Anthony Mann
ALSO BY WILLIAM DARBY AND FROM MCFARLAND Deconstructing Major League Baseball, 1991–2004: How Statistics...
120 downloads
2229 Views
3MB Size
Report
This content was uploaded by our users and we assume good faith they have the permission to share this book. If you own the copyright to this book and it is wrongfully on our website, we offer a simple DMCA procedure to remove your content from our site. Start by pressing the button below!
Report copyright / DMCA form
Anthony Mann
ALSO BY WILLIAM DARBY AND FROM MCFARLAND Deconstructing Major League Baseball, 1991–2004: How Statistics Illuminate Individual and Team Performances (2006) John Ford’s Westerns: A Thematic Analysis, with a Filmography (1996; paperback 2006) Major League Baseball, 1979–1992: A Year-by-Year History Using Fan Oriented Statistics (1993) American Film Music: Major Composers, Techniques, Trends, 1915–1990 (1990, paperback 1999)
Anthony Mann The Film Career WILLIAM DARBY
McFarland & Company, Inc., Publishers Jefferson, North Carolina, and London
LIBRARY OF CONGRESS CATALOGUING-IN-PUBLICATION DATA
Darby, William, 1942– Anthony Mann : the film career / William Darby. p. cm. Includes bibliographical references and index. ISBN 978-0-7864-3839-6 softcover : 50# alkaline paper 1. Mann, Anthony, 1906–1967. 2. Motion picture producers and directors—United States—Biography. I. Title. PN1998.3.M36D37 2009 791.4302'33092—dc22 [B] 2009024023 British Library cataloguing data are available ©2009 William Darby. All rights reserved No part of this book may be reproduced or transmitted in any form or by any means, electronic or mechanical, including photocopying or recording, or by any information storage and retrieval system, without permission in writing from the publisher. Cover image: Cimarron (1960) directed by Anthony Mann. Credit: MGM/Photofest ©MGM. Manufactured in the United States of America
McFarland & Company, Inc., Publishers Box 611, Je›erson, North Carolina 28640 www.mcfarlandpub.com
To the memory of Dr. Finley A. Hooper (1922–1993), teacher, mentor, and friend
This page intentionally left blank
Acknowledgments While the majority of those who contributed to my understanding of Anthony Mann’s career and works are cited in the bibliography or the chapters that follow, there are a few individuals whom I must single out for special thanks. Charles Greenwell and the late Bernie Cohan allowed me to “think out loud” about Mann and his movies. I undoubtedly owe them both for advice which prevented egregious missteps and for patience which went beyond the bounds of friendship. Jeanine Basinger, our foremost Mann scholar, encouraged me several years ago when I began to look at Mann seriously. I needed to be assured that I wasn’t simply spinning my wheels, and she was kind enough to tell me that I was not. My son David has helped me with numerous technical details, and I thank him for learning so much about modern technology. My wife Carolyn has endured my varying moods throughout this project with her customary equanimity, support, and love. As always, she makes my life as a writer a pleasure. Naturally, none of these good persons are to be blamed for any evasions or overstatements in what follows.
vii
This page intentionally left blank
Table of Contents Acknowledgments Introduction
vii 1
1. In Search of Anthony Mann 5 2. Mann and the B Film 26 3. Mann and Film Noir 48 4. Mann and the Western 92 5. Mann and the 1950s 166 6. Mann and Epic Films 201 7. Mann and the Century of Total War: The Heroes of Telemark (1965) and A Dandy in Aspic (1968) 239 8. Mann and the Critics 254 Filmography 267 Chapter Notes 281 Selected Bibliography 283 Index 287
ix
This page intentionally left blank
Introduction I first became intrigued with Anthony Mann when I was one of a select audience for the debut of The Fall of the Roman Empire in downtown Detroit in 1964. Some of my enthusiasm for the film was tempered by the individual to whom this book is dedicated, and whose more fastidious factual tastes were bound to conflict with some of its fast-and-loose playing with the historical record—points which he especially registered after I had persuaded him to see the movie. Although I can recall Dr. Hooper admonishing me over the fact that Sohames of Armenia (Omar Sharif in Mann’s work) had existed one hundred and fifty years before the events portrayed, I retained a serious affection for The Fall of the Roman Empire and I linked Mann with another much admired film of my youth, Men in War (1957). In the late 1980s I decided to re-examine Mann to see if my earlier reactions had been valid in any serious way. I had done the same thing with other movies from my young adulthood and often found them either overblown (Marlon Brando’s One-Eyed Jacks) or disappointing (the Jason Robards, Jr. comedy A Thousand Clowns). After viewing El Cid (1961) and The Fall of the Roman Empire, and, at that point, always looking for ways to move ahead as a college English instructor, I decided to research Mann in the hopes of producing what I thought would be yet another probably all-too-formulaic scholarly article. However, in the standard process of checking all the previous “sources” for Mann, I quickly learned that they were anything but plentiful and so I could not simply react in a predictably academic fashion. Eventually, I became intrigued enough to write much of what serves as the basis for the discussion of Mann’s epics in Chapter 6 of the current volume, but, alas, at a length that was simply unwieldy for the few scholarly journals I eventually contacted about possible publication. Before that time I was brash enough to send a copy of my work to Professor Jeanine Basinger at Wesleyan University, whom I had discovered was the only serious Mann scholar working in the United States. I wanted to see how she would react to what I had written and, being much younger then, the idea that such an “unsolicited manuscript” would be an intrusion never crossed my mind. 1
2
Introduction
Fortunately, the good professor not only read what I had written but also promptly responded in most encouraging and enthusiastic terms; and, while she will, in all probability, have now forgotten what she wrote at that time, her kind words suggested to me that I might indeed have something worth saying about Mann. If nothing else, her missive made me appreciate anew the significance of Blanche DuBois’s famous line in A Streetcar Named Desire: “I have always relied on the kindness of strangers.” For the past twenty years, many other things (including writing books on baseball, film music, and John Ford’s westerns) have intervened, even though Mann remained as someone I wanted to explore further. When I returned to Mann two years ago, I suspected that many new works on the director and his films would have emerged, especially given the surge of publications in film and film studies since the mid–1980s. But that was clearly not the case as newer critics and commentators tended to treat Mann as either a subject to be introduced to those unfamiliar with his work or as evidence for larger theories they wished to propound about psychological, social, or sexual changes in either society or film. While much of what was written offered thought-provoking insights about individual Mann films, all too often the basic emphases of his subject matter and the course of his career were assumed in order to focus on these particular summary and ideological problems. While my work does not seek to seriously revise the general critical outlines of Mann’s career, it does set out to re-examine his films from the perspectives of stylistic developments within the movie business during his lifetime as well as major social and historical trends that affected the director and his subjects. In examining all of his movies, I have gained an enhanced appreciation for Mann as a storyteller, a screen stylist, and a serious thinker. No matter whether the film is set in the back alleys of a modern city, the rugged landscapes of the West, or the huge canvasses of medieval Spain or ancient Rome, Mann never forgets the personal plot which is the spine of virtually every movie. The more often one watches the majority of Mann’s films, the more frequently one realizes how subtly and completely their diverse cinematic elements are integrated. Even with such modest efforts as his apprentice films from 1942 through 1946, or the decidedly woeful Serenade (1956), one can admire Mann’s efforts to transform mediocre material through cinematic means; indeed, despite his training in the theatrical world of New York, he almost intuitively understood that movies must “show” and not simply “tell.” Cinematography, costume and set design, acting, and music conspire within most of Mann’s finished films to serve the bigger human issues addressed in the stories he is telling. If great dramatic art is to be judged on the basis of
Introduction
3
the coherence of all its disparate elements, then Mann is clearly one of a handful of movie directors who achieved such stature. How he perfected that art, while offering abiding perceptions and ideas about violence, family life, and historical obligations, can best be seen by examining his films in approximate chronological order and in terms of their overriding themes. The biographical details of Mann’s life before he directed his first feature film, Dr. Broadway (1942), are set forth in Chapter 1, and, while admittedly sparse, they offer a necessary background to the director’s career as well as an instance when one must resist the temptation of offering pop psychological explanations in order to make a more pleasing and seemingly fuller account of his life. Mann’s work as an “apprentice” is analyzed in Chapter 2 where we see that his early suspense films and musicals, while decidedly B efforts, provided him a solid grounding in movie techniques. Even at this early stage of his career, the director was not producing “filmed plays,” and when he moved on to film noir he showed himself to be an able Hollywood craftsman. Chapter 3 examines eight of Mann’s noir films in matched pairs that center on larger thematic conflicts, as well as an early costume drama, The Black Book (1949), and a police procedural drama, Follow Me Quietly (1949), which he co-wrote. His movement into westerns, hailed by one and all among critics and commentators as opening the most successful period in Mann’s career, provides the basis for Chapter 4. Ten of his films, which appeared between 1950 and 1958, are treated in matched pairs that focus on the thematic issues they raise, and another work, Night Passage (1957), is discussed because of Mann’s aborted involvement with it. The director’s other films from the 1950s are taken up in Chapter 5 and grouped in categories that are more arbitrary than those discussed in Chapters 3 and 4. With these films we see Mann working on Americana, whether as an historical mystery (The Tall Target, 1951), a propagandistic flag-waver (Strategic Air Command, 1955), or a literary adaptation (God’s Little Acre, 1958). Chapter 6 discusses the director’s involvements with epic film production. His less than happy, less than successful associations with Spartacus (1960) and Cimarron (1960) are followed by a discussion of his satisfying experiences and results with El Cid and The Fall of the Roman Empire. His two epics demonstrate both the intellectual maturity and the artistic excellence that Mann had perfected by this stage of his career. Indeed, these works are comparable, if not superior, to anything else in the genre, and remarkably demonstrate his mastery of yet another standard movie type. His last two films are analyzed in Chapter 7 and, while they were not popular upon their initial releases, they also demonstrate his great facility as a storyteller
4
Introduction
capable of using the film medium to offer insights into the modern world in which he found himself. Mann’s stature, both within the history of Hollywood and the larger arena of world filmmaking, is argued in Chapter 8 where it is urged that it is long past time for his critical importance to be both more greatly appreciated and more widely recognized. His earliest critics from the late 1960s and early 1970s clearly saw that Mann was one of a kind—a perception that most contemporary reviewers tended to either downplay or ignore altogether. The passage of time and the emergence of newer styles of filmmaking have made many of Mann’s directorial contemporaries appear either passe or hopelessly dated, while, if anything, that same temporal movement has made his works loom ever larger as enduring contributions to the art of motion pictures.
1
In Search of Anthony Mann Anthony Mann died on April 29, 1967, while in Berlin working on the film A Dandy in Aspic. Unfortunately, this was still a time when film scholarship was neither as respectable nor as organized as it is today; and, as a result, many of the details of the director’s life and career are either obscure or unknown. While the few interviews that Mann gave offer some professional insights and bits of personal information, it is simply not possible to reconstruct a detailed biography, especially for his earlier work on stage and when breaking into the movies. As his daughter Nina recently admitted, her father is something of a “mystery” even for her, so she, like any aspirant critic or commentator, must accept “looking at his films” to better understand Anthony Mann.1 The future film director was born in Point Loma, a city near San Diego, on June 30 of either 1906 or 1907. There is also some confusion as to whether his first name was Anton or Emil. No such obscurity attaches to his surname of Bundsman. His father was Emil Theodore Bundsmann and his mother was Bertha (nee Waxelbaum), who was originally from Macon, Georgia, and both of them were philosophy teachers. An early connection with the Theosophical Society of San Diego would certainly have accorded with the intellectual interests of his parents and may have also sparked a theatrical interest in the young Mann. In 1917 the family moved to New York where Anton/Emil exhibited a penchant for school playacting which was reinforced by his participation in the Young Hebrew Men’s Association; indeed, Mann may have been both directing and acting while still in high school. With the death of his father in 1923, the boy decided to leave school in order to help with the family finances. Because he was fortunate enough to get a night watchman’s job at Westinghouse Electrical, he was able to indulge his passion for the theater by attending auditions and exploring other theatrical possibilities during the daytime. Within a very short period, Mann went to work full time in the Triangle Theater in Greenwich Village. His taking a major cut in pay to do so implies that getting into the theater had been his major motive for ending his formal education. 5
6
Anthony Mann
He appeared as an actor in The Dybbuk in an English version by Henry Alsberg under the direction of Howard Barlow, and in The Squall by Jean Bart in 1925–1926. Later in the decade he performed in The Blue Peter as a “Chinese” under the direction of S. Templeton Thurston in a cast that featured future Hollywood stalwarts Margaret Wycherly, Warren William, and Morris Ankrum. He subsequently played another supporting role (as a “workman”) in a production of Anton Chekhov’s Uncle Vanya which featured Franchot Tone and Morris Carnovsky. Mann joined the Theater Guild in 1930 as both a production manager and (eventually) a director, working there with such notables as David Belasco and Rouben Mamoulian. At the same time he appeared in Streets of New York (1931), in which he played the “Duke of Calcavella”; the play was directed by Dion Bochanius and featured Dorothy Gish. He then appeared with Miss Gish and Henry Hull, as the featured leads, in The Bride the Sun Shines On which was directed by Will Cotton. The young man was billed as a “photographer.” In 1933 Mann directed Thunder on the Left, scripted by Jean Ferguson Black from a novel by Christopher Morley. Louis Jean Heydt was the most notable member of the cast in a drama which did not please Brooks Atkinson of the New York Times. According to the critic, Thunder on the Left “with its medley of realism and fantasy grows less intelligible scene by scene.” Atkinson also argued that the theme of whether a young man should or should not choose to grow up would have required “myriad genius” on the part of the director and that, unhappily, the third act came off as “incoherent and silly.”2 Mann soldiered on directing The Squall which appeared on Broadway in 1933, and in which he both acted and performed as an assistant stage manager. He also established his own summer stock repertory company which featured Macdonald Carey, who would star in the director’s first film, Dr. Broadway (1942), and James Stewart, with whom Mann would work so well and so extensively from 1950 to 1955 in Hollywood. Van Johnson and Imogene Coca were featured in New Faces of 1936, a revue crafted by Mindret Lord and Everett Marcy with some minor sketches supplied by director Mann himself. The New York Times saw this “soufflé” as “cheerful ... and unpretentious.”3 After directing Cherokee Night (1936), Mann’s next theatrical venture was So Proudly We Hail by Joseph Viertel which featured Richard Cromwell and Eddie Bracken as cadets in a military school that, ultimately, dehumanizes its young men. The central character’s transformation from “artistic to atavistic” was clearly not helped by the director, for the New York Times dismissed the play as “on the whole ... built mainly on sound and fury.”4 Mann’s
1. In Search of Anthony Mann
7
last stage effort, The Big Blow, was written by Theodor Pratt, featured E.G. Marshall, and was performed at the WPA Ford Theatre. Once again, Brooks Atkinson had little good to say about the direction of this melodrama set in “Florida cracker land.” Although he deemed the production technically adept, the critic found the suspense “not well handled” by the “uncertain directive hand” that operated throughout.5 While Mann was working at all sorts of jobs within the theater for much of the 1920s and 1930s, he found time to marry Mildred Kenyon in 1936, and the couple produced two children, Anthony (b. 1938) and Nina (b. 1944) before they divorced in 1956. By 1937 Mann was also working for the Selznick Studio as an East Coast talent scout; and, in that capacity he accompanied executive Kay Brown during a promotional college tour seeking potential Scarlett O’Haras for the upcoming Gone with the Wind (MGM/Selznick, 1939). Mann subsequently supervised numerous screen tests for the epic as well as Intermezzo (Selznick, 1939) and Alfred Hitchcock’s Rebecca (Selznick, 1940).6 In 1939 Mann moved to Hollywood and began working at Paramount as an assistant director, a position he quietly filled for the next three years. His most notable assignment was Sullivan’s Travels (1941), a film that enabled him to work with comedic genius Preston Sturges. According to Mann (whose own films rarely feature humor or comedy), he learned a great deal from the writer-director. I directed a little [of Sullivan’s Travels]. I’d stage a scene and he’d tell me how lousy it was. Then I watched [the] editing and was able gradually to build up knowledge. Preston insisted I make a film as soon as possible. He said it’s better to have done something bad than to have done nothing.7
Mann got that opening opportunity at the studio with Dr. Broadway, a B film that featured the screen debut of its leading man, Macdonald Carey. Mann’s first feature was thoroughly panned by both Variety and the New York Times, with the former offering that the film was “a ‘c’ in the guise of a ‘b’” with few if any prospects at the box office. In addition, Vari-
Preston Sturges gave Mann his first hands-on directorial experience with Sullivan’s Travels (Paramount, 1941). Mann served as assistant director on the film.
8
Anthony Mann
ety claimed that Mann’s direction “just wasn’t.”8 Less harshly, the Times review simply dismissed Dr. Broadway as a “Damon Runyonesque” effort that “falls flat.” With Mann’s second effort, the cheapie musical Moonlight in Havana (also 1942), Variety was even more severe as its reviewer insisted that the film “gets no assistance from director Anthony Mann.” It was not until he was put in charge of The Great Flamarion (Republic, 1945) that critics began to mildly praise Mann’s direction; and such attention came about largely because of the presence of the legendary Erich von Stroheim in the title role. While Mann was both in awe and somewhat envious of his leading man’s “genius,” he would later insist that his experience had taught him that he had to “work” at his craft and could not rely on inspiration as the actor had seemingly done.9 Whatever anxieties might have beset Mann simply by virtue of working with the flamboyant actor were undoubtedly exacerbated because von Stroheim disliked the flashback plot of The Great Flamarion, believing that such a structure ultimately bored the audi-
Publicity still from The Great Flamarion (Republic, 1945). The title character (Erich von Stroheim) pursues Connie Wallace (Mary Beth Hughes) in a plot seemingly based on The Blue Angel (UFA, 1930). Mann would later note that von Stroheim was a genius while he was only a talent and had to work at his craft.
1. In Search of Anthony Mann
9
ence. (Von Stroheim would later be featured in Billy Wilder’s classic Sunset Blvd. [Paramount, 1950] which would feature one of Hollywood’s most notable and celebrated flashback plots.) While the New York Times summarily dismissed The Great Flamarion as “an exercise in tedium,” Variety offered a much more comprehensive and appreciative review. Despite the film’s being a “heavy melodrama,” its production values, camerawork, and editing were all praised; and the reviewer also saw the film as offering von Stroheim one of his better roles at that time. Even more significantly, Mann’s direction was seen as “imaginative and well paced.”10 The director’s other efforts at Republic, Strangers in the Night (1944) and Strange Impersonation (1946), while stylistically and thematically foreshadowing Mann’s more mature films, elicited no such extended reactions from either source. By 1945 Mann was also working at RKO where his first effort Two O’Clock Courage was dismissed as “slow paced” by Variety and as a “modest little item of second-rate cinematic form” by the New York Times.11 The director’s second studio entry, Sing Your Way Home, a B musical comedy also released in 1945, was also panned for its unconvincing plot and miscast youngsters as wartime refugees with no notice of Mann’s work whatsoever. Variety found The Bamboo Blonde (1946) to be a “tired affair” made on a low budget, featuring mediocre sets, and with direction that was “never too good and never too bad.”12 By this time, after nearly five years of trying to improve mediocre scripts and motivate marginal acting talents, Mann realized that he would have to provide better materials for himself or be consigned to Hollywood’s various B units for the rest of his career. Teaming with writer Dorothy Atlas, the director came up with the story line for Desperate (RKO, 1947), his first major film noir and a taut thriller (at 73 minutes) in its own right. Variety praised the finished product as a “ripsnorting gangster meller” which was enhanced by the absence of familiar lead and character actors. The ending, in which the protagonist (Steve Brodie) singlehandedly kills the villain (Raymond Burr) to free himself and his family from pursuit by the police and the underworld, “gives [the] film a lift.” And, while some “corny incidents” should have been edited out of Desperate, Mann’s direction “mainly stresses suspense” and is “done skillfully.”13 His next career move, to Producers Releasing Corporation which would soon become Eagle-Lion Pictures, saw Mann emerge as a definitive master of American film noir. Railroaded (1947) was scripted by John C. Higgins who would be the lead writer on T-Men (1947), Raw Deal (1948), He Walked by Night (1948), and Border Incident (1949). Their initial collaboration was hailed by Variety for being an “old type blood-and-thunder gangster meller”
10
Anthony Mann
John Alton with Ethel Barrymore on the set of It’s a Big Country (MGM, 1951). Mann and the Hungarian-born Alton perfected a striking film noir vision style in T-Men (1947), Raw Deal (1948), He Walked by Night (1948), The Black Book (1949), Border Incident (1949) and Devil’s Doorway (1950). Alton would win an Oscar for his work on An American in Paris (MGM, 1951).
that was far better than its “no-name cast” would lead one to expect. Mann was cited for his “real acumen in developing [a] maximum of suspense.”14 Starting with T-Men, the director also teamed up with the highly accomplished and strongly individualistic cinematographer John Alton, and together they did much to canonize film noir stylistics. Beginning with that film and moving on to Raw Deal, He Walked by Night, The Black Book (1949), Border Incident, and Devil’s Doorway (MGM, 1950), Mann and Alton created deeply shadowed and chiaruscuro lighting patterns that brought the rainy streets and shabby hiding places of film noir memorably to the screen not only in crime stories but in a costume drama and a western as well. For the cinematographer, who had begun working in Hollywood for MGM, gone to France to assist famed director Ernst Lubitsch, and forged his own writing and directing career in Argentina in the 1930s, Mann was “a
1. In Search of Anthony Mann
11
director I can really sit down and talk with.”15 Their partnership ultimately proved to be so successful that some later critics have gone so far as to argue that Alton, and not Mann, should be seen as the “auteur” of the works on which they collaborated. However, both men prospered apart from each other as Alton won an Oscar for An American in Paris (MGM, 1951) and Mann emerged as a master of westerns and epic films. T-Men got them off to a rousing start with its tale of Treasury agents working their way into a Los Angeles–based counterfeiting ring. Higgins’s screenplay provided some startling twists, such as the murder of agent Gennaro (Alfred Ryder) in front of his helpless colleague O’Brien (Dennis O’Keefe); opportunities for physical action, such as O’Brien’s being beaten by irate gamblers in a washroom; and intriguing locations, such as the docked freighter where O’Brien finally uncovers the higher-ups in the counterfeiting operation. Variety’s reviewer compared the film favorably to the celebrated The House on 92nd Street (Twentieth Century–Fox, 1945) for its location work, predicted “good grosses,” and found Mann’s direction to be “well done.” Although he called T-Men “wearisome,” Bosley Crowther also lauded the location work and the director’s “fine sense of melodramatic timing” in the New York Times.16 These critical sources voiced essentially the same reactions to Raw Deal whose romantic triangle between Joe Sullivan (Dennis O’Keefe), Pat (Claire Trevor), and Ann (Marsha Hunt) makes the film probably the most romantic that Mann ever did. He Walked by Night, while officially credited to Alfred Werker, was largely directed by Mann, who once again collaborated with Higgins and Alton to produce a taut thriller. Variety noted that there was no romantic angle to slow down the action and that Richard Basehart (as the mysterious alienated criminal Morgan) was a “talented find.” Ironically, its review also declared the film to be “another package of dynamite” comparable to T-Men, while the New York Times singled out “Werker’s brisk direction.”17 In 1949 Mann saw another of his story ideas produced by RKO as Follow Me Quietly, a modest police procedural of 60 minutes that was directed by Richard Fleischer. At the same time the director worked on his first costume drama, The Black Book, which was produced by long-time Hollywood executive Walter Wanger. While reaction to this drama set in Paris during the Reign of Terror was mixed, Mann’s film was reviewed by The New Yorker and Newsweek as well as Variety and the New York Times. During this time, Wanger, his actress-wife Joan Bennett, and their company Diana Productions were actively trying to develop projects for famed German émigré director Fritz Lang. They had collaborated with Lang on Woman in the Window (1944), Scarlet Street (1945), and The Secret Behind
12
Anthony Mann
the Door (1948). In January of 1946, Diana Productions bought the screen rights to a short story by veteran western writer Stuart Lake in the hope of turning out another vehicle for Lang—an undertaking that would, ultimately, lead to Anthony Mann’s first critically acclaimed western Winchester ’73 in 1950. However, before he took over that assignment, Mann and his key collaborators Higgins and Alton were persuaded to come to MGM by newly arrived studio production chief Dore Schary, who had also worked at RKO during the late 1940s. Even though Schary had been summarily fired by new RKO boss Howard Hughes, Nicholas Schenck of MGM, worried by that studio’s having fallen on lean financial and production times, and increasingly disenchanted with the management choices and style of long-time head Louis B. Mayer, had eagerly brought Schary on board. In his new situation Mann was not only able to complete Border Incident, which he had been developing prior to leaving Eagle-Lion, but also to do so in a much glossier style than he would have been able to achieve at the lesser studio. The completed work was seen by Variety as a “solid” second feature, and, in an aside, their reviewer credited Mann with having directed He Walked by Night.18 In addition, Schary approached Mann about doing his first western, Devil’s Doorway, and the director was thoroughly convinced after reading the screenplay by Guy Trosper. However, while Mann would subsequently declare that the script was the best he ever had, and his film would feature long-time MGM star Robert Taylor, the studio was initially reluctant to release Devil’s Doorway because of its downbeat subject matter (white prejudice against Native Americans), plot resolution (the death of the protagonist), and casting against type (Taylor as a Shoshone). The contemporary box office success of Twentieth Century–Fox’s Broken Arrow (1950) spurred timid MGM’s executives to put Mann’s film into release. Variety’s review praised Mann and Alton but felt that the movie’s box office prospects were “not good”; however, five months later, the New York Times called Devil’s Doorway “a whooping action film,” praised the direction of its battle sequences, and thought that Taylor had delivered “a forceful performance.”19 With the passage of time, Mann’s first western has gained more respect as a serious, realistic, and moving account of the problems of the Native Americans in the Old West, while Delmer Daves’s more immediately popular Broken Arrow is now regarded as a bit too melodramatic and romanticized. Inspired by his stage success in Harvey, the Mary Chase vehicle about an amiable middle-aged drunk and his giant imaginary(?) rabbit, James Stewart agreed to a two-picture deal with Universal in 1949 in order to get the play filmed. This arrangement, worked out by the actor’s agent Lew Wasser-
1. In Search of Anthony Mann
13
man, was unusual in that Stewart waived a considerable portion of his salary in favor of subsequently getting a percentage of the films’ profits. While he would operate in this fashion for much of the rest of his Hollywood career, Stewart’s immediate problem was to find a property that would satisfy the second obligation in his contract. In doing so, he came across the preliminary versions of Winchester ’73 which were in the Universal files. The ultimately unsuccessful attempts of Walter Wanger and Fritz Lang to create a workable script had commenced when the producer met with Stuart Lake in late 1945 about the possibility of reviving an earlier effort by the writer entitled “Superstition Mountain”; however, Lake convinced Wanger that a newer story—the basis of Winchester ’73—would be a better bet.20 As a result, Wanger not only hired Lake to produce a screenplay but also agreed with Universal that the project would be one of two Diana productions for 1946 at a budget of $1–1.3 million and to be delivered by December 31 of that year. When Lake subsequently came up with a twenty-page outline, instead of the two hundred pages that Wanger expected, the producer fired the writer, who then went on to produce a novel based on this story. In the meantime Lang, who had become enamored of studio screenwriter Silvia Richards, decided that his latest girlfriend would be the one to produce the Winchester ’73 script; however, when the less than enthused or ambitious Miss Richards could not produce a workable effort, the whole project was allowed to fall into the Universal files. When Stewart came across it there, he initially wanted Lang to direct, but the latter had other commitments and so the actor began looking for an alternate. Stewart then saw some of Mann’s work, was impressed, and decided to offer Winchester ’73 to the director. Now budgeted for $850,000, shooting started in Tucson and wrapped up by February, 1950.21 While Stewart worked diligently in preparing for the film, even going so far as to practice for four days before doing its initial rifle-shooting contest sequence, he was eventually faced with the ironic facts that Harvey enjoyed modest business while Winchester ’73 proved to be financially and professionally much more significant. Mann’s film cast Stewart as a more mature and more complex figure than any he had memorably portrayed up to that time: Lin McAdam is a hero with a penchant for physical and emotional violence that sets him distinctly apart from such characters as the cracker barrel philosopher–lawman Tom Destry (in George Marshall’s Destry Rides Again [Universal, 1939]), the idealistic Jefferson Smith (in Frank Capra’s Mr. Smith Goes to Washington [Columbia, 1939]) and the scholarly (and slightly graying) Rupert Cadell (in Alfred Hitchcock’s Rope [Warner Brothers, 1948]). From 1950 to 1955 Mann and Stewart would make seven more films, and
14
Anthony Mann
in their westerns they would perfect a hardbitten persona for the actor that would ultimately be memorably used by Alfred Hitchcock in Vertigo (Paramount, 1958) and John Ford in Two Rode Together (Columbia, 1961). Winchester ’73 was also the first of three western scripts by Borden Chase who, in Bend of the River (Universal, 1952) and The Far Country (Universal, 1955), would explore the new Stewart persona from the perspectives of a man trying to become respectable (Glyn McLyntock in the earlier film) and a character reluctantly coming to accept his obligations to the larger society in which he lives (Jeff Webster in the later work). Chase’s screenplay and the other technical aspects of Winchester ’73 were lauded by Variety as “Grade A” with good box office prospects. In addition to praising all the featured actors, the reviewer singled out Stewart’s performance as a “lean concentrated portrayal,” while Mann’s direction was “on a par” with the overall quality of the film. Bosley Crowther initially dismissed Winchester ’73 as a typical “cowboy loves gun” horse opera; however, he also noted that the work was “action crammed” and complimented the “light handed direction” that Mann brought to it.22 The Furies (Paramount, 1950) found Variety equating it to Winchester ’73, while the New York Times simply damned the film with faint praise by calling it “colorful.” Cinematographer Victor Milner’s Oscar nomination for the film better suggests its stylistically baroque qualities.23 In 1951, in some measure because of his successes the previous year, MGM sent Mann to Rome where he worked on the studio’s blockbuster production of that year, Quo Vadis. While the final film was largely directed by Hollywood veteran Mervyn LeRoy, two of its obvious “second unit” sequences— the triumphal entrance of the protagonist into Rome and the burning of the city at the mad Nero’s command—are attributed to Mann. His subsequent direction of the action sequences in The Tall Target (MGM, 1951), a train and costume movie about a potential assassination attempt on newly elected president Abraham Lincoln, was “well developed,” although the film needed to reduce its footage devoted to railroad exteriors according to Variety.24 Bend of the River, the second Stewart-Mann collaboration, and the first of seven successive films in which the director would work with the actor, found screenwriter Chase adapting Bill Gulick’s novel Bend of the Snake (1950) by significantly altering its plot and switching the action to Oregon. In the novel, the Emerson Cole character is older than the protagonist and caught up in a war for stagecoach hegemony in the Northwest; eventually, his bad deeds are unearthed and, while he succeeds in temporarily overcoming his various “good guy” rivals, Cole does die by drowning. However, the villain does so in Gulick’s original in spite of the hero’s trying to rescue him; and such characters as the entire Baile family, the
1. In Search of Anthony Mann
15
gambler Trey Wilson (Rock Hudson) and the money-crazed storekeeper Hendricks (Howard Petrie) are significant Chase additions. The central character, named Scott Burton, who emerges as a rancher, gives way to Glyn McLyntock, the ex–Missouri border raider trying to overcome a checkered past, in which he was almost hanged at one time, in order to settle down among the apple-growing community he helps to establish in the new Oregon territory. Variety’s laudatory review emphasized that Stewart was as good as he had been in Winchester ’73 while predicting a “hearty” business for the film. Mann was cited for his “vigorous direction” and the episode in which McLyntock and Cole kill the marauding Indians at night in a forest was singled out as brilliantly executed. While this critic also responded to its “strong outdoor features,” the ever-acerbic Bosley Crowther could only complain of the use of Stepin Fetchit as a comic stereotype.25 The ensemble qualities of The Naked Spur (MGM, 1953) were praised by the New York Times as “refreshingly tough and taut as they come” and its director again lauded for his handling of its action scenes. Variety believed The Naked Spur was “made to order for the western addict,” thought the five-member cast was uniformly excellent, and praised Mann for its unrelenting pace and “understated action” sequences.26 With the completion of The Naked Spur Mann’s contract with MGM came to an end at a time when Hollywood studios were cutting back on long-term arrangements in the face of the rising tide of television. Thunder Bay (Universal, 1953) received mild notices; and, while Variety could praise Mann for getting action “to replace” talkiness, its commentator essentially agreed with the New York Times which dismissed the film as “very ordinary.”27 No such reservations were expressed by these critics with The Glenn Miller Story (Universal, 1954) as both the Times and Variety saw this musical biopic as certain to be successful; indeed, the former found it to be the best Hollywood musical biography since Yankee Doodle Dandy (Warner Brothers, 1942), while the latter, despite some reservations about the film’s length, found its direction to be “sympathetic.”28 Strategic Air Command (Paramount, 1955), the third film initiated by star Stewart which Mann essentially agreed to do out of loyalty rather than intense personal commitment, was variously praised for its music and aerial photography (by the New York Times) as well as its large-screen process (VistaVision) and the ways in which the action segues from scene to scene.29 The work represents the most overtly jingoistic or patriotic film that Mann ever directed as its story of a ballplayer turned jet pilot ended up pleading for national preparedness and praising the military organization that was protecting America’s safety and prosperity.
16
Anthony Mann
From left (foreground): James Stewart, Anthony Mann and cinematographer Charles Lang (standing, right) on the set of The Man from Laramie (Columbia, 1955). The last collaboration between the actor and the director would prove to be one of their best as Will Lockhart (Stewart) discovers his need for revenge must give way to his being human.
1. In Search of Anthony Mann
17
The Far Country and The Man from Laramie (Columbia, 1955) completed the series of westerns for which Mann and Stewart would later be celebrated by critics. The Far Country received good reviews from Variety, which characteristically cited its box office appeal, and the New York Times, which praised its location work.30 The second film represented what Mann would later call his final variation on the tough persona which he and Stewart had created; at the same time, with its heavy emphasis on family and patriarchy, it clearly foreshadows Man of the West (United Artists, 1958). The director’s work on The Man from Laramie was described as “expertly punched” by Variety and as “fierce and steady” by the Times; more insightfully, the first reviewer also commented on how directly the violence related to the plot development.31 It was seemingly this feature of The Man from Laramie that helped to precipitate the breakup of the Mann-Stewart working partnership. When Will Lockhart is roped and dragged through a fire during the scene at the salt flats, and when he battles against Dave Waggoman (Alex Nicol) and Vic Hasbro (Arthur Kennedy), it is clearly Stewart who is being photographed without the use of a stunt double. Such a procedure was, of course, in line with Mann’s sense of realism; indeed, his oft-cited remarks about how exterior locations add immeasurably to the actors’ performances clearly imply such a direct approach to scenes of violence. His star, who was in his late forties by this time, while outwardly agreeable to doing such sequences, was privately complaining about their rigors, and when Mann subsequently questioned the characterization that Stewart wanted to develop in Night Passage (Universal, 1957), the two men went their separate ways.32 Before that professional rupture, however, Mann turned out The Last Frontier (Columbia, 1955); and, while the film received a lukewarm critical reception—Variety said it “never rises above the routine” and the Times’s Bosley Crowther simply noted that its theme was civilization is “awful”—it has emerged as one of the director’s more intriguing works.33 No such claim can be advanced for Serenade (Warner Brothers, 1956). This attempt to reprise the success of The Glenn Miller Story flounders from beginning to end. Variety described Mann’s direction as “skillful” but its review and that of the New York Times offer little more than damning with faint praise for tenor Mario Lanza’s supposed “comeback” effort.34 During the filming of Serenade, Mann and leading lady Sarita Montiel fell in love, a development that led to his divorce of Mildred and remarriage to the Mexican actress in 1957. Montiel appeared in Robert Aldrich’s Vera Cruz (United Artists, 1954) and Samuel Fuller’s Run of the Arrow (RKO, 1957); however, the fact that she had to be dubbed (by co-star Angie Dickinson) in the less than distinguished Tension at Table Rock (RKO, 1956),
18
Anthony Mann
when combined with her less than scintillating work in Serenade, indicates her limitations as a performer. When Mann and Stewart differed over Night Passage, the director shifted over to The Tin Star (Paramount, 1957) with a script by celebrated screenwriter Dudley Nichols. The usual sources found The Tin Star to be “a quality western” with “smooth direction” and an outstanding performance from Henry Fonda (Variety) in addition to exhibiting a “lean laconic fashion” on Mann’s part (The New York Times).35 Mann next moved to independent production with his own company Security Pictures, for which he directed Men in War (1957) and God’s Little Acre (1958), two of his most successful works. In addition to lead writer Philip Yordan, the crews included cinematographer Ernest Haller, composer Elmer Bernstein, and lead actors Robert Ryan and Aldo Ray. The Korean War story received only slight praise from Variety which claimed it was “mostly for male audiences” even though the battle scenes, the music, and the performances of Ryan as the beleaguered commander, Ray as a seemingly heartless professional warrior, and Robert Keith as a shell-shocked colonel, were all praised. The always prickly Bosley Crowther simply dismissed Men in War as yet another exposition of the theme that combat is “unequivocal hell” and found Mann’s direction “clichéd.”36 While it is based on the novel Combat (1949) by Van Van Praag, Men in War transforms its source in many obvious ways. Yordan transfers the World War II action of the book to the early stages of the Korean War; eschews its approach, in which many characters appear and disappear almost at random, to hone in on the trials of a single combat unit; and abandons its downbeat ending, in which the major character is finally sent home because of wounds, to offer a profound meditation on how savage apparently civilized men must become in order to survive in war. Once again, the film’s reputation has grown considerably with the passage of time and the emergence of more skeptical sensibilities. The critical responses to God’s Little Acre were much more laudatory. While initially billed as a lurid tale of unrestrained sexuality—and hailed by the mainstream publications Life, Time, and Newsweek because of such prerelease publicity—the serious critics saw the finished film as “adult, sensitive, and intelligent” (Variety). Ryan’s performance as the tragic-comical patriarch Ty-Ty and the musical treatments of Elmer Bernstein were also lauded. Mann was praised for his direction of his whole ensemble, which included performers with talents as various as Tina Louise (as the earthy but honorable Griselda) and Buddy Hackett (as the comically inept Pluto Swint).37 The director’s next film, Man of the West, is now widely hailed as a mas-
1. In Search of Anthony Mann
19
From left: Director Nicholas Ray with Philip Yordan. The screenwriter would work with Mann on The Black Book (1949), The Last Frontier (1955), Men in War (1957), God’s Little Acre (1958), El Cid (1961) and The Fall of the Roman Empire (1964).
