Bioceramic s Volume 10
Edited by Lauren t Sedel Laboratoire de Recherches Orthopediques Faculte de Medecine Lariboisie...
49 downloads
2027 Views
37MB Size
Report
This content was uploaded by our users and we assume good faith they have the permission to share this book. If you own the copyright to this book and it is wrongfully on our website, we offer a simple DMCA procedure to remove your content from our site. Start by pressing the button below!
Report copyright / DMCA form
Bioceramic s Volume 10
Edited by Lauren t Sedel Laboratoire de Recherches Orthopediques Faculte de Medecine Lariboisiere-Saint Louis Universite Paris 7 - Denis Diderot Paris, France
Christia n Rey Ecole Nationale Superieure de Chimie Institut National Polytechnique de Toulouse Toulouse, France
PERGAMON
Pergamon/Elsevie r Titles of Relate d Interes t
BIOCERAMICS BOOK SERffiS Bioceramic s 4: W. BONFELD, G. W. HASTINGS and K. E. TANNER (ISBN 0 7506 0269 4) Bioceramic s 6: P. DUCHEYNE and D. CHRISTIANSEN (ISBN 0 08 042143) Bioceramic s 7: O.H. ANDERSSON, R.-P. HAPPONEN and A. YLI-URPO (ISBN 0 08 042144 X) Bioceramic s 8: J. WILSON, L. L. HENCH and D. GREENSPAN (ISBN 0 08 0426778) Bioceramic s 9: T. KOKUBO, T. NAKAMURA and F. MIYAJI (ISBN 0 08 0426840) RELATED JOURNAL Biomaterials(ISSN 0142-9612) For details on the above Pergamon/Elsevier Science book series or a free specimen copy of any Elsevier Science journal please contact your nearest Elsevier Science office (see copyright page for addresses).
Bioceramic s Volume 10 Proceedings of the 10th International Symposium on Ceramics in Medicine, Paris, France, 5-9 October, 1997 Editedby Lauren t Sedel Christia n Rey
U.K.
Elsevier Science Ltd, The Boulevard, Langford Lane, Kidlington Oxford 0X5 1GB, U.K.
U.S.A.
Elsevier Science Inc., 655 Avenue of the Americas, New York 10100, U.S.A.
JAPAN
Elsevier Science Japan, Tsunashima Building Annex, 3-20-12 Yushima, Bunkyo-ku, Tokyo 113, Japan
Copyright ' 1997 Elsevier Science Ltd All Rights Reserved No part of thispublication may be reproduced, stored in a retrievalsystem or transmittedin anyform or by any means: electronic, electrostatic, magnetic tape, mechanical, photocopying, recording or otherwise, without permission in writing from the publishers. First Edition 1997 Librar y of Congres s Catalogin g in Publicatio n Dat a A catalog record for this book is available from the Library of Congress Britis h Librar y Cataloguin g in Publicatio n Dat a A catalog record for this book is available from the British Library ISBN 0 08 0426921
Cover picture BOURDALOU Factory of Comte d’ Artois Limoges - End of XVIII century Adrien Dubouche National Museum, Limoges
Printed in Great Britain at the University Press, Cambridge
Organizin g Committe e Chairme n
Laurent Sedel Christian Rey
Member s
Alain Meunier Didier Bernache-Assollant
Secretar y
Martine Henry-Amar
Scientific Committe e D. Bernache-Assollant J. Delecrin P. Frayssinet M. Hamadouche P. Marie A. Meunier A. Moroni
M. Nardin R. Nizard N. Passutti H. Petite S. Redey L’H. Yahia
Internationa l Advisor y Committe e A. Barbosa (Portugal) P. Boch (France) W. Bonfield (UK) G. Daculsi (France) P. Ducheyne (USA) P. Griss (Germany) K. de Groot (Netherlands) U. Gross (Germany) L.L. Hench (USA)
S.F. Hulbert (USA) T. Kokubo (Japan) H. Oonishi (Japan) J.A. Planell (Spain) A. Ravaglioli (Italy) C. Rey (France) J. Wilson (USA) T. Yamamuro (Japan) A. Yli-Urpo (Finland)
Scientific Endorsemen t European Society for Biomaterials Society for Biomaterials (USA) European Society for Orthopaedic Research Japanese Society for Biomaterials Ceramics Society of Japan Japanese Society of Orthopaedic Ceramic Implants National Institute for Scientific and Medical Research (I.N.S.E.R.M., France) National Centre for Scientific Research (C.N.R.S., France)
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
Prefac e The 10th Bioceramics volume reports on the meeting held in Paris from 5th to 8th October 1997. It has been a great pleasure for me to edit this book with the highly respected scientist, Christian REY. Bioceramics in Medicine has become one of the major fields in biomaterials. Many different bioceramics, with various material compositions and characteristics producing different biological behaviour, result in a wide range of medical applications. Dense ceramics, such as aluminium oxide, present a range of properties which should allow the material to last for many years within the living body. This highly oxidised material should also theoretically resist corrosion related to oxygen capture. The latter exhibits very interesting tribological properties when compared to either metal or polyethylene, which are more widely employed. Bioceramics made of calcium phosphate of different chemical compositions texture and porosity, are of great interest for the replacement of defective bone lost through tumour excision or major trauma or to enhance bone repair after fracture, fusion or ridge augmentation. Calcium phosphate ceramics have been employed to copy bone mineral. The imitation of bone mineral is very difficult as it presents a complex system within which formation, degradation and even texture are not fully understood. However, artificial calcium/phosphate of various compositions and even textures has been proved to be bone friendly. Osteoconduction has been demonstrated by many of these materials and their capacity to provide a scaffold for bone cells is also well recognised. Is this related to the three dimensional aspects of these materials and to the ability of mesenchymal stem cells to grow on this support? Or is osteoconduction only related to the chemical composition of the ceramic? Even if the answers to these questions are not available at the present, results confirm the excellent osteoconductivity of calcium/phosphate ceramics. Further questions need to be addressed: what are the events following bone apposition on the surface of the ceramic? Will this material resorb allowing natural bone to replace the artificial material, providing either an excellent bone union or bone apposition. Or will this material remain unchanged providing a permanent bone apposition or bone augmentation necessary for a shelf procedure ? Bioglasses, containing different types of silica with phosphorus, represent another very interesting field. These materials bond to bone without any visible interface. Do these bioglasses provide enough bone bonding strength? Do they enhance bone union? Experimental results appear to be positive, but confirmation in the human
viii Preface
body is yet to come. Mixed materials such as apatite wollastonite glass ceramics (AWGC) show both remarkable tolerance as well as strength and an ability to remain unchanged for many years, when implanted in the living body. As well as clinical applications, fundamental subjects are also discussed. What is the mechanism of bone cell osteoconduction? Is it related to chemical or physical factors, or both? What is the role of the micro and the macro geometry of the surface? Would it be possible to imitate these characteristics on other materials, such as metals or polymers? All these questions and many others are discussed in this book. The applications of bioceramics are numerous. Orthopaedic and dental surgery are the two major fields of interest but others such as plastic surgery, E.N.T., problems of percutaneous devices, embolisation materials, calcium phosphate cement are also increasingly important. Finally the bioceramics field is one of the most active biomaterials applications and has grown considerably in the last twenty years. Its high level scientific input from a wide range of backgrounds and the participation of industries create a great interest in this subject. We hope that everybody, whatever his own interest, will find something of value in this book.
Laurent SEDEL
CONTENTS CALCIU M PHOSPHAT E IN VIVO FORMATIO N Precipitatio n of Calcium Phosphat e on Titani a Ceramic s K-L. Eckert, S.-W. Ha, S. Ritter and E. Wintermantel Apatit e Formatio n on Polymer s by Biomimeti c Processin g Using Sodium Silicate Solution F. Miyaji, S. Handa, T. Kokubo and T. Nakamura Bonelike Apatit e Formatio n on the Surfac e of ChemicaU y Treate d Tantalu m Substrates : Effect of Heat Treatmen t T. Miyazaki, H.M. Kim, F. Miyaji, T. Kokubo and T. Nakamura
3
7
11
Influenc e of Hydroxyapatit e Particl e Size and Morpholog y on Hapex^ ^ M. Wang, R. Joseph and W. Bonfield
15
Effect of Fluorid e Substitutio n on the Biocompatibilit y of Hydroxyapatit e K.A. Ring, L. Di-Silvio, I.R. Gibson, C. Ohtsuki, L.J. Jha, S.M. Best and W. Bonfield
19
Apatit e Precipitatio n in Biphasi c Calcium Phosphat e Cerami c After Incubatio n in Rabbi t Serum and Ionic Simulate d Body Fluid (SBF) R. Rohanizadeh, J.M. Bouler, D. Couchourel, M. Padrines and G. Daculsi
23
Apatit e Precipitatio n in Biphasi c Calcium Phosphat e Cerami c After Implantation : Influenc e of Implantatio n Site R. Rohanizadeh, M. Trecant-Viana, J. Delecrin, J.M. Bouler and G. Daculsi
27
GLAS S CERAMIC S BIO ACTIVIT Y Bioactivit y and Structur e of Organicall y Modified Silicate Synthesize d by the Sol-Gel Metho d K. Tsuru, S. Hayakawa, C. Ohtsuki and A. Osaka Hydroxyapatit e Formatio n on Bioactive Glass Coate d Titaniu m C.Y. Kim and S. Kwon
33
37
X Contents
Effect of Multivalen t Cation s in Calcium Silicate Glasses on Bioactivit y N. Imayoshi, C. Ohtsuki, S. Hayakawa and A. Osaka
41
Transformatio n of Bioactive Glass Granule s into Ca-P Shells In Vitr o S. Radin, P. Ducheyne, S. Falaize and A. Hammond
45
Multilayere d Coating s of Hydroxyapatite/Glas s Cerami c Composite s Plasm a Spraye d on Ti-6A1-4V Alloy P.L. Silva, J.D. Santos and FJ. Monteiro
49
The Bony Reactio n to Rapidl y Degradabl e Glass-Ceramic s Based on the New Phas e Ca2KNa(P04) 2 C. Miiller-Mai, G. Berger, C. Voigt, B. Bakki and U. Gross
53
Resorbable , Porou s Phosphat e Inver t Glasses - Firs t in Vitr o and in Vivo Result s J. Vogel, K.-J. Schulze, D. Reif, P. Hartmann, U. Platzbecker and B. Leuner
57
Implantatio n of Bioactive and Iner t Glass Fibre s in Rat s - Soft Tissue Respons e and Short-Ter m Reaction s of the Glass M. Brink, P. Laine, K. Narva and A. Yli-Urpo
61
Spina l Fusion Using Titaniu m Spacer s With Bioglass^ and Autogenou s Bone: A Comparativ e Stud y in Sheep J. Wilson, G. Lowery and S. Courtney
65
DENSE AND POROU S BIOACTIV E CERAMIC S Macroporou s Biphasi c Calcium Phosphat e Ceramics : Influenc e of Macropor e Diamete r and Macroporosit y Percentag e on Bone Ingrowt h O. Gauthier, J-M. Bouler, E. Aguado, P. Pilet and G. Daculsi Mechanica l Fatigu e of Hot Presse d Hydroxyapatit e S. Raynaud, E. Champion, D. Bernache-Assollant Mechanica l Propert y Change s in Macroporou s Cerami c After Implantatio n into Bone and Muscle M. Trecant-Viana, J. Delecrin, J.M. Nguyen, J. Royer and G. Daculsi
71
75
79
Contentsxi
Differenc e of Bonding Behavior Between Four Differen t Kinds of Hydroxyapatit e Plat e and Bone S.S. Chung, C.K. Lee, K.S. Hong and H.J. Yoon
83
Treatmen t of Osteomyeliti s by Antibiotic-Soake d Porou s A-W Glass Cerami c Block K. Kawanabe, Y. Okada, H. lida and T. Nakamura
87
Calcium Hydroxyapatit e Cerami c Implant s Impregnate d With Antibioti c for the Treatmen t of Chroni c Osteomyeliti s Y. Yamashita, T. Yamakawa, K. Kato, Y. Shinto, N. Araki and A. Uchida
91
BONE CELL S ONT O BIOACTIV E CERAMIC S Measuremen t of Intac t Osteocalci n Content s in the Composit e of Porou s Hydroxyapatit e Cerami c and Allogeneic Marro w Cells M. Akahane, H. Ohgushi, T. Yoshikawa, S. Tamai, Y. Dohi, K. Hosoda and T. Ohta Si-Ca-P Xerogels and Bone Morphogeneti c Protei n Act Synergisticall y on Rat Stroma l Marro w Cell Differentiatio n In Vitr o E.M. Santos, P. Ducheyne, S. Radin, B. Shenker and L Shapiro Effect of Surfac e Instabilit y of Calcium Phosphat e Ceramic s on Growt h and Adhesion of Osteoblast-Lik e Cells Derived from Neonata l Rat Calvari a T. Suzuki, M. Hukkanen, L.D.K. Buttery, J.M. Polak, Y. Yokogawa, K. Nishizawa, F. Nagata, Y Kawamoto, T. Kameyama and M. Toriyama Histologica l Evaluatio n of Culture d Bone Graf t Using Cryopreserve d Marro w CeUs H. Nakajima, T. Yoshikawa, H. Ohgushi, M. Akahane, S. Tamai, K. Mishima and K. Ichijima Interaction s of Bioceramic s on Huma n Osteoarthriti s (OA) Type B Synoviocytes. Effects on Interleuki n Levels and Lipoxygenas e Pathway s B. Liagre, J-L. Charissoux, M-J. Leboutet, D. Bernache-Assollant and J-L. Beneytout A Long Term Implantatio n of Culture d Bone in Porou s Hydroxyapatit e T. Yoshikawa, H. Ohgushi, H. Nakajima, M. Akahane, S. Tamai and K. Ichijima
97
101
105
109
113
117
xii
Contents
SURFAC E BEARIN G CERAMIC S Oxide Ceramic s for Articulatin g Component s of Tota l Hip Replacement s G. Willmann
123
Ex Vivo and In Vitr o Analysis of the Alumina/Alumin a Bearin g System for Hip Join t Prosthese s H.J. Refior, W. Plitz and A. Walter
127
Hybri d Alumina-Alumin a Hip Replacement : A Survivorshi p Analysis and Result s at a Minima l Five Year FoUow-Up M. Hamadouche, P. Bizot, R.S. Nizard and L. Sedel
131
Low Temperatur e Ageing Behaviour of Zirconi a Hip Join t Head s J. Chevalier, J.M. Drouin and B. Cales Characterizatio n of Zirconi a Coate d by Bioactive Glass: Preliminar y Observation s M. Bosetti, M. Santin, M. Mazzocchi, A. Krajewski, M. Rastellino, A. Ravaglioli and M. Cannas
135
139
Calcium Phosphat e Particle s are Found at the Polyethylen e Inser t Surfac e Whethe r Implante d With Ha-Coate d Devices or Not. A SEM-EPM A Study P. Frayssinet, L. Gineste, G. Bonel and N. Rouquet
143
Bone Remodellin g Aroun d Implante d Material s Under Load-Bearin g Condition s M. Oka, Y.S. Chang, S. Yura, K. Ushio, J. Toguchida and T. Nakamura
147
CLINICA L USE OF CERAMIC S Clinica l Comparativ e Stud y Between Porou s Coate d and Hydroxyapatit e Porou s Femora l Implant s Y.H. Kim, J.H. Shon and I.Y. Choi
153
Revision Rate s and Radiographi c Change s Associated With Differen t Socket Interfac e Technologie s : Clinica l Result s from 416 Patient s at 6 To 8 Year s FoUow-Up M.T. Manley, A. Edidin, J. A. Epinette, R.G. Geesink, J.A. D’Antonio and W.N: Capello
157
Contents xiii
Comparativ e Stud y of the Result s Between Custom Non-Coate d Cementles s Hip Implant s and Mirrore d Cementles s HA-Coate d Hip Implant s on the Contra-Latera l Side M. Mulier and G. Deloge
161
Improvemen t of THR With Spongiosa Meta l Surfac e Using the Wear Couple Ceramic-On-Cerami c G. Quack, G. Willmann, H.G. Pieper and H. Krahl
165
Acetabula r Reconstructio n in Revision Tota l Hip Arthroplast y Using a Bone Graf t Substitut e R.P. Pitto and D. Hohmann
169
POSTE R 1 Effect of Solution Ageing on Sol-Gel Hydroxyapatit e Coating s B. Ben-Nissan, C. Chai and K.A. Gross Ionic Cement s : Influenc e of the Liquid/Soli d Rati o on Porosit y and Mechanica l Propertie s F. Betchem, P. Michaud, F. Rodriguez and Z. Hatim
175
179
Sinterin g and Therma l Decompositio n of Hydroxyapatit e Bioceramic s J. Cihlar and M. Trunec
183
An Elaboratio n of the New Dissolution Mechanis m for Apatit e S.V. Dorozhkin
187
Ultrastructura l Study of Long Term Implante d Ca-P Particulat e into Rabbi t Bones A. Dupraz, R. Rohanizadeh, J. Delecrin, P. Pilet, N. Passuti and G. Daculsi
191
Bioactive Glass-an d Glass-Cerami c Composite s and Coating s M. Ferraris, E. Yerne, A. Ravaglioli, A., Krajewski, L. Paracchini, J. Vogel, G. Carl, C. Jana
195
Mechanica l Characterisatio n of Bioactive Coating s on Zirconi a E. Verne, M. Ferraris, C. Moisescu, A. Ravaglioli and A. Krajewski
199
xiv
Contents
Vacuu m Plasm a Spraye d Titaniu m and Hydroxyapatit e Coating s on Carbo n Fiber Reinforce d Polyetheretherketon e (Peek )
203
S.-W. Ha, A. Gisep, H. Gruner, J. Mayer and E. Wintermantel Low Temperatur e Crystallizatio n of Hydroxyapatit e Sputtere d Films in an Autoclav e
207
J. Hamagami, K. Nakamura, Y. Sekine, K. Yamashita and T. Umegaki Fabricatio n of In-Cera m Cor e by Sheet Formin g Proces s
211
D-J . Kim , M-H . Lee and C.E . Kim Surfac e Structur e of Bioactive Titaniu m Prepare d by Chemica l Treatmen t
215
H.M. Kim, F. Miyaji, T. Kokubo, T. Suzuki, , F. Itoh, S. Nishiguchi and T. Nakamura Prefabricate d Biological Apatit e Formatio n on a Bioactive Glass-Cerami c Promote s In Vitr o Differentiatio n of Feta l Rat Chondrocyte s
219
C. Loty, S. Loty, T. Kokubo, N. Forest and J.M. Sautier The Effect on Mechanica l Propertie s by Osteoblasti c Cell Ingrowt h in Macroporou s Syntheti c Hydroxyapatit e and Interpor e 200 ^ ^
223
E. Nordstrom, H. Ohgushi, H. Yoshinari, S. Tamai and T. Yokobori Characterizatio n and Cell Reactio n of a-TCP - and HAp-Coating s on Titaniu m Plat e
229
M. Ohgaki, S. Nakamura and M. Akao The Ectopi c Osteoconductio n Model
233
H. Ohgushi, M. Okumura, T. Yoshikawa, H. Ishida, H. Yajima and S. Tamai Condition s of the Coprecipitatio n of Calciu m Hydroxyapatit e With Zr02 , ZrO i " Y2O3, AI2O3 from Aquoeu s Solution s Using Ammoni a
237
V.P. Orlovskii, Zh A. Ezhova and E.M. Koval Transformatio n of a-TC P to Hydroxyapatit e in Organi c Media
241
K. Sakamoto, S. Yamaguchi, A. Nakahira, K. Kijima and M. Okazaki Structur e and Solvation Effects of P04^- , HP04^- , H2P04 ’ and H3PO 4 from AMI and PM 3 A.J. Sahnas, A. Serret, M. Vallet-Regi and L.L. Hench
245
Contents xv
The Detaile d Configuratio n of Carbonat e Ions in Apatit e Structur e Determine d by Polarize d Ir Spectroscop y
249
Y. Suetsugu, I. Shimoya and J. Tanaka Tissue Cultur e on Amorphou s Calciu m Phosphat e Coatin g
253
K. Suzuki, Y. Kageyama, Y. Kita, A. Yoshino, K. Matsushita and T. Kokubo Bonelike Apatit e Layer Forme d on Organi c Polymer s by Biomimeti c Proces s : TEM-ED X Observatio n of Initia l Stag e of Apatit e Formatio n H. Takadama, F. Miyaji, T. Kokubo and T. Nakamura Sinterabilit y and Second Phas e Formatio n of Syntheti c Hydrox y Apatit e : Controllin g Parameter s and Effect on Bond Strengt h
257
261
H-J. Youn, H.S. Ryu, K.S. Hong, S.S. Chung and C.K. Lee Porou s Sol-Gel Bioglassfi from Near-Equilibriu m Dryin g
265
J. Zhong and D.C. Greenspan
POSTE R 2 Ceramic-Cerami c Bearin g System s Compare d on Differen t Testin g Configuration s
271
J. ChevaHer, B. Cales, J.M. Drouin and Y. Stefani Dissolution and Mechanica l Behaviou r of Plasma-Spraye d Cerami c Coating s for Orthopaedi c Application s
275
N. Demonet, P. Benaben, J.L. Aurelle, B. Forest and J. Rieu Design of a Calciu m Phosphat e Bone Cemen t Suitabl e for the Fixatio n of Meta l Endoprosthese s
279
FCM. Driessens, L Khairoun, MG. Boltong and Ja. Planell Quantitativ e Compariso n of In Vivo Bone Generatio n With Particulat e Bioglassfi and Hydroxyapatit e as a Bone Graf t Substitut e
283
Y. Fujishiro, H. Gonishi and L.L. Hench Test of Bioactivit y in Four Differen t Glasse s A.M. Gatti, L.L. Hench, E. Monari, F. Gonella and F. Caccavale
287
xvi
Contents
Compariso n of Bone-Implan t Attachmen t Strengt h Between the Implant s With Hydroxyapatite-Coatin g and Tricalciumphosphate-Coatin g on Titaniu m Arc Spraye d Titaniu m
291
K. Hayashi, T. Hara, T. Imamura and Y. Iwamoto Effect of Hydroxyapatit e Coatin g on Bony Ingrowt h into Groove d Titaniu m Implant s
295
K. Hayashi, T. Mashima, K. Uenoyama, T. Hara and Y. Iwamoto Mechanis m of the Inflammator y Reactio n of Conventiona l Calciu m Phosphat e Cemen t
301
K. Ishikawa, Y. Miyamoto, M. Nagayama and K. Suzuki Fractur e of Alumin a Cerami c Head in Tota l Hip Arthroplasty . - Repor t of a Case With Histologica l Examinatio n and Particl e Characterisatio n
305
Y. Kadoya, A. Kobayashi, P.A. Revell, H. Ohashi, Y. Yamano, G. Scott and M.A.R. Freeman Experimenta l Comparativ e Stud y Between Rough-Blaste d and Hydroxyapatit e Coate d Implant s
309
Y.H. Kim, J.S. Park, I.Y. Choi, M.R . Park and T.S. Park Mechanica l and Biological Propertie s of Alumin a Bead Composit e
313
M. Kobayashi, T. Nakamura, T. Kikutani, Y. Okada, N. Ikeda, S. Shinzato and T. Kokubo Remodelin g of Bone Aroun d Hydroxylapatite-Coate d Femora l Stem s
317
A.A. Edidin and M.T. Manley Processin g and Characterisatio n of Biological Hydroxyapatit e Derived from Cattle , Sheep and Deer Bone
321
M.R . Mucalo , G.S. Johnson and M.A. Lorie r Catastrophi c Wear of Meta l Ball of Bipolar Hip Prosthesi s After Fractur e of Alumin a Cerami c Screws Used for Acetabula r Bone Graf t
325
H. Ohashi, Y. Yutani, A. Kobayashi, Y. Kadoya and Y. Yamano Antibacteria l Propert y of Ag-Doped Calciu m Phosphat e Compound-Cellulos e Composite s K. Okada, Y. Yokogawa, T. Kameyama, K. Kato, Y. Kawamoto, K. Nishizawa, F. Nagata, M. Okuyama
329
Contents xvii
Wear Behaviour of Polyethylen e Cup Against 28 mm Alumina Ball in Tota l Hip Prosthese s H. Oonishi, N. Murata, S. Kushitani, S. Wakitani, K. Imoto, Y. Iwaki and N. Kin In Vitr o Cell Behavior of Osteoblast s on Pyros t Bone Substitut e J-S. Sun, F.H. Lin, Y-H. Tsuang, Y-S. Hang, C.Y. Hong and H.C. Liu The Efficacy of Hydroxyapatite-Tricalciu m Phosphat e Filler for Bone Defects Associated With Humera l Pseudoarthrosis : Compariso n With Autogenou s Iliac Bone Graft s K. Suzuki and M. Yamada
333
337
341
Experimenta l Study of Apatit e Cement Includin g Cisplati n Y. Tahara, Y. Ishii, S. Sasaki, I. Takano and K. Ohzeki
345
In Vivo Evaluatio n of Sol-Gel Bioglassfi. - Biomechanica l Finding s D.L. Wheeler, R.G. Hoellrich, S.W. McLoughlin, D.L. Chamberland and K.E. Stokes
349
Fixatio n of Hip Prosthese s by Hydroxyapatit e Coatin g G. Willmann
353
Acetabula r Reconstructio n With an Artificia l Bone Block S. Yoshii, M. Oka, T. Yamamuro, H. lida, Y. Kakutani, K. Ikeda, H. Murakami and T. Nakamura
357
Participatio n of Calcium Phosphat e Cement s for Healin g of Alveolar Bone M. Yoshikawa, H. Oonishi, Y. Mandai, K. Minamigawa and T. Toda
361
BIOCERAMIC S SYNTHESI S AND EVALUATIO N Synthese s of Rapid Resorbabl e Calcium Phosphat e Ceramic s With High Macr o or High Micr o Porosit y G. Berger, R. Gildenhaar, U. Ploska and M. Willfahrt
367
Composit e Bioceramic s Mad e of Macroporou s Calcium Phosphat e Ceramic s FiUed With a Self-Settin g Cement . Histologica l Evaluatio n P. Frayssinet, A. Lerch, L. Gineste and N. Rouquet
371
xviii
Contents
Physica l Propertie s of an Apatiti c Cerami c Containin g Tricalciu m Phosphat e Prepare d by the Way of a Cement Z. Hatim, M. Freche and J.L. Lacout Cytocompatibilit y of Calcium Phosphat e Coating s With Variou s Ca/P Ratio s P. Frayssinet, L. Arbore and N. Rouquet Compariso n of Resorptio n and Bone Conductio n of Two CaCO a Bone Substitute s J.C. Fricain, Ch. Baquey, B. Basse-Cathalinat and B. Dupuy Reliabilit y of Dual Energ y X-Ray Absorptiometr y in Evaluatio n of Phospho Calcic Bioceramic s in Rabbi t J.X. Lu, O. Legrand, B. Flautre, A. Gallur, M. Descamps, B. Thierry, P. Hardouin and B. Sutter The Evaluatio n of Degradabilit y of Melt and Sol-Gel Derived Bioglassfi InVitr o D.C. Greenspan, J.P. Zhong, X.F. Chen and G.P. LaTorre
375
379
383
387
391
COMPOSIT E CERAMIC S Upgradin g of Hydroxyapatit e Cerami c Biocompatibilit y by Incorporatio n of a-Tricalciu m Phosphat e S. Sarig, F. Apfelbaum and F. Kahana
397
Preparatio n of Composit e Material s Calcium Hydroxyapatite/CoUage n by Coprecipitatio n Metho d O.I. SHvka and V.P. Orlovskii
401
Bony Reactio n of Severa l Kinds of Ca-P-Collage n Conjugate d Sponges H. Oonishi, F. Sugihara, K. Minamigawa, Y. Mandai, K. Nagatomi, S. Kushitani, H. Iwaki, N. Kin, E. Tsuji
403
In Vitr o and In Vivo Tests of Newly Developed TCP/CPL A Composite s M. Kikuchi, S-B. Cho, Y. Suetsugu, J. Tanaka, T. Kobayashi, M. Akao, Y. Koyama and K. Takakuda
407
Occlusion of Dentin Tubule s by 45S5 Bioglassfi L.J. Litkowski, G.D. Hack, H.B. Sheaffer and D.C. Greenspan
411
Contents xix
Bioiner t and Biodegradabl e Polymeri c Matri x Composite s Filled With Bioactive Si02-3CaO-P205-Mg O Glasses and Glass-Ceramic s R.L. Reis, A.M. Cunha, M.H. Ferdandez and R.N. Correia
415
The Healin g of Segmenta l Bone Defects, Induce d by Bioresorbabl e Calcium Phosphat e Cement Combine d With rhBMP- 2 ; Using as Past e K. Ohura, C. Hamanishi, S. Tanaka and N. Matsuda
419
DENTA L AND E.N.T . APPLICATION S Implan t Placemen t Enhance d by a New Bioactive Materia l E. Schepers and L. Barbier
425
Behaviour of Bioactive Glass (S53P4) in Huma n Fronta l Sinus Obliteratio n K. Aitasalo, J. Suonpaa, M. Peltola and A. Yli-Urpo
429
All-Cerami c Denta l Bridge s by the Direct Cerami c Machinin g Proces s (DCM) F. Filser, P. Kocher, H. Liithy, P. Scharer and L. Gauckler
433
Grindin g of Zirconi a - TZP in Dentistr y - CAD/CAM-Technolog y for the Manufacturin g of Fixed Dentures R. Luthardt , W. Rieger and R. Musil Zirconi a Implant s With a Plasma-Spraye d SiOi -HA Bioactive Coatin g A. Pedra and P. Sharroc k
437
445
ORTHOPAEDI C APPLICATION S Effect of Time and Temperatur e on the Productio n of Porou s Electrolyti c Hydroxyapatit e Coating s N. Asaoka, S. Best and W. Bonfield
447
Calcium Phosphat e Formatio n on Chemicall y Treate d Vacuum Plasm a Spraye d Titaniu m Coating s S.-W. Ha, K-L. Eckert , H. Gruner and E. Wintermante l
451
Propertie s of Plasm a Spraye d Bioactive Fluorhydroxyapatit e Coating s X. Ranz, C. Rey, N. Antolotti, M.F. Harmand, A. Moroni, L. Orienti, G. Viola, S. Bertini, A. Scrivani
455
XX
Contents
Longer-Ter m Mechanica l and Biological Evaluatio n of Titaniu m Alloy Coate d With Apatit e Layer
459
W.Q. Yan, K. Kawanabe, T. Nakamura and T. Kokubo Electrophoreti c Coating s of Porou s Apatit e Composit e onto Alumin a Ceramic s
463
K. Yamashita, E. Yonehara, J-i. Hamagami and T. Umegaki Osseointegratio n in Experimenta l HA-Coate d Femora l Stems
467
E. De Santis, G. Rinonapoli, C. Doria, A. Manunta and M.C. Sbernardori Effect of Hydroxyapatite-Coatin g on the Bondin g of Bone to Titaniu m Implant s in the Femu r of Ovariectomize d Rat s
471
T. Hara, K. Hayashi, Y. Nakashima and Y. Iwamoto
BI O ACTIV E BON E CEMEN T Optimizatio n of Settin g Time and Mechanica l Strengt h of ^-TCP/MCP M Biocement s
477
P. Van Landuyt, C. Lowe and J. Lemaitre Influenc e of the Particl e Size of the Powder Phas e in the Settin g and Hardenin g Behaviou r of a Calciu m Phosphat e Cemen t
481
M.P. Ginebra, E. Fernandez, F.C.M. Driessens, M.G. Boltong and J.A. Planell Subcutaneou s Tissue Response s and Kinetic s of Cells to Tetracalciu m Phosphat e Cement s
485
M. Yoshikawa, H. Oonishi, Y. Mandai, F. Sugihar and T. Toda Biological Behaviou r of a Bioactive Bone Cemen t Implante d in Rabbi t Tibia e
489
A. Afonso, M. Vasconcelos, R. Branco and J. Cavalheiro Histologica l Stud y of a DCPD-Base d Calciu m Phosphat e Cemen t
493
P. Frayssinet, L. Gineste, P. Conte, J. Fages, N. Rouquet and A. Lerch Bioactive Bone Cemen t Studie d in Canin e Tota l Hip Arthroplasty , 2 Year s FoUow-Up Stud y H. Fujita, T. Nakamura, K. Ido, Y. Matsuda, H. lida, M. Kobayashi, M. Oka and Y. Kitamura
497
Contents xxi
NE W MATERIAL S AND TECHNOLOGIE S
Experimenta l Stud y on Hydroxyapatite/N-Carboxymethy l Chitosa n Filler s
503
R. Martinetti, L. Dolcini, A. Ravaglioli, A. Krajevski and C. Mangano
Injectabl e Chitosamin e Hydroxylapatit e Bone Past e
507
J.J . Railhac, P. Sharrock, D. Galy-Fourcade, C. Zahraoui and N. Sans
Manufactur e of a Hydroxyapatite-Chiti n Composit e
511
A.C.A. Wan, E. Khor and G.W. Hastings
Load-Bearin g and Ductil e Hydroxylapatite/Polyethylen e Composite s for Bone Replacemen t
515
R.L. Reis, A.M. Cunha and M.J. Bevis
In Vitr o Assessment of Hydroxyapatite - and Bioglassfi - Reinforce d Polyethylen e Composite s
519
J. Huang, L. Di Silvio, M. Wang, K.E. Tanner and W. Bonfield
Osteoconductiv e Propertie s of Pur e and Type-A Carbonate d Hydroxyapatite s
523
S.A. Redey, D. Bernache-Assollant, C. Rey, P.J. Marie, M. Nardin and L. Sedel
Coagulatio n Times of Blood in Contac t With Gel-Derive d Silica-Alumin a Composit e Powder s
527
S. Takashima, C. Ohtsuki, S. Hayakawa and A. Osaka
Preparatio n of P"*"-Implante d Y203-Al203-Si02 Glas s for Radiotherap y of Cance r
531
M. Kawashita, F. Miyaji, T. Kokubo, G.H. Takaoka, I. Yamada, I. Suzuki and M. Inoue
New Ferromagneti c Bone Cemen t for Local Hyperthermi a K. Takegami, T. Sano, H. Wakabashi, J. Sonoda, T. Yamazaki, S. Morita, T. Shibuya and A. Uchida
535
xxii
Contents
BIOCERAMIC S PROCESSIN G Adsorptio n of L-Lysin e onto Silica Glass : A Synergisti c Approac h Combinin g Molecula r Modelin g With Experimenta l Analysi s
541
R.A. Latour Jr., J.K. West, L.L. Hench, S.D. Trembley, Y. Tian, G.C. Lickfield and A.P. Wheeler Effects of Divalent Cation s on Calciu m Phosphate s Precipitatio n on a Langmuir-Blodgett e Monolaye r
545
S.B. Cho, Y. Suetsugu, J. Tanaka, R. Azumi and M. Matsumoto Effect of Processin g on the Characteristic s of a 20 Vol.% AI2O3 Platelet Reinforce d Hydroxyapatit e Composit e
549
S. Gautier, E. Champion, D. Bernache-Assollant Mechanica l Evaluatio n of Phosphat e Biodegradabl e Glasse s by Mean s of Indentatio n Method s
553
F J . Gil, R. Terradas, J. Clement, G. Avila, S. Martinez and J.A. Planell Silicon in Connectiv e Tissue: Semi-Empirica l Molecula r Orbita l Model s
557
K.D. Lobel, J.K. West and L.L. Hench The Effect of Hea t Treatmen t on Bone Bondin g Ability of Alkali-Treate d Titaniu m
561
S. Nishiguchi, T. Nakamura, M. Kobayashi, W-Q. Yan, H-M. Kim, F. Miyaji and T. Kokubo Therma l Processin g of Compac t Bovine Bone
565
G. Vargas, M. Mendez, J. Mendez and J. Lopez
EVALUATION S M E T H O D S AND NE W APPLICATION S Characterizatio n of Syntheti c and Biological Calciu m Phosphat e Material s by Micro-Rama n Spectrometr y
571
G. Penel, G. Leroy, G. Cournot and E. Bres Biological Evaluatio n of Glas s Reinforce d Hydroxyapatit e by Flow Cytometr y M.A. Lopes, J.C. Knowles, K.A. Hing, J.D. Santos, F.J. Monteiro and L Olsen
575
Contentsxxiii
Evaluatio n of Macrophag e Respons e to Cerami c Particle s by Flow Cytometry : Analysis of Phagocytosi s and Cytotoxicit y
579
I. Catelas, R. Marchand, L’H. Yahia and O.L. Huk Stud y of Porou s Interconnection s of Biocerami c on Cellula r Rehabitatio n In Vitr o and In Vivo
583
J.X. Lu, B. Flautre, K. Anselme, A. Gallur, M. Descamps, B. Thierry and P. Hardouin Repai r of Osteochondra l Defect Using Artificia l Articula r Cartilag e
587
M. Hasegawa, A. Sudo, Y. Shikinami and A. Uchida Calciu m Phosphat e Ceramic s as Controlle d Release System s for FGF- 2
591
V. Midy , E. Hollande , C. Key and M. Dar d C-SRC Oncogen e mRNA Expressio n in Porou s Hydroxyapatit e Ceramic s K. Mishima, H. Ohgushi, T. Yoshikawa, H. Nakajima, E. Yamada, S. Tabata, Y. Dohi and K. Ichijima Autho r Inde x Keywor d Inde x
595
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
CALCIUM PHOSPHATE IN VIVO FORMATION
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
Bioceramics, Volume 10 Edited by L. Sedel and C. Rey (Proceedings of the 10th InternationalSymposium on Ceramics in Medicine, Paris, France, October 1997) '1997 Elsevier Science Ltd
PRECIPITATIO N OF CALCIU M PHOSPHAT E ON TITANI A CERAMIC S K.-L. Eckert, S.-W. Ha, S. Ritter, E. Wintermantel Chair of Biocompatible Materials Science and Engineering, Department of Materials, ETH Zurich, Wagistrasse 23, CH-8952 Schlieren, Switzerland
ABSTRAC T Titania ceramics were prepared, pretreated with lOM NaOH solution and immersed in simulated body fluid (SBF) for up to 10 days. Morphological and chemical changes were analysed by SEM and EDX. NaOH-pretreatment lead to surface roughening of the titania grains and to formation of needle-like crystals. EDX analysis showed that Na was present at the surface. After immersion in SBF precipitation of spherical agglomerates occurred together with formation of a layer of needle› like crystals. Na in the surface disappeared and Ca became distinct after 10 days of immersion, suggesting a precipitation of calcium phosphate. Thus the reactions which were observed on titania surfaces after NaOH treatment are similar to those observed on titanium metal after identical treatment. KEYWORD S Titania ceramics, NaOH treatment, calcium phosphate INTRODUCTIO N The formation of biomimetic calcium phosphate layers on titanium surfaces immersed in simulated body fluid (SBF) was shown to occur after chemical treatment with alkaline solutions [1,2]. Due to the similarity of surface oxide layers on titanium metal and previously developed titania ceramics [3], it is assumed that the same procedure could also induce the formation of calcium phosphate layers on titania ceramics. The aim of the present study was to prove latter hypothesis that titania ceramics can be modified by sodium hydroxide (NaOH) treatment in a way that afterwards a calcium phosphate layer is formed if they are immersed in simulated body fluid. MATERIAL S AND METHOD S Ceramic Processing Titania ceramic discs of 10 mm diameter were prepared from titania powders by mixing 20 g of processed titanium dioxide powder (dso" 6.1 |Lim) with 12.0 g titania powder 1171 (Kronos, Germany), 1.0 g graphite powder KS6 (Lonza, Switzerland) and 2.8 g paraffin (MP 64 C, Fluka, Switzerland) into a thermoplastic body. The mixture was heated to 100 C and pressed into round discs of 15 mm diameter. For polymer burnout the samples were placed on an alumina refractory plate and heated to 300 C at a rate of 5 K/h. Final sintering was performed at 1350 C
4
Bioceramics Volume10
with a heating rate of 3 K/min and 25 min holding time. Finishing was done by ultrasonic cleaning for 15 seconds and flushing with deionized water. NaOH Treatmentand Immersionin SBF Alkaline treatment of the titania samples was carried out in lOM NaOH. The specimens were placed into a conical flask filled with 100 ml NaOH. Immersion was performed at 60 C for 2 hours in a laboratory shaker rotating at a speed of 70 rpm. After NaOH treatment the samples were gently flushed with deionized water for 1 minute. Immediately after soaking, the NaOH treated samples were placed into polypropylene vessels containing 25 ml simulated body fluid (SBF) prepared according to [5]. The pH of SBF was 7.4, pH control was performed at the end of every immersion period. The vessels were sealed and immersion in SBF was carried out at 37 C for 1, 4 and 10 days in a laboratory shaker rotating at 70 rpm. After the immersion in SBF the samples were thoroughly rinsed with deionized water and dried in ambient atmosphere at room temperature. Morphological and Chemical Characterization Morphology of the NaOH treated and of the immersed titania surfaces was analysed using scanning electron microscopy (SEM, Hitachi S-2500C). They were compared with control samples, not treated with NaOH, but immersed in SBF. Energy dispersive X-ray (EDX) analysis was performed at an acceleration voltage of 25 kV with an X-ray microanalysis system attached to the SEM (Voyager, Noran Instruments). EDX spectra were acquired with an acquisition time cf 100 seconds. The specimens were coated with platinum in a sputter coater prior to SEM and EDX analysis. RESULT S AND DISCUSSIO N NaOH Treatment Scanning electron microscopic evaluation of the surface of the untreated ceramic showed that the surface has a granular structure (figure 1) with growth steps on the individual grains which occur due to the crystalline nature of the material (figure 2). NaOH treated titania surfaces were similar to untreated samples with the difference that, at higher magnification, surface roughening on the titania crystallites and formation of needle-like structures was observed (figure 4). EDX analysis
Figure 1: Survey of untreated titania ceramic. The surface topography is defined by the granular structure of the material. The total porosity of the material is 25 %.
Figure 2: Untreated titania ceramic. The grains are structured by growth steps.
Precipitationof Calcium Phosphateon Titania Ceramics: K-L. Eckert et al.
5
(figure 7) of the untreated controls showed no other signals than titanium. After NaOH treatment Na was present at the surface. It is assumed that the newly formed, needle-like structures, which were observed with SEM (figure 4) contain sodium. Besides Na and Ti, no additional elements were found at the surface of NaOH treated specimens. Immersion in SBF After one day of immersion, the formation of globular precipitates and a fine layer of needle-like crystals were observed. The appearance of the precipitated layer did not change significantly during the following periods of immersion. After 10 days, the titania surface was completely covered with a layer consisting of needle-like crystals and spherulitic precipitations (figure 5). The thickness of the deposited layer as well as the amount of spherulites (figure 6) was markedly
I igure 3: I ilania ceramic after NaOHtreatment. No change in the topographical characteristics can be noticed.
Figure 4: Titania ceramic after NaOHtreatment. The surface was roughened, growth steps were partly etched away. Newly formed crystals occurred at the surface and in pores.
Figure 5: NaOH-pretreatment and 10 days of immersion in SBF. The surface is completely covered by a precipitated layer.
Figure 6: NaOH-pretreatment and 10 days of immersion in SBF. The precipitated layer consists of needle-like crystals and of spherical agglomerates.
6
Bioceramics Volume10
c
3 O
O
10 Energ y [keV]
Figure 7: EDX spectra of the sample surfaces at various processing stages. On untreated samples only titanium signals could be detected. Pt signals are caused by the platinum sputter coating of the samples. After immersion in NaOH solution (Ti02+NaOH), a Na peak occurs. After 10 days of immersion in SBF, Ca is present, indicating the precipitation of calcium phosphate at the surface. increased compared to day one. However, the original topography of the titania ceramic surface was still maintained. In the EDX spectra, Ca was identified after the first day of immersion and became more distinct with time (figure 7). In contrast, Na vanished, probably due to ion exchange processes [5]. On control samples which were not treated with NaOH, no precipitation was observed. CONCLUSIO N The current work showed that precipitation of calcium phosphates on titania ceramics occurs similarly to those on titanium metal. In conclusion, the investigation has shown the potential of biomimetic calcium phosphate deposition on titania ceramics after pretreatment with lOM NaOH solution at 60 C for 2 hours. REFERENCES 1. Kokubo, T., Thermochimica Acta, 1996, 280/281, 479-490 2. Kim, H.-M., Miyaji, F., Kokubo, T., Nakamura, T., Journal of Biomedical Materials Research, 1996, 32, 409-417 3. Blum, J., Eckert, K.-L., Schroeder, A., Petitmermet, M., Ha, S.-W. and Wintermantel, E. In: Bioceramics Volume 9, Elsevier Science Ltd., Oxford 1996, 89-92 4. Kokubo, T., Hata, K., Nakamura, T., Yamamuro, T. In: Bioceramics Volume 4, Butterworth-Heinemann, Guildford (1991), 113-120 5. Clearfield, A., Lehto, J., Journal of Solid State Chemistry, 73 (1988), 98-106
Bioceramics, Volume 10 Edited by L. Sedel and C. Rey (Proceedings of the 10th InternationalSymposium on Ceramics in Medicine, Paris, France, October 1997) '1997 Elsevier Science Ltd
APATIT E FORMATIO N ON POLYMER S BY BIOMIMETI C PROCESS USING SODIU M SILICAT E SOLUTIO N F. Miyaji^, S. Handa\ T. Kokubo^ and T. Nakamura^ ^ Department of Material Chemistry, Faculty of Engineering, Kyoto University, Yoshida-honmachi, Sakyo-ku, Kyoto 606-01, Japan ^Department of Orthopaedic Surgery, Faculty of Medicine, Kyoto University, ShogoinKawaharacho, Sakyo-ku, Kyoto 606-01, Japan
ABSTRAC T A variation of biomimetic process which aims at a bonehke apatite coating on organic polymers with complex shapes was attempted by using sodium silicate as a catalyst for the apatite nucleation, and a simulated body fluid as a medium for the apatite growth. An apatite-forming abihty was the highest when the Si concentration and Si02/Na2 0 ratio of the sodium siUcate solution were above 2.0 M and 1.0-1.5, respectively. Particular sihcate ohgomers were assumed to be most responsible for the apatite nucleation. The apatite layer was formed not only on the flat PET surfaces but also on curved surfaces of fine PET fibers constituting a fabric, where the apatite layer was interconnected each other. This method is expected to enable the bonelike apatite coating on various kinds of materials with complex shapes. KEYWORDS : Apatite, Biomimetic process, Sodium silicate, Simulated body fluid INTRODUCTIO N A biomimetic process has been developed for coating a dense and uniform bonelike apatite layer on organic polymers as follows [1,2]. First, in order to form apatite nuclei on the substrates of organic polymers, the polymer substrates are placed on CaO-Si02- or Na2 0-Si02based glass particles soaked in a simulated body fluid (SBF) with ion concentrations nearly equal to those of human blood plasma [3]. Next, in order to make the apatite nuclei grow, the polymer substrates are soaked in 1.5SBF with ion concentrations 1.5 times the SBF. The disadvantage of the above biomimetic process lies in the diflficulty of apatite coating on the materials with complex shapes, since in the first treatment the apatite nuclei are formed only on the material surface which is faced to the glass grains. In the present study, the apatite formation on organic polymers was attempted by using sodium silicate solution as a nucleating agent for the apatite formation instead of the glass particles, and 1.5 SBF as a medium for the apatite growth. MATERIAL S AND METHOD S Preparatio n of sodiu m silicat e solutio n Reagent grade sodium metasilicate (Na2 Si03) was dissolved into distilled water to prepare solutions with 0.5, 1.0, 2.0 and 3.0 M Si-concentration. As another series of sodium silicate
8
Bioceramies Volume10
solutions, the solutions with SiO./Na.O ratio of 0.5, 0.67, 0.8, 1.0, 1.5 and 2.0 were prepared by adding reagent grade NaOH or SiO ^ xH^ O into sodium metasihcate solution, where Si concentration was fixed at 3.0 M. Preparatio n of l.SSBF The 1.5SBF with ion concentrations (Na^ 213.0, K^ 7.5, Mg^^ 2.3, Ca^^ 3.8, CI’ 223.2, HCO3’ 6.3, HPO/ 1.5, s o / 0.8 mM) 1.5 times the SBF was prepared by dissolving reagent grade NaCl, NaHC03, KCl, K^HPO.^H^O, MgCl^^H^O, CaCl^ and Na^SO^ into distilled water. The pH of the solution was adjusted at 7.25 with NH^QCH^OH) and 1 M-HCl at 36.5T. Apatit e coatin g on polyme r Rectangular substrates (10 x 10 x 1 mm ) of poly (ethylene terephthalate) (PET) were abraded #400 and washed with ethanol. And then the substrates were subjected to a glow discharge treatment in O2 gas for 30 s [4] for producing polar groups on the polymer surfaces, which might contribute to the strong attachment between silicate ions and the substrate. After the treatment, the substrates were soaked in sodium sihcate solutions with various concentrations and Si02/Na20 ratios for 6 h at 36.5T. After removing from the solution, the substrates were dried at room temperature, rinsed with distilled water and then soaked in 20 ml of 1.5 SBF for various periods. A fabric (10 x 15 mm^ in area) woven with ultrafme PET fiber (2 \xm^)(Toray Co. Ltd., Otsu, Japan) was also used as a substrate. Surfac e analysi s After the soaking in 1.5 SBF, surface structural and morphological variations of the specimens were characterized by a thin-film X-ray diffractometer (TF-XRD; thin-film attachment CN2651A1, Rigaku-Denki Co., Tokyo, Japan), a Fourier transformed infrared (FT-IR) reflection spectrometer (System 2000 FT-IR, Perkin-Elmer Ltd., Buckinghamshire, England) and a scanning electron microscope (SEM; S-2500CX, Hitachi Co., Tokyo, Japan). RESULT S AND DISCUSSIO N Effect of concentratio n of sodiu m silicat e solutio n Figure 1(a) shows the TF-XRD patterns of the surfaces of PET substrates soaked in 1.5 SBF for 6 d after soaking in sodium metasihcate solutions with various concentrations for 6 h. The peaks ascribed to apatite were observed for the 2.0 and 3.0 M-treated specimens. Figure 2 shows the SEM photographs of the surfaces of PET substrates soaked in 1.5 SBF for 6 d after soaking in sodium metasihcate solutions with various concentrations for 6 h. In the case of 0.5 M, apatite particles were deposited only on a small part of the surface of the substrate. The number of apatite particles increased for the treatment with 1.0 M solution. Moreover, whole surfaces of the substrates were covered with apatite layer for the treatment with 2.0 and 3.0 M solutions. These results indicate that the apatite-forming tendency becomes higher with increasing concentration of sodium sihcate solution. This is explained by assuming that the number of sihcate ions attached to the substrates increased with increasing concentration of sodium silicate solution, forming more apatite nuclei. It should be, however, noted that the degree of the apatite formation is almost the same between 2.0 and 3.0 M. This suggests that the number of sihcate ions attached to the substrates are saturated at 2.0 M concentration. Effect of compositio n of sodiu m silicat e solutio n Figure 1(b) shows the TF-XRD patterns of the surfaces of PET substrates soaked in 1.5SBF for 6 d after soaking in sodium silicate solutions with various Si02/Na2 0 ratios for 6 h. The peaks ascribed to apatite were observed for 1.0 and 1.5 of Si02/Na20 ratios. Figure 3 shows the SEM photographs of the surfaces of PET substrates soaked in 1.5 SBF for 6 d after
Apatite Formation on Polymers by BiomimeticProcessing: F. Miyaji F. et al. 9 O Apatite
O Apatite
SiOg / Na20
20 30 40 50 60 i^ 20 30 40 50 60 26 (CuKa) / degree 29 (CuKa) / degree Figure 1 TF-XRD patterns of the surfaces of PET substrates soaked in 1.5SBF for 6 d after soaking in sodium silicate solutions with (a) various concentrations and (b) various Si02/Na20 ratios for 6 h. 10
fi 6 ' D3
go fi CD
mMm
0 fi O O O u D Rt
’0fiOQQuD
Figure 2 SEM photographs of the surfaces of PET substrates soaked in 1.5SBF for 6 d after soaking in sodium metasilicate solutions with various concentrations for 6 h.
Hofi
o'
iofi tlfiCQQuD
’’Wm
Figure 3 SEM photograplis of the surfaces of PET substrates soaked in 1.5SBF for 6 d after soaking in sodium sihcate solution with various Si02/Na2 0 ratios for 6 h.
10 Bioceramies Volume10
soaking in sodium silicate solution with various Si02/Na2 0 ratios for 6 h. No apatite was observed for 0.5 of ^\0^f^?i^Oratio. The whole surfaces of the substrates were covered with apatite for 1.0 and 1.5 of Si02/Na20 ratios. Apatite particles were deposited on the substrates in part for 2.0 of Si02/Na2 0 ratio. These indicate that the sodium silicate solutions with 1.0 and 1.5 of Si02/Na2 0 ratios are most adequate for apatite formation. It is well known that the structure of sihcate ions changes with the composition of sodium silicate solutions [5]: silicate ions are primarily present as monomer for SiO2/Na2O<1.0, dimer, linear trimer and/or cychc tetramer for 1.0<SiO2/Na2O<2.0, and polymer larger than oligomer for SiO2/Na2O>2.0. Taking into account that the substrates which were treated with sodium silicate solutions of 1.0-1.5 of Si02/Na20 ratio formed apatite most effectively, silicate oligomers such as dimer, linear trimer and/or cyclic tetramer might most contribute to the apatite nucleation. Apatite coating on PET fabric It was observed by SEM that the continuous apatite layer is formed on each fine PET fiber. The apatite layer was interconnected each other and it was not peeled off even by the bending of the fabric. Characteristics of apatite In the present work, even in the case where apatite-forming ability is the highest, the surface of the apatite layer was not smooth. Tliis indicates that the number of apatite nuclei formed on the substrates are not enough for forming dense and uniform apatite layer, which may be due to lower apatite-forming ability of adsorbed silicate ions compared with that of silicate ions released from CaO, Si02-based glass grains. The adhesiveness of the apatite to the substrate was also lower in the former than in the latter. This is explained by assuming that the bonding of sihcate ions with the substrate surface is not stable. However, the most distinct advantage of this method from other ones is a possible coating of the bonelike apatite on various materials with complex shapes. The bonehke apatite layer is formed not only on the flat surfaces but also on curved surfaces of fine PET fibers constituting a fabric. This structure is quite similar to that of natural bone in part. If this composite can be fabricated into three dimensional structure analogous to that of natural bone, the resultant composite could exhibit analogous mechanical properties to those of natural bone, in its elastic modulus as well as in its strength and fracture toughness. ACKNOWLEDGMENT This work was supported by a Grant-in-Aid for Scientific Research, The Ministry of Education, Science, Sports and Culture, Japan. REFERENCES 1. Tanahashi, M., Yao, T., Kokubo, T., Minoda, M, Miyamoto, T., Nakamura, T. and Yamamuro, T., 7. Am. Ceram, Soc. 1994, 77, 2805-2808. 2. Tanahashi, M., Yao, T, Kokubo, T., Minoda, M., Miyamoto, T., Nakamura, T. and Yamamuro T., 7. Ceram, Soc. Japan 1994, 102, 822-829. 3. Kokubo, T., Kushitani, H., Sakka, S., Kitsugi, T. and Yamamuro, T., 7 Biomed.Mater.Res. 1990,24,721-734. 4. Tanahashi, M., Yao, T, Kokubo, T, Minoda, M., Miyamoto, M, Nakamura, T. and Yamamuro, T., 7 Biomed.Mater.Res.1995, 29, 349-357. 5. Her, R.K., In: Ue Chemistryof Silica,John Wiley & Sons, New York 1979, 130-145.
