Ann. Henri Poincar´e 9 (2008), 1–33 c 2008 Birkh¨ auser Verlag Basel/Switzerland 1424-0637/010001-33, published online January 30, 2008 DOI 10.1007/s00023-007-0348-2
Annales Henri Poincar´ e
Rigidity and Positivity of Mass for Asymptotically Hyperbolic Manifolds Lars Andersson, Mingliang Cai, and Gregory J. Galloway Abstract. The Witten spinorial argument has been adapted in several works over the years to prove positivity of mass in the asymptotically AdS and asymptotically hyperbolic settings in arbitrary dimensions. In this paper we prove a scalar curvature rigidity result and a positive mass theorem for asymptotically hyperbolic manifolds that do not require a spin assumption. The positive mass theorem is reduced to the rigidity case by a deformation construction near the conformal boundary. The proof of the rigidity result is based on a study of minimizers of the BPS brane action.
1. Introduction Developments in string theory during the past decade, in particular the emergence of the AdS/CFT correspondence, have increased interest in the mathematical and physical properties of asymptotically hyperbolic Riemannian manifolds. Such manifolds arise naturally as spacelike hypersurfaces in asymptotically anti-de Sitter spacetimes. Asymptotically hyperbolic manifolds have a rich geometry at infinity, as exhibited by, e.g., renormalized volume and Q-curvature. The mass of an asymptotically hyperbolic manifold may, under suitable asymptotic conditions, be defined as the integral of a function defined at infinity, the so-called mass aspect function. This feature is related to the fact that, in contrast to the asymptotically Euclidean case, bounded harmonic functions on an AH manifold are not in general constant, but have nontrivial boundary values at infinity. In this paper we shall prove a scalar curvature rigidity result and a positive mass theorem for asymptotically hyperbolic manifolds. The results do not require a spin assumption. The positive mass theorem is reduced to the rigidity case by a novel deformation construction near the conformal boundary. The proof of the rigidity result is based on a study of minimizers of the BPS brane action.
2
L. Andersson, M. Cai, and G. J. Galloway
Ann. Henri Poincar´e
Let (M n+1 , g) denote an (n + 1)-dimensional Riemannian manifold, and let H denote (n + 1)-dimensional hyperbolic space of curvature K = −1. As a prelude to proving positivity of mass in the asymptotically hyperbolic setting (see the discussion below), we first establish the following rigidity result. n+1
Theorem 1.1. Suppose (M n+1 , g), 2 ≤ n ≤ 6, has scalar curvature S[g] satisfying, S[g] ≥ −n(n+1), and is isometric to Hn+1 outside a compact set. Then (M n+1 , g) is globally isometric to Hn+1 . In the case that (M n+1 , g) is a spin manifold, this theorem follows from a result of Min-oo [19] (see also [2, 13]), as well as from the rigidity part of the more recently proved positive mass theorem for asymptotically hyperbolic manifolds [10, 26]. The main point of Theorem 1.1 is that it does not require a spin assumption. We note, for comparison, that there have been some other recently obtained rigidity results for hyperbolic space [4,7,21,24] that do not require a spin assumption, but these impose conditions on the Ricci curvature. The proof of Theorem 1.1 is based on the general minimal surface methodology of Schoen and Yau [22], adapted to a negative lower bound on the scalar curvature. This means, in our approach, that minimal surfaces are replaced by non-zero constant mean curvature surfaces, and the area functional is replaced by the so-called BPS brane action, as utilized by Witten and Yau [27] in their work on the AdS/CFT correspondence. From the regularity results of geometric measure theory, we require M to have dimension ≤ 7 in order to avoid the occurrence of singularities in co-dimension one minimizers of the brane action1 . In Section 2 we prove a local warped product splitting result, where the splitting takes place about a certain minimizer of the brane action. This splitting result, which extends to the case of negative lower bound on the scalar curvature previous results of Cai and Galloway [5, 6], is then used to prove Theorem 1.1. Our original motivation for proving Theorem 1.1 was to obtain a proof of positivity of mass for asymptotically hyperbolic manifolds that does not require a spin assumption. In [15], Gibbons et al. adapted Witten’s spinorial argument to prove positivity of mass in the 3 + 1 asymptotically AdS setting. More recently, Wang [26], and, under weaker asymptotic conditions, Chru´sciel and Herzlich [10] have provided precise definitions of the mass in the asymptotically hyperbolic setting and have given spinor based proofs of positivity of mass in dimensions ≥ 3. These latter positive mass results may be paraphrased as follows: Theorem 1.2. Suppose (M n+1 , g), n ≥ 2, is an asymptotically hyperbolic spin manifold with scalar curvature S ≥ −n(n + 1). Then M has mass m ≥ 0, and = 0 iff M is isometric to standard hyperbolic space Hn+1 .
1 However,
the work of Christ and Lohkamp [8, 17] offers the possibility of eliminating this dimension restriction.
Vol. 9 (2008)
Positivity of Mass for AH Manifolds
3
Physically, M corresponds to a maximal (mean curvature zero) spacelike hypersurface in spacetime satisfying the Einstein equations with cosmological constant Λ = −n(n + 1)/2. For then the Gauss equation and weak energy condition imply S ≥ −n(n + 1). Here we present the following version of Theorem 1.2, which does not require M to be spin. Theorem 1.3. Let (M n+1 , g), 2 ≤ n ≤ 6, be an asymptotically hyperbolic manifold with scalar curvature S[g] ≥ −n(n+ 1). Assume that the mass aspect function does not change sign, i.e., that it is either negative, zero, or positive. Then, either the mass of (M, g) is positive, or (M, g) is isometric to hyperbolic space. As noted above, the mass aspect function is a scalar function whose integral over conformal infinity determines the mass; see Section 3 for precise definitions. Our approach to proving Theorem 1.3 is inspired by Lohkamp’s variation [18] of the Schoen–Yau [23] proof of the classical positive mass theorem for asymptotically flat manifolds. Our proof makes use of Theorem 1.1, together with a deformation result, which shows roughly that if an asymptotically hyperbolic manifold with scalar curvature satisfying, S ≥ −n(n + 1), has negative mass aspect then the metric can be deformed near infinity to the hyperbolic metric, while maintaining the scalar curvature inequality. This deformation result (Theorem 3.2), along with an analysis of the case in which the mass aspect vanishes identically (Theorem 3.9), and their application to the proof of Theorem 1.3 are presented in Section 3.
2. The rigidity result The aim of this section is to give a proof of Theorem 1.1. 2.1. The brane action Let (M n+1 , g) be an (n + 1)-dimensional oriented Riemannian manifold with volume form Ω. Assume there is a globally defined form Λ such that Ω = dΛ. Let Σn be a compact orientable hypersurface in M . Then Σ is 2-sided in M ; designate one side as the “outside” and the other as the “inside”. Let ν be the outward pointing unit normal along Σ, and let Σ have the orientation induced by ν (i.e., determined by the induced volume form ω = iν Ω). Then, for any such Σ, we define the brane action B by, B(Σ) = A(Σ) − nV(Σ) , (2.1) where A(Σ) = the area of Σ, and V(Σ) = Σ Λ. If Σ bounds to the inside then, by Stokes theorem, V(Σ) = the volume of the region enclosed by Σ. Although Λ is not uniquely determined, Stokes theorem shows that, within a given homology class, B is uniquely determined up to an additive constant. We wish to consider the formulas for the first and second variation of the brane action. First, to fix notations, let A denote the second fundamental form
4
L. Andersson, M. Cai, and G. J. Galloway
Ann. Henri Poincar´e
of Σ; by our conventions, for each pair of tangent vectors X, Y ∈ Tp Σ, A(X, Y ) = ∇X ν, Y ,
(2.2)
where ∇ is the Levi–Civita connection of (M, g) and h = , is the induced metric on Σ. Then H = tr A is the mean curvature of Σ. variation of Σ = Σ0 , with variation Let t → Σt , − < t < , be a normal ∂ ∞ vector field V = ∂t = φν, φ ∈ C (Σ). Abusing notation slightly, set B(t) = t=0 B(Σt ). Then for first variation we have, (2.3) B (0) = (H − n)φ dA . Σ
Thus Σ is a stationary point for the brane action if and only if it has constant mean curvature H = n. Assuming Σ has mean curvature H = n, the second variation formula is given by B (0) = φL(φ) dA , (2.4) Σ
where, 1 L(φ) = − φ + (SΣ − S − |A|2 − H 2 ) φ , (2.5) 2 and where SΣ is the scalar curvature of Σ and S is the scalar curvature of M . Here L is the stability operator associated with the brane action, and is closely related to the stability operator of minimal surface theory. Using the fact that H = n, L can be re-expressed as, 1 L(φ) = − φ + (SΣ − Sn − |A0 |2 ) φ , 2
(2.6)
where Sn = S + n(n + 1) and A0 is the trace free part of A, A0 = A − h. We note that, in our applications, Sn will be nonnegative. A stationary point Σ for the brane action is said to be B-stable provided for all normal variations t → Σt of Σ, B (0) ≥ 0. For operators of the form (2.6), the following proposition is well-known. Proposition 2.1. The following conditions are equivalent. 1. Σ is B-stable. 2. λ1 ≥ 0, where λ1 is the principal eigenvalue of L. 3. There exists φ ∈ C ∞ (Σ), φ > 0, such that L(φ) ≥ 0. In particular, if λ1 ≥ 0, φ in part 3 can be chosen to be an eigenfunction. 2.2. Warped product splitting In this section we prove the local warped product splitting result alluded to in the introduction. As a precursor, we prove the following infinitesimal rigidity result.
Vol. 9 (2008)
Positivity of Mass for AH Manifolds
5
Proposition 2.2. Let (M n+1 , g) be an oriented Riemannian manifold with scalar curvature S satisfying, S ≥ −n(n + 1) . (2.7) n Let Σ be a compact orientable B-stable hypersurface in M which does not admit a metric of positive scalar curvature. Then the following must hold. (i) Σ is umbilic, in fact A = h, where h is the induced metric on Σ. (ii) Σ is Ricci flat and S = −n(n + 1) along Σ. Proof. By Proposition 2.1, there exists φ ∈ Σ, φ > 0, such that L(φ) ≥ 0. The 2 ˜ = φ n−2 h is then given scalar curvature S˜ of Σ in the conformally rescaled metric h by, n n − 1 |∇φ|2 S˜ = φ− n−2 −2 φ + SΣ φ + n−2 φ 2 n − 1 |∇φ|2 (2.8) = φ− n−2 2φ−1 L(φ) + Sn + |A0 |2 + n − 2 φ2 where, for the second equation, we have used (2.6) with f = φ. Since all terms in parentheses above are nonnegative, (2.8) implies that S˜ ≥ 0. If S˜ > 0 at ˜ to some point, then by well known results [16] one can conformally change h a metric of strictly positive scalar curvature, contrary to assumption. Thus S˜ vanishes identically, which implies L(φ) = 0, Sn = 0, A0 = 0 and φ is constant. Equation (2.6), with f = φ then implies that S ≡ 0. By a result of Bourguignon (see [16]), it follows that Σ carries a metric of positive scalar curvature unless it is Ricci flat. Thus conditions (i) and (ii) are satisfied. Proposition 1.1 will be used in the proof of the following local warped product splitting result. Theorem 2.3. Let (M n+1 , g) be an oriented Riemannian manifold with scalar curvature S ≥ −n(n + 1). Let Σ be a compact orientable hypersurface in M which does not admit a metric of positive scalar curvature. If Σ locally minimizes the brane action B then there is a neighborhood U of Σ such that (U, g|U ) is isometric to the warped product ((−, ) × Σ, dt2 + e2t h), where h, the induced metric on Σ, is Ricci flat. By “locally minimizes” we mean, for example, that Σ has brane action less than or equal to that of all graphs over Σ with respect to Gaussian normal coordinates. A related result has been obtained by Yau [28] in dimension three. Proof. Let H(u) denote the mean curvature of the hypersurface Σu : x → expx u(x)ν, u ∈ C ∞ (Σ), u sufficiently small. H has linearization H (0) = L, where L is the B-stability operator (2.6). But by Proposition 2.2, L reduces to − , and hence H (0) = − . We introduce the operator, ∗ ∞ ∞ ∗ H : C (Σ) × R → C (Σ) × R , H (u, k) = H(u) − k, u , (2.9) Σ
6
L. Andersson, M. Cai, and G. J. Galloway
Ann. Henri Poincar´e
which one easily checks has invertible linearization about (0, 0), since the kernel of H (0) contains only the constants. By the inverse function theorem, for each τ sufficiently small there exists u = uτ and k = kτ such that H(uτ ) = kτ and u dA = τ . Since u (0) ∈ ker H (0), the latter equation implies that u (0) = Σ τ const > 0. Thus for τ sufficiently small, the hypersurfaces Σuτ form a foliation of a neighborhood U of Σ by constant mean curvature hypersurfaces. Using coordinates on Σ and the normal field to the Σuτ ’s to transport these coordinates to each Σuτ , we have, up to isometry, U = (−, ) × Σ
g|U = φ2 dt2 + ht ,
(2.10)
where ht = hij (t, x)dxi dxj , φ = φ(t, x) and Σt = {t} × Σ has constant mean curvature. Since Σ locally minimizes the brane action, we have, B(0) ≤ B(t) for all t ∈ (−, ), for sufficiently small. Let H(t) denote the mean curvature of Σt . H = H(t) obeys the evolution equation, dH = L(φ) , (2.11) dt where for each t, L is the operator on Σt given in Equation (2.5). Since Σ locally minimizes the brane action, we have H(0) = n. We show H ≤ n for t ∈ [0, ). If this is not the case, there exists t0 ∈ (0, ) such that H(t0 ) > n. Moreover, t0 can be chosen so that H (t0 ) > 0. Let S˜ be the scalar curvature of Σt0 in the 2 conformally related metric ˜ h = φ n−2 ht0 . Arguing similarly as in the derivation of (2.8), Equations (2.5) and (2.11) imply, 2 n − 1 |∇φ|2 − n−2 −1 2 2 ˜ S=φ 2φ H (t0 ) + S + |A| + H + , (2.12) n − 2 φ2 where all terms are evaluated on Σt0 . The Schwartz inequality gives, |A|2 ≥ H 2 /n > n. This, together with the assumed scalar curvature inequality (2.7), implies that S + |A|2 + H 2 > 0. We conclude from (2.12) that Σt0 carries a metric of positive scalar curvature, contrary to assumption. Thus, H ≤ n on [0, ), as claimed. Now, by the formula for the first variation of the brane action, it follows that (H − n)φ dA ≤ 0 , for all t ∈ [0, ) . (2.13) B (t) = Σt
But since B achieves a minimum at t = 0, it must be that B (t) = 0 for t ∈ [0, ). Hence, the integral in (2.13) vanishes, which implies that H = n on [0, ). A similar argument shows that H = n on (−, 0], as well. Equation (2.11) then implies that L(φ) = 0 on each Σt . Hence, by Proposition 2.1, each Σt is B-stable. From Proposition 2.2, we have that At = ht , where At is the second fundamental form of Σt , and that φ only depends on t. By a simple change of t-coordinate in (2.10), we may assume without loss of generality that φ = 1. Then the condition ∂h At = ht becomes, in the coordinates (2.10), ∂tij = 2hij . Upon integration this 2t gives, hij (t, x) = e hij (0, x), which completes the proof of the theorem.
Vol. 9 (2008)
Positivity of Mass for AH Manifolds
7
2.3. Proof of the rigidity result In order to prove Theorem 1.1 it is convenient to work with an explicit representation of hyperbolic space Hn+1 . We start with the half-space model (H n+1 , gH ), where, H n+1 = {(y, x1 , . . . , xn ) : y > 0}, and 1 (2.14) gH = 2 dy 2 + (dx1 )2 + · · · + (dxn )2 , y and make the change of variable y = e−t , to obtain Hn+1 = (Rn+1 , g0 ), where, (2.15) g0 = dt2 + e2t (dx1 )2 + · · · + (dxn )2 . As in the statement of Theorem 1.1, let (M n+1 , g) be a Riemannian manifold with scalar curvature S[g] satisfying S[g] ≥ −n(n + 1). We assume that there are compact sets K ⊂ M , K0 ⊂ Rn+1 such that M − K is diffeomorphic to Rn+1 − K0 , and, with respect to Cartesian coordinates (t, x1 , . . . , xn ) on the complement of K, g = g0 . We want to show that (M n+1 , g) is globally isometric to Hn+1 . Since M is simply connected near infinity, it is in fact sufficient to show that M has everywhere constant curvature KM = −1. Our approach to proving this is to partially compactify (M, g) and then minimize the brane action in a suitable homology class. To partially compactify, we use the fact that the translations xi → xi + xi0 are isometries on (Rn+1 , g0 ). Choosing a > 0 sufficiently large, we can enclose the compact set K in an infinitely long rectangular box, with sides determined by the “planes”, xi = ±a, i = 1, . . . , n, −∞ < t < ∞. We can then identify points on opposite sides, xi = −a, xi = a, i = 1, . . . , n, of the box in the obvious manner to ˆ , gˆ). Note that outside the obtain an identification space which we denote by (M compact set K, ˆ = R × T n , gˆ = dt2 + e2t h , M (2.16) n ˆ , gˆ) is just a standard hyperbolic where h is a flat metric on the torus T . Thus, (M cusp outside the compact set K, with scalar curvature satisfying S[ˆ g] ≥ −n(n + 1) globally. ˆ bounded Choose b > 0 large so that K is contained in the region of M between the toroidal slices t = ±b, and fix a t-slice Σ0 = {t0 } × T n , t0 > b. Σ0 ˆ into an “inside” and an “outside”, the inside being the component separates M ˆ of M − Σ0 containing the cusp end t = −∞. We consider the brane action of hypersurfaces Σ homologous to Σ0 , B(Σ) = A(Σ) − nV (Σ) .
(2.17)
We note, as is needed to define B(Σ) unambiguously, that since Σ is homologous to Σ0 it, too, has a distinguished “inside” and “outside”, determined by the fact that both Σ0 and Σ are homologous to a t-slice far out on the cusp end. We now want to minimize the brane action B in the homology class [Σ0 ]. The basic approach is to consider a minimizing sequence Σ1 , Σ2 , . . . and use the compactness results of geometric measure theory to extract a regular limit surface. The potential difficulty with this approach is that, in principle, the surfaces
8
L. Andersson, M. Cai, and G. J. Galloway
Ann. Henri Poincar´e
Σ
Σ
U
ˆ Σ
K
Σ
Σ0 t ˆ Figure 1. Replacing Σ by Σ.
ˆ. Σ1 , Σ2 , . . ., or portions of them, may drift out to infinity along either end of M But, in fact, that can be avoided in the present situation, owing to the existence of natural barrier surfaces, namely the t-slices themselves. Fix t-slices Σ = {t1 } × Σ, t1 > t0 , and Σ = {t2 } × Σ, t2 < −b. We show that any minimizing sequence can be replaced by a minimizing sequence contained in the region between Σ and Σ . To this end, consider a hypersurface Σ homologous to Σ0 that extends beyond Σ into the region t < t2 . Without loss of generality we may assume Σ meets Σ transversely. Let D be the part of Σ meeting {t ≤ t2 }, and let U be the domain bounded by Σ and D. Then ∂U consists of D and a ˆ be the hypersurface homologous to Σ0 obtained from Σ by part D of Σ . Let Σ replacing D with D (see Figure 2). Since U is contained in a region where the metric (2.16) applies, and since in this region div(∂t ) = n, we apply the divergence theorem to obtain, ˆ nV(Σ) − nV(Σ) = n vol(U ) = div(∂t )dV U = ∂t , ndA + ∂t , ∂t dA D
D
ˆ . ≥ −A(D) + A(D ) = −A(Σ) + A(Σ) ˆ ≤ B(Σ). By a similar argument Rearranging this inequality gives the desired, B(Σ) the same conclusion holds if Σ extends beyond Σ into the region {t > t1 }. Thus, we can choose a minimizing sequence Σi , for the brane action within the homology class [Σ0 ] that is confined to the compact region between Σ and Σ . Since V(Σi ) ≤ V(Σ ), we are ensured that limi→∞ B(Σi ) > −∞. Then the compactness and regularity results of geometric measure theory (see, e.g., [14, 22] and
Vol. 9 (2008)
Positivity of Mass for AH Manifolds
9
references therein) guarantee the existence of a regular embedded hypersurface S homologous to Σ0 that achieves a minimum of the brane action on [Σ0 ]. In general S will be a sum of connected embedded surfaces, S = S1 + · · · + Sn . The next thing we wish to observe is that there is a nonzero degree map from S to the n-torus Σ0 . This map comes from the ‘almost product’ structure ˆ given in (2.10). A simple deformation of the t-lines in the vicinity of K of M ˆ → Σ0 such can be used to produce a continuous projection type map P : M that K gets sent to a single point on Σ0 under P , and such that P ◦ j = id, ˆ is inclusion. Then f = P ◦ i : S → Σ0 , where i : S → M ˆ where j : Σ0 → M is inclusion, is the desired nonzero degree map. Indeed, f induces the map on homology f∗ : Hn (S) → Hn (Σ0 ), and using that S is homologous to Σ0 , we compute, f∗ [S] = P∗ (i∗ [S]) = P∗ (j∗ [Σ0 ]) = id∗ [Σ0 ] = Σ0 = 0. Thus, by linearity of f∗ , at least one of the components of S, S1 , say, admits a nonzero degree map to the n-torus. By a result of Schoen and Yau [22], which does not require a spin assumption, S1 does not admit a metric of positive scalar curvature. (In fact it admits a metric of nonnegative scalar curvature only if it is flat). Moreover, we know that S1 minimizes the brane action in its homology class (otherwise there would exist a hypersurface homologous to Σ0 with brane action strictly less than that of S). Thus, we can apply Theorem 2.3 to conclude that a neighborhood U of S1 splits as a warped product, U = (−u0 , u0 ) × S1
gˆ|U = du2 + e2u h ,
(2.18)
where the induced metric h on S1 is flat. But since S1 in fact globally maximizes the brane action in its homology class, by standard arguments this local warped product structure can be extended to arbitrarily large u-intervals. Hence K will eventually be contained in this constructed warp product region. It now follows ˆ has constant curvature K ˆ = −1. This in turn implies that M has conthat M M stant curvature KM = −1. By previous remarks, we conclude that M is globally isometric to hyperbolic space.
3. Positivity of mass The aim of this section is to give a proof of Theorem 1.3 on the positivity of mass in the asymptotically hyperbolic setting. We shall adopt here the definition of asymptotically hyperbolic given in Wang [26]: Definition 3.1. A Riemannian manifold (M n+1 , g) is asymptotically hyperbolic provided it is conformally compact, with smooth conformal compactification ˜ , g˜), and with conformal boundary ∂ M ˜ = S n , such that the metric g on a (M n ˜ deleted neighborhood (0, T ) × S of ∂ M = {t = 0} takes the form g = sinh−2 (t)(dt2 + h) ,
(3.19)
10
L. Andersson, M. Cai, and G. J. Galloway
Ann. Henri Poincar´e
where h = h(t, ·) is a family of metrics on S n , depending smoothly on t ∈ [0, T ), of the form, h = h0 + tn+1 k + O(tn+2 ) , (3.20) n n where h0 is the standard metric on S , and k is a symmetric 2-tensor on S . We refer to k as the mass aspect tensor; it is the leading order measure of the deviation of the metric g from the hyperbolic metric. Its trace with respect to h0 , trh0 k, is called the mass aspect function. Up to a normalizing constant, the integral of the mass aspect function over the sphere defines the mass (or energy) of (M, g), mass = S n trh0 k. For convenience, we repeat here the statement of our positivity of mass result. Theorem 3.1. Let (M n+1 , g), 2 ≤ n ≤ 6, be an asymptotically hyperbolic manifold with scalar curvature S[g] ≥ −n(n + 1). Assume that the mass aspect function trh0 k does not change sign, i.e., that it is either negative, zero, or positive. Then, either the mass of (M, g) is positive, or (M, g) is isometric to hyperbolic space. The proof, which makes use of the rigidity result Theorem 1.1, is carried out in the next two subsections. In Subsection 3.1 we obtain the deformation result mentioned in the introduction, see Theorem 3.2 below. This, together with Theorem 1.1, implies that the mass aspect function cannot be negative, see Proposition 3.3. In Subsection 3.2, it is proved, using Theorem 1.1 again, that if the mass aspect function vanishes then (M, g) is isometric to hyperbolic space, see Theorem 3.9. These results together imply Theorem 3.1. 3.1. The deformation result Suppose (M n+1 , g) is asymptotically hyperbolic in the sense of Definition 3.1. Then by making the change of coordinate, t = arcsinh( 1r ), in (3.19) it follows that there is a relatively compact set K such that M \ K = S n × [R, ∞), R > 0, and on M \ K, g has the form, 1 dr2 + r2 h , (3.21) g= 1 + r2 where h = h(·, r) is an r-dependent family of metrics on S n of the form, 1 (3.22) h = h0 + n+1 k + σ , r where h0 is the standard metric on S n , k is the mass aspect tensor and σ = σ(·, r) is an r-dependent family of metrics on S n such that for integers , m ≥ 0, one has, |(r∂r ) ∂xm σ| ≤ C/rn+2 ,
(3.23)
for some constant C. For the proof of the deformation theorem and the positive mass theorem, it is sufficient to assume condition (3.23) for 0 ≤ , m ≤ 2. Let (M n+1 , g) be asymptotically hyperbolic, with scalar curvature satisfying, S[g] ≥ −n(n + 1). What we now prove is that if the mass aspect function of (M, g) is pointwise negative then g can be deformed on an arbitrarily small neighborhood of infinity to the hyperbolic metric, while preserving (after a change of scale) the
Vol. 9 (2008)
Positivity of Mass for AH Manifolds
11
scalar curvature inequality S ≥ −n(n + 1). A more precise statement is given below. Theorem 3.2. Let the metric g be given as above. Suppose that the scalar curvature of g, S[g], satisfies S[g] ≥ −n(n+1). If the mass aspect function trh0 k is pointwise negative, then for any sufficiently large R1 > R there exists a metric gˆ on M such that, g, R ≤ r ≤ R1 (3.24) gˆ = 1 2 2 ga = dr + r h0 , 9λR1 ≤ r < ∞ , r2 1+
a
where a ∈ (0, 1), and such that, n(n + 1) . (3.25) a (The constant λ > 1 depends only on the mass aspect function; see Section 3.1.1.) S[ˆ g] ≥ −
Theorems 1.1 and 3.2 may be combined to give the following result. Proposition 3.3. Let (M n+1 , g), 2 ≤ n ≤ 6, be an asymptotically hyperbolic manifold with scalar curvature satisfying, S[g] ≥ −n(n + 1). Then the mass aspect function trh0 k cannot be everywhere pointwise negative. Proof. Suppose to the contrary that the mass aspect function is strictly negative. Given any p ∈ M , choose R large enough so that p is not in the end S n × [R, ∞). Theorem 3.2, together with a rescaling of the metric, implies the existence of a metric g˜ on M such that (M, g˜) satisfies the hypotheses of Theorem 1.1. Hence, (M, g˜) is isometric to hyperbolic space Hn+1 . But, modulo the change of scale, by our construction, g˜ will differ from g only at points on the end S n × [R, ∞). It follows that (M n+1 , g) has constant negative curvature curvature in a neighborhood of p. Since p is arbitrary, (M n+1 , g) must have globally constant negative curvature, which, by the asymptotics of (M n+1 , g), must equal −1. Since M is simply connected at infinity, we conclude that (M n+1 , g) is isometric to hyperbolic space Hn . But this contradicts the assumption that the mass aspect function is negative. Proof of Theorem 3.2. We now turn to the proof of the deformation result. Introduce coordinates x = (x1 , x2 , . . . , xn ) on S n . We use the convention that for a function f = f (x, r), f (x, r) = ∂r f (x, r), and f (x, r) = ∂r2 f (x, r). Let ωij and kij be the components of h0 and k, respectively, with respect to the coordinates (x1 , x2 , . . . , xn ). Then g in (3.21) takes the form
dr2 αij g= + r2 ωij + n+1 dxi dxj 2 1+r r where αij = kij (x) +
βij (x, r) . r
12
L. Andersson, M. Cai, and G. J. Galloway
Ann. Henri Poincar´e
We are assuming (cf., (3.23)) αij satisfies the bounds, |(r∂r ) ∂xm αij | ≤ Λ .
(3.26)
for all integers , m, 0 ≤ , m ≤ 2. Let μ denote the the mass aspect function, μ = trh0 k = ω ij kij ; by assumption, |μ| > 0. Let μ ¯ = maxx |μ(x)|, μ = minx |μ(x)|. We shall be making estimates of geometric quantities in terms of the above defined constants. In particular, we shall use a generic constant C = C(n, R, Λ, μ ¯, μ) depending only on n, R, Λ, μ ¯, μ, which may change from line to line. We shall further use the notation O(1/rk ) for a quantity bounded by C(n, R, Λ, μ ¯ , μ)/rk . 3.1.1. Preliminary definitions. Fix R1 > R to be specified later. Set 1 n+1 μ ¯ λ= . μ Let a = a(n, μ ¯, μ, R1 ) ∈ (0, 1) be a number such that μ 1 n+1 4 μ ¯ n+1 3 < . − 1 < n 3 (4λR1 )n+1 a n 4 (3λR1 )n+1 To show such an a exists, it suffices to show that μ μ ¯ n+1 4 n+1 3 < n+1 n 3 (4λR1 ) n 4 (3λR1 )n+1 or equivalently n+1 3 4 μ ¯ λ > . 4 3 μ By our choice of λ, this is equivalent to n 4 >1 3 which is obviously true. It follows from the definition that a 1 as R1 ∞. It is straightforward to show the existence of a smooth function ψ : R → R+ such that for any R1 > R.
1 , r ≤ 7λR1 ψ= (3.27a) 0 , r ≥ 8λR1 ψ (r) ≤ 0 for all r
(3.27b)
b (3.27c) r c |ψ (r)| ≤ 2 (3.27d) r where b, c are positive constants. In the following, we consider a fixed function ψ satisfying the conditions (3.27). |ψ (r)| ≤
Vol. 9 (2008)
Positivity of Mass for AH Manifolds
13
In the deformation construction, we shall consider functions f : S n ×[R, ∞) → R, satisfying the following conditions. f (x, R) = 1 ,
for x ∈ S n ,
(3.28a)
and for (x, r) ∈ S n × [R, ∞) the conditions 1 ≤f ≤2 2 1 |f (x, r)| ≤ 2 r 1 |ΔS n f | ≤ n r n 1 |∇S f |2 ≤ n . r In particular, the constant function f ≡ 1 satisfies conditions (3.28). In carry out the deformation from the metric g to the metric ga , we shall metrics of the form, 1 ψαij 2 2 gf,ψ = dr + r ωij + n+1 dxi dxj . 1 + r2 f r
(3.28b) (3.28c) (3.28d) (3.28e) order to consider
(3.29)
Given ψ, the main objective is to construct an f satisfying (3.28) so that gf,ψ has the required properties. 3.1.2. Scalar curvature formulas. We need formulas for the scalar curvature S[gf,ψ ] of the metric gf,ψ . Lemma 3.4. Let f, ψ satisfy the assumptions (3.28) and (3.27). Then the metric gf,ψ has scalar curvature, 1 S[gf,ψ ] = −n(n + 1)f − nrf + n (n|μ|ψ − r|μ|ψ )f + J , (3.30) r where J is a term bounded by C(n, R, Λ, μ ¯, μ)/rn+2 , and such that J = 0 for r ≥ 8λR1 . Proof. We describe our approach to carrying out this computation. Setting, ψαij h = 1 + r2 f and gij = r2 ωij + n+1 , (3.31) r gf,ψ becomes, 1 2 dr + gij dxi dxj . h Applying the Gauss equation to an r-slice Σ = S n × {r} gives, gf,ψ =
S[gf,ψ ] = SΣ + |B|2 − H 2 + 2Ric(N, N ) ,
(3.32)
(3.33)
where SΣ , B and H are the scalar curvature, second fundamental form and mean curvature of Σ, respectively, and Ric(N, N ) is the ambient Ricci curvature in the ∂ direction of the unit normal N = h1/2 ∂r . In terms of coordinates, B and H are
14
L. Andersson, M. Cai, and G. J. Galloway
Ann. Henri Poincar´e
√ given by, bij = B(∂i , ∂j ) = 12 h ∂r gij , and H = g ij bij . We then compute each term in (3.33) in turn. For the first three terms we obtain, making use of the bounds (3.26) and (3.27) 1 n(n − 1) SΣ = + O (3.34) r2 rn+3 1 1 n n + 1 |μ|ψ 1 |μ|ψ + − + O (3.35) H = h2 r 2 rn+2 2 rn+1 rn+3 n 1 |μ|ψ |μ|ψ |B|2 = Bi j Bj i = h 2 + (n + 1) n+3 − n+2 + O . (3.36) n+4 r r r r Equations (3.35) and (3.36) combine to give, n(n − 1) |μ|ψ − (n − 1)(n + 1) n+3 |B|2 − H 2 = h − r2 r |μ|ψ 1 . + (n − 1) n+2 + O r rn+4
(3.37)
∂ Applying the Raychaudhuri equation to the unit normal N = h1/2 ∂r to the level sets of r, we have, √ 1 (3.38) Ric(N, N ) = −N (H) − |B|2 − hΔΣ √ . h Making use of equations (3.35) and (3.36), we derive from (3.38), 1 n n + 1 |μ|ψ 1 1 |μ|ψ Ric(N, N ) = − h + − + O 2 r 2 rn+2 2 rn+1 rn+3 1 n(n + 1) |μ|ψ |μ|ψ 1 |μ|ψ − n + + O +h 2 rn+3 rn+2 2 rn+1 rn+4 √ 1 (3.39) − hΔΣ √ . h Equations (3.34), (3.37) and (3.39) then combine to give, n + 1 |μ|ψ 1 n(n − 1) n(n − 1) n 1 |μ|ψ S[gf,ψ ] = h − h − − − + O h r2 r2 r 2 rn+2 2 rn+1 rn+3 1 |μ|ψ |μ|ψ |μ|ψ + (n + 1) n+3 − (n + 1) n+2 + n+1 + O h r r r rn+4 √ 1 1 − 2 h Σ √ + O . (3.40) rn+3 h
Setting h = 1 + r2 f in the above, and making use of the bounds (3.28) and (3.27), one derives in a straight forward manner equation (3.30). Moreover, it is clear from the computations that all ‘big O’ terms vanish once ψ vanishes. The following Corollary gives the form of the scalar curvature which will be used in the deformation construction.
Vol. 9 (2008)
Positivity of Mass for AH Manifolds
15
Corollary 3.5. Let f, ψ satisfy the assumptions (3.28) and (3.27). Then, there is a nonnegative function A1 : [R, ∞) → R+ , independent of f , such that A1 ≤ C(n, R, Λ, μ ¯ , μ)
and
A1 = 0
for
r ≥ 9λR1 ,
and such that the scalar curvature S[gf,ψ ] of gf,ψ satisfies the inequality r n n+1 A1 (r) n+1 S[gf,ψ ] ≥ − n |μ|ψ − |μ|ψ f − + . r r n n r
(3.41)
(3.42)
Proof. Using the product rule, equation (3.30) may be expressed as, n 1 S[gf,ψ ] = − n (rn+1 f ) + n (n + 1)|μ|ψ − r|μ|ψ f r r 1 1 − n (n + 1)|μ|ψ − r|μ|ψ f + O r rn+2 which, by the bounds (3.28) and (3.27) simplifies to, 1 r n n+1 n+1 S[gf,ψ ] = − n |μ|ψ + |μ|ψ f + O − r . r n n rn+2
(3.43)
It follows that there exists a smooth function A : [R, ∞) → R+ , satisfying, A ≤ C(n, R, Λ, μ ¯, μ) and A = 0 for r ≥ 9λR1 , such that, r n n+1 A(r) n+1 S[gf,ψ ] ≥ − n |μ|ψ + |μ|ψ f − n+2 . − (3.44) r r n n r Now define A1 : [R, ∞) → R+ by, A1 (r) =
r n
r
9λR1
A(t) dt . t2
One easily checks that the properties (3.41) hold. Moreover, since, A1 (r) 1 A(r) =− , r n r2
(3.45)
(3.46)
inequality (3.42) follows from (3.44). Finally, it is clear from the construction that A and hence also A1 may be chosen to be independent of f . 3.1.3. Defining η: Rounding the corner. Let η1 (x, r), η2 (r) be given by η1 (x, r) = rn+1 + η2 (r) =
r
r n+1 A1 (r) |μ|ψ − |μ|ψ − , n n r
(3.47a)
n+1
, (3.47b) a where the function A1 appearing in η1 is the function A1 defined in Corollary 3.5. By (3.42), S[g1,ψ ] ≥ − rnn η1 . Further, ga has constant curvature −1/a, and hence S[ga ] = − rnn η2 . In the rest of the argument we shall be choosing R1 sufficiently large, so that the required conditions are satisfied. We shall successively increase R1 as required.
