96305_Russell_03_27.qxp
3/28/2006
11:18 AM
Page i
LITERARY CRITICISM AND CULTURAL THEORY
Edited by
William E. Cai...
39 downloads
502 Views
1MB Size
Report
This content was uploaded by our users and we assume good faith they have the permission to share this book. If you own the copyright to this book and it is wrongfully on our website, we offer a simple DMCA procedure to remove your content from our site. Start by pressing the button below!
Report copyright / DMCA form
96305_Russell_03_27.qxp
3/28/2006
11:18 AM
Page i
LITERARY CRITICISM AND CULTURAL THEORY
Edited by
William E. Cain Professor of English Wellesley College
A ROUTLEDGE SERIES
96305_Russell_03_27.qxp
3/28/2006
11:18 AM
Page ii
LITERARY CRITICISM AND CULTURAL THEORY WILLIAM E. CAIN, General Editor OUTSIDER CITIZENS The Remaking of Postwar Identity in Wright, Beauvoir, and Baldwin Sarah Relyea
OVERHEARD VOICES Address and Subjectivity in Postmodern American Poetry Ann Keniston
AN ETHICS OF BECOMING Configurations of Feminine Subjectivity in Jane Austen, Charlotte Brontë, and George Eliot Sonjeong Cho
MUSEUM MEDIATIONS Reframing Ekphrasis in Contemporary American Poetry Barbara K. Fischer
NARRATIVE DESIRE AND HISTORICAL REPARATIONS A.S. Byatt, Ian McEwan, Salman Rushdie Tim S. Gauthier NIHILISM AND THE SUBLIME POSTMODERN The (Hi)Story of a Difficult Relationship from Romanticism to Postmodernism Will Slocombe DEPRESSION GLASS Documentary Photography and the Medium of the Camera Eye in Charles Reznikoff, George Oppen, and William Carlos Williams Monique Claire Vescia FATAL NEWS Reading and Information Overload in Early Eighteenth-Century Literature Katherine E. Ellison NEGOTIATING COPYRIGHT Authorship and the Discourse of Literary Property Rights in Nineteenth-Century America Martin T. Buinicki “FOREIGN BODIES” Trauma, Corporeality, and Textuality in Contemporary American Culture Laura Di Prete
THE POLITICS OF MELANCHOLY FROM SPENSER TO MILTON Adam H. Kitzes URBAN REVELATIONS Images of Ruin in the American City, 1790–1860 Donald J. McNutt POSTMODERNISM AND ITS OTHERS The Fiction of Ishmael Reed, Kathy Acker, and Don DeLillo Jeffrey Ebbesen DIFFERENT DISPATCHES Journalism in American Modernist Prose David T. Humphries DIVERGENT VISIONS, CONTESTED SPACES The Early United States through the Lens of Travel Jeffrey Hotz “LIKE PARCHMENT IN THE FIRE” Literature and Radicalism in the English Civil War Prasanta Chakravarty BETWEEN THE ANGLE AND THE CURVE Mapping Gender, Race, Space, and Identity in Willa Cather and Toni Morrison Danielle Russell
96305_Russell_03_27.qxp
3/28/2006
11:18 AM
Page iii
BETWEEN THE ANGLE AND THE CURVE Mapping Gender, Race, Space, and Identity in Willa Cather and Toni Morrison
Danielle Russell
Routledge New York & London
RT6960X_Discl.fm Page 1 Monday, March 20, 2006 11:16 AM
Published in 2006 by Routledge Taylor & Francis Group 270 Madison Avenue New York, NY 10016
Published in Great Britain by Routledge Taylor & Francis Group 2 Park Square Milton Park, Abingdon Oxon OX14 4RN
© 2006 by Taylor & Francis Group, LLC Routledge is an imprint of Taylor & Francis Group Printed in the United States of America on acid-free paper 10 9 8 7 6 5 4 3 2 1 International Standard Book Number-10: 0-415-97696-0 (Hardcover) International Standard Book Number-13: 978-0-415-97696-1 (Hardcover) No part of this book may be reprinted, reproduced, transmitted, or utilized in any form by any electronic, mechanical, or other means, now known or hereafter invented, including photocopying, microfilming, and recording, or in any information storage or retrieval system, without written permission from the publishers. Trademark Notice: Product or corporate names may be trademarks or registered trademarks, and are used only for identification and explanation without intent to infringe.
Library of Congress Cataloging-in-Publication Data Catalog record is available from the Library of Congress
Visit the Taylor & Francis Web site at http://www.taylorandfrancis.com Taylor & Francis Group is the Academic Division of Informa plc.
and the Routledge Web site at http://www.routledge-ny.com
96305_Russell_03_27.qxp
3/28/2006
11:18 AM
Page v
Contents
Preface and Acknowledgments Chapter One Where Am I and How Did I Get Here?: The Connections between Space, Identity, and the Fiction of Willa Cather and Toni Morrison
vii
1
Chapter Two Background Foregrounded: The Significance of Setting or “Don’t Skip the Descriptive Bits”
27
Chapter Three Maneuvering through the Maternal Landscape: Traditions, Tropes, and New Techniques
59
Chapter Four Home, Hearth, and Harpies: Discovering a Space of One’s Own in the Domestic Sphere
103
Chapter Five “This Way to the Egress:” Exiting Thoughts on the Cartography of Connection
151
Notes
189
Bibliography
203
Index
221 v
96305_Russell_03_27.qxp
3/28/2006
11:18 AM
Page vi
96305_Russell_03_27.qxp
3/28/2006
11:18 AM
Page vii
Preface and Acknowledgments
The origins of this study are multiple and varied. I came to it, or it came to me, from several directions. Statements from a variety of sources triggered deeper consideration than, on the surface, they seemed to merit. As I taught Cather’s My Antonia and Morrison’s Song of Solomon, I had the strong impression that the two were connected. Something more than the classifications of “American Fiction” or “Women Writers” linked the pair. A student’s brutally honest confession about “skipping the background stuff ”—the attitude that setting was superfluous, unnecessary, open to editing—helped to sharpen my focus. I came to the conclusion that the setting—in all its complexity—is a crucial element in the process of interpreting the writings of Cather and Morrison; to edit it out is to rewrite (badly I might add) the text. A short time later, I read two interviews in which Morrison addressed the relationship between identity and place. In the first, she asserted that women have a stronger sense of place than men; in part because women perform intimate acts in places (the gendered division of labour has a spatial effect). In the second interview, Morrison distinguished between black and white women. Unlike white women, black women are able to combine the nest and adventure; that is, the security of home and the freedom of mobility. She opened up the territories for one group of women while reinforcing the gendered division of space for the remaining women. I was curious as to whether or not this assessment applied to Morrison’s own fiction and if Cather’s work supported or refuted the insistence that race altered the experience of gendered space. As I began my project, I recognized a need for a theoretical framework within which I could articulate my close textual analysis. My starting point was what I would call the traditional approach to geography. It entails an almost uniform division of space into two related categories: masculine/feminine, real/imaginary, public/private, urban/rural. The labels vary but the use vii
96305_Russell_03_27.qxp
viii
3/28/2006
11:18 AM
Page viii
Preface and Acknowledgments
of binaries and emphasis on separation is fairly consistent. An implicit (sometimes explicit) value system was embedded in, and sustained by, the divisions. One element was privileged at the expense of the other; more often than not, gender entered the equation. In particular, the work of Gaston Bachelard struck me as needing closer examination; his theories were cited repeatedly in the works of other scholars. The angle/curve, masculine/feminine distinction Bachelard identified seemed, at first, to carry a great deal of weight. If only visually, the gendered pattern made sense; the correlation between body and landscape seems to be logical. Bachelard’s refusal to consider non-felicitous space and his contention that confrontation or dissension can only occur in the space of hatred and combat relies on too narrow an interpretation. Re-negotiating boundaries is not entertained in Bachelard’s theories; nor is the possibility of alternative constructions of space. I turned to feminist geographers in the hopes of finding a broader approach—a less claustrophobic depiction of space. A wider recognition of the political implications of spatial divisions did emerge in my reading (the social effects of gendered space and the need to re-evaluate attitudes about the landscape in particular) but there was a troubling acceptance of the enhanced status of the public sphere. The emphasis was on moving women into spaces identified with men rather than ameliorating the spaces linked with women. Rejecting the domestic sphere in pursuit of the space of political action actually led to the same constrictive definitions of space. The home receives a great deal of attention in the fiction of Cather and Morrison; much of the action in the novels occurs in the home. Home as a site of oppression is a concept which is challenged in their fiction; their alternative and contrasting depictions promote nurturing and inspiring domestic spaces. The home is not reduced to a simple, idealized space by either author; nor is it generalized as a negative location. Complexity and the possibility of connection are central components of the domestic spaces (both natural and constructed) Cather and Morrison incorporated into their novels. The two authors have been approached in terms of similar categories or topics of discussion. They cover a great deal of common terrain; in particular, the importance of the land, gendered landscapes, and the significance of the home. The unique depictions Cather and Morrison create of the American landscape, in all its complexity, challenge existing mainstream assertions about American fiction. There was both an opening and need for this study; re-evaluations of the theories of space and identity will provide new insights into American literature.
96305_Russell_03_27.qxp
3/28/2006
Preface and Acknowledgments
11:18 AM
Page ix
ix
A concern with the limitations of space shaped this study in a tangible way; the constraints of a “manageable” text prevented a consideration of all the fiction written by Cather and Morrison. The desire for a balanced discussion meant that Cather’s fiction in particular had to be pared down. As a result, I have only selected novels (no short stories will be examined) and have opted to focus on three of Cather’s key landscapes—the prairie, southwest, and Southern settings—in an attempt to achieve a range within the physical restrictions. I therefore make no claims that this is an exhaustive exploration of space and identity in the writings of Cather and Morrison. The decision to utilize a thematic approach for the comparison, rather than a chronological exploration of individual texts, had two origins. First my interest is in the overall patterns of Cather’s and Morrison’s representations of space and the potential for shared territories and techniques. Second, close sequential analysis of each text was not possible given the range of the novels I wished to analyze. A thematic approach permitted a comparison which is rich in detail despite the constraints of a single volume study. This technique has sometimes led to a movement between texts that may seem abrupt to readers not familiar with all the novels but the desire for an extensive view of the literary landscapes created by Cather and Morrison was given priority over a single text approach. Cather and Morrison resist categorization. Space in their novels is depicted as fluid and interconnected rather than rigid and contradictory. Domestic space is naturalized; natural space is domesticated. The emphasis is on inclusion. Intimacy and immensity are achieved within the same setting. Cather and Morrison challenge hierarchies and dichotomies through their creation of hybrid geography. Expanding our understanding to the intricate connections between identity and place as they play out in the fiction of Cather and Morrison opens up the territory of American fiction. The result is not a space of conflict, but complementary space. The tension between the longing for home and impulse for adventure so often identified with American literature is in fact defused, although not completely resolved, in the texts in this study. The novels of Cather and Morrison refute the myth of a unified American landscape by broadening its territory. Protective communities which foster identity and encourage artistic endeavors are crucial factors in the fiction of Willa Cather and Toni Morrison. They have also played a vital role in my life. I would like to thank my family for their support through the daily struggles (both big and small, real and self-inflicted): my brothers for their humour and matter-of-fact conviction that I would succeed; my father for his unshakeable faith in my abilities; my mother for her practical involvement in the process, her impartial
96305_Russell_03_27.qxp
x
3/28/2006
11:18 AM
Page x
Preface and Acknowledgments
insights and her blatant bias in my favour; and my precious daughter (joy of my heart and light in dark places). Thanks are also due to my community of choice—the teachers and professors who showed me that my love of reading could become a way of life. Special thanks are due to Professor Elizabeth Sabiston for her guidance, support, ceaseless efforts on my behalf, and her friendship. I would also like to acknowledge Professors Susan Warwick and Leslie Sanders for the generous gift of their time and thoughtful comments.
96305_Russell_03_27.qxp
3/28/2006
11:18 AM
Page 1
Chapter One:
Where Am I and How Did I Get Here?: The Connections between Space, Identity, and the Fiction of Willa Cather and Toni Morrison
Je suis l’espace où je suis. I am the space where I am. —Noel Arnaud1
As is so often the case, Arnaud’s seemingly simplistic statement raises an extremely complex issue. The conclusion that location (“where I am”) and identity (“I am”) are interchangeable is quite provocative. What happens to identity when the spaces we occupy are determined by factors such as gender, race, social class, or any number of arbitrary classifications? Where do choice and decree intersect in the space/identity equation? Spatial markers ground the English language. Communicating our positions is a daily practice. We rarely give a second thought to the spatial significance of phrases like “upward mobility,” “high society,” “public and private spheres;” they are merely “figures of speech.” We write, and read, of social, cultural, and political landscapes. Recognizing that our identities are formed in (and through) such spaces is crucial to any discussion of identity. Both the construction and representation of space (whether it is demarcated as geography, place, or landscape) are crucial to identity formation. Space is never neutral; it carries with it a history. Ideological, cultural, and social concerns inform both our understanding and depictions of space. Concepts of the nation, of gender, and of race have a particular resonance in explorations of identity and space. Whether in the
1
96305_Russell_03_27.qxp
2
3/28/2006
11:18 AM
Page 2
Between the Angle and the Curve
“real” world or the realm of literature, the representation of space is central to comprehension of individual and collective identity. “A nation is an act of the imagination,” contends Terry Eagleton, “‘a country of the mind,’ rather than a tract of land or collection of individuals. It is in effect a myth and it needs that myth making mechanism known as literature to sustain it.”2 Such an assertion insists that a nation is written into being; in this context, literature and space theory, identity and geography, reinforce each other—each is subject to change and fluctuation rather than being fixed and stable. Galvin Cologne-Brookes proposes a circular relationship between the literary work and the literal landscape: “while America is written into being, American writing which totals up into the idea of America, is itself shaped by the physical geography of the land” (1). Mutual dependence, Cologne-Brookes suggests, characterizes the exchange between author and “subject.” What is the myth of America that emerges in its fiction? Clearly a single myth of America or American fiction cannot accommodate the multiple perspectives of the vast array of American authors. Nor, for that matter, can a single project provide an all-encompassing statement about “American Fiction”—a Sisyphean task if ever there was one. Within the literature of the United States, the connection between identity (national and individual) and space has garnered much attention from writers, critics, and readers. The fiction of Willa Cather and Toni Morrison offers rich territory for the exploration of this connection. Even a cursory glance at their fiction reveals the wide range of physical and symbolic terrains Cather and Morrison create; such an exercise effectively destabilizes the notion of a simple image of the American landscape. It also highlights the mythmaking role of the two writers: their stories enhance and expand the story that is America. Horse, raft, car, plane; trail, river, road, open skies—American literature is frequently identified by its vehicles for movement and avenues of escape. Cologne-Brookes highlights “America’s rich tradition of travel writing . . . ;” a journey through the American terrain has proved to be the impetus for many fictional adventures (16). Self- discovery is often depicted as occurring outdoors, whether it is a pastoral ideal or the more foreboding American wilderness. “We are taught,” observes Mickey Pearlman, that American literature “is about space, open space, and the ways in which hearty or hesitant, defiant or defensive, American heroes experience both its potential and its limitations” (1). Migration and freedom of movement often receive the most attention, but the importance of a home (literal or longed for) is also vital to the definition of American fiction. “American literary history,” cautions Joseph R. Urgo, “reflects the interplay of rootedness and
96305_Russell_03_27.qxp
3/28/2006
11:18 AM
Where Am I and How Did I Get Here?
Page 3
3
migrancy, settlement and escape” (1). Apparently contradictory urges (and spaces) are actually interconnected; an accurate representation of American fiction must acknowledge each element. The ongoing engagement with the issue of geography and identity, which is so prevalent in American literature, has inspired a myriad of writers. Cather and Morrison are authors for whom the question of space and identity is central to their literary endeavors. “Writing” a country has typically taken a white, masculine slant. Images of early settlements in North America often focus on the conquest of a wild, but fertile land. The virgin soil is tamed by the pioneer; feminine landscape is made productive by the masculine farmer (a “conclusion” which will be explored in Chapter Two). Approaching the land as a female space is not original to North America. It is the by-product of a long standing tradition which resurfaces in “New World” literature. Other carry-overs from “Old World” fiction include the rich and complex symbol of the garden, the “country versus city” antithesis, and the identification of the landscape with, and as, the human body. This study will address how Cather and Morrison situate their works of fiction and their characters within such a tradition. It is a process complicated, or perhaps enriched, by such factors as gender, race, and the tension between independence and connection. Possible responses to the “standard” representations of literary settings, whether they are urban or rural, developed or natural, range from accommodation to covert undermining to overt rejection; all three tactics are employed, to varying degrees, by Cather and Morrison in their complex depictions of space and identity. “Instead of shaping masculine space into something feminine,” Ruth Salvaggio proposes, “women bring feminine space to life by writing from, through, and about the spaces women themselves have occupied” (262). While Salvaggio acknowledges that “black women and third-world women . . . have become increasingly aware of the absent space they occupy . . . [in] feminism,” she suggests that the common ground of being female leads to essentially similar experiences and conceptions of space (272). It is an assertion which I will revisit in my conclusion. Both Cather and Morrison challenge reductive responses to spatial demarcations. The relationship between the individual and the world is complex, but identity is intimately and irrevocably entwined with place. Neither author writes within a masculine space or the standard definition of feminine space; the two explore counter definitions and alternative terrains. The result is a hybrid territory of connection which incorporates both feminine and masculine characteristics. One is immediately and intensely aware of location when reading a Cather or Morrison novel. The variety of settings speaks to the richness of the American literary landscape. While Cather and Morrison incorporate
96305_Russell_03_27.qxp
4
3/28/2006
11:18 AM
Page 4
Between the Angle and the Curve
extremely diverse landscapes—prairies and tropics, the southwest and the midwest among other locales—the importance of place in their fiction is strikingly similar. Settings dominate their texts; the land becomes a character unto itself in many of their stories. Eudora Welty praises Cather’s gift for never losing “sight of the particular in the panorama”—her ability to create impressive landscapes without sacrificing detail (44). It is a literary concern shared by Morrison. “I felt a very strong sense of place,” Morrison acknowledges in an interview with Robert Stepto, “not in terms of the country or the state, but in terms of the details, the feeling, the mood of the community, of the town” (10). Setting is not just a physical place, but a living presence in Morrison’s writing. Minute details and expansive visions combine to construct environments which engage both characters and readers. Cather’s characters, argues Laura Winters, “do not simply live in places; they live places emotionally, spiritually, and intellectually” (3). It is an assessment which could easily be applied to Morrison’s characters. What is typically background is foregrounded in the novels of Cather and Morrison; descriptions of the textual landscapes cannot be glossed over. The setting functions on several levels in the novels being examined in this study. Place can be a character and/or catalyst; it has both an identity of its own and an impact on the identities of those who experience it. The interaction between person and place can be mutually transforming; a specific site can alter an individual’s perspective as effectively as an individual can alter the physical landscape. In her interview with Stepto, Morrison offers an opinion on the significance of space in the formulation of identity for women in particular: . . . I think some of it is just a woman’s strong sense of being in a room, a place, or in a house. Sometimes my relationship to things in a house would be a little different from . . . my brother’s or my father’s or my son’s . . . I do very intimate things “in place.” I am sort of rooted in it, so that writing about being in a room looking out, or being in a world looking out, or living in a small definite place, is probably very common among most women . . . (10–11)
Women, Morrison proposes, have a more intimate relationship with place because they (generally) perform more intimate tasks in that space. The use of qualifiers—“some,” “sometimes,” “little,” “sort of,” “probably”—is telling; Morrison does not assert that this experience is universal to all women nor is it necessarily permanent.
96305_Russell_03_27.qxp
3/28/2006
11:18 AM
Page 5
Where Am I and How Did I Get Here?
5
THE POLITICS OF LOCATION: IDENTITY AND PLACE The exchange between setting and subject in the stories in this study is quite complex. Identity, of person and place, is open to external manipulations which can be coercive or co-operative. The question of identity has inspired two (broad) theoretical approaches: the essentialist and the constructionist arguments. In plain terms, the essentialists contend that there exists an inner essence which is expressible through language. The constructionists counter that the subject is shaped by systems of language, culture, and ideology. I fall into the second camp and my interpretation of the characters penned by Cather and Morrison is informed by this line of reasoning. As will become evident in the subsequent chapters, the fiction supports the constructionist theory. Cather and Morrison depict individuals who are altered by the environments they experience. Identity is malleable in the writings we will be analyzing. The debate is succinctly articulated by Simone de Beauvoir: “One is not born, but rather becomes, a woman” (301). Neither biology nor some vague inner essence accounts for woman; she is the creation of a variety of interactions with the world around her. By extension, man is also a product (and producer) of his environment. Gender identity is “performatively constituted by the very ‘expressions’ that are said to be its results,” insists Judith Butler (25). “Feminine behaviour” is not simply the by-product of a womb; it is also a response to socially prescribed expectations. Patriarchy (apologies to Freud) is not built upon (or by) the penis. As Linda Martin Alcoff notes, “gender systems are not the legacy of nature, they are the legacy of a power struggle” (21). Social practices and ideology have determined inequitable relationships based upon gender, race, class, or any number of arbitrary classifications. Race is often approached as an established, clearly demarcated status; however, such a conclusion rests on shaky ground. “In the United States,” asserts Siobhan B. Somerville, “the term ‘race’ has always been contested. In nineteenth-century scientific usage, it might refer to groupings based variously on geography, religion, class or color” (21). Over time the emphasis has shifted to the “color line,” but that too lacks rigidity. Gayle Wald’s work on racial passing illustrates how the “‘boundary’ of race is subject to ongoing contestation and mutation” (10). Race can be performed or denied, capitalized on or concealed. Somerville’s conclusion that race refers to “a historical, ideological process rather than to fixed transhistorical or biological characteristics: one’s racial identity is contingent on one’s cultural and historical location” proposes that identity has a greater range of possibilities than racial categories would initially suggest (7).
96305_Russell_03_27.qxp
6
3/28/2006
11:18 AM
Page 6
Between the Angle and the Curve
While Andrew Pepper acknowledges that “terms like race and ethnicity no longer refer to categories that are fixed and stable but to ones that are best seen as fluid and relational . . . ,” he cautions, “the temptation to entirely collapse race and ethnicity on top of one another needs to be resisted” (243). “Black” is no more effective at conveying the identities and experiences of all people of colour than “woman” is at conveying the identities and experiences of all women. Subtle and not so subtle differences must be acknowledged in order to utilize the spaces of possibility located in the externally imposed labels. Negotiating identities within the definitions of race and ethnicity likewise requires recognition of the “cultural and historical location.” There are social, economic, political, and geographic effects created by the system of identification; re-, or self-, definition can be a powerful tool in dismantling inequitable power structures. Beauvoir’s distinction between biology and socially and culturally constructed categories challenges the assumption that identity is visually recognizable. The need to include “other” on census forms and other official documents is an acknowledgement of the pitfalls of such an approach. To attempt to reduce identity (individual or national) to a single statement is to conclude that there is a single identity which can be articulated. Stuart Hall rejects such a stance; in his theory multiple, overlapping (at times contradictory) identities constitute the “self.” Identifications, Diana Fuss similarly concludes, can shift, multiply, and contradict. “Subjectivity must be kinetic, not static; it must be multiplied, not single,” contends Elizabeth Deeds Ermarth (408). Identity is not just in process, it is in processes. It is in a state of “palimpsestuousness”3 concludes Ermarth, and its “singularity exists in the unique and unrepeatable sequence of a life, but not in some essential ‘subject’” (412). Each life is distinct because no sets of experiences are identical; subtle differences lead to individual identities. Movements or relocations can alter identities. “I need to understand,” writes Adrienne Rich, “how a place on the map is also a place in history within which as a woman, a Jew, a lesbian, a feminist I am created and trying to create” (212). Rich is located through categories of classification and the “place on the map” she occupies. In her discussion of Rich’s work, Mary Eagleton concludes, “the body is subject to the whim of locations, imponderable twists of fate that lead to doom or survival” (305). Geography can be a life or death issue as World War II and more recent conflicts in Afghanistan and the Middle East depict almost daily. The spaces we live in shape survival rates and strategies. Identities emerge, in part, in response to the physical conditions (positive or negative) we encounter. The places we occupy matter. Distinguishing between the influence of the locale on the individual and the
96305_Russell_03_27.qxp
3/28/2006
11:18 AM
Where Am I and How Did I Get Here?