Bioceramics, Volume 10 Edited by L. Sedel and C. Rey (Proceedings of the 10th InternationalSymposium on Ceramics in Medicine, Paris, France, October 1997) '1997 Elsevier Science Ltd
BONELIK E APATIT E FORMATIO N ON THE SURFACE OF CHEMICALL Y TREATE D TANTALUM SUBSTRATES : EFFEC T OF HEAT TREATMEN T T. Miyazaki\ H. M. Kiin\ F. Miyaji\ T. Kokubo^ and T. Nakamura^ ^Department of Material Chemistry, Faculty of Engineering, Kyoto University, Sakyo-ku, Kyoto 606-01, Japan, ^Department of Orthopedic Surgery, Faculty of Medicine, Kyoto University, Sakyo-ku, Kyoto 606-01, Japan
ABSTRAC T It was previously shown that the induction period for apatite formation on Ta metal in a simulated body fluid (SBF) is decreased from 4 to 1 weeks, when it was treated with a NaOH solution to form a sodium tantalate gel layer on it. The sodium tantalate gel layer as-formed on the surface of the NaOH-treated Ta metal is, however, mechanically unstable and easily peeled off from the substrate. In the present study, the effects of the heat treatment on the structure and apatiteforming ability of the surface layer of the NaOH-treated Ta metal were investigated. The sodium tantalate gel layer which was formed on Ta via NaOH-treatment was dehydrated and stabilized by the heat treatment above 300 C. The NaOH-treated Ta metal heat-treated at 300 C showed almost equal induction period for the apatite formation to that of the substrate without heat treatment. KEYWORDS : Tantalum, Heat treatment, Simulated body fluid (SBF), Bioactivity, Apatite, Sodium tantalate INTRODUCTIO N Metallic materials such as stainless steel and titanium alloys have a high strengths and hence have been widely used for orthopedic implants under highly loaded condition. They, however, do not bond directly to living bone. On the other hand, some ceramic materials are known to bond directly to living bone via formation of a bonelike apatite layer on their surfaces [1]. If such a bonelike apatite layer is formed on the surfaces of the metals in vivo,they can directly bond to living bone. Since Ta metal shows high malleability and ductility and hence can be fabricated in complex shapes [2], bioactive Ta metal is expected to be useful as orthopedic implants in complicated shapes. It was previously shown that a dense and uniform bonelike apatite layer was formed on Ta metal within 1 week when it was treated with NaOH aqueous solution and soaked in simulated bodyfluid(SBF) with ion concentrations nearly equal to human blood plasma [3]. This induction period for the apatite formation is much shorter than that of the untreated Ta metal, 4 weeks. In the process of the NaOH treatment, sodium tantalate gel layer is formed on the surface of Ta metal. The surface gel layer is, however, unstable and easily peeled off from the substrate. Heat treatment of the NaOH-treated Ta metal is expected to dehydrate and densify the surface gel layer as in the case of the NaOH-treated Ti metal [4]. In the present study, the effects of the heat treatment on the surface structure, stability of the surface layer, and apatiteforming ability in SBF were investigated for the NaOH-treated Ta metal.
12 Bioceramics Volume10
MATERIAL S AND METHOD S Tantalum plates of 10 X10 X1 mm^ were ground with #400 diamond paste, treated with 5 ml of 0.5 A/-NaOH aqueous solutions at 60 C for 24 h, washed with distilled water and dried at 40 C for 24 h. After the above treatments they were heated up to various temperatures, from 200 to 500 C, at a rate of 5 C/min in an electric ftinace, inunediately took out of the fiimace, and allowed to cool in room temperature. In order to examine the stability of the surface layer, the NaOH-treated Ta substrates with and without heat treatment were attached with Scotch tapefi and then it was detached. The NaOH- and heat-treated Ta substrates were soaked in 30 ml of simulated body fluid (SBF) with ion concentrations nearly equal to those of human blood plasma [5] and pH7.40 at 36.5 C for various periods until 4 w. The surface structural changes of the Ta due to the NaOH treatments and soaking in SBF were characterized by thin-film X-ray diffraction (Thin-film attachment CN2651A1, Rigaku, Co., Tokyo, Japan) and scanning electron microscopy (SEM; S-2500CX, Ifitachi Co., Tokyo, Japan). Changes in element concentrations and pH of SBF due to soaking of the specimens were measured by inductively coupled plasma (ICP) atomic emission spectroscopy (Model SPS-1500VR, Seiko Instrument Co., Japan) and a pH meter (Model D-14, Horiba Co., Japan). RESULT S AND DISCUSSIO N Figure 1 shows the SEM photographs of the detached surface of Ta substrates with and without heat treatment at 300 C after the NaOH-treatment. The gel layer on the surface of asNaOH-treated Ta substrate without heat treatment was mechanically so weak that it was easily peeled off the substrate. On the other hand, the surface layer of the substrate which was heattreated at 300 C was not peeled off from and the glue of the tape remained on the substrate. This indicates that the sodium tantalate gel layer on Ta metal was stabilized by the heat treatment as low as at 300 C. Figure 2(a) shows the thin-film X-ray diffraction patterns of the surfaces of Ta substrates with NaOH-treatment and heat treatment. The sodium tantalate gel layer remained as an amorphous phase up to 300 C, taking into account the broad halo patterns at about 30 in 29, and it converted into crystalline sodium tantalate at 500 C. In the former process below 300 C, the sodium tantalate gel layer might be dehydrated to form an amorphous sodium tantalate layer. Figure 2(b) shows the thin-film X-ray diffraction patterns of the surfaces of Ta substrates which were subjected to NaOH and heat treatments, and subsequent soaking in SBF for Iweek. The NaOH-treated Ta metal heat-treated at 300 C showed almost equal induction period for the As NaOH-treated
With heat treatment at 300 C
'8(9 ' (§QOQ'
m
Figure 1 SEM photographs of the detached surfaces of Ta substrates with (right) and without (left) heat treatment at 300 C after 0.5M-NaOH treatment.
Bonelike Apatite Formation on theSurface of TantalumSubstrates:T. Miyazaki et al. 13
10
20
30
40
50
60
10
2ft(CuKa) /deg.
20
30
40
50
60
2B(CuKa) /deg.
Figur e 2 Thin-fil m X-ra y diffractio n pattern s of the surface s of Ta substrate s which were subjecte d to 0.5A/-NaOH treatmen t and heat treatmen t (a) and subsequen t soakin g in SBF for 1 w (b). 155
None -*-
8 i4oJ r c o O 135-
Na 50
100
150
200
0
Soaking time /h
1 -1
E
^ 0.9 C
o
(0 C 0.8 -
(1)
50
100
150
Soaking time /h
200
o c o Oo.7-
50
100
150
200
Soaking time /h
L
^ V^500 C \ ^ \ "^ \ 300 C V. "^ None ^ 1
50
,
100
1
150
200
Soaking time /h
Figur e 3 Change s in element concentration s and pH with soakin g of NaOH-treate d Ta substrate s with and withou t heat treatment .
14 Bioceramies Volume10
apatite formation to that of the substrate without heat treatment, whereas that heat-treated at 500 C showed the induction period as long as 2 weeks. At any rate, these induction periods are much shorter than that of original Ta substrate without NaOH-treatment, 4 weeks. Figure 3 shows the changes in element concentrations and pH with soaking of NaOH-treated Ta substrate with and without heat treatments. The pH value and the concentration of Na steeply increased and those of Ca and P decreased with soaking of Ta substrates in SBF for all the treatments. The increase in pH at the initial soaking period is significantly smaller in heat treatment at 500 C than in heat treatment at 300 C and without heat treatment. The difference in the apatite-forming ability with the heat treatment conditions are explained as follows. The tantalum oxide hydrogel laytir is formed on the NaOH- and heat-treated Ta metals by ion exchange of Na^ ion in the amorphous or crystalline sodium tantalate layer with HsO^ ion in SBF when they were soaked in SBF. It is assumed that thus formed tantalum oxide hydrogel induces apatite nucleation and the released Na^ ion increases the degree of supersaturation with respect to apatite in SBF by increasing pH to accelerate the apatite nucleation. The apatite nuclei grow into a continuous layer by incorporating the Ca^^ and P04^" ions from the surroundingfluidwhich is already supersaturated with respect to the apatite [3]. In this case, the rate of apatite formation should be governed by the rate of the Na^ ion release fron the sodium tantalate layer, since it determines the rates of the tantalum oxide hydrogel formation and the increase in the degree of supersaturation with respect to apatite in SBF. The rate of the Na^ ion release decreased with increasing heat treatment temperature due to the dehydration and densification of the sodium tantalate gel layer. Therefore, the rates of the tantalum oxide hydrogel formation and the increase in the degree of supersaturation of SBF decreased and hence the induction period for the apatite formation increased in the order without heat treatments treatment at 300 C< treatment at 500 C. The increase of induction period for the apatite formation was especially remarkable for the treatment at 500 C (2 weeks) because the crystalline sodium tantalate gave only a small amount of Na^ ion release, resulting in the small pH increase (SeeFig.3) In conclusion, the Ta metal which was subjected to NaOH and 300 C-heat treatment gave the stable surface layer without retarded apatite formation. CONCLUSIO N The surface of the NaOH-treated Ta was stabilized by the heat treatment at 300 C. The induction period for the apatite-formation of it was still much shorter than that without NaOH treatment. Thus NaOH- and heat-treated Ta metal is believed to form apatite on its surface also in vivo in a short period and bond directly to living bone. REFERENCE S 1. Kokubo, T., J.Ceram. Soc. Japan,1991, 99, 965-973. 2. Stackpool, G. J., Kay, A. B., Morton, P., Harvey, E. J., Tanzer, M., Bobyn, J. D., In: Proceedingsof CombinedOrthopaedicResearchSocietiesMeeting,San Diego, California 1995, 45. 3. Miyazaki, T., Kim, H. M., Miyaji, F., Kokubo, T., and Nakamura, T., In: Bioceramics Volume 9, Elsevier, Oxford 1996, 317-320 4. Kim, H. M., Miyaji, F., Kokubo, T., and Nakamura, T., J. Mater.Sci.: Mater.Med, in press 5. Kokubo, T., Kushitani, H., Sakka, S., Kitsugi, T. and Yamamuro, T., J. BiomedMater.Res., 1990, 24, 721-734.
Bioceramics, Volume10 Edited by L. Sedel and C. Rey (Proceedings of the 10th InternationalSymposiumon Ceramics in Medicine, Paris, France, October1997) '1997 Elsevier Science Ltd
INFLUENC E OF MORPHOLOG Y ON
HYDROXYAPATIT E
PARTICL E
SIZE
AND
HAPEX^ M
M.Wang, R Joseph* and W.Bonfield IRC in Biomedical Materials, Queen Mary and Westfield College, Mile End Road, London El 4NS,U.K. Sree Chitra Tirunal Institute for Medical Sciences and Technology, Trivandrum-695 012, Kerala, India
ABSTRAC T Synthetic hydroxyapatite particles of two median sizes and different morphologies have been used to manufacture hydroxyapatite reinforced high density polyethylene composites (HAPEX^^) for medical applications. The effects of hydroxyapatite particle size on properties of the resultant composites were investigated using various techniques. It was found that HAPEX^^ with smaller hydroxyapatite particles possessed higher torsional modulus. Young’s modulus and tensile strength, but lower strain to failure. Examination of fracture surfaces revealed that a mechanical bond existed between the reinforcement and the matrix. particlesize,morphology,polyethylene, composite,property KEYWORDS : hydroxyapatite, INTRODUCTIO N Hydroxyapatite (HA) reinforced high density polyethylene (HOPE) composite, now designated as HAPEX’^^, has been developed since the early 1980’s as an analogue for bone replacement [1]. With 40vol% of HA, HAPEX^^ possesses a stiffness approaching that of cortical bone, a superior toughness and considerable bioactivity [2]. Implants made of HAPEX^^ encouraged bone apposition rather than fibrous encapsulation which is encountered with other implant materials [3]. The modulus and strength of HAPEX^^ are adequate for minor load bearing applications such as orbital floor reconstruction [4]. Recent progress in hydrostatic extrusion of HAPEX^^ indicated that composites with high stiffness and strength (within the bounds for cortical bone) can be manufactured for major load bearing skeletal implants [5]. Previous work on ceramic particle (or glass bead) reinforced polymers suggested that the particle size had effects on mechanical properties of composites [6,7]. Likewise, HA particle size and morphology are expected to influence the properties of HAPEX"^^. In this paper, results obtained from HAPEX’^^ composites with HA of different particle characteristics are reported. Such information is important for other investigations where techniques such as chemical coupling and hydrostatic extrusion are used for the enhancement of properties of HAPEX’^. MATERIAL S AND METHOD S Two grades of synthetic hydroxyapatite powder (P88 HA and P8IB HA, Plasma Biotal Ltd, UK) were incorporated, respectively, into a high density polyethylene (Rigidex HM4560XP, BP Chemicals Ltd, UK) to produce HAPEX^^ through an established processing route [8]. Prior to 15
16
Bioceramics Volume10
composit e processing , the particl e size of HA was measure d with a Malver n MasterSize r and the particl e morpholog y examine d by a JEOL6300 F scannin g electro n microscop e (SEM) . The BET surfac e are a of HA paiticle s was also analysed . Unfilled HDPE and HAPEX^ M with up to 45vol% of HA were produce d 1.75mm and 4mm thick composit e plate s were mad e by compressio n moulding . The molecula r mass of the HDPE matri x was measure d using high temperatur e gel permeatio n chromatograph y (GPC ) and the distributio n of HA particle s in HDPE was investigate d unde r SEM. Tensil e specimen s (ISO 527) were mad e from 1.75mm thick composit e plates . All tensil e tests were conducte d on an Instro n 6025 testin g machin e at a crosshea d speed of 0.5mm/min . Selected tensile fractur e surface s of the HAPEX^ ^ composite s were examine d unde r SEM. For torsiona l tests , rectangula r bar s (25mmx2mmx2mm ) were cut from 4mm thick composit e plates . Torsiona l modulu s of HAPEX^ ^ was determine d using a specially built testin g rig [9]. For dynami c mechanica l analysi s (DMA), specimen s of dimension s 23mmx3mm x 1.75mm were used. All tests were performe d on a Perkin-Elme r DMA 7 system in the temperatur e time scan mode, using the thre e point bendin g configuratio n at the frequenc y of IHz . The stati c stres s was 120% of the dynami c stres s require d in orde r to give a strai n value of 0.02% . A temperatur e rang e of -100 to 110*C was used for specimen s with 0, 20 and 40vol% of HA. A heatin g rat e of 4"C/minut e was maintaine d throughou t the analysis . RESULT S The media n particl e sizes of as-receive d hydroxyapatit e powder s were 4.14jim and 7.32|Lim for P88 HA and P81B HA, respectively , but the particl e size distributio n peake d at 3.8|Lim (P88 HA) or 6.5|a,m (P81B HA). Both grade s of HA had significan t amount s of sub-micro n size particles . Their specific surfac e area s were marginall y different , being 8.27m2/g for P88 HA and 7.61mVg for P81B HA. SEM examinatio n at high magnification s reveale d tha t particle s of both grade s of HA were compact s of crystallites , but these crystallite s appeare d mor e orderl y and were large r in P81B HA tha n in P88 HA. After compounding , HA particle s in both composite s were well dispersed , with a homogeneou s distributio n in the polymer matrix . Subsequen t composit e processin g did not alter these characteristics . Result s obtaine d by high temperatur e GPC showed tha t a slight reductio n in weight averag e molecula r mass of HDPE occurre d durin g compounding . With an increas e in HA volume fraction , the averag e molecula r mass of HDPE was decreased . Tabl e 1 Mechanica l propertie s of HAPEX"^ ^ composite s HA Volume
(%) 0 10 20 30 40 45
Young’ s Modulu s (GPa ) (P88) (P81B)
Tensile Strengt h (MPa ) (P81B) (P88)
0.65+0.02 0.98–0.02 1.60–0.02 2.73–0.10 4.29–0.I7 5.54–0.62
17.89–0.29 18.32+0.34 17.30+0.27 17.00+0.29 17.77+0.09 17.65+0.17 19.55+0.20 19.99–0.15 20.67+1.56 20.85+0.30 18.98+2.11 20.07+1.33
0.72–0.03 0.98+0.07 1.55+0.04 2.46+0.21 3.74+0.14 5.39–0.81
’ rorsiona l Modulu s (GPa ) (P88) (P81B) 0.28+0.09 0.39+0.16 0.48–0.06 0.71+0.16 1.18+0.07 1.46+0.26
0.28–0.09 0.27–0.04 0.39–0.05 0.62–0.07 1.03–0.16 1.23–0.21
Result s obtaine d from tensile and torsiona l testin g ar e tabulate d in Tabl e 1. Young’ s and torsiona l modul i as well as tensile strengt h of HAPEX^ ^ increase d significantl y with an increas e in HA volume fraction , while fractur e strai n decreased . Composite s with high HA volume s (up to 40% ) possessed considerabl e ductiht y (fractur e strai n = 4.5% with 40vol% of P81B HA). With 45vol% of HA, the composite s becam e brittl e and exhibite d a reduce d tensile strength .
Influenceof Hydroxyapatite Particle Size and Morphology on Hapex : M. Wang et al.
17
SEM examinatio n of tensile fractur e surface s of the composite s suggested tha t ther e was no chemica l bond between HA and HDPE . The polymer flowed aroun d the HA particle s and the particle s debonde d from the matri x durin g tensile testing . No residua l polyethylen e was found on HA particle s after tensile fracture. The DMA result s presente d in this pape r ar e obtaine d from HAPEX’^ ^ with P81B HA, which ar e used to show trend s rathe r tha n for comparison . For polymeri c materials , the following equation s exist: E = a/e = E’ + iE"
(1)
tan a = E"/E ’
(2)
wher e E is dynami c modulus , E’ is storag e modulu s and E" loss modulus , tan 3 quantifie s the interna l frictio n or damping . The storag e modulu s (E’ ) of HAPEX"^ ^ is plotte d agains t temperatur e in Figur e 1. As expected , it increase d with an increas e in HA conten t and decrease d with an increas e in temperature . Unlik e storag e modulu s which decrease d monotonicall y with an increas e in temperature , the loss modulu s of the composite s initiall y decrease d with a temperatur e rise from -100*C to -25*C, it then increase d to p e ^ at aroun d 40*C, with a subsequen t decreas e toward s higher temperatures . The tan 3 values were calculate d for HAPEX^ ^ between -100*C and lOO’C . At temperature s of interest , i.e. 20*C, 37 C and 60’C , obtaine d tan d values ar e plotte d agains t HA volum e fractio n in Figur e 2. The additio n of HA reduce d the dampin g of the polymer , with the degre e of reductio n dependin g on HA volume fraction . 10.00 n
S
o
8.00 H
Vp = 0 Vp = 20% Vp = 40%
0.30 n eo 0.2 0 4
0.10
T r -150 -100 -50 0 50 100 150 Temperatur e ( C) Fig.l Variatio n of storag e modulu s with temperatur e for HAPEX^ M with P81B HA
0.00- 1
0.0
r
0.1
0.2 0.3 0.4 HA Volume Fractio n Fig.2 Variatio n of tan d with HA volume fractio n for HAPEX with P81B HA
T
0.1 0.2 0.3 HA Volume Fractio n
Fig.3 Normalise d Young’ s modulu s as a functio n of HA volumefraction for HAPEX^ ^
r
0.2 0.3 0.4 HA Volume Fractio n Fig.4 Normalise d tensile strengt h as a functio n of HA volumefraction for HAPEX^ ^
18 BioceramiesVolume 10
DISCUSSIO N The two grades of particulate hydroxyapatite, P88 HA and P81B HA, do not differ significantly from each other except for their size and morphology. Difference in the properties of the composites can only be attributed to the difference in HA particle size and morphology. Examination of polished surfaces indicated that HAPEX^^ containing either grade of HA had a homogeneous distribution of HA particles in the HDPE matrix. As was discussed in a previous paper [8], the design of the compounding extruder is such that a high level of shear is produced during composite compounding, which results in the break-down of HA particle agglomerates. When composite properties are normalised to those of unfilled HDPE, Young’s and torsional moduli of the composites exhibit monotonic increases with the increase in HA content (Figure 3). The tensile strength experiences an initial decrease but increases to peak at 40vol% of HA. Further addition of HA causes reductions in composite strength (Figure 4). The Young’s and torsional moduli are consistenUy lower for HAPEX^^ with P81B HA than those of HAPEX^M with P88 HA. The difference in median particle size is 3.18|xm between P81B HA and P88 HA (but P81B HA nearly doubles the size of P88 HA), which has caused reductions of O.lSGPa and 0.55GPa in torsional modulus and Young’s modulus respectively. These decreases are relatively small but significant. If HA particles with much larger size differences were used, greater differences in properties would be expected, as was the case for other composites [7]. Since HDPE is a viscoelastic material, it has both the capability to store energy (measured as storage modulus) and the ability to dissipate energy (measured as loss modulus). The dissipation of energy manifests itself as internal friction or damping. In a polymeric composite, the energy dissipation may also comefromthe filler-matrix interface wherefrictionbetween the two phases can occur. It appears that the addition of HA has actually limited the mobility of the amorphous phase in the polymer and hence reduced the damping of the composites. An increase in HA content results in the decrease in polymer volume and thus the overall damping of the composite. CONCLUSION S An increase in hydroxyapatite volume fraction leads to increases of both strength and modulus of the HAPEX’^M composites, with a simultaneous reduction in strain to failure. HAPEX’^^ with smaller hydroxyapatite particles possesses higher torsional modulus. Young’s modulus and tensile strength, but lower strain to failure. It is demonstrated that DMA is useful for studying the viscoelastic behaviour of HAPEX’^ composites. ACKNOWLEDGEMENT S The authors would like to thank their colleagues for assistance and helpful discussions during the course of this work. Support from the UK EPSRC is gratefully acknowledged. R.Joseph is indebted to the British Council for sponsorship.
REFERENCES
1. Bonfield, W., Grynpas, M.D., TuUy, A.E., Bowman, J., Abram, J., Biomaterials(1981), 2, 185-186 2. Bonfield, W., Annals ofNew York AcademyofSciences(1988), 523, 173-177 3. Luklinska, Z.B., Bonfield, W., Bone-Bonding Biomaterials, Reed Healthcare Communications, 1992, 74-77 4. Downes, R.N., Vardy, S., Tanner, K.E., Bonfield, W., Bioceramics4 (1991), 239-245 5. Ladizesky, N.H., Wang, M., Miettinen, E.M., Tanner, K.E., Ward, I.M., Bonfield, W., Proceedingsof theFifthWorldBiomaterialsCongress,Toronto, Canada, 1996,442 6. Landon, G., Lewis, G., Boden, G.F., JournalofMaterialsScience(1977), 12, 1605-1613 7. Xavier, S.F., Schultz, J., Friedrich, K., JournalofMaterialsScience(1990), 25, lAW-lAlQ 8. Wang, M., Porter, D., Bonfield, W., British Ceramic Transactions(1994), 93,91-95 9. Somerton, M., Braden, M., Ward, I.M., Woods, D.W., Biomaterials(1991), 12, 13-16
Bioceramics, Volume 10 Edited by L. Sedel and C. Rey (Proceedings of the 10th InternationalSymposium on Ceramics in Medicine, Paris, France, October 1997) '1997 Elsevier Science Ltd
EFFEC T OF FLUORID E SUBSTITUTIO N ON THE BIOCOMPATIBILIT Y OF HYDROXYAPATIT E King K.A.,1 Di-SUvio L.,2 Gibson I. R.,1 Ohtsuki C.,^ Jha L. J.,1 Best S.M.,1 Bonfield W. 1 IRC in Biomedical Materials, Queen Mary and Westfield College, Mile End Road, London El 4NS, UK. 2 IRC in Biomedical Materials, Institute of Orthopaedics, Brockley Hill, Stanmore, HA7 4LP,UK. 3 Biomaterials Laboratory, Faculty of Engineering, Okayama University, Tsushima, Okayama 700, Japan ABSTRAC T Hydroxyapatite (HA) and 0.2 and 0.3 wt% fluoride-substituted apatite (F-HA) were studied using in vitrotesting by both inmiersion in simulated body-fluid and direct cell culture on ceramic substrates. X-ray diffraction and scanning electron microscopy revealed the formation of a bone› like ^atite layer on F-HA discs after only 3 days inunersion in simulated body-fluid, compared to 14 days on HA discs. The increased activity of the substituted ^atite was confirmed by in vitro assessment using a primary human osteoblast-like (HOB) cell line. HOB cells cultured on the substituted apatites demonstrated elevated levels of tritiated thymidine incorporation compared to pure HA. However, alkaline phosphatase expression after 7 days in vitrowas found to be independent of substrate composition, indicating that fluoride substitution did not affect the phenotypic expression of the HOB cells. Scanning electron microscopy of the cultures after 1 day in vitrodemonstrated formation of a bone-like apatite layer on the surface of the 0.3wt% F-HA, and a protein-like layer was identified on both 0.2 and 0.3 wt% F-HA discs after 3 days in vitro. INTRODUCTIO N De Jong Was the first to observe the similarities between the X-ray diffraction patterns of bone powder and hydroxyapatite in 1926 and until recently, bone mineral was widelyregardedas being analogous to hydroxyapatite. However, the apatite lattice accommodates many ionic substitutions^’^ and it is therefore not surprising that bone mineral, which is produced in solution in the presence of many complex and varied physiological fluids, is composed of a highly substituted non-stoichiometric hydroxyapatite. The principle substituent is carbonate which replaces phosphate groups^, but the calcium ions also undergo substitution by ions such as sodium, magnesium, and strontium^*^ and the hydroxyl groups are reported to be readily exchanged with fluoride and chloride^. It therefore follows that the substitution of controlled levels of the appropriate ions into the hydroxyapatite lattice could be advantageous as a result of closer mimicry to bone mineral. In this study an assessment of the effect of a single lattice substitution (fluoride for hydroxyl) has been made. Ruoride levels in natural bone mineral have been reported as between 0.02 and 0.08 wt % ^’9. 19
20
Bioceramies Volume10 14 Days
JL
J^
7 Days
14 Days 7 Days
*Ac^
a
AMUWA .
3 Days
-.gu^AJkLk. LI
ODays
1 I I I I I I I I I I I 1*1^*1 M f’\ i f I 1 ’ I* rt
20
25
30
35
40
45
50
20
25
30
35
40
45
rr^
50
(5) Diffraction Angle (26) (a) Diffraction Angle (26) Figure 1 XRD patterns for SBF immersed (a) HA and (b) 0.3 wt% F-HA disks. MATERIAL S AND METHOD S Hydroxy^atite was prepared by a precipitation reaction between stoichiometric proportions of calcium nitrate and diammonuium orthophosphate solutions^^. The substitution of 0.2 and 0.3 wt % fluoride was achieved by the addition of varying concentrations of ammonium fluoride during precipitation. The filter cake was dried and milled to pass through a <75 pm sieve. The sieved powder was uniaxially pressed into discs at 40 MPa and sintered at 1200 C for 2 hours to a final diameter of either 12 or 25 mm. The flat surfaces of the larger discs were polished to a 1 pm surface finish and placed in K-9 simulated body fluid (SBF) solution^ ^ for 3, 7 and 14 days at 36.5 C. After immersion, the surfaces of the discs were analysed for any spontaneous apatite precipitate using X-ray diffraction (XRD) and scanning electron microscopy (SEM). The as-sintered, flat surfaces of the smaller discs were seeded with human osteoblast-like (HOB) cells and incubated in Dulbecco’s Modified Eagles Medium, supplemented with 10 % foetal calf serum, at 37 *C in a humidified, 5% CO2 atmosphere for up to 7 days. As a control, cells were also cultured on Thermanox discs. Cellular activity and proliferation were assessed by measurement of the total DNA^^ and the ^H TdR uptake on 2 and 4 day cultures which had been exposed to ^H TdR for the last 24 hours of culture. Alkaline phosphatase (ALP), a predictive marker of osteoblastic phenotype and differentiation, was assayed on 7 day cultures using a COB AS-BIO (Roche, UK) centrifugal analyser. The cellular morphology and activity of 1 and 3 day cultures were studied qualitatively using scanning electron microscopy. 4 los
250-]
0.2 wt% 0.3 wt% F-HA F-HA
Released in Medium Produced in Cell Lysate
Control
HA
L
^^
0.2 wt% F-HA
0.3 wt% F-HA
Figure 2 Results of biochemical assays indicating (a) relative cellular activity (proUferation) and (b) expression of cellular phenotype (differentiation).
Effect of Fluoride Substitutionon the Biocompatibilityof Hydroxyapatite:K.A. Hing et al.
21
RESULT S AND DISCUSSIO N Change s in the intensit y and broadnes s of peak s obtaine d by surfac e XRD of SBF soaked discs indicate d the presenc e of precipitate d £^tit e after 14 days on HA discs compare d to only 3 days on F-HA discs (Fig. 1). The increase d activit y in the substitute d apatite s was confirme d by the result s of the biochemica l assay s performe d on the HOB cell cultures , in which cells incubate d on the substitute d 2q)atite s demonstrate d elevated levels of ^H TdR incorporatio n compare d to pur e HA (Fig. 2a). In contrast , it appeare d tha t substitutio n did not effect the phenotypi c expressio n of the HOB cells, with cells incubate d on both HA and F-HA substrate s expressin g similar levels of ALP after 7 days invitro(Fig. 2b). Scannin g electro n microscop y of culture s demonstrate d tha t HOB cells incubate d on the contro l and 0.3 wt% F-HA substrate s possessed a mor e flattene d morpholog y (Fig. 3a,d) in compariso n to the HOB cells incubate d on the 0.2 wt% F-HA and particularl y the HA substrate s (Fig. 3b,c). Thi s agree s well with the findings of the ^H TdR incorporation , as a flattene d morpholog y generall y indicate s a well attache d cell^^ , wher e cell attachmen t has been shown to affect the proliferatio n rat e of osteoblast s in vitro^^.Furthermore , a protein-lik e layer was
Figur e 3 Scannin g electro n micrograph s demonstratin g typica l HOB cell morphologie s when culture d for 1 day on (a) Thermanox , (b) HA, (c) 0.2 wt% and (d) 0.3 wt% F-HA substrates .
22
Bioceramics Volume if)
Figur e 4 Scannin g electro n micrograp h demonstratin g a bone-lik e ^atit e layer on a 0.3 wt% F-HA substrat e after 1 day in HOB cell culture . identifie d on both the F-HA substrate s after 3 days invitroand the formatio n of a bone-lik e apatit e layer on 0.3 wt% F-HA substrate s was noted after 1 day in vitro(Fig. 4). This behaviou r has previousl y been reporte d to be indicativ e of a bioactiv e surface^^*^^ . CONCLUSIO N The substitutio n of low levels of fluorid e into the apatit e lattic e has resulte d in an elevate d level of bioactivit y when compare d to tha t of stoichiometri c hydroxy^atite . ACKNOWLEDGEMENT S The author s wish to acknowledg e thefinancial suppor t of EPSR C (UK) and JNIC T (Portugal) . REFERENCE S 1 De Jon g WJ. , Rec. Trav . Chim. , 45,445,1926 2 Posner A.S. Physiologica l Reviews. 49 (4), 760-792,1969 3 Le Gero s R.Z., Le Gero s J.P. , In: An Introductio n to Bioceramics , Eds: Hench LI.. , Wilson J. Worl d Scientific, Singapore , 1993 4 Le Gero s R.Z., Traut z O.R., Le Gero s J.P. , Klein E., Bull. Soc. Chim . Franc . 1712-1713,1968 5 Vaugha n J.M . The Physiology of Bone. Clarendo n Press , Oxford , 1981 6 Posner A.S., Eane s E.D., Harpe r R.A., Zipki n I., Arch . Ora l Biol., 8, 549-570,1963 7 Posner A.S., BuU. Hosp. Join t Dis., 39,126-144,1978 8 Aoki H. Science and Medica l Application s of Hydroxyapatite . Takayam a Press , Tokyo , 1991 9 Le Gero s R.Z., Proc . Inter . Sem. Orthop . Res. Ed: Niwa S., Springer-Verlag , Nagoya , 1992 10 Jh a LJ. , Best S.M., Santo s J.D., Bonfield W., Bioceramics , 9,165-168,1996 11 Kukub o T., Kushitan i H., Sakk a S., Kitsug i T., Yamamur o T., J. Biomed. Mater . Res. 24, 721-734,1990 12 Kapuscinsk i J., Skoczyla s B., Anal. Biochem., 83, 252-257,1977 13 Hunte r A., Arche r C.W., Walke r P.S., Blunn . Biomaterials , 16 (4), 287-295,1995 14 Folkma n J., Moscona A., Nature , 273, 345-349,1978 15 Davies J.D . The Bone-Biomateria l Interface . Toronto , Universit y of Toront o Press , 1991 16 de Bruiji n J. Calciu m Phosphat e Biomaterials : Bone Bondin g and Biodegredatio n Properties , PhD. Thesis , Leiden , 1993
Bioceramics, Volume 10 Edited by L. Sedel and C. Rey (Proceedings of the 10th InternationalSymposium on Ceramics in Medicine, Paris, France, October 1997) '1997 Elsevier Science Ltd
APATIT E PRECIPITATIO N IN BIPHASI C CALCIU M PHOSPHAT E CERAMI C AFTE R INCUBATIO N IN RABBI T SERU M AND IONI C SIMULATE D BODY FLUI D (SBF) R. Rohanizadeh, J.M. Bouler, D. Couchourel, M. Padrines and G. Daculsi Centre de recherche interdisciplinaire sur les materiaux d’interet biologique - UPRES 2159, 1 Place A. Ricordeau, 44042 Nantes cedex 01, France
ABSTRAC T To evaluate the influence of organic factors in the precipitation process, biphasic calcium phosphate blocks were incubated in ionic simulated body fluid (SBF) and rabbit serum. Fragments of block surface were observed and analyzed by transmission electron microscopy after 2 and 6 weeks, and the compressive strength of the blocks was measured after 8 weeks. The results showed that i) apatitic microcrystals appeared around ceramic crystals in both solutions; ii) organic factors such as proteins and enzymes may control crystal growth and nucleation; iii) precipitated microcrystals were in continuity with the lattice planes of hydroxyapatite (HA) ceramic crystals; and iv) microcrystals were more aggregated around HA than p-tricalcium phosphate implants. KEYWORD S Calcium Phosphate, Precipitation, Ultrastructure INTRODUCTIO N A hydroxyapatite (HA)/p-tricalcium phosphate (p-TCP) mixture (60/40% by weight) produces biphasic calcium phosphate (BCP) with optimal properties for bone substitution [1]. Precipitation of carbonated apatite resulting fi-om the dissolution/precipitation process has been observed after implantation of BCP [2]. Precipitated microcrystals decrease the void space between crystals, enhancing the mechanical properties of the ceramic [3]. Although precipitation is a physicochemical reaction, organic factors such as proteins and enzymes may influence this process, as in the mineralization of biological tissues. To investigate the effects of organic factors on precipitation, we incubated BCP blocks in two different solutions: ionic simulated body fluid (SBF) and rabbit serum. Transmission electron microscopy (TEM) was used to investigate crystal morphology, the structure of the precipitates, and the influence of the seed species (HA and (3TCP). The relative effects of precipitation on the compressive strength of incubated BCP were also studied. MATERIAL S AND METHOD S Three blocks of macroporous BCP (5x5x10 mm, Triosite^^, Zimmer, France) composed of 60% HA and 40% P-TCP were incubated in 2 ml of rabbit serum and in SBF prepared according to a previously described method [4]. The blocks were kept in sterile conditions in an oven at 37 . After 2 and 6 weeks, fragments of block surface were embedded in LR White and cut into ultrathin sections (90 nm) for TEM analysis. To measure compressive strength after 2 months, the ends of blocks were removed and each block was cut horizontally into 3 equal parts. TEM observations at 23
24
Bioceramics Volume10
low and high magnification s were then carrie d out at 200 Kv (Jeol 200 CX). Electro n diffractio n was performe d to identif y the structur e of cerami c and precipitate d crystals , and the pattern s were indexed and identifie d by mean s of a simulato r (Electro n Diffractio n 2.4, Laboratoir e de Metallurgi e Physique , LSPES ) which used store d crystallographi c dat a for known calcium phosphat e phase s and generate d pattern s for direc t compariso n with observe d diffractio n patterns . RESULT S AND DISCUSSIO N TEM studie s of fragments incubate d in SBF reveale d tha t needle-shape d microcrystal s precipitate d aroun d cerami c crystal s (Fig. la). The shap e and size of precipitate d microcrystal s did not var y in differen t areas . The precipitate s were very well crystallized , and the lattic e plane s of the microcrystal s could be observe d in high-resolutio n TEM (HrTEM ) (Fig. lb). These plane s of 0.82 nm and 0.53 nm, with an angle of 72 between them , corresponde d respectivel y to apatit e lattic e plane s of (100) and (101). Figur e lb shows tha t precipitate s in SBF grew along the a-axis of the apatit e structur e (lattic e plane s of (100)). Electro n diffractio n confirme d tha t the structur e of precipitate d microcrystal s was apatiti c (Fig. Ic), showing a ring diffractio n patter n of precipitate d microcrystal s in SBF. D-spacin g of the first and second rings was 0.35 and 0.28 nm respectively , correspondin g to apatit e lattic e plane s of (002) and (112).
Figur e 1. TEM (a), HrTE M (b) observations , and electro n diffractio n of precipitate d microcrystal s (P) aroun d cerami c crystal s (C). In rabbi t serum , precipitate d microcrystal s were also observe d aroun d cerami c crystal s (Fig. 2a). As they were poorl y crystallize d and very fragile unde r irradiation , their lattic e plane s
Apatite Precipitationin BCP After Incubation in Rabbit Serum and SBF: R. Rohanizadehet al.
25
could not be observed in high-resolution TEM. As in SBF, the electron diffraction pattern of microcrystals in serum showed a ring pattern corresponding to the apatite structure (Fig. 2b). In contact with ceramic crystals, the precipitates in serum took the form of small round microcrystals, whose shape and size changed with increasing distance from the crystal surface until they ultimately became flattened crystals. Comparison of the precipitation between two different solutions indicated that organic factors in the serum changed the shape, size and crystallinity rate of the precipitates. These organic factors did not modify the crystal structure of the precipitates, which was apatitic in both solutions. TEM observations in serum showed that the size of precipitates in contact with the ceramic surface was smaller than in SBF. In fact, some proteins may have adhered to the ceramic surface [5]. In biological fluid, non-coUagenic proteins such as osteopontin and bone sialoprotein [6] can affect crystal nucleation and growth. In serum, organic factors also inhibited growth along the a-axis, with crystals assuming flattened shapes.
Figure 2. TEM observation (a) and electron diffraction pattern (b) of precipitated microcrystals (P) around ceramic crystals (C) in serum. Figure 3a and b presents high-resolution TEM observations of the junction between ceramic and precipitated microcrystal. Figure 3a shows an HA crystal with lattice planes of (100). Precipitates were in continuity with the lattice planes of the MA crystal (homogeneous epitaxic growth). Figure 3b shows a p-TCP crystal. The fiinge along the edge of the crystal indicates that precipitation proceeded in a direction different from that of the lattice planes of p-TCP. Electron diffraction showed that apatitic precipitated microcrystals were more abundant and were aggregated more around HA than p-TCP ceramic, since both HA and microcrystals have an apatite structure. In terms of potential energy for the system, the growth of apatitic microcrystals that prolong HA lattice planes is more favorable than that developing within the p-TCP structure. Table 1 shows the compressive strength of incubated and non-incubated blocks. Compressive strength increased after incubation in both solutions, though this increase was greater for rabbit serum than SBF, probably because of the effect of drying on the organic material in the former solution. In fact, one resuh of the presence of precipitated microcrystals was a decrease in ceramic microporosity which enhanced the mechanical properties of the ceramic.
26
Bioceramics Volume10
Figure 3. a) Precipitated microcrystals (P) were in continuity with the lattice plans of HA crystal; b) Precipitated microcrystals were in a direction different from that of the lattice planes of p-TCP. Table 1. Compressive strength of incubated and non-incubated blocks. Before incubation Compressive strength (MPa)
4.07 – 0.02
After incubation in SBF 5.73 –0.01
After incubation in rabbit serum 6.32 –0.07
REFERENCE S 1. Daculsi G., Passuti N., Martin S., Deudon C , LeGeros R.Z. and Raher S., J. Biomed. Mater. Res., 1990, 24, 379-396. 2. Daculsi G., LeGeros R.Z., Heughebaert M. and Barbieux I., Calcif. TissueInt., 1990, 46, 2027. 3. Trecant M., Delecrin J., Nguyen J.M., Passuti N. and Daculsi G., J. Mater. Sci., 1996, 7, 227229. 4. Yamada S., Nakamura T., Kokubo T., Oka M. and Yamamuro T., J. Biomed Mater. Res., 1994, 28, 1357-1363. 5. Fujisawa R. and Kuboki Y., Biochim. Biophys. Acta, 1991, 1075, 56-60. 6. Hunter G. K., Hauschka P.V., Poole A.R., Rosenberg L.C., and Goldberg H.A., Biochem. J., 1996, 317, 59-64.
Bioceramics, Volume 10 Edited by L. Sedel and C. Rey (Proceedings of the 10th InternationalSymposium on Ceramics in Medicine, Paris, France, October 1997) '1997 Elsevier Science Ltd
APATITE PRECIPITATION IN BBPHASIC CALCIUM PHOSPHATE CERAMIC AFTER IMPLANTATION: INFLUENCE OF IMPLANTATION SITE R. Rohanizadeh, M. Trecant-Viana, J. Delecrin, J.M. Bouler and G. Daculsi Centre de recherche interdiscipiinaire sur les materiaux d’interet biologique - UPRES 2159, 1 Place A. Ricordeau, 44042 Nantes cedex 01, France ABSTRACT Diphasic calcium phosphate blocks implanted into rabbit trabecular bone and muscle were recovered 18 weeks later and observed and analyzed by transmission electron microscopy, electron diffraction and electron microprobes. The resuhs showed that: i) apatitic microcrystals appeared by secondary nucleation at both bone and muscle sites; ii) precipitated microcrystals were found around ceramic crystals at bone sites but distributed randomly in micropores at the muscle site; iii) the ratio of calcium to phosphate was higher for microcrystals at bone than muscle sites; and iv) precipitated microcrystals around (J-tricalcium phosphate crystals were less aggregated to the ceramic surface than those around hydroxyapatite. These findings suggest that microenvironmental parameters such as fluid circulation and interaction of ceramics with proteins or cells affect the physicochemical dissolution/reprecipitation process. KEYWORDS Calcium Phosphate, Precipitation, Ultrastructure INTRODUCTION The most widely tested types of bone graft materials are hydroxyapatite (HA) and Ptricalcium phosphate (P-TCP). A mixture of HA and P-TCP produces biphasic calcium phosphate (BCP) which possesses the reactivity of 3-TCP and the stability of HA, providing optimal properties for resorption/bone substitution [1]. Calcium phosphate ceramics undergo physical and chemical changes in biological fluids, causing the precipitation of apatitic microcrystals between ceramic macrocrystals [2]. Precipitation is a physicochemical process which restores the balance between ceramic and fluid. In in vivo conditions calcium phosphates are also in contact with proteins, cells and enzymes, and these biological factors could influence the precipitation process, as in the mineralization of biological tissue. In this study, MBCP (macroporous biphasic calcium phosphate - 70% HA and 30% PTCP) blocks were implanted into rabbit bone and muscle to investigate the influence of the two different environments on precipitation process, the junction between ceramic crystals and precipitated microcrystals, and the influence of two ceramic compounds (HA and p-TCP crystals) on the precipitation process. MATERIALS AND METHODS Twenty cylinders form implants of macroporous BCP (5x5 mm) were implanted into five rabbits. Each animal received 4 implants: two in lefl: and right femurs and two in left and right thighs. The animals were sacrificed after 18 weeks, and the implants were recovered, fixed in 80% 27
28
Bioceramics Volume10
ethyl alcohol and embedde d in methylmethacrylate . A fragmen t of the implan t surfac e was cut with a knife into ultrathi n sections (90 nm thick ) and examine d in transmissio n electro n microscop y (TEM ; Jeol 200CX, 200 Kv) to stud y the morpholog y and spatia l distributio n of precipitate d microcrystal s at two implantatio n sites. Electro n diffractio n and electro n microprob e analysi s were also performe d to identif y the structura l and chemica l component s of cerami c and precipitate d crystal s and the influenc e of HA and P-TC P on precipitation . RESULT S AND DISCUSSIO N TEM studie s showed tha t precipitate d microcrystal s had completel y or partiall y filled the spaces between cerami c crystals . Variation s in the quantit y and densit y of these microcrystal s were observed , especially at muscle sites. A differenc e in the spatia l distributio n of precipitate d microcrystal s was noted at the two sites. The precipitate s were dense and surrounde d cerami c crystal s at bone sites (Fig. 1), while precipitatio n was generall y less dense and occurre d randoml y in the spaces between cerami c crystal s at muscle sites (Fig. 2). This differenc e could have been due to the circulatio n of biological fluids in the microporosity . Because of the natur e of angiogenesi s in bone implants , the circulatio n of biological fluid is greate r tha n in muscle implant s which ar e surrounde d by muscle fibers formin g a capsul e tha t canno t easily be penetrate d by fluids. Fluid circulatio n in the microporosit y of bone implant s could be a factor limitin g precipitatio n between cerami c crystals .
Figur e 1. TEM observatio n showing precipitate d microcrystal s (P) and cerami c crystal s (C) in a bone implan t
Figur e 2. TEM observatio n shovin g precipitate d microcrystal s (?) and cerami c crystal s (C) in a muscle implan t
Figur e 3 shows a rin g patter n of precipitate d microcrystal s at a muscle site in which the ring s correspon d to apatit e (002) and (112) lattic e planes . Electro n diffractio n demonstrate d tha t the precipitate d microcrystal s at both bone and muscle sites were apatite . However , the Ca/P weight rati o obtaine d by microprob e analysi s on precipitate d microcrystal s was higher at bone (2.1 –0.1) tha n muscle sites (2 – 0.05). The lower Ca/P rati o at muscle sites indicate d tha t the microcrystal s containe d less carbonat e or had a high rat e of additiona l non-apatiti c phase s [3]. The rin g electro n diffractio n patter n was not an adequat e mean s of distinguishin g between polycrystal s when additiona l minor phase s formed .
Apatite Precipitationin BCP After Implantation: R.Rohanizadehet al.
29
High-resolutio n TEM demonstrate d tha t epitaxi c growt h was limited at muscle sites, wher e microcrystal s were less associate d with cerami c crystal s and showed a rando m orientation . In physicochemica l terms , epitaxi c growt h can occur at both bone and muscle sites. As in the mineralizatio n of biological tissues, protein s influenc e the precipitatio n process . At a muscle site, some protein s may adher e to the cerami c surfac e and contro l or inhibi t crysta l growth[4-5] . At a bone site, absorbe d nonspecifi c protein s ar e regularl y eliminate d from the cerami c surfac e due to cellular degradation , and growt h is controlle d by specific protein s such as osteoponti n and osteonecti n [6-7]. At both sites, cerami c crystal s identifie d as HA by electro n diffractio n (Fig. 4a) were surrounde d by precipitate s mor e closely associate d with the crysta l surfac e tha n those identifie d as P-TC P (Fig. 4b). As the precipitate d microcrystal s were apatite , the structur e of HA may be mor e favorabl e tha n tha t of (J-TC P to the growt h of apatit e microcrystals .
Figur e 3. Electro n diffractio n patter n of precipitate d microcrystal s (P) at a muscle site; the ring s correspon d to apatiti c lattic e plane s of (002) and (112).
Figur e 4. Electro n diffractio n in a bone implant ; a: an HA crysta l identifie d by electro n diffractio n was surrounde d by precipitate s mor e associate d with the crysta l surface ; b: a P-TC P crysta l
30
Bioceramies Volume10
identified by electron diffraction was surrounded by precipitates less associated with the crystal surface. CONCLUSIO N The features of precipitated microcrystals in implanted ceramics differ according to the implantation site. In the mineralization of biological tissues, elements such as cells and proteins probably influence the local precipitation process. Ceramic/protein and ceramic/cell interactions and their effects on dissolution and reprecipitation have not been clearly identified and require further investigation, e.g. in vitrostudies in different simulated body fluids. REFERENCES 1. Daculsi G., Passuti N., Martin S., Deudon C , LeGeros R.Z. and Raher S, J. Biomed. Mater. Res., 1990, 24, 379-396. 2. Daculsi G., LeGeros R.Z., Heughebaert M. and Barbieux I., Calcif,TissueInt., 1990, 46, 2027. 3. LeGeros R.Z., Daculsi G, Gregoire M., Heughebaert M. and Gineste M., Bone-Bonding.Reed HealthcareCommunication,1992, 89, 201-212. 4. Hunter G. K., Hauschka P.V., Poole A.R., Rosenberg L.C. and Goldberg H.A., Biochem. J., 1996, 317, 59-64. 5. Hunter G.K., Kyle C.L. and Goldberg H.A., Biochem. J., 1994, 300, 723-728. 6. Nagata T., Todescan R., Goldberg H.A., Zhang Q. and Sodek J., Biochem. Biophys. Res. Commun., 1989, 165, 234-240. 7. Fisher L.W. and Termine J.D., CliN Orthop., 1985, 200, 362-385.
GLASS CERAMICS BIOACTIVITY
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
Bioceramics, Volume 10 Edited by L. Sedel and C. Rey (Proceedings of the 10th InternationalSymposium on Ceramics in Medicine, Paris, France, October 1997) '1997 Elsevier Science Ltd
BIOACTIVIT Y AND STRUCTUR E OF ORGANICALL Y MODIFIE D SILICAT E SYNTHESIZE D BY TB E SOL-GE L METHO D Kanji Tsum, Satoshi Hayakawa, Chikara Ohtsuki, and Akiyoshi Osaka Biomaterials Lab., Faculty of Engineering, Okayama University Tsushima, Okayama-shi 700 Japan
ABSTRAC T We investigated effects of H Q and calcium nitrate(Ca(N03)2»4H20) contents in gelling solutions on bioactivity and microstructure of Onnosils-type organically modified silicates. Analysis of 29si MAS NMR spectra indicated that amounts of H Q do not show any significant effects for local structure aroimd Si atoms. The SEM-EDX analysis of fracture-surface for Ormosils-type sample showed that the pore size and amount of Ca incorporated in their structure depended on HCl amounts. We concluded that greater bioactivity was attributed to incorporation of more calcium ions in the polymer due to addition of larger amounts of HCl and/or Ca(N03)2*4H20. INTRODUCTIO N Bioactive ceramics can directly bond to Uving bone via an apatite layer deposited on their surface when they are embedded in the body[l]. Although some of them are already clinically used, they still could not be used for soft-tissue replacements because of their high Young modulus. Thus they should be modified to more softness and toughness for clinical application to repairing sites that needs higher flexibility. Incidentally, Ohtsuki et al. reported that Ca(II) ions and silanol group(Si-OH) were the important components for formation of biologically active apatite layer in a body fluid[2]. One might expect that organically modified ceramics containing calcium and silicates shows the apatite-forming abihty, i.e. bioactivity. On this basis, we recently synthesized Ormosils-type organically modified silicate through sol-gel processing, and found that thus synthesized material formed apatite layer on its surface in a simulated body fluid(SBF)[3,4], This indicates thus synthesized Ormosils-type organically modified ceramic is bioactive, and has potential of serving basis for novel bioactive materials. However, effect of synthetic conditions on the bioactivity and microstructure are not revealed yet. In this study, we investigated effects of the amount of H Q or Ca(N03)2»4H20 added to the solutions for Ormosils-type samples on their bioactivity and microstructure. MATERIAL S AND METHOD S We synthesized caldum-containing Ormosils-type organically modified ceramics starting from ploy(dimethylsiloxane) (PDMS,-(SiO(CH3)2)n-)> tetraethoxysilane (TEOS), Si(OC2H5)4) and calcium nitrate (Ca(N03)2*4H20). One of the typical compositions for starting materials was: TEOS:PDMS:HCl:H20:Ca(N03)2*4H20 = 1 : 1.67 : 0.05 : 3 : 0.05. Detailed procedure was given in the previous reports[3,4]. In the present study, 33
34
Bioceramics Volume10
the ratio of HCl and Ca(N03)2«4H20 was varied in the range of Ha/TEOS=0.05-0.1(mol) and Ca/TEOS=0’-0.1(mol), respectively. The synthesized samples were cut to 15x10x1 mm^ in size, and the surface was polished with a #2000 emery paper. Then they were gently rinsed with ethanol and dried. Microstructure of the fracture-surface was observed with a scaiming electron microscope(SEM), JEOL JSM-6300, equipped with an energy dispersive X-ray analyzer (EDX, PhiUips EDX-4). The specimens were soaked in a simulated body fluid(Kokubo solution) at 36.5 C up to 14 days. The Kokubo solution was prepared as described by Cho et al\5\. It has been proved[6] that the in vivoapatite formation on implants can almost fully be reproduced in vitroexperiments in the Kokubo solution. Thin-film X-ray diffraction(TF-XRD) was used to examine formation of hydroxyapatite layer on the surface of the specimens after soaked in the Kokubo solution. To evaluate local structure around Si atoms in the samples, ^^Si Cross-polarization Magic Angle Spiiming (CP MAS) NMR spectra was measured for the samples after pulverized. In the NMR measurement, the sample spiiming speed was 5-6kHz at the magic angle(54.7 ) to the external field. 29si NMR spectra of the samples were measured at 9.4T on a JEOL JNMGX400 FT-NMR spectrometer, equipped with a TU-GSX400 MAS probe. 29si NMR spectra were acquired at 79.3MHz with 5.0-(xs pulses, 12.0s recycle delays, 15.0(xs dead time. The signals for an 80’-400 pulses were accumulated. The chemical shift (6 in ppm) of 29si was determined using tetramethylsilane(TMS)(6=0 ppm : ^^Si chemical shifts where 6 denoted the isotropic chemical shift) as an external reference substance. Poly dimethyl silane(6=-34.0 ppm) was used as the secondary external reference. RESULT S AND DISCUSSIO N Figure 1 shows the TF-XRD patterns of the samples with varied ratio of HCl after soaked in the Kokubo solution up to 14 days. They are denoted as "HCl X Ca Y " where X is the molar ratio HCl/TEOS(mol) and Y is the molar ratio Ca/TEOS (mol). Fig. 1 indicates that apatite formation on the Ormosils-type samples with a fixed ratio of Ca(N03)2*4H20 was enhanced by the increasing of the amount of HCl added. For the samples with varied ratio of Ca(N03)2*4H20 at H Q of Y=0.1, apatite formation was enhanced by the increasing of the amount of calcium nitrate added. Thus the bioactivity of the Ormosils-type materials was effected not only additional amounts of Ca(N03)2*4H20 but also the amounts of H Q solution. The results of 29si CP MAS NMR measurements shows that two groups of Si atoms were distinguished on the basis (rf the chemical shift: the first peak(-10 to -25 ppm) was due to 02SiMe2(Me=-CH3) units from PDMS while the other peak(-100 to -110 ppm) was due to Si02 units originated from TEOS. Both peaks were very broad because they were the envelopes of a few component peaks. Deconvolution of them on the basis of the chemical shift data in the literature[7] indicates that the former peak had three components and the latter had two. The former curve was fitted with Lorentz functions and the latter was fit with Gaussian functions. Each component in the former peak is assigned to PDMS chain(D) , cyclic ohgomers(E)cycUc) and copolymerized species(D(Q)), respectively. The Si04 units for the latter peaks are denoted as (y^ groups where n represents the number of bridging oxygen atoms around a Si atom in the siUca matrices. Thus obtained peak positions and the relative peak area (%) are given in Table 1. Table 1 indicates that amount of H Q does not show a significant effect for the local structure of Si atoms. Similar was found for the effect of Ca(N03)2*4H20. Fig. 2 shows the results of SEMEDX analysis of fractured surfaces for Ormosils-type samples. Size of pores in the samples seems to increase with increasing the ratio of HCl solution. In addition, the concentration of Ca
Bioactivity and Structureof Organically Modified Silicate: K. Tsuru et al.