16
L. Andersson, M. Cai, and G. J. Galloway
Ann. Henri Poincar´e
η η1 η2 R1
3λR1
4λR1
7λR1
Figure 2. Construction of η. Lemma 3.6. There is an R1 > R, R1 = R1 (n, R, Λ, μ ¯ , μ) such that the following inequalities hold. η1 (x, r) < η2 (r) ,
R1 ≤ r ≤ 7λR1
(3.48a)
η1 (x, r) − η2 (r) > μ/20 ,
R1 ≤ r ≤ 3λR1
(3.48b)
η2 (r) − η1 (x, r) > μ ¯/10 ,
4λR1 ≤ r ≤ 7λR1 .
(3.48c)
Proof. We need to consider only the interval R1 ≤ r ≤ 7λR1 . There, ψ ≡ 1, and ψ ≡ 0. We start by proving (3.48a). By construction, we have for r ≥ R1 , using |μ| > 0 and the properties of a, after some manipulations, 1 A(r) 1 − 1 (n + 1)rn+1 − η2 − η1 > r a nr 2 μ ¯ 4 (n + 1) 1 A(r) . > − r 3 n (4λ)n+1 nr Since A(r) ≤ C(n, Λ, R, μ ¯, μ), it follows that (3.48a) holds for R1 sufficiently large. Next we prove (3.48b). Since (η1 − η2 ) < 0 for r ≥ R1 , it is sufficient to prove the inequality at r = 3λR1 . We have μ 1 n+1 (3λR1 )n+1 1− η1 (x, 3λR1 ) − η2 (3λR1 ) ≥ + a n (3λR1 )n+1 A1 (3λR1 ) − , 3λR1 which by using the properties of a and simplifying gives, 3 n+1 A1 (3λR1 ) μ− > 1− . 4 n 3λR1
Vol. 9 (2008)
Positivity of Mass for AH Manifolds
17
One checks that 1 − 3/4 > 1/10. Thus, in view of the fact that A1 ≤ C(n, R, Λ, μ ¯ , μ), by possibly increasing R1 we see that (3.48b) can be made to hold. We proceed in a similar fashion to prove (3.48c). We have 1 n+1 μ ¯ −1 − η2 (4λR1 ) − η1 (x, 4λR1 ) ≥ (4λR1 )n+1 a n (4λR1 )n+1 n+1 4 −1 μ ¯. ≥ 3 n We note that 4/3 − 1 > 1/10. This completes the proof of Lemma 3.6. We shall define η = η(x, r) to be a suitably increasing function of the variable r that smoothly transitions from η1 to η2 (see Figure 1). In order to make meaningful estimates, its construction shall be made fairly explicit. Its construction depends on two auxiliary functions α and β, which we now introduce. Let α : [0, ∞) → R be a function satisfying, 1. α(r) = 0 for r ≤ R1 , 2R1 ≤ r ≤ 5λR1 , and r ≥ 6λR1 . 2. α > 0 for R1 < r < 2R1 , α < 0 for 5λR1 < r < 6λR1 , and 6λR1 ∞ α(t)dt = α(t)dt = 0 .
(3.49)
−∞
R1
Consider, α(r) . η1 (x, r) − η2 (r) It follows from Lemma 3.6 and the properties of α that γ is nonnegative and bounded, 0 ≤ γ ≤ C(n, Λ, μ, μ ¯) . γ(x, r) =
Next, define m(x) by the condition 1 + m(x)
6λR1
γ(x, t) dt = 0 ,
(3.50)
R1
and let
r
γ(x, t) dt .
β(x, r) = 1 + m(x) R1
Then, β satisfies, β = 1,
for r ≤ R1
(3.51a)
β = 0,
for r ≥ 6λR1
(3.51b)
for all r .
(3.51c)
0 ≤ β ≤ 1,
Conditions (3.51a), (3.51b) are clear. For (3.51c), we consider, β = mγ. As observed above, γ ≥ 0, and hence from (3.50), m ≤ 0, so that mγ ≤ 0. Hence β is decreasing, which implies that 0 ≤ β ≤ 1.
18
L. Andersson, M. Cai, and G. J. Galloway
Ann. Henri Poincar´e
Now we are ready to define η. Let r β(x, t)η1 (x, t) + 1 − β(x, t) η2 (t) dt . η(x, r) = η1 (x, R1 ) + R1
Lemma 3.7. η defined as above satisfies the conditions
η1 (x, r) r ≤ R1 n+1 η(x, r) = η2 (r) = r a , r ≥ 6λR1 η (x, r) ≤ η2 (r) =
(n + 1)rn , a
Proof. For r ≤ R1 , we have β = 1, so
r
η(x, r) = η1 (x, R1 ) + R1
(3.52a)
R1 ≤ r < ∞ .
(3.52b)
η1 (x, t)dt = η1 (x, r) .
In the following calculations, which only involve derivatives and integrals with respect to r, we suppress reference to x in order to avoid clutter. For r ≥ 6λR1 , we have β = 0, which gives r 6λR1 η(r) = η1 (R1 ) + βη1 + (1 − β)η2 dt + η2 dt (3.53) R1
= η2 (r) − η2 (6λR1 ) + η1 (R1 ) +
6λR1
6λR1
R1
βη1 + (1 − β)η2 dt .
A partial integration gives 6λR1 βη1 + (1 − β)η2 dt R1
(3.54)
(3.55)
r=6λR1 − = η2 (6λR1 ) − η2 (R1 ) + β(η1 − η2 ) r=R1
6λR1
β (η1 − η2 )dt (3.56)
R1
use the properties of β and γ = η2 (6λR1 ) − η2 (R1 ) − η1 (R1 ) − η2 (R1 ) − m
6λR1
αdt
(3.57)
R1
use (3.49) = η2 (6λR1 ) − η1 (R1 ) .
(3.58)
Substituting this into the formula for η(x, r), we obtain, η(x, r) = η2 (r) ,
for
r ≥ 6λR1 .
We have now established (3.52a). Next we prove (3.52b). We have η = βη1 + (1 − β)η2
(3.59)
Vol. 9 (2008)
Positivity of Mass for AH Manifolds
19
and hence, by (3.48), η ≤ βη2 + (1 − β)η2 = η2 =
(3.60)
n
(n + 1)r . a
(3.61)
We shall now make use of the function η defined above to define a function f , which shall be shown to satisfy the conditions (3.28). This fact allows us to apply the result of Corollary 3.5 to estimate the scalar curvature of the deformed metric gf,ψ defined in terms of this f . 3.1.4. Defining f . We define f by, f=
A1 r η1 + Ar1
η+
,
(3.62)
which implies,
r n+1 A1 |μ|ψ − |μ|ψ f − = η. (3.63) rn+1 + n n r Here, A1 = A1 (r) is the function determined in Corollary 3.5. It is crucial to note here that A1 is independent of the particular f , as long as it satisfies the conditions (3.28). Our task is now to show that f defined as above does satisfy these conditions as long as R1 is chosen sufficiently large. This will be demonstrated in Lemma 3.8 below. It then follows from equation (3.63) above, Corollary 3.5 and (3.52b) that S[gf,ψ ] satisfies, n n(n + 1) . η ≥− rn a In addition we have, gf,ψ = g on [R, R1 ] and gf,ψ = ga on [9λR1 , ∞). Thus, subject to the following lemma, Theorem 3.2 has been proven. S[gf,ψ ] ≥ −
Lemma 3.8. Let η be as in Section 3.1.3, and let f be given in terms of η by (3.62). ¯, μ) sufficiently large, so that the inequaliThen, there is an R1 = R1 (n, R, Λ, μ ties (3.28) are valid. Proof. The condition (3.28a) is clear from the construction. Since (3.28c) implies (3.28b) we only need to verify that |f | ≤ 1/r2 and |∂x f | ≤ 1/rn , |∂x2 f | ≤ 1/rn . We begin by showing there is an R1 sufficiently large, and not smaller than the previously made choices of R1 , so that |f | ≤ 1/r2 . We have, f =1+ This gives f =
(η − η1 ) . η1 + A1 /r
(η − η1 ) (η − η1 ) − η + (A1 /r) . η1 + A1 /r (η1 + A1 /r)2 1
(3.64)
20
L. Andersson, M. Cai, and G. J. Galloway
Since
r
η(x, r) = η1 (x, R1 ) + R1 r
η1 (x, r) = η1 (x, R1 ) +
R1
we have,
r
η − η1 =
Ann. Henri Poincar´e
βη1 + (1 − β)η2 dt , η1 dt
(1 − β)(η2 − η1 ) .
R1
so
(η − η1 ) = (1 − β)(η2 − η1 ) .
Hence,
|(η − η1 ) | ≤ (η2 − η1 ) =
1 − 1 rn (n + 1) + O(1/r) a
(3.65)
C . (3.66) r Here and below C = C(n, R, Λ, μ ¯, μ) is a generic constant. Recall that by construction we have C (A1 /r) ≤ 2 . r Combining the above inequalities, we have (η − η1 ) C (3.67) η1 + A1 /r ≤ rn+2 . ≤
Now since |(η − η1 ) | ≤
C r
we have |η − η1 | ≤ C for r ∈ [R1 , 9λR1 ]. This together with
(3.68)
|η1 | ≤ Crn implies that
(η − η1 ) C η + (A /r) 1 (η1 + A1 /r)2 1 ≤ rn+2 . Equations (3.67) and (3.69) imply C |f | ≤ n+2 r for r ∈ [R1 , 9λR1 ]. By choosing R1 large enough, we have 1 |f | ≤ 2 r which gives (3.28c).
(3.69)
Vol. 9 (2008)
Positivity of Mass for AH Manifolds
21
Next we demonstrate that by, if necessary, further increasing R1 , we can ensure that the condition 1 |∂xk f | ≤ n , k = 1, 2 , r holds, where ∂x denotes partial differentiation with respect to any one of the coordinates xi . Recalling (3.64), we have ∂x f =
η − η1 ∂x (η − η1 ) − (∂x η1 ) . η1 + A1 /r (η1 + A1 /r)2
We estimate the second term first. By (3.68), |η − η1 | ≤ C, so 1 η − η1 (η1 + A1 /r)2 ∂x η1 ≤ r2n+2 |∂x η1 | . Recalling r n+1 A1 |μ|ψ − |μ|ψ − n n r we find |∂x η1 | ≤ C. Hence the modulus of the second term in ∂x f is bounded by C/r2n+2 . Now consider the first term in ∂x f . Recall r η − η1 = (1 − β)(η2 − η1 ) dt R1 r r = (1 − β)(η2 − η1 ) + (η2 − η1 )β dt η1 = rn+1 +
R1
R1
r
= [1 − β](η2 − η1 ) +
(η2 − η1 )β dt
R1
so ∂x (η − η1 ) = −(∂x β)(η2 − η1 ) − (1 − β)∂x η1 r
∂x (η2 − η1 ) β + (η2 − η1 )∂x β dt . + R1
Now,
r
∂x β = (∂x m) R1
Recall,
α η1 − η2
6λR1
1+m R1
r
+m
∂x
R1
α η1 − η2
α =0 η1 − η2
so 1 m = − 6λR1 R1
α η1 −η2
= O(1/R1 ) .
.
22
L. Andersson, M. Cai, and G. J. Galloway
Hence,
6λR1 R1
∂x
∂x m = − 6λR1 R1
One can see that ∂x so
α η1 − η2
Ann. Henri Poincar´e
α η1 −η2 2 α η1 −η2
.
= O(1) ,
∂x m = O(1/R1 ) . Hence we have, using m = O(1/R1 ), ∂x β = O(1) and therefore ∂x β(η2 − η1 ) = O(1) . Next we consider the second term in ∂x f . We have |∂x η1 | ≤ C , so (1 − β)∂x η1 = O(1) . Since m = O(1/R1 ), we have, β = m
α = O(1/R1 ) η1 − η2
but, ∂x (η2 − η1 ) = O(1) so,
∂x (η2 − η1 )β = O(1/R1 ) .
Similarly,
∂x β = O(1/R1 )
and η2 − η1 = O(1) . Hence, and therefore,
∂x (η2 − η1 ) β + (η2 − η1 )∂x β = O(1/R1 ) , r
∂x (η2 − η1 ) β + (η2 − η1 )∂x β = O(1) .
R1
Adding the three terms, we get, ∂x (η − η1 ) = O(1) . This implies that the first term in ∂x f is O(1) = O(1/rn+1 ) , η1 + A1 /r
Vol. 9 (2008)
Positivity of Mass for AH Manifolds
23
i.e., |∂x f | ≤
C rn+1
.
Similar arguments give, |∂x2 f | ≤
C . rn+1
By choosing R1 large enough we obtain, |∂xk f | ≤
1 , rn
k = 1, 2 .
Lemma 3.8 follows.
As discussed above, now that Lemma 3.8 is established, we have completed the proof of Theorem 3.2. 3.2. The case of vanishing mass aspect function In this subsection, we prove the following. Theorem 3.9. Let (M n+1 , g), 2 ≤ n ≤ 6, be an asymptotically hyperbolic manifold with scalar curvature satisfying, S[g] ≥ −n(n + 1). If the mass aspect function trh0 k vanishes identically, then (M, g) is isometric to hyperbolic space. We note that while Theorem 3.9 generalizes Theorem 1.1, its proof relies on it. We note also that our positivity of mass result, Theorem 3.1, follows immediately from Proposition 3.3 and Theorem 3.9. For notational convenience we set d = n + 1. Further, let capital latin indices run from 1, . . . , d − 1, let lowercase latin indices run from 1, . . . , d, and let y A be coordinates on S d−1 . Further, let (xi ) = (t, y A ) be coordinates on (0, T ) × S d−1 , and, as usual, let h0 be the standard metric on S d−1 . 3.2.1. Conformal gauge. Consider a conformally compact d-dimensional manifold ˜ = M ∪ ∂M , and (M, g) where M is the interior of a manifold with boundary M −2 suppose g is of the form g = ρ g˜, with ρ a defining function for ∂M for a metric g˜ ˜. which is smooth on M ˜ . Letting g˜ → θ2 g˜ and ρ → θρ leaves g Let θ be a positive function on M unchanged. Such a transformation can therefore be viewed as a change of conformal gauge. ˜ which in a neighborhood of ∂M can be written in Let g˜ be a metric on M the form g˜ = dt2 + h0 + td γ (3.70) where γ = γij dxi dxj is a smooth tensor field on (0, T ) × S d−1 for some T > 0, such that the restriction of γ to ∂M is a smooth tensor on S d−1 , i.e., γ ∂M = γ(0, y)AB dy A dy B . The following lemma shows that after a change of conformal gauge we may assume that g˜ is in Gauss coordinates based on ∂M .
24
L. Andersson, M. Cai, and G. J. Galloway
Ann. Henri Poincar´e
Lemma 3.10. Consider the conformally compact metric g = sinh−2 (t)˜ g . There is −2 ˆ ˆ a conformal gauge change so that g takes the form g = sinh (t)g˜, where tˆ(p) = ˜ is of the form dgˆ˜ (p, ∂M ), and gˆ gˆ˜ = dtˆ2 + h0 + tˆd γˆ where γˆ = γˆ(tˆ, y)AB dy A dy B is a tˆ-dependent tensor field on S d−1 , such that γˆ ∂M = γ ∂M . In particular, g is asymptotically hyperbolic in the sense of Def inition 3.1, with mass aspect tensor k = γ ∂M . Proof. Let ρ = sinh(t). Arguing as in [2, Section 5], we shall find a function θ such that ρˆ := θρ = sinh(tˆ), where tˆ = dgˆ˜ (p, ∂M ), is the distance to the boundary in the metric gˆ ˜. This is equivalent to the condition that fˆ := arcsinh(ˆ ρ) = tˆ, with ˆ |df |ˆ = 1. A calculation as in the proof of [2, Lemma 5.3] shows that this condition g ˜
is equivalent to the equation ρ˜ g(dθ, dθ) + 2θ˜ g (dθ, dρ) = θ4 ρ + θ2 a
(3.71)
where a = ρ−1 (1 − g˜(dρ, dρ)). For g˜ of the form (3.70), we have a = −ρ + O(td ). Equation (3.71) is a system of first order partial differential equations, with characteristics transversal to ∂M = {t = 0}, and satisfies the conditions for existence of solutions with initial condition θ = 1 at ∂M , see [25, volume 5, pp. 39–40]. Hence there is a small neighborhood U of ∂M , and a solution θ to (3.71) on U . We shall need the following fact. Claim. θ = 1 + td+1 w, where w is smooth up to ∂M . The proof of the claim is straightforward and is left to the reader. Now we have that tˆ = arcsinh(θ sinh(t)) = t[1 + O(td+1 )], and hence t = tˆ 1 + O(tˆd+1 ) where the O(td+1 ) and O(tˆd+1 ) terms are smooth functions of (t, y) and (tˆ, y), respectively. It is straightforward to verify that sinh−2 (t) = sinh−2 (tˆ)[1 + tˆd+1 ] and g = sinh−2 (tˆ)gˆ ˜, with gˆ˜ = dtˆ2 + h0 + tˆd γˆ where γˆ has the property that γˆ(0, y) = γ(0, y). By construction, tˆ is the distance to ∂M , and hence the above is the form ˆ of g˜ in Gauss coordinates, based on ∂M . It follows that γˆ is a tˆ-dependent tensor on S d−1 .
Vol. 9 (2008)
Positivity of Mass for AH Manifolds
25
3.2.2. Conformal deformation. Assume (M, g) is asymptotically hyperbolic in the sense of Definition 3.1. Then, in slightly different notation, (M, g) has a conformal ˜ , g˜) with conformal boundary ∂ M ˜ the round sphere, and such compactification (M ˜ that near ∂ M , g has the form, g = ρ−2 g˜ (3.72) where ρ = sinh(t) and (3.73) g˜ = dt2 + h0 + td γ , d−1 where h0 is the standard metric on S and γ = γ(t, ·) is a t-dependent family of d−1 ˜ . Note that the mass aspect tensor is given by, metrics on S smooth up to ∂ M k = γAB ∂ M˜ . Let h = h0 + td γ be the metric induced on the level sets of t, and let s denote the scalar curvature defined with respect to h. Further, let Kij = 12 ∂t hij . The only nonvanishing components of K are KAB = 12 dtd−1 γAB + O(td ). denote the covariant derivative defined with respect to g˜ and let S˜ deLet ∇ note the scalar curvature of g˜. The formula for the scalar curvature of conformally related metrics gives, l ρ + ρ2 S˜ . l ρ∇ l ρ + (2d − 2)ρ∇ l∇ S = −d(d − 1)∇ Claim. S has the asymptotic form, S = −d(d − 1) + O(td+1 ) .
(3.74)
Indeed, by Taylor’s theorem, we have s = S[h0 ] + O(td ), and hence, S˜ = s − 2hAB ∂t KAB − (hAB KAB )2 + 3KAB K AB 0
0
d−1 = (d − 1)(d − 2) − d(d − 1)td−2 hAB ). 0 γAB + O(t
Further, using ρ = sinh t, l∇ l ρ = sinh(t) − g˜ij Γ tij cosh(t) ∇ d = sinh(t) + hAB 0 KAB + O(t )
d d = sinh(t) + td−1 hAB 0 γAB + O(t ) . 2 l ρ∇ l ρ = cosh2 (t). Putting this together, one finds afFinally, we note that ∇ ter a few manipulations that the terms involving the mass aspect function, μ = ˜ ), in S[g], at order td , cancel. Equation 3.74 follows. hAB 0 (γAB ∂ M By standard results [3, Theorem 1.2], there is a unique positive solution u such that limx→∞ u(x) = 1, to the Yamabe equation for prescribed scalar curvature −d(d − 1) in dimension d, −
d+2 4(d − 1) Δu + Su + d(d − 1)u d−2 = 0 . d−2
Let v = u − 1 and let Sˆ =
d−2 S + d(d − 1) . 4(d − 1)
(3.75)
26
L. Andersson, M. Cai, and G. J. Galloway
Ann. Henri Poincar´e
Then the Yamabe equation takes the form ˆ = −Sˆ − F(v) −Δv + dv + Sv
(3.76)
d+2 d(d − 2) d+2 v . (1 + v) d−2 − 1 − 4 d−2 2 In particular F (v) = O(v ). A straightforward application of the maximum principle shows that since S[g] ≥ −d(d − 1), we have v ≤ 0 and hence
where
F (v) =
u ≤ 1. Linearizing the Yamabe equation around u = 1, we obtain the equation −Δ¯ u + d¯ u + Sˆu¯ = 0 . The indicial exponents of this equation are −1, d. It follows that the solution to the Yamabe equation is of the form u = 1+v with v = vd,1 td log t+vd td +higher order. However since by Equation (3.74), Sˆ = O(td+1 ), it follows [1] that vd,1 = 0, and in fact v is smooth up to boundary, with v = vd td + higher order . Let L = −Δ + d. Equation (3.76) takes the form Lv = f
(3.77)
with f given by ˆ − F(u − 1) . f = −Su In particular, f ≤ 0 and f = 0 except when Sˆ = 0. Let Lt be the operator defined by Lt u = − sinh2 (t)∂t2 u + (d − 2) sinh(t) cosh(t)∂t u + du . We have √ Lu = Lt u − sinh2 (t)∂t det h∂t u − sinh2 (t)Δh u , where Δh is the Laplacian on S d−1 with respect to the metric h(t, ·) = h0 + td γ. In particular Δh involves only y A -derivatives. We now introduce a function w which will be used as a supersolution, in order to control the leading order term in v. Let w = −td (1 + dt). Lemma 3.11. There exists constants t1 = t1 (d) > 0, A = A(d) > 0 such that Lt w > Atd+1 ,
for
0 < t < t∗ .
Proof. Using w = −td (1 + dt), we obtain, Lt (w) = sinh2 (t) d(d − 1)td−2 + d2 (d + 1)td−1 − (d − 2) sinh(t) cosh(t) dtd−1 + d(d + 1)td − d(td + dtd+1 ) = d(d − 1)td + d2 (d + 1)td+1 − (d − 2) dtd + d(d + 1)td+1 − [dtd + d2 td+1 ] + O(td+2 ) = d(d + 2)td+1 + O(td+2 ) , and the lemma follows.
Vol. 9 (2008)
We have,
Positivity of Mass for AH Manifolds
27
√ Lw = Lt w − sinh2 (t)∂t det h∂t w .
For metrics of the form we are considering, trh ∂t h = O(td−1 ). Hence by Lemma 3.11, we have Lw > Atd+1 − Ct2d where C = C(d, γ). This means there exists t2 > 0, t2 = t2 (d, γ) such that Lw > 0 ,
for 0 < t < t2 .
Lemma 3.12. Let (M, g) be asymptotically hyperbolic, so that (3.72) and (3.73) ˜ , with hold. Let f be a function on (M, g), and assume that f is smooth up to ∂ M d+1 fall off f = O(t ). Let L = −Δ + d, and let v be the unique solution to Lv = f ˜ and J with v = O(td ). Then v = vd td + td+1 J with vd = vd (y) smooth on ∂ M ˜ . If f ≤ 0, f = 0, then vd < 0. smooth up to ∂ M Proof. Let v¯a = aw and let v be as in (3.77). We have f ≤ 0, and hence by the ˜ . It follows that there is > 0, strong maximum principle v < 0 in the interior of M t2 > t3 > 0, so that sup v(t3 , y) < − . y∈S d−1
For each a ≥ 0, v¯a is a supersolution to L in the region 0 < t < t3 and for 0 ≤ a ≤ a∗ , we have that v¯a (t3 ) > v(t3 , y) for y ∈ S d−1 . Further, we clearly have v¯a (0) = v(0, y) = 0 for y ∈ S d−1 . It follows from the maximum principle that for small a, v¯a > v in the region 0 < t < t3 . Fix an a with this property. Since v¯a = −atd + O(td+1 ), dividing the inequality, v ≤ v¯a , by td and letting t 0 gives vd ≤ −a. We are now ready to state the following analogue of a well-known result in the asymptotically flat setting (cf., [20]). Proposition 3.13. Let (M, g) be asymptotically hyperbolic in the sense of Definition 3.1, with scalar curvature S[g] ≥ −d(d − 1), and with strict inequality somewhere. Then there exists a conformally related metric gˆ such that 1. (M, gˆ) is asymptotically hyperbolic, 2. S[ˆ g] = −d(d − 1), and 3. μ[ˆ g ] < μ[g], where μ[g], μ[ˆ g ] are the mass aspect functions of (M, g), (M, gˆ), respectively. Proof. Lemma 3.12, together with the discussion prior to Lemma 3.11, shows that the solution u to the Yamabe equation is of the form u = 1 + ud td + td+1 J
28
L. Andersson, M. Cai, and G. J. Galloway
Ann. Henri Poincar´e
˜ . Then, after a change of with ud = ud (y) < 0, and with J smooth up to ∂ M coordinates, gˆ = u4/(d−2) g can be brought into the form, 4 1 gˆ = sinh−2 (t) dt2 + h0 + td γ + 1+ ud h0 + td+1 z d−2 d ˜. where z = zij dxi dxj is smooth up to ∂ M By Lemma 3.10, after a change of conformal gauge, we have 4 1 gˆ = sinh−2 (tˆ) dtˆ2 + h0 + tˆd γˆ + 1+ u d h0 d−2 d ˜ and γˆ (0, y) = γ(0, y). It follows where γˆ = γˆ(tˆ, y)AB dy A dy B is smooth up to ∂ M from the above that the mass aspect functions satisfy, 4(d − 1) 1 (3.78) μ[ˆ g ] = μ[g] + 1+ ud < μ[g] , d−2 d
since ud < 0.
For the purpose of establishing Theorem 3.9, we need the following immediate consequence of Propositions 3.3 and 3.13. Corollary 3.14. Let (M, g) be as in Theorem 3.9; in particular, assume μ[g] = 0. Then g has constant scalar curvature S[g] = −d(d − 1). Proof. Suppose S[g] > −d(d − 1) somewhere. Then, by Proposition 3.13, there exists a conformally related metric gˆ such that (M, gˆ) is asymptotically hyperbolic, S[ˆ g] = −d(d − 1), and μ[ˆ g ] < μ[g] = 0. But this directly contradicts Proposition 3.3. 3.2.3. Deforming the metric. Now we will show that if g has constant scalar curvature S = −d(d − 1) and vanishing mass aspect function, then it is Einstein, Ricg = −(d − 1)g. Thus, let (M, g) be as in Theorem 3.9, and assume S[g] = −d(d − 1). Let = Ric − S g Ric d denote the traceless part of Ric. Note that since g has constant scalar curvature have vanishing divergence. Ric and Ric For the subsequent analysis, we shall need detailed information about the asymptotic behavior of Ric. Lemma 3.15. Let (M, g) be as in Theorem 3.9 (so that (3.72) and (3.73) hold, and the mass aspect vanishes). Then = − d td−2 γ + td−1 z Ric 2 where z = zij dxi dxj .
Vol. 9 (2008)
Positivity of Mass for AH Manifolds
29
∇ denote the Ricci tensor and covariant derivative defined with Proof. Let Ric, respect to g˜. The conformal transformation formula for Ricci curvature is jρ + ∇ l ρ˜ l ρ∇ i∇ ij + ρ−1 (d − 2)∇ l∇ l ρ˜ gij − (d − 1)ρ−2 ∇ gij (3.79) Ricij = Ric where in the right hand side, indices are raised with g˜. Note that if γ = 0, then Ric = (d − 2)h0 and the only nonvanishing terms in the formula for Ric are Rictt = (d − 1) sinh−2 (t) RicAB = (d − 1) sinh−2 (t)h0 AB . Now we consider the case with nonvanishing γ, but with vanishing mass aspect function, i.e., μ = hAB 0 γAB t=0 = 0. 1 Let Kij = 2 ∂t g˜ij . Then the nonvanishing terms in K are KAB = 12 dtd−1 γAB + d O(t ). Let h, ∇ /, ric denote the induced metric, covariant derivative and Ricci tensor on the level sets Mt of t. We use coordinates y A on these level sets, and raise and lower indices with h. Note that h = h0 + td γ, and hence, since ric involves no t-derivatives, we have by Taylor’s theorem, ric = Ric[h0 ] + O(td ) = (d − 2)h0 + O(td ) . We have from the Gauss, Codazzi, and second variation equations Rictt = −hAB ∂t KAB + KAC K C B 1 = − d(d − 1)td−2 hAB γAB + O(td−1 ) 2 which using μ = 0 gives, = O(td−1 ) , B RictA = ∇ / KBA − ∇ /A (hBC KBC )
= O(td ) , AB = ricAB − ∂t KAB + 2KAC K C B − KAB hCD KCD Ric 1 = (d − 2)h0 − d(d − 1)td−2 γAB + O(td−1 ) . 2 Thus we have = (d − 2)h0 − 1 d(d − 1)td−2 γ + O(td−1 ) . Ric 2 We next consider the remaining terms jρ + ∇ l ρ˜ l ρ∇ i∇ l∇ l ρ˜ Bij = ρ−1 (d − 2)∇ gij − (d − 1)ρ−2 ∇ gij . t Recall that since we are in a Gauss foliation, the only non-vanishing terms in Γ ij are tAB = −KAB . Γ
30
L. Andersson, M. Cai, and G. J. Galloway
Ann. Henri Poincar´e
We have Btt = −(d − 1) sinh−2 (t) , BtA = 0 , BAB = sinh−1 (t) (d − 2)KAB cosh(t) + sinh(t)hAB − (d − 1) sinh−2 (t) cosh2 (t)hAB , 1 = −(d − 1) sinh−2 (t)h0 AB + d(d − 2)td−2 γAB + O(td−1 ) . 2 This shows that d Ric[g] = −(d − 1)g − td−2 γ + O(td−1 ) 2 which gives the Lemma. Consider the curve,
λs = u4/(d−2) gs s
(3.80)
where, for s small, gs is the smooth curve of metrics, gs = g − sRic[g], and us is the conformal factor such that S[λs ] = −d(d − 1). Note that u0 = 1. By Lemmas 3.10, 3.15, and our earlier discussion on the asymptotic form of solutions to the Yamabe equation, λs is asymptotically hyperbolic in the sense of Definition 3.1. Let μs denote the mass aspect function of λs . s Let u ¯ = ∂u ∂s |s=0 . Then, by differentiating the Yamabe equation (3.75), with u = us and g = gs , with respect to the parameter s, we obtain the equation, 2. −Δ¯ u + d¯ u = −|Ric| By Lemma 3.12, we have u ¯ = u¯d td + O(td+1 ) , = 0. with u ¯d = u ¯d (y) < 0 if Ric 4(d − 1) 1 ∂s μs s=0 = 1+ u¯d . d−2 d Proof. Clearly, α = ∂s μs s=0 is of the form α = αRic + αu , where α = ∂s μ(gs )
Lemma 3.16.
Ric
and
s=0
αu = ∂s μ(u4/(d−2) g)s=0 . s
Let gs = sinh−2 (t)˜ gs . In order to determine the s-dependence of the mass aspect function we consider g˜s . It follows from Lemma 3.15 that d sinh2 (t)∂s g˜s = td γ + O(td+1 ) . 2 Since by assumption trh0 γ ∂M = 0, we have αRic = 0. It follows that the first order change in the mass aspect function of λs is given by αu , which clearly is determined by the first order change in the conformal factor us . The result follows.
Vol. 9 (2008)
Positivity of Mass for AH Manifolds
31
We are now ready to complete the proof of Theorem 3.9. Proof of Theorem 3.9. Let (M, g) be as in Theorem 3.9. Recall d = n + 1. By = 0. Corollary 3.14, S[g] = −d(d − 1). Suppose that g is not Einstein, i.e., Ric 4/(d−2) Let λs = us gs as in (3.80). As previously observed, λs is asymptotically hyperbolic with scalar curvature S[λs ] = −d(d − 1), and with mass aspect μs . By Lemma 3.16, ∂s μs |s=0 < 0, and hence for small s > 0, λs has negative mass aspect function. But in view of Proposition 3.3, μs < 0 gives a contradiction, and hence it must hold that Ric = 0. We can now apply the rigidity result of Qing [21] (see also [4, 7]) to conclude that in fact (M, g) is isometric to hyperbolic space. This concludes the proof of the positive mass theorem in the case of vanishing mass aspect function. Naturally, it would be desirable to find a way to remove the sign condition on the mass aspect from our positive mass result. Within the context of the approach taken in this paper, one possible way to accomplish this would be to extend the results of Corvino–Schoen [11, 12] and Chru´sciel–Delay [9] on initial data deformations to the asymptotically hyperbolic setting. Starting from Proposition 3.13, the aim would be to deform the time-symmetric initial data to be exactly Schwarzschild-AdS outside a compact set, without changing the scalar curvature and the sign of the mass. Starting from Schwarzschild-AdS with mass m < 0, the deformation result of Section 3.1 is then easily proved.
Acknowledgements We thank Piotr Chru´sciel for comments and discussion. This work was initiated at the Conference on Mathematical Aspects of Gravitation at the Mathematical Research Institute in Oberwolfach in 2003. We thank the Institute for its hospitality and support. This work was supported in part by NSF grants DMS-0407732 and DMS-0405906.
References [1] L. Andersson and P. T. Chru´sciel, Solutions of the constraint equations in general relativity satisfying “hyperboloidal boundary conditions”, Dissertationes Math. (Rozprawy Mat.) 355 (1996), 100. [2] L. Andersson and M. Dahl, Scalar curvature rigidity for asymptotically locally hyperbolic manifolds, Ann. Global Anal. Geom. 16 (1998), no. 1, 1–27. [3] L. Andersson, P. T. Chru´sciel and H. Friedrich, On the regularity of solutions to the Yamabe equation and the existence of smooth hyperboloidal initial data for Einstein’s field equations, Commun. Math. Phys. 149 (1992), 587–612. [4] V. Bonini, P. Miao, and J. Qing, Ricci curvature rigidity for weakly asymptotically hyperbolic manifolds, Comm. Anal. Geom. 14 (2006), no. 3, 603–612.
