BRITISH NARRATIVES OF EXPLORATION: CASE STUDIES OF THE SELF AND OTHER
Empires in Perspective
Series Editors:
Adviso...
194 downloads
1357 Views
1MB Size
Report
This content was uploaded by our users and we assume good faith they have the permission to share this book. If you own the copyright to this book and it is wrongfully on our website, we offer a simple DMCA procedure to remove your content from our site. Start by pressing the button below!
Report copyright / DMCA form
BRITISH NARRATIVES OF EXPLORATION: CASE STUDIES OF THE SELF AND OTHER
Empires in Perspective
Series Editors:
Advisory Editor:
Tony Ballantyne Duncan Bell Francisco Bethencourt Caroline Elkins Durba Ghosh Masaie Matsumura
Titles in this Series 1 Between Empire and Revolution: A Life of Sidney Bunting, 1873–1936 Allison Drew 2 A Wider Patriotism: Alfred Milner and the British Empire J. Lee Thompson 3 Missionary Education and Empire in Late Colonial India, 1860–1920 Hayden J. A. Bellenoit 4 Transoceanic Radical, William Duane: National Identity and Empire, 1760–1835 Nigel Little 5 Natural Science and the Origins of the British Empire Sarah Irving 6 Empire of Political Thought: Indigenous Australians and the Language of Colonial Government Bruce Buchan 7 The English Empire in America, 1602–1658: Beyond Jamestown L. H. Roper 8 India in the French Imagination: Peripheral Voices, 1754–1815 Kate Marsh
Forthcoming Titles Law and Imperialism: Criminality and Constitution in Colonial India and Victorian England Preeti Nijhar Slaveholders in Jamaica: Colonial Society and Culture during the Era of Abolition Christer Petley
www.pickeringchatto.com/empires
BRITISH NARRATIVES OF EXPLORATION: CASE STUDIES OF THE SELF AND OTHER
Edited by Frederic Regard
london PICKERING & CHATTO 2009
Published by Pickering & Chatto (Publishers) Limited 21 Bloomsbury Way, London WC1A 2TH 2252 Ridge Road, Brookfield, Vermont 05036-9704, USA www.pickeringchatto.com All rights reserved. No part of this publication may be reproduced, stored in a retrieval system, or transmitted in any form or by any means, electronic, mechanical, photocopying, recording, or otherwise without prior permission of the publisher. © Pickering & Chatto (Publishers) Ltd 2009 © Frederic Regard 2009 British narratives of exploration : case studies on the self and other. – (Empires in perspective) 1. Travelers’ writings, English – History and criticism 2. Geographical discoveries in literature 3. Identity (Psychology) in literature 4. Intercultural communication in literature 5. Other (Philosophy) in literature 6. English prose literature – 17th century – History and criticism 7. English prose literature – 18th century – History and criticism 8. English prose literature – 19th century – History and criticism I. Regard, Frederic 820.9’32’0903 ISBN-13: 9781851966202 e: 9781851965953
∞
This publication is printed on acid-free paper that conforms to the American National Standard for the Permanence of Paper for Printed Library Materials. Typeset by Pickering & Chatto (Publishers) Limited Printed in the UK by the MPG Books Group
CONTENTS
Introduction: Articulating Empire’s Unstable Zones – Frederic Regard I. Fantasy, Wonder and Mimicry: Proto-Ethnography from the Middle Ages to the Renaissance 1 Encountering Africa: Uses of the Other in The Book of John Mandeville (1357) – Kofi Campbell 2 Naming the Other, Claiming the Other in Early Modern Accounts of First Encounters: from Mandeville to John Nicholl (1607) and Richard Jobson (1623) – Ladan Niayesh and Nick Myers 3 False Play and Dumb Show in The World Encompassed by Sir Francis Drake (1628) – Sophie Lemercier-Goddard 4 ‘Waterali’ Goes Native: Describing First Encounters in Sir Walter Ralegh’s The Discovery of Guiana (1596) – Line Cottegnies II. Distance in Question: Translating the Other in the Eighteenth Century 5 Domestication and Recognition of the Other in John Lawson’s A New Voyage to Carolina (1709) – Robert Sayre 6 The (He)art of First Encounter at Tahiti: Samuel Wallis’s Conflicts of Interest (1767) – Sandhya Patel 7 Distance and Proximity in James Cook’s First Voyage around the World (1768–1771) – Anne Dromart 8 Walking in the Contact Zone: Georg Forster and the Peripatetic Mode of Exploration (1768–1777) – Christian Moser 9 The Disorder of Things: Empiricism and the Cartographic Enterprise, or, the Observations of Samuel Hearne (1795) and Alexander Mackenzie (1801) – Cheryl Cundell
1
19
29 39 51
63 71 83 97
107
III. Stereotypes Undermined: Shifting the Self in the Nineteenth Century 10 John Franklin and the Idea of North: Narrative of a Journey to the Shores of the Polar Sea in the Years 1819–1822 – Catherine Lanone 119
11 ‘Cultivating that Mutual Friendship’: Commerce, Diplomacy and Self-Representation in Hugh Clapperton’s Journal of a Second Expedition into the Interior of Africa from the Bight of Benin to Soccatoo (1829) – Anne-Pascale Bruneau 12 Trying to Understand: James Tod among the Rajputs (1829, 1832) – Florence D’Souza 13 ‘Shifting Perspectives: Visual Representation and the Imperial ‘I’ in Anna Jameson’s Winter Studies and Summer Rambles in Canada’ (1838) – Jennifer Scott 14 Charles Darwin in Patagonia: Descriptive Strategies in the Beagle Diary (1831–1836) and The Voyage of the Beagle (1845) – Virginia Richter 15 Fieldwork as Self-Harrowing: Richard Burton’s Cultural Evolution (1851–1856) – Frederic Regard 16 Fictionalizing the Encounter with the Other: Henry Morton Stanley and the African Wilderness (1872–1890) – Nicoletta Brazzelli Notes Works Cited Index
131 141
153
167 179
193 203 227 239
INTRODUCTION: ARTICULATING EMPIRE’S UNSTABLE ZONES Frederic Regard
The idea of this collection first arose in the course of a research seminar I conducted at the École Normale Supérieure, Lyon, France, between the spring of 2003 and that of 2006, a seminar which ENS-Éditions very rapidly chose to publish as a book.1 It then took its final, international form during the conference on ‘Unstable Zones: Self and Other in British Narratives of Exploration’ which I convened at the ENS in March 2007. The carefully selected, heavily revised essays presented here are not focused on ‘travel narratives’ as a literary genre or as emblems of a ‘tourist’ culture, two fields of research which have been substantially dealt with in recent years. Nor do we attempt to define the characteristic features of a genre in relation to other genres – such as the pilgrimage narrative2 – or to employ the historian’s method of examining the great projects of territorial expansion and the effects of a continued relationship with the foreign. This is a book on exploration, and more precisely on exploration narratives written by British explorers on their return from ‘contact zones’, understood here not as predetermined spaces where Self and Other come to meet on fixed grounds, but as ‘social spaces where cultures meet, clash, and grapple with each other’.3 As a consequence, the essays collected in this volume deal mainly with accounts of first encounters, focusing on the pragmatic aspects of communication between Self and Other, from the medieval and Renaissance period to the late nineteenth century, in North or South America, in Asia as well as in Africa, from the South Pacific to the Antarctic; from Mandeville, Drake and Ralegh to Franklin, Stanley and Burton. The main objective is to scrutinize what has hitherto been ignored; namely, the precise moment of mutual discovery experienced in the field, as recorded by the Western observer, the one participant to the scene supposed to have known how to write about this shared experience – a practice traditionally assumed to signal the ‘Great Divide’ between oral and literate cultures, pre-logical and logical systems of thought, pre-capitalist and capitalist economies, non-ethical and ethical social organizations.4 The volume should thus be of particular significance to all those interested in the history of –1–
2
British Narratives of Exploration
travel, piracy and exploration, but also to those interested in anthropology, in the sociology of communication, in the production of knowledge systems, and finally those interested in the issues of national or personal identity in the context of the British Empire(s). Until now, scholarly attention on exploration narratives has been somewhat erratic. Such narratives have been used as a store for collections of ‘adventure narratives’, as in Benedict Allen’s Faber Book of Exploration, or Fleming and Merullo’s The Explorer’s Eye. Symptomatically, those two works offer exploration narratives of the twentieth century, focusing either on interstellar space or on the great marine depths, where there can in fact be no surprise of a first encounter, where technology constitutes an obvious screen between Man and the realm he explores, and where a tradition of writing – journals, logs, diaries, travelogues, ‘personal narratives’, etc. – is lost. Exploration narratives will also often serve as anecdotal supporting evidence for historians5 or geographers.6 And of course it is certainly the case that we are becoming more and more interested in the history of maps, as is attested by a number of books published by the British Library.7 All in all, it seems such works make the issue of ‘representation’ the sole object of their curiosity. Without ever questioning the possibility that there might have existed other procedures of knowledge-production than the process which Michel Foucault called the ‘tableau’ – the Enlightenment ‘table’ as symbol of a reordering of reality performed by penetrating and sage clinical observation – such works take it for granted that the world can indeed not only exhaust itself in visibility and readability, but also divide itself between observer and observed.8 Using Edward Saïd’s work on ‘Orientalism’ as a major theoretical reference point, impressive work has been undertaken to analyse how discourse was employed by the West to ensure its superiority over the rest of the world, the representation of difference conceived in terms of ‘a Western style for dominating, restructuring, and having authority over the Orient’.9 Paradoxically enough, however, it is to be feared that the perspective common to all such approaches has ended up reaffirming the preeminence of one of the most potent myths of the West: the explorer’s status as an avatar of progress, reason and civilization, a myth which in fact seems not to have gathered full momentum before the mid-nineteenth century. To be sure, Stanley’s late nineteenth-century narratives seem to be anxious to construct an ethos – an image of the self projected through discursive practice and personal scenography10 – of the white explorer’s supremacy. But such an ethos seems at variance with the more qualified, sometimes even disturbing, public image of themselves some of his nineteenth-century predecessors – Tod, Clapperton and Burton in his pre-African years – had sought to construct. These men belonged to the first half of the nineteenth century, or to the early Victorian period, when the belief in progress seems to have been tempered with a joy in discovery and a largeness in spirit. It is only as the century moved towards
Introduction
3
centralization and uniformity, that self-images started to rely more and more on practicality and steadiness, and that the humour, eccentricity and sometimes even theatricality of the early Victorians started to be less acceptable than the often arrogant postures of their followers. Of course – and Darwin’s view of life not only as evolution from primitive to civilized state, but also as Godforsaken contextual placing and unpredictable conflict for survival, was no doubt a major source of secret terrors here – one should never overlook the possibility that violent polarization may have been the symptom of a desperate late-nineteenthcentury struggle to maintain coherence, a battle against anxiety, division and self-doubt. Still, we should keep in mind that the protocols of geographical observation and measurement which constitute what we consider to be the traditional tools of the West’s scientific outlook were not in fact fully worked out before the second half of the nineteenth century. Highly popular books such as John Herschel’s Manual of Scientific Enquiry (1849) and Francis Galton’s Art of Travel (1855), alongside with equally popular tracts and lectures such as E. G. Wakefield’s A View of the Art of Colonization (1849) and J. R. Seeley’s Expansion of England (1883), undoubtedly conditioned Western explorers’ perception of otherness, and therefore inevitably their conception of intersubjectivity.11 The traveller was then transformed into a professional explorer by a specific rhetoric, which turned the adventurer into both a statutory national hero and an institutionally recognized scientist, a combination of postures which inevitably predetermined the outcome of any encounter by polarizing positions. This unwilling perpetuation of an after all very recent myth of extreme polarization has had an unforeseen impact on our knowledge of first encounters. Not only is the current work on this topic still predominantly focused on the question of ‘representation’, but more surprisingly, it is still this question which continues to form the basis of the most recent studies emerging from ‘postcolonial’ approaches, or ‘feminist’ ones. Fundamentally, it is always a matter of identifying the secret or implicit ‘motivations’ behind the ‘representations’ elaborated by both the rhetoric of conquest and that of ‘anti-conquest’.12 And in aiming to unearth the secret behind the ‘tableau’, one that is always inevitably linked to colonialist violence even under the guise of innocent natural history, the uncertain event of the encounter itself is forgotten. What we propose to do here, on the contrary, is to articulate the links between the formation of multiple imperial narratives, at different historical moments, and the shifting politics of intersubjectivity with which they intersect, by focusing on the actual moment of this ‘encounter’, a term to be understood henceforth in its Goffmanian sense of an unpredictable ‘social situation’, a moment when individuals find themselves and the others accessible to the naked senses of one another, required to ratify one another as authorized focuses of attention, but without the guarantee – due
4
British Narratives of Exploration
to the unrehearsed nature of the event – that the expected, cultural structuring of conduct will work effectively.13 The focus is thus made to bear on the dialectics of proximity and distance between Self and Other, a central concern of eighteenth-century British explorers, as will be established by studies of Wallis’s, Cook’s and Forster’s logs. If the initial expectations presiding over first encounters may have been constrained by a set of polarities – the colonizer and the colonized looking at each other from the two sides of an unbridgeable gulf, cultural, technological, racial, linguistic and so forth –, and reaffirmed through the production of the explorers’ narratives addressed to a national community at home, our assumption here is that they must also have been challenged while on the terrain, causing each interlocutor to enter into a dialectics of self-images and status hierarchy, and therefore to experience uncertainty and trouble, on both sides, irrespective of time periods. Differentiating between the writings of first-hand eye-witnesses to Indian culture and the armchair writers of colonization, Karen Kupperman has convincingly argued that the earliest encounters between the English and the Indian societies were in fact characterized by ambivalence and complexity.14 Indeed, the uncertainty and contingency experienced by those who participated in the early encounters should induce us to surmise that in context, with all the unpredictability of verbal or non-verbal interaction and communicational exchange, knowledge systems must have been challenged, frames of meaningmaking disrupted, ‘representations’ shattered, postures undermined, positions reversed, and identities transformed. When Spivak writes that ‘empire messes with identity’, she means that empire distorts the identity of the colonized. Perhaps we should contemplate the possibility that the colonizing subject’s identity, too, is distorted in the process of encounter.15 Surely, what took place in firstencounter scenes was less transaction, or translation, than negotiation, a process by which ‘sides’ could no longer be secured: in any genuine process of communicative exchange, very little is in fact left immune, and much may be lost, or gained. What happens in the field when the performance of self-identity does not function properly in the interactional ritual? The book concentrates on such moments, when the differences the ritual of encounter is supposed to establish or re-establish break down; when misrepresentations prevail over intended representations; when the ‘stigmatized’ Other manages to efface his or her ‘virtual identity’ in the eyes of the ‘normal’ self to assert his or her own ‘actual identity’;16 or worse even, when the ‘normal’ Self ’s identity suddenly allows itself to be ‘contaminated’ by the Other’s, engaging into mimicry and more or less furtive impersonations of ‘barbarians’ and ‘savages’ – as is indeed the case, although with varying amplitude, in the accounts brought back by Drake, Ralegh, Cook
Introduction
5
and Burton. Do we have traces of those unstable zones of interaction? Were such encounters recorded, and, most importantly, how? Where, for example, were such scenes staged: on board a navigator’s ship? On a beach? Inside a primitive hut? Along the road? Alongside a boat caught in ice? In the course of a trekking expedition though a jungle? Or, if one comes to think of Anna Jameson and Georg Forster, during ‘rambling’ excursions? How did context affect not only the explorers’ conception of knowledge and self-identity, but also the very nature and structure of their reports? Were dialogues recorded? Using direct or reported speech? Through which procedures of accommodation or domestication – quoting, translating, naming, renaming – was the Other’s speech allowed to be articulated? What were the perspectives adopted? Through whose eyes were shock, wonder, admiration, awe, recorded? How were such experiences dramatized, narrativized and even fictionalized in the explorers’ subsequent accounts? For example, what happens to the myth of the ‘noble savage’ when Hawkesworth processes Cook’s logbook to adapt it to the expectations of a British nationalist audience? What takes place between Wallis’s first log and his second one? When on board the same ship one officer records his experience from the safety of his cabin while another feels free to go ashore and venture into unknown territory, both geographical and social? When one happens to be a woman explorer? A botanist? An artist? A Scotsman, a Welshman, an Irishman? A Catholic? A Protestant? A British exile hired by an American newspaper? And what does it tell us, not only about the varied processes of ‘othering’ the not-Self, but also about self-fashioning? Discovery narratives as anthropology, but also, most importantly, as autobiography: portrayals of a fantasized Other as much as narratives of an ‘imagined’ Self – personal, communal, national.17 It will come as no surprise that after Erving Goffman’s redefinition of encounter as interaction and performance, Johannes Fabian’s indictment of anthropology’s denial of simultaneity – what Fabian calls the anthropologist’s ‘allochronism’18 – became of central importance to the colleagues who attended the Lyon seminar and the ensuing international conference: had Western culture always been so successful in refusing to occupy the same temporal space as its observed object of knowledge? Had the explorer and the explored engaged in face-to-face encounter never managed to live ‘in the same Time’? What use, then, had been indigenous guides, translators and interpreters? We began to perceive the relevance for our purpose of studies examining the perils of the translation of linguistic and cultural ‘alterity’,19 and in fact the perils of any ‘discourse of the other’ – what Certeau calls ‘heterology’.20 But, precisely, had explorers’ reports been necessarily and inevitably ‘heterological’? Our central question became the following: if a social role requires validation by other social participants, did it really never happen that instead of presenting themselves unfavourably and fully cooperating in the expected manner, the non-Westerners refused their inferior
6
British Narratives of Exploration
status and articulated not necessarily violent claims to full-fledged humanity? Clapperton’s anecdote of a pantomime parodying colonial practices, staged by the Africans to entertain their European visitors, should definitely alert us to this possibility. In Certeau’s words, did it never happen, then, that the Other’s ‘inscribable’ body did not fully comply with the heterologist’s conquering written word? That the Other’s reluctant body resisted the cultural patterns of the visitor, and even spoke out? Was the Other always bound to be the dead corpus of the ethnographer? Or did this muted Other’s corpse manage to resist objectification, resurrect from the table, and become a haunting presence, preventing both the explorer and the explored from resting in peace? ‘Who’s there?’, Shakespeare’s Barnardo famously asks before Hamlet’s story even begins to unravel. Who was there, at the exact moment of the first encounter, and even in the immediate aftermath of contact, when Self and Other had to be couched in writing? This is not another book on British imperialism, on its ideological assumptions, its procedures and practices. What we deal with here is the history of the construction of a British identity ‘in context’, which is to say as an intersubjective linguistic event occurring on a specific terrain.21 We examine this uncertain space where Self faces Other, where the two are wrenched from their alloted fixed places and thrown together on a stage to be shared as ego and alter ego. We argue by the same token that this staging is not necessarily based upon the traditional agonistic model of colonial combat or trauma, that foreign travel itself, from the Middle Ages to the late nineteenth century, may have come ‘perilously close to subversiveness’,22 that, even before the eighteenth-century British rejection of the Catholic model of ‘Conquest’ in favour of the more democratic, Protestant model of peaceful transaction and negotiation23 – of which Cook was indeed the emblem, ‘an Orpheus-like hero exemplifying the highest British values of peaceful exploration and enlightened cultural contact’24 – the Renaissance discourse of ‘wonder’ may have demonstrated the contextual relativity of difference.25 What we suggest is that the great ethnologists of the twentieth century, Malinowski, Radcliffe-Brown or Evans-Pritchard, may have had very early timid predecessors, who certainly realized that there was no knowing the Other outside a cultural dialectic, and did not hesitate therefore to transform the monologic, ‘allochronic’ discourse of the Western outsider into a dialogic, polyphonic one. If the Protestant ethics of negotiation effectively prevailed, successful commercial relationships implied that exchange be beneficial to both sides, thus allowing for the possibility not only of a shared ground of mutual understanding, but also of a potentially unpredictable communicational dialectics. Perhaps there was an even deeper specificity to British narratives in that they were all written . . . in English. As Anthony Burgess and Peter Ackroyd have claimed, the English language itself seems to have been an extraordinary vehicle for alterity, rich enough in itself to accommodate otherness, created in such a
Introduction
7
way that it originally presented all the attributes of a ‘melting pot’, on the model of Drake’s ship, precisely: ‘The language itself was a melting pot – not fixed and elegant and controlled by academics, but coarsely rich and ready for any adventures that would make it richer. English was a sort of Golden Hind’.26 Was such linguistic disposition why Ralegh’s tale easily fitted into an ‘indigenous cultural praxis’, recuperating myths of Indian origin and giving over to homophonic language play even in a foreign tongue?27 Should we here perceive the first step towards a linguistic transformation of the British outsider into an insider, the secret of a profound cultural kinship between, say, Ralegh and Burton? As will often appear in the essays collected in this volume, alterity in British exploration narratives is effectively encountered, pragmatically experienced and linguistically tested, so that the representational crisis enacted is also a self-representational crisis. Still, the stage of this crisis was brought to us by narratives, ‘narrativization’ being assumed to be integral to all cognitive procedures.28 The essays thus focus on scenes of hesitation, disquiet, trouble, not as those scenes actually happened – a truth for ever irretrievable – but as they were recorded and related in writing, mediated through a particular rhetoric. David Amigoni’s comments on Alfred Russel Wallace’s The Malay Archipelago (1894) may be illuminating here. He notes that when Wallace entered a Dyak village in Borneo and was stared at as if he had been some strange animal, thus ‘swap[ping] roles to become one of the creatures [an orang-utan] that in other circumstances he ha[d] hunted and observed’, this post-Darwinian blurring of the frontier between Self and Other was made conspicuous through Wallace’s fictional devices. Everything happens, Amigoni remarks, as if there were some kind of correlation between breaking down the species barrier and collapsing the partitioning between natural historical and fictional writing.29 If scientific revolutions come about through a change of metaphor of the world,30 how could the Westerner’s frames of perception and patterns of meaning concerning his or her Other be redefined without similar rhetorical upheavals? But how, then, are we to reconcile this inescapability of metaphorical redescription with the traditional aspiration of the exploration narrative to an absence of style, to a form of writing anxious to present the bare facts in all their freshness, without the mediation of the perverted figures of metaphor and comparison?31 At the end of the eighteenth century, Mungo Park’s aim was indeed to offer his reader ‘a plain, unvarnished tale’ of his African adventures.32 But since we may feel entitled to suspect that Park was in fact quoting less from the dictates of the Royal Society than from Shakespeare’s Othello (‘I will a round unvarnish’d tale deliver / Of my whole course of love’)33, to what extent should we trust the tale’s vow of transparency and believe in the explorer’s presence to himself ? Narratives may even be of a more intimate stuff and betray secret, personal fantasies. When
8
British Narratives of Exploration
he arrived at the entry to the long-sought Northwest Passage in 1818, John Ross really saw a wide range of mountains blocking the view across Lancaster Sound, which he described and even charted, while all his men, sailors and officers alike, assured him that in place of the ‘Croker Mountains’ there seemed indeed to be a passage.34 Very often, the material conditions of exploration were enough in themselves to distort perception. Like Livingstone, most explorers ‘returned to England emaciated shells of their former selves’,35 in a state of what Fabian has called ‘ecstasis’, having had to endure privation, exhaustion or fevers, and to consume alcohol or opiates to alleviate their sufferings, which, worked together, greatly undermined their sense of objectivity and rationality, while paradoxically furnishing a ground for cross-cultural understanding.36 Even if we admit the possibility that British explorers remained unaffected by illnesses or hallucinations and retained intact their ability to carry out the scientific tasks they had been assigned, does not the very vindication of ‘scientific’ or ‘realist’ objectivity betray an ‘imperialist’ rhetoric used to produce effects of scientificity, and therefore effects of authority or superiority? The very ideal of a transparent discourse, untarnished by the tropes of a given culture, paradoxically evokes the biblical myth of an original, pre-Babel form of communication. The most apparently neutral description by Cook of a trunk or of an unknown foliage observed on a Pacific island – ‘some kind of leaves’37 – implies a referent from which implicit comparisons can be made by the intended reader at home. When Mary Kingsley perceives the African mangrove as a metaphor for the origin of the world,38 does she not also reactivate the myth of undifferentiated chaos before divine intervention – a topos Stanley would later merge with that of the providential arrival of the white colonizer? British explorers could never undo their own inherited rhetoric, for without their idiosyncratic vision of the world, the interpretative work would simply have been a sheer impossibility. There never was a ‘new world’. The world the explorers discovered and described was always already constrained and therefore constructed by ‘discourses’, fantasies, knowledge systems, cultural structures of meaning-making, including the myths and other narratives which make up a national community and ensure that the message is effectively received by those who have stayed at home. The articles in this volume strive to establish the way in which each explorer, in the historical and cultural context to which he or she belonged, strove to reconcile the shock of the unknown and the recognition of the familiar, the new gaze and the inherited discourse, the naked surprise and the cultural filter, in his or her own particular style. This may result in tensions, even internal dissensions; this may also produce disturbing effects. For example, although they shared the same Enlightenment culture and explored the same regions at approximately the same time, Hearne and Mackenzie had widely diverging interpretations of what empiricism induced them to do at a practical level. And when Darwin invites his