25
25
30 35 2e/de g
30 35 2e/de g
25
35
30 35 2e/de g
Figur e 1 TF-XR D pattern s of sample s synthesize d with variou s amount s of HCl after soaked in the Kokub o solution up to 14 days. O : Apatit e
in the sample s also increase d with increasin g the rati o of H Q and Ca(N03)2*4H20 . Therefore , greate r apatite-formin g abilit y has been attribute d to incorporatio n of mor e calcium ions in the polymer due to large r amount s of HQ . Dissolution of Ca(II ) ions in the structur e not only favor s formatio n of a sihca hydroge l layer conductiv e to apatit e nucleatio n but increase s in degre e of siq)ersaturatio n for ^atit e in the Kokub o solution . Therefore , we conclude d tha t controllin g the incorporatio n of Ca(II ) ions is essentia l for preparatio n of bioactiv e Ormosils-typ e organicall y modified ceramics .
Tabl e 1. Peak position s and relativ e peak are a (%) of the 29si CP MAS NMR peaks . The left tabl e is due to 02SiMe2 units(Dgroup ) from PDMS. Theright tabl e is due to Si02 units(Q ^ group ) originate d from TEOS . Dg roups Sampl e nam e
0*^9 roups
6 (relative pea k area , % ) D(Q)
Dcydic
6 (relative pea k area , % )
D
Q3
Q4
HCl 0. 1 -CaO.OS
-17. 2 (28 )
-19. 6 (51 )
-21. 7 (21 )
-102. 3 (24% )
-108. 5 (76% )
HCl 0.0 9
C a 0.0 5
-17. 1 (29 )
-19. 7 (53 )
-21. 9 (18 )
-102. 7 (22 )
-108. 6 (78 )
HCl 0.0 7
C a 0.0 5
-16. 9 (30 )
-19. 7 (49 )
-22. 0 (21 )
-102. 9 (28 )
-108. 7 (72 )
HCl 0.0 5
C a 0.0 5
-17. 0 (34 )
-19. 6 (45 )
-21. 9 (21 )
-103. 0 (31 )
-108. 6 (69 )
36
Bioceramics Volume10
HCI 0.0 5 rCa 0.0 5
SiKa 99.8% I CaKaO.2 %
SIKa 984%; CaKal6%
Figure 2 SEM-EDX analysis of fracture-surfaces for Ormosils-type samples. Apatite : X = no apatite after 14 days Apatite 3 days = apatite deposited after 3 days
CONCLUSIO N Apatite-forming ability of Ormosil-type organically modified ceramic is enhanced by controlled amounts of HCl and Ca(N03)2*4H20. Analysis of ^^Si MAS NMR spectra indicates that additional H Q does not show any significant effects for local structure around Si atoms. The porosity and Ca content incorporated in the structures depends on amounts of HCl. We have concluded that controlling the incorporation of Ca(II) ions is essential for preparation of bioactive Ormosils-type organically modified ceramics.
REFERENCES
1. Hench, L. L. and Wilson, J. In: An introductionto bioceramics.World Scientific, Singapore, 1993,1-24. 2. Ohtsuki, C , Kokubo, T. and Yamamuro, T., J. Non-Cryst.Solids, 1992,143,84-92. 3. Tsuru, K., Ohtsuki, C. and Osaka, A. 7. Mat. Sci.,Mat. Med., 1997,8, 157-161. 4. Tsuru, K., Hayakawa, S., Ohtsuki, C. and Osaka, A. In: BioceramicsVolimie 9, Pergamon, Oxford, 1996,419-422. 5. Cho, S.B., Nakanishi, K., Kokubo, T., Soga, N., Ohtsuki, C , Nakamura, T., Kitsugi, T. and Yamamuro, T. J. Am. Ceram.Soc, 1995, 78, 1769-1774. 6. Kokubo, T., Kushitani, H., Sakka, S., Kitsugi, T. and Yamamuro, T., J. Biomed.Mater. /?ej.,1990, 24,721-734. 7. Iwamoto, T., Morita, K., and Mackenzie, J. D.,J. Non-Cryst.Solids, 1993,159,65-72. ACKNOWLEDGEMENT S The authors thank Prof. T. Yoko of Kyoto University for his helpful advice and assistance in the NMR measurements. One of the authors(K. T.) gratefully acknowledges the Research Fellowship of the Japan Society for the Promotion of Science for Young Scientists.
Bioceramics, Volume 10 Edited by L. Sedel and C. Rey (Proceedings of the 10th InternationalSymposium on Ceramics in Medicine, Paris, France, October 1997) '1997 Elsevier Science Ltd
HYDROXYAPATIT E FORMATIO N ON BIOACTIV E GLASS COATE D TITANIU M Cheol Y. Kim and Sungmin Kwon Dept. of Ceramic Engineering, Inha Univ. 253, Yonghyun-dong, Nam-ku, Inchon,402-751. Korea.
ABSTRAC T Two different bioactive glasses were coated on a titanium to give it a bioactivity, and then the bonding characteristics between a titanium and a coated layer and the hydroxyapatite formation in a simulated body fluid(SBF) on the coated specimens were studied. TisSis was found at the interface between titanium and glass coat in the groundcoat layer, and this enhaced the titanium-glass bonding. The hydrox}^apatite formation was observed only on the covercoat fired under 800 C, which is in an amorphous phase, and was retarded for the sample fired over 850 C, which contains an oxyapatite. KEYWORDS : Bioactive Glasses, Titanium, Hydroxyapatite, Groundcoat, Covercoat INTRODUCTIO N It has been well known that bioactive glasses are one of the best candidates for an implant material because of their excellent bonding behavior to the living tissue. ^^ The major drawback of these materials to use as a practical implant is their poor mechanical strength. To solve this problem, several works on coating the bioactive glasses to a strong substrate such as alumina and metal have been carried out.^^ A metal substrate has an advantage over an alumina because the former has better mechanical properties. However, most of metals easily oxidize specially at high temperarure and release some harmful ions when implanted for a long period of time. A titanium is now known as one of the best biometals for an implant material because it is chemically inert in a body. In the present study, therefore, two kinds of bioactive glasses are coated on a titanium by using a double coating method. The primary objectives of this study are 1) to find the bonding behavior between glass and titanium, and 2) to find the hydroxyapatite formation on the glass coated layer in a simulate body fluid. 37
38
Bioceramies Volume10
MATERIAL S AND METHOD S Two types of glass powder, as shown in Table 1, were prepared by melting the glass batch in a Pt-crucible at 1500 C for 2 hours followed by pulverizing them to less than 44/mi in an agate mortar. The glass powder was dispersed in an aceton, and spray-coated on a titanium. Glass 55SF and 5 5 SB were used for a groundcoat and a covercoat, repectively. The glass coated titanium was fired in a tube furnace at the temperature ranging from 1150 Cto 1300 C. Ar gas was flowed into the tube furnace at the rate of 2.5 1/min to prevent the oxidation of the titanium. The bioactive glass coated titanium was reacted in a simulated body fluid (SBF), which has pH of 7.3, and the ratio of the bioactive glass coated area to volume of the reaction solution was set at 0.1 cm’^ and the reaction temperature at 37 C. The crystalline phases of the heat-treated bioactive glass coated layer and the hydroxyapatite crystalline phase after the reaction test were examined by a thin film x-ray diffractometer. Tabl e 1. Batch Compositions of Bioactive Glasses
(mol%)
sample
Si02
P2O5
Na.O
CaO
Cap.
B2O3
55SF
55.1
3.4
9.2
27.8
4.5
-
50SB
50.1
3.4
9.2
32.3
-
5
RESULT S AND DISCUSSIO N Bondin g Behavior between Glass and Titaniu m When 55SF glass was coated on a pure titanium and fired under Ar-gas condition at 1300 C for 2 minutes, the crystalline phases of the glass layer are shown in Fig.l. TisSia crystal was found at the interface, and this crystal promotes the bonding of the glass layer to the titanium. 55SF glass coated Ti-metal was fired between 1150 C and 1300 C, and the XRD patterns are shown in Fig.2. Afluorapatitecrystal was obtained at a lower firing temperature. Thefluorapatitewas mehed as increase in temperature and a -wollastonite was developed at 1300 C. It is believed that titanium ions penetrated into glass layer at a higher firing temperature and acted as a nucleating agent for an (7-wollastonite crystal formation. Generally an oxyapatite and fluorapatite crystal form at a lower temperature without nucleating agent. No hydrox>apatite formation was observed when these samples were reacted in the SBF.^^
Hydroxyapatite Formation on Bioactive Glass Coated Titanium:C. Y. Kim and S. Kwon 39
w a-Wollastonite
W a-Wollastonit e W
I
I
T Titanium
|i>ii MmA»nM^u,0umiiK^
i3ao c
50^m
wl w s gs ^
I w
^
1250X
w
c
F Fluorapatit e
83p.m
100^m
I t I i I 20
30
40
50
26 (degree)
60
70
10
20
30
40
50
60
20 (degree)
Fig.l XRD patterns of 55SF glass coated Fig.2 XRD patterns for the surface of 5SF with increase in depth, heat-treated coated titanium, heat-treated at variat 1300 C in Ar atmosphere ous temperature for 2 mins Hydroxyapatit e Formatio n on Overcoate d Glass Layer Because no hydroxyapatite was formed on the groundcoat, another low melting glass 50SB was overcoated on the 55SF, and fired at 750T- 900T for 2 min. The glass layer crystallized into an oxyapatite when heat-treated at 900 C, and an amorphous overcoat layer was obtained when heat-trested at 800 C as shown in Fig. 3. These double-coat samples were reacted in SBF for 48 hours, and their XRD patterns are shown in Fig.4. The samples heat-treated at 850 C and 900 C showed oxyapatite crystal which were formed during the heat treatment. The sample heat-treated at 800’’C, however, showed a typical X-ray diffraction pattern of a newly formed hydroxyapatite precipitated on the glass surface. The reason for the delay of the hydroxyapatite formation on the oxyapatite crystal containing samples is because the matrix phase txu’ns into a chemically durable phase, and most of phosphorus ions are trapped in the oxyapatite crystal. This indicates that the leaching of phosphorus ions from the bioactive glass plays a very important role for the easy formation of the hydroxyapatite even in the phosphorus ion containing solution like SBF.
40
Bioceramics Volume10 0 Oxyapatite O Oxyapatite
1
H Hydroxyapatite 1
01
1 I L*M**«M(
900 C
KaJLjimlJliil
L-H’*»W\.
850 C 1
i " L^NIWWV K 1 ""^
20
30
40
50
60
20 (degree)
Fig.3 XRD patterns for the surface of 50SB coated titanium. Heat treated at various temperatures for 2 minutes.
10
800 C
:Tr^
1
J .1 .i_L _
10
1 1
20
30
40
50
60
2e (degree)
Fig.4 XRD patterns for the surface of 50SB coated titanium after corrosion in trisbuffer solution for 48 hrs.
CONCLUSIONS Bioactive groundcoat glass has a good chemical bonding to titanium by producing TisSis crystal at the interface. No hydroxyaptite formation was observed on the groundcoat after reaction in SBF, while hydroxyapatite crystal was obtained on the covercoat glass, which was fired at the temperature lower than 800 C. REFERENCE S 1. P. Ducheyne, P. Bianco, S. Radin and E. Schepers, Bone-BondingBiomatehals,Reed Healthcare, conmiun., 1992, 1-12 2. J. K. Kim and C. Y. Kim , J.Kor.Ceram.Soc, 1990, Vol.27, No.7, 925-933 3. C. Ohtasuki. A. Osaka and T. Kokubo, Bioceramics,1994, Vol. 7, 73-78
Bioceramics, Volume 10 Edited by L. Sedel and C. Rey (Proceedings of the 10th InternationalSymposium on Ceramics in Medicine, Paris, France, October 1997) '1997 Elsevier Science Ltd
EFFEC T OF MULTIVALEN T CATION S IN CALCIU M SILICAT E GLASSE S ON BIOACTIVIT Y Naoki Imayoshi, Chikara Ohtsuki, Satoshi Hayakawa and Akiyoshi Osaka Biomaterials Lab., Faculty of Engineering, Okayama University, Tsushima, Okayama 700, Japan
ABSTRAC T We examined the apatite formation for CaOSiO^ glasses containing Vp^, WO3, Ta205or Cr03 after they were soaked in a simulated body fluid(SBF) for various periods. Surface reaction of glass with SBF and reconstruction of an Si-O-Si network in the surface layer were studied with ^^Si MAS-NMR spectroscopy which gave the average ratio of bridging/nonbridging oxygen for an Si atom(Q"). It was shown that Ta^O^ and Cr03 effectively depressed the apatite formation and that V^Og and WO3 up to 5mol% caused little influence while dissolution of Ca( II) and Si(IV) was enhanced. Analysis of the ^^Si MAS-NMR spectra showed that the distribution of Q" was different for each transition metal oxides, and thus suggested that the structure of silica hydrogel layer was affected by those cations. INTRODUCTIO N Bioactive glasses and glass-ceramics bond to living bone directly[l]. The condition for those to bond to living bone, i.e. bioactivity, is to form a bone-like apatite layer when embedded in the bony defect. A binary glass 50CaO-50SiO2(mol%) forms the apatite layer, hence it serves a basic system for bone substitutes. Addition of third components like AI2O3 and TiO, depresses the apatite formation [2]. Thus, those cations cause opposing effects on bioactivity of glasses as they modify chemical properties and structure of a silica gel layer that is assumed to favor the apatite nucleation. It is essential to understand what structural and chemical role the third cations have in bioactive glasses. Transition metal cations are worth examining such effects since their structural roles may depend on glass composition. In this study we examined the apatite formation of SOCaO-SOSiO^ glasses doped with 5mol% transition metal oxides as well as dopant-free glass soaking in a simulated body fluid(SBF) which are similar in inorganic composition to that of the human blood plasma. Moreover, ^^Si Magic Angle Spinning(MAS)-NMR spectra of pulverized glasses were measured before and after soaked in the SBF to determine glass structure. MATERIAL S AND METHOD S Glasses were prepared due to an ordinary melt-quench method in a series of composition: x (V2O3, WO3, Tap^ or CrO3)(50-x/2)CaO(50-x/2)SiO2 where the molar ratio CaO/SiO, was maintained to 1. The obtained glasses were cut into rectangular specimens 15 X 10 X Imm^ and polished with a diamond paste. They were soaked in the SBF with pH=7.25 at 36.5 C. The SBF was prepared as described by Cho eta/[31. After soaking the glasses into the SBF, their surface structure was examined by FT-IR spectroscopy and thinfilmX-ray diffractometry(TF-XRD). The concentrations 41
42
Bioceramics Volume10
of calcium, silicon and phosphorus in the SBF after each period of soaking were measured by inductively coupled plasma(ICP) emission spectroscopy. ^S i MAS-NM R measuremen t The glanular glasses with 150-300^im in diameter were served for the^^Si MAS-NMR measurement before and after soaking in the SBF for various periods. ^^Si MAS-NMR spectra were recorded at 9.4T on a JEOL JNM-GSX400 FT-NMR spectrometer, equipped with a TU-GSX400MAS probe. Samples were placed in a zirconia sample tube. The sample spinning speed at the magic angle to external field was 5-6kHz. ^^Si MAS-NMR spectra were measured at 79.3MHz with 4.0-^s pulses, 2.5s recycle delays. About 1000 pulses were accumulated. Poly dimethyl silane(PDMS) was used as secondary external reference substance to determine the -^Si chemical shifts. RESULT S AND DISCUSSIO N Figure 1 shows the TF-XRD patterns of the surfaces of the metal oxide-doped and oxide-free 50CaO-50SiO, glasses soaked in the SBF for 7 and 30 days. The diffraction peaks near 26 and 32 were assigned to (002) and an envelope of (211), (112) and (300) of apatite, respectively. Fig. 1 indicates that SOCaO-SOSiO^ glass, 5mol%V203 and 5mol%W03 doped-glasses formed apatite on their surfaces in the SBF within 7 days, whereas 5mol%Ta205 and 5mol%Cr03 doped-glasses did not form it even after 30 days. This difference on apatite-forming ability among glasses suggests changes of chemical property and structure of SOCaO-SOSiO^ glass due to the addition of the transition metal oxides. The concentrations of calcium and silicon of the SBF due to soaking the glasses are shown in Figs. 2 and 3. They increased with the period for 5mol%V205 and WO3 doped-glasses, whereas only a slight
(b)30d Q
X-ra y 50CaO’50SiO 2
’’^w V ^
5mol%V,O s
0
5mol%W0 3
CI
e
A 2 _A^A^ _ 5mol%Ta20 5 5mol%Cr0 3 ^ *f*l’*rrHrT i 1 1 1 1 1 Trt’^’i"^"’* "
20
25
30 35 2e/de g
40
20
25
30 35 2e/de g
40
Figure 1 TF -XRD patterns of 50CaO-50SiO 5mol% Vp^, WO3, Ta203 and Cr03 doped-glasses soaked in the simulated body fluid for 7 days (a) and 30days (b). O: Apatite
Effects of MultivalentCations in Calcium Silicate Glasses on Bioactivity:N. Imayoshi et al. 10 §2. 5 S ^2. 0 .0
(b)[SJ ]
-J
_
J
^,^
1 1.5
ii.o
-
s o
O.Or
10
15 20 Time/da y
25
43
-^ crS^m 15 20 i 25
10
6
30
135
Tim e / da y
Figure 2 Changes in Ca (a) and Si (b) concentrations of the simulated body fluid due to immersion of 50CaO-50SiO 5mol% V p ^ , WO3, Idifi^ and Cr03 doped-glasses in the simulated body fluid. D: 50CaO-50Sia, A: 5mol%V203, A: 5mol%W03, O: 5mol%Tap3 and FI: 5mol%Cr03. "
increase was noticed for 5mol% Cr03 doped-glasses. There appears no changes in the concentrations for 5mol% Ta203 -doped glass. This means the addition of Ta^O, improves chemical durability of 50CaO-50SiO^ glass and suppresses the dissolution of calcium and silicon. The increase in calcium favors the apatite formation due to increase in the degree of supersaturation with respect to hydroxyapatite, and the release of silicon from glasses shows formation of silanol groups which plays an important role on apatite nucleation. Similar analysis indicated release of vanadium, chromium and tungsten from the glasses in the SBF, although tantalum ion was not detected even after soaking for 30 days. Therefore, the dissolution of vanadium and tungsten ions from their glasses in the SBF did not affect the apatite formation. In contrast, 5mol%Cr03 doped-glasses did not form the apatite layer although release of calcium and silicon was detected. These results suggest that the dissolved chromium ions in the SBF remarkably suppresses the nucleation and/or growth of the apatite. Figure 3 shows ^^Si MAS-NMR spectra of 50CaO-50SiO,, 5mol%V,03, WO3, Ta,05 and Cr03 doped-glasses before soaking in the SBF. Each peaks were deconvoluted into two or three Gaussian functions on the basis of least square fitting. Each component was assigned to Q^ ( ? or Q^on the basis of the reference data[4], where Q" shows the number of bridging oxygen. Relative peak area of each Q" group (n=2-4) of 50CaO-50SiO, does not differ from that for 5mol% transition metal oxides. This means that the apatite formation is not associated the initial local structure around an Si atom. Fig. 4 shows 2^Si MAS-NMR spectra of 5mol% Vp^and WO3 doped-glasses after soaking in the SBF for various periods. Leaching of calcium ions from the glass surfaces forms the Si-OH bonds of Q2 and Q^ groups without changing much of their ratios. However, the fraction of Q^ decreased for 5mol%V205 and WO3 doped-glasses with longer periods, probably due to polymerization of the SiOH bonds of Q2 groups. The increase in the fraction of Qt is attributed to the formation of Q^ units on the glass surface in the SBF. From Figs. 1 and 4, it is concluded that Q"^ units are favorable to apatite formation. Similar analysis for 5mol%Ta205 and Cr03 doped-glasses suggested absence of such changes in Q^ and Q^ for those glasses. A high field chemical shift, found in Fig. 4, for Si in the Q^ groups suggests that some of the Q^ groups involve Si-O-P bonds.
44
Bioceramics Volume10 I I H | H I H I I I I | I I I I | I I I 1 | I I I I | I I H |IH I I | I I I
’S i MAS-NM R spectr a
I l l i | n i l 11I I i | I II I I n i l | i i i 1 1 I I 1 1 | i 1 1 1 1 I I I
5mol % V^O g
Q-
^4
50CaO-50SiO ,
5mol%Cr0 3 tHliliiiilmiLifH l
Figure 3 ^^Si MAS-NMR spectra of pulverised 50CaO-50SiO,, 5mol%V,03, WO3, Ta,03 and CrOj doped-glasses before soaking in the simulated body fluid.
Figure 4 ^^Si MAS-NMR spectra of pulverised 5mol%V20g and WO3 doped-glasses after soaking in the simulated body fluid.
SUMMAR Y The apatite formation for 50CaO-50SiO, glass respectively varied by addition of transition metal oxides. The addition of 5mol% V^O^ and WO3 hardly effected the apatite formation in the SBF, while the addition of 5mol% TaPg and CrOj remarkably suppressed the apatite formation. The addition of the former increased in calcium and silicon concentration and the structure of silica gel layer as a result of chemical reaction in the SBF favored the apatite formation. But the addition of the latter improved the chemical durability and suppressed the formation of silica gel layer. Moreover dissolution of chromium ion in the SBF suppressed the apatite formation. REFERENCES 1. Hench, L.. L., Splinter, R. J., Allen, W. C. and Greenlee, T K. J, Biomed.Mater.Res. Symp.,2, 117-141(1972). 2. Ohtsuki, C , T. Kokubo, T, Takatsuka and T. Yamamuro, J. Mater.Sci.: Mater Med.,3, 119125 (1992). 3. Cho, S.B., Nakanishi, K., Kokubo, T, Soga, N., Ohtsuki, C , Nakamura, T, and Yamamuro, T. J. Am. Ceram.Soc, 78, 1769-1774 (1995). 4. Selvaray, U., Rao, K. J., Rao, C. N. R., Klinowski, J. and Thomas, J. M. Chem.Phys. Lett.,114, 24(1985). ACKNOWLEDGMENT S The authors thank Professor F. Horii and Mrs. K. Omine of Kyoto University for their helpful advice and assistance in the NMR measurements. Fmancial support by the Asahi Glass Foundation is gratefully acknowledged.
Bioceramics, Volume 10 Edited by L. Sedel and C. Rey (Proceedings of the 10th InternationalSymposium on Ceramics in Medicine, Paris, France, October 1997) '1997 Elsevier Science Ltd
TRANSFORMATIO N OF BIOACTIV E GLAS S GRANULE S INT O CA-P SHELL S IN VITR O S. Radin, P. Ducheyne, S. Falaize, A. Hammond Department of Bioengineering, University of Pennsylvania 3320 Smith Walk, Philadelphia, PA 19104
ABSTRAC T Bioactive glass (BG) reactions were modeled in physiological solutions in static or dynamic conditions using either integral (no solution exchange) or differential (with solution exchange at designated time periods) modes of immersion. BG granules (either 300-355 or 200-300 |im) were immersed in tris buffered solution complemented with plasma electrolytes (TE), or with both plasma electrolytes and 10% serum (TES-10). Post-immersion solutions were analyzed for changes in Siconcentrations. Granules were analyzed for compositional, morphological and structural changes resulting from immersion by using scanning electron microscopy (SEM), energy dispersive X-ray (EDX) analysis and Fourier Transform Infrared (FTIR) spectroscopy. The amount of Si released from BG granules in the differential mode of immersion in TE was double the one in the integral mode. The dissolution was further enhanced in serum-containing TES-10: total dissolution of silica was observed after 1 week of differential immersion in TES-10. The granules with totally dissolved silica were transformed into hollow Ca-P shells. KEYWORDS : bioactive glass, in vitro, surface modification, dissolution INTRODUCTIO N A unique phenomenon of excavation of bioactive glass granules of narrow size range (300-355 |im), concomittant differentiation of osteoprogenitor cells, and formation of new bone tissue inside the excavated granules was observed in vivo [1]. Notwithstanding the biological evidence for this resorption to be cell mediated [1], solution mediated effects can also play a role. Before, bioactive glass (BG) reactions were modeled in physiological solutions using static or integral conditions (no fluid flow or solution exchange) [2,3]. However, physiological fluids in the body are in constant circulation. Thus, in this study, we modeled the reactions of BG granules in dynamic conditions using a differential mode of immersion. This immersion methodology represents conditions in which the solution is continuously replenished. In this paper we document that only differentially performed immersion experiments simulates the internal resorption process. MATERIAL S AND METHOD S BG 45S5 granules with a composition 45% Si02, 24.5% Na20, 24,5% CaO and 6% P2O5 (Orthovita, Malvern, PA), were immersed, either integrally or differentially, in tris buffered solution complemented with either plasma electrolytes 45
46
Bioceramics Volume10
(TE) or complemented with both electrolytes and 10% newborn bovine serum (TES-10) at 370c for up to 1 week. Granules of either 300-355 or 200-300 |iim were used. The granules were immersed at a weight-to-solution ratio of 0.5 mg/ml. In the differential mode, the solutions were exchanged at 3, 6, 10, 24 hours and then every day. Post-immersion solutions were analyzed for changes in Siconcentrations using atomic absorption spectrophotometry (AAS, 5100, PerkinElmer, Norwalk, CT). Following immersion, the BG granules were analyzed for compositional and morphological changes using SEM/EDX (JEOL 6400) analyses. Morphological changes were viewed on granules attached to a carbon tape and coated with carbon. Some of the post-immersion granules were fractured under a light stereo microscope to expose the inner surface. Cross sectional analysis was performed on post-immersion granules embedded in epoxy and polished using diamond coated discs. After polishing the cross-sections were coated with carbon. FTIR analysis was also used to determine the structure and composition of the reaction surfaces. RESULT S AND DISCUSSIO N The Si-release from BG granules of 300-355 |Lim (expressed as weight % of the original Si content) vs. immersion time in the integral mode in TE, and the differential mode in TE and TES-10 is shown in Figures 1 a,b. Whereas 34.5% of the original Si-content was dissolved after 1 week of immersion in the integral mode in TE, the cumulative Si-dissolution in TE was equal to 69.6% in the differential mode. The dissolution was further enhanced by differential immersion in TES-10: total dissolution of the silica from granules was observed after 1 week of differential immersion. Similar results (i.e. total silica dissolution after differential immersion in TES-10) were obtained for BG granules of 200-300 ^m.
80- .
Le 40 -
1
20 ^
0 H f 3
-
- TE.inligr«
1^ 1 24
j
X
1 72
--
4
^
168 0
24
Time of immersion (hours )
Figure 1 a,b. Si-release (% of the original Si-content in BG) from BG granules (300-355 \xm)vs. immersion time in integral mode in TE (a) and differential mode in TE and TES-10 (b). Arrow indicates time to formation of a HA surface layer detectable by FTIR.
In Vitro Transformationof Bioactive Glass Granules (300-355 fiMj into Ca-P Shells: S. Radin 47
Figures 2 a, b. SEM micrographs of BG granules after differential immersion in TES-10 for 168 hours: (a) view of a fractured granule after silica dissolution; (b) cross-section of an internally dissolved granule (embedded in epoxy and polished). The SEM micrographs of granules after differential immersion in TES-10 (Fig. 2 a,b) show transformation of the granules into hollow shells. The EDX spectra (Fig. 3) corresponding to three different spots of the cross-section indicate that the hollow particle was mainly composed of a Ca-P phase which contained traces of CI, Na and Mg. The Ca/P ratio in the different spots on the shell varied from 1.1 to 1.3. No significant Si-content could be detected on either outer or inner surfaces of the shell. FTIR spectrum of the granules after differential immersion in TES-10 showed that the Ca-P phase was partly or fully crystalline, as indicated by the sharpening and splitting of the P-O band in the lower energy region (Fig. 4). The crystalline phase could not be identified because of extra absorption bands present in the energy region from 700 to 950 cm-1 due to spectral distorsion associated with a rough surface (i.e. small particles).
keV
Figure 3.Three EDX spectra (the spectra overlap) taken from three different spots on the hollow shell cross-section (shown on Fig. 2b): at the outer surface, at subsurface and on the inner surface.
48
Bioceramics Volume 10
Figure 4. FTIR spectrum of BG granules after differential immersion in TES-10 for 168 hours. Split of the P-0 band in the lower energy region indicates formation of a crystalline Ca-P phase. The observed effect of the mode of immersion and the presence of serum protems on the the degree of silica dissolution can be explained as follows. In the mtegral mode of immersion in serum-free TE silica dissolution was slowed down after 24 hours of immersion due to formation of a HA surface layer (detected by FTIR). The protective effect of the surface HA layer on dissolution of silica-based bioactive glass has been described elsewhere [4]. Our data indicate that the differential mode prompted continuous Si dissolution in TE at the immersion stages preceedmg the HA formation (Fig. la). As we previously reported [5], the presence of serum in TES-10 slows down the HA formation. The surface reaction layer which forms in TES-10 is composed of amorphous Ca-P accumulations in a silica matrix. This layer does not prevent continuous Si-dissolution. As a result all the sihca dissolved from the granules in these experiments. Granules of which all the sihca was dissolved in TES-10, were fully transformed to hollow Ca-P shells. Crystallization of the Ca-P phase occured upon Si-dissolution. CONCLUSION S 1. In vitro immersion in a serum solution using conditions reflecting the continuous fluid flow in vivo, leads to internal dissolution of glass granules. Static immersion experiments fail to achieve this phenomenon. 2. Transformation of bioactive glass granules into hollow Ca-P shells can be achieved in vitro. AKNOWLEDGMEN T This work was supported by grants NSF BSC 93-09053 and NIH DE-10693
REFERENCES
1. Schepers, E., De Clercq, M., Ducheyne, P. and Kempeneers, R., J.Oral. Rehab..,1991, 18, 439-452. 2. Hench, L.L., J. Am. Cer. Soc, 1991, 74(7), 1487-510. 3. Kokubo, T., J. Non-Cryst. Solids, 1990, 120, 138-151. 4. Hench, L.L., J. Non-Cryst. Solids, 1978, 28, 83-105 5. Radin, S., Ducheyne, P., Rothman, B., Conti, A., J. Biomed.Mat. Res., 1997, 35, in press.
Bioceramics, Volume 10 Edited by L. Sedel and C. Rey (Proceedings of the 10th InternationalSymposium on Ceramics in Medicine, Paris, France, October 1997) '1997 Elsevier Science Ltd
Multilayere d Coating s of Hydroxyapatite/Glas s Cerami c Composite s Plasm a Spraye d on Ti-6A1-4V Alloy P.L.Silva*^* J.D.Santos^*, F.J.Monteiro^* ^ISEP-CEIA-Instituto Superior de Engenharia, Institute Politecnico do Porto, R. de S.Tome, 4200 Porto, Portugal. INEB-Instituto de Engenharia Biomedica, Pra^a Coronel Pacheco 1,4050 Porto, Portugal. ’-’Departamento de Engenharia Metalurgica, FEUP, Universidade do Porto, R. dos Bragas, 4099 Porto Codex, Portugal. ABSTRACT Aiming at obtaining plasma sprayed coatings with enhanced bioactivity, when in contact with host tissues, double layered coatings were prepared. The top layer was composed of a hydroxyapatite (HA)/4% P2O5 glass composite and the undercoat was of pure simple HA onto Ti-6A1-4V alloy. X-Ray Diffraction Analysis (XRD) of the composite top layer showed that it was less crystalline than simple HA layer due to the glass addition, and was composed of a HA matrix with a small amount of p-TCP. Scanning Electronic Microscope (SEM) observations showed that it has been possible to obtain double-layered coatings with good bonding between them and well adherent to the metallic substrate. Coating to substrate adhesion was determined according to three standard methods: ASTM C 633-79, ASTM D 1002 and DIN 50161. Image analysis technique was used to determine the type of failure mechanism that took place and it was found that 85.6%–2.7 was adhesive and 13.4%–2.7 cohesive. The coating to substrate adhesion values are within the range commonly required for this type of plasma sprayed coatings for medical applications. KEYWORDS : Plasma-spraying, ceramic composites, adhesion. INTRODUCTIO N The interest in using HA for biomedical applications is commonly known [1-3]. However, it has been proved that for load bearing applications the mechanical properties of HA, mainly its strength and fracture toughness should be improved [4-5]. In a previous work [6], it has been shown that by applying a P2O5 based glass reinforcement to HA, fracture toughness and biaxial bending strength were enhanced. In this work, HA reinforced with 4%P205 based glass was used as a surface layer, i.e., the material that primarily establishes contact with tissues and organic fluids. In order to adjust glass chemical composition as closely as possible to inorganic part of bone chemical composition [7-9], Na20, MgO and K2O oxides were incorporated into P2O5 based glass. This composite was the top layer of a mixed coating containing as an undercoat a pure HA layer, adherent to the Ti-6Al-4V alloy. One of the main concerns when using plasma sprayed coatings is to obtain adequate coating to substrate adhesion [10]. The way by which a coating adheres to a substrate is very complex and not fully understood [11-13]. Several theories and mechanisms of adhesion have been proposed but there is no single one that might explain all adhesion behavior [11-14]. 49
50
Bioceramics Volume10
P205
35
Table 1 - Glass chemical composition (mol%). CaO Na20 K2O 35 10 10
MgO 10
Due to the difficulty in quantifying this property, three standard methods have been chosen allowing for crossed results evaluation. MATERIAL S AND METHOD S P205-CaO based glass was prepared from reagent grade chemicals and its chemical composition may be seen in Table 1. The glass was wet mixed and milled with HA powder using methanol. 4% glass addition was used. Mixed powders were dried and isostatically pressed at 200MPa, The method used for composite preparation has been fully described elsewhere [6]. Cylindrical shaped samples were sintered at 1300^C and once again milled, using an agate ball mill pot. The powders were then sieved to obtain a grain size distribution suitable for plasma spraying deposition. Two kinds of HA were used for the base coatings: HA-P, supplied by Plasma-Technik with the reference code, AMDRY AM 6021, specifically prepared for plasma spraying and used "as received"; HA-I, supplied by Plasma Biotal and conditioned to be used for plasma spraying. Plasma spraying was performed under atmospheric conditions using a Plasma Technik automated equipment. After grit blasting the Ti-6A1-4V alloy with AI2O3 spheres, and chemical degreasing with trichlorethylene, a 50\im HA coating was sprayed followed by the deposition of SOjxm HA/glass composite coating. Samples were characterized by XRD and compared with an XRD spectrum obtained for a 100|Lim commercial HA-P coating. Ten samples were used for each of the three adhesion experiments. From ASTM D 1002 tests, comparative shear strength values were obtained. With the ASTM C 633-79 it was possible to obtain coating adhesion under stresses normal to the surface, and with ASTM C 633-79 DIN 50161
0 1,5+0,2 cm
l . t cm
ASTM D1002
1,6mn n 1
1 Z.TTnm
sttear
"^.^afcr^ ^
Fig.l - Test specimens according to ASTM D 1002, ASTM C 633-79 and DIN 50160 standards.
Coatings of HA/Glass Ceramic CompositesPlasma Sprayed on Ti-6al-4v Alloy: P.L. Silva et al.
v._^L^U--^X^w ;
51
M- MU AMkli&«ii^.^.v^^^^ ^
a) b) Fig.2-XRD spectra for HA-I+composite samples a) and HA plasma sprayed samples b). DIN 1061 testing compressive stresses were applied. The shape and dimensions of the test specimens may be seen in Fig.l. The glue used to assemble the test specimens in both, ASTM D 1002 and ASTM C 633-79 tests, was Plasmatex Klebbi from Plasma Technik. In order to determine what type of failure mechanism took place, cohesive or adhesive, fracture surfaces were observed by SEM according to image analysis technique. RESULT S AND DISCUSSIO N XRD spectra may be observed in Fig.2. Both coatings had an HA matrix with small amounts of P-TCP. Comparing with the HA + composite samples, the simple commercial HA coating presents higher cristallinity. Adhesion results are presented in Table 2. Slightly higher adhesion values were obtained for the HA-I+composite samples. Both coatings have shown higher resistance to uniaxial tensile stress than to shear stresses, applied in ASTM D 1002 experiments or compressive stresses used in the DIN 60161 standard. Examples of image analysis applied to the samples tested according to ASTM C 633-79 are presented in Fig.3. The areas where some coating remained attached to the substrate are yellow colored and the gray color represents Ti-6A1-4V alloy substrate. Using this technique it was possible to determine that HA-I+composite failure was 85.6 – 2.7% adhesive and 13.4% – 2.7 cohesive. HA-P+composite samples have shown 57.2%–4.6 adhesive and 42.8%–4.6 cohesive failure. In samples subjected to ASTM D 1002 the coating was completely transferred to the counterpart so that image analysis determinations were not performed. Fracture surfaces of samples subjected to DIN 50161 have showed that failure occurred by the coating - cohesive failure. Magnification of the failure area have shown that fracture surfaces were irregular and some failure planes may be observed, which indicates that brittle failure took place. SUMMAR Y In this work an attempt was made to obtain new coatings designed to tailor the needs of bonding to neighbor tissues and whitstanding for a reasonable amount of time the contact with physiological environment. A surface coating capable of inducing a fast response from the host tissue in the early moments of implantation was created, showing a more reduced dissolution kinetics in the long term, thus allowing for the newly formed bone tissue to be fully established Coating HA-I+composite HA-P+composite 1 Glue
ASTM D 1002 (MPa) 14.9–4.3 13.1–3.8 22.7–0.1
ASTM C 633-79 (MPa) 35.4–6.5 33.8–5.6 70.0–0.1
DIN 50161 (MPa) 40.0–9.8 36.1 –8.6 2
1
52
Bioceramics Volume10
Fig.3 - Failure surface image analysis photomicrograph of an HA-I+composite sample a) and HAP+composite sample b) and adequately fixed to the implants. As it was clearly detected in Fig.2, the upper layer coating was more amorphous than HA, probably due to the glass incorporation. Results presented in Table 2 show that coating to substrate adhesion was slightly improved when HA-I + composite double layers were used. These results may be explained by the fact that HA powders used to produce these coatings had higher strength and density than those used to prepare the HA-P+composite coatings since they were isostatically pressed and sintered. Both kinds of double layered coatings present higher adhesion values for ASTM C 633-79 - tensile stresses than for ASTM D 1002- shear stresses or DIN 50161 - compressive stresses. Comparing these results with the needs for the implanted materials in load bearing applications, 30MPa, it may be concluded that both double layers seem to entirely satisfy stress requirements. Image analysis, seen in Fig.3 and performed on samples subjected to ASTM C 633-79 tests, have shown that adhesion failure was 85% adhesive for HA-I + composite samples but, for HAP+composite coatings this value decreases to 57%. This behavior may be explained by the fact that when using HA-I+composite samples both HA - the one from the composite layer and the "pure" HA layer - were prepared by the same procedure. HA-P+composite samples were prepared with two different kinds of HA powder, the HA powder from the composite that was isostatically pressed and sintered, and the commercial HA from the bottom layer that was applied "as received". The fact that in the ASTM D1002, the double layer was completely transferred to the counterpart have showed that this was a mainly adhesive failure. The DIN 50161 failure surface observations presented essentially cohesive kind of failure.
Acknowledgment s The authors which to thank INEB for the provision of laboratory facilities, financial support of JNICT trough Ref.PBICT/CTM/1890/95 and Marta Sa and Barbara Silva for their immense collaboration in the execution of the adhesion experiments.
REFERENCES 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. 6. 7. 8. 9. 10. 11. 12. 13. 14.
RDucheyne , J.BiomedMater.Res.App.Biomater., 21 (1987), 219. H.Aoki, in ScienceandMedical Applications of Hydroxy apatite, Takayam a Pres s System Center , JAAS, Tokyo, (1991), 165. R.Z.Legeros , Adv.Dent.Res.,2, (1988), 164. G.With,H.Va n Dijk, N.Hattu , K.Prijs , J. Mater.Sci., 16, (1981), 1592. M.Akao , H.Aoki, K. Kato , J. Mater.Sci., 16, (1981), 809. J.D. Santos , P.L. Silva, J.C . Knowles, F.J.Monteiro , /. Mater.Sci., Mater.Med.,1, (1996), 187. D. Williams , Medical& Dental Materials, Pergamo n Press , (1986). C.Rey, Biomaterials, 11,(1990), 14. G.Evans , J.Behiri , J.Currey , B.Bonfield, /. Mater.Sci., Mater.Med.,1, (1990), 38. D.Matejka , B.Benko, Plasma Spraying ofMetallic Materials, Joh n Wiley & Sons, (1989). S.D.Brown , ThinSolidFilms,119, (1984), 127. K.L.Mittal , Adhesion Me^LSurement of ThinSolidFilms,Thick Films and Bulk Coatings , ASTM STP 840. R. Dixon, Surface Engineering, 11,(1993), 4. W.Lian , Novel Plasm a Sprayin g Processin g for Enhance d Surfac e Engineering , Matetrial s World , 4,
Bioceramics, Volume 10 Edited by L. Sedel and C. Rey (Proceedings of the 10th InternationalSymposium on Ceramics in Medicine, Paris, France, October 1997) '1997 Elsevier Science Ltd
THE BONY REACTIO N TO RAPIDL Y DEGRADABL E GLASS-CERAMIC S BASED ON THE NEW PHAS E Ca2KNa(P04) 2 C. Muller-Mail, G. Berger^, C. Voigt^ B. Bakki^, U. Gross^ Department of Traumatology and Reconstructive Surgery^ and Institute of Pathology^, Universitatsklinikum Benjamin Franklin, Freie Universitat Berlin, Hindenburgdamm 30, 12200 Berlin, Germany, Federal Institute for Materials Research and Testing, Berlin-^, Germany. ABSTRAC T Glass-ceramics in the composition field of CaO-K20-MgO-Na20-P205 can be produced based on the main crystalline phase Ca2KNa(P04)2. The degradation rate depends on the whole composition, i.e. the crystalline phases as well as the residual glass-phase. The degradation rate of the two investigated glass-ceramics was higher as in B-tricalciumphosphate (B-TCP) and was mainly due to passive leaching processes, especially in GB18. Both materials exhibited bonebonding properties and allowed at least for partial guided bone regeneration during degradation. KEYWORDS : Bone/interface/glass-ceramics/degradation/guided bone regeneration/ultrastructure. INTRODUCTIO N Bone defects, for example after trauma, need reconstruction. Such defects can be reconstructed by using autologous bone and homologous bone, both having their drawbacks and limitations. An alternative method uses bioactive bone-bonding implant materials which display different degradation rates. In most of these materials the interface is stabilized by bone-bonding and therefore, the bone bonding material is not further subject to degradation and replacement by bone [1]. On the other hand, the higher degradable materials should allow for guided bone regeneration while being degraded. Thus, the degradation rate should not be too high. The goal of this study was to evaluate two new synthetic implant materials based on a Ca2KNa(P04)2-phase as a glass/glassceramic composite. The dissolution rate of these materials in comparison to 13-TCP is enhanced by exchanging Ca against other ions such as K, Na and by adding Mg [2]. MATERIAL S AND METHOD S Two particulate implant materials were tested with the following constituents according to [2]: GB14 with a content of CaO 30.67 %, MgO 2.45 %, Na20 9.42 %, K2O 14.32 % and P2O5 43.14 % (particle dimentions were measured to be 370 – 70 |nm width and 610 – 100 jam length, n = 45), and GB18 containing CaO 17.72 % and MgO 12.75 %, Na20 9.79 %, K2O 14,88 %, P2O5 44.86 % (380 – 70 |im width, 630 – 100 |Lim length, n = 27). Both compositions are meltable and crystallize spontaneously fi-om the melt. Thus, they can be easily produced. Both particulates consist of a main crystal phase and other amorphous and crystal moieties. The dissolution rate was measured in vitro (0.2 M TRIS-HCl) and yielded rates of 292 – 40 and 1278 – 80 mg/1 for GB14 and GB18, respectively. Therefore, the materials were much more soluble as B-TCP in the same testing system (30,6 – 10 mg/1)[3]. The dissolution rate is controllable by the amount of added ions, such as Na, K, or Mg. Particulates were sterilized by dry heat at 180 C for 30 min.. 100 mg 53
54
Bioceramics Volume10
were implanted into each femur below the patella sliding plane into trabecular bone in Chinchilla rabbits after arthrotomy of the knee joint. The defect containing the particulates was closed using a chondrocortical bone slice produced by the hollow cylinder drill after removing the adherent trabecular bone below the cartilage. After implantation, this slice was fixed in the anatomical position by the pressure of the revised patella. Thus, no particles were observed in the knee-joint. A total of 9 animals was operated bilaterally per material and each 3 animals were sacrificed at 7, 28, and 84 days and the femora were prepared for scanning (SEM) and transmission (TEM) electron microscopy as described [4] except that the specimens for SEM-investigation were air dried after rinsing in hexamethyldisilasane. RESULT S AND DISCUSSIO N Specimens prior to implantation In the SEM the GB14-particles showed three different appearences. Two particle types consistend mainly of crystalline spheres attached to each other by a thin film of amorphous matrix. The crystalline spheres had diameters of either 10 – 1 |im (n = 30 measured) or 45 – 6 )Lim (n = 30). Between the crystalline spheres representing the ceramic moiety and the amorphous glass-phase there were some cracks up to 2 |Lim width and more than 20 |im length. At the neck of separate spheres, where cracks contacted each other, roundish pores were created of approximately 3.5 |Lim diameter. The third kind of particles was the most dense, since there were no cracks or pores and crystalline spheres were not detectable. The GB18 particles were also dense and homogeneous with only few deepenings and elevations. There were no apparent substructures (Figure 1). Specimens after implantation All cases showed healing without special events. During the time course between 7 and 84 days of implantation the surface morphology of the three GB 14 particle types changed considerably. The crystalline spheres either of 45 or 10 jam in diameter were degraded, leading in the case of 45 )Lim spheres to a microporosity of their surfaces with pores and cracks with diameters of 1 jiim or 2 \xm width, respectively. Later on, this process led to a destruction and formation of smaller substructures (Figure 2). Thus, irregular porous substructures of some |Lim in length were produced indicating a rapid degradation of the spheres. The 10 \im crystalline spheres decreased contineously in size by keeping their spherical outline. In the third kind of GB14 particles the amorphous moiety was leached at already 7 days liberating roundish crystalline substructures with mean diameters of 13 – 4 |Lim (n = 10). Between the amorphous moiety and the spheres cracks developed which increased in width at longer time intervals (Figure 3). Already at 7 days pores of about 0.5 fim developed in the spheres. The pore diameters grew with time leading to a complete destruction in some cases. In vitro experiments have shown, that this degradation process led to high concentrations of Mg and P in the medium as well as to precipitations rich in these ions on the substrate. The osteoblast growth was slightly inhibited as compared to Thermanox^[5]. In the GB18 particles at 7 days the ceramic moiety consisting of rod-like structures of up to 20 fim length was liberated, possibly by leaching of the surrounding amorphous glass moiety. Later on, these rod-like structures were also degraded as in the GB14 particles and smaller irregular substructures were formed (Figure 2). At 7 days there was almost exclusively fibrous material surrounding the different particle types. At 28 days bone was observed in contact to the GB14 particles. The bone contacted the dense particles and the particles with 45 \xm crystalline spheres directly, whereas the particles with small 10 \xmspheres were separated from the bone by clefts of about 1 |um width. The different tissue
Bony Reaction to Degradable Glass-Ceramics Based on the Phase Ca2KNa(P04)2: C. Muller-Mai et al.
55
reactions indicate that the chemical composition of the different moieties within single particles as well as in particle types was varying. In general, GB18 developed more bone contact as GB14, probably related to the higher reactivity. There was bone at 28 days in contact to the particles and at 84 days there was almost complete bone contact of the GB18 particles. In the TEM, all particulates exhibited crystalline and amorphous parts. There seemed to be empty spaces between both phases suggesting some microporosity prior to implantation. At each time interval there was soft tissue with fibroblasts and macrophages as well as bone in the interface with increasing bone amounts at longer time intervals especially in contact to GB18 and the dense GB14 (Figure 3). Mineralization occured in the cracks between spheres. Both particulates were degraded with a higher rate of the GB18. In GB14 this was due to a destruction of the spheres as well as to leaching of the amorphous moiety. In GB18 there was first leaching of the amorphous phase leading to the liberation of rod-like structures which degraded also later on. REFERENCE S 1. Muller-Mai, CM., Voigt, C , Baier, R.E. and Gross, U. Cells & Mater. 1992, 4, 309-327. 2. Berger, G., Gildenhaar, R. and Ploska, U. In: Bioceramics Volume 8, Wilson, J., Hench, L.L., Greenspan, D. (eds), Pergamon, Oxford, UK, 1995, 453-456. 3. Berger, G., Gildenhaar, R., Gross, U., Knabe, C, Loginow-Spitzer, A., Miiller-Mai, C , Ploska, U. and Radlanski, R. In: Werkstoffe fiir die Medizintechnik, Symposium 4, Breme, J. (ed), DGM-Informationsgesellschaft Verlag, Frankfurt, Germany, 1996, 59-65. 4. Miiller-Mai, C , Voigt, C. and Gross, U. Scanning Microsc. 1990, 4, 613-624. 5. Knabe, C , Gildenhaar, R., Berger, G., Ostapowicz, W., Fitzner, R., Radlanski, R., Gross, U. and Siebert, G.K. In: Transactions, Vol. I, 5th World Biomat. Congress, International Liaison Committee (ed), University of Toronto Press, Toronto, Canada, 1990, 890.
Figure 1: Surfaces of the particle types prior to implantation. A: GB14 with 45 |Lim spheres, cracks and a pore; B: GB14 with 10 |Lim spheres; C: Dense GB14; D: GB18. SEM, bar 20 jim.
56
Bioceramics Volume10
Figure 2: A: Spheres (45 jim-type) at 7 days with newly developed pores and cracks. B: GB18 at 84 days surrounded by bone with rod-like crystalline moiety. SEM, bars A:50 |Lim, B: 100 |Lim.
Figure 3: A: Dense GB14 at 84 days with cracks between amorphous and crystalline moiety with pores in separate spheres surrounded by bone. B: Bone bonding to ceramic moiety of GB18 at 84 days (grey, white areas as artefacts due to loss of glass-ceramic). TEM, bars A: 100 |im, B: 1 jim.
Bioceramics, Volume 10 Edited by L. Sedel and C. Rey (Proceedings of the 10th InternationalSymposium on Ceramics in Medicine, Paris, France, October 1997) '1997 Elsevier Science Ltd
RESORBABL E POROU S PHOSPHAT E INVER T GLASSE S - FIRS T IN VITR O AND IN VIVO RESULT S J. Voger, K.-J. Schulze^ D. Reif, P. Hartmann^ U. Platzbecker^ B. Leuner^ ’Otto-Schott-Institut, Friedrich-Schiller-Universitat, FraunhoferstraBe 6, 07743 Jena, Germany, ^Klinik fiir Orthopadie, Technische Universitat, FetscherstraBe74, 01370 Dresden Germany, ^Biovision GmbH, Am Vogelherd 1, 98693 Ilmenau, Germany, ’’Institut fiir Optik und Quantenelektronik, Friedrich-Schiller-Universitat, Max-Wien-Platz 1, 07743 Jena, Germany
ABSTRAC T A resorbable phosphate invert glass was investigated in view of its solubility behavior "in vitro". First animal experiments were carried out using a porous shape of the phosphate invert glass and of the corresponding glass ceramic. Both the solubility tests and the animal experiments confirm an excellent biocompatibility. The living bone grows into the pores of the implants and the materials are reabsorbed in course of time. The resorption rates meet the expectations. KEYWORD S Phosphate glasses, resorbable, porous, solubility tests, animal experiments INTRODUCTIO N The regeneration of bony defects can be supported by resorbable implants. Sintered tricalcium phosphate is mainly used for these clinical applications today. Pure dense sintered TCP shows a good biocompatibility [1,2]. However, in dependence on size and place of the filled bony defect, the resorption term of this material can reach up to some years and rests of the material can cause biomechanical problems. Additionally, the different solubilitys of the crystalline phase and the amorphous grain bounderys can result in a disintegration of the material in grainy particles. In these cases, a biocompatible resorbable homogeneous material possessing a clearly increased resorption rate is desirable. Some calcium phosphate invert glasses are suitable for the development of resorba› ble implants showing well defined resorption rates [3,4]. Because these glasses don’t show phase separation, they represent single phase systems with an uniform solubility. Using a salt-sintering process, the glasses can also be produced in a porous shape with a texture similar to that of spongious bone. A selected glass of this group and the corresponding glass ceramic were used for animal experiments and solubility tests. 57
58
Bioceramics Volume10
MATERIAL S AND METHOD S The composition of the investigated glass/glass ceramic was determined by usual wet chemical methods: 32.6 mol% P2O5, 27.6 mol% CaO, 27.6 mol% Na2 0, 12.2 mol% MgO. Mixed sodi› um/calcium diphosphates and a B-TCP phase, stabilized by magnesium, are the main crystal phases of the glass ceramic. ^^P MAS NMR experiments confirmed the invert glass structure of the materials. They contain not or low condensed phosphate groups exclusively. In their porous form both materials show an total open porosity of 65%. The diameters of the pores vary between 150|Lim and 400^m (figure 1). Smaller pores in the walls between the main pores are caused by the sintering process and range from about l|im and 60^m (15%). Informations about the solubility behavior in dependence on time were obtained using a simple soaking test: Two grams of the substances (grain size 315|Lim to 400 |im) in 200 ml destilled water were shaked by a shaking machine at 37 C for 24 hours. In the eluate, the pH-value and the quantity of dissolved ions were determined. The soaked glass grains were washed and the same procedure was repeated eight times. For the animal experiments guinea pigs were used. Cubes (2x2x2 mm^) of the porous materials were implanted into the tibiae of 72 animals, both sides. After 2, 4, 8, 16, 32 and 64 weeks bone speci› mens containing the rests of the implants were resected. Besides the histological investigation, also histomorphometrical methodes were used. The determination of the total area of the implants by a light microscope combined with a drawing unit and a PC gave informations about the resorption rate in vivo. RESULT S AND DISCUSSIO N Table 1 gives the total quantity of dissolved ions (E Ca^^Mg^^,Na^,P04 ^in mg/1) in dependence of soaking period. The values of the glass are five to seven times higher than the values of TCP. Because of the strongly increased surface of the porous glass also the quantity of dissolved ions is
Figure 1. Resorbable porous phosphate invert glass with a total open porosity of 65%.
Resorbable,Porous PhosphateInvert Glasses: J. Vogel et al.
59
Table 1. Total quantity of dissolved ions (E Ca^^,Mg^^,Na’^,P04 ^’in mg/1) in dependence on soaking period eluatel
eluate2
eluateS
eluate4
eluateS
eluate6
eluate7
eluate8
glass
115.5
126.3
117.3
85.6
89.1
84.8
83.8
78.5
porous glass
290.1
190.1
144.8
120.0
112.6
153.5
160.7
159.0
TCP
16.0
17.8
13.8
15.8
16.5
increased. The reason for the minimum at the fourth and fifth period is unknown in this time. Possibly, an unstable intermediate layer is formed because of the higher reactivity of the porous material. The delayed resorption in vivo some weeks after implantation (see below) could be caused by such a layer. However, the amounts of the several dissolved ions never exceed the physiological tolerance. After an initial period, the values of both glass and porous glass are nearly constant. This is also valide for the pH-values of the eluates (figure 2). Similar to TCP the pH-values come close to the physiological pH-value. Therefore, cell toxicological problems are not to be expected. The lower pH-values of the porous glass in the first eluates is caused by the production process of the porous texture. The histological investigations of both glass and glass ceramic didn’t show any symptoms of inflammation. Within the first two weeks post operation the formation of thick osteoid beams was observed. In the following time the pores act as a guide rail for the young bony cells growing in and the implants are completely incorporated by osteoid after three to four month.
10,Q|
physiologica l pH TCP porous phosphat e glas s phosphat e glas s
9,59.0 i 8.5-
X
Q.
8,07,5 ^
7.oH
,,>^J ;
6,56,0 -
4
5
6
eluate number
Figure 2. pH-values of eluates in dependence on soaking period
60
Bioceramics Volume10
10Oi 4
V
\
^
80-
^ ^ ?