Page 7
7
influence of the individual on the locale is no easy process. J. R. R. Tolkien raises the issue in The Fellowship of the Rings: Sam Gangee, musing on the elves, observes, “whether they’ve made the land, or the land’s made them, it’s hard to say, if you take my meaning” (473). Indeed, the boundaries blur even in the non-fictional world. Navigating the literal terrain is an integral component in creating our identities. Physical locations can be catalysts for self-knowledge. Cather and Morrison utilize various landscapes as springboards for discovery and exploration. I would like to highlight two key scenes illustrating the importance of place in Cather’s and Morrison’s depiction of identity. The protagonist of O Pioneers! has a “new consciousness of the country, felt almost a new relation to it . . .” (47). It is a recognition of her emotional investment in the country. A slightly different but equally moving discovery springs from Baby Suggs’ relocation in Beloved. Knowing little about her scattered children and even less about herself, she lacks the “map to discover what she was like. . . . [but] when she stepped foot on free ground . . . she saw with clarity . . . and discovered something else new: her own heartbeat” (140–1). Alexandra Bergson and Baby Suggs seemingly have little more than sex in common. Alexandra is a white woman, strong in body (indeed she is described as an Amazon), surrounded by family on land their father has left them free of debt. Baby Suggs is a freed slave whose body has been broken by forced labour, her family is scattered and shattered, her last remaining son has bought her her freedom, but himself remains a slave, and her home is derived from the charity of white abolitionists. Decidedly different life experiences, and yet, there are remarkable similarities in the excerpts. Each woman discovers a new awareness of the natural world which in turn leads to a recognition of her own heart. Their geographic journeys—Alexandra’s trip to gauge the potential of other farming locations and Baby Suggs’ movement from the plantation to free land—provide both women with the maps to orient themselves. Prior to these moments neither Alexandra nor Baby Suggs has had the leisure to contemplate her own place in the world. Opening themselves to the influence of the natural settings, the women are at last able to locate themselves in their environments. Identity and geography became personally intertwined in the “lives” of Alexandra Bergson and Baby Suggs. Another factor in determining identity is the audience. “‘Identity,’ though ostensibly a noun,” suggests Zygmunt Bauman, “behaves like a verb . . .” (19). It is an active operation, or, as Vaclav Havel deems it, “an accomplishment, a particular work, a particular act.”4 It is necessarily incomplete and ongoing. Maureen Whitebrook posits identity as expressing “something
96305_Russell_03_27.qxp
8
3/28/2006
11:18 AM
Page 8
Between the Angle and the Curve
of one’s self . . . for public consumption . . .” (6). Identity is selective, fragmentary. It is also intensely adaptable, she continues, needing to allow “that that expression may need to be modified by the reaction of others” (6). Cather and Morrison depict the flexible nature of identity in The Song of the Lark and Song of Solomon. Thea Kronborg, while a child, believes “public opinion could be placated” by mimicking mainstream behaviours (111). She alters her behaviour to accommodate the expectations of others; it is a feeble attempt to escape detection. Pilate Dead diminishes herself as a tactical maneuver. Bailing her nephew out of jail, she becomes “Louise Beaver and Butterfly McQueen;” she even appears to be shorter (205). Pilate “shrinks” herself, sacrificing her dignity and pride in order to attain her goal. Identity is an interactive process which is, to a large extent, shaped for, and by, the spectators. The performances may occur on several levels. They may involve appearance, public practices, or language use; the aim is to convey a particular persona or identity to others. Identity performance can therefore be a strategic act; it can defy or defuse, conceal or confirm. Willa Cather and Toni Morrison clearly recognized the potential for self-creation in the act of self-naming. Named Willela after an aunt, Cather rechristened herself Willa. It was the first in a series of relabellings: her middle name Love (for the doctor who delivered her) was transformed to Lova and finally replaced with Sibert in “recognition” of her namesake (so named by Willa herself ) William Seibert (the change in spelling should be noted— Cather subtly fashions her own identity). Biographical information on Morrison suggests her name shift was a slight one: Chloe Anthony Wofford became Toni Morrison after her marriage (and subsequent divorce). John N. Duvall reveals that the correct name was Chloe Ardelia Wofford— Anthony/Toni is in fact a fiction. Linking Morrison’s “gesture of authorial self-fashioning” to that of Cather, Duvall proposes that “as for Cather, authorship for Morrison seems to be in part a masculine activity” (35, 51). The other side of the coin is that in stepping into the “male” territory indicated by their chosen names, Cather and Morrison sought to challenge gender assumptions about identity. Self-identification is thus an exercise in (artistic) aggression as opposed to a concession on authorial authority. In point of fact, both Cather and Morrison retain feminine first names—Willa and Toni, not William or Tony—which undermine Duvall’s suppositions about authorship as a “masculine activity.” Artistic control was a grave concern for Cather in particular. The power she continues to exert over scholars who would like to utilize her private letters is well-documented. More insidious perhaps, has been Cather’s manipulation of the story of her “origins.” The widely quoted assertion that the
96305_Russell_03_27.qxp
3/28/2006
11:18 AM
Page 9
Where Am I and How Did I Get Here?
9
formative years of a writer’s life are eight to fifteen camouflages Cather’s southern beginnings. Identity—at least “officially”—becomes an act of omission in Cather’s hands. An anecdote from her southern childhood reveals that Cather recognized the subversive power of performing identity early on. She is reported to have told an old, patronizing judge: “I’se a dang’ous nigger, I is!” The incident suggests both an awareness of racial difference and a willingness to break from conventions via a startling stance. Self-definition serves as a statement of rebellion; Cather vehemently articulates her opinion of the judge’s perception of her. CONNECTING THE PIECES: IDENTITY FORMATION AND GROUP IDENTIFICATION THROUGH STORY-TELLING The act of self-construction is a crucial part of the development of identity; so too is the process of connection. “Self-designation,” concludes Priscilla L. Walton, is empowering; “to say is to assert, and to resist the broad label placed upon one by society at large” (133). Pride in “difference,” in connections to the non-mainstream groups, enhances an individual’s self-worth while defusing his/her isolation. Language functions as a site of resistance, of connection, and of potential liberation; by its very nature it requires an affiliation (however tenuous) with a community. “Inhabiting a language,” theorizes Ermarth, “means inhabiting a reality, and that so-called ‘reality’ . . . changes with the language” (410). The possibility of transformation lies in the material itself. “It is in language that people constitute themselves as subjects,” proposes Catherine Belsey (47). Speaking one’s story and hearing the stories of others is more than mere entertainment in this context; they are survival strategies.5 Textual space is as vital to identity formation as is geographic space. Story telling as an identification process is an ambiguous activity. Selfediting or self-censorship can obfuscate as much as it can explicate. Awareness of the audience (whether supportive or hostile) distorts the attempt at communication; narratives of identity can therefore shift over time and reshape themselves to suit specific situations. Counterstories—defined by Hilde Lindemann Nelson as “the cluster of histories, anecdotes, and other narrative fragments . . . [which] resist an oppressive identity . . .”—are vehicles of defiance and a means of insisting on recognition (6). Cathy Moses utilizes a stronger term for these “alternative” narratives—dissenting fictions. They “focus on identities forged in struggle,” on “the materiality of the excluded, of the marginalized body in history and in resistance struggles” (12, 3). Story telling is a political act; it reinforces both individual and collective identities.
96305_Russell_03_27.qxp
10
3/28/2006
11:18 AM
Page 10
Between the Angle and the Curve
It is an insistence on subjectivity and a demand for the inclusion of multiple voices/identities in the collective narrative.6 Stories are powerful tools for recording and recognizing histories which might otherwise be lost. They serve to protect and propagate connections which are vulnerable to being severed. Morrison’s Song of Solomon encapsulates the effects of disconnection: tragic consequences develop from the disruption of the Dead family’s story. Slaveholders clearly discerned the positive effects of shared tales. “Both during the crossing and in the New World,” observes Iyunolu Folayan Osagie, “slaves who shared similar language ties” were separated (44). The exercise in linguistic isolation was an attempt to defuse the “narratives of resistance . . . kept alive in slaves’ shared memory of cultural stories” (44). Denying cultural and personal memories by imposing language barriers was a tactic for robbing the captives of their identities. Jennifer Fleischer interprets the system of Southern slavery as an insidious “assault on each slave’s memory, a crucial basis of each person’s sense of self and reality” (27). Eradicating a collective base of knowledge disorients both the first set of victims and the subsequent generations. A pivotal resource for reinforcing identity is “lost” precisely when it is most needed. The process of stripping the slave of his/her humanity is an effective tactic for perpetuating the system of slavery. “Objects” cannot assert identity, nor can they insist upon basic human rights. It is a lesson in cruelty and propaganda graphically employed by the Nazis in World War II. The practice of slavery and the pursuit of the “Final Solution” had disturbingly similar effects on the identities of their victims. Film-maker France Akerman explains how the “repressed histories” of concentration camp survivors “returned to haunt the second generation . . . because they didn’t tell us about that past, because they didn’t pass it down to us, what they did pass down was . . . this sense of uprootedness” (Bergstrom, 98). In the silence, a gaping void is created. Again, the discontinuity distorts the identities of those who experience the denial first-hand and those who encounter its aftermath. Unable to access the oral histories of her parents and their communities, Akerman “searched for a false memory, a kind of imaginary, reconstructed memory rather than the truth . . .” (Bergstrom, 98). The need for knowledge, even if unreliable, is compelling. Resurrecting the past is a vital (and revitalizing) task for all victims of oppression. Recovering memory is a restatement of subjectivity. Landscapes of memory surface in many of Cather’s and Morrison’s novels; they connect (in some cases re-connect) characters with lost or forgotten experiences necessary for identity formation. Authors of slave narratives in particular, concludes Fleischer, “cross over the threshold of visibility into cultural memory
96305_Russell_03_27.qxp
3/28/2006
11:18 AM
Where Am I and How Did I Get Here?
Page 11
11
[through their narratives], they effectively steal themselves back . . .” (3). While “steal” is a troubling choice—it implies the unlawful removal of a lawful possession—Fleischer’s recognition that identity can be re-established through story telling is perceptive. Collective stories provide a context for individual remembrances. “Corporate memory,” defined by Elizabeth Rauh Bethel as “the memories of families, of communities, and of generations,” affords “critical evaluation and reinterpretation to the individualized experience . . .” (vii). Meaning is enhanced by knowledge of similar or shared circumstances. Studies in social psychology “suggest that group identity is fundamental to the construction of self-identity,” summarizes Osagie (24). The need for a connection with members of a sympathetic group is particularly intense for oppressed or marginalized individuals. While the goals and identity of the collective may differ from those of the person, there is a reassuring strength in numbers. The pursuit of a “counter collective memory”—a recognition of the missing groups in Maurice Halbwachs’ term—is not simply an exercise in “feeling better.” It is a necessary step in establishing identity. The formulation of “remembrance communities,” observes Odile Jansen, expanding upon Halbwachs’ work, is a common trait of “groups with a weak power status” whose “memories and narratives are like the undercurrents of a river within the dominant collective memory” (37). Neither entirely silenced nor completely subsumed by the mainstream “narrative,” these remembrance communities afford much needed respite from the assault of an “official” story which ignores, if not denies, the possibility of their existence. “History,” asserts Robert Young, “is the realm of violence and war; it constitutes another form by which the other is appropriated into the same” (15). Accommodation is not the practice of history. Young concludes, “for the other to remain other it must not derive its meaning from history but must instead have a separate time which differs from historical time” (15). The danger in historical appropriation is the loss of any identity which counters the “norm.” Memory, or rather its suppression, argues Ernest Renan, “is a crucial factor in the creation of a nation. . . . the essence of a nation is that all individuals have many things in common and also that they have forgotten many things” (11). Denial and distortion of facts, Renan contends, are a necessary part of the growth of a nation. The formation of America is frequently represented through the use of birth imagery. The myth of an empty land nurtured into life has a strong emotional and artistic resonance. It has little or no factual support; the land was not unpeopled, nor was it free to be claimed by the settler willing to “civilize” it. The removal of Native Americans, Mike Fischer insists, “was seen as
96305_Russell_03_27.qxp
12
3/28/2006
11:18 AM
Page 12
Between the Angle and the Curve
a sine qua non for successful white settlement” (31). Accommodating the existing inhabitants did not mesh with the drive to establish a “new” country. The history of settlement has been sanitized. Building communities, Marilyn R. Chandler observes, “meant suppressing the guilt attached to violent expropriation of land . . .” (1). Romanticizing the dwindling tribes was a widespread tactic; the phrase “Vanishing American” was deliberately misleading. “The Indians did not simply vanish,” notes Janis P. Stout, “the process was not nearly so innocuous as that. But the notion became widely accepted because it so soothed the national conscience” (158). Knowledge of the violent origins of America was (and in many ways still is) too disconcerting to face. Recontextualizing the “process” of the country’s development fulfilled a psychological need of its new inhabitants. Birthing a nation is another means of circumventing the violent destruction of the indigenous peoples. It too operates on the premise that there existed only raw materials for a country and not a “recognizable” country. In Birthing A Nation: Gender, Creativity and the West in American Literature, Susan J. Rosowski proposes a provocative reading of Henry David Thoreau’s landmark text Walden. She asserts that “Thoreau shaped his sojourn in nature into the female version of creation demanded by the American challenge to give birth to a nation” (6). As evidence Rosowski cites the fact that two years, two months, and two days are compressed into one year with two distinct parts: “the first is a brief prefatory period of three months during which Thoreau accomplishes conventionally male pioneer tasks: he clears the land, hews timber, and constructs a cabin. The second consists of his nine months’ residency, and it culminates in multiple births—of spring, of himself as a writer, and of a new nation” (6). Thoreau “births” a nation through his writing—the positive interaction with nature obscures the historical facts of land appropriation (Thoreau does not appropriate the land on a literal level but does so on a literary level)—and peoples it—out of his experience is born the mythical American man: self-sufficient, at ease in his environment, and a perceptive philosopher. The “American Dream” has become a trite phrase, but its allure inspired many a migration. “America as both locale and dream,” note Werner Sollors and Maria Diedrich, “was nonexistent in the African cosmology” (4). The first Africans came, not as pioneers, but as prisoners and property. It was a decidedly different experience of the new country for the slave than for the European immigrant. Sollors and Diedrich emphasize the fact that “whereas Columbus conquered ‘new’ lands for Europeans, thus increasing their mobility and freedom and providing them with new perspectives, the African diaspora stands for the end of freedom, for the loss of perspec-
96305_Russell_03_27.qxp
3/28/2006
11:18 AM
Page 13
Where Am I and How Did I Get Here?
13
tives . . .” (5). For an immigrant (whatever the motivation for relocation), the change in location serves as an escape (whether from something, or to something); possibility and hope are evoked by the concept of “America.” For the captive, enforced relocation is a movement from freedom to imprisonment; the reality of the brutal journey and the conditions of slavery prevent the individual from “recognizing” America as a “land of possibility.” Traditionally, the myth of America has not had room for this “alternative” reality. To insist on the existence of alternative memories, to refuse to “forget,” is to challenge the foundation of the nation. Exposing the structural supports of history-mis-remembering, forced forgetting—opens up a space of possibility. It is in effect a way of expanding “borders.” Multiplicity of identity destabilizes fixed notions of national identity. It can be an invigorating and/or terrifying journey. The new territory is spacious enough to accommodate multiple narratives, thereby extending the national story in the process. Willa Cather and Toni Morrison have been active participants in this literary expansionism. Rejecting the restrictive expectations frequently imposed upon American writers, each author embraces her own vision of story telling and “appropriate” subject matter; the results are bodies of fiction rich in details of uniquely American life experiences and landscapes. SHARED TERRITORIES: DISTINCTIVE YET SIMILAR TECHNIQUES A common interest in issues of identity and space take Cather and Morrison over a great deal of similar terrain. Starting from personal geographic touchstones (frequently, but by no means exclusively, the prairie and the southwest for Cather and the midwest for Morrison) the two create landscapes which feature immensity and intimacy. The novels reveal a shared interest in the emotional and psychological effects of landmarks. Multiple and interconnected landscapes add depth to the already evocative and provocative stories. Dreamscapes and geometrical nightmares are interjected through startling visual effects—a distorted tree in Death Comes For the Archbishop, a freefloating door/window in Paradise—while sensory reminders trigger shadowscapes—music in The Song of the Lark, ginger in Song of Solomon. Forays into the geography of memory further illustrate the complexity of space. Places, in the fiction of Cather and Morrison, are multilayered, having both visual/tangible aspects and imaginative/ethereal attributes. Energy and movement characterize their representations of the physical environment; landscape takes on a personality of its own. Moving within and outside the
96305_Russell_03_27.qxp
14
3/28/2006
11:18 AM
Page 14
Between the Angle and the Curve
traditional depiction of the garden, the country versus city dynamic, and the sexualized landscape, both authors redefine and expand the places open to women. They play with the expectations raised by such symbols. Situating their characters in naturally occurring womb/rooms (caves, caverns, nests, and bowers), houses, and the larger physical and spiritual communities, Cather and Morrison imply that both natural and constructed, open and enclosed spaces are important factors in the shaping of identity. Critics have approached Cather and Morrison—separately—from a multitude of directions. Their works have been examined in terms of style, language, imagery, and literary influences; feminists, historians, linguists and even television personalities (specifically Oprah Winfrey) have sought to decipher their meanings. My interest lies in the treatment of humanmade and naturally occurring shelters, the representation of the landscape—both natural and human (physical and social settings)—how the spaces and places they occupy are reflected in (and reflect) specific characters, and perhaps most significantly, the ways in which “home” and “landscape” interrelate in the fiction of Cather and Morrison. Shared areas of concern, for both critics of Cather and Morrison and the writers themselves, include: the significance of the home,7 notions of confinement and movement,8 the relationship between identity and place,9 the importance of the land,10 gendered landscapes,11 and gendered responses to nature.12 While the pair has received attention in these categories individually, openings exist for critical inquiry examining Cather and Morrison together, and re-examining conclusions about single novels in the context of a larger body of work. UNRAVELING THE THEORY OF SPACE: ESTABLISHING COMMON GROUND While my emphasis will first and foremost be upon the novels themselves, I will draw upon theories of geography, psychology, social anthropology, philosophy, architecture and ecofeminism. “Space,” “place,” and “landscape” are potentially slippery terms which are often interchanged, but are in fact quite different. A brief survey of the definitions of these terms would be a useful prelude to a statement of their scope within the parameters of this project. Discovering common theoretical ground is necessary to appreciate the uncommon literary “ground” Cather and Morrison explore, and create, in their fiction. Space in particular has been approached from a variety of perspectives. Gaston Bachelard specifically concentrates on “felicitous space,” emphasizing
96305_Russell_03_27.qxp
3/28/2006
11:18 AM
Where Am I and How Did I Get Here?
Page 15
15
“the human value of the sorts of space that may be grasped, that may be defended against adverse forces, the space we love” (xxxi).13 Within his very particular framework Bachelard contends that “space that has been seized upon by the imagination cannot remain indifferent space subject to the measures and estimates of the surveyor” (xxxii). The space itself is altered by the interaction with the individual. It is a measurable entity (“estimates of the surveyor”) but a malleable one (“seized upon by the imagination”). Bachelard expands the concept of space to incorporate the experience of the individual, but only experiences of a positive nature. Refusing to address the existence of “hostile space” creates a noticeable void in Bachelard’s philosophy, as does his assertion that the “space of hatred and combat can only be studied in the context of impassioned subject matter and apocalyptic images” (xxxii). The discussion of the representation of space in the fiction of Cather and Morrison in the subsequent chapters of this study reveals that the “combat” can, and does, take a more subtle form. The experience of space (particularly, but not exclusively) for female characters all too often incorporates the negative. Hostile space must be taken into account in any comprehensive analysis. Binaries are in fact commonplace in theories of space. Henri Lefebvre identifies “ideal” and “real” spaces. “Perceptual space” and “lived space” are E. Relph’s terms for categorizing space. Claudine Herrmann separates physical and mental spaces. The list of critics employing the “either/or” approach is a lengthy one. While the labels may vary, the implication of an oppositional relationship lingers. Classifying by categories suggests rigid divisions, but the possibility of interpenetrability subtly undermines such a position. The spaces, although linguistically exclusive, are in fact mutually dependent—each is defined against the other and the “boundaries” frequently blur. Penetrability and accessibility are central concerns in the distribution and maintenance of space. Issues of access and exclusion, control and defenselessness, surface repeatedly in the varied spaces Cather and Morrison include in their fiction. The complexity of space is evident in the multiple definitions Webster’s Third New International Dictionary of the English Language provides. In short, space is both “a lapse of time between two points in time” and “a specified quantity of time.” It is “a part marked off or bounded in some way” and “an unobstructed area (as of land).” Space is “the shaped volume defined by architectural forms (as walls, roofs, courts, and wings)” and the “part of space unaltered by the removal of a material object.” It is “the region beyond the earth’s atmosphere . . . all of the universe beyond the solar system” and “a blank interval between words or lines in written or printed matter.”
96305_Russell_03_27.qxp
16
3/28/2006
11:18 AM
Page 16
Between the Angle and the Curve
The formal definition reinforced (and expanded) my sense of the term. In my reading space has generally been a rather vague, abstract term suggesting open territory, free from human development, more to do with nature than structures. Further study has emphasized the ambiguity of the word; the prevalence of binaries (implied and/or explicit) complicates the act of definition. Inside/outside, mental/social, perceptual/existential, psychological/physical—these pairings speak to the enigmatic quality of space. They suggest (but do not necessarily sustain) contradiction, opposition. My use of the term incorporates each of these couplings, but emphasizes their interconnectedness; categories are useful organizational features (particulary when dealing with such a slippery concept as space), but the neat divisions they imply cannot, and do not, exist. The other problem with divisions of space into pairs is the air of “inevitability” suggested by the technique. Identifying “natural” distinctions in effect camouflages their use as a tactic of control and containment. “Place,” at least on the surface, does lend itself to compact and concise categories. Drawing once again upon the authority of Webster’s Dictionary, place is deemed the “physical environment [or] surroundings;” “ a building or locality used for a specific purpose;” “ a particular region or center of population;” “an individual dwelling or estate;” “ a fortified military post;” “ a particular portion of a surface; specific locality; spot;” “ relative position in the social scale; degree of prestige;” “a proper or designated niche;” “an available seat or accommodation.” Space is an expansive term; place denotes the particular, the specific within space. Place is measured off space. It is often distinguished by a specific use or purpose. Place can indicate structures or physical geography, or the position of a person or a group of persons. It thus names, classifies, and, seemingly, contains through definition. Place can create security (protective enclosures) or a sense of confinement (“protective” enclosures). There is a human element to place; in the act of construction, of naming, physical geography is humanized.14 Landscape, like place, incorporates a human element. In its strictest definition, according to Webster’s Dictionary, landscape is a “picture representing a view of natural scenery (as fields, hills, forests, water);” “ the art of depicting such scenery;” “the surface of the earth; the land forms of a region in the aggregate especially as produced or modified by geological forces;” “ a portion of land or territory that the eye can comprehend in a single view including all the objects so seen;” “ vista, prospect.” As a verb landscape means “to make a landscape of; to improve by landscape architecture or gardening.” Landscape, in this sense, begins with nature, but it is a natural setting which has been “improved” (some might argue distorted) whether by
96305_Russell_03_27.qxp
3/28/2006
11:18 AM
Where Am I and How Did I Get Here?
Page 17
17
pruning shears or paintbrush. There are two components to landscape: the viewed (the “natural”) and the viewer (complete with whatever emotional and intellectual baggage he or she brings to the interpretation). A broader connotation emphasizes the surrounding features (natural and/or constructed) of a particular setting. The details the eye takes in comprise the landscape; it is a wide terrain reduced to a “manageable” view. Physical surroundings and human social practices are key factors in the definitions of landscape. D. W. Meinig proposes that “landscape is related to, but not identical with, nature” (2). More than the physical environment is incorporated in the term landscape; it is Meinig’s assertion that “any landscape is composed not only of what lies before our eyes but what lies within our heads” (34). The individual viewer shapes the landscape based upon his or her perceptions. Detached observation of the vista is an impossibility; associations and expectations infuse our interpretations. Nor can personal responses be entirely separated from collective ones; socialization is an inescapable factor in our modes of reasoning. Personal and cultural meaning are imposed on, and reflected in, the landscapes we encounter and create. The term landscape has been expanded to incorporate such modifiers as: economic, social, political, literary, and critical; in the process the initial link to the natural world has been weakened (and in some cases, obliterated). Sharon Zukin’s work on cultural landscapes is useful; specifically the recognition that systems of power lie behind the structures imposed on physical geography, and that the landscapes of the “powerful” and the “powerless” both create the panorama. My use of the terms landscape, place and space recognizes the hidden power structures that lurk behind the standard connotations. Issues of definition and counter-definition, of access to and control of, and the far-reaching implications of the division of space, place, and landscape are all facets of my approach to the fiction of Cather and Morrison. One of the conventional representations of space that Cather and Morrison work with, and against, is gendered space. The assumption of a division of space along gender lines has a variety of sources; one particularly insidious approach links woman with nature. Feminists, Gillian Rose proposes, “have discussed the distinction between Nature and Culture at some length, because they see it as one of those oppositions which are heavily gendered and power-ridden” (68). If woman is viewed as being close to nature, such a model concludes, then she is excluded from culture. The intellectual, political and social implications of such a simplistic equation are staggering. “Appropriate” places based upon gender are reinforced by citing the “self-evident facts.” To argue against the binary is to confront a system of beliefs
96305_Russell_03_27.qxp
18
3/28/2006
11:18 AM
Page 18
Between the Angle and the Curve
about biological differences, social practices, and theories of identity with a weighty history behind it. Simone de Beauvoir’s landmark text, The Second Sex, (1949), courageously tackles the theoretical approach which asserts that the masculine is associated with culture while the feminine is associated with nature. Man, as a result of this rationalization, is able to dominate and manipulate both woman and environment. It is a dichotomy which she opposes, but powerfully articulates. Woman, a negation as the result of the male subject setting “himself up as the essential as opposed to the other, the inessential, the object,” is a blank space to be imposed upon (xx). Beauvoir challenges the definition of “woman as womb” pointing out the (seemingly) obvious fact that man too has glands that “secrete hormones” (xviii). Perhaps most importantly, Beauvoir questions the implicit power dynamic which stems from the explicit hierarchy of man being aligned with culture and woman with nature. She notes man’s troubled relationship with nature: . . . we know what ambivalent feelings Nature inspires in man. He exploits her, but she crushes him, he is born of her and dies in her; she is the source of his being and the realm that he subjugates to his will; Nature is a vein of gross material in which the soul is imprisoned, and she is the Supreme reality, she is contingence and Idea, the finite and the whole. . . . (162)
The exchange between man and nature/woman is a violent one in Beauvoir’s assessment. Combat seems to characterize the interaction and aggression is not limited to one side. Superiority and fear mingle in the masculine equation “woman equals nature;” containment and resistance collide behind the illusion of control. Forty-two years later, Elizabeth Wilson theorizes that the binary Beauvoir identified persists: “mapped on to the opposition of city and country, culture and nature, is male and female: man is culture and woman is the earth” (17).15 The division has achieved self-sustaining status. It is presented as reflecting the “natural” order; spatial systems are thus descriptive, not prescriptive. “Gender systems,” Alcoff adamantly asserts, are the result of power struggles, not nature (21). It is a conflict with a long history. The mind/body split Beauvoir and countless other feminist scholars16 have sought to refute has almost a timeless quality.17 Time and scholarly tomes have created an air of inevitability in the mind/body, male/female dichotomy.
