H S U B T S U M GO
ALSO BY BILL PRESS Spin This! All the Ways We Don’t Tell the Truth
H S BU T S U M GO The Top Ten...
13 downloads
1048 Views
1MB Size
Report
This content was uploaded by our users and we assume good faith they have the permission to share this book. If you own the copyright to this book and it is wrongfully on our website, we offer a simple DMCA procedure to remove your content from our site. Start by pressing the button below!
Report copyright / DMCA form
H S U B T S U M GO
ALSO BY BILL PRESS Spin This! All the Ways We Don’t Tell the Truth
H S BU T S U M GO The Top Ten Reasons Why George Bush Doesn’t Deserve a Second Term
BILL PRESS
DUTTON
DUTTON Published by Penguin Group (USA) Inc. 375 Hudson Street, New York, New York 10014, U.S.A. Penguin Books Ltd, Registered Offices: 80 Strand, London WC2R 0RL, England Penguin Books Australia Ltd, 250 Camberwell Road, Camberwell, Victoria 3124, Australia Penguin Books Canada Ltd, 10 Alcorn Avenue, Toronto, Ontario, Canada M4V 3B2 Penguin Books (NZ) Ltd, Cnr Rosedale and Airborne Roads, Albany, Auckland 1310, New Zealand Published by Dutton, a member of Penguin Group (USA) Inc. First printing, June 2004 First Electronic edition, October 2004 Copyright © 2004 by Bill Press All rights reserved registered trademark—marca registrada library of congress cataloging-in-publication data Press, Bill, 1940Bush must go / by Bill Press. p. cm. MSR ISBN: 0 7865 5250 6 AEB ISBN: 0 7865 5251 4 Set in Sabon Designed by Leonard Telesca Without limiting the rights under copyright reserved above, no part of this publication may be reproduced, stored in or introduced into a retrieval system, or transmitted, in any form, or by any means (electronic, mechanical, photocopying, recording, or otherwise), without the prior written permission of both the copyright owner and the above publisher of this book. The scanning, uploading, and distribution of this book via the Internet or via any other means without the permission of the publisher is illegal and punishable by law. Please purchase only authorized electronic editions, and do not participate in or encourage electronic piracy of copyrighted materials. Your support of the author’s rights is appreciated. Making or distributing electronic copies of this book constitutes copyright infringement and could subject the infringer to criminal and civil liability. Visit our web site at www.penguinputnam.com
For newlyweds David and Hez. Congratulations!
Contents
Introduction 1 #1 THE WAR IN IRAQ: He Lied Us into War 7
REASON
#2 THE WAR ON TERROR: He Has Made Us Less Safe from Terrorism 43
REASON
#3 JOBS: He Put 3 Million Americans Out of Work 72
REASON
#4 THE DEFICIT: He Spent Money Like a Drunken Sailor 96
REASON
#5 THE PATRIOT ACT: He Undermined Our Most Basic Freedoms 123
REASON
#6 CRONY CAPITALISM: He Sold America Out to Special Interests 147
REASON
#7 FOREIGN POLICY: He Ruined America’s Standing in the World 173
REASON
VIII
CONTENTS
#8 THE ENVIRONMENT: He’s the Worst President Ever 197
REASON
#9 BROKEN PROMISES: He’s a Divider, Not a Uniter 223
REASON
#10 THE CREDIBILITY GAP: He Never Tells the Truth 246
REASON
BONUS REASON
FLORIDA: He Stole the 2000 Election 260 Conclusion 275 Acknowledgments 279 Bibliography 281 Organizations/Websites 285
H S U B T S U M GO
Introduction “One year ago today, the time for excuse-making has come to an end.” George W. Bush January 8, 2003
In our great democracy, elections come and go. Some are more exciting than others. Some are more important than others. But make no mistake about this one. The presidential election of 2004 is the most important of our lifetime. Never before has there been such a dangerous man in the White House. Never before has it been so vital, for the good of the republic and everything we stand for as Americans, to oust an incumbent president from office. Before Tom DeLay lumps me among the “Bush-haters,” I want to make one thing perfectly clear: I do not hate George W. Bush. It’s nothing personal. I just think he’s a sad, sorry excuse for a president. His policies have ruined the economy, pitted Americans against each other, destroyed the environment, taken us into an unwise and unnecessary war and made enemies around the world. Despite losing the 2000 popular vote to Al Gore, George Bush did not walk lightly into the Oval Office. His administration brought more than a change of presidents and cabinet secretaries.
2
INTRODUCTION
He acted as if he had a mandate. Both at home and abroad, he has steered this nation in radical and dangerous new directions. He has betrayed our trust. He has adopted policies that are antithetical to our core national values. On the international scene, Bush promised a “humble” foreign policy. Instead, he has delivered the most arrogant brand of foreign relations possible. He abandoned the idea of “containment,” successfully followed for four decades by Republican and Democratic presidents alike—against such enemies as the Soviet Union, Communist China and Cuba—and replaced it with his new policy of “first strike” or “anticipatory selfdefense.” Under the new Bush doctrine, the United States asserts the right to go anywhere, anytime and overthrow any government we think may someday pose a threat. Iraq was Bush’s first preemptive war. Today, over a year later, it is still a war in search of a reason. As it turns out, everything George Bush told the American people to justify going to war in Iraq was a lie. We’ve found no weapons of mass destruction, no nuclear weapons, no long-range missiles, no bomb-carrying drones, no connection to September 11, no links to Osama bin Laden and no imminent threat to the United States. The war in Iraq—which has so far claimed over 600 American lives—was both unnecessary and unwise. Bush also reversed course on decades of international cooperation—much of it wisely championed by his father—on global issues. Flying the flag of neo-isolationism, Bush canceled U.S. participation in existing treaties on the law of the sea, biological weapons and missile defense. He pulled the plug on a new treaty on global warming and thumbed his nose at the United Nations. As a result, respect for the United States and for our president has deteriorated around the world. Bush is ridiculed as the “Toxic Texan.” Even among our allies, most people now regard America as an unfriendly and belligerent power. The
INTRODUCTION
3
United States could only round up two other countries, Great Britain and Australia, to join in the invasion of Iraq—and then on a very small scale. On the home front, Bush has wreaked even more havoc. He took the country’s economy from A-OK to IOU, turning a projected ten-year, $5 billion surplus into a projected $5 billion deficit and, in the short term, replacing Bill Clinton’s balanced budget with a 2004 budget deficit of $374 billion, the largest in history. According to projections issued by the White House Budget Office in January 2004, Bush will set an all-time new deficit record of $520 billion in 2005. At the same time, Bush rewarded his favorite constituency, those Americans making over $320,000 a year, with two back-to-back tax cuts that they didn’t need and we couldn’t afford. Eight years of the most robust economic growth in history have been followed by three years of Bush recession and the loss of 2.8 million private sector jobs. After ten quarters of decline or stagnation, the economy may be finally starting to rebound. But, even so, it’s a jobless recovery. Nine million Americans are still out of work; George Bush will be the first president since Herbert Hoover to leave office with more Americans out of work than when he arrived. The Bush recession hurt all Americans—except those special interests who fueled his election campaign with big contributions. To them, he handed a whole grab bag of federal goodies: giant new subsidies to big agricultural firms; freedom to continue polluting to refineries and utilities; access to national monuments and forests to timber and mining interests; and drilling in Alaska and national parks to oil companies. George Bush paid his friends back, big time. At the same time, he declared war on all the rest of us. George Bush cut funds for student loans and Head Start. He stuck seniors with a prescription drug plan that charges them more for less. He built up a bigger, bloated federal government.
4
INTRODUCTION
He caused irreparable damage to the environment. And he unleashed Attorney General John Ashcroft in a direct assault on our civil liberties under the so-called USA Patriot Act. Bush and Ashcroft have violated the due process of law by locking up suspects for months with no access to a lawyer and no chance to prove their innocence. They have also trampled on the Fourth Amendment by requiring law-abiding citizens to open up their bank, medical, credit card, telephone and computer records to the FBI. It’s all part of the war on terror, they argue. Yet George Bush’s so-called war on terror is mostly pure public relations. He has actually left us more vulnerable to terrorism, not less. To be fair, Bush has done a few good things. He stepped up to the plate after September 11 and demonstrated strong leadership. He led a successful campaign against al Qaeda in Afghanistan. He refused to brand Islam as a violent religion, or all Muslims as terrorists. He proposed a temporary work permit for undocumented workers from Mexico. That’s it. Trying to be as generous as I can, those are the only four positive things I can think of. And they are completely overshadowed by all the evil he has done. On November 6, 2000—the day before he lost the popular vote to Al Gore—George Bush told a crowd in Bentonville, Arkansas: “They misunderestimated me.” We sure did. He turned out to be a far worse president than we had ever feared. And that’s why this election is so critical. Anyone who follows American politics knows that whenever a president is running for reelection, the election is more about him than his opponent. That’s certainly true this year. The election of 2004 is not about whether you like George Bush better than John Kerry. The election of 2004 is about one thing only: It is a referendum on George Bush’s record. It is a referendum on his disastrous policies. It is our only chance to
INTRODUCTION
5
get rid of him before he can do any more damage—to our nation, to our environment and to our children’s future. Two friends of mine, Mark and Susie Buell, took a trip around the world in 2003. They returned inspired by the beautiful sites they had visited, but disheartened at the antiAmericanism they encountered everywhere they traveled. I wanted to know who people blame, Americans in general or George Bush? For now, Mark and Susie reported, they only blame George Bush—because they know we didn’t really elect him in 2000. But if we reelect him in 2004, they warned, then they will start to blame us. We can’t let that happen. I admit that writing this book was tough. There are a thousand reasons why George Bush doesn’t deserve a second term, and didn’t deserve a first one. But, to save time and trees, I had to limit my list to the top ten—and that was hard. So I need your help. Let’s make this a cooperative project. You, no doubt, have your own reasons for dumping this guy. At any time, I invite you to turn to the back of this book and use the space provided for listing “My Own Top Ten Reasons for Getting Rid of George Bush.” Or check out my website at BillPress.com—and sound off. But, please, join the team: Read my top ten reasons, add your own, share them with your friends and neighbors and then—run to the ballot box and send this president back to Texas. We need regime change in America, too. We can’t afford four more years of George W. Bush. If you need any ammunition for voting against George Bush, here they are: the top ten reasons why George Bush must be denied a second term.
REASON # ONE
The War in Iraq: He Lied Us into War “I think war is a dangerous place.” George W. Bush August 7, 2003
What’s the worst thing a president could do? Get drunk on the job? Divert millions of dollars into his own pockets? Ignore his official duties? Prance around naked on the Truman Balcony? That’s all pretty bad. But there’s something a whole lot worse. The worst thing a president could ever do is to take this country to war on false pretenses. And that’s exactly what George Bush did. In the past, only a handful of presidents have led us into war. But George W. Bush lied us into war. He launched a war on terror and then abandoned it for a long, costly and unrelated war in Iraq—which only gave global terrorists more time to regroup and rearm. In Iraq, he sacrificed the lives of hundreds of our sons and daughters—not for a war he had to wage to defend this country, but for a war he chose to wage. Think about it. Nothing could be more despicable. There could be no more important reason for being tossed out of the White House.
8
REASON #1
George Bush lied to the American people, and because of that, hundreds of American men and women gave their lives in an unnecessary and unwise war.
The Selling of the War Toward the end of 2003, when it became clear that weapons of mass destruction would never be found in Iraq, the White House suddenly changed its tune about why we went to war in the first place. Saddam Hussein was an evil despot, President Bush began to argue. He had gassed his own people. He had ordered the execution of thousands of political prisoners. He had filled Iraq’s prisons and torture chambers with thousands more. The United States had a humanitarian duty to go in and free the Iraqi people from this tyrant. Granted, Saddam Hussein was a thug. One of the most evil men on earth. The people of Iraq, and indeed the whole world, are better off with him out of power and in prison. But there are still two things wrong with this new Bush spin. First, no matter how much George Bush likes to play emperor of the world, the United States has no moral or legal authority to invade any country, anytime, and overthrow any leader we don’t happen to like. We especially don’t have the right to do so alone, outside the legitimate umbrella of the United Nations. Iraq was not a democracy. But neither are Saudi Arabia, Syria, Libya, Egypt, Cuba, Sudan, Burma, the United Arab Emirates, North Korea, Bahrain, Iran and any other number of countries. Iraq’s Saddam Hussein was a tyrant. But so are North Korea’s Kim Jong Il, Libya’s Muammar Qaddafi, Cuba’s Fidel Castro, Sudan’s Omar al-Bashir and Burma’s
THE WAR
IN IRAQ
9
Than Shwe. You could make the same case against any one of them that George Bush made against Saddam Hussein. In October 2003, for example, Saudi Arabia ordered the arrest of hundreds of demonstrators in Riyadh who were demanding greater political freedoms. Is King Fahd next on America’s hit list? Probably not. He has too much oil. In February 2004, the BBC reported that North Korea is killing political prisoners in experimental gas chambers and testing new chemical weapons on women and children. Is Kim Jong Il next on America’s hit list? Probably not. He has nuclear weapons. There’s the problem. Once we start down the road of singlehandedly stepping in and overthrowing ruthless leaders, where do we stop? How do we decide who gets bumped and who doesn’t? And why won’t other rogue nations simply learn the lesson of North Korea and Pakistan: Acquire nuclear weapons and the United States won’t touch you? The second thing wrong with the latest White House spin is: That’s not the argument President Bush gave for going to war. Not even close. Maybe he could have persuaded the American people we had to go to war for humanitarian reasons, as his father did in Somalia. But Bush Jr. didn’t even try. In fact, Deputy Secretary of Defense Paul Wolfowitz, considered the intellectual architect of the Iraq war, has said that saving the Iraqi people from Saddam Hussein wasn’t reason enough to warrant a war. Outlining Bush’s decision-making process in a May 2003 interview with Sam Tannenhaus of Vanity Fair, Wolfowitz candidly acknowledges: “We settled on the one issue that everyone could agree on, which was weapons of mass destruction.” As for Saddam Hussein’s criminal treatment of the Iraqi people, Wolfowitz adds it “is a reason to help the Iraqis but it’s not a reason to put American kids’ lives at risk, certainly not on the scale we did it.” George Bush hopes we forget what he said at the time, but
10
REASON #1
we don’t. American men and women were not sent to Iraq to rescue the Iraqi people from Saddam Hussein. They were sent on a mission to defend the United States from Saddam Hussein and his WMD when, in fact, the evidence now proves, there was no threat. Over and over again, President Bush gave six reasons why we had to go war in Iraq: 1. We had tried diplomacy and it had failed. 2. War was the only option. 3. Saddam Hussein had weapons of mass destruction, in great quantities, deployed to the front lines to be used against our troops. 4. Saddam Hussein either already had nuclear weapons, or was in the process of developing them. 5. Saddam Hussein was connected to al Qaeda and at least indirectly involved in September 11. 6. Saddam Hussein and his WMD were an immediate threat to the United States, which is why we couldn’t give UN inspectors any more time. To this day, there is no evidence to support any one of the six reasons President Bush gave for going to war in Iraq. But, worse yet: There is ample evidence to prove that President Bush deliberately exaggerated available intelligence and lied to the American people about the need to go to war. Now that his original rationale for war has fallen apart, President Bush cannot be allowed to reinvent history in 2004. He must be held accountable for the reasons he gave in 2002 and 2003 for sending our troops into battle. He must face responsibility for every one of his lies.
THE WAR
IN IRAQ
11
Lie #1: Diplomacy Didn’t Work President Bush still insists he went to war in Iraq reluctantly, because he tried diplomacy at the United Nations first, but it just didn’t work. That is so far from the truth, it’s amazing he can say it with a straight face. It’s clear that President Bush went to the United Nations reluctantly, after having already decided to go to war, and only because he was convinced to do so by Secretary of State Colin Powell. And he went to the United Nations after having spent three years deep-sixing at least half a dozen UN initiatives. Thanks to The New Republic’s Peter Beinart for first collecting and publishing these headlines, which illustrate Bush’s utter disdain for any UN initiatives, no matter how worthy the cause: “U.S. Boycotts Nuclear Test Ban Meeting” (Washington Post, November 12, 2001)
“U.S. Scuttles Germ War Conference” (Washington Post, December 8, 2001)
“U.S., Europe Clash at Child Summit” (Washington Times, May 9, 2002)
“European Union Ratifies Treaty Aimed at Curbing Global Warming; U.S. Alone in Opposition” (Associated Press, May 31, 2002)
“U.S. Opposition to New International Court Gets Bad Reviews Abroad” (Kansas City Star, July 13, 2002)
12
REASON #1
Having demonstrated his unwillingness to work with the UN, it was no surprise that when President Bush finally appeared before the General Assembly, he did so with a chip on his shoulder. He defiantly told them that if they didn’t join the war he had already decided upon, the United Nations would be irrelevant. “My way or the highway” is what passes for diplomacy in the Bush White House. President Bush also ridiculed the failure of Hans Blix and his UN inspectors to find Iraq’s weapons of mass destruction— leaving him with egg on his face when David Kay, Bush’s chief inspector, later attributed his own failure to find WMD to the fact that the first round of UN inspectors, in the early 1990s, did such a good job they scared Saddam Hussein into destroying his illicit weapons. Then Bush sent Colin Powell back to the United Nations with a totally flawed case for war. “My colleagues, every statement I make today is backed up by sources, solid sources,” he told the Security Council. He then proceeded to describe a frightening array of unmanned drones designed to deliver biological weapons, mobile weapons labs, stockpiles of biological and chemical weapons, long-range missiles and an active nuclear weapons program. Taken together, they certainly provided the “smoking gun” everyone was looking for. Except they didn’t. None of the core assertions made by Powell turned out to be true. His reputation for honesty became one of the first victims of Bush’s war in Iraq. It’s obvious now that George Bush was never sincere about seeking the support of the United Nations. He had already deployed troops to the region before approaching the UN. With or without UN backing, he had already made up his mind to go to war. As a final insult, President Bush to this day claims that the war in Iraq was not a unilateral effort. Saddam Hussein, he insists, was overthrown by a “Coalition of the Willing.” He
THE WAR
IN IRAQ
13
brags that his forty-six-member coalition is bigger than the thirty-four-nation coalition put together by his father for the first Gulf War in 1991. That is outrageous. This guy will stop at nothing. He even lies about his own father. Daddy Bush, let’s remember, only went to war in Iraq after securing a resolution from the United Nations—and after Saddam Hussein’s forces had invaded Kuwait. Under the UN banner, the first Persian Gulf War was prosecuted by a thirty-four-nation military force, with each nation contributing troops on the ground, aircraft, ships or medics. Dozens of other nations expressed support for the war or sent money—making the actual number of coalition members over one hundred. And, best yet, coalition members paid 80 percent of the cost. By contrast, George W. Bush really only had two partners in Iraq: England and Australia. But even England sent only forty-five thousand troops and Australia only two thousand— compared to three hundred thousand U.S. forces. And the United States paid the full freight—estimated to reach $200 billion. Except for the Brits and the Aussies, the rest of Bush’s socalled “Coalition of the Willing” didn’t send any troops. Some of them did nothing more than sign a letter saying they supported the war. According to one press report, Morocco volunteered to send two thousand monkeys to help detonate land mines. Put them on the list! The island nation of Palau is a typical Bush coalition member. Palau has a population of twenty thousand, but no military. It did send a letter supporting the war and offered the use of its harbors and airports. Which the Pentagon had to decline, because Palau is five thousand miles from Iraq. Palau joins Costa Rica, the Marshall Islands, Iceland, Micronesia and the Solomon Islands as the six unarmed nations in Bush’s coalition. Rwanda, Uzbekistan, Panama, South Korea, the Philippines,
14
REASON #1
Macedonia, Mongolia, Honduras, the Dominican Republic, Latvia and Eritrea issued statements of support. And according to a report of the Institute for Policy Studies, many of them did so, under threat of loss of U.S. military or trade assistance. Phyllis Bennis, author of the Institute study, says such nations should be called “The Coalition of the Coerced.” The truth is, George Bush rejected any diplomatic solution to the situation in Iraq, just like he rejected any diplomatic efforts to solve the problems of nuclear proliferation or global warming. He’s a man who doesn’t see any value in even trying to work together with other nations. He prefers to go it alone, no matter the consequences.
Lie #2: No Other Solution but War Even if everything George Bush said about Saddam’s arsenal were true, he was still wrong to assert that war was the only option—and that September 11 had made preemptive war a necessity. There was at least one other option: a formula followed by every president, Democrat and Republican, since World War II, including George Bush’s father. It’s called containment, or deterrence. Here’s how it works. The other side knows that you have overwhelming military might. And they know you won’t hesitate to unleash it at the slightest provocation. So they stay in their box and don’t do anything stupid. Containment worked for fifty years against the Soviet Union. They were a very real and imminent threat to the United States. They had over one thousand ballistic missiles aimed at American cities. Their dictators killed even more people than Saddam Hussein. Yet we never invaded the Soviet Union. We contained them. Containment is what George Bush is using today against
THE WAR
IN IRAQ
15
North Korea. Led by nutso Kim Jong Il, North Korea is clearly in violation of UN resolutions. It may already have nuclear weapons. It has definitely restarted its nuclear weapons program. It has a long-range missile than can reach Alaska, and possibly even the West Coast. But Bush does not propose invading North Korea. Instead, he’s asking for multilateral talks—and deterrence. Containment even worked against Saddam Hussein himself, as none other than Dick Cheney boasted, when he was secretary of defense. He warned in August 1990 that “It should be clear to Saddam Hussein that we have a wide range of military capabilities that will let us respond with overwhelming force and extract a very high price should he be foolish enough to use chemical weapons on United States forces.” In fact, Hussein did not use biological or chemical weapons in the first Gulf War, because of the fear of retaliation. And for eleven years after the end of Desert Storm, deterrence continued to work against Saddam Hussein. He invaded Kuwait. Coalition forces put him back in his box. After that, he never made one false move. Because he knew what would happen if he did. Even in the buildup to war, Cheney acknowledged that containment was working. “Saddam Hussein is bottled up,” he told Tim Russert on Meet the Press on September 16, 2001.
Lie #3: Weapons of Mass Deception Of all the reasons given to justify the invasion of Iraq, one stands out: Saddam’s weapons of mass destruction. He had them, President Bush insisted, and we had to disarm him. What They Said
“Simply stated, there is no doubt that Saddam Hussein now has weapons of mass destruction. There is no
16
REASON #1
doubt he is amassing them to use against our friends, against our allies, and against us.” Dick Cheney, Speech, VFW Convention, August 26, 2002
“There’s no debate in the world as to whether they have those weapons . . . We all know that. A trained ape knows that.” Donald Rumsfeld, Pentagon Briefing, September 13, 2002
“He’s amassed large clandestine stockpiles of biological weapons, including anthrax, botulism toxin, possibly smallpox. He’s amassed large clandestine stockpiles of chemical weapons, including VX, Sarin and mustard gas.” Donald Rumsfeld, Pentagon, September 19, 2002
“There can be no doubt that Saddam Hussein has biological weapons . . . Our conservative estimate is that Iraq today has a stockpile of between one hundred and five hundred tons of chemical weapons agent. That is enough agent to fill sixteen thousand battlefield rockets. Saddam Hussein has chemical weapons. And we have sources who tell us that he recently has authorized his field commanders to use them.” Colin Powell, United Nations, February 5, 2003
“According to the British government, the Iraqi regime could launch a biological or chemical weapons attack in as little as forty-five minutes after the order were given.” George W. Bush, Rose Garden, September 26, 2002
THE WAR
IN IRAQ
17
“Saddam Hussein is a man who told the world he wouldn’t have weapons of mass destruction, but he’s got them.” George W. Bush, Sioux Falls, November 3, 2002
“Intelligence gathered by this and other governments leaves no doubt that the Iraq regime continues to possess and conceal some of the most lethal weapons ever devised.” George W. Bush, Address to Nation, March 17, 2003
“We found the weapons of mass destruction. We found biological laboratories. And we’ll find more weapons as time goes on. But for those who say we haven’t found the banned manufacturing devices or banned weapons, they’re wrong. We found them.” George W. Bush, Interview with Polish TV, May 2003
The Facts
Now please go back and read those statements again—and notice their absolute certainty. They didn’t say Saddam Hussein “may” have weapons of mass destruction. They said there was “no doubt” he had them. They didn’t say, before the war, Saddam Hussein had weapons “programs.” They said he had “actual weapons of mass destruction.” They didn’t say Saddam “once” possessed WMD. They said he had them “now.” They didn’t say they were hidden “underground” in caves. They said the weapons had been moved to the front lines “to use against American troops.”
