Biopesticides
METHODS
IN
BIOTECHNOLOGY’”
John M. Walker, SERIES EDITOR 12 EnvironmentalMonitoring of Bacteria,edit...
180 downloads
4126 Views
41MB Size
Report
This content was uploaded by our users and we assume good faith they have the permission to share this book. If you own the copyright to this book and it is wrongfully on our website, we offer a simple DMCA procedure to remove your content from our site. Start by pressing the button below!
Report copyright / DMCA form
Biopesticides
METHODS
IN
BIOTECHNOLOGY’”
John M. Walker, SERIES EDITOR 12 EnvironmentalMonitoring of Bacteria,edited by CloveEdwards, 1999 11 AqueousTwo-PhaseSystems, edited by Rap Hattl-Kuul, 1999 10. CarbohydrateBiotechnologyProtocols,edited by Chrrstopher Bucke, 1999 9. DownstreamProcessingMethods,edited by Mohamed LIesal, 1999 8 Animal Cell Biotechnology,edlted by Nlgel Jenkms, 1999 7. Affinity Biosensors:Techniques and Protocols, edlted by Km R Rogers and Ashok Mulchandanr, 1998
6. Enzymeand Microbial Biosensors:Techniques and Protocols, edlted by 5. 4. 3. 2. 1
Ashok Mulchandam and Kern R Rogers, 1998 Biopesticides:Use and Delivery, edited by Frankhn R. Hall and Julius J. Menn, 1999 Natural ProductsIsolation, edited by Rxhard J P Cunnell, 1998 RecombinantProteinsfrom Plants:Prod&on and Isolation of Clinically Useful Compounds, edited by Charles Cunmngham and AndrewJ R Porter, 1998 BioremediationProtocols,edited by David Sheehan, 1997 Immobilizationof Enzymesand Cells, edited by Gordon F Blckerstafi 1997
Biopesticides Use and Delivery
Edited by
Franklin R. Hall Ohio State Unwersity, Wooster, OH
and
Julius J. Menn Excipula, Inc , Highland, MD
Humana
Press
Totowa, New Jersey
0 1999 Humana Press Inc 999 RIvervIew Drive, Suite 208 Totowa, New Jersey 075 I2 All rrghts reserved No part of this book may be reproduced, stored m a retrieval system, or transmltted m any form or by any means, electromc, mechamcal, photocopymg, mlcrofilmmg, recording, or otherwlse wlthout wrttten permIssIon from the Publisher Methods m Blotechnologyc\* IS a trademark of The Humana Press Inc All authored papers, comments, opmlons, conclusions, do not necessarily reflect the views of the publisher This publlcatlon IS printed on acid-free ANSI 239 48-1984 (American Standards Permanence of Paper for Prmted Library Covet Brian
lllustratlon A FederIc
Cover
design
Fig
by Patricia
For additional copies, Humana at the above E-mall
I A m Chapter
or recommendations
are those
of the author(s),
and
paper @ Institute) Materials I6 “Naturally
Occurrmg
Baculovlruses
for Insect
Pest Control,”
by
F Cleary pricing address
humanaahumanapr
for bulk purchases, and/or mformatlon or at any of the followmg numbers Tel corn,
or visit
our Webslte
about other 973-256-1699, http //humanapress corn
Humana Fax
titles, contact 973-256-834 1,
Photocopy Authorization Policy: Authorlzatlon to photocopy items for internal or personal use, or the Internal or personal use of specific clients, IS granted by Humana Press Inc , provtded that the base fee of US $8 00 per copy, plus US $00 25 per page, IS paid directly to the CopyrIght Clearance Center at 222 Rosewood Drive, Danvers, MA 01923 For those orgamzattons that have been granted a photocopy license from the CCC, a separate system of payment has been arranged and IS acceptable to Humana Press Inc The fee code for usersofthe TransactIonal Reporting Service IS [O-89603-5 15-8198 $8 00 + $00 251 Printed
m the Umted
Library
of Congress
Mam
entry
Methods
under
States Cataloging
of America m Pubhcatlon
IO 9 8 7 6 5 4 3 2
I
Data
title
In biotechnology’*
Blopesttcldes
use and dellvery/edlted by Franklm R Hall and Juhus J Menn cm --(Methods In biotechnology, 5) P Includes Index ISBN O-89603-5 15-8 (alk paper) I Natural pestlctdes 2 BIologIcal pest control agents 3 Agrrcultural 1 Hall, Franklin R II Menn, Juhus J III Series SB95l I45 M37B56 1998 632’ 954~2 I 98-25118 CIP
pests-Blologtcal
control
Preface It was our intention and goal to bring together m Biopestzcides Use and the latest advances in the science and technology of the evolving field of biopesticides In the context of crop protectton, btopesttcides are a key component of integrated pest management (IPM) programs, m which biopesticides are delivered to crops m inundative quantities, vs the moculative approach, which is charactertstic of classical biological control. Although there are several definitions of biopesttcides m the literature, we chose to define them as either microbials themselves or products derived from microbials, plants, and other biological entities. In the developed, industrial countries, primarily in Western Europe and the United States, biopesticides are receiving more practical attention, smce they are viewed as a means to reduce the load of synthetic chemical pestttides m an effort to provide for safer foods and a cleaner envtronment. In the developing countries, biopestictdes are viewed as having the potential to exploit nattve resources to produce crop protection agents that would replace imported chemical pesticides and conserve much-needed hard currencies These trends are well represented by the dynamic growth of engineered crops expressing the delta-endotoxm insecticidal protem crystals of Bacillus thuringzenszs (B.t ) m corn, cotton, and potatoes and the development of recombinant B.t.s and biopesticides as key crop protection agents against such pests as the soybean caterpillar, which is effectively controlled by a nuclear polyhedrous virus m Brazil, the use of neem extracts m East Africa and India, and various botamcals m East Africa and South America. The btopesticide market is expected to grow at a rate of 10% per year vs l--2% for chemical pesticides. The current biopesticide market IS estimated at $500 million worldwtde At the projected rate of growth, the sales volume ~111 double by the year 2007. It is likely that major breakthroughs m biopesticide technology ~111further increase the rate of growth of biopesttcide usage A pertinent example mvolves the efforts by several multmattonal companies to produce baculoviruses m deep fermentation Success m this area could provide a major boost to the mcorporation of baculoviruses as major crop protection agents m the biopesticide armamentarmm. Delavery
V
Preface
VI
We do not view biopesticides as replacements for chemtcal pesticides on major crops Biopesticides, viewed realistically, will most likely find uses as supplements to chemical pesticrdes and as rotation agents m early season on major crops to retard the onset of resistance. Other uses that will increase the acceptance of biopesticides ~111be m IPM programs on minor crops and niche markets We have mvrted leading experts m the btopesticide field to contribute comprehensive chapters on mode of action, development, productron, dehvery systems (formulations), and market prospects for the future. In addition, we invited registration experts from both government and industry to review current registration requirements, time frames, and costs of registration and compare them with registration requirements of conventtonal pesticides. We also have contributions describing momtormg procedures and management of resistance of pests to biopesticides. It is our goal that this volume will serve as the current, most comprehensive treatise on the rapidly emerging field of btopesttcides and a useful resource for practitioners, students, regulators, and mdustrial planners and marketers. Franklin Julius
R. Hall J. Menn
Contents .. .- . . .. . .. . .. . . . . . ,.,,... . . . .. . .. .. . .. . . .. . . .. . . , V Preface .. . . .. . . . . .. . . . . .., XI Lrst of Contributors . . .. . . .. . . . . , . .. . .. .. . . . .. .. . .. . 1 Biopesticides. Present Status and Future Prospects .. . . . . . . I Julius J. Menn and Franklin R. Hall.. . .. ... . PART I
PROJECTIONS ON OPPORTUNITIES FOR BIOPESTICIDES IN CROP PROTECTION . . . .. . . . .. .. . .. . . . . . . . . ..
..
I1
2 The North American Scenario . .. .. . . . . . .. 13 . . . . *. . .. ., , .. . Jerry Caulder 3 Microbial Bropesticides: The European Scene Tariq M. Butt, John G. Harris, and Keith A. Powell. . . . .. ...*.... . . . 23 4 Developing Countries 45 Balasobramanyan Sugavanam and Xie Tianjian . . . . .. . .. . .. . , . . 5 Pesticide Policy influences on Biopesticide Technologies 55 . . . .,.. . . .. . .. . .. .. . .. . .. . . . . . . . .. . . .. . Noel D. llri . . . . . .. . . 75 . .. . .. . . .. , . .. . .. . .. . . . . . PART I I. BIOFUNGICIDES . . 6 Commercral Development of Brofungicides 77 ...* ,. . Rafael Hofstein and Andrew C. Chapple . 7 Biological Control of Seedlrng Diseases . . . . 103 K. Prakesh Hebbar and Robert D. Lumsden . 8 Joint Action of Microbials for Disease Control .. . . . . 117 Claude Alabouvette and Philippe Lemanceau .. 137 . .. .. . .. . .. . . . . . . .. .. . . . .. . . . .. . . . .. .. . . PART II I BIOINSECTICIDES 9 Neem and Related Natural Products . . . . . . , . . . .. . ,. . . . . .. . . . .. 139 Murray B. lsman 10 Commercial Experience with Neem Products 155 . . .. . .. ... . ,. . James F. Walter 11 Fermentation-Derived Insecticide Control Agents The Spinosyns Thomas C. Sparks, Gary D. Thompson, Herbert A. Kirst, Mark B. Hertlein, Jon S. Mynderse, Jan R. Turner, . .. . . . 171 and Thomas V. Worden . . .. . . . . . . . . . . 12 Baa//us thunng/ensis. Natural and Recombinant Bllomsecticide Products 189 James A. Baum, T. B. Johnson, and Bruce C. Carlton . . .. . . . . vii
*., VIII
Contents
13 Transgenrc Plants Expressing Toxms from Bacillus thuringrems . , . .. . .. Jonnie N. Jenkins 14 Production, Delivery, and Use of Mycoinsectrcides for Control of Insect Pests on Field Crops . Steven P. Wraigt and Raymond 1. Carruthers . 15 Entomopathogemc Nematodes .. . .. , Parwinder Grewal and Ramon Georgis 16 Naturally Occurring Baculovrruses for Insect Pest Control . . . . Brian A. Federici . . . .. . . . 17 Recombinant Baculoiviruses . . .. , . .*.. . . .,... . . .. .. ... Michael F. Treaty 18 Joint Actron of Baculoviruses and Other Control Agents ,.. .. .. William F. McCutchen and Lindsey Flexner . . . . . .. . PART IV BIOHERBICIDES . . . .. . .. . .. . . . . . . .. . .. . .. . .. . .. . . . . . . .. . .. . . .. . , .. . .. .,.,. 19 Mycoherbrcrdes . .. Alice L. Pilgeram and David C. Sands . . . 20 Formulation and Application of Plant Pathogens for Brologrcal Weed Control . . .. . .. .. . Nina K. Zidack and Paul C. Quimby .. . . . PART V OTHER BIORATIONAL TECHNOLOGIES 21 Phereomones for Insect Control. Strategies and Successes . . .. . . .. . . . . D. R. Thomson, L. J. Gut, and J. W. Jenkins . . . . ., PART VI REGISTRATION OF B!OPESTICIDES ,..... ..,. . , , . 22 The Federal Registratron Process and Requirements for the United States .. ... . . .. . ., J. Thomas McClintock , .. . . 23 IR-4 Bropestrcrde Program for Minor Crops . , Christina L. Hartman and George M. Markle 24 RegistratrorYRegulatory Requirements In Europe Mike Neale and Phil Newton .. 25 Environmental and Regulatory Aspects, industry Wew and Approach .. Joseph D. Panetta , .. PART VII MANAGEMENT PROTOCOLS . . .. . 26 Formulatrons of Biopesticides Susan M. Boyetchko, Eric Pedersen, Zamir K. Punja, . . ., , . .. . . and Munagala S. Reddy .. . .. . . . . . .. . . 27 Delivery Systems and Protocols for Biopesticides ,.. ,. .. Roy Bateman ... . .,.* . . *. . . . .. . .* .. .
211
233 271 301
321 34 1 357 359
371
383 385 473
415
443 453 473 485
487 509
ix
Contents 28
Analysis, Momtormg, and Some Regulatory Implications *.*,... . . . ., .. . . . . .. . .. . . Jack R. Piimmer 29 Principles of Dose Aquisitlon for Bioinsecticides . .. . .. . . . .. .. . .* * Hugh F. Evans, .., ..*... . . ....* .. . 30 Strategies for Resistance Management .. .. , . ,. . ., . ..., . . . . .. . .. .. . Richard T. Roush 31 Field Management’ Delivery of New Technologies to Growers .. . Mark E. Whalon and Deborah L. Norris . . . .. .. . . . .*... ..* . . . Index . . .. . . . , . .
529 553 575 .
595 609
Contributors Laboratoire de Recherches SUPla Flare pathogene duns le Sol, Doon, France ROY BATEMAN International Institute of Biologtcal Control, Ascot, UK JAMES A. BAUM Ecogen, Inc., Langhorne, PA SUSAN M. BOYETCHKO Agriculture and Agri-Food Canada, Saskatoon, Canada TARIQ M. BUTT IACR-Rothamsted, Harpenden, UK BRUCE C. CARLTON New Jersey Agrtcultural Experimental Statton, Cook College, Rutgers Untversity, New Brunswick, NJ RAYMOND I. CARRUTHERS National Program Stag USDA/ARS, Beltsvtlle, MD JERRY CAULDER Mycogen Corporation, San Dtego, CA ANDREW CHAPPLE Ecogen, Inc., Langhorne, PA HUGH F EVANS Forestry Commtsston Research Agency, Wreccleshan, UK BRIAN A. FEDERICI Department of Entomology and Interdepartmental Graduate Program tn Genetics, University of California, Riverside, CA LINDSEY FLEXNER DuPont Agricultural Research Center, Newark, DE RAMON GEORGIS Therm0 Trtlogy Corp., Columbta, MD PARWINDER GREWAL Department of Entomology, Ohio State Untverstty, Wooster, OH L. J. GUT Department of Entomology, Michigan State University, East Lanstng, MI FRANKLIN R. HALL Ohto State University. Wooster, OH JOHN G. HARRIS Zeneca Agrochemicals, Bracknell, UK CHRISTINA L. HARTMAN IR-4 Biopesticide Coordinator, Rutgers, The State Untverstty of New Jersey, New Brunswick, NJ Present Address. Agricultural Products Research Division, American Cyanamid Co , Princeton, NJ K. PRAKESH HEBBAR USDA/ARS, Beltsvtlle, MD MARK B. HERTLEIN DowElanco Discovery Research, Indianapolis, IN RAPHAEL HOFSTEIN Ecogen, Inc., Langhorne, PA MURRAY B. ISMAN Department of Plant Science, University of Brtttsh Columbia, Vancouver, Canada CLAUDE ALABOUVETTE
l
l
l
l
l
l
l
l
l
l
l
l
l
l
l
l
l
l
l
l
l
l
xi
xii
Contributors
JOHNIE N. JENKINS
Crop Sctence Research Laboratory, USDA/ARS, State, MS J. W. JENKINS Pactfic Btocontrol Corp , LitchJield, AZ TIMOTHY B. JOHNSON Ecogen, Inc , Langhorne, PA HERBERT A. KIRST Elanco Animal Health Research and Development, Greenfield, IN PHILIPPE LEMANCEAU Laboratotre de Recherches sur la Flore pathogene darts le Sol, Dyon, France ROBERT D. LUMSDEN USDA/ARS, Beltsvtlle, MD GEORGE M MARKLE . IR-4 Associate Dtrector/Professor, Rutgers, The State Untverstty of New Jersey, New Brunswtck, NJ J THOMAS MCCLINTOCK USEPA, Washtngton, DC WILLIAM F. MCCUTCHEN DuPont Agricultural Research Center, Newark, DE JULIUS J. MENN 9 Exctpula, Inc , Highland, MD JON S MYNDERSE Lilly Research Laboratories, Elt Lilly and Co, Indtanapolts, IN MIKE NEALE Novartts Crop Protectton, Basel, Switzerland PHIL NEWTON Novartts Crop Protectton, Basel, Swttzerland DEBORAH L. NORRIS Michigan State Unzversity, East Lansing, MI JOSEPH D PANETTA 9 Regulatory and Envtronmental Affairs, Mycogen Corp , San Diego, CA ERIC PEDERSEN Agrtum Inc., Saskatoon, Canada ALICE L. PILGERAM 9 Department of Plant Pathology, Montana State Untverstty, Bozeman, MT JACK R. PLIMMER Tampa, FL KEITH A. POWELL Zeneca Agrochemtcals, Bracknell, UK ZAMIR K PUNJA Centre for Pest Management, Simon Fraser Untverstty, Burnaby, Canada PAUL C. QUIMBY, JR Northern Plains Agrtcultural Research Laboratory, USDA/ARS, Stdney, MT MUNAGALA S. REDDY Saskatoon, Canada RICHARD T. Rousn Department of Crop Protectton, Untverstty of Adelatde, Glen Osmond, Australia DAVID C. SANDS Department of Plant Pathology, Montana State Untverstty, Bozeman, MT THOMAS C. SPARKS DowElanco Dtscovery Research, Indtanapolts, IN BALASUBRAMANYAN SUGAVANAM UNIDO, China GARY D. THOMPSON DowElanco Dtscovery Research, Indtanapolts, IN D. R. THOMSON Pact@ Btocontrol Corp , Vancouver, WA l
Mississippt
l
l
l
l
l
l
l
l
l
l
l
l
l
l
l
l
l
l
l
l
l
l
l
Contributors
xii
XIE TIANJIAN UNIDO, China MICHAEL F TREACY Amerctan Cyanamid Co., Prtnceton, NJ JAN R TURNER Ltlly Research Laboratones, Elt Lilly and Co , l
l
l
Indtanapolts, IN NOEL D. URI Economtc Research Service, US Department of Agriculture, Washington, DC JAMES F. WALTER Rohm and Haas Co., Philadelphia, PA MARK E. WHALON 9 Michigan State Untverstty, East Lansing, MI THOMAS V. WORDEN DowElanco Discovery Research, Indtanapolts, IN STEPHEN P WRAIGH~ Plant Protectron Research Unit, US Plant, Soil, and Nutrition Laboratory, USDA/ARS, Ithaca, NY NINA K. ZIDACK Department of Plant Pathology, Montana State Untverstty, Bozeman, MT l
l
l
l
l
1 Biopesticides Present Status and Future Prospects Julius J. Menn and Franklin R. Hall
1. Introduction Bropestlcrdes, mcludmg mrcrobral pestrctdes,entomopathogenic nematodes, baculoviruses, plant derrved pestrcides, and Insect pheromones, the latter when used as mating drsruptlon agents, are recetvmg increased exposure m scientific annals and the lay press, as alternatrves to chemical pestrctdesand as key components of integrated pest management (IPM) systems(2,2). The reality, however, IS that biopesticrdes currently represent only a small fractron of the world pestrcide market. At the present time, various economrc forecasting servtces estrmated the world market for pesticides m 1995 at approx $29 btlhon 0. The bropestrcrde share of the market was estimated to be around $380 million in 1995 (1). Although representing only 1.3% of the total, and since the majority of bropesticides are currently marketed for insect control, blopesttcides represent approx 4.5% of the world insecticide sales. However, the growth rate for bropestrcrdes over the next 10 years has been forecast at 1O-l 5% per annum m contrast to 2% for chemical pesticides (2) The foregoing IS based on several assumpttons that are predicated on the successor failure of several technologies; notably, transgemc crops expressing Baczllus thuringzensis (Bt) insect protein toxins. Should the latter be successful and allowmg that Bt engineered crops are m the biopesttcide arena, the growth rate of biopestrcides will be much greater than forecast The potential for resistance developmg to B&engineered crops m lepldopterans may alter the equatron stgmficantly. Furthermore, the agrochemlcal mdustry has been introducing recently hrghly Insect-pest-specific insecticrdes wrth modes of actlon From
Methods F R Hall
m B/otechno/ogy, and
J J Menn.
vol 5 B/opestmdes eds
0 Humana
1
Press,
Use and De//very Totowa,
NJ
2
Menn and Hall
that are targeted to pest species.Such selective msectlcldes may also slow down the rate of growth of blopestlcldes. However, the science, technology, and marketing of blopesticldes are forging ahead as key components of IPM and sustamable agriculture. In this volume we have brought together a select group of biopesticlde experts reporting on the current status and prospects for blopestlcldes, their role m crop protection, delivery systems,monitormg resistance management, marketing, reglstratlon and pohcles influencing their future prospects. It IS our mtent to provide the readers of this volume with the state of knowledge, current status, and future prospects for blopestlcldes as key components of IPM programs in contemporary agriculture. 2. Opportunities for Biopesticides The followmg discussion highlights chapters included m this volume. The prospects and economic projections for bropesttcldes m the United States, Europe, and developing countries are discussed m Chapters 2, 3, and 4 The current state of blopestlclde development for the Unlted States (Chapter 2) 1s presented from an industry standpoint and although optlmlstlc, expectations for future commercializations are tempered by a plea for increased coordmatlon by industry, academics, growers, and others, because of the need to more effectively utilize these tools within the context of IPM, transgemc plants, and so forth. The European scene (Chapter 3) 1sa detailed descrlptlon of some of the microbial experiences and lrkewlse calls for added support from Extension/industry m the “implementation” phase. In the developing countries (Chapter 4), experiences (mainly with Bt) m China, Thailand, and other countries are identified wherein quality control, education, and a request for more activity from international organizations will aid the transfer of blopestlcide technology to active usage as complementary technologies to chemical pestlcldes, rather than as “mere replacements ” As a final component to the sectlon on opportumtles, pesticide pohcy issues, constraints and incentives for new technologies, and the recent impact of US legislation are outlined m Chapter 5 Although the outlook IS comphcated, the key factors of pesticide regulation, the Fan Act and Food Quality Protection Act (FQPA), government subsidies affecting crop dlverslty, management expertise with ecologlcally based systems, and “demand” for green produce will influence technology identification and lmplementatlon 3. Biofungicides In a section focusing on Blofunglcldes, it 1s clear that relatively few blofunglcldes have reached marketing status to date. AQ 1O@1sa recent mtroduction as a control agent against powdery mildew of fruit, primarily grapes
Blopes trades
3
(Chapter 6; ref. 3). These authors provide a well-documented roadmap of laboratory and field experiences with AQlO@ that should serve as a clear guide to “what works and what doesn’t” m developing a better understandmg of these btoagents n-rthe drffcult “real world ” As the authors conclude, dtssectmg the molecular elements contributing to fungal pathogenrcity will indeed aid progress m thts arena as we attempt to insure that all possrble attributes are expressed m targeting thts brofungtctde. It will be interesting to follow the fortunes of thts proneermg mtroductron m competttton wtth an old establtshed product, such as sulfur, and newer selective chemrcal fungtcrdes. Brofungrcrdes for control of seedling diseases, such as pythmm, fusarmm, rhizoctoma, and vertrcillmm, have received mcreasmg attention m recent years (41, primarily as nontoxrc, nonresidue producmg control agents. The utrhty and development of Glzocladzumvzrens for control of sorlborne pathogens IS described m Chapter 7, and the authors emphasize the necessity of a logical, well-documented series of studies from dtscovery through ecologtcal understanding and final usage studies m order to fully develop opportunmes for seedlmg brocontrol agents. Joint actton of brofungtctdes IS a relatively new area of mvestrgatton. Joint actton, or posstbly synergy, may increase the utrhty of brofungicrdes, as was demonstrated by combmmg a nonpathogemc strain of Fusarzum oxysporum wtth a strain of Pseudomonasfluorescens to control Fusarzum wilts (5) More recent advances m this mterestmg arena are described m Chapter 8. In thts complex array of poorly understood interacttons, It IS clear that good knowledge of antagomsts and then behavior are key constraints to more raprd commerctalrzatron It IS likely that niche markets may well prove to be useful starting points for marketing these btocontrol agents 4. Bioinsecticides Broinsecttcrdes represent the maJor segment of bropesticldes and comprrse the largest array of diverse mtcrobrals and natural products m the bropestrcrde armamentarium. Chapters 9 and 10 deal primarily with neem seed derived products and neem or1 as insect growth regulators, antrfeedants, msectrcrdes, and fungicides, and provide a clear outline of the hrstory and the current and future status of neem-related products. The potential of Azadnachtm, the prmctpal Insect-active macrocyclic lactone component of neem seed 011, has broad msectrcrdal actrvrty that makes rt an attractive candidate insecticide for specralty and niche crops (6). To date, the most economrcally significant bromsectrcrdes were the avermectms, derived by fermentation of a streptomyces species and chemrtally defined as macrocylic lactones The most notable are abamectrn (avermectm Bl) and Its chemrcally modified analog, Emamectm benzoate
4
Menn and Hall
(MK-244). These blomsectlcldes were described m numerous publlcatlons, including ref. 7. More recently, a chemically related class of fermentation-derived msectlcldes, the spmosyns from Succharopolyspora species, was introduced by DowAgroSclences (8). The lead member IS spmosad, with excellent msectlcldal activity against lepldopterous larvae and other msects (Chapter 1I). An Interesting story describing Its development 1s hlghhghted by the authors’ awareness of resistance management and the opportunities to develop a unique set of molecules possessingsafe envlronmental and mammalian profiles, while at the same time proving to be selective, and thus somewhat market restricted. Clearly, there would seem to be “more to come” from this group of interesting bioactive naturally derived products. The best known group of blopestlcides, the Bts, are also produced by fermentation but yield insectlcldal crystal proteins rather than discrete chemicals, such as the spmosyns and avermectins By selection of natural Isolates from the thousands known, as well as those derived from plasmtd conJugatlon and recombinant DNA technology, it has become feasible to tailor make Bts that are targeted against specific insect pests (9,ZO; Chapter 12). Although identifying the limitations of field persistence and mcomplete coverage of target surfaces, the authors project a positive outlook for this vast array of toxins as attractive alternatives to existing products. The successwill depend on developments m improved formulations and an improved understanding of dosetransfer processes (as is the case with almost every blopestlcldal agent). The Bt technology has been taken a step further by engineering cotton, corn, and other crops to express truncated versions of the cryIA genes from Bt vanety kurstaki Engineered plants provide protection against certain lepidopterous larvae, notably Heliothis vzrexens, a major pest of cotton and corn (IO; Chapter 13). Although the picture looks bright as indicated by the recent flurry of merger activity among seed, chemical, and biotechnology companies, such as Monsanto, DuPont, AgrEvo, and others, rt IS tempered with a divergence of opmrons about llmltatlons resulting from pest resistance. As noted m Chapters 14 and 30 (under management strategies), one of the key concerns mvolvmg transgemc crops expressing Bt toxins IS the potential for resistance development m target insects. Contmuous exposure to the toxin challenge has a high probablllty for selection of reslstant mdlvlduals. Strategies have been developed to delay and/or ameliorate the onset of resistance mvolvmg establishment of refugia and high expression of Bt protein toxins in engineered plants (12,13) Entomopathogenic fungi (mycoinsecticldes) are gaming increased attention as environmentally friendly insect control agents. Although over 750 species were reported to infect insects, few have received serious conslderatlon as potential commercial candidates. Beauverza bassiana appears to have the
Biopestmdes
5
broadest potential as a viable msect control agent (14). The status of this area of insect control IS identified m Chapter 14. Technological advances m production, formulation, and shelf life have contributed substantially to the viabtlrty of mycoinsectictdes as practtcal insect management agents that can compete economically with chemical insecticides in certain situations, such as fruit and specialty crops. A comprehensive review of the use of entomopathogemc nematodes is covered m Chapter 15 Summarizing the rapid commercialization (prmctpally in the 199Os), the authors relate these successesto large-scale productton technology and innovative formulations allowing shelf stability that has allowed a cottage-type industry to emerge in both the United States and Europe. An ongoing plea IS made for more integration of crop protection technologies and technology transfer trainmg; both are emphasized as constraints to continued progress. Baculoviruses are summarized in three chapters dtscussmg natural (Chapter 16) and recombinant (Chapter 17) baculovnuses, as well as experiences with jomt action of baculovu-uses with other control agents (Chapter 18) Baculoviruses have already been employed as biopesticides m the United States, m the 1970s for control of the cotton bollworm, Helicoverpa zea, m cotton and the gypsy moth, Lymantrza dispar, m forests. However, the product, Elcar, for control of H. zea failed as a commercial entity, largely resultmg from inability to compete with the then newly introduced pyrethroids, mstabthty in the field, slow action, and narrow spectrum of bioactivity (15). In contrast, considerable success m control of the velvetbean caterpillar, Anticawa gemmatalis, was achieved m Brazil on large soybean acreage (16, Chapter 16). However, these represent isolated cases of successful field use of baculovnuses. Broader use was precluded as a result of the already listed shortcommgs. With the advent of recombmant DNA technology, baculoviruses have received renewed attentton because of their small genome and uncomplicated molecular organization, allowmg for ready mtroductton of quick-acting msect toxic genes, such as an engineered portion of the scorpion toxin, AaIT, which greatly improves the field performance of the engineered baculovuus by killing the pest insects more rapidly (17,28; Chapters 17 and 18). An improved understanding of the toxtctty processes involved with the joint action of baculovirus with other toxins and chemical pesticides may jump start this group of viruses to greater market potentials. 5. Bioherbicides Btologtcal weed control (bioherbicides) has been actively pursued for several years, primarily m academic and government research institutions. To date, over 100 weed pathogens have been reported (19). However, only a handful of
6
Menn and Hall
bioherbictdes have entered commercial channels with very limited success, primarily because of their mabihty to compete with chemical herbicides that are specific, economic, and pose no environmental and residue hazard. However, bioherbicides are ideally suited for control of undesirable vegetation m pasture and rangeland, where the use of chemical herbtctdes would be prohibitively expensive (Chapters 19 and 20) 6. Other Technologies The successful development of pheromone based insect mating disruption m fruit trees and vineyards m North America and Western Europe has given pheromones a new dtmension as biopestictdes and provides promise that this technology, using pheromones as biocontrol agents, ~111reduce dependence on chemical pesticides for insect control m orchards and vmeyards (Chapter 2 1). 7. Registration of Biopesticides In recogrntton of the White House polictes concernmg environmental quality improvements and reduced dependence on chemical pesticides, wtth stated but unlikely attainable goals that 75% of chemical pesticides will be replaced with biopesticides by the year 2000, the USEPA established a Biopestictdes Pollution and Prevention Divtsion (BPPD) to manage accelerated registration and registration of biopesticides. The BPPD approved for registration 14 new biopestlctdes m 1995 and 10 m 1996, representing 35-40% of all new pesticide registrations. The average duration for registration of a btopesticide has been 12 mo vs 36-45 mo for a conventional chemtcal pesttctde. Furthermore, the agency required stgmficantly fewer data for a biopesticide m support of fmdmg no significant adverse effect to humans and the environment. The agency provides for an expedited review of the registrant’s application, the tolerance fee 1s waived, and requirements for an emergency use permit (EUP) may also be waived. The registration and associated policies m the US and Europe are described m detail m Chapters 22 and 24. The enlightened pohcuesand regulations governing btopesticides are especially sigmficant with regard to the approval process for use of biopestictdes on minor crops involvmg the IR-4 program (Chapter 23). The views of the industry relating to recent “safer” policies, by USEPA and other agenctes, are described m Chapter 25 Future expectations are tempered by the expressed need (by industry) for greater incentives provided by the USEPA, a renewed focus on clarifymg the benefits of such agents, greater coordmation/consolidation of databases, and greater flextbility m registration processes to provide recognition and encouragement of these more selective molecules offering greater environmental and human safety.
Biopes ticides
7
8. Management Protocols Completmg the “hfe cycle of development” of crop protection biopestictdes IS that area that seemsto be mcreasrngly important in successfultmplementation of more complex molecules/strategres,i.e., user management.Biopestrcides,posstbly even more so than chemical pesticides,are very dependenton proper formulatton and delivery systemsas key elements in performance. Furthermore, shelf life and ratesof apphcation are also largely a function of appropnate formulations (Chapters 26 and 27). Momtonng the fate of biopesticidespost application 1salso critical m determimng efficacy and survival of btocontrol microbials. Much of the momtormg scienceand technology ISrelatively new and mvolves growing emphasisand attention to this area(Chapter 28). The doseacquisttion(including pest encounter)processes(and realitiesof poor use efficiencies)arejust now being betterunderstoodandtranslatedto improved placement cnterra for thesemolecules.Chapter29 provides a somewhatspectficbut unique look into the array of detailsneededfor anoptimizeduse.It provides an interestingcorollary to the storyrelatedin Chapter6, I.e.,the researchexperiences,researchma1successand failures with AQ 10 However, whethercompaniesarereadyto assumeagreaterrole in more basicstudiesmvolvmg this technologyis yet unknown. Resistance management 1sa recurring theme throughout, with recogmtion bemg given to this Important phase of developing any crop protection agent. Chapter 30 provides some interesting points about the practicality of managing resrstance, which is mcreasmgly receiving much attention by the industry, A final thrust to the story of bropesticide development covers the user acceptance of increasingly complex crop protection strategies (Chapter 3 1) These new crop protection agents (biopesticldes) are more specific, lessrobust m environmental persistence, require more precise timing, offer significant opportumtres as alternatives to conventional pesticides, yet clearly are not quite as reliable. Management of information, monitormg, and use profiles will help m achieving success,but this will require additional grower education by all parties concerned with education and technology transfer of new crop protectton strategies. Continued emphasis by the industry on conventional chemistries as the “development model” for pesticides, the lack of new visionary thmkmg about long-term economic and ecological benefits of biopesticides, and needed educational thrusts about cosmetic standards, performance expectations, and detailed use requirements remam serious constraints hmitmg this technology (20). 9. Conclusions In summary, bropesttcides are achieving a modicum of growth as alternatives to conventional pesticides. However, their full potential has yet to be reached. The key factors/trends envisioned to significantly impact future developments mclude the following
Menn and Hall Regulatory/legislative and economic pohcles, mcludmg the new FQPA, may encourage further growth via fast trackmg/reduced reglstratlon reqmrements for bloratlonals. Developed country policies (globally) will continue to press for safer materials and alternatives to chemical pestlcldes, mcludmg more complex crop protectlon strategies, such as IPM/ICM, and others Developing countries have already mltlated thrusts to more efficiently utlhze such materials User education m both cases remains a serious constraint for Increased growth of blopesticldes Greater attention by industry/academra to reduced risk agendas (human and envlronment), as well as an Improved identlficatlon of the economic benefits profile of a crop protection strategy will greatly aid a sustainable growth of bropestlcldes Industry experiences such as with AQ 10, further illustrate the need for a comprehensive review of the plant/disease ecosystem complexity regarding the reduced reliance on the sole “conventional wisdom” approach of tradltlonal pestlcldes Blopestlcldes are more specific, more complex, less robust m the environment, and require greater knowledge about the ecosystem mteractlons. Partnermg of expertise will engender greater successwith these more complex agents, 1e , mterdlsclphnary teams must be the accepted norm m the development strategy There must be continued recogmtlon of the “power” of the transgetuc technology to influence a sustainable agriculture and plans made for such options as reslstance management, pestlclde pohcy mfluences on crop diversity, density, and other variables, frequency of planting, and so forth. Recogmtlon by the industry that “delivery” Is an essential part of the crop protection use pattern ~111 aid the speed of user acceptance of blopestlcldes Contmuatlon of the emphasis on environmental and ecotoxiclty requirements should aid increased acceptance and registration of btopestlcldes, whrch will probably remam in niche crops. The ldentificatlon and utrllzatlon of natural plant defense mechamsms interfaced with temporal/spatial phenomena may reveal an mterestmg array of new product opportunities. Industry willingness to mvest more than the traditional knowledge/ marketing skills m this approach wdl dictate ultimate success. Recent industry mergers and amalgamations accompamed by developments m transgemc technologies and value-added products would suggest not only unique crop protection opportumtles, but also reveal a powerful agenda m life science strategies for the new millennium agriculture.
References 1 Menn, J J (1997) Blopestlcldes-are they relevant7 m Focus on Blopestzcrdes, The Royal Society of Chemistry, pp, 1,2. 2 Menn, J J (1996) Biopestlcldes Has then time come? J Envrron ,%I Health B 31(3), 383-389.
3 Daust, R A and Hofstem, R. (1996) Ampelomyces quuqualu, a new blofunglclde to control powdery mildew rn grapes Brrghton Crop Protection Conference on Pests and Diseases-November 18-2 1, 1996, BrIghton, UK, 1, 33-40.
Biopes ticides
9
Papavizas, G. C. (1985) Trichoderma and Ghocladmm: biology, ecology, and potential for blocontrol. Ann Rev Phytopathol 23,23-54. Alabouvette, C. (1996) Blological control of Fusarium wilts IOBC wprs Bulletln/Bulletln OILB srop 19(8), 58
Leskovar, D. I. and Boales, A K (1996) Azadlrachtm: potential use for controlling lepidopterous insects and increasing marketability of cabbage Hort Scr 31(3),405-409
Mrozlk, H (1994) Advances m research and development of Avermectms, m Natural and Engineered Pest Management Agents (Hedm, P A , Menn, J. J , and Hollingworth, R. M , eds.), ACS Symposium Series, vol 551, no 5, American Chemical Society, Washington, DC, pp. 54-73. 8 Larson, L L , Sparks, T C , Worden, T V., Winkle, J. R., Thompson, G D., Klrst, H A., and Mynderse, J. S. (1996) Spmosad, the first members of a new class of Insect control products, the Naturalytes Proc. XX Znternatlonal Congress ofEntomology 19-009, 9
10.
11
12 13.
587
Carlton, B. C. (1992) Development of improved bloinsectlcldes based on Bacdlus thuringzensis,m PestControlwzthEnhancedEnvironmentalSafe@(Duke, S O., Menn, J J , and Phmmer, J. R , eds.), ACS Symposmm Senes, vol. 524, no. 18, American Chemical Society, Washington DC, pp 258-266. Carlton, B C (1993) Genetics of BT insecticidal crystal proteins and strategies for the construction of improved strains, in Proceedings of the X&W Be&v&e Symposzum(Lumsden, R. D. and Vaughn, J, L , eds.), ARS, USDA, Beltsvdle, MD, pp 326-337 Jenkms, J. N. (1993) Use of Bacrllus thurlnglensls genes m transgenlc cotton to control lepldopterous insects (Duke, S 0 , Menn, J J , and Pllmmer, J. R., eds ), ACS Symposium Series, vol. 524, no 19, American Chemical Society, Washington, DC, pp 267-280 Tabashnik, B E (1995) Resistance to msectlctdes, Bacillus, and transgemc plants Pestle. Outlook 6(4), 24-27 Tabashmk, B. E , Malvar, T , Lm, Y-B., Finson, N., Borthakur, D., Shin, BS , Park, S-H , Masson, L., Maagd, R. A., and Bosch, D. (1996) Crossresistance of the DIamondback moth indicates altered interactions with domam II of Bacillus thurlngienszs toxins. Appl Environ Mlcrobzol 62(8), 2839-2844,
14 Feng, M. G., Poprawskl, T. J., and Khachatounans, G. G (1994) Production, formulation and application of the entomopathogemc fungus Beauverla basslana for Insect control. current status. Blocontrol SczenceTechnol 4, 3-34 15 Huber, J (1986) Use of baculovlruses m pest management programs, m The Bzology ofBaculovtruses, vol. 2 (Granados, R R and Fedenci, B. A , eds.), CRC, Boca Raton, FL, pp I8 l-202 16. Moscardl, F. (1988) Production and use of entomopathogens m Brazil, m Bzotechnology, Blologlcal Pesticidesand Novel Plant-Pest Resistancefor Insect Pest Management (Roberts, D. W. and Granados, R. R., eds.), Cornell University
Press, Ithaca, NY, pp 53-60
10
Menn and Hall
17 Bonnmg, B C and Hammock, B D. (1996) Development of recombmant baculovuuses for insect control Ann Rev Entomol 41, 191-2 10 18 Kmg, L A , Possee, R D , Hughes, D S., Atkmson, A E , Palmer, C P , Marlow, S A , Ptckermg, J M , Joyce, K A , Lawrte, A M , Mtller, D P , and Beadle, D. J (1994) Advances m Insect vtrology Adv. Insect Physlol 25, l-73 19 Zorner, P S , Evans, S L , and Savage, S D (1993) Perspecttves on provtdmg a reallsttc techmcal foundanon for the commerctahzatton of btoherbtcrdes, in Pest control with Enhanced Envwonmental Safety (Duke, S 0, Menn, J J , and Plrmmer, J. R., eds ), ACS Symposmm Series, vol 524, no 6, American Chemtcal Society, Washmgton, DC, pp 79-86 20 Gaugler, R (1997) Alternative paradigms for commercializing btopesttctdes Phytoparasltzca 25(3), 179-l 82
I
PROJECTIONS ONOPPORTUNITIES FOR BIOPESTICIDES IN CROPPROTECTION
2 The North American Scenario Jerry Caulder 1. Historical Trends and Highlights of Significant Advances The first glimmermg that microbes could be used to control msects is generally traced back to 1834 when Aogostmo Bassi discovered that a fungus, Beauveria basslana, caused an mfectious disease m the stlkworm. However, it was not unttl some 40 yr later that the first attempts were made to use insect pathogens to control pest populations, when Metchnikoff m Russia expertmented with A4etarhizium anzsoplzae for control of a beetle attacking wheat. Large scale attempts to use Insect pathogens took place in the Umted States toward the end of the 19th century, when a variety of pathogens were evaluated for control of the chmch bug (I). The tdentlflcatlon of bactertal pathogens of insectswas not far behind A key dtscovery took place in 190 1 when Ishiwata discovered a Bacdlus spp attackmg the silkworm Berliner discovered the same species mfectmg flour moths m Germany in 1915, and named the organism Bacrllus thurrng~ensu (Bt), after the German province of Thueringen (2), At the same time, others were looking elsewhere for novel ways to control msect pests and decrease the substantial crop losses they caused each year. Insecticidal chemicals were identified from a variety of sources,mcludmg such compounds as lead arsenate, as well as natural plant compounds, such as the pyrethrins and mcotme. In 1939, the era of the synthetic organic msecttctdes was ushered m with the discovery by Mueller of the msectictdal properties of DDT. The excellent efficacy and low cost of petrochemrcal-based compounds like DDT, coupled with then quack kill and broad spectrum of actrvtty, quickly made them the universal standards for controllmg Insect and mite pests. Research with biopesticrdes contmued to advance, with tdentification of new strains and species of pathogens and their metabolites. But it was not until the From Methods UI Biotechnology, vol 5 Btopesbodes Use and Dellvery Edlted by F R Hall and J J Menn 0 Humana Press Inc , Totowa, NJ
13
14
Caulder
1940s that the first btopesttctde product was commerctahzed m the Umted States, when a bacterial product based on Bacllluspoplllae was mtroduced for control of the Japanese beetle. In the 1950s the first Bt products were commercrahzed m the Umted States for control of a vartety of caterpillar pests attackmg crops and forests The greatest advances m the area of btopestrctdes have taken place wtth Bt products. These advances involved isolation of novel strams with htgher potency, as well as tdenttficatton of new strains producmg entirely novel toxms active on different pest species The tdenttficatton of Bt variety tsraelensts (3) as a potent mosqutto larvtctde suggested that Bt toxms could be active on a variety of targets. The 20 yr of research and product development that followed that key discovery have more than borne out those expectations At the same time, the revolution m molecular biology and genetic engmeermg allowed the unique and highly potent 6-endotoxms produced by Bt to be manipulated u-t a variety of ways that substanttally enhance then utthty and performance Some of these key advances are discussed m more detail below.
2. The Biopesticide
Conversion
As we look at the growing interest m bropesttctde-based products, tt 1s easy to see that a maJor trend m agrtculture today 1s a converston of pest management practtces from tradtttonal broad spectrum chemical pesticides to highly specttic btologtcally based products What has created and driven this btologtcal converston, and what are the prospects for btopesttctdes in North America? We can start by notmg the very different approaches involved m tdenttfymg new chemical pesticide leads vs new btopesttctde leads. On the surface, they appear quite stmtlar, because a great deal of drscovery and screening IS mvolved m both types of crop-protectron agents. However, the underlymg concepts are fundamentally different The chemtcal screening approach has htstortcally been very much an Edtsoruan search, i.e., a random screening of thousands of synthesized compounds for pesttctdal acttvtty. This has led to the development of many new compounds with excellent activity at a low cost to farmers Bropesttctdes, on the other hand, are based on btologlcal relationshrps, with mtttal tdenttficatton of a new class of actlves, typically resulting from tsolatton of a pathogen from the target pest or tts envtronment. Once a new active ingredient IS rdenttfied, then the development effort becomes very similar to the chemical approach, m that random screenings agamst insects are mtttated. However, even then, the screening 1s generally more targeted than for a chemtcal screenmg program Thus, the base concept of beginning with biological relattonshtps, such as pathogenests or antagonism, as a strategy for discovermg new acttves, means that the agents identtfted will generally be much more selective m their actton.
North American
Scenario
15
Issues of environmental contammatton, worker and food safety, and nontarget effects from the use of chemicals are all derived from then nontarget actrvrty, and it 1sthese problems that are driving the development of alternatives such as the btopesttcldes. If biopesticides provide a safer, more selective form of insect control, then why do they account for only a fraction of the total pesticide market m North America and elsewhere’ Several factors limit the size and growth rate of btopestictdes Btopesttcidesgenerally lack the broad-spectrum activity, speedof control, residual life, and low cost of their chemical counterparts In the context of theseperceived limitations, biopesticides also tend to be more dtfficult to use, have shorter shelf lives, and tend to be more costly than traditional chemicals As a result of these challenges, penetration mto major insectictde markets has been limited There are at least two factors that will drive the growth of btopestrctdes. First, as society increasingly looks at the total value of a particular technology for pest control, this means lookmg beyond acute control and assessinghow a pest control product or group of products fits into the overall crop ecosystem, Another factor that will drive the growth of btopesttctdes 1sthe enthusiasm that 1scentered around biotechnology and the realization that the tools are available to improve effectiveness of btopesttcides while retammg then qualities of low environmental impact. 3. Use of Genetic Engineering to Enhance Biopesticides Has Become a Dominant Trend Begmnmg m the 1980s and to the present, a variety of molecular approaches has been used to improve market acceptance of bropestrcides. Early on, most of these efforts were directed at improving microbial msecticides, such as Bt, which has been in commercial use for over 40 yr (4). However, its use has been largely restricted to niche markets. Specific charactertstics that limit the wider use of Bt include hmtted host-range specificrty, inability to target cryptic feedmg pests, slow action compared to chemical msecticides, and lack of residual activity (4). Two general approaches were used to improve these charactertstics. One approach has been to transfer Bt toxins (genes) mto alternate mtcrobtal hosts, to address the issues associated with insect feeding or residual actrvtty. In 199 1, Mycogen (San Diego, CA) received EPA registration for the first two genetically engineered mtcrobial bioinsecticides, MVP@ and M-Trak@. These products consisted of Bt toxins that were produced and encapsulated m the host bacterium, Pseudomonas jluorescens. Recently, Ecogen has developed methods for homologous recombinatton with Bt This technology was used m the recent development of CryMax@ bioinsectrctde. These engineered microbial msecttcides do address such issues as spectrum of activity, residual hfe, and cost of product.