20
Anthony Mann
terpiece, if not as the masterpiece, in Mann’s entire career. Its initial release in New York found the film running off Broadway in a secondary theater in spite of its featuring Gary Cooper as its leading man. Variety noted that while it contained scenes of “great power” in showing how its protagonist must revert to “savagery,” Man of the West suffers from being obsessed with “pseudo-masculinity.” Its emphases on realistic, rather than psychological, conflict make it “one of the bloodiest, most brutal, and unsparing portraits of the Old West.” Paradoxically, the New York Times thought the film exhibited too much “staginess,” even though it was “well acted and beautifully photographed” and Mann had directed “like a stalking panther.”38 Mann’s screenwriter, Reginald Rose, worked diligently to transform the Will C. Brown novel The Border Jumpers (1955) into a workable movie script. To do so, Rose deleted major elements such as a Texas Ranger eventually marrying Billie Ellis; the protagonist frequently remembering his wife Lucy, never approaching the saloon singer romantically, and killing Coaley himself after their epic struggle; and the blind Dock Tobin committing suicide after all the other members of his gang are gunned down in an attempted raid on a general store. Rose cleverly emphasized the madness and power of the outlaw patriarch, the torments of the trapped protagonist who must annihilate his former evil family, and the character of Cousin Claude, who emerges as a powerful mirror image of Link Jones. Indeed, the moral and intellectual insights of Mann’s protagonist stand in the sharpest contrast to the simpler and more accepting personality of Brown’s leading character. The next phase of Mann’s career found him laboring, with varying degrees of success, on Cimarron (MGM, 1960) and Spartacus (Universal, 1960). For the former film, the director was called back to his former studio to remake the RKO original which had won the Best Picture Academy Award in 1930. Producer Edmund Grainger and screenwriter Arnold Schulman saw the popular Edna Ferber novel (1929) as a great romantic story set in the West, while Mann envisioned the film as a panorama of the social movements that had shaped America from the late nineteenth through the early twentieth centuries.39 The director tried to make an outdoor epic by relying heavily on location shooting, but studio executives eventually became troubled by this approach because they felt the film needed more emphasis on the soap opera marriage of its principal characters, Yancey (Glenn Ford) and Sabra Cravat (Maria Schell). This disparity in approaches eventually reached a boiling point and Mann left the production. It was finished by Grainger, who brought in Reggie Callow to film some scenes to make the romantic angst of the Cravats more apparent. While Mann is officially credited as the director of Cimarron, the unevenness of the finished picture was perhaps best described
1. In Search of Anthony Mann
21
by the New York Times’s Bosley Crowther who found it “exciting—for half an hour.”40 Interestingly enough, Edna Ferber thought it the better of the two film versions, even though she believed that neither work had truly caught the spirit of what she had written.41 Universal had decided to financially back Kirk Douglas’s Spartacus; however, the actor-producer’s wish to have Stanley Kubrick, who had overseen the masterful anti-war Paths of Glory (United Artists, 1957), direct this blockbuster was looked at askance by studio officials, who insisted that the more experienced Mann be used. However, after a few weeks of shooting, neither Douglas nor Universal were pleased with the results, and so the director was fired—albeit he was paid his full salary ($75,000) by Douglas, who personally handled the dismissal. One popular explanation for this turn of events was that Mann was being too subservient to actor Peter Ustinov, who won an Oscar for his performance as Batiatus the ever-mercenary trader in gladiators, and that Douglas became incensed over this seeming slight. While the truth of the matter seems more mundane, it remains fairly clear—as Mann himself would subsequently state—that much of the film’s first hour was done by the director in spite of Kubrick’s getting the screen credit.42 Serendipitously, in spite of these two artistic and personal setbacks, Mann’s reputation as an epic director was secured by his next assignment, El Cid, released in 1961 under the aegis of legendary producer Samuel Bronston. As a vigorous self-promotional genius, Bronston, whose family was related to the famous Russian Revolutionary leader Leon Trotsky (Lev Davidovich Bronstein), had finagled his way into various film studio jobs in France during the 1930s; and, at the same time, he had made a useful contact in the widow of the American novelist and short story writer Jack London.43 Forced to leave France and emigrate to the United States because of “financial difficulties,” Bronston inveigled a job as a film producer at Columbia in the early 1940s. The Adventures of Martin Eden, based on the London novel, was released in 1942; and Bronston went on to be officially credited as the producer on United Artists’ Jack London (1943), a highly romanticized account of the writer’s life. He was then associated with City Without Men (1943), Lewis Milestone’s somber war drama A Walk in the Sun (United Artists, 1945) and the delightful Agatha Christie adaptation And Then There Were None (United Artists, 1945) crafted by expatriate French director Rene Clair. Despite such associations, Bronston fell on hard times in the late 1940s and returned to Europe where he was able to ingratiate himself with the Papacy to the extent that the Roman Catholic Church hired him to produce a series of documentary films on the artistic treasures of the Vatican. By the late 1950s Bronston, ever the calculating promoter, had come to realize that
22
Anthony Mann
movie production in Spain could be financed in ways that would attract foreign investors. Due to currency restrictions imposed by the Franco government, profits could only taken out of the country in the form of Spanish currency which was seriously devalued in international markets. Bronston proposed (to virtually anyone who would listen) that by making movies for worldwide release he could essentially utilize the “frozen funds” and pay his investors back in more profitable currencies. His own predilection for epic stories and his own quest for artistic “realism” not only led to Bronston’s building his own movie studio near Madrid but also to his setting forth on a series of six epic films with international casts. These spectacles, which increasingly came to feature performers from various countries in an effort to maximize their box office appeal, were characterized by the painstaking construction of open air sets and Bronston’s own style of highly individualized marketing. While his first two releases, John Paul Jones (1959) directed by John Farrow, and King of Kings (1961) directed by Nicholas Ray, enjoyed enough success to keep Bronston financially afloat, it was with El Cid (1961) that he was to enjoy his greatest success: That film, made at a cost of approximately $6.5 million, grossed nearly $26.5 million upon its initial release. Unhappily, this financial windfall led to the ultimate demise of Bronston’s production company: The movie impresario was not financially careful in being too trusting of some of his closest associates, as well as prodigal with production moneys. His financial plan was, quite simply, that the profits from a movie in release would satisfy his creditors and encourage new investors; and, while this scheme worked to perfection with El Cid, Bronston’s successive works— 55 Days at Peking (1963) again directed by Nicholas Ray, The Fall of the Roman Empire (1964), and Circus World (1964) with Henry Hathaway in charge—were Producer Samuel Bronston. The ornate producnot nearly profitable enough tion values of El Cid (1961) and The Fall of the to keep his movie operation Roman Empire (1964) reflect the prodigality with which Bronston approached epic filmmaking. afloat. It was, indeed, the
1. In Search of Anthony Mann
23
production costs of The Fall of the Roman Empire, estimated at between $26 and $28 million, that sank the producer’s ship when that film returned approximately $7 million at the box office on its initial release. Mann was brought into this idiosyncratic atmosphere of continual financial promotion and production values that outdid anything ever attempted before (or since) in terms of the scale of the sets, especially for The Fall of the Roman Empire. His work on El Cid was widely heralded by critics, with Variety emphasizing the film’s action and “pictorial values” while singling out Genevieve Page (as the villainous Urraca) and Douglas Wilmer (as the Moorish ally Moutamin) for their performances. Bosley Crowther gave the film the very best notice that he ever had for a Mann work, going so far as to praise the director and cinematographer Robert Krasker. In addition, the veteran New York Times critic extolled the “sheer pictorial punch” of much of the film and was especially delighted by the duel sequence at Calahorra. At the end of the year, Crowther even included El Cid in his list of the ten best films of 1961.44 Eager to repeat his success and working with individuals who were constantly looking for new epic material, Mann suggested the theme of Roman imperial decline to Bronston and Philip Yordan, who was functioning as a writing supervisor for the producer; and they, in turn, pitched the idea to Sophia Loren and Charlton Heston, the co-stars of El Cid. While Loren was willing to participate, Heston balked for personal and professional reasons and then accepted the lead role in 55 Days at Peking, another project that was in the works at the Spanish movie studio. Eventually, even without Heston’s participation, Mann and Bronston gathered a thoroughly epic cast for The Fall of the Roman Empire with Stephen Boyd, Loren, Alec Guinness, James Mason, Christopher Plummer, and Omar Sharif along with numerous other well-known performers. The grandiose sets, which were built as free standing and three-dimensional structures, included the winter fortress–palace of Marcus Aurelius and a virtual reconstruction of the Roman Forum. Despite such attention to detail, and spectacular sequences like the forest battle with the German barbarians, the chariot race–fight between Livius (Boyd) and Commodus (Plummer), the gigantic battle of the four armies on the plains of Asia Minor, and the final orgiastic and duel scenes within the Forum, The Fall of the Roman Empire was a decided commercial failure. The review in Variety proved shortsighted when it declared that this Bronston release was “bigger and better than El Cid,” for, while The Fall of the Roman Empire may well have been more lavish in its sets, the story simply did not please in spite of its being “cleverly directed.”45 Bosley Crowther was clearly more prescient when he declared the film
24
Anthony Mann
to be “incoherent and overdone;” and, if observers can now see a great deal more to appreciate in Mann’s Roman epic, the critic’s judgment was undoubtedly reflective of the more sober political atmosphere which descended upon America after the assassination of President Kennedy. While El Cid presented the triumph of heroic action over social and political disarray (and was shown at least three times at the White House during Kennedy’s administration), The Fall of the Roman Empire reflected some of the loss of confidence in political action that would become even more marked as the 1960s wore on. Shortly after his marriage to Sarita Montiel was annulled in 1963, Mann wed ballerina Anna Kutzho, with whom he had a son, Nicholas, born in 1965. At the same time, because of the increasing shift toward independent movie production and the demise of the Bronston establishment, Mann realized that he would have to take a greater hand in finding projects. Now based in Europe, he was instrumental in producing as well as directing The Heroes of Telemark, a Rank-Columbia co-production that was released in 1965 and which would be his last completed film. This World War II story of Norwegian resistance fighters undoing Nazi efforts to produce “heavy water,” an essential ingredient for an atomic bomb, found the director reunited with leading man Kirk Douglas. In addition to feeling that he “owed” Mann a movie because of what had happened on Spartacus, the star later described how the director would throw snow in his face, and that of co-star Richard Harris, in order to increase the verisimilitude of their scenes in the wintry landscape. Variety praised the art direction and the cinematography and pronounced The Heroes of Telemark a “lofty, gripping, and carefully made entertainment”; the New York Times found the film “scenically beautiful” and complimented Mann for his “tight direction.”46 Despite such complimentary reviews, the work did only modest box office business, in part, perhaps, because of its anticlimactic screenplay which featured an entire hour of plot after the main attack on the German installation. Clearly, Mann’s film lacked the kind of typical bravura ending found in such films as The Guns of Navarone (1961). More notable and obvious plot problems also beset the last film on which Mann worked. A Dandy in Aspic featured a script by Derek Marlowe, who had written the 1966 novel on which the work was based; however, both versions were simply too convoluted, and the overall plot of a double agent being used as a pawn by callous superiors had been much more deftly rendered in The Spy Who Came In from the Cold (Paramount, 1965) which featured Richard Burton and was based on a John Le Carre novel. In addition, and most tragically, the director died in the middle of
1. In Search of Anthony Mann
25
filming and was replaced by leading man Laurence Harvey, who completed the work for Columbia in 1968. A Dandy in Aspic was panned by both Variety (which saw its direction as “contrived”) and the New York Times (which dismissed it as “wobbly”). While one would like to imagine that the finished product would have been improved if Mann’s guiding hand had been present throughout its shooting, it is strikingly apparent that the director was critically regarded as passé.47 However appropriate such an evaluation was for its time, Mann’s final films are much more resonant and prescient today. The Fall of the Roman Empire, however entertaining the personal stories that went into its making, appears particularly apt in being a meditation over how political power is, ultimately, lost. Indeed, it is a film that operates at several levels; and, while it has been evaluated and often dismissed in terms of plot or acting, on a philosophical level Mann’s work emerges as one of the truly thought-provoking efforts in film history. If anything, the large-scale intellectual challenges thrown out by The Fall of the Roman Empire render its earlier dismissals as essentially beside the point. At the same time, The Heroes of Telemark and A Dandy in Aspic show Mann turning his attention to the twentieth century in ways that he had not heretofore done. The claustrophobic worlds of his noir films and the contented societies he portrays in his obligatory assignments for James Stewart— Thunder Bay, The Glenn Miller Story, and Strategic Air Command—lack the scope of these two final films. While they are uneven because of the director’s death and the circumstances under which A Dandy in Aspic was completed, both films illustrate Mann’s greater concern with coming to grips with the modern world of the Cold War and potential annihilation.
2
Mann and the B Film Had Anthony Mann died or simply quit Hollywood before 1947, his career as a film director would be of little interest, save to the most zealous of auteurist critics. From his debut, effort with Dr. Broadway (Paramount, 1942) through The Bamboo Blonde (RKO, 1946), Mann was beset by trite scripts, meager production values, and superficial (if not incompetent) actors. While two of these films—Strangers in the Night (Republic, 1944) and Strange Impersonation (Republic, 1946)—exhibit stylistic features and thematic emphases that mark the mature filmmaker, Mann was, at best, making B pictures on very tight shooting schedules. Mann exhibits greater control as he works through these assignments, and one can clearly discern a marked stylistic gain with his first feature for RKO, Two O’Clock Courage (1945), if only because of more luxurious production and post-production facilities supplied by that studio. If Dr. Broadway foreshadows Mann’s work in film noir by virtue of its urban setting and character types, Two O’Clock Courage also anticipates this later development because of its emphases on a weak male protagonist and the conflicting personas of the women he encounters during his basically nocturnal adventures. During the war years, Mann worked industriously enough as a B film director at Paramount, Universal, Republic, and, finally, RKO. His debut film Dr. Broadway is of greatest interest because it shows Mann’s relative control of the medium in which he was to work until his death twenty-five years and forty-one pictures later. While the five musicals which Mann turned out during this period also show his stylistic competence, they are neither inspired or inspiring; at best, they show how the director could accommodate himself to standard studio assignments. Strangers in the Night and Strange Impersonation were much more temperamentally congenial to Mann because they deal with suspense, murder, violence, and psychological anguish and serve as clear anticipations of what he would accomplish in film noir.
26
2. Mann and the B Film
27
Breaking the Ice: Dr. Broadway Mann’s debut feature is, at best, a well-crafted B feature whose wisecracking script and austere production values uneasily compete for slightly more than an hour. Fortunately, Mann achieves a pace that covers up much of the clichéd character drawing and familiar plot holes that beset the script. He also delineates his first set of double villains, offers some signature stylistic moments, and provides harsh physical violence, all traits that will mark his more lauded later films. Initially, one is struck by the comic dialogue in Dr. Broadway. The good characters—Dr. Timothy Kane (Macdonald Carey), Detective Sergeant Pat Doyle (Richard Lane), and Connie Madigan (Jean Phillips)—are virtually signaled by their breeziness. Indeed, their repartee reassures the audience that nothing serious will happen to any of them. On the other hand, the villains—Vic Telli (Eduardo Ciannelli) and Jack Venner (J. Carrol Naish)—are never given any genuine comic lines. The dying Telli, who has been paroled because of a terminal illness, can plead with Dr. Kane after we see him simply snarling at his former confederate Venner. The haberdasher-criminal can only alternate between being browbeaten, hypocritical, or demonic with Telli and Kane. The protagonist is one of those concoctions so beloved by screenwriters, for Timothy Kane embodies the noble loner qualities we associate with the heroes of private eye and cowboy fiction. Under prodding by Sergeant Doyle, who asks midway through the film why Kane “hangs around Broadway” instead of developing a lucrative practice elsewhere, Dr. Broadway offers that he is “needed” here. Like numerous knights errant and such fictional and idealist characters as Raymond Chandler’s Philip Marlowe and Jack Schaefer’s Shane, Mann’s central figure is sacrificing himself for a greater, com- Dr. Timothy Kane (MacDonald Carey) and Connie Madigan (Jean mon good. Phillips) in Dr. Broadway (ParaAs the eponymous hero, Kane mount, 1942). Mann’s first film emerges as a combination of Lancelot, uneasily combines tension and Tarzan, and Sherlock Holmes: Not only comedy.
28
Anthony Mann
does he seek to do good deeds because he must but he also has the support of a virtual community of Broadway’s denizens whenever he needs their assistance. Just as the Lord of the Jungle could summon up its animal population to aid him in combating evil, Dr. Broadway can enlist the aid of his urban pals, a group that includes con men like the Professor (Olin Howland), newspaper vendors like Broadway Carrie (Mary Gordon) and assorted toughs like Maxie, the Goat (Warren Hymer). Kane naturally agrees to seek out Telli’s long-lost daughter in order to deliver the money ($100,000) left to her by her father. When he is confronted by an imposter in the duplicitous Mary (Jane Randolph in the first of three appearances for Mann) who has been sent by Venner, Kane quickly discovers that she has her tonsils, because of a detail that Telli shared earlier with him about “holding” his daughter’s hand when she had them removed. Despite such prescience, the protagonist gets knocked out and is at risk of his life at the climax. To alleviate this problem, Mann unhappily resorts to a deus ex machina device which has Maxie kill Venner so that Kane does not have to do so; indeed, the staging of this sequence offers an abrupt reversal because the audience does not see Maxie until after the shots have been fired. Vic Telli is introduced as apparently out to get even with Mann’s protagonist because the latter’s testimony sent him to prison. Despite numerous warnings, Dr. Broadway goes to meet Telli in a nightclub, and the sequence is initially staged as though it were to be a shootout. Telli holds court at a side table and, after dismissing the obsequious Venner, he is told that Kane has arrived. The camera then tracks with a waiter who informs various patrons of the impending confrontation and they, in turn, get up and leave. At the end of that track, Kane is shown entering and silence prevails as he walks to Telli’s table in a reverse tracking shot. At the criminal’s table Kane is initially perplexed when Telli reaches into his breast pocket, but, instead of a gun, he produces a cigar—a trait that Venner has already brought to the audience’s attention by mentioning that Telli has always offered him a cigar in their previous meetings. While the withholding or rewarding of a cigar represents a simple way of delineating good and bad guys, it is a measure of Mann’s skill at this point that he feels that this device be underlined by expository dialogue; as he develops, the director will simply show such actions without comment and allow his audiences to make such connections for themselves. Mann is more purely visual with other sequences, particularly Telli’s murder. Kane is initially informed of the criminal’s return by a message written on a mirror, the first of numerous instances when such an object and its reflections will be used in Mann’s films. Telli’s demise in Kane’s office is, of course, not shown in any detail; instead, as he settles into a chair to be treated
2. Mann and the B Film
29
Connie Madigan (Jean Phillips) on the building ledge at the beginning of Dr. Broadway (Paramount, 1942). Mann’s film begins and ends in the same location with the title character rescuing the heroine on both occasions.
30
Anthony Mann
by a heat lamp, we see a door behind Telli that is being ominously opened. Later, when Kane and Doyle notice the heat lamp is still on (after the protagonist told Telli he should only stay under it for five minutes) and rush to the office, their reactions to the apparently “cooked” villain are handled through reactions shots of their faces, then a quick cut to an electric light as if to re-emphasize what has happened. Venner emerges as the film’s major villain, albeit one for whom overt violence is only a last resort; indeed, like Rick Coyle (Raymond Burr) in Raw Deal (1948), the hoodlum prefers to have others do his dirty work. In an extended confrontation with Kane, the master villain mixes open confessions and threats with repartee about buying a suit; in doing so, Venner comes across as a charming antagonist—one who prefigures such characters as Emerson Cole (Arthur Kennedy) in Bend of the River (1952) and Judge Gannon (John McIntire) in The Far Country (1955). One of Venner’s gang, Red (Gerald Mohr), anticipates the libidinous henchmen perfected later by John Ireland in Railroaded (1947) and Raw Deal as well as Charles McGraw in T-Men (1948) and Border Incident (1949). Red not only slaps Connie around after taking her prisoner but he also works over one of his gang when the man attempts to leave prior to their executing Mann’s heroine in line with Venner’s ultimatum to Kane about delivering Telli’s money or losing the girl. The abruptness with which Red strikes out at both of these other characters and the sadistic pleasure he seemingly takes in humiliating them are traits that Mann will explore and perfect in such figures as Dave Waggoman (Alex Nicol) in The Man from Laramie and Coaley (Jack Lord) in Man of the West (1958). The most notable stylistic feature of Dr. Broadway is its emphasis on heights. The film is framed by two scenes on a building ledge, one played for comedy and exposition and the other for resolution. In the first scene, which opens the movie, Connie perches precariously on the ledge and has attracted the attention of police, firemen, and various gawkers as she hollers “Out of this world!” A sorely beset fire chief and Pat Doyle muse over the situation until Dr. Broadway shows up, speculates on the psychology of the seeming suicide, and then offers to get her down. After some elliptical dialogue about his being a “pigeon,” Kane does get the girl inside only to discover that she has been hired to promote a jazz band that is “out of this world.” He then knocks Connie out in order to gain time so that he can maneuver her out of serving time in jail. While the rapidity of Kane’s affection for Connie and the ease with which he contrives to get a friendly judge to parole her to him as his receptionist are inevitable features of B movie scripting, Connie’s subsequent cleaning of Kane’s office window—by leaning out precariously and having
2. Mann and the B Film
31
him pull her back inside—makes the obvious connection that he must and will save her in the film’s climax. That action occurs when Connie manages to get away from the Venner gang and call attention to her being once again perched on the building ledge by dropping one of her shoes on the head of a pedestrian nine stories below. Now aware of the gang’s hiding place, the police and Sergeant Doyle storm the building and arrest the thugs; at the same time, Kane has his final confrontation with Venner and the latter is killed. The film then moves to its quick resolution as Connie is now terrified of being on a ledge and once again only the protagonist can save her. After Kane gets her to stop being “frozen” and to come back with him to the open window, Mann’s camera reverses to Doyle and a friend as they watch the lovers embrace as signaled by Connie’s telltale bending up to kiss the hero. In this way Mann restores comic order to the world of Dr. Broadway in a thoroughly judicious (and inexpensive) B movie fashion. Dr. Broadway was not well received on its initial release; however, a later and more nuanced evaluation from The Motion Picture Guide offers that Dr. Broadway “is a poor first film from director Anthony Mann, but it does hint at his later talents.” Dr. Broadway reveals Mann’s ability to understand the genre in which he was working; if he does little that is out of the ordinary, at the same time he does nothing that slows the pace or that seems gratuitous. Clearly Mann had learned well from his earlier years in and around Hollywood.
Mired in Musicals (1): Moonlight in Havana (1942), Nobody’s Darling (1943), My Best Gal (1944), Sing Your Way Home (1945), and The Bamboo Blonde (1946) Between 1942 and 1946, Mann directed five B musicals at Universal, Republic, and RKO. While none of them rise above the ordinary, they again show his competence in handling generic pieces. Mann combines the placing of musical numbers with the love triangles and screwball comic turns that mark Hollywood efforts of the time. These films are obviously quickly made and replete with cheap sets and process shots, and Mann’s sure sense of pace once again serves to conceal their meager budgets. While each film ends with an obligatory lavish production number—a convention that always finds huge spaces and elaborate casts and props suddenly employed in what has heretofore been an austere film world—Mann never allows these big set pieces to go on too long as he brings about quick romantic resolutions to his supporting plots. Whether it’s the happy fadeout of Moonlight in Havana (Universal, 1942)
32
Anthony Mann
in which the reconciled lovers, Johnny “Whizzer” Norton (Allan Jones) and Gloria Jackson (Jane Frazee), perform to “Rhythm of the Tropics”; the “Blow, Gabriel, Blow” ending of Nobody’s Darling (Republic, 1943) where teenage sweethearts, Janie Farnsworth (Mary Lee) and Chuck Grant (Jackie Moran) cavort; or the army base production of “Everything Is Awfully Humpty Dumpty” in My Best Gal (Republic, 1944) as Johnny McCloud (Jimmy Lydon) and Kitty O’Hara (Jane Withers) are blissfully reunited, Mann never allows such sequences to become tedious. The finale of Sing Your Way Home (RKO 1945) is more succinct as the adult lovers, Steve Kimball (Jack Haley) and Kay Lawrence (Anne Jeffreys), return to her nightclub only to discover that the ingénue lovers, Bridget (Marcy McGuire) and Jimmy (Glen Vernon), have substituted for them in the big production number (“Imagine Me”). Mann ends the film with a shot of the laughing adults which is thoroughly in keeping with his plot line in which the egotistical reporter Steve must be comically corrected by the people around him and, most especially, by the affection of Kay. Mann takes a similarly light and comic approach in The Bamboo Blonde (RKO, 1946) when he has the feuding lovers, Pat Ransom Jr. (Russell Wade) and Louise Anderson (Frances Langford), reconcile at the home of the boy’s rich parents. This resolution follows a staged emergency landing by Pat which is designed to enable his parents (Paul Harvey and Regina Wallace) to meet the girl he loves. After Pat has fallen into an oil well and been thoroughly soaked, he returns to the palatial Ransom home to find that Louise has captivated his parents into singing, so he whisks her off into a side room as the end credits emerge on screen. Mann’s wartime musicals often include mistaken or serious love triangles to keep their thin plots afloat. In Moonlight in Havana this relationship turns on a comic gambit in which Johnny Norton must have a head cold in order to sing well. At one point Norton can only attain this condition by kissing the already sniffling Patsy Clark (Marjorie Lord), who then briefly imagines that the protagonist is in love with her. To add to this complication, their kissing scene is witnessed by Gloria, who immediately sees romantic perfidy, a development which leads to some inevitable comic confusions before the lovers arrive at the climax to sing and dance. Sing Your Way Home briefly pits the lovestruck and teenage Bridget against the more mature Kay; however, this complication remains fixed at a comic level because Steve never seriously considers the younger infatuated girl as suitable. The love triangle figures more significantly in The Bamboo Blonde in that Pat is initially engaged to Eileen Sawyer (Jane Greer), even though she is too busy in the film’s opening sequence to spend the evening with him before he ships out to the Pacific. While her absence leads to Pat’s meeting
2. Mann and the B Film
33
Commander Pat Ransom, Jr. (Russell Wade) admires the pin-up painting of singer Louise Anderson (Francis Langford) which inspires him and his crew to fight more effectively against the Japanese in The Bamboo Blonde (RKO, 1946).
Louise and their happy times at a small diner and train station, Eileen later emerges as a distinct threat to the eventual happiness of the lovers. When Pat and his crew return from overseas as heroes because of their record in action (apparently motivated by their painting of Louise in a bathing suit on their B-29), Eileen shows her jealous nature by intruding into the airport
34
Anthony Mann
meeting between the pilot and Louise and reasserting her position as his fiancée. This situation becomes even more explosive when Pat prevails on the general (Jason Robards) to allow Louise to accompany him and his crew on the bond drive for which they have been brought back home. During this tour the singer delivers a musical number (“Right Along About Evening”) in which she strips down to her slip and takes a folded poster of Pat to bed with her at one rally. Despite such an obviously symbolic “coupling,” Eileen re-emerges to convince the middle-class Louise that Pat’s wealthy parents will never accept her as a daughter-in-law. This development leads to Louise’s oversexed performance of “I’m Good for Nothing But Love” in front of the elder Ransoms, their guests, and a stunned Pat. When Louise then runs out, the hero follows her to the local airport to set up the film’s comic resolution. Interestingly, the nefarious Eileen is simply shunted to one side—and essentially forgotten—in the final sequence. These films also feature obvious comic relief characters with Hollywood’s most memorable funny drunk, Jack Norton, appearing in Moonlight in Havana and Sing Your Way Home. Gladys George, as inept homemaker Eve Hawthorne/Farnsworth in Nobody’s Darling, and George Cleveland as superstitious Broadway producer Ralph Hodges in My Best Gal, also operate as stereotypes to provide laughs. While Eve Hawthorne/Farnsworth eventually emerges as a caring mother and a faithful wife, Hodges is strictly a comic foil who constantly consults astrology charts, insists that the “kids” cannot be in his show, and then relents to give them “one chance.” Much of the comic business in Sing Your Way Home naturally devolves on Jack Haley who performs various pratfalls and verbal gaffes, while the loudmouth impresario Eddie Clark (Ralph Edwards) carries the same burdens in The Bamboo Blonde. Edwards’s performance is probably the most annoying turn rendered by anyone in these films and, finally, comes across as a rare instance when an actor comes across as “too stagey” in a Mann work. These musicals all turn on familiar generic and plot conventions. Thus, we find the old chestnut of “let’s put on a show” so the kids “can be discovered” as the central plot point in Nobody’s Darling and My Best Gal. The “show must go on” motif is utilized in Moonlight in Havana so that Johnny must finally choose between baseball (his ostensible reason for initially wanting to get to Havana and rejoin his team) and show business (the means he uses to get to Cuba because he’s broke and the team won’t advance him any travel money). Naturally, romance and applause win out in Moonlight in Havana, even though the team’s owner has money problems; and, in a bit of slapdash plot-
2. Mann and the B Film
35
ting, those financial worries are magically resolved before Johnny and Gloria do their final number. Sing Your Way Home offers numerous shipboard performances by the repatriated “hep cats,” all designed to win attention and become part of Steve’s radio broadcast; while The Bamboo Blonde, as a showcase for Frances Langford, uses her songs to underline her romantic feelings for Pat. Loyalty to show business is a pronounced feature of Nobody’s Darling which begins with the news that matriarch Eve has been replaced as a leading lady by her movie studio. This bombshell is Publicity still of Frances Langford at the delivered to daughter Janie by time of The Bamboo Blonde (RKO, 1946). her father, Curtis Farnsworth The singer would also be featured in The (Louis Calhern), who has deciGlenn Miller Story (Universal, 1954). ded that he too must retire in order to spare his wife’s feelings. While this initial ploy only leads to Eve’s becoming angry, because Curtis presents it as a unilateral decision (in order to hide the truth from his beloved wife), and throwing him out while threatening divorce, the couple reconciles when their daughter is about to be expelled from the prestigious Pennington School, an educational enclave for the children of movie stars. At the film’s conclusion, the Farnsworths and Mr. Grant (Lloyd Corrigan) are persuaded by the benevolent and wiser Miss Pennington (Lee Patrick) to allow the school’s musical revue to go on with their children, Janie and Chuck, in the leading roles. The parents are convinced not only by the argument that the show must go on but also by their own egotistic assumptions that their offspring must inevitably be talented because of genetics. Mann uses the same motif in My Best Gal in which a doting grandfather, Danny O’Hara (Frank Craven), takes pains to get his granddaughter Kitty to follow in his showbiz footsteps. After allowing the neighborhood to eavesdrop on Kitty as she showers and sings, Danny tries to cajole her to go to an audition but runs up against her practical argument that she enjoys eating too much to want to risk trying for a career in show business. This
36
Anthony Mann
conflict is carried further when the smitten Kitty goes out on a date with Johnny who has agreed to Danny’s scheme to get her to unwittingly audition for an important producer. When Kitty sees through this ruse, she becomes angry with Johnny to create the familiar “she loves me, she loves me not” plot dilemma. Her dismay becomes even more pronounced when Johnny appears to betray “the kids” by selling his musical to Hodges with the understanding that Broadway professionals will be its cast. However, by this time Danny has fallen ill and needs money for an operation so that it’s clear to the audience that Johnny has sacrificed for a nobler cause. When Kitty figures out the real reason for her lover’s behavior, she naturally rushes to see him off at the train station (he’s enlisted) and then persuades Hodges to change his mind about casting the youngsters in order to set up the army base finale. On the road to that resolution, Mann interjects a highly sentimental scene between Danny and Kitty in which the grandfather gives her a set of tap shoes as a symbolic gesture to affirm her new commitment to the performing life. The shoes, it turns out, had belonged to Kitty’s mother—an erstwhile vaudevillian like Danny—and he’s been saving them for an appropriate moment. Now that Kitty has opted for a show business career, she can receive the shoes, which she promises to restore and use in the future. We see here how the director makes an object stand for a complex of ideas and emotions and, while the meanings are still delivered through expository dialogue, his use of such symbols will become both more profound and less obvious in later films. World War II emerges as both background and then foreground in the plots of Mann’s B musicals. Nobody’s Darling touches on wartime scarcities by showing Eve Hawthorne/Farnsworth trying to become a homemaker, failing at cooking a stew, and then crying for some domestic help, only to be told by the faithful Curtis that there are no servants to be had because of the impact of the war. In My Best Gal, Johnny has eagerly enlisted and is hailed by one and all for his dedication to the war effort. In addition, the film concludes with a musical revue at a military base that stylistically foreshadows Mann’s later rendering of outdoor musicianship in The Glenn Miller Story (Universal, 1954). The plot of Sing Your Way Home finds a gaggle of child entertainers being sent back to the United States under the care of a reporter who has written an egocentric book about his war experiences. The Bamboo Blonde offers an overseas sequence that includes both studio scenes with the B-29 crew as they decide to paint their captain’s supposed girlfriend on the fuselage of their plane and actual combat footage to establish their danger and prowess. Mann would combine these elements most notably in The Glenn
2. Mann and the B Film
37
Miller Story in a memorable sequence in which the protagonist continues to lead his band at a London hospital despite the threat of incoming Nazi rockets. These five musicals offer other foreshadowings of Mann’s more mature style. Typically, he employs mirror shots with reflections to underline dramatic moments, so that the comic resolution of Moonlight in Havana begins with just such a set-up to emphasize that the romantic-farcical situation is about to be resolved. In My Best Gal, Kitty’s initial song (“I’ve Got a Wonderful Feeling”) is partly shot as she sits before a mirror, and the scene in which Pat comes back to Louise in The Bamboo Blonde finds her looking into a mirror as they realize for the first time that they truly love each other. Mann presents interesting shots of feet in My Best Gal as Kitty gets dressed in its opening sequence; in Nobody’s Darling as a way of tracking into the Pennington School for the first time; and in Sing Your Way Home when he shows part of a dance number in a shower and discreetly cuts to the girls’ shuffling feet. Perhaps the most single arresting shot (and one that points to verticality as a major thematic and stylistic feature in Mann’s more celebrated movies) occurs in Nobody’s Darling at the end of a romantic reconciliation scene between Janie and Chuck. They have returned from their publicized night out, been hassled by reporters and photographers, and then beset by irate parents who insist on removing them from the Pennington School, when they meet in a hallway. While their adolescently shy puppy love slowly emerges, Mann cleverly ends the scene by having them go off in opposite directions on a staircase, with Chuck rising and Janie descending. In addition to being an obvious visualization of the immediate plot point of their being separated, this shot offers the youngsters a convenient way to reluctantly say goodbye. Thus, even in such formulaic pieces, Mann was developing stylistic ways of getting thematic points across; and, perhaps more importantly, he was quickly coming to appreciate that movies had to be directed to and through the camera. At the same time, the director was employing rudimentary framing and flashback devices to offer a greater distance from the action that would provide his audience with a more privileged position in regard to the stories being presented to them. In Nobody’s Darling there is a dream sequence in which Janie imagines herself to be Chuck’s one and only with his dancing attendance and, finally, giving her his sharpshooter pin as a symbol of their going steady. Some of this material represents the heroine’s sublimated desires as well as her guilt over stealing the coveted pin (Mann does not stay with the dream conceit long enough to encourage such pop psychological musings).
38
Anthony Mann
His initial set-up in The Bamboo Blonde is more interesting in that the film begins with a reporter arriving at the world headquarters of Bamboo Blonde Enterprises to get a story on the company’s origins. The journalist sits down to interview the apparent head of this conglomerate, Eddie Clark, and is immediately beset by a non-stop sales pitch about various Bamboo Blonde products (from furniture to candies). The loquacious executive (Ralph Edwards at his worst) finally sits down too and we go into a flashback of Pat Jr. and Louise meeting at Eddie’s Club 50. This device is employed through the first half of the movie as Clark’s voiceovers bridge plot transitions; however, by film’s end, this arrangement has been forgotten and so there is never any return to the opening “present” to complete the framing. Clearly, a work like The Bamboo Blonde did not require the more serious framing devices that attach to more significant works like Orson Welles’s Citizen Kane (1941) or Fritz Lang’s Woman in the Window (1944).