96305_Russell_03_27.qxp
3/28/2006
11:18 AM
Page 19
Where Am I and How Did I Get Here?
19
Woman as body and man as mind is problematic, not to mention a gross over-simplification. Reconfiguring this line of reasoning, HollyYoungbear-Tibbetts casts the connection between woman and her physiology in a much more favourable light. She asserts that . . . irrespective of the cultural conditionings . . . Whatever reality may be, our human delimination to three-dimensional life draws its spatial intelligence from the lessons of that initial intimate maternal landscape as well as subsequent landscapes of individual and collective experience. (32)
The female form introduces us to the tactile realm; these initial lessons colour succeeding geographic experiences and, more specifically, our sense of the world. The maternal body, in Youngbear-Tibbetts’ assessment, is a powerful paradigm and an invaluable source of information. It is the centre of geographic knowledge and the origin of personal knowledge (understanding the distinction between “her” and “I” is the first step in recognizing subjectivity). The identification of body and landscape is, however, often read in a more negative light. It is an equation which lends itself to exploitation.18 Physical locations are frequently read (and written) as gendered. The world is, at least symbolically, divided into masculine and feminine spaces. A myriad of voices has shaped the discourse on gendered space; one of the more pervasive has been that of Sigmund Freud—both through his own texts and by echoes in the compositions of countless others (many who reject his psychoanalytical theories nonetheless utilize his comments on spatial imagery). Freud’s work on dream imagery specifically draws upon biological (and visual) differences between the sexes to account for psychological and emotional differences. Female genitals, he contends, are represented by boxes, chests, pockets, ships, churches, and jewel-cases; whereas sticks, umbrellas, posts, and trees are substituted for the male genitals. Male organs are (not too surprisingly) projectiles. Female organs appear as locations— containers or vessels. Sexual differences are anchored in concrete objects in Freud’s theory of dream imagery. Emil A. Gutheil continues in this vein in his exploration of dream symbols. Substitutes for the phallus include: an “umbrella (opening signifies erection), hat, necktie, sail, flagpole, key, fishing pole, fountain pen . . . all types of rifles, guns, swords, knives . . .” (53). A “bag, wound, nest, cavern, ring, target, muff, door (front door), window, pot, box, cage . . . drawer” can read as representing the vagina (56). Putting aside the highly subjective nature of dream analysis as a diagnostic tool, even a novice interpreter can
96305_Russell_03_27.qxp
20
3/28/2006
11:18 AM
Page 20
Between the Angle and the Curve
recognize the mimetic relationship between projectiles or (structural) erections and the penis, and containers or receptacles and the vagina. Visually, anatomy and article blend, but such approaches presume a simplistic equation—man acts and woman passively receives—which masks complex issues and interactions.19 It is precisely the complexities of space and identity which Cather and Morrison explore in their novels. While the gendered division of space most frequently reads as a simplistic equation—for example, masculine equals public, feminine equals private—the same cannot be said for the depiction of specifically maternal spaces. Womb imagery abounds in literature and theory, and ambiguity frequently surrounds its symbolism. Simultaneously life-giving and life-threatening, not surprisingly, it is often a source of anxiety. Beauvoir interprets the womb, “secret and sealed like a tomb” (165), as particularly problematic for men: . . . many young men adventure not without anxiety into the secret dark of woman, once more feeling childhood’s terror at the threshold of a cave or tomb, its fright at jaws, scythes, traps: they fancy that the swollen penis may be caught in the mucus sheath. (429)
Emasculation, infantilization, the mystery (and dread) of the unknown— woman (or more specifically womb) as Other is a terrifying territory in Beauvoir’s analysis. It is a space which defies man’s control. In the process it exposes the fragile basis of his “superior” position. The scientific drive to master problems of fertility and discover a means of recreating life outside the womb are perhaps attempts to deal “rationally” with the terror Beauvoir describes. If only visually, the test tube and the Petridish recreate the angle/curve polarity.20 Victor Turner offers a similar assessment of the womb; he links it to liminality. The womb, like liminality, represents a state “betwixt and between the positions assigned and arrayed by law, custom, convention, and ceremonial” (95). It is a space in which identity is both lost and created. In her analysis of Colette’s Le Toutounier Ann Leone Philbrick also reads the womblike space as an enigmatic threshold which is “at once regenerative and smothering.” It is the “refusal to lock these forces into a clear didactic,” Philbrick contends, which results in the “ambiguity of familiar spaces that affirm and undo identity” (32). The use of womb imagery in literature is readily identifiable, but recognition has by no means decreased the ambiguity or mystery of this specialized spatial symbol. Contemplative site and prison, the womb is both beginning and end (and frequently beginning
96305_Russell_03_27.qxp
3/28/2006
11:18 AM
Page 21
Where Am I and How Did I Get Here?
21
again). Maternal spaces represent the power of regeneration and termination; they hold both a promise and a threat. Rejecting the either/or insistence of categories like public/private, exterior/interior, Cather and Morrison expand the places open to women. They do not negate the importance of the home or sheltering spaces; in fact they honour them. However, they also acknowledge the significance of the larger world—natural spaces, community, sacred sites—and accordingly situate their characters in environments replete with variety, contrasting and conflicting spaces, and spaces that challenge the very core of identity. The expansive visions of Cather and Morrison push against the boundaries of gendered spaces. Images, not of flight or evasion, but connection dominate their fiction; connections which are frequently painful, but ultimately fulfilling, and above all, necessary. RECONTEXTUALIZING PERSONAL TERRITORIES On the surface Willa Cather and Toni Morrison seem to share little more than gender and career choice. One was born in Virginia and claimed that her formative years were spent in Nebraska, the other in Ohio; Cather died in 1947, Morrison is a contemporary writer. Cather was childless and is frequently identified as a lesbian while Morrison is a divorced mother of two sons. Cather was white and Morrison is African American. Biographical differences reveal only part of the picture; in many ways, literary similarities bridge the distance created by time, race, and personal experiences. Both Cather and Morrison received university educations, were teachers, worked in the publishing industry. Most significantly, both reveal a gift for writing lyrical and evocative prose. In point of fact the literary lives of the two authors do intersect—at least briefly—in Morrison’s Playing in the Dark: Whiteness and the Literary Imagination. Referring to Sapphira and the Slave Girl, Morrison reads Cather as working “out and toward the meaning of female betrayal as it faces the void of racism. She may not have arrived safely, like Nancy, but to her credit she did undertake the dangerous journey” (28). Acknowledging the attempt rather than the result—the tone is one of grudging respect—Morrison confirms that she is familiar with at least one of Cather’s novels. A discussion of the representation of space in the writings of Cather and Morrison would be incomplete without an examination of the intersection of race and space. Spatial divisions clearly occur along multiple lines, but race is a key determinant in the experience of space in America. While, as Gayle Wald theorizes, “racial, class and gender discourses are mutually
96305_Russell_03_27.qxp
22
3/28/2006
11:18 AM
Page 22
Between the Angle and the Curve
reinforcing and inextricably linked” they cannot be collapsed into one another (9). The experiences Morrison documents are based upon very different histories from those of Cather’s characters. Enforced relocation and objectification leave a unique legacy. Emigration in the pursuit of a better life carries its own fears and hardships, but the very journey suggests a degree of autonomy (indentured servitude is another matter, but it too holds out the hope of freedom). Land ownership in America was a mark of freedom for emancipated slaves. European immigrants to America must also have viewed the land as an emblem of personal independence, but their travels to a new land were (at least on the surface) a matter of choice (albeit one shaped by a need to escape pogroms, poverty, and personal persecution) as opposed to being the result of captivity. Achieving the goal of land ownership was nonetheless a decidedly different process for white and black farmers. The passage of the Homestead Act in 1862, at least theoretically, cleared the way for white settlers to earn their land through five years of cultivation. In practice, as Henry Nash Smith observes, “between the passage of the Homestead Act in 1862 and 1890, only 372,659 entries were perfected. At most, two millions of persons . . . could have benefited . . . during a period when the population of. . . . the Western states within which most of the homesteading took place, [increased] by more than ten millions” (190). Although by no means a wide-scale success, the Homestead Act nevertheless offered opportunity and encouragement to white settlers. While the free-soil mentality rejected the extension of slavery into the territories, it also resisted the presence of black farmers. The “image of the yeoman with which the farmers of the Northwest identified themselves was a free-soil symbol” proposes Smith. He concludes, “the classless society of the fee-simple empire had no place for the Negro” (173). The Homestead Act did not address the ramifications of slavery although it did deter its spread. The invitation to the frontier(s) implied egalitarianism, but reinforced racial boundaries along spatial lines. Historical differences in the experience of space echo in present day spatial divisions. Despite social, economic, political and geographical inequities, Morrison articulates the distinction between black and white perceptions of space as (at least imaginatively) favouring the black individual. She addresses the intersection of race, space and gender in an interview with Claudia Tate: It seems to me there’s an enormous difference in the writing of black and white women. Aggression is not as new to black women as it is to white women. Black women seem able to combine the nest and the
96305_Russell_03_27.qxp
3/28/2006
11:18 AM
Page 23
Where Am I and How Did I Get Here?
23
adventure. They don’t see conflicts in certain areas as do white women. They are both safe harbor and ship; they are both inn and trail. We, black women, do both. We don’t find these places, these roles, mutually exclusive. (122)
Race supersedes gender as the central factor in Morrison’s equation. Identity is linked to interior and exterior locations. It is adaptable to, and can accommodate the demands of each setting. Racism inadvertently creates a (potentially) empowering space. “Black men and women,” Kimberlé Crenshaw observes, “live in a society that creates sex-based norms and expectations which racism operates simultaneously to deny . . .” (222). For black women, not being tied to the limiting definition of “lady” can permit the fuller experience of being a woman. Morrison recontextualizes the process of exclusion: white women are denied access to the broadest range of practices. It is striking, however, that she refers to women, regardless of race, in spatial terms: nest, harbor, and inn. Her assertion that black women have the adroitness to combine what are generally posited as oppositions—adventure and safety, stasis and movement—is quite provocative; Morrison claims an ability to envision and create a place outside the traditional gendered division of space. I believe this assertion is an accurate assessment of her fiction, but question her exclusion of white women writers from this process of defining an alternative territory. Both Toni Morrison and Willa Cather, as this study will demonstrate (particularly the final chapter), create a hybrid space which challenges standard representations of gendered space. LOOKING BEYOND BIOGRAPHY: CREATIVE CONNECTIONS BETWEEN CATHER AND MORRISON Despite differences in life experience, the two authors share strong literary similarities. An examination of their theories and practices reveals that the seeming distance between the women is, to a large extent, creatively bridged by the art they generate. In their own fiction and comments on the criteria for effective writing Cather and Morrison occupy a great deal of common ground. Each novelist demands active participation from her readers; the imaginative involvement of the audience is integral to the creative process. Cather describes the design of the text as being pared down: “whatever is felt upon the page without being specifically named there—that, one might say, is created. It is the inexplicable presence of the thing not named, of the overtone divined by the ear but not heard by it the verbal mood . . .” (On Writing, 41).
96305_Russell_03_27.qxp
24
3/28/2006
11:18 AM
Page 24
Between the Angle and the Curve
Implication and suggestion rather than overloading the novel with unnecessary details, Cather theorizes, are the best methods for writing an effective story. The approach implies a confidence in the ability (and willingness) of the reader to flesh out the skeletal details and to name “the thing not named.” Morrison’s expectations are equally high: “my writing expects, demands participatory reading, and that I think is what literature is supposed to do. My language has to have holes and spaces so the reader can come into it.”21 The creative process of the text does not end with the printed word on the page. What the novel does and does not contain, what language can and cannot convey, are all catalysts for the reader. Meaning is conveyed through, and discovered in, a variety of forms: implications, allusions, patterns of imagery, and symbolically charged settings among other sources. PIECING TOGETHER THE PUZZLE: AN OUTLINE OF THE PROJECT Having claimed my territory, it would be useful to provide a map of the terrain I will be covering. Chapter Two: “Background Foregrounded: The Significance of Setting or ‘Don’t Skip the Descriptive Bits,’” shifts into textual analysis with an eye towards illustrating the importance of place in the fiction of Cather and Morrison. Setting is crucial in the stories in this study. By exploiting the use of nature as an organizational feature, the natural world as “character,” and the humanized landscape, the link between identity and place is clarified. Layered landscapes—literal and literary, living and non-living, real and surreal—reinforce the complexities of space, place, and identity. The drive to locate the familiar in an unfamiliar terrain (particularly through the desire for comforting landmarks) provides insight into character formation. Naming is a tactic frequently employed in an effort to de-mystify an alien environment. Chapter Three: “Maneuvering Through the Maternal Landscape: Traditions, Tropes, and New Techniques,” moves from the general setting to the specifically sexualized landscape and tradition of gendered spaces. Efforts to familiarize natural spaces include approaching the territory as body—specifically as a female body ripe for male exploration and exploitation—and/or garden—domestication is also represented as a form of male conquest. Cather and Morrison reject such depictions of the land by exploring symbolically charged settings like the virgin land, the garden, the country/city opposition, and the landscape as body/body as landscape motif. Issues of autonomy complicate experiences of space and place, but the impulse to domesticate natural spaces is highlighted by both authors.
96305_Russell_03_27.qxp
3/28/2006
11:18 AM
Where Am I and How Did I Get Here?
Page 25
25
From gendered landscapes and naturally occurring womb-rooms the analysis will turn to the concept of home in Chapter Four: “Home, Hearth and Harpies: Discovering a Space of One’s Own in the Domestic Sphere.” The naturalization of domestic places—home as an extension of nature—is crucial to the positive depictions of the home in the writings of Cather and Morrison. Womb-rooms as shelters/refuges and political spaces dominate the stories. Sites of (potential) connection, they are key elements in the formulation of identity. The complexities of the home—shelter can become prison—are explored and a redefinition of the home as a place of connection and mutual responsibility is asserted. The landscape of connection so prevalent in the novels is highlighted in Chapter Five: “‘This Way to the Egress:’ Exiting Thoughts on the Cartography of Connection.” The importance of the community—mainstream and communities of choice—in the development of identity is stressed in this section. Isolation is exposed as a dangerous path while genuine relationships offer the possibility of security and happiness. Sacred spaces—nature, the humanized natural world, and the spaces occupied by sacred symbols—assist in the quest for connection. The issue of whether or not interactions with the natural environment are gendered is addressed by Cather and Morrison. They play with expectations, challenging spatial models based upon hierarchies and rigid dichotomies. In the process a hybrid territory beyond the boundaries of masculine and feminine space emerges—a place between the angle and the curve.
96305_Russell_03_27.qxp
3/28/2006
11:18 AM
Page 26
96305_Russell_03_27.qxp
3/28/2006
11:18 AM
Page 27
Chapter Two
Background Foregrounded: The Significance of Setting or “Don’t Skip the Descriptive Bits”
Identity—individual and collective—is inseparable from setting. Whether it is a positive or negative influence, the environment must be acknowledged in any consideration of character. The diverse and seemingly unconnected physical terrains encountered in the texts of Cather and Morrison—prairie and plantation, desert and tropics, countryside and cityscape, Southwest and Midwest, North and South—speak to the tremendous richness of the American literary landscape. Immensity and intimacy are key features in the settings created by Cather and Morrison. Mythic material for provocative and enduring stories, the geography of America affords each author a crucial element of tale telling. Several distinct landscapes emerge in the works of Cather and Morrison: for Cather, the prairie and the Southwestern canyon country are often central locales (New York City, Quebec and Virginia also appear in her novels), while Morrison frequently incorporates the rural south, Midwestern towns, and northeastern cities. Personal landscapes provide fertile starting grounds for imaginative works. Their connections to specific places have furnished both Cather and Morrison with creative centres; the two are linked in that the geography of memory surfaces in their fiction and is “expressed in the language of space.”1 Fryer concentrates on the influence of the Southwest on Cather’s artistic voice: “Center implies circumference, a place in space. To find the center of one’s boundless desire, to give it form, is to begin in a space that is felicitous, one that frees the imagination. For Cather, the American Southwest was such a liberating space, one to which she returned, as to a touchstone” (Prairie Schooner, 29). It is a landscape which is recreated in several of 27
96305_Russell_03_27.qxp
28
3/28/2006
11:18 AM
Page 28
Between the Angle and the Curve
Cather’s novels and short stories. It resonates with artistic and emotional significance. Fryer acknowledges that the Southwest is not Cather’s sole geographic influence, but offers a fairly compelling argument that it is the primary touchstone. While I wholeheartedly accept the imaginative importance of the Southwest in Cather’s fiction, I believe that her prairie and southern experiences must also be recognized as “felicitous” spaces which free the imagination. Much critical attention has been focused on the importance of Cather’s prairie years; her fictional representations of being relocated to this unique terrain (whether from Europe or the American South) have been analyzed from a variety of perspectives. Discussions of her Southern roots have been slower to surface; Cather herself dismissed her beginnings through her statement about the formative years of an artist (which coincide with her relocation to Nebraska). Southern influences can, however, be traced in several of her novels. Transplanted Southerners appear in My Antonia and A Lost Lady, and in Sapphira and the Slave Girl Cather returns to the land of her childhood. Judith Fetterley assumes a provocative position, arguing that Cather “could construct Nebraska as a subject for art precisely because she came to it at a certain age and as an outsider, an immigrant” (Romines, 13). A degree of detachment and an openness to new experiences accompanied the child’s move; they served the adult writer well. Familiar territory is a key factor in Toni Morrison’s fiction. Geography becomes an artistic element in the hands of a gifted writer. In an interview with Claudia Tate, Morrison speaks of her own geographic touchstone: “I am from the Midwest so I have a special affection for it. My beginnings are always there. No matter what I write, I begin there. I may abandon this focus at some point, but for now it’s the matrix for me” (119). The places experienced during her youth and maturation are linked to Morrison’s fictional process. Lorain, Ohio, specifically serves as the setting for The Bluest Eye, but its influence, Morrison asserts, surfaces in each of her works. Literary landscapes, in the fiction of Morrison and Cather, are infused with the emotional responses evoked by literal environments in the authors’ lives. The shapes, moods, and characters of these specific locales are woven into the fabric of the narratives. LITERARY LANDSCAPES: SUBSTANCE AND STYLE What might be dismissed as “mere” background in fiction, the physical setting of the story, is subtly foregrounded in the writings of Cather and Morrison. Open or natural spaces, the places where identity is honed, and the
96305_Russell_03_27.qxp
3/28/2006
Background Foregrounded
11:18 AM
Page 29
29
larger cultural landscape are key components. Each thread must be recognized in order to appreciate the beauty and complexity of the tales Cather and Morrison weave; a great deal of information is encoded in their landscapes. The bold and disturbing assertion of a former student—“editing out the descriptive bits saves time on reading”—reveals the mindset against which instructors and authors must all too often struggle. The assumption that details of landscape, whether it is natural or social, are mere “filler” obscures the manifold function of the unique environments which are meticulously (re)created in the novels in this study. A review of the term “pathetic fallacy”—”the attribution to natural objects of human capacities and feelings”—suggests one reason for not “pruning the greenery.” The term was introduced by John Ruskin in 1856 (Modern Painters, Volume III, Chapter 12). It was not a compliment. As the entry in A Glossary of Literary Terms observes, “as used by Ruskin—for whom ‘truth’ was a primary artistic criterion—the term was derogatory, since it applies to descriptions, not of the ‘true appearances of things to us,’ but of ‘the extraordinary, or false appearances, when we are under the influence of emotion, or contemplative fancy’” (129). Cather and Morrison do inject their landscapes with the “extraordinary,” “emotion,” and “contemplative fancy.” They implicitly reject Ruskin’s “objective truth,” offering instead their own versions of “truth” in representation.2 The judgment evident in Ruskin’s concept of the term is defied by Cather’s and Morrison’s evocative “attribution to natural objects of human capacities and feelings.” Infusing the natural environment with human sentiment or emotions (a tactic which stops short of complete personification) enhances the complexity of a story. The method can enrich both the style (adds a “poetic” or playful flavour to the prose) and the substance (contains a statement about human behaviours) of the work. In her study of Carr, O’Keeffe and Kahlo, Sharyn Rohlfsen Udall interprets the three artists as exploring “nature as a geography of the unconscious in which human forms and relationships masquerade as natural features and landforms” (3). The visual effect in their paintings is striking; shapes and colours, shadows and light prompt a re-evaluation of the connections between inner and outer landscapes. In the texts of Cather and Morrison, reading the language of the land expands the spoken and unspoken aspects of their tales. Pathetic fallacy, while now identified as a “neutral” term, carries with it a negative history.3 Another designation is needed to redeem this creative approach; humanized landscape seems to venture too far into the territory of personification. “Humanesque” terrain is perhaps a more accurate indicator of the lively and life-like geography found in the fiction in this study. A landscape
96305_Russell_03_27.qxp
30
3/28/2006
11:18 AM
Page 30
Between the Angle and the Curve
that mirrors a character’s emotional state can be an evocative literary device; to dismiss its potential for expanding the levels of communication is shortsighted. Cather and Morrison do, however, range beyond this technique: nature is also utilized as an organizational feature; the environment itself becomes a “character” within the story; and the concept of identity is clearly connected to place in their fiction. Authors frequently draw upon nature, and more specifically the four seasons, as a structural device for their works of fiction. Morrison’s The Bluest Eye explicitly uses the cycle of the seasons. It is composed of a “Prologue” (a backward glance by the narrator), and four sections titled “Autumn,” “Winter,” “Spring” and “Summer.” The effect of the titles is shocking. Progression is implied, but not achieved. “There is no renewal for Pecola,” concludes Jan Furman, “in spring she is violated; by summer she is annihilated” (22). The structure of the novel speaks directly to the story itself. The use of natural processes contrasts disturbingly with the unnatural events in Pecola Breedlove’s life. Cather’s My Antonia links the narrative action to particular seasons. While chapter titles do not expressly identify the natural cycle, the descriptions of key events do incorporate specific seasons. Varying the use of nature as a means of shaping a story, Cather ties the structure of O Pioneers! directly to the development of the land. The first four parts of the novel trace the pioneer and prosperous phases of the Divide; the final section—“Alexandra”—reinforces the connection between the land and the central character. Each of the narratives I am discussing utilizes elements of nature and/or natural landscapes as a means of conveying information about particular characters and enhancing the richness of the story. Even in Morrison’s “city novel” Jazz and the city scenes in Cather’s The Song of the Lark, the underlying presence of the natural world is clearly noticeable. Landscapes of memory surface frequently in the fiction of Cather and Morrison. Whether triggered by external stimuli or consciously recalled, the geography of the past is irrevocably a part of the terrain of the present. “The past leaves its traces,” insists Lefebvre, “no space ever vanishes utterly . . .” (37, 164). In unexpected ways, the spaces of the past make themselves known in the spaces of the present. William James’s work on the sensation of place explores the “unarticulated affinities” between a person and a place (244). Seldom a conscious connection, to describe it James utilizes such terms as “psychic overtone” and “fringe” to indicate the intellectual distance of the individual from the emotional or non-intellectual significance of the particular space. It is a sensation or impression that hovers rather than an explicit statement of relations. “A tune, an odor, a flavor,” proposes James,
96305_Russell_03_27.qxp
3/28/2006
Background Foregrounded
11:18 AM
Page 31
31
“sometimes carry this inarticulate feeling” of familiarity (244). Seemingly unrelated elements are actually the components of an intricate web of connections. Recognition often occurs on a visceral level. Death Comes for the Archbishop contains a particularly striking example of an external factor conjuring up distant landscapes and long past times. The sound of the Angelus ringing carries Latour back to his lodgings in Rome. It is, as Deborah Williams aptly describes, “a series of echoing associations that come together to form a whole” (81). The strokes carry him even farther, to somewhere he has never been: “Jerusalem perhaps. . . .” (43). Latour accesses landscapes personally familiar, and familiar only through the teachings of his faith. New Mexico recedes as the spaces of remembrance surface and yet it is the bell rung in a Santa Fe church that inspires the imaginative (and historical) journey. The bell itself has a remarkable provenance. It is inscribed in Spanish and dated 1356 when it was pledged during the wars with the Moors (44). Latour’s reflection that the Spanish learnt silver work from the Moors disconcerts Father Joseph. It is Latour’s subsequent explanation for why the sound struck him as “oriental,” however, which scandalizes the simple priest: the Angelus is an adaptation of a “Moslem custom” introduced by the Templars (45). Father Joseph cannot face this element of the bell’s history; he closes his mind (and ear) to the concept. Latour’s perceptive hearing, however, detects the echoes of distant lands, cultures, and faiths behind the familiar sound. Distant and distinct geographic points on a map converge in Song of Solomon. A warm autumn night carries the scent of ginger on the air, linking Michigan with Africa. Haunting the dreams of sleepers and reshaping the thoughts of those who are awake, the African air is unexpectedly inspiring. It distorts dreams, and those who are awake have thoughts which are “both intimate and far away” (185). Responses are intensely individual: Milkman detects luxury while Guitar senses vengeance in the evening breeze. The inhabitants of the Southside have no personal memories of Africa, but the scent-laden air reaches their subconscious, collective memory much as the bells inspire a never-visited Jerusalem for Latour. Thoughts and activities are thus “both intimate and far away,” personal and distanced. The shadowscapes of Africa and Jerusalem enter the texts through external stimuli; these landscapes surface above, and then recede behind, the actual (physical) locations of the incidents. Music proves to be the trigger for Thea Kronborg’s journey, in The Song of the Lark, into the landscapes of the past. Listening to Dvorak’s symphony “From the New World” she is brought back to the familiar land of
96305_Russell_03_27.qxp
32
3/28/2006
11:18 AM
Page 32
Between the Angle and the Curve
Laramie. In the music she intuitively discovers her own “sand hills” and “the immeasurable yearning of all flat lands” (174). Thea’s emotional response to the notes inspires the recreation of familiar territory—a feeling of home— and an unexperienced terrain. The places she has known merge with those she has never consciously encountered. So too, does time escape practical boundaries; Thea envisions a time which long precedes her experience. The music is evocative, summoning visual images from both a personal and a collective background. Layers of lands and experiences linger behind the chords, elevating mere emotional responses to identification of, and with, the larger world. Connecting personal experience with the life-lessons of humanity is a process Tom Outland must internalize in The Professor’s House. Living on the mesa, the isolated adventurer discovers the artifacts of a lost civilization. The presence of humans moves him; “the evidences of human labour and care” strikes Tom as a stirring message (173). The landscape holds the memory; it waits only to be discovered and deciphered. It is a painful, but essential task; understanding those who have existed before him is crucial to Tom’s development. In time, Tom himself will become a symbol of the landscape of the past. The Professor refers to the region as “Outland Country” and observes an “unusual background behind [Tom’s] shoulders . . .” (112). Man and mesa merge; the memory of Tom is sheltered in, and by, the land, not in the lab where he makes his portentous discovery. For Tom and the Professor, the geography of memory is both personal and historical. Recognition of the interaction of the past and present is particularly important for Americans, proposed Morrison in an interview in City Limits in 1988. She was concerned with the culture’s failure to come to terms with the past: “we live in a land where the past is always erased and America is the innocent future in which immigrants can come and start over, where the slate is clean.”4 Rejecting this sanitized version of history, Morrison’s fiction highlights the fact that the past must be acknowledged. It will not “stay in the past,” but intrudes in the present and threatens the future. Beloved is the most startling of Morrison’s explorations of the past/present link. “Here is no extended Proustian act of remembering a lost world with the help of a madeleine dipped in tea,” wryly observes Eusebio L. Rodrigues (62). The return of the murdered daughter obliterates any notion of separate epochs. Beloved becomes the living past, the lost daughter returned. She also embodies a past that was not personal. Ferguson’s observation that “as the baby daughter of a second-generation slave” Beloved’s memories represent a “displacement . . . backwards in time,” is quite perceptive (162). Cryptic recollections of the “other place” provide snapshots of life on
96305_Russell_03_27.qxp
3/28/2006
Background Foregrounded
11:18 AM
Page 33
33
the slave ships. Beloved carries a past that is not (directly) her own into a present in which her own existence is extremely tenuous. “Memory itself is understood as geographical space,” Weissberg writes of Morrison’s Beloved (115). Places of the past occupy both concrete and abstract space in the novel. They simultaneously exist in landscapes captured in memory and in the locations of the present. The geography of memory has a tangible presence in Sethe’s explanation of “rememory” to her daughter Denver: “places are still there . . . a house burns down, it’s gone, but the . . . picture . . . stays . . . out there, in the world . . .” (36). The physical structure may be destroyed, but the concept or essence of the place remains. Nor is it simply an abstract notion, for in Sethe’s theory the places of the past are as real as those of the present. Sethe’s “analysis” is supported by Lefebvre. “Theory,” he notes, “has shown that no space disappears completely or is utterly abolished in the course of the process of social development—not even the natural place where that process began. ‘Something’ always survives or endures . . .” (402). The division between time periods is challenged by Sethe’s interpretation. The woman who carries the mark of the past on her back—scars from being whipped—articulates a world of fluid and interconnected spheres. The distinctions between time periods are similarly obliterated in Sethe’s philosophy. “Rememory, as Sethe defines it,” concludes Budick, “is the relocation of the mind’s thought-pictures of the past ‘out there,’ in the physical world. It is the concrete and corporeal resurrection of the past in the present, as if time did not exist” (118). Boundaries between the past and the present, the psychological and the physical are variable in Sethe’s assessment. She makes it clear that even if she dies the picture remains and further, that if Denver were to go to Sweet Home “it will happen again . . .” (36). The interaction between person and place is a key part of the process; the “picture” lingers, but requires a viewer to bring it into focus. Past and present landscapes mingle in the mind and in the eye. Space thus spans time and physical boundaries. The wide-reaching connections of geography are perceptively illustrated in an exchange between Milkman and Guitar in Song of Solomon: “‘ . . . gimme the tea, Guitar . . . No geography.’ . . . ‘Okay. . . . What about some history. . . . Or some sociopolitico—No. That’s still geography . . . I do believe my whole life’s geography’” (114). Guitar emphasizes the intricate connections between history, politics, and other social practices and geography. The places we know and the spaces we occupy are more than simply decorative; a lesson Milkman (and the attentive reader) must internalize at great personal cost. Location has a substance far beyond its descriptive value.
