Sphere........................................... 48 Saayan Chattopadhyay, University of Calcutta, India Referring to the mainstream and alternate news media industry, this chapter argues that the notion of collaboration does not hinge only between a professional and an amateur, or trained reporters and common citizens, or perhaps more commonly, different kinds of media— rather it is a much greater transformation since it is a collaboration between society and technology with its palpable economic implications. The author points out the emergence of network entrepreneur and also the reconfiguring media and journalistic practices. Chapter 5 Using Virtual Communities to Involve Users in E-Service Development: A Case Study..................... 61 Eva Söderström, University of Skövde, Sweden Jesper Holgersson, University of Skövde, Sweden This chapter drives motivation from the issue of involving the end users for development of useful and sustainable e-services. With the help of a case study in the travel industry, it explains how new technological advancements and phenomena, primarily virtual communities, can be used as a main source of end user requirements. Chapter 6 Emerging Web Tools and Their Applications in Bioinformatics........................................................... 76 Shailendra Singh, PEC University of Technology, India Amardeep Singh, Punjabi University, India
This chapter gives a brief overview of the emerging field of bioinformatics bioinformatics and explains the need for collaboration in its broad research based activities. While sharing the web Web tools commonly used by scientists and researchers, the authors establish the need of collaborative tools to support their work. Chapter 7 Collaborative Web for Natural Resources Industries............................................................................. 90 Nikhil Chaturvedi, SAP Asia Pte. Ltd., Singapore This chapter focuses on the petroleum and mining industry – a resource intensive industry where collaboration across the entities in the value chain is very high and can be positively affected by the webWeb. Drawing from his first hand experiences in this industry, the author explains the extent of collaborative web Web and also the unleashed potential that still needs to be realized. Chapter 8 Optimizing Collaborative E-Commerce Websites for Rural Production Using Multi Criteria Analysis.............................................................................................................. 102 Z. Andreopoulou, Aristotle University of Thessaloniki, Greece T. Koutroumanidis, Democritus University of Thrace, Greece B. Manos, Aristotle University of Thessaloniki, Greece This chapter takes an account of the website features to be facilitated while designing a collaborative website for e-commerce purposes in rural sector. With the help of qualitative and quantitative analysis of content characteristics, this chapter proposes a methodology aiming to optimize their websites. The retrieved websites are classified in groups aiming to identify the optimum group of websites, which can be used as a benchmark by other companies in the sector. Chapter 9 Online Grocery Provision Resistance: Understanding Urban (Non)Collaboration and Ambiguous Supply Chain Environments ..................................................................................... 120 Ronan de Kervenoael, Sabanci University, Turkey & Aston University, UK Burcin Bozkaya, Sabanci University, Turkey Mark Palmer, University of Birmingham, UK This chapter investigates the resistance by online retailers, logistic firms, and urban planners in the development of supply chain infrastructures for online grocery provision. Drawing upon twenty nine in-depth interviews with experts in online retail, logistics, and urban planning within an urban metropolis in an emerging market, the authors report different ways (ideological, functional, regulatory, and spatial) in which collaboration is resisted in online retail provision. Chapter 10 Applying Game Mechanisms to Idea Competitions............................................................................ 144 Florian Birke, Technical University Braunschweig, Germany Maximilian Witt, Technical University Braunschweig, Germany Susanne Robra-Bissantz, Technical University Braunschweig, Germany
With the help of a study carried out to analyze various idea competitions, this chapter proposes the use of game mechanism for generating / accumulating ideas in organizations. Based on theoretical insights, analysis of 18 cases and three interviews, this study demonstrates the actual occurrence of game mechanisms and their effect on the motivation of participants. Section 3 Organizational Aspects of Collaborative Web Mass adoption of collaborative web Web tools by individuals is resulting in increasing individual empowerment and more dynamism in business relations leading to severe implications for business organizations. This section, with the help of three chapters, brings forth some implications and recommendations to enable organizations relook their plans, policies and controls and move towards more open structure and culture that accommodates the changing individual and social behavioral patterns. Chapter 11 Dynamic Co-Opetitive Network Organization Supported by Multi Agent Architecture.................... 163 Paolo Renna, University of Basilicata, Italy The focus of this chapter is on the development of a multi agent architecture to support a network of enterprises that collaborate in a co-opetition relationships environment. The research concerns the investigation of a life cycle of the network in which the partners change dynamically. In particular, the enterprises that participate in the network can exit or continue to participate, while the enterprises that operate outside the network can evaluate to participate in the network. A simulation environment is proposed that allows business users to evaluate the proposed approach in a co-opetitive network to support the plant’s participation decision. Chapter 12 The Influence of Collaborative Web on Knowledge Management, Organizational Structure and Culture in Knowledge Intensive Companies . .............................................................. 184 Kathrin Kirchner, Friedrich Schiller University Jena, Germany Mladen Čudanov, University of Belgrade, Serbia In this chapter, the authors explore the influence that the collaborative Web tools have on knowledge management, organizational structure, and culture of knowledge-intensive companies. As a result of interviews and surveys done in Serbia, the authors report that with collaborative webWeb, organizational structure, culture, and knowledge management change is perceived among employees, and that employee’s loyalty changes from company orientation toward virtual community orientation. Chapter 13 Virtual Reality and Identity Crisis: Implications for Individuals and Organizations.......................... 202 Archana Tyagi, University of Business and International Studies Geneva, Switzerland
Identity has become one of the most important issues for human development and adjustment in today’s turbulent times. Virtual reality has recently emerged as an effective tool to extend a healing space for an alternative identity. The focus of this chapter is on the challenges faced by the young generation, which is struggling to understand its identity. Thereon, an attempt has also been made to link the organizational identity with the individual identity. Section 4 Blending Real and Virtual Worlds The ongoing trends towards miniaturized devices, touch based and more natural interfaces, and collaborative processes, are enabling many new forms of convergence. The convergence of real and virtual worlds is one such pre-dominant form that forward looking business organizations need to earnestly explore. This section helps the reader peep into the futurist trends and applications where the real and virtual worlds of business converge and augment each other. Chapter 14 Virtual Worlds for Collaborative Meetings.......................................................................................... 221 Arhlene A. Flowers, Ithaca College, USA Kimberly Gregson, Ithaca College, USA Whether businesses will make use of virtual worlds for meetings, training, and events is not just an academic question. This chapter covers the evolution of technology for virtual meetings, a theoretical analysis of tele-presence in virtual meetings, case studies of companies utilizing virtual worlds as meeting venues, and practical considerations for conducting virtual meetings and events. Chapter 15 Collaborative Virtual Business Events: Potential and Challenges . .................................................... 245 Roma Chauhan, Institute for Integrated Learning in Management, India Ritu Chauhan, Jamia Hamdard, India In addition to saving time and cost, virtual business events enable knowledge on demand, so crucial for the end users. This chapter delves into the opportunities and challenges of rich interactive virtual business events, particularly virtual exhibitions and conferences. With the help of examples of available services and usage patterns, the authors highlight the associated challenges for the end users, organizers, and developers. A blended form of real and virtual business event is suggested as a workable business proposition. Chapter 16 Augment Your Business Reality with New Age Web Tools................................................................ 261 Lukas Ritzel, IMI University Centre, Switzerland This chapter peeps into the emerging trend of Web 3.0. Particularly focusing on augmented reality (AR), this chapter takes the readers to a futuristic tour with the help examples of a number of futuristic applications where the boundaries between real and virtual worlds get blurred.
Compilation of References ............................................................................................................... 282 About the Contributors .................................................................................................................... 313 Index.................................................................................................................................................... 319
xiii
Preface
“It is the long history of humankind (and animal kind, too) – those who learned to collaborate and improvise most effectively have prevailed.” Charles Darwin Collaboration is the key to survival. Just like individuals and mankind, business organizations also depend on collaboration for survival and growth. The concept of departments, committees, teams, meetings, feedbacks, conferences, et cetera, which are so fundamental to any organizational structure, culture, behavior, and performance, all point to the importance of collaboration. With globalization of economies and growth of information and communication technologies (ICT), the boundaries and scale of collaboration have moved from the intra-organizational to inter-organizational level. Two way people-people or business-business collaborations have given way to multidirectional collaborations involving multi-agents; primarily, individuals, organizations, technologies, and communities. Employee ownership, multi-partner global supply chains, collaborating competitors, and engaging customers are all imperative for the sustained growth of an organization today. The past two decades have witnessed a drastic shift in the way business is conducted. Levels of hierarchy have reduced. Business processes have gone leaner. Continuous learning and innovation have become the norm rather than the competitive advantage. Though economic and legal reforms have been a significant contributor to globalization, it is due to ICT that such scales have been manageable. ICT has been instrumental in increasing the demand as well as supply of products and services by bringing together the buyers and suppliers from across the oceans and time zones. A key result of all such changes is the rise in entrepreneurial growth of business and competition, thus raising the bar of service and excellence and redefining the form and conduct of organizations. Business has gradually become e-business, and World Wide Web has become the playfield for business organizations. Over these years, Web has evolved from read-only environment to a strong collaborative medium where users have access to a wide range of tools and resources. To mark the distinct stages of this evolution, many researchers agree with the versioning of Web; with Web 1.0 broadly representing the read-only Web; Web 2.0 representing the read-write Web or social Web; and Web 3.0 representing the Semantic Web and related developments moving towards intelligent Web. Though intelligent Web is still in fancy, wiki, blogs, tagging, social networking sites, and many such forms of collaborative Web tools have already paved their way into our lives on personal and business front. Individuals today spend a significant part of their day on the Web and social networks. Search engines, wikis, and blogs have brought in a paradigm shift from the culture of knowledge ‘management’ to knowledge ‘co-creation.’ While the earlier form of Web was first adopted by business organizations and entrepreneurs, and gradually accepted by individuals; the new age Web technologies have witnessed individuals as first adopters,
xiv
with business organizations following the suite. The evolution of open source and social networking trends are forcing organizations to collaborate and rethink the way they innovate, create and execute their strategies, products and services. The making of Barack Obama (Nations, 2010) and Coke (Carlson, 2009) as the popular brands on Facebook and IBM saving huge money by hosting its virtual meetings over Second Life (Virtual World News, 2009) are the cases in point that highlight the fact that collaborative Web holds the potential for competitive advantage for individuals as well as organizations. The McKinsey survey (2009) reported the increasing use of blogs, podcasts, wiki, Web videos, really simple syndication and social networks resulting in innovation, better marketing, reduced time and cost thus improving the efficiency and effectiveness of internal as well as external collaborations and leading to emergence of networked organization. Virtual team interaction, customer’s surveys and feedback, talent hunt, knowledge sharing, and advertising are some of the areas where business organizations have started utilizing these tools. As a result, new forms of agile and learning organizations are evolving. Enormous speed, flexibility, knowledge, and connectivity resulting from this evolution offer immense potential to change the competitive landscape of individuals, business organizations as well as nations. As embracing this change is becoming increasingly important as well as feasible for businesses, this change is also enabling more and more individuals to become virtual entrepreneurs in their own ways. An employee, rather than spending the whole life in the silos of an organization, can today reach out globally as an individual seeker or provider of knowledge. Every individual is a potential writer and publisher today. Imagine, an employee spending a part of its office time to exercise its freedom of voice over blogging, or adding to the collective wisdom of a consortium, or strengthening his/her professional network over, say, LinkedIn. Should businesses see this act as loss of productivity or an indirect gain in collective wisdom and growth? Should business policies control employees’ access to such community building or should they capitalize on the new technologies as well as the surplus abilities of the internet generation? In what way can these technologies generate more value for business? These and many such questions confront the organizations today as they experiment with the opportunities and challenges offered by the changing form of the Web. It demands a different set of culture, organizational structure, and policies to reap out such benefits while controlling the side-effects. For example, while most forward looking organizations today create blogs to get customer feedback and also to propagate ideas and product knowledge, they face the challenges of managing 24x7 spontaneity and quick redress expected by the bloggers. They also lack the systems and processes required to manage such a large pool of gathered knowledge. The organizations desire that their employees get accustomed to new age work styles but then balancing productivity and organizational loyalty often become the conflicting issues. One can get a glimpse of such imbalances by looking at the statistics of bloggers who have been fired from their jobs. This obviously indicates a confusing situation for both – individuals as well as organizations because both are today operating on the no man’s land where the etiquette, ethics and rules are not well defined. Business and IS policy makers are yet to find ways to manage that thin line difference between individual versus business goals. This book aims to explore the practices, strategies and emerging patterns with respect to use of such new generation technologies in business organizations. To remain focused, we have restricted our explorations around collaborative nature of business and the potential or actual use of emerging Web technologies therein. However, we refrain from any attempt to bring out the distinction between various versions or names given to such technologies. For the purpose and context of this book, we prefer to use the term collaborative Web to encompass all technologies that have evolved after the initial read-only
xv
Web environment or Web 1.0. Simply said, collaborative Web allows its users to communicate, with each other as well as with other technologies, and communicate intelligently towards creation of better products, services and knowledge thus leading to business and economic growth. Though, we believe that any research is less likely to generate a structured model for use of Web due to the inherent unstructured nature of the business environment, the situation certainly warrants an initiative to identify and bring together the evolutionary multiple threads characterizing the changing business patterns. This edited book is an endeavor to bring forth such multiple threads, identify the current practices and future possibilities of making collaborative Web as a tool for business. It also presents the opportunities and challenges confronting organizations in the light of such emerging trends. The book presents a set of sixteen chapters grouped into four sections. A brief outline of the sections is included here. A detailed sectional preview has been provided at the beginning of each section. Section 1. Towards Collaborative Web sets the tone of this book. It is agreeable that the conventional business wisdom cannot be applied to use new tools and techniques without first understanding the nature of such technological changes. Thus, it is imperative to start with an understanding of the characteristics of Web today and appreciate the need for embedding collaborative Web into the business model. Three chapters grouped in this section together bring out the evolution of Web and e-business and suggest the integration of the two to have sustainable organizations and economies. Real life examples have been sprinkled appropriately to provide glimpses of changing business needs and formations. Section 2. Collaborative Applications in Business portrays a diverse set of business applications of collaborative Web. With the help of seven chapters, this section showcases the tools usage in information intensive industries notably in journalism and Web-services as well as in resource intensive industries such as oil and natural resources and agricultural sector. These chapters, with the help of examples collectively illustrate a generic pattern that collaborative Web tools and technologies have already started penetrating into the core business processes of different industries, affecting their collaborative value chains. Though, the adoption of these tools is still in small pockets, there is increasing clarity that they hold the potential to make a significant contribution to improvise business collaborations. Section 3. Organizational Aspects of Collaborative Web highlights the fact that there are far reaching effects of collaborative Web on the structure and culture of business organizations. Online ways to collaborate have introduced speed and dynamism in business relations; as a result the external as well as internal business partnerships are getting more dynamic and fluid. Employee loyalties are shifting from organizations to virtual communities. With the help of three chapters grouped in this section, we aim to sensitize the organizations, business managers and of course researchers to think through the risks of this fast emerging trend. Some strategies to convert these risks into opportunities are also covered. Section 4. Blending Real and Virtual Worlds brings home the essence of making judicious choice of tools and technologies for next generation businesses. Each of the three chapters included in this section illustrates the use of virtual reality for making business collaborations more human and sensory. Real life examples have been included to illustrate the options and usage patterns in conducting virtual meetings and business events. This section prompts the readers to go a bit creative and augment their business reality with virtual one thus creating a business world that is seamlessly collaborative. The flow of the sections, moving from section 1 to section 4 clearly establishes the increasing degree of collaboration across the value chain and also increasing pervasiveness of collaborative Web technologies across the value chain. Students, practitioners and researchers can draw hints from this flow to strategize their business models which are more collaborative and seamlessly connected. IWhen we first set out with the theme of this book around a year ago, the most commonly heard and read stories about
xvi
the use of collaborative Web for business processes were around internal communication, marketing and customer feedback. With the help of this project, our implicit target was to delve deeper into identifying specific business processes and their linkage with the collaborative Web, while understanding the related implications for individuals, organizations and society. Thanks to our chapter contributors who joined us from different industries, professions, and geographies and helped us in compiling a piece of knowledge to showcase diverse applications and effects of collaborative Web. Well balanced on academic rigor and practical insights, this work also aims to set future directions for strategists, managers, academicians, researchers and students in any area of business and management. Dear reader, we hope that our carefully selected set of chapters adds more practical insights, improves your understanding of the subject, and also gives you future directions for research and experimentation. We will be privileged to receive your feedback to take this subject knowledge forward in the best interest of theory and practice of Web-enabled businesses. Kamna Malik U21Global Graduate School, Singapore Praveen K. Choudhary HCL Technologies, India
REFERENCES Carlson, N. (2009). Coke has no idea how it got 3.3 million fans on Facebook. Silicon Alley Insider. Retrieved August 11, 2010, from http://www.businessinsider.com/coke-has-no-idea-why-its-so-popularon-facebook-2009-3 McKinsey Quarterly. (2009). How companies are benefiting from Web 2.0: Global survey results. Retrieved August 11, 2010, from http://mckinseyquarterly.com/Business Technology/BT Strategy/How companies are benefiting from Web 20 McKinsey Global Survey Results 2432 Nations, D. (2010). How Barack Obama is using Web 2.0 to run for President. Retrieved August 11, 2010, from http://webtrends.about.com/od/Web20/a/obama-Web.htm Virtual World News. (February 27, 2009). IBM saves $320,000 with Second Life meeting. Retrieved August 11, 2010, from http://www.virtualworldnews.com/2009/02/ibm-saves-320000-with-second-lifemeeting.html
Section 1
Towards Collaborative Web
OVERVIEW One may disagree on the stages, names, version numbers and definitions assigned to various forms of web, but what is equivocally acceptable about today’s web is its growing collaborative nature. While Wikipedia is reshaping the publishing industry, youtube is a great example of new wave in media and entertainment industry. Customers today have someone to listen to them and help them; and people with innovative ideas can find some takers, thanks to company blogs and virtual communities. This trend is pervasive and forceful to the extent that business organizations of this era cannot afford to ignore this. There is a large pool of web technologies and related software services available; what organizations need as the first step is to relook their business model and make web-enabled collaborations an intrinsic part there in. This section, with the help of three chapters takes you through different dimensions that need to be considered for weaving the collaborative web of business for better business and economic growth. Chapter 1 by Pankaj Kamthan is based on the premise that unless the nature of the product is understood, its true potential cannot be exercised. The chapter identifies and elaborates eight unique characteristics in the developmental environment of Web Applications viz. Computing EnvironmentNeutral, Domain-Specific, Human-Centered, Information Interaction-Intensive, Model-Driven, Open Environment-Based, Pattern-Oriented, and Quality-Sensitive. It then moves on to discuss the implications of these characteristics on users and towards different aspects of business organizations including transfer of knowledge and management. In chapter 2, R. Todd Stephens takes a look at how organizations can integrate Web 2.0 technology into their current electronic commerce environment. . The author highlights that the standard e-commerce focusing on conduct of business transactions will be soon as passé as an information-only site. To sustain themselves, organizations need to move to the next level of creating networks as an intrinsic part of their business model. This chapter runs you through the prominent technological developments such as wiki,
blogging, social networks, social tagging, mash-ups and user oriented content; and shares real life examples and reminds that integration strategies for these technologies should follow bottom-up approach. Chapter 3 by Julie Vardhan draws our attention towards the linkage between knowledge, entrepreneurship and growth of economy. It highlights recent advances in several understandings which underpin the creation of knowledge, the iterative knowledge loops, the knowledge economy itself and the range of technologies used by the entrepreneurs leading towards knowledge diversification, specialization and optimization resulting into growth of the overall economy. Some of the recent knowledge based growth models have also been shared, illustrating the effects of innovation in creation of new frontiers and firms and more specifically on firms exploiting new age web technologies.
1
Chapter 1
Towards a Characterization of the Developmental Environment of Web Applications and its Business Implications Pankaj Kamthan Concordia University, Canada
ABSTRACT The Web has been changing since its inception. In particular, the evolution of the developmental environment of Web Applications has been multi-directional. This chapter provides a conceptual characterization of such technical directions, relationships between these directions, and their implications towards business organizations. The consequences of a commitment to these directions are considered with the support of examples and/or empirical studies as appropriate. The challenges faced by Semantic Web Applications and Social Web Applications are briefly outlined.
INTRODUCTION The Internet, particularly the Web, has opened new vistas for many sectors of society and over the last decade has played an increasingly integral role in our daily activities of communication, information, and entertainment. The use of the DOI: 10.4018/978-1-60960-581-0.ch001
Web has changed people’s behaviors, in some cases indispensably and even irreversibly. It is evident that conventional business practices that apply to one product cannot be simply mapped to another without first understanding the nature of the product, and the same applies to Web Applications. This chapter identifies and elaborates unique characteristics in the developmental environment of Web Applications. It also
Copyright © 2011, IGI Global. Copying or distributing in print or electronic forms without written permission of IGI Global is prohibited.
Towards a Characterization of the Developmental Environment of Web Applications
considers the implications of these characteristics on users and towards different aspects of business organizations including transfer of knowledge and management. The rest of the chapter is organized as follows. First, the background and related work is presented. This is followed by an exploration of a list of characteristics that uniquely posit the nature of Web Applications. Next, challenges and directions for future research are outlined. Finally, concluding remarks are given.
BACKGROUND In this section, the basics of Web Applications that are relevant for the rest of the chapter are provided. The people who have a stake in a Web Application are outlined, and previous work on characterizing Web Applications is discussed.
Basic Terminology Related to Web Applications For the sake of this chapter, a Web Application is defined as a Web Site that behaves like an interactive software system specific to a domain and typically requires a non-trivial infrastructure for development. This infrastructure may include a disciplined and systematic development process, a team with high-level of knowledge and skills, deployment of additional software on the clientand/or server-side, and a schedule comprising of several weeks or months from inception to completion. The use of a Web Application has evolved from its origins in the mid 1990s. It has been shown in empirical studies (Weinreich et al., 2008) that, instead of merely seeking information, users now also expect to be able to interact with a Web Application to carry out certain tasks. This in turn has had an impact on how Web Applications are perceived, developed, and managed.
2
For the sake of this chapter, Web Engineering (Mendes & Mosley, 2006) is a discipline concerned with the establishment and use of sound scientific, engineering and management principles and disciplined and systematic approaches to the successful development, deployment, and maintenance of ‘high-quality’ Web Applications.
Stakeholders of Web Applications A stakeholder is a person who has interest in a Web Application for some purpose. For the sake of this chapter, the stakeholders of Web Applications are broadly classified into producers and consumers. The producers are responsible for server-side concerns of a Web Application; the consumers are receivers on the client-side of a Web Application. For example, business executives, project managers, and software engineers belong to the category of producers; beginner and advanced users belong to the category of consumers. It is possible to devise more sophisticated stakeholder classification schemes based on other criteria. For example, stakeholders could be classified based on their degree of influence (Alexander, 2005) on a Web Application. However, doing so is beyond the scope of this chapter. It is evident that the stakeholders of Web Applications are diverse. For example, there can be anthropological differences, cultural differences, and differences of personal preferences among stakeholders. These can be relevant to the development of Web Applications that aim to target a diverse audience.
Related Work on Characterizing the Development of Web Applications In this section, a chronological account of previous work related to this chapter is presented. A model for characterization of Web Applications has been given (Lowe, 2002). However, details of individual characteristics are not given and the discussion is relatively dated.
Towards a Characterization of the Developmental Environment of Web Applications
It has been noted that Web Applications vary in a number of ways from traditional software including uncertainty of the domain, often shorter time-to-market, and rapid changes in technologies (Lowe, 2003; Ziemer & Stålhane, 2004). However, the arguments are often based on perception rather than social and technical reality. It has been pointed out that different types of Web Applications vary along the lines of their nature, form, purpose, and development (Selmi, Kraïem, & Ghézala, 2005). However, the treatment is relatively dated. The variations between conventional software systems and Web Applications have been pointed out (Mendes & Mosley, 2006). However, the criteria focus on the development and underlying technologies rather than the stakeholders. Finally, a characterization from the viewpoint of basic elements of Web Engineering, namely project, people, process, and product has been proposed (Kamthan, 2009a). The approach taken in this chapter is an alternate, although not necessarily orthogonal, to this work.
AN ANTHOLOGY OF SALIENT CHARACTERISTICS IN THE DEVELOPMENT ENVIRONMENT OF WEB APPLICATIONS The following characteristics, based on the observations and experience of the author over a number years, identify the pivotal directions of evolution in the developmental environment of Web Applications: [C-1] Computing Environment-Neutral, [C-2] Domain-Specific, [C-3] Human-Centered, [C-4] Information Interaction-Intensive, [C-5] Model-Driven, [C-6] Open Environment-Based, [C-7] Pattern-Oriented, and [C-8] QualitySensitive. Figure 1 depicts [C-1] − [C-8], and their interrelationships of dependencies. The presence of an arrow in the figure signifies that the source ‘relies-upon’ the destination. The interest in this
chapter is in a confluence of [C-1] − [C-8]. It is the contention of the author that [C-1] − [C-8] are relevant; however, there is no claim that they are sufficient. These characteristics and their implications are discussed in some detail in the subsequent sections.