Toward Film Noir: Strangers in the Night (1944), Two O’Clock Courage (1945), and Strange Impersonation (1946) Mann was more at ease with Strangers in the Night (1944) which took him away from the frequently contrived situations of B musicals and allowed him to work in the more sinister and melodramatic worlds of suspense and the woman’s film. Character types who would inhabit his later successes, whether for good or ill, can be seen in nascent form in this brief (56-minute) second feature. The screenplay for Strangers in the Night by Bryant Ford and Phil Gangelin anticipates the far more successful play and film versions of Norman Krasna’s Dear Ruth by essentially serving up the same plot situation with a diabolical, rather than a romantic or a comedic, twist. The sinister Hilda Blake (Helene Thimig) not only fantasizes that she has a daughter named Rosemary but goes so far as to write letters for the girl and to spend much of her time gazing adoringly at a portrait of this imaginary child. Naturally, she performs these actions within a proverbial “old dark house” in which mirrors abound and the reflection of candlelight provides appropriately eerie shadow patterns for Mann and his cinematographer, Reggie Lanning, to exploit. Rosemary’s letters to Marine Johnny Meadows (Don Terry) ultimately boomerang on Hilda when the wounded Guadalcanal veteran shows up on her doorstep looking for her daughter; moreover, this difficulty is then quickly exacerbated by Johnny’s meeting and being smitten by local physician Leslie Ross (Virginia Grey) and then learning that there is no Rosemary. This last complication pushes Hilda over the brink so that she murders her own best friend (and Johnny’s informant) Ivy Miller (Edith Barrett)
2. Mann and the B Film
39
before attacking the lovers and meeting her own demise. Unhappily, that event represents an obvious employment of the deus ex machina resolution brought on, as Jeanine Basinger sagely notes, because of the superabundance of plot contained within this modestly budgeted B programmer. In a variation of the ending of Oscar Wilde’s The Picture of Dorian Gray, the distraught Hilda is conveniently killed when she pleads for help to Rosemary’s portrait and it promptly falls and kills her! While Strangers in the Night embodies stylistic touches that foreshadow what Mann would accomplish in film noir (atmospheric lighting, mirror reflections), the largely static rendering through dialogue of much of the plot underscores the director’s less-than-assured grip on the material. Even if certain standard character types found in the later films are clearly present here, one still wishes for more visual and physical representations of the characters’ internal states. At best, Hilda Blake represents the first of many older parental figures who exercise decisive influences within Mann’s films; indeed, in her delusional approach to the world she inhabits, she foreshadows Dock Tobin (Lee J. Cobb) of Man of the West (United Artists, 1958) who is arguably the most dominating parental figure in all of Mann’s films. Johnny Meadows, despite having been wounded in combat, resembles such weak Mann male leads as Stephen Lindstrom (William Gargan) of Strange Impersonation (1946), the cynical though dominating Rip Darrow (Wendell Corey) of The Furies (Paramount, 1950), and, most notably, the ever-loyal Gaius Livius (Stephen Boyd) of The Fall of the Roman Empire (Paramount, 1964). Like these later figures, Meadows reacts to rather than acts upon the situation in which he finds himself. Of course, that arrangement arises in significant measure because Strangers in the Night and these other films are dominated by their female characters. In these works Mann must deal with many of the elements traditionally associated with “soap opera,” and one of the most obvious of those is the denatured male who exists only to please the more dominant female. Clearly, Mann was never as successful with this kind of arrangement as he was when his male leads were stronger and more self-willed, as seen most clearly in Cimarron (MGM, 1960) in which one is never certain whether the leading character is the male, Yancey Cravat (Glenn Ford), or the female, Sabra Cravat (Maria Schell). If Lindstrom emerges as simply cloying in the attention he pays to Nora Goodrich (Brenda Marshall) in Strange Impersonation, and Darrow as a plot contrivance against which the protagonist Vance Jeffords (Barbara Stanwyck) can react in The Furies, Gaius Livius seems more dramatically justified because of the historical subject matter of The Fall of the Roman Empire. Indeed, a weak male protagonist in a work dedicated to
40
Anthony Mann
exploring the nature of historical change allows the spectator to more acutely feel just how “the times they are a-changing.” No such rationalization can, of course, be adduced for Johnny Meadows in Strangers in the Night, for his character is simply a plot device to which Mann unhappily devotes far too much time in this tiny film. The director was still obviously struggling to find himself and his own style in this feature, and it would be some time yet before Mann came to fully appreciate what “the language of cinema” could do to transform the inherent talkiness of a script such as that of Strangers in the Night. Two O’Clock Courage (1945) finds Mann combining a whodunit with a screwball comedy in a remake of an earlier RKO release, Two in the Dark (1936). Both films are based on a novel by Gelett Burgess which initially appeared in 1934 and is even more prolix than the plot of Mann’s film. The novel, also entitled Two O’Clock Courage, is replete with literary allusions delivered by a reporter named Hillier (who hardly matches Richard Lane’s comic stereotype as Haley) as well as a first-person point of view and more complicated romantic machinations. Burgess’s novel also uses frequent newspaper accounts to bridge plot transitions, and a partner to the amnesiac hero, Josephine Ghelt, who represents a genuine down-on-her-luck Depression character with whom the protagonist is never romantically involved. Mann’s film uses Burgess’s primary mystery ploy about murder resulting from the theft and plagiarism of a play (entitled “Two O’Clock Courage”) but the script changes all the characters’ names, does away with many of the supporting figures, and reshapes the others into seeming wisecracking cynics. Thus, we find Police Lieutenant Brenner (Emory Parnell) and the newspaper reporter, Haley, constantly trading barbs and putdowns while, at the same time, being unable to see details that are right in front of their faces. When the protagonist Ted Allison (Tom Conway) points out an alternate escape route at the scene of the crime, Brenner lamely opines that he “never thought of that.” Haley has an extended gag with his managing editor in which he keeps changing the identity of the killer and forcing the latter to remake the front page; at one point the reporter is even suspicious of “Harry,” which is a pet name that Patty (Ann Rutherford) has given to her cab. As if these two characters weren’t enough comic relief, we also find a butler who is so ditzy that he is temporarily charged with the murder of his employer; Jack Norton as yet another falling-down-drunk who recognizes the amnesiac Allison in a nightclub; and a nosy spinster landlady who keeps trying to eavesdrop on Allison and Parry when they are in the girl’s apartment. Even the second female lead Helen (Jane Greer) has to come in drunk in order to reveal that Mark Evans (Lester Matthews) is implicated in the murder of the theatrical producer Dilling. Such buffoonery, when coupled
2. Mann and the B Film
41
with Patty’s virtual non-stop smart aleck dialogue and Allison’s frequently bemused responses, prevents Two O’Clock Courage from becoming a film noir despite its use of archetypal genre settings (nightclubs and darkened streets) and situations (amnesia and the seemingly powerless individual who must prove his innocence). Patty is a most familiar, if not clichéd, type: the girl who automatically decides she must take care of the victimized hero in spite of knowing virtually nothing about him. Her instincts simply tell her on their first meeting that Allison, in spite of his being dazed and injured, and in spite of his fitting the physical description of the suspect the police are seeking, and in spite of her having picked him up near the scene of the crime, cannot be guilty. So she quickly becomes his partner, and, as the story unfolds, predictably falls in love with him. Such cheerfulness, naïveté, and trust are decidedly at odds with the values of hardboiled femme fatales such as Phyllis Dietrichson (Barbara Stanwyck) in Double Indemnity (1944) and Kathie Moffett (Jane Greer) in Out of the Past (1947). Two O’Clock Courage opens with an evocative musical main theme by Roy Webb that segues into its opening scene on a foggy, dark street. Ted Allison enters and stumbles against a lamp post, and we see he is groggy and bleeding. He then lurches across the street and is almost hit by Patty’s cab to some appropriately eerie music; however, with her arrival the film’s mood abruptly changes into screwball comedy accompanied by mild danger. While the protagonist is driven to exonerate himself, and rediscover who he is, even this quest becomes comic as he pretends to understand the remarks of people he meets who know his real identity. His comic bumblings finally yield his identity when he returns to Mark Evans’s hotel room and discovers that Helen has been there, a development that leads the plagiarist playwright to angrily blurt out Allison’s name. Such serendipitous plotting also distinguishes the end of Two O‘Clock Courage. When Allison goes alone to the murdered producer’s house and is shot after discovering an incriminating copy of the original play with its author’s name on it, a dream-flashback sequence explains his initial involvement at the crime scene. Unfortunately, while this reversal of his amnesia is clear to Allison, he cannot convince the bumbling Lieutenant Brenner of his innocence until the conscience-stricken Helen stumbles into the room to deliver her drunken confession about Evans. Even then, the apparent suicide of Evans turns out to be another murder—this time by celebrated stage actress Barbara Borden (Jean Brooks), who is the murderer of Dilling as well. All of these plot details are revealed in rapid succession so that the mystery in Two O’Clock Courage emerges as decidedly secondary to its romantic comedy elements.
42
Anthony Mann
Mann is clearly undone here by a script that offers too much talk and too little action. The characters are not morally or psychologically ambivalent enough to engage him and there are simply no opportunities for the kinds of stylized violence that would mark his more mature films. The pace of Two O’clock Courage again covers over some of its plot problems, such as a picture of Jason Robards in Mark Evans’s room that Allison seemingly recognizes but which never leads anywhere. One senses that at some point, Mann simply gave up on the script and simply let things happen. In keeping with his penchant for rapid resolutions, the film ends with a breezy fadeout as Allison and Patty, now wed, return to her apartment and her harridan landlady—this time to foil the latter with a marriage license after the groom has carried his bride across the threshold. Such a reprisal and reversal of their earlier “fake wedding” scene with the landlady is, at best, a small pleasure in a clichéd film. Mann moves into more interesting material with Strange Impersonation, a work that uneasily moves between film noir and woman’s picture with the latter tendency ultimately winning out. The central plot focus is the proverbial “man trouble” found in countless Bette Davis, Joan Crawford, and Barbara Stanwyck vehicles; however, Strange Impersonation also uses an extended dream sequence in which the nightmare world of film noir presses increasingly on the protagonist. In a fashion similar to Fritz Lang’s Woman in the Window (RKO, 1944) Mann’s plot resolves itself when the character wakes up to discover that she has simply had a bad dream. In keeping with the romantic inclination of the film, this realization leads to a final clinch between Nora Goodrich (Brenda Marshall) and Stephen Lindstrom (William Gargan) in which all the previous malevolent moments and events are simply rendered void by the bliss of the to-be-married couple. Dr. Lindstrom personifies the passive male so often found in women’s pictures, whether he is being patient and indulgent with Nora’s quest for scientific fame or simply reacting after her supposed death in the dream sequence by marrying the manipulative Arlene Cole (Hillary Brooke) on the rebound. Once Nora’s face has been injured, Stephen can protest that he still wants to marry her, but he is then easily duped by Arlene’s machinations. He goes from whining about the fact that Nora no longer wants to see him, to passively accepting the heroine’s dismissal of him, to then marrying her romantic rival without ever taking any action on his own. Arlene’s scheme, by which she separates Nora and Stephen through first convincing the hospital staff that his visits are upsetting to Nora and then Lindstrom that the protagonist has issued the order that he no longer see her, underscores the weak nature of the male lead. In that same vein, Stephen acts romantically in ways that seem more
2. Mann and the B Film
43
From left: Dr. Nora Goodrich (Brenda Marshall), Nurse (Mary Treen), and Arline Cole (Hillary Brooke) in Strange Impersonation (Republic, 1946). In Nora’s dream sequence she awakens to discover that her face has been seriously marred in a fire. The scheming Arline feigns concern but soon turns against Mann’s protagonist.
characteristically female because he is the ever-solicitous male who consistently accedes to whatever Nora dictates. Their first romantic tryst in her lab is initiated when Lindstrom convinces Arlene, the protagonist’s assistant, that he needs something from the library and she obliges by going out for a cigarette. After some modest kisses, Nora then sends Stephen away as he resignedly asks. “Why did I fall in love with a chemist?” Later, at Nora’s apartment, Stephen’s romantic urges are checkmated once more by Nora’s turning his every remark into an excuse to show off her scientific knowledge until Lindstrom finally asks her to stop. His reason for showing up leads to the major romantic crisis in Strange Impersonation as Stephen once again presses Nora to marry him because he is leaving for France the very next day! She, of course, refuses because she needs to test her anesthetic and, in a bit of obvious symbolic byplay, she takes off her engagement ring only to have him put it back on her finger. The love triangle in Strange Impersonation is essentially Arlene’s cre-
44
Anthony Mann
ation, and her motivation appears to be malevolence for the sake of malevolence, as one never gets any sense that she is in love with Lindstrom. If he is, at best, a meal ticket to security and wealth, Arlene seems driven by a need to punish Nora because of her holding Stephen at arm’s length for the good of science and her own career. Indeed, we are left to conclude that Strange Impersonation is psychologically structured as an object lesson to the heroine about the need for giving in to the wishes of a “good man” before she loses him to a “bad girl.” Once Nora reappears as Jane Karaski in the dream section and wins the admiration of Stephen because of her prowess in the laboratory, a second triangle emerges with Nora as the instigator. Her easy victory—Lindstrom tells her he is divorcing Arlene because he has fallen for her and hopes to start a “new life” together in France—brings the central section of Strange Impersonation to its nightmarish conclusion. This sequence plunges the film into the surreal nature of Nora’s dream world as she is arrested for seemingly having murdered herself. Because she
Dr. Nora Goodrich (Brenda Marshall) in Strange Impersonation (Republic 1946). Her lab coat and glasses establish her initial frigidity and cold treatment of Dr. Stephen Lindstrom (William Gargan) in the earlier scenes of the film.
2. Mann and the B Film
45
has taken over the identity of Jane Karaski (Ruth Ford), a slattern who came to rob her and whom she struggled with and killed in self-defense, and someone whose identity Nora was able to assume because her attacker’s corpse was mistakenly identified as her own, the police now believe that Nora is a killer. This heavily ironic situation is, of course, thoroughly in keeping with the fatalistic atmosphere of such celebrated noir films as Detour (PRC,1945) and The Dark Corner (Twentieth Century–Fox,1946). Mann presents Nora’s climactic agony in a rapid series of shots in which a police lieutenant (Lyle Talbot) and a conniving insurance salesman (George Chandler) accuse the protagonist despite her protests that “I’m Nora!” This frenzied montage intercuts their accusations (“You killed her!”) with probing lights and dissonant musical cues to lead to Nora’s fainting and subsequent return from the world of her nightmare. Nora’s dream world is replete with standard film noir elements. In addition to characters like Arlene and the real Jane Karaski, both of whom are strictly out for themselves, we find Mann briefly using a voiceover when Nora decides to become Jane Karaski after her assailant has fallen from the apartment balcony and had her face destroyed. Before Strange Impersonation descends into its dream sequence, we meet Jane Karaski (because she is inadvertently knocked down by Nora’s car) and the insurance hustler J.W. Rinse (who comes immediately upon the scene, urging the drunken Jane to sue for damages). When Nora takes Jane to the latter’s rooming house, and Rinse inevitably follows, we plummet into a setting of flashing neon, urban sleeze, and rapacious characters so common to film noir. Despite such stylistic touches, Strange Impersonation has Nora’s love life as its central concern; indeed, the strongest elements in her dream revolve around her suppressed wishes about wanting to start a “new life” and her reliance on physical beauty to provide her with an identity. Nora must learn to become a woman who relies on marriage, rather than career, for happiness, so that the dream ultimately strips her of any desire to be a scientist. The fire that results when Arlene adds more chemicals to the anesthetic mixture at the beginning of the nightmare leads to Nora’s being hospitalized with a burned face. She then rejects Stephen in large measure because she cannot believe he will accept her scarred countenance; and, after Arlene maneuvers her into believing that Lindstrom is seeing someone else, Nora utters a highly revealing line: “He didn’t give up [France] for me!.” Thus, despite her rejection of Stephen, we see that Nora is dismayed that he is not still pining for her. Her subsequent homecoming with Arlene presents the altered Nora without any protective bandages, and we see her scars appropriately lit from below and accompanied by a musical stinger. After a brief exchange with Arlene about how she’s planning to have plastic surgery, the latter leaves and
46
Anthony Mann
Nora wanders around her apartment. The doorbell rings and the protagonist finds Jane Karaski in the hallway. After being admitted, and noting that Nora lives in a “swell joint,” Jane urges that she should have been more generously awarded after the accident, pulls a gun and begins to take things of value. As she and Nora move toward the door, they fight and Jane is pushed over the balcony. After looking down, Nora rushes out to the street and learns that Karaski’s corpse has been identified as her own because of the jewels on it and, more traumatically and symbolically, because Stephen, who just happened to be coming for a visit, has recognized the engagement ring on the dead woman’s finger! After a newspaper headline announces Nora’s death, Mann cuts to a Los Angeles plastic surgeon’s office and a montage in which Nora’s face is “fixed”; however, as she is recovering, she comes upon yet another newspaper story about the wedding of Stephen and Arlene and becomes distraught enough to want to get out of bed. Told that she must remain in the hospital for at least three more months, Nora decides that she will use her new physical and personal identity to gain revenge on Arlene. By doing so, the protagonist reasserts the “new life” theme of Strange Impersonation paradoxically at the center of her earlier rejection of Lindstrom in the real world of the film. Nora has, in essence, become a mirror image of Arlene in wanting to work her will upon the world, and her new sense of urgent purpose causes her kindly surgeon (H.B. Warner) to warn her that she cannot really change herself. His advice comes after her bandages have been removed and we see her restored face, which is decidedly better made-up than before her accident. Despite this warning, which echoes one of the standard themes of science fiction in which the overreacher is invariably destroyed, Nora-Jane moves ahead with her scheme. At this point, however, the austere budget of Strange Impersonation comes to the forefront, for the audience is asked to believe that a cosmetic makeover and a change in hair color are sufficient to fool the other characters about Nora’s identity. When she returns to the Wilmott Institute and applies for a job with Stephen, he does not recognize her even though he is sufficiently drawn to her so that he invites her to his home for dinner with Arlene. Under the latter’s suspicious gaze, Nora-Jane explains that she was a lifetime friend of the deceased Dr. Goodrich and that when they were together, “we were always taken for sisters.” In her laboratory job, NoraJane is such a great success that Stephen declares she is “amazing” and that he feels as if he is “working with Nora again.” The protagonist’s revenge comes full circle when Lindstrom tells her about his impending divorce and promises they will have a life together—events that trigger the montage climax of Nora’s dream.
2. Mann and the B Film
47
Strange Impersonation returns from Nora’s nightmare by means of a dissolve to the heroine lying on her couch just as she was before the initial descent into her dream world. She awakens to find that Stephen has been watching over her and that he has sent Arlene home long ago, actions that were prompted because Lindstrom had to return for his forgotten briefcase. Quickly dismissing the scientific experiment that has occasioned her somnolence, the shaken Nora rushes to a mirror to be sure that she is still herself, cries for joy when she sees her familiar reflection, and then turns to her fiancé to urge they marry at once so they can go to France as husband and wife. Naturally, Stephen is overjoyed and responds to Nora’s symbolic question—“How do you like the way I look?”—by kissing her. That the heroine has at last discovered who she is and become giddy over the prospect of being Lindstrom’s bride is characteristically rendered by this sequence’s being photographed in a mirror, an object that Mann has repeatedly used to demarcate major changes in his characters and plots throughout these apprentice films. In his first five years as a film director, Anthony Mann learned to improvise in order to improve on the meager scripts and budgets with which he had to work. While he always did the best he could with formulaic musicals, mysteries, and women’s pictures, Mann came to see that his real strengths could best be utilized in stories centered on more physically and psychologically violent characters and situations. He would always be able to handle, and sometimes even improve, obligatory assignments (The Glenn Miller Story, Strategic Air Command [Paramount, 1955], Serenade [Warner Brothers, 1956]) in the future, but rising above such formulaic work would require finding other ways to express his thematic and stylistic strengths. The emergence of the film noir style in Hollywood and the motivational dualities of the leading female characters in Strange Impersonation would offer the means by which Mann would rise to become an A director in the next few years. Clearly, his time as an apprentice filmmaker had prepared him for better things.
3
Mann and Film Noir Film noir is often regarded as a style and a mood rather than a genre unto itself. While such films do not have the typological clarity that one associates with westerns or science fiction, there is much critical consensus on the historical limits of film noir. Most accounts see Billy Wilder’s Double Indemnity (1944) as the beginning of a cycle which was essentially played out by the time that Orson Welles’s Touch of Evil (1958) appeared. While there have been later films which embody much of the style and spirit of film noir, such as Chinatown (1974) and Body Heat (1981), these efforts often lack the dramatic power of earlier works. The world-weary sense of survival of the protagonists in these later films, their often consciously constructed natures as homage to the works of the earlier period, and their employment of color photography are traits that significantly separate these post–1958 efforts from film noir in its heyday. Postwar doubts and anxieties brought on by the advent of the atomic age with the bombings of Hiroshima and Nagasaki undoubtedly contributed to the emergence of film noir, as did a dissatisfaction with studio Hollywood’s consistent penchant for the “happy ending.” Earlier films had, of course, ended “unhappily” but always with the underlying message that order and right were being restored. Throughout the 1930s, gangster films consistently adhered to this pattern so that the deaths of Enrico Bandello (Edward G. Robinson in Little Caesar [1930]), Tony Camonte (Paul Muni in Scarface [1932], and Duke Mantee (Humphrey Bogart in The Petrified Forest [1936]) were overtly presented as necessary defeats of criminal hubris. Even in John Huston’s classic version of The Maltese Falcon (1941), a film which exhibits some of the stylistic and plot characteristics of film noir, the removal of the villain (in this case Mary Astor’s duplicitous Bridget) by the man who is in love with her (Humphrey Bogart as Sam Spade) leads to a sense of the restoration of order. While the detective protagonist can tell the murderess that he will experience “some bad nights” without her, Spade is never as madly in love as such film noir characters as Johnny Farrell (Glenn Ford in Gilda [1946]) with the title character or Jeff 48
3. Mann and Film Noir
49
Bailey (Robert Mitchum in Out of the Past [1947]) with the murderous female lead. Noir films frequently combine naturalistic exteriors with very stageylooking interiors to emphasize the claustrophobic and trapped lives their major characters lead. Thus, Jeff Bailey’s romantic scenes with the “good” girl Ann (Virginia Huston) occur against natural backdrops in daylight, while his fevered affair with “bad” girl Kathie Moffett (Jane Greer) happens on a darkened beach or within confined spaces in Out of the Past. Typically, when he and Kathie seem most happily in love they are staying in a cabin in the woods; and, naturally, their bliss comes up short when Jeff’s former partner Fisher (Steve Brodie) shows up to blackmail them. The ensuing struggle between the two men occurs within the unlit cabin and ends when Kathie shoots Fisher after Jeff has overpowered him. Murder in film noir often results from a combination of middle-class greed and the manipulation of lovesick males by less sentimental and more ruthless females. Typically, in Double Indemnity Phyllis Dietrichson (Barbara Stanwyck) gets Walter Neff (Fred MacMurray) to kill her husband (Tom Powers) for an insurance payout, only to be tripped up when her greed causes insurance investigator Barton Keyes (Edward G. Robinson) to smell a rat. If Kathie Moffett and Phyllis Dietrichson are too greedy for their own good, the men they manipulate emerge as helpless pawns of fate; indeed, Jeff Bailey and Walter Neff are victims of the “twists of fate of an irrational universe.”1 The cast of characters peculiar to film noir begins with such non-heroic protagonists, men who can occasionally perform bold physical deeds but who are finally the playthings of much stronger and physically irresistible women. In addition, lesser villains are often psychopaths like Vince Stone (Lee Marvin in The Big Heat [1953]) or Monty Montgomery (Robert Ryan in Crossfire [1947]), and corruption is rampant in both society and police departments. Ultimately, the characters in noir emerge as flat in that they gradually reveal their personalities and motivations but hardly ever show any signs of changing for the better as a result of the traumatic experiences they undergo. Most of these films are played out against urban cityscapes which are distinguished by nightclubs full of lonely egotists, hotel rooms invariably lit by blinking neon lights, rain-soaked streets which are often empty late at night, and police stations with numerous probing interrogation lamps. Such backgrounds are frequently coupled with voiceover narrations and lengthy flashback sequences to establish the characters’ attitudes about the loss of order and the growth of cynicism, sexual tensions and jealousies, moral indifference and complacency, and destructive and often gratuitous brutality. Within and against such themes and attitudes, the protagonists of film noir
50
Anthony Mann
are often on the run either because their pasts have caught up with them or because they must try to clear themselves of criminal charges that have arisen because of the workings of fate. Mann was a major contributor to film noir in its heyday; indeed, from 1947 to 1949 he not only worked exclusively in this genre but he also may have been its single most important director. His own visual style certainly emerged during this period as did his skill at dealing with compromised and violent characters. His eight contemporary noir films can be grouped around four plot features that distinguish the genre: (1) blind love which leads to disaster or heartbreak or both; (2) criminal involvement which can only be undone through the protagonist’s taking great risks and suffering severe emotional and physical pain; (3) eccentric villains whose charm or expertise almost compensate for their criminal acts; and (4) police heroes who infiltrate the underworld by taking on its characteristics and defeat it only after profound injuries. In addition, Mann created a most intriguing variation with The Black Book (1949), which is set in the Revolutionary Paris of 1794 but is inhabited by standard film noir character types, and helped to create the screenplay for Richard Fleischer’s more modest Follow Me Quietly (1949).
Prisoners of Love: The Great Flamarion (1945) and Raw Deal (1948) The Great Flamarion can easily be seen as deriving from The Blue Angel (1930) in its emphasis on an older man trapped by his own obsession for a younger woman. While embodying neither the technical skill nor the tragic dimensions of the Josef von Sternberg classic, Mann’s film illustrates his increasingly visual style of storytelling. In the backstage world of The Great Flamarion we are given brief glimpses of various showbiz eccentrics; however, their idiosyncrasies and comic banter are never allowed to dominate the sober events of the film’s plot. There is an almost Shakespearean quality about these minor characters, for they function as a veritable chorus commenting on the actions of the principals in the foreground. The clownish tumbler (Lester Allen) and the philosophical stagehand (Michael Mark) in Mexico City set forth an ironic perspective with their dialogue about everybody’s “being on stage”; while the buffoonish vaudeville couple, who recite their theatrical résumé (“snappy songs”) when being interrogated by the police, symbolize the tawdry world of The Great Flamarion. Other random comments about “poor Eddie” (Stephen Barclay) and how his dead wife Connie (Mary Beth Hughes) was sexual “dynamite” are rendered in sympathetic tones to provide the sense of an uncaring world that
3. Mann and Film Noir
51
Dan Duryea (as Al Wallace) and Erich von Stroheim (as the title character) in The Great Flamarion (Republic, 1945). Mann frames the two besotted males in a mirror to suggest that they are equally under the spell of the scheming Connie Wallace (Mary Beth Hughes) in the director’s first film noir.
is impervious to the romantic agony of the title character (Erich von Stroheim). Mirrors are more prominent than in Mann’s past work. The act in which Flamarion displays his skill with pistols is conspicuously played out in front of a large mirror so that we see the synchronized movements that Al Wallace (Dan Duryea) must make to avoid being shot. After their first performance, we find Al and Connie in their dressing room arguing over her flirting with Flamarion. After Al tells his wayward wife that she can’t leave him because he knows too much about her criminal past, the glowering femme fatale is reflected in a mirror. Once Connie has infatuated him, Flamarion tries to persuade Al to leave the act, and their meeting once again plays out against a mirror in the protagonist’s dressing room; indeed, Mann’s composition offers double images of both men to show how each of them has become a victim of the amoral Connie. For one telling moment the two characters are photographed as though joined at the neck to make this symbolic connection even more obvi-
52
Anthony Mann
ous. After Al’s death and the long separation instituted by Connie, we see the lovestruck Flamarion primping in a mirror in the hotel in Chicago where he expects to be reunited with his beloved. Mann enhances the protagonist’s rapture even further through a montage showing Flamarion briefly dancing for joy, picking out a wedding ring, and arranging flowers—all to a muted rendition of Mendelssohn’s “Wedding March” on the soundtrack. Flamarion’s loss of control throughout the film is underscored further by Mann’s manipulation of guns as symbols. The protagonist’s prowess and power derive, of course, from his skills as a marksman so that it is not unusual to see him practicing with an air pistol when Connie comes to see him about his threat to dismiss both her and Al after the latter has been slightly off in his timing during a performance. When she flirts with him and explains that Al is suffering from jealousy (“I think he knows how I feel about you”), Flamarion is skeptical, but the ominous ticking of a clock and his subsequent inability to continue with his target practice clearly signal that he is about to descend into being the proverbial besotted male of film noir. Before Connie proposes that Flamarion accidentally “shoot” Al, she fondles one of the protagonist’s pistols in an obvious bit of sexual symbolism. When Flamarion realizes that Connie has ditched him in Chicago and sets out to find her, we see his moral and financial decline reflected in his pawning all of his pistols, save one. Appropriately enough, when he confronts Connie in Mexico City, their struggle culminates with her using the weapon to mortally wound Flamarion prior to his strangling her to death. Mann utilizes a framing pattern in The Great Flamarion: The plot starts with its climax and then doubles back as the dying protagonist insists that he must tell his story to the vaudevillian who has found him prone on the stage. Flamarion’s flashback constitutes the bulk of the film and is, naturally, accompanied by his voiceover reflections throughout. The flashback ultimately returns to the film’s opening scene to bring the plot to its logical end with the death of Flamarion, who has functioned as his own witness to the “truth” that will obviously never be uncovered otherwise. Mann also employs effective tracking shots to bring the audience into this opening scene as well as to emphasize Flamarion’s despair when he realizes that Connie has stood him up in the Chicago hotel. The first of these shots takes viewers inside the cheap theater in Mexico City with its milling crowd and threadbare acts to suggest that illusions will be central to what follows: Connie appears to be something to Flamarion that she is not, just as the performers in the theater play at being what they are not. The tracking shot in the hotel emphasizes the course of Flamarion’s search for Connie in that he appears all but lost when measured against the scale of the lobby, just as he is similarly confused about both Connie’s motives and whereabouts.
3. Mann and Film Noir
53
The protagonist’s subsequent search for the girl is appropriately rendered by a montage of rushing trains, seedy streets, and his selling of his pistols to a pawnbroker. In the midst of this sequence, Flamarion encounters Cleo (Esther Howard), an old colleague, and she informs him about Connie’s attachment to Eddie, who was featured as a bicycle rider in Pittsburgh where the sharpshooter’s flashback began. Using this clue, Flamarion is able to track down the unfaithful Connie and, after killing her, to flee into the rafters of the theater. We see him ascend to that hiding place from a bird’s eye camera angle; and subsequent shots show him hanging on, with an open trapdoor further accentuating the precarious height to which the wounded man has ascended. Flamarion’s subsequent fall to the stage can be seen as his coming down to the “real world” in which he must repent and atone for his crime. The Great Flamarion’s love triangle foreshadows a similar relationship in the more celebrated Out of the Past because the two male leads are obsessed by the same cynical and conniving female. Unlike Jacques Tourneur’s Kathie, however, Connie ultimately wants nothing to do with either Al or Flamarion; indeed, she appears to be a veritable nymphomaniac in that we see Eddie arguing with her about her flirting with a new man just prior to her being killed by Flamarion. Earlier, his awareness of his wife’s sexual appetites drives Al to drink because he cannot live without Connie and yet he knows that she will never change. He can threaten to reveal her sordid past, but he is basically too weak and too easily impressed by any sign of affection from her to ever do so. Mann illustrates their alienated relationship in a hotel lobby as Connie hides in a phone booth in the right front of the frame while Al buys some cigarettes at the left rear of the composition. Of course, by this time the besotted Flamarion has agreed to the shooting of Al on stage, and all that seemingly remains is to get Wallace sufficiently drunk so that a coroner’s verdict of accidental death will inevitably result. Flamarion resembles Connie (and many another film noir character) in that he also has a traumatic past that has shaped his present life. Like Howie Kemp (James Stewart) in The Naked Spur (1953), Mann’s marksman has been wronged by a woman who cost him his identity. Somehow Connie knows about this situation for she brings it up in Flamarion’s train compartment in her most seductive scene with him. From her (“I know about Alma”) we learn that the protagonist has been double-crossed by a woman and dismissed from the army as a result. Thus, for fifteen years Flamarion has been solely dedicated to his sharpshooting act—an allegiance that earlier has caused him to berate Al because “you were one beat off.” If the finale of this act, in which Flamarion cuts a shoulder strap on Connie’s dress with a wellplaced bullet, again dramatizes the protagonist’s latent sexual feelings in an
54
Anthony Mann
obvious fashion, the initial set-up of the whole situation, in which a seemingly enraged husband (Flamarion) returns to find his wife (Connie) entertaining another man (Al), cleverly mimics the love triangle at the center of The Great Flamarion. Connie’s subsequent kissing of the protagonist on the train (done to “wake him up”) leads inevitably to his wondering whether his newfound romantic feelings represent a “new life” or the “beginning of the end.” We next see Flamarion and Connie in a restaurant as he fusses over her and she starts hinting about getting rid of Al in a scene that clearly echoes Double Indemnity. Connie later tells Flamarion about her dream in which Al suffers an “accident”; however, this revelation only occurs after she examines a dress that the protagonist has bought for her and caresses his pistol while smiling seductively at him. Their next meeting occurs after the inquest into Al’s death on stage and finds Flamarion chastising Connie for being late (“Aren’t you ever on time?”); however, despite such romantic eagerness, he then accepts her three-month separation scheme which she explains as a “trip” to see her mother. After Connie insists there can be no communications between them during this time, the infatuated protagonist gladly gives her $10,000 in cash and sets up their future rendezvous in Chicago. Their final meeting introduces another stylistic device that Mann will exploit throughout his noir period, for a swinging lamp is used to impressionistically light Flamarion’s strangling of Connie. Raw Deal is clearly superior both thematically and stylistically because it eschews the melodramatic character drawing of The Great Flamarion and incorporates better production values than the earlier film. In the interim, Mann had found his two most important collaborators in film noir—writer John C. Higgins and cinematographer John Alton—and both of them contribute notably to Raw Deal. In its plot Raw Deal attains a sense of tragedy as each of its three leading characters, Ann Martin (Marsha Hunt), Joe Sullivan (Dennis O’Keefe), and Pat Cameron (Claire Trevor), ends up victimized and so exposed to his or her own raw deal. Mann’s greater artistry is apparent from the opening credit sequence which uses a bleak prison wall as its backdrop to symbolize how the characters are caught or trapped by their own wishes and desires. The inevitable atmosphere of film noir is reinforced by an eerie main title musical theme meant to create unease and to, again, foreshadow the bleak world in which the protagonists move. Alton’s brilliant camerawork commences with a deeply shadowed waiting area in which Pat must sit until Joe’s “other visitor” is finished, and with the distorted optical treatment of the simultaneously ongoing interview between Ann and Joe inside. This second composition sets
3. Mann and Film Noir
55
these two characters conspicuously apart from their surroundings and, thus, makes plausible the emerging love between them, which belongs only to them and which will ruin any prospect for happiness for the nervously waiting Pat. Alton’s style with the criminal world of Raw Deal comes to the forefront later in a fight sequence inside a taxidermist’s shop. Joe goes there ostensibly to get his share of the loot from the robbery for which he “took the fall” to protect crime boss Rick Coyle (Raymond Burr). The latter, however, has lured Sullivan to this meeting so that his Marsha Hunt (as Ann Martin) in Raw Deal minion Fantail (John Ireland) (Reliance/Eagle-Lion, 1948). By this point her can kill the escaped convict. character has changed from a law-abiding Rick’s underling initially gets idealist to an infatuated woman willing to kill the drop on Joe in a shot that to help prison escapee Joe Sullivan (Dennis shows both of them in deep O’Keefe). When Ann subsequently breaks focus, a stylistic trait which will down on a bench, Joe discovers that he’s in characterize Mann’s films all love with her. the way through A Dandy in Aspic (1968). Joe manages to turn the tables on Fantail and the shop owner (Tom Fadden) in a fistfight that basically takes place in the dark with only small pools of light to demarcate the struggling figures. At one point the hero impales the gunman on a moose antler after himself being assaulted with a broken bottle. A more conventional arrangement characterizes the visual presentations of the sadistic Rick, who is frequently photographed from low angles to emphasize his being threatening and powerful. Given that the character is essentially something of a coward, such set-ups offer a kind of ironic undercutting of Mann’s principal villain. At the same time, when Rick is killed in a final struggle with Joe inside the darkened office of his nightclub, he is pushed into a veritable tunnel of fire and falls downward in an obvious visual
56
Anthony Mann
reversal of his earlier stature. His fiery death, which suggests that Joe has, finally, freed himself from his own evil past is, alas, once again fraught with irony, for by this time Sullivan has been mortally wounded himself and only has enough energy left to rescue Ann and then die in her arms. Alton’s most arresting work takes place on board the freighter to which Pat and Joe have fled prior to Raw Deal’s savage finale and after they have quarreled over whether Sullivan should seek revenge on Rick for the earlier ambush at the taxidermist’s. In their heated exchange in a seedy hotel room, Pat had tried to dissuade Joe from going against the criminal boss by arguing, “If Ann asked, you wouldn’t do this” and promptly gotten slapped by her (supposed) lover. Pat has learned that Ann has been taken as a hostage by Rick, but she does not tell Joe about this development at this point. Instead, realizing the depth of Joe’s feelings for her romantic rival by virtue of being hit, Pat temporarily runs out of the room only to return because she is tied to Joe no matter what he does or how badly he treats her. Once aboard the steamer, which will take them to South America and safety, Joe ironically starts talking about marriage, something Pat has wanted to hear for years; however, she cannot stop thinking about what she hasn’t told her beloved about Ann’s plight, and the guilt she is feeling is beautifully caught by the composition of this scene. Alton shoots Pat in a darkly lit medium closeup which takes up approximately half of the frame with the other half being given over to a well-lit clock on the cabin wall which ticks ominously and more emphatically as Joe continues talking about their future. The rising tension finally erupts when Pat breaks down and shouts “Ann” to the hero, who then quickly learns of the danger in which the woman he now loves finds herself, and goes to her rescue. Unhappily, Pat cannot stop Joe when saving Ann becomes his object; and his death then takes on the unsettling nature of a good man being destroyed, a theme more appropriate to classical tragedy than to the standard melodramatics of Hollywood. More typical film noir stylistic devices include Pat’s voiceover narration which supplies a sense of omniscience and fate to everything we see. Thus, flashing neon illuminates the motel to which the three principals flee in Crescent City. Raw Deal also uses a lack of communication to achieve further irony in a manner that foreshadows the resolution of the initial killing which prompts all the action in Orson Welles’s Touch of Evil. Just as the audience in that more celebrated film learns of the identity of the killer in a veritable throwaway line, John C. Higgins’s script for Mann’s film supplies the information that Rick and his henchmen know that Joe has been officially cleared of any involvement in the earlier robbery. However, this exoneration does nothing for the inevitably doomed protagonist, who never hears of it. Raw Deal presents much more frequent and more graphic violence than
3. Mann and Film Noir
57
one encounters in The Great Flamarion. This tendency would, of course, become more marked and more remarked upon as Mann’s career unfolded; nevertheless, its presentation is nearly as sophisticated here as it would be in later films. While such behavior is expected from the villains, Joe pushes Ann down viciously after discovering that she has called the police after he has ordered her not to do so. Because of her action, Joe, Pat, and Ann must flee together because the girl’s apartment has become too dangerous for the escaped convict to use as a hideout; and this plot development is illuminated by Joe’s rationalization of his romantic feelings by insisting that having Ann along will enable them to more readily get through any police roadblocks. Later, when Pat becomes more aware of the effect Ann has on Joe, she slaps her rival; and, of course, Joe slaps Pat when she implies that he is in love with Ann. This last act dramatizes the shift in the romantic triangle in Raw Deal in starkly physical and photographic terms. When Pat reveals that Ann has been abducted by Rick and will probably be killed, she does so while standing in the doorway of the freighter cabin which she and Rick occupy. Her resigned posture clearly indicates that she will not stop Joe from going to rescue the other woman, while the doorway symbolizes Joe’s escape from the life that Pat wanted to have with him. In essence the male protagonist is about to make his second escape in Raw Deal. This plot reversal is foreshadowed in an earlier sequence in which Joe, Pat, and Ann hide out in the countryside with a mechanic who will supply them with a car. Joe and Ann start a romantic encounter in a garden only to be interrupted by police sirens in a jarring reversal of mood which suggests that the law has caught up with the fugitive protagonist. However, Mann then reverses audience expectations once again as we discover that the police are actually in pursuit of another prison escapee (Whit Bissell) who begs to be admitted into the cottage to which Joe and Ann have retreated. The imploring fugitive tells of how he loved a woman and then killed her before he dashes back off the porch to perish in a volley of police bullets. In a darkened closet Joe and Ann are huddled together as she symbolically notes, “That could be you.” Pat’s essential absence from this sequence as well as the fact that Joe does not seek her out is, once more, evidence of the director’s increasing skill and sophistication. Rick Coyle resembles the stock, often under-motivated, if not unmotivated, villain of countless films; however, Raw Deal makes his melodramatic character much more interesting by consistently associating him with the primary element of fire. In his first scene the ever-malevolent Rick touches a lit cigarette lighter to the ear of a subordinate who has momentarily displeased him. Later, in a truly unsettling scene, Mann shows Rick so disturbed at being interrupted that he throws a plate of burning crepes into the face of
58
Anthony Mann
a nightclub hostess, who is seemingly his girlfriend! When one recalls the anguish of Nora Goodrich in Strange Impersonation over the injury to her face, the depth of Coyle’s depravity becomes even more heinous. Of course, Rick reluctantly tries to make amends by throwing dollar bills at the distraught woman; however, his gesture does not diminish his cruelty which has been caught memorably by Alton’s camera angle by which the burning food has been thrown directly into the faces of the viewing audience. Rick’s death in the blazing inferno in his office is thoroughly appropriate and almost Biblical (“Those who live by the sword shall perish by the sword”). Ann’s epiphany moments in Raw Deal come about when she breaks into the fight in the taxidermist’s, picks up a gun, and wounds Fantail. While she does so to help Joe, the man she loves, Ann still breaks into tears because of her realization that she is capable of a degree of violence that she has tried intellectually to deny in herself and all “good” people. Once Joe has overcome his opponents, Ann flees from the scene of mayhem to run headlong down a beach until she collapses, and the pursuing hero then arrives to attempt to comfort her, only to end up kissing her as she declares, “Oh, Joe, I do love you!” The character’s remorse offers an early example of the moral duality that will distinguish so many of Mann’s later celebrated western protagonists: In resorting to violence, Ann has had to face that capacity within herself and, perhaps, to realize her own potential for evil. It is thoroughly appropriate that Ann openly declares her love for Joe at this point, since she has truly entered his world for the first time and, in so doing, become a more rounded character than the nagging do-gooder she has appeared to be to this point. Joe is struck by Ann from the beginning, for their initial prison interview ends with his asking, “Would you wait three years for me?” as a riposte to the girl’s marked optimism about how little time he would have to serve if he just followed her advice. After Ann gives him her address (and so sets up his subsequent flight to her apartment with Pat), Joe asks her not to “wear that perfume” on her next visit as he is made restless by it. Such double talk gives way to more overt action when Joe climbs through a window into Ann’s apartment, awakens her by kissing her, and then quickly puts his hand over her mouth to prevent her crying out. Their relationship becomes clear on the beach and the discretionary fadeout over their embrace clearly implies that Joe and Ann spend the night together romantically. Joe exhibits the kind of momentary rage and loss of control that we associate with later Mann protagonists when he sends Ann away in order to save her from the kind of life he leads. On a road next to the ocean, Joe drives with Ann to meet Pat, who has been told earlier to rent a car and join them at this point. Joe then orders the lovestruck and startled Ann to take the rented car and get away; however, she does not immediately move to do so,
3. Mann and Film Noir
59
and in a fury, he opens her door and orders her to “get out!” Naturally, his attempt at doing the right thing founders when Rick captures Ann, even if Joe’s final rescue of her by laying down his own life reveals the depths of his romantic feelings. Joe’s final act of nobility seals the fate and the future of Pat, who has recognized almost from the beginning of Raw Deal that she is being replaced as the object of his affection. She initially sees Ann when the latter is leaving the prison and is stunned by the younger woman’s good looks. This opening sequence once more reveals Mann’s sophisticated control of his story: Pat has had to wait while her beloved Joe has been with another woman and the action then segues beautifully into her next scene when she again waits for her beloved to make his prison break. As passing cars and their intrusive lights unnerve Pat in the front seat of a getaway car, she offers that “all my life I’ve been waiting,” and by the film’s end we clearly see that that will continue to be her fate. On the road to that sober resolution, Pat remarks, after twisting her ankle and being carried into the cottage hideaway, that Joe “has never really told me he loves me.” Her final condition is artfully foreshadowed by Pat’s frequently wearing a veiled hat, as though she were already in mourning even before Joe’s death, and further reinforced by the fact that she and Sullivan never kiss, in marked contrast to the number of times that he and Ann do so. Both of these elements are present in Pat’s most romantic scene with Joe aboard their getaway ship when he talks about their married future, and she ironically does not want to listen to words she has waited her whole life to hear (“Why can’t he stop talking!”) because of her guilt over not telling him about Ann’s dilemma. Pat finally realizes that any time Joe kisses her in the future “he’d be kissing Ann” and so reveals what has happened to her rival. In keeping with her genuine love for Joe—one that finally wants his happiness above her own—there is a relief in Pat’s voice when she sees the dying hero cradled in Ann’s arms and concludes: “There’s my Joe [with] a kind of happiness in his face.”