16
Caulder
4. Plant Expression of Biologically Derived Toxins Will Allow Penetration of Biopesticides Into Key Markets In North America, the largest msectlclde markets are associated with the control of insect pests m corn and cotton. The difficulty of blopestlcldes penetratmg these markets has to do with the biology of the primary insect pests.In corn, the primary insect pest 1s the corn rootworm complex, which IS comprised of several species wlthm the genera Diabrotzca. These larvae hve m the so11and cause economtc damage by feedmg on corn roots. Because of the solldwelling habltat, delivery of a mlcroblal product mto the feeding zone has been impractical or cost prohibitive. In cotton, the main pest 1sthe Heliothine complex. In North America, this complex consists of the tobacco budworm and bollworm. These larvae feed on parts of the plant, such as terminals and flowers, that rapidly outgrow msecticlde sprays. Larger larvae burrow mto bolls and become inaccessible to sprayed msectlctdes. For these insects, expression of the Bt toxin m the plant tissue may be the optlmal solution. Thts approach provides the ideal solution to the pesticide delivery issue and lack of residual activity The commercial impact of plants expressing Bt is just now bemg felt. 1996 marked the first sales of msect-reslstant transgemc corn by Mycogen and Cuba (Novartls), and insect resistant cotton and potatoes by Delta and Pme Land and Monsanto 5. Plant Expression Will Enhance the importance of Bt as a Source of Insect-Resistant Proteins The first insect-resistant transgemc crops entering the marketplace contam CryIA Bt toxms, which are active against a variety of lepldoptera Based on the initial demand for these crops, there IS every indication that the marketplace will demand crops that are resistant to other major insect pests. To satisfy this demand, additional insect active proteins will have to be discovered. Although blologlcally active proteins can and will be identified from many sources, it 1s likely that Bt will continue to serve as the primary source of insect active proteins for the near future. Strong current demand for Bt toxins is, in part, a result of their reputation for safety and efficacy. This demand will be met by the incredible diversity of toxin proteins that 1sproduced by Bt The pace at which new Bt proteins are being discovered 1s Illustrated by the fact that, m 1989, 14 toxin proteins were discussed m the classic Hofte and Whitely review (5); the latest Bt review, refers to over 100 Bt proteins (6). The discovery of this vast array of Bt proteins has important lmpllcatlons. One 1sthe ability to manage or delay resistance development. Resistance has not been a major problem with Bt msectlcldes, probably because of the limited use of these products Exceptions do occur when Bt usage IS particularly intense. A good example IS the use of Bt m cole crops to control diamondback
North American
Scenario
17
moth. In tropical or semitropical areas, where growing seasonsare long, diamondback moth populations have developed resistance to CryIA toxins. Resistant populations have been isolated from insects m Florida, Hawaii, the Phihppmes, and Southeast Asia. Even though these insects are resistant to CryIA toxins, they still are susceptible to other Bt toxins, such as CryIC. Given the structural dtversity of Bt toxins, the author is optimrstic that additional protein families with no cross resistance ~111be identified. With an adequate number of noncross-resistant toxins, rotation and other use schemes can be developed to delay the onset of resistance. The challenge facing both industry and academia will be to reach an agreement over which management schemes are most appropriate. As more chemically diverse &endotoxms are discovered, the number of insects that are susceptible to these new Bt toxins is expanding. A case in point is the identtfication of Bt toxins that are active against black cutworm Black cutworm, Agrotis zpszlon, has traditionally been difficult to control with Bt toxins. Recently, the activity of two distmct Bt toxins has been repoited agamst cutworm (7,s). Similar progress is being made agamst recalcitrant Coleoptera, such as the corn rootworm (9). One can envision the impact that controllmg these two soil pests of corn ~111have on the overall msectrcide market, since over $300 milhon IS spent on chemical pesticides to control corn soil pests 6. Field Performance: Examples and Role in IPM Implementation Another key problem associated with the use of broad-spectrum chemicals has been then- impact on the crop ecosystem. Dependence on these materials has often created an unstable situation in agricultural pest management. Insecticide resistance, combmed with lethal effects on natural enemies, has resulted in pest resurgence and secondary pest outbreaks. The concept of integrated pest management (IPM) was developed in the 1950s and 1960s to address these agronomic problems, as resistance to DDT and organophosphate msecttcides began to cause crop failures m cotton and other crops m a number of countries IPM is an ecological approach to pest control that requires selective agents that are effective on target-pest species, yet preserves natural enemies and retains their contribution to overall control. Btopesticides are the most selective of currently available pest-control agents. As we commercialize a greater diversity and number of blopesticrde products, we Increase our potential to develop effective and comprehensive ecologically based IPM programs that will provide farmers with the greatest value, efficacy, and sustainability. Biopesticides have delivered great benefits to growers when used m IPM systems in a variety of crops. In fresh market tomatoes in Caltforma, for example, Trumble et al. (10) compared total input costs and yields achieved, under a standard conventional treatment regimen that used 7-8 applications of
18
Caulder
methomyl and permethrm, to an IPM program that used 3-4 applications of a Bt product. In these trtals, conducted m 1992 and 1993, the IPM program provided net profits equal to or better than those obtained with the chemical standard treatment. In replicated commerctal trials conducted in three valleys of Smaloa, Mexico, m processed tomatoes, Trumble and Alvarado-Rodriguez (21) evaluated an IPM program based on regular sampling and action thresholds The IPM program used a Bt product, a mating disruption pheromone product, abamectm, and releases of egg parasites. The IPM program was compared to a conventional program using chemical msecticldes applied 35 times m what was designed to be the best approximation to conventional grower practices. The results of these season-long trials showed that m the autumn planting the IPM program yielded net per-acre profits that were $304-579 higher than the conventional program. During the winter and spring plantings, only the IPM program was profitable Subsequent to these trtals, Alvarado-Rodriguez began implementmg this IPM program on a number of farms m Smaloa, Mexico, and m Florida, Honduras, and Nicaragua. On these farms, sigmficant yield increases have also been realized, compared to conventional practices. IPM programs like this one are showing that biopesticides can deliver excellent value, not only m addressing environmental and safety concerns, but m providing farmers with the agronomic and economic benefits of lowered input costs and higher yields. Thus, one can see that the bioconversion of agriculture IS being driven by a fundamental shift, not Just m the types of agents used, with a strong movement to biopesttcides and pest-resistant transgemc plants, but also m the systems m which these innovattve biotechnology products are being employed. As mentioned, the biopesticide industry has completed its first season sellmg Bt corn and one season sellmg Bt cotton. Bt corn, which expresses toxins to control European corn borer, has performed quite well. Likewise, growers using Bt cotton needed fewer msecticide applications than growers that planted conventional cotton. However, during the 1996 growing season, there was some concern over the efficacy of Bt cotton. The problem was greater than normal bollworm populations. The reduced efficacy of Bt cotton against high populations of bollworm was demonstrated prior to the commercial launch (12). Nonetheless, the need for additional insecticide use took many people (farmers, researchers, and the press) by surprise. This situation illustrates the importance of an IPM mmdset as opposed to the mmdset that accompanied the mtroduction of synthettc msecticides in the 1940s and 195Os,when application of an msecticide was thought to be the complete solution to a pest problem.
North American
Scenario
19
7. The Future Looking forward, tt seemsinevitable that the transition to btologtcally based pest control practices wtll contmue. A major driving force impactmg agriculture IS the exponential rate of population growth that will produce a population of over 6 billion people by 2000. The impact that this growth will have on entomology and agriculture IS multifold (13). As the populatton increases by 1 billion every 10 yr, there will be extraordinary demands on our ability to produce food and fiber Most of the population growth is taking place m less developed countrtes. Although populations are more stable m the more developed countrtes, acreage devoted to agriculture IS decreasing. The challenge to both private and pubhc sector researchers must be to find addmonal ways to Increase agricultural productivtty m the face of an increasing populatton and decreasing acreage. The rate of population growth necessitates mcreasmgly efficiency m moving research ideas into the marketplace. An important trend IS the formatton of consortta and alliances between research efforts m public and private sectors, These alliances allow groups to focus on key research goals and make progress in a timely manner This trend must continue. Pesticide safety has been an important consideration for many years and will continue to drive btoinsecttcide growth. People have a reasonable concern about pesticides in then diet and environment. The issue of environmental quality 1swell established m more-developed countries. Stated simply, people do not want synthetic chemical residues m their foods. This issue 1s as much a perception as it IS a true toxtcology issue. As the population density increases, environmental quality ISlikely to become a more important issue m more countries, regardless of their state of economic development. Absent significant changes m current practices, nontarget effects of pesticides have an mcreasingly significant impact on environmental quality. One consequence of the increasing populatton and urbanization of farmlands is the increased contact between people and agricultural production. As this increase contmues, the safety of synthetic insecticides will become a greater issue. Biopestlcides effectively address the issues of environmental quality and safety. Since the active ingredients m biopesttcides exist in the natural environment, there 1sa greater level of comfort or a greater perception of safety. As progress m brotechnology and the discovery of new Bt toxins continue, people can look forward to increased use of biopestrcides and btologlcal toxins expressed m transgemc plants. People will have to ask how best to use these tools For example, should biopestrcides be deployed as synthetic msectrcrdes? Are pest-resistant transgemc plants an example of scheduled spraying taken to an extreme position? Alternatively, should these tools be used as part of an overall management strategy that includes parasltolds, predators, and pathogens, as outlined m the early IPM concepts proposed by Smith and van den
20
Caulder
Bosch (14) and others. The selecttvtty of bropestrcide and pest-resistant transgenie plants are complimentary for preservation of predatory msects.Moreover, the sublethal effects of biopesticides may actually mamtam predator populations (15). The integration of transgenic plants mto IPM is also an important Issue. On the surface, the scheduled spraying model for both bropesticides and transgemc plants may seem lakea good Idea. However, there are undesirable consequences, such as resistance development. Would it be better to use these plants m the context of IPM, in which the selectron pressures of a toxin expressed m plants are made less intense? These biopestrcide and transgemcs plants will play an important role. Their rmplementatton will require the coordmated actions of manufacturers, academics, growers, and private consultants.
References I Madehn, M. F. (1963) Diseasescaused by hyphomycetous fungi, tn Insect Pathology, vol 2 (Stemhaus, E A , ed ), Academic, New York, pp 233-272 2. Luthy, P , Jaquet, F., Huber-Lukac, H. E , and Huber-Lukac, M. (1982) Physiology of the delta-endotoxm of Bacrflus thurmgzenszs mcludmg the ultrastructure and histopathologrcal studies,in Basic Bzology of Mlcroblal Larvzczdes of Vectors of Human Dzseases (Michal, F , ed ), UNDP/World Bank/WHO, Geneva, Switzerland, pp 29-36 3 Goldberg, L H and Margaht, J (1977) A bacterral spore demonstratmg rapid larvrcrdal activity against Anopheles sergentu, Uranotaenla unguzculata, Culex unlvattatus, Aedes aegyptz and Culexprplens Mosq News 37,355-358. 4. Gelernter, W. and Schwab, G E (I 993) Transgemc bacteria, vu-uses, algae and other microorganisms as Bacillus thurznglensls toxin delivery systems, in Bacillus thurmgrenszs, An Environmental Blopesttclde Theory and Practice (Entwistle, P F ,
Cory, J. S.,Bailey,M. J., andHrggs,S , eds), Wiley, Chrchester,UK, pp. 89-104 5 Hofte, J and Whiteley, E B. (1989) Insectrcidal crystal protems of Bacillus thurmglensu. Microblol Rev 53,242-255 6 Schnepf, E , Crickmore, N , Van Rie, J , Lereclus, R , Baum, J , Feitelson, J , Zergler, D. R , and Dean, D. H (1997), manuscript m preparation. 7. Estruch, J J , Warren, G. W , Mullms, M A , Nye, G J , Craig, J. A , and Kozrel, M G (1996) V1p3A, a novel Bacillus thurmgiensis vegetative msecticidal protein with a wide spectrum of actrvities against lepidopteran msects Proc Nat1 Acad Scl 93,5389-5394
8 Lambert, B., Buysse,L., Decock,C , Jansens,S , Piens,C , Saey,B., et al (1996) A Baccllus thurlngzensls msectrcrdal crystal protem wrth a hrgh activity against members of the family Noctmdae. Appl Environ Microbzol 62, 8&86 9 Fertelson, J. S , Payne, J., and Kim, L (1996) Baczllus thurzngzensls insectsand beyond. Bzo/Technology lo,27 1-275. 10 Trumble, J T , Carson, W G., and White, K K (1994) Economic analysis of a Baczllus thurzngzensu-based Integrated pest-management program m fresh-market tomatoes. J Econ Entomol 87, 1463-1469
North Amencan
Scenario
21
11 Trumble, J T and Alvarado-Rodriguez, B (1993) Development and economtc evaluation of an IPM program for fresh market tomato productlon m Mexico Agriculture Ecosystems Environ 43,267-284 12 Mahaffey, J. S , Bacheler, J S., Bradley, J. R., and Van Duyn, J W (1994) Per-
formance of Monstanto’s transgemc B t. cotton agamst hrgh populations of Lepropterous pests m North Carolma, m Proceedmgs Beltwzde Cotton Conferences, pp 1061-1063. 13 Metcalf, R L (1996) Applted entomology m the twenty-first century Am Entomol 42,2 16-227 14 Smtth, R F and van den Bosch, R (1967) Integrated control, m Pest Control Blologlcal, Physical and Selected Chemzcal Methods (Kllgore, W. W and Doutt,
R L , eds ), Academx, New York, pp. 295-340 1.5 Soares, G G., Lewts, W J , Strong-Gunderson, J. M., Waters, D. J , and Hamm, J J.
(1993) Integratmg the use of MVPB bromsectxlde, a umque Bt-based product, with natural enemies of Noctmd pests. a novel concept m cotton IPM, m Proceedzngs of the 2nd Canberra Bacdlus thurmgzenszs Meeting, pp 133-145
3 Microbial
Biopesticides
The EuropeanScene Tariq M. Butt, John G. Harris, and Keith A. Powell 1. Introduction There 1s growmg interest in the explottatton of naturally occurrmg mtcroorganisms for the control of crop pests, weeds, and diseases.Btologtcal control agents (BCAs) may offer more environmentally friendly alternatives to chemical pesticides.They could also be used where pestshave developed resistanceto conventional pesticides.Unfortunately, there 1scomparattvely httle investment m the research and development of these organisms compared with that spent on the discovery of chemical pesttctdes.Two reasonsfor this are that microbial pesticides usually have a narrow host range, and that they often give mconststentand poor control in field trials. Consequently, more attentton 1sbeing given to the selectton of broad-spectrum blopesttcidesand improvements m production, formulation, and apphcatton technologtes. Efforts are also being made to opttmtze the impact of these agentsby mtegrating them with other novel crop protection strategies(I). One factor that cannot be ignored is the market potential of btopestictdes.Currently, only speciahzed,niche markets exist. Their full potential has not been realized because of the absenceof strong mcentrves to develop these agents and/or discourage chemical pesticides;availabrlity of new, biodegradable chemical pestlcrdes; absence/breakdownof the mfrastructure that facilitates transfer of new technologles and research knowledge to the end user (i.e., grower); absence of a universally acceptable regrstratron procedure; restrtcttons in the use of exottc BCAs; and lack of robust and reliable field effects Progress is also slow because the chtef producers are often small-medium-size enterprises(SMEs) that have hmtted resources for effective development and marketing of products. From Edited
Methods m B~olechnology, vol 5 Blopeshodes by F R Hall and J J Menn 0 Humana Press
23
Use and Dehvery Inc , Totowa, NJ
Butt, Harris,
24
and Powell
Fungicide 20% Herbickie 49%
hectic
Fig. 1. The share of crop protection in each of the major sectors of the world market.
Europe
Fungicide 30% Herbii5e 48%
Insecticide 22%
Fig. 2. The European Market share for fungicides, insecticides, and herbicides.
Figure 1 showsthe current shareof the agrochemicalmarket worldwide for insect, fungal, and weed control. For convenience, insecticides also include nematicides and
molluscicides.The Europeanmarkethasa different shape,with plant pathogensbeing more important and insectcontrol being a more minor component (Fig. 2). Clearly, from thesefigures, one might expectthe development of biological control for plant pathogensto have beencenteredin Europe. There is, however, little evidence of this. The useofBacillus thuringiensis (Bt) for control of insectshasbeendeveloped mostly in the United Statesand Canada.It is in the key cotton crop that B&derived genes have beenused to provide crop resistanceto insects. A wide range of BCAs have or arebeing developed ascommercial biopesticides produced in Europe, often with global markets in mind. In order to survive, many SMEs market products of other companies or produce BCAs under license. Presumably, this mutualism will decline as the use of BCAs increases(i.e., the market expands) and it becomes more lucrative for individual companies to develop their own agents. 2. Formulation and Delivery For any crop-protection agent, an efficient formulation is a necessityto translate laboratory activity into adequate field performance. The formulation must
Microbial
Biopesticides:
European
Scene
25
be mtrmsrcally compattble with the BCA, and, ideally, the formulated maternal should have superior performance compared wtth the unformulated material (2) For BCAs, there are particular challenges to be faced, because the active ingredient 1sfrequently a living organism that must be kept relatively tmmobile and inactive while in storage, but quickly resume its normal metabohc processes once applied to the target site To achieve this, some form of drying process ts usually done, such as an-drying, freeze-drying, or lyophihzation. A preservative, such as Proxel (1,2-benzisothtazohn-3-one), will often be mcorporated to prevent microbial contammatton Subsequent formulation IS then usually as a wettable powder, water-dispersible granule, or dust. Another approach is suspension in oil, m which the purpose IS to exclude oxygen from the organism, thus preventing respiration. An example is the Bt subspp kurstuki insecticide formulation Dipel ESNT, in which the actrve ingredient is encapsulated and then suspended in an 011base Moore et al. (3) found that dried comdra stored m 011formulatrons remamed viable longer than those stored as a dried powder, especially If stored at relatively low temperatures (IO-14 vs 28-32OC). Additton of sihca gel to oil-formulated conidia prolongs then shelf life. Undried conrdra of Metarhzzzum jluvovinde, without sthca gel, lose viability rapidly, with germmatron droppmg below 40% after 9 and 32 wk at 17 and 8°C respecttvely. After 127 wk in storage, germination remained at over 60 and 80% for the drred formulations at 17 and 8°C respecttvely (4). These comdra were found to have retained full vtrulence, compared with freshly prepared formulattons. Furthermore, conidta dried to 4-5% morsture content showed greater temperature tolerance than conidia with higher motsture content. McClatchie et al. (5) report that htghtemperature treatments caused delay in germmatton, as well as death of A4 flavovzrzde comdia. However, drymg comdta by adding sthca gel to 011 formulatrons greatly increased temperature tolerance Desprte thus, formulatrons composed of living cells still suffer sigmficant degradatron over trme, and this IS a problem that still needs to be solved. This IS a particular issue for the nonspore-forming bacterta and fungt The situation is rather easier wrth spore-forming organisms. Restmg stages, such as spores, are desrgned to retam water, be robust, and survive m a viable state, even when subjected to harsh envtronments. Nucleopolyhedrovrruses also produce propagules that are encapsulated with polyhedrin, giving them a tough, reststant coatmg that facthtates survival These types of organisms are, therefore, more easily formulated, and ltqurd products, such as suspension concentrates, are quite feastble. Equally important, the formulation type and packaging materials must be broadly similar to those wtth which the grower 1s already famthar. The products should be capable of application through the standard hydraulrc sprayer or
26
Butt, Hams, and Powell
applicatton equipment that 1scommon to a partrcular market, and have as few unique requirements as posstble A grower IS unhkely to mvest m new spray equtpment solely to treat a BCA, nor 1s he going to accept a very different spray regime or more frequent apphcattons than 1snormal practice. The grower will also want to purchase his BCAs through the same dtstributton chain as hts agrochemtcals. Yet, a distributor is not going to be happy to have to handle BCA formulations differently from his normal chemical stock. The dtstributor will expect the product to be packaged m standard sizesand types of contamers, as used throughout the agrochemtcals mdustry Storage stabthty must be such that product purchased at the start of one seasonIS good for the whole of that seasonand the next, without any special storage requirements. If the shelf hfe of a BCA forrnulatton ISvery limited, then a distributor may only be prepared to buy small quanttttes,thus hmitmg avatlabthty, or will only stockproduct on a consignment basts,which is a major mconvemenceto the BCA supplier Also, some BCAs have a specific need for refrigeratton, but very few dtstrtbutors m Europe have such facthttes, and even fewer would be prepared to invest m them. Finally, the BCA formulation must be composed of safe materials One of the mam features of BCAs is their perceived safety benefits to the envtronment, beneficials, nontargets, and, of course, the applicators. These benefits would be negated tf toxic formulatton components were used m the product. If the product 1stargeted at a fohar pest or disease, then addtttonal problems are subsequently encountered. All the usual requtrements for successful fohar treatment need to be met, mcludmg good sprayabtlity, no nozzle blockage, good leaf deposttton and dtstributton, and adequate rainfastness. In order to achieve these attributes, surfactants, stickers, and wetters must be mcorporated mto the formulation or applied m tank mixture. One of the chief causes of macttvation of many BCAs on the leaf surface 1sthe effect of ultravtolet (UV) radiation. High levels of UV can lead to rapid degradation of the material, perhaps wtthm a single day. Mtcroencapsulatton of the BCA has been one approach to overcome this problem, although this IS technically difficult and quite expensive to manufacture. Another technique that has been used, particularly with baculovnuses, is to incorporate mto the formulation or tank mtx an optical brightener. These brighteners may reflect UV or reduce its impact by disstpatmg the energy as fluorescent light and heat. But they can only protect the BCA when they are m the immediate proximity of the organism Because this is hard to achieve when simply admtxed mto the formulation, results with this approach have been highly variable. To exploit this technology effectively, ways have to be found to keep the brightener or other UV protectant materials m mtimate contact with the BCA. Also reported are the usage of otlbased formulations, which have proved to be beneficial to UV protection of comdta of M flavovmde (4,6,7)
Microbial
Biopesticides:
European
Scene
27
In the case of mrcrobtal msectlcides, good drstrtbutron over the leaf 1sessential, because they are nonsystemtc materials, and must come m contact with, or be consumed by, the target insect, m order to deliver a toxrc dose Feedmg attractants incorporated mto the formuiatron may be useful to encourage Insects to feed on the BCA (8), and Bt products are frequently tank-mixed wrth 2 kg/ha of sugar for fruit and vme pests in Europe, with good reported effect In other cases,some very specrfic additives can have a positive effect For example, the LD,, for some formulatrons of Beauveria basslana was reduced by 97% by the addrtron of coconut 011.It was suggested that the cutmophtlic propertres of the or1 could allow a greater number of fungal comdta to penetrate the mouth parts of the insect (9) 011 carriers can also distribute the moculum over the insect cutrcle, often carrying the comdta to the thm mtersegmental membranes, which are more readily penetrated by entomogenous fungr (Butt, personal observation). A different series of prtortttes come mto play when devrsmg formulattons for the control of soilborne pests and diseases Placement of the BCA IS of prime importance, to ensure that dlstrtbution through the soil 1s even, and, therefore, there IS a good chance that the BCA and the pest or pathogen will come in contact with one another. Preplantmg, BCAs can be applred as granules m-furrow, and by drench apphcatton On a small scale, such as m glasshouse sttuattons, material can be thoroughly incorporated Into the so11 Postplantmg, a drench applicatton or irrrgatron can be employed to take the BCA mto the son. Seed treatment may also be an option, although most seed tend to recetve a chemtcal fungrcide to control seedborne drseases, and these treatments can often be antagomstrc to BCAs. 3. Biological Control of Plant Pathogens Biological control of plant pathogenic fungi has long been an ambttton for academic and industrial researchers. However, there IS little evidence of major breakthroughs m the marketplace. The issues and problems have been dealt with m many publlcattons (IO). There are products that are avatlable for both soilborne and foltar pathogens, as well as considerable research on postharvest disease(11,12). Several products are or have been registered m Europe (Table 1) Current products are shown in Table 2. Although the products listed m Table 2 are commercially avarlable, the total sales of btological agents for crop protectron agamst plant pathogens amounts to much less than 1% of the fungrcrde market m Europe. The problem faced by developers of brologrcal agents for control of disease are complex and drfficult. Crops are grown under a variety of chmattc and environmental conditions, and temperature, rainfall, sot1type, crop variety, and
2
Fmland, Sweden, Norway
Adapted with permIssIon from ref. 33.
(= Penzophora) glgantea
Phlebropsrs
Country
for Biological
Netherlands Sweden, France United Kingdom
in Europe
Vertlc&um dahliae Truzhoderma harzlanum Trrchoderma wnde
Registered Finland, Hungary, Norway,
Agents
Streptomyces grzseovwzdzs
Agent
Table 1 Some Microbial Switzerland
Control
Target pathogen Fusarwm spp, Alternana, Pythlum, Botrytq and other so11 pathogens Agamst Dutch elm disease Sell-borne fungal diseases Antagonist to silverleaf fungus (Stereum purpureum) Fomes annosus
of Plant Diseases
Kemrra Agro Oy Kemu-a Agro Oy Gustafson Various Ecogen Ecogen Natural Plant Protectron (NW Various
GlioMix Mycostop Kodiak Vanous AQlO Aspire Fusaclean Various
Truzhoderma viride
Supplier
Control
Kemrra Agro Oy
Commercial name
Sold in Europe for Biological Rotstop
Products
Phleblopsls (= Penrophora) gigantea Ghocladmm sp Streptomyces grrseovwldls Bacillus subtills Agrobacterlum radlobacter Ampelomyces quzsqualls Candida oleophda Fusarlum oxysporum FO 47
Product
Table 2 Some Commercial
Wood treatment
Promotes plant growth, competes wrth soil microbes Fusarwm spp and other sod pathogens Soil pathogens Agrobacterium tumefaclens Powdery mildew Postharvest decay of citrus and apple Fusanum oxysporum, F momliforme
Fomes annosus
Target pathogen
of Plant Pathogens
30
Butt, Hams, and Powell
pathogen can change from farm to farm, or even within one field The producer of a crop protection product has to be able to give some assurance to the farmer that the product ~111 be robust, m order for the product to be used. The avallablllty of effective chemical controls for fohar pathogens has made it unlikely that a biological agent will compete effectively It is, therefore, not surprlsmg that the maJorrty of efforts m research has been concentrated on sotlborne or postharvest diseases Even m these situations, the lack of robustness has hmlted the penetration of such products. When success has been achteved, it has been m limlted crop-pathogen mteractlons, and has often been specific to crop, pathogen, and growmg sltuatlon The control of Agrobacterzum tumefaclens by the closely related bacterium Agrobactenum radzobacter (13) IS a classic example. The bIologIca agent IS apphed to unmfected roots of cuttings, and 1s then allowed to colomze the niche that would normally be at risk from the pathogemc species The success of this treatment may be enhanced by the productlon of a specific antlblotlc that mhlblts growth of the pathogen An lllustratlon of the problems faced m control of disease under more varied condltlons was provided by the excellent work of Defago et al. (14). This group showed that the sol1 environment played a key part m the ablhty of Pseudomonasfluorescens to control black root rot of tobacco One so11 type showed excellent potential for disease control, but a second negated the effect of the bacterium The application of nonpathogenic strains to control pathogenic fungi has been demonstrated by the work of Alabouvette et al. (15) Nonpathogemc Fusarzum oxysporum llmlted disease caused by pathogemc Fusarzum. the suppression was linked to the ratio of density of the nonpathogemc population m relation to the pathogenic species. The nonpathogemc strams compete with other mlcroorgamsms for nutrients and elicit a defense response m the plant, which protects It agamst more aggressive strains of Fusarzum Trlchoderma harzlanum and T wide have been proposed by various groups as potential BCAs. Trzchoderma sp appear to have the ablhty to rapidly colonize clean surfaces, such as compost or freshly cut timber Several products have been available, but the market share has been mmlmal. One problem may be the lack of competltlve ablhty of these species when apphed to so11or other media with an active mlcroblal population. One exception 1s GhoMlx, which IS a formulation of the fungus Glzocladzum. This product promotes plant growth and, presumably because of its rapld growth, the fungus prevents establlshment of potential disease-causing microbes. Antagonists of postharvest diseases share some of the attrlbutes of the above For example, the success of Epicoccum nlgrum, Penlcllllum oxalicum, and Candzda sake, which are bemg developed to control Monzlwzza laxa (brown rot
Microbial
Blopes ticldes:
European
Table 3 Factors That May Affect the Success
Scene
31
of BCAs for Plant Pathogens
Factors affectmg long-term survival Physlcal Soil type Matrtc potential Temperature PH Blottc Ablllty to colonize substrate Competition Survival structures Host genome Resistance of pathogen to BCA
Factors affectmg speed of effect BCA Germmatlon and recovery time Release from formulation Speed of growth Movement to site of actlon Pathogen Growth rate Degree of mche protectton Productlon of toxins
Adapted with permlssron from ref. IO
of peaches and other fruit), Fusarzum oxysporum fsp lycopersicz (tomato wilt), and Penzczllium spp, respectively, IS dependent upon their ability colonize the
fruit surface raptdly and displace the disease. Antagomstlc yeastsalso produce extracellular materials (mostly polysacchandes) that not only enhance their survival, but also restrict colomzation sites and the flow of germmatlon cues to other fungal propagules. Bacterial antagonists like Badus subtzh produce antlblotlcs (e.g , Iturm), which mhlblt diseases hke the brown rot pathogen Monzlznza fructzcola. The exact mechanisms of antagonism are poorly understood, but involve a complex of attributes, including nutrient competltlon, site exclusion, attachment of the antagonist to the pathogen, secretion of pathogemcity-related enzymes, induced resistance, and antlblosls caused by the actlon of bloactlve compounds Table 3 illustrates the issuesfaced when attempting to develop a BCA for so11 diseases,and shows quite clearly the need to take Into account many factors when considering the potential for a new project in this area. Given the difficulties listed above, the lack of commercial successfor blologlcal control IS perhaps not surpnsmg. It 1snevertheless possible, as demonstrated by Rlshbeth (16) m the control of Fomes anrzosus by Phlebzopszs (= Penzophora) gzgantea In this sltuatlon, the cut tree stump is inoculated with the blologlcal agent immediately after cutting. The control ISachieved becausethe substrateIS rapldly colonized by the control agent and the pathogen 1sunable to enter and thus Infect the nearby trees via the root system.This example shows clearly that specificity, competition, and growth rate are all important This lessonshould be heededby all those tempted to embark on a new project for biologtcal
control
32
Butt, Hams, and Powell
4. Biological Insecticides: Field Performance and Role in IPM Implementation 4. I. Mycoinsecticides Some of the pathogens that have been or are being developed for the control of insect pests belong to the fungal division Deuteromycotma, class Hyphomycetes (Table 4). The most common species are Metarhlzzum anzsopliae, Beauverla basslana, Paecdomyces fumosoroseus, and Vertdlwm lecarw These can be readily isolated from soils from most parts of the world, and are known to have a wide host range, but strains can doffer m then- specificity and virulence (I 7,18). Fungi, unlike bacteria and vnuses, do not have to be ingested to cause infection, but can penetrate the insect cuticle directly, using a combtnation of enzymes and mechanical (18-20). Once the pathogen has gained accessto the nutrient-rich hemocoel, the fungus may grow as thin-walled blastospores or hyphae. Most strains secrete htstolyttc enzymes and msecttctdal metabohtes. The latter can disorient the host, stop It from feeding, and cause death before mycelial colomzatton of the hemocoel 4.1.1. Verticdlium lecanll The fungus, Vertzczlliumlecanu, has been developed as a btomsectlctde for the control of aphids, whiteflies, thrtps, and red spider mites Christian Hansen’s BIO Systems were particularly acttve developmg the product for usage m Scandinavta, as MtcroGermin (21). The fungal spores are dried to form a wettable-powder formulatton, whtch can be mixed with water to produce a suspension suitable for immersion of plant cuttings. Shelf life ISclaimed to be 6 mo at 5°C. The chief market has proven to be the protection of glasshouse cuttings by dipping, prior to potting. Aphids and whttefltes can be a major problem m glasshouse plants, and, m such a closed envtronment, reststance to chemical msectictdes tends to develop quite qutckly. MtcroGermm offers an effective alternattve to chemicals m what 1s a high-value market, Potential outside of a glasshouse environment is limited, however, because the fungus reqmres a relative humidity of between 95 and 100% for at least 10-12 h to germinate effectively and colonize the insects. Late in 1995, the Dutch company, Koppert, purchased Christian Hansen’s Bio Systems. Koppert already had a similar product m then range, called Mycotal, and so it IS expected that efforts will be made to market a single product for other northern European glasshouse markets alongside then- extensive product range of predators and biocontrol agents. 4.7.2. Beauvena and Metarhizium Wlthm each genus, there are two species that have been examined for biological control potential. Beauveria bassiana and B. brongmartiz have been
Fungus
of Mycoinsecticides Pest insect Whltefly and thrlps Aphids Vine weevil Coffee berry borer Sugar cane white grub Corn borer Colorado beetle Colorado beetle Colorado beetle Cockchafer Cockchafer Cockchafer Locusts, grasshoppers Whitefly
in Europe
aReglstered, but not on sale, other products under development ‘Some commentators suggest quite large scale use (>lO,OOO ha), but this has been disputed (34). =From ref. 34 dUnder hcense from ThermoEcotek (now Therm0 Tnlogy)
Vertlcdlwn lecanu V. Iecann Metarhizlum anlsopllae Beauvena basslana Beauverla brongnlartn Beauveria basslana B. bassiana B. bassiana B basslana B. brongnlartii B. brongnlartti B brongnlartu Metarhlzlum flavovirlde Paecllomyces fumosoroseus
Scale Production
Mycotal Vertalec BIO 1020” Comdla Betel Ostrinil Bovenn Boverol Boverosil Engerlingspllz Schweizer-Beauvena Melocont Green Muscle PreFeRal
Product
Table 4 Commercial
Koppert, Holland Koppert, Holland Bayer, Germany AgrEvo, Germany NPP (Calliope), France NPP (Calliope), France Former USSRb Czech Republic/Slovaklac Czech RepublicYSlovakla” Andermatt, Switzerland Eric Scwelzer, Switzerland Kwlzda, Austria CABI, UK Biobest, Belglumd
Producer
34
Butt, Harris,
and Powell
the focus in this genus, and these species are known to produce a cyclodepsipeptide called beauvericin, which is toxic to insects. Similarly, Metarhizium anisopliae and M. flavoviride produce related insecticidal metabolites called destruxins. These toxins play an important role in the pathogenicity of the fungus, and probably help to disable the insect’s self-defense mechanisms while the fungus invades and colonizes the hemocoel. In Switzerland, a biological method to control the subterranean pasture pest, Melolontha melolontha, with the insect-pathogenic fungus B. brongniartii was developed during the 1980sand the pathogen was registered in 1990. Since then, approx 5000 kg are applied per annum to 100-I 50 ha of mostly pasture. Another strain of this fungus has been developed by Natural Plant Protection (NPP; France), and is sold under the commercial name Betel for the control of the sugar cane white grub (Hoplochelus marginalis, Melolonthinae) in the tropics. NPP also developed a strain of B. bassiana for the control of European corn borer, Ostrinia nubilalis (Table 4). Both pathogens are produced using solid fermentation technology. The pathogenis formulated in clay granules and applied at 25 kg/ha (Ostrinil) or 50 kg/ha (Betel). According to the manufacturers, the granules are applied in the sameway as chemical granules. Both products are stable for 1 mo at 35”C, but the shelf life is increased at lower temperatures. In Germany, Bayer AG developed BIO 1020, a strain of M. anisopliae for the control of Otiorhynchus sulcatus (black vine weevil) (22). This pest is a major problem on several ornamental crops in glasshouses and nursery stock. The product consists of dry granules with a claimed shelf life of 6 mo if kept in cool conditions. The granules are admixed with soil, and, following water uptake by the granules, the fungus produces large numbers of conidia that are viable for many months. Insects become infected when they come into contact with these conidia. This does mean, however, that the application must be of a preventative nature, but, because of the long survivorship of the conidia, satisfactory protection should be achieved for the whole duration of the crop. The recommended rate of the formulated product is 1 g/L soil, at which good levels of control of 0. sulcatus have been seenon a number of glasshousecrops (Fig. 3). Such a product has an excellent fit with other predators, parasites, and microbial agents for glasshouse crop protection. Recently, the use of M anisopliae has been reported for the control of western flower thrips, Frankliniella occidentalis (23). Strains of this fungus have also been shown to be highly pathogenic to several crucifer pests, yet is harmless to honey bees (17). In both instances, conidia were formulated in either aqueous solutions or oil, and were applied to leaf surfaces using conventional and/or electrostatic sprayers. Poor control can be attributed mostly to low temperatures and humidities, which will prevent spore germination and infection. In addition, UV light will
Microbial Biopesticides: European Scene
Azalea
I
Fuchsia
Chrysanthemum
I
Cyclamen
Begonia
Fig. 3. Effectiveness of BIO 1020 against Otiorhynchus sulcatus eggs and larvae in ornamentals under glasshouse conditions 28 d after treatment. (Adapted with permission from ref. 22.)
quickly inactivate spores, and leaf expansion and rain will dilute the inoculum on the leaf surface. Overcoming these factors will greatly improve fungal efficacy. Equally important is maximizing spore viability and ensuring better contact of the inoculum with the insect surface, because mortality is dose-related. The speed of kill (LT,,) is also dose-dependent (17,241. The more inoculum contacting the pest, the shorter the time to death. Selection of virulent, ecologically competent strains, combined with improved formulations and more effective targeting of the pathogen, will lead to more efficacious pest control. At IACR-Rothamsted, a push-pull strategy, based on the use of semiochemicals, is being developed in which pests are encouraged into trap crops or discard areas, where they are inundated with fungal pathogens. When developed, this strategy should greatly reduce the use of chemical pesticides (I). 4.2. Bacteria Only two species of bacteria have been developed for control of insect pests: Bt and B. sphaericus (Table 5). Products based on the different strains of Bt are the most widely used biological control agents in Europe. Bt subspp kurstaki (Btk) is used to control lepidopterous pests in vegetables, tomatoes, top fruit, vines, olives, and forestry. An example of the latter, in a major Polish forestry project, is described below.
Table 5 Insect-Pathogenic Active ingredient Bt serotype 3 Bt subsp azzawaz Bt subsp kurstakz Delta endotoxm of Bt subsp kurstakz Bt subsp tenebrionzs Bt subsp zsraelenszs Baczllus sphaerzcus
Bacteria
and Toxins
Registered
Registered uses (pest/crop) Wide range of crops and orchards Lepidopteran larvae Lymantria,
Ostrznza
Lepidopteran pests Coleopteran larvae Dipteran pests Mosquito larvae
in Europe Country
France France, Germany France, Germany, Hungary, Italy Austria Austria, Germany, Hungary Finland, France, Germany, Hungary Italy, Netherlands, Sweden France
Adapted with permtsslon from ref. 33
Poland IS a major softwood producer. Forests cover about 8.8 mullion ha, approx 30% of the land mass, and are a major earner of foreign currency. Protecting this resource is clearly a very high priority, especially because there are at least five sertous lepidopteran pests that can cause significant losses. Nun
moth (Lymantrza monacha) IS the most serious of these pests m Polish comferous forests. The larvae are major defoliators, feeding particularly off young leaves. Infestations are usually cyclical, with serious outbreaks occurring about every 50-60 yr. Unexpectedly, though, in the spring of 1994, over 600,000 ha of Polish forestry became seriously infested. This had not been predicted, since the last serious outbreak had only been 12 yr earlier. Polish scientistswere of the opmlon that the usage of broad-spectrum chemical insecticides to control the previous outbreak had made the forest more vulnerable to attack (25). It was postulated that the msecticide treatments had also elrmmated key parasites and predators of the nun moth, thus enabling the pest to increase m numbers more qutckly, and effectively shortenmg the outbreak cycle. A deciston was taken to spray the forests to control the latest nun moth
outbreak, but this time using more selective insecticides. An emergency program was put together in May 1994, with funding from the World Bank, European Union’s FAIR program, the Danish Environmental Protection Agency, and the British Know-how fund, totaling m excessof $9 mrlhon. Together with funding provided by the Polish government’s National Fund for Environmental Protectron, the total project cost came to more than $22 million (26). A special forestry formulation of Btk called Foray 48B, from Novo Nordisk accounts for almost 25% of the total insecticide used m forest systems. This
M/crob,al Biopestm-ies. European Scene
37
material is suitable for spraying from aircraft or helicopters at volumes as low as 4 L/ha when applied through ultra-low volume (ULV) spray equipment. As part of the project, Micronair ULV equipment was provided, to completely re-equip the Polish aerial applicator fleet, and pilot training was provided to enable the best results to be obtained. Usage of Btk was especially concentrated m environmentally sensitive areas, or where forest sorls dramed into rivers or lakes. Brological and economic impact studies were put mto place, to examme the implications of the spray program. The results were excellent, with Btk providmg about 95% control of the pest on average, while having minimal impact on beneticials and nontarget organtsms. Smaller, follow-up spray programs m 1995 and 1996 have effectively finished the job, and one would hope that the pest cycle in Poland has now been returned to its more natural 50-yr pattern. The nun moth causes similar problems m adjacent countries, m particular, Germany, Belarus, Ukraine, the Baltic Republics, and the Czech Republic. The Polish project has acted as a model for these other countries, and similar programs utrhzmg Btk are now m place, for example, m Belarus. For some years now, products based on Btk have become the first choice for lepidopteran pest control m North American forestry, especially for gypsy moth (Lymantria &spar) outbreaks. This trend is quickly spreading to Europe, where Btk IS mcreasmgly perceived as a highly effective and environmentally benign forestry msecticide Bt subspp zsraelenszs (Bti) is a quite different type of microbial msecticide. This strain is active against the larval stagesof Diptera, m particular, mosquito larvae. Mosqmtoes are, by nature, only regarded as pests when they are m the vicmity of people. Traditionally, mosquitoes have tended to be controlled by spraying or fogging the adults with broad-spectrum chemical insecticides, but this also exposes the human population to chemical residues of these pesticides. In these more environmentally conscious times, alternatives are being sought to reduce exposure risk. Although habitat alteration, such as marshland draining, has hrstorically been one of the best and most long-lived techniques for mosquito control, the opportumties to adopt these techniques are rapidly drmmishmg. Indeed, within Europe, there is a trend to protect and increase wetland areas, because they are regarded as being extremely valuable to wrldltfe, especially birds, but at the same time they present mosquito species with new opportunmes for colomzation and breeding (27). Control efforts have mcreasmgly moved toward tackling the problem at source, by applying larvrcrde to the waterbody utmzed by the mosqurtoes for breeding. However, because many breeding sites are m environmentally sensi-
38
Butt, Harris, and Powell
Fig. 4. Bti Europeanmarket, 1992-1993. tive areas, chemical larvicides (especially organophosphates) are inappropriate. A viable alternative has proven to be mosquito larvicides based on Bti. These products, such as VectoBac or Bactimos, contain a mixture of dipteran-active crystal proteins and spores. Various formulations are available, including liquids, wettable powders, granules, and slow-release briquettes. When applied to the water surface, the mosquito larvae filter out the Bti particles (together with other particulate organic matter), acquiring a toxic dose. Younger instars are more susceptible that older instars, and pupae and adults are not affected. Thorough, regular, and accurate scouting of the breeding site is therefore essential, to time the larvicide application correctly to target predominantly young instar stages. European countries have taken a number of different approaches to mosquito control and employ Bti products to varying degrees (Fig. 4). In France, mosquito control is predominantly in tourist areas, especially along the coast of southern France. Here, more that 80% of the Bti used is in the form of locally made sand granules. These are produced by mixing Bti primary powder (active ingredient) or wettable-powder formulations with high-grade sand, plus a small quantity of vegetable oil. Specially converted helicopters apply these granules, especially to forested or marsh areas, for the control of Aedes caspius. In Germany, a major mosquito control program is conducted in the Upper Rhine Valley, where the river banks tend to become flooded, especially in the
Microbial
Biopesticides:
European
Scene
39
spring, as the river rises because meltwater from Switzerland swells the volumes carried. In the valley itself, the major problem IS Aedes vexans, whtch tends to lay eggs on dry ground that wdl subsequently become temporarrly flooded. The primary control method IS using Bti larvtctde. Scouting of the breeding sites allows targeted applications to be made either by knapsack sprayer or helicopter-applied granular treatments over larger water bodies and in thick woodland. Another problem faced by this team IS that 50% of the houses m the valley villages collect rainwater in barrels for home/garden usage, and A vexans and Culex pzplens are found to proliferate in these To combat these pests, Btt tablets (Culmex) are manufactured locally and distributed freeof-charge to the householders to treat these contamers (28) (N Becker, personal communicatton) Hungary has a large number of government-sponsored tenders covering a major proportion of the country Key areas are Lake Balaton, Danube, and Ttsza River valleys. A wide range of mosquito pestsare found, includmgAea%s, Anopheles, Culex, and Mansonza A number of prtvate apphcatton companies compete for the spray contracts, using mostly Btl liquid formulations applied from helicopters. Although Btt usage patterns vary constderably across Europe, the products are viewed as possessmg many advantages, including being envnonmentally benign and cost-effective m practical usage. 5. New Developments 5.1. Baculoviruses
Nucleopolyhedrovnuses (NPVs) are increasingly being considered for use as insect control agents. Such vu-uses are almost exclusrvely pathogenic to Lepidoptera. These vtruses produce restmg structures called polyhedra, contaming one or more mfecttve vrrions. When the insect larva consumes contaminated foliage, the polyhedra dissolve in the midgut, releasing the virtons, which then invade midgut epithehal cells. The virus replicates wlthm these cells, uttltzmg them as a stepping stone to build up viral numbers, and subsequently, to invade the hemocoel and colonize the remainder of the Insect. The life cycle IS completed when the insect dies, liquefies, and releases large quantitles of new polyhedra onto the leaf surface. A small number of wild-type baculoviruses have been commerctalized m Europe A typtcal example IS Mamestra brassicae NPV, sold as Mamestrm by Calllope SA, which IS used to control early mstars of Helicoverpa armigera, Mamestra brasslcae, and Plutella xylostella. The product IS formulated as a suspension concentrate and used at 5 L/ha It is registered for use on vegetables m France, Germany, Belgmm, Switzerland, Italy, and United Kingdom, and has been trtaled against cotton pests in Africa.