[C-1] Computing EnvironmentNeutral In the last two decades, there has been a proliferation of computing devices and user agents with diverse configurations. In particular, there has been an influx of computing devices such as notebook and tablet computers that vary considerably in their options for data input/output, screen capabilities, memory, disk space, and processing power. Indeed, if forecasts are any indicators, it is likely that the non-stationary devices will outsell stationary devices in the coming years. It is not practical for a typical user to change the underlying device or user agent to suit the demands of different Web Applications. It is expected by the users that the same services are available on an array of devices (related to [C-3]). Therefore, it has become ever more important for Web Applications to be perceived as being neutral to the volatility in the computing environment. In the past decade, there has been notable progress in this direction. The current initiatives such as the W3C’s Ubiquitous Web Applications Activity are a step forward. The producers of Web Applications have been confronting the challenge by providing dynamic delivery of resources based on an assessment of the clientside computing environment. This assessment, for example, can include recognizing the device and personalizing according to user preferences. In particular, it is effective to produce and archive a single, normative representation of information that, upon request, can be transformed to multiple presentations of information, tailored according to environmental needs including specificities of device types, operating systems, and user agents.
3
Towards a Characterization of the Developmental Environment of Web Applications
Figure 1. The characteristics of evolution of Web Applications and their interrelationships of dependencies
The proliferation of information technologies such as the Extensible Markup Language (XML), the Extensible Stylesheet Language Transformations (XSLT), and the Cascading Style Sheets (CSS) has played an important role for bringing this to a realization.
Challenges In general, a commitment to computing environment-neutrality is not free of cost. In order to achieve computing environment-neutrality to an acceptable degree, any advantages specific to, for example, hardware or software optimization, must be sacrificed. To check device variability, particularly that on mobile devices, the devices themselves and/or device simulators need to be acquired. The aim of minimizing (ideally, eliminating) dependency of a Web Application on user agents can require more time and effort on part of producers, not least due to the fact that the user agents are themselves prone to change. This variability also places extra burden on acceptance testing.
4
[C-2] Domain-Specific There are different types of Web Applications addressing different domains (Arrue, Vigo, & Abascal, 2008; Deshpande et al., 2002). The nature and underlying goals of an organization can be reflected in a Web Application that is domain-specific. Indeed, domain-specificity has been central to Web Applications for e-business: the actual information (including the advertisements, if any), style of expressing information, and presentation of information are all in the direction of the domain. The notion of a Web Portal has been instrumental in the proliferation of domain-specific Web Applications. For example, a Web Portal of skin care products is identifiably different from a Web Application connected to a bank’s information system. The interaction design in general and presentation design in particular, including typographical decisions, should reflect the differences between Web Applications pertaining to different domains.
Towards a Characterization of the Developmental Environment of Web Applications
There is increasing support for domain engineering in the development of Web Applications. For example, the information of the underlying domain is critical to the user models and the usage models (related to [C-3]). There are design patterns (Van Duyne, Landay, & Hong, 2007) that also suggest that the genre of a Web Application be specified at the start of development (related to [C-7]).
Challenges There can be undesirable side-effects of domainspecificity. The language used in a domain-specific Web Application, including terminology, may be acceptable to regular users; however, it may alienate new users if appropriate steps are not taken. These steps could include general introduction and provision of context-sensitive help.
[C-3] Human-Centered There are number of reasons due to which humancenteredness of Web Applications (Nielsen & Loranger, 2006) needs to be reflected throughout development and during operation. The consumers of interactive systems such as Web Applications are heterogeneous. Indeed, users can vary in a number of ways including age, mental and physical ability, educational background and skills, culture, gender, geographical location, goals, personal preferences, and temperament. This diversity must be acknowledged, embraced, and subsequently acted upon. The variations in the technological background and skills of consumers are especially relevant. There are consumers of Web Applications such as digital natives (Palfrey & Gasser, 2008) that were born at the time digital technologies were taking shape and/or have grown up with digital technologies. These digital technologies include those that underlie the current non-stationary computing devices as well as the Internet in general and the Web in particular. In contrast, there are also consumers of Web Ap-
plications such as digital immigrants or digital laggards that, by law or economic necessity, are required to use the Web. It is increasingly been acknowledged that the mere existence of a Web Application is neither necessary, nor a sufficient condition for its utility to a user. It has become important for the producers to consider the value a Web Application provides to a user throughout the development process and highlight the services it provides to a user upon delivery. Indeed, value and service can be dominant factors on which the success and failure of a Web Application is measured, and ignoring any of them can adversely impact the bottom-line of the business that owns that Web Application. The shift of focus on technologies to focus on people in the past decade has had an impact on how Web Applications should be viewed, namely a consideration of only technical aspects is insufficient in providing the quality of service expected from Web Applications by their consumers. The acknowledgement of the significance of the role of humans has led to a variety of changes at all levels of development of Web Applications. The process models for development of Web Applications have become more human-centric (Kamthan, 2008a; Kamthan, 2008b). The formulation of concrete user models such as personas (Pruitt & Adlin, 2006) and elicitation of user requirements has become an imperative. There has been an influx of a number of approaches for developing interactive systems in general and Web Applications in particular such as include activity-centered design, contextual design, empathic design, and so on. The acknowledgement of a user’s context, inception of personalization (related to [C-2]), and use of recommender systems are some of the prime examples of human-centeredness of Web Applications.
Challenges There are possible side-effects of human-centeredness of Web Applications. An emphasis
5
Towards a Characterization of the Developmental Environment of Web Applications
on the users and their environment may lead to over-attention and dependence on the data derived from ethnographic studies and user feedback, both during and after development. An initiative for personalization usually comes at the cost of privacy, and providing a priori guarantees to users of the appropriate use of the data submitted by them can be a challenge. There is also the potential for the use of the Web for persuasion (Weinschenk, 2009) that can adversely impact the credibility of a Web Application (Fogg, 2003).
[C-4] Information Interaction-Intensive The ‘invisibility’ of a computer was posited more than two decades ago (Norman, 1998). By treating information as a ‘first-class’ concern, the Web has acted as a catalyst in this regard. The Web has placed yet another layer between a human and the computer’s operating system interface, namely that of an information interface (Pirolli, 2007). The structural, behavioral, and creational aspects of information directly affect the consumers of Web Applications. It is likely that, among the consumers of Web Applications, the digital natives are the most exposed to and accustomed to the presence of information interfaces (related to
[C-3]). Therefore, attention and commitment to information interfaces is imperative for understanding the nature of Web Applications. The study of information interfaces belongs to the discipline of human-information interaction (HII). HII relies on a number of cognate disciplines (Albers, 2008) such as cognitive psychology, social psychology, human factors, human-computer interaction, information science, and technical communication. The structural, behavioral, and creational aspects of information interface design usually make use of patterns (related to [C-7]). Figure 2 illustrates multiple interfaces: the information interface of an abstract Web Application, the user interface of the user agent, and the user interface of the underlying operating system. Figure 3 illustrates an information interface created by viewing a Portable Document Format (PDF) document in the Mozilla Firefox user agent: the interface elements on the top belong to the user agent and the interface elements on the bottom belong to the Adobe Reader plug-in. It makes use of a number of information design, presentation design, and search design patterns (Van Duyne, Landay, & Hong, 2007).
Figure 2. The information interface in the hierarchy of human-to-machine interaction
6
Towards a Characterization of the Developmental Environment of Web Applications
Challenges The presence of information interfaces presents new development challenges. For example, a consumer may have to deal with multiple different interfaces within the same Web Application or across different Web Applications. This could be prohibitive in the absence of any contextsensitive help. The challenge increases if there are features across interfaces that are same or similar in presentation but different in functionality, or same or similar in functionality but different in presentation. For example, accessibility and usability issues of the search interface provided by a Web Application are not necessarily identical to that of a general-purpose search engine or to that provided by a user agent being used to access that Web Application.
[C-5] Model-Driven The interest in the development of Web Applications has steadily moved from concrete to abstract artifacts that can be achieved by conceptual model-
ing. There are a number of advantages of modeling including creating an environment for discussion across project team, early cost estimation, exploring and experimenting with design alternatives, identifying stakeholders, minimizing attention at the level of transient technologies, and so on. The assortment of desirable models includes a problem domain model, user model (such as user role, user profile, and/or persona), usage model (such as a use case model and/or a task model), and macro- and micro-architectural design models. The design models can be refined further to include specific aspects of design such as structure and behavior, usually using design patterns (related to [C-7]). Table 1 lists some early conceptual models in the development of Web Applications and their potential uses. The interest and initiatives towards modeling Web Applications has gradually increased over the past decade (Rossi et al., 2008). Initially, there were modeling approaches specific to Web Applications such as the Object-Oriented Hypermedia Design Method (OOHDM), UML-based Web Engineering (UWE), W2000, and the Web Mod-
Figure 3. An example of an information interface for a Web Application
Table 1. The potential uses of early conceptual models in the development of Web Applications €€€€Conceptual Model Type
€€€€Potential Use(s)
€€€€Problem Domain Model
€€€€Requirements Elicitation and Specification, Glossary
€€€€Stakeholder Model
€€€€Project Management Plan
€€€€User Model
€€€€User Requirements Elicitation and Specification, Acceptance Testing
€€€€Use Case Model
€€€€Cost Estimation, Behavioral Requirements Elicitation, Test Case Specification
€€€€Task Model
€€€€Interaction Design Description
7
Towards a Characterization of the Developmental Environment of Web Applications
eling Language (WebML). Now there are a number of extensions of the Unified Modeling Language (UML) for Web Applications in form of UML profiles (Rossi et al., 2008), each often focused on one of the possible views of the application. The availability of open modeling environments (related to [C-6]) can help in that endeavor.
Challenges The adoption of conceptual modeling, in spite of its usefulness, is not automatic. The organization’s process maturity and availability of resources can affect the degree of commitment, if at all, to conceptual modeling. In general, the knowledge and experience in conceptual modeling are rare, and therefore expensive. The proposed UML profiles for Web Applications tend to have different goals, and a ‘standard’ is yet to emerge.
[C-6] Open Environment-Based It would not be an overstatement to assert that, in the absence of an open environment, a widespread acceptance of the Web would not have been possible. Indeed, the architecture of the Web (Jacobs & Walsh, 2004), and the entire technological infrastructure that supports it, is based on an open environment. The availability of open resources, for both the producers and the consumers, has played a critical role in the success of Web Applications. The support software that is of primary concern to the producers and the consumers of Web Applications has been open. The classical exemplars on the client-side include the NCSA Mosaic and Lynx and on the server-side include the NCSA Web server. These were followed by the introduction of the Apache Web server and then the formation of the Apache Software Foundation, followed by the ascent of the Mozilla Project. The Open Source Software (OSS) has made an indispensable contribution to the development of
8
Web Applications. The ‘family’ of OSS clients, servers, and content management systems has flourished, and there does not appear any sign of decline in growth. The relationship between the Web and OSS is symbiotic (Kamthan, 2007). Indeed, Web has become the de facto platform for the development of OSS. There are a number of OSS foundries such as SourceForge that have been set up as Web Applications, and have been instrumental in dissemination of OSS.
Challenges In spite of the prevalence of OSS, their quality is still an open issue. The stability of OSS is not guaranteed: there are open source projects that have become dormant or have been discontinued after relatively short period of time. A commitment to such OSS can therefore impact the velocity of development of a Web Application. As open source projects are voluntary efforts, timely customer support can be an issue, especially for new initiatives.
[C-7] Pattern-Oriented The reliance on conceptually reusable experiential knowledge is crucial for the development of Web Applications. In the past couple of decades or so, one form of such knowledge, namely patterns, has been found useful. For the sake of this chapter, a pattern is defined as an empirically proven solution to a recurring problem that occurs in a particular context (Buschmann, Henney, & Schmidt, 2007; Kamthan, 2010). There are benefits of patterns for both the producers and the consumers of Web Applications. If used appropriately, patterns contribute to business values such as reduce cost, reduce time to market, increase quality to market, and increase product lifetime (Elssamadisy, 2007). The use of patterns for HII leads to information interfaces that are
Towards a Characterization of the Developmental Environment of Web Applications
familiar to the users of Web Applications, and it is known that familiarity contributes to usability. In recent years, a systematic approach based on patterns, for orienting the development of (Mobile) Web Applications aiming for ‘high-quality’, has been realized (Kamthan, 2008a; Kamthan, 2008b; Kamthan, 2008c). In particular, it is expected that models during the analysis and design phases are based on patterns. The deployment of tools can become crucial in a ‘large-scale’ use of patterns (related to [C-6]). Table 2 illustrates the role of patterns in the development of Web Applications based on some Web Engineering process. The relationship between the Web and patterns is symbiotic (Kamthan, 2008a). Indeed, Web has become the de facto platform for dissemination of patterns. There are a number of pattern collections available on repositories such as the Hypermedia Design Patterns Repository, the Portland Pattern Repository, and the Amsterdam Collection of Patterns that have been set up as Web Applications, and continue to serve the pattern community.
Challenges In spite of the advantages emanating from a commitment to patterns, there are certain limitations. There may be insufficient development experience in new domains. Therefore, even though desirable, there may not be any patterns for such domains. For example, even though the aware-
ness of accessibility in the development of Web Applications has increased over the past decade, there is currently a scarcity of stable and mature accessibility patterns. The selection of patterns is non-trivial due to a number of reasons including the absence of a ‘standard’ for pattern description. It is expected that the use of patterns can aid quality; however, in general, the relationship between quality and patterns (Kamthan, 2009c) is equivocal (related to [C-8]). Finally, studies pertaining to the return on investment (ROI) of patterns are yet to be seen.
[C-8] Quality-Sensitive There are different views of quality. For the sake of this chapter, these views include, but are not limited to, conformance to authoritative sources (such as standards), economical benefits, and consumer satisfaction. There are a number of reasons for paying attention to quality during the development of Web Applications. For example, a corporate trainer may want to use a Web Application for classroom demonstration without being interrupted by unsolicited pop-ups on unrelated topics; a senior citizen with low visual acuity would like to use the Web for banking from home but may be concerned about readability of text and entrusting others with personal information; a person with epilepsy would like to use the Web to look for travel destinations for her upcoming vacation without being confronted with animations; and
Table 2. The relationships between patterns and models in a process for the development of Web Applications €€€€Web Engineering Process €€€€Web Application Quality Model €€€€Conceptual Models
€€€€Is-Sensitive-To
€€€€Web Application Quality Model
€€€€Is-Visible-In
€€€€Conceptual Models
€€€€Is-Supported-By
€€€€Patterns
€€€€Depends-On
€€€€Web Application Stakeholder Model
€€€€May-Use
€€€€Patterns
€€€€Lead-To
€€€€Web Application
9
Towards a Characterization of the Developmental Environment of Web Applications
so on. Therefore, the needs pertaining to quality of the consumers of Web Applications should be a ‘first-class’ concern for the producers (related to [C-3]). There are other reasons for a commitment to quality. In general, a lack of quality has negative implications resulting in a ‘loss to society’ (Akingbehin, 2005). The success of a Web Application as perceived by its stakeholders is also often intrinsically related to its quality (Pertet & Narasimhan, 2005). The purpose of a quality model is to lend an understanding of quality. In general, a quality model provides a decomposition of quality into a number of attributes, relationships between those attributes, and means of quantifying those attributes. The recent quality models for Web Applications (Kamthan, 2008a; Kamthan, 2008b) have emphasized a number of quality attributes that are relevant to stakeholders including accessibility, credibility, legality, maintainability, privacy, reliability, security, and usability. These models also underscore the interplay of quality and patterns (related to [C-7]). The movement in quality engineering of Web Applications has been from technical to social concerns. There was early awareness of the significance of maintainability, reliability, security, and usability, followed by attention on accessibility, legality, and privacy, and in turn followed by credibility. This could be explained by the pervasiveness of Web Applications. The users are spending increasingly more time on the Web, and increasingly depending on the Web for routine activities. There have also been notable efforts in this area by commercial vendors like Adobe Systems, Microsoft, and Sun Microsystems to ensure that their products are sensitive to quality concerns of end-users. In particular, the support for accessibility in products such as Adobe Flash and Adobe Reader has increased over the past decade.
10
Challenges In spite of the evident significance of quality assurance and evaluation, it is not free of cost. The infrastructure required for setting up a dedicated quality engineering program, including laboratories, may not be within the budget of certain academic institutions and small-to-medium-size enterprises (SME). The number of engineers for testing Web Applications has improved over the years; however, experts in heuristics evaluation of accessibility or usability are scarce and not inexpensive. There are a few free-to-use tools for evaluating, say accessibility, credibility, and usability of Web Applications; however, guidance for their appropriate use may not always be freely available, if at all. Finally, a Web Application can be a complex system, and a single quality model may not be sufficient. Indeed, as shown in Table 3, there is a need for multiple quality models for a Web Application, each emphasizing a specific aspect of that Web Application.
Remarks The characteristics [C-1] − [C-8] apply only to the Surface Web, not the Deep Web. It is important to note that, apart from those discussed above, certain characteristics, such as EthicallyAware, Law-Abiding, Standards-Conforming, or Value-Added, are among the desirable potential candidates. However, currently these can not be unequivocally seen as perceived directions for the evolution of Web Applications. For example, the pervasiveness of information technology in general, and the Internet and the Web in particular, has given rise to new ethical dilemmas (Tavani, 2004). However, the current commitment of organizations towards an ethicsaware Web Applications is unclear.
Towards a Characterization of the Developmental Environment of Web Applications
Table 3. A selected collection of different quality models in the development of Web Applications €€€€Type of Quality Model
€€€€Examples
€€€€Conceptual Model Quality Model
€€€€Domain Model Quality Model, Use Case Model Quality Model
€€€€Specification Quality Model
€€€€Requirements Specification Quality Model
€€€€Information Quality Model
€€€€Text Quality Model, Two-Dimensional Graphics Quality Model, Animation Quality Model
€€€€Design Quality Model
€€€€Navigation Design Quality Model, Presentation Design Quality Model
€€€€Implementation Quality Model
€€€€Data Quality Model, Source Code Quality Model
Implications of Characterizing the Development of Web Applications for Business Organizations The characteristics that reflect relatively stabilizing invariants in the evolution of the development of Web Applications need to be identified and explored for a number of reasons, including their implications on business organizations.
Implications for Knowledge Transfer In general, an awareness of the directions in the evolution of the development of Web Applications could be useful for corporate trainers who are involved in curriculum development related to Web Engineering at their respective organizations. For example, instead of the conventional focus on technology-oriented courses (Krunić et al., 2006) under the label of ‘Web Design,’ or the like, it could open new vistas for curriculum design. The potential topics for courses include Conceptual Modeling of Web Applications (related to [C-5]), Open Source Web Applications (related to [C-6]), Quality of Web Applications (related to [C-7] and [C-8]), and User-Centered Web Applications (related to [C-3] and [C-8]), to name a few. In these courses, basic concepts of Web Applications and services to consumers become primary, and technology, albeit important, becomes secondary.
Implications for Management The Web has become a ‘first-class’ medium for a number of industries. This has had a notable impact on business decision making and organizational practices, especially those industries that are committed to Business-to-Business (B2B) and Business-to-Consumer (B2C) electronic commerce (E-Commerce). Project A characterization of Web Applications is relevant to technical leaders who are involved in planning their future information technology policies at their respective organizations. There is a constant drive in industry to gain a competitive edge through a number of means such as by improving existing workflows, finding avenues of reusable knowledge, eliciting new directions for personnel training, and so on. An understanding of the avenues being pursued in the engineering of Web Applications could help charter new paths for these directions. Process In the early days of the Web, the organizations followed an ad-hoc or essentially linear approaches towards the development of ‘large-scale’ Web Applications. However, taking into consideration the working habits of the people involved (related to [C-3]) and following an evolutionary approach towards development are being recognized as increasingly relevant to the underlying process
11
Towards a Characterization of the Developmental Environment of Web Applications
environment. This trend is likely to continue for the foreseeable future. The organizations have come to embrace agile methodologies such as Extreme Programming (XP), Lean Development, and Scrum. Indeed, empirical studies (Clutterbuck, Rowlands, & Seamons, 2009) have shown some success in doing so. However, transition to agility is not automatic, depends intrinsically on an organization’s culture, and comes with a price. For fruitful development, an organization must seek a balance on the rigidity-agility spectrum.
FUTURE RESEARCH DIRECTIONS In this section, two directions of evolution of the Web (Murugesan, 2010), namely the Semantic Web and Social Web are considered, and their implications for producers and consumers of Web Applications are briefly outlined.
Towards a Characterization of the Development of Semantic Web Applications The Semantic Web has emerged as an extension of the current Web that adds technological infrastructure for better knowledge representation, interpretation, and reasoning (Hendler, Lassila, & Berners-Lee, 2001). It has promised a new era of Semantic Web Applications, especially those that can make implicit knowledge explicit and reason with it. The attention on the Semantic Web has reinforced the significance of the separation of the representation and presentation of information. This, in turn, has positive implications towards accessibility/usability and maintainability. For example, multiple user-supplied style sheets can be associated with a single source of representation, and multiple target presentations can be generated from a single source of representation. Indeed, a better representation of knowledge opens new possibilities for Semantic Web Ap-
12
plications with ‘intelligent’ user interfaces (IUIs), especially those of adaptation and personalization. The representation of knowledge in form of ontologies holds the promise of more precise and relevant searching as demonstrated by experimental search engines like CORESE, SWSE and Swoogle.
Challenges The apparent benefits of the Semantic Web come with certain challenges. Even though there have been many advances towards enabling the technical infrastructure of the Semantic Web in recent years, there is much to be done in addressing the human and social concerns (Kamthan & Pai, 2005). In particular, the learning curve and requisite skills expected by the underlying technologies, especially by knowledge representation languages; the cost-benefit ratio in the production of large, domain-specific ontologies; quality assurance and evaluation of ontologies; performance of reasoning with these ontologies over the network; and usability of query formulations on devices with restricted capabilities, are some of the unique challenges for a broad acceptance of Semantic Web Applications. For example, the Web Ontology Language (OWL) is one of the key layers of the Semantic Web technology ‘stack.’ OWL recursively depends on a number of other technologies for its definition, all of which need to be learned for a thorough understanding and subsequent optimal use.
Towards a Characterization of the Development of Social Web Applications The Social Web, or as it is more commonly referred to by the pseudonym Web 2.0 (O’Reilly, 2005), is the perceived evolution of the Web in a direction that is driven by ‘collective intelligence,’ realized by information technology, and characterized by user participation, openness, and network effects.
Towards a Characterization of the Developmental Environment of Web Applications
It has spawned a new era of Social Web Applications (Bell, 2009), and opened new vistas for collaboration among globally distributed participants. The Social Web celebrates the human involvement in the evolution of the Web. If the Web leveled the playing field between large and small businesses, the Social Web, to certain extent, levels the playing field between producers and consumers. Indeed, Social Web applications like Del.icio.us, Facebook, Flickr, LinkedIn, Wikipedia, and YouTube, are but a few examples of the phenomenon where a consumer becomes a co-producer, or a prosumer, in a social network. In this sense, the Social Web itself is an environment for the development of (Social and/or Semantic) Web Applications. For example, there are Social Web Applications that can be used by members of a project team to communicate with each other, collaboratively develop conceptual models listed in Table 1, and disseminate process artifacts (Kamthan, 2009b).
Challenges The apparent benefits of the Social Web (Kamthan, 2009b) come with certain challenges. A systematic process for developing Social Web Applications has yet to emerge. The Social Web Applications, particularly those labeled as Rich Internet Applications (RIA), can place demands on the client-side that could be perceived as severe. The conventional user interface metaphors for desktop and Web Applications are not sufficient for Social Web Applications, and innovation in that direction is desirable. For example, conventional applications have dialogues between human and computer; in Social Web Applications, this model has to be extended to dialogues between humans, in some cases groups of size greater than two. The Social Web has brought forth issues related to quality, specifically of legality, privacy, and security, not encountered previously. The Social Web applications will need to address new technical and social requirements to be viable.
For example, the reuse of information in mashups (Ogrinz, 2009) raises the issues of the rights of the original author and appropriate attribution by its users. The ease of involvement in social networks has led to a proliferation of participants on services such as Facebook and MySpace; however, at the cost of privacy if not configured and controlled adequately. If surveys are any indicators, the digital natives are likely the most frequent users of and/ or participants in the Social Web Applications. The ease of publishing information has led to a new group of contributors, including digital natives; however, lack of adequate knowledge and/ or experience of protecting information have also increased potential threats to security. The Social Web has also blurred the lines between the roles and responsibilities of a producer and a consumer with respect to the corrective and perfective maintenance of a Web Application. For example, the contributors of information in the role of prosumers may not have adequate training in discerning the quality of information that they contribute to Social Web Applications such as Wikipedia. This raises the issue of believability of the information presented to a consumer in general and of the credibility of Web Applications in particular (Fogg, 2003). For example, the potential for the distribution of inaccurate medical information from unqualified sources has particularly had an acute impact on the user perception of health-related Web Applications, and is not likely to improve by inviting unmonitored end-user development.
Remarks The development of Semantic Web Applications and Social Web Applications reflects machineoriented and human-oriented extension of conventional Web Applications, respectively. It is relatively early to characterize this new generation of applications. In doing so, the characteristics [C1] − [C-8] are deemed necessary but not sufficient.
13
Towards a Characterization of the Developmental Environment of Web Applications
For the sake of argument, consider the case of Social Web Applications. It is likely that Social Web Applications need to move from genericity to specificity (related to [C-2]). For example, there are generic social networking applications like Facebook, but also means for creating community-specific social networks using systems such as Ning. Furthermore, to be inclusive, the Social Web Applications need to commit to universal design (Chisholm & May, 2008), and therefore to accessibility and usability (related to [C-8]). However, given a group of participants in a Social Web Application, there is also a need to consider the sociological impact that entails from the computer-mediated communication among participants themselves. This is not completely addressed by [C-1] − [C-8].
