Domingo A Herrero Arizona State University
Approximation of Hilbert space. operators VOLUME I
Pitman Advanced Publishing Program BOSTON· LONDON· MELBOURNE
PITMAN BOOKS LIMITED 128 Long Acre, London WC2E 9AN
PITMAN PUBUSHING INC 1020 Plain Street, Marshfield, Massacllusetts Associllted Contpflllia
Pitman Publishing Pty Ltd, Melbourne Pitman Publishing New Zealand Ltd, Wellington Copp Clark Pitman, Toronto
© Domingo A Herrero 1982 First published 1982 AMS Subject Classifications: Primary 47ASS, 41A6S, 47A60; Secondary 47A15, 47AS3, 81C12 British Library Cataloguing in Publication Data Herrero, Domingo A. Approximation of Hilbert space operators. Vol. 1-(Researcb notes in mathematics; 72) 1. Hilbert space 2. Operator theory I. Title II. Series 515. 7'33 QA329 ISBN 0-273-08579-4 Library of Congress Cataloging in Publication Data Herrero, Domingo A. Approximation of Hilbert space operators. (Research notes in mathematics; 72- ) Bibliography: v. 1, p. Includes index. 1. Operator theory. 2. Hilbert space. I. Title. II. Series: Research notes in mathematics; 72, etc. QA329.H48 1982 515.7'24 82-10163 ISBN 0-273-08579-4 (v. 1) All rights reserved. No part of this publication may be reproduced, stored in a retrieval system, or transmitted, in any form or by any means, electronic, mechaniall, photocopying, recording and/or otherwise without the prior written permission of the publishers. This book may not be lent, resold, hired out or otherwise disposed of by way of trade in any form of binding or cover other than that in which it is published, without the prior consent of the publishers. This book is sold subject to the Standard Conditions of Sale of Net Books and may not be resold in the UK below the net price. Reproduced and printed by photolithography in Great Britain by Biddies Ltd, Guildford
To Buenos Aires, on her four-hundred first birthday
"A mi se me hace cuento que empez6 Buenos Aires, la juzgo tan eterna como el agua o el aire" (Jorge Luis Borges)
Contents
1. Stability and approximation
1
1.1 Lower estimated derived from the Riesz-Dunford functional calculus 1.2 Lower estimates for the distance to Nk(H) 1.3 Lower semicontinuity of the rank 1.4 Stability properties of semi-Fredholm operators
2 6 8 9
1.5 On invariance and closure of subsets of L(H)
10
1.6 Notes and remarks
11
2. An aperitif:
approximation problems in finite dimensional
spaces
12
2.1 Closures of similarity orbits in finite dimensional spaces
13
2.1.1 The nilpotent case
15
2.1.2 Proof of Theorem 2.1 2.1.3 The lattice (N(Ek)/i,<)
16 17
2.1.4 Closures of similarity orbits of finite rank operators 2.2 The distance from the set of all non-zero orthogonal projections to N(H)
19
20
2.2.1 The limit case
20
2.2.2 On the exact values of 6k and nk 2.2.3 A companion problem: the distance from the set of
23
all non-zero ide!_11potents to N{H) 2.3 On the distance to Nk{H) 2.3.1 A general upper bound 2.3.2 Two illustrative examples
25 27 27 30
2.3.3 An example on approximation of normal operators by nilpotents
33 vii
2.3.4 On the distance to a similarity orbit 2.4 On the distance from a compact operator to N(H) 2.5 Notes and remarks 3. The main tools of approximation
3.1 The Rosenblum operator:
X
+
AX -XB
3.2 Generalized Rota's universal model 3.3 Apostol triangular representation 3.4 Correction by compact perturbations of the singular behavior of operators 3.5 Apostol-Foia~-Voiculescu's theorem on normal restrictions of compact perturbations of operators 3.5.1 Schatten p-classes 3.5.2 Normal restrictions 3.5.3 Density of sets of operators with bad properties 3.6 Notes and remarks 4. Two results borrowed from the theory of C*-algebras 4.1 Essentially normal operators
4.2 4.3 4.4 4.5
Brown-Douglas-Fillmore theorem Berger-Shaw trace inequality Examples of essentially normal operators An application to approximation problems
Matrix models for operators Spectra of compact perturbations of operators Voiculescu's theorem Closures of unitary orbits 4.5.1 Operator-valued spectrum and unitary orbits 4.5.2 Concrete examples of closures of unitary orbits 4.5.3 On normal and quasinilpotent restrictions
viii
37 38 41
3.1.1 Linear operator equations 3.1.2 Approximate point spectrum of a sum of commuting operators 3.1.3 Local one-side resolvents in L(H) 3.1.4 The left and the right spectra of TAB 3.1.5 Rosenblum-Davis-Rosenthal corollary 3.1.6 The maximal numerical range of an operator 3.1.7 The norm of TAB
4.1.1 4.1.2 4.1.3 4.1.4
35
41 41 42 44 50 53 54 56 58 62 69 74 75 76 78 79 84 84 84 85 89 90 92 94 96 99 99 100 101
4.6 Irreducible operators
104
4.7 Notes and remarks
106
5. Limits of nilpotent and algebraic operators 5.1 Limits of nilpotent operators
108 108
5.1.1 Normal limits of nilpotents
108
5.1.2 Spectral characterization of N(H)
111
5.2 Closures of
~imilarity orbits of normal operators with perfect spectra 5.3 Limits of algebraic operators 5.4 Normal operators in closures of similarity orbits 5.5 Sums of two nilpo~ents 5.6 The Apostol-Salinas approach: an estimate for the distance to Nk(H) 5.7 Salinas' pseudonilpotents 5.8 Limits of nilpotent and algebraic elements of the Calkin algebra 5.9 On the spectra of infinite direct sums os operators 5.10 Notes and remarks
6. Quasitriangularity
113 114 115 117 120 124 128 130 132 135
6.1 Apostol-Morrel simple models
135
6.2 Quasitriangular operators
140
6.2.1 Equivalence between the formal and the relaxed
definitions of quasitriangularity 6.2.2 Two lower estimates for the distance to (QT)
141 142
6.2.3 Spectral characterization of quasitriangularity
145
6.3 Biquasitriangular operators
146
6.3.1 Block-diagonal and quasidiagonal operators
146
6.3.2 Characterizations of biquasitriangularity
147
6.4 On the relative size of the sets (QT), (QT)*, (BQT),
[N(H)+K(H)] and N(H)-
153
6.5 A Riesz decomposition theorem for operators with
disconnected essential spectrum 6.6 Notes and remarks 7. The structure of a polynomially compact operator
154 157 162
7.1 Reduction to the (essentially) nilpotent case
162
7.2 The structure of a polynomially compact operator
164
ix
7.3 7.4 7.5 7.6 7.7
Restrictions of nilpotent operators 167 Operators similar to Jordan operators 171 A similarity invariant for polynomially compact operators 173 Nice Jordan operators 177 Notes and remarks 188
8. Closures of similarity orbits of nilpotent operators 8.1 Universal operators 8.1.1 Universal quasinilpotent operators 8.1.2 Universal compact quasinilpotent operators 8.2 Compact perturbations of not nice operators 8.3 Quasinilpotents in the Calkin algebra
189 189 194 194 198
8.3.1 General quasinilpotents 8.3.2 Nice elements of the Calkin algebra
198 204
8.4 Compact perturbations of nice Jordan operators
205
8.4.1 8.4.2 8.4.3 8.4.4 8.4.5
Nice Jordan nilpotents Nilpotents of order 2 Quasinilpotent perturbations Universal operators in N~,h(H) A general criterion for universality
8.5 Separation of isolated points of the essential spectrum affiliated with nilpotents 8.6 Notes and remarks REFERENCES INDEX SYMBOLS AND NOTATION
X
189
206 211 212 215 222 230 236 239 249 253
Preface
The last decade has been fruithful in results on approximation of Hilbert space operators, due to a large extent to the impulse given by Paul R. Halmos in his famous survey article "Ten problems in Hilbert space". The purpose of this monograph (and a second one, by C. Apostol, L. A. Fialkow, D. A. Herrero and D. Voiculescu that will follow and complete the results contained here) is to provide a set of general arguments to deal with approximation problems (in the norm-topology) related to those subsets of the algebra L!HI of all operators acting on a complex separable infinite dimensional Hilbert space that are invariant under similarities. Many interesting subsets of L(HI have this property: nilpotent operators: algebraic operators (satisfying a fixed polynomial): polynomially compact operators: triangular, quasitriangular and biquasitriangular operators: cyclic and multicyclic operators: semi-Fredholm operators (with fixed given indices): operators whose spectrumis equal to a fixed compact subset of the complex plane ~. or whose spectra are contained in a fixed nonempty subset of ~: any bilateral ideal of compact operators, etc, etc. The following list illustrates the kindsofproblems to be considered here: a) Given a subset R of L(HI invariant under similarities, defined in algebraic, geometric or analytic terms (e.g., the set of all algebraic operators, the set of all operators T such that T3 is compact, the set of all cyclic operators), characterize its norm-closure in "simple terms". Since the spectrum and its different parts are the most obvious similarity invariants of an operator, these "simple term~' will usually be expressed in terms of properties of the different subsets of the spectra of the operators in the closure of R. b) More generally, obtain a formula for the distance from a given operator to R or, al least, upper and/or lower estimates for this distance. c) In a surprisingly large number of interesting cases, either R is invariant under compact perturbations, or its closure is contained xi
in (or equal to) the set of all compact perturbations of R. Compact perturbations will be used as a useful tool for approximation and will be also analyzed with respect to the above mentioned peculiar properties. d) Analogues to the problems in a) and b) for subsets of the quotient Calkin algebra. In Chapter I, we shall obtain all the necessary conditions for approximation that can be easily derived from the Riesz-Dunford functional calculus and the well-known stability properties of semi-Fredholm operators. This chapter is followed by "an ap~ritif": the solution of several approximation problems in finite dimensional spaces, which only depend on the results of Chapter I and some "handwork" with matr~ces.
It is interesting to observe that, for a large number of approximation problems (but, unfortunately, not for all of them) the "obvious" necessary conditions derived from the results of Chapter I are actually sufficient, but the proofs of their sufficiency are very hard.These proofs are constructive to a large extent and the "tools" for these constructions are developed in Chapters III and IV: Rosenblum's coro~ lary, Rota's universal model and extensions, Apostol's triangular representation, results on compact perturbations and results "borrowed" from the theory ofC*-algebras (the Brown-Douglas-Fillmore theorem, Voiculescu's theorem, results on closures of unitary orbits). Except for those results related to the theory of C*-algebras (Chapter IV) , the monograph is essentially self-contained. Results on approximation of Hilbert space operators really begin in Chapter V with the characterization (due to c. Apostol, C. Foia~ and D. Voiculescu) of the closure of the set of all nilpotent operators. The closure of the set of all algebraic operators is then obtained as a corollary and this result is used to characterize biquasitriangularity, the closure of the similarity orbit of a normal operator with perfect spectrum and to give several results about the closure of the similarity orbit of an arbitrary operator. Combining the above results with Apostol-Morrel "simple models", we shall obtain the Apostol-Foia~-Voiculescu theorem on the spectral cha; acterization of quasitriangularity. Since algebraic op~rators and operators that "look like backward shifts" are the simple3t examples of triangular operators, this approach to quasitriangularity is, perhaps, more natural than the original one. Finally, the last two chapters are devoted to a deep analysis of the structure of a polynomially compact operator and to the clos~e of xii
its similarity orbit, respectively. A large part of the material contained in the last chapter consists of unpublished results of c. Apostol-D. Voiculescu, J. Barr!a-D. A. Herrero and D. A. Herrero on closures of similarity orbits of essentially nilpotent operators. The author is deeply indebted to Professors Constantin Apostol, I. David Berg, Charles A. Berger, Ronald G. Douglas, Alain Etcheberry, Lawrence A. Fialkow, Ciprian Foia,, Carl M. Pearcy, Allen L. Shields and Dan Voiculescu, and to his professors and ex-fellow students from the University of Buenos Aires, Alejandro de Acosta, Mischa Cotlar, Beatriz Margolis, Lazaro Recht, Norberta Salinas and, very especially, to his wife Marta B. Pecuch de Herrero for infinitely many informal discussions and suggestions and, most important, for their friendly support during all these hard years. The contents of this monograph have been developed in a "Seminar on Approximation of Hilbert Space Operators• at the University of Georgia (Athens, Georgia, USA), during the academic year 1980-1981. The author wishes to thank the authorities of the University of Georgia for their support and to his colleagues Edward Azoff, Richard Bouldin, Kevin Clancey, Douglas N. Clark and Derming Wang for their assistance during the preparation of the manuscript. Many of their valuable observations have been included here. Domingo A. Herrero
Tempe, Arizona June, 1981
xi~i
1 Stability and approximation
As explained in the Preface, in "most" approximation problems related to similarity-invariant sets of operators, the "obvious" necessary conditions for approximation that can be derived from the RieszDunford functional calculus and the stability properties of semi-Fredholm operators turn out to be also sufficient. In a certain sense,this short first chapter contains all the necessary conditions and the remaining of the monograph (and the second one that will follow [16]) is devoted to explain why these necessary conditions are also sufficient. Throughout this monograph, the word operator will always denote a bounded linear transformation mapping a complex Banach space into another. If X and Y are complex Banach spaces, the Banach space of all operators mapping X into Y will be denoted by L(X,Y). We shall write L(H) for the Banach algebra L(H,H), where His a complex separable Hilbert space. Unless otherwise stated, H (H 0 , H1 , H2 , ••• , etc) will always denote an infinite dimensional Hilbert space. The algebra L(H) contains the open subset G(H) ={WE l(H):
W is invertible}
(the linear group of L(H)), which will play a very important role here. A subset R of L(H) is called invariant under simiLarities (or simiLarity-invariant) if it is invariant under conjugation by elements of the group G(H), i.e., T
€
R => S (T)
c
R,
where -1 .S (T) = { WTW :
W
E
G(H)}
is the simiLarity orbip of T. If K(H) denotes the ideal of all compact operators acting on Hand ~:l(H) + A(H) = L(H)/K(H) is the canonical projection of L(H) onto the (quotient) Calkin algebra, then the image ~(T) = T+K[H) ofT € l(H) in A(H) will also be denoted by T. The reader is referred to [77], [119] for the general theory of Hilbert space operators. 1
1.1 Lower estimates derived from the Riesz-Dunford functional calculus A nonempty bounded open subset n of the complex plane a: is a Cauchy domain if the following conditions are satisfied: (i) n has finitely many components, the closures of any two of which are disjoint, and (ii) the boundary an of n is composed of a finite positive number of closed rectifiable Jordan curves, no two of which intersect. In this case, r = an will be assumed to be positively oriented with respect to n in the sense of complex variable theory, i.e., so that 1 2'11'i
J
d>..
r >..-~
{1, if =
o,
~ e n 1 n- = nur
if ~
(the upper bar will always denote closure with respect to the metric topology of the underlying space). Clearly, r is uniquely determined by n (and conversely). We shall say that r is a rectifiabZe contour. If all the curves of r are regular analytic Jordan curves, we shall say that r is an analytic contour (or n is an anaZytic Cauchy domain). If A is a Banach algebra with identity 1 and a e A, the spectrum of a will be denoted by a(a). The complement p(a) = 0:\o(a) of a(a) in the complex plane is the resoZvent set of a and the function >.. ~ (X-a)-l (from p(a) into A) is the resolvent of a. It is well-known that (X-a)-l is an analytic function of >.. in that domain that it satisfies the first resoZvent equation: (>..-a) -l_ (p-a) -l = (ll- X) (>..-a) -l (p-a) -l (X rll e p (a) ). Furthermore, if a, be A and>.. e p(a)np(b), then (>..-a)- 1 - (X-b)-l = (X-a)- 1 (a- b) (X-b)-l (second resolvent equation). If a is a nonempty clopen subset of a(a), then there exists an analytic Cauchy domain n such that a c nand [a(a)\a]nn-= -; in this case 1 Jr (>..-a) -1 dX E(o;a) = 2 '1fi
is an idempotent of A commuting with every b in A such that ab = ba. (E(a;a) is the Riesa idempotent corresponding to a.) The following theorem is just a quantitative form of the classical result on upper semi-continuity of separate parts of the spectrum. The reader is referred to [76], [153], [172], or [173,Chapter XIV] for the basic properties of the Riesz-Dunford functional calculus. THEOREM 1.1. Let a and b be two elements of the Banach algebra A 2
~ith
identity 1. Assume that the spect~um o(a) of a is the disjoint u~ ion of two compact subsets a 0 and o 1 such that o 1 is nonempty (o 1 t< ~)
a~d Zet n be a Cauchy domain such that a 1
lla-brJ< minfmc;~.-a)-~J- 1 : (where JI.Jidenotes the norm of A)
II = II a- at II
;~.
If
an},
€
= min{ 11!>.-a) -~1- 1 :
A "- an} and
= t6 < li
-~~- 1
for all A E an, so that o(at)nan = fJ for all t E Thus, the idempotent
....!..-f 2w1 an
et
nn- = -·
then o(b) nO 'I ffand o(b) nan =fJ.
PROOF. Assume that II a-b II = 6 < m let at= (1-t)a+tb, 0 ~ t ~ 1: then 11!>--at> - <><-a>
0 and a 0
c
(>.
-at
~0,11.
) -1 d.>.
is a well defined element of A for all t E [0,1]. Furthermore, if 0 ~ t < s ~ 1, the second resolvent equation implies that
whence it readily follows that t + et is a continuous mapping from [0,1] into A. Since o 1 = o(a)nn 'I fJ, it follows that 1
eo = 2w1
f
(;i.-a)
-1
d).
F o,
an so that II e 0 II :2; 1 (Recall that et is idempotent, 0 ity, lle 1 11 :2; 1 and therefore el
= 2!i f
(>.-b)-1 d). an This is clearly impossible, unless o(b)nn
~
~
t
1). By continu
F 0. F fJ.
0
Recall that if (X,d) is a metric space and B(Xl (Bc(X]) is the family of all nonempty bounded (closed bounded, respectively) subsets of X, then ~(A,B)
= inf{e
>
0:
B
c
AE, A
c
BE},
where AE = {x EX: dist[x,AJ s e},defines a pseudometric in B(Xl (a metric in Bc(X], resp.);dH(A,B) is the Hausdo~ff distance between A and B, A, B € Bc(X]. The qualitative form of Theorem 1.1 is the following COROLLARY 1.2. (i} Let a be an element of a Banach algebra A with identity. Assume that o(a) is the disjoint union of two compact subsets a0 and a 1 such that o 1 F fJ. and that a 1 is contained in abounded openset 0. Then there ezists a constant C = C(a,o 1 ,n) > 0 such that 3
o(b)nO t: ~foro aZZ bin A satisfying lla-bll 0, there e~ists 6 > 0 suah that a(b) a(a)E, provided lla-bll < 4, i.e., the mapping a+ a(a) from A into Be(~) (Hausdorff distanae) is upper semiaontinuous.
c
PROOF. (i) follows immediately from Theorem 1.1: Given a 1 and 0 (as above) , there exists a Cauchy domain o1 such that a 1 c n1 c n 1 - c S2 and a 0 no 1 - =~-Take c = min{lj(A-a) -1II -1 : Ac: an 1 }. (ii) Apply (i) with a0 ~and 0 =interior a(a)E. 0 COROLLARY 1. 3 . (i) If S2 is an open subset of ~. then {a c: A: c S'l} is an open subset of A. (ii) If E is a G6 subset of ~. then {a € A: a(a) c E} is a G6 subset of A. In par-tiauZar, the set {a e; A: a (a) = {0}} of aZZ quasiniZpotent eZements of A is a G6 in A. a(a)
PROOF. (i) follows from Corollary 1.2(ii) and (ii) is an immediate consequence of (i) • 0 The limit case of Theorem 1.1 yields the following COROLLARY 1.4. Let a, o 1 (o 1 7: ~) and assume that b c: A satisfies the inequality
n be
II a- b II s min{ II< A-a) -11 I -1 :
as in Theorem 1.1 and >.
c:
anl;
PROOF. Define at as in the proof of Theorem 1.1; then Theorem 1.1 implies that a(atlnan = g and o(at)nS'l t: ~for 0 s t < 1. Since lim(t _,. 1) lib- at II= 0, i t follows from Corollary 1.2(i) that o(b)nO- cannot be empty. 0 It is convenient to observe that the result of Corollary 1.4(and, a fortiori, the result of Theorem 1.1 too) is sharp. In fact, we have EXAMPLE 1.5. Let P c: L(H) be a non-zero orthogonal projection and let Q = {A: I A-ll < ~}; then II< A-P) -lll-l = ~ (A € an ) • Thus' by Corol lary 1.4, a(B)nS'l- 7: ~ for all B in L(H) such that liP- Bll s ~On the other hand, if A = ~. then II P- A II = ~ and o (A) = {~} c an. If T c: L(H), o is a clopen subset of o(T) and E(o;T) is the corresponding Riesz idempotent, then the range ran E(o;T) and the kernel ker E(o;T) of E(a;T) aresubspacesofH invariant under every B-in L(H) commutinq with T (i.e., hyperinvariant forT), and H can be written as 4
the algebraic (not necessarily orthogonal!) direct sum H = ran E(a:T)+ ker E(a:T). (Here and in what follows, subspace will always denote a closed linear manifold of a Banach space.) Furthermore, the spectrum of the restriction T)ran E(a:T) ofT to ran E(a:T) coincides with a and the spectrum of the restriction T!ker E(a:T) coincides with a(T)\a [l73,Chapter XIV]. In what follows, ran E(a:T) will be denoted by H(a:Tl. If a = {X} is a singleton, we shall simply write H(X:T) (E(X:T)) instead of H({X}:T) (E({X}:T), resp). If a = {X} and dim H(X:T) is finite, then X is called a normaL eigenvaLue ofT: in this case, H(X:T) coincides with ker(X-T)n for some n ~ 1. The set of all normal eigenvalues ofT will be denoted by a 0 (T). Clearly, a 0 (T) is contained in the point spectrum ap(T) ofT (i.e., the set of all eigenvalues ofT). The esse~ tiaL spectrum ofT, i.e., the spectrum ofT in A(H) will be denoted by ae (T).
COROLLARY 1.6. Let A, Be L(H); then (i)
Assume that a is a nonempty
~Lopen)subset
of a(A) and Let Q
~Cauchy domain) be a neighborhood of a such that
[a(A)\a]nO- =-.If X dO}. then a 1 =a (B) nO -,; ~; (ii) furthermore, dim H(a:A) =dim H(a 1 :B) (0 s dim H(a:A) s ~>. (iii) If a is a nonempty cLopen subset of a (A) and the Cauchy e domain n is a neighborhood of a such that [a e (A)\a]nO- = ~. then a e (B) nO-,;- for aZZ Bin L(H) suah that IIA-BII < min{I!CX-A)-~1-l: A e an}.
II A- B II
< min{
II< X-A) -~~-l:
PROOF. (i) and (iii) follow immediately from Theorem 1.1, applied to A= L(H) and to A= A(H), respectively. (ii) This follows from the proof of Theorem 1.1. Observe that, if At= (1-t)A+tB, then the continuity of the mapping t + E(a(At)nO:At) (0 s t s 1) implies that the idempotents E (a :A) = E (a (A 0 ) nO :A0 J and E (a 1 :B) E (a (A1 ) nO:A1 ) necessarily ha-ve the same (finite or infinite) rank.O Until now, we have only applied the arguments of functional calc~ lus to a very particular class of functions analytic in a neighborhood of the spectrum a(a) of an element of the Banach algebra A: namely, the characteristic function of a suitable neighborhood of a clopen su~ set of a(a). Analogous results hold in a much more general setting: namely, PROPOSITION 1.7. Let a be an eLement of the Banach algebra A with identity 1 and let f be an anaLytic function defined in a neighborhood n of a(a). Given £ > 0, there ezists ~ > 0 such that f(b) is weLL-de5
fined for aZZ b in A satisfying
II a- bll
II f (a) - f
< ti and. mol'eovel'.
(b)
II
< e.
PROOF. Let n 1 be a Cauchy domain such that a(a) c n 1 c Ql- c Q. By Corollary 1.2(i), there exists o1 > 0 such that a(b) c n 1 for all b inA satisfying lla-bll < ti 1 • Clearly, f(b) is well-defined for all these b, by means of the integral f(b)
= 2!i
Ianl f(~) <~-b)-ld~.
The second resolvent equation implies that max{ 11<~-b) -~1:
~ " an 1 }
< l+max{
11<~-a) -11:
~ " an 1 l,
and llf(a)-f(b) II s (1/2'11") .length(an 1 > .max{ If(~) I·II-11 x
-1
II>:
A.
E
an 1 l ·II a- blj,
provided II a - b II < o2 (for some o2 , 0 < o2 s ti 1 ) • It follows that, i f !Ia -bll < o for a suitably chosen ti, 0 < then f (b) is well-defined and II f {a) - f (b) II < e. fJ
o < oz
The following particular case is especially important for our purposes. COROLLARY 1.8. Let
a~:
A.
let~
be an isolated point of a(a) and
let k
={(A.-~} • in some neighborhood of~
f(A.) for some k
2:
0
• in some
neighborhoodofa(a)\{~}.
1.
Let {an\,,:1 be a sequence of elements in A such that !Ia- ani!-+ 0 (n-+oo). Then f(an) is IJJell-defined for all n large enough and
f(a) =0 if and only if lim(n-+ oo) l!f(anlll
=
0.
1.2 Lower estimates for the distance to Nk(H)
Let Nk (A l = {a E A: a"· = 0} denote the set of all nilpotent elements of order at most k {k = 1,2, ••• ) of the Banach algebra A, and let N(A) = uk:l Nk(A) be the set of all nilpotents ·of A. In order to simplify the notation, the set of all nilpotents (of order at most k) in L(H) will be denoted by N(H) (Nk(H), resp), or simply by N if His understood. It is a trivial consequence of Proposition 1.7 that, given a non6
constant polynomial p,the set {a E particular, i f we choose pk(A) COROLLARY 1.9. (i)
=
A:
p(a) = 0} is closed in A. In
Ak (k = 1,2, ••• ), then we obtain
Nk(A) is alosed in A for aZZ k = 1,2, •••
N(A) is an F0 subset of A.
(ii)
The following result provides a partial answer to the problem of estimating the distance from a given operator to Nk(H). PROPOSITION 1.10. (i) Bkx = O,
for some
x
II A- B II
Let A, BE L(H). If IIAkxll = llxll = 1, but in H and some k l! 1, then
~
max{
(ii) If IIAkxll = llxll = 1, but Bkx = 0 for some x in H and some k
~
1, and max{IIAII,IIBIIl = M, then IIA-BII ;:: 1/(kM).
(iii) for some k
Let a, b e: A (a Banaah algebra). If llakll = 1, but bk = O, ~
1, then
II a- b II ;:: max{ l/k-11 all, l/k-11 bIlL
(iv) If II akll =1, but bk = 0, for some k M,
~
1, and max{ll aJI,IIblll
=
then IJa-bll ~ 1/(kM). PROOF.
(i)
Let IIAII = M and IIA-BII = cS. I t is completely apparent
that II B II ~ M+cS, and therefore 1 = II Akx II = II
~I~:~
~
II Ak-Bk II
11Air-j-11A-BII-11BIIj
~ I~:~
~ cSI~:~
II Ak-jBj-Ak-j-lBj+lll
Mk-j-l(M+cS)j =
cSMk-li~:~j
cSMk-l[ ( l+.Q) k-1] (cS/M) - l = (M+o) k_t;c, M so that (M+cS)k
~ Mk+l. Hence, cS ;:: (Mk+l)l/k_M.
I f we assume that IIBII = M and IIA-BII =
o,
then IIAII ~ M+cS and we
arrive at the same inequality, whence the result follows. The remaining statements follow by the same argument. REMARKS. 1.11. (i)
0
Since, in Proposition l.lO(ii) and (iv), M
cannot be smaller than 1 and (by the mean-value theorem) 1/ ( 2kt.t)
< (~+1) l/k_M s 1/ (kM) ,
for all k;:: 1, the estimates of (i) and (ii)
((iii) and (iv)) are of
the same order. (ii)
The argument of the proof of Proposition l.lO(i) also ap-
plies to the case when IIP(A)xll = llxll = 1, but p(B)x = 0, for some pol2_ m k· nomial p, p(A) = rrj=l(A-Aj) J. Since ll[p(A)-p(B)Jxll = 1, IIA.-BII cannot
7
be "too small", where the words "too small" have a concrete numerical expression in terms of p and A . The same applies, of course, to (ii), (iii) and (iv).
1.3 Lower semicontinuity of the rank PROPOSITION 1.12. Let A e L(H) and Zet {An}n:l be a sequence of opePatoPs such that II A- A II -+- 0 (n + oo); then n (i) rank As lim inf(n + oo) rank An. If IIAnxll ~ £11xll foP some £ > 0 and aZZ x in a subspace Hn with dim Hn ~ d, then II Axil ~ £11 xll fop aZZ x in a subspace H0 with dim H0 ~ d. (iii) If An e KIHI foP aZZ n ~ n 0 , then A e K(HI. (ii)
PROOF. (i) If lim inf(n + oo) rank An=oo, then there is nothing to prove. Assume that lim inf (n + oo) rank An= d < oo. Passing, if necessary, to a subsequence, we can directly assume that rank An= d for all n = 1. 2, ••.• If rank A~ d+l, then there exist d+l linearly independent vectors y 1 , y 2 , ••• , yd+l e H such that {Ayj}~!i is a line~rly indepen~ ent set. Clearly, Y =linear span{y 1 ,y 2 , •.• ,yd+l} has dimension d+l and therefore Ynker An~ {O} for each n = 1,2, ••.• It is easily seen that {An}n:l is a bounded sequence and there exists y e Y and a subsequence {An.}J.:l such that IIAYII = 1 but lim(j + oo)IIA Yll = 0, so that "" J nj {An.lj=l cannot converge to A, even in the strong operator topology, a J
contradiction. Therefore, rank A s d. (ii) Observe that our hypothesis implies that IIA*-A~II + 0 and i IIA*A-A~Anll + 0 (n + oo). Now the result follows from an elementary ana~ysis of the spectral decompositions of the hermitian operators A*A and A*A (see, e.g., [117]). n n The third statement is trivial. 0 It is convenient to recall that A e LIHI is compact if and only if ran A does not contain an infinite dimensional subspace [71],[96]. we shall use the following non-standard notation: If A e KIHI is not a finite rank operator, then rank A will be defined as oo-. Thus, rank T = oo will be an equivalent way to say that T is not compact. The different possible ranks will be linearly ordered by 0 ~ 1 ~ 2 ~ ••• ~ n ~ n+l ~ ••• ~ 8
oo- ~ ""•
1.4 Stability properties of semi-Fredholm operators Recall that T € L(H) is a semi-FredhoZm operator if ranT is clos ed and either nul T = dim ker T or nul T* = dim ker T* = dim H/ran T
is finite (where T* denotes the adjoint ofT in L(H)). In this case, the index of T is defined by ind T = nul T - nul T*. The following theorem resumes the main properties of the semiFredholm operators. The reader is referred to [106] and [153,Chapter IV] for details. THEOREM 1.13. Let T E L(HI be a semi-FredhoZm operator; then (i) T* is aZso a semi-FredhoZm operator and ind T* = -ind T; (ii) There exists a constant 6 > 0 such that IITxll ~ 6llxll for aZZ x 1 ker T and II T*y II ~ 611 y II for aZZ y .L ker T*; moreover, 6 can be chosen as min{). E o([T*T]~)\{0}}; (iii) There exists 6 = 6(T) > 0 such that if A E: L(H), tiAlls land j).j < 6, then T+).A is semi-Fredho Zm ar~d ind (T+AA) = ind '1', nul (T+AA) s nul T and nul (T+AA) * s nul T*;moreover,nul(T+I.A) and nul (T+).A) *are constant for 0 <-~).I < &. (iv) In particuZar, if {An}n:l is a sequence of operators such that IIT-Anll _,. 0 (n->- co), then An is semi-FredhoZm for all. n <-: n 0 and nul T "' lim sup(n _,. co) nul An' nul T* "' lim sup(n _,.co) nul A~; (v) If K € K(H), then T+K is semi-FredhoZm and ind(T+K) = ind T. (vi) If B is another semi-FredhoZm operator and ind T+ind B is ~ezr-defined (i.e., {ind T,ind B} ~ {oo,-oo} or {-oo,oo}J, then TB is a semi-FredhoZm operator and ind TB = ind T+ind B. In particular, ~ is semi-Fredholm and ind ~ = k (ind T), for aZZ k "' l. A semi-Fredholm operator T is a FredhoZm operator if -co < ind T < The well-known Atkinson's theorem asserts that Tis Fredholm if and only if Tis invertible in A(H)[ll9], [153]. Hence,
~.
pF(T)
=
11:\ae(T)
=
{).€11::
).-Tis Fredholm}
(the FredhoZm domain of T) is an open subset of a:. The Zeft ~ight) spectrum of an element a of a Banach algebra A will be denoted by a 1 (a) (ar(a), resp) and its complement p1 (a) =II:\ a (a) (p (a) = 11:\0 (a)) is the Zeft (right, resp) resoZvent set of a. R. r r Thus, a e (T) = a",e (T) ua re (T) , where a".. e (T) = a".. (T) ( l.eft essential. spectrum) and a (T) = a (~) (right essential. spectrum). It is well-known re r that the intersection aR.re(T) = a 1e(T)nare(T) (some authors call oR.re(T) the WoZf spectrum ofT) contains the boundary aae(J) of aJTl 9
and therefore, it is a nonempty (compact) subset of ~. Its complement ~\aire(T) = pie(T)upr~(T), where pie(T) = ~\~ie(T) and pre(T) =~\are (T), coincides with ps-F(T) ={A e ~: A-T is semi-Fredholm}, the semiFredholm domain of T.
ll
The following results are an immediate consequence of Theorem 1. and its proof (see [153,Chapter IV]).
COROLLARY 1.14. Let T E L(H); then (i) Ps-F(T) is the disjoint union of the (possibly empty) open n ® -oo sets {ps-F(T)}_oo
Ps-F(T) = {A €, ~: A-T is semi-Fredholm with ind(A-T) = h}, -oo~h~oo. (ii) For eaah h, -oo ~ h ~ oo, ph s- F(T) is a lower semiaontinuous funation of T in the sense that, if II T- Tnll + 0 (n + oo) and e: > 0, then h h p 6 _F(T) c [p 6 _F(Tn)]e: for all n ~ n0 (e:). (iii) pOs- F(T) aontains the resolvent set p(T) = ~\a(T) ofT, and a0 (T).