18
REASON #1
And they lied. Every last one of them lied, starting with President Bush. We now know that Saddam Hussein had no biological or chemical weapons. Yes, he had acquired them in the 1980s, from poisonous and disease-producing materials he had purchased from American firms, with the full knowledge and blessing of the United States. Yes, in the Iran–Iraq war, he used chemical weapons against Iranian troops and against the antiSaddam Kurdish population of northern Iraq. When he did so, the United States did nothing. Instead, we continued our support of Iraq against Iran. Donald Rumsfeld, then former secretary of defense, even flew to Baghdad and met with Saddam Hussein to reaffirm our support. But, as several sources now confirm, Saddam Hussein destroyed his stockpile of chemical and biological weapons after Desert Storm, because he feared getting caught by UN inspectors. From then on, he only bluffed about WMD to maintain his status in the Arab world. George W. Bush’s number one reason for invading Iraq was bogus. It was all what Senator Ted Kennedy called a fraud “made up in Texas.” David Kay, Bush’s own chief inspector, the man he sent to Iraq to find weapons of mass destruction, found none. “I think there were stockpiles at the end of the first Gulf War,” he told a Senate committee. “A combination of UN inspectors and unilateral Iraqi action got rid of them.” Kay also said he was sure we would never find any WMD, no matter how long we kept looking. And those famous mobile weapons labs Colin Powell warned the Security Council about? According to Kay, they were used to manufacture hydrogen for use in military weather balloons. The administration’s whole approach reminded David Kay of “The Boy Who Cried Wolf.” As he told ABC News on February 5, 2004: “There was no wolf.”
THE WAR
IN IRAQ
19
So what happened? How did Bush and Cheney get it so wrong? There are only two possibilities. Either they didn’t understand the intelligence they were given, or they willfully cherry-picked through the intelligence in order to make the strongest possible case for war. In other words, they were either incompetent or dishonest. Either way, Bush is responsible. Trying to shift the blame, President Bush is now trying to lay it all on various intelligence agencies, for giving him bad information. But that won’t wash. Intelligence is never an exact science. But the truth is that CIA and other agency reports were never as black-and-white as members of the administration portrayed them. Many of them expressed reservations about the existence of Saddam’s illegal weapons cache. And many of them actually contradicted the White House. Trying to defend his agents from accusations of botching prewar intelligence, a defensive CIA Director George Tenet insisted in a speech at Georgetown University on February 5, 2004: “They never said there was an imminent threat.” But the White House had no room for nuance. As early as the summer of 1995, Hussein Kamel, Saddam Hussein’s son-in-law and the highest-ranking Iraqi official ever to defect, told the CIA that, after Desert Storm, Iraq had destroyed all its chemical and biological weapons stocks and the missiles to deliver them. Turns out he was telling the truth, but nobody believed him. Okay, that was long before George W. Bush got to the White House. But, later, they had their own fair share of warnings that the worst case scenario they were painting was not based in fact. In September 2002, for example, while the Bush administration was starting to make the case for war, a Defense Intelligence Agency study on Iraq’s chemical weapons program stated that there was “no reliable information on whether Iraq
20
REASON #1
is producing and stockpiling chemical weapons.” The report also concluded: “A substantial amount of Iraq’s chemical warfare agents, precursors, munitions, and production equipment were destroyed between 1991 and 1998 as a result of Operation Desert Storm and UNSCOM actions”—the same conclusion later reached by David Kay. In December 2002, three months before the war, a classified report—prepared by a team of U.S. intelligence analysts, military officers and civilian Pentagon officials and sent to the National Security Council—warned of the possibility that Iraqi weapons of mass destruction might never be found. In February 2003, as American troops were already massing on the Iraqi border, a CIA report stated: “We do not have any direct evidence that Iraq has used the period since Desert Fox to reconstitute its Weapons of Mass Destruction programs.” No reliable evidence? Destroyed weapons? No direct evidence? You never heard any of those possibilities from Commander Bush, did you? George Bush wasn’t misled. He misled us. Here’s what happened. George Bush and Dick Cheney decided to go to war. Then they went out and “sexed-up” any available evidence to support it. What they couldn’t find, they manufactured. The Bush war team, in fact, never let lack of evidence get in the way. If intelligence agencies couldn’t make a strong enough case, the White House decided it would make it for them. Dick Cheney made repeated visits to CIA headquarters and badgered intelligence operatives into producing reports to support the administration’s drive to war. When the CIA didn’t deliver, Donald Rumsfeld set up his own intelligence operation at the Pentagon, the Office of Special Plans, with orders to sift through the information on Iraq, discard the doubtful and highlight the worst. Here’s how far they were willing to go. The CIA, the Pentagon and the State Department, we learned after the war, based
THE WAR
IN IRAQ
21
most of their dire warnings on information provided by Iraqi defectors loyal to Cheney pal Ahmed Chalabi, head of the Iraqi National Congress (INC). His followers, of course, had their own agenda: convincing the United States to overthrow Saddam Hussein to pave the way for Chalabi to become the new head of Iraq. So they made up stories about stockpiles of illegal weapons and poison-spreading drones. The frightening report of mobile weapons laboratories, for example, came from a Chalabi supporter and former major in the Iraqi intelligence service, who later admitted he had been “coached by the INC” on what to tell American investigators. It worked. Without checking their sources on what turned out to be wildly exaggerated claims—or without seeking confirmation from our own intelligence agencies—Bush, Cheney, Rumsfeld and Powell believed everything Chalabi’s agents told them. A major part of their case for war—repeated in Bush’s State of the Union address and Powell’s presentation to the United Nations—was based solely on lies told by Chalabi’s defectors. Chalabi, a member of the postwar Iraq Governing Council, today admits that he and his fellow thugs lied about everything. But, he insists, it was all done for a good reason. He even has the audacity to call his followers “heroes in error.” “As far as we’re concerned,” he told reporters in Baghdad on February 19, 2004, “we’ve been entirely successful.” And as of March 2004, on orders of an unrepentant Donald Rumsfeld, the Pentagon was still paying Chalabi’s operation $340,000 a month. Lies don’t come cheap. Of course, in all of his public warnings about weapons of mass destruction, President Bush never mentioned any of the doubts, caveats or uncertainties expressed in original intelligence reports. Otherwise, Americans might have come to suspect the truth. That’s also why he rejected the request of France, Germany
22
REASON #1
and Russia to give Hans Blix and his UN weapons inspectors more time. He was afraid that, if inspectors continued turning up nothing, members of Congress might conclude that Saddam Hussein, in fact, no longer had any weapons of mass destruction—and withdraw their support for his little war. In complete disregard for the truth, President Bush deliberately sorted through the available evidence about Iraq’s weapons of mass destruction, picked out only the worst of it and then exaggerated even that, in order to scare the shit out of the American people and win their support for the war. Why does it matter that there were no weapons of mass destruction found? Because, without WMD, George Bush’s entire foundation for sending our young men and women into battle was fraudulent. Even Secretary of State Colin Powell has, indirectly, conceded that point. In a February 2, 2004, interview, Glenn Kessler of the Washington Post asked Powell if he would still have recommended an invasion, knowing Iraq had no weapons of mass destruction. “I don’t know,” Powell replied, “because it was the stockpile that presented the final little piece that made it more of a real and present danger and threat to the region and to the world.” Without WMD, Powell admitted, the president’s entire case for war collapses. “The absence of a stockpile changes the political calculus,” he told the Post. “It changes the answer you get.” So what was President Bush’s response to the growing evidence that he lied about Iraq’s weapons of mass destruction? In true political fashion, in February 2004, he named a commission to investigate what happened. Except this is a Soviet-style investigation. George Bush appoints all the members. They report back to him. But they don’t report back until March 2005—six months after the November election. Therefore, there is zero accountability. Isn’t it amazing? As Jon Stewart pointed out on The Daily
THE WAR
IN IRAQ
23
Show, Janet Jackson bares her breast on TV and the FCC reacts the next day. President Bush lies about sending young Americans to die and nothing happens for over a year. When asked by Tim Russert on Meet the Press on February 8, 2004, why he didn’t ask for the commission’s work to be completed before November (Tony Blair’s similar inquiry will be completed in July 2004) President Bush had the nerve to say: “We didn’t want them to be hurried.”
Lie #4: Saddam’s Nuclear Weapons As scary as biological and chemical weapons are, they pale in importance compared to the big kahuna: nuclear weapons. I don’t care how big a peacenik you are—nobody wants a madman like Saddam Hussein playing around with a nuclear bomb. It was hard to oppose taking him out if he, indeed, had nukes. And President Bush left no doubt he did. What They Said
“Saddam Hussein has defied all these efforts and continues to develop weapons of mass destruction. The first time we may be completely certain he has a nuclear weapon is when, God forbid, he uses one.” George W. Bush, United Nations, September 12, 2002
“I would remind you that when the inspectors went into Iraq and were denied, finally denied access, a report came out of the Atomic—the IAEA, that they were six months away from developing a weapon. I don’t know what more evidence we need.” George W. Bush, News Conference with Tony Blair, September 7, 2002
24
REASON #1
“Iraq has made several attempts to buy high-strength aluminum tubes used to enrich uranium for a nuclear weapon.” George W. Bush, United Nations, September 12, 2002
“Today Saddam Hussein has the scientists and infrastructure for a nuclear weapons program, and has illicitly sought to purchase the equipment needed to enrich uranium for a nuclear weapon. Should his regime acquire fissile material, it would be able to build a nuclear weapon with a year. George W. Bush, Radio Address, September 14, 2002
“The British government has learned that Saddam Hussein recently sought significant quantities of uranium from Africa.” George W. Bush, State of Union, January 28, 2003
“Saddam Hussein has been absolutely devoted to trying to acquire nuclear weapons. And we believe he has, in fact, reconstituted nuclear weapons.” Dick Cheney, Meet the Press, March 16, 2003
“We have no indication that Saddam Hussein has ever abandoned his nuclear weapons program. On the contrary, we have more than a decade of proof that he remains determined to acquire nuclear weapons.” Colin Powell, United Nations, February 5, 2003
THE WAR
IN IRAQ
25
The Facts
Once again, note the absolute certainty: We don’t need any more evidence. He’s buying all the stuff necessary to make ’em. And he’s already got ’em. Except that it’s just not true. Every assertion by President Bush about Saddam Hussein’s nuclear weapons has been soundly disputed. Those aluminum tubes he warned about, which he claimed could only be used to enrich uranium? Even before President Bush’s speech to the United Nations, the State Department and the Energy Department had both debunked that idea. The International Atomic Energy Agency also ruled out their potential use in a nuclear program. And Chief Inspector David Kay later confirmed that the aluminium tubes were designed for conventional artillery rockets. Before he made his UN address, Bush had been informed there were serious doubts the aluminum tubes had anything to do with nuclear weapons. He asserted it anyway. How about Saddam’s buying yellowcake uranium from Niger? That was the explosive charge made by President Bush in the now infamous sixteen words of his January 28, 2003, State of the Union address, quoted above. But it had long before been proven untrue. Information that Saddam Hussein might be attempting to reconstitute his nuclear weapons program by purchasing yellowcake uranium from Niger was first reported to the CIA by British authorities, who had heard it from Italian intelligence agents. Vice President Dick Cheney demanded that the CIA check it out, so they sent former Ambassador Joseph Wilson to Niger to investigate. Wilson returned and reported it was phony baloney. Dr. Mohammed al-Baradei, head of the IAEA, did his own investigation and concluded the allegation was based on a set of clearly forged documents.
26
REASON #1
Armed with this new data, the CIA warned the White House about including the yellowcake charge in the State of the Union. But Bush did so anyway. At which point Wilson wrote an op-ed in the New York Times accusing the administration of ignoring his findings and deliberately misleading the American people. Administration officials later admitted that the accusation about yellowcake should not have been included in the president’s address to Congress, but they blamed it all on the CIA. Meanwhile, Ambassador Wilson paid the price for honesty by having his wife, a top secret CIA operative agent, outed to Crossfire’s Robert Novak by a vindictive, and still unknown, White House staffer. Build a nuclear weapon within a year? That was a figment of George Bush’s imagination. The classified National Intelligence Estimate of October 2002 estimated that, even if Iraqi scientists got their hands on fissile material, they were at best five to seven years from producing their first nuclear weapon. Besides, as former CIA analyst Kenneth Pollack, author of The Threatening Storm: The Case for Invading Iraq, wrote in the January/February 2004 Atlantic Monthly, it was unlikely Iraq could obtain weapons-grade material from any foreign source, anyway. They’d been trying to do so for twenty-five years, with no success. Iraq’s entire nuclear weapons program? Long ago disputed. Nobody believed it anymore, except maybe George W. Bush— who either believed it, or lied about it. As early as October 1997, the IAEA reported on its on-site inspections: “These verification activities have revealed no indications that Iraq had achieved its program objective of producing nuclear weapons . . . Furthermore, there are no indications that there remains in Iraq any physical capability for the production of weapon-usable nuclear material of any practical significance.” In fact, the IAEA noted, there were
THE WAR
IN IRAQ
27
much more serious nuclear threats in Iran, Libya and North Korea. In October 2002, the State Department’s Intelligence and Research Department publicly disagreed with warnings raised by other agencies, mainly the Pentagon, about Iraq’s nuclear program. “The activities we have detected do not add up to a compelling case that Iraq is currently pursuing what INR would consider to be an integrated and comprehensive approach to acquiring nuclear weapons.” In sum, there was no evidence to support the alarmist claims of President Bush about Iraq’s nuclear weapons, and no need to go to war to destroy a weapons program that did not exist. But even if there were no illegal weapons, Bush laid another powerful argument on the table: September 11.
Lie #5: Saddam’s Connection with Al Qaeda Remember September 11! That became George Bush’s rallying cry—and not just for retaliatory attacks against terrorists. As reported by Mike Allen in the Washington Post on September 11, 2003, two years after the attacks on the World Trade Center and the Pentagon, Bush invokes 9/11 when talking about almost any issue under the sun. Asked at a July 2003 news conference about plans to spend $170 billion on his reelection campaign, for example, Bush replied: “Every day, I’m reminded about what 9/11 means to America.” And on Labor Day that same year, explaining to union members why there were so many Americans out of work, he said: “I want you to think back to that fateful day, September the 11, and what happened afterwards.” September 11 became George Bush’s excuse for everything.
28
REASON #1
But nowhere did George Bush invoke that horrible day more than in making the case for war in Iraq. In order to justify the war, he knew he had to link Saddam Hussein to Osama bin Laden. And so, from the beginning, he painted the war in Iraq as part and parcel of the war on terror—which started on September 12, 2001, and was aimed at al Qaeda and their allies, including Saddam Hussein. What They Said
“This is a man that we know has had connections with al Qaeda. This is a man who, in my judgment, would like to use al Qaeda as a forward army.” George W. Bush, Dearborn, Michigan, October 14, 2002
“This is a man who has had contacts with al Qaeda. This is a man who poses a serious threat in many forms, but catch this form: He’s the kind of guy that would love nothing more than to train terrorists and provide arms to terrorists so they could attack his worst enemy and leave no fingerprints. This guy is a threat to the world.” George W. Bush, St. Paul, November 3, 2002
“This is a man who cannot stand America, he cannot stand what we stand for, he can’t stand some of our closest friends and allies. This is a man who has got connections with al Qaeda.” George W. Bush, Dallas, November 4, 2002
THE WAR
IN IRAQ
29
“What I have said is a fact—that there are al Qaeda in a number of locations in Iraq.” Donald Rumsfeld, Pentagon Briefing, August 21, 2002
“We clearly know that there were in the past and have been contacts between senior Iraqi officials and members of al Qaeda going back for actually quite a long time.” Condoleezza Rice, PBS, September 25, 2002
“But what I want to bring to your attention today is the potentially much more sinister nexus between Iraq and the al Qaeda network, a nexus that combines classic terrorist organizations and modern methods of murder.” Colin Powell, United Nations, February 5, 2003
The Facts
According to a TIME magazine poll of October 2002, 71 percent of Americans believed Saddam Hussein had been directly involved in the 9/11 attacks. No wonder. After listening to President Bush and other administration officials, you could be excused for believing that Saddam Hussein sat down with Osama bin Laden and helped plan the 9/11 attacks—or even flew one of the jets into the World Trade Center. Again, all of the evidence suggests just the opposite. First, there is the fact that, in the Muslim world, Saddam Hussein and Osama bin Laden are 180 degrees apart. Bin Laden is a fundamentalist freak who wants to restore the rule
30
REASON #1
of Islamic law throughout the Arab world—the kind of Muslim fanatic Hussein wanted nothing to do with. While Saddam was the very type of modern, secular, worldly, profane Arab leader bin Laden wanted to get rid of. They hated each other. There is no record of their having ever met, let alone having collaborated on anything. In one of his recorded messages, bin Laden names Saddam Hussein among the enemies of true Islam. The only “evidence” offered of any Iraq–al Qaeda connection was a meeting—originally reported by Czech officials— that allegedly took place in Prague, in April 2001, between September 11 mastermind Mohammed Atta and a senior member of the Iraqi intelligence agency. However, the Czech government later told the White House there was no evidence to confirm that meeting ever took place. And the CIA and FBI searched all his travel records and determined that Atta was actually in Virginia Beach at that time. Ironically, in his presentation to the Security Council, Colin Powell cited the presence of the Ansar al-Islam terrorist group in northern Iraq as further proof of Saddam Hussein’s terrorist connections. Powell knew better. Ansar al-Islam was a radical Islamist group headquartered in Kurdish territory and under the umbrella of the U.S./British no-fly zones—an area over which Saddam Hussein had no control. Their goal was to establish an independent Islamic state in northern Iraq. And, on one of their training videos, their leader refers to Saddam Hussein as “a real monster and not a real Muslim.” In fact, the evidence of any link between Saddam Hussein and September 11 was so thin that, one by one, every one of the war hawks ran away from it. Tony Blair was the first. He told reporters on January 21, 2003, two months before the beginning of the war: “The truth is, there is no information I have that directly links Iraq to September 11.”
THE WAR
IN IRAQ
31
After the war was over, President Bush followed Blair’s lead. Sort of. “We have no evidence that Saddam Hussein was involved with the September 11 attacks,” he said. Although he still insisted: “There’s no question that Saddam Hussein had al Qaeda ties.” But he didn’t offer any evidence. Finally, even Colin Powell threw in the towel. Earlier he had warned the United Nations: “Iraqi officials deny accusations of ties with al Qaeda. These denials are simply not credible.” In January 2004, he admitted that: “I have seen no smoking gun, no concrete evidence about the connection” between the government of Iraqi president Saddam Hussein and terrorists of al Qaeda. Now we know the truth: 1. Saddam Hussein was in no way connected to Osama bin Laden and in no way responsible for the September 11 attacks. And we also know: 2. Planning for the war in Iraq had, in fact, begun long before September 11. 3. The war in Iraq was not part of the war on terror—it was a long and costly distraction from the war on terror. Eyes on Iraq Before September 11
When did the United States start thinking about overthrowing Saddam Hussein? There’s no fixed date. But there’s no doubt about this: It started long before September 11. The first public call for overthrowing Saddam Hussein came in 1987—from Richard Perle, shortly after leaving his job as assistant secretary of defense under President Reagan.
32
REASON #1
For three years, until his resignation in February 2004, Perle also served as a member of President Bush’s Defense Policy Board. In 1996, Perle and fellow neoconservatives prepared a position paper for Benjamin Netanyahu, newly elected Prime Minister of Israel. Their report, titled “A Clean Break,” recommended “removing Saddam Hussein from power” and “weakening, containing and even rolling back Syria.” The road to peace in Israel, they argued, led from Baghdad to Damascus to Tehran—and then to Jerusalem. Joining Perle as coauthors of the report were Douglas Feith, now undersecretary of defense for policy, and David Wurmser, today special assistant to Undersecretary of State John Bolton. In 1997, Zalmay Khalilzad and Paul Wolfowitz argued for the ouster of Saddam Hussein in an article in The Weekly Standard entitled “Overthrow Him.” Wolfowitz is now deputy secretary of defense and Khalilzad is a special envoy to Afghanistan and Iraq. Coincidence? I think not. In 1998, a posse of leading neoconservatives sent an open letter to President Clinton, urging him to take military action against Iraq. American policy, they argued, “should aim, above all, at the removal of Saddam Hussein’s regime from power.” Clinton was advised “to take the necessary steps, including military steps, to protect our vital interests in the Gulf.” In addition to Perle, Wolfowitz, Feith and Khalilzad, other members of the Bush administration who signed the letter to Clinton included Defense Secretary Donald Rumsfeld, Deputy Secretary of State Richard Armitage, Undersecretary of State for Arms Control John Bolton and Undersecretary of Defense Dov Zakheim. Clearly, that cabal of neocons walked into the Bush administration with a fixed agenda: Get rid of Saddam Hussein. And they didn’t waste any time making it official administration policy.
THE WAR
IN IRAQ
33
As first reported by Jane Mayer in The New Yorker, a top secret National Security Council document dated February 3, 2001, instructed NSC staff to cooperate with Vice President Dick Cheney’s Energy Task Force. The melding of national security and energy staffs was important, said the directive, because the focus of Cheney’s group included “the review of operational policies toward rogue states” such as Iraq—and “actions regarding the capture of new and existing oil and gas fields.” Who knew? Cheney wasn’t just planning on how to drill for oil in Alaska. He was already plotting how to take over the oil fields of Iraq. More evidence. According to former Treasury Secretary Paul O’Neill—whom President Bush praised as a “straight shooter”—war against Iraq was discussed at the very first meeting of Bush’s National Security Council—eight full months before September 11. In The Price of Loyalty, O’Neill says that from day one the administration decided to remove Saddam Hussein and then looked for the opportunity and reasons for doing so. “From the start, we were building the case against Hussein and looking at how we could take him out and change Iraq into a new country,” he told author Ron Suskind. “And, if we did that, it would solve everything. It was about finding a way to do it. That was the tone of it. The President saying, ‘Fine. Go find me a way to do this.’ ” The opportunity came on September 11, 2001. As recounted by Bob Woodward in Bush at War, on September 12, when President Bush met with the National Security Council to decide how to respond to the previous day’s attacks on America—even though not one Iraqi national was among the nineteen hijackers and there was zero evidence Saddam Hussein was involved—Rumsfeld and Wolfowitz recommended an invasion of Iraq.
34
REASON #1
It wasn’t just Rumsfeld and Wolfowitz who made the early leap to Iraq. According to Bush’s own former counterterrorism czar, it was President Bush himself. In his book Against All Enemies, Clarke tells of meeting the president in the White House Situation Room on the evening of September 12—an exchange first denied, then confirmed by National Security Advisor Condoleezza Rice. Clarke says the president grabbed him and a few others, closed the door to the conference room and gave them his orders. Quoting directly from Clarke’s book: “Look,” he told us. “I know you have a lot to do and all . . . but I want you, as soon as you can, to go back over everything, everything. See if Saddam did this. See if he’s linked in any way . . .” I was once again taken aback, incredulous, and it showed. “But, Mr. President, al Qaeda did this.” “I know, I know,” said Bush, “but . . . see if Saddam was involved. Just look. I want to know any shred . . .” “Absolutely, we will look . . . again.” I was trying to be more respectful, more responsive. “But, you know, we have looked several times for state sponsorship of al Qaeda and not found any real linkages to Iraq. Iran plays a little, as does Pakistan, and Saudi Arabia, Yemen.” “Look into Iraq, Saddam,” the president said testily and left us. By the following weekend, in a war summit at Camp David, the decision to invade Iraq had already been made. As Paul Wolfowitz related to Sam Tannenhaus of Vanity Fair: “There was a long discussion during the day about what place if any Iraq should have in a counterterrorist strategy. On the surface of the debate it at least appeared to be about not whether but when. There seemed to be a kind of agreement that yes it
THE WAR
IN IRAQ
35
should be, but the disagreement was whether it should be in the immediate response, or whether you should concentrate simply on Afghanistan first.” Clearly, plans for the war in Iraq had been made way ahead of time and left sitting on the shelf—waiting for the right opportunity for Wolfowitz and Rumsfeld to hand them to Bush. The president put them back on the shelf, but only until he had taken care of Afghanistan. Once President Bush was ready to uncork his own plans for invading Iraq, he waited until the perfect moment, September 2002. After all, as White House Chief of Staff Andrew Card told the New York Times, “From a marketing point of view, you don’t introduce new products in August.” No, from a cynical point of view, you wait until the first anniversary of September 11. Then, for the next six months, Bush barnstormed around the country like a traveling salesman, selling his war. He professed not to know yet what to do about Iraq. But, in fact, he was just trying to drum up support for a decision he had already made, over a year earlier. Time Out from the War On Terror
The vast majority of Americans, myself included, supported the president in his determination to wipe out terrorism. We supported the invasion of Afghanistan. That war was wise, necessary and justified—everything the war in Iraq was not. It was in his State of the Union address on January 29, 2002, when President Bush suddenly changed the subject. He never once mentioned al Qaeda or Osama bin Laden. Instead, he singled out Iran, North Korea and Iraq as members of the “axis of evil.” Why Iraq? Again, there was no connection between Saddam Hussein and Osama bin Laden. Even President Bush now
36
REASON #1
admits that. There were no terrorists hiding in Iraq. There were no training camps in Iraq. There is no evidence Iraq funneled any weapons to terrorists. CIA Director George Tenet indirectly questioned the president’s new focus. Less than a week after the 2002 State of the Union, he told the Senate Select Committee on Intelligence that the al Qaeda terrorist network, not Iraq, was “the most immediate and serious threat” to the United States. There is no way the war in Iraq can be considered part of the war on terror. In fact, it may have undercut the war on terror—by draining away scarce resources, by diverting attention from the real enemy and by generating more hatred of America and more terrorist acts against Americans around the world. Not to mention giving terrorists another place to attack American troops: Iraq. Speaking at New York University on August 7, 2003, former Vice President Al Gore raised other problems caused by going to Iraq. Noting that a congressional investigation had just concluded that Saddam Hussein had nothing whatsoever to do with September 11, Gore told his audience: “Therefore, whatever other goals it served—and it did serve some other goals—the decision to invade Iraq made no sense as a way of exacting revenge for 9/11. To the contrary, the U.S. pulled significant intelligence resources out of Pakistan and Afghanistan in order to get ready for the rushed invasion of Iraq and that disrupted the search for Osama at a critical time. And the indifference we showed to the rest of the world’s opinion in the process undermined the global cooperation we need to win the war against terrorism.” That same conclusion was reached by at least one person high up in the Bush White House. Richard A. Clarke, Bush’s point person on terrorism, writes in Against All Enemies: “Many thought that the Bush administration was doing a good
THE WAR
IN IRAQ
37
job of fighting terrorism when, actually, the administration had squandered the opportunity to eliminate al Qaeda and instead strengthened our enemies by going off on a completely unnecessary tangent, the invasion of Iraq.” And these critiques were echoed by voices within the very walls of the Pentagon. A report published by the U.S. Army War College in January 2004 accused the Bush administration of taking a dangerous detour from the war on terror into an “unnecessary” war in Iraq. Authored by Professor Jeffrey Record of the Air War College at Maxwell Air Force Base in Alabama, the War College document contends that Saddam Hussein was already contained and did not represent a threat to the United States. The war in Iraq, record concludes, was a “war-of-choice distraction from the war-of-necessity against al Qaeda.” Go figure. Al Qaeda attacked the United States. We started out after al Qaeda. Then we suddenly changed course and made a huge, unnecessary, costly detour to Iraq. This made no sense.