Troubled Bystanders: Desperate (1947) and Side Street (1949) Desperate is a breakthrough film for Mann in that it is more stylistically sophisticated than anything he had done up to that time; indeed, all that is missing is John Alton, whose cinematic genius would augment the director’s work for the rest of the 1940s and early 1950s. Mann’s ability to foreshadow plot developments through seemingly innocuous bits of action is clearly on display in Desperate. Thus, in its opening scene a small neighborhood boy
60
Anthony Mann
Steve Randall (Steve Brodie) and wife Ann (Audrey Long) are hounded by underworld forces in Desperate (RKO, 1947). Mann’s first successful film noir finds the protagonist finally fighting criminal boss Walt Rodak (Raymond Burr) to save himself and his bride.
plays “stick ’em up” with protagonist Steve Randall (Steve Brodie) after the latter has returned home from work. Steve’s comic plight obviously foreshadows that the plot will take him into increasingly “desperate” situations. Also characteristic of Mann’s emerging masterful style is the use of camera reversal, for we see Randall proudly polishing the logo on his truck before a track is made to bring the meddlesome little boy into the frame. Walt Radek (Raymond Burr again as a deranged villain) is introduced by a camera shot that deliberately frames him against the rungs of a chair, ostensibly to associate his character with jail bars and the criminal and entrapping underworld which he inhabits and seemingly controls. After the unsuccessful robbery of the fur company in which his headstrong brother Joe (Larry Nunn) is captured by the police, we find Walt and his gang in a low-ceilinged cellar which represents a veritable Hell. At the warehouse robbery, Steve, who thought he had been hired for a legitimate transport job,
3. Mann and Film Noir
61
has become an unwitting guilty bystander. In attempting to escape and so foil Radek’s plan, Steve pulls his truck rapidly away from the loading dock and causes Joe to fall and be overpowered by the police. In a bravura sequence that follows the botched theft, Steve is brought into the gangsters’ lair and ordered to take the rap for Joe. When he refuses, Steve is brutally beaten by Walt’s henchmen. This struggle is brilliantly and impressionistically lighted by a single overhead swinging light bulb that alternately casts light and shadow on the struggling men and on onlookers Walt and Shorty (Freddie Steele). An initial close-up of a fist starts this sequence and, after Steve has been subdued, Walt reports the make and model of the protagonist’s truck to the police. When Steve continues to object, Radek breaks the neck off a liquor bottle and, again in a tight close-up, waves it in the protagonist’s face while sadistically noting, “I’ll bet that bride of yours is real pretty.” Viewers are thus plunged into the kind of graphic violence and subconscious plot foreshadowing of more to come which mark so many of Mann’s films. When Steve subsequently escapes from Radek, he calls Ann and they meet on a train in which their plight is underscored by another tight closeup, as if to indicate their isolation in a world in which they find themselves hunted by both police and mobsters. Their lengthy journey to Anne’s kindly Aunt Klara (Ilka Gruning) and Uncle Jan (Paul Burns) takes them from the train to cars, to busses, and, ultimately, to their own feet as they try to elude various pursuers and would-be captors. At one point they even manage to hide out in the back of a truck loaded with cartoonish mannequins, and, after the police have cursorily searched it at a roadblock, we see their heads among these grotesque masks to suggest once more the madhouse world into which they have descended. In the meantime, Radek hires the sleazy investigator Pete (Douglas Fowly) to find the fleeing couple, and when the nettlesome private eye returns with an initial clue, we see Mann’s major villain appropriately photographed from low angles to indicate his control of the situation. The same technique is used in the climactic staircase gun battle between Randall and Radek. As Steve climbs the staircase, the mobster is consistently shot from below. However, Steve’s ascent, which represents his own climbing out of the quagmire into which he and Ann have fallen, gradually brings him into an equivalence with his nemesis. Walt futilely empties his pistol at Steve, but the latter kills the mobster with a single shot, and Radek’s death finds the former master of the underworld bouncing off staircase railings as his corpse plunges to the ground floor. The criminal’s descent is, appropriately, shot from a high angle to signify how the beleaguered protagonist has finally saved both himself and his family.
62
Anthony Mann
This clever climax has been preceded by another beautiful rendered sequence in Steve’s apartment. The protagonist has just sent Ann and their infant child to California to arrange for the purchase of a gas station they hope will remove them from the dilemma in which they find themselves. However, when the now optimistic Steve opens the door to his room he is quickly overpowered by Walt and Shorty and forced to endure waiting for midnight when they plan to kill him. This scheme has been hatched by Walt as an appropriate revenge for Joe who is scheduled to die at that same moment in the electric chair. However, in a nice bit of plot reversal, Walt himself dies at that exact time as noted by the manipulative police detective Ferrari (Jason Robards). Before that resolution, Steve must suffer waiting for death, and we hear both a musical pulse and a ticking clock heavily emphasized on the soundtrack to underscore his agony. These impressionistic sounds continue and are accompanied by intense close-ups of Walt, Shorty, and the sweating Steve. Eventually, the camera moves in even closer so that the eyes of each character are emphasized to go along with even louder musical and auditory pulsations. After he has killed Walt and been sent off by the police, Steve walks down the darkened street as the camera pulls back and rises to a long shot to symbolize the freedom the protagonist has achieved and can finally enjoy. Because Desperate traces the reversal of fortunes through the journey that Steve and Ann undertake, Mann uses one stylistic device abundantly to symbolize this major plot development: The initial set-up of a scene is gradually augmented by a slight camera tracking that either reverses or comments ironically on what has first been shown. When Ann gets the rushed phone call from Steve telling her to flee from their apartment, her distress is slightly muted by a panning shot to the meddlesome little boy (sitting on the staircase) who has, obviously, overheard her conversation. Later, in the train, Ann buys a newspaper which has Steve’s picture on its front page and a story about his being a fugitive from justice; and, when the protagonist notices another passenger with the same paper who intermittently glances at him, he immediately tells Ann they must leave the train. After their hasty exit, the passenger laughingly tells his wife that he can always spot honeymooners by their happy expressions! After they abandon the train, Steve goes to a shabby used car lot and runs afoul of its crooked owner Morgan (Cy Kendall) so that he must technically “steal” the car he has already paid for and worked to get into running condition. When this vehicle breaks down, Steve and Ann are picked up by a passerby (Robert Bray) who initially appears to be a do-gooder but who then reveals that he is the local sheriff. Following their subsequent arrival at the farm of Ann’s relatives, Steve is persuaded by the religious Aunt Klara
3. Mann and Film Noir
63
to have a formal Czech wedding because she does not believe Ann’s civil ceremony is valid. At the subsequent festivities, a radiant Ann tells Steve that she feels “safe for the first time,” a line that is immediately and ironically undercut by a track to the arrival of the mercenary Pete, who immediately recognizes the fugitive pair—information which he takes back to Walt. By now Ann has revealed her pregnancy to Steve (a point she was agitated about making in the film’s opening sequence) and, because of a shootout at Walt’s hideout between criminals and police in which Pete is killed and Radek severely wounded, the couple is given some months during which they can believe they are safe. However, after a store owner asks Steve about exactly when his baby is due, Mann’s main character recognizes Walt in a car parked across the street behind his own truck and must use a bag of seeds to shield himself from the criminal’s view. Naturally, Steve comes back to the farm to tell Ann that they must again flee because a situation, which appeared to be safe, has suddenly become dangerous. When Ann’s labor pains force them into a hospital, Steve is beset by a persistent insurance salesman in the waiting room. This character, while ostensibly brought in as comic relief, creates a major plot point when he succeeds in selling Steve a policy after the protagonist has been assured that it will pay his family no matter when or how he dies. Steve subsequently mails this policy to Ann after he has put her on the bus to California, so we see that even a seemingly minor character has contributed to the development of Mann’s film. The police in Desperate are hardly reassuring, for once Steve has managed to get Ann safely ensconced with her relatives he returns to the city in an attempt to clear his name. When he pleads his case with Ferrari, the policeman oscillates between outright cynicism and contempt before ordering the protagonist out of his office. It is only when Steve has left that Ferrari tells a subordinate that he is using Randall as bait to lure Radek into the open. Even more ironically, Ferrari later tells Steve that “we don’t want you any more” just before the protagonist falls into Walt’s hands. While the police do show up in time to thwart Radek’s plan for a midnight murder, Randall must go alone into the apartment house to kill the sadistic murderer. Ferrari briefly notices and comments on Steve’s only having to use a single bullet to dispatch the villain as a prelude to eagerly dictating a “press release” in which he, and not Steve, is presented as responsible for Radek’s demise. In his final act, Ferrari tells Steve he is “free to go” and smiles benevolently as Randall walks away into a presumably better life in California. While it is not, as engaging as Desperate, Side Street also displays stylistic touches that characterize Mann’s best works. The story of Joe Norson (Farley Granger) starts by reversing that of Steve Randall in that we learn that this Mann protagonist is suffering from money troubles because he failed
64
Anthony Mann
as the owner of a gas station. Unlike the earlier protagonist, though, Joe consciously chooses to commit a crime, only to be saved by the police when it becomes apparent that he has gotten in over his head. However, like Steve, Joe must also personally extricate himself from the clutches of the underworld during a riveting car chase through Manhattan’s streets.2 The credits to Side Street offer tracking aerial views of New York to set up this finale chase sequence as well as to establish the cityscape against which the characters move. The narrow streets of the metropolis and the heavy emphasis on location shooting—traits that the film shares with numerous films from the late 1940s which were influenced by The House on 92nd Street (1945) and its “documentary” style—combine to make the city into a veritable landscape in its own right. Its overarching presence throughout much of Side Street points toward Mann’s westerns with their consistent use of landscape to enhance and enlarge the conflicts in which their characters find themselves embroiled. Typically, when Joe is trapped (for a second time) inside a taxi with the murderous George Garsell (James Craig) and his driver-stooge Larry Giff (Harry Bellaver), Mann’s camera records much of this chase sequence from extremely high (bird’s eye) angles. Such shots reemphasize the point that Joe has been basically running in and up blind alleys since he stole the money from the office of the shady lawyer Victor Backett (Edmon Ryan). At the same time, these shots reduce Joe’s plight by making it appear a Farley Granger as Joe Norson in a publicity part of the inevitable nature still from Side Street (MGM, 1949). The of things: He is simply one young mailman becomes embroiled with the more tiny individual struggling underworld when he steals from mobster George Garsell (James Craig). The film uses against the larger powers of numerous Manhattan locations to portray society and the universe. Mann Norson’s lifestyle and efforts at redemption. intercuts such depersonalizing
3. Mann and Film Noir
65
shots with close-ups of the conflicted characters inside the cab to achieve a balance between the cosmic and the personal. Ultimately, one is never allowed to forget that Joe Norson is an individual and a type. Mann’s protagonist remains sympathetic despite his crime, for he has taken an envelope which he believes contains only $200 from Bakcett’s open safe because he wants to buy a present for his pregnant and long-suffering wife Ellen (Cathy O’Donnell). When Joe discovers that the envelope contains $30,000, he quickly realizes the trouble he has gotten himself into, and at one point we even see him crying out of frustration after he has thrown himself on a bed in despair. Knowing he must protect Ellen and his in-laws, Joe rapidly concocts a story about getting a new job out of town so that he can stash the hot money and figure out some way to extricate himself from a no-win situation. He subsequently decides to leave the money with local bartender Nick Drummon (Ed Max) in the guise of an “anniversary present” for his wife while he goes off to live in a cheap hotel. When Joe gives Nick the package, the latter surveys it and asks, “What did you do? Rob the mail?” The line not only reinforces the gnawing guilt of the protagonist but also foreshadows the bartender’s subsequent theft of the contents of the package. On his later return to this bar, Joe learns that Nick has sold out and gone away; however, he thinks nothing of this news since the new owner returns what appears to be the parcel. By this time Joe has decided he must go to Backett, confess what he has done, and return the money; in essence, he has become genuinely repentant and is now seeking forgiveness. When confronted, however, Backett insists that he has not been robbed and dismisses Joe rather summarily because he is doubtful about what Joe is really trying to do. Backett restrains Garsell at first, because, as a lawyer, he is fearful that their blackmail schemes will be revealed. Garsell, who has already murdered the call girl Lucille Colner (Adele Jergens) who fronted the shakedown of the aging businessman Emil Lorrison (Paul Harvey), cannot be checked for long. He and Giff grab Joe off the street, and Garsell proceeds to beat up the protagonist when he discovers the package is full of scrap paper. Norson only manages to save himself by jumping out of the speeding car and falling in front of an oncoming truck, which miraculously runs over him without making any physical contact. Because Garsell has threatened Joe’s wife and family, Norson now actively sets out to find the missing money. His search initially takes him to an undertaking parlor where a bratty boy eventually accepts a bribe to give up Nick Drummon’s address. In a nice bit of further plot development, after Joe has rushed off, this youngster jokingly announces to a friend that this has been the second time that day that he has sold this information to someone. Given this detail, it comes as no surprise that Joe finds Nick dead in the
66
Anthony Mann
latter’s seedy apartment, and it is even less surprising that he will become the prime suspect in this killing, as shown in inevitable newspaper headlines. Joe’s next move takes him to a local bank where bureaucratic teller Harold Simpson (Whit Bissell) pedantically informs him that the name of any person making a large withdrawal cannot be divulged. After riding home in the subway and seeing Joe’s picture in a newspaper, Simpson is confronted by Mann’s protagonist and threatened into giving up Lorrison’s name. Joe pretends to have a gun in his pocket during this scene and, in doing so, offers a portrait of the conflicted Mann hero whose methods and psyche frequently resemble those of the villains. Joe’s search next leads him to nightclub singer Harriet Sinton (Jean Hagen), whom he tracks down in a second-class lounge. After flirting with her and buying her drinks, Joe searches Harriet’s purse and is seen doing so by the girl, who promptly calls her boyfriend, Garsell. Harriet’s phone call precipitates the climax of Side Street; however, before that car chase, Garsell strangles her in the backseat of Giff’s cab, after promising her a great romantic future with him and after giving her numerous kisses. The murderous Garsell even shoots Giff when the latter runs out of the taxi to surrender to the police. When Joe manages to crash the car, Garsell dies in a hail of gunfire from the many police officers who have arrived on the scene. His death in medium close-up against a metal railing puts the emphasis on his dying expression and his final actions, which resemble those of a trapped animal. Mann’s film does not resort to the elaborate choreography or the editorially balanced shots that so often accompany cinematic gun battles. Death here is, indeed, up close and personal. One of the more obvious reasons that Side Street does not affect viewers as strongly as Desperate lies in its use of a voiceover. In this case Captain Walter Anderson (Paul Kelly) opens the film with some generalized statistics on New York culminating in his mentioning that there is a murder a day, and most these end up on “my desk.” The tone of Kelly’s delivery, both here and later, never sounds hurried, flustered, or frightened. He is also unflappable in the numerous police procedural scenes in which he both commands his subordinates and controls eager reporters. Anderson’s efficiency reassures the audience that Joe Norson will survive precisely because this patient and knowledgeable police detective is on his side. After noting that Joe has gotten into “more than he bargained for” because of robbing Backett’s safe, Captain Anderson reassures the audience, after the climactic car chase, that Norson, who is being taken away on a stretcher, while “no hero, no criminal,” is “going to be all right.” Side Street also embodies standard stylistic features that are characteristic of Mann. Joe reaches the conclusion that he must go on the lam before
3. Mann and Film Noir
67
a mirror in his and Ellen’s bedroom. On his mail carrier rounds, Joe pauses before a shop window to eye a mink coat; as he does so, the camera angle is reversed so as to photograph him gazing in with the coat now dominating the frame in an obviously symbolic expression of what he longs to do for his beloved Ellen as well as the fact that he is essentially walled off from achieving such a goal. In Backett’s office, as he is delivering the mail, Joe bends down to retrieve a fallen object; however, his attempt at courtesy is abruptly checked by Garsell, who steps on the fallen money and tells Joe to leave it alone. Appropriately enough, when he has finally succeeded in breaking into the lawyer’s safe and taken the money envelope, the fleeing Joe bumps into the gunman as he leaves Backett’s office. Such stylistic devices and stagings enable Mann to reinforce the central plot movement of Side Street in which Joe Norson, like Steve Randall, must extricate himself from the nightmarish netherworld into which he has fallen. The difference, of course, is that Joe can only do so with the active help of the police, a quality that is clearly signaled by the film’s final shot from the ambulance that takes him and Ellen away from the car wreck which saved him and led to Garsell’s death. Randall’s confident final walk in Desperate has been replaced by a nurturing wife and a kindly cop, who represent the kinds of community support which will become ever more essential to the heroes of many subsequent Mann films.
Intriguing Villains: Railroaded (1947) and He Walked by Night (1948) While Railroaded and He Walked by Night contain lengthy sequences devoted to police work and forensic investigations, their emphases on such procedures are ultimately superseded by their villains, who emerge as the most intriguing and lively characters in these films. Duke Martin (John Ireland) and Roy Morgan (Richard Basehart) represent a deepening of characterization for Mann’s leading bad men—a development that will blossom even further during the 1950s in his more celebrated westerns. Such a development must also be credited to John C. Higgins who scripted both of these works as well as the more widely praised T-Men and Border Incident. These two films have static opening credit sequences, with Railroaded resorting to an obvious model of a neon-lit city street and He Walked by Night opting for a rough-looking wall with sinister shadows cast upon it. In both movies, police officers are killed in the line of duty to provide key plot points and to establish the depravity of their respective villains. Duke Martin kills a patrolman during the opening robbery at the beauty parlor-bookie joint managed by Clara Calhoun (Jane Randolph) and then dumps his fatally
68
Anthony Mann
wounded cohort Cowie (Keefe Brasselle) on a local doctor’s doorstep. Roy Morgan’s attempt to break into an electronics store is interrupted by an offduty policeman whose suspicions are aroused. When Morgan starts to walk away, the officer follows in his car, asks for some identification, and then is shot at point blank range by the criminal. We see the police at work with Captain MacTaggart (Charles D. Brown) being ably assisted by Mickey Ferguson (Hugh Beaumont) in Railroaded; however, their collective efficiency only extends so far, for when the innocent Steve Ryan (Ed Kelly) is implicated by Cowie, the police are basically content to accept the dying criminal’s word. Only Mickey’s emerging love for Rosa Ryan (Sheila Ryan) keeps him on the case, and his efforts have to be undertaken “on his own time.” It is, of course, Rosa who most strongly refuses to believe that her brother could be guilty and who undertakes her own investigation to find the real killer. The smitten Mickey follows in her wake and gradually figures out Martin’s guilt only because Rosa has provided the impetus. Police procedures are much more noticeable in He Walked by Night as the efficiency of laboratory work is more consistently stressed. The forensics technician Lee (Jack Webb) and Captain Breen (Roy Roberts) are able to develop clues and act decisively in moments of crisis; and we see their combined talents at work as they supervise a number of witnesses who provide them with an artist’s composite sketch of Roy. Lee has reduced this process to a series of slides of various facial features, and Breen masterfully interrogates each of the contributing eyewitnesses. Once the picture has been assembled, Mr. Reeves (Whit Bissell), the electronics shop owner who has unwittingly been operating as Roy’s “fence,” is brought in and instantly declares as he sees the drawing, “It’s Roy!” Harsh physical, psychological, and verbal violence marks Duke Martin’s relationship with Clara Calhoun. They conspired to set up the initial robbery as a means of cheating their mutual boss, the nightclub owner Ainsworth (Roy Gordon). However, because of the killing of the police officer and the subsequent “heat” it has generated, Ainsworth decides he must close Clara’s operation, and Duke subsequently finds his bored girlfriend drinking too much and feeling sorry for herself. He slaps her and then reminds her that “cops ain’t people” before ordering her to get out of town. In their next meeting, Duke is convinced that Mickey has been to see Clara and gotten her to talk. When his moll denies this allegation because of her feelings for him, the gangster dismisses her with “Don’t give me that love stuff!” Their final rendezvous begins with Duke eavesdropping on Clara’s phone call to the police in a local drugstore. After copying and (presumably) checking the number Clara has dialed, Martin confronts his co-conspirator
3. Mann and Film Noir
69
Richard Basehart (as Morgan) fights it out in the underground sewer system in Los Angeles in He Walked by Night (Eagle-Lion, 1948). Although Mann was not officially credited as the director of this film, it was widely understood (even at the time of its release) that he had been responsible for most of it, including the brilliant shoot-out finale which would be echoed in The Third Man (British Lion/ London Films/Selznick, 1949).
and shoots her after Clara has appropriately (and almost predictably) been looking nervously into a mirror. Roy Morgan’s capacity for violence is most evident when he sneaks into Reeves’s home, despite police protection that has been provided for the shop owner. The killer pistol-whips Reeves in order to get money from him and then, while leaving, adds a gratuitous kick to the fallen man. The expressions of pleasure on Richard Basehart’s face as he performs these actions clearly signal the character’s depravity. In an earlier confrontation at Reeves’s establishment, Roy managed to get money from the owner and then successfully overpowered one policeman and shot another, Chuck Jones (Jimmy Cardwell), who is the best friend of Sergeant Marty Brennan (Scott Brady). Both films feature heavily stylized climaxes in which the killers are brought to justice in fatal gun battles fought largely in the dark. In Railroaded, Duke sets up a late night meeting with Rosa at the Club Bombay on
70
Anthony Mann
the pretext of giving her some additional information which will prove Steve innocent. However, the gangster quickly turns their conversation in another direction by asking the surprised heroine, “Why was Clara talking to you?” Fortunately, Mickey is outside, spots the menacing Duke with Clara, and breaks in to save his girl, who gets wounded in the ensuing melee. This gun battle finds Martin hiding behind overturned tables which he maneuvers through the impressionistically shadowed room. His wild shooting enables Mickey to urge “okay that’s six.” When Martin still tries to escape, Mickey kills him with a single shot. Duke dies in a tight close-up as he falls toward the camera and the viewing audience. The climactic gun battle in He Walked by Night is much longer and much more critically celebrated. Roy is temporarily cornered in his bungalow, but he manages to get away into the city’s sewer system—a means of escape which he has utilized earlier. Captain Breen then systematically covers all the exits on this particular section of the water system before he, Brennan and the others descend into the underground maze to pursue Morgan. In a brilliant sequence, John Alton’s camerawork shows retreating and advancing outlines of bouncing flashlights as the police inexorably track down the killer, who scampers wildly in various directions. Thwarted by a patrol car parked over a manhole cover which prevents his getting out of the sewer system, Roy finally turns to battle, is gassed out of his hiding place, and cut down by police bullets. Guns literally belch fire, and sound effects— echoing footfalls and reverberating gunshots—augment the highly impressionistic lighting throughout this entire sequence, which comes to a conclusion as Roy’s corpse is turned over and He Walked by Night abruptly ends. Duke Martin emerges as both a fastidious and potentially charming individual in Railroaded. His seduction of Clara seems apparent right from the outset, even though his ability to terrorize others is, perhaps, best demonstrated when Cowie identifies Steve Ryan as the cop killer, even though the younger mobster is dying himself. We later see that the bullets Duke uses are always perfumed, and he is often shown either caressing his pistol or polishing a cigarette case. As his unsuspecting boss Ainsworth says, “Duke’s an artist.” The criminal’s ambivalent relationship with Rosa begins when she shows up at Clara’s apartment to confront the latter about her testimony about the robbery. As the gunman watches from his hiding place in a closet, the women get into a fight and Rosa overpowers the inebriated Clara. When Miss Ryan goes, Duke reemerges and then orders his girlfriend to leave town because he has been attracted to the heroine and wants to try to manipulate her in the same sadistic/romantic fashion as he does Clara. When Rosa subsequently comes to the Club Bombay looking for clues
3. Mann and Film Noir
71
that will exonerate her brother, Duke sees her from Ainsworth’s upstairs office and then joins her at a table on the main floor. The gangster suggests that he has “sources” who can help her; however, at the same time, he insists that “you’re beautiful” and then asserts himself by telling her “don’t interrupt” as he continues to flirt with her. At their second meeting, Mickey intrudes upon Duke and Rosa, asks the criminal about Clara’s whereabouts, and is rebuffed by both of them. Indeed, when Rosa implies that Steve has been framed by the police, Duke joyfully asks, “So you hate cops, eh?” After this scene, Duke drives Rosa home and makes a date with her for the next evening, all the while insisting “For you, baby, anything.” A third meeting between these characters finds Duke producing an alcoholic who tells a story that, much to Rosa’s delight, exonerates Steve. When the gangster insists that he will need $300 to pay for his expenses in the matter, the heroine agrees to deliver the money on the following evening. Their final rendezvous, which ends in the gun battle with Mickey, finds the moody Duke upset because, prior to killing Clara, he copied down a phone number that turned out to be Rosa’s. His sinister question “Why was Clara talking to you?” reveals his consistently egotistical attitude toward the world. However, by this time, Duke Martin has emerged as the first of Mann’s charming villains. His characterization will be more adroitly rendered and thematically important in such figures as Emerson Cole (Arthur Kennedy) in Bend of the River (1952) and Ben Vandergroot (Robert Ryan) in The Naked Spur. Roy Morgan is the most alienated villain in Mann’s works, for we never learn exactly what is motivating him. Greed does not explain his actions because his modest lifestyle in a court that resembles a motel and being accompanied only by a faithful dog belie that motive; indeed, Morgan appears to be working at crime as one might work at an everyday job. Marty Brennan learns from two other policeman (John Dehner and Byron Foulger) that Morgan worked in their station before he went off to war, that he was an exceptionally good employee, and that he, surprisingly, never asked to get his old job back once he had returned to civilian life. The absence of an elaborate backstory or a traumatic injury or incident to account for Roy’s current behavior is thoroughly in keeping with the unromantic tone of He Walked by Night, a film that conspicuously lacks any love interests. Indeed, the only prominent female role is given over to an addled neighbor of Morgan’s (Dororthy Adams) who bothers Marty when the latter is posing as a milkman to learn exactly where Roy lives. After the factory owner Reeves declares that Roy is an electronics “genius,” we see that quality in his many disguises and his own procedural methods (e.g., changing license plates) which thwart the police. When Roy
72
Anthony Mann
is wounded in the shootout at the electronics store, Mann stages a powerful scene in which the criminal operates on himself; and, in a bit of bravura acting, Richard Basehart makes the audience “feel his pain” as he extracts a bullet from his side in sweaty medium close-up. The other traits of Roy’s which emerge are his pleasure in inflicting pain, best seen when he smiles as he kicks the fallen Reeves, and his fatalistic delight in fighting the police in the sewer system, best seen when he alternates expressions of joy and fear during this entire sequence. Roy Morgan, largely because of the skillful ways he is rendered by actor and director, takes on the world-weary cynicism and resignation to fate one associates with Macbeth; like Shakespeare’s usurper and murderer, the villain of He Walked by Night chooses to die fighting rather than to surrender to the greater forces which are overwhelming him. Railroaded clearly presents more of the compromised, convoluted, and conventional characters that one customarily associates with crime films. Marie (Peggy Converse), who works as Clara’s assistant in both the beauty salon and the betting parlor, causes the initial shootout between Cowie and the patrolman when she screams, despite being told not to do so. Her disagreement with Clara at the police station on the physical appearances and number of the robbers marks her for death, and no one is surprised to learn that she has been murdered (presumably by Duke) and thrown in the river, with only a tattered purse to identify her corpse. Mr. Ainsworth, as the criminal Mr. Big, typically has a cynical younger mistress and an arrogance about how he can always control Duke. Naturally, he gets gunned down by his more ruthless subordinate, who has managed to lull Ainsworth into being too relaxed around him. Rosa Ryan and Mickey Ferguson embody the standard boy-meets-girl aspects of the film, so that her initial resistance to the policeman will gradually soften throughout its course. Mickey, who has grown up in the same neighborhood, is appropriately stunned when he initially sees the heroine (“You’re not Rosie, are you?”); however, his romantic feelings must be subordinated to his obligations as an officer of the law, for he will not compromise his ethics to help Steve (and so gain Rosa) unless the evidence warrants his doing so. As he tells Rosa, “feelings don’t count” when she tries to seduce him into not arresting her sibling on the sole basis of her instinctively knowing that Steve is incapable of murder. Mickey later rationalizes his romantic rejection at Club Bombay by meeting Rosa after Duke has driven her home and complimenting her on “a good act.” Appropriately enough, Mickey kisses Rosa at this point to reassure the audience that the heroine will, indeed, be his at the final fadeout—a foreshadowing that proves thoroughly accurate in the last scene of Railroaded in which, after Steve has returned from prison and been welcomed home, everyone exits except for the lovers who joyfully embrace.
3. Mann and Film Noir
73
Clara Calhoun (Jane Randolph) spies Duke Martin (John Ireland) in Railroaded (Eagle-Lion, 1947). Mann’s use of mirrors is once again significant as the criminal decides that his talkative girlfriend must be killed.
Finally, both of these films show working police officers, Ferguson and Brennan, who are thoroughly devoted to their craft. While Mickey feels the strain of being in love with Rosa and still having to jail her brother, he is able to anticipate the wishes of his superiors as well as to employ the newest techniques in crime detection—giving Steve a paraffin test. He is also clearly observant, for it is he who notices the perfume on the murder bullet and later connects it to Martin’s pistol. Moreover, as a dogged police professional, Ferguson insists on working on Steve’s case when all his colleagues believe they have the right man in custody. At Clara’s apartment, Mickey turns up a photograph of Duke and thus ties the gangster to the earlier robbery; then he further forces Martin’s hand by appearing to be coming out of Calhoun’s digs—a misperception on Duke’s part that results in the hairdresser’s death. Marty Brennan shares a similar dedication to finding a cop killer in He Walked by Night, and he also utilizes newer procedural means in his quest. However, his doubts about his own efficiency finally provoke Captain Breen into temporarily removing him from the case—a ploy which his superior
74
Anthony Mann
uses to get Marty to operate with greater insight. This lesson is delivered by the wounded, and potentially paraplegic, Sergeant Jones, who fell victim to the insidious Roy in the shop gun battle. Jones simply tells his partner to work doggedly at the case, and that is what Brennan proceeds to do. His posing as a milkman reveals Roy’s hideout, and Marty performs as an admirable second to Captain Breen in the final pursuit and gun battle with the frenzied Morgan.
Tortured Heroes: T-Men (1948) and Border Incident (1949) In each of these films, government agents go undercover to dismantle criminal enterprises. These descents into the underworld are, however, not without serious costs in suffering and death for the good guys who, despite the supposedly omniscient forensics and support units behind them, must largely improvise for themselves once within these criminal milieus. While Dennis O’Brien (Dennis O’Keefe) and Tony Genaro (Alfred Ryder) are always in contact with their Treasury Department superiors once they have penetrated the counterfeiting ring in T-Men, they must use their own wits in dealing with the suspicious and avaricious world to which they have been sent. Pablo Rodriguez (Ricardo Montalban) and Jack Bearnes (George Murphy) must similarly suffer and improvise. A more striking feature of both films is that in each of them a government agent and obvious good guy protagonist dies in a wrenching fashion. Tony Genaro, whose identity has become known to the criminal gang, tries to locate the incriminating notebook left by the Schemer (Wallace Ford) before escaping; however, he seeks too long and ends up trapped by Moxie (Charles McGraw) as his partner O’Brien can only helplessly watch. Genaro is brutally gunned down; alternating close-ups of his face and that of O’Brien, trying stoically not to reveal his own identity, create a devastating effect. The same situation is reprised in Border Incident when Bearnes is discovered to be an immigration officer and Owen Parkson (Howard da Silva) orders his execution. The federal man dies very graphically in a barren field where, after being wounded, he is unable to get away from a mechanical threshing machine that literally tears him to pieces as Jeff Amboy (Charles McGraw once more) drives it over his prone body. Bearnes’s death agonies are played out in front of Pablo and Juan Garcia (James Mitchell) who, being unarmed, can do nothing to stop Amboy and Clayton Nordell (Arthur Hunnicutt). T-Men and Border Incident are also helped considerably by having the same screenwriter, John C. Higgins, and the same cinematographer, John
Arnold Moss, George Murphy and Alfonso Bedoya in Border Incident (MGM, 1949). Zopilote (Moss) and Cuchillo (Bedoya) menace American undercover agent Jack Bearnes (Murphy) in Mann’s first project at MGM.
