An Historical Study of Athenian Verse Epitaphs from the Sixth through the Fourth Centuries BC
by
Julia Lougovaya
A thesis submitted in conformity with the requirements for the degree of Ph.D. Graduate Department of Classics University of Toronto
©by Julia Lougovaya (2004)
Reproduced with permission of the copyright owner. Further reproduction prohibited without permission.
1+1
Library and Archives Canada
Bibliotheque et Archives Canada
Published Heritage Branch
Direction du Patrimoine de !'edition
395 Wellington Street Ottawa ON K1A ON4 Canada
395, rue Wellington Ottawa ON K1A ON4 Canada Your file Votre reference ISBN: 978-0-494-22057-3 Our file Notre reference ISBN: 978-0-494-22057-3
NOTICE: The author has granted a nonexclusive license allowing Library and Archives Canada to reproduce, publish, archive, preserve, conserve, communicate to the public by telecommunication or on the Internet, loan, distribute and sell theses worldwide, for commercial or noncommercial purposes, in microform, paper, electronic and/or any other formats.
AVIS: L'auteur a accorde une licence non exclusive permettant a la Bibliotheque et Archives Canada de reproduire, publier, archiver, sauvegarder, conserver, transmettre au public par telecommunication ou par !'Internet, preter, distribuer et vendre des theses partout dans le monde, a des fins commerciales ou autres, sur support microforme, papier, electronique et/ou autres formats.
The author retains copyright ownership and moral rights in this thesis. Neither the thesis nor substantial extracts from it may be printed or otherwise reproduced without the author's permission.
L'auteur conserve la propriete du droit d'auteur et des droits moraux qui protege cette these. Ni la these ni des extraits substantiels de celle-ci ne doivent etre imprimes ou autrement reproduits sans son autorisation.
In compliance with the Canadian Privacy Act some supporting forms may have been removed from this thesis.
Conformement a la loi canadienne sur la protection de la vie privee, quelques formulaires secondaires ant ete enleves de cette these.
While these forms may be included in the document page count, their removal does not represent any loss of content from the thesis.
Bien que ces formulaires aient inclus dans la pagination, il n'y aura aucun contenu manquant.
•••
Canada Reproduced with permission of the copyright owner. Further reproduction prohibited without permission.
An Historical Study of Athenian Verse Epitaphs from the Sixth through the Fourth Centuries BC Ph.D. 2004 Julia Lougovaya Department of Classical Studies University of Toronto
ABSTRACT This dissertation explores the social and historical significance of Attic verse epitaphs from their appearance in the second quarter of the sixth century to the late fourth century. By examining verse epitaphs in context (both archeological and literary), the thesis assesses the way in which various strata of society commemorated the dead; it thereby permits acquaintance with a wider range of people than found in literary sources. The material under investigation consists primarily of verse epitaphs edited by P.A. Hansen in Carmina Epigraphica Graeca, with the addition of a few recent discoveries. Since this dissertation
considers the archeological context of inscriptions, including the appearance of the inscription, type and location of the monument, etc., it also makes extensive use of archeological data. Chapter One is a study of archaic Attic verse epitaphs. During this period, the practice was confined to the elite, whether Athenians or foreign residents in Athens, and inscribing verse on a funerary monument was one of the features of elite display at a burial site. The tradition ceased around 500 BC when this type of display, which was associated with elite families during the reign of the Athenian tyrants, was either forbidden or deemed inappropriate following the liberation from tyranny and the reforms of Kleisthenes. Chapter Two investigates fifth century Athenian public verse inscriptions. It argues that during a period of at least fifty years (from the reforms of Kleisthenes to at least the mid 460s or even later) the Athenians did not inscribe public funerary monuments with verse epitaphs. Instead, there developed a special genre of inscriptional verse which I call public commemorative or celebratory epigrams. At some point in the mid fifth century the practice
ii
Reproduced with permission of the copyright owner. Further reproduction prohibited without permission.