32
L. Andersson, M. Cai, and G. J. Galloway
Ann. Henri Poincar´e
[5] M. Cai, Volume minimizing hypersurfaces in manifolds of nonnegative scalar curvature, Minimal surfaces, geometric analysis and symplectic geometry (Baltimore, MD, 1999), Adv. Stud. Pure Math., vol. 34, Math. Soc. Japan, Tokyo, 2002, pp. 1–7. [6] M. Cai and G. J. Galloway, Rigidity of area minimizing tori in 3-manifolds of nonnegative scalar curvature, Comm. Anal. Geom. 8 (2000), no. 3, 565–573. [7] M. Cai and J. Qing, On the rigidity of AdS spacetime, preprint (2006). [8] U. Christ and J. Lohkamp, Singular minimal hypersurfaces and scalar curvature, math.DG/0609338 (2006). [9] P. T. Chru´sciel and E. Delay, On mapping properties of the general relativistic constraints operator in weighted function spaces, with applications, M´em. Soc. Math. Fr. (N.S.) (2003), no. 94, vi+103. [10] P. T. Chru´sciel and M. Herzlich, The mass of asymptotically hyperbolic Riemannian manifolds, Pacific J. Math. 212 (2003), no. 2, 231–264. [11] J. Corvino, Scalar curvature deformation and a gluing construction for the Einstein constraint equations, Comm. Math. Phys. 214 (2000), no. 1, 137–189. [12] J. Corvino and R. M. Schoen, On the asymptotics for the vacuum Einstein constraint equations, J. Differential Geom. 73 (2006), no. 2, 185–217. [13] E. Delay, Analyse pr´ecis´ee d’´equations semi-lin´eaires elliptiques sur l’espace hyperbolique et application a ` la courbure scalaire conforme, Bull. Soc. Math. France 125 (1997), no. 3, 345–381. [14] H. Federer, Geometric measure theory, Die Grundlehren der mathematischen Wissenschaften, Band 153, Springer-Verlag New York Inc., New York, 1969. [15] G. W. Gibbons, S. W. Hawking, G. T. Horowitz, and M. J. Perry, Positive mass theorems for black holes, Comm. Math. Phys. 88 (1983), no. 3, 295–308. [16] J. L. Kazdan and F. W. Warner, Existence and conformal deformation of metrics with prescribed Gaussian and scalar curvatures, Ann. of Math. (2) 101 (1975), 317–331. [17] J. Lohkamp, The higher dimensional positive mass theorem I, math.DG/0608795 (2006). [18] J. Lohkamp, Scalar curvature and hammocks, Math. Ann. 313 (1999), no. 3, 385–407. [19] M. Min-Oo, Scalar curvature rigidity of asymptotically hyperbolic spin manifolds, Math. Ann. 285 (1989), no. 4, 527–539. ´ Murchadha and J. W. York Jr., Gravitational energy, Phys. Rev. D 10 (1974), [20] N. O no. 8, 2345–2357. [21] J. Qing, On the rigidity for conformally compact Einstein manifolds, Int. Math. Res. Not. (2003), no. 21, 1141–1153. [22] R. Schoen and S. T. Yau, On the structure of manifolds with positive scalar curvature, Manuscripta Math. 28 (1979), no. 1–3, 159–183. [23] R. Schoen and S. T. Yau, On the proof of the positive mass conjecture in general relativity, Comm. Math. Phys. 65 (1979), no. 1, 45–76. [24] Y. Shi and G. Tian, Rigidity of asymptotically hyperbolic manifolds, Comm. Math. Phys. 259 (2005), no. 3, 545–559. [25] M. Spivak, A comprehensive introduction to differential geometry, second ed., Publish or Perish Inc., Wilmington, Del., 1979.
Vol. 9 (2008)
Positivity of Mass for AH Manifolds
33
[26] X. Wang, The mass of asymptotically hyperbolic manifolds, J. Differential Geom. 57 (2001), no. 2, 273–299. [27] E. Witten and S.-T. Yau, Connectedness of the boundary in the AdS/CFT correspondence, Adv. Theor. Math. Phys. 3 (1999), no. 6, 1635–1655 (2000). [28] S. T. Yau, Geometry of three manifolds and existence of black hole due to boundary effect, Adv. Theor. Math. Phys. 5 (2001), no. 4, 755–767. Lars Andersson∗ , Mingliang Cai, and Gregory J. Galloway Department of Mathematics University of Miami Coral Gables, FL 33124 USA and ∗ Max-Planck-Institut f¨ ur Gravitationsphysik Am M¨ uhlenberg 1 D-14476 Postdam Germany e-mail:
[email protected] [email protected] [email protected] Communicated by Sergiu Klainerman. Submitted: March 16, 2007. Accepted: June 14, 2007.
Ann. Henri Poincar´e 9 (2008), 35–63 c 2008 Birkh¨ auser Verlag Basel/Switzerland 1424-0637/010035-29, published online January 30, 2008 DOI 10.1007/s00023-007-0349-1
Annales Henri Poincar´ e
Projecting Massive Scalar Fields to Null Infinity Claudio Dappiaggi Abstract. It is known that, in an asymptotically flat spacetime, null infinity cannot act as an initial-value surface for massive scalar fields. Exploiting tools proper of harmonic analysis on hyperboloids and global norm estimates for the wave operator, we show that it is possible to circumvent such obstruction at least in Minkowski spacetime. Hence we project norm-finite solutions of the Klein–Gordon equation of motion in data on null infinity and, eventually, we interpret them in terms of boundary free field theory.
1. Introduction In the study of classical fields over four dimensional Lorentzian curved backgrounds, Penrose conformal completion techniques have played since their introduction a pivotal role. In particular the related notion of asymptotic simplicity/flatness entails the embedding of a (four dimensional) physical spacetime (M, gμν ) as a bounded open , gμν ) being g a conformal rescaling of g. In set in an unphysical background (M this setting the image of M in M can be naturally endowed with a boundary structure usually referred to as ± , i.e., future or past null infinity. Heuristically the endpoint of all the null geodesics in (M, gμν ), ± is thus the geometrical locus where the trajectory of zero rest mass particles ends. Hence it is manifest how null conformal boundaries can be exploited as a powerful tool to study either the asymptotic properties of radiation fields associated to massless wave equations, either the scattering properties of massless fields [12]. Furthermore, from the perspective of quantum field theory over curved backgrounds, ± plays a key role in the realization of the holographic principle. The latter conjectures that the information of any field theory on a D-dimensional Lorentzian background M can be recovered by means of a suitable second field theory constructed over a codimension one submanifold Σ embedded in M . Hence,
36
C. Dappiaggi
Ann. Henri Poincar´e
in asymptotically flat spacetimes it is natural to conjecture that the role of Σ is played by the null conformal boundary and this idea has been deeply investigated both at a classical and at a quantum level in [4]. To better understand the main rationale underlying the success of Penrose conformal techniques from a field theoretical perspective, let us consider a working example, namely the massless Klein–Gordon scalar field ψ conformally coupled to gravity in a globally hyperbolic and asymptotically flat four dimensional space time M . Barring a few technical assumptions, each solution of g − R6 ψ = 0 with compactly supported initial data on a Cauchy surface can be mapped into a solution of g ψ − R ψ = 0 , (1) 6 . , where ψ = Ω−1 ψ. Although ψ is strictly defined only over the image of M in M global hyperbolicity of M and uniqueness of solutions for second order hyperbolic . Accordingly PDE, allows us to extend ψ to a smooth solution for (1) over all M ± we can define the projection of ψ over the boundary simply as its restriction: . ∞ ± Ψ± = ψ| ± ∈ C ( ). It is Ψ the key ingredient to study properties of bulk physical phenomena starting from boundary data in the unphysical spacetime as exploited, to quote just a few examples, in [4, 12]. Nonetheless the situation is not heavenly as it may seem since the above construction drastically fails whenever one considers massive fields. Even in the simplest situation of the Klein–Gordon scalar field over flat four dimensional Minkowski spacetime, conformal invariance of the equation of motion is broken. Furthermore it has been argued in [9, 24] that ± cannot be used as an initial value surface for massive fields and that it is not possible to project any solution of g − m2 ψ = 0 into a smooth function over ± . This result has been established with an elegant argument in [9]: the space of sections of any vector bundle on ± which is homogeneous for the action of the Poincar´e group carries only massless representations1. Hence it seems impossible to exploit the powerful means of Penrose compactification whenever we deal with solutions of partial differential equations containing a term proportional to a scale length such as the mass. In other words, since the information of the data evolving to infinity along causal timelike curves flows in to future timelike infinity i+ (a codimension 2 subthe unphysical spacetime M manifold of M hence not a proper boundary), it seems impossible to exploit null infinity as a tool to study massive fields. 1A
reader familiar with Penrose compactification techniques could argue that the relevant symmetry group on null infinity is not the Poincar´e but the BMS group which is the semidirect product between the proper ortochronous component of the Lorentz group and the smooth functions over the 2-sphere thought as an Abelian group under addition. Nonetheless, since in Helffer construction the key role is played by the translational subgroup of the Poincar´e group, the result can be extended also in a BMS framework remembering that it exists a four dimensional normal subgroup of the full BMS group homomorphic to T 4 [4].
Vol. 9 (2008)
Projecting Massive Scalar Fields to Null Infinity
37
The aim of this paper is to provide a way to circumvent the above obstruction at least in Minkowski background. In particular we will exploit both tools of harmonic analysis and global norm estimates for the wave equation in order to project a solution for the massive Klein–Gordon equation of motion into meaningful data over null infinity. More in detail, the outline of the analysis and hence of the paper will be the following: in the next subsection we recollect some basic details about the notion of asymptotic flatness. In Section 2, instead, we specialize to Minkowski background and we consider solutions of the massive Klein–Gordon equation of motion satisfying a finite norm condition in such a way that their Fourier transform is a square integrable function over the mass hyperboloid Hm . Exploiting a few results due to Strichartz on harmonic analysis over hyperboloids we shall introduce a unitary map between two copies of L2 (Hm ) and the space of square integrable functions over the light cone C. Furthermore such a map will also act as an intertwiner between the quasi-regular representations of the Lorentz group on L2 (Hm ) and L2 (C). Afterward we exploit global norm estimates to associate to each square integrable function over the light cone a norm finite solution for the wave equation in Minkowski spacetime. By means of Penrose compactification techniques and trace theorems, we project these functions on null infinity. Eventually, in Section 3, we show how the projected data can be interpreted in terms of a diffeomorphism invariant field theory intrinsically constructed over null infinity. 1.1. On asymptotically flat spacetimes In this section we recollect some known facts about the definition and the properties of asymptotically flat spacetimes. Although we are going to work in Minkowski background, the following summary can be useful for a twofold reason: from one side, in Section 3, we shall interpret the projection of the data from a bulk massive scalar field in terms of a field theory on future null infinity whereas, from the other side, we look at this paper as the first step to solve the same problem on a generic asymptotically flat background. Hence it could be interesting to understand where our construction relies on properties specific of Minkowski spacetime and where, on the opposite, our results could be traded to a more general scenario. In the literature there are several different notions of asymptotic flatness at (future or past) null infinity which are obviously all equivalent if the bulk spacetime is Minkowski; hence a reader familiar to any of these can skip to the next section without a second thought. We shall instead adopt the specific definition first introduced by Friedrich (see [6] and references therein from the same author) of a class of spacetimes which are flat at future null infinity and they admit future time completion at i+ . The reason for this choice lies in the realm of quantum field theory over curved backgrounds. In particular, in [4] it has been shown that it is possible to project the Weyl *-algebra of observables for a massless scalar field in Minkowski spacetime as a subsector of a suitable counterpart at null infinity
38
C. Dappiaggi
Ann. Henri Poincar´e
because the Lichnerowicz propagator for the wave operator is strictly supported on the light cone. On the opposite, in a generic curved background, a priori this does not hold true since the support includes a tail strictly contained in the cone and, hence, in the conformal completion language propagating at future timelike infinity. Thus, in order to recast the result of [4] in a generic scenario, Friedrich definition is the most appealing (to this avail see the analysis in [14]). In detail a four dimensional future time oriented spacetime M with a smooth metric gμν which solves the vacuum Einstein equation is called an asymptotically flat and vacuum spacetime with future time infinity i+ if it exists a second four , dimensional spacetime (M gμν ) with a preferred point i+ , a diffeomorphism λ : M → λ(M ) ⊂ M and a non negative scalar function Ω on λ(M ) such that g = Ω2 λ∗ g and the following facts hold: ) is closed and λ(M ) = J − (i+ ) \ ∂J − (i+ ; M ). Moreover ∂λ(M ) = 1. J − (i+ ; M + + + . − + + ∪ i where = ∂J (i ; M ) \ {i } is future null infinity. 2. λ(M ) is strongly causal. . 3. Ω can be extended to a smooth function on M + ν Ω(i+ ) = μ∇ 4. Ω|∂J − (i+ ;M = 0, dΩ(x) = 0 for x ∈ and dΩ(i+ ) = 0, but ∇ ) −2 gμν (i+ ). . ν Ω, it exists a strictly positive smooth function ω, defined 5. Calling nμ = gμν ∇ μ (ω 4 nμ ) = 0 on + , such that the in a neighbourhood of + and satisfying ∇ −1 μ integral curves of ω n are complete on + . From now we shall refer to λ(M ) simply as M since no confusion will arise in the manuscript due to this identification. Furthermore we point out that, with minor adaption, the above definition can be recast for spacetimes which are asymptotically flat with past time infinity i− and henceforth we shall refer only to + though the reader is warned that all our results hold identically for − . Thus let us consider any asymptotically flat spacetime as per the previous definition; the metric structure of future null infinity is not uniquely determined but it is affected by a gauge freedom in the choice of the compactification factor namely, if we rescale Ω as ωΩ with ω ∈ C ∞ (+ , R+ ), the topology and the differentiable structure of future null infinity is left unchanged. Hence the difference between the possible geometries for the conformal boundary is caught by equivalence classes of the following triplet of data (+ , na , hab ) where + stands for the . a the covariant derivative with Ω (being ∇ S2 × R topology of null infinity, na = ∇ . + respect to gab ) and hab = gab |+ . Two triplets ( , na , hab ) and (+ , na , hab ) are called equivalent if and only if it exists a gauge factor ω such that hab = ω 2 hab whereas na = ω −1 na . The set of all these equivalence classes is universal in the sense that, given any two asymptotically flat spacetimes M1 and M2 with associated triplets (+ 1 , n1a , + + + ab ) and ( , n , h ), it always exists a diffeomorphism γ ∈ Dif f ( , hab 2a 1 2 2 1 2 ) such ab that γ ∗ hab = h and γ n = n . ∗ 1a 2a 2 1
Vol. 9 (2008)
Projecting Massive Scalar Fields to Null Infinity
39
The set of all group elements γ ∈ Dif f (+ , + ) mapping a triplet into a gauge equivalent one2 is called the Bondi–Metzner–Sachs group (BMS). It is always possible to choose ω in such a way that on null infinity we can introduce the socalled Bondi frame (u, z, z¯) where u is the affine parameter along the null complete geodesics generating + and (z, z¯) are the complex coordinates constructed out of a stereographic projection on C from (θ, ϕ) ∈ S2 . Accordingly the BMS group is SO(3, 1) C ∞ (S2 ) acting as u −→ u = KΛ (z, z¯) u + α(z, z¯) , (2) ¯z¯ + ¯b . a . az + b , z¯ −→ Λ¯ z= , (3) z −→ Λz = cz + d c¯z¯ + d¯
a b where Λ is identified with the matrix satisfying ad − bc = 1, whereas c d KΛ (z, z¯) =
1 + |z|2 . |az + b|2 + |cz + d|2
A direct inspection of this formula shows that the BMS group is a regular semidirect product and it is much larger than the Poincar´e group. In a generic scenario such a problem cannot be easily overcome though one can recognize that any element in the Abelian ideal C ∞ (S2 ) can be expanded in real spherical harmonics as l l 1 ∞ α(z, z¯) = αlm Slm (z, z¯) + αlm Slm (z, z¯) . ∀α(z, z¯) ∈ C ∞ (S2 ) . l=0 m=−l
l=2 m=−l
Here we have separated the set of first four components – known as the translational component of the BMS group – since it is homomorphic to the Abelian group T 4 . Furthermore the following proposition holds: Proposition 1.1. The subset SO(3, 1) T 4 of the BMS group made of elements (Λ, α(z, z¯)), where α(z, z¯) is any real linear combination of the first four spherical harmonics, is a BMS subgroup and if we associate to α(z, z¯) the vector
3 a00 μ √ , a1−1 , a10 , a11 , a =− 4π 3 the action of Λ ∈ SO(3, 1) on aμ is equivalent to the transformation of the 4-vector in Minkowski background under the standard Lorentz action. The proof of this theorem has been given in Propositions 3.11 and 3.12 in [4]. We wish to stress that, in a generic asymptotically flat spacetime, we cannot exploit this last statement to select a preferred Poincar´e subgroup in the BMS since, acting per conjugation over the above SO(3, 1) T 4 subset with any 2 Although
at first sight we are considering a subgroup of the whole set of diffeomorphisms, one should take into account that the constraint we impose is equivalent to require that the bulk geometry is left unchanged, i.e., we are working on a fixed background.
40
C. Dappiaggi
Ann. Henri Poincar´e
element (I, Slm (z, z¯)) ∈ SO(3, 1) C ∞ (S2 ) with l > 1, we end up with a different though equivalent Poincar´e subgroup. Nonetheless, since in this paper we are taking into account only Minkowski background, we can exploit a result due to Geroch, Ashtekar and Xanthopoulos [2, 8] namely Proposition 1.2. In any asymptotically flat spacetime (M, gμν ) it holds and a) any Killing vector ξ in M smoothly extends to a Killing vector ξ in M ˜ the restriction ξ of the latter to is tangent to null infinity; it is uniquely determined by ξ and it generates a one-parameter subgroup of the BMS. b) the map ξ → ξ˜ is injective and, if the one-parameter subgroup of the BMS generated by ξ˜ lies in C ∞ (S2 ), then it must also be a subgroup of T 4 . According to the last proposition, in a Minkowski background, the Poincar´e isometries identify a preferred subgroup of the BMS group, i.e., the set 2 ¯ ¯ 0 1 z+z 2 z−z 3 |z| − 1 R = Λ, α(z, z¯) α(z, z¯) = a + a +a +a , (4) 1 + |z|2 1 + |z|2 1 + |z|2 which is homomorphic to SO(3, 1) T 4 .
2. From massive to massless scalar fields on Minkowski spacetime Let us consider four dimensional flat Minkowski spacetime (M, ημν ) and a scalar field φ : M → C satisfying the Klein–Gordon equation with squared mass m2 > 0: η φ − m2 φ = 0 .
(5)
In the most general framework we should seek for tempered distributions solutions to such PDE and their Fourier transform is a function supported on the mass 3 hyperboloids Hm (see Section IX.9 of [15]) η μν pμ pν = p20 − i=1 p2i = m2 , being pμ = (p0 , pi ) with i = 1, . . . , 3 the standard global coordinates3 on each fibre of the cotangent bundle T ∗ M canonically identified as R4 × R4 . . The mass hyperboloids can be parameterized4 with the coordinates r = | p|≡ 1 3 . . p p0 2 2 2 3 p ∈ [0, ∞), ζ = ∈ S → R and = = ±1. The value of p2 is i=1
i
| p|
|p0 |
0
p|2 , whereas the variable provides a way fixed by the defining relation p20 = m2 + | to distinguish in R4 between the upper and lower hyperboloid and we will keep track of it for the sake of generality. An interested reader can adapt the following constructions to a single hyperboloid with minor efforts. To conclude, identifying Hm with the coset O(3,1) O(3) , we can endow it with the O(3, 1) invariant measure dμ(Hm ) = 3 The
2 √ r drdζ. r 2 +m2
symbols are here adopted with respect to the standard high energy physics terminology though we do not seek at the moment any physical interpretation of the forthcoming analysis leaving it for the conclusions. 4 We wish to stress to a potential reader that we are adopting nomenclatures and symbols for coordinates as in [20] which are partly different from those in [21], where some results of this section were first derived.
Vol. 9 (2008)
Projecting Massive Scalar Fields to Null Infinity
41
Moreover, as outlined in the introduction, the aim of this section is to associate to each solution of the Klein–Gordon equation of motion a massless scalar field. To this avail we need to take into account only a subclass of all possible solutions of (5), namely those which are finite with respect to a suitable norm. Such problem was already pointed out in [20] where the following solution was suggested: it must exists a real number α ≥ 0 and a function f (r, ζ, ) such that, being x the spatial component of xμ and · the standard Euclidean scalar product on R3 , √ 2 2 φ(xμ ) = dμ(Hm ) eirx·ζ e−i r +m t f (r, ζ, ) =±1H m
and φ2α =
α
dμ(Hm )|(r2 + m2 ) 2 f (r, ζ, )|2 < ∞ .
(6)
=±1H m
Dropping from now on all references to dμ(Hm ), we may call the Hilbert spaces of functions satisfying (6) as L2α and, out of a direct inspection of the above formula, one can realize that L20 coincides with L2 (Hm ), the space of square integrable functions over the mass hyperboloid. Furthermore, for a generic φ ∈ L2α the following chain of inequalities holds: ∞ > φ2α ≥ dμ(Hm )(r2 + m2 )α |f (r, ζ, )|2 =±1H m
= m2α+2
dμ(H1 )(r2 + 1)α |f (r , ζ, )|2
=±1H 1
> m2α+2
dμ(H1 )|f (r , ζ, )|2 ,
=±1H 1
where, in the equality, we rescaled the coordinate r to mr = r and H1 stands for the hyperboloid with m = 1. Hence f (r , ζ, ) lies in L2 (H1 ) or, equivalently, the original φ ∈ L20 ≡ L2 (Hm ). This identity shows that the following chain of inclusions holds: L2α ⊂ L2α ⊂ 2 L (Hm ) ≡ L20 for all 0 < α < α . For this reason, from now on, we will work only within the space L20 unless stated otherwise. To summarise the key point, the constraint (6) allows us a way to select only those solutions φ of (5) whose Fourier transform admits a restriction – f – on the mass hyperboloid which is square integrable with respect to the O(3, 1)-invariant measure. Furthermore we can require the O(3, 1) group to act on f with the quasiregular scalar representation, i.e., for any Λ ∈ O(3, 1) and for any pμ ∈ Hm → R4 U (Λ)f (pμ ) = f (Λ−1 pμ ) ,
f ∈ L2 (Hm )
being U unitary strongly continuous but not irreducible.
(7)
42
C. Dappiaggi
Ann. Henri Poincar´e
Henceforth our plan is to discuss and later to exploit the following Strichartz result: it is possible to construct an operator T from L2 (Hm ) ⊕ L2 (Hm ) into the space of square-integrable functions over the light cone with respect to the O(3, 1)invariant measure and T is also a unitary intertwiner5 between the quasi-regular O(3, 1)-representations. 2.1. From hyperboloids to light cones The analysis and the statements in this section are based upon the theorems proved in [21] even though part of the results have been independently developed also in [11] by means of integral transforms associated to horospheres. The proof of most of the following results strongly relies upon the embedding of the mass hyperboloid and of the light cone in R4 . All the analysis can be recast in terms of the intrinsic structures over these symmetric spaces and we refer to [17] for an interested reader. As a starting point we shall briefly discuss and characterize some properties of square integrable functions over the light cone. Let us quickly recall that the latter is the geometric locus p |2 = 0 \ (0, 0) , C = pμ = (p0 , pi ), η μν pμ pν = p20 − | where pμ = (p0 , p ) = (p0 , pi ) with i = 1, . . . , 3 are the same global coordinates introduced in the previous section. As for Hm we can represent C, together with an O(3, 1)-invariant measure in a more convenient coordinate system which is basically constructed with a limiting procedure (i.e., m → 0) from the counterpart . . on the mass hyperboloid. Namely, if we refer to r = | p |, ζ = |pp | ∈ S2 → R3 and . p|2 whereas = |pp00 | = ±1, the value of p20 is set by the defining relation p20 = | the measure is dμ(C) = rdrdζ. Here the two values of allow us to distinguish between the future and the past light cone and, as for the massive case, we keep track of them for the sake of completeness. The next step consists of a specific characterization for square integrable functions over the light cone with respect to dμ(C). Let us consider the set D0σ and D1σ respectively of even and odd smooth functions over C homogeneous of degree σ in the r-variable, i.e., of the form rσ g(ζ, ). Then the following proposition holds Proposition 2.1. If σ = −1 + iρ with ρ ∈ R, then D0σ and D1σ can be closed to Hilbert space Hσ0 and Hσ1 with respect to the norm dζ|g(ζ, )|2 . rσ g(ζ, )2σ = =±1
S2
Furthermore 5 We recall that, given a group G with the representations U and U on the Hilbert spaces H and H , a bounded linear map T : H → H is called an intertwiner if U (g)T = T U (g) for all g ∈ G.
Vol. 9 (2008)
Projecting Massive Scalar Fields to Null Infinity
43
1. the quasi-regular O(3, 1) scalar representation acting on the functions over C as U (Λ)F (pμ ) = F (Λ−1 pμ ) ,
∀pμ ∈ C → R4 ∧ ∀F ∈ L2 (C) ,
is strongly continuous unitary and irreducible on both Hσ0 and Hσ1 . 2. for any F ∈ L2 (C) it exists a unique function ϕ0 in Hσ0 and ϕ1 in Hσ1 such that, calling F0 (pμ ) = 12 (F (pμ ) + F (−pμ )) and F1 (pμ ) = 12 (F (pμ ) −F (−pμ )), then ∞ dρ 2 dζ |ϕj (ρ, ζ, )| , j = 0, 1 (8) Fj (pμ )L2 (C) = 2π =±1 −∞
S2
and ∞ dρ Fj (r, ζ, ) = r−1+iρ ϕj (ρ, ζ, ) . 2π =±1
j = 0, 1 .
(9)
−∞
The image of the map F → (ϕ0 , ϕ1 ) is onto all pairs with a finite right hand side in (8). Proof. We here sketch the main details of the proof as in [21]. To start, let us notice that the norm over D0σ and D1σ is well defined since, up to the sum over , it is equivalent to the norm over L2 (S2 , d2 x) being d2 x the Lesbegue measure on S2 . The unitarity and strong continuity of the quasi-regular representation arises due to the O(3, 1)-invariance of the measure on the light cone. Hence for any F (pμ ) ∈ L2 (C) with pμ ∈ R4 satisfying η μν pμ pν = 0, it holds: 2 dμ(C)|U (Λ)F (pμ )| = dμ(C)|F (Λ−1 pμ )|2 C
C
= C
dμ(ΛC)|F (pμ )|2 =
dμ(C)|F (pμ )|2 ,
C
where, in the second equality, we performed the coordinate change pμ → Λpμ . To prove irreducibility let us note that any function f ∈ Hσj with j = 0, 1 can ∞ l be decomposed in spherical harmonics, i.e., f (r, ζ, ) = rσ g(ζ, ) = l=0 m=−l alm Ylm (ζ)k rσ where k = 0, 1 and the coefficients ajm must vanish if j = 0 and l + k is odd or if j = 1 and l + k is even. Consider now, as a special case, a function in Hσj with all but one of the coefficients alm equal to zero. We show now that the action of the quasi-regular O(3, 1) representation generates a second function with the coefficients al+1,m = 0. To this avail let us choose an element of SO(1, 1) ⊂ O(3, 1) parameterized by an angle α, apply it to f and then let us differentiate with respect to α. The resulting function f evaluated in α = 0 is f (r, ζ, ) =
(σ − l)(l + 1) σ r Yl+1 (ζ)k+1 . 1 + 2l
44
C. Dappiaggi
Ann. Henri Poincar´e
Since all these operations should map any irreducible subspace of Hσj into itself, the statement in point 1 of the theorem holds. To demonstrate point 2 let us associate to any F (pμ ) ≡ F (r, ζ, ) ∈ L2 (C), the functions gj (r, ζ, ) = rFj (r, ζ, ) with j = 0, 1. Hence for each j ∞ 2 dμ(C)|Fj (r, ζ, )| = dζ dr r−1 |gj (r, ζ, )|2 < ∞ , C
0
S2
∞
−1
2
which implies that 0 drr |gj (r, ζ, )| < ∞ per Fubini’s theorem. We can now apply Mellin inversion theorem to write ∞ ∞ iρ gj (r, ζ, ) = dρ r ϕj (ρ, ζ, ) = dρ eiρ ln(r) ϕj (ρ, ζ, ) . −∞
−∞
The apply Plancherel theorem to conclude ∞ us to −1 ∞ that ∞ last identity suggests 2 2 d ln(r)|g (r, ζ, )| = dρ(2π) |ϕ (ρ, ζ, )| and that ϕ (ρ, ζ, ) = j j j 0 −∞ 0 d ln(r) is ln(r) 2 e gj (r, ζ, ). Hence, upon integration over the compact S -coordinates, we recover (8) and (9). The overall construction relies only on Mellin inversion formula and the Plancherel theorem; thus the map from Fj onto ϕj exists whenever the latter is square-integrable. To conclude the analysis on the functions over a light cone, let us recall the following result still from [21]: Lemma 2.1. Whenever ρ = 0 then ρ A0 (ρ)ϕ(ζ , ) = |ζ · ζ − |−1−iρ ϕ(ζ, )dζ , π =±1 S2 ρ A1 (ρ)ϕ(ζ , ) = |ζ · ζ − |−1−iρ sgn ζ · ζ − ϕ(ζ, )dζ , π =±1
(10)
(11)
S2
are unitary operators respectively on odd and on even functions in L2 (S2 × ±1). In (10) and (11) “ · ” stands for the standard Euclidean scalar product on R3 , whereas a function f (ζ, ) ∈ L2 (S2 × ±1) if and only if |f (ζ, )|2 < ∞ . =±1
S2
We can now put together the previous lemma and Proposition 2.1 in order to represent any F ∈ L2 (C) in terms of a scalar function supported on the whole R4 as ∞ 1 2 dρ ρ dζ | p · ζ − p0 |−1+iρ ψ0 (ρ, ζ , ) F (pμ ) = 3 2π =±1−∞ S2 p · ζ − p0 ) , (12) + ψ1 (ρ, ζ , )sgn(
Vol. 9 (2008)
Projecting Massive Scalar Fields to Null Infinity
. being ψk (ρ, ζ , ) = to (9). Furthermore, F 22 =
π ρ Ak (ρ)ϕk (ρ, ζ , )
=±1
S2
dζ
∞
−∞
45
with k = 0, 1 and ϕk chosen according
dρ 2 ρ |ψ0 (ρ, ζ , )|2 + ψ1 (ρ, ζ , )|2 , 2π
being the norm , 2 that defined in (6) fixing α = 2. The original F is recovered simply imposing in (12) the constraint p0 = | p|. Such a property will be exploited in Proposition 2.2. Let us now move back to the square integrable functions over Hm and, to = − ∂ 22 + 3 ∂ 22 . We wish to stress that is the fix notations, let us call i=1 ∂pi ∂p0 D’Alembert wave operator in the momentum space and, in this manuscript, it has no relation with , the counterpart in the coordinate space. Instead of working with (p0 , pi ) or (m, r, ζ), we introduce as a useful tool for next proposition the new local coordinates (m, s, ζ) defined in the region | p| < . 2 . |p| 2 2 p| ∈ (0, ∞), s = |p0 | ∈ [0, 1), ζ ∈ S and = ±1 which |p0 | as m = p0 − | distinguishes between positive and negative values of p0 . The advantage of this new frame lies in the expression for the D’Alembert = − ∂ 22 − 3 ∂ + H2 , where H is the Laplacian wave operator which becomes ∂m m ∂m m on the unit hyperboloid. We stress to the reader that in the forthcoming discussion all derivatives act in a weak/distributional sense. It is standard result that H is a selfadjoint operator on f ∈ L2 (Hm ), | H f ∈ L2 (Hm ) , with a continuous negative spectrum; furthermore it commutes with the quasi = 0 for any Λ ∈ regular O(3, 1) representation, i.e., [U (Λ), H ] = [U (Λ), ] O(3, 1). The strategy is to consider the mass hyperboloid as a non characteristic initial surface for the wave equation u(m, s, ζ, ) = 0 to be solved in the region m ≥ 0. In particular the following lemma holds: Lemma 2.2. Calling B = −H − 1, then for any f, g ∈ L2 (Hm ) the function √
u(m, s, ζ, ) = m−1+i
B
√
f (s, ζ, ) + m−1−i
B
g(s, ζ, )
(13)
= 0 for m > 0 with Cauchy data satisfies u u(1, s, ζ, ) = f (s, ζ, ) + g(s, ζ, ) , iB − 2 ∂(mu) ∂m (1, s, ζ, ) = g(s, ζ, ) − f (s, ζ, ) . 1
Furthermore for all m > 0 it holds 2 f 22 + g22 = =±1
S2
1 dζ 0
(ms)2 ds (1 − s2 )2
2 − 1 ∂(mu) 2 (s, ζ, ) , |u(m, s, ζ, )| + B ∂m
where , 2 is the norm (6) with α = 2.
2
46
C. Dappiaggi
Ann. Henri Poincar´e
Proof. If we show that u(m, s, ζ, ) is a solution of D’Alembert wave equation then the statement on Cauchy data holds per direct substitution and the identity √ i B 2 on L (Hm ). between norms stands per unitarity of the operator m Hence let us consider any but fixed v ∈ C0∞ (R4 ) whose support does not include the origin. Dropping the dependence which is irrelevant in the proof, integration per parts grants: 4 μ μ μ d p v(p )u(p ) = d4 p u(pμ )v(p ). R4
R4
Since both the coordinates (m, r, ζ) and (m, s, ζ) cover the mass hyperboloid, a direct inspection of the transformation relation between these two frame systems (ms)2 shows that dμ(Hm ) = (1−s 2 )2 dsdζ. Hence the above formula reads
∞ dm 0
Hm
H ∂2 3 ∂ + dμ(Hm ) mu(m, s, ζ) − − v(m, s, ζ) ∂m2 m ∂m m2
∂ ∂2 dμ(Hm ) m−1 v(m, s, ζ) H − m2 − 3m u(m, s, ζ) , ∂m2 ∂m
∞
dm
= 0
Hm
which, inserting the expression for u(m, s, ζ) in the hypothesis, becomes
∞ dm 0
dμ(Hm ) m−1 v(m, s, ζ) (H + 1 + B) u(m, s, ζ) = 0 ,
Hm
. being B = −H − 1.
The choice of the initial surface as the unitary hyperboloid is pure convenience and no generality is lost in this process since it is possible to pick any Hm and none of the forthcoming results would be modified. The independence from m in the norm identity in the last lemma and the equality limm→0 dμ(Hm ) = dμ(C) suggests that we are now in position to construct a unitary intertwining operator T : L2 (C) → L2 (Hm ) ⊕ L2 (Hm ). As a matter of fact all the needed ingredients can be found in the previous lemma and in formula (12): Proposition 2.2. Given any function F ∈ L2 (C) let us consider it as a function over all R4 by means of decomposition (12) and let us split it as F = F+ + F− where + represents the contribution of the integral in the ρ-variable between 0 and infinity in (12) whereas the pedex − refers to that between minus infinity and 0. . . Then let us call as f = F+ |Hm and g = F− |Hm the restriction of F+ and F− on the mass hyperboloid obtained imposing on the coordinates pμ in (12) the constraint p20 = | p|2 + m2 . It holds either that f, g ∈ L2 (Hm ), either that the function u constructed as in Lemma 2.2 coincides with F .
Vol. 9 (2008)
Projecting Massive Scalar Fields to Null Infinity
47
Furthermore the map T : L2 (C) −→ L2 (Hm ) ⊕ L2 (Hm ) , which associates to each function F ∈ L2 (C) the pair (f, g) above defined, is an intertwiner between the O(3, 1) representations. The demonstration is left to [21]. Remark 2.1. A consequence of the above proposition is that any f ∈ L2 (Hm ) can be represented as a function f (pμ ) defined over the whole R4 ∞ dρ μ 2 − p0 |−1+iρ ψ0 (ρ, ζ , ) f (p ) = ρ dζ | p · ζ 2π 3 =±1 0 S2 (14) + sgn p · ζ − p0 ψ1 (ρ, ζ , ) , where ψ0 (ρ, ζ , ) =
d4 p δ(η μν pμ pν − m2 )f (pμ )| p · ζ − p0 |−1−iρ ,
R4
and ψ1 (ρ, ζ , ) =
d4 p δ(η μν pμ pν − m2 )f (pμ )| p · ζ − p0 |−1−iρ sgn p · ζ − p0 .
R4
The original f ∈ L2 (Hm ) is obtained from the above representation imposing on p0 the constraint/defining relation p20 = | p|2 + m2 . Let us also pinpoint 1. although (14) is written in terms of the global coordinates pμ , we can first restrict ourselves to Hm as explained above and, then, we can switch to intrinsic coordinates (r, ζ, ). In this way the generic function f ∈ L2 (Hm ) is explicitly decomposed into a direct integral in terms of irreducible representations of O(3, 1). 2. Proposition 2.2 provides a way to explicitly construct the inverse intertwiner . T = T −1 : L2 (Hm ) ⊕ L2 (Hm ) → L2 (C). As a matter of fact starting from any two functions f, g ∈ L2 (Hm ), one can generate a solution of D’Alembert wave equation out of (13) whose restriction to the light cone is a function F ∈ L2 (C); in a few words T(f, g) = F . From our perspective this a slightly inconvenient situation since we start with a solution of (5) and, hence, with a single function f ∈ L2 (Hm ). Unfortunately the Cauchy problem, upon which (13) is based, requires two initial conditions. Hence we adopt the choice to imbed L2 (Hm ) into the diagonal component of L2 (Hm ) ⊕ L2 (Hm ), namely we fix the map i : L2 (Hm ) → L2 (Hm ) ⊕ L2 (Hm ) such that i(f ) = (f, f ). Clearly this choice is not unique and the resulting function on the light cone we will construct depends also upon the choice of i.