CONCLUSION The characteristics presented in this chapter aim to provide an understanding of the state-of-the-art in the development of Web Applications. They also highlight technical and social challenges that are likely for both the producers and consumers of Web Applications. In the past decade, there have been numerous advances towards enabling the technological infrastructure of the Web in lieu of addressing the technical challenges. However, there is much to be done in addressing the social challenges. The Web continues to grow at an alarming pace, and the dependence of the society on it continues to increase. It can be anticipated that there will be new generation of Web Applications, possibly unique in some ways. It is likely that the [C-1] − [C-8] presented in this chapter will remain relevant for the foreseeable future. However, in order to characterize sustainable development that provides value to both the producers and consumers of these ‘new’ Web Applications, they may need to evolve accordingly, both in terms of their emphasis and their granularity.
14
REFERENCES Akingbehin, K. (2005). A quantitative supplement to the definition of software quality. The Third ACIS International Conference on Software Engineering, Research, Management and Applications (SERA 2005), Mt. Pleasant, U.S.A., August 11-13, 2005. Albers, M. J. (2008). Human-information interaction. The Twenty Sixth Annual ACM International Conference on Design of Communication (SIGDOC 2008), Lisbon, Portugal, September 22-24, 2008. Alexander, I. F. (2005). A taxonomy of stakeholders: Human roles in system development. International Journal of Technology and Human Interaction, 1(1), 23–59. doi:10.4018/jthi.2005010102 Arrue, M., Vigo, M., & Abascal, J. (2008). Supporting the development of accessible Web applications. Journal of Universal Computer Science, 14(16), 2699–2719. Bell, G. (2009). Building social Web applications: Establishing community at the heart of your site. O’Reilly Media. Buschmann, F., Henney, K., & Schmidt, D. C. (2007). Pattern-oriented software architecture, volume 5: On patterns and pattern languages. John Wiley and Sons. Chisholm, W., & May, M. (2008). Universal design for Web applications: Web applications that reach everyone. O’Reilly Media. Clutterbuck, P., Rowlands, T., & Seamons, O. (2009). A case study of SME Web application development effectiveness via agile methods. The Electronic Journal of Information Systems Evaluation, 12(1), 13–26. Deshpande, Y., Murugesan, S., Ginige, A., Hansen, S., Schwabe, D., Gaedke, M., & White, B. (2002). Web engineering. Journal of Web Engineering, 1(1), 3–17.
Towards a Characterization of the Developmental Environment of Web Applications
Elssamadisy, A. (2007). Patterns of agile practice adoption: The technical cluster. C4Media. Fogg, B. J. (2003). Persuasive technology: Using computers to change what we think and do. Morgan Kaufmann. Hendler, J., Lassila, O., & Berners-Lee, T. (2001). The Semantic Web. Scientific American, 284(5), 34–43. doi:10.1038/scientificamerican0501-34 Jacobs, I., & Walsh, N. (2004). Architecture of the World Wide Web, vol. 1. World Wide Web Consortium (W3C) recommendation. Kamthan, P. (2007). On the prospects and concerns of integrating open source software environment in software engineering education. Journal of Information Technology Education, 6, 45–64. Kamthan, P. (2008a). A situational methodology for addressing the pragmatic quality of Web applications by integration of patterns. Journal of Web Engineering, 7(1), 70–92. Kamthan, P. (2008b). A methodology for integrating patterns in quality-centric Web applications. International Journal of Information Technology and Web Engineering, 3(2), 27–44. doi:10.4018/ jitwe.2008040103 Kamthan, P. (2008c). Towards high-quality mobile applications by a systematic integration of patterns. Journal of Mobile Multimedia, 4(3/4), 165–184. Kamthan, P. (2009a). A model for characterizing Web engineering. In Khosrow-Pour, M. (Ed.), Encyclopedia of Information Science and Technology (2nd ed., pp. 2631–2637). Hershey, PA: IGI Global. Kamthan, P. (2009b). A methodology for integrating the social Web environment in software engineering education. International Journal of Information and Communication Technology Education, 5(2), 21–35. doi:10.4018/jicte.2009040103
Kamthan, P. (2009c). On the symbiosis between quality and patterns. The Third International Workshop on Software Patterns and Quality (SPAQu 2009), Orlando, USA, October 25, 2009. Kamthan, P. (2010). A viewpoint-based approach for understanding the morphogenesis of patterns. International Journal of Knowledge Management, 6(2), 40–65. doi:10.4018/jkm.2010040103 Kamthan, P., & Pai, H.-I. (2005). An experience in ontological representation of Web application patterns for the Semantic Web. The First Workshop on Semantic Web Enabled Software Engineering (SWESE 2005), Galway, Ireland, November 6, 2005. Krunić, T., Ružić-Dimitrijević, L., Petrović, B., & Farkaš, R. (2006). Web design curriculum and syllabus based on Web design practice and students’ prior knowledge. Journal of Information Technology Education, 5, 317–335. Lowe, D. (2002). Characterisation of Web projects. The Eighth Australian World Wide Web Conference (AusWeb 2002), Sunshine Coast, Australia, July 6-10, 2002. Lowe, D. (2003). Web system requirements: An overview. Requirements Engineering, 8(2), 102–113. doi:10.1007/s00766-002-0153-x Mendes, E., & Mosley, N. (2006). Web engineering. Springer-Verlag. doi:10.1007/3-540-28218-1 Murugesan, S. (2010). Web X.0: A road map. In Murugesan, S. (Ed.), Handbook of research on Web 2.0, 3.0 and X.0: Technologies, business, and social applications (pp. 1–11). Hershey, PA: IGI Global. Nielsen, J., & Loranger, H. (2006). Prioritizing Web usability. New Riders Publishing. Norman, D. A. (1998). The invisible computer: Why good products can fail, the personal computer is so complex, and information appliances are the solution. The MIT Press.
15
Towards a Characterization of the Developmental Environment of Web Applications
O’Reilly, T. (2005). What is Web 2.0: Design patterns and business models for the next generation of software. O’Reilly Network. Ogrinz, M. (2009). Mashup patterns: Designs and strategies for using mashups in enterprise environments. Addison-Wesley. Palfrey, J., & Gasser, U. (2008). Born digital: Understanding the first generation of digital natives. Basic Books.
Weinreich, H., Obendorf, H., Eelco, M., & Herder, M. (2008). Not quite the average: An empirical study of Web use. ACM Transactions on the Web, 2(1), 5:1-5:31. Weinschenk, S. M. (2009). Neuro Web design: What makes them click?New Riders. Ziemer, S., & Stålhane, T. (2004). The use of trade-offs in the development of Web applications. International Workshop on Web Quality (WQ 2004). Munich, Germany. July 27, 2004.
Pertet, S. M., & Narasimhan, P. (2005). Causes of failure in Web applications. (PDL Technical Report PDL-CMU-05-109). Carnegie Mellon University, USA.
ADDITIONAL READING
Pirolli, P. (2007). Information foraging theory: Adaptive interaction with information. Oxford University Press. doi:10.1093/acprof:o so/9780195173321.001.0001
Brajnik, G. (2001). Towards Valid Quality Models for Web Sites. The Seventh Conference on Human Factors and the Web (HFWeb 2001), Madison, U.S.A., June 4-6, 2001.
Pruitt, J., & Adlin, T. (2006). The persona lifecycle: Keeping people in mind throughout product design. Morgan Kauffman.
Casteleyn, S., Daniel, F., Dolog, P., & Matera, M. (2009). Engineering Web Applications. Springer Verlag. doi:10.1007/978-3-540-92201-8
Rossi, G., Pastor, O., Schwabe, D., & Olsina, L. (2008). Web engineering: Modelling and implementing Web applications. Springer-Verlag. doi:10.1007/978-1-84628-923-1
Constantine, L. L., & Lockwood, L. A. D. (2002). Usage-Centered Engineering for Web Applications. IEEE Software, 19(2), 42–50. doi:10.1109/52.991331
Selmi, S. S., Kraïem, N., & Ghézala, H. H. B. (2005). Toward a comprehension view of Web engineering. The Fifth International Conference on Web Engineering (ICWE 2005), Sydney, Australia, July 27-29, 2005.
Costagliola, G., Ferrucci, F., Gravino, C., Tortora, G., & Vitiello, G. (2004). The Impact of Accessibility and Usability on the Development of Web Applications. International Workshop on Web Quality (WQ 2004), Munich, Germany, July 27, 2004.
Tavani, H. T. (2004). Ethics and technology: Ethical issues in an age of information and communication technology. John Wiley and Sons. Van Duyne, D. K., Landay, J., & Hong, J. I. (2007). The design of sites: Patterns for creating winning websites. Prentice-Hall.
16
Graham, I. (2003). A Pattern Language for Web Usability. Addison-Wesley. Hasan, L. R., & Abuelrub, E. (2006). Criteria for Evaluating Quality of Websites. The Sixth IBIMA Conference on Managing Information in Digital Economy, Bonn, Germany, June 19-21, 2006.
Towards a Characterization of the Developmental Environment of Web Applications
Lynch, P. J., & Horton, S. (2009). Web Style Guide: Basic Design Principles for Creating Web Sites (3rd ed.). Yale University Press. Ricca, F., & Tonella, P. (2006). Detecting Anomaly and Failure in Web Applications. IEEE MultiMedia, 13(2), 44–51. doi:10.1109/MMUL.2006.26 Ross, M. (2002). Quality in Web Design for Visually Impaired Users. Software Quality Journal, 10(4), 285–298. doi:10.1023/A:1022185920401 Sampaio, A., Vasconcelos, A., & Sampaio, P. R. F. (2004). Towards Reconciling Quality and Agility in Web Application Development. International Workshop on Web Quality (WQ 2004), Munich, Germany, July 27, 2004. The following publications advocate a systematic and/or disciplined approach towards the development of ‘high-quality’ Web Applications from a user’s perspective:
KEY TERMS AND DEFINITIONS Accessibility: The usability of a product, service, environment, or facility by people with the widest range of capabilities. The concept of accessibility addresses the full range of user capabilities and is not limited to users who are formally recognized as having a disability. The usability-oriented concept of accessibility aims to achieve levels of effectiveness, efficiency, and satisfaction that are as high as possible considering the specified context of use, while paying particular attention to the full range of user capabilities within the user population.
Information Scent: An information scent is a cue to a person (namely, the information seeker) in an information environment that indicates that the information environment has the information the person seeks. Model: A simplified description with respect to some goal of an entity from a particular viewpoint. Pattern: An empirically proven solution to a recurring problem that occurs in a particular context. Quality: The totality of features and characteristics of a product or a service that bear on its ability to satisfy stated or implied needs. Semantic Web: An extension of the current Web that adds technological infrastructure for better knowledge representation, interpretation, and reasoning. Social Web: A perceived evolution of the Web in a direction that is characterized by user participation, openness, and network effects; driven by ‘collective intelligence;’ and realized by information technology. Universal Design: The design of products and environments to be usable by all people, to the greatest extent possible, without the need for adaptation or specialized design. Usability: The extent to which a product can be used by specified users to achieve specified goals with effectiveness, efficiency, and satisfaction in a specified context of use. Web Engineering: A discipline concerned with the establishment and use of sound scientific, engineering and management principles and disciplined and systematic approaches to the successful development, deployment, and maintenance of ‘high-quality’ Web Applications.
17
18
Chapter 2
Web 2.0:
Integration Model with Electronic Commerce R. Todd Stephens AT&T, USA
ABSTRACT In this chapter, the author takes a look at how organizations can integrate Web 2.0 technology into their current electronic commerce environment. The success of the Internet can be seen within any organization, but customers are asking for more interaction with the enterprises they do business with. In a few years, having a standard electronic commerce site will be as passé as having an information only site today. Organizations must progress to the next level in order to have a viable business model in the future. Web 2.0 provides the basic technology for creating a network of customers who are passionate about the company’s product offering. This chapter reviews several different examples where organizations have added Web 2.0 to their environment and are succeeding in transforming themselves.
INTRODUCTION Small, medium and large organizations are being transformed from an old business model built around the command and control aspects of information management to a new one where collaboration and social networking are the esDOI: 10.4018/978-1-60960-581-0.ch002
sential components in defining a long-term business value. When researchers speak of Web 2.0 applications, they tend to focus on the technology aspects of the environment. However, the real impact of integrating Web 2.0 technologies is in the transformation of the organizational business model. The following sections of this chapter will focus on defining Web 1.0 with electronic commerce followed by a basic definition of Web
Copyright © 2011, IGI Global. Copying or distributing in print or electronic forms without written permission of IGI Global is prohibited.
Web 2.0
2.0. This will then be followed by examples and discussions on the different business utilizations of Web 2.0 technology.
Background While the web itself is about twenty years old, businesses are still implementing technology into the fabric of the business model. The background section will focus on defining the building blocks for the framework including defining the basic components of Web 1.0 which focused on the online marketing presence and the business transaction. The Web 2.0 section will focus on defining the basic building blocks of customer interactions.
Electronic Commerce Business Process Model Generally speaking, an end user will go through a defined process while engaging in an electronic commerce environment. Teo and Yeong (2003) described the consumer business model with five steps: need recognition, information search, alternative evaluation, purchase and after purchase evaluation. Kotler (2003) proposed a framework that included the following activities in the buyer’s decision process: problem identification, search, trust building, evaluation of alternatives, choice and post-purchase behavior. From these and other models, we can develop our own model with six basic steps. 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. 6.
Recognize Needs Search for Available Products Evaluate Product Alternatives Decide and Choose a Product Execute Transaction Post-Purchase Activities
The process begins when a customer recognizes one’s need. This need could be for a product or service or simply the recognition of a companies
offerings. The recognition phase indicates the need for brand development which focuses on marketing and communications. This is especially true with organizations that have consumer based product lines. Companies spend millions of dollars each year to get the message out to the user community of their value proposition and brand. Once the customer recognizes the need then they need to have the ability to search for the right product or service. This may include customization options and bundling several products or services together in order to deliver a more focused solution. Generally speaking, the product offering is defined as the product catalog where specific information is provided to the customers such as color, size, use and any other descriptive metadata. Once a user has found the product, they will then move into an evaluation phase where they try to determine if the product is right for them. This may include color selection, size, model or any other components that fit with the individual’s life style. Many sites allow for a side by side comparison of products in order to review the different features. After evaluating products, customers then decide if a purchase it necessary. The purchase will result in a transaction which is then followed up with several support functions. Support functions might include help, online chat, documentation, quick start guides, etc.
Web 1.0 and Electronic Commerce The term Web 1.0 emerged from the research and development of Web 2.0. Prior to this, researchers commonly referred to Web 1.0 as Electronic Commerce or E-Business. Other researchers actually separate Web 1.0, meaning online presence, from electronic commerce. In this chapter, we will use the combination definition for simplicity and clarity. Where as, web 1.0 focused on a read only web interface (plus transactions), Web 2.0 focuses on a read-write interface where value emerges from the contribution of a large volume of users.
19
Web 2.0
The internet initially focused on the command and control of the information itself. Information was controlled by a relatively small number of resources but distributed to a large number which spawned the massive growth of the web itself. Like television, the web allowed for the broadcasting of information to a large number of users. Initial web sites were built simply to communicate presence or provide information on the business itself. This component included information like marketing materials, investor relations, employment opportunities, and product information. While many organizations have succeeded in making progress towards an interactive web environment, their applications to date have still focused on an outdated Web 1.0 model, in which they take traditional offline activities and simply move them online. Most companies have taken advantage of the internet to find survey respondents, target a certain demographic or characteristic, and boost response rates – but few have taken advantage of the hallmark of Web 2.0: user-generated content (Freedman, Konwiser, Nielsten, & Van Ostern, 2008). Some researchers describe the integration of the business transaction as Web 1.5, indicating a separate phase of development. This altered the static information environment and transformed the web into an integral part of the business environment. The World Wide Web (WWW) was conceived at the European Particle Physics Laboratory in Switzerland. Berners-Lee, Cailliau, Luotonen, Figure 1. Web 1.0 and business (Source: Author)
20
Nielsen, and Secret (1994) describe the web as “collaborative medium” which would allow information providers in remote sites to share ideas without boundaries. Most businesses have moved towards the web in order to take advantage of the capabilities of the electronic-commerce business model. Moving business functions from a traditional brick and mortar model to an electronic commerce model is not as simple as it might seem. Simply, Web 1.0 revolves around the digital enablement of transactions and processes within the organization, involving information systems under the guidance or control of the firm (Laudon & Traver, 2003). Electronic Commerce describes the process of buying or selling products, services, and information via computer networks. Web 1.0 emerged as major channel for the worldwide distribution of products, services and professional jobs. The first Electronic Commerce applications were in the form of electronic fund transfers or also referred to as wire transfers (Schneider, 2002). These applications evolved to transmit information of all kinds including business transactions. The basic definition of Electronic Commerce implies some form of transmission of information in order to conduct business (Barnard & Wesson, 2003). For this research, we are going to use the Web 1.0 model depicted in Figure 1. This model is composed of six basic areas which include the brand information, product or service elements, metadata, educational materials, product discovery and Electronic Commerce
Web 2.0
business functions. The industry box represents information that aids the end user to understand who, what and why the company is in business. A company’s brand can be one of the most valuable assets they have to control and monitor. The industry box includes the following components of an online environment: interface design (including style, color, and professionalism, logo, tag lines, and information content quality) and industry background information. The second and third boxes work together to describe the product or service that the company provides. The first defines the basic product while the second provides the metadata or structured information that describes that product or service. Barnard and Wesson (2004) include product descriptions, images, price, availability, options and relationships with other products. These two boxes define the basic product catalog for the organization. The fourth box defines the various methods of accessing the product information including search, product categories, and usage based classifications such as most popular. The fifth box describes the basic components of Electronic Commerce as described in the prior section. The final box focuses on the basic education of the user and may include online help, customer service, FAQ or any other education related function related to the product, service, industry or online environment. This model defines the majority of the Electronic Commerce environments online today.
Web 2.0 and Social Web Web 2.0 represents a shift in thinking in how people and organizations communicate. Sometimes referred to as sharing, collaboration, aggregate knowledge or community driven content and social software creates the foundation of collective intelligence (Weiss, 2005). Much of the Web 2.0 technology is difficult to nail down to an exact definition. The basic truth is that Web 2.0 emphasizes employee interaction, community and openness (Millard & Ross, 2006). O’Reilly
(2005) defined Web 2.0 as a platform spanning all connected devices. Web 2.0 applications are those that make the most of the intrinsic advantages of that platform delivering software as a continuallyupdated service that gets better as more people use it, consuming and remixing data from multiple sources, including individual users, while providing their own data and services in a form that allows remixing by others, creating network effects through an “architecture of participation” and going beyond the page metaphor of Web 1.0 to deliver rich user experiences. Along with these characteristics, Smith and Valdes (2005) added simple and lightweight technologies and decentralized processing to the mix. Web 2.0 technologies are changing the internet from a search and consume environment to a dynamic and interactive experience emphasizing contribution and collaboration (Murugesan, 2007). Web 2.0 is not a uniform concept, but a generic term or metaphor for new internet technologies and applications. It can be seen as a revival, intensification, renewal or even as a second generation of the internet in which user generated content has a central place. Web 2.0 has also been called the social web, because its content can be more easily generated by users, as well as the collective intelligence of users. Users are not the passive consumers of content, but co-producers. Interaction plays an important role in Web 2.0 to create shared information (Kool & Wamelen, 2008). Osimo and Burgelman state that Web 2.0 is about technology and attitude. Miller (2005) describes 2.0 applications as those applications that make the most of the intrinsic advantages of that platform of services. While Web 2.0 has many and often confusing definitions most include the concepts of Social Networking, Weblogs, Wikis, Really Simple Syndication (RSS) Functionality, Social Tagging, Mashups, and User Defined Content.
21
Web 2.0
Social Networking Millions of people are now using social networking sites to connect, share and track the activities of people with strong and weak ties. The emergence of these social network sites generally focus on specific user groups such as professionals or common interest communities (i.e. Linked In). Professional networking behaviors include maintaining contacts, socializing, engaging in professional activities such as attending conferences, participating in community groups, and increasing the viability for others (Dougherty & Forret, 2001). In Web 2.0, social networking also includes personal and group e-mailing, blogging and joining online social networks (Brown, Farnham, & Schwartz, 2009). Basically, social networks provide the opportunity for people to connect and communicate in a timely manner. Most social networks focus on a central repository to store information about the individuals and then utilize various methods to relate one individual to another. This relationship is the basis for the social network in which people can share information. The methods of creating a relationship vary from associated metadata, invitationS and related experiences like place of employment.
Weblogs or Blogs Weblogs or blogs have become so ubiquitous that many people use the term as a synonymous for a “personal web site” (Blood, 2004). Unlike traditional Hypertext Markup Language (HTML) web pages, blogs offer the ability for the nonprogrammer to communicate on a regular basis. Traditional HTML style pages required knowledge of style, coding and design in order to publish content that was basically read only from the consumer’s point of view. Weblogs remove much of the constraints by providing a standard user interface that does not require customization. Weblogs originally emerged as a repository for linking but soon evolved to the ability to publish content and
22
allow readers to become content providers. The essence of a blog can be defined by the format which includes small chunks of content referred to as posts, date stamped, reverse chronological order and content expanded to include links text and images (Baoill, 2004). The biggest advancement made with Weblogs is the permanence of the content which has a unique Universal Resource Locator (URL). This allows the content to be posted and along with the comments to define a permanent record of information. This is critical in that having a collaborative record that can be indexed by search engines will increase the utility and spread the information to a larger audience. With the advent of software like WordPress and TypePad along with blog service companies like blogger.com, the weblog is fast becoming the communication medium of the new web.
Wikis A Wiki is a web site that promotes the collaborative creation of content. Wiki pages can be edited by anyone at anytime. Informational content can be created and easily organized within the wiki environment and then reorganized as required (O’Neill, 2005). Wikis are currently in high demand in a large variety of fields due to their simplicity and flexibility. Documentation, reporting, project management, online glossaries and dictionaries, discussion groups or general information applications are just a few examples of where the end user can provide value (Reinhold, 2006). The major difference between a wiki and a blog is that the wiki user can alter the original content while the blog user can only add information in the form of comments. While stating that anyone can alter content, some large scale wiki environments have extensive role definitions which define who can perform functions of update, restore, delete and creation. Wikipedia, like many wiki type projects, has readers, editors, administrators, patrollers, policy makers, subject matter experts, content maintainers, software developers and system
Web 2.0
operators (Riehle, 2006). All of which create an environment open to sharing information and knowledge to a large group of users.
RSS Technologies Originally developed by Netscape, RSS was intended to publish news type information based upon a subscription framework (Lerner, 2004). Many internet users have experienced the frustration of searching internet sites for hours at a stretch to find relevant information. RSS is an XML based content-syndication protocol that allows web sites to share information as well as aggregate information based upon the users needs (Cold, 2006). In the simplest form, RSS shares the metadata about the content without actually delivering the entire information source. An author might publish the title, description, date and copyrights to anyone that subscribes to the feed. The end user is required to have an application called an aggregator in order to receive the information. By having the RSS aggregator application, end users are not required to visit each site in order to obtain information. From an end user perspective, the RSS technology changes the communication method from a search and discover to a notification model. Users can locate content that is pertinent to their job and subscribe to the communication.
Social Tagging Social tagging describes the collaborative activity of marking shared online content with keywords or tags as a way to organize content for future navigation, filtering or search (Gibson, Teasley, & Yew, 2006). Traditional information architecture utilized a central taxonomy or classification scheme in order to place information into a specific pre-defined bucket or category. The assumption was that trained librarians understood more about information content and context than the average user. While this might have been true for the local library with the utilization of the Dewey Decimal
system, the enormous amount of content on the internet makes this type of system un-manageable. Tagging offers a number of benefits to the end user community. Perhaps the most important feature to the individual is the ability to bookmark the information in a way that is easier for them to recall at a later date. The benefit of this ability on a personal basis is obvious but what about the impact to the community at large. The idea of social tagging is allowing multiple users to tag content in a way that makes sense to them. By combining these tags, users create an environment where the opinions of the majority define the appropriateness of the tags themselves. The act of creating a collection of popular tags is referred to as a folksonomy which is defined as a folk taxonomy of important and emerging content within the user community (Ahn, Davis, Fake, Fox, Furnas, Golder, Marlow, Naaman, & Schachter, 2006). The vocabulary problem is defined by the fact that different users define content in different ways. The disagreement can lead to missed information or inefficient user interactions (Boyd, Davis, Marlow, & Naaman, 2006). One of the best examples of social tagging is Flickr which allows user to upload images and “tag” them with appropriate metadata keywords. Other users, who view your images, can also tag them with their concept of appropriate keywords. After a critical mass has been reached, the resulting tag collection will identify images correctly and without bias.
Mashups: Integrating Information Another Web 2.0 technology describes the efforts around information integration or sometimes referred to as “mashups”. These applications can be combined to deliver additional value that the individual parts could not deliver on their own. One example of mashups is HousingMaps.com that combines the Google mapping application with a real estate listing service on Craiglists. com (Jhingran, 2006). Other examples include
23
Web 2.0
Chicagocrime.org who overlays local crime statistics onto Google Maps so that end users can see what crimes were committed recently in the neighborhood. Another site synchronizes Yahoo! Inc.’s real-time traffic data with Google Maps. Much of the work with web services will enable greater extensions of mashups and combine many different businesses and business models. Organizations, like Amazon and Microsoft are embracing the mash-up movement by offering developers easier access to their data and services. Moreover, they’re programming their services so that more computing tasks such as displaying maps onscreen gets done on the users’ personal computers rather than on their far-flung servers (Hof, 2005).