Introduction
9
contemporaries to understand the unknown through the known,39 doesn’t this porous interchange between the civilized and the primitive produce a rhetoric which is already accepting the necessity of a hybridity of scientific thought? If we accept this fundamental premise that all narratives of first encounters were written at this juncture between an inherited national ‘culture’ (‘best seen … as a set of control mechanisms … for the governing of behavior’)40 and a revolutionary cognitive or hermeneutic event demanding personal adaptation to the new situation, several other questions emerge. One may wonder whether the historically-determined metaphors of the interpretative schema which produced and guaranteed the effectiveness of knowledge in a specific cultural context were systematically inscribed in the exploration narratives of the same period. Did this ‘ideological’ structuring of knowledge differ fundamentally according to whether the exploration and encounter occurred in the sixteenth or in the nineteenth century? For instance, did commerce or profit, which motivated the expeditions of Drake and Ralegh supply the Protestant English, then British explorers with the first and most prevalent of metaphorical filters in everything relating to non-violent, peaceful exchange? This would indeed seem to be the case of Clapperton’s and Stanley’s nineteenth-century visions of Africa. But even so, were the situations of dialogue conceived in the same terms? Were the general procedures which determined the pragmatic effectiveness of such scenes identical? What were the various signs – verbal and non-verbal: gestures, rituals, dumb shows, pantomimes, even silences – which the individual explorers thought worth recording? Can we sketch a history of first exchanges, and of the way they were mediated in narrative? For example, can we safely claim that communication between Self and Other gradually transformed from misunderstanding or disdain, to comprehension, then to mutual enrichment and finally to postcolonial hybridity and postmodern disillusionment (one would think here of Bruce Chatwin’s In Patagonia)? Or should we, rather, speak of individual postures, dictated to the explorers by specific contexts, through the circumstances these individuals sometimes unexpectedly found themselves in? Perhaps we should then also accept the possibility that we need to distinguish between several successive postures in the same historical context, and even within the same explorer. Should we not, for example, distinguish between the Franklin of the beginning of his mission and the Franklin who realizes that the hierarchical relation linking the civilized to the primitive is crumbling down and is even being inverted? Or between the Burton representing the East India Company, stationed in Sindh to supervise its annexation, and the same man mandated by the Royal Geographical Society, nomadizing through the Arabian sands? And what about the postures dictated by the haunting ghost of a preceding explorer, and more crucially still, of a preceding exploration text? Like any
10
British Narratives of Exploration
other narrative, an explorer’s account inevitably quotes from various other texts, thus gaining consistency through internal ‘dialogism’, or ‘inter-textuality’.41 We do need to wonder whether the intertextual postures inherent in any situation of enunciation were not equally overdetermining in the production of various Self–Other differential systems. Drake and Ralegh were keen to dissociate their accounts from earlier Spanish and Portuguese – and therefore Catholic – narratives; Cook’s apprehension of the Polynesians’ ‘thievish’ tendencies was informed by Wallis’s log; Tod’s understanding of Rajasthan’s laws and customs was determined by his knowledge of the European feudal system of land ownership; Stanley’s ideological recuperation of Africa’s economic potential largely drew on biblical prophetic imagery. The Self ’s relation to the Other is always, so to speak, ‘predicted’ by a narrative mediation – etymology, prophecy, myth, logbook, journal, treatise, essay, novel, advertisement, etc. – whose relevance is either validated or invalidated by individual field experience and personal (re)inscription. To a certain extent, every explorer-writer may be said to produce him or herself as the effect of an ‘anxiety of influence’. ‘There is nothing outside the text’, deconstructionists argue:42 yes, indeed, texts there were, both before and after the experience of encounter, text upon text therefore, a hyper-intertextuality from which the unpredictability of faceto-face encounter was bound to emerge transfigured. The challenge therefore is to study how the destabilizing presence of otherness transpires all the same, more or less repressed, adulterated, domesticated, accommodated, glorified, in a textual unstable zone poised between the singularity of personal field experience, the individual desire to open unbeaten tracks in the art of description and the more or less limiting awareness of the existence of previous records. As a matter of fact, such tension may be the source of these exploration narratives’ enduring power of fascination, perhaps even the source of their surprising literary quality. The eighteenth-century incestuous proximity of established writers and supposedly inarticulate explorers – John Hawkesworth’s rewritings of several Commanders’ logbooks, George Keate’s re-elaboration of Captain Wilson’s reports of his amicable relations with the Palauan inhabitants in the Western part of the Pacific Ocean – should not divert our attention from the obvious fact: all reports – log entries, journals, retrospective narratives, fictional reelaborations – were narratives, complex fabrics of lexicon, viewpoint, trope, quotation, elision, temporality, plot. Exploration accounts, as well as ethnographic descriptions or anthropological studies, were, and still are, literary artefacts. The book was initially composed as a succession of ‘case studies’ arranged chronologically. It seemed this basic principle of consecutive chapters was perfectly adapted to the philosophy of a volume whose ambition was to demonstrate that field experience, whatever the historical period or geographical location, could only yield undetermined responses which therefore required specific case
Introduction
11
studies. But objection could be made that such a structuring device could prove an unreliable tool in colonial and postcolonial studies. The possibility of formatting the whole enterprise according to thematic units, which could be called ‘chapters’, uniting individual essays irrespective of historical context, was then seriously considered. Transhistorical affinities and similarities between the individual narratives of highly different personalities, in widely different contexts, could indeed be emphasized: instances of such affinities were to be perceived even between Mandeville and Stanley, whose narratives definitely seek to submit the not-Self to an ambivalent process of ‘othering’ and ‘saming’; Lawson’s ‘prospective vision’ of Carolina anticipates Stanley’s capitalist gaze; Clapperton’s universalizing perspective on the Africans could be placed alongside a number of eighteenth-century narratives, and his treatment of the theme of ‘wonder’ might even invite comparison with Drake’s; cases of mimicry, linguistic or behavioural, may bring Ralegh and Burton into unexpected proximity, and so forth. Once ascertained, this continuity in discontinuity could easily delineate a number of recurrent modalities of encounter, entailing a limited number of chapters bearing alluring titles such as ‘Inventing the Other’, ‘Domesticating the Other’, ‘Fictionalizing the Other’, ‘Destabilizing the Self ’, etc. The major risk involved was of course decontextualization. There is indeed a cultural continuity between medieval and Renaissance narratives which ceases to exist in the course of the eighteenth century, when empiricism and nationalism radically redefine the coordinates of identities; and Darwin’s revolutionary theories in the second half of the nineteenth century, together with the social, economic and political upheavals generated by a triumphant imperialist system, undisputably redefine the British explorer’s conception of Self and Other. One is forced to admit, come to that, that more could have been achieved in articulating the formation of imperial narratives on Britain’s shifting politics of intersubjectivity: for example, it is unquestionably the case that there were times when religious, political or commercial motivations were granted priority over genuine curiosity or cognitive ambitions, depending on the situation abroad or at home as well as on the intellectual climate of the day. Still, what case studies establish is the extreme variety of individual responses to specific situations: the official instructions – which most of the time accompanied the explorers to the ends of the earth – recommending ‘intercourse’ with the Other, could be interpreted with a certain degree of freedom once in context, as even eighteenthcentury natural historians and anthropologists could adopt diverging postures regarding their objects of observation; and throughout the nineteenth century, the growing popularization of ‘developmental’ then ‘evolutionary’ theories helped reaffirm cultural hierarchies as much as it encouraged cultural relativism.
12
British Narratives of Exploration
The structure of the book seeks therefore to steer a middle course between the purely successive and the purely thematic. By grouping various essays inside chapters dealing with historical periods, the book emphasizes the inevitability of historicization; by choosing general headings for such chapters, each offering a thematic thread to pursue through the case studies, it also underlines the profound unity linking the various exploration narratives within a specific cultural context. In the first chapter, ‘Fantasy, Wonder and Mimicry: Proto-Ethnography from the Middle Ages to the Renaissance’, Kofi Campbell examines the most important Middle English travelogue, The Book of John Mandeville and focuses on two encounters in particular: Mandeville’s meetings with a Muslim Sultan, and his observations on the cultures of Africa. In both cases, the author’s descriptions were meant to function as enticements to colonization. Campbell argues this was accomplished through the confluence of two seemingly opposite rhetorical practices. By stressing the otherness of the Muslims and Africans, the author constructed them as dangerous people who needed to be contained. At the same time, by focusing on their fleeting similarities, he also suggested that they were similar enough, and that they therefore could be made more culturally like his audience. Indeed, he even calls for their conversion. The next essay broadens the perspective. Starting from a brief study of the process of naming in the medieval period, Nicholas Myers and Ladan Niayesh argue that during the Renaissance names corresponded to fantasmatic archetypes arising from the inner mental and cultural landscape of the West, a landscape which European explorers went in search of – and, inevitably, ‘found’. Cannibalism was thus assumed to characterize the primitives, and the assumption became its own proof. Niayesh and Myers go on to argue that, as in John Nicholl’s Hourglasse of Indian Newes (1607), the designation of the Other involved the use of book titles whose function was in fact to project fantasies of fascination and horror; in Richard Jobson’s Discovery of the River Gambra (1623), which conceived of itself as a genuine attempt at proto-ethnography, naming became part of a trial-and-error hermeneutics of culture in which appellation, serving the purpose of ideological ‘interpellation’, supplanted or partly eclipsed ethnographic knowledge. All such approximations are recuperated within the providentialist framework, the naming of the Other turning out to be a (re)claiming of the territory of the Self. Sophie Lemercier-Goddard then focuses on The World Encompassed by Sir Francis Drake, which rehearses the first English circumnavigation in history (1577–80), and shows how a Pirate’s venture is transformed into a ‘famous voyage’ of discovery by emphasizing the importance of ‘wonder’, not so much before new lands or unknown passages as before other human beings. A close reading of the text shows that Drake’s rhetoric of the body is an essential ingredient of the wonderful, as the English develop a form of discourse based on the
Introduction
13
use of visual signs, of objects and dumb shows, and as they participate in an Indian ceremony to change it and interpret it according to their own interests. Lemercier-Goddard analyses how it is in fact a pantomime which enables the Westerners to ‘translate’, that is to say to take possession of, the land. Line Cottegnies focuses her analysis on Sir Walter Ralegh’s Discovery of Guiana (1595). Her study reveals that though Ralegh’s account was inevitably informed by the topoi and myths elaborated through a tradition of ‘fantastic ethnography’, and though it reflected a detailed knowledge of previous travellers’ accounts, it also evinced Ralegh’s desire for a genuine dialogical encounter with native societies. But ‘Waterali’ seemed to be aware of the necessarily ambivalent nature of his enterprise. By focusing on the linguistic aspects of the encounter, on the question of communication and misinterpretation, Cottegnies manages to show that Ralegh’s descriptions of scenes of first encounter involved in fact a mutual form of colonial ‘mimicry’. In the second chapter, ‘Distance in Question: Translating the Other in the Eighteenth Century’, Robert Sayre takes us to the east coast of North America at the dawn of the eighteenth century. In late December 1700, John Lawson and a group of nine Englishmen and Native Americans set off on a two-month trek into the Carolina backcountry. Lawson, who was in close contact with twenty Indian tribes, had then no other option but to rely on native translators to communicate with his hosts. Sayre places A New Voyage to Carolina (1709) within the tradition of accounts of travel in North American Indian territory, before he analyses the dynamics of domestication of the Indian ‘Other’ within the text. Lawson’s narrative of encounter ultimately pictures a highly ‘unstable zone’, since a process of destabilization of certainties is enacted, leading ultimately to a partial and contradictory recognition of the specificity and value of the Other. Of course the eighteenth century was the age of unprecedented systematic maritime exploration. Commander Samuel Wallis was the first Englishman to come across what is known today as the Polynesian archipelagos, specifically Tahiti (1767). His log has rarely been studied whereas his journal, written once back in England has attracted more critical attention (neither has been published). Considering the log to be the primordial written representation attesting to the very first encounter between the British and the Tahitians, Sandhya Patel proposes a comparison between the Wallis log and the Wallis journal which brings to light how the process of representation of Self and Other in the log cultivates ambivalence, while the journal seems to be intent on posting clearer markers for future colonization. Patel thus comes to the conclusion that the log’s rendition of first encounters may be read as a site of uncertainty where the politics of encounter is shaped in a telegraphic but perhaps more accurate form. The journal of Cook’s first voyage to Tahiti and New Zealand was published only a few years later by Hawkesworth (1773), containing not only Cook’s descrip-
14
British Narratives of Exploration
tion of new, as yet uncharted, territories but also his relation of the more or less successful attempts of the British at establishing links with indigenous populations – as were the Admiralty’s explicit instructions. Anne Dromart shows how difficult it seems to have been for all actors in the field to know how close or how distant to each other the British and the islanders wanted, or needed, to be. Focusing her reading on aspects of communication and territoriality, but also on the metaphors and grammatical structures of Hawkesworth’s narrative, Dromart perceives this trouble to have been generated by the Europeans’ growing awareness of issues of cultural difference. Christian Moser then argues that in the late eighteenth century a shift had occurred in the European discourse of exploration. By comparing Cook’s writings with those of the Anglo-German scientist Georg Forster, who accompanied Cook on his second voyage to the South Pacific and published his own account of the expedition, A Voyage around the World (1777), Moser relates Forster’s mode of exploration to the emergent bourgeois practice of walking and analyses its implications for the negotiation between Self and Other in first-contact situations. Cook’s descriptive labour depends on maintaining an outsider’s position, using the ship as a mobile home that allows the explorer to extricate himself from his involvement in the foreign culture. Forster, for his part, attempts to integrate his observations of how he procured his information, thus opposing the off-shore practice of natural history and the inland practice of anthropology. The close of the eighteenth century inaugurated the age of Empire. By the early 1800s several companies had established trading posts and forts across North America, where fur and copper were to be found in seemingly unlimited abundance. The mythical Northwest Passage – which could provide a water route to the trading markets of the Orient – became of crucial importance. Prominent among the explorers’ narratives whose overt purpose was the expansion of the territory and trade interests of the British Empire were Samuel Hearne’s A Journey from Prince of Wales’s Fort in Hudson’s Bay to the Northern Ocean (1795) and Alexander Mackenzie’s Voyages from Montreal on the River St. Laurence, through the Continent of North America, to the Frozen and Pacific Oceans (1801). Cheryl Cundell’s comparative study demonstrates that the two narratives reflected in fact opposite attitudes to empiricism, natural history and anthropology. She argues that these opposite interpretations of the same method entailed profoundly differing perceptual modes, which speak through the nature of the observations emphasized in each text, and inevitably shape the explorers’ textual constructions of Self and Other. In the third, final and longest chapter, ‘Stereotypes Undermined: Shifting the Self in the Nineteenth Century’, the authors focus on the growing unease which seems to have assailed a significant number of British explorers’ narratives, even among the staunchest and most aggressive supporters of England’s ‘mission’. A
Introduction
15
perfect example of this is to be found in the continuation of Hearne’s, Mackenzie’s and Ross’s vain efforts to find the Northwest Passage. In the 1820s, England sought to preserve the position of European leader which it had carved for itself during the war against Napoleon. Russia had to be beaten at its own game, and supremacy now urgently demanded that Britain should at long last discover the Passage. Hence the expedition led by John Franklin which he describes in his Narrative of a Journey to the Shores of the Polar Sea (1823). According to Catherine Lanone, the journal of the expedition questions the very concept of exploration, raising the problem of its ideological constructs, hermeneutic codes and ontological modes. As food becomes scarce and pain increases, Franklin’s journal seems to relate an initiatory journey, complete with trials and hardships. Meeting the Other then becomes a twofold process: initially casting the Indians as inferior beings whose function is to serve and obey, Franklin is gradually forced to grant them a greater presence, notably when they come to the rescue of the starving survivors of the expedition. Lanone pinpoints various slips and gaps in Franklin’s narrative, which she reads as symptoms of the collapse of stereotypes of Self and Other. The slave trade, gold and ivory, were other powerful lures for the Empire, whose arms reached therefore towards much warmer subSaharan latitudes. But even if British explorers were less in need of indigenous assistance than in the Arctic regions, it seems harsh polarization was not necessarily in order in their narratives. Anne-Pascale Bruneau argues that Hugh Clapperton’s account of his second expedition into West Africa offers a surprisingly favourable portrait of Africans. Clapperton’s Journal of a Second Expedition into the Interior of Africa (1829), a compilation of various documents that survived Clapperton’s death by dysentery in 1827, is informed by a universalizing and broadly sympathetic outlook, which seems at times to be inherited from the eighteenth century. Through an analysis of the various forms of non-verbal exchanges reported by Clapperton, Bruneau brings to light the presence of codes underlying first encounters, and relates them to the existence of previous forms of commercial contact between Europeans and Africans, of which the journal itself provides evidence. More importantly still, her study focuses on how both the British and the Africans construct politically useful self-representations, and suggests that, in its textual representations of these encounters, Clapperton’s journal tends rather to minimize than to emphasize the distinctions between Self and Other. The crowning jewel of the British Empire, needless to say, was the Raj. James Tod was one of its major early architects. In 1799, he went to India as a cadet in the Bengal army of the East India Company, and in 1818 was appointed political agent for the states of western Rajputana. But Tod was also an extraordinary scholar, whose Annals and Antiquities of Rajasthan (1829–32) laid the foundation of the systematic study of Rajasthan’s history and culture. Florence D’Souza
16
British Narratives of Exploration
shows how this formidable Orientalist accepted the help of Indian scholars, participated in local rituals and compared the nature of Rajput attachment to their ancestral lands with feudal or allodial systems of land ownership in medieval Europe. Tod also tried to render versions of Rajput history intelligible for his European readership, without failing to note Rajput moral, artistic and scientific advancement, to his superiors’ great dismay and embarrassment. Another source of imperial ‘trouble’ from within was the presence of women explorers. Anna Jameson travelled to Upper Canada to join her estranged husband, and according to Jennifer Scott it is precisely through Jameson’s liminal position in her marital status, her uncertain fate as a potential Upper-Canadian resident, and her wavering loyalty to the colonial project, that Winter Studies and Summer Rambles in Canada (1838) reveals fissures in the woman explorer’s sense of national identity. Jameson describes moments of ‘first contact’ with the Native Canadians as well as the Upper-Canadian landscape using the already-politicized language of the picturesque with a view to domesticating otherness. But her portraits of individual Indians, the personal relationships that transpire through such ‘sketches’, together with the impetus to communicate cultural difference to her British readership, also demonstrate Jameson’s willingness to acknowledge the complexity of Upper-Canadian oral culture. As a consequence, her journal seems to work towards an uneasy balance between national loyalty, feminism and a defence of racial equality. At home a major cultural event reshuffled the cards of the game of differentiation. Those were the days of the gradual seeping in of evolutionary theories. Two decades before the official publication of The Origin of Species (1859), Charles Darwin had laid the foundations for his future theory during his circumnavigation of the globe (1831–6), not only by collecting specimens of exotic fauna and flora, but also by exposing his epistemological preconceptions to destabilizing contact with peoples on different ‘rungs’ of civilization. In particular the voyage to Patagonia (1832) proved a journey into the past, in which the inhabitants of Tierra del Fuego were cast as the fossilized remnants of an older, primitive stage of humanity. At the same time, the border between the civilized and the savage state of mankind proved to be precarious, as was demonstrated by the story of Jemmy Button and other ‘Anglicized’ Fuegians, returning on the Beagle to their native country and swiftly relapsing to their former ‘savage’ stage. Virginia Richter addresses two aspects of Darwin’s encounter with the Patagonians: firstly, the concepts – such as ideas of scientific observation, discovery, civilization and racial difference – that have a bearing on his descriptions of the ‘Other’; secondly, the textual strategies coming into play in the two versions of his travel report, the private diary and the public – and highly successful – narrative of his Voyage on the Beagle (1839). Another formidable figure of the mid-century was Richard Burton, explorer, soldier, Orientalist, ethnologist, linguist, diplomat
Introduction
17
and poet, one of the most fascinating characters ever produced by the East India Company, which had posted the young man to Sindh, one of the four provinces of today’s Pakistan, where Burton lived with the Muslims and learned several Eastern languages and dialects. In 1853, Burton famously travelled incognito to the forbidden holy cities of Medina and Mecca disguised as a pilgrim. My contribution to the volume consists in putting Burton’s Personal Narrative of a Pilgrimage (1855–6) into perspective by reading it alongside with his first book, Sindh (1851), and a short autobiographical sketch written at approximately the same time and appended as a postscript to Falconry in the Valley of the Indus (1852). I argue that what is fascinating about Burton’s early, pre-African texts is that they never entirely manage to portray him as a fully reliable authority holding a statutory position and marking hierarchical differences between Self and Other. With Burton, the imperialist programme is in fact both implemented and undermined, as the explorer-ethnographer becomes aware of the linguistic postures implied by the situations of interlocution in which his adventures place him. Burton thus constructs a hybrid image of himself, blurring the demarcation line not only between the Westerner and the Oriental, but also between real and fantasized life, or between being and writing, breaking down the boundaries between ethnographic description and literary self-refashioning. The volume closes on a notoriously controversial figure, Henry Morton Stanley, whose published work also closes the century. A major icon of American journalism as well as of British imperial heroism, muscular Christianity and late-Victorian masculinity, Stanley mapped large areas of Central and Eastern Africa and solved some of the continent’s geographical enigmas, but was also involved in horrific crimes in the Congo. Focusing on the conspicuous textuality of Stanley’s three major narratives of exploration, published between 1872 and 1890, Nicoletta Brazzelli argues that Stanley’s reports in fact implicitly sought to construct Africa as a stage where he could refashion himself into a British national hero, which induced him to represent Africa as a place of darkness and savagery. The trope of the ‘monarch-of-all-I-survey’ then transforms the explorer into the God-like creator of an imaginary Africa turned into a utopian object of future exploitation and consumption. Simultaneously, however, the representation of African space provides Stanley’s readers with a glimpse into the origins of civilization and the laws of evolution, which even in his case implies a redefinition of the borders between Self and Other.