Lie #6: Imminent Threat to the United States The reason George Bush gave for diverting from the war on terror and taking on Saddam Hussein, of course, was that Iraq presented an immediate, serious threat to the United States. What They Said
“The danger is clear: using chemical, biological, or, one day, nuclear weapons, obtained with the help of Iraq, the terrorists could . . . kill thousands or hundreds of thousands of innocent people in our country.” George W. Bush, Address to Nation, March 17, 2003
38
REASON #1
“Saddam Hussein is a threat to America.” George W. Bush, Springfield, Illinois, November 3, 2002
“The Iraqi regime is a threat of unique urgency.” George W. Bush, Rose Garden, October 2, 2002
“The danger to our country is grave. The danger to our country is growing.” George W. Bush, Rose Garden, September 26, 2002
“Saddam’s pursuit of weapons of mass destruction poses a grave danger—not only to his neighbors, but also to the United States.” Dick Cheney, Conservative Political Action Conference, January 30, 2003
“No terrorist state poses a greater or more immediate threat to the security of our people and the stability of the world then the regime of Saddam Hussein in Iraq.” Donald Rumsfeld, Congressional Testimony, September 19, 2002
“This is about imminent threat.” Press Secretary Scott McClellan, White House Briefing, February 10, 2003
Today, whenever he is asked about these past statements, President Bush, like some little third-grader, stomps his foot and declares: “I never said imminent! I never said imminent! I never said imminent!” The strongest language he ever used,
THE WAR
IN IRAQ
39
Bush insists, was that Saddam Hussein was a “grave and gathering threat to America and the world.” Nonsense. Whatever word or words he or his top team used—grave, gathering, unique, urgent or imminent—there was no doubt what message they sent to the American people. Saddam Hussein was so serious a threat that we could not allow UN inspectors any more time. We had to act immediately. And that, my friends, is George Bush’s most absurd argument of all. The Facts
What if I told you all this about big bad Iraq . . . 1. In 2001, Iraq spent $1.4 billion on its military. The United States spent $330 billion. 2. Iraq had no navy. 3. Iraq’s air force consisted of a fleet of aging Soviet aircraft that were at best 55 percent combat ready. 4. Those planes that could fly were limited to less than 40 percent of Iraqi territory. Over 60 percent of Iraq’s airspace was contained in “no-fly” zones patrolled by U.S. and UK fighter planes. 5. Iraq’s army consisted of 350,000 troops, the vast majority of whom were poorly trained conscripts. 6. The army was equipped with outdated Soviet arms and tanks, reported at maximum 50 percent combat effectiveness. Would you believe that country to be a threat to the United States? Of course not. No wonder our troops cut through them like butter.
40
REASON #1
Okay. Forget conventional weapons. If the Iraqis had weapons of mass destruction, it might have been a threat to the United States. But, as we have already seen, they didn’t. If they had long-range missiles, as President Bush charged, Iraq might have been a threat. But they didn’t. And what about that fleet of “unmanned aerial vehicles” President Bush warned about? In October 2002, he warned they “could be used to disperse chemical and biological weapons across broad areas.” And, he said, they were aimed directly at the United States. “We are concerned that Iraq is exploring ways of using these UAVs for missions targeting the United States.” Damned right. If they had those long-range UAVs, that would make Iraq a threat to the continental United States. Except they didn’t. American officials later admitted the drones had a maximum range of several hundred miles. There is no way Iraq was a threat, imminent or otherwise, to this country. Now, that was number 6. The last of the six lies George Bush told before the war. But we can’t close this chapter without mentioning the big lie he and Dick Cheney told about what would happen after the war. So here goes . . .
Lie #7: Welcomed as Liberators Leading up to the war in Iraq, a lot of people were asking: “Okay, we now know there’s no turning back. We’re going to war. But what’s the exit strategy? Will we have to keep troops there? How long? And how dangerous will it be?” Senator Joe Biden, ranking Democrat on the Foreign Affairs Committee, predicted American troops would have to remain in Iraq as long as ten years. The Bush administration had one response to all of those worry warts: Chill. No problem. Piece of cake. American troops wouldn’t be there long and they wouldn’t be in trouble.
THE WAR
IN IRAQ
41
Dick Cheney went even further. Appearing on Meet the Press on March 16, 2002, he told Tim Russert: “The Iraqis are desperate to get rid of Saddam Hussein and they will welcome as liberators the United States when we come to do that.” The vice president said that because that’s what his buddy Ahmed Chalabi told him. But Cheney should have known better than to trust Chalabi. And so should Donald Rumsfeld and George W. Bush. Because they believed Chalabi—about how warmly Americans would be welcomed, as well about Saddam’s possession of weapons of mass destruction—U.S. troops were sent to Iraq without any postwar plan and without proper support or protection. No sooner had the war ended than they became sitting ducks for disgruntled supporters of Saddam Hussein. On May 1, 2003, when President Bush was landed on the USS Abraham Lincoln and declared major combat operations over, the death toll in Iraq was 138. As of this writing, April 2004, over 470 more American troops have been killed by bombs or sniper fire in what was promised to be “friendly” Iraq. For the administration, trusting Chalabi turned out to be a bloody, costly, tragic mistake—and one for which George W. Bush must be held responsible.
A War of Choice One year later, it is clearer than ever. The war in Iraq was not a war George Bush had to fight in order to protect the United States. This was a war George Bush chose to fight. And George Bush made the wrong choice. This war, though not the occupation, is now behind us. And
42
REASON #1
any election must be about the future. But we can never go forward with someone who did the worst thing any president could to. We can never trust the future to any president who misled us into war. For lying the United States into a costly and unnecessary war in Iraq, GEORGE BUSH MUST GO!
REASON # TWO
The War on Terror: He Has Made Us Less Safe from Terrorism “We cannot let terrorists and rogue nations hold this nation hostile or hold our allies hostile.” George W. Bush, August 21, 2000
In January 2002, White House political chief Karl Rove spoke about the war on terror to a meeting of the Republican National Committee: “We can go to the country on this issue because they trust the Republican Party to do a better job of protecting and strengthening America’s military might and thereby protecting America.” In his first campaign fundraising letter, May 2003, President Bush wrote: “I’ll be depending on friends and supporters like you to get my campaign organized and operating across our country. We have no more urgent and important duty than to wage and win the War on Terrorism.” In selecting a site for their 2004 convention, the Republican National Committee decided to go to New York City for the first time in their 150-year history. As part of convention activities, there will be a memorial service held at Ground Zero. And they deliberately scheduled the convention later than it’s ever been held, from August 29 to September 4—in order to coincide with the third anniversary of September 11.
44
REASON #2
The first Bush campaign commercials, which began airing the first week of March 2004, showed footage of firemen carrying bodies out of the rubble at Ground Zero. And, in his first attack ad against John Kerry, which began airing less than one week later, President Bush said: “Now we face a choice. We can go forward with confidence, resolve and hope. Or we can turn back to the dangerous illusion that terrorists are not plotting and outlaw regimes are no threat.” Now, I don’t know anybody who believes that “terrorists are not plotting,” but in any case, the point is clear: George Bush wants the 2004 election decided on the issue of homeland security. In so doing, of course, he is breaking a pledge he made to a bipartisan meeting of congressional leaders at the White House on January 23, 2002: “I have no ambition whatsoever to use national security as a political issue.” He can’t defend his record on jobs, the economy, deficits, health care, education and Social Security. So he is trying to win reelection on the backs of three thousand people killed on September 11. As Bush told Tim Russert on February 8, 2004: “I’m a war president.” He believes the war on terror is the issue voters care most about, and it’s the issue he himself talks and brags about the most: “We learned a lesson on September the 11th,” Bush told reporters in August 2003, “and that is, our nation is vulnerable to attack. And we’re doing everything we can to protect the homeland.” Sounds good. But it’s all bunk. The truth is, even on his self-proclaimed number one issue, George Bush has failed to deliver. In many ways, he has made us less safe—by failing to take necessary precautionary measures at home, and by stirring up more anti-American hatred abroad. He abandoned the hunt for al Qaeda in favor of an illconceived, unwise and unnecessary invasion of Iraq. And he
THE WAR
ON
TERROR
45
did little or nothing to put in place the security measures we need here in the United States to protect the homeland from future attacks. Instead he created a huge new government agency. Because he boasts about it so often, many Americans believe the president is pulling out all the stops to protect us. But, in fact, the closer you look at George Bush’s so-called homeland protection program, the more you realize it is all smoke and mirrors— like one of those old Hollywood western movie sets. Nothing is real. Just phony building fronts, propped up for effect.
Failing to Recognize the Threat Richard Clarke stirred up a firestorm by accusing the Bush administration of not taking terrorism seriously enough prior to September 11. It was an “important” issue for them, he acknowledged, but not an “urgent” one. The White House responded with a campaign of character assassination against Clarke the likes of which had never been seen before, not even in a town that specializes in destroying people. Dick Cheney, Don Rumsfeld, Colin Powell, Condoleezza Rice, President Bush and even First Lady Laura Bush all jumped up to tear Clarke down. But they couldn’t refute Clarke’s eyewitness testimony—because he told the truth. Clarke was a bulldog on terrorism. No president, he believed—and he served under four of them—took the threat of terrorism seriously enough. However, Clarke did convince President Clinton to take certain steps. After al Qaeda blew up our embassies in Kenya and Tanzania, Clinton made terrorism the administration’s number one priority. He sent 60 cruise missiles raining down on an al Qaeda training camp in Afghanistan. He gave the CIA a green light to find and assassinate Osama bin Laden. And, under Clinton’s direction, National Security Advisor Sandy Berger held daily “principal”
46
REASON #2
meetings in the White House—with the heads of defense, state, justice, the FBI and the CIA—to chart progress in tracking down al Qaeda terrorists, at home and abroad. As related by Clarke—the man in charge—that focus and that sense of urgency disappeared once George W. Bush arrived. Clarke briefed Cheney and new Security Adviser Condoleezza Rice on terror. Nothing happened. He asked to brief the president. He was refused. He pressed Rice to continue Berger’s practice of daily meetings of principals to pursue the Clinton’s administration goal of lessening the threat of al Qaeda. He was told to come up with a new plan, instead—to eliminate al Qaeda. Meanwhile, despite growing warnings during the summer of 2001 about a colossal attack against Americans, there were no meetings held and no action taken—not even when the president was told on August 6 that al Qaeda might hijack a plane and fly them into American buildings. Finally, on September 4—one week before September 11— a meeting of principals was held. They approved the outline Clarke had presented to Rice way back in January 2001 and forwarded the plan to the president. The same day, a frustrated Clarke sent a letter to Rice, urging her and other White House policy makers “to imagine a day after a terrorist attack, with hundreds of Americans dead at home and abroad, and ask themselves what they could have done better.” Bush and others attacked Clarke so viciously because his testimony undercut the main theme of the president’s reelection campaign: that he walked into the Oval Office tough on terrorism and has been tough ever since. But Clarke’s testimony, as powerful as it is, does not stand alone. There is additional evidence, some made public long before Clarke ever published his book, that the Bush administration initially failed to take terrorism seriously.
THE WAR
ON
TERROR
47
On August 9, 2001, Attorney General John Ashcroft released the Justice Department’s new “Strategic Plan.” He did not rank fighting terrorism as one of the department’s seven main goals—even though his predecessor, Janet Reno, had called terrorism “the most challenging threat in the criminal justice area.” Just weeks before the September 11 attacks, the FBI asked Attorney General John Ashcroft for $588 million to beef up their efforts to fight terrorism by hiring 54 translators and 248 new counterterrorism agents. Ashcroft turned them down, and the White House backed him up. At that time, terrorism wasn’t worth spending more money on. And even after September 11, as shown in documents released to the Washington Post by the Center for American Progress, Bush was still pinching pennies in fighting terrorism. On October 12, 2001, responding to the September 11 attacks, the FBI asked for $1.5 billion in additional funds for counterterrorism. The White House cut their request down to $531 million. Who knows? If only Bush had listened to Clarke, if only Rice had made terrorism a top priority, if only Ashcroft had given the FBI the help it needed—maybe those warnings during the summer of 2001 would have been acted upon—and maybe the horror of September 11 could have been avoided. WAR IN IRAQ—THE BIG DISTRACTION The number one reason why President Bush has failed in the war on terror is that he abandoned the course—and led the country into a huge distraction in Iraq. Think back to the spring of 2002. The war in Afghanistan had been successful. The Taliban was out of power, and American ally Hamid Karzai was in. A worldwide coalition of nations
48
REASON #2
supported the efforts of the United States to hunt down and punish the perpetrators of September 11. And al Qaeda’s training camps had already been destroyed. But, most importantly, we had Osama bin Laden on the run. He and his remaining lieutenants were locked down in the mountains of Afghanistan, somewhere along the Pakistani border, and American intelligence agents and military were closing in. Then, suddenly, the Bush administration shifted gears—and shifted both attention and resources to Iraq—which had nothing to do with pursuing al Qaeda. As a result, bin Laden escaped, free to continue his evil ways. And, while the United States was preoccupied with Iraq, al Qaeda has enjoyed a resurgence, recruiting more young terrorists around the world—witness the March 2004 bombings in Madrid. That has created many more clear and present dangers to American lives and freedoms than Saddam Hussein ever did. There have been more bombings by al Qaeda and its terrorist allies in the two and a half years since September 11 than there were in the two and a half years before. As reported by columnist Joe Klein in the February 15, 2004, issue of TIME, the detour to Iraq has generated concern inside U.S. intelligence agencies that our larger campaign against terrorism has actually been retarded as a result. “Our actions in Iraq have caused a net increase in terrorists,” one intelligence gatherer anonymously told Klein. “We’ve gotten better at finding and killing them. But there are a lot more Islamic young people with a desire to fight us.” A point echoed by Charles Pena, director of defense policy studies for the Cato Institute, in a December 2003 position paper: “The U.S. occupation of Iraq makes the radical Islamists’ case that the West is invading Islam, which only encourages the Muslim world to unite against the United States.” Most significantly, those same concerns—about what we
THE WAR
ON
TERROR
49
lost by turning our attention to Iraq—have been expressed by several members of the U.S. Senate and by President Bush’s own former point man on terrorism. Richard Clarke left the White House in March 2003, having also served under Presidents Reagan, Bush and Clinton. In his book, Against All Enemies, he laments: “A new al Qaeda has emerged and is growing stronger, in part because of our own actions and inactions. It is in many ways a tougher opponent than we faced before September 11 and we are not doing what is necessary to make America safer from that threat.” Clarke notes the irony of President Bush’s election-year boast of “fighting terrorists in Iraq so that we don’t have to fight them in the streets of America.” “He never points out,” Clarke observes correctly, “that our being in Iraq does nothing to prevent terrorists from coming to America, but does divert funds from addressing our domestic vulnerabilities and does make terrorism recruitment easier.” In the Senate, no one has spoken out more forcefully on this issue than Florida’s Bob Graham, former chairman of the Senate Intelligence Committee. “Are we safer because Saddam Hussein is in jail? Yes,” he told me in an interview for this book. “But what did we give up in order to go after Hussein? We gave up our focus on the areas that are really dangerous. And we gave up our focus on the war on terror.” In effect, George W. Bush took a year out from the war on terror to fight his war in Iraq. And that has had serious consequences. The fact is: The Iraq war has made us more vulnerable to terrorism, not less. Most terrorism experts agree. After crushing al Qaeda in Afghanistan, in weighing what further military action to take in response to September 11, there were three tests: (1) which of the evil forces out there had the capacity to kill Americans, meaning people trained to carry out terrorist attacks, (2) which
50
REASON #2
groups had the will, or desire to attack America and (3) which groups were represented by terrorists inside the United States or close enough to be able to strike American soil. Iraq flunked all three of the tests. Even if Saddam Hussein did have WMD and the will to drop them on Atlantic City, Seattle or Topeka, he did not have the means to deliver them. And he had no death squads in or near the United States. Nevertheless, Bush used the events of 9/11 as pretext for putting all his attention on Iraq, rather than focusing on those areas that represented real dangers of proliferation—starting with the former Soviet Union.
Russia and Nunn-Lugar In terms of weapons of mass destruction, the most dangerous threat by far was, and remains, Russia. If there’s any place terrorists might easily get their hands on existing, off-the-shelf, ready-to-go weapons of mass destruction, it’s the former Soviet Union—with its combination of enormous stockpiles of illicit weapons and weak security. President Bush might understand this, if he had only listened to the Republican chairman of the Senate Foreign Relations Committee, Richard Lugar of Indiana. “I have no doubt that Osama bin Laden and al Qaeda will use weapons of mass destruction if they are able to steal, buy, or build them,” said Lugar after September 11, but before the Iraq war. “And where are they most likely to be able to steal or buy them? Russia.” It’s the same warning sounded in January 2001 by a bipartisan task force on security issues headed by former Republican Senator Howard Baker and former Clinton White House Counsel Lloyd Cutler. They called Russia’s unspent and unguarded stockpiles of nuclear weapons “the most urgent unmet national security threat to the United States today.”
THE WAR
ON
TERROR
51
But the U.S. Senate actually recognized the problem and started dealing with it a decade earlier. In 1991, Congress enacted the Nunn-Lugar Cooperative Threat Reduction Program— named after Republican Lugar and Democrat Sam Nunn—a program designed to lessen the threat posed by WMD by locating, deactivating and destroying existing stockpiles, starting in Russia. By the time George W. Bush took office, it had been hugely successful: dismantling 6,212 Russian nuclear warheads. It had destroyed an additional 520 intercontinental ballistic missiles, 451 ICBM silos, 624 nuclear air-launched cruise missiles, 445 submarine-launched ballistic missiles, 408 SLBM launchers, 27 strategic missile submarines. Nunn-Lugar teams had also removed all nuclear weapons from the former Soviet Republics of Ukraine, Belarus and Kazakhstan. Then George W. Bush took over and stopped Nunn-Lugar dead in its tracks. He cut its budget by $140 million in 2002, and shut down the program for eight months. In January 2003, he reluctantly allowed the program to resume, but with severely reduced funding and still limited to Russia. Despite the progress made so far under Nunn-Lugar, Russia remains the most dangerous place in the world today—the easiest place for terrorists to obtain weapons of mass destruction. Only one-half of Russia’s nuclear missiles have been dismantled. It also has enormous stashes of chemical weapons and biological pathogens, tactical nuclear weapons, stores of plutonium, dirty nuclear reactors and decommissioned nuclear submarines—all protected by minimal security. Senator Graham told me of visiting one former biological weapons lab where vials of anthrax were stored in an old refrigerator. The only security measure in place was a string tied around the refrigerator, apparently to dissuade any potential terrorist from opening it. In February 2004, facing reelection, Bush finally woke up
52
REASON #2
and agreed to expand Nunn-Lugar beyond Russia. But, once again, he didn’t put his money where his mouth was. Senator Lugar estimates the cost to get rid of these very real threats at $2 billion a year. The president budgeted only $451 million in FY 2004 and, despite his newfound rhetorical devotion to the cause of cleanup, even less, $409 million, for FY 2005. So there you have George Bush’s ass-backwards program for protecting us from weapons of mass destruction: • In 2004, he’ll spend at least $100 billion in Iraq, where no weapons of mass destruction have been found. • In 2005, he proposes spending only $409 million in Russia, where there are still thousands of known and unprotected weapons of mass destruction. As Senator Graham says, “If we had spent a fraction of what we spent in Iraq on Nunn-Lugar, we’d be enormously safer today.”
Sideshow in Iraq President Bush never mentions the war in Iraq without invoking September 11. Of course not. He’s got to justify his war of choice somehow. But, as we saw in the last chapter, there is simply no connection. There is no evidence that Saddam Hussein played any role in September 11. There is no record of terrorist activity inside Iraq. There is no evidence of any significant contacts between the Iraqi government and al Qaeda. To the contrary, there is ample evidence Osama bin Laden and Saddam Hussein did not trust each other, because one was a secular Arab despot and the other was the most extreme of Islamic fundamentalist bigots.
THE WAR
ON
TERROR
53
But the gang of hardliners around the president—Cheney, Rumsfeld, Wolfowitz and Perle, if not the president himself— had had designs on invading Iraq ever since the end of Desert Storm. They were looking for an opportunity to take Saddam out, and September 11 provided the perfect cover. When, immediately after the war in Afghanistan, Bush endorsed the invasion of Iraq, he called it the next step in the war on terror and claimed a Saddam–al Qaeda connection. Why? Because he knew that linking the war in Iraq to the war on terror was the only way he could justify it. In so doing, he badly misled the American people. Iraq was not the main arena of terror in the world. It was only a sideshow, at best. There were no terrorist attacks inside Iraq— until George Bush’s war was over.
Terrorists Discover Iraq Yet, unfortunately, Bush’s prophecy of Iraqi terrorism was self-fulfilling. If there was no terrorism in Iraq before the war, there was plenty as soon as the war was over. Iraq suddenly became the terrorists’ favorite new killing field, and would-be terrorists have flocked to Iraq from around the world, eager to take potshots at America’s sons and daughters. On the Senate floor, West Virginia’s Robert Byrd noted the irony: “The president has now stated that the war in Iraq is the central front on the war against terrorism. But it was our invasion of Iraq which has turned that nation into a staging ground for daily terrorist attacks against our occupation forces.” In fact, it wasn’t until after the war that there was actual evidence of an al Qaeda operative in Iraq. Files discovered by U.S. forces showed that Abu Musab al-Zarqawi—a Jordanian long suspected of ties to al Qaeda—had moved into Iraq and was actively directing terrorist attacks on American occupation
54
REASON #2
forces. And that may be the ultimate folly of George W. Bush’s invasion of Iraq. Where there were no al Qaeda terrorists before, there are now. And they’re killing American troops almost daily. This is what Bush calls progress in the war on terror. THE HOME FRONT: LOTS OF TALK, NO ACTION But the war in Iraq is not the only way George Bush has fumbled the war on terror. He has also failed here at home—by misdirecting resources or simply abandoning the field. There’s a good reason we don’t feel more secure after 9/11—the domestic war on terror is a hollow promise.
Accountability for September 11 Let’s start with what obviously went wrong before 9/11— and what’s been done to correct it. There was, first of all, a huge intelligence failure. As we learned, there had been warnings, as early as 1995, of al Qaeda plans to hijack airliners and fly them into American buildings. Two of the hijackers were spotted at a terrorist summit meeting in Malaysia and traced back to San Diego, then forgotten. In July 2001, FBI agents in Phoenix warned headquarters of several young Arab men taking flying lessons. In August, FBI agents arrested Zaccarias Moussaoui for expressing unusual interest in how to steer a jumbo jet, but not how to take off or land. And on August 6, President Bush was warned in his daily security briefing that al Qaeda might try to hijack airplanes and attack America. It’s pretty obvious that nobody connected the dots. The problem is: Nobody was held responsible. Not one head has rolled at the CIA or FBI because of failure to follow up on all those warnings, track down the potential terrorists and infiltrate their organizations.
THE WAR
ON
TERROR
55
Brian Sullivan, a former security specialist for the FAA, and one of the first to warn of weaknesses in security at Boston’s Logan Airport, laments: “Without accountability, we’ll never achieve a sense of justice for the victims’ families and we’ll never change the culture of bureaucracy which prevented our government from achieving its most important mission—that of protecting its citizenry. Not a single person—no one in the FBI, CIA, DOT or FAA—has been held accountable for the most dismal failure in our history since Pearl Harbor.” George Bush, in fact, continues to express confidence in CIA Director George Tenet. Why? The CIA blew it pre-9/11, and blew it again on Iraq’s weapons of mass destruction. Bush should have fired Tenet a long time ago—and would have, except he’s afraid that Tenet would let the cat out of the bag on how the White House “sexed up” the intelligence on Iraq provided them by the CIA. The second obvious failing before September 11 was that terrorists were able to obtain visas in the first place and, in some cases, enter and leave the country freely on fraudulent visas. Adding insult to injury, ringleader Mohammed Atta’s renewed visa was mailed to him by an incompetent INS—six months after 9/11. So what’s been done to correct this glaring loophole? Nothing. Some authority for visas has been transferred from INS to the new Department of Homeland Security; the rest remains with the State Department. Needless to say, dividing responsibility up between two departments is probably not the best way to achieve efficiency, or accuracy. And our borders remain an open door. Once in a while border agents get lucky, like when they caught the guy with a carload of explosives headed for Los Angeles in 1999. But most of the time our borders, north and south, are an easy and inviting opportunity for those seeking to enter the country illegally.