60-
^
40-
A
0\ \ ’^^
20-
()
glass cerami c phosphat e glass j
A>.....___ ^
1
10
20
30
1
40
1
50
1
60
weeks
Figure 3. Total area of resorbable implants in vivo in dependence on time From that time on the osteoblasts of the osteoid are changed to osteocytes. After 64 weeks the spongiosa framework represents a mixture of ripe bone, osteoid and small amounts of incorporated glass/glass ceramic particles. Simultaneous to the formation of bone the porous phosphate glass and glass ceramic are reabsorbed. Figure 3 gives the course of the total area of the implants in dependen› ce on time. 64 weeks post operation only small rests of the materials are detectable (glass: around 2%, glass ceramic: around 10 %). A mechanical instability caused by the dissolution of the implants was not observed. Obvoisly, it is compensated by the increasing bony integration of the implants. CONCLUSION S Both the phosphate invert glass and the glass ceramic meet the requirements of resorbable implant materials. Simultaneous to the resorption process the implants are bony integrated. The resorption rate of the materials is adjusted to the growth and the mineralization of bone. REFERENCE S 1.
Koster, K., Heide, H., Konig, R., Langenbecks Arch. Chir. 343 (1977), 174
2.
Klein, C , Driessen, A., de Groot, K., van den Hooff, A., J. Biomed. Mater. Res. 17(1983), 769784
3.
Hartmann, P., Vogel, J., Schnabel, B., J. Non-Cryst. Solids, 176 (1994), 157-163
4.
Vogel, J., Hartmann, P., Schulze, K.-J. In: Advances in Science and Technology 12: Materials in Clinical Applications, Techna Sri., Faenza 1995, 59-66
Bioceramics, Volume 10 Edited by L. Sedel and C. Rey (Proceedings of the 10th InternationalSymposium on Ceramics in Medicine, Paris, France, October 1997) '1997 Elsevier Science Ltd
IMPLANTATIO N OF BIOACTIV E AND INER T GLAS S FIBRE S IN RAT S TISSU E RESPONS E AND SHORT-TER M REACTION S OF THE GLAS S
SOFT
M. Brink\ P. Laine^ K. Narva^ and A. Yli-Urpo^ ^Department of Chemical Engineering, Abo Akademi University, Biskopsgatan 8, FIN20500 Abo/Turku, Finland ^Institute of Dentistry, University of Turku, Abo/Turku, Finland ABSTRAC T The purpose of this work was to develop a bioactive glass fibre that resorbs in soft tissue without causing inflammatory reactions. In addition, the glass should bond to bone and be easily manufactured. Two different biocompatible glasses were chosen for implantation, and glass surface reactions as well as soft tissue response were evaluated. An inert commercial glass fibre was used as reference. After implantation, all glasses were in good contact with the surrounding tissue. The biocompatible glasses were severely resorbed after 28 days in soft tissue indicating that these glasses are suitable for membranes in orthopaedic and maxillofacial surgery, and for reinforcement of resorbable biopolymers. The reference glass fibre did not show any signs of reaction. KEYWORD S glass fibre, glass reactions, resorption, soft tissue, tissue response INTRODUCTIO N Resorbable bioactive glass fibres may be used as membranes for tissue guiding and as carriers for growth factors in orthopaedic and maxillofacial surgery. The glass fibres may also be used for reinforcement of resorbable biopolymers. For these applications, the fibres should preferably resorb within weeks after implantation without causing any inflammatory reactions. In addition, the fibres must be easily manufactured without risk for devitrification (crystallisation) of the glass melt or fibres. Pazzaglia et al. [1] have developed bioactive glass fibres for substrates for bone apposition, but implanted into rat soft tissue, an intensive inflammation reaction occured. Other bioactive glass fibres, but intended for bone implants, have been presented by Vita Finzi Zalman et al. [2] while Graves and Kumar [3] have developed a bioabsorbable glass fibre for reinforcement of bioabsorbable polymers. The latter fibres are based on the system CaO-P205.
Two different glasses, glass 20-92 and 13-93, were selected for implantation into rat soft tissue. Glass 20-92 is biocompatible but since it contains only 50 wt % SiOi, it has a narrow working range [4,5]. Glass 13-93, containing 53 wt % Si02, is bioactive and has a large working range [4,5]. An inert commercial glass fibre, the E-glass, was used as reference material. After implantation in rat soft tissue, initial glass reactions as well as soft tissue response were evaluated. 61
62
Bioceramics Volume10
MATERIAL S AN D METHOD S The denotations and compositions of the fibres used are given in Table 1. The glasses 20-92 and 13-93 were melted for 1.5 h at 1360’’C in a ceramic crucible (Hackman-Arabia, Finland). The batch size was about 300 g, and all raw materials except the sand were of analytical grade. Glass fibres were obtained by pouring the glass melt onto a rotating plate (about 30 cm in diameter) of stainless steel. The thickness of the fibres could be controlled by changing the spinning velocity. Fibres of glass 20-92 are shown in Figure 1. The E-glass fibres were obtained from Ahlstrom Glass Fibres, Karhula, Finland. The sizing was removed by heating for 40 minutes at 650^C. Prior to implantation, all glass fibres were cut into a length of 5-7 mm, rinsed with ethanol and sterilised in hot air. Two or three different glass fibres were implanted subcutaneously into the soft tissue of 18 Long Evans male rats weighting 290-440 g. The rats were anaesthetised with 0.6-1.0 ml Hypnormfi/Dormicumfi. After the implantation times of 7, 14 and 28 days, the rats were killed with CO2. Tissue samples were fixed in 70% alcohol and embedded into plastics. Histological sections were made using a cutting-grinding technique and stained with toluidine blue. Tissue reactions were analysed with light microscopy and glass surface reactions by scanning electron microscopy (SEM) and energy dispersive X-ray analysis (EDXA). RESULT S AN D DISCUSSION After 7 days, no inflammatory cells were detected around glass 13-93 and 20-92. In general, the number of inflammatory cells around the glass fibres was minimal after all implantation times, and most of the surrounding tissue was inflammation-free. The number of inflammatory cells around E-glass was minimal after 7 days. All glass fibres were in good contact with surrounding tissue, and connective tissue grew in tight contact with the glass surfaces. Figure 2 and 3 present glass 20-92 and 13-93, respectively, after 7 days in rat soft tissue. For fibres of glass 20-92 and 13-93, it was found that the resorpfion had started already after 7 days in soft tissue. The resorption was detected as a silica rich layer at the fibre surface, with sporadic formation of calcium phosphate on top. This result is in accordance with previous studies on rods of glass 13-93 in soft dssue [6]. For glass 20-92, with a durability significantly lower than that of glass 13-93 [7], only a core of original glass surrounded by a silica layer was left after 7 days in vivo. The resorption of this glass was thus more pronounced than that for glass 13-93. However, the surrounding tissue did not show any signs of inflammation. The E-glass showed neither any inflammatory reaction in soft tissue, nor did it resorb. E-glass after 14 days in rat soft tissue is shown in Figure 4. After 28 days in rat soft dssue, fibres of glasses 20-92 and 13-93 were severely resorbed. Glass surface reactions after implantation are presented in Table 2.
Table 1. Denotations and composifions (in wt %) of the investigated glass fibres, and fibre diameter. Fibre 0 Glass NaiO K2O MgO CaO B2O3 AI2O3 P2O5 Si02 70-300 ^m 20-92 15 15 2 15 3 50 70-300 \im 13-93 6 12 5 20 4 53 10 |Lim** E-glass 1* 0.7 22.5 6.4 14.7 54 *Na20+K20 **The E-glass was implanted as a bunch of fibres.
Implantationof Bioactive and Inert Glass Fibres in Rats: M. Brink et al.
63
Table 2. Glass surface reactions after implantation into rat soft tissue for several observation times. (Ca,P = calcium phosphate) Glass 7 days 14 days 28 days 20-92 Silica gel with Ca,P Silica gel with Ca,P Silica gel with Ca,P 13-93 Silica gel with Ca,P Silica gel with Ca,P Silica gel with Ca,P No reaction No reaction No reaction E-glass* *without sizing CONCLUSION S This study indicates that glasses 20-92 and 13-93 are suitable for biomedical use as resorbable materials. Which of these two is the more suitable depends on the application. It was shown that fibres of these two glasses resorbed while the E-glass fibres did not. The resorption was initiated almost immediately but no inflammation reaction was detected. ACKNOWLEDGEMENT S This work was financially supported by the Finnish Technology Development Centre (TEKES) and the Academy of Finland (FA).
K-i^
Figure 1. Fibres of glass 20-92.
Figure 2. Glass 20-92 after 7 days in rat soft tissue, (magnification 125x)
64
Bioceramics Volume10
Figure 3. Glass 13-93 after 7 days in rat soft tissue, (magnification 125x)
Figure 4. E-glass after 14 days in rat soft tissue, (magnification 125x)
REFERENCES 1. Pazzaglia U.E., Gabbi, C , Locardi, B., Di Nucci, A., Zatti, G. and Cherubino, P. J Biomed.Mater.Res. 1989, 23, 1289-1297. 2. Vita Finzi Zalman, E., Locardi, B., Gabbi, C. and Tranquilli Leali, P. WO 91/12032 i. Graves (Jr.), G.A. and Kumar, B. United States Patent 4,604,097. 4. Brink, M. /. Biomed.Mater.Res. (to appear). ^’ appe^)^" ^"’’"’^"’ ^ ’ "’’PP’"’^’’’ ^-^- ^ ^ Yli-Urpo, A. J. Biomed.Mater.Res. (to
’
TTL^r.’^It
’
" ’ ^’’’""’^"^ ^- ’ " ’’^’’
^’’’’
BiomaterialsCongress,
7. Brink, M., Karlsson, K.H. and Yli-Urpo, A. WO 96/21628 (pending).
Bioceramics, Volume 10 Edited by L. Sedel and C. Rey (Proceedingsof the10th InternationalSymposiumon Ceramics in Medicine, Paris, France, October1997) '1997 Elsevier Science Ltd
Spinal Fusion using Titanium Spacers with Bioglassfi and Autogenous Bone: A Comparative study in Sheep June Wilson\ Gary Lowery^, Stephen Courtney^ 1. Imperial College, Dept. of Materials, Prince Consort Rd. London SW7 2BP Tel/Fax 44(0)171 594 6745 2. Research Institute International, 6400 W. Newberry Road, Ste. 206, Gainesville, Florida 32605-4391 USA
ABSTRAC T Spinal fusion, or the surgical accomplishment of a bony union of deficient vertebral segments, is required in cases where long-term immobilization of these segments is indicated. In the anterior lumbar spine, this procedure requires the use of an intervertebral graft construct which is able to support the axial forces until confluent healing of the graft material occurs. In this study titanium surgical mesh spacers were filled with autologous bone, Bioglassfi, or a mixture of the two in the adult sheep spine. After three and six months the new bone was assessed both qualitatively and quantitatively and results show that although at three months autologous bone is to be preferred, by six months there is no significant difference between the three graft materials. This is particularly important since provision of sufficient autologous bone is always difficult and is associated with a high morbidity rate.
INTRODUCTIO N Spinal fusion is indicated in a variety of disorders of the lumbar spine. The goal of this surgery is to achieve bony immobilization of the affected levels. Anterior interbody fusions, usually relying on the use of autologous bone, are indicated in many cases of discal deficiency [1]. AAV ceramic monoliths [2] and titanium mesh spacers packed with autologous cancellous bone [3] have been used in this procedure. Availability and morbidity issues limit the use of harvested autologous bone [4], while the use of allograft involves inherent concerns regarding disease transmission. The ideal bone graft supplement to autologous bone should be both osteoinductive and osteoconductive, allowing bone to grow in a confluent manner, and resorbable, allowing complete replacement by new bone and restoration of near-normal host conditions. The mixing of bioactive glass particles with autologous bone is expected to provide an osteoinductive and osteoconductive material in which the osteogenic proteins derived from the host bone act with the bioactive material to promote rapid bone growth throughout the spacer used for stabilization, which must eventually depend n bony union rather than metallic fixation.
MATERIAL S Titanium surgical mesh intervertebral spacers (Depuy, Inc., Warsaw, Indiana) Particulate 45S5 Bioglassfi 100-410|im diameter. (USBiomaterials Corporation, Alachua, Florida) Autologous bone chips harvested at surgery
METHOD S Cages were placed in four adjacent vertebral (LI -L4) fenestrations created in adult sheep. Six animals were studied after three months and five after six months. The death of one animal in the second group was unrelated to the experiment. Of the four cages, one was filled with the autologous bone chips, one with Bioglass particulate and one with an approximately 50-50 mixture of the two, before insertion in the defect. The fourth cage was left unfilled as a control. The allocation of cages to sites was rotated through the animals. The cage is shown in fig. 1. In the first two animals the larger cage was used, in the remainder the cage was 10mm in diameter. Postoperativecare: Sutures were removed after 7 days. Postoperatively, the animals were monitored for signs of pain or distress until fully recovered (7-10 days). Intramuscular anti-inflammatory pain medication was administered as needed for pain. Food and water intake was monitored during the experimental period. 65
66 Bioceramics Volume 10
Fig. 1. Titanium mesh cage At autopsy the cages and surrounding tissues were removed and fixed in formalin. They were embedded in plastic and sawn sections cut transversely. The sections were stained with Paragon and Sanderson’s stains and the nature of the bone assessed. Sections with a complete and well-oriented cage cross-section were used to measure the amount of bone-fill within the cage using an Olympus Image Analysis system. The measurements were made by taking the total cross-sectional area of the cage, measured around the outer circumference and subtracting the area of the titanium mesh to give the area available for infill. The area which was not bone was then identified and subtracted from the area available and the bone infill was expressed as a percentage of the area available. In this way we hope to minimize any differences resulting from the use of 14mm cages in the first two animals and 10mm cages in the rest.
RESULT S The animals recovered well from the surgery and regained their mobility. After three months the bone infill was seen to contain particles of the Bioglassfi with normal bone (fig. 2). Space not filled by bone contained variable amounts of fibrous tissue, but no significant inflammation. After six months the appearance of the bone was similar but space not filled by bone contained little fibrous tissue and seemed to be empty.
Fig 2. Trabecular bone containing Bioglass after six months {Sanderson stain
Spinal Fusion Using TitaniumSpacers With Bioglass^and AutogenousBone: J. Wilson et al. 67 Table 1 - Bone infill after 3 months Cage alone: Bioglassfi alone: Bone alone: Mixture
46.2% 56.7% 93.3% 64.2%
(20.7%-58.1%) (23.5% - 100%) (85.4% - 100%) (57.6% - 78%)
n=5 n=5 n=4 n=5
Table 2 - Bone infill after 6 months Cage alone: Bioglassfi alone: Bone alone: Mixture
47% 82.3% 98% 81.7%
(32.4% - 83%) (67.6% - 90.4%) (94.1%-100%) (69.9%-88.1%)
n=4 n=3 n=3 n=4
After three months the percentage of bone infill was as shown in Table 1. At six months however differences between test groups were less, Table 2. There was considerable variation between animals and thus a spread in the measurements but it is clear that autologous bone remains the best choice in the shorter term, although under optimal conditions complete bone fill was achieved using Bioglassfi alone in one animal. Between 3 and 6 months no change occurred in the amount of bone in the control cages and little change was possible in those filled with bone, since the fill was so high by 3 months. The infill in those filled with Bioglassfi alone and the particulate had increased to where there was no significant difference between them. The results are shown in fig. 3. Students t-test showed that there are no statistical differences between the test groups at six months.
10 0
tt
40
Cage Alone D Bioglass(R ) Alone [H Bone Alone 3 Months
(A)
Fig. 3. (A) Bone fill at 3m. (B) at 6m.
6 Months (B)
Mixture
68 Bioceramics Volume 10
CONCLUSION S We believe that we have shown in this experiment that particulate 45S5 Bioglassfi can be used to replace or dilute autologous bone used to assist in bony repair, thus reducing the immobility associated with harvesting of such bone. It appears also from these results that the contribution of autologous bone and associated osteoinductive factors may be effective even when only small amounts, such as those derived from the bleeding subchondral endplates and generated during surgery, are mixed with the Bioglassfi. The regeneration is slower than that achieved with autologous bone but the clinical advantage lies in the reduction to a minimum of the need for harvesting of bone from the patient.
POS T SCRIP T In November 1996 an 11 month-old bulldog puppy was brought to the University of Florida’s Veterinary Medical Teaching Hospital suddenly paralyzed as a result of a congenital spinal disorder, hemivertebra. She was successfully treated by stabilizing the spine with titanium mesh filled with particulate Bioglassfi and is now completely recovered and mobile. The surgeon. Dr. Roger Clemmons, explained that there is normally no treatment for this condition other than euthanasia.
ACKNOWLEDGEMENT
S
The authors thank Dr. Y. Fujishura of Tahaka University, Japan for the image analysis. The work was supported by USBiomaterials Corporation, Alachua, Florida.
REFERENCE S
1. Fraser RD, Spine,1995 20 (suppl.) pp. 167-177S. 2. Yamamuro T; Bioceramics8, 1995 Pergamon Press, Oxford England., pp.123-127. 3. Lowery GL and Harims J., Manual of InternalFixationof Spine,Raven Press, 1996 Lippencott-Raven Publishers, Philadelphia, PA, pp. 127-146. 4. Fernyhough JC, Schimandle JH, Weigel MC, Edwards CC, Levine AM, Spine,1992 17 pp. 1474-1480.
DENSE AND POROUS BIOACTIVE CERAMICS
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
Bioceramics, Volume 10 Edited by L. Sedel and C. Rey (Proceedings of the 10th InternationalSymposium on Ceramics in Medicine, Paris, France, October 1997) '1997 Elsevier Science Ltd
MACROPOROU S DIPHASI C CALCIU M PHOSPHAT E CERAMICS : INFLUENC E OF MACROPOR E DL\METE R AND MACROPOROSIT Y PERCENTAG E ON BON E INGROWT H 1,2
O. Gauthier, ^J-M. Bouler, ^’^E. Aguado, ^P. Filet and ^G. Daculsi
^ Laboratoire de Chimrgie, Ecole Nationale Veterinaire de Nantes, Route de Gachet, BP 40706, 44307 Nantes cedex 03, France, ^ Centre de Recherche sur les materiaux d’interet biologique, Faculte de Chimrgie Dentaire, 1 place Alexis Ricordeau, 44042 Nantes Cedex 01, France ABSTRAC T A total of 60 cylindrical 6 x 6 mm samples of a macroporous biphasic calcium phosphate (MBCP) ceramic was implanted into a distal femoral site in 30 rabbits. These samples represented 6 kinds of implants with 2 different macropore diameters and 3 different macroporosity percentages. Eight weeks after implantation, analysis of backscattered electron images of implant surfaces analysed by a factorial design method showed that implants with 565 ^im pore size provided more abundant newly-formed bone both in peripheral and deep pores than those with 300 jam pore size. No significant differences were found between implants with 40% and 50% macroporosity, suggesting that the influence of macropore size on bone ingrowth was greater than that of macroporosity percentage. MBCP implants with 565 ^im pore diameter and 40% macroporosity represented the optimal association for homogeneous and abundant bone ingrowth. KEYWORD S : bone substitute, ceramic, calcium phosphate, porosity INTRODUCTIO N Macroporosity is conducive to osteoconduction of BCP ceramics but also has many effects on their mechanical behaviour [1, 2]. Cell colonisation and bone ingrowth apparently occur when macropore size is greater than 100 |.im [3], and a reduction in macroporosity may have negative results for the biological properties of macroporous biphasic calcium phosphate (MBCP) ceramics, in that optimal macroporosity parameters have not yet been defined. The purpose of this study was to evaluate the influence of macroporosity on the osteoconduction of BCP ceramics. Bone ingrowth was quantified in several kinds of MBCP implants to determine the most desirable pore size and porosity percentage for osteoconduction. MATER[AL S AND METHOD S We used a MBCP ceramic with a 60/40 HA/pTCP weight ratio. Two main parameters were tested : macropore size (Fl) and macroporosity percentage (F2). Two different macropore diameters, 300 and 565 jam, and two different macroporosity percentages, 40% and 50%, were studied. These four values defined an experimental domain that was studied with a factorial design method (FDM), based on a first-order polynomial mathematical model, to analyse the quantitative resuhs and determine the influence of each factor on bone ingrowth [4, 5]. Ten samples each of 4 kinds of MBCP implants with different macroporosity levels (table 1) were prepared for purposes of statistical evaluation (I = 300 jam and 40% , II = 565 \xmand 40%, III = 300 |Lim and 50%, IV = 565 |im and 50%). 71
72
Bioceramies Volume10
Table 1. Experimental matrix
1
^
1
I II III IV
Fl : macropore diameter (jLim) -1 +1 -1 +1
F2 : macroporosity percentage (%) -1 -1 +1 +1
level -1 level +1
300 –33.3 565121.7
40+1.8 50 –2.0
11-2 : interaction between Fl andF2 +1 -1 -1 +1
Ten samples of 2 other kinds of implants (V = 50% and 565 jam, VI= 30% and 300 \xm)were used on ten other rabbits to compare the experimental data for newly-formed bone with the values calculated with the FDM. Ceramic implantations (randomised distribution) were performed on 30 New Zealand white rabbits. A cylindrical defect was created at the distal end of rabbit femurs at the epiphysometaphyseal junction. A MBCP implant 6 mm long and 6 mm in diameter was positioned to fill the defect. All rabbits were killed 8 weeks after implantation. Femoral extremities were excised, fixed in glutaraldehyde solution, dehydrated in graded ethanol and embedded in glycolmethylmethacrylate. Sections of the femur from each group were analysed by undecalcified histological examination. For each sample, serial sections were cut perpendicular to the long axis of the implant. Qualitative observations were performed in light microscopy on solochrome-cyanine stained sections and with polarised light on unstained ones. The block was then sputtered with Au-Pd for scanning electron microscopy (SEM) observations. Quantitative evaluation was performed by image analysis of the SEM observations of implant surfaces using backscattered electrons (BSE). The whole surface of implants was divided in 12 contiguous fields and recorded on SEM with magnification X50. Threshold was determined by the operator on image analyser and the newlyformed bone surfaces were then automatically calculated and expressed as the percentage of the whole surface. RESULTS All implants showed extensive osteoconduction. In light microscopy, most peripheral pores were completely filled with well-mineralised lamellar bone. This new bone often showed a haversian structure. Only implants II and IV showed evidence of bone colonisation in deep pores where lamellar bone was found on the surface of almost every macropore. Measurements from SEM and image analysis observations based on graylevel distribution allowed to calculate a mean percentage of newly-formed bone for the samples of each kind of implant (table 2). According to the experimental matrix of the FDM, the influences of each factor and the interaction between Fl and F2 (I1.2) were determined for implants I, II, III and IV. The equation describing the percentage of newly-formed bone in implants can be formulated as follows : (1) newly-formed bone % = CM% + Si(fi.Fi), where CM% is the calculated mean for implants I, II, III and IV, and li(fi.Fi) is a first-order polynomial fiinction depending on significant influences and interaction between factors Fl and F2.
Macroporous Biphasic Calcium Phosphate Ceramics: O. Gauthieret al.
73
Table 2. Newly-formed bone percentages for the different kinds of MBCP implants. Implants
I
U
II I
IV
newly-formed bone % Implants newly-formed
16.7 – 3 . 9 1
20.6 – 5 . 5 0
16.8 – 3 . 0 7
22.0 – 6 . 9 3
V 22.0 – 5 . 3 0
VT 8.7 –3.28
Calculated mean (CM ) 19.0
bone % Using values from the experimental matrix, the equation became : (2) newly-formed bone % = C M % + (2.28 x F l ) + (0.39 x F2) + (0.35 x F l F2) Only the influence of macropore diameter seemed to have a significant impact on bone ingrowth. The equation can thus be simplified : (3) newly-formed bone % = C M % + 2.28 X I , XI was a coded value related to macropore diameter D by XI = (D - 432.5)/l32.5 The equation then became : (4) newly-formed bone % = 11.6 + (0.017 D) For implants V, F D M gave a percentage of newly-formed bone of 21.2% – 5.07, whereas the experimental results for 10 MBCP samples of implant V gave a percentage of newly-formed bone of 22.0% – 5 . 3 0 These two values were not significantly different. The experimental results for implants VI were not predicted by the FDM (table 2). DISCUSSIO N A FDM mathematical model was used to investigate in vivo mechanisms relative to the influence of macropore size and macroporosity percentage on bone ingrowth. Our precise experimental conditions showed that newly-formed bone in MBCP ceramics can be regarded as a simple and linear function of macropore size (11.6 + 0.017 D). FDM could not account for the behaviour of VI implants whose macroporosity parameters were chosen outside of the experimental area. This indicates that interpretation of FDM data cannot be extended beyond the experimental limits defined by implants I, II, III and IV but can predict bone ingrowth if macroporosity parameters are still chosen inside the experimental domain. Our in vivo conditions led to great variability. However, our work concerned a large number of BCP samples and provided very precise quantitative evaluation using SEM with BSE [6]. This original image analysis method based on the recording of contiguous images seems to be applicable to the study of biomaterials with good reproducibilty. Macroporosity confers osteoconductive properties on bone substitutes and it is generally admitted that 80-100 )Lim is the minimal pore size for osteoconduction. In our study, after 8 weeks of implantation, better bone ingrowth was achieved for macropores of 565 than 300 |nm. Newly-formed bone was not only significantly more abundant in BCP implants with 565 fim macropores but was also observed in both peripheral and central macropores. The BCP implants with 30% macroporosity and 300 |im pore diameter gave a very low rate of newlyformed bone. Their macropore size and macroporosity percentage were both inadequate with our
74
Bioceramics Volume10
model. In fact, the FDM and experimental results indicated that macroporosity percentage was a less important influence than macropore size. For a similar macropore size, there was no significant difference in newly-formed bone for implants with 40% or 50% macroporosity. Our results would appear to have important mechanical implications. The mechanical properties of BCP ceramics improve in vivo due to bone ingrowth in macropores and reprecipitation of biological apatites in micropores [7, 8, 9]. In our study, a macropore size of 565 jLim provided a higher rate of newly-formed bone than one of 300 \xm.The presence of this new bone over the entire implant surface can have a favourable influence on BCP mechanical behaviour. The more macroporous implants are before implantation, the less mechanical resistance they offer [10] but it has been demonstrated that macroporosity percentage has a greater influence than macropore diameter on the compressive strength of BCP implants [5]. From this study, we could consider that implants with 565 j.im macropore size and 40% macroporosity could have a 67% higher compressive strength (24.3 MPa) compared to the same implants with 50% macroporosity (14.5 MPa). A reduction in macroporosity without major effects on bone ingrowth seems possible with 40% rather than 50% macroporosity. CONCLUSIO N This in vivo study of bone ingrowth in MBCP ceramics indicates that the influence of macropore size is greater than that of macroporosity percentage. For the same macropore size, no significant difference in newly-formed bone was noted for implants of 40% and 50% macroporosity. Osteoconduction was more efficient for MBCP implants with a 565 than a 300 jiim macropore m pore diameter and a 40%) macroporosity percentage should provide mechanical diameter. A 565 |Li improvement and preserve optimal bone ingrowth in MBCP ceramics. REFERENCE S 1. Daculsi, G. and Passuti, N., Biomaterials 1990, 11, 86-87. 2. De Groot, K., Ann.NY Acad. Sci. 1988, 253, 227-233. 3 Shimazaki, K. and Mooney, V., J. Orthop. Res. 1985, 3, 301-310. 4. Goupy, J. In: La methode des plans d’experience, Dunod, Paris, 1988. 5. Bouler, J.M., Trecant, M., Delecrin, J., Royer, J., Passuti, N. and Daculsi, G., J. Biomed. Mater. Res. 1996, 32, 603-609. 6. Skedros, J.G., Bloebaum, R.D., Bachus, K.N., Boyce, T.M. and Constantz, B., J. Biomed. Mater. Res. 1993, 27, 47-56. 7. Martin, R.B., Chapman, M.W., Holmes, R.E., Sartoris, D.J., Shors, E C , Gordon, J.E., Heitter, DO., Sharkey, N.A. and Zissimos, AG., Biomaterials 1989, 10, 481-488. 8. Daculsi, G., LeGeros, R.Z., Heughebaert, M. and Barbieux, I., Calcif Tissue Int. 1990, 46, 20-27. 9. Trecant, M., Delecrin, J., Royer, J. and Daculsi, G., Clin. Mater. 1994, 15, 233-240. 10. Le Huec, J.C, Schaeverbeke, T., Clement, D., Faber, J., Le Rebeller, A., Biomaterials 1995, 16, 113-118.
Bioceramics, Volume 10 Edited by L. Sedel and C. Rey (Proceedings of the 10th InternationalSymposium on Ceramics in Medicine, Paris, France, October 1997) '1997 Elsevier Science Ltd
MECHANICA L FATIGU E OF HO T PRESSE D HYDROX Y APATIT E S. Raynaud, E. Champion, D. Bernache-Assollant Laboratoire de Materiaux Ceramiques et Traitements de Surface, ESA CNRS 6015, 123, Avenue Albert Thomas, 87060 Limoges, France
ABSTRAC T Polycrystalline hydroxyapatite (HAP) was densified by hot pressing. Dynamic fatigue resistance of the resulting ceramics and degradation process in aqueous solution were investigated. Inmiediate fracture strength in air decreases from 90 MPa to 40 MPa when residual porosity ratio increases from 2% to 6%. The crack propagation exponent n, characteristic of subcritical crack growth, decreases from 22.5–2 in air to 10=^4 in Ringer’s solution for materials densified at 98% of the theoretical value. A value of only n = 14–4 is obtained in air at 94% of relative density. The degradation in solution proceeds by dissolution of crystalline HAP which leads to the decohesion of grains located around residual pores at the surface of the material. KEYWORD S : Hydroxyapatite, Strength, Fatigue, Dissolution. INTRODUCTIO N Hydroxyapatite (Caio(P04)6(OH)2) is a ceramic material of interest for biological applications [1,2]. Although the mechanical properties of dense HAP, fracture strength and toughness, have been widely reported [3-7], few studies concerning mechanical fatigue are available yet [6-8]. The long time application of stresses, even at low level, can induce delayed fracture, depending on environmental conditions. For HAP, it is important to evaluate its behaviour under mechanical loads because this bioceramic is known to be chemically affected by physiological environment [9]. Fatigue phenomenon is analysed in term of subcritical crack growth with the relationship [10]: V=
da dt
= AKf A
(1)
where V is the crack velocity, a is the crack length, Ki is the stress intensity factor at the crack tip, A is a constant, and n is the propagation exponent. The value of n is characteristic of the resistance to mechanical fatigue of a material under a given environment. The fracture strength depends on the stressing rate according to the relation [11]: 75
76
Bioceramics Volume10
Lna f
-Ln B(n + l)an-2 n+1
(2)
-Lna n+l
where a^ is the fracture strength, B is a constant, G\ is the inert fast fracture strength and d is the stressing rate. Thus, the measurement of fracture strength at different stressing rates allows the determination of the propagation exponent n from the slope of the straight line on the graph Lna^ = F(Lna). This work consisted in determining fatigue data for hot pressed HAP ceramics and evaluating the influence of the environment on materials degradation. MATERIAL S AND METHOD S A commercial stoichiometric hydroxyapatite powder was hot pressed under a constant compressive stress of 10 MPa either at 1165 C during 1 hour or at 1100 C during 30 minutes. Sintered blocks were cut into bars of 4*3*25 mm^ and each bar was polished with a 3 jim diamond paste. Quasi static, or immediate fracture strength in air was determined by three-point bending with a 16 mm span and a crosshead speed of 0.2 mm.min-l. The dissolution of HAP ceramics was investigated in Ringer’s solution at 37 C [12]. The degradation of samples was evaluated by measurements of surface roughness for immersion times ranging from one day to three weeks. Mechanical testing of HAP samples by dynamic fatigue in solution was investigated in a device which permits the control of liquid environment (constant temperature of 37 C and constant liquid flowing), the crosshead speed varied in the range 3.10-^ nmi.min-l to 2 mm.min-l. Since the determination of fracture strength measured by three-point bending can be biased by the location of the flaw which initiates crack propagation, an artificial defect was generated on the surface of samples by Vickers indentation under 4.9 N load. RESULT S AND DISCUSSIO N Immediate fracture strength in air decreases from 90 MPa to 40 MPa when the residual porosity ratio increases from 2% to 6%. Dynamic fatigue experiments allow to calculate the crack propagation exponent n (from equation 2). The results obtained from linear regressions of measured data are given in table 1. Values of n = 22.5–2 and n = 14–4 are obtained for HAP ceramics tested in ambient air and densified at 98% and 94% of the theoretical density, respectively. The propagation exponent is n = 10–2 for materials at 98% of relative density, tested in Ringer’s solution. In air, both fracture strength and resistance to subcritical crack growth decrease as the volume fraction of residual pores increases. In the same way, the liquid environment induces a drastic drop of the resistance to fatigue for HAP ceramics densified at 98%. These results are close to those found by G. De With who showed an important sensitivity of HAP Table 1. Analysis of dynamic fatigue plots. Experimental conditions HAP 98 % in air
Linear regression Lna = 4.43 + 4.23 10’^ L n a
HAP 98 % in Ringer’s solution Lna = 4.48 + 9.05 1 0 ’ L n a HAP 94 % in air HAP 94 % in Ringer’s solution
Lna = 4.04 + 6.59 lO’^Lna Not significant - too low confidence level
Meclumical Fatigue of Hot Pressed Hydroxyapatite:S. Raynaud Qi al.
77
180-
^
160140-
e
/
120-
HAP 94% HAP 98%
1 0 0^ 8 06 0-
20 30 40 50 60 70 APPLIE D STRES S (MPa)
Figure 1. Simulated lifetime versus fictive applied stress.
40^
nt-* 10 15 TIM E (days)
20
25
Figure 2. Average surface roughness versus immersion time in Ringer’s solution.
to slow crack growth in air (n = 26), mechanical degradation which is enhanced by water environment (n = 12) [7]. The results on mechanical fatigue characteristics can be clearly illustrated by the evaluation of time-to-failure under a fixed stress. Indeed, dynamic fatigue experiments allow to calculate an estimation of the lifetime of a material. The lifetime under constant applied stress is given by the following relationship : Lntf=LnBa|
n-2
- nLn Ga
(3)
where tf is the time-to-failure and a^ is the applied stress, n and B a " ^ are calculated from the linear regressions constants of dynamic fatigue data. Simulated plots of time-to-failure under constant applied stress are given in Figure 1. They show that the lifetime under mechanical loads is much shorter when the material is subjected to liquid environment. For example, in the case of HAP densified at 98 %, the lifetime under a tensile stress of 30 MPa would be of about 100 hours in solution whereas it would be of more than 100 years in air. An expected lifetime of 20 years in solution would require that stresses do not exceed 15 MPa, which means that HAP ceramics cannot be used in stressed regions of the body. This behaviour also indicates that stress enhanced chemical reaction proceeds at the crack tip, resulting in a very low resistance of HAP to subcritical crack propagation in liquid solution. The influence of liquid environment on HAP degradation can be evaluated by surface observations. Figure 2 shows the plots of average roughness (Ra) of samples surfaces versus immersion time in Ringer’s solution. The difference in initial Ra values between HAP densified at 98% and 94% is due to residual pores at the surface of materials. In any case, the average roughness increases with the immersion time in Ringer’s solution. For HAP densified at 94%, a doubling of Ra value is noticed after three weeks of immersion. A typical SEM micrograph of HAP surfaces after 3 weeks of immersion is given in figure 3a. Compared with the initial surfaces (fig. 3b), the degradation of materials surface after immersion is not uniform. Rings like grooves with dimensions close to the grains size appear in only some regions and dense regions do not seem to be degraded. It can be assessed that the degraded regions are preferentially located around residual pores presents at the surface of initial material.
78
Bioceramics Volume10
Figure 3. SEM micrographs of HAP surfaces (material densified at 94%). (a) after 3 weeks of immersion - (b) initial. This shows that dissolution of HAP is accompanied by the decohesion of some grains. Different interpretations can be found to explain the degradation mechanism of calcium phosphates in liquid. In our case, it can be hypothesised that the degradation proceeds through HAP surface dissolution. This phenomenon would lead to a preferential decohesion of grains located around pores. CONCLUSIO N The mechanical behaviour of HAP depends strongly on the presence of residual pores. In solution, it is subjected to surface dissolution accompanied with grains decohesion around these pores. Slow crack growth is enhanced by the dissolution at the crack tip. Thus, HAP ceramics appear too brittle and sensitive to liquid environments to be used under stresses. Providing a good control of the microstructural design of HAP matrix may be obtained to prevent the detrimental effect of residual pores, composite technology seems to be a way to improve the mechanical reliability and decrease the motion of subcritical crack growth in HAP based materials and finally extend their potential applications.
REFERENCES
Oonishi, H., Biomaterials,1991, 12, 171-178. Hench, L.L., J, Amer. Ceram.Soc, 1991, 74 [7], 1487-1510. Jarcho, M., Bolen, C.H., Thomas, M.B., Bobick, J., Kay, J.F. and Doremus, R.H., J. Mater.ScLA916, 11, 2027-2035. 4. Akao, M., Aoki, H. and Kato, K., ibid.,1981, 16, 809-812. 5. Halouani, R., Bernache-Assollant, D., Champion, E. and Ababou, A., 7. Mater. Sci. Mater. Med., 1994,5,563-567. 6. Thomas, M.B., Doremus, R.H., Jarcho, M. and Salsbury, R.L., J. Mater. Sci, 1980, 15, 891-894. 7. De With, G., Van Dijk, H.J.A., Hattu., N. and Prijs, K., ibid.,1981, 16, 1592-1598. 8. Nonami, T. and Wakai, P., J. Ceram.Soc. Jpn.,1995, 103 [6], 648-652. 9. De Groot, K., In: Bioceramics,Annals New-York Acad. Sci. 1988, 227-233. 10. Evans, A.G., Int.Journ.of Fracture,1974, 10 [2], 251-259. 11. Fett, T. and Munz, D., J. Eur. Ceram.Soc, 1990, 6, 67-72. 12. Barbosa, M.A., In: Biomaterialsdegradation,edited by M. A. Barbosa, 1991, 227-252. 1. 2. 3.
Bioceramics, Volume 10 Edited by L. Sedel and C. Rey (Proceedings of the 10th InternationalSymposium on Ceramics in Medicine, Paris, France, October 1997) '1997 Elsevier Science Ltd
MECHANICA L PROPERT Y CHANGE S IN MACROPOROU S CERAMI C AFTE R IMPLANTATIO N INT O BON E AND MUSCL E M. Trecant-Viana\ J. Delecrin\ J.M. Nguyen", J. Royer\ G. Daculsi’ ^ Centre de recherche interdisciplinaire sur les tissus calcifies et les biomateriaux, Facuhe de chirurgie dentaire, 1 place A. Ricordeau, 44042 NANTES, France ^ Unite statistique et informatique medicales, CHRU, 44042 NANTES, France Laboratoire de mecanique des structures, Ecole Centrale de Nantes, 1 rue de la Noe, 44000 NANTES, France ABSTRAC T Compressive strength and stiffness of MBCP were investigated after 1 to 18 weeks of implantation in rabbit bone and muscle. It was shown that in the two sites the mechanical properties of the implants increased with the implantation duration. Nevertheless, these changes occured to a different degree or followed a different law, suggesting site-dependant structural, physico-chemical and histological modifications. This hypothesis was confirmed by a stepwise multiple linear regression analysis relative to the two mechanical characteristics and four variables (macroporosity, bone, ceramic and microporosity). The role of newly formed bone was confirmed : it filled the macropores and confered a composite stmcture to the implant. In addition the influence of physico-chemical exchanges (dissolution/reprecipitation process) leading to a decrease of the microporosity was revealed. KEYWORD S : calcium phosphates, mechanical properties, in vivo INTRODUCTIO N Clinical applications of calcium phosphate bioceramics as bone grafts substitutes are limited by their poor mechanical properties [1-4]. Macropores are necessary to promote bone formation inside the ceramic [5], but obviously they decrease the mechanical characteristics of the implant. Yet this initial strength has been shown to change when the biomaterial was placed in contact not only with bone [6-9] but also with muscle [9]. Phenomenons taking place in implanted calcium phosphate ceramics (dissolution/reprecipitation process and bone formation) have been the subject of numerous investigations [10-19] but the mechanisms which determine the mechanical properties modifications are still unidentified. The objective of this study w^as to provide quantitative understanding of the effects of physico-chemical changes and bone formation on the compressive strength and Young modulus of implanted Macroporous Biphasic Calcium Phosphate (MBCP). MATERIAL S AND METHOD S Experiment MBCP cylinders were implanted (1, 2, 3, 6, 12, 15 and 18 weeks) into the femoral epiphysis (6x6 mm) and muscle (5x5 mm) of mature male New Zealand rabbits. Samples intended for mechanical investigation were prepared as described in a previous w^ork [8]. After compressive strength and stiffness measurements, specimens were embedded in methyl methacrylate for visual characterization of implant stmcture ; macropore, ceramic and bone 79
80
Bioceramics Volume10
percentages were measured on microradiographs and microporosity was determined using backscattered electron (BSE) imaging [20]. Analysis The means and standard deviations for com.pressive strength and the Young modulus w^ere determined and a stepwise multiple linear regression analysis w^as performed relative to the tv/o m.echanical characteristics and the four variables (macroporosity, bone, ceram.ic and microporosity) to determ,ine the best predictor of a and E of implanted MBCP. RESULT S Visual characterizatio n of implant structure Figure 1 shows the changes in bone and macroporosity after implantation into bone. It can be observed that macroporosity decreased as bone formation occured during the first 12 weeks. Then bone percentage became stable and macroporosity remained unchanged For MBCP implanted in muscle, only a slight tendancy to degradation of the ceramic was obser\^ed at 18 weeks. SEM image analysis showed that microporosity decreased similarly in bone and muscle sites during the implantation period studied (Figure 2). Compressive strength and stiffness Compressive strength increased linearly in both sites during the first 15 weeks (Figure 3). Comparison of the slopes revealed that the increase in compressive strength was greater when N4BCP v/as implanted into bone (Student /-test, n=72, p<0.0001). Concerning the stiffness, it w^as shown that in bone site the Young modulus increased linearly until w^eek 15 and then stabilized, w^hereas in muscle it obeyed an hyperbolic law (Figure 4). Multiple linear regression Microporosity and ceramic were the best em,pirical predictors of compressive strength and stiffriess (Table 1). Only the com^pressive strength of MBCP implanted in muscle v/as less correlated but the significance of microporositv was confirmed by simple linear regression (n=17, p=0.0017). DISCUSSIO N Results of this study showed that mechanical properties of MBCP changed after implantation in both bone and muscle. Nevertheless, according to the implantation site, modifications occured to a different degree (lower slope for compressive strength of MBCP in muscle) or followed a different law (nonlinear development of the Young modulus in muscle), revealing site-dependant structural, physico-chemical and histological modifications. MBC P implanted into bone Visual characterization of implant structure revealed thai bone formation occured inside the m^acropores during the first 12 weeks of implantation followed by stabihzation. On the other hand mechanical strength still increased until the 15^^’ week. Then two phases in the m.echanical properties evolution of implanted MBCP could be distinguished : i) during the first 12 weeks, MBCP mechanical characteristics seemed to be related to partial filling of macropores with new bone and ii) after 12 weeks, modification of the mechanical properties depended only on the composite behavior of the implant. The strengthening between 12 and 15 weeks could result from the maturation of newiy-fbrmed bone (collagen fiber density and orientation, mineralization, trabecular organization and connectivity, as observed with normal bone [2123]) or from a consolidation of the ceramic/new bone interface. Conversely, iht decrease after 15 w^eeks could be due to bone remodelling (increasing number of resorption sites and w^oven bone transformation into lamellar bone [21-23]). This study also revealed the significance of microporosity, w^hich v/ould appear to be the best predictor of compressive strength and elastic modulus. The decrease in m^icroporosity following apatite microcr>’Stals precipitation [20] could have partly accounted for the increase in the mechanical strength o^ MBCP im^planted in bone.
Mechanical Property Changes in Macroporous Ceramic After Implantation:M. Trecant-Vianaet al.
81
MBC P implanted into muscle Regression analysis showed that microporosity was the best predictor of compressive strength and elastic modulus. Thus strengthening of MBCP im.planted into m.uscle appeared to be the result of apatite niicrocr>’stals precipitation in ceramic micropores. mJcroporosit y (%) 7 01
50-i
\ \ 40-]
1
H^
10
12
14
16
10
13
12
14
16
18
vwseks
Figure 1. Evolution of macroporosity ( )and bone ( ) percentages in MBCP implanted into bone.
Figure 2. Evolution of microporosity percentage of MBCP implanted into bone ( ) and muscle ( )
E (MPa)
CT (MPa)
15001 i25Cri
I
t
’ I*
^%\U. 6
8
10
12
10
14
12
14
16
18
20
w e e ks
weeks
Figure 3. Com.pressive strength of MBCP implanted into bone ( ) and muscle ( } as a fijnction of implantation duration. CT (MPa )
BoRc .site Muscle site
Figure 4. Young m.odulus of MBCP imiplanted into bone ( ) and muscle ( ) as a function of implantation duration. E (MPa) i: - 1125.3042 - 98.9118M + 34.8183C (r-0.83) f-: = 837.2275 - 60.8271K4 + 21.4962C (r=0.82)
* CT = 16.042 - 0.34534M (r=U.57)
Table 1. Results of multiple linear regression (M : Microporosity, C : Ceramic). * Simple linear regression confirming the significance of microporosity (p<0.05).
82
Bioceramics Volume10
CONCLUSION The physico-chemical, histological and stmctural modifications result of bioactivity and osteoconduction processes. This study formed bone which not only filled macropores but also gave implant, and the significant role of physico-chemical exchanges biological apatites in ceramic microporosity.
of im.planted MBCP were the confirmed the effect of newly a composite structure to the leading to the precipitation of
REFERENCES 1. Bemache-Assolant, D. L ’IndustrieCeramkjueet Verriere1993, 883, 421-434 2. De Groot, K. Arm.NY Acad.Sci. 1988, 253, 227-233. 3. Metsger, D.S., Rieger, M.R., Foreman, D.W. Fourth WorldBiomaterialsCougres 1992, April 24-28, Berlin, Federal Republic of Germany. 4. Rao, R.W., Boehm, R.F. J. Dent.Res 1974, 53, 1351 -1354 5. Daculsi, G., Passuti, N. Biomat. 1990, 11, 86-87. 6. Martin, R.B., Chapman, M.W., Holmes, R.E., Sartoris, D J., Shors, E C , Gordon, J.E., Heitter, DO^ Sharkey, N.A., Zissimos, AG. Biomat.1989, 10, 481-488. 7. Martin, R.B., Chapman, M.W., Sharkey, N.A., Zissimos, S.I., Bay, B., Shors, E C Biomat. 1993, 14,341-348. 8. Trecant, M., Delecrin, J., Royer, J., Daculsi, G., Clin.Mat. 1994, 15, 233-240. 9 Trecant, M., Delecrin, J., Nguyen, J.M., Royer, J., Passuti, N., Daculsi, G. /. Mater. Sci. : Mater. In Med. 1996,^ 7, 227-229. 10. Daculsi, G., LeGeros, R.Z., Ner>’, E., Lynch, K., Kerebel, B. J. Biomed.Mater. Res. 1989,23,883-894. 11. Daculsi, G., Passuti, N., Martin, S.,. Le Nihouannen, J.C, Brulliard, V., Delecrin, J., Kerebel, B. Rev. Chir. Orthop.1989, 75, 65-71. 12. Daculsi, G., Passuti, N., Martin, S., Deudon, C , LeGeros, R.Z., Raher, S. J. Z?/o/wet/. Mater Res. 1990, 24, 379-396. 13. Daculsi, G., LeGeros, R.Z., Heughebaert, M., Barbieux, 1. Ca/c// Tissue Int. 1990,46, 20-27. 14. Daculsi, G., LeGeros, R.Z., Deudon, C Scanning Microscopy. 1990, 4(2), 309-314. 15. Hardouin, P., Choppin, D., Devyver, B., Flautre, B., Blary, M.C., Guigui, P., Anselme, K. J. Mater Sci. : Mater In Med. 1992, 3, 212-218 16. Heughebaert, M., LeGeros, R.Z., Gineste, M., Guilhem, A. J. Biomed.Mater Res. 1988,22,257-268. 17 LeGeros, R.Z., Parsons, R., Daculsi, G., Driessens, F., Lee, D., Metsger, S. In: Bioceramics: Material characterizationvs. in vivo behavior, 1988, Ducheyne, P . ; Lemons, J. (eds.). New York Acad. Sci. 253, 268-271. Moore, D C , Chapman, M.W., Manske, D J. Orthop Res. 1987, 5, 356-365. 19 Passuti, N., Daculsi, G., Rogez, J.M., Martin, S., Bsamtl J.V. Clin. Orthop. andRel. Res. 1989,248, 169-176. 20 Trecant, M. Ph.D. Thesis, Nantes University, France, 1996. 21 Katz, J.L., Yoon, H.S., Lipson, S., Maharidge, R., Meunier, A., Christel, P. Calcif. TissueInt. 1984, 36, S31-S36. 22 Martin, B. Calcif. Tissue Int. 1993, 53, S34-S40. Martin, R.B., Ishida, J../ Biomech.1989, 22, 419-426
Bioceramics, Volume 10 Edited by L. Sedel and C. Rey (Proceedings of the 10th InternationalSymposium on Ceramics in Medicine, Paris, France, October 1997) '1997 Elsevier Science Ltd
DIFFERENC E OF BONDIN G BEHAVIO R BETWEE N FOUR DIFFEREN T KIND S OF HYDROXYAPATIT E PLAT E AND BONE . S.S. Chung\ C. K. Lee^ K. S. Hong^ H. J. Yoon^ 1. Department of Orthopaedic Surgery, Samsung Medical Center. 50 ILWON-dong, Kangnam- Ku, Seoul, 135-710, Korea. 2. Department of Orthopaedic Surgery, Seoul National University Hospital. 3. School of Materials Science and Engineering, Seoul National University. ABSTRAC T The interface between four different kinds of hydroxyapatite(HAp: HA 1, HA 5, HA 6, and HA 9) and bone and the surface of the HAps were examined. The HAps were made with different starting Ca/P ratios (1.5, 1.67, and 1.83) and different maturation temperatures (30 and 90 C). Sintered HAp plates were implanted in rabbits’ tibiae, femora, and muscles of thigh. The XRD analysis, light microscopy, scanning electron microscopy, and Instron were used to examine the formation of hydroxy apatite, new bone formation, bonding behavior and tensile strength. Tensile strength was greatest between HA 9(Ca/P 1.67, 30 C) and bone, though not statistically significant. We also observed more significant new bone formation on the surface of HA 9 using light microscopy. Scanning electron microscopic examination showed partial resorption of the surface of HAp plates and mechanical as well as direct bonding between HAps and bones. [KEYWORDS : Hydroxy apatite, rabbit, tensile strength, bonding behavior] INTRODUCTIO N The autogenous bone graft has many advantages, but there are many complications and problems in harvesting autogenous bone from iliac crest [1]. The allograft as well as heterograft have many problems to be used routinely as graft material [2,3]. Hydroxyapatite has been widely studied and used in clinical field as a bone graft substitute [4,5]. There are many reports comparing biologic responses using different kinds of ceramics, such as hydroxyapatite, tricalcium phosphate, calcite, bioactive glasses, etc. [5,6]. It was our investigation that different kinds of hydroxyapatite as well as different kinds of ceramics could show different biologic responses. Four different kinds of hydroxy apatites have been made and examined for their biologic responses. MATERIAL S AND METHOD S Four kinds of hydroxyapatite powder were selected among 9 kinds of powder and compacted into plate shapes, which were then sintered at a temperature of 1300 C. The HAps were named as HA 1, HA 5, HA 6, and HA 9 and their synthetic conditions were Ca/P 1.5 (maturation temperature of 90 C), Ca/P 1.5 (30 C), Ca/P 1.83 (30 C) and Ca/P 1.67 (30 C), respectively. Eighty-four white rabbits around 3.5Kg were divided into 4 groups according to HAps used. HAp plates were inserted into proximal tibiae of all rabbits(n==21/group) through a slit of medial and lateral cortex (Fig. 1 a), into distal femora 83
84
Bioceramics Volume10
(a) (b) Figure 1. Photos of rabbit’s tibia implanted with hydroxyapatite plate across the proximal tibial metaphysis (a) and prepared for biomechanical test (b). (n=6/group) through a slit of lateral cortex and into lateral thigh muscle (n=6/group). Seven rabbits of each group were sacrificed at 2, 4, and 8 weeks and tibiae, femora and HAps in the thigh muscles were harvested. The tibiae were wrapped with saline gauze and deeply freezed at a temperature of-70 C. One femur each sacrificed was immersed in 2.5% glutaraldehyde and the other femur of each sacrificed was preserved in formalin. HAps in the muscle was deeply freezed. After harvesting all specimens, tibiae were thawed for about 4 hours at room temperature, and then segments of proximal tibial metaphyses containing HAp plate were excised and prepared for the biomechanical test to measure the tensile strength between HAp and bone(Fig. 1 b). Traction was applied vertically to the interface between the HAp plate and the bone at a crosshead speed of 5mm/min using an Instron (Instron 8500, Instron corporation, USA). Thin segment (200 \\.mthickness) of distal femur containing HAp plate was obtained using diamond saw for the scanning electron microscopic (SEM, S2460N, Hitachi, Japan) examination to examine the interface between HAp and bone. Another thin segment of distal femur was obtained after decalcification for light microscopic observation. The surface of the HAp plates was examined with scanning electron microscopy before and after embedding of the HAp into thigh muscle. RESULT S AND DISCUSSIO N Table 1 shows average failure load between hydroxyapatite plates and rabbits’ tibiae. At two weeks after insertion of the HAp plates into rabbits’ tibiae and femora, bone and HAp did not bond together. Table 1. Failure load between hydroxyapatite plates and rabbits’ tibiae measured by Instron. HA 9 HA type HA l HA 6 HA S (1.83, 30 C) (Ca/P, temp.) (1.67, 30 C) (1.5,90 C) (1.5, 30 C) PO 2 weeks non-bonding (7) non-bonding (7) non-bonding (7) non-bonding (7) PO 4 weeks 2.54–1.48(7) 2.08 –1.04 (7) 2.25 –1.36 (7) 3.94–1.23 (7) PO 8 weeks 2.50–1.22(7) 2.12 –1.49 (7) 2.34–1.09(7) 4.01 –0.75 (7) HA : Hydroxyapatite, PO : postoperative Ca/P, temp. : Starting Ca/P ratio, maturation temperature Data : Average failure load – standard deviation (n=number of rabbits)
Bonding Behavior BetweenFour DifferentKinds of HA Plate and Bone: S. S. Chung et al.
85
(a) (b) Figure 2. Light microscopic findings 8 weeks after insertion of HA 5 (a) and HA 9 (b). Hydroxyapatite cannot be seen because of decalcification. Black dusts on (a) are remnant of hydroxy apatite. There is more prominent new bone formation on HA 9 than on HA 5. (H&E staining, x 100) At four and eight weeks, the average tensile strength was greatest between HA 9 and bone, though there was no statistically significant difference regarding the types of HAp and postoperative periods. This finding well corresponded to morphological observation using light microscopy and scanning electron microscopy. New bone formation on the HAp plates was observed on light microscopic examination and the new bone formation was more evident on HA 9 (Fig. 2 a-b). On scanning electron microscopic examination, there was very prominent new bone formation on HA 9. Irregular resorption of the surface of HAp plate and bone ingrowth into the irregularity were also more prominent on HA 9 than on other HAps (Fig. 3 a-d).
(c) (d) Figure 3. Scanning electron microscopic findings of the interface between hydroxyapatite plates and bone at 8 weeks after insertion. (x40) (a) HA 1, (b) HA 5, (c) HA 6, (d) HA 9.
Bioceramics Volume10 Di-y Pow^d-er
1300*^0, S i n t e r i n g C a / P=
1 &
.83. SO^C A
^
^ A. .