1 ENCOUNTERING AFRICA: USES OF THE OTHER IN THE BOOK OF JOHN MANDEVILLE (1357) Kofi Campbell
This essay discusses one of the most important travel documents from the medieval English period, The Book of John Mandeville.1 The Book became the most popular travel narrative of the English Middle Ages, and describes the author’s purported encounters with many different cultures. The Book first appeared in 1357, its author claiming to be an English knight born and bred in St Albans who left England in 1322 and travelled around the world for just over thirty-five years. The author’s claims and descriptions of foreign lands were, for the most part, accepted without question, and the work came immediately to enjoy what Suzanne Akbari refers to as ‘extraordinary popularity’.2 Within a few short years it had been translated into almost every European vernacular. It was not until the late nineteenth century that comparisons with other contemporary texts proved ‘beyond question for the most part, that the author had in fact ‘done it at Home’.3 No trace has ever been found of a real John Mandeville who might have written this book, and whoever wrote it never travelled to the places he describes. It is a compilation of several sources (both learned and anecdotal) whose author made several additions and changes to his sources, so that it forms a coherent narrative of his ‘journeys’ throughout the world. Iain Higgins reads The Book as multiple, as containing within the text several different genres: a piece of intermittent crusading propaganda; an occasional satire on the religious practices of Latin Christians; an implicit treatise on the right rule in both Christian and non-Christian worlds (a kind of mirror for Christian princes); a proof of the earth’s sphericity, the existence of the inhabited antipodes, and the possibility of circumnavigation; a demonstration that most non-Christians have a ‘natural’ knowledge of the One, True God; a framed collection of tales and diversities, both exemplary and entertaining; and the desultory memoirs – the travel lies, in fact, of a ‘verray parfit gentil’ English Knight Errant.4 – 19 –
20
British Narratives of Exploration
The text’s ‘typicality as a compilation’,5 and the fact of its continual recopying, retransmission and re-editing, means that we must pay attention to the selection of materials the redactor of any particular version chooses to include, and the ideological shades with which he imbues them, as a means of tracing both that version’s relationships with its foreign others, and the kinds of knowledge for which its audience hungered. There are approximately 300 extant manuscripts, approximately forty-four in English, and some twenty-four known versions of The Book, six in English. The English versions are the Bodley, Cotton, Defective, Egerton, Metrical and Stanzaic Fragment. The version which will concern us most here is the Bodley text found in MS. Bodleian e Musaeo 116, a text which M. C. Seymour describes as ‘an abridgement of a lost English translation of a Latin recension of the Insular Version, i.e. at five major removes from the original work’;6 in other words, it is a thoroughly Anglicized version of the text, translated and abridged for an English audience. Although the Bodley was not the most widely circulated version in the Middle Ages, it is the version with the second highest number of extant manuscripts. Furthermore, it is the version which is speculated to have been composed latest of all the English versions (as late as 1450), thereby suggesting that as the century progressed, interest in travellers’ tales to Africa increased; unlike the other, earlier, English versions of The Book, the Bodley is positively obsessed with Africa. The Metrical version has only this to say about Africa: In that land of Ethiopia there is a well, I swear, where during the day the water is so cold that no man may drink of it, and so hot at night that no man might touch it. The waters are hot, dirty and salty, because of the great heat that strikes them. And each person in that country has but one foot, and it is truly so broad that it covers his whole body when the sun is shining hotly, for they suffer greatly for the heat. And next to that land men shall find a land called Little India.7
The entire African area is covered in some fourteen lines. The narrator of the Defective version is equally brief : In the south of this land all the people are completely black. And in that place is a well in which the water that is so cold during the day that no man might drink it, and so hot at night that no man might suffer his hand in it. In this land the rivers and all the water are turbulent [lit. troubled] and somewhat salty because of the heat. And men of that land get drunk easily and have little appetite for food. And they commonly suffer from consumption and they do not live long. In Ethiopia are such people who have only one foot and they travel so fast that it is marvelous to see, and it is a large foot which makes a shadow and covers the whole body from the sun. And in Ethiopia is the city of Saba, of which one of the three lords who offered [gifts] to our lord was king. I have told you of Ethiopia, from where men go into India.8
Encountering Africa
21
This version can stand as well for the Cotton and Egerton versions which are very similar, which is explained by the fact that all three texts are descended, at least partly, from the Insular version. The Egerton text, though, is also descended from a lost text which is based on the Royal Latin version. This is significant because the Bodley Book is also based on the Royal Latin version, making the Egerton text the English version to which the Bodley is most closely associated. This is relevant for two reasons. The first is that the Egerton version is the only English text of The Book to contain, in a section which deals with the diamond wealth of India, the following statement: ‘And if ye will know the virtues of the diamond, I shall tell you as Isidore libro 16, Ethicorum, capitulo de cristallo, and Bartholomew De Proprietatibus Rerum, libro 16, capitulo de adamante say’.9 The Bodley redactor, in making his text, moves this entire discussion, originally focusing on India, into his description of Africa. The second reason has to do with the Bodley redactor’s treatment of Africa. The Bodley version of The Book, unlike the other English versions, deals extensively with Africa. The redactor accomplished this by simply taking narratives from other sections of the book and placing them, often verbatim, into the sections of his Book which describe the lands of Africa. And, one of the sections he transposes is that which describes the diamond riches of India; this is the section which, in the Egerton (the only English version with which the Bodley shares a common ancestor), also contains a reference to Bartholomew’s De Proprietatibus Rerum, a text which constructed Africans in rather negative ways, offering potential justifications for taking the wealth it also described. This connection is not sufficient to prove that that text’s reading of blacks directly influenced the Bodley redactor’s; what cannot be denied is that the Bodley redactor has read at least parts of Bartholomew, that he is fascinated with Africa in a way that none of the other English redactors is, and that the colonialist desire we can trace within many Middle English texts circulates within this text in many of the same ways that it does throughout that body of literature. I will argue that, through his encounters with Africa and its peoples, the author asks his audience to reconsider their own cultural self-definitions in both positive and negative ways. I will also suggest that the author’s descriptions are meant to function as enticements to colonialism. This is accomplished through the bringing together of two seemingly opposite rhetorical practices, namely the processes of ‘othering’ and ‘saming’. By stressing the otherness of the Africans the author constructs them as dangerous people who need to be contained. At the same time, by focusing on their many similarities, he also suggests that they are similar enough to his audience that they could eventually be converted, and made more culturally like his audience, a conversion which he explicitly calls for at the end of his text. Of course, because this work is first and foremost a text which seeks to establish the inherent superiority of its own culture in rela-
22
British Narratives of Exploration
tion to others, our narrator always begins by constructing his others as backward, uncivilized savages. In the first place, he ensures that his audience encounters the Africans first as a manifestation of physical otherness, as almost completely other to his audience. There are some, for example, ‘that have only one foot, and they can run so fast on that one foot that it is an amazing sight. And that foot is so big that it is an amazing sight; it will cover all his body against the heat of the sun’.10 And, as the medieval body of writing dealing with Africa usually did, this text often associates these racial differences with heat. We are told soon after that ‘that same island is so hot that because of the great heat in the air, men’s private parts hang down to their knees’.11 And although he has previously highlighted the unendurable heat of the place, the narrator also stresses its opposite: ‘In that country of Ethiopia there is a country towards the west where the air is so cold that, because of the cold, there is a continual frost which freezes the water so that it turns to crystal’.12 Thus, even the physical spaces of Africa are constructed as mercurial and unpredictable. But the author of this text goes beyond mere physical difference, offering his audience a glimpse into the cultural realm of the Africans, and it is here that he ensures that his audience will encounter the Africans as not only other, but as uncivilized primitives. We learn, for example, that ‘In Ethiopia men and women, in the summertime, go together to streams and lie therein from morning till noon, all naked, because of the great heat of the sun’.13 This imagery, and the hint of forbidden pleasure it offers, is part and parcel of the primitivizing process here, the suggestion that these people live in a world of unbridled sensuality. They are closer to animals than to reasoning humans. It is also somewhat of a commonplace in medieval travel literature. Geraldine Heng notes that the titillating nature of such images is ‘a resonant example of the kind of narrative pleasure offered by European travel stories focusing on the exotic … Audiences of travelogues are conditioned, from the proto-anthropology of Herodotus and Pliny on, to expect the exotic/erotic, the forbidden/taboo’.14 In other words, savages in different parts of the world are expected to be erotic as well as exotic, for that is part of what makes them savages. Indeed, the sense of decadence and the hint of sexuality deepen as we move into another part of Ethiopia, Lamore, where ‘the heat is so great and burning that the custom there is that every man and woman goes about naked, and scorns those that are clothed. For they say that Adam was naked, and Eve also’.15 This is a particularly inspired rhetorical strategy, in that the narrator has the Africans construct themselves as backward and primitive. Not only are they naked, but they excuse that nakedness themselves through an appeal to archaic times. In this way the text refutes John Friedman’s assertion that ‘cultural evolution’ was simply
Encountering Africa
23
not part of the ‘conceptual vocabulary’ of the medieval period, and that social differences were usually explained away as ‘the result of degeneration’, rather than as ‘an earlier stage of cultural evolution’.16 Here, the Lamorans are precisely constructed as being at an earlier stage of cultural/religious evolution, in a time prior to the more advanced audience of the text. The text’s audience understands that humanity has moved beyond the age of the patriarchs, and that it is wrong to try and live in that way; the primitive Lamorans still live, culturally, in those earlier times. The redactor denies them ‘coevalness’, to use the terminology of Johannes Fabian. The ‘denial of coevalness’ is a concept he applies to early modern ethnography but, as is the case with many (post)colonial conventions, it has its origins in the Middle Ages. Fabian argues that early modern ethnographers denied ‘coevalness’, or contemporaneity, to the other cultures they encountered. The denial of coevalness describes the ‘persistent and systematic tendency to place the referent(s) of anthropology in a Time other than the present of the producer of anthropological discourse’.17 In other words, they subjected their others to a process of primitivism, constructing them as less culturally advanced than the ethnographers themselves. We can clearly see this process at work in The Book. Even further, we learn that in Lamore ‘there are no marriages between men and women, but rather all the women of that country are shared by every man’.18 In this way the Africans of Lamore become not only primitive, decadent and uncivilized, but also specifically ungodly, for marriage was a sacred sacrament ordained by God, and such casual sexuality was perceived as being directly against the dictates of God. The text here again separates the Africans effectively from the Christian English audience encountering them, and lowers the Africans to the level almost of brute animals, wallowing naked in the water all day long and copulating at will with any woman they choose. There can be no doubt that this behaviour on the part of the Africans would have been read as offensive and blasphemous to the text’s audience. But Mandeville is not content to show the blasphemy of the Africans so indirectly. He tells us that ‘in that same country of Ethiopia they honour the ox instead of god, because of his simpleness and goodness, and for the work that he does and the profit which comes because of him’.19 Nor is it only the common people who act this way; even the king himself, we are told, ‘has always an ox with him wherever he goes and honours it as his god … and the king puts his hand into the dung and takes some, and rubs it on his teeth, his breast, his forehead and his face, so that he might be blessed through the virtue of that holy thing’.20 Even as he discusses the blasphemous religion of the Africans Mandeville continues to emphasize their savagery: ‘in the country of Ethiopia they slay their children before their gods as a sacrifice, and take the blood and sprinkle it on their idols’.21
24
British Narratives of Exploration
As has often been observed, this story is reminiscent of the biblical narrative of Abraham, who was ordered by God to kill his son. But, in the civilized Christian paradigm, God steps in and stops the sacrifice, explaining that it was just a test. Here, a biblical exemplum is translated onto the African world, emphasizing the love and justice of Christianity over and against the bloody savagery of the Africans’ religion. In this way The Book conflates racial otherness and religious difference, constructing the Africans as inferior in both categories. And we must always remember that religious difference was a particularly charged one during this time of Christian crusaderism; the expansion of the faith and conversion of unbelievers was still a fundamental part of Christian thinking, and therefore the construction of Africans as religiously different, indeed as heretics and blasphemers, was necessarily a politically charged one. The fact that these ox-worshipping heretics are encountered in Africa brings us to the most important facet of the Mandeville-author’s portrayal of the Africans and their culture, particularly as that culture relates to the English Christian culture which formed this text’s audience. Andrew Fleck argues that Mandeville represents each culture he encounters based on a scale of similarity and difference in relation to his own: ‘some cultures are very similar … others are radically different, and in between are cultures of ambiguous difference’.22 Heng echoes this idea, suggesting that Mandeville describes ‘each far-off country on an implied or explicit scale of distance from Europe, and especially from England and France . . . [and] also constitutes the rest of the world as the periphery of Christian Europe.23 Fleck argues further that the narrator tends to portray these foreign cultures as proto-Christian, claiming that, for the most part, they would embrace Christianity, and other Western cultural and social institutions, given the chance: an obvious gesture towards colonialism. Fleck’s schematic is useful, but flawed when applied to the Bodley version. He suggests that for Mandeville, the Greeks were the epitome of a similar-yetdifferent culture; the Africans are the epitome of a radically different culture; and the Muslim Saracens represent an ambiguously-different culture. He bases this division on the fact that the Africans are constructed purely as inhuman and indeed monstrous, such as the race of people who have only one foot; these ‘monstrous races’, he argues, are present ‘to provide an aesthetic contrast, as a clearly sub-human other, to the reader’s sense of self … Their fantastically grotesque bodies serve to create ‘absolute difference between reader and subject’.24 These ‘monstrous races’ are then contrasted in Fleck’s argument with the socalled ‘human’ races, with whom the audience would have more in common, such as the Saracens. As a result of closer contact, he argues, the Saracens occupy an ambivalent place in Mandeville’s text, simultaneously attractive and repellant, while the still-distant Africans are completely inhuman and other.
Encountering Africa
25
But as we can see from some of the examples I gave above, Fleck’s assessment of Mandeville’s treatment of Africans does not apply to the Bodley version. While the Bodley redactor does indeed portray many Africans as monstrous, inhuman and utterly different, he also acknowledges often that there are lands in Ethiopia where the people are of the ‘human’ kind, to use Fleck’s terminology. Thus, some Ethiopians may lie around naked in the water, but the shame in that is that they expose their human bodies, just as the women who have sex with many men make shameful use of their also human bodies. But the Bodley redactor goes even further than this, at times identifying the Africans closely with his Christian audience, much more closely than one might expect. One of the tests of the ambivalence Fleck sees in Mandeville’s portrayal of the Saracens, is that Mandeville often acknowledges many of the points of similarity between the two religions, creating an unstable space within which ‘they’ become both like and unlike ‘us’. In fact, there are also several times when Mandeville creates such spaces of similarity between the African cultures and his own. The difference between the two spaces lies in Mandeville’s differing reactions to the two cultures. Immediately after describing the Lamorans’ habit of walking around naked, for example, Mandeville tells us that they explain their actions by noting that Adam and Eve did the same. As I argued before, this explanation serves a primitivizing function, but at the same time it serves as a common reference point between these people and the text’s English audience. This moment works to soften the absolute difference of the Africans and make them a touch more familiar. Likewise, the Lamorans excuse their lack of monogamous marriages through an appeal to the biblical injunction ‘Crescite et multiplicamini’, that is to say, ‘Grow and multiply [and replenish the earth]’: here too the narrator creates another moment of congruence and familiarity, however transitory, while at the same time re-identifying them as heretical.25 In these moments, the Africans become startlingly similar for a brief instant. Now, when the Muslim Saracens blur the lines between cultures, Mandeville responds, in the words of Andrew Fleck, by summarizing ‘the points of faith not in contention between Christians and Saracens, and concludes that they believe in most of the essential tenets necessary to become Christian … They are not irredeemably different and could … be brought to accept Christian beliefs’.26 But when the Africans blur those same lines, Mandeville is absolutely silent, letting their own explanations stand as the final word. His silence is not surprising. Mandeville’s England was still quite concerned with the Saracens, not only as a religious, political and social other, but also commercially. Exchanges between Muslims and the Western world were important enough that his audience would have been deeply interested in such points of similarity, and so he speaks to them directly. I suggest that Mandeville’s willingness to silently allow African
26
British Narratives of Exploration
similarity as well as difference, indeed to indirectly insist upon that similarity, demonstrates the growing importance of Africa to medieval England. Africa is for the most part portrayed as utterly different, and the Africans as inhuman savages, so it makes little sense that Mandeville would attempt to reconcile their conception of Christianity too closely with his own. Yet the text’s colonialist desire also generates points of congruence, spaces in which there exist the possibilities of similarities as well as difference. It is not enough that there is wealth in Africa, and that the Africans are weak; the later eighteenth and nineteenth-century discourses of colonialism were driven largely by the fiction, or more generously the belief, that the colonizing power was, in reality, helping the colonized peoples. For that to be possible, though, similarities must exist; there must be a way for the colonized to be helped and so it becomes necessary that, although the Africans have a king who worships an ox, there also exist within those lands seeds of Christianity, however heretical and blasphemous. It might be possible to take a man who worships an ox and make him into a Christian, but it is certainly easier to do so to people who already have an inkling of the faith. Thus it is also important that a nest of Nestorians resided there, and still persist in some places; however misguided, they too are Christians, and as such represent a moment of similarity between cultures, a gap which can be widened and exploited. Indeed, Mandeville tells us that there is even a Christian relic in Ethiopia, the hand of Saint Thomas the Apostle, which the locals use for magical purposes.27 So while the Africans are certainly not as ambiguously constructed as the Saracens, they are certainly portrayed in a way which makes them less starkly other than commentators of this text have tended to argue; the Bodley author is careful to construct the Africans as extremely different, even monstrous at times, but not so monstrous that their fascination disappears. This focusing on similarities, or saming, what Heng calls ‘recuperations of otherness’, works by domesticating ‘all otherness by narcissistically reproducing oneself, and the image of one’s culture, even while ostensibly speaking of otherness’.28 This concept wholly informs the work of the Bodley redactor. Iain Higgins argues that we should, in fact, ‘read The Book’s depictions of cultural and religious diversity as so many small mirrors in which “over there” at once differs from and resembles “over here”, and consequently both reflects and reflects critically on Christianity’.29 The text dwells on both difference and similarity, ‘using difference to reassert Christianity’s superiority, and similarity to expand Christendom in potentia’.30 These other cultures, these mirrors, offer distorted reflections that are nevertheless recognizable, and what they tend to reflect, as Fleck, Heng and Higgins all recognize, are proto-Christian societies. The construction of these societies in this carefully proto-Christian way, this process of saming, deals with foreign cultures by effectively ‘incorporating them into the fold of a vastly expanded, if also discontinuous and largely imagined, proto-Christian commu-
Encountering Africa
27
nity’.31 This, of course, makes it much easier to imagine and justify their eventual conversion and subjugation. As Heng argues, The Book’s conception of a world ‘made up of places where a Christian European subject might not feel wholly alien – might, indeed, feel at home because of religion – theorizes the possibility of relocation’.32 Indeed, she goes on to argue, the continual insertion of the familiar into every foreign society, ‘invites relocation: urges forth the directive to explore, expand, and even to settle. Identification with otherness, and participation in otherness, ultimately have the secondary effect of inviting the relocation of Europeans’.33 The Book of John Mandeville works precisely to invite this relocation, by suggesting to its audience that even the most remote strangers are, in the end, rather similar; Paul Strohm argues that ‘this confidence in ultimate sameness bolsters confidence in the possible conversion of the rest of the world’.34 Akbari concurs, suggesting that Mandeville creates ‘the image of a unified and harmonious world, shaped by the wisdom of its maker’.35 By constructing the Africans as both similar and dangerously different, Mandeville simultaneously suggests to his audience that they must be contained, and that they are similar enough to his audience, so that that containment can actually be accomplished. He suggests, in other words, a fairly radical idea at the time; that the savage Other is already partly contained within the Christian Self, and can thus more easily be incorporated into that Self.
2 NAMING THE OTHER, CLAIMING THE OTHER IN EARLY MODERN ACCOUNTS OF FIRST ENCOUNTERS: FROM MANDEVILLE TO JOHN NICHOLL (1607) AND RICHARD JOBSON (1623) Nicholas Myers and Ladan Niayesh
René Descartes considered that ‘travelling is almost the same as conversing with people from other centuries’.1 This quote underlines the extent to which an enterprise of discovery of new lands is a historical endeavour as much as it is a geographical one. Indeed, to discover a place which is distant in space seldom fails to amount for explorers to searching for a place that is also distant in time. This causes them to expect an encounter with a more ‘primitive’ culture by the standards of their own, or allot (more or less consciously) a new location to myths and legends of otherness pertaining to their own culture.2 Compared with and brought back to a better-known cultural reference, alterity can thereby be explained, classified and ultimately appropriated by travellers who view it, not with innocent eyes, but with selective ones, looking out for a confirmation of the beliefs and expectations with which they had set out on their journey. Likewise, armchair travellers reading their accounts back home often nurse the same double expectation vis-à-vis the narratives which they ‘explore’, insofar as they look both for the pleasure of novelty and a place for such novelty in their own framework of cultural assumptions. In this chapter, we intend to focus on names and naming as a locus for this encounter between selfhood and difference in early modern narratives of exploration. After a general introduction on the moral background of medieval taxonomy and its incidences on early discoveries, we will concentrate on the case studies of one narrative of American exploration, followed by one of African exploration. To the extent that culture can be defined as ‘an organized system of differences’,3 taxonomy and naming play a decisive role in any experience of apprehending otherness. The Adamic assumption that the name is the key to the – 29 –
30
British Narratives of Exploration
nature of things and beings presides over much of the pseudo-geographic and pre-ethnographic writings of the Middle Ages, of which Isidore of Seville’s Etymologies is a good example. As indicated by the treatise’s title, the Church Father makes extensive use of known etymologies to account for the distant marvels and monsters that he lists, harnessing and controlling otherness by linguistic means. Thus the Greek roots aith (meaning ‘burned’) and ops (meaning ‘face’) forming the word ‘Ethiop’ suggest to him that, for better or worse, the Ethiopians’ colour is the result of their close proximity to the sun, while they can indifferently be located in Africa or in India. In the same manner, the Cyclops (literally the ‘round-eyes’), the Cynocephali (‘dog-heads’), the Amazons (‘without breast’), the Hermaphrodites (a conflated version of the physical attributes of Hermes and Aphrodite) or the Anthropophagi (‘man-eaters’) can be diversely located or displaced at will, as long as they remain in the margins of the known world being, as they are, creatures of the extreme, both in their bodies and in their habitat.4 The appellations given to these and other monstrous races by Isidore and his predecessors (Ctesias, Pliny, Solinus, etc.) have no geographical basis, but are entirely dependent on physical appearance, diet and sexual practices. It follows that the monstrous races’ names make them figures for vices or, more rarely, for virtues in the didactic and moral – rather than properly speaking geographical – works in which they appear. Thus, for example, according to the Gesta Romanorum, a collection of pseudo-antique tales composed by an English Franciscan friar before 1342, the Blemmyes have their eyes and mouths in their breasts because they are humble, while the Panotii have big ears so as to better listen to the word of God; and the notoriously handsome Pygmies are a living testimony to how an enterprise that begins well may nevertheless be curtailed.5 In the highly didactic and moral geography of the Middle Ages, monstrous races stand true to the double etymology of the word ‘monster’, insofar as they serve to ‘show’ (monstrare) as well as to ‘warn’ (monere). Traces of this geography of dogma and imagination abound in medieval cartography, as well as in the works of medieval travellers and pseudo-travellers, such as Sir John Mandeville, who in his Travels frequently provides explanations for the mores of the inhabitants of the exotic lands he is supposed to have visited. Let us take as an example the curious ways of the Christian inhabitants of the Isle of Lamory. Those people go naked, Mandeville reports, ‘for they say that God made Adam and Eve all naked’, and they copulate freely because ‘they say that God commaunded to Adam and Eve and all that come of him saying: Crescite et multiplicamini et repleti terram’.6 The European discovery of the New World was to a large extent a rediscovery of this moralized medieval background in a new locale. This is how in 1522 Hernán Cortés sent to Charles V of Spain some bones supposedly belonging to Plinian Giants, while in 1540 Francesco de Orellana named the river Amazon
Naming the Other, Claiming the Other
31
after a European legend which he thought he had located in America. As for Walter Ralegh, he asserts the existence of Amazons and Blemmyes in Guiana, a discovery which makes him believe in the authenticity of Mandeville’s Travels at the surprisingly late date of 1596: Such a nation was written of by Mandeville, whose reports were held for fables many years, and yet since the Indies were discovered, we find his relations true of such things as heretofore were held incredible.7
Reportedly equipped with a volume of Mandeville’s Travels, Christopher Columbus did not just discover the New World, he also invented the term ‘Cannibal’, which became one of the chief stereotypes associated with America in the minds of its early travellers and settlers. A linguistic deformation of the name of a warlike native population, the Caribs or Canibs of whom the Admiral had heard during his first journey in the Lesser Antilles in 1492, the appellation made him formulate some Isidorian etymological hypotheses of his own. To him, ‘Can’ in ‘Canib’ appeared suggestive of canis, meaning ‘dog’ in Latin, which made Columbus suppose he had found the trace of the terrible Cynocephali of Plinian and Mandevillian fame in the islands he had just explored. Alternatively, he considered that ‘Can’ could stand for the Great Khan, whose kingdom he hoped to reach. As a result, his ‘Cannibal’ becomes a name haunted by many presences of diverse historical and geographical provenances, all of them equally ferocious, as in the following report made by Peter Martyr de Anghiera, who compiled the first account of the Columbian journeys: The wylde and myscheuous people called Canibales or Caribes, which were accustomed to eate mannes fleshe (and called of the olde writers, Anthropophagi) molest them [meaning the Arawaks] excedyngly, inuadynge theyr country, takynge them captiue, kyllyng and eatyng them.8
A geography which equates Caribbean natives with the Anthropophagi (legendary inhabitants of Mount Caucasus) is a geography that takes little account of the compass, mapping out a mindscape more than it does a landscape. This is how the term ‘cannibal’, despite its being originally derived from the name of an existing ethnic group, is gradually divested of its ethnicity, becoming first a noun and then an adjective that despite being associated with the New World frame, is not necessarily related to the native Caribs. Such is the case in the following excerpt, from Ralegh’s Discovery of Guiana, written nearly a century after Columbus’ discovery, and in which the term ‘cannibal’ appears as a synonym for man-eater and is applied to Europeans: The Spaniards to the end that none of the people in the passage towards Guiana or in Guiana itself might come to speech with us, persuaded all the nations, that we were man eaters, and Cannibals … 9
32
British Narratives of Exploration
What we have just said of the linguistic odyssey of the term ‘Cannibal’ could equally apply to a variety of other appellations, e.g. ‘Amazon’, which starts as a legend relocated in America, before becoming a descriptive noun, and eventually a chief stereotype associated with the American continent, and appearing alongside the charge of cannibalism in most of the allegorical representations of the New World. Associated together, the figures of the Amazon and of the Cannibal embody the same fear of a hungrily absorptive other, filling New World accounts with what Gaston Bachelard calls ‘the homeopathic function of terror’.10 More than referring to ethnic groups, such terms as ‘Amazon’, ‘Cannibal’ or simply ‘Savage’ name a fear or a fantasy, which makes them hover somewhere in the unstable zone separating the Self and the Other. To illustrate the ideological instability of such categories, we suggest we follow the linguistic odyssey of the term ‘Cannibal’ in the first known account of English presence in Saint Lucia, which is the unfortunate story of a shipwreck and ensuing hardships in a hostile environment, taking place in 1605. The account was written by John Nicholl (of whom little is known, except that he was one of the few survivors of the expedition) and published in 1607 under the title An Houre Glasse of Indian Newes. The full title of the work, appearing on the title page of its first and only known full edition, gives a summary of the adventures narrated therein: Houre Glasse of Indian Newes. OR A true and tragicall discourse, shewing the most lamentable miseries, and distressed Calamities indured by 67 Englishmen which were sent for a supply to the planting in Guiana in the yeare. 1605. Who not finding the saide place, were for want of victuall, left a-shore in Saint Lucia, an Island of Caniballs, or Men-eaters in the West-Indyes, vnder the Conduct of Captain Sen-Iohns, of all which said number; onely a 11. are supposed to be still liuing, whereof 4. are lately returnd into England. Written by Iohn Nicholl, one of the aforesaid Company.