User Contributed Content One of the basic themes of Web 2.0 is user contributed information. The value derived from the contributed content comes not from a subject matter expert, but rather from individuals whose small contributions add up. One example of user contributed content is the product review systems like Amazon.com and reputation systems used with ebay.com. A common practice of online merchants is to enable their customers to review or to express opinions on the products they have purchased (Hu & Liu, 2004). Online reviews are a major source of information for consumers and demonstrated enormous implications for a wide range of management activities such as brand building, customer acquisition and retention, product development and quality assurance (Hu, Pavlou, & Zhang, 2006). A person’s reputation is a valuable piece of information that can be used when deciding whether or not to interact or do business with. A reputation system is a bi-directional medium where buyers post feedback on sellers and vice versa. For example, eBay buyers voluntarily comment on the quality of service, their satisfaction with the item traded and promptness of shipping.
24
Sellers comment about the prompt payment from buyers or respond to comments left by the buyer (Christodorescu, Ganapathy, Giffin, Kruger, Rubin, & Wang, 2005). Reputation systems may be categorized in three basic types: ranking, rating and collaborative. Ranking systems use quantifiable measures of users’ behavior to generate ratings. Rating systems use explicit evaluations given by users in order to define a measure of interest or trust. Finally, collaborative filtering systems determine the level of relationship between the two individuals before placing a weight on the information. For example, if a user has reviewed similar items in the past, then the relevancy of a new rating will be higher (Davis, Farnham, & Jensen, 2002).
INTEGRATION OF WEB 2.0 INTO ELECTRONIC COMMERCE Earlier in this chapter, we defined the six basic steps of electronic commerce: recognize needs, search for available products, evaluate product alternatives, decide and chose a product, execute transaction and post-purchase activities. Other than the actual transaction, all of these activities can integrate Web 2.0 technologies. For example, a blog could be used as a tool to help users recognize needs and create demand. A blog could also be used to make product announcements of new features, new optionsor new bundling packages. While at the same time, it can help in post-purchase activities by publishing tips and techniques about how-to advice. Integrating Web 2.0 technologies into the various steps would simply reflect the marketing and branding strategy. The goal should be to ensure a common experience across the entire value-chain. The following section will review specific examples of how organizations have completed this integration.
Web 2.0
Examples and Discussion While the model represents an ideal environment, researchers want to see how organizations are actually deploying the web technology and the business value that is delivered. Returning to the six steps of the proposed model, the recognition phase is an ideal phase to leverage Web 2.0 tools within the business to build brand awareness. Twitter is a micro-blogging tool that allows individuals to send broadcast messages to anyone and allows you to follow others who have similar ideas (Kwak, Lee, Park, & Moon, 2010). These messages are limited to 140 characters but do allow organizations to monitor the brand message from their customer base. Companies are using Twitter as a marketing channel, much like an extension to their corporate blogs. They will post about corporate accomplishments and distribute links that take people back to corporate web pages, press releases and other promotional sites. Other organizations are leveraging Facebook and LinkedIn to enhance their branding message. Organizations like AT&T, Coca-Cola and Intel are leveraging social tools in very unique ways. One organization that stands out in the leveraging Web 2.0 technology is the Blendtec organization. Blendtec does a wonderful job at leveraging YouTube to showcase their products quality and strength. YouTube is a Web 2.0 service for sharing videos. The “Will It Blend” marketing program showcases the product blending everything from guns to the iPhone (Blythe & Cairns, 2009). The program is entertaining, innovative as well as informative. All of which make these advertisements some of the most watched videos on the internet. In the search component, we introduced new technologies such as the end user tagging and tag clouds. One organization that is leveraging this technology is Snooth (http://www.snooth.com/) which is a social environment for wine experts. Snooth allows users to tag specific wines with a variety of tags such as fruit, spices, Smokey, bramble fruits, leather, black, cool and menthol.
Users can then click on these tags to view other popular wines with the same tag classification. Tags offer a unique method of locating specific wines that fit the customers taste and preferences. Snooth also utilizes a controlled vocabulary for wine classification to go along with the free form of tags. Here, end users can classify the wines by location, type, color and variety. The evaluation stage allows organizations to integrate Web 2.0 in a variety of ways. Crutchfield (http://www.crutchfield.com) is an electronics retailer that has leveraged the online environment since the 1980’s. Originally a catalog retailer, Crutchfield has moved online and now added several Web 2.0 components to their environment. Each product in the catalog can be rated and commented on by the customer. The company only asks the user to create an account in order to provide the feedback. The end result of this capability is to allow new customers to evaluate products based on these ratings and feedback. The indirect benefit of utilizing this type of technology is to showcase buyer intent. Amazon.com, for example, integrates a feature that utilizes the user behavior. The “Customers also bought” or “Popular Books” leverages the behavior of the customer and in turn utilizes this information to provide another base for evaluation. None of this capability would have been available with just the online catalog a few years ago. The final area reviewed is the support area and like the first area, here also many organizations are leveraging Web 2.0. Dunkin Donuts sells donuts, coffee and other bakery items. The company utilizes Facebook, social applications, iPhone applications, twitter and a variety of other technologies in order to support the customer. The company has also used Facebook to run a sweepstake where the result was to increase their fan base by 800,000. The bottom line for the organization is to create attention, fun and communications with the customer community. Another example is Starbucks which primarily sells coffee around the world. They recently
25
Web 2.0
launched “My Starbucks Idea” which is a Web 2.0 platform that allows customers to present ideas on new products, better service, advertising and customer support. Additionally, customers can vote for and rank ideas. This allows the community to communicate what’s important to them to Starbucks. So far, over 70,000 suggestions have been submitted and the top idea received 95,000 votes and over 1,000 comments. In the end, the company has saved in product development and reduced costs by implementing some of the ideas presented through the social media technology (Bailey & Horvitz, 2010). As described in the background section, more and more organizations are looking toward Web 2.0 to get closer to the consumer and build communities around the product or service. In many enterprises, the customer is confined to a limited role in the process of development, delivery, and innovation of the business model. Businesses no longer have 20 years to manage the growth cycle and lock out competitors due to intellectual property rights. Take the Apple iPhone as an example. Within three weeks of the product’s release, hackers disabled the AT&T network connection requirement and made changes to the hardware so that the iPhone could be connected to any network. Within three months, China was able to produce the MiniOne which worked on any network and could run more applications (Dartford, 2007). Tapscott (2006) indicates that a power shift is underway in which only those organizations that can harness mass collaboration will survive. As these examples showcase, we are moving toward a more open and collaborative electronic commerce environment. In order for businesses to invest the resources in developing social software, the business value must be easily identified. Developing and engaging the community is important but if the result fails to deliver an increased value to the business then resources may have been better served in other areas. Other business models may depend on advertising or click-thru rates which can be greatly enhanced with Web 2.0 tools. Much
26
has been written about viral marketing which is basically any strategy that encourages individuals to pass on a marketing message to others, creating the potential for exponential growth in the message’s exposure and influence. Organizations can leverage this medium to drive their value and brand message to a large number of users fairly quickly. The key here is the ability to tap into the enthusiasm of the consumers so that they are encouraged to become producers. Each of these organizations focused on created communities to enable this synergy which then can be translated into real business value.
CONCLUSION Without a doubt, Web 2.0 technologies will continue to be integrated into the core web application. In 1968, Mel Conway (1968) devised the “Conway Law” which states that the structure of systems will reflect the structure of the organization that develops it. Since the majority of organizations are built under the command and control, centralized and authoritative model, the ability to incorporate collaborative technologies will be limited at best. Integrating these technologies into established business models implies approaching the problem from bottom-up rather than from top to down. The concepts of Electronic Commerce are well over ten years in maturity. While Web 2.0 technologies are still in their infancy, there is still plenty of room for growth. Additionally, we should see the plethora of new technologies and new integration methodologies like web services and cloud computing. Services offered within the Web 2.0 framework are now part of the internet’s evolutionary history. This implies that if a firm wants to be on the internet, it has no choice but to find an appropriate role for these technologies (Benjamin, Birkland, & Wigand, 2008).
Web 2.0
REFERENCES Ahn, L., Davis, M., Fake, C., Fox, K., Furnas, G., Golder, S., et al. Schachter, J. (2006). Why do tagging systems work? Proceedings of the SIGCHI conference on Human Factors in computing systems. Montreal, Canada: The Association of Computing Machinery.
Boyd, D., Davis, M., Marlow, C., & Naaman, M. (2006). Social networks, networking & virtual communities: HT06, tagging paper, taxonomy, Flickr, academic article, to read. Proceedings of the seventeenth conference on Hypertext and hypermedia. Odense, Denmark: The Association of Computing Machinery.
Baoill, A. (2004). Conceptualizing the weblog: Understanding what it is in order to imagine what it can be. Interfacings: Journal of Contemporary Media Studies, 5(2), 1–8.
Brown, P., Farnham, S., & Schwartz, J. (2009). Leveraging social software for strategic social networking and community development at events. Communities and Technologies 2009. University Park, PA: The Pennsylvania State University.
Barnard, L., & Wesson, J. (2004). A trust model for e-commerce in South Africa. Proceedings of the 2004 annual research conference of the South African institute of computer scientists and information technologists on IT research in developing countries. Stellenbosch, Western Cape, South Africa.
Christodorescu, M., Ganapathy, V., Giffin, J., Kruger, L., Rubin, S., & Wang, H. (2005). An auctioning reputation system based on anomaly detection. Proceedings of the 12th ACM conference on Computer and communications security. Alexandria, VA: The Association of Computing Machinery.
Benjamin, R., Birkland, J., & Wigand, R. (2008). Web 2.0 and beyond: Implications for electronic commerce. ICEC 2008. Innsbruck, Austria.
Cold, S. (2006). Using really simple syndication (RSS) to enhance student research. ACM SIGITE Newsletter, 3(1), 6–9. doi:10.1145/1113378.1113379
Berners-Lee, T., Cailliau, R., Luotonen, A., Nielsen, H. F., & Secret, A. (1994). The WorldWide Web. Communications of the ACM, 37(8), 76–82. doi:10.1145/179606.179671 Blood, R. (2004). How blogging software reshapes the online community. Communications of theACM, 47(12), 53–55. doi:10.1145/1035134.1035165 Blythe, M., & Cairns, P. (2009). Critical methods and user generated content: The iPhone on YouTube. Proceedings of the 27th international conference on Human factors in computing systems. Boston, MA: The Association of Computing Machinery.
Conway, M. (1968). How do committees invent? Datamation, 14(4), 28–31. Dartford, M. (2007). China’s iClone. Polar Science, 8(7), 15–16. Davis, J., Farnham, S., & Jensen, C. (2002). Finding others online: Reputation systems for social online spaces. Proceedings of the SIGCHI conference on Human factors in computing systems: Changing our world, changing ourselves. Minneapolis, MN: The Association of Computing Machinery. Forret, M., & Dougherty, T. (2001). Correlates of networking behavior for managerial and professional employees. Group & Organization Management, 26, 283–311. doi:10.1177/1059601101263004
27
Web 2.0
Gibson, F., Teasley, S., & Yew, J. (2006). Learning by tagging: Group knowledge formation in a self-organizing learning community. Proceedings of the 7th international conference on Learning sciences. Bloomington, IA: The Association of Computing Machinery. Hof, R. (2005). Mix, match, and mutate. Business Week Online. Retrieved October 1, 2006, from http://www.businessweek. com/@@76IH*ocQ34AvyQMA/ magazine/ content/05_30/b3944108_mz063.htm.
Laudon, K. C., & Traver, C. G. (2006). E-commerce: Business, technology, society. EnglewoodCliffs, NJ: Prentice-Hall. Lerner, R. (2006). At the forge: Creating mashups. Linux Journal, 147(10). Miller, P. (2005). Web 2.0: Building the new library. Ariadne, 45(1), 5–6. Murugesan, S. (2007). Understanding Web 2.0. IT Professional, 9(4), 34–41. doi:10.1109/ MITP.2007.78
Hu, M., & Liu, B. (2004). Mining and summarizing customer reviews. Proceedings of the 10th Conference on Knowledge Discovery and Data Mining. Seattle, WA: The Association of Computing Machinery.
O’Neill, M. (2005). Automated use of a wiki for collaborative lecture notes. Proceedings of the 36th SIGCSE technical symposium on Computer science education SIGCSE ‘05. St. Louis, MO: The Association of Computing Machinery.
Hu, N., Pavlou, P., & Zhang, J. (2006). Can online reviews reveal a product’s true quality? Empirical findings and analytical modeling of online wordof-mouth communication. Proceedings of the 7th ACM conference on Electronic commerce. Ann Arbor, MI: The Association of Computing Machinery.
O’Reilly, T. (2005). What is Web 2.0: Design patterns and business models for the next generation of software. Retrieved July 17, 2006, from http://www.oreillynet.com/pub/a/oreilly/tim/ news/2005/09/30/what-is-web-20.html
Jhingran, A. (2006). Enterprise information mashups: Integrating information simply. Proceedings of the 32nd International Conference on very Large Data Bases. Seoul, Korea: The Association of Computing Machinery. Kool, D., & Wamelen, J. (2008). Web 2.0: A basis for the second society. Proceedings of the 2nd International Conference on Theory and Practice of Electronic Governance. Cairo, Egypt: The Association of Computing Machinery. Kwak, H., Lee, C., Park, H., & Moon, S. (2010). What is Twitter, a social network or a news media? Proceedings of the 2010 international World Wide Web conference. Raleigh, NC: The Association of Computing Machinery.
28
Osimo, D., & Burgelman, J. (2007). Web 2.0 for e-government: Why and how. 4th Ministerial eGovernment Conference. Lisbon, Portugal: AMA. Reinhold, S. (2006). Wikitrails: Augmenting wiki structure for collaborative, interdisciplinary learning. Proceedings of the 2006 international symposium on Wikis WikiSym ‘06. Odense, Denmark: The Association of Computing Machinery. Riehle, D. (2006). How and why wikipedia works: An interview with Angela Beesley, Elisabeth Bauer, and Kizu Naoko. Proceedings of the 2006 international symposium on Wikis Wiki-Sym ‘06. Odense, Denmark: The Association of Computing Machinery. Schneider, G. (2002). Electronic commerce. Florence, KY: Course Technology.
Web 2.0
Smith, D., & Valdes, R. (2005). Web 2.0: Get ready for the next old thing. Gartner Research Paper. Stamford, CT. Tapscott, D., & Williams, A. (2006). Wikinomics: How mass collaboration changes everything. New York, NY: Penguin Group. Weiss, A. (2005). The power of collective intelligence. netWorker, 9(3), 16–23. doi:10.1145/1086762.1086763
ADDITIONAL READING
Coleman, D., & Levine, S. (2008). Collaboration 2.0: Technology and Best Practices for Successful Collaboration in a Web 2.0 World. Cupertino, CA: Happy About. Farmer, R., & Glass, B. (2010). Building Web Reputation Systems. Sebastopol, CA: O’Reilly Media. Freedman, J., Konwiser, E., Nielsten, E., & Van Ostern, C. (2008). Market Research: Web 1.0 in a Web 2.0 World How can we listen instead of asking questions?Tuck School of Business at Dartmouth—Glassmeyer/McNamee Center for Digital Strategies.
Azua, S. (2009). The Social Factor: Innovate, Ignite, and Win through Mass Collaboration and Social Networking. IN, Lebanon: IBM Press.
Funk, T. (2008). Web 2.0 and Beyond: Understanding the New Online Business Models, Trends, and Technologies. Santa Barbara, CA: Praeger.
Bell, A. (2009). Exploring Web 2.0: Second Generation Interactive Tools - Blogs, Podcasts, Wikis, Networking, Virtual Words, And More. Seattle, WA: Createspace.
Hsieh, M., Kao, Y., & Yuan, S. (2008). Web 2.0 Toolbar: Providing Web 2.0 Services for Existence Web Pages. Asia-Pacific Services Computing Conference, 2008. APSCC ‘08. Yilan, Taiwan: IEEE.
Bernoff, J., & Li, C. (2008). Groundswell: Winning in a World Transformed by Social Technologies. Boston, MA: Harvard Business School Press.
Jones, B. (2007). Web 2.0 Heroes: Interviews with 20 Web 2.0 Influencers. New York, NY: Wiley.
Brown, P., Farnham, S., & Schwartz, J. (2009). Leveraging Social Software for Strategic Social Networking and Community Development at Events. Communities and Technologies 2009. University Park, PA: The Pennsylvania State University. Casarez, V., Cripe, B., Sini, J., & Weckerle, P. (2008). Reshaping Your Business with Web 2.0: Using New Social Technologies to Lead Business Transformation. Columbus, OH: McGraw-Hill Osborne Media. Christakis, N., & Fowler, J. (2009). Connected: The Surprising Power of Our Social Networks and How They Shape Our Lives. New York, NT: Little, Brown & Company.
Kotler, P. (2003). Marketing Management (11th ed.). Englewood cliffs, NJ: Prentice-Hall. McAfee, A. (2009). Enterprise 2.0: New Collaborative Tools for Your Organization’s Toughest Challenges. Boston, MA: Harvard Business School Press. Murugesan, S. (2007). Understanding Web 2.0. IT Professional, 9(4), 34–41. doi:10.1109/ MITP.2007.78 Peilin, W., & Shaohua, H. (2008). Web 2.0 And Social Learning in a Digital Economy. Information and Communication Technologies: From Theory to Applications, 2008. Damascus, Syria: IEEE.
29
Web 2.0
Powell, J. (2008). 33 Million People in the Room: How to Create, Influence, and Run a Successful Business with Social Networking. Upper Saddle River, NJ: Financial Times Press. Shirky, C. (2009). Here Comes Everybody: The Power of Organizing Without Organizations. New York, NY: Penguin Group. Shuen, A. (2008). Web 2.0: A Strategy Guide: Business thinking and strategies behind successful Web 2.0 implementations. Sebastopol, CA: O’Reilly Media. Smith, D. & Valdes, R. (2005). Web 2.0: Get ready for the next old thing. Gartner Research Paper. Stamford, CT. Surowiecki, J. (2005). The Wisdom of Crowds. Harpswell, ME: Anchor. Tapscott, D., & Williams, A. (2006). Wikinomics: How Mass Collaboration Changes Everything. New York, NY: Penguin Group. Teo, T., & Yeong, Y. (2003). Assessing the Consumer Decision Process in the Digital Marketplace. Omega: The International Journal of Management Science, 10(31), 349–363. doi:10.1016/S03050483(03)00055-0 Weiss, A. (2005). The power of collective intelligence. netWorker, 9(3), 16–23. doi:10.1145/1086762.1086763
30
KEY TERMS AND DEFINITIONS Collaboration: Collaboration is a term used to describe technologies that allow multiple individuals to communicate without requiring a physical presence. Their tools differ from Web 2.0 in that they may or may not have social capabilities. Electronic Commerce: Electronic Commerce is the integration of business transactions with the online environment. Reputation Systems: A reputation system leverages the social metadata in order to rank or rate individual value to the network. The idea is that as someone contributes more or produces higher quality information, their reputation is enhanced. Social Networking: A social network is a collection of individuals and the connections between them. These connections create a network of relationships in which value can be found. Taxonomy: Taxonomy is a term used to describe a classification system. Taxonomy is the method of ordering information based on the metadata and correlating relationships. Web 2.0: Web 2.0 is the term used to describe technologies that allow for a many to many conversation in the online environment. That is, many people can create content and many people can consume the information.
31
Chapter 3
Entrepreneurship and Growth in Knowledge Economy Julie Vardhan Manipal University, Dubai
ABSTRACT Come any age, it is the ecclesial and axiomatic belief that the only sustainable resource of comparative or competitive advantage is the knowledge and knowledge applications. In the current scenario, there is growing evidence, interest, and belief that knowledge will provide an unbeatable cutting edge to the entrepreneurs who want to establish and lead their business in this period. The challenge is that the realm and concept of knowledge is still complex, and its transfer and relevance to entrepreneurship is yet to be fully discovered and established. The objective of this chapter is to highlight recent advances in our several understandings of such forces that underpin the creation of knowledge, the iterative knowledge loops, the knowledge economy itself, and the range of technologies used by the entrepreneurs leading towards knowledge diversification, specialization, and optimization resulting into growth of the overall economy. In this chapter, contemporary explanation of growth, knowledge-based growth, and finally, an entrepreneurially driven growth model will be explored. Growth will be researched not only in terms of knowledge economy, but also in terms of knowledge, and economy in specific. Some of the recent knowledge based growth models also focus upon, namely, the effects of innovation in creation of new frontiers and firms, and more specifically, on firms exploiting various web technologies and business frontiers, inter-industry, and cross platform avenues. The chapter conceptually demonstrates the importance of knowledge as driver of growth, and concludes with the entrepreneurial leadership as the locus and paradigm of growth. DOI: 10.4018/978-1-60960-581-0.ch003
Copyright © 2011, IGI Global. Copying or distributing in print or electronic forms without written permission of IGI Global is prohibited.
Entrepreneurship and Growth in Knowledge Economy
INTRODUCTION
BACKGROUND
“That knowledge has become the resource, rather than a resource, is what makes our society postcapitalist.” What Peter Drucker in 1993 said about knowledge is that it is the only reliable source of competitive advantage, holds true and buoyant even in this period of economic downturn. Knowledge should be given a strategic importance by all firms run on entrepreneurial scales. It has been well acknowledged understanding that expanding the level of entrepreneurial activity has increasingly been more important for the economic well being of any country. In the current scenario, there is a growing interest that knowledge may prove to be the cutting edge to the entrepreneurs who want to establish their business in the period of downturn. Yet the realm of knowledge is complex and its relevance to entrepreneurship is yet to be fully developed. In this chapter an attempt has been made to draw on the literature from knowledge, knowledge economy and entrepreneurship and provide an understanding of how knowledge can be considered as the most important resource for entrepreneurs. First the concept of knowledge and entrepreneurship would be reviewed separately and then it would be integrated to come up with the concept of knowledge entrepreneurship towards the growth of the economy. To remain competitive in today’s market it requires rapid response to changes in the market based on sound business decisions. This is a challenge to entrepreneurs, who in this age need to take the help of technology to remain competitive. The main objective of this chapter is hence to highlight the recent advances in our understanding of the forces that underpin the creation of knowledge, the knowledge economy and further development of knowledge by the entrepreneur leading towards growth of the overall economy.
Of Knowledge and Knowledge Economy
32
If we consider the economic evolution over the ages, we can find the civilization beginning with the agriculture based economy. Gradually, it moved up to the industrial age which brought in great shift in the economy with the concepts of mass production, global trading, franchising, branding, customization and so on. With the onset of internet, came the information age, where the clients and customers had easy access to information and knowledge. So it was difficult for any entity to remain isolated from competition. Through evolution, the present age has been rightly called the Knowledge Economy which is about the organizations’ sustainable ability to utilize the readily available resources to create value for the organizations as well as for the society. The rise in information accessibility and technology during the last decade has helped economies move from physical resources towards resources which are knowledge based. But it is not just IT which has helped economies move towards knowledge but also the organization which has adapted more innovative approach towards its gainful processes and through intellectual sprawls. It is much about innovative approaches, investment and excellence through learning and knowledge sharing which has helped in the process of globalization and leading to what we call the Knowledge Economy. And so, the Knowledge Economy is fundamentally different from the preceding Industrial Economy or the Agrarian Economy because its core value is related to bytes, not bits—in the form of customized, applied information or more specifically custom knowledge. With the dramatic increase of available knowledge resources and with almost unlimited capacity of databases (Rifkin, 2000), the critical question has become: what should be selected and what should be ignored which means majority of
Entrepreneurship and Growth in Knowledge Economy
the modern day organizations are operating in a knowledge based economy gaining competitive advantage over each other through knowledge based resources available in common domain.
The Notion of Knowledge The notion of knowledge has attracted numerous definitions, discussions and attributes. At the outset, it needs to be clarified that though knowledge and information may be used interchangeably there is a marked distinction between the effects that information and knowledge casts. While information is relatively readily available, easily codified, transmitted, and received, the custom application of the information by the seeker can be said to constitute knowledge. Knowledge is therefore much more structured information that needs greater efforts to codify, transmit and interpret because part of it is tacit (Polanyi, 1966). The present economy is challenged by lack of custom knowledge along with an overflow of information. The process of selection and reflection is of vital importance to organizations as this would generate the differentiating factor between entrepreneurial successes in Knowledge Economy. As Geiger and Schreyögg (2006) argue, that since this selection will ultimately be inevitable, it is therefore better to manage it in a reflexive manner based on arguments rather than by hidden mechanisms. Seen this way, knowledge management would certainly have to foster the emergence of information and innovation, but would also ensure the quality of the generated knowledge. From the overwhelming stream of information the knowledge should then be structured and codified so as to make it relevant or needed knowledge for the purpose of innovation (Stehr,1994) To sum up these theories, knowledge can be said to be that resource which gathers information, churns them to find the best and the most relevant and needed knowledge and through this lead to innovation. [Information → Knowledge → Innovation]
This brings us to the concept of innovation. “Innovation is the specific tool of entrepreneurs, the means by which they exploit change as an opportunity for different businesses or different services.” This definition of innovation by Drucker (1985) sums up the importance of innovation to entrepreneurship. The knowledge can therefore be said to be the trigger for innovation which is carried on by entrepreneurs. Knowledge can be classified in different ways according to its discourse or application so that we may have social knowledge, scientific knowledge, technical knowledge, entrepreneurial knowledge, tacit knowledge and explicit knowledge. For the purpose of our present study we shall concentrate on entrepreneurial knowledge. Entrepreneurial intention is formed through rational and analytical thinking in social, political and economic contexts and through instinct and holistic thinking based on individual backgrounds, personalities and abilities (Bird, 1988). The entrepreneurial knowledge is a combination of all the inherent knowledge and skills of the entrepreneur along with an enabling environment whereby the entrepreneur is able to seize the business opportunity. Before we delve further into the relationship between knowledge and entrepreneurship we must review in the next section as to who is considered to be the entrepreneur.