96305_Russell_03_27.qxp
34
3/28/2006
11:18 AM
Page 34
Between the Angle and the Curve
The importance of the physical environment is indisputable; location dominates a Cather or Morrison text. “Her novels are rooted in place,” Rosowski asserts of Cather (51). Rigney offers a similar assessment of Morrison: “locale is always deeply and historically significant for Morrison . . .” (63). Morrison herself, in a conversation with Thomas Leclair, acknowledges, “I sometimes lose interest in the characters and get much more interested in the trees and animals” (370). Moments in Cather’s writing suggest a similar experience; characters recede and the landscape insists on recognition. Whether it is a geographic region, town, city street, or single home, intricate details of location are initiated with the first words of, and sustained throughout, the novels in question. UNCREDITED CHARACTERS: PERSONALIZING NATURE From Cather’s southwestern canyons to Morrison’s lush tropical island, the geographic settings are spectacular. Each of these authors has a remarkable gift for recreating the physical environment through the written word—a vivid picture of the natural scenery leaps off their pages. True to life landscapes become life-like in another sense, for both Cather and Morrison, to varying degrees, engage in personification of the natural world. There is a key moment in O Pioneers! when Alexandra Bergson discovers a love for the country; it is an intensely personal (and mutual) exchange between the land and the woman. Drinking in the panorama “until her tears blinded her” it is as if “the Genius of the Divide, the great, free spirit which breathes across it . . . bent lower than it ever bent to a human will before” (44). The Divide is not simply a life sustaining space; the land produces crops, but it also provides an epiphany. It speaks to Alexandra’s heart and, having heard her response, bends to her—it is humanlike, indeed almost lover-like, in its interaction.5 What was an object—the land—becomes an interactive subject—a free spirit willing to receive her desire. Morrison employs a similar technique in Beloved. The focus, however, is on the seasons rather than the physical terrain. Public performance characterizes the personification. In this novel the natural world is not a lover, but a disgruntled player. The seasons act like prima donnas; each “convinced its performance is the reason the world has people in it . . .” (116). The spectacle of the changing seasons is replete with the petty egos and behaviors of the human realm. The richness of the seasonal colours is mirrored in Morrison’s lyrical description. Humanizing the natural world in this passage permits a mixture of playfulness and poignancy—the “prima donna” palavers while the landscape dies.
96305_Russell_03_27.qxp
3/28/2006
Background Foregrounded
11:18 AM
Page 35
35
Tar Baby is the text in which Morrison sustains the personification of the natural realm beyond a single (or several) episode(s). Landscape features and wild creatures are thinking and feeling entities in this novel. The first chapter introduces the Isle des Chevaliers in bold strokes. Development disturbs the natural order; the “clouds and fish were convinced the world was over . . . Only the champion daisy trees were serene . . . they ignored the men and continued to rock the diamondbacks that slept in their arms” (9). Vibrantly coloured, teeming with vitality, the tropical island is clearly a symbiotic collection of life complete with human attributes—it is a sentient being. The intrusion of the actual human world in the humanized natural world threatens the balance of the island. The fact that this natural space is being decimated in order to build wintering places for outsiders injects an emotional element into the description. The landscape resists conquest; island and mansion, with their diametrically opposed needs, are at odds throughout the story. Ultimately, it is the dwelling that is infiltrated by the island’s forces. The importance of the humanized landscape is highlighted in Saposnik-Noire’s reading of Cather’s My Antonia. In her analysis the “landscape acts as a silent protagonist because we cannot speak of the actions or feelings of characters . . . without invoking images of nature” (179). The human qualities of the land—“a personality possessed of a sense of motion, sexuality and mood”—Saposnik-Noire contends, are directly connected to the human characters (171). Jim Burden’s first experience of Nebraska is daunting to say the least. He is struck by the emptiness of the environment and yet he felt motion in the landscape “as if the shaggy grass were . . . herds of buffalo . . . galloping, galloping . . .” (12–13). This young boy, transplanted from Virginia upon the death of his parents, has an immediate awareness of the life force which surrounds him. The movement, the vitality of the land, seem to enter him—he “felt,” not “thought”—and as the novel progresses it becomes increasingly clear that the growth and development of Jim and his companion Antonia are mirrored in (and mirror) that of the prairie. Humanizing the natural world permits a degree of playfulness and level of emotion in what might otherwise be an unremarkable descriptive passage. A minimum of words achieves a maximum effect; the distance between natural and human spheres is imaginatively bridged. A powerful counterpart to this tactic of humanizing the natural is the practice of dehumanizing the human through natural references. Following a particularly horrific emotional confrontation with his wife, Valerian Street, one of the central characters in Tar Baby, notices “the Negroes had all gone out of the room, disappeared like bushes, trees, out of his line of vision . . .” (232). Morrison
96305_Russell_03_27.qxp
36
3/28/2006
11:18 AM
Page 36
Between the Angle and the Curve
chillingly conveys Valerian’s attitude towards his employees: they are ranked with the landscape features. The implicit value judgement stems from the denial of the servants’ humanity. In a variation of this technique, Cather utilizes natural imagery to illustrate Ivy Peters’ inhumanity in A Lost Lady. In this novel the character’s physical appearance and personality strangely validate the comparison. Valerian Street fails to see his servants as anything other than objects because they are black servants; when they step out of that role (by leaving the room) they step into invisibility (out of his line of vision). Ivy Peters insists on being recognized; he intrudes freely and frequently on the gazes of the other characters. The text draws close attention to several of his physical traits in particular, his red skin “flecked with tiny freckles, like rust spots,” and small eyes with the “absence of eyelashes [which] gave his pupils the fixed, unblinking hardness of a snake’s or a lizard’s” (14). Ivy is a nasty creature who revels in being repulsive; his nickname—Poison Ivy—is spawned, not by his complexion, but from his propensity for poisoning dogs. His brutal character is instantly recognizable and Ivy’s subsequent actions (maiming a bird, destroying the landscape) sustain this first impression. Appearance mirrors personality in Ivy’s case; he is determined to be as inhuman as possible. Whereas Valerian fails to recognize the humanity of his employees, Ivy denies his own (and that of his victims) humanity. Ivy has no qualms about exploiting the natural and human landscapes for his own benefit. Valerian too profits from the natural landscape: literally in the development of the Isle Des Chevaliers and symbolically through the servants who have maintained his luxurious lifestyle for years and are left with a “promise of being taken care of in the will . . .” (233). Each of these men, Valerian and Ivy, approach the human and natural realms as separate spheres with distinct hierarchical positions and vulnerability to exploitation. Linking a character with nature need not be a negative practice; Cather and Morrison create deep connections between the natural world and two of the most compelling female characters in literature. Antonia Shimerda, the title figure in My Antonia, has eyes which are “like the sun shining on brown pools in the wood” and brown skin (17). She exudes warmth, vitality and fertility; she is the embodiment of nature. The earthy tones used to describe Antonia here and throughout the book telegraph her ultimate (and triumphant) status as an “earth mother.” There is no sense that Antonia is diminished in any way by her close association with nature. The contrast between Antonia and her fruitful family and farm and the childless, landless Jim Burden is clear and poignant. It is not ownership of the land, but an active connection to the rhythms and lessons of the natural world which gives Antonia her strength.
96305_Russell_03_27.qxp
3/28/2006
11:18 AM
Page 37
Background Foregrounded
37
Morrison fashions a figure that shares Antonia’s affinity with nature and her remarkable life force: Pilate Dead. In an eerie, but evocative act of amelioration, Morrison ties a woman whose final words reflect her great love of humanity and eagerness to assume responsibility for the fates of others with the man who washed his hands of accountability. The name is a confused gift of love from her grieving father; being illiterate, he selects a “group of letters [which looked] . . . strong and handsome . . . like a tree hanging in [a] protective way over a row of smaller trees” (18). His “reading” of the controversial name—relying on the visual impact of the letters—is strangely appropriate; Pilate is associated with trees in the novel, is intensely protective of her family, is strong and handsome, and guides (pilots) her nephew through the terrain that will afford him an opportunity to discover his own identity. She is a distinctly positive character who is not diminished, but enlarged through her identification with nature. Intertwined spaces, not separate spheres, mark the lives of Pilate and Antonia; the two exist in harmony with, rather than at the expense of, the earth. PLACE AND IDENTITY: INTIMATE CONNECTIONS The interaction between individuals and the physical locales they inhabit are all -encompassing. Place (whether fictional or existing in the “real world”) is not experienced objectively; it affects the individual in each aspect of his/her personality. Welty’s assessment of “Place in Fiction” reveals that: Place has the most delicate control over character . . . by confining character it defines it . . . Place in fiction is the named, identified, concrete, exact and exacting, . . . gathering spot of all that has been felt, is about to be experienced, in the novel’s progress. (122)
The physical site has an emotional resonance; the human element cannot be divorced from the definition of place. The connection between the person and the place helps define the individual and the space. Humanized space becomes place. Group identity, particularly for the displaced or marginalized, is often located in a shared space. Stressing the epistemological value of the physical setting, Christian makes a strong case for the importance of the land in Morrison’s novels: “the land is a participant in the maintenance of the folk tradition. It is one of the necessary constants through which the folk dramatize the meaning of life. . . . Setting then is organic to the characters’ view of themselves” (65). Communal land is a part of the community’s traditions
96305_Russell_03_27.qxp
38
3/28/2006
11:18 AM
Page 38
Between the Angle and the Curve
and value systems; this collective experience of the environment is directly related to concepts of identity. More than a specific location is shared; the site becomes the locus of personal (yet public) history and knowledge. Selfidentification, Christian contends, hinges upon location. The key to whether the identification with place is a positive or negative dynamic, for any character, hinges upon the issue of whether it is a selfdetermined or externally imposed identification. Steward Morgan recognizes the personal value of the land in Paradise. Roaming his pastures brings Steward the reassuring knowledge that he could never be lost on his own land (95). Ownership of his ranch is an integral part of Steward’s identity—his stability is linked to its stability. He locates himself through his home. Equally important to Steward’s process of identification is his connection to the town of Ruby. It is a place founded by eight families; intricate webs of relationships sustain the community. Outsiders, particularly the women of the convent, are viewed as violating an intensely specialized space. Murder becomes a justifiable means of maintaining boundaries in the minds of the men of Ruby. Violation of the home does occur in Beloved. Outsiders (slave catchers) introduce violence into a (relatively) peaceful, communal location. Self-identification is a painful process for Baby Suggs; it begins with her awareness that she never had the opportunity for her personality to develop (140). A large part of her newfound freedom is Baby Suggs’ struggle to “place” herself emotionally, intellectually and physically. Having accomplished this necessary, but arduous task, she is at last able to become a participant in the community. It is a position Baby Suggs maintains with grace and insight until the fateful celebratory party drives a wedge between her and her neighbors. Through the space created by this detachment returns the horror of the slave plantation; no warning call precedes the arrival of the schoolteacher and his men. Slavery and racism clearly compromise Baby Suggs’ and Steward Morgan’s efforts to find spaces of their own, but their struggles are crucial to self-preservation. A person’s “place” is a complicated designation in Sapphira and the Slave Girl. The system of slavery in Cather’s text is a (mostly) benign entity which serves to locate individuals. Till, the mother of the “Slave Girl,” seemingly views her connection to the Dodderidges “as one of the fixed conditions you were born into . . . ;” a fourth generation slave. She accepts it as “their natural place in the world” (219). She does not openly question the inequity of the hierarchy and can only articulate her concern for her daughter’s safety after her flight as a “low, cautious murmur . . .” (249). To speak otherwise would be to step outside of her “natural place” but Till does voice the hope that in the new setting “she’ll have some chance.”
96305_Russell_03_27.qxp
3/28/2006
Background Foregrounded
11:18 AM
Page 39
39
Nancy does indeed have a chance at a better life in Canada. The facilitator of her flight, Rachel Blake, observes of another character, “a man’s got to be stronger’n a bull to get out of the place he was born in” (130). Nancy’s escape is all the more surprising. She flees the prospect of being raped by Martin Colbert rather than actively seeking a life of autonomy and self-fulfillment. However frustrating Cather’s representation of Nancy is, the young girl’s refusal to be her owner’s pawn is a bold stance of self-definition. Nancy’s vision is limited, but it ranges beyond Sapphira’s label of sexual object ripe for exploitation. Wielding the power is no protection against being “placed” by others. Neither Sapphira nor her husband is native to the area; they moved to the Virginia backwoods after their marriage. He in particular is viewed by the locals as an outsider: the absence of a “Southern accent amounted almost to a foreign accent” (5). Sapphira too “spoke differently from the Back Creek people; but they admitted that a woman and an heiress had a right to” (5). The couple is approached with caution (if not suspicion). They do not become “naturalized” citizens despite their love for the place. Love of the land mitigates, but does not eradicate the “foreignness” of the Colberts. An emotional attachment to the land in Willa Cather’s The Song of the Lark and O Pioneers! does provide the central female characters with a sense of identity and a source of inspiration unparalleled in their human relationships. Each woman recognizes a crucial element of her own personality in the geography of her formative years. Thea Kronborg approaches coming home as returning to a refuge where “one’s heart sang” and there is a sensation “of going back to a friendly soil, whose friendship was somehow going to strengthen her. . . .” (191–2). Thea is attuned to the land; its harmony provides sustenance not only for the woman she has become, but also for the artist into whom she continues to evolve. Alexandra Bergson’s interaction with the natural landscape is equally affirmative. She experiences happy days “close to the flat, fallow world about her, and felt . . . in her own body the joyous germination in the soil” (135). Alexandra’s connection with the Divide seems to extend beyond identification or sympathy, into empathy— she is the land, the land is her. Godfrey St. Peter, the title character of Cather’s The Professor’s House, turns to the natural landscape for solace during a period of personal confusion. He reconnects with his boyhood in Kansas, rediscovering “the original, unmodified Godfrey St. Peter” (239). This child of the earth, or more accurately of the water, embodies the personality St. Peter has clung to during his married and academic lives: what he deems “his original self ” (242). Throughout the text waterscapes, in particular the lake, serve as sources of
96305_Russell_03_27.qxp
40
3/28/2006
11:18 AM
Page 40
Between the Angle and the Curve
inspiration and consolation for St. Peter. They are key elements in his sense of identity. The professor, Alexandra, and Thea all recognize and embrace the importance of place in their self-definitions. In tune with their surroundings, the three derive internal strength from external settings. Morrison offers several responses to the problem of externally imposed categories of identity based upon place. Joe Trace in Jazz is labeled “country” by his neighbors and customers. Far from a putdown, the appellation reflects a sense of the familiar, a recognition of the emotional resonance in his voice: “it had a pitch, a note [which]. . . . reminded them of men who wore hats to plow . . .” (71). Joe evokes images of the country homes abandoned in favour of the city; his voice is soothing and comfortable—a nostalgic breeze that carries the country of their youth to his urban listeners. They are at ease with his presence in their homes. Joe enters more like a welcome visitor than a working salesman. The psychological effect serves him well; being “country” assists Joe in selling his beauty products. The “country versus city” pattern, with its implicit hierarchy, permits Joe’s customers a sense of superiority. The women become the sexual aggressors. They tease and cajole him and their husbands treat the flirting as non-threatening; he “counted on flirty laughing women to buy his wares . . .” but knows the interaction can go no further (71). Joe Trace is not an urban predator. He is a reminder of a more benign way of life, and yet it is Joe who ultimately pockets their money. Cather too introduces the country/city paradigm, offering a distinction between country and town girls. They are terms that encode a system of social values. On the surface, the scales tip in favour of the town girls, but the narrative offers extended and sympathetic portraits of the country girls. My Antonia is peopled with immigrant girls who are physically striking with a “vigour which . . . developed into a positive carriage and freedom of movement . . . ;” in sharp contrast to the town girls whose “muscles seemed to ask . . . not to be disturbed” (127, 128). Social positioning devalues the farm girls—elitism esteems town-life over country existence—but Jim Burden clearly recognizes the superiority of this new “breed.” Initially at least, he is in the minority; despite the attraction, town boys continue to marry their “own kind.” To do otherwise would require stepping outside of the social framework; the young men lack the fortitude to break with tradition. Divisions between town and country are perpetuated in personal relationships. Ultimately, however, it is the immigrant girls and their families who prosper. Morrison’s Tar Baby offers an unequivocal example of how a label can be limiting. Local groundskeeper Gideon is known to most of the central characters simply as “Yardman.” Conceding that it is not his actual name
96305_Russell_03_27.qxp
3/28/2006
Background Foregrounded
11:18 AM
Page 41
41
(given by his employers not his parents), Jadine coldly observes, “he answers to it” (115). Only Son, the man who guards his own name like a treasured secret, is disturbed that Gideon has been rechristened “Yardman, as though he had not been mothered” (161). The origins of the servant are irrelevant to the fulfillment of the services. Gideon is literally defined by his “place”—he is the man of the yard—and that definition robs him of his identity, if not humanity. The process of location (or relocation) is no less dehumanizing in The Bluest Eye. At first glance Morrison’s treatment of the transplanted Southern girls is a positive connection between identity and place. Having soaked up the “juice of their hometowns,” they have deep roots and firm stalks (81–2). On the surface these characters seem to have strong origins—their roots are deep—which are directly connected to their “home” land. But there is an eerie, unnatural stillness about these girls; a sense of self-stifling accompanies them. In fact they move “without a stir” (82). They do not affirm, but deny their affinity with nature. What they struggle to cultivate is not the “natural” but the “civilized.” Life is approached as a war against the “funkiness of passion, . . . of nature, . . . of the wide range of human emotions” (83). Fear of losing control, of being linked with “niggers [who] were dirty and loud” controls the lives of the Mobile girls (87). They accept, and perpetuate, the judgements of a racist society; self-definition is distorted by an external code of behaviours and values. Negotiating the spaces of conflicting communities can lead to geographic dislocation and confused identities. In her reading of Tar Baby, Ryan contends that Jadine Childs’ “rootless” condition (she is an orphan) is further exasperated by “receiving a Eurocentric education” which results in her being “grafted onto a self-alienating cultural base from which to view her own and the experiences of other African peoples” (78). Jadine receives intellectual and psychological nourishment from sources worlds away from her family roots. The process expands her horizons at the same time that it shrinks them. She moves between locations and communities, but is never completely at ease. Transplantation similarly distorts the perspectives of the Southern girls who learn to serve the white community (The Bluest Eye, 83). More than simply moving north, it is their deliberate erasure of their personalities which displaces these girls. They have stepped outside one community (the “common” black neighborhood) without being able to completely access the new community (if not the white society then the next best version of it). Occupying a false “personal space” is thus linked to the physical places a character inhabits. The distortion of identity can accompany a geographic relocation.