56
REASON #2
Congressman David Obey points out that as late as one year after September 11 there were several northern border crossings that were not staffed twenty-four hours a day. At nighttime, they just placed a traffic cone in the road, advising travelers to seek out another entry point into the United States. Boy, that’ll stop those terrorists!
Department of Homeland Security It’s hard to believe that anybody takes Tom “Duct Tape” Ridge seriously after he told Americans that the best way to protect themselves from terrorist attacks was to seal the windows of their homes with plastic sheeting and duct tape. The terrorists are coming. Quick! Buy duct tape! Nor should anybody take Tom Ridge seriously when he continues to invoke a meaningless system of color-coded alerts. Are we Orange today? Or Yellow? Or Red? And what are we supposed to do about it? No matter what color we are, Tom Ridge’s answer is always the same: Don’t do anything differently. Go shopping. Just be alert. Nobody should take Tom Ridge’s Department of Homeland Security seriously, either. It’s a typical, knee-jerk, big-government response to a problem: Move the boxes around on an organizational chart. Or, in this case, worse yet: Create a whole, new, confusing box: the third-largest federal bureaucracy. Even worse, in a typical Bush move, the administration promised the moon on homeland security, but didn’t put up the money. How big a priority is homeland security for George Bush? Get this. In 2003, George Bush spent more money on tax cuts for the rich than on protecting our homeland. In FY 2003, the entire budget for the new Homeland Secu-
THE WAR
ON
TERROR
57
rity Department was $38 billion. The cost of the Bush tax cuts that year—for the wealthiest 1 percent of Americans—was $41 billion. In 2004 and 2005, George Bush plans to spend over three times more on tax cuts for the rich than on protecting our homeland. In FY 2004, the Homeland Security budget was $36.6 billion. The cost of the Bush tax cuts was $124 billion. In the president’s budget for FY 2005, he requests $40.2 billion for Homeland Security. The cost of the Bush tax cuts will be $126 billion. And here’s another indication of how big a priority protecting the homeland is for President Bush. In 2003, the war and occupation in Iraq cost $166 billion. That same year, we spent $38 billion on homeland defense. In 2003, George Bush spent over four times fighting an unnecessary war in Iraq than on protecting our homeland from terrorists. The next time President Bush brags about doing “everything he can” to provide homeland security, somebody should holler: “Put your money where your mouth is!”
First Responders Even with a mammoth new government agency, it’s not federal employees in Washington who are the first line of defense against terrorist attacks. Except, of course, for the Post Office, whose workers were all but ignored during the anthrax scare. In every case, the first ones called in any emergency are the brave men and women who serve in our city, state and county police, fire and rescue departments—like “New York’s Bravest,” and “New York’s Finest” so many of whom gave their lives on September 11.
58
REASON #2
The president’s 2005 budget includes $3.6 billion for local police and fire agencies. That may sound like a lot of money. But that’s actually a cut of $805 million from what they received in 2004—and far, far from what is needed to do the job. Bush also cut funds for the Centers for Disease Control by 8.9 percent, the same week letters laced with ricin were sent to Senate Majority Leader Bill Frist. Indeed, the big scandal of George Bush’s homeland security agenda is how many times he stands in front of local police and fire departments, praises their work—and then goes back to Washington and refuses to send the money he promised. In February 2004, Homeland Security Director Tom Ridge admitted to the Senate Governmental Affairs Committee that over half the money allocated since September 11 to help local emergency aid agencies prepare for terrorist attacks had not been disbursed by his agency. In true pre-9/11 Washington style, they were just sitting on the money. In June 2003, a study by the Council on Foreign Relations found local emergency response agencies “dangerously unprepared” for major terrorist attacks—mainly because of inadequate federal funding. Most jurisdictions still don’t have the basic communication equipment that enables local agencies to talk to each other and coordinate their responses. After meeting with first responders across the country and assessing their readiness, former Republican Senator Warren Rudman concluded they would need $98.4 billion over the next five years—on top of the $27 billion budgeted by the Bush administration. “If the nation does not take immediate steps to better identify and address the urgent needs of emergency responders, the next terrorist incident could be even more devastating than 9/11,” Rudman warned.
THE WAR
ON
TERROR
59
Homeland Pork One of the reasons there’s not more money for first responders is that so much of the Homeland Security budget goes to plain old government pork. Hidden in the 484-page legislation creating the department were dozens of special projects that have little, if anything, to do with homeland security. Outgoing Senator Phil Gramm, for example, stuck in funding for an academic homeland security research center at Texas A&M University. There were also homeland security study centers created at New Mexico State University and the University of Tennessee. Among other items funded in the homeland security legislation were these important anti-terrorist projects: • $2 million so the Smithsonian could start constructing a 108,000-square-foot building in Maryland to house its collection of fish, frogs, bugs, birds and other animals preserved in alcohol-filled containers • $5 million to subsidize farmers’ markets and roadside produce stands in thirty-one states • $2.5 million to map coral reefs in the waters around Hawaii • $10 million in aid to farmers along the Rio Grande in Texas Senator John McCain, one of the Senate’s leading critics of pork barrel spending, told reporters the obvious: “These are policy changes which have nothing to do with any national emergency.” Also tucked into the homeland security measure was a provision to limit the rights of parents of autistic children to sue pharmaceutical giant Eli Lilly. This, of course, had nothing to do with homeland security, but everything to do with the fact
60
REASON #2
that the biggest drug companies gave Republicans $16.3 million in campaign contributions in 2002. Another special interest payback. The night after signing the homeland security legislation, President Bush flew to Des Moines, Iowa, to speak at the Fourteenth Annual World Pork Expo! Don’t tell me that was just a coincidence.
What Homeland Security? You would think the Department of Homeland Security was filled with people working on—well, here’s a wild guess— homeland security! Right? Wrong! Many of the functions assigned to the new bureaucracy, from 160 existing departments or agencies, have nothing to do with security at all. So what are all those Homeland Security guys doing, anyway? Here are some responsibilities transferred from other agencies. From the Department of Agriculture: • Regulating the exhibition of animals in zoos and circuses • Eradicating the boll weevil, the fruit fly and the plum pox virus • Maintaining the missing pets network (Now we know what he’s there for. Fido is missing. Orange Alert! Get out the duct tape! Call Tom Ridge!) There’s more. From the Coast Guard: • Breaking up ice on rivers and lakes to allow commercial ship traffic • Making sure pleasure boaters are wearing their life vests
THE WAR
ON
TERROR
61
• Protecting fish and marine mammals (Normally, I’m all for that. But protecting elephant seals is not saving us from al Qaeda.) From the Customs Agency: • Enforcing laws against child pornography (Again, important, but not terrorist-related) • Recovering stolen pieces of art and antiquities From the Federal Emergency Management Agency (FEMA): • Administering the national flood insurance program • Providing emergency food and shelter for hurricane victims • Adopting earthquake-safe building codes Now, all of those functions are worthwhile. But they have nothing to do with homeland security. And, of course, while so-called “security” workers are hunting down the boll weevil or trying to track down that oriental carpet stolen from you at Dulles Airport, they’re not doing what they’re supposed to be doing—which is protecting us from terrorists. In fact, outside of harassing passengers at airports, the Department of Homeland Security is doing almost nothing to protect us. And, even there, it’s doing a half-ass job.
Please Take Off All Your Clothes One place you can’t miss Tom Ridge’s security cops is at any airport. You may not get to the terminal without having to stop and open the trunk of your car. You certainly can’t get to the
62
REASON #2
gate without running the gauntlet of the Transportation Security Agency, or TSA. Okay, you don’t have to take off all your clothes. But almost. Take off your coat. Take off your jacket. Take off your belt. Take off your shoes. Empty your pockets. Show your photo ID—twice. Show your boarding pass—twice. It sure takes the fun out of flying. It sure is a pain in the ass. But, what the hell, if it makes flying safer, I’m all for it. Does it? In researching this book, I put that question to one of the nation’s most respected experts on airline security. I asked David Forbes, co-chair of BoydForbes, Inc., an aviation security consulting company: Have all the new procedures of TSA made it safer to fly? His one-word answer: “No.” Yes, cockpit doors have been reinforced. Yes, there are armed marshals on some flights. And, yes, if you fly into or out of Washington’s National Airport, you still can’t get up to pee within thirty minutes of takeoff or landing. (One desperate congressman was arrested for peeing in a plastic cup.) But that’s not good enough. As Forbes notes, there’s a phony premise underlying all the increased security at airports: the belief that, the next time terrorists strike the United States, they will do so the same way they did the last time. Fat chance. They aren’t that stupid, as we should have learned on September 11. But the biggest problem, according to Forbes, is that “while they’re doing a good job of locking the front door, they’re leaving the back door wide open.” And he’s right. Sure, you can’t get on a plane anymore with a nail file in your pocket. Grandma can’t board without getting out of her wheelchair and being frisked. And because one idiot in France put explosives in his shoe, millions of Americans every day have to take their shoes off to walk through the metal detectors.
THE WAR
ON
TERROR
63
Meanwhile, there is still almost no screening of checked luggage or freight in the belly of the plane. Why not? As Congressman Ed Markey points out, this is not rocket science. The Israeli airline El Al has been screening checked luggage for decades. They have also developed special “bomb-proof” containers and reinforced the exterior walls of the plane to protect against any device that might escape detection at screening and explode in the hold. The only reason we still don’t do the same in the United States is that airlines and cargo companies don’t want to bear the extra cost or inconvenience. Bottom line: Until every piece of checked luggage on every flight is screened, airport security is a joke. Another big weakness: There is also little increased security around the perimeters of most airports. Next time you fly take a look at the parking lots around airports, the access roads, fuel farms, maintenance hangers, nearby parks and open space. They are all locations from which a terrorist could shoot a shoulder-fired missile and bring down a wide-body aircraft. Yet, even though the technology exists to protect commercial aircraft from Stingerlike missiles, the TSA is doing nothing about it. In 2003, the TSA did introduce a new requirement that all foreign travelers entering the United States be fingerprinted and photographed in order to check for possible terrorists. Which raises the obvious question: If the terrorist is already on board the plane heading for the United States, aren’t we planning on getting his fingerprints—one flight too late? Still feeling safer? But if the TSA is doing too little to increase airline security, it’s doing absolutely nothing to protect other means of transportation.
64
REASON #2
Throw Momma from the Train Flying, after all, is only one way to get from here to there. It’s only one choice from an entire menu of transportation options available to us, the friendly travelers—or to them, the unfriendly terrorists. Take Amtrak lately? I do, often, from Washington to New York. It’s great, it’s convenient, it’s affordable—and it’s entirely unprotected. Forty-thousand railroad stations in America, with no guards, no bag checks, no metal detectors. Hell, I think you could carry a bazooka on board a train, stuff it in the overhead compartment, and no one would notice. The horrendous terrorist attack on four trains in Madrid in March 2004, killing 190 people, reminded us how vulnerable our own rail system is. And the same is true of every subway and municipal bus system in the country. Take a long drive lately? Hundreds of thousands of miles of interstate highways. Ever wonder what’s inside all those vans or eighteen-wheelers flying by you? Nobody knows. Certainly not the Department of Homeland Security. But Timothy McVeigh can’t be the only terrorist ever to think of a Ryder truck as a delivery vehicle for evil. If you don’t take the plane, train or car, you can always take the boat. Ninety-five thousand miles of coastline. Over threehundred ports, receiving over fifty-thousand foreign ships a year, 70 million cargo containers entering New York harbor alone. Containing what? Don’t ask Tom Ridge. Still today, only 2 percent of all containers entering the United States are x-rayed for possible explosives or other dangerous materials. As was proven, to the great embarrassment of Homeland Security, when ABC’s investigative reporter Brian Ross brought a shipment of active nuclear material halfway around the world and into the United States—twice!—without getting caught.
THE WAR
ON
TERROR
65
In January 2002, the Customs Agency launched the Container Security Initiative, a plan to get the twenty biggest foreign ports to screen all containers before they are shipped to the United States. It’s a program President Bush took credit for while visiting New Jersey on June 24, 2002: “The Customs Service is working with overseas ports and shippers to improve its knowledge of container shipments, assessing risk so that we have a better feel of who we ought to look at, what we ought to worry about.” But, as is often the case with his big public initiatives, he didn’t back it up with any money. His 2003 budget contained nothing for port security grants and no money for the Container Security Initiative. In August 2003, he even vetoed the $39 million Congress had voted for the Container Security Initiative. And, once again, his 2004 budget contained zero funds for port security or the overseas container security program. Funds for container inspection were finally included in the budget for 2005, but the program is already three years behind—and tens of thousands of containers continue to flow unchecked into American ports every day.
Big Fat Targets Our ports aren’t the only areas where we’re vulnerable— and where no protective action has been taken by the Bush administration. Consider also . . .
Nuclear Power Plants We know from documents found among the papers of al Qaeda operatives—and cited by President Bush himself—that terrorists have also set their sights on America’s nuclear power plants. Yet there have been virtually no extra security measures taken to protect them—and us—even after September 11.
66
REASON #2
On March 25, 2002, Congressman Ed Markey released a chilling report, entitled “A Hard Look at the Soft Spots in Our Civilian Nuclear Reactor Security.” It examined security measures ordered by the Nuclear Regulatory Commission at nuclear installations around the country. Among its chilling findings: • The NRC does not know how many foreign nationals are employed at nuclear reactors. • The NRC does not know what its licensees spend on security or how many security guards are employed at each reactor. • Twenty-one nuclear reactors are located within five miles of an airport. • All but 4 of 103 U.S. nuclear reactors were designed without regard to the potential for impact from even a small aircraft. • The NRC has rejected placing antiaircraft capabilities at nuclear facilities, even though other countries have done so. • Significant quantities of spent nuclear fuel exist at reactors all across the U.S. and are stored in buildings that are not hardened structures. Feeling any safer?
Oil Refineries and Chemical Plants If there’s little extra security at the nation’s nuclear power plants, there’s even less at refineries and chemical plants— despite the danger they pose to the population in case of accident or terrorist attack. Take the Valero Energy Corporation’s refinery, located in New Jersey, just across the Delaware River from Philadelphia International Airport. According to the EPA, it is one of 123 chemical plants in the country containing sufficient amounts of
THE WAR
ON
TERROR
67
toxic materials that, if released into the atmosphere, would create deadly vapor clouds endangering over 1 million people. Yet, as with George Bush’s policies involving oil and energy, security at refineries and chemical installations has been left entirely up to private industry. There is no federal program. There are no federal security standards that must be met. It’s a huge, gaping hole in security. And it makes a mockery of the whole myth of a nationwide umbrella of protection. Adds New Jersey Senator Jon Corzine: “If we can’t deal with something as simple and straightforward a risk to the population as these chemical plants and refineries, I think we’re not taking homeland security seriously.”
Have a Nice Weekend But at least you have to have some kind of identification to enter a refinery or chemical factory. Not so for places where most people hang out on weekends. We don’t want to become a police state. We don’t want to see armed guards everywhere. But, you gotta admit, despite all of George Bush’s tough talk about homeland security, in public areas we are every bit as vulnerable to terrorism today as we were before September 11. For whatever reason, suicide bombers have not yet struck on U.S. soil. God forbid they ever do. There are too many places of opportunity: shopping malls, sports stadiums, churches, restaurants, office buildings, busy intersections and the nation’s electric grid—all with no added protection. It’s only a matter of time. As Congresswoman Jane Harman, ranking Democrat on the House Intelligence Committee, sadly concludes: “Al Qaeda remains as dangerous as it was before September 11.” Meanwhile, without taking the steps necessary to protect us, President Bush continues to raise the threat of terrorism as
68
REASON #2
justification for his entire foreign and domestic agenda. For him, September 11 is an excuse for everything from denying due process to enacting mammoth tax cuts. He exploits 9/11 for his own personal political agenda, while leaving America vulnerable to terrorist attack. He’s trying to get reelected by scaring people to death. NO ULTIMATE MILITARY SOLUTION In the end, the greatest weakness of President Bush’s socalled war on terror is neither the misdirection of the war in Iraq nor the inadequate security measures taken by the Department of Homeland Security. It’s his failure to recognize that terrorism can’t be stopped by military might alone. Of course, that is too complicated for George Bush to understand. He has the worldview of a Wild West sheriff. He even talks like one. Of al Qaeda, he warned: “They can run, but they can’t hide.” Of Osama bin Laden, he ordered: “Bring him back, dead or alive.” Of possible terrorist attacks on American soldiers, he stupidly boasted: “Bring ’em on.” George Bush just doesn’t get it. He thinks terrorism can be wiped out with guns and bombs. He’s wrong. Look at the Middle East. No country in the region has greater military might than Israel. No world leader has unleashed more tanks, planes, helicopters, gunships, missiles, bombs or troops against terrorists than Ariel Sharon. Yet terrorists still strike Israeli citizens. And every retaliatory strike by Israel inspires more young Palestinians to become suicide bombers. It’s not that force has no place in the war on terror. It is an essential and legitimate form of self-defense and retaliation. The invasion of Afghanistan was just and necessary. So is the roundup and arrest of known al Qaeda operatives here and around the world. It’s just that military might alone won’t
THE WAR
ON
TERROR
69
work. The war on terror has to be waged on many fronts. And the most important is not military. It’s ideological. The real evil is not terrorism. Terrorism is but a method. The real evil is Islamic fundamentalism and its believers, who use terror to achieve or advance their ends. Senator Bob Graham uses the analogy of weed-killer. “In getting weeds out of your garden,” he notes, “it’s not enough to just cut down and kill the weeds. You also have to deal with the seeds. Or else the weeds just come back.” In order to be successful in reducing the level of terrorism directed against America, we must also deal with the causes of religious zealotry, the seeds of terrorism. And that requires a reexamination of some policies that generate hatred of the United States. Those policies include: America’s unflinching, wholehearted support for Saudi Arabia, one of the most corrupt and least democratic regimes in the Middle East, and the one from which fifteen out of nineteen of the September 11 terrorists hailed; a refusal to engage in the peace process and the abandonment of our role as honest broker in the Israeli-Palestinian conflict; and foreign aid that builds Arab military machines, but does nothing to improve educational, economic or democratic opportunities for over a billion Arab people who live in poverty and political repression. If only he were a student of history, George Bush could learn a lot from President Harry Truman and General George Marshall. After World War II, they recognized that the best way to frustrate the spread of godless communism was not through military might alone—but through winning the hearts and minds of people through the economic rebuilding of Europe, as proof of what America was really all about. Again, there is zero evidence that George Bush is even capable of understanding this—as Delaware’s Senator Joe Biden learned the hard way. Biden told The New Yorker’s George Packer that
70
REASON #2
in December 2001, shortly after the fall of the Taliban, he was asked by President Bush to draft a proposal for winning over young Muslims worldwide. Biden, then chair of the Senate Foreign Relations Committee, went to Afghanistan a month later and came back with a specific plan. The roots of terrorism, Biden explained to Packer, lie in a worldwide struggle “between the values of liberal democracy and the destructive ideologies that fester with dictatorship, misery, and humiliation.” In that struggle, America needed “to expand the conditions for democracy in the most concrete ways, with serious commitments of energy and resources, or risk greater instability.” So Biden wrote a very down-to-earth proposal for President Bush: to build, staff and supply a thousand schools in Afghanistan at a cost of $20,000 each. The schools would employ teachers, many of them women, and would teach a modern curriculum, not the religious zealotry of the madrassas. “It was something concrete we could show the Afghans we’re doing,” Biden told Packer. “It was something other than the butt of a gun.” But the idea went nowhere. By that time, Bush was already planning his war in Iraq—another military campaign. He no longer had time for “hearts and minds.” Instead, he went in the opposite direction, initially referring to the war on terror as a “crusade.” The problem with treating the war on terror as a mere military struggle, of course, is—that means we’ll never win it. Because we’re fighting the wrong war. On this point, President Bush and his advisors are clueless, according to Ivo Daalder, terrorism expert with the Brookings Institution, and author of America Unbound. In an interview for this book on February 18, 2004, he told me: “They don’t get it, because they don’t believe this is an ideology,” says Daalder. “They believe that this is a state-based threat . . . that
THE WAR
ON
TERROR
71
if you get rid of evil people, who are in finite supply, you will have resolved the problem.” And, of course, that’s not the case. Because as long as our policies remain unexamined and unchanged, we will just inspire more and more America-hating young terrorists. The only long-term solution, Daalder argues, echoing Biden, is to give them something to live for: “to provide people in the Islamic world with an alternative that gives them hope in a period where they now have only despair.” The only short-term solution is to replace Sheriff Bush with someone who has sense enough to get the bigger picture. For promising to protect us from terrorism but not doing so . . . For making us less safe from terrorism, not more . . . For his reckless, imperialist foreign policy that generates more anti-Americanism around the world . . . GEORGE BUSH MUST GO!
REASON # THREE
Jobs: He Put 3 Million Americans Out of Work “I’m a war president.” George W. Bush Meet the Press February 8, 2004
He got that right. George W. Bush waged war in Afghanistan and he waged war in Iraq. And he brags a lot about those two wars—even if, as we have seen, the second one is hardly something to be bragging about. But there’s a third war George Bush never talks about: a war that has meant economic disaster for millions of Americans. I’m talking about the all-out war George Bush has waged on America’s working families. Since day one in the Oval Office, Bush has led a systematic, calculated, broad-scale, relentless campaign to deny hardworking Americans their benefits, their rights, their wages and their jobs. In fact, if you had to choose one single domestic issue on which the 2004 election should be decided, it is this one: JOBS. And if you had to choose one issue, more than any other, for which George Bush should be denied a second term, it is this one: JOBS. He pretends to care about working Americans. He insists
JOBS
73
the economy is improving. He says everything’s rosy and jobs are actually on the rise. When the exact opposite is true.
Jobs Projected, Jobs Lost If you believe President Bush, there are more jobs out there today than workers available to fill them. And even more new jobs on the way. How many new jobs are going to be created in 2004? In early February, speaking in Springfield, Missouri, he predicted 2.6 million—only to back off that prediction just one week later. But that’s the Bush pattern: one phony job prediction after another. He hasn’t got one right yet. In the spring of 2003, Bush predicted that 1,836,000 jobs would be created between June and December. Instead, only 221,000 jobs were produced—about 12 percent of what Bush projected. He was off target by 1,615,000 jobs. Last summer, Bush predicted that 5.5 million jobs would be created between July 2003 and December 2004. According to his plan, that would mean 2,142,000 jobs by February 1. Instead, there were only 296,000 new jobs—about 14 percent of what Bush predicted. He wasn’t even close. He was 1,846,000 jobs short of the mark. Last fall, Bush predicted we would end the year with a bang: 150,000 jobs created in December. Actually, only 1,000 new jobs were created. He was off by 149,000. He delivered less than 1 percent of what he had promised. Then he came back with his Alice-in-Wonderland prediction of 2.6 million jobs for 2004. Meeting that goal would require an average increase of 460,000 jobs a month from February through December 2004. Not likely, when January only produced 112,000 jobs and February only 21,000. March bounced back with 308,000 new jobs.
74
REASON #3
No wonder George Bush backed off his 2.6 million job prediction. But it’s also no secret why he continues to crow about new jobs “just around the corner.” He’s trying to change the subject. He doesn’t want anybody to focus on how many old jobs have actually been lost since he took office. According to the Bureau of Labor Statistics, 2.8 million manufacturing jobs were lost since January 2001. Compare that to Bill Clinton’s record of job gains: • Eight years of Bill Clinton: 22 million new jobs created. • Three years of George Bush: 2.8 million jobs lost. Those jobs were lost across the country. No region was spared the negative fallout from Bush’s economic follies. In fact, between June and December 2003, only three states— Alaska, Wyoming and Kansas—met the Bush projection for job creation. Forty-seven out of fifty states lost jobs. Let’s face it. There is no way the Bush administration will realize 2.6 million new jobs in 2004, as he predicts. But even if it does—do the math—George Bush will still fall 200,000 short of making up the 2.8 million jobs lost since he took office. So there’s no way he can escape what awaits him: • George Bush will become the first president since Herbert Hoover to end his first term with fewer Americans employed than when he took office. That is not the kind of record that begs for a second term.
Blame It on Clinton Like everything else, George Bush tries to blame the loss of jobs and the stagnant economy on Bill Clinton. He inherited a
JOBS
75
“weak economy,” he claims. And, he adds, he took office in the “middle” of a recession that began in November 2000. Like everything else George Bush says, you can’t believe it. Fact: George Bush did not inherit a weak economy. He inherited the strongest economy this country has ever known— eight years of steady economic growth under Bill Clinton—and the longest period of economic expansion in history. As he did with the Clinton budget surplus, Bush turned it upside down. Fact: George Bush did not inherit a recession. The National Bureau of Economic Research, which keeps track of such things, made it official: The recession started in March 2001. George Bush took office in January 2001. From the get-go, this was a Bush recession. He had already spooked Wall Street after only two months in office. I have nothing against Barbara Bush. She strikes me as a nice lady. I like her spunk. But didn’t she ever teach her kids to stand up and take responsibility for their own actions? Apparently not.