How to Define an Entrepreneur? Entrepreneurship is a complex exuberance and entails a wide range of practices and parameters. Some believe that entrepreneurship must involve risk-taking individuals who start new ventures that are innovative and experience rapid growth. Others may only focus on the idea that entrepreneurship is about starting new ventures. We begin with the theory on entrepreneur given by Schumpeter (1942), “The fundamental impulse that sets and keeps the capitalist engine in motion comes from the new consumer goods, the new methods of production or transportation, the new markets….this
33
Entrepreneurship and Growth in Knowledge Economy
process incessantly revolutionizes the economic structure from within, incessantly destroying the old one, incessantly creating a new one”. He called this the ‘creative destruction’ which is a unique attribute of the entrepreneurs who effectively translate ideas and dreams into creation of goods and services to society. Ever since the work of Schumpeter(1934), entrepreneurship has been regarded as a primary channel of economic growth and creation of wealth. Schumpeter considered the entrepreneurs as the main vehicle to move an economy forward from static equilibrium and by inducing processes of creative destruction, challenging existing structures and changing economic equilibrium. While Schumpeter called the entrepreneurs as creating economic disequilibrium, Kirzner (1992) claimed that the entrepreneurs created economic equilibrium by using the resources and his abilities to create the much needed equilibrium in the economy. Knight (1921) proposed the role of the entrepreneur as someone who had the ability to transform uncertainty into a calculable risk. Peter Drucker through his various associations with entrepreneurs, calls the entrepreneurs not as risk takers which is the generally held belief, rather says that they are better decision makers as they know which risks to avoid and which risks to trade-off, and further which risks to buy-in. Lazear (2005) defined the entrepreneur as someone who specializes in taking judgmental decisions about the coordination of scarce resources. In Shane and Venkataraman’s seminal paper (2000, p. 218), entrepreneurship is defined as: “…the nexus of two phenomena: the presence of lucrative opportunities and the presence of enterprising individuals”. Shane and Venkataraman suggest that it comprises the analyses of “how, by whom and with what effects opportunities to produce future goods and services are discovered, evaluated and exploited”. To take the dominant concepts forward from the various definitions of entrepreneurship we can say that they all revolve around the individuals having the ability to identify and exploit oppor-
34
tunities, elicit the required information and use the selected knowledge base to form their own enterprise. Knowledge seems to be one critical underlying determinant of the characteristics of the entrepreneur. We can call the knowledge which is most required by the entrepreneur to achieve his objectives as the “entrepreneurial knowledge”knowledge which is relevant to the functioning of the market forces and the economy, with respect to entrepreneurs’ enterprise. The information is widely available in any given economy, but its proper utilization depends on a large number of macro-micro factors. Taking this institutional aspect one step further, Acs et al. (2004) argue that the exploitation of knowledge depends on the broad spectrum of institutions, rules and regulations, or, in their terminology, on an economy’s knowledge filter. The knowledge filter is the gap between new knowledge and economic knowledge or commercialized knowledge (Arrow, 1962). The greater the knowledge filter, the more pronounced is this creative gap between new knowledge and new economy – crystallizing into what is commercialized/ customized knowledge economy. It can therefore be suggested that entrepreneurs are catalysts building equilibrium in the economy within the time-opportunity-creativity continuum - building a perfect epitome of information and knowledge that has eventually earned them distinction, and helped them in delivering the enablement and creating the value for the total of society and economy, and on occasions to state as well.
THE KNOWLEDGE PROCESSES AND ENTREPRENEURSHIP We shall enumerate upon the studies conducted by selective author gallery on their views on entrepreneurship, and the characteristics of entrepreneurs to understand better entrepreneurship relative to knowledge. Hayek (1949) found that a key feature of market economy is the partitioning of knowledge among individuals. Knowledge plays
Entrepreneurship and Growth in Knowledge Economy
an important role across economic variables and its agents. Hence knowledge constitutes one fundamental source of entrepreneurial opportunity. As mentioned earlier there have been contributions made by Schumpeter in the field of knowledge and entrepreneurship but it can be inferred indirectly. It was Schmitz (1989) who developed a model where an increase in the proportion of entrepreneurship leads to the growth of the economy. Shane and Venkatraman (2000) presented the nexus between opportunity and agency, whereby opportunities are not singular phenomena, but are idiosyncratic to the individual. This means that the individual having unique attributes can take up the process - these unique attributes can then build up the knowledge in the given stream. Since knowledge is the differentiating attribute for entrepreneurs who through their knowledge can create innovative products, ideas, processes or the businesses itself, we can consider the Timmons Model (Timmons, Zacharakis and Spinelli 2004) of entrepreneurship here, according to which an individual having certain characteristics can muster the required resources and the opportunity to create a new venture. Timmons analyzed more than 50 studies on the characteristics of entrepreneurs and found a consensus around the following general characteristics: commitment and leadership, determination, opportunity obsession, tolerance of risk, ambiguity and uncertainty, creativity and innovation, self reliance, ability to adapt, and motivation to excel. The innovation process and the new start ups are all driven by the entrepreneurs. Entrepreneurs introduce new products and newer processes in an economy. In the process, incumbent firms are forced to innovate in order to withstand the pressure generated by new firms. As a result entrepreneurship has a rejuvenating effect on economies. According to this model, the entrepreneur is the locus for creation of wealth in any given society. Over the years, over several years, it results in the growth of the total of society and economy.
The Variables in the Growth Model For the purpose of our deliberations, we consider the Growth Model as given by the Global Entrepreneurship Monitor (GEM) (Bosma and Levie, 2009). The GEM model (Figure 1) is an insightful and comprehensive framework showing the relationship between innovation and entrepreneurship, efficiency enhancers, basic requirements and how these help in creation of new businesses. These new businesses, once established, grow, have more branches, more resources, create more opportunities, more spiraling dependencies and provide more returns which results in growth of the economy. Considering all other variables in the GEM Model as given during a certain time period in an economy, we can see that it would be the entrepreneur who is at the locus for bringing about the change and introducing dynamics of growth through his attitudes, activities and aspirations – given any economy. The motivating factors within more factor-driven economies, where the institutions, infrastructure, basic education and health are the major concerns of the economy, are the entrepreneur’s basic necessity of survival and where entrepreneur is aware of his aspirations and limitations of the economy, and operates much in local economy. The motivating factors within more efficiency driven economies, where better education and training, goods and labor market efficiency, financial market sophistication, technological enablement, enabled export-import regulations, single window clearance systems, R&D transfer, government entrepreneurship programs, commercial and legal infrastructure and institutions are available, are entrepreneurs advanced necessity to excel, and where entrepreneur is aware of greater facilitations and also countering limitations. The challenge entrepreneur lives is inclined more towards state machinery and clauses governing economy and less towards society and state as a whole. On contrast, the innovation driven economies are the best design
35
Entrepreneurship and Growth in Knowledge Economy
Figure 1. The revised GEM model (Source: Bosma and Levie, 2009)
and best configuration of the entire state, societal and economic facilitations to administer, enforce and enable entrepreneurial growth, and where entrepreneurs [for example Google, Apple, MS et al] live in a tradition of abundance and pride, with the necessity to go beyond the horizon, beyond expectations, and the challenge they live is equally inclined towards society, economy and state.
Information Technology and Collaboration – Web 2.0 and Google Perspective The Knowledge Economy marks a profound shift in mass appeal - mass returns whereby customers become collaborators with their trusted partners
36
and with other customers to create experiencerich, money-rich engine. The entrepreneur in this economy must be able to encompass the information that businesses create and apply, as well as the wide spectrum of increasingly convergent and linked technologies that process those experiences and knowledge. Once again, to remain competitive in today’s market it requires rapid response to changes in the market based on sound business decisions. This is the challenge to entrepreneurs. Available information is often concealed, incomplete, inconsistent or out of date. When information is available, it is incessantly difficult to chart and graph key performance indicators for trends, or to drill down and understand what is behind and ahead of those numbers. Finally, it is often a dream to access all information related to one’s
Entrepreneurship and Growth in Knowledge Economy
own domain or access the custom knowledge. The new age technology, Web 2.0 technologies provide solutions to these challenges to the entrepreneur. The importance of information technology as a competitive advantage has rightly been compared to that of Porter’s competitive advantage by Kollmann, T. (2006). According to him, initially it was important for the companies to either focus on quality of the products or price to gain a quality leadership or cost leadership among the competing firms in the market. But in future, the source of competitive advantage would be through having information leadership in terms of better information, better processes to transfer the information and better knowledge to use the information in the most appropriate way. The growing relevance of IT and the expansion of electronic data networks have created a new commercial/ business dimension that can be called the network economy or the Net Economy. Information transfer has become faster with technologies such as the internet/ WWW, mobile telecommunications and interactive television (ITV). If we take the example of Google, the new company in the Knowledge Economy had been started independently, and is an example of an innovative company…how this
ultimately leads to value creation can be shown through figure 2. The term “Web 2.0” is commonly associated with web applications that facilitate interactive contributions to the website’s content, in contrast to websites where users are limited to the passive viewing of information that is provided to them. Examples of Web 2.0 include web-based communities, hosted services, web applications, socialnetworking sites, video-sharing sites, wikis and blogs. Web 2.0 websites allow users to do more than just retrieve information. They can build on the interactive facilities of “Web 1.0” to provide “Network as platform” computing, allowing users to run software-applications entirely through a browser. Users can own the data on a Web 2.0 site and exercise control over that data. The Web 2.0 era is all about services, not only software. Using the web as a platform, Google is among the leaders providing services using Web 2.0 core competencies like AJAX, controlling data sources and online applications. Taking further the example of Google, it can be seen how they have now integrated collaborative web based technol-
Figure 2. Adapted from Kollmann, T. (2006)
37
Entrepreneurship and Growth in Knowledge Economy
ogy to foster innovation and ultimately growth. Some of the services offered by Google are: Google Maps [http://maps.google.com], along with Gmail and Google’s word processing, spreadsheet and calendaring applications are great examples of Rich Internet Applications, another core competency of Web 2.0. The Sidewiki [http://www.google.com/ sidewiki], another of its services can also share entries through the users Google profile, Blogger, Facebook, or Twitter. The free Google Custom Search [http://www. google.com/ cse], launched in October 2006, was “among the top two widgets on the web” The Subscribed Links service [http://www. google.com/coop/subscribedlinks], again only available to signed-in Google account holders, may be one of the most useful of Google’s custom search capabilities. The service appears to be designed for high-volume data providers and for websites whose contents change frequently. With the introduction of iGoogle [http://www. google.com/ig] in May 2005, the whole of the Google experience can be personalized through a portal-based webpage. There are a number interactive applications and blocks of content which can be added. In late 2007, Google began testing a new product with a strong personal and social networking context. Calling it “knol”, a word Google coined to mean “unit of knowledge”, it [http://knol.google. com/k] enables anyone with a Google account to create a webpage on any topic (within the terms of service). The chief differences between writing and editing a Knol page and a Wikipedia one is that Knol offers a better online editor and keeps the author very much in charge of the content. Knol began with what Google calls a “moderated collaboration” With the launch of Google Wave in 2009, it can be the beginning of a convergence of several Google service offerings into a single, unified product and the cross fertilization of other Google services with Wave technology. Various Google Wave developer resources indicate that “Develop38
ers can enhance their existing web applications by embedding Google Wave directly in their application, allowing you to seamlessly integrate communication and collaboration” [http://code. google.com/apis/wave/guide.html]. “Ads by Google” is found on any website whereby revenue can be earned by enabling Google to place contextually targeted ads on their website. Google AdSense also enables companies to advertise to large numbers of internet users using a basic AdWords campaign at an affordable price. This is named as Long Tail effect. Another core competency of a Web 2.0 company is the ability to “harness the collective intelligence”. One way Google does this is through its pagerank search algorithms [http://en.wikipedia. org/wiki/PageRank]. Google determines the true value of a link on the web, through its link structure. It’s not just about a page being there and people clicking on it, it’s about who links to this page and how those sites are useful or related to people. Their approach to pagerank has made Google the top search engine on the web. Another way they harness collective intelligence is through their purchase of Blogger.com. Google owns one of the largest free blogging sites on the internet and it’s well known that blogs help increase a site’s pagerank dramatically. Though Google had been founded as a business founded on searching the web, it is transforming itself into a real time collaborative web experience from any kind of platform. Through its many products and services, Google as a brand is coming to symbolize not just a search experience, but the experience for anyone using the web through any type of online device (Mattison, 2010). Google’s “technological advantage” comes from its incremental innovations, information collection from customers and collaborators, research for the correct processes to be implemented and finally the value addition in terms of the effectiveness of the search engine. Google’s technology has emerged from a series of continuous improvements and continuous outreach in the lives of businesses and people.
Entrepreneurship and Growth in Knowledge Economy
Google as an example also subscribes to the idea of cornucopia - the traditional symbol of abundance, described by Hisrich and Peters (2002). The value and growth begins with the individual entrepreneur and his knowledge in the base technology, the synthesis of the knowledge and social needs, and then ends with products or services available for mass consumption in the marketplace with a ripple effect on regions, then nations and eventually the world economy.
Measuring the Metrics in Knowledge Economy To integrate the concepts of Knowledge with entrepreneurship we can show the relation as given in figure 3. While a number of studies have been conducted from the organization’s point of view showing the utilization of scarce resources by these organizations to create a profitable output, we shall consider the work of Penrose (1959), who considered that internal factors that drive the long-term growth of a firm are assumed to be unutilized resources. Such resources through the entrepreneur’s knowledge can be changed to utilized resources. This again brings us to the concept of entrepreneurship as the characteristics of an individual to create value for the society by exploiting opportunities and utilizing the resources optimally. Knowledge again seems to be the driver for the several characteristics mentioned by Timmons,
Zacharakis and Spinelli (2004), especially to do with opportunity and risk. The entrepreneur faces tons of information – social, economic, commercial and technical. He has to select the required, relevant information to consider the opportunity available to him. According to Knight, the entrepreneur has to deal with uncertainty and only through his knowledge base, he is able to decide upon which areas to take risks, which to avoid and when to evade. With the availability of the new technology, it is again up to the entrepreneur to select the right means to reach his business objective. For the purpose of the present study, we shall take up the Knowledge Economy Index (KEI) as given by the World Bank to understand the correlation between KEI and ICT of UAE, the G7, India and Singapore. As mentioned in the KEI index there are broadly four variables to measure it, namely education, the use of ICT, innovation and institutional and economic regime. The application of knowledge – as manifested in areas such as entrepreneurship and innovation, research & development, software & design, industry and banking and in people’s education and skills levels–is now recognized to be one of the key sources of growth in the global economy. The KEI includes what is known as the four pillars of the Knowledge Economy framework: •
An economic and institutional regime to provide incentives for the efficient use of
Figure 3. Process of Growth in Knowledge Economy
39
Entrepreneurship and Growth in Knowledge Economy
existing and new knowledge and the flourishing of entrepreneurship; An educated and skilled population to create, share, and use knowledge well; An efficient innovation system of firms, research centers, universities, consultants and other organizations to tap into the growing stock of global knowledge, assimilate and adapt it to local needs, and create new technology; Information and communication technology to facilitate the effective creation, dissemination, and processing of information.
• •
•
It was designed by the World Bank for 146 countries to allow for a cross-country comparison on these variables. The variables, both actual and relative have been normalized on a scale of 0 to 10 relative to other countries in the comparison group. As an example we can see in Table 1, the KEI of UAE, the comparison group being all countries. The examples have been taken as representing a country according to the division of the economies by the GEM Model. Thus we have India as a factor driven economy, UAE as an efficiency driven economy and Singapore and G7 representing the innovation driven economies.
Table 1. KEI of UAE. Source: Knowledge Economy Index, 2009, World Bank United Arab Emirates Group: All Countries
S.No.
Index
1.
Knowledge Economy Index (Average of 3, 4, 5, 6)
6.73
2.
Knowledge Index (Average of 4, 5, 6)
6.72
3.
Economic Incentive and Institutional Regime
6.75
4.
Education
4.9
40
5.
Innovation
6.69
6.
ICT
8.59
Further, if we represent graphically (figure 4) the relation between KEI and ICT, it shows how the KEI is related to ICT and conversely how better ICT can generate growth for the whole economy. A comparative table showing the KEI of UAE with G7 countries, Singapore and India has been shown in Table 2, which highlights the challenges ahead for these countries to come to the standards of those of developed countries in the G7. The entrepreneur can take the help of Web 2.0 resources such as weblogs, social networking sites, podcasts, video and VoIP that are enabling real-time, rich interaction among individuals around the world at virtually no cost other than time (assuming computer and access). The advantages to the business would be as follows. 1. It would help in collaborating and streamlining business processes between customers, employees, and partners. The end result is the availability of many new applications that manipulate and deliver previously unavailable data and trends. No longer confined to the desktop, these web-based applications are available from any browser equipped computer. 2. Enable secure and remote access from anywhere with an internet connection so that there would be low software costs and little to no set-up cost. 3. Would have the flexibility of dynamic user interfaces and enhancing value. Google is the premier example of this approach. Every user who follows a Google search to a website refines the pagerank search process to provide more accurate search results for the next user. Amazon encourages customers to write online reviews of its products. All these companies have used the collaborative web in making the users active participants which adds value and credibility to the company or researcher.
Entrepreneurship and Growth in Knowledge Economy
Figure 4. KEI and ICT Index comparison of 4 countries
Table 2. Comparative KEI of UAE with G7 countries, Singapore and India. Source: Knowledge Economy Index, 2009, World Bank KEI
Economic
Innovation
Education
ICT
Country
recent
1995
recent
1995
recent
1995
recent
1995
recent
1995
G7
8.72
9.12
8.15
8.82
9.19
9.3
8.75
9.13
8.8
9.22
Singapore
8.44
8.49
9.68
9.67
9.58
9.05
5.29
6.23
9.22
9
UAE
6.73
6.48
6.75
7.46
6.69
6.59
4.9
4.27
8.59
7.62
India
3.09
3.56
3.5
3.47
4.15
3.7
2.21
2.56
2.49
4.5
4. Social Networking sites like LinkedIn offer services that allow users to build personal profiles and create contact lists. Users can then enter the names of people they wish to contact and the software looks for relationship chains linking them to their targets. This allows users to leverage the power of personal relationships to meet potential customers or partners. 5. Blogs allow business executives to create direct channels of communication with customers, employees and partners. Most of the well known companies and their senior managers have their own blogs. 6. Wikis support online communities and teams, allowing all members to create, edit and access information on topics of interest. Wikipedia, an online encyclopedia, allows content to be added or edited by any registered user.
Effective collaboration with customers, employees, and partners provides 360-degree visibility, allowing an organization to see what is happening along the entire value chain. Customers provide valuable information on their needs and how well products and services meet End User requirements. Employees and partners provide information that supports improved business processes. Web 2.0 technologies support deeper collaboration, and thus better information gathering, than ever before possible. Entrepreneurs succeed better in this technology enabled environment. Sustainable Development can be made by countries that can be equated with entrepreneurial entities by pursuing coherent strategic approaches to building their country’s capabilities to create, access, and use intellectual and technological capital as characterized by the Knowledge Economy. The Challenge Lives for the Entrepreneur!
41
Entrepreneurship and Growth in Knowledge Economy
CONCLUSION An intelligent entrepreneur equipped with relevant technological infrastructure, methodologies and applications know-how will help himself in identifying, assembling the right processes, and the right people across the globe to overcome any business challenge and set sail on the opportunities. This chapter attempts to bring out conceptually the relationship between information, knowledge, technology, innovation, new ventures and how all of these through the drive and insight of the entrepreneurs bring about growth and creation of wealth. The information sharing, interoperability, user-centered design, and collaboration on the world wide web are hallmarks of technology leverage. The exploration of these interdependent variables of knowledge and entrepreneurship in this chapter is expected to provide a better understanding of the role of technology, information and knowledge in the knowledge economy leading to competitive advantages attributable to entrepreneurs and beneficial interests enjoyed by its potential clients and society as a lasting beneficiary. This is unequivocally supported by the KEI parameters. The importance of knowledge to entrepreneurship and to the knowledge economy is only an attempt to relate these and various concepts to each other and accelerate the beneficial results for the society, economy and state as a whole. Multilateral efforts, governments at all levels, legislation and industry platforms are foundations to these entrepreneurial enterprises and in the context of entrepreneurial Knowledge Economy.
Limitations and Future Research Directions The burgeoning agenda among thinkers and policy makers related to knowledge generation, its funding, research and development and commercialization leading to the benefit of entrepreneurs
42
is confirmed by the fact to enact and establish a number of legislations and institutions which are in force and operating as of today, the world around. While the subject is of living importance, for the present study the scope excluded statistical research and analyses of secondary resources between economies and economic variables and, at times, may not endorse the strict assumptions or representation of the published literature. The discussion on the dependent or interdependent variables of knowledge and entrepreneurship in this chapter is expected to provide a better understanding of the role of knowledge in the knowledge economy leading to comparative or competitive advantages attributable to entrepreneurs. It does seem to be a promising endeavor to further explore the challenge through future research on each of the variables. The future research should be based on, governmental and multi lateral bodies statements, industry forum statements, ministerial programs, statistics, computing methods et al. It should be based on larger audience and larger cross reference of the materials on the entrepreneurship and technology, and illustrating how mutual benefits [among entrepreneurs, industry, governments, and society in general] could be translated into policy and framework agreements for the well being of all entities.
REFERENCES Acs, Z., & Audretsch, D. (Eds.). (2003). Handbook of entrepreneurship research: An interdisciplinary survey and introduction. Boston, MA/ Dordrecht, The Netherlands/ London, UK: Kluwer Academic Publishers. Arrow, K. (1962). Economic welfare and the allocation of resources for invention. In Nelson, R. (Ed.), The rate and direction of inventive activity. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.
Entrepreneurship and Growth in Knowledge Economy
Bird, B. J., & Jelinek, M. (1988). The operation of entrepreneurial intentions. Entrepreneurship Theory & Practice, 13(2), 21–29. Bosma, N., & Levie, J. (2009). 2009 executive report. Global Entrepreneurship Monitor. Retrieved July 21, 2010, from http://www.gemconsortium. org/download/1279710182340/ GEM%20 2009%20Global%20Report%20Rev%20140410. pdf Drucker, P. (1985). Innovation and entrepreneurship: Practice and principles. New York, NY: Harper & Row. Drucker, P. (1993). Post-capitalist society. Geiger, D., & Schreyögg, G. (2006). Coping with the concept of knowledge: Toward a discursive understanding of knowledge. In Baum, J. R., Frese, M., & Baron, R. A. (Eds.), The psychology of entrepreneurship. Psychology Press. Hayek, F. A. (1949). Individualism and economic order. London, UK: Routledge & Kegan Paul. Hisrich, R., & Peters, M.P. (2002). Entrepreneurship (5th ed.). New Delhi: McGraw-Hill Publishing. Kirzner, I. (1973). Competition and entrepreneurship. Chicago, IL: University of Chicago Press. Kirzner, I. (1992). The meaning of the market process. London, UK: Routledge. Knight, F. (1921). Risk, uncertainty and profit. Boston, MA: Houghton Mifflin. Kollmann, T. (2006). What is e-entrepreneurship? – Fundamentals of company founding in the net economy. International Journal of Technology Management, 33(4), 322–340. doi:10.1504/ IJTM.2006.009247 Lazear, E. P. (2005). Entrepreneurship. Journal of Labor Economics, 23, 649–680. doi:10.1086/491605
Mattison, D. (2010). Time, space, and Google. Searcher, 18(4), 20–31. Polanyi, M. (1966). The tacit dimension. New York, NY: Doubleday. Rifkin, J. (2000). The age of access: The new culture of hypercapitalism, where all of life is a paid-for experience. The Putnam Publishing Group. Schmitz, J. (1989). Imitation, entrepreneurship, and long-run growth. The Journal of Political Economy, 97, 721–739. doi:10.1086/261624 Schumpeter, J. (1911/34). The theory of economic development. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press. Schumpeter, J. (1942). Capitalism, socialism and democracy. New York, NY: Harper and Row. Schumpeter, J. (1947). The creative response in economic history. The Journal of Economic History, 149–159. Shane, S., & Venkataraman, S. (2000). The promise of entrepreneurship as a field of research. Academy of Management Review, 25, 217–226. doi:10.2307/259271 Stehr, N. (1994). Knowledge societies. Sage Publications. Timmons, J. A., Zacharakis, A., & Spinelli, S. (2004). Business plans that work: A guide for small business. McGraw Hill.
ADDITIONAL READING Acs, Z. (1996). Small Firms and Economic Growth. In Acs, Z., Carlsson, B., & Thurik, R. (Eds.), Small Business in the Modern Economy. Oxford: Blackwell Publishers.