48
C. Dappiaggi
Ann. Henri Poincar´e
To summarise we have set the map T ◦ i : L2 (Hm ) → L2 (C) such that T (i(f )) = F . In order to complete our task, a last question must be answered namely if, to any element of L2 (C), it corresponds a function in Minkowski spacetime which solves the wave equation. A positive answer has been already given in [22] and6 , thus, we end up with: Proposition 2.3. If F ∈ L2 (C), then it is the restriction on the light cone of the Fourier transform of a function ψ ∈ L4 (M, d4 x) which solves the wave equation η ψ(xμ ) = 0 with Cauchy data ∂ψ ψ(0, xi ) = f1 (xi ) , 0, xi = f2 (xi ) , ∂t √ 3 ∂ 2 1 1 with K 2 f1 (xi ) and K − 2 f2 (xi ) ∈ L2 (R3 , d3 x) where K = − and = i=1 ∂x 2. i Furthermore it exists a suitable constant C such that 1 1 (15) ψ(xμ )L4 (M) ≤ C K 2 f1 (xi )L2 (R3 ) + K − 2 f2 (xi )L2 (R3 ) . Proof. The first part of the proposition is proved in Lemma 1 of Strichartz seminal paper [22]. Hence we know that ψ(xμ ) is a solution for the wave equation lying in L4 (M, d4 x) and we need only to focus on Cauchy data. In a standard Minkowski frame with coordinates xμ = (t, x) ∈ R4 we can decompose the solution for the wave equation constructed out of F as d3 p ei(p·x−t|p|) F1 (p) + ei(p·x+t|p|) F−1 (p) , ψ(t, x) = 16π 3 |p| R3
where F1 and F−1 are respectively the restriction of F to the upper and lower light cone. Taking into account the identity d3 p F1 (p) F−1 (p) − 12 ψ(t, x) = −i √ K ei(p·x−t|p|) + ei(p·x+t|p|) , 3 | p| | p| 16π 3 R
1
and evaluating this expression for t = 0, we discover that K 2 ψ(0, x) is up to a multiplicative constant complex number the sum of the Fourier transform of 1 F±1 (p) √ ; hence, being F ∈ L2 (C), per Plancherel theorem K 2 ψ(0, x) ∈ L2 (R3 , d3 x). 2| p|
Deriving now once in the time variable and exploiting the same kind of identity, we end up with d3 p 1 F1 (p) F−1 (p) ∂ψ − ei(p·x+t|p|) (t, x) = i √ K 2 ei(p·x−t|p|) . 3 ∂t | p| | p| 16π R3
6 For
an interested reader, we point out that the first successful attempt to construct global norm estimates for solutions of the D’Alembert wave equation is due to Segal in [16] though he considers only the two dimensional scenario.
Vol. 9 (2008)
Projecting Massive Scalar Fields to Null Infinity
49
Hence, evaluating at t = 0 this expression and still exploiting the Plancherel 1 x) ∈ L2 (R3 , d3 x). theorem as in the previous case, we end up with K 2 ∂ψ ∂t (0, To conclude the demonstration it suffices to notice that the field ψ(xμ ) and the functions f1 (xi ), f2 (xi ) satisfy the hypotheses of corollary 2 in [22] where the norm estimate (15) for the homogeneous D’Alembert wave equation has been proved. 2.1.1. From bulk to null infinity. The results from the previous section can be applied to introduce a “projection” of finite-norm solutions φ for the massive Klein–Gordon equation to null infinity. In particular let us summarise that all the informations of φ can be encoded in the following triplet of data: 1. the function ψ(xμ ) which solves the massless Klein–Gordon equation of motion constructed along the lines of Proposition 2.3, 2. the quasi-regular representation U (Λ), 3. the intertwiner T : L2 (C) → L2 (Hm ) ⊕ L2 (Hm ). We stress that the inclusion of T and U as a datum to reconstruct the original massive field is essential since neither assigning U implies that it exists a unique unitary intertwiner T nor fixing T implies that it is an intertwiner for a unique pair of representations U and U . Thus the overall problem reduces to find a projection for ψ(xμ ) to null infinity. As a first step let us remember that Minkowski spacetime can be compactified in the Einstein static universe [23]. More in detail, let us consider the coordinates (u, v, θ, ϕ) being (θ, ϕ) the standard coordinates on S2 , u = t + r and v = t − r with r as radial coordinate and let us choose as conformal factor −1 Ω2 = 4 (1 + u2 )(1 + v 2 ) . (16) Hence the flat metric is rescaled to ds2 = gμν dxμ dxν =
4 (u − v)2 2 (θ, ϕ) , −dudv + dS (1 + u2 )(1 + v 2 ) 4
. with dS2 (θ, ϕ) = dθ2 + sin2 θdϕ2 . If we perform the change of variables τ = tan−1 u + tan−1 v ,
η = tan−1 u − tan−1 v ,
(17)
then we can realize the original Minkowski spacetime as the locus (−π, π) × (−π, π) × S2 ⊂ R × S3 with respect to the metric g μν dXμ dXν = −dτ 2 + dη 2 + sin2 η dS2 (θ, ϕ) , ds2 =
(18)
. Let us notice that, the closure of the image i.e., that of Einstein static universe M gμν ) is compact and that + is nothing but of Minkowski spacetime in (R × S3 , the locus τ + η = π. More importantly this new background is still globally hyperbolic and, if we . introduce ψ = Ω−1 ψ, then it is a solution of the Klein–Gordon equation g ψ − . μν R ∇μ ∇ν is the wave operator with respect to the metric gμν g =g 6 ψ = 0 where and R = 1 is the scalar curvature of Einstein static universe. Furthermore, since
50
C. Dappiaggi
Ann. Henri Poincar´e
, we can recast the original Cauchy surface R3 at t = 0 is mapped into τ = 0 in M the Cauchy problem in Proposition 2.3 as ⎧ μ ψ(X ) μ ⎪ ⎪ ⎨ g ψ(X ) = 6 X i ) = f1 (X i ) (19) ψ(0, ⎪ ⎪ ⎩ ∂ ψ i = f2 (X i ) , ∂τ 0, X . 12 f1 (X i ) ∈ L2 (S3 ) and K − 12 f2 (X i ) ∈ where X μ = (τ, X i ) = (τ, η, θ, ϕ) and where K the square-root of the Laplace–Beltrami operator out of the spaL2 (S3 ) being K tial component of the metric (18). Here square integrability is meant with respect to the measure dμ = sin2 η sin θdηdθdϕ. μ ) satisfies the Klein–Gordon equation with m2 = 1/6, it coincides Hence ψ(X −1 and furthermore it lies in with Ω ψ in the image of Minkowski spacetime in M 4 4 L (M, | g|d X) since ψ(xμ )4L4 = |ψ(xμ )|4 d4 x R4
= R4
μ )|4 Ω4 d4 x = |ψ(x
π π
d4 X
μ )|4 , | g ||ψ(X
−π −π S2
where in the last equality we exploited the coordinate change (17). Unfortunately, since our aim is to project ψ on null infinity, the best available tools to define a function on + are trace theorems for Sobolev spaces. In order to exploit them the set of solutions for the wave equation we are taking into account is too big and thus we need to consider only more regular solutions for the wave equation. To understand which is the less restrictive constraint we have to impose, let us gather all the needed ingredients. As a first step we point out that, being Minkowski spacetime an openset of finite volume (either with respect to Lesbegue g|dτ dηdS2 (θ, ϕ)) in Einstein static universe, then measure or with respect to | H¨older inequality grants us that Lp (M ) ⊂ Lq (M ) for all 1 ≤ q < p ≤ ∞ (see Chapter 2, Lemma 3.7 in [19]). This property can be recast at a level of first order Sobolev spaces in Lp (M ), i.e., W 1,p (M ) ⊂ W 1,q (M ) for 1 ≤ q < p ≤ ∞. As a second step we aim to exploit Proposition 4.3 in [19] according to which, if Ω is a bounded domain in RN with a three dimensional C 1 -boundary ∂Ω, then it exists a linear trace operator γ : W 1,p (Ω) → Lp (∂Ω) which is continuous and uniquely determined by the boundary value of the functions u ∈ C 1 (Ω). Furthermore the kernel of γ is W01,p (Ω), i.e., the closure of C0∞ (Ω) in W 1,p (Ω). Our scenario meets all the geometric requirements in the above hypothesis since Minkowski background is a bounded open set in Einstein static universe R × S3 which, in its turn, can be identified as an open set of R5 . Furthermore the boundary of M consists of two smooth null hypersurfaces – future and past
Vol. 9 (2008)
Projecting Massive Scalar Fields to Null Infinity
51
null infinity – and thus, taking into account that ψ lies in L4 (M, d4 X) and hence in Lp (M, d4 X) for all 1 ≤ p ≤ 4, we can apply such proposition only to those ψ ∈ W 1,p (M ) still with 1 ≤ p ≤ 4. With this further condition set and with the inclusion relations between the Sobolev spaces as discussed before, we are entitled to introduce the map γ|+ : W 1,p (M ) → Lq (+ ) where q can be fixed to any value lower or equal to p. Here + is the locus (−π, π) × S2 and the measure on + is the Lesbegue one. Hence, being + in this reference frame an open set of R × S2 , each function on Lq (+ ) can be also read as an element in Lq (R × S2 ). This property will be exploited in the next section. Taking into account that, both from a physical point of view and for the analysis in the next section, it is better to work with Hilbert spaces on the boundary we can summarise the previous discussion as: Proposition 2.4. Assume that Minkowski spacetime is conformally embedded as , an open set – M – of Einstein static universe (M g) with g as in (18). Then, . 4 4 4 for anysolution of the wave equation ψ ∈ L (R , d x) the function ψ = Ω−1 ψ ∈ g|d4 X) – with Ω chosen as in (16) – solves (19). Furthermore, whenL4 (M, | ever ψ ∈ W 1,p (M ) with p ≤ 4, it exists a continuous projection operator γ|+ : W 1,p (M ) → Lq (+ ) where we fix q = 2 if 2 ≤ p ≤ 4 whereas q = 1 if p = 1. The image Ψ under γ|+ of ψ will be referred to as its restriction on future null infinity. Remark 2.2. This last proposition partly overlaps the scenarios envisaged in [4,12] where only solutions ψ to the D’Alembert wave equation with compactly supported initial data where taken into account. As partly discussed in the introduction, in this case, ψ ∈ C ∞ (R4 ) and accordingly also ψ ∈ C ∞ (M ) adopting the nomenclature of the previous analysis. Furthermore the uniqueness of the solution for the Cauchy problem of the Klein–Gordon equation in the Einstein static universe al coinciding with ψ if restricted lows to construct a unique function in the whole M to M . Hence, in this case, restriction to + simply means evaluation of the solution on future null infinity. Remark 2.3. We point out that the additional regularity condition (i.e., ψ ∈ W 1,p (M )) on the solutions for the D’Alembert wave equation has been set in the Einstein static universe because a direct inspection of the previous construction shows that, although, whenever f ∈ Lp (R4 , d4 x), Ω−1 f ∈ Lp (R4 , Ω4 d4 x) for p ≤ 4, this does not held true for first order Sobolev spaces. In other words, even if f ∈ W 1,p (R4 ), then, exploiting Liebinitz rule, one can realize that, due to the contribution of the derivatives of the conformal factor (16), Ω−1 f lies in Lp (R4 , Ω4 d4 x) but not necessary in W 1,p (R4 , Ω4 d4 x). Hence we have achieved our goal since all the information from the original massive field φ satisfying (5) has been projected onto null infinity in the triplet
52
C. Dappiaggi
Ann. Henri Poincar´e
(Ψ, U , T ) where U is the quasi-regular O(3, 1) representation acting on the massless field and T is the intertwiner constructed in the previous section. Two natural questions arise at this stage: • What about Poincar´e covariance? • How can we translate at a field theoretical level the assertion that (Ψ, U , T ) contains the information of the massive scalar field? Let us answer to the first and simpler question. Up to now we have considered only the quasi-regular O(3, 1) action on the set L2 (C) or L2 (Hm ). If we want to deal instead with Poincar´e covariant scalar field theories, a function φ satisfying either (5) or D’Alembert wave equation would transform in a momentum frame as μ ) = eiaμ pμ φ(Λ −1 pμ ) , (Λ, aμ )φ(p U where the hat symbol stands for the Fourier transform. This identity supplemented with the constraints η ρσ pρ pσ φ(pμ ) = m2 φ(pμ ) with m2 ≥ 0 and sgn(p0 ) > 0 is a unitary irreducible representation for the full Poincar´e group [3]. In order to relate the two above points of view, beside the trivial restriction from O(3, 1) to SO(3, 1), we need only to invoke the induction-reduction theorem (c.f. Chapter 18 in [3]) according to which the quasi-regular representation U (Λ) on L2 (Hm ) is a) the SO(3, 1) representation induced from the identity representation of SO(3), b) the restriction of the scalar Poincar´e representation to the Lorentz group. At the same time, if we start from U (Λ), it induces the unitary and irreducible scalar representation of the full Poincar´e group. A similar reasoning and conclusion holds if we consider L2 (C) with the associated quasi-regular representation U (Λ). 2.2. Data reconstruction on null infinity In this subsection we face the last and most important question namely in which sense the information from the bulk massive field, projected on null infinity out of U , T ), can be interpreted from a classical field theory perspective. To this end (ψ, we shall exploit some recent analysis according to which it is possible to explicitly construct a diffeomorphism invariant field theory on future null infinity. Afterwards our aim will be to show how the above triplet can be interpreted in terms of such a boundary free field theory. Bearing in mind the notations and the nomenclatures of Subsection 1.1, we review some features of the construction of a Poincar´e invariant field theory on + – thought as a null differentiable manifold7 – for smooth scalar fields invariant under the R subgroup of the BMS as discussed in [1, 4, 5]. For a different approach to holographic related issues which also takes into account the BMS group, a reader may wish to consult [18]. 7 More
appropriately one should claim that we are constructing a QFT on the equivalence class of triplets (+ , na , hab ) associated to the bulk Minkowski spacetime.
Vol. 9 (2008)
Projecting Massive Scalar Fields to Null Infinity
53
We shall follow two possible roads: the first starts from a massless bulk scalar field and it imposes BMS invariance on the projection of such a field on null infinity whereas the second ignores the bulk and it constructs a scalar free field theory on + by means of the Mackey–Wigner programme, i.e., we only exploit the knowledge of the symmetry group. We stress that the full construction has been developed for a generic asymptotically flat spacetime due to the universality of the boundary structure. Hence, although both the above mentioned approaches have been fully accounted for in [4, 5], here we will only review the details adapted to the case of Minkowski bulk spacetime and, thus, Poincar´e symmetry group on null infinity leaving an interested reader to the above cited manuscripts for a careful analysis. Let us thus start from the first part of this programme; in order to construct a meaningful scalar field theory on + starting from the bulk, we can focus only on smooth solutions ψ for the D’Alembert wave equation. As per Remark 2.2 such a bulk field projects to Ψ ∈ C ∞ (+ ). Then, if we wish to define a suitable representation of R acting on each Ψ, the following proposition holds [4]: Proposition 2.5. Let us take Minkowski spacetime (M, ημν ) and an associated , spacetime (M gμν ) out of Penrose compactification process (not necessarily Einstein static universe) and let us fix an arbitrary gauge factor ω. Then, for any but fixed λ ∈ R and for any but fixed g ∈ R ⊂ BM S, a R-representation is A(λ) (g) : λ is C ∞ (+ ) → C ∞ (+ ) such that the map t → A(λ) (gt )Ψ = lim+ (ωΩ) gt∗ (ψ) + smooth for every fixed bulk scalar field ψ with smooth projection Ψ on and for every but fixed one-parameter subgroup of the bulk Poincar´e group. In the Bondi frame (u, z, z¯) it reads (λ) A (g)Ψ (u , z , z¯ ) = KΛ−λ (z, z¯)Ψ(u, z, z¯) , ∀g = Λ, α(z, z¯) ∈ R where the primed coordinates and KΛ (z, z¯) are defined as in (2) and (3). Since our aim is to deal with unitary and irreducible representations we have to go one step further, i.e., Proposition 2.6. Let us consider the set S(+ ) ⊂ C ∞ (+ ) of real functions Ψ such that Ψ itself and all its derivatives decay faster than any power of |u| when |u| → ∞ and uniformly in (z, z¯). Then S(+ ) can be endowed with the strongly non degenerate symplectic form ∂Ψ1 ∂Ψ2 σ(Ψ1 , Ψ2 ) = − Ψ1 Ψ2 dudS2 (z, z¯) , ∂u ∂u R×S2
and (S(+ ), σ) is invariant only under A(1) . Furthermore if we introduce the pos + of Ψ ∈ S(+ ) as itive frequency part Ψ du iEu + (E, z, z¯) = √ Ψ e Ψ(u, z, z¯) , E ∈ [0, ∞) (20) 2π R
54
C. Dappiaggi
Ann. Henri Poincar´e
+ . If we denote with S(+ )C the complex linear combi=Ψ + + Ψ we can write Ψ nations of these functions Ψ(E, z, z¯), then + 1. S( )C can be closed to Hilbert space H with respect to the Hermitian inner product 1, Ψ 1, Ψ 2 = −iσ(Ψ 2) . Ψ Furthermore the Hilbert space (H, , ) is unitary isomorphic to the space L2 (R × S2 , EdEdS2 (z, z¯)). 2. the representation A(1) of R on H acts as (1) (E, z, z¯) A (g)Ψ −1 −1 EKΛ (Λ−1 z, Λ−1 z¯), Λ−1 z, Λ−1 z¯ , (21) = eiEKΛ (Λ z,Λ z¯)α(z,¯z) Ψ for any g = (Λ, α(z, z¯)) ∈ R and A(1) is unitary on H. The proof of this theorem is a recollection with minor modifications of the demonstration of Proposition 2.9, 2.12 and 2.14 in [4]. Hence we refer to such paper for an interested reader. We now state a useful lemma out of this last proposition: Lemma 2.3. The projection on + of each function ψ constructed as in Proposition 2.4 can be unitary mapped into an element of (H, , ). Proof. In Proposition 2.4 we projected a function with support on the image of Minkowski spacetime in Einstein static universe to a function Ψ ∈ L2 (+ ) being + , in that specific background, (−π, π) × S2 . Since S2 is compact and (−π, π) is an open bounded set of R, Ψ can also be read as an element of L2 (R × S2 ). We stress that, switching from the Lesbegue measure in L2 (+ ) to the natural SO(3)-invariant measure on S2 for L2 (R × S2 ) is harmless. ∈ According to Plancherel theorem and to (20) the Fourier transform Ψ L2 (R × S2 , EdEdS2 ) and, hence, according to Proposition 2.6, it can be unitary mapped in (H, , ). This concludes the first part of our programme though a complete analysis would require the proof that A(1) is irreducible or how it decomposes in irreducible components. The answer to this question will be a byproduct of the Wigner– Mackey analysis that we discuss now. Such approach calls for the construction of a classical free field theory on a generic manifold only by means of the symmetry group, R ⊂ BM S in our case. Although R is homomorphic to the Poincar´e group we cannot simply refer to the standard construction for a covariant field theory in Minkowski background as discussed, to quote just one example, in Chapter 21 of [3]. On the opposite we need to consider R as a subgroup of the BMS and, hence, we shall adapt the analysis in [4] to this simpler scenario. Referring to this last cited paper for further details, let us introduce the character associated to an element of N ≡ C ∞ (S2 ) as a group homomorphism
Vol. 9 (2008)
Projecting Massive Scalar Fields to Null Infinity
55
χ : N → U (1). Since N can be endowed with a nuclear topology (see Theorem 2.1 in [5]) it can be seen as an element of the Gelfand triplet N ⊂ L2 (S2 ) ⊂ N ∗ where N ∗ is the set of real continuous linear functionals on N (endowed with the induced topology). Hence, as shown in Proposition 3.6 in [4], for any character χ it exists a distribution β ∈ N ∗ such that χ(α) = ei(β,α) ,
(22)
where (, ) stands for the pairing between N ∗ and N . Such a result can be applied also to the translational subgroup of the Poincar´e 4 ∞ 2 group on + provided either that one exploits the inclusion 4T∗ ⊂ C (S ) previ4 ously discussed either that the dual space of T – namely T – is characterized in the following way [13]: if we construct the annihilator of T 4 as & 4 0 % T = β ∈ N ∗ | β, α(z, z¯) = 0, ∀α(z, z¯) ∈ T 4 , 4 ∗ is (isomorphic to) the quotient T
N∗ . (T 4 )0
Still referring to [4], the Wigner–Mackey approach for the BMS group introduces the intrinsic covariant scalar field on null infinity as a map ψ : N ∗ → H which transforms under the unitary representation D of SO(3, 1) C ∞ (S2 ) as D Λ, α(z, z¯) ϕ (β) = χβ (α)ϕ(Λ −1 β) , ∀ Λ, α(z, z¯) ∈ SO(3, 1) C ∞ (S2 ) where χβ is a character. Whenever the bulk spacetime is the Minkowski background and hence we deal with the R subgroup of the BMS, the above expression translates in ⎧ ∗ ⎨ ϕ : T4 → R (23) ⎩ D Λ, α(z, z¯) ϕ (β) = χβ (α)ϕ(Λ −1 β) ∀ Λ, α(z, z¯) ∈ R , where now β must be thought both as a distribution and as a representative for ∗ an equivalence class in the coset (TN4 )0 . Remark 2.4. It is important to point out that, in the above discussion, the real difference between a scalar field on Minkowski background and on null infinity is due to the action of the representation or more properly of the U (1) phase factor. To be more precise, Proposition 3.2 in [5] grants us that, being T 4 a subspace ∗ of a locally convex topological linear space, namely C ∞ (S2 ), the coset (TN4 )0 is a 4-dimensional space. Thus, if we introduce the set of dual spherical harmonics ∗ Ylm with l = 0, 1, m = −l, . . . , l defined as (Yl∗ m , Ylm (z, z¯)) = δll δmm , then any 4 ∗ β∈ T can be decomposed as β=
l 1 l=0 m=−l
∗ βlm Ylm .
56
C. Dappiaggi
Hence we can extract from each β the four-vector
3 β00 μ √ , β1−1 , β10 , β11 . β =− 4π 3
Ann. Henri Poincar´e
(24)
Moreover we define the action of Λ ∈ SO(3, 1) on a generic distribution β ∈ N ∗ as Λβ, α(z, z¯) = β, Λ−1 α(z, z¯) ∀α(z, z¯) ∈ C ∞ (S2 ) , (25) being the action of Λ on α(z, z¯) the one defined in (2) and (3). A direct inspection ∗ ∗ of Proposition 1.1 and of the isomorphism between (TN4 )0 and T 4 shows that β μ transforms as a covector and the quantity m2 = ημν β μ β ν
(26)
is SO(3, 1) invariant. Furthermore m2 is also a Casimir for the unitary and irreducible representations of the BMS group and hence also for the R subgroup. This confirms the previous statement according to which (23) differs from the counterpart in Minkowski background only in the character. The covariant scalar field (23) does not transform under an irreducible representation of the R group and, hence, in a physical language it represents only a kinematically allowed configuration. On the opposite, if we look for a genuine free field, ϕ should transform under a unitary and irreducible representation; to overcome such a discrepancy we can still exploit Wigner–Mackey theory which calls for imposing a further constraint to (23). From a more common perspective in classical field theory, this operation amounts to impose on ϕ the equations of motion written in the momenta representation; for the above scalar field it reads [4]: μν = 0, (27) η βμ βν − m2 ϕ[β] where βμ is the four vector as in (24). Two comments on (27) are in due course: 1. the equation under analysis could be recast in the more appropriate language of white noise calculus. In the general framework of BMS free field theory ϕ[β] is a functional over a distribution space which is square integrable with respect to a suitable Gaussian measure μ. Hence (27) should be recast in this scenario in terms of (multiplication) operators acting on L2 (N ∗ , dμ) and such analysis has been carried out in [5]. In ∗ paper we can avoid such this techniques exploiting the identification of T 4 with R4 which grants us that (27) acquires the standard meaning, i.e., the support of ϕ[β] is localized over the mass hyperboloid if m2 = 0 and over the light cone if m2 = 0. Most importantly the function ϕ corresponds to an element in L2 (C). 2. the equations (23) and (27) are equivalent to a function transforming under a unitary and irreducible representation of the Poincar´e group induced from the SO(3) or from the SO(2) T 2 little groups depending if m = 0 or m = 0. At the same time a direct inspection of the analysis of Chapter 3
Vol. 9 (2008)
Projecting Massive Scalar Fields to Null Infinity
57
in [4] immediately shows that the representation in (23) is nothing but the scalar BMS representation restricted to the R subgroup. Before concluding our analysis we still need the last ingredient which relates the two above constructions of a massless scalar field theory on + . Theorem 2.1. A field Ψ on + constructed as in Proposition 2.4 corresponds to a R field (23) which satisfies (27) with m = 0. Hence the representation A(1) is also irreducible on L2 (R × S2 , EdEdS2 ). Proof. We provide here a much shorter proof than that of Theorem 3.35 in [4]. satisfies (21). Let us recall that, according to Lemma 2.3, Ψ Furthermore, following the characterization of a light cone embedded in R4 . as discussed at the beginning of Section 2.1 and identifying E with r = | p|, we the Fourier transform of Ψ constructed as in ∈ L2 (C) being Ψ end up with Ψ can be read on its own as the Proposition 2.4. According to Theorem 1 in [22], Ψ satisfying D’Alembert restriction on C of the Fourier transform for a function Ψ ∈ wave equation and, hence, lying in L4 (R4 , d4 x). The Fourier transform for Ψ = 0 and the Poincar´e group R still acts S (R4 ) satisfies the constraint η μν pμ pν Ψ (1) as A . To conclude the demonstration, let us now consider (23) which satisfies (27) with m = 0. Exploiting the identification between the distribution β and the covector pμ , a direct inspection shows that the scalar R representation acts on (23) as the representation A(1) . Thus each Ψ constructed in Proposition 2.4 has been mapped into a massless R scalar free field. Irreducibility of A(1) is now a consequence of Mackey construction which grants us that the scalar R (and, thus, the A(1) ) representation induced from the scalar E(2) representation is irreducible. At this stage one could require, as a natural property, that the bulk-toboundary projection operation must be compatible with the Poincar´e action. In other words, we must prove that, if we act on a norm-finite solution φ of (5) with an element of SO(3, 1)↑ T 4 , this corresponds to the action of the same element in R on Ψ, the projection on + . Since the bulk massive field is related to a massless scalar field in the bulk out of an intertwiner between the quasi-regular Lorentz group representations (univocally inducing the full Poincar´e group scalar representation as previously discussed), we can switch from φ to ψ, solution of the bulk D’Alembert wave equation. The following proposition holds: Proposition 2.7. Let us consider any massless scalar field ψ constructed as in Proposition 2.3 such that ψ ∈ W 1,4 (R4 ). Let us also call γ |+ : W 1,4 (R4 ) → L2 (+ ) , . the map which rescales ψ to ψ = Ω−1 ψ with Ω as in (16) and then projects ψ + on as in Proposition 2.4. Then,
58
C. Dappiaggi
Ann. Henri Poincar´e
1. for any g ∈ SO(3, 1)↑ T 4 , γ |+ ψ(xμ ) , γ |+ ψ(g −1 xμ ) = A1 (g ) being g the elements of R correspondent to g out of the homomorphism in (4), 2. γ |+ is, up to the homomorphism between R and SO(3, 1)↑ T 4 , an intertwiner between the Poincar´e scalar representation in the bulk and the R representation A1 on the boundary. Proof. As a starting point we recall that, according to Proposition 1.2, the Poincar´e algebra is generated by a set of Killing vectors for the flat metric which smoothly extend on + in a set of ten independent BMS algebra elements generating by exponential map the whole R subgroup per completeness of + . Hence we can exploit Proposition 3.4 in the second paper in [14] to conclude that the first of the two statements in the proposition is true for all smooth solutions of the D’Alembert wave equation in Minkowski spacetime. The strategy we shall now follow is to exploit this last result together with the density of C0∞ (R4 ) in the Banach space L4 (R4 ). Hence, omitting the explicit dependence on the point xμ for sake of simplicity, for any ψ ∈ W 1,4 (R4 ) seen as an element of L4 (R4 ), we can choose a sequence ψn ∈ C0∞ such that ψn → ψ as n → ∞ in the topology of L4 (R4 ). We now wish to show that we can choose each ψn in such a way that it satisfies the D’Alembert wave equation. For a generic convergent sequence, we know that, in the worst case scenario, ψn = ρn = 0 with ρn ∈ C0∞ (R4 ). For any n let us select a new function – say fn – which solves fn = ρn , fn (0, x) = 0 , (∂t fn )(0, x) = 0 . Hence we can invoke again the results from [22] to claim that, since ρn ∈ C0∞ (R4 ) 4 and, thus, ρn ∈ L 3 (R4 ), it holds that fn ∈ L4 (R4 ) ∩ C ∞ (R4 ) with fn L4 ≤ Cρn 43 . Per direct inspection, fn → 0 as n → ∞ and, if we introduce ψn = L ψn − fn , we know that, per construction, ψn = 0 and ψn → ψ in the topology of L4 (R4 ) since ψn − ψL4 ≤ ψn − ψL4 + fn L4 . Furthermore, since ψn ∈ . C ∞ (R4 ) we know that ψn = Ω−1 ψn is a smooth solution of the D’Alembert wave equation conformally coupled to gravity in the image of Minkowski in Einstein static universe. The initial data for the Cauchy problem g − R6 ψn = 0 (being g the metric (18)) are compactly supported since ψn ∈ C0∞ (R4 ) and fn vanishes on the surface t = 0. Hence, per uniqueness of the solutions for second order hyperbolic PDE, we are entitled to extend ψn to a smooth solution of the same partial differential equation on the whole Einstein static universe. Consequently we can restrict each ψn on + and, per construction of traces on Sobolev spaces (see Chapter 2 of [19]), ψn |+ = γ|+ (ψn ). Let us now consider a generic element g ∈ SO(3, 1)↑ T 4 . Calling D(g) the scalar Poincar´e group representation which coincides with the Lorentz quasiregular representation U whenever g = (Λ, 0), we end up with ψ(g −1 xμ ) =
Vol. 9 (2008)
Projecting Massive Scalar Fields to Null Infinity
59
D(g)ψ(xμ ) and, being D bounded, strongly continuous and irreducible, ' ' ψ(g −1 xμ ) − ψ (g −1 xμ )L4 = 'D(g) ψ(xμ ) − ψ (xμ ) ' 4 → 0 . n
n
Let us now consider ' ' 'γ γ |+ (ψ)' |+ D(g)ψ − A1 (g )
L2
L
' ' |+ D(g)ψn 'L2 ≤ 'γ |+ D(g)ψ − γ ' ' |+ D(g)ψ − A1 (g ) + 'γ γ |+ (ψ)' n
L2
.
Exploiting the linearity of the trace γ|+ , the first term becomes ' ' 'γ |+ D(g)(ψ − ψ ) ' 2 . n
L
Taking into account that γ|+ is also continuous, hence bounded and that rescaling g |d4 X) where M is the per Ω−1 is a unitary operator from L4 (R4 ) in L4 (M, | image of Minkowski spacetime in the Einstein static universe, we can conclude that the above norm tends to 0 as n goes to infinity. The second term can be rewritten as A1 (g ) γ |+ (ψn − ψ)L2 (+ ) = γ |+ (ψn − ψ)L2 (+ ) where, first, we exploited the result in Proposition 3.4 in the second paper in [14] and, later, the unitarity of A1 . With the same reasoning as for the first term, we can conclude that, since ψn → ψ, the above norm tends to 0 as n → ∞. Hence the first statement in the theorem is proved. The second is linear arises simply recalling that ψ(g −1 xμ ) = D(g)ψ(xμ ), the trace operator and bounded and Ω−1 is a unitary operator from L4 (R4 ) in L4 (M, | g |d4 X). We have now all the ingredients to conclude our analysis on the projection of a massive bulk scalar field: Theorem 2.2. Let us consider any norm-finite solution φ of (5) with the associated triplet (ψ, U , T ). The latter projects to a triple (Ψ, U , T ) on future null infinity which identifies two Poincar´e invariant free scalar fields constructed a ` la Wigner– Mackey and solving (27) with the same mass value as φ. Proof. According to the hypothesis of the theorem we can associate to φ the triplet (ψ, U , T ) where ψ solves the D’Alembert wave equation. We can now exploit Proposition 2.4 to project ψ in a square integrable function Ψ over + : Ψ = ρ(ψ) . −1 where ψ = Ω ψ. Hence, being U and T respectively a representation and an intertwiner thus independent from coordinates, we construct on null infinity the triplet (Ψ, U , T ). The representation U (Λ) is the quasi-regular representation of the Lorentz group and it unambiguously induces (or it is the restriction of) the scalar R representation which acts on Ψ as the representation A(1) from (21). We can now exploit Theorem 2.1 according to which the pair (Ψ, A(1) ) corresponds to one R invariant field (23) which satisfies (27) with m = 0. Hence (Ψ, A(1) ) can be traded with (ϕ, D(Λ, α(z, z¯))) where (Λ, α(z, z¯)) ∈ R and D is the scalar representation in (23). Still the induction-reduction theorem for group representations (Chapter 18 in [3]) grants us that the restriction of D to SO(3, 1) is exactly U and that the quasi-regular representation unambiguously induces the scalar R representation. U , T ). The circle has Hence we have mapped the original triplet (Ψ, U , T ) in (ϕ,
60
C. Dappiaggi
Ann. Henri Poincar´e
been almost closed and our last step consists of exploiting the same reasoning as in the proof of Theorem 2.1, i.e., we can read ϕ as a solution for the massless wave C . Hence we can now equation constructed out of an element of L2 (C) – say ϕ| 2 exploit our last ingredient namely the intertwiner T : L (C) → L2 (Hm ) ⊕ L2 (Hm ), C ) = (f, g). Accordingly both f and g lies in L2 (Hm ) and the Lorentz i.e., T (ϕ| group acts as [U (Λ)f ] (pμ ) = f (Λ−1 pμ ) for all Λ ∈ SO(3, 1). Still exploiting Theorem 1 in [22], we can interpret f (or g) as the restriction on the mass hyf or ϕ g – whose Fourier transform satisfies perboloid Hm of a function – say ϕ the Klein–Gordon equation of motion with mass m and it lies in Lp (R4 , d4 x) with 10/3 ≤ p ≤ 4. If we now take into account that the original field ϕ is an intrinsic R free field, we are entitled to switch from pμ to the variables β μ . To conclude we can exploit Remark 2.4 according to which a covector β μ transforming under ∗ the standard SO(3, 1) action corresponds to a distribution β ∈ T 4 ⊂ N ∗ on which Λ ∈ SO(3, 1) acts according to (25). Eventually still the induction theorem f , U ) allows us to construct from U the scalar R representation D. Hence both (ϕ and (ϕ g , U ) correspond unambiguously to a R massive scalar field as in (23) with support on the mass hyperboloid, i.e., with the same value for m2 as the original Minkowski field φ. Remark 2.5. The projection of a bulk massive scalar field into two boundary massive scalar fields is a natural byproduct of the intertwining operator. In the projection of f ∈ L2 (Hm ) to a function over the light cone, we could imbed f into the element (f, f ) of the diagonal subgroup of L2 (Hm ) ⊕ L2 (Hm ); on the opposite on the boundary we perform the inverse operation mapping a square integrable function over the light cone into L2 (Hm ) ⊕ L2 (Hm ). Hence there is no guarantee that the intertwiner identifies an element of the diagonal subgroup and we are forced to take into account two massive fields instead of a single one.