96305_Russell_03_27.qxp
3/28/2006
11:18 AM
42
Page 42
Between the Angle and the Curve
CONCRETE FOUNDATIONS AND SYMBOLIC MANIFESTATIONS: THE INTERSECTION OF THE LITERAL AND THE LITERARY Cather and Morrison are extremely adept at capturing literal landscapes in their fiction. “Placing” a character is a key element of their narratives; concrete details create geographic settings which can help to identify individuals. Soaphead Church’s letter to God in The Bluest Eye relies heavily on real world geography: Once upon a time I lived . . . on one of your islands . . . in the South Atlantic between North and South America, enclosing the Caribbean Sea and the Gulf of Mexico: divided into the Greater Antilles, the Lesser Antilles, and the Bahama Islands. Not the Windward or Leeward Island colonies, . . . but within, . . . the Greater of the two Antilles . . . (176–177)
Soaphead’s meticulous, indeed obsessive, positioning of himself effectively inserts a map into Morrison’s novel. It is significant that the precise geography is in fact a landscape from Soaphead’s past. He appears to offer a concrete statement of location, but is in fact dodging the issue by focusing on the “once upon a time.” He makes no reference to his current locale. The fairytale quality of Soaphead’s correspondence with God—once upon a time—links his letter with the compulsion to locate oneself often associated with childhood. Adrienne Rich categorizes her childhood habit of recording her address as an exercise in locating herself: Adrienne Rich 14 Edgevale Road Baltimore, Maryland The United States of America The Continent of North America The Western Hemisphere The Earth The Solar System The Universe6
It is a playful means of testing and affirming her own boundaries. Detail is a source of comfort; it confirms the existence of the child Rich and the larger world in which she is contained.
96305_Russell_03_27.qxp
3/28/2006
11:18 AM
Page 43
Background Foregrounded
43
Alice Munro employs the tactic in Lives of Girls and Women. The child Del addresses a letter for the child-like Uncle Benny: I wrote his name and address in full: Mr Benjamin Thomas Poole, The Flats Road, Jubilee, Wawanash County, Ontario, Canada, North America, The Western Hemisphere, The World, The Solar System, The Universe. (12)
Despite the close attention to geographic connections, Uncle Benny protests “You haven’t got far enough. Isn’t Heaven outside of the Universe?” (12). While the exchange is quite comical, it does raise weighty ontological issues. Questions of knowing and being lurk behind the ever-expanding series of spatial markers. Geographic ambiguity in fact reflects Soaphead’s own tenuous situation; in the previously cited letter he makes a claim to godhead—he has usurped God’s powers by “changing” Pecola Breedlove’s eyes to blue. He is blurring boundaries of creation. The literal landscape incorporated in the text thus affords subtle insights into character; what Soaphead omits reveals a great deal about his uncertain status. Rich warns that what is harmless in the child can become in an adult “the arrogance of believing ourselves at the center.”7 Aspiring to godhead, Soaphead has symbolically removed himself from the human map. The actual geography is no longer relevant as he has relocated himself to a higher plain. The omission of details identifies Soaphead’s position in the literary landscape: he is deliberately attempting to step outside its parameters. In effect, Soaphead rewrites the landscape in his refusal to write himself into the existing setting. Playing with the practice of reading a literary landscape literally, Cather has Godfrey St. Peter and Tom Outland of The Professor’s House essentially “write themselves” into a literary setting. The pair takes a Fray Garces’ manuscript into the Southwest and retraces “his trail on horseback. Tom could take a sentence from Garces’ diary and find the exact spot . . .” (235). The young man brings the landscape of literature alive for St. Peter. Scholar and adventurer step out of academic discussion and into the Southwestern region. Cather creates characters that recreate written geographies. Texts within texts and landscapes within landscapes; the practice adds depth to an already (emotionally) profound landscape. It is a setting that is intellectually and emotionally evocative for both reader and character; the novel blurs the distinction between the two—following Tom’s adventures on the mesa, the reader mirrors the process employed by Tom and St. Peter. We too access the landscape through the written word.
96305_Russell_03_27.qxp
44
3/28/2006
11:18 AM
Page 44
Between the Angle and the Curve
The questioning of boundaries and the formation of alternate spaces speaks to the complexity of place. Recalling Welty’s interpretation of “place in fiction”—the “concrete . . . spot of all that has been felt”—provides a glimpse of the intricate nature of place (122). “Concrete” and “felt” would appear to be mutually exclusive states; one is tangible, the other ethereal. In fact, all places accommodate these seemingly contradictory qualities. There is the point on the map—represented by degrees of latitude and longitude—and there is what the map cannot capture; the symbolic and emotional components of place exist beyond the borders of cartography. Map drawing is the art of demarcating boundaries and yet the edges of the map (the limits of the paper or the book) also frame an absence. What lies beyond the arbitrary borderlines? Geography is both what the eye can see—the particular landmass or body of water—and the mind imagine or recall from past encounters—the possibilities hovering behind, and in, the physical. The two elements are mutually dependent. Dixon interprets “the symbolic geography in Morrison’s fiction” as emerging from “precise physical details . . .” (115–6). The fictional location has roots in the real world. Similarly, the American Southwest in Cather’s writings, Fryer asserts, is “a space [which is] both metaphorical and actual, a space which can be both sensed and touched” (Prairie Schooner, 185). Each author builds her symbolic and emotional landscapes on the solid foundations of physical geography. “Real world” geography expands into a variety of spaces and landscapes in the novels of Cather and Morrison. From the surreal dreamscape to the desperate need for a landmark in an expansive terrain, it is the exchange between human being and territory which takes precedence in their literary landscapes. THE SPACE OF ABSENCE: CONVENIENCE OR COMMENTARY? To varying degrees, all novels incorporate gaps and/or silences. “Editing” of events results in “offstage” occurrences—the “time passes” section where a character matures or peripheral problems are resolved—Cather does not narrate Antonia’s “fall,” Morrison withholds the moment of Eva Peace’s mutilation. Space as an entity is, however, specifically recognized by both authors. Cather’s treatment of space(s) is not as self-conscious or sustained as Morrison’s forays into space. Although a character in The Professor’s House, Crane, is working on “the extent of space” little reference is made to his experiments; there are no explicit comments on the concept of space, whether occupied or not, in Cather’s novels (72). Morrison directly addresses the space of absence. Her conclusions about the strong “nonwhite, Africanlike (or Africanist) presence or persona”
96305_Russell_03_27.qxp
3/28/2006
Background Foregrounded
11:18 AM
Page 45
45
in American literature provide insight into Morrison’s interest in the space of absence. In Playing in the Dark Whiteness and the Literary Imagination, she insists that “the contemplation of this black presence is central to any understanding of our national literature and should not be permitted to hover at the margins of the literary imagination” (6, 5). As a writer Morrison enacts what she proposes as a critic: her fiction brings the absence/presence issue in American literature front and centre. What is often a structural feature in fiction becomes a striking thematic device in several of Morrison’s novels. The space of absence is a recurrent image in her work, but perhaps the most evocative example occurs in Beloved. As several critics have observed, the central address in the novel— 124—foregrounds the fact of loss. 124 “signals many absences,” states Budick, “not least of which is Beloved, the missing third child” (131). The disruption in the logical order of the numbers—1 2 3 4—mirrors the disruption in the natural order—the loss of ancestors and descendants. Rafael Perez-Torres identifies these “concrete absences” as creating a floating space for the reader, “a space that floats somewhere between an absent past and an absent future” (93). The unrecoverable past and the unattainable future haunt the present. Personal and historical continuity have been hindered by the system of slavery. The rupture in time takes a spatial form. Perez-Torres approaches the equation from the reader’s perspective, but his observations are equally applicable to Sethe’s experience. Ignorance over the fate of her husband takes a shape of its own. It is a space of “resentment at . . . his cowardice, or stupidity or bad luck” which “was filled now with a brand-new sorrow . . .” (95). The absence of Halle is an ambiguous, but tangible space for Sethe. Just as the geographic specificity of the house number externalizes the personal loss, so too does the internal space, structured around the missing husband, concretize Sethe’s private sorrow. Paul D’s disturbing information about Halle’s fate (his failed attempt to escape the plantation) serves only to alter, not to eradicate this space of suffering. Empty space is a particularly frightening prospect for many of Morrison’s characters. While not a specifically haunted space as is the case in Beloved, unfilled space does have a haunting presence in several of her novels. There is a jarring visual effect in Paradise that encapsulates how disconcerting the space of absence can be. The men discover a huge cross with only a space “where there used to be a Jesus” (12). What is missing is chillingly clear; the void has been deliberately created, and it has a powerful emotional resonance. The women of the convent unwittingly create a “justification” for the murderous actions of the men: they are punishing the godless. This
96305_Russell_03_27.qxp
46
3/28/2006
11:18 AM
Page 46
Between the Angle and the Curve
rationale conveniently overlooks the fact that the rampage has begun before the cross is encountered; the space of absence the women create (maleless, godless) is nonetheless the source of their deliberate destruction. An accidental, but no less disturbing emptiness is created in Sula with the drowning death of Chicken Little. The young boy’s encounter with Sula and Nel has catastrophic consequences. Child’s play leads to his death by drowning and the alienation of the young girls. The literal absence of Chicken Little—his failure to surface—is less significant than the space his death opens between Sula and Nel. The space of silence looms between the pair. At his funeral “there was a space, a separateness” which is not bridged until the two girls imaginatively detach the coffin in the earth from the memory of his laughter (64). Chicken Little is resurrected as a living memory associated with a space of physical loss. Locating the dead body in the lifeless coffin liberates the laughing child’s spirit. The revelation seemingly frees the girls; they never discuss the incident. A subsequent encounter with the space of loss elicits a deeper response from the adult Sula. She is altered by the departure of her lover Ajax. Seeking signs of his having been there she finds only “his stunning absence;” it is “so decorative, so ornate, it was difficult . . . to understand how she had ever endured . . . his magnificent presence” (134). The space of absence that lingers is oddly enough a full space—decorative and ornate belie the emptiness created by Ajax’s exit. Ajax’s absence is as consuming as his presence; Sula’s home becomes a shadowy shrine: the mirror he used becomes “an altar” (134). Ajax transforms the place even as an absence. Common objects are elevated by virtue of being used by the lost lover. Sula’s space is no longer her own and it clearly bewilders her. The loss of her boyfriend redefines both Sula and her home. It is an experience which echoes the effect of her affair with Nel’s husband on Nel’s space and sense of identity. Sula’s rationale for sleeping with Jude illustrates both her contempt for the town’s value system and her method of organizing her life: “there was this space in front of me, behind me, . . . Jude filled it up” (144). Sula experiences life spatially. Her best friend’s husband is simply a means for filling internal and external space; Sula’s concern is not with consequences, but with personal satisfaction. Although the gratification takes a sexual form, it is not the sex act itself, but the problem of empty space that drives Sula. Empty space is no less challenging when it occurs in the natural landscape. Ten generations in Paradise shape their lives around a fear of the physical and psychological ramifications of unfamiliar territory. Space beyond recognizable boundaries implies openness and possibility, but it also contains
96305_Russell_03_27.qxp
3/28/2006
Background Foregrounded
11:18 AM
Page 47
47
antagonistic forces. “Out There” space which was “beckoning and free, became . . . a void where random and organized evil erupted . . .” (16). The men of Ruby embrace insularity in light of the horrors of “Out There.” The very words suggest a territory beyond the safe zone, a space which houses past and future torments, a removal or exclusion from the (implied) civilized “here.” Open space is overwhelming. It is both a literal threat—physical vulnerability occurs in an open terrain—and a psychologically intimidating entity—“Out There” challenges the foundations of identity. The dread of outdoors is more subtly described in The Bluest Eye than in Paradise, but it is no less frightening. The reality and symbolism of the wilderness are utilized to modify undesirable behaviour and to reinforce the communal values of the contrasting, civilized space. As Claudia MacTeer recognizes early in life, outdoors was the “the end of something, an irrevocable, physical fact . . .” which defined their condition (17). Early in her life Claudia is taught to fear open territory as a termination and source of terror. It is not only represented as a negative space, but as a punishment for negative behaviour. Being outdoors is an affliction; it involves a physical and social vulnerability. The possibility of ending up outdoors functions as a powerful tool of social conformity. Nancy’s desperate flight in Sapphira and the Slave Girl is a journey from her “natural place” to “there” over which looms the fear of “nowheres.” Preparing for her journey, the young girl worries about the work she has not completed, but consoles herself with the thought that she can send it back once she gets “there” (232). Nancy has only the vaguest sense of where she is heading. Even the practical Mrs. Blake has but a shadowy notion of the destination; “how vague . . . [she thought] was this ‘there’ that Nancy spoke of—there was Canada, wasn’t it?” (232). It is a space beyond their experience, indeed almost beyond their comprehension, and as such it can only be envisioned as a hazy location. It is this lack of precision which disheartens Nancy when she must part from Mrs. Blake; her terrors are encapsulated in her lament: “I can’t bear it to belong nowheres!” (237). Nancy desires firmer ground upon which to build her identity. Belonging is an integral part of identity. Acknowledgement or denial of an individual’s existence is a chillingly effective method of social control. The Bluest Eye captures one of the spatial effects of racial prejudice. Armed with the appropriate fee and a desire for Mary Janes, Pecola Breedlove enters a candy store. The clerk virtually negates her identity. Looking at him there is a “vacuum where curiosity ought to lodge . . . The total absence of human recognition . . . it is the blackness that accounts for, that creates” it (46–49). The white shop owner briefly recognizes, then dismisses the fact of Pecola’s
96305_Russell_03_27.qxp
48
3/28/2006
11:18 AM
Page 48
Between the Angle and the Curve
existence. The “audience” withdraws; the performance of identity therefore fails. She is the vacuum—the space entirely devoid of matter—she does not matter in his assessment. Pecola’s blackness is thus a space unto itself; a space separated from human recognition. Despite achieving her goal of purchasing the candy, Pecola is instructed once again on her “position.” As her heartbreaking and insane quest for “the bluest eyes” reveals, Pecola clearly understands that she is defined by what she is not—white and blue-eyed like the namesake of the candy she devours with orgasmic pleasure. She attempts to fill the vacuum with a self-image that completely denies her own reality precisely because it is too painful for Pecola to acknowledge. The space of anger is potentially invigorating, but extremely unnerving in The Bluest Eye. Exiting the store, Pecola first feels shame, and then anger but “reasons” at least “there is a sense of being in anger. A reality and presence” (50). Pecola attempts to reinsert herself in the social landscape via the space of anger. The energy of her anger fuels a desire for recognition. It voices her need to be acknowledged. Ultimately, however, she cannot sustain the anger and her shame returns; external labels (black equals nothing) stymie the act of self-definition. Only the consumption of the candy can subsume Pecola’s misery; empty space is too daunting for the neglected and abused child to master. The press to fill it (whether with food or the fantasy of having the bluest eye) is an effort to stave off the anger that lurks beneath the surface. For Pecola it is a coping mechanism, but it is also an avoidance tactic, a fear of facing her true situation. It is a practice the narrator in Jazz recognizes. Dismissing as an illusion the expressed desire of her neighbors for a space “that need not be filled . . . other than [with] their own thoughts,” the narrator cautions, it would “knock them down” (16). This vacant space will be characterized by “the seep of rage” (16). It will not be the space of ease, but rather the space of disease. The buried anger will surface in this empty space with destructive potential. The final pages of Jazz force the narrator to confront her own method of filling up space. Having assisted the reader in accessing the story of Joe, Violet and Dorcas the narrator anticipates the fate of the subsequent triangle of Joe, Violet and Felice but they defy her efforts: “they were, busy being original, . . . while I was the predictable one . . . thinking my space . . . was the only one . . .” (220). Her narrative, she concedes, has missed the point— in “watching the streets” she neglected the hidden emotions (221). The assumption that the story occupies a single space blinds the narrator to the multiple and interconnected spaces of the characters. And yet, however inaccurate the narrative may be, it is not a false space; it is but one of many
96305_Russell_03_27.qxp
3/28/2006
11:18 AM
Page 49
Background Foregrounded
49
(potential) narrative spaces. The recognition that her textual space is not the only one, or perhaps even the one that mattered, highlights the diverse nature of space. COLLIDING “WORLDS”: LAYERING THE LANDSCAPE Multiple spaces co-exist in the novels of Cather and Morrison; each author explores both the varieties of space and their interconnections. Rigid boundaries are not reinforced in the novels in this study. Dreamscapes, with their surreal movement between the familiar and the uncanny, are a particularly striking feature in their fiction. As Rigney points out, “all of Morrison’s fictions partake of a dreamscape, contain a quality that is surreal at times, largely because of [a] refusal to mark dreams as distinct or separate from ‘reality’” (27). It is an observation that is also true of Cather’s writing. Each of these authors challenges the divisions of the real and the non-real; the issue of reality is treated in all its ambiguity and intricacy. The spaces Cather and Morrison create are often discomforting and frequently disorienting. The line between the “spirit world” and the “real world” is virtually erased in Beloved. The missing, murdered, third child returns with a vengeance and the concept of separate spheres is shattered. Through Beloved, Morrison “presents an apocalyptic demolition of the boundaries between the earthly and spiritual realms,” contends Susan Bowers, “an invasion of the world of the living by the world beyond the veil” (211). Cryptic descriptions of the space of the dead and the journey to re-enter the landscape of the living hint at a shadowy, crowded place. It lacks a concrete quality in part because it is accessed through the perceptions of a child—Beloved was barely walking when she was murdered—and because the concrete is seemingly absent from the spirit realm. Indeed, she has trouble with her own physicality; keeping her head on and her teeth intact is literally a struggle for Beloved not to fall apart. The collision between the living and non-living worlds is less extreme in Morrison’s other novels, but it is still present. Milkman Dead dismisses Freddie the janitor’s story that his mother was killed by ghosts and his birth brought on by a woman who was transformed into a white bull. In Milkman’s frame of reference it is merely the superstitions of the uneducated and gullible. As Song of Solomon progresses Milkman must acknowledge his own ghosts and the intertwining spaces of the past and present, “real” and “unreal.” In time, he will encounter the spirit of his own grandfather, a murdered man who brings cryptic messages to Pilate. Macon Dead I is a restless soul who insists on recognition. He moves between the spirit realm and the
96305_Russell_03_27.qxp
50
3/28/2006
11:18 AM
Page 50
Between the Angle and the Curve
spaces his progeny occupy in a desperate attempt to be understood. Initially, however, Milkman’s reaction is one of skepticism and discomfort; he insists not only on separate spheres, but also on the non-existence of the spirit world. Avoidance through denial is a tactic employed by Richard Misner and Anna Flood in Paradise. Entering the convent grounds after the attack on the women they sense something, but cannot agree on what it is. The encounter sparks a seemingly light-hearted debate: What did a door mean? . . . a window? focusing on the sign rather than the event . . . anything to avoid . . . what they were wondering. Whether through a door . . . or a beckoning window . . . What would be on the other side? (305)
Lacking the personal incentive of Milkman or the tangible presence of Beloved (a bridge between the two realms), Richard and Anna attempt to keep their discussion light and on the surface level. The laughter is, however, tinged with fear and dread. Sensing another realm, they can neither open the door intellectually nor peer through the window imaginatively. The haunting question “what on earth” gestures towards a terrain the pair cannot enter; they retreat behind laughter to the security of the “real world” (305). Dreamscapes make the intangible tangible. The blend of concrete details with the surreal and fanciful create the impression that the landscape is both “real” to the touch and ephemeral in nature. Song of Solomon has a key scene where Milkman describes what he calls a dream to Guitar. Watching his mother planting tulips, Milkman is witness to an unreal phenomenon: “the flowers grew [to the point that] only her shoulders [and] flailing arms [were visible] high above those bobbing, snapping heads” (105).8 In narrating the experience Milkman denies its “reality”—it was a dream—but the moment of experience is very real to him. Despite this fact, he hides behind the defense that it was merely a dream when Guitar challenges him on his failure to help his mother. Putting aside the issue of personal responsibility (a lesson Milkman will painfully learn), the exchange between the men suggests that Guitar sees, and seeks, no distinction between the waking world and the dream state. He can access a variety of sources of knowledge. It is a skill Milkman must develop during his journey to his ancestral home. At this point Milkman insists upon a separation of, and value distinction between, the two spheres. Fanciful and physical landscapes are represented as inseparable in Sula and Tar Baby. Interaction between the two types of spaces is spontaneous
96305_Russell_03_27.qxp
3/28/2006
Background Foregrounded
11:18 AM
Page 51
51
and frequent in these two texts. Long before a physical encounter, Nel and Sula meet in dreams. Solitude sends them “stumbling into Technicolored visions [which] included . . . someone, who, . . . shared the . . . dream” (51). The dreamscape is a comforting space for Nel and Sula. It is a space of colour and connection that blends seamlessly with their everyday settings—Edna Finch’s Mellow House and Garfield Primary School. Ill at ease in their homes and in the company of their families, the dream world offers the young girls what the real world withholds. Son’s efforts to insert the geography of Eloe into Jadine’s dreams in Tar Baby are conscious attempts to circumvent the obstacles which separate him from the woman he desires. Awake in the “real” world, Son whispers a landscape into being, manipulating the terrain of the sleeping woman’s mind. He attempts “to insert his own dreams into her . . . about yellow houses with white doors . . . and the fat black ladies . . . minding the pie table in the basement of the church . . .” (119). Son too approaches dream and real world settings as inseparable. He attempts to seduce Jadine via her dreams not as an end unto itself, but as a prelude to consummation in the waking world (45). Cather’s forays into the dreamscape also incorporate physical geography with imaginative realms. The focus in A Lost Lady is on the landscape as the concretized dream. Captain Forrester shares his philosophy of dreams: “a thing that is dreamed . . . is . . . an accomplished fact” (44–45). The “railroads across the mountains” sprang from their dreams much like he “dreamed [his] place on the Sweet Water” (44–45). Settling the West was in effect the creation of a dreamscape; it is the living embodiment of the visions of a group (or groups) of people. Unfortunately, it is a dying dreamscape. Vulnerable to the manipulations of a generation “trained to petty economies,” the space and “the princely carelessness of the pioneer” territory is literally, and figuratively, losing ground to economic exploitation (90). Practical concerns supersede aesthetic values. Ivy Peters drains Captain Forrester’s beautiful, but unproductive marsh in order to create grazing land; it is both a pragmatic and spiteful act. The “noble” vision is fading. It no longer dominates the physical terrain or the value systems of the men of power. Alienated from his own generation (Ivy Peters and his ilk), Niel Herbert is cast in the dubious role of the recorder of this soon to be vanquished era: “the visions . . . would always be his” (145). Men and dreams are drifting into the territory of memory. The airy visions, briefly realized, are destined to be remembered in the reveries of a kindred soul, not immortalized in the living landscape. They become a lingering presence behind the visible features of the environment.