43
Entrepreneurship and Growth in Knowledge Economy
Audretsch, D., Keilbach, M., & Lehmann, E. (2006). Entrepreneurship and Economic Growth. New York: Oxford University Press. doi:10.1093/ acprof:oso/9780195183511.001.0001 Baumol, W. (1968). Entrepreneurship in Economic Theory. The American Economic Review, 64–71. Baumol, W. (1990). Entrepreneurship: Productive, Unproductive and Destructive. The Journal of Political Economy, 893–921. doi:10.1086/261712 Bessant, J., & Tidd, J. (2007). Innovation and Entrepreneurship. England: John Wiley and Sons Ltd. Brown, T. E., & Ulijn, J. M. (2004). Innovation, entrepreneurship and culture: the interaction between technology, progress and economic growth. Cheltenham, UK; Northampton, Mass., USA: E. Elgar Pub. Casson, M. (2002). The Entrepreneur: An Economic Theory. Northampton, MA: Edward Elgar. Entrepreneurship in American Higher education, a report from the Kauffmann Panel on Entrepreneurship curriculum in Higher Education. Retrieved July 21, 2010 from http://www.kauffman.org/ uploadedfiles/entrep_high_ed_report.pdf Ferreira, J. J., Marques, C. S., & Fernandes, C. (2010). Decision-Making for location of new Knowledge intensive businesses on ICT sector: Portuguese evidences. International Journal of E-Entrepreneurship and Innovation, 1(1), 60–82. doi:10.4018/jeei.2010010104 Gibb, A. (2002). In Pursuit of a New ‘Enterprise’ and ‘Entrepreneurship’ Paradigm for Learning: Creative Destruction, New Values, New Ways of Doing Things and New Combinations of Knowledge. International Journal of Management Reviews, 4, 213–231. doi:10.1111/1468-2370.00086 http://www.e2conf.com/downloads/whitepapers/ ent2-10_TWwhitepaper.pdf
44
http://www.entrepreneur.com/magazine/entrepreneur/2007/february/173496-2.html http://www.gemconsortium.org/national_reports. aspx McClelland, D. (1961). The Achieving Society. New York: Free Press. McDonald, R. E. (2002). Knowledge entrepreneurship: linking organisational learning and innovation. University of Connecticut. Porter, M. (1990). The Competitive Advantage of Nations. New York: The Free Press. Senge, P. (1993). The fifth discipline. London: Random House. Sternberg, R. J. (2004). Successful Intelligence as a Basis for Entrepreneurship. Journal of Business Venturing, 189–201. doi:10.1016/S08839026(03)00006-5 The Entrepreneur’s Guide to Web 2.0: Top 25 Applications http://www.avivadirectory.com/ entrepreneur-apps/ Tywoniak, S. A. Knowledge in Four Deformation Dimensions. Retrieved from http://org.sagepub. com/cgi/content/refs/14/1/53 Vardhan, J. (2010). Entrepreneurial Spirit and Innovative Culture: Drivers for Creation of Wealth. Paper presented at the 4th Middle East Quality Congress, Dubai. Web 2.0 and Entrepreneurs Source: http:// en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Web_2.0 Websites of Universities and Institutions of Higher Education: www.worldbank.org/kam
Section 2
Collaborative Applications in Business
OVERVIEW While it is nearly impossible to outline the complete usage and implications of the web in its current form, given the degree of diversity and complexity of usage of web, it is very interesting to see completely new and uncharted territories of web based applications and their impact on business. As there are and could be very many implications of business web, this section of the book tends to outline the collaborative applications of the current form of web, which also provides a brief peek into the future growth and directions of development of the next generation of web. The following set of seven chapters is a distillate of experience of the authors, in their respective fields, which is as diverse as journalism to bioinformatics to petro chemical industry. The first chapter although set in the Indian context by Saayan Chattopadhyay on collaborative usage of web in journalism, provides a global perspective on the emergence of a collaborative web based platform that embraces participatory, networked, hyper-mediated journalism. What Saayan argues is that as social dynamics of journalism is changing, the newer aspects of web technology are actively fostering collaborative journalism. Indeed, we are all aware of the usage of popular social sites like Twitter being actively used by news networks and TV anchors to drive what is being often being called “citizen journalism”. The second chapter in this section, authored by Eva Söderström and Jesper Holgersson illustrates a case study on E Services and on how new technological advancements and collaborative phenomena, primarily virtual communities, can be used as a main source of eliciting end user requirements. The authors analyze the data through a robust methodology which shows that end user requirements can be effectively elicited using internet and web based tools as illustrated in this chapter. The third chapter by Shailendra Singh and Amardeep Singh comes from a new emergent industry of Bio- informatics as compared to the previous few. The chapter outlines the details of Bio- informatics
industry, usage of various web based tools that are typically used for this industry. The chapter illustrates a case study to show case the usage of these tools in this industry. What makes this chapter interesting is the fact that an industry so much dependent on constant research, is able to collaborate in research using web based tools and also there is huge potential of utilizing the web based tools in this industry across geographies and diversity. The fourth chapter in this section by Nikhil Chaturvedi, provides a perspective of not only the petroleum and mining industry and potential of internet in this traditional industry, but also points out the huge potential of collaboration of the supply chain across this industry. What Nikhil is able to point out in this chapter, is that leading organizations in this industry like petroleum super-majors and large mining companies have already started utilizing web for some near real-time and batch-mode interaction with the external entities. Nikhil goes on to point out that the collaborative web has tremendous potential to further enhance the operational efficiencies in this industry, even though the actual usage of web at this stage is very nascent. The next chapter by Z. Andreopoulou, T. Koutroumanidis and B. Manos comes from a completely different background and geography. The authors have created an interesting scenario of adopting ecommerce in a rural background. Indeed, since the sector of rural production holds difficulties while adopting e-commerce models, the authors’ aim of this chapter is to present a methodology aiming to optimize the conceptual content model used in collaborative e-commerce websites promoting rural production. Interestingly, we editors found a striking similarity in the pattern of usage of internet usage in the rural back ground in India. There has been a significant case of usage of the concept of e-commerce in rural scenario as illustrated by the “e-Choupal” concept pioneered by company ITC. The case study illustrated by Prof C K Prahalad points out in “Fortune at the Base of the Pyramid”: ‘The e-Choupals, information centers containing a computer linked to the Internet, represent an approach to seamlessly connect subsistence farmers with large firms, current agricultural research, and global markets.’ Sixth chapter in the bouquet of interesting chapters illustrating the usage of web in the diverse business scenarios paints the picture of another country Turkey, of usage of online grocery system in the city of Istanbul. In fact, this chapter by the authors Ronan de Kervenoael, Burcin Bozkaya, Mark Palmer shows the typical issues and concern that arise in the implementation online grocery system. The chapter illustrates the different patterns of resistance facing and deployed by online retailers, logistic firms and urban planners, in the case of online grocery logistic within an emerging market metropolis like Istanbul, and the role they play in supporting and preventing collaboration. Authors tend to prove that online practices in retail business like grocery in the emerging large scale metropolis like Istanbul, still have difficulty achieving the potential objectives, since the last mile digital revolution leading to multi-actor integration and multi-product sourcing provision in supply chain management (SCM) will take a significant amount of time to become a reality. The last chapter in this series by Florian Birke, Maximilian Witt and Susanne Robra-Bissantz from Germany, provides the next dimension of the web utilization, which is across companies and product and service value chains in terms of increased innovation potential. This is a unique research by the authors, where in they have deduced that utilization of gaming theories is a very powerful tool to increase collaboration and increase innovations in the online world of competitions. The authors argue that with online sites like Wikipedia, it is increasingly plausible to explore one possible approach to transfer the positive motivational effect of games to idea competitions. The authors have corroborated their thoughts with a detailed studies of 18 cases and three interviews, that this study demonstrates the actual occurrence of game mechanisms and their effect on the motivation of participants in online competitions and chances
of organization to utilize these results to achieve much greater success in their employee collaborations and innovation results within and across the organizations with their end users and consumers. The critical aspect of why we editors chose the above chapters in this section was an attempt to showcase, a very diverse emergent pattern of usage of web in different industries. What was clearly visible is that firstly across all industries, practitioners and academicians are trying different ways to use web to improve their business efficiencies through multi– stakeholder’s collaboration. Although it is visible that the benefits due to collaborative web are not commensurate in the brick mortar industries due to last mile issues or depth penetration of internet in those industries, as compared to more information based industries, there is still a large scale usage across all sectors. Additionally, the section illustrate that there is a very positive pattern of usage of collaborative web in newer economies like Turkey, Greece and India apart from developed nations like Sweden.
48
Chapter 4
Collaborative Journalism: Networks, News Media and the Public Sphere Saayan Chattopadhyay University of Calcutta, India
ABSTRACT Journalists’ responsibility has an intrinsic relation with the economic and socio-political institutions within which they work. To bring the notion of collaboration into the discussion of journalism and news media organization— irrespective of whether it is technological or social— would thus broaden its conventional intention of studying the social dynamics by which news is produced within key social institutions, and ultimately to propose a method for correlating the changing facets due to collaborative Web with established theories of the relationship between discourse, professional practices, and economic endeavors. What this chapter argues is that collaboration does not hinge only between a professional and an amateur, or trained reporters and common citizens, or perhaps more commonly, different kinds of media; rather, it is a much greater transformation since it is a collaboration between society and technology with its palpable economic implications. In this context, this chapter attempts to understand the emergence of “network entrepreneur” and his/her engagement with the multiple discursive and institutional networks. By referring to various mainstream and alternative news media organizations in India and beyond, this chapter questions in what way news media and journalistic practices are reconfiguring to accommodate a more collaborative platform that embraces participatory, networked, hypermediated journalism. DOI: 10.4018/978-1-60960-581-0.ch004
Copyright © 2011, IGI Global. Copying or distributing in print or electronic forms without written permission of IGI Global is prohibited.
Collaborative Journalism
INTRODUCTION In the past decade and a half, we have begun to witness a radical change in the organization of information production. Enabled by technological change, we are beginning to see a series of economic, social, and cultural adaptations that make possible a fundamental transformation of how one constitutes the information environment one occupies as autonomous individuals, citizens, and members of cultural and social groups. A string of changes in the technology, economic organization, and social practices of production within this environment has created emerging opportunities for how we produce, disseminate and exchange information, knowledge, and culture. The transformation brought about by the collaborative networked information environment is deep-seated that brings fundamental structural changes. It points to the very basis of how liberal markets and liberal democracies have coevolved for almost two centuries. At present there are more than 60,000 titles registered as newspapers in India; almost 9,000 of these are being published on a regular basis. Besides, there are more than one hundred national television channels and hundreds of local channels, as well as large number of private radio stations especially in the metros (Audit Bureau of Circulation, 2006). Parallel to this, within the ambit of what is popularly known as “new media” there is consistent development that presently rivals the traditional media segments as well. Most of the established media organizations have already stepped in to the new media sector, with web and mobile services. Websites like indiatimes. com, manoramaonline.com, hindutantimes.com, rediff.com, in.com, merinews.com, oneindia.in, sulekha.com have created a niche for themselves. Indian media have outperformed the overall Indian economy; they are expected to be over US$18.6 billion by 2010. Nonetheless, in keeping with the corporatization of journalism, web journalism in India has essentially become an
extension of the already established news media business, predominantly producing, among other things, market-friendly soft stories and popular syndicated content. However, disagreements continue to unfold regarding which website deserves to be acknowledged as news website, with different interested parties each staking their respective claim. This controversy stems primarily from disagreements over how best to define what constitutes a news site as distinct from other related types of sites. Much of the early, experimental work was conducted by newspaper companies placing their news reports online, thereby blurring – some might say remediating – traditional categories. Somewhat crudely, I suggest that Indian news media sites can be categorized into four different groups. The first group consists of the sites that are primarily Web extensions of the existing print media publication or news agencies: timesofindia. com, manoramaonline.com, hindustantimes.com, hinduonnet.com, indianexpress.com, tehelka. com and ptinews.com. The second comprises sites that are similar extensions of the recognized news broadcast media: ibnlive.in.com, ndtv.com, timesnow.tv, zeenews.com and aajtak.com. The third is the purely online news sites, which, besides Google and Yahoo! India news services, include merinews.com, india-newsbehindnews.com, indiatogether.com and indianews.net. The fourth is the news portals, which are relatively popular in terms of traffic ranking: rediff.com, indiatimes. com, sify.com, oneindia.in, 123india.com and so on (Chattopadhyay, 2010, p. 293). Within this perspective, in this chapter I examine a particular intersection of the emerging collaborative practices within the domain of web journalism and the more pervasive changes being perceptible in socio-economic sphere. These changes have most visibly affected the journalistic practices or the production of news both by individuals and by cooperative efforts in a wide range of loosely or tightly woven collaborations. However, the social significance of such col-
49
Collaborative Journalism
laborative engagement and its allied economic consequence can never be overemphasized. In this changing scenario, this chapter questions the predominant world view that predictably and rigidly disassociates the natural/social from the technical; and the individual from the technology. New media do not just provide a new voice; rather, they provide the ability to fabricate new linkages of institutions, individuals and machines. These new linkages can be witnessed across the domain of online journalism, in the open source community and in a variety of other collaborative journalistic practices as well. What this chapter seeks to argue is that the notion of collaboration does not hinge only between a professional and an amateur, or trained reporters and common citizens, or perhaps more commonly, different kinds of media— rather it is a much greater transformation since it is a collaboration between society and technology with its palpable economic implications. As the networks become “simultaneously real, like nature, narrated, like discourse, and collective, like society” (Latour, 1993, p.6); and the human beings emerge as “Homo Sapiens Technologicus”, the collaboration entails far reaching implications that not only questions the given categories of modernity but also reconstitute them. Hence, it is not only individualistic isolated communicative nodes rather a complex negotiation of linkages that engenders the hybridity of this medium and calls for new practices, strategies and patterns.
COLLABORATION FOR A NEW PUBLIC SPHERE? Jürgen Habermas introduced the concept of the public sphere as a sphere which mediates between society and state, where the public organizes itself as the bearer of public opinion, accords with the principle of the public sphere – which once had to be fought for against the arcane policies of monarchies and which since that time has made possible the democratic control of state activities
50
(Habermas, 1989, p.136). It is first of all a realm of our social life in which something approaching public opinion can be formed. Access is guaranteed to all citizens. A portion of the public sphere comes into being in every conversation in which private individuals assemble to form a public body (Ibid.). He also contended that this bourgeois public sphere went into decline after the consolidation of the bourgeois hegemony. However, the scholar chiefly credited for introducing the “public sphere” notion into the media debate was Nicholas Garnham. He suggested that a market allocation of cultural resources, combined with the destruction of public service media, threatened “public communication”, which he argued, lay at the heart of the democratic process (Garnham, 1986, p.37). Garnham pointed to a string of negatives associated with this process of commercialization, namely, a growing focus on privatized domestic consumption built around the television set, the creation of “information rich” and “information poor” sectors and the replacement of “national” cultural spheres with an international media market (p.38). Certainly, Habermas like Garnham and other cultural interventionists were deeply concerned at the growing commercialization of the media; hence naturally, at heart, the “public sphere” issue seems to be about creating alternatives to one-dimensional, narrowed, manipulated or closed communication. It is important to note, the two crucial shifts that mark the most advanced economies of the world today. The first shift, is towards an economy centered on information— that includes financial services, accounting, software, science and news— and cultural, comprising of films, music production and also news. The second move is towards a communication environment built on inexpensive processors with high computation capabilities, interconnected in a pervasive network—the phenomenon we associate with the Internet. The collaborative environment, which seems to be the center of new practices, strategies and patterns for news media organizations,
Collaborative Journalism
is only possible because of these shifts. And echoing Benkler, I assume that it fundamentally reshaped the notion of public sphere: “from the mass-mediated public sphere to a networked public sphere” (Benkler, 2006, p.10). Although, whether it offers a “platform for better democratic participation; as a medium to foster a more critical and self-reflective culture” (Ibid., p.2) is a position that I may find difficult to concur. However what is more crucial for this study is to identify the very ambivalent nature of this collaborative environment. On one hand, the linkages of various communicative nodes are much more perceptible in the domain of news media on the web; on the other hand, these nodes remain as individualistic and as discrete as possible. For instance if we consider the citizen journalism section in Indian news websites like ibnlive.in or merinews.com the reports, photos and videos come from locations which are generally known, if not the hometown of that particular citizen reporter. What he reports is something that he personally finds interesting or amusing, which is directly opposite to the “assignments” that the professional journalist are assigned to cover. It is his “private”, personal involvement to something or some event that— if he finds the opportunity— he attempts to make “public”. Similarly, the controversy involving an Indian Minister of State and an active Twitter user, who ran into trouble for a message he posted on the social networking site in which he commented sarcastically in response to a query “tweet” from a journalist, points to this very aspect. The minister’s remark was meant as a humorous private and personal reply, as he himself mentioned later, but the underlying reason for the political commotion ensuing from his “tweet” was the clear and rigid distinction between the public and the private, that the minister’s comment somewhat deviated. What I wish to suggest is that although the technology is increasingly adapting to the collaborative, participatory environment but the collaboration between the public and the private remains distant. Such collaboration would entail
a breakdown of these distinctions and perhaps while attempting to create a new public sphere we might have ended up creating a new private sphere.
JOURNALISM 2.0: NEW PRACTICES, STRATEGIES AND PATTERNS Irrespective of whether it is a new public sphere or a private sphere, the notion of collaboration undeniably remains at the heart of the debate regarding the possibilities of new technologies, particularly the web, to facilitate new forms of participation in economic and public life, to reform political debate and citizenship and to rekindle the institutions of democracy. Although, since the inception of the internet the utopian visions of the internet was instrumental in this sense of optimism centered on participation and politics. But it has been reinvigorated recently through the discussion around, what is popularly being termed as Web 2.0. In this post-broadcast, digital collaborative media era, the notions of journalism and journalists are also transformed - defined by new alignments of productive and distributive power and media consumption and use; hence, necessitating, perhaps too admiringly, an expression: “Journalism 2.0”. The term obviously connotes a sense of “up gradation” from the older practices and concepts. Then what are the transformations brought about through this new-fangled practices of journalism? Certainly there are some structural changes, which have affected the patterns of the news media organizations in the twenty-first century. To what the extent print/broadcast and web journalism should be integrated continued to be at the center of industry discussions all through the late 1990s and into the new millennium. The rising influence of the web on national news reporting and the continuing pressure online technologies brought to bear on newsroom operations compelled more newspapers to mull over how to best integrate their print newspaper and online news services
51
Collaborative Journalism
(Compton, 2010; Allan, 2006; Noack, 1998,). Here it is imperative to recollect how in the last few years almost all the established print and broadcast news media organizations in India have integrated new web based content and services ranging from microblogging, “citizen reporting” sections and the option of commenting on the reported stories by readers in their sites. Indeed, it was becoming increasingly evident that the success of the typically smaller online operations was necessarily dependent on tapping the talents and newsgathering resources of the vastly larger print newsroom (Paul, 2000). Perhaps that is why, even small and mid segment local newspapers in India, like Aajkaal or Sangbad Pratidin in Bengali language also have their own websites; and which is usually available in vernacular languages. However, in developed countries, after some experimenting, newspapers that had established stand-alone new media divisions began reversing course and looking to integrate their online section with the mainstream, offline news section. In 2008, Gannett Co., a leading international news and information company that publishes 85 daily newspapers in the USA, including USA Today, acquired Ripple6, Inc., a leading provider of social media services and went through a restructuring of its business and subsequently in 2009 Gannett’s online network, ended up with more than 100 digital communities and a combined reach of approximately 25 million people that amounted to ten percent of its revenues (Connell, 2008). There exist a considerable number of approaches to the study of the necessity for collaboration between the online and offline news media. In their research on managing emerging technologies, Day and Schoemaker (2000) found that one of the fundamental mistakes that companies make when establishing an innovative venture, like launching a news site, is to ignore the connections and possible collaboration between it and the existing parent operation. Clark (2001) and Zollman (2000) asserted that integration or collaboration offers synergies that facilitate marketing and financial
52
advantages other than assisting in improved journalistic practices. However, such collaboration entails, as I have earlier mentioned, certain structural changes; but what are the stages through which these structural changes are initiated in the news media organizations? Drawing upon Everett M. Rogers’ influential scholarship on diffusion of innovations, Lawson-Borders applied it to study media organizations and new technology, while developing the following trajectory: the first stage, known as the “agenda-setting” points to the early period, when media companies recognized the implications of the Internet and the growth of the personal computer; the second stage, designated as “matching” refers to the consequent formation of online divisions to exploit the potential of the world wide communication network; the third stage, “redefining/restructuring” refers to the infamous dot.com “bust” in early 2000, when web media organizations retrenched and economized online resources; and the fourth stage, “clarifying”, points to the growing importance of “convergence,” as journalists start being familiar with delivering news through multiple new media technologies. In the fifth stage, known as “routinizing”, which is particularly pertinent for this study, the innovation becomes an ongoing part of the organization’s activities. Finally, the fifth stage is “still unfolding for media organizations as they deliberate over strategies and best practices to propel the organizations into the future” (Lawson-Borders, 2003, p.93). What kinds of emerging strategies and practices are we witnessing? The notion of journalism 2.0 sees the Internet as allowing enthusiastic communities and individuals to come together and provide more value for a given news and information site. Here I hasten to remind that the initial reports of 26/11 Mumbai terrorist attack first came through social networking sites and blogs. Mere moments after the first shots were fired, Twitter users in India and particularly in Mumbai were delivering almost instant eyewitness accounts of the situation. Furthermore, it is suspected that at
Collaborative Journalism
the height of the Mumbai terrorist attacks, the Indian government attempted to shutdown the Twitter stream people were using to disseminate news and information, amid fears that it could be used by the terrorists to help them evade capture (Beaumont, 2008). I am not, of course, suggesting that Twitter, Facebook Myspace and other social media are in a position to replace the mainstream news media yet; however, there can be little doubt that they offer a potent collaborative communication platform that is emerging even in a developing nation like India. An analogous emerging practice is “crowdsourcing” that effectively demonstrates how a large group of unpaid, non-professional but committed individuals can outperform a small group of experienced and paid professionals. Crowdsourcing is a relatively new term, coined by Jeff Howe in a 2006 article for Wired News. It is quite similar to “distributed,” “collaborative” or “open-source” reporting and many scholars and professionals use the terms interchangeably. It is often referred as “pro-am journalism” a portmanteau of “professional” and “amateur”. The focus of crowdsourcing is usually ongoing production of information while distributed reporting or “opensource” reporting relates more closely to a specific and fixed-time project, such as responding to a specific query or reporting on a specific subject. The online version of Encyclopedia Britannica, for example, cannot keep up with Wikipedia in terms of updating articles and information. And Microsoft, with all its resources, has struggled to keep pace with the development of the Firefox browser, a project powered by volunteers collaborating together under the nonprofit Mozilla Foundation (Briggs, 2007, p.47). Rediff.com, like “Yahoo Answers” includes a specific link “ask users” with every news story, where the reader can ask any question related to the article or otherwise to other users of the site who may provide the answer. And not to mention, most of the websites of established Indian news media
organizations include citizen report sections that in effect depends on crowdsourcing. The practice of news reporting has adapted and changed significantly to make use of the possibilities of the new media environment. For instance, the notion of “micro-reporting”, sometimes also referred as “hyper-local” reporting takes into consideration events and developments normally neglected by mainstream media. Hence, the news and information pertaining to small towns and remote locales, which hitherto did not receive adequate coverage, are being reported on a regular basis. Likewise, the notion of distributed reporting is a form of transparency for a news organization. Traditionally, readers learn about stories a news organization is working on only when the articles are finished and published. “While it is customary to keep a story idea secret to prevent the competition from running with the idea, the distributed reporting model requires a news organization to go public with a story idea early in the reporting process. The reason? To allow readers to assist in the reporting of the story” (Briggs, 2007, p.48). In addition, the nature of the news story has changed considerably beyond the “push-pull” concern of the early online reporting. Instead of being a singular article, the news story, nowadays, has become a thread that involves multiple authors often yielding multiple related articles. The readers are actively involved even before the publication of a particular news report, as they ask questions, write comments and supplement information through the interactive, participatory web media. Besides, the readers also collaborate in the promotion and dissemination of the news report through the concept of “peer-recommended news” as certain services like emailing the news, RSS feeds or social bookmarking are becoming ubiquitous. Hence, collaborative media do not just provide a new voice; rather, they provide the collaborative potential to fabricate new linkages of institutions, individuals and machines. Such transformations have also ushered in new patterns of production, which Yochai Ben-
53
Collaborative Journalism
kler (2006) identifies as “nonmarket production”. There is a large number of individuals— often comprising of artists, scientists, politicians, businessmen, and professionals belonging to various sectors— who contribute to Wikipedia, citizen journalism sites, blogs, social bookmarking sites or post comments in news-sites— who are collectively producing works of clear economic value but are, for the most part, not participating in an economic market as such. As Benkler (2006, p.3) notes, “these new patterns of production—nonmarket and radically decentralized— will emerge, if permitted, at the core, rather than the periphery of the most advanced economies. It promises to enable social production and exchange to play a much larger role, alongside property- and marketbased production, than they ever have in modern democracies”.