Butt, Harris, and Powell
40 Table 6 Virus Yield from Wild-Type Stram
AcNPV-wild-type AcNPV + AaHIT (AcST3)
and Transgenic
AcNPV
Virus yield/larva (PIBs x lo-*) 96 1.0
The biggest disadvantage m using wild-type baculoviruses for insect control is the slow speed of kill. Insects can often take longer than 100 h to die, and are stimulated by the mfection to increase their feeding rate above normal in the interim. The consequence of this can be that unacceptable crop damage can occur before the population can be controlled. Researchers have sought to tackle this issue by arming baculoviruses with foreign genes expressmg msectspecific toxins, using genetic engineering techniques. It 1s believed that, by expressing a fast-acting toxin within the insect cell, feeding mhibmon and paralysis could occur quite quickly followmg ingestion, and that acceptable crop protection could be achieved. The Institute of Virology at Oxford, a facility of the National Environment Research Council (NERC), has been one of the pathfinders m relation to the research, and subsequent field testing, of genetically modified viruses m Europe Under extremely strict conditions of containment, modified Autographa calzfornica nucleopolyhedrovuuses (AcNPV), expressing a marker gene, were first trtaled m 1986, to determine the spread and survival of the virus. This was followed up with viruses that contained suicide genes, and then examples that were polyhedrm-negative, that is, deficient m then- protective coat protems, significantly reducing their persistence in the environment (29). More recently, work has concentrated on AcNPV containmg the Androctonus australis insectspecific scorpion toxin gene (coded AcST3). This modtfied vu-us was demonstrated to give significantly faster speed-of-kill m larvae of Trichoplusza ni under field conditions. Furthermore, because a baculovn-us is only capable of reproducing while the host is still alive, polyhedra yields from the msects infected with recombinant vnus were substantially lower than those infected by the equivalent wild-type (29) (Table 6) This suggests that, under practical use conditions, recombinant baculovnuses are competitively disadvantaged compared to wild-types, and, as such, are likely not to predominate m the environment. Other toxin genes can also be considered, as demonstrated m Fig. 5. Two constructs are compared with the wild-type AcNPV. The first construct has received a spider-derived gene encoding for a-laterodectus insect toxin (30). The second construct has received a gene described as Tox 34#4, which is an RT-PCR-generated cDNA clone encoding a protein with a high level of
Microbial Biopesticides: European Scene
41
Dose
Activity
1 x 10E6
PIB’slml
days after treatment
Fig. 5. Activity of wild-type AcMNPV vs constructsagainst Heliothis virescens (tobaccobudworm). (Adapted with permissionfrom ref. 32.) homology (94% identity) to the original TxP-1 itch mite (@emotes tritici) toxin (31). Both of these constructs have the toxin gene driven off the PlO viral promoter, which commences expression about 36 h postinfection. As can be seen,there is a substantial benefit in terms of speed-of-kill, especially with AcNPV + Tox 34#4 (32). This virus is used solely as a research standard within Zeneca. Arguably, highly effective recombinant baculoviruses offer the best likelihood of microbial insecticides achieving chemical-like levels of efficacy and crop protection effect, and have excellent potential for usage in key European markets, such as vegetables, fruit, and tomatoes. 6. Future Prospects The momentum for the development of natural agents for the control of pests, weeds, and diseaseswill be sustained. This will, in part, be the result of increasing awareness and sensitivity of the general public to health and environmental risks associated with chemical pesticides. However, as knowledge and experience in the harnessing of BCAs increases, they will be easier to deploy, and, therefore, will be used more extensively than at present. This momentum can only be maintained if there is investment in the research and development of BCAs, combined with support from extension services and industry, to optimize the impact of these agents. Only then can the technology
42
Butt, Harris, and Powell
be transferred to the end user, and a sustainable, envn-onmentally protection program established.
friendly
crop
References 1 Pickett, J A , Butt, T M , Doughty, K J., Wallsgrove, R M , and Wtlltams, I H (1995) Mmimismg pesticide input m otlseed rape by explomng natural regulatory processes Plenary lecture, m Proceedzngs of the GCIRC 9th Internatzonal Rapeseed Congress, Cambridge, UK, &7 July, 2,565-57 1 2 Rhodes, D J (1990) Formulatton requirements for btologlcal control agents Aspects Appl Bzol. 24, 145-153 3 Moore, D , Douro-Kpmdou, 0 K., Jenkins, N E , and Lomer, C J (1996) Effects of moisture content and temperature on storage of Metarhzzzum flavovzrzde comdta Bzocontrol Scz Technol 6, 5 16 1 4 Moore, D., Bateman, R P , Carey, M., and Prior, C (1995) Long-term storage of Metarhzzzumflavovzrzde comdra m 011formulattons for the control of locusts and grasshoppers. Bzocontrol Scz Technol 5, 193-199 5 McLatchte, G V , Moore, D , Bateman, R P , and Prior, C (1994) Effects of temperature on the viabtlny of the comdta of Metarhzzzum flavovzrzde m oil formulations Mycologzcal Res 98, 749-756 6 Moore, D , Bndge, P. D , Htggms, P. M , Bateman, R P , and Prior, C (1993) Ultravtolet radiation damage to Metarhzzzum flavovzrzde conrdta and the protectton given by vegetable and mineral oils and chemical sunscreens Ann Appl Bzol 122,605-616 7 Jenkins, N E and Thomas, M B (1996) Effects of formulation and appltcatton method on the efficacy of aerial and submerged comdta of Metarhzzzum flavovzrzde for locust and grasshopper control Pestzczde Scz 46,299-306 8 Smith, D B., Hostetter, D. L , and Pmnell, R E. (1980) Laboratory formulation compartsons for a bacterial (Bacillus thurzngzenszs) and vtral (Baculovrrus Helzothzs) msecttctde J Econ Entomol 73, 18-21 9 Lisansky, S. (1989) Btopestmides fall short of market proJections Performance Chem l&387-396 10 Powell, K A , Faull, J L , and Renwrck, A. (1990) Commercial and regulatory challenge, m Bzologzcal Control of Sozl-Borne Plant Pathogens CAB lnternational, Wallmgford, UK 11 Pusey, P L , Wtlson, C L , and Wtsmewski, M E (1993) Management of postharvest diseases of fruits and vegetables strategies to replace vamshmg fungicides, m Pestzczde Interactzons zn Crop Productzon Benejczal and Deleterzous Effects (Altman, J , ed ), CRC, Boca Raton, FL, pp 477-492 12 Wilson, C L. and Wismewskt, M E (1989) Biological control of postharvest diseases of fruits and vegetables an emerging technology Annu Rev Phytopathol 27,425-441 13 Ryder, M H and Jones, D A (1990) Biological control of crown gall, m Bzologzcal Control of So&Borne Plant Pathogens CAB International, Wallmgford, UK 14 Defago, G. and Haas, D (1990) Pseudomonads as antagomsts of sotlborne plant pathogens. mode of action and genetic analysts Sozls Bzochem 6, 249-29 1
Microbial
Biopesticides:
European
43
Scene
15 Alabouvette, C (1990) Biological control of Fusarzum welts m suppresstve solIs, m Btologzcal Control of Sod-Borne Plant Pathogens CAB lnternattonal, Wallingford, UK 16 Rtshbeth, J. (1963) Stump protection against Fomes annosu~ III. Inoculatton with Pentophora gtgantea. Ann Appl Btol 52,63-77
17 Butt, T M , Ibrahtm, L , Ball, B. V , and Clark, S J (1994) Pathogemctty of the entomogenous fungt Metarhtztum antsopltae and Beauverta basstana agamst cructfer pests and the honey bee Bzocontrol Set Technol 4,207-2 14 18 Butt, T M , Ibrahtm, L , Clark, S J., and Beckett, A (1995) The germmation behavtour of Metarhtztum anzsopltae on the surface of aphid and flea beetle cuticles Mycologzcal Res 99, 945-950. 19 St. Leger, R , Butt, T M., Staples, R , and Roberts, D W (1989) Syntheses of proteins mcludmg a cuticle-degrading protease during dtfferenttatton of the entomopathogemc fungus Meturhtztum antsopltae Exp Mycol 13,253-262 20 St Leger, R , Butt, T M , Goettel, M S , Staples, R , and Roberts, D W (1989) Productton in vrtro of appressorta by the entomopathogemc fungus Metarhtztum antsopltae Exp Mycol 13,274-288 21 Anon (1989) Agrow Btologtcal Crop Protectton, PJB, Surrey, UK. 22. Remecke, P , Andersch, W , Stenzel, K , and Hartwtg, J (1990) BIO 1020, a new mtcrobtal msecttctde for use m horttcultural crops, m Proceedtngs ofthe Brtghtun Crop Protectton Conference, Pests and Diseases, vol 1, pp 49-54 Vestergaard, S , Gtllespte, A. T , Butt, T M., Schretter, G , and Etlenberg, J. 23 (1995) Pathogentctty of the hyphomycete fungt Verttctlltum lecantt and Metarhtztum anzsoplrae to the western flower thrtps, Frankitntella occtdentalts Btocontrol SCZ Technol 5, 185-192 24. Butt, T M., Barrtsever, M , Drummond, J, Schuler, T H , TIRemans, F T , and Wtldmg, N (1992) Pathogemcity of the entomogenous, hyphomycete fungus, Metarhtzzum antsoplzae agamst the chrysomeltd beetles Psylltodes chrysocephala and Phaedon cochleartae Btocontrol Set Technol 2,325-332 25. Glowacka B and Malmowskt, H (1994) Department of Forest Protectton, Warsaw, personal communicatton 26 Anon (1994) A threat to a thud of Poland’s forest Bzotzmes (Novo Nordtsk) 27. Harris, J. G (1994) Expertence of B t z usage m U.S A , Europe, and Afrtca, m Proceedtngs of the Semtnar on Mtcrobtal Control ofMosquttoes, Untversttt Sams Malaysia, Penang, Malaysta 28. Becker, N and Margaltt, J. (1993) Use of Baczllus thurzngzenszs zsraelenszs agamst mosquttoes and blacklies, m Bactllus thunngienszs, An Envtronmental Btopestzczde Theory and Practzce (Entwtstle, P. F , Cory, J S., Bailey, M J , and Htggs, S , eds ), Wtley, Chtchester, UK, pp 147-170 29 Cory, J (1995) Open Baculovirus Publtc Meetmg, NERC Oxford, November 30. Watkms, M , Ktyatkm, N , Hughes, D , Beadle, D , and Ktng, L (1997) Study on the btologtcal properties of a novel recombinant baculovirus, tn Proceedtng of the BCPC Necesstty? pp. 279-284
Conference,
Microbtal
Insecttctdes,
Novelty
or
44
Butt, Harm, and Powell
31 Tomalskr, M D and Mtller, L. K (1991) Insect paralysis by baculovn-us medrated expresston of a mtte neurotoxm gene. Nature (Lond) 352,82-85. 32 Harrts, J G (1997) Mrcrobtal msecttcldes an industry perspective. How the mdustry sees the future, the opportumttes and the tools to solve the problem, m Proceedmgs of Mcroblal Insectudes Novelty or Necewty? BCPC Symposium 68,4 I-50. 33. OECD (1996) Data requirements for registration of bropesttcrdes in OECD member countries survey results. Envnonment monograph No 106, OECD, Pans, France, p 12 1 34. Feng, M G , Poprawskt, T. J , and Khachatourians, G. G (1994) Productton, formulation and appltcatton of the entomopathogemc fungus Beauverla basslana for insect control. current status Bzocontrol Scl Technol 4,3-34
4 Developing Countries Balasubramanyan
Sugavanam
and Xie Tianjian
1. Introduction Blo- and botanical pesticides are often grouped together m developing countries as possible alternatives to chemical pesticides. In reality, botanic pestlc!des are no different from chemical pesticides, but blopestlcides are all far removed from them. Botanical pesticides derived from tobacco (Nicotiana tabacum), pyrethrum (Chrysanthemum cznerariaefolium), derrls roots, neem, and so on, have been known for many decades, but occupy only a very small fraction of the overall pesticide market, which IS now worth almost $28 bllhon, and 1slikely to grow to $34 bilhon by the year 1998. Some of the well-known botanical pesticides will fail today’s strict and exhaustive reglstratlon requirements. However, the botanical pesticides gave ideal models for sclentlsts to modify structure and optimize blologlcal activity The synthetic pyrethroids revolutionized the pesticide industry m the 197Os,and today share more than a $2 bllllon market. In the 1980s and 199Os,based on mcotme and strobllurm, major inventions were made m bringing to the market compounds, such as Bayer’s (Germany) tmidacloprid (11 and ICI (UK) A5504 (azoxystrobm) (2), shown in Fig. 1. In addition, BASF also has invented a strobllurin analog called kresoxlme methyl (BAS490F). These will have a big impact In the plant funglclde market. In these mventlons, traditional structure-activity relationship, partltlon coefficients, mode-of-action studies, and computer graphics have been utilized by synthetic chemists to invent key molecules that could fit the relevant enzyme surface, like lock and key, to invoke the needed blologlcal actlvlty and at the same time not interfere with mammalian and aquatic species and not accumulate in the environment. In the case of blopesticldes, there was a great hope for these products during the early 1970s. However, because of major breakthroughs m conventronal From Methods m Botechnology, vol 5 Elopesfudes Use andDe/wery E&ted by F R Hall and J J Menn 0 Humana Press Inc , Totowa, NJ
45
46
Sugavanam and Xie
Imidadoprid
Fig 1 Chemicalsrecently synthesizedusmgnatural products as lead compounds chemistry durmg the 1970s and 1980s in the invention of new synthetic chemlcals, the resources available to blopestlcldes became less and less At the same time, with the soarmg cost of inventing new pestlcldes, the long and expensive time required for reglstermg pesticides, and also problems encountered m developing countries caused by misuse of pesticides and the unnecessary exposure of workers and the environment to highly toxic pesticides, there was a great necessity and urgency to move to user- and environment-friendly pestlcldes. Blopestlcldes came at an ideal time and also, many countries agreed to relax registration requirements and reduce the time required to register blopestlcldes. This started a flurry of research actlvltles by many companies to Invest more m research and development to dlscover blopestlcldes. A large number of pheromones, and blologlcal agents based on fungi and viruses, have been successfully tested m the laboratorles and the field, but there has been very little impact m the market Still, the Baczllus thurzngzenszs (Bt) registered during the 1970s for insect control, and the various genetic mampulatlons of It, dominate the biopestlclde market 2. The Situation in Developing Countries With great importance given to integrated pest management (IPM) worldwide, the role of biopestlcldes 1scrucial as one of Its components. In developmg countries, excessive use of pesticides has caused development of resistance by insects and fungi to many conventional pesticides, and also resurgence of pests caused by destruction of natural enemies. Classic examples, including the brown plant hopper on rice, and bollworms and white fly on cotton, are all problems emanating from human use or misuse of synthetic pestlcldes. Barbosa (3) lists hundreds of pests of mternatlonal importance m more than eight major crops to which Bt could play a role. Although Bt and other blopestlcldes have good potential, both on their own or within the definition of IPM, there are many barriers to cross, because the new synthetic pestlcldes are becoming more and more effective, the formulations are becommg more and more userand environment-friendly, while blopestlcldes lack consistency m their field performance, and suffer quality variations and shelf-life mstablhty The luxury
Developing
Countries
47
of usmg synthetic pesticides m various types of formulattons and delivery systems are hmited m the case of biopesttcides Again, big companies getting fully mvolved m developmg biopesttcides are also lrmited because of lower profit margms, hence, only companies addressmg mche markets, or when organic farms supplemented with attractive subsidies to compensate for addltional costs m terms of using biopesticides and biological agents, are taking up biopesticrdes. In developing countries, lower labor costs would make biopesttcides or biological agents, such as viral msecticides, more attractive, provided there are enough mcentives and technical assistancegiven by the governments and international agencies, such as FAO, WHO, and UNIDO. Such countries such as Indonesia, the Philippines, and Egypt have been phasmg out a number of msecticides, and here the biopesticides could replace some of them and fit wtthin the prmctples of IPM. 3. Production of Biopesticides in Developing Countries Developtng countrtes began looking into the local production of biopesticides, focusing mostly on Bt, almost 30 years ago. In 1964, China estabhshed a research and development laboratory to explore possible local production. A group of researchers at Campmas Umversity m Braztl studied all aspectsof Bt fermentation in the 197Os,and filed two patents In Egypt, Bt production was carried out in a sugar and dtsttllery company using a 5000 L fermenter equipped with centrifugatton and drymg facihties Countries such as India, Mexico, and Thailand tried to look mto low cost production of Bt Unfortunately, exceptmg China, most of these attempts never became a commercial reality, because of lack of experience m quality control, formulation, and application of btopesttcide at that time. In Chma, Beauverza basszsana was the most important fungal msectitide, and was developed more than 10 yr ago A vast amount of vtgorous mycelium was harvested from fermentation (liquid stage) and transferred mto semisolid media (solid stage), consisting of bran, sugar, agar, and minerals. The final product contained 1.8 x IO” spores/g. Many village manufacturers adopted this procedure to produce 5. basszana for control of pine caterpillar and corn borer. Chma’s Ministry of Forestry is m charge of formulatmg the product standards, and will be publishing them soon. For viral msecticrde, the first factory was established m 1985 to produce Hellothzs armzgera NPV. The production flow chart is given tn Fig. 2 Artificial diet for rearing msects was composed mostly of soybean, barley, and yeast Recently, most HaNPV preparations have been processed mto cheaper liquid formulattons. In China, three HaNPV firms have been registered, and about 100 t of this product, contammg 3 billion PIB/mL, are now sold to farmers for control of cotton bollworm
Sugavanam and Xie
48
new hatched
the fourth
tnster
lnrvae
larvae’
Fig. 2 Flow chart of HaNPV production.
4. Bt Production in China Bt production m China has a long history. In the early stages, problems m fermentation and product quality control caused fluctuation m the performance of the product However, since the 198Os,great improvements have been made m screening strains and overcoming phage contammation, changing downstream processmg, formulation, and bioassay procedures. The flow chart of production of Bt m China is given below: Llquld Liquid stock seed + slant seed -+ fermentation + sieving -+ centnfugatlon + checking quality -+ packaging liquid formulation Solid Spray drying of the centrifugal hquld + mlcromlllmg + blendmg + checking quality + packaging powder formulation
In China, use of local Bt strains is encouraged. Several hundred Bt strains are screened every year. One strain, MP-342(H3ab), screened by Hubet Bt Research Centre (Bt RDC), containing cryIA(a), cryIA(c), cryIIA, cryIIB, and cryV genes, shows high toxicity to cotton bollworm. It is the most important Bt strain for commerctal production. Thousands of local Bt strains have been collected in several institutes and universities in China. Primarily defatted soybean flour and cottonseed flour are used as raw material.
During the early days
Developing
Countries
49
of commerctal productton, the concentration of medta was between 3 and 4%, whrch induced low potency of broth. Based on Bt metabolism studies, optrmtzmg fermentation media composition and fermentation parameters, the potency now can reach the level of 3000-4000 IU/pL Phage contammatton, which once threatened Bt fermentation, 1s now completely removed, and the failure rate Induced by phage has been kept to below 1% since 1986. Two kinds of Bt formulattons are produced. The liquid formulatron, usmg only centrifugatton, 1snot as good as the wettable powder formulatton, but is very popular, and today makes up 70-80% of the total Bt market m China. 5. Quality Control Quality control plays a key role m Bt productron. Spore count has been totally replaced by bioassay. The standard sample developed by BtRDC and the Central Chma Agricultural University have been adopted by the scientific community and manufacturers. Two testing insects, cotton bollworm (Heliothzs armzgera) and diamondback moth (Plutellu xylostella), are used in the laboratory The product quality standards are as follows: liquid formulation: 20004000 IUIyL, 1 yr stabthty period, powder formulatton: 16,000-32,000 IU/pL, 2 yr stab&y period. Good-quality Bt products, reasonably priced, are becoming popular m China. Over 40 factories have been registered; all equipment used m the plants are made locally, and give satisfactory performance. BtRDC is the biggest Bt manufacturer in China, and has increased its capacity by moving from 7000-L fermentor in the early 1980s to 40,000-L fermentor now. The production of ltqutd formulation has increased from 1200 Mt in 1993 to 1400 Mt in 1994 to 2500 Mt in 1995 to 5500 Mt in 1996. Most of the wettable-powder formulations are exported. In China, more than 1 mtllton ha are treated with Bt, and local productron will keep increasing, and will complement synthetic pestrctdes in selected important outlets. 6. Registration Requirements Registration requirements of btopesttcides vary from country to country. In China, the Instrtute for the Control of Agrochemlcals, Ministry of Agrtculture (ICAMA), 1sthe authority for pesticide registration. Based on the fact that there are no accidents reported in large-scale Bt production and application, and no adverse effect on nontarget species, such as honey bees, buds, and fresh water fish for decades,and that all Bt manufacturers use native strams for local production, ICAMA makes registration requirements for Bt simple and effective For finished products, the guidelines of data required are given in Table 1. The potency of Bt products is determined by bioassay with newly hatched cotton bollworm (Helzothzs armigera) or dlamondback moth (Plutella
50
Sugavanam Table 1 Guidelines
for Data Required
for China’s
and Xie
ICAMA Registration
Chemical and physical properties Name and type of formulation Quantity of active ingredient Content and identity of nonactive ingredients, such as UV protectors Water-retaining agents, and so on Content of extraneous organisms Chemical and physical properties Stability of product and effect of temperature and storage conditions on biological activity Method of analysis Toxicology Acute oral toxicity or pathogenicity (to mice) Acute dermal toxicity (to Oryctolugus cuniculus) Efficacy Crops to be protected Target pests Degree of specificity for target pests Effective dose level and mode of action Rate, frequency, and method of application
xylostella) in different factories, and by comparing this to a standard sample supplied by ICAMA. According to the guidelines and analysis method mentioned above, most manufacturers do not have difficulties in obtaining registration for Bt products. It is clear that ICAMA makes a great contribution to promoting Bt production and development. Registration of viral and fungal insecticides is just in the early stages. 7. Biopesticides
in Thailand
Thailand has played an important role in promoting biopesticides. Research and development carried out at Mahidol University and the Ministry of Agriculture at Keserat University have promoted both Bt and viral insecticides that have been taken up by private entrepreneurs. Thailand has also played the role of focal point in UNIDO’s program (4) Regional Network on Pesticides for Asia and the Pacific (RENPAP) (see also Subheading 9.). India has been a long supporter of biopesticides, but most of the work was research-oriented, with very little applied research and promotion of production. Because of a highly subsidized malaria eradication program using DDT, there was no incentive
to use biopesticides
in vector control.
Resistance
to
Developing
Countries
51
DDT and its illegal use in agriculture might be a major incentive for moving to biopesticides as environmentally friendly alternatives in malaria vector control. Export barriers because of pesticide residues might also provide outlets for the application of biopesticides in vegetables, cotton, and so on. 8. Other Countries In 1995 UNIDO, in collaboration with the RENPAP, organized a workshop on production and quality control of biopesticides in China (5), in which many Asian countries participated. The main objective of the workshop was to assist countries in Asia to develop capabilities in production and use of biopesticides. Many papers presented in the workshop (5) revealed the situation in many countries of the region. In Pakistan, the use of microbial insecticide has been adopted as part of IPM approach to provide an environment-friendly alternative to generally hazardous broad-spectrum insecticides used against Heliothis armigera. Laboratory bioassays using spore crystal preparations of Bt kurstaki indicated high mortalities of the first instar larvae of H. armigera. Potted chickpea (Cicer arietinum L) plant testsrevealed that the biopesticide Dipel2x and Dipel ES (Bt kurstaki), at rates of 1.6 kg/ha and 2.0 L/ha, caused 81.48 and 84% larval mortality, respectively. Field tests of Bt on chickpea crops (three consecutive seasons)indicated that Dipel2x and Dipel ES (Bt kurstaki; Abbot, USA), at the rates of 1.6 kg/ha and 1.5 L/ha (with and without molasses), respectively, caused significant increase in grain yield, compared to control plots. In Pakistan, where the major portion of insecticides are used on cotton, use of biopesticides and biological control agents would be economically and environmentally appealing, but commercial production and use of these is still not seriously taken up in that country. In the Philippines, the use of biopesticides is becoming increasingly important. The total market share of Bt in the insecticide market increased from 4% in 1992 to over 9% in 1995. The use of Btk is primarily in cabbage, against diamondback moth. In the Philippines, lack of facilities and financial support for Bt research and development, and lack of technology on bioassay and commercial production of Bt, are the major constraints in the development of Bts and their formulations. In South Korea, in order to reduce adverse impact on nontarget organisms and the environment, the government has put the emphasis on development of alternative pest control agents based on low input and sustainable agriculture. Biopesticides obviously appear as good alternatives. Of the 568 pesticides registered in the country, biopesticides account for 3% (15 products). Production of biopesticides increased almost 200-fold in the last 10-yr period (1984-l 994). Quality control of pesticides is regulated under the Pesticide Management Law through the National Agricultural Science and Technology Institute (NASTI). The quality of Bt-based pesticides is switched to Diamondback Moth Unit
52
Sugavanam
and Xie
(DBMU) from Biologtcal International Unit (BIUL). In South Korea, signif? cant research work 1sbemg carried out on btopesttctdes, but needs integrated gutdelmes, tncludmg btologtcal testmg methods, requu-ed for quality assurance of btopesticides. In Vietnam, research work on the utthzatton of btopestictdes was mmated m 1970, m order to develop domestic production of Bt. Bt application IS quite effective and popular m controllmg pests, such as Plutella xylostella in vegetables, and other leptdopteran pests. In collaboratton with the Food Industries Instttute, 300-L batches of Bt kurstaki, with a shelf life of 7 mo under low temperature, are bemg produced, and the product has been commerctahzed Though the locally produced Bt is cheaper than imported Bt, product standardization and contammations are some of the problems yet to be solved. In Africa, major research and development work has been cart-ted out at the International Center of Insect Physiology and Ecology (ICIPE), m Nairobi, Kenya Independently, and m collaboratton wtth mternattonal orgamzatton and bilateral agencies, the center has developed Bts and carried extensive field studies. Recently, they have been testing a Bt product from Finland called Dudstop for the control of filth flies, whtch are known to be potenttal agents for transmtsston of entertc diseases,such as dysentery, mfanttle dtarrhea, typhoid, and trachoma, among others. Most of the tests have been carrted out m refugee camps m Kenya, Ethiopia, Tanzania, and Et-urea. In collaboratton with the Hebrew Umversity of Israel, the Institute ts testing Bt uraelensu and Bacdlus sphaerzcus for larvicidal effect on different mosqutto spectes and then perststence. The Institute is eager to establish pilot plant factlittes for productton of some Bts, but, again, lack of funds and support make these goals unattainable. 9. Activities of International Organizations International orgamzations have been acttve for many years m promotmg btopesttctdes, on their own, or as part of an IPM strategy With the development of resistance to many pesticides and the problems faced with the contmued use of DDT m malaria vector control, and the recent concern over perststent orgamc pollutants, Bt lsraelenszs offers an excellent opportunity to interfere wtth the mosqutto cycle at tts cructal stage as a larvtctde. As early as 1982, the World Health Organization, supported by the World Bank and the United Nations Development Programs (UNDP), developed gutdelmes (6) for productton of Bt H-14 for biological control of vectors. The guidelines supported production of Bt m developmg countrtes for both public health and agricultural requirements The FAO and UNIDO were requested to assist in early-stage evaluatton and plannmg. UNIDO has been active m orgamzmg workshops m productton, quality control, and bioassay in developmg countries. The FAO also wtll extend its code of conduct for btopesttctdes. Most of the work so far
Developmg Countr/es
53
has been concentrated on conductmg workshops and expert group meetings, with many recommendations for commercial production of biopesticides to complement synthetic pesticides. As always, most of these recommendations were not followed by financial and policy incentives and commitments by donor or recipient countries. 10. Opportunities for Developing Countries With developmg countries giving great emphasis to IPM, biopesticides offer an excellent opportunity for developing coutries. Some of the reasons for this, as could be seen from the experience of China, are summarized below. 1 Raw materials are locally available, and could be made from locallyavailableBt strams 2 Preparation of vuus msecttctdes needs manual labor and, hence, 1s highly suttable to developmg countrtes 3. Technology transfer and quality control could be negotiated with relevant companies or mstitutrons m both developed and developmg countrtes 4. For proper trammg m apphcatton of btopesttctdes, mternattonal orgamzattons, such as FAO, UNIDO, and WHO, could be contacted 5. Use of biopesttctdes would also eliminate export restrtctlons based of restdues of certam pesticides, especially in vegetables, frmts, and other commodittes.
Developing countries should look into biopesticides for complementmg synthetic pesticides and not for replacing them. If carefully planned m certain outlets, biopesticides would bring great benefits m reducing the use of synthetic pesticides, especially those that are toxic and persistent. There should be a systematic national/regional strategy to momtor development of resistance to biopesticides, so that they could be rotated along with synthetic pesticides. With the present technology, the market share of biopesticides would be very limited, compared to synthetic chemicals. If one combines biopesticides wtth biologtcal
agents, disease, and insects, and herbicide-resistant
transgemc
crops, the overall effect of biotechnology on crop production and protection will have great impact in the next millennium. One should also apply the caution that synthettc pesticides will contmue to dominate
the market tn the near
and distant future, because of constant improvement m mventions of new pesticides, their formulattons,
and application
technology.
References 1, Shtokawa, K , Tsubot S , Kagabu, S , and Morrtya, K (1994) Imtdacloprtd a chlopraomcotmyl msecttclde, its invention and features, m Ezghth ZUPAC Znternational Congress of Pestlclde Chemutry, Options 2000, American Chemical Society, Washmgton, DC, p. 4 2. Anthony, V M , Clough, J M , Godfrey, C R A, and Godwm, J R (1994) Syntheses of fungtctdal methoxyacrylates, Ezghth IUPAC Internatzonal Con-
54
3.
4
5
6
Sugavanam and X/e gress of Pestzclde Chemistry, Optlons 2000, Amertcan Chemtcal Soctety, Washmgton, DC, p 5 Barbosa, S (1993) Potential of Bt m mtegrated pest managementfor developmg countrtes, m Blopestlclde Bt and rts Appllcatlons in Developing Countries (Salama, H S , Morris, 0 N , and Rached, E , eds), National Research Centre, Catro, Egypt, and IDRC, Canada,pp 59-7 1 Dhua, S P (1992) Regtonal network on pesttctdes for Asta and the Pacific (RENPAP) an overview, m Recent Developmentsin the Field of Pestwdes and thew Application to Pest Control (Holly, K , Copping, L S , and Brooks, G T , eds ), UNIDO, Vtenna, pp 277-284 Report on Workshop on Productton and Qualtty Control of Btopesttctde Bt Wuhan, Republtc of Chma, November, 1995 UNIDO Report, DP/ID/Ser A/ 1765,1995. Vandekar, M and Dulmage, H T , eds (1983) Guzdellnesfor Pvodzxtzon of Bacillus thurznglensls H-14, UNDP, World Bank, WHO
5 Pesticide Policy Influences on Biopesticide Technologies Noel D. Uri 1. Introduction Pesticide pohcy has a substantial impact on the development and use of btopesttctdes. Before explormg the nature and extent of this impact, it 1sworthwhile to examine btopestictde use, m order to put policy influences m proper perspective The constant evolution and adoption of new productton practices, includmg relatively pesticide-intensive farming, has led to a sustained increase m output and comctdent benefits to the American consumer m a variety of ways, mcludmg the price of food The conventional pesticides used today were new and uncertam m prevtous periods In an analogous way, biopesttcrdes and other forms of biologrcal control being developed today will be conventtonal pesttctdes m the future. The growth of biopesttcide use is an Integral part of the technologtcal revolutton m agriculture that has generated major changes m production techniques, shifts in input use, and growth m output and producttvtty (I) Predicting the growth m biopestlctde use, however, IS difficult, because of recent changes in federal laws affecting the farm sector (a major consumer of btopesttctdes) and regulating the registration and use of pesticides. Addtttonally, accurately forecasting the changes m the price of biopesticldes relative to the price of conventtonal pesticides complicate the predictron problem. These issues will be discussed below The market for brologtcally based pest controls IS small but fast growing The market value of btologtcally based products-natural enemies, pheromones, and mtcrobtal pesticides-sold m the United States during the early 1990s was estimated at $95-147 mtllton, 1.3-2 4% of the total market for pest control products (2). At least 30 commercral firms produce natural enemies. From Methods ,n Biotechnology, vol 5 B,opest!ades Use and Dehvery Edited by F R Hall and J J Menn 0 Humana Press Inc , Totowa, NJ
55
56
U-1
Even though the current market for brological products is growing, and large pest-control companies are begmnmg to participate, the market IS still so small that biologlcals are unlikely to replace conventional chemical pesticides m the foreseeable future, unless major research and development activities are started (3). Biologrcal pest management includes the use of pheromones, plant regulators, and microbial organisms, such as Bacillus thuringlenszs (Bt), as well as pest predators, parasites, and other beneficial organisms. The US Envnonmental Protection Agency (EPA) currently regulates biochemicals and mrcrobral organisms, and classifies them as biorational pesticides. 7.7. Microbial
Pesticides and Pheromones
Brorational pesticides have differed significantly from conventional pesticides, because they have generally managed rather than eliminated pests, have a delayed impact, and have been more selective (4). Thus, for example, microbial pesticides have not been successful as herbicides, because target weeds are replaced by other weeds not affected by the microbial pesticide Among the most successful mrcrobials has been Bt, which kills Insects by lethal infection. Growers have dramatically mcreased then use of Bt during the 199Os, especially under blomtensive and resistance-management programs, because of its environmental safety, improved performance, selectrvity, and activity on insects that are resistant to conventional pesticides. It is one of the most important msect management tools in certified organic production. Bt was used m more than 1% of the acreage of 12 fruit crops m 1995, up from 5 crops m 199 1 (Table 1). Between 12 and 23% of the apple, plum, nectarine, and blackberry acreage received Bt applications m 1995, and it was applied on over half of the raspberry acreage. Among vegetable crops, the acreage treated with Bt increased for 13 of the 20 crops surveyed between 1992 and 1994, and was used on about half or more of the cabbage, celery, and eggplant acreage Bt has been used on only a couple of field crops. Corn acreage treated was steady at 1% m 1994 and 1995, and treated cotton acreage increased from 5% m 1992 to 9% m 1994 and 1995 New Bt strains, with activity on insects not previously found to be susceptible to Bt, have been discovered in recent years. Current research is devoted to improving the delivery of Bt to pests and to increasing the residual activity and efficacy of Bt. Pheromones are used to monitor populatrons of crop pests and to disrupt mating m organic systemsand some IPM programs. Pheromones were used on 37% of fruit acreage to monitor and control pests, and on 7% of vegetable acreage to control pests (Table 2).
Table 1 Agricultural Applications of Bacillus fhuringiensis Selected Crops in Surveyed States, 1991-1995
Crop Field crops Corn Cotton (upland) Fruit Grapes Oranges Apples Peaches Prunes Pears Sweet cherries Plums Nectarmes Blueberries Raspberries Blackberries Vegetables Tomatoes, processed Lettuce Sweet corn Onion Broccoli Tomatoes, fresh Cantaloupe Snap beans Cabbage Bell peppers Cauliflower Cucumbers Strawberrres Celery Honey dew Spinach Eggplant
Planted acres (in thousands)
(Bt), Area receivmg apphcation (in % acres)
1991
1992
64,105 1 I .650
a
796 760 345 144 94 68 47 44 36 30 11 4
a
b
2 3 C, 0 a n a L1
b
0
a
11 49 18 b
323 191 164 128 111 104 98 71 70 61 54 51 46 36 26 10 4
b 6 b
b b b b b b b b h b b b b
OApplred on CO5% of the acres *Not a survey year for that commodny (Adapted wtth permlssron from refs. 40 and 42.)
57
1993 ‘2
5
b b b
8
b
b
b
10 8 45 n
b
6 18 3 ” 7 31 32 20 48 35 12 19 24 51 28 13 13
1 9
1 9 6 3 12 5 9 2 9 14 22 5 52 23
1 8
b
b
1995
2 7 13 3 0
b
b
1994
h b b b b
b b
b h b b b b b b b b
5 20 3 1 14 39 8 29 64 37 20 22 33 61 10 21 48
b
b b b b b 6 b b b b h b b b b b
58
Ur1
Table 2 Use of Selected Biological Pest Management Practices on Fruit and Vegetable Crops in Major Producing States in the 1990s % of acres Crop Fruit Grapes Oranges Apples All frurts Vegetables Sweet corn Tomatoes Lettuce All vegetables
Planted acres (m thousands)
Beneficial Insects
Pheromone traps
Resistant varietres
18 22 2 19
14 28 66 37
31 21 16 22
NA 5
17
NA NA NA NA
730
613 381 3251 640 357 259
2914
3 3
6
1 7
NA not avarlable (Adapted with permlsslon from refs. 40 and 41 )
1.2. Beneficial
Organisms
Natural enemres of crop pests or beneficrals may be Imported, conserved, or augmented. Many crop pests are not native to thts country, and the US Department of Agrrculture (USDA) issues permits for the natural enemies of these pests to be Imported from thetr country of ortgm. Natural enemy rmportatron and establishment, also called classrcal brologrcal control, has been undertaken prrmartly m umverstty, state, and federal projects. Twenty-erght states operate brocontrol programs, and most have cooperatrve efforts with USDA agencies (2) Some crop pests, such as the woolly apple aphid m the Pacific Northwest, have been largely controlled with this method. Natural enemies may also be conserved by ensuring that then needs for alternate hosts, adult food resources, overwmtermg habitats, a constant food supply, and other ecologrcal requirements are met, and by preventing damage from pestrctde apphcattons and other cropping practrces (5). Over one-half the certrfied organic vegetable growers m 1994 were provrdmg habitat for beneficrals. A small but mcreasmg number of companies are supplymg natural enemies of insects, weeds, and other pests to farmers. For greenhouse and agrrcultural crop productron, most natural enemies being sold, such as beneficial insects, predatory mites, parasitic nematodes, and insect egg parasites, are used for managing pest mites, caterpillars, citrus weevrls, and other insect and arthro-
Policy
Influences
on Biopesticides
59
pod pests, However, a number of natural enemies-musk thistle defohatmg weevils, for example-are bemg sold for managmg weeds on rangeland and unculttvated pastures (6). The Cahfornia Environmental Protection Agency has published a list of commercial suppliers of natural enemies m North America since 1979, and the number has increased steadily. In 1994, 132 companies were listed, mostly m the United States, offering over 120 different orgamsms for sale (7). 1.3. Host-Plant Resistance Corn and soybean breeding for genetic resistance to insects, disease, and other pests has been the research and development focus of major seed companies for many decades (8). US soybean acreage, for example, receives virtually no fungictdes, because of the effectiveness of the disease-resistant soybean cultivars that have been developed. The use of classical breeding programs is now being augmented wtth new plant breeding efforts using transgemc and other genetic engineering techmques. In March 1995, the EPA approved, for the first time, a limited registration of genetically engineered plant pesticides to Cuba (Base& Switzerland) and Mycogen (San Diego, CA), and, m August 1995, granted condrtronal approval for full commercial use of a transgemc pesticide to combat the European corn borer (9). Thts plant pesticide, Bt corn, is produced when the genetic mformation related to insecticidal properttes IStransferred from the Bt bacterium to the corn plant. This technology could reduce the need for conventional chemical msectrcides in corn productton. In 1995,26% of US corn-planted acreage was treated with msecticides, and corn borer is one of the top insect pests targeted for treatment. Since these new corn varieties, however, contam natural genes and genes produced from the soil bacteria Bt, many scienttstsare concerned that the new corn will hasten pest immunity to Bt That is especially a concern for the growmg number of producers who rely on the foliar-applied Bt, and has led the EPA to approve the new pestrcrdes, condrtioned on the momtormg for pest resistance and the development of a management plan in case the insects become resistant Although most classtcal breedmg programs have focused on pests resistant to chemtcals or treatments that were too expensive (10), consumer concern over pesticides m agricultural products has prompted biotechnology companies to enter the genetically engineered plant market. As agricultural biotechnology products attam commerctal success,some private Investment fundmg may shift from the smaller pharmaceutical markets toward agrtcultural crop protection (II). On the other hand, consumer acceptance of bioengmeered Bt corn, Bt cotton, and other genetically engineered crops has not yet been dem-
Uri
60
onstrated m major US markets. A 1992 survey of consumer attitudes about food biotechnology found that most consumers want mformation on labels about vartous food characteristics, including the use of biotechnology (12) Animal Plant Health Inspection Service (APHIS) has approved or acknowledged 638 field trials for insect-resistant varieties since 1987,286 field trials to test viral resistance, and 94 field trials for fungal resistance (23). 2. Biopesticide Use in the Context of Pesticide Policy Many factors affect the adoption of biopesticides as a crop productton technology. Pest cycles and annual fluctuations caused by weather and other envtronmental conditions often determine whether infestation levels reach treatment thresholds. Changes m farm biopesticide use are related to producers’ decisions on the amount and mix of crops to plant. Given this, other factors that influence bropesttcide use decisions are relative factor prices and government farm, conservation, and regulatory policies 2.1. Relative
Factor
Prices
The changing relative prices between different pesticides 1simportant, especially as biopestictdes strive to replace conventional pesticides For example, the largest pesticide market m the United States is cotton. It accounts for 35% of the msectictde market, with about $850 million m sales m 1996 (13). Bt cotton has the potential to be a challenge to conventional fohar sprays for control of the budworm/bollworm complex. The cost of Bt cotton, including Tracer (DowElanco, Indianapolis, IN), Pirate (American Cyammid, Pearl River, NY), Proclatm (Merck, Whitehouse Station, NJ), and Confirm (Rohm and Haas, Philadelphia, PA), however, averages about $34/acre. Conventional insecticide treatment averages around $10,20/acre. Given the current price differential, Bt cotton is not likely to replace conventtonal msecticides. In another example, btological control has been shown to be effective on Canada thistle, leafy spurge, the knapweeds, St. Johnswort, musk thistle, and other weeds. Biologtcal control through beneficial insects (e-g , Canada thistle stem mnnng weevtl and musk thistle rosette weevil), however, 1sprtced substantially higher than, say, atrazme. In 1996, the price of atrazme (a common herbicide used to control these weeds) was approx $3.90/acre, and btologtcal control is priced at about $70.00/acre (13). Thus, biological control will not likely to replace atrazme or one of the other triazme herbicides m the near future,
2.2. Government Commodity and Conservation Programs Federal commodity and conservation programs affect agricultural biopesticide use, m part, through the amount of acres planted. Past commodity programs were designed primarily to provide price and income protectron for
Policy Influences on Biopesticides
61
farmers. Land set-aside requirements helped restrict supply and increase commodtty prices (14). Although the Federal Agriculture Improvement and Reform Act (FAIR) of 1996 eliminated those set-aside requirements, the reauthorized Conservatton Reserve Program, designed for envtronmental objectives, pays producers to keep acreage in conserving uses, rather than in production. Fewer acres planted generally implies less biopesticides applied. Other federal agricultural conservatron programs influence productton practices on planted acreage, which in turn wtll affect biopesticide use. 2.3. Agricultural Chemical Regulations: Implications for Biopesticide Use Pesticide regulation m its modern form began with the enactment of the Federal Insecttcide, Fungicide, and Rodenticide Act (FIFRA) m 1948. Under this mandate, Congress required that all chemicals for sale m interstate commerce be registered against the manufacturers’ claims of effectiveness. The law also required manufacturers to indicate pesticide toxicity on the label. Congress amended FIFRA in 1954, 1959, and 1964, but, in practice, pesticide regulatton by 1970 meant efficacy testing and labeling for acute (short-term) toxicity. Pesticide regulation passed mto a new phase with the 1972 amendment to FIFRA, and the transfer of regulatory jurisdiction to the EPA. Under this new regulatory regime, Congress gave the EPA the responsibility of reregistermg extstmg pesticides, examining the effects of pesticides on fish and wtldlife, and evaluating acute and chronic toxicity In the 1988 amendment to FIFRA, pesticide producers were required to demonstrate, wtthm 9 yr, that all pesticides registered before November 1984 meet current standards (4). Pesticides are also regulated by various provtsions of the Federal Food, Drug and Cosmetic Act (FFDCA). Under the FFDCA, the EPA establishes the maxtmum allowable level (tolerance) of pesticide residues that can be present on foods sold m interstate commerce, and the Food and Drug Admimstratton (FDA) momtors food and feed for pesticide residues. In 1996, Congress passed the Food Quality Protection Act (FQPA), which was intended to update and resolve inconsistenctes in the two major pesticide statutes: FIFRA and FFDCA. The major components of the FQPA address the issues of settmg a single, health-based standard (i.e., a reasonable certainty of no harm) for all pesticides m all foods (although benefits can continue to be considered in certain instances when setting standards), provtdmg special protection for infants and children, regulatory relief for minor use pesticides, expediting approval for safer (reduced-risk) pesticides, requnmg periodic reevaluatton of pesticide registrations and tolerances, and reauthorizing and increasing registrant fees to fund such reevaluattons, establishing national umformtty of tolerances unless States petition for an exception, and mandating
62
U-1
the dtstrtbutton of mformatton m grocery stores on the health rusks of pesttcldes and how to avoid such rusks (24a,Z5,16). The crttical components of the FQPA, as far as btopestictdes are concerned, deal with expediting the review of mmor-use pesticides and expediting the approval of reduced-risk pesttcides. Both sections of the legrslatton should serve to accelerate the development and commercialtzatton of new btologtcal approaches to pest control EPA 1s giving hrgh prtority to rmplementmg the Minor Use Provtslons of FQPA. It has created a new program dedicated solely to coordmating minor use Issues withm the Office of Pesttcrde Programs The defimtton of a minor-use crop has been determined to be a crop produced on fewer than 300,000 acres, or a major crop (a crop grown on more than 300,000 acres) for whtch the pesticide use pattern 1s so limtted that revenues from expected sales ~111 be less than the cost of regtstermg the pesttclde, and there are msuffictent efficactous alternatives for the use, alternatives pose greater risks, the mmor use is stgmficant m managing pest resistance, or the minor use plays a stgmficant part m integrated pest management (IPM) The first part of the definition means that all but 26 of the 600-plus crops produced m the United States are minor crops. EPA will consider every crop m the United States to be a minor crop, except for almonds, apples, barley, canola, carrots, corn (field and sweet), cotton, grapes, hay (alfalfa and other), lettuce, oats, oranges, peanuts, pecans, popcorn, rice, rye, snapbeans, sorghum, soybeans, sugarcane, sugarbeets, tobacco, tomatoes, sunflowers, and wheat. Provtstons intended to help preserve the availabthty of minor use pesticides include expedrting the review of data submitted m support of mmor uses, granting time extenstons for submtttmg data on minor uses, and giving those who invest m data development for minor uses addrtronal exclusive rights to use of the data to support registration. The mmor use program at EPA, m conJunctton wtth a similar program at the USDA wtll coordinate decrstons on minor use issues m consultation with growers. A revolving grant fund is authorized at the USDA to fund the generation of data necessary to support minor use regtstratton. The Department of Health and Human Services 1s authorized to fund studtes in support of registration or reregistration of minor use pesticides that are important for public health purposes The Reduced-Risk Pesticide Inmattve 1s designed to encourage the development, regtstratton, and use of new pesticide chemicals, which would result m reduced risks to human health and the environment, compared to existing alternatives. In 1995, the average amount of time tt took to register a new conventional pesticide was 38 mo; the new reduced rusk pesticides take, on average, 14 mo (17). Since 1993,29 new chemtcal submtssrons have been received by EPA as reduced-risk pesticide candidates. Of the 29, 17 met the reducedrisk crtterta for expedited review Nme of those 17 have been registered
Policy Influences on Biopesticides
63
In November 1994, EPA established a separate division m the Office of Pestrcrde Programs, the Bropesticides and Pollution Prevention Division, to encourage the development of reduced-risk pestictdes, and to manage the regrstration and reregistration of biopesticides Biopesticides are defined by EPA to include naturally occurring and genetically engineered microorganisms, genetically engineered plants that produce then own pesticides (such as crops that produce the msectrcidal proteins from the Bt bacteria), and naturally occurrmg compounds, or compounds essentially identical to naturally occurrmg compounds, that are not toxic to the target pest (such as pheromones) EPA approved 14 new biopesticide active ingredients m fiscal year 1995 and 10 m fiscal year 1996, which represents over one-third of new active mgredients registered rn those years EPA also issued Reregistration Eligibrhty Decision documents for eight bropesticides. FQPA explicrtly recognizesthe importance ofieduced-risk pesticides and supports expedited review to help these pesticides reach the market sooner and replace older and potentially riskier chemicals. The new law defines a reducedrisk pesticide as one which “may reasonably be expected to accomplish one or more of the followmg: reduces pesticide risks to human health; reduces pestrcrde risks to nontarget organisms; reduces the potential for contammation of valued, environmental resources,or broadensadoption of IPM or makesit more effective.” Other statuteswith the potential to affect pesticide use include the Clean An Act, Clean Water Act, Safe Drinking Water Act, Coastal Zone Management Act (CZMA), and the Endangered Species Act. The Water Quality Act of 1987 (sec. 3 19) and the CZMA address nonpomt somces of pollution, such as those from farm fields These are discussed in detail in ref. 18 4. Effects of Policies on Development and Use of Pesticides In the agricultural sector, pohcy influences on pesticides take two forms. Fn-st, pohcy affects the choice of production practice, which will be more or less pesticide-intensive, depending on the policy. Second, government policy directly impacts the development of new pesticides and pest-management practices Each of these issues IS discussed m turn. 4.1. Direct and Indirect Impact of Government Policy on Use of Pesticides Government regulation attempts to mitigate the adverse effects of pesticide use Prmcipally because of concerns over the environmental problems associated with pesticide use m production agriculture, farmers, with some mvolvement on the part of government rn the form of cost sharing and educational and technical assistance, are experimentmg with a myriad of new and traditional tools, materials, and practices Short-term productivity enhancement and
64
Un
chemical use efficiency are the major goals m some of the systems; envn-onmental risk reduction and the long-run sustamabihty of farming are more promment m others To help mmimrze the trade-off between lower pesticide use and reduced net farm income, IPM, precision farmmg, and cultural and biological pest and nutrient management methods are among options encouraged by some. The first two attempt to increase efficiency of chemical use, the latter two attempt to avoid chemical use altogether. Pest scoutmg, economic thresholds, and other tools to help the farmer determine when to make pesticide applicattons, which pesticides to use, and how much to use, have been developed for decades, and expert systems and other decision-support systems to integrate these elements are emerging Prectsion farming and herbicide-resistant bioengineered crops are efficiency technologies that aim at reducing pestictde use that are Just now being developed and commerctahzed. Scoutmg and threshold use is widespread m specialty crop production (19) Half of the US fruit and nut acreage, and nearly three-quarters of the vegetable acres m the surveyed states, were scouted for insects, mostly by professional scouts. Growers reported using thresholds as the basis for making pesticide treatment decisions on virtually all of these scouted acres. Potato growers reported that 85% of their acreage was scouted and thresholds were used m making nearly three-quarters of their msecticide apphcatton decisions. A number of alternative productton practices, including crop rotation, conservation tillage, alterations m planting and harvestmg dates, trap crops, samtation procedures, irrtgatton techniques, fertihzation, physical barriers, border sprays, cold-an treatments, and habitat provision for natural enemies of crop pests, are now bemg relatively more extensively used for managing crop pests. Their diffusion IS expected to grow more widespread. These alternative production practices work by preventmg pest colonization of the crop, reducing pest populations, reducing crop injury, and enhancmg the number of natural enemies m the croppmg system (20). Crop rotation is one of the most important of these techmques that is currently m widespread use. Over half of the corn and soybeans were grown m rotation with each other during the mid- 1990s (22). Farmers rotating corn with other crops used msectictdes less frequently than did those plantmg corn 2 yr m succession (11% vs 46%). Corn IS often grown as a monocrop in areas that have high demand for livestock feed, and where climatic restrictions limit the soybean harvest period (8). Crop rotation is much less prevalent for cotton, however, which has among the highest per acre returns of the field crops grown m the United States, and less than one-third of the cotton producers use this technique.