3. Conclusions In this paper we have shown that, exploiting Strichartz harmonic analysis on hyperboloids, it is possible to project the information of a norm finite massive scalar field φ in Minkowski spacetime into a triplet of data on null infinity: (Ψ, U , T ) where Ψ is the projection on + out of a trace operator of a solution for the bulk D’Alembert wave equation, U is the SO(3, 1) quasi-regular representation whereas T is a unitary intertwiner from L2 (C) to L2 (Hm ) ⊕ L2 (Hm ). The result we achieve has a twofold advantage. From one side it is coherent with Helfer result which states that the space of sections for any vector bundle over null infinity homogeneous under the action of the Poincar´e group carries only the massless representation. As a matter of fact Ψ can be ultimately interpreted as a free field on the conformal boundary with m = 0. From the other side we can recover the original interpretation of massive fields exploiting the action of T and, as shown in Theorem 2.2, the original single field φ corresponds to two separate massive free fields in the R invariant theory constructed a` la Wigner–Mackey.
Vol. 9 (2008)
Projecting Massive Scalar Fields to Null Infinity
61
Although we believe the result is rather appealing opening a wide range of possible applications, it is fair to admit that it is to a certain extent not sharp. As a matter of fact, in the whole construction we performed three arbitrary choices: the first, already discussed, refers to the imbedding of an element f ∈ L2 (Hm ) (the restriction on the mass hyperboloid of the Fourier transform of φ) into the diagonal subgroup of L2 (Hm ) ⊕ L2 (Hm ). The second and the strongest between the performed choices arises in the projection to + ; the general solution ψ of the D’Alembert wave equation we con 4 4 g|d x) but, in order to apply trace theorems, we needed structed lies in L (M, | to consider at least Sobolev spaces of first order. This restricts the range of validity of our results and it will be interesting to eliminate such constraint from our analysis. The third and less pernicious of the choices lies in the construction of the above mentioned trace operator. As a matter of fact we embedded Minkowski spacetime into an open region of Einstein static universe. Hence this amounts to select a preferred gauge factor ω according to the definitions of Section 1.1 contrary to the projection operator introduced in [4, 12] which provides a smooth function over + for any possible choice of ω. Nonetheless we feel that, fixing ω in our analysis, does not lead to a loss of generality since we can ultimately interpret our results in terms of a general field theory constructed over + without the need for such a choice of the gauge factor. To conclude we wish to discuss possible applications of our results. Our main target is an holographic interpretation of bulk field theory along the lines of [4] and the previous section was written with this goal in mind. As a matter of fact we have proved that, at least in Minkowski background, it is possible to project each solution of a massive Klein–Gordon equation of motion into a suitable counterpart at null infinity. Within this respect we must stress that our result may not be sharp since the information of the bulk massive field is encoded in a unique boundary massless scalar field which, on its turn, corresponds to two massive scalar fields on + . It is conceivable that a modification of our construction may lead to define a bulk-to-boundary projection map in such a way that the massless field on future null infinity gives rise to a single Klein–Gordon field out of the intertwiner T ; we feel this subject worth of a deep analysis in the forthcoming future. Such bulk-toboundary interplay does not represent the only possible application of our analysis and we envisage that our results could be possibly exploited also in other research fields such as, to quote an example, conformal scattering problems. Nonetheless we believe that the most interesting perspective consists of the development of a similar result in a generic globally hyperbolic and asymptotically flat spacetime. Already at a first reading of this manuscript, one can realize that the extensive use of tools proper of harmonic analysis forbids to mimic our procedure in a more generic scenario8 . Nonetheless we feel that finding a way to project the 8 It
is possible to wonder if our construction extends to higher dimensional flat backgrounds and, since both the tools proper of harmonic analysis and Strichartz estimates can be generalized to any dimension, there is no apparent obstruction. On the opposite the question if one can derive
62
C. Dappiaggi
Ann. Henri Poincar´e
information for a massive scalar field on null infinity in Minkowski background is an encouraging starting point to deal with the same problem in more complicated frameworks. A positive conclusion of such a research project would also open the way to develop in a generic background (and not only in Minkowski), with tools proper of the algebraic quantization of field theory, a correspondence between the quantized bulk massive scalar theory and the boundary counterpart. We aim to address such an issue in future works.
Acknowledgements The author is grateful to V. Moretti and N. Pinamonti for fruitful discussions at early stages of this research project and to O. Maj for several useful discussions on hyperbolic partial differential equations. This work has been partly supported by GNFM-INdAM (Istituto Nazionale di Alta Matematica) under the project “Olografia e spazitempo asintoticamente piatti: un approccio rigoroso”.
References [1] G. Arcioni and C. Dappiaggi, Exploring the holographic principle in asymptotically flat spacetimes via the BMS group, Nucl. Phys. B 674 (2003), 553, [arXiv:hepth/0306142]. [2] A. Ashtekar and B. C. Xanthopoulos, Isometries compatible with asymptotic flatness at null infinity: A complete description, J. Math. Phys 19 (1978), 2216. [3] A. O. Barut, R. Raczka, Theory of group representations and applications, World Scientific 2ed (1986), [4] C. Dappiaggi, V. Moretti and N. Pinamonti, Rigorous steps towards holography in asymptotically flat spacetimes, Rev. Math. Phys. 18 (2006), 349, [arXiv:grqc/0506069]. [5] C. Dappiaggi, Free field theory at null infinity and white noise calculus: A BMS invariant dynamical system, arXiv:math-ph/0607055. [6] H. Friedrich, On static and radiative space-times, Comm. Math. Phys. 119 (1988), 51. [7] I. M. Gel’fand, M. I. Graev and N. Ya. Vilenkin, Generalized functions: Application of harmonic analysis, Vol. 4 (1966), Academic Press. [8] R. Geroch, Asymptotic structure of space-time, (1977) ed. P. Esposito and L. Witten, Plenum, New York. [9] A. D. Helfer, Null infinity does not carry massive fields, J. Math. Phys. 34 (1993), 3478. [10] S. Hollands and A. Ishibashi, Asymptotic flatness and Bondi energy in higher dimensional gravity, J. Math. Phys. 46 (2005), 022503, [arXiv:gr-qc/0304054]. a similar result for higher dimensional curved backgrounds is less adequate since conformal completion techniques ` a la Penrose may run into serious difficulties [10].
Vol. 9 (2008)
Projecting Massive Scalar Fields to Null Infinity
63
[11] N. Limic, J. Niederle and R. Raczka, Eigenfunction expansions associated with the second-order invariant operator on hyperboloids and cones. III, J. Math. Phys. 8 (1967), 1079. [12] L. J. Mason, J.-P. Nicolas, Conformal scattering and the Goursat problem, J. Hyper. Diff. Eq. 1 (2004), 197. [13] P. J. McCarthy, The Bondi–Metzner–Sachs group in the nuclear topology, Proc. Royal Soc. London A343 (1975), 489. [14] V. Moretti, Uniqueness theorem for BMS-invariant states of scalar QFT on the null boundary of asymptotically flat spacetimes and bulk-boundary observable algebra correspondence, Comm. Math. Phys. 268 (2006), 727, [arXiv:gr-qc/0512049]; Quantum ground states holographically induced by asymptotic flatness: Invariance under spacetime symmetries, energy positivity and Hadamard property, [arXiv:grqc/0610143], to appear in Comm. Math. Phys. [15] M. Reed and B. Simon, Methods of modern mathematical physics II: Fourier analysis, Self-Adjointness, (1975) Academic Press. [16] I. Segal, Space-time decay for solutions of wave equations, Adv. in Math. 22 (1976), 305. [17] W. Rossmann, Analysis on real hyperbolic spaces, J. Func. Anal. 30 (1978), 448. [18] B. Schroer, Area density of localization-entropy, Class. Quant. Grav. 23 (2006), 5227, [arXiv:hep-th/0507038]. [19] R. E. Showalter, Monotone operators in Banach spaces and partial differential equations, Mathematical Surveys and Monographs 49 (1997) AMS. [20] R. S. Strichartz, The stationary observer problem for u = M u and related equations, J. Diff. Eq. 9 (1971), 205. [21] R. S. Strichartz, Harmonic analysis on hyperboloids, J. Func. Anal. 12 (1973), 341. [22] R. S. Strichartz, Restrictions of Fourier transforms to quadratic surfaces and decay of solutions of wave equations, Duke Math. Jour. 44 (1977), 705. [23] R. M. Wald, General relativity, (1984) Chicago University Press. [24] J. Winicour, Massive fields at null infinity, J. Math. Phys. 29 (1988), 2117. Claudio Dappiaggi Dipartimento di Fisica Nucleare e Teorica Universit` a di Pavia via A. Bassi 6 I-27100 Pavia Italy e-mail:
[email protected] Communicated by Klaus Fredenhagen. Submitted: May 7, 2007. Accepted: July 16, 2007.
Ann. Henri Poincar´e 9 (2008), 65–90 c 2008 Birkh¨ auser Verlag Basel/Switzerland 1424-0637/010065-26, published online January 30, 2008 DOI 10.1007/s00023-007-0350-8
Annales Henri Poincar´ e
Renormalization of Orientable Non-Commutative Complex Φ63 Model Zhituo Wang and Shaolong Wan Abstract. In this paper we prove that the Grosse–Wulkenhaar type noncommutative orientable complex scalar ϕ63 theory, with two non-commutative coordinates and the third one commuting with the other two, is renormalizable to all orders in perturbation theory. Our proof relies on a multiscale analysis in x space.
1. Introduction Since the rebirth of non-commutative quantum field theory [2, 5, 27, 29], people encountered a major difficulty. A new kind of divergences appeared in noncommutative field theory [20], the UV/IR mixing. It is a kind of infrared divergence which appears after integrating the high scale variables and can’t be eliminated. It lead people to declare such theories non-renormalizable. But a real breakthrough of that deadlock came from H. Grosse and R. Wulkenhaar [11,13]. They found that the right propagator for the scalar field theory in non-commutative space should be modified to obey the Langmann–Szabo duality [18]. In a series of paper they proved that the ϕ4 scalar field theory in 4 dimensional Moyal plane, ϕ4 4 for short, is renormalizable to all orders using Polchinski’s equation [21] in the matrix base. Rigorous estimates on the propagator required by the Grosse–Wulkenhaar analysis and a more explicit multiscale analysis were provided in [23]. Then Gurau et al. gave another proof that the non-commutative ϕ4 4 is renormalizable, also with a multiscale analysis but completely in position space [15]. The corresponding parametric representation of the model was also built in [16]. Recently the model has been shown to have no Landau ghost, so that it is actually better behaved than its commutative counterpart [3,4,12] and can presumably be built non perturbatively. Apart from the ϕ4 4 theory, many other theories in non-commutative space have now also been proved to be renormalizable to all orders, such as the Gross– Neveu model in 2 dimensional Moyal plane [30], the LSZ model [19] and the ϕ3 theory in various dimensional space [8–10]. For an updated review, see [24, 25].
66
Z. Wang and S. Wan
Ann. Henri Poincar´e
In this paper we prove that the orientable non-commutative complex ϕ6 field theory, (ϕ¯ ϕ)3 for short, in 2 + 1 dimensional space, with two dimensions equipped with non-commutative Moyal product and the third one which commutes with the two others, is renormalizable to all orders of perturbation theory. In the first section we derive the propagator and establish the x-space power counting of the theory. In the second section we prove that the divergent subgraphs can be renormalized by counterterms of the form of the initial Lagrangian. Our proof, based solely on x space with multiscale analysis, follows closely the strategy of [15]. For technical reasons, we restrict ourselves here to the simpler orientable case, but we plan to study the nonorientable case or real scalar ϕ63 model as well. We are motivated by the fact that the quantum Hall effect at finite temperature should also be described by a 2+1 dimensional field theory with two anticommuting space and one commuting imaginary time coordinates [17, 22, 24, 28]. Our model is therefore a first step towards understanding how to renormalize such theories. We plan to compute in a future publication the renormalization group flow of this model, which involves three parameters λ, g and Ω, instead of two in the ϕ44 case.
2. Power counting in x-space 2.1. Model, notations 3 The simplest orientable non-commutative complex ϕ6 3 theory is defined on R equipped with the associative and non-commutative Moyal product d2 k (2.1) d2 y a x+ 12 θ·k b(x+y) eik·y . (a b)(x) = 2 (2π) The action functional is xμ ϕ) ¯ (˜ xμ ϕ) + μ20 ϕ¯ ϕ S[ϕ] = d2 x dx0 ∂μ ϕ¯ ∂ μ ϕ + ∂0 ϕ¯ ∂ 0 ϕ + Ω2 (˜ λ g + ϕ¯ ϕ ϕ¯ ϕ + ϕ¯ ϕ ϕ¯ ϕ ϕ¯ ϕ x, x0 (2.2) 2 3 where x ˜μ = 2(θ−1 )μν xν , and x = (xμ ), μ = (1, 2) are the non-commutative variables and x0 is the commutative variable, that is [xμ , xν ] = iθμν ,
[x0 , xμ ] = 0 .
Here θμν is a constant matrix and the Euclidean metric is used. Lemma 2.1. The kernel of the propagator in our (ϕ¯ ϕ)3 model is 1
(x −x )2 Ω coth(2Ωt) Ω Ω(2t)− 2 x·x − 0 4t 0 −μ20 t (x2 +x2 )+ sinh(2Ωt) 2 C(x, x ) = √ 3 , e− 2π sinh(2Ωt) 2
2
2
with x2 = x21 + x22 , x = x 1 + x 2 , x · x = x1 x1 + x2 x2 .
(2.3)
Orientable Non-Commutative Complex Φ63 Model
Vol. 9 (2008)
67
Proof. The propagator of interest is expressed via the Schwinger parameter trick as: ∞ dte−tH . (2.4) H −1 = 0
Let H be H = −∂12 − ∂22 − ∂02 + Ω2 x2 + μ20
(2.5)
where μ0 is the mass of the field. The integral kernel of the operator e−tH is: 1
e
−tH
Ω(2t)− 2
(x, x ) = √ 3 e−A , 2π sinh(2Ωt) Ω cosh(2Ωt) 2 Ω (x0 −x0 )2 (x +x2 )− x · x + +μ20 t . A= 2 sinh(2Ωt) sinh(2Ωt) 4t
(2.6) (2.7)
At first we note that the kernel is correctly normalized: as Ω → 0, we have e−tH (x, x ) →
1 (4πt)
3 2
e−
|x−x |2 +|x0 −x0 |2 4t
,
(2.8)
which is the normalized heat kernel. Then we must check the equation d −tH e + He−tH = 0 . dt
(2.9)
In fact,
1 2 d −tH Ωe−A (2t)− 2 Ω2 e x + x2 =√ 3 − 2Ω coth(2Ωt) + 2 dt sinh (2Ωt) 2π sinh(2Ωt) 2 (x0 − x0 )2 1 −1 2Ω cosh(2Ωt) 2 − μ0 . − t − x·x + (2.10) 2 4t2 sinh2 (2Ωt)
Moreover, (−∂12
−
∂22 )e−tH
−∂02 e−tH
1 Ωe−A (2t)− 2 Ω2 (x2 + x2 ) =√ 3 2Ω coth(2Ωt) − sinh2 (2Ωt) 2π sinh(2Ωt) 2Ω2 coth(2Ωt) 2 2 + x·x −Ω x , (2.11) sinh Ωt 1 (x0 − x0 )2 1 Ωe−A (2t)− 2 − =√ 3 . (2.12) 4t2 2π sinh(2Ωt) 2t
It is now straightforward to verify the differential equation (2.9), which proves the lemma. Now let’s consider the interaction vertices. The non-commutative complex ϕ63 model may a priori exhibit both orientable vertices: Vo =
1 1 ϕ¯ ϕ ϕ¯ ϕ(x) + ϕ¯ ϕ ϕ¯ ϕ ϕ¯ ϕ(x) 2 3
(2.13)
68
Z. Wang and S. Wan
Ann. Henri Poincar´e
and non-orientable vertices: 1 1 Vno = ϕ¯ ϕ¯ ϕ ϕ(x) + ϕ¯ ϕ¯ ϕ¯ ϕ ϕ ϕ(x) 2 3 1 1 + ϕ¯ ϕ¯ ϕ ϕ¯ ϕ ϕ(x) + ϕ¯ ϕ¯ ϕ ϕ ϕ¯ ϕ(x) . 3 3
(2.14)
In this paper we limit ourselves to the case of action (2.2), hence to orientable vertices. In the two dimensional non-commutative space the interaction vertices (orientable or not) can be written as [6, 30]: V (x1 , x2 , x3 , x4 ) = δ(x1 − x2 + x3 − x4 )ei
1≤i<j≤4 (−1)
i+j+1
xi θ −1 xj
(2.15)
for four point vertices and V (x1 , x2 , x3 , x4 , x5 , x6 ) = δ(x1 − x2 + x3 − x4 + x5 − x6 ) ei
1≤i<j≤6 (−1)
i+j+1
xi θ −1 xj
(2.16)
for six point vertices. Here we note xθ−1 y ≡ 2θ (x1 y2 − x2 y1 ). These vertices are completed to make them local in the commutative t coordinate, that is we have to multiply them by δ(x01 − x02 )δ(x01 − x03 )δ(x01 − x04 ) or δ(x01 − x02 )δ(x01 − x03 )δ(x01 − x04 )δ(x01 − x05 )δ(x01 − x06 ) respectively. The main result of this paper is a proof in configuration space of Theorem 2.1 (BPHZ theorem for non-commutative (ϕ¯ ϕ)3 ). The theory defined by the action (2.2) is renormalizable to all orders of perturbation theory. Let G be an arbitrary connected graph. The amplitude associated with this graph is (with selfexplaining notations):
AG = dxv,i dx0v dxv,i dx0v dtl (2.17) v∈V4 ,i=1,...4
v∈V6 ,i=1,...6
l
i+j+1 xv,i θ −1 xv,j δ(xv,1 − xv,2 + xv,3 − xv,4 )eı i<j (−1) V4
i+j+1 xv,i θ −1 xv,j δ(xv,1 − xv,2 + xv,3 − xv,4 + xv,5 − xv,6 )eı i<j (−1) V6
l
×e
1
Ω(2tl )− 2
√ 3 2π sinh(2Ωtl ) −
Ω coth(2Ωtl ) Ω (x2v,i(l) +x2 )+ sinh(2Ωt xv,i(l) ·xv ,i (l) − 2 v ,i (l) l)
(x0,l −x0,l )2 −μ2 t 4tl
0 l
.
For each line l of the graph joining positions xv,i(l) and xv ,i (l) , we choose an orientation (see next section) and we define the “short” variable ul = xv,i(l) − xv ,i (l) , u0l = x0v(l) − x0v (l) and the “long” variable vl = xv,i(l) + xv ,i (l) just as the
Vol. 9 (2008)
Orientable Non-Commutative Complex Φ63 Model
69
Figure 1: Orientation of a tree.
work of Gurau et al. [15]. With these notations, defining 2Ωtl = αl , the propagators in our graph can be written as: √ − 12 Ωαl dαl − Ω4 coth( α2l )u2l − Ω4 tanh( α2l )vl2 − μ2Ω20 αl − 2αΩ u0l 2 l . (2.18) e √ 3 2 2π sinh(α ) l l 2.2. Orientation and position routing We solve the δ function at every vertex by a “position routing”, following the strategy and notations of [15]. The position routing is similar to the “momentum routing” of the commutative case, but we have to take care of the cyclic invariance of the vertex. Consider a connected graph G. We choose a rooted spanning tree in G, then we start from an arbitrary orientation of a first field at the root and inductively climbing into the tree, at each vertex we follow the cyclic order to alternate entering and exiting lines. This is pictured in Figure 1. Let n = n6 + n4 be the number of vertices of the graph, with n6 of the ϕ6 and n4 of the ϕ4 type, N the number of its external fields, and L the number of internal lines of G. We have L = 3n6 + 2n4 − N/2. Every line of the spanning tree by definition has one end exiting a vertex and one end entering another. This may not be true for the loop lines, which join two “loop fields”. Among these, some exit one vertex and enter another; they are called well-oriented. But others may enter or exit at both ends. These loop lines are subsequently referred to as “clashing lines” [15]. If there are no clashing lines, the graph is called orientable. This is exactly the case in this paper, because ϕ variables can contract only to ϕ¯ ones. Choosing the ϕ variables as entering and the ϕ¯ as exiting, the form of the vertices in (2.2) ensure alternance of entering and exiting lines.
70
Z. Wang and S. Wan
Ann. Henri Poincar´e
We also define the set of “branches” associated to the rooted tree T . There are n − 1 such branches b(l), one for each of the n − 1 lines l of the tree. The full tree itself is called the root branch and noted b0 . Each branch is made of the subgraph Gb containing all the vertices “above l” in T , plus the tree lines and loop lines joining these vertices. It has also “external fields” which are the true external fields hooked to Gb , plus the loop fields in Gb for the loops with one end (or “field”) inside and one end outside Gb , plus the upper end of the tree line l itself to which b is associated. We call Xb the set of all external fields f of b. We can now describe the position routing associated to T . Here we will not limit ourselves to orientable graphs but will deal with the non-orientable graphs as well. There are n δ functions in (2.17), hence n linear equations for the 6n6 + 4n4 positions, one for each vertex. The position rooting associated to the tree T solves this system by passing to another equivalent system of n linear equations, one for each branch of the tree. This equivalent system is obtained by summing the arguments of the δ functions of the vertices in each branch. To do this we firstly fix a particular branch Gb , with its subtree Tb . In the branch sum we find a sum over all the ul short parameters of the lines l in Tb and no vl long parameters since l both enters and exits the branch. This is also true for the set Lb of welloriented loops lines with both fields in the branch. For the set Lb,+ of clashing loops lines with both fields entering the branch, the short variable disappears and the long variable remains; the same is true but with a minus sign for the set Lb,− of clashing loops lines with both fields exiting the branch. Finally we find the sum of positions of all external fields for the branch (with the signs according to entrance or exit). Obviously the Jacobian of this transformation is 1, so we simply get another equivalent set of n δ functions, one for each branch. For instance in the particular case of Figure 2, the delta function is δ ul1 + ul2 + ul3 + uL1 + uL2 + uL3 − vL4 + vL5 + X1 − X2 + X3 − X4 − X5 + X6 . (2.19) For an orientable graph, the position routing is summarized by: Lemma 2.2 (Position routing). We have, calling IG the remaining integrand in (2.17):
δ(xv,1 − xv,2 + xv,3 − xv,4 ) (2.20) AG = v4
δ(xv,1 − xv,2 + xv,3 − xv,4 + xv,5 − xv,6 ) IG xv,i , x0v,i v6
=
b
⎛ δ⎝
l∈Tb ∪Lb
ul +
⎞ ε(f )xf ⎠ IG
xv,i , x0v,i
f ∈Xb
where ε(f ) is ±1 depending on whether the field f enters or exits the branch.
Vol. 9 (2008)
Orientable Non-Commutative Complex Φ63 Model X1
+
_
_
X2
+
X6
_
X5_
vL5
+
_ +
_
u L3 u L2
ul1 _
X4
ul2
_
uL1
_
+ +
ul3 +
vL4
+
71
+ _
+ _
+ X3
Figure 2: A branch.
Using the above equations one can at least solve all the long tree variables vl in terms of external variables, short variables and long loop variables, using the n − 1 non-root branches. There remains then the root branch δ function. If Gb is orientable, this δ function of branch b0 contains only short and external variables. Here we shouldn’t forget that each external variable can be written as linear combination of short variable and long variable. If Gb is non-orientable one can solve for an additional “clashing” long loop variable. We can summarise these observations in the following lemma just like that in [15]: Lemma 2.3. The position routing solves any long tree variable vl as a function of: • the short tree variable ul of the line l itself, • the short tree and loop variables with both ends in Gb(l) , • the short and long variables of the loop lines with one end inside Gb(l) and the other outside, • the true external variables x hooked to Gb(l) . In the orientable case the root branch δ function contains only short tree variables, short loop variables and external variables but no long variables, hence gives a linear relation among the short variables and external positions. In the non-orientable case it gives a linear relation between the long variables w of all the clashing loops in the graph some short variables u’s and all the external positions. From now on, each time we use this lemma to solve the long tree variables vl in terms of the other variables, we shall call wl rather than vl the remaining
72
Z. Wang and S. Wan
Ann. Henri Poincar´e
2n6 + n4 + 1 − N/2 independent long loop variables. Hence looking at the long variables names the reader can check whether Lemma 2.3 has been used or not. 2.3. Multiscale analysis and crude power counting In this section we follow the standard procedure of multiscale analysis [26]. First the parametric integral for the propagator is sliced in the usual way: ∞ C u, u0 , v = C 0 u, u0 , v + C i u, u0 , v ,
(2.21)
i=1
with C u, u0 , v = 0
1
√
∞
1
Ωα− 2 dα
√ 3 2 2π sinh(α)
μ2
e
2 2 α Ω α Ω 0 −Ω 4 coth( 2 )u − 4 tanh( 2 )v − 2Ω α− 2α
2
l
(u0 )
(2.22) and
√ −1 Ωα 2 dα − Ω4 coth( α2 )u2 − Ω4 tanh( α2 )v2 − μ2Ω20 α− 2αΩ (u0 )2 l . e √ 3 M −2i 2 2π sinh(α) (2.23) We have an associated decomposition of any amplitude of the theory as μ AG = AG . (2.24)
C i u, u0 , v =
M −2(i−1)
μ
Lemma 2.4. For some constants K (large) and c (small): C i (u, v) ≤ KM i e−c [M
i
u+M i u0 +M −i v]
(2.25)
(which a posteriori justifies the terminology of “long” and “short” variables). We can use the second order approximation of the hyperbolic functions near the origin to prove this lemma. Taking absolute values, hence neglecting all oscillations, leads to the following crude bound:
|AG | ≤ dul du0l dvl C il ul , u0l , vl δv , (2.26) μ
l
v
where μ is the standard assignment of an integer index il to each propagator of each internal line l of the graph G, which represents its “scale”. We will consider only amputated graphs. Therefore we have only external vertices of the graph; in the renormalization group spirit, the convenient convention is to assign all external indices of these external fields to a fictitious −1 “background” scale. To any assignment μ and scale i are associated the standard connected components Gik , k = 1, . . . , k(i) of the subgraph Gi made of all lines with scales j ≥ i. These components are partially ordered according to their inclusion relations and the (abstract) tree describing these inclusion relations is called the Gallavotti– Nicol` o tree [7, 15]; its nodes are the Gik ’s and its root is the complete graph G.
Orientable Non-Commutative Complex Φ63 Model
Vol. 9 (2008)
73
More precisely for an arbitrary subgraph g one defines: ig (μ) = inf il (μ) , l∈g
eg (μ) =
sup
l external line of g
il (μ) .
(2.27)
The subgraph g is a Gik for a given μ if and only if ig (μ) ≥ i > eg (μ). Now we should choose the real tree T compatible with the abstract Gallavotti–Nicol` o tree to optimize the bound over spatial integrations, which means that the restriction Tki of T to any Gik must still span Gik . This is always possible (by a simple induction from leaves to root). We pick such a compatible tree T and use it both to orient the graph as in the previous section and to solve the associated branch system of δ functions according to Lemma 2.3. We obtain:
il il 0 −il M il dul du0l dvl e−c [M ul +M u +M vl ] δb |AG,μ | ≤ K n l b l
il il 0 −il ≤ K n M il dul du0l dwl e−c [M ul +M u +M vl (u,w,x)] δb0 . (2.28) l
l
Then we can find that any long variable integrated at scale i costs KM 2i . The integration over the non-commutative short variable at scale i brings KM −2i , and the commutative one brings KM −i (there is no long variable in the commutative dimension) so the integration over each tree line at scale i brings a total convergent factor KM −3i . The variables “solved” by the δ functions bring or cost nothing. For an orientable graph we should solve the n − 1 long variables vl ’s of the tree propagators in terms of the other variables, because this is the maximal number of long variables that we can solve, and they have highest possible indices because T has been chosen compatible with the Gallavotti–Nicol` o tree structure. We should study more carefully the commutative variable which is the 0th dimension of any tree line of T . While the model for the non-commutative variables is non local, it is local for the commutative variables. So we can’t integrate over all the position variables (or the equivalent line variables) but have to save one, the root (we name it xν0 ). We will use this point when we perform the renormalization where the imputed amplitude of any connected component depends only on one commutative external position xν0 . This point is also very important for the power counting of the non-orientable model as it implies the maximal number of commutative short variable we can integrate over is n − 1 not n. Finally we still have the last δb0 function (equivalent to the overall momentum conservation in the commutative case). It is optimal to use it to solve one external variable (if any) in terms of all the short variables and the external ones. Since external variables are typically smeared against unit scale test functions, this leaves power counting invariant. We now define S the set of long variables to be solved via the δ functions hence the set of n − 1 tree lines as there are only orientable graphs in our model. Gathering all the corresponding factors together with the propagators prefactors M i leads to the following bound:
|AG,μ | ≤ K n M il M −3il . (2.29) l
l∈S
74
Z. Wang and S. Wan
Ann. Henri Poincar´e
In the usual way of [26] we write
M il =
il
l i=1
l
and
M=
l∈S
M
−3il
=
M=
i,k l∈Gik
il
M −3 =
l∈S i=1
(2.30)
M −3
(2.31)
i,k
i,k
i
M l(Gk )
l∈Gik ∩S
and we must now only count the number of elements in Gik ∩ S. As remarked above Gik ∩ S = Tki , and the cardinal of Tki is n(Gik ) − 1. Using the fact that 2l(Gik ) − 6n6 (Gik ) − 4n4 = −N (Gik ) we can summarise these results in the following lemma: Lemma 2.5. The following bound holds for a connected graph of (ϕ¯ ϕ)3 model (with external arguments integrated against fixed smooth test functions):
i |AG,μ | ≤ K n M −ω(Gk ) (2.32) i,k
for some (large) constant K, with
ω(Gik )
= N (Gik )/2 + n4 − 3 .
This lemma proves the power counting for orientable graphs. But it is not yet sufficient for a renormalization theorem to all orders of perturbation. Indeed only planar graphs with a single broken face look like Moyal products when their internal indices become much higher than their external ones. So we must prove that the non-planar graphs or graphs with more than one broken face have better power counting than what Lemma 2.5 states. Vertices oscillations should be taken into account to prove that, and this is done in the next section. 2.4. Improved power counting Recall that for any non-commutative Feynman graph G we can define the genus of the graph, called g and the number of faces “broken by external legs”, called B [13, 23]. For a general graph, we have g ≥ 0 and B ≥ 1. In the previous section we established that ω(G) ≥ N/2 + n4 − 3 ,
if G orientable .
(2.33)
The subgraphs with g = 0 and B = 1 are called planar regular. We want to prove that they are the only non-vacuum graphs with ω ≤ 0. It is easy to check that planar regular subgraphs are orientable, but the converse is not true. To prove that orientable non-planar subgraphs or orientable planar subgraphs with B ≥ 2 are irrelevant requires to use a bit of the vertices oscillations to improve Lemma 2.5 and get: Lemma 2.6. For orientable subgraphs with g ≥ 1 we have ω(G) ≥ N/2 + n4 + 1 .
(2.34)
Orientable Non-Commutative Complex Φ63 Model
Vol. 9 (2008)
75
For orientable subgraphs with g = 0 and B ≥ 2 we have ω(G) ≥ N/2 + n4 − 1 .
(2.35)
This lemma is sufficient for the purpose of this paper. It implies directly that graphs which contain only irrelevant subgraphs have finite amplitudes which are uniformly bounded by K n , using the standard method of [26] to bound the assignment sum over μ in (2.26). The rest of this subsection is essentially devoted to the proof of this Lemma. We return before solving δ functions, hence to the v variables. We will need only to compute the oscillations which are quadratic in the long variables v’s to prove (2.34) and the linear oscillations in vθ−1 x to prove (2.35). Fortunately an analog problem was solved in momentum space by Filk and Chepelev-Roiban [1,6], and adapted to position routing by Gurau et al. [15]. We just borrow from the method of [15]. As the procedures for our paper are almost the same as that for ϕ44 in [15], we reproduce the argument as concisely as possible, and we refer to [15,30] for more details. The short variables are inessential in this subsection, as the integration of them always bring about convergent terms. But it is convenient to treat on the same footing the long v and the external x variables, so we introduce a new global notation y for all these variables. Then the vertices rewrite as
i+j+1 yi θ −1 yj +yQu+uRu) δ y1 −y2 + y3 −y4 + y5 −y6 + εi ui eı( i<j (−1) (2.36) v
for some inessential signs εi and some symplectic matrices Q and R. As there are no oscillations for the commutative coordinates, there are no Filk moves for them. Since the precise oscillations in the short u variables is not important to this problem, we will note in the sequel Eu any linear combination of the u variables. Let’s consider the first Filk reduction [6], which contracts tree lines of the graph. It creates progressively generalized vertices with even number of fields. At a given induction step and for a tree line joining two such generalized vertices with respectively p and q − p + 1 fields (suppose p is even and q is odd), we assume by induction that the two vertices are δ (y1 − y2 + y3 · · · − yp + Eu ) δ (yp − yp+1 + · · · − yq + Eu ) eı(
1≤i<j≤p (−1)
i+j+1
yi θ −1 yj +
p≤i<j≤q (−1)
i+j+1
yi θ −1 yj +yQu+uRu)
. (2.37)
Using the second δ function we see that: yp = yp+1 − yp+2 + · · · + yq − Eu .
(2.38)
Substituting this expression in the first δ function we get: δ(y1 − y2 + . . . − yp+1 + . . . − yq + Eu )δ(yp − yp+1 + · · · − yq + Eu ) eı(
1≤i<j≤p (−1)
i+j+1
yi θ −1 yj +
p≤i<j≤q (−1)
i+j+1
yi θ −1 yj +yQu+uRu)
. (2.39)
76
Z. Wang and S. Wan
Ann. Henri Poincar´e
2 4
5
3
1 6
7
Figure 3: A typical rosette.
The quadratic terms which include yp in the exponential are (taking into account that p is an even number): p−1
q
i=1
j=p+1
(−1)i+1 yi θ−1 yp +
(−1)j+1 yp θ−1 yj .