Alton. The distinctly stylized presentations of violence and locations in these films derive, of course, from the lighting talents of Alton; indeed, with him Mann had found the ideal visual collaborator for his own nightmarish film noir ideas, and these films thus represent the purest expressions of what the director was trying to capture in the genre. This collaborative team had been
76
Anthony Mann
so successful by 1949 (they also worked together on Raw Deal) that new MGM head Dore Schary, who brought Mann and his two collaborators to the studio encouraged them to complete Border Incident, which they had been working on for Eagle-Lion. The more lavish production differences inherent in the wealthier studio can be readily seen by comparing the credit and immediate opening sequences of T-Men and Border Incident. The earlier film opens with its credits superimposed over a shot of the Treasury Department Seal, while Border Incident features much more dramatic and insightful shots of the border of Mexico and the United States as well as of the fences that separate the two countries and the treacherous terrain over which illegal entrants must return south—often to their deaths. T-Men segues to a voiceover by Reed Hadley which introduces a Treasury official, who then ponderously announces that what follows is based on actual Department cases—all in a style that consciously imitates the documentary “realism” of numerous post-war thrillers. Border Incident also opens with a voiceover explaining the need for immigrant Mexican workers to keep California’s agricultural industry humming and emphasizing how the majority of these individuals cross the border legally. Those laborers who cross illegally are often robbed, as we see next in a sequence in which some of these unwary souls are waylaid by Parkson’s gang, robbed, killed, and thrown into quicksand. In this way Mann foreshadows the end of Border Incident while at the same time providing some expository background for what is about to happen in his film. The federal agents in both stories must assume different identities to penetrate the criminal worlds they wish to destroy; and, while such alterations can include name changes as well as phony documents, they must still work diligently at fleshing out their aliases. Even then, unfortunately, they are not able to control the world out of which they have come, so that Genaro is tripped up by inadvertently meeting his young wife at a Los Angeles market. While her noisy girlfriend points him out, the wife (June Lockhart) is smart enough to deny that Genaro is her husband; however, this exchange has been witnessed by Schemer who, in turn, reveals it to Moxie in a futile attempt to stop the thug from killing him in a Turkish bath. Parkson’s contacts in Kansas City eventually inform him that Bearnes is not the escaped criminal he is claiming to be, and so the discovered agent must meet his grisly demise in the cornfield. Both films feature numerous villains since they focus on the structure of the underworld more than Mann’s other noir films. In Detroit, O’Brien and Genaro are confronted by the shady hotel operator Pasquale (Tito Vuolo), a character they do not hesitate to push around in their new roles
3. Mann and Film Noir
77
as tough guys. They must also deal with the Motor City’s Vantucci mob in order to find out exactly where the counterfeiters are operating in Los Angeles; and this involvement leads to a beating for Genaro after O’Brien has “blown town” to try and locate where the Schemer is active in the California megalopolis. In addition to the sadistic Moxie, the heroes are also exposed to Shiv (John Wengraf) and Diana (Jane Randolph), subordinates of the Mr. Big who is behind the entire operation. In order to infiltrate the smuggling operation in Border Incident, Rodriguez and Bearnes must begin in Mexico where they are assailed by Hugo (Sig Ruman) and the thugs who work for him—Zopilote (Arnold Moss), Cuchillo (Alfonso Bedoya), and Pocoloco (Jose Torvay). On the other side of the border, in addition to the air pistol aficionado Parkson and his stooges, Mann’s protagonists must deal with Chuck (Jack Lambert) and the sinister Mrs. Amboy (Lynn Whitney). Pablo only survives in this chaotic world because of his friendship with Juan who, in pulling the agent from certain death in quicksand at the climax, reemphasizes the essential improvisational and “lone” hand that all of Mann’s federal men must play. Camera stylistics in T-Men include a complex set-up in which O’Brien must extricate the face plate of the counterfeit set he has offered to the villains. He has taped this valuable commodity under a bathroom sink, knowing full well that if it were not hidden he would be killed. Unfortunately, Moxie has chosen to shave there so that O’Brien must move around him to get the plate—a sequence that is neatly done with low angle shots showing precisely where the object is and how the agent discreetly extricates it. Alton also cleverly photographs locations in Detroit—the public library and the Scott Fountain on Belle Isle—to provide the film with a greater verisimilitude than has heretofore been present in Mann’s works. Finally, a decided future tendency in the director’s films appears at the end of T-Men when O’Brien is taken to the counterfeiters’ ship, escapes, and eventually kills Moxie in an on-deck gun battle. This sequence is not only brilliantly lit and choreographed but it also emphasizes the architectonics of the vessel and is thoroughly in accord with Mann’s increasing awareness of the importance of locations. At the same time, Moxie’s futile knocking on a locked ship door just prior to being shot by O’Brien visually reverses the scene in the steambath in which Schemer futilely tried to avoid his fate. Alton’s cinematography remains at the same high level in Border Incident, which is resplendent with character business and plot reversals that we have seen earlier and which will become more sophisticated in later Mann efforts. Parkson’s fondness for shooting clay pigeons with an air pistol visually reprises the scene in The Great Flamarion in which we see the title character practicing in his room. Pablo’s search for help after witnessing Bearnes’s
78
Anthony Mann
Moxie (Charles McGraw) terrorizes Dennis O’Brien (Dennis O’Keafe) in T-Men (Eagle-Lion, 1947). Mann’s first big film noir success is replete with physical and psychological violence as undercover agent O’Brien penetrates a counterfeiting ring. The ambivalence of good and bad guys in Mann comes to the fore as O’Brien must watch his partner (Alfred Ryder as Anthony Gennaro) gunned down. Later, he retaliates against McGraw.
death takes him to apparent safety in a local ranch house where, after having called for outside help, he is confronted by a transformed Mrs. Amboy. The gun she points at Rodriguez represents a classic reversal of expectations in Mann, particularly because this lady has not been seen before this sequence. Finally, when he is in Mexico, Bearnes tries to follow the illegal workers but is diverted because he is also being followed by another of Hugo’s henchmen, Fritz (Otto Waldis). Bearnes hides, surprises Fritz, and knocks him out in a fashion that will recur when Will Lockhart (James Stewart) confronts the oily Chris Boldt (Jack Elam) in The Man from Laramie (1955). T-Men is arguably Mann’s most overtly violent film, a quality frequently noted by critics. What emerges as distinctive about the director’s style at such moments is that they are mostly recorded on the faces of those witnessing or suffering from these grim actions, rather than in extendedly overt or graphic representations of the harms actually being administered. The most
3. Mann and Film Noir
79
disturbing aspect, however, is the speed and ease with which Mann’s good guy protagonists adapt to such underworld mayhem and use it themselves. Like Lin McAdam (James Stewart) in Winchester ’73, agent O’Brien walks a thin line between good and evil; and his moral dualism, which will become increasingly prominent in Mann’s westerns, creates a tension not found in the director’s other noir films. When he initially begins to follow the Schemer, O’Brien reveals himself to the criminal by passing him a counterfeit bill in a crap game; however, the agent is then mistakenly identified as passing the bad bill to another player (an act which Schemer performed) and he is soundly beaten by a group of irate bettors. The federal man ends up on the floor of a washroom as his assailants throw him into the forefront of the frame to create the illusion that O’Brien is being tossed into the laps of the audience. Later, when he confronts Schemer in the latter’s apartment, O’Brien chokes the older man in a shot conspicuously framed through a lamp shade. Although he agrees to let Schemer take one of his counterfeit bills to the higher-ups in the organization, O’Brien has clearly adopted the ethos of violence fully embodied by all and sundry in the underworld. Indeed, the criminals in T-Men utilize physical violence to test anyone who approaches them; so, as a result, O’Brien is confronted by Moxie and Brownie (Jack Overman) shortly after Schemer delivers the counterfeit bill to his superiors. Moxie applies a thorough beating to O’Brien, even going so far as to pull his knuckles out of their sockets in a sequence that focuses on the anguish on the protagonist’s face. Then, as a final touch, Moxie claps O’Brien’s ears to deafen him, an act that is supported by a ringing musical effect on the film’s soundtrack. Later, when O’Brien is taken to see the mob’s higher-ups and told that his offer is being seriously considered, he promptly slugs Moxie to get even for the earlier beating. Mann’s presentation of violence reaches a crescendo with the death of Schemer, whose penchant for Turkish baths causes his demise, just as his fondness for exotic Chinese candy earlier enabled O’Brien to track him down. The Schemer finds himself confronted by a betowelled Moxie who comments ominously on how someone could easily die if the steam were turned up too high. The older man quickly discerns why Moxie has been sent; however, despite various appeals, including his information about Genaro’s accidental meeting with his wife, Schemer is scalded to death. Alton uses reflected lighting and impressionistic steam to devastating effect in this sequence, and its visual climax finds Schemer trying futilely to break a tiny window in a door that Moxie holds fast. We cannot hear Schemer’s final words; we only see the anguish and terror on his face. At Tony Genaro’s execution, the dying agent manages to slip the pawn
80
Anthony Mann
ticket he has uncovered in Schemer’s room to O’Brien; and, appropriately enough, another federal agent subsequently picks a fight with the remaining protagonist so that the ticket can be passed on to headquarters. O’Brien’s final suffering occurs aboard the freighter as he guns down Moxie in a reprise of the film’s opening sequence in which that thug killed a key federal witness on a loading dock. O’Brien’s subsequent collapse leads to the rapid ending of T-Men in which government agents swarm all over the ship, trap the other criminals, and tear gas them into submission. The film’s ending then features a magazine article in which we learn that O’Brien is recovering and that Genaro’s sacrifice has not been in vain, because their actions have been in the best tradition of the Treasury Department standing up for justice in America. Violence in Border Incident is not nearly as prevalent as in T-Men, but two sequences stand out. In the first, Bearnes is tortured by his Mexican captors who want to know where he has hidden the blank immigration permits he claims to have. Their questioning proceeds as he is tied down and periodically jolted with electricity, once again in a style that relies heavily on the actor’s facial expressions rather than on close-ups of how the devices are used. Bearnes is initially awakened by a knife at his throat in an obvious bit of symbolic manipulation, and the lines that cross his chest superimpose a Christian cross as well as seemingly foreshadowing his eventual demise. The climactic battle on the border, fought between farm workers and Parkson’s gang, is the film’s most extended instance of sustained physical suffering. Pablo has disarmed Parkson and sent him ahead through an opening in the rocks to be shot by his Mexican colleagues before he and the other laborers engage in hand-to-hand combat with the bandits. When Pablo overcomes Zopilote, the latter’s body sinks under the quicksand surface; however, Rodriguez now finds himself sinking inexorably into the same deadly ooze. An extended struggle ensues in which Juan manages to extricate Pablo, but only after a Herculean effort punctuated with appropriately sinister musical cues. Interestingly enough, even though no federal agents arrive in time to help, Border Incident ends with an obligatory scene in which order is restored. The immigration departments and heads of both Mexico and the United States, who originally planned the operation, once again convene to celebrate Rodriguez’s achievement and to lament the loss of Bearnes. The voiceover then resumes to assure the audience that all is well again on the border because of the brave sacrifices of the agents of both countries. Border Incident, like Side Street, illustrates Mann’s growing appreciation of how settings and location work could enhance the material he is filming. The nighttime trek through the rocks and gorges leading into Mex-
3. Mann and Film Noir
81
ico is visually enhanced by Jeff Amboy’s revolt against his erstwhile superior, Parkson. As they move toward the “canyon of death,” Jeff asserts himself by taking Parkson’s money and demeaning him as someone who is only good at shooting inanimate targets. In essence, just as Duke Martin did with Mr. Ainsworth in Railroaded, the underling has simply been waiting for a chance to take over. However, in this case, Jeff decides to let Parkson live because the ranch owner can walk behind the laborers with a rifle to keep them moving. Jeff and Nordell take positions on plateaus above the dry river bed and we see their silhouettes as menacing shadows looming over the seemingly doomed Mexicans through much of this sequence. Naturally, when Pablo disarms Parkson and a gun battle erupts, the Mexican agent kills Amboy, who falls to his death from a great height. This emphasis on high places is further developed when Bearnes is brought to Parkson’s ranch from Mexico, questioned about the location of the permits, and then sent away to sleep. Because he has consistently urged that he’s “hot” and the subject of a state-wide dragnet, Bearnes has been placed in a room at the top of a water tower and kept under guard. When Juan tells Pablo that he has seen Bearnes there, Rodriguez sneaks out of the wetbacks’ barracks and climbs up to his colleague’s room. In doing so, Pablo manages to elude the suspicious Nordell, who is aroused by disturbing sounds from above him, by moving around the outside of the structure as Bearnes occupies the gunman. While we have seen Mann’s fascination with high places on display in Dr. Broadway and Strange Impersonation, this setting and its complicated visual presentation foreshadows more predominant and meaningful heights in such later works as The Naked Spur and The Fall of the Roman Empire (1964).
History as Film Noir: The Black Book (a.k.a. Reign of Terror) (1949) Mann’s initial foray into historical costume drama utilizes many of the plot devices, character types, and stylistic techniques of his noir films; however, his thematic concerns are much more philosophical in their political and social orientations here than in those atmospheric thrillers. The Black Book is also helped considerably by the talents of its veteran art director, William Cameron Menzies, who had worked on numerous Hollywood blockbusters including Gone with the Wind (1939). His set designs for Mann’s low budget film suggest opulence and large-scale locations through the manipulation of mise-en-scène. Menzies’s designs are augmented by the always notable cinematogra-
82
Anthony Mann
phy of John Alton, who works within a consistently dark canvas to make stunning impressions through the manipulation of lighting and claustrophobic close-ups. Alton cleverly and quickly establishes the overall tone of The Black Book in its opening sequence as we see Charles D’Aubigny (Robert Cummings) riding on the horizon and framed against a thoroughly inky sky with numerous low clouds. When the character arrives at the Austrian castle to which the Marquis de Lafayette has been exiled, Alton shows D’Aubigny’s entry by a high angle shot that emphasizes the gates and walls of the palace. In a film in which such sites consistently represent obstacles that the protagonist must overcome or barriers that he must get past, this initial shot foreshadows the political and social maelstrom which D’Aubigny (and the audience) will face for the rest of the film. When Charles is given a talismanic ring that will identify him to Lafayette’s French supporters who are trying to prevent Robespierre (Richard
Charles D’Aubigny (Robert Cummings) and Fouché (Arnold Moss) struggle in The Black Book (Wanger/Eagle-Lion, 1949). Mann’s foray into the “Reign of Terror” portrays French politics and its popular leaders in film noir style and fashion.
3. Mann and Film Noir
83
Basehart) from becoming a dictator, he rides off again silhouetted against the same horizon and darkly impressionistic sky. His arrival at a battered windmill again prepares us for the turmoil and carnage that will be Revolutionary Paris, for D’Aubigny’s entry here is lit so that only his face is clearly in view as a knife is held to his throat; he manages to avoid death by showing the ring to his assailants. This set-up will be used again in Man of the West (1958) when Link Jones (Gary Cooper) opens the door to the hut in which the Tobin gang is hiding and a pistol is pointed at him. The Black Book also features a voiceover like so many of Mann’s noir films. The initial credits are shot against a background of raging fire, and these flames carry over to an opening sequence which introduces several of the principal historical characters of the story. These political figures include Robespierre, Danton (Wade Crosby), Tallien (Norman Lloyd), St. Just (Jess Barker), and Barras (Richard Hart), and their images are superimposed on the roaring flames to emphasize the narrator’s message about the chaos of the Reign of Terror in French history. The voiceover’s tone is strident, feverish, and almost hysterical as he offers rapid characterizations (e.g., Barras is a “good man”) that essentially tell the audience how these figures are to be seen; and, while such overt exposition can be faulted, this technique points once more to the severe budget constraints with which Mann and his collaborators had to work. Another feature of Mann’s increasing artistry which is abundantly displayed in The Black Book is the ease and acumen with which he handles scenes of tension. An extended prison sequence in which Charles is detained by St. Just arises because of doubts that Robespierre and his minions have as to whether the protagonist is who he claims to be—Duvall, the notorious executioner of Strasbourg. Madame Duvall has been sent for and Charles, who has witnessed the death of her husband and taken his place in order to infiltrate Robespierre’s inner circle, clearly believes that his real identity will soon be revealed. However, in a typical example of Mann’s penchant for abrupt plot changes, D’Aubigny’s fears are allayed when his “wife” appears, kisses him passionately, and chides him about neglecting her—all to the obvious chagrin of Robespierre and St. Just, who must now let Charles go free. At this juncture, the real Madame Duvall shows up and demands to see Robespierre. She is told she must wait by an elderly gatekeeper who is distracted by the need to let Charles and the fake Madame Duvall out of the prison. As they and St. Just wait patiently for the fumbling and maddeningly slow sentry to unchain the gate, the soldier casually mentions to the real Madame Duvall that she might wish to speak to St. Just about her problem. This moment of tension is then eased when that lady insists that she will talk to no one but Robespierre; as a result, Charles then gets into a carriage in
84
Anthony Mann
which Madeleine (Arlene Dahl) sits smiling before explaining how she has managed to rescue the protagonist with the help of a female actress-friend. Mann even interweaves a comic turn to create tension when Charles and Madeleine must escape from Paris because they have obtained Robespierre’s death list and need to hide until the following day when that document will be circulated among the members of the Assembly to thwart the would-be dictator’s power grab. The lovers escape from Paris dressed as peasants in a farmer’s cart, and when they must show their papers at the city’s outskirts they are delayed by a guard who only wants to bargain with them about bringing him some chickens when they next come to the market. Mann cleverly juxtaposes the anxious but outwardly calm couple to the suspicious but inwardly greedy guard to create tension, especially since the audience knows that St. Just and his cohorts are already in hot pursuit. Another ingenious presentation of tension occurs at the farmhouse to which Charles and Madeleine flee. D’Aubigny throws himself on a cot because he is exhausted; however, when St. Just and his men arrive, the protagonist inadvertently leaves Robespierre’s incriminating notebook behind in his haste to escape with Madeleine. The villains actively search for them but are thwarted, and when the lead soldier (Charles McGraw) reports on their lack of success to St. Just, the latter decides that he will take a brief nap in the same bed which Charles has just abandoned. Grandmother Blanchard (Beulah Bondi) spots the black book lodged under a pillow just as St. Just is lying down; and, since she is not quick enough to retrieve it, all she can do is make sure the valuable object is securely tucked under the pillow on which the villain’s head is now resting. Charles and Madeleine sneak back to the farmhouse seeking the black book, and the protagonist figures out that St. Just is lying on it. He then goes to the window of the children’s room and rouses them to assist by creating a distraction; their subsequent outbursts cause St. Just and his henchmen to break into the children’s room. In the ensuing confusion we see Madeleine grab the book and run to Charles, who has managed to steal two horses from their pursuers. Mann deftly marks the end of this sequence with a framing shot of the grandmother and the children smiling benevolently as the hero and heroine ride off and their pursuers scramble to take up the chase. The director’s familiar skill in presenting graphic physical violence is also markedly apparent in The Black Book; indeed, the film strikes an appropriate balance between directly showing such effects and merely suggesting them by clever staging. In a carriage ride through the turbulent nighttime streets of Paris, the duplicitous Foche (Arnold Moss) and Charles are attacked by robbers; the police prefect shoots one of these assailants in the head, and we see a brief shot of the man’s bloodied face before Foche pushes him into the
3. Mann and Film Noir
85
cobblestoned street. Charles expertly dispatches the other attacker by pushing a torch into his face and, although we do not get a grim close-up, this figure then also falls off into the roadway. D’Aubigny’s act resembles the kind of behavioral change exhibited by O’Brien in T-Men; like the federal agent posing as a counterfeiter, the undercover spy takes on the very traits of the criminals with whom he must deal. We see tortured victims suspended from the ceiling in the bakery cellar which is Robespierre’s secret hideaway: one is killed by the ever-present McGraw and Madeleine is only reluctantly cut down later because the villains can trade her for the black book. The heroine has, of course, presumably been racked and whipped before this release as indicated by her decorously torn clothing. In the prison when Robespierre arrives to witness the reunion of the Duvalls, some of the doomed inmates raise an enormous hue and cry which is put down when guards randomly fire shots at the future victims of the guillotine. When D’Aubigny and Foche find the black book in Robespierre’s library, a struggle ensues in which Charles eventually strangles the police prefect; however, Foche has merely passed out, for he subsequently brings one of Madeleine’s earrings to the protagonist in an effort to regain the incriminating tome. By this time, of course, as Foche reveals, Robespierre has been seized by the mob. However, that development, which has been the purpose of his entire mission, does not prevent Charles from again choking the police prefect in order to find out where Madeleine has been hidden. This second choking scene again emphasizes the degree to which the hero has adopted the methods of the amoral and terrifying world in which Foche prospers and survives. Fire is used throughout The Black Book to underscore the tumultuousness of the times. In addition to its prominence in the opening and closing credits, this element is deftly employed when the real Duvall is killed. We see the notorious executioner checking his appearance after he has been shown to his room in the inn, just before a hand emerges from the right side of the frame and begins to throttle him. As these struggling figures move quickly below camera range, Mann’s composition stays focused on the top of the dressing table, the mirror, and a burning candle. After a couple of moments, a hand rises from below the table and symbolically snuffs out the candle to indicate that Duvall is dead. One is inevitably reminded here of Othello’s line, “Put out the light/And then put out the light” as he moves toward killing Desdemona. When Charles rescues Madeleine at the film’s climax he is shown entering the wrecked bakery with a torch prominently in his left hand. As he desperately rummages through the fallen timbers and then works frantically at
86
Anthony Mann
trying to find a way to get behind what he thinks is a false bookcase, he continues to hold this burning taper. Finally, in dismay, he decides to leave, but before he does so he tosses the torch back against the bookcase. By this time Robespierre’s notorious henchman, who is holding Madeleine in the room behind the shelf, has become aware of Charles’s presence; however, the sadistic McGraw has also inadvertently knocked over a bottle of wine whose contents have seeped into the outer room. By virtue of his fallen torch, Charles notices the fluid running out on the floor, immediately rushes back to the bookcase, retrieves his torch, and pries open the entrance to the concealed chamber. After he forces open the connecting door, he manages to evade McGraw’s sword thrust and, in a desperate struggle, kills the latter by burning him to death. The Black Book also contains allusions to and echoes from past and future Mann films. Its central plot device, in which D’Aubigny must penetrate the world of Robespierre and his gang in order to “save” France, obviously resembles what the federal agents are doing in T-Men and Border Incident. Thus, Charles’s initial meeting with Lafayette, in which the Marquis ruefully says that he cannot order D’Aubigny to do anything, reprises the openings of these other films by setting up the protagonist as the good man who must willingly volunteer to face danger to help his society. When he is initially admitted to Madeleine’s hidden room in the tavern, Charles is struck down by her protectors and thrown to the floor so that he falls toward the camera, just as O’Brien did in the washroom in T-Men. Later, when Madeleine has succeeded in getting Charles away from Robespierre by means of the fake Madame Duvall, she is able to thwart their pursuers by motioning for a cart to block the following posse—a tactic that was also utilized in T-Men when O’Brien’s potential rescuers were temporarily held up by the raising of a bridge while he was facing the counterfeit gang by himself. The sequence at the Blanchard farm takes us back to Desperate. Once again a fleeing couple has gone into the countryside to avoid urban dangers; and, once again, their pursuers catch up with them and, in doing so, terrorize the local inhabitants. In his treatment of the grandmother and the three children, St. Just embodies a greater psychological acumen and subtlety than Walt Radek did with Aunt Klara and her husband; however, the sinister official’s charming attempt to persuade the youngest child to reveal whether Charles and Madeleine have been at the farm is symbolically contradicted when St. Just kicks a cat that has been scratching his leg. Even more interesting is the fact that Charles and Madeleine hide in the loft of a barn to evade their pursuers: the association of such a setting with getting away from one’s society accompanies central plot moments in The Great Flamarion and El Cid (1961).
3. Mann and Film Noir
87
The character drawing in The Black Book is more nuanced than in any previous Mann film, a quality that seemingly arises from the talents of its major writer Philip Yordan, who supplies distinctly different speaking styles to its more prominent figures. Thus, Foche consistently uses comic repartee to conceal his cynical self-interests and to underscore his nonchalance about the violence he sees and engenders. Typically, in the cellar after Robespierre has ordered a tortured enemy [to be] put to death, and after the victim screams, Foche asks Charles, “Why don’t you eat your bun?” as he bites into his own roll which is skewered on a knife. When D’Aubigny and Madeleine discover the corpse of one of St. Just’s victims who has been killed to throw guilt on Barras and his supporters, Foche turns up and mockingly asks, “Who, me?” when the protagonist eyes him suspiciously. Madeleine’s dialogue oscillates between scorn and seductiveness; however, after her initial meeting with Charles, we realize that her style is contrived to protect her and the political services she is trying to render to France. As she falls in love with D’Aubigny once more, and so assuages the emotional wounds she caused him four years before the opening of The Black Book, Madeleine’s dialogue becomes not only more normal but also noticeably less important; and it is no surprise that she is essentially silent at the film’s end when she is sheltered in the protagonist’s arms. In its plot emphasis on the injury that Madeleine inflicted on the hero earlier, Mann’s movie foreshadows The Naked Spur in which being emotionally injured by a woman who seemingly loved him has turned Howie Kemp into a bounty hunter. Madeleine’s typical tone is goading mockery whenever Charles complains to or becomes dismissive of her; at one point she taunts him by asking “Tell me about the women who went with the wine” after he has spoken of drowning his sorrows in alcohol after she abandoned him. Robespierre’s dialogue illustrates his dual nature, for while he is pompous and self-righteous in public, in private he is much more candid and egomaniacal. These latter traits emerge, however, when he must defend himself against the enraged Assembly and the mob which pursues him into his office after the black book has become public property. His initial entry into that inner sanctum finds France’s would-be autocrat confronted by Foche, who has appropriated Robespierre’s chair and offers that he has done so to see how it would “fit.” Robespierre’s petulant demand of the police prefect (“Don’t call me Max!”) is adroitly handled as Foche consistently uses that diminutive through the whole sequence. Robespierre’s egotism is demonstrated by his actions as well as his words. At one point we see him conferring with St. Just about the political trick they have played by pretending the black book is missing in order to implicate and exterminate their opponents in the Assembly. Their meeting has the
88
Anthony Mann
master villain seated before a mirror while having his wig delicately powdered by an unseen servant. Robespierre’s various terms for the public which he wishes to rule over further emphasize the character’s rabid self-involvement, for he consistently sees himself as their savior rather than their servant. In his cellar in the bakery lair he proclaims to Foche and Charles that the people are a “mob” which can only be controlled by a strong man capable of ruling through “fear.” Later, after the incriminating book with its death list has turned the Assembly against him, Robespierre argues that the “mob are my children” and asks, if he is removed, “Who takes my place?” Fearful that Robespierre’s oratorical skills will turn the tide yet again, Foche tells an assistant to “shut his mouth” and a pistol shot does exactly that for Robespierre is wounded in the mouth and never utters another syllable. Its thematic implications, finally, provide The Black Book with its most intriguing moments. While the story pits an obvious group of good guys against an equally obvious group of villains, there are disconcerting elements on both sides: The supposedly benevolent Taillien becomes part of the shouting mob which condemns Robespierre to death, while the criminally manipulative Foche survives to establish the film’s wonderfully equivocal ending. The world that these characters inhabit is thoroughly given over to power and privilege, and the only way to checkmate a Robespierre is to use his own methods against him. The tyrant has risen by being able to foment public hysteria against his rivals, as we see in an early scene in which Danton is sentenced to death because Robespierre has whipped up a frenzy of emotion against his erstwhile ally. Throughout The Black Book, Robespierre and his confederates operate like a criminal gang precisely because they can manipulate the public and easily turn the citizens of Paris into a bloodthirsty mob. Of course, the same methods they employ ultimately rebound upon them, for once Robespierre has been deposed and silenced, any vestiges of him are eradicated by the very same citizens who had been working his will against his enemies. The wreckage that D’Aubigny must struggle through at the ruined bakery before he manages to rescue Madeleine is a clear indication of the fickle and turbulent emotions of the mob, as is the revelry and laughter with which they react to Robespierre’s execution. The citizens’ collective behavior begs the question of why anyone would ever want to lead such a rabble and whether the sacrifices and dangers endured by Charles and Madeleine have been worth anything at all. A concluding scene suggests these disturbing possibilities by reaffirming that, despite everything that has happened, the cynics are still in control and history will inevitably provide France with a dictator in spite of Robespierre’s removal. Foche, the rascal and diplomat who always survives any change in
3. Mann and Film Noir
89
regime, engages in a casual conversation with a soldier in the teeming streets of the city as the mob dances and sings patriotic songs. In the course of their discussion, the military man, who is consistently shot with his back to the camera, reveals himself to be Napoleon Bonaparte after Foche has belatedly asked for his name. This larger irony is followed by a brief concluding shot of Charles and Madeleine ascending a staircase with their arms about each other as they, presumably, go off into a romantic future. However, what that future can be, given their signal failure to alter the basic modus operandus of France’s political world, must remain as cloudy as the rising smoke that swirls up from the various bonfires lighting Paris. If the protagonist has managed to stop one would-be despot, he has clearly not stopped his country’s headlong descent into ever-graver political and military problems. The closing credit, with its background once more of raging flames, announces “The End of the Reign of Terror”; however, this very set-up hardly indicates that any happy restoration of normalcy has occurred. Mann would ultimately explore many of these problems in his major epic films, and he would find more thematically provocative answers to the dilemmas posed by the end of The Black Book in those works. His initial entry into epic and historical filmmaking, however arresting as an example of the director’s increasing artistry and thematic sophistication, does not finally succeed because of the austerities of its budget and, perhaps even more tellingly, the weakness of its leading man. Robert Cummings as D’Aubigny fails to convince because we never sense any depth of feeling in what he does or how he reacts. In his initial meeting with Madeleine, the actor is too smug and cynical in recounting their stormy romantic past and his great disappointment and desperation after she deserted him. While some of his difficulties must, of course, be attributed to the script, Cummings is simply not capable of making us believe that he embodies such repressed emotional depths. Mann would use the same background situation with the protagonist of The Naked Spur and the very skill of James Stewart makes Howie Kemp’s pent-up nature agonizingly believable. Mann and The Black Book would have been better served if Cummings and Richard Basehart had exchanged roles, for we could much more easily attribute emotional depths to the latter performer and lust for power to the former.
Mann as Screenwriter: Follow Me Quietly (1949) Mann and Francis Rosenwald are credited with the story idea for this film which uses police procedures and a psychopathic killer to produce a
90
Anthony Mann
taut and tight (59-minute running time) second feature. While it is possible that Mann himself may have briefly worked on its actual shooting, Follow Me Quietly emerges as a highly competent B feature from director Richard Fleischer, who would go on to an interesting career in both film noir (The Narrow Margin [1952]) and epic (The Vikings [1958] and Barabbas [1962]). The finished movie clearly embodies plot situations, themes, and stylistic techniques which have evolved throughout Mann’s work in film noir. The protagonist, Grant (William Lundigan), a dedicated police officer, embodies the same kind of professional determination one associates with comparable characters in Railroaded, T-Men, and Border Incident. Like Mickey Ferguson, Dennis O’Brien, and Pablo Rodriguez, Grant must catch the mysterious “Judge” who has strangled seven victims after we see him dispatch the newspaper editor McGill (Frank Ferguson) early in the film. At the same time, Grant resembles Marty Brennan of He Walked by Night when he speaks of suffering from insomnia brought on by his inability to apprehend the criminal and then offers that he would forfeit “a year’s pay” just to see the face of the “Judge.” Like Brennan, Grant has internalized the case; and, in a bit of similar plotting, he is confronted by his superior Mulvane (Charles D. Brown) who asks whether he shouldn’t be taken off the case. The police procedural elements of Follow Me Quietly focus symbolically on Grant’s brainstorm about making a dummy that resembles the unknown killer in every particular, except that its face is left deliberately blank. This object is then shown to Grant’s fellow officers who, apparently, cannot visualize the physical dimensions of the murderer they are seeking. While this plot device comes perilously close to straining the audience’s “suspension of disbelief,” at the end of this sequence the dummy is spun around to reveal its facelessness and a police spokeman shouts “I kill!” What ultimately saves such hamfisted moments, of course, is the very speed with which everything happens in Follow Me Quietly: The pace is so rapid that one hardly has time to notice such histrionic excesses. In a later sequence, Grant is complaining to himself in what he believes is an empty office. He wanders into an adjoining room in which the dummy seemingly rests in a chair facing out a window, and Grant continues with his various ruminations as rain lashes against the glass. The protagonist is then interrupted by his assistant, Collins (Jeff Corey), who, after eavesdropping for a moment, says “You’re getting more like the ‘Judge’ every day.” This innocuous remark implies the kind of symbiotic relationships between heroes and villains that will emerge so strongly in Mann’s westerns. As the two police officers leave, the camera tracks back into the abandoned room and a figure rises out of the chair, puts the real dummy back there, and goes off into the night. This shocking kind of reversal is a tactic
3. Mann and Film Noir
91
we have seen repeatedly in Mann’s noir films, and here it is used to suggest several thematic points. Like the astute loner-criminal mastermind Morgan in He Walked by Night, the “Judge” has penetrated the world of the police; at the same time, his recklessness suggests a subconscious desire to be caught and the stormy setting has served to once again trigger his killing instincts. The climactic struggle between Grant and the “Judge” occurs atop various storage tanks, and it features the kind of location shooting and tense close-ups so prominent in Desperate, T-Men, and Border Incident. Their protracted struggle on a scaffold finds Grant suffering in a style that reminds us of the agonies endured by Mann’s protagonists in these films; indeed, it is only a final fortuitous push that enables Fleischer’s hero to throw the villain to his death and bring Follow Me Quietly to its expected conclusion. Struggling in high places and falling precipitously to one’s death will become veritable stylistic markers in Mann’s westerns and epics. Follow Me Quietly does, alas, feature a nagging reporter, Ann (Dorothy Patrick), who emerges as the protagonist’s inevitable love interest, and an obvious red herring in the owner of the bar-restaurant in which Grant and his colleagues consistently meet to drink and discuss the case. This figure is played by veteran Hollywood character actor Nestor Paiva, who was nearly always cast as a shady or villainous figure. Here he is simply functioning as comic relief as his continuous poring over daily racing forms serves to punctuate his serving customers, relaying various bits of information, and smiling briefly at Grant and Ann in the last scene fadeout. The opening credit sequence for Follow Me Quietly is much more arresting with its tracking shot of rain pouring on a sidewalk with the pacing feet of a woman to foreshadow the film’s major plot directions: The rain is the trigger which sets off the mad “Judge” and Ann will have to chase her story throughout the rest of the action. The killer’s megalomania about rain is reinforced during his descent from the storage tower with Grant. While the “Judge” has meekly surrendered when confronted by the police officer, a dripping pipe causes him to revert to his frenzied ways and assault, and all but overpower, the protagonist. His combination of madness and guilt is also reinforced when another sorry specimen comes forward to confess to being the “Judge.” Fortunately, the police quickly see through this imitation killer (Douglas Spencer) and, in doing so, show their professional capabilities. In two bits of serendipitous casting, Grant’s superior is played by the same actor who was Mickey Ferguson’s boss in Railroaded, and the “Judge” is portrayed by an actor (Edwin Max) who would play a duplicitous and eventually murdered bartender in Side Street.
4
Mann and the Western Anthony Mann’s stature as an American filmmaker rests most solidly on his accomplishments as a director of westerns. While John Ford, Raoul Walsh, and Howard Hawks created films in this genre over several decades, Mann produced ten exemplary efforts in a nine-year span (1950–1958). Unlike such contemporary and efficient directors as Robert Aldrich, Delmer Daves, and Budd Boetticher, Mann fundamentally altered the emotional nature of the standard western protagonist to provide a uniquely tragic atmosphere to the genre. The costs of preserving and protecting civilization, heroism through violence, and seeking revenge to right a damaged personal past are clearly laid out in the director’s westerns. These films portray a world in which every choice has a concomitant cost and characters must choose what is better instead of indulging the luxury of choosing what is best. The literary and social sources of the Hollywood western have long been understood and appreciated. James Fenimore Cooper’s Leatherstocking saga (1823–1841) is often cited for providing the origin of the western because of its portrayal of Natty Bumppo, the first highly independent and morally consistent loner who, ultimately, dies protecting the fledgling civilization which finally forces him out. Owen Wister’s The Virginian (1902) is also widely regarded as the first serious novel set within the time frame that movie westerns would immortalize. This novel clearly embodies the theme of clashing cultures as its more refined and formally educated Eastern-born and -bred heroine gradually comes to appreciate the virtues of its simpler, honest and moral Western-born and -bred hero. Western films also draw on the traditions and stereotypes set forth in innumerable dime novels that glorified such figures as Wild Bill Hickok, Jesse James, Wyatt Earp, and Billy the Kid. In such romances, uncomplicated heroes and villains enacted “horse operas” in which the good characters always triumphed over the evil ones. In addition, Buffalo Bill Cody’s Wild West Show brought many of these same character types and situations to audiences worldwide, so that such spectacles as trick riding and lone stagecoaches fighting off pursuing Indians became veritable clichés very early in 92
4. Mann and the Western
93
the twentieth century. Frederick Jackson Turner’s celebrated historical essay on the closing of the frontier (1893) added another feature to the mix with its implicit message of the passing of a way of life. Filmmakers would utilize all these elements to cast a nostalgic haze over and impart an often bitter sense of loss to many a western. Against a basic structure of the chivalrous hero who, like the knight errant of medieval legend, must rid the world of evil, novelists and screenwriters developed a number of standardized western plots. One of the most familiar is the revenge story in which the protagonist must seek redress for the murder of a family member. Typically, Ringo (John Wayne) seeks revenge for his massacred family in John Ford’s Stagecoach (1939), and Matt Morgan (Kirk Douglas) must avenge the rape and murder of his Indian wife in John Sturges’s Last Train from Gun Hill (1959). The cavalry western frequently combines conflicts between officers and subordinates with the need for training raw recruits against a background of threats from various “hostiles.” In addition, such plots often fictionalize historical events or offer symbolic commentaries on the course of American history. Thus, one finds General Custer and the battle of the Little Big Horn celebrated in Raoul Walsh’s They Died with Their Boots On (1941) and Union and Confederate enemies being united in the face of greater dangers in Robert Wise’s Two Flags West (1950). Town taming also looms large in the pantheon of western plots; indeed, this necessity arises from the fact that there is “no law west of ...” as well as from the inability of ordinary citizens to organize any resistance to the criminal forces in their midst. Frequently, however, such scenarios also emphasize the initial reluctance of the hero to get involved in “other people’s business.” At other times the protagonist is a beleaguered lawman whose devotion to “doing things legal” conflicts with the avariciousness and fears of those he has been hired to protect, and this motif always underscores the singular courage with which the chivalrous hero must “do what a man’s got to do.” We see Wade Hatton (Errol Flynn) take up the marshal’s duties only after a child has been killed because of rampant lawlessness in Michael Curtiz’s Dodge City (1939); Virgil Earp (Sam Elliott) shames his brothers into joining him as lawmen in George P. Cosmatos’s Tombstone (1993). The darker aspects of such plots are best exemplified by the struggles of Will Kane (Gary Cooper) in Fred Zinnemann’s High Noon (1952) and John T. Chance in Howard Hawks’s Rio Bravo (1959). The former figure quits after the entire Miller gang has been killed, a decision symbolized by his dropping his marshal’s badge in the dust and riding off with his Quaker bride (Grace Kelly): the latter lawman builds a team of “professionals” who defeat the superior numbers of the villains through skill and courage.