Policy Influences on Biopesticides
65
4.2. Impact of Government Policy on Development of New Pesticides Research and development expenditures are an important factor affecting the development of new pesticides. There is a fairly extensive literature exploring the relationship between research and development expenditures on a good or service and the use of that good or service (22-24). Basically, research and development expenditures m basic mdustrtes, such as the chemical industry, are conditioned by the present value of expected net revenue. That is, research and development expenditures are made with the expectation that a profit for the firm will result. The net present value is a function of costs, such as research and development expenditures, and regulatory costs of getting a new pesticide registered, as well as the revenue generated from the sale of the pesticide. In this setting, and as apparent from the foregoing discussion, pesticide pohcy is only one, albeit an important one, of the factors affecting pesticide use, and hence the development of btopesttcides. Any government pohcy affecting relative factor prices, price responsiveness, expected returns from chemical use, conservation, and technology development and adoption will impact the development of new pesticides. The two major statutes, FIFRA and FFDCA, instruct regulators to weigh the benefits of pesticide use against unreasonable risks. This balancing process has been characterized so that the use of the term “unreasonable risk” implies that some risks will be tolerated under FIFRA; it is clearly expected that the anttctpated benefits will outweigh the potential risks when a pesticide is used according to commonly recognized, good agricultural practice (25). A study of the impact of pesticide regulation on innovation and the market structure in the United Statespesticide industry shows that pesticide regulatton in the United States has encouraged the introduction of fewer, yet less toxic pesticrdes (#j.* The 1972, 1978, and 1988 amendments to FIFRA require that new and existing pesticides meet strict health and environmental standards. Requirements for pesticide registration wtth the EPA include field testing, which can include up to 70 different types of tests that can take several years to complete and cost mtlhons of dollars. They consist of toxicologtcal studies, a two-generation reproduction and teratogenicity study, a mutagenicity study, oncogemcity studies, and chronic-feeding studies. The toxicological studies include acute (immediate), subchronrc (up to 90 d), and chrome (long-term) effects. Other tests are used to evaluate the effects of pesticides on aquatic systems and wildlife, farmworker health, and environmental fate. Recent *High toxlclty pestlcldes are those that belong to Class I acute toxlclty (indicated m the label), or are chrotucally toxic to humans, or to fish and wildlife. Lower toxlclty pesticides are all others (4)
66
U-i
estimates suggest that research and development of a new chemical pesticide (including the testing indicated above) costs between $50 and 70 million and takes 11 yr (4). As a consequence of the regulation requirements, pesticide firms refocused their research away from persistent and toxic pesticides. The number of pesticides with chronic (long-term) toxicity dropped by 86 between the 1972 and 1976 and 1987 and 1991 periods, and lower toxicity pesticides account now for more than half of pesticide sales. A 10% increase in testing costs is associated with a 2.8% increase in the proportion of less-toxic pesticides registered. In 1996, the Office of Pesticide Programs of the EPA registered 22 new pesticide active ingredients, more than half of which were considered reduced-risk pesticides. These decisions included the approval of 10 biopesticides and 12 new chemicals, which include three reduced-risk chemicals (26). The biopesticides include Bt Cotton (Monsanto), I-octen-3-01 (Armatron), Jojoba oil (IJO Products), Bt (CryMax) (Ecogen), Myrethecium verrucaria (Abbott), meat meal (Lakeshore Enterprises), red pepper (Lakeshore Enterprises), Verticillium lecanii (Abbott), NK Bt corn (Northrup King), Monsanto Bt corn (Monsanto), and Lavandin oil (S.C. Johnson). Pesticide regulation has also had undesirable consequences. Regulation discouraged new chemical registrations: The number of new pesticides registered by the EPA in 1987-l 99 1 was half that of 1972-l 976 and each 10% increase in pesticide regulatory costs caused a 2.7-% reduction in the number of new pesticides introduced (4). The higher regulatory costs contributed to an industry-wide increase in research spending, which encouraged some small firms to leave the pesticide industry. Pesticide regulation also encouraged firms to focus their research on pesticides used in larger crop markets, such as corn and soybeans, abandoning minor-crop markets, such as horticultural crops. The decline in new registrations of chemical pesticides suggests that there are market opportunities for biopesticides and genetically modified plants. These products are not only environmentally preferable, but also less costly to develop and register than chemical pesticides. Thus, it has been estimated that the average cost of developing a biopesticide ranges from $3 to 5 million vs $50 to 80 million for the development of conventional pesticides (27). Such new products, however, as noted previously, are only effective against a narrow range of pests. The 15 largest (in terms of retail sales) agricultural chemical companies are developing biopesticides, including pheromones, bioinsecticides (viruses), botanical extracts, soybean seed, corn and sorghum seed, microbial products, Bt manufacturing, microsponge formulation, and gene insertion. Cropper et al. (28) examined EPA’s Special Review Process for pesticides between 1975 and 1989, to determine whether the decision to cancel or continue the registration of pesticides could be explained by the risk and benefits associated with pesticides. Cropper et al. estimated a trade-off of $35 million
Policy
Influences
on Biopesticides
67
in producer benefits per cancer avoided among pesticide applicators. More recently, Cropper et al. (28) estimate a trade-off of $72 million per cancer avoided among pesticide applicators and $9 million per cancer avoided among consumers (in 1986 dollars). Abler (30) argues that these figures are too high, because Cropper et al. calculated the benefits at existing prices, not considering the effect of pesticide restrictions on producer prices. Abler argues that producers could even gain from pesticide restrictions if output prices increased enough. On the other hand, higher output prices caused by restrictions on pesticide use have not been empirically documented. 5. Conclusions Biopesticides developed and used in the future will emerge against the backdrop of the environmental effects associated with the use of conventional pesticides and government policies designed to control these effects. In the final analysis, farmers’ choices on pesticides will be influenced by the prevailing costs and benefits of conventional pesticides and their alternatives, including biopesticides. The outlook for pesticide use is complicated, though some directions can be perceived. There are a number of factors that will serve potentially to impact pesticide use, which in turn will affect the development of biopesticides. These include pesticide regulation, the FAIR Act, the crops planted, the management of ecologically based systems, and consumer demand for green products. 5.1. Pesticide Regulation Pesticide regulation will continue to exert a major influence on pesticide use and the development of pesticides and pest management alternatives in the United States.The number of pesticide-active ingredients for sale in the United States has decreased by 50% since 1989 because of EPA’s reregistration process (31). Moreover, regulatory changes involving the removal from the market of pesticides, which had been previously registered, because of evidence on unacceptably high health hazards from occupational exposure, may also undermine the confidence that farmers have in the safety of pesticide use (32). Finally, implementation of the FQPA of 1996 will impact pesticide registrations in general and biopesticides in particular. The FQPA is designed to expedite the review of minor-use pesticides and the approval of safer pesticides. Both sections of the legislation should serve to accelerate the development and commercialization of new biological approaches to pest control. Although the legislation does not expressly recognize the presumption of biologicals for the expedited review category, the provision will assist in promoting new research and development activities (17).
68
Uri
5.2. The FAIR Act Short-term effects of the FAIR Act on blopestrcideuse stemfrom greater flexlbllity provided to producers through elimination of baseacreageand set-asides.Elimlnation of base acreage will faclhtate rotations, which could reduce insecticide use. Without the concern of mamtaming base acreageto receive federal deficiency payments,one would expectproducers to plant crops for which returns are higher (e.g., corn rather than wheat), where producershave suchoptions. Hence,blopestlcide use will change based on how and where the mix of crops will change. For example, If producers plant more corn, a more chermcally intensive crop, rather than wheat, which generally requires lesschemicals,one would expectchemical use to increase (13) Elimination of set-asides,other acreagereduction programs, and a potentially smaller Conservation Reserve Program could result m increased planted acreage, with resulting increasedblopesticide use. Set-asides,however, have been relatively low, If not zero, for several program crops recently, sothe increasein planted acreage would not be dramatic. In net, greater biopestlclde use would be expected if more chemically intensive crops areplanted on existing acreageand greater acreageoverall ISplanted, but greater crop rotations would curb such growth (26). In the long-term, input use will hinge on the relative marginal productlvlty and cost among labor, pesticides, fertilizer, and other factors, which the FAIR Act will not alter. As nominal prices decline from 1995-1996 peaks, and real prices are anticipated to continue to decline, there will be less incentive to apply inputs whose value of the marginal product does not increase. Although federal support will fall, market demand 1sexpected to keep commodity prices relatively high by historical standards. Thus market mcentlves will replace federal mcentlves regarding apphcatlon of chemical inputs 5.3. Crops Planted The USDA projects that crop acreage of eight major crops will rise between 5 and 10% by the year 2005 from 1995 levels (33).* Both corn and wheat acreage are expected to rise by about 10 million acres each; that of cotton 1s expected to decline by about 3 mllhon. Hence, although the changing mix of crop acreage complicates a proJection of pesticide use, it seems likely that, from increased planted acreage, blopesticlde use will continue to rise, if other influences are held constant (13). 5.4. Ecologically Based Management Systems The USDA announced several years ago that switching to an ecosystembased approach for managing natural resources 1samong its major agricultural prloritles for the 1990s (34). The new approach, which 1sto be adopted gradu*Cropsarebarley,corn,uplandcotton,oats,rice,sorghum,soybeans,
and wheat
Pohcy Influences on Biopesticides
69
ally, adds the goal of mamtammg or improving the condttton of the land as the context for providing sustamable levels of goods and services. Ecosystem management 1spartly based on the emergmg research on btodiverstty, ecosystems, and environmental accountmg from new scientific disciplines, such as conservation biology, landscape ecology, and ecological economics. The impacts of species loss on crop-breeding programs, and more complete accountmg of the costs of food and fiber productton, are some of the issues that are addressed. Much of the imttal application of this approach has been for national forests and other pubhc resources, but tts potential use for crop productton systems 1s also being explored The National Research Council (NRC) (35) has published the results of a study to examme ecologtcally based pest management practices for agriculture and forestry. The NRC report concludes that pest resistance and other problems created by pesticide use has created a need for an alternative approach to pest management that can complement and partially replace current chemically based pest-management practices. Ecosystem-basedpest management is the approach that was recommended. The USDA’s Forest Service adopted an ecosystem management philosophy in June 1992, and this approach has been influencing the development of forest management plans m the Pacific Northwest and other areas. For example, ecosystem design-arrangmg landscape structures m the watershed to support species biodiversity, as well as timber production and recreation-was used in the recently developed forest management plan for a 30,000-acre watershed in Mt. Hood National Forest (31). A number of stateshave begun to examine ecosystem-based pest management m specific agricultural cropping systems. Maine’s Agricultural and Forest Experiment Statton, for example, has recently reported results from the first 4 yr of its pioneering industry-supported ecosystem proJect on sustainable potato production (36). Various states and regions also have some ecosystem research underway, mcludmg some federally funded IPM proJects, which are lookmg at btologtcal alternatives, as well as public-private efforts at the local level, such as the Chesapeake Bay watershed project, and the BIOS proJect for California almond growers. 5.5. Consumer Demand for Green Products and the Market Response The market for food products with a green label, such as certified organic and IPM, has been growing m the United States.Although organic food products only account for about 1% of total retail food sales at the present time, overall orgamc sales reached $2.8 billion in 1995, and have increased over 20% annually since 1989 (37). Orgamc foods are becoming more widely avatlable to United States consumers through the growing number of large natural
70
Uri
food stores, mainstream supermarkets, and direct outlets, such as farmers markets. A consistent set of national standards for organic productton and processmg, which 1s currently being developed by USDA, IS expected to enhance consumer confidence in the United States. Development of these standards was required by the Orgamc Foods Productton Act, which was passed by Congress as part of the Food, Agriculture, Conservation, and Trade Act of 1990. This legtslatton requn-es that all except the smallest organic growers will have to be certified by a state or private agency accredited under the national standards. The National Organic Standards Board, which was appointed by the USDA to help implement the provisions of the act, currently defines organic agriculture as a sustainable production management system that promotes and enhances biodiversity, biological cycles, and so11 biological activity. It 1s based on mmtmum use of off-farm production inputs and on practices that mamtam organic Integrity through processing and distributton to the consumer (38). In tandem with the growth m demand for food with a green label is the demand for food with less pesttctde residue. Btopesttctdes are viewed as being safer than chemical products (27). Early m then development, biopesticide companies, mcludmg Biosys, Consep, Ecogen, and Mycogen, were forced to concentrate then marketing efforts on niche markets (prtmarily vegetables and fruits) because products did not have the price/performance (efficacy) characteristics necessary to compete m the larger pesticide markets They are now estabhshmg themselves in major markets lrke cotton and corn. They found the less-competitive niche markets were a sheltered corner where they could mature. These small markets gave biopesticides a sales base for products that did not have the attributes desired m larger markets. Biopesttcide companies have since invested heavily m upgrading products, so they can move beyond then- niche market base mto major pesticide markets (39). Biopesttcide companies have made substantial improvements m recent years and have become more competitive with conventional chemical companies Most btopestlctdes have improved prtce/performance charactertsttcs as a result of improved technology, which has resulted m better efficacy and lower costs. For example, recently developed Bt products, mcludmg Bt (CryMax) (Ecogen) and Mattch (Mycogen) have more concentrated toxins, give more consistent performance, have longer residual formulations, and contam relatively more potent Bt strains. These improvements have allowed the companies to lower prices, Finally, companies have reposmoned products m markets where the products add value, and have focused on educating growers on the use of the products. For example, nematodes have been repositioned to address selected citrus
Policy
Influences
71
on Biopesticides
and ornamental markets. These sorts of reposltloning, markets, should continue m the future, as companies products are most effective.
focusing recogmze
on selected where their
References 1 Carlson, G A and Castle, E. N (1972) Economics of pest control, m Pest Control Strategres for the Future, Commlttee on Pest and Pathogen Control, National Academy of Sciences, Washmgton, DC, pp 72-l 03 2 US Congress, Office of Technology Assessment (1995) Bzologzcally Bused Technologzesfor Pest Control, OTA-ENV-636, US Government Prmting Office, Washmgton, DC 3 RIdgeway, R , Inscoe, M , and Thorpe, K (1994) Bzologzcally Bused Pest Controls Markets, Industrzes, and Products, US Department of Agriculture, Agl ~cultural Research Service, Washington, DC 4 Ollmger, M and Fernandez-CorneJo, J (1995) Regulatzon, lnnovatzon, and Market Structure zn the US Pestzczde Industry, Agricultural Economic Report 7 19, US Department of Agriculture, Econom.lc Research Service, June 5 LandIs, D A and Orr, D B (1996) BIologIcal control approaches and apphcatlons, Electronzc IPA Textbook (Radchffe, E. B and Hutchlson, W D., eds ), Unrverslty of Minnesota and the Consortium for International Crop Protection, Mmneapolls, MN 6 Poritz, N (1996) Biological control of weeds, m Bzologzcal Control of Weeds 1996 (Pontz, N , ed ), Montana State Umversity Press, Bozeman, MT, pp l-21 7 Hunter, C (1994) Supplzers of Beneficzal Organzsms zn North America, PM 9403, Cahforma Envlronmental Protectlon Agency, Department of Pestlclde Regulatlon, Sacramento, CA. 8 Edwards, C R and Ford, R. E. (1992) Integrated pest management In the corn/soybean agroecosystem, m Food, Crop Pests, and the Envzronment (Zalom, F G and Fry, W E , eds ), American Phytopathologlcal Society, St Paul, MN 9 Environmental Protection Agency (1995) EPA Issues condltlonal approval for full commercial use of field corn plant pestlclde targeting the European corn borer, EPA Press Release, Washington, DC 10 Zalom, F and Fry, W (1992) Food, Crop Pests, and the Envzronment, American Phytopathologlcal Society, St Paul, MN. 11. Nleblmg, K (1995) Agricultural biotechnology compames set their sights on multi-bllhon $$ markets, Genet Eng News 12, I,2 12 Hoban, T and Kendall, P. (1993) Consumer Attztudes about Food Technology Project Summary, Extension Service, North Carolma State Umverslty, Raleigh, NC 13. Economic Research Service (1997) Agrzcultural Resources and Envzronmental Zndzcators, US Department of Agriculture, Washmgton, DC 14 Aspelm, A L (1984) Pestzczde Industry Sales and Usage I992 and 1993 Market Estzmates, BEAD, Office of Pestlclde Programs, US EnvIronmental Protectlon Agency, Washington, DC, June
Uri
72
14a. (1996) Pesttctde and Toxzc Chemtcal News, August 21, FCN Publrshmg, Washmgton, DC. 15 US Envtronmental Protectton Agency (1996) Major issues tn the Food Qualzty Protectton Act of 1996, Preventron, Pesttctdes, and Toxic Substances, Washmgton, DC, August 16 Jaemcke, E (1997) The Myths and Realtttes of Pesttctde Reductton, Henry A Wallace Instttute for Alternattve Agriculture, Beltsville, MD 17 US Environmental Protection Agency (1997) 1996 Food Quality Protectton Act Implementatton Plan, Preventton, Pesticides, and Toxic Substances, Washmgton, DC 18 (1996) Farm Chemrcals Handbook, Meister, Wtlloughby, OH 19 Vandeman, A , Fernandez-ComeJo, J , Jans, S , and Lm, B H ( 1994) Adoptton of Integrated Pest Management tn US Agrtculture, AIB-707, US Department of Agrtculture, Resources and Technology Divrsion, Economic Research Service 20 Ferro, D N (1996) Cultural controls, m Electrome IPM Textbook (Radcliffe, E B and Hutchison, W D , eds ), Umversity of Mmnesota and Consortium for International Crop Protection, Mmneapohs, MN 21 Lm, B H and Delvo, H (1994) Pest Management Practices on 1993 Corn, Fall Potatoes, and Soybeans, Natural Resources and Environment Drvision, Economic Research Service, US Department of Agriculture, Washmgton 22 Kahn, A (1971) Economtcs ofliegulatton, Wiley, New York 23 US Congress, Office of Technology Assessment (1986) Technology, Publzc Poltcy, and the Changing Structure ofAmerican Agrtculture, OTA-F-285, US Govemment Prmtmg Office, Washmgton, DC, March. 24 Scherer, F M. (1980) Industrial Market Structure and Economtc Performance, Rand McNally, Chtcago 25 National Research Council (1993) Pesttcides tn the Diets ofInfants and Children, National Academy, Washington, DC 26 Office of Pesticide Programs (1996) Office of Pestrctde Programs Annual Report for 1996, Environmental Protectton Agency, Office of Pesticide Programs, Washington, DC, November 27 Anonymous (1996) Future development of biopesticides expedited by FQPA Pestrctde Toxic Chem News 24, 19-20 28 Cropper, M L., Evans, W N , Berardi, S J , Ducla-Soares, M M , and Portney, P R (1992) Determinants of pesticide regulatton a statistrcal analysts of EPA decision makmg, J Poltt Econ 100, 175-197. 29 Cropper, M L., Evans, W. N., Berardi, S. J., and Ducla-Soares, M. M. (1992) Pestictde regulation and the rule-making process, Northeastern J Agrtcultural
Resource Econ 21,77-82 30 Abler, D G (1992) Issues m pesttcide policy Northeastern J Agrrcult Resource Econ 21,93,94 3 1 Pease, W S , Liebman, J , Landy, D , and Albrtght, D (1996) Pesttctde Use tn Caltfornta. Strategies for Reducing Environmental Health Impacts, Calrforma Pohcy Seminar, Umversrty Environmental Health
of Califorrna,
Berkeley, Center for Occupatronal
and
Policy Influences on Biopesticides
73
32. Bender, J. (1994) Future Harvest Pesttctde-Free Farmtng, Umversity of Nebraska Press, Lmcoln 33. World Agricultural Outlook Board (1997) Agrtcultural Baselzne Projectzons to 200.5, Refecttng the 1996 Farm Act, WAOB-97-1, US Department of Agrtculture, Washmgton, DC, February. 34. Comanor, S and Gelburd, J (1994) Ecosystem approach to resource management, Agrzculturai Outlook, AO-204, Economrc Research Service, US Department of Agrtculture, January-February 35 National Research Counctl (1995) Ecologtcally Based Pest Management New Soluttons for a New Century, National Academy, Washington, DC. 36 Umverstty of Mame (1996) The Ecology, Economtcs, and Management of Potato Cropptng Systems’ A Report of the Ftrst Four Years of the Maine Potato Ecosystem Project, Bulletm 843, Mame Agricultural and Forest Expertment Statton, Orono, ME, Aprtl 37 Natural Foods Merchandiser (1996) Widening market carries orgamc sales to $2.8 billion m 1995, Nat Foods Merchandiser 17, 5-7 38 Ricker, H S (1997) Nattonal organic program: status and Issues, m Proceedtngs of the Thzrd National IPMSympostum/Workshop, US Department of Agriculture, Economic Research Service, Washmgton, DC, pp. 63-65. 39. Btosctence Securmes (1996) The Outlook for Bzopesttctdes, Btoscience Securtties, Inc , Ormda, CA 40 US Department of Agriculture (various) Agrzculturaf Chemical Usage Fruzt Crops Summary, Nattonal Agricultural Stattstics Service and the Economtc Research Servwe, Washmgton, DC 41 US Department of Agrtculture (various) Agrzcultural Chemtcal Usage* Vegetable Crops Summary, National Agrtcultural Stattsttcs Servtce and the Economic Research Service, Washmgton, DC
II BIOFUNGICIDES
Commercial
Development
of Biofungicides
Raphael Hofstein and Andrew Chapple 1. Introduction The commercial development of biofungicrdes received a significant boost m recent years, primarrly because of impressive progress in the rsolatron and charactertzatron of novel strains of microorgamsms that can fulfill the mam characteristics of a brofungrctde, which are the consistent suppression of pathogens under field conditions, and easy mass production in standard fermentation facrlrties (1,2). Progress was imtially slow because of the mherent properties of the natural isolates, most of which are obligatory parasites that require the presence of a host for propagation (3). With the meteoric development m recent years of new tools m industrial molecular biology, and, more specifically, m the area of fermentation technology, srgmficant progress has been made m the commercral development of cost-effectrve brofungrcrdes. The conceptual and methodological consideratrons leading to a commercially vtable product for biological control of fungal diseasesIS the theme of the followmg discussion. The arena of btofungicide development has been classified mto three categories: sorlborne pathogens; foliar diseases;and postharvest rots durmg storage All three have been extensively documented over the past decade (4.Q. However, only a few brofungrcrdes have been successfully promoted through regrstratron, and even fewer have managed to cross the barrier between basic and commercral development. Those that have managed to overcome the hurdles of actually becoming a commercral bropesticrde have included in then development, right from the inception of an research and development program, a crmcal analysts of market needs and potential, as well as financtal conslderatrons, such as cost of goods (9). From Edited
Methods UJ B~ofechnology, vol 5 Bmpestmdes by F R Hall and J J Menn 0 Humana Press
77
Use and Delwery Inc , Totowa, NJ
78
Hofstein and Chapple
Historically, the list of commercially viable blopestlcldes Included almost exclusively Baczllus thurzngzenszs (Bt)-based products for the control of lepldopteran pests (20). The hst of Bt products became very lmpresslve m recent years, primarily because of DNA recombinant technology, and products entermg the market have proven to be very effective against a whole array of economically important pests (21). However, unlike Bt products that rely on an inert protemaceous crystal toxin as the active ingredient, most of the blofungicides under dlscussion require an Intact, hvmg cell for function (12). Moreover, since Bt-based products are relatively inert, they can be readily incorporated mto a user-friendly formulation. Intact-cell-dependent blofunglcldes, on the other hand, require very delicate and rather sophisticated approaches m the design of a commercial formulation, one that will ensure product stablhty durmg storage (I.e., shelf life), as well as rellablhty during apphcatlon (23). As discussed by Baker (2415) and Baker and Scher (26), It IS well recognized that a substantial amount of biological control occurs m nature, and that increased or even spectacular suppresslon of plant disease can occur naturally m some agricultural situations These events, though well documented and potentially useful for the isolation of blologlcal control agents, did not result m the development of many commercially viable products. Likewise, the delicate equlllbrlum between saprophytlc and parasitic mlcroflora on the phylloplane has been dlscussed by Dubos (17), who brilliantly made reference to blocenosls as the backbone of such an equlllbrmm Again, because of the natural balance between antagonists and pests, disease may be suppressed. However, m order to Implement these features mto economically feasible control of fohar diseases, a better understanding of the dynamics of antagonist-pathogen interactions 1s required. Moreover, the antagonist has to fulfill certain criteria before it can be considered a legitimate candidate for promotlon to a commercial blofunglclde Several reviews have addressed aspects of maxlmlzmg the chances of developing a naturally occurring organism (18-20). The criteria for a successful blofunglclde can be summarized as follows. Effective suppression of the fungal pathogen before It causes economically important damage to a crop Consistent performance under authentic condltlons of crop management and the crop environment Adaptation to exlstmg integrated pest management (IPM) schemes of disease control Price competitiveness with other means of combatmg the same target pest Compatlblhty with other chemical or blologlcal treatments targeting other pest(s) Adaptation to commonly used farm agronomic methodologies Preservation of naturally occurrmg beneticlal antagonist(s) of related or nonrelated pests User and environment frlendlmess
Commercial
Development
of Biofungicides
79
The hkehhood for successful development of a commerctally vtable btofungtctde 1smaxtmtzed once all these crtterta are fulfilled. To obtain a reliable program that uses such products as prominent building blocks of a comprehensive IPM approach, it 1scrucial, right from the onset of the research program, to evaluate the adaptation of a naturally occurring orgamsm mto an economttally feasible strategy of pest control. The prmctpal drawback to developing btofungtctdes is that it is very difficult to harness the organisms to mdustrral processesof mass productron, especially fermentation m sterrle vessels, as well as incorporatton mto user-friendly formulations (21). Clear understanding of the delicate balance between antagonistic mtcroorgamsms and crop pests could eventually lead to manipulation of ecosystems to enhance crop protectron (22-24). Regarding sotlborne and foltar pathogens, the impact of naturally occurring saprophytes on disease suppression is well documented. However, tt 1s now established that it IS insufficient to rely on mnocuous mrcroflora to ensure the high degree of plant protection required m modern agriculture. The balance has to be shifted m a direction antagonistic to the fungal pathogen, or else to impose quantttattve advantages to the antagonist. The latter is the tmpetus for seeking an alternative approach by vn-tue of the development of commercial biofungtcides, and this can be most eastly attained by directed mtroductton of a selected antagonist into a given btocenosts, as prevtously proposed m excellent review articles (see refs. 25 and 26). 2. Steps in the Development Process The development of a cost-effective btofungtctde is an intricate undertakmg. The various steps involved in the process are m a quote rrgid order, which IScritical tf failure IS to be avoided. The authors describe a sequence of steps m the development strategy based on experience reflecting successes,but also failures, m several campaigns. These steps are depicted m a rather rtgorous and critrcal fashion. 2.1. Screening for Naturally Occurring Microorganisms The best source for potentially effective biofungrctdes is the site of natural interactton between a pathogen and tts antagonist. For instance, hypovirulent strains of a plant parasite were sought in sites of declining disease, or, in the case of soilborne pathogens, screening for mtcrobtal antagomst m suppressive soAs (27). In the case of hyperparasttic antagonists such as Ampelomyces quzsqualu, the hyperparastte of various powdery mildews (PMDs), the pathogen could serve as a carrier, and, therefore, colonies of the pathogen can actually become an ideal site for screenmg (28-30). Several criteria should be used as guidance from onset of the screening process, including extent of antagonism m a bioassay that best resembles the commercial envnonment (31,32), adapt-
80
Hofstern and Chapple
abtltty of the antagomsttc mtcroorgamsm to artttictal mass-productton factlttres (33), and versattltty of antagomsm to vartous spectes of the pathogen on dtfferent crops (34). 2.2. Selection of the Most Cost-Effective Fermentation Process Several methodologies have been adopted for mass productton of pesttcidal mtcroorgamsms, but the only economtcal approach currently avatlable IS one that relies on submerged fermentatton m a sealed fermentation tank. All others, including fermentation m a solid matrix, require an unacceptably long process m especially dedicated equipment. The latter has a detrimental effect on cost of goods, and therefore becomes prtce-prohtbttlve. Submerged fermentatton has proven to be the preferred technology, and one that allows for hrgh ytelds m a relattvely short period of time To attain a cost-effective process, tt IS rmperatrve to select a growth medium that rehes on mdustrtal waste products wellbalanced to supply an optimal ratio between nitrogen and carbon (35) Every development program must address such elements as low-cost nutrients and opttmizatton of the time-course. The prmcrpal author has reviewed these elements (36) describing the development of AQ 10, a btofungtctde developed for the control of PMD, based on A quuquah. 2.3. Development of Bioassays A system that can adequately simulate an authentic snuatlon m a commercoal setting 1sa crtttcal element in a proper research and development program (37). The chances of selectmg the mtcrobtal tsolate of choice to be promoted from a ubtqurtous microbial strain mto a cost-effecttve btopestictde can be maxrmtzed by a versatile assay system The btoassay has to reflect the mode of actton of the product. Although most research efforts resulted in the eluctdation of anttbrottc-producing bacteria for pathogen control that can be simulated m a Petri dish, progress made m recent years m industry, gave rise to more complex fungal agents, whose mode of action ISbased on parastttsm or competttion for space and nutrients. A preferable assay system for such agents IS the intact-plant simulator, tested m a growth chamber or greenhouse. 2.4. Development of a User-Friendly Formulation Product formulatton IS a most crtttcal aspect of the entire development program. A user-friendly formulatron has to fulfill several crrterra, mcludmg allowmg a mtcroorganism to retain and express tts pesttctdal properties; providing a stgmficant extension of shelf life of at least 6, but preferably 18 mo, at ambient conditions, so that the biofungtctde can be stored over two seasons; and allowing the active ingredient to be applied wtth extstmg appltcatton equtpment. During the course of developmg AQ 10 for commercial acceptabtltty,
Commercial Development
of Biofungicides
81
several major changes m the features of the formulation were requtred m order to fulfill the above criteria. After screening several options, a water-dispersible granular formulation proved to be most adequate for the product. It is chtefly because of this formulatton that AQ 10 reached commerctaltzatton relatively quickly Better understandmg of market needs durmg the prehmmary stage of product development may asstst in the process of tatlormg the right formulatron to each product 2.5. Establishment
of an Extensive
Field-Testing
Program
It IS cructal, and yet insufficient, to design a powerful screening broassay When adopted for the development and fine-tuning of a chemical pestictde, such bioassays often adequately predict how a new product will manifest Itself m the field; however, this ISdefimtely msuffctent m the caseof biofungtctdes. Modes of action, such as micoparasitism (e.g., Ampelomyces [38], T~rcI?odevma harzlanni 1391, and Giocladwm roseum [40l) or competttton for space and nutrients, such as in the case of, e.g., ASPIRE (Ecogen, Langhorne, PA) (41) and BIOSAVE (Ecosctence, New Brunswick, NJ) (42), for postharvest decay control, can only be determined partially in a simulator or bioassay. To demonstrate its full potential, a product must be tested m the field, and preferably in large plots, rather than the small replicated blocks commonly used for statistical analysts. Field trials are also the best stage to determme how a biofungicide can be incorporated mto an IPM program (43-46). 2.6. Preparation of a Registration Package Since biofungicides are considered envtronmentally friendly, most registration authorrttes view them as safe, and hence justify a relatively fast track of revtew (47). It 1s the authors’ experience that each case IS different, and, according to the purpose of the program and the target pathogen, the registration authorities will select the evaluation process to meet the nature of the appltcatton. For instance, biofungicides for postharvest decay control m packmghouses were relieved of the need to conduct ecological testing, since the orgamsms are expected to be applied only in a confined environment (48). Btopesticides can be exempted from tolerance requirements, and usually are relieved from any significant periods of field re-entry intervals (REI). Such elements are clear advantages of a biopesttctde, and will be obtained only when properly represented during the registration process. 2.7. Establishment of Demonstration Programs Small-plot, randomly replicated trials are part of the prerequtstte for product registration, but demonstration trials in which the product manifests itself under the authentic conditions of a commercial setting are crucial for biopesticides m
82
Hofstein and Chapple
general, and biofungicides m particular Once registered, a btofungicide can, at a relattvely early stage of its development, be subjected to such demonstration programs without having to absorb the burden of crop destruction. The benefits of such trials are threefold: first and foremost, they help the end user get acquainted with the prmciple of disease control through competition and/or parasrtism; they are also essentral for an adequate analysis of the formulation and its adaptability for a commercial setting; last, they are the only setting that allows for proper design of IPM schemes (49,50). 2.8. Design of User-Friendly Protocols Since biofungicides are a relatively new component m the arsenalof tools avallable to the farmer as part of the agronomic routine, the protocols must be very detailed, and certain issues,such as rates, application intervals, and methods of application, must be addressed cautiously. It is, conceptually, as well as techrntally, erroneous to assumethat the extrapolation from a standard protocol representmg a chemical fungicide to that of a btofungicide ISlmear. It definitely is not. A good example is the matrix of permtssible tank mrxesof AQ 10 and chemical nutrients, msecticides, and fungicides (51). Incorporatton of AQIO into an IPM program calls not only for legitimate alternation between a chemical and biological agents: In general, the two have to be mcluded m the sametank mix, otherwise, the whole program can be questioned from an economic standpoint. AQlO became commerctally recogmzed and acceptable only when a breakthrough had been made m the area of compatibility with other treatments. Compatibthty, together with fine-tuned ratesofapphcation, and optimization of Intervals, are key elements in the protocol as it 1spresentedto the end user. It must be stressedthat the primary concern of the end user is the cost-effectiveness of the product. 3. Product Development: AQ10 as a Test Case The development of A guzsqualzs mto a commercial product (AQl 0) for the control of PMD on a variety of crops is an mstructive example of the authors’ views of the learning curve related to the commercial development of biofungicides m general. It is a truism that the most difficult step for any biological control agent is that from glasshouse to the field, something very few biocontrol agents have managed. Because AQ 10 has successfully crossed this hurdle, a large part of this chapter is devoted to a description of the development trials, and, more importantly, the thmkmg behind the trials and the analysis that followed It is certainly not enough to conduct trials merely to see if it works, and at what rates, and so on. Especially for brologicals that will be combined into IPM programs, bringing the real world mto the trials and designmg assessmentand scoutmg schemes that are realistic for the end user are critical components of trial design.
Commercial Development
of Biofungicides
83
3.1. From the Glasshouse to the Field A. quisqualis has a field- and glasshouse-testing history quite at odds with the conventional academic approach. Although it started its developmental career in the laboratory and the glasshouse (52,53), the speed at which it progressed to the field was very different from that of the usual process for microbial agents. Most other agents have undergone academic laboratory and glasshouse study, and, while learned publications are prepared, passthrough a great number of generations prior to being subjected to the intended environment: the field. The latter route, namely the development of the agent with the glasshouse setting in mind, can be detrimental, because commercial application is much broader than just tailoring a product for the glasshouse industry. Such an approach may slow down commercial development, and the strain may go through even more generations before a desire to increase the range of use of the organism (or the realization that the glasshousemarket cannot sustain an on-going research program, let alone a company) causes the researchers to expand their horizons. By now the strain is very much at home in the test tube and flask, and the sort of selection pressures put on the active ingredient, the spores, in the fermenters can cause problems. The organism is first selected for an environment completely at odds with the real world-the small-scale fermenter or lab production system-and then is expected to perform in an environment where a pathogen has many advantages. In the case of PMD, these advantages include continued selection pressure by the grower for not only resistance or tolerance to any conventional pesticides, but also speed of infection and subsequent spread throughout the crop, especially in situations like the glasshouse and vineyards, where regular prophylactic sprays are the norm. AQlO bypassed some of this by being tested in the field very early. As a result, development decisions were field-driven, not laboratory- or glasshouse-driven. Not only do growers’ habits and cultures have an impact, but so does mass production in a fermentation vessel. The fermenter is analogous to a two-edged sword. Selecting for fast-growing, high-yielding strains that are tolerant to fermenter conditions may be an advantage. In the case of insecticidal nematodes or bacilli, fermenter-targeted strains may be narrowing the range of expression of the organism toward the faster-acting end of the spectrum. Taking the natural population ofA. quisqualis, there is probably going to be a normal distribution of behavior regarding the likelihood of the spore to germinate, or other characteristics. Clearly, a product for the control of PMD is best composed of spores that germinate at the least provocation, and it is presumed that the fermenter selection pressure drives the organism toward rapid response to signals for growth or germination. To put it crudely, those cells in the original inoculum that grow fastest will have a significant advantage over any slowerresponding cells, so that the progeny (i.e., the AQlO formulation itself) is
84
Hofstein and Chapple
largely made up of fast-responding members of the natural population. This may or may not act in favor of the preferred selection of the population that ought to be manifested in the authentic environment of the open field. Such considerations must be included in the design for optimal screening of the best naturally occurring strain to be selected for commercial development. The AQlO strain of A. quisqualis, which eventually became the strain of choice, was isolated from a semiarid part of Israel (54), and then transferred to other parts of the world for further field development. The advantage is that upon transfer to other locations, such as vine-growing areas of Italy, France, California, and South Africa, the spores had to adjust to less extreme, more humid environments than those of the original locale. Hence, the AQ 10 strain of A. quisqualis is probably performing reasonably well, having been taken from an environment where rapidly exploiting such conditions would be important. The PMD present in the vineyard has been under a very different set of environmental pressure in different parts of the world. Therefore, and almost as a guideline, if a replacement to the current strain of AQ 10 should be required, or if a biological control agent for downy mildew or gray mold in vines is needed (55), then the organism or strain chosen should be sought in semiarid climatic zones,where the optimal conditions for the control organism are close to those required for normal conditions of the targeted disease. Similar thinking was applied to the development of a yeast strain (Aspire) for the control of postharvest decay pathogens. The two may only be differentiated by the fact that the latter is destined for the confined environments of a packinghouse (56). It is important to note that biofungicides, such as AQ 10 and ASPIRE, which affect the pathogen via hyperparasitism and competition, respectively, are at a disadvantage whenever the environment favors the fungal pathogen, simply because the pathogen develops at an explosive, almost epidemic, rate (57). To avoid such scenarios in vines, and in order to establish a more persistent level of disease control, AQlO was applied frequently (Le., every 1O-14 d), and as part of a more comprehensive IPM approach in which sulfur, sterol-inhibitor fungicides, and AQlO offer a variety of tools for PMD control. Multiple applications apparently work by establishing a critical mass of spores in the treated area. These spores are not expected to survive long in the environment, and must interact with existing colonies of PMD quite rapidly, It has been observed in several different locations that, on the surface of leaves, AQ 10 can remain dormant in the absence of the pathogen for up to 14 d, but only when humidity is constantly high (i.e., >90%). In the normal conditions of the greenhouse or, even more so, the open field, the spores will have to germinate and interact with the host within several hours. This is the rationale behind the strong recommendation to apply the product at cooler or more humid periods of the day.
Commercial
Development
of EGofungicides
85
Early m the development of AQlO as a field control agent for PMD control in grape vmes, it was assumed that it could be used as a stand-alone treatment, with the idea of replacing chemical fungicides almost entirely Although AQ 10 gave consistently improved control of PMD when compared with untreated vines, disease control was too often unacceptable from a commercial viewpoint, especially toward the end of the growmg season.It was therefore decided that the chief strategy of use for AQ 10 would be as a replacement for conventional chemical control during certain morphological stages of vme and grape development (e.g., bloom to bunch closure, or from closure to verarson). For example, for a season of seven or eight 14- or 10-d interval sprays, the first two would be sulfur (m keeping with general PMD control practice), the next three AQlO, and the last 2-3 sprays would be an ergosterol biosynthesis inhrbitor (EBI), or similarly powerful chemical. However, field results were still extremely variable using this approach. Although, in general, AQ 10 performed less effectively m high disease pressure situations and with highly PMD-susceptible vine varieties, there were fatlures of control m situations that appeared optimal for AQlO, and other, excellent and reproducible results against high disease pressure m non-PMD-tolerant varieties. To resolve these mconsistenties and come up with user-friendly guidelmes, the results from several trials were closely analyzed. Two methods of disease assessmentwere used m the field trials. disease mctdence and disease severity. Disease Incidence reflects the percentage of leaves or grape bunches showing any PMD symptoms. Disease severity, on the other hand, scores the average diseased surface area of leaf or berry covered with PMD symptoms One of the prmcipal problems with the analysis of a season’s field data from multiple sites is the variability m assessors’estimates of disease severity. It is far easier to standardize disease incidence between cooperators or field-trial operators. However, Ecogen was fortunate, because, for two consecutive years, five of SIX trials m one of the programs were all assessedby the same highly sktlled and experienced cooperator, who on several occasions had shown a very high level of consistency of disease estimation, when results were reassessedby outside observers. It was therefore possible to assessthe relationship between disease mcidence and the underlying disease severity, and also the relationship between disease mcidence at one assessment date and dtsease severity at the next. The former is important as a measure of the accuracy of disease incidence for estimating severity; the latter as a measure of the reliability of predicting later disease severity based on current estimates of disease incidence. The data was collected from four different sites, whtch represent highly qualified grapevine growing areas in Italy. (It should be noted that a similar analysis has been made for other parts of the world, with virtually semi-
86
Hofstein and Chapple
lar results.) In each sate, AQlO was tested as part of an IPM scheme with two sulfur sprays at bud-break, followed by 2-3 AQlO sprays and followed by 23 sprays of an EBI. One other component m the blend of treatments was a selection of surfactants chosen to enhance the germmatton of AQ 1O’s spores. For SIX mdtvidual trials at the four sites, It IS clear from Fig. 1A that, wtthm sites, there IS a good correlatton between the underlymg disease severity and the disease incidence assessed. However, there was no such correlatton when considering the individual treatments (Fig. 1B). Therefore, the data was reanalyzed, taking the individual blocks from the sues, and treating these as expertmental units This approach makes sense when considering the variability wtthm sites* Although overall mean effects might differ from sate to site, the variability within any given site was always high, and blocks from one site gave levels of disease severrty that might be expected at another Analyzmg the data this way, Fig. 2A shows a clear linear relattonshtp between assessment of disease incidence and the underlying disease seventy. Similar lmeartty IS attained for the same data when broken up with respect to treatment regime, as opposed to site (Fig. 2B). However, It was the predictive power of disease incidence that was of particular significance for the future of the product development. As It appears m Fig. 3, from the relationship between the dtsease inctdence at the first assessment date and the disease severity at the second assessment date, there was a clear and reliable relationship between the two measurements. It was, therefore, decided that incidence could be used by a grower as a disease-threshold mdtcator for spraying The data has also been depicted to reflect the prolonged impact of AQl 0 on disease progresston. Figure 3 represents the correlation of severtty m second assessment as a function of percent mcrdence m the first assessment. The question reman-red. What threshold should be used? An alternative way of consrdermg the data presented IS as percent effective control (i.e., the reduction m PMD severity when compared with the untreated control plot included m the trial). Figure 4 represents the analysts of the data when the latter approach has been adopted. It reveals two important pomts. First, the regresston line of percent effective control at the second assessment date vs disease incidence, measured at first assessment date, IS far shallower for the standard chemical regtmen than for any IPM regimen including AQ 10 as a treatment. The difference m slope 1s a measure of the relative fragility of the btologrcal control agent, which should be interpreted as an mdlcatton that, at least m the case of btologrcal fungicides, there IS lrttle room for error m timing of appltcation. Once the PMD reaches a certain level of mfestatlon, the AQIO regime loses acceptable control. Second, rt 1sclear from these data (Fig. 3) that the threshold for effective control by AQ 10 IS under 30% disease mcldence. growers typically accept about 10% severity as a legitimate level of
0
10
20
40 50
% Disease Severity
30 60
70 80
. _.
I II III IV V VI
I
60 -
0
I
B
8
10
20
0
30
0
40
v 0 0 0
n
A
Regime:
50
60
70
IPM Regime I IPM Regime II IPM Regime III IPM Regime IV Standard chemical Untreated Check
Application
% Disease Severity
0.
80
Fig 1 Correlation of % diseasemcldence at the first assessmentdate with diseaseseventy at the sameassessment date Data pomts are mean values for trial sites(A) or treatment regimens (B)
,
Trral Locatron: - l Trial site ---------- Trial site -- -- -- -- m TrIalsite -- -- -- -- * Trialsite --- --- -- 0 Trial sde -0 Trial site
too
. .
20
40
60
60
* Trial site IV 0 Trial site V 100
1
0
0
0
I 20
a
.o
.
.
40
.
.
60
* . v o o o
60
100
IPM Regime I IPM Regime II IPM Regime Ill IPM Regime IV Standard chemical Untreated Check
Fig 2. Correlation of disease mcldence (x-axis, first assessment date) with disease severity (y-axis, loglO, same assessment date), usmg mdlvldual blocks from trial sites (A) or treatment regimens (B) as the data pomts
0
.
0 0 0 000
:
Commercial Development
of Biofungicides
89
Trial Location: Trial site I . Trial site II 0 Trial site Ill * Trial site IV . 0, I 0 Trial site V . .;;.,“p 0 0 Trial site VI -- -- -- -_ -- ‘m; &a’;-~,,‘o Qo . jJ *,-‘I Ao . + ’ xv ‘I I* 41 .* b, f 0 P,, o,.9x”o Q ’ l
- I ,f; , . I 0
.
,’ .* .
, 4’ . ‘a
II1 I1
i
: I I I ,
. . l--I--.-.-20
40
0
x
u
y=O.226+0.0148xX r2. 0.855; PcO.0001
60
,-..L-.L 80
_ 100
% Disease Incidence, 1st Assessment Fig. 3 Correlation of % disease mcldence at the first assessment date with the dlsease severity at the second assessment date (logI scale), using mdlvldual blocks from trial sites as data pomts (I e , data points are registered with respect to trial site) Correlation coefficient (r?) = 0 855
damage to the crop at the end of the wine-grape season. Since these observations were made, and as a critIca measure during commerclahzatlon of AQ 10 for a variety of crops with much lower damage tolerance, the product has been presented as a preventative treatment that is a very effective tool for PMD control, as long as it ISapplied when visible incidence is nearly zero (mstructions to growers are to use the product when diseaseincidence doesnot exceed 3%). % Disease seventy assessment 1(treatmentn) % Disease seventy assessment2 (treatmentn) % Disease seventy assessment 1 (untreatedcheck) - % Disease seventy assessment2 (untreatedcheck) (1)
Figure 4 depicts the percent disease suppression, but with no reference to the existing level of disease;Figure 5 shows the percent relative control, 1.e, the percent suppression of disease over the period of the two assessmentsas a function of the background disease levels at the time of the assessment(Eq. 1). For example, if a treatment had 12% disease severity at the first assessment, with a background of 20% m the untreated check in that block, and 16% severity at the second assessment,with a background disease severity of 45%, then
90
Hofs tein and Chapple 100
~+m.&O ---_8 -. t3 0 O--------Oa-----_ ‘. ---------~~~ ‘. ----.-____ .JI/l. v . --__ 0 *‘ j .A,Qy)bf am0 . . .i . . ” . ‘. ‘.. . . =ll . . .. . . -\ A * -. . t. Ii- . . . . A .. ’ ‘. I G . -\ ‘. - - - AQ regression line “9 _ Chemical regression line ’ “=y-; . * . A IPM Regime I , .. n IPM Regime II . T IPM Regime III . . _ * IPMRegime IV . o Standard chemical I
I
0
I
20 % Disease
40 incidence,
I
I
I
60
80
100
1st assessment
Fig 4 Correlation of disease mcldence at first assessment date with % effective control at the second assessment date (see text), usmg mdlvldual blocks from trial regimes as data points (1.e , data points are registered with respect to treatment) the PMD will have been suppressed by 24 5% (a posltlve value; Fig. 5) However, if the PMD 1sescaping control, percent relative control will be negative.