(iv) (v)
h
If h 'F O, then p 6 _F(T) is a bounded set. If the minimal index of A-T, A " ps-F(T), is defined by
min.ind(!.-T) = min{nul(A-T),nul(A-T)*}, then the funation A + min.ind(A-T) is aonstant on every component of Ps-F(T}, except for an at most denumerable subset p:_F(T) without limit points in ps-F(T) . Furthermore, if~ E p;_F(T) and A is a pointof p F(T} in the same component as ~ but A i p F(T), then
s-
s-
min.ind(~-T)
(vi)
A
i
If A
> min.ind(A-T).
ps-F(T) and nul(A-T} < oo (nul(A-T)* < oo, resp), then oo n ps-F(T) <=> ker(A-T} c nn=l ran(A-T) oo n (ker(A-T)* c nn=l ran(A-T)* , resp.). E
s
p:_F(T) is the set of singular points of the semi-Fredholm domain p s- F(T) ofT~ pr s- F(T) = p s- F(T)\pss- F(T) is the set of regular points. It is completely apparent that pr F(T) is open and contains p(T). On sthe other hand, it is easily seen that p:_F(T) contains a 0 (T). InCha£ ter III we shall return to the analysis of these sets.
1.5 On invariance and closures of subsets of L(H) A subset R of L(H) is called invariant under unitary equivalence 10
if
T
E
R
=> U(T) c
R,
where U(H) = {U € L(H): U is unitary} and U(T) = {UTU*: U € U(H)} is the unitary orbit of T. It is completely apparent that U(T) c S(T). We shall establish without proofs some very elementary facts that will be frequently used in the future. PROPOSITION 1.15. If R is a subset of L(H) invariant either under simiZarities, or under unitary equivaZenae, or under aompaat perturbations (i.e., R+K(H) = RJ, then R- has the same property.
1.6 Notes and remarks Theorem 1.1 is just the quantitative version of [153,Theorem 3.16, p.212J (see also [177], or [132,Theorem lJ). Corollaries 1.3(ii) and 1.9(ii) are two elementary observations due to S. Grabiner [108] and D. A. Herrero [132], respectively. Proposition 1.10 is a mild improvement of a result due to D. A. Herrero rlSO,Lemma 4.3] (see also [44, Lemma 4.1]). The notion of "rank T ;= oo-" for a compact operator T, not \ of finite rank, was introduced by J~ Barr!a and D. A. Herrero in [44] in connection with the analysis of '~e similarity orbit of a nilpotent operator (See also Chapter VIII). The notion of "minimal index" is due to C. Apostol [10]. The fact that the singular points of Ps-F(T) are isolated points of this set was discovered by I. c. Gohberg and M. G. Krein [107]. In the above mentioned article, C. Apostol proved that p:_F(T) is, precisely, the set of points of discontinuity of the function that maps A€~-F(T) into the orthogonal projection of H onto ker(A-T) (see also t2S,Lemma 1.6 and Corollary 1.7]). This result will be analyzed in Section 3.3.
11
2 An aperitif: approximation problems in finite dimensional spaces
In this chapter we shall analyze several intrinsically finite dimensional problems, as well as infinite dimensional ones which can be solved through an essentially finite dimensional approach or by an argument in Which the (finite or infinite) dimension of the underlying Hilbert space plays absolutely no role. It will be convenient to introduce some notation: H will always denote a complex separable Hilbert space of dimension d, 0 s d s ~. If 0 s d < ® 1 then we shall also write ~d (with its canonical inner product) instead of H. If A, B E L(H), A- B (A~ B) will mean that A and B are similar (unitarily equivalent, resp.). A 7 B will be used as an alternative . . _ s1m _1 way to 1nd1cate that B € S(A) I i.e., that IIB-W AN II~ 0 (n ~ oo)for ~ n n in G(H). If A ~ Band B ~ A (equivaa suitable sequence {W} n n= 1 s1m s1m lently, S(A)- = S(B)-), then we shall say that A and Bare asymptotically similar. (In symbols: A# B.) It is completely apparent that s!m is a reflexive and transitive relation and that # is, indeed, an equi~ alence relation in L(H) .(Use Proposition 1.15. It is well-known and trivial that - and ~ are also equivalence relations.) If A E L(H 1 ) and B E L(H 2 ), where H1 and H2 are isomorphic Hilbert spaces (in symbols: H1 ~ H2 ) , then A# B will be understood as "up to a unitary mapping U from H2 onto H1 ", i.e., S (A)-= S (UBU*)-. The same observation applies to the other relations. The relation sim induces a partial order < in the quotient set L(H)/#, defined by: Let [A]= {T E L(H): S(B)
T#A}; [B] <[A] i f A sim B.(Equivalently,
c S(A)-.)
Given a (finite or denumerable) uniformly bounded family {AV }V€ r of operators such that A" E L(H") for all v in r, we shall denote by 49 v E r Av the direct sum of· the operators A" acting in the usual fashion on the orthogonal direct sum H = •vEr Hv of the spaces Hv, i. e., if x = 8lV€ r x V is a vector of H, then (8lV£f Av)x = •vEr Avxv. Clearly, IIIBVEf A)l = sup(v 12
E
r> IIA)I <
oo
If r = {1,2, ••. ,n}, we shall also write A1eA 2e •... eAn. If AV ~A£ L(H) for all v in r and card r =a (0 ~a~~>, then A(a)will de H(a) (orthogonal directnote the operator eV£ r Av acting on •v, r Hv sum of a copies of H) . If M is a subspace of H, then ML = H9M is the ortho9onal complement of M in H. Given f, g 10 H, f8g" L(H) is the rank one operator defined by (f9g)x = <x,g>f, where<.,.> denotes the inner product of H. FIHl = {Lj~l fj6gj:
fj, gj
€
H, j = 1,2, ••• ,n; n = 1,2, •.• }
is the ideal of all finite rank operators acting on H. Let {e 1 ,e 2 , ••• ,ek} be the canonical orthonormal basis (ONB) of ~k and let qk" L(~k) be the operator defined by (2 .1)
(k
= 0,1,2, .•• ;
q 0 is the 0 operator acting on the trivial space {0},
q 1 is the 0 operator acting on the one-dimensional Hilbert space ~.
~l ~
and qk admits the matrix representation 0 0 0
1 0
0 1
0
0
0 0 0
0 0 0
(k
qk
0
0
0
0
1
0
0
0
0
0
X
k)
with respect to the canonical ONB, for k =2,3, •.• ). These operators will play a very important role throughout this monograph. A £cr(a)} will denote the spectral raFinally, sp(a) =max{ IXI: dius of a £ A (a Banach algebra) •
2.1 Closures of similarity orbits in finite dimensional spaces
As remarked in the introduction, for many approximation problems the "obvious" necessary conditions derived from the results of Chapter I turn out to be sufficient too. Here is a concrete example of this situation: THEOREM 2.1. Let T
£
L(~
d
) and let p(X)
m
k"·
ITj=l (X-Xj) Jrxi ~ Aj• 13
for i F j) be its minimal (monic) polynomial; then the closure of the similarity orbit of T is equal to S(T)
= {A£ L(~d):
rank q(A) s rank q(T) for all qlpl,
~here
q!p denotes a monic polynomial q dividing p. Furthermore, if L £ L(~d), then L # T if and only if rank q(L) rank q{T) for all q!p if and only if L ~ T.
COROLLARY 2.2. Let T e L(~d); then the follo~ing are equivalent: (i) S(T) is maximal ~ith respect to inclusion (equivalently, [T] is a maximal element of (L(~d)/#,<)J; (ii)
T ~ lB.~~\ ]-
(), ].+qk j )
0 ..] and k.] as in Theorem 2.1, j
= 1,2, ••. ,m),
(iii) Lj~l kj = d (~here the kj's have the same meaning as in Theorem 2.1); (iv) T is a cyclic operator; (v) S(T)- ={A£ L(~d): o(A) o(T) and dim H(A;A) dim H(A:T) for all A in o(T)}. COROLLARY 2.3. LetT e L(~d); then the follo~ing are equivalent: (i) S(T) is minimal (equivalently, [T] is a minimal element); (ii) kj (defined as in Theorem 2.1) is equal to 1 for all j = 1, 2, ••• ,m; (iii) T is similar to a normal operator; (iv) S(T) is closed in L(~d); (v) T £ S(L) for all Lin L(~d) such that o(L) o(T) and dim H(A;L) =dim H(A;T) (A e o(T)J.
d -1 LetT, A£ L(~ I and assume that IIA-WnTWn II+ 0 (n + aa) for a suitable sequence {Wn}n:l of operators in G(~d). Clearly, q(A) and q(WnTWn -1 ) = Wnq(T)Wn -1 are well-defined (for all n = 1,2, .•• ) for all q!p and (by Proposition 1.7) l!q(A) -Wnq(T)Wn-lll + 0 (n + -1
aa).
Since rank Wnq(T)Wn =rank q(T) (for all n = 1,2, ... ), it follows from Proposition 1.12(i) that rank q(A) s rank q(T). Hence the conditions of Theorem 2.1 are necessary. The sufficiency of these conditions will be proved in several steps. The second statement of the ~eorem is a trivial consequence of the first one: It is obvious that S(L) = S(T) if and only if o(L) = o(T) and rank q(L) = rank q(T) for all qlp (Use Proposition 1.15). On the other hand, a simple analysis of the Jordan forms of L and T shows that rank q(L) = rank q(T) for all qlp if and only if L and T 14
are similar. (In particular, this implies that they have the same spectrum.)
2.1.1 The nilpotent case LEMMA 2.4. If 1 s m s k-1, then ~eqk sim ~+leqk-l"
computations show that W is invertible, e: .•• ,m), W -1 f 1 = (l/e:)f 1 and W -1 f.= f.(j = 2,3, .•. ,k) and e: e: ] ] -1 Qe: = We:(qmeqk)We: = Q+e:f 1ef 2 , where Qf 1 = 0, Qe 1= f 1 , Qei= ei_ 1 (i = 2,3, ••• ,m), Qf 2= 0 and Qfj= fj-l (j = 3,4, •.• ,k). It is immediate that Q = ~+ 1 eqk-l and that Q = lim(e: + 0) Qe:(unless otherwise stated, lim must always be understood as a limit in the noPm-topoZogy). D LEMMA 2.5. Let T S(T)-= {A
E
E
L(~d):
L(~d) be a nilpotent of oPdeP m; then rank Aj s rank Tj foP j = 1,2, ••• ,m}.
PROOF. We have already observed that the condition "rank Aj s; rank Tj for j = 1, 2, ..• ,m" is necessary. (Observe that the minimal po!, ynomial of T is p(A) = Am.) Assume that rank Aj s; rank Tj for j = 1,2, ••• ,m. Clearly, we can directly assume that T and A are Jordan forms, i.e., (t 1 l (t 2 l (tk) (cx 1 l (cx 2 l (cxh) T q $q e •.• eq and A = ~ eq $ ••• e'Im nl n2 nk 1 m2 h (tj' cxi
> 0).
We shall proceed by induction on m(T,A) = d+Lj:l (rank Tj- rank Aj).
The case m(T,A) = 1 is trivial. Assume that m(T 1 ,A1 ) s; n implies that T1 7 A1 , whenever A1 and T1 are nilpotent operators acting on a s~m . · finite dimensional space and satisfy rank A1 J s; rank T1 J for all j =. 1,2, .•• , and let A, T E L(~d) be nilpotent operators such that rankAJ s rank Tj for all j = 1,2, ••• , and m(T,A) = n+l. If Tan~ A have a.common Jo~dan block.qr' then T = qreT 1 , A= qr $A1 , rank A1 J-rank T1 J =rank AJ- rank TJ s; 0 for all j = 1,2, ••• , 15
m(T1 ,A1 ) s (n+l)-r s nand, by induction, T1 sim A1 . A fortiori, T=qr $Tl sim qr$A1= A. If T and A have no common Jordan blocks and if r ~ 1 is the minimum index such that ~ < nr, then T has the form T = qn
$qn $T' r-1 r (where n 0 = 0 and q 0 acts on a {0}-space, if r = 1) and we have rank As < rank T8 for nr-l + 1 s s s mh- 1. Indeed, if rank As= rank Ts and if as (ts, resp.) denotes the number of Jordan blocks of A (T, resp.) with order of nilpotency grea! er than or equal to s, then it is obvious that as > ts and this yields the contradiction rank As-l = as+rank As> ts+rank Ts =rank Ts-l. Setting T1 = qn
+1 $qn _ 1$T' , we can check that rank T1 j = rank r-1 r . Tj for j = 1,2, •.• ,nr-l and rank T1 J= rank Tj-1 for nr_ 1 +1 s j s mh -1, so that s rank T1 j for j = 1,2, ••.• m -1 On the other hand, m(T 1 ,A) s m(T,A)- (rank Tmh-l- rank T1 h ) m(T,A) - 1 = n, and consequently, T1 sim A. If r > 1, then T sim Tl by n1-1 n1 !.emma 2.4._If r=l, then qn 1 "' }:j=l ej6ej+l E: L(a: ) is similar to e:e 1 ee 2 +-!~! 2 1 ej6ej+.l (« ~ 0) and, lett-Ulg e: + 0, we conclude that T s!m 0 T1 • In either case, Ts!m T1 sim A, and therefore A £ S (T)-.
2.1.2 Proof of Theorem 2.1 L (Q: d )
(0 S d < oo) 1 the minimal polynomial of k· J (A.-I' A., i f i -F j) and rank q(A) s rank T is p, p(A) = nj=l (;\-A.) J ~ J q(T) for all qiP· We want to show that T simA. Clearly, we can directly assume (without loss of generality) that T and A are unitarily equivalent to their Jordan forms: let T = $j:l (Aj+Qj), where a:d = $j:l Hj and Qj is a Jordan nilpotent acting on the subspace H., 0
Assume that T, A m
16
E:
A~ e r= ml (A r +Rr ), where Rr is a Jordan nilpotent acting on Hr and satisfying the conditions
rank (Rr)s s rank (Qr)s, s = 1,2, •.• ,kr,r=l,2, ••• ,m. By Lemma 2.5, Or s!m Rr and, a fortiori, Ar+Or sim Ar+Rr for all r = 1,2, ••• ,m, whence it readily follows that m
m
T = ej=l (Aj+Qj) sim ej=l (Aj+Rj) ~ A. The proof of Theorem 2.1 is complete now.
0
REl-1ARK 2. 6. Since nul q (T) = d-rank q (T) , the conditions "rank q(A) s rank q(T) for all qlp" can be replaced by the conditions "nul q(A) ~ nul q (T) for all ql p". PROOF OF COROLLARIES 2.2 AND 2.3. It is easily seen that T has the form of Corollary 2.2(ii) if and only if S(T) is maximal; (v) => (i) is a trivial implication and (ii) => (v) follows from Theorem 2.1. Now Corollary 2.2 fol~ows from the well-known algebraic fact that (ii), (iii) and (iv) are equivalent. Similarly, S(T) is minimal if and only if k.= 1 for all j = 1,2, J d ..• ,m, if and only if T is similar to a normal operator acting on ~ ; (v) => (i) is a trivial implication and (ii) => (v) follows from Theorem 2.1. On the other hand, it easily follows from Theorem 2.1 and its proof that if k.= 1 for all j = 1,2, •.• ,m, then the minimal polynomial J of A € S(T) is necessarily equal top and that A-T, i.e., S(T) S(T) is a closed subset of L(~d). Conversely, if S(T) is closed and T s!m A, then A € S(T) = S(T) and therefore A - T. A fortiori, A ~ T, whence it readily follows s1m d that [AJ = [TJ = S(T) is a minimal element of (L(~ )/#,<). The proof of Corollary 2.3 is complete now. 0
2.1.3 The lattice (N(~d)/i,<) The partially ordered set (poset) (L(H)/i,<) is never a lattice (unless dim H = 0). However, it contains many interesting lattices. Co~ sider the case when H = ~d is a finite dimensional space and let n (T.) d T ej=l qj J € L(~ ) ; then rank Tj = 'j+l+2'j+ 2+ .•• +(n-j)Tn and this implies that . 1 . "+1 T. =rank TJ- - 2rank TJ +rank TJ :<: 0, for j = 1,2, ••• ,n. (2.2) J
Let Ed be the set of all (d+l)-tuples (m 0 ,m1 ,m 2 , ••• ,md) of non17
negative integers such that {
d = m0 > m1 ~ m2 mj-l- 2mj + mj+l
0, and (2. 3) ~
0 for all j = 1,2, ••. ,d-1.
Observe that these two conditions imply that mj > mj+l' unless mj = 0, and mj-l- mj
0
~ v ~·
It is easily seen that (I:d,s) is a poset, d = max{m 0 ,m
0} >
max{m 1 ,mil
2
•••
~
max{md,md}
0
and 2 max{mj,mj} s max{mj_ 1+mj+l'mj_ 1 +mj+ 1 } s max{mj_ 1 ,mj_ 1 }+max{mj+l'mj+l}, so that p v ~· e I:d. It is completely apparent that~ v ~· is the least upper bound (l.u.b.) of~ and u' with respect to the partial orders. Since I:d is finite, every subset of I:d has a l.u.b .. In particular, ~A~·
= l.u.b.{v e I:d:
v s
~and
v s
~·}
is the (unique) greatest lower bound of~ and~·· It readily follows that (I:d,s) is a finite lattiae with supremum (d,d-l,d-2, ... ,2,1,0) and infimum (d,O,o, ... ,o,o,o). Given~= (m0 ,m 1 , .•• ,md) e I:d' define T e N(~d) by d (Tj) ~ T~ = IBj=l qj where Tj = mj_ 1 -2mj+mj+l for j = 1,2, ... ,d-1 and Td =md_ 1 : (2.2) and (2.3) guarantee that the mapping ~ ~ [T~] (2.4) is a bijection from I:d onto N(~d)/# and, moreover, that rank T j =mj for j = 0,1,2, ••• ,d. Combining these observations with Theorem 2.1, we obtain THEOREM 2.7. The mapping (2.4) defines an order-preserving bijeation from (I:d,s) onto (N(~d.)/#,s). In partiaular, (N(~d)/#,s) is a finite lattiae with supremum [qd] and infimum [0] (0 = ql (d)) .
18
2.1.4 Closures of similarity orbits of finite rank operators Let H be an infinite dimensional Hilbert space and let T, A E F(H); then T and A are algebraic operators with nul T =nul A= oo and there exists a finite dimensional subspace H(T,A) reducing both, A and T, such that TIH(T,A)L = AIH(T,A)L = 0 (H(T,A) can always be defined so that dim H (T ,A) s 2 rank T + 2 rank A) • Assume that A E S(T)-; then we can prove exactly as in the finite dimensional case that rank q(A) :S rank q(T) and, by using Proposition 1.12(ii), that nul q(A) ~ nul q(T) for all qJp, where p is the minimal polynomial of T. Conversely, if A satisfies those conditions, then it is not difficult to check that AIH(T,A) satisfies the same conditions with respect to TIH(T,A) and therefore, by Theorem 2.1, TIH(T,A) sim AIH(T,A). A
fortiori, T = TIH(T,A)$0 simA= AIH(T,A)$0; hence, we have
COROLLARY 2.8. Let T E L(H) be a (necessarily algebraic) finite Pank operator with minimal polynomial p, then S (T)
= {A E L (H) : rank q (A) s rank q (T) and nul q (A) for all qlp}.
Let L
E
L(H);
then L#T if and onl-y if L
~
:?:
nul q (T)
T.
REMARK 2.9. Since H is infinite dimensional, the conditions "rank q(A) s rank q(T) and nul q(A) ~ nul q(T) for all qlp" of Corollary 2.8 still imply that cr(A) = cr(T). However, the following example shows that those two conditions cannot be replaced by "cr(A) = cr(T) and rank q(A) s rank q(T) for all qJp": Let T be an orthogonal projection of rank 2 and let A be an orthogonal projection of rank 1; then cr(A) = cr(T) = {0,1}, and rank q(A) :S rank q(T) for all qlp (p(;\) = J.(J.-1) ),but A cannot belong to s(T)~, because 1 =dim H(l;A) ~dim H(l;T) = 2. Reversing the roles of A and T, we see that conditions of Corollary 2.8 cannot be replaced by "cr(A) = 0 (T) and nul q(A) ;:, nul q(T) forall qlp: Let NF(H) = N(HinF(H) and NFk(H) Since H is infinite dimensional, NF 1 (H)
c
NF 2 (H)
c
...
c
NFk (H)
c
{T
E
NF(H):
NFk+l (11)
c
rank T
:S
k-1}.
...
is an infinite chain (all the inclusions are proper: no two sets in this chain coincide), and this chain naturally induces a chain of lattices
19
(NF 1 (H)/*,<) c (NF 2 (H)/lt,<) c ... c (NFk(H)/It,<) c (NFk+l(H)/#,<)c •. , where (as can be easily checked by using Theorem 2. 7) ( NFk (H)/#,<) is order-isomorphic with (Ek,s); moreover, the above chain is in correspondence with a chain of natural order-preserving inclusions between the lattices {(Ek,s)}~=l ( (E 1 ,s) c (E 2 ,s) c ••• c (Ek,s) c (Ek+l's) c ••• ) . Let (E,S) be the set union of the Ek's with the induced partial order, i.e., if~. ~· £ E, then~. ~· E Ek for all k ~ k 0 (~,~·) and we define~ s ~· in (E,s) if~ s ~· holds in (Ek ,s). 0
COROLLARY 2.10. (NF(H)/#,<) is a lattice with infimum [0] and no maximal element. This lattice is oPdeP-isomoPphic with (E,s). REMARK 2.11. However (as we shall see in Chapter VIII),
(NF(H)/#,
<) does have a supremum in (L(H)/#,<).
2.2 The distance from the set of all non-zero orthogonal projections to N(H)
2.2.1 The limit case
Let P(H) be the set of all non-zero orthogonal projections in L(H). What is the exact value of the distance n.. = inf{ll P - Q II: from P(H) to N(H)
(1-1
P
E
P (H) , Q
(2.5)
N (H) }
E
an infinite dimensional space)?
According to Example 1.5, liP-Oil> l:i for all Q in L(H) such that o(Q)n{)..: p. -11 : ; l:i} = [8. Since o(Q) = {0} for every nilpotent Q, the above inequality holds, in particular, for all Q in N(/-1). Hence, noo ~ l:i. It will be shown that n.. = l:i; more precisely, if nk
inf{IIP-OII:
P
E
P(/-1), Q
1\
= inf{IIP- Oil:
P
E
P(«:k), 0
Nk(H)}
E
and E
N(U:k) },
then it is completely apparent that l:i ::; noo ::; nk ::; ok is non-increasing with k. We have the following THEOREM 2.12. l:i < ok $ l:i +sin (m:l) I whel'e m integral pal't of (k-1)/2), for all k ~ 3. In particular , lim(k + oo) ok = lim(k + oo) nk 20
$
1 and nk (ok)
((k-1)/2]
nco = Js.
I= the
We shall need some auxiliary results. LEMMA 2.13. Let 1 s m < n < ~ and let m < r < n, s be such that r+s = m+n. If {ei}i~l ({fj}j! 1 J is an ONB of ~r (~s. :r>esp. ), r-1 s-1 T =
and
r-1 s-1 .,m-1 L = e exists a unitrs rs n111 ary ope:r>ator V € L(~ ~~ ) such that IIVTV* - L II = II T- V*LV II = s (m), where s (m) =2sin (m:l) , Vei = ei> for m+1 s i s r, and Vfj = fj, for m+l s j s s. PROOF. Define
gt
r+l-t'
m+l-r $ t s 0, t7T t7T (cos 2 (m+l)) em+1-t + (sin 2 (m+l)) ft' 1 s t s m, m+1 s t s s,
ft'
t1T t7T ) kt = (-sin 2 (m+ 1 )) em+ 1-t + (cos 2 (m+l) ft, 1 s t s m,
and s-1 m-1 R = is also an ONB of ~r~s, the pair {gt,kt} generates the same two-dimensional subspace as the pair {em+l-t'ft} (for each t such that 1 s t s m), T = qr$qs and L = qn~~ = R. Now a straightforward computation shows that L = VRV*, where V is the unitary operator defined by Vgt = {
em+ 1-t' ft'
m+l-r s t s 0 1 s t
s s
and em+1-t'
1
s
t
s m.
On the other hand, (T-R)gt
0,
(T-R) g 0
(1-cos 2 (~+1)) em- (sin 2 (~+l)) f 1 ,
(T-R)gt (T-R)gm
(cos 2 (~+1) - l) gt+l- (sin 2(~+1))kt+1' 1 s t s m-1, m7T (sin 2 (m+l) - l) fm+l
(T-R) gt
0,
(T-R)kt
(sin 2(~+l))gt+1+(cos 2 (~+1) - 1 l kt+1 I
(T-R) km
mTI (cos 2 (m+l)) fm+l •
and
m+1-r s t s -1,
m+1
$
t s s,
1 s t
$
m-1,
21
Since V{gt,kt} = V{em+l-t'ft} (1 s t s m; V { ••• } denotes the oZosed Zinear span of{ •.• }), these two-dimensional subspaces are pa: wise orthogonal and (T-R)gt L (T-R)kt for 1 s t s m-1, we conclude that . 2 'If 11 2 ~ II T-R II -- max{[ sl.n 2 (m+l) + (cos 2 (m+l) - 1) J ,
.
I}
Ia (s1.n 2 (m+l) - 1) +bees 2 (m+l) max lal2+lbl2=1 ( 11 1) 2 ~ 2 . 'If ( ) . 2 'If = [ Sl.n 2 (m+l) + cos 2 (m+l) J = Sl.n (m+l) = s m • mw
m1r
Since IIVTV*-LII = IIT-V*LVII = IIT-RII, we are done.
D
The above proof admits a very simple geometric description: Th1 action of q r (e r + e r- 1 + e r- 2 + ••• + e 2 + e 1 + 0) can be described by an arrow of length r, and the action of T = qreqs by two arrows o1 lengths r and s, as follows m
r s
Similarly, R can be indicated as m
n
T maps em+l to em' the pair {em+l-j'fj} onto the pair {em-j'fj+: of "parallel" vectors (j = 1,2, ••• ,m-l) and the pair {e 1 ,fm} onto {0, fm+l}. On the other hand, R maps em+l to (cosn/2(m+l))em+(sinn/2(m+l: £ 1 , which is equal to the result of a "slight twist" of the vector er in the two-dimensional space V{em,f 1 }, the pair {em+l-j'fj} onto a "slight twist" of the "parallel pair" {e .,f.+l} (j = 1,2, ••. ,m-l)aJ m-J J a "slight twist" (in the reverse sense) of fm to fm+l" The accumulation ofall these "slight twists" after m+l steps wi: map em to fm+l and f 1 to 0. This fact will be described by the follo' ing scheme m (T + R)
r
:;:::::><:::::::
-~
s
Conversely, if we take ({gt}t~+l-ru{kt}t~l) as the original ONl of Er&E8 ~ En~ and modify R to obtain T, then the corresponding scheme will be (R + T)
:::::::><::
n
m
In this case, the twist will move g 0 to 22
~
to 0 and k1 to -gm+l
In what follows, we shall freely use these schemes instead of ana lytic descriptions in the proofs. COROLLARY 2.14. If k ~ 3, 1 s m s ({k-1)/2], p = k-m and U = ,p-1 p * p-1 p . L j=l ej6ej+l + ep6el E L (a: ) • then up "' qp + ~qp ) "' vp. lJhePe vp t.S the unitary operator defined by V e.= (w )le. (lJhere -wp is a primip ] p ] k tive p-th root of lJ and there e:r:ists a unitary operator V E L (a: ) suah that !!VqkV*-qmEDUpll = s(m).
PROOF. It is (Observe that the determinant(X-Vp) Represent qk
straightforward to check that Up ::: qp+(qp*)p-l == Vp three operators are unitary and determinant(X-Up) = = xP- (-l)P.) by a "curled arrow" and modify the action of the op-
erator in the subspace
V{e 1 ,e 2 , ••• ,em,em+l'ek-m'ek-m+l'"""'ek} as in
Lenuna 2 • 13
(qk
-+
m
qmEDUP)
We conclude as in the above lemma that there exists an operator Lm,p"' qmEDUP such that l!qk-Lm,pll = s(m).
0
PROOF OF THEOREM 2.12. With the notation of Corollary 2.14: Let L(O:k) be the orthogonal projection of a:k onto the one-dimensional kernel of ((-1)-~EDUP), where m = [(k-1)/2] and p = k-m: then P e
liP- (-l:z)VqkV*I! sliP+ (l:z)qmEDUpil+ (l:zli!VqkV*- ~EDUPI! s l:z + l:z s (m) = l:z + sin (m:l) • 7T
Hence, cSk s l:z +sin (m+l) • It readily follows that cSk=inf{I!P-QI!:
P c P(O:k), Q
E
N(O:k) and !lUlls 3/2+sin (m:l)}.
(2.6) Since P(O:k) x {Q E N(O:k): I!QII s 3/2+sin (m:l)} is a compact sue_ set of L(O:k) ~ L(O:k), it is easily seen that the infimum in (2.6) is actually attained for some pair (Pmin'Gmin) in this set. Thus, by our previous remarks (Example 1.5), 0
2.2.2 on the exact values of cSk and nk
PROPOSITION 2.15. If 2 s h = dim H s oo,
th~n
23
inf{IIP- Oil:
p
P(H),
€
a
E
N2(H)} = /2/2.
Furthermore, the above infimum is aatually attained by the operators Pmin =
[~ ~)eoh_ 2
and Qmin =
c P(H)
(~ =~Jeoh_ 2
E
N2 (H),
where the 2 x 2 matriaes aat an a two-dimensional subspaae H2 of H and Oh_ 2 denotes the 0 operator aating on (H 2 )l. PROOF. It is straightforward to check that Pmin
E
P(H), Qmin
E
N2(H) and JIPmin-Qminll = /2/2. On the other hand, if Q e N2 (H) and P E P(H), then either 0 = 0 and II P - o II = II P II = 1, or o ~ o • Assume that JJP- Oil< /2/2. If x e ker Q and y l ker Q, then IIPxJJ IJ
II P -
Q II
?:
It readily follows that 62=n2= ue of 6k or nk (k ?: 2). Ifk 3,
[11 ']
p3 = 1/3 1 1 1 1 1 1
and
03 =
0
/2/2.
/2/2. This is the only known val
2/3[: 11] 0 1
2 = 2/3[q3+(q3)
]
,
0 0
then P 3 e P (a: 3 ) (P is a rank one projection), 0 3
N (a: 3 ) and II P 3
-o
311 is equal to 2/3. Thus, ~ ~ n 3 ~ 15 3 ~ 2/3. This result is certainly better than the poor estimate 15 3 ~ ~ + sin ~~ = 3/2 given by Theorem 2.12 and the same is true for the k-dimensional analogues pk = 1/k ~i~l~ '~1 ei&eJ. and ok = (2/k) [qk+(qk) 2 + 3 k-1 J . (qk) + ••• +(qk) J of P 3 and Q3 , respect1ve1y, for smaZZ values of k. E
However, there is some numerical evidence that the estimate ~+sin(m~ 1 ) is much better than II Pk -Qk II for all k
and
24
?:
20.
2.2.3 A companion problem:
The distance from the set of all non-zero
idempotents to N(H) Clearly, P(H) is not invariant under similarities. The smallest set invariant under similarities containing P(H) is the set of all non zero idempotents acting on H, E(H) = {WPW- 1 : P E P(H), WE G(HJ} = {E E LIHI: E 2 =E~O}. We shall see later that if R1 and R2 are two subsets of L(H) , where H is an infinite dimensional space, then R~nR; is "very large", in general; namely, when R: contains an operator R. ~ J ] such that Rj is not an algebraic element of A(H), for j = 1,2.(See Chapter of the second monograph.) Very little is known about dist[Rl'R 2 J = inf{
IIR 1-R2 11:
Rj
E
Rj' j = 1,2}
for the case when one of the sets R~ or R; is a subset of the algebra~ ic operators (or, more generally, operators whose images are algebraic elements of the Calkin algebra) . In particular, what is the value of n~ = dist[E(H) ,N(H)J for the case when H is infinite dimensional? What is the answer if H = ~k or NIH) is replaced by Nk(H) (and dim H = ~> for some k ~ 2? Clearly, if and
then 0
~
nk
s
nk = distr.EIH),Nk(H) J ok' for all k ~ 2.
(H infinite dimensional),
PROPOSITION 2.17. (i) ok = 1/k, but E(ah and all Q in N(~k) (k "' 2). (iiJ 0 ~ nk s 1/k and n~ = 0.
I!E-Qi!
>
1/k for a'Ll E in
k
PROOF. (i) Let {e.} .~ 1 be the canonical ONB of ~ and let Pk k ] ]- k k-j (1/k)}:. . 1 e.t9e. and Wk - L· 1 n e.t9e. (n = 1,2, ••• ). Straight~, J= ~ J ,n J= J J forward computations show that.Pk is a rank one projection, wk ,n is in vertible, and ~ (nj-i k -l) 0 k,n = l.ld<jsk ei@ej
E
N (~k).
Since li Ek,n- Q k,n II = II~Llsjsisk (nj-ik -l) ei e ej II <1/klll
s ( 1 /k)
k-1 k-i -r I Li=OLr=1 n er+ieer I
k {II Lr=1
~k-i ei+rt9er Ill< ereerII + (l/n) ~k-111 l.i=1 l.r=1 '' · 1/k+1/n,
25
we see that 15k_ s; 1/k. On the other hand, if F o (F) c { O,l} and
€
k trace F = Lj=l = rank F ?? 1,
so that ~ 1/k for (at least) one value of j, 1 ::; j ::; k. ] ] k k Given F as above and Q € N(~), we can find an ONB {fj}j=l so that Q is strictly upper triangular with respect to that basis, i.e., = 0 for 1 s j s i s k. In particular, we have IIF-OII
~max
I<(F-Q)f.,f.>l =max II?? 1/k, lsjsk J J lsjsk so that !IF-Oil~ 1/k, i.e., &k_ ~ 1/k. Furthermore, since = 0 for 1 s j s i s k, it easily fol~ J lows that, eitheriiF-QII > 1/k or = 0 for 1 s j = 1/k for all j = 1,2, •.• ,k: i.e., F admits an upper triangular matrix with 1/k in all the diagonal entries with respect to the ONB {fj}j! 1 • But the second possibility implies that o(F) = {1/k}, a contradiction (recall that k ~ 2). Hence, IIF- Qll > ~Sk_ = 1/k for all F in E(~k) and all Q in N(~k). Since the second statement is a trivial consequence of the first one, we are done. D Clearly, the trace argument cannot be applied in the case when H is infinite dimensional, but the above result suggests the following CONJECTURE 2.18. nk = E(H) and all Q in Nk(H) (k
cSk = 1/k, ~
but liE-Oil> 1/k for all E in
2).
The last result of this section says that the above conjecture is true at least for k = 2. PROPOSITION 2.19. If 2 s h
= dim
n2 = 152 = inf{IIE- Oil:
E
H s €
ro,
E(H),
then Q
€
N2 !Hl}
but this infimum cannot be attained foP any paiP (E,Q), E
~. €
E(H),Q
€
N2 (H).
PROOF. If E = 1, then i t is clear that liE- oil = 1 for every quasinilpotent Q. Let E =
Ill- oil ~ sp(l-Q)
(~ :):::nEE)L
be the matrix of E € E(H)\{1} with respect to the decomposition H ran ES(ran E)L and let
26
lc oJ
0 =
be the matrix of Q
€
L(H)
(with respect to the same decomposition). ~ 2 (H)
if and only if
= AB+BD
= CA+DC = 0.