War on Working Class Americans Why were so many jobs lost under George Bush? It didn’t just happen. He made it happen, through a series of direct attacks on working Americans. We’ll go into detail about each one of these anti-worker initiatives. But, first, here’s the list—a partial list—of the ways George Bush has shown his utter disregard and contempt for working Americans. Those who, unlike him, couldn’t afford to goof off until they were forty years old, because they had to go out and work for a living—and still do.
76
REASON #3 George W. Bush vs. American Workers
• He tried to eliminate overtime pay for 8 million workers. • He refused to extend unemployment benefits by six months. • He eliminated 140,000 highway construction jobs. • He opposed federal funds for hiring 75,000 new firefighters. • He cut funds for job training and workplace safety. • He canceled collective bargaining rights for 170,000 Homeland Security personnel. • He forced the EPA to lie about air quality at Ground Zero, endangering the health of emergency and construction workers. • He appointed anti-labor, big business cronies to every labor-related post in his administration. • He rescinded tough ergonomic rules protecting workers from repetitive motion injuries. • He tried to destroy unions for federal workers through privatization. • He signed new trade deals in Singapore and Chile, sending still more jobs overseas. • He rolled back tariffs on imported steel, denying protection to American steel workers. • He banned United and Northwest mechanics from going on strike. • He intervened to break up a strike by West Coast dockworkers. • He refused to protect workers’ pension plans from corporate crooks. • His top economic advisor praised the practice of exporting jobs to cheap labor markets around the world. • He stiffed workers by directing his tax cuts to those making over $200,000 a year.
JOBS
77
• He supported “paycheck protection”—more aptly called “paycheck deception”—to get labor unions out of politics and off the backs of Republicans. So don’t ask why working men and women feel so unwelcome in George Bush’s America. They are unwelcome. No other group of Americans has been victims of such a direct siege by Bush and Cheney. Now let’s review each of Bush’s attacks on American workers, as documented by the AFL-CIO on its outstanding website, aflcio.org.
Overtime Protection Here’s the dilemma: As we’ve just seen, with the economy so uncertain, businesses are hesitant to hire new employees. So, instead, they ask existing workers to work longer hours. Which means they have to pay them overtime. Here’s George Bush’s answer: Redefine the legal definition of “overtime” to let businesses off the hook—and screw 8 million healthcare, aerospace, defense, high tech and other workers out of the extra pay they deserve. It’s outrageous treatment, especially coming from a guy who never worked overtime in his life and barely puts in forty hours a week at the Oval Office. New overtime rules proposed by the Bush administration in March 2003 enable employers to get out of overtime by reclassifying certain categories of workers as “managers” or “administrative” staff—and thus exempt from the time-and-a-half overtime pay required by the Fair Labor Standards Act for every hour worked above forty hours a week. The president also vowed to veto the 2004 Labor Appropriations Act if it contained language rolling back his new overtime rules. After howls of criticism from Democrats and Republicans in
78
REASON #3
Congress, the administration softened the rules somewhat—by guaranteeing overtime pay to 1.3 million low-wage employees previously ineligible for it. But here’s the kicker. At the same time, the Labor Department issued guidelines for employers, called “payroll adjustment,” on how to get around the new regulations. By shifting low-income employees now eligible for overtime to lower hourly wages and then adding on overtime pay, employers can end up paying, in combined pay plus overtime, no more than what the employee would have earned in the first place. Pretty tricky, huh? For blue-collar workers, that can be significant. The Communications Workers of America estimates that overtime pay can make up one-half the weekly income of those who receive it. “No overtime” means an average pay cut of $161 per week, which adds up to thousands of dollars a year. George Bush is paying for his tax cuts on the backs of lowincome workers.
Unemployment Benefits Americans experienced a double whammy in 2001: September 11 and the Bush recession. We’re still trying to recover from both. The year 2004 began with 10 million Americans out of work. While waiting for the economy to recover and new jobs to appear—all those new jobs that George Bush promises are “right around the corner”—Democrats in Congress proposed a temporary relief measure: extending emergency federal unemployment benefits for long-term laid-off workers by six months—and adding thirteen weeks of benefits for jobless workers in all fifty states. You might think that’s exactly the kind of humanitarian re-
JOBS
79
lief a compassionate conservative would go for. You’d be wrong. George Bush’s response: No way, Charlie. Too bad you’re out of a job—but you’re on your own, pal. Unemployment benefits have run out for millions of working men and women, but Bush refuses to extend them.
Highway Construction It worked in the Great Depression. It’s worked in every other recession. Public work projects are the best way to create new jobs, put people back to work—and build a lot of important public improvements. Not this time around. George Bush took the opposite approach. Instead of setting the example by encouraging federal agencies to hire the unemployed to rebuild America’s roadways, bridges, airports and infrastructure, he acted to put more people out of a job. President Bush proposed cuts of 29 percent in already scheduled highway construction and maintenance repair. That not only made the interstates less safe to drive, it cost the jobs of 140,000 highway construction workers in 2002—and an estimated 380,000 jobs over the next decade.
New Firefighters In addition to police officers, who were the heroes of September 11? The firefighters! And who were the first group of workers George Bush dumped on after September 11? The firefighters! One year after 343 New York City firefighters were killed at the World Trade Center, the International Association of
80
REASON #3
Firefighters and the International Association of Fire Chiefs sought a federal grant of $7.6 billion to hire 75,000 new firefighters in cities across the country over the next ten years. President Bush turned them down. Instead, he proposed spending $3.5 billion on training and equipment for existing firefighters, police and emergency responders. But, as Firefighters president Harold Schaitberger noted, “All the right equipment in the world and all the training isn’t really of much value if you don’t have adequate numbers of personnel to perform their mission.” But then, as we saw in the last chapter, Bush cut funds for all first responders. Not for nothing were firefighters among John Kerry’s earliest supporters. The way George Bush screwed them, what do you expect?
Job Training Speaking of job training, what President Bush gives with one hand, he takes away with the other. Just four months after taking over, in April 2001, the Bush administration revoked previously approved federal grants for safety and health training programs. That left immigrant workers and workers in high-risk jobs, like construction, with less on-the-job protection. Two months later, in June 2001, to help pay for the first round of Bush tax cuts, the administration cut $259 million from the dislocated workers program and another $100 million in adult job training. Both programs suffered more cuts in 2002. The onslaught continued. In his 2003 budget, President Bush proposed cutting enforcement of workplace safety and health standards and safety training for workers. He also eliminated eighty-three inspectors from the Occupational Safety
JOBS
81
and Health Administration, or OSHA. And even more cuts in worker training and workplace health and safety were made in 2004 and in next year’s proposed budget. His record speaks for itself. Training workers for new jobs? Protecting the health and safety of America’s workforce? They’re simply not high priorities for George W. Bush.
Collective Bargaining/Homeland Security The last thing George Bush wanted was for workers in the new Department of Homeland Security to take any lessons from flight attendants or dockworkers. He made sure they’d never go out on strike—by denying them the right of collective bargaining from day one. In July 2002—after spending months rejecting calls by Senators Joe Lieberman and Max Cleland, Congresswoman Jane Harman and others for a new, cabinet-level homeland security agency—President Bush suddenly reversed course and proposed his own department. With one big difference: All 170,000 workers in George Bush’s agency would be stripped of their civil service and collective bargaining rights. Denying workers their rights was necessary, said the president, for reasons of national security. Bullshit. All of those workers would be doing the same jobs they had done for years in other agencies, with full worker protection. Nineteen terrorists weren’t able to crash into the World Trade Center and the Pentagon because employees in the pesticide division of the Department of Agriculture had civil service protection. George Bush was just exploiting the tragedy of September 11 to try to break the unions. Which he did again in January 2003, when federal employees took over the job of airport security screening at all airports. You know, the guys who make you take off your shoes before you walk through the metal detector.
82
REASON #3
Members of the new Transportation Security Agency, or TSA, are doing a good job. But they have no workers’ rights. No civil service protection. No right to bargain for a better deal, or go on strike. Giving them the same rights other workers enjoy, says the Bush administration, would not be “compatible with the nation’s war against terrorism.” There you have it: George Bush’s philosophy about organized labor. In his world, belonging to a labor union is tantamount to giving aid and comfort to the enemy.
Dangerous Air at Ground Zero When I first heard Senator Hillary Clinton complaining about this, I couldn’t believe it. Hillary must be wrong. Not even George Bush could be so coldhearted as to put construction workers at Ground Zero at risk. But, I soon discovered, Senator Clinton was correct. From the beginning, there was a lot of concern about toxic fumes from the burning debris at Ground Zero. But on September 18, 2001, the Environmental Protection Agency put everyone at ease by declaring that the air around the site was “safe to breathe.” With that reassurance, thousands of rescue and construction workers toiled for months at the cleanup site without protection, and residents and workers later returned to the area believing it was safe to do so. Except it wasn’t. In August 2003, the EPA’s own inspector general issued a shocking report. First of all, he charged, the EPA “did not have sufficient data and analysis to make such a blanket statement.” Second, the EPA was required to clear all statements about air quality at Ground Zero with the National Security Council. And, most devastating of all, he reported, the EPA was pressured by the White House to omit cautions about hazards from
JOBS
83
such air pollutants as lead, cadmium, asbestos and smoke from fires, some of which continued to burn for four months. Not even the workers at Ground Zero got any respect from George Bush.
Anti-Labor Appointments In life, you are what you eat. In government, you are whom you appoint to key positions. Looking at his appointments, there’s no doubt George Bush is anti-labor. After failing to get his first choice for labor secretary, the conservative commentator Linda Chavez, Bush settled on the relatively harmless Elaine Chou, the wife of Republican Senator Mitch McConnell (himself a sworn enemy of campaign finance reform). Then he made sure Chou stayed in line by naming as solicitor of the Labor Department Eugene Scalia, a fierce opponent of organized labor and the son of one of the five Supreme Court justices who crowned Bush president. Immediately prior to his nomination, Scalia had led the big business charge to overturn rules protecting workers from ergonomics injuries. In fact, Scalia was so openly anti-labor he couldn’t even get confirmed in a Republican-controlled Senate. Bush had to give him a recess appointment. Most dangerous to American workers, however, was the appointment of John Ashcroft as attorney general. As senator from Missouri, Ashcroft consistently voted against worker safety and health, Social Security and Medicare, the patients’ bill of rights, raising the minimum wage, prevailing wage guarantees, protection of overtime and the forty-hour workweek. This is the man George Bush chose to enforce the nation’s labor laws. But that was just the beginning. Throughout his administration, whenever a special board or commission was created to
84
REASON #3
study issues affecting the workforce, George Bush stacked it with pro-business, anti-labor voices. In May 2001, for example, he named a special commission to study whether or not privatization of Social Security was a good idea. All fourteen members said ahead of time they supported privatization. Not one representative of organized labor was included. In December 2002, he named a nine-member panel to study the privatization of the U.S. Postal Service and a thirty-two-member Advisory Commission on U.S. Trade Policy. There was not one representative of labor, environmental or consumer groups named to either. Is there any doubt at this point? George Bush doesn’t care what working men and women think. They have no voice in the Bush administration.
No Protection for Workplace Injuries The workplace can be a dangerous place, and not just for Hollywood stuntmen or deep sea divers. Most workplace injuries, in fact, don’t involve broken bones or loss of limbs. Two million workers a year suffer so-called soft tissue or musculoskeletal injuries, such as carpal tunnel syndrome, caused by repetitive motion, heavy lifting or poorly designed work sites. Ask any supermarket clerk, high tech worker, assembly line worker or software technician. Unless they see blood on the floor, however, big business doesn’t want to pay. Led by the U.S. Chamber of Commerce and then-private attorney Eugene Scalia, big corporations convinced Congress to repeal stringent OSHA rules on ergonomic injuries. It was the first time that Congress had ever interfered with OSHA’s legal responsibility to protect workers. Of course, Bush signed the legislation. One month later, he sided with business again, instructing
JOBS
85
the Justice Department—headed by labor enemy John Ashcroft— to file an amicus brief on behalf of Toyota Motors and against an assembly line worker who had complained of repetitive motion injuries. In June 2001, Labor Secretary Elaine Chou announced a new set of watered-down ergonomic rules to replace the former tough OSHA requirements. But these new rules—in keeping with Bush’s refusal to demand any responsibility from corporate America—were purely voluntary. And Chou admitted there were no plans to enforce them, anyway. Chou even absolved companies from the requirement to report musculoskeletal injuries. Her theory: If nobody reports them, they must not exist. Which, of course, was just the opposite of the Bush administration theory on weapons of mass destruction: If nobody reports them, they must exist.
Busting the Unions George Bush is not stupid. Even he understood that the best way not to have to deal with unions is simply to get rid of them. Which he tried to do the moment the Supreme Court handed him his job. As previously noted, he denied collective bargaining rights to all 170,000 employees of the Department of Homeland Security. He also forbade new federal airport screeners from forming a union. But the union-busting Texas cowboy was just getting started. By executive order, George Bush revoked union representation for workers in five divisions of the Justice Department. He did so, he said, to prevent people working in intelligence or law enforcement from going on strike, even though existing federal law already prohibited them from striking. In another executive order, Bush opened the door to privatization of all air traffic controllers. He proposed eliminating civil
86
REASON #3
service protections for all civilian employees of the Pentagon. And he pulled the plug on union representation for thirteen hundred employees of the National Imagery and Mapping Agency. But George Bush still wasn’t satisfied. There were a few unions left! He also began the process of turning the U.S. Postal Service over to the private sector, thereby getting rid of 750,000 union employees. And he announced new rules to facilitate privatization of 850,000 additional federal jobs—all now held by union members. It was all part of George Bush’s determination to bust the unions, gut civil service protection and hand over jobs and lucrative contracts to politically well-connected corporate cronies. As he does for everything else, President Bush invoked September 11 as justification for his extreme anti-union initiatives. But, as usual, the war on terror had nothing to do with it. Bobby Harnage, president of the federal employees union, says Bush has it ass-backwards: “The fight against terrorism, in which federal employees have always been on the front lines of the homeland, is about preserving our freedoms—including the right to organize—not destroying them.”
Exporting More Jobs . . . Even before George Bush took office, millions of American jobs had been lost because of NAFTA (the North American Free Trade Agreement). As president, he accelerated the trend. One of his first acts as president was, in effect, to expand NAFTA by allowing Mexican trucks and buses to enter the United States and do business across the country. Warnings by
JOBS
87
the Teamsters Union of substandard truck, bus and driver safety regulations in Mexico were simply ignored. In April 2001, Bush signed an agreement with thirty-three countries of North and South America and the Caribbean to create a “Free Trade Area of the Americas.” The new trade deal is expected to lure so many jobs overseas it’s already been dubbed “NAFTA on steroids.” And in March 2003, he secretly negotiated new “fast track” trade deals with Chile and Singapore—deals Congress has no authority to amend in order to protect workers or the environment.
Notice the double standard: As we will discover in reason number 7, George Bush has no truck with treaties or global organizations. In fact, he’s pulled the United States out of almost every one of them. The one exception: trade. He’ll sign any international agreement that exports more American jobs.
Now you know why George Bush can’t find those new jobs he’s always talking about. He sent them all overseas—and then said it was a good idea.
. . . And Bragging About It! One thing I’ll give them credit for: The Bush White House has one of the best spin machines I’ve ever seen. They know how to paint tax cuts for the rich as God’s gift to the middle class. And they can find a hundred ways to claim that weapons of mass destruction are really there, when there aren’t any. But
88
REASON #3
on one embarrassing occasion the Bush spinmeisters fell down on the job. They let the cat out of the bag: George Bush doesn’t really care about American jobs. It wasn’t Bush himself who told the truth. It was Gregory Mankiw, chairman of the Council of Economic Advisors and the president’s chief economic advisor. While the president was running around the country assuring audiences he would create 2.6 million new jobs in 2004 and stop the flow of American jobs overseas, Mankiw revealed what the administration really thought about losing jobs to foreign competitors: They loved it. It was good for America. “Outsourcing is just a new way of doing international trade,” Mankiw told a Washington trade audience upon release of the Council’s 2004 report. “I think outsourcing is a growing phenomenon, but it’s something that we should realize is probably a plus for the economy in the long run.” Mankiw had no sooner left the podium, than Republican House Speaker Dennis Hastert called the president and reportedly said: “What, are you crazy?” Chagrined that his top economic aide had punctured his phony, job-friendly, public profile, President Bush tried to back away from Mankiw’s remarks. But it was too late. He had already endorsed the Council’s report and sent it to Congress— with his signature. So now we know George Bush’s official policy on outsourcing. Send the jobs to China, Singapore, India or Nicaragua. He doesn’t give a damn.
Rolling Back Steel Tariffs Even a blind pig can sometimes find a truffle. Even a blindto-labor George Bush can sometime find a good thing to do for workers. George Bush did once—then quickly reversed himself.
JOBS
89
Since 1998, forty-two American steel companies had gone bankrupt, putting fifty thousand steelworkers out of work. And the few remaining companies couldn’t compete with what’s called “steel dumping”—cheap, subsidized imports from Europe, Asia and South America. So, in March 2002, to protect America’s steel industry and give firms a chance to get back on their feet, President Bush imposed tariffs on imported steel for three years. It looked like a bold move for a Republican president—even though it was done only to garner electoral votes in places like West Virginia and Pennsylvania—but he soon got cold feet. In December 2003, only twenty months into the tariffs, Bush did a complete U-turn. He bowed to pressure from the European Union and dropped the tariff protection. It was, said Steelworkers president Leo Gerard, “clear evidence of capitulating to European blackmail and a sorry betrayal of American steelworkers and steel communities.”
Airline Employees—No Right to Strike Only two months into his administration, President Bush let workers know whose side he was on. In March 2001, airline mechanics at Northwest Airlines who had been working without a contract for four and a half years voted to go out on strike. But President Bush stopped them at the gate. He became only the second president in thirty-five years to tell workers they could not exercise their right to strike. Just three months later, he did it again. Bush used his presidential authority to prohibit twenty-three thousand American Airlines flight attendants from going on strike and exercising their collective bargaining rights. By now it had become a bad habit. When fifteen thousand mechanics at United Airlines voted to go on strike in December
90
REASON #3
2001—after two frustrating years of trying to reach agreement with management—Bush intervened again, on the side of management, of course, and against the workers.
Dockworkers For George Bush, it doesn’t matter whether workers are on land, in the air or on the sea. He’s against them all. He stopped airline workers from going on strike. He stopped dockworkers, too. In October 2002, he invoked the Taft-Hartley Act to intervene in a lockout of West Coast ports. Ten thousand five hundred dockworkers were ordered to go back to work, without a contract. It was the first time Taft-Hartley had been used since 1978. Earlier, Bush had said he would call out federal troops if necessary to prevent dockworkers from going on strike. As in the Gilded Age, workers don’t have much of a chance at collective bargaining when the White House and the U.S. Army line up on the side of management.
Kiss Your Pension Plan Good-bye Enron. The name will forever stand for shady business deals, phony bookkeeping and corporate crooks, including Bush’s buddy, “Kenny Boy” himself. Thousands of trusting Enron employees believed their bosses and lost every dime in their pension plans. They kept all their retirement funds wrapped up in the company stock. Indeed, in many cases, they had no choice. And they got suckered. But Enron wasn’t alone. Enron was just the first company to sink while unscrupulous executives at many others were taking their money and running, leaving thousands of employees
JOBS
91
empty-handed. In the wake of Enron came Tyco, Global Crossing, Waste Management, Adelphia and others. Those poor workers lost everything. They will never get their money back. But their plight made obvious the need for pension reform to protect other employees from suffering the same fate. And Democrats in the Senate, led by Ted Kennedy and the late, great Paul Wellstone stepped up to the plate. The Democratic plan required companies to offer investment advice to employee/shareholders. Companies were also required to notify employees when executives were dumping their stock. Employees were not only permitted to diversify, they were warned when investments in their own company stock amounted to more than 20 percent of their portfolio. But that was too much worker protection for George Bush. He put forth his own plan, which let companies force workers to remain 100 percent invested in company stock for long periods of time, even as long as they worked for the company. The president’s proposal also denied workers any voice in how their pension plan was run. The Enron scandal shook the world. But it couldn’t shake George Bush from his loyalty to corporate robber barons and his disregard for working men and women.
Tax Cuts Aimed at the Wealthy Working Americans are hurting. They need help. But they didn’t get any from George Bush. As we will discuss in greater detail in the next chapter, he had the opportunity. Even if we couldn’t afford it, he successfully promoted two huge tax cuts: $1.3 trillion dollars’ worth in 2001 and another $2 trillion in 2003. He could have used
92
REASON #3
those tax cuts to help working families. Instead, working men and women got chicken feed. Actually, working Americans got screwed twice by Bush’s tax cuts. First, because all that money he spent on tax cuts was money not available for improving education, health care, Social Security or Medicare. Second, because they got left behind when the checks were handed out. According to Citizens for Tax Justice, 40 percent of Bush’s tax cuts were handed out to the top 1 percent of wealthiest Americans. The bottom 60 percent—made up of working men and women—received only 12.7 percent of the cuts. With his first tax cut, 34 million taxpayers—all working class citizens— got no rebate check at all. President Bush is a reverse Robin Hood. He robs from the poor in order to give to the rich. Yet he insists that all Americans will benefit from his tax cuts, because the rich will spend their extra cash and it will spread out all across the land. We’ve heard that baloney before. It’s Ronald Reagan’s old “trickle down” theory. The problem is, says the ever witty Reverend Al Sharpton, “After all these years, we still didn’t get any down. We just got the trickle.”
Paycheck Deception During the 2000 presidential race, John McCain convinced Americans of the need for campaign reform. He did such a good job selling it that he trounced George Bush by nineteen points in New Hampshire. So, once in the White House, Bush knew he needed to do something about the issue. Otherwise, everyone would think he was in bed with lobbyists and special interests—which, of course, he was. In March 2001, he trotted out his own plan for campaign reform. And guess what? It wasn’t aimed at lobbyists or special
JOBS
93
interest money at all. It was aimed at American workers. In a letter to then Senate Majority Leader Trent Lott, Bush proposed federal legislation to enforce so-called “paycheck protection,” whereby union members can refuse to have any portion of their dues used to support the union’s political activities. This is one of the oldest union-busting tricks known to humankind. It’s more accurately called “paycheck deception.” What it really does is encourage union workers to be freeloaders: enjoying all the benefits unions win for workers without helping to support them. And, by starving unions of funds, it makes them that much weaker and less able to bargain for future benefits. So-called “paycheck protection” is nothing more than the government’s way of joining forces with corporate bosses to bust the unions. And, of course, George Bush is for it.
Trying to Fake It By late 2003, Bush was so desperate to come up with even a handful of new jobs he could take credit for that he tried to fake it. The first thing he did was announce creation of a new position of “Jobs Czar” in the Commerce Department. Now, this was a crazy idea in the first place. There was no way one new bureaucrat could make up for 2.8 million lost manufacturing jobs. But then Bush proved how phony it was, and how low a priority it was for him—by waiting six months before naming anybody to the post. When he finally did get around to naming his jobs czar, Bush blew it again. It turned out that his first choice for the job, Tony Raimondo, the chairman of Behlen Manufacturing Co., a manufacturer of steel buildings, had laid off eighteen hundred employees in 2002 and opened a factory outside of Bejing! That’s
94
REASON #3
right. The very man George Bush pretended could stop the flow of jobs overseas was himself the poster boy for exporting jobs. Oops! Raimondo withdrew his name from consideration. You think that was embarrassing? You ain’t seen nothing yet. Wait till you see how he tried to redefine the nature of work and equate Mickey D’s with General Motors. Declaring that “outsourcing” was good for America was not the only anti-labor provision of “The Economic Report of the President,” which Bush signed and sent to Congress in February 2004. The same report also seriously suggested reclassifying fast-food jobs as manufacturing jobs. That was one way Bush could boast of “new manufacturing jobs created by my administration”—even though there was no guarantee that former steelworkers or autoworkers would be happy flipping burgers at McDonald’s. Bush’s ludicrous proposal prompted Michigan Congressman John Dingell, tongue planted firmly in cheek, to congratulate Bush’s top economic advisor Gregory Mankiw on his innovative approach to job creation. His letter begins: Dear Dr. Mankiw: I noticed in the recently released Economic Report of the President that there was some consternation in the defining of manufacturing. It could be inferred from your report that the administration is willing to recognize drink mixing, hamburger garnishing, French/freedom fry cooking, and milk shake mixing to be vital components of our manufacturing sector. I am sure the 163,000 factory workers who have lost their jobs in Michigan will find it heartening to know that a world of opportunity awaits them in high growth manufacturing careers like spatula operator, napkin restocking, and lunch tray removal.