It appears from Fig. 5 that the higher the disease mcldence at the first assessment date, the more likely it IS that the PMD will not be controlled There are several caveats. The first disease assessmentswere all performed after at least one of the AQ 10 sprays had been completed, and the second assessmentsafter at least one or two more AQlO sprays Intervals between assessment dates ranged from 7 d when disease pressure was very high, to 21 d, when disease pressure was much lower. Hence, the mltlal disease pressure at the first assessment date was generally higher in the AQ 10 treatments than m the chemical ones, and subsequent control of disease would have been more difficult to accomplish m the AQ 1O-treated plots than m the chemically treated ones. In the cases presented, the disease was allowed to run Its course. Useful mformatlon was obtamed about control effects at high disease threshold, but these would not normally be obtained m a grower’s vineyard, because AQIO would have been replaced by a more robust method earlier m the season as an act of eradication. The question still remains: What exactly 1sthe threshold to recommend to growers?
Commercial
Development
of Blofungicides
r
-60 % Disease incidence, 1st assessment
Fig 5 Relatronshlp between % disease incidence at the first assessment date and % relative control at the second assessment date (see text), comparing the chemical standard regimen (filled triangles and all the AQIO treatments combmed (hollow circles) PMD infectlon 1s microscopic. The observable symptoms (small powdery colomes on leaves or berries) are evidence that the infection has been present for some time. Requtring a grower to use a microscope is clearly unreasonable, so the threshold for changmg from AQlO to conventional chemicals, based on observable symptoms reflected m scoring for percent incidence, has been set lower than the data presented actually mdlcates. In practice, and from other research, the manufacturer has been recommending a much lower threshold, approx 3% Incidence. This has two advantages: First, scouting need not be at too short an interval, requiring excessive time and labor, second, the grower has confidence m the control of the disease, even late in the season. The above threshold became a firm guideline. Figure 6 shows the result from trials in an area heavily infested with PMD. Yet, because of careful disease management, and with a much better understanding of the attributes and hmitatlons of AQ 10, it became the first blofunglclde to be officially included in IPM programs. It may, after all, appear a trivial discovery, but, because of Its mode of action, bringing hyperparasltlsm onto existing colonies of PMD, it took many field trials and much sophisticated data analysis to be able to reach such conclusions, and to draw practical guidelines from them.
Hofstein and Chapple
92 Data on bars is % disease incidence associated with the
Fig 6 Trial results for Bourgogne (France) site, showing % disease severity for chemical, AQ 10, and untreated regimens, for three assessment dates Numbers on bars are % disease severity
3.2. Timing and Quality of Spray Applications Spray application techniques have been known to play an important role m the performance of many pesticides (58). It appears that it is an even more important consideration in the commercial development of biopestictdes, and products of AQlO’s nature, in particular. One prerequisite IS that the apphcanon equipment used m trials must match that of the end user. Aspects of thts problem have been demonstrated m preliminary work (59), which shows that the distribution of particles of A quuqual~s m a spray tank differs markedly before and after passage through a pump (Fig. 7). Because efficiency of application of AQlO is dependent on distributing single spores evenly through a canopy, clumpmg of spores can decrease the efficiency of apphcatton stgmficantly. It was also shown that the dtstrtbutton of particles of a mineral surfactant (60), considered an enhancer of spore germinatton, also differs dramatically preand postpump. The particle distribution for the surfactant is depicted in Fig. 7. Surfactant systems for emulstfymg oils that are nonfungnoxtc are difficult to find, and, although the mineral oil used in most AQlO studies has some
01
0.15
0
Adjuvant oil 0.08
0.1
Log,, particle size pm
A. quisqualis
Ftg 7 The effect of pump sheer stress and atomtzatton on the frequency dtstrtbutton of A qusqualzs sporesand adJuvant or1(ADDQ) m the spray volume, pre- and postpump B, stirred m a beaker; T, stirred m 50 L of water m a spray tank; R, after 5 min recycling through a diaphragm pump; and S, after recycling and then spraying through a hydraultc flat fan nozzle (Reproduced wtth permtsston from ref. 59)
c
0
g. 0.05
.-g r
va
.-R N"
3 v
8
z-
94
Hofstern and Chapple 12 days after inoculation a
m
Treated at 1st symptoms and at 1st symptoms.
Fig 8. Compartson of two strategres for trmmg start of A quuqualls apphcatron applymg only at first stgns of disease, or applying 1 d after moculatton again at first signs of dtsease (Glasshouse trral In zucchnn, agamst Sphaerotheca fuhgznea ) Bars with the same letter do not doffer at the P < 0 05 level (Tukey’s HSD test) surfactant properties, these were found to be msufficrent to form a reasonable emulsion. When drops are created by the atomtzatron system, the probabrhty that a spore IS delivered with an or1 droplet must be high (near 1.O) for the enhancement properttes of the 011to take effect. It 1snoticeable that the small-scale trtals n-tthe glasshouse were done with an-pressurized systems that lack pumping or recycling. These hmttanon might have hampered the performance of AQ 10 Indeed, later on, all tnals were conducted with growers’ equipment, and, as tn the vane trials, efficacy has Improved on several crops, mcludmg roses and zucchnn, growmg m a glasshouse The trmmg of AQlO apphcattons has been addressed m more detarled test trials on cucumbers m glasshouses. One set of trials (Fig. 8) demonstrated that prophylactic treatment of cucumber resulted m effective suppression of PMD Essentially, AQlO apphcatton as early as arttficial mfection, followed by another appltcatton at first disease symptoms, gave very good results, whereas delaying application until disease symptoms were observed fatled to do so The results given m Fig. 8 mdtcate that spores of AQlO ought to be available at onset of PMD
Commercial
Development
of Biofungrcides
95
The tmphcation of these trtals for a standard recommendation to the glasshouse industry appears to be that A. quzsqualzs is effective for a short time after application, and that obtaining control very early m the disease progresston is crmcal. Hence, the grower must have a good idea of the ltkehhood of the dtsease occurrmg m the glasshouse, m order to trme the first apphcations. Again, coverage and even distribution of AQlO are crtttcal apphcatton parameters. Several risk-assessment models have been developed for the forecast of disease development. One of the most powerful examples has been described by Gubler et al. for PMD (62). This model has been translated into practical terms, and telemetry statlons have been mstalled rn several locations, to provtde warnmg of the onset of disease progression (i.e., ascospore release) These phenomena have been coupled to the prophylacttc concept of AQ 10, and tt was proved again, whenever the product was applied at relatively low levels of incidence, that tt provided commerctally acceptable disease control. Timing of appltcation and quality of applicatton are two major concerns in any program m proficient design of plant protectton, m general, and to btological pathogen control, m particular. However, in addition to inclusion withm IPM programs, assessmentof combmatton treatments of btofungictdes with environmental chemistry has also become a prtority, e.g., tank mtxes plus rates, advantages of addtttves H3, tdentificatton of alternate regtmes An exhausttve list of combinations has been screened, and the results offered to end users of AQlO (51). It became apparent that the latter mformatton contributed such value to the program that this has become a key component m every research and development program at Ecogen. 4. Current Status and Future Prospects Past reviews concernmg commercral development of btofungtcldes have highlighted the importance of cost-effective production of the active mgredient (62,63). Stgmficant progress has been made m recent years, and tt IS worth emphastzmgthe breakthroughs m massproductton of mtcrobial active mgredients through submerged fermentation, a method yteldmg large amounts of product m a cost-effective process. It has been demonstrated by the senior author, as well as other research groups, that a product-tailored formulation IS a key element m the whole program. However, what we have tried to accomplish m this chapter, which discussesthe experrence of developmg A. quuquah mto a commercial product, is to draw some basic conclusions that might be useful for others with a similar objective. It appears from this case study that the only way to learn about the attributes of a tentative btofungtctde is to throw tt mto an authentic commerctal sttuation as early in the program as possible. Such an approach, even though possessmgnumerous logtsttcal hurdles, apparently offers some significant shortcuts. This concept could be viewed as a useful gmdelme
96
Hofstein and Chapple
m any development program, but appears to be more profound m the development of blofunglcldes, since most of the small-scale slmulatlon assays commonly used m the development of chemicals fail to represent the commercial arena during the development of blologlcals. ASPIRE, a naturally occurring yeast for the postharvest control of decay, 1s a useful example of how the experience gathered during the development of AQ 10 helped accelerate the process of lmprovmg another blofunglclde The yeast suppresses decay formatlon via competition with germinating spores of prominent pathogens (e g., Penzczllzum spp) for space and nutrients. Although a standard tray assay, whereby artificially wounded and inoculated fruit ought to represent a situation in the packmghouse, has always been useful m the commerclal development of chemical funglcldes, the same has not been the case for blofungicldes In order for ASPIRE to express its full funglcldal potential, we had to rely on natural wounding and natural infestation (19). Again, when we consider the best approach to the development of blofunglcldes, taking the program to the end user 1sthe preferred approach. ASPIRE received a boost m the rate of development when it was subjected to testing m pilot- and commercial packing lines. Under these circumstances, it became apparent once agam that a blofunglclde cannot be promoted as a stand-alone program, but rather must be offered as part of a comprehensive disease control program, namely a tool m IPM Several accomplishments have been made m recent years m the area of commercial disease control Tnchodex@ (Makteshum, Israel) has been developed for gray mold (Botrytis) control, and Fusarium prollforatum was recently proposed for downy mildew control (on grapes) Other products have been commerclahzed for the suppression of soilborne pathogens It 1sstriking to review recent developments and realize that a better understanding of disease etiology, together with realization that no product can combat devastating pathogens as a stand-alone treatment, reveal an underlying opportunity for new discoveries m the area of plant pathology. In fact, at a time when many chemicals already suffer loss of performance because of pesticide resistance, blopestlcldes in general, and blofungicides m particular, are becoming recognized tools for reslstance management wtthm IPM systems. Molecular biology has produced many powerful tools for lmprovmg the understanding of pathogen-host recogmtlon and interaction. The resolution has already had a tremendous impact on expression of Bt genes m transgemc plants, offermg a whole new concept m defense against msect pests (66). Slmllarly Impressive is the progress made m an area of plant defense mechanisms and the molecular processesinvolved in defense induction (65). However, methodologles with higher resolutions are still required, to enable a better understandmg of the molecular attributes of microbial fungicldal agents known to date
Commercd
Development
of Biofungicides
97
These will, in turn, allow for a more focused effort m improving the performance of the products. AQ 10 and Trichodex are two examples of brofungrcides developed in recent years, and mtroduced already as commercial products. In reviewing the status of these examples, together with a whole host of biofungtcides for the control of soilborne pathogens, it is quite obvious that their potential to combat fungal pathogens has not been expressed. Therefore, and primarily as a safety compromise, they are promoted as a component within IPM systems,and are greatly dependent on amendment with chemical fungicides or enhancers. However, once the analytical resolution of dissecting the molecular elements that contribute to the fungicidal activity are revealed, it is presumed that the potential is better utilized. Indeed, recent developments m genetic engineering have already provided significant potential to improve some of the attributes. Future prospects are viewed as two parallel directions of product developments: intensify the expression of active gene products m better hosts, e.g., walldegrading enzymes, such as chitinases and glucanases of bacterial origin expressed m Trichoderma (66), and dissect fungicidal genes and their expression in transgemc plants. The latter approach has already proven extremely fruttful m producing herbicide-resistant or lepidopteran-pest-resistant crops, as mentioned above. It will be possible to achieve similar successeswith respect to fungal disease control, regardless of the direction selected for development, only when there is a better understanding of the molecular basis of disease suppression. As a result of increasing knowledge of the mechamsms of pathogenicity, more progress IS expected to be made m developmg new types of diseaseprotectants, as well as the genetic engineering of resistant plant varieties. The key to progress is the successm extensively interfering with the virulence of the pathogen. Agam, all that IS known to date about the mode of action of AQlO is that it exerts its suppressive effects via hyperparasitism of PMD. We have not been able to determine the molecular cues of host-pathogen recogmnon, let alone the process by which A quzsqualis governs the metabolic function of the pathogen Progress m elucidation of the mode of action will have nnmediate implications on the quality of the biofungicide product. It ~111still remam an overridmg concern of those who translate scientific achievements mto commercial products to ensure that all inherent attributes are expresseddespite hurdles of mass production, and that it is all executed m a cost-effective fashion. References 1 Chet,I. (1987) ZnnovatzveApproaches To Plant Disease Control. Wiley,Toronto,Canada. 2 Papavizas,G. C (1984) Soilborneplant pathogens new opportunities for biological control. Proceedings 1984 Brltlsh Crop Protection Conference-Pests and Diseases,
pp 371-378.
98
Hofstein and Chapple
3. Sundheim, L. and Tronsmo, A. (198X) Hyperparasites in biological control, in Biocontrol qf Plant Diseases (Mukerji, K. G. and Garg, K. L., eds.), CRC, Boca Raton, FL, pp. 53-69. 4. Cook, R. J. (1993) Making greater use of introduced microorganisms for biological control of plant pathogens. Annu. Rev. Phytopathol. 31, 53-80. 5. Cook, R. J. (1993) The role of biological control in pest management in the 21st century, in PestManagement: Biologically BasedTechnologies,vol. 18 (Lumsden, R. D. and Vaughn, J. L., eds.), Beltsville Symposium. American Chemical Society, Washington, DC, pp. l&20. 6. Fokkema, N. J., Gerlagh, M., Kohl, J., Jongebloed, P. H. J., and Kessel, G. J. T. (1994) Prospects for biological control of foliar pathogens, in Proceedings qfthe Brighton Crop Protection Conference: Pests and Diseases,BCPC Publications, Major Print Ltd., Nottingham, UK, pp. 1249-1258. 7. Janisiewics, W. J. (1988) Biological control of diseases of fruit, in Biocontrol qf Plant Diseases,vol. 2 (Mukergi, K. G. and Grag, K. L., eds.), CRC, Boca Raton, FL, pp. 228-235. 8. Wilson, C. L, Wisniewski, M. E., El-Gaouth, A., Droby, S., and Chalutz, E. (1996) Commercialization of Antagonistic yeasts for the biological control of postharvest diseases of fruit and vegetables. J. Ind. Microbial. 46,237-24 1. 9. Cook, R. J., Bruckart, W. L., Coulson, J. R., Goettel, M. S., Humber, R. A., Lumsden, R. D., et al. (1996) Safety of microorganisms intended for pest and plant disease control: a framework for scientific evaluation. Biol. Control 7,333-35 1. 10. Carlton. B. C. (1990) Economic consideration marketing and application of biocontrol agents, in New Directions in Biological Controls-Alternatives ,for SuppressingAgricultural Pestsand Diseases(Baker, R. R. and Dunn, P. E., eds.), Liss, New York, pp. 4 19-434. 11. Bravo, A. (1997) Minireview: phylogenetic relationships of Bacillus thuringiensis b-endotoxin family proteins and their functional domains. J. Bacterial. 179, 2793-280 1. 12. Lumsden, R. D. and Walter, J. F. (1995) Development of the biocontrol fungus gliocladium virens: risk assessment and approval for horticultural use, in Biological Control: BeneJitsand Risks(Hokkanen, M. T. and Lynch, J. M., eds.), Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, UK, pp. 263-269. 13. Lewis, J. A. and Papavizas, G. C. (1987) Application of Trichoderma and Gliocladium in alginate pellets for control of Rhizoctonia damping-off. Plant Pathol. 36,438-446.
14. Baker, R. (1982) Induction of suppressiveness,in SuppressiveSoilsand Plant Disease (Schneider, R. W., ed.), American Phytopathology Society, St. Paul, MN, pp. 35-50. 15. Baker, R. (1983) State of the art: plant diseases, in Proceedingsqf the National Znterdisciplinary Biological Control Conference(Battenfield, S. L., ed.), Cooperative State Reservation Service, U. S. Department of Agriculture, Washington, DC, pp. 14-22. 16. Baker, R. and Scher, F. M. (1987) Enhancing the activity of biological control agents, in Innovative Approaches to Plant DiseaseControl (Chet, I., ed.), Wiley, Toronto, Canada, pp. l-l 7.
Commercial
Development
of Biofungicides
99
17. Dubos, B. (1987) Fungal antagonism in aerial agrobiocenoses, in/nnovativeApproaches to Plant Disease Control (Chet, I., ed.), Wiley, Toronto, Canada, pp. 107-I 35. 18. Hemming, B. C. and Houghton, J. M. (1993) Influence of biotechnology on biocontrol of take-all disease of wheat, in Biotechnology in Plant Disease Control (Chet, I., ed.), Wiley-L&, New York, pp. 15-38. 19. Wilson, C. L. and Wisniewski, M. E. (1994) Large scale production and pilot testing of biological control agents for postharvest diseases, in Biological Control of Postharvest Disease, Theory and Practice (Chet, I., ed.), CRC, Boca Raton, FL, pp. 89-100. 20. Cate, R. (1990) Biological control of pests and diseases: integrating a diverse heritage, in New Directions in Biological Control: Alternatives for Suppressing Agricultural Pests and Diseases (Baker, R. R. and Dunn, P. E., eds.), Liss, New York, pp. 333-344. 21. Lumsden, R. D. and Lewis, J. M. (1989) Selection, production, formulation, and commercial use of plant disease biocontrol fungi, problems and progress, in Biotechnology of Fungi for Improving Plant Growth (Whips, J. M. and Lumsden, R. D., eds.), Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, UK, pp. 17 l-l 90. 22. El-Ghaouth, A. E., Wilson, C. L., and Wisniewski, M. E. (1995) Sugar analogs as potential fungicides for postharvest pathogens of apple and peach. Plant Dis. 79, 254-258. 23. Fokkema, N. J. (1976) Antagonism between fungal saprophytes and pathogens on aerial plant surfaces, in Microbiology ofAerial Plant Surfaces (Dickinson, E. and Preece, F., eds.), Academic, New York, pp. 487-506. 24. Katan, J. (1985) Solar disinfestation of soils, in Biology and Management of Soilborne Plant Pathogens (Parker, C. A., Rovira, A. D., Moore, K. J., Wong, P. T. W., and Kollmorgen, J. F., eds.), APS, St. Paul, MN, pp. 274-278. 25. Blakeman, J. P. and Fokkema, N. J. (1982) Potential for biological control of plant diseases on the phylloplane. Annu. Rev. Phytopathot. 20, 167-l 92. 26. Olivier, J. M. (1983) Les organismes antagonistes d’agents phytopathogenes, in Faune et Flore Auxiliaires en Agriculture. ACTA, Paris, pp. 145-164. 27. Chet, I. and Baker, R. (1981) Isolation and biocontrol potential of Trichoderma hamatum from soil naturally suppressive of Rhizoctonia solani. Phytopathology 71,286-290. 28. Falk, S. P., Gadoury, D. M., Cortesi, P., Pearson, R. C., and Seem, R. C. (1995) Parasitism of uncinula necator Cleistothecia by the mycoparasite Ampelomyces
quisqualis. Phytopathology
85, 794-800.
29. Galper, S., Sztejnberg, A., and Lisker, N. (1985) Scanning electron microscopy of the ontogeny ofAmpelomyces quisqualis pycnidia. Can. J. Microbial. 31,961-964. 30. Taber, R. A., Smith, D. H., Petit, R. F., and Johnson, J. D. (198 1) Potential for biological control of Fulvia,fulvum by Hansfordia in Texas. Phytopathology 71, 908-912. 3 1. Falk, S. P., Gadoury, D. M., Pearson, R. C., and Seem, R. C. (1995) Partial control of grape powdery mildew by the mycroparasite Ampelomyces quisqualis. Plant
Dis. 79,483-490.
100
Hofstein and Chapple
32. O’Neill, T. M., NIV, A , Elad, Y., and Shttenberg, D (1996) Btological control of Botrytzs cznerea on tomato stem wounds with Trtchoderma harztanum in Israel Eur J Plant Path01 102,6355643 33 Jackson, M and Schtsler, D. H. (1992) The composition and attrtbutes of Colletotrzchum truncatum spores are altered by the mutational envtronment Appl Envtron Mtcrobtol. 58,2260-2265. 34 Phthpp, W D and Cruger, G. (1979) Parasitismus von Ampelomyces qutsqualzs auf Echlen Mchltauptlzen an Gurken und andern Gemtisearten 2 PfZanzenkr Pflanzenschutz 86, 129-142 35. Engelkes, C. A , Nuclo, R L , and Fravel, D. R. (1997) In effect of carbon, mtrogen, and C N ratto on growth, sporulatton, and btocontrol efficacy of Talaromyces jlavus Phytopathology 87,500-508 36 Hofstem, R and Fridlender, B (1994) Development of production, dehvery, formulation and dehvery systems for biohnrgtcides, m Brtghton Crop Protectron Conference Pests and Dueases, BCPC Publications, Major Print Ltd , Nottmgham, UK, pp 1273-l 280. 37 Abu-Foul, S , Raskm, V. I , Sztejnberg, A , and Marder, J B (1996) Disruption of chlorophyll organization and function m powdery mildew dtseased cucumber leaves and its control by the hyperparasite Ampelomyces quzsqualts Phytopathology 86, 195-l 99 38 SzteJnberg, A , Galper, S., Mazar, S , and Ltsker, N (1989) Ampelomyces quzsqualzs for biologtcal and integrated control of powdery mildew m Israel J Phytopathol. 124,285-295 39 Zimand, G , Elad, Y , and Chet, I. (1996) Effect of Trrchoderma harzranum on Botrytts ctnerea pathogenictty Phytopathology 86, 1255-1260 40 Sutton, J C , LI, D., Pang, G , Yu, H., Zhang, P , and Valdebemto-Sanhueza, R M. (1997) Gltocladtum roseum. a versattle adversary of Botrytts cwerea m crops Plant Dts 81,3 16-328 41 Wtlson, C L and Wtsmewskt, M E., eds (1994) Bzologzcal Control OfPostharvest Dtsease of Frutts and Vegetables-Theory and Practtces CRC, Boca Raton, FL 42 Jamsiewicz, W J , Usall, J , and Bors, B (1992) Nutrittonal enhancement of btocontrol of blue mold on apples Phytopathology 82, 1364-l 370. 43 Elad, Y , Zimand, G , Zaqs, Y , Zuriel, S , and Chet, I (1993) Use of Trtchoderma harztanum in combmatton or condmons alternation wtth fungictdes to control cucumber gray mold (Botrytzs cznerea) under commercial greenhouse condittons Plant Pathol. 42,324332 44 Elad, Y., Shtienberg, D., and Niv, A. (1994) Trichderma hrzzanum T39 integrated with fungicides: improved btocontrol of gray mold, m Brighton Crop Protectton Conference Pests and Dweases, BCPC Publications, MaJor Print Ltd , Nottingham, UK,pp 1109-1114 45 Daoust, R A and Hofstein, R (1996) Ampelomyces quzsqualts, a new biofungicide to control powdery mildew m grapes, m Brtghton Crop Protectton Conference Pests and Diseases, BCPC Publications, MaJor Print Ltd , Nottingham, UK, pp 33-40.
Commercial
Development
of Biofungicides
101
46 Lmdow, S. E., McGourty, G., and Elkms, R (1996) InteractIons of antlblotlcs with Pseudomonasfluorescens strain a506 m the control of fire bhght and frost mJury to pear. Phytopathology 86, 841-848. 47 Federal register EPA (1989) Data Requirements for Pesticide Registration, Final Rule. 53, 15,952-l 5,999. 48 Federal register, EPA ( 1995) Candzda oleophlla Isolate I- 182 (ASPIRE) Exemptlon from the Requn-ement of a Tolerance. 60, 11,032-l 1,033. 49. Katz, M (1997) Powdery mildew. biological enhances growers’ options. Grape Grower
29,4-7
50 Cavanaugh, P (1997) New blofunglclde reduces resistance, late sulfur. Am. Vzneyard 6,3-5
5 1 Hudson, R A (1997) Compatibility of Ampelomyces quxqulzs spores with commercial chemical products for use in IPM programs Phytopathology 87, S45. 52 Sundhelm, L and Kreklmg, T (1982) Host-parasitic relationships of the hyperparasite Ampelomyces quzsqualts and Its powdery mildew host Sphaerothzca fullgznea Phytopathology 104,202-2 10 53 Jarvls, W. R. and Klmsby, K. (1977) The control of powdery mildew of greenhouse cucumber by water sprays and Ampelomyces qulsqualzs Plant Du Rep 61,728-730
54 SzteJnberg, A , Galper, G., and Lisker, N (1990) Condltlons for pycmdlal production and spore formation by AmpelomycesquzsqualzsCan J Mcroblol 36, 193-198 55 Falk, S. P , Pearson, R C , Gadoury, D. M , Seem, R C , and SzteJnberg, A (1996) Fusarlumprollferatum as a blocontrol agent against grape downy mildew Phytopathology 86, 101&1017 56 Droby, S , Chalutz, E , Wlsmewskl, M E , and Wilson, C E (1996) Host response to mtroductlon of antagonistic yeasts used for control of postharvest decay, m Mzcroblology ofAerza1 Plant Surfaces (Moms, C E , Nlcot, P , and Nguyen-The, eds ), Phytopathology Press, St Paul, MN 57 Wilson, C L , El-Ghaouth, A E., Chalutz, E., Droby, S., Stevens, C , Lu, J Y , Khan, V , and Arul, J (1994) Potential of induced resistance to control postharvest diseases of fruits and vegetables Plant Du 78, 837-844 58. Chapple, A C , Downer, R. A, and Hall, F R (1993) The effect of spray adJuvants on swath patterns and droplet spectra for a flat-fan hydraulic nozzle. Crop Protection 12,579-590
59. Chapple, A. C. and Bateman, R. P (1997) Application systems for mlcroblal pesticides. necessity not novelty, m Brztzsh Crop Protection Councd Symposium Mzcrobzal ZnsectzczdesNovelty or Necesszty?(Evans, H F , ed ), BCPC Publlcatlons, Major Print Ltd , Nottingham, UK, pp 18 l-l 90. 60 Phlllpp, W D , Beuther, E , Hermann, D , Klmkert, E , Oberwalder, C , and Schmldke, M (1990) Formulation of the powdery mildew hyperparaslte Ampelomyces qulsqualzs J Plant Dls Protectzon 97, 120-132 61 Gubler, W. D., Thomas, C. S., Weber, E., Luvisl, D., Leavitt, G , and Smith, R. (1997) Use of a weather station based disease risk assessment for control of grapevine powdery mildew m California Phytopathology 87, S36
102
Hofstein
and Chapple
62 Whtpps, J. M (1992) Status of biologtcal disease control Hortudtural Blocontr-ol Scz Technol. 2,3-24. 63 Lumsden, R D , Lewis, J A , and Fravel, D R (1995) Formulation and deltvery of btocontrol agents for use against sotlborne plant pathogens, m Bloratlonal Pest Control Agents Formulattolz and Delwery (Hall, F R. and Barry, S , eds ), Symposium Series, American Chemtcal Society, Washmgton, DC, pp 16&l 82 64 Perlak, F J , Deaton, R W , Aremstrong, T A, Fuchs, R L , Sums, S R , Greenplate, J T., and Ftschhoff, D A (1990) Insect reststant cotton plants Brotechnology 8,939-943 65 Broghe, K., Broghe, R , Benhamou, N , and Chet, I (1994) The role of cell wall degrading enzymes m fimgal dtsease reststance, m Biotechnology In Plant Dzsease Control (Chet, I , ed ), Wiley-Ltss, New York, pp 139-156 66 Chet, I , Barak, Z , and Oppenhetm, A (1994) Genetic engmeermg of mtcroorgamsms for improved biocontrol acttvrty, in Bzotechnology zn Plant Disease Control (Chet, I , ed ), Wtley-Lrss, New York, pp 21 l-235
Biological
Control of Seedling Diseases
K. Prakesh Hebbar and Robert D. Lumsden 1. Introduction Seedlmgs of economically important crop plants are attacked by various soilborne pathogenic fungi, such as Pythium, Fusanum, Rhlzoctorua, Phytopthora, and others, which cause either seed rot before germmation or seedling rot after germmation, resultmg m billions of dollars m cumulative crop losses. These diseases are often termed pre- and postemergence damping-off, or seedlmg blights Greenhouse crops grown in soilless cultures, as well as field crops, are susceptible to soilborne fungal pathogens, resulting m considerable economic losses.Currently, the most widely used control measure for suppressing soilborne diseases IS the use of environmentally hazardous fungicidal treatment of seed, seedlings, or soils. However, problems encountered, such as development of pathogen resistance to fungicides, mabillty of seed-treated fungicides to protect the roots of mature plants, rapid degradation of the chemicals, and a requirement for repeated applications, have given impetus to alternative remedies (2). One approach to address this problem is to use naturally occurrmg and environmentally safe biological control microorganisms, used alone or m conluncnon with integrated pest management (IPM) strategies (2). Several biological control agents have been commercialized or have been registered for commercial field trials (3) However, a major problem encountered m the area of biological control is the mconsistencies m performance of biocontrol products (4). According to Bowen and Rovtra (5), rapid migration to newly formed root surfaces from the point of inoculation, as well as rapid growth rates, can also be helpful in improvmg the performance of biocontrol agents Suslow and Schroth (6) have reported, m a dose response study, that the mmtmum number of viable cells needed for uniform colonization and plant growth promotion m From Methods m Biotechnology, vol 5 Blopestmdes Use and Debvery Edtted by F R Hall and J J Menn 0 Humana Press Inc , Totowa, NJ
103
Hebbar and Lumsden
104
sugarbeets with Pseudomonasfluorescens was IO5 bacteria/seed or 10’ bacteria/g dry wt moculum. Failure m moculum trials may be caused by selection of moculants that do not have some of the above charactertstics (7). This may also be caused by factors such as lack of knowledge related to the ecology of btocontrol agents, poor sot1colomzatton and persistence, and limited dehvery technology currently available. The obJeCtiVe of this chapter is to describe the successful discovery and commercial development of two btological control agents: a bacterium, Burkholderra cepacla; and a fungus, Ghocladium wrens. 2. Examples of Biological Control Agents Examples of bacteria that are currently commercially available are Gramnegative B cepacza (Deny TM, CCT, Carlsbad, CA), and Agrobacterlum radzobacter (Nogall TM, Bro Care Technology, Australia) and Gram-positive Baczllus subtzlzs (Kodiak HBTM and EptcTM, Gustafson) and Streptomyces gnseovwcd~s (Mycostop TM,Kemira OY, Finland). The fungal btocontrol products available commercially are Glzocladzum wrens (SoilGardTM, ThermoTrilogy, Columbia, MD) and Trichoderma harzranum (T22TM and Root ShteldTM, Bioworks, Geneva, NY). Most of the above mentioned products are effective m controlled envtronments, such as greenhouses, but only a few of these products have been used extensively for biologtcal suppression of fungal diseases m major fruit (Nogall) and field crops (Kodiak) (3). This chapter wtll discuss the discovery and development of two biocontrol agents: a bacterium, B cepacla, and a fungus, G wrens. 2.7. Burkholderia 2 1.1. Ecology
cepacia
Studies of corn monoculture soils in the midwestern United States(8) and m France (9) showed that high populations of B. cepacza (syn Pseudomonas cepacza) (IO), a ubiquitous sot1bactermm, were associatedwith the rhizosphere and roots of corn, In addition, successive corn culttvation increased populations of B. cepacla (9). The rhizosphere/nonrhizosphere (R/S) population ratio was 4000, indicatmg its affimty for corn roots. When applied as seed moculants, B cepacza strains isolated from corn colomzed the rhizosphere and roots of corn extensively, with seed moculum levels as low as 10 bacteria/seed Within 2 wk, populattons proliferated to 10’ colony formmg units (CFU)/g dry wt of root (II). B. cepacza 1s also an efficient colonizer of roots and rhizosphere of radish (12), pea (231, sunflower (14), and soybean (IS). Although B cepacia has been described as a phytopathogen causing sour skm of onion bulbs (16), and also as a secondary pathogen m humans with cystic fibrosis (27), strains isolated from the rhtzosphere of corn do not cause necrosis of onion tissue (18), and are quite different from the chmcal strains (19).
Biological Control of Seedling Diseases
105
2.1.2. Mode of Action B. cepacia strains isolated from the rhizosphere of corn have a broad-spectrum antifungal activity against a range of fungal pathogens (18). Pyrrolnitrin has been reported as the major metabolite responsible for the broad-spectrum antifungal activity of B cepacia (5,12,20). On the contrary, the reference strain ATCC 254 16, an onion pathogen, does not produce pyrrolmtrm (21) Recent reports indicate that, in addition to pyrrolnitrin, B. cepacia produces antifungal compounds such as siderophores (22-24) and chlorinated phenylpyrrole antibiotics (29, as well as the hydrolytic enzyme P-1,3-glucanase (26).
2.1.3. Biological Control Numerous reports now exist on the isolation and utilization of B cepacza for biological control of vartous sorlbome fungal pathogens in different crops (22,24,18, 21,23,27-31) In growth chamber studies, Hebbar et al. (28) determmed that the majority of sot1strains of B. cepacia were unable to suppressearly corn seedling infection by Fusarium moniliforme, but those isolated from corn roots could do so. Isolates of B cepacaa from lettuce roots, when used as seed treatments,reduced radish seeddamping-off causedby Rhizoctonia solam AG4 by 50% (12). Although B. cepacia ISeffective againsta wide range of soil pathogens,its success asa seedtreatment is determmed by various factors, such astotal number of bacteria addedto coat the seeds,soil temperature,and, in somecases,the plant cultivar used. In greenhousestudies,the optimum concentration of B. cepacia necessaryto reduce seedlingdamping-off in corn causedby acombmation of three pathogens(Fusanum graminearum, Pythium ultimum, andPythium arrhenomanes), was determmed to be 1OSCFU/seed(30). In the samestudy,the optimum temperature(25°C) for B. cepacia to be effective was higher than that (18’C) for the fungal biocontrol agent G. virens. Kmg and Parke(28) determined that, although the efficacy of B. cepacza to suppress Aphanomyces eutezches root rot andPythium damping-off m peaswas not limited to a single cultivar, the differential effects of biocontrol were related to the degree of suscepttbthtyto the pathogen of eachof the four cultivars tested. Although B. cepacia is consideredas a biocontrol agent with potential for largescaleapplication, there is only one commercial product available, marketed by CCT under the trade nameDeny. Recently,promising resultswere obtained (32) m extensive field trials conductedby Agrium (Saskatoon,Canada)to evaluate, the feasibility of using B. cepacia strain Ral-3 for biological control and growth enhancementof conifer seedlings. 2.2. Gliocladium 2.2.1. Eco/ogy
virens
The fungus G. wrens Miller, Giddens, and Foster (=Trichoderma wrens, Miller, Giddens, Foster, and von Ark) was originally isolated from a sclero-
Hebbar and Lumsden
106
tmm of the plant pathogemc fungus Sclerotinza manor burled and recovered from a Beltsville, MD, soil G vzrens 1snative to all parts of the United States and 1swidely distributed throughout the world (33,341. G vzrens is a hyphomycete with no confirmed sexual stage The possible sexual stage is Hypocrea gelatznosa (33,35). It proliferates as asexual conidta that are held m masses of moist spores. It survives as vegetative segments of the mycehum, termed chlamydospores, usually embedded m organic matter. The spores are not airborne and are dispersed only as spore suspensions m water, or carried m sot1 or m organic debris Recently, molecular evidence Indicated that G vzrens is more closely related to Trzchoderma than to the type spectes of the genus Glzocladzum. This supports suggestions to refer to the fungus as T wrens, rather than G wrens (35). Because of the prevalence m the literature for the established name, G wrens, the authors prefer to use this name. However, the probable relationship to Trzchoderma 1srecognized. 2.2.2.
Mode of Action
G wrens is a common sot1 saprophyte, and, as with many other sotlborne fungi, produces several antibiotic metabolites (36-41) that are thought to enhance tts soil competittveness The metabohte most likely associated with control of Pythium and Rhtzoctonia damping-off is gltotoxm, an eptpolythiopiperazine-3,6-dione antibiotic (36,40,42, 42a). Ghotoxm has antibacterial, antifungal, antiviral, and antttumor activity It also interferes with phagocytic cells, and is unmunosuppressive (41). Smce gliotoxin has moderate mammahan (rats) toxtctty (50 mg/kg) (41), mgestion directly by an animal or human 1sof some concern. However, thorough evaluatton of formulattons indicated only traces of gltotoxin m the product (43), and the formulation is not toxic to rats (44). Consequently, the wheat-bran-based product would not be harmful tf ingested. Moreover, gltotoxm 1sproduced after mcorporation of the granular product mto the soil, remains active for a short period of ttme, and is inactivated (Lumsden, unpublished results). A defimttve role for ghotoxm mvolvement m the mechanism of antagomsm is supported by recent mutattonal analysts studies of G wrens (G-20 = GL-21) (45). In that case, at least for action of Gl-21 against P ultimum, about 60% of the biocontrol efficacy of the wild-type strain was lost when strains were mutated to no longer produce glrotoxm. The remammg bto-control effecttveness might realisttcally be attributed to competition of G wrens with P ultimum for nutrients. Conversely, other mutational analysis evtdence, m the case of R. solani, suggests that competition for nutrients might account for a greater effect on achieving biocontrol than production of antibiotic metabohtes (46)
Biological Control of Seedling Diseases
107
2.2.3. BiologIcal Control Several reports have been published on btologlcal control of a wade range of sotlborne fungal pathogens by G vzrens under both field and greenhouse condmons. Recently, the development of G vzrens for damping-off disease control m greenhouse applications was described (47). The commercial development of G vzrens as a granular formulatron, wrth the trade name SotlGard, was accompltshed by a process that included drscovery of the btocontrol fungus, product development, marketing assessment, product formulattons, process development, extensive efficacy assays, regtstratton wtth the U. S. Environmental Protection Agency (EPA), scale up, and test marketing. The biologtcal control properties of the fungus, G vixens, were aimed at controllmg damping-off diseases of seedlings caused by P ultlmum and R soianl m greenhouse production of seedlings and bedding plants (47). The biological control efficacy of G vzren~ was tested extensively and determmed to be consistent and reliable when used as prescribed for control of damping-off m greenhouse apphcattons (2,43,47-49) Also, G. vzrens reduced disease caused by R solanl on potato (SO) and ornamental crops (48,49) In field trials, appltcatton of G vzrens reduced the mctdence of southern blight caused by Sclerotzum rolfszi in carrots and tomatoes, and increased yield (51). Preliminary results have shown that seed treatment with G virens reduced damping-off in corn caused by a combinatton of P. ultimum, P. arrhenomones, and F gramznearum both in greenhouse (30) and field trials (W. Mao, personal communication). 3. Production and Application of Biocontrol Agents Certain crtterta were considered important in the early stages of development of G. vzrens and B cepaczaas brocontrol agents (4,s). For G vzrens, thts mcluded a bioassay method for selectmg the best strain of G wrens, which also considered: the use of a commercially available soilless medium, used m commercral glasshouses where the disease problems (damping-off) occur; the study of appropriate pathogens, such as P u&mum and R. solam, which are important in greenhouse operations in which the use of a btologrcal control agent would probably be most successful because of fairly uniform culture condrttons; selection of indigenous microorganisms to the United States, because nomndrgenous mlcroorgamsms might be conceived as more likely problems for the United Statesenvironment; the potential for the use of a single isolate of a btocontrol agent for control of both pathogens would be preferred over a mixture of isolates; and the utilizatron of high-value crops, important m the ornamental productton industry to defray the cost of development and registration Similarly, the above logic was also used m the development of B. cepaczaas a btocontrol agent. However, the crop was a field crop, corn, and
Hebbar and 1umsden
108
the targeted pathogens were Pythzum and Fusarium spp (8,11,28). On the basis of these factors, it would make the process for registration and commerciahzation of an agent for control of plant diseaseseasier. 3.7. Liquid Fermentation Major advances have been made m the production of biocontrol agents using hqutd fermentatton (52). The strategy used for large-scale production of Grampositive bacterial agents (Baczllus spp) has been to obtain heat- and desiccation-resistant endospores of bacteria or chlamydospores of fungi. Large-scale production of the resistant chlamydospores of fungal antagonists, such as Trzchoderma and Glzocladzum spp are now possible using llqutd fermentation (53). Although large-scaleproduction of Gram-negative bacterial agents(B. cepacla and P f2uorescen.s) is feasible, a major problem is encountered because of then sensitivity to desiccation. This constraint greatly affects the next step, which IS the delivery and application technology 3.2. Formulation
Development
Upon selection of an antagonist of choice, an appropriate formulation of the biocontrol agent for ease of preparation, application, and maximum efficacy should be chosen. Formulation is a key to product success, because it can determine success of delivery, shelf life, and stability of its effectiveness against plant pathogens. The first formulation for G wrens was based on alginate-wheat-bran granules (prill) (7,54), and was called GlioGardTM. Later in product development, certain quality control problems were encountered m the scale-up process. Difficulty was encountered because of the holding times for biomass, and for drying the alginate prill preparations m large volumes. For this reason, and because of an increase m the cost of alginate, the formulation was modified by including dextrm as a binder, reducing the algmate content, and preparing the biomass mixture by a fluid-bed granulation method. These changes did not affect the shelf life and efficacy characteristics, and thus were adopted for a modified product, SoilGard (47). Quality control 1sessential for formulatton development. A simple, but welldefined quality-control program should be m place for comparison of different formulations, and should examine, among other factors, viabihty, stability, and efficacy (43). If a quality control program is not m place during formulation research, product development can be severely delayed, which will ulttmately impact profitability. Quahty control is also extremely important during commercial productton of biocontrol agents (43). With favorable results obtained m detailed efficacy trials (49), additional trials were expanded to include several other cooperators, to ensure that results could be replicated (43). When similar results were obtained, trials were con-
Biological Control of Seedling Diseases
109
ducted with several bedding-plant grower cooperators using different protocols (43). With the exception of artrficral mfestatron with pathogens, whrch was used in the earlier trials, researchers were at liberty to use whatever plants they desired, and their own apphcatton schedules. The design of the trials in step arrangement allowed for less control m the way the product was handled with each phase of testing. By the time commercral growers were included m the trials, natural mfestatron was used to determine efficacy, and the grower was srmply given the product with a basic set of mstructrons, srmilar to those now provided on the product label. So far, other than a liquid-based or peatbased formulatron, further progress has not been achieved m formulatmg B cepacia strains (G. Growell, CCT, personal commumcation). 3.3. Application
of Biocontrol
Agents
The most commonly used methods for delivermg btologrcal control agents, especrally under controlled greenhouse conditions, are soil amendments usmg granulated formulations (SorlGard) or drenching with liquid formulations (Deny). Seed applications of dry formulatron have been successfully used for field crops such as cotton and peanuts (Bacillus spp, Kodiak). Seed apphcatron of G vzren~IS currently bemg investigated in the Btocontrol of Plant Diseases Laboratory (US Department of Agriculture, Agrrcultural Research Service). Preliminary results have shown that seed treatments with dry fungal biomass rich m chlamydospores are equal to, or better than, fungrctdes m reducing damping-off m corn (30). However, delivery of Gram-negative bacterial agents as seed treatments for field crops is still a major problem. Brocontrol agents, such as P.fluorescens or B. cepacia, coated on the seeds,have a short shelf hfe (at room temperature), and are readily killed by desiccation. Unless methods are found for their delivery as seed apphcattons, then large scale use may not be feasible However, liquid formulattons (Deny) are bemg tried usmg drip nrtgatton for a few high-value crops, such as strawberry and melons. 3.4. Registration
of Biocontrol
Agents, G. virens as Example
Regrstratron of G virens with the EPA was mtttated by W. R. Grace (now Therm0 Trilogy, Columbia, MD) (44). The EPA reviews applications and regulates mrcroorganisms used as biocontrol agents if they are genettcally engineered, nonmdtgenous to the United States, or if they will be field-tested on more than 10 acres (4.05 ha) of land or 1 acre surface of water (0.41 ha) (55). Subdivision M of the EPA Pesticide Testing Gurdelmes (56) treats mrcrobial agents for the control of plant pests in ways similar to those for chemical pesticides. Companies applying for registration must provide extensive mformation for approval for commercial use of microbial pesticide products. Product testing 1sset up in a tier systemthat recogmzesthe mherent rusksand degrees
110
Hebbar
and Lumsden
of exposure associatedwith different usesof pesticides In addition to production and taxonomrc data, long- and short-term effects on a variety of orgamsms,mcludmg plants, ammals, and other nontarget organisms, may be necessary. Three formulattons of G wrens (Gl-2 1) were approved by the EPA WRCGL-2 1, a manufacturmg-use product (fungal biomass), can be used m formulations of btocontrol products. WRC-AP- 1 (GhoGard) is an end-use formulated prtlled product containing calcmm algmate, wheat bran, and proprietary additives to prolong shelf life. The prtlls or granular material is mixed with sot1or soilless plant growmg media at least 1 d prior to planting, or incorporated mto the medium surface m plant beds prior to, or at, planting. The formulation 1s used at the rate of l-l 5 lb/yd3 (approx 1 g/L) of media when mixed, or at the rate of 0.75-l ounce/sq ft when applied to the bed surface. WRC-AP-2 (SoilGard) is an improved granulated product, with somewhat improved efficacy, and which is more economical to manufacture. GhoGard is no longer being produced, and is replaced on the market with SoilGard (47). 3.5. Compatibility of Biological Agents with Chemical Pesticides and Other /PM Strategies Recently, one of the major endeavors to improve the efficacy of btologtcal control agents, has been to use them m an IPM strategy, such as sot1solarizatton (57,58), or by using btocontrol agents resistant or tolerant to chemical pesticides (59,60) Initial results from field trials to evaluate suppression of the southern blight pathogen, S ~olfszz,m bell pepper, mdtcated that the biocontrol fungus, G wrens, was sensitive to so11solarizatton, and therefore could not be used m this combmatton. In contrast, the temperature tolerant biocontrol fungus Tularomycesflavus has been used successfully m combmatton with soil solarizatton (58). Soil solartzation, followed by the application of btocontrol agents, may improve disease suppresstveness. Seedling bioassays with corn indtcated that the btocontrol bactermm, B cepacia, could be used m combination with chemical pesticides to improve seedling emergence (9). Seedling vigor was better, when corn seedswere treated with thtram fungicide m combtnation with a peat-based formulation of B cepacia, than when either treatment was used alone. Btological agents, espectally those that are root-assoctated microorgamsms, may perform better than chemtcal or physical treatments of the soil. This ts because of then ability to colomze root tissue and have an effect on the deeper layers of the so11profile. In addmon, fungicides can protect plant seedlmgs only for a short duration, and the effect of soil solartzatton 1slimited in the upper few centimeters of the solI. Although chemical fungtctdes or soil solartzatlon has been shown to be effictent m suppressmg dampmg-off diseases on then own, there is a defimte advantage m combmmg these strategies with btocontrol agents.