This title page does not only provide us with a summary of the contents, but equally resorts to nomination in order to arouse an expectation and establish an interpretative pact. Here, ‘Saint Lucia’ appears half Spanish and half English, linguistically disputed between those two claimants long before the territory
Naming the Other, Claiming the Other
33
itself could become an object for dispute. Meanwhile its being defined as ‘an Island of Caniballs, or Men-eaters’ leaves us to wonder if ‘cannibal’ appears here in its ethnic sense (since the island is located right in the midst of the Caribbean Sea) or in its moral sense, as is suggested by the would-be synonym provided: ‘or Men-eaters’. The promised account of cannibalism in the West Indies appears as an answer to the other expectation aroused by this title page, i.e. the one contained in the term ‘Guiana’, a name evoking the ‘large, rich and bewtiful kingdome’ of Raleghan fame, referred to in the first pages of Nicholl’s narrative as ‘the great and mightie kingdome of Guiana’, ‘reputed to be the chiefest place for golde mines in all the West India’.11 Between them, the fear contained in ‘Cannibal’ and the fantasy contained in ‘Guiana’ epitomize the two sides – monstrous and marvellous – of the New World experience. Such a title undoubtedly leaves the reader to expect the unfortunate English sailors’ odyssey to be transformed into a ‘digestive odyssey’12 through the man-eaters’ entrails. But the author of the account surprises us by his repeated waverings between an expected cliché and the utterly different experience that he faithfully records. Witness the coup de théâtre taking place during the scene of the English crew’s first landing on the island: And so hauing beene seuenteene weekes at sea … we were brought to an Iland in the West India somewhat distant from the maine, called Santa Lucia … inhabited onely with a companie of most cruell Caniballs, and men-eaters, where we had no sooner anchored, but the Carebyes came in their Periagoes or Boats aboard vs with great store of Tobacco, Plantons, Potatoes, Pines, Sugar Canes, and diuerse other fruits, with Hens, Chickens, Turtles, & Guanas.13
We may note here the doubling of the appellation, ‘Caniball’ referring to the natives in their man-eating role, and ‘Carebye’ referring to them as traders selling wholesome food. The passage telescopes the two images around the same preoccupation with nourishment. As often in New World accounts, the good Indians and the savage Indians juxtaposed here are the same Indians, viewed differently. Treating them as if they were naked in their culture just as they were found naked in their bodies, such narratives project onto the natives their own fears and fantasies motivated by a hostile environment, thereby claiming, if not the natives themselves, at least what the natives could be made to represent. In Nicholl’s account, as well as in most accounts of early American discoveries, we do not find the natives’ point of view, only whatever point of view is attributed to them by the European mediator reporting the encounter and ventriloquizing the natives’ discourse. Witness the following passage, corresponding to the Europeans’ decision to leave the island as a result of deteriorating relationships with the Indians:
34
British Narratives of Exploration And wee concluded, rather then wee would stay and dye so miserably at the Carrabies hands, who thirsted for nothing but to eate our flesh, and drinke our blood, as they had done with many other of our fellowes, wee promised vnto the LORD . . . to betake our selues vnto his mercy, and doubted not but that hee would guide vs safely to some Christian Harbour.14
How can the narrator know whether or not the Caribs, whose language he does not speak, ‘thirst for nothing but to eate’ his flesh? Despite the assertion ‘as they had done with many other of our fellowes’, none of the English sailors of this account gets eaten by the natives. Here the pronoun ‘they’ becomes a generic appellation, reaching well beyond those particular natives, referring to a more or less fabricated savage type rather than to individuals actually encountered. In the words of Pierre Chaunu, ‘the Cannibal does not speak of himself, he speaks only of us; the Cannibal is us’.15 Significantly enough, an account which capitalized on fears of native cannibalism finally materializes those fears among Europeans alone as, stranded on another island with no provisions left, they consider that possibility and come very close to actually practising it, before their final rescue by the Spaniards. Coming nowhere close to claiming either native land or natives themselves, the English sailors of this account seem to have claimed and appropriated only an appellation, ‘cannibal’, an accusation which comes from them and eventually returns to them and them alone. ‘I is an other’, Arthur Rimbaud wrote in a famous letter to George Izambard.16 Considering this and such like fear-stricken, fantasy-laden accounts of American encounters in which the natives are ultimately either forgotten or flattened out into a stereotype produced by and for Europeans, this formula might be aptly reversed into ‘The other is an I’. But could the same phenomenon be reproduced closer to home and in a better-known cultural frame? This is the question to which we shall turn our attention now, by examining a narrative of a first encounter in Africa, The Golden Trade, originally published in 1623, by one Richard Jobson.17 Jobson describes his voyages to Ethiopia and the Gambia River during 1620– 1. About the man himself, very little is known. The references to Ireland in his account, some of which show a fairly detailed knowledge of conditions there, may indicate that he was the Jobson who worked for the Lord Admiral of Ireland years before, but this is not certain. This development will be limited to two aspects of the work – the ethnic divisions in the area he visited and the question of religion – since we argue that they bring to the fore the interpretative difficulties which the observing gaze itself is subject to in encounters with cultural material which is recalcitrant to assimilation into known cognitive frameworks. The exact title of his piece is The Golden Trade, or A Discovery of the River Gambra, and the Golden Trade of the Aethiopians. This last term, it will be
Naming the Other, Claiming the Other
35
remembered, had been used in the vaguest way for centuries to refer to an area stretching right across northern Africa. The river Gambia in effect cuts Senegal in half and gave its name to the country which was, much later, formally colonized by the British. Although Jobson’s account took book form, and was published two years later in an abridged version by the compiler Samuel Purchas, it was ostensibly addressed to the gentlemen and merchant adventurers who had founded the Guinea Company. Thus its intention, like much travel writing of the period, is exhortative, to encourage the Company’s investors to continue to finance exploratory voyages of just the sort that Jobson had led in 1620–1. The ‘gold’ of the title turned out to be very elusive. When he was far upriver the author heard from a Mandinga trader of a town in which the houses were said to be covered with gold, but this is of course exactly the kind of fabulation that merchant adventurers commonly used as leverage with their backing investors. In any case, Jobson came back with very little. What is certain is that Jobson gives the most detailed account in English or indeed any other language of the ethnic communities along the Gambia in the early modern period. Appearing well on into the seventeenth century as it does, however, the question arises as to what extent Jobson’s narrative concerns a first encounter in the pristine sense of the term. Strictly speaking, it is nothing of the kind: the Portuguese had been trading up and down the coast of West Africa since the middle of the fifteenth century. Indeed, a mulatto race of Afro-Portuguese, whom we shall come back to, had long lived in scattered communities alongside the indigenous ones. The English themselves had sent the first tentative expeditions to Senegal in the 1550s. However, upriver it was a different situation, and Jobson is at pains to claim that his party formed the first white people that upriver Africans had encountered. Notwithstanding this, the shock of cultures in evidence here must be sharply distinguished from the experience of the Americas. The issue of the effective enslavement of indigenous communities in the New World, which famously generated enormous theological and political debate, particularly in Spain, was not an issue in Africa, insofar as it was a pre-existing fact of life. Indeed, although Jobson was not in the Gambia to take part in the slave trade, and explicitly refused it, African traders he encountered made it clear that slaves would have been the most precious commodity he could have offered them, along with the salt which he did profitably barter. It cannot be said that Jobson claims anything as a possession by naming it, certainly not in the way that Columbus and the conquistadors who accompanied Cortés and Pisarro did. From a cultural perspective, though, the interest of Jobson’s account lies precisely in the mishearings and misreadings which characterize it and effectively give his efforts to interpret what he observes a shifting, trial-and-error feel. Culture, as much as Nature, abhors a vacuum: when Jobson’s knowledge of local conditions, whether concerning language, culture or religion, comes up short, as
36
British Narratives of Exploration
it frequently does, exegesis rushes in to attempt to make something out of nothing – transparency out of opaqueness – and effectively ‘domesticate’ strangeness for his readers. At certain points his account is coloured with what might be termed an irony of stance, the irony of assuming oneself to represent the norm, and in fact being a stranger in a strange land, and this is no less true for the fact that Jobson himself is only uneasily aware of it. An instance of this is the episode in which he has to strip off and get into the water because the Mandingas whom he had hired as rowers flatly refuse to do so, for fear of the crocodiles. Seeing his example, and survival, they consult together and decide to follow him in at the next difficult passage in the river. When he asks them to explain their change of heart, he learns to his surprise that they had reasoned that, as they put it, ‘the white man shine more in the water … and therefore if Bumbo come, he would surely take us first’.18 The narrative immediately places the requisite distance between their reasoning and his by assuring the reader that at no point was any member of his party, black or white, attacked by crocodiles. Partly, this is self-representation by Jobson as a sort of prototype of the unflappable Englishman abroad, but more importantly, it immediately re-establishes the proper hierarchy of rationalities, if not a simple mutually exclusive opposition: pragmatic rationality against unreason and superstition. Yet – and this is the irony – what the narrative unwittingly highlights is that here he is confronted with his own strangeness. His skin makes him singular and even monstrous in this landscape. The problem of nomenclature is common to all travel narratives, of course, and Jobson’s is no exception. The river itself, he notes, is variously referred to as Gamba, Gambia, and Gambra; but what is most disorienting for the mental habits of taxonomy and classification that Jobson represents is the fact that most of the indigenous populations do not denote it by a name at all, but simply by the common noun, gee used for all types of river. Problems of description extend to the various ethnic communities. Jobson’s party encounters three distinct ethnic groups. The Mandingos, dominant in the area, who are referred to interchangeably as Blackmen or Ethiopians; the Fulbe, herders who are described as being ‘a tawny people’, resembling ‘Egiptians’ (that is, gypsies); and the mainly mulatto Afro-Portuguese, referred to as ‘Portingales’.19 This last group emerges as particularly unplaceable in its cultural identity and practices. A number of years after Jobson’s journey, a French traveller known as the Sieur de la Courbe confirmed his judgement on this point, commenting that ‘most of them say neither Christian nor Muslim prayers, and others say both’.20 Their failure to observe the proper liturgical boundaries is taken by Jobson to be symptomatic of a general treacherousness characterizing them, and it is clear that he finds it easier to respect the steadfast, if mistaken, piousness of the Muslims.
Naming the Other, Claiming the Other
37
Towards the herding Fulbe, Jobson exhibits a measure of sympathy for a group whom he considers to be exploited by the Mandingo, tempered in a complex way by revulsion for their bestiality. He notes, for instance, that they do not even bother to whisk away the flies which swarm thickly over them. An important implication lies behind the apparently insignificant detail: husbandry, for Jobson, far from leading to assimilation between man and beast, as here, emphasizes the unbridgeable distance between the two in the society he comes from. On the other hand, in a passage in which he describes bartering with the Fulbe women for their dairy products on the river bank, he compares their standards of cleanliness to those of the Irish, who, he claims, follow very much the same way of life. And the comparison is much to the latter’s disadvantage. Of course, such exemplary even-handedness towards an indigenous African community must also be read as a judgement on the completely irrecuperable nature of the Catholic Irish who remained, for the incipient imperial project of Elizabethan and Jacobean England, perhaps the most recalcitrantly ‘barbarous’ of colonized subjects, representing a direct threat for the Crown and English Protestantism in a way that no other colonized subjects did. It is in his encounter with the local forms of Islam that the weak points in Jobson’s frame of reference, and his attempts to shore them up, are most evident. Displaying a degree of ignorance that is surprising, even for a European, he appears to assume that familiarity with figures such as Eve, Moses and David indicates acquaintance with the Old Testament, whereas of course they are mentioned in the Koran. The marabouts, familiarized for his English readership as ‘Mary-buckes’, he considers as priests, although at this period it is more accurate to think of them as lay scholars of Islam, who were dedicated to spreading their faith, certainly, but who also doubled as traders in the mid-river area. The Arabic scripts which he saw he takes to resemble Hebrew. Naturally, Jobson uses the only cultural categories he has to hand. Anthony Pagden has analysed the extent to which, in the New World especially, the problem of recognition, which entailed a very rough procedure of analogy from the new to the old, was simply blind to local particularities.21 A particularly flagrant instance of this is to be found in the episode in which Jobson attempts to describe a marabout at prayer, in which he claims that he faces east initially but then turns west.22 Of course, all such distortions are recuperated and diminished within the providentialist framework which, in more than one sense, authorizes Jobson’s presence. In discussion with the marabouts he learns that, for Islam, Christ is recognized as a nabi – a great prophet – but notes also the Muslims’ scepticism as to His being the son of God. Serenely, he records their admiration of the superior technology of the visitors as evidenced in the ocean-going vessels and navigational skills which had brought them there. Without its being said in so many words, he leaves the reader to conclude that these are signs of God’s special
38
British Narratives of Exploration
favour, recognized as such even by the as-yet unconverted. For that is how he sees them: Thus like humaine creatures in darknesse they argue, being barred from that glorious light, which shines in the east, whereof though they have heard, they have not yet made use but no doubt when the fulnesse of time is come they shall; for amongst themselves a prophesy remains, that they shall be subdued, and remaine subject to a white people: and what know we, but that determinate time of God is at hand, and that it shall be his Almighty pleasure, to make our nation his instruments, whereof in my part I am strongly comforted in regard of the familiar conversation … and the faire acceptance I received.23
If it is a truism that much travel writing is characterized by an anxiety to maintain proper thresholds between the civilized, as localized in the Self, and the barbaric, as exhibited by the Other, it is equally true that the ambivalence of such narratives arises from the tension between repulsion and fascination, the felt-yet-resisted temptation to allow the boundary of the Self ’s cultural identity to dissolve as one is sucked into the vortex of the unknown that the Other represents. Marlow’s familiar remark in Heart of Darkness about taking the earth away from those who have flatter noses not being a pretty thing unless it be redeemed by ‘the idea’ is pertinent here. What Conrad calls ‘idea’, we would probably now call the ideology which underwrites appropriation. In our analysis of accounts of first encounters in both the Caribbean and West Africa we have sought not only to demonstrate that ideology is the sustaining pillar in the observer’s construct of the Other, but also to touch on a few nodal points of manifest uneasiness and ambiguity in the process of naming that demonstrate the tensions to which that pillar is subjected.
3 FALSE PLAY AND DUMB SHOW IN THE WORLD ENCOMPASSED BY SIR FRANCIS DRAKE (1628) Sophie Lemercier-Goddard
When at the end of The Tempest Prospero is asked to tell his former enemies of his preservation on his strange island, he dismisses their request as untimely but provides instead a ‘wonder’1 to content them: the sight of Ferdinand and Miranda’s false play at chess, with the two characters looking at the company gazing at them, their own eyes similarly caught in a wonderful vision. The discourse of ‘wonder’ is an essential element of travel narratives: it marks the encounter with difference, when in the course of a long journey the Self comes across the Other. The narrative which results from such encounters purposes to tell readers at home about different people and exotic places, and above all to make them experience astonishment or admiration. In The World Encompassed by Sir Francis Drake (1628), which relates the circumnavigation accomplished by Sir Francis Drake between 1577 and 1580, the rhetoric of the wonderful is particularly needed, as the navigator can hardly boast of any major discovery at the end of his three-year voyage. When he returns to Plymouth Harbour in September 1580, Drake may be the first Englishman in history to have sailed around the earth, but he comes second to Magellan, whose men had accomplished the first circumnavigation more than half a century earlier (1519–22), entering what they called the Mar Pacifico, i.e. the Pacific Ocean, from the ‘Strait of Magellan’, which the Portuguese explorer discovered in 1520. Though difficult to navigate, this route, sheltered by mainland South America and the Tierra Del Fuego archipelago, is still safer than the ‘Drake Passage’, which the Englishman discovered after passing through the Strait, and where one of his three remaining ships was lost far South (September 1578) while another was forced to turn back to England. Throughout his journey, the English navigator follows in the steps of the Spanish, or the Portuguese. The text published in 1628 is the first comprehensive account of the voyage, although it should always be kept in mind that its author is not Francis Drake – 39 –
40
British Narratives of Exploration
himself, but the navigator’s nephew, also named Francis Drake (1573–1634), who plays on his homonymy in his title, The World Encompassed by Sir Francis Drake, to suggest falsely that his compilation is the firsthand account of his famous uncle. Unlike Columbus before him, or Pigafetta, the diarist of Magellan’s voyage, Drake failed to publish the tale of his adventures immediately after his return. The continuous plundering of Spanish ports and vessels along the coast of South America probably explains the lack of publicity given to his otherwise remarkable achievement. For though the number of men who came home safe and sound was never specified, Drake’s company fared much better than their predecessors: out of the 270 men who had left Spain with Magellan in August 1519, only eighteen had survived the expedition. A short account of Drake’s circumnavigation had first been published in 1589 in Richard Hakluyt’s Principall Navigations, in the form of twelve unnumbered pages, a late addition to Hakluyt’s anthology which may have reflected Drake’s sudden renewal of favour at Court after his successful participation in the defeat of the Great Armada in 1588. Drake’s ‘Famous Voyage’ had then been inserted in the second edition of Hakluyt’s Navigations in 1600, and an almost identical version had again been published in 1625 by Hakluyt’s successor, Samuel Purchas, in Purchas his Pilgrimes. I argue that, given its unusually late publication for a travel narrative, the 1628 text – again, a compilation of Hakluyt’s text, incomplete diaries and various reports, edited by Drake’s nephew – uses the discourse of wonder to make up for the delayed presentation of events which had taken place fifty years earlier. The wonderful is also part of a legitimation process, toning down the mercantile objectives of the voyage, presenting instead a geographical survey of the globe, backed up with an anthropological and religious dimension. After a century of expeditions to the New World, Drake’s voyage thus proposes to redefine the category of the Other, ranging from the similar and yet monstrously abject other, to the wonderfully different ‘alter ego’. A close reading of the account shows that towards the end of their journey, when the English company come across the Indians of North California, meeting the Other in fact implies a new communicational strategy. I show that the discourse of wonder, based on dumb shows – to be understood here both as sign language and false play – leads to an apparent communion between Self and Other, a supposedly intimate fellowship which binds the two parties through faith, while enacting the sharing and eventually the translation of the Indians’lands and possessions. As Steven Greenblatt argues, the style of travel narratives combines the simplicity of a monotonous prose and the production of wonder thanks to a deliberate rhetorical strategy: the ‘realist’ streak guarantees the authenticity of the events related by non-professional writers, while the ‘wonderful’, or ‘marvellous’, sustains the interest of the reader, thus providing ‘an aesthetic response in
False Play and Dumb Show in The World Encompassed by Sir Francis Drake
41
the service of a legitimation process’.2 In the 1628 edition of The World Encompassed, the flat description of the travellers’ progress is punctuated by the insistent repetition of the adjectives ‘wonderful’ or ‘marvellous’. However, such adjectives are found less as symptoms of the exotic than as generic markers: for instance, they serve to qualify the long, eventless crossing of the ocean, ‘the vast gulph, where nothing but sea beneath us and aire above us was to be seene, as our eies did behold the wonderfull workes of God in his creatures’;3 or conversely, they come into play to undermine the violence of some of the first encounters with the Indians on the Peruvian coast: ‘The General himself was shot in the face, under his right eye, and close by his nose, the arrow piercing a marvellous way in, under basis cerebri’.4 Hostile action which might have imperilled the whole voyage – and actually cost the life of two men – becomes a ‘wonderful’ scene in its own right. As a point of fact, the whole world is made to appear ‘wonderful’. When they sail across the equator, Drake’s men enter a land of plenty where resources are not only abundant but easily gathered, with birds or fish landing naturally on deck. The world is turned upside down, and a reverse logic seems to prevail. Mogador, off the coast of Morocco, the first sight of land after the company’s departure from England, already signals a shift to a world of deceiving appearances: the Moors welcome the navigators in a very friendly way, but soon prove to be deceitful when they seize one of the Englishmen unawares. The natural kingdom also seems to be upside down, as when flying fish are spotted.5 Dainty and wholesome fruit is found in January on the northern coast of Africa, but in summer, on the western coast of America, the travellers find a squalid and barren country which they call ‘the frozen zone’.6 The face of the earth thus appears to be ‘deformed’: ‘Besides how unhandsome and deformed appeared the face of the earth itself ! Showing trees without leaves, and the ground without greenes in those months of June and July’.7 As a consequence, economic rules seem to have been turned upside down as well. Men and women are bought like merchandise, while water is sold to the natives of Cape Blank at a very high price, in containers meant for liquor.8 On the western coast of South America, Drake’s men even discover that it is easier to find gold than fresh water: they lighted on a Spaniard who lay asleep and had lying by him 13 barres of silver, weighing in all about 4000 Spanish ducats … Our search for water still continuing, as we landed again not farre from thence, we met a Spaniard with an Indian boy, driving 8 lambs or Peruvian sheep: each sheep bore two leathern bags, and in each bag was 50 pound weight of refined silver, in the whole, 800 weight.9
The English later come across a Portuguese ship laden with ‘fruit, conserves, sugars, meal and other victuals, and (that which was the especial cause of her
42
British Narratives of Exploration
heavy and slow sailing) a certaine quantitie of jewels and precious stones, 13 chests of rials of plate, 80 pound weight in gold, 26 tons of uncoyned silver’, but they are still searching for ‘some convenient place, wherein to trim our ship, and store ourselves with wood and water and other provisions as we could get’.10 Such lines also suggest to what extent even the traditional economy of plundering is revisited by the discourse of wonder. Within two weeks of their arrival off the coast of North Africa, Elizabeth’s privateers had already seized three Spanish fishing boats and two caravels. But Drake’s men do not seize or chase Spanish or Portuguese ships; they simply find, take or meet them. The 1628 text thus systematically erases all the traces of the violent colonial competition between the European nations which the first account of the voyage in 1589 had underscored. Suffice it to compare the two following accounts of the same event: Being before this Island, wee espied two ships under sayle, to the one of which wee gave chase, and in the end boorded her with a ship boate without resistance which we found to be a good Prize.11 On the South-west of this Iland [St Iago] we tooke a Portugall laden the best part with wine, and much good cloth, both linnen and woollen, besides other necessaries, bound for Brazill, with many gentlemen and Marchants in her.12
The rhetoric of the wonderful serves still another purpose, since it also manages to root the text in a Christian perspective. The first sight of land after leaving Plymouth is Cape Cantine in Barbary and, as the text is very careful to underline, it occurs on 25 December. The name ‘Barbary’ seems henceforth to be taken to mean the site of ‘barbarity’, and the allegorical dimension of Drake’s relation of events clearly emerges, for instance, when the travellers go ashore to find doves assaulted by hawks and ‘such like birds of prey’, or when south of the island they spot great stores of ‘very wholesome but very ugly fish to look to’.13 The strange coincidence of the Christian calendar and of the materialization of Muslim territory thus functions as a filtering grid for Drake’s perception of the coastal regions of North Africa, inciting readers to inscribe his voyage within a Christian pattern, and therefore to bestow upon his men some kind of divine ‘mission’. This is later confirmed by the interpretation the text makes of the date of Drake’s return to England: And the 26. of Sept. (which was Monday in the just and ordinary reckoning of those that had stayed at home in one place or countrie, but in our computation was the Lords day or Sonday) we safely with joyfull minds and thankfull hearts to God, arrived at Plimoth, the place of our first setting forth.14
The difference between the travellers’ calendar and that of their fellow citizens evinces the discrepancy between the manifest purpose of the voyage – Drake brings back enough treasure to pay off the entire national debt, and the Queen
False Play and Dumb Show in The World Encompassed by Sir Francis Drake
43
knights him – and its supposedly concealed religious motives, as if the booty the pirates are bringing home were only meant as a cover-up for the missionaries’ spiritual agenda. One may very well argue that Drake’s arrival in the New World is marked by a similar example of Christian symbolism. Out of the five ships that make up the English fleet, the Pelican, the Elizabeth, the Marigold, the Swan and the Christopher, it is the latter, literally the ‘Christ-bearer’, which gets lost when they come in sight of the Brazilian coast. The fleet is immediately spotted by the Indians who light what the English crew take to be sacrificial fires. The Christopher is found again nine days later – only to be severed from the rest of the fleet a second time three weeks later – and the temporary loss of such an aptly named ship seems to suggest that the Indian fires were not meant to protect the natives from the Europeans as potential invaders, but rather to emphasize both the tragic fate of the heathen tribes and the arrival of the English as the coming of Christianity to America. But this sense of wonder is not limited to the rhetorical devices or religious topoi used in Drake’s description of the New World. It is presented from the very outset as the very purpose of the expedition, except that the English do not start with the ambition to see the wonders of the world, or to admire unknown lands and their strange inhabitants; Drake and his men set on their journey with the objective of becoming themselves objects of admiration. As the narrator of The World Encompassed explains: Neither had [Francis Drake] omitted to make provision for ornament and delight, expert musicians, rich furniture … and divers shows of all sorts of curious workmanship, wherby the civilitie and magnificence of his native country, might amongst all nations whithersoever he should come, be the more admired.15