It is immediate that Q e
= o 2 +CB II E- Oil :S ~:
A2 +BC Assume that
then Ill- All
~ and
:S
liD II
:S
~ and therefore
o(A) c {A: Jl-AI s ~}and o(D) c {A: !AI s ~}.Thus, by the spectral mapping theorem, o (A 2 ) o(-BC) c {A: :le A ~ ~}
and 0
(D 2 )
=
o(-CB)
c
{A:
Since o(-BC)\{0} = o(-CB)\{0}
I AI
~}.
:S
(see, e.g., [ll9], [153], [172])and
A is invertible (recall that Ill-All s ~ < 1 ) , it readily follows that o(-BC) = o(A 2 ) = {~} c o(-CB) = o(D 2 ) c {0,~} and o(A) = {~} c o(D) c {0,!1}. Hence, liE- oil ~
Ill-All ~ sp(l-A)
= ~-
Assume thati!E-QJJ =~.Since o(A) = {~} = oR.(A), there exists a sequence {xn}n:l of unit vectors in ran E such that JJ(A-~)xnll-+- 0 (n +
oo) • On the other hand, A2 = -BC and A invertible imply that
Ellxll
II Cx II ~
for some e: > 0 and for all x in ran E, so that JJE- Oil
:?.:
lim sup(n
-+- co)
IJ(E- Olxnll
~
lim sup(n
-+- co) {
i!(l-A)xn11 2 +11-Cxn11 2 l~
~ (~+£2)~
>
~.
a contradiction. Hence
II E - Q II
> ~
for all 0 in ~ 2 ( H) •
On the other hand, it readily follows from Proposition 2.17 that inf {II E - 0 II:
2.3 On the distance to
E
€
E (H) , Q
€
~ 2 (H) }
s
~.
0
~k(H)
2.3.1 A general upper bound LEMMA 2. 20. Suppose that T
€
II T II s 1 and II Tk II s E: for some (T*T)~ = JLO,l]A dE (speatral deaomp£ L (H),
k ~ 2 and some e:. 0 < E s 1. Let sition) and let P = E([O,Ie:J); then
11((1-P)T(l-P)]k-41 s (k-1)/e:. PROOF. Clearly,
II TP II
s le:, and 27
e:11xlr
~
11Tkxll2 =
II~k- 1 xl1 2
=
IIPIT*T)~Tk-lx+ll-P) IT*T)~Tk-lxll2
~II (1-P) (T*T)~Tk-lxll 2
=
II
~ e:II11-P)~-lxll 2 , for all x in H. Hence, 1111-P)Tk- 1 11 s le:. On the other hand,
(1-P)~- 1 = [ ll-P)T]k-l+ll-P)TPT[Il-P)T]k-J+Il-P)T 2 PT[ 11-P)T]k- 4 + ••• +11-P)T
k-2
PT,
so that 11[11-P)Til-P)Jk-11 s 11[(1-P)T]k- 1 11 s 11(1-P)Tk-11+ { 1111-P) TPT[ 11-P) T]k-~~ + 1111-P) T 2 PT[ 11-P) T]k-~~ + ••• II11-P)Tk- 2 PTIIl s
ll(l-P)~-1I+!k-2)IITPII s lk-1)/e:. 0 k
THEOREM 2.21. Tf T E L(Hl. IITII s 1 and liT II s e: foro some k and some e:, 0 < e: s 1, then
2
;>
I 2. 7) wheroe ~kle:) is a continuous, positive, non-decroeasing function defined on 10,1] such that lim(e: + 0) $k(e:) = 0. Moreovero, ~kle:) can be inductively defined by $ 2 le:) = l2e:)~ and $k(e:) = {e:+$k_ 1 1(k-l)/e:) 2 }~. fork= 3,4, •••• PROOF. Let P be defined as in Lemma 2.20 and let T = [E 1 T1]ran P E 2 T 2 ker P be the matrix of T with respect to the decomposition If k = 2, define T' = PT(1-P) =
H
ran P$ker P.
(~ ~l).
Since
(~ ~,.2 ) Iran P and ker P
1
=
0
ran P, it follows from Lemma 2.20 and its proof that
II T- T' II
=
1 (:~ ~J 1 {II(:~ ~JII \II(~ ~JI 2 r s
s (e:+£)
~ = ( ~.
~ 3 and (2.7) holds for j s k-1, with ~ 2 (e:) and 4>.(£) = {e:+~.-l((j-2)/£) 2 }\ for j = 3,4, •• ,k-l. Assume that k
J J Clearly, IIT 2 11
28
=
11(1-P)Til-P) II s 1 and, by Lemma 2.20, IIT 2
2 £)
= (2e:)~ k-L
11 s
(k-1)/E. Thus, by our inductive construction, we can find T2 (ran P)
f
Nk-l
such that II T 2 -T211 s lj)k-l ( (k-1) /E). Define
T' It
is easily seen that T'
€
Nk(H) and a formal repetition of our
previous argument (for the case when k = 2) shows that IIT-T'Il s lj)k(E)
{E+Ij)k-l((k-l)IE) 2 }~
(def)
4
D
k.
J ().i~ Aj if i ~ jJ be a potynomiat and tet Mp(H) = {A € L(H): p(A) = 0}. Given E > 0, there e:J:ists 6 > 0 suah that, if IITII s 1 and IIP(T) II s 6, then COROLLARY 2.22.
=
Let p().)
rrj:l (A-Aj)
dist[T,Mp(H) J < E. PROOF. I f m = 1, then the result follows from Theorem 2.21. As~
2. There exists E1 > 0 such that the m open disks D1 , o2 , ••• ,Dm of radius El centered at ). 1 , A2 , ••• , Am' respectively, are pairwise disjoint. Let E0 > 0 be such that i f IP(A) I < E0 , then A is sume that m
contained in one of these disks. Let 1 I = 2ni aD. J
PJ. We shall show that
().-T)-1 d)..
is a bounded function of IIPII, IITII, e 0
Pk
for small IIP(Tlll· Observe that p(A)- p(T) = a1 q
in
(A-T)q(A,T)
,
p(J.)
for a polynom!_
the variables A, T. Thus 1-p(T)p(A)-l = ().-T)q(A,T)p(A)-l.
Now, for A such that I A-Aj I = El we have that IIP(A) small i f IIP(T)II
-1
p(Tlll
is
is. Let E=p(A)-lp(T); then
().-T) - l = p(A) -lq().,T) (1-E) - l = where II J II s II p (A) -lq (A ,T>II ·II E
IV (1-JI E II>
p(A) -lq(A,T)+J,
is small since II p (A) -lq (A ,T)II is
bounded by a funtion of II T II and p (A) • Thus the P. 's are bounded ( j
J
2, ••• ,m) • On the other hand, k. 1 II
1 = ll2n1 Since each (T-).j)
k·
1
I aD.
P(A)- ().-).j)
I aD.
(A-Aj)
J
+
k.
().-).j)
k. JJ d). II
k.+l
J Jd).ll s IIJII·E 0
J
J
Jpj is small (provided IIP
use Theorem 2.21 to perturb TP. to aT~
J
J
is a nilpotent of order at most k .•
•
k. lq().,T)
= l,
J
in
L(ran P.) J
such that (TJ~-).J.)
•
I f H =ran P.+ker P., define T. =T~+O with respect to this decomJ J J J
29
position (j
= 1,2, ••• ,m)
= Lj~l
and T'
II T- T' II ~ max{ll P j 11·11 Tj-TI ran P jll: provided II p (T) II < c5 for some c5
>
Tj. Then p(T') = 0 and 1 ~ j ~ m} < e:,
0 small enough.
0
Let T, k and e: be as in Theorem 2.21 and let n. 0 < n ~ 1, be the k-th root of e: (i.e., 11~11 ~ nk) and define ljlk(n) = cpk(e:), k = 2,3, ••• ~ then Theorem 2.21 implies that, if k = 2, then dist[T,N 2 (H)J s l2n!kif k = 3, then dist[T,N 3 (H) J ~ (n3+4n3 / 2 )~, •• , and dist[T,Nk(H) 1 = O(e: 2 = 0
po~
CONJECTURE 2.23. There exists a continuous function ljl(n), defined on [0,1], such that ljl(n) > 0 on (0,1], lji(O) = 0 and dist[T,Nk(H)J s 11J(n) for all Tin L(H) such that IITII ~ 1 and IITkll ~ nk (i.e., the functions ljlk(n) can be replaced by a single one).
2.3.2 Two illustrative-examples The rough argument of the proof of Proposition 1.10 might suggest that those estimates are very poor. However, Lemma 2.13 shows that the "very poor" lower estimates given by Proposition 1.10 are actually the best possible except, perhaps, for a constant factor independent of k. Indeed, if T and L have the form of that lemma, then nul ~+l = 2 (m+l) >nul Lm+l=2m+l. Thus, if W (U) is an invertible (unitary, resp.) operator, we can always find a unit vector x = x(W) (= x(U), resp.) such that IILm+lxll = 1, but (WTW-l)m+lx = 0 ( (UTU*)m+lx = 0, resp.), whence it readily follows from Proposition l.lO(i) ((ii), resp.) that dist[L, S(T)] :?: 2l/(m+l)- 1 (dist[L,U(T) J :?: 1/(m+l), resp.). An even more surprising example can be constructed on the same lines. We shall need the following auxiliary result (With the notation of Lemma 2.13): COROLLARY 2.24. (i) Let {gn}-m
Let ·H+ = y{gn}n~O(H_ = V{gn}n
(ii) If k ~ 3 and 1 5 m 5 [ (k-1V2J, there exists a unitary W : (~m) (oo)EBH ~ (~k) (oo) such that k,m llq (oo) -W (q (oo)$U)N* II= s(m). k k,m m k,m PROOF.
(i)
For suitably defined A'
=A
and B'
= B,
oper~
we have
m
o~=m-1
'
(-oo,oo)
----------~--------==~==~~--.~~m
whence we obtain (-oo,m)
A'EilB':
( 0 ,oo) II!~EilU)- (A'$B'lll
= s(m) and the unitary operator Vm can be chosen so
that Vm(A'EilB')v; = AEilB, Vmgo=k 1 and Vmg_ 1 =-km. (ii) Since r = k-2m ~ 1, there exists U' = U such that (
qk
~ q
( 00)
m
( 00) $U I )
k
__......,:;:._::::--><~=
. ·><
m (~
fact that r
~
.
m
)
k
...X =:;;;:. .:::::J:T-kk:- -
~
- - -
m
1 guarantees that we can consistently apply the ar-
gument of Lemma 2.13 to each step.), with llqk(oo) -qm(oo)$U'II = s(m), whence the result follows.
0
EXAMPLE 2.25. Let s be a unilateral shift of multiplicity one and letT
E
L(H)
be unitarily equivalent to s(oo)$S*(oo); then IITkll = 1 for
all k ~ 1, cr(T) = crR.re(T) ={A:
IA.I
51} and
2l/k- 1 5 dist[T,Nk(H) J s 4 sin TT/([ (k-1)/2]+1) < BTT/k, for all k
~
3.
PROOF. It is not difficult to see that IITkll = 1 for all k
~ 1 and
that nul(>.-T) =nul(>.-T)*=oo for all A. in the open unit disk D ={A: 1>-1 < 1}, whence it follows that cr(T) =crR.re(T) =D-.
Let 0 c: Nk(H). Since Qk=O, it follows from Proposition l.lO(iii) that liT-Oil'??: 2l/k_l (k =·1,2,3, ••• ). On the other hand, i f k ~ 3, m=
31
[ (k-1)/2] and the operators are defined with respect to a suitable ONB of H, it is not difficult to infer from Corollary 2.24(i) and (ii) that ( (qk (oo}) (oo) "' qk (oo)): ll
II qk (co)
-
(~am•) (oo)ll +ll(~eu•) (oo) -Til
(oo) -
~ (oo) eu'll +ll~eu• - ses* II = 2s (m)
= 4{sin 'IT/([ (k-1)/2]+1)} < B'IT/k. Our next example shows that the infinite dimensional ampliations of finite dimensional examples can produce certain surprises. (An ator T in L(H) is called an ampliation if T = A81 = A("") for some ator A € L(Ho) I 1 s dim Ho s oo.) EXAMPLE 2.26. Let k > h ~ 3: then the operators A qk (h) (A, B € L(~kh)) satisfy dist[B,S(A)]
1:
qh (k) and B = (2.8)
however, 21/k-1 s dist[B(ool,S(A(oo))] s 4{sin 'IT/([(k-1)/2]+1) (2.9) +sin 'IT/([(h-1)/2]+1)}
Bn(l/k+l/h).
<
PROOF. Observe that nul A= k >nul B =h. Thus, dist[B,S(A)] ~ 1. (Use Proposition l.lO(i) as in our previous observations at the begi~ ning of this section.) On the other hand, A~ EA for all E > 0, so that 0 € S(A)-, whence we obtain (2.8). The lower estimate of (2.9) follows from Proposition l.lO(iii) ([A(oo)]h=O, II[B(oo)Jhll = IIB(oo) II= 1.) The upper estimate follows from the proof of Example 2.25: For suitably chosen·T = s<"">es*(oo), A' =A and B' = B, we have IIB'-A'II s IIB'-Tit+JIT-A'II s 4{sin 'IT/([(k-1)/2]+1)
+sin 'IT/([(h-l)/2J+l)} < B'IT(l/k+l/h).
D
Example 2.26 suggests that, if H is infinite dimensional, then 1 N (H) = {Q € N(H): !lOll s 1} "looks like" IU+iQI (where !1J denotes the set of all rational numbers), in the following sense: Observe that Gl+iGI = uk:l (Qik +i!IJk) , where !Ilk = {m/n: "large" nowhere dense subset of !IJ+i
A
m € 2Z , 1 s n s k}, !Ilk +iQlk is a
€
Gl+ill} < 1/(k/21+ 0 (k + oo)
and (GI+iGI) (in the complex plane) coincides with the much larger set 1 1 E, and N (H) = uk=l [N (H)nNk(H)J. 00
32
CONJECTURE 2.27. max{dist[Q,Nl(H)nNk(H)J: some constant C > 0 independent of k.
0
E
Nl(H)} ~ C/k for
An affirmative answer to this conjecture would provide some heuristic explanation to the wild structure of N1 (H) - (see Chapter V).
2.3.3 An example on approximation of normal operators by nilpotents > SO, p = [,/k/2hrJ, n
aj =
p
-1
and r = [kn/2] and let Qk E k-1 L(~k) be the operator defined by Qk = Lj=l aj ej+ll8ej with respect to the ONB {ej}j~l of ~k, where Let k
l
nn, for r (n-1) < j s rn, n = 1, 2, ••• ,p, nn, for r(2p-n) < j s r(2p-n+l), n = 1,2, .•• ,p, 0, for 2rp < j ~ k-1.
(Roughly speaking: Qk is a truncated weighted shift; the weights aj grow from n to 1 through p steps of length r and then go down from 1 to 0 through p steps of length r, so that the upper step has length 2r with weights equal to 1, i.e., a. = 1 for r(p-1) < j ~ r(p+l) .) . . . . J . .. . In the f~rst mod~f~cat~on, we shall "~gnore" the coord~nates 1,2, ... ,r(p-1) and r(p+l)+l,r(p+l)+2, ••• ,k and apply Corollary 2.14 to the subspace V{er(p-l)+l'er(p-l)+ 2 , ••• ,er(p+l) }. It is easily seen that we can modify Qk in order to obtain an operator Ri = Tieur+l' where U +l ~ e 10e +l+L.: 1 e.+ 10e. is a unitary operator acting on a subspace r r JJ J 1 1 1 of dimension r+l and there exists an orthonormal system {f 1 ,f 2 , ••• ,f2t r (p-1) 1 2r k . R , _ such that {ej}j=l u{fj}j=lu{ej}j=r(p+l)+l ~san ONB of a:, T1ej-Qk ej for j i 1
1
(r(p-l),r(p+l)J, Tier(p-l) =fi, _
1_
Tif~=f~+l for h = 1,2, ••• , h 1
r-2, T1 fr_ 1 - (1-n)er(p+l)+l and Ur+lfh- (wr+l) fh for h = r,r+l, ••• ,2r (-wr+l is a primitive (r+l)-th root of 1); furthermore, IIOk-Rill = s(r-1). Let T1 be the operator obtained from Ti by replacing each weight equal to 1 by 1-n and R1 = T1eur+l; then II Qk- R111 ~ s (r-1) +n. Now we can apply the same argument to R1 in order to obtain an OE erator R2 = T2e (l-n)u 2 reur+l, where u 2 r is a unitary operator acting on a subspace of dimension 2r, whose eigenvalues are equal to minusthe 2r 2r-th roots of 1, T 2ej = ~ej for all j I. (r(p-2) ,r(p+2) ], T2er(p- 2 ) = 2
2
2
2
(l-2n)f 1 , T2 fh = (l-2n)fh+l for h = 1,2, •••,r-2, T2 fr-l = (l-2n)er(p+ 2 )+l'
,£;_
{fi,f~, ••• 1 } is an orthonormal system that spans a subspace orthor u{ej}j=r(p+ k gonal to the span of the vector ({ej}j=l 2 )+1), II R1 - R2 II ~ (1-n)[s(r-l)+n]and this second modification only affects the vectors 33
· th e su b space spanned by (e.}. { r (p-1) r (p+2) 1n J J=r ( p- 2 ) +1 u{e.}. J J=r ( p+ l) +1 ), so that IIOk- R2 JJ = max{JJok- R1 JJ,JJR 1 - R2 11} s s(r-l)+n, etc. An easy inductive argument shows that after p-1 steps we finally obtain an operator L = u mre:£?-1 (l-· )U 1...,.. (k+l-(2p-l)r) k r+l J=l Jn 2r ~~1 such that JJok-~11 s s(r-ll+n < 2n/r+[lk/2lnJ < 5(n/k)~ for all k >SO. On the other hand, if 1 s k s 50, then 5(1T/k)~ > 1. Thus, we have the following PROPOSITION 2.28. (i)
FoP eaah k
~
1 thePe exists a noPmaZ
opeP~
toP~ E L((tk) suah that JJLkJI = 1 and dist[~,N(a:k)] < 5(1T/k)~. (ii) If H is infinite dimensional, thePe exists a noPmaZ opePatoP M suah that cr(M) = D-, !Uhepe D = {;\: !AI< 1} and distrM,Nk(H)J < 5(1T/k)~ fop all k = 1,2, •••. In partiauZar, ME N(H)-.
PROOF. (i) If k > 50, define ~ as above. If 1 s k s SO, take Lk = 1, Qk=O. (ii) Let {Am}m:l be an enumeration of all those points A in Osuch that both lAml and (arg Am)/1T are rational numbers (arg 0 is defined equal to 0) and let M be a diagonal normal operator with eigenvalues A1 ,A 2 , ••• ,A , ••• such that nul(A -M) =cofor all m = 1,2, ••• , i. . m (co) m e., M = (d1ag{A 1 ,A 2 , ••• ,Am, •.. }) Given k, it is easytoseethatMcanbe written as M" (EDm:l Am Lk) (co), whence it readily follows that dist[M, Nk (H) J A
fortiori, ME N(H)-.
0
The result of Proposition 2.28(i) is, in a certain sense, the best possible. Observe that if Nk E L(a:k) is normal and there exist k Qk € N(a: ) and e:k > 0 such that JJNk- QkJJ < e:k' then (by Corollary 1.6 (i)) cr(Nk) is a connected set containing the origin. If the points e:k of cr(Nk) are more or less evenly distributed in a connected neighborhood n of the origin with smooth boundary (namely, n = D), then 2 cr(Nk) will include n and therefore k1re:k ~ m2 (n), where m2 denotes e:k the planar Lebesgue measure. Hence, e:k ~ [m 2 (0)/(1Tk)J~ = O(k-~). cannot be connect (On the other hand, if e:k is too small, then cr(Nk) e:k ed, a contradiction.) CONJECTURE 2.29. There exists a constant C > 0 (independent of k) 34
such that dist[N,N(~k)J ~ Ck-~ for every normal operator N such that II Nil= 1 (k = 1,2, ••. ) .
E
L(~k)
The following result provides some extra support to this conjecture. Observe that if A E L(~k) is hermitian and 0 ~ A ~ 1, then the points of a(A) are not evenly distributed in any set of positive measure. (More precisely, m2 (a(A)£) ~ 2c+~c 2 independently of k, and 2c+ 2 .,. 0, as £ ..,. 0.) nE k
PROPOSITION 2.30. If A € l(~ ), 0 dist[A,N(~k)] > (1/2/k), k = 1,2, ••••
~A~
1, and 1
E
a(A), then
PROOF. Assume that IIA-QII ~£for some Q E N(~k), Q = H+iJ (Cartesian decomposition); then IIA-HII = IIJR.e(A-Q) II~ IIA-QII ~£and trace (H) = trace (llle Q) = Ie trace (Q) llle 0 = 0. On the other hand, it is easily seen that a(A) ~ ~O,l]{Use Carol £ lary 1.6(i)), so that trace {A) ~ l+{l-2c)+{l-4c)+ ••• +{l-2nc), where n = [l/2c](= integral part of {l/2c)). It is clear that l/2c ~ n > l/2c-l. Hence, {n+l) > l/2c and n-1 trace {A) ~ {n+l) - 2c}:j=O j = (n+l)- {n+l) nc = {n+l) {1-nc) > l/4c. Let A f A dE and H = J A dF (spectral decompositions) • If a E [0,1], c'> c and rank F{{a-c',aa)) l > a-(a-c) =c, a contradiction. Hence, rank F{[a-c,aa)) ~rank E{[a,aa)) and, by symmetry, rank F([a,ao)) ~rank E{[a-c,ao))' for all a E [0,1]. It folows that 0 = trace (H) > trace {A) - kc > 1/ 4c - kc. Hence, c > 1/2/k. By a compactness argUMent (exactly as in the proof of Theorem 2.12), we conclude that dist[A,N{a:k)J = min{IIA-OII=
Qk =0,
11011 ~
2} > 1/2/k.o
2.3.4 On the distance to a similarity orbit LetT E L{a:d) be a ayalia operator with minimal polynomial p, p(A) = n.m1 {A-A·)kj {A. -1- A·, i f i -1- j); then }:.m1 k. =d and Tis sim J=
J
l.
J
J=
J
ilar to the Jordan form ej:1 {Aj+qk·). Let A E L{a:d) be an operator wfth spectrum a(A) = {a 1 ,a 2 , ••• ,an} 35
and dim H(a.;A) =h .• (Clearly, }:.n 1 h. =d.) Define JJ 1 =JJ 2 = •.• =JJk =A 1, J
l.
J=
1
l.
JJk +l=JJk +2= ... =JJk +k =:\2' ••• 'JJd-k +l=JJd-k +2= ... =JJd=A and 1 1 12 m m m 11 1 =1!2= ••• = 11 h = al' 11 h +1 =l!h +2= ••• = 11 h +h =a2, ••• ' 11 d-h +1 1 1 1 1 2 n = Sd-h +2 = Bd-h +3 = • • • = Bd = an; then A admits a representation as . n
n
an upper triangular matrix of the form
A
0
Bd (with respect to a suitable ONB of ~d). It is not difficult to conclude from Theorem 2.1 that
T sim B = 0 )Jd
Moreover, the same result applies to any upper triangular representation of A. Hence, we have COROLLARY 2.31. Let A and T be as above; then dist[A,S (T)] ~ min
max
aEE(k) whe~e
E(k)
l~j~k
I JJ. - S (.) J
0
J
1.
(2.11)
denotes the set of aZZ permutations of k elements.
Unfortunately, the estimate (2.11) is very poor, in general. Name ly, if~ and Qk have the form of Proposition 2.28(i), then qk is cyclic, qk sim Qk (by Theorem 2.1) and
dist[~,S(qk)] ~ IILk-Qkll
< 5(1T/k)!oz
+
0 (k
+co).
However, sp (Lk) = 1 (-1 E a (Lk)) and a (qk) = {0}, so that the only information that we can obtain from Corollary 2.31 is that dist[Lk' S(qk)J s 1. PROBLEM 2.32. Find a formula for 36
dist[A,S(T)] (A, T
E
l(~d)).
We shall close this section with a partial answer to this problem. n
n
hk)
(o;k)
COROLLARY 2.33. If T=EDk=l ~k and A=EDk=l qk al'e finite rank opel'atol's, rank TJ =rank AJ fol' j = 1,2, ••• ,r and rank Tr+l < rank Ar+l fol' some r ;:.: 2, then 21/(r+l) -1
$
dist[A,S(T) J s 2 s([{r-1)/2]}.
PROOF. The lower estimate follows from Proposition l.lO(i). In order to obtain the upper estimate, we can directly assume without loss of generality that A, T E L(~d) (for some d, 0 < d < ~>. Then, our hypotheses and formula (2.2) imply that T· = o;. for j = 1,2, J J ... , r-1, but 'r < o:r· Since r > 1, this means, in particular, that T and A have exactly the same number of direct summands, which is equal toT=
Lj~l
'j"
After eliminating all common direct summands, we can directly assume (without loss of generality) that T =ED n q (Tk) and A=q (o:r> n {
q ED ( T)) n m
)
> r~ m
r
:'X
:X
r..._..... m
\
lrr
)
r
:X ~>r
:X: >r'-v-'
>
m
m blocks of length r
n" - - - - _ _ _ _ __,).,.........::.:...__:'O<"X--:::r·
'"V"""
~
n'
m
(where r < n" s n' s n and n' is the largest Jordan block of A), whence we obtain dist[A,U(qnED~(T))J s s(m). Similarly, we have dist[T,U(qnED~(T))J s s(m). Combining these two inequalities, we obtain dist[A,S(T)] s dist[A,U(T)] s dist[A,U(qnED~(T))] + dist[T,U(qnED~(T))J s 2 s(m).
0
2.4 on the distance from a compact operator to N(H)
37
j k-1 j j ••• ,ek can be chosen in such a way that llfj~fj- Jz}:r=l er~er+~l < lf + 2n/k. Define Gl Al2 Al3 G2 A23 G3 G 0
Gd k-1 where Gj = (;\/2) Lr=l
e;~e:+l
IIF&lO((k-l)d) -Gil
and Aij = aijfj_8fj; then
max{ll Gj- ;\jfj~fjll: < max{l;\jl/2:
1
~
j
1 ~ j ~ d} ~
d}+27r/k=sp(F)/2+27r/k.
Let K € K(HJ (H infinite dimensional) and let e: > 0 be given. Then there exists a finite rank operator F such that II K- F II < e:/3. £ £ Moreover, by the upper semicontinuity of the spectrum (Corollary 1.2),' F can be chosen so that sp(F ) < sp(K)+e:/3. £ £ Since F e: F I H) , there exists a finite dimensional subspace H of £ £ H, dim H£ = d ~ 1, such that H£ reduces F£ and F £ IHi£ = 0. Let F = F I"H , let M be a subspace of dimension kd containing H for some k £ £ £ £ large enough to guarantee that 2n/k < e:/3 and define G e: L (M ) as above £ and G e l(H) in such a way that G IM = G and G IMi = 0. £ kd £ £ £ £ Then G e F(H), G = 0 and £ e: IlK-Gil !> IIK-Fe:II+IIF'e:-Ge:ll < e:/3-+JIF-GII < e:/3+~ sp(F)+e:/3 < J;z sp(K)+e:.
Since e: can be chosen arbitrarily small, we obtain the following upper bound: PROPOSITION 2.34. If K e K(H) (H an infinite dimensionaZ space), then the distance from K to the set of aZZ finite rank nilpotent oper~ tors cannot e~ceed ~ sp(K). In partiauZar, every compact quasinilpotent operator can be uniformZy approximated by finite rank niZpotents.
2.5 Notes and remarks The problem of characterizing the closure of a similarity orbit in simple terms was raised by D. A. Herrero in [139]. This reference contains all the basic properties of the sets S(a) (for a in a Banach algebra A), the notion of asymptotic similarity, several properties of 38
the poset (A/i,<), the analysis of several relevant examples, etc. The results include the proof of the implications (ii) => (iv) => (i) of Corollary 2.3 (in the above mentioned more general setting [139,Proposi tion 1]) • Theorem 2.1 and Corollary 2.8 are due to J. Barrra and D. A. Herrero [43,Theorem 1.1], who also proved that (F(H)nN(H)/#,<) is a lattice (0 ~ dim H ~ oo). The concrete model (Ed,~) for this lattice (Theorem 2.7) is an unpublished result of c. Apostol and D. Voiculescu[34]. In [129], J. H. Hedlund tried to detetllline the eKaot value of 11 00 = dist[P(H),N(H)] and showed that 1/4 ~ 11 00 ~ n 2 =o 2 =12/2 (Proposition 2.15) . He also analyzed the norm of the difference Pn - Qn for several values of n ~ 100 and suggested that these operators could be used to prove that ok + ~ (k + oo).(Personal communication to the author.) The solution of the problem evolved as follows: 1) 11 00 =~ (D. A. Herrero [132,Corollary 9], by using infinite dimensional arguments; 2) ok does converge to~. ask+ oo (D. A. Herrero [133,Section 7(d)], modif~ ing the previous argument); 3) ok ~ ~+[l+(k-l)~J/2k ~ ~+1/2/k (N. Sal! nas, [18l,Lemma 3.3], by using an argument due toP. R. Halmos [125]): 4) ok >~and T)k < ~+(8 log k)/k (D. A. Herrero, [149,Proposition 6.5]) and 5) ok < ~+sin 1T/([ (k-1)/2]+1) (D. A. Herrero, [150,Corollary 5.2]). P. R. Halmos and L. J. Wallen called an operata~ T in L(H) a pown• parotiaZ isometroy if Tk is a partial isometry for all k <: 1 and pro~ ed that T has this property if and only if T ~ {ek:l qk(Tk)}es
<
10/log k,
for all k large enough. The results of Section 2.2.3 are unpublished observations of D. 39
A. Herrero (However, the fact that dist[ E(a:k) , N(a:k) J = 1/k was also i!!l dependently proved by B. Aupetit and J. Zemanek in [200,Example 2.4]), It is worth to remark that the proof of Proposition 2.17(i) actually yields the following stronger result: PROPOSITION 2.35. inf{I!T-QII:
T
but this infimum is
t:
Fo~
each k
~
2
L(O:k), a(T) ={0,1}, Q
neve~
t:
N(~)}
1/k~
attained.
The results of Section 2.3.1 are due to s. L. Campbell and R. Gellar [64]. That every compact quasinilpotent operator is the norm limit of finite rank nilpotents is an observation of R. G. Douglas [123,Problem. 7] and the improvement given here (Proposition 2.34) is due to D. A. Herrero [149,Proposition 6.6].
40
3 The main tools of approximation
In this chapter and the following one, we shall analyze the main "tools" of approximation. Some of these "tools" developed within the framework of Operator Theory: The Rosenblum equation AX- XB = C, Rota's universal model and its generalizations, the triangular representation of C. Apostol and the theorem of C. Apostol, C. Foia~ and D. Voiculescu on normal restrictions of small compact perturbations of operators. These, as well as some of their consequences, will be developed here. Two other important results (the Brown-Douglas-Fillmore theorem and Voiculescu' s "non-commutative Weyl-von Neumann theorem") , from the theory of C*-algebras, will be analyzed in Chapter IV.
3.1 The Rosenblum operator:
X
+
AX- XB
3.1.1 Linear operator equations Let A be a Banach algebra with identity. The mapping a + La, where La" L(AJ is defined by La(b) = ab (be A) is called the Pegutar Zeft ~ep~sentation of A. It is well-known that this mapping is an isometric isomorphism from A into L(A). Similarly, the regular right representation (defined by a + Ra " L(A), where Ra (b) = ba) is an isometric anti-isomorphism (i.e., ab + R R ) • In particular, o (L a ) = o (Ra ) = o (a) for all a in A. -b a Given a, be A, Tab" L(A) is defined by Tab(c) =ac-cb, i.e., r ab =La - ~. It is easily seen that La and ~ commute and that
()., ll "
a:) ,
so that
LEMMA 3.1. Let X be a aomplex Banaah spaae and ZetA, B"E: L(X) be
41
two operator>s such that AB = BA; then o(A+B)
a" o(A), B" o(B)}
o(A) +o(B) ={a+B:
c
and o(AB)
o(A)o(B) = {aB:
c
a " o(A), B " o(B)}.
PROOF. Let B c L(X) be a maximal abelian algebra containing A and B. Clearly, 1 f Band (A-A)-l ((~-B)-l) belongs to B for all A 1 o(A) (~I a(B), resp.). Let M8 be the set of all multiplicative linear functionals on B; then the Gelfand theory implies that o(A+B) = {cp(A+B):
cp
M8 J
E
= {cp(A)+cp(B):
cp " M8 J cr(A) +o(B)
and o(AB) = {cp(AB): c{cj>(A):
cp cp
COROLLARY 3. 2.
M8 J = {cp(A)cp(B):
E
E
M8 }.{cj>(B):
o (-r ab)
cp
E
cp " M8 }
M8 } = o(A).o(B).
0
cr (a) - cr (b) .
c
PROOF. Since La~ = ~La' it follows from Lemma 3.1 that a (La-~) c a (La) -a(~). On the other hand, a (La) = a (a) and cr(b), whence the result follows. We shall see later (Corollary 3.20) that when A sion is actually an equality.
L(H)
this inclu
3.1.2 Approximate point spectrum of a sum of commuting operators The appr>oximate point spectrum of A OTT(A)
~:
{A
E
{A
E ~:
E
L(X) is the set
A-A is not bounded below}
and
a 6 (A)
=
A-A is not onto}
is the approximate defect spectrum of A. It is completely apparent that op(A) c oTT(A) c oi(A) and a 6 (A) c or(A). Furthermore, if At denotes the Banach space adjoint of A, then it is not difficult to see that crTT(A) =·cr 6 (At) and o 6 (A)
=
crTT(At).
(If X is a Hilbert space, on(A) = oi(A) = crr(A*)* and a 6 (A) oi(A*)*, where O* = {~: A f Q} for each Q c ~.)
42
LE~~
3.3. Given any Banach space X, there is an isometric imbedding of X into a larger Banach space X', and a mapping A+ A' of L(X) int9 L(X') which is an isometric isomorphism such that every A' is an extension of A and a (A') =a (A') =a (A) • p 7r 7r PROOF. Let ~ 00 (X) be the Banach space of all bounded sequences of elements of X with the norm ll{x } : 1 11 = sup llx llx and let e (X) "' n nn n o {{xn} E ~ (X): II xn II + 0 (n + "')}. It is easily seen that e 0 (X) is a subspace of ~"'(X). We define X'= ~"'(X)/e (X) and the imbedding of X into X' by x + 0 [{xn}J (=the coset of {xn}), where xn = x for all n = 1,2, . . . • Clear ly, this mapping is an isometric isomorphism of X into X'. Similarly, given A in L(X), we define A' E L(X') by A'[{xn}J = [{Axn}]; then A+ A' defines an isometric isomorphism from L(X) into L(X') •
If A ~ a7r(A), then there exists a sequence {xn}n:l of unit vectors in X such that II 0 and for all x in X, then it can be easily seen that II
1T
1T
PROOF. (i) Let A E a (A+B); then, by Lemma 3.3, A € a ((A+B) ') 7r p cr (A'+B') and A'B' =B'A'. It readily follows that the subspace p M = ker(A'+B'-A) is invariant under A' and B', and B' IM = (A-A') IM. Thus, if a E a (A' IMl then A-a E a (B 1 1Ml and therefore 1T
A= a+(A-a)
E
a (A'IMl+a (B'IMl
1T
c
a (A')+a (B') =a (A)+cr (B).