Biological Control of Seedling Diseases
171
4. Current Status and Future Prospects Despite problems associated with the shelf life and delivery of blological agents, progress has been encouraging in terms of their acceptance as alternatives to chemical seed treatments when used alone or in conjunction with chemicals m an IPM strategy Currently, these questions are being asked. Can pathogens develop resistance to biocontrol agents; can their effectiveness be improved by combmmg two or more biological agents; will their effectiveness be restrlcted to certain kinds of environments; and 1sblologlcal control economically feasible? Commercialization of biocontrol agents 1sdependent on marketing assessment and determination of market availability and profit margins. Several factors should be considered, including the patentability of the formulation or strain of the blocontrol agent; the need m agricultural production systems for safe, reliable, nonchemical treatments for controlling plant diseases; the requirement for simple, mexpenslve fermentation systemsto produce biomass of blocontrol agents m large commercial scale fermenters; and the ability of biological pest control agents to be generally less damaging to the envlronment, and cheaper to develop, register, and market than chemical control compounds. Considering all of these factors, biological control products are begmmng to be recognized as commercially feasible for agricultural markets, and for plant protection strategies in general. The commerclahzation of the two blologlcal products mentioned in this chapter (Deny and SollGard) are good examples of how successful blologlcal control projects can matenahze, if a logical step by step approach, from the mltlal discovery, and ecological study, to the final development, 1sused. Also, close cooperative work between pnvate companies and public research institutions facilitates development of new and mnovatlve btocontrol products. 5. Note Mention of a trademark or proprietary product does not constitute a guarantee or warranty of the product by the USDA, and does not imply approval to the exclusion of other products that may also be suitable. References 1. Cook, R J. and Baker, K. F (1983) Nature and Practzce of Bzologzcal Control of Plant Pathogens APS, St.Paul, MN. 2 Lumsden, R D and Locke, J C ( 1989) Blologlcal control of damping-off caused by Pythum ultlmum and Rhuoctonza solam with Glzocladzum wrens m soilless mix Phytopathology 79,361-366 3. Lumsden, R. D., Lewis, J. A., and Fravel, D. R. (1995) Formulation and delivery of blocontrol agents for use against soilborne plant pathogens, m Bloratlonal Pest
712
4
5 6 7 8
9
10
11
12.
13 14. 15
16 17
Hebbar and Lumsden
Control Agents (Hall, F R. and Barry, J. W , eds ), American Chemtcal Society, Washmgton, DC, pp. 16&l 82 Lumsden, R D and Lewis, J A. (1989) Selection, productton, formulation and commerctal use of plant disease biocontrol fungi, problems and progress, m Btotechnology ofFungifir Improvtng Plant Growth (Whtpps, J. M. and Lumsden, R. D , eds ), Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, UK, pp 17 I-l 90 Bowen, G D and Rovira, A D (1976) Mtcrobtal colonization of plant roots Annu Rev Phytopathol 14, 121-144 Suslow, T V and Schroth, M N (1982) Rhrzoctoma of sugar beet effects of seed apphcatlons and root colomzatton on yield Phytopathology 72, 199-206 Kloepper, J W., Ltfshttz, R., and Zablotowtcz, R. M (1989) Free-living bacterial mocula for enhancing crop producttvtty Trends Btotechnol 7,3944 Hebbar, K P., Davey, A G , and Dart, P J ( 1992) Rhtzobacterra of corn antagonistic to Fusartum montforme, a sotlbome fungal pathogen tsolatton and tdenttfication Sod Btol Btochem 24, 978-987. Hebbar, K P , Martel, M. H., and Heulm, T (1994) Burkholderta cepacta, a plant growth promotmg rhrzobacterial assoctate of corn, in Improvtng Plant Producttvzty wzth Rhzzosphere Bacterza (Ryder, M H., Stephens, P M , and Bowen, G D , eds.), Proceedzngs, Thud International Workshop on Plant Growth Promoting Rhtzobacterta, Adelaide, Austraha, pp 201-203 Yaabucht, E , Kosako, Y., Oyalzu, H , Yano, I , Hotta, H , Hastmoto, Y , Ezakt, T , and Arakawa, M. (1992) Proposal of Burkholdena gen Nov and transfer of seven species of the genus Pseudomonas homology Group II to a new genus, wtth type species Burkholderza cepacra (Pallerom and Holmes, 1981) comb Nov Mtcrobtol Immunol 34, 125 1-l 275 Hebbar, K P , Davey, A. G., Merrm, J , McLaughlin, T. J., and Dart, P J (1992) Pseudomonas cepacta, a potenttal suppressor of corn sotlborne diseases Seed moculatton and corn root colomzatton Sod B1o1 Biochem 24, 999-l 007 Homma, Y , Sata, Z , Htrayama, F , Konna, K , Shnahama, H., and Suzuki, T. (1989) Productton of anttbtotrcs by Pseudomonas cepacra as an agent for biological control of sotlbome plant pathogens. So11Btol Btochem 21, 723-728 Parke, J. L. (1990) Population dynamics of Pseudomonas cepacta m the pea spermosphere m relation to blocontrol of Pythzum Phytopathology 80, 1307-l 3 11 Hebbar, K P , Berge, O., Heulm, T , and Smgh, S P (199 1) Bacterial antagonists of sunflower (Helzanthus annuus L) Fungal pathogens Plant Sod 133, 13 l-140 Hebbar, K P , Hackett, J. D , Fravel, D R , and Lumsden, R D (1995) Assoctatton of Burkholderta cepacta and Pseudomonas with corn and soybean roots and their role m suppressmg pre-emergence damping-off of soybean Abs Phytopath01 85, 1136 Burkholder, W H (1950) Sour skin, a bacterial rot of onion bulbs Phytopathology40,115-117 Lessee, T. G , Hendrtckson, W., Manning, B D , and Devereux, R (1996) Genomtc complextty and plasttcrty of Burkholderta cepacta FEMS Mcrobtol Lett 144, 117-128
Biological
Control
of Seedling
Diseases
113
18 Hebbar, K. P , Atkinson, D., Tucker, W , and Dart, P J (1992) Suppression of Fusarcum monrlrforme by corn root-associated Pseudomonas cepacla SolI Blol Bzochem 24, 1009-l 020 19. G~lhs, M., Van, V T., Bardm, R., Goor, M., Hebbar, P., Wrllems, A , et al. (1995) Polyphastc taxonomy m the genus Burkholderza leadmg to an emended descriptron of the genus and proposition of Burkholderza vletnamlensls sp Nov. for N2-fixing isolates from rice m Vietnam Int J Systematzc Bacterial 45,274-289 20 Jamsiewrcz, W J and Roitman, J (1988) Biological control of blue mold and grey mold on apple and pear with Pseudomonas cepacla Phytopathology 78, 1697-1700 21. Homma, Y., Chtkuo, Y , and Ogoshl, A (1990) Mode of suppression of sugar beet damping-off caused by Rhlzoctonla solam and Aphanomyces cochllodes by seed bactertzatton with Pseudomonas cepacla, in Plant Growth Promoting Rhczobacterza-Progress and Prospects (Keel, C., Koller, B , and Defago, G , eds ), Proceedzngs, Second Internattonal Workshop on Plant Growth Promoting Rhtzobacteria, Interlaken, Switzerland, pp. 115-l 18. 22. Barelmann I , Meyer, J M , Tarez, K., and Budztktewtez, H (1996) Cepaciachelm, a new catecholate siderophore from Burkhoiderla (Pseudomonas) cepacla. Z Naturforschung
51,627-630
23 Smirnov, V V , Kiprianova, E. A , Gargulya, A D , Dodatko, T A , and Ptlyaschenko, I I (1990) Anttbtotic activity and siderophores of Pseudomonas cepacla Appl Blochem and Mxroblol
26, 5843.
24 Meyer, J. M , Hohnadel, D., and Halle, F (1989) Cepabactm from Pseudomonas cepacla, a new type of siderophore J Gen Mlcroblol 135, 1479-1487. 25 Rottman, J N , Mahoney, N E., Janistewtcz, W J., and Benson, M (1990) A new chlormated phenyl pyrrole antrbiotic produced by antifungal bacterium Pseudomonas cepacla J Agrlc
Food Chem 38,538-541.
26 Fravel, D R , Marois, J. J , Lumsden, R D., and Conmck, W J , Jr (1985) Encapsulation of potential btocontrol agents m an algmate-clay matrix Phytopathology 75,774-777 27. Cartwrtght, K. D and Benson, D M (1995) Optimization of biological control of Rhizoctoma stem rot of Pomsetta by Paecllomyces ldaclnus and Pseudomans cepacla. Plant Dzs 79, 30 l-308 28 King, E B and Parke, J. L (1993) Btocontrol of Aphanomyces loot rot and Pythzum damping-off by Pseudomonas cepacza. Plant Dls 77, 1185-l 188 29 Lumsden, R. D , Garcia, E R., Lewis, J A., and Frtas, T G. A (1987) Suppression of damping-off caused by Pythzum spp m soil from the indigenous Mexican Chmampa agricultural system. Soul Bzol. Blochem 19, 50 l-508 30. McLaughlin, T. J , Quinn, J P., Betterman, A., and Bookland, R. (1992) Pseudomonascepacla suppression of sunflower wilt fungus and role of antifungal compounds m controlling dtsease. Appl Envzron. Mlcroblol 58, 1760-l 763 3 1, Renato-de-Frettas, J and Germida, J. J. (1991) Pseudomonas cepacla and Pseudomonasputlda as winter wheat inoculants for btocontrol of Rhzzoctonla solam Can J Mlcroblol 37,780-784.
114
Hebbar and Lumsden
32 Reddy, M S., Funk, L M , He, D N , and Pedersen, E A (1996) Status on commerclal development of Burkholderla cepacza for bIologIca control of fungal pathogens and growth enhancement of comfer seedlings for a global market, m Advances zn Bzologzcal Control of Plant Diseases (Whehhua, T , Cook, R J , and Rovira, A., eds ), Proceedings, International Workshop on BIological Control of Plant Diseases, BelJmg, May 22-27 33 Domsch, K H , Cams, W , and Anderson, T (1980) Cornpendzum of Sozl Fungi, vol 1 Academic, London 34. Farr, D F , Bills, G F , Charnuns, G P , and Rossman, A Y. (1989) Fungi on Plants and Plant Products zn the Unzted States American Phytopathologlcal Society, St Paul, MN. 35 Samuels, G J and Rehner, S A. (1993) Toward a concerpt of genus and species of Trzchoderma, m Pest Management Bzologzcally Based Technologzes (Lumsden, R D and Vaughn, J. L., eds.), American Chemical Society, Washmgton, DC, pp 186-l 88 36 Aluko, M 0 and Hering, T. F (1970) The mechamsms associated with the antagomstlc relationship between Cortzczum solanz and Glzocladzum wrens Trans Br Mycol Sot 55, 173-179 37 Howell, C R and Stlpanovlc, R D (1983) Ghovirm, a new antibtotlc for Glzocladzum wrens, and Its role m the bIologIca control of Pythzum ultrmum Can J Mzcrobzol 29, 321-324. 38 Jones, R W and Hancock, J G (1987) ConversIon of vmdm to vlrldlol by vlrldmproducing fungi Can, J Mzcrobzol 33,963-966 39 Lumsden, R D , Locke, J C., Adkms, S T , Walter, J F , and Rldout, C J (1992) Isolation and locahzatron of the antlbiotlc ghotoxm produced by Gliocladzum wrens from alginate prrll m so11and soilless media Phytopathology 82,23&235 40 Lumsden, R D , Rldout, C J , Vendemla, M E , Hamson, D J , Waters, R M , and Walter, J F (1992) Characterlzatlon of major secondary metabohtes produced m sollless mix by a formulated strain of the blocontrol fungus Glzocludzum wrens Can J Mzcrobzol 38, 1274-1280 41 Taylor, A (1986) Some aspects of the chemistry and biology of the genus Hypocrea and Its anamorphs, Trzchoderma and Glzocladzum Proc Nova Scotia Inst Scz 36,27-58 42 Roberts, D P and Lumsden, R D (1990) Effect of extracellular metabolltes from Glzocladzum wrens on germmatlon of sporangla and mycellal growth of Pythzum ultzmum Phytopathology 80,46 l-465 42a. Warmg, P , Elchner, R D , and Mulbacher, A (1988) The chemistry and biology of the unmunomodulatmg agent ghotoxm and related eprpolythlodloxoplperlzmes Med Res Rev 8,499-524 43 Mintz, A and Walter, J F (1993) A private Industry approach development of GhoGardTM for disease control m horticulture, m Pest Management Bzologzcally Bused Technologres (Lumsden, R D and Vaughn, J L , eds ), American Chemlcal Society, Washmgton, DC, pp 398-403. 44 Lumsden, R D , Locke, J C , and Walter, J F. (1991) Approval of Glzocludzum wrens by the U S Envlronmental Protectlon Agency for blologlcal control of Pythlum and Rhlzoctoma dampmg-off. Petrza 1, 138
Biolog~cai Control of Seedltng Diseases
115
45 Wtlhtte, S E., Lumsden, R D , and Straney, D. C (1994) Mutational analysts of gliotoxm productton by the biocontrol fungus Gltocladtum wrens m relation to suppression of Pythmm damping-off Phytopathology 84,816-82 1. 46 Howell, C R and Stipanovic, R. D. (1995) Mechamsms m the biocontrol of Rhtzoctonta solani-mduced cotton seedlmg disease by Gltocladtum wrens antibiosts Phytopathology 85469-472 47 Lumsden, R D., Walter, J. F., and Baker, C. P (1996) Development of G/locladtum vzrens for dampmg-off disease control Can J Plant Path01 18, 463-468. 48. Lumsden, R D. and Vaughn, J. L. (1993) Pest management’ biologically based technologies, m Proceehngs ofBeltsvtlle Symposzum XVIII, Beltsville, MD, May 2-6, American Chemtcal Soctety, Washington, DC, p. 435 49. Lumsden, R. D., Locke, J. C , Lewis, J A., Johnston, S. A , Peterson, J. L , and Rtstamo, J. B (1990) Evaluation of Gfzocladtum wrens for biocontrol of Pythmm and Rhtzoctoma dampmg-off of bedding plants at fout greenhouse locations Brol. Cult Control Tests 590 50 Beagle-Ristamo, J. E and Papavizas, G. C (1985) Biological control of rhtzoctoma stem canker and black scruf of potato Phytopathology 75, 560-564 51 Rtstamo, J B., Lewis, J. A., and Lumsden, R D. (1994) Influence of isolate of Gltocladtum vtrens on sclerotra of Sclerotwm rofin, soil mtcrobiota, and the incidence of southern blight Phytopathology 81, 1117-I 124 52 Jackson, M and Schisler, D H (1992) The composttton and attributes of Colletottwhum truncatum spores are altered by the mutational environment Appl Envtron Mtcrobtol 58,226@-2265. 53 Eyal, J., Baker, C F , Reeder, J D , Devane, W E , and Lumsden, R D (1997) Large scale productron of chlamydospores of Gltocladtum wrens strain Gl-2 1 m submerged culture. J. Zndust Mtcrobtol Brotechnol 19, 163-l 68 54 Lewis, J A and Papavizas, G. C. (1987) Application of Trtchoderma and Gllocladrum in alginate pellets for control of Rhizoctonia dampmg-off Plant Path01 36,438-446 55. Betz, F , Rispm, A , and Schneider, W (1987) Biotechnology products related to agrtculture Overview of regulatory decisions at the U S. Envnonmental Protection Agency. ACS Symposium series 334, American Chemical Society, Washington, DC, pp 3 16-327 56 (1989) Data requirements for pesticide registration; final rule. Federal Register 53, 15,952-15,999 57. Ristamo, J. B., Perry, K B., and Lumsden, R. D. (1996) So11 solarization and Gltocladtum wrens reduce the mcrdence of southern blight (sclerotrum rolfirr) m bell pepper m the field. Btocont Sci and Technol 6,583-593 58 TJamos, E. C. and Fravel, D. R. (1995) Detnmental effects of sublethal heatmg and Talaromyces flavus on microsclerotia of Verttctlltum dahltae Btol Control 85,388-392. 59 Papavtzas, G C , Lewis, J A , and Abd-El Moity, T. H (1982) Evaluation of new biotypes of Trtchoderma harztanum for tolerance to benomyl and enhanced biocontrol capabilities. Phytopathology 72, 126-132
116
Uebbar and Lumsden
60 Postma, J and Luttrkholt, A. J. G (1993) Selectton of benomyl-resrstant Fusarcum tsolates for ecologrcal studies on biological control of Fusarzum welt of carnation Neth J Plant Path01 99, 175-188 61 Burkhead, K D , Schtsler, D A , and Slmmger, P J (1994) Pyrrolmtrm productron by biologtcal control agent Pseudomonas cepacla B37w m culture and colomzed wounds of potatoes Appl Envwon hkcroblol 60,203 I-2039 62. Frrdlender, M Inbar, J., and Chet, I (1993) Btologrcal control of soilborne plant pathogens by beta-l ,3-glucanase-producing Pseudomonas cepacra. So11Bzol 63 Mao, W., Lewis, J A, Hebbar, K. P , and Lumsden, R D. (1997) Seed treatment with a fungal or a bacterral antagomst for reducmg corn dampmg-off caused by species of Pythzum and Fusarwm Plant Dis 81,450-454.Blochem 25, 1211-1221.
Joint Action of Microbials Claude Alabouvette
for Disease Control
and Philippe Lemanceau
1. Introduction
During the past 20 yr, more attention than ever has been given to the development of btological methods to control plant diseases.Indeed, the concern for food of high quality, wtthout residues of pesticides, and for a sustainable agrtculture that will preserve the fertthty of soil, and prevent the pollutton of the environment, has stimulated research dealmg with btological control At the same ttme, progress made m molecular technology has provided tools to study the modes of action of btocontrol agents. It 1snow possible to understand the mechanisms by which an antagonist can hmtt either the density or the activity of the target pathogen, and can induce resistance of the host plant. This knowledge should help to identify the environmental condmons favorable for application of biocontrol, and improve efficiency and consistency of biocontrol methods. Until now, practical apphcatton of btological control has been limited to a very few commerctal products effective against a limited number of pathogens in a few crops. One strategy to make biological control successful would be to associate in a single product several btological control agents having complementary or even synergistic modes of action against the same pathogen, or having antagonistic effects on several pathogens affecting the same crop. Usually, biological control agents have been selected for their efficacy toward a given pathogen, and therefore have a limited spectrum of targets. This target specificity is a disadvantage for practtcal use of these biocontrol agents, smce they have to be compattble with the pesttctdes required to control other pests and diseases affecting the same crop. An associatton of mtcroorganisms able to control several diseaseswill represent a great advantage for practical application of biological control Association of several microorganisms in a single product would also improve the consistency of the control. Indeed, btologtcal From Methods m Biotechnology, vol 5 B/opeshodes Use and Debvery Edlted by F R Hall and J J Menn 0 Humana Press Inc , Totowa, NJ
717
118
Alabouvette and Lemanceau
control IS often considered as less conststent than chemtcal control. Even tf It IS not always true, one must admit that brologrcal control 1smore dependent on envtronmental factors than chemical control. The idea to utthze combmatrons of antagomsttc mtcroorgamsms came from the study of soulsthat are naturally suppressive to diseasesinduced by sotlborne plant pathogens. Indeed, the control provided by the complex mteractrons responsible for sot1suppresslveness 1salways more consistent and stable with time than the control provided by a gtven strain of antagomstrc mtcroorgamsm, Isolated from the suppresstve so11 and mvolved m the mechanisms of suppressron. In this chapter dealing with Joint action of mtcrobtals for disease control, the first part will be dedrcated to a summary of knowledge resulting from the study of soils suppressive to fusarmm w&s, m order to show the great complextty of mechanisms responsible for consrstent control of a disease The chref modes of action by which antagomsttc mtcroorgamsms control diseases~111be presented m the second part Then, examples of the beneficial effects of assoclatton of several mtcroorgamsms having different modes of action will be presented, before dtscussmg prospects for then application as blologtcal control products, 2. An Example of Joint Action of Microbials: Soils Naturally Suppressive to Fusarium Wilts Suppressive soils are soils m which diseaseincidence or diseaseseventy remams low despite the presenceof the pathogenand environmental conditions favorable to diseaseexpressionon a susceptiblevartety of hostplant. Soils suppressiveto someof the most tmportantdiseasescausedby sotlbomeplant pathogenshave beendescribed, mdrcatmgthat so11suppresstvenessISnot a rare phenomenon(Z-3). Among the bestknown examples are soils suppressive to msarium wilts. The study of these ~011s demonstrated clearly that suppresstvenessIS based on mteractronsamong several mtcroorgamsmshaving different modesof action and acting togetherto conststently control the disease.The followmg summary of studiesdealing with soils suppressive to fusarrum weltswill not only illustrate the complex@ of mechanismsmvolved, but also the dtfficulty m reproducing sucha phenomenonby mtroducing selectedstrains of antagomsttcrmcroorgamsm m a conducive sot1 The first reports of fusartum-wilt-suppressive soils were made by Stover (4) m Central America, where banana planted m soils having a high content m Montmortllomte-type clays were less affected by the Panama disease than banana planted m solIs from another type Later, Smith andSnyder(5,6), studymg a suppressive sot1from California, made the observatton that thts so11was rich m Fusarium oxysporum, leading Toussoun (7) to state that soils suppressive to fusarmm wilts induced by pathogenic F oxysporum harbor high levels of saprophytrc fusarra. But It was still unclear whether so11suppressrveness was linked to sot1ablotrc characterrsttcs or to the sot1mtcroflora. Louvet et al.
Joint Action of Microbia/s
119
(8) were the first to establish the microbial nature of soil suppressiveness to fusarium wilts They demonstrated that suppressiveness disappears after heat treatments that destroy most of the microorgamsms, and is restored by mtroducmg a small proportion of the suppressive soil mto the heat-disinfested suppressive soil. It was also possible to make a conducive soil suppressive by mixmg 10 p 100 of suppressive soil in it. This global transfer of suppressiveness is achieved by the introduction of a sample of suppressive microflora mto the conducive soil. To determine the role of each population constitutmg the mixture, Rouxel et al. (9) isolated different types of microorgamsms from the suppressive soil and reintroduced them mto the heat-treated soil. Results showed that nonpathogemc F oxysporum and Fusarwn solam wet e involved m the mechanisms of soil suppressiveness, but the mechanisms by which the soils suppress disease remam obscure. Constdermg that addition of glucose to the suppressive soil made it conducive and stimulated the germination of chlamydospores of F oxysporum, Alabouvette et al (10) suggested that competition for carbon (C) could be one of the mechanisms by which soils suppress fusartum wilts. Alabouvette et al. (22) also demonstrated that the microbial biomass was greater and more responsive to glucose amendment m a suppressive than in a conducive soil, and concluded that both the general suppression caused by the activity of the total biomass of the soil and the specific suppression caused by the activity of the nonpathogemc Fusana were responsible for the suppressiveness of the soils from the Chlteaurenard area (12) At the same time, Kloepper et al. (13), studying the role of the populations of fluorescent pseudomonads m the rhizosphere of plant, suggested that they could contribute to control diseases.Following the same track, Scher and Baker (14,15) established that either a fluorescent strain of Pseudomonas sp, isolated from a suppressive soil, or its siderophore, can causea conducive soil to become suppressive to fusarmm wilts. Based on the fact that addition of a strong u-on (Fe)-chelator (EDDHA) also made a conducive soil suppressive, it was concluded that competitton for Fe was the chief mode of action of the siderophoreproducmg pseudomonads. Finally, Elad et al. (16,17), having established that the growth of germ tubes arising from chlamydospores was reduced m the presence of siderophore-producing pseudomonads, concluded that competition for Fe was the mechanism responsible for soil suppressiveness to fusarmm wilts. Almost at the same time, Schneider (18) isolated nonpathogemc strains of F. oxysporum from suppressive soils m California, and demonstrated that their addition to a conducive soil infested with F oxysporum f.sp. aplz contributed to hmttmg the severity of fusarium wilt of celery. Later, Pauhtz et al. (19) estabhshed that a Metz sandy loam from the Salmas Valley, suppressive to fusarium wilt of several crops, supported large populations of nonpathogemc F oxysporum, and suggested that they could contribute to soil suppressiveness.
120
Alabouvette and Lemanceau
Together, these data pointed clearly to the role of nonpathogemc fusarta and fluorescent pseudomonads m the suppresston of fusarmm writs m suppressive soils, and tt was necessaryto consider the role of both types of microorganisms. Park et al. (20) and Mandeel and Baker (21) considered the Joint action of nonpathogentcfusarta and fluorescent pseudomonadstn the mechanismsof suppression of t%sanumwelts,but the clearestdemonstrationof the postttve mteracttonbetween theseantagonistswas provided by Lemanceauet al. (22,23; see Subheading 4.). As demonstrated for soil suppressive to htsarium wilts, examples of sot1suppressive to other diseasesalso showed that several mtcroorganisms acting together or successively,and having different modes of action, are responsible for disease suppression.Therefore, microbtal assoctattonsmay be proposed to mimic the complex mteracttonsexisting m suppresstvesoils and achteve btological control 3. Modes of Action of Biological Control Agents To improve efficacy and consistency of btologtcal control, mtcrobtal assoclattons can be proposed However, the btocontrol agents have to be chosen m conJunctton with then modes of actton, whtch should not exclude each other, but, on the contrary, show a complementary or even a synergistic effect. Diseasecontrol may result from a dtrect antagontsmdirected against the pathogen,especiallydunng its saprophyttcgrowth phase,or from an indirect action through induced reststanceof the hostplant. The chief modes of action by whtch antagomsttc mtcroorgarusmscould control diseaseswill be reviewed quickly, keeping m mind that a smgle stramof btocontrol agent may expressseveral modes of actions. 3.1. Microbial
Antagonism
Mtcrobial antagonism implies direct interactions between two mtcroorgantsms that share the same ecologtcal niche. Three mam types of direct mteracttons may be characterrzed: parasitism, competition for nutrtents, and anttbiosts. These mteractions are not exclustve of each other; on the contrary, a gtven strain may possessseveral modes of actions, and tt IS often difficult to dtstmgutsh the relative tmportance of each of them m the efficiency of the observed antagomsm. Microbial antagonism occurs mostly during the saprophyttc phase of plant pathogens, and contributes to reducing the moculum density and/or the saprophyttc growth of the pathogen in the so11and at the root surface, resultmg in a decrease of the probabthty for the pathogen to achieve successful mfecttons of the host plant. 3.1.1. Parasitism Parasitism of plant pathogen by other mtcroorgantsms, including vnuses, IS a well-distributed phenomenon, but its significance in relation to btological control of plant diseases 1sstill controverstal.
Joint Action of Microbials
121
Many fungi contam vu-uses or vu-us-hke particles, and m a few cases this parasitism has been associated with reduced virulence of the pathogen. The best example ISthat of Cryphonectria parasitica, hypovirulent strains of which are being used as blologlcal control agents m several countries (24). Mycoparasltes, such as Conzothyrzum minitans and Sporldesmium sclerotlvorum, have been tested as blocontrol agents, and some of them are efficient in controlling diseases caused by Sclerotuzla spp and other sclerotiaforming fungi (25,26). The parasitic activity of strains of Trzchoderma sp has been extensively studled, and plays a major role in the antagonism expressed against Rhzzoctonza solani (27). But discrlmmation between parasitism and other modes of action 1sdifficult to establish, since cell-wall-degrading enzymes, such as chltinases and glucanases, are mvolved m the process of parasitism. Most strams of Trlchoderma spp possessseveral modes of action contributing to their blocontrol activity (28). Whether parasitism is one mode of action that can be deliberately associated with other modes of action to improve efficacy of blologlcal control has not yet been investigated. 3.1.2. Competition for Nutrients Because so11IS an ohgotrophic milieu, and because so11microorganisms and plant pathogens are heterotrophic, competition for C and energy IS strongly expressed m SOIL 3 1.2.1
COMPETITION
FOR CARBON
As already stated (see above), competltlon for C IS one of the mechanisms responsible for so11suppresslveness to fusarmm wilts. Competltlon for C IS expressed m every soil, and ISconsidered responsible for the well-known phenomenon of funglstasls, which describes the mhlbltlon of fungal spore germlnation m soil (29,30). Energy deprivation in sol1 is also partly responsible for “general suppression of a pathogen that is directly related to the total amount of mlcrobiologlcal activity at a time critical to the pathogen” (2). This general suppression results from the combined activity of several microbial populations, and, even if the mechanisms are not clearly understood, application of mlcroblal assoclatlons will increase the intensity of competltlon for nutrients. Any specific antagonism IS expressed on this background of general suppression, and any blocontrol agent apphed to sol1 will be submitted to soil fungistasis. Some species or strains of antagonists are more competltlve than others, and should be selected for biological control. For example, Couteaudler and Alabouvette (31) have shown that a great diversity exists among strains of nonpathogemc F. oxysporum in relation to their ability to utilize C efficiently. A slgmficant correlation was established between the ability of several strains
122
Alabouvette and Lemanceau
of nonpathogemc F oxysporum to mhrbtt the germmatron of the pathogen m the rhlzosphere, reduce drseaseIncidence of fusartum writ of flax, and compete efficiently for C, with the pathogenic F oxysporum m sot1 (32). Competitton for C has also been involved in the determtmsm of the antagonism expressed by different strains of Trcchoderma sp against several plant pathogens, especially F. oxysporum (33). 3.1 2.2. COMPETITION FOR MINOR ELEMENTS
Competttion for minor elements also frequently occurs m so11 As already stated (see above), competmon for Fe 1sone of the modes of action by whtch fluorescent pseudomonads hmtt the growth of pathogenic fungi and reduce disease incidence or severity. Under conditions of Fe stress,these bacteria synthesize stderophores, called pseudobactms or pyoverdms, which show a higher affinity for Fe3+than fungal srderophores. Numerous studies have associated the bacterial antagonism to pseudobactm synthesis, and several review papers are available (34-3 7). Other micronutrtents (Cu, Mn, Zn) also play a role in controllmg diseases induced by soilborne pathogens. Then- mode of action is not clearly established, but they contribute to some extent to sot1suppresstveness (38). The most important point to stress 1sthat competrtton for a given nutrient IS not exclusive from competmon for another nutrient, and, therefore, assoctatron of two antagomsttc mtcroorgamsms competing with the pathogen for two dtfferent nutrients may result m an increased efficacy of biocontrol. Moreover, competttton for nutrients 1snot exclusive from other modes of action, and may play an important role m the effictency of a btocontrol agent, even tf another mode of action has been investigated 3.1.3. Antibiosis Antrbtosts is the antagonism resulting from the production by one mtcroorgamsm of secondary metabolites toxic for another mrcroorganism. Antrbrosis 1sa very common phenomenon responsible for the btocontrol activity of many organisms, such as Pseudomonas spp, Bacillus spp, or Trlchoderma spp developed as btocontrol agents. A variety of different anttbtottcs, bactertocms, enzymes, and volatile compounds have been described, and are Involved m the suppressron of different pathogens. Several review articles are available (39-42). A given strain of brocontrol agent may produce several types of antifungal compounds, effective against certain species of fungal pathogens. For example, the production by fluorescent Pseudomonas sp of phenazmes and 2-4-dtacetylphloroglucmol was shown to be the prrmary mode of antagonism agamst Gaeumannomyces gramznzs var. triticz (43-45), but 2-4-dtacetylphloroglucmol and cyanide were
Joint Action
of Microbials
123
mvolved in the antagonism expressed against Chalura elegans (44,46,47). On the contrary, these secondary metabolites have not yet been implicated m the inhibition of the growth or activity of F oxysporum (37). Since a given strain often produces several of these metabolites, the best procedure to demonstrate the involvement of a given molecule in the antagonistic activity of the biocontrol agent is to produce mutants affected m their ability to synthesize the molecule, and to demonstrate that the deficient mutant is no more able to control the disease (41). But it is important to emphasize that a single antifungal metabohte generally does not account for all the antagomstic activity of a biocontrol agent (40). Therefore, it may be very useful to associate several strains of btocontrol agents producing different types of antifungal metabolites, to improve the efficacy or enlarge the acttvity spectrum of biological control. 3.2. Induced Systemic Resistance More and more studies are devoted to the resistance induced m the host plant by apphcatton of btocontrol agents. Induced systemic resistance classically occurs when an inducing agent is applied prior to challenge maculation with a pathogen, resulting in reduced diseasem compartson to the nomnoculated control. Kuc et al. (48) reported systemic protection of cucumber against Colletotricum orbzculare when the cotyledons or the first leaves of the plant were premoculated with the same pathogen. It has also been well established that the premoculatton of an host plant with an incompatibleforma speczalzs or race of F oxysporum will result in reduced disease severity when the plant IS moculated with the compatible pathogen (49). Therefore, it was suggested that the nonpathogemc fusaria used to control fusarium welts may be effective through induced resistance (22). Using one experimental design wtth a split-root system, which allowed application of the biocontrol agent on one side and the pathogen on the other side, Ohvam et al. (50) demonstrated that mduced systemic resistance contributes to the biocontrol efficacy of a nonpathogemc strain of F oxysporum The fluorescent pseudomonads, selected for their plant-growth-promotmg capacity or for their biocontrol activity, have been shown to induce systemic resistance in the plant (51). The first evidence was given by Van Peer et al. (52), who demonstrated that root colomzation of carnation by a stram of fluorescent Pseudomonas sp resulted in an accelerated and increased accumulation of phytoalexms m the stem of carnation after moculatton with F oxysporum f.sp. dianthl. Many other biocontrol agents are able to induce resistance m the host plant, and several recent review papers are available (48,51,53). Induced resistance is not exclusive from other modes of action, and may exert a complementary
124
Alabouvette and Lemanceau
effect to microbial antagonism. Indeed, direct antagonism usually limits the saprophytic growth of the pathogen, resulting m a decreased number of infection sites, and induced resistance ltmrts the growth of the pathogen during its parasitic phase inside the plant. Because the control resulting from an associatton of several modes of action is generally more effective and consistent than the control provided by a single mode of action, it would be interesting to associate several modes of action m combmmg several microorgamsms for biologrcal control. 4. Associations of Microorganisms for Biological Control and Growth Promotion 4.7. Microbial Associations for Biological Control One of the best-documented examples of a microbial associatton used to improve efficacy and consistency of btological control is provided by the association of strains of nonpathogemc F. oxysporum with strains of fluorescent Pseudomonas spp, tsolated from soils suppressive to fusartum wilts. From a theoretical point of vrew, competition for C between pathogemc and nonpathogemc F oxysporum, the existence of which has been demonstrated in the suppressive soils from Chiteaurenard, was not contradictory with the existence of competmon for Fe, as demonstrated m the suppressive soils from the Salinas Valley. Therefore, considering the two hypotheses, Lemanceau et al (54) established that both competition for C and competmon for Fe drd exist m the suppressive soils from Chateaurenard, even if the populatrons of fluorescent Pseudomonas spp isolated from the suppressive soil were not more competitive for Fe than the populations isolated from a conductve sot1 (54). Addition of C with EDDHA in a conducive soil resulted m an intermediate level of receptivity between the htgh conduciveness observed after addition of C and strong suppressiveness after addition of EDDHA (55). These observations prompted the hypothesis of a complementary effect of nonpathogemc F oxysporum with fluorescent Pseudomonas spp. Indeed, followmg a specific screening procedure, Lemanceau and Alabouvette (56) isolated from the suppressive soil strains of fluorescent Pseudomonas spp able to improve the efficacy of biological control achieved by the application of a strain of nonpathogemc F oxysporum. Park et al. (2U), followmg another approach, also showed that interactions between Pseudamonasputzda and strains of nonpathogemc F. oxysporum could achieve biocontrol of fusarmm wilts. The mechanisms of this beneficial mteraction remained obscure until Lemanceau et al (22,23), using a siderophore-deficient mutant ofP putzda strain WCS358, demonstrated that competition for Fe resulting from the activity of the bacterial strain enhanced the efficacy of competition for C between strains of F. oxysporum. Indeed, the growth yield of a stram of F oxysporum growmg on a single source
Joint Action
of Microbials
725
of C was greatly reduced m the presence of the bacterial siderophore pseudobactm 358. Moreover, it was shown that the nonpathogemc strain Fo47 was less sensitive to pseudobactm-mediated Fe competition than the pathogenic F. ox~~~orurn f.sp. dzanthi strain WCS816. These data together demonstrated that competition for Fe, resultmg from stderophore production by Pseudomonas spp renders more severe competrtton for C, resulting from the activtty of both the total biomass and the nonpathogenic F oxysporum. These mechanisms, which exist in naturally suppressive souls,may be used to achieve biological control of fusarium wilts by introduction of selectedstrams of nonpathogemc F oxysporum associated with fluorescent Pseudomonas spp mto conducive substrates. Several experiments carried out under commercial-type conditions have demonstrated the validity of such an approach. The control provided by the association of the nonpathogemc F oxysporum strain Fo47 with the P fluorescens strain C7 was always better and more consistent than the control achieved by either one or the other biocontrol agent (56,57). Fungi other than F. oxysporum can be associated to fluorescent Pseudomonas spp to achieve biological control of fusarium wilts. Coinoculation m pot bioassays ofAcremomum rutdum and Verticillium lecanil with different strams of Pseudomonas spp, significantly suppressed disease,compared with the control treatment, if the microorganisms were applied m moculum densities that were ineffective m suppressmg disease as separate inocula (58). Nonpathogemc strains of F. oxysporum have also been associated with other bacteria, such as Bacillus sp, but, rn the case of fusarium wilt of chickpea, the association of a strain of Baczllus sp did not improve the control achieved by a strain of nonpathogenic F. oxysporum (59). Other microbial associations, such as Trichoderma spp with Pseudomonas spp have also been studied to improve efficacy of biological control, but the results were often contradictory and ~111be discussed below (see Subheading 5.). On the contrary, several studies have demonstrated that association of bacteria with mycorrhizal fungi have a beneficial effect on plant growth. 4.2. Microbial Associations for Plant Growth Promotion The roots of most terrestrtal plants are inhabited by symbiotic fungi forming specialized structures known as mycorrhizas. Based on the mteractions established between the fungus and the plant root, two mam types of mycorrhtzas are distmguished: the ectomycorrhizas and the vesicular-arbuscular mycorrhizas.In both cases,the association between the fungus and the root occurs m the soil, and therefore can be influenced by other soilborne microorganisms Recently, some beneficial associations have been described. A recent review by Garbaye (60) shows how the symbiotic establishment of mycorrhizal fungi on plant roots is affected in various ways by the other micro-
126
Alabouvette
and Lemanceau
organtsms of the rhtzosphere Some bacteria, mostly fluorescent pseudomonads, consistently promote mycorrhtzal development. These bacteria have been called mycorrhizatton helper bacteria (MHBs) Several modes of action have been proposed to explain these postttve mteractions between bacteria and a mycorrhtzal fungus: The bactermm prohferatmg tn the rhizosphere before any mvolvement of the symbtottc fungus improves the recepttvity of the root to the mycorrhrzal formation; the bacterium interferes with the plant fungus recogmtion mechamsms, which are the first steps of the mteractton process leadmg to the symbtosts, the bacterium helps the growth of the fungus in its saprophytic stage in the rhizosphere, or on the root surface; the metabolic activtty of the bacterium multtplymg m the rhtzosphere modifies the physicochemical properties of the soil m a way to facilitate mycorrhizal mfectton, the bacterium triggers and accelerates the germination of the spores or other dormant propagules specialized m the conservation of the fungus m the soil. Whatever the mechanism, the use of helper bacteria as an adjuvant of fungal moculum is considered m order to improve mycorrhtzatton of trees There are also several papers reporting the synergtsttc effect of the association of VA-mycorrhiza with nitrogen (N)-fixing bacteria For example, Azcon et al. (61) described selecttve interacttons between different species of mycorrhizal fungi and strains of Rhizoblum meliloti apphed to Medzcago satwa. Depending on the combmatton of strains tested, there was a significant increase of the concentration and/or content of N m the shoots. This increase may be a consequence of a phosphorus-mediated sttmulation of N-fixation by VA-mycorrhiza, but m other cases the increase m mtrogen content seems to reflect a VA-mycorrhtzal-mediated enhancement of N uptake from the soil. In another example, Paula et al. (62) reported synergistic effects of VA-mycorrhtzal fungi and drazotrophtc bacteria on nutrition and growth of sweet potato Tuber production and N and phosphorus accumulatton were increased when diazotrophtc bacteria were applied together with VA-mycorrhtza-fungal spores. Thts beneficial effect seems to be caused by an enhanced mycorrhization of the plant in the presence of the bacteria. These few examples show that assoctatton of several mtcroorgamsms IS not only useful for biocontrol of plant drseases, but tt may also contribute to enhance plant growth.
5. Use of Microbial Associations for Biological Control: Prospects and Constraints Although experiments conducted under commerctal-like condtttons have shown great mterest m using microbtal assoctations to improve efficacy and consistency of btological control, practical appltcations of these mixtures need
Joint Action
of Microbials
127
further mvestlgatlon. It 1s first necessary to evaluate the compatlbilrty of the microorganisms under various envlronmental condltlons, and, second to develop production and formulation processes leading to a commercial product easy to handle and apply. 5.1. Compatibility
Between Microorganisms
To show an additive effect, the mlcroorgamsms to be associated must be fully compatible. They must establish together m the rhlzosphere of the host plant, without excluding each other by competltlon or antiblosls. This compatlblllty may be influenced by environmental condltlons, as shown by the contrasting data resulting from the assoclatton between strains of Trzchoderma spp with fluorescent pseudomonads Dandurand and Knusden (63) failed to demonstrate any beneficial effect of the associatlon of a strain of Pseudomonasfluorescens with a strain of Trlchoderma harzzanum m controllmg Aphanomyces root rot of peas, although the presence of the bacteria stimulated the hyphal growth of the fungus orlgmatmg from the coated pea seeds. Hubbard et al (64) reported that a strain of Trzchoderma hamatum applied as comdla to pea seedswas effective in controllmg seed rots caused by Pythzum spp in some soils, but not m other soils. This failure was a result of the antagonism exerted by fluorescent pseudomonads that colomze seed coats and lyse germlmgs of T hamatum on treated seeds This antagonism between fluorescent pseudomonads and T. hamatum was controlled by Fe avallabihty m the soil, and addition of ferrous oxalate to soil permitted T hamatum to protect pea seeds. In vitro experiments confirmed that extracellular compounds produced by fluorescent pseudomonads, under condltlons of Fe deprivation, were responsible for mhlbltlon of T hamatum, and suggested that pseudomonads mhlblt T hamatum through the production of slderophores. Studying the interactions between fluorescent pseudomonads and VA mycorrhlzal fungi, Pauhtz and Lmdermann (65) failed to show any beneficial effect of the VA mycorrhizal fungi on the population density and activity of the fluorescent pseudomonads. The mteractlons depend both on the fungal species and the bacterial strain. The population density of the bacteria was lower m the rhizosphere of cucumber roots colonized by Globus intraradices than m nonmycorrhizal plants. But this difference was not detected when the mycorrhizal fungus was Globus etunacatum. If some strains of fluorescent pseudomonads delayed the germination of G etunicatum spores, none of the bacterial strains affected the colomzation of cucumber roots by the mycorrhlzal fungus These results show how complex and specific are the mteractlons between several strains of microorganisms benelklal for plant growth. It is therefore impossible to draw any general conclusion.
128
Alabouvette and Lemanceau
Havmg selected mdependently, two efficient microorgamsms do not guarantee that their association will result m an increased beneficial effect. The best approach to create effective combinattons of beneficial microorganisms IS to isolate the candidate microorgamsms from the same ecological niche, and to develop specific screening procedures. For example, the nonpathogemc F. oxysporum strain Fo47 and the P jluorescens strain C7 have been isolated from the same suppressive soil, and then selection has been conducted in a biotest m which the two mtcroorgamsms have been confronted alone or together to the host plant and its pathogen (56). Only 8% of the bacterial strains associated with Fo47 increased the biocontrol capacity of the nonpathogemc F oxysporum. Then their compatibihty has been studied under various environmental conditions, m soil and m rockwool, m the rhizosphere of different plant species (66). Moreover, it has been established that the nonpathogemc F oxysporum strain Fo47 was much lesssusceptibleto the pseudobactm produced by a strain of P.Juorescens than a strain of F. oxysporunzf.sp. dzanthi (23). More attention should be given to the natural associations of microorganisms m order to select antagonists that could be used m combmations.
5.2. Development of Microbial Products Development of microbial products based on association of microorgamsms has not yet been achieved Obviously, the microorganisms will have to be produced separately by liquid or solid-state fermentation, but the question is whether they can be mixed m a single formulation, or have to be formulated and stored separately, to be mixed at the moment of application. Fermentation and formulation processes represent important steps in the development of a biocontrol product. Indeed, not only should a high biomass be produced at the lowest cost, but the properties of this biomass, i.e., tts capacity to control the disease, must be conserved during the processing and the storage Several review papers are available that discuss the principal requirements for producmg and formulatmg an active biomass (67,68). Obvtously conditions of production and formulation are different for fungi and bacteria, but, even for the same species, the results may differ from one strain to another. For example, Hebbar et al. (69) showed that the proportton of comdia vs chlamydospores of F oxysporum erythoxzll, used to control coca, varies according to the composition of the growth medium, and, for the same medium, varies from one strain of F oxysporum to another Formulatton of mtcroorgatnsms as seed coating requires spectfic conditions to preserve the viability of the microorgamsms, and to enable then growth in accordance with seed germmatton. The water activity 1san important factor to control, and it would be difficult to determine conditions favorable to the survival of a mixture of bacteria and fungi at the seed surface.
Joint Action
of Microbials
129
At the present time, cultures grown in hydroponics on artificial substratum (rockwool) represent an unique opportunity to apply microbial associations. In hydroponics, the microorganisms can be applied through the drip irrigation system, as a mixture, or successively, and repeated applications can easily be done. Microbial associations can also easily be applied to potting mixtures. It 1spossible to mtx each microorgamsm with one of the constituents of the mixture, and to use this organic matter as the support of the microorgamsms Peat and bran-peat mixtures are classically used to grow microorganisms, such as Trzchoderma and Glzocladzum, and peat is also used as a vector to apply Bradyrhizobium to seeds (70). This strategy is presently used m this laboratory to prepare a substratum, enriched with growth-promotmg microorganisms, to improve the successof acclimatation of vitro plants. The last step before commercial use of such microbial mixtures will be registration, and one must admit that it would probably be more difficult to prove the mocuity of a mixture than that of a single strain of microorganism. Today, there is no example of commerctal application of a biocontrol product assoctatmg several strains of antagonistic microorganisms.
5.3. Association of Several Modes of Action in a Single Strain Recently, another approach has been proposed to make biological control more successful. Rather than associatmg several strains of biological control agents m a single product, it has been proposed to associate several modes of action in a single strain of biocontrol microorganism. Accordmg to Roberts (71), three strategies can be followed to enhance the btocontrol performance of a bacterial strain through genetic engineering: adding biocontrol traits to bacterial biocontrol agents, modifying the regulation of expression of traits important to biocontrol, and enhancing the stability of the biocontrol activity. Several papers report attempts to associatein a given strain 0fP jluorescens or P. putzda the capacity to produce several of the secondary metabolites havmg antifungal properties. The mtroduction of DNA encoding the synthesis of an antagonistic metabolite m a nonproducmg strain usually resulted in an increased disease suppression by the transformed strain, in comparison with the parental strain. For example, insertion of the locus responsible for the synthesis of 2,4-dtacetylphloroglucmol mto nonproducer strains resulted m synthesis of phloroglucinol and increased mhibition of G. gramznzs var trztzcz and R. solani m vitro (43). The strain P3 of P j’haorescens had only a slight activity in controlling black root rot of tobacco, but the recombinant with cyanide-encoding genes from the strain CHAO showed an increased btocontrol activity (46).