ABSTRACT
of inscribing verse epitaphs resumed in Athens, in commemoration of those who were granted the honor of public burial by the Athenians. Chapter Three opens with discussion of the reappearance of private grave monuments inscribed with verse epitaphs, and then analyzes verse epitaphs of the later classical period, often in comparison with and contrast to the archaic tradition.
iii
Reproduced with permission of the copyright owner. Further reproduction prohibited without permission.
ACKNOWLEDGMENTS
The completion of this thesis was made both possible and enjoyable by the help of many people. My dissertation committee comprised outstanding scholars of various fields who were always ready to share their expertise, Emmet Robbins and Jonathan Burgess in early Greek poetry, and John Traill in the thorny field of Greek epigraphy. Joseph Day's critical comments were very helpful at the final stage of the project. Above all, my supervisor, Malcolm Wallace, contributed to all aspects of my thesis, and has been a most helpful teacher and colleague. My ideas have not always been shared by members of my committee, and I take full responsibility for the views expressed in this study, as well as for any mistakes. I owe many thanks to the Department of Classics at the University of Toronto for providing scholarly and material support during my time as a graduate student, and to Ann-Marie Matti and Coral Gavrilovic for their kind assistance in all practical matters associated with my work at the Department, which was often conducted long-distance. My indefinite gratitude goes to my family for their unflagging support, especially to my father, Michael Bronstein, who helped me in all computer matters, my husband, Rodney Ast, who discussed and read my study, offered numerous insightful comments, and helped in every possible way, to our younger daughters, Alitsia and Aglaia, the source of constant joy, and to our older daughter, Marfa, without whose resourcefulness I would never have been able even to start this work.
iv
Reproduced with permission of the copyright owner. Further reproduction prohibited without permission.
LIST OF TABLES AND FIGURES
Table 1. Archaic Attic Epitaphs, p. 223. Figure 1. Outline of the stele ofMnasitheios from Akraiphia, p. 57. (After Andreiomenou 2000, p. 85, fig. 1. Drawing by R. Posamentir. Courtesy ofR. Posamentir.) Figure 2. Upper part of the stele of Mnasitheios with reconstructed finial, p. 59. (After Andreiomenou 2000, p. 89, fig. 4. Drawing by R. Posamentir. Courtesy ofR. Posamentir.) Figure 3. Drawing of the gravestone and epitaph for Philon, CEG 76, p. 80. (After Kourouniotes 1897, col. 151, fig. 5.) Figure 4. Drawing of the gravestone and epitaph for Pleistias, CEG 77, p. 81. (After Kourouniotes 1897, col. 152, fig. 6.) Figure 5. Periboloi in Section A of the Kerameikos, p. 159. (After Garland 1982, p. 137, fig. 2. Reproduced with permission of the British School at Athens.) Figure 6. Peribolos of Koroibos of Melite (A 20), p. 160. (After Brueckner 1909, p. 105, fig. 66.) Figure 7. Peribolos ofDionysios ofKollytos (A3), CEG 593, p. 161. (After Brueckner 1909, p. 66, fig. 37.)
V
Reproduced with permission of the copyright owner. Further reproduction prohibited without permission.
ABBREVIATIONS
CAT = Chr. Clairmont, Classical Attic Tombstones, Kilchberg 1993--. CEG = Carmina epigraphica Graeca Carmina epigraphica Graeca: saeculorum VIII-V a.Chr.n., P.A. Hansen, ed., Berlin and New York 1983. Carmina epigraphica Graeca: saeculi IV a. Chr. n. (CEG 2), P.A. Hansen, ed., Berlin and New York 1989. DAA = A. E. Raubitschek, Dedications from the Athenian Akropolis; a catalogue of the inscriptions of the sixth and fifth centuries B. C., Archaeological Institute of America 1949. FGE
=
Further Greek Epigrams: Epigrams before A.D. 50 from the Greek Anthology and Other Sources not included in 'Hellenistic Epigrams' or 'The Garland of Philip ', D. L. Page, ed., rev. and prepared for publication by R. D. Dawe and J. Diggle, Cambridge 1981.