1T 1T 1T 1T 7r 7r (ii) Take A € a (AB); then N = ker(A'B'-A) is invariant under A' 7r and B'. If A= 0 then a (A') or a (B') contains 0, so 0 € a (A)a (B). 1T 1T -1 7r 1T If A~ 0, then A' IN has the two sided inverse A B' IN. Choose a in 3cr(A'INl; then A/a E 3a(B'INl. But this implies that a € a7r(A' INl c a11 (A'), A/a E a (B' IN> c a (B'), giving in turn 1T 7r A = cdA/a) E a (A') .a (B') =a (A) .a (B). D 1T 1T 'If 7r
The duality between approximate point spectrum and approximate de feet spectrum mentioned above, gives the following 43
COROLLARY 3.5. If A, B € L(X) and AB (iJ a 5 (A+B) c cr 0 (A)+cr 0 (B). ( i i J a 0 (AB) c a 0 (A) • a 0 (B) •
BA, then
LEMMA 3.6. Let H be a Hitbert spaae and tet A (i) crn(LA) = cr 0 (RA) = at(A). (iiJ cr 0 (LA) = crn(RA) = ar(A).
E
L(H); then
PROOF. (i) Let A E a (A) =a. (A) 1 then there exists a sequence n ~ {xn}n=l of unit vectors such that 110.-A)xnll + 0 (n + ~>. It follows that II<X-LA) (xnexn) II= II (X-A)xn exnll = II<X-A)xnll + 0, so that A-LA cannot be bounded below. Hence,crt(A) c an(LA). Conversely, if A € an(LA), then there exists a sequence {Xn}n:l in L(H) such that 11Xn11 = 1 for all n = 1,2, ••• , and II<X-A)Xnll+ 0 (n _,. oo). For each n, choose yn E H such that 1 s 11Yn11 s 2 and 11Xnyn11 = llxnll = 1; then II<X-A) (Xn y n ) II + 0 (n + ~>, whence we conclude that A € a n (A). . It follows that at(A) = crn(LA). If X-RA is onto, then there exists B in L (H) such that (X-RA)B = B(X-A) = 1, so that XL cri(A). Hence, cr 0 (RA) ~ crt(A). Conversely, if X-A is left invertible and C(X-A) = 1, then (A-RA) ~
RC = R(X-A)RC = RC(X-A) = R1 = 1, i.e., ).-RA is right invertible, whence we conclude that a 0 (RA) c or (RA) c at (A) • Hence, a 0 (RA) =a R. (A) • The second statement follows by the same arguments. 0 From Theorem 3.4, Corollary 3.5 and Lemma 3.6, we immediately obtain the following COROLLARY 3.7. Let A, B € L(H); then (i) cr1T(TAB) c crt(A) -crr(B). (iiJ cr 0 (TAB) c crr(A) -crt(B). We shall see later (Section 3.1.4) that these inclusions are actu ally equalities.
3.1.3 Local one-side
resolvents in L(H)
LetT € L(H) and let n be an open subset of pr(T). A continuous function F:Q + L(HI satisfying the equations {;1.-T)F(A.) - 1 (A.
E
Q)
and F(A.)- F(Jl) = (Jl-A.)F(A.)F(Jl)
(A.,Jl
€
n)
will be called a right resotvent for T (defined on Q). It is completely apparent that such a function F is an analytic function defined on 44
derivative F' 0..) = -F 2 (A). Similarly, if t) is an open subset of p R. (T) and G: t) ... L (H) is a co~ tinuous function satisfying G(A) (A-T) = 1 (A E t)) and G(A)-G(~) = (~-A) G(A)G(~) (A,~ € t)), then G is called a left resolvent forT (defined on t1 clearly, G is analytic on t)). Moreover, if F(A) is a right resolvent forT* (defined on n t*), then G(A) = F(~)* is a left resolvent for T (defined on t)) • Q with
For any A {
€
~
pr(T),
E
pR.(T), we shall put
Rr(A,T) = (A-T)*[{A-T)(A-T)*J-l, RR.
(~
,T)
= [ (1J-T) * (~-T)] -1 (~-T) *.
(3 .1)
It is easily seen that Rr(.,T):pr(T) ... L(H) (RR.(.,T):p 1 (T) ... L(H)) is continuous on this domain and satisfies the equation (A-T)R (A,T) = r 1, >. E pr(T) (R 1 (~,T)(1J-T) = 1, ~ E p 1 (T), resp.). However, Rr(.,T) (R (.,T)) does not satisfy, in general, the resolvent equation, i.e., it is not a right (left, resp.) resolvent for T. THEOREM 3.8. LetT E L(H). Given E > 0, there e~ists a right resolvent for T defined on pF (T) npr (T) e~cept for an at most denumerable set S c pr(T) which does not accumulate in pr(T), such that
s
c
cap r (T)J £ ={A
€
cr:
distn,ap r (T)J s £}.
Applying the above theorem toT*, we obtain the following dual result. COROLLARY 3.9. LetT E L(H). Given E > 0, there e~ists a left re~ oZvent forT defined on pF(T)npR.(T) e~cept for an at most denumerable setS' c pR. (T) which does not accumulate in pR.(T), such that S' is included in [
LEMMA 3.10. Let T such that 0 closed.
€
€
L(Hl and Zet M be an invariant subspace ofT
Pre<TIM). Then ran TMi is closed if and only if ranT is
PROOF. Since 0 € Pre<TIM>, Pker(TIM>* will be a finite rank projection. Thus, if we write 45
N = {z < M.l:
Pker(TJM)*PMTz=O}
we haveN c M.l, dim (M.leN) <~and, consequently, ranT is closed if and only if T(M+N) is closed in H. This reduces our problem to showing that T(M+N) is closed
<=> 0
Observe that Pker(TJM)*PMTN we obtain that T(M+N)
TM+PM.1TN
c
On the other hand, given y
€
TM.1N
c
is closed.
implies that PMTM
c
TM, whence
TMM+TM.1N = TM+TM.1N.
M and z c N, we can choose y 0
€
M such
that TMyo = -PMTz, whence we obtain TMy+TM z = T(y+y 0 +z) € T(M+N). Henc~ we have the equality T(M+N) = TM+TM.1N, where the sum in the right side is orthogonal and TM is closed. It readily follows that T(M+N) is closed if and only if TM.1N is closed. 0 COROLLARY 3.11. LetT € L(H) be an operator with closed range and Zet M be an invariant subspace of T such that (TM) M and 0 belongs to pR.e(TM ). Then 0
€
pr(TM).
PROOF. Since T* has closed range and 0 € Pre(TM.L*), it follows from Lemma 3.10 that TM* has closed range. Moreover, since TM hasdense range, TM* must be injective, so that 0 € pR.(TM*); equivalently, 0 € Pr(TM). LEMMA 3.12. Let T
0 €
L(H) be an operator with closed range and Zet
M be an invariant subspace ofT such that ker T c M and 0 E pr(TM). Then 0 € pR. (TM.1l and the set {A € a:: ker(A-T) c M} is a neighborhood of the origin.
PROOF. Since ker T c M and TM is right invertible, 0 cannot be an eigenvalue of TM.l· Using Lemma 3.10 we see that ran TM.1 is closed and therefore 0 € pR.(TM.L) • For each A in the open set pR.(TM.L) and xA 0 = PM.L(A.-T)xA
€
ker(A.-T), we have
(A.-TN.L)PM.LXA.
Since A.-TM.L is injective, it follows that PM.1xA. = 0, i.e., xA. conclude that pR. (TM ) c {A. c «:: ker(A.-T) c M}.
46
€
M. \'le 0
\' n ~ n ~ l·k=l ker{~k-T) = ker ITk=l{~k-T) .
PROOF. The inclusion 'c' is obvious and the converse inclusion is trivial for n = 1. We shall proceed by induction over n. Assume that we have n mk n ~ Lk=l ker{~k-T) ~ ker rrk=l{~k-T) and let .
~n+l.: crp{T)\{~1'~ 2 ,
G~ven
(~k-T)~ (k
.• ,~n} and mn+l be a natural number. n+l ~ mn+l n x.: ker ITk=l{A.k-T) , we have that {~n+l-T) x <: ker ITk=l
and, by our inductive assumption, we can find yk.: ker{Xk-Tfk
= 1,2, ... ,n)
m
such that (A.n+l-T) n+l x = Lk~l yk. Define
~-l -i-1 .)m 1 {~k-T)~J n+ Yk' xk = { Li=l {~n+l-~k) k
1, 2, ••• , n, and
follows.
0
LEMMA 3.14. Let T .: l(H) and Zet x e H be such that the set of ze roes of the function ~ + Pker(A.-T)x• has an accumuZation point r;; e pr(T); then Pker(A-T)x = 0, foP alZ A in the component Qr, of pr(T) aontaining the point 1;.
PROOF. Let a= {~ e Ql;: Pker(~-T)x = 0} and assume that a ~ Ql;. Since a has an accumulation point in Q , we can find ~ e Ql;naa and a I; sequence {~k}k=l c a such that ~k ~ ~. lim(k .... oo) ~k = ~Observe that A + Pker (~-T) = 1-Rr (~ ;T) (A-T) (where Rr (~;T) !s defined by (3.1)) is continuous at~- Thus, if M = V{ker(~k-T)}k=l' then ker(~-T) c M and therefore ran(~-TM) is closed. But ran(~-TM) is obviously dense; hence~ e pr(TM). Let Q0 ={A e Ql;: ker(A-T) c M}. By Lemma 3.12, Q0 is a neighborhood of ~. Since x .;. M , we see that Pker ( ~ -T) x = 0 for all X e 1!0 , co!! tradicting the assumption that~ E aa. This implies that a Ql; andthe proof is complete. 0 00
47
LEMMA 3.15. LetT e L(H), x e
Hand~
e pr(T) ~e suah that
Pker(~,;-T)k
x= 0. for all k = 1,2, ••• , then Pker(A-T)x = 0 for aZZ A in the component 0~ of pr(T) containing 1;.
PROOF. Let M = V{ker(!;-T)k}k:l. Since 1,;-T is surjective, we see k+l that (1;-T)ker(~-T) c ker(~;-T)k (k = 0,1,2, ••• ), so that ran(~-TM) is dense. On the other hand, ker(~,;-T) c M. Hence, ran(~-TM) is closed andit follows that 1,; e pr(TM). Since X e M , it follows from Lemma 3.12 that the set no= {A e n~ : ker(A-T) c M} is a neighborhood of 1,;, and therefore Pker(A-T)x = 0 (A e n0 ). By Lemma 3.14, Pker(A-T)x = 0 for all A in 0~· 0 PROPOSITION 3.16. LetT e L(H) and Let a be a compact subset of pr(T)ncrp(T); then there exists x in H such that Pker(A-T)x f 0 for aLL A e cr. h
PROOF. Let {ni}i=l be the components of pr(T) having nonempty intersection with o and set cri =crnni. For each i (i = 1,2, ••• ,h), we choose ~i e cri and yi e ker(~i-T), yi f 0. Then it is possible to find non-zero complex numbers ai(i = 1,2, ••• ,h) such that the vector y = L·hl a.y. satisfies Pk ( T)y f 0, i = 1,2, ••• ,h. 1= 1 1 er ~iLet {).={A e cr: Pker(A-T)y=O}. If /:,.={6, we take x=y. If{). f {6, we can apply Lemmas 3.14 and 3.15 in order to show that /:,. is a finite set, /:,. = {Ak}k~l and that there exists natural numbers {mk}k~l such that On the other hand, since By Lemma 3.13, y n mk n ran{ II k=l (A k -T) } * is closed, we can find x e H such that y ={IIk=l (Ak-T)mk}* x. Assume that Pker(~-T)x = 0 for some ~ e crk then x = (~-T)*z for some z e Hand therefore y = (~-T)*{IIk~l(Ak-T) k}* x. But this is impo~ sible: if~ f Ak (for all k = 1,2, ••. ,n), we have Pker(~-T)y = 0; if ID'+l 1 } • In either ~=A· (for some j, 1 ~ j ~ n), then y e {ker(A.-T) J J J case, this contradicts our assumptions on y. 0 LEMMA 3.17. LetT e L(H), and Let n 1 be a component ofpr(T)such that nul(A-T) 1, A e n1 • Fo~ any £ > 0 there exists a right resoLvent R of T on n1 except for an at most denumerabLe set s1 , which does not accumuZate in n1 , and satisfies s1 c ran 1 J£.
=
PROOF. By Lemmas 3.14 and 3.15 and Proposition 3.16, there exists 48
a vector y E H such that Pker{A.-T)y f 0 for all A. E n 1 \s 1 , where s 1 is an at most denumerable subset which does not accumulate in n1 and such that sl c canlJ£. (Take 0 = {A. E Ql: dist[A.,an 1 J ~ £}, in Proposition 3.16.) Fix A. 0 E n 1 ,s 1 and let z be a non-zero vector in ker(A. 0 -T). If R0 is a fixed right inverse of A0 -T, then any right inverse of A. 0 -T is of the form Rt = R +zet, where t E H. Choose t
0
= -
-1
R~y
(Since Pker (A. a-T) y f 0, it readily follows
that f 0, so that t i s well-defined.): then =
{z~t) *y ,x> =
-1
R~y ,x>
0
for all x in H, so that y L ran Rt. For A E nl the following identity holds: (A.-T) Rt = ( {A.-A. 0 ) Rt+1) • -1
This shows that A.~ -(A.-A. 0 ) is a mapping from n 1 into the camp~ nent of pF(Rt) which contains the point at infinity. Also, for A. E n 1 , the Fredholm index of {A-A 0 )Rt+l is zero. Suppose thatker[{A 1 -A 0 )Rt+l] f {0} for some A. 1 E n 1 ,s 1 • Then it follows from the above identitytha~ for some x f 0, (A. 1 -T)Rtx = 0. In this case, Rtx E ker(A. 1-T) and since the last space is one-dimensional, ker ( A. 1 -T) c ran Rt. This contradicts ran Rt and Pker(Al-T)y f 0. It readily follows that the operator (A.-A 0 )Rt+l is invertible for all A. in n 1 ,s 1 • The operator valued function
y
E
R(A.) = Rt((A.-Ao)Rt+l]-1 is a right resolvent forT in n 1 \S 1 • This completes the proof. D LEMMA 3.18. Let T E L{H) and let Qn be a aomponent of pr(T) suah that nul (A.-T) = n, A. E Qn. Foro any £ > 0, there exists a right resolvent F ofT on Qn exaept foro an at most denumerable set Sn, whiah does not
accumulate on nn, and satisfies sn
c
cannJ£.
PROOF. We proceed by induction on n. The result is clear if n = 0, for then nn is a component of the resolvent set p(T) ofT (and F(A) = (>.-T) -l, A. E Qn) and the case n = 1 is contained in the preceding lemma. Suppose the result has been obtained in the case n = k-1. Let Qk be a component of pr(T) such that nul(A.-T) = k, A. E nk. It follows from Pr~ position 3.16 that for any £ > 0 there exists a vector y E H for which Pker(A.-T)y f 0, for all A E Qk\S', where S' is an at most denumerable set which does not accumulate in nk and satisfies S' c cankJ£. Let MA = ker(A.-T)n{y}L, for A E nk' and let M = V{MA}AEnk· Obviously, M is invariant under T and relative to the decomposition H = MGlM.L, 49
T [TM A ) • 0
T
1
M
It is easy to establish that A-TM is onto for A " Qk and clearly (A-TM ... ) is onto for A € Qk. It follows that for A " nk \S', nul ( >..-TM) k-1 and nul(A-TM.d = 1. By Lemma 3.17 and our inductive hypothesis TM has a right resolvent R(A) on Qk\S' and TM1 has a right resolvent G(>..) on Qk\S", where S" is a (possibly empty) finite or denumerable subset of Qk which does not accumulate on ~ and satisfies S" c [oQk]c· Define F (A) = (
R( >..)
0
(with respect to the above decomposition), where Sk = S'uS". It is eas ily seen that F(A) is a right resolvent for T on Qk\Sk' sk is at most denumerable, Sk does not have any accumulation point in Qk and Sk c rankJc·
o
PROOF OF THEOREM 3.8. Clearly, it suffices to define a right resolvent F on each component of pr(T), except for an at most denumerable subset S with the desired properties. Let n be a component of pr(T) such that nul(A-T) =n(n) ~ 0, A" n. I f n(Q) =0, then n c p(T) and the only possible definition for F is F(A) = (A-T)-l =the resolvent of T restricted to n~This is true, in particular, for the unbounded component of pr(T).) If 1 $ n(Q) < oo, then Q is a bounded component of pr(T). If Q intersects the compact set~= {A< pr(T)\p(T): dist[A,apr(T)] ~ c}, then we define F on Q\S(Q), where S(Q) is an at most denumerable subset of n which does not accumulate in n and satisfies S(Q) c Can> £ by using Lemma 3.18. If Qn~ = ~, then we can use the same arguments as in that lemma in order to construct a right resolvent F on Q\S(Q),where S(Q) is an at most denumerable subset which does not accumulate in Q (the condition S(Q) c Q c Can) is trivially satisfied in this case). £ It is completely apparent that this defines a right resolvent for Ton pr(T)\S, where S = u{S(Q): n is a component of pr(T)\p(T)} is an at most denumerable subset of pr(T) with the desired properties.o
3.1.4 The left and the right spectra of tAB THEOREM 3.19. Let A, B" L(H); then (i) a 6 (TAB) = crr(TAB) = crr(A)- aR, (B). (iiJ cr'lf(TAB) = aR,(tAB) = aR,(A) -crr(B).
50
PROOF. (i) By Corollary 3.7 and our observations at the beginmng of Section 3.1.2, cr~(TAB) c crr(A) -cr.R.(B) and cr~(TAB) c crr(TAB). Assume that \J E crr(A)- cr.R.(B) (i.e., \J can be written as \J =.a-a, where a E crr(A) and a E ot(B)) and that TAB-\J is onto. Then, given C ~ L(H), there exists X E L(H) such that (TAB-\J) (X) =TA-a,B-a(X) = (A-a)X -X(B-a) =c. Since ran(TAB-\J) is closed, there is a constant m > 0 such that II(TAB-\J) (Tlll ~ m dist[T,ker(TAB-\J) ], for all T in L(H). In parti£ ular, X= X(C) can be chosen so that (m/2liiXII :;;; IICII. Since a E or(A) and 8 E ot(B), we can find unit vectors x, yin H such that II = IICII; for this C and X=X(C) chosen as above, we have 0 < IICII = = <(TAB-JJ) (X)y,x> = <[ (A-a)X-X(B-a) ]y,x> s I<Xy,(A-a)*x>I+I<(B-S)y,X*x>l s (2/m>llciHIIylll < llcll, a contradiction. We conclude that o~(TAB) =or(A) -o.R.(B) c or(TAB). Assume that \J t ar(A) -a.R.(B); equivalently, or(A-j.i)nat(B) =,. Since crr(A-\J) and a.R.(B) are nonempty,compact, and disjoint, there exists Cauchy domains QA' n8 and Q such that crr(A-\J) c QA c (QA)- c Q, aR,(B) c n8 and (Q8 )-nQ- = ,. It follows from [1], [2] (see also [185]) that there exists an analytic function RA-\J (A) defined on pr (A-\J) such that (A-j.i-A)RA-j.I(A) 1 on this domain. (If ~\QA c pF(A-j.i), then we can choose RA -j.l (A) as the right resolvent constructed in Theorem 3.B.);sim ilarly, there exists an analytic function La(A) defined on p.R.(B) (If ~\QB c pF(B), then we can choose L8 (A) as the left resolvent given by Corollary 3.9.) such that L8 (A) (B-A) = 1 on this domain. Clearly, RA-\J and L8 are analytic in a neighborhood of an.Let n0 be a component of Q. Since aR, (B) nQ- = ,, it follows from Cauchy's theo rem that fan L8 (A) dA = o.
=
0
A fortiori,
Let a•n =
and 2;i
fan RA-~(A)dA
= 2;i
Given Yin L[H),
fa•nRA-~(A)dA
1.
let -1
~(Y) =X= 2 wi
f
an
RA-~(A)YLB(A)dA.
It is completely apparent that ~ defines a bounded linear mapping from L[H) into itself. l'le shall verify that~ is a right inverse for TAB-~· Indeed, . (TAB-~) (X) = (A-~)X-XB = -1
2wi
f an(A-~)RA-~(A)YLB(A)dA+
1
2wi fanRA-~(A)YLB(A)BdA
= -1 2wi f ao(A-~-A)RA-~(A)YLB(A)dA+ (TAB-~) o~
f aORA-~(A)YLB(B-A)dA
2 !i(fanRA-~(A)dA)Y = Y,
;;i YfaoLa(A)dA+ i.e.,
21wi
=
1 on L [H). Hence, ar (TAB) c ar (A) -a R. (B) and the proof of (i) is complete. (ii) By Corollary 3.7 and our observations at the beginning of Section 3.1.2, aw(TAB) c aR. (A)- ar(B) and aw(TAB) c aR. (TAB). Assume that~" aR.(A)-ar(B), i.e.,~= a-13 for some a ( aR.(A)and some f3 "ar(B). This means that, given € > 0, we can find unit vectors x, yin H such that II
= II TA-a,B-B (xey)
II
= II
(A-a) (x8y) - (xey) (B-13) II
II (A-a)x 8y-x8(B-f3)*yl! ~ I!
Since € can be chosen arbitrarily small, we conclude that TAB-II is not bounded below, i.e., JJ " aw (TAB). It readily follows that aw('A~ = aR. (A)- ar(B) c aR. (TAB). Now assume that aR.(A-~)nar(B) = 9 and let tA' tB and t be three Cauchy domains such that aR.(A-~) c tA c (tA) c t, ar(B) c tB and (t~ nt- = 9. By [1], [2](see also [185], Theorem 3.8 and Corollary 3.9), there exist an analytic function Ra(A) defined on pr(B) and an analytic function LA-~(A) defined on pR.(A-~), such that (B-A)Ra(A) :1 for all A in pr(B) and LA-~(A) (A-A) 1 for all A in pR.(A-~). Proceeding as in the last part of the proof of (i), we can easily check that
=
1
~(Y) = 2wi
defines a left inverse of aR. (A)- ar(B).
fat
LA-~(A)YRa(A)dA
TAB-~·
It readily follows that aR.(TAB)
From Theorem 3.19 and its proof, we obtain 52
0
c
COROLLARY 3.20 (Rosenblum's theorem). If A, BE L(H), then (i) cr(TAB) = cr(A) -a(B); (iiJ If l.l I a (A) -a (B), then there ereists a Cauohy domain n suah that a(A-}.1) c n, a(B)nrl = ~ and
(TAB-}.1) By taking A obtain
-1
(X)
0 or B
0 in Theorem 3.19 and using Lemma 3.6, we
COROLLARY 3.21. If A E L(H), then ar(LA) = a 6 (LA) a 1 (RA) = cr~(RA) = crr(A). (ii) a 1 (LA) = cr~(LA) = crr(RA) = cr 6 (RA) = cr 1 (A). (i)
3.1.5 Rosenblum-Davis-Rosenthal corollary The following is the most important consequence of Theorem 3.19 for the purposes of approximation. COROLLARY 3.22. Let H1 and H2 be two Hilbert spaoes, Zet L(H 1 ), BE L(H 2 J and C E L(H 2 ,H 1 ) and assume that ar(A)na 1 (B)
A E =~.Then
the operators ( Ao
(aating on H
=
Be)
and
AIBB
H119H 2 .J are similar.
PROOF. Assume that H1 and H2 are infinite dimensional then we can identify them via a unitary mapping of H1 onto we can directly assume that H1 = H2 = H0 and H = H0 (2 ) • By (i), TAB is onto and therefore there exists X E L(H 0 ) such =-c. Then (:
and
(~ ~)
is invertible
~) (~ ~) ([~ ~)-l
Hence, AIBB =
spaces;
H2 , i.e., Theorem 3.19 that AX-XB
(~ ~) ~)
=
(:
=
(~ -~)).
(10 1X) -l (A0 BC) (10 X)1 .
If A acts on a finite dimensional space and B acts on an infinite dimensional space, define a = IIAIHIBI~l and consider the operators alBA e L!H 2tH 1 J, B and C'=(g) E L!H 2 ,H 2mH 1 ). It follows from the first part of the proof that 53
[ ~ ~ ~]
-
(aeA)eB
ae(AeB).
0 0 B
Assume that W
then {ae
(:~)}w-w[ae(AeB)J=~~~-
~ -:~~~-~ 1 ~<~•~>-
0 - --
-]=
l(o B)w21-w2la (o B)w22-w22(AeB)
o,
1
so that aw 12 -w12 (AeB) = 0 and r~ ~)w 21 -w 21 q = 0. Since cr (a) ncr ( (~ ~)) c cr (a) n[cr (A) ucr (B)] = cr (a) ncr (AeB)
= $§,
it readily follows from Corollary 3. 20 that w12 = 0 and w21 = 0. Hence W= w11ew 22 , w11 and w22 are invertible operators, and (consider the (2,2)-entry of the above 2 x 2 matrix!) w22-l (: i.e., (:
~)
~)
w22 = AeB,
is similar to A8B.
The cases when H2 is finite dimensional and H1 is infinite dimensional or both, H1 and H2 are finite dimensional spaces can be similar ly analyzed to reach the same conclusion: ( Ao
Be) - AeB.
0
3.1.6 The maximal numerical range of an operator It was observed in Section 3.1.1 thati~ABII s min{IIA->.If+liB->.11: ). E ~}. In order to complement our previous results about 'AB' it will be shown that this inequality is actually an equality. The concept of mazimaZ numeriaaZ range of an operator plays a central role here. Recall that the numeriaaZ range of T E LfH) is the set defined by W(T)
=
{:
x
E
H, llxll
= 1}.
The classical Toeplitz-Hausdorff theorem ~sserts that W(T) is a convex set [119,Problem 166]. The maximal numerical range of T is the set
54
LEMMA 3.23.
w0 (T)
is a nonempty, aZosed, aonvex subset of W(T)-.
PROOF. Everything but convexity is obvious. Let A, J..l
t'
w0 (T).
Wit~
out loss of generality, we can assume that IITII =1. Let {xn}n:l' {yn}n:l be two sequences in H such that II xn II =II y n Ii = 1 for all n = 1, 2, ••• , ll!'xn II .. 1, ltl'Ynll .. 1, .. A and .. J.l (n + "'). Consider Tn = Pn TPn' where Pn is the projection of H onto Vfxn,yn} and let n be a pomt of the segment [A,J..l] joining A and J..l. Then for each n, it is possible, by the Toeplitz-Hausdorff theorem, to choose an' f3n such that = -+ n and II unll = 1, where un = anxn +f3nYn· Observe t:hat I <xn,yn>J s e < 1 and therefore max{Janl ,JenJ} s M= (1-62)-!:1 (otherwise ll'hxn+ f3nyJI < 1) for all n sufficiently large. We have 1
Jl!'u n IJ2 = = JJun IJ2 - < (1-T*T) U n ,un >
Since 2
IJ(l-T*T)xn ll=llxn 112 -2JI!'xn II +IIT*Tx n 112 2 = (1-JtJ.'x n 112 >- 11 2 > s 1-JI!'xn II .. 0 (n .. "') and, similarly, 11<1-T*T)ynJI + 0 (n + "'), we conclude that ll!'unll + 1 and -+ n (n +"').Therefore, w0 (T) is a convex set. 0 0 s
If A € L (H) , the operator 15 A= T AA is the innel' del'ivation of L (H) induced by A. 3.24. Let J..l
LEMMA
w0 (T), then IJ15TJI
E
2(11Til2 -IJ..l! 2 >!:1.
PROOF. Note that IliST II= supfll TA-AT II: A € L (H) , II Ail= 1}. Since J..l E € H such that llxnll=l, for all n=l,2, ••• , ltl'xJI IITII and -+ J..l. Set Tx n =a nn x +a nn y , where y n is a unit vector
w0 (T), there exist xn -+
orthogonal to xn. Set Vn = xn8xn- yn8yn; then II
2:
2(!1TII 2 -JanJ 2 >!:1-e:n, where e:n + 0 (n + "').
Since an-+ J.1 (n .. "'), the proof is complete. PROPOSITION 3.25. Let T (i)
0
€
L(H); then the foZZowing al'e equivalent
w0 (T);
li~ll=2ltrll; IITII 2 + IAJ 2 s IIT+Ail2 fol' aZZ A IITIJ s IJT+AII for aZZ A E a:.
(ii) (iii)
(iv) PROOF. then 114r11
€
2:
(ii) =>
0
(i) => (ii)
€
a:;
It follows from Lemma 3.24 that, if 0
2]1!'1J. Therefore, 11~11= 2lh:'ll· (i) If 114rll=211!'11, then there exist xn
€
Hand An
w0 (T),
€
€
L(H) 55
such that llxn11=11An11= 1 and II
11,
I t readily follows that IIAnn x II-+ l=IIAn I!Txn II-+ IITII and !ITAnn x II -+ II T II· Passing, i f necessary, to a subsequence, we can directly assume that -+ ~ and -+ y (n -+ 00 ) . Since IIAnn X II-+ 1 =llxrJ'I· nn ,Ann i t is completely apparent that ll, y e w0 (T) • Moreover, since II
n
xn II -+ 211 T II and H is uniformly convex, the norm of z to
o,
n
= TA x +A Tx tends n n n n n
as n -+ ""· Thus, we have
= - +
= - + n n nn where En -+ 0, as n -+ ""·
= - + n nn n n
£
n
,
(Indeed, i t follows as in the last step of the
proof of Lemma 3.24 that IIAn*Anxn -xnll-+ 0, as n-+ oo.) Thus, y = lim(n -+ oo) = -lim(n -+ oo) = -ll·
Since both that
and -ll belong to
ll
w0 (T),
i t follows from Lemma 3.23
o "w 0 (T). If 0 e
(i) => (iii)
w0 (T),
then there exists a sequence {xn}n:l
of unit vectors such that
for all A e
a:.
(iv) => (i)
Assume that IITII s IIT+AII for all A "
By rotating T, we may assume that lle
w0 (T)
= 1, lle s c/2} and let M=supfiiTxll: Let ll = min{c/2,
I M,
"M,
a:,
but 0
I w0 (T).
~ c > 0. Let M={xeH:
llxll
x eM}; then M < IITII· then II
llxll= 1, let Tx = (a+ib)x+y, where y
.l
x; then
II ll > 0. Thus, II T-llll <
II T II,
contrary to the hypothesis.
Since (iii) => (iv) is a trivial implication, we are done.O THEOREM 3.26. LetT " L(H); then II6TII= 2 min{IIT-AII:
A "
PROOF. We have already observed that II6T II s 2 inf{ll T-A II:
a:). A " a:}.
By an elementary argument of compactness (observe that liT-All-+ ""• as IAI -+ oo), i t is easily seen that the above infimum is actually attained at some point ll " II
a:, " a:
i.e., this infimum is a minimum. But IIT-llll s implies that II6TII = 116 (T-ll)ll = 2 IIT-llll·
{iv) => (ii) .)
3.1.7 The norm of the operator TAB
56
(Use
0
LEMMA 3. 27. Let T continuous.
L (H) • The mapping X +
£
w0 (T+A) is
uppezo semi-
PROOF. We can assume, without loss of generality, that II T II = 1. Suppose that i.e w0 (T) s a and let e: > 0. Let f~ = sup{ll Ax II: II x II = 1, i.e ~ a+e:}; then M < 1. It is clear thatiiT+AII ~ 1-IXI. However, for y £ H, IIYII = 1 and l.e ~ a+e:, we see that II. 0 £ ~). Hence, w0 (T+X 0 ) coincides with the intersection of all the open halfplanes containing it. Thus, we can find finitely many open halfplanes sl' s2'"""' sm such that
w0 (T+X 0 )e:
m
nj=l Sj
c
c
w0 (T+X 0 ) 2e:.
By the first part of the proof, we can find o that
w0 (T+A)E
c
m
nj=l Sj
c
W0 (T+A 0 ) 2e:
provided I A - X0 I < o• Hence, X + w0 (T+X) is an upper semicontinuous mapping.
D
We define the nozomalized maximal numezoical zoange WN(T) of an ope~ ator T £ L(H), T ~ O, to be the set w0 (T/IITII>· From Lemma 3.27 we obtain the following COROLLARY 3.28. If IIT+AII is upper> semicontinuous.
LEMMA 3.29. Let A, B following azoe equivalent (i)
(ii)
E
~ 0
foro aZZ X, then the map X+ WN(T+A)
L(H) be two non-zeroo operoatozos; then the
11-rABII = IIAII+JIBI~ WN(A)nWN(-B) ~ ~.
PROOF. The proof is very similar to that of Proposition 3.25 (i) => (ii), and so we shall only sketch a portion. Let A£ WN(A)nWN(-B) and e: > 0; then there exist x, y £ H such that llxll = IIYII = 1 and = ~IAI~e:A and = -~IBI~e: 8 , 0 s e:A' e:B < e:. Since J11AII = -<sy,y>/IIBI~e:', it is possible to define an operator U of norm l+e:" which sends x to y
and -By/liB II to AxJ11AII<where e:', e:" are small if e: is small). The rest of the proof is virtually unchanged. D 57
LEMMA 3.30. Assume that A. B ar multiple of the identity. Then min{IIA-:l.II+I!B-:l.ll:
if and only if WN(A-).I)nWN(-(B-).1))
LIHI and neither A nor B is a saal
€
:l.
€
~
a:}= IIA-J.I!I+I!B-J.III 9.
PROOF. Assume that WN (A-J.I) nWN (- (B-Il) ) ~ 9. Then Itr"AB II = liT A-ll , B-).111 = II A-IJII + IIB-Illl • Since it is obvious that ltr" AB II cannot be larger than min{I!A-:l.II+I!B-:l.ll: ). € a:}, we see that the condition is necessary. In order to prove the sufficiency, we can directly assume that J.1 = 0. Thus, given ). € a: and £ > 0, there exist unit vectors x, y in H such that IIIA+:l.)xii+II(B+:l.)yjj /IIAII+/IIBII> s Kll:l.l 2+£), where K is a constant independent of). and£. Assume that WN(A)nWN(-B) = 9. Then, dH[WN(A) ,~7N(-B)] = cS > 0, and (by upper semicontinuity; Corollary 3.28) dH[WN(A+:l.) ,WN(-B-:l.)J > cS/2, for ). small. Thus, by convexity and upper semicontinuity, any choice of x, y which satisfies the above conditions, must satisfy the inequal ity j<(A+:l.)x,x>/IIAHII+<(BH)y,y>/IIBHIII:t cS/4 for:>.. small. But thenw~ are led to the inequality j:l.jcS/8 s K!:>..l 2 for a suitable choice of arq:>.. and l :>..I small, which is impossible. Thus, J.l = 0 was not minimal, which completes the proof. 0 THEOREM 3.31. Let A. BE L(H); then ltr" AB II = min{ll A-"11 + 1~-:>..11 :
:l. E a:}·
PROOF. Clearly, ltr"ABII s min{IIA-:l.H+IIB-:l.ll: :l. € a:}. I f A orB is a multiple of the identity, the rest of the proof is trivial. Let ll £ a: be any point such that the above minimum is attained at J.l• By Lemmas 3. 29 and 3. 30, liT AB II = ltr" A-ll ,B-ll II = II A-JJif-t- II B-J.III • The proof is complete now.