67, 30 C
c a y p=
il
jiyix^_
j^
./ C a / P= 1 5, 90 C
/
C a / P= 1.5. 30 C ’N
^-^ ; i/
^
A_^_^
._,_^-~^
(a) (b) Figure 4. XRD patterns of hydroxyapatite powder made for this study (a) reveal single phase of the powder and partial decomposition at high temperature (1300 C) to tricalcium phosphate (b). After 8 weeks in the muscle, the surface of the ceramic became granular because of partial resorption of the surface. XRD examination shows partial decomposition of HAp into tricalcium phosphate at high temperature(1300 C) and the amount of decomposition was different according to the synthetic conditions of the powder(Fig. 4 a - b). The partial resorption might reflect the partial decomposition of the HAps at high temperature, because the tricalcium phosphate was known to be subject to partial bioresorption in the biological environment [7]. This resorption resulted granular surface and this seemed to help mechanical interlocking between HAps and bone. Hydroxyapatites showed different biological responses according to the synthetic conditions. Hydroxyapatite made with Ca/P ratio 1.67 and maturation temperature 30 C showed most favorable responses in the rabbits’ tibiae and femora. Further investigation will be performed to produce porous hydroxyapatite using this biocompatible synthetic condition to fmd pore size and configuration, which can show more favorable biological responses. ACKNOWLEDGMENT The present work was supported by the grant of the ministry of Health and Welfare of Republic of Korea.
REFERENCES
1. Arrington E.D., Smith W.J., Chambers H.G., Bucknell A.L. and Davino N.A. Clin. Orthop. 1996,329,300-309. 2. Bolano L. and Kopta J.A. Orthopedics.1991, 14, 987-996. 3. Buck B.E., Malinin T.I. and Brown M.D. Clin. Orthop.1989, 240, 129-136. 4. Emery S.E., Fuller D.A., Bensusan J.S. and Stevenson S. Transactionsof the 40th annual meeting,OrthopaedicResearchSociety,1994, New Orleans, Louisiana. 156-27. 5. Jarcho M. Clin. Orthop.1981, 157, 259 - 78. 6. Neo M., Kotani S., Fujita Y., Nakamura T. and Yamamuro T. / Biomed.Mater.Res. 1992, 26, 255-267. 7. Renooij W., Hoogendoom A., Visser W.J., Lentferink R.H.F., Schmitz M.G.J., van leperen H., Oldenburg S.J., Janssen W.M., Akkermans L.M.A. and Wittebol P. Clin. Orthop.1985,197,272-285.
Bioceramics, Volume 10 Edited by L. Sedel and C. Rey (Proceedings of the 10th InternationalSymposium on Ceramics in Medicine, Paris, France, October 1997) '1997 Elsevier Science Ltd
TREATMEN T OF OSTEOMYELITI GLAS S CERAMI C BLOC K
S BY ANTIBIOTIC-SOAKE
D POROU S A-W
K. Kawanabe, Y. Okada, H. lida, and T. Nakamura Department of Orthopedic Surgeiy, Faculty of Medicine, Kyoto University, 54 Shogoin-Kawaharacho, Sakyo-ku, Kyoto 606, Japan. ABSTRAC T A new dnig delivery system was developedforosteomyelitis using apatite-wollastonite containing glass ceramic (A-W GC) that had been soaked with antibiotics under high vacuum. An 8-mm^ porous A-W GC block (porosity; 70% and 20-30%) and hydroxyapatite (HA) block (porosity; 35-48%) were placed in a bone cement mixer, and mixed with an antibiotic solution. The slow release activity of two antibiotics, isepamicin sulfite and cefinetazole sodium,fromthe porous blocks was tested. An evaluation was made of the slow-release capabilities of the isepamicin sulfitefromthe porous A-W GC block (porosity; 70%) which was maintained at more than 0.5 ^ig/ml after 28 days. However, that from the porous HA block was less than 0.5 ng /ml after 14 days. In a clinical study, two patients with osteomyelitis, including one with infected hip arthroplasty and osteomyelitis of the tibia, were treated and thefecihad completely healed by the end of the follow-up period. INTRODUCTIO N Chronic osteomyelitis is difficult to treat due to the characteristics ofbone, and the object of treatment is to maintain the bactericidal concentration of antibiotic at the infection focus long enough for the healing process to begin. Various antibiotic carrier systems have been developed, including one in which bone cement is mixed with antibiotic-impregnated polymethylmethacrylate (PMMA) beads [1.2] . However, the problem with the use of PMMA beads inserted locally is that subsequent surgery is required for replacement with an autograft. Recently, dmg delivery systems (DDSs) using resorbable materials, collagen [3] , fibrinogen [4] and polylactic acid [5] have been developed. Although it is not necessary to remove them, they cannot be used tofillthe infection site with new bone without bone grafting. We have developed a new DDS using antibiotic-soaked porous A-W GC block, which was demonstrated previously to forma chemical bond with living bone and to have a mechanical strength nearly equal to that of cancellous bone [6] . MATERIAL S AND METHOD S In vitrostudy Two types of porous apatite-wollastonite containing glass ceramic (A-W GC: Nippon Electric Glass Co., Ltd, Otsu, J^an) werefibricatedin 8-mm^ blocks of porosity is 70% (A-W GC 70) and 2030% (A-W GC 20-30), with pore sizes of 200 ^m and 10-50 ^m, respectively. A porous hydroxy^atite (HA) block of the same size, porosity 3548%, pore size 50-300 [im (Bioceram: Sumitomo Pharmaceutical Co.. Ltd, Tokyo, J^an) was used as a control (Fig.l). Two kinds of antibiotic, isepamicin sulfate (ISP: C22H43N5O12 x H2SO4, (X ^2), MW: 569.61) andcefmetazole 87
Bioceramics Volume10
^iia.-a
liiiiiili^f c
1 ^^is^^W-^m^’W^MmMmB^, (a) (b) Figure 1. SEM appearance of (a) surface of A-W GC ( porosity 70%) and (b) HA (porosity 35-48%) (CMZ: Ci5Hi6N705S3Na, MW: 493.51) were used. An experimental study of DDS with antibiotic-soaked porous blocks was carried out follows. The three kinds of porous ceramic block were placed in a bone cement mixer (Mixevac 11 High Vacuum System, Stiyker, MI, USA) and mixed with solutions of the two antibiotics, ISP and CMZ (100 mg/ml), and vacuumed at about 500 mmHg for 10 min to allow the antibiotics to soak into the pores. The antibiotic absorption rates of A-W GC 70, A-W GC 20-30 and HA determined by this method were 76.1%, 21.8% and 25.3%/ 8 mm^ volume, respectively. To estimate the concentration of slow-release antibiotic, the blocks were stored in PBS (3 ml) at 37 C. andthePBS was replaced every two days. Preserved PBS containing the released antibiotic was stored at -20t;. An in vitro elution study was then performed using antibiotic assay by high-perfonnance liquid chiomatogi^hy (HPLC), Clinical case Two patients were treated using this method. A 35.year-old man was operated on for osteomyelitis of the right proximal tibia Abscessformationwas observ^ed in the sameregionnine years after the primary operation, and Salmonella was cultured from this specimen. Afier undergoing curettage, appropriate A-W GC blocks were placed in a cement vacuum mixer and soaked with the antibiotics CMZ and ISP. The A-W GC blocks were trimmed and inserted into the osteomyelitis focus. The other patient was a 55-year-old hemophilia man, who was sufieringfix)minfeaed arthroplasty. He underwent revision surgery using antibiotic-soaked A-W GC blocks. The follow-up terms were lyr 6mo and lyr, respectively. RESULT S An evaluation was made of the slow-release capabilities of ISP, and the level was maintained at at least 0.5 ng/ml after 28 days in both A-W GC 70 and 20-30 blocks. However, the level from the porous HA block was less than 0.5 ^ig/ml after 28 days. In the case of CMZ, the three kinds of porous block showed a level of less thanO.5 [ig/ml even after 14 days (Fig. 2). The mean release ratio (antibiotic released in PBS / antibiotic soaked in block) of A-W GC 70, A-W GC 20-30 and HA were 91%, 100% and 100% for ISP, and 48.7%, 37.9% and 42.3% for CMZ, respectively.
Treatmentof Osteomyelitisby Antibiotic Soaked Porous A-W Glass Ceramic: K. Kawanabe et al. CMZ(ug/mi)
ISP(ug/ml) 1 0 0 0 0 0 (] D A-W GC (70% )
D A-W GC (70% ) @ A-W GC (20-30% )
0 A-W GC (20-30% )
HA
2 d 4 d 6 c l 8 d
14 d
18 d
HA
0,1
L
2d 4 d 6 d 8d
14 d
(a) (b) Figure 2. A gr^h showing therateofreleaseof ISP (a) and CMZ (b)fromA-W GC 70, A-W GC 20-30 and HA. hi the dinical cases, both the feci had healed at the end of the follow-up period without complications. The border between the A-W GC blocks and bone became unclear lyr 6mo afer surgery in the case of osteomyelitis in the right proximal tibia (Fig. 3).
(a) (b) Figure 3. A 3 5-year-old-man, osteomyehtis of the right proximal tibia was recurred after nine years afier primaiy operation, (a) Radiogr^hs made one week after second operation. After curettage the infection focus, porous A-W GC blocks were soaked with CMZ and ISP, and implanted, (b) Radiograph made lyr 6mo after second operation. The border between the porous A-W GC and bone became unclear compared with one week.
90
Bioceramics Volume10
DISCUSSIO N Antibiotic-loaded acrylic bone cement beads has been studied in detail and used clinically. However, it must be removed by a further operation, and its long-term implantation is difficult. Some authors have reported that PMM A bone cement has a disadvantage of thermal damage to the antibiotic [1.2] Recently, biodegradable materials have been developed as DDSs for antibiotics. However, these materials can not fill the dead space and may be afocusforrecurrent infection over a long period. Bioactive ceramic is an ideal DDS fiom this view point. Although HA was used as a DDS for antibiotics in a several reports [7.8] , A-W GC has been demonstrated to have higher mechanical strength and bioactivity than HA, and A-W GC 70 absorbed andreleasedmore antibiotic than the porous HA block during a one month period in this study. The high-vacuum system using a cement mixer was efective for soaking the antibiotics into the ceramic pores REFERENCE S 1. Whaling, H., Dingelden, E., Bergmann, R., Reuss, K. The release of gentamicine fix)m polymethylmethacrylate beads. J. Bone Joint Surg., 1975. 60-B. 270-275. 2. Baker, AS., Greenham, L.W., Release ofgentamicinfix)macrylic bone cement. J. Bone Joint Surg., 1988. 70-A.1551-1557. 3. Ascherl, R., Stemberger, A., Lechner, F. Behandelung der chronischen osteomyelitis mit einem koUagen-antibiotika-verbund-vorlaufrge mitteilung. Umfall Chirurg., 1986. 12. 125-127. 4. Zilch, H., Lambiris, E. The sustained release ofcefotaxin fiom afibrin-cefotaxincompound in treatment of osteitis. Arch Orthop Trauma Surg. 1986. 106. 36-41. 5. Wei, G., Kotoura, Y., Oka, M., Yamamuro, T., Wada, R., Hyon, S.H., Ikada, Y., A bioabsorbable deliveriy systemforantibiotic treatment of osteomyelitis. J Bone Joint Surg., 1991. 73-B. 246-252. 6. Nakamura, T., Yamamuro, T., Higashi, S., Kokubo, T., Itoo, S. A new glass-ceramicforbone replacement: Evaluation of its bonding to bone tissue. J Biomed Mater Res., 1985. 19. 71-84. 7. Shinto, Y., Uchida, A.,Korkusuz, F., Araki, N., Ono,K. Calcium hydroxyapatite ceramicused as a delivery system for antibiotics. J Bone Joint Surg., 1992. 74-B. 600-604. 8. Itokazu, M., Matsunaga, T., Kumazawa, S., Oka, M. Treatment of osteomyelitis by antibiotic impregnated porous hydroxyapatite block. Clin. Mater., 1994. 17. 173-179.
Bioceramics, Volume 10 Edited by L. Sedel and C. Rey (Proceedings of the 10th InternationalSymposium on Ceramics in Medicine, Paris, France, October 1997) '1997 Elsevier Science Ltd
CALCIU M HYDROXYAPATIT E CERAMI C IMPLANT S IMPREGNATE D WIT H ANTIBIOTI C FOR THE TREATMEN T OF CHRONI C OSTEOMYELITI S YasuoYamashita,Toru Yamakawa ,Kou Kato Yoshitaka Shinto*, Nobuhito Araki*, Atsumasa Uchida Department of Orthopaedic Surgery, Mie University Faculty of Medicine,Ed)basi 2-174, Tsu-shi, Mie-ken 514, Japan *Department of Orthopaedic Surgery, Osaka University Medical School, Yamada-oka, suita-shi 2-2, Osaka-Fu, 565, Japan. ABSTRAC T Twenty patients with chronic osteomyelitis were treated by implanting calcium hydroxyapatite ceramic with antibiotic into a cavity produced after through surgical excision of necrotic tissue. Within 3 months all of the infected sites had healed. During the period of follow-up ranging from 3 to 75 months we have never experienced a recurrence of infection. There were 3 of those patients had infected prostheses and were successfully revised One patients underwent one stage revision surgery, and another two patients underwent two stage operation. Not only was infection controlled, but there was incorporation of the ceramic material into host bone as judged by radiography. We recommend the use of porous pieces of calcium hydroxyapatite impregnated with antibiotic as a new drug delivery system for the treatment of chronic osteomyelitis. KE Y W O R D S Antibiotics, Hydoroxyapatite, Drug delivery system. Osteomyelitis INTRODUCTIO N Chronic osteomyelitis is known to have difficult surgical problem, particularly in the developing world, despite advances in surgery and more than fifty years experience with antibiotic therapy. Two principles of treatment are paramount: necrotic tissue which has a blood supply unnable to promote normal healing process must be removed, and appropriate antibiotic drugs must be administered [1]. Porous calcium hydroxyapatite (CHA) which is similar to bone mineral composition has excellent biocompatibility, can resist mechanical forces, and is effective in filling cavities and defects in bone [2]. We have already reported porous CHA is very effective as a slow release system for antibiotics in an animal model. [3,4] We have now used porous CHA impregnated with antibiotic clinically and report our experiences, and we believe that this new system is simple, can be performed safely in some few stage, and offers satisfactory results. MATERIAL S AN D METHOD S We treated 11 men and 9 women with chronic osteomyelitis using the principles of surgical debridement, local implantation of CHA impregnated with antibiotic, and systemic 91
92
Bioceramics Volume10
antibiotic administration. The mean age of the patients at the time of treatment was 39.1 years (range: 14 to 77 ). The duration of disease was judged to be from 12 to 132 months (mean: 33 months). At the time of initial presentation all patients had clinical and^or radiological evidence of chronic osteomyelitis. The chronic infection occurred after acute hematogenous osteomyelitis in 12 patients, following open fracture in 3, after closed fracture in 1, and after joint replacement in 3. Nine patients had one or more draining sinuses. Each site of infection was initially aspirated in order to detect a causative organism. The pathogens cultivated were Staphylococcus aureus in 8 cases, Staphylococcus epidermidis in 3, Pseudomonas aeruginosa in two, and Streptococcus pyogenes. Streptococcus pneumoniae, and Klebsiella pneumoniae in each one. The choice of antibiotic for impregnation into the CHA ceramic material was determined by the sensitivity of the cultured organism to drugs. In the 4 patients in whom no organisms were grown broad spectrum antibiotics were selected. We assessed healing by the clinical picture, laboratory findings, and radiological evidence of incorporation of the CHA implant and remodeling of surrounding bone. The duration of follow-up was from 3 to 75 months (average: 47.9 months). Preparation of CH A ceramic impregnated with antibiotic. CHA ceramic blocks were sintered at 1200 C for two hours and had a porosity of 30% to 40% with diameter of the micropores between 40 and 150 micrometers. There was an interconnecting pore structure open to the external surface of the blocks. Operative procedures. The bone cortex was fenestrated to a size permitting removal of all necrotic bone, sequestra, and pathological granulation tissue. During the necrectomy, the chosen antibiotic was packed into a central cylindrical cavity in each porous block and the cavity then sealed with a CHA plug. (Figure 1) The volume of antibiotics packed into the cavity depended on the size of the cavity within the different blocks. The usual range of antibiotic dose in each ceramic block was between 100 and 400 mg. The antibiotics were used, either alone, or in combination. The excavated defect in the bone was then packed with the CHA ceramic pieces which had been each impregnated with the chosen antibiotic. Various sizes and number of ceramic block were used so that the excavated bone defect could be completely filled.
Figure 1 Illustration of CHA impregnated with antibiotics.
Figure 2 Case 1 Chronic osteomyelitis of the proximal region of the tibia.
Calcium Hydroxyapatite Ceramic Implants Impregnated With Antibiotic: Y. Yamashitaet al.
93
CASE R E P O R T S Case 1 An 18-year old man had complained of dull pain in the proximal leg and around the knee. The radiographs showed a sclerotic thickening of the cortex in the proximal tibia. The lesion was opened, anddebrided, and then packed with number of CHA ceramic blocks which had been impregnated with fosfomycin sodium anddbekacin sulfate, ( as no causative organism was cultured ).Four months after the operation, the lesion had been completely healed (Figure 2). Case 2 A 40-year old man with osteosarcoma of the distal femur had infection after wide resection with reconstruction by a tumor knee prothesis. The prosthesis was removed and pathological granulation tissues were debrided and the antibiotic-impregnated CHA blocks were placed in dead space. After 3 months the revision surgery with another tumor knee prosthesis was performed The patients had no recurrence of infection and maintain excellent function after 3 years (Figure 3). Case 3 A 67-year old woman had infection of a knee prosthesis inserted for the treatment of osteoarthritis. She was treated firstly with antibiotic-impregnated Polymethylmetacrylate (PMMA) beads. She had persistent pain and swelling of the knee. A biopsy indicated that Staphylococcus epidermidis was the pathogenic organism. The prosthesis was removed and all necrotic tissue were carefully debrided The antibiotic-impregnated CHA ceramic blocks and another prosthesis was inserted in one stage. Twelve weeks after the revision surgery there had been no recurrence of infection (Figure 4).
Figure 3 Case 2 Chronic osteomyelitis of the mega prosthesis for osteosarcoma in the treatment of distal femur.
Figure 4 Case3 Inplantation of CFIA drug delivery system for the infectedTKA.
94
Bioceramics Volume10
RESULTS At the latest follow-up examination for each of the 20 patients all foci were completely healed Fifteen had pain relief and improvement of laboratory abnormalities within 4 weeks after surgery. In the rest there was resolution of infection within 12 weeks. Recurrence of infection has never occurred after this treatment for follow-up period Radiolucent zones around the ceramic implant gradually disappeared over six months, and in some cases homogenous intramedullary radiodensity surrounded the CHA blocks. There was no radiological evidence of degradation of the ceramic, but in those patients in whom we performed ’second look’ surgery after healing there was some histological evidence of ceramic degradation. DISCUSSIO N It is essential to maintain a high concentration of an appropriate drug at the affected sites for a sufficiently long time, in order to obtain complete eradication of infection of bone and soft tissues. Because of the altered structure of the tissues surrounding an infected site the diffusion of antibiotic drugs into the central part of the infection may require high serum concentration of the drugs. This may cause side effects such as myelosuppression, renal failure, and hepatitis. It is possible to increase the local concentration of antibiotics by impregnating them into carrier vehicles which are implanted into the infected site. PMMA used generally as a bone cement has been the most widely evaluated[5,6,7]. The disadvantages include reduced biocompatibility with bone, short duration of antibiotic release, very low release rate, thermal damage to the antibiotic, and the requirement to remove the PMMA at the end of therapy. Nevertheless this method has been widely used for the surgical treatment of chronic osteomyelitis. Drug delivery system with porous hydroxyapatite ceramic may be effective to apply an appropriate drug for various di sease such as pyogenic osteomyelis, tuberculous osteomyelitis. We are of the opinion that antibiotic-impregnated CHA ceramic is superior to acrylic bone cement systems. Many antibiotic can be placed in a CHA as there is no thermal damage to the drug. All of the impregnated antibiotic can be released over a long period and none is trapped in the ceramic. Biomechanical properties of CHA is similar to those of bone, and the composite of ceramic with newly-formed ingrowth of bone into the pore is almost same as the original bone. As a consequence the antibiotic-CHA ceramic composites both control the infection, restore mechanical strength, encourage osteoconduction into their pores, and avoid the need for further surgery. From these findings, we believe that this new system is simple, can be performed safely in one stage, and offers satisfactory results.
REFERENCES
1. Norden,C.W., Gillespie,W. J. and Nade,S. Infectionin Bones andJoints Boston,Blackwell, 1994, 3-418. 2. Uchida,A., Araki,N., Shinto,Y., Yoshikavva,H., Ono,K. and Kurisaki,E., J .BoneJoint Surg [Br] 1990, 72-B, 298-302. 3. Shinto,Y., Uchida,A., KorukusuzJF., Araki,N. andOno,K., y^on^/om/^wrg 1992, 74-B, 600-604. 4. KorukusuzJF., Uchida,A., Inoue,K., Shinto,Y., Araki,N. andOno,K. J Bone Joint Surg [Br] 1993, 75-B,111-114. 5. Buchholz,H.W., Elson,R.A., andHeinert,K. Clin Orthop1984, 190,96-108. 6. Bayston,R., and Milner,R.D. J Bone Joint Surg [Br] 1982; 64-B, 460-464. 7. Boda,R. Arc/i OrthopTraumaSurg 1982, 101:39-45.
BONE CELLS ONTO BIOACTIVE CERAMICS
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
Bioceramics, Volume 10 Edited by L. Sedel and C. Rey (Proceedings of the 10th InternationalSymposium on Ceramics in Medicine, Paris, France, October 1997) '1997 Elsevier Science Ltd
MEASUREMEN T OF INTAC T OSTEOCALCI N CONTENT S IN THE COMPOSIT E OF POROU S HYDROXUAPATIT E CERAMI C AND ALLOGENEI C MARRO W CELL S M. Akahane, H. Ohgushi, T. Yoshikawa, S. Tamai, Y. Dohi,* K. Hosoda** and T. Ohta** Department of Orthopedics, and Public health*, Nara Medical University, Kashihara city, Nara 634, Japan ; Teijin Institute for Bio-Medical Reserch**, Teijin Ltd., Hino city, Tokyo 191, Japan
ABSTRAC T Osteocalcin is synthesized particularly by osteoblast as an extracellular matrix protein. We measured intact osteocalcin contents in allogeneic rat marrow cells/hydroxyapatite (HA) composites implanted at rat subcutaneous sites. At 4 weeks after implantation, bone formation was not detected and only a trace of the osteocalcin was detected in the composite. However, under the immunosupression with FK506, bone formation together with abundant osteocalcin was detected in the composite, and the osteocalcin content was comparable to that of isogenic marrow/HA composites. These results indicate that under the immunosupression, allogeneic bone marrow cells can differentiate into active osteoblasts of which activity is comparable to that of isogenic marrow cells. KEYWORD S Osteocalcin, Hydroxy apatite.
Allogeneic bone marrow
INTRODUCTIO N We have reported that subcutaneous implantation of HA ceramics combined with marrow cells show new bone formation [1]. Osteocalcin (bone Gla protein) is a major noncoUageneous protein in bone matrix and exclusively synthesized by osteoblast. Biochemical analysis of the marrow/HA composites showed that the osteocalcin begun to appear at about 3 weeks when the obvious bone formation initiated, then the osteocalcin contents and bone area increased as time passed [2]. Therefore, the osteocalcin is a useftil biochemical parameter to identify bone tissue. For measuring the osteocalcin, the harvested composites were immediately crushed, homogenized and then measured by using radioimmunoassay (RIA). For some cases, the ceramics were frozen until the assay of osteocalcin [2,3]. Recently, we reported that not only isogenic cells but allogeneic [4,5] cells show bone formation under immunosuppression with FK506. We also established the method of measuring intact rat osteocalcin using anti N- and anti C-terminal rat osteocalcin antibodies raised against a Nterminal 20 residues peptide and a C-temiinal 10 residues peptide of rat osteocalcin [6]. In 97
98
Bioceramics Volume10
this experiment, we measured intact osteocalcin in the cryopreserved composite which was combined with either allogeneic or isogenic marrow cells, and focused on the effect of freezing and immunologic barrier. MATERIAL S AND METHOD S Marrow cellpreparationand Implantationof ceramic Male 6-week-old ACI and 7-week-old Fischer 344 rats were used for donor. Syngeneic 7week-old Fischer rats were used for recipient. The magnitude of the immunological mismatch between ACI and Fischer rat is major. Marrow cell suspensions (5 x 10 ^ nucleated cells/ml) from ACI and Fischer rats were prepared as reported previously [4]. Disk shaped (5mm diameter, 2mm thickness) HA ceramics (Interpore 200, Interpore International, Irvine, Cahfomia) were immersed in each cell suspension from ACI or Fischer rats, then implanted on the back of a recipient Fischer rat. AdministrationofFK506 and Harvest of ceramic FK506 (Fujisawa Pharmaceutical Co., Ltd., Osaka, Japan) was suspended in saline and administered intramuscularly to the recipient rats (Img/Kg/day). As a control, saline was administered. All rats received FK506 or saline every day for 2 weeks and every second days for additional 2 weeks. The ceramics were harvested at 4 weeks after the implantation and stored at -80 C for about 1 month.
Peroxidase | anti N-20 Ab ^^/^N^
N terminal
I
20 peptide s
10 peptide s
1
3
C terminal
^N"" ^
anti C-10 Ab
Figure 1. Schema of the intact osteocalcin measurement by sandwich immunoassay.
IntactOsteocalcinContentsin theCompositeof HA and AllogeneicMarrow Cells: M. Akahaneet al. 99 Measurement of intact osteocalcin
The frozen ceramics were crushed, homogenized in 0.2 % Nonidet P40 containing 1 mM MgCl2 and centrifuged. Osteocalcin was extracted from the sediment by shaking in 2 ml of 20 % fonnic acid for 2 weeks at 4 C. An aliquot (500 \i\) of the fonnic acid extract was then applied to a colunm of Sephadex G-25 and eluted with 10 % fonnic acid. Protein fractions were collected, lyophilized and used for measurement of intact osteocalcin. The principle of the measurement is based on the sandwich iminunoassay which recognizes both N and C tenninal peptides of osteocalcin molecule (Fig. 1). A peroxidase conjugated with a rabbit F (ab’)2 fragment of the anti-N-tenninal 20 residues peptide antiserum (anti-N-20) was prepared [7], Polystyrene balls were dipped in anti-C-10 IgG in phosphate buffered saline (PBS) and incubated at 4 C overnight. Immobilization was tenninated by rinsing the balls with PBS, followed by coating with 1 % bovine serum albumin-PBS at 4 C for 2 days. Standard solutions of purified rat osteocalcin were prepared at concentrations of 0-5 ng/ml. Two hundreds fil of standard solution and 200 \A of peroxidase-labeled anti-N-20 IgG solution with the anti-C-10 IgG-fixed balls were placed in glass tubes. After incubation for 1.5 h at 37 C, each ball was washed three times with saline, then 0.4 ml of tetramethylbenzidine and 0.017 % hydrogen peroxide were added to the tube. The mixture was incubated at 37 C for 30 minutes and the enzyme substrate reaction was tenninated by adding 1 ml of IN H2SO4. The enzyme reaction product was measured by the absorbance at 450 nm. RESULT S AND DISCUSSIO N In this experiment, the harvested ceramics (marrow/HA composites) were immediately immersed into liquid nitrogen and stored at -80 C for about 1 month. Then the ceramics were crushed and maintained at 4 C to extract osteocalcin for about 2 weeks in 20% formic acid. As shown in Table 1 (without FK506), mean intact osteocalcin content in the frozen and stored isogenic marrow/HA composite was 0.68 jug/implant. The content was comparable to 0.59(ag/implant in non-frozen composite which was immediately crushed at the time of harvesting and followed by osteocalcin extraction in 20% formic acid. The osteocalcin
Table 1. Bone fonnation and osteocalcin contents (|ig/implant) in marrow/HA composite, (data are mean – SEM).
Allografts^ Isografts ^ Isografts ^ 1) 2)
With FK506 Osteocalcin Bone fonnation contents + 1.017 –0.224 + 0.854 –0.179 "
" - -
-
-
_
_
Without FK506 Bone fonnation Osteocalcin contents 0.036 –0.004 + 0.682 –0.210 + 0.588 –0.165
The data show the intact osteocalcin contents measured by sandwich immunoassay as described in Materials and Methods. The osteocalcin contents in the isografts (isogenic marrow/HA composites) were measured by conventional RIA as described in ref [3]. The composites were crushed immediately after harvesting and followed by osteocalcin extraction in formic acid.
100
Bioceramics Volume10
contents of the non-frozen composites were detennined by conventional radio-immunoassay (RIA). The data indicate that there was few degradation of osteocalcin molecule during the steps of the measurement and therefore the molecule is quite stable under the low temperature of -80 C and 4 C in the presence of forniic acid. Furthennore, the data indicate the reliability of our previous reports of osteocalcin measurement (RIA) in marrow/HA composite. The bone formation occurred in allogeneic m a r r o w / H A c o m p o s i t e under immunosuppression with FK506. However, it was not observed in allogeneic composite without FK506 and only a trace of the osteocalcin was detected in the composite (Table 1). In this experiment, we measured intact osteocalcin molecule, because it is known that degradation of bone tissue accompanies the degradation of osteocalcin molecule. Therefore, measuring the intact form is crucial in identifying nonnal bone tissue. As shown in Table 1, the amount of osteocalcin in the allogeneic marrow/HA composite with FK 506 was comparable to that of the isografts (with and without FK506). The data of this experiment i n d i c a t e that the bone formed in allogeneic m a r r o w / H A c o m p o s i t e s u n d e r immunosuppression with FK506 did not show rapid degradation which might be initiated by the immunological reaction. Therefore, the surface of HA can support natural process of osteoblastic differentiation of allogenic marrow cells under immunosuppression with FK506.
REFERENCES 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. 6. 7.
Ohgushi, H., Goldberg, V. M. and Caplan, A. I J.Ortop.Res.,7:568-578,1989. Yoshikawa, T., Ohgushi, H., Okumura, M., Tamai, S., Dohi, Y. and Moriyama, T. Calcif Tissue Int., 50:184-188,1992. Inoue, K., Ohgushi, H., Yoshikawa, T., Tamai,.S., Dohi, Y., Hosoda, K. and Ohta, T. Bioceramics Volume. 8:99-102,1995. Sempuku, T., Ohgushi, H., Okumura, M. and Tamai, S. J.Orthop.Res.,14:907-913,1996. Sempuku, T., Ohgushi, H., Okumura, M. and Tamai, S. Bioceramics Volume. 8:397401,1995. Ohta, T., Azuma, Y., Kiyoki, M., Eguchi, H., Hosoda, K., Tsukamoto, Y. and Nakamura, T. Calcif Tissue Int., 59:283-290,1996. Fujiwara, K. Yasuno, M, and Kitagawa, T. Cancer Res., 41:4121-4126,1981.
Bioceramies, Volume 10 Edited by L. Sedel and C. Rey (Proeeedings of the 10th InternationalSymposium on Ceramics in Medicine, Paris, France, October 1997) '1997 Elsevier Science Ltd
SI-CA- P XEROGEL S AND BON E MORPHOGENETI C PROTEI N AC T SYNERGISTICALL Y ON RA T STROMA L MARRO W CEL L DIFFERENTIATIO N IN VITRO E. M. Santos^, P. Ducheyne^’^, S. Radin^. B. Shenker^, I. and Shapiro^ Departments of ^Bioengineering, ^Pathology, ^Biochemistry and ^Orthq)aedic Surgery, University of Pennsylvania, Kiiladelphia, PA 19104.
ABSTRAC T The effect of a novel bioactive xerogel glass carrier with and without bone morphogenetic protein (BMP) on the osteogenic activity of rat stromal marrow cells was studied in vitro. Cell differentiation was more pronounced on xerogel glass without BMP than that of cells grown on plastic with BMP. Stromal cell differentiation, as measured by alkaline phosphatase activity and osteocalcin synthesis was most increased when the BMP was incorporated or adsorbed onto the xerogel glass. The data suggest that the xerogel glass concentrates osteoinductive proteins at its surface and potentiates their function. KEYWORDS : bioactivity, growth factor, cell culture, cell differentiation INTRODUCTIO N Fracture non-unions and large bone defects represent major clinical pDblems in the practice of reconstructive orthopaedic surgery. ^ Since current treatments for these conditions, such as autogenous bone grafting, have limitations inherent in their use, new approaches for bone tissue repair are valuable.^’*’ One novel approach is the use of osteoinductive bone growth factors, such as bone mOTphogenetic proteins (BMP).^ Bioactive glass has been shown in numerous studies to bond to bone in ydvo. In our group we have shown that porous bioactive glass can serve as an effective template for the growth of bone like tissue in vitro.^These studies also revealed the importance of pre-treating the glass surface. The treatment led to the formation of a calcium phosphate surface layer with proteins adsorbed and incorporated into it. With this treatment neonatal rat calvaria osteoblasts expressed the markers of the osteoblast phenotype extensively within 4-7 days of culture. In contrast, without the treatment, the osteoblast phenotype was not yet expressed within the same culture duration. Using sol gel synthesis exclusively at room temperature, a glass has been made that releases functional bone growth factors in a sustained manner over a period of several weeks. ^ In this paper we document the effect of this material with and without BMP-2 on the proliferation, differentiation and function of rat stromal marrow cells. 101
102
Bioceramics Volume10
MATERIA L AND METHOD S Synthesis: Xerogel discs with a composition of 70% Si02 - 25% CaO - 5% P2O5 (S70) were synthesized using a room temperature sol-gel procedure. Tetramethylorthosilane, calcium metbov^’^thoxide and triethylphosphate were mixed under an argon atmosphere. After casting, soluuu.. ryith or without BMP in 0.1 N acetic acid mixed with a-MEM containing 15% fetal bovine serum was added to sol samples. Solutions with BMP (recombinant human BMP-2, Genetics Institute, Cambridge MA) contained 25 ^lg of it. Gels were aged and dried to 50% of their original weight. The resulting discs (10 mm in diameter and 4 mm in height) were sterilized by exposure to ultraviolet light. Material pre-treatment to form a calcium phosphate surface laver was conducted before cell culturing by immersion in sterile Dulbecco’s phosphate-buffered saline (GibcoBRL/Life Technologies, Grand Island, NY) for 3 hours. Treamient parameters were selected such that the treatment would not cause a significant loss of incorpwated protein from the sol-gel prior to the cell culture experiments. After the treatment, Fourier transform infrared spectroscopy (FTIR) (Nicolet 5DXC) was performed to establish that P-0 bend peaks were present, thereby revealing the formation of calcium phosphate layer. As a second pre-treatment step, for which we developed the rationale in our lab before"*, S70 discs were immersed in 3 ml of tissue culture medium (TCM) containing a-MEM + 15% fetal bovine serum for 1 hour prior to cell culture. Rat Stromal mam?W ggUs were harvested from 4-5 week female Wistar rats using the methods described by Maniatopoulos et al.^ Isolated cells were plated on tissue culture plates in medium containing a-MEM + 15% FBS with 50 U/ml penicillin, 50 ^g/ml streptomycin, and 10" 8 M dexamethasone in a 37 ""C, 5 % CO2 - 95% air incubator. Non-adherent cells were removed by washing after 24 hours. Thereafter, the medium was supplemented with 50 M^g/ml of ascorbate and exchanged every two days. Once the cells were confluent (after 1 week of primary culture) the adherent cells were detached using 0.25% trypsin in Ca- and Mg- free Hank’s Balanced Salt Solution and resuspended in culture medium. 1 x 10^ stromal cells in a 100 |xl TCM solution were seeded on the surface of S70 discs or tissue culture plates (35 mm in diameter) and allowed to attach for one hour. Medium was then added to the culture dish and incubated for either 6 or 10 days. The medium was exchanged every other day. Control groups included cells cultured in tissue culture dishes without BMP (C) otwith 10 ng BMP added to the initial medium and with every medium exchange (C-BT). Experimental groups included sol-gel discs without BMP (SG), or with BMP added as follows: 25 ^g of BMP incorporated into the S70 discs (SG-BI) , 100 ng of BMP added to TCM during the second pre-treatment step (SG-BP), 10 ng of BMP added to the initial medium as well as with every medium exchange (SG-BT) . Aliquots of the medium were collected before every exchange and before cell harvesting. Cell lysate was obtained by aspirating the TCM from the plates, washing the plates with PBS, and then extracting the sample with 1 ml of 3% Triton X-100 in PBS. Cell extracts were analvzed for total protein content, total DNA content, alkaline phosphatase activity (AP) and osteocalcin production using techniques described elsewhere.^ AP activity and osteocalcin synthesis results were normalized to cell number (DNA content) and surface area available for cell growth. Collagen typing was performed by SDS-polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis (SDS-PAGE) run at 100 mV.
Si-Ca-P Xerogels and BMP on Rat Stromal Marrow Cell DifferentiationIn Vitro: E.M. Santos et al.
103
RESULT S The average DNA content of groups and alkaline phosphatase (AP) activity, normalized by DN A content and surface area available for cell culture, are displayed in Figures 1 a, b.
mc 0 0 ^
m 3 days
10 days
1
SG
SG-BI SG-BP SG-BT C-BT
10 days
Figure 1 a,b. Average DNA content (a) and normalized AP activity (b) of control and experimenta l groups. Samples without BM P containe d considerably more DNA than controls (p<0.001) , indicating that cells in samples without BM P proliferate d extensively . This can be explained by considering that the expmmenta l groups with BM P showed an elevate d normalized AP activity over the correspondin g groups without BMP . With BMP , cells move on their differentiatio n pathway at the expense of proliferatio n in the the undifferentiate d state. Cells on S70 (SG) also showed an increased normalized AP activity when compared with stromal cells on tissue culture plastic (C). Similarly, a higher normalized AP activity was noted when cells were grown on S70 discs plus BM P (SG-BI , SG-B P and SG-BT) , when compared to the group of cells grown on tissue culture plastic with BM P added to the medium (C-BT). SG-B P and SG-B I groups were not statisticall y different (p>0.2) at 10 days, but both SG-B P and SG-B I were significantly higher in normalized AP activity than the groups C, SG and C-BT (p<:0.001) . It is also worth noting that the AP activity of the control group of cells on S70 (SG) was higher at both 6 and 10 days than for stromal cells grown on tissue culture plastic with BM P added to the culture medium (C-BT). In general, samples with BM P had much greater protein content than controls (p<0.001) . The samples cultured on S70 discs with incorporate d BM P (SG-BI ) containe d the greatest amount of protein (data not shown). In geno^, the osteocalci n levels of the groups with BM P were greater than those of the groups without BM P (data not shown). At 10 days, medium from cells cultured on S70 pre-treate d with BM P (SG-BP ) containe d the highest concentratio n of osteocalcin . SDS-PAG E analysis, used to vCTify the synthesis of type I collagen, indicated that the most intense bands were present in SGBI samples, followed by the oth^ samples that receive d BM P treatment . DISCUSSIO N AN D CONCLUSIO N The data shows that the effect of the material substrate on cellular differentiatio n was as important as that of BM P added to the tissue culture medium. The material itself without BM P produced a greater response in AP activity of cells than tissue culture medium to which BM P was
104
Bioceramics Volume10
added. BMP is a powerful stimulator of diff^^ntiation in stromal marrow cells in the presence of the surface-treated sol-gel material. Actually, the effect of BNfP on cell diff^entiation is potentiated as follows from the low amount of DNA, and the high AP activity and osteocalcin production. At shorts time periods (six days) BNfP added to solution combined with the xerogel (SG-BT) had the greatest effect on stimulating cell differentiation, while at the longer time periods (ten days) BMP adsorbed to the surface of the xerogel (SG-BP) ac incorporated within (SG-BI) had the greatest effect on differentiation. In view of the data on the effect of BMP adsorbed or incorporated into the glass on differentiated cell function, our results suggest that the sol-gel material concentrates osteoinductive and growth regulatory proteins, naturally present in serum, at its surface in a biologically active fwm. Furthermore, the results indicate that the calcium phosphate surface layers formed on Si-containing, biologically reactive materials play an important role in stimulating osteoblastic differentiation of stromal marrow cells. BMP added to the materials stimulates extracellular matrix formation as measured by total protein present in culture. The cells exposed to xerogel with incorporated BMP produced substantially more protein (40-50% more) than cells on xerogels with adsorbed BMP (p<0.01) and even more than control cell populations without BMP. These results suggest that BMP is a powerful stimulator of extracellular matrix formation in stromal marrow cells and that a sustained release carrier is the most effective way to stimulate matrix production by cells. In summary, this study together with other studies from our laboratory reveals numerous benefits in using a porous xerogel for delivery of a growth factor. The porosity and chemical structure of the xerogel allow sustained release of the factor over a defined time period. In addition, the surface of the xerogel can be modified to generate a local environment that promotes both cell adhesion and extracellular matrix formation. In this study, we optimized synthesis of the xerogel with respect to effecting cellular activity and controlled release. And, as the data suggest, BMP is taken up and then continuously made available from the Si-Ca-P xerogel. Importantly, the growth factor is biologically active in that it influences cell differentiation and function.
REFERENCES
1. Praemer, A., Fumer, S. and Rice, S.D., Park Ridge, IL: Am.Ac. ofOrthop.Surgery,1992. 2. J. M. Lane and H. S. Sandhu, Orthop.Clin.NAm., 1987,18 (2), 213-225 . 3. C. J. Damien and J. R. Parsons, JAppliedBiomater.,1991, 2, 187-208 . 4. A. El-Ghannam, P. Ducheyne, and I. M. Shapiro, JMiomed.MatJies,1995, 29, 359-370 . 5. S. B. NicoU, E. M. Santos, S. Radin, R. S. Tuan and P. Ducheyne, Biomaterials,in press. 6. C. Maniatopolous, J. Sodek, and A. H. Melcher, Cell Tissue Res.,1988, 254, 317-330 .
Bioceramics, Volume 10 Edited by L. Sedel and C. Rey (Proceedings of the 10th InternationalSymposium on Ceramics in Medicine, Paris, France, October 1997) '1997 Elsevier Science Ltd
EFFEC T OF SURFAC E INSTABILIT Y OF CALCIU M PHOSPHAT E CERAMIC S ON GROWT H AN D ADHESIO N OF OSTEOBLAST-LIK E CELL S DERIVE D FRO M NEONATA L RA T CALVARI A T. Suzuki, M. Hukkanen,! L. D. K. Buttery,i J. M. Polak,i Y. Yokogawa,^ K. Nishizawa,^ F. Nagata,2 Y. Kawamoto,^ T. Kameyama,^ and M. Toriyama,^ Department of Biological Science and Technology, Science University of Tokyo, 2641 Yamazaki, Noda, Chiba, 278 Japan; i Department of Histochemistry, Royal Postgraduate Medical School, Du Cane Road, London W12 ONN, United Kingdom; ^National Industrial Research Institute of Nagoya, Kita-ku, Nagoya 462, Japan; ABSTRAC T Using composite sinters of hydroxyapatite (HAP) and 6-tricalcium phosphate (TCP) as culture carriers, whose Ca/P molar ratios were adjusted in stepwise fashion to values of L50, L55, L60, L64 and 1.67, osteoblast-like cells derived from neonatal rat calvaria and a mouse fibroblast L-929 cell line were cultured and cell growth rates, adhesion and metabolism were investigated. Growth rates of both cells were accelerated on the TCP-HAP ceramics compared to zirconia ceramics. Adhesiveness of osteoblast-like ceUs on TCP-HAP ceramics was also enhanced more than on zirconia alone. Measurement of alkaline phosphatase activity showed that the cellular activity was enhanced by culturing osteoblast-like cells with high concentrations of calcium. These results suggest that the surface of TCP-HAP ceramics, especially 100% HAP ceramics, is effective to accelerate growlh and differentiation of osteoblast-like cells. KE Y WORDS : bioceramics, osteoblast, hydroxyapatite, tricalcium phosphate, tissue culture INTRODUCTIO N In our previous studies the chemical and physical structure of the sintered mixtures of HAP and TCP carriers were shown to influence the adhesion and growth of mouse fibroblast L-929 cells [1-3]. Observations derived from in vivo studies of implanted ceramics have suggested that the slow solubility of calcium phosphate ceramics seems to be necessary for osteoconductivity and remodeling of the fibrous connective tissues, and for natural bonding of the tissue with the implant [4]. Furthermore, hydroxyapatite ceramics have been reported to have good biocompatibility with osteoblastic cells with no biotoxic reactions [5]. These results suggest that the surface of calcium-phosphate ceramics have the potential to stimulate remodellmg of bone in vivo by acceleratmg the growth of osteoblastic cells. However, the TCP-HAP ceramic hybrid surface can be relatively unstable and may be causative factor for reduced adhesion of cells to the ceramic material, cellular damage and for subsequent inflammatory reactions in osteoarticular tissues. In view of this we have investigated the effects of the surface structure of biocompatible ceramics on the growth and adhesion of osteoblast-enriched neonatal rat calvaria cells cultured on the TCP-HAP composite ceramics. 105
106
Bioceramics Volume10
MATERIAL S AN D METHOD S Ceramic disk plates, 30 mm in diameter and 2 mm thick, consisting of TCP and HAP in various ratios, were used in this study. The Ca/P ratio was adjusted to values of 1.50, 1.55, 1.60, 1.64 and 1.67. Zirconia (ZrOz) disk plate and a polystyrene culture dish (LUX) were used for comparison. Primary osteoblast-like cells were obtained by sequential collagenase digestion of rat calvaria from neonatal rats according to the method of Wong and Cohn [6]. The mouse-fibroblast cell line, L-929 (NCTC Clone 929), was used for comparison. The effect on cell adhesion and growth patterns of Ca-enriched medium was investigated by culturing cells in the medium supplemented with CaCh. The concentration of Ca was adjusted to 2.5, 5, 10, 17, 33, and 50 mM by dissolving CaCh into MEM containing fetal bovme serum (10%). The initial cell density was adjusted at 2 x 10^ cells/cm^ of osteoblast (OB)-like cells and at 5 x 10^ cells/cm^ of L-929 cells. Cultured cells were sonicated and aliquots of the supematants were analyzed for total alkaline phosphatase activity using an Alkalme phosphatase B-test Wako assay kit (Wako Chem. Co., Osaka, Jpn). RESULT S Figure 1 shows the time-dependent variations of concentrations of Ca and PO4 ions after immersion of TCP-HAP ceramics in distilled water and culture medium. The solubility in distilled water was higher for TCP than for HAP. Tlie dissolved Ca and PO4 in the medium were likely to be removed from the solution by deposition on immersed TCP-HAP ceramics. The variation of zeta potential of the TCP-HAP ceramics was unstable with significant changes in the charges as shown in Figure 2. These results suggest that the stability of the surface is closely
(a) 2.0
1.50
1.55 1.60 1.65 1.70 Ca/P molar ratio Figure 1. Time-dependent profiles of calcium and phosphate in distilled water (a), and in culture medium (b) by immersing TCP-HAP ceramics for 1, 3, and 6 days.
1.50 1.55 1.60 1.65 1.70 Ca/P molar ratio Figure 2. Time-dependent changes of surface zeta potential of TCP-HAP ceramics by immersing in distilled water (a), and in culture medium (b).
Effect of Surface Instabilityof TCP-HAP Ceramics on Growth and Adhesion: T. Suzuki et al.
S 40
LJU^LA^
J 30
< I 201U
107
J
jri’"^^
6dj--|
10
o
0 1.50
1.55 1.60 1.65 Ca/P molar ratio Figure 3. Population of OB-like cells on TCP-HAP ceramics and on a ZrOz; Z.
’
II
’ ,
’
,
,’
’
Ca/P molar ratio Figure 4. ALP activity of OB-like cells on TCP-HAP ceramics and on a Zr02; Z.
related to both reactions of association and dissociation of calcium and phosphate in culture medium. Figure 3 shows time-dependent variations in populations of anchored OB-like cells on TCP-HAP plates as a function of Ca/P molar ratio of the carrier material. The cell numbers on Zr02 disk plates at 2 d were higher than on TCP-HAP disk plates except those on TO-HIOO plate. However, the cell numbers on TIOO-HO, T70-H30, and TO-HlOO plates reached higher values than those on Zr02 plates at 9 d. Variations in total cellular ALP activity is shown in Figure 4. Total ALP activities of OB-like cells on TCP-HAP plates were expressed at the higher level than those on ZrOz throughout the time-course studied. Figure 4 also shows that ALP activity of OB-like cells on TCP-HAP plates was elevated according to increase in the HAP content. The adhesiveness of OB-like cells on TCP-HAP plates except for TO-HIOO was weaker than on ZrOz during the first four days of culture as shown in Figure 5. The adhesion strength measured by trypsination method [1], F^^^^, at 4 d culture on ZrOz was 0.53, while it was from 0.39 to 0.53 on TCP-HAP plates. However, the adhesion of OB-like cells on TCP-HAP plates increased during the later growth phase. The highest value of F^ ^ for OB-like cells was obtained on TO-HIOO plate at 9 d of culture.
Figure 6 shows the effects of Ca concentration on adhesion of
1.55 1.60 1.65 Ca/P molar ratio Figure 5. Adhesiveness of OB-like cells on TCP-HAP ceramics and ZrOa.
1
10 100 Initial Ca concentration (mM) Figure 6. Effects of Ca concentration on adhesiveness of OB-like cells.
108
Bioceramies Volume10
OB-like cells on LUX carrier. High concentrations of CaCh damaged the cells and decreased their growth rate, while total cell number and ALP activity increased gradually when Ca concentration was lower than 17 mM. The adhesion of OB-like cells at 2 d and 4 d were almost constant when Ca concentration was lower than 10 mM. However, cells cultured in medium with 5 mM and 10 mM of Ca demonstrated increased adhesion at 6 d and further at 9 d of culture. These results support the view that the adhesion of OB-like cells on TCP-HAP plates is increased compared with inert materials and dependent on Ca/P ratio of the ceramic carrier material. DISCUSSION Implanted porous calcium phosphate ceramics have been shown to have strong osteogenic potential with new bone forming in the pore regions. The instability of TCP-HAP ceramics is thought to be a factor in accelerating osteoconductivity and improving the chemical affinity and connectivity with bone tissue in vivo. However, the high solubility and reactivity of bioceramic surfaces may cause damage to adherent cells, which in turn may stimulate inflammatory responses in surrounding tissues. Our previous studies showed that the high solubility of the surface structure reduced the adhesion strength between L-929 cells and TCP-HAP ceramics [1]. Nevertheless, morphological observations and a series of other analyses showed that the weak solubility of the TCP-HAP ceramics were preferable not only for the grov^h of cells, but the surface was shown to be stable enough also to enhance cell adhesion. The accelerated increase in the ALP activity of OB-like cells on TCP-HAP ceramics suggests that the calcium phosphate surface supports both the growth and differentiation of osteogenic cells. In conclusion, this study has further clarified the effects of TCP-HAP composite ceramics, and especially 100% HAP, on the growth and adhesion of OB-like cells during the early phase of the mineralization process. Time-dependent variation of the cellular ALP activity suggests that the TCP-HAP ceramics are able to stimulate differentiation of osteoblasts and therefore to promote osteogenesis in vivo, ACKNOWLEDGMEN T This work was supported by the Bilateral International Joint Researdi Grant by the Japanese Government, the British Council (promotion of the joint research project between United Kingdom and Japan) and the Medical Research Council U.K. The authors are grateful to Dr. Francis J. Hughes of Department of Periodontology, London Hospital Medical College for his advise on osteoblast culture.
REFERENCES 1.
2. 3. 4. 5. 6.
Suzuki, T., Yamamoto, T., Toriyama, M., Nishizawa, K., Yokogawa, Y., Mucalo, R.M., Nagata, F., Y. Kawamoto, Y., and Kameyama, T., /. Biomed. Mater. Res., 1997, 34, 507-517. Nishizawa, K., Toriyama, M., Suzuki, T., Kawamoto, Y., Yokogawa, Y., and Nagata, F., Nihon Kagaku Kaishi, 1995, 63-67. Toriyama, M., Kawamoto, Y., Suzuki, T., . Yokogawa, Y., Nishizawa, K., and Nagata, F., J. Ceram.Soc. Jpn, 1995, 103, 46-49. Niki, M., J. Jpn. Soc. Biomater.,1994, 12, 5-21. Bagambisa, F.B., and Joos, U., Biomaterials,1990, 11, 50-56. Wong, G.L., and Cohn, D.V., Nature, 1974, 252, 713-715 (1974).
Bioceramics, Volume 10 Edited by L. Sedel and C. Rey (Proceedings of the 10th InternationalSymposium on Ceramics in Medicine, Paris, France, October 1997) '1997 Elsevier Science Ltd
HISTOLOGICA L EVALUATIO N OF CRYOPRESERVE D MARRO W CELL S
CULTURE D
BON E
GRAF T
USIN G
H. Nakajima^’^, T. Yoshikawa^’^, H. Ohgushi’, M. Akahane\ S. Tamai\ K. Mishima^ and K. Ichijima^ Departments of Orthopaedic Surgery^ and Pathology^, Nara Medical University, Kashihara City, Nara 634, JAPAN.