130
AlabouvetteandLemanceau
Having demonstrated the synergistic effect of the assoctatton of two chttmolytic enzymes from T. harzzanum with cells of Enterobacter cloacae on the mhtbttion of spore germmatton of several pathogenic fungi, Lorito et al. (72) suggested transformmg the bacteria with the fungal genes encoding cellwall-degrading enzymes to improve the efficacy of those btocontrol bacteria. Today, the large possibilities offered by genetic engineering stimulate this type of research dealmg with improved strains for btological control. However, before practical application of these strains, many problems have to be solved and the successof this strategy will also depend on the acceptance by the public of the use of transgemc mtcroorganisms. 6. Conclusion Biological control of plant diseases,especially of plant diseasesinduced by soilborne pathogens, is presently restricted to a ltmtted number of commerctal preparations based on a single antagonistic microorganism Most, if not all, of the biocontrol agents control plant pathogens through several modes of action, havmg a complementary beneficial effect. Since a single antagonist does not possessall the possible modes of action, tt would be very Interesting to assoctate several antagonists, to improve efficacy and consistency of btologtcal control. Indeed, m compartson to biological control based on the application of a smgle microorgamsm, natural control of diseases,such as control provided by suppressive soils, appears complex, always involving several microorganisms, and several mechanisms. It seems possible to conclude that the more complex are the mteracttons, the better is the control achieved by the microorgamsms. However, this brief review of the literature shows that there are only a few examples of potential uses of microbial associations for biological control, or for promoting plant growth. Indeed, the selection of compattble antagonists requires a good knowledge of the modes of action of the antagomsts,and also of their ecological behavtor m different soils and m the rhizosphere of several plant species. Much more research 1sneeded before a mixture of beneficial microorganisms will be put on the market. However, as stressed above, there are a few specific niches, such as potting mixes and hydropomcs, m which apphcatton of mtcrobtal associations should be possible m the near future References 1 Baker, K F. and Cook, R J , eds (1974) Biological Control of Plant Pathogens American PhytopathologySociety,St Paul, MN 2 Cook, R J and Baker, K. F., eds (1983) Nature and Practice ofBlologwa1 Control of Plant Pathogens American PhytopathologySociety,St Paul, MN 3 Schneider,R W., ed (1982) Suppresswe Sods and Plant Disease American Phytopathology Society,St Paul, MN
Joint
Action
of Microbials
131
4 Stover, R H (1962) Fusarial wilt (Panama disease) of bananas and other Musa species CMI Phytopathol Pap 4, 117 p. 5 Smith, S N and Snyder, W C (1971) Relattonshtp of moculum density and soil types to severtty of fusarmm wilt of sweet potato Phytopathology 61,1049-l 05 1 6. Smith, S N and Snyder, W. C. (1972) Germination of Fusarzum oxysporum chlamydospores m soils favorable and unfavorable to wilt estabhshment Phytopathology 62,273-277 7 Toussoun, T A. (1975) Fusarmm-suppressive soils, m Bzology and Control of So&Borne Plant Pathogens (Brnehl, G. W , ed.), American Phytopathology Society, St Paul, MN, pp 145-15 1 8 Louvet, J , Rouxel, F., and Alabouvette, C. (1976) Recherches sur la resistance des sols aux maladies I-Mise en evidence de la nature microbtologtque de la resistance d’un sol au developpement de la fusartose vasculaire du melon. Ann. Phytopathol 8,425-436 9 Rouxel, F , Alabouvette, C , and Louvet, J. (1979) Recherches sur la r&stance des sols aux maladies IV-Muse en Cvtdence du role des Fusarzum autochtones dans la reststance d’un sol a la Fusariose vasculane du Melon. Ann Phytopathol 11, 199-207. 10. Alabouvette, C., Couteaudler, Y , and Louvet, J. (1985) Recherches sur la reststance des sols aux maladies XI-Etude comparative du comportement des Fusarzum spp dans un sol resistant et un sol sensible aux fusartoses vasculaires enrrchis en glucose. Agronomte 5,63-68. 11 Alabouvette, C , Couteaudier, Y., and Louvet, J (1985) Recherches sur la resistance des sols aux maladies XII-Acttvtte resptratotre dans un sol resistant et un sol sensible aux fusarloses vasculaires enrichis en glucose Agronomze 5,69-72 12. Alabouvette, C., Couteaudter, Y , and Louvet, J. (1985) Soils suppresstve to Fusarmm wilt mechanisms and management of suppressiveness, m Ecology and Management of Soil Borne Plant Pathogens (Parker, C A , Rovtra, A D., Moore, K. J., Wong, P. T. W , and Kollmorgen, J. F., eds ), American Phytopathology Society, St. Paul, MN, pp. 101-106. 13 Kloepper, J W , Leong, J , Temtze, M , and Schroth, M N. (1980) Pseudomonas stderophores a mechamsm explaining disease-suppressive soils Cur-r Mtcrobtol 4,3 17-320 14 Scher, F. M and Baker, R. (1980) Mechanism of biological control m a Fusarmmsuppressive soil Phytopathology 70,4 1224 17. 15. Scher, F. M and Baker, R (1982) Effect of Pseudomonasputtda and a synthetic iron chelator on mductton of so11suppresstveness to Fusarmm wilt pathogens Phytopathology 72, 1567-l 573. 16. Elad, Y. and Baker, R. (1985) Influence oftrace amounts of cattons and stderophoreproducing pseudomonads on chlamydospore germination of Fusartum oxysporum. Phytopathology 75, 1047-1052. 17. Elad, Y and Baker, R (1985) The role of competition for iron and carbon m suppression of chlamydospore germination of Fusartum spp by Pseudomonas spp. Phytopathology 75, 1053-l 059
132
Alabouvette and Lemanceau
18 Schneider, R. W (1984) Effects of nonpathogemc strams of Fusarrum oxysporum on celery root mfectlon by F oxysporum f. sp apll and a novel use of the lmeweaver-burk double reciprocal plot technique Phytopathology 74, 646-653 19. Pauhtz, T. C., Park, C S , and Baker, R (1987) BiologIcal control of Fusarmm wilt of cucumber with nonpathogemc isolates of Fusarlum oxysporum Can J Mzcrobzol 33,349-353 20 Park, C S , Pauhtz, T C , and Baker, R (1988) Blocontrol of fusarmm wilt of cucumber resulting from mteractlon between Pseudomonasputlda and nonpathogemc Isolates of Fusarlum oxysporum. Phytopathology 78, 190-l 94 21 Mandeel, Q. and Baker, R (1991) Mechamsms involved m blologlcal control of fusarmm wilt of cucumber with strains of nonpathogemc Fusarlum oxysporum Phytopathology 81,462-469 22, Lemanceau, P , Bakker, P. A. H M , De Kogel, W J , Alabouvette, C., and Schlppers, B (1992) Effect of Pseudobactm 358 production by Pseudomonas putzda WCS358 on suppression of Fusarmm wilt of carnations by nonpathogemc Fusarlum oxysporum Fo47 Appl Enwon Mlcroblol 58,2978-2982. 23 Lemanceau, P , Bakker, P A. H M , De Kogel, W J , Alabouvette, C , and Schlppers, B (1993) Antagonistic effect on nonpathogemc Fusarrum oxysporum strain Fo47 and pseudobactm 358 upon pathogenic Fusarlum oxysporum f sp dzanthz Appl. Environ Mlcrobrol 59,74-82 24 Van Alfen, N K., Jaynes, R A , Anagnostakis, S L , and Day, P R (I 975) Chestnut blight. biological control by transmissible hypovirulence m Endothla parasltlca Science 189,890,89 1 25. Adams, P B and Fravel, D R (1993) Dynamics of Spondesmwm, a naturally occurring fungal mycoparaslte, m Pest Management Bzologlcally Based Technologzes (Lumsden, R D. and Vaughn, J. L., eds ), American Chemxal Society, Washmgton, DC, pp. 189-195 26 Whlpps, J M and Lewis, D H (1980) Methodology of a chitm assay Trans Br Mycol sot 74,41&417 27 Elad, Y., Chet, I., Boyle, P , and Hems, Y. (1983) Parasitism of Trzchoderma spp on Rhlzoctoma solanr and Sclerotrum rolfsu. Scanning electron mlcroscopy and fluorescence mxroscopy Phytopathology 73,85-88 28 Lonto, M., Harman, G E., Hayes, C K., Broadway, R M , Tronsmo, A , Woo, S. L., and DI Pletro, A (1993) Chltmolytlc enzymes produced by Trrchoderma harzlanum antifungal activity of purified endochltmase and chltoblosldase Phytopathology 83, 302-307 29 Lockwood, J L (1977) Funglstasts m solIs Blol Rev 52, l-43. 30 Lockwood, J L (1988) Evolution of concepts associated with sodborne plant pathogens. Annu Rev Phytopathol 26,93-121 3 1 Couteaudler, Y and Alabouvette, C (1990) Quantitative comparison of Fusarlum oxysporum competltlveness m relation with carbon utlhzatlon FEMS Mlcroblol Ecol 74,261-268 32. Alabouvette, C. and Couteaudler, Y (1992) BiologIcal control of fusarmm wilts with nonpathogemc Fusana, m Blologzcal Control of Plant Diseases (TJamos, E C., Cook, R J , and Papavlzas, G C , eds ), Plenum, New York, pp. 415426
Joint Action
of Microbials
133
33 Sivan, A and Chet, I (1989) The posstble role of competmon between Trtchoderma harztanum and Fusarmm oxysporum on rhizosphere colonization P&opathology 79, 198-203. 34 Leong, J. (1986) Siderophores* then btochemistry and possible role m the btocontrol of plant pathogens Annu Rev Phytopathol 24, 187-209. 35 Schtppers, B., Bakker, A W , and Bakker, P A H M (1987) Interactions of deletertous and beneficial rhtzosphere mtcroorgamsms and the effect of cropping practices Ann Rev Phytopathol 25,339-358 36 Bakker, P A H M , Van Peer, R , and Schippers, B (199 1) Suppression of sonborne plant pathogens by fluorescent pseudomonads: mechanisms and prospects, m Development tn Agrtculturally Managed-Forest Ecology (Beemster, A B R , Bollen, G. J , Gerlach, M., Ruissen, M. A., Schippers, B , and Tempel, A , eds.), Elsevter, Amsterdam, pp 2 17-230. 37. Lemanceau, P. and Alabouvette, C. (1993) Suppression of msanum wilts by fluorescent pseudomonads. mechanisms and applicattons. Btocontrol Scz Technol 3,2 19-234 38. Hoeper, H. (1996) Importance of physical and chemical soil properties m the suppressiveness of soils to plant diseases Eur J Sot1 Bzol 32,41-58 39. Fravel, D. R. (1988) Role of anttbiosis in the btocontrol of plant diseases Ann Rev Phytopathol 26,75-9 1 40 Loper, J E and Lmdow, S E (1993) Roles of competmon and anttbtosts m suppression of plant diseases by bactertal brologtcal control agents, m Pest Management Biologtcally Based Technologtes (Lumsden, R. D and Vaughn, J L , eds ), American Chemical Socrety, Washington, DC, pp 144-l 55 41. Weller, D. M and Thomashow, L S. (1993) Microbial metabolttes with blological activity against plant pathogens, in Pest Management Btologically Based Technologzes (Lumsden, R D. and Vaughn, J L., eds ), American Chemical Society, Washington, DC, pp 173-l 80. 42. Alabouvette, C., Hoeper, H., Lemanceau, P., and Steinberg, C (1996) Soil suppressiveness to diseases induced by soil-borne plant-pathogens, m Sorl Bzochemistry, vol 9 (Stotzky, G. and Bollag, J. M , eds.), Marcel Dekker, New York, pp 371-413 43 Vincent, M N , Harrison, L. A., Brackm, J. M., Kovacevlch, P A , MukerJt, P , Weller, D M., and Pierson, E A (1991) Genetic analysts of the antifungal activity of a soil-borne Pseudomonas aereofactens strain Appl Environ Mtcrobtol 57,2928-2934 44. Keel, C., Schmder, U , Maurhofer, M., Votsard, C , Lavtlle, J , Burger, U , et al
(1992) Suppresston of root diseases by Pseudomonasfluorescens CHAO. Importance of the bacterial secondary metabohte 2,4-dtacetylphloroglucinol Mol PlantMtcrobe Interact. 5,413. 45 Harrtson, L , Teplow, D B , Rinaldi, M., and Strobel, G. (1991) Pseumycms, a famtly of novel pectides from Pseudomonas syrzngae possessing broad-spectrum antifungal activity J Gen Microbtol 137, 2857-2865 46. Voisard, C , Keel, C , Haas, D , and Defago, G. (1989) Cyanide productton by Pseudomonasfluorescens helps suppress black-root rot of tobacco under gnotoblottc condmons EMBO J 8, 35 l-358
134
Alabouvette and Lemanceau
47 Keel, C , Wnthner, P H , Oberhansh, T H , Volsard, C , Burger, U , Haas, D , and Defago, G (1990) Pseudomonads as antagonists of plant pathogens m the rhtzosphere role of the anttbtottc 2,4-dtacetylphloroglucmol m the suppression of black-root rot of tobacco Symbrosts 9,327-34 1 48 Kuc, J (1987) Plant tmmumzatton and its applicability for disease control, m Innovatzve Approaches to Plant Dtsease Control (Chet, I , ed ), Wiley, New York, pp 255-274 49 Btles, C L and Martyn, R D (1989) Local and systemtc reststance induced n-r watermelons by formae speciales of Fusarium oxysporum. Phytopathology 79, 856860 50 Olivam, C., Steinberg, C , and Alabouvette, C (1995) Evtdence of induced reststance m tomato inoculated by nonpathogemc strains of Fusarrum oxysporum, m Envtronmental Btottc Factors tn integrated Plant Dtsease Control (Manka, M , ed ), Polish Phytopathologrcal Society, Poznan, pp 427-430 51 Kloepper, J W , Zehnder, G. W., Tuzun, S , Murphy, J F , We], G , Yao, C., and Raupach, G (1996) Toward agrtcultural tmplementatton of PGPR-mediated induced systemic resistance against crop pests, m Advances rn Btologtcal Control ofPlant Dtseases (Tang, W., Cook, R. J., and Rovira, A , eds ), Proceedings of the International Workshop on Biologtcal Control of Plant Diseases, China Agricultural University Press, BeiJmg, May 22-27, pp. 165-174. 52 Van Peer, R , Ntemann, G J., and Schippers, B (1991) Induced resistance and phytoalexme accumulation m btologtcal control of fusarmm wilt of carnation by Pseudomonas sp strain WCS417r Phytopathology 81,728-734 53. Van Loon, L C. (1996) Drsease-suppressive actions of Pseudomonas bacteria induced resistance, in Proceehngs of a Workshop on Btologtcal and Integrated Control ofRoot Dtseases tn Sotlless Cultures (Alabouvette, C , ed ). IOBC/WPRS Bulletm, DlJon, September 18-2 1, 1995, pp 53-6 1 54 Lemanceau, P., Alabouvette, C , and Couteaudter, Y (1988) Recherches sur la resistance des sols aux maladies XIV-Modtficatton du mveau de receptivtte d’un sol reststant et d’un sol sensible aux fusartoses vasculanes en rtponse a des apports de fer ou de glucose Agronomte 8, 155-l 62 55. Lemanceau, P. (1989) Role of competition for carbon and iron m mechamsms of soil suppresstveness to fusarmm wilts, m Vascular Wilt Diseases ofPlants-Baste Studies and Control (TJamos, E C and Beckman, C H , eds ), NATO ASI Series, Springer-Verlag, Berlin, pp. 386-396 56 Lemanceau, P and Alabouvette, C (1991) Btologtcal control of fusarmm dtseases by fluorescent Pseudomonas and non-pathogemc Fusartum Crop Protectton 10,279-286 57 Alabouvette, C , Lemanceau, P , and Steinberg, C (1993) Recent advances m btologtcal control of fusarmm wilts Pestzctde Set 37,365-373 58 Leeman, M , Den Ouden, F M , Van Pelt, J. A., Comehssen, C , Bakker, P A H M , and Schtppers, B (1995) Suppresston of fusarmm welt of radtsh by co-moculatton of fluorescent Pseudomonas spp and of root colonizing fungi Eur J Plant Path01 102,2 l-3 1
Joint Action
of Microbials
135
59 Hervas, A , Landa, B , and Jlmenez-Dtaz, R. (1997) Influence of chtckpea geno-
type and Bacillus sp on protection from Fusarmm wilt by seed treatment wtth nonpathogemc Fusarmm oxysporum. Eur J Plant Pathol , 103,63 l-642 60 Garbaye, J (1994) Transley Revtew No. 7&--Helper bacteria a new dimension to the mycorrhizal symblosts. New Phytol 128, 197-2 10 61 Azcon, R , Rubto, R , and Barea, J M. (1991) Selecttve mteracttons between different species of mycorrhtzal fungi and Rhlzobzum melzlotl strains, and their effects on growth, N2-fixation (15N) and nutrrtron of Medlcago satlva L New Phytol 117,399404. 62 Paula, M A , Urqutaga, S , Srquerra, J 0 , and Doeberemer, J (1992) Synergistic
effects of vesrcular-arbuscular mycorrhrzal fungi and dtazotrophtc bacteria on nutrmon and growth of sweet potato (Ipomoea batatas) B~ol Ferttl SOJ~S 14,61-66 63 Dandurand, L M and Knudsen, G. R (1993) Influence of Pseudomonas ji’uorescens on hyphal growth and brocontrol activity of Trlchoderma harzzanum m the spermosphere and rhrzosphere of pea. Phytopathology 83,265-270 64 Hubbard, J P., Harman, G E , and Hadar, Y (1983) Effect of soilborne Pseudomonas spp on the btologtcal control agent, Trlchoderma hamatum, on pea seeds Phytopathology 73, 655-659 6.5 Pauhtz, T C and Lmderman, 66
67
68
69
R G (1989) lnteractlons
between fluorescent
pseudomonads and VA mycorrhizal fungt New Phytol 113,3745 Eparvrer, A., Lemanceau, P., and Alabouvette, C (1991) Populatton dynamtcs of nonpathogemc Fusarlum and fluorescent Pseudomonas strains m rockwool, a substratum for sotlless culture FEMS Mzcoblol Ecol 86, 177-l 84 Lumsden, R D and Lewis, J A (1989) Selection, productton, formulation and commercial use of plant disease btocontrol fungt. problems and progress, m Bzotechnology of Fungi for Improvmg Plant Growth (Whipps, J M and Lumsden, R D , eds ), Umverstty Press, Cambridge, UK, pp 17 l-2 17 Harman, G E. and Taylor, A G (1990) Development of an effectrve btologrcal seed treatment system, in Blologlcal Control of Sod-Borne Plant Pathogens (Hornby, D , ed.), C A B Internattonal, Wallmgford, pp 415426 Hebbar, K P , Lewts, J. A., Poch, S. M , and Lumsden, R D. (1996) Agrtcultural byproducts as substrates for growth, comdratton and chlamydospore formation by a potential mycoherbrctde, Fusarmm oxysporum strain EN4 Bzocontrol Scz
Technol. f&263-275 70 Catroux, G , Revellm, C , and Hartmann, A. ( 1996) Possible strategtes to improve the efficacy of mtcrobtal moculants and inoculatron methods, m Blologzcal and Integrated Control of Root Diseases zn Sodless Cultures (Alabouvette, C., ed ),
Working Group “Btological Control of Fungal and Bactertal Plant Pathogens”, IOBC/WPRS Bulletm 19, DlJon, France, September 18-2 1, 1995, pp 159-l 63 71 Roberts, D P. (1993) Genetically modified bacteria for btocontrol of sotlborne plant pathogens, in Pest Management Blologlcally Based Technologies (Lumsden, R D and Vaughn, J. L , eds.), Amencan Chemical Society, Washmgton, DC, pp 33&346. 72 Lortto, M , DI Ptetro, A , Hayes, C K., Woo, S. L , and Harman, G E (1993) Anttfungal, synergisttc mteractton between chttmolyttc enzymes from Trzchoderma harzlanum and Enterobacter
cloacae Phytopathology
83,72 1-728.
III BIOHERBICIDES
9 Neem and Related Natural Products Murray 6. lsman 1. Introduction Although botamcal msectlcldes once held a positlon of Importance m the grower’s arsenal of plant protectlon products, they were almost completely dlsplaced m most mdustrlahzed countries by synthetic insectrcides m the 1950s and 1960s. However, Increasing documentation of the negative environmental and health Impacts of synthetic neurotoxlc msectlcides and increasingly stringent government regulation of pesticides has resulted in renewed interest in the development and use of botamcal pest management products In spite of this interest, there remam only a handful of botamcal msectlcldes m use m North America and Europe, with few new products on the threshold of commerciahzatlon (Z-3). To this point, the market for botanical msectlcldes has been dominated by two plant preparations whose commercial productlon goes back over 150 years. pyrethrum and rotenone While synthetic pyrethrolds (chemicals loosely modelled after the natural msectlcldal constituents m pyrethrum) are among the most potent and widely used conventional msectlcldes, natural pyrethrum (from Chrysanthemum cinerariaefolium; Asteraceae) has maintained a small but consistent market share among so-called “alternative” pest control products Rotenone (from Derris elliptzca and Lonchocarpus spp; Legummosae) 1s still used to a small extent for insect control, but 1snow primarily used as a commercial plsclclde (fish poison), reflecting its original use over 300 years ago. Neither of these products enjoys wide use m conventional crop production, but they have been embraced by organic food producers. Other botanical msectlcldes have seen use in mdustrlahzed countries, but for various reasons have slipped from the marketplace or are used on a very hmlted scale. These include nicotine (from Nzcotzana tabacum, Solanaceae), From Edited
Methods by
m Biotechnology,
F R Hall
vol 5 Btopestmdes
and J J Menn
0 Humana
139
Press
Use and DeBvery Inc , Totowa,
NJ
140
lstnan
quassia (from QUUSSEU amara; Stmaroubaceae), ryama (from Ryan~~speclosa; Flacourtiaceae), and sabadilla (from Schoenocaulon officianale; Lihaceae). Why have so few botanical insecticides been developed? One overwhelmmg reason is that the discovery process, based on screening samples through bioassays with pests,has focused on materials that are acutely toxic to insects. However, acute toxicity 1snot the usual modus operandi m the real world of plant defensive chemistry, m which selection seems to have favored a more moderate approach: herbivore deterrence or dtscouragement. If an mvesttgator uses Insect mortality as the bioassay end point, as one would m the case of synthetic msecttctdes, it is not surprismg that so few plant preparattons have been discovered that have efficacy (in the laboratory) comparable to conventional msecttctdes. However, the demonstrated field efficacy and subsequent commercial development of botanical msecticides derived from the Indian neem tree (Azadzrachta zndlca; Meltaceae) have changed our basic assumptions about how a natural product must affect insects to be useful for plant protection on a commerctal scale. Neem functions primarily as an insect growth regulator, but also as a behavior-modifying substance, deterring feeding and/or oviposition m certain pest species (4). Of equal importance, neem has mmtmal toxtctty to vertebrates, is soft on natural enemies (5) and pollmators (61, and degrades rapidly m the environment. Neem serves as a paradigm for the development of other botanical msectictdes having nonneurotoxic modes of action (I), Environmental nonpersistence is an important trait that neem shares with other botanical insecticides. Although neem and perhaps other botanical preparations will prove to have superb efficacy in certain pest management contexts, for the most part it is unrealistic to expect botamcals to displace conventional msecttcides m agriculture and forestry, except where protection of the envtronment is paramount. The extent to which mainstream agriculture is prepared to accept botanical insecticides as legitimate products for plant protection may well depend on the successof neem m the marketplace m the next decade. 2. Materials 2.1. Choice of Plants There is a long list of properties that would be desirable for an ideal msectttide (for example, see refs. 2 and 7); to some extent, the mmimal presence of existmg botanical msecticides m the marketplace reflects the fact that they fall to meet some of the criteria necessary for commercial success.Neem has many desirable attributes, including efficacy at low concentrations, broad spectrum of action, mmimal nontarget toxicity, and no environmental persistence-but even neem has limitations, and is not a panacea for pest management.
Neem
and Related
Natural
Products
747
In reviewing the barriers to the commercialization of new botanical msecticldes (3), the following are listed as major barriers* abundance of the natural resource, standardization and quality control, and registration. In the final analysts, two constderattons are foremost: efficacy against one or more pests, and ongoing availability of the natural resource. Although many plant preparations can be used to mitigate pests, only a select group of these are sufficiently and reliably efftcacious to the point that people will actually purchase and use them repeatedly. However, the products that can deliver suitable performance must also be available to the manufacturer in quanttties sufficient to justify the costs of product development and production. To some extent, users will accept a Iowet absolute level of efficacy, but only if the product is safe to the user and the environment, mexpensive, and easily obtained and applied. Neem seeds, as the starting material for botanical msecticides, benefitted greatly not only from the widespread availabilrty of neem trees in India, but also from the fact that seedswere previously harvested and traded for the manufacture of soap. The foliage of Ginkgo biloba produces both medtcmal and msecticldal compounds (8,9); the latter (dtterpene lactones) can be obtained as a byproduct followmg extracting and removal of the more lucrative flavone glycostdes and proanthocyanidms, the compounds of pharmaceutical interest. If the starting plant material IS used exclusively for productton of insecticides, then it must be naturally plenttful, or, preferably, readily cultivated. In these cases, the cost of producmg the plant material can be a significant factor for development. 2.2. Tissue Harvested If the plant is grown strtctly for the production of natural msecttctdes, the best tissue to harvest must be established. This is especially the case for woody perennial plants, but the reader need only be reminded that pyrethrum is an extract of chrysanthemum flowerheads, and rotenone is obtained specifically from the roots or rhizomes of derrts. If the plant has other uses, then the harvest of biomass for msectictde productton has to be both sustainable and compatible with the other uses. The harvested part of the plant should be relatively abundant, at least seasonally, and easily harvested to mirnmize labor costs. Ideally, one wants to select the plant tissue that provides the optimal concentration of active mgredtent(s), and requires the mmtmal extraction, cleanup, and refinement. Seeds tend to be a good starting material, because they are often well protected m nature by secondary compounds. However, seed productton is often limited in species that are not prolific On the other hand, seeds can be a waste product of, for example, the fruit juice industry. Botanical insecticides can be
142
lsman
prepared from the seedsof soursop (Annona muncata, Annonaceae) and grapefruit (Cztrus paradzsz; Rutaceae), and m certam regrons the seeds of these species can be sourced m large quantmes at mmtmal (or no) cost. For species that have no other use, tt 1s advisable to screen vartous plant ttssues to determine the ttssue having the best combmatton of btoactivity and biomass avatlabrltty. McLaughlin and coworkers have done such an assessment on various plant parts of the pawpaw tree, Aszmzna trzloba (Annonaceae) (20) Although the seeds and unripe fruit produce the most acttve extracts, they are also the least available forms of btomass. The tissues found to gave the best balance of yield and btoacttvtty are the stem bark and wood, but because separation of the bark from the wood could be costly, the most appropriate ttssue for harvest on a sustainable basrs was deemed to be stems Further broassays establrshed that the smallest-size class of stems, namely, twrgs of C6.5 mm m diameter, were the most btoacttve. 2.3. Collection Sites Just as the quahty of agricultural commodmes varies between seasons and between locattons, so do the msecttctdal constituents of the plants that produce them. Although chemical vartabthty is a natural phenomenon, It 1s one that must be managed if a botanical msecttctde IS to be efficiently produced Chemtcal composttton of plants can vary at all levels among spectes, among and within populations, and between tissues Vartatton m the msecttctdal constttuents of Hawanan Zanthoxyhun (rutaceae) sp (II), and of the shrub Aglaaa odor&a (mehaceae) (12), are but two well-documented examples In the case of neem, numerous studies have been undertaken armed at determmmg the factors regulating variabthty of azadtrachtin content m the seeds, but none to date have been conclustve. For all intents, tt remains necessary to assessthe quality of neem seed, erther by chemical analysts (llqutd chromatography) or vta bioassay prior to commerctal-scale extractton. There ~111always be good and bad batches of starting maternal, but achieving a mmtmum acceptable level or standard can be accomphshed by blending lots of dtffermg qualtty, as 1sdone wtth other commodmes, such as coffee beans or tea Plant secondary compounds can be obtained through other means, though perhaps with decreased variabtlity. For example, pyrethrms can be produced by chrysanthemum tissue culture (13), as can azadtrachtms from Azadzrachta cell-suspenston cultures (14). Plant-ttssue culture offers several advantages for the productton of secondary metabolttes (opttmrzatton of productton, no seasonaltty, fewer co-extractives), but tt remains to be seen whether thts method can be cost effective, compared to harvestmg tissue from growing plants
Neem
and Related
Natural
Products
143
3. Methods 3.7. Screening for Bioactivity The wide range of insect species used for screening btoassays, and, stmtlarly, the wide range of bioassay types themselves, usually ensure that comparisons of results between laboratortes are tenuous at best. Assuming that the goal of the research is the discovery and development of an msecticide for the management of phytophagous pests of agriculture and forestry, tt makes sense to use a plant-feeding pest spectes as the primary screening organism. However, if screening 1s limited to one species, tt is easy to miss potentially useful bioacttvity against other types of pests, so a more thorough approach is to use a battery of bioassay species, Examples of this approach are the screening programs at the Rothamsted Experimental Station in the United Kingdom (15), the National Chemical Laboratory in India (16), and the Research and Development Corporation in Japan (17). In industry, tt IS not uncommon for as many as 10 pest species to be tested with candidate compounds. Although desirable, few laboratories can afford to mamtam contmuous cultures of more than three insect species, because of the human resources and direct costs required. Some mvestigators who have screened extracts from many plant species have relied on a single organism, e.g., brine shrimp (18) or mosquito larvae (17,19), largely because of the convemence m using these species. Though these bioassays are sensitive and reproducible mdicators of cytotoxtctty, they are not necessarily good predictors of btoactivity against agricultural pests (17). In the author’s research program, the primary screening species is the tobacco cutworm (Spodoptera Iztura), an noctuid pest of tobacco and vegetable crops m tropical and subtropical Asia. Active plant extracts are subsequently evaluated against a range of insects, rncludmg the migratory grasshopper (Melanoplus sanguinipes), the green peach aphid (Myzuspersrcae), the yellow mealworm (Tenebrzo molitor), and the large milkweed bug (Oncopeltus fasciatus). The primary bioassay, utilizing the cutworm, measures larval growth and survival of neonate larvae reared at 26°C for 10 d on arttfictal media, to which plant extracts (or fractions thereof, or pure compounds) are admixed Crude extracts are screened at 1000 ppm fresh wt (= 0 l%), pure compounds at 50 ppm. For compounds active at these concentrations, ECsO values (effective concentration reducing larval growth by 50% compared to controls) are established based on dose-response relattonships obtained usmg four or five lower concentrations An advantage of the larval growth bioassay is that tt can detect effects on the insect that have either behavioral or phystological bases,and effects resultmg from a wide range of modes of action. Many investigators have used antifeedant bioassays (either choice or no-choice feeding tests) for screenmg plant extracts. These strictly behavioral
744
lsman
bioassaysare no longer conducted on a routine basis for three reasons: A strong antifeedant wrll result m suppressedgrowth m the aforementioned diet bioassay, so a separate bioassay measuring feeding behavior alone IS not needed, differences between insect speciesare far greater for behavioral effects (feeding deterrence) than for physiological effects (toxrcity), and feeding behavior can be a function of bioassay duration, because insects can quickly habituate to feeding deterrents, as has been demonstrated in the case of azaduachtm, the prmcipal antifeedant from neem (20). The utility of antifeedantsper se as crop protectants is therefore questionable, given the plasticity of insect feeding behavior This variation in behavior response IS well exemplified by azadnachtm, the most potent insect antifeedant yet discovered Even closely related species of noctuid caterpillars differ srgmficantly m then behavioral responses to this substance, but their physiological responses are far more consistent (21). And, although azadirachtm is a profound antifeedant for the desert locust, it has no antifeedant effect agamst the migratory grasshopper (22) or the strawberry aphid (23), although both of the latter species are susceptible to the phystological actions of the compound Acute toxicity can be determmed through different modes of admmistranon, i.e., via direct topical application, or via exposure of insects to residues of test materials applied to glass plates or vials (24). A less precise but perhaps more realistic approach is to spray-test materials (m dilute alcoholic solutions) onto plants, either naturally or artificially infested with insects. Placmg insects onto freshly treated plants can indicate contact action of residues of the test material, rather than assessing the impact of the material hitting the pests directly. In these types of bioassays, mortality is normally assessedafter 24 or 48 h An important shortcommg of such experiments is that not all useful crop protectants result m pest mortality within 48 h; significant chronm effects can therefore be missed if acute mortality is the only bioassay endpoint considered. For example, neem msecticides often take 4-7 d to kill lepidopteran larvae (basically, at the time of the next molt), but these insects, though ahve m the mterim, often cease feeding almost immediately, so no further damage to the crop is inflicted. If we are to seriously consider the dtscovery and development of botanical msecticides, we must be prepared to consider many modes of action that do not result in acute mortality. 3.2. Extraction
Active prmciples from most existmg botanical msecticides are of moderate polarity and can be readtly extracted usmg alcohols of various origm. Important considerations m the choice of solvents include cost,safety (low flashpoint), and the potential for recycling Effluent disposal and flammability may preclude the use of organic solvents m some cases,but, for example, petroleum disttl-
Neem
and Related
Natural
Products
145
lates are used for the extraction of pyrethrum. There have been very few attempts to use exotic solvents and/or extraction technologies to obtain botamcal insecticides, though a supercritical fluid-extraction process (utilizmg liquid C02) for yielding concentrated pyrethrins from Chrysanthemum flowers has been patented (25). In the case of neem, the seedscan contam up to 40% by weight of oil, and tt is preferable to remove the oil, either through cold pressing or hexane extraction, prior to initial extraction for the azadirachtms. Note that neem oil itself, refined or clarified, can be used as a separate crop protectant targeted at certain soft-bodied pests. For some materials, it may be possible to use a crude extract, followmg removal of the extracting solvent, if the active constituents are present m sufficient concentration However, m most cases, some additional cleanup or refinement is necessary. This can normally be accomplished by some form of hquid-liquid partition, including the use of countercurrent extraction, on a commercial scale. The goal, though, should be to mmimize the number of steps needed to obtain a technical grade extract with an acceptable concentration of active ingredients. Extraction of insecticidal acetogenins from the bark of A. triloba provides an excellent example (28). Bioactivity (measured as brine shrimp toxicity) of the crude ethanohc extract is increased 4.5x by solvent partttion, but an additional partition of the organic phase leads to a further 42-fold increase m acttvity-almost to the same level as that of the mam constituent m purity. Both cost and yield of each step must be factored into the equation before the manufacturer can decide what level of refinement is justified. 3.3. Standardization For a botanical to be approved for use (i.e., registered) m industrialized countries, the putative active ingredient(s) must be specified and Its concentration guaranteed on the product label. It is therefore necessaryto standardize the technical grade material (refined plant extract). There are various chromatographic means of quantifying mdivtdual constituents of complex mixtures such as plant extracts, but high-performance liquid chromatography appears to be the most widely applicable for most types of insecticidal compounds found m plants. The active prmctples m plants almost always occur as suites of closely related structures, often comparable to one another in bioactivity when isolated. Thus, they are collecttvely considered to be the active ingredient, viz., pyrethrins in pyrethrum and azadirachtms m neem. Quantification of active ingredients is not only important for regulatory purposes, but also for trade; m the case of neem, the (total) azadirachtin content determines the price of the refined seed extract.
146
lsman
Neem kernels contam at least a dozen analogs of azadn-achtm.The chemlstry and biological activity of these are extensively revlewed by Kraus and Rembold (4). There are some significant differences m the behavioral (antlfeedant) and physlologlcal (growth-disrupting) effects of these compounds, but mvestlgatlons of structure-activity relations have revealed that the entlre carbon skeleton 1sessential for insect-growth-regulatmg activity. This reahzatlon, combined with the structural complexity of the azadirachtm molecule (containing 13 chu-al centers and 4 oxygenated rings), diminishes the prospect of syntheslzmg a simpler compound retaining the outstanding bloactivlty of the natural product. From a practical standpoint, the issue of structure-activity relations of the naturally occurring azadirachtms is largely a moot point, because, of the dozen or so compounds m neem kernels, two account for about 99% of the total. These are azadlrachtm proper (sometimes referred to as “aza A”), and 3-tlgloylazadlrachtol (frequently referred to as “aza B”). In analyzing 20 partially- to highly-refined neem kernel extracts via HPLC for hmonoid constltuents, we found that these two compounds occur m ratios of 2-6 to 1 (average 2 5.1), with azadlrachtin dominating (Isman et al., unpubhshed data). As an Insect growth regulator, 3-tigloylazadlrachtol ls substantially more active than azadlrachtm agamst some pest species (e.g., S. litura and Epzlachna vanvestu), but less active against others (e.g., Schzstocerca gregarza and Helzothis vzrescens). As an antlfeedant against noctuld larvae, 3-tlgloylazadlrachtol appears to be somewhat less active than azadlrachtm Given the above observations, considering the azadlrachtms collectively in quantitatmg the active ingredients m neem preparations seems to be a reasonable approach. 3.4. Formulation Some of the existing botamcals have been sold primarily m the form of dusts or powders, but these tend to be relatively inefficient with respect to delivery of toxlcant to the target pest and residual action on plant foliage More desirable, and more widely used, are emulsifiable concentrate (EC) formulations of botanicals. Most botamcals lend themselves well to the preparation of EC formulations. Because of then- moderate polarity, the technical grade extracts often dissolve readily m conventional alcohol-based carriers. There are also numerous conventional food-grade emulsifiers (e.g., ethoxylated glycerides or esters) that will produce stable aqueous emulsions of the dissolved extract. Compared to many synthetic msectlcides, the active principles m many botanical msectlcldes, mcludmg neem, tend to be very susceptible to photodegradation, and labile to oxldatlon m storage. To counter these deleterious actions, UV-absorbing adjuvants (i.e., sunscreens) and food-grade antloxldants
Neem and Related Natural Products
147
can be added to the formulation, although then ability to protect the active ingredients should be determined empirically. Some actives may be sufficiently stable to allow the preparation of ready-to-use formulations, with or without a propellant, for use m the home and garden.
3.5. Applications The predominant botamcals m current use, namely pyrethrum and rotenone, enjoy widespread use, at least in part, because they are broad-spectrum msectictdes. Newer botanicals, including several under development, have more subtle and varied modes of action, functionmg as moltmg disruptants, proteinsynthesis mhtbitors, or inhibitors of other specific enzyme systems. In some cases, it 1slikely that several modes of action are possible for a single compound. In the field, neem acts as a crop protectant largely through tts action as an insect growth regulator, but suppression of feeding through the insect’s central nervous system and behavioral effects (deterrence of feedmg and oviposition), and reduced mobility or vigor, cannot be discounted in some applications. Neem is active against a wide array of pest spectes, including members of most of the economtcally important insect orders, but, like some other botamcals, has poor contact action and IS efficacious only when ingested by the target pest Another consequence of the anti-hormonal actton of azadirachtm can be reduced fecundity following ingestion of sublethal doses by either larvae (Leptdoptera) or adult insects (Coleoptera). Whtle the Impact of this effect may not be nnmediately apparent (I.e., within a growing season), It can contribute to long term populatton reduction of pests. Such an effect could be particularly important for multtvoltme species where latter generations are the most potentially damaging to the crop. Against certain pests such as aphids, efficacy IS influenced to a large degree by the host plant, presumably reflecting the relative systemic movement of azadnachtm m different crop species (26). Though the systemic action of neem has been demonstrated in some important crop species and even m certain tree species, it 1sdangerous to assume this applies to all plants. Empirical studies with specific crops are clearly warranted. Other botamcals under development are more selective in their efficacy; if commercrahzed they will have to be aimed at mche markets where they can compete with conventional products. For example, the thiophene a-terthienyl is extremely effective against mosquito larvae, but variable against plant-feedmg pests (27), gmkgohdes, msectictdal diterpenes from Ginkgo bzloba foliage are effective against planthoppers, but only weakly active against lepidopteran pests (9); and hmonm, an abundant triterpene from grapefruit seed is a potent antifeedant for the Colorado potato beetle Leptinotarsa decemlineata, but relatively ineffective against leptdopteran pests (28).
lsman
148 3.6. Compatibility
with Integrated
Pest Management
Most botanical msecticides are relatively soft on nontarget arthropods, probably because they have to be Ingested to be effective (1.e , they lack contact toxtctty) and owing to their limited persistence on foliage. In particular, neem has been shown to have mmtmal impact on natural enemies of aphids (5) and predatory mites commerctally reared as biocontrol agents (29). Equally important, neem does not disrupt foraging by honeybees and other pollmators, nor does tt appear to pose a risk to bees (6,30). These properties suggest that neem insecticides will be quite compatible with integrated pest management in many crop ecosystems.Less is known regarding the effects of other botamcals under development on natural enemies and pollinators. If these products can be demonstrated to have reduced impact on nontargets, their attractiveness to growers will be enhanced. 4. Results 4.7. Recent Products Renewed interest m botanical msecticides is ostensibly a consequence of the recent mtroduction of neem into the market. The ortgrnal neem product, Margosan-OTM was introduced into the United Statesby W R. Grace (Columbra, MD) m 1990. Developed by Robert Larson of Vtkwood Botamcals (Sheboygan, WI) with the assrstanceof the U.S. Department of Agrtculture, tt consisted of an ethanol extract of ground neem seeds mixed with an emulsifier to a final concentratton of 0.3% azadtrachtm and approx 20% neem oil. This product contmues to be sold by Ringer (Mmneapolts, MN) under several trade names, including Safer Bto-Neem TM Margosan-0 was followed mto the marketplace by a range of products based on oil-free neem seed extracts, developed by AgrtDyne Technologies (Salt Lake City, UT) These products, contammg 3% azadnachtm as the active ingredient, mcluded AzatmTMfor nonfood crops and AhgnTM for food crops. Since 1992, several companies in India, as well as firms m Germany and Australia, have independently developed processes to obtain oil-free concentrated neem seed extracts m a dry form, typically contammg between 10 and 30% azadirachtm(s). From these technical grade extracts, EC formulations containing between 2 and 5% azadrrachtin can be readily prepared. ThermoTrrlogy (Columbia, MD) (having acquired both the Biopestictdes Division of W. R. Grace and AgriDyne Technologres) is currently marketing an oil-free neem msecticide contammg 4.5% azadtrachtm(s) under the name Neemtx 4.5TM Among other companies, Trifolio-M GmbH in Lahnau, Germany has developed products under the tradename of NeemAzalTM that are currently being sold m India, and for which regulatory approval in Germany is imminent. For-
Neem and Related Natural Products
149
tune Btotech (Secunderabad, India) is pursuing registration of neem msectitides in the United States. Closely related to the Indian neem tree IS the chinaberry tree, Melza azedaruch (meliaceae). The seeds of this tree contam msectictdal constttuents from which a pest-control product can be prepared, but the seeds also contam meliatoxms, substancesthat are toxic to vertebrates (31). However, the bark of this tree and that of Melza toosendan (considered a race of A4. azedarach by some authors, a distinct species by others) contam hmonoid triterpenes that can be used to produce a botanical msecttcide (32). Such a product 1scurrently manufactured m the Peoples’ Repubhc of China, for use against frutt, nut, and vegetable pests. The active ingredient listed on the label is 0.5% toosendanm, but the commercial product is known to contain 0.1% of a synthetic pyrethroid or other conventional msecticide. Trials m North America using the Chinese product, and formulated bark extract alone, indicate that the latter has only limited efficacy as a stand-alone product, suggesting that the limonoids function primarily as a synergist to the small amount of synthetic insecticide m the commercial formulatton. 4.2. Botanicals Under Development Several other botanical materials have been the subject of considerable SCIentrfic investigation and could proceed to commerctal production if suitable parties m the private sector are prepared to shepherd them through the regulatory process. A number of these botamcals are reviewed elsewhere (2). Insecticides prepared from the seeds of soursop fruit (A muricata) and the twigs of the pawpaw tree (A tnloba) have been the subjects of U.S. patents (33,3#). In both cases, the active ingredients are annonaceous acetogenins. Field trrals demonstrate that plant extracts containing these compounds are effective against a wide range of insect and mite pests, and they act synergistttally when combined with pyrethrum or neem (35). In purity, the acetogenins show stgmficant mammalian toxicity, although some are particularly effective as antitumor agents. It can be argued that, as crude, complex mixtures in relatively low concentrations, annonaceous acetogenms could be effective for pest management without posmg appreciable risks to humans and wtldhfe, a situation not unlike that for pyrethrum and rotenone. Crude foliar extracts of iVicotiaaa gossez and related species, prepared by rinsing foliage with dichloromethane, are very effective for the control of soft-bodied arthropod pests (36). The active compounds m the extracts are sucrose esters having acyl substituents (Ct-ClO) on both the fructose and glucose moietres. However, commercial synthesis of these compounds is not economically feasible, and their recovery from Nicotmna foliage may not be, either.
150
lsman
A standardized extract from seeds of Meha volkenm, a species native to East Africa and related to the neem tree, shows good potential for management of a number of pest insects, especially the yellow fever mosquito, Aedes aegyptz, and the desert locust, S. gregarza (37) Prehmmary results of laboratory and field trials m the United States suggest that this material could be efficacious againstagricultural pestsm temperatecountrtes,aswell (H. Fescemyer, personal communication) Other botanical preparations that have been touted for pest management include root extracts of marigolds (Tagetes spp), rich m throphenes, as a mosquito larvrcide (27), fohar extracts of G biloba for control of the brown planthopper on rice (9), limonin from grapefruit seeds for control of the Colorado potato beetle (38), and seed extracts of lupms (Lupznus spp), rich in qumohzidme alkaloids, which function as feeding deterrents and msecticides to a wade range of pests (39) 4.3. Future Trends With consumer and polmcal pressure for reductions m pesticide usage m agriculture and forestry, and increased awareness of the nontarget impacts of garden pesticides among homeowners, the prospectus for botanical msecticides 1sthe most favorable it has been for 50 yr. As we reach the mtllenmum, with proper marketing and continued refinement, we should see neem msecticides approach the current use levels of pyrethrum. Neem 1scurrently being evaluated as an alternative to synthetic pyrethroids for protection of cotton in China and Australia Cotton represents the largest single market sector for insecticides, so even modest successesm these trials could lead to an explosive Increase m the global demand for neem products. Increasing use of any new msecticide raises the specter of pest resistance In this regard, botanical materials consistmg of mixtures of active prmciples may have an advantage over conventional synthetic insecticides. Artificial selection experiments with diamondback moth larvae (Plutella xylostella) (40) and green peach aphid nymphs (A4 permae) (41) suggest that pest species cannot readily evolve resistance to neem-based msecticides, even though, m the same experiment, selection with pure azadirachtm led to the development of nmefold resistance to this natural product m the aphid. Other botamcal products, mcludmg some of those mentioned m this chapter, should reach the market for specialty uses; few of the products under development ~111have the widespread apphcabtlrty m agriculture and forestry that neem appears poised to attam. Also, botamcals should Increase their share m the home and garden (domestic) msecticide market, perhaps reaching 50% by volume in 1&15 yr. Up to the present, regulatory approval, designed around synthetic pestictdes, has constituted a barrier to the introduction of new botamcals, primarily because
Neem
and Related
Natural
Products
151
botamcals usually consists of complex mixtures of active ingredients, and can have more than one mode of action in pests. However, there IS evidence that regulatory authorities, having gamed experience with botanicals through evaluatton of neem insecticides, are likely to look more favorably on these alternative products, with procedures aimed at moving new products into the marketplace with fewer impediments.