0
REMARK 3.32. It is completely apparent from Proposition 3.25(iii) that there exists exactly one J.1 E a: such that II T-JJ II = min £11 T- :>..II : ;\. E a:}. However, simple examples show that, in general, the J.1 of Lemma 3. 30 is not unique.
3.2 Generalized Rota's universal model Let T £ L (H) •. Since o(T) is a compact set, it has a fundamental system of open neighborhoods which are analytic Cauchy domains (i.e., Cauchy domains whose boundaries consists of pairwise disjoint regular 58
analytic Jordan curves: see definition in Section 1.1). Let r =an, where Q is an analytic Cauchy domain containing a(T), and let L2 (r) be the Hilbert space of (equivalent classes of) complex functions on r which are square integrable with respect to (l/2nrtimes the arc-length measure on r: M(r) will stand for the "multiplication by A" operator acting on L2 (r). The subspace H2 (r) spanned by the rational functions with poles outside n- is invariant under f1(r). By M+(r) and M_(r) we shall denote the restriction of M(r) to H2 (r) and its compression to L2 (r)eH 2 (r), respectively, i.e. M(r)
(
M+(r)
o
)H 2 (r) M_ L2 (r)eH 2 Z
( 3. 2)
with respect to the above decomposition.(Here and in what follows, we write
( 3. 3)
A
as an alternative way to indicate that A admits such a k x k operator k matrix decomposition with respect to the orthogonal direct sum H = ej=l Hj , where Aij:Hj ~ Hi' 1 ~ i,j s k. Such a decomposition is clearly unique.) It is well-known [36], [73], [74,Sections 9] that H2 (r) is areproducing kernel space and that it can be realized as a space of analytic functions defined on n: furthermore, it can be easily checked that a(M(r)) =aJM(r)) =ae(M+(r)) =ae(M_(r)) =r, a(M+> = a(M_(r)) = n-, nul(A-M+(r)) =nul(A-M_(r))*=O and ind(A-M+(r)) ind (A-M_ (r)) * = -1 for all A in
( 3. 4)
Q,
M(r) is normal and l!r(M(r))l! =llr(M+(r))ll =llr<~_(r))ll = max{lr(A)l: A e: for each rational function r with poles outside n-.
Q}
The Hilbert space completion H2 (r)8H of the algebraic tensor pro~ uct of H2 (r) and H can be regarded as a space of analytic H-valued functions defined on n, or as a space of (equivalent classes of) weakly measurable square integrable functions on r, in which case it will 59
also be denoted by H2(r:H). THEOREM 3.33. LetT E L(H) and 0 be as above, and let R =ran (M+(r)81-18T); then R is a subspaae of H2 (r:H) invariant under M+(r)&l, the restriation of M+(r)&l to R is similar to M+(r)&l and the aompression of M+(r)el to R~ is similar to T. PROOF. Since M+(r)el-l&T is equal to multiplication by X-T in 2 H Cr:H) and X-T is invertible on r, it is clear that R is closed. Mar~ over, the similarity of f1+(r)81 and M+(r>&ljR is implemented byH+(r)~n18T. All we have to do is find an operator L:H 2 (r:H) + H with range H and kernel R such that Lo(M~r)&l) = ToL. We shall define for f E H2 (r: H) the element Lf E H by 1
2 ~i
Lf
f ao(X-T) -1
f(X) dX.
It is easily seen that Lo(M+(r)&l) Lo(l8T) = ToL, so that R c ker L. On the other hand, if fx(A) = x (x E H), then Lfx x, so that ran L is equal to H. Let o 1 be an analytic Cauchy domain containing 0 such that the restrictions of functions analytic in a neighborhood of o 1 to r are dense in H2 (r) (By Runge's approximation theorem, it suffices to choose o 1 so that every bounded component of ~\0 contains a component of ~\ n 1 > and let e (X) = 1, e c H2 (r). 0 2 0 Lets E L(H (r:H)) be the operator defined by Sf= f-e&Lf. Since Lf = L(e9Lf), it follows that ran s = ker L. Thus, in order to complete the proof, it will be sufficient to show that S(flr> E. R for every Hvalued function f analytic in a neighborhood of o 1 . Because of the analyticity of (X-T)-lf(A) in a neighborhood of o;>n' we have Lf = 2 1~i It follows that for cs
I; E
f anl
(X-T) -1 f(X) d)..
0
1 2dfaol [ (A-1;)-l- (X-T)-lJf(X) dX
( r-T)
..
l
2~i
fan
(A-1;)-l(X-T)-l f(X) dX. 1
Since fanl (X-1;)-l(X-T)-l f(X) dX is an analytic function of 1; (1; c o 1 ), it readily follows that s = CM+Cr>el-l&T)( 2 fa 01 <x-c>- 1 <X-T>- 1 f(X) dx) cR. The proof is complete now. 0
!:L
REMARK 3. 34. According to the proof of Theorem 3. 33, the diagram
60
H -----=T:___ _ _ H
is commutative, i.e., T = (LIRL)-loT 1 a(LIRL). Since Lfx = x (where fx (A) :: x, x E H), it follows that Ll RL is bounded below by . inf{llfxll:
llxll =
1} =
([length(r)]/2-rr)~.
On the other hand, the Cauchy-Schwartz inequality implies that IlLII s ([ length(r) 1/2-rr) ~ max{ II< A-T) -11:
A
r},
E
so that (3.5) Let r be a rational function with poles outside Q
and let
B)R
T' RL'
where T' is similar to T1 then llrII s llr<M+(r)~H>II
=
llr<M+(r))ll
= max{lr(A)I:
A
E
r},
whence we obtain the following COROLLARY 3.35. (i) Given T E L(H) and a bounded open neighbo~ hood ~ of a(T), ~ is a spect~aL set (in the sense of von Neumann) fo~ some operator T' - T, i.e •• llrII s max{jr()..)"l:
A
E
i!J-}
fo~ aLL rational functions r ~ith poles outside ~-.
(iiJ In pa~ticular, if a(T) {0} and e > 0, then '1'' - T such that !IT'll < E and T sim O.
the~e e~ists
~~ 3.36. Let H = H1eH 2e .•• eHk and assume that A E LIH) admits an upper triangular operator matri~ ~ith respect to this decompositio~ i.e .•
61
All Al2 Al3 A22 A23 A33
.Al,k-lAlk .A2,k-1A2k .A3,k-1A3k
Hl H2 H3
A 0
~-~k-h-l.k Hk-1 Hk ~k
then A s!m All$A22$A33e ••• e~-l,k-le~k· PROOF. Let wn = nen 2en 3e ••• enk-1 enk (w1.. th respect to the same decomposition). Clearly, W is invertible with inverse w -l=n- 1 en- 2en- 3 -k+l -k n n e ••• en en , and a straightforward computation shows that
IIWnAWn- 1 -·j~l Ajjll s [n- 1 +n- 2+ ..• +n-k+lJIIAII
+
0 (n +co). 0
It follows from (3.2) and Theorem 3.33 that MCr>el
=
(M+(r)91
o
Z91 )H 2 (r;H) M_Cr)el L2 cr>eHeH 2 Cr;H)
M+(r)&liR [
0
0
where
[:~)
z1 ]R T' z2 H2 (r;H)9R 0 M_(r)&l L2 (r)9HeH 2 (r;H)
B
= Z&l, M+(r)&liR - M+(r)&l and T' - T. Combining this obser
vation with Lemma 3.36, we obtain COROLLARY 3.37. Let T e L(H) and Zet n be an anaZytia Cauahy domain aontaining a(T) ~ith an = r; then MCr> s!m
M+(r)eM_Cr),
M(r)&l s!m (M+(r)el)e(M_Cr)el),
l4(r)91 sim (M+(r)9l)eTe(M_(r)91) and l1+(r)91 s!m (M+(r)8l)eT.
3.3 Apostol's triangular representation r
Given T e L(H), let H (T) = V{ker(~-T): ~ e Ps-F(T)}, let H.(T) r r ,. V{ker(~-T)*: ~ e ps-F(T)} and let H0 (T) be the orthogonal complement of Hr(T)+Ht(T). Denote the compression ofT to Hr(T), Ht(T) and H0 (T) by Tr' Tt and T0 , respectively. Recall that A e L(H) is a t~ian guZa~ operator if it admits an upper triangular matrix; i.e.,
62
all al2 al3 a22 a23 a33
A
(3. 6)
0
with respect to a suitable ONB. Apostol's triangular representation and its basic properties are established in the following THEOREM 3.38. (i)
Hr(T) is orthogonal to Ht(T), so that {3.7)
H = Hr{T)SH 0 {T)SHt{T).
(ii) Hr{T) and Hr{T)SH 0 (T) are invariant under T, so that Tadmits a 3 x 3 upper triangular operator matrix representation {3. 8)
T
with respect to the above decompostion, ~here (iii) Tr = TIHr(T) is a triangular operator, o{Tr) = ot{Tr) = aire{Tr)u[pr(Tr)\p{Tr)], a{Tr) is a_perfect set, every compon:nt of oire{Tr) intersects the set op{Tr) and op(T;> = ~. so that ps-F{Tr) ~and min.ind(A-Tr) = 0 for all A € ps-F{Tr)• and (iv) Tt is the adjoint in L(Hi(T)) of the triangular operator
T*IHt(T), o{Tt) = or{Tt) = otre{Tt)u[pt(Tt)\p(Tt)], o(Tt) is a perfect set, every component of otre{T{) intersects the set op(Ti)- and op{Tt) ~. so that p:_F(Tt) = 9 and min.ind{A-Tt) = 0 for all A € ps-F(Tt). Furthermore, (v) A~ Pker{A-T) (A € Ps-F(T)J is a continuous function for A € prs- F(T) and discontinuous for A € pss- F(T); ps-F{T) c pr{Tr)npt(Tt); (vii) Pi-F(T) c p{T0 ) ; (viii) p:_F(T) c o 0 {T0 ); (ix) a 0 lT) c p{Tr)np(Tt)no 0 {T0 ); (x) If A= {A 1 ,A 2 , ••• ,Am} is a finite subset of p:_F(T), then TN TASTA, ~here TA acts on a finite dimensional subspace, o{TA) =A (Vi)
and A
c
p~-F{TA).
We shall need several auxiliary results. LEMMA 3.39. If B
€
L(H), A
€
o{B) and II
Mllxll
for aZZ x
€
63
fl,
then IIA- Bll ;;, M for every triangular operator A.
PROOF. Assume that A has an upper triangular matrix of the form n n= n be the orthogonal projec tion of fl onto V{e 1 ,e 2 , ••• ,en} and let y be a unit vector orthogonal to ran(A-B) (so that (A-B)*y = 0); clearly, PnAPn = APn. Given e:, 0 < e: < 1, there exists n 0 = n 0 (e:) such that 11Pn (A-B) *y II < e: for all n;;, n 0 • Pn(A-B)*Pn can be regarded as an operator acting on the finite dimensional space Mn =ran Pn. It follows from the finite dimensionality of Mn that this subspace contains a unit vector zn such that II[P n (A-B)*P n J*z n II= liD l'"n (A-B)P n z n II< e:. ~1e have Pn z n = z n , and (3.6) with respect to the ONB {e } ~ 1 • Let P
IIA-BII;;, lim inf(n
~>
11<1-Pn) (A-B)Pnll
+ ~>
11<1-Pn) 0,-B)Pnll
+
2:
lim inf(n
2:
lim inf(n ....
ao)
2:
lim inf (n ....
ao)
?:
M-e:.
11 (1-P n ) (A-B)P n z n II
Since e: can be chosen arbitrarily small, we conclude that IIA- Bll 2:
M.
0
COROLLARY 3.40. If A is a triangular operator with matrix (3.6) with respect to the ONB {en}n:l. then (i) a(A) =aR. (A) = aR.re(A)uap(A); (ii) Every clopen subset of a(A) intersects d(A) = {ann}n:l and every component of a(A) intersects d(A)-; (iii) Every isolated point of a(A) belongs to d(A); (iv) If ker(A-A)* ~ {0}, then A " d(A). PROOF. (i) The equality a. (A)= a. (A)ua (A) is trivial. On the ... ..re p other hand (since A is triangular) Lemma 3. 39 implies that a (A) =a 1 (A). (ii) Let a 0 be a clopen subset of o (A) such that a 0 nd (A) = 11 and let Q be a Cauchy domain containing d(A) such that a0 nn- = 11. It is eas ily seen that, if 1
E = 2ni
fan
(A-A)
-1
dA,
then Een =en for all n = 1,2, •••• Since E is an idempotent and ran E => V { e n }n= "" 1 = fl, it readily follows that a 0 = 11. Since a(A) is a compact Hausdorff space, every component of a(A) is the intersection of all the clopen subsets containing it. Let a bea component of a(A) and let {a : a " A} be the family of all clopen su~ a sets of a(A) containing a. It follows from the first part of the proof that aand(A) # 11 for all a in A. A fortiori, and(A) = (nao;A aalnd(A)-= 64
na£A[aand(A)-J ~ 9 (by an obvious argument of compactness). (ill) This is a trivial consequence of (ii). (iv) Assume that (A-A) *y = 0 for some ). £ a (A) and some unit vector y £ H; then 0 = <{).-A)*y,en> = ' for all n = 1,2, ••• ,
so that y J. {).-A)Mn' where Mn = v£e 1 ,e 2 , .•. ,en}' for all n = 1,2, •••• If"'). I d(A), then {).-A)Mn=Mn (n = 1,2, ••• ) and therefore y J. V{Mn}n=l = H; so that, y = 0, a contradiction. Hence, ). € d(A). 0 PROPOSITION 3.41. LetT£ L(H) Q
and~
£ Pn-F(T); then
lim{). ~ ~) Pker{).-T)
exists (in the norm topoZogy). Q is the orthogonaZ projection onto ker (~-T)n{nn:l ran(~-T)n}.
PROOF. Assume first that ~-Tis onto. By Corollary 1.14(v), ).-T is onto for all ). in some neighborhood Q of ~· It follows that Pker {).-T) = 1-Rr 0. ,T) {).-T) (where Rr {). ,T) is defined by (3.1), ). £ g) converges in t~e norm to 1- Rr{).,T) {).-T) = Pker{).-T) as A ~ ~· Put M= nn:l ran (~-T) n. Because (~-T) is semi-Fredholm, M is closed (i.e., is a subspace) and (~-T)M = M. Hence (~-TM)M = M. For). ~~clearly (~-T)ker{).-T)=ker().-T) and so ker{).-T) c M. I t follows that p
=p
p
ker().-T) ker{).-TM) M and the first paragraph shows that this has the desired limit.
D
COROLLARY 3.42. LetT£ L(H) and~ £ Ps-F(T). The foZZowing cond£ tions are equivaZent (i) ~is a reguZar point of Ps-F(T). (ii)
Pker{).-T) is continuous
at).=~·
PROOF. (i) => (ii) If nul{).-T) is a finite constant in some neig~ DO borhood of~ then Corollary 1.14(vi) shows that ker{).-T) c nn=l ran {).-T)n. By Proposition 3.41, Pker{).-T) is continuous at ). = If nul{).-T)* is a finite constant in a neighborhood ollary 1.14(vi) shows that DO n ker(~-T)* c nn=l ran(~-T)* CLAIM:
Since
~· of~
then Cor (3.9)
is semi-Fredholm, (3.9) is equivalent to DO n (3.10) ker(~-T) c nn=l ran(~-T) • DO n Indeed, if ker(~-T) c nn=l ran(~-T) , then ~-T
65
1, 21 • • • •
then y= (~-T)*y 1 for some y 1 E H. There-1 [{y}] ~ ~. so that y = (~-T)* 2y fore ran(~-T)* J J (~-T)* 2 3 -2 for some y 2 E H and ran(~-T)* J ker(~-T)* J (~-T)* [{y}] ~ ~By induction, there exists y in H such that y = (U - T) * ny , n n n n = 1,2, .••. Hence, y E "n:l ran(~-T)*. This proves that (3.10) implies (3.9). The converse implication follows by taking adjoints. Thus, if y
E ker(~-T)*,
2 ker(~-T)*
Since (3.9) and (3.10) are equivalent, we conclude (as in the first part of the proof) that Pker(A-T) is continuous at A = U· (ii) => (i) If Pker(A-T) is continuous at A = u, then (3.10) holds. Hence (3.9) also holds and (i) follows from Corollary 1.14(vi). 0
Let H = ej~l Hj' where Hj ~ H for all j = 1,2, ••• ,k, and let A E LIHI with matrix of the form (3.3) with respect to this decomposition. Observe that A is compact if and only if Aij is compact for all i and j. On the other hand, since Hj ~ H (i.e., Hj is infinite dimensional) for all j, Hj can be identified with H via a fixed unitary map (j = 1, 2, ••• ,k).
Then L[HI can be identified with the algebra of all k x k matrices with entries in LIHI, KIHI can be identified with the ideal of all k x k matrices with entries in K[HI and (by taking the corresponding quotients) A(H) can also be identified with the algebra of all k x k matrices with entries in A(H) (k=l,2, ••• ). This identifications will play a very important role. The proof of the following elementary algebraic lemma is left to the reader. LEMMA 3.43. Let NK 2 (R) be the ring of all 2 x 2 matriaes with entries in a ring R with identity 1. Then
(i) If (~ ~) has a right inverse RJ. If q is 1-nvertible, then pa = 1. (ii) If (~ ~) has a Zeft inverse 1. RJ. If p is invertible, then dq
[~ ~) (~ ~)
in re 2 (R) • then qd
1 (in
in re 2 (R) • then ap = 1 (in
PROOF OF THEOREM 3.38. (i) By Corollary 1.14(vi), either ker r (A-T) c ran(A-T) or ker(A-T)* c ran(A-T)* for every A E Ps-F(T). If u E p~-F(T) and u ~ Ar then (A-T)ker(u-T) = ker(u-T) and so [ker(A-T)*J~ = ran(A-T) J ker(~-T). 66
By Corollary 3.42 JIPker(J.J-T)- Pker(A-T)JJ + 0 (J.J readily follows that ker(A-T) c [ker(A-T)*J~. Hence, Hr(T) = V{ker(A-T):
A~
r Ps-F(T)}
~
+
A), whence i t
r V{ker(A-T)*: A€ p 5 _F(T)}=HJI.(T)
and, a fortiori, H = Hr(T)$H 0 (T)$HJI.(T). (ii) The invariance of Hr(T) and Hr(T)$H 0 (T) =HJI.(T)~ under Tis immediate. Hence, T admits a matrix representation of the form (3.8). (iii) Let {A n }n= ml be a denumerable dense subset of pra- F(T). By Corollary 3.42 Hr(T) = V{Mn}n:l' where Mn=ker(An-T). It is completely apparent that Tr has an upper triangular matrix with respect to an ONB obtained by Gram-Schmidt orthonormalization of a union of ONB's of the subspaces {Mn}n:l and d(Tr) = {An}n:l in this representation (where d(Tr) has the meaning of Corollary 3.40). By Corollary 3.40, cr(Tr) =oii.(Tr) = crR.re(Tr)uop(Tr)' every component of o(Tr) intersects d(Tr)- c [p~-F(Tr)]- (Observe that A-Tr is o~ to for each A E prs- F(T)) and o p (T*) r c d(T r ) ={A n }n= 1 • Since {A n }n= 1 can be arbitrarily chosen (under the condition {A n }- = [ pra- F (T) J-, of course), it readily follows that op(T~) =~and, a fortiori, that p:-F (Tr) = ~ and min. ind (A-Tr) = 0 for all A E Ps-F (Tr). It is also clear that cr(Tr) does not have any isolated point, i. e., either H (T)={O} and cr(Tr)=~, or cr(T) is a nonempty perfect set r r + and cr(Tr) =cr ~re (T)ucr p (T) 0 r =on~re (T)u[p r (Tr )\p(T r )]. Since ps- F(T) r = pr(Tr)\p(Tr)' it follows that every component of oR.re(Tr) intersects [pr(Tr)\p(Tr)J-. In order to prove (iv), we only have to apply the arguments of (iii) to T*JHJI. (T) (Indeed, observe that the equivalence of (3.9) and (3.10) and Corollary 1.14(vi) imply that p~-F(T) =p~-F(T*)*)~ (v) is the content of Corollary 3.32 and (vi) follows from (iii), (iv) and 00
00
their proofs: If A E Ps-F(T)\pr(Tr)' then A E crR.re(Tr) c cre(T), a con tradiction. Hence Ps-F(T) c pr(Tr). A similar argument shows that Ps-F(T) c pli.(T 1 ). (vii) Assume that Hr(T) t- {0} and H1 (T) t- {0} ~ then Hr(T), HR. (T), Hr(T)$H 0 (T) and H0 (T)$HJI. (T) are infinite dimensional spaces. Suppose that A E: ps-F(T) and ind(A-T) > -m~ then A-T1 is invertible and A-T is right invertible. By decomposing H as [Hr(T)$H 0 (T)J$ H1 (T), A-T can be written as the 2 x 2 matrix A-T
[l•- [~Jll\_]= [P r). 0
A-T
R.
Oq
By Lemma 3.43(i), pis right invertible. Since
67
P =
* ) [ >..-T' 0 r >..-To '
it follows from the same lemma that >..-T0 is right invertible. Similarly, if ind(>..-T) < oo, we conclude from Lemma 3.43(ii) that >..-T0 is left invertible. Hence >.. E ps-F(T0 ) and therefore either >..-T0 is invertible, or nul(>..-T0 ) ~ 0 or nul(>..-T0 )* ~ 0. Thus, in order to complete the proof, it only remains to show that >.. ; ap (T0 )uo p (T*)*. 0 Assume that (>..-T0 )x= 0 or equivalently (>..-T)x 1 H0 (T). The invariance of Hr(T)$H 0 (T) implies that (>..-T)x E Hr(T). Since >..-T maps Hr(T) onto itself, there is some y E Hr(T) such that (>..-Tr)y= (>..-T)x. Since y- x E ker (>..-T) c Hr (T), x must be equal to 0. An analogous argument shows that nul (>..-T 0 ) * = 0 and so >..-T0 is invertible, i.e. >.. " p (T 0 ) . If either Hr(T) = {0} or H1 (T) = {0}, then the result follows by an even simpler argument. (viii) Let v" pss- F(T). If vis not an eigenvalue ofT, o then (vi) shows that we have ker (v-T) = ker (v-Tr) and (by Lemma 3 .12) we can find a neighborhood Q of v such that ker(>..-T)=ker(>..-Tr)' for all A
En.
This implies that v E p~-F(T), a contradiction. Hence, v E op(T0 ). On the other hand, the first part of the proof of (vii) indicates that v E ps-F(T0 ) and, by (vii) and Corollary 1.14 (v), v is an isolated point of a (T0 ) . Therefore, v E o0 (T 0 ) . (ix) This follows immediately from (vi) and (viii). (x) Let A be a finite subset of pss- F(T). It follows from (viii) that A c o 0 (T 0 ) and, a fortiori (since A is closed), A is a clopen sub set of a (Tr}, so that (by Riesz' decomposition theorem) To where
= [A T23J) 0
B
'
A acts on a finite dimensional space, a (A) = A and Ana (B) = ' . Therefore T admits the decomposition Tr Tl2 Tl3 Tl4 A T23 T24 0 T 0 B T34 0 0
where A= a (A)
0 c
0
TR.
pr (Tr) np 1 (T 1 ), i.e., or (Tr) noR. (A) =or (A) noR. (TR.) =a (A) n
a(B) = or(A)no 1 (CR.) = '· By Corollary 3.22 and its proof, there exist operators X, Y such that 68
and
Y) (A B12 ) [1 YJ-l 1
o c1 o 1
(A 0 ).
=
o c1
Hence
TA
A has the desired properties and A£ p~-F(TA)' where
Tr T'
A
*
= [0
B
0
0
0
From Theorem 3,38 and Lemma 3.36, we obtain the following COROLLARY 3.44. Let T (3.8); then
LIHI
£
with triangular representation
T slm Tr$T 0 eT 1 •
3.4 Correction by compact perturbation of the singular behavior of op-
erators The Weyl speatrum of T
£
LIHI is defined by
oW(T) = n{o (T+K):
K £ K (H)} •.
It is easily seen that ow(T) is the largest subset of the spectrum that is invariant under compact perturbations and that (by Theorem 1.13(v) ) ow(T) contains every complex X such that X-T is not a Fredholm operator of order 0. Furthermore, it is well-known that ow(T) actually coincides with this set, i.e., ow(T) ={X
£
a::
X-T is not a Fredholm operator of index 0}. (3.1])
(The inclusion 'c' will easily follow as a corollary of Theorem 3.48 below.) The Browder speatrum ofT is the complement of o0 (T) in the spectrum, i.e., oB (T) =a (T) \o 0 (T).
69
Clearly, a(T) ~ aB(T) aaW (T) c a ae (T) c a a tre (T) •
~
aw(T)
~
~
ae(T)
atre(T) and
'~
aaB(T)
c
PROPOSITION 3.45. Given T € L(H). there exists K E K(H) such that p:-F (T+K) = ' . a(T+K)= aB (T) and min.ind(T+K-).) = min.ind(T-).) foro all ). E Pi-F(T); moreover. K can be chosen equal. to a normal. compact operator such that
IITl'll r = max{dist[).,3ps-F(T)]:
).
s Ps-F(T)}.
€
PROOF. Let Tr T12 Tl3]Hr(T) T0 T23 H0 (T) 0 0 Tt Ht(T)
T = [0
be the triangular representation (3.8) of T and let {~n}lsn<m (0 s m s m) be an enumeration of the eigenvalues of a 0 (T). Then T0 admits the representation
* T
~
0
*
n +T n
0 •
- - - - - -
0
- - - - - -
I
-:~m-
Hm
where H1 , H2 , ••• , Hn•··· are defined so that ej~l Hj coincides with the Riesz subspace of T0 corresponding to the clopen subset {~ 1 .~ 2 , ••• , ~n} of a(T 0 ) (1 s n < m) and Hm=H 0 (T)e{elsn<m Hn}. It is not difficult to check that a (Tm) c a (T0 ) \a 0 (T0 ) = aB (T 0 ) . For each ~ n , let An E ap s- F(T) be any point such that 1~ n -A n I = dist[~ ,a(T)\p F(T)J. It is easily seen that ).n Ea... re (T). Thus, if n sT~ is the operator obtained from T0 by replacing ~n by An (1 s n < m), and T'=
[~r T~! :~!]. 0
0
T1
then it follows from Theorem 3.38 (Observe that (T') =T and (T'). = s r r "' ·T1 !) that ps-F(T') =,, a(T') =aB(T') =aB(T) and K=T'-T is a diagonal normal operators with eigenvalues ). 1 -~ 1 (with multiplicity equal to dim H1 ), ). 2 -~ 2 (with multiplicity equal to dim H2 ), ••• , ).n-~n (with 70
multiplicity equal to dim Hnl , ••• , so that
1 ~n<m}=max{dist [J.In•3Ps-F(T)J:
IIKII=max{j).n-llnl: LEMMA 3.46. LetT ~ank
exists a finite (i)
(ii) (iii)
IIKJ.III
<
r
'll
£,
L(H),
€
ope~ato~ €
'll
p:_F(T)\cr 0 (T) and E > 0. Then the~e
€
such that
K 1J
Ps-~(T+K'Il).
min.ind(A-(T+Kll.ll =min.ind().-T)k, A
If
\1
E
l~n<m}.O
€
ps-F(T)\{'11}, k=l,2, •••
~T EDT', whe~e T
p:_F(T)\{J.I} and T
aats on a fis F \1 E p s-
nite dimensional spaae, cr(T ) = {v} and \1\1 € " p r F(T'), " then \1 r s\1 (T+K ) and T+K ~ T EDT", whe~e \1 € p F (T") • 'll 'll " " s" PROOF. By Theorem 3.38, 1J
M the
ap((T 1 l*l* and denote by
E
crp(Trlucrp((T 1 )*)*. Suppose that'll
€
Riesz spectral subspace of T 0 corre-
H
sponding to cr(T 0 ) \{ll}• I f we put
'll
H
=
0
(T)9M then
Tl3 Tl4 Hr(T) T23 T24
T
M
TJ.I T 34 HJ.I
0
T1 H1 (T)
Let S ' --
(Tll T34) 0 T . R.
Since cr(T) = {ll}, we can find a ].1
(finite rank!) operator A
such that IIAII < E/2, cr(T +A) ={J.I} and nul(T +A-J.I) =1. ker(T +A-u)*, 'll
x
~
'll
].1
€
(Thus, i f x
L(H ) j.l
€
0, then x is a cyclic vector for T +A.) Define S"
(T~ +A
;J ~~
].1
(T).
By Corollary 3.22, S"- (Tll+A)EDT1 , i.e., S" has an invariant subspaceR complementary to HJ.I such that S"IR € T 1 • Let W € L(HJ.IEDH 1 (T)) be an invertible operator such that s 1 = WS"W-l= (T +A) E9T • 'll 1 E ker(Til+A-ll), 0 < llfll < e:/(2IIWII·IIW-11>, and let e £ ker(T1 1. Let s 2 =s 1 +e&f € L(HJJEDH 1 (T)), A E a:, y € H 1 (T) and z € H11 and assume that (s 2 -'lll (y+z) = 0; then (s1-~y+e+(~-~ z = 0. Hence
Let f
1J)*, llell
(T -A)Y+e = 0, (T +A-A)Z = 0. 1 j.l I f ). ~ 'll, then A ,l cr (T +A) = { 'll}. I t follows that z = 0 and therefore,
'll
(T 1 -A)y=O. Since crp ~ 0 and (T 1-J.JlY = -e ~ 0. But this is impossible because el ran(T 1-JJ). We conclude that crp (s 2 ) = jl.
71
Observe that 52=
[(T +A->.)* f@e ) (T +A 0 )H e~f Ti H~(T) , so that (S2-Al* = 0 (TP-A)* •
Since H is finite dimensional, it is not difficult to check that = ker(s 2 -~)*d(p) (where d(p) =dim HI!) and HP c v {ker(S 2 -Al*: A € Ps-F(T)}, whence we conclude that HR.(s 2 ) =HP8HR.(T) and (s 2 )R. = s 2 • Let s 3 = w- 1 s 2w and set
H~
S
=
Tr Tl2 8 13]Hr(T) [ 0 T0 1M s 23 M 0 0 s 3 HP8HR.(T)
where s 13 = (T 13 T14 ) and s 23 = (T 23 T24 > 1 then K = s- T is a finite -1
p
rank operator such that IIKPII s IIAII+IIWII·IIW ll·lleQfll < £/2+£12 = £1 Hr(S)=Hr(T) and HR.(S)=HpeHR.(T) and Si=s 3 , and H0 (S)=M and S0 =T0 1M· Now (i), (ii) and (iii) can be easily verified by using Theorem 3.38. If p £ ap(Tr), then we decompose T as
T
Tr Tl2 Tl3 Tl4 Hr(T) 0 Tp T23 T24 H p 0 0 (To)·M T34 M 0 0 0 TR. HR. (T)
where HI! is the (finite dimensional) Riesz subspace of T0 corresponding to {p} and M = H0 (T)9H p • Applying the above arguments to
(:r T~2r p
instead of S', we can find a finite rank operator K' 1.1 such that IlK' 11 < e::, and
£
L[H (T)8H l r 1.1
satisfies Hr(s 4 ) = Hr(T)8HI.I and In this case we define R14]Hr(T)8HI.I T34 M Ti HR. (T) 13 - (T where R13T23 ) and K'eo has the desired
I
It is easily seen that K
1.1
S- T "'
0
1.1
K[Hl,
72
PROPOSITION 3.47. Let T IIKII < e:: suoh that
£
L[H) and e:: > O; then there e%ists K
£
(i)
o 0 (T+K) = o 0 (T) and (T+K) IH(>.;T+K)
~
TIH(>.;T) for all >.
E
o0 (T);
(ii) p~-F (T+K) = Ps-F (T) \00 (T); (iii) min.ind(T+K->.) = min.ind(T->.) for aZZ >.
E
p~-F(T).
PROOF. Let 1:!. ={A" ps-F(T)\[o 0 (T)up(T)]: dist[A,Clps-F(T)] ~ E/2}. Clearly, 1:!. is a compact set and A= l:!.n[ps F(T)\o (T)J is finite. Appl~ so ing Lemma 3.46 a finite number of times (once for each point in A), we sati~
can find a finite rank operator K1 such that I!K 111 < E/2 and T+K 1 fies (i), (iii) and (iiI)
Now we can repeat the argument of the proof of Proposition 3.45 in order to "push" the points of p:_F(T+K 1 )\o0 (T) to Ps-F(T+K 1 J by means of a compact perturbation K2 , I!K 2 11 < E/2, which only affects the action of (T+K 1 ) 0
•
It is easily seen that K = K 1 +K 2 satisfies all our requirements.
0 THEOREM 3.48. LetT" L(H) and E > 0; then there exists K" K(H)
suah that IlK II < E+max{ dist[A, Clps-F (T)]:
>. " o 0 (T)}
andmin.ind(T+K->.)=0 foro all>." p 5 _F(T).
In partiauZar, o(T+K) ={A "
a::
>.-T is not a F1'edhoZm operato1' of index 0}
PROOF. By Propositions 3.45 and 3.47, we can find a compact tor K1 such that I!K 111 < E/2+max{dist[A, Clp 5 _F (T)]:
>.
E
oper~
o 0 (T)}
and the operator A= T+K 1 satisfies the following properties: p~-F (A) = r Ps-F (A) and min. ind (A-A) =min. ind (>.-T) for all >. " Ps-F (T). Thus, in order to complete the proof it suffices to show that there exists K2 " K(H), I!K 2 11 < r./2, such that min.ind(A+K 2 ->.J = 0 for all>. E ps-F(A) = p 5 _F(T). (Indeed, K= K1 +K 2 will obviously satisfy all our requirements.) Let 1:!. = {>." ps-F(A): dist[A,aps-F(A)] ~ E/6} and !:!. 1 ={A E /:!.: min.ind(>.-A) ~ 0}. By Proposition 3.16 we can find y,z " H such that Pker(>.-A)y ~ 0, Pker(>.-A)*z ~ 0, for all>. " /:!. 1 • Let Ca = ayez, a > O. i'le have min. ind (A+Ca ->.) =min. ind (A->.) -1, for all >. Since min.ind(>.-A) =0 for all>.
E
E
A1 , a> 0.
I:!.\A 1 , it readily follows that
73
6\6 1 that
c
p1 (A) pr(A). Therefore, there is a positive constant n 1 such 110..-A)x!l ~ n1 for all>. E p 1 (A)n(6\6 1 ) and 11<>.-A)*xll ~ n1 for all >. e pr(A)n(6\6 1 ),
for all x -.: H, II x II = 1. Thus, if 0 < a < min{e:/6,n 1 /2}, then IICall < e:/6 and min.ind(A+Ca1.) =0 for all>. e 6\6 1 • Now we can apply the same arguement to A+C (l , etc. After finitely many steps we obtain a finite rank operator c 1 such that 11c 1 11 < e:/6, min.ind(A+C 1->.) = 0 for all>.