(2.40)
Using the expression (2.38) for yp we see that the second term gives only terms in yLu, as θ is antisymmetry. The first term yields: p−1
q
(−1)i+1+j+1 yi θ−1 yj =
i=1 j=p+1
q−1 p−1
(−1)i+k+1 yi θ−1 yj ,
(2.41)
i=1 k=p
which reconstitutes the crossed terms, and we have recovered the inductive form of the larger generalized vertex. After each Filk move we will have two more vertices. So by this procedure we will always treat only even vertices. We finally rewrite the product of the two vertices as: δ(y1 − y2 + · · · + yp−1 − yp+1 + · · · − yq + Eu )δ(yp − yp−1 + · · · − yq + Eu ) eı(
1≤i<j≤q (−1)
i+j+1
yi θ −1 yj +yQu+uRu)
, (2.42)
where the exponential is written in terms of the reindexed vertex variables. In this way we can contract all lines of a spanning tree T and reduce G to a single vertex with “tadpole loops” called a “rosette graph” [1]. In this rosette to keep track of cyclicity is essential so we draw the rosette as a cycle (which is the border of the former tree) bearing loops lines on it (see Figure 3). Remark that the rosette can also be considered as a big vertex, with r = 4n6 + 2n4 + 2 fields, on which N are external fields with external variables x and 4n6 + 2n4 + 2 − N are loop fields for the corresponding 2n6 + n4 + 1 − N/2 loops. When the graph is orientable, the
Vol. 9 (2008)
Orientable Non-Commutative Complex Φ63 Model
77
long variables yl for l in T will disappear in the rosette. Let us call z the set of remaining long loop and external variables. Then the rosette vertex factor is i+j+1 zi θ −1 zj +zQu+uRu) δ z1 − z2 + · · · − zr + Eu eı( 1≤i<j≤r (−1) . (2.43) We can go on performing inductively the first Filk move and the net effect is simply to rewrite the root branch δ function and the combination of all vertices oscillations (using the other δ functions) as the new big vertex or rosette factor (2.43). The second Filk reduction [6] further simplifies the rosette factor by erasing the loops of the rosette which do not cross any other loops or arch over external fields. Putting together all the terms in the exponential which contain zl we conclude exactly as in [6] that these long z variables completely disappear from the rosette oscillation factor, which simplifies as in [1] to δ(z1 − z2 + · · · − zr + Eu )eı(zIz+zQu+uRu)
(2.44)
where Iij is the antisymmetric “intersection matrix” of [1] (up to a different sign convention). Here Iij = +1 if oriented loop line i crosses oriented loop line j coming from its right, Iij = −1 if i crosses j coming from its left, and Iij = 0 if i and j do not cross. These formulas are also true for i external line and j loop line or the converse, provided one extends the external lines from the rosette circle radially to infinity to see their crossing with the loops. Finally when i and j are external lines one should define Iij = (−1)p+q+1 if p and q are the numbering of the lines on the rosette cycle (starting from an arbitrary origin). If a node Gik of the Gallavotti–Nicol` o tree is orientable but non-planar (g ≥ 1), there must therefore exist at least two intersecting loop lines in the rosette corresponding to this Gik , with long variables w1 and w2 . Moreover since Gik is orientable, none of the long loop variables associated with these two lines belongs to the set S of long variables eliminated by the δ constraints. Therefore, after integrating the variables in S the basic mechanism to improve the power counting of a single non planar subgraph is the following: −2i1 2 w1 −M −2i2 w22 −iw1 θ −1 w2 +w1 E1 (x,u)+w2 E2 (x,u) dw1 dw2 e−M −2i1 (w1 )2 −M −2i2 (w2 )2 +iw1 θ −1 w2 +(u,x)Q(u,x) = dw1 dw2 e−M 2i1 −2i2 M −2i1 )(w2 )2 = KM 2i1 dw2 e−(M +M = KM 2i1 ≤ K . (2.45) 1 + M −2(i1 +i2 ) In these equations we used for simplicity M −2i instead of the correct but more complicated factor (Ω/4) tanh(α/2) (see (2.18)) (of course this does not change the argument) and we performed a unitary linear change of variables w1 = w1 + 1 (x, u), w2 = w2 + 2 (x, u) to compute the oscillating w1 integral. The gain in (2.45) is M −2i1 −2i2 , which is the difference between O(1) and the normal factor M 2i1 +2i2 that would be generated by the integrals over w1 and w2 if there were not the oscillation term iw1 θ−1 w2 .
78
Z. Wang and S. Wan
Ann. Henri Poincar´e
So after the integration of the non-commutative part of the two clashing lines the gain is almost M −4i . This basic argument must then be generalized to each non-planar leaf in the Gallavotti–Nicol` o tree. Actually, in any orientable non-planar ‘primitive’ Gik node (i.e., not containing sub non-planar nodes) we can choose an arbitrary pair of crossing loop lines which will be integrated as in (2.45) using this oscillation. The corresponding improvements are independent. This leads to an improved amplitude bound:
i |AG,μ | ≤ K n M −ω(Gk ) (2.46) i,k
ω(Gik )
N (Gik )/2
where now = + n4 + 1 if Gik is orientable and non planar (i.e., g ≥ 1). This bound proves (2.34). Finally it remains to consider the case of nodes Gik which are planar orientable but with B ≥ 2. In that case there are no crossing loops in the rosette but there must be at least one loop line arching over a non trivial subset of external legs in the Gik rosette (see line 6 in Figure 3). We have then a non trivial integration over at least one external variable, called x, of at least one long loop variable called w. This “external” x variable without the oscillation improvement would be integrated with a test function of scale 1 (if it is a true external line of scale 1) or better (if it is a higher long loop variable)1 . But we get now −2i 2 −1 +2i 2 (2.47) dxdwe−M w −iwθ x+w.E1 (x ,u) = KM 2i dxe−M x = K . We find that a factor M 2i in the former bound becomes O(1) hence is improved by M −2i . So the power counting is ω(Gik ) = N (Gik )/2 − 1 + n4 . We find that the two point graphs with n4 = 0 and N (Gik ) = 2 maybe logarithmically divergent. They do not appear renormalizable at first sight. But we remark that in the orientable (ϕ¯ ϕ)3 model there will never be such subgraphs with N (Gik ) = 2 and B = 2. This is the reason we limit ourselves to this case2 . Then all graphs with B ≥ 2 are also safe. The only divergent graphs which need renormalization are the planar regular graphs.
3. Renormalization In this section we need to consider only divergent subgraphs, namely the planar two point, four point and six point subgraphs with a single external face (g = 0, B = 1, N = 2, 4, 6 for n4 = 0 ,N = 2, 4 for n4 = 1, and N = 2 for n4 = 2). We shall prove that they can be renormalized by appropriate counterterms of the form 1 Since
the loop line arches over a non trivial (i.e., neither full nor empty) subset of external legs of the rosette, the variable x cannot be the full combination of external variables in the “root” δ function. 2 We thank our referee for correcting an earlier version of this paper, which lead us to this important point.
Vol. 9 (2008)
Orientable Non-Commutative Complex Φ63 Model
79
of the initial Lagrangian. We would like to remark that for any graph, contrary to the non-commutative variables, the commutative variables of the external points are local. So there is only one integral over the commutative variable for each vertex. 3.1. Renormalization of the six-point function Consider a 6 point subgraph which needs to be renormalized, hence is a node of the Gallavotti–Nicol` o tree. This means that there is (i, k) such that N (Gik ) = 6. The six external positions of the amputated graph are labelled x1 , x2 , x3 , x4 , x5 and x6 . We also define Q, R and S as three skew-symmetric matrices of respective sizes 6 × l(Gik ), l(Gik ) × l(Gik ) and 2[n6 (Gik ) − 1] × l(Gik ), where we recall that 2(n(G)6 − 1) is the number of loops of a 6 point graph with n6 vertices. The amplitude associated to the connected component Gik is then A(Gik )(x1 , x2 , x3 , x4 , x5 , x6 , x0ν )
= du du0 C x, u, u0 , w ∈Tki
dul du0l dwl Cl
0 ul ul , ul , wl δ x1 − x2 + x3 − x4 + x5 − x6 +
l∈Gik , l∈T ı( p
×e
l∈Gik
.
(3.1)
Here the variable x0ν is the root commutative variable as discussed in Section 2.3 and we will write it as x0 hereafter. The exact form of the factor (−1)p+q+1 xp θ−1 xq p
is not essential for this paper and was discussed exhaustively in [15, 30]. The important fact is that there are no quadratic oscillations in X times W (because B = 1) nor in W times W (because g = 0). Cl is the propagator of the line l. For loop lines Cl is expressed in terms of ul and wl by formula (2.18), (with v replaced by our notation w for long variables of loop lines). But for tree lines ∈ Tki recall that the solution of the system of branch δ functions for T has reexpressed the corresponding long variables v in terms of the short variables u, and the external and long loop variables of the branch graph G which lies “over” in the rooted tree T . This is the essential content of Subsection 2.2. More precisely consider a line ∈ Tki with scale i( ) ≥ i; we can write v = X + W + U where X =
e∈E()
ε,e xe
(3.2)
(3.3)
80
Z. Wang and S. Wan
Ann. Henri Poincar´e
is a linear combination on the set of external variables of the branch graph G with the correct alternating signs ε,e , W =
ε,l wl
(3.4)
l∈L()
is a linear combination over the set L( ) of long loop variables for the external lines of G (and ε,l are other signs), and U =
ε,l ul
(3.5)
l ∈S()
is a linear combination over a set S of short variables that we do not need to know explicitly. The tree propagator for line then is C u , X , U , W , u0 u2 α α 2 2 Ω 0 M −2(i()−1) √ − 12 Ωαl dαl e− 4 coth( 2 )ul +tanh( 2 )[X +W +U ] − 2α Ω = . (3.6) √ 3 M −2i() 2 2π sinh(αl ) To renormalize, let us call e = max ep , p = 1, . . . , 6 the highest external index of the subgraph Gik . We have e < i since Gik is a node of the Gallavotti–Nicol` o tree. We evaluate A(Gik ) on external fields3 ϕ¯≤e (xp , x0 ) and ϕ≤e (xp , x0 ) as: A Gik =
6
dxp dx0 ϕ¯≤e x1 , x0 ϕ≤e x2 , x0 ϕ¯≤e x3 , x0 ϕ≤e x4 , x0
p=1
× ϕ¯≤e x5 , x0 ϕ≤e x6 , x0 A(Gik ) x1 , x2 , x3 , x4 , x5 , x6 , x0
6
dxp dx0 ϕ≤e xp , x0 eıExt du du0 C u , u0 , tX U , W (3.7) = p=1
×
∈Tki
l∈Gik
0 ıtXQU+ıURU+ıUSW ul , ul , wl δ Δ + t ul e i
dul du0l dwl Cl l∈T
l∈Gk
.
t=1
with Δ = x1 − x2 + x3 − x4 + x5 − x6 and Ext = 6p
3 For
the external to be exactly e the external smearing factor should be in fact index ≤e (x ) − ≤e−1 (x ) but this subtlety is inessential. ϕ ϕ p p p p
Orientable Non-Commutative Complex Φ63 Model
Vol. 9 (2008)
term is irrelevant. Let U = R(t) = −
l∈Gik
81
ul , and
α Ω
tanh t2 X2 + 2tX W + U 4 2 i
∈Tk
≡ −t2 AX.X − 2tAX.(W + U ) . where A =
Ω 4
= A Gik
tanh( α2 ), and X · Y means
6 ⎡
"
∈Tki
X .Y . We have
dxp dx0 ϕ≤e xp , x0 eıExt du du0 C u , u0 , U , W
p=1
⎣
(3.8)
∈Tki
⎤
dul du0l dwl Cl (ul , wl )⎦ eıURU+ıUSW
(3.9)
l∈Gik l∈T
δ(Δ) + 0
1
dt U · ∇δ(Δ + tU) + δ(Δ + tU) ıXQU + R (t) eıtXQU+R(t)
#
where C (u , U , W ) is given by (3.6) but taken at X = 0. The first term, denoted by τ A, is of the desired form (2.16) times a number independent of the external variables x. It is asymptotically constant in the slice index i, hence the sum over i at fixed e is logarithmically divergent: this is the divergence expected for the six-point function. It remains only to check that (1 − τ )A converges as i−e → ∞. But we have three types of terms in (1−τ )A, each providing a specific improvement over the regular, log-divergent power counting of A: • The term U · ∇δ(Δ + tU) . For this term, integrating by parts over external variables, the ∇ acts on external fields ϕ≤e , hence brings at most M e to the bound, whether the U term brings at least M −i . • The term XQU . Here X brings at most M e and U brings at least M −i . • The term R (t). It decomposes into terms in AX · X, AX · U and AX · W . Here the A brings at least M −2i() , X brings at worst M e , U brings at least M −i and X W brings at worst M e+i() . This last point is the only subtle one: if ∈ Tki , remark that because Tki is a sub-tree within each Gallavotti– Nicol` o subnode of Gik , in particular all parameters wl for l ∈ L( ) which appear in W must have indices lower or equal to i( ) (otherwise they would have been chosen instead of in Tki ). In conclusion, since i( ) ≥ i, the Taylor remainder term (1 − τ )A improves the power-counting of the connected component Gik by a factor at least M −(i−e) . This additional M −(i−e) factor makes (1 − τ )A(Gik ) convergent and irrelevant as desired.
82
Z. Wang and S. Wan
Ann. Henri Poincar´e
3.2. Renormalization of the four-point function Consider a 4 point subgraph which needs to be renormalized, hence is a node of the Gallavotti–Nicol` o tree. This means that there is (i, k) such that N (Gik ) = 4. The four external positions of the amputated graph are labelled x1 , x2 , x3 and x4 . We also define Q, R and S as three skew-symmetric matrices of respective sizes 4 × l(Gik ), l(Gik ) × l(Gik ) and [2n6 (Gik ) + n4 (Gik ) − 1] × l(Gik ), where we recall that [2n6 (Gik ) + n4 (Gik ) − 1] is the number of loops of a 4 point graph with n6 + n4 vertices. The amplitude associated to the connected component Gik is then A(Gik ) x1 , x2 , x3 , x4 , x0 (3.10)
du du0 C x, u, u0 , w dul du0l dwl Cl ul , u0l , wl = ∈Tki
l∈Gik , l∈T
× δ x1 − x2 + x3 − x4 +
ul eı(
p
p+q+1
xp θ −1 xq +XQU+URU+USW )
.
l∈Gik
The renormalization procedure is almost the same as that for the 6 point function. Let us call e = max ep , p = 1, . . . , 4 the highest external index of the subgraph Gik . We have e < i since Gik is a node of the Gallavotti–Nicol` o tree. We evaluate A(Gik ) on external fields ϕ¯≤e (xp , x0 ) and ϕ≤e (xp , x0 ) as: A Gik =
4
dxp dx0 ϕ¯≤e x1 , x0 ϕ≤e x2 , x0 ϕ¯≤e x3 , x0 ϕ≤e x4 , x0
p=1
× A Gik x1 , x2 , x3 , x4 , x0
4 dxp dx0 ϕ¯≤e x1 , x0 ϕ≤e x2 , x0 ϕ¯≤e x3 , x0 ϕ≤e x4 , x0 eıExt = p=1
∈Tki
du du0 C u , u0 , tX U , W
(3.11)
⎞ ⎛ ıtXQU+ıURU+ıUSW dul du0l dwl Cl ul , u0l , wl δ⎝Δ + t u⎠ l e
l∈Gik l∈T
l∈Gik
with Δ = x1 − x2 + x3 − x4 and Ext = A(Gik )
=
4 ⎡ ⎣
4
p+q+1 xp θ−1 xq . p
t=1
Then we have
dxp dx0 ϕ≤e xp , x0 eıExt du du0 C u , u0 , U , W
p=1
l∈Gik l∈T
∈Tki
⎤ dul du0l dwl Cl ul , u0l , wl ⎦ eıURU+ıUSW
Orientable Non-Commutative Complex Φ63 Model
Vol. 9 (2008)
"
δ(Δ) + Uμ · ∇μ δ(Δ) + iXQU − 2AX(W + U ) × δ(Δ)
1 + 2
0
1
83
(3.12)
dt(1 − t) (U · ∇)2 δ(Δ + tU) + f (t)δ(Δ + tU) eıtXQU+R(t)
#
where R ,X and U are the same as (3.8), and again C (u , u0 , U , W ) is given by (3.6) but taken at X = 0. The first term, denoted by τ A, is of the desired form (2.15) times a number independent of the external variables x. It is is linearly divergent: this is the divergence expected for the four-point function. It remains only to check that (1 − τ )A converges as i − e → ∞. But we have three types of terms in (1 − τ )A, each providing a specific improvement over the regular, log-divergent power counting of A: • The term U · ∇δ(Δ) vanishes due to the parity, as it is odd integral over u. • the third term (the terms linearly proportional to U and W )on the r.h.s. is zero due to the parity, as they are also odd integrals over u and w. • In the remainder terms of tailor expansion, for the term U2 · ∇2 δ(Δ + tU) the∇2 brings M 2e through the integral by parts and the U2 brings M −2i . So it is convergent. • for the last term, f (t) = −2A.X.X + (XQU )2 + 4[AX(W + U )]2 − 4iXQU AX(W + U ) and this term is convergent. 3.3. Renormalization of the two-point function We consider now the nodes such that N (Gik ) = 2. We use the same notations than in the previous subsection. The two external points are labelled x and y. Using the global δ function, which is now δ x − y + U , we remark that the external −1 oscillation eıxθ y can be absorbed in a redefinition of the term eıtXQU , which we do from now on. The full amplitude is
dul du0l dwl A(Gik ) = dxdydx0 ϕ¯≤e x, x0 ϕ≤e y, x0 δ x − y + U l∈Gik , l∈T
Cl ul , u0l , wl du du0 C u , u0 , X , U , W eıXQU+ıURU+ıUSW . ∈Tki
We first perform the Taylor expansion in the position variables of external fields: ϕ¯≤e x, x0 ϕ≤e y, x0 δ x − y + U = ϕ¯≤e x, x0 ϕ≤e y, x0 δ x − y + sU |s=1 $ = ϕ¯≤e x, x0 ϕ≤e y, x0 δ(x − y) + U · ∇δ(x − y) 1 1 + (U · ∇)2 δ(x − y) + 2 2
0
1
% ds(1 − s) (U · ∇) δ x − y + sU . 2
3
(3.13)
84
Z. Wang and S. Wan
Ann. Henri Poincar´e
We perform then a Taylor expansion in t at order 3 of the remaining function f (t) = eıtXQU+R(t) ,
(3.14)
2
where we recall that R(t) = −[t AX.X + 2tAX.(W + U )]. We get A0 = dxdx0 ϕ¯≤e x, x0 ϕ≤e x, x0 eı(URU+USW )
dul du0l dwl Cl (ul , wl ) du du0 C u , u0 , U , W l∈Gjk , l∈T
∈Tki
1 1 1 2 (3) dt (1 − t) f (t) . f (0) + f (0) + f (0) + 2 2 0
(3.15)
In order to evaluate that expression, let A0,0 , A0,1 , A0,2 be the zeroth, first and second order terms in this Taylor expansion, and A0,R be the remainder term. First, A0,0 = dxdx0 ϕ¯≤e x, x0 ϕ≤e x, x0 eı(URU+USW )
(3.16) dul du0l dwl Cl (ul , wl ) du du0 C u , u0 , U , W l∈Gjk , l∈T
∈Tki
is quadratically divergent and is exactly the expected form for the mass counterterm. Then
A0,1 = dxdx0 ϕ¯≤e x, x0 ϕ≤e x, x0 eı(URU+USW ) dul dwl Cl (ul , wl )
du du0 C u , u0 , U , W
l∈Gik , l∈T
ıXQU + R (0)
(3.17)
∈Tki
vanishes identically. Indeed all the terms are odd integrals over the u and w variables. A0,2 is more complicated:
dul dwl Cl (ul , wl ) A0,2 = dxdx0 ϕ¯≤e x, x0 ϕ≤e x, x0 eı(URU+USW )
du C (u , U , W )
l∈Gik , l∈T
− (XQU )2
∈Tki
2 . − 4ıXQU AX · (W + U ) − 2AX · X + 4 AX · (W + U )
(3.18)
The four terms in (XQU )2 , XQU AX · W , AX · X and [AX · W ]2 are logarithmically divergent and contribute to the renormalization of the harmonic frequency term Ω in (2.2). (The terms in xμ xν with μ = ν do not survive by parity and the terms in (xμ )2 have obviously the same coefficient.) The other terms in XQU AX · U , (AX · U )(AX · W ) and [AX · U ]2 are irrelevant. Similarly the terms in A0,R (x) are all irrelevant.
Orientable Non-Commutative Complex Φ63 Model
Vol. 9 (2008)
85
Next we have to consider the terms of the first order expansion in external variables in (3.13), for which we need to develop the f function only to second order. We have A1 = dxdydx0 ϕ¯≤e x, x0 ϕ≤e y, x0 U · ∇δ(x − y) eı(URU+USW )
dul dwl × Cl (ul , wl ) du du0 C u , u0 , U , W f (0) + f (0) l∈Gik ,l∈T
+ 0
1
∈Tki
dt(1 − t)f (t)dt .
(3.19)
The first term is A1,0 = dxdydx0 ϕ¯≤e x, x0 ϕ≤e y, x0 U · ∇δ(x − y) eı(URU+USW )
(3.20) × dul dwl × Cl (ul , wl ) du du0 C u , u0 , U , W , l∈Gik ,l∈T
∈Tki
which vanishes identically due to the parity. The second term is A1,0 = dxdydx0 ϕ¯≤e x, x0 ϕ≤e y, x0 U · ∇δ(x − y) eı(URU+USW )
× dul dwl × Cl (ul , wl ) du du0 C u , u0 , U , W l∈Gik ,l∈T
∈Tki
× iXQU − 2AX (W + U ) .
(3.21)
The first term in the r.h.s. is dxdx0 ϕ¯≤e x, x0 U · (−i)∇ϕ≤e x, x0 eı(URU+USW )
× dul dwl × Cl (ul , wl ) du du0 C u , u0 , U , W × XQU l∈Gik ,l∈T
(3.22)
∈Tki
It is logarithmically divergent and is proportional to the term ϕ(x ¯ ∧ p)ϕ 4 . But this term is also vanishing, as for each graph there is always a mirror graph (see [3] for details) that is the same as the former but reflected in a mirror. When we add them up, e.g., the tadpole up with the tadpole down, the result is zero.5 • The term AXW · U · ∇ϕ≤e (x, x0 ). The operator ∇ brings a factor M e ,A brings a factor M −2i() , U brings a factor M −i and W brings M i(l) . The final factor is M −(i+i()−2e) · M −(i()−i(l)) . We remark that the scale of a tree line is higher than the loop line that lies over it, or the loop line would be chosen as tree line instead. So i( ) > i(l) and this term is irrelevant. 4 We 5 We
thank our referee for pointing out this important point. are very grateful to Prof. Rivasseau for explaining this.
86
Z. Wang and S. Wan
Ann. Henri Poincar´e
• The term AXU · U · ∇ϕ≤e (x, x0 ) is smaller as U brings M −i and there is no long loop variables. So it is irrelevant. • We can easily find that A1,R is smaller hence irrelevant. Now we consider the second order expansion in external variables in (3.13). We only have to expand f (t) to first order. We have 1 (U · ∇)2 δ(x − y) eı(URU+USW ) A2 = dxdydx0 ϕ¯≤e x, x0 ϕ≤e y, x0 2
× dul dwl Cl (ul , wl ) du du0 C u , u0 , U , W l∈Gik ,l∈T
× f (0) +
1
∈Tki
dtf (t)dt .
(3.23)
0
The first term is 1 (U · ∇)2 δ (x − y) eı(URU+USW ) A2,0 = dxdydx0 ϕ¯≤e x, x0 ϕ≤e y, x0 2
× dul dwl Cl (ul , wl ) du du0 C u , u0 , U , W . (3.24) l∈Gik ,l∈T
∈Tki
The terms with μ = ν do not survive by parity. The other ones reconstruct a counterterm proportional to the Laplacian. The power-counting of this factor A2,0 is improved (with respect to A) by a factor M −2(i−e) which makes it only logarithmically divergent, as should be for a wave-function counterterm. The second term is 1 (U · ∇)2 δ(x − y) eı(URU+USW ) A2,0 = dxdydx0 ϕ¯≤e x, x0 ϕ≤e y, x0 2
× dul dwl Cl (ul , wl ) du du0 C u , u0 , U , W l∈Gik ,l∈T
×
0
1
∈Tki
dt iXQU − 2tAXX − 2AX(W + U ) .
(3.25)
It is irrelevant as the terms in the integral bring at least a convergent factor M −(i−e) . Putting together the results of the two previous section, we have proved that the usual effective series which expresses any connected function of the theory in terms of an infinite set of effective couplings, related one to each other by a discretize flow [26], have finite coefficients to all orders. Reexpressing these effective series in terms of the renormalized couplings would reintroduce in the usual way the Zimmermann’s forests of counterterms and build the standard renormalized series. The most explicit way to check finiteness of these renormalized series in order to complete the “BPHZ theorem” is to use the “classification of forests” which distributes Zimmermann’s forests into packets such that the sum over assignments in each packet is finite [26]. This part is identical to the commutative case. Hence the proof of Theorem 2.1 is completed.
Orientable Non-Commutative Complex Φ63 Model
Vol. 9 (2008)
87
Appendix A. The non-commutative ϕ63 model In this appendix we discuss briefly the non-orientable real scalar ϕ63 model, and its renormalizability which is questionable. The action functional, with the notations of (2.2) is now 1 Ω2 1 1 S[ϕ] = d2 x dx0 xμ ϕ) + μ20 ϕ ϕ ∂μ ϕ ∂ μ ϕ + ∂0 ϕ ∂ 0 ϕ + (˜ xμ ϕ) (˜ 2 2 2 2 λ g + ϕ ϕ ϕ ϕ + ϕ ϕ ϕ ϕ ϕ ϕ (x) . (A.1) 4 6 In the real ϕ6 model, there are only two kinds of cyclically invariant vertices, namely the ϕ4 term: V (x1 , x2 , x3 , x4 ) = δ(x1 − x2 + x3 − x4 )ei
1≤i<j≤4 (−1)
i+j+1
xi θ −1 xj
(A.2)
and the ϕ6 term: V (x1 , x2 , x3 , x4 , x5 , x6 ) = δ(x1 − x2 + x3 − x4 + x5 − x6 ) ei
1≤i<j≤6 (−1)
i+j+1
xi θ −1 xj
(A.3)
times the local factor in the time direction. Again we note xθ−1 y ≡ 2θ (x1 y2 −x2 y1 ). The discussion is almost the same as that in (ϕ¯ ϕ)3 model, with a difference in the power counting of the non-orientable graph. When several disjoint Gik subgraphs are non-orientable it is better to solve longer clashing loop variables, essentially one per disjoint non-orientable Gik , because they spare higher costs than if tree lines were chosen instead. We define S to be the set of n long variables to be solved via the δ functions. First we put in S all the n − 1 long tree variables vl . Then we scan all the connected components Gik starting from the leaves towards the root, and we add a clashing line to S each time when a new non-orientable component Gik appears. We also remove p − 1 tree lines from S so that each time p ≥ 2 non-orientable components merge into a single one. In the end we obtain a new set S of exactly n − 1 + p − (p − 1) = n long variables. So thanks to inductive use of Lemma 2.3 in each Gik , we can solve all the long variables in the set S with the branch system of δ functions associated to T plus an additional loop variable. But for the commutative dimension, there are always n − 1 short tree variables to be integrated. So for a general non-orientable graph we will earn only a convergent factor M −2i and the degree of divergence given by this crude analysis becomes ω(Gik ) = N (Gik )/2 + n4 − 1 (recall Lemma 2.5). Let us consider the improved analysis taking oscillations into account. From the analog of Lemma 2.6 we see that graphs with g = 0, n4 = 0, B = 2 and N = 2 remain dangerous. Such graphs can’t appear in the (ϕ¯ ϕ)3 model as they are non-orientable. In the ϕ6 model they can appear, are logarithmic divergent and don’t look like the initial quadratic terms in the Lagrangian. So the two point function of this (ϕ¯ ϕ)3 model seems non-renormalizable, but maybe the situation can be rescued by combining all renormalizations together, as is done, e.g., in [30]
88
Z. Wang and S. Wan
Ann. Henri Poincar´e
or maybe we can solve this problem by exploring further the vertex oscillations. The study of this problem is still in progress.
Acknowledgements The author is very grateful to V. Rivasseau for successful direction and encouragement and many useful discussions on this work. We are also very grateful to the anonymous referee for critical comments. This work is supported by NSFC Grant No.10675108.
References [1] I. Chepelev and R. Roiban, Convergence theorem for non-commutative Feynman graphs and renormalization, JHEP 03 (2001), 001, http://www.arXiv.org/abs/ hep-th/0008090hep-th/0008090. [2] A. Connes, M. R. Douglas, and A. Schwarz, Non-commutative geometry and matrix theory: Compactification on Tori, JHEP 02 (1998), 003, http://www.arXiv.org/ abs/hep-th/9711162hep-th/9711162. [3] M. Disertori and V. Rivasseau, Two and three loops beta function of non commutative Φ44 theory, Eur. Phys. J. C50 (2007) 661, http://www.arXiv.org/abs/hep-th/ 0610224hep-th/0610224. [4] M. Disertori, R. Gurau, J. Magnen and V. Rivasseau, Vanishing of beta function of non commutative Φ44 to all orders, Phys. Lett. B649 (2007), 95–102, http://www.arXiv.org/abs/hep-th/0612251hep-th/0612251. [5] M. R. Douglas and N. A. Nekrasov, Non-commutative field theory, Rev. Mod. Phys. 73 (2001), 977–1029, http://www.arXiv.org/abs/hep-th/0106048hep-th/0106048. [6] T. Filk, Divergencies in a field theory on quantum space, Phys. Lett. B376 (1996), 53–58. [7] G. Gallavotti and F. Nicol` o, Renormalization theory in four-dimensional scalar fields. i, Commun. Math. Phys. 100 (1985), 545–590. [8] H. Grosse and H. Steinacker, Renormalization of the non-commutative ϕ3 model through the Kontsevich model (2005). [9] H. Grosse and H. Steinacker, A nontrivial solvable non-commutative ϕ3 model in 4 dimensions, http://www.arXiv.org/abs/hep-th/0603052hep-th/0603052. [10] H. Grosse and H. Steinacker, Exact renormalization of a non-commutative phi**3 model in 6 dimensions, http://www.arXiv.org/abs/hep-th/hep-th/ 0607235hep-th/0607235. [11] H. Grosse and R. Wulkenhaar, Power-counting theorem for non-local matrix models and renormalization, Commun. Math. Phys. 254 (2005), no. 1, 91–127, http://www.arXiv.org/abs/hep-th/0305066hep-th/0305066. [12] H. Grosse and R. Wulkenhaar, The beta-function in duality-covariant noncommutative ϕ4 -theory, Eur. Phys. J. C35 (2004), 277–282, http://www.arXiv.org/ abs/hep-th/0402093hep-th/0402093.
Vol. 9 (2008)
Orientable Non-Commutative Complex Φ63 Model
89
[13] H. Grosse and R. Wulkenhaar, Renormalization of ϕ4 -theory on non-commutative R4 in the matrix base, Commun. Math. Phys. 256 (2005), no. 2, 305–374, http://www.arXiv.org/abs/hep-th/0401128hep-th/0401128. [14] R. Gurau, V. Rivasseau, and F. Vignes-Tourneret, Propagators for non-commutative field theories, Ann. H. Poincar´e 7 (2006), 1601–1628, http://www.arXiv.org/abs/ hep-th/0512071hep-th/0512071. [15] R. Gurau, J. Magnen, V. Rivasseau and F. Vignes-Tourneret, Renormalization of non-commutative ϕ44 field theory in x space, Commun. Math. Phys. 267 (2006), no. 2, 515–542, http://www.arXiv.org/abs/hep-th/0512271hep-th/0512271. [16] R. Gurau and V. Rivasseau, Parametric representation of non-commutative field theory, Commun. Math. Phys. 272 (2007), 811–835, http://www.arXiv.org/abs/ math-ph/0606030math- ph/0606030. [17] S. Hellerman and M. Van Raamsdonk, Quantum Hall Physics = noncommutative field theory, JHEP 0110 (2001), 039, http://www.arXiv.org/abs/ hep-th/0103179hep-th/ 0103179 [18] E. Langmann and R. J. Szabo, Duality in scalar field theory on non-commutative phase spaces, Phys. Lett. B533 (2002), 168–177, http://www.arXiv.org/abs/ hep-th/0202039hep-th/0202039. [19] E. Langmann, R. J. Szabo, and K. Zarembo, Exact solution of quantum field theory on non-commutative phase spaces, JHEP 01 (2004), 017, http://www.arXiv.org/ abs/hep-th/0308043hep-th/0308043. [20] S. Minwalla, M. Van Raamsdonk, and N. Seiberg, Noncommutative perturbative dynamics, JHEP 02 (2000), 020, http://www.arXiv.org/abs/hep-th/ 9912072hep-th/9912072. [21] J. Polchinski, Renormalization and effective Lagrangians, Nucl. Phys. B231 (1984), 269. [22] A. Polychronakos, Quantum Hall states as matrix Chern–Simons theory, JHEP 0104 (2001), 011, http://www.arXiv.org/abs/hep-th/0103013hep-th/0103013. [23] V. Rivasseau, F. Vignes-Tourneret, and R. Wulkenhaar, Renormalization of noncommutative ϕ4 -theory by multi-scale analysis, Commun. Math. Phys. 262 (2006), 565–594, (Online First) DOI: 10.1007/s00220-005-1440-4 (2005), http://www.arXiv. org/abs/hep-th/0501036hep-th/0501036. [24] V. Rivasseau and F. Vignes-Tourneret, Renormalization of non-commutative field theories, http://www.arXiv.org/abs/hep-th/0702068hep-th/0702068. [25] V. Rivasseau, Non-commutative renormalization, http://lanl.arxiv.org/abs/ 0705.0705hep-th/0705.0705. [26] V. Rivasseau, From perturbative to constructive renormalization. Princeton series in physics. Princeton Univ. Pr., Princeton, USA, 1991, 336 p. [27] N. Seiberg and E. Witten, String theory and non-commutative geometry, JHEP 09 (1999), 032, http://www.arXiv.org/abs/hep-th/9908142hep-th/9908142. [28] L. Susskind, The quantum hall fluid and non-commutative Chern–Simons theory, hep-th/0101029 [29] R. J. Szabo, Quantum field theory on non-commutative phase spaces, Phys. Rep. 378 (2003), 207, http://www.arXiv.org/abs/hep-th/0109162hep-th/0109162.
90
Z. Wang and S. Wan
Ann. Henri Poincar´e
[30] F. Vignes-Tourneret, Renormalization of the orientable non-commutative Gross– Neveu model, Ann. H. Poincar´e 8 (2007), 427–474, http://www.arXiv.org/abs/ math-ph/0606069math-ph/0606069. Zhituo Wang and Shaolong Wan Institute for Theoretical Physics and Department of Modern Physics University of Science and Technology of China Hefei, 230026 P. R. China e-mail:
[email protected] [email protected] Communicated by Raimar Wulkenhaar. Submitted: April 10, 2007. Accepted: July 20, 2007.
Ann. Henri Poincar´e 9 (2008), 91–107 c 2008 Birkh¨ auser Verlag Basel/Switzerland 1424-0637/010091-17, published online January 30, 2008 DOI 10.1007/s00023-007-0351-7
Annales Henri Poincar´ e
Sinai Billiards under Small External Forces II Nikolai Chernov Abstract. We study perturbations of Sinai billiards, where a small stationary force acts on the moving particle between its collisions with scatterers. In the previous work [7] we proved that the collision map preserved a unique Sinai– Ruelle–Bowen (SRB) measure that was Bernoulli and had exponential decay of correlations. Here we add several other statistical properties, including bounds on multiple correlations, the almost sure invariance principle (ASIP), the law of iterated logarithms, and a Kawasaki-type formula. We also show that the corresponding flow is Bernoulli and satisfies a central limit theorem.
1. Introduction This a continuation of our paper [7], and we use the symbols and notation of the latter for compatibility. Let B1 , . . . , Bs be open convex domains on the unit 2D torus T2 . Assume that B¯i ∩ B¯j = ∅ for i = j, and for each i the boundary ∂Bi is a C 3 smooth closed curve with nonvanishing curvature. Let a particle of unit mass move in D = T2 \ ∪i Bi according to equations q˙ = p ,
p˙ = F
(1.1)
where q = (x, y) is the position vector, p = (u, v) is the momentum (velocity) vector, and F(x, y, u, v) = (F1 , F2 ) is a stationary force (independent of time). Upon reaching the boundary ∂D = ∪i ∂Bi , the particle gets reflected elastically, according to the classical rule (1.2) p+ = p− − 2 n(q) · p− n(q) ; here q ∈ ∂D is the point of reflection, n(q) is the inward unit normal vector to ∂D, and p− , p+ are the incoming and outgoing velocity vectors, respectively. The case F = 0 corresponds to the ordinary billiard dynamics on the table D. It preserves the kinetic energy, so that one can fix it by setting p = 1. Then the phase space of the system is a compact 3D manifold Ω0 = D × S 1 . The billiard flow Φt0 on Ω0 preserves the Liouville measure μ0 (which is uniform on Ω0 ).