JOBS
95
“It’s The Economy, Stupid” When all is said and done, that campaign slogan made famous by James Carville in the 1992 Clinton campaign still rings true today. There’s no issue more important than the economy, because it impacts each and every one of us. George Bush’s combined record on the economy—out-ofcontrol federal spending, record budget deficits, 2.8 million jobs lost—leaves him and us in bad shape. Don’t believe me? Listen to a conservative Republican. In September 2002, I spoke to a conference of the International Council of Shopping Centers in Half Moon Bay, California. Great group, by the way. Very smart and very successful businessmen. Preceding me on the program was one of their favorite speakers, Donald Straszheim, head of Straszheim Global Advisors of Santa Monica. Don gave an outstanding and detailed, if somewhat gloomy, picture of the U.S. economy, sector by sector. He told this roomful of largely Republican business leaders: “You won’t like hearing this, but we must face the facts. And I especially hate saying it while Bill Press is in the room, but: The last three years have been the worst economic performance of any president since Herbert Hoover.” Don wouldn’t say the next sentence, but I will—with glee. Based on his dismal economic record, Herbert Hoover didn’t get a second term. And neither should George W. Bush. GEORGE BUSH MUST GO!
REASON # FOUR
The Deficit: He Spent Money Like a Drunken Sailor “It’s clearly a budget. It’s got a lot of numbers in it.” George W. Bush May 5, 2000
One of the least inspiring public speakers I ever heard was former California Governor George Deukmejian. But he still delivered one of the most memorable political lines I can remember. In his first State of the State address, Deukmejian complained of his predecessor Jerry Brown: “He took the state from A-OK to IOU.” Change one word—state to nation—and that sums up the presidency of George W. Bush. He’s no compassionate conservative. And he sure as hell ain’t no fiscal conservative, either. His latest budget, for 2005, calls for a record $2.1 trillion in federal spending—with a projected deficit of $520 billion, another record. The facts are: • George Bush is the biggest spender in American history. • Federal government spending under President Bush has increased twice as fast as under President Clinton. • Only under Lyndon Johnson did the budget grow faster.
THE DEFICIT
97
• George Bush has racked up the biggest federal deficit in history. • George Bush inherited a projected $5.6 trillion, ten-year surplus. He has turned it into a projected $2.9 trillion deficit. That’s a negative swing of $8.5 trillion dollars in only three years. • Non-defense discretionary spending has gone up 14 percent—more than during eight years under Ronald Reagan or eight years under Bill Clinton. In September 2003, three fiscal watchdog groups—the Committee for Economic Development, the Concord Coalition and the Center on Budget and Policy Priorities—issued a joint statement calling the current budgetary situation “the most fiscally irresponsible” in U.S. history. I must be getting old, because I can still remember when Republicans used to be the party of smaller government. And the party of fiscal responsibility. No longer. Ronald Reagan cracked the mold and George H. W. Bush broke it, but George W. Bush smashed it to pieces. And it started even before he came to Washington. As governor of Texas, Bush was already a big spender. According to the Dallas Morning News, during his five years in office, the annual state budget catapulted from $73 billion to $98.1 billion—a 34 percent leap in spending which dwarfed the federal government’s 21 percent increase over the same period. That just whetted George Bush’s appetite for big spending— and bigger government—once he set up camp on the shores of the Potomac, a big spending spree that started the day he took office.
98
REASON #4
$pending $pree Under George Bush, we’ve suffered from what New York Times columnist Thomas Friedman calls the “budgets of mass destruction.” Here’s Dubya’s most recent spending spree, as calculated by budget analyst Brian Riedl of the conservative Heritage Foundation: 1. In 2003, President Bush presided over $2.157 trillion in federal spending—with a $374 billion deficit. 2. In 2003, inflation-adjusted federal spending topped $20,000 per household for for the first time since World War II. 3. In 2003, under George Bush, the federal government spent $20,300 per household, taxed each household $16,780 and left each household with a deficit of $3,520. 4. 2004, like 2003, will see the highest level of federal spending since World War II. If Bill Clinton had run the government like that, Republicans would have accused him of fiscal irresponsibility. And rightly so. No doubt you’ve heard the White House spin on all this big spending. It’s not George Bush’s fault, they piously insist, it’s the fault of Democrats in Congress. And, besides, it’s all because of 9/11. Don’t you believe it. Bush can’t blame his spending spree on congressional Democrats, as in: “They made me do it.” Except for a brief interlude in 2001—when Democrats controlled the Senate, thanks to the defection of Republican Jim Jeffords— Republicans have been in charge of Congress for the entire Bush presidency. Nor can Bush blame it all on congressional Republicans.
THE DEFICIT
99
He’s the president. It’s his budget, his spending, his tax cuts and his deficit. As a candidate for president, George Bush didn’t promise to cut one single federal program. And since assuming the office, as many conservatives in Congress have pointed out—he hasn’t vetoed one single spending bill. Leading conservative Paul Weyrich, national chairman of Coalitions for America, told a news conference on January 15, 2004: “I complained about profligate spending during the Clinton years, but never thought I’d have to do so with a Republican in the White House and Republicans controlling the Congress.” Arizona Senator John McCain, who accuses Congress of “spending money like a drunken sailor,” says Bush must bear at least part of the blame. “The president cannot say, as he has many times, that I’m going to tell Congress to enforce some spending discipline,” McCain points out, “and then not veto bills.” Not only that, under President Clinton, a Republicancontrolled Congress had passed a rule requiring that all new tax cuts or spending proposals be offset by tax increases or benefit reductions: a plan called “pay as you go.” But even that brake on new spending was allowed to expire in 2002 without a peep from the White House. Congress reinstated it in 2004. Bush can’t blame it on September 11, either. Again, the numbers tell the whole story. From 2001 to 2003, federal spending went up $296 billion. New defense spending accounted for $100 billion, or 34 percent of that increase. Homeland security–related spending took up another $32 billion, or 11 percent. New discretionary spending, totally unrelated to defense or security, captured the largest share: $164 billion, or 55 percent. What did George Bush spend all our money on? Anything he could think of. Including $1.5 billion for federal marriage
100
REASON #4
counselors to meet with young couples and advise them on how to have a “happy and healthy marriages.” No, folks, I am not making this up. At a debate in Orlando, when I informed former House Speaker Newt Gingrich of this latest Bush proposal, he said it was the craziest idea he had ever heard of. Especially from the president of what used to be the small government party. Here’s another Bush special. Ten years ago, conservatives were crying for elimination of the National Endowment for the Arts. “Why should the government be funding artists?” was the rallying cry of Gingrich, Dick Armey, Jesse Helms and others. For 2005, George Bush gave the NEA, the conservatives’ favorite whipping boy, an additional $18 million—15 percent more than it received in 2004. But, for George Bush, that was just chump change. Not counting the war in Afghanistan, the new Homeland Security Department or the costly war on and occupation of Iraq, here are a few of his bigger ticket items.
Supersize Spending Bill Exhibit A of George Bush’s spending spree is the Omnibus Spending Bill he signed into law in January 2004, just to keep the lights on in government agencies. The total price tag was $820 billion. This supplemental spending bill for 2004 includes $328 billion of new, non-defense related, discretionary spending and $23 billion in projects identified by Citizens Against Government Waste as pure government pork. But Big Spender Bush didn’t hestitate to approve the whole enchilada.
THE DEFICIT
101
Subsidies for Rich Farmers The farm bill sent by Congress to President Bush in May 2002 wasn’t just another government handout. Conservative legislators called it the largest non-defense expansion of government since the Great Society. The Congressional Budget Office put a price tag on the bill of $171 billion over ten years. That’s bad enough. But, after reviewing the history of agricultural subsidies, the Heritage Foundation’s Brian Riedl said the full cost of Bush’s program would likely soar to $462 billion over the next decade—more than the government will spend on education and environmental protection combined. At that rate, each of America’s 456,000 full-time farms would receive a windfall of $1 million in subsidies and higher food prices. Which would cost the average American household $1,805 in higher taxes and $2,572 in higher food prices. In other words, somebody has to pay. And that’s you and me. It wouldn’t be so bad if those subsidies went to poor, struggling family farms—as a temporary prop to help them get on their feet. No such luck. Bush’s agricultural payments are like his tax cuts: They go mainly to the rich. Three-quarters of the subsidies go to the top 10 percent of farmers, with an annual average income of over $250,000. Biggest farm subsidies ever? Welfare for the rich? George Bush doesn’t care. He signed the bill anyway. And, one year later, he signed an even bigger one.
Pricey Prescription Drugs In 2003, George Bush broke both his own record and the bank too, with the new “benefit” of prescription drugs—the
102
REASON #4
biggest government expansion since LBJ created Medicare in 1965. The mega-pork Medicare bill signed by President Bush was opposed by many liberals because it contained no cost controls, rewarded pharmaceutical companies with windfall profits and would end up costing seniors more for prescription drugs, not less. And because, beginning in 2006, it would stick seniors with higher premiums for less coverage. Bush’s Medicare plan was also opposed by many conservatives, because of its budget-busting cost, which the White House said at the time was $400 billion. But, once again, George Bush pulled the old “bait and switch” on members of Congress. In late January 2004, one month after he had signed the legislation, the White House announced that the cost of the president’s new Medicare plan was actually $534 billion— which increased the projected 2005 deficit to $520 billion. Documents obtained by the Washington Post also revealed that the White House knew months earlier that the actual cost would be over $500 billion—but deliberately lied to Congress and the American people, using the $400 billion figure, until after the Medicare legislation had been enacted by Congress and signed into law by the president. Richard S. Foster, chief actuary of the Medicare program, later told the New York Times that he was aware of the higher price tag, but had been warned by the Bush administration not to tell anyone—or risk being fired. You’re not surprised, are you? If they’ll lie about weapons of mass destruction, why wouldn’t they lie about Medicare? Not all conservatives in Congress rolled over for Bush. Freshman Congressman Tom Feeney of Florida told reporters about a personal call he received from the president, asking him to vote for the Medicare package. “I basically said it was a matter of principle,” Feeney recalled. He told the president: “I didn’t come to Washington to ratify and expand Great Society programs.” “Neither did I, pal!” retorted Bush.
THE DEFICIT
103
Nor did all conservative commentators keep their mouths shut either, as the White House had hoped. Stephen Moore, president of the Club for Growth, the leading spokesman in Washington for limited government and unlimited tax cuts, said the Medicare bill proved that “George Bush doesn’t have an anti–Big Government bone in his body.” In the Washington Times, columnist Cal Thomas called Bush’s Medicare bill “a pathetic betrayal of the faith many had put in the Republican Party to reduce the size and role of government in our lives.” Writing in the same conservative rag, Human Events editor Terry Jeffrey uttered a typical conservative lament: “Since when did subsidized drug handouts become a defining issue for the party of limited government?” Answer: Once George Bush took office. Under him, the Republican Party is no longer the party of limited government or fiscal discipline.
Mission to Mars In January 2004, President Bush announced his goofiest and most expensive proposal to date: a manned mission to Mars, following the establishment of a permanent American space station on the moon. No, no. George Bush didn’t say he wanted to send himself to Mars. We should be so lucky. He proposed sending a whole squadron of astronauts to Mars, instead. Even so, it’s too bad he didn’t talk to his daddy first. Bush 41 entertained the same bold stroke. It was one way, he believed, to prove that he did, after all, have a long-term vision for the country. Or, as used to say, it was good for “the vision thing.” But he abandoned the idea when NASA told him the first few missions would cost $400 billion—in 1989 dollars. Obviously, Bush 43 didn’t ask the key question—“How
104
REASON #4
much will this dang thing cost?”—before launching his own moon/Mars mission. But others did. And the numbers are out of this world. Literally. The two remote-controlled rovers, “Spirit” and “Opportunity,” which landed on Mars in early 2004 and sent back such remarkable photos, weighed only a ton—and cost $410 million each. According to The New Republic’s Gregg Easterbrook, if the one-thousand-ton equipment necessary to land a team of astronauts on Mars could be launched at the same price per pound, sometime around 2015, the total cost would be $410 billion. Think about that. $410 billion—more than the entire $374 billion budget deficit for 2003—for one single Mars mission. This is nuts! And President Bush himself must have had a bad case of sticker shock. Less than a week later, delivering his third State of the Union address, he didn’t say one word about going to Mars. Nevertheless, some conservatives started calling him “President Moonbeam.” And then there’s the biggest ticket item in George Bush’s reckless spending.
Tax Cuts Okay. Before anybody accuses me of mixing apples and oranges, suddenly switching from spending proposals to tax cuts, I want to make one thing perfectly clear. Don’t believe the Bush propaganda that cutting taxes is different from spending money. In the end, they are one and the same. Sure, they’re different in that money spent goes into a new or existing government program. And taxes cut go into your pocket. Into your pocket, that is, as long as you’re part of the lucky 1 percent of wealthiest Americans who actually benefit from George Bush’s tax giveaways.
THE DEFICIT
105
But spending and tax cuts are the same in the most important sense: They’re both money out the door. One minute, you’ve got a trillion in the bank. The next minute—whether you’ve spent it on schools or tax cuts—you don’t. George Bush’s tax cuts are the most costly, most outrageous, most reckless, most unfair, most harmful and most fiscally irresponsible expenditures of his administration. Bush’s obsession with tax cuts has driven even many fiscally responsible Republicans crazy. In his book Running on Empty, Pete Peterson, former commerce secretary under President Nixon, laments: “At a time when the federal government should be building up surpluses to prepare for the aging of the baby boom generation, it is engaged in another reckless experiment with large and permanent tax cuts.” There have been three Bush tax cuts: 2001, 2002 and 2003. (He’s now pushing for another one in 2004.) And they’re all bad. His first tax cut, in 2001, came when there was still a huge Clinton surplus. We’ve got money left over, so give it back to the people, Bush said. Sounds reasonable, except for the fact that there were a lot more pressing needs those funds could have been used for—like shoring up Social Security, for example. Or providing health care for the 43 million Americans who don’t have any. Bush made the call. Instead of taking advantage of a oneterm surplus to fix Social Security or solve the health care crisis, he chose to line the pockets of the rich with a $1.3 trillion tax cut. His second tax cut, in 2002, was equally irresponsible. Since this time there was already a deficit, Bush suddenly changed his tune. A year before he had argued that tax cuts were the perfect solution in times of surplus because we had too much cash lying around. Now he argued that tax cuts were the perfect solution in times of deficits because they would stimulate the economy and create new jobs.
106
REASON #4
Of course, that never happened. But the facts never stopped George Bush. One year later, with the economy struggling to deal with a colossal $374 billion deficit, he was back with still another tax cut. And now in 2004, when we’re even deeper in debt, he’s back for more—his fourth proposed tax cut. No matter how deep the hole, George Bush just keeps on digging. He’s spending as if we still have lots of money in the bank. Right there, that tells you something about George W. Bush: He doesn’t have a clue when it comes to fiscal policy. As far as he’s concerned, there’s only one solution to every problem. Surplus or deficit, rain or shine, good times or bad, war or peace, it doesn’t matter. Like some windup doll, George Bush spits out the same two words: tax cuts, tax cuts, tax cuts. But there was another big problem with Bush’s tax cutting zeal. Not only did he spend over $4 trillion dollars on tax cuts when the nation could not afford it, he also deliberately targeted his tax cuts only to the upper crust. The vast majority of American families got little, if any, relief.
Tax Cut 2001: Boondoggle for the Rich When Chief Justice William Rehnquist persuaded four other justices to join him in crowning George W. Bush president of the United States, the nation was enjoying an unprecedented period of economic prosperity: reflected in a balanced budget, an in-the-bank $127 billion surplus and a projected ten-year surplus of $5.6 trillion. Today, it’s all gone—thanks to George Bush’s tax cuts. Just three weeks after he walked into the Oval Office, Bush rolled out his across-the-board cut in income taxes—even though John McCain and Steve Forbes, both big tax cut advocates
THE DEFICIT
107
themselves, had argued that Bush’s plan would sink the federal government back into deficit spending. At that time, the federal government faced the kind of choice we would love to face in our own bank accounts, at least once in our lifetime: What’s the best way to use that extra cash on hand? It was a question of priorities. The country still had many unmet needs: 43 million Americans without health care; seniors on Medicare with no prescription drug coverage; a Social Security system about to go broke; and public schools in need of repair. That was one option for using the surplus. The other was to give it back in the form of tax cuts. George Bush made all the wrong choices. He decided to reward his fat cat friends and screw the people. Instead of giving tax cuts to middle class Americans who needed them the most—and would go out and spend the money right away, giving the economy a big shot in the arm—he handed it all to those who don’t need it: the very wealthiest Americans. Now let’s take a minute out to correct a big slice of Republican propaganda: that Democrats don’t like tax cuts. Not true. Democrats are 100 percent for tax cuts. As long as we can afford them. And provided they go to the people who need them. And that’s where George Bush went wrong. You’ve heard the rhetoric. President Bush bragged that his first tax cut—$1.35 trillion over ten years—would grant the average family $1,600 in relief. And that those families at the bottom of the economic ladder would receive the biggest percentage of cuts. Neither was true. Bush’s tax cuts did not help lower income or middle class families. Had he wanted to help working families, he would have cut the highly regressive payroll tax. But by
108
REASON #4
cutting income taxes across the board—which means those who pay the most naturally get the biggest tax cuts—he simply further fattened the bank accounts of the already well-to-do.
The White House hates an organization called Citizens for Tax Justice (http://www.ctj.org) because they have blown the whistle on every phony promise Bush has made about his tax cuts. But neither the president nor his economic advisors have ever disproved CTJ’s findings. They can’t. Because CTJ’s numbers are right. According to Citizens for Tax Justice: 1. The average family got nowhere near $1,600. • 90 percent of taxpayers received less than $1,600 in relief. • 27 percent of taxpayers received no relief at all. 2. Most of the tax relief went to families at the top of the ladder. • 40 percent of tax cuts went to the wealthiest 1 percent of Americans, those struggling souls making over $337,000 a year. • 53 percent of tax cuts went to the wealthiest 5 percent of Americans, those making over $147,000 a year. • The lower 40 percent of families, those making $27,000 or less, received only 4.3 percent of the cuts. • Families making between $27,000 and $44,000 received 8.4 percent of cuts. • The typical single taxpayer received only $249 from the Bush plan, after the first-year-only rebate of $300—forced on Bush by Democrats. • The best off one-half of 1 percent of taxpayers received an average $46,000 tax cut.
THE DEFICIT
109
Protecting the Family Castle One special feature of the 2001 tax cut best illustrates Bush’s compulsion for making the rich even richer: the gradual elimination of the estate tax. Now, even for Republicans, this was tricky. How to convince the American people that those who inherit huge pieces of property—the equivalent of European castles—should pay no taxes? How to whip up sympathy for America’s nobility, living in luxury on their landed estates? Bingo! Republican focus groups produced the perfect solution: Change the name. Don’t call it the “estate tax.” Call it instead the “death tax.” And don’t call them castles, mansions or estates. Call them “family farms” instead. Parroting this cynical research, George Bush suddenly started talking about “getting rid of the estate tax in order to save America’s family farms.” But it was all a big lie. First of all, it’s not a “death” tax. Dead people don’t pay it. Their heirs do, when they are suddenly handed huge sums of unearned money. Here’s what I don’t understand. If a working person has to pay taxes on every dollar he or she earns by the sweat of his or her brow, why shouldn’t others have to pay taxes on every dollar they simply inherit? Why do people who work for a living get the shaft, while those who inherit their wealth pay no taxes? Isn’t that un-American? Not to George Bush—who, of course, stands to inherit a shitload of money himself. One more thing. Let’s be honest. This has nothing to do with family farms. Under existing law, a farm couple can pass on to their heirs a farm worth up to $4.1 million without paying any taxes—as long as their kids continue to farm the property for ten years. In fact, when queried by reporters, the American Farm Bureau, one of the big supporters of Bush’s attempt to repeal the estate tax, admitted they could not name
110
REASON #4
one single farm in the entire country that was lost because of estate taxes. Not one. How many Americans would benefit from repeal of the estate tax? Damned few. The tax only applies to properties worth at least $1 million, or $2 million for couples, and a husband or wife can leave any size estate to their spouse tax-free. As calculated by the Center for Budget and Policy Priorities, the estate tax applies to less than three thousand estates in the entire country, all worth in excess of $5 million. Again, only the extremely wealthy care. And only the extremely wealthy—like the Bushes and the Cheneys—benefit. Saying it helps working families doesn’t make it so. The first round of Bush tax cuts in 2001 was nothing but welfare for the rich. And so was the next big package, round three in 2003.
Tax Cut 2003: The Rich Get Richer You’ve already given the wealthiest people in America a huge bonanza of a tax cut. So what do you for an encore? If you’re George Bush, the answer is easy: You give them another one! And that’s exactly what he did. On May 28, 2003, President Bush signed another mammoth tax cut, this one even bigger than the first: $1.6 trillion over ten years, not counting $400 billion in added interest payments on the federal debt. This plan accelerated some of the tax cuts originally enacted in 2001, but also included reductions in taxes on capital gains and stock dividends. George Bush again sold his tax cut as a gift to the middle class. “These tax reductions will bring real and immediate benefits to middle-income Americans,” he stated. “Ninety-two million Americans will keep an average of $1,083 more of their own money.”
THE DEFICIT
111
Nonsense. Like his buddy, Enron’s Ken Lay, President Bush was cooking the books. Say you had a roomful of homeless people—and in walks Bill Gates. Their net worth is nothing; his is $400 billion. Suddenly, the “average” net worth of everybody in the room is $100 million! According to George Bush’s math, those homeless folks just got rich fast. And, according to his math, most Americans got a $1,083 tax cut. Except they didn’t. It’s a bogus statistic. The only true measure of the fairness of any tax relief is the median tax cut, not the average. As the word “median” indicates, it’s the dollar level smack dab in the middle of the tax cuts. Half of Americans receive more than that amount; the other half of Americans get less. For 2003 and 2004, the median tax cut for the Bush plan is $120. That’s a long way from $1,083. But, if George Bush insists on talking about averages, here are some real average figures—as calculated by our friends at Citizens for Tax Justice—numbers never disputed by the Bush administration: • 31 percent of American taxpayers will get absolutely nothing—zip!—from the 2003 Bush tax plan. • In 2003, 49 percent of all taxpayers received $100 or less in tax reduction—for an average tax cut of $19. • By 2006, 88 percent of all taxpayers will receive $100 or less—for an average tax cut of $4. • From 2003 to 2007, the bottom 60 percent of American taxpayers will receive an average $350 total in tax cuts. • During the same period, the wealthiest 1 percent of Americans will receive an average total tax cut of $96,634. And, of course, something had to give to make way for Mr. Bush’s tax cuts. Among the items he put on the chopping block in his latest budget: home heating subsidies; job training and employment programs; housing vouchers for the poor; Title I
112
REASON #4
funding for the nation’s poorest schools; and health care benefits for veterans. The budget also raises the entrance fees for national forests and parks. Gotta pay for those tax cuts somehow. And, for Bush, tax cuts for the wealthy are a higher priority than money for the homeless or veterans.
Don’t Tax My Portfolio The centerpiece of Bush’s 2003 tax cut package was his demand to eliminate the tax on stock dividends. This idea was not included in his original plan. Nobody in the administration even thought of it until it was suggested to the president in an economic forum by mega-broker Charles Schwab—who, of course, would stand to reap an enormous windfall, both personally and professionally, as head of one of the nation’s largest investment firms. George Bush looked like he was ready to cry “Bingo!” One more chance to help his pals on Wall Street. But, of course, he couldn’t be honest and promote gutting the tax on dividends as payback to Charles Schwab, Merrill Lynch and Paine Webber. So he sold it instead as a boon to America’s senior citizens. Does this guy have no shame? In the end, Congress did not eliminate the tax on dividends. It reduced it to the same level as the tax on capital gains, 15 percent—at a cost of $396 billion over ten years. But, even so, how could a cut in dividend taxes benefit most American seniors? Three-quarters of seniors don’t qualify because they don’t own any stock, or they receive less than $1 per year in stock dividends. Most of the rest have their stocks tied up in retirement funds, where they don’t pay any taxes anyway until they withdraw their funds. Of those seniors who do benefit from a lower tax on dividends, the biggest cuts go to only 2.7 percent of America’s el-
THE DEFICIT
113
derly, those with annual incomes of over $200,000 per year, hardly the Mom and Pop crowd. Meanwhile, 77 percent of seniors, with annual incomes of $50,000 or less, receive only an average $44 tax cut. Most seniors would have been better off if George Bush had spent that $396 billion shoring up Social Security or Medicare. Like every other one of Bush’s tax scams, the cut in taxes on stock dividends is designed to help those who need it least.
Bush Launches Class Warfare You know as well as I that every time we point out how Bush’s tax cuts are overwhelmingly geared toward helping the wealthiest people in the country, conservatives go bonkers— accusing us of “class warfare,” pitting one class of Americans against another. So let’s get this straight, once and for all. It’s not Democrats who started class warfare. It’s George Bush who started class warfare—by waging war on the poor and middle class. His entire administration so far is nothing but class warfare. He takes care of the top 5 percent—and he leaves the other 95 percent to fend for themselves. Democrats don’t have anything against rich people. In fact, some of the wealthiest people in this country are strong Democrats. Just look at the Kennedys. But Democrats believe that the wealthy should pay their fair share of taxes, and not always be looking for another government handout. That’s the spirit of William H. Gates, Sr., father of the richest man in the world, who spoke out against President Bush’s plan to eliminate the estate tax because, he argued: “Taxing dead multimillionaires is eminently more fair than taxing the not-so-rich living.” That was the spirit of Edward Filene, founder of the great Filene’s department store and bargain basement, who also
114
REASON #4
helped organize the U.S. Chamber of Commerce in 1912. “Why shouldn’t the American people take half my money from me?” he said about taxes. “I took all of it from them.” And that’s the spirit of CNN’s Larry King. During the 2000 Democratic convention in Los Angeles, I was chatting outside our work space with Larry. Talk got around to taxes and he told me: “Let me tell you something. Last year, I paid $3 million in taxes. And you know what I say?” I shook my head no, waiting for the standard rant against government’s picking his pockets, but Larry surprised me. “I say, that means I had a damned good year. And I hope I owe even more taxes next year.” What a contrast to George Bush’s fat cat friends, who are motivated by one thing only: pure greed. They want the United States to launch preemptive wars around the world, but they don’t want to pay the taxes to support our military. They want to drive their gas-guzzling, air-polluting Hummers from Houston to Denver, but they don’t want to pay the taxes to maintain the interstates. They want to make millions, but they don’t want to pay taxes to support the best government in the world, without which they wouldn’t be free to make a dime.