94
Anthony Mann
Range wars and cattle drives have also been frequently exploited as subjects for westerns. Such plots center on rivalries between ranchers, quarrels between land barons and newcomers who threaten the open range, or the personal and natural obstacles involved in getting a herd to a railhead town. We see battling patriarchs in William Wyler’s The Big Country (1958) and embattled farmers pressed by a ruthless cattle owner in George Stevens’s Shane (1953). Jim McKay (Gregory Peck) resolves the crisis in the first film by getting Rufus Hennessey (Burl Ives) and Major Terrill (Charles Bickford) to kill each other, thus bringing about peace. The conflict in Stevens’s film is resolved when Shane (Alan Ladd) uses his expertise as a gunfighter to destroy Wilson (Jack Palance) and his heinous employer (Emile Meyer) in a conventional and therapeutic shootout. Family and individual tensions are resolved in Howard Hawks’s Red River (1948) as Tom Dunson (John Wayne) and his adopted son Matthew Garth (Montgomery Clift) battle deserters, stampedes, Indians, and each other. Classic westerns generally take place within fairly narrow limits of time and place. For the most part, they occur in a period that begins just slightly before the Civil War and which ends around 1890, with Custer’s massacre at the Little Big Horn in 1876 being a frequent chronological marker. They are also usually set west of the Mississippi River in an area that stretches from Texas to Oregon. Within the canon of western films there are, of course, notable exceptions to these limits: John Wayne’s The Alamo(1960) and Howard Hawks’s The Big Sky (1952) are set in the 1820s and 1830s, while Martin Ritt’s Hud (1963) and Abraham Polansky’s Tell Them Willie Boy is Here (1969) occur well within the twentieth century. Ray Enright’s version of The Spoilers (1942) and Robert Aldrich’s Vera Cruz (1954) take place in the Yukon and Mexico. If the temporal and geographical limits of westerns can be somewhat flexible, their characters fall into much more consistent types and groups. In addition to cavalrymen, marshals, and ranchers, we see individual outlaws and outlaw gangs in Henry King’s Jesse James (1939) and Sam Peckinpah’s The Wild Bunch (1969). The former film offers a sanitized version of the famed outlaw’s life by presenting his life of crime as a protest against a railroad’s cruel minions; the latter work presents a more disturbing portrayal of the supposed loyalties that even killers feel toward each other as Pike Bishop (William Holden) and his men die gloriously fighting against a cynical and savage Mexican despot. The sidekick, usually an older male companion, is another standard type and often such figures are murdered by the villains to force the hero into openly confronting them. This pattern can be seen all the way from King Vidor’s The Texas Rangers (1936), in which the nefarious villain (Lloyd
4. Mann and the Western
95
Nolan) kills the comic sidekick (Jack Oakie) and so provokes the fury of the hero (Fred MacMurray), to Clint Eastwood’s Unforgiven (1992) in which another bad guy (Gene Hackman) kills another sidekick (Morgan Freeman) to bring the wrath of the protagonist (Eastwood) down upon him and his companions. The citizenry in westerns is often cowardly and nearly always equivocal; they may give lip service to law and order, but they are incapable of supporting its representatives or repelled by the violence that must be invoked to bring about peace. One needs only to think of the timid townspeople in Vincent McEveety’s Firecreek (1967) or the hostile storekeepers of Edward Dmytrky’s Warlock(1959) to appreciate the ignobility of the “people.” Such consistency is also found among the many gambler-gunfighters who populate westerns. At their best, such figures support the establishment by siding with the sheriff (the many portrayals of Doc Holliday), while at their worst they simply connive for their own ends (Jeff Goldblum in Lawrence Kasdan’s Silverado [1985]). The Native Americans present greater character variations, for while they are frequently presented as simply a hostile mass or terrifying sadists, they can also assume noble stature and even become worthy of love and respect. One film that captures many of these attributes is John Farrow’s Hondo (1953) in which the Apache chieftain Vittorio (Michael Pate) stands in sharp contrast to his barbaric subordinate Silvio (Rodolfo Acosta). Thus, Vittorio frees Hondo (John Wayne) when he, Vittorio, comes to believe that the cavalry scout is the father of Angie Lowe’s (Geraldine Page) son, while Silvio kills the protagonist’s dog simply out of spite. Neither of these characters is, however, remotely close to the idealistic portrait of Cochise (Jeff Chandler) in Delmer Daves’s celebrated Broken Arrow (1950) which consciously sets out to revise the typical silent and savage stereotypes of earlier westerns. Closely associated with such figures, we find the cavalry scout who is an expert not only in the native languages and mores but also capable of seeking out trails and possible ambushes. Such lone wolf figures can be viciously independent (Robert Duvall in Walter Hill’s Geronimo: An American Legend [1994], Charlton Heston in Charles Marquis Warren’s Arrowhead [1953]) or simply attached to the army life (James Coburn as Samuel Potts in Sam Peckinpah’s Major Dundee [1965], Ben Johnson as Sergeant Tyree in John Ford’s She Wore a Yellow Ribbon [1949]). Westerns also typically feature only two kinds of women—good girls and bad girls—in major roles. Older female characters are nearly always subdued, content with aging as hotel keepers or faithful wives, or used as comic confidantes or foils. Often the major female leads work themselves into a love
96
Anthony Mann
triangle with the hero and, invariably, one of them wins his affection at the fadeout. George Marshall’s Destry Rides Again (1939) provides us with a good girl in Janice Tyndall (Irene Hervey) who understands Eastern fashions and being ladylike; a bad girl in Frenchy (Marlene Dietrich) who consorts with the villain (Brian Donlevy) but then gives up her worldly cynicism when she meets the protagonist (James Stewart); and a comic wife in Lily Belle Callahan (Una Merkel) who tyrannizes her second husband Boris Stavrogin (Mischa Auer) and gets into a humiliating saloon brawl with Frenchy. Westerns are also characterized by repeated settings and symbols. The town not only embodies the citizenry who can be alternately cowardly, heinous, or hypocritical, but also features certain standard buildings that are endemic to the genre. Thus, we find the general store, the hotel, the livery stable and, perhaps most importantly, the saloon in nearly every western; and, while each of these locations can be used in presenting the plot, the last structure is the most frequently utilized. The typical western saloon nearly always houses the bad guys, who either own the establishment or frequent it; and when the hero goes into this location there is almost always some kind of confrontation, whether a gunfight, a fistfight, or merely a stare down. Other physical locations that abound in westerns are mining camps (Clint Eastwood’s Pale Rider [1985]), hideouts in which outlaws evade their pursuers (Nicholas Ray’s Johnny Guitar[1954]), ranches that approach imperial stature (King Vidor’s Duel in the Sun [1946]), and forts that must withstand various redskin menaces (John Ford’s Fort Apache [1948]). The horizon is another physical feature that is often invoked as a framing device and, more obviously, as a spectacular backdrop for beautifully choreographed columns of horses and riders, perhaps never more brilliantly than in John Ford’s The Searchers (1956). All of these elements conjoin in the best westerns to support the virtues and themes that most distinctly distinguish the genre. Children are nearly always revered as the embodiments of the future, and they are consciously taught by their elders how to act when they become adults; indeed, the passage to maturity is central to a film like Don Siegel’s The Shootist (1976) in which the wayward Gillom Rogers (Ron Howard) takes the moral path in life because of the words and actions of the dying gunman John Bernard Books (John Wayne). Individual responsibility and a refusal to become a victim of larger forces are also themes that permeate many westerns, in part because of the needs for respect, identity, and, perhaps in even larger measure, because each man must be able to defend himself and those he loves on a frontier where there is little or no law. The struggle to establish a viable civilization in the wilderness is embod-
4. Mann and the Western
97
ied in the conflict between the lawman and the outlaw, with the former bringing about the peace and security needed to create long-lasting conditions that will protect women and children. Indeed, for much of its history the western has glorified the triumph of middle-class morality at the expense of the ethical chaos bred by greed and criminality. On the flip side, we see numerous glamorous portraits of famous bad men who are shown as either misunderstood or fighting against unjust forces themselves. It is the sheer individualism of gunmen, both good and bad, that comes through in this struggle, for only the faster draw can ultimately win. Significant, though, is the frequency with which westerns focus on the importance of death. While many villains (and countless extras) die with little or no fanfare (except for expert stuntwork), many of the more serious deaths in westerns lead either to formal funeral scenes or to prolonged dying sequences in which virtually the whole community participates. Another frequent theme in the western is that romantic love offers salvation for the hero by supplying him with a refuge from the world of gunplay in which he is immersed. At times, such emotions can extend to an entire community as we see at the end of Russell Rouse’s The Fastest Gun Alive (1956) when the whole town goes along with the fictitious death of George Temple (Glenn Ford) so that he will no longer have to exercise his gun prowess and can simply live out his life with wife Dora (Jeanne Crain). In many other instances a long struggle brings the lovers together as in Budd Boetticher’s The Tall T (1957) in which Pat Brennan (Randolph Scott) and Doretta Mims (Maureen O’Sullivan) walk off together as a result of having bested the outlaws who kidnapped them. The better woman will also emerge after the hero casts off his first choice, who proves either mercenary or self-centered as in Rudolph Mate’s The Violent Men (1955) in which John Parrish (Glenn Ford) is rejected by Caroline Vail (May Wynn) because he chooses to defend his property against Lew (Edward G. Robinson) and Cole Wilkerson (Brian Keith). Parrish’s choice leads to a range war in which he comes to win the affection of Judith Wilkerson (Dianne Foster) by virtue of rescuing her father and destroying her uncle and her perfidious mother (Barbara Stanwyck). In his ten westerns, Anthony Mann employed plots, characters, settings, and themes that would be familiar to fans of the genre. At the same time he used these forms to carve out his own particular take on the western in order to push the genre in relatively new directions. At first, he brought some of the concerns and atmospherics of film noir to the western, but, as time went on, his more personal and psychological interests came to the forefront. Like the genre’s other great directors, Mann would ultimately use the western to convey profound themes about the human condition, and his ideas would
98
Anthony Mann
be powerfully implemented by the characteristic physical and intellectual features that attached to the genre.
Out for Revenge: Winchester ’73 (1950) and The Man from Laramie (1955) Mann’s protagonists in Winchester ’731 and The Man from Laramie are out to avenge the death of a close family member. Lin McAdam (James Stewart) seeks the killer of his father—his older brother Matthew (Stephen McNally)—in the first film; and Will Lockhart (Stewart once more) searches for the man who sold repeating rifles to the Apaches and caused a massacre in which his younger brother was killed in the second. McAdam’s quest brings him initially to Dodge City in Winchester ’73 only after he has been pursuing Matthew (a.k.a. Dutch Henry Brown) for a very long time. Lockhart has deliberately taken a leave of absence from his military duties to pass himself off as a freight hauler and go to Coronado, where he believes he can discover the villain in The Man from Laramie. McAdam and Lockhart are not nearly as alienated as other Mann western heroes; indeed, in both cases they have something to which they can return—a place or an institution that gives them a sense of belonging to a community. Thus, at the end of the earlier film Lin will seemingly return to his ranch with both his best friend, “High Spade” Frankie Wilson (Millard Mitchell), and his newly discovered love, Lola (Shelley Winters), in tow. Captain Lockhart can calmly ride back to Fort Laramie after suggesting that he will welcome Barbara Waggoman (Cathy O’Donnell) should she ever be passing through. In both works the protagonists feel no need to settle into the places where the action has taken place. Indians figure prominently in both Winchester ’73 and The Man from Laramie as veritable aliens who are feared but only occasionally respected. The gunrunner Joe Lamont (John McIntire) quickly establishes his racial identity (“I’m white!”) with Dutch Henry and his cohorts (James Millican and Steve Brodie) in the cantina in Winchester ’73. After he has won the famous rifle from Brown, Lamont goes to a rendezvous with the renegade Young Bull (Rock Hudson) and is killed so that the Sioux chief can possess the magic weapon. Later, Dutch Henry shoots the dead Lamont, whose corpse has been propped up by a campfire, in order to regain the rifle. When the outlaw then goes to inspect his handiwork, he quickly sees that the trader is dead and wonders aloud, “Why do they always scalp?” We next see Young Bull and his braves in pursuit of Steve Miller (Charles Drake) and his fiancée, Lola, who are driving to the home they will share after they have married. The furious chase sequence climaxes when Steve deserts
4. Mann and the Western
99
Lola to seek help elsewhere—an act of cowardice that is only slightly redeemed by his finding the encamped soldiers, returning to the girl, and guiding their buckboard down into the ravine where the troopers are encamped. Unfortunately for the frightened Steve, Sergeant Wilkes (Jay C. Flippen) points out that he and his raw recruits are pinned down by Young Bull’s forces. Only the subsequent appearance of Lin and High Spade, who are also fleeing from the Indians, saves the situation, for they bring the knowledge and the additional firepower which defeats the savages on the ensuing morning. Lin wisely counsels Sergeant Wilkes on the ways of the Sioux by pointing out that they will not fight at night, and then he sets the method by which the Indians’ morning assault can be defeated. His mastery of tactics and his ability to kill Young Bull (and so drive the “hostiles” away) establishes McAdam’s prowess as an Indian fighter. The Indian presence in The Man from Laramie is more continuous but less accentuated. When Lockhart initially arrives in Coronado and finds Barbara Waggoman’s general store, he is greeted by a taciturn Apache assistant (Frank Darrow) who is presented at first as a hand on a railing. Lockhart asks the hired man about a repeating rifle for sale that hangs on a wall; and, when he is told that a brave brought it in the previous spring as trade goods, the protagonist becomes even more convinced that he has come to the right place to find his brother’s killer. The surly assistant, whom Lockhart orders to help with unloading his wagons, is extremely suspicious; later on, we see him at the edges of the action when the protagonist fights Chris Boldt (Jack Elam) in the street. The Apache’s involvement with the death of Boldt, a crime for which Lockhart is arrested, remains mysterious as we watch him disappear after the sheriff, Tom Quimby (James Millican), orders the hero to jail. In the climax of The Man from Laramie the erstwhile shop assistant emerges as the leader of the Apaches who have come for their rifles after Vic Hansbro (Arthur Kennedy) has signaled them from the high ridge on which he and Dave Waggoman (Alex Nicol) have hidden the weapons. When Lockhart intervenes and forces Vic to help him push the wagon load of rifles and ammunition off the ridge—an action that leads to the vehicle’s exploding— the Apaches retreat back down the inclined trail and wait for Vic to ride down. Their leader shoots Hansbro off his horse and, as the villain writhes in agony symbolically clutching at the ground of the Barb Ranch which he will never possess, another brave finishes off the gunrunner with an arrow in his back. Both Winchester ’73 and The Man from Laramie feature paired villains who represent different levels and types of malevolence. Dutch Henry, the
100
Anthony Mann
Barbara Waggoman (Cathy O’Donnell), Vic Hansbro (Arthur Kennedy), and Will Lockhart (James Stewart) meet at a nighttime church social in The Man from Laramie (Columbia, 1955). Once again, the female lead must abandon the charming bad man for the more solid protagonist in order to grow up.
smart though surly leader of the outlaws in the first film, is always quick to exert himself physically and to threaten anyone who balks at anything he wants to do. Characteristically, he offers to smack Lola when she stays too long at a table with him and Waco Johnnie Dean (Dan Duryea) and is shown wrestling the title weapon off both Lin and his criminal partner. His skill for planning is shown in the methodical way in which he explains the scheme he has concocted for the stage robbery in Tascosa. Indeed, this efficient design will eventually metamorphose into the delusionary schemes of Dock Tobin (Lee J. Cobb) in Man of the West. Waco is a more interesting and more arresting character, albeit one who can be as mean and deadly as the wayward McAdam brother. He combines a cynical laugh with a great capacity for sadism as we see on his initial entry at the ranch to which Steve and Lola have come. Even though the outlaw has brought a pursuing posse to this location, and he and his men are under
4. Mann and the Western
101
pretty constant fire, Waco wants the Winchester which has come into Steve’s possession. Because he cannot persuade Miller to sell the weapon, Waco decides to humiliate Steve in front of Lola while, simultaneously, supervising his cohorts as they battle the posse. Waco finally so provokes Steve that the latter foolishly tries to outdraw him and is killed. Dave Waggoman offers a much starker portrait of villainy in The Man from Laramie, for he is a bully who must use the men behind him to enforce his will. At the salt flats where Lockhart and his wagoners have gone to harvest what they believe is a free product, Dave barges in, burns the protagonist’s wagons, shoots his mules, and then orders the hero dragged into submission by the cowhands who accompany him. Dave later relies on these same hired hands in his gunfight with Lockhart. After being wounded in the hand, the younger Waggoman orders his men to hold the protagonist still so he can shoot Lockhart’s pistol hand. However, this bit of psychic revenge, which breeds repulsion even among those who ride with him, is not enough to satisfy Dave, who then rides to the ridge where the rifles are hidden and proceeds to signal the Apaches to come and get them. When his partner in crime, Vic, shows up and tries to dissuade him, Dave remains impervious to the harm that the Apaches on the warpath will bring to everyone in the region; thus, his own ego overrides any rationality he may possess. Vic Hansbro, on the other hand, is the most charming of these four villains, even if he does kill young Dave and almost succeeds in murdering the patriarch of the Barb, Alec Waggoman (Donald Crisp); in both cases the ranch foreman shows some regret for what he does, but his own ambitions quickly override such moments of remorse. Initially, Vic operates as a protective older brother for the headstrong Dave by stopping the assault on Lockhart’s wagons at the salt flats and then later, in town, taking on the burden of fighting the protagonist, who has been delivering a thrashing to the younger Waggoman. When Lockhart subsequently shows up at the Barb to collect damages for his destroyed property, Hansbro cheerfully greets him and amicably agrees that their earlier fight should be considered a draw. Each of these films also features a sidekick. High Spade accompanies Lin to the end of his quest and, along the way, fights beside him most efficiently during Young Bull’s attack. Morever, Frankie Wilson also functions as a voice of conscience and warning to Lin. Before the finale in Tascosa, as he and McAdam sit around a campfire, High Spade admonishes the protagonist that, “Hunting a man to kill him ... you’re starting to like it.” In return, after defending himself by urging essentially that a man’s got to do what a man’s got to do, Lin compliments his saddlemate by reflecting that his father once told him that if a man had one friend he was rich, and “I’m rich.” Charlie O’Leary (Wallace Ford) becomes Lockhart’s sidekick in The Man
102
Anthony Mann
from Laramie when he offers to help the protagonist discover who has armed the Apaches. Charlie has grown to admire Will because of their time together on the trail and, even though he warns that “hate” ill becomes a man like Lockhart, he attaches himself to the hero because “I’m a lonely man.” The bonding scene between them resembles the earlier one in Winchester ’73. Charlie does not accompany Lockhart continuously; indeed, the older man offers to go among his Apache relatives to find out what he can about the shipment of rifles. His abrupt return shortly afterward helps to unravel the mystery because he brings news of the impending delivery and the aggressiveness of the Apaches. Charlie then helps Will track the wagon that originally brought in the rifles and assists in the rescue of the fallen Alec Waggoman. A startling feature in both Winchester ’73 and The Man from Laramie is the frequent loss of control exhibited by Mann’s protagonists. While most commentators note that the good guy possesses some of the same capacity for violence as the bad guy, it is the depth of the rage we see in Lin McAdam and Will Lockhart which is unsettling. We see this capacity in Lin in the saloon in Dodge City where he spies his reprobate sibling and they both attempt to draw pistols that they do not have since Wyatt Earp (Will Geer) has disarmed everyone in town except himself and his brothers. An even more disturbing scene finds the protagonist confronting Waco Johnnie Dean in another saloon in Tascosa and, after asking for information about Dutch Henry Brown, jumping furiously into action by twisting the outlaw’s left arm behind his back and pushing his face down and into the bar top. As he does so, McAdam’s facial expression alternates between grim determination and a kind of jubilant hysteria brought on by a release of his emotions. Taking action against this enemy releases some of the tension which Lin has been carrying throughout the film. Lockhart does not live nearly as close to the emotional edge as Lin McAdam. However, he exhibits determination and emotional release when he fights Dave and Vic in the town square and the cattle pen of Coronado; indeed, he appears almost gleeful when Hansbro interrupts his pummeling of Dave and he can attack the other man. While he exhibits a steely exterior most of the time, Lockhart’s reaction to being shot in the hand by Dave runs a gamut from crying out in pain to cursing his cowardly assailant (“You scum!”). In the finale with Vic on the ridge we see Lockhart initially determined and then given over to a strained effort to push the wagon load of rifles over the side, and these reactions perfectly match his emotional changes in this sequence. While he only wanted to execute Hansbro at first, Lockhart quickly realizes that more is at stake than his own need for revenge and that he must prevent the rifles from falling into the hands of the Apaches.
4. Mann and the Western
103
Both films have their climaxes in similar locations, and these high places in which the villains are seemingly dominant can only be reached by the heroes after they have struggled to ascend them. McAdam pursues his wayward sibling to a ridge that is behind the outlaws’ cabin in which Dutch Henry and Waco planned the Tascosa robbery. In a lengthy rifle battle between the brothers—one that is replete with each one verbally taunting the other—Lin climbs to the top despite being pinned down momentarily by his brother’s skillful shooting. On the crest they continue the verbal sparring until Matthew/Dutch Henry runs lows on cartridges, rises up to get a better shot at Lin, is shot instead by the protagonist, and plunges from the ridge. The same falling pattern attends Lockhart’s final confrontation with Vic in The Man from Laramie, only this time the wagon of rifles goes over the side and explodes. The frantic effort of Hansbro and Lockhart to push it over the edge sees them struggling against the imminent arrival of the Apaches and their own physical weaknesses—the protagonist’s bandaged right hand and Hansbro’s ineptness in guiding the wagon. When their ordeal is over, Lockhart reverses his earlier pronouncement about wanting to kill Hansbro and motions for the villain to get out of his sight. In this way Will overcomes his own need for revenge and so establishes a leading thematic difference between these two films. Lin McAdam’s quest for vengeance in Winchester ’73 is fulfilled with the death of Matthew/Dutch Henry, however, this search has cost several lives and the protagonist appears totally spent because of the ordeal he has undergone. Lin virtually clings to Lola in a desperate effort to gain some solace for what he has had to do. Lockhart’s rejection of revenge segues into his final scene with Kate Canaday (Aline MacMahon), who has captured the man of her dreams in the blinded Alec Waggoman, and Barbara Waggoman, who appears to want to fall in love with him. The protagonist’s gentle farewell, with its note about nearly everyone in Laramie knowing Captain Lockhart should she pass through that town, clearly constitutes a much calmer and more romantic finale. Because he has managed to transcend his own emotions, Lockhart has created a much more stable world and a more pleasant future for himself. Winchester ’73 gets off to a rousing start in Dodge City with the shooting contest between the estranged McAdam brothers for possession of the perfect rifle; however, before that memorable and extended sequence, a much more defining moment occurs in the saloon to which Lin must go to sign up for the contest. In addition to the psychologically revealing empty-holsterdrawing on each other, the protagonist and Dutch Henry spar in other ways. After witnessing their “showdown” Wyatt Earp warns both of them that they must take their personal trouble out of his town; however, as he admonishes
104
Anthony Mann
From left: James Stewart, Shelley Winters, an unidentified crew member and Anthony Mann (far right) on the set of Winchester ’73 (Universal, 1950). Mann’s commercially successful western leads to seven more films with Stewart. Together they create a hard bitten and neurotic persona for the actor and produce some of the most memorable westerns ever made.
Lin, Dutch Henry orders a glass of milk for his brother-antagonist. In doing so, and in later relieving his sibling of the prized rifle, the villain introduces the notion of violence as emasculating—an association that Mann manipulates throughout the movie. Waco Johnnie Dean’s arrival and gun battle with the posse at Steve and Lola’s ranch also features the same pattern of humiliation as the outlaw goads the cowardly Miller into drawing on him. Waco orders Steve to make some coffee, even though Lola offers to do so, and then chides the other man about needing to wear an apron. When Steve brings the coffee to him, Waco trips him up and Miller falls across the table and into the camera, a stylistic feature that we have seen in many of Mann’s noir films. In killing Steve, Waco naturally gains control of the talismanic weapon, and he proceeds to get away with it and Lola by sacrificing the men who are with him. As they run out of
4. Mann and the Western
105
the now-burning house onto its front porch and die in a hail of the posse’s bullets, Waco takes the heroine out through a side window. In the sequence in which Young Bull is killed and his band of warriors driven off by the soldiers, Lin, and High Spade, Mann introduces two themes in Winchester ’73. On the night before the battle, Lola speaks to Lin about her dream of owning her own home; and, while she imagines that she will have such a place with Steve, as we have seen, Waco Johnnie Dean insures that that prospect will not work out. At another level, of course, the film foreshadows its conclusion when Lin will take Lola with him back to the ranch that he and his father worked, so they can start a new life. After the defeat of the Sioux as they are preparing to leave, Lin and High Spade get into a brief conversation with Sergeant Wilkes who wishes that they had been with him at the battle of Bull Run. When our heroes respond that they were there, but on the other side, all three men laugh as a way of symbolically reconciling the greater struggle that the nation has endured; now, in 1876, these former enemies can unite against a common foe without feeling any bitterness that the Civil War bred. Mann’s film also incorporates some obvious symbolic objects and devices, most notably the weapon which gets passed from Lin to Dutch Henry, to Lamont, to Young Bull, to Steve Miller, to Waco Johnnie Dean, back to Dutch Henry, and then back to its “rightful” owner, the protagonist. Nearly every character who sees the Winchester wants to possess it, and frantic physical struggles—between Lin and Dutch Henry, between Waco and Steve, and, finally, between Waco and Dutch Henry—often lead to its being taken away from a current owner. The opening credits culminate in a title card explaining the nature of the rifle against the background of the actual weapon which starts the real action, and a tracking shot to a close-up of the gun finishes the last scene of Winchester ’73 after Lin has returned and embraced Lola. His emerging love for the songstress-piano player initially appears before the morning battle with the Sioux. In a very suggestive bit of business, Lin gives Lola a pistol so she can defend herself, and she smilingly notes that she understands “about the last [bullet]” being meant for her should the white men be overcome. What is obvious here is that Lin must see to her welfare even though Lola is still formally engaged to Steve, who once again proves unequal to the task of protecting his woman. After the Indian attack has been rebuffed, Lola returns the pistol to Lin but asks if she can keep the last bullet as a memento, a request the amused Lin immediately grants. Later, in the outlaws’ cabin to which Waco has brought her following their escape from the burning ranch, we see the girl affectionately fingering the bullet as a reminder of the man she unconsciously loves. This connec-
106
Anthony Mann
tion is underlined when Lola discovers a picture of Lin and Dutch Henry with their father, an act that quickly elicits a violent response from the dour Matthew. On the porch of the shack, as Dutch Henry prepares to ride off to waylay the stagecoach he plans to rob, we see Lola again playing with the bullet, and then telling the outlaw that she knows the “other man” in the picture. The villain looks at the cartridge in Lola’s hand and adds that the man in the photo has been trying for years “to get one of those into me.” The girl only comes to understand this remark when High Spade explains Lin’s quest to her in Tascosa after she has been wounded rescuing a child and the protagonist has ridden off to finish his wayward brother. Winchester ’73 is the most episodic of all Mann’s westerns in that it moves from place to place and incorporates various generic elements. The quests of the hero—to regain the rifle he won in Dodge City and to kill the individual who took it from him and killed their father—give the film its plot spine; however, characters appear for discrete episodes—the trader Lamont and the cantina owner Riker (John Alexander), Young Bull, Sergeant Wilkes and recruits (two of whom are played by Tony Curtis and James Best), Wyatt Earp and his entourage—and then are simply not seen again. In this way Mann dramatizes the journey motif of the screenplay; presumably, Lin McAdam, like Homer’s Odysseus, will become a wiser and a better man because of what he experiences on the trail. This result is, however, highly muted in that Lin seems only slightly smarter at the end of the film, even though such additional wisdom has only been gained by his enduring tremendous physical danger and psychological suffering. The Man from Laramie is, ultimately, a much better integrated work, if perhaps not as immediately enjoyable as Winchester ’73. The initial meeting between Lockhart and Barbara incorporates one of the major symbolic designs of the entire film in that the protagonist must climb up a staircase to find the girl, and once there be treated to a cup of tea in a conspicuously homey atmosphere. In this way we learn that Barbara embodies the gentler aspects of civilization which are essential to the plot lines of innumerable westerns. At the same time, she introduces one of the major themes of The Man from Laramie by talking about her father’s wasted life in Coronado as a shopkeeper. Later, we see that her dismay over her parent who stayed on because of unfulfilled promises from his brother, Alec, is a cause of Barbara’s desire to get away with Vic. She cannot, however, convince Hansbro to give up his dreams of someday owning the Barb, and in a powerful scene Mann dramatizes their insoluble conflict by showing the villain angrily kissing the naively hopeful heroine in a kind of psychic rape designed to overpower her rationality. The Man from Laramie also embodies a long-standing range war between
4. Mann and the Western
107
Kate Canaday and the Barb. The older woman’s introduction comes about when, after Vic has taken over for the beaten and waterlogged Dave in the fight with Lockhart, she deftly shoots a pistol out of the hand of the enraged younger Waggoman. Kate finally succeeds in hiring the protagonist to be her foreman because of his desire to get out of jail after he has been accused of the murder of Chris Boldt and approached by Alec and Kate, each of whom wants him to work for them. The rivalry between Kate and Alec is neatly resolved when the Waggoman patriarch is brought to her ranch by Lockhart and Charlie after they have discovered his fallen body at the base of the inclined trail leading up to the hidden rifles. At the Canaday house, Alec is nursed by Kate, who has been in love with him for years, and by the film’s final scene the now completely blind old man needs to have her with him at all times—a prospect that turns Miss Canaday into a giddy romantic girl. Alec Waggoman, while resting in a darkened room at the Half Moon, not only comes to “see” his need for Kate but also reveals to Lockhart that Vic Hansbro is the man he has been seeking. At the conclusion of The Man from Laramie we see Kate Canaday installed as the mistress of the Barb, and we hear Alec calling for her from within as she says goodbye to Mann’s protagonist. Lockhart’s coming to Coronado has removed both the sources of current troubles (Dave and Vic) as well as healed the longstanding emotional and territorial animosities of the older generation. The plot of The Man from Laramie borrows from classical drama in its emphasis on conflicts arising out of family hatreds and jealousies. Alec Waggoman’s symbolic dream about the man who comes to kill his beloved son, the source of his immediate fears about Lockhart, must be painfully revealed for its inaccuracy. The older man, like Sophocles’s Oedipus, must find the truth through humiliation and injury; indeed, like that literary figure, Mann’s patriarch only comes to see reality after he has been rendered blind. The sibling rivalry between Dave and Vic for Alec’s affections and his property resembles the machinations of the bad sisters in King Lear, while Lockhart’s efforts to exonerate himself with the older man put him in the position of the faithful daughter in Shakespeare’s play. The protagonist’s relationship to Alec Waggoman is, of course, epitomized in their gun battle after the funeral service in Coronado for the fallen Dave. The elder Waggoman remains convinced that Lockhart has killed his son and, after refusing Vic’s offer to accompany him, he rides out alone to seek vengeance. Naturally, Lockhart has anticipated the situation and awaits Alec at Kate’s ranch. He stands under a tree with a rifle cradled in his left arm with his right hand conspicuously bandaged as a result of Dave’s earlier sadistic act. Alec’s failing sight causes him to holler at Lockhart so he can know where the latter is standing, and then we see him spraying bullets wildly
108
Anthony Mann
about as the protagonist stands his ground, never fires a shot, and still manages to unhorse the crazed older man. Appropriately enough, Lockhart lifts Alec and puts him back in the saddle, all the while telling him that he is “not the man in your dream.” While still not convinced of Lockhart’s innocence, Alec examines some bills of sale and discovers a shipment that has never been received. Suspecting that this discrepancy may be the source of the gunrunning that Lockhart has come to uncover, Alex tells Vic that they must ferret out the truth, otherwise the older man will always have doubts about his deceased son. While the guilty Vic tries to dissuade Alec by urging that he not probe into Dave’s activities, the elder Waggoman, like Oedipus, must seek out the truth however personally damaging it may be. On the trail with Vic, Alec discovers the only place where a wagon load of rifles could be hidden; and, as he rides up the steep incline that rises to the top of the ridge, his foreman and wouldbe surrogate son rides up to be abreast of him on the narrow ledge. The angry and frightened Hansbro then wrestles with Alec, who falls seemingly to his death; however, in yet one more final reversal of expectations, there is no effort by Vic to put the patriarch back in his saddle.
Healing the Past: The Naked Spur (1953) and The Tin Star (1957) These films both feature bounty hunters, and each man has only come to this profession because of a great personal injury in his past. In The Naked Spur Howie Kemp (James Stewart) has gone to the Civil War after leaving his ranch under the control of his seemingly faithful fiancée, only to lose the property because she sold it out from under him to run away with another man. Now he seeks money to regain his former home by hunting Ben Vandergroot (Robert Ryan), a man who knows about his past, for a $5,000 reward. In The Tin Star Morgan Hickman (Henry Fonda) has turned to bounty hunting because of the deaths of his son and wife during his earlier career as a town marshal. He discovered too late that the people he was sworn to protect would not support him in a time of need, and since then he has devoted himself to bringing wanted men in, dead or alive. Both men have an unspoken need to break out of their obsessions with the past, to get over its injuries, and to begin life anew in the present. Kemp only comes to this realization by struggling with his demons, which remain largely inarticulate, and gaining the love of Lena Patch (Janet Leigh). Hickman finds his redemption through a boy, Kip (Michel Ray), and his mother, Lorna Mayfield (Betsy Palmer), so that he can restore his former life. Kemp’s evolution only comes at the cost of great physical and psychological suffer-
4. Mann and the Western
109
ing. He is initially too shortsighted and too emotionally strung out by wanting to get even with his past to realize that love in the present is more important. Hickman, a more experienced and worldly-wise character, reverses his course much more quickly and easily; he lets his actions speak for him with Kip, Lorna, and the apprentice lawman Ben Owens (Anthony Perkins). Both films also place an emphasis on professionalism, especially the ability to handle life-threatening situations efficiently. While much of The Tin Star centers on Hickman’s training Owens so that the younger man can survive as a town marshal, a more sinister kind of expertise surfaces in The Naked Spur through the actions of Roy Anderson (Ralph Meeker). This dishonorably discharged cavalry officer not only succeeds in scaling a rock face to initially capture Vandergroot, but he even more skillfully sets up a deadly crossfire to kill the Indian band that is pursuing him. It is thoroughly in keeping with the thematic values of the movie that Anderson ultimately kills Ben and then dies in trying to get the outlaw’s corpse out of the roiling waters into which it has plunged. Hickman’s expertise dominates the early scenes between him and the idealistic but gullible Owens. The former lawman proves his capability by shooting a gun out of the hand of Bart Bogardus (Neville Brand) when the latter has tricked the young sheriff into a potentially deadly situation. Of course, the protagonist explains that he intervened because Owens had not signed the necessary reward claim for the dead man Hickman brought into town at the beginning of The Tin Star. Morgan’s professional efficiency is most obvious when he captures Ed (Lee Van Cleef) and Zeke McCaffey (Peter Baldwin) by smoking them out of a cave; Hickman’s every movement accomplishes this task after the headstrong and awkward Owens has gotten himself wounded and so must simply stand by and watch. Mann’s opening credits in these films operate as veritable overtures to what follows. The Naked Spur begins with a shot of a snow-capped mountain in the distance accompanied by some apprehensive sounding music. There is then a rapid cut to a close-up of the spur on Howie Kemp’s boot, the weapon he will use to defeat Ben. As he rides away from the camera and into the wilderness to which he has tracked the outlaw, the soundtrack is replete with brief musical stingers that accentuate the violent struggles that follow. The Tin Star’s credits feature an opening shot in which a rider (Hickman) slowly descends a hill with a second horse, which carries a dead outlaw. The sequence then segues to brief shots of a river, at which Hickman and Owens will be seen practicing later, and a shot of the town’s main street, down which the bounty hunter slowly proceeds and which will be reprised in the final scene when the rejuvenated Hickman leaves town with Kip and Lorna.
110
Anthony Mann
Lena Patch (Janet Leigh) and Howard Kemp (James Stewart) struggle with the rope that is tied to the corpse of Ben Vandergroat at the end of The Naked Spur (MGM, 1953). The protagonist finally breaks down and realizes that Lena’s love and not the bounty on Vandergroat is what must be uppermost in his life.