This reversed feeling of wonder may call to mind a famous drawing, ‘America’ (c. 1575), by Jan Van der Straet, better known as Johannes Stradanus, a Flemish painter. Stradanus describes the Florentine navigator Amerigo Vespucci – whose transatlantic trips to the New World at the very end of the fifteenth century had inspired cartographer Martin Waldseemüller to label the new continent after Vespucci’s Christian name – as he sets on the shores of ‘America’. The drawing is intensely allegorical, Vespucci being represented as engaged in a ritual of interaction with a naked feminine figure named ‘America’. Strangely enough, Vespucci’s composed gaze and self-assured countenance are met by what looks to us more like a look of wonder on America’s part, than a possible gesture of apprehension:16 the naked allegory looks at the intruder with parted lips, and she holds up her hand not in a defensive way, but as if she were about to touch the explorer and test his reality. Of course, the feeling of wonder is more often than not generated by natural elements, rather than by the people encountered: the lush vegetation on Mucho
44
British Narratives of Exploration
Island off the Chilean coast anticipates further and greater riches (‘besides … it is thought to be wonderfull rich in gold’);17 mountains in Tierra del Fuego are ‘of so rare a height, as they may well be accounted amongst the wonders of the world’.18 Once natural resources have been listed, however, the description of the inhabitants follows, usually pointing out the natives’ ‘comely’ proportions and harmless disposition, as if it were of the greatest importance that the discourse of wonder be reserved either for the natural beauties of the New World, or for the English gentlemen themselves.19 Even the Indians’ partial nakedness and the widespread custom of body painting are seen not as tokens of otherness, but as familiar signs recalling the otherness of those other strangers at home, women: ‘some paint their whole bodies black, leaving onely their neckes behind and before white, much like our damosels that weare their squares, their neckes and breasts naked’.20 Resemblance, more than difference, is emphasized by the narrative, which therefore derides the fiction of the giants of Patagonia described by Magellan: ‘they are nothing so monstrous, or giantlike as they are reported’.21 On the northern Californian coast where they settle for a month, in a place they name ‘Nova Albion’, the travellers note the patriarchal organization of Indian society, and they underscore the pliant characters of the women, ‘very obedient to their husbands, and exceeding ready in all their services; yet of themselves offring to do nothing, without the consents or being called of the men’.22 As a consequence, the English do not hesitate to present themselves as the Indians’ ‘friends’.23 The Other is indeed less the Indian than the Portuguese or the Spanish, whose colonial influence in America is harshly indicted for having subjected the natives to the ‘most miserable bondage and slavery’.24 Whenever the English undergo an attack, as at Cyppo, on the Chilean coast, the text is anxious to draw a distinction between the innocent Indians and their Spanish tormentors: [One Englishman] whose dead body being drawn by the Indians from the rock to the shore, was there manfully by the Spaniards beheaded, the right hand cut off, the heart plucked out, all which they carried away in our sight.25
The Spaniards are also denounced for their ‘most filthie and loathsome manner of living … wherein (amongst other the like Spanish virtues) not only whoredom, but the filthiness of Sodom, not to be named among Christians, is not common without reproof ’.26 Particular emphasis is laid on their cruelty when dealing with the Indians: [The Spanish] suppose they show the wretches great favour when they do not for their pleasures whip them with cords, and day by day, drop their naked bodies with burning bacon: which is one of the least cruelties, amongst many, which they universally use against that Nation and people.27
False Play and Dumb Show in The World Encompassed by Sir Francis Drake
45
The fried bacon is a potent symbol, which reverses the traditional accusation of cannibalism associated with the American Indians. No instance of anthropophagy is ever recorded in Drake’s narrative; nor is it completely wiped out from the text. A generic feature of white colonist fiction of the Other,28 hints of cannibalism are in fact displaced: by suggesting that the Spaniards break down the frontier between pork meat and human flesh, the text turns the European Catholics into the true barbarians. The construction of the Indian as alter ego of the Protestant gentleman goes hand in hand therefore with an ‘otherization’ of the monstrous Catholic. The expedition does not only serve thus the political interests of England; more importantly, the text suggests that English colonization is needed to save the souls of the Indians, whose fine bodies are a clear sign of divine election: They have cleane, comely and strong bodies: they are swift of foot, and seem very active. Neither is anything more lamentable … than that so goodly a people, and so lively creatures of God, should bee ignorant of the true and living God … having in truth a land sufficient to recompence any Christian Prince in the world, for the whole travell and labour, cost and charges bestowed in that behalfe: with a wonderfull enlarging of kingdome, besides the glory of God by encreasing of the Church of Christ.29
Drake does not pose as a conqueror ready to take the riches of the land, but as a true Christian ambassador, whose efforts can only be rewarded by the gratefulness of the natives. But although the Indian other may be a ‘friend’, he is hardly a fully recognized alter ego, or an equal. Whenever a meeting is planned between the Indians and their visitors, men are exchanged as a pledge to guarantee the safe return of their fellow countrymen. The same equation always applies, with one Englishman standing for two natives. In Mogador already, two Moors had come onboard while one Englishman had been left on land as a pledge of their return. Non-Europeans, however, do not uniformly arouse the same benevolence as that induced by the Indians. The Moors encountered along the northern coast of Africa are descried for their inhuman manners: ‘in eating … their manner was not only uncivil and unsightly to us, but even inhumane and loathsome in itself ’.30 Not only are the Moors presented as different, but the balanced syntax which yet seems to posit cultural relativism and anthropological neutrality (‘uncivil and unsightly to us’) fails to produce anything but a fundamentally alien category (‘inhumane and loathsome in itself’). No attempt is made here to look at the Other with an unbiased eye, unaffected by cultural or moral prejudice. The discrepancy between the white man’s benevolent discourse on Native Americans and his scornful indifference to the Moors therefore alerts us to the nature of Drake’s ideological posture: it is easier and more profitable to be the
46
British Narratives of Exploration
champion of human rights where lands are still waiting to be claimed, rather than in the Old World where the domination of the Spanish and Portuguese is already complete. Having redefined both the Indians as victimized alter egos and themselves as benevolent saviours, the English travellers seek to promote further encounters in the hope of developing trade. Communication between the explorers and the natives always proceeds along the same three successive steps. The two parties first establish contact by exchanging visual or oral signs, as on Mogador Island, when Moors ‘by signs and cries made show that they desired to be fetched aboard’.31 Once contact has been made, objects are exchanged. The third stage is that of verbal communication. Each step presents its own difficulties, but contrary to all expectations, it is the third and final stage, that of conversation, which proves to be the easiest mode of interaction. The sign language Europeans and American Indians develop is quite elaborate. Some signs can have ambivalent or even opposed meanings. For instance, a fire can be a worrying sign, a ‘sacrifice to devills’, designed to wreak havoc among the English fleet when they are lit by Indians along the coast of Brazil;32 or it can be just the opposite, a friendly beacon, for instance when, a month later, Drake goes ashore and lights fires in the hope of retrieving his missing ships, the Christopher and the Marigold.33 The encounter which takes place with an Indian South of Valparaiso attests to the complexity of this language: ‘we showed him, partly by signs, and partly by such things as we had, what things we needed, and would gladly received by his meanes, upon exchange of such things as he would desire’.34 Sign language includes mime and the presentation of objects which make up for words (a glass or a bottle may easily translate as ‘water’ for instance). But we reach here a further degree of subtlety, as objects do not necessarily stand for themselves, but for their opposites: ‘by such things as we had, what things we needed’. This first stage segues into a courteous conversation which curiously seems to be unhampered by linguistic difficulty: ‘So he offered himself to be our pilot to a place … where, by way of traffic, we might have at pleasure, both water, and those other things which we stood in need of. This offer our general very gladly received’.35 The English explorers seem to be fluent in sign language on both sides of the Atlantic, communicating with Moors or Indians alike. In their first encounter with non-Europeans, on Mogador Island, the English already show a remarkable command of this new language: They that came aboard were right courteously entertained, with a daintie banquet, and such gifts as they seemed to be most glad of, that they might thereby understand that his fleete came in peace and friendship … This offer they seemed most gladly to accept, and promised, the next day, to resort again, with such things as they had to exchange for ours.36
False Play and Dumb Show in The World Encompassed by Sir Francis Drake
47
Once on board, the exchange includes gifts, then mime (the verb ‘seem’ shows their guests reacting with signs of contentment, or joy), and ends with the promise to return the next day. Though here again we may imagine the Moors resorting to sign language to express their solemn arrangement (possibly with their hands on their hearts, or respectfully bowing with clasped hands?), the very notion of ‘promise’ – a performative utterance that cannot exist outside language – signals a shift to verbal communication. What the text fails to mention, however, is that a man who ‘had attained to some use of the tongue’ was also present on board, a detail which is recorded by Francis Fletcher, chaplain to the expedition, in his diary.37 The presence of the translator explains how some elementary conversation could complement the sign language and pantomime. By keeping silent about the presence of such a mediator, The World Encompassed gives the impression that the English and the Moors communicate in a natural and universal language; that they have the ability to understand one another beyond the language barrier, no longer miming but simply trusting the rhetoric of the body – gestures or voice inflections. Assuming that foreign words can almost naturally be turned into transparent signifiers, the narrative thus entertains the illusion that the discovery expedition is also a journey back in time, transporting Europeans into a ‘wonderful’, prelapsarian world, as if the curse of Babel could indeed be removed. The skirmish that follows this favourable first encounter confirms this interpretation. Though the two parties have agreed to meet the next day to exchange more commodities, the second meeting turns out to be an ambush in which an Englishman, one John Fry, is captured. Fletcher interestingly notes here that Fry happens to be the apprentice translator. Fletcher does not, however, conclude that Fry is kidnapped because of his economic value, but rather that his linguistic skills directly explain his rash behaviour: Fry ‘had attained to some use of the tongue (and therefore the bolder) did suddenly but unadvisedly leap out of the boat onshore’.38 In Fletcher’s account, linguistic translation is more of a liability, exposing men rather than helping them to communicate; bilingual literacy only impedes the natural communication which can exist between the Europeans and the natives. On Mucho Island, Drake’s first stop after sailing through the Strait of Magellan, the English fall into another ambush because of a single word. After agreeing to supply them with fresh water, the islanders suddenly turn against the visitors: The cause of this force and injurie by these Ilanders, was no other but the deadly hatred which they beare against their cruell enemies the Spaniards … And therefore … (suspecting us to bee Spaniards indeed, and that the rather, by occasion that though command was given to the contrary, some of our men in demanding water, used the Spanish word Aqua) sought some part of revenge against us.39
48
British Narratives of Exploration
In Drake’s narrative, Spanish words are for the English as many traps laid by their enemies, like the name given to the Pacific ocean, ‘called by some Mare pacificum, but proving to us rather to be Mare furiosum’.40 The name chosen by Magellan seems to be specifically designed to deceive the English navigators, as the three ships which make it through the Strait are carried off course by contrary winds and tempests for several weeks. This, and the incident on Mucho Island, only confirm the travellers’ distrust of words when they cease to be the transparent signifiers of some kind of natural language. Linguistic bilingualism is clearly not a prerequisite to communicate with the natives of the New World. The climactic episode of Nova Albion reveals then the full potential of this pre-Babel, both natural and ‘wonderful’ language. The navigators stop on the West American coast – somewhere in the San Francisco area –41 to trim their ships after an unsuccessful attempt to find the Northwest passage (they probably sailed as far north as the area that would become the United States–Canadian border). They befriend the local tribe, and this is where their dumb shows prove the most effective. For after a month of regular encounters, the Indians eventually relinquish all their rights to their land, and willingly offer their kingdom to Francis Drake, whom they greet as their new king. The first encounter gets off to a very good start. An Indian emissary is sent to welcome the visitors, delivering three successive orations, which though ‘long and tedious’, are the prelude to an offering of a feather headdress.42 The text insists on the feeling of wonder experienced by the Indians when they first see the English, ‘wondring at [them] as at Gods’, ‘as men ravished in their mindes’43 – though no precise description is given to substantiate this assertion. The godlike nature of the Europeans, a commonplace in travel accounts of the Americas since Columbus, Vespucci and later Cortés, is presented as a delusion, but the travellers, who at first are intent on freeing their Indian hosts from such a misconception, gradually seem to fully endorse their new identity, as is suggested by the subtle shift of meaning of the preposition ‘as’. Used first to draw a comparison, ‘as’ eventually indicates capacity and identity: ‘their errand being rather with submission and feare to worship us as gods’.44 During the third encounter, the Indians set up a strange ceremony in which the men, after another ‘long and tedious oration’, come to their visitors loaded with presents, while their women tear their flesh, cry and shriek ‘in a monstrous manner’.45 To put an end to what they think is a bloody sacrifice, Drake and his men respond with a religious ceremony of their own: This bloudie sacrifice (against our wils) beeing thus performed, our Generall with his companie in the presence of those strangers fell to prayers and by signes in lifting up our eyes and hands to heaven, signified unto them, that that God whom we did serve, and whom they ought to worship, was above.46
False Play and Dumb Show in The World Encompassed by Sir Francis Drake
49
The mechanical gesticulation is followed by the reading of chapters from the Bible and the singing of psalms, which are reverently listened to by the Indian audience: In the time of which prayers, singing of Psalmes … they sate very attentively: and observing the end at every pause, with one voice still cryed, Oh, greatly rejoycing in our exercises.47
In this strange pantomime, Christian devotion becomes a dumb show in which religious fervour is replaced by outward signs, meant to engage the attention of the Indians and divert them from their own practice. The new performance combines Indian and Christian rituals, as is the case with the exclamation ‘Oh’, earlier described as a common Indian response during their leaders’ orations. The Indians also use the word ‘Gnaàh, by which they entreated that we should sing’.48 This improvised spectacle shows not only the Englishman’s capacity for ‘empathy’, so typical according to Greenblatt of the Renaissance Western explorer, using improvisation and ‘psychic mobility’ as a tool of colonial power,49 but also Drake’s ability to rewrite the other’s ritual into his own scenario, predicated on the assumption of the possibility of immediate, transparent communication, unimpaired by linguistic difference. The success of this pantomime leads to a second ceremony, held within a week of the sailors’ arrival. The natives again deliver several long orations before renouncing their land: the king and divers others made severall orations, or rather indeed if wee had understood them, supplications, that [our General] would take the Province and kingdome into his hand, and become their king and patron: making signes that they would resigne unto him their right and title in the whole land, and become his vassals in themselves and their posterities: Which that they might make us indeed beleeve that it was their true meaning and intent; the king himselfe … set the crown upon his head … These things being so freely offered, our Generall thought not meet to reject or refuse the same … for that he knew not to what good end God had brought this to passe, or what honour and profit it might bring to our countrie in time to come.50
The phrase ‘if wee had understood them’ temporarily exposes the false play of the English dumb show: the hypothetical proposition unveils the linguistic incomprehension on both parts, while simultaneously transcending it since the sentence claims that linguistic competence is not needed, as the English fully comprehend the intentions of the Indians, and the crown set on Drake’s head comes only as a confirmation of the ritual. A combination of sign language and verbal communication based on the rhetoric of the body, the ‘natural’ language devised in the New World thus produces a colonial discourse of wonder: the Indians are represented as freely resigning their lands, their selves and their history to the representatives of the English sovereign’s nascent Empire – a scene
50
British Narratives of Exploration
reminiscent of Miranda’s acceptance of the false play of her sweet lord: ‘Yes, for a score of kingdoms you should wrangle,/ And I would call it, fair play’.51 Like Columbus before them, the English therefore take possession of Nova Albion thanks to a linguistic performance.52 A plaque is then erected to commemorate the transfer of authority, described as ‘a plate of brass, fast nailed to a great and firme post’, which presents the Queen’s portrait to her new subjects thanks to an English six-pence coin.53 To the English, the coin is to be taken literally, as the concrete sign of the commercial transaction, and it also functions as an assurance to future explorers that good bargains are there for the taking. Its meaning is also metaphorical, as it ceases to bear any monetary value to become the visual symbol of the distant political power it represents. Drake’s use of the Queen’s head, a simple representation of an absent reality endowed with quasi-magical powers, is emblematic of the ‘theatre of wonder’ which travel narratives gradually generated, giving priority to the body to produce the emotional and intellectual experience of wonder, at the expense of the natural wonders of the world.54 The six-pence coin, as a metaphorical and visual sign, but also as a literal joke which is lost on the Indians, thus clearly shows that the discursive economy of wonder is based on dumb show and false play. But false play is not only at the expense of the American Indians. No colonization project ensued, as the attempts at founding an American colony were soon to focus on the eastern coast of North America. And the plaque itself was never found, an absence casting serious doubt as to the reality of the whole episode. The dumb shows produced by the first encounters between the American natives and the English travellers thus reveal the complexity of interaction between the travellers themselves and their fellow countrymen at home. One should indeed guard against seeing the dumb show strategy as a onesided fooling of the native population: English culture was then marked by fears and misgivings, as much as by confidence, and all parties in these dramas were uncertain about the outcome of such relationships.55 As the visitors’ stay draws to a close, a final dumb show is organized: the Indians begin with their usual sacrifices, lighting fires, tormenting themselves, and Drake’s men, eager to stop this heathen practice, respond again with their own Christian pantomime. This time, the Indians follow suit and start replicating the Englishmen’s behaviour through a curious play of mimicry: ‘suffering the fire to go out, and imitating us in all our actions; they fell alifting up their eyes and hands to heaven as they saw us do’.56 The show of course delights the white man. But on the day of the English crew’s departure, the Indians take their farewell by lighting fires all along the coast. The World Encompassed does not linger on the episode to determine whether their mimicry had been false or fair play.
4 ‘WATERALI’ GOES NATIVE: DESCRIBING FIRST ENCOUNTERS IN SIR WALTER RALEGH’S THE DISCOVERY OF GUIANA (1596) Line Cottegnies
In a letter to his wife dated 14 November 1617 and written from the Cayenne river on his second ill-fated voyage of exploration in Guiana, Sir Walter Ralegh writes: ‘To tell you that I might be here King of the Indians were a vanitie; but my name hath still lived among them; here they feed me with fresh meat, and all that Countrey yields, all offer to obey me’.1 This was not a lie. In fact, travellers report that both the words ‘Waterali’ and ‘Gualtero’ are attested in the seventeenth century in local Amazonian dialects as honorific titles, enduring well into the eighteenth century.2 This extraordinary fact reveals the impact Ralegh made on political consciouness and oral traditions as early as his first 1595 expedition, and how, while he was dealing with what Lévi-Strauss would call ‘cold cultures’ – i.e. societies which do not possess a written culture – his own memory (or a shadow of it) was preserved through oral transmission. One of the purposes of this paper is to try and assess the significance of this incorporation of Ralegh’s name into local cultures, even though his exploration failed to advance the English presence in Guiana. In 1595, Ralegh promised the Indians he would be back with an army to free them from the Spaniards, but he had to delay his expedition until 1617, where divisions among the Indians and new skirmishes between the English and the Spaniards caused his men to set fire to a Spanish town – in direct contradiction with James I’s instructions. In the process, he lost his son Wat, and his trusted friend and captain Lawrence Keymis committed suicide. He sailed back to England only to be sent to the scaffold. In his edition of the 1596 Discovery of the Large, Rich, and Bewtiful Empyre of Guiana, Neil Whitehead describes the narrative as an ‘enchanted text’, whose magic appeal derives from its unique ‘blending of the factual and fictitious’,3 which might account for the enduring attention it has received over the years. Informed by the topoi and myths elaborated through the ‘fantastic ethnography’ of classical and modern authorities,4 The Discovery of Guiana also reflects – 51 –
52
British Narratives of Exploration
Ralegh’s precise knowledge of previous travellers’ accounts, mostly Spanish, which he lists at the end of his own text. Neil Whitehead confirms how carefully Ralegh’s ethnology is informed by his predecessors’ narratives. But he also reads the text as ‘proto-ethnography’, because more than is usually the case in these documents, it tells us about Ralegh’s empirical quest for a real dialogical encounter with local indigenous cultures and practices; in Whitehead’s words, it ‘strongly registers native culture’.5 This is manifest, for instance, in the place and status he grants the indigenes of Orinoco and their own discourse in the text, recording his various interviews with them, which leads to the hybridization of colonial discourse that Young describes in Colonial Desire.6 What Ralegh’s narrative eventually reveals is, in Whitehead’s words, the ‘symbiotic nature of cultural construction and the two-way, mutual character of cultural transmission, even from colonized to colonizer’.7 This essay will focus on Ralegh’s encounters with natives in their linguistic aspects, to show that while they are fraught with ideological and ethical anxieties, they also manifest a genuine desire to communicate with the Other, with all the ‘miscommunication’ this implies.8 As will be apparent, these encounters result in a kind of mutual ‘colonial mimicry’,9 whereby the colonial discourse accommodates (and is accommodated by) indigenous languages and practices. Intriguingly Ralegh consistently configures his meetings with the Indians as ‘first’ encounters with unspoilt natives – irrespective of the fact that the whole area had been in contact with the Spaniards for close to a century. This is more, it seems to me, than just a political stance aiming at somehow making up for the English absence in the area until then. It can be interpreted instead as a desire to symbolically recast these encounters as virgin of all previous associations, at a time when the Spanish settlement was meeting with increasing opposition among the local tribes. Ralegh’s text is in fact motivated entirely by its wish to undo and unwrite the Spaniards’ previous ‘discoveries’. The narrative is striking, for instance, for its permeability to and accommodation of vernacular toponyms and patronyms. In direct opposition to the Spaniards who usually renamed places and cities, baptized the Indians they befriended or employed, and gave them Christian, Spanish-sounding names, Ralegh tries to record the local names and toponyms, transcribing them phonetically. He does not take up Captain Keymis’s suggestion to rename the Orinoco River Raleana, after his own name,10 for instance. Through this, he shrewdly acknowledges the anteriority of the natives’ presence on the land, but also avoids using Spanish names altogether, thus occulting their having taken possession of the country. Throughout the text, Ralegh defines his conduct as systematically contrasting with the Spaniards’. For instance, like Drake before him, he insists on the Spanish cruelty to the natives, and pits it against the ‘temperance’ and ‘respect’ with which he and his crew treat them. His attitude to naming places and people is
‘Waterali’ Goes Native
53
part of the same strategy. Michel de Certeau, commenting on Theodor Galle’s engraving representing Vespucci and America, after the famous drawing by Jan van der Straet, writes: ‘what is initiated here is a colonization of the body by the discourse of power. That is writing that conquers’.11 Stephen Greenblatt has described how, for Columbus, ‘taking possession is principally the performance of a set of linguistic acts: declaring, witnessing, recording. The acts are public and official’.12 But it is the Spanish conquest at large that was carried out through a series of pragmatic, illocutionary procedures: the drafting of records, acts, deeds and precise maps, and then through massive campaigns of evangelization and schooling – including the teaching of the Spanish language. By recording native names in his text and drafting a map that includes Indian toponyms,13 Ralegh, who presents himself to the Indians as an official ambassador from the Queen, establishes a unique colonial bond between England and the tribes he meets, as he offers himself both as a liberator from the Spanish yoke and as a reportercum-transcriber of their reality. This he thought possible because of the identity of his translator and interpreter, an Indian whom he had brought from England, and with whom he seems to have established a close enough relationship that he felt communication with the natives could be transparent. Ralegh seems in fact to have developed strong friendships with several natives. It is perhaps not wholly surprising that he should have later been followed in the Tower by two Indian servants, named Ragapo and Harry, who, as tradition has it, seconded him in the kinds of ‘chemistry experiments’ that his contemporaries viewed with much suspicion – and which might have had something to do with coca.14 In a typical passage of his 1596 narrative where he details the brutal treatment of natives in the hands of the Spaniards, Ralegh even presents himself as a hero of the Indian cause, telling the reader how he delivered five ‘caciques’ – a local word which he appropriates and uses very freely in his text – whom he says ‘are called in their own language Acarewana’ – an actual Carib word for ‘King’; and he adds: ‘now of late since English, French, & Spanish are come among them, they cal [sic] themselves Capitaynes, because they perceive that the chiefest of every ship is called by that name’.15 This is a wonderful example of the reciprocal hybridization of discourse (or two-way mimicry) in the kind of colonial, discursive context Whitehead and Young describe: Ralegh appropriates an Indian word, ‘Cacique’, but he simultaneously gives us what turns out in fact to be an accurate transcription of a local title, attested by other sources. Meanwhile, the locals, inspired by the naval hierarchy of their invaders, reciprocally appropriate a European title (‘Capitaynes’), which they see as equivalent to theirs, although it is not clear if the word was used phonetically by the Indians or if this refers to the way the Europeans came to call the indigenous lords. This two-way process, I would like to claim, applies to most of the situations described by Ralegh, as his text focuses on mimetic, or what I call ‘transitive’, exchanges.