ACTOR-NETWORK THEORY: SOCIETY, TECHNOLOGY AND JOURNALISM What this collaboration has in stake for society? It is clear that these changes may seem minute, isolated and perhaps trivial but if one looks at the macro level then it may unravel certain notions that go beyond media and journalism and affects how society itself is constituted. To this end we can constructively draw insight from the body of sociological work known as STS (science, technology, and society), or, more specifically, “actor-network theory” (ANT). One of the basic insights of sociologists such as Bruno Latour, Michel Callon, and John Law, is that what we understand as “the social” consists of much more than purely human actors. Humans are thus intricately networked with machines, software, texts, objects, databases and so on. “What we call the social is materially heterogeneous: talk, bodies, texts, machines, architectures, all of these and many more are implicated in and perform the social” (Law, 1994, p.2).
54
To put it more simply, actor-network theory as explained by Bruno Latour (1992) attempts to analyze a series of negotiations, which explains the progressive constitution of a network in which both human and non-human actors take on identities according to established strategies of interaction. Actors’ identities and qualities are defined during negotiations between representatives of human and non-human “actants”. What they term an “actant” can be anything endowed with the ability to act, including people and material objects. Actors and actants, both terms are, however, occasionally used interchangeably and “actor” and “network” are mutually constitutive. An actor can not act without a network and a network always consists of actors. Journalism, especially in the new media environment, as a network of actors can therefore be extended to include a whole series of objects, artifacts, and technologies. This development can be seen as a hybrid collectivity of human and nonhuman components, and thus we can sidestep the mistake of understanding it as constituted purely by one or the other. This, I suggest, permits us to realize the complexity of web journalism as it visibly collapses the rigid categorizations that are pivotal in the understanding of modern journalism. The list of different technologies and objects one may incorporate in this actor-network of web journalism is potentially endless. However, certain artifacts and technologies like the digital imaging devices, internet, mobile phones are of particular importance, but what must be recognized— as actor-network theorists argue— is their agency or active status. In attempting to move away from static properties and the purity of divides and distinctions, Latour (1993) argues that the agency of technologies and artifacts does not lie in the essence, in the ‘nature’, of an object, but is an effect, an outcome of a set or series of relations. This notion of relational agency means that the internet, digital cameras, or digital communication devices are only an agent inasmuch as series of associa-
Collaborative Journalism
tions are made and subsequently held together. This active status of these new media devices is an effect of these relations and associations. As Bruno Latour (2005, p.247) remarks, “The question of the social emerges when the ties in which one is entangled begin to unravel; the social is further detected through the surprising movements from one association to the next; those movements can either be suspended or resumed; when they are prematurely suspended, the social as normally construed is bound together with already accepted participants called ‘social actors’ who are members of a ‘society’; when the movement toward collection is resumed, it traces the social as associations through many non-social entities which might become participants later; if pursued systematically, this tracking may end up in a shared definition of a common world, what I have called a collective; but if there are no procedures to render it common, it may fail to be assembled; and, lastly, sociology is best defined as the discipline where participants explicitly engage in the reassembling of the collective.” Hence, consistent with a world view that habitually and steadfastly separates the natural from the mechanical and the actor from the action, naturally journalists and those who study journalism routinely separate news and newsmakers, reporters and audience, press and politics. Nevertheless, as I have earlier stated, these categorizations are starting to disintegrate in practice. As new media technologies increasingly occupy the ambit of journalism, they necessitate a new trajectory of theorization, like actor-network theory with which to comprehend the production and circulation of public discourse and for the role of what Latour and others might call socio-technical hybrids in the process. Web journalism in turn offers actornetwork theory not only a new site at which to observe the close readings of social life, but a new professional domain in which to develop the implications of its studies of science and technology
for the study of media, discourse and governance. “Like scientists, journalists have long collaborated in the production of social order. And like scientists, they have done their work in relation to economic and political institutions that their work in turn has helped shape” (Turner, 2005, p.322).
NETWORK ENTREPRENEUR AND COLLABORATIVE JOURNALISM IN INDIA This collaboration of multiple discursive and institutional networks also entails an entrepreneurial aspect. Over the last decade, news media and journalistic practices are reconfiguring to accommodate a more collaborative platform that embraces participatory, networked, hypermediated journalism. While, the traditional newsroom is going through an organizational restructuring, as I have mentioned earlier, the conventional news organization and its business interests are gradually shifting towards this presumably more prospective segment. It is noteworthy to mention here, one such collaborative news media initiative in India— NewsRack.in. Developed by Subramanya Sastry, a web developer, the site lets users specify certain filtering rules which are used to select relevant articles from incoming news feeds. The selected articles are then classified into various categories. The users create their own profile on NewsRack and save news stories under different categories. They also have an option to browse public news archives prepared by other users. To a certain extent, NewsRack has an advantage over the news aggregator of Google or Yahoo. Although it is simple to search for general news on the Google, but when it comes to subject-specific news items it is not all that competent. Google displays a handful of categories in which all news is classified; whereas, in NewsRack the categories are defined by users so, there is no limit on the number of categorization for any news item.
55
Collaborative Journalism
The scheme of NewsRack complicates the traditional understanding of journalism and news. In journalism and much of journalism studies, “actors” generally come in three categories: sources, journalists and reader/viewer; albeit all of them are human but the members of any one group might at times be members of the others; however, they are treated as analytically divergent. Each one acts as a link in a chain— sources disclose information, journalists collect and package it as news, and readers receive and consume it. Information itself moves through a series of representations although reasonably unaffected. This framework in turn endorses what Michael Schudson (2003) has called the “information-based model of citizenship”, in which citizens are supposed to act rationally at the voting booth on the basis of the news and information journalists have delivered to them. NewsRack, and its founder Subramanya Sastry along with other volunteer-contributors, in contrast serve as news gatherer, news source, and audience member all at once. Their engagement confuses the analytical categories on which traditional journalism studies have long depended. However, considered along the framework of actor-network theory, Sastry and all the others who contribute in the filtering and archiving of the news in various categories —and of course his web site—can be seen to represent and form a part of an actor-network. These “actors” and “actants” do not merely deliver news through the web site; on the contrary, they and the network in which they collaborate translate it into something new. Collectively they constitute a hybrid, an actor-network of news which, as Latour (1993, p.6) claimed of all networks, simultaneously “real, like nature, narrated, like discourse, and collective, like society”. In this perspective we may consider Subramanya Sastry, as what Ronald Burt would term a “network entrepreneur” and his site emerges as a form of actor-network. Being a network entrepreneur, Subramanya Sastry negotiates between mul-
56
tiple discursive and institutional networks and his website translates a range of news stories produced within that network and put into further circulation. In that way, Subramanya Sastry assembles NewsRack not as something like a newspaper or television news channel— that is, an independent account of events and information— rather, more like a sphere for public discussion. This discussion, nonetheless, predominantly permits network members, who may or may not be a representatives of the press but they collectively classify, organize, filter and disseminate news which are coming from established news media; hence together it can be seen to construct new linkages of institutions, economy, individuals and technology. A more institutionalized form of such effort is the first Indian website wholly devoted to citizen journalism, merinews.com. Founded by Vipul Kant Upadhyay, merinews.com clearly states, “People to People (P2P) interaction is of paramount importance and rather inevitable. Emanating from the need to empower democracy by providing a media to the people of the country to communicate with one and all, www.merinews. com is an effort to provide one such platform to interact and express. It is a news platform for collective wisdom, ’Of The People, By The People, For The People’”. Merinews.com, like the celebrated South Korean citizen journalism site, ohmynews.com, is based on the concept of participatory, collaborative journalism which “transcend beyond the limitations of conventional media and allows citizens of the country to report, read, write, comment and debate news, views - happenings they find significant” (Merinews, 2010). The site does not simply offer new conduits for the dissemination of news; rather these networks and their human collaborators, collaborate in the creation of new socio-technical formations. New media do not just offer professionals like Vipul Kant Upadhyay and Subramanya Sastry a new medium; rather, they
Collaborative Journalism
offer them the ability to foster new networks that can be witnessed across the world of web journalism, open source reporting, crowdsourcing, and in a variety of other journalistic practices and emerging technologies. A similar effort is idishoom.com, which is the only media movement of its kind in India that is essentially run by voluntary citizen editors and reporters, who as responsible and concerned citizens have created idishoom as a platform to raise a collective voice against social inequities and injustice. Over the last three years idishoom. com has been receiving considerable popularity especially among the urban youth of India and now claims to have over two million subscribers. Another, such collaborative initiative, Instablogs is a news ecosystem bringing bloggers, citizen journalists and traditional media together. Founded in 2005 by Ankit and Nandini Maheshwari, originally, the plan was to launch a global-local network of fifty news-based blogs but presently it features “a diverse community of news reporters, business owners, college students, housewives, artists, parents, and more in different countries and regions” (Instablogs, 2010). Considered in this way, several Facebook or Ning communities or other social media “groups” can be conceived as similar but informal instances of collaborative journalism that not only stand to address the political world but also points to emerging entrepreneurial aspects. Notwithstanding the fact that “nonmerket production” dominates collaborative peer-production project till date but we merely need to recognize that the material conditions of production in the networked information economy have transformed in ways that enhance the relative significance of social sharing and exchange as a modality of economic production (Benkler, 2005, p.92).
CONCLUSION This chapter is an attempt to investigate the nature of the claims that speak of the ways in which the users of online news are reconstituting the paradigms which have traditionally governed journalism and journalists. What counts as journalism in the networked, open-source society is open to negotiation, with fluidly changing points of convergence and divergence between its practice in the mainstream and in the margins. If a modern understanding of journalism assumes a distinct division between individuals, institutions and technology and their respective forms of agency, the collaborative journalistic practices on the web allow to recognize the socio-technical hybrids that are becoming increasingly widespread in journalism within a networked new media environment. In the process, collaborative journalism not only blurs traditional categories of analysis, but raises a series of critical social questions about the relationship between economy, society and journalism, to the extent it is possible to discern that notions of “authority” and “credibility” are in flux, with certain longstanding reportorial principles seeming tired, if not anachronistic, since in the last few years, numerous journalists have appeared on the web whose collaborative work straddles the line between professional and non-professional journalism and whose positions bridge multiple institutions. However, there is also no reason to believe that industrialized and institutionalized communication will be entirely superseded by new communication technologies. Perhaps, a more probable situation is that the Internet will itself become another site for institutionalized communication. Although websites in India no longer rely on NRI (Non-resident Indian) traffic and a large number of news-sites are now substantial profit-making ventures but still there are several issues that the emerging collaborative culture has to confront. The journalists and news-mediacollaborators in India need to tackle not only the
57
Collaborative Journalism
increasing institutionalization of the collaborative space and practices under the influence of global capital, but they also need to mull over the more elementary problems, like the paucity of online information in native languages, shady political intervention, and not to mention, infrastructural inadequacy in rural areas. It can not be denied that predominantly, “information-rich elite” has access to enormous quantities of information as well as to the capability of actively sharing ideas and information on the Internet. The “information poor”, on the other hand, remain passive and dependent and tend to draw on only from the hegemonic mainstream communication system, namely, the (mass) products of the culture industry (Louw, 2001, p.66). They remain either virtually excluded from the global communication system, as is the case with most rural Indians or only have access as passive recipients to mass-produced messages in the form of free-to-air, state owned television or radio channels like Doordarshan and All India Radio. Nonetheless, much can be gained from considering the relative strengths and limitations of collaborative journalism especially its implication in the emergence of new socio-economic formation. Do the new collaborative media technologies necessarily create new ‘spaces’ for communicative dialogue or debate? If it does then what is the nature of those spaces; for instance, is the notion of a new private sphere a more feasible proposition than a new public sphere? What possibilities can be discerned for opposing the established discourses of global network capitalism with nonmarket production? In what way, journalism and news media is constituted as a socio-technical network and how should we interpret the modality of these networks and traditional institutions? Presumably, the struggle between the forces for discursive closure and emerging autonomy and open-endedness will remain an attribute of human existence amid emerging technology for the imminent future; but how these struggles of the future, play themselves out remains to be seen.
58
REFERENCES Allan, S. (2006). Online news: Journalism and the Internet. Berkshire, UK: Open University Press. Audit Bureau of Circulations. (2006). NRS 2006: Key Findings [Press release]. Retrieved April 3, 2010 from http://www.auditbureau.org/nrs2006. htm Beaumont, C. (2008). Mumbai attacks: Twitter and Flickr used to break news. The Telegraph. Retrieved November 27, 2008 from http://www. telegraph.co.uk/news/worldnews/asia/india/ 3530640/Mumbai-attacks-Twitter-and-Flickrused-to-break-news-Bombay-India.html Benkler, Y. (2006). The wealth of networks: How social production transforms markets and freedom. New Haven, CT: Yale University Press. Briggs, M. (2007). Journalism 2.0: How to survive and thrive. J-Lab: The Institute for Interactive Journalism & the Knight Citizen News Network. Bruns, A. (2008). Merinews: Citizen journalism in India. Snurblog. Retrieved March 27, 2008, from http://snurb.info/node/790 Burt, R. (2000). The network entrepreneur. In Swedberg, R. (Ed.), Entrepreneurship: The social science view (pp. 281–307). Oxford, UK: Oxford University Press. Chattopadhyay, S.(20092010). Online journalism: The changing media ecology from an Indian perspective. In Tunney, S., & Monaghan, G. (Eds.), Web journalism: A new form of ctizenship? (pp. 289–305). Eastbourne, UK: Sussex Academic Press. Clark, S. (2001). Looking at the present: The current status of journalism on the Internet. Paper presented at 2001 Online Journalism Symposium, a project of the Knight Chair in Journalism at the University of Texas at Austin.
Collaborative Journalism
Compton, J. R. (2010). Newspapers, labor and the flux of economic uncertainty. In Allan, S. (Ed.), The Routledge companion to news and journalism (pp. 591–601). New York, NY: Routledge. Connell, T. (2008). Gannett acquires social media provider Ripple6. Press Release. Retrieved November 13, 2008, from http://www.gannett.com/ news/ pressrelease/2008/pr111308.htm Day, G. S., & Schoemaker, P. J. H. (2000). A different game. In Day, G. S., & Schoemaker, P. H. (Eds.), Wharton on managing new technologies (pp. 22–39). NJ: John Wiley & Sons, Inc. Garnham, N. (1986). The media and the public sphere. In Golding, P., Murdock, G., & Schlesinger, P. (Eds.), Communicating politics: Mass communications and the political process. Leicester, UK: Leicester University Press. Habermas, J. (1989). The public sphere: An encyclopedia article. In Bronner, S. E., & Kellner, D. M. (Eds.), Critical theory and society: A reader (pp. 136–142). New York, NY & London, UK: Routledge. Howe, J. (2006). The rise of crowdsourcing. Wired Magazine, 14(6), 69–76. Instablogs. (2010). Instablogs tour. Retrieved February 20, 2010, from http://www.instablogs. com/tour/ Latour, B. (1993). We have never been modern. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press. Law, J. (1994). Organizing modernity. Oxford, UK: Basil Blackwell. Lawson-Borders, G. (2003). Integrating new media and old media: Seven observations of convergence as a strategy for best practices in media organizations. The International Journal on Media Management, 5(2), 93.
Louw, P. E., & Chitty, N. (2000). South Africa’s miracle cure: A stage-managed TV spectacular? In Malek, A., & Kavoori, A. P. (Eds.), The global dynamics of news coverage and news agendas. Stamford, CT: Ablex. Merinews.com. (2010). About us. Retrieved February 9, 2010, from http://www.merinews. com/aboutus.jsp Murdock, G., & Schlesinger, P. (Eds.). (1987). Communicating politics (pp. 45–53). Leicester, UK: Leicester University Press. Noack, D. (1998). Crossfire: Print vs. online newsrooms. Editor & Publisher, 131, 38–41. Paul, N. (2000). Integrating old and new media newsrooms. Cyberjournalist. Retrieved July 26, 2000, from http://www.cyberjournalist.net/ integrating-old-and-new-media-newsrooms/ Schudson, M. (2003). Click here for democracy: A history and critique of an information-based model of citizenship. In Jenkins, H., Thorburn, D., & Seawell, B. (Eds.), Democracy and new media (pp. 49–60). Cambridge, MA: MIT Press. Turner, F. (2005). Actor-networking the news. Social Epistemology, 19(4), 321–324. doi:10.1080/02691720500145407 Zollman, P. (2000). The key question: Integration or independence. Online Technology. Retrieved April 19, 2009, from http://www.newsandtech. com/issues/ 2000/04-00/ot/04-00_zollman.htm
ADDITIONAL READING Bruns, A. (2005). Gatewatching: Collaborative online news production. New York: P. Lang. Fenton, N. (2001). New Media, old news: Journalism and democracy in the digital age. Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage.
59
Collaborative Journalism
Greenspan, A. (2004). India and the IT Revolution: Networks of global culture. London: Macmillan. doi:10.1057/9780230510371 Habermas, J. (1989). The structural transformation of the public sphere: An inquiry into a category of bourgeois society. Cambridge, Massachusetts: MIT Press. Jenkins, H. (2006). Convergence culture. London: New York University Press. McLuhan, M. (1995). Understanding media. London: Routledge. (Original work published 1964) Poster, M. (2006). Information Please: Culture and politics in the age of digital machines. London: Duke University Press. Rossiter, N. (2006). Organized Networks: Media Theory, Creative Labour, New Institutions. Rotterdam: NAI. Shirky, C. (2008). Here comes everybody: The power of organizing without organizations. London: Penguin. Staiger, J., & Sabine, H. (2009). Convergence, media, history. New York: Routledge. Tapscott, D., & Williams, A. D. (2006). Wikinomics: How mass collaboration changes everything. New York: Penguin. Terranova, T. (2004). Network Culture: Politics for the Information Age. London: Pluto Press.
KEY TERMS AND DEFINITIONS Actor-Network Theory (ANT): Actor-Network theory’s methodology involves scientific
60
realism, social constructivism, and discourse analysis in its central concept of hybrids that are simultaneously real, social, and discursive. Developed as an analysis of scientific and technological artifacts, ANT’s theoretical distinctiveness derives from its refusal to reduce explanations to either natural, social, or discursive categories while recognizing the significance of each. The modern constitution or world view uses one dimensional language operating in the framework of opposite poles of nature and culture. Knowledge and artifacts are explained either by society (social constructionisms) or by nature (realism). In order to transcend this dualism a second dimension is needed. Through Actor-Network theory, it is possible to understand the simultaneous construction of culture, society and nature. Citizen Journalism: Citizen Journalism refers to the practice of reporting news events by members of the public without professional training in journalism or affiliation to established news media. That information can take many forms, from blogs, contribution in citizen journalism sections of news media to podcast or webcast. It can include text, pictures, audio and video. Public Sphere: The public sphere is the arena within which debate occurs; it is the generation of ideas, shared knowledge and the construction of opinion that occurs when people assemble and discuss. According to Habermas, it is a network for communicating information and points of view. The public sphere is where ideas and information are shared. Media theorists have used Habermas’ public sphere to explain the importance of communication for the processes of democracy. For Habermas, the public sphere was most constructive when not influenced by commercial interests or state control.
61
Chapter 5
Using Virtual Communities to Involve Users in E-Service Development: A Case Study Eva Söderström University of Skövde, Sweden Jesper Holgersson University of Skövde, Sweden
ABSTRACT Thriving in the Internet era requires both Internet presence and careful development of the e-services provided using this technology. However, one major problem is how to involve the end users of the eservice(s), something which is necessary if the e-services are to be useful and sustainable. This chapter presents a case study on the e-service development process using a major player in the travel industry as the case. The main focus is on how new technological advancements and phenomena, primarily virtual communities, can be used as a main source of end user requirements. Virtual communities are both of strategic and practical relevance and even cause a need to redefine the term “user participation.” E-services constitute a major trend for private as well as public organizations and should address Internet technology advancements when being developed.
INTRODUCTION The Internet enables companies to interact with customers as never before, learning ways DOI: 10.4018/978-1-60960-581-0.ch005
to improve service, develop new products and fine-tune marketing strategies (Hofacker, Goldsmith, Bridges, & Swilley, 2007). An e-service is an artifact for electronic delivery of services and is one major trend in recent technological
Copyright © 2011, IGI Global. Copying or distributing in print or electronic forms without written permission of IGI Global is prohibited.
Using Virtual Communities to Involve Users in E-Service Development
developments. For example, it is used to boost e-government adoption, externally to citizens and businesses as well as internally for increased efficiency of work processes. In the private sector, the focus thus far has been on the more technical aspect usually termed “web services”, which are software applications, or one technical implementation of an e-service. However, the concept “e-service” is much more than simply technology. It encompasses the entire chain from developer to user. Until recently, development of e-services has been developer-driven and focused on automating manual processes within organisations (Asgarkhani, 2005). There has been little or no consideration to the users of the e-service (Andersen & Medaglia, 2008; Anthopoulos, Siozos, & Tsoukalas, 2007; Melin, Axelsson, & Lundsten, 2008). At best, user needs are guessed instead of thoroughly analyzed by the developing party (Jupp, 2003). The development of these services poses somewhat different challenges and perspectives compared to traditional information systems development, as will be demonstrated later in the chapter. It is therefore highly important to investigate and analyse the conditions under which e-services are being developed, as well as how users can actively contribute to this process. Internet technology has become a rising star for eliciting or gathering input into the e-service development process, where input primarily refers to user preferences, desires, complaints and requirements. The new developments and innovative uses the Internet has brought is an unexplored source of valuable information as far as e-service development is concerned. Our primary focus is the role of virtual communities in this scenario, and we will demonstrate the usefulness of said communities using a real-life industry case. In order to set the stage, background information on e-services and user participation in e-services development will first be discussed. The latter includes four identified problem areas in the said development. The primary internet technology of interest, Virtual Communities, will
62
be explained next, before the case study itself is introduced with its associated research methodology. The case ends with a section on solutions and recommendations, before the chapter concludes with future work and conclusions.
BACKGROUND E-services are used in many different settings and there is no commonly agreed definition (Rowley, 2006) but there are some general characteristics applicable for most e-services. Firstly, e-services are based on electronic interactions between a service provider and a service consumer (Javalgi, Martin, & Todd, 2004; Liao, Chen, & Yen, 2007; Rowley, 2006). Secondly, e-services are intangible, inseparable and heterogeneous (Edvardsson & Larsson, 2004; Javalgi et al., 2004; Johannesson, Andersson, Bergholtz, & Weigand, 2008; Järvinen & Lehtinen, 2004). The creation of some kind of value is also stressed by many authors (Edvardsson & Larsson, 2004; Hultgren, 2007; Preist, 2004) meaning that the e-service interaction must generate a positive outcome, either for the producer or for the consumer or most preferable, for both. In this paper we have chosen to view e-services as artefacts for the delivery of services electronically, i.e. e-services are viewed as applications making it possible to offer and use services via electronic communication channels, such as the Internet. We distinguish between two basic types of e-services; commercial ones and public ones. The outmost important difference between these is that public e-services (often described as egovernment services) are not based on the user’s ability or desire to pay (Henriksen, 2004). Public administrations do not seek profit but instead they are striving for cost reductions by increased internal efficiency and more efficient communication with citizens (K Axelsson & Melin, 2007; Charalabidis, Askounis, Gionis, Lampathaki, & Metaxiotis, 2006). Furthermore, public e-services must be targeted towards a wide spectra of users
Using Virtual Communities to Involve Users in E-Service Development
considering several aspects, such as different disabilities, geographical limitations, language issues etc. (Henriksen, 2004; van Velsen, van der Geest, ter Hedde, & Derks, 2009) whereas commercial e-services may be targeted in any direction. Additionally, e-government services must consider or are affected by, laws and regulations to a much greater extent than commercial ones (Hung, Chang, & Yu, 2006; Teicher, Hughes, & Dow, 2002). Many public e-services are unique, and are in many cases rarely used by citizens, for example, an e-service for applying for a drivers license (van Velsen et al., 2009). This means that the citizen must adapt to new e-services processes, which in turn requires that they are given support in how to use the service. This situation is different for private e-services, which often are similar and more frequently used. This means that the private e-service user generally finds it significantly easier to handle these types of e-services (van Velsen et al., 2009).
User Participation in E-Service Development User participation is a concept used in many different settings and most often, user participation refers to the involvement of end users in the development process of an information system (Cavaye, 1995). User participation in the development process may come in many forms. Nevertheless, the same general benefits from user participation will be accomplished, e.g. better information quality resulting in more consistent and accurate requirements and more realistic expectations on the upcoming system from the users point of view (Bjerknes & Bratteteig, 1995; Cavaye, 1995; Kensing & Blomberg, 1998; Matthing, Kristensson, Gustavsson, & Parasuraman, 2006; van Velsen et al., 2009). Development of e-services has traditionally been focusing on automating manual processes within organizations (Asgarkhani, 2005). Attention to the end user, i.e. the consumer, has in many
cases been neglected (Andersen & Medaglia, 2008; Anthopoulos et al., 2007; Melin et al., 2008). However the role of the user is now shifting towards more active user participation in various forms (K. Axelsson & Melin, 2008; Lindblad-Gidlund, 2008; Melin et al., 2008). The main arguments for this is that user needs are more likely to be met; meaning that not only the providing organization but also the user of a particular e-service experiences benefits when using the e-service (Andersen & Medaglia, 2008; Carroll & Rosson, 2007; van Velsen, van der Geest, ter Hedde, & Derks, 2008). By using the Internet and other electronic networks for communicating organizations today are trying to shift focus from internal user groups with distinct needs easy to target to a situation where the users are external with dispersed needs which are hard to target (Albinsson, Forsgren, & Lind, 2007). It is a challenging task as it is to target users for internal information systems development projects but it is even more challenging to target users of e-services aiming for external users, i.e. customers, citizens, other businesses. (K. Axelsson & Melin, 2008; Melin et al., 2008). (Holgersson, Söderström, Karlsson, & Hedström, 2010) have analyzed user participation in e-service development from a goal perspective. In doing so, they identified four problems or challenges when including users in development: (1) Identifying the user target segment, (2) Identifying the individual user within each segment, (3) Getting users to participate, and (4) Lacking adequate skills.