IEG2 = M. L. West, Iambi et Elegi Graeci ante Alexandrum Cantati, 2nd ed., Oxford 1998. IGAA = L. H. Jeffery, "The Inscribed Gravestones of Archaic Attica," BSA 57, 1962, pp. 115-153. IGLPalermo = M. T. Manni Piraino, Iscrizioni greche lapidarie del Museo di Palermo, "SIKELIKA. Collana di monografie pubblicate dal Centra Siciliano di Studi Storico-Archeologici 'Biagio Pace', Serie Storica," 6. Palermo 1973. LGPN =Lexicon of Greek Personal Names LGPN I: Aegean Islands, Cyprus, Cyrenaica, P. M. Fraser and E. Matthews, eds., Oxford 1987. LGPN II: Attica, M. J. Osbome and S. B. Byrne, eds., Oxford 1994. LGPN III.A: Peloponnese, Western Greece, Sicily, and Magna Graecia, P. M. Fraser and E. Matthews, eds., Oxford 1997. LGPN III.B: Central Greece: From the Megarid to Thessaly, P. M. Fraser and E. Matthews, eds., Oxford 2000. LSAG = L. H. Jeffery, The Local Scripts of Archaic Greece, ed. rev. with a supplement by A. W. Johnston, Oxford 1990. ML
R. Meiggs and D. M. Lewis, A Selection of Greek Historical Inscriptions to the End of the Fifth Century, Oxford 1969.
vi
Reproduced with permission of the copyright owner. Further reproduction prohibited without permission.
TABLE OF CONTENTS
ii
ABSTRACT ACKNOWLEDGMENTS
IV
LIST OF TABLES AND FIGURES
V
ABBREVIATIONS
VI
vii
TABLE OF CONTENTS
1
INTRODUCTION CHAPTER ONE. ARCHAIC ATTIC VERSE EPITAPHS
10
1. Early Archaic Burial Practice to ea. 600 BC
10
Prior to ea 600 BC, 10. Changes ea. 600 BC, 12. Solon's Funerary Legislation, 14.
2. Archaic Attic Verse Epitaphs in Context
15
Typology of Monuments Associated with Verse Epitaphs, 15. Display and Layout of Archaic Attic Verse Epitaphs, 17. Verse vs Prose, 18.
3. Commemorated Deceased
18
Death in War, 19. Virtues of the Deceased, 22. Origin of the Deceased, 26. Untimely Death, 29. Other Expressions of Grief, 37.
38
4. ChiefMourner Identity of the ChiefMoumer, 38. Grief of the ChiefMoumer, 44.
5. Address to a Passer-by and Reflections
45
6. Monument
47
Sight of the Monument, 47. Sculptors' Signatures on Monuments with Verse Epitaphs, 48.
60
7. Meter and Literary Context Meters Employed in Archaic Attic Epitaphs, 60. Metrical Anomalies, 62. Excluded Inscriptions, 63. Literary Elegy and Verse Epitaph, 66. The Meaning of Elegos, 67. Inscriptional Evidence for Threnodic Elegy, 69. Literary Elegy and Verse Epitaph, Revisited, 72.
8. Disappearance of Verse Epitaphs in Attica ea. 500 BC
74
Post-Solonian Funerary Legislation, 74. After the Disappearance: Athenians and Athenians(?) Outside Attica, 80.
vii
Reproduced with permission of the copyright owner. Further reproduction prohibited without permission.
TABLE OF CONTENTS
CHAPTER TWO. PUBLIC VERSE EPITAPHS AND COMMEMORATIVE EPIGRAMS Introduction
84 84
1. Literary Evidence to 479 BC
85
Chalkis, ea. 507-501 BC, 85. Marathon 490 BC, 87. Artemisium and Salamis, 91. Plataia, 91.