54
British Narratives of Exploration
Ralegh consistently offers a phonetic transcription of his interlocutors’ indigenous names, and this is an equivalent, in many respects, to cartography: it is not simply an ‘effet de réel’ to guarantee the veracity of his narrative in the eye of a disbelieving English reader. It is a means of drafting a living picture of the country at a given moment, fixing the forces present on the spot in the perspective of a further implanting of the English, since Ralegh is hoping at that stage for a prompt return – hence the stress on the garnering of information from all quarters: [O]f al these I got som knowledge, & of manie more, partly by mine own travel, & the rest by conference: of som one I lerned one, of others the rest, having with me an Indian that spake many languages, & that of Guiana naturally. I sought out al the aged men, & such as were greatest travelers. And by the one & the other I came to understand the situations, the rivers, the kingdoms from the east sea to the borders of Peru, & from Orenoque southward as far as Amazones or Maragnon, and the regions of Maria Tamball, and of all the kings of Provinces, and captains of townes and villages, how they stood in tearms of peace or war, and which were friends or enimies the one with the other, without which there can be neither entrance nor conquest in those parts, nor els where . . .16
This explains for instance why he transcribes the names of the captive Indian chiefs in full, as well as many other Indians’ names: ‘Those five Capitaynes in the chaine were called Wannawanare, Carroarori, Maquarima, Tarroopanama, & Aterima’.17 The litany of names again serves to emphasize the contrast with the Spaniards who are shown, on the contrary, to be set on obliterating the memory of the indigenous past by killing the elderly leaders, burning out villages, deporting the population and renaming young captives. We know they also burned many age-old Indian codeces throughout South America, in order to force the population to learn Spanish. In this context, Ralegh’s inclusion of native names could be read as a diplomatic act of recording the history of the vulnerable societies he was planning to save and rule. A similar strategy of mimicry is used by Ralegh when he impresses the Indians with the greatness of his Queen, describing her as ‘the great Casique of the north, and a virgin, and had more Caciqui under her then there were trees in their Iland … an enemy of the Castellani in respect of their tyrannie and oppression’.18 This the indigenes translate in their turn – and Ralegh’s attempt at transcribing this Indian version of Elizabeth’s title is extraordinary – as ‘Ezrabeta Cassipuna Aquerewana, which is as much as Elizabeth, the great princesse or greatest commaunder’.19 This instance shows Ralegh’s talent (or his interpreter’s, or both) at making himself mimetically comprehensible by the natives; but it also demonstrates, I think, how conscious Ralegh was of the symbolic import of name assimilation. The assimilation of his own name in a phonetic neologism
‘Waterali’ Goes Native
55
(‘Waterali’), although not mentioned in his own text, can be seen as part of the same strategy of ‘attuning’ English names to Indian ears. The ‘assimilation’ process always goes both ways with Ralegh, and he in turn records in his narrative the stories of various Indian chiefs with whom he has established a special relationship, above all the old Topiawari whom he meets twice during this trip. This in turn allows him to record the alleged ‘surrender’ of the Indians to the English. The scene of the first encounter with Topiawari is powerfully illustrated by a plate Theodore de Bry inserted in his 1599 Americae pars VIII, a volume which includes an abridged Latin version of Ralegh’s text adorned with seven plates.20 The image, reproduced in Whitehead’s edition,21 illustrates the scene of Ralegh’s reception of the chief under his own tent – a scene reminiscent of other diplomatic encounters, such as the famous meeting between Henry VIII and Francis I at the Field of the Cloth of Gold in 1520: we arrived at the port of Morequito, and ankored there, sending away one of our Pilots to seeke the king of Aromaia, uncle to Morequito, slaine by Berreo as aforesaide. The next day following, before noone he came to us on foote from his house, which was 14 English miles, (himself being a 110. yeers old) & returned on foote the same daie, & with him many of the borderers, with many women & children, that came to woonder at our nation, and to bring us down victuall, which they did in great plenty, as venison, porke, hens, chickens, foule, fish, with divers sorts of excellent fruits and rootes, & great abundance of Pinas, the princesse of fruits, that grow under the Sun, especially those of Guiana. … After this old king had rested a while in a little tent, that I caused to be set up, I began by my interpretor to discourse with him of the death of Morequito his predecessor, and afterward of the Spaniards …22
The illustration captures a wonderfully equivocal moment, which I would like to describe as expressing the transitivity of exchange that I have been pointing out: Ralegh, with his baton of commander, is obviously entertaining the chief in a courtly fashion, treating him as a foreign head of state by having him sit ‘in state’ next to him, under the canopy. The fact that they should be sitting on a stool and facing the audience is itself an European posture of power – the illustrator was obviously a very astute reader of Ralegh’s. But the scene becomes visually reversible, as the Chief is shown pointing out the offerings brought by his people, subtly inverting the perspective: the performance of hospitality is obviously Indian, and he seems to be entertaining the English, who are clearly shown as the recipients of his gifts. We can contrast the huddled English men – some, curiously, with Spanish helmets, probably spoils of war –, with their hands on their swords (strutting perhaps, or looking slightly nervous), and the group of confident, pacific natives with their arms full of gifts of food. The ambivalence of the moment is also captured by the unspecificity of the witnesses’ physical traits, as some of the natives are made to look very European, as is obvious, for instance, in the women’s headstyles. We can further note the similarities between the elabo-
56
British Narratives of Exploration
rate design of Ralegh’s costume and the chief ’s feathers, and the intimacy with which Ralegh’s arm and baton seem almost to rest on his neighbour’s arm: the picture perfectly illustrates the special relationship that Ralegh claims to have established with Topiawari. The background vignette illustrates another scene, however: the farewell scene between Ralegh (recognizable thanks to his sword), who is leaving for England again with the chief ’s son, as will be seen later. What is striking in this vignette is the absence of Ralegh’s soldiers: the scene concentrates instead on the singular relationship between Ralegh and the Indians, who are here featured as an ordered army, albeit with ‘native’ weapons: this is meant to illustrate the military alliance Ralegh claimed he had achieved with Topiawari against the Spaniards. The mature Ralegh obviously warmed to the old chief: at one point in his text he transcribes a long narrative of Topiawari’s – a unique moment which the anthropologist Neil Whitehead reads as an intense ethnographical transcript of an actual conversation. In this passage, Ralegh interprets the Indian’s tale as a historical narrative alluding to the invasion of the regions by Inca warriors in the previous century, while Whitehead has in fact recently deciphered it as a mythopoetic creation tale about the conflict between the spirits of water and of rain.23 However, the place and status granted Topiawari and his speech in Ralegh’s text is striking, all the more so as it ends with the Englishman’s expression of his admiration for the old man: This Topiawari is held for the proudest, and wisest of all the Orenoqueponi, and so he behaved himselfe towards me in all his answers at my returne, as I marvelled to finde a man of that gravity and judgement, and of so good discourse, that had no helpe of learning nor breed.24
A few pages later, he includes another long interview with Topiawari, in indirect speech, which ends on a striking moment of immediacy when Ralegh is caught literally transcribing the Chief ’s own words in direct speech in the first person – in a process of ventriloquization: [A]nd because said hee, they [the Spaniards] woulde the better displant me, if they cannot lay handes on mee, they have gotten a Nephew of mine called Eparacano, whome they have christened Don Juan, and his sonne Don Pedro, whome they have also apparrelled and armed, by whome they seeke to make a partie against mee in mine owne countrey …25
This second interview ends with a solemn alliance, and Ralegh’s promise to come back a year later with an army; it is then followed by a deeply symbolic exchange: [H]e freely gave me his onelie sonne to take with me into England … and I left with him one Frauncis Sparrow; a servant of captaine Gifford, (who was desirous to tarry,
‘Waterali’ Goes Native
57
and coulde describe a cuntrey with his pen) and a boy of mine called Hugh Goodwin, to learne the language.26
Ralegh thus returned to England with the Chief ’s son Cayoworaco, and, if we are to believe Whitehead, with the two servant boys who would later spend some time with him in the Tower.27 Once again, the difference between the Spaniards’ strategy of forced assimilation (implied in the renaming of the Chief ’s nephew and his son) and Ralegh’s assimilation of Indian names is striking. As was reported later, Francis Sparry (not ‘Sparrow’) was quickly captured by the Spaniards and Goodwin was attacked by four jaguars in the jungle – an episode which Whitehead explains anthropologically as having to do with a ritual killing; as far as the three Indians were concerned, they seem to have eventually found their way back to Guiana.28 The extraordinary moment of the ‘exchange of sons’ (‘a boy of mine’) is probably one of the most emblematic instances of the mimetic structure of exchange that I have underlined in the text. It also, incidentally, testifies to Ralegh’s deep understanding of the value of exchange in native societies, which has since then been amply documented by Marcel Mauss. In The Gift, Mauss showed how giving and exchanging were the basis of many primitive societies, and that the practice of exchanging was governed by a series of obligations that could be considered as the basis for a moral system. Interestingly, in the various rituals of exchange to which Ralegh partakes, he shows an acute awareness of these native obligations. This might be accounted for by the fact that Ralegh had perhaps carefully read his predecessors’ accounts, or that his translator was a good go-between, or because the economy of the gift in an aristocratic society was not so dissimilar. However, these obligations are: the obligation to receive gifts (which shows respect to the giver) and the obligation to give, and even to return gifts – which establishes the giver or the recipient of the gift as an honorable person, deserving respect. Most of the contacts with Indians ritually begin with gifts of food, which are highly symbolic of power, particularly when the country in unknown by one of the parties; but Ralegh is constantly shown to reciprocate, and he even knows to anticipate by giving first. At one point, he comes across a group of Arwacan natives, allies of the Spaniards, who are terrified by the English because they have been told that they are cannibals.29 Shrewdly, Ralegh gives them food and trinkets without demanding anything in return, which results in their defecting to the English. The anecdote points to a fascinating reversibility here: by participating in the local economy of giving, Ralegh enters into dialogue with native culture; but it is also clear that his strategy is not devoid of self-interested calculation, and the gifts of trinkets themselves reflect common colonial practices. With Topiawari, the practice of exchange even takes on the competitive and strategic aspect that Mauss describes and that finds its most extreme variant in the Potlatch – a north-west coast Native American form
58
British Narratives of Exploration
of competitive exchange that eventually leads to the destruction of costly gifts. In fact, Ralegh finds himself caught up in a spiral of conspicuous consumption, and he clearly ends up giving more than he receives: For I did not in any sort make my desire of golde knowen, because I had neyther time, nor power to have a greater quantitie. I gave among them manye more peeces of Golde then I receaved of the new money of 20. shillings with her Majesties picture to weare, with promise that they would become her servants thenceforth.30
In a society whose economy is based on exchange, coins become fetish-like gold medals, precious because they are rare gifts, while remaining instruments of colonial domination that allow the Queen’s portrait to be displayed and passed around. Interestingly, Ralegh expresses here the ambivalence of his colonial motivations, by contrasting his strategy of giving with the strategic dissimulation of his desire for gold. In his approach to the natives he appears constantly torn between mimetic sympathy and his colonial quest, the object of which is the gold of the Indians, a pursuit he is aware of sharing with the Spaniards: ‘we came both for one errant’.31 Nevertheless, his clever mimetic participation in the gift culture, which ultimately leads to the symbolic exchange of sons – and which his own son’s death will tragically echo twenty years later – can explain why his memory could live on, years after he had left. At the very end of his narrative, Ralegh reports an Inca prophecy which he has heard from his Spanish counterpart (and nemesis), the governor of Trinidad, Antonio Berrio. This prophecy heralds the restoration of Inca rule and the final victory of the English over the Spaniards in South America: And I farther remember that Berreo confessed to me and others (which I protest before the Majesty of God to be true) that there was found among prophecies in Peru (at such time as the Empyre was reduced to the Spanish obedience) in their chiefest temples, amongst divers others which foreshewed the losse of the said Empyre, that from Inglatierra those Ingas shoulde be againe in time to come restored, and delivered from the servitude of the said Conquerors.32
This ‘Peruvian’ prophecy seems to come to Ralegh as a sudden afterthought (‘I farther remember’), after he has already expanded his vision of an English empire rivalling the Spanish one. It very aptly serves his final plea for a full-scale English colonization of Guiana: The countrey is alreadie discovered, many nations won to her Majesties love & obedience, & those Spanyards which have latest and longest labored about the conquest, beaten out, discouraged and disgraced, which amonge these nations were thought invincible.33
By having his worst enemy report the prophecy, and by having him do so in public (‘Berreo confessed to me and others’), Ralegh hopes to convince his read-
‘Waterali’ Goes Native
59
ers, and foremost among them, Queen Elizabeth, to support further expeditions and settlements. But Ralegh’s anxiety about the extraordinarily apt status of the prophecy to bolster his case is clearly perceptible in his additional resort to a solemn asseveration: ‘which I protest before the Majesty of God to be true’. It could be argued that the Knight protests too much. The source of this ‘prophecy’ is unclear; it is most likely that Ralegh made it up. It does not feature in any of the histories of the Incas of the period. A prophecy that did feature in these histories, however, is another, more famous one, which Ralegh alludes to here: the supposedly age-old prophecy that foretold the fall of the Inca empire and was interpreted retrospectively as announcing, and justifying, the arrival of the Spaniards. In his popular 1607 history of the Incas, Comentarios reales de los Incas, the Inca-born Spanish writer Garcilaso de la Vega interviews an old chief about the fatalism of Inca leaders in the face of the Conquistadors: if the Incas relinquished all their power so easily to a handful of Spaniards, he is told, it is because of an old prophecy according to which ‘at a certain period of Years after the succession of such a number of Kings, there should come a sort of people from far remote Countries, never seen, or known before in those Regions, who should take away their Religion and subvert their Empire’.34 Garcilaso de la Vega shows how this prophecy, supposedly transmitted from generation to generation, was taken to be fulfilled by the coming of the Spaniards. It was even alleged to have caused one of the last Inca Kings, Huaynac Capac, to legate his Kingdom to the Spaniards.35 If the actual existence of the prophecy before the arrival of the Spaniards is dubious – although these kinds of prophecies were widespread in highly ritualized societies and oral cultures as ways of making sense of history – it is interesting here to see just how a political prophecy was put to use both to comprehend an overwhelming experience and justify the present political situation. To the best of my knowledge, Ralegh’s 1596 narrative is the earliest text to record a ‘prophecy’ that establishes a link between the future of the Incas and the English. It is obviously modelled on the better-known prophecy justifying the Spanish rule. The irony of this extraordinary textual moment is that it did take up a life of its own, with a little help from native leaders. As early as 1597, a Dutch expedition is told that an oracular fire-spirit, Wattopa, spoke to a ‘captain’ of Caribs who was about to be hanged by the Spaniards and foretold ‘deliverance through the Dutch and English’.36 The ‘prophecy’ is attested again in the eighteenth century, as in the preface to the second, 1723 edition of de la Vega’s Comentarios reales published in Lima, which was censored by the colonial authorities as seditious.37 A a matter of fact, the eighteenth-century editor of de la Vega’s text – Andrés Gonzalez de Barcia Carballido y Zuniga – quotes Ralegh as his source, in the Latin version of the text that was published in 1599 by Theodore de Bry in his collection of voyages.38 It is this Latin version of Ralegh’s text
60
British Narratives of Exploration
that circulated widely in the seventeenth and eighteenth centuries rather than the English one. In the eighteenth century, in fact, the prophecy was used by the Inca revolutionary movement as part of a campaign to organize resistance to the Spaniards.39 As such, it contributed to the gradual emancipation of Southern America from the Spanish yoke and it facilitated the return of the English in the region. In 1769, the explorer Edmund Bancroft tells us in his Essay on the Natural History of Guiana in South America that almost two centuries after Ralegh’s first trip, the natives of the region still retain the memory of his promise that from England would come an army that would free them from the Spaniards: they retain a tradition of an English chief, who many years since landed amongst them and encouraged them to persevere in enmity of the Spaniards, promising to return and settle amongst them, and afford them assistance: and it is said that they still preserve an English Jack, which he left them, that they might distinguish his countrymen.40
This anecdote wonderfully illustrates how Ralegh’s ‘prophecy’, tailored for an oral tradition on the model of pre-existing similar prophetic utterances, can be read as emblematic of the two-way ‘assimilation’, or mimeticism, that is characteristic of Ralegh’s colonial encounters. His stroke of genius, as a master myth-maker, was to author the prophetic statement in print for the benefit of future ages – de Bry’s and Hakluyt’s extraordinarily successful collections of travels were of course instrumental in publicizing it beyond its immediate English readership.41 Finally, one can perhaps point out that Ralegh was himself a poet, with a keen ear for sound effects, and this it is obvious in his attempt to link the destiny of the Incas (or ‘Ingas’) with that of the inhabitants of ‘Inglatierra’. The quasi homophony between ‘Ingatierra’ and ‘Inglatierra’ (with a one-letter différance) obviously played a part in his forging the prophecy, as well, perhaps, as in its extraordinary subsequent fortune. This also illustrates, incidentally, another form of hybridization, ironic this time, with the language of the Spanish enemy, which is used here to undermine their own power. What The Discovery of Guiana reveals, ultimately, is the mutual entanglement of languages and practices in colonial milieu, which I have described as a mimetic, transitive exchange. One illustrious reader at least was not convinced. When Ralegh was sent to the Tower by King James on his return from his second trip, he kept with him a list ot items that can finally be interpreted as metonymic tokens of his engagement with an idealized form of ‘Indian-ness’ with which he had become deeply fascinated: ‘a ‘Stob’ of gold, a Guiana idol of gold, a ‘plott’ of the river Orinoco’,42 not to mention his beloved pipe. With these items as talismanic emblems of his symbolic possession of Guiana, ‘Waterali’ could still imagine himself as ‘King of the Indians’. It is to be wondered if Ralegh ever owned the kind of pipe that became known in England and Holland around the mid-
‘Waterali’ Goes Native
61
seventeenth century as a ‘Sir Walter Ralegh pipe’, because it bore a human head vaguely reminiscent of Ralegh’s on the bowl (seemingly watched by an openmouthed crocodile, carved on the stem). Such pipes were made both in Holland and in England and seemed to have been very popular around the middle of the century.43 These pipes represent to me perfectly hybrid, ‘entangled objects’, to use Whitehead’s phrase;44 and as such they perfectly exemplify the mutual ‘colonial mimicry’ at work in the encounters described above: the characteristic shape of the clay Dutch and English pipe, subverted by native decorative motifs – in the present case a stylized crocodile – makes for a totally hybrid object, half-way between the two cultures. There is no better emblem for the unique ambivalence of Waterali in A Discovery of Guiana.