E
6 and o(A+C 1 )
c
interiora(A)e:/ 6 • (3.12)
Let {Qj}l~n<m (0 s m s w) be an enumeration of the components of a(A+C 1 )np s- F(A) such that min.ind(>.-A) ~ 0 for all >. e nJ.• (Clearly, u. Q. c [ap F(A)] 13 .) A repetition of our previous argument shows J J se: that there exists a positive constant n < min{e:/6,n 1/2} such that the relations (3.12) remain true if A+C 1 is replaced by A+C 1 +B for any B in L (H) such that liB II s n • r If >. 1 e Ps-F(A+c 1 >no 1 , then the arguments used for the construction of C can be repeated here in order to find a finite rank operaa tor c 2 , 1 , II c 2 , 1 11 < n/2, such that min. ind (A+C 1 +C 2 , 1 ->. 1 ) = 0. By induction, we can construct finite rank operators c 2 1 , c 2 2 , ••• ,c 2 n•···• n
CO
I
I
IIC2,n11 < n/2 (n=1,2, ••• ) such tha; C2=~n=l c2,n min.ind(A+C 1 +c 2->.) =0 for all>. e Ps-F(A+C 1 +c 2 ), 6
c
r
Ps-F(A+C 1+c 2 )
and
cr(A+C 1 +c 2 )
Since max{dist[A,aps-F(A)]:
c
€
I
K(H), IIC211 < nr
interior cr(A)e:/ 6 • s
>. e Ps-F(A+C 1 +c 2 )} < e:/6,
we can apply the arguments of Proposition 3.45 in order to find a compact normal operator c 3 , IIC 3 !1 < e:/6, such that min.ind(A+C 1 +c 2+c 3->.)=0 for all>.
E
Ps-F(A). 0
An
operator T e L(H) such that min.ind(>.-T)
0 for all >. e Ps-F(T)
(3.13)
will be called a smooth operator.
3.5 Apostol-Foiaf-Voiculescu's theorem on normal restrictions of compact perturbations of operators 74
Given Tin L(H) we cannot expect, a priori, to find an infinite dimensional invariant subspace M such that TIM is normal. An important approximation argument (due to C. Apostol, C. Foia~ and D. Voiculescu) asserts that some arbitrarily small compact perturbation of T always has that property. We shall need some extra notation to make it more clear.
3.5.1 Schatten p-classes Recall that if K is compact, then (K*K)~ can be written as (K*K)~ A3
In:l An en@en with respect to some ONB {en}n:l' where ;~. 1 = IIKII 2! A2 2! ···~An 2! An+l 2! ••• ~ 0 and An+ 0 (n + ~>. The Schatten p-cZass cP(H) of compact operators is defined by
cP(H)
= {K
E
K(H):
2!
In:l A~ < oo}, 0 < p < oo,
and C (H) = K(H). The reader is referred to [77], [107], [183] for the properties of these ideals of operators. In particular, we have: (a) If K E cP(H), then K* E cP(H): (b) cP(H) (C 00 (H)) is a Banach space under the norm IKI = IK*I 00
00
p 1/p
p
p
(with respect to some ONB {fn}n:l of H. The result is independent of the particular ONB.): (e) c 1 (H) = the ideal of trace class operators is isometrically isomorphic to the dual K(H)t of K(H). This isomorphism is defined by C1 (H) :;; K ++4lK E K (H) t , where ~K(X)
= tr(KX), X E
K{H):
(f) c 7 (H)t = K(H)tt is isometrically isomorphic to L(H). This isomorphism is defined by L(H) :;; A++ ~A E C1 (H) t , where
~A(K) = tr(AK), K (g)
If A
E
E
c1 (H):
L(H) is a non-negative hermitian operator, then tr(A)
=
In:l (0 s tr(A) s
oo)
is well-defined and the result is independent of the particular ONB {fn}n:l of H.
75
(h) (C 2 (H), 1-1 2 > (=the ideal of Hilbert-Schmidt operators) is a Hilbert space. If A, B" c2 (H), then AB*" c 1 (H) and the inner product of c2 (H) is.given by = tr(AB*).
3.5.2 Normal restrictions With the above notation in mind, we have the following THEOREM 3.49. Given T" L(HI. a nonempty compact subset rt of ote E > o. there ezists an infinite dimensional subspace H c H 1 E and KE ,;: C (H) such that jK E 11 < E (so that IlK EII < eJ. (T-K E)H E c HE• T = (T-K ) IH is a diagonal normal operator of uniform infinite multi E E E plicity and o(TE) = oe(TE) rt. (T) and
PROOF. Let {An}n:l be a sequence of complex numbers such that {An}-= r t and (3.14) card{m: Am for each n= 1,2,... It is obvious that rt c ote(T) cot (T). Therefore, we can find a unit vector e 1 " H such that II
_ [Xl+tll
T -
1
T21 then [til]: v{e 1 } T21
+
T12)el 1
;
T22 {el}.i.
{e 1 }.L is a rank-one operator,
11[:~:]11
E/4 and <
Ti 2 :{e1 }.1. + V{e 1 } is also a rank-one operator. Clearly, we can find a finite dimensional subspace M1 => V{e 1 } such that IIT~ 1 1Mill < E/4. Let R1 be the orthogonal projection of H onto Mi and define c 1 by
0] [0
Ti2] Rl. cl = [til + 0 0 0 T21 It is easily seen that jc 1 11 <
l(:~~) j
1+1Ti21Mil 1 < E/2 and
where N1 = M1 n{e 1 }.1.. Clearly, o (T 1 ) = o (TY. Thus, we can apply the same argument te te to T1 in order to obtain a unit vector e 2 " M1 , a trace class operator c 2 such that 1c2 11 < £!4 and a finite dimensional subspace N2 ~ V{e 1 , 76
e 2 } such that V{el,e2} N2e V{e 1 ,e 2 }. A2 N2
E2
D2
By induction, we can find orthonormal vectors e 1 ,e 2 , .•• en•···• and trace class operators c 1 ,c 2 , .•. ,cn, ••• such that KE = Ln:l en € Cl (H), IKEil s Ln:l ICnll < E and
T-KE=[~E :):~ where HE = V{en}n:l and TE Ln:l An enQen (strong limit of the partial sums). The condition (3.14) guarantees that T has the desired properties. 0 L(H), nonempty compact subsets r~ c a~e (T) and rr c are(T), E > 0 and diagonal normal operators N~ and Nr of uniform infinite multiplicity such that r~ c a(N 1 ) = ae(N 1 ) c Cr 1 >E and rr c a(N r ) = o r (Nr) c Cr r ) E , there exists an operator L E L(H), COROLLARY 3.50. Given T
L '
€
[~·
:
such that liT- Lll < 2E. PROOF. Applying the inductive argument of the proof of Theorem 3. alternatively toT and toT*, we can find K € c 1 (H), IIKII s IKI 1 < r/2 such that 49
T-K
Mi * [0 A 0
0
where M1 and Mr are diagonal normal operators of uniform infinite multiplicity such that a (M1 ) = r 1 and o (Mr) = r r' resp •. Since r~ c o(N 1 ) =oe(Ni) c (fi)E and fr c o(Nr) =oe(Nr) c (fr)E, and N1 and Nr are diagonal normal operators of uniform infinite multiplicity, we can easily "spread" the spectral measures of M1 and Mr(CO!!, centrated in op(M1 ) and ap(Mr), resp.) in order to obtain normal oper~ tors NR_ and N~ such that NR_ "' NR., N~"' Nr, IIM1 - NR_II < 3E/2 and IIMr-N;II < 3E/2. The operator L obtained by replacing MR. and Mr by the normal operators NR_ and N;, respectively, satisfies all our requirements.o 77
3.5.3 Density of sets of operators with bad properties We shall say that a certain property (P) a Hilbert space H) is a bad property if:
(of operators acting on
(I)
If A has the property (P) , then n+BA has the property (P) for all a E ~ and all 6 ~ O, (II) If A has the property (P) and T - A, then T has the property (P), and (III) If A has the property (P) and cr(A)ncr(B) = ~. then A$8 has the property (P) • Examples of "bad properties" are frequent in the literature: nam~ ly, (1) T is not cyclic, (2) The spectrum of T is disconnected (or cr(T) has infinitely many components, or c components, where c is the power of the continuum), (3) crp(T) has nonempty interior, (4) The commutant of T is not abelian, (5) T is not similar to a normal operator, (6) T is not algebraic, etc, are examples of properties satisfying (I), (II) and (III). THEORm~
atoP A
~ith
3.51. If (P) is a bad pPopePty and thePe exists some the property (P), then the set {TE
L(H):
ope~
Tsatisfies (P)}
is dense in L(H).
PROOF. Let~ E acre(T)n3p(T). Given£> 0, we can find A E p(T) such that IA-~1 < £/2. By Corollary 3.50, we can find L E L(H) such that IIT-LII < £/2 and L =
[~
:)
with respect to some decomposition H = M$M~, where M and M~ are infinite dimensional subspaces and A I cr(B). (Observe that~ E acre(T) c crtre(T) and take r 1 = {A}ucr 1 e(T), rr = crre(T).) Let n = dist[A,cr(B)]. Clearly, 0 < n < £/2: thus, if 0 < 6 < n/(1-IJIAII>· then it follows from Corollary 3.22 that
R)
A+6A M= [ O B
-
(A+6A)$B.
Now (I), (II) and (III) imply that M has the property (P). Since II T-MII s II T-LII+~IAII < £, and £ can be chosen arbitrarily small, it read ily follows that T E {S E L(H): S satisfies (P)} • 0 An
78
inductive repetition of the same argument yields the following
COROLLARY 3.52. If {(Pn)}n:l is a denumerab~e set of bad properties, then (P) = un:l (Pn) is a bad property. FurthermoPe, if thePe ezist operators A1 , A2 , ••• , An•··· in L(H) such that An satisfies (Pn) (foP each n = 1,2, ••• ), then {T E L(H): T satisfies (P)} is dense in L (H).
3.6 Notes and remarks The operators TAB were first systematically studied by M. Rosenblum in [174]. Rosenblum's theorem has been proved there, except that the equality a (TAB) =a (A) -a (B) is replaced by the weaker statement a(TAB) c a(A)- cr(B). The fact that this inclusion is actually an equa! ity is due to D. C. Kleinecke (see [l57,IntroductionJ). Corollary 3.22, for the special case when cr(A)no(B) = ,, is usually called Rosenblum's corollary (see, e.g., [17l,Chapter 0]}. In [69], c. Davis and P. Rose~ thal re-analyzed Rosenblum's results and proved that cr 6 (TAB)= crr(A)oR.(B) and cr 11 (TAB) = crR.(A) -crr(B) and extended Rosenblum's corollary to Corollary 3.22. Their arguments include the use of the BerberianQuigley construction (Lemma 3.3; see [45], [l72,p.25J) in order to prove Theorem 3.4 as given here. Finally, L. A. Fialkow modified Rose~ blum's original argument (by using analytic one-sided inverses instead of resolvents) in order to show thatcr 6 CTAB) =crr(TAB) and cr'lf(TAB) = aR. (TAB) [87]. More precisely, Fialkow's results read as follows THEOREM 3.53. Let A, B
E
L(H); then the
fo~~owing
aPe equivalent
for TAB: {i) TAB is surjective; {ii) crr(A)naR.(B) = ,; {iii) ran TAB contains the minimal idea~ F(H); {iv) TAB is Pight invePtible in L(L(H)). Clear~y, TAB maps every norm idea~ {in the sense of R. Schatten [183]) J c K(H) into itse~hand each of the above conditions is also equivalent to each of the following ones {v) TABIJ is suPjective foP some norm ideal J; {vi) TABIJ is surjective for every norm ideal J; {vii) TABIJ is right invePtible in L(J) for some norm ideal J; (viii) TABIJ is right invertible foP evePy noPm ideal]. MoPeover, in this case ker TAB and ran TAB aPe complementary subspaces of L(H) and ker TABIJ and ran TABIJ aPe complementaPy subspaces of J for each norm ideal ).
79
THEOREM 3.54. The following are equivalent for TAB: (i) TAB is bounded below; (ii) at (A)nor(B) = ~; (iii) TAB!F 1 !HI is bounded below (where F 1 (HI is the set of all rank~one operators); (iv) TAB is left invertible in L(L(HII; (v) TABIJ is bounded below for some norm ideal J; (Vi) TABIJ is bounded below for every norm ideal ]; (vii) TABIJ is left invertible for some norm ideal J; (viii) TABIJ is left invertible for every norm ideal ]. Moreover, in this case ran TAB and ker TAB (ran TABIJ and ker TABIJJ are complementary subspaces of L(HI (of J for every norm ideal ], respectively). Furthermore, Fialkow also considered the operator TAB induced by TAB in the Calkin algebra, defined by ~AB(X) =AX-XB. His results for these operators can be summed up as follows (see [59], [86], [87], [99J, [89J, [9oJ).
THEOREM 3.55. The following are equivalent for TAB: (i) TAB is surjective; (ii) ~AB has dense range; (iii) ore(A)note(B) = ~; (iv) TAB is right invertible in L(A(H)). In this case, a right inverse for TAB is given by ~
-
-1
-
cJ>(Y) = 2ni Ian RA(>.)YLB(A.l d>.. where n is a Cauchy domain such that are(A) c n and ate(B)nn = ~. RA (>.) is an analytic right inverse of (>.-~) defined on a neighborhood of ~\n and Ls<>-> is an analytic left inverse of (A.-B) defined on a neighborhood of Q-. Moreover, ker ~~g and ran tAB are complementary subspaces of A(H). THEOREM 3.56. The following are equivalent for t~B: (i) ~AB is bounded below; (ii) ote(A)nore(B) = ~; (iii) TAB has a left inverse in L(A(H)J. In this case, a left in verse for TAB is given by
$
=
2!i {an Lx
d>..
where n is a Cauchy domain such that ate (A) c n and are (B) n n- = ~. ~ (>.) is an analytic left inverse of (A.-~) defined on a netghborhood of 80
~\G and Rs(A) is an anaLytic right inverse of (A-B) defined on a neig~ borhood of Q-. Moreover, ker TAB and ran TAB are compLementary subspaces of A(H).
THEOREM 3.57. (i) TAB is a Fredholm operator in L(L(H) l if and onLy if oe(A)no(B) =o(A)noe(B) =~; oe(TAB) =[o(A) -oe(B)Ju[oe(A)-o(B)]. (iiJ 'AB is a semi-FredhoLm operator if and only if o 1 e(A)no~B) o 1 (A)ncrre(B) =~or ore(A)ncrt(B) =or(A)ncrte(B) =16. Moreover, Fialkow also proved the following asymptotic version of Theorem 3.19(i) [90,Theorem 1.1]. THEOREM 3.58. The foLLowing are equivaLent (i) ran 'AB is dense in L(H); (iiJ 1) ore(A)note(B) = 16, and 1 2) There exists no nonzero X e C (H) such that BX = XA; (iii) Given Y e L(H) and E > 0, there exists X e L(H) such that tAB(X)- Y e K(H) and II
(~ ~) (acting on H
= H1eH 2 J
and
A$8
are asymptoticaLLy simiLar.
The construction of one-sided resolvents (Theorem 3.8 and Corollary 3.9) is due to c. Apostol and K. Clancey [15] (see also [14]). The proof strongly depends on a previous deep result of C. Apostol (Proposition 3.16 [lO]).This result extend to the case of an arbitrary compact set o the one obtained in [26] for the case when o is simply connected. The results of Section 3.1.6 and 3.1.7 have been taken from J. G. Stampfli's article [189]. Indeed, Stampfli proved that if Cis an irreducible C*-subalgebra with identity of L(H) (in particular, if C = l(H)), then II!STII = 2 min{IIT-AII: A e: ~}for each inner derivation 1ST inC (and the analogous result for the operators 'AB' A, 8 e C). Exte~ sions of Stampfli's results to derivations on certain C*-algebras and 81
W*-algebras were given by c. Apostol and L. Szid6 [31]. For the case of an inner derivation in the Calkin algebra, it is known that
{!IT-
THEOREM 3.60 (C.-K. Fong [99]). If T E L(H), then ilo:rll = 2 min A. II: A E a:}. Moreover, there exists an orthogonal projection X e
L(HI such that llo:rll = llo:r(2X-llll·
The interesbed reader will find a very detailed analysis of the spectra, left spectra and right spectra of large families of operators "somehow related" with the operators TAB (including tensor products of operators; the operator X~ Lj~l AjXBj, where {A1 ,A 2 , ••• ,An} and {B 1 , B2 , ••• ,Bn} are separately commuting families of operators in L (H),-etc), in [55], [79], [91],[92], [100], [187] and, very especially, in several papers by R. E. Harte [127], [128]. Very recently, the spectrum of the operator X ~ Lj~l AjXBj has been completely determined by R. Curto [68]. In [175], Gian-Carlo Rota proved that the backward shift of infinite multiplicity is a "universal model" for all operators T in L (H) such that sp(T) < 1 (see also [130,Lecture X]). Two (very close) universal models for an operator T with arbitrary spectrum and the spectrum of the model equal to a suitable neighborhood of o(T) were independently obtained by D. A. Herrero [142] and D. Voiculescu [l94,Prop£ sition 2.1]. The model given here (Theorem 3.33) is the one due to Vo! culescu. J. A. Ball obtained analogous models for commuting n-tuples of operators [41] and F. Gilfeather used Rota's original construction and an iterative argument to give a different (and independent) proof of Herrero's corollary (Corollary 3.35); moreover, Gilfeather [105] -1 actually showed that the invertible operator W such that T' =WTW satisfies the conditions of that corollary can be constructed in the C*alqebra C*(T) generated by T and 1. Theorem 3.38 (except for those details concerning the structures of Tr and Tt given by (iii) and (iv) ), Proposition 3. 47 and Theorem 3. 48 are due to C. Apostol [10]. A simplified version of Apostol's tria~ gular representation has been obtained by R. Bouldin in [52]. The version given here (Theorem 3.38) combines the arguments of [10], [52] and some improvements of D. A. Herrero (items (iii) and (iv)), based on Corollary 3.40 which, in turn, is a particular case of [144] (Theorem 1 or Theorem 2). However, the proof of Corollary 3.40(i) given here is not the same as the one given in [144]. This new proof has been based on Lemma 3.39 (due toR. G. Douglas and C. M. Pearcy [75]) which will play an important role in the characterization of quasitriangularity (see Chapter VI below). 82
In [190], J. G. Stampfli proved that, given T E LIHI there exists K € K(H) such that a(T+K) = aw(T) (without any estimate on II Kill; moreover (as observed by N. Salinas; see Remark on p.l74 of [190]), the fact that a(T+K) = a 8 (T) for some Kin LIHI is implicitly contained in that paper. A more general theorem, containing both results, has been obtained by C. Apostol, C. M. Pearcy and N. Salinas in [28] (see also Section 4.3 of Chapter IV below.) Theorem 3.49 is Theorem 2.2 of [23]. This clever approximation ar gument is one of the most important ingredients for the theorem on spectral characterization of quasitriangularity of c. Apostol, c. Foia~ and D. Voiculescu (obtained in that paper; see Chapter VI below). The result can be regarded as an asymmetric version of the analogous r~ sult of C. M. Pearcy and N. Salinas for semi-normal operators [162]. These results (and many other related ones scattered thorugh the lite~ ature; see, e.g., (3], [139], [163], [179] and, very especially, [56] and [57]) are based on an argument due to F. Wolf [199]. (See also the partially related articles [71],[95] and [96].) Corollary 3.50 appears in [27]. Theorem 3.51 is a mild generalization of Herrero's theorem for non-cyclic operators. Indeed, the same result is actually true for the Banach spaces tP (1 ~ p < ~J and c 0 (see [146,Theorem 4]). The underlying idea is contained in a paper of N. Salinas [178].
83
4 Two results borrowed from the theory of C* -algebras
The similarity orbit of T U(T)
E
L(H) contains the unitary orbit of T
= {UTU*: u
E
U(H)}
(where U (H) is the unitary group of L (H) ) , which plays a very important role in approximation problems. We shall see later that, since U(T) c S(T)-, a large amount of information about S(T) can be obtained from the structure of U(T)-. This structure is closely related with the C*-algebra C*(T) generated by T and the identity 1 E L(H). I~st of those results related with closure of unitary orbits (and many others) connected with approximation problems can be derivedfrom two deep results of the theory of C*-algebras. These results (the Brown-Douglas-Fillmore theorem and Voiculescu's theorem) will be stated here without proofs (suitable references will be given) • Several consequences of these two results will be completely developed her~
4.1 Essentially normal operators An operator T E L(H) will be called essentially normal if T is a normal element of the Calkin algebra or, equivalently, if the self-~ mutator [T* ,T] = T*T- TT* is compact. One way in which these operators arise is as compact perturbations of normal operators. The interestin essentially normal operators is due to two facts: a) Not all of them arise in that fashion; b) There is a rich family of operators of the form "normal+compact" whose structure is not obvious from their analytic expression. (This is, by far, the most important fact from our viewpoint.)
4.1.1 Brawn-Douglas-Fillmore theorem Essentially normal operators have been completely classified in the famous article [60] of L. G. Brown, R. G. Douglas and P. A. Fill84
more. Their main results will be quoted here in the most convenient form for our purposes. (The reader is referred to the above cited arti cle for proofs.) It is completely apparent from the definition that if T is essentially normal, then cr... e (T) = cr re (T) and therefore _,. < ind (A-T) < oo for all A £ Ps-F (T) , p s-F (T) = Pp (T) and cr R.re (T) = cr e (T) • THEOREl-i 4.1 (BDF theorem). If T1 and T 2 a1'e essentiaZly no1'maZ ope1'ato1's on H, then a neaessa1'y and sufficient condition that T1 be unita1'iZy equivaZent to some aompaat perturbation of T2 is that cre(T1) cre(T 2 J and ind().-T 1 ) =ind().-T 2 ) for aZZ). I cre(T 1 J. There is a special case of particular interest. COROLLARY 4.2 (BDF corollary). (i) If T is an essentiaZZy normaZ operator on H suah that ind ().- T) = 0 fo1' aZ Z A E ps-F (T) • then T is in NoJt(H)
+ K(H) =
{N+K:
is normaZ,
N
K
is aompaat}
In partiauZa1', eve1'y essentiaZZy normaZ operator T suah that oe(T) does not disaonneat the p Z.ane is in Noll ( Hl + K (H) • (iii) NOJt(H) + K(H) is a aZosed subset of L(H). (ii)
4.1.2 Berger-Shaw trace
inequal~
In order to make the above results useful for approximation purposes, a large family of essentially normal operators will be exhibited. We shall need some extra notation. Given T E L(H), let A(T) (= the weak closure of the polynomials in 1 and T) , Aa. (T) ( = the weak closure of the rational functions of T with poles outside o(T)), A' (T) ={A E L(H): AT=TA} (=the commutant ofT) and A." (T) = {B E L (H) : BA = AB for all A in A' (T)} (= the double commutant of T) be the four (weakly closed) sublagebras of L(H) naturally associated with T. It is apparent that A(T) c Aa.(T) c A"(T) c A' (T). The muZtipZiaity ~(A) of a (weakly closed, identity containing) subalgebra A of L(H) is defined by ~(A)
= inf{card(r):
H = V[Ax: A
E
A, x
E
rJ, r
c
H}
(4 .1)
(1 ~~(A) s ~>. Tis n-muZtiayalia (n-rationaZZy multiayaZ.ic) if 1dA(T)) =n (~(Aa.(T)) =n, resp.). An oper,ator T E L(H) is called hypono1'maZ if [T*,TJ is a positive semi-definite hermitian operator; T is called subnormal. if there ex-
85
ists a normal operator N acting on a Hilbert space R containing H such that His invariant under Nand T=NIH. It is not difficult to see that (Normal) => (Subnormal) => (Hyponormal) • None of these implications can be reversed; e. g., M+(r) of (3.2) are subnormal, but not normal. It readily follows from (g) of Section 3.5.1 that
the operators
tr[T*,T]=~n:l dT*T-TT*)fn,fn>=~n:l (jjTfnjl2 -jjT*fnlr>
(4.2)
(0 s tr[T*,TJ s ~) is well-defined for all hyponormal T. The main result of [50 J asserts that if Tis a hyponormal n-rationally multicyclic operator, then [T*,TJ e c7 (H); moreover, j[T*,TJj 1 =tr[T*,TJ s (n/-rr) meas 2 (a(T)),
( 4. 3)
where meas 2 denotes the planar Lebesgue measure. In order to prove this inequ~lity, we shall need an auxiliary result. LEMMA 4. 3. If ll (A a (T)) = n, then n s ll (A (T)) s n+l. PROOF. It is trivial that }.l(A(T)) ~ }.l(Aa(T)) = n. Assume that H = Vbxj: A e Aa(T), j = 1,2, .•• ,n} for a suitable finite family {x 1 ,x 2 , ••. ,xn} c Hand let {Akj}k:l (j=l,2, ••. ,n) ben pairwise disjoint dense subsets of p(T). If the positive constants {ck.}k~l ._1 2 , ••• ,n are suitably chosen, then l.J~;,~ 1 l~;k~lllck.(Ak·-T)-l J - ,J-, .J J xjll <~and therefore x
o
= L.j=ll.k=l ~; n ~; ""
( ) -1 ckj Akj-T xj
is a well-defined element of H. Now it is easily seen that, for suitably chosen polynomials pll,i' 1
n
2
Pll,i'pll,i'"""'pll,i' we have ll
-1
n
-1
so that (A 11 -T) x 1 e M=V{Axj: the same argument shows that (Ak.-T) J
-1
j
x 1 - {Pll,i (T)x0 +~j=l Pn,i (T)xj} 11
+
o
(i
+ <»),
A e A(T), j=O,l,2, ••• ,n}; moreover,
.
x. eM for all J=l,2, ••• ,n, and all k=l,2, ••• J
Hence (by Runge's approximation theorem), r(T)xj e M for all j l,2, ••• ,n and for all rational functions r with poles outside cr(T). It readily follows that M is invariant under Aa(T). Since M contains the vectors x 1 ,x 2 , ••• ,xn' we conclude that M=H. Hence, ll(A(T)) s card{x0 ,x 1 ,x 2 , .•• ,xn} = n+l. 0 THEOREM 4.4 (Berger-Shaw trace inequality). If T e L(H) is a hyp£ 86
normal n-rationally multiayalic operator, then [T*,TJ J[T*,TJI 1 satisfies the inequality (4.3). In particular, T is essentially normal.
£
C7 !HI and
PROOF. It will be convenient to split the proof in several steps. (I)
Assume that A is hyponormal and p-multicylic, i.e., k k k co H = V{A x 1 ,A x 2 , ••• ,A xp}k=O
for suitably chosen p vectors x 1 , x 2 , .•• , xp in H. Let {fk}k:l be the ONB of H obtained by means of the Gram-Schmidt process of orthonormalization applied to the sequence x 1 ,x 2 , .•• ,x ,Ax1 , 2 2 2 k k k p AX 2 , ••• ,Axp,A x 1 ,A x 2 , ••• ,A xp, ••• ,A x 1 ,A x 2 , ••• ,A xp•··· • It is easi ly seen that A admits the matrix representation all a21 a31 a41
A=
a12
a22 a32 a42
al3 a23 a33 a43
al4 a24 i34 a44
. ap2 apl ap3 ap+l,l ap+l,2 ap+l,3 ap+2,2 ap+2,3 ap+3,3 0
ap4 ap+l,4 ap+2,4 ap+3,4 ap+4,4
fp • fp+l fp+2 fp+3 fp+4
Hence, given m > p+2, we have (akr is defined equal to 0 for all
r s 0) ~ m 2 * 2 _ ~ m k+p 2 co 2 0 s Lk=l
s , m , k+pl 2 , oo 2 m k+p 2 Lk=tn-p+l
subnormal operator (e0 (X) = 1 is a cyclic vector forT~) and a(T~) = tji(D)-=0- [73]. I f {en}n:o is the canonical ONB of H2 (ao) (defined by en(;\)= Xn, n=O,l,2, ••• ), then ~DO 2 2 ICT¢,T4>] I 1 =tr[T;,Tcf>J=Ln=O(IITtjlenll -IIT$en11)
=
~n:o ( ll~m:o
~
DO
= Lm=l ml cml
IIIm~O
cmx n+mll 2 -
2
em An-mll 2 >
= (l/7T) f 0 14>' (X) I
2
dA = (l/7T)meas 2 Wl
(where dA denotes the planar Lebesgue measure) • Hence, lcT;,Tq,J1 1 = (l/1T)meas 2 W> = (l/7T)meas 2 [a(Tifi)J. Given
(III)
£
> 0, we can find finitely many simply connected
analytic Cauchy domains
o1 , o 2 , ••• , Oq such that
1) a(T)u(ur~l Or)- c 6. ={X: 2) 0 -nO - = {6, i f r '1- s;
r
lXI s IITIIl;
s
3) cr(T)n(ur!h Or)-={6; and 4) meas 2 (6.\[cr(T)u(ur~l Or)-]) < £. If cf>r:D + Or is a conformal mapping (r = 1,2, ••• ,q), k
1 and
A = [T$(61 q T ) (n)] (k) k r=l
L
E
Aa(T), j=l,2, ••• ,n}, it is not difficult to
check that
(H61[61r~l
H2 (3D) (n) ]) (k) =
V{Bk[yj61(61r~l e~~~)]:
i=l,2, ••• ,nk, 15 j so that
~
(IV) to A =
~,
nand j = i
5
Bk .: Aa(Ak),
(mod n)},
is nk-rationally multicyclic. By Lemma 4.3, Ak is (nk+l)-multicyclic. Thus, applying (I)
we obtain
ICA,,~JI 1 =ki[T*,TJI 1 +nk~r~ 1 1CT$ ,Tcf> Jl 1 r
5
(nk+lli1Akll 2 = (nk+l>IITII 2
r
= [ (nk+l)/7T]meas 2 (6.).
From this inequality, (II) and 1) - 4) of (III), it follows that ki[T*,TJI 1 < [(nk+l)/7THmeas 2 [cr(T)J+~r~l meas 2 COr)+d
-(nk/7T)Lr~l meas 2 (nr) = [(nk+l)/1TJmeas 2 Ca('I') J
88
Hence, I[T*,TJI 1
<
[(n+l/k)/irJmeas 2 [a(T)J-tjiTII2/k+nE.
Since k can be taken arbitrarily large and E can be chosen arbitrarily small, we conclude that I [T*,TJI 1 s (n/7r)meas 2 [a(T) ].
0
4.1.3 Examples of essentially normal operators The operator M+(r) of (3.2) is subnormal and rationally cyclic (the function e 0 (>.) = 1 being a cyclic vector for A4 (M+(f)).) Thus, by Theorem 4.4, M+(r) is an essentially normal operator. On the other hand, since 0 = [M(r)*,M(r)] = [
[M+ (r) * ,M+ ( r ) ] - ZZ* Z*M (r) - M (r) Z*
+
-
M+(r)*Z- ZM_(r)* JH 2 (r) Z*Z+[l1_ (r) * ,M_ (r)] H2 (r)l'
it readily follows from the same proposition that [M+(r) * ,M+ (f)]= ZZ* E C 1 (H 2 (r)). A fortiori, [M_(r)*,M_(r}]=-Z*Z € c 1 (H2(r)l), so that M_(r) is also essentially normal and Z is a Hilbert-Schmidt operator. (Indeed, Z is a finite rank operator.) From Corollary 4.2, we obtain the following COROLLARY 4.5. Let Q be an analytic Cauchy domain with boundary r and let M be a normal operator such that a (Ill) = ae (M) = Q-. Then MIBM+ (r) and .f.11BM_ (r) are unitar•iZy equivalent to compact perturbations
= an
of M.
A different kind of examples can be constructed as follows: Let be a nonempty bounded open set such that Q =interior Q- and let N(Q) be the "multiplication by >." operator acting on L2 (Q,dA). The subspace A2 (G) spanned by the rational functions with poles outside n- is inva~ iant under N(Q). By N+(Q) and N_(Q) we shall denote the restriction of N(Q) to A2 (n) and its compression to L2 (n)eA 2 (n), respectively, i.e., Q
N(Q) = (
N+(Q)
G )A2 (0)
0
N_(Q) A2 (Q)l.
(4 .4)
As in the case when U+ (Q) (Section 3. 2) , A2 (Q) is a reproducing kernel space and it can be realized as a space of analytic functions defined of Q: furthermore, 89
cr(N(n)) =cre(N(n)) =cr(N+(O)) =cr(N_(rl)) =cre(N_(O)) =n-,
o and ind <11- N+ (O)) = -1 for all ll € n. N(Q) is a normal operator, N+(n) is a rationally cyclic subnormal operator (Hence, N+(fl) is an essentially normal operator, by Theorem 4.4) and llr(N(fl)lll =llrCN+(O))II =max {lr(A) 1: A E an} for each rational function r with poles outside n-. ae (N+ Cnl) = an, nul <11- N+ Cnl) =
(4. 5)
Now it is clear that N+(O*)* is also an essentially normal operator such that nul Cll- N+ (O*) *) = ind C11- N+ Cn*) *) = 1 for all ].J € o and { llr (N+ (0*) *) II= max{ Ir (A: I : A E an} for each rational function r with poles outside n • Indeed, it can be actually shown that (see [SO], [Sl]) tr[N+(O)*,N+(Q)] s (l/n)meas 2 (0)
(not Q
!) •
Now it follows from the BDF theorem that COROLLARY 4.6. If N is a normal. operator suah that cr(N)
an, then N+(fl)$N+(O*)* is unitarily equivalent to a aompaat tion of N.
(=
cre(N))
perturb~
COROLLARY 4.7. If Tis an essentially normal. operator, nn={A € 11:: ind(A- T) = n} (1 s In I < oo) and N is an arbitrary normal. operator suah that cr(N) =cre(N) =cre(T), then Tis unitarily equivalent to a aompaat pertubation of L
= Ne{en:l [N+ Con*)* J Cnl }e{en:l N+ Cn_nl Cnl}
. d as t h e 0 operator ( wh ere N+ ( n) must b e ~nterprete
.
aat~ng
on
,.o . ~ ~n
the
aase when n = [6.)
Indeed, the conditions llr (N+ (fl) >II = llr (N+ Co*) *lll =max{ I r (A) I : X € iHl}imply, in particular, that IIEll-N+(O)J- 1 11= IIC].J-N+(Q*)*J- 1 11=1/dist [ll,rl-] and this suffices to guarantee that L is well-defined. Since tr[N+(On)*,N+(On)J s (l/~)meas 2 (nn), it is not difficult to check that L is essentially normal.
4.1.4 An application to approximation problems It is easily seen that if N is a normal operator, then so is ever 90
y operator M in the closure U(N)- of U(N). In this case, U(N)- admits a very simple characterization. The following result is straightforward.