92
N. Chernov
Ann. Henri Poincar´e
In the study of billiards, one uses the collision space M0 = (q, p) ∈ Ω0 : q ∈ ∂D, p · n(q) ≥ 0 ,
(1.3)
which consists of all outgoing velocity vectors at reflection points. The first return map F0 : M0 → M0 is called the billiard map (or the collision map). The space M0 can be parameterized by (r, ϕ), where r is the arclength along ∂D and ϕ ∈ [−π/2, π/2] is the angle between p and n(q). In these coordinates, M0 = ∂D × [−π/2, π/2]. The map F0 preserves a finite smooth measure on M0 with density dν0 = const · cos ϕ dr dϕ. The flow Φt0 is a suspension flow over the base map F0 under the ceiling function τ0 (X) = min{t > 0 : Φt0 X ∈ M} (the next collision time). Billiards on tables D = T2 \ ∪i Bi as described above are known as dispersing billiards or Sinai billiards. The map F0 is ergodic, mixing [28], Bernoulli [15], and has other strong statistical properties, such as exponential decay of correlations [6, 32] and the central limit theorem [3]. The billiard flow Φt0 is also ergodic, mixing [28], and Bernoulli [15]. Under an additional assumption of finite horizon (see below) the flow Φt0 enjoys stretched exponential decay of correlations [9] and satisfies the central limit theorem [3]. Various perturbations of Sinai billiards have been studied in [1,18–21,29,30], see also a survey [22]. Most notably, when F is a small constant force with a Gaussian thermostat (see below), then one can rigorously prove a one-particle version of classical Ohm’s law and the Einstein relation [4, 5]. More recently, perturbed Sinai billiards were used in the analysis of the Galton board [12] and self-similar Lorentz channels [2, 11]. A general class of Sinai billiards with small external forces F = 0 was studied in [7] under the following assumptions: Assumption A (Additional integral). A smooth function E(q, p) is preserved by the dynamics (1.1)–(1.2). Its level surface, Ω = {E(q, p) = const} is a compact 3-D manifold such that p = 0 on Ω and for each q ∈ D and p ∈ S 1 the ray {(q, sp), s > 0} intersects the manifold Ω in one point. Under Assumption A, Ω can be parameterized by (x, y, θ), where (x, y) = q ∈ D and 0 ≤ θ < 2π is a cyclic coordinate, the angle between p and the positive x axis. The dynamics (1.1)–(1.2) restricted to Ω is a flow that we denote by Φt . In the coordinates (x, y, θ) the equations of motion (1.1) can be rewritten as x˙ = p cos θ ,
y˙ = p sin θ ,
θ˙ = ph ,
(1.4)
where p = p > 0
and
h = (−F1 sin θ + F2 cos θ)/p2 .
It is also useful to note that p˙ = F1 cos θ + F2 sin θ .
(1.5)
Vol. 9 (2008)
Sinai Billiards under Small External Forces II
93
Both h = h(x, y, θ) and p = p(x, y, θ) are assumed to be C 2 smooth functions on Ω, and note that 0 < pmin ≤ p ≤ pmax < ∞ . (1.6) There are two particularly interesting types of forces satisfying Assumption A. One is a potential force F = −∇U , where U = U (q) is a potential function; it preserves the total energy T = 12 p2 + U (q). The other type is isokinetic forces satisfying (F · p) = 0, they preserve the kinetic energy K = 12 p2 , so one can set p = 1 as in billiards. For example, given any force F, one can construct an isokinetic force by adding Gaussian thermostat: q˙ = p ,
p˙ = F − αp where α = (F · p)/(p · p) .
(1.7)
For a function f on Ω, let fx , fy , fθ denote its partial derivatives and f C 2 the maximum of f and its first and second partial derivatives over Ω. Put (1.8) B0 = max p−1 min , pC 2 , hC 2 . Assumption B (Smallness of the force). We assume that the force F and its first derivatives are small, i.e., max |h|, |hx |, |hy |, |hθ | ≤ δ0 . More precisely, we require that for any given B∗ > 0 there should be a small δ∗ = δ∗ (D, B∗ ) such that all our results will hold whenever B0 < B∗ and δ0 < δ∗ . We note that the smallness of δ∗ is required in [7] at several crucial steps, some of those requirements are more severe than others. Physical implications of those requirements are discussed in Remark on p. 232 in [7]. Assumption C (Finite horizon). There is an L > 0 so that every straight line of length L on the torus T2 crosses at least one obstacle Bi . Now we introduce the collision space of the system (1.1)–(1.2): M = (q, p) ∈ Ω : q ∈ ∂D, p · n(q) ≥ 0
(1.9)
and the corresponding collision map F : M → M. The space M can be parameterized by (r, ϕ) as before, in these coordinates M is identical to M0 in (1.3). Theorem 1.1 ([7]). Under Assumptions A, B, and C, the map F : M → M is a smooth hyperbolic map with singularities that has uniform expansion and contraction rates. It admits a unique SRB measure ν, which is positive on open sets, K-mixing and Bernoulli. It enjoys exponential decay of correlations (with bounds uniform in the force F) and satisfies the central limit theorem. We remark that in unperturbed Sinai billiards the hyperbolicity results from a rather obvious geometric fact that divergent families of trajectories remain divergent (under the action of the flow) and grow exponentially in size at time goes on. In our perturbed billiards, the same property holds for the so-called strongly divergent families of flow lines (whose orthogonal cross-section has curvature bounded
94
N. Chernov
Ann. Henri Poincar´e
below by a positive constant), see precise definition in [7, p. 208]. Similarly, strongly convergent families are defined (those remain convergent and expand in the timereversal flow).
2. Advanced statistical properties of F Here we derive further statistical properties of the collision map F by employing the coupling method recently introduced by L.-S. Young [33] and modified by D. Dolgopyat [10, Appendix A]. It is based on iterations of probability measures supported on unstable curves. First we recall a few definitions and facts following [7]. An unstable (or stable) curve γ ⊂ M is a trace of a strongly divergent (resp., convergent) family of flow lines [7, p. 213]. We may assume [7, p. 215] that the curvature of unstable and stable curves is uniformly bounded. To ensure distortion control we cut M into countably many homogeneity strips [7, p. 216] that accumulate near ∂M, thus F becomes discontinuous on the preimages of the boundaries of those strips. A curve is homogeneous if it lies in a single homogeneity strip (i.e., in one connected component of M). For any X ∈ γ denote by Jγ F n (X) the Jacobian of the map F n restricted to γ at X. If F i (γ) is a homogeneous unstable curve for all 0 ≤ i ≤ n, then we have the following distortion bound, see [7, Lemma 4.2]: | ln Jγ F n (X) − ln Jγ F n (Y )| ≤ C|F n (γ)|1/3 ,
X, Y ∈ γ
(2.1)
where |γ| denotes the length of γ, and by C we will denote various positive constants independent of the force F. Accordingly, if γ u is a homogeneous unstable manifold (called h-fiber in [7]) and ργ u is the u-SRB density on γ u , i.e., the unique probability density satisfying ργ u (X) Jγ u F −n (X) = lim , X, Y ∈ γ u , (2.2) n→∞ Jγ u F −n (Y ) ργ u (Y ) d then (2.1) implies dX ln ργ u (X) ≤ C|γ u |−2/3 ; see, e.g., [8, Section 5.6]1 . If γ1 , γ2 are unstable curves and ξ a stable h-fiber crossing each γi in a point Xi , then the Jacobian of the holonomy map h : γ1 → γ2 at X1 satisfies e−C(β+δ
1/3
)
≤ J h(X1 ) ≤ e−C(β+δ
1/3
)
(2.3)
where δ = |ξ(X1 , X2 )| is the length of the segment of ξ between X1 and X2 , and β is the angle between the tangent vectors to γ1 and γ2 at X1 and X2 , respectively. A little cruder estimate was proved in [7, Lemma 4.3], but a close examination of the proof shows that it in fact implies (2.3). Alternatively, one can prove (2.3) directly, as in [8, Theorem 5.42]. Given X, Y ∈ M, denote by s+ (X, Y ) ≥ 0 the future separation time (the first time when the images F n (X) and F n (Y ) for n ≥ 0 lie in different connected 1 The
book [8] is devoted to classical (unperturbed) billiards with smooth invariant measures, but many technical facts proven there hold in our case as well.
Vol. 9 (2008)
Sinai Billiards under Small External Forces II
95
components of the collision space M), and similarly let s− (X, Y ) ≥ 0 denote the past separation time (this definition takes into account that M is cut along the boundaries of the homogeneity strips, cf. [7, p. 223]). Observe that if X and Y lie on one unstable curve γ ⊂ M, then |γ(X, Y )| ≤ CΛ−s+ (X,Y ) , where Λ > 1 is the hyperbolicity constant for F , cf. [8, Eq. (5.32)]. Now (2.3) implies (see, e.g., [8, Proposition 5.48]) that for any X, Y ∈ γ1 | ln J h(X) − ln J h(Y )| ≤ Cϑs+ (X,Y ) ,
(2.4)
where ϑ = Λ−1/6 < 1. Following Young [32, p. 597], we call the property (2.4) the ‘dynamically defined H¨ older continuity’ of J h. Next we define a class of probability measures supported on unstable curves, following [8,10]. A standard pair = (γ, ν) is a homogeneous unstable curve γ ⊂ M with a probability measure P on it, whose density ρ (with respect to the Lebesgue measure on γ) satisfies | ln ρ(X) − ln ρ(Y )| ≤ Cr ϑs+ (X,Y ) .
(2.5)
Here Cr > 0 is a sufficiently large constant (independent of F). For any standard pair = (γ, ρ) and n ≥ 1 the image F n (γ) is a finite or countable union of homogeneous unstable curves (h-components) on which the density of the measure F n (P ) satisfies (2.5); hence the image of a standard pair under F n is a family of standard pairs (with a factor measure). More generally, a standard family is an arbitrary (countable or uncountable) collection G = {α } = {(γα , ρα )}, α ∈ A, of standard pairs with a probability factor measure λG on the index set A. Such a family induces a probability measure PG on the union ∪α γα (and thus on M) defined by PG (B) = Pα (B ∩ γα ) dλG (α) ∀B ⊂ M . Any standard family G is mapped by F n into another standard family Gn = F n (G), and PGn = F n (PG ). For every α ∈ A, any point X ∈ γα divides the curve γα into two pieces, and we denote by rG (X) the length of the shorter one. Now the quantity ZG = supε>0 ε−1 PG (rG < ε) reflects the ‘average’ size of curves γα in G; we only consider standard families with ZG < ∞. The growth lemma [7, Proposition 5.3] implies that ZGn ≤ C(θn ZG + 1) for all n ≥ 0 and some constant θ ∈ (0, 1), see a proof in [8, Proposition 7.17]; this estimate effectively asserts that standard families grow under F n exponentially fast. A standard pair (γ, ρ) is proper if |γ| ≥ δp , where δp > 0 is a small but fixed constant. A standard family G is proper if ZG ≤ Cp , where Cp is a large but fixed constant (chosen so that a family consisting of a single proper standard pair is proper, as a family). The image of a proper standard family under F n is proper for every n ≥ 1. A smooth foliation of M by (long enough) unstable curves gives us a proper standard family G such that PG = ν0 , the billiard invariant measure, see [8, p. 172].
96
N. Chernov
Ann. Henri Poincar´e
Also, there is a special standard family E consisting of (maximal) unstable hfibers γ u for the map F with the SRB densities ργ u on them and the factor measure generated by ν; in that case PE = ν, the family E is proper (due to [7, Proposition 5.6]) and obviously F -invariant. Next we present the key tool of the Young–Dolgopyat approach – the coupling lemma (for a detailed account see [8, Appendix A] and [8, Section 7.5]). Given a standard pair = (γ, ρ), we consider a ‘rectangle’ γˆ = γ × [0, 1] and equip it with ˆ with density a probability measure P ρˆ(X, t) = ρ(X) dX dt ;
(2.6)
the map F can be naturally defined on γˆ. Given a standard family G = (γα , ρα ) γα , ρˆα ) the family of the correspondwith a factor measure λG , we denote by Gˆ = (ˆ ˆ G the ing rectangles and equip it with the same factor measure λG ; we denote by P induced measure on the union ∪α γˆα . n
Lemma 2.1 (Coupling lemma). Let G = (γα , ρα ), α ∈ A, and F = (γβ , ρβ ), β ∈ B, be two proper standard families. Then there exist a bijection (called coupling map) ˆG ) = P ˆ E , and a (coupling time) Θ : ∪α γˆα → ∪β γˆβ that preserves measure; i.e., Θ(P function Υ : ∪α γˆα → N such that A. Let (X, t) ∈ γˆα , α ∈ A, and Θ(X, t) = (Y, s) ∈ γˆβ , β ∈ B. Denote m = Υ(X, t) ∈ N. Then the points F m (X) and F m (Y ) lie on the same stable h-fiber in M. B. There is a uniform exponential tail bound on the function Υ: ˆ G1 Υ > n ≤ CΥ ϑn , P (2.7) Υ for some constants CΥ > 0 and ϑΥ < 1 (independent of F, in the sense of Assumption B). A detailed (and lengthy) proof is given in [8, Chapter 7] for unperturbed Sinai billiards. It applies to our case with one little modification. While for unperturbed billiards the construction of the so called ‘magnet’ rectangle, see [8, Proposition 7.83], is relatively simple as it deals with one (billiard) map, in our case it requires a more elaborate argument, as we deal with a class of maps and need uniformity in F. In fact, an analogue of the ‘magnet rectangle’ (called rhombus) is constructed in [7, Lemma 6.5] and its necessary properties are proved in [7, Corollary 6.8]. The coupling lemma has many remarkable implications, some of them we state next. Motivated by (2.4), we say that a function f : M → R is dynamically H¨ older continuous if there are ϑf ∈ (0, 1) and Kf > 0 such that for any X and Y lying on one unstable curve s (X,Y )
|f (X) − f (Y )| ≤ Kf ϑf+
(2.8)
and for any X and Y lying on one stable curve s (X,Y )
|f (X) − f (Y )| ≤ Kf ϑf−
.
(2.9)
Vol. 9 (2008)
Sinai Billiards under Small External Forces II
97
We denote the space of such functions by H. It contains every piecewise H¨ older continuous function whose discontinuities coincide with those of F ±m for some m > 0. For example, the return time function τ (X) = min{t > 0 : Φt (X) ∈ M} belongs in H. Proposition 2.2 (Equidistribution). Let G be a proper standard family. For any dynamically H¨ older continuous function f ∈ H and n ≥ 0 n f ◦ F dPG − f dν ≤ Bf θfn (2.10) M
M
where Bf = 2CΥ (Kf + f ∞ ) and θf = [max{ϑΥ , ϑf }]1/2 < 1. In other words, iterations of measures on standard pairs converge to the SRB measure exponentially fast. For the proof, see [8, Theorem 7.31]. To estimate multiple correlations, let f0 , f1 , . . . , fr ∈ H and g0 , g1 , . . . , gk ∈ H be such that f ’s have identical parameters ϑf = ϑfi , Kf = Kfi , and f ∞ = fi ∞ for all 0 ≤ i ≤ r, and g’s have identical parameters ϑg = ϑgi , Kg = Kgi , and g∞ = gi ∞ for all 0 ≤ i ≤ k. Consider two products f˜ = f0 · (f1 ◦ F i−1 ) · (f2 ◦ F i−2 ) · · · (fr ◦ F i−r ) for some 0 > i−1 > · · · > i−r and g˜ = g0 · (g1 ◦ F i1 ) · (g2 ◦ F i2 ) · · · (gk ◦ F ik ) for some 0 < i1 < · · · < ik . We use a short-hand notation ν(f ) =
M
f dν.
Theorem 2.3 (Exponential bound on multiple correlations). For all n > 0 n ν f˜ · (˜ g ◦ F n ) − ν(f˜)ν(˜ g ) ≤ Bf˜,˜g θf,g (2.11) where
1/4 θf,g = max ϑΥ , ϑf , ϑg , α1 < 1,
α1 < 1 is a constant from [7, Corollary 5.4], and
Kf g∞ Kg f ∞ r k Bf˜,˜g = Cf ∞ g∞ + + f ∞ g∞ . 1 − ϑf 1 − ϑg For the proof, see [8, Theorem 7.41]. We remark that the theorem remains valid if fi ’s only satisfy (2.8) and gi ’s only satisfy (2.9). Not only the exponential bound (2.11) is novel and important itself, but the exact formulas for θf,g and Bf˜,˜g are essential in the proof of the central limit theorem and the almost sure invariance principle (ASIP), see [8, Sections 7.8–7.9]: Theorem 2.4 (Almost sure invariance principle). Let f ∈ H such that ν(f ) = 0 ,
σf2
=
∞ n=−∞
ν f · (f ◦ F n ) = 0
(2.12)
98
N. Chernov
Ann. Henri Poincar´e
Denote Sn = f + f ◦ F + · · · + f ◦ F n−1 and define a continuous function WN (s; X) of s ∈ [0, 1] by n S (X) n WN ;X = √ N σf N at rational points s = n/N and by linear interpolation in between. Then there is a standard Wiener process (a Brownian motion) B(s; X) on M with respect to the measure ν so that for some λ > 0 |WN (s; X) − B(s; X)| = O(N −λ )
(2.13)
for ν-almost all X ∈ M. Corollary 2.5 (Law of iterated logarithm). For ν-a.e. point X ∈ M lim sup Sn / 2nσf2 log log n = 1 . n→∞
For proofs, see [8, Sections 7.9]. We emphasize that all our constants are independent of F and the convergence is always uniform in F. We should note that our bound on the error term in (2.13) is not optimal; better bounds, e.g., O(N −1/4+ε ), can be obtained by using methods of recent works [14, 26]. A more general (vector) version of the ASIP can be derived based on the results of the manuscript [25] (not yet published). Since τ (X) is dynamically H¨older continuous, it satisfies the central limit √ theorem, i.e., (tn − nν(τ ))/ n converges to a normal distribution N (0, στ2 ); here tn = τ + τ ◦ F + · · · + τ ◦ F n−1 is the time of the nth collision. Actually, στ > 0 (this follows from the mixing property of the flow proved in the next section, as explained in [8, Remark 7.63]). Also, let nX (T ) denote the number of collisions on the trajectory Φt (X), √ 0 < t < T . Then T /nX (T ) → ν(τ ) for a.e. X ∈ M and (nX (T ) − T /ν(τ ))/ T converges to a normal distribution N (0, σ 2 ) with σ 2 = στ2 /[ν(τ )]3 ; for a proof, see [8, Sections 7.10]. Next we derive a formula specific to the case F = 0 (motivated by Kawasaki formulas in nonlinear response theory [31]). For any f ∈ H ν(f ) = lim ν0 (f ◦ F k ) n→∞
= ν0 (f ) + lim
n→∞
= ν0 (f ) + lim
n→∞
n k=1 n
ν0 (f ◦ F k ) − (f ◦ F k−1 ) ν0 (f ◦ F k )(1 − g) ,
(2.14)
k=1
where g = dF −1 ν0 /dν0 is the Jacobian of the map F with respect to the billiard invariant measure ν0 . A direct calculation gives
τ (X) p(X) exp g(X) = div Γ(X) dt p F (X) 0
Vol. 9 (2008)
Sinai Billiards under Small External Forces II
99
where Γ = p cos θ, p sin θ, ph is the vector field in Ω generating the flow Φt , cf. (1.4). Since ln p + phθ , div Γ = px cos θ + py sin θ + pθ h + phθ = d dt τ (X) we have g(X) = exp 0 phθ dt . Observe that g = 1 + O(δ0 ), where δ0 is a small constant in Assumption B. Also note that ν0 (g) = 1 and g(X) is a piecewise smooth function whose discontinuities coincide with those of the map F . Furthermore, ln g is dynamically H¨ older continuous with ϑln g = Λ−1/2 and Kln g = CpC 2 hC 2 being independent of F. We now use the special standard family E consisting of maximal unstable h-fibers γ u ⊂ M with SRB densities ργ u . The probability measure d˜ ν = g dν0 on M induces a conditional density ρ˜γ u on each γ u , which is proportional to gργ u , hence its logarithm is dynamically H¨ older continuous:
| ln ρ˜γ u (X) − ln ρ˜γ u (Y )| ≤ (Cr + Kln g ) ϑs+ (X,Y ) . for X, Y ∈ γ u . Of course, the density ρ˜γ u may not satisfy (2.5), but its images under F m will smooth out (due to distortion bounds [8, p. 203]) and then satisfy (2.5) for all m ≥ m0 , where m0 = m0 (pC 2 , hC 2 ). Thus, F m0 (˜ ν ) will coincide with PG for some proper G. Now standard family Proposition 2.2 implies that both ν0 (f ◦ F k ) and ν0 g · (f ◦ F k ) = ν˜(f ◦ F k ) converge to ν(f ) exponentially fast (and uniformly in F), thus the sum in (2.14) is bounded by a geometric series. This yields the desired Kawasaki formula: ν(f ) = ν0 (f ) +
∞
ν0 (f ◦ F k )(1 − g) ,
(2.15)
k=1
where the series converges exponentially fast and uniformly in F.
3. Bernoulli property of the flow Φt In this section we study the flow Φt : Ω → Ω. It is shown in [7] that Φt is a hyperbolic flow with uniform expansion and contraction rates. Its weakly unstable (and stable) manifolds are 2D surfaces in Ω that are made by families of strongly divergent (resp., convergent) flow lines. Strongly unstable and stable manifolds of the flow Φt are cross-sections (but not necessarily orthogonal!) of the corresponding families of flow lines. Clearly, Φt is a suspension flow over the base map F : M → M under a ceiling function τ . Strictly speaking, in a suspension flow the velocity must be equal to one, which can be achieved by changing the metric within Ω, but this change does not affect the existence or ergodicity of the SRB measure. Thus Theorem 1.1 easily implies the following: Corollary 3.1. The flow Φt : Ω → Ω admits a unique SRB measure μ, which is positive on open sets and ergodic.
100
N. Chernov
Ann. Henri Poincar´e
However, the mixing of the flow Φt requires a more elaborate argument. Loosely speaking, a hyperbolic flow is not mixing if its stable and unstable foliations are (locally) jointly integrable, i.e., for any phase point X ⊂ Ω all short chains consisting of alternating stable and unstable manifolds starting at X lie in a submanifold of codimension one transversal to the flow. For the billiard flow Φ0 , the lack of joint integrability was observed by Sinai [28], it is related to the opposite convexity of stable and unstable manifolds in Ω, see a detailed argument in [8, Section 6.11]. In our case, stable and unstable manifolds of the flow may not have opposite convexity, so we use a roundabout way to establish their nonintegrability. First we sharpen certain facts established in [7] for the map F . For any curve γ ⊂ M let mγ denote the Lebesgue measure on γ. For any point X ∈ M we denote by γ u (X) and γ s (X) the stable and unstable h-fibers through X. The point X divides the curve γ α (X), α = u, s, into two pieces, and we denote by rα (X) the length of the shorter one. Lemma 3.2. For every homogeneous unstable curve γ ⊂ M and mγ -almost every point X ∈ γ the stable h-fiber γ s (X) exists, i.e., rs (X) > 0. Moreover (3.1) mγ rs (X) < ε ≤ Cε for all ε > 0. The dual statement holds for stable curves. The existence of γ s (X) follows from two results of [7]: Eq. (6.4) and the Fact stated on p. 227. The estimate (3.1) is a local version of [7, Proposition 5.6], and for its proof see [8, Theorem 5.66]. Lemma 3.3. For every stable curve γ we have ν(∪X∈γ γ u (X)) > 0. For every unstable curve γ we have ν(∪X∈γ γ s (X)) > 0. Proof. The first statement follows from the proof of [7, Lemma 6.12]. Note that the second statement is not dual to the first one, since the SRB measure ν is not preserved under the reversal of time. The second statement follows from Lemma 3.2, the absolute continuity ([7, Lemma 4.3]), and the first statement here. Corollary 3.4 (Sinai’s fundamental theorem). Let X ∈ M and F n be continuous at X for all n > 0. Then for any ε > 0 and A > 0 there exists an open neighborhood U ⊂ M of X such that for any unstable curve γ ⊂ U mγ Y ∈ γ : rs (Y ) > A|γ| ≥ (1 − ε) |γ| . Similarly, if F n is continuous at X for all n < 0, then for any stable curve γ ⊂ U mγ Y ∈ γ : ru (Y ) > A|γ| ≥ (1 − ε) mγ |γ| . Observe that if A 1 is large, then a vast majority of points Y ∈ γ lie on stable (unstable) h-fibers which are much longer than the curve γ itself. This corollary follows from Lemma 3.2, see [8, Section 5.13]. We recall [7, p. 233] that given a stable h-fiber γ s and ε > 0 we denote by Γε (γ s ) the union of all stable h-fibers in M that are ε-close to γ s in the
Vol. 9 (2008)
Sinai Billiards under Small External Forces II
101
Hausdorff metric. We call γ s a density h-fiber if for every ε > 0 the set Γε (γ s ) has positive Lebesgue measure in M. (This is an analogue of Lebesgue density points of subsets of Rn .) The union of density h-fibers has full Lebesgue measure [7, Lemma 6.12]. Now we call γ s a ν-density h-fiber if for every ε > 0 the set Γε (γ s ) has positive ν-measure. Similarly, we define unstable ν-density h-fibers. Lemma 3.5. Every density h-fiber is also a ν-density h-fiber. Proof. For stable h-fibers, this follows from Lemmas 3.3 and the absolute continuity. The claim for unstable h-fibers can be proved by a construction similar to the proof of [7, Proposition 6.13]. Precisely, let γ u be a density h-fiber and ε > 0. Let γ be a stable curve crossing γ u . By reducing γ, if necessary, we can ensure that mγ (γ ∩ Γε (γ u )) > (1 − ε )mγ (γ), where ε > 0 is arbitrary small. Now we pull the entire structure back under F −n until we get mγ (γ(−n)) ≥ β˜2 mγ (γ) (here and below we use the notation of [7, Section 6]). The set F −n γ(−n) consists of stable curves that straddle the fixed rhombus R. Then it is not hard to deduce that the u set F n (RF ) ∩ Γε (γ u ) has a positive ν measure. We will only consider density h-fibers without saying that explicitly. Consider a continuous curve in M that is a finite union of segments of stable and unstable h-fibers (of course, stable and unstable h-fibers must alternate). Such curves are called Hopf chains or zigzag lines or us-paths (‘us’ stays for ‘unstablestable’). We require that at every “junction point” where two segments of h-fibers meet, those can be continued beyond the junction point. If a chain is not simple, i.e., has self-intersections, it can be shortened by the removal of extra loops, hence we will only consider simple chain. A chain is called a loop (or n-loop) if it is a simple closed curve in M (consisting of n segments of h-fibers). Chains and loops are instrumental in many proofs of ergodicity that go back to Hopf [16, 17]. Lemma 3.6 (“Zigzag lemma”). For every open connected set V ⊂ M and two curves γ1 , γ2 ⊂ V let distV (γ1 , γ2 ) denote the minimal length of smooth curves lying in V and connecting γ1 with γ2 . Then there is a zigzag line that starts on γ1 and ends on γ2 , lies entirely in V , and whose total length is ≤ C · distV (γ1 , γ2 ). This follows from Sinai’s fundamental theorem (Corollary 3.4), one just constructs a zigzag line starting at γ1 , moving in a general direction along a curve γ ⊂ V connecting γ1 with γ2 , whose length is nearly minimal, and eventually crossing γ2 ; a detailed construction of such zigzag lines is described in [8, Section 6.5]. Since stable and unstable h-fibers are uniformly transversal [7, Lemma 3.10], one can easily ensure the necessary bound on the length of the chain. Lemma 3.7. There is a global constant d0 = d0 (D) > 0 such that for every small force F there is a simple 4-loop (four is the minimal number of h-fibers in a loop), where all the h-fibers have length ≥ d0 . Proof. This follows from Corollary 3.4 and Lemma 3.5.
102
N. Chernov
Ann. Henri Poincar´e
We now turn to the flow Φt : Ω → Ω. Let X ∈ M and L ⊂ M a loop consisting of segments of h-fibers γ1 , . . . , γn , so that γi ∩ γi+1 = ∅ and γ1 ∩ γn = {X}. Consider Y = Φt X for some t ∈ (0, τ (X)). We now ‘lift’ the loop L from M to Ω in the following way: for each stable or unstable h-fiber γi let Γi be a stable (resp., unstable) manifold of the flow Φt that projects down onto γi and such that Γi ∩ Γi+1 = ∅ for i = 1, . . . , n − 1. (We assume that L is small enough so that the entire construction lies in the interior of Ω and avoids intersections with the boundary ∂Ω.) Now it is clear that ∪ni=1 Γi is a continuous curve in Ω starting at Y and terminating at some point Y lying on the trajectory Φt (Y ), i.e., Y = Φτ (L) (Y ) for some small τ (L). We call L a closed loop if τ (L) = 0 and an open loop otherwise. Clearly, reversing the orientation of L (i.e., traversing L in the opposite direction) simply changes the sign of τ (L). Given an orientation of L, one can easily verify that τ (L) does not depend on the choice of the initial point X ∈ L or t. In the billiard systems (where F = 0), all the loops are open, and in fact |τ (L)| equals the ν0 -measure of the domain bounded by L, see [8, Lemma 6.40]. Next we verify the existence of open loops for small forces. Lemma 3.8. For every ε > 0 there is a δ∗ = δ∗ (D, B0 , ε) > 0 such that whenever a force F satisfies Assumptions A–C with δ0 < δ∗ , then 1 − max p(x, y, θ)/ min p(x, y, θ) < ε , x,y,θ x,y,θ i.e., the function p(x, y, θ) is almost constant on Ω. Proof. Due to (1.5), p slowly changes along the trajectories of the flow, and due to (1.2) it does not change at collisions. Now the lemma follows from the uniform bound (1.8) on the derivatives of p, and the uniform bounds on correlations in Theorem 1.1. Lemma 3.9. For every ε > 0 there is a δ∗ = δ∗ (D, B0 , ε) > 0 such that whenever a force F satisfies Assumptions A–C with δ0 < δ∗ , then all the first order derivatives of the function p(x, y, θ) are less than ε. This lemma follows from Lemma 3.8 and the following elementary fact: Sublemma 3.10. Let Ω be a smooth compact manifold with boundary, f : Ω → R a C 2 function whose first and second order derivatives are uniformly bounded by a constant B0 . Then for every ε > 0 there is a δ = δ(Ω, B0 , ε) > 0 such that if |f (X) − f (Y )| < δ for all X, Y ∈ Ω, then all the first order derivatives of f are less than ε. The following lemma sharpens [7, Lemma 3.6]: Lemma 3.11. For every ε > 0 there is a δ∗ = δ∗ (D, B0 , ε) > 0 such that whenever a force F satisfies Assumptions A–C with δ0 < δ∗ , then for any strongly divergent family of trajectories on an interval (t0 , ∞) we have |αt | < ε for all t > t0 + c for some constant c > 0.
Vol. 9 (2008)
Sinai Billiards under Small External Forces II
103
Proof. The proof is a modification of that of Lemma 3.6 in [7]. The main difference is that now, in the equation (3.22), all the terms can be made arbitrarily small, except κ, which is still positive and bounded away from zero. Hence, the term −κ(α − pθ /p) drives α to zero whenever α is not small enough, and the other terms are not strong enough to stop this drive. We now recall the meaning of the function αt , see [7, p. 204]. Let Γu ⊂ Ω be an unstable manifold of the flow, then its trajectories {Φs (Y )}, Y ∈ Γu , s > 0, make a strongly divergent family. For every t > 0 the image Φt (Γu ) is an unstable manifold, too; its projection onto the table D is a curve that is a cross-section of the above family of flow lines. Now αt is the cotangent of the angle between that cross-section and the corresponding flow-line. If αt = 0, then the cross-section is orthogonal (and this is the case for unperturbed billiards); if αt is small, then the cross-section is almost orthogonal. The above lemma now implies that unstable manifolds of the perturbed flow Φt are good approximations to those of the billiard flow Φt0 . Due to the time reversibility, a similar property holds for stable manifolds. Now it takes a simple geometric argument to conclude the following: Corollary 3.12. Let L ⊂ M be a simple 4-loop from Lemma 3.7. If ε in Lemma 3.11 is small enough, we have τ (L) = 0, i.e., L is an open loop. Next we establish a general fact: Proposition 3.13. If there exists an open loop L ⊂ M, then the flow Φt is mixing and Bernoulli. Proof. For simplicity we assume that L is an open 4-loop (and one exists due to Corollary 3.12); it will be clear from our argument that it applies to arbitrary loops, too. The following lemma can be verified by direct inspection: Lemma 3.14. Let L1 , . . . , Lk ⊂ M be simple loops, oriented in the same way (say, all – clockwise), and bounding nonoverlapping domains V1 , . . . , Vk . Suppose that these domains are adjacent to each other so that V = V1 ∪ · · · ∪ Vk is a simply connected domain in M . Then V is bounded by a loop L and we have τ (L1 ) + · · · + τ (Lk ) = τ (L). Now, let γ1u , γ2s , γ3u , and γ4s denote the sides of the 4-loop L (which are alternating unstable and stable h-fibers). Let X1 and X2 denote the midpoints of γ1u and γ3u , respectively, and V the open ε-neighborhood of the straight line joining X1 with X2 , where ε dist(X1 , X2 ). Due to Lemma 3.6, there is a zigzag line L joining γ1u ∩ V with γ3u ∩ V , lying entirely in V , and having length |L | ≤ C · dist(X1 , X2 ). The zigzag line L divides the domain bounded by L into 2 subdomains, each bounded by a loop. Due to Lemma 3.14 one of these two loops is open, we denote it by L1 . It has four sides: two unstable sides (≈halves of γ1u and γ3u ) and two stable sides: one is γ2s or γ4s and the other is L (the latter is, of course, a zigzag line, but it stretches along a stable curve joining X1 and X2 , so we call it a stable side). Now
104
N. Chernov
Ann. Henri Poincar´e
we apply the same argument to construct a zigzag line joining the middle part of γ2s (or γ4s ) with the middle part of L and stretching along an unstable curve. This gives us two smaller loops, one of them will be open (again by Lemma 3.14), and we denote it by L2 . Now we repeat our construction inductively and obtain a sequence of open loops Ln , n ≥ 1, such that |Ln | → 0, hence τ (Ln ) → 0, as n → ∞ (but τ (Ln ) = 0 for every n). In other words, there are open loops with arbitrarily small values of τ (L)! Recall that all sides of our loops are density h-fibers, hence there are plenty of open loops with arbitrarily small τ values. More precisely, if we remove an arbitrary collection of h-fibers of the total ν-measure zero from M, then there still remain open loops with arbitrarily small (but non-zero) τ values. Next, it is known that, under general assumptions, a completely hyperbolic flow (which Φt is) with an ergodic SRB measure is either Bernoulli or Bernoulli times rotation. In the latter case a factor of the flow Φt is a circle rotation (and, of course, in this case the flow is not even mixing). Hence, the Bernoulli property is equivalent here to the mixing property. A general result of this sort was obtained by Ornstein and Weiss [27]. In the particular setting of certain perturbations of billiard flows, this fact was proved earlier by Kubo and Murata [21]. Assume now that the flow Φt is Bernoulli+rotation, i.e., there is a factor Ξ : Ω → S 1 so that Ξ ◦ Φt ◦ Ξ−1 is the rotation of the circle S 1 at constant speed. We call the sets Ξ−1 (p) ⊂ Ω, for p ∈ S 1 , layers. It is clear that μ-almost every stable or unstable manifold Γ ⊂ Ω lies in one layer; we call such stable and unstable manifolds typical. We call the projections of typical stable and unstable manifolds on M, along the trajectories of the flow, typical h-fibers; then ν-almost every h-fiber is typical. Let L ⊂ M be any loop consisting of typical h-fibers. Its ‘lift’ in Ω, as constructed above, will consist of typical stable and unstable manifolds of the flow Φt . Since every typical stable and unstable manifold lies in one layer, the entire lift of the loop L belongs in one layer, too. Hence, τ (L) is a multiple of the period of the rotation Ξ ◦ Φt ◦ Ξ−1 of S 1 . But we have seen that there are plenty of loops consisting of typical h-fibers with arbitrarily small non-zero τ values, thus the period of rotation must be zero. This proves Theorem 3.15. The flow Φt : Ω → Ω is mixing and Bernoulli. Lastly we present a central limit theorem for the flow Φt . Let F : Ω → R be a
τ (X) bounded function such that f (X) = 0 F (Φt X) dt is a dynamically H¨older continuous function on M (this holds, for example, when F is smooth with bounded derivatives). Note that F dμ = ν(f )/ν(τ ) . μ(F ) = Denote St (X) =
t 0
Ω
F (Φ X) dt for all t > 0 and X ∈ Ω. t
Vol. 9 (2008)
Sinai Billiards under Small External Forces II
105
Theorem 3.16√(Central limit theorem). There is σF ≥ 0 such that the function (St − μ(F ) t)/ t on Ω converges to a normal distribution N (0, σF2 ). This theorem follows from the central limit theorem for the map F applied to f and τ , see, e.g., [8, Theorem 7.68]. Note that we are not using the mixing property of the flow Φt . In fact, probabilistic limit theorems usually hold for suspension flows regardless of their mixing properties, as long as the base map is strongly chaotic, see, e.g., [13, 24].
t ˜ (t) = 0 p(s) ds denote the position of the moving particle As a corollary, let q
on the universal cover of the torus T2 . Then there exists a 2-vector a = Ω p dμ √ and a 2 × 2 positive definite matrix V such that (˜ q(t) − at)/ t converges to a twodimensional normal distribution N (0, V). The matrix V is close to the diffusion matrix of the unperturbed Sinai billiard, which is known to be non-singular [3], thus V cannot be singular either. In Theorem 3.16, σF2 = σf2 /ν(τ ), where σf2 is defined by the infinite series (2.12). If the flow Φt has rapidly decaying correlations, one usually can prove that ∞ 2 σF = μ (F ◦ Φt ) · F dt . (3.2) −∞
For the unperturbed billiard flow Φt0 , correlations decay at least as fast as a ‘stretched exponential’ function [9], which ensures (3.2) for that special case. But the results of [9] to dot extend to the perturbed flow Φt . By using a different approach, Melbourne [23] obtained fairly strong (‘superpolynomial’) bounds on correlations for rather general hyperbolic flows under the assumption that four periodic orbits exist whose periods satisfy a Diophantine-type condition, see (2.1) in [23]. This result implies rapid mixing, and therefore (3.2), for typical (in certain topological and measure-theoretic senses) flows Φt . It would be interesting to obtain bounds on correlations for all flows Φt covered in this paper.