5 DOMESTICATION AND RECOGNITION OF THE OTHER IN JOHN LAWSON’S A NEW VOYAGE TO CAROLINA (1709) Robert Sayre
In this essay I will discuss the encounter experience of the English colonizer John Lawson with North American Indians, as textualized in A New Voyage to Carolina, published in London in 1709. I will attempt to show how this narrative of encounter pictures a highly ‘unstable zone’, one in which, in the representation of the confrontation of Self and Other we see deployed first and foremost many patterns of domestication of the Other. But at the same time a process of destabilization of the comfortable certainties thereby established comes into play, leading ultimately to some real recognition of the specificity and value of the Other, albeit partial and contradictory. Next to nothing is known for sure about Lawson before his arrival in Carolina in 1700. His birth date has not been established with certainty, though there is some indication it may have been 1674. The main problem confronted by biographers insofar as his English period is concerned, is the commonness of both his first and last names in England at the time. He probably came from a well-to-do family (though nothing designates it as a noble one), and he seems to have received a university education. Concerning his reasons for going to America, Lawson explains in the introduction to his book that, desiring to travel he spoke with a man ‘who was very well acquainted with the Ways of Living in both Indies; of whom, having made Enquiry concerning them, he assur’d me, that Carolina was the best country I could go to’.1 Lawson soon thereafter shipped out from London, and arrived in Charles Town (Charleston, SC) after a stopover in New York. He spent several months there, and then set out on an expedition to explore the interior of the country, in regions little known to the English at the time. He may have been commissioned to undertake this trip by the governors of the province, or by an English collector of botanical specimens whom he met in London, though these are only suppositions as there is no sure indication of the motives for Lawson’s trip.2 Whatever the case may be, this first – 63 –
64
British Narratives of Exploration
foray lasted about two months, from December 1700 to February 1701, and covered some 500 miles (although Lawson claims a thousand miles in the subtitle of his book).3 Lawson was accompanied by five other Englishmen, and four Indians (one of whom was a woman) to serve as guides. Their course of travel took them in a wide curve to the west and north. Then, with some of his fellow travellers, Lawson returned to the coast, but far north of Charles Town, near the Virginia border. He settled in this area, which was inhabited by only a small number of settlers, with Indian tribes (particularly the Tuskarora) still located nearby. Lawson mainly remained there during the eight years preceding publication of his book, returning briefly to London to arrange for publication, but also making repeated trips into the interior and visiting the Indians of the region. He engaged in various activities in this period: botanizing for the English collector for whom he may have made his initial trip, surveying (he was named ‘Surveyor General’ of the province in 1708), fur trading and above all real estate speculation. He was instrumental in the founding of several new towns: Bath, the first town of North Carolina, incorporated in 1706, and, several years later, New Bern. So Lawson was very centrally involved in the British colonization effort in the area. As such, he was clearly perceived to be a threat by his Indian neighbours, for he was captured and put to death by Tuskaroras when on an exploratory trip that almost certainly was made with a view to new settlement. This brief sketch of John Lawson’s activities in the Carolinas provides a context for understanding the dynamics of domestication of the Other in his travel account. The latter includes both a narration of his first trip (‘A Journal of a Thousand Miles’), and a section in which he presents his general reflections on Indians (‘Exact Description and Natural History of That Country’), as he had come to know them over the longer period. These two elements are often found, sometimes in separate parts, sometimes intermingled, in accounts of encounter with North American Indians.4 In the term ‘domestication’ I mean to include, on the one hand, expressions of possession and control of the Other by the Self (here the Self is a collective one: the colonial subject), but also the symbolic transformation, through language, of the Other into the Self, the ‘de-othering’ of the Other, as it were. We find ample illustration of both aspects of domestication in Lawson’s discourse on Indians in A New Voyage to Carolina. The work is dedicated to the ‘Lords Proprietors’, the governing body of the province; ‘I here present Your Lordships’, Lawson tells them in the dedication, ‘with a Description of your own Country’.5 Lawson proposes, then, to reveal to the possessors their possession, hitherto largely terra incognita to them, inhabited by alien Others. In this sense the text as a whole can be seen as an instrument of domestication. Moreover, a rhetorical figure recurs regularly in the account of the first expedition, which imagines future, concrete appropriation of the land
Domestication and Recognition of the Other
65
by the English. We might call it ‘prospective vision’. As the traveller gazes on land now occupied by Indians, he sees in his mind’s eye what that land could become in the hands of the English. Lawson describes, for example, a valley that is perfectly adapted to cultivation and well irrigated by rivers that are ‘very convenient for the Transportation of what Commodities this Place may produce’;6 in another passage, he says of the site of an Indian town that it ‘would prove an exceeding thriving range for Cattle, and Hogs, provided the English were seated thereon’.7 Also, as if to buttress these prefigurations of English possession, Lawson often emphasizes the fidelity and submission to the British settlers of the Indian tribes he visits. Very near the beginning of the narrative, for instance, he claims that ‘they [the English settlers] have an entire Friendship with the neighbouring Indians of several nations, which are a very warlike People, ever faithful to the English … and are a great Help and Strength to this Colony’.8 So, although Lawson points out at one point that ‘the Savages do, indeed, still possess the Flower of Carolina, the English enjoying only the Fag-end of that fine Country’,9 his text asserts present control, and strongly projects a future possession by the English that has not yet been fully accomplished. If we look now at the other aspect of domestication, the ‘de-othering’ of the Other, we might first point to a striking linguistic practice, apparently adopted by the group of travellers as a whole and echoed in Lawson’s text. The individual Indians with whom he and his fellow travellers develop particular relations (most often the chiefs that host them), are designated by familiar English nicknames, such as ‘Santee Jack’, ‘Keyauwees Jack’ and ‘Enoe Will’.10 Thus, the Indians’ selfdesignated names are replaced by attributed Anglo-Saxon names. The kind of Anglo-Saxon name given, well illustrated by the example of Jack, which is used several times, makes especially acute the loss of identity by the Indian Other. For here a unique, invented Indian name (this was the common practice of North American natives) is replaced by a particularly commonplace, quasi-anonymous English one. In the case of chiefs, the renaming would also have the effect of removing the aura of moral authority that was inherent to their position and integral to their identity. But this refusal of alterity goes beyond naming and often permeates the style of the narrative. For Lawson often translates what he observes of Indian life into an English frame of reference, forcing what he sees into familiar moulds that eliminate the specificity of difference. This can be seen in his choice of vocabulary in portraying scenes involving Indians, and interactions with them. In describing a ceremony, for instance, Lawson speaks of a ‘ditty’ being sung; the best hunters are termed the ‘chief Sportsmen’; and Lawson calls the woman with whose family he was lodged on one occasion his ‘landlady’.11 Beyond isolated vocabulary, this tendency can infect an entire narrative sequence. Lawson recounts one incident in which another of the Englishmen in his party becomes interested in
66
British Narratives of Exploration
having sex with an Indian woman and gives her gifts to gain her assent before going off with her. When he returns she has taken some of his things and disappeared. But the story is told in a jovial, burlesque style, in the tones of an English picaresque novel, with the two protagonists called ‘Mr Bridegroom’ and ‘Mrs Bride’ and their coupling a ‘Winchester-Wedding’ (probably a forced marriage, as Lefler suggests in an editorial note). The story ends in mock pathos, with the author waking early to see a melancholy figure who in less than 12 Hours, was Batchelor, Husband, and Widdower, his dear Spouse having pick’d his Pocket of the Beads, Cadis, and what else should have gratified the Indians for the Victuals we receiv’d of them. However, that did not serve her turn, but she had also got his Shooes away … Thus dearly did our Spark already repent his new Bargain, walking bare-foot, in his Penitentials, like some poor Pilgrim to Loretto.12
This tendency to translate the experience of the Other into familiar frameworks of the Self often seems to stymie Lawson’s attempts to understand what he witnesses. For he is confronted with an overall culture that is entirely alien, in which particular elements that superficially resemble elements of his own culture in fact take on entirely different meanings. Thus, in the above scene Lawson seems to treat the Indian woman’s act as pilfering qua taking repayment for the food offered by the Indians to the English, though such a motive would be entirely inimical to the Indian ethic of hospitality. Similarly, in another passage the sexual freedom of girls before marriage is called ‘Whorish’ (‘the more Whorish, the more Honourable’, Lawson exclaims,13 and the women who play a diplomatic role in giving their favours to visitors are described in language suggesting actual prostitution: ‘They are mercenary, and whoever makes Use of them, first hires them, the greatest Share of the Gain going to the King’s Purse, who is the chief Bawd’.14 Here the emphasis is also on the monetary. Coming himself from a thoroughly commercial culture and society, Lawson often depicts Indian society in mercantile terms. According to his account Indian brides are ‘sold’, and Indians can ‘buy off ’ a murder with wampum, ‘their Mammon’ as he once calls it.15 While in this way he changes many observed aspects of Indian social relations into the currency, often in a literal sense, of his own social background, in the realm of religion Lawson is confronted with practices entirely alien to English Protestantism, that call forth other domesticating strategies. Lawson in fact hesitates between two alternative means of bringing the Indians’ religious rites and beliefs into sync with his own spiritual worldview. In a few passages he suggests that Indians may be devil-worshippers, thus bringing their practices into the Christian universe of discourse but as blasphemous negation.16 He seems to have trouble believing this explanation, though, and more often opts for a debunking approach, also couched in his own cultural terms. Often myths and legends become simply ‘lies’ – he treats in this way, for example, the tale of how
Domestication and Recognition of the Other
67
a tribe came to possess lightning in the form of a partridge17 – and shamans are ‘quacks’ or ‘cunning knaves’ who are purposely fooling a credulous people.18 In addition to these ‘de-othering’ devices applied to the religious domain, Lawson also attempts on several occasions the spiritual equivalent of domestication as possession/control: he tries his hand at proselytizing, attempting to convert to Christianity one of his guides, as well as one of the chiefs he spends some time with, albeit with ambiguous results.19 There are, however, a considerable number of points in Lawson’s narrative, starting from early on, at which destabilizing elements are introduced that question this affirmative message of domination and absorption of the Other by the superior Self. At one point he acknowledges, for example, that he owes his life to the canoeing skill of one of the Indian guides on the expedition,20 guides otherwise complacently referred to as ‘our’ Indians.21 Also, in spite of his scornful debunking of Indian beliefs and magical practices in many instances, his responses in this area are in fact contradictory and hesitant, for he informs the reader that he has been witness to, and has been told of, efficacious Indian cures, and concedes that they compare well with European medecine.22 Even more puzzling and disquieting – since the cures could be explained, without abandoning European medical principles, by the use of effective herbs – are instances in which he sees a prophecy fulfilled or seemingly supernatural control exercised by a shaman over a natural phenomenon – in one case, a thunder storm.23 Lawson appears to be at a loss to account for these occurrences within the terms of his system of belief and understanding, and is reduced to reporting them without commentary. At the same time Lawson shows signs of frustration in his desire to understand more fully. For the Indians refuse to answer certain questions that he asks, especially those that involve their religious beliefs and practices. In one instance, Lawson observes several Indians approaching a concave stone, placing tobacco in it and spitting; they remain silent when he asks them why.24 Lawson also becomes curious regarding the Indian custom of circumcision, but tells the reader that ‘if you ask them, what is the Reason they do so, they will make you no Manner of Answer; which is as much as to say, I will not tell you. Many other Customs they have, for which they will render no Reason or Account; … for there are a great many of their Absurdities, which, for some Reason, they reserve as a Secret amongst themselves …’25 Lawson’s irritation seems palpable in this passage. He cannot understand why his interlocutors will not simply explain everything straightaway. This irritation would seem to reveal a real fear and frustration at not being able to control the Other fully through forcing it to give up its secrets, and at not receiving a ‘Reason’ for its ‘absurdities’ that would provide a translation of the Other into the Self.
68
British Narratives of Exploration
These passages show chinks in the armour, so to speak, but others seem to point toward a more active questioning of stereotyped certainties of European superiority. Moral superiority, first and foremost, for Lawson has found ‘amongst some of them, great Observers of Moral Rules, and the Laws of Nature; indeed, a worthy Foundation to build Christianity upon …’26 A worthier one, perhaps, than was to be found in his English compatriots, whose cheating of the Indians Lawson castigates, leading him to the admission that ‘if we do not shew them Examples of Justice and Vertue, we can never bring them to believe us to be a worthier Race of Men than themselves’.27 More generally, the superiority of the English way of life is brought into question in one passage in which Lawson alludes to the many cases, of which he has personally known several, of Englishmen who have chosen to remain among the Indians, ‘without ever desiring to return again among the English, although they had very fair Opportunities of Advantages amongst their Countrymen’.28 Lawson’s narrative of encounter even moves beyond these doubts and questionings in some passages, to arrive at a modicum of what I will call ‘recognition’, a term that has both cognitive and evaluative aspects: cognitive insight into the nature of the Other, and willingness to attribute positive value to the Other. In fact, from the start Lawson expresses a desire to write truly and justly about the Indians, claiming in the introduction to his work to be a rectifier of erroneous conceptions propagated in the past by English traders, who were generally uneducated and self-seeking, and who, although on their travels ‘they often spend several Years, are yet, at their Return, uncapable of giving any reasonable Account of what they met withal …’29 Yet he also indicates, in one passage, that he is aware of the great difficulty of comprehending and appreciating radical otherness, claiming that the Indians’ ‘way of living is so contrary to ours, that neither we nor they can fathom one anothers Designs and Methods’.30 In spite of this general difficulty, and in spite of the many ways in which his cultural ‘blinders’ get in the way, Lawson does at points seem to show a lucid awareness of a number of areas of Indian culture, perceived as significantly different from English (and European) modes of thought and behaviour. In surprising contradiction to his commercialization of Indian culture elsewhere, in certain places in his text Lawson develops the idea that Indian money, means of measurement and sense of time and work are all fundamentally different from those of Europeans, and that these are interrelated. The Indians never push themselves to work so as to accumulate goods or wealth, he claims, but only do as much as is necessary to provide subsistence; when travelling or hunting, though, they often exert themselves enthusiastically and tirelessly because these activities bring both pleasure to them and practical advantage to their group.31 Lawson points out in another place that the production of wampum is extraordinarily painstaking and time-consuming, but since the Indians ‘never value their time … they can
Domestication and Recognition of the Other
69
afford to make them’.32 He also makes the related observation that the Indian method of measuring the length of a wampum belt is to extend it from the elbow to the little finger, but ‘(t)hey never stand to question, whether it is a tall Man, or a short one, that measures it’.33 What he is pointing to here, clearly, is that the standardized quantification of commercial transactions does not hold with the Indians. Lawson’s text often also points to an underlying principle of Indian societies which is at loggerheads with English and European ones: the tight-knit, integrated nature of their communities. Although often belied by the textual practices I have illustrated above, Lawson does often emphasize, in portraying the Indians, egalitarian sharing of material goods, deep attachments, generosity and mutual aid, the predominance of the common good over that of the individual, etc.34 This adds up to a striking lack of dissension, as Lawson comments: ‘They never fight with one another, unless drunk … They say, the Europeans are always rangling and uneasy, and wonder they do not go out of this World, since they are so uneasy and discontented in it’.35 Although ostensibly just reporting what Indians say, Lawson seems to be speaking with them as well. Here cognitive insight seems to be mixed with strong sympathy. Some commentators have gone so far as to speak of a thematics of the ‘noble savage’ and of a New World Eden.36 My analysis here attempts, however, to reveal the complexities and contradictions in Lawson’s work. And indeed, particularly in the last section of his work which gives a general portrait of the Indian peoples he has known, Lawson expresses admiration for many specific aspects of Indian society (the lenient treatment of children, and funeral customs that do not include burial of the body, for example). More significantly, the generalizing section, and with it the work as a whole, culminates in an overall praise of, and plea for the Indians: They are really better to us, than we are to them … We look upon them with Scorn and Distain, and think them little better than Beasts in Humane [sic] Shape, though if well examined, we shall find that, for all our Religion and Education, we possess more Moral Deformities, and Evils than these Savages do … these Indians are the freest People in the World, and so far from being Intruders upon us … we have abandon’d our own Native Soil, to drive them out, and possess theirs; neither have we any true Balance, in Judging of these poor Heathens, because we neither give Allowance for their Natural Disposition, nor the Sylvian Education, and strange Customs, (uncouth to us) they lie under.37
It is true that this passage occurs in the context of final recommendations to the settlers (and Lords-Proprietors) as to how to ‘make these People serviceable to us, and better themselves thereby’,38 that is, to civilize and convert them, and extend British rule. Lawson recommends doing so by persuasion and intermarriage rather than by force and trickery, but this does not change the nature of the
70
British Narratives of Exploration
goal. In spite of the imperial context, though, this statement as well as a good many passages preceding it, stand in strange contrast to the discourse of domination and de-othering that I have discussed. The reader is left, finally, with a puzzlingly dissonant impression. How can the blatant contradictions in Lawson’s text be explained? I can only, in conclusion, suggest some tentative possibilities. One involves the fact, already hinted at, that insight and sympathy are most strongly concentrated in the generalizing section, in contrast with the travel account. We might hypothesize that in the account of the voyage Lawson remains too close to lived experience to escape his conditioned responses, whereas the framework of the treatise provides him with greater intellectual distance. Moreover, only in the final summation of that section does Lawson become fully conscious of a point toward which he tended previously. But while this may explain the distribution of the dissonant elements in the text, we still would need to try to understand how a man so energetically engaged in the colonial enterprise, and whose prose is so often permeated with that perspective, could in the same text rather forcefully question and subvert it. In this regard I would suggest that perhaps Lawson’s text can stand as an illustration of a general principle:39 the potential (only a potential, but a potent one) for transcendence of the Self ’s conditioning in the experience of travel encounter itself.
6 THE (HE)ART OF FIRST ENCOUNTER AT TAHITI: SAMUEL WALLIS’S CONFLICTS OF INTEREST (1767) Sandhya Patel
The writing of travel and its publication has served various ideological ends over the centuries. Prominent among those is the production of a newly discovered Other, both place and person, but also of a rediscovered Self, that of the traveller himself. In 1598, Richard Hakluyt initiated a compilatory trend – ‘pioneering in its scope’ in Bohls and Duncan’s words1 – which contributed to the undertaking of empire and importantly paved the way for a national archival memory-making and for the invention of a national identity rooted in maritime exploits, articulated not in poetry but in prose narratives, in the language of the common man: ‘What the old epics were to the royally or nobly born, this modern epic is to the common people’.2 In his conceptualization of the narrative of exploration, MacLaren identifies four stages, the first of which is the logbook entry made en route. The journal then gives body to the log entry, ‘informing it with continuity and purpose’: whereas the log entry may display tentativeness, in the journal, the use of the past tense and retrospection generates orderliness and consistency. This production is central in the emergence of an author, as the narrative is also shaped by the potential audience’s exigencies. The third and fourth stages, the draft manuscript and the publication itself, are similarly subject to the demands of the audience.3 The nature of the texts I will be examining here draws attention to the log entry itself as a site of ambivalence – which the navigator explores and fully exploits. Commander Samuel Wallis was the first Englishman to have more than a fleeting encounter with the inhabitants of what is known today as the Tuamotu archipelago. Furthermore, his discovery of the Society Isles in the South Pacific, specifically Tahiti, is the earliest documentary record of the encounter between Europeans and Polynesians. Unlike his successors, though, Wallis did not write a journal onboard ship; his log may nevertheless be interpreted as a key text in elucidating relationships between Self and Other, in that it attests to first encounter – 71 –
72
British Narratives of Exploration
in an account which has not been reworked to suit the tastes of a reading public. Little academic attention has been paid to the Wallis texts precisely because of this form. In the major studies on the Wallis material, such as Pearson’s article on the scope of John Hawkesworth’s emendations in An Account of the Voyages … performed by Commodore Byron, Captain Carteret, Captain Wallis and Captain Cook, only the log held at the Public Records Office (hereafter PRO) in London is referred to.4 The PRO holds a log written most probably by Wallis himself, according to Hugh Carrington who published George Robertson’s journal. Robertson was Master onboard the Dolphin and his text is accepted as being the most authoritative account of the ship’s sojourn at Tahiti. Another Wallis log exists, however, archived in Australia at the Mitchell Library in Sydney.5 Importantly, this document is similar but not identical to the one in London, and I argue that the differences between the two epitomize tensions between conflicting representations of Self and Other in the South Pacific. Wallis’s manuscripts were significantly both logs, not a log and a journal, but the disparities between the two transcribe in their short message form the intricacy of the politics of first contact in this part of the Pacific. A comparative study of the two documents must necessarily be based on two assumptions – firstly a supposition as to whom the authors were, and secondly a premise as to which log was written first. The handwriting and the signature confirm at first view that both logs were written by Wallis. I propose on the strength of this that the Australian text, which I will call ‘the first log’, was Wallis’s first impression. The London text, which will hereafter be referred to as ‘the second log’, seems to have been written afterwards. My proposal is based on the encapsulatory dimension of the first log (the Australian text) and the relatively more elaborate stylistic turn of the second (the London text). Some passages in both logs, though importantly more so in the London log, are not in abbreviated note form and are narratives in the fashion of a journal, with hypotactic characteristics. This is so when Wallis deliberately decides to devote two or three pages to descriptive purpose, though the first, Australian log also contains descriptive passages. Encapsulation – short sentences, sometimes nominal, with little punctuation and few conjunctions, and simple syntax – characterizes most of the Australian log entries. Thus, going from notes to narrative appears more likely than going from narrative to notes. Exactly when the second, London log was written remains to be seen and needs to be determined. Most research (very little as compared to work on Cook or the Forsters) has been done on this second log and none, as far as I know, on the first. The objective here is to minutely identify and explore this initial reworking by Wallis, well before Hawkesworth committed himself to the task. Wallis’s two logs display a revealing production and promotion of Self and Other which, though not as outright as various editors’ reworking of narratives of exploration,
The (He)art of First Encounter at Tahiti
73
is largely significant. Even the inventorial form of travel writing then may be understood as a self-conscious form of recuperation in the interests of collective and personal enterprise.6 Greg Dening argues that ‘when [the explorers] tried to describe what they saw, they themselves were revealed. Their own values, the structures of their consciousness and the categories of their mind were present in the things they selected to describe’.7 Bhabha interrogates what he terms as the formulation of strategies of representation and empowerment in the context of competing communities.8 His ‘dynamics of writing’ acquire additional significance in the pre-colonial context, as they also transcribe to some extent the socio-politics of first encounter, clearing the way for future action, namely annexation and appropriation, conquest and colonization. Thus, Wallis’s texts recounting the encounter with one group of the Pacific peoples seem to lend themselves particularly well to a type of close reading which may be considered as revealing these ‘sites of ambivalence’. This study will specifically focus on how Wallis negotiated his representations of situations of conflict. Greg Dening’s conceptualization of this contact, very appropriately described as taking place on a beach and therefore symbolic of a meeting of worlds at the frontier – us and them, good and bad, familiar and strange – is relevant here. Dening argues that difference can be so great that the only means of control is violence. He calls attention to an oversight in this understanding of contact – it patently overlooks the aggression inherent ‘in the presumed right to possess the land’.9 Interestingly, the identities of the assailant and defender are not posited as firmly in Wallis’s first log as in the second. Thus, his observations in the latter attest to a gradual polarization of initially uncertain categories, which emerge more clearly sparing the Englishmen any blame for the violence of contact. They are the defenders and the Tahitians, the assailants. The disparities between Wallis’s two texts seem to illustrate the materialization of this ‘managerial process’, which is also a process of stereotyping.10 The typology I propose comprises three modes of disparity between the two documents, namely: discretionary diction (by which I mean a sometimes weighted choice of words in order to convey a specific view of events), strategic oversights/additions, and questions of chronology. These modes work together sometimes in single entries and inform a discussion of the politics of the South Pacific and specifically Tahitian contact zones, based on that which Wallis himself wrote up as the first Englishman to sail across these islands. Pinaki in the Tuamotu archipelago is sighted on 6 June 1767, the first sign of land in the Pacific for weeks. On 8 June, after having precariously secured meagre supplies at Pinaki, Wallis sails on to the second nearby atoll, Nukutavake. There, the second log performs its detailing deed in providing elements which expand the telegraphic form of the first log into a more narrative form. These added details weight the polemical aspect of the very first potentially antagonis-
74
British Narratives of Exploration
tic encounter between the islanders and the English, which the observations in the first log do not, as the following example shows. In the second log, the boats are manned and armed because Wallis sees fifty natives ‘drawn up’ and ‘running about with long Pikes and fire brands’.11 This is inserted in the second log in brackets, as a justification for arming the men. The dynamic confrontational dimension of the Tahitians’ response to the longboats coming within the reach of the shore is accentuated by verbs such as ‘drawn up’ and ‘running about’, and of course by the reference to their weapons. Wallis takes pains to point out that any aggression on the English side is to be avoided at all costs. The English are ‘civil’, attempt to ‘persuade’, and endeavour not to give offence, and by these civil and civilized means, are to obtain fruit and water. But the natives stand guard and do not suffer them to land, up in arms. The first log is rather less categorical in its representation of the events. The diction does not produce an image of any offensive in the offing, and there is no mention of natives up in arms. No running about either, implying disorganized martial frenzy, but simply ‘great many inhabitants on the beach’, and a short: ‘They would not suffer the people to land’.12 Here, the violence of contact is significantly less apparent as compared to its palpable presence in the second log. The power relations are most definitely weighted on the Tahitians’ side, as the Tahitians refuse to let the boats land. The second log, though, imbalances the relationships in terms of control, and this through recourse to what may be qualified as a considered addition of detail, which stresses the strength and serenity of the British manoeuvres in the face of this potential assault. As the contact zone takes shape, the language in the second log does indeed take on a more narrative form, though not in terms of literary artifice. More details are added, through parentheses and longer sentences, and the construction of collective Self is privileged as contact is prolonged and structured. The rational rationale of contact on the British side emerges more firmly. These tendencies are illustrated in the first log, in which Wallis includes an interesting and rather decisive detail of this first encounter, namely that two members of the expedition do indeed try to force a landing: ‘They would not suffer the people to land – except two who they soon put into the boat again’.13 In the second log, the incident is entirely glossed over, and the aggressive stance of the Tahitians is thrown into relief: ‘they stood on their ground with long Pikes & would not suffer the people to land’.14 This is going somewhat against the pacific ethics of encounter as detailed in the instructions to Lieutenant Furneaux in the first few lines of the entry in the second log: ‘… endeavour to traffic with them for fruit water or anything that might be useful to us at the same time not to give them offence but endeavour by civil means to get refreshments from them’.15 In view of this strategic oversight in the more narrative second log, where adding detail is undoubtedly one of the textual functions, the relating of the