4. Mann and the Western
111
The Naked Spur is possibly Mann’s most lushly photographed western; indeed, its many panoramic shots of mountains and clear blue skies stand in the most marked contrast to the base and often dark motives of its characters. The director’s profound feeling for landscape thoroughly permeates the action and adds considerably to the emotional struggles of Howie Kemp to become human, Ben Vandergroat to escape, Roy Anderson and Jesse Tate (Millard Mitchell) to earn more reward money or strike gold, and Lena to make a new start in California. Savage rock faces, narrow ledges, roaring rapids, and claustrophobic caves are all deftly used to augment the plot: the sheer difficulties of the terrain and weather (a coming rainy season) test the characters and prove that only the two survivors can transcend such difficulties and so prove worthy of a new life. The dramatic tension of The Naked Spur arises from the machinations of the captured Ben, who consciously sets out to divide and conquer his captors. In this process he uses Lena by having her scratch his back in front of the always lecherous Roy; he tells Jesse about a gold strike he has found back in the hills; and he assaults Howie through insults and flattery. In essence, the outlaw works on the greed of his captors by reminding them of how two shares are larger than three, and he is able to manipulate Roy and Jesse because of Kemp’s initial refusal to make the others aware of the size of the reward on Vandergroat. The protagonist’s showing of a wanted poster (with its bottom section torn off) to Jesse and Roy displays Howie’s alienation in the early sections of the story. He hires Tate for $20 to show him the way to some burned-out fires that the aged prospector has come across, and when they have trailed the outlaw to his mountain hideout, he drafts Jesse to fight with him against Ben. When he discovers that Vandergroat has a $5,000 price on his head, Tate angrily returns the $20 to Howie and, along with Roy who has been instrumental in capturing the outlaw, claims a larger share of the reward. Kemp’s dissembling with his cohorts as well as allowing them to think he is a lawman underscore the protagonist’s desperation in wanting to reclaim his ranch and his past. Vandergroat eventually persuades Jesse to cut him loose so he can lead the aged prospector to a supposed gold mine—a ruse that gets Tate killed by Ben, who really wants only to set up a final ambush in which he can kill Roy and Howie. While Jesse accepts his misfortune and tries to bargain his way out of this fix, his coldblooded execution by Ben finally turns Lena against the outlaw. She has come to see that Vandergroat is the murderous killer he is reputed to be and, when the others arrive, she foils Ben’s first shot and is knocked to one side. In essence, the girl has made a moral and a romantic choice to commit to justice and to Howie. Her rejection of Ben and of fond
112
Anthony Mann
memories of her dead outlaw father who was Vandergroat’s partner foreshadows Man of the West in which Link Jones (Gary Cooper) must kill all the members of his criminal family. Roy Anderson’s murderous capacity comes to the forefront in the sequence in which he forces the other characters to join in his killing of the Indians who have followed him to revenge a rape he committed before he was dishonorably discharged from the army. After he tells Howie and the others that the pursuing group is after him and nags them about joining him in making a stand against the redmen, Kemp cuts Roy short with “Your fight ... not ours.” Once Anderson has ridden away, Howie and the others proceed slowly through a wooded area with the Indians following them at the same leisurely pace into a clearing. This slow parade passes by a fallen log under which we see Roy waiting with a rifle; once both groups are past him, and just after Howie and the Indian chief have exchanged peace signals, Anderson opens fire and his companions are forced to battle for their lives. The efficiency of the group is clearly demonstrated by the massacre of their opponents. At one point, however, Ben, who is unarmed and whose hands are tied, is grabbed by one of the redmen and appears to be about to be overpowered; however, Kemp comes to his rescue and beats Vandergroat’s assailant to death with a pistol. This struggle goes on far too long and is yet another instance of Mann’s using action to speak for a character; all the pentup rage in Kemp comes to the surface in this brutal fight. During this melee the protagonist is wounded in the leg to symbolize that his going over the edge must be punished. As the wounded Howie and the others leave the scene of the slaughter, Mann’s camera briefly focuses on one fallen brave lying in a position that suggests the Crucifixion. Howie Kemp’s wound combines with his exhaustion through the rest of The Naked Spur to dramatize his emerging return to being fully human. When he and the others arrive at rapids swollen by rain and argue over whether to cross there or take “four or five days” to find an easier transition downstream, Howie becomes enraged when Roy insists that Vandergroat is only a “sack of money.” The two men then fight in a characteristically staged struggle. Not only are they grappling on the ground and among fallen timbers but Roy presses a rope into Howie’s face and even draws a pistol on the hero before being overpowered. This fight leaves Anderson unconscious and Kemp all but collapsing into some refreshing water; however, what is even more notable is that none of the other characters intervene in any way. Ben smiles, Jesse simply looks on, and Lena only rushes to Kemp’s side after the struggle is over. (The protagonist still distrusts her because of earlier events.) Their romantic relationship is central to the major themes of The Naked Spur, and Mann presents its development in subtle and obvious ways. After
4. Mann and the Western
113
he has been wounded, Howie attempts to ride but finally succumbs to his pains and falls off his mount; Lena nurses him through a night of fever and delirium. As he rambles about his romantic past, the girl comforts him and the soundtrack signals their emerging involvement through variations played on Stephen Foster’s “Beautiful Dreamer.” This melody, whose very title emphasizes Lena’s hopes for a better life, is then prominently invoked on the ensuing morning when Howie comes out of his fever, wonders why the others have let him sleep so long, and, as Lena re-bandages his wound, asks, “Why should you care?” While the girl offers no answer, the prominence of the Foster tune clearly presents her motivations. Lena’s feelings are again obvious on the trail later that day when she sees Kemp being pushed off his horse by Ben. This sequence is foreshadowed by Vandergroat’s loosening of the cinch on Howie’s saddle before they break camp, and then the outlaw rattles on as Howie unwittingly starts to doze off. However, when Vandergroat knocks Kemp off, the hero’s fall down a steep hillside is stopped by a fallen tree. We then see Howie agonizingly struggling to regain the safety of the ledge from which he has fallen as Roy, Jesse, and Ben look on and only Lena shows any concern for him. In this way Mann re-emphasizes the major thematic thrust of The Naked Spur, for Howie Kemp must ultimately move away from the greedy and self-centered world of outlaws and bounty hunting and rise into the world of genuine human emotions embodied by Lena. A more extended ensuing sequence in a cave demonstrates the struggle within Kemp to achieve such humanity. In a driving rainstorm the travelers seek refuge there, and as they settle in for the night, Ben prevails upon Lena to distract Howie long enough so that the outlaw can crawl out of the back of the shaft to freedom. After Jesse and Roy have fallen asleep, Vandergroat cues the girl to go to Kemp, who is standing watch. The Foster melody rises once more on the soundtrack as the nascent lovers start to talk. She reveals her California dream (“some place new”) while he remembers his idyllic life as a rancher with a house, neighbors, and a community to which he belonged. When Howie suggests that they might return to his ranch together on the money he will earn for taking Ben back to be hanged, Lena refuses because such an act “would be steppin’ on a grave.” At this point Howie grabs Lena and kisses her passionately, as if to signal that her desires as well as her beauty have overcome him; however, once again, Mann employs a reversal because Jesse shouts that Ben is getting away and the alerted Howie immediately jumps up and goes in pursuit. After he has caught the outlaw and dragged him back to the center of the cave, Kemp’s fury takes over as he gives Vandergroat a gun and challenges him to a shootout then and there. Clearly, the protagonist is venting his rage at Lena’s
114
Anthony Mann
seeming betrayal against the individual he sees as its source; however, Ben is wise enough not to accept Howie’s challenge (“I ain’t got a prayer against you”). For a moment Kemp seems bent on simply gunning down his antagonist, but he does not and then, in an obviously symbolic gesture, he goes back to the mouth of the cave and angrily kicks at the tin cups full of water which had been the initial subject of conversation between Lena and himself. The final battle in the rocks between Ben, Howie, and Roy, shows Mann’s great facility with action sequences. After the outlaw has killed the gullible Jesse and left his body below, he takes Lena and goes up to a ridge from which he can easily pick off his foes as they ride out of some woods and into the clearing below. The impatient Vandergroat then fires shots that graze the dead man’s boots in order to hasten the arrival of his enemies. Lena offers to run away with him if he will spare Kemp. The cynical Ben simply responds that she will come along with him anyway after he has killed his pursuers, and the idealistic girl then proceeds to hit his rifle as he is about to kill Howie. After he has knocked her unconscious, Ben starts firing away at Howie and Roy below. Howie climbs up the outer edges of the giant rock formation that Ben is on, Roy keeps the killer occupied by rifle fire. As he nears the top of his ascent, Kemp takes off his left spur to use as a pick on the harsh rock surface. When he is almost at the top of the ledge, Ben hears Howie and crawls over to kill him. The protagonist hooks the outlaw’s face with the spur, causing Vandergroat to rise up in pain and be killed by Roy. In a visual reprise of the end of Winchester ’73 the villain’s body tumbles off the height into the raging waters pouring through the gorge below. As we see Ben’s corpse caught up on a log and washed into a small whirlpool, Howie forgets his quest for money and rushes over to see if Lena is all right, for in the proceeding battle Ben has claimed that she has been wounded and is bleeding fiercely as one more ruse to get his antagonists to reveal themselves. Roy Anderson now rushes to retrieve Ben’s corpse by stringing a rope across the surging waters to where the outlaw’s body is floating. The cavalryman skillfully pulls himself across and gets a rope around the cadaver; however, his announcement (“I got him!”) is skillfully juxtaposed by Lena’s passionate cry (“Stop it!”) to emphasize the major conflict that is still raging within Howie Kemp. At this point a huge piece of driftwood carries Roy away to his death as the protagonist succeeds in pulling Ben’s body out of the surging waters. As he drags the outlaw’s corpse toward his horses, Lena pleads with Howie to “cut him loose,” but the protagonist reverts to being a bounty hunter solely out for money. In a film in which the hero has had to struggle against physical obstacles and endure savage physical pain, his emotional conflict reaches crisis proportions at this point.
4. Mann and the Western
115
In a remarkable combination of directing and acting, Kemp’s conversion occurs as James Stewart is photographed from the rear trying to tie Vandergroot’s corpse onto a horse’s back. We see his reactions in the tightening and loosening of his shoulders as Lena begs him to stop and, then, in a more resigned voice, tells Howie she will go with him and do whatever he wants. In this way the past has been reversed as the hero finds a woman who will be faithful to him even if he chooses to live off the “blood money” that he has been seeking; and, as Stewart’s shoulders visibly sag, the strains of “Beautiful Dreamer” take over once more. The tension that Howie Kemp has been carrying throughout is now dissipated and, appropriately, he does the right thing by burying Ben’s corpse and riding off with Lena to California as the film ends. As one would expect, Mann fills The Naked Spur with numerous objects and situations that reinforce its major conflicts and plot resolution. In addition to the object of the title, the spur which Howie uses to overcome Ben, pistols are featured throughout; indeed, a close-up of a sixgun opens the movie’s initial sequence in which the protagonist creeps up on Jesse Tate and his mule. The wanted posters that Howie and Ben show are also important in that the former’s torn copy omits the price on the outlaw’s head so that when the latter shows his entire version to Jesse and Roy he is able to begin driving a wedge between his three captors. Later, Roy’s discharge paper shows that he has been dishonorably separated from the service and, naturally, establishes him as closely akin to Ben in being greedy and egocentric. Anderson is also associated with ropes, for he tries to overpower Howie with one and then skillfully uses another to get to the floating corpse of Vandergroat. High places also clearly figure prominently in both the opening siege of Ben’s lofty hideout and at the end when Roy and Howie attack the outlaw on the ridge on which he has perched to ambush them. These confrontations again display the thematic movement of The Naked Spur, for in the first encounter Howie is unable to scale the rock wall, while in the second he not only succeeds in climbing up a sheer incline but also overpowers the outlaw at the top. While Kemp was initially motivated by hatred and his desire for money to re-do his past, in the climactic scene he is subconsciously moved to act because of his love for Lena and a desire to do the right thing. In both instances Roy Anderson also plays a pivotal role. The disgraced cavalryman’s arrival finds him easily ascending the sheer rock face after Howie has failed and then getting the drop on Ben: at the raging river gorge Anderson dies in trying to recover the corpse of the man he has just killed. Roy thus goes from being a bemused spectator and efficient participant in the first instance to a frenzied and shortsighted victim in the second case. In essence, he becomes
116
Anthony Mann
what Kemp is at the beginning—and his death offers a subtle verdict on what such conduct will ultimately lead to. After Howie and Jesse trail the outlaw to his first ridge hideout, they are beset by rocks that Vandergroat rains down on them. Kemp persuades his elderly guide to provide cover as he tries to work around the other side and find a place to scale up to the wanted man. At this point Anderson rides in, introduces himself as an “extraordinary” Indian fighter, and tags along to see whether Kemp and Tate will succeed. Roy offers to provide cover for Howie as the bounty hunter attempts to climb the vertical rock face, and then he sits chuckling as he watches the protagonist attempt this difficult ascent. Mann shoots this sequence from tight angles to catch the fear and anguish on Howie’s face as he slips and slides back down the rope, burning his hands in the process. At this point Roy takes over and nimbly scales the cliff, albeit with one momentary slip when Mann’s camera records a passing smile on Kemp’s face. At the top Anderson sneaks up on the prone and unarmed Vandergroat, who laughingly says “Now ain’t that the way” when the ex-soldier gets the drop on him. In the fight which follows between them, Ben laughs madly throughout and is only overpowered when Howie and Jesse arrive. The presence of Lena and her dying horse, the reason why Ben and she have had to stop, adds another dimension to the manhunt and further complications to the plot of The Naked Spur. Vandergroat, who begins to emerge as the devil/tempter in the film, urges that Lena must help him get sufficient time to turn his captors against each other. In a clever juxtaposition of words and actions, the outlaw says he “must scratch open sore spots” on Howie, Jesse, and Roy at the same time that Lena is massaging his back in the first of many instances when that action is used to emphasize her sexuality. After Jesse and Howie determine that Ben is above them, the two men briefly confer about how to storm the outlaw’s elevated position. When Kemp announces that he has finally caught up with the object of his hunt, the aged miner sagely notes, “You got him, but he’s got you too.” This remark, which implies that the immediate capturing of Ben is going to be, at best, most difficult, carries significant weight beyond just being a reference to the characters’ present standoff. For the duration of The Naked Spur, what Ben represents to Howie—a chance to rework his past—is, what possesses the protagonist. It is only after he has ascended the second ridge, recovered the outlaw’s corpse, and then buried it that Howie Kemp overcomes the condition set forth in Jesse’s remark. The Tin Star initially stands out because of its photographic style. The film is replete with deep focus shots, especially from inside Owens’s office, to emphasize the omnipresence of the town and citizens; the young lawman
4. Mann and the Western
117
must learn to handle both. Door frames and a long tracking shot also distinguish the opening sequence in which Hickman brings a dead body into town, reports to the sheriff, and is rebuffed by most of the populace who, appropriately enough, despise bounty hunters. At the film’s climax Mann returns to the jail office and, when a rock is thrown through its front window and the shade violently thrown up, we see the waiting mob and its leader Bogardus across the street in another elaborate set-up. Mann also introduces each of his principal characters either through appropriate objects or places that define them; this economy makes the exposition of The Tin Star as appropriately rapid as it needs to be while, at the same time, introducing the relationships and conflicts that mark the subsequent action. As Morgan Hickman rides slowly into the town with his burden, the camera moves closer and closer to him until we simply see the
From left: Ben Owens (Anthony Perkins) arrests the McGaffey brothers, Zeke (Peter Baldwin) and Ed (Lee Van Cleef), in The Tin Star (Paramount, 1957). The training of a novice sheriff (Perkins) by a veteran lawman turned bounty hunter (Henry Fonda) causes both men to arrive at a greater understanding of themselves.
118
Anthony Mann
suspended hand of the outlaw he has killed. At the same time, the stunned faces of the townspeople are shown in medium shots of them in clusters. Hickman must pass a gnarled tree on his way to the sheriff’s office, and this object, found conspicuously in the middle of the street, symbolizes the struggles that will come as well as the often tangled webs that are human history and society. Once inside the jail, Hickman discovers Owens practicing twirling his pistols. After Ben fumbles in putting one of them back into his holster, Hickman asks, “Where’s the sheriff?” and Owens quickly reaches for his vest with the tin star on it. This initial emphasis on the badge as not only a symbol of office but also a source of personal identity introduces another pattern that underpins the major themes of The Tin Star. Owens’s ineptness and Morgan’s initial doubt that the young man could, indeed, be the town marshal sets up the apprenticeship situation in which the older man will train the younger one to become a professional. At the same time, Morgan Hickman’s own healing process, by which he will learn to quit living in regrets about his past, will be completed by his final acceptance of a tin star from Owens. After he has been told he must wait for his reward money, and after he has been refused a room at the local hotel because the townspeople loathe bounty hunters, Hickman rides over to the livery stable in the hope of bedding down his horses for the night. There he is confronted by Bart Bogardus, the owner who is also related to the dead man Morgan has brought in, and told that his business is not wanted. The villain is a hulking, swaggering figure, replete with a prominent white hat, who rejects Hickman at the same time that he is chasing Kip out of his establishment. The insouciant boy has been indulging his love of animals, and in the street he asks if he can ride one of Morgan’s horses. In decided contrast to Bogardus, the bounty hunter gladly allows the boy to ride behind him. Their trip to Kip’s home on the outskirts of town leads to Hickman’s finding a place to stay as Lorna Mayfield accedes to her son’s urging that the protagonist and his animals remain with them. The widow is conspicuously associated with the house and the many chores that go with keeping it up: We see her knitting clothes for other people because she needs the work, doing dishes, and insisting that she sleep in front of the fire for she will be up and about before either Morgan or Kip. The protagonist’s emerging love for Lorna begins with their first night in her parlor when Hickman feels as though this situation were a reprisal of his own domestic life and briefly alludes to his own family (“I had a boy once”). Kip’s role as an instigator is emphasized by a sprightly musical theme that is introduced as he and Hickman initially ride to the boy’s home and which is invoked often through the rest of the film. The boy’s headstrong
4. Mann and the Western
119
desire to explore and have adventures shows that he, like Ben Owens, needs the guidance of an older male, and Morgan’s emerging feelings eventually lead to his becoming that figure. Kip’s association with animals, especially the pigeons he keeps and then releases when he and Lorna leave with Morgan at the end of the film, is marked throughout: A horse brings him and the bounty hunter together and leads to the former lawman becoming his new father. When Hickman subsequently gives Kip a pony, the boy cannot resist riding the animal in pursuit of the posse that thunders past his home in pursuit of the McGaffeys; and, in a wonderful bit of plotting, Hickman must rescue Kip and Owens out in the fields that surround the cave in which the murderous brothers have holed up. Dr. McCord (John McIntire) represents the history and the conscience of the town in which Hickman and Owens struggle to find their real identities. While Morgan is beset by the outraged official representatives of the place when they learn his occupation (“Collect your money and get out!”), lesser figures are equally hostile and even McCord eyes him suspiciously. The good doctor does, however, have a soft spot for Owens and his fiancée, Millie (Mary Webster), for he attempts to reconcile them in the sheriff’s office when the girl urges that Ben must give up the job. McCord emphasizes that Millie’s own father was the previous sheriff and kept the town safe, that Ben has succeeded to that responsibility, and that her tasks must be to support the man she loves and the need for social order. This argument is even more strongly urged in McCord’s office when he tries once more to reunite the estranged young people and tells Millie that no one can “run away from responsibility.” Familiar stylistic features reappear in The Tin Star, particularly in the sequence in which the venerable McCord is killed by Ed McGaffey. Leaving the scene of a birth, McCord admonishes his horse to simply take him home and settles down for a nap; however, his trip is interrupted by the elder McGaffey, initially shown in a frame that emphasizes his foot in the saddle and which, characteristically, reverses the mood of the scene. At the McGaffey ranch, Dr. McCord patches up the wounded Zeke and purports to believe the brothers’ story about a hunting accident. As he leaves at dawn to return to the town and his seventy-fifth birthday celebration, McCord remarks to Ed that the weather promises it’s “going to be a fine day.” We then see the aged physician again settling into his carriage and preparing once again for a nap as his faithful horse takes over. Inside, the McGaffeys worry about McCord’s realizing that Zeke’s wound was a result of a holdup that led to the death of a stage driver. Ed is convinced that the physician knew the truth from the moment he stepped into their house and is preparing to kill the old man, while his wounded sib-
120
Anthony Mann
ling tries to talk him out of doing so. Mann does not show the actual killing; instead, we see the townspeople awaiting McCord’s arrival, starting to sing “For he’s a jolly good fellow” when they see his carriage in the distance, and then falling into stunned silence as the slumped-over physician passes by. When McCord’s notebook is checked, the townspeople learn that his last stop was the McGaffey ranch and their collective rage leads to posting of a reward on the brothers “dead or alive.” The irony of the situation becomes increasingly apparent as Bogardus and many others rush to form a posse while prodding Owens to lead them. In essence, they have become the same kind of hunters they once scorned. At the McGaffey ranch, after Bogardus has assumed control of the posse, this enraged mob decides to burn down the house. They do so by means of a burning wagon which is pushed into the front of this dwelling in a set-up that visually reprises the attack of the posse on Steve’s ranch in Winchester ’73. The larger point, of course, is the loss of control exhibited by these men and the way in which Bogardus has prompted them into becoming worse than themselves. When the house is ablaze, the villain and the others ride off apparently looking for the McGaffeys, but actually seeking more opportunities for destruction. The futility of this act of mob violence is underscored when Kip, Hickman, and Owens all separately come upon the scene of destruction and then proceed to where the brothers are hiding because the boy pursues a dog there and the men come looking for him. The Tin Star clearly presents a serious theme about the necessity for taking personal responsibility, whether for one’s own actions or to protect the common good. This value is initially implied by the fact that Morgan and Lorna each have become disillusioned by the ways people have treated them in the past. Their revelations of these situations to each other are prompted by the bounty hunter’s comment that Kip looks “part Mexican,” a remark that angers Lorna as she explains that the boy is really part Indian. She assumes that Hickman is racially bigoted and orders him to leave in the morning. On the ensuing day, however, after he has been to town and signed some papers related to the reward money, Hickman returns to the Mayfield house only to be visited by Owens, who has learned that the older man was once a lawman. In an effort to get Morgan to help him, the neophyte sheriff announces that he has secured a room in town for the older man; however, Morgan quietly states that he already has a room and a smiling Lorna obviously forgives him and starts falling in love with him. We then learn that Lorna was the daughter of an Indian agent, married a brave, and then saw her husband killed because of prejudice against redmen. Her story emphasizes that caring for Kip—the need for civilized society to protect children—outweighs such shortsightedness and helps further
4. Mann and the Western
121
the parental relationship which Morgan has been gradually moving toward. In the past, Hickman has suffered because, even though he was the town marshal, he could get no financial help from those he protected when his wife fell ill; instead, he had to go out and hunt down a criminal for the $1,000 reward which could move his family to a healthier climate. His effort proved to be too little, too late for both his wife and his young son, so Hickman decided to become a full-time bounty hunter. Morgan’s situation resembles the dilemma of Will Kane in High Noon (1952) in that the perfidy of the citizens is consistent in both films. Hickman’s rebirth comes about through his training of Owens, for he moves from being critical and cynical to being the younger man’s partner in the climax of The Tin Star. When Morgan sees the young man playing with his pistols on his first visit to the jail, he can only look on with scorn. A shooting the next day by Bogardus forces Owens to take action, and Hickman watches as the novice commits error after error; however, when the villain hides his hand behind his hat and is about to kill the young man, Morgan shoots the pistol out of his hand. As Owens tries to thank him, Hickman denies he had any noble intentions—all he was trying to do was ensure that he would get paid promptly. However, such tough-mindedness is belied by the protagonist’s then giving the would-be lawman a lecture which ends with the advice, “Take off that tin star and stay alive.” Owens finally convinces the reluctant Hickman to teach him the ways of being a sheriff, largely because he points out that Bogardus will take over if he does not succeed. Morgan is convinced by this argument that a worse man will replace the inept Owens so he takes the latter to a riverside to teach him about shooting. After telling Ben that he lacks confidence, Hickman adds that a lawman must shoot to kill when he decides he must shoot. In a subsequent scene the two men go into a saloon and Hickman teaches Ben to stop trying to act tough, to “learn what to stay out of” when a drunken brawl breaks out, and, ultimately, to learn to study men. In his final lesson the bounty hunter shows Owens how to capture the McGaffeys by flushing them out of their cave by burning prairie grass at its entrance, but he delivers this lesson only after the younger man has gotten himself slightly wounded through attempting to “negotiate” with the hidden outlaws. Toughened by this last experience and now capable of applying Hickman’s teachings, Owens waits out and then puts down an attempt by Bogardus and his mob to lynch the McGaffeys. Ben must overcome the advice of the respectable citizens, who want him to back down, and the apparent indifference of Hickman, who waits to see when the drunken citizens will demand the prisoners be turned over to them. As the two men sit in the jail’s front office and Morgan sagely counsels that the would-be lynchers must get
122
Anthony Mann
“liquored up” before they try anything, Owens offers a tin star to his mentor, but Hickman refuse to wear it. When the broken window and rattling shade reveal that Bogardus and his cohorts are ready to hang the McGaffeys, Ben takes a shotgun into the street and walks confidently toward the crowd as we see Morgan come out to the porch wearing the tin star which he has finally picked up again. While The Tin Star emphasizes the frequent ill treatment of native Americans, this subplot remains subordinate to the master-apprentice story at the center of the film. Bogardus’s insults to Kip in the stable introduce racial prejudice; and the bad man’s initial confrontation with Owens begins with the villain’s dismissal of a killing by urging that the dead man was a “half breed and had it coming!” Later Ben tells Morgan that the McGaffey brothers, who have just ridden past them at the river where the lawmen have been practicing marksmanship, have some “Indian blood,” and Bogardus incites the mob reaction to McCord’s murder by yelling that the brothers are “breeds.” The Tin Star has Owens kill Bogardus and the latter fall backward toward the camera in a signature Mann set-up. To establish his authority, Ben not only disperses the lynch mob but also goads the villain into fighting with him; in essence, he has learned that he must use violence to gain control and so bring peace. These actions establish that the young lawman now embodies the sense of responsibility that Dr. McCord earlier urges upon Millie. The town is once again in safe hands because Owens has replaced Millie’s father as its protector, and we see the restoration of order dramatized in the exit of Hickman with Lorna and Kip. After the boy releases the pigeons he cannot take with him, the new family rides through the main street in town as Morgan assures Ben that he can handle everything on his own. Their passage reverses the visual pattern which brought Hickman on the scene in the first place, and the emotional changes in Morgan are further reflected by his saying that he will find a town of his own and return to being a sheriff.
The Costs of Civilization: Devil’s Doorway (1950) and The Last Frontier [a.k.a. Savage Wilderness] (1955) These films offer more complicated thematic treatments of the issues that rise between individuals and the societies or communities in which they either live or into which they are attempting to be assimilated. While Will Lockhart, an outsider in Coronado in The Man from Laramie, notes the unfriendliness of many of its inhabitants, the difficulties faced by Lance Poole (Robert Taylor) in Devil’s Doorway and Jed Cooper (Victor Mature) in The Last Frontier are more pointed and more pervasive. These protagonists seek to be accepted for different reasons, but the obstacles they encounter raise
4. Mann and the Western
123
the larger point of individuals deriving major parts of their identities from the communities and people with whom they reside. As aliens—Lance is a Shoshone and Jed a free-spirited trapper—both men yearn to become at one with their societies. Ironically, the nobler and more idealistic Poole, who wants to create a perfect place in Sweet Meadows where all people will be welcome, is killed because of the prejudices he arouses, while the baser and more practical Jed, who only wishes for a life in the army so that he may impress Corinna Marston (Anne Bancroft), lives to triumph both socially and romantically after the death of Colonel Marston (Robert Preston). Mann’s protagonists in these films are military heroes whose prowess in combat is shown by their ability to quickly size up and react to violently changing conditions. Lance leads the war party that defeats the sheepmen’s attempt to bring their herds onto his property; indeed, his knowledge of tactics finds the Shoshones using dynamite to destroy both the animals and the men who have come against them. In the later protracted siege of his ranch by Verne Coolan (Louis Calhern) and the aroused townspeople, Lance’s capabilities as a leader are again apparent when he negotiates a safe conduct for the women and children under his authority. Once he has agreed to scout for the army, Cooper, as the natural man of the forest and mountains, has no difficulty seeking and finding Marston’s beleaguered retreating column or spying on Red Cloud’s camp. We see Jed frequently on the branches of enormous trees or blending into the terrain as he takes Colonel Martson to see where the Indians are encamped or as he returns from his own act of desertion to try to save Gus (James Whitmore) and Marston’s troopers from the ambush that Red Cloud has set up. In this sequence, as the cavalrymen follow their glory-crazed commander to death by charging into the enemy, Cooper rallies the infantry and gets these men back to the safety of Fort Shallan after he has attended his dying mentor. Cooper takes command because no officers are present, battles the attacking redmen deftly and individually, and even carries a fallen comrade during this extended retreat. Jed’s abilities as a man of war are on display when he overpowers one of Red Cloud’s sentries and takes away a cavalry jacket that the fallen warrior was wearing, when he runs out of the stockade in a drunken fury to kill some braves who are nearby, and when he battles with and eventually kills Sergeant Decker (Peter Whitney). Poole also dominates as a fighter when we see him triumph over Ike Stapleton (James Millican) in a bar brawl that Coolan has instigated, when he repulses the sheepmen’s initial foray into Sweet Meadows by wounding its leader Rod MacDougall (Marshall Thompson), and when he sneaks up and silently strangles the crooked lawyer. Ulti-
124
Anthony Mann
mately, the individual courage of these two Mann protagonists is shown when Jed is accepted into the service and in the casual way that Lance mentions during his initial meeting with Orrie Masters (Paula Raymond) that he has received the Medal of Honor. The villains of Devil’s Doorway and The Last Frontier are obvious representatives of society for they stand well within its acceptable limits as far as race and decorum are concerned. Verne Coolan, who has come West for reasons of health, may be a bigot about Native Americans, but he is also a lawyer and so an embodiment of the newer civilized order that is emerging in Wyoming. Colonel Marston, no matter his shortcomings as an officer or a tactical strategist, commands the garrison at Fort Shallan and so represents the order that such forces are inevitably bringing to the wilderness. Coolan and Marston do, however, obviously trade on their respectability and authority to manipulate the situations in which they find themselves. The lawyer does so by inveigling others to do his dirty work and consistently prodding the sheep herders and the irrational townspeople into action. Coolan buys Ike Stapleton’s allegiance and then forces Sheriff Zeke Carmody (Edgar Buchanan) to follow the letter of the law in dealing with the resettlement of Sweet Meadows. While both the gunman and the lawman die in the initial battle with Lance and his warriors, Coolan is appropriately killed later in the dark by Poole. Colonel Marston uses Sergeant Decker as a cat’s paw and then relies on the disciplined loyalty of Captain Riordan (Guy Madison) in dealing with Cooper, and trades on military protocol to checkmate his fellow officers when they question his plans. When Riordan’s request to have the colonel relieved of command is denied, Marston refuses to institute any formal action against his subordinate because, as he says, such a proceeding would not be in the army’s “best interests”; and, even though his obsessive quest for military glory proves futile and costs several lives, Colonel Marston does die heroically in battle. Mann emphasizes fistfights in tight quarters in both films to symbolize the difficult moral and personal conflicts that beset Poole and Cooper. While such encounters invoke the style of film noir, their extended brutality and the sheer exhaustion of the participants are much more in keeping with the director’s larger themes in his westerns. The physical battering that Lance receives during his saloon fight with Stapleton is symbolically prompted by a sign which forbids the sale of liquor to Indians and accompanied by numerous reaction shots of indifferent or gloating spectators. Its finale, in which the protagonist throws a drink in the face of his unconscious opponent, nicely dramatizes what Poole has been fighting for while, at the same time, reemphasizing that the town has turned against him. Cooper’s fatal brawl with Sergeant Decker, prompted by Colonel
4. Mann and the Western
125
Marston’s oblique hint to his obsequious subordinate to “provoke him,” is rendered as a brilliant stylistic tour de force as we are shown the men battling within the confines of the scout’s room. Cooper and Decker are photographed from an extremely high angle as they grab various objects and attempt to strangle each other within what clearly emerges as a visual reprise of the bear trap into which the colonel had earlier fallen. The fighters then break through the cabin door and take their struggle up to the roof as Mann’s camera tracks along and then reverts to reaction shots of Riordan, Corinna and the initially gleeful and then dismayed Marston. Jed finally throws his antagonist to the ground and his death and, when the colonel orders his arrest for killing a soldier, the protagonist snaps, throws down the cavalry jacket he has been wearing (declaring it to be nothing but a “dirty, filthy blue rag”), and vaults out of the fort. This crisis follows closely upon the traumatic situations that Cooper had to face in the aftermath of his leaving Colonel Marston to die in a bear trap. Jed is stunned when those he thought were his friends and his beloved condemn what he is done, even though the protagonist has come to believe that eliminating the commander is what the others wanted and what is necessary for the preservation of the outpost and its garrison. Jed’s dilemma, over the contradictory values and wishes of the society he wants desperately to belong to and his own wild and free life up until now, is resolved when Mungo (Pat Hogan) meets him after the hero has deserted the fort and tells him that he no longer belongs in the wilderness. The two men then part— the Indian to the life of a trapper and Cooper to the commitments of “civilization” by returning to battle Red Cloud and find a rapprochement with the army and Corinna at the film’s conclusion. The protagonist of Devil’s Doorway rides into town as the credits wind down, dressed as a Union soldier just returned from the Civil War. During the five subsequent years in which Lance builds up his ranch, he conspicuously wears white man’s clothes so that Orrie is initially surprised when he tells her he is a Shoshone. As he is driven to defend his land, Poole adopts a headdress and Indian clothing and, only when he finally surrenders, does he again put on his Union jacket. Indeed, in his walk up to the waiting Lieutenant Grimes (Bruce Cowling) and Orrie, Lance’s mixture of the clothing of the two cultures and his collapse in death symbolizes exactly the forces that have killed Poole. His final words, “We’re all gone,” reemphasize what has happened to his utopian dream for Sweet Meadows as well as that there is little or no place for Native Americans in the face of encroaching white rules and regulations. Orrie Masters and Corinna Marston are conspicuously Eastern women who exemplify the softer and feminine sides of civilization. While she sur-
126
Anthony Mann
Lance Poole (Robert Taylor) realizes he must fight against overwhelming odds in Devil’s Doorway (MGM, 1950). Mann’s film offers a much more sober view of Native American–White relations than does the more heralded Broken Arrow (Twentieth Century–Fox, 1950).