ABSTRAC T Rat bone marrow cells obtained from femora were cultured in a standard medium for ten days. The cultured cells were released by trypsin treatment and stored at -196 C (liquid nitrogen) in a preservative culture medium containing 10% dimethylsulfoxide. After 3 months, the cryopreserved cells were thawed and subcultured in porous hydroxyapatite(HA; Interpore 500). The medium consisted of Eagle-MEM containing 15% fetal bovine serum, antibiotics, ascorbic acid, P-glycerophosphate and dexamethasone. After 2 weeks of the subculture, the composites of the cultured bone and porous HA were subcutaneously implanted into syngeneic rats. These implants were harvested 2 and 4 weeks postimplantation and prepared for histological analysis, which showed bone formation together with active osteoblasts in many pore regions. These results indicate the osteogenic capacity of cryopreserved marrow cells in porous HA. KE Y WORDS : cryopreservation, hydroxyapatite, bone marrow, dexamethasone, bone graft
INTRODUCTIO N Bone marrow stromal cells are fibroblast-like cells that are thought to include precursors of different connective tissue phenotypes, including adipocytes and osteoblasts[l]. Previously, Maniatopolous et al. demonstrated that in the presence of dexamethasone, cultures of rat marrow stromal fibroblasts formed mineralized nodules that resembled bone[2]. We also have reported the appearance of osteogenic cells in porous biomaterials by transplantation of marrow/materials composites to heterotopic (extraosseous) sites[3, 4], and more importantly we have found that not only fresh marrow but also cultured human fibroblastic cells can show the osteogenic response resulting in bone formation at heterotopic sites[5]. Cryopresevation is clinically available technique for the prolonged storage of many mammalian tissues such as pancreatic islets, blood, bone marrow cells and spermatozoa[6]. At present experiment, we analyzed the osteogenic capacity of cultured bone graft derived from cryopreserved marrow cell culture. 109
110
Bioceramics Volume10
MATERIAL S AND METHOD S Materials; Coralline hydroxyapatite ceramic (HA) was used in this experiment. A hydrothermal chemical exchange converts the original calcium carbonate exoskeleton of coral into a completely inorganic replica of HA. The solid and porous components of the microstructure are completely interconnected. The pores average is 600 micrometers in diameter and their interconnections average is 260 micrometers in diameter. Interpore International (Irvme, CA) manufactured the HA and labeled it as Interpore 500. We used the cubic structure (5x5x5mm) of the HA. Preparation of Cryopreserved Marrow Cells; Marrow cells were obtained from the femoral shafts of a seven-week-old male Fischer rats. The femora were taken and cut at both ends of epiphysis under aseptic conditions. The marrow cells were flushed out with the 10ml of a standard culture medium using a 10-ml syringe with a 21 gauge needle. A standard culture medium consisted of an Eagle’s minhnal essential medium (MEM) containing 15% fetal bovine serum (ICN Biomedicals Japan Co. Ltd.) and antibiotics (lOOU/ml penicillin, lOO^ig/ml streptomycin and 0.25|Lig/ml amphotericine B, Sigma). The cells were collected in a T-75 flask (COSTAR) containing 15ml of the culture medium. The medium was changed after 24 hours to remove nonadherent cells. Subsequently, the medium was renewed 3 times a week. Cultures were maintained in a humidified atmosphere of 95% air and 5% CO2 at 37 C. After 10 days in primary culture, the cells were released by 0.1% trypsin treatment and concentrated to 10^ cells/ml in a preservative culture medium by centrifiigation at 900rpm for 5min at room temperature, then frozen and stored at -196 C in liquid nitrogen for 3 months. The preservative culture medium consisted of Eagle’s MEM containing 10% dimethylsulfoxide and 20% fetal bovine serum. At the time of culture, the frozen cells were thawed and reseeded on T-75 flask in 15ml of standard medium for removal of non-adherent cells which were probably dead. After 24 hours, the cells were trypsinized and concentrated to 10^ cells/ml in a standard medium. The trypsinized cells were used for subcultures on well or in porous hydroxyapatite(HA). Culture of Cryopreserved Cells on a Culture well; To ascertain the osteogenic capacity of cryopreseved marrow cells, we cultured these cells for alkaline phosphatase(ALP)-stain. The cells were seeded at 100 X 10^ cells/35mm Falcon tissue culture plate and cultured for 2 weeks. The subculture was done with 2 ml of the standard medium supplemented with lOmM Na (3 glycerophosphate, 82|ig/ml vitamin C phosphate(L-ascorbic acid phosphate magnesium salt nhydrate) and with or without lO’^M dexamethasone(Dex), which is known to induce osteoblastic differentiation of marrow stromal cells in culture conditions. The culture medium was renewed 3 times a week. After 2 weeks of subculture, ALP was stained as described previously[7]. Culture of Cryopreseved Cells in Porous HA ; The cells were subcultured in HA as described previously[8]. Briefly, HA block were soaked in 4ml of the cell suspension in a CO2 incubator. After 2 hours of incubation, each composite of HA and cells was transferred into one well of a 24-well plate and subcultured in 1ml of the medium containing P-glycerophosphate, vitamin C phosphate with or without Dex, as described above. The medium was renewed 3 times a week. After 2 weeks of subcultures, the composites were prepared for following implantation. Six composites were implanted subcutaneously at 6 sites of the back of each syngeneic rat: three composites subcultured in the presence of Dex were separately implanted in the right side, and the other three composites subcultured in the absence of Dex were separately implanted in the left side. The grafts were harvested at 2 and 4 weeks after implantation and prepared for decalcified sections. The specimens were fixed in 10% buffered formaline, decalcified (K-CX solution, Falma Co., Tokyo) and stained with hematoxylin and eosin. These specimens were examined under light microscopy.
Evaluation of CulturedBone Graft Using CryopreservedMarrow Cells: H. Nakajima et al.
Dex (+)
Ill
Dex (-)
Fig. 1 ALP stain of cryopreserved cells cultured with or without Dex. Many ALP positive nodules were seen in the cultured tissue with Dex.
2W
4W
Fig.2 Dex-treated composite 2 weeks (left) and 4 weeks (right) postimplantation. Both show active bone formation on the HA pores. Right shows regenerated marrow tissue associated with new bone formation at 4 weeks. (HE stain, X 40)
112
Bioceramics Volume10
RESULTS Cryopreserved marrow cells which were subcultured for 2 weeks with Dex on culture dishes showed many calcified nodules. The calcified nodules were stainable for ALP (Fig.l). The same ALP activity was seen on the nodules when subcultures were done using fresh marrow cells. These findings indicate that cryopreserved marrow cells have osteogenic potency same as fresh marrow cells, because alkaline phosphatase activity is known to reflect osteoblastic activity. The Dex-treated composites using cryopreserved cells showed obvious bone formation sevral weeks after implantation. As shown in Fig. 2, many active osteoblasts in contact with the newly formed bone matrix were clearly seen in the pore areas. Number of osteoblasts and area of bone increased as time passed. In contrast, it was hard to detect bone formation in the Dex-untreated composites. DISCUSSION We demonstrated that cryopreserved marrow cells, which were stored for 3 months in liquid nitrogen, show histological active bone formation both in vitro and in vivo conditions. This indicates that cryopreserved marrow cells have comparable osteogenic capacity to that of fresh marrow cells. HA ceramics are useful as bone graft substitutes and can show osteogenesis when combined with freshly isolated marrow cells[3, 4] or with their cultured bone[8-12]. Present resuhs also showed the osteogenic potential of cryopreserved marrow cells. If new methods are applied clinically, it may eliminate the limitation of bone graft and furthermore be available for elderly patients with low osteogenic ability using marrow cells frozen and stored at young age of the patients. REFERENCES 1. Owen M. In: Bone and Mineral Research3 Elsevier, Amsterdam 1985, 42-53. 2. Maniatopolous C, Sodek J. and Melcher A.H., Cell TissueRes., 1988, 254, 317-330. 3. Ohgushi H., Goldberg V.M. and Caplan A.I., J. Orthop.Res., 1989, 7, 568-578. 4. Yoshikawa T., Ohgushi H., Okumura M., Tamai S., Dohi Y. and Moriyama T., Calcif Tissue Int.,1992, 50, 184-188. 5. Ohgushi H. and Okumura M., Acta Orthop.Scand, 1990, 61, 431-434. 6. Farrant J. In: Low Temperature Preservationin Medicineand Biology Pitman Medical, 1980, 1-18. 7. Ohgushi H., Dohi Y., Katsuda T., Tamai S., Tabata S. and Suwa Y., J. Biomed Mat. Res., 1996,32,333-340. 8. Yoshikawa T,, Ohgushi H. and Tamai S., 1 Biomed Mat. Res., 1996, 32, 481-492. 9. Ohgushi H., Dohi Y., Yoshikawa T., Tamai S., Tabata S., Okunaga K, and Shibuya T., J. Biomed Mat. Res., 1996, 32, 341-348. 10. Yoshikawa T., Ohgushi H. and Tamai S. In: Bioceramics Volume 9, Pergamon, Oxford 1995, 421-426. 11. Yoshikawa T., Ohgushi H., Akahane M., Sempuku T., Tamai S. and Ichijima K. In: BioceramicsVolume 9, Pergamon, Oxford 1996, 65-68. 12. Yoshikawa T., Ohgushi H., Dohi Y. and Davis J.E., Bio-Medical Mater. Eng., in press,
Bioceramics, Volume 10 Edited by L. Sedel and C. Rey (Proceedings of the 10th InternationalSymposium on Ceramics in Medicine, Paris, France, October 1997) '1997 Elsevier Science Ltd
INTERACTION S OF BIOCERAMIC S ON HUMA N OSTEOARTHRITI S (OA) TYPE B SYNOVIOCYTES . EFFECT S ON INTERLEUKI N LEVEL S AND LIPOXYGENAS E PATHWAY S Bertrand Liagre^, Jean-L. Charissoux^, Marie-J. Leboutet^, Didier Bemache-AssoUant^ and Jean-L. Beneytout^ ^ Facultes de Medecine et de Pharmacie, E.R.S. CNRS 6101, 2 rue du Docteur Marcland, 87025 Limoges Cedex, France ^ Service dOrthopedie-Traumatologie et ^ Service d’Anatomie Pathologique, CHRU de Limoges, Hopital Dupuytren, 2 avenue Martin Luther King, 87042 Limoges Cedex, France ^ LMCTS, U.R. A. CNRS 320,123 avenue Albert-Thomas, 87060 Limoges Cedex, France ABSTRAC T We investigated the effects of the biomaterials hydroxy2q)atite (HAP) and fluorapatite (FAP) on cultured human OA type B synoviocytes by analysing interleukin-la (IL-la) production and arachidonic acid metabolism via lipoxygenase pathways. A portion of opsonized particles were endocytosed and found in numerous phagolysosomes in human synoviocyte cytoplasms. The present stucfy demonstrates that HAP and FAP calcined at 700 C induced a decrease in IL-la production but markedly decreased the synthesis of lipoxygenase products after one month incubation with the particles. This model will allow us to stucfy the possible inflammatory response (arachidonic acid metabolism, proinflammatory cytokines) that can be induced by any biomaterials used in orthopaedics. INTRODUCTIO N The nature of the response of human tissue to particulate debris from total joint prostheses has not been clearly defined. Some early investigators thought that hip prostheses were inert [1], but others postulated a hypersensitivity rejection phenomenon in some patients [2]. Most histological studies have confirmed that the predominant cell types in the tissue surrounding loosened total hip prostheses are macrophages, giant cells andfibroblasts[3]. IL-1 is a pleiotropic cytokine and a potent mediator of the inflammatory response in connective tissues with the c^)acity to induce the synthesis and the secretion of coUagenases such as matrix metalloprotease-1, stromelysin-1, gelatinase A and prostaglandin Ej (PGEj) by synoviocytes and chondrocytes [4]. Lipoxygenase metabolites have been demonstrated to modulate a host of biological activities and appear to be of particular importance in inflammation, fibrosis and the immune response [5]. The aim of our study was to understand \^ether release of particulate debris from total joint prostheses in organism could induce an inflammatory phenomenon over time. The majority of previous studies were done either in vivo on animal models by injections of particulate prosthesis material or in vitroon macrophages [6] and on OA synovial lining cells [7]. The behaviour of human osteoblasts cultivated on HAP-coated disks [8] was studied in vitroand comparison of the effects of HAP and FAP were studied on the release of growth hormone on human osteosarcoma cells [9]. In our work and contrary to previous studies on macrophages, we investigated the effects over time of biomaterials such as HAP and FAP on human OA type B synoviocytes in culture by analyzing IL-la production and arachidonic acid metabolism via lipoxygenase pathways. 113
114
Bioceramies Volume10
MATERIAL S AND METHOD S HAP, Caio(P04)5(OH)2, is a chemical component ^ o s e composition is very close to that of natural bone. HAP powder was prepared in an aqueous medium by slow addition of a (NH4)2(HP04) solution containing NH4OH to boiling Ca(^0^)2,4 HjO solution at pH 9. The powder was calcined at 700^C in order to improve its crystallization state, and to eliminate the volatile impurities (NH4NO3). For characterization, a small fraction of the powder was heated at lOOO^’C and then analysed t^ X r ^ difGraction and a basic test to reveal the presence of CaO. Xray difGraction patterns (Fig. 1) show no additional peak of C2^(?0^ and CaO, and the basic test with phenolphtaleine (AFNOR 894-066) was negative. This is a very sensitive test vAiich confirmed that the Ca/P ratio of this powder was 1.67 – 0.004, the theoretical stoichiometry of pure HAP. Particles were sterilized and opsonized was done according to Estensen et al. [10]. OA synoviocytes were isolated from fresh synovial biopsies obtained from OA patients undergoing hip synovectomy. Synovia were minced and digested by enzymatic reaction. Adherent cells were cultured in complete medium and, at confluence, cells were trypsinized and passed. Cells were used between passages 4 and 8 when they morphologically ressembled "fibroblast-like** synoviocytes. HAP and FAP powders were opsonized and incubated at 10^ particles/10^ cells for one week and for one month. Particles and cells were seeded in culture flask at the same time. Culture medium was changed every two days. No additional particles were added during the entire study. Particles were not removed during medium change because they bound to synoviocyte cell membranes. Synoviocyte culture supematants, henceforth referred to as synoviocyte conditioned medium, were collected, centrifiiged, aliquoted and stored at -80^C. All synoviocyte conditioned media were evaluated for IL-la and the collection period was two days because of the short IL-la half life. The amounts of IL-la in synoviocyte conditioned media were measured by commercially available EIA kits (Cayman Chemical Company, Ann Arbor, NO, U.S.A.). Furthermore, synoviocyte cultures were collected for analysis of exogenous arachidonic acid metabolites t^ reverse-phase-high pressure liquid chromatogr^hy (RP-HPLC) according to Bonnet et al. [11]. Acidified samples and synthetic standards were injected on a 5 ^m Radial-Pack C18 cartridge (Waters-Millipore, Saint-Quentin en Yvelines, France) protected by a Waters CI8 Guard Pack precolumn. Lipoxygenase metabolites were eluted at a flow rate of 2 mL.min’^ using a tertiary methanol-acetonitrile-H20 gradient as previously described. Radioactivity was detected at the exit of the column by a Flow One/Beta A500-Packard system. Metabolites of [1-^^C] arachidonic acid were identified by comparing their retention times with those of synthetic standards and quantitated by measuring the areas under the respective peaks. Each peak count was adjusted relative to the total radioactivity of the corresponding sample. For each incubation, the amount of every metabolite was compared with the control assay. RESULTS AND DISCUSSIO N In the presence of HAP or FAP, synovial proliferation slows over time (Fig. 2). However, under our experimental conditions, no cytotoxic effects were observed when particles were present. Transmission electron microscopy confirmed the nontoxicity of the two materials, as there was no spontaneous detachment of cells, and human synoviocytes presented normal cytoplasm and nucleus. Human OA type B synoviocytes spontaneously synthesized IL-la yMch increased over time (Table I). The presence of HAP and FAP inhibited II-la synthesis and II-la levels after one week were decreased compared to control cultures: 75% and 67% for HAP and FAP respectively (Table I). Moreover, by one month incubation, II-la synthesis dramatically declined compared to control cultures: 86% and 83% for HAP and FAP respectively (Table I)- In agreement with the results of Boimet et al. [11], we observed the formation of metabolites issued from the lipoxygenase pathways after incubation of 10^ cells with 1 \iC\[1-^^C] arachidonic acid in the presence of calcium ionophore A23187 (Fig. 3 A).
Interactionsof Bioceramieson Human Osteoarthritis(OA) Type B Synoviocytes:B. Liagre et al.
4S
A«gl«
SO
{19}
SS
115
to 0»vs
Figure 1: Xray difGraction pattern of HA P powder.
Figure 2: Proliferation of human OA type B synoviocyte s exposed to HA P ( -M- ) and FAP ( - x- ) particles; control culture ( - o ).
After one month, HA P and FAP particles did not seem to influence the formation of LTC 4 and LTE4. In fact, a marked decrease in HETE s (15-, 12- and 5-HETE) , LTB4, its isomer A6-/ran5^LTB4, and LTC 4 ^^^ ^^^’LTE 4 was not detecte d (Fig. 3B and 3C). In conclusion , using our experimenta l conditions, HA P and FAP decrease the secretio n of IL-l a and leukotrien e and HET E synthesis in human OA type B synoviocyte s in culture in a similar manner. Macrophages, which are representativ e of an inflammatory cell type, can only be used in short term invitrostudies. Our model, because cell culture is possible, has the advantage of prolonged exposure of human OA type B synoviocyte s to powders. This model will allow us to study the possible inflammatory response (arachidonic acid metabolism , proinflammatory cytokines) that can be induced by any biomaterials used in orthopaedics . One must be prudent in making assumptions about the invivopropertie s of a biomaterial based on a simple extrapolatio n of/>iv//ro results. Table 1. IL-l a release d by human OA synoviocyte s exposed to HA P and FAP particles by one week or one month incubation. Stimulus^
D - l a (pg/mL)b
Unstim. (1 week)*
6.33–1.5 8
Unstim. (1 month)*
13.73–3.2 9
106 HA P (1 week)*
1.58–0.0 6
106 HA P (1 month)*
1.92–0.1 3
106 FA P (1 week)*
2,08–0.5 2
106 FA P (1 month>
2.33–0.5 7 ^Stimulus abbreviations : Unstim., spontaneou s release by unstimulate d human OA type B synoviocytes ; 10<5 HA P or 10^ FAP, 10^ HA P or FAP particles/10 ^ ceUs. ^EL-l a concentratio n is expresse d as pg/mL/10^ cells. ** P < .05 relative to unstimulate d group, paired Student / test).
116
Bioceramies Volume10
8
s
\Q
u
iQ , u
k^ ia
u
ifwtr’-^ 4a
Figure 3: Extended scales of radioactive profiles of human OA type B synoviocyte s incubated with [1-^^C] arachidonic acid. A: referenc e profile; B: with HA P particles for one month; C: with FAP particles for one month. Metabolites identifie d were A6-/>-anj^LTB4 (peak 1), LTB 4 (peak 2). 15-HETE (peak 3), H-HET E (peak 4), 5-HETE (peak 5). LTC 4 (peak 6), LTE 4 (peak 7). Peak 8 is the peak of [1-^^C] arachidonic acid. REFERENCE S Chamley, J., London, Churchill Livingstone, 1972, p 9. 1. 2. Evans, E.M., Freeman, MAR. , Miller, AJ., and Vernon-Roberts, B.J., J, Bone JointSurg,,1974,56B , 626-642 . Goldring, S.R, Schiller, AL. , Roelke, M., Rourke, CM. , ONeill, D.A., and Harris. W.H., J. BoneJointSurg.,1983, 65A, 575-584 . M c Guire-Goldring, M.B., Meats, J.E., Wood, D.D., Ihrie, E.J., Ebsworth, N.M., and Russel, K.G.G.,Arthritis Rheum.,1984,27 , 654-662 . 5. Henderson, W.R.,yim. Rev.Respir. Dis., 1987,135,1176-1185 . 6. Charissoux, J.L., Najid, A , Cook-Moreau, J., Setton, D., and Rigaud, M., Clin. Orthop. Rel Res.,1996.326 , 259-269 . 7. Tawara, T., Shingu, M., Nobunaga, M., and Naono, T., Inflammation, 1991,15 , 145-157 . Labat. B.. Chamson, A . and Frey, J., J. Biomed. Mater.Res., 1995,29,1397 1401. 9. Downes. S., Clifford. C.J.. Scotchford. C , and Klein. C.P.AT.,7. Biomed. Mater.Res,,1995.29 , 1053-1060 . 10. Estensen. R.D.. White. J.G.. and Holmes. B., Nature,1974,248 , 347-348 . 11. Bonnet, C . Bertin, P.. Cook-Moreau. J.. Chable-Rabinovitch . H., Treves, R , and Rigaud, M.. Prostaglandins, 1995, 50, 127-135 .
Bioceramies, Volume 10 Edited by L. Sedel and C. Rey (Proeeedings of the 10th InternationalSymposium on Ceramics in Medicine, Paris, France, October 1997) '1997 Elsevier Science Ltd
A LON G TER M IMPLANTATIO N HYDROXYAPATIT E
OF CULTURE D
BON E
IN
POROU S
T. Yoshikawa^’^, H. Ohgushi^, H. Nakajima^ ’^, M. Akahane^, S. Tamai^ and K. Ichijima^ Departments of Pathology^ and Orthopaedic Surgery^, Nara Medical University, Kashihara City Nara 634, JAPAN.
ABSTRACT : In vitro bone tissue in porous areas of hydroxyapatite (HA) can be constructed by marrow cell culture treated with dexamethasone (Dex). To investigate in vivo osteogenic potential of the cultured bone for a long tenn period, the composites of HA and Fischer rat marrow cells were cultured in a Eagle’s Minimum Essential Medium containing 15%fetal bovine serum and Dex for 2 weeks, and were subcutaneously implanted into 7-week-old male syngeneic rats. The implants were harvested 52 weeks (one year) postimplantation and examined histologically. Almost all pores were filled with lamellar bone and some porous areas showed the appearance of regenerated bone marrow. Fluorochrome labeling (calcein) administered 50 weeks postimplantation was seen near the surface of bone in porous areas of the HA. These resuks indicate the persistent in vivo osteoblastic activity of the in vitroprefabricated culture bone in HA. KE Y WORDS : Hydroxyapatite, Bone marrow cell, Dexamethasone, Bone graft INTRODUCTIO N Bone like tissue can be produced by culturing bone marrow cells in a medium containing dexamethasone (Dex) and P-glycerophosphate, as previously reported [1-6]. Hydroxyapatite ceramics (HA) has been used as bone graft substitutes which can support osteoblastic differentiation [7-9] and we recently reported that HA combined with this cultured bone tissue possesses a high osteogenic ability when grafted in v/vo[10-12]. Therefore, the composite (HA and cultured bone) can be expected to be a bone grafting substitute having high osteogenic ability. The high osteogenic ability was confirmed by biochemical analysis. High alkaline phosphatase activity, which indicates osteoblastic activity, in the harvested composites began to appear at 1 week postimplantation and was maintained until 8 weeks. Bone Gla protein, an specific product of osteoblasts, began to increase at 1 week, followed by a steady increase until 8 weeks [8]. These findings indicate that this composite in in vivo situations can be categorized as the hybrid artificial organ. To confirm the ftinction of the composite as organ, the composite should maintain its activity for a long term period. In present study, we examined the osteogenic capacity of Dex-treated composites after one year postimplantation. 117
118
Bioceramics Volume10
Materials and Methods Materials; Coralline hydroxyapatite ceramic (HA) was used in this experiment. A hydrothermal chemical exchange converts the original calcium carbonate exoskeleton of coral into a completely inorganic replica of HA. The solid and porous components of the microstructure are completely interconnected. The pores average is 600 micrometers in diameter and their interconnections average is 260 micrometers in diameter. Interpore International (Irvine, CA) manufactured the HA and labeled it as Interpore 500. We used the cubic structure (5x5x5mm) of the HA. Marro w cells preparation and Culture; Marrow cells were obtained from the bone shaft of femora of Fischer 344, male, 7-week-old rats. Both ends of the femora of a rat were cut away from the epiphysis, and the marrow was flushed out by using 10 ml of culture medium expelled from a syringe through a 21 gauge needle. The released cells were collected in two T-75 flasks (COSTAR) containing 15 ml of the below-mentioned standard medium. Subsequently, the medium was renewed three times a week. Cultures were maintained in humidified atmosphere of 95% air with 5 % CO2 at 37 C. A standard medium consists of an Eagle-Minimal Essential Medium (MEM) containing 15% fetal bovine serum ( ICN BIOMEDICALS JAPAN Co. Ltd. ) and antibiotics ( 100 units/ml Penicillin, lOOj^g/ml Streptomycin, and 0.25|ig/ml amphotericine B, Sigma ). After 10 days in primary culture, marrow stromal cells were released from their culture substratum using 0.1% trypsin. The cells were concentrated by centrifiigation at 900 rpm for 5 minutes at room temperature, resulting in 10^ cells/ml. The HA blocks were soaked in 4 ml of the marrow cell suspension (10^ cells/ml). After 2 hours of incubation, each block was transferred into a 24 well-plate ( FALCON ) for subcultures. One HA block was subcultured in one well with 1 ml of the standard medium supplemented with lOmM Na (i-glycerophosphate (MERCK), 82 jUg/ml vitamin C phosphate ( L-Ascorbic Acid Phosphate Magnesium Salt n-Hydrate, C6H609PMg2/3.nH20, WAKO PURE CHEMICAL INDUSTRIALS ) and lO’^M dexamethasone (Dex, Sigma) [1,8]. The medium was renewed three times a week and the subcultures were maintained for 2 weeks. Implantation; Six composites after 2 weeks of subculture were implanted subcutaneously at 6 sites of the back of each Fischer 7-week-old male rat. These implants were harvested at 52 weeks (one year) postimplantation and prepared for histological analysis. To determine the bone dynamics in the composite, some rats were intramuscularly given one dose (15 mg/kg) of calcein at 50 weeks postimplantation and prepared for undecalcified histology at 52 weeks. Histological evaluation; The implants were harvested 52 weeks postimplantation, and were fixed in 10% buffered formaline, decalcified (K-CX solution, Fahna Co., Tokyo) and stained with hematoxylin and eosin. For undecalcified sections, the implants were immediately fixed with 70% ETOH and stained with Villanueva bone stain. These were dehydrated in an alcohol series, defatted, embedded in methylmetacrylate, and observed under light microscopy or fluoromicroscopy.
A Long Term Implantationof CulturedBone in Porous Hydroxy apatite:T. Yoshikawa et al.
119
Figure 1. The composite graft 52 weeks after implantation. White area shows the ghost of hydroxyapatite ceramic produced by decalcification procedures. Black area indicates the new bone appeared in porous area and M indicates regenerated marrow tissue. (Decacified sections stained with hematoxylin and eosin. x80)
Figure 2. The composite 52 weeks postimplantation. Undecalcified section under fluoroscopy. Arrowheads indicate the interface between bone and hydroxyapatite. B indicates bone and C indicates hydroxyapatite ceramic. Arrows indicate the calcein labeling, administered 50 week after implantation. (Villanueva bone stain, xlOO)
120
Bioceramies Volume10
RESULT S AND DISCUSSIO N Fifty-two weeks after implantation of the composites, almost all pores were filled with bone and some porous areas showed the appearance of regenerated bone marrow in association with the new bone formation [Fig.l]. Not only resting osteoblasts but also active osteoblasts could be detected on the surface of bone. All of Dex-treated composites (12/12) showed bone formation. By fluorochrome labeling, the line of calcein administered 50 weeks postimplantation could be detected near the surface of the bone in many porous areas [Fig.2]. These results indicate that the composite of cultured bone and porous hydroxyapatite maintains the osteogenic ability for along time period and, therefore, the composites can fimction as hybrid artificial organ. The findings clearly showed that the tissue culture technology applied in present experiments can stimulate the inherent osteogenic ability of marrow stromal cells is pore regions of HA and importantly the ability persists for a long term period. Based on the fact that human cultured marrow cells possess osteogenic potential[13-15], the present graft procedures show the possibility in clinical application of reconstructive surgery.
REFERENCES 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. 6. 7. 8. 9. 10. 11. 12. 13. 14. 15.
Maniatopoulos C , Sodek J. and Melcher A.H. Cell TissueRes., 1988, 254, 317-330. Yoshikawa T., Ohgushi H., Dohi Y., and Davies J.E. Bio-Med.Mater. Eng., in press. Ohgushi H., Dohi Y., Katsuda T., Tamai S., Tabata S. and Suwa Y., J. Biomed. Mat. Res., 1996, 32, 333-340. Ohgushi H., Dohi Y., Yoshikawa T., Tamai S., Tabata S., Okunaga K. and Shibuya T., Biomed Mat. Res., 1996, 32, 341-348. Yao K-L., Todescan R.J. and Sodek J., J. Bone and Mineral Res.. 1994, 9,231-240. Davies J.E., Chemecky R., Lowenberg B. and Shiga A., Cells Mater. 1991, 1, 3-15. Ohgushi H., Goldberg V.M., and Caplan A.I. J.Orthop.Res.,1989, 7 568-578 Yoshikawa T., Ohgushi H., Okumura M., Tamai S., Dohi Y. and Moriyama T. Calcif. TissueInt., 1992,50, 184-188. Okumura M., Ohgushi H., Yoshikawa T. and Tamai S., Ceramics in Substitutiveand ReconstructiveSurgery, 1991, 353-361. Yoshikawa T., Ohgushi H., and Tamai S., J. Biomed Mat. Res. 1996, 32, 481-492. Yoshikawa T., Ohgushi H., and Tamai S., BioceramicsVol. 8, 1995, 421-426. Yoshikawa T., Ohgushi H., Akahane M., Sempuku T., Tamai S. and Ichijima K., Bioceramics Vol. 9, 1996, 65-68 de Bruijin J. D., vd Brink I. and Bovell Y. P., BioceramicsVol.9, 1996, 45-48. Haynesworth S.E., Goshima J., Goldberg V.M. and Caplan A.I., ^o«^, 1992,13, 8188. Ohgushi H. and Okumura M.,Acta. Orthop.1990, 61,431-434.
SURFACE BEARING CERAMICS
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
Bioceramics, Volume 10 Edited by L. Sedel and C. Rey (Proceedings of the 10th InternationalSymposium on Ceramics in Medicine, Paris, France, October 1997) '1997 Elsevier Science Ltd
OXID E CERAMIC S FOR ARTICULATIN G COMPONENT S OF TOTA L HI P REPLACEMENT S G. Willmann CeramTec Medical Product Division, P.O.B. 1149, D-73201 Plochingen, Germany
ABSTRAC T The state of the art of ceramics for total hip repalcement (THR) is reviewed, reporting some tribological facts and future trends. Modem hip systems are designed in a modular way. By using the concept of cup inserts the surgeon has the option to use either a cup insert of PE-UHMW or an alumina cup insert formetal backed socket. The wear couple alumina-on-alumia offers extremely low wear rates when approved components are used. The combinations alumina-on-zirconia and zirconia-on-zirconia are not approved. WEA R COUPLE S USED IN THR Alumina ceramics were introduced more than 20 years ago as a material for bearing surfaces in total hip replacements (THR) [1]. The objective was to minimise the wear debris to overcome the problem of osteolysis caused by the polyethylene wear particles. Osteolysis is still a problem in orthopedics. To minimise wear of the articulating surfaces in THR there are two approaches classified as "hard / soft" and "hard / hard" (table 1), both offering the option to minimize wear. Approved wear couples in total hip replacement [1-7]
Table 1. Femoral head
socket
remark
typical wear
cobalt chromium
PE-UHMW
standard
0.2 to 0.5 mm per year
almnina
PE-UHMW
standard
< 0.1 mm per year
zirconia
PE-UHMW
new approach
alumina
alumina
used since 25 years
alumina
CFRP
5 |im per year (clinical results) < 1 ^un per year (HIPed alumina) a few ^m per year
123
124
Bioceramics Volume10
One option is to use ceramic articulating against polyethylen e (PE-UHMW) , the better one is the wear couple alumina-on-alumin a [6,7]. The standard combination for THR s is a metal femoral head articulating against an acetabula r cup of polyethylen e (PE-UHMW ) The wear rate for the mostly used combination metal / PE is > 0,2 mm, sometime s up to 0,5 mm / year [9-11], Biolox forte alumina heads articulating against polyethylen e (hard / soft) have a lower wear rate. It is below 0,1 mm / year [9-11]. Dueto that the loosening rate of stems is lower, too. Since 1974 more than 2 million alumina component s have been successfiill y used. The mechanica l propertie s of Y-TZ P zirconia are very atractive, e. g.fracturetoughness and bending strength. This offers the option to design heads with diameters smaller than 28 mm. Femoral ball heads of Y-TZ P were introduced . Alumina and zirconia femoral heads in combination with polyethylen e cups (hard / soft) have similar tribological properties . In respect to wear Y-TZ P offers no adavantages . Heads of Y-TZ P are more expensiv e than alumina. The combination alumina femoral head articulating against an alumina cup or cup insert (hard / hard) has the lowest wear rate known. Clinical results are < 5 pm / year [2,6]. There are lots of investigation s on Biolox forte femoral heads articulating against Biolox forte acetabular cups or cup inserts. Histological investigation s of retrieve d Biolox implants prove that the wear particles have a diamete r in the order of 1 ^m [6 ]. Alumina particles don’t cause any problems, they are biocompatible . The investigatio n of retrieve d Biolox implants (in vivo up to 20 years) prove that the wear rate is extremel y low, e.g. lessthan 5 fim per year [2,6]. Ring-on-disc tests and simulator test prove that the combination Y-TZ P ceramic / Y-TZ P ceramic and Y-TZ P zirconia / alumina are disastrous [4,12] . Table 2.
Approved and not approved wear couples in THR
Femoral head
socket
apporved
remarks
alumina
PE-UHM W
yes
standard
Biolox forte (HlPed alumina)
Biolox forte
yes
Biolox forte (HIPed alumina)
any alumina
no
any alumina
Biolox forte (alumina)
no
Y-TZ P zirconia
PE-UHM W
yes
Y-TZ P zirconia
alumina
no
desastrous wear
Y-TZ P zirconia
Y-TZ P zirconia
no
desastrous wear
} } }
see comment on next page
Oxide Ceramicsfor ArticulatingComponentsof Total Hip Replacements:G. Willmann 125
Table 2 shows a list of wear couples that are apporoved or not approved. It is important to draw the surgeons’s attention to the fact that only approved wear couple shall be used. Approval is a legal problem. A system or a wear couple will only be apporved if tests have been performed and if reports about good results are available. In the USA there are very strict regulations for that, in Europe the European Community passed directives for evaluationg the risk of a medical divice. Table 2 shows a list of wear couples that are apporoved or not approved. The good clinical results for the wear couple alimiina-on-alumina are only achieved if there is a gap between the head and the socket. Due to that lubrication is possible. There is some kind of standardization for the diameters of the ceramic femoral heads, but no standardization for the tolerances of the diameters. Therefore components offered by different companies shall not be combined. It may well be that due the bad tolerancesfrictionof the wear couple may be too high. If a surgeon combines a not approved wear couple he will be responsible for quality assurance. That is law in most countries. The advice has to be: NEVER MIX AND MATCH. RELIABILIT Y The regulations of the American Food and Drug Adminisatration and the directives of the European Community state that a medical device shall be safe, i. e. the risk due tofracturehas to be minimized. Ceramics are brittle and the probabilty of failure may be higher than for metal components. Today’s ceramic heads and cup inserts have a very low risk of failure due to fracture. Statistics prove that thefrtacturerate is in the oerder of 0.01 % [1,13]. The revision rate due to failiu-e of a ceramic compomnent is much lower than the one for septic or aseptic loosening, see table 3. This result is based on more than 1.5 million Biolox heads. To improve reliabilty in THR modem alumina is hot isostatic pressed (HIP) to maximize density and to minimize the grain size of the mircostructure to below 2 ^un. Both materials properties are correlated to mechanical strength. Heads and cups are laser marked to eliminate critical flaws. Using a 100 % proof - test only heads and cups that withstand fracture loads far above maximum physilogical loads which is in the order of 6 to 8 times body weight [14]. Table 3:
Revision rate in THR
Revision rate
due to
to 10 %
aseptic loosening
about 1 %
septic loosening
0.02 %
fracture
of a ceramic component
126
Bioceramics Volume10
Figure 1.
Modular designed hip system with the option to use metal-on-polyethylene , alumina-on-polyethyne , zirconia-on-polyethylene , and alumina-on-alumin a
FUTUR E TREND S For systems in total hip replacemen t the future trend is then wear couple hard / hard [6,7]. Modem hip systems are designed ikn a modular way, see figure 1. By using the concept of cup inserts the surgeon has the option to use either a cup insert of PE-UHM W or an alumina cup insert for metal-backe d sockets. REFERENCE S 1. Clarke, I., G. Willmann in: Cameron, H .U .(ed.) BoneImplant Interface (1994) 203 - 252 2. Henssge, E .J., I. Bos, ans G. Willmann J. Mat. Sci.Mat. Medicine 1994 5. 57 - 661 3 Willmann, G.,H. J. Friih, and H. G. Pfaff Biomaterials 1996 17. 2157 - 2162 4 Friih, H. J., G. Willmann, H. G. Pfaff Biomaterials 1997 18. (in press) 5 Friih, H.-J., G. Willmann Biomaterials (in press) 6. Puhl. W. (ed.) Die Gleitpaarung BIOLOXinderHuftendoprothetik Enke Verlag (1996) 7. Puhl, W. (ed) Performace of theWearCoupleBIOLOXforte in TotalHip Arthroplasty Enke Verlag (1997) 8. Willmann, G. Biomed. Technik 1997 42. (in press) 9. Weber, B. G., Th. Fiechter Orthopadie 1989 18. 370 - 376 10. Zichner, L. P., H.-G. Willert Clin: Orthop: Rel:Res 1992 282. 86 - 94 11 Th. Lindenfeld Der Orthopade 1997 (in press) 12. Oonishi, H., M . Ueno, H. Okimatsu, and H. in: Kokubo, T., T. Nakamura, F. Miyaji (eds.) Bioceramics 9 (1996) 503 - 506 13. Willmann, G. Mat. wiss. Werkstofflechni k 1996 27. 280 -286 14. Richter, H. G. and G. EWillmann in [6] 77 - 83
Bioceramics, Volume 10 Edited by L. Sedel and C. Rey (Proceedings of the10thInternational Symposium on Ceramics in Medicine, Paris,France,October1997) '1997 Elsevier Science Ltd
EX VIV O AND IN VITR O ANALYSI S OF THE ALUMINA/ALUMIN SYSTE M FOR HEP JOIN T PROSTHESE S
A BEARIN G
HJ. Refior*, W. Plitz**, A. Walter** *Orthopadische Klinik, Klinikum GroBhadern, MarchioninistraBe 15, D-81377 Munchen **Labor fur Biomechanik und Experimentelle Orthopadie, Klinikum GroBhadern, MarchioninistraBe 23, D-81377 Munchen
ABSTRAC T The increased awareness of polyethylene debris as one of the main reasons causing osteolysis around implants raised the expectation of a renaissance of the ceramic/ceramic bearing system. Simulator tests result in linear wear rates below 1 ^m per million cycles and per component corresponding to a gravimetrical wear estimation of less than 1 mg per million cycles for a current alumina quality. These improved alumina materials show an advantage for linear wear of factor 5 at minimum compared with quality levels ten years ago. Contrary to simulations, collections of up to date more than 50 retrieved alumina/alumina implants have shown that linear wear rate frequency maxima exceed by 2 orders of magnitude those couples which were not exposed to loosening artifacts. The wear rate probability is not normally distributed and arithmetic means do not seem adequate to describe or compare invitro and ex-vitro results. KEYWORD S Tribology, hip joint replacement, ceramics INTRODUCTIO N Endoprosthetic loosening is increasingly considered to be the consequence of wear dependent osteolysis in the anchorage area of the implant, even though there are less secured findings about the biologic effects of the characteristics of wear particles. This is obviously valid for ceramic/ceramic couplings, too. Considering the increasing knowledge \vith regard to wear problems of polyethylene components a renaissance of the hard selfpaired s}’Stem was announced at the beginning of the nineties. In this respect there may be pointed out that chemical reactions are not to be expected in case of pure alumina contrary to the reaction products of metals. MATERIA L Subject of the investigations were 54 revised as well as 11 brand-new alumina/alumina implants (Table 1). The alumina quality of the presented revised ceramic couplings varies according to the state of the art in the deliver}^ year as well as the different manufacturers. The minimal quality requirements are to be found in the 1981 edition of the International Standard 6474. In the course of a revison of this International Standard the upper limit for the avarage grain size was reduced from 7 ^m to 4.5 ^im (ISO 6474 2nd edition). 127
128
Bioceramics Volume10
Table 1:
Material, density and average grain size Number [n] 54
Dcnsitiy fg/cm^l 3.86-3.97
Revision samples 1997-1991 (different manufacturers) Rosenthal, Feldmiihle/Cerasiv, Ceraver 1 Simulator Specimens 1986 3.94 - 3.96 9 (Biolox I, Feldmiihle) 1 Simulator Specimens 1996 3.98* 2 1 (Biolox forte, CeramTec) * typical value according to the manufacturer (CeramTec)
Mean Grain Size 1 fum] 2.2 - 16.4 1 4.1-4.9 1.8*
The material and design quality of 9 brand-new ceramic components were tested in the hip joint simulator corresponded to the state of the art of the year 1986. The grain sizes were at the maximum limit of the actual standard. For the sake of comparison two further tests were performed under identical test conditions using ceramic couplings recently manufactured (Biolox forte, CeramTec). By means of hot isostatic pressing after sintering it is possible to achieve a lower avarage grain size while improving density and strength at the same time. Presenting a mean grain size of 1.8 fim and a densitiy of 3.98 g/cm^ the new material greatly exceeds the standard requirements, METHOD S The tribologic tests (Table 2) were performed in a hip joint simulator type Miinchen I. The three axial movements are controled electronic-hydraulically within mechanically defined limits so that certain contact positions of the gliding components are not permanently exact reprocduced. The stress pattern with its PAUL type double peak simulating normal walking deserves rather critical consideration according to recent results of telemetering total hip prostheses. This fact does also refer to the use of distilled water as lubricant, since compared to solutions of bovine serum and physiological salt it may represent a more severe condition for degradation of polluted ceramics due to the corresponding metals. A turntable device (Taylor-Hobson TR-30 PC) was used for profilometric wear quantification of simulator specimens as well as retrieved samples. These linear wear data of the simulator specimens were completed with planimetry (MOP AM02) of abrasion areas that seemed to be macroscopically roughened and with gravimetric measurements (Sartorius Balance 1712 MP8). In the case of retrieved objects mean grain size (SEM) and chemical structure (AAS) was analyzed where the X-ray documentation refering to positioning or migration of the prosthetic component respectively made it possible. Table 2: Test conditions in the hip joint simulator type Miinchen I Movement: Loading:
Frequency: Lubrication Temperature:
3-axial (frontal 12 / sagittal 45 / transversal 14 ) double peak 1. Maximum 2500 N 2. Maximum 3000 N Preload 300 N 0.9 Hz aqua dest. 37 – 2 C
Analysis of the Alumina/AluminaBearing Systemfor Hip Joint Prostheses:HJ. Refior et al.
129
SIMULATO R RESULT S OF EARLIE R QUALIT Y CERAMIC S The abrasive character of the dominant wear mechanism is \vithout doubt at high wear rates III. Peak loads induce initial grain excavations getting between the gliding surfaces and may cause avalanche like increasing wear due to 3-body wear. From the sphericity deviations and the planimetric values of the abrasive areas before and after each test interval it is possible to estimate mathematically a wear volume. In case of small abrasive quantities this volume calculated from dimensional data is up to 90 % below the volume that can be estimated by means of weight loss measurements. One cause coming into question is the general insuflFiciency of the profilometric assessment method to register concentric form changes if wear mechanisms result in a regular material loss as shown for relief polishing documented in SEM investigations. Such large area wear with maximum depth of fractions of micrometers was neither profilometrically reliably to register nor macroscopically detectable. Nevertheless, gravimetric control measurements showed at these relief polishing phenomena a wear rate up to 1.5 mg per million cycles. Contrary to a simulator test under normal test conditions wear may increase more than hundredfold in case of a singular harsh repositioning even without simulation of subluxation. On the other hand, a high angle positioning of the cup from 45 to 55 causes a wear increase rate of only 25 to 65 per cent. Overcritical sphericity deviations 111 do obviously have a much greater influence on wear rates increase than such a suboptimal inclination angle. The effects of the above mentioned conditions for peak loads may superimpose additively or multiplicatively and should be used for the interpretation of clinical wear phenomena. At present, due to the lack of a consistent testing concept, it is impossible to present a quantitative estimation of loosening dependent wear for explants that were revised because of loosening mainly. Nevertheless, laboratory tests may serve as guiding data and for 9 specimens they provide an avarage wear rate for alumina selfpaired couplings of 3.8 and 1.9 micrometers per million cycle for the ball and cup component respectively. But for the explanation of sometimes contradictory wear values of revision objects the conclusion seems much more improtant that with an increasing number of cycles wear rates are not constant but they descent down to the limits of the available measuring device. SIMULATO R RESULT S FOR OPTIMIZE D ALUMIN A Compared to Biolox I the selfpaired Biolox forte presents a determined measurable improvement of linear wear by factor 5 and if taking considering different error possibilities by a factor over 10 /3/. The maximum measurable linear wear of a single component was at 0.9 [im per million cycle in the run-in phase, whereas after the second and third million of cycles no change could be registered any more by profilometry. Weight loss estimations resulted in a maximum wear volume of 0.2 mm^ for both components. Abrasion is the predominant wear mechanism again but contrary to the grain excavations of the earlier materials it is characterized by primarily transcristalline abrasion. RESULT S OF THE RETRIEVE D OBJECT S The collection of retrieved objects comprises 54 couplings of different design and an implantation time between 3 months and 13 years. The components were manufactured between the years 1975 and 1991. The wear rates that were established profilometrically range from 30 nm to 3.7 mm per year with a maximum frequency most appropiately described with the geometric mean value of 3.1 micrometer per year. The adequate arithmetic mean value in case of normal distribution would result here in a value of more than 120 micrometer per year and is influenced drastically by few high maximum values of the left inclined distribution. The largest group of the same design were the ceramic/ceramic couplings with a design after Mittelmeier. It comprised the component with 3.7 mm maximum wear in the cup rim noticed already in laboratory tests. It presented sharp-edged unpolished reliefs by means of which the potential contact areas of the bearing components are essentially reduced at small deviations of inclination angles of the cup from an ideal
130
Bioceramics Volume10
Table 3:
Range of estimated linear wear rates per component based on the changes of the sphericity deviations number
1 Revision samples 1997 -1991 (different manufacturers) Rosenthal, Feldmuhle/Cerasiv, Ceraver 1 Simulator Specimens 1986 (Biolox I, Feldmuhle) 1 Simulator Specimens 1996 1 (Biolox forte, CeramTec)
54
minimum
maximum
fjim]
0.03
3.7 X 10^
9
0.1
6.3
2
0.2
0.9
1
position. Wear rates of retrieved samples with cup positions below 55 slightly decrease from about 2 to 1.5 micrometer per year, the values for higher positions show the danger of excessive wear and shorter implantation time. Of course the final wear performance is a result of multifactorial processes. But it seems remarkable that all components with wear rates below 0.5 micrometer per year present mean grain sizes of less than 4 micrometer. DISCUSSIO N An overview of the range of all estimated linear wear rates is given in Table 3 demonstrating a large scattering of the data of the mainly because of loosening retrieved explants and the comparable narrow ranges of the simulator wear data which present the estimated wear rates of a run-in phase during the first million of simulated walking cycles. One of the most frequently mentioned cause for the reserve of the users of ceramic/ceramic couplings was besides the fracture possibility the supposed material specific sensitiveness of the system to critical inclination angles of the cup. Simulator results show that a steep cup position of 10 from the ideal positioning results in a wear increase of at maximum 65 per cent, but other peak load conditions are able to generate far more wear. Steep positioned cups of ceramic/ceramic revision objects seem to show clearly higher wear rates, but the same time these wear rates are usually overlayed with loosening artifacts difficult to be estimated. An explanation might be provided by comparing the frequency distribution of wear rates from simulator tests, autoptical explants and loosened revision samples. Based on the data provided by Henssge et al. 74/ in his investigations of autoptic ceramic components there may be derived a maximum frequency below 0.1 micrometer per year and a wear rate distribution coinciding with the corresponding simulator results the maximum frequency of which corresponds to that of the revision objects. Taking into account the design-dependent wear phenomena of explants it can be concluded that the improvements of the tribological behavior found in laboratory tests for components of hot isostatic pressed alumina will present a 5 or 10 times less wear rate in vivo only in case of an adequate cup design. LITERATUR E 1. Walter, A.: On the Material and the Tribology of Alumina-Alumina Couplings for Hip » Joint Prostheses. Clin. Orthop. 282:31, 1992 2. Walter, A., Bdhmer, F.: On the geometrical shape of artificial hip joint bearings with articulation of identical materials. Implant Materials in Biofunction, Advances in Biomaterials, Elsevier, 8:143, 1988 3. Walter, A.: Investigations on the Wear Couple Biolox forte/ Biolox forte and earlier Alumina Materials, Proceedings of the 2""* CeramTec Symposion 7/8.3.1997 in press 4. Henssge, E.J., Bos, I., Willmann, G.: AI2O3 against AI2O3 combination in hip endoprostheses. Histologic investigation with semiquantitative grading of revision and autopsy cases and abrasion measures. J. Mater. Med. Sci. 5:657, 1994
Bioceramics, Volume 10 Edited by L. Sedel and C. Rey (Proceedings of the 10th InternationalSymposium on Ceramics in Medicine, Paris, France, October 1997) '1997 Elsevier Science Ltd
HYBRI D ALUMINA-ALUMIN A HI P REPLACEMENT : A SURVIVORSHI P ANALYSI S AN D RESULT S AT A MINIMA L FIV E YEA R FOLLOW-U P M. HAMADOUCHE, P. BIZOT, R.S. NIZARD, and L. SEDEL Department of Traumatology and Orthopaedic Surgery, Lariboisiere Hospital , 2 rue Ambroise Pare 75010 Paris, France Laboratoire de Recherches Orthopediques. URA CNRS 1432, Faculte de Medecine Lariboisiere-St Louis, 10 Ave de Verdun, 75010 Paris, France
ABSTRAC T The survivorship of an hybrid alumina-alumina total hip arthroplasty has been evaluated in a series of 55 patients (62 hips). A press-fit bulk alumina socket and a cemented titanium alloy stem were implanted. Bearing surfaces were a 32 mm alumina head articulating with the alumina socket. Four failures occured: 3 were reoperated for aseptic loosening of the socket and 1 for femoral head fracture. The overall survival rate at six years was 90.8% when revision was considered as failure. At a mean follow-up of 82.5 months, 95.2% hips were graded very good or good while 71.4% showed radiolucent lines around the socket. Socket fixation has to be improved. INTRODUCTIO N Since Charnley introduced metal on polyethylene (PE) total hip arthroplasty (THA) in the 1960s (1), an increasing number of papers reported on PE wear debris generating aseptic loosening and osteolysis mediated through biological reactions (2). Alumina on alumina bearing surfaces was proposed as an alternative to metal on plastic friction couple by P.Boutin in 1970 (3). Since this period, an improvement in the manufacturing process made alumina a reliable material. Until 1982 the acetabular component was always cemented using a conventional cementing technique, loosening of the acetabular cemented components (4,5,6). Loosening of the acetabular cemented components (4,5,6) was the main reason for failure. For this reason a short series of patients had a bulk alumina socket implanted with a press-fit technique (Cerapress). The aim of this study was to evaluate prospectively the survivorship of an hybrid alumina-alumina prosthesis using a press-fit cementless fixation in a limited number of patient. PATIENT S AND METHOD S From March 1982 to December 1990, 62 hybrid THAs were performed in 55 patients. The 32 mm head and socket component were made of surgical dense alumina ceramic. The femoral stem was made of anodised titanium alloy (TiA16V4). The socket was a bulk alumina cup with Inun grooves allowing bone ingrowth. Of the 55 patients, 36 were male (65.5%) and 19 female (34.5%). The average age at the time of hip replacement was 49.6 years (range 22.5 to 75.4). The average weight was 75.4 Kg (50 to 108) and height 172.5 cm (154 to 193). The right hip was operated on 25 patients and the left hip in 23, while 7 had bilateral replacement. Initial diagnosis is presented in Table 1. THA was the first surgical procedure for 43 patients while 12 had previous hip surgery procedures. All arthroplasties were performed by the senior author (L.S.) through a posterolateral 131
132
Bioceramics Volume10
approach in all cases except for one lateral approach with trochanteric osteotomy. Allograft in one patient and autograft in seven were used to reconstruct an acetabular deficiency. Table 1. Initial diagnosis Underlying disease Primary osteoarthrosis Avascular necrosis Hip dysplasia and CDH Posttraumatic 1 osteoarthrosis Ankylosing spondilitis 1 Other coxopathy
1 TOTA L
Figure 5. Bilateral THA at 3 and 11 years
Number of hips 23 21 7 5 3 3 62
% 1 37.1 33.9 11.3 8.1 4.8 4.8
100 1
Systematically, the stem was cemented using a second generation technique.The socket component was impacted in a 2 nmi under-reamed acetabular cavity (Cerapress). Clinical ratings (Merle d’Aubigne-Postel grading system PMA) were determined pre- and postoperatively (7). On the immediate post-operative and at the latest follow-up anteroposterior radiographs, several parameters were investigated on the socket side: inclination angle of the cup, evolution of radiolucent lines in six zones of the socket and vertical or horizontal migration (8). RESULT S 13 patients (14 hips) were lost to follow-up. 25 patients (28 hips) were examined and 12 patients (14 hips) were interviewed by telephone at least five years after THA (mean 82.5 months, range 59.9 to 144.7). One patient with bilateral hip replacement died two years after THA from septicaemia. At the latest follow-up, both sides were graded excellent. Four revisions were documented in this series: one for femoral head fracture and three for aseptic loosening of the socket. The femoral head fracture occured 34.8 months after THA and remained unexplained: seven days before fracture the hip was graded excellent and no radiographic changes were noticed. Revisions for aseptic loosening occurred respectively 36.3, 53.1 and 68.4 months postoperatively. The mean PMA was 14.5 (range 12 to 17). Two patients had a patent socket migration and one was operated for permanent pain. The remaining 37 patients (42 hips) had a mean preoperative PMA of 11.2 – 2.2 (3.6 for pain, 3.5 for walking ability and 4.1 for motion) Vs 17.1 – 1.8 (5.5 for pain, 5.5 fro walking ability and 5.8 for motion) posoperatively (p< .0001). No radiological modification was noticed on the femoral side. On the socket side 4 hips (9.5%) showed migration of the acetabular component but had good clinical results except for one. 25 hips out of 37 (71.4%) showed a two-zone radiolucent line or more, 6 of them being complete (5). There was no correlation between the presence of radiolucent lines and clinical results. Neither osteolysis nor bone loss was observed even in case of cup migration or aseptic loosening. The survivorship analysis was performed using revision and revision for aseptic loosening of the socket as failure . The survival rates were respectively 90.8% (82.1% - 99.5%) and 92.7% (84.7% 100.7%) at six years as shown on fig. 1 and 2. An univariate analysis was then performed on sex, age (fig.3), initial diagnosis (fig.4), previous hip surgery, position of the socket. None of these parameters did significantly influence the results.
Hybrid Alumina-AluminaHip Replacement:A SurvivorshipAnalysis: M. Hamadoucheet al. Figure 1. THA survivorship. Revision considered as failure ^99.5 %
100 p
-o
, 90.8 %
80 4
82.1 %
I
"f
I ^^^ o I
Mean Surv. 95% Inf. (Surv.) 95% Sup. (Surv.)
40 20 0
-1
0
1
1
10
1
1
20
1
1
1
1
1
r
I
1
1
30 40 50 60 Postoperative months
1
70
1
80
Figure 2. THA survivorship. Revision for aseptic loosening considered as failure. 1.007% 100
1 = ^ ^
80 i
84.7 %
T3
> 60 i Mean Surv.
^
40 i
95% Inf. (Surv.) 95% Sup. (Surv.)
20 T
0
I
I
10
I
I
20
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
30 40 50 60 Postoperative months
I\
r
70
80
Figure 3. THA survivorship. Revision for aseptic loosening considered as failure for patients older than 50 years of age and younger than 50 years of age. 100-f 80
"" ^^^
> 60 4
^
40
Mean Surv. Age< 50 years old * Mean Surv Age
50 years old
20 4 0 4 1
10
’
1 -1
20
1
30
1
1
1
1
V-|
1
I
40 50 60 70 Postoperative months
80
133
134
Bioceramies Volume 10
Figure 4. THA Survivorship. Revision for aseptic loosening considered as failure for patients with primary ostearthrosis and for patients with other initial diagnosis 95.1 % 89.8 %
100 4 801 0) C/3
> 60
* Mean Surv. Primary osteoarthrosis
0^
o c
40 4 Mean Surv. Other initial diagnosis 20 4 0 4 -| ’ I
0
10
^"i ’ I "-n ’ I
I ’ I T
20 30 40 50 60 Postoperative months
70
-
80
DISCUSSIO N AND CONCLUSIO N Alumina-alumina combination has proved to generate 4,000 times less particles than metal-PE, wear debris being considered as bioinert (3). However, cemented fixation of the socket was not reliable enough. In order to improve this situation, a cementless bulk alumina socket was used. The fracture of an alumina implant remains a matter of concern, but it must be noticed that in our experience this one was the fourth in a 17 years period on more than 1,500 alumina-alumina hip replacement. In this case of cementless cup fixation, a micromotion is probably tolerable as demonstrated by the absence of correlation between radiolucent lines and clinical data. Despite the relatively large number of failures, the overall revision rate was comparable to metal-PE combination. The absence of osteolysis could be attributed to the lack of wear debris. Nevertheless, the initial anchorage of the bulk alumina acetabular component must still be improved. REFERENCES 1. Charnley J., Springier Verlag 1979. 2. Savio J.A. Ill, Overcamp L.M. and Black J., Clin.Mater., 1994, 15, 101-147. 3. Boutin P., Christel P., Dorlot J.M., Meunier A, de Roquancourt A., Blanquaert D., Herman S. and Sedel L., J.Biomed.Med.Res., 1988, 22, 1203-1232. 4. Sedel L., Kerboull L., Christel P., Meunier A. and Witvoet J., J.Bone Joint Surg., 1990, 72-B, 658-663. 5. Nizard R.S., Sedel L., Christel P. Meunier A., Soudry M. and Witvoet J., Clin.Orthop.Rel.Res. 1992, 282, 53-63. 6. Sedel L., Nizard R.S., Kerboull L. and Witvoet J., 1994, 298, 175-183. 7. D’aubigne R.M. and Postel M., J.Bone Joint Surg., 1954, 36-A, 451. 8. DeLee J. and Charnley J., 1976, Clin.Orthop.Rel.Res., 1976, 121, 20.