96305_Russell_03_27.qxp
52
3/28/2006
11:18 AM
Page 52
Between the Angle and the Curve
Visions inspired by the landscape in Death Comes For the Archbishop are both disorienting and reaffirming for the title character. Cather plunges Jean Marie Latour into an unfamiliar setting that tests his physical endurance while reinforcing his spiritual commitment. New Mexico challenges Latour’s sense of reality as “every mesa was duplicated by a cloud mesa” and the “great tables of granite . . . were inconceivable without their attendant clouds, which were a part of them, as the smoke is part of the censer . . .” (95). Cloudscape mirrors landscape. There is a surreal quality to the cloud formations; they shift shapes. In this exotic environment surface the memories of others—specifically the Orient. Alternately “flat terraces” and “silvery pagodas” the clouds are as much a creation of the viewer as they are of atmospheric conditions (95). The reference to the censer in particular suggests that these impressions are filtered through the perspective of a religious man. Latour’s response speaks to his aesthetic sensibilities and his intellect. Imposing an alien culture on the setting (pagodas) the priest highlights the foreignness of his own faith in such a land. As he will come to understand, Latour must connect his religion to the landscape if he is to propagate it. Learning to read the Southwestern terrain is crucial to Latour’s personal, and professional, spiritual development. The recognition that more than merely complementary, land and sky are “inconceivable” without each other is a pivotal discovery. Latour envisions an inverted order stemming from the unique physical setting: while normally “the sky is the roof of the world . . . here the earth was the floor of the sky” (232). One lives not on the earth, but in the sky, Latour concludes. The importance of the land pales in comparison with the celestial sphere. It is rather fitting for a man of God to raise his eyes to heaven, but it is not just the cloudscape that inspires Latour’s meditations. The opening pages of “Book One” find him lost in a “geometrical nightmare.” The monotony of the landscape bewilders Latour: the “blunted pyramid, repeated . . . upon his retina . . .” prompts him to close “his eyes to rest them . . .” (17–18). Disoriented by heat, exhaustion, and the seemingly endless monotony of the New Mexico terrain, Latour tries to shut the “intrusive omnipresence of the triangle” out completely. Truly a lack of insight, for it is in the external environment that Latour finds the internal fortitude to endure his physical hardships. The New Mexico desert functions as a physical embodiment of Latour’s spiritual terrain—if only he would utilize both his eyesight and his imagination. Opening his eyes, the priest discovers the tree which resembles the cross. Physical and spiritual landscapes merge as the triangle is refined into a more readily recognizable representation of the Holy Trinity—the
96305_Russell_03_27.qxp
3/28/2006
11:18 AM
Page 53
Background Foregrounded
53
Cross. Prayer before the juniper tree leaves him “refreshed” and leads him to contemplate Christ’s sufferings (19). The desert withholds physical relief, but provides spiritual nourishment. “Bringing” faith to the “heathen” territory, the missionary rediscovers his own spirituality in the land. Latour need only recognize the possibility; meditating on the tree and the sky leads away from earthly concerns and back to God. As disorienting as the panorama is, particular details inspire Latour to remember both the sufferings of the Lord and his own spiritual commitment. MARKING THE LAND: PLACING OURSELVES IN THE LANDSCAPE The exchanges between people and places are frequently concretized in specific landscape features. Webster’s Dictionary defines a landmark as “a mark for designating the boundary of land: a fixed object . . . by which the limits of a farm, a town, or other portion of territory may be known and preserved; a conspicuous object on land that serves as a guide to navigation at sea; a natural object or man-made structure that marks a course or characterizes a locality; an event, achievement, characteristic, or modification that marks a turning point or a stage.” Landmarks help create territories; they separate one space from another. Focusing attention on specific details, they can be naturally occurring or artificially imposed on the landscape. Each type is inscribed with meaning beyond its physical presence. The true power of a landmark lies in its emotional and ideological significance. “Whether constructed by nature or by people,” O’Brien asserts, “landmarks are products of the human imagination, the visual equivalent of folktales and stories” (61). We have a strong need for landmarks; they both ground us (tangible presence demarcating boundaries) and free us (appeal to our imaginative processes). They weave our stories into the fabric of the physical world. Cather explores the disconcerting effects of an absence of landmarks in several of her works. Unfamiliar territory leaves a traveler with little or no frame of reference. The intangible benefit of a landmark is highlighted in Death Comes For the Archbishop. Comparing the plight of the early missionaries to New Mexico with that of St. Paul and his companions, Latour concludes, that there was a comfort in suffering “in that safe little Mediterranean world, amid the old manners, the old landmarks” (276). Among the numerous hardships endured by “New World” missionaries, foreign terrain and the absence of familiar (and therefore emotionally comforting) features are the primary privations in Latour’s estimation. To
96305_Russell_03_27.qxp
54
3/28/2006
11:18 AM
Page 54
Between the Angle and the Curve
endure torment in a visually recognizable landscape is somehow less painful than suffering in an alien setting. The missionary experience, as Latour describes it, is not unlike that of the prairie pioneer. The overpowering presence of the land itself and one’s consequent inability to discern scattered and diminutive dwellings in the landscape have an emotional and psychological impact on settlers. Jim Burden’s transplantation from Virginia to Nebraska in My Antonia captures the disorienting effects of an unfamiliar terrain: there was “nothing to see; no fences, no creeks, or trees . . . nothing but land . . .” (7). This new landscape is described in terms of what it is not; absences define it as it is contrasted with Virginia—a place of distinct landmarks. The vastness of Nebraska instills a sense of alienation, of being inconsequential, leading Jim to confess, “between that earth and that sky I felt erased, blotted out” (8). It is a space in the initial stages of becoming place. It holds both the opportunity for artistic creation and the possibility of continued isolation. Locating himself in this unsegmented environment is a daunting task to the young boy; he has no means of grounding himself. A desire to assert identity, indeed to mark existence, is frequently translated into the construction of a structure designed to dominate the natural landscape. It is a public performance of identity; often a tangible representation of an intangible value system. The building becomes an external symbol of the internal struggle to overcome the debilitating effect of the new country. “The absence of human landmarks” in a new country is “depressing and disheartening,” insists the narrative voice in O Pioneers! (13). A proud symbol of personal and collective identity, the Church of Sainte-Agnes is visible for miles, unlike the town. Although of a more modest scale, it is not unlike Latour’s cathedral in Death Comes for the Archbishop. The strong physical presence of the place of worship—“powerful and triumphant”—is a dramatic declaration of the enduring faith of its parishioners (141). It is both a structure and a message that insists on recognition. Although the expressed purpose of the building is spiritual, it also fulfills a secular function: it breaks the psychological and physical effect of the otherwise uninterrupted landscape. The secular and the spiritual comingle in a prominent structural feature in Paradise. Responding to the “extravagant space” of freedom the original founders of Haven construct a communal oven: “having been routed from office by whites, refused a homestead by coloreds, [they] wanted to make a permanent feature in that open land . . .” (99). The oven is a testimony to the strength of the group. It speaks of the hardships they have weathered as a unit. It is, initially, a site that serves practical purposes: suste-
96305_Russell_03_27.qxp
3/28/2006
Background Foregrounded
11:18 AM
Page 55
55
nance and companionship. It unites the community. When the descendants of Haven’s settlers must relocate they “broke up the Oven and loaded it into two trucks even before they took apart their own beds” (16). The moment marks a shift in the collective experience of the landmark. Symbolic value supersedes practical concerns; this former emblem of communal cohesion creates a quiet, but insidious division. The once valued landmark is transformed into a bulky burden: the women say nothing “but privately they resented the truck space given over to it. . . . Resented also the hours spent putting it back together . . .” (103). Preoccupied with the more “prosaic” details of relocating their families to an as yet unformed town (Ruby), the women do not acknowledge the symbolic importance of the oven. Soane Morgan seems to speak for all the women when she expresses a concern that “a utility [has] become a shrine . . .” (103). The quest to “make a permanent feature in that open land” in this novel is a gendered one. It is also generational; the youth of Ruby have no interest in maintaining the Oven, openly challenging its meaning. The evolving needs of the community are not reflected in the static symbol. Its significance is lessened by its failure to fit into the cultural landscape. A landmark need not be religious or quasi-religious in order to have emotional or psychological resonance. Houses too can be symbolic features of the landscape.9 When the Burdens move to Black Hawk in My Antonia their home is a landmark for those from the country. The building signals a transition from the country to the town; it thus has a practical geographic value. It carries a message separate from its inhabitants—the Burdens purchase it from Preacher White—but the human element is an integral part of the landmark. The house is a distinct symbol of hospitality—the barn is at the disposal of the farmers and the dwelling provides rest, refreshments and a place to tidy up after the long journey. A house likewise fulfills a dual function in Beloved. 124 evolves into a symbol of cordiality and a marker of a journey’s end. Under Baby Suggs’ loving care, the structure on the edge of the community becomes a site of safety and healing for those escaping slavery or other forms of persecution. It was a “cheerful, buzzing house where . . . Strangers rested [and] . . . Messages were left . . .” (87). The existence of a recognizable landmark is particularly powerful given the physically disorienting effects of slavery. Denying the slave knowledge of the countryside was a crucial element of control; as Diedrich and Sollors observe: “if you don’t know where you are, you don’t know where to run” (5). Like the Burdens’ home, 124 takes on a significance beyond the dwelling of a particular family. Each house is a part of the physical and verbal landscapes; the structure is visible on the horizon and the sanctuary it affords
96305_Russell_03_27.qxp
56
3/28/2006
11:18 AM
Page 56
Between the Angle and the Curve
is reflected in, and through, oral tales shared by travelers. Clearly human interaction elevates these two homes; it is the kindness and nurturing received within the walls and the opportunity to connect with fellow human beings which raises their status above a country-inn or waystation. Close attention to the description of 124 reveals a poignant fact: it exists only in the past. It “had been” a positive and nurturing place. Jim Burden revisits his family home via his memoir. Despite the distance of time, it remains a heartening and active location. Time is not so kind to 124. The house is invaded by slave-catchers and a mother responds in a horrifying way. After the murder and attempted murders (death before re-enslavement is Sethe’s distraught conclusion), 124 ceases to be a landmark because of the actions of its inhabitants. The physical presence of 124 (on the outskirts of town) remains, but its recuperative powers (whether for the body or the spirit) are obliterated. Social ostracism and desperate violence nullify a previously integral sanctuary. 124 takes on an entirely new symbolic significance after Sethe’s release from prison. It serves as a warning to the rest of the community of their personal and collective vulnerability. Naturally occurring landmarks occupy a different, but equally precarious position. Human intervention can physically destroy a natural landmark—manipulating the environment for any number of purposes—or emotionally shelter it. In a sparse landscape, unique features take on a heightened importance. Jim Burden explains the protective sentiment towards trees: “trees were so rare . . . that we used to feel anxious about them . . . the scarcity of detail . . . made [it] so precious” (21). A distinctly visible and poignant part of the prairie, trees achieve a presence beyond their physical size. Individual trees are readily identifiable, but it is their symbolic representation of the settlers’ own struggles which makes them so evocative. Jim’s trees give shape to the prairie and to his personal experience. An external sign of an internal state, the frame of mind of the viewer enhances the visual impact of the natural symbols. Natural landmarks surface at key points in Death Comes For the Archbishop, particularly in the story of Father Junipero. Lost with a companion in the desert, the pair is disheartened until they see “three great cottonwood trees . . .” (278). They are taken care of by a “pious” family who reside near the trees (279). When the missionaries return to the monastery their auditors declared the trees are a local landmark, but no one lived in that region. Failure to locate the dwelling and the memory of the serenity of the family (the child in particular) leads the priests to conclude that their saviors were not earthly, but spiritual entities. The tangible presence of the three stately trees evokes the majesty of the Holy Family. As the men of faith feel their “hearts”
96305_Russell_03_27.qxp
3/28/2006
Background Foregrounded
11:18 AM
Page 57
57
weaken the desert landscape offers spiritual sustenance. Archbishop Latour is so moved by the story that he permits himself to repeat it only twice; perhaps his protective gesture is a testament to his own spiritual encounter with a Cross-like tree (18). Spiritual or sensual, the knowledge of a landmark’s existence can inspire a variety of pilgrimages. Naturally occurring monuments take on a decidedly erotic tone in Morrison’s Paradise. Sent on an elusive quest by her boyfriend, Gigi seeks a rock formation “shaped like lovers;” near “a town called Wish” she will find “loving to beat the sky” (63).10 There is no official record of the town “too small for a map;” residents of Tucson dismiss her queries as “crazy” (64). Gigi gives up her attempt to reconnect with her missing boyfriend, but not “the desert lovers [who] broke her heart” (64). Conceding Mickey has the location wrong, she clings to the conviction that his claim simply “summoned to the surface what she had known all her life existed . . . somewhere” (64). Morrison’s use of the ellipses succinctly conveys the intangible nature of this “landmark.” For Gigi it is real, despite her inability to locate it; the rock formation concretizes a feature of her internal landscape. The town is aptly, if incorrectly, named, for this intimacy is precisely what Gigi wishes for—“loving to beat the sky.” The search for the rock lovers leads Gigi to the discovery of another sensual symbol. A traveling companion tells her he has heard of “two trees [which] grew in each other’s arms” (66). Ruby, Oklahoma is said to be the location of this natural phenomenon. Legend has it that the entwined trees increase sexual desire and squeezing between them leads to “an ecstasy no human could invent or duplicate” (66). Again it is a “landmark” which must be sought out to be viewed—it is not labeled on a map or advertised as a tourist attraction. It is a tale told by a new acquaintance who has only “heard of,” not witnessed, the natural wonder. While the story of the tree lovers propels Gigi to travel to Ruby, she never locates the trees. It is a privilege which belongs to Consolata, the pseudo-nun whose lover shows her the two entwined trees. The pair of arboreal lovers provides their human counterparts with shade and the “protection of [their] agonized trunks” (231). The natural realm sanctifies what the social world would condemn—an illicit love affair. The connection between the sets of “lovers” gives the landmark its poignancy as the odd couplings mirror each other. Morrison’s landmarks lack the high visibility normally associated with public markers, but they are intensely significant in the personal and erotically charged landscapes of her characters. They fail to appear on official maps, the records of white, mainstream cultural geography. They are
96305_Russell_03_27.qxp
58
3/28/2006
11:18 AM
Page 58
Between the Angle and the Curve
nonetheless part of the “panorama” Zukin identifies as incorporating “both the landscape of the powerful—cathedrals, factories, and skyscrapers—and the subordinate, resistant, or expressive vernacular of the powerless—village chapels, shanty towns, and tenements” (16). Markers, in Morrison’s fiction, are located via “counter” maps that privilege the personal over the authenticated. It is often a subversive space accessed through verbal rather than physical guides. Hovering around the edges of “recognized” landscapes (the ones with the authoritative “voices”), the monuments offer alternate definitions of what constitutes a landmark. They are an example of what McKee deems “Morrison’s black American cultures [struggling] to claim the spaces of their existence, their culture, and their history that whites have seen as empty” (Producing American Races, 25). They are only visible to a specialized eye, inserted into the landscape for a distinct audience. Sought out by characters who are themselves on the fringe of the dominant society, it follows that the landmarks are likewise marginalized. Despite being isolated farmers or spiritual pilgrims, Cather’s characters are able to carve out clear positions in the landscapes. The landmarks they create or discover (for the most part) fit seamlessly into the social map (even Latour’s Cathedral, while visually jarring, is accommodated in the social landscape by virtue of its purpose). Churches, crosses and houses are easily recognizable and blend into the collective environment with little or no conflict. Rock or tree lovers in sexually explicit positions, ovens verging on shrines, and houses which support escaped slaves (and later a murderer) are a challenge to the notion of common landmarks or even a shared experience of geography. And yet, although they have diverse appearances, landmarks in the fiction of Cather and Morrison are, at their cores, similar. Both authors utilize these features to convey a message of hope, support, and a sense of belonging to the individuals who view them. Connection to, and through, the landscape occurs on several levels: self-identification is contingent on place, the identification of place is largely determined by the individual’s sense of identity, and the place of the individual within the group and the group within the larger society, all shape the experience of space. Locating oneself in the cultural, social, or physical landscape is made easier by the presence of landmarks. Recognizing these markers requires an awareness of the entire terrain; the “background” therefore functions as the explication to the story in the foreground.
96305_Russell_03_27.qxp
3/28/2006
11:18 AM
Page 59
Chapter Three
Maneuvering through the Maternal Landscape: Traditions, Tropes, and New Techniques
Identity and place, as Chapter Two illustrated, are intimately connected. Such an assertion has several interpretations; firstly, who we become has much to do with the places we develop in and, secondly, the definition of place hinges upon human identification. The use of landmarks to reshape (and thereby redefine) an alien environment is one method of coping. Another popular tactic is to render the mysterious as recognizable, to make the exotic domestic. Through the act of naming we change space to place, the unfamiliar terrain to the familiar territory. In this drive to decipher a disconcerting landscape we frequently (and perhaps logically) turn to human— primarily female—features to demystify the unknown quantity. “The complicated topography of the female genital parts,” Freud asserts, “makes one understand how it is that they are often represented as landscapes.”1 I would argue that the easily recognizable visual relationship between land forms and female features (hills and breasts, valleys/caves and vagina/womb) affords a more compelling rationale. In identifying the landscape as female, we are, in effect, transforming the unfamiliar into the “familial.” “Mother earth,” however, is not the only interpretation of the feminized terrain. Concepts of the virgin territory and land as object of (sexual) conquest do complicate the use of topography. The mimetic relationship between body and land is appreciated with little effort by the eye. The “I” too responds, for, as Holly Youngbear-Tibbetts observes, our “first knowledge . . . is topographic—the landscape of the maternal body . . .” (32). There is a degree of intimacy created through the equation of earth and mother; tentative, tactile, explorations of identity 59
96305_Russell_03_27.qxp
60
3/28/2006
11:18 AM
Page 60
Between the Angle and the Curve
(physical boundaries, emotional connections) are played out in the infant’s discovery of his/her body and that of the mother. Similar exchanges between the seeing “I” (of whatever age) are (to varying degrees) shaded by these early interactions. The seemingly benign connection between the female form and the natural environment does, however, have potentially sinister implications.2 Both “Woman and Nature are vulnerable to the desires of men,” cautions Rose (Feminism and Geography, 96). Exploitation can be both literal and literary; sexualized landscapes frequently objectify woman and nature for particular ends. Appropriation of natural resources and indigenous women are well-documented aspects of colonization. The human cost of the push to “tame” undeveloped regions is painfully recorded in various sources—history books, company ledgers, and the writings of both the conquerors and the conquered. Alison Blunt and Gillian Rose document the tactic of incorporating “sexual imagery” in Imperialist literature “to create and sustain the heroic stature of male colonizers who conquered and penetrated dangerous, unknown continents, often characterized by the fertility of both indigenous vegetation and women” (10). The explorer is thus a virile, sexual adventurer. Such a paradigm excludes woman as colonizer; there is no “masculine” wilderness ripe for her to subjugate. Action is the prerogative of the male while passive acceptance is the lot of the female. Even the relatively domestic chore of settling “non-foreign” territory exploits the concept of a gendered landscape. The farmer is a rather ambiguous figure of adventure; raising crops and animals, while hard work, is rarely viewed as being the equivalent of “conquering” and “penetrating” “unknown continents.” The literary representation of the masculine pioneer, however, frequently collapses the distinction between the heroic explorer and the man who cultivates the discovered land. MASCULINE FARMER, FEMININE LAND: SETTLEMENT OR SEDUCTION? Images of early settlements in North America often focus on the conquest of a wild, but fertile land, “a mythic place” Susan Armitage identifies as “Hisland,” which is “perpetuated in western history texts . . .” (3). It is a region populated by “a cast of heroic characters [who] engage in dramatic combat, sometimes with nature, sometimes with each other . . . they are mountain men, cowboys, Indians, soldiers, farmers, miners, and desperadoes, but they share one distinguishing characteristic—they are all men” (3). I would add, they are all conspicuously single men.
96305_Russell_03_27.qxp
3/28/2006
11:18 AM
Page 61
Maneuvering through the Maternal Landscape
61
The myth that emerges from (or perhaps along with) the American frontier, is the unattached male braving the wilderness free from the constraints of domesticity and women. Nash Smith provides a rather telling letter from a witness to a wagon train: . . . there assembled during May, 1843, American citizens with their families . . . each one on himself alone dependant [sic] . . . Surrounded by his wife and children, equipped with wagon, ox-team, and provisions . . . without . . . other protection than their invincible rifles and the wives and progeny clustered around them. (38)
The author, William Gilpin, ranks the wife and children ahead of the wagon, but behind the “invincible rifles.” Migration is a family affair (three references in a brief excerpt), but the focus remains on the “American citizen”— the male pioneer. Despite historical evidence to the contrary—Daniel Boone too had a wife and children—the socially unfettered fellow dominates western mythology. He is freedom personified. The difficulties of accommodating a sedentary lifestyle within a masculine myth of adventure are fairly obvious: mobility versus settlement, selfindulgence versus social responsibility, bachelorhood versus marriage. Smith concludes that, by virtue of his profession, the frontier farmer had little popular appeal as a literary hero. Redefining the parameters of the farmer’s activities is one tactic of elevating his heroic status. A “national erotics of male dominance,” theorizes Mary Paniccia Carden, reads America as “begotten by self-made men on the sometimes pliant, sometimes resistant, but always feminized wilderness” (275). It is a decidedly sexual exchange. Playing with the writings of Richard Slotkin (Regeneration Through Violence: The Mythology of the American Frontier) and Frederick Jackson Turner (The Frontier in American History), Carden captures the symbolic physicality of the interaction: America is a “wide-open land of unlimited opportunity for the strong, ambitious, self-reliant individual to thrust his way to the top; in the ‘virgin soil of the frontier,’ this ‘thrusting’ male pioneer enacts the violent heroics of masculine creativity that expand national borders” (275).3 Territorial conquest is an act of sexual aggression and possession. The plough is a substitute penis that breaks the virgin soil for the cultivation of crops. The pioneer foregrounds the fact that the frontier is a transitory state. Settlement belies the notion of the limitless expanse; the boundary can only be pushed so far. The frontier scout is therefore an endangered species from the moment he enters the literary imagination. Re-casting the role of heroic nation-builder is an inevitable development. Westward movement, Smith’s
96305_Russell_03_27.qxp
62
3/28/2006
11:18 AM
Page 62
Between the Angle and the Curve
study concludes, formulated new communities, “communities devoted . . . not to marching onward but to cultivating the earth. They plowed the virgin land . . . and the great Interior Valley was transformed into a garden . . .” (123). Man reconstructs the unruly environment; taming the land is an act of imposing order and productivity. The relationship between settler and setting is decidedly adversarial. Pioneers respond to the landscape, Smith notes, with hostility tinged with fear. Warfare, not harmony, best describes his reading of the settler/setting relationship; the “idealized frontier farmer [is] armed with that supreme agrarian weapon, the sacred plow” (123). The peaceful imagery evoked by the reference to a garden is undercut by the implication of violence. Cultivation is an act of aggression in Smith’s context. It becomes a self-defensive gesture in Roderick Nash’s assessment. He similarly identifies “conquest of [the] wilderness” as the “major concern” of the pioneer (24). Significantly the notion of subduing the wilderness is not limited to the land; while on the “direct, physical level, it constituted a formidable threat to his very survival . . . civilized man [also] faced the danger of succumbing to the wildness of his surroundings and reverting to savagery himself” (24). The untamed land poses a physical and emotional threat to the early farmers. It has the potential to be a benefactor, but is approached as an opponent. In both studies, the pioneer is clearly masculine while the landscape is suggestively feminine—the virgin soil.4 America as a garden raises several related, but contradictory images in writings about the frontier. Smith’s garden is the product of “heroic” physical toil. Annette Kolodny offers an alternative vision in The Lay of the Land: America is the garden, waiting to be experienced. Many immigrants she asserts, were inspired by a desire to embrace “a maternal ‘garden,’ receiving and nurturing human children . . .” (5). “Eden, Paradise, the Golden Age, and the idyllic garden,” Kolodny proposes, “were subsumed in the image of an America promising material ease . . . and a return to the primal warmth of womb or breast in a feminine landscape” (6). The new landscape is a sheltering space providing sustenance and security. While it is approached as an ideal (and idealized) locale in this romanticized assessment, the land is not immune to the manipulations of the settlers. As they quickly recognized, Kolodny points out, “the success of settlement depended on the ability to master the land, transforming the virgin territories into something else . . .” (7). It should be noted that once again the land is feminine and the settler masculine (Kolodny draws attention to the obsession with “the lone male in the wilderness”). The gendered landscape, while theoretically idyllic, is in need of practical “improvement.” Settlement, by its very nature, must alter the environment.