Largest Deficits in History Now here’s the problem: When you combine George Bush’s big spending and his big tax cuts, what do you get? Big trouble. I never thought I’d hear myself say this, but here goes: Where’s Ross Perot when we really need him? In 1992, he got the American people so fired up about the budget deficit, he got 19 percent of the vote—and helped elect Bill Clinton president! Now, here’s what’s interesting. In 1992, under the first President Bush, the deficit—even though it was the second largest in history—was only $186 billion. And the national debt was $3 trillion. Today, under Junior Bush, the projected deficit for
THE DEFICIT
115
2005 has ballooned to a whopping $520 billion, an all-time record high. And that does not include the cost of the occupation of Afghanistan, or the war with and occupation of Iraq. The national debt is now over $7 trillion and George Bush is seeking authorization to raise it another $1 trillion. I repeat: Where’s Ross Perot when we really need him? If Mr. Perot would come out of his self-imposed exile, there are two points he would make about budget deficits. The first is: If you want a balanced budget, elect a Democrat. If you want a giant budget deficit, elect a Republican. And that’s the God’s honest truth. Not one Republican president has balanced the budget in the last thirty-four years. I checked the history of balanced budgets, starting with President Jimmy Carter. Here are the numbers, which you can find on the website of the Bush White House Office of Management and Budget. Notice how deficits went down, or disappeared, under Democrats. And, despite all their rhetoric, notice how it went up, up, up under Republicans. President
Year
Deficit/Surplus
Carter
1977 1978 1979 1980
−$22 −$34 −$18 −$11
Reagan
1981 1982 1983 1984 1985 1986 1987 1988
−$13 billion −$38 billion −$109 billion −$143 billion −$178 billion −$211 billion −$157 billion −$128 billion
billion billion billion billion
116
REASON #4
(continued) President
Year
Deficit/Surplus
Bush 41
1989 1990 1991 1992
−$121 −$124 −$148 −$186
Clinton
1993 1994 1995 1996 1997 1998 1999 2000
−$188 billion −$142 billion −$147 billion −$96 billion −$83 billion −$32 billion +$12 billion* +$108 billion*
Bush 43
2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 Projected
+$106 billion* −$146 billion −$313 billion −$374 billion −$520 billion
billion billion billion billion
The numbers don’t lie. The asterisks indicate the only three years in the last twenty-eight that the federal government has reported a surplus. All three—1999, 2000 and 2001—were budgets submitted by President Clinton. Ronald Reagan ran for president promising to balance the budget. He even promoted the Balanced Budget Amendment. Instead, he racked up more debt than all previous presidents combined. George H. W. Bush became president, promising to balance the budget. And didn’t. Bill Clinton promised to cut the deficit in half. He did more
THE DEFICIT
117
than that. He eliminated the deficit and left George W. Bush with a $106 billion surplus. George W. Bush squandered the surplus and delivered the biggest deficits in history. And now he has the audacity to claim that his budget plan will cut the deficit in half in five years. Does anybody really believe that? Remember, this is the same guy who predicted that his first round of tax cuts would actually produce a surplus and create 5.5 million new jobs. Count on the Congressional Budget Office for setting the record straight. According to their analysis, President Bush’s budget will not only not cut the deficit in half over five years, it will run up $2.75 trillion in additional debt over the next decade.
Deficits Do Matter Ever since Ronald Reagan rode into town on his white horse, the conservative mantra has been: “No deficits. The budget must be balanced.” As noted by the Concord Coalition and fellow budget hawks: “For twenty years, there was bipartisan consensus in Washington that large and rising budget deficits were damaging. The budget debate . . . was often rancorous, but it was based on the shared goal of shrinking the large, damaging deficits that loomed.” That changed suddenly with the disastrous presidency of George W. Bush. Fiscally responsible conservatives and liberals still believe in the virtue of not spending more money than you have, but the Bush White House has adopted a different tune: “Deficits don’t matter.” That’s what Vice President Dick Cheney told former Treasury Secretary Paul O’Neill. Reading The Price of Loyalty, you get the feeling that having O’Neill present at meetings of the Bush cabinet was like finding the proverbial turd in the punch
118
REASON #4
bowl. At one meeting, O’Neill proposed building “triggers” into the tax cuts: provisions that would kick in and prevent some of the cuts if the surplus disappeared. The president wanted no part of such a prudent backstop. At another skull session, O’Neill warned the vice president that the country could not afford the massive tax cuts Bush was proposing because they would surely lead to huge deficits. According to O’Neill, Cheney cut him off with a curt “Reagan proved deficits don’t matter.” Meaning, of course, you can always charge everything to the government’s credit card. It would be wonderful if this were true. But it’s not. The federal government cannot continue to spend over budget, no more than you and I can in our own household. Sooner or later, those bills come due. Someday, somebody has to pay off the credit card. Deficits matter because they have a huge psychological impact on Wall Street. Simply put: Investors have less confidence in the American economy when the federal government can’t manage its own funds. Even President Bush pretended to understand that when he told congressional Republicans on January 31, 2004: “One clear signal we need to send to the American people and the markets is, we’re going to be wise when it comes to the expenditure of the people’s money.” But, of course, George Bush never practices what he preaches. President Clinton, by contrast, both preached and practiced the same lesson. In his own memoirs, In an Uncertain World, Clinton’s Treasury Secretary Robert Rubin writes: “In important ways, the deficit had become a symbol of the government’s inability to manage its own affairs—and of our society’s inability to cope with economic challenges more generally, such as our global competitiveness, then much in question. The view that fiscal discipline was being restored contributed to lower interest rates and increased confidence, and that led to more spending and investment, which in turn led to job creation, lower unemployment rates, and increased productivity.”
THE DEFICIT
119
Deficits also matter, as we know in our own lives, because more debt means spending more money just to pay interest on the debt. Same with the federal government. Large deficits absorb national savings, crowd out productive investment and suck up money that could be used for other priorities, like defense, education or health care. As the Concord Coalition points out, that’s true whether we owe the debt to American or foreign investors. “If they [deficits] are financed by borrowing from domestic lenders, the economy will have less money available for investing in plant and equipment, education for our children and training for our workers, research and development, and the other building blocks of our economic future. If they are financed by foreigners, we will owe a mushrooming debt to the rest of the world, with growing interest costs that must be serviced very year.”
Note: George Bush would never admit it, but it’s quite possible that he’s purposely running up huge deficits in order to force spending cuts and leave Congress less money available to spend on other programs. This is the old “starve the beast” theory first proposed by Reagan Budget Director David Stockman: that the only way to stop Congress from spending is to put the country so deeply in debt there’s no money left in the till. If true, this would not only make President Bush dishonest, by lying to the American people about the need for deficit spending, it would also make him even more fiscally irresponsible, by saddling future generations with mountains of debt to pay for his refusal or inability to keep spending under control. Especially when it’s Bush himself, not the Congress, who’s responsible for most of the new spending over the last four years.
120
REASON #4
In a January 2004 radio address, President Bush told his audience: “My plan reduces the national debt . . . so fast, in fact, that economists worry that we are going to run out of debt to retire.” When he says stuff like that, you have to wonder: Is he deliberately lying or just appallingly uninformed? Budget analysts at the Concord Coalition estimate that interest payments on the national debt will reach $470 billion a year—bigger than the entire defense department budget—by 2013. That is simply money pissed away. Finally, deficits matter because whatever bills we can’t pay, we’re just stacking up for our children and grandchildren to pay. And that’s just downright irresponsible. By 2008, once baby boomers start to retire, the costs of Social Security, Medicare and Medicaid will be growing faster than the economy. It’s going to be tough enough to pay for that. But President Bush is making it worse, piling on even more debt that future generations will have to deal with before they can solve their own problems. Given today’s huge budget deficits, there’s no other way out. Our kids will face higher taxes, or reduced public services, thanks to George Bush. Which is just the opposite of what he promised in his second State of the Union address on January 28, 2003: “We will not deny, we will not ignore, we will not pass along our problems to other Congresses, to other presidents, and other generations.” Promises made, promises broken. Today, when asked about deficit spending, President Bush gives one of two answers. Sometimes, he makes a joke of it. “You know,” he says, “when I was campaigning in Chicago in the general election, somebody said, ‘Would you ever deficit spend?’ I said, only if we were at war, or if there was a national emergency, or we were in a recession. Little did I realize we’d get the trifecta.” There’s only one problem with that answer. Reporters
THE DEFICIT
121
double-checked every statement made during the campaign. He never said it. Bush’s other response is to insist that, facing a huge deficit, more spending and more tax cuts are the answer. We’re already in a hole, he argues, so by going deeper into the hole, we will spend ourselves out of the hole. More spending! More tax cuts! There’s only one problem with that answer. He’s dead wrong. When you’re in a hole, the first rule is to stop digging.
The Deficit and September 11 As he does with everything else, President Bush is still trying to blame the budget deficit on September 11. Don’t you believe it. It’s another big Bush lie. The calendar tells the whole story. In April 2001, the White House predicted the surplus would climb to $125 billion by the end of the year. In May 2001, Bush signed his $1.3 trillion tax cut. By August 2001, one month before September 11, the Congressional Budget Office reported that the surplus had disappeared and we were already back into deficit spending. One-third of the surplus lost, said the CBO, was due to a steadily weakening economy. Twothirds of it was caused by the Bush tax cut. In its latest report, February 2004, the CBO confirmed that 36 percent of the federal deficit is due to the combined Bush tax cuts, 31 percent to new spending on defense and security, and the remaining 33 percent to the continuing economic slowdown. September 11 didn’t create the deficits. George Bush’s irresponsible tax cuts did.
122
REASON #4
Bottom Line: Blame It on Bush As noted above, it’s not just liberals who are concerned about Bush’s reckless spending. Many fiscally responsible conservatives are, too—and more and more of them are speaking out. In the December 8, 2003, issue of The Weekly Standard, Executive Editor Fred Barnes writes: “Under Bush, the era of small government is over.” “Want to curb federal spending?” Barnes asks. “Replace President Bush with a Democrat.” Adding: “This is not entirely a joke.” That’s a leading conservative speaking. As a liberal, I second the motion. For uncontrolled spending, unaffordable and unfair tax cuts and historic budget deficits . . . For three years of fiscal mismanagement . . . GEORGE BUSH MUST GO!
REASON # FIVE
The Patriot Act: He Undermined Our Most Basic Freedoms “If he’s—the inference is that somehow he thinks that slavery is a—is a noble institution I would—I would strongly reject that assumption—that John Ashcroft is an open-minded, inclusive person.” George W. Bush January 14, 2001
Most of us have read George Orwell’s classic 1984. Did you ever think you’d live in an America where people were rounded up, thrown in prison and held for years without a trial and without being allowed to talk to a lawyer? Did you ever think you’d live in an America where cops could search your home first—and get permission second? Did you ever think you’d live in an America where the government could pry into your bank records, e-mails, credit card accounts and drug prescriptions— even though you’d committed no crime? Did you ever think you’d live in an America where every library book you checked out was monitored and reported to the FBI? Well, friends, you live in that kind of America today. Welcome to George Bush’s America, where civil liberties have been seriously undermined in the name of fighting terrorism. We hear a lot of talk about the constitution these days: the new constitution adopted in Iraq. But I don’t know why they bothered to write their own. Why didn’t we just give them ours? After all, it’s a brilliantly crafted document. It’s worked
124
REASON #5
for 217 years. And we’re not using it anymore. In fact, we’re abusing it. Correction. We’re not abusing it. George Bush and John Ashcroft are. And we’re letting them get away with it. Let’s start right there. You don’t really need ten reasons to vote against George Bush. You need just one: John Ashcroft. Or, as I call him, J. Edgar Ashcroft. Making him attorney general was one of George Bush’s worst decisions. We knew from his record as a senator what kind of A.G. he’d be. This is the guy who led the opposition to James Hormel’s nomination as ambassador to Luxembourg. A prominent San Francisco businessman and philanthropist, Hormel had strong bipartisan support for his ambassadorial job. But Ashcroft insisted he was unqualified to represent the United States. Hormel happens to be openly gay. This is the guy who deep-sixed the nomination of Ronnie White, respected chief justice of the Missouri Supreme Court, to the federal bench. Ashcroft accused White of being “procriminal,” simply because he was the sole dissenting vote in one death penalty case—even though, on every other capital punishment case, he voted the same way as the three justices appointed by Ashcroft when he was governor. But White also happens to be black. Which, in Ashcroft’s mind, is almost as bad as being gay. Too harsh? Remember, this is the guy who met with a leader of the Council of Conservative Citizens to discuss the plight of one of their members, imprisoned for conspiring to kill an FBI agent. The CCC are a group of Southerners who consider African-Americans intellectually inferior to whites. Trent Lott got in trouble for meeting with them, too. Ashcroft is also the guy who went to Bob Jones University in 1999, one year before it dropped its ban on interracial dating, to proclaim that “America is unique among nations” be-
THE PATRIOT ACT
125
cause “we have no king but Jesus.” In Ashcroft’s America, Muslims, Jews, Buddhists and nonbelievers are not welcome. At his confirmation hearing, forty-two senators voted against Ashcroft: a record number of no votes for any attorney general nominee. And these were the people who knew him best, his fellow senators. Still, J. Edgar Ashcroft sneaked by. He soon proved, in the most bizarre way, to be the same moralistic zealot he’d been as attorney general, governor and senator of Missouri. One of his first official acts was to order that a huge statue of Lady Liberty in the Justice Department lobby be draped with blue cloth. Lady Liberty, you see, had bare breasts. In fact, since she was twelve feet tall, she had big bare breasts. J. Edgar was worried that reporters might be distracted during his news conferences—staring at her, instead of inscribing his powerful words. So he had her covered, from head to toe—even though George Bush would soon go to war against countries that forced women to wear a burka. If that doesn’t make Ashcroft a zealot, I don’t know what does. But I digress. Once Ashcroft was confirmed, we knew we were in trouble. We just didn’t know how much. We knew he’d go after criminals. That’s what attorney generals are supposed to do. We just didn’t expect him to go after law-abiding citizens. Hey, folks. That’s you and me. And it all started on September 12, 2001. Now, I don’t know about you, but I didn’t fly any plane into the World Trade Center. And I don’t know any other American who did. Nineteen foreign nationals flew those planes into the World Trade Center and the Pentagon. Fifteen of them were from Saudi Arabia, one from Lebanon, two from the United Arab Emirates and one from Egypt. But John Ashcroft’s response was to declare war on American citizens—by chipping away at our liberties.
126
REASON #5
If you don’t believe me, ask former Georgia Congressman Bob Barr. If Bob Barr didn’t exist, liberals would have to invent him. He called for Bill Clinton’s impeachment two years before Monica Lewinsky ever went to work at the White House. He served on the Board of the NRA—while still a member of Congress. He authored the Defense of Marriage Act, even though he was twice divorced. Around Washington, Bob Barr was known as Mr. Conservative and Mr. Mean. By reputation, he embodied everything wrong with conservatives today: highly partisan, uncompromising, the last person you’d want your mother-in-law to marry. Actually, he’s a nice guy. He and I have become friends. We’ve had drinks together, even though he’s not exactly a barrel of laughs in a bar. He doesn’t drink. He always orders iced tea. Nothing worse than a sober conservative. As I discovered hanging out with Tucker Carlson, conservatives are much more fun when they’re having a few drinks. So when Bob Barr teams up with the ACLU against something—and when the NRA joins People for the American Way against the same—you know it’s gotta be pretty goddamned bad. It is. It’s George Bush’s—and John Ashcroft’s— USA Patriot Act.
Giving Patriotism a Bad Name The USA Patriot Act. Clever name, isn’t it? But it’s more than just a name. It’s an acronym for the “Uniting and Strengthening America by Providing Appropriate Tools Required to Intercept and Obstruct Terrorism Act of 2001.” Whew! Some Justice Department functionary must have worked his ass off to come up with that one. George Orwell would be proud. But actually, the act has little to do with obstructing terrorism and a lot to do with giving the government more police powers to use against law-abiding citizens—all in the name of fighting terror.
THE PATRIOT ACT
127
From its title, you would think the Patriot Act was the result of a long congressional investigation into what went wrong on September 11, how terrorists managed to outwit the FBI and the CIA and what new police powers were needed to prevent such terrorist acts to happen again. Wrong. There was no such congressional investigation until two years later. Nor was there any internal administration investigation. Instead, just three days after September 11, John Ashcroft cleaned off the Justice Department shelves and marched up to Congress with a 342-page grab bag of expanded police powers the FBI had wanted for a long time—and were just waiting for the right opportunity to seize. Shamelessly exploiting the national unity we all felt after being attacked on 9/11, and playing on the fear that still paralyzed all Americans, even members of Congress, Ashcroft lumped the whole list of expanded powers together as the Patriot Act, insisted these new measures were necessary to fight the war on terror—and demanded that Congress enact the sweeping new legislation within three days. But it was obvious from the beginning that these expanded police powers had nothing to do with September 11. Indeed, the more we learned about what government bureaucrats knew prior to September 11—and what countermeasures were not taken—the clearer it became that terrorists were able to attack this country not because federal agencies lacked sufficient police powers, but because they failed to use the powers they had. For example, we learned that German intelligence officials gave American investigators the first name and telephone number of one of the September 11 hijackers two and a half years before the attacks on New York and Washington, but the United States failed to pursue the lead. U.S. officials never contacted German authorities about the tip until after September 11. We learned that the CIA had tracked two of the 9/11 hijackers from a terrorist summit meeting in Malaysia all the
128
REASON #5
way back to San Diego, where they rented an apartment in their own names and were even listed in the phone directory. The CIA soon dropped their trail, and never notified the FBI of the terrorists’ newly established sleeper cell inside this country. We learned that an FBI agent in Phoenix had discovered a handful of Middle Easterners taking flying lessons in schools around the country and suggested that the bureau launch a national investigation. But headquarters did nothing. We were also told about another agent in Minneapolis who requested permission to search e-mails of a French Moroccan named Zacarias Moussouai, who only wanted to learn how to steer a plane, not how to take off or land. Headquarters refused. We learned that thirteen of the nineteen September 11 hijackers had entered this country legally, having been granted visas by the INS. That the INS had no information on the remaining six. That three of the thirteen, including ringleader Mohammed Atta, were still in the country, even though their visas had expired. That Atta, with his expired visa, drove from Boston to Canada on September 10, then flew from Canada back to Boston the next morning to board and commandeer the ill-fated American Airlines Flight 11—all without arousing the suspicions of the INS. And—here’s the icing on the cake—that the INS mailed renewed student visas to Mohammed Atta and fellow hijacker Marwan al-Shehhi—six months after September 11. As first reported by David Corn in his book The Lies of George W. Bush, we learned that a briefing prepared for senior government officials at the beginning of July 2001 contained the following language: “Based on a review of all-source reporting over the last five months, we believe that Usama bin Laden will launch a significant terrorist attack against U.S. and/or Israeli interests in the coming weeks. The attack will be spectacular and designed to inflict mass casualties against U.S. facilities or interests. Attack preparations have been made. Attack will occur with little or no warning.”
THE PATRIOT ACT
129
Who says we had no advance warning about September 11? Most shocking of all, we learned that during his daily intelligence briefing on the morning of August 6, 2001, while vacationing on his ranch in Crawford, Texas, President Bush was informed that Osama bin Laden and his team of Muslim extremists were studying ways to hijack airliners and use them to strike targets inside the United States. And what did the leader of the free world do? He went fishing! And we learned from his testimony before the 9/11 Commission that counterterrorism czar Richard Clarke repeatedly tried to persuade National Security Advisor Condoleezza Rice and President Bush to respond to heightened terrorist threats during the summer of 2001—and they did nothing. Having reviewed all the warnings received and ignored, former New Jersey Governor Thomas Kean, chairman of the 9/11 Commission, told CBS News in December 2003 that the terrorist acts of September 11 could and should have been prevented. “There are people that, if I was doing the job, would certainly not be in the position they were in at that time because they failed,” Kean said. “They simply failed.” Clearly, the CIA, the FBI, the INS and the president had all the powers they needed before 9/11. They just didn’t use them. They were asleep at the switch. Nor was there any evidence that, had the new police powers demanded by Ashcroft been in place earlier, the attacks on the Pentagon and World Trade Center could have been prevented. There was simply no connection between what happened on September 11 and what John Ashcroft was asking for. There was no need for the Patriot Act. Bob Barr, at least, saw what Ashcroft was up to and had the guts to say so. “You are just trying to use September 11 to get extraordinary new police powers through Congress that you could never get otherwise,” Barr told Ashcroft bluntly. In response, the attorney
130
REASON #5
general accused members of Congress who did not agree with his proposal of “giving ammunition to the enemy.” And he warned that failure to act immediately would make the United States vulnerable to another imminent terrorist attack. It worked. Afraid of being painted as sympathetic to terrorists, members of Congress overwhelmingly passed the Patriot Act. With only four hours of debate they approved a 342-page bill most of them had never even taken the time to read—and turned this country into as close to a police state as we’ve ever been. In the Senate, the vote was 98 to 1. Only Wisconsin Democrat Russ Feingold dared vote against it, incurring the wrath of both the White House and fellow Democrats. In his powerful book Dude, Where’s My Country? filmmaker Michael Moore quotes Senator Feingold’s eloquent words on the Senate floor. They deserve a second reading: There have been periods in our nation’s history when civil liberties have taken a backseat to what appeared at the same time to be the legitimate exigencies of war. Our national consciousness still bears the stain and the sears of those events. The Alien and Sedition Acts, the suspension of habeas corpus during the Civil War, the internment of Japanese-Americans, German-Americans and ItalianAmericans during World War II, the blacklisting of supposed communist sympathizers during the McCarthy era, and the surveillance and harassment of antiwar protestors, including Dr. Martin Luther King Jr., during the Vietnam War. We must not allow these pieces of our past to become prologue. Ninety-eight Senators were wrong and Senator Feingold was right. He’s the only one who understood what was really going on. And, besides, he’s got a brass pair of huevos. Too bad he didn’t run for president.
THE PATRIOT ACT
131
George Bush and John Ashcroft insist that the Patriot Act is only designed to help catch more terrorists. Not true. Sure, the FBI, CIA, INS and other agencies have sweeping, new powers to use against terrorists and criminals. But, as we shall see, those same new powers can also easily, be turned against law-abiding citizens. There is no distinction in the law.
Go Get Those Terrorists! After 9/11, George Bush acted like a tinhorn dictator. Come to think of it, he talked like one, too. “Bring him back dead or alive!” Thank you, Sheriff George. Nonetheless, at the risk of sounding like George Bush, I still think I speak for all Americans when I say: Whatever it takes to track down terrorists who threaten the lives of Americans—Go get ’em! For those who kill innocent men, women and children . . . For those who blow themselves and others up, just to make a political point . . . For those who attacked us on September 11, and for all those who aided and abetted them . . . It’s War! We’ll give law enforcement agencies whatever powers they need to bring the guilty to justice. Ah, but’s that the key word: GUILTY. And that’s the problem. George Bush and John Ashcroft weren’t satisfied with the guilty. They took a page right out of the KGB. They abused the new powers given them by Congress not only to go after the guilty, but to round up, harass and punish the innocent—throwing all established rules of justice out the window and violating every standard of fair play this country stands for.
132
REASON #5
The Great Roundup In the weeks immediately following September 11, the Justice Department rounded up over one thousand young men of Middle Eastern origin whom they “suspected” of possible links to the al Qaeda terrorist network. These young men were charged with no crimes, were provided no lawyer and were given no public hearing—but were detained indefinitely. Not only that, the Justice Department refused to tell their families where they were being held. And, to this day, J. Edgar Ashcroft has released the names of only those twenty-nine individuals against whom the department brought criminal charges. Of course, Bush and Ashcroft could never get away with treating American citizens like that. Until recently, they couldn’t get away with treating visitors like that, either. But, in this case, Bush tried to justify such extraordinary, and perhaps unconstitutional, police action as an unfortunate, but necessary, part of the war on terror. Ironically, there was only one part of the detainees’ civil liberties that Ashcroft refused to violate: their right to bear arms. When the FBI started checking instant background files to determine if any of them had recently bought a firearm, Ashcroft shut them down. That information, he decreed, could only be used at the time of purchase of a gun. Yes, that’s right. Not even the war on terror could justify offending the National Rifle Association. Ashcroft locked up hundreds of innocent men on the pretext that they were terrorists—but forbid his agents from checking gun records to see which ones might have actually been planning violence. Eventually, some detainees were released because not even Ashcroft could find anything on them. Over two hundred others were hauled before top secret, closed-door immigration hearings, found guilty of nothing more serious than an expired
THE PATRIOT ACT
133
visa or a jaywalking ticket—and expelled from the country. Charges were filed against only twenty-nine. Many others are still behind bars. But here’s the kicker. Despite Bush’s justifying everything Ashcroft did in the name of “the war on terror,” out of over one thousand young Muslims detained after 9/11, only one case has gone to trial—with decidedly mixed results. In Detroit, four individuals were accused of conspiracy to commit terrorism. Two of them were acquitted of all charges. Two others were initially found guilty, but their convictions are now under review because federal prosecutors failed to reveal that one of their witnesses had lied on the stand. The judge also blasted Attorney General John Ashcroft for violating the trial’s gag order. Ashcroft’s great roundup, in other words, was nothing but one giant fishing expedition. In terms of the war on terror, the whole operation was a bust. But J. Edgar Ashcroft did not let one colossal failure stop him. Those students and workers who were not caught in the big roundup were nabbed in the next phase of the Justice Department’s reign of terror.