Bioceramics, Volume 10 Edited by L. Sedel and C. Rey (Proceedings of the 10th InternationalSymposium on Ceramics in Medicine, Paris, France, October 1997) '1997 Elsevier Science Ltd
LO W TEMPERATUR E AGEIN G BEHAVIO R OF ZIRCONI A HIP JOIN T HEADS . J. Chevalier, J.M. Drouin, B. Cales Norton Desmarquest Fine Ceramics, ZI n l, 27025 Evreux Cedex, France
ABSTRAC T Low temperature ageing of zirconia ceramic hip joint heads (PROZYRfi, HIP) was analyzed. Transformation kinetics from 134 C down to 60 C allow an accurate prediction of ageing at body temperature : an incubation period of about 10 years followed by a slow surface transformation is expected. 25 years are required to obtain 20% monoclinic content. Wear simulations show 40% monoclinic content does not increase Polyethylene wear significantly. KEYWORD S zirconia, ageing, phase transformation, wear INTRODUCTIO N Surgical grade yttria-stabilized zirconia (Y-TZP) ceramics have been successfully introduced in orthopaedy for 12 years as hip joint heads. They present reduced polyethylene (PE) wear [1], which is one of the major concerns today in hip arthroplasty. Their mechanical properties are much better than recorded with alumina ceramics in terms of toughness and strength. This improvement in mechanical properties is related to the stress induced transformation from the tetragonal to the monoclinic phase around the cracks, conunonly known as transformation toughening [2]. Up today, about 300.000 zirconia hip joint heads have been successfully implanted, mainly in Europe and in the United States. In recent years, a surface tetragonal to monoclinic (t-m) transformation of yttria-stabilized zirconia has been recorded for so called low temperature ageing in humid atmosphere [3]. The origin of this mechanism is believed to be attributed to a reaction between water and Zr-O-Zr bonds of the ceramic [4]. This reaction has been clearly identified from 100 C to 500 C and occurs with a maximum rate at 250 C. Following these results, the long term stability of surgical grade zirconia ceramics has sometimes been questioned in the literature [5]. However, extrapolation of simple first order transformation kinetics from high temperature studies down to 37 C must be regarded with suspicion. Moreover, results of flexural strength on bending bars cannot be interpreted for hip joint heads because of the strong effect of machining on transformation kinetics [6]. It is the aim of the present paper to accurately predict the long term ageing behavior at 37 C of a surgical grade zirconia ceramic (PROZYRfi) from ageing experiments on hip joint heads between 134 C and 60 C. A first attempt is made to correlate surface transformation to wear behavior of polyethylene. 135
136
Bioceramics Volume10
MATERIAL S AND METHOD S Experiments were conducted on commercially available zirconia hip joint heads (PROZYRfi), processed from 3Y-TZP powders, sintered then hot isostatic pressed (HIPed) in order to increase their strength. The mean grain size calculated from the linear intercept method is 0.5 |im. Kinetics experiments were conducted using both steam sterilization at 134 C and 120 C and ageing in Ringer’s solution from 100 C down to 60 C, with femoral heads of different batches in order to obtain a good insight into manufacturing process. At least 3 heads of each batch were tested for each ageing temperature. Near surface monoclinic content was followed by X-ray diffraction (CuKa, penetration depth « 5 \xm).Surface transformation was also observed by means of an optical interferometer with height resolution of – 0.1 nm (X-Y resolution of 0.5 |j,m). Wear experiments were conducted on the same zirconia heads versus conunercial PE acetabular cups, coupling on a MTS hip simulator. Hip joints were submitted to physiological loading (maximum load 2500N) in a synthetic serum (Plasmionfi, Roger Bellon) containing 25g/l proteins. RESULT S AND DISCUSSIO N Figure 1 shows the monoclinic content measured by X-ray diffraction on the surface of the zirconia heads for one given batch of heads as a function of ageing in steam and in Ringer’s solution. It appears that the variation of monoclinic content versus time is perfectly described with sigmoidal curves showing that a simple first order kinetic, which was sometimes used in literature is unsuitable to fit Low Temperature Transformation (LTT) data. This also suggests that the Mehl-Avrami-Jonhson (MAJ) law [7] already used in the literature for higher temperatures by Tsubakino et al.[8], is relevant. MAJ law gives an expression of monoclinic content/versus time t on the form :
/ = l-exp-(6/) "
(1)
where n is a constant that must be determined for each zirconia ceramic and b gives the activation energy Q of the transformation mechanism by :
* = ^exp(^--^J
(2)
where T is the absolute temperature, A is a constant and R is the gas constant, n and b parameters can be deduced from a logarithmic plot of Equation 1 which defines a straight line of slope n and ordinate origin ln(b). It has been observed that n is independent of temperature and equal to 3+0.4. We must remember the MAJ equation, which was often used to describe time-transformation isotherms in alloy systems, assumes an incubation period, then nucleation and growth for n values between 3 and 4. Optical interferometer effectively revealed tm transformation proceeds by nucleation of monoclinic sites from one grain and growth to the neighboring grains after an incubation time dependent on temperature. Nucleation was detected by small isolated spots of about 1 nm height at the surface of the heads corresponding to the volume expansion caused by transformation. Growth was observed by an increase of these spots in size.
Low TemperatureAgeing Behaviour of Zirconia Hip Joint Heads: J. Chevalieret al.
137
^ CI
o
'
o o
s
1
10
100
1000
10000
time (hours) Figure (1): Kinetics of phase transformation between 60 C and 134 C The plot of ln(b) as a function of 1/RT gives a straight hne of slope Q which was found to be about 109 KJ/mol. for this zirconia. The activation energy allows the simulation of ageing at 37 C as presented on Figure (2) which takes into account the scattering from one batch to another. Slow surface transformation occurs after an incubation period of 10 years. Approximately 25 years are then required to obtain a monoclinic content of 20%. I. Thompson et al. calculated a monoclinic content of 20% after only 5 to 11 month at 37 C in another zirconia ceramic. This stresses the need to produce a well controlled microstructural/chemical composition like in the presently studied zirconia ceramic to obtain a high degree of reliability.
80 : 70 60 o 50 40 - h 30 o 20 o o 10 0-
^
^
v i ^ ^ ^ ^ ^n > ^ ^ ^ ^ ^ J^^^^^
^^^^""^
^^J^^^p^ 1
\ ^ \
10
1
15 20
\
\
25
30
\
\
35 40
\
’
45 50
time (years) Figure (2): Predicted ageing behavior at 37 C for PROZYRfi heads.
138
Bioceramics Volume10
Wear of UHMWPE is one of the main issues in hip arthroplasty. The question that can be risen is the effect of surface transformation on wear behavior of zirconia femoral heads against polyethylene cups. To answer the question a first series of tests was conducted on heads artificially aged or not against commercial PE cups. Results are summarized in table I for 4 different monoclinic contents, in terms of PE weight loss after 5 millions cycles and monoclinic content after testing. Table I shows no significant effect of transformation on PE weight loss, even for 40% monoclinic content. On the other hand, wear has no effect on surface transformation because monoclinic content is the same before and after wear tests. Wear rates measured in this study (0.6 to 1.10 mg / million cycle) are low when compared to the limited number of publications dealing with zirconia - UHMWPE pairing [1,9]. Indeed, McKellop [1] and Saikko [9] found a wear rate of 10 mg / million cycle in bovine serum and 0.4 to 7.1 mg / million cycle in Ringer’s solution respectively. This stresses the effect of lubricant conditions (in particular protein content) and of the quality of initial surface finish (2 or 3 nm for these zirconia heads) on wear. This preliminary study should be continued up to 10 millions cycles and completed by a microstructural analysis of both heads and cups. Also the influence of the media on wear results must be understood in order to propose relevant lubricant conditions. 1
1
monoclinic content (%) before wear experiment
monoclinic content after 5 millions cycles
< 2% < 2% 30 %
< 2% < 2% 30% 40%
40%
Polyethylene weight loss (+ I mg)
5mg 3mg 4mg 3mg
1 1 1 1
Table I: Wear results after 5 millions cycles. CONCLUSIO N Low Temperature Transformation of commercially available zirconia hip joint heads is investigated in a large range of temperatures. The activation energy is calculated with a good accuracy, leading to a prediction of ageing at 37 C. A slow surface transformation can be recorded after an incubation period of 10 years in body situation. A first series of wear tests on a hip joint simulator suggests surface tetragonal to monoclinic transformation doe not increase wear significantly up to a level of 30 to 40 % monoclinic content which corresponds to 25 to 35 years at 37 C. This kinetic study cannot be extended to other zirconia ceramics and specific characterization of one given zirconia is highly recommended. REFERENCES Mc Kellop H., Lu B., Benya P., Park S.H., OrthopaedicResearchSociety,1992, paper n 402. Gupta T.K., Lange F.F., Bechtold J.H, J. materialsScience,1978, 13, 1464-1470. Kobayashi K., Kuwajima H., Masaki T., SolidStateIonics,1981, 3/4, 489. Sato T., Shimada M, J. Am. Ceram. Soc, 1985, 68, 356. Thompson I., Rawlings R.D., Biomaterial,1990, 11, 505-508. Lilley E., ceramictransactions,1990, 10, 387-406. Christian J.W., The theory of transformations in metals and alloys, Pergamon Press, 471 p. Tsubakino H., Sonoda K., Nozato R., J. MaterialsScienceLetters,1993, 12, 196.
Bioceramies, Volume 10 Edited by L. Sedel and C. Rey (Proeeedings of the 10th InternationalSymposium on Ceramics in Medicine, Paris, France, October 1997) '1997 Elsevier Science Ltd
CHARACTERIZATIO N OF ZIRCONI A COATE D BY BIOACTIV E GLASS : PRELIMINAR Y OBSERVATION S M. Bosetti^, M. Santin^, M. Mazzocchi*, A. Krajewski*, M. Rastellino’^, A. Ravaglioli* and M. Cannas’^ ’^Department of Medical Sciences, Human Anatomy, University of Torino, 28100 Novara, Italy Institute for Technological Research on Ceramics, (IRTEC), CNR Faenza, Italy ABSTRACT The cell/biomaterial interface is one of thefimdamentalaspects that should be studied to evaluate the biocompatibility of a new implantable material. Cell attachment and orientation in vitrodepends on mechanical and physico-chemical characteristic of the biomaterial, influenced particularly by protein adsorption to the material itself This abstract reports observations on serum protein adsorption, growth and adhesion of fibroblasts on Zirconia covered surfaces by two different phosphate vitreous substances (differing for Tantalium and Lantanium presence). The pattern of adsorption of serum proteins onto Zirconia surfaces was characterized by an increased presence of proteins in the molecular weight range of 20-90 kDa thus permitting to conferm that bioactive glass coating led to a drastic increase of adsorbed proteins. Cell cultures has defined an accettable biocompatibility with a significantly greater cell growth on AP40 and RKKP coated materials than on uncoated Zirconia. In conclusion, these coatings permit the combination of the mechanical qualities of Zirconia (elsewhere demonstrated), which is not very biocompatible, with the properties of new ceramics which are not mechanically resistant, but biocompatible. KEYWORD S Zirconia; in-vitro biocompatibility; glass coating INTRODUCTIO N Biomaterials for bone implants can be subdivided into four categories according to their relative surface reactivity with surrounding tissue: (1) toxic when tissue dies, (2) non› toxic, biologically inactive when tissue forms a non-adherent fibrous capsule around the implant, (3) non-toxic, bioactive when tissue forms an interfacial bond with the implant, (4) non-toxic, dissolution of the implant when tissue replaces implant. To combine the mechanical properties of a high-strength inert ceramic with the specific properties of bioactive materials a composite was suggested based on Zirconia [1] as a support and biological glasses as coating. An optimized thermal treatment process was carefully developed to coat Zirconia substrates by amorphous or glass-ceramic AP40 and RKKP. The preparation of the coatings consisted in covering the Zirconia substrate by a 139
140
Bioceramies Volume10
slip (binders and water), then heating them at temperatures slightly above the melting, obtaining 100-200 mm thick layers [2, 3]. We studied two coatings, differing for Tantalium and Lantanium presence, and evaluated their in vitro protein adsorption and cytocompatibility, taking Zirconia as reference material. MATERIAL S AND METHOD S Zirconia substrates (d « 6.00–0.05 g cm"^ , corresponding to a relative density of 98.5%– 0.05 in respect to the theoretical one) sintered at IRTEC-CNR Faenza, Italy, and obtained by 3% Y203-stabilized Zirconium oxide powders, with an average grain size of about 1 mm diameter, was used As coating materials two bioactive glasses were used: AP 40: 44.30 Si02 / 24.50 h-C^^^^^h’ ^^-^^ CaO / 4.60 Na20 / 0.19 K2O / 2.82 MgO/4.99CaF2. RKKP: 43.82 Si02 / 24.23 b-Ca3(P04)2 /18.40 CaO / 4.55 Na20 / 0.19 K2O / 2.79 MgO / 4.94 CaF2 / 0.99 Ta205 / 0.09 La203. We underline that the few % of Ta205 and La203 was added to enhance the osteoproductivity. The bioactive glass-ceramic were prepared by melting of the starting products in a platinum crucible at 1450 C in a laboratory Kiln for 2 hours. The melted glasses were normally quenched into cold water or poured on preheated graphite moulds to obtain bars. The coarse granulated glasses were powdered by an Alumina vibratory ball mill and sieved up to a granulometry less than 100 mm; they were utilized at average granulometries of 40 mm (RKKP) and 100 mm (AP40). Each coating was characterized by optical and scanning electron microscopy, compositional analysis and characterized by X ray dififractometry in order to stucfy the microstructure. The adhesion of the coatings on Zirconia was tested by Vickers Indentation Method at the coating/Zirconia interface [4]. The bioactivity of glasses and glass-ceramics, both as coating and as bulk, was evaluated and compared by examining serum protein adsorption and growth and adhesion of fibroblasts on the materials. Squares of biomaterials were incubated with serum for Ihoiu* at room temperature. After removal of serum, squares were washed four times in phosphate buffer saline. The squares were then cut in pieces, trasfered into Eppendorf tubes and incubated at 90 C for 10 min in a 2% (w/v) SDS. Samples were analysed by SDS-PAGE according to the method of Laemmli [5] and the gel stained with a Silver Stain kit (BioRad). For adhesion and proliferation tests, humanfibroblasts(MRC5) were added to the luminal surfece at 5x10^ cell/cm^. After 2 hours of cell adhesion the culture media has been added in each 1.5 cm diameter well in a 24 microplate well. Adhesion test was performed after 6h culture time while proliferation test after 5 days culture. The materials, were rinsed in PBS,fixed20 min at 60 C and stained 5 minutes in a 0.025% Acridine Orange solution, a nucleic acid staining [6]. Cell mmiber on each material, was counted using a fluorescent microscope. Statistical analysis of the data was carried out using a Etell computer equipped with SPSS for Windows software. Duncan test was performed to compare, adhesion and proliferation
Characterizationof Zirconia Coated Bioactive Glass: M. Bosettiet al.
141
results for the four materials tested ; p value was obtained from the ANOV A table. The conventiona l 0.05 level was considere d to reflect statistica l significance . RESULT S AND DISCUSSIO N Studies of serum protein adsorption allowed to give clues about the formation of a conditioning layer on the material surfaces. The electrophoreti c patterns of the serum protein desorbed from the surfaces clearly showed an increase d protein binding after coating of the Zirconia with AP40 and with RKK P (Figure 1). No significant difierenc e was observed concernin g fibroblastattachmen t on to the three substrates studied: Zirconia, AP40 coated Zirconia and RKK P coated Zirconia (Figure 2). Fibroblast proliferatio n (Figure 2) showed a significantly greater cell growth on AP40 and RKK P coated Zirconia than on uncoate d control; no statistica l difference s were seen betwee n the two coated materials. The appearance of MRC 5 fibroblasts stained with acridine orange, after 6 days growth on bioactive glass coated Zirconia, evidence d a higher cell spread with a cell isles organization , characteristi c of new tissue formation. The results obtained in this paper seems to indicate that the coating of Zirconia either with AP40 or with RKK P may enhance the interaction s of the surfaces with biological component s thus favouring the integration of the prosthesis in the damaged tissue. In conclusion, these coatings permit the combination of the mechanica l qualities of Zirconia, which is not very biocompatible , with the propertie s of new ceramics which are not . mechanicall y resistant, but biocompatible
KDa
51.6
Figure 1: SDS-PAG E of proteins desorbed from material surfaces conditione d by serum. Lane 1: molecular weight standards; Lane 2: 1:25 diluted human serum; Lane 3: Zirconia; Lane 4: AP40; Lane 5: RKK P (for details see Materials and Methods).
142
Bioceramies Volume10
25
iSproliferation
MMM
ladheston
20
Zirconia Materials Zirconia AP40 RKKP
AP40 Proliferation 15,16*3,40 20,9318,01* 23,4117,50*
RKKP Adhesion 12,11*4,88 11,1215,64 10,00 s 4,88
*p<0.05 Figure 2: Human fibroblasts (MRC5) adhesion and proliferation results. Cell number referred to a 0.17 mm^ surface respectively after 6 hours and 5 days culture.
REFERENCES 1. Hulbert S.F., In: "An introductionto Bioceramics" Advances series in Ceramicsyolumc1, World Sc. Publ. Co. Ed. by L.L.Hench and J.Wilson, 1993, 25-29. 2. Berger G., Gildenhaar R., In: "Ten years of clinical experience"4thWorld BiomaterialsCongress,Apr., 24-28, 1992, Berlin, RFD, 33-35. 3. Ferraris M., Verne E., Moisescu C, Ravaglioli A., Krajewski A, In: Proceedingsof the 3rdMeetingandSeminaron Ceramics, Cells and Tissues,May, 2-4, 1996, Faenza Ed Italy. 4. Ferraris M., Verne E., Appennino P., Moisescu C, Krajewski A, Ravaglioli A, Proposed for prints in J. ^w. Cer. Soc. Bull. (1997). 5. Laemmli U. K., Nature1970, 227, 680. 6. Kirkpatrick C I , Dekker A, Biomat.TissueInterface1992,10, 31-41.
Bioceramics, Volume 10 Edited by L. Sedel and C. Rey (Proceedings of the 10th InternationalSymposium on Ceramics in Medicine, Paris, France, October 1997) '1997 Elsevier Science Ltd
CALCIU M PHOSPHAT E PARTICLE S AR E FOUN D AT THE POLYETHYLEN E INSER T SURFAC E WHETHE R IMPLANTE D WIT H HA-COATE D DEVICE S OR NOT . A SEM-EPM A STUDY . Patrick Frayssinet*^, Laurent Gineste^, G. Bonel*, N. Rouquet* * Bioland, 132 Rte d’Espagne, 31100 Toulouse, France. See de Biologie Buccale, Ecole Dentaire, Universite Paul Sabatier, Toulouse ^ Laboratoire du Tissu Osseux et des Pathologies Osteo-articulaires, Universite Paul Sabatier, 31100 Toulouse, France. ABSTRAC T Calcium phosphate debris have been searched using SEM-EPMA at the surface of several polyethylene cups whether implanted with HA-coated devices or not. It appeared that calcium phosphate particles which had characteristics suggesting that they were not from artifact origin were found at the surface of the most of cups. Several hypothesis can explain the presence of these particles at the polyethylene surface. INTRODUCTIO N Polyethylene debris have proved to be responsible for dramatic osteolytic processes leading to aseptic prosthesis loosening. Third body wear, due to the presence of metal or ceramic particles at the polyethylene surface, has been suspected in many cases. Bloebaum et al. (1) reported the presence of calcium phosphate particles at the surface of polyethylene hip inserts which had been implanted with HA-coated metal backs or HA-coated hip stems. He suggested that HA-particles from the coating had migrated to the articulating surface causing the release of UHMWPE particles, hence a foreign body reaction. We examined the surface of several polyethylene hip implants with scanning electron microscopy (SEM) coupled to energy dispersive spectroscopy (EDS) microanalysis in order to detect any calcium phosphate particle surface contamination. The UHMWPE implants were implanted with either HA-coated or non-coated devices and for various periods of time. MATERIAL S AND METHOD S Twelve different inserts were obtained during revision or autopsy. None of these inserts were retrieved for an abnormal wear but for a reason concerning the stem. The inserts examined were not selected to appear in this series which explains its heterogeneity. The characteristics of the implants are given in table 1. Different methods were used to prepare the UHMWP surface for SEM observation in order to avoid contamination or calcium phosphate precipitation on the surface after retrieval. The surface was not handled by the surgeon during retrieval and was first gently washed in an isotonic solution of NaCl. Upon arrival in the laboratory, each insert was immersed in a 1.5% solution of sodium hypochlorite for 24 hours to remove all organic remnants on the polyethylene surface. It was then washed with demineralized water. Once processed, the inserts were then divided into three groups based on the implant depth. Each was treated differently. Group 1 : The surface of the implant was gold palladium coated for direct observation by SEM at 15kV; Group 2 : An epoxy polymer was molded in the cup and the polymer 143
Bioceramies Volume10
144
detache d from the cup surface once polymerizatio n had taken place to make a print of the cup surface. This was then gold-palladium coated and observed by SEM ; Group 3 : An epoxy polymer was cast in the cup as described . The cup was then cut in half and the epoxy polymer detache d from the surface. The cupfragmentswere then gold-palladium coated and observed by SEM . Abrasion wear was characterize d by the presence of scratches , adherenc e wear by the presence of wrenche d polymer sheet and fatigue wear by the presence of small cracks. Table 1: characteristic s of the samples examine d implant number "^’ 1
granuloma
HA-coated device ""Ye r
femoral head
group 2
implantation time 0.5 year
group 3
1 year
Stainless steel
0
Yes
group 3
2 years
Stainless steel
0
Yes
group 3
3 years
Stainless steel
0
Yes
yes
group 1
2 years
0
No
yes
group 1
3 years
0
No
no
group 1
11 years
0
No
unknown unknown
no no
group 1 group 1
2 months 5 years
yes yes
No No
10
unknown
no
group 1
15 years
yes
No
11 12
unknown unknown
no no
group 1 group 1
12 years 6 years
Stainless steel Stainless steel Cobaltchromium alumina stainless steel Cobaltchromium Alumina stainless steel
yes yes
No no
metal back
7
type of acetabula r wmponent biarticulate d (Zimmer, Swindon, UK ) biarticulate d (Zmimer, Swindon, UK ) biarticulate d (Zimmer, Swindon, UK ) biarticulate d (Zimmer, Swindon, UK ) Harris (Zimmer, France) Harris (Zimmer, France) unknown
8 9
2 3 4 5 6
process
Stainless steel
’
Q
RESULT S Implant n l: Scratches were found at the surface of the insert base with much debris inside these scratches and their vicinity. ED S reveale d that these particles were made of iron-chromium-nickel , titanium-aluminu m or calcium phosphates . The debris were less than SOfim in size. Implant n^2: debris were rare at the implant surface. Calcium phosphate particles were found on one polymer fragment only. However, there were numerous particles of stainless steel (ironchromium-nickel ) and titanium alloy. Scratches were found on the base of the insert. There was a pollution by silicon products. Implant n 3: iron-chromium-nicke l particles were found at the surface of every polyethylen e part. Some titanium alloy particles were also found. Pollution caused by silicium products disseminate d at the polymer surface of one part was observed . Small cracks were observed at the polymer surface. Implant n 4: No scratch was found on the implant surface, however , some poljmier sheets detache d from the material were found. A cluster of calcium phosphate s and iron-chromium-nicke l debris was apparent.
Calcium PhosphateParticles are Found at the PolyethyleneInserts Surface: P. Frayssinetet al.
145
Implants VL’S and 6: No scratch was found on the implant surface. Sodium chloride and calcium phosphates were found on the implant surface. Implant n 7: A lot of particles consisting of Ca, P, O, Na, CI, Si and Mg were found at the implant surface. These particles were of fluffy appearance and less than 60 ^im in size. Implant n 8: A few particles composed of Ca, P and O, of porous aspect were found at the polymer surface located close to the edge of the acetabular cup where scratches were visible. Other much more numerous particles consisted of aluminum oxide compound containing traces of titanium. These particles were smaller than 20 \xm. Implant n 9: no particles were found in the observed region. Implant n 10: A lot of particles composed of Ca, P and O were found encrusted in the polymer surface. Their surface was flattened and they were fragmented. Implant n ll: small fragments of a compound made of Ca, P and O formed encrusted clusters of particles in the polyethylene surface. Other particles consisted of Ca and O. Na and CI were sometimes found associated with the Ca-P-0 particles. Implant n 12: Particles composed of Ca, P and O were found encrusted within the polyethylene surface, particularly m the scratched region. Calcium oxide and Fe particles were also found. All such particles had a flattened surface and were fragmented (fig. 1). Figure 1 : SEM photograph (a) and EDS (b) of a flattened particle encrusted in the surface of the implant n 12 showing that the particle was made of Ca, P and O.
DISCUSSIO N AN D CONCLUSIO N This study showed that the presence of many particles having different origins can be found at the UHMWP inserts surface. We have found calcium phosphate particles at the surface of every kind of polyethylene inserts whether they,were implanted with HA-coatings or not. We were not able to show if these particles were constituted of one or several calcium phosphate phases and what is the
146 Bioceramies Volume 10
Ca/P ratio of these materials. The reason for this is that the use of a standardles s EPM A (electro n probe microanalysis ) technique without some independen t confirmatio n of the compositio n in test specimen s can lead to very large errors, which may go unrecognize d (2). Several origins may be attributed to the calcium phosphate particles found at the polyethylen e surface : a particle contaminatio n before the implantation , particularly during the manufacturin g processes , or after the implantation at the retrieval or during the specime n preparation. a debris migrationfrombone tissue. a secondary nucleatio n at a foreign body surface in a supersature d liquid in calcium and phosphorus. d by the ED S analysis, and the absence of collagen The absence of carbon in these particles assesse traces (3) in material make the bone debris origin very unprobable. The presence of NaCl crystals or silicated compounds at the surface of some implants in our series shows that the control of surface contaminatio n is a critical step in the qualitative electro n microscopy analysis. NaCl crystals are undoubtedl y formed during the surface drying step and some Si compounds may be brought in on the surgeon gloves or during sectionin g of an implant even with a protecte d surface. However, the presence of calcium phosphate particles encruste d in the polymer surface is in favor of the presence of these particles before the retrieval. Calcification of syntheti c or natural polymers once implanted in human or animal bodies is very well documented . Vascular devices , breast implants, collagen based materials very often show calcificatio n that may be visible on radiographs. Serum and extracellula r fluids are solutions supersaturate d in calcium and phosphorus. Furthermore , Radder et al (4) demonstrate d that copolymers rich in polyethylen e oxide were associate d with rapid and abundant calcification . It is therefore not surprising that heterogeneou s nucleatio n can take place at the polyethylen e surface once it is in contact with such a medium. We can suppose that the polyethylen e surface would provide a good seed material for heterogeneou s crystallizatio n of calcium phosphate , specially in the zone where the polyethylen e surface presents molecular periodicit y or in the cracks and crevices . Furthermore , the fragmentation of calcium phosphate s at the surface of the cups, creates nuclei for secondary nucleatio n (5, 6). REFERENCE S 1. Bloebaum, R.D., Beeks, D., Dorr, L.D., Savory, C.G., DuPont, J.A., Hoffmann, A.A., Complications with hydroxyapatit e particulate separation in total hip arthroplasty. Clin Orthop, 1994, 298: 19-26. 2. Goldstein, J.I., Newbury, D.E., Echlm, P., Joy, D.C., Romig, Jr, A.D., Lyman, C.E., Fiori, C , Lifshin, E., Quantitative X-ray analysis: theory and practice. In: Scanning Electron Microscopy and X-Ra y Microanalysis. A Text for Biologists, Materials Scientists , and Geologists. Second Edition. Plenum Press. New York and London 1992. 3. Reid, S.A., Micromorphological characterizatio n of normal human bone surfaces as afimctionof age. Scanning Microscopy 1, 1987: 579-59 7 4. Radder, A.M., Davies, J.E., Sodhi, R.N.S., van der Meer, S.A.T., Wolke, J.G.C., van Blitterswijk, C.A., Post-operativ e carbonate-apatit e formation in PEO/PBT copolymers (Polyactivefi) . Cells and Materials 1995, 5: 55-62. 5. Mersmann, A., Kind, M., Chemical engineerin g aspects of precipitatio n from solution. Chem Eng Technol 1988, 11:264-276 . 6. Mullin, J.W., Heterogeneou s nucleation . Crystallization, 3. ed, Butterworth, London 1985: pp 182-185 ,
Bioceramies, Volume 10 Edited by L. Sedel and C. Rey (Proeeedings of the 10th InternationalSymposium on Ceramics in Medicine, Paris, France, October 1997) '1997 Elsevier Science Ltd
BON E REMODELLIN G AROUN D LOAD-BEARIN G CONDITION S
IMPLANTE D
MATERIAL S
UNDE R
M. Oka, Y.S.Chang, S. Yura, K. Ushio *, J. Toguchida, T. Nakamura * Department of Artificial skeletal systems, Research Center for Biomedical Engineering, * Dept. of Orthop. Surg., Kyoto University, 606 Kyoto, Sakyoku, Shogoin ABSTRAC T Bone formation and remodeling around implanted materials are influenced by the load-bearing conditions. In this study, three types of material were implanted into dog femoral condyles and bone formation and remodelling were observed for 24 weeks thereafter. Even thickening of lamellar bone was observed around bead-coated alumina implants, whereas thick fibrous tissue surrounded by corticalized bone formed around those made of smooth alumina. With an implant made of an artificial osteochondral composite material, thickening of ingrown trabeculae could be observed as early as 4 weeks. Bone ingrowth into the titanium fiber mesh was abundant and increased with time after implantation. This interstitial bone ingrowth resulted in the complete integration of this implant and the viable host bone. These results suggest that artificial osteochondral material is a promising material for joint replacements. KEYWORD S Bone remodelling. Artificial articular cartilage. Load-bearing condition. Bone ingrowth. Porous structure. INTRODUCTIO N Bone formation and remodeling around implanted material is influenced by the type of material, its surface properties and the anatomical site of implantation [1]. Bone formation and remodeling also depend on the loading conditions. As mechanical stress influences the remodelling process of bone and subsequently its structure and strength, in accordance with Wolffs law, materials implanted into bone should be under load-bearing conditions to elucidate interstitial bone ingrowth into the implants [2]. In this study, we compared bone formation and remodelling around solid and porous materials under load-bearing conditions. Another purpose of this study was to investigate the rate and extent of interstitial bone ingrowth into the pores of the titanium fiber mesh of an artificial osteochondral composite device, which we have developed as an artificial articular cartilage [4, 5, 6]. MATERIAL S AND METHOD S Three types of rectangular parallelepiped test pieces were used. One type of alumina test piece was manufactured into an implant with a mirror-finished articular surface and bead-coated sides; the other type was of the same size and shape with smooth side surfaces. The third type of test piece was the same shape, but manufactured ft-om pure titanium fiber with a porosity of 70% and mean pore size of 170 M ni, and the articular surfaces were 147
148
Bioceramics Volume10
shaped using the mirror-finished polyvinyl alcohol (PVA) hydrogel we have developed as an artificial articular cartilage. The composite material was made by infiltrating PVA (molecular weight, 220,000) solution into the pores of the distal half of the titanium fiber implant and then binding it to the fiber by gelling the PVA. The shear strength between the PVA hydrogel and titanium fiber was about 2.2MPa. In the control dogs, osteo-chondral defects were left open in the femoral condyles. Thirty-two mature adult mongrel dogs, weighing approximately 15-20 kg, were divided randomly into four groups of eight, which bore the implants for 4, 8, 12 and 24 weeks. All the specimens retrieved from the animals were examined using radiography, and all segments of the femur containing implants were then excised and fixed. Undecalcified sections of femur including the implants were cut and then ground into thicknesses ranging from 100 to 150 // m. Giemsa surface staining and contact microradiographic examination of the same cut section were performed. Histological changes of tibial joint surfaces, including menisci, were examined using Thionin staining. RESULT S Four weeks after the operation, thin and irregular ingrowth of newly formed immature bone into the pores of the bead-coated alumina implants was found, some of which reached the deepest layer. From 12-24 weeks after implantation, trabecular bone remodelling advanced further, producing a regular lamellar pattern. Contact microradiography (CMR) showed good fixation and uniform trabecular thickening around the bead-coated implants. (Fig. 1-A) Examination of the sections containing smooth-sided alumina showed that immature bone had also formed and surrounded the implants 4 and 8 weeks after implantation. However, 12 weeks postoperatively, a radiolucent zone surrounded by radiopaque changes around the smooth surfaced alumina at the bone-implant interface was apparent. After 24 weeks, the thickness of the fibrous layer had increased and the radiolucent zone surrounded by sclerotic bone observed on the radiographs was even more obvious. (Fig. 1-B) Abundant new bone ingrowth into the pores of the titanium fiber implant was present 4 and 8 weeks postoperatively (Fig. 2-A,B), and thereafter lamellar bone remodelling advanced further. By 24 weeks, neither demarcates nor radiolucent zones around this material were observed and, like the bead-coated alumina implant, no interposing fibrous tissue surrounding the titanium fiber mesh was present. Mature bone formed in the pores of the titanium fiber, which enabled this composite material to become attached firmly to the adjacent bone. DISCUSSIO N In order to determine the actual bone ingrowth and remodelling around the materials under conditions closer to the clinical situation, we believe the materials should be implanted under load-bearing conditions [1, 2]. Takagi et al [3]. implanted bead-coated and uncoated alumina test pieces into the load-bearing portions of the medial and lateral femoral condyles of dogs. They observed that the uncoated implants showed signs of loosening similar to those observed clinically. In contrast, bonding of the bead-coated implants was significantly stronger than that of the uncoated implants and increased with time after implantation. We used Takagi’s method and implanted three types of test piece. The results of our experiments revealed the differences between the bead-coated and smooth-surfaced alumina
Bone RemodelingAround ImplantedMaterials Under Load-Bearing Conditions:M. Oka et al.
149
implants particularly clearly. At the bone-implant interface, uniform lamellar bone thickening was observed around bead-coated alumina, whereas thick fibrous tissue surrounded by corticalized bone formed around smooth alumina. These prominent bone remodelling pattern differences might not be manifest unless the materials are implanted under load-bearing conditions. During the early postoperative stages micromotion of the implant will occur more often with the smooth-surfaced than bead-coated alumina, which may produce favorable conditions for fibrous tissue production. In the case of bead-coated alumina, however, micromotion will be prevented by the new bone formation around the beads [1]. Load-bearing conditions can be considered to be a more severe test for materials implanted in the bones than non-load-bearing conditions. Therefore, the considerable bone ingrowth into the pores of the titanium fiber mesh implant observed as early as 4 weeks after implantation, encourages us to use this material for joint replacement [2]. The reasons why we developed an artificial articular cartilage have been described in detail in our previous publications [4, 5, 6]. In short, it is necessary to preserve, as far as possible, the cancellous bones, which play an important role in the shock-absorbing effects of the joints. With respect to some of the mechanical properties of this material that are desirable for an artificial articular cartilage, such as lubricating and shock-absorbing functions, we obtained very encouraging results, which are described in detail in other papers [4, 5, 6]. The most important problem in developing an artificial articular cartilage is to fix the material quickly and firmly to the bone. With this aim, we manufactured an artificial osteo-chondral composite material composed of porous titanium fiber with PVA infiltrated into its pores. We implanted this composite material under the same loading conditions in this study as alumina implants. Excellent bone ingrowth into the pores of the titanium fiber mesh was observed 8 weeks after implantation and neither demarcated nor radiolucent zones around the implant were observed [5, 6]. As the wear-resistant properties of PVA hydrogel have been improved strikingly by gamma-ray irradiation, this composite material appears to be a very promising material for artificial joints. Furthermore, as the tibial joint surface remained intact against the artificial articular cartilage, in contrast to marked pathological changes with both types of alumina implant, PVA hydrogel is a very promising joint prosthetic material [6]. REFERENCE S 1. Chang, Y.S., Oka, M., et al., Biomat.,1996, 17, 1141-1148. 2. Oka, M., et al., Clin. Biomech.,ed. by Hirasawa, et al. Springer, Berlin, 1994, 124-137. 3. Takagi, H., Yamamuro, T., Hyakuna, K., Nakamura, T., Kotoura, Y. & Oka, M., Appl. Biomater.,1989, 23(A2), 161-181. 4. Oka, M., Noguchi, T., Kumar, P., Ikeuchi, K., Yamamuro, T., Hyon, S. H. & Ikada, Y., Clin. Mater.,1990, 6, 361-381. 5. Oka, M., Ikeuchi, K., Tsutsumi, S., Yamamuro, T., Noguchi, T. & Nakamura, T., Bomechanics in Orthopedics,ed. S. Niwa, S.M. Perren & T. Hattori, Springer, Berlin, 1992, 282-298. 6. Oka, M., Cahiers d’enseignement de la SOFCOT 57, Expansion scient, Francaise, 1996, 62-74
150
Bioceramics Volume10
Fig. 1-A: CMR of bead-coated alumina, 12 weeks after implantation. (X 10)
Fig. 2-A: New bone formation into the pores of titanium fiber, 8 weeks after operation. CMR X 10
Fig. 1-B: Bone remodeling around smooth sided alumina at 24 weeks after implantation. CMR X 10
Fig. 2-B: The artificial osteochondral composite material was integrated to the host bone, 8 weeks after operation. Giemsa surface stain X 10
CLINICAL USE OF CERAMICS
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
Bioceramics, Volume 10 Edited by L. Sedel and C. Rey (Proceedings of the 10th InternationalSymposium on Ceramics in Medicine, Paris, France, October 1997) '1997 Elsevier Science Ltd
CLINICAL COMPARATIVE STUDY BETWEEN POROUS COATED AND HYDROXYAPATITE POROUS COATED FEMORAL IMPLANTS - Retrospective matched pair study, average 5 years results Young Ho Kim,
Jeong Hwa Shon,
D Yong Choi
Department of Orthopedic Surgery, Hanyang University, Kuri Hospital, 249~1, Kyomoon-Dong, Kuri, Kyunnggi-Do, 471-020, Korea ABSTRACT Authors performed a retrospective matched-pair study for 64 uncemented total hip arthroplasty which include same number of hips with porous coated and HA porous coated femoral components using same kind of implant (Zimmer Anatomic^) to identify whether HA coat was efficient to get more favorable clinical results. Excellent function was achieved at 6 months in HA group and 1 year in porous group and mean Harris hip score maintained higher in HA group compare to porous group for whole period of follow up. Endosteal bone formation was noted mostly in zone 2, 6 in both groups and appeared earlier with larger extent and higher incidence in HA group compare to porous group. Radiolucencies were seen in zone 4 most commonly in both groups and the extent and the incidence of radiolucency were smaller and lower in HA group compare to porous group. Endosteal osteolysis were seen in 2 cases in HA group and 3 cases in porous group, and that in HA group was noted first earlier and smaller in mean size compare to that in porous group. Conclusively, HA coated implants improved and stabilized clinical and radiologic results earlier, and maintained superior results compare to porous coated implants until average 5 years follow up. INTRODUCTIO N Porous implant which was developed to use an alternative to cemented implant for young patients revealed the less than expected bone ingrowth and the more than expected fibrous ingrowth on retrieval specimens[2]. So thin HA coating was applied on the porous surface to solve the problem. But there is still debate regarding whether the use of a thin HA coating on a porous implant surface results in increase rate and amount of bone ingrowth emd such increase would result in improved clinical and radiographic performance. Dorr mentioned that there was no difference in the clinical results between HA porous coated and porous coated implants with same design[4]. But Whitecloud et al reported that early clinical and radiologic results with HA systems appeared superior to non HA coated systems with the support of animal study[6]. So we performed a retrospective matched pair clinical comparative study for 64 uncemented total hip arthroplasties which included same number of porous coated and HA porous coated femoral components to identify the efficacy of HA coating clinically. 153
154
Bioceramics Volume 10
MATERIAL S AND METHOD S The uncemented anatomic hip system(Zimmer, Warsaw, U.S.A.) with porous pad of wire mesh were used as porous coated implant and the same design femoral prosthesis with additional CALCICOT(70% HA + 30% TCP) coating implant. Our study included 32 cases respectively in both groups. Harris-Galante II acetabular components with porous coating and modular Cr-Co femoral heads of 28mm diameter were used in all patients. All the variables such as age, sex and quality of bone etc. were similarly matched and average follow up period was 61.2(48-72)months in porous coated group and 59.2(48-68)months in HA coated group. All data were assessed and analized clinically and radiographically. RESULT S Excellent function was achieved at 6 months in HA group and 1 year in porous group and mean Harris hip score maintained higher in HA group compare to porous group for whole period of follow up. Mean time of weight bearing without support since operation was 6.4 weeks in HA group and 10.1 weeks in porous group, which was statistically significant. The incidence of thigh pain was 9.4 % in HA group, which was clinically lower than that in porous group, 18.7%. Endosteal bone formation appeared mostly in zone 2, 6 in both groups and extent and incidence of endosteal bone formation were lager and higher in HA group compare to porous group. Endostead bone formation was noted first at 3 months in HA group and at 6 months in porous group. In overall view, endosteal bone formation appeared earlier with larger extent and higher incidence in HA group compare to porous group. Radiolucencies were seen in zone 4 most commonly in both groups and extent and incidence of radiolucency were smaller and lower in HA group compare to porousp group. Radiolucencies were noted first at 6 months in HA group and at 3 months in porous group. In overall view, radiolucencies were seen later with smaller extent and lower incidence in HA group compare to porous group. Cortical bone remodelling reactions were commonly seen in zone 2, 6 in HA group and in zone 3, 5 in porous group and overall incidence of them were similar in both groups. Calcar remodelling was seen earlier with higher incidence in HA group compare to porous group. Incidence of pedestal formation including stable or unstable type was lower in HA group compare to porous group. Endosteal osteolysis around stem were seen in 2 cases in HA group, which was noted first at 32.7 month on averge and 3.5cm in mean size, and in 3 cases in porous group, which ws noted first at 25.5 month on average and 6cm in mean size. Mean linear wear rate was 0.30 – 0.13mm in HA group and 0.28 – 0.15mm in porous group, which were similar in both groups. Engh’s radiologic score for fixation and stability was increasing in fixation scale, and decreasing in stability scale with time in both groups, and maintain higher in HA group compare to porous group. Definite radiographic sign of bone ingrowth was achieved at 6 months in HA group, and 1 year in porous group.
Clinical ComparativeStudy BetweenPorous Coated and HA Porous Femoral Implant: Y.H. Kim et al.
155
CAS E ILLUSTRATIO N This 51 year old female patient had total hip arthroplasty with HA porous coated anatomic stem for avascular necrosis of left femoral head. The patient could walk without difficulty in the absence of crutch since 4 weeks after operation. She had proximal femoral fracture with long spiral oblique fashion assoacted with the subsidence of stem after slip down at postoperative 6 week(Fig. 1). In retrieved stem, remained HA coating about porous surface could not be observed and more than 90% of porous surface was replaced by bone and porous pore were filled with bone mostly(Fig.2). DISCUSSIO N AN D CONCLUSION S This study shows that HA coated implants improved and stabilized clinical and radiologic results earlier compare to porous coated implants. HA group improved Harris hip score earlier and had lower incidence of thigh pain and could walk without support earlier than porous group. When we assessed the patients clinically, we felt that patient who had HA coated implants usually answer more comportable than those who had porous coated implants. These results might be due to achievement of the early initial stability of HA coated implant resulting from its early osteoconductive property. The radiographic results such as earlier appearance with larger extent and higher incidence of endosteal bone formations and later appearance with smaller extent and lower incidence of radiolucencies in HA group might also support the clinical results.
Fig. 1 Six weeks postoperative roentgenogram reveals long spiral oblique fracture of the femur from proximalportion to distal to the tip of stem.
Fig. 2. Microscopic finding of retrieved porous pad area of implant. Notes bony femoral ingrowth between fiber-mesh of titanium.
156
Bioceramics Volume10
Bone growth on to HA or porous coated stems showed endosteal bone condensation over the HA or porous coating on femoral stem followed by distal radiolucency around non-coated stem area. Distal radiolucency are probably due to micromotion between the stiff distal stem and the more elastic bone[3]. Higher incidence of distal radioluency in porous coated stems could be explained by less stability of porous coated stems resulting from less endosteal bone formation in addition to the difference of elasticity between bone and stems. Cortical remodelling probably reflected adaptive change of cortex to local stress pattern, which was regarded as evidence of good implant fixation[5]. Symmetrical cortical remodellings which was associated with extensive endosteal bone formation were appeared frequently in HA group, and asymmetrical type which was associated with increased localized intramedullary stress were appeared frequently in porous group. Mean linear wear rate of polyethylene was similar in HA and porous coated stem. This results were supported by the report in which HA coating does not increase polyethylene wear[l]. Endosteal osteolysis was appeared later and smaller size in HA group despite of similarity of mean linear wear rate in both groups. This results might be due to profuse impacted endosteal bone formation between proximal portion of femoral component and proximal portion of femoral canal functioned as banier to movement of polyethylene wear debri. Conclusively, HA coated implants improved and stabilized clinical and radiologic results earlier, and maintained superior results compare to porous coated implants until average 5 years follow up. REFERENC E 1. Bauer T.W., Taylor S.K., Jiang M. and Medendrop S.V., Clin Orthop, 1994, 298, 11. 2. Bobyn J.D., Engh C.A. and Classman A.H., Clin Orthop,1987, 224 : 303. 3. D’Antonio J.A., Apello W.N., Crothers CD., Jaffe W.L. and Manley M.T., / Bone Joint Surg, 1992, 74-A, 995. 4. Dorr L.D., / Bone Joint Surg, 1993, 75-A, 1728. 5. Geesink R.G.T. and Hoefnagels N.H.M., / Bone Joint Surg, 1995, 77-B, 534. 6. Whitecloud T.S., Cook S.D., Enis J.E., Amstrong D. and Lisecki E.J., / Bone Joint Surg, 1992, 74-B supp. HI , 252.
Bioceramics, Volume 10 Edited by L. Sedel and C. Rey (Proceedings of the 10th InternationalSymposium on Ceramics in Medicine, Paris, France, October 1997) '1997 Elsevier Science Ltd
REVISIO N RATE S AND RADIOGRAPHI C CHANGE S ASSOCIATE D WIT H DIFFEREN T SOCKE T INTERFAC E TECHNOLOGIES : CLINICA L RESULT S FRO M 456 PATIENT S AT FIV E TO EIGH T YEAR S FOLLOW-UP . M.T.Manley**, A.Edidin**, J.A.Epinette+, R.G.Geesinkt, J.A.D’Antonio*, W.N.Capello-. ** Osteonics Corp., Allendale, NJ, USA; +CRDA, Bruay la Buissiere, France; tState University of Limburg, Maastricht, Netherlands; * M, H & D Orthopaedics, Swickley, PA, USA; -Indiana University, Indianapolis, IN, USA. ABSTRAC T Over the last seven years, we have followed the clinical course of 456 total hip replacement patients all of whom received the same hydroxylapatite coated cementless femoral stem and either a control porous coated acetabular component, a press-fit hydroxylapatite coated acetabular component or a threaded, hydroxylapatite coated acetabular component. We found acetabular bone remodeling changes and implant revision rates were different for the different cup types; the hydroxylapatite coated threaded components needmg the smallest number of cup revisions for aseptic loosening (0.44%) while the press-fit hydroxylapatite coated components needing most revisions (10.2%). These rates compared with 1.0% for the porous controls. Radiographic data suggests that interface failure with the press-fit cups tended to initiate at the implant/bone interface inferior to the component where the shear and tensile stresses caused by physiologic loads are greater than elsewhere around the implant periphery. We concluded that the bond between bone and smooth hydroxylapatite coated acetabular component interfaces may be compromised by physiologic tensile stresses unless interlock between unplant and bone is achieved by threads or other features incorporated in the implant design. KEYWORD S Hydroxylapatite coatings, implant fixation, clinical resuhs. INTRODUCTIO N Clinical studies of uncemented cups at five years or more follow-up have shown failure rates from zero to about eight percent for porous implants [1-4], but as high as thirty to forty percent for other cementless designs [5-7]. Attempts to improve fixation by adding threads to the implant design have shown mixed results with early clinical failures reported [7-10] as well as good results with threaded cup designs which incorporated also a biological fixation surface in the design of the metal shell [7,11,12]. Our study was designed to compare the clinical performance at a minimum of five years follow up of acetabular components with two different hydroxylapatite interfaces and to compare the results of both to a control implant with a porous fixation coating. The intent was to determine whether a bonded or an interlocked interface produces the best prospects for long term stable fixation in the cementless acetabulum. 157
158
Bioceramics Volume10
MATERIAL S AND METHOD S In this clinical study conducted in the U.S. and Europe, we have followed 456 patients with 497 total hips to a minimum follow-up of five years. All patients received the same type cf femoral component (Omnifit-HA, Osteonics Corp., Allendale, NJ) and one of three acetabular cups each with a different fixation surface (porous, hydroxylapatite coated press-fit and hydroxylapatite coated threaded). Ninety-six patients received 103 cups in the porous cup group, 152 patients had 166 cups implanted in the hydroxylapatite press-fit cup group and 208 patients received 228 cups in the hydroxylapatite threaded cup group. After surgery, clinical and radiographic evaluations of each patient were conducted at five to seven weeks post-operation and at six months, at one year, and at each year thereafter. Analysis of radiographs included evaluation for radiolucencies, cancellous condensation, component migration, and osteolysis. Selected radiographic series from patients with both stable and unstable components were digitized and computer enhanced using commercially available image enhancement software (Imagika, Clinical Measurement Corp., Upper Saddle River, NJ).
RESULT S At the 5 year evaluation, 395 patients (86.6 per cent of the population) reported no pain associated with their joint or joints. Clinical results broken down by cup type showed that at 5 year follow-up the porous press-fit cup group had a mean Harris score of 94.1, the hydroxylapatite press-fit cup group had a mean score of 96.0 and the hydroxylapatite threaded cup group had a mean score of 97.6. These five year scores were not statistically significantly different one from another. Radiographic observations at a minimum of five years follow-up showed that a stable bone interface was maintained by 92.7% of the porous implants, by 88.2% of the hydroxylapatite coated press-fit implant group and by 100 % of the hydroxylapatite coated threaded implants (Figure 1). Analysis of revision rates showed one implant revised for aseptic loosening in the porous cup group (1%) and one m the hydroxylapatite threaded group (0.44%). By comparison, in the hydroxylapatite coated press-fit implant group, seventeen of 166 unplants were revised (10.2%) and a further four of these implants were found to be loose by radiographic criteria at five years follow-up. Analysis of the radiographs of these press-fit implants prior to failure showed a region of radiolucency inferior to the implant which increased in width as follow-up progressed (Figure 2). DISCUSSIO N Comparison of the failure rates between the cups in our study shows that the hydroxylapatite coated press-fit components performed significantly worse than the other two implant types (p<0.001). In assessing the difference between implants, the hydroxylapatite coatings were manufactured to the same specifications, the geometry of all cup types was similar and all implants were fabricated from commercially pure titanium. The difference between the successful groups and the unsuccessful group is in the morphology of the fixation surfaces. Both the hydroxylapatite threaded surface and the porous coating could achieve interlock with bone, while the hydroxylapatite coated press-fit surface relied for fixation on a bond between bone and implant coating.
Revision Rates and Radiographic Changes Associated With Different Cup Types: M.T. Manley et al.
159
Finite element analyses [13,14] have suggested that if a metal backed implant is bonded to the acetabular preparation, very high local tensile stresses, caused by physiologic activity, will be found at the fixation interface close to the component rim. A potential for failure cf bonded interfaces is suggested by these models, and once bond failure occurs the models suggest that component loosening, distraction between inferior cup and bone and finally cup migration will result. Radiographic evidence of this failure of this type is shown in our study, with the hydroxylapatite press-fit interfaces tending to show initial signs of failure at the inferior interface. The absence of such failures with the hydroxylapatite coated threaded and the porous designs suggests that these interfaces are able to withstand the stresses imposed by patient activity, presumably because of the interlock achieved between the implants and the acetabular bone. SUMMAR Y This clinical comparison of three acetabular components of similar geometry but different bone fixation interfaces has shown acetabular revision rates that are dependant on the fixation surface used. The hydroxylapatite coated press-fit cups had an unacceptable loosening rate. Failure of the fixation interface with these implants began inferiorly to the implant and then progressed toward the pole. Similar interface failures with the hydroxylapatite coated threaded cups and the porous cups appear to have been prevented by the mechanically mterlocked interfece which these implants achieved with bone by the design of their fixation surfaces. Our study suggests strongly that interlock between an acetabular component and bone is a prerequisite for successful long term cementless fixation in the acetabulum.
REFERENCES 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. 6. 7. 8. 9. 10. 11. 12. 13. 14.
Heekin R.D., Callaghan J.J.,Hopkinson W.J., Savor>’ C.H., and Xenos J.S. J. Bone and JointSurg.1993, 75-A:,77-91. Kim Y-H., Kim V.E.M. J. Bone and JointSurg.1993, 75-B, 6-13. Schmalzried, T.P., and Harris, W.H. J Bone and JointSurg., 1992 74-A, 1130-1139. Schmalzried, T.P., Wessinger, S., Harris, W.H. J Arthroplasty.1994, 9, 235-242. Engh, C.A., Glassman, A.H., Griffin, W.L., and Mayer J.G. Clin Orthop.1988, 235, 91-110. More R.C., Amstutz H.C., Kabo, J.M.,Dorey, F.J.,and Moreland J.R, Clin. Orthop., 1992 282, 114-122. Pupparo, F.; and Engh, C.A, Clin. Orthop.,1991 271, 201-206. Apel, D.M., Smith, D., Schwartz, CM., Paprosky, W.G., Clin. Orthop.,1989, 241, 183-189. Capello,W.N. Clin.Orthop.,1990, 261, 102-106. Fox, G.M., McBeath, A.A., and Heiner, J.P., J Bone and JointSurg.,1994, 76-A: 195-201. Cartillier, J.C, In: HydroxyapatiteCoatedHip and Knee Arthroplasty,Expansion Scientifique Francaise, Paris, 1994, 165-168. Duthoit, E., Epinette, J.A., and Carlier, Y., In: HydroxyapatiteCoatedHip and Knee Arthroplasty,Expansion Scientifique Francaise, Paris, 1994, 176-186. Mann K.E., Osteonics Corp. Internal Report, 1996. Rapperport, D.J., Carter, D.R., Schurman, D.J., J. Orthop. Res.,1987, 5, 548-561.
160
Bioceramics Volume10
Figure 1 Hydroxylapatite Coated Threaded Cup at 7 Years Follow-up.
Figure 2 Enhanced Image of Hydroxylapatite Coated Press-fitCup at Four Years Follow-up.