2. Inscriptional Evidence to 480/479 BC
92
IG 13 1142 (1}, 92. The Persian Wars Epigrams, IG 13 503/504 (2 and 3), 93.
3. Public Commemorative Epigrams: Features and Further Examples
104
The Tyrannicides Epigram (430), 105. The Eion Epigrams, 105. The Eurymedon Epigram, 107.
4. Evidence for the Burial of the War Dead in Athens
112
5. Patrios Nomos
113
6. Public Verse Epitaphs
125
Bringing Ta 6cna Home or Burying on the Battlefield: (a) Individual Burials, (b) Collective Burial, 114. Burying the War Dead Publicly (Bru.lOoic;x}, 117. Prothesis and Ekphora, 119. Epitaphios Logos, 120. Patrios Nomos Reconsidered, 121. Evidence from Pausanias and Plato, 122. The Epitaph for Argive Casualties (135), 125. Epitaphs for Distinguished Foreign Individuals (11, 12, 469), 126. The Epitaph for Athenians who Fell at the Hellespont (6), 129. The Koroneia Epitaph (5), 131. Fragmentary Verse Epitaphs of the mid Fifth Century, 134. The Potidaia Epitaph, 134. An Epitaph for Athenian Cavalrymen (4}, 136. A New Epitaph for Athenian Cavalrymen, 138. Public Epitaphs in the Late Fifth Century, 143.
CHAPTER THREE. ATTIC VERSE EPITAPHS OF THE LATER CLASSICAL PERIOD Introduction
144 144
1. Reappearance of Private Athenian Verse Epitaphs
145
Private Verse Epitaphs in the Fifth Century, 145. Date and Causes of the Reappearance ofPrivate Athenian Verse Epitaphs, 149.
2. Later Classical Attic Verse Epitaphs in Context
157
Periboloi, 157. Typology of Classical Grave Stelai, 158. Display and Layout of Verse Epitaphs, 15 8. Verse Epitaphs Associated with Large Periboloi, 159. Members of Propertied Families, 165.
3. Commemorated Deceased
168
Death in War, 168. Virtues of the Deceased, 171. Origin of the Deceased, 174. Activities of the Deceased: (a) Soothsaying and Priesthood, (b) Medicine, (c) Theater and Music, (d) Craftsmanship, (e) Occupations of Foreigners, 175. Untimely Death and Death in Old Age, 198. Grievous Fate, 200. viii
Reproduced with permission of the copyright owner. Further reproduction prohibited without permission.
TABLE OF CONTENTS
4. ChiefMoumer
200
5. Addresses and Reflections
203
6. Monument
205
7. Peculiarities of Poetic Diction and Meter
205
The Bridal Chamber of Persephone, 205. Gods and Personifications, 207. Meter, 208.
CONCLUSION
209
BIBLIOGRAPHY
212
TABLE
223
ix
Reproduced with permission of the copyright owner. Further reproduction prohibited without permission.
INTRODUCTION
1. Verse Epitaphs as a Subject of Social History The purpose of a funerary monument is both to mark a burial site and to perpetuate the memory of the deceased. In Homer, the place of burial is a physical entity, generally marked in some way, and the memory of the deceased lives on not in written memorials but in songs and legends. Earthen mounds over the graves of heroes tell unwritten tales about those buried beneath them, as we fmd in the Iliad where, before engaging in a duel, Hector imagines his opponent's death and the tomb that will be a source of stories for future generations and will perpetuate the memory of a fallen hero of the Trojan War: crfi~a
Te oi xevwmv enlnAaTei 'EAAT)CJTIOVTCt>. Kai lTOTE TIS eilTlJOI Kat 0\I'IYOVUJV av8pt:Jnwv VTJt lTOAVKAi)YSt lTAEUJV eni oivona lTOVTOV" avSp6s ~ev TObE on~a lTciAat KaTaTe8VT)WTOS, OV lTOT' aptCJTEVOVTa KaTEKTaVE <paiSt~OS "EKTWp. (7.86-91) ... and so that they might heap a mound over him by the wide Hellespont. And someone will say, even one of those not yet born, as he sails on a many-benched ship over the wine-colored sea: "This is the tomb of the man who died long ago, whom glorious Hektor once killed as he was doing deeds ofvalor."