LEMMA 4.8. If N
E
={ME L(H):
U(N)
L(H) is normal, then M is normal, a(M) =a(N),ae(M) =ae(N) and
nul(A-M) =nul(A-N)
for aU A£ a(N)\ae(N)}.
We have the following PROPOSITION 4.9. If M is a normal operator suah that cr(M) is a
perfect set, K is compact and cr(M+K) = a(M), then M
; M+K. s1.m
PROOF. I t is easily seen that ae (M) = ae (M+K) =a (U) • Let N be a diagonal normal operator such that a(N) = a(M), i.e., Ne =A e with oo oo n nn respect to some ONB {en}n=l and {An}n=l is dense in a(M). Assume,mor~ over, that all the eigenvalues of N have infinite multiplicity. By Lemma 4. 8,
U(M)- = U(N)-; furthermore, the BDF theorem implies that M
is unitarily equivalent to a compact perturbation of N. In other words, N can be chosen s.o that M- N is compact, and therefore M + K = N+C, where C = !M- N) +K E K (H). Clearly, a (N+C) =a (M+K) = a(M) = a(N). Since N " U(M) suf~icient
c
S(M)-, i t follows that
K s!m N. Hence, i t is
to show that N s!m N+C. Let Pn be the orthogonal projection
of H onto
y{e 1 ,e 2 , ••• ,en}; then IIC-PnCPnll + 0 (n +oo) (recall is compact), and therefore IICN+C)- [{1-P )N(l-P )+P (N+C)P Jll= n n n n CP II + 0 ( n + oo) • n By using this observation and the upper semicontinuity of spectrum (Corollary 1.2(ii)), given e: > 0 we can find m=m(e:) that lie- PmCPmll < e:/2 and max{disHA,a(N) J:
that C 1""-P ~ n the
such
A E a[Pm(N+C)Pm]} < e:/2.
(since a(N) is a perfect set) we can find an operator Fm E L(ran
Thus,
Pm) such that IIFm- Pm(N+C)Pmlran Pmll < e:/2 and a(Fm) is a set of m · t po1.nts · · . d J.StJ.nc ~l m ,~ 2 m , ••• ,~mm o f t h e po1.nt spectrum o f N. Let FE F(H) be the operator defined by:
Flran P =F
m
m
and
Flran (1-Pm) =0. Then II!N+C)- (N+Flll = llc-FII s IIC-PmCPnJ~!Fm-Pm(N+C) Pm11+11Fm- (F+N) Iran P~ll < e:, N+F
o:
N$Fm and N8Fm-N, whence the result
follows.
0
COROLLARY 4.10. If T E L(H),
boundary u (U) =
n-,
r = an
n
is an analytic Cauchy domain with
containinig a (T) and M is a normal operator such that
then
M s+J.'m M$M+(r) (oo)$T, M
+ M$M+(r) (oo), M + M$M_(r) (oo). sim sim
PROOF. By Lemma 4.8, Corollary 4.5 and Proposition 4.9, -t M(co) ; (M$M (f)) (oo) = t-!(oo) eM (r) (oo) T M$M (f) (co) S1m S1m + + S1m + and (by a similar argument) M -t M$M (f) Coo). S1m On the other hand, by Corollary 3.37, M+(f) (co) T M+(f) (oo)eT, (oo) s1m whence we readily obtain M s!m MeM+ ( r) $T. 0 .M
4.2 Matrix models for operators
LetT" L(HJ and let
~n=O.."
interior(~n>- (1 s lnl
pF(T): ind(A.-T) =n}. Define nn= (so that fln=interior(fln)-), and
N+(T) =en:l N+Cn_n) (n), N_(T) =en:l [N+(Sln*)*J(n), where N+(fl) is defined by (4.4). THEOREM 4.11. Given T" LIHJ, thePe sition H = H+eH 0 eH- suah that T+K "'
I
e~ist
K" K(HJ and a deaompo-
N+ (T) * 0 B 0
(4. 6)
0 N
pespect to that decomposition, whePe B is a smooth opePatoP and o(B) = oe(B) = oe(T).
~ith
PROOF. By Theorem 3.48, we can find K1 " KIHJ such that T+K 1 is smooth. Since 3ae(N+(T))u3ae(N_(T))=3(ulsjnj
fln)
c
a(ulsjnj
~n)
c
3oe(T),
which is contained in aire(T), it follows from Theorem 3.49 and Corollary 3.50 that
(with respect to a suitable decomposition of the space) , where N+ and N- are normal operators such that o(N+) =ae(N+) =oe(N+(T)) and o(N-) = a (N-) =a (N (T)) , respectively. e e Observe that lim(n-+ oo) {meas 2 (n n )+meas 2 (fl -n ) } = 0 and that the stronger form Qf the Berger-Shaw trace inequality for the operators N+ W_n) and N+ (rln *) * says that tr[N+(rln*)*,N+(fln*)J s and 92
(l/~)meas 2 (fln)
tr[N+{rl-n)*,N+(Q-n)] s (l/'lf)meas 2
It is not difficult to conclude that [N+(T)*,N+(T) ], [N_(T)*,N_ [N~(T)*,N~(T)] and [N:(T)*,N~(T) ], where
N' (T) =ED "" N (Q )(n) and N' (T) =ED "" [N (0 *) *] (n) n=l + -n n=l + n ' + are compact operators. Hence, by the BDF theorem (Theorem 4.1; see also Corollary 4.6), N+ (N-, resp.) is unitarily equivalent to a compact perturbation of N+(T)EDN~(T) (N~(T)EDN_(T), resp.), i.e., there exists a compact operator K3 such that
(T+K1 +K 2 )+K 3
0 N+ (T) 0 N: (T) 0 0 0 0 0 0
* * *
* * Bl 0 0
N~(T)
0
where
- [N~ 0(T)
B2 -
0
* * * 0 N (T)
*
:
0
N' (T)
B1
=
r··
0(T) B•2 *• J , 0 0 N_(T)
l •
+ Finally, by Theorem 3.49, there exists a compact operator K4 K4EDO (K4 acting on the subspace corresponding to B2 ) such that
~
OED
where B = B2+K4 is a smooth operator. In particular, cr(B) = cr'li(B) =cre(B)u{X
E
pF(B):
ind(X-B) "O}=cre(B)u{pF(B)ncr(B)}.
Let K = K1 +K 2+K 3+K 4 ; then (see observations after Corollary 3.41) ~
N+ ci> * [ 0 § 0
0
Since cre(N+(T))ucre(NjT)) c cre(T), we readily conclude that cre(B) must also be contained in a (T). Uoreover, since a (N+(T))ucr (N (T)) = e e e cse(N+' (T)) ucre(N'- (T)) c a e (B), it follows that a e (B) =a e (T). Thus, in or der to complete the proof it only remains to show that pF (B) ncr (B) = [1. Assume it is not true. Then X- B is a non-invertible Fredholm operator for some complex X; furthermore, by stability properties of the index (Corollary 1.14(i)), we can directly assume that X does not belong to the nowhere dense set ae(N+(T))ucre(N_(T)). By smoothness, ind 93
{).-B) =m~O. Now, i f A E p;{T) =p;(N+{T)), then A j. pF(N_.(T))ncr(N_(T)) and it is straightforward that ind(A- T) = ind(A- N+ (T)) +ind(A- B) = ind(A- T) +m, a contradiction. + (T) = pF+ (N_(T) ). A similar argument proves that A cannot belong to pF Since A j. p;{.T)up;(T), it follows that 0 = ind(A- T) = ind(A- B) =m, a new contradiction. We conclude that pF (B) ncr (B) =fl. Therefore, the compact operator K satisfies all our requirements. 0 4.12. In the above theorem (as in Corollary 4.7), we had to use the stronger inequality RE~~
tr[N+(!'l)*,N+(fl)J s (l/Tr)meas 2 (fl) (not fl
:)
in order to guarantee that N+(T) and N_(T) have compact self-commutators. Given e, 0 < e < 1, it is not difficult to construct denumerably many pairwise disjoint open connected subsets n 1 , n 2 , ••• , nn'''' of the unit square ({a.+ia: o s a.,a s 1}) with an =an 1 fol' aZZ n=l,2, .. n n . .. , such that meas 2 (!'ln) < e/2 , n = 1, 2,... • In th~s case, meas 2 meas 2 (ann> > 1-e for all n = 1, 2, ••• The following theorem provides a representation for T modulo compact operators, "symmetric" to the representation (4.6). Its proof fol lows by the same arguments as in Theorem 4.11 and will be omitted.
THEOREU 4.13. Given T E L(H), thel'e exist C sition H = H_IDH 0 1DH+ such that T+C "' [
N_(T) * 0 B 0
respect to that decomposition, a(B) =cre(B) =cre(T).
~ith
E
K(H) and a decompo-
(4. 7)
0 ~hel'e
B
is a smooth opel'ator and
REMARK 4.14. If T is essentially normal, then it directly follows from the BDF theorem that T- F "' N+ (T) IDBIDN_ (T) (for a suitable compact operator F), where B is a normal operator such that a (B) = ae (B) = ae(T).
4.3 Spectra of compact perturbations of operators 94
Now we are in a position to improve the qualitative parts of sition 3.45 and Theorem 3.48.
Prop~
THEOREf.1 4.15. LetT e: L{H). If {n} M is an enumeration of the n ne: bounded components of ps-F (T) (!JJhere either M = {1, 2, ••• ,m} or M is the set of aZZ natuPaZ. numbePs), {d } r• is a family of non-negative inten ne: ·• gePs, {Ak}ke:K (bJhePe either K = {1,2, ••• ,r} oP K is the set of alZ. nat!! raZ. numbePs) is an at most denumerable subset of p s- F(T) !JJith no accumuZation point in ps-F(T) and {Jk}ke:K is a family of operatoPs acting on spaces of positive finite dimension such that a(Jk) = {Ak} (k e; K), then thePe e~ists a compact opePatoP C such that (i) a(T+C) =al'l(T)u{Ak}u[u{On: dn > O}J; (ii) p:_F(T+C) = {Ak} and (T+Cl 0 IH 0 (Ak:T+C) ~ Jk foP all k e: K (whePe (T+C) 0 is the centPal opePatoP in the Apostol's tPiangulaP repPesentation (3.8) of T+CJ; and (iii) min.ind(T+C-A) =dn fop aZZ A e: On\{Ak}. COROLLARY 4.16. Let T e L(H) and let a be the union of aw(T) and some bounded components of ~\aw(T); then thepe e~ists K e: K!HI such that a (T+K) = a. In paPticular, thePe e~ists K0 e: K!HI such that ~\a(T+K0 ) is connected. PROOF OF THEOREM 4.15. By Theorem 3.40 there exists c 1 e: K{H) such that
where M is a diagonal normal operator such that M "' M(ao) and a(M) =a e (M) = a... re (T) , and a... re (B 1 l= a... re (T) • By Theorem 3.48, we can find c 2 e: K{HI (which only modifies the action of B1 ) such that :], and n B2 is a smooth compact perturbation of B1 . Clearly, T+C 1 +c 2 is also smooth. Let in= ind(T+C 1 +c 2 -A) = ind(B 2-A), A e: On (-ao s in s ao). Since the Ak's do not accumulate in ps-F(T), we can find points pk (k e: K) in ap (H) such that I Ak- Pkl + 0 (k + co). Let J+ = Gl{Jk_: Ak e pr(D 2 )} and J_ = 95
I9{Jk: Xk € p1(B2)}, where Jk - Jk is any operator such that IIJk- Xk II < 1/k for all k € K. It is easily seen that there exist compact pertur bations M+ and M- of U such that t-1+ = MIBJ+ and M- = Iii9J_, respectively. Now we can proceed as in the proof of Theorem 4.11 in order to ob tain a compact operator c 3 such that J o
o T+C 1 +e 2+c 3 =
0 IO * * * I N_ 1 o * * * -o- 1 N'_*_ '* I
*
-
* * *
I
0 0 o
0 1 0 B2 * 1 * * 0 1 0 0 N' I 0 0 o Lo- o -o±:N+_o_
o
o
o
o o 1o
J+
where N+ = IB{N+(gn) (dn): in~ 0, dn > 0}, N_ = 19{ N+(On*)* (dn): in < 0, dn > 0}, J_eN_eN: and N~IBN+IBJ+ are compact perturbations of ~1 and
B3
N'
= [0
0
l
* *
B2
* .
0
N~
Finally, we can use Theorem 3.48 (as in the proof of Theorem 4.1U in order to find a compact operator c 4 (which only modifies the action of B3 ) such that T+C 1+C 2+C 3+c 4 = [J-:N- : 0
:
l
(B is smooth).
0 N+IBJ+
Let C=C 1 +c 2+c 3+c 4 (clearly, C € K(H}). It can be easily checked that cr(J_) =crp(J_)- c {Ak}ucr.ll.re(T), o(J+) =crp(J+)- c {Xk}uo.ll.re(T), pss- F(T+C) c {Xk} and (since B is smooth) min.ind(T+C-X) = d n for all X € On\{Xk}, so that crW(T)u[u{Qn:
dn > 0}]
c
On the other hand, if Xk
P.~~,{[:
o(T+C) €
c
oW(T)u{Xk}u[u{Qn:
op(J_) then Xk
p.II.(B)np(N+IBJ+) =
€
N+:J+)) and Corollary 3.22 implies that T
dn > 0}].
~
Jki9Tk, where Xk
£
p~-F(Tk). A similar argument implies that the same result holds for Xk
crp(J+), whence we obtain (ii). Since (i) and (iii) follow immediately from (ii) and our previous observations, we are done. 0 £
4.4 Voiculescu's theorem
96
*:C
~
An abstract C*-algebra is a Banach algebra C with an operation C satisfying the conditions: (i) (a*)*=a, a € C; (ii) (a+b) * = a*+b*, a,b € c; (iii) (>..a)*=Xa*, >. € a:, a € c; (iv) (ab) * = b*a*, a,b € c; and (v) llall2 = lla*all• a E c.
(An operation *:C
~
C satisfying (i)- (iv) is called an involution.)
The most obvious example of a C*-algebra is L(H), with * equal to the usual'adjoint operation'. Given a (finite or denumerable) family {Tn} of operators in L(H), we shall denote by C*({Tn}) the C*-algebra generated by the Tn's and the identity operator, i.e., the minimal norm-closed algebra containing 1, T1 , T2 , ••• , Tn•··· and T!, T~, •.• , T*, •••• Every separable C*-subalgebra of L (H) (containing the identn ity) has this form. If {Tn} = {T} consists of a single operator, then we shall simply write C*(T) instead of C*({T}). A *-representation p of d C*-algebra C on a Hilbert space Hp is an operator p from C into L(H ) which preserves products (i.e., p is a p homomorphism of rings: p (ab) = p (a) p (b)) and involutions (i.e., p(a*) = p(a)* in L(H p )) • I f C has an identity e and p(e) =1 , then pis ca! led unital; p is faithful if it has a trivial kernel. It is well-known that a *-representation p is faithful if and only if it is an isometric mapping from C onto p(C) c L(HP) (see, e.g., [37], [72], [l76J). The following classical result can be found in any of these reference~ THEOREl1 4.17 (Gelfand-Naimark-Segal theorem). Every abstract C*algebra C with identity admits a faithful unital *-representation p in L(H ) for a suitable Hilbert space H , i.e., C is isometrically *-isoP p morphia to a C*-algebra of operators. Furthermore, if C is separable, then Hp can be chosen separable. Since we are only interested in separable C*-algebras, every Hilbert space (H, H , etc) considered here will be separable. p Two *-representations p 1 :C ~ L(H 1 ) and p 2 :C ~ L(H 2 ) are unitarily equivalent (or, simply, equivalent) if there is a unitary operator U from H1 onto H2 such that p 2 (a) =Up 1 (a)U* for all a E C; p 1 and p 2 are approximately equivalent (p 1 ~a p 2 ) if there is a sequence of unitary operators Un:H 2 ~ H1 such that p (a) -Unp 2 (a)U~ ~ K(H 1 ) (n=l,2, ••• ) and { 1 lim(n ~co) IIPl(a) -Unp2(a)U~II=O
(4. 8)
97
for each a
E
C. It is easily seen that
~a
is an equivalence relation.
THEOREM 4.18. (i) Let C be a separable C*-algebra with identity and let p:C + L(HP) be a unital *-representation of C. Let y be a uni! al *-representation of n•p(C) (c A(HP)) on a Hilbert space Hy. Then p
~a
p$yonop.
(ii) Let p 1 and p 2 be two unital *-representations of C on HiZbert spaces H1 and H2 , respectively, and let Hj = {pj (a)x: a E ker n• Pj' X E H.}-, j=l,2. The the following are equivalent:
J (1)
Pl "'a P2· There is a sequence of unitary operators Un:H 2 .•. ) such that (2)
lim(n (3)
II P1 (a)
+ oo)
- Unp 2 (a) U~ II= 0, for each a
E
+
H1 (n=l,2,
C.
There exist sequences of unitary operators Un:H 2
+
H1 and Vn:
H1 + H2 (n=l,2, .•• ) such that UnP 2 (a)U~ +
p1 (a)
and
Vnp 1 (a)V~ +
p 2 (a),
in the weak operator topology, for each a E C. (4) ker P1 = ker p 2 , ker nap 1 = ker 1fop 2 and the *-representations of C on Hi and induced by p 1 and p2 , respectively, are equivalent. (5) ker P1 = ker P2 , ker 11aP 1 = ker 11oP 2 and the *-representations of ker 71•P 1 ~m Hi and Hi induced by P_t and p2' resp., al"e equivalent.
Hi
Recall that a *-representation p of a C*-algebra C on HP is irreducible if there is no non-trivial subspace M of HP reducing all oper~ tors in p(C). COROLLARY 4.19.· (i) Every unital *-representation of a separable C*-algebra with identity is approximately equivalent to a direct sum of irreducible *-representations. (ii) Let p be a unital *-representation of a separable C*-algebra C on a Hilbert space Hp. In order that all unital *-representations of C appro:x:imately equivalent to p be actually equivalent to p it is neces sary and sufficient that p(C) be finite-dimensional. COROLLARY 4.20. Let p 1 , p 2 be infinite dimensional unital *-repr~ sentations of a separable C*-algebra C with identity; then (i) If ker p 1 =ker p 2 and neither p 1 (C) nor p 2 (C) contains any non-•ro compact operator, then P 1 "'a P 2 • (ii) If ker p 2 ~ ker 1r•p 1 , then p 1 ep 2 "'a p 1 • 98
4.5 Closures of unitary orbits Let T € L(H) and let C*{T) be the C*-algebra generated by T and the identity. Denote by p0 the identity *-representation of C*{T) on H ( p0 (A) =A for each A in C* {T)) and let S be any operator in U{T)-. It is easily seen that C' (T) = {L € L(H): {UnLU~}n:l is a Cauchy sequence in L(H) for each seque~ce {Un} in U(H) such that {UnTU~}n:l is Cauchy} is a C*-algebra containing C* {T) and therefore there is a (necessarily unique) unital *-representation p1 of C* {T) on H such that p1 {T) = S. {This representation is defined as follows: I f liS- UnTU~ II .... 0 {n + oo) for a suitable sequence {Un}n:l in U(H), then pl {A) = {norm) lim{n .... oo) un AU*n I A € C* {T) . ) Since T € U{S)-, it is not difficult to check that p1 is also faithful: indeed, p1 ~a p0 • Conversely, if p1 is a unital *-represent~ tion of C* (T) on H and p1 ~a p0 {clearly, this p1 is faithful), then p 1 {T) belongs to the closure of the unitary orbit of T = p0 {T). 4.5.1 Operator-valued spectrum and unitary orbits The above remarks and the results of Section 4.4 have the following direct consequences. PROPOSITION 4.21. Let T € L(H); then (i) S € U{T) if and onZy if there e~ist sequences {U0 }n:l and {Vn}n:l of unitary operators suah that Un TU~ -+ S (weakZy)
and
VnSV~
+
T (UJeak Zy ) .
(ii) If p is a unitaZ *-representation of C*{!) on H and p{T) A, then there e~ist s 1 , s 2 € U{T) suah that s 1 ~TeA, s 2 ~ T8A{oo}.(If p0 is the identity *-representation of C*{T), then p0 ~a p0 8p ~a p0 8 p {""). )
(iii) B= p(T) for some unitaZ *-representation p of C*{T) if and only if either T has a reduaing subspaae M suah that TIM ~ B or there exists a sequenae {T } ""1 in LIHI suah that T ~ B{oo)eT' (for suitabZe n n= n n operators T~, n=l,2, ••• J and IIT-Tnll+ 0 {n-+ oo}. (iv) If S € U{T)- and E > 0, there is a unitary operator U suah that S-UTU* € K(H) and IIS-UTU*II < E· (v) There exists S € U{T) suah that S is an infinite direat sum of irreduaibZe operators.
99
PROPOSITION 4.22. The follo~ing are equivalent forT in L(H): (i) U(T) is closed. (ii) C*(T) is finite dimensional. (iii) T "'AEBB(co) ~ ~here A E L(~)~ B E L(a:n) for some pair (m,n), 0 s m < co, 1 s n < co. COROLLARY 4.23. The set of all reducible operators is dense in Furthermore~ given Tin L(H) and E > 0~ there exists K E K(Hl~ < E~ such that T+K is reducible.
L(H). IlK II
REMARK 4.24. Given ann-tuple T= (T 1 ,T 2 , ••. ,Tn) er its unitary orbit {(UT 1U*,UT 2U*, ••• ,UTnU*)
E
L(H)(n):
L(H) (n), consid
E
u
E
U(H)}.
We shall say that Tis reducible if T1 , T 2 , ••. , Tn have a joint reducing subspace. Clearly, in this framework, the results of Section 4.4 imply that the analogues of Propositions 4.21 and 4.22 and Corolar y 4.23 hold for n-tuples. In order to determine U(T) in concrete terms we shall need the following definition: The operator-valued spectrum E(T) ofT E L(H) is the set of all those operators A acting on some subspace of dimension n, 1 s n
U(T)-, we shall say that T and S are approximately unitar£ ly equival~nt operators (T "'a S). It is easily seen that "'a is an equivalence relation and that T "' S implies that T 7 S and S 7 T. s~ s~ a With the above definition in mind, we have the following characterization of U(T)-: E
THEORIDt 4.25. Suppose
T~
S
E
L(H). Then T "'aS if and only if
I: (T) = I: (S) •
4.5.2 Concrete examples of closures of unitary orbits From Proposition 4.2l(iv), we obtain PROPOSITION 4.26. If N E L(H) is normal, L is a diagonal normal operator in U(N) and E > 0~ then there exists U E U(H) such that N - ULU* 100
E
K(H)
and
II N - ULU* II <
E•
Hence, every normal operator is equal to a diagonal operator up to a compact perturbation of arbitrarily small norm It is not difficult to check that if T € L(H) then H can be written as
HNor(T)eHAbnor(T), where HNor(T) and HAbnor(T) reduce T, TNor
= TIHNor(T) is normal (= the normal part of T) and TAbnor = TIHAbnor(T)
(= the abnormal part of T) has no nontrivial reducing subspace M such that TIM is normal; more precisely, HNor(T) =nn:l ker[T*n,Tn]. (Of course, HNor(T) and HAbnor(T)can be infinite dimensional, finite dimensional or even {0}.) PROPOSITION 4.27. If T, S c L(H) and Tis essentiaZZy normaZ, then T "' a S if and onZy if SAb nor "' TAb nor ,ae (S) =ae (T) and nul(A-S) for azt >. E(o(S)uo(T)]\cre('l').InparHcuZar,if K € K(H), then
= nul(A-T) U(K)- = {C €
Kfi,J) c
C "' KAbnoreod, wheztll Od is the 0 opeztato;ro acting on
a subspace of dimension d, 0 s d s ""• and d+dim HAbnor (K) = ""}.
PROPOSITION 4. 28. If T is hypono;romaZ and T = TAbnor• then U(T)
=>
{S c L{fl):
S"' TeN, N is no;romaZ and o(N) c oJT)}.
4.5.3 On normal and quasinilpotent restrictions Let T E L(H) and let {An} be a (finite or denumerable) sequence of distinct points of 01 e(T). According to Theorem 3.40, there exists a compact operator K1 such that - (Ni * ) Hl T+Kl- 0 Al Hl.l' where N1 € L(H 1 ) is a diagonal normal operator such that N1 "' (diag{Al' A2 , ••• ,An•···}l (co) and oe(A1 l =cre(T), ore
0
l~~ '
: Nr
H3
where Nr"' (diag{Jl 1 ,~ 2 , ••• ,~m'"""}) (oo). Let r = {A }- = cr (N ) = cr (N ) and r = { ~ } - = cr (N ) = cr (N ) and conin 1 et r m r er sider the (separable!) C*-algcbra C=C*({'f;ts1 ,ts 2 , ••• ,tsn, ••• ;it1 ,tt 2 , ••• , Rm, ..• }) generated by r, If and the images in the Calkin algebra of the orthogonal projections Pn (onto ker (An- N1 ) ; n = 1, 2, ••• ) and- Rut (onto 101
ker(l.lm- Nr) 1 m= 1,2, ••• ) • Let p:C ~ L(H ) be a faithful unital *-representation. Since
(1-~j~l Pn)(T+K)~j~l Pn=O, ~k=l~A(l-~k=ll\) =0, it is not difficult to conclude that
p(~)
(•) •
[~· ~ ~~-
By Proposition 4.21, we have PROPOSITION 4.29. LetT£ L(H) and let r 1 and rr be closed subsets of a. (T) and a (T), respectively. Then there exists S = T such ... e re a that
s •
TO[~• ~ ~rl·
~here
N1 and Nr are diagonal normal operators of uniform infinite multiplicity such that a (N 1 ) = ae (N 1 l = r 1 and a (Nr) = ae (Nr) = r r• respectively. COROLLARY 4.30. LetT£ L(H). If r is a closed subset of ae(T) and N is a normal operator such that a (N) = ae (N) = r, then there exists an operator A such that Ps-F (A) = Ps-F (T) \f > {
m~n.ind (A-A) k =min. ind (A-T) k for aZZ A
£
ps-F(A)
(4.9)
k-1,2, ••• , and
T slm NIBA. PROOF. Clearly r can be written as r = r 1 ur r' where r 1 c a R.e (T) and rr c are(T) are closed sets. Let S be the operator constructed in Proposition 4.287 then, by Lemma 3.36, we have T =a S sim TIB(N 11BBIBNr) = (N 119Nr)IB(TIBB). Clearly, a(N 11BNr) =ae(N 11BNr) = r, so that N119Nr =aN (Lemma 4.8). Let A be an operator unitarily equivalent to NIBTIBB. It is completely apparent that ps-F(A) c ps-F(T)\r. On the other hand, since p is fai~ ful, it readily follows that p s- F(B) =p s-F(B)up-s- F(B), p s- F(B) => p s- F (T)\f, p;:F(B) => p;:F(T)\r and p~-F(B)n(ps-F(T)\f) =~,whence we imme diately conclude that A satisfies (4.9). Since (N IBNr)IB(TIBB) ~a NIBA, we are done. 0 00
102
00
00
00
Applying Corollary 3.50 to the direct summand of S unitarily equivalent top(~)<~> (in Proposition 4.28), we obtain COROLLARY 4.31. LetT € L(H) and Zet rR. and rr be aZosed subsets of a... e (T) and a re (T). respeativeZy. Given e > 0 and normal operators NR. and Nr suah that rR. c cr(NR.) =cre(NR.) c (fR.)e and rr c a(Nr) =ae(Nr) c (r ) • there e:r:ists L € L (H) suah that r e:
L [~R. :1 : ]• 0
0
Nr
Ps-F(L) =ps-F(T)\[cr(Nr)ucr(NR.)J. min.ind(A-L)k=min.ind(A-T)k for all A € ps-F(L). k=l,2, ••.• and IIT-LII < 2e:. (Apply Lemma 4.8 to the result of the first modification.) LetT € L(HJ and assume that~ is an isolated point of ae(T). If e: > 0 is small enough to guarantee that {A: I A - ~I s e:} ncr e (T) ~},
={
then
1 I R = 2'1Ti IA-~I=e:
(A - T) -l dA
defines an idempotent commuting with T (in the Calkin algebra). This idempotent can be lifted to an idempotent R € L(H) such that ae(RTRI ran R) = {~} (RTR=RT=TR modulo K(H)) _ and a e ((1-R)T(l-R)) lker R) =a e 1 (T) \ { ~}. Let W € G (H) be such that WRW = P is an orthogonal projection and let L = WTW-l: then L = B$ (ll+Q) + (compact) for some B such that ll I ae(B) and Q is a quasinilpotent operator acting on the infinite dimensional reducing subspace H of L. ~ Let p:C*(~+Q) ~ LIH ) be a faithful unital *-representation of p C*(~+Q). Clearly, O$p is a (not faithful, unless B acts on a finite dimensional space!) unital *-representation of C*(L). By Proposition 4.2l(ii), L "'a L$(~+G)(co)' where G=p(Q). It readily follows that T ~ T$(~+G) (co) : furthermore, since p is sim faithful, we can use Corollary 1.8 to show PROPOSITION 4.32. Let T E L(H) and assume that cre(T) has an ted point ll· Then there e:r:ists a quasinitpotent G such that T
~
s~m
T$(l-[+G)
(co)
isoZ~
•
Moreover. if
103
{
(A -p) k in some open neighborhood of P.
0, in some open neighborhood of cre(T)\{p},
(k = 1, 2, ••• ) • then Gk = 0 if and onZ.y if fk (T) = 0.
4.6 Irreducible operators According to Corollary 4.23, every operator has an arbitrarily small compact perturbation which is reducible. If reducible is replaced by irreducible, the result is still true. In fact, in this case the answer is much stronger and the proof is definitely simpler. Hore precisely, we have LEf·if1A 4.33. The set of aZ.Z. irreduaibZ.e operators is dense in L(Hl. Furthermore, given Tin L(H), p > 1 and 0 < e < 1, there e~ists Kp in cP(Hl. IKPIP < e. such that T+Kp is irreduaibZ.e. PROOF. Let T = A+iB (Cartesian decomposition) • According to the Weyl-von Neumann-Kuroda theorem (see, e.g., [153, p. 525,Theorem 2.3]), there exists K1 E cP(Hl, IK 1 1 < e/3 such that A+K 1 is a diagonal herP ® ® mitian operator with respect to some ONB {en}n=l of H. Let {An}n=l be the sequence of corresponding eigenvalues (i.e., (A+Kl) e = A e , n = 1, . n n n 2, ••• ). It is easily seen that now we can find K2 E c1(1f), IK 2 11 <E/3. K2 an hermitian diagonal operator (with respect to the same ONB) such that (A+K 1 +K 2 )en=pnen' n=l,2, ... , and the pn's are all distinct. It is not difficult to check that A' (A+K 1 +K 2 ) =A (A+K 1 +K 2 ) = {B E L(H): B = ~n:lynen@len (strong limit of partial sums)} is the set of all diagonal normal operators with respect to that basis. In particular, a subspace M reduces A+K 1 +K 2 if and only if PM=~ {ejt!lej: j E N (M)}, where N (M) is a subset of the natural numbers (N (M) = { j: e. E J M}). Assume that j E N(M), but h t N(M) and let R E L(H) be such that either ~ 0 or ~ o. It is easily seen that R cannot commute.with PM' i.e., M does not reduceR. Let B = (b 'k) . k:l be the matrix of B with respect to the ONB J J, {e } : 1 and let 0 < n < e/6. Define K by n n2 3 n 4 n n /2 n /3 n /4 •
n2 /2 n3/3 n4 /4 n3/3 n4 /4 •
K
104
n
= n4/4
•
Then IKnll ~ ~n=l n(nn/n)=n/(1-n) < e:/3. Since the set {b J"k}.],k":.l is at most denumerable, there exists some n such that bjk+nj+k/(j+k) ;.o, for all j,k=l,2, •.•
( 4 .10)
Let K3 =Kn for some n• 0 < n < e/6, satisfying (4.10). Then B+K 3 cannot be reduced by any nontrivial reducing subspace of A+K1 +K 2 • Thus, T+(K 1 +K 2+iK 3 ) is irreducible and
THEOREf.f 4.34. (i) The set of aU ir:roeduCJibl.e operator'S is a GcS dense subset of LIH). (ii) The set of a1.1. redueibl.e operators is an F dense subset of a
LIHl.
PROOF. According to Corollary 4.23 and Lemma 4.33, it only remains to show that the set R(H) of all irreducible operators is an Fa. Let P be the set of all those hermitian operators H for which 0 ~ H ~ 1. Recall that P is exactly the weak closure of the set of all projections. Let P0 = P\ { ;>.,: ). " a:}. Since P is a weakly closed subset of the closed unit ball of L (H) , it is weakly compact, and hence the weak topology for P is metrizable. Since the set of all multiples of the identity is weakly closed, it follows that P0 is weakly locally compact. Since the weak topology has a countable base, the same is true for P0 , and therefore P0 is weakly a-compact. Let P1 , P2 , ••• , be weakly co~pact subsets of P0 such that un:l Pn = P0 • Let Pn ={A" L(H): AH=HA for A some H" P} (n=l,2, ••• ); the n spectral theorem implie~ that un:l Pn = R (H) • Suppose that~ " Pn (k = 1,2, ••• ) and II~- All-+ 0 (k -+co). For each k, find an Hk " Pn such ~Hk = Hk~. Since Pn is weakly compact and metrizable, there is no loss of generality in assuming that the sequence {Hk}k:l is weakly convergent to H " Pn. CLAnh
AH = HA.
Indeed, if x,y " H, then
~ 11~-AII·IIxii·IIYII+I<(~-H>x,A*y>l-+
o
(k-+ co).