References 1 Isman, M B (1994) Botanical msecticides Pestzczde Outlook 5, 26-3 1 2 Isman, M B (1995) Leads and prospects for the development of new botanical msecticides Rev Pestle Toxzcol 3, l-20 3 Isman, M B (1997) Neem and other botamcal msecticides barriers to commercialization Phytoparasltzca 25, 339-344. 4 Schmutterer, H , ed (1995) The Neem Tree VCH, Wemheim, Germany 5 Lowery, D. T and Isman, M. B (1995) Toxictty of neem to natmal enemies of aphtds Phytoparasltzca 23,297-306 6. Naumann, K and Isman, M B. (1996) Toxicity of neem (Azadwachta wzdrca A Juss) seed extracts to larval honeybees and estimation of dangeis from field appllcations Am Bee J 136,5 18-520 7 van Beek, T A and de Groot, A (1986) Terpenoid antifeedants Part I An overview of terpenoid antifeedants of natural origm Recued des Travaux ChzmlqueF des Pays-Bas 105,5 13-527 8 O’Reilly, J (1993) Gznkgo bzloba-cultivation, extraction and therapeutic use of the extract, m Phytochemlstry and Agrzculture (van Beek, T. A and Bretelei, H , eds ), Clarendon, Oxford, pp 253-270 9 Ahn, Y J , Kwon, M , Park, H. M , and Han, C G (1997) Potent msectictdal activity of Ginkgo bzloba derived trilactone terpenes against Ndaparvata lugens, m Phytochemzcalsfor Pest Control (Hedin, P A , Hollmgworth, R M , Masler, E P , Miyamoto, J., and Thompson, D G , eds.), American Chemical Society, Washmgton, DC, pp 90-105. 10 Ratnayake, S , Rupprecht, J K , Potter, W. M , and McLaughlm, J L (1991) Evaluation of the pawpaw tree, Aszmznu trlloba (Annonaceae), as a commercial source of the pesticidal annonaceous acetogenms, m New Crops (Jamck, J and Simon, J E , eds.), Wiley, New York, pp. 644-648 11 Marr, K L and Tang, C. S. (1992) Volatile insecttcidal compounds and chemical variabihty of Hawaiian Zanthoxylum (Rutaceae) species Bzochem Syst Ecol 20, 209-217 12 Satasook, C , Isman, M B , Ishibashi, F , Medbury, S , Wniyachitra, P., and Towers, G H N (1994) Insecticidal bioactivity of crude extracts of Aglaza species (Mehaceae) Bzochem Syst Ecol 22, 121-127 13. RaJasekaran, T , Perena, J , Ravishankar, G A., and Venkataraman, L V (1996) Repellency of callus derived pyrethrins to mosquito Culex qurnquefasclatus Say and red flour beetle Trlbollum castaneum Herbst Int Pest Control 38, 155-159
152
lsman
14 Morgan, E. D., van der Esch, S A., Jarvts, A P , Macctom, O., Gtagnacovo, G , and Vttale, F (1996) Productton of natural msecttctdes from Azadzrachta spectes by tissue culture. Abstract, International Neem Conference, Lawes, Australia. 15. Khambay, B P. S. and O’Connor, N (1993) Progress m developmg msecttcides from natural compounds, in Phytochemzstry and Agrzculture (van Beek, T A and Breteler, H , eds ), Clarendon, Oxford, pp 40-61 16 Sharma, R N (1984) Development of pest control agents from plants a comprehenstve workmg strategy, m Natural Pesticides from the Neem Tree and Other Tropical Plants (Schmutterer, H and Ascher, K R S , eds ), GTZ, Eschbom, pp 55 l-563 17 Escoubas, P., LaJide, L , and Mizutam, J (1994) Insecttctdal and anttfeedant activtttes of plant compounds. potenttal leads for novel pesttctdes, m Natural and Engineered Pest Management Agents (Hedm, P. A., Menn, J. J., and Hollmgworth, R M , eds ), American Chemical Society, Washmgton, DC, pp 162-l 7 1 18 Alkofahl, A., Rupprecht, J. K., Anderson, J E., McLaughlin, J L , MikolaJczak, K L , and Scott, B. A (1989) Search for new pesttctdes from higher plants, m Insectwdes of Plant Orrgrn (Amason, J T , Phllogene, B J R , and Morand, P , eds.), American Chemical Society, Washmgton, DC, pp 2543 19. Cepleanu, F , Hamburger, M 0 , Sordat, B , Msontht, J D , Gupta, M P , Saadou, M , and Hostettman, K (1994) Screening of troptcal medtcmal plants for mollusctctdal, larvtctdal, fungtcidal and cytotoxic activities and brme shrtmp toxtctty Int J Pharmacog 32,294-307. 20. Bomford, M. K and Isman, M. B. (1996) Desensmzatton of fifth mstar Spodoptera lztura (Lepidoptera. Noctutdae) to azadtrachtm and neem Entomol Exp Appl 81,307-313 21 Isman, M. B. (1993) Growth mhtbttory and anttfeedant effects of azadtrachtm on SIX noctutds of regtonal economic tmportance Pestlclde Scl 38,57--63 22. Champagne, D. E., Isman, M B , and Towers, G. H. N (1989) Insectictdal acttvtty of phytochemicals and extracts of the Mehaceae, m Insectzczdes of Plant Ongzn (Arnason, J. T., Phtlogene, B. J. R., and Morand, P., eds.), Amertcan Chemical Society, Washington, DC, pp 95-109 23 Lowery, D. T and Isman, M B. (1993) Antifeedant acttvity of extracts from neem, Azadwachta mdlca, to strawberry aphtd, Chaetoslphon fragaefolu J Chem Ecol 19, 1761-1773. 24. Isman, M B , Proksch, P , and Yan, J -W. (1987) Insecttctdal chromenes from the Asteraceae: structure-activity relattons. Entomol Exp Appl 43,87-93 25. Sims, M. (1981) Ltqutd carbon dioxide extraction of pyrethrins US Patent No 4,281,171 26 Lowery, D. T and Isman, M B (1994) Insect growth regulatmg effects of neem extract and azadtrachtm on aphids Entomol Exp Appl 72, 77-84 27. Amason, J. T., Phtlogene, B. J. R , Morand, P., Imne, K., Iyengar, S., Duval, F., et al (1989) Naturally occurrmg and synthetic thiophenes as photoactivated msecttctdes, m Znsectzcides of Plant Orzgzn (Amason, J T , Phtlogene, B J R , and Morand, P , eds ), American Chemical Soctety, Washmgton, DC, pp, 164-l 72
Neem
and Related
Natural
Products
153
28. Mendel, M J., Alford, A. R., and Bentley, M. D. (1991) A comparison of the effects of hmonm on Colorado potato beetle, Leptrnotarsa decemltneata, and fall armyworm, Spodoptera frugtperda, larval feeding. Entomol Exp. Appl 58, 191-194. 29. Spollen, K. M. and Isman, M. B. (1996) Acute and sublethal effects of a neem msecticide on the commercial biocontrol agents Phytosetulus perstmtlts and Amblysetus cucumerts (Acari Phytoseiidae), and Aphzdoletes aphtdtmyza (Rondam) (Diptera. Cecidomyiidae) J. Econ. Entomol 89, 1379-1386 30 Naumann, K , Currie, R. W , and Isman, M. B. (1994) Evaluation of the repellent effects of a neem msecticide on foraging honey bees and other pollinators Can Entomol 126,225-230. 3 1 Ascher, K R S , Schmutterer, H., Zebitz, C. P. W., and Naqvi, S. N H (1995) The Persian lilac or chmaberry tree: Melta azedarach L , m The Neem Tree (Schmutterer, H , ed ), VCH, Wemheim, pp. 605-642 32 Chiu, S -F. (1995) Melra toosendan Sieb. & Zucc., m The Neem Tree (Schmutterer, H , ed), VCH, Weinheim, pp. 642-646. 33. Moeschler, H. F., Pfuger, W., and Wendlisch, D. (1987) Pure annonm and a process for the preparation thereof. US Patent No. 4,689,323 34 MikolaJczak, K L , McLaughlin, J. L., and Rupprecht, J. K. (1988) Control of pests with annonaceous acetogenins. US Patent No. 4,721,727. 35. McLaughlin, J. L., Zeng, L , Oberlies, N H , Alfonso, D , Johnson, H A , and Cummings, B. A. (1997) Annonaceous acetogenms as new natural pesticides. recent progress, m Phytochemicals For Pest Control (Hedm, P. A., Hollingworth, R. M , Masler, E. P , Miyamoto, J , and Thompson, D G , eds ), American Chemical Society, Washmgton, DC, pp. 117-133. 36. Pittarelh, G W , Buta, J. G., Neal, J W , Jr., Lusby, W. R., and Waters, R M (1993) Biological pesticide derived from Nicottana plants US Patent No. 5,260,28 1 37 Rembold, H and Mwangi, R W. (1995) Melta volkensu Gurke, m The Neem Tree (Schmutterer, H., ed ), VCH, Wemheim, Germany, pp. 647-652. 38. Murray, K. D., Alford, A. R., Groden, E., Drummond, F. A., Starch, R H., Bentley, M. D., and Sugathapala, P. M. (1993) Interactive effects of an antifeedant used with Bacrllus thurmgtensu var. san dtego delta endotoxm on Colorado potato beetle (Coleoptera: Chrysomehdae). J Econ Entomol 86, 1793-l 801 39. Wink, M. (1993) Production and application of phytochemicals from an agricultural perspective, m Phytochemtcals and Agrtculture (van Beek, T A. and Breteler, H , eds ), Clarendon, Oxford, pp 171-213. 40 Vollinger, M. (1995) Studies of the probability of development of resistance of Plutella xylostella to neem products, m The Neem Tree (Schmutterer, H., ed ), VCH, Wemhelm, Germany, pp. 477483 41. Feng, R. and Isman, M. B. (1995) Selection for resistance to azadnachtm m the green peach aphid, Myzus perstcae Expertentta 51,83 l-833
10 Commercial
Experience
with Neem Products
James F. Walter 1. Introduction The agricultural mdustry of the 1990s IS challenged to find new methods and materials for controllmg pests and diseases. New legtslatton, mcludmg the 1996 Food Quality Protection Act, Worker Protection Standard, and Pesttctde Reregtstratton, are limiting the avatlabtltty of traditional chemical pesticides. Governmental policies committed to the institution of integrated pest management (IPM) programs, the mcreasmg resistance developed by msects and pathogens to chemical pesticides, and the public concern about chemicals m general has u-utiated a re-evaluation of pesticide use. increasingly, farmers m developed and developing nations are looking toward the use of natural materials as pest-control agents (I). Neem-based msectlcldes containing azadtrachtm address these concerns. The insect-growth regulator (IGR), azadtrachtm, affects over 300 species of Insects, including such important pests as armyworms, leafmmers, aphids, whiteflies, psyllids, and numerous other insect pests (2). In addition to controllmg these pests, many azadirachtm-based msecttcides have negligible effect on natural beneficial insects, and low environmental impact (3). These properties make azadlrachtm a sensible material to use m most pest-management programs. However, significant manufacturing, regulatory, and application problems had to be solved before azadxachtin could be brought to the market. Since then mtroduction mto the agricultural market m the United States m 1993, azadirachtmbased pesticides are fast becoming an important tool in crop protection, although the total amount of azadirachtm sold 1smuch less than 1% of all Insecticides sold.
From Methods in Blofechnology, vol 5 B/opestmdes Use and Delwery Edlted by F R Hall and J J Menn 0 Humana Press Inc , Totowa, NJ
155
156
Walter
2. Where Does Azadirachtin Come From? Extracts and parts from the neem tree have been used for centuries to control numerous insect pests and diseases,and as a therapeutic substance The neem tree, or Azadzrachta zndzca (A. Juss), 1sa member of the mahogany family (4). The trees are a hardy, broad-leaved evergreen that can reach heights of 100 ft It grows prlmarlly m tropical regions where the rainfall 1s<32 m./yr, and IS native to such areas as India, Pakistan, Indonesia, and Thailand. Neem has spread throughout the world, and various amounts of neem can be found m such diverse areas as Australia, Sudan, Senegal, Saud1Arabia, Haiti, Mexico, Nicaragua, and Hawaii (5). The dlstrlbutlon of neem 1slimited, because it 1sa tropical tree and cannot withstand cold winters. Azadlrachtin is found m varymg degrees in all parts of the plant. However, the highest concentration of azadn-achtm 1susually m the seeds. Currently, the maJorlty of neem-based msectlcldes are produced m India, with smaller amounts being produced m Sri Lanka, Australia, Nicaragua, and Thalland In India, seeds from the neem tree fall m early spring, after the monsoon rams The seedsare collected by local farmers, cleaned, dried, and brought to local trading centers, where they are auctioned to the highest bidder. From the trading centers, the seeds are moved to the extraction plant, where manufacturmg-grade or end-use products are produced. The vast maJorlty of neem seed collected in India goes mto the extraction of neem oil, which is used to produce soaps and toothpastes (6). Less than 5% of the neem seed collected in India goes into the production of neem insecticides. There are many different grades of neem-based extracts produced m India, ranging from crude products that primarrly contam oil from the neem tree and only a small fraction of azadlrachtm (<0.15%), to highly refined extracts of relatively high purity (>20%). In general, the cruder materials are uncharacterlzed and thus have little, if any, quality control. The more highly refined products are, m general, more highly characterized and thus more consistent. There are obvious differences between the characterlstlcs of neem-based pestlcldes, but even mmor varlatlons m formulation can effect the overall product quality (7) A great variety of manufacturing processes are used to produce neem msectlclde, and the varlablhty m product quality has led to a series of inconsistent reports on the activity, efficacy, and toxicity of azadlrachtm. For instance, Schafer and Jacobson (8) report that the acute oral toxlclty (LD,,) for expressed or extracted neem oil 1s>lOOO mL/kg for red-winged blackbirds. But Sharma et al. (9) report that the acute oral LD,, for neem seed 0111s 39.9 mL/kg for chickens. Larson (6) reports the LDsO for the commercial product Margosan-0 (Vlkwood Botamcals, Sheboygan, WI) 1s>I 6 mL/kg for mallard ducks. &mllarly, Chopra (10) reports that neem-seed 011produced occasional diarrhea,
Commercial
Experience
with
Neem
Products
157
nausea, and general discomfort when given orally to human adults. A 4-mo-old infant died after being administered 12 mL of neem oil for a cough (II). Yet neem oil is commonly used as an oral medication in India, and oral doses of neem as high as 6 mL/kg caused no mortality in female albino rabbits (22), Margosan-0 produced no mortality for rats when fed at a rate of 5 g/kg (10) These reports mdicate that the toxicity and chemical composition of neem extracts can vary significantly. This makes the comparison of different extracts difficult. Although azadirachtin has been identified as a key mgredient, neem extracts can contain dozens of other extractable materials that can influence the toxicity and efficacy of the extract. In particular, aflatoxms have been identified as a potentially toxic contaminant of neem extracts. Other limenotds include such compounds as salannm, mmbandiol, nimbm, and deacetyl mmbinbandiol, all of which have insecticidal activity. This has created confusion in the literature and led to unsubstantiated claims regarding azaduachtin. In order for a product to be registered and suitable for use m developed countries, a consistent,reliable, efficacious product had to be developed. The development of neem msecticides was expensive and drawn out, and took many years of development. 3. The History of the Commercialization of Azadirachtin-Based Pesticides in the United States The development and commercialization of refined azadirachtm-based msecticides has been spearheadedby two companies m the United States.This is somewhat ironic, since there is very little neem grown in the United States,and the regulatory environment in the United States is very strict. However, these two factors probably stimulated the development of efficient, consistent, azaduachtm extraction techniques. The history of azadnachtm-basedmsecticides m the United Statesis very convoluted, with several parties changing hands and products changing names, and constant improvements m technology. The first commercial use of an azadnachtm-basedpesticide for nonfood use was approved by the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) in 1985. Vikwood Botamcals, owned by Robert Larsen, introduced Margosan-0 for use on trees and shrubs to control leafmmers and gypsy moths. This product was developed m part with the assistance of the United States Department of Agriculture (USDA) m Beltsville, MD, and was tested throughout the world Margosan-0 contamed an ethanohc extract of neem seedswith 0.3% azadirachtin (6). However, because of manufacturing and formulation problems, Margosan-0 production was limited to sample quantities, and, although it became an academic international standard, it had little commercial impact. In 1988, W R. Grace (New York, NY) purchased the patent, registration, and technology for Margosan-0 from Larson. Over the next several years, Grace improved the manufacturing and formulation technology for azadnachtin, which resulted in a much more consistent product.
158
Walter
In 1990, Grace changed the formulatton of Margosan-0, reducmg the active content to 0.25%, expanded the registration to include several important insect pests, mcludmg whiteflies, aphids, and armyworms, and expanded its use to include the greenhouse and mteriorscape environments Working through its partially owned subsidiary, Grace/Sierra Horticultural Products, Grace mtroduced Margosan-0 m the greenhouse/nursery mdustry (14). Margosan-0 had a caution label and no specific handling requirements Sales of Margosan-0 were primarily targeted to the control of whiteflies on pomsetttas and other ornamental crops, and the product successfully established the commercial viability of azadtrachtm-based insecticides. In 1992, Agrtdyne Technologies (Salt Lake City, UT) received registration for, and introduced, Azatm to the greenhouse market and Turfplex to the lawn care Industry Both Azatm and Turfplex contamed 3% azadn-achtm m a naphalene solvent, and carried a warning label. Azatm made inroads mto the greenhouse market because of its higher concentration and price position, but sales of Turfplex were weak and the product was dropped after a few seasons. Grace introduced the product Bioneem (0 09% azad), through Ringer, for the consumer pesticides market. Because of their nontoxic mode of action on insects and then inherent low toxictty, the EPA has created rational guidelmes for the registration of neembased msecttcides In 1993, the EPA granted an exemption of tolerance for using azadn-achtm on all food crops at ~20 g azadirachtm/acre. Grace received approval for, and Introduced, Neemix (0 25% azadirachtin) for use on food crops. Inmal sales efforts were targeted on vegetables m Florida. Simultaneously, Grace, m collaboration with an Indian partner, started up the world’s largest azadirachtm plant m Tumkur, India (15, Neemtx found good acceptance m the citrus and vegetable markets for control of such pests as armyworms, leafmmers, and aphids. In 1994, Grace received registration for a 4.5% azadirachtm formulation, and introduced Neemix 4.5 to the agricultural market The 4.5% formulatton, being 18 times more concentrated than the 0.25%, reduced the difficulty of handling large volumes of material and simplified package dtsposal. Also m 1994, Grace sold Grace/Sierra Horticultural Products to the Scotts Company (Marysville, OH). Grace retained ownership of the biopesticide business, but Margosan-0 was renamed Neemazad. In March 1996, AgrtDyne Technologies was sold to Biosys of Columbia, MD. Biosys is a nematode and pheromone producer, and this acquismon was seen as a strategic fit In May 1996, while divesting itself of noncore businesses, Grace sold its biopesticide busmess to Therm0 Ecotek, which formed a new company, ThermoTrdogy (Columbia, MD), to market and develop these biopesticides (16). In September 1996, Biosys filed for bankruptcy (17) In
Commercial
Experience
with Aleem Products
159
January 1997, ThermoTrilogy bought the assetsof Biosys out of bankruptcy, and thus became the sole producer and supplier of azadrrachtm m the United States.With the acquisition of the Biosys assets,ThermoTrilogy has become a much more dtversrfied bropesticide company. It is drffrcult to predict rf azadirachtm will remam a focus of the company. 4. Development of Azadirachtin-Based Insecticides Outside of the United States Outside of the United States, India is the largest user of azadn-achtm-based msecticrdes. Because of familiarity and a captive supply, companies in India have produced and distributed for many years neem-based pesticides that claimed to contain azadirachtin. Various manufacturers, including West Coast Herbochem (Neemark) and Godrej Soaps (Neemacure), produced neem-oilbased pesticides that were unregistered and did not specify an azadirachtm content, because no formal registration system had been established. In 1993, the government of India formalized the registration process for neem-based msecticides. They created a registration system, unique to India, based on the azadirachtm content of the product. Crude neem-oil-based formulations are required to contam 0.0 15% azadirachtm More refined extracts were allowed to contam 0.15,0.3, 1,2, or 5% azadirachtin. Acute toxicity and chemical testmg is required for all formulations. Many small companies entered the market with oil-based azadirachtm formulations. The overall quality and effectiveness of these products has been rather mconsistent, because of variabilmes m oil quality. Several large Indian companies have entered the azadirachtm pesticide market with higher-concentration, and higher-quality, products, mcludmg Spit (Neem Gold), E.I.D. Parries (Neemazal) and MargoBrocontrols (Econeem). Most of the azadirachtm-based pesticides produced m India are used on three mam crops: tea, cotton, and vegetables (28). Other than m the United States and India, the use of azadu-achtm-based msecticides is sparse, but the approval of new registrations in many countries may change this situation. Registration for neem-based pesticides manufactured by ThermoTrilogy or Biosys have been approved m Saudi Arabia, Taiwan, Israel, Spain, Chile, Mexico, Nicaragua, Costa Rtca, and Ecuador A German company, Trrfoho, has received registration of an azadirachtm-based msecticide (Neemazal) in Switzerland, and has applied for registration m Germany. Despite the great amount of fundamental research conducted on azadirachtm m Europe, only recently has azadirachtm been registered m a few countries there. These new registrations should allow for the expanded use of azadn-achtm (19). Along with the registered uses for azadirachtm, there are several countries where azadirachtin is used without formal registrations Australia and Indone-
760
Walter
sta have several plantings of neem, and mdrviduals have been sellmg unregistered azadu-achtm-based msecticides for a number of years. Although most of the products are used as mosqmto repellents or cures for head lice, some have been used on food crops. Development projects in Kenya, Senegal, Thailand, Nicaragua, Phihppmes, Ham, and other countries, supported by European or American governments, have started up rudimentary neem extraction plants or tramed local farmers to produce neem-based msecticides (18). The exact amount of azadnachtm used at this level is unmonitored, and, thus, it IS difficult to estimate the true extent to which neem is used. 5. How Does Azadirachtin Work? The primary active ingredient m most neem pesticides ISa compound called azadnachtm. Although neem extracts can, and usually do, contain other compounds that can control insects or influence the activity of azadnachtm, neem pesticides generally only specify their azadtrachtm content. Azadtrachtm is a hmmotd or, more spectfically, a tretranor triterpenoid with great msecttctdal activity. Azadnachtm 1schemically very complicated and has not been chemically synthesized. Azadirachtm has numerous effects on msects; however, Its major modes of actton are that of a powerful IGR, a feedmg deterrent, and an oviposttion deterrent. These three modes of action give azadu-achtm unique properties that make it very useful m today’s agricultural mdustry. Most farmers are not familiar with these modes of action, and need to understand them, so that they will know what to expect when they use the product. The most pronounced mode of action of azadirachtm is as an IGR. IGRs effect the hormonal system of insects, preventmg them from developmg normally mto mature insects. However, thts IGR property will not cause the immediate death of the insect pests Azadnachtin is structurally similar to the natural insect hormone ecdysone. Ecdysone regulates the development of insects, and any disruptton m its balance will cause improper development, Azadnachtm interferes with the production and reception of this msect hormone durmg an insect’s growth and molting. Thus, m thts manner, azadirachtm blocks the molting cycle, causing the msect to die (20). Because of its IGR effect, azadirachtin does not immediately kill msects and does not ktll adult insects. Immature insects die durmg their development, thereby reducmg the overall populatton over a period of time. The length of time depends mostly on the species of insect, age of insect, and the size of the population. Mortality can be seen m as little as l-2 d, to as long as a few weeks. Azadirachtm has its greatest effect on the early mstars. However, azadnachtin has effects on the emergence of pupae of some insects. It has been observed that the pupae of the leafmmer Liromyria trzfolia (21) and the frutt fly Ceratztls capztata (22), treated with azadnachtm, die before they emerge as
Commercial Experience with Neem Products
167
Table 1 Control of Beetarmy Worm (BAW), Cabbage Looper (LOOPER), and Diamond Back Moth (DBM) on Broccoflower in Oxnard, CA Treatment
Rate (per acre)
BAW
Average number Loopers
Untreated Xentari Neernlx Asana
1 lb 0.5 gal 9 6 oz
0 67 A 0.47 AB 0.83 A 023 B
09A 0.73 A 0.90 A 03B
DBM 0.47 0 23 0 37 0 07
A B A c
Plant damage P-3 45A 31A 1.2 B 08B
Three treatments made weekly at 100 gal/acre and evaluated after the third treatment Treatments followed by the same letter do not slgmficantly differ (P = 0 05 Duncan’sMRT)
adults. This variability in the expression of the activity of azadrrachtm can confuse farmers. Many IGRs have the drawback that they do not immediately kill the pest insect, thus leaving the insect to further damage the plant until it succumbs to the IGR. However, m the case of azadirachtm, the additional modes of actlon help protect the plants from damage while the IGR works on the insect Many insects exposed to azadlrachtm will stop feeding shortly after exposure. This, m effect, ends the damage to the plant, even though the insect larvae are still present This effect 1sexperienced m the field, where insect counts may not be significantly reduced, but plant damage is not occurring. In field trials conducted in California, the author has noted that broccoflower treated with Neemlx had amounts of worms present equivalent to the untreated control. But the damage caused to the plant was significantly reduced in the Neemlx-treated plots, and similar to that observed in plots treated with conventional msecticldes (Table 1). This mode of action complicates scouting, because insect counts are not totally representative of potential damage. 6. Formulation Effects Currently, m the United States, at least four different formulations contaming azadirachtin are registered for commercial use. They vary in active ingredient content, manufacturing process, as well as formulation components. ThermoTrilogy produces three azadirachtin forrnulatlons, including BloNeemT”, containing 0.09% azadirachtm m an alcohol base and supplied to the homeowner market. NeemixBTM and NeemazadBTM,contammg 0.25% azadlrachtm m an alcoholic base with 5% neem 011,are supplied to the agricultural and greenhouse markets, respectively. Neemlx and Neemazad were previously called Margosan-0. Neemix 4.5 and Neemazad 4.5, contaming 4.5% azadn-achtm m an acetate base, are marketed m the agricultural and greenhouse markets, respectively. Biosys produces Azatm and Align, which contam 3% azadlrachtm
Walter
162 Table 2 Final Population Density of A. pisum Exposed to Broad Beans Treated with Several Neem Insecticides at Equivalent Rate of 100 mg of Azadirachtin/L No. aphids Control
Azatm
Neemix
RH-9999
1392.25 A
654 B
232 C
1378 5 A
Table 3 Toxicity of Neem Insecticides to Immature A. pisum Exposed as First lnstars to Neem Insecticides at 100 mg of AzadirachtML Control
Azatm
Neemlx
RH-9999
2oc
68 0 B
90.0 A
80C
Means followed by same letter are not stgnlficantly different Based on five rephcates m a naphthalene base. Azatm is supplied to the greenhouse trade, and Align 1s supplied to the agricultural trade. Despite the fact that all these products contain azadlrachtin, which has little mammalian toxicity, the different mert Ingredients create products that have different levels of toxicity and may not perform similarly. Wan et al. (23) has recently shown that the naphthalene carrier m Azatm makes It 10 times more toxic to Juvenile salmon than is Neemix (Margosan-0). Formulation differences also impact the ability of these materials to control insects. Stark and Walter (24) demonstrated that three different azadlrachtm contaming formulations, when applied at the same rate of azadlrachtm, showed very different ablhtles to control the pea aphid, Acyrthoszphonpzssum (Harris). In these tests, they examined the effects of Neemlx (Margosan-0), Azatm, and an experimental formulation RH-9999 (Rohm and Hass, Phlladelphla, PA) on the pea aphid on broad beans. Trials conducted on mixed-age populations, as well as first mstar nymphs, showed that, when applied at equal rates of azadlrachtm, Neemlx was statistically more effective than the other materials, and RH-9999 had little effect (Tables 2 and 3). Slmllar results were reported by Eckberg et al (25), who noted that Neemlx (Margosan-0), used at a low rate, killed forest tent caterpillars, Mulacosoma disstria, more quickly than Azatzn at a much higher rate (Table 4). Further analysis conducted by Stark and Walter (26) suggests that the presence of llmmlods other than azadlrachtin, present m Neemlx, including
Commercial
Experience
with Neem
Products
163
Table 4 Effect of Azatin EC and Neemix (Margosan-0) on Mortality of Forest Tent Caterpillars % Mortahtv Treatment Untreated Azatin Neemlx
Rate 50 PPM 125PPM
7 DAT
11 DAT
15 DAT
19 DAT
24 DAT
OOA OOA 160A
OOB 10.5 B 61 3A
40B 30.0 B 68.0 A
80B 70 0 A 82.0 A
380B 86 0 A 90 0 A
Fourth mstar larvae were placed m a Petri dish with ash leaves treated with the products for 6 d Then the treated leaves were replaced with untreated leaves Numbers within a column followed by the same letter are not slgmficantly different (P = 0.05) by SNK
Table 5 Effect of Removing Neem Oil Components from Neemix and Adding to Aratin and RH-9999 No aphids Control 1437.75 A
Azatm
Azatm + 011
RH-999
RH-9999 + 011
625.25 C
281.75 D
1416.0 A
810.0 B
Means followed by same letter are not slgmficantly different Population density of,4 p~sumexposed to several neem msectlcldes at 100 mg of azadlrachtmil
mmbandlol, deacetylsalanmn, deacetylnimbin, mmbm, 6-acetylnimbandtol, and salanmn, and the or1component, are responsible for the enhanced acttvity of Neemtx. These hmmotds have little or no msecttcldal of then own at the levels present, but appear to strmulate the activity of azadnachtin Removal of these components from Neemrx reduces its activity, but then addition to the other azadnachtm formulattons Increased the activity of azatm and RH-9999 (Table 5). This 1sfurther amplified by the fact that recommended apphcation rates for azatm (S-21 oz/lOO gal, equivalent to 8-18 g azadtrachtm/lOO gal) are roughly 3 ttmes higher than those recommended for Neemtx (2.5-5 pt/ 100 gal equivalent to 2.8-5.6 g azadirachtin/lOO gal). Thus, azadtrachtm-based msecttctdes cannot be compared solely on this azadirachtin content. Other factors Influence the acttvlty of azadirachtin. 7. Adjuvant
Effects
An adjuvant is used to aid the operatton or improve the effectiveness of a pesticide. The term mcludes such matertals as wetting agents, spreaders, emulsifiers, dispersing agents, and penetrants. These materials are commonly used
Walter
164 Table 6 Effect of Adjuvants on Control of Greenhouse Whitefly on Tomato Treatment Untreated Neemlx Neemlx + Bond Neemlx + Plyac Neemlx + Intact Neemlx + Kmetlc Neemlx + Sllwet Neemlx + Soydex Neemlx + Dynamic Neemix + Joint venture
by Neemix
Adluvant rate
% Mortahty 19 35 A
002% 002% 025% 0.02% 0.03% 025% 025%
05%
3288 B 4078 B 37 1B 5007c 5321C 7452 CD
92.11 D 83 02 D
91 27D
Mortahty of first mstarnymphsexposedto Neemtxat a rateof 0 5 gal/100gals (5 ppmazadlrachtm) Meansm the samecolumnfollowedby the sameletterare statlstlcallyequal, P=OO5
to enhance the performance of conventional pestlcldes. Although azadirachtm works differently from conventional pesticides, because of its broad spectrum of activity, many applications of azadirachtin can benefit from the addition of adJuvants. As with most pesticides, getting the material to the pest 1s of utmost importance Although azadirachtm has some systemic propertles and will translocate across the leaf cuticle (26), it does not effectively move from leaf to leaf The use of spreading agents has been shown to improve coverage and enhance the activity of azadlrachtin m the laboratory and m the field. Laboratory trials conducted on greenhouse whitefly (Trraleurodes vaporariorum) indicate that not all adjuvants mfluence azadlrachtin similarly. In these trials, tomato plants were introduced into a greenhouse whitefly colony and the adults were allowed to lay eggs. The plants were then removed and sprayed with solutions of Neemlx (0.5 gal/l00 gal) containing various adJuvants. Seven d later, the mortality of the immature nymphs was evaluated. The results presented m Table 6 indicate that most of the adJuvants Improved the performance of Neemlx, but the adJuvants contammg vegetable or mineral 011 (Joint Venture and Soydex) gave the most significant improvement. Field tnals conducted m Florida show that the addition of Joint Venture to Neemlx 4.5 improved whitefly control (Table 7). Other effects have been noted with other adjuvants. For instance, the addltlon of Cell-u-wet dramatically improved the efficacy of Neemix to control pepper weevil damage, but did not Improve the control of armyworm m field
Commercial
Experience
with Neem
165
Products
Table 7 Control of Silver Leaf White Fly on Tomatoes with Neemix and Joint Venture No dead nymphs/leaf Treatment Neemlx Neemlx + Joint venture
Thiodan + Ambush + Soydex
Rate/acre
ODAT
4DAT
0.5 gal
0 05 0 05 0.12
0.14 0.37 0 10
0 5 gal + 0.25 gal
1 qt + 8 02 +1 qt
lIDAT 0 02 0 50 0 06
18DAT 0 25 1 10 0 32
Treatments applied on d 0,8, and 15 at 100 gal/acre. Evaluations made on d 0,4, 11, and 18.
Table 8 Effect of Additives on Control of Rosy Apple and Green Peach Aphids at Two Locations (Sebastopol, CA and Graton, CA) Treatment
Untreated M-Pede Stylet 011 Neemix Neemlx + Stylet oil Neemlx + M-Pede
Sebastopol
Graton
Rate/acre
Damaged shoots
Infested shoots
2 gal 2 gal 0 5 gal 0.5 gal + 2 gal 0.5 gal + 2 gal
1005 7 65 8 65 65 3 30
6.25 A 3.17 AB 2.75 B 358AB 0.5 B 3 17AB
Apphcatlons apphed 3 times, 10-14 d apart, at 100 gal/acre The Sebastopol trial was evalu-
ated for damaged shoots and the Graton trial for infested shoots trials m Florida.
This result 1s sigmficant,
because Neemrx
does not ktll the
adult pepper weevil, but in some way deters their ovipositton on the fruit. The addmon of spreading agents that slow the rate of drying, such as Cell-u-wet, enhances this activity. In field trials in California, the addition of materials like Stylet 011 and M-Pede
improved
the control
of aphids by Neemlx.
In these
trials, apple trees infested wtth aphids were sprayed 3 times over a 1mo period, and then evaluated for aphid damage. Four replications were included per treatment. In one trial, the addition of Stylet oil at 2% dramatically improved the performance of Neemtx, and, m another case, M-Pede provided a stmilar response (Table 8). Both M-pede and Stylet 011have some insecticidal activtty on their own, but the combinatton with Neemix IS much more effective. All of these trials indicate that, for some pests, the addmon of adjuvants that increase coverage and delay drying of the application, enhance the activtty of Neemix.
Mixtures of azadn-achtmwith other pesticides often show an apparent synergy.
Walter
166
Table 9 Neemix Has Been Found to Have Little or No impact on the Following Beneficial Organisms When Used According to Label Directions General beneficial organisms
General insect predators and parasites Delphastus pusdlus Scymnus sp
Honeybee worker adults (Apes melllfera) Spiders (Lycosa pseudoannolata, Chwoanthlum
mzldzz)
Nematodes (Steznernema, Heterobdztus) Lady beetles (Cocclnellldae, Hlppodamla
Phytosendus persrmllus Lyslphlebus tesacelpes
convergens)
Earthworms (Elsema foetlda) Nonorlbated mites Sprmgtalls (Collembola) Ground beetles (Carabtdae) Rove beetles (Staphylrnldae)
Aphelznus asychzs Eretmocerus callfornlus Encarsla formosa Pysttalla lnclsls Encarsla translena
Clearly, the influence of extractton processes,formulation solvents, and even formulation adjuvants can make the comparison of neem-based msecttctdes difficult, tf not imposstble. Although researchers and manufacturers have tried to use azadtrachtm as a marker mdtcattve of a product pesticide acttvtty, practical experience indicates that this has been unsuccessful. Farmers and other applicators must rely on the manufacturer’s recommendatton and data developed by local extension agents when selecting application rates and adjuvants for controllmg specific pests. The lack of a true standard of acttvtty for neem extracts is a clear difficulty m the commerctahzatton of neem Substandard or degraded products have too often left farmers with the impression that neem products are not effective. However, with high-quality products and the proper use of adjuvants, these impressions can be overcome In the United States market, because of the presence of only two neem suppliers, confuston is somewhat limited But m the world market, the differences m neem pesticides are not well understood and are a major obstacle to the acceptance of neem msecttcides 9. Use of Neemix
with Beneficial
Insects
Neem pesticides, and, m particular, Neemtx, are an excellent choice of materials to use when the preservation of beneficial msects 1s important In both laboratory and field tests,Neemtx was found to have little or no effect on benefictals, such as spiders, lady beetles, parasitic wasps, and predatory mites (27,28). Table 9 presents a list of beneficial
insects compatible
with Neemlx.
Azadnachtin has also been demonstrated not to reduce honeybee pollmatton m the field, nor to effect worker bees through direct contact sprays In fact, recent
Commercial Experience with Neem Products
167
work suggests that the consumption of Neemix can actually be beneficial to bees through the control of Chaulk brood and Varoa mites (29). In laboratory testsperformed on aphid parasites,it was found that, even after four applications of azadirachtin, the wasps inside the parasitized aphids exposed to the azadirachtm emerged m equal numbers to the untreated aphids (30). In other studies, Neemix did not significantly affect lady beetles or parasitism by P jlavzpes. The compatibility of neem with beneficial insects IS especially important because of today’s expanding IPM programs. Neemtx’s low impact on beneficials allows it to be used m conjunction with these predators and parasitoids with little worry about the effect rt ~111have on them. This strategy of combmmg Neemix with beneficial insects has been used successfully m the field to control insect pests. Pepper growers in Florrda have learned thts by using Neemix early in the seasonto control armyworms and aphids and protect beneficial insects. The loss of beneficial msectscaused by the use of mcompatible msecticides causes secondary pests to multiply unchecked, and typically result in late seasoncontrol problems. The use of Neemrx preserves the natural balance of beneficial insects, and thus ehmmates the need for additional pesticrde apphcattons, whrch ultrmately saves the grower money (31). It has been speculated that the msensmvity of beneficial insects to Neem extracts, m general, 1sbecause neem products must be ingested to be effective Thus, insects that feed on plant tissues will be effected by the extracts, but those that feed on nectar or other insectsrarely contact lethal concentrates (32). This is clearly not the case, because bees can be fed concentrations of Neemix m a sugar solution that would kill whiteflies or other insect pests (29). Beneficial insects m some way have a defense mechanism agamst azadnachtm, probably because of a different evolutionary history of carnivores and herbivores. 10. Summary Researchers have for years extolled the potential of using azadirachtm-based pestictdes on ornamental and food crops. After several years of regulatory review, azadirachtm was approved for use on food crops m the United States, m 1993, and was mtroduced for sale in Florida, and later California and Texas, for use on vegetables under the trade name of Neemix. In 1995, sales expanded to the Northwest and Northeast, and a new, more concentrated formulation, Neemix 4.5 (4.5% azadnachtm), was introduced. Because of its inherent safety, Neemix has been granted an exemption from tolerance for use at ~20 g a.1.per acre, and has the shortest re-entry time allowed by the EPA. Similarly, azadirachtin-based msecticides have been registered in several other countries, mcludmg Mexico, Saudi Arabia, Taiwan, Chile, and India. These products would never have been developed without the contributions of several mtemational researchers, mcludmg H. Schmutterer, W. Kraus, M. Jacobson, H. Rembold, R. C. Saxena, E. D. M Saxena, and K. R. S. Asher.
168
Walter
As a pesticide, azadnachtm kills Insects slowly and does not krll adult insects. Thus, neem-based msectrctdesare often used m combmatron with adulticrdes or beneficial insects, which expand the efficacy of the product. Education of farmers, and the development of practical strategies are essential to the effective use of azadirachtm-based pesttctdes.Manufacturers and extension agents must work m cooperation for azadirachtm-based pesttcrdesto succeed. Commercralization of azadirachtm 1splagued by the problem that the brological actrvrty of neem-based pesticides cannot be Judged solely by their azadnachtin content. Differences in extraction process, formulatton solvents, and adjuvants can dramatrcally influence the toxrcrty and pestrcidal activity of neem-based pestrcrdes. Detailed field experience with specific azadirachtmbased msecticides IS critical for both manufacturers and extension agents, to effectively recommend applicatron rates sufficient for adequate pest control. Despite these limitations, azadirachtin based msectrcides have established niche uses for controlling pests on peppers, melons, lettuce, tomatoes, pears, cm-us, celery, and other crops. The future demands for safe, environmentally sound pesticides will undoubtedly offer additional uses for azadirachtin. References 1 Mau, R F. L , Gusukuma-Minuto, L R , and Shimabuku, R. S (1994) Laboratory evaluations of biomsecticides against DBM larvae Arthropod Manage Tests 20, 327 2 Schmutterer, H and Smgh, R. P (1995) Uses of Neem, m The Neem Tree (Schmutterer, H , ed ), Verlagsgesellschaft, Wrenham, GDR 3 Schmutterer, H (1995) List of Insect pests susceptible to neem products, in The Neem Tree (Schmutterer, H , ed ), Verlagsgesellschaft, Wrenham, GDR, pp l-29 4 Benge, M D (1989) The tree and its characteristics, cultivation and propagation of the neem tree, m Focus on Phyotochemrcal Pestlcldes (Jacobson, M , ed.), CRC, Boca Raton, FL, pp. l-l 6 5 Schmutterer, H (1995) Introductory remarks, m The Neem Tree (Schmutterer, H , ed.), Verlagsgesellschaft, Wienheim, GDR, pp. IX-XII 6 Larson, R 0. (1989) Commercialization of neem, m Focus on Phytochemlcal Pestzcrdes (Jacobson, M , ed.), CRC, Boca Raton, FL, pp. 155-160 7 Isman, M. B , Koul, 0, Lowery, J. J., Arnason, D , Gagnon, J G., Stewart, J , and Salbum, G S (1990) Development of a neem-based msecticrde m Canada m neem’s potential m pest management programs, Proceedmgs of the USDA Neem Workshop (Locke, J C , ed.), USA ARS, pp. 32-39 8 Schafer, E W and Jacobson, M (1993) Repellency and toxrcity of 55 Insect repellents to red winged blackbirds (Angelausphoenzceus) J Envwon SCI Health l&493-497 9 NCR (1992) Neem, m A Tree for Solving Global Problems (Ruskm, F R , ed ), National Academy, Washmgton, DC, pp l-l 37
Commercial
Experience
with Neem
Products
169
10. Chopra, R N., Badhwar, R L , and Ghosh, S. (1968) in Pozsonous Plants oflndza, vol 1. (Pravad, J , ed ), Indian Council of Agricultural Research, New Delhi, pp. 248-270.
11, Sinmah, D , Baskaran, B. G , Looi, L. M., and Leong, K. L (1983) Reye-like syndrome due to Margasa oil poisonmg: report of a case with post mortem lindings Am J. Gastroenterol. 77, 158-164. 12. Jacobson, M. (1989) Pharmacology and toxrcology of neem, in Focus on Phytochemtcal Pestrctdes (Jacobson, M , ed ), CRC, Boca Raton, FL, pp 133-l 83 13 Smniah, D., Baskaran, G., Looi, L. M., and Leong, K. L. (1983) Fungal flora of neem seeds and neem oils toxicity, Malaysia, Appl Btol 12, l-l 2 14 Walter, J. F. and Knauss, J. F. (1990) Developing a neem-based pest management product, m Proc. Neem ‘s Potenttal tn Pest Management Programs (Locke, J. C., ed.), USDA ARS, USA, pp 29-3 1. 15. Anon. (1993) “New York Times News Service,” June 6. 16. Anon (1996) “Company News on Call,” May 14. 17 Anon. (1996) “Busmess Wire,” September 30 18. Walter, J. F (1996) Proceedings International Neem Conference, Austraha (Smgh, R P , ed.), m press. 19. Walter, J. F (1996) International Conference on Standardization of Neem Pesticides, Stuttgart, Germany 20. Mordue (Luntz), A. J. and Blackwell, A. (1993) Review of the activity of azadnachtm. J. Insect Phystol 39,903-924. 21. Smith, R. and Chaney, W. (1995) Update on leafmmer pest control U C Crop Reporter February 3, l-3. 22 Stark, J. D , Vargas, R. J., and Wong, T. Y (1990) Effects of Neem Extracts on Trephiretha Fr. #Fhes and then Parasitoids m Hawaii, Nemo Potential in Pest Management Program USDA ARA, pp 36-42 (Locke, J C , ed ) 23. Wan, M. T., Watts, R G., Isman, M. B , and Strub, R. (1996) Evaluation of the acute toxicity to juvenile Pacific Northwest salmon of azadnchtm, neem extract, and neem-based products. Bull Environ Contam Toxtcol 56,432-439 24. Stark, J D. and Walter, J. F. (1995) Neem oil and neem 011 components affect the efficacy of commercial neem insecticides J Agrtcult Food Chem. 43,507-512. 25. Eckberg, T. B., Cranshaw, W., and Sclar, D. C. (1994) Evaluation of neem msec-
ticides and persistence for control of forest tent caterpillar, Ft Collins, CO Arthropod Manage Tests: 1995,20, 327. 26. Larew, H. G., Knodel, J. J., and Marion, D. F. (1987) Use of fohar-applied neem (azadirachta zndica A. Juss) seed extract for the control of the birch leafmmer, Fenusa pustlla (Lepeletier). J Envtron Hort 5, 17-19. 27 Stark, J. D., Vargas, R. I., and Wong, T. Y. (1990) Proc. Neem ‘s Potenttal tn Pest Management Programs (Locke, J C , ed ), USDA ARS, USA, pp 106-l 13. 28 Hoelmer, K. A., Osborne, L. S , and Yokomu, R. K (1990) Effects of neem extracts on beneficial insects m greenhouse culture, Proc Neem s Potenttal zn Pest Management Programs (Locke, J. C., ed ), USDA ARS, USA, pp 100-106
170
Walter
29 Lru, T P (1995) Possible control of chalkbrood and noseme drsease of the honey bee wrth neem. Am. Bee J 134, 195-198 30 Schauer, M (1985) Die Wrrkung von Ntemmhaltsstoffen auf Blattlause und dte Rubenblattwanze. Doctor thesis, Umversrty of Gressen, Germany 3 1 Walter, J F (1996) Use of botanical pestrcides for the control of pepper pests, Internatronai Pepper Conference Proceedmgs (Maynard, D , ed ), pp 17-19 32 Wrlhams, L. A D and Manstgh, A (1996) Insecttctdal and acamedal actron of compounds from Azahrachta zndzca (A Jus) and thetr use m troprcal pest management Integrated Pest Manage Rev 27, 133-145
11 Fermentation-Derived
Insect Control Agents
The Spinosyns Thomas C. Sparks, Gary D. Thompson, Herbert A. Kirst, Mark B. Hertlein, Jon S. Mynderse, Jan R. Turner, and Thomas V. Worden 1. Introduction Many insect pests present an ongoing battle between the grower’s ability to control the pest and the pest’s ability to resist the available control methods Several well-known examples include the Colorado potato beetle on potatoes, the diamondback moth on vegetable crops, and the Helzothzs complex on cotton. The discovery of new, novel insect control agents for use against these and other Insect pests has served as a focal pomt for insecticide research for more than four decades There are a number of approaches that can be taken m the discovery of Insect control agents, and these have been discussed from a variety of vlewpoints (Z-4). A key component m all of these various vlslons for the discovery of new potential Insect control agents IS natural products A variety of natural products have been or are used as insect control agents (5), mcludmg pyrethrum, abamectm, milbemycin, azadirachtm, mcotme, rotenone, and ryania (6-10). LikewIse, natural products have served as leads for a variety of insect control agents, mcludmg the pyrethrolds, Juvenoids, chlorfenapyr, and, arguably, the phenyl carbamates (9,11-23). Thus, it IS reasonable to expect that natural sources will continue to provide other new insect control agents. It is the purpose of this chapter to outline the discovery, chemistry, and biology of a new class of novel, fermentation-derived Insect control agents the spmosyns. From Methods in Biotechnology, vol 5 Bopeshodes Use and Delwery Edlted by F R Hall and J J Menn 0 Humana Press Inc , Totowa, NJ
171
172
Sparks et al.
2. Discovery of the Spinosyns A key aspect of searching natural sources for new products 1s to mnnmaze the ltkelthood of redtscovermg known, unmterestmg compounds. This IS critical because of the time and difficulty of lsolatmg and identtfymg the compound or compounds that are associated with a given blological activity. Just as deconvolutron can be a key pinch point m the utilization of combinatortal chemistry, the isolation and tdenttficatlon of components m a naturally occurring source represents a deconvolutlon of nature’s combinatortal chemistry. Thus, it is prudent to take measures that increase the probablllty of the isolated comp