Elsewhere in the Iliad grave mounds serve as landmarks, as, for example, in the case of Ilos' tomb, which is conspicuously situated before the walls of Troy (e.g.,
It. 11.166). In
the Odyssey, Elpenor bids Odysseus to bum his corpse, bury the ashes, heap up a mound and place his oar on top of it, so that future people may learn
(eooo~evotot
nv8eo8at) his
story (Od. 11. 74-78). Legends are likely to have been attached to such markers, which served as a sign, the significance of which was transmitted in songs about the heroes. With the appearance of writing in the eighth century or so, Greeks began to inscribe grave markers, uniting the physical object and spoken word. Writing on the grave marker was meant, first of all, to identify the grave; it indicated possession, much as other kinds of early inscriptions designated the property of gods or men. 1 Simply to identify the marker as funerary and to associate it with a particular individual, a word such as
on~a
or CJTTJATJ
and the name of the deceased would have sufficed. But virtually from the beginning of the tradition of sepulchral inscriptions, we find in Greece something more elaborate than simple 1
LSAG, pp. 61-62; Scodell992, p. 58.
Reproduced with permission of the copyright owner. Further reproduction prohibited without permission.
INTRODUCTION
2
labels. Some epitaphs aimed already then at the preservation of the memory of the deceased through narration of circumstances surrounding the death and burial of the commemorated person, through bestowal of praise, references to the burier, and descriptions of the monument. Mere labeling of the grave was generally the purview of short prose records, while the conveyance of a brief account intended to perpetuate the deceased's memory appears to have been possible exclusively in verse. Interestingly, both prose and verse epitaphs existed concurrently, and early verse epitaphs do not show any sign of having derived from prose records. From the moment that they first appeared, verse epitaphs represented an effort on the part of survivors to keep the memory of the deceased alive, and this effort does not seem to have been considered the result of some religious obligation to the dead, nor was it because of some practical concern about marking the grave with a record that would simply identify it. Verse epitaphs were rather a social gesture through which the burier sought to capture the attention of the reader and perpetuate the memory of the deceased. The claim on memory made in a verse epitaph was a status claim and it was exercised only by a fraction of the society. The circle of people constituting this fraction was, however, wider than the elite ofwhom we are generally informed by our other, mainly literary, sources, and analysis of epitaphs allows one to investigate how this wider circle of people wanted to represent the deceased (and living) members of their families. Verse epitaphs can be expected to follow certain patterns, primarily because their subject matter is limited to the purpose of sepulchral inscription (identification of the burial and commemoration of the deceased) and because they are designed to be consumed by a fairly wide circle of literate people (and thus to conform to these people's expectations). At the same time, an epitaph, when considered along with the monument and burial complex, is unique in belonging to a certain burial and is meant to be memorable. The room between normative requirements and originality or individualization in verse epitaphs is very narrow, but the ways in which both the normative requirements and individualization are carried out reflect broad social norms and demonstrate what was deemed by certain circles of people at certain periods of time to be especially praiseworthy or grievous, and thus worthy of being committed to what was perceived as eternal memory. This study of verse epitaphs therefore aims to be a contribution to Greek social history.
Reproduced with permission of the copyright owner. Further reproduction prohibited without permission.