prisingly functions as a lawyer in the predominantly masculine world of Wyoming (a situation that initially startles Lance nearly as much as his being an Indian disturbs her), Orrie characteristically works to bring about peace through compromise to the dangerous situation into which Lance brings her. Her unspoken love for Poole goads her into sending for governmental
4. Mann and the Western
127
help when Sweet Meadows is besieged because of her abiding allegiance to the rule of law; indeed, because it has been her father’s profession, she essentially insulates herself within its rules in order to have some emotional stability to cling to. Orrie may have deeper feelings for Lance, but she always remains an idealist. In their conversation, she once more urges Poole to surrender, even though he will have to spend the rest of his life in prison. Corinna Marston eschews any overt idealism for, if anything, she is looking for a new life that will either relieve her of being the colonel’s wife or somehow magically transform her spouse into being a human being instead of a martinet. Her loveless marriage is shown in several scenes in which we see her futile efforts to transform their relationship consistently rebuffed by his obsessions with duty and glory. While Corinna can insist that she married a “man” and not “just a uniform,” the colonel can maintain that he is only a man because of wearing a uniform. Her subsequent passion for Jed takes her into his arms and his cabin, but she still insists that she will not trade being the colonel’s wife for being Cooper’s “squaw.” When Jed and Colonel Marston then ride out to survey Red Cloud’s camp, Gus appropriately chastises Corinna by pointing out, “If one of them don’t come back, you can be thanking yourself.” Because Jed Cooper does, ultimately, “come back,” he wins Corinna at the end of The Last Frontier when she appears smiling on a porch after he has dismissed the troops. The reappearance of the film’s title song (which inappropriately sounds far too jaunty) marks this change as the lovers gaze at each other and the camera rises into the snowy skies to bring the movie to its end. This conclusion does, of course, drastically alter the plot of Richard Roberts’ The Gilded Rooster, on which The Last Frontier is based, for in that novel Jed murders the mad commander and is then shunned by the community of the fort while the Riordan character ends up with Corinna. The ending of Mann’s film has often been dismissed as simply “tacked on” due to studio pressures, and one might initially agree that it seems too truncated, too convenient, and probably too “commercial,” given the story that has led up to it. On the other hand, Mann does not supply enough basis for ending the film as the novel does. Since Riordan and Corinna are hardly ever together on screen, a more biting finale would appear way too contrived. It could simply be that the director wanted viewers to remember what Jed has given up to gain the rewards of civilization—Corinna and a uniform. In The Last Frontier, Marston’s death arises out of his megalomaniac drives, and its final scene can be construed as emphasizing that Cooper has lost a great deal in making the choice he has. In keeping with the fact that life-changing decisions produce losses as well as gains, the protagonist will no longer have
128
Anthony Mann
either the companionship or the wisdom of Gus and Mungo and he will have to work to make Corinna happy in civilized ways that will, probably, be as perplexing to him as those he has already encountered. Lance Poole’s misplaced optimism and dour fate are made abundantly clear from the opening scenes of Devil‘s Doorway. His warm reception in the local saloon by its owner (Tom Fadden) and Zeke Carmody is swiftly counteracted by the slight tracking shot which reveals Coolan, who intones about “how sour the air got” when the protagonist entered. Lance ignores the remark because he is quickly distracted by the arrival of his aged father (Fritz Leiber) and Red Rock (James Mitchell). When his parent addresses him in Shoshone, Poole asks if he has forgotten English and proceeds to speak to him in that language. This obvious attempt on the protagonist’s part to assimilate to his society goes for nothing when Lance must ride to town for help for his dying father. The indifference he encounters from Coolan and the physician, Dr. MacQuillan (Harry Antrim), who are playing cards in the saloon, starts Poole’s descent into defeat and death. The conflicting values of father and son are made apparent in the earlier scene when Lance returns to the ranch and tells his parent that he’s got “a saddlebag full of dreams” about the future in Sweet Meadows. The protagonist wants to make their home a place where there is charity for all because of the riches that will arise out of cultivating the range and their herds. This idyllic vision, with its socialist overtones, is immediately countered by the father’s pessimism which begins with his insistence to his son, “You are again an Indian” and then emphasizes Lance’s Shoshone name, Broken Lance. If that title ironically foreshadows the hero’s fate, the depths of the dying old man’s despair emerge even more strongly when he goes on to say, “The truth will kill you. Our people are doomed.” These remarks provoke confusion in Lance, especially when coupled with the benevolent neglect of the physician who only reluctantly rides back from town to pronounce the older Shoshone dead. Poole’s bitter question about what he owes the bigoted doctor points to how Lance will attempt to ameliorate the racist society which has grown up during his absence. In a montage we see him building up a formidable cattle herd and prospering; however, new land laws are enacted that make it impossible for him to retain the title to Sweet Meadows and everything he and the other Shoshones have labored to achieve. In addition, the first “reward” that Lance derives from his new wealth is his brutal encounter with Stapleton in the saloon. Still hoping that moderation will carry the day, Lance turns to Orrie Masters with the idea that the law can somehow work to his advantage. His initial encounter with her provokes shocked reactions not only from these
4. Mann and the Western
129
principals but also from the girl’s mother (Spring Byington). In a clever subplot, Mann mirrors the younger woman’s acceptance of Lance through the actions of her mother. When Orrie decides that she must visit Sweet Meadows to confer with her client, Mrs. Masters demands to go along and conspicuously brings a shotgun. After a day spent at the ranch, Lance escorts the two women home and bemusedly tells the mother that the next time she takes out a shotgun she should be sure it has a firing pin. By this time Mrs. Masters can laugh at his remark since she has discovered for herself that Poole is anything but a wild savage. This trip to Sweet Meadows is undertaken because Orrie has learned that under the new territorial laws, Broken Lance has no legal standing; indeed, “You’re not an American citizen.” Poole expresses his dismay in rebellious rhetoric, but Miss Masters counters with the inevitable riposte that everyone must obey the law. Like many another protestor, Lance laments the unjustness of such a law in the face of obeying one’s conscience and operating to help real people with real problems. At this point a young Shoshone boy returns from his initiation into manhood. He has been three days in the wilderness, with no provisions, in search of an eagle whose feathers he must bring back to the tribe. As the boy struggles to crawl to the front porch of the ranch, Lance stands aside and tells the horror-stricken Orrie that every Shoshone boy must pass a similar test. The heroine’s idealism becomes even more apparent when she questions whether what the boy has been forced to do and endure isn’t “rather cruel.” Lance’s defense of his tribal ethos not only points up the need to accept the customs and mores of others but also emphasizes the virtue of inculcating self-reliance to the group’s children. His proclivity to deal with the “real” world is then further underscored when Poole allows a group of destitute Shoshones, who have fled the reservation, to stay on his land despite Orrie’s warnings that he is, again, breaking the law. When she asks what he has told the aged, blind chief (John Big Tree) who leads this forlorn band, Lance tells the lady lawyer, “I told them they were home.” Despite her best efforts to broker a compromise between Poole and the sheepherders, who have been induced by Coolan’s promise of abundant fodder for their animals, Orrie is outmaneuvered by her older opponent when she tries to get the townspeople sign a petition in Lance’s favor. Coolan initially circulates a rumor about Miss Masters being in love with the protagonist and then offers to sign her petition after he had learned that Poole has taken direct action against the sheepmen. As events spiral into ever-greater violence, the protagonist emerges in a native headdress and is photographed in deep shadows as he argues with Orrie about how he must fight to protect his property. His outburst is followed by a brief moment in which he almost
130
Anthony Mann
takes her hand, but his failure to do so clearly indicates that Lance cannot be saved through love. The last conversation between Orrie and Lance occurs after his ranch house has been burned and the siege of Sweet Meadows has been taken over by the army. Even though Coolan is dead, the deaths of so many others (Zeke Carmody, Rod MacDougall) have made the hero’s demise virtually certain; Poole echoes his father when he tells the lawyer, “It’s hopeless.” Her urging that he will receive a “fair trial” does nothing to assuage Lance’s bitterness. After he sarcastically tells her to comfort the Shoshone women and children who are being taken to the reservation with such ideas, Lance dismisses Orrie by saying that he cannot accept her “feeling.” He chooses to fight and die rather than to give in to her pleas; at best, he can only wistfully note that love between them might have worked “a hundred years from now.” In addition to the clever ways in which he presents the melancholy relationship of Lance and Orrie, Mann uses other devices to make thematic and plot points in Devil‘s Doorway. A barking dog greets Lance upon his initial entry into the town and, after Coolan’s hostility has been established and the protagonist prepares to ride off with his father and Red Rock, the same animal barks furiously and chases the Shoshones out. In Sweet Meadows, Lance’s father momentarily stumbles in getting up to the porch as a prelude to his ominous and bitter warnings and subsequent death. When the sheepmen arrive in the town, Mann has Poole driving his cattle in at the same time that their flocks enter from the opposite direction; the cattle drive the sheep to the side and then thunder past to foreshadow the conflict between these two groups. Finally, just before his death, we see Lance fondly holding his father’s pipe as a way of conveying the losses—of the past and of his identity—that he has experienced. Familiar elements of the director’s style abound in Devil’s Doorway. The low ceiling in the saloon and its cramped quarters enable Mann to stage a bravura fistfight and, at the same time, to imply that Poole will always be trapped in the white man’s world of social and legal barriers. The tracking shot that reveals the sinister Coolan at the bar was, by now, a veritable given in the director’s work, and the dynamite battle between the Shoshones and the sheepmen features impressive low-angle shots with horses’ legs in the foreground and struggling men in the background. The same kind of camera set-up will reappear in The Man from Laramie when Lockhart and Hansbro fight in the cattle pen in Coronado, while Lance’s rage, seen when he pummels Stapleton and strangles Coolan, foreshadows the emotionally troubled character that James Stewart will portray in Bend of the River. The last rites for Lance’s father, while set in a cave, echo the more extended treatment of Marcus Aurelius’s funeral in The Fall of the Roman Empire (1964).
4. Mann and the Western
131
The Last Frontier also embodies a clash of cultures, albeit among characters whose motives are not as intellectually pronounced as those of those of the individuals in Devil’s Doorway. Jed Cooper, Colonel Marston, and Corinna are preoccupied with their own short-run desires: They clearly do not share the philosophical or idealistic outlooks espoused by Lance and Orrie in the earlier film. The only character who has found something to die for is the colonel, and he is essentially dismissed as mad by the other characters. The protagonist, Gus, and Corinna all insist that life, not death, is the greater value—and they are supported by Captain Riordan and Captain Clark (Russell Collins) in their attempts to stop Marston’s mad gamble for glory through defeating Red Cloud. The struggle between civilized and uncivilized characters yields numerous ironies in The Last Frontier, for both sides bring worthy and ignoble motives and traits to this conflict. While Jed Cooper represents the natural man who must be tamed into following society’s ways, those who stand for civilization frequently embody contradictory impulses which the scout cannot understand. Colonel Marston can admire Captain Riordan’s initiative in appealing to the high command to stop his planned attack on Red Cloud, but he is not above sending Sergeant Decker to kill the protagonist. When the men fight and Decker is killed, Marston is quick enough and hypocritical enough to order Riordan to arrest Cooper for killing an American soldier. The captain, who voices many of the lessons which the protagonist must learn to become civilized, has been adamant in holding to the law when Cooper managed to “lose” Marston in a bear trap. However, when the scout leaps over the wall, Riordan cannot bring himself to enforce the law by shooting Jed. Such a duality runs even deeper in Colonel Marston, who has been virtually exiled to Fort Shallan because of his conduct at the battle of Shiloh. His title of “the butcher of Shiloh” was earned when his entire command of 1500 men was annihilated there because he ordered an attack against fortified artillery. Marston’s revelation of this stain on his record is prompted by his visit to the post hospital where he eagerly seeks recruits among the wounded for his expedition against Red Cloud. Captain Clark, the fort’s doctor, reacts when Marston proclaims that “holding actions do not win battles” and presses Riordan to ask their commanding officer about his actions at Shiloh. Earlier we have learned that Marston and Clark have a shared past, for the colonel essentially rebuffs the captain’s initial greeting with an implication that the physician has exhibited cowardice in earlier circumstances. Cooper’s conversion to civilization is represented through plot devices, verbal references, and elements of staging. Upon their arrival at Fort Shallan, the trappers are gradually convinced by Captain Riordan to become
132
Anthony Mann
scouts, and Jed’s eagerness to take on this role is caught when he, Gus, and Mungo are confronted by a flag-lowering ceremony. Cooper imitates the soldiers standing at attention and prevails upon his friends to join him in awkward salutes; however, when the ceremony is finished, the protagonist repeats the command of “dismissed” and then laughs uproariously with his companions. In the film’s last scene, in which snow is flying, we see Riordan ordering the company’s new sergeant to dismiss the troops and Jed, now in full uniform, turns to face the camera and once again barks out “dismissed.” This time he laughs in pleasure before he turns to the porch and the waiting Corinna. Both Cooper and Colonel Marston are referred to as animals by other characters. In their first impromptu meeting, Jed tells Corinna, after he discovers that her husband is at Fort Medford, that she is probably a widow since that garrison will have been wiped out by the Indians. When she does not cry over what he has said, the protagonist pointedly asks Corinna, “What kind of woman are you?” and she reacts by calling him an “animal.” After a later prolonged romantic scene between them, Jed rejoins Gus, who has hobbled out of a sick bed to alert the would-be lovers about impending discovery. When the older trapper tells Cooper that he is a veritable “bear” among the civilized people at Fort Shallan, Jed’s distraught reaction is caught in his desperate plea that “I don’t want to be a bear.” That response reveals Cooper’s emerging desire to be civilized in order to possess Corinna. However, he is even more confused by conversations he then has with Captain Clark and Captain Riordan. By this time everyone is aware of Colonel Marston’s suicidal plan to attack Red Cloud, so the protagonist is not surprised when Clark urges that his commander is “not well” and that something needs to be done to thwart his mad plan. Jed abruptly dismisses Clark’s lament by saying that the physician has a pistol which he can use on the colonel. Cooper then asks Riordan to account for the commanding officer’s obviously barbaric nature. When the captain patiently explains that even in civilization there are uncivilized individuals, he does so by stating that Marston is “an animal among us.” Jed then raises one of the ironic themes of The Last Frontier when he asks, “What’s the good of being civilized?” These conversations and his own desire for Corinna drive Cooper into taking direct action against the colonel when Marston insists on seeing the Indian camp. As they spy on Red Cloud’s village, Marston taunts Jed about his wife and raises the conflict of sexual jealousy between them. When the ever-driven commander then wants to hurry back to Fort Shallan, Jed allows Marston to push on ahead of him and fall into a bear trap. As the furious colonel repeatedly orders “Get me out,” Cooper stands on the edge of the
4. Mann and the Western
133
pit and calmly twirls a rope as he informs Marston that they must talk. The scout insists that the officer must renounce his plans for attacking Red Cloud or be left in the trap to die. Not surprisingly, despite Jed’s best efforts and use of the rope as a lure, Marston refuses and the scout rides back to the fort. When he gets there and announces that he has “lost” the colonel, Jed is dumbfounded by the reactions of Riordan and Corinna, for in his mind he has simply done what they and all the others wanted him to do. The captain immediately condemns Cooper as a murderer and summarily dismisses him as one who is “not fit to wear a uniform” because he does not understand the need for unquestioning obedience within the military world. Jed then goes to Corinna and points out that the colonel “did it to himself”; however, when she is less than enthusiastic about this explanation, the mystified protagonist insists, “It’s what you all wanted!” Now enraged because he has tried to protect Corinna and been chastised, Jed slaps her and then goes back to retrieve the colonel. After he has hoisted Marston up, the colonel mockingly says, “I know my wife” and, thus, wins a psychological victory over Cooper. Mann’s affection for location work is also clearly displayed in The Last Frontier, especially in the ways in which the interior space of Fort Shallan is photographed and utilized: we are never allowed to forget that the wooden enclosure is full of entries and obstacles, and its physicality is emphasized by the fluid camera trackings that demarcate its architectonics. In addition, the topography of the surrounding wooded area is caught time and time again from the opening sequence in which Red Cloud’s braves waylay Jed, Gus, and Mungo through the final battle in the opening and trees in which Marston is killed and Cooper leads the retreat. The protagonist’s skills in scouting and quietly moving to overpower individual enemies are symbolized by his costumes which camouflage him so that he blends into the landscape. Some other notable stylistic similarities between The Last Frontier and Mann’s other works can be seen in the numerous odd camera angles used in the fight between Cooper and Decker when that struggle is confined to the scout’s quarters, and the reversal in mood achieved when a love scene between Jed and Corinna is interrupted by gunfire and a medium close-up of a trooper with a hatchet lodged in his back. The film also echoes The Tin Star’s apprenticeship theme when Jed silently scales the fort’s wall and puts a knife to the throat of a young sentry with the warning that the boy must learn to use his ears as well as eyes while on guard duty. The symbolic square formed by guards’ shields in The Fall of the Roman Empire appears many times in The Last Frontier, perhaps most noticeably when a drunken and disillusioned Jed countermands Colonel Marston’s orders for marching out to success by telling the assembled troopers to kiss
134
Anthony Mann
their girls goodbye because they will be dead after tomorrow. Jed Cooper also resembles the persona created by James Stewart in his westerns with Mann: If his dismissal of Clark’s request about Marston shows that the protagonist will not take any chances for anyone else, a later scene in the woods finds the hero repeatedly knifing a fallen foe with a look of savage rage and pleasure alternating on his face. A principal theme of The Last Frontier is the conflict between the morally and emotionally settled world of civilized society, as embodied by Riordan and Corinna, and the turbulent and uncertain world of freelance individuals like Gus and Mungo. In this intellectual struggle, Jed Cooper is obviously torn between following what is comfortable and familiar and going over to the more uncomfortable and strange. To its credit, Mann’s film shows virtues on both sides, and in so doing suggests one of the most enduring issues in a genre in which heroes must use violence to achieve peace and barbaric skills to bring about the settled conditions in which civilization can flourish. Unlike so many standard westerns, The Last Frontier locates its protagonist’s motivations not in glorious and pure self-sacrifice but rather in his desire to possess the woman he sees as the embodiment of all the rewards of civilization. While Jed’s struggle to become worthy of Corinna can be seen as a conflict between the uniform (duty) and love (personal indulgence), the hero’s actions eventually promote the greater good, especially after his error in imagining that those around him wanted Colonel Marston murdered. Captain Riordan remains the voice of civilized rationality and military obligation throughout by virtue of his constant insistence that Fort Shallan must be held against Red Cloud, at least until spring when reinforcements will arrive. The captain attempts to convince Marston of this obligation, but to no avail as the colonel simply overrides him as post commander by virtue of his superior rank. Riordan’s allegiance to the army and its ways of doing things prevents him from directly removing his superior; at the same time, he will not act against Cooper when following strict military rules would require him to kill the scout. In classical genre terms Captain Riordan may have right on his side, but he is too civilized to impose his own morality on his surroundings. Only a more savage man, Cooper, can save the situation once Marston has been allowed to blunder into another defeat. Thus, the notion that building and holding a position in the wilderness is more important than the marital or emotional needs of any single individual emerges as a primary theme in the world of The Last Frontier. Jed Cooper must learn the virtue of doing the dirty work of civilization by eschewing the free and wild existence he has lived and become a soldier dedicated to carrying out the orders of his superiors—a change that is foreshad-
4. Mann and the Western
135
owed in his reporting first to Gus about Red Cloud’s encampments and not going initially to Marston, who had ordered him to undertake this mission. Only when Jed has been rebuked by Mungo as no longer belonging “out there” in the wilderness from which they have emerged, been present to save the remains of Marston’s command, and become a real soldier can he enter the disciplined and emotionally controlled worlds of Fort Shallan, Corinna, and, by implication, civilization itself.
War in the Family: The Furies (1950) and Man of the West (1958) Mann’s roots in the theater and his predilection for classical drama made The Furies and Man of the West projects that he would temperamentally find attractive. These films revolve around the often emotionally explosive psychodynamics of family life and the sobering dictum that the sins of the parents devolve upon their children. Thus, The Furies resembles King Lear in that a shortsighted patriarch must be undone and then redeemed by his children, while Man of the West echoes the Oresteia in that the crimes of an older generation must be expunged by the acts of the younger generation it has produced. Of course, the plots of these films do not rigidly imitate those of Shakespeare and Aeschylus; however, their resolutions do echo those masterpieces while showing how far Mann had come within the western genre. It is surely appropriate that Man of the West offers the most subdued finale not only of any of the director’s westerns but of any of his works. The Furies ends with a conventional romantic fadeout as Vance Jeffords (Barbara Stanwyck) and her lover, Rip Darrow (Wendell Corey), take the corpse of T.C. Jeffords (Walter Huston) back to be buried at the family ranch, the Furies. As they ride, they decide that their first son will be named T.C. as a measure of the reconciliation that has occurred between the cattle baron and his daughter just prior to the patriarch’s death at the hands of Mama Herrera (Blanche Yurka). Man of the West’s more somber conclusion finds Link Jones (Gary Cooper) and Billie Ellis (Julie London) riding away from the scene of the showdown between the protagonist and the savage outlaw patriarch Dock Tobin (Lee J. Cobb). Link and Billie clearly realize there can be no romantic future for them. He must return to his wife and family and she must live content with having discovered that there is a good man worthy of being loved, if only for a time. Both films feature complicated love triangles that are at the center of their primary thematic concerns. In The Furies, Vance is initially torn between her longstanding feelings for Juan Herrera (Gilbert Roland) and the attraction of newcomer Rip Darrow, neither of whom finds favor in the eyes of
136
Anthony Mann
her father. T.C. manages to show up the gambler by offering him money to abandon Vance, and the old man then hangs Juan in spite of the Herreras agreeing to abandon their “squatter’s rights” on his property. In both cases, the father deliberately acts in front of the daughter to assert his control. These acts, coupled with the arrival of Flo Burnett (Judith Anderson) as T.C.’s wife, drive Vance to seek revenge on her parent. The romantic triangle is much less prominent in Man of the West for we never see the wife that Link Jones has left behind before setting out to find a schoolteacher for his hometown. Nevertheless, this woman’s existence clearly dominates at the end of the film when the protagonist must abandon any hope of a future with Billie. It is, of course, once again a measure of Mann’s growing sophistication that he relies on his audience to remember
Lee J. Cobb (as Dock Tobin), Julie London (as Billie Ellis), and Gary Cooper (as Link Jones) in Man of the West (United Artists, 1958). The mad outlaw patriarch (Cobb) must be killed by Mann’s protagonist (Cooper) but not before he rapes the singer. Mann’s final western sees his main character annihilate the criminal “family” with whom he grew up years before.
4. Mann and the Western
137
this connection: He has come to understand that one of the basic pleasures for some viewers is actively drawing inferences instead of simply being shown every plot detail. At the same time that he is achieving this level of artistry, Mann is still producing a work that entertains by its immediate on-screen developments. Familiar devices that the director employs include high places to which characters either ascend or from which they descend. The Herrera mountaintop fortress is assaulted in a veritable dress rehearsal for the intricate scaling attacks in Winchester ’73 and The Naked Spur. Only T.C.’s use of dynamite and his own personal bravery turn the tide in his favor in this pitched battle. We even see him stop briefly, despite falling rocks and ricocheting bullets, to scratch his back on a rock and then, after the Herreras have given up, to call out his ranch hands as “my brave lads” as they emerge from various hiding places. At the conclusion of the train robbery in Man of the West, Sam Beasley (Arthur O’Connell) must conspicuously pull himself up to where Link is standing, peering down at him, in a set-up that efficiently shows that Jones must become the other man’s guide and protector. At the climax, Link goes after Dock Tobin, who is on a crest above him. As the crazed villain comes down from this lofty perch, shooting wildly, Link guns down the embodiment of his own evil past. A pair of scissors figures prominently when Vance and Flo have a heated discussion about the latter’s impending marriage to T.C. That exchange occurs in the room of the patriarch’s deceased first wife, which has been preserved as a veritable shrine where T.C. spends at least an hour upon any return to the ranch. His son Clay (John Bromfield) had chided his sister for going in there and actually wearing one of their mother’s dresses just before the old man’s arrival in the opening sequence. Vance is, thus, dismayed that Flo wants to talk in the mother’s room, and she becomes even more upset when Mrs. Burnett announces her engagement to T.C. and their plan to send Vance on a world tour. Vance accuses Flo of simply wanting her father’s money and then picks up the scissors when T.C. enters and confirms what she has been told. Mann’s protagonist then hurls the scissors at her rival for his affections, and disfigures Mrs. Burnett’s face as well as precipitating the lynching of Juan Herrera by the enraged patriarch. The knife that Coaley (Jack Lord) brandishes throughout the “strip tease” scene in Man of the West carries a comparable symbolic weight. In a significant set of gestures, Dock momentarily caresses the singer’s hair and then his underling repeats that movement, only he uses the knife instead of his hand. In the sequence which follows, Coaley orchestrates Billie’s disrobing while holding the knife to Link’s throat and the girl reveals her feelings for the beleaguered protagonist by agreeing to the outlaw’s demands only
138
Anthony Mann
after she sees blood on Jones’s skin. Later, on the trail when Link provokes Coaley into a fight, he taunts the younger man by urging that he needs a knife in order to be brave enough to tussle with him. In a clever juxtaposition, their savage struggle culminates with the protagonist ripping Coaley’s clothes off in a mock reenactment of the humiliation he had earlier imposed on Billie. Mann’s finesse with landscapes is also prominent as his camera records impressionistic shadows and looming cacti as backgrounds in The Furies and the progress from verdant countryside to desolate hills and somber desert in Man of the West. While much of the action takes place in interior locations (the Jeffords ranch house and the bedraggled shack in which the Tobin gang is holed up), the exterior locations lend an obvious grandeur to the tales Mann is presenting. T.C. Jeffords and Dock Tobin ultimately become largerthan-life figures because of their associations with the surrounding terrain. The patriarch of the Furies dominates men and animals in the outdoors, while the mad outlaw calls down his final challenge to Link from a cliff that visually dominates the man and objects below. The screenplays of these films also utilize repeated phrases to mark clear dramatic movements in their plots. Vance refers to her father as the “top man” in her world when T.C. returns with the banker Reynolds (Albert Dekker) after his initial visit to San Francisco. She then uses the same expression with Rip Darrow when she invites him to dance at her brother’s wedding party against the wishes of her parent: her repetition naturally foreshadows the resolution in which Vance will end up as supremely content to obey her gambler/banker husband. Sam Beasley is taken aback when Link merges easily into the outlaw world of the Tobins and remarks to the protagonist that “you’ve changed,” not realizing that the hero has simply reverted to his former life. When Cousin Claude (John Dehner) utters the same line, its repetition underscores how the outlaw has “seen through” Link’s manipulation of Dock and implies that Claude will kill his “cousin” rather than see anything happen to the aged outlaw patriarch. Money also figures prominently as a plot device in both of these movies. In The Furies, T.C.’s need for cash has led him to print up his own currency without regard for how many outstanding obligations he has contracted. When Clay makes a seemingly casual reference to his father’s independent financial excesses in front of Reynolds, the banker opines that he may have to delay completing the negotiated loan between T.C. and his employer’s bank until these matters “can be cleared up.” While his weak son has deliberately acted to injure and undermine him in the only way he can, T.C. has only to threaten to expose Reynolds’ affair with one of the ranch’s servants to get the banker to back down. Later, of course, Vance and Rip undo T.C.
4. Mann and the Western
139
by paying him in his own worthless scrip after the patriarch has rounded up all the cattle on his range. Link’s money pouch represents the trust that his neighbors have placed in him, even though they know about his past, and so it embodies his reformed identity as a “good man.” His own sense of responsibility is shown early when he carefully packs the pouch into his traveling bag along with his pistol belt. Unfortunately, Sam Beasley discovers Link’s mission and tries to finagle the protagonist into accepting Billie as a schoolteacher, all within the hearing of a Tobin gang member, Alcott (Jack Williams), who is on the train. Not surprisingly, this outlaw takes Link’s traveling bag when the Tobin gang attacks. Link is distraught when he discovers the pouch has been taken from the stolen bag which he finds lying in the barn to which Dock has sent him and Billie. The hero’s restored sense of himself is only fully complete when he finds the money pouch in the dead Dock Tobin’s vest: Killing his outlaw parent has “healed” both the past and the present for Link. The patriarchs in The Furies and Man of the West are both tyrants capable of asserting their arbitrary wills on those around them at a moment’s notice. Each old man can use violence as we see when T.C. orders the hanging of Juan Herrera and when Dock talks fondly of how he and a much younger Link murdered “old Ben Skull” to get $11,000. As the addled outlaw tells it, Link held this victim while Dock took “the top off his head,” a recollection that moves Tobin to proclaim that in that distant time, “we were big.” T.C. Jeffords tempers his viciousness with a ready acceptance of ill fortune—both with Flo and when he must sell his herd for worthless paper— that redeems him. He can even note that he has felt “cold” ever since Juan’s death as a psychosomatic symptom of guilt. While Dock Tobin wears a scarf inside the heated cabin, no such softness can ever be discerned in him. At best, he keeps his outlaw brood under control and kills Coaley when the latter attempts to shoot an unarmed Link. T.C. and Dock also function as “creators” of Vance and Link; however, once again, the contrasts between these characters are more marked than their similarities. Despite his stubborn temper and propensity for cruelty, the elder Jeffords does provide a role model for Vance, and she obviously recognizes this quality at the end of The Furies. Dock’s immersing of Link in killing and thievery is what the protagonist has deliberately set out to escape from, and the only “benefit” that Jones gets from such training is that it enables him to annihilate the Tobin gang, as he realizes he must if he and Billie are to have any chance to survive. Intrusions into the spaces of other characters are also integral to both plots. Rip Darrow’s arrival at the Jeffords’ wedding starts his relationship with Vance and leads to the many love-hate scenes which will gradually
140
Anthony Mann
Walter Huston in his last role (as the aging but headstrong T.C. Jeffords) and Barbara Stanwyck (as his equally determined daughter, Vance) in The Furies (Paramount, 1950). Mann’s western ultimately suffers from too much romantic and psychological angst and scenes too full of dialogue.
reshape the protagonist’s emotions. Flo Burnett’s arrival and her subsequent wounding by Vance lead, of course, to the final protracted conflict between the daughter and her father over who will control the Furies. Link Jones’s entrance into the darkened outlaw cabin, a place from his earlier life he has instinctively found, sets in motion the struggle by which the hero eradicates his past in order to once again live in the present. Vance Jeffords initially functions as the mistress of her father’s ranch; indeed, even Clay ironically refers to her as a “princess.” She is happy being T.C.’s designated heir and being consoled by the platonic love she feels for Juan until she falls immediately for Rip at her brother’s wedding party. Her own inherent proclivity for control collapses when the gambler fails to appear after she has arranged for him to come to the ranch and even baked a cake to show that she can be a “lady.” Angered by Darrow’s cavalier treatment and the accompanying laughter of her father and El Tigre (Thomas Gomez) at her jilting, Vance angrily rides into town to confront the man who has
4. Mann and the Western
141
humiliated her. Bursting into his room, the headstrong Vance is slapped by Rip and then has her face pushed into a wash bowl. This familiarly styled Mann violence leads to a passionate embrace between them as Rip kisses Vance and she laughs in triumph. At their next meeting Vance openly talks of marriage and Rip reveals that he knows about the $50,000 dowry that T.C. has set aside for his daughter. In a warning that the protagonist chooses to ignore, the gambler insists that he will not “be proposed to”; and this sentiment becomes even more important after he arrives the next day at the Furies. T.C. has decided to offer Darrow a bribe to abandon Vance, and the gambler takes the dowry money much to the dismay of his lover. Darrow rejects Vance because, as he says, “You’re married already ... to the Furies” and she contents herself with complaining to her father after Rip leaves. Vance notes that Darrow is the only man who has ever made her cry, and T.C. knowingly responds, “Welcome home.” When next seen, Darrow appears at the ranch as a representative of the Anaheim Bank that holds the mortgage on the Furies. He and the other bankers have come to warn T.C. that he must drive out the Herreras and the squatters on his land in order for his collateral—the title to his property— to be acceptable to the bank. After this message has been delivered, Vance asks to speak with Darrow alone in order to tell him that all his future dealings with the Jeffords must be done through Scotty Hyslip (Wallace Ford), the ranch’s accountant. Vance then tells Rip, “Don’t ever set foot on the Furies again” before she slaps him. The lovers’ next meeting is an accidental one on the grounds where they originally went on the night of Clay’s wedding. The irate Vance fires a shot at Darrow as he calmly notes, “You’re on the prod.” After she decides to destroy T.C.’s empire, Vance goes to Rip for financing and he, symbolically, gives her the $50,000 dowry which he has deliberately saved. In return for regaining the “Darrow strip,” a piece of land which had belonged to his father, Darrow bankrolls the protagonist; however, his own romantic yearnings come to the surface when he tells Vance that she’s “in love with hate.” In San Francisco, where Vance maneuvers Mrs. Anaheim (Beulah Bondi) in order to set up her father’s final catastrophe, Rip again slaps her and then kisses her, but this time Mann’s protagonist walks out laughing. Their final romantic agony begins as they ride to their favorite trysting place, Rip kisses Vance, and she tells him that too much has happened for them to have any future together, even though he now insists that all he wants is love. T.C.’s death propels Vance back into love with Darrow, and the film’s resigned but happy finale sees them riding to the Furies with all sorts of future plans—all accompanied by an orchestral treatment of the song about her father’s mythical prowess.
142
Anthony Mann
T.C. Jeffords emerges as an almost legendary figure as we see him repeatedly scorning his advanced age by doing things more appropriate to a much younger man. His stormy initial entrance is quickly followed by his extrication of a calf stuck in the mud—a dangerous act because of the Herrera brothers who ride up and momentarily consider killing the “padrone.” Ironically, Juan stops his siblings by pointing out that such a deed, if done in front of Vance, would be barbaric. The patriarch’s confrontations with Rip at the wedding and with Vance, as well as his summary judgment on Juan, underscore the ruthlessness of the man, if also subtly pointing to the kind of character and strength he must have needed to lay claim to the massive area he now commands. His acceptance of Flo’s refusal to help him with his money troubles also sets T.C. apart. When his disfigured socialite wife points out that Jeffords will drop her for a younger woman once he has reestablished his finances, the cattle baron compliments her on being honest. The cattle drive shows T.C. outriding and outworking everyone else. At a campfire with Scotty and El Tigre, the patriarch appears to be sleeping when one of his cowhands starts singing about the mythical rancher and his legendary deeds. The song’s lyrics inspire the patriarch to attempt one last feat as he spots a wild bull grazing near the encampment; when someone mentions that the animal is “the king of the Furies,” T.C. immediately jumps into the saddle and tears out after the beast. As he ropes and, ultimately, overpowers the bull by wrestling its horned head to the ground, the soundtrack emphasizes the song melody and reaches an appropriate crescendo when he declares that “I’m still king!” When he later realizes that Vance and Rip have outsmarted him in the cattle deal, the aged warrior laughingly declares, “I’m back to scratch” and immediately begins making plans for restoring his fortunes. Even though his schemes are cut short by Mama Herrera’s bullet and her triumphant laughter of revenge, the dying T.C. can still praise the skill of his assassin before dying in Vance’s arms. Mann’s increasing sense of artistic compression is readily apparent in The Furies. Thus, when we first see the stern matriarch of the Herrera clan, she is conspicuously armed with a rifle and placed in the foreground of a frame in which Vance and Juan occupy the center. Naturally, when T.C. attacks her mesa home-fortress, Mama Herrera fires gleefully at the attackers and helps to push boulders down on them. The film also relies on portraits of T.C. and his first wife as symbols of the power they exert: His picture dominates the entrance hall of the ranch house, while the dead mother’s image is found in her room which the aged patriarch has kept inviolate since her death. T.C.’s character is further revealed by the bust of Napoleon that adorns his office and the history of that figure he is reading when Rip and Vance come in to see him.
4. Mann and the Western
143
The movie also features numerous musical cues that deftly augment its plot developments. Given that the music score is by the renowned Franz Waxman, such insightful accompaniment is not to be wondered at; his subtle cues help make The Furies much more thematically significant than it might have been. Typically, when we first see the portrait of T.C. the musical theme which will accompany his character is introduced, while his falling into the mud after rescuing the calf is supported by an appropriately comic cue. Vance’s rage at being stood up by Rip is augmented by an angry “stinger” on the soundtrack, while the theme song becomes thoroughly dominant during the cattle roundup. On the final ride back to the ranch with T.C.’s corpse, Waxman reprises that song in a much slower tempo to provide a melancholy feeling, only to end the film with the song being sung again as the final credits appear. Several other Mann films are either echoed or foreshadowed in The Furies. The battle against the Herrera stronghold clearly resembles Lin McAdam’s killing of his brother in Winchester ’73 and Howie Kemp’s initial capture of Ben Vandergroot in The Naked Spur. In each case, the attackers fight not only against bullets and rocks but also against the very terrain through which they must ascend. T.C.’s use of dynamite in the battle harkens back to the tactics Lance Poole uses against the invading sheepmen in Devil’s Doorway, while the back-scratching requests of the Jeffords patriarch are incorporated into the villain’s characterization in The Naked Spur when Ben has Lena do this for him to distract his captors. The dunking of Vance’s head into a wash basin by Rip is, perhaps, perfected in Spartacus (1960) when the title character (Kirk Douglas) drowns the vicious gladiatorial trainer Marcellus (Charles McGraw) in a vat of soup. Several themes emerge in The Furies, nearly all of which touch on the romantic struggles of its central characters. After Flo Burnett becomes T.C.’s fiancée, Vance goes to her father and points out that her mother was probably too much of a “lady” and not nearly enough of a “woman” for her lusty parent. This dichotomy between the female’s “proper” and “improper” roles spills over into the complex love-hate relationship between Vance and Rip. It is only at the end of the film, in what seems a somewhat hurried ending, that we see the heroine bowing to the hero’s demands and accepting the role of being the “good wife.” Mann also juxtaposes violence and love with these characters who slap, kiss, and taunt each other for most of its running time; and this conflict only begins to dissipate when Vance tells Rip that it’s too late for them, for, in so doing, she finally shows the same understanding he initially brought to their romance. Ultimately, their reconciliation makes the omnipotence of romantic love and its clear superiority over hatred, revenge, or simply getting even
144
Anthony Mann
the primary thematic lesson of the film. In that sense The Furies constitutes the most prolonged and difficult love story in a Mann western, even if its conclusion with Vance and Rip smiling at each other falls well within the conventions of Hollywood soap opera. Link Jones is the most complicated protagonist in any of these westerns, and, as such, the character represents a significant thematic development. While Glyn McLyntock in Bend of the River and Jeff Webster in The Far Country, Howie Kemp, and Jed Cooper are either seeking a communal life or driven to see the importance of such an arrangement in their lives, Link Jones has already established himself within a community. Moreover, in doing so, he has managed to overcome his past, get married, start a family, and become a paragon of the town in which he lives, and in which his fellow citizens are aware of his violent earlier life. In essence, Jones has already solved the problems faced by the other Mann protagonists, but then he is thrown back into the very life which he fought to escape. It’s as though McLyntock, who we learn was a border raider, were to be thrown back into the very Missouri in which he operated as an outlaw. The signal difference is that Jones is not merely thrown into a past environment but back into the outlaw band (or “family”) in which he was an integral member. The protagonist’s uneasiness with the wider world is apparent from the opening scenes of Man of the West, for after he changes clothes in the back of a stable at Crosscut, Link nervously decides to put the money pouch and his guns into his traveling bag. At the railway station, Jones acts like a horse or cow as he jumps aside when the train stops and emits a cloud of smoke. Then he is confronted by the town’s marshal (Frank Ferguson) who suspiciously eyes him and asks if they have ever met; Link says no and tells the lawman that his name is “Henry Wright.” The marshal then asks if Jones has ever heard of Dock Tobin and the protagonist’s hurried denial is followed by an ominously composed shot in which the lawman’s pistol and holster dominate half of the frame. To underscore all these reminders of his past and reemphasize his unease, Link is next shown trying to fit into a train seat that is too small for him. Naturally, all the protagonist’s worst fears are realized after the train pulls away and he finds himself on foot with Sam and Billie. His knowledge of the terrain, the place “where outlaws used to ride” as Beasley had noted earlier, leads Link back to the lonely and bedraggled shack in which he lived during his outlaw life. Jones is initially struck that the old place is “still standing” and, when asked by Billie about his past there and who he was then, he goes on to urge that “I don’t know what I was.” After he finds that Dock and the gang are still ensconced inside, Link must quickly agree that he has come back to rejoin them and resume his previous ways in order to save himself
4. Mann and the Western
145
and the others. His charade conceals a terrible fear—that he will be swamped by his past and, thus, lose both his present and his future. Link feels definitely trapped when he realizes that the money with which he has been entrusted has been seized by the outlaws, and he laments to Billie that “I can’t go home” because of its loss. The protagonist then realizes that he must kill all the gang members not only to save himself but also to restore the world which he has made for himself. His ruthlessness, which now comes boiling to the surface, represents an epiphany, for Link can take on the traits of the violent sociopaths by whom he is now surrounded. Thus, when Sam complains about how he is being illtreated by Trout (Royal Dano) as he digs a grave for the fallen Alcott, Link simply picks up a shovel and waves it at the mute gunman to scare him. The protagonist’s descent into the violent world of the Tobin gang reaches its climax in his prolonged fight with Coaley; for, after he begins to strip the younger outlaw and asks “How does it feel?” as revenge for what was done earlier to Billie in the shack, Link then starts to strangle his opponent, but he stops short. His insight (“I can’t do it”) is clearly a defining moment for the protagonist. While he can use the methods of the outlaws to destroy them, he cannot indulge his own passions to the extent of enjoying killing another man. Link’s relationship with Billie is also clearly foreshadowed in the film’s opening scene when their paths cross in front of the saloon in which she has been singing. As an old man removes the sign announcing her act, Billie thanks him for not wanting to have his hands all over her and goes on her way. Later, we see Link and Billie cross paths once more at the train station