The (He)art of First Encounter at Tahiti
75
nature of the encounter is modified from the first to the second log. The violent landing – the necessary encroaching on a land which constitutes ‘incomprehensible extravagance’16 – is effaced in the second log, preserving the symbolic representation of the civilized means of contact employed by the British. This representation thus produces a polarization effect of the ‘us’ and ‘them’ – defender and assailant – dichotomies. The islanders then leave, and the English being in need of sustenance proceed to help themselves to the food and water on the island. They take on supplies until the 11 June, not being in any way disturbed by any lingering islanders who in the second log are described as having ‘fled’ Nukutavake.17 While the islander is thus produced as assailant, the second log also confusedly attempts to characterize the ‘native’ as cowardly or ineffectual, which may also work towards attenuating the power of the Other, associated with being the aggressor, and reinforcing that of the Self, consolidating further the categories established on first contact by the writing strategies just discussed. Wallis’s second log institutes thus a categorial confusion, whereas the first ‘impression’ continues in a more composed strain which elides to some extent the production of colonial discourse. On the 11 June, when the Dolphin approaches Lord Egmont Island, the first log describes the situation thus: At ½ past 3 the New Island Bore from the East End of it [Charlotte Island] SE about one mile – at this time we were abreast of 8 Sail of Double Canoes that were hauled upon the beach and were the same People that left Charlotte Island, the people all sitting on the Beach, their things just taken out of their Canoes.18
This description represents the Tahitians as resting, or waiting for ensuing events. The image evokes serenity, peaceableness and a certain watchfulness. The second log then transforms this visual encounter and further grounds the image enunciated initially in this South Pacific context on 7 June: We saw the Canoes with all the Inhabitants by them that had fled from Charlotte Island, there were not any Hutts but the people had hauled up their Canoes upon the Beach and placed their Weomen & Children under them and they came down close to the waterside with big Pickes in their Hands, & some with Firebrands making a great noise and dancing in strange manner. There were 7 or eight Double Canoes with about Four score Men Weomen and Children.19
Here the representation is at odds with the ambiance of Wallis’s initial notation. In effect, the islanders’ belligerent intentions are made clear. They are brandishing weapons, their women and children are safe under the canoes, out of harm’s way, implying that they expect to wage war. The ‘strange’ manner in which they are dancing constructs these potential enemies, and the categorial strategy further ‘fixes’ the production of their otherness – an important feature of colonial discourse.20 Thus in the second log, the discursive practice of repetition of the
76
British Narratives of Exploration
hostile posturing of the islanders may very well be understood as a means of ‘othering’, based on proximity to or distance from violence. Wallis thus sails from Lord Egmont, and from the putatively aggressive islanders, taking care to point out (but only in the second log) that there was ‘little likelihood of refreshment to be met with on it’.21 The reworking of powerplay is thus identifiable in the minute details of these first encounters. It is based ‘on a manipulation of relations of force’.22 Seemingly insignificant details then acquire particular importance in this respect. For example, it may be inferred from the entry on the 18 June in the second log that the Tahitians are somewhat in awe, and retreat to the safety of the shore on just ‘seeing’ the boats: ‘Severall canoes coming off put back on seeing our boats’.23 In the first log, Wallis is clear: Lieutenant Furneaux goes ‘very near three or four canoes – who all pulled for the shore’.24 The threat emanates in the first log from the Englishmen, and the withdrawal of the Tahitians is its result, which is not the case in the second. The second log seems to downplay the potentially aggressive gestures on the part of the longboat crew. Which version is true is of little importance here. What is significant is the polysemic representations of this encounter by the same man. The play of influence is indeed rooted in representations of relations of force. The potentially vulnerable position of the Englishmen faced with the islanders on their home ground, in need of nothing and apparently aware of the violence of the contact zone, is the backdrop to this oscillation in the attempt at manipulating the relations of force. Wallis in the second log may thus be understood as seeking authorization for strategies which will inevitably justify conquest in terms of a mode of violent appropriation.25 The exigencies of the situation require that the process of discovery and learning apparent in the first log be subjugated to the ‘signifiers of stability’ inherent in stereotypical discourse – namely those of courage and daring displaced by otherly cowardice and treachery. Thus, the Englishmen in the boat are forced to throw the Tahitians a rope in order to make an attempt at trade; the Tahitians in turn attempt a hijacking of the boat, according to the second log. The firing of a warning shot puts an end to the endeavour as the Tahitians let go of the rope; the hijacker swims away and the boat returns to the ship.26 No mention is made of this episode in the first log, in which the Englishmen are quite frankly shown to be at a disadvantage. The fact that it is described in the second seems to re-establish the rather disrupted order of things in the first log. What matters for posterity, and therefore for the nationalist enterprise, is that the Englishmen be shown to have parried an unjustified attack without loss of life, saving the collective Self from any humiliation. The sixteenth-century image of ‘the chiefest Captaines at sea, the greatest Merchants, and the best Mariners of our nation’, in Fuller’s terms, is thus preserved in the second log.27 As Dening puts it, ‘it was neither the nail nor the life that was important but the theatre of discipline and right order’.28
The (He)art of First Encounter at Tahiti
77
In the first log, on the contrary, the ship sails away from the island with no victuals, the natives having refused trade relations and the woods being inaccessible: ‘they made signs that they would bring Fowles CocoaNutts Hogs &ce. But after waiting severall Hours not one came & the woods being inaccessible the Boats Returned and we Sailed from the Island’.29 Discretionary diction and strategic oversight thus produce an ambiguous account. Accordingly, the rather genial description of the Tahitians in the first log – ‘The Inhabitants were about two Hundred Men Weomen & Children – all well look’d Stout people – the Weomen Handsome & dress’d in white …’30 – disappears in the second entirely, as if the empathy (between Self and Other) of this description could disrupt the rather more polemical politics of encounter identifiable in the second long, justifying the use of firearms and lauding the success of the men in bringing off fresh fruit and vegetables in spite of the attack on them by hostile Tahitians. The next encounter is of a different nature. As HMS Dolphin sails along the shore on 19 June 1767, the ship is surrounded with a hundred or so canoes, and the Tahitians, empty-handed, are invited onboard. This time, both logs focus on the ‘thievish’ quality of the people.31 Together, the logs also represent the people as ‘hallowing and Shouting that we could scarce hear each other speak’ and as setting up ‘a great Hallow’.32 These descriptions thus use what can be described as the repetitive mode as they mutually reinforce the representation of the islanders as being iniquitous and belligerent. The wider and ongoing pattern of differentiation is consolidated the next day when the site of encounter is again at sea, not on land, and the English have still not managed to land with or without the permission of the islanders; they have not been able to find anchorage, and are overwhelmed as the Tahitians surround the boats and this time attack. The encounter is related in the two logs in quite different ways. In the first log, Wallis recounts how the boats are prevented from getting close to a ‘fine bay’ both by the breakers and by a concerted attack with stones by a fleet of canoes. Wallis’s men react by firing once, which does nothing but incite the Tahitians to continue their attack, and then they fire a second time. The shot wounds one of the islanders, on which the assailants pull off, which allows the marines to row back to safety. Wallis as Captain plays no role in the management of the crisis, the responsibility of using firearms being left in the hands of Furneaux who is directly under threat : the inhabitants came off in their Canoes & was beginning to pillage them & throw stones there being near one hundred Canoes about them so they fired a musquet clear of them to let them see on which they set up a great Hallow & came close to the Boat on which they shot at one & wounded him for they were quite surrounded & expected they would [illegible] in a moment on which they pulled off at a distance & never came near them again & they got safe onboard.33
78
British Narratives of Exploration
In the second log, Wallis allots himself a rather more active part in the whole affair. For example, it is the Captain who orders the boats to come onboard on observing that hundreds of canoes have surrounded them. He also orders the first warning shot to be fired, but takes no responsibility for the second shot, which is fired by the mate and wounds a Tahitian: They then stood round to an Opening when they were surrounded with a vast number of Boats [ illegible] and at the same time made the signal for them to come Onboard, the Boats did then attempt to board Ours and threw stones at them on which I ordered a shot to be fired over them and the Mate that was in one of the boats found that if he suffered them to come nearer he should not be able to defend himself fired a Musquett with Buck shot and wounded a Man who was then standing up ready to jump onboard in the Shoulder on which they all moved off and suffered the boats to return to the Ship without any molestation.34
What is also interesting here is the omission Wallis makes. In the first log, while his longboats are being attacked, Wallis is busy trading (rather ineffectually) with the islanders in another hundred canoes amassed around the ship: at the same time we had some hundreds of Canoes about the ship – to whom I gave nails & some Trifles but they brought nothing in exchange & so thievish that they clambering up the side & taking everything they could lay hand on.35
This, in terms of tactics, may well have been a diversionary strategy on the part of the Tahitians. In the second log this reference to trading at the same time is entirely omitted. By not including this episode, Wallis lets yet another occurrence of trade gone bad, but this time under his direct command, pass. More importantly still, Wallis saves himself from any possible accusation of neglect of duty or mismanagement: trading while his men are being attacked is hardly ‘the right order of things’. Thus, in the second log as noted, Wallis’s management of the crisis comes to the fore as long as his strategy is in keeping with his peaceful mission. When a Tahitian is wounded, the mate is responsible and though justified in his action, is not obeying Wallis’s orders. The second text, whilst recounting some failure (to land, to obtain food, to find anchorage), nevertheless builds up Wallis’s authority through his successful direction of a crisis situation. In view of these examples, the second log produces the effect of a classification, using the defender/assailant categories to preclude a certain form of victimhood more apparent in the first. Victimhood in the first log does not allow representations of supremacy or control, which are seriously compromised as the boat’s hopes of landing and finding anchorage are continually dashed. These first encounters then set the scene for further conflicts of interest with the discovery of Tahiti. After sailing from Mehetia on 20 June, the island of Tahiti comes into view, holding promises of a tropical paradise: ‘The shore pleasant beyond imagination full of inhabitants Millions of CocoaNutt Trees
The (He)art of First Encounter at Tahiti
79
fine Cascades running off the Mountains’.36 The relation of ensuing events raises interesting questions of chronology. In the first log, the armed encounter is described thus: at 9 Ordered the Master with the Boats Mann’d and Arm’d to land along the Shore to the Westward and look after a Watering place there were at this time severall hundred Canoes about the Ship and the Shore & when the Boats came near the Shore several Boats that were very large laid the Barge Onboard & threw stones at them and the Other Boats were coming up with them fast that they could by no signs make them keep off not even by firing Musquets over them & two more large sailing Canoes full of men coming [illegible] for the Boats and it would have certainly sunk her he fired & wounded two which made them all shoar off and they made no more attempts so the Boats continued Sounding in Shoar and looking out for a good watering Place. The Canoes about the Ship brought off Cocoanutts, plaintains, a few Fowls and some small Hogs & other Refreshments which they bartered for Nails &ce.37
In the second log, the order of events is reworked: as soon as we had secured the ship, sent the Boats to sound along the shore and to look at the place where we saw the water at this time a great number of boats came of from the shoar to the ship and brought of with them Hogs, Fowls & plenty of fruit which we bought of them for Nails and such like things; but when our boats pulled toward the shore, most of the Natives went at them and after them keeping at a Distance, but as the boats drew nigher The natives grew bolder and on a sudden three large Sailing boats ran at the Cutter and carried away her Outlicker and stove her quarter, more coming down they fired two Muquetts over them, which they only laught at and attempted the barge who fired at the Boat that was laying her onboard and much wounded a Man on which they desisted and went away to Leeward, and other returned to the Ship again and traded.38
The writing strategy by which the categorial effect is produced here is based on recourse to discretionary diction and to the chronology of the reporting. In the first log, Wallis describes the stone-throwing as a reaction to the boats approaching the shore. The last sentence refers to the trading which takes place during and after this skirmish. In the second, the Englishmen’s attempt at landing is reworked somewhat. In the first log, Wallis orders his men to land, while in the second they are sent in simply to reconnoitre the location of the river and sound. The objective in this second ‘system of recordation’39 is more reasonable than ordering a landing after days of hostility. Further, the consequent attack is contextualized by a presentation of the equitable abundant trading before the boats approach the shore line (the subsequent attack by the Tahitians is thus represented as unreasonable). This slight revision of diction and chronology is significant as it elides any British confrontational stances in the second log as, for example, setting out to land. This elision works towards reinforcing the categories which have been taking shape since first contact. In the second log,
80
British Narratives of Exploration
the British are first attacked, and fire once they have suffered material damage. Even then the Tahitians are presented as ignoring the warning justly given by the Englishmen according to the right order of things, negligently laughing at such prevision (again consolidating the image of hostile show or blustering on the part of the islanders). This is not the case in the first log: warning shots are fired as the Tahitians approach in their canoes before any contact. All these skirmishes come to a head on 24 June 1767. The ensuing struggle is for the Tahitians their final but failed attempt at sea to resist the British onslaught. The details of the naval battle between the two adversaries are reported in the two logs in broadly similar ways, but again strategic omission is identifiable in the second, which unobtrusively operates as an ‘apparatus of power’.40 In the build up to the battle, the first log relates an overture of peace which the second does not: At ½ past Nine a boat with a large Company over the Middle & brought a large Plaintain tree with a bunch of various coloured feathers & a Pig & a Man who sat on the top of the Canopy made motions of peace & pointed to himself and then to the Ship is tho’ twas to be given to the Superior.41
These motions of peace are not recorded in the second log and this important event thus loses its significance without the qualification detailed in the first log: At last a Man sitting on a canopy that was fixed on a large double canoe made signs to let him come near the Ship which I allowed him to do when he gave a Bunch of red and yellow feathers to one of our People to bring to me and then put of.42
Similarly, the two logs do not necessarily concur as to the actual rather telling particulars of the battle itself. The first log details two charges: every Canoe set up a Halloo & threw such a Shower of Stones at all parts of the Ship that was astonishing, on which I ordered the People to fire on them, they persisted sometime but some of our Great Guns breaking a few of their Large Canoes & the QuatorDeckGuns fired loaded with Musquetts that made them sheer off. however they Kept hovering at a Distance & Throwing Stones – things which they did with Great Judgement and hurt many of our People. They on our ceasing fire after a Pause made a Second effort and came on with a Great Resolution but on their coming near & slinging stones we fired a few Loaded with Great Guns and Grape at them and they all pulled for the Shore so that at Noon there was not a Canoe to be seen.43
In the second log, Wallis describes a rather more heated battle, with the Tahitians attacking three times. The effect of their first volley of gunfire only ‘puts them into some confusion’.44 Another bout of shooting pushes back the second Tahitian onslaught. The Tahitians finally retreat after a third attempt which ends in the destruction of one canoe: ‘I ordered them to be fired on and one of the
The (He)art of First Encounter at Tahiti
81
schott hit the Canoe that had called the others to him and cut it asunder, on seeing which they immediately disappeared that in half an hour there was not a canoe to be seen’.45 This representation of the battle details a more measured approach as compared to the description in the first log, in which firing into the crowd is an immediate reaction to the initial rush. In the second, in effect, the Englishmen are forced to fire amongst the canoes only after three concerted raids, and the result is the destruction of only one canoe. Further, the fact that it is the one from which the chiefly figure proclaims the commencement of hostilities is particularly propitious (not detailed in the first log), justifying conquest as a means of appropriation. In the second log, Wallis himself acquires presence and prestige as the battle progresses. In the first log, he refers freely to his feeble condition and to the fact of his being in the gallery, following events from there by looking out of the window. This detail is omitted in the second log and the Captain’s active presence on deck is substantiated. His more frequent use of the personal pronoun in the second log corroborates this more operational representation of Self. Wallis’s logs may be considered as being, then, at the heart of the South Seas construct and as laying bare the fragility of these representative artefacts. The texts attest to an intricate process of workmanship exacerbated by the fact that up until the arrival at Tahiti, Wallis is himself transcribing reports that have been brought to him by Lieutenant Furneaux. In other words, even Wallis’s firsthand reports are in fact secondhand. This initial interpretative process, associated with the subsequent transcriptive writing up of the two logs discussed in this paper, highlights the intricacies of the process of representation by operations of language, even at this early textual stage. In Saïd’s view, the distinction between representation and misrepresentation without positing a pre-existing ‘truth’, may very well be a matter of degree.46 When the language is in its most basic form, as in the first log, representation seems less ideologically inclined. The degree of deformation increases as the language becomes subject to distorting factors, namely the cultural and political ambience. Though all captains claimed that their need for food and water overrode all other claims for territoriality, ownership, or sacredness, Dening argues that the question of power, or self-image countermanded all others.47 The Wallis texts qualify this analysis somewhat in that in his first log, without the subtext inherent in a more narrative archival form, Wallis may well have expressed some sense of seemliness, perhaps less troubled with considerations of command or control.
7 DISTANCE AND PROXIMITY IN JAMES COOK’S FIRST VOYAGE AROUND THE WORLD (1768–71) Anne Dromart
In 1766 the Admiralty and the Royal Society jointly planned an expedition to the South Seas. If the Admiralty had territorial ambitions, and hoped to establish the existence of the mythical terra australis incognita, the continent that many Europeans thought existed as a counterweight to the Northern hemisphere’s continental masses,1 what came across as the apparent aim of the exploration was the Royal Society’s scientific mission to observe the transit of Venus across the sun, due on 3 June 1769. Captain James Cook was appointed to command Her Majesty’s Bark the Endeavour, and the expedition left Plymouth on 26 August 1768, with official instructions, both from the Admiralty and the Royal Society, underlining the importance of astronomical measurements and geographical exploration, as well as the necessity of establishing contact with the indigenous peoples.2 The island of Tahiti was both the place where the scientific calculation of the distance from the earth to the sun was to be carried out, and an opportunity for supposedly easy commerce with distant populations who had already been in contact with Europeans. The ship was then to sail further west and south, in search of the hoped-for continent, taking this opportunity to draw maps of New Zealand, at the risk of entering into contact with native tribes as yet unknown to European explorers. Cook himself did not write the narrative through which his exploits came to be known in 1773. John Hawkesworth, a writer of miscellaneous essays, plays, stories and journalism, and a one-time friend of Dr Johnson, was commissioned by the Admiralty to edit the explorer’s papers, a work for which Hawkesworth is said to have received the huge sum of £6,000.3 Hawkesworth’s text was therefore the authorized edition of Cook’s logbook. In this paper, references to Hawkesworth’s text will be made through dates of entry, as they appear on the ‘South Seas’ online edition of the 1773 official record held by the National Library of – 83 –
84
British Narratives of Exploration
Australia4 and references to Cook’s own logbook will be to Beaglehole’s 1968 edition. As is well known, the record published by Hawkesworth caused quite a sensation in Britain. Among the causes for the uproar was Hawkesworth’s tale of the way the islanders innocently indulged in free sex, which was widely condemned on moral grounds.5 What interests me here, however, is how Cook’s journal, as rewritten by Hawkesworth, reveals not promiscuity, but tension: the tension that both Europeans and non-Europeans – whether Tahitians or Maoris – seem to have experienced in deciding how close or how distant from each other they actually wanted to be. What I argue, furthermore, is that this issue of physical distance between the two groups made manifest the cultural issues involved in exchange. The search for an ideal ground of exchange, both in terms of trade and mutual understanding, was constantly frustrated by the realization that spatial arrangements could in fact only be determined through shared cultural codes. As it thus invites the Europeans to question their own attitude towards the Other, suggesting that common cultural grounds are the cornerstone of effective communication, Hawkesworth’s edition of Cook’s logbook introduces a timid awareness of the meaning and role of cultures in interaction, a notion of culture which surprisingly seems to break away from the Enlightenment ‘uniformitarian view’ of human nature as a shared universal.6 But what a close reading of Hawkesworth’s rhetoric also reveals, however, is that such encounters seem to be worth describing in Hawkesworth’s view only insofar as they produce an unequal relationship between the navigator and the islander. The values of the white man constitute the filter through which various events are interpreted. Gunpowder then becomes not only a talisman of power, but also a cultural tool used to regulate distance and proximity on the model of a hierarchical structuring of relationships. At first view, Hawkesworth’s narrative seems to express no fear of, or contempt for, the South Seas islanders. The narrative is not centred on the Europeans only; it allows room for the natives, as is constantly suggested by the verbal forms used. For instance, the natives are very often allowed to become the grammatical subjects of verbs, as if the narrator of the Journal were willing to grant them the dignity of being centres of perception and thought, to the extent that the ‘savages’ are metamorphosed into enigmas to be understood: ‘They had with them a pig, which they would not part with’.7 Hawkesworth’s choice of ‘would’ clearly suggests the perception of a will which remains opaque to the visitors and consequently kindles their curiosity. The reader nevertheless perceives a contradiction here. Cook must establish peaceful relationships with the islanders, but he cannot allow the natives any pre-eminence if he wants to remain in control of the situation of interlocution. The aim of the voyage was indeed to acquire a
Distance and Proximity in James Cook’s First Voyage around the World (1768–71)
85
better knowledge of new territories and cultures, but it also aimed at enlarging England’s ‘network’ of wealth and power.8 Cook is certainly careful to follow the Earl of Morton’s recommendations, ‘to exercise the utmost patience and forbearance with respect to the natives of the several Lands where the Ships may pass’,9 but he is equally mindful not to risk having his boat dismantled by the Tahitians – Cook was fully aware that when Samuel Wallis, who had arrived back in England just in time to pass on navigational information to the Admiralty, had made landfall at Tahiti in June 1767, he had been attacked by the Polynesians. Cook’s concern, therefore, is both to protect the natives from his men, and to protect his men from the natives. Hawkesworth’s record is very careful to underscore this mixture of benevolence and mistrust: A proper person or persons will be appointed to trade with the Natives … and no officer or seaman or other person belonging to the Ship, excepting such as are so appointed, shall trade or offer to trade.10
The Admiralty and its representatives recurrently find refuge in such specific rules, aimed at securing safe relationships between the European visitors and the South Seas islanders. If such rules prove necessary, is it not because exchange between civilized and uncivilized is thought to be potentially risky for both sides? The implicit assumption here is that the British common sailors might be tempted to act with the islanders as with an inferior species, perhaps even as with animals (as will indeed appear further down), an attitude very likely to cause trouble for the two parties. Rules therefore restrict exchanges to a highly coded form of ‘trade’, thus delineating the scope and nature of contact. They also suggest both that the natives, however different, are human beings who should be treated as such, and that the Europeans are entrusted with a mission that makes sense only if their supremacy remains unquestioned throughout the ritual of interaction. As is implied by the necessity of the permanence of such rules, Cook and his crew are thus repeatedly confronted with a major difficulty: they must choose how close to, or how distant from the natives they want to be. Hawkesworth’s narrative first describes such relationships in terms not of cultural exchange, but of ‘territoriality’ – the ground each covers in the presence of the other party, so that the right distance between the two is maintained.11 The Journal is replete with notations concerning the spatial distance that separates the two groups, whether at Tahiti, in New Zealand or in Australia. An apt image of the gap between the savages and the civilized is thus to be found in the stretches of water lying between Cook’s ship and the Maoris’ canoes: ‘At this time we saw several canoes standing cross the bay’,12 ‘About fifty of them seemed to wait for our landing, on the opposite side of the river’.13 In Australia and in New Zealand, what is immediately noticeable about the natives’ attitude is their obvious, whether real or pretended, lack of interest in the newcomers, with the
86
British Narratives of Exploration
unforeseen result that direct, face-to-face contact cannot in fact be established.14 Cook is very eager to bridge the gap and ‘establish an intercourse with them’,15 but there is nothing in the narrative that suggests that the other party is interested in communicating or exchanging with the Europeans. So that when Cook and his men decide to bridge the distance and approach the islanders, diffidence is replaced with violence, and territoriality becomes a hot issue. The meeting ground is seen as a highly unstable zone, in which proximity may be a source of danger, to both sides. At one point, in New Zealand, a sailor, feeling threatened by the attitude of the islanders, fires his musket over the natives’ heads, meaning to scare them off, and thus to re-establish a safe distance between the two parties. But these tribes have never seen white men before, and know nothing consequently about gunpowder; still undeterred, they move closer, which causes the marine to shoot this time at a native and kill him.16 Hawkesworth’s text strongly suggests that the attack on the marines had been premeditated and that the islanders were the aggressors, not suspecting once that encroaching on native land without having been formally invited to do so might have been perceived as a form of aggression. His account draws a vivid picture of savages rushing out of the woods, brandishing lances: ’When we had got some distance from the boat, four men, armed with long lances, rushed out of the woods . . . in a few minutes [they] renewed the pursuit, brandishing their lances in a threatening manner’.17 Once more, Hawkesworth’s grammatical choices serve to underscore the spatial movements in which communication seems to be caught, implicitly reshuffling the uncertain ground of interaction into two distinct, antagonistic communities. When they hear the sailor’s musket, the Europeans huddle together and become a compact ‘we’ facing the indiscriminate ‘they’ of the Maoris: ‘they went back, dragging after them the dead body, which however they soon left, that it might not incumber their flight. At the report of the first musquet we drew together, having straggled to a little distance from each other, and made the best of our way back to the boat’.18 What Hawkesworth’s narrative also suggests is that the ‘we’ of the Europeans is welded together by values – solidarity, respect for the dead – which do not seem to prevail among the fierce savages. The narrator’s ‘I’ – Cook’s assumed voice – only reappears in Hawkesworth’s account when he has Cook remember his instructions and decide to re-establish contact: As I was desirous to establish an intercourse with them, I ordered three boats to be manned with seamen and marines, and proceeded towards the shore, accompanied by Mr. Banks [ Joseph Banks, the naturalist and botanist of the expedition], Dr. Solander, the other Gentlemen, and Tupia [a Tahitian serving as guide and interpreter]; about fifty of them seemed to wait for our landing, on the opposite side of the river, which we thought a sign of fear, and seated themselves upon the ground: at
Distance and Proximity in James Cook’s First Voyage around the World (1768–71)
87
first, therefore, myself, with only Mr. Banks, Dr. Solander, and Tupia, landed from the little boat, and advanced towards them.19
This time again, the grammar of the text is symptomatic of the predicament in which Cook and his men find themselves. Whereas the Europeans are clearly identified and named, the savages are only referred to through an unspecified, collective ‘them’; what is more, ‘I’ and ‘them’ are repeatedly positioned at opposite ends in the sentences. The Europeans’ hesitations are marked both by the shifts from the ‘I’ to the ‘we’, indicating intense debate in the boats between Cook and his companions, and by the verb inflections which express the doubts with which the ‘Gentlemen’ seem to be agonized (‘seemed to’, ‘we thought’). Finally, the narrowing of the distance between the two parties, as Cook and his men advance towards the islanders, is a source of suspense, the outcome of the meeting being marked b