Acknowledgements The author is grateful to I. Melbourne and the anonymous referee for very useful comments. The author is partially supported by NSF grant DMS-0354775.
References [1] P. R. Baldwin, Soft billiard systems, Physica D 29 (1988), 321–342. [2] F. Barra and T. Gilbert, Steady-state conduction in self-similar billiards, Phys. Rev. Lett. 98 (2007) paper 130601, 4 pp. [3] L. A. Bunimovich, Ya. G. Sinai, and N. I. Chernov, Statistical properties of twodimensional hyperbolic billiards, Russ. Math. Surv. 46 (1991), 47–106.
106
N. Chernov
Ann. Henri Poincar´e
[4] N. I. Chernov, G. L. Eyink, J. L. Lebowitz and Ya. G. Sinai, Steady-state electrical conduction in the periodic Lorentz gas, Comm. Math. Phys. 154 (1993), 569–601. [5] N. I. Chernov, G. L. Eyink, J. L. Lebowitz and Ya. G. Sinai, Derivation of Ohm’s law in a deterministic mechanical model, Phys. Rev. Lett. 70 (1993), 2209–2212. [6] N. Chernov, Decay of correlations and dispersing billiards, J. Stat. Phys. 94 (1999), 513–556. [7] N. Chernov, Sinai billiards under small external forces, Ann. H. Poincar´e 2 (2001), 197–236. [8] N. Chernov and R. Markarian, Chaotic Billiards, Mathematical Surveys and Monographs, 127, AMS, Providence, RI (2006), 316 pp. [9] N. Chernov, A stretched exponential bound on time correlations for billiard flows, J. Statist. Phys., 127 (2007), 21–50. [10] N. Chernov and D. Dolgopyat, Brownian Brownian Motion – I, Memoirs AMS, to appear. [11] N. Chernov and D. Dolgopyat, Particle’s drift in self-similar billiards, manuscript. [12] N. Chernov and D. Dolgopyat, Diffusive motion and recurrence on an idealized Galton Board, Phys. Rev. Lett. 99 (2007), 030601. [13] M. Denker and W. Philipp, Approximation by Brownian motion for Gibbs measures and flows under a function, Ergod. Th. Dynam. Syst. 4 (1984), 541–552. [14] M. Field, I. Melbourne, and A. T¨ or¨ ok, Decay of correlations, central limit theorems and approximation by Brownian motion for compact Lie group extensions, Ergod. Th. Dynam. Syst. 23 (2003), 87–110. [15] G. Gallavotti and D. S. Ornstein, Billiards and Bernoulli schemes, Comm. Math. Phys. 38 (1974), 83–101. [16] E. Hopf, Statistik der geodetischen Linien in Mannigfaltigkeiten negativer Kr¨ ummung, Ber. Verh. S¨ achs. Akad. Wiss. Leipzig 91 (1939), 261–304. [17] E. Hopf, Statistik der L¨ osungen geod¨ atischer Probleme vom unstabilen Typus, II, Math. Annalen 117 (1940), 590–608. [18] A. Knauf, Ergodic and topological properties of Coulombic periodic potentials, Commun. Math. Phys. 110 (1987), 89–112. [19] A. Kr´ amli, N. Sim´ anyi and D. Sz´ asz, Dispersing billiards without focal points on surfaces are ergodic, Commun. Math. Phys. 125 (1989), 439–457. [20] I. Kubo, Perturbed billiard systems, I., Nagoya Math. J. 61 (1976), 1–57. [21] I. Kubo and H. Murata, Perturbed billiard systems II, Berboulli properties, Nagoya Math. J. 81 (1981), 1–25. [22] C. Liverani, Interacting particles, In: Springer Encycl. Math. Sci. 101 (2000), 179– 216. [23] I. Melbourne, Rapid decay of correlations for nonuniformly hyperbolic flows, Trans. Amer. Math. Soc. 359 (2007), 2421–2441. [24] I. Melbourne and A. T¨ or¨ ok, Statistical limit theorems for suspension flows, Israel J. Math. 144 (2004) 191–209. [25] I. Melbourne and M. Nicol, A vector-valued almost sure invariance principle for hyperbolic dynamical systems, preprint.
Vol. 9 (2008)
Sinai Billiards under Small External Forces II
107
[26] N. Nagayama, Almost sure invariance principle for dynamical systems with stretched exponential mixing rates, Source: Hiroshima Math. J. 34 (2004), 371–411. [27] D. Ornstein and B. Weiss On the Bernoulli nature of systems with some hyperbolic structure, Ergod. Th. Dynam. Sys. 18 (1998), 441–456. [28] Ya. G. Sinai, Dynamical systems with elastic reflections. Ergodic properties of dispersing billiards, Russ. Math. Surv. 25 (1970), 137–189. [29] P. A. Vetier, Sinai billiard in potential field (construction of fibers), Coll. Math. Soc. J. Bolyai, 36 (1982), 1079–1146. [30] P. A. Vetier, Sinai billiard in potential field (absolute continuity), Proc. 3rd Pann. Symp. Math. Stat., 1983, 341–351. [31] T. Yamada and K. Kawasaki, Nonlinear effects in the shear viscosity of a critical mixture, Prog. Theor. Phys. 38 (1967), 1031–1051. [32] L.-S. Young, Statistical properties of dynamical systems with some hyperbolicity, Ann. Math. 147 (1998) 585–650. [33] L.-S. Young, Recurrence times and rates of mixing, Israel J. Math. 110 (1999), 153– 188. Nikolai Chernov Department of Mathematics University of Alabama at Birmingham Birmingham, AL 35294 USA e-mail:
[email protected] Communicated by Eduard Zehnder. Submitted: May 14, 2007. Accepted: September 14, 2007.
Ann. Henri Poincar´e 9 (2008), 109–130 c 2008 Birkh¨ auser Verlag Basel/Switzerland 1424-0637/010109-22, published online January 30, 2008 DOI 10.1007/s00023-007-0352-6
Annales Henri Poincar´ e
On the Volume of Nodal Sets for Eigenfunctions of the Laplacian on the Torus Ze´ev Rudnick and Igor Wigman Abstract. We study the volume of nodal sets for eigenfunctions of the Laplacian on the standard torus in two or more dimensions. We consider a sequence of eigenvalues 4π 2 E with growing multiplicity N → ∞, and compute the expectation and variance of the volume of the nodal set with respect to a Gaussian probability measure on√the eigenspaces. We show that the expected volume of the nodal set is √ const E. Our main result √ is that the variance of the volume normalized by E is bounded by O(1/ N ), so that the normalized volume has vanishing fluctuations as we increase the dimension of the eigenspace.
1. Introduction The nodal set of a function on a manifold is the set of points where it vanishes. Nodal sets for eigenfunctions of the Laplacian on a smooth, compact Riemannian manifold have been studied intensively for some time now. For instance, it is known [6] that except for a subset of lower dimension, the nodal sets of eigenfunctions are smooth manifolds of codimension one in the ambient manifold. In particular one can define their hypersurface volume (in two dimensions this is the length). A conjecture of Yau is that the volume of the nodal set is bounded above and below by constant multiples of square root of the Laplace eigenvalue. Yau’s conjecture was proven for real-analytic metrics by Donnelly and Fefferman [7]. The lower bound in the case of smooth surfaces is due to Br¨ uning [4], see also [5] for planar domains. In this paper we study the volume of nodal sets for eigenfunctions of the Laplacian on the standard flat torus Td = Rd /Zd , d ≥ 2. We write the eigenvalue equation as Δf = −4π 2 Ef , where E ≥ 0 is an integer. The eigenvalues on the torus always have multiplicities, with the dimension N = N (E) of an eigenspace Z. Rudnick was supported by the Israel Science Foundation (grant No. 925/06). I. Wigman was supported by CRM analysis laboratory fellowship.
110
Z. Rudnick and I. Wigman
Ann. Henri Poincar´e
corresponding to eigenvalue 4π 2 E being the number of integer vectors λ ∈ Zd so d that |λ|2 = E. In dimension d ≥ 5 this number grows as E → ∞ roughly as E 2 −1 , but for small values of d, particularly for d = 2, the behaviour is more erratic, and depends on the prime decomposition of E. We will consider random eigenfunctions on the torus, that is random linear combinations 1 bλ cos 2πλ, x − cλ sin 2πλ, x (1.1) f (x) = √ 2N λ∈Zd :|λ|2 =E with bλ , cλ ∼ N (0, 1) real Gaussians of zero mean and variance 1 which are independent save for the relations b−λ = bλ , c−λ = −cλ . Let E = EE be the eigenspace associated to the eigenvalue 4π 2 E (i.e., the space of functions of form (1.1)). We denote by E(•) the expected value of the quantity • in this ensemble. For instance, the expected amplitude of f is E(|f (x)|2 ) = 1. Denote by Z(f ) the volume of the nodal set of an eigenfunction (1.1). Our first result, Proposition 4.1, is that the expected value of Z is √ E(Z) = const · E for a certain constant depending only on the dimension d. This is of course consistent with the bounds of Donnelly and Fefferman [7]. √ Our main result, Theorem 6.1, is that the variance of the normalized volume Z/ E is bounded by Z 1 Var √
√ , as N → ∞ . E N (We believe that the correct upper bound for the variance is O(1/N )). Thus the √ value die out as the multiplicity N fluctuations of Z(f )/ E around its mean √ tends to ∞. Note however that Z(f )/ E is not asymptotically constant; for ind stance, if E = dm2 then for the eigenfunction f (x) = j=1 sin 2πmxj we have √ √ Z(f )/ E =√2 d while if E = m2 then for the eigenfunction f (x) = sin 2πmx1 we have Z(f )/ E = 2. Theorem 6.1 can be viewed as lending support to the expectation1 that for eigenfunctions on negatively curved manifolds, which are believed to behave similarly to random waves [2], the volumes of nodal sets, normalized by the square-root of the eigenvalue, do tend to a limiting value. See [12] for some work on the complexified nodal set of eigenfunctions in this context. Previous work in this vein is due to B´erard [1], who computed the expected surface measure of the nodal set for eigenfunctions of the Laplacian on spheres. Neuheisel [10] also worked on the sphere and gave an upper bound for the variance. Berry [3] computed the expected length of nodal lines for isotropic, monochromatic 1 We
thank Steve Zelditch for a discussion of this.
Vol. 9 (2008)
Volume of Nodal Sets
111
random waves in the plane, which are eigenfunctions of the Laplacian with eigenvalue E. He found that the expected length (per unit area) is again of size about √ E and argued that the variance should be of order log E. More recently, F. Oravecz and ourselves have investigated a different characteristic of the nodal set of eigenfunctions on the torus, namely the Leray nodal measure [11], and have succeeded in obtaining the precise asymptotics of the variance of the Leray measure as N → ∞. 1.1. Plan of the paper We employ a version of the Kac–Rice formula for the volume of the nodal set, which using the Dirac delta function can be written as δ f (x) |∇f (x)|dx , Z(f ) = Td
see Section 3 for the rigorous version. To compute the expected value of Z is then a simple matter once we find that f (x) and ∂f /∂xj are independent Gaussians. This is done in Section 4. In Section 5 we derive a formula for the second moment of Z, which requires knowing the covariance structure of the 2d + 2-dimensional Gaussian vector v(x, y) = (f (x), f (y), ∇f (x), ∇f (y)). That v(x, y) is indeed a nondegenerate 2d + 2 dimensional Gaussian is verified in the appendix. As a result, we find that E(Z 2 ) = Td K(z)dz, with exp − 12 vΩ(z)−1 v T 1 dv
K(z) =
v1 v2 , d+1 2 (2π) 2d 1 − u(z) R det Ω(z) where u(z) = E(f (x)f (x+z)) is the two-point function of the ensemble, and where Ω(z) is a certain positive definite 2d × 2d matrix which enters into the covariance structure of the Gaussian vector v(x, y). In Section 6, which is the heart of the paper, we bound the variance of Z.
2. The model: Random eigenfunctions on the torus 2.1. Random eigenfunctions We consider non-constant eigenfunctions of the Laplacian on the standard flat torus Td = Rd /Zd . The solutions of the eigenvalue equation Δψ + 4π 2 Eψ = 0 ,
E = 0 ,
form a finite dimensional vector space E = EE , having as a basis the exponentials e2πiλ,x , for λ in the frequency set Λ = ΛE = {λ ∈ Zd , |λ|2 = E} . We define an ensemble of Gaussian random functions f ∈ E by 1 bλ cos 2πλ, x − cλ sin 2πλ, x f (x) = √ 2N λ∈Λ
112
Z. Rudnick and I. Wigman
Ann. Henri Poincar´e
with bλ , cλ ∼ N (0, 1) real Gaussians of zero mean and variance 1 which are independent save for the relations b−λ = bλ , c−λ = −cλ . Thus we can rewrite 2 f (x) = bλ cos 2πλ, x − cλ sin 2πλ, x (2.1) N λ∈Λ/±
where now only independent random variables appear. With our normalization, we have E(|f (x)|2 ) = 1 for all x ∈ Td . Definition 2.1. An eigenfunction f ∈ E is singular if ∃x ∈ Td with f (x) = 0 and ∇f (x) = 0. An eigenfunction f ∈ E is nonsingular if ∇f = 0 on the nodal set. Lemma 2.2 ([11], Lemma 2.3). The set of singular eigenfunctions has codimension at least 1 in E, and so has measure zero in E. 2.2. Properties of the frequency set The dimension N = dim E is the number of the frequencies in Λ, which is the number of ways of expressing E as a sum of d integer squares. For d ≥ 5 this grows roughly as E d/2−1 as E → ∞. For d ≤ 4 the dimension of the eigenspace need not grow with E. For instance, for d = 2, N is given in terms of the prime β decomposition of E as follows: If E = 2α j pj j k qk2γk where pj ≡ 1 mod 4 and qk ≡ 3 mod 4 are odd primes, α, βj , γk ≥ are integers, then N = 4 j (βj + 1), and otherwise E is not a sum of two squares and N = 0. √ On average (over integers which are sums of two squares) the dimension is const · log E. The frequency set Λ is invariant under the group Wd of signed permutations, consisting of coordinate permutations and sign-change of any coordinate, e.g., (λ1 , λ2 ) → (−λ1 , λ2 ) (for d = 2). In particular Λ is symmetric under λ → −λ and since 0 ∈ / Λ, we find N is even. We write Λ/± to denote representatives of the equivalence class of Λ under λ → −λ. We will need some simple properties of Λ: Lemma 2.3. For any subset O ⊂ Λ which is invariant under the group Wd , we have E 1 · δj,k . λj λk = (2.2) |O| d λ∈O
Moreover for any C ∈ R , d
1 E C, λ2 = |C|2 . |O| d
(2.3)
λ∈O
Proof. For i = j use the symmetry of O under the sign change of the i-th coordinate to change variables and deduce that the LHS of (2.2) vanishes. For i = j
Vol. 9 (2008)
Volume of Nodal Sets
113
note that the sum λ∈O λ2i is independent of i since O is symmetric under permutations; hence we may average the RHS over i to find that λ∈O
λ2i =
d 1 2 1 |O|E , λi = ||λ||2 = d i=1 d d λ∈O
λ∈O
proving (2.2). To prove (2.3) we expand C, λ2 =
d
j,k=1 cj ck λj λk
and use (2.2).
Note that (2.3) implies that the frequency set Λ spans Rd . 2.3. The two point function The two-point function of the ensemble is 2 u(z) := E f (x + z)f (x) = N
cos 2πλ, z .
(2.4)
λ∈Λ/±
The two-point function clearly satisfies |u(z)| ≤ 1. We will need to know some of its basic properties, proved in [11], which we summarize as: Proposition 2.4. The two point function satisfies 1. 2. 3. 4.
There are only finitely many x ∈ Td where u(x) = ±1. points 2 The mean square of u is Td u = 1/N . The mean fourth power of u is bounded by2 Td u4 1/N . √ The kernel 1/ 1 − u2 is integrable on Td .
Part 1 follows from [11, Lemma 2.2], part 3 is [11, Proposition 7.1], and part 4 is [11, Lemma 5.3].
3. A formula for the volume of the nodal set Let χ be the indicator function of the interval [−1, 1]. We define for > 0 f (x) 1 Z (f ) := χ |∇f (x)|dx . 2 Td Lemma 3.1. Suppose that f ∈ E is non-singular. Then vol f −1 (0) = lim Z (f ) . →0
Proof. By the co-area formula [8], for f smooth and φ integrable, we have ∞ φ(x)|∇f (x)|dx = φ(x)dx ds . Td 2 Except
−∞
f −1 (s)
possibly in dimensions d = 3, 4 we have a better bound in [11] of o(1/N ), though we have no use for this finer information in this paper.
114
Z. Rudnick and I. Wigman
Taking φ(x) :=
Ann. Henri Poincar´e
f (x) 1 2 χ( ),
which is constant on the level sets f −1 (s) gives 1 Z (f ) = vol f −1 (s) ds . 2 −
Now if f is non-singular then s → vol(f −1 (s)) is continuous at s = 0 and so by the fundamental theorem of calculus, 1 lim vol f −1 (s) ds = vol f −1 (0) . →0 2 − Thus lim→0 Z (f ) = vol(f −1 (0)) as claimed.
Lemma 3.2. For all f ∈ E we have
√ Z (f ) ≤ 6d E .
We begin with the one variable case which we state as a separate lemma (cf. [9, Lemma 2]): Lemma 3.3. Let g(t) be a trigonometric polynomial of degree at most M . Then for all > 0 we have 1 |g (t)|dt ≤ 6M . 2 {t:|g(t)|≤} Proof. We partition the set {t : |g(t)| ≤ } ⊆ [0, 1] into a union of maximal closed intervals [ak , bk ] (with ak < bk ), disjoint except perhaps for common edges, such that on each such interval g has constant sign, that is either g ≥ 0 or g ≤ 0. If g ≥ 0 on [ak , bk ] then either g(ak ) = − or g (ak ) = 0 and ak is a local minimum for g, and g(bk ) ≤ + . If g ≤ 0 on [ak , bk ] then either g(ak ) = + or g (ak ) = 0 and ak is a local maximum for g, and g(bk ) ≥ − . If g ≥ 0 on [ak , bk ] then bk bk |g (t)|dt = g (t)dt = g(bk ) − g(ak ) ≤ 2 , ak
ak
while if g ≤ 0 on [ak , bk ] then bk |g (t)|dt = ak
bk
−g (t)dt = g(ak ) − g(bk ) ≤ 2 .
ak
Thus the total integral is bounded by the number ν of intervals [ak , bk ]: 1 |g (t)|dt ≤ ν . 2 {t:|g(t)|≤} Now the number of intervals is bounded by the number of a’s for which g(a) = ± plus the number of a’s for which g (a) = 0. Since both g and g are trigonometric polynomials of degree ≤ M , the number of such intervals is therefore 3·2M = 6M . This gives the required bound. We now prove Lemma 3.2 by reduction to the one-dimensional case.
Vol. 9 (2008)
Proof. Since |∇f | ≤
Volume of Nodal Sets
d
∂f j=1 | ∂xj |
115
we have
d f (x) ∂f 1 χ Z (f ) ≤ ∂xj dx 2 Td j=1 and we will bound each term. Taking j = 1, we have
∂f (t, y) 1 f (x) ∂f 1 dt dy . χ ∂x1 dx = 2 Td 2 {t∈T1 :|f (t, y)|≤} ∂t y∈Td−1 d−1 In the inner integral we have a one variable polynomial g(t) = √ for each y ∈ T f (t, y) √ of degree at most E and hence by Lemma 3.3, the inner integral is at most 6 E. Summing over j introduces another factor of d.
As a consequence of the fact that for nonsingular functions we can compute the volume Z(f ) of the nodal set of f ∈ E via Lemma 3.1 and the fact that almost all f ∈ E are nonsingular (Lemma 2.2), we find: Corollary 3.4. The first and second moments of the volume Z(f ) of the nodal set of f are given by lim Z1 Z2 . E(Z) = E lim Z , E(Z 2 ) = E 1 ,2 →0
→0
4. The expected volume of the nodal set In this section we show Proposition 4.1. For d ≥ 1,
√ E(Z) = Id E
where
Id =
4π Γ d+1 d2 . d Γ 2
Proof. Since Z is uniformly bounded by Lemma 3.2, we can use the Dominated Convergence Theorem to write E(Z) = E lim Z = lim E(Z ) . →0
By Fubini’s theorem,
→0
1 f (x) χ E(Z ) = E |∇f (x)|dx 2 Td f (x) 1 χ = E K (x)dx . |∇f (x)| dx =: 2 Td Td
116
Z. Rudnick and I. Wigman
Ann. Henri Poincar´e
1 Now for each x ∈ Td , the function f → 2 χ( f (x) )|∇f (x)| is bounded and hence we may evaluate the integral by using the joint probability density of the variable (f (x), ∇f (x)), whose components are Gaussian of zero mean with covariance ∂f 2 (x) = 0 E f (x) = 1 , E f (x) ∂xj
and
E
∂f (x) ∂f (x) ∂xj ∂xk
=
E 2 · 4π 2 λj λk = 4π 2 · δj,k N d
(4.1)
λ∈Λ/±
by (2.2). Thus 1 K (x) = 2
χ R
a
e
b|2 db d| |b| exp − 2 8π E (2π)d/2 (4π 2 E/d)d/2 Rd a 2 1 2 1 e−a /2 da . |v | exp − |v | dv χ 2 2 d R R
−a2 /2
√ 4π 2 E =√ d · (2π)(d+1)/2
da √ 2π
Integrating over Td and taking the limit → 0 gives √ E(Z) = Id E where
1 |v | exp − |v |2 dv . 2 Rd 2 In the one-dimensional case, I1 = R |v|e−v /2 dv = 2. For d ≥ 2 , ∞ 2 1 |v | exp − |v |2 dv = vol(S d−1 ) re−r /2 rd−1 dr . 2 0 Rd 1 Id = √ d(2π)(d−1)/2
Using d
vol(S d−1 ) = gives
2π 2 , Γ d2
∞
rd e−r
2
/2
dr = 2
d−1 2
Γ
0
d+1 2
d+1 √ 1 2 d/2 Γ 2 |v | exp − |v | dv = 2(2π) 2 Γ d2 Rd
(which is consistent with the computation for d = 1). Thus 4π Γ d+1 2 Id = d Γ d2 as claimed.
Vol. 9 (2008)
Volume of Nodal Sets
117
5. An integral formula for the second moment 5.1. The covariance matrix The covariance matrix Σ(x, y) of the Gaussian vector (f (x), f (y), ∇f (x), ∇f (y)) is given by A B (5.1) Σ= BT C where E (f(x)f (y)) E(f (x)∇f (x)) E(f (x)∇f (y)) E f (x)2 , B = A= E (f (y)f (x)) E f (y)2 E(f (y)∇f (x)) E(f (y)∇f (y)) E(∇f (x)T ∇f (x)) E(∇f (x)T ∇f (y)) C= . E(∇f (y)T ∇f (x)) E(∇f (y)T ∇f (y)) For generic (x, y), the covariance matrix Σ(x, y) is nonsingular (see Appendix A).
and
Lemma 5.1. The covariance matrix Σ(x, y) depends only on the difference z = x−y and is given in terms of the two-point function u by A(z) B(z) Σ(x, y) = B(z)T C(z) where
A(z) =
1 u(z) , u(z) 1
(here 0,∇u are row vectors), and
C(z) = where H =
∂2u ∂xj ∂xk
B(z) =
0 −∇u(z) 0 ∇u(z)
−H(z) 2 −H(z) 4πd E I 4π 2 E d I
is the Hessian of u.
Proof. By definition of the two point function, we have A = pute B, use
E
and hence In particular
1 u
∂f ∂ (x)f (y) = E f (x)f (y) = ∂j u(x − y) ∂xj ∂xj
E f (x)∂j f (y) = ∂j u(y − x) = −∂j u(x − y) . E f (x)∇f (x) = 0 .
Therefore
B(z) =
0 −∇u(z) 0 ∇u(z)
(where 0 denotes the d-dimensional zero row vector).
u . To com1
118
Z. Rudnick and I. Wigman
Ann. Henri Poincar´e
To compute C, use (4.1) to find 4π 2 E Id . E ∇f (x)T ∇f (x) = d More generally E ∂j f (x)∂k f (y) = and so
∂2 ∂2u E f (x)f (y) = − (x − y) ∂xj ∂yk ∂xj ∂xk
E ∇f (x)T ∇f (y) = −
Thus C=
∂2u (x − y) = −H(x − y) . ∂xj ∂xk j,k 4π 2 E d I
−H
−H
4π 2 E d I
as claimed. The inverse of Σ (when it exists) is given by ∗ ∗ Σ−1 = ∗ Ω−1 with Ω being the 2d × 2d matrix Ω = C − B T A−1 B . We will call Ω the reduced covariance matrix. We have det Σ = det A det Ω = (1 − u2 ) det Ω . By Lemma 5.1, we have 2 T 1 4π (E/d)I D D −H Ω= − −H 4π 2 (E/d)I 1 − u2 uDT D
(5.2) uDT D DT D
(5.3)
2
∂ u where D(z) = ∇u(z) and H = ( ∂x ) is the Hessian of u. j xk
5.2. A formula for the second moment Proposition 5.2. The second moment of Z(f ) is given by E(Z 2 ) = K(x)dx
(5.4)
Td
where 1 K(x) = √ 1 − u2 Denote K1 ,2 (x, y) :=
1 4 1 2
We have the following
R2d
exp − 21 vΩ−1 v T dv √ v1 v2 . (2π)d+1 det Ω
E
∇f (x) ∇f (y) χ
f (y) f (x) χ dμ(f ) . 1 2
(5.5)
Vol. 9 (2008)
Volume of Nodal Sets
119
Lemma 5.3. For (x, y) ∈ Td × Td with u(x − y)2 = 1 E , K1 , 2 (x, y) d
1 − u2 (x − y)
(5.6)
where the implied constant depends only on the dimension d. Proof. Write f (x) = f, U (x), where U (x) is the unit vector √ 2 cos 2πλ, x, sin 2πλ, x λ∈Λ/± ∈ S N −1 , U (x) = √ N and where we identify the function f with a vector in RN via (2.1). Note that U (x), U (y) = u(x − y) is the cosine of the angle between U (x) and U (y). We have ∇f (x) = DU · f where the derivative DU is a d × N matrix. Equivalently, ∂ U (x) , 1 ≤ i ≤ d. ∇f (x) i = f, ∂xi By the triangle and Cauchy–Schwartz inequalities, d √ ∂ E f , f · U (x) ∇f (x) ≤ ∂xi i=1 by a computation of
∂U ∂xi .
Therefore
E K1 ,2 (x, y)
4 1 2
|f (x)|<1 |f (y)|<2
2
f 2 e− f
/2
df .
(5.7)
Consider the plane π ⊂ RN spanned by U (x) and U (y). The domain of the integration is all the vectors f ∈ RN so that the projection of f on π falls into the parallelogram P of lengths 2 1 and 2 2 . The cosine of the angle between the sides of P is U (x), U (y) = u(x − y). Therefore the area of P is 1 . area(P ) = 4 1 2
1 − u(x − y)2 Write the multiple integral in (5.7) as the iterated integral 2 − f 2 /2 f e df dp , P
(5.8)
p+π ⊥
where the variable p runs over all the points of the parallelepiped P . The inner integral in (5.8) is O(1) with the constant depending on d only. Indeed, note that for every f1 ∈ π ⊥ , p + f1 2 e− p+f1
2
/2
2
= ( p 2 + f1 2 )e−( p
(1 + f1 2 ) · e− f1
2
+ f1 2 )/2
/2
,
120
Z. Rudnick and I. Wigman
Ann. Henri Poincar´e
2
since p 2 e− p /2 is bounded. Our claim follows from convergence of the integral 2 (1 + w 2 )e− w /2 dw. Therefore RN −2 2 1 f 2 e− f /2 df area(P ) 1 2
. |f (x)|<1 2 1 − u(x − y) |f (y)|< 2
Substituting the last estimate into (5.7) proves (5.6). Proof of Proposition 5.2. By Corollary 3.4, we have E(Z 2 ) = lim E
1 1 ,2 →0 2 1
Td
∇f (x) χ
f (x) 1
1 dx 2 2
Td
∇f (y) χ
f (y) 2
dy dμ(f )
2
where μ is the Gaussian measure dμ(f ) = e− f /2 (2π)dfN /2 . We wish to change the order of the limit and the integration. To do so, we notice that by Lemma 3.2, the integrand is bounded by O(E). Therefore, the change of order follows from the dominated convergence theorem. Thus the integral equals f (x) f (y) 1 lim ∇f (x) ∇f (y) χ χ dxdydμ(f ) . 1 ,2 →0 4 1 2 E (Td )2 1 2 Using Fubini’s theorem, this equals to f (x) f (y) 1 lim ∇f (x) ∇f (y) χ χ dμ(f )dxdy . 1 ,2 →0 4 1 2 (Td )2 E 1 2
(5.9)
Now we wish to exchange the order of taking limit and the integration over (Td )2 . To justify it, we use the dominated convergence theorem with Lemma 5.3. The upper bound for u(x) = ±u(y) is sufficient, since this happens for almost all (x, y) ∈ (Td )2 , and changing the values of a function on a set of measure 0 does not have any impact on the integrability and the value of the integral of a function. The convergence of the RHS of (5.6) was shown in [11]. Therefore, we may exchange the order of the limit and the integral in (5.9) to obtain 2 K(x, y)dxdy, (5.10) E(Z ) = Td ×Td
where K(x, y) =
lim K1 ,2 (x, y) .
1 ,2 →0
We will replace the vector (f (x), f (y), ∇f (x), ∇f (y)) with a 2d + 2 dimensional Gaussian vector with covariance matrix Σ(x, y) = Σ(x − y) defined in (5.1). The proof that for almost all x, y this is indeed a 2d + 2 dimensional process, is
Vol. 9 (2008)
Volume of Nodal Sets
121
relegated to Proposition A.1 in the appendix. This gives K1 ,2 (x, y) −1 T w1 w2 1 dvdw = v1 v2 χ χ e−(v, w)Σ (v, w) /2 √ 4 1 2 R2d+2 1 2 det Σ(2π)d+1 1 2 −1 T dvdw 1 = v1 v2 e−(v, w)Σ (v, w) /2 √ . (5.11) 4 1 2 −1 −2 R2d det Σ(2π)d+1 We therefore have K(x, y) =
1 1 ,2 →0 4 1 2
1
2
lim
−1
−2
R2d
−1
v1 v2 e−(v, w)Σ
(v, w)T /2
√
dvdw . det Σ(2π)d+1
Since the last integrand is continuous, we may use the fundamental theorem of the calculus to replace the averaging over w1 , w2 by the value at w1 = w2 = 0, to obtain dvdw −1 T v1 v2 e−(v, 0)Σ (v, 0) /2 √ . K(x, y) = det Σ(2π)d+1 R2d We have ∗ ∗ −1 Σ = ∗ Ω−1 with Ω = C − B T A−1 B being the reduced covariance matrix, which we computed in (5.3). Together with (5.2) we find exp − 12 vΩ−1 v T dv 1 √ |v1 ||v2 | . K(x, y) = √ d+1 2 (2π) 2d 1−u R det Ω Finally, we get Proposition 5.2 by noticing that K(x, y) = K(x − y), and therefore the (double) integral in (5.10) may be expressed as a single integral. In the course of the proof we saw that K(x, y) = lim1 ,2 →0 K1 ,2 (x) . Therefore, taking the limit 1 , 2 → 0 and using Lemma 5.3 we obtain Corollary 5.4. If u(x)2 = 1 then E . K(x)
1 − u(x)2
6. A bound for the variance In this section we prove: Theorem 6.1. For d ≥ 2,
E √ Var(Z) = O . N
122
Z. Rudnick and I. Wigman
Ann. Henri Poincar´e
6.1. Plan of the proof 2 We use the integral formula (5.4) for the second moment of Z(f ), that is E(Z ) = Td K(z)dz, with exp − 12 vΩ−1 v T 1 dv √ K(z) = √ v1 v2 . 2 (2π)d+1 1 − u R2d det Ω
As√in [11], we will define a notion of “singular points” in Td where the factor 1/ 1 − u2 is large, and treat separately the singular and nonsingular points. The singular set is√shown to give a contribution of O(E/N ). On the nonsingular set, the factor 1/ 1 − u2 may, up to an admissible error, safely be replaced by 1. To treat the Gaussian integral, we write Ω(z) =
4π 2 E I − S(z) d
and recover the square of the expected value E(Z)2 from the contribution of the identity matrix I; the rest is then the key quantity for bounding the variance. Setting
that that variance is bounded σ(z) to be the spectral norm of S(z), we show by E( Td σ(z)dz + O(1/N )). Now σ(z) is at most tr(S(z)2 ), whose integral we need to bound. We do this by using √ Cauchy–Schwartz, which allows us to√bound it by ( Td tr(S(z)2 )dz)1/2 1/ N . Hence the variance is Var(Z) E/ N . It should be possible to improve this to O(E/N ). 6.2. The singular set We give the definition of [11] for singular points: Definition 6.2. A point x ∈ Td is a positive singular point if there is a set of 1 x| frequencies Λx ⊂ Λ with density |Λ |Λ| > 1 − 4d for which cos 2πλ, x > 3/4 for all λ ∈ Λx . Similarly we define a negative singular point to be a point x where there ˜ x ⊂ Λ of density > 1 − 1 for which cos 2πλ, x < −3/4 for all λ ∈ Λ ˜ x. is a set Λ 4d √ Let M ≈ E be a large integer. We decompose the torus Td = Rd /Zd as a disjoint union (with boundary overlaps) of M d closed cubes I k of side length 1/M centered at k/M , k ∈ Zd . Definition 6.3. A cube I k is a positive (resp. negative) singular cube if it contains a positive (resp. negative) singular point. Definition 6.4. The singular set B is the union of all singular cubes. In [11], we showed that the measure of the singular set is bounded by 1 (6.1) meas(B)
u(x)4 dx
N Td (and except in dimensions d = 3, 4 this is o(1/N )).
Vol. 9 (2008)
Volume of Nodal Sets
123
In order to bound the contribution of the singular set to the integral in (5.4), we use Corollary 5.4. It was shown in [11] (see (6.3)) that dx 1
. (6.2)
u(x)4 dx
2 N 1 − u(x) B Td Therefore we obtain: Corollary 6.5. The contribution of the singular set is bounded by E . K(x)dx