The Middle Eastern Dragnet Once again following the KGB playbook, Ashcroft next sent out the word: He or his agents wanted to have a private interview with every foreign student who was in the United States legally. He invited all of them to report to the nearest FBI office for “questioning.” Actually, he didn’t invite all of them in. He invited male students only. He didn’t invite all foreign students, either. He only invited those from Middle Eastern countries—five thousand of them. Actually, he didn’t invite all Middle Eastern natives,
134
REASON #5
either. Students from Saudi Arabia were exempted. That’s right. Even though fifteen of the nineteen September 11 terrorists were from the royal kingdom, students from Saudi Arabia were not required to report to the FBI.
Note: Despite its known terrorist ties and its history as a staging ground for Osama bin Laden, this was the second time Saudi Arabia received special treatment by the Bush administration post 9/11. The first was for members of bin Laden’s own family. In the days immediately after September 11, when all commercial flights were still grounded, only one plane was in the air. With special permission from the White House, a charter jet flew around the country, gathering up all twentyfour members of Osama bin Laden’s extended family in the United States and whisking them back to Saudi Arabia. Did any of Osama’s uncles, brothers, nephews or cousins have any information on his whereabouts? When was the last time they had seen or talked to him? Had they given him any financial help? We’ll never know. They were spirited out of the country without being questioned by the FBI—simply because Saudi Ambassador Prince Bandar vouched for their character.
Back to the dragnet. Stop and think about what an outrageous abuse of authority this was. These young men were in the United States legally. They had committed no crime. They were not accused of committing any crime. Yet they were forced to surrender to federal authorities for questioning about possible ties to terrorism. If they did not “volunteer” for interrogation, they were arrested. If, while being examined for links to terrorists, they were found to have any problems with immigration documents, they were immediately deported.
THE PATRIOT ACT
135
The KGB could not have done it any better. But this is not the old Soviet Union. This is the United States, where innocent people are not rounded up and given the third degree without first doing something wrong. Not even people from other countries. At least, they never were until George Bush took office. Of course, he would never admit to any bias. In fact, at the very time J. Edgar Ashcroft was ordering every male citizen from certain Middle Eastern countries to report to the FBI, President Bush was piously insisting that the war on terror was not a war on Islam, that we did not believe all Muslims were terrorists—and that the Justice Department would never practice racial profiling. But his actions belied his words. What’s the one thing all those rounded up had in common? They were all Muslims. And they were all olive-skinned. No racial profiling? As many pointed out, after Timothy McVeigh blew up the Alfred Murrah building in Oklahoma City, we didn’t round up all blond, blue-eyed, Christian Caucasians and investigate them for potential links to his terrorist ring. So why did we round up all Muslims after 9/11? Because, no matter what they said in public, Bush and Ashcroft, in fact, did believe all Muslims were terrorists, or at least potential terrorists, and they treated them as such. Before he goes back to Crawford, Texas, maybe George Bush will explain to all of us why he dragged into FBI offices five thousand students—most of whom had never heard of, let alone met, Osama bin Laden—while U.S. authorities actually helped bin Laden’s own family members flee the country with no questions asked. I’m curious. Aren’t you? Again, as part of the war on terror, the Middle Eastern Roundup was a big bust. Not one of the five thousand questioned was found to have any link with al Qaeda. But as outrageous and un-American as their treatment was,
136
REASON #5
it was nothing compared to the reception awaiting alleged prisoners of war from Afghanistan.
Gulag Gitmo President John F. Kennedy imposed a trade embargo on Cuba in 1963 because, he argued, the island nation was a serious danger to our national security. After all, at Fidel Castro’s invitation, the Soviet Union had installed nuclear missiles on Cuba aimed at the United States. Kennedy had every reason to respond to a serious threat to our national security. Today, even though Cuba long ago ceased to be a threat to the United States, the embargo remains in place—but for a different reason. President Bush now insists we will never trade with Cuba as long as Castro is in power because of his political persecutions and abysmal human rights record. What hypocrisy. At the southern tip of Cuba, on the U.S. Navy Base at Guantanamo Bay, the United States treats political prisoners in ways that not even Fidel Castro would approve of—and that would never be allowed or tolerated on U.S. soil. Locked up at Guantanamo are 660 Muslims from fortyfour countries who were arrested in Afghanistan shortly after the war, bound, gagged, hooded and flown halfway around the world to be kept in solitary confinement, with no access to a lawyer or family, for over two years now. They have been given no trial or hearing at which they might prove their innocence. The Defense Department says it plans to keep them there for many years, perhaps indefinitely. It is, writes conservative legal commentator Stuart Taylor in The National Journal, “a betrayal of what America stands for.” Lord Steyn, a judge of England’s highest court, said of the situation at Guantanamo Bay: “As a lawyer brought up to admire the ideals of American democracy and justice, I would
THE PATRIOT ACT
137
have to say that I regard this as a monstrous failure of justice.” U.S. officials privately acknowledge that at least a third of the Guantanamo inmates, including three teenagers released in Spring 2004, are completely innocent. They include farmers, taxi drivers, cobblers and laborers. Many of them are there simply because they were identified by Afghans and Pakistanis eager to get the generous bounty the American military was tossing around for anybody connected to al Qaeda. What did they care if they fingered an innocent person? They got the money. What does Bush care if he’s locked up innocent people? He doesn’t need a trial. He knows they’re all guilty. “The only thing I know for certain is that these are bad people,” he told reporters. Holding prisoners of war with no charges and no chance to clear their name is a clear violation of Article V of the Geneva Convention, to which the United States is a signed member. So how do Bush and Ashcroft get away with it? Here’s how: They refuse to call the detainees prisoners of war. They call them “enemy combatants” instead. And they insist that during wartime the commander in chief has exclusive authority over enemy combatants. Not even the courts, they claim, have any jurisdiction over the actions of a commander in chief in wartime. And since, unlike conventional wars, the “war on terror” will last forever, those so-designated enemy combatants can be held forever. With George Bush’s blessing, this is justice, Ashcroft-style. They label you an “enemy combatant” and anything goes: no formal charges necessary. No lawyer. No trial. You simply disappear. Bush and Ashcroft used the same modus operandi to justify detaining two American citizens, Jose Padilla and Yasser Esam Hamdi. Padilla was arrested in Chicago on suspicion of bringing a “dirty bomb” into the country. No explosives were found, but he was labeled an “enemy combatant” and, as such,
138
REASON #5
has been held in military prison in Charleston, South Carolina, for over two years—even though no charges have been filed. Hamdi, arrested in Afghanistan while fighting for the Taliban, was transferred from Guantanamo Bay to the military prison at Norfolk Air Station. He’s also been held for over two years, even though the Justice Department says it has no immediate plans to file charges against him. Does the “war on terror” empower the president to brand people, even American citizens, as “enemy combatants” and thereby ignore all standards of due process? The Bush administration has no doubt. But two federal courts have found that they are breaking the law. The Federal Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit, in New York, ruled that Ashcroft and Bush were violating Jose Padilla’s civil rights by holding him indefinitely without trial. The Ninth Circuit, in California, ruled that it was unconstitutional for the administration to hold 660 foreigners at Guantanamo Bay without giving them access to legal representation and judicial review. Those two cases will soon be before the U.S. Supreme Court—as well as an appeal by Yasser Hamdi to a decision by the Fourth Circuit, in Richmond, Virginia, that he is, in fact, a legitimate “enemy combatant,” because he was arrested on foreign soil. These are important test cases, because they speak to the heart of what dictatorial powers a president can grab—and to what extent our basic freedoms are secure—even during wartime. As summed up in the Ninth Circuit’s ruling, the issue is whether or not “the Executive Branch possesses the unchecked authority to imprison indefinitely any persons, foreign citizens included . . . without permitting prisoners recourse of any kind to any judicial forum.” Bush’s violation of due process and denial of basic rights to detainees in the United States and at Guantanamo is the kind
THE PATRIOT ACT
139
of political tyranny we used to condemn when practiced by dictators like Chile’s General Augusto Pinochet. Even the conservative magazine The Economist called it a policy “unworthy of a nation which has cherished the rule of law from its very birth.” But, of course, all the guys Bush and Ashcroft are persecuting, both here and in Cuba, are foreigners, or foreign-born. And, besides, they’re all Muslims. They would never try the same tactics against American citizens. Right? Wrong! They already are.
John Ashcroft Wants to Know What You’re Reading I remember the first time I read George Orwell’s classic novel 1984: a frightening portrayal of life under a totalitarian dictatorship, where citizens have no right of privacy and Big Brother is free to hear, see and poke his nose into everything people do. You probably had the same reaction. Thank God, I thought, I live in a country where that could never happen. Little did we know: Orwell was prophesying what America would be like under George W. Bush and his Orwellian Patriot Act. As we’ve seen, Bush and Ashcroft are applying the Patriot Act in unprecedented, and perhaps unconstitutional, ways to go after those suspected of having ties to terrorism. That’s bad enough. What’s worse, the Patriot Act gives them the same extraordinary powers to go after us law-abiding citizens. Remember the Fourth Amendment? The right of privacy? We don’t have any left. The Patriot Act took it away. Without cause, without our doing anything wrong, the federal government now has the authority to snoop into every aspect of our daily lives, starting with our:
140
• • • • •
REASON #5
Bank records School records E-mail Online transactions Credit card accounts
The FBI can also seize and investigate our medical records— which is why we now have to sign a privacy consent form every time we visit the doctor. They can also go into the local library and demand to see what books we’ve checked out, turning every librarian into a snitch. And, under the infamous “sneak and peek” provision of the Patriot Act, the FBI can even search our homes or offices and listen in on our phone calls— without getting a search warrant first. Ironically, one of the first to complain about the Patriot Act was Bush supporter Rush Limbaugh. After admitting he was a drug addict and checking himself into a detox center, Limbaugh groused that police were looking into his medical and banking records to see if he had broken the law in order to feed his illegal drug habit. It was too late for Rush’s whining. He had already helped give away the store, by enthusiastically backing Bush’s call for the Patriot Act. But, this time, Rush was right. When the government declares open season on our banking, credit card, email and medical records, it’s enough to make you ask: What country are we living in? Whatever happened to the good old U.S. of A.? Even one of the authors of the Patriot Act now says it represents Big Brother at his worst. In November 2003, former Justice Department official Viet Dinh told the Los Angeles Times that the act could, and soon would, be used to deny American citizens due process of law under the Constitution. Of course, Bush administration officials insist federal agents would never use their expanded powers to intrude into the lives
THE PATRIOT ACT
141
of law-abiding citizens. They forget that the FBI once planted tape recorders under Martin Luther King’s hotel room bed. And that Republican president Richard Nixon ordered the FBI to raid the office of Daniel Ellsberg’s psychiatrist. The expanded police powers of the Patriot Act are so intrusive and so unpatriotic, over 150 cities and counties, including Philadelphia, have refused to enforce or comply with them. The National League of Cities passed a resolution asking Congress to repeal parts of the act. And anti–Patriot Act resolutions were also passed by the states of Hawaii, Vermont and Alaska, whose conservative Congressman Don Young calls the legislation the “worst act we ever passed.” His comments were echoed by another prominent conservative, tax reform crusader Grover Norquist. Host of a weekly gathering of conservatives to plot legislative and political strategy, Norquist warned his fellow-travelers against rushing to support Ashcroft’s power grab: “Someday Hillary Clinton’s going to be attorney general, and I hope conservatives keep that in mind.” The Patriot Act is such a gross violation of privacy, it has inspired many jokes by stand-up comics. My favorite is about the day John Ashcroft visited a Washington, D.C., elementary school. After the attorney general offered his standard pitch on the war on terror, little Johnny raised his hand: “I have three questions. Where is Osama bin Laden? Where is Saddam Hussein? And isn’t the Patriot Act a big infringement of our civil liberties?” Before Ashcroft could respond, the bell for recess rang and all the students made a dash for the school yard. When they returned, little Virginia raised her hand: “Mr. Attorney General, I have five questions. Where is Osama bin Laden? Where is Saddam Hussein? Isn’t the Patriot
142
REASON #5
Act a big infringement of our civil liberties? Why did the recess bell ring twenty minutes early today? And— where’s Johnny?” The Patriot Act will eventually be subject to litigation. It will be up to the courts to decide whether any president can, as George Bush has done, scale back individual rights during wartime without violating the Constitution. But the president already has at least one vote on the Supreme Court. In March 2003, Justice Antonin Scalia assured an audience at John Carroll University in suburban Cleveland that he saw no constitutional problem in the government’s scaling back individual rights during wartime. “The Constitution just sets minimums,” Scalia declared. “Most of the rights that you enjoy go way beyond what the Constitution requires.” For him, and George Bush, the war on terror means we can kiss the Bill of Rights good-bye.
The Pentagon Wages War—on Privacy Now, all along, I know what you’ve been thinking: Where’s John Ashcroft going to store all this information he’s collecting on us Americans? There’s not enough room at the Justice Department. You’re right. There’s not enough room at the Justice Department. So he’s turning it all over to Secretary of Defense Donald Rumsfeld to store at the Pentagon. It is, after all, the world’s largest office building. Bigger than a Super Wal-Mart. Rummy wasn’t satisfied with freeing the Iraqi people from Saddam Hussein. With George Bush’s blessing, he also insisted on helping free the American people—from our right of privacy. His contribution to the war on terror is called the “Total Information Awareness Project,” or TIA. Its goal is to collect
THE PATRIOT ACT
143
as much information as possible on 300 million Americans, to store it in a giant Pentagon “supercomputer” and then to sort through it to see if anything points to a possible connection to terrorism. It is what Oregon Senator Ron Wyden called “the most far-reaching snooping program ever proposed against law-abiding Americans.” Yet spineless members of Congress—once again afraid of appearing weak-kneed in the war on terror—gave Rumsfeld $200 million for the project. Adding insult to injury, Rumsfeld then put the TIA under the command of John Poindexter. Yes, that John Poindexter, the same one who convinced President Reagan to sell arms secretly to Iran and use the profits, illegally, to fund the contras in Nicaragua. A grand scheme for which he was convicted of five felonies and only escaped prison because Congress granted him immunity. Would George Bush please explain: Why did he invite such a disgraced American to be part of his administration? Didn’t he promise to “clean up” government, not soil it with yesterday’s criminals? Poindexter quit his Pentagon post in August 2003 after it was revealed that his office had also organized a “futures market” where players could bet on when and where the next terrorist attack would occur. But his Super Snooper was already in operation. And here’s what it means for you and me: No Privacy Left. From now on, the Pentagon will have a dossier on each and every one of us. With one click of the mouse, Big Brother will know: • Every commercial transaction we make: magazine subscriptions, airline tickets, credit card purchases, concerts attended, bank records, telephone calls, plus videotape from surveillance cameras at shopping malls or sporting events.
144
REASON #5
• Every government contact we have: tax records, driver’s license, passport application, bridge tolls paid, judicial and divorce records, speeding tickets, plus every book we take out of the library. • Every aspect of our personal lives: medical records, prescriptions we purchase, grades we receive in school, websites we visit, plus e-mails we send and receive. Okay, maybe I’m old-fashioned about this, but here’s what I think. If there’s a good reason to suspect someone of terrorism, then I say: Go ahead and collect every bit of information you can about the sucker. But for you and me, who wouldn’t know a terrorist if we saw one sipping coffee at Starbucks, I say: Keep your cotton-pickin’ fingers, eyes, ears and nose out of my personal life. Big Brother has no right to keep a dossier on me or any one of my fellow law-abiding Americans. If I wanted to live in a country where the government keeps a file on everybody, I’d move to Saudi Arabia.
The Terrorists Are Winning What’s astounding is how easily George Bush could get away with these assaults on our civil liberties, both at the Justice Department and at the Pentagon. He simply said they were necessary tools in the war on terror. And most Americans went along with it. But you and I now know better. And that, my friends, is a key reason why George Bush doesn’t deserve a second term: his bullshit, dangerous and un-American argument that fighting terrorism requires us to sacrifice the basic freedoms that make us so proud to be Americans. We don’t buy it. As columnist Nat Hentoff wrote in The Village Voice on February 27, 2004: “It should take far more than the mon-
THE PATRIOT ACT
145
strous brutality of a handful of terrorists to drive us to abandon our core constitutional values.” Freedom of speech. Freedom of assembly. Freedom to express our disagreement with official government policy. The right of privacy. Those cherished freedoms define us as Americans. They were handed down to us by our Founding Fathers and secured by the brave warriors of the American Revolution. They have been defended ever since by millions of courageous men and women in uniform, from World War I to the war in Iraq. They are the reason people around the globe envy us and want to come here to live. We must never let the federal government chip away at our basic constitutional freedoms—not even when nineteen crazed terrorists strike on U.S. soil and kill three thousand. I know, when it comes to Bush’s wholesale invasions of our privacy, some brain-dead conservative commentators argue: “What are you worried about? If you’ve done nothing wrong, you have nothing to hide.” Too bad those jerks don’t listen to Bob Barr. They don’t deserve the label “conservative.” When it comes to civil liberties, the test is not: Why aren’t we willing to surrender part of our freedoms to the central government? The test is: What right, or what need, does the central government have to take them away from us? Building secret dossiers on you and me is not going to help catch one terrorist. But it does mean we are not as free today as we used to be. General Wesley Clark warned of that very danger when Ashcroft proposed round two of the Patriot Act: “One of the risks you have in this operation is that you’re giving up some of the essentials of what it is in America to have justice, liberty, and the rule of law. I think you’ve got to be very, very careful when you abridge those rights to prosecute the war on terrorists.” As Americans, we do not have to choose between fighting terrorists and preserving freedom. That is a false dichotomy.
146
REASON #5
We can and we must fight terrorism and remain free at the same time. For once we sacrifice our basic liberties, the terrorists win. Looking at the Patriot Act and the Pentagon’s super computer, it’s clear that the terrorists are already winning. For naming John Ashcroft attorney general . . . for his direct assault on our American freedoms . . . for throwing the Constitution out the window . . . GEORGE BUSH MUST GO!
REASON # SIX
Crony Capitalism: He Sold America Out to Special Interests “We ought to make the pie higher.” George W. Bush February 15, 2000
One thing you can say for sure about George W. Bush: He remembers his friends. And he rewards them. Big time, as Dick Cheney might add. In fact, if you look carefully at the Bush White House, you might see a special banner hanging over the front door: “Quid Pro Quo.” Which is Latin for “Screw the People, Bless the Special Interests.” Sometimes paraphrased as: “You scratched my back, so now I’ll scratch yours.” But don’t wait for your back to be scratched. The “you” George Bush is referring to on his banner is not you and your neighbors. It’s not average Americans trying to pay their bills at the end of the month. He’s only referring to those who wrote big checks to get Bush and Cheney in the White House. In every area, from health care to environmental protection to jobs in the administration, the story of the first three years of President Bush’s administration is one of “Crony Capitalism.” Special favors done for special interests. During the 2000 campaign, Kayne Robinson, second-in-
148
REASON #6
command at the National Rifle Association, raised a few eyebrows when he told NRA members why it was so important to work to elect George Bush. If Bush wins, he bragged, we not only won’t have to fight bad gun control legislation anymore, we’ll be inside the Oval Office, writing the kind of gun legislation we want. And that’s the way it’s been for corporate America under George Bush. From department to department, it’s the same pattern of activity: Executives from coal companies, utilities, pharmaceutical companies, the cattle industry, Wall Street, the NRA and other special interest groups are invited in. First they report on how much money they gave to Republicans in the last election. Then they tell the administration what they want. And then George Bush delivers. Quid pro quo. Bush’s record of crony capitalism must be a major issue in the 2004 campaign. “We face a growing threat to our liberty and justice in America today,” Howard Dean wrote in his campaign pamphlet Common Sense for a New Century. “Thomas Jefferson and James Madison spoke of the fear that economic power would one day seize political power. That fear is now being realized. Under the Bush Administration, pharmaceutical companies draft our Medicare laws. Oil executives sit in the Vice President’s office and write energy bills.” Actually, it’s even worse than that. Because the first thing that George Bush did, across the board, was fill his administration with people from corporate America to service corporate America—starting with his vice president, Halliburton’s own Dick Cheney, and his chief of staff, the automobile manufacturers’ own Andrew Card. That way, when business representatives came knocking, they were guaranteed a friendly reception. Their own cronies opened the door. How convenient. As we will see in more detail below, mining companies show up at the Department of Interior to push for digging mines on protected federal lands and they’re
CRONY CAPITALISM
149
greeted by—their former lobbyist. Food processors gather at the Department of Agriculture to protest tougher meat inspections and they get the red carpet treatment from—their former chief lobbyist. Auto manufacturers show up at the White House to argue against higher fuel efficiency standards and their host is—you guessed it!—Andy Card. Maybe I’m old-fashioned, but it does seem to me that naming lobbyists to head government agencies that regulate the very industries they once lobbied for is a huge conflict of interest. Didn’t George Bush promise to “restore honor and dignity” to the White House? Apparently, ethical conflicts don’t count. But George Bush wasn’t taking any chances. Before he invited the foxes into the hen house, he put a fox in charge of every hen house. It is no longer government of the people, by the people and for the people. The people have no access and no voice in George Bush’s America. Today it is government of special interests, by special interests and for special interests. Given Bush’s background, it’s not surprising. Big business cronies of his daddy’s set him up as an oilman, then bailed him out of every one of his failed enterprises. Then they planted him up in the baseball business, where he and his corporate pals conned the public into building them a new stadium—on which Bush then cashed in. As governor of Texas, Bush routinely sided with oil, gas and electric utilities. As a result, when he left office, Texas was rated number one among the states— number one in air and water pollution, that is. Bush’s Texas generated more pollution than any other state or any province of Canada. As Molly Ivins points out, the man is “congenitally incapable of checking the excesses of capitalism.” He thinks big business can do no wrong. As he often tells audiences of business leaders, he thinks government’s job is simply “to get out of the way and let business and entrepreneurs do their work.”
150
REASON #6
Never would it occur to George Bush that government has a much more important job: To step in and protect the public when corporations do not act in the public interest. The sad reality is that our government will no longer be able to protect us as well, now that Bush has rewarded his corporate contributors by gutting so many of the tough regulations already in place. Fortunately, there are organizations like the Center for Public Integrity, Texans for Public Justice and the Center for Responsive Politics which keep score of government favors for campaign cash. Check out their websites: www.publicintegrity.org, www.whitehouseforsale.org and www.crp.org. All three organizations are religiously nonpartisan. They know that, for the most part, the people who write campaign checks do so only because they want something in return. And they acknowledge that politicians of both parties have always rewarded campaign contributors with big favors. But never before, they report, have they seen so much money given to a presidential candidate—or so many government goodies blatantly and shamelessly handed out in return.
The Bush administration is like one huge, ongoing Sotheby’s auction to which you and I are not invited. Only those who’ve already written a check for at least $100,000 are allowed in the room. George Bush himself is at the podium. And one by one, America’s assets are put on the auction block—“Going, going, gone!”—until there’s nothing left. George Bush has systematically sold America out to the highest bidder. With the help of the Center for Public Integrity and Texans for Public Justice, let’s take a look at George Bush’s selling of America: who gave how much and what they got in return.
CRONY CAPITALISM
151
JOBS FOR SALE Before he could rain favors on special interests, George Bush first had to make sure he had the proper rainmakers in place. To fill top government jobs, he turned to three groups of supporters: lawyers who saved his ass in Florida; major campaign fundraisers; and corporate contributors. They are the people who make up the Bush administration.
The Big Florida “Thank You” Even before he could get around to rewarding his campaign contributors, George Bush had another important group to take care of: the phalanx of conservative lawyers who worked overtime in Florida to help him steal the election from Al Gore. Without their legal trickery, George Bush would never have made it to the White House. So naturally he paid them back with the first, and some of the best, jobs in his administration. Four giant law firms did most of the dirty work for Bush in Florida. Here’s how George Bush paid them back with highprofile jobs.
Florida Payback 1. Gibson, Dunn & Crutcher: Ted Olson, Solicitor General of the United States Eugene Scalia, son of Justice Antonin Scalia, Solicitor for the Department of Labor Robert Bonnor, U.S. Customs Commissioner M. Sean Royal, Deputy Director of the Federal Trade Commission’s Bureau of Competition Miguel Estrada, failed nominee to the federal D.C. Court of Appeals
152
REASON #6
2. White & Case: Tim Flanigan, Deputy White House Counsel Marcos