The Problem of Knowing the E-Service Market Segment An e-service should address a clear “target audience”, i.e. it should be clear for what purpose and for what user it is developed. The target service market segment for the e-service should therefore be identified and analysed (Holgersson et al., 2010). Depending on the degree of participation or the type of users developers have access to, different approaches should be selected. For
63
Using Virtual Communities to Involve Users in E-Service Development
example, an organization primarily seeking to attract new customers or do they wish to provide better e-services for existing customers? Is the organization commercial and aiming for higher revenues or is it a government striving for better services to citizens? In this sense, e-government services complicate things since they have to be offered universally to all citizens (Henriksen, 2004) and therefore have to be usable for many different types of users. Identifying new eservices for commercial reasons may call for the user innovation approach, whereas participatory design may be more suitable when developing basic e-government services. The motivation is that e-government workers may be less inclined to thinking innovatively than commercial users.
The Problem of Identifying Users for Development Efforts The decision of design approach is also steered by the amount of available resources to allocate to a development project. Users of both commercial e-services as well as e-government services are most often external (Albinsson et al., 2007). This will make it more complicated to find the appropriate users to participate with, compared to traditional information systems development inside organizational boundaries. Looking at e-government services, potential users of the e-services are scattered across different ages, genders, ethnic background, knowledge level, etc. It hence becomes difficult to choose a suitable group of users to work with. This is easier for commercial, private organizations, who target a more narrow/focused customer group (Holgersson et al., 2010). Finding lead users, a key part of the user innovation approach, may be even more complicated since not any representative user will do. User innovation often seems like an appealing design approach to choose, but in many cases, other design approaches must be considered due to the problem of finding the desired users.
64
The Problem of Getting Users to Participate in E-Service Development It may be straight forward to get users residing in-house to participate in the design process, since they can be obligated to participate and may see the benefits more clearly (Albinsson et al., 2007). E-services for commercial as well as governmental usage pose greater challenges since participation must be based on free will, i.e. the users must be persuaded to participate which most likely will reduce the number of suitable participants. It should be noted that it is possible to command participation in primarily governmental organizations such as the military forces. However, this is not ideal, since voluntary participation does provide more creative results. Restricted user access may influence the type of interaction techniques used, that is type of seminars for eliciting requirements etc. This problem concerns degree of participation and is a crucial question to ask at this stage. If active user participation is sought, part of team or advisory participation could be suitable approaches.
The Problem of Lacking Adequate Skills E-services development is complex since e-service artifacts often inherit a complex architecture from back-office systems. Most often this complexity is invisible to the user and it cannot be required that they even should have such knowledge. Even so, user participation in e-service development increases the likelihood for mutual benefits (Andersen & Medaglia, 2008; Carroll & Rosson, 2007; van Velsen et al., 2008) since the user needs are more likely to be met. But in order to formulate requirements the user is required to have extensive knowledge of what it is possible to ask for. Hence, skill inadequacy is a fourth challenge important to address when letting the user participate in eservice development. The private sector has an advantage here, since they appear more inclined to follow the latest developments and trends than
Using Virtual Communities to Involve Users in E-Service Development
the public sector employees are. Of course, this is not a rule per se, but rather an observation.
Virtual Communities The rapid development of internet gives new opportunities to create virtual communities (VCs) in the cyberspace centered around offering communication and interaction between members sharing the same interests (Parsell, 2008). A VC can be seen as a group in which individuals come together around a shared purpose, interest or goal, where most depend on electronic communications to support interaction among members who are not physically collocated (Koh, Kim, Butler, & Bock, 2007; Lu, Zhao, & Wang, 2009). VCs are part of the web intelligence technology (Lu et al., 2009; Zong, Liu, & Yao, 2007) and is one type of knowledge network (Merali & Davies, 2001). As such, it highlights the importance of the link between social capital and knowledge resources for effective knowledge management (Merali & Davies, 2001). Thus far, most individuals think of VCs as on line social networks (OSNs) which mostly focus on maintaining social relations, e.g. Facebook, MySpace etc. (Fogel & Nehmad, 2009; Mislove, Marcon, Gummadi, Druschel, & Bhattacharjee, 2007) and to find and communicate with individuals sharing the same interests, e.g. discussion forums etc. However, research is ongoing about VC for intra-company discussion, knowledge sharing, etc. (de Moor & Weigand, 2007). Migrating offline communities into online VCs has the potential to greatly improve their efficiency and ability to support the sharing of critical information and knowledge in a timely fashion (Koh et al., 2007). Members in a VC have different reasons for participating. Yu, Jiang, & Chan (2007) mention four general categories of motives for user participation in VCs: 1. Altruism, which is the intent to increase the welfare of one or more other individuals
2. Collectivism, which intends to increase the welfare of a group or collective 3. Principlism, which holds some moral principles such as justice and fairness 4. Self-interest, which is the personal motivations Moore & Serva (2007) have expanded this categorisation into 14 categories, which more or less is a detailing of the ones mentioned above. This chapter is not focused on VC research per se, and the categorisation of four is therefore sufficient for our purposes.
USING VIRTUAL COMMUNITIES FOR ELICITING REQUIREMENTS WHEN DEVELOPING E-SERVICES The chapter explores e-services development, what makes it unique and how VCs can be used to involve the users of the said services in the development process without actively involving them as traditional approaches for user participation do. The aim is twofold: to identify suitable ways to work with users using VCs and to identify the challenges in this work. We will investigate these issues by using a real-life case study to both illustrate the points made and to identify new findings. As stated in the background, typical VC activities include information sharing and problem solving. Most of these activities take the form of posting and viewing opinions, questions, experiences, information and knowledge sharing within the VCs discussion forums. Hence, posting and viewing are fundamental elements in the ongoing life of any VC (Koh et al., 2007). However, it is important to highlight the fact that the posting activity stimulant is not necessarily the same as the viewing activity stimulant (Koh et al., 2007). This means that organizations can tap into discussions of VCs to learn more about their customers’ experiences, desires, needs and
65
Using Virtual Communities to Involve Users in E-Service Development
concerns (Hofacker et al., 2007). VCs provide a foundation for facilitating collaboration and learning among individuals, such as customers or citizens, separated by physical distance and organizational boundaries (Koh et al., 2007). For this chapter, learning to be made concerns how the desires and requirements of e-service users can be incorporated and used in e-service development. VCs have been studied extensively in many aspects for a long time, but little is yet known about how they can be utilized for these purposes.
membership services. These points can be used to purchase further travels and other services provided by partners. The e-services in focus in this chapter concern those e-services that are provided within the frame of the membership.
Research Methodology The data collection in the case study consisted of interviews (see table 1 for an overview) as well as extensive studies of project documentation with a major focus on the earlier project stages focusing on analysis and design. In the interviews, two senior IT architects with managerial functions were the primary target of interest, since they have an overview of the e-service development work and oversee all ongoing development projects. Both have significant, long-term experience from e-service development and are highly familiar with the development methodology and ongoing trends. Another respondent came from the marketing and customer relations department, and was a senior marketing manager with an “umbrella perspective” over customer issues. In addition, we followed one e-service development project and conducted interviews with four participants therein. Interview questions started with introductory questions to clarify for example roles and responsibilities, communication paths in development situations, the development methodology, requirements management, user participation and maintenance issues and technical questions of the eservice, etc. There were some variations in the
The Case Study Our case study is based on a real company and all the background information is genuine. The identity of the company is irrelevant and all actors will therefore be protected by anonymity. Furthermore, the travel industry is rather “tight” and any further information on geographical location, size and types of services offered may reveal the identity. Thus, the company from here on will be referred to as “Company X”. The case concerns private e-services rather than public egovernment services, since is intended to show how any organization - private or public - can use emergent phenomena to improve their e-services and the development thereof. Company X is an international company in the travel industry with branches in several countries and with services of different types offered and provided all over the world. It offers membership to its travelers, a membership which involves being rewarded points for travelling and using the Table 1. Interview respondents
66
Participants
Role
Number of interviews
P1, P2
Senior IT architects
4 x 2 hours
P3
Project manager
1 x 2 hours
P4
System specialist
1 x 2 hours
P5
IT architect
1 x 2 hours
P6
Test leader
1 x 2 hours
P7
Senior marketing manager
1 x 2 hours
Using Virtual Communities to Involve Users in E-Service Development
exact interview question set-up depending on the role of the respondent. All interviews lasted about 2 hours and were documented via extensive notes that were sent to the interviewees afterwards for validation and to ensure correct interpretation of their answers. In addition, Company X made an extensive number of documents available for study. These were also included in the analysis. The data was analyzed by comparing answers and by searching for expressions concerning requirements elicitation, channels or media that is monitored or used during elicitation and development, along with motivations for why these choices were made.
The Need for a Modernised Solution One main concern in Company X is to continuously develop and enhance their customer support. They therefore launched a membership program some years ago, to keep and increase customer loyalty. One consequence, however, has been that the manual handling of member loyalty related services increased, which became very expensive. Furthermore, there was a need to increase the number of ways in which to make offers and to remove some limitations in the service structure. Online functionality in terms of an e-service was considered a highly suitable approach to address these problems, and it was decided that a new e-service would be developed. This e-service
would reduce the number of contacts made to the customer support center, and thereby relieve the strain on administrative functions. Communication with the users used to take place either via telephone to the customer service or via regular mail and other types of direct user contact. The before-picture is shown in figure 1. The desired solution should be generic enough to suit different member needs concerning the variety of services provided by Company X. Connections to surrounding systems, internal as well as external, had to be established, and appropriate follow-up procedures concretised. Company X determined that unless the e-service was developed, demands on the customer support would be continuous and Company X would fail to compete with other similar membership programs provided by competitors. Profitability and opportunities could thereby be lost. The e-service stores information about all members in the membership program, including track records of what they do and how they travel. When customers are to book for a specific service and pay using the points gathered, the booking is made in Amadeus which in turn communicates with the e-service. With the new e-service environment, the user (Company X’s customer) is supposed to work via a booking dialogue connected to the Amadeus e-Retail system. There, they can pay with their customer loyalty points or with money. Basically, the e-service offers
Figure 1. Communication patterns before the introduction of Internet technology
67
Using Virtual Communities to Involve Users in E-Service Development
the members several options for how to interact with company X when making various types of bookings. In addition, the e-service provides the member with additional information which is easy to access and monitor in comparison with other interaction alternatives outside the scope of the e-service.
E-Service Development with VCs VCs has provided X with new ways of working with users not previously possible, as is shown in figure 2. One major new channel is the monitoring of traveler VCs on the Internet in which company X and its membership service is discussed by community members. Such VCs are knowledgesharing communities and to some extent also problem-solving, since they can solve problems of certain areas through collaborative networks (Yu et al., 2007). Participation in this kind of VC is hence motivated by personal interest and by collectivism, since it helps this group of travelers to enhance their travelling and use of the membership points. Developers in Company X review the comments and discussions in the forum and records relevant points. These points (ideas, problems, loop holes, etc.) are brought forward to the relevant project group which evaluates them for possible action. After selection based on relevance, the results are passed on to the relevant organizational unit.
purpose, but rather as comments and feedback on existing services and needs for new services. These requirements are elicited by tapping into forum discussions and from analysing customer behavior. The customer department of Company X uses the forum/virtual community discussions a lot and thereby avoids overloading the customers with questions and queries. The customer behavior is by far the most important indicator of whether or not e-services are appreciated by the users or not, as well as how changes in these services affect the behavior.
Requirements Elicitation in Company X One basic aspect of requirements elicitation is that Company X rarely gathers new requirements, but often wants to check how their customers appreciate already existing things. Such things can be those that Company X wants to evolve or alternatively thoughts and experiences from new services. E-services have affected the development process, which is expressed by P4, “E-services have affected the rules, not so that they are more difficult to keep track of, but in that it is simpler to test them. But the same requirements still need to be gathered”. Requirements are, accordingly, elicited by: •
Basic View of User Participation in Company X The users of the e-services provided for the membership program are the members themselves. However, they are, with a few exceptions, only passive users and do not actively take part in the e-services development. Furthermore, the developers are users of the e-services too. Quoting P3, “Many of the consultants in Company X are frequent users themselves, and it has so far been enough”. In many cases, requirements are not gathered from a requirements elicitation
68
•
Large member studies, focusing on appreciation and experience. These studies are made via email or online via the Company X web portal. One sample question is,” what do you think of the possibility to use the membership points for booking hotels?” Directed membership studies outside of the border of the more general ones. These studies are made towards smaller customer segments that use an already implemented service. For example, one upcoming study will concern whether or not the members/ users like the new hotel booking service, what they do not like, and so on.
Using Virtual Communities to Involve Users in E-Service Development
Figure 2. Communication patterns after the introduction of Internet technology and e-services
•
•
Online inquiries directed at selected customer segments concerning different aspects of the membership program. Focus groups, which are only rarely used since Company X considers it difficult to gain new and useful knowledge this way. “The way you ask the question determines the answer you will get” (quote Company X). This quote emphasises the difficulties in arranging valuable focus group sessions.
Studies can consist of tests, as highlighted by P7, “We do tests where we have both groups and control groups. These groups get different information, and then we monitor their behavior. These are all real, live tests”. The e-services are provided via the Internet portal of Company X. In addition to the inquiries and studies for requirements elicitation, other issues, ideas and problems are identified by tracking member actions on the web pages. This consists of following a logged-in user in terms of where clicks are made, where they run into problems and in particular if the users fail in their tasks and log out. If a certain number of users terminate their actions on the same page, this will be subject to review and analysis in order to identify the problems and take corrective
action. Because of this tracking, which is stored in the customer database, Company X knows its users well. Quoting P7, “We follow up behavior, for example via customer inquiries and the like. We know our customer segment and know approximately what they want and what they want to do”. It should be noted that the goal of using VCs in Company X is not to elicit primarily new requirements but rather to provide a complementary way of finding requirements in an otherwise highly complex elicitation process.
How Does Company X Communicate with Its Users? One important aspect to consider is that Company X’s membership program includes a well-defined set of customers, with – seen from the membership program point of view – a well-defined interest. The users are focused on travels and how they as customers can obtain and use membership points. Many of these customers travel a lot and are active in various VCs where the different aspects of the membership are discussed. Quoting P7, “With the Internet and the sites, we have access to customers and competitors directly. All information is there if you just look”. Even though there is a willingness
69
Using Virtual Communities to Involve Users in E-Service Development
to include users more, this is still identified as problematic, as in the quote by P4, “More active user participation is problematic, since you do get in a lot of questions that really do not belong to the project. It is difficult to focus on what really shall be done”. According to Company X, these customers are extremely knowledgeable about the membership program. The extensive and encompassing customer database enables Company X to easily identify suitable customers in defined spectra. There are, in other words, no problems in identifying the customer segments, since they only have one that is well-defined and since the database contains all the information necessary for this task. In cases where customers participate in some form of activity, there is rarely a problem to motivate participation, hence the challenges of identifying target groups and users within these target groups as well as getting the users to willingly participate (Holgersson et al., 2010) are no problems for Company X. The reason is that the customers, who generally are on the top levels in the membership program, are genuinely interested by the program and the services associated with it. In summary, Company X communicates with its users in the following ways (see also figure 2): • • • •
Online surveys Threads in virtual communities/discussion forums, such as Flyertalk Dedicated virtual communities/discussions forums, such as Facebook In rare cases Company X gives some customers a phone call
Figure 2 displays the various ways in which Company X communicates with its customers, and the entrance of Internet technology has certainly affected the ways in which communication takes place. Contrasted to figure 1, the number of contact points has certainly increased given the new technology. This, coupled with the extensive customer database, has dramatically increased the knowledge Company X has about its customers.
70
In the case of VCs, Company X should be seen as an “early adopter”. Ali-Vemas & Luukkainen, (2008) and Rogers (2003) have defined five types of adopters: innovators, early adopters, early and late majority and laggards. The travel industry and hence Company X, often constitutes the early adopters of new technology (Azzara, 2002; Murphy & Stoyanova, 2003), at least in the case of e-services – or rather the more technical aspect of web services. One key point is that early adopters demonstrate the value of adoption through their own commitment (Boh, Soh, & Yeo, 2007). This is a strong characteristic for Company X and is essential not the least since the travel industry is such a competitive market.
How Does Company X Get the Users to Participate? Company X does not, with only a limited amount of exceptions, actively involve users when developing e-services. The customers seldom come up with new revolutionary ideas but they are very good at providing feedback. Still, there is a desire to include them more, “One would like to include the users more in the development projects, but the external ones are difficult to get to participate. Internal ones are a different matter” (P1 and P2). However, the fact that the target group members themselves are genuinely interested in the membership program for their own personal reasons is one important point to make. The result is that the customers are more willing to answer questions and contribute with informatio, but Company X is nevertheless reluctant to contact these users too often given that they know of their busy schedules, rather than it being the customers who object to participation. Furthermore, Company X would like to involve the users more, but in specific parts of the development process. Quoting P3, “If we are to include users, it will need to include usability testing for identifying mistakes”. It is often Company X itself that monitors different VCs and the like, which means that
Using Virtual Communities to Involve Users in E-Service Development
the customers often do not need to be enticed to participate. They already participate in the forum due to their own free will and Company X takes part of their opinions and the information they leave without users even noticing that they in fact participate in development. Based on the discussions and threads of interest brought up in the VCs, new features can be developed and improvements to existing e-services can be made. Furthermore, the large customer database with its huge amount of information about the customers, their behavior, preferences, etc. coupled with tracking user behavior, is a valuable input to e-services development and enhancement. Both communities and the customer database can be thought of as implicit inclusion of users in the development of e-services. Users provide input, but not through direct contact. There is, however, one part of the development process where a selected user group participates, as quoted by P6, “The interaction designer has used small usability tests for adjustments”. Normally, such tests are only used when the development concerns great changes or large new features. There are also several ideas of how, and for what task, users could become more involved, as illustrated by the quote from P5, “…we have had two consultants without specific Company X knowledge. They thus know how people who work think, but perhaps we should have had more external dialogue tests. Picking out some selected membership program users in such tests would be great in an ideal world”. However, there are also ideas on including users earlier in the process, primarily during requirements elicitation as a complement to the VC monitoring and customer database. Quoting P5, “What the user needs to be part of is for all the functionality, which is natural”.
Solutions and Recommendations E-service development is flourishing but the conditions and circumstances surrounding development have changed with the new ways of communicat-
ing using internet technology, such as VCs. For example, the ways in which knowledge can be gained on customer/user behavior vary to a much greater extent nowadays. The main interest in this paper has concerned the growing role of VCs in the development of e-services. It is no secret that user participation has a positive influence when developing e-services and VCs can be utilised to tap into customer or citizen, ideas, opinions, requirements, desires and so on. This information is critical to really getting to know the users, their behavior and preferences. It can then be utilised for developing e-services of higher quality and of greater usability, without the same extent of user participation as in traditional development. Our study shows that the “tapping” of information is of great importance, but in addition, Company X can provide feedback and ask for more information. They, thereby, are able to detail requirements and desires, which is important for the quality of the results. This extra round of inquiry is rarely even possible when using for example traditional questionnaires, in particular when these are anonymous. Internet technology and VCs have hence provided more refined ways of elaborating on the elicited requirements. The knowledge about the customer segment is great in organisations developing e-services because of the VCs and the expanded use provided by internet technology. The result is that users are influential, without necessarily participating directly in the development process. As a consequence, we need to change the way user participation is perceived in this setting. The new perception, or perspective, must encompass that users can have influence beyond traditional requirements elicitation, in which interviews, questionnaires, and observations are commonly used. New internet technology and the increasing role of VCs where users themselves participate and share knowledge actively bring increased user knowledge – without direct communication between them and the e-service developers. It may therefore be valid to consider this as user influence
71
Using Virtual Communities to Involve Users in E-Service Development
and not participation. Face-to-face meetings can never be replaced solely by the Internet; rather, the Internet is a valuable complement to the same. Our intent with presenting the case study is not to state general validity of our claims in all other settings. Instead, it should be interpreted as an illustration of how a company that wants to be in the forefront can use the novel technologies to gain knowledge and thus to develop better services and products as a consequence. Daring to look outside the box is a prerequisite for being an early adopter of new technology, even if it means challenging the perceptions of industry as well as academia.
FUTURE RESEARCH DIRECTIONS By incorporating the new internet technology developments, users can influence e-service design without directly participating in their development, and sometimes not even being aware of their influence. We do not advocate that VCs should be the only tool for eliciting user input, but rather recommend it to be used as one more source in addition to for example actual user involvement. The extent to which users should be directly involved in development is a challenging “balance act” for all organizations, and VCs can assist to avoid overwhelming users with requests for input. However, the ways in which VCs are used must be carefully planned and tuned to the needs at hand. They can provide a valuable information source coupled with other means, such as the extensive customer knowledge database in Company X, online user surveys, online bulletin boards, and so on. Separately, they may only provide one piece of the puzzle, but taken together, they may show pretty much the entire picture. Still, much is unknown in this area. Future work includes a more in-depth look into VC research and use findings therein for a more detailed analysis of for example motivational aspects of participating in VCs. Such research may
72
provide valuable insights into how VCs can be used for knowledge-gathering activities to support e-service development. Therefore, additional case studies are needed in which various forms of VCs are reviewed and tested in order to elicit eservice requirements. The ways in which e-service developers can utilize and even organize and steer VCs for this purpose need to be included as well. Comparative studies between public and private organizations may furthermore provide essential insight into whether similar user participation advantages can be drawn for public VCs as for private ones. Another potential and valuable route is to draw on knowledge management and e-learning technology to enhance learning ability, knowledge gained and knowledge lost from development to use of the e-services.
CONCLUSION This chapter has explored the strategic use and practice of using VCs for the development of e-services and the importance of such sources in this process. The use of VCs requires awareness, strategic planning, and the right tools in order to be successful, considering the vast flora of VCs available, and the difficulty to choose which information in the VCs to incorporate. They constitute a new way of communicating and collaborating with users of e-services and enable developers to create usable and useful e-services without straining too much on the users’ limited available time. However, since there is a tendency to use VCs and similar technologies instead of involving users directly, the term “user participation” will need to be redefined. We are speaking of user involvement without participation,and both research and practice should reflect and investigate these changes. Internet technology developments of recent time provide opportunities not previously possible and if used properly, consciously and strategically, they can be tools that provide competitive advantages. The case presented in
Using Virtual Communities to Involve Users in E-Service Development
this chapter provides one such example. To the best of our knowledge, there are no similar case studies focused on how VCs can be used in eservice development. There are studies on VCs, motivations for participating in them, their role in creating social structures and so on. But none of them are taking the focus that we have presented in this chapter. There is a need for additional and comparative studies, covering both private as well as public organization, which will be part of the future work. Finally, in the travel industry and others of equal degrees of competitiveness, having the “edge” can be a make or break thing. The importance of the matter thus becomes clear and deserves further attention.
REFERENCES Albinsson, L., Forsgren, K., & Lind, M. (2007). Towards a co-design approach for open innovation. Designed for co-designers workshop. Paper presented at the Participatory Design Conference 2008 (PDC 2008). Ali-Vemas, T., & Luukkainen, S. (2008). Service adoption strategies of push over cellular. Personal and Ubiquitous Computing, 12(1), 35–44. doi:10.1007/s00779-006-0122-3 Andersen, V. K., & Medaglia, R. (2008). Egovernment front-end services: Administrative and citizen cost benefits. Paper presented at the EGOV 2008. Anthopoulos, L. G., Siozos, P. S., & Tsoukalas, I. A. (2007). Applying participatory design and collaboration in digital public services for discovering and re-designing e-government services. Government Information Quarterly, 24, 353–376. doi:10.1016/j.giq.2006.07.018 Asgarkhani, M. (2005). The effectiveness of eservice in local government: A case study. Electric Journal of E-Government, 3(4), 157–166.
Axelsson, K., & Melin, U. (2007). Talking to, not about, citizens – experiences of focus groups in public e-service development. Paper presented at the EGOV 2007. Axelsson, K., & Melin, U. (2008). Citizen participation and involvement in e-government projects – an emergent framework. Paper presented at the EGOV 2008. Azzara, C. (2002). Web services: The next frontier: A primary research opportunity study. Bjerknes, G., & Bratteteig, T. (1995). User participation and democracy. A discussion of Scandinavian research on systems development. Scandinavian Journal of Information Systems, 7(1), 73–98. Boh, W., Soh, C., & Yeo, S. (2007). A case study of RosettaNet. Communications of the ACM, 50(12), 57–62. doi:10.1145/1323688.1323695 Carroll, J. M., & Rosson, M. B. (2007). Participatory design in community informatics. Design Studies, 28(3), 243–261. doi:10.1016/j. destud.2007.02.007 Cavaye, A. L. M. (1995). User participation is systems development revisited. Information & Management, 28, 311–323. doi:10.1016/03787206(94)00053-L Charalabidis, Y., Askounis, D., Gionis, G., Lampathaki, F., & Metaxiotis, K. (2006). Organising municipal e-government systems: A multi-facet taxonomy of e-services for citizens and businesses. Paper presented at the EGOV 2006. de Moor, A., & Weigand, H. (2007). Formalizing the evolution of virtual communities. Information Systems, 32(2), 223–247. doi:10.1016/j. is.2005.09.002