96305_Russell_03_27.qxp
3/28/2006
11:18 AM
Page 63
Maneuvering through the Maternal Landscape
63
The pioneer experience reshaped both the land and the human landscape. Mike Fischer contends that “there can be no Eden in Nebraska, because its origins are not innocent” (37). “Populating” the new territory was actually a process of displacing and replacing the Plains Indians. Oblique references to the existence of Native Americans surface in My Antonia, but the absence of a continued presence is effectively glossed over. The origins of the “garden of America” differ markedly when the myth is compared with history. Shelley Newman detects a similar discrepancy between the story of America and the reality of slavery. “Slavery is the original sin in the American garden,” she insists, noting that “linked with slavery, the myth of origin is doubled, opposing the foundation myth with the reality that fuels it” (57). The assault upon indigenous peoples and the violent relocation of Africans are crucial elements in the process of creating America. The myth of the garden welcoming, or fostered by, the white settlers cannot accommodate the facts of settlement, but it maintains its hold over the literary imagination. GARDENING IN THE NEW WORLD: “NATURALIZING” FEMININE SPACE The frontier as a whole is a garden in Smith’s version; it is the fruit of men’s labours. Kolodny narrows the scope of the cultivated space and redefines the gardener in The Land Before Her: Fantasy and Experience of the American Frontiers. Many female pioneers sought to defuse the apprehension created by the vastness of the new territory through “idealized domesticity.” Gardens and orchards break the immense terrain into manageable (and managed) portions. Practical needs and psychological supports are served by the familiarized natural space; the sustenance it provides is both physical and spiritual. The land and gardener achieve a type of harmony, albeit a tenuous one, given the harsh conditions of the environment. “Domesticity” suggests that the garden is an extension of the home while “idealized” introduces the notion of perfection or excellence. Rather than being “the garden of the world” these individualized gardens are intimate spaces, no less important to the process of settlement, but intensely personal places. They are protective enclosures in a landscape seemingly without borders (descriptions of the prairie in particular emphasize its immensity). The image of the garden as an intimate, often idealized, but always specialized space resonates throughout literature. Gardens recall what David Stouck identifies as “a literary tradition that locates innocence and happiness in a rural retreat, a tradition that equates the golden age with the garden of Eden” (53). Stouck specifically concentrates on pastoral art, but the
96305_Russell_03_27.qxp
64
3/28/2006
11:18 AM
Page 64
Between the Angle and the Curve
image of a private place of near, if not complete, perfection sheltering an emotionally fulfilled individual, is found in many types of writing. “The place of perfect repose and inner harmony,” A. Bartlett Giamatti concurs, “is always remembered as a garden” (11). Tranquility and a symbiotic relationship with nature are frequently associated with garden imagery. Connection with the land is equated with a type of spirituality and/or inner peace. It entails a withdrawal from the larger world into a self-contained space. More than a mere cultivated plot, the garden is a place of physical and intellectual retreat, theorizes J. Douglas Porteous: The garden, since Genesis and the Koran, has been a symbol of both earthly and future delight. Gardens have traditionally been places of privacy and retirement, where one may leave the troubles of the outer world and come to terms with the eternal cyclic round of growth. Gardens are symbols of regeneration and care. (96)
Contemplative sites, havens for spiritual regeneration, gardens are protective enclosures. They hold out the possibility of a desire fulfilled (spiritual or earthly) and the (re)-achievement of a symbiotic relationship with the natural realm. Part of the power of the garden’s appeal is its separation from worldly trials and tribulations; of course, should the isolation be externally rather than self-imposed, a creative centre can be transformed into a prison. The enclosed, walled garden can be protective and prescriptive. Multiple readings accompany the image of the garden, from “idealized domesticity” to “symbols of regeneration and care,” but it is primarily read as a feminine space. The figure in the garden, more often than not, is a woman. The man enters her space (and not infrequently her!); the fertility and sensuality of the land blend with that of the woman. Noting a “shift in the literary representation of the garden after Dante,” Giamatti identifies the major difference as the depiction of the woman in the garden: . . . in Dante’s Eden, for instance, Matelda was descended from Eve. . . . in the enchanted gardens of Ariosto, Tasso, and Spenser, Alcina, Armida and Acrasia are lineal descendants of Homer’s Circe. They are sorceresses, and what is true of them is true of their gardens: the more attractive they appear, the more dangerous they are. (5–6)
The female space is represented as tempting, but treacherous. He cites examples of “Knights seeking ease and pleasure who . . . succumbed to a ‘state of
96305_Russell_03_27.qxp
3/28/2006
11:18 AM
Page 65
Maneuvering through the Maternal Landscape
65
virtually infantile passivity’ as they lay motionless in the arms of the dominating female figure in the gardens” (359). Seduction is thus an act of destruction (Eve lost Adam Eden!). “Distracted” from their noble quests, these men are essentially emasculated by their experiences in the female gardens. Giamatti brushes over the fact that the Knights were “seeking ease and pleasure”—the gardens (and gardeners) in fact fulfill their desires. Whether derived from the sexual knowledge of Eve or the magical knowledge of Circe, the power of the woman is represented as a threat to the man. He must be on guard when entering her domain.5 CULTURAL CONSTRUCTS: THE CITY AS A MASCULINE DOMAIN While country and garden are represented as feminine landscapes the city is frequently written, and read, as masculine space. With its tall towers and carefully mapped streets the modern city can be interpreted as embodying Freud’s phallic symbols and Bachelard’s straight angles. It is a physically imposing landscape of concrete and steel erections. Space is divided into readily identifiable sections with specific purposes. Location reinforces social hierarchies: penthouse versus squat house. The city, at least in theory, is a place of distinct boundaries. In practice, however, commercial, financial, residential and entertainment districts often blend. While architects and city-planners do take the visual effect into account, utility is the primary concern of the city structure. The contrast between city and country is visually striking, but so too is the ideological comparison. The assumption that woman has a closer affinity with the natural realm than man does, and social theories on the “appropriate” behaviour of respectable women regarding the spaces and places they may inhabit, combine to render the city a male domain. It is “a space which is fashioned, shaped and invested by social activities during a finite historical period,” theorizes Lefebvre (73). Susan Merrill Squier proposes that because “the city is a cultural artifact” and “women have always had a problematic relationship to culture itself,” the division is socially engineered by “both biologically based and socially enforced stereotypes” (4). Susan Warwick offers a compelling observation: the garden and natural landscape are also cultural constructs; that is, even if the individual does not physically alter the environment, the act of viewing and interpreting imaginatively and intellectually constructs the setting.6 The concept of a naturally occurring feminine space is a mere myth. Elizabeth Wilson interprets the representation of the city as a purely masculine space as being equally mythical. While she concedes, “the city is
96305_Russell_03_27.qxp
66
3/28/2006
11:18 AM
Page 66
Between the Angle and the Curve
‘masculine’ in its triumphal scale, its towers and vistas and arid industrial regions,” Wilson asserts that “it is ‘feminine’ in its enclosing embrace, in its indeterminacy and labyrinthine uncentredness” (7). The city is neither masculine nor feminine; in her reading it is both. Despite a case for the androgyny of the city, the two spaces are more frequently approached as adversarial: “country versus city, feminine versus masculine.” This paradigm reinforces the notion of gendered territories; “the city cannot exist without its opposite,” Wilson observes. She summarizes the pattern as mapping “on to the opposition of city and country, culture and nature . . . male and female: man is culture and woman is the earth” (17). Such interpretations deny the complexity of both the city and the country (and male and female!); simplistic divisions and definitions only scratch the surface. The “nature” of the woman in the city, all too often, is oversimplified. Along with the image of the city as the bastion and cradle of civilization there exists the seamy, sexual component. The relative anonymity of the city creates openings for behaviours and desires not sanctioned by “proper” society. Accommodating woman as both a public and private occupant of the city (also a public and private entity) is not easy in the “either/or” paradigm. As a result, the presence of women in the city is frequently linked with sexual license; she is “temptress,” “whore,” “fallen woman,” “lesbian,” concludes Wilson. She is also “heroic womanhood who triumphs over temptation and tribulation” (6). She is both threat and the one threatened. Woman is the anomaly in the urban setting; not until Theodore Dreiser’s taboo-breaking Sister Carrie (1900) did the heroine boldly venture into the American city. Sexuality in fact is the key to Carrie Meeber’s success. AT PLAY IN THE CITY: RECONFIGURING THE CULTURAL ARTIFACT Representations of the city are not the mainstay of a Cather text; while several cities (New York, Chicago, Washington and Quebec for example) are featured in her writings, they are effectively overshadowed by rural settings. Despite the fact that she preferred to live and work in a city, Cather focused on country or natural settings in her fiction.7 When the city does appear in her writings it is often treated with ambivalence or outright hostility. Cather appears to write within the tradition of the city as a masculine space. Few of her female characters venture from their country homes; more often than not, Cather directs her artistic energies away from the urban environment. My Antonia briefly addresses the female experience of a non-country space. The sexual threat of the urban environment is conveyed through
96305_Russell_03_27.qxp
3/28/2006
11:18 AM
Page 67
Maneuvering through the Maternal Landscape
67
Antonia—she is seduced and betrayed in Denver—but the action takes place “offstage” and is only recounted briefly. While Denver is still in the west, and not much of a city at this point in time, it is clearly a distinctive space. It is larger than the town of Black Hawk and the brief glimpse provided by Mrs. Steavens—“she’d been living in a brick block, where she didn’t have proper conveniences to wash . . .”—suggests a squalid tenement (202). It is a block, not a home, and Antonia’s garments are not the only sullied items. Sexual and emotional vulnerability surround Antonia’s journey away from the country. It is to the rural land that the battered, but undefeated heroine returns; re-immersing herself in farm life heals Antonia. The city as a source of culture and entertainment is, however, valued in My Antonia. Cather has Antonia marry a man who likes “theatres and lighted streets and music” (235). He is a kindred spirit to Antonia’s own refined father. The “city versus country” debate is nonetheless lopsided in My Antonia: the “city man” Cuzak’s success is linked to Antonia’s fruitful farm and the children they create. He achieved nothing on his own in the city. Even the apparent success of Jim Burden—prominent lawyer, married “well,” lives in the city—is suspect. Jim follows the usual pattern of success: leave the farm for town, go to university, build a career in a cosmopolitan city, but his loveless and barren marriage and virtual detachment from the natural world (as a lawyer for the railway his connection with the landscape differs dramatically from his boyhood affinity with the environment) give his achievements a melancholy air. The city is not a glorified space in this novel. The image of an individual adrift in a heartless city surfaces in O Pioneers !. In this narrative it is a male character damaged by the urban environment. Cather anticipates the modernist interpretation of the city as an alienating place. Carl Linstrum laments the soul-crushing indifference of the city. He is one of thousands with “no ties . . . When one dies, they scarcely know where to bury him” (83). Freedom, Carl warns Alexandra, “means that one isn’t needed anywhere” (83). Based upon his personal experience and observations, Carl rejects the representation of the city as a superior cultural space. Anonymity and isolation mark the city experience, but Alexandra does not accept the conclusion that country life is inherently better. Behind the idyllic facade lurks the potential for emotional and intellectual atrophy: “We pay a high rent, too [growing] hard and heavy here . . . and our minds get stiff ” (83). The awareness that there is something larger than her farm comforts Alexandra. She voices a desire for her youngest brother Emil to journey to the city, but does not propose the adventure for herself. Knowledge that the city exists is sufficient for Alexandra; she expresses no need for a first-
96305_Russell_03_27.qxp
68
3/28/2006
11:18 AM
Page 68
Between the Angle and the Curve
hand view. Realistic about the limitations of her home, Alexandra still chooses to remain on the farm. She does not, perhaps cannot, envision herself within a city. An appreciation of a life force beyond her personal experience serves as a validation of Alexandra’s own life choices. A country girl alone in a big city is frequently a recipe for disaster in literature. Plunged into an unfamiliar cityscape in pursuit of her dream, Thea Kronborg, in The Song of the Lark, resists this pattern of defeat. Initially, Thea is indifferent to her surroundings; Chicago “was simply a wilderness through which one had to find one’s way” (169). The young girl is not impressed with the cultural construct. Thea conflates the country/city binary; Chicago is a “wilderness,” not a “civilized” space. The city is a necessary evil; labyrinthine, it must be deciphered in order to be navigated. Her father’s assessment of the city as a sordid site fails to titillate Thea (137). The city holds no allure for Thea. A soul-stirring concert and a mistake in directions are required to make Thea “conscious of the city itself . . .” (175). Accosted by several men, Thea begins to lose the sensation evoked by the music. The city poses a physical, sexual, and artistic threat to Thea. It is an adversary to be met head on, but that very resolution suggests that the city is also a catalyst, a challenge to the emerging artist. Negative in nature, the city is nonetheless a positive force for Thea; it introduces her to music as a true art form and intensifies her determination.8 Thea’s experience of the city is as close as Cather comes to an endorsement of urban life. Cities figure prominently, if ambiguously, in two of Morrison’s novels: Tar Baby and Jazz. The rural versus urban dynamic comes into play in Tar Baby, but it is the male character Son who is identified as, and champions, the country. Son describes the all black town of Eloe as “ninety houses, three hundred and eighty-five people;” so remote is this rural site that it cannot be reached by plane, train, bus or taxi—only “bumming a ride” can take you to Eloe (173, 244). The sharp contrast between Son and Jadine is concretized in their “native” environments. Jadine is a city girl, at ease in “Baltimore. Philadelphia. Paris” and above all, New York (173). Son is pure country. New York disorients Son. Alone in a hotel, he needs Jadine to provide “the ballast and counterweight to the stone of sorrow New York City had given him” (217). A self-reliant and self-sufficient man, Son is now adrift in a city inhabited by a strange race. The men are emasculated, the girls sorrowful, and old age and childhood have been hidden. It is a surreal experience which challenges his own sense of identity. Son interprets the inhabitants of New York as deformed and de-naturalized. They are familiar and yet unrecognizable. It is
96305_Russell_03_27.qxp
3/28/2006
11:18 AM
Page 69
Maneuvering through the Maternal Landscape
69
the urban environment, he concludes, which is responsible for the distortion of character. As he moves through the city he sees the walking wounded (the psychologically damaged) and feels himself slipping into a similar state of being. The city disturbs and diminishes Son, but it invigorates Jadine. New York reorients Jadine. She too is physically and psychologically altered by the metropolis, but it is an empowering experience for Jadine. The city seems to enter her body: her “legs were longer . . . her neck really connected her body, to her head . . . if ever there was a black woman’s town, New York was it. . . . she would . . . take it and give it to Son” (221–2). The “possession” is mutual; woman and city share a symbiotic relationship. Jadine has a freedom of movement, a feeling of belonging in New York which she is unable to achieve in Eloe or on the Isle des Chevaliers. It is not a damaging location for her; it heals Jadine on several levels. New York restores Jadine’s autonomy and independence. Concepts of masculinity and femininity are destabilized by the city. It is Jadine’s to “give” to Son; she will be his guide and provider (her friends sublet them the apartment, she earns thousands of dollars modeling). Son clearly feels “un-manned” by this “black woman’s town.” Despite her feelings about New York, the lovers relocate to Eloe. Jadine credits Son with making her feel “unorphaned,” not the city (209). The journey to Florida in fact “reorphans” her; the expectations of the tiny community drive a wedge between Jadine and Son. She is no more at ease in his rural hometown than Son is in her urban environment; neither can adapt to the behavioural codes of the other’s territory. Repulsed by the “flaws” in their respective “homelands,” geographic relocation becomes an exercise in redemption for Son and Jadine.9 Each interprets the other as needing to be rescued; conflicting locations are cast as adversaries in the struggle for autonomy. The city dominates Jazz. A strong presence in the text, it almost becomes a central character. The narrator confesses difficulty in distinguishing the people from the “work of the stonemasons,” when viewing the metropolis from an elevated vantage point (7). City structures and the lives of individuals become visually inseparable—both combine to create the City that requires no name. The narrator identifies the City as an invigorating place: it “makes me dream tall and feel in on things. . . . I’m strong. Alone, yes, but top-notch and indestructible—like the City in 1926 when all the wars are over and there will never be another one” (7). And yet, as the final pages of the novel make clear, the narrator is not a participant in city-life, but a mere voyeur. She is not “in on things” and her strength is suspect given that she fails in her anticipation of the tragedy of Violet, Joe and Felice (having
96305_Russell_03_27.qxp
70
3/28/2006
11:18 AM
Page 70
Between the Angle and the Curve
witnessed the violent resolution of the Violet, Joe, Dorcas entanglement, she incorrectly assumes the subsequent grouping will share a similar fate). The narrator’s false (and perhaps smug) sense of security is effectively conveyed in the haunting declaration that all the wars are over. Each of the narrator’s assertions about the City has a two-sided quality; she contends that the City affords freedom—“ordinary people can . . . get on the streetcar . . . and ride anywhere,” but they choose to remain in their neighborhoods “because everything you want is right where you are: the church, the store, the party, . . . the postbox (but no high schools), . . . the bootleg houses (but no banks) . . .” (10). It is a qualified freedom at best. Educational and financial institutions and opportunities lie elsewhere. Morrison’s use of brackets functions as a textual representation of social exclusion. The narrator describes a city within a city; race effectively divides the urban space. The area inhabited by black residents is defined against the larger—“white”—city. The implicit defiance of the statement, the insistence on freedom of movement, is belied by the limited choices available to black individuals. And, as was the case in Tar Baby, the City somehow distorts human progression: “the young are not so young here, and. . . . Sixty years . . . is as much as anybody feels like being bothered with” (11). City-life clearly exacts a personal price. Possibility and limitation, freedom and constraint, the City in Jazz is all things and nothing. Jocelyn Chadwick-Joshua articulates the contradictory nature of the city: it is “nurturer and agitator,” it reflects “the innermost desires, frustrations, and fears of [the] characters,” and it “paradoxically offers and denies . . . opportunity and freedom” (169–170). To a large degree the character of the city is contingent upon the characters themselves; personal choices and attitudes colour the city experience. The narrator’s decision to observe the lives of others signals an avoidance of the life force of the City (220). Adopting the role of mere watcher isolates and diminishes the narrator. Although she assumes a position of knowledge and authority, the narrator must finally confront both her acts of self-delusion and her lifeless life. By acting as the “objective” chronicler of the lives of others, the narrator denies her own subjectivity. In effect, she steps out of her own life in order to step into the lives of Violet and Joe. Failure to connect with other human beings leads to a sense of alienation which warps the narrator in Jazz; she is ultimately detached from both herself and the other characters. Failure to connect in Sula leads to worldweariness and indifference. Sula’s adventures cover a great deal of geography but all she discovers is boredom. The cities and men “merged into one large personality” (120–121). The inability to find a friend, to connect with her
96305_Russell_03_27.qxp
3/28/2006
11:18 AM
Page 71
Maneuvering through the Maternal Landscape
71
lovers distorts Sula’s experience of the city. New York fails to invigorate Sula as it did Jadine. Morrison explores the need for connection in “City Limits, Village Values: Concepts of the Neighborhood in Black Fiction.” She theorizes that the “missing quality in city fiction” is the ancestor. The presence of this figure transforms the setting: “the city is wholesome, loved when such an ancestor is on the scene, when neighborhood links are secure. The country is beautiful—healing because more often than not, such an ancestor is there” (39). The absence of an ancestor in Sula, Jazz, and Tar Baby accounts for the ambiguous representation of the city. Sula’s ancestors are in Medallion; despite her disconnection from her family, she returns “home” from the ancestor-less city. Joe and Violet connect with each other, but lack an ancestor—Joe’s mother is an elusive creature and the rest of their family is scattered, possibly dead. Jadine has the sensation that New York is home but having broken from her only relatives, she too lacks an ancestor. She returns, not to New York, but to Paris after her break up with Son. While Morrison holds out the possibility of connection in both an urban and rural location (wherever there is an ancestor), connection in Cather’s writing occurs in the country, not the city. Cather seemingly writes within the tradition of the city: it is represented as a sexual threat (Antonia’s experience), an indifferent creature (Carl’s impression), a hostile force (Thea’s sensation), and an emotionally barren place (Jim’s life and marriage in particular). With the exception of Thea’s experience, we only hear of city-life from a distance; the urban site is granted a peripheral position in most of Cather’s fiction.10 She does, however, diverge from the tradition of the city as a male domain in her treatment of the female artist. Cather acknowledges the potential artistic and intellectual value of the city through Thea’s development and, to a lesser extent, Alexandra’s conviction of the humanizing power of the city. “Possibility” is a stronger feature in Morrison’s representation of urban life than it is in Cather’s work. Morrison plays with the tradition of the city. She exposes the emotional detachment and isolating effect of the urban landscape through the narrator of Jazz and the character of Sula. There is, however, a strong suggestion that these two figures are complicit in their alienation; the narrator reduces her own life to being a mere observer of the lives of others, while Sula confuses a physical act with emotional intimacy. The possibility of personal connection is illustrated by the re-connection of Violet and Joe. The pair rediscovers the city as friends and lovers. Sexual freedom for women in the city is not without its pitfalls, Morrison makes clear, but nor is it without its pleasures. While Sula’s
96305_Russell_03_27.qxp
72
3/28/2006
11:18 AM
Page 72
Between the Angle and the Curve
affairs fail to gratify her emotional needs, Jadine’s relationship with Son clearly adds a dimension to her already empowering connection with the city, albeit temporarily. The social mores of Eloe which demand that Son and Jadine not only not share a bed, but also not share a house, do not come into play in New York. The traditional pairings of city and country, male and female are dramatically reversed in Tar Baby. Morrison challenges the stereotypes and the implications that accompany them. CULTIVATING THE PLOT: STORY TELLING THROUGH SPECIALIZED LANDSCAPES Another symbolically charged locale which both Morrison and Cather incorporate in their fiction is the garden. It is a specialized space with a scope of meaning which reaches far beyond its physical boundaries. Gardens have appeared in literature as sanctuaries and retreats, protective and empowering enclosures, sites of imprisonment, and symbols of fertility. They serve practical, emotional, psychological, aesthetic, and spiritual purposes. Typically the figure in the garden is female—nurturing, tending the vulnerable plants— her fertility is suggestively linked with that of the garden. Gardens figure prominently in Cather’s fiction, appearing in all of the texts in this study. While Morrison includes gardens in only three of the novels under discussion, they are also intensely significant symbols. In Song of Solomon, Paradise, and The Bluest Eye details of description are fairly sparse as the actual garden is secondary to the metaphorical one. Ruth Dead’s garden, as related by her son, is a surreal space in which the flowers smother her, “taking away her breath with their soft jagged lips” (105). Milkman interprets the episode as a warning against “seriousness,” but Guitar’s response suggests an alternate interpretation (105). He asks why Milkman, recognizing that his mother is being suffocated, did nothing. Guitar’s perception is razor sharp. The “dream” reveals Milkman’s irresponsibility and emotional detachment. What does the garden imply about Ruth? Milkman insists that she enjoys gardening and yet she appears to be “the unhappiest woman in the world” (104). Prior to her marriage, creativity through nature was a source of strength for Ruth. She took great delight in arranging fresh flowers and other natural objects in a bowl. Her husband’s inability to appreciate the beauty of her driftwood centerpiece (he criticizes her meal) destroys this creative outlet for Ruth. From this point on, the centerpiece is not an element of nature, but a watermark on the table. It too anchors Ruth; it functions “as a mooring a checkpoint . . . [assuring her]. That she was alive somewhere, inside . . .”
96305_Russell_03_27.qxp
3/28/2006
11:18 AM
Page 73
Maneuvering through the Maternal Landscape
73
(11). As a consequence of Macon’s cold criticism, Ruth has difficulty distinguishing her waking state from the realm of dream. Disconnected from nature and a natural life (her world is virtually reduced to her loveless marriage and tension filled house), Ruth appears to be unable to resist the oppressive forces acting upon her. And yet, Milkman sees her as “kicking to the last;” Ruth is diminished and ineffectual, but rejects defeat (105). The garden is a place of pleasure and misery for Ruth. The incident speaks to her sense of being overwhelmed by her own life—she after all plants the bulbs which rapidly grow into a life-force which smothers her—and to her relationship with her son—his callous indifference to her welfare in the dream reflects his attitude and behaviour in “waking” life. The message, like the surreal scene, is hazy. What is clear is that the mother’s garden is more complex than a simple, positive symbol of fertility, source of pleasurable labour, or retreat from the harshness of life. Gardens become instruments of war in Paradise. Spanning a ten year period, the battle of the blossoms accompanies an improvement in the material lives of the women of Ruby. Labour saving devices grant leisure time and allow the women to act on desire rather than necessity (90). The surplus time and energy are put to poor use and a hobby becomes a “habit” which in turn becomes “so frenetic a land grab, husbands complained of neglect . . .” (89). The conspicuous consumption of materialism is concretized in the town’s gardens. They serve no practical purpose—indeed they supplant vegetable gardens—and have little aesthetic value. The gardens become “de-naturalized” spaces, which serve as part of a social dialogue (“mine’s bigger than yours” mentality). Although the rivalry is over by the time of the story, the landscape is marked by “frenetic” competition. Ruby is filled with “fat, overwrought yards;” they are neither peaceful nor pleasing to the eye (90). The violence suggested by the phrase “garden battles” is precisely that—only a suggestion—but Morrison does link violence to the garden more directly in Paradise. The attack on the convent leaves no physical evidence (the bodies disappear) except in the garden which is a mixture of “blossom and death” (304). Without human care, the once productive garden reverts to a wild state. The death and regrowth visible in the yard mirror what has happened in the house. An absence of bodies and the inability to comprehend and articulate their disappearance is intensified by the sudden appearance of a door/window in the middle of the garden. Though incomprehensible to the viewers, the intrusive feature signals a world beyond the violence and destruction. The physical garden is transformed into a surreal site. Temptation and terror enter a garden robbed of its tranquility and order by a single act of violence.11
96305_Russell_03_27.qxp
74
3/28/2006
11:18 AM
Page 74
Between the Angle and the Curve
The violation of the garden takes a harrowing significance in The Bluest Eye. The child narrator Claudia MacTeer links the lack of marigolds with Pecola Breedlove’s tragedy. Haunted by guilt that she planted the seeds incorrectly, Claudia observes, “we had dropped our seeds just as Pecola’s father had dropped his seeds in his own plot of black dirt” (5–6). Pecola is literally her father’s garden; her infertility is linked with the infertility of the land: both seeds and baby die (6). Cholly Breedlove’s act, whether “lust or despair,” is the direct cause of his daughter’s psychological destruction. He is the primary, but not the only person responsible for Pecola’s misery. No marigolds grow in the neighborhood, and the symbolic link between Pecola and the plants is an indictment of the entire community. Claudia personalizes the guilt over, and sense of responsibility for, Pecola’s fate, but the larger group is culpable. It fails to protect the young girl and then hypocritically shuns her when she descends into madness. The image of the garden—a place of growth and sanctuary—is shattered just as Pecola, the “plot of black dirt,” is psychologically fragmented by the rape and stillbirth. Morrison utilizes a space replete with symbolism to explore emotionally charged issues—rape and incest. Cather’s representations of gardens tend to affirm the positive image of the garden. Imbued with more concrete details than those of Morrison, their symbolic value is in no sense diminished by the descriptive touches. Perhaps the most memorable of Cather’s gardens is Antonia Shimerda’s personal sanctuary. Rediscovering Antonia after a twenty year separation, Jim Burden senses: “the deepest peace in [her] orchard” (My Antonia, 219). The atmosphere is tranquil; the location is insulated and isolated. Antonia’s orchard serves as a refuge from life’s struggles, but it is a temporary retreat offering solace and the strength to face hardships. The prospect of burying their dog in this special place seems to be a genuine consolation for Antonia’s youngest children (219). The garden is not an avoidance of the difficult aspects of life. It is in fact a mechanism for facing them. The emotional needs of the grieving children are fulfilled without allowing them to become debilitating. Antonia’s garden provides a means for dealing with the realities of death and the continuation of life. The genesis of Antonia’s garden is a crucial element of its power. While it is clearly a maternal space—Antonia’s trees “were on [her] mind like children” and the fertility of the land is mirrored in her own large family—Antonia does recreate the “bench and . . . table under the bushes” of her father’s garden in her “grape arbor with seats built along the sides and a warped plank table” (150, 219). More importantly she preserves the social value of her father’s garden; it was a place where “he used to, sit . . . with his friend
96305_Russell_03_27.qxp
3/28/2006
11:18 AM
Page 75
Maneuvering through the Maternal Landscape
75
. . . [and] talk—beautiful talk” (150). Antonia opens her garden for the school picnic each year. As insulated and isolated as the enclosure seems to be it is, nonetheless, a social space. It is accessible to the community, albeit on Antonia’s terms. The society which once judged her, now seeks out Antonia’s enclave for social gatherings. Antonia’s garden symbolizes the successful merger of Old and New Worlds. It is a “cultivated plot” on several levels. Bountiful in terms of the fruit it provides, it is also a source of spiritual nourishment. The value of the sanctuary is poignantly emphasized by the absence of such a space in Jim Burden’s life; his only retreat is in his memory. Jim has an abstract connection with the land—loving it “with a personal passion”—but is virtually detached from it (2). Antonia has both a practical and a spiritual relationship with the country. Her garden sanctuary provides a temporary respite for Antonia; it is an idyllic space, but she is very much a part of the stream of life. “Idealized domesticity” through gardens is foregrounded in The Song of the Lark. Taming a portion of the prairie and de-mystifying the new terrain are crucial survival aids for the pioneer. Mrs. Kohler attempts to recreate her former Rhine Valley village in Moonstone, Colorado. Hiding in the transplanted vegetation, she “lived under the shade of what she had planted and watered and pruned. In the blaze of the open plain she was stupid and blind like an owl . . .” (20). Mrs. Kohler makes a “foreign” landscape familiar by reproducing the motherland. The emotional value of the cultivated plot outweighs its practical benefits. It anchors the woman. On the prairie Mrs. Kohler is altered, diminished; in her garden she is active and knowledgeable. Physically more open than Antonia’s enclosure, the Kohler garden is in fact the more isolated of the two places. Mrs. Kohler effectively barricades herself in her garden. She only leaves to make Christmas purchases (20). Mrs. Kohler is not an entirely anti-social figure. She does embrace Thea and undertakes the reclamation of Professor Wunsch: “the old woman went at him as she did at her garden . . .” (21). Unfortunately, Mrs. Kohler is less successful with the man than she is with the landscape. Professor Wunsch reverts to his old ways. In contrast, the prairie encroaches on, but does not conquer, the garden. The creative nature of the Kohler garden is elevated to a new level through Thea Kronborg. For the child, it was one of a limited number of welcoming spaces; at odds with the community, Thea sought out emotional resources in non-public places. Frequently, in the midst of (adult) artistic struggles and disappointments she finds herself “in the Kohlers’ garden:” “they save me: the old things, things like the Kohlers’ garden”
96305_Russell_03_27.qxp
76
3/28/2006
11:18 AM
Page 76
Between the Angle and the Curve
(384). Imaginatively, Thea returns to Mrs. Kohler’s garden when she needs nourishment for her soul. Although she refers to it as the “Kohlers’ garden,” the text is quite insistent that it is Mrs. Kohler who is truly responsible for its success. She creates “a garden of her own.” Thea is returning to a maternal space and the artistic stirrings of childhood and early adolescence. A self-protective creation is transformed into a site of inspiration which enhances Thea’s artistry. The garden is an imaginative sanctuary that liberates rather than restricts the growth of the artist. The garden itself can be a medium of artistic expression. The visual impact of their creations is clearly a factor for Mrs. Kohler and Antonia Shimerda; each woman cultivates an aesthetically pleasing setting which also serves practical purposes (fruit production, much needed shade). While typically the figure in the garden is female, Cather also incorporates male gardeners. Unlike the two women who combine utility with beauty, several of the men focus solely on the aesthetic impact of their gardens. Godfrey St. Peter, the title character in The Professor’s House, spends over twenty years creating “a French garden in Hamilton:” . . . not a blade of grass [in the] tidy half-acre of glistening gravel and glistening shrubs and bright flowers. There were trees, . . . a spreading horse-chestnut, a row of slender Lombardy poplars . . . Masses of greenbrier grew . . . the prickly stems interwoven and clipped . . . (6)
Ordered and meticulously maintained (qualities increasingly absent in his changing life), St. Peter’s garden has been “the comfort of his life” (5). It is not associated with his family—gravel hardly invites children’s play and it is the place where he “worked off his discontent” staying behind while his wife and daughters went on vacations—but “it was there that he and Tom Outland used to sit and talk . . .” (7). The garden has an exotic or foreign air about it. As Marilyn R. Chandler observes, St. Peter reveals a “preference for the European, the decorative, the exclusive, and the secluded over the more frank, sociable American use of outdoor domestic space” (195). Avoidance of the domestic is part of the allure of his garden for the professor. Unlike Antonia and Mrs. Kohler whose cultivated plots welcome their families and friends, St. Peter’s garden serves as a barricade against unwelcome intruders (his wife, daughters, and neighbours in particular). St. Peter makes a protective and male-centered enclosure. It is almost an unnatural natural setting bearing the mark of the interior designer more than that of a gardener (absent is the lush fertility of Antonia’s creation).12 The plants are not native to the region (not unlike Antonia’s and Mrs.