Hence, ~Hk + AH (weakly, as k + ~>. By taki~g adjoints, we can similarly ch:ck that Hk~-+ HA and therefore A" Pn. Hence, P is closed (n=l,2, ••• ) and therefore R(H) is an F (in n a the norm topology) • 0 105
4.7 Notes and remarks The BDF theorem and the Berger-Shaw trace inequality have been pu~ lished in the "Proceedings of a Conference on Operator Theory, Halifax, Nova Scotia, 1973", Lecture Notes in Mathematics Volume 345, Springer Verlag, Berlin-Heidelberg-New York, 1973 (see [60], [50]). The interested reader can also consult [61], [62], [49] and W. B. Arveson's su~ vey article [38]. Lemma 4.3 is a portion of Proposition 2 of D. A. Herrero's article [146]. The present proof of the Berger-Shaw trace inequality (Theorem 4.4) combines four ingredients: (I) is an argument due to D. Voiculescu [196,Proposition 1]. This argument has been independently discovered by c. Berger (unpublished result; see also comments in [196]); (II) is a classical result (see, e.g., [SO,Theorem 1]); (III) is an "ad hoc" modification of the second computational lemma of C. A. Berger and B. I. Shaw [49]; and (IV) is an observation of D. A. Herrero. An extended version of the Berger-Shaw trace inequality can be found in the above mentioned article of D. Voiculescu. The reader is referred to [66], [167] and [168] for a detailed account of the theory of hyponormal operators. Proposition 4.9 is [133,Lemma 1]. The matrix models for operators are due to C. Apostol [6] and Theorem 4.15 is a consequence of those constructions and Apostol's triangular representation. Corollary 4.16 (in fact, a stronger form of it) was proved by C. Apostol, C. M. Pearcy and N. Salinas in [28]. The notion (4.8) of approximately equivalent *-representationsand all the results of Sections 4.4 and 4.5.1 are contained in the article [195] by D. Voiculescu, except for the equivalence between (1) and (3) of Theorem 4.18, which has been independently obtained by W. Arvesonin the above mentioned survey article (see [38,Theorem 5]) and by D. W. Hadwin [112,Corollary 4.2] (indeed, Hadwin established it in a slightly weaker form), and Theorem 4.25 is also due to Hadwin [112,Corollary 3.6]. Hadwin's reducing operator-valued spectrum E(T) has been modelled on J. Ernest's operator-valued spectrum [80] and the reducing essentiai matricial spectra of operators of C. M. Pearcy and N. Salinas. (See [160], [164], [165], [166], [179]. The article [63] of J. Bunce and N. Salinas is also relevant in this context.) The different pieces of E(T) in [112] correspond to the possibilities offered byProposition 4.21 (ill): namely: 1) A is in the assentiaZ Peducing .opePatoP spectPum of T, denoted by Ee(T), if A(•) E E(T); 2) If n is a positive integer, then 106
the n-dimensionaZ reducing operator spectrum ofT, denoted by En(T), is E(T)nL(~n) and the n-dimensionaZ essentiaZ reducing operator spectrum
ofT, denoted by En(T), is Ee (T)nL(~n); 3) The infinite-dimensionaZ e reducing operator spectrum ofT, denoted by E®(T), is E(T)nL(H), and the infinite-dimensionaZ essentiaZ reducing operator spectrum of T, de noted by r:(T), is Ee(T)nL(H). In [112] Hadwin also proved (Theorem 3.9) that U(T)- is always arcwise connected, thus extending the corresponding result for normal operators, previously obtained by R. Gellar and L. Page in [104] (see also [85]). Proposition 4.26 is essentially the I. D. Berg's extension to no~ mal operators of the classical Weyl-von Neumann theorem on diagonaliz~ tion of hermitian operators via small compact perturbations [47J.(This result has also been independently obtained by w. Sikonia in his doctoral dissertation; see [186].) Propositions 4.27 and 4.28 are essentially due to D. W. Hadwin [111] and to C. M. Pearcy and N. Salinas [162] (see also [160]). Proposition 4.29 was proved in [97] in connection with a problem of quasisimilarity of operators; see also [58], [160]. The problem of characterizing closures of unitary orbits has been developed by D. W. Hadwin in his doctoral dissertation [111] and in [1121. His ideas and techniques go beyond this particular problem. The interested reader can also consult Hadwin's papers [113], [114] and [54] (joint work with A. Brown and c.-K. Fang), and the closely related articles [101] and [191]. Lemma 4.33 is a mild improvement of a result of P. R. Halmos. That result and Theorem 4.34 are contained in [120]. The proof of Lemma 4~3 given here is due to H. Radjavi and P. Rosenthal [170]. It is convenient to remark that Voiculescu's Corollary 4.23 affirmatively answers in the most complete form Halmos' Problem 8: Is every operator the norm-limit of reducible ones? [123,p.919]. In [116], D. w. Hadwin extended Voiculescu's theorem (and many other related results) to cover the case of non-separable C*-algebras and operators acting on non-separable spaces.
107
5 Limits of nilpotent and algebraic operators
As a first application of the tools introduced in the previous two chapters, it will be shown that the closures of the set of all nil potent operators and the set of all algebraic operators can be characterized very simply in terms of the different parts of the spectrum. Essentially the same kind of arguments can be used to obtain two important results about closures of similarity orbits.
5.1 Limits of nilpotent operators THEOREM 5.1. The to~s
cZosu~e
of the set N(H) of aZZ nilpotent
one~a
acting on H coincides with the set of aZZ those A in L(H) satisfy-
ing the conditions:
cr(A) is connected and contains the o~igin; ae(A) is connected and contains the o~igin; and (iii) ind(~-A) = 0 fo~ aZZ ~ € Ps-F(A). (i)
(iiJ
Since cr(Q) = cre(Q)= {0} for each 0 € N(H), the necessity of (i) and (ii) follows at once from Corollary 1.6(i) and (iii), respectively. Since ~-Q is invertible (hence ind(~-Q) = 0) for all ~ ~ 0, the necessity of (iii) follows from Theorem 1.13(iii). The sufficiency of condi tions (i), (ii) and (iii) will be proven in two steps. REMARK 5.2. Theorem 5.1 implies, in particular, that every quasinilpotent operator is a limit of nilpotent ones.
5.1.1 Normal limits of nilpotents We have already shown (Proposition 2.28(ii)) that N(H)- contains a normal operator t1 such that cr(M) = 0(0,1)-, where D(ll,r) = 0 € a:: 1~-lll < r} is the disk of center ll and radius r > 0. By Lemma 4.8,
U(M)
108
= {N
€
L(H):
N is normal and cr(N)
Since rQ € N(H) for each Q in N(H) and each r > 0, it readily fol lows that N(H)- contains every normal operator whose spectrum is a disk centered at the origin. LEl~~ 5.3. Let N be a normal operator such that cre(N) has an accumuLation point A0 and Let Q € N(H); then N sim N$(A 0 +Q).
PROOF. Let {An}n:l be a sequence of distinct points of a (N) such e (co) that An->- Ao (n ->-co). By Lemma 4.8, N ~a N1 = N$(diag{A 0 ,A 1 ,A 2 , ••_.}) Assume that Q € Nk(H): then Q admits a canonical k x k operator matrix representation of the form
0
012 0
Ql3 Q23 0
Ql,k-1 Qlk 02,k-l Q2k 03,k-l Q3k
ker ~leker Qo ker o2eker 01 ker o 3 eker 02 (5 .1)
Q 0
0
0
Qk-leker 0k-2 ok-l,k ker 0 ker Qkeker Qk-l
k
(Clearly, ker Q = {O} and ker Q =H.) Replacing, if necessary, Q by Q~£qk(co) .!given by (2.1): 0 < £ << 1) we can directly assume that ker QJeker gJ-l is infinite dimensional for all j = 1,2, ••• ,k. Given n ~ 1, let Rn be the operator obtained by replacing the diagonal entries A0 in A0 +Q by An+l'An+ 2 , ••• ,An+k. It is easily seen that
By Corollary 3.22 and the above observation, _ k (co) k (co) ~ Nl$Rn->- Nl$(Ao+Q) Nl- Nle(ej=l An+j) - Nl$[($j=l An+j) +Q] (n->- co),
i.e., N
~a
N1 sim N$(A 0 +Q) •
D
Recall that the Hausdorff distance in the family BP(X) of all bounded nonempty subsets of a metric space (X,d) is the pseudoMetric defined by (5 .2)
Moreover, the restriction of d 8 to the family Bc(X} of all cZosed bounded nonempty subsets of X is ametric space: (Bc(X} ,d8 ). Lemma 4.8 and the "spreading the spectral measure argument" (that w~ have already applied, e.g., in Corollary 3.50) applied to-normal o~ 109
erators with spectra equal to their essential spectra, yields the following simple (but very useful!) result: LEMMA 5.4. If M and N al'e nol'maZ. opel'ators such that o(M) o(N) oe(N) and dH[o(M),o(N)] < E, then dist[M,U(N)J < E,
dist[N,U(M)] <E.
COROLLARY 5.5. If M and N al'e nol'maZ. operatol's such that o(N) is a perfect set, o(M) ~ o(N) and each component of o(M) intersects o(N), then N s~m + M. PROOF. It is completely apparent that oe(N) = o{N) and cre(M) cr(M). Let E > 0 and let cr(M) c uj:l D(Aj,E/4) be a covering of o(M) by open disks of radii E/4 centered at points of cr(Ml. It is easily seen that if the A.'s are properly ordered, we can find points~· in J
J
D(Aj,E/4), j = 1,2, .•• ,m such that, if A1 = {~ 1 .~ 2 ····•~r 1 }, ~={~rl+l' ••.
,~
r2
}, .•• ,
A={~
p
+ , .•. ,~ }(r = m), then A1 rp-l 1 rp p
max{dist[~j,Ah-l]:
~j
£
Ah} < E/2, h
c
o{N), and 1,2, ••• ,p-l.
m
Let {Mj}j=l be a finite set ofmnormal operators such that o(Mj) cre(Mj) = D(Aj,E/2) and let {Qj}j=l be nilpotent operators. By Lemma 5.3,
rl N s!m Ne{ej=l (~j+Qj)} and, by using Propositions 2.28(ii) and our previous observations, we see that the oj 's can be chosen so that IIMj-(~j+O:fll is arbitrarily small for all j 1,2, .•• ,p1 . It readily follows that pl N s!m N${$j=l Mj) and, by an obvious inductive argument, that N s!m ME where ME is a normal operator such that o(M)
c
m
cr(Me:) = oe(Me:) = [uj=l
D(~j,e:/2)
J
c
cr(M) (JE/ 4 ),
so that ~(o{M),o(ME)J <E. By Lemma 5.4, we can find M~ ~Me: such that IIM-M'II < e:. Since E can be chosen arbitrarily small, we conclude e: that N sim
M.
PROPOSITION 5.6. If M is normal., then M £ N(H} o(M) is a connected set containing the ol'igin.
0
if and onZ.y if
PROOF. It was already observed that o(M) must necessarily satisfy the given conditions for each Min N(H}-. Assume that o(M) is connected and contains 0. Given e: > 0, it fol
110
lows from Lemma 5.4 that there is a normal operator Me such that a(tie) is the closure of a connected open neighborhood of the origin and IIM-M£ II <e. Clearly, it suffices to show that M£ e N(.H)-. Let n > 0 be small enough to guarantee that D(O,n) c a(M) and let N be a normal e: n operator such that a(Nn) = D~O,n)-. By Proposition 2.28(ii), Lemma 4.8 and Corollary 5.5, N e N(H) and N + M • n n s~m £ Since N[H) is invariant under similarities, it follows from Prop~ sition 1.15 that M£ e NIH)-. D
5.1.2 Spectral characterization of NIH) Recall that an operator R is called algebraic if it satisfies an algebraic equation. If R is algebraic with minimal monic polynomial p, p(A) = rrj~l (A-Aj)kj, then it is easily seen that a(R) = {A 1 ,A 2 , •••• , Am} and, by Corollary 3.22,
* (5. 3)
R
0
Am+0"''Il Hm
kl k. k. where H1 = ker(R-A 1 ) , and Hr= {ker rrj~l (R-Aj) J)e{ker rrj;;;f
r
Let Atg(H) denote the set of all algebraic operators ac'tinq on H. It is easy to see, by using the expressions (5.1), (5.3) and Corollary 3.22 that the algebraic operator R is the limit of a sequence {Rn}n:l of operators such that Rn is similar to a normal operator and a(Rn) consists of exactly Lj~l kj (= the degree of the minimal polynomial of R) points. LEMMA 5.7. Let N,T e L(H), a(N) is a perfect set and a(T)
~here
c
N is a normal operator such that a(N). Then N s!m N$T.
PROOF. Let £ > 0 and let n1 , n be analytic Cauchy domains such that a(N) c n1 c o1 c 0 c a(N)£/ 2 and each component of n intersects a(N). If M1 , Mare normal operators such that a(M 1 ) = n1- and a(M) = n~ and R is an algebraic operator such that a(R) c 0\0 1 -, then it follows from Lemmas 5.3 and 5.4, and Corollary 4.10 that
111
By Propositions 5.6 and 1.15, and Corollary 4.10, R can be chosen so that
where II S II < e./2. since o(R)no(M+(an 1 >(~))
c
(O\n 1->nn 1 -
~.
it follows from Corel
lary 3.22 that RGlM+ (ClQl)
(~).-
[RX
0 M+ ( ClS'Jl)
) (oo)
l
for any X. Thus, if we choose X= OGlOGlz(oo) (where Z is defined by (3.2)), then
MGlTGlRGlM+ ( Cl0 1 ) (oo) ~ MalTGl[M Gl M1Gl
[M- (zan(!)> ("")
o
(oo) +S$0]
M+ (00 1 )
MGlT[MGlM 1GlM(Cl0 1 ) ("")+S$0]. Since MGlMGlM 1 GlM(Cl0 1 ) ("") za M and dH[o(N) ,o(M)] < e./2, it follows from Lemma 5.4 that S(N) contains an operator unitarily equivalent to NGlT+S', where II S' II < e./2+11 S II < e.. Since e. can be chosen arbitrarily small, we conclude that N sim NGlT. D Now we are in a position to complete the proof of Theorem 5.1. Suppose that A € L(H) satisfies (i), (ii) and (iii) and let E > 0. Since o 0 (A) = ~, it follows from Theorem 3.48 and (iii) that there exists K1 € K(H), llx 1 11 < E/4, such that A1 = A-K 1 satisfies cr(A 1 ) = crtre(A 1 ). Clearly, A1 also satisfies (i). Let p be a faithful unital *-representation of C*(A 1 ) on H and ~ (oo) p le-t Ai = p (A 1 ). It readily follows that i f A2= (Ail , then a (A 2 ) =crtre(A 2 ) = o(A 1 ). By Proposition 4.2l(ii) and (iv), there exists x2 E K(H), IIK 2 11 < e./4, such that A3= A1 -x 2 a A1 GlA 2 • Finally, by Propositions 4.29 and 4.2l(ii) and (iv), there exists K3 E K(H), IIK 3 11 < E/4, K3 = x 3 , 1ex 3 , 2 , such that
A 1 -K 3 ,l~ (~ ~~)
and
A 2 -K 3 , 2 ~
where N is normal and cr(N) otre(A 1 ) Hence, if K = K1+K 2+K 3 , then
ll2
(: 2
= cr(A 1 ).
~2)
,
N 0 IC 1 0 I 0 _s 21 ~ _c~ 0 0 IBl 0 I 0 0 10 N
A-K
(5. 4)
Since a(B 1 )ua(B 2 l c a(N), it follows from Proposition 5.6, Lemma 5.7 and Proposition 1.15 that there exist nilpotent operators Q. such J that IIB 1EBN-Q 1 11 < £/4 and IINEBB 2 -o 2 11 < £/4. Hence, there exists R in l(H), II Rll < £/4 such that
~
A-(K+R)
Q = [: 2 k.
kl+k2
A straighforward computation shows that if~· J= O,then Q =0, J i.e., Q £ N(H) and therefore distrA,N(HJJ < IIKII+IIRII <£.Since£ can be chosen arbitrarily small, it readily follows that A£ N(H)-. The proof of Theorem 5.1 is complete now. 0
5.2 Closures of similarity orbits of normal operators with perfect spectra THEOREf.1 5. 8. Let N £ L (HI be a norma Z operator suah that a (N) is a perfeat set; then S(N) is the set of aZZ those operators A in L(HJ satisfying the following aonditions (i) a(A) ~ a(N) and eaah aomponent of cr(A) interseats cr(N); (ii) ae (A) ~ oe (N) (=a (N)) and eaah aomponent of ae (A) interseats cre (N); and (iii) ind(A.-A) = 0 for aZZ A.£ Ps-F(A). PROOF. Since o(N) oe(N) = a~re(N), the necessity of the conditions (i), (ii) and (iii) follows from Corollary 1.6(i) and (iii) and Theorem l.l3(iii), exactly as in Theorem 5.1. Assume that A£ l(H) satisfies (i), (ii) and (iii) and let£> 0. Minor modifications of the proof of Theorem 5.1 (formula (5.4)) indicate that we can find a compact operator K, IlK II < £/3 such that
A-K
::::!
N2 0 lc o I 1 0 s 21 o c2 0 0-~-B 1- 0 I 0 0 ,o Nl
-
-
ED
N4 0 IIC 3 0 0 8410 c4 o -o-i'i~ 3 -o- , I 0 0 10 N3
(5.5)
where Nj::::t Nand a(Bj) c a(Nj), j = 1,2,3,4. By Lemma 5.4 we can find an operator n such that N sJ.m "t M, a(N) c cr(n) = oe(M) c a(N)£, o(M) is the closure of a Cauchy domain and liN-Mil
113
L(H), IIRII < e/3, such that B =A(K+R) is the operator obtained from (5.5) by replacing the N.'s by nor J mal operators M. "'M such that IIN.-M.II < e/3, j = 1,2,3,4. J J J Since a(M) is the closure of a Cauchy domain, it is very easy to prove that M = A1eA2eA 3eA 4 , where the Aj's are normal operators such that a(A 1 lna(A 2 ) = a(A 3 )na(A 4 ) = ~. a(Aj) is the closure of a Cauchy domain and each component of a(M) contains a component of a(A.) forall J j = 1,2,3,4. By Corollary 5.5 and Lemma 5.7, N s1m U = (A 1eA 2 )e(A 3eA 4 ) and A. ~ M.$B., j = 1,2,3,4. Thus, we can find operators A! ~A. J S1m J J J J such that 11Mj$Bj-Ajll < e/3, j = 1,2,3,4. Since o(Ailna(A2) = a(Ajln a(A4l = ~. it follows from Corollary 3.22 that < e/3. A fortiori, we can find R
M
~
€
C
Hence, N s1m C and IIA-CII < IIA-BII+max{ 11Mj$Bj-Aj II= j
1 , 2, 3, 4} < II K II+ IIR ll+e I 3 < E •
Since e can be chosen arbitrarily small, we conclude that N s1m & 0
5.3 Limits of algebraic operators THEOREM 5.9. The c~osure of the set Aig(H) of a~~ algebraic oper~ tors acting on H coincides with the set of all those operators A in L(H) satisfying the following condition ind(). -A) = 0 for all A. e: ps-F(A). (5.6) PROOF. The necessity of (5.6) follows from Theorem 1.13(iii). On the other hand, if A satisfies (5.6) and e > 0, then we can proceed as in the proof of Theorem 5.1 in order to show that A-K has the form (5.4) for a suitable compact operator K, IIKII < e/3, where N is a normal operator such that a(N) =a (N) =a (A) = a(A-K) ~ o(B.), j = 1,2. e e J By Lemma 5. 4 we can find a normal operator l1 such that a (ri) is the closure of a Cauchy domain, a(N) c a(f1) c a(N)E/ 3 and liN-Mil < t./3. Thus, if B is a suitable operator in L(H) unitarily equivalent to the result of replacing the N's by M's in the 4 x 4 operator matrix of (5.4), then IIA-BII < IIKII+IIN-MII < 2e/3. Since r1 is normal and a(t1) has only finitely many components, it readily follows from Theorem 5.1 that M € Aig(H)-. Since a(M) is a perfect set and a(Bj) c o(M), j = 1,2, it follows from Lemma 5.7 that M 7 M$B., j = 1,2. Since Alg(H) is invar s1m J iant under similarities, it follows from Proposition 1.15 that M$Bj € Alg(H)-, j = 1,2. Thus, we can find algebraic operators R1 , R2 such that IIMeB 2-R 2 11
114
< £13 and !IB 1 et-1- R1 11 < c/3.
It is completely apparent that if R1 , R2 are algebraic operators, then so is
whence we deduce that
Since c can be chosen arbitrarily small, we conclude that A belongs to Alg(H)-. 0 Observe that the condition (5.6) is invariant under compact perturbations. By using this observation, our remarks at the beginning of Section 5.1.2 and Theorem 5.8, we obtain the following COROLLARY 5.10. Alg(H) Alg(H1-+K(H) ~ [Alg(H)+K(H)Jl(H): R is similar to a normal operator with finite spectrum} l(H):
indO.-A)
~ 0
{R e ~{A
e
fox• all). e Ps-F(A)}.
From Theorem 5.1 and Remark 5.2, we obtain COROLLARY 5.11. Suppose that A e l(H), ind(),-A) ~Ofor all A e and cr 0 (A) is a finite set and ae(A) has finitely many components a 1 , a 2 , •.. , a • Let A. be an arbitrary point of a., j ~ 1, 2, •.• ,m. m J ~ J Then there exists a sequence {Rn}n~l of algebraic operators such that a(R ) ~ {)..} .m 1 ua (A), R IH (a (A) ;R ) ~ AjH (a {A) ;A) for all n ~ 1,2, ••• n J J~ o n o n o and IIA-Rnll + 0 (n-+- oo). p 5_F(A)
COROLLARY 5.12. Let A be a finite nonempty subset of~ and let S(A) ~ {A e L(H): cr(A) c A}; then S(A) is the set of all operators T satisfying the conditions (ii Each component of a(T) or oe(T) intersects A; and (ii) ind{).-T) ~ 0 for alZ ). e Ps-F(T). Fur>thermore, S (A)-~ {A e S (A): A is algebraic}-.
5.4 Normal operators in closures of similarity orbits PROPOSITION 5.13. Let T e l(H) and Zet N be a normaZ operator such that o(N)~ o(T) and dim H(A;N) ~ dim H(A;T)for each isolated point X
of a (T). Then T
sim
N.
115
It is completely apparent that if T and N are related as in the above proposition, then cr o (N) = cr o (T) and cr e (N) = oB(T) = cr(T)\cr 0 (T). It will be convenient to provide a separate proof for the case when cr(T) is totally disconnected. LEMl1A 5.14. If T ~ L!H), cr(T) is totally disaonneated and N is a no1'maZ. operator suah that cr (N) = cr (T) and dim H ().;N) = dim H (;\ ~T) for eaah isolated point A of cr(T), then T sim N. PROOF. Let T and N be as indicated and let £ > 0. Then we can find a finite covering {Qj}j:l of cr(T) by pairwise disjoint open sets such that Q.ncr(T) ~~and diameter n. < £/4, for all j = 1,2, ••• ,m. J J Thus, i f Aj ~ Qj' then Qj c D(~j'£/2) (j = 1,2, •.. ,m). By Corollary 3.22, T ~ $. 1 T., where T.= TIH(o(T)nQ.;T). Let N. J= J J J J = NIHCcr(Tj)~N). It is easily seen that dim H(a(T)nnj~T) =dim H(a(T)nQj; N) for all j = l,2, ••• ,m. By Corollary 3.35, there exists T~ E J L[H(cr(T)nQ.;N)], T'. ~ T. such that IIT~->...11 < £/2. On the other hand, i t J J J J J is completely apparent that liN.-;\ ·II < £/2. m J J Hence, T ~ $j=lTj and IIN-$j: 1 Tjll
max{IINj-Tjll:
j = l,2, ••. ,m}
s max{IINj-).jll+ll).j-Tjll:
j = l,2, ••• ,m} < £,
0
whence we readily conclude that T sim N.
PROOF OF PROPOSITION 5.13. Let a denote the set of all non-isolated points of ae(T). Given£> 0, we can use Corollary 3.22 to obtain that T ~ A$B, where A= TIH
c
o(A). A fortiori, a(C)
c
o(M),
which is a perfect set. Given n > 0, let n 1 , Q be analytic Cauchy domains such that o(M) c n1 c n1 c Q c o(M) and each component of Q intersects a(M). Let M1 n be a normal operator such that o(M1 J = n 1 • By Lemma 5.4 we can find M normal such that o(M ) = a (~1 ) = Q- and IIM-M II < 2n and, by Coroln n en n lary 5.12 there exist algebraic operators R1 , R2 such that o(R 1 )uo(R2l 116
c fl\fl 1 -, a(R 1 )na(R2 ) M_ (ao)
II
=
fl, IIR1 -M11 1BM1 1BM+(afl 1 l(ao)ll < n andi!R 2-\eM1 e
< 11. By Lenuna 5. 3 and Corollary 5. 5,
A s!m M11 eR1 1BCIBR 2 • Since o(R1 ), a(R 2 ) and o(C) are pairwise disjoint, it follows from Corollary 3.22 that M11 1B(R1 eceR 2 ) - M11 1BL(C';x1 ,x 2 ,x 3 ), where M sim M
s!l'(l M11 1BR1 1BR 2 , so that
L(C';X 1 ,x 2 ,x 3 )
=
1:l :~ ::] , 0
0
R2
C and x1 , x2 , x 3 are arbitrarily chosen operators. It follows from (3.2), Theorem 3.23 and our choice of R1 and R2 that x 1 , x 2 , x 3 and C' can be chosen so that
C' -
II L(C' ;x1 ,x 2 ,x 3 )
- M1 <2 >IBM(an 1 > {ao)
II
< E.
Hence, S(A)- contains an operator A' such that IIA'-M IBM1 <2 >e M(an 1 > (ao) II< n· Since M11 eM 1 ( 2 )1BM(an 1 > (co) ::ta M11 (Lenuna and 11 can be chosen arbitrarily small, we conclude that A s!m U. D
4.ai
5.5
Sums of two nilpotents
LIHI; however,
THEOREM 5.15. N(H)-+[N(H)-nNo4(H)] +K(H).
1
t NIHI+NIHI
PROOF. LetT£ LIHI and~ £ aoe(T). By Proposition 4.29 there exist K £ KIHI and a decomposition H = H0 eH 1 (co) (H 0 , H1 are infinite dimensional spaces) such that T
=
AIBR(ao)+K, A
L {H 0
E
1, R
* R
= [:
B 0
L(Hl)'
E
A
"' T, R .., R{ca), and
T *
M~,
~ M3
where o(B) c ae(T). Let e: > 0 and let Mk be a normal operator such that cr(t1k) j;l.l s sp(T)+(l-2-k)E} (k = 1,2, ..• ). Define
{).:
Me:= OIB(OIB ••• IBOIBMiiBOIB ••• IBOIBMiiBOIB ••• IBOIBMk_IBOIB ••• ) (with respect to the decomposition H = H0 IBH 1 (co)) , where the direct sum mand Mk occupies the nk-th coordinate,
Mk
=
["' ~
0 0 0
·r 0
M2 , k Mk M3
1,2, ••• ,
117
and 1 s n 1 Let
<
n2
<
•••
< ~ <
••••
be the operator obtained from R by replacing the ~·s in the (1,1) and (3,3) entries by two copies of Mk• k = 1,2, .•. , let L be the operator obtained from AeR(~) by replacing R by Lk in the nk-th coordinate (k = 1,2, ••• ) and defineS = L+K. E It is completely apparent that T = S +(~-M ) . Since ~-M is nore: E E mal and a(~-ME ) = {A £ ~= jA-~1 ~ a+e:} is a closed disk containing the origin, it follows from Proposition 5.6 that M € NIH)-. On the E other hand, it is clear that a e (S e: ) =a... re (S e: ) = {A £ ~= jAj s a+c}. If a(S) =a (S ), then S € N(H)• (by Theorem 5.1) and we are done. E e E E Thus, in order to complete the proof of the first statement, we only have to show that if nk + ~ (k + ~> fast enough, then a(S) =a (S ). E e E Let Pn denote the orthogonal projection of H onto the n-th copy of H1 and let P0 be the orthogonal projection onto H0 • Clearly, if ~n-1
~n-1
Kn = K- (1-L.j=O Pj)K(l-L.j=O Pj), then IIKnll + 0 (n + co). By Corollary 1.2(ii) there exist constants &k' &1 > &2 > ••• > &k k > ••• > 0 and &k + 0 (k + ~>, such that a(Te[ej=l LjJeCk) c a(~~+ 1 ), provided II Ck II < &k (k = 1, 2, ••• ) • Let n 1 ~ 1 be the first index such that II Kn 1 II < &112 and define nk inductively so that 1. s n 1 < n 2 < ••• < nk < ••• and IlK II < &k/2 for all k = 1,2, •... Defl.ne S as above nk e: with this particular sequence. It is obvious that a(S) =a (S )ua (5) e: e o = a(M )ua (S ). Assume that a (S) ~~and let y E a 0 (S ); then jyj = E 0 E 0 E E a+e:+n for some n > 0. By Corollary 1.2(i) there exists & > 0 such that a(S +F)nD(y,n/2) ~~for all Fin L(H) with IIFII < &. Let h be large E enough to guarantee that &h < 2& and observe that (if n 0 is defined to be equal to 0) (n.-n. -j) n {(Ae[e.h 1 {R J J-l eL.}])+(K-K )jran~. hOPJ.} S -K L+(K-K ) J= . J nh J= e: nh nh (n.-n. 1 -J) co J Je[e._h+l{R eL.}J. J(n.-n. -j) J ~ J J-1 ) . a (M ) , we conSince IlK II < & and a<•j=h+l{R eLj} E nh elude that (n. -n. -j) n a(Ae[e.h 1 {R J J-l eL.}J+(K-K ) Iran l· ho PJ.) J= J ~ J= is not contained in a(M ) • E Since a(R) c a(Me:), it easily follows that if
118
V = (AGl Gl.h {R. J=l J
(n.-n. -j) n J J-l GlL.} +(K K ) I '\ h P.)GlR(oo), J - ~ ran l. j=O J
then o(V) is not contained in o(Me:). But, on the other hand, it is not difficult to check that v TGl[Glj=~ Lj)+Ch, where ch is compact and IIChll s 211Knh11 < oh. Hence, by our definition of oh, o(V) c o(~+l)
=
o(Me:), a contradiction. Hence, o(Se:) = oe{Se:) = o{ME), whence it follows that T = Sc+{~ M) E: N(H)-+[N(H)-nNoll(H)J. E Finally, observe that if 1 = o1+o 2+c, where oe{Q 1 )uoeC0 2 l c D(O,~ and C is compact, then l-Q 2 = Q1 +C and therefore l-Q 2 = Q1 , so that oeC0 1 l=oefl-Q 2 l = oe{Q 1 lnoe(l-0 2 )cD(O,~)nD(l,~) =~.a contradiction. Hence, 1 ; N ( H ) +N (H) +K (H) • 0 A simpler construction yields the following PROPOSITION 5.16. For each T
E
L(H), dist[T,N(H)] s; sp{T).
PROOF. Let e > 0 and let {~n}lsnsm {1 s; m s; oo) be a dense subset oe(T) (c oR.re{T)). By Proposition 4.29, there exists K E K(H), IIKII < e/2, and a decomposition H = H0 GlH 1 {H 0 ,H 1 are infinite dimensional spaces) such that
of
T = AGlR+K, A ( L(H 0
),
R
E
L(H 1 ),
A~
T, o{R)
oe(T) and
where N {diag{~ 1 .~ 2 , ••• ,~n····l> {oo)= Gll~n~m ~nln (ln denotes the identity on a subspace Rn = H1 >. By Lemma 5.4 we can find normal operators Mn E L(Rn) such that o{Mn) = oe(Mn) = {t~n= 0 s; t ,;; l}e/ 4 and 1Jllnln-Mn11 < l>~nl+e:/2. Let M = Gll,;;ns;m Mn; clearly, o(M) = oe(M) = [ul~n~m o{Mn)]
= u>te:o(T) {ttJ:
Ostsl}e/ 4
is connected and contains the origin. Thus, if S is the operator obtained from R by replacing the two N's by M's, then o(S) oR.re(S) = o{M) and therefore (by Theorem 5.1) S e: N!H 1 )-. It is easily seen that E = o(A)\o(S) = o(T)\a(M) is a finite {eventually empty) subset {~ 1 .~ 2 , •.. ,~p} of a 0 {A). Hence, _ [AIH(E;A) A0
* ]H(E;A) A0 H0 eH(E;A)
where H(E;A) is finite dimensional and a(A0 ) c a(S). It readily follows that A IH ( E; A) = L+O, where L is a normal diaqonal opera tor such 119
that II Lll = max{ I Aj I: 1 ,; ; j ,; ; p} ,;;; sp(T) and Since cr(A0 ) c cr(S), it follows that cr ((A-LeO) es) = cr (Q) ucr (A0 ) ucr (S) N(H)
c
is a nilpotent.
Q
cr (S) •
Since S E N (fl}-, the above inclusion implies that Tl = (A-LeO) es (Use Theorem 5.1). On the other hand, by construction
€
IIT-T1 11 = max{IILIIriiR-SII +IJKIIl < sp(T)+e:. Since
£
can be chosen arbitrarily small, we conclude that dist[T,N(H)] s sp(T).
It readily follows from Theorem 5.1 that the upper estimate given by Proposition 5.16 is very poor, in general: namely, if a is hermitian, cr(H) = [0,1] and £ > 0, then there exist nilpotent operators g 1 and Q 2 such that IIH-Q 1 11 < £ and IIH-(l-Q 2 lll < r:. Hence, cr(l-Q 2 l = {1} :md sp(l-Q 2 l = 1, but dist[l-Q 2 ,N(H)] < 2£! Better estimates will be given in Chapter XI (second monograph) •
5.6 The Apostol-Salinas approach:
An estimate for the distance to
Nk(HJ LEMMA 5.17. LetT E N(H). Then fo~ eve~y n > 0, 8 > sp(T) and every positive integer k there existn Q € Nk(HeH) cuah that II- oil < aJITIJ+s+ IIT:l11 • nS PROOF. Let U and V be two isometries in L (H) such that VV*+UU* = 1. ·-1 we define for 1 s j s k the subspace M. of HeH given by M. = {TJ xe "l"L ] J nS]- vJ--ux: X € H}. (Note that X
€
H}
I
i.e., M. is the image under an isometry of the graph of the transpose of (1/n~j-l)Tj-l. Hence M. is closed, i.e., it is a subspace.) ]
It is easy to see that MjnMh = {0} i f 1 s j,h s k, j ,P h. This is due to the fact that the second components of the elements in M. and ~hare k orthogonal. Let M = '· 1 M. and let {y } 1 be a sequence in M such l.J= J m m= that lim(m ..,. coJIIY II= 0. Since M .nMh = {0}, j ,P h, we can write uniquely k m · J ·-1 ·-1 y = }". 1 y ., where y .= TJ-1x .$nf:\J vJ Ux ., for some x ·" 11, m J= m,J m,J m,J m,J m,J 1 5 j ;:; k, m = 1,2, •.•• Since lim(m ... co) IIY.mll = 0 I lim(m .. co) IlL .~ 1 nSj-lvj-lux .11 = 0. Then lim(m->-oolllvj-lux J-11 = 0, 1 < j ;:; k, Jm,J m, and hence lim(m->- coJIIx ·II= 0, 1-> j s k. Therefore, lim(m->-ooJIIY m, ]·II m,J 00
120
]
= 0, 1 s j s k, and hence the algebraic direct sum M is closed, i.e., it is a subspace. Now define Q £ l(HCBH) by .l k-1 k-1 QIMkeM = o, OILj=l Mj = (Tesv> ILj=l Mj. Thus, the representing matrix of OIM on Lj~l Mj is of the form 0
0
0
*
0
0
0
*
0
0 0 0
0 0 0
0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 • • * 0 Therefore it is clear that Qk = 0. Let Pk be the projection onto ker V*k. Then [ (TesPkV) - QJLj~l (Tj-lxjeasj-lvj-luxj) k j-1 k-1 j-1 k j-1 j-1 [TLj=l T xj-TLj=l T xj]8[SPkVLj=l aS V Uxj k j-1 j-1 k k_k ~k-1 j-1 j-1 -SVLj=l aS V uxj] = T xk8[Pka8 v-uxk+~j=l aS V Uxj] k
T xkeo. Since 1 k-1--k-1 1 k j-1 j-1 llxkll=-"k-TIIaB v- Uxklls-"k-111/.j=laB v Ux.ll aS aS J 1 k j j-1 j-1 s -"k-1 lit j=l T xjeas v uxjll , aS k k-1