Bioceramics, Volume 10 Edited by L. Sedel and C. Rey (Proceedings of the 10th InternationalSymposium on Ceramics in Medicine, Paris, France, October 1997) '1997 Elsevier Science Ltd
COMPARATIV E STUDY OF THE RESULT S BETWEE N CUSTO M NON-COATE D CEMENTLES S fflP IMPLANT S AND MIRRORE D CEMENTLES S HA - COATE D HI P IMPLANT S ON THE CONTRA-LATERA L SIDE . Dr M Mulier, G. Deloge University Hospitals U.Z. Leuven Departement of Orthopeadic Surgery Weligerveld,! 3212 Lubbeek Pellenberg (Belgium) ABSTRAC T Introduction Hydroxyapatite coatings to prostheses are reported to give a very early and reliable stability and show a better osseointegration compared with identical non-coated implants. Materials SL Methods: Since 1990 we have implanted 43 HAP- coated femoral stems based on the computer mirrorimage of the contra-lateral side custom hip stem. The patients received this custom prosthesis earlier by surgery using the I.M.P. ( = Intra-operative Manufactured Prosthesis) system of Stewal Implants. This study was setup in order to determine the influence of HA coatings on the performance of the I.M.P. implant. For each patient a HA coated stem and a custom-made rasp was made, based on the geometry data of the custom-made contralateral side. Of the 43 implanted prosthesis we have 30 patients with a minimum follow-up of 3 years on both sides.(3 - 7 years). We evaluated both sides clinically and radiographically. 161
162
Bioceramics Volume10
Results; All the 43 rasps and respective stems could be introduced without much diflSculty. This proves the high grade of similarity of the femoral cavities of both femurs Radiographically: On the uncoated side bony pedestal formation below the distal tip was observed in 50 % of the cases. On the contra-lateral HA coated side this pedestal formation was observed in 1 case. This pedestal formation may be triggered by excess force transmissionfromthe prosthesis to the bone possibly by late subsidence, (see figure 1 and 2) No other significant differences were observed radiographically. The HA coated implants didn’t show any form of osteolysis caused by defragmentation of the HA coating. Clinically: Most of the patients have a more secure feeling on the HA coated side during monopodal stance; this appeared insignificant. To compare Harris scores between sides in the same patient was difficult. Conclusions; The HA coated implants show a much better radiographical result then the non -coated implants. It is a challenge to coat the implants during surgery. This way the I.M.P. system could become available to all the patients with a difficult and unpredictable femoral geometry (i.e.: revisions, C.D.H.).
Comparative Studyof Non-Coated Implants andHA-CoatedImplants: M. MulierandG. Deloge 163
CEMENTLESS IMP
PEDESTAL 43 %
Figure 1: Radiological evaluatio n ( Pedestal) : Cementies s IM P stem.
CEMENTLESS IMP WITH HA COATING
PEDESTAL 5%
Figure 2: Radiological evaluation (Pedestal) : Cementies s IM P stem with HA coating proximal.
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
Bioceramics, Volume 10 Edited by L. Sedel and C. Rey (Proceedings of the 10th InternationalSymposium on Ceramics in Medicine, Paris, France, October 1997) '1997 Elsevier Science Ltd
IMPROVEMEN T OF THR WIT H SPONGIOS A META L SURFAC E USIN G TH E WEA R COUPL E CERAMIC-ON-CERAMI C Gerd Quack, MD, PhD; Gerd Willmann, PhD.*; Hans-Gerd Pieper, MD, PhD; Hartmut Krahl, MD, PhD., Prof. Department of Orthopaedic Surgery of the Alfried Krupp Hospital, D-45117 Essen (Germany) * CeramTec Medizintechnik, D-73207 Plochingen (Germany) Keywords: all-ceramic wear couple, total hip endoprosthesis with spongiosa-type metal surface Abstract Based on positive 6-years results of the SMS cup system (*Spongiosa A/etal 5’urface), we improve this THR to an all-modular system with the wear couple ceramic-on-ceramic. As corresponding results are available for ceramic/polyethylene couples of the SMS system, such improvement of the survival curve of this system may reasonably be ascribed to the use of all-ceramic couples. It is thus possible to clearly assign any failures which may additional occur to the new components. The follow-up of the first 50 patients shows good short-term results. Introduction In the meantime, uncemented hip endoprosthetics can look back on highly successful results. Despite this, the fact that THR tend to be subject to loosening after a dwelling period of 10 years cannot be ignored. Such process of aseptic loosening is essentially caused by increased abrasion of the polyethylene (PE) used in material-mix couples in which metal or alumina ceramic balls are used together with PE-cups. The abraded PE particles which are not carried off by the organism, cause high formation of granuloma which again cause osteolysis alongside the prosthetic components - which in the end causes the loosening of the implant [1]. Alumina ceramics Replacing the metal femoral head by a Biolox femoral head allows for the rate of abrasion to be reduced by > 50%. Further reductions of such rate can only be achieved if the PE insert is replaced by a ceramic insert. The use of all-ceramic couples, i.e. THR femoral head and acetabular cup made of Biolox forte, allows for the rate of abrasion a reduction by factor 100 (tbl. 1) [6, 8]. The properties of Biolox (AI2O3) ceramics, which are described below, make the material particularly suited for hip endoprostheses: Aluminaceramicsare bioinert The high-purity alumina available today are extremely resistant to corrosion and will not emit any ions to the body. Hence, they can be classified as both, biocompatible and bioinert materials. This fact also means that they will not induce any connective osteogenesis. Wettability ofAluminaceramics The wettability of almnina in respect of polar liquids such as synovial fluid is better than the one offered by PE or CoCrMo. Hence, the material offers the best prerequisites for a lubricating film to establish between the prosthetic counterparts. Formation of the lubricating film is supported by the gap provided between the ceramic femoral head and the ceramic insert, which is generated by the difference in diameter between the head and the insert. The type of friction involved in vivo is a mixed friction which among other things is due to the oscillating movement of the hip joint. 165
166
Bioceramics Volume10
Configuration fern, head/cup
Abrasion / year in mm
Metal/PE diam.
heads of 22 mm up to 0.5 mm rest: > 0.2 nun Biolox/PE <0.1 mm Biolox/Biolox up to 0.005 nun Biol. forte/Biol. forte < 0.001 mm Basic prerequisite: no loosening process involved of the stem and /or the cup Tbl. 1: Rate of abrasion
Fig. 1: SM S cup, Biolox forte insert
Wear ofAluminaceramics Owing to its extreme hardness (pyramid hardness of 2000 HV), the material is subject to extremely low wear. The material’s median grain size of < 0.002 nun and its high density allow for highly polished functional surfaces, i.e. of surfaces featiuing a low peak-to-valley height to be achieved. In combination with the good wettability offered by AI2O3 ceramics, the material enables excellent tribological properties. According to the studies conducted by Saikko [6] and by Walter [8], the rate of abrasion obtained for Biolox forte/Biolox forte couples ranges below 0.001 nun/year. DimensionalstabilityofAluminaceramics Owing to their high elasticity modulus of 380 GPa, alumina ceramica are extremely rigid and are not subject to neither plastic nor elastic deformation. This means, that they offer long-term dimensional stability even when exposed to high strain. Aluminaceramicsare safe The material offers an extremely high compressive strength of > 500 MPa. This means that the femoral heads and cup inserts made of it will notfracturewhen exposed to the different types of stress incurred in vivo. The resistance tofractureoffered by Biolox forte femoral heads of 28 nun in diameter exceeds 50 kN (> 5 tons), while the one offered by the smallest Biolox forte insert is 86kN(>8tons)[l,9]. However, the current experience in the use of ceramic cups has shown that the bone will not integrate the ceramic surface in the sense of a connective osteogenesis (ace. to Osbom), owing to the ceramic material’s absolute bioinertness. As a result, the implant is subject to early loosening. This basic property of ceramics is the cause of the failures experienced for monobloc cups. The autopsy examinations performed by Plenck [4], Hensge [3] and Fritsch [2] represent the connecting link between the theoretical and the in-vitro properties of all-ceramic couples, and the clinical results obtained for them. Such results can be summarized as follows: - Abrasion rates of < 0.005 nun/year are obtained if neither the stem nor the cup have loosened. - The diameters of the abrasion particles of AI2O3 ceramics ranges between 0.001 and 0.002 mm which is definitely lower than the ones observed for PE particles which were up to 0.02 mm. - The amount of abrasion particles is extremely low (< 0.005 mm/year) as long as there is no loosening of the implant and the cup and the stem. - Abrasion particles of AI2O3 ceramics are classified as biocompatible material. They will not cause any undesirable tissue reactions, which is due to their bioinertness and the small size and small amount of abrasion particles.
Improvementof THR With Spongiosa Metal Surface: G. Quack et al.
167
Osseointegratio n of the uncemente d SMS-TH R system The degree of osseous integration of uncemented metal cup components essentially depends on the design of the prosthetic surfaces. As far as the modular SMS cup system is concerned, the biological idea is to the fore: - Preservation of as much bone as possible. Resulting from this a spherical shape of tiie cup was devised. A cone is provided on tiie inside of the cup in order to allow for optimumfixationof the PE or of the ceramic insert. - Osseous integration of the prosthesis into the osseous bed through spongiosa-type wide-meshed enlargement of surfaces, which is achieved by coating the implant with tripodes: the cancellous bone represents the load-carrying and load-transmitting structure for positioning the cup and the stem. It reacts to the implant by integrating it. For this reason, the implant surfaces must feature a load-carrying structure and must provide suflBcient gaps into which the trabeculae of the spongiosa and the supplying vessels may vascularize [5]. Until December 1996, a total of 709 of these SMS cup systems were implanted. The follow-up examination of the first 95 uncemented hip endoprostheses (implanted in 1987 to 1991) with wide-meshed SMS cups yielded good medium-term results, with only one cup loosening and protruding into the minor pelvis (for data refer to table 2). The system used consisted of a ceramic femoral head (Biolox) and a PE cup insert. Yielded from this was a loosening rate of < 1.05% after a dwelling time of 6.03 years, and the good osseous integration predicted was confirmed. The consequences which can be drawnfromthefindingsobtained for the use of alumina ceramics [7] and from the positive medium-term results (*tained for the SMS cups must be a division of fiinctions [5]: - Ceramics should be used as gliding components offering minimum abrasion for the articular fimction as such. - Metal (CoCrMo, Ti) should be used for thefimctionof osseous integration. A cup system featuring a 3-dimensional wide-meshed surface and using Biolox forte ceramic inserts was developed, which as the central element offers a modular structure of the gliding couple. Resulting from this development was im imcemented and completely modular THRsystem offering optimum prerequisites to enable connective osteogenesis and low wear of the aJumina articular surfaces (fig. 1). On the basis of the experience gained from the use of the SMS cup system over the years, the improvement achieved in respect of the life of the prostheses is clearly due to the use of ceramic/ceramic couples. Also, it is possible to assign the causes of failures. Such findings shall be specified fiirther with the help of a comparative study investigating the use of Biolox^E and Biolox forte/Biolox forte couples. SMS-CU P / aver. 6.03 y. - 95 SMS cups -47 females (49,47%) - 48 males (50,53%) Mean Score: Harris hip score 92.80 pts (+/- 7.11) Merle d’Aubigne sc. 16.74 pts (+/-1.36) - Aseptic loosening:! SMS cup = 1.05% TbL 2: Medium-term results
From November 1995 to March 1997, tiie first 50 patients below the age of 61 have received a gliding couple consisting of ceramic Biolox forte femoral head and insert. There have been no complications due to the use of ceramics. So far, the regular follow-up examinations have yielded good clinical (Harris hip score) and radiological results. In respect to the surgical technique used, the items specified below should be accounted for: - Use of an exact surgical technique and optimum positioning of the cup must be ensured.
168
Bioceramics Volume10
- Both, the cone available on the inside of the cup, and the cone of the stem must never be damaged during handling and implantation . - Necessit y of using special implantation instruments . - To enable optimum cone-fitting , the ceramic insert must not be allowed to rest on the metal bottom of the cup (fig. 1). Summary The SM S THR-system (manufacture d by ESKA ) offers optimum osseointegratio n owing to the spongiosa-typ e design of its surface. The abrasion rate is drastically reduced as a result of the improved gliding propertie s of the all-ceramic (Biolox forte) couple, as long as the use of an exact surgical technique is ensured. The residual abrasion particles produced are bioinert and will be carried off by the organism without any problems. The ceramic component s will prolong the survival of the THR caused by the decrease of any osteolysi s due to abrasion. As a resuh the prosthesis will not loosen, or at least will loosen at a much later point in time. This means a much better prognosis, especiall y in the case of younger patients. A comparing study with the wear couples Biolox/PE and Biolox forte/Biolo x forte will help specifying these statements . First experience s with 50 cases, 2 years afler the first implantation , show good short-term results. Reference s 1. Clarke, I.C , P. Campbell, N. Kossovsky: Debris-mediate d osteolysi s - a cascade phenomeno n involving motion, wear, particulates , macrophage induction and bone lysis. In: St. John, K.R. (ed.): Particulate Debris from Medical Implants. AST M STP 1144, Philadelphia 1992, pp. 7-26. 2. Fritsch, E., H. Mittelmeier, J. Heisel, K. Remberger, S. Pahl: Micro- and macroscopic findings on capsular tissues of the hip after alumina arthroplasty. Proc. 6th Biomaterials Symposium "Ceramic Implant Materials in Orthopaedic Surgery", Sept 21-23, 1994, Gottingen (Germany); H.G. Buchhom, H.-G. Willert, in press 1996. 3. Hensge, E.J., I. Bos, G. Willmann: AI2O3 against AI2O3 combination in hip endoprostheses . Histologic investigation s with semiquantitativ e grading of revision and autopsy cases and abrasion measures. J. Materials Science Materials in Medicine 5 (1994) pp. 657-661 . 4. Plenck, jun. H., M . Buhler, A. Walter, K. Knahr, M. Salter: Fifteen years experienc e with alumina-cerami c total hip-joint endoprostheses : a clinical, historical and tribological analysis. In: Ravaglioli, A., A. Krjewski (eds): Bioceramic and the Human Body. Elsevier Appl. Sci., London, New York 1992, pp. 17-25. 5. (Juack, G., G. Willmann, H. Krahl, H. Grundei: Konzeptionell e Uberlegunge n zur Verbesserung der Pfanne der ESKA-Hftendoprothese durch die Gleitpaarung Keramik/Keramik [Conceptiona l consideration s relating to the improvemen t of the acetabula r cup of the ESK A hip endoprosthesi s achieve d through the use of ceramic/cerami c couples] . Biomed. Technik 41 (1996) 9, pp. 253-259 . 6. Saikko, V.: Wear test of the couple BIOLO X forte/BIOLOX forte. In: W. Puhl (ed.): Performance of the wear couple BIOLO X forte in hip arthroplasty. Enke Verlag Stuttgart, 1997. 7. Sedel, L., RS . Nizard, I. Kerbouli, J. Witvoet: Alumina-alumina hip replacemen t in patients yonger than 50 yars old. Clin. Orthop. 198 (1994), pp. 175-183 . 8. Walter, A.: Investigation of the wear couple BIOLO X forte/BIOLOX forte. In: W. Puhl (ed): Performance of the wear couple BIOLO X forte in hip arthroplasty. Enke Verlag Stuttgart, 1997. 9. Willmann, G.: Hiiftgelenkersat z - eine tribologische und konstruktive Herausforderun g [Hip arthroplasty - a challenge in respect of tribology and design]. Mat. Wiss. u. Werkstofitechni k 27 (1996) pp. 199-205 .
Bioceramics, Volume 10 Edited by L. Sedel and C. Rey (Proceedings of the 10th InternationalSymposium on Ceramics in Medicine, Paris, France, October 1997) '1997 Elsevier Science Ltd
ACETABULA R ARTHROPLAST
RECONSTRUCTIO N IN REVISIO N TOTA L Y U S I N G A BON E G R A F T S U B S T I T U T E
HI P
R.P. Pitto and D. Hohmann
Department of Orthopaedics, Friedrich-Alexander University, Waldkrankenhaus St. Marien, RathsbergerstraBe 57, 91054 Erlangen, Germany ABSTRAC T Twenty acetabular reconstructions in revision total hip arthroplasty with severe loss of bone stock were performed combining the use of autogenous bone grafts, synthetical hydroxyapatite ceramic and reinforcement rings. The rings were fixed with screws on the host bone. The grafts fused within 4 months after the operation in all the cases. No migration of the acetabular component or lysis of the mixed graft was seen in 19 cases after 2 years. One implant failed because of malposition and was revised 6 months after the operation. These preliminary findings give rise to cautious optimism that this is a reliable method for acetabular reconstruction. KEYWORD S Hip Prosthesis, Revision, Bone Stock, Bone Graft Substitute, Ceramic. INTRODUCTIO N Deficiency of bone stock is a major problem in revision arthroplasty. Filling of the cavities by cement or metal leads to ftirther bone defects, if renewed loosening occurs. The use of autogenous bone grafts is a biological way to solve the problem, but the quantity of the available harvested material is limited. For ethical, bacteriological and viral safety reasons, management of bone banks is becoming increasingly restrictive [2]. Synthetical bone substitutes offer an alternative to homologous grafts. The goal of this study was to evaluate prospectively the clinical and radiological results of acetabular reconstructions after revision of loose acetabular components with severe bone stock defects combining the autogenous grafts with synthetical hydroxyapatite ceramic. MATERIAL S AN D METHOD S Twenty revision arthroplasties were performed using the impaction grafting technique on the acetabular side [4]. The morselized autogenous grafts were mixed with synthetical hydroxyapatite ceramic (granulate or blocks, Synthacerfi, Scientific Development, Munich, D) (Fig.l and 2). Reinforcement rings of Muller (9 cases), Ganz (5 cases) and Burch-Schneider(6 cases) (Protek, Munsingen, CH) were used to anchor the new Prothesis, to impact the mixed autoheterografts and to protect them during the healing. The clinical assessment was performed according to the criteria of the Chamley 6-6-6 Hip-Score-System [1] and a similar method was used to classify the pre- and post-operative bone stock of the acetabulum [3]: normal acetabulum (grade 6); peripheral ectasis (grade 5); protrusion (grade 4); ventral defect (grade 3); ventro-cranial defect (grade 2); dorsal defect or discontinuity of the pelvis (grade 1). 169
Bioceramies Volume10
170
1 1
* ’’ ^ ^
*
^ 1 ^
ilk ^ii
% j’%^
Figure 1. The interconnecting porous framework of Synthacerfi, a synthetical hydroxyapatite ceramic [Ca5(Po4) 3OH].
Figure 2. The diameter of the pores of the synthetical hydroxyapatite ceramic is constant (600 jam). The porosity amount to 80%. Magnification: - = 100 |im.
Acetabular Reconstructionin Revision Total Hip Arthroplasty:R.P. Pitto and D. Hohmann 171
RESULTS The follow-up examination of the 20 patients at 24 months (min. 18, max. 28) showed the improvement of the pain score (av. pre-op, 2.6, av. Fw.-up grade 5.2), of the function score (av. pre-op. 2.5, av. Fw.-up grade 4.9) and of the motion score (av. pre-op. 4.3, av. Fw.-up grade 5.2). The roentgenological analysis of the grafts showed the fusion within 4 months after the operation in all the cases and a gradual condensation (Fig.3), but one of them had evidence of some degree of bony resorption. The bone stock had increased in all the cases (av. pre-op. 3.1, av. Fw.up grade 4.9). There were no signs of implant loosening. One case underwent a re-revision 6 months after the implantation because of malposition of the component and recurrent luxation. The graft showed in this case fusion at the host bone interface and osteointegration of the synthetical hydroxyapatite ceramic.
Figure 3. A) Aseptic loosening of a Wagner surface cup with severe osteolysis and protrusion. B) Revision and reconstruction of the acetabulum with impaction grafting and a reinforcement ring with hook of Ganz. C) Roentgenological signs of fusion of the graft, remodelling and stable implantation 2 years after surgery.
172
Bioceramics Volume10
DISCUSSIO N The revision of the loose acetabular component with severe bony defect filled with a mix of synthetical hydroxyapatite ceramic and autologous bone grafts have proved to be of value. The results shows the good tolerance of the heterografts and a roentgenological evolution similar to that observed with pure autografts [5]. Further study is necessary, but these preliminary findings give rise to cautious optimism that this is a reliable method for acetabular revision, reconstruction and reconstitution. Careful pre-operative evaluation and peri-operative assessment to match bone defects, grafting patterns and reinforcement ring are of paramount importance. AKNOWLEDGMEN T The authors would like to express their thanks to Prof. K. Draenert and Dr. Y. Draenert, Centre of Orthopaedic Research, Munich, Germany, for the support of this study.
REFERENCES 1. 2. 3. 4. 5.
Charnley, J. In: Low FrictionArthroplastyof theHip, Springer, Heidelberg 1979, 20-24. Levai, J.P., Boisgard, S. Clin, Orthop.Rel, Res. 1996, 330, 108-114. Pitto, R.P. J. Bone Joint Surg.(Br.)(in print). Sloff, T.J.J.H., Huiskes, R., Van Horn, J. Acta Orthop.Scand. 1984, 55, 593-596. Stringa, G., Pitto, R.P., Di Muria, G.V., Marcucci, M. Int. Orthop. 1995, 19, 72-76.
POSTER 1
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
Bioceramics, Volume 10 Edited by L. Sedel and C. Rey (Proceedings of the 10th InternationalSymposium on Ceramics in Medicine, Paris, France, October 1997) '1997 Elsevier Science Ltd
EFFEC T OF SOLUTIO N AGEIN G ON SOL-GE L HYDROXYAPATIT E COATING S B. Ben-Nissan, C.S. Chai and K.A. Gross Department of Materials Science, University of Technology, Sydney P.O. Box 123, Broadway, N.S.W., 2007, Australia
ABSTRAC T Sol gel technology offers an alternative technique for producing a bioactive surface for improved bone attachment. Hydroxyapatite was synthesized using the sol-gel technique with alkoxide precursors and the solution allowed to age up to 7 days. Coatings produced on MgO substrates were characterised by differential thermal analysis, thermal gravimetric analysis. X-ray diffraction and atomic force microscopy. It was found that, similar to the wet method of hydroxyapatite synthesis, an ageing time is required to produce a pure hydroxyapatite phase. KEYWORD S Hydroxyapatite, sol-gel, alkoxide, ageing, coating, characterisation INTRODUCTIO N Hydroxyapatite is an established material for applications such as maxillofacial reconstructive surgery and non load bearing applications [1]. One of the currently used methods to overcome low mechanical properties of bulk hydroxyapatite is to coat substrates such as titanium and its alloys. To date, many processes have been investigated. These include dip coating into a powder suspension [2], electrophoretic deposition [3], sputter coating [4] and plasma spraying [5]. Of these processes, plasma spraying is used commercially. Thermal spraying, however, requires good process control to avoid decomposition at high temperatures and is limited to coatings thicker than 30 jim. An alternative coating method is sol-gel deposition. While commonly being used for producing glasses and oxides, it has more recently been utilized to produce other more complex materials as well as non-oxide ceramics. The advantages of the sol-gel technique include (a) increased homogeneity due to mixing on the molecular scale, (b) reduced firing temperatures of ceramics due to small particles with high surface areas (c) ability to produce uniform fine-grained structures [6]. 175
176
Bioceramies Volume10
Sol-gel techniques have been previously used to synthesize hydroxyapatite powder [7] and coatings [8,9]. This work illustrates the necessity of ageing time on the phase composition of the coating. METHOD S Solution Preparation 1.5x10"^ moles of calcium diethoxide (Kojundo Ltd., Japan) was suspended in ethanol and then dissolved in ethanediol (BDH Chemicals, Australia) with the aid of vigorous stirring in a glove box under dry nitrogen atmosphere. A second solution consisting of a stoichiometric amount of triethyl phosphite (Aldrich, U.S.A.) diluted in ethanol was prepared and added to the calcium bearing solution. Stirring was maintained for a period of ten minutes. Solutions were allowed to mature for 0 and 7 days before being used to make coatings. Coating Procedure Magnesia single crystal substrates (Zirmat, U.S.A.), 10x10x0.5 mm in size were chosen to study the coating quality, without the influence of the interactions with a reactive substrate such as titanium [10]. Substrates were ultrasonically cleaned in acetone and ethanol and then coated using a Headway Research (U.S.A.) spin coater. A volume of 0.5mL of solution was applied to the substrate and spun at 2500 r.p.m. for 10 seconds. Coated substrates were hydrolysed in an air oven (Labec, Aust.) at 70 C for 10 minutes, followed by prefiring at 500 C in a mufile furnace (Ceramic Engineering, Aust.) for 15 minutes. The coating/hydrolysis/prefiring procedure was repeated until 5 layers were deposited. After the final layer had been prefired, the coated substrates were heated at 200 C/hr to 1000 C and soaked for 15 minutes followed byfiunacecooling. Characterisation Technique s X-ray diffraction (Siemens D5000, Germany) was conducted on coated substrates using CuKa radiation and a glancing angle geometry. This attachment was necessary due to the small coating thickness. Scan parameters included a scan range of 28 to 40 29, step size of 0.02 , step time of 5 seconds and X-ray incident angles between 0.5 and 5.0 . Thermal analysis techniques differential thermal and thermogravimetric analysis (DTA and TGA) were performed using a SDT 2960 simultaneous thermal analyser (TA Instruments, USA). Samples were heated at 10 C/min to 500 C, held for 15 minutes and then heated to 1200 C at 200 C/hr (3.33 C/min). This heating rate was chosen to replicate the heating schedule. The morphology of the coated substrates were examined using a Park Scientific Instrument (Autoprobe LS, U.S.A.) atomic force microscope (AFM). RESULT S AND DISCUSSIO N The use of a pre-firing stage at 500 C facilitates coating build-up. It also removes the volatile species allowing the rapid heating rate to sintering conditions. Thermal shock is minimized due to the small coating thickness and the relatively small amount of material deposited. Hence, the thin coatings have a low susceptibility to thermal shock cracking, and facilitates ease of gas (including alchohol) removal. In addition, the thermal gradient within the coating is very small and the sintering conditions in all locations of the coating are similar.
Effect of Solution Ageing on Sol-Gel Hydroxyapatite Coatings: B. Ben-Nissan et al.
177
Fired coatings appeared quite uniform except towards the edges where it was thinner (seen as interference fringes). This would be a thinning of the coating due to the edge effect. Complete coverage is thus dependent upon the wettability and geometry of the object. Ageing The X-ray diffraction patterns for coatings produced after 0 and 7 day ageing periods are shown in Figure 1. Hydroxyapatite is evident after 0 days ageing, however, the presence of CaO (JCPDS 4-777) and other peaks suggests that the reaction has not reached completion. The coating produced after an ageing period of 7 days appears to consist solely of hydroxyapatite. Thus, it is evident that an ageing period is necessary to allow the different species present in the coating solution to mix thoroughly. Given the complex kinetics of this system, it is possible that some chemical reactions may take place during this maturing period. This ageing phenomena is similar to the ripening procedure used in the "wet method" to produce a stoichiometric hydroxyapatite [11]. Thermal analysis of the hydrolysed gel produced after maturing time of 7 days exhibited an endothermic peak at 110 C and three exothermic peaks at 216, 430 and 550 C. The large endotherm corresponds to the evolution of residual solvent and adsorbed moisture. This is followed by two large exothermic reactions at 216 and 430 C respectively. These reactions correspond to the formation of chemical bonds through condensation and polymerisation as well as the evolution of residual water and/or alchohol. This has also been reported with zirconia gels [12]. A smaller exothermic reaction occurs at 550 C. It is believed that this reaction represents the crystallisation of hydroxyapatite [13]. The vertical translation observed on the DTA/TGA curve at SOC’C represents the 15 minute pre-firing heat treatment. Surface Morphology The surfaces of the coatings were examined using AFM. The coatings were crack free and consisted of 2 distinct regions. The surface was covered with small grains, approximately 200nm in size. These smaller grains exhibited a "cauliflower-like" surface which was broken up by larger grains, approximately 800nm in diameter. These were observed at random separations across the coating surface and can be identified as peaks in figure 3a and lighter regions in figure 3b. It is possible that the larger grains had formed as a result of exaggerated grain growth. 1
’
1
’
I
’
i
1 S
^ ’c
I e 1
28
30
1
32
34
, 36
0 da>{s ageing 38
40
Degrees (20)
Figure 1. X-ray diffraction pattern of coatings produced from solution matured for 0 and 7 days.
200
400
600
800
1000
1200
Temperature (^C)
Figure 2. DTA/TGA plots for hydrolysed gel matured for 7 days.
178
Bioceramics Volume10
A B Figure 3. Atomic Force Microscope scans of coatings, using solutions matured for 7 days. CONCLUSION S Hydroxyapatite coatings have been produced via the sol-gel route. It was found that to induce the formation of a coating that is predominantly hydroxyapatite, solutions should be aged prior to use. AFM examination revealed the presence of two distinct regimes consisting of grains 200nm and 800nm in size respectively after being sintered at 1000 C.
REFERENCES 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. 6. 7. 8. 9. 10. 11. 12. 13.
de Groot, K., de Putter, C, Sillevis Smitt, P.A.E. and Driessen, A.A. In : Scienceof Ceramics,Brit. Ceram. Soc, Stoke on Trent, 1981, 433-437. Lacefield, W.R., Ann.NY. Acad. Sci.,1988, 523, 72-80. Ducheyne, P., van Raemdonck, W., Heughebaert, J.C. and Heughebaert, M., Biomater., 1990, 11, 244-54. Ong, J.L., Lucas, L.C., Lacefield, W.R. and Rigney, E.D., Biomater.,1992,13, 249-254. Gross, K.A. and Bemdt, C.C., J. Biomed.Mat. Res.,to be published in 1997. Johnson, D.W. and Gallagher, P.K. In : CeramicProcessingbeforeFiring, John Wiley and Sons, U.S.A., 1978. Masuda, Y., Matubaram, K. and Sakka, S., J.Ceram. Soc. Japan,1990, 98, 1266- 1277. Chai, C, Ben-Nissan, B., Pyke, S. and Evans, L., In.SurfaceModificationTechnologiesVII, T.S. Suddshan, K. Ishizaki, M. Takata and K. Kamata, Eds. Cambridge University Press, UK, pp. 509-525, 1994. Deptula, A., Lada, W., Olczac, T., LeGeros R.Z. and LeGeros J.P., In : BioceramicsVol. 9 University Press, Great Britain, 1996, 313-316. Chai, C. and Ben-Nissan, B., J. Aust. Ceram. Soc, 1993, 29 (1/2), 81-90. Osaka, A., Miura, Y., Takeuchi, K., Asada, M. And Takahashi, K., J. Mat. Sci.:Mat. in Med.,1991,2,51-55. Ben-Nissan, B., Anast, M., Bell, J., Johnston, G., West, B.O., Spiccia, L., de Villiers, D. and Watkins, I., Proc. 1stInt. Symp. Sci. ofEng.Cer.,S. Kimura and K. Niihara Eds., MikawaHaitsu,Koda, 1991,25-29. Gross, K.A., The amorphous phase in hydroxyapatite coatings, PhD dissertation, 1995, State University of New York at Stony Brook, USA.
Bioceramics, Volume 10 Edited by L. Sedel and C. Rey (Proceedings of the 10th InternationalSymposium on Ceramics in Medicine, Paris, France, October 1997) '1997 Elsevier Science Ltd
IONI C CEMENTS : INFLUENC E OF LIQUID/SOLI D RATI O ON POROSIT Y AND MECHANICA L PROPERTIE S F.Betchem*, P. Michaud*, F. Rodriguez*, Z. Hatim**. * Laboratoire de Pharmacie Galenique, Faculte des Sciences Pharmaceutiques, 35, chemin des Maraichers 31062 Toulouse Cedex ** Laboratoire de Chimie-Physique, Universite Chouaib Doukkali, Faculte des Sciences, B.P. 20 El Jadita-Maroc. ABSTRAC T Ionic cements are widely studied in orthopaedics and the biocompatibility, nontoxicity, and partial resorbability of hydroxyapatite are well known. In this study, we analyzed the effect of varying the liquid/solid ratio over a short range (0.40 - 0.50) with an ionic cement which has Ca/P atomic ratio 1.63. We examined the influence on axial and diametral tensile strengths, hardening and porosity. We observed that, when the amount of liquid is increased, the excess water is not used for the reaction, and occupies an interstitial position in the solid. So the porosity and the hardening time increase while the tensile strength decreases. KEYWORD S Ionic cements, hydroxyapatite, porosity, hardening, mechanical resistance. INTRODUCTIO N Ionic cements are being increasingly studied in orthopaedics. Their interest is due to their composition and structure, which are close to those hydroxyapatite (Caio(P04)6(OH)2, HAp), their easy utilization, and their non-exothermicity [1,2]. In order to reach total rehabitation, a cement has to present sufficient porosity to allow diffusion of body fluids but an increase in porosity is frequently correlated with a decrease in mechanical resistance. This paper shows how the variation of the liquid/solid ratio over a short range (0.40 - 0.50) leads to modifications of the mechanical and physical properties in vitroand in a moist atmosphere at 37 C. The value Ca/P of 1.63 was chosen in order to prepare a non stoechiometric apatite and to be sure to obtain a total reaction of all the initial reagents. MATERIAL S AND METHOD S Cement paste was prepared by addition of a liquid containing calcium and phosphate ions to a mixture of solid Calcium Phosphates (table 1) Ca4(P04)20, TTCP and a-Ca3(P04)2, a-TCP [3]. In the cement formula, the Sodium Glycerophosphate (NaGP) is useful for improving the paste homogeneity. The paste was placed in silicone molds (9 mm diameter and 5 mm thickness) for 10 minutes in a moist environment at 37 C. Then, the cylindrical samples were removed from the molds and kept in a moist environment at 37 C for 96 hours. Before analysis, each sample was dried in an infrared balance at 110 C for 10 minutes. These samples were used to determine the mechanical properties with a Diametral Tensile Strength (DTS) machine PHARMATEST PTB 311 and computerized single punch machine KORSH Ekod for Axial Tensile Strength (ATS). The specific area and total pore volume of the samples were measured by a nitrogen high speed surface area 179
180
Bioceramics Volume 10
Powder
12000 7
8.68 g 1.32 g
TTC P and a-TCP NaGP
E E 10000 8000
Liquid
Ca(OH)2 H3PO4 H2O
Ca/P=1.635 liq/sol=0.4 3 "Ca/P=1.635 liq/sol=0.4 5 - Ca/P=1.635 Iiq/sol=0.5 0 B
6000 +
0.12g 0.29 ml to 100%
.5 4000 % 2000 24 30 36 Time (min)
Table 1: Composition of the cement
Graph 1 : Hardness versus time (Ca/P = 1.63, hquid/solid = 0.43) and pore size analyzer Quantachrome NOVA 1000 for specific area; mercury pore size analyzer Micromeretic autopore 11-9215 for total pore volume. To follow the hardening, we used a texture analyzer TAXT2. Cement paste was introduced into a mold of 12 mm diameter and 12 mm height which was placed in a steel block of great thermal inertia to keep the cement temperature at 37 C during measurements. One measurement was made every 3 minutes for one hour with a 1 mm punch in the following conditions : 2 mm/s for downward and rise speed; penetration of 5 mm. For each cycle we took the maximum strain to plot the hardening curve.
RESULT S AND DISCUSSIO N The graph 1 shows the setting and the hardening evolution of a cement with three different liquid/solid ratios in a moist atmosphere at 37 C. In the three curves, there is two main stages before reaching to hydroxyapatite. The part A corresponds to the formation of brushite (CaHP04, 2H2O, DCPD) by acidic and basic reactions between TTCP, a-TCP and phosphoric acid contained in the solution. 120 J
ir no f B
S 100 ^
^
^ g.
51 *Z 49 ^
70 f 60
0.35 0.43 045 Uquid/solid ratio
93.37 53’ 83.53 49
90 +
59 111.94 + 57 ’ 56 101.26 55 ^ 54
47 H-
-H
0.4
0.45
-+0.5
45 0.55
Liquid / solid ratio
Graph 2 : Tensile strength after 96 hours in Graph 3 : Porosity and specific area versus moist atmosphere at 37 C liquid/solid ratio Liquid/Solid ratio 0.40 0.43 0.45 0.50
Apparent density 1.56 1.50 1.48 1.38
Measured density 2.46 2.46 2.52 2.49
Theoretica l % of open porosity 37 40 42 45
Residual humidity rate (% ) 12.50 14 15 15.50
Table 2: Theoretical open porosity and residual humidity rate of sample differents from their liquid/solid ratio.
Ionic Cements:Influenceof theLiquid/SolidRatio:F. Betchemet al. 181 00
0.3
’JS^:
0.2 2 0.1
S 0.0-H^ ^ 00
o
H-3
rrr rr 10000
1000
100
Diameter (Angstroms)
s (view by Figure 1: Distribution of pore size by mercury Figure 2 Porosity and HA p needle intrusion in 0.43 liquid/solid ratio sample. SEM X 20000) in 0.43 liquid/solid ratio sample. The part B correspond s to the formation of octocalciu m phosphate (Ca8H2(P04)6, 5H2O, OCP ) [4] which in turn gives HA p after several hours. The curves also show that the setting and hardening times increase as the liquid/solid ratio increases . In graph 2, we observe the large modificatio n of mechanica l propertie s when the amount of liquid is increased . Graph 3 shows the rise of specific area and porosity as the liquid/solid ratio increases . The rise of porosity is due to excess water which occupies an interstitial position during hardening in a moist environmen t at 37 C. When the liquid is removed by drying in an infra red balance it contribute s to the porosity and specific area. Table 2 shows the results of density and humidity rate measurements . The differenc e betwee n apparent and measured density is explaine d by the open porosity. Moreover the rise of the residual humidity rate as the liquid/solid ratio increase s shows that the reaction which leads to HA p uses the necessar y amount of water and the excess of water occupies an interstitial position in the solid. The measuremen t of excess of liquid consists in measuring the residual humidity rate. The results achieve d by nitrogen and mercury pore size analyzers are compatible with the theory: in each sample the rate of open porosity depends on liquid/solid ratio and is included betwee n 45 and 60%. The decrease of mechanica l resistance is correlate d with porosity [5,6]. Another fact can contribute to the decrease of the mechanica l propertie s : a large amount of liquid slows down the crystallizatio n by modifying the different calcium phosphate s successivel y formed. The mercury pore size analyze of samples shows that there is two pore families for each liquid/solid ratio : the main family is situated near 1000 Angstroms diamete r (figure 1) and increase s as the amount of liquid increases . The vision of figure 2is a SEM photograph (x 20000) illustrating the porosity and the needle s of HA p inside the cement (Ca/P =1.63 and liquid/solid ratio = 0.43). CONCLUSIO N The liquid/solid ratio is an important paramete r in the preparation of ionic cements . The amount of water required is determine d by the Ca/P ratio. Excess liquid is not used for the reaction but occupies an interstitia l position in the solid. When the excess of liquid increases , the porosity and the hardening time increase and the tensile strength decreases . To achieve sufficient porosity while maintaining correct mechanica l properties , the formulation of those cement s must be optimize d and the precise conditions of their utilization must be determined .
182
Bioceramics Volume10
ACKNOWLEDGMEN T We thank TEKNIMED (B.P. 60, Vic en Bigorre, France) for financial support of the work and for providing of powder raw materials. One of the authors (F.B.) wishes to gratefully acknowledge Pr J.L. Lacout for encouragement and support.
REFERENCES
1. E.W. BROWN, L.C. CHOW, J. Dent Res.,62, 1983, 672. 2. A. A MIRTCHI, J. LEMAITRE, E. MUNTING, Biomaterials,11, 1990, 83-88. 3. J.L. LACOUT, E. MEJDOUBI. Procede d’obtention d’hydroxyapatite phosphocalcique, application au comblement osseux ou au moulage de pieces et produits utilises. Brevet Fr92.09019/PCT/FR. 4. J.L. LACOUT, E. MEJDOUBI, M. HAMAD, J. Mater Sci, Mater.Med, 7, 1996, 371374. 5. R.WmCE, J. Am. Ceram. Soc, 79, 1993, 1801-1808. 6. O. BERMUDEZ, M.G. BOLTONG, F.C.M. DRIESSENS, J.A. PLANELL, J. Mater. Sci. Mater.Med, 4, 1993, 389-393.
Bioceramies, Volume 10 Edited by L. Sedel and C. Rey (Proceedings of the 10th InternationalSymposium on Ceramics in Medicine, Paris, France, October 1997) '1997 Elsevier Science Ltd
SINTERIN G BIOCERAMIC
AND S
THERMA L
DECOMPOSITIO N
OF
HYDROX Y APATIT E
J. Cihlar and M. Trunec Department of Ceramics, Institute of Materials Engineering, Brno Technical University, Technicka 2, 616 69 Brno, Czech Republic
ABSTRAC T In the course of high temperature treatment of injection moulded hydroxyapatite ceramics (HA) sintering, grain growth and thermal decomposition of HA to tricalcium phosphate took place. The sintering was finished at 1573 K. The grain growth started at 1500 K and the thermal decomposition started at 1623 K. The activation energy of grain growth was 215" kJ/mol, that of thermal decomposition 283.5 kJ/mol. The optimum sintering temperature was found at 1473 K. KEYWORD S Hydroxyapatite ceramics, thermal decomposition, gram growth, sintering, kinetics INTRODUCTIO N Properties of sintered hydroxyapatite ceramics, namely their mechanical and biochemical properties depend on the physical and chemical structure of HA [1]. This structure is dependent on processing parameters of HA ceramics, namely on conditions of thermal treatment. In the course of thermal treatment sintering, grain growth and thermal decomposition of HA take place [2]. Data published about the physical and chemical behaviour of HA ceramics in the course of thermal treatment are not consistent. Nonuniformity namely has to do with an optimal sintering temperature and mechanism of thermal decomposition of HA ceramics [3, 4, 5]. In this contribution the authors try to make a kinetics and mechanism of thermal decomposition more clear and to give optimal tempei-ature of HA sintering. MATERIAL S AND METHOD S The samples of HA ceramics were prepared by ceramic injection moulding. Materials used and sample processing had been published [2]. Thermal treatment of HA samples was made in a superkanthal furnace in air atmosphere of 25% relative humidity at the temperature range from 1373 K to 1773 K for 1 to 22 hours. The microstructure and microanalysis of HA specimens were determined by SEM on a JXA-840 microscope equipped with an energy dispersion analysator (Link). The phase composition of HA ceramics was established by X-ray diffraction analysis on a D-500 diffractometer (Siemens). For quantitative phase analysis the part of spectrum in the range of 30 to 50 for 26 was used. The diffraction of (121) + (211), (300) and (301) planes were used for HA content determination, the diffraction of (123) + (254), (434) + (264) + (401) and (400) planes were used for the determination of tricalcium phosphate (TCP) content. 183
184
Bioceramics Volume10
RESULTS AND DISCUSSION Sintering The dependence of linear shrinkage of hydroxyapatite ceramics on sintering temperature is given in Figure 1. In the temperature range from 1373 to 1573 K linear shrinkage increased with increasing temperature. A maximum shrinkage (16%) was obtained at the temperature of 1573 K. With this maximum linear shrinkage the hydroxyapatite ceramics had relative density of 98%. Sintering at the temperature above 1573 K (in the air atmosphere) did not result in further increase of the density of hydroxyapatite ceramics.
1100
1200
1300
1400
SINTERING TEMPERATURE [K]
Figure 1 The dependance of the shrinkage of HA ceramics on sintering temperature
Figure 2a Microstructure of injection moulded HA ceramics sintered at 1373 K for 1.5 hour SINTERING TIME [hour] ’ \m Y
2
4
1
1
’
6
1
-I
8
T
1
Sintering Time Sintering Temperatur e
1
\
iy
1
10
A
Y-
0 1000
* t-^t
1200
1
1
-1 5.
1400
\
1600
SINTERING TEMPERATURE [K]
Figure 2b Microstructure of injection moulded HA ceramics sintered at 1773 K for 1.5 hour
Figure 3 The dependence of the grain size of HA ceramics on sintering time and temperature
Sintering and ThermalDecompositionof Hydroxyapatite Bioceramics:J. Cihlar and M. Trunec 185
Grain Growth The microstructure of the sintered HA ceramics is shown in Figure 2. The average grain size of the HA ceramics sintered at 1373 K for 1.5 h was about 1 |Lim (figure d). The HA ceramics sintered at 1773 K for 1.5 h contained grains of the average size of 16 fin (^Figure 2b). The growth of grain size depended, above all, on sintering temperature. The most pronounced grain growth was observed in the temperature range from 1573 K to 1673 K (see Figure 3). Thermal decomposition The loss in weight (due to the loss of water) of hydroxyapatite ceramics started ai the temperature of 1373 K. A negligible shift of diffraction lines of HA iccompanied b> weight loss of HA was caused by formation of oxyapatite (OA). HA-OA system (termed as hydroxyoxyapatite [4]) was stabile for 15 h at temperature 1573 K. The presence of crystalline a-TCP was detected until sintering for 2 hours at 1623 K. The course of thermal decomposition is perceptible from Figure 4.
Figure 4 Section by the layer of TCP on the surface of HA ceramics sintered at a) 1573 K for 22 hour b) 1773 K for 8 hour %
200
1 1 1 1 1 1 1
1
LU
150 Q. O
^
CO CO
UJ
z "^ o X
1
1
1
1
\
-4 ^ J
c
\
A 1
1
^
/ Oi [ 0
1
-5
yi
50
1
Ep = 283. 5 kJ/mo l
^^^^"^^ 1
100
O
r - - i-
I ’ 1 ’ 1 1
1
1 1
I
.
I
.
I
.
200 400 600 800 100012001400 SINTERING TIME [min]
Figure 5 The dependence of the thickness of TCP layer on the sintering time
1
0,56
0,57
.
1
0.58
1
I
0,59
.
I
0,60
.
0,61
lOOOyT [1/K] Figure 6 The temperature dependence of the rate constant of HA decomposition
186
Bioceramies Volume10
The thermal decomposition started on the surface of HA ceramics. At first, islands of TCP appeared (Figure 4a). These islands were connected together in the compact TCP layer growing into the inside of HA-OA ceramics (Figure 4b). The growth of thickness of TCP layer (x) with time (t) was described by parabolic rate law x=(Kt)^^^ (see Figure 5) [6], where K is a factor of proportionality. The rate of the thermal decompositicm of HA-OA is then controlled by diffusion of reaction products (water) through the layer of TCP. The activation energy of thermal decomposition of HA-OA was 283,5 kJ/mol (see Figure 6). In the temperature range from 1623 to 1773 K, thermal decomposition products of HA ceramics contained only TCP. Traces of tetracalciumphosphate appeared at 1773 K. The thermal decomposition of HA ceramics could be described by equations: 2 Ca5(P04)30H o Caio(P04)60 + H ^ (1373 - 1723K)
(1)
Ca,o(P04)60 <^ 3 Ca3(P04)2 + CaO
(1623 - 1723 K)
(2)
3 Ca3(P04)2 + CaO o Ca4(P04)20
(above 1773 K)
(3)
CONCLUSION S In the course of thermal treatment of HA ceramics thermal decomposition of HA took place at the temperature higher than 1623 K. The layer of reaction product - TCP was formed on the surface of HA samples. The kinetics of thermal decomposition was described by parabolic rate law. The activitation energy of thermal decomposition was 283.5 kJ/mol. Optimum sintering temperature of injection moulded HA ceramics was found at 1473 K Acknowledgements The autors thank Mrs Drahoslava Janova for providing the SEM photographs and Dr. Antonin Buchal for providing X-ray diffraction analyses. This project was supported by Czech Ministry of Education Fund. REFERENCE S 1. LeGeros, R.Z. and LeGeros, J.P. In: An Introduction to Bioceramics, World Scientific, London 1993,139 (Eds.: Hench, L.L. and Wilson. J.). 2. Cihlar, J. and Trunec, M., Biomaterials1996, 17, 1905-1911. 3. Zhou, J. Zhang, X. Chen, J Yeng, S. and De Grot, K., J. Mater.ScL, Mater.Med. 1990, 4, 83-85 4. Wang, P.E. and Chaki, T.K., Biomaterials:Materialsand Application,ACerS, Ohiol995, 225 ( Eds.: Fischman, G. and all.) 5. Locardi, B., Pazzaglia, V.E., Gabbi, C. and Profilo, B.,Biomaterials14, Oxford 1993, 437441 6. Kingery, W.D., Bowen, H.K. and Uhhnann, D.R., Introductionto Ceramics,New York 1976, Wiley, 386
Bioceramics, Volume 10 Edited by L. Sedel and C. Rey (Proceedings of the 10th InternationalSymposium on Ceramics in Medicine, Paris, France, October 1997) '1997 Elsevier Science Ltd
AN ELABORATIO N OF THE NEW DISSOLUTIO N MECHANIS M FOR APATIT E Sergey V. Dorozhkin Research Institute of Fertilisers and Insectoflingicides Kudrinskaja sq. 1-155,123242 Moscow D-242, Russia
ABSTRAC T Used methods of scanning electron microscopy, Auger-electron spectroscopy and IR-reflection spectroscopy, a new information about chemical dissolution of fluorapatite in phosphoric acid was obtained and analysed. The dissolution was found to occur incongruently on the very thin surface layer of fluorapatite, via previous leaving of fluorine followed by calcium. The experimental results obtained were extended with literature analysis. A new chemical mechanism for apatite dissolution in acids was proposed as a result. The mechanism for the first time described the chemical irregularity of the dissolution process at the atomic (ionic) level. KEYWORDS : apatite, dissolution, chemical mechanism. INTRODUCTIO N A pure calcium apatite is widely used as a bioceramics in medicine, because its chemical composition is very close to the inorganic part of animal and human bones and teeth. Unlike natural bones, the artificial bioceramic substitutes based on apatite (or covered with apatite) are not alive; so they are in constant interaction with different biological and chemical substances inside a human body. That is wiiy, the fundamentals of apatite dissolution are so important for the correct simulation of processes occurring with the substitutes in vivo. There are a large number investigations, devoted to apatite dissolution kinetics in the acidic medium [1]. Different models for the apatite dissolution process were proposed as a result. The polynuclear dissolution model [2] seems to be the most likely dissolution mechanism among them. But non of the models described chemical transformations occurring on the apatite crystal surface during dissolution. For nowadays the only equation, used for apatite dissolution in acidic medium, is the following chemical reaction [1,2]: Ca5(P04)3F + TKT = 5Ca^’^ + 3H2P04" + HF
(1)
Reaction (1) means that seven hydrogen ions are necessary to dissolve one « molecule » of apatite and reports nothing about a possible chemical mechanism. But as soon as reaction (1) occurs, the chemical mechanism at the atomic (ionic) level must exist. MATERIAL S AND METHOD S 187
188
Bioceramics Volume10
Crystals of natural fluorapatite and pure phosphoric acid were used for the experiments. 0.1 - 1 g of crystals were dissolved in 200 - 300 ml of 2 - 7 M H3PO4 solution during 3 - 20 s under temperature of 50 - 90 C and Reynolds hydrodynamics (Re) of 2000 - 3000. After being slightly dissolved, the crystals were quickly separated from the acid solution by filtration through a filter with porosity of 1.0 jim, followed by washing them in acetone during 20 - 25 s and drying in air at room temperature. After being washed and dried, the crystals were studied with a scanning electron microscope (SEM) JSM 35CF (secondary electron mode, acceleration voltage of 15 kV), IRreflection spectroscope Specord 75 (in the range of 2000 - 200 cm"^) and Auger electron spectroscope (AES) Jump 10 with the standard measurement techniques [3], published elsewhere [4]. After being investigated the crystals were washed in water during 2 - 5 min and the above acidic treatment followed again. The results obtained for the treated crystals were compared with the same of initial fluorapatite. RESULT S AND DISCUSSIO N Table 1 shows position of some adsorption bands of fluorapatite in the IR spectra for the initial crystals (row 1), the crystals treated in acid followed by washing them in acetone (row 2), and the same as row 2, but with additional washing in water during 1 min (row 3). Three new absorption bands at 1100, 1046 and 668 cm"^ were found for the treated crystals (Table 1, row 2). Two of them (1100 and 1046 cm’^) were found in the libration range of phosphate groups [1, 5]. They pointed out to some chemical changes occurred with the bands at 1116 and 1078 cm"^ respectively. The third band (668 cm’^) was new. It appeared in the libration range of hydroxyl groups [1,5]. Similar results of AES are given in Table 2. The very thin surface layer, equal to the Augerelectrons formation and scattering (approximately 1-3 nm), was found to have lost all fluorine and atomic ratio of Ca : P decreased from 1.67 – 0.05 (initial apatite) to 1.30 – 0.05 for the apatite treated [4]. The latter value appeared to be close to that of octacalcium phosphate Ca8H2(P04)6’5H20 (Ca : P = 1.33) [1]. Thus, both methods have pointed out to some chemical changes happened on the surface of fluorapatite treated. The results of SEM showed clear evidence for the appearance of a conducting layer on the surface of apatite treated in acid [4]. Unlike initial apatite (it is dielectric), the apatite treated was found to have enough surface conductivity to be studied in the SEM directly [5]. On the other hand, crystals of acidic calcium phosphates CaHP04 and Ca(H2P04)2 were also found to have surface conductivity good enough to be studied in the SEM directly. Thus, the results of SEM also pointed out to some changes occurred on the crystal surface of apatite during dissolution. To extend information about the surface layer obtained, some additional results were taken from literature. Apatite was found to be charged positively in acidic mediums [6, 7] as a result of chemosorption of protons [6] or calcium and protons [7] from the solution. Another results of the
Table 1. The wave numbers (iij, cm"^) of some IR spectra bands for fluorapatite rowl. Initial apatite
1116
-
1078
row 2. Etched apatite washed in acetone
-
1100
-
1046
668
-
1078
-
668
row 3. Etched apatite washed in acetone and water 1116
An Elaboration of the New Dissolution Mechanismfor Apatite: S.V. Dorozhkin 189
Table 2. AES results of Ca/P ratio on the surface of fluorapatite (according to the rows in Table 1) row 1
row 2
row 3
1.67 – 0.05
1.30 – 0.05
1.65 – 0.10
sequence of atomic (ionic) dissolution of fluorapatite were also taken from literature. Apatite was found to dissolve incongruently; moreover, the following sequence of ionic dissolution was established: first fluorine, next calcium and afterwards phosphate [8, 9]. DISSOLUTIO N MECHANIS M As soon as apatite was found to be dissolved in acidic mediums mainly [1], the role of protons was noteworthy. According to the above [8, 9], fluorine dissolved first. But the results of IR-spectroscopy (Table 1, row 2) pointed out to hydroxyl incorporation into the crystal lattice of fluorapatite. Hydroxyl is known to be easily replaced with fluorine and back in the channels parallel to the c axis [1]. So, it is logical if a first chemical equation describes the exchange of fluorine with hydroxyl or water: Ca5(P04)3F + H2O + H" = Ca5(P04)3(H20)’’ + HF
(2)
Here incorporation of water is chosen instead that of hydroxyl, because in acidic medium investigated incorporation of basic hydroxyl is very unusual. Protons are supposed to be previously chemosorbed on the surface of apatite crystals (positive charge formation [6, 7]) and used as a catalyst [2] for removing of fluorine and water incorporation instead. A possibility of such substitution is taken from literature [1, 10]. Molecule of water consists of two 0-H bonds; each of them is believed to be able to form the libration band at 668 cm’* (the results of IR-spectroscopy). As soon as a local positive charge on apatite has already appeared (2), an interaction of other protons becomes more difficult. So, dissolution of one calcium cation might be supposed: 2Ca5(P04)3(H20)’’ = 3Ca3(P04)2 + Ca^’’ + H20
(3)
Reaction (3) corresponds completely with the results of [8, 9] (calcium dissolves ahead of phosphate) and partly with the results of AES, because for intermediate Ca3(P04)2 obtained, Ca : P atomic ratio is equal to 1.50 (i.e.the ratio is already not 1.67 – 0.05, but it is still not 1.30 – 0.05). A fiirther interaction between protons and apatite surface might be described as follow: Ca3(P04)2 + 2H^ = Ca^"’ + 2CaHP04
(4)
Here next calcium is replaced with two protons. This equation completely corresponds with the results of [8, 9], SEM (a conductive layer appears, because CaHP04 is formed) and IRspectroscopy (changes with phosphate bands at 1116 and 1078 cm"* have happened) and partly with ones of AES, because for CaHP04 the Ca : P ratio is afready 1 : 1 (i.e.below 1.30 – 0.05). A reasonable explanation of this difference is easy: a mixture of CaHP04 and Ca3(P04)2 is formed on the surface of apatite treated in acid. Both of these substances were proposed as precursors of apatite formation [11]. So, for the above reasons reaction (4) contradicts to nothing. At last, phosphate ions also dissolve according to one of the following reactions:
190
Bio ceramics Volume10
CaHP04 + 2H’’ = Ca^"’ + H3P04 CaHP04 + tf