96305_Russell_03_27.qxp
3/28/2006
11:18 AM
Page 77
Maneuvering through the Maternal Landscape
77
Kohler’s introduction of non-native plants) and are essentially pruned into submission. St. Peter’s garden functions as a retreat from both his family and the larger human landscape (decidedly unlike Antonia’s use of her garden, and, to a lesser extent, Mrs. Kohler’s semi-inviting space). Not an inherently bad thing, if temporary, but there is a danger of a refuge becoming life-denying as opposed to life-sustaining. Escape can easily become abnegation. Captain Forrester’s garden in A Lost Lady is markedly less formal than Professor St. Peter’s, but the pitfalls of self-isolation remain. Incapacitated by an injury, Captain Forrester worked “in his garden, trimmed his snowball bushes and lilac hedges, devoted a great deal of time to growing roses” (23–4). This once giant of a man grows “heavier and weaker” (91). He is diminished, one might even say emasculated, by both his physical injury and his wife’s infidelity. Unable to satisfy his wife’s physical and economic needs, Captain Forrester is reduced to marking time on a sun-dial. Retreating to the sanctuary of his garden is a type of negation; the Captain is literally marking his time. It is also an avoidance tactic: focusing on the flowers distracts him from his failed marriage (distracts, not blinds—he knows about his wife’s infidelity). Godfrey St. Peter’s retreat to his garden is less dramatic in terms of his physical appearance, and yet he too approaches it as an opportunity to detach himself from family life. Characters who withdraw from the reality of life pay the ultimate price in O Pioneers !. Marie Shabata and Emil Bergson consummate their love in what appears to be an ideal location. Emil discovers Marie in the orchard which was “riddled . . . with gold . . .” (174). Marie emerges from a dream and, finding herself in Emil’s arms, whispers “I was dreaming . . . don’t take my dream away !” The orchard is sensual, almost a fairytale world, and the frustrated lovers are at last in a place conducive to their passion. Relatively private, the orchard is protected by a hedge “so dense that one could see through it only by peering closely between the leaves” (176). They are seemingly in a “walled garden of love.” The fruit garden, however, promises what it cannot provide. It is in fact an extension of a house made claustrophobic by jealousy. Violence enters the garden in the form of Marie’s husband—a figure conveniently forgotten by the lovers. The sanctuary afforded by the natural space is temporary; its protective powers are a mere illusion. Their dreamlike encounter is ethereal and Marie and Emil pay for their transgressions with their lives. Nature alone responds sympathetically to the ill-fated pair: the blood stained grass “told only half the story. Above Marie and Emil, two white butterflies . . . were fluttering in and out among the interlacing shadows, diving and soaring . . .” (182). The brutal reality of the murders is but part of the story; the passage implies that
96305_Russell_03_27.qxp
78
3/28/2006
11:18 AM
Page 78
Between the Angle and the Curve
some type of transcendence is the other. Earlier in the text Marie is described as moving “flutteringly, along the path, like a white night-moth;” both she and Emil are “free spirits” (166). Whether we interpret the white butterflies as Marie and Emil, or symbols of a life-force beyond that of individuals, the natural world seemingly commiserates with the lovers. Despite the presence of the murder victims, the tranquility of the garden reimposes itself: the natural cycle continues.13 Temptation and betrayal in a garden have a strong literary and religious resonance. In O Pioneers ! the garden, or more specifically the orchard, is the initial temptation. Marie Shabata tells Carl Linstrum (the original caretaker of the trees), “we’d never have bought the place if it hadn’t been for this orchard, and then I wouldn’t have had Alexandra . . . ,” nor, presumably, her brother Emil (91). Charmed by Frank Shabata’s appearance and eager to be free of the restrictions of school and family, Marie marries impulsively, but soon repents. Emil awakens Marie to the knowledge of love, desire, and genuine connection. The price of the knowledge takes on biblical proportions: expulsion from the edenic environment via the explosion of a shotgun. The allure of the fruit-garden sets into motion a whole series of misfortunes. Death Comes For the Archbishop explores the temptation of the garden on several levels. On its most basic level, the garden is a source of physical sustenance. Further development sharpens an epicurean attitude to food; Father Joseph laments the difficulties of cooking without proper vegetables. Missing his Sandusky garden and vineyard, he observes, it is a “missionary’s life; to plant where another shall reap” (39). The aesthetic value of the garden eludes the priest. Accustomed to a wider variety of tastes, Father Joseph is concerned with the practical benefits of cultivating crops. But he is also a truly religious character who recognizes the role of the missionary—planting seeds and sacrifice. He is therefore philosophical about his dietary deprivations. In sharp contrast to Father Joseph’s acceptance of austere conditions, Cather incorporates the story of Friar Baltazar, the tyrannical priest of Acoma. Driven by worldly desires and tastes, Baltazar exploits his flock for personal gain. The garden becomes the symbol of the discord between the religion he preaches and the personal demands he makes. It is formed and maintained through forced labour. The seeds Baltazar plants are the seeds of hostility. He alienates his congregation through exploitation and self-indulgence. Tempted by the physical and sensual gratification of the garden—“the Friar at Acoma lived more after the flesh than after the spirit”—Baltazar betrays his own faith (105). His exploits ultimately end in murder; one he commits and the other is his own. The women of Acoma in particular
96305_Russell_03_27.qxp
3/28/2006
11:18 AM
Page 79
Maneuvering through the Maternal Landscape
79
delight in the death of the garden. Tyrant and symbol both perish. The “loss” of the garden, in this context, is an act of liberation rather than a privation. The spiritual value of the garden is reinforced through the philosophy and actions of Father Latour. Recognizing the symbolic and practical value of the cultivated plot, the priest capitalizes on both attributes: his garden fulfills bodily, aesthetic, and spiritual needs. The Bishop’s sole recreation is his garden and it is truly a labour of love. He introduces “fruit as was hardly to be found even in the old orchards of California . . . [urging] new priests to plant fruit trees . . . and to encourage the Mexicans to add fruit to their starchy diet. Wherever there was a French priest, there should be a garden . . .” (265). Much like Antonia and Mrs. Kohler, Latour recreates the motherland in a foreign terrain. Indeed, the French priests are to be identified with, and by, their gardens. Latour’s horticultural efforts encourage inclusion; his cuttings reshape “many Mexican gardens” (201). Latour and his followers are planting seeds which alter the physical landscape. The variety of plants Latour’s garden produces provides physical benefits to priests and parishioners alike. More significant from the church’s perspective is the fact that they are sowing the seeds of faith which transform the spiritual landscape. A favorite quote, which Latour often shares with his students, highlights the symbolic value of the garden: “Man was lost and saved in a garden” (265). Delicate plant and fragile faith must be tenderly cared for in the harsh New Mexico environment. The garden is a simple, but enduring symbol of faith; it offers both temptation and salvation. The garden becomes a particularly complicated space (and symbol) in Sapphira and the Slave Girl. Technically, it is Sapphira Colbert’s domain; she owns both the land and the gardeners (her slaves). Visiting a dying Jezebel, the mistress emphasizes their joint labour in transforming the Virginia countryside: “When I sit out on the porch and look around, I often think how we used to get up early and rake over the new flower-beds and transplant before it got hot” (87). She articulates an experience of collective creativity, an immersion in nature, but the chore is imposed on Jezebel just as surely as the non-native plants are imposed on the land. In response to Sapphira’s prodding, “I expect you remember those things, too,” Jezebel simply “looked up at her and nodded” (88). The gesture is, at best, a vague articulation of assent. The silence suggests a different memory from that of the slave owner, but the text refuses to provide it. Jezebel’s involvement in the garden is framed as an honour: “until Jezebel was eighty years old, Sapphira had entrusted her to oversee the gardens . . .” (96). To say the least, the lack of choice renders the privileged status suspect. The focus of the cultivation is significant: Sapphira
96305_Russell_03_27.qxp
80
3/28/2006
11:18 AM
Page 80
Between the Angle and the Curve
desires a tangible reminder of her homeland (Loudoun County). Jezebel is herself “transplanted” from Africa; her sly joke about relishing “a li’l pickaninny’s hand” is a hint that this is not her garden (89). She injects a jarring (and violent) element into Sapphira’s nostalgic conversation. Jezebel plants her own “seed,” insisting on a counter vision of the garden she has “gained” at the cost of her world. The connections of Sapphira and Jezebel to the garden are largely in the past. Each is housebound—Sapphira to the mainhouse and the chair carried by slaves, and Jezebel to her slave cabin—movement in the garden is no longer the option it once was. Both slave and mistress are detached from any beauty or comfort the transformed terrain may have offered (again, in the case of Jezebel, it is unclear how much personal pleasure her obligation afforded); that privilege falls to Nancy, the young slave girl. Persecuted by Sapphira’s lascivious nephew, Nancy finds genuine solace in the landscape: “Nancy didn’t believe there was a lovelier spot in the world . . . She felt so joyful . . .” (196–197). Despite her vulnerable position—out of favour with her mistress and with no means of redress against Martin—Nancy opens herself to the beauty and emotion of the garden. Her eye does not scan the sight from a distance; she is immersed in the luxurious growth. Unnoticed, Nancy glories in its charms; it renews her faith in her home. The passion it inspires is joy, not fear. The garden is, at least temporarily, a space of “idealized domesticity” for Nancy (despite her slave status). The young slave girl is a striking figure in the garden; her beauty is reflected in, and reflects, the blossoming flowers. The site is hers, but she is the possession of Sapphira. Ownership of the garden is complicated by the issues of legal right, proprietorship through labour, and possession through spiritual kinship. Sapphira’s authority over the garden is not absolute; the act of appreciation is itself a form of possession. The complexity of garden imagery is apparent in the multiple representations found in the fiction of Cather and Morrison. Cather incorporates the garden more frequently than Morrison, but both authors play with the expectations raised by the image. Morrison’s gardens tend to emphasize the imaginative over the tangible. She ventures into the surreal whereas Cather grounds her garden imagery in minute details which frequently gain mythic status. Examples of “idealized domesticity” through gardens and orchards are found in My Antonia, O Pioneers !, Death Comes For the Archbishop, and Sapphira and the Slave Girl. Each of these texts depicts the garden as a sanctuary which introduces a small piece of the motherland into a foreign landscape. Morrison reveals how easily the idealized can be distorted through the garden battles of Paradise; gardens are figurative weapons, not sanctuaries, in Ruby.
96305_Russell_03_27.qxp
3/28/2006
11:18 AM
Page 81
Maneuvering through the Maternal Landscape
81
Violence enters the garden (and novel) with the attack on the convent women. In The Bluest Eye the violence is no less real, but the garden is symbolic—Pecola is treated like the dirt plot. Cather too introduces violence into the garden in O Pioneers! and Death Comes For the Archbishop, but it is defused through natural imagery and the distance of story telling. The depictions of the life-stifling retreats of Godfrey St. Peter and Captain Forrester are recognitions of the detrimental effects of withdrawing from the mainstream of life in favour of the garden. Bishop Latour’s inclusive garden sanctuary provides a counterpoint to the tempting conclusion that it is the male character who “misuses” the garden. While a case could be made that Latour’s celibacy (and exclusion from the social role of husband) is a factor in the positive status of his garden, it should be noted that the professor and captain are also celibate (in the present tense of the novels they have separate sleeping quarters from their wives, and largely separated lives). Despite his spiritual role (perhaps because of it), Latour does not withdraw from the stream of life. Like Antonia’s, the bishop’s garden is a continuation of life, not a substitute for it (as is the case with St. Peter and Forrester). Mrs. Kohler’s near isolation in The Song of the Lark also resists a gendered reading; she is selective about who gains admission to her spiritual oasis. Gardens are complex and frequently ambiguous spaces in the fiction of Cather and Morrison. REDEFINING THE HEROIC ENDEAVOUR: INTERACTION WITH THE FEMININE LANDSCAPE The practice of equating woman with the land and portraying man as the heroic (and all too often sexual) conqueror is a shared area of concern for Cather and Morrison. The Bluest Eye provides a particularly powerful indictment of the assumption that both woman and land are available for appropriation and exploitation. The “rape of the land” metaphor so often used to describe the cultivation of the wilderness is concretized in Pecola Breedlove— she is literally the violated virgin land. Morrison implicitly rejects the image of the hero armed with a plow imposing order on an untamed land. Cholly Breedlove’s action bears no fruit: the child dies, Pecola descends into madness, the already troubled family disintegrates, and he disappears. At best he is impotent, at worst lethal; disorder, not order, grows out of the assault. Cholly is cast not as the hero, but as the villain. He is not a noble figure; his actions call into question the sanitized versions of the settlement of the frontier—America was not an “unpeopled” land open for the taking. Cholly’s act of possession carries historical implications (his own history of being violated and the violation of the country).
96305_Russell_03_27.qxp
82
3/28/2006
11:18 AM
Page 82
Between the Angle and the Curve
Cather too challenges the concept of the hero, but in a less harrowing manner. The farmer as a triumphant conqueror of the prairie is undercut in O Pioneers !: “the record of the plow was insignificant, like the feeble scratches on stone left by prehistoric races, . . .” (13). The “mark” left on the land is, at best, ambiguous. It verges on inconsequential, failing to identify its author. Grandiose notions of heroic settlement are mocked by the imbalance in the scale of the land to the accomplishments of the man. It is important to recognize the context of the commentary. John Bergson is dying and in his eleven years of farming he has failed to conquer “the wild land he had come to tame . . . Its Genius was unfriendly to man . . .” (13–14). Weak and defeated, John Bergson has lost his battle with the land and yet, bypassing his three sons, he passes the legacy of the struggle to his daughter Alexandra. Redefining the pioneer, John implores her to persevere where he cannot. He assesses his children and astutely selects Alexandra to pursue his dream. Practical concerns override gender expectations in John Bergson’s decision. He clearly clings to the dream of conquering the prairie despite personal feelings of frustration. Prosperity and order do ultimately come to the countryside and Alexandra is firmly in the forefront of the development. Life becomes easier on the Divide and the earth “yields easily to the plow . . .” (52). Sixteen years of hard work and the formidable prairie is “tamed.” The implication is that it is the whim of the land, not the work of the people, which is responsible for the transformation. The “Genius” of the Divide which was “unfriendly” to John Bergson speaks to his daughter. Alexandra achieves a type of harmony with the land that her father was unable to discover. The truly heroic act appears to be a willingness to “listen” to the earth and to endure through hardships.14 The redefinition of the heroic figure continues in My Antonia. In this novel the father once again is a failure as a farmer. It is Antonia Shimerda who succeeds in the environment which conquers her heartbroken father. In one of the most visually powerful moments in the text Antonia, Jim, and the other immigrant girls witness a remarkable sight: “Magnified across the distance by the horizontal light, [a plough] stood out against the sun. . . . There it was, heroic in size, a picture writing on the sun” (156). The emblem of the pioneer’s struggle—the plough—is dramatically displayed. Immense and powerful enough to compete with the sun, the image “writes” the story of the farmer. Coming as it does, on the heels of a discussion of Coronado’s adventures in America, the symbol suggests a new concept of heroism. When Jim tells the girls that Coronado “died in the wilderness, of a broken heart” they empathize with the explorer: “more
96305_Russell_03_27.qxp
3/28/2006
11:18 AM
Page 83
Maneuvering through the Maternal Landscape
83
than him has done that . . .” (155). The young immigrants personalize the historic adventures. On one level an empathetic response diminishes the heroic figure— Coronado is not larger than life, he is a recognizable character—but it also gives him depth by reinforcing his humanity. As darkness descends, the “forgotten plough . . . sunk back to its own littleness somewhere on the prairie” (156). The sharpness of the details fades into vagueness and the magnitude of the emblem shrinks into littleness. Transitory though it is, the moment offers a counter-definition of the heroic. The combination of personalizing the great explorer Coronado, and making historical the personal endeavours of the farmer, implicitly challenges the distinction between adventurer as hero and farmer as hero. In a similar re-evaluation the farmer as conqueror is rejected by the novel. The productive farmer, Antonia Shimerda, is in tune with the land; she represents harmony with, rather than conquest of, the landscape. She responds to the natural beauty of the country and the potential for earning a living from the land. Antonia does manipulate the environment in order to render it productive, but there is a strong emotional connection between the cultivator and the cultivated soil. The trees are her “children” and Antonia’s pride in her home has little to do with economic prosperity. IDENTIFYING THE LAND: FEMININE FEATURES AND LITERARY REPRESENTATION(S) The symbolic link between woman and land takes many forms in the fiction of Cather and Morrison. Perhaps the most overt examples of the identification of woman with and as the land occur in My Antonia and Jazz. The descriptions of Antonia Shimerda externalize her internal connection with the natural environment: her eyes are reminiscent of “the sun shining on brown pools in the wood” and the “rich” colour of her skin and hair heighten the association (17). She is described in earth tones and as the novel progresses her fertility is decisively linked with that of the land.15 A genuine affection for children (not just those she gives birth to) and a conscious affiliation with the countryside (she has had her time in the town and desires no more) characterize Antonia. The earth mother takes an equally remarkable form in Morrison’s Jazz. Joe Trace seeks his mysterious mother in the countryside. He has no memory of any genuine maternal contact. Instinctively Joe turns to the mother earth to find some tangible evidence of his own absent mother. Abandoning hope of a real relationship, Joe is willing to settle for a sign,
96305_Russell_03_27.qxp
84
3/28/2006
11:18 AM
Page 84
Between the Angle and the Curve
some gesture of recognition: “Maybe those were her fingers moving like that in the bush, not twigs, but . . . he could not see . . .” (37). Unable to distinguish between branch and hand, his mother’s body literally merges with the landscape. The female form and the fecund land are interchangeable in this scene. Antonia is a dominant (but not dominating) presence in her children’s lives. In stark contrast, Joe’s mother is a shadowy presence in his world. She “ran away from [him], but not too far. Just far enough away to annoy everybody because she was not completely gone, and close enough to scare everybody because she creeps about . . .” (37). Known only as Wild, she emerges from, and dissolves into, the landscape in the stories of the community. Joe can only access his mother through the natural environment; she does not (perhaps cannot) fulfill the social roles associated with motherhood. Longing for mother-love, Joe can only experience a connection with the terrain. In both texts mother earth and earth mother are symbolically connected. Wild and Antonia are in tune with the natural realm, but Antonia is clearly a social figure. Wild is disconnected from her son and the community. She is “earth” at the expense of “mother.” Woman as land, man as conqueror is boldly rejected in Sula. The literary practice of equating the female body with a sexually available natural landscape is inverted by Morrison. Mounting her lover “like a Georgia pine . . . ,” Sula envisions “loam, fertile, free of pebbles and twigs” at the centre of Ajax (129, 130). Sula will be the water that keeps his “soil” “rich and moist” (131). The suggestion that it is a symbiotic relationship—“How much water to keep the loam moist? . . . how much loam . . . to keep my water still?”—is belied by the violent labour which requires “a chisel and small tap hammer” to expose the loam (131). Power is wielded by Sula, not her male lover and fertility is located in his passively yielding body. “By comparing Ajax to earth and Sula to rain,” observes Pin-chia Feng, “Morrison consciously reverses a literary convention in which a woman is compared to the fertile field to be nourished and impregnated by her man” (86–7). Sula is not earth; she is element. She does not wait to be acted upon; hers is the force which defines the land (Ajax). Sula stands out as an exception, but the dominant representation of the natural landscape links it with the feminine form. Motherhood or the ability to reproduce is not the only rationale for associating the female body with the land. Production is obviously a shared trait of the two, but so too is the element of seduction. Niel Herbert’s experience of the Forresters’ marsh in A Lost Lady is particularly sensual: There was an almost religious purity about the fresh morning air, the tender grass . . . Niel wondered why he did not often come . . . to see
96305_Russell_03_27.qxp
3/28/2006
11:18 AM
Page 85
Maneuvering through the Maternal Landscape
85
the day before men and their activities had spoiled it . . . He would make a bouquet . . . gathered off the cheeks of morning. . . . (70–71)
The location is erotically charged and its sensuality is implicitly linked to the Lady he is on his way to surprise. When he approaches her bedroom window the surprise is Niel’s; he hears Mrs. Forrester and her lover laughing. As long as she remained “unspoiled” by the activities of men, Mrs. Forrester retained the “purity” Niel associates with the marsh. Once she slips from her pedestal, it is “the end of that admiration and loyalty that had been like a bloom on his existence” (72). The discovery leads Niel to decry “lilies that fester” as smelling “far worse than weeds” (72). Seduced by his image of Mrs. Forrester, Niel cannot forgive her for acting on her sensual impulse and engaging in a sexual affair. Niel Herbert plunges into the feminine space of the marsh with little concern for the effects of his intrusion. His act of using his knife to cut “the stiff stems, crowded with red thorns” can be construed as an attack on the roses “only half awake, in the defenselessness of utter beauty;” Niel’s presence is a disruption of the natural order (70–71). The knife can easily be read as a phallic symbol; at the very least, it is a destructive presence in the idyllic locale. The seemingly harmless activity of gathering wild roses thus takes on a malevolent tone, particularly if the flowers are identified with/as woman as the previous passage strongly suggests. Cutting the roses anti