INTRODUCTION
3
2. State of Scholarship and Objectives
The employment of verse in documenting a burial constitutes a status claim, but the content of these claims may vary by time and place and can involve various social strata. I confine my study of Greek sepulchral epigrams to Attic verse epitaphs from the earliest attestation to the reign of Demetrios of Phaleron in 317-307 BC, when the practice of inscribing them significantly decreased, and I intend to investigate how and by whom these status claims were made at different points within this period. In doing this, I hope to identify some of the tastes and norms of people who are often omitted from literary sources. To gain further insight into these tastes and norms, I have chosen also to examine the inscriptions in their archeological context, since verse epitaphs do not exist in isolation, but are incised on grave monuments and constitute part of the larger display at a burial site. The study of funerary inscriptions as part of the monuments on which they appear was pioneered by L. H. Jeffery, whose article "The Inscribed Gravestones of Archaic Attica" (IGAA) remains indispensable for any investigation of archaic Attic funerary inscriptions.2
Christoph Clairmont' s examination of the correlation between verse epitaphs and funerary reliefs represents a rare attempt to consider both the physical appearance of the monument and the text of the epitaph. 3 There are also several general studies, both literary and archeological, that do not deal specifically with verse epitaphs but help situate them in their historical context. The excellent introduction to Greek burial practices by Donna Kurtz and John Boardman surveys different types of burials and the development of funerary monuments from the Bronze Age through the Hellenistic period.4 Robert Garland's The Greek Way ofDeath briefly covers the general topic of what the Greeks did with their deadfrom attitudes about death to ceremonies surrounding interment of the body-and provides valuable references to the most relevant ancient literary sources. 5 Ian Morris' recent work, Death-Ritual and Social Structure in Classical Antiquity, looks at the social structure of ancient society through evidence provided by archeology, suggesting how, for example, archeological fmds from a given cemetery can contribute to our knowledge of a particular 2
Although Jeffery was not concerned with verse epitaphs in particular, many of the gravestones that she discusses actually carry verse epitaphs (simply because, as we will see, there are more verse epitaphs extant from archaic Attica than prose). 3 Clairmont 1970. Although Clairmont's approach is potentially useful, the study is handicapped by the isolated treatment of the monuments under investigation from the broader tradition of inscriptional verse epitaphs. 4 Kurtz and Boardman 1971. 5 Garland 1985.
Reproduced with permission of the copyright owner. Further reproduction prohibited without permission.
4
INTRODUCTION
society and its beliefs about death. 6 In addition to these general studies, there has also been more specialized work done on Greek sculptured funerary monuments by archeologists and art historians like Hans Diepolder, Friis Johansen, Gisela Richter, and Christoph Clairmont. 7 The general topic of Greek epigrams has been widely studied, too, with recent interest particularly in the epigrams of the Hellenistic period, 8 Simonides and the Simonidea, 9 the origin of elegy, 10 and even in the interaction between the written word and its reader, or the "anthropology of reading." 11 Of the scholarship that deals more specifically with sepulchral verse inscriptions, Joseph Day's investigation of how people of the archaic period might have perceived a funerary monument inscribed with an epigram is a good example of a study that fruitfully combines both the archeological and literary approaches. 12 Ute Ecker' s work is valuable for its identification of literary parallels to archaic Greek epitaphs/ 3 while Christian Breuer' s book provides interesting discussion of the representation of values in funerary reliefs and epigrams in the fourth through the second centuries BC. 14 In addition to these contributions, there are of course collections of inscribed verses,
which often include valuable notes or commentaries.
Peter A. Hansen's Carmina
Epigraphica Graeca ( CEG) provides the most reliable texts of sepulchral inscriptions, which are accompanied by brief bibliographies and notes, and it therefore serves as a very good basis for the study of Greek epitaphs. 15 Among older collections, the most relevant for my work have proven to be Georg Kaibel's Epigrammata Graeca ex lapidibus collecta and Epigrammata by FriedHi.nder and Hoffleit, in which the editors, through lucid translations and thoughtful commentaries, clearly show how they have understood each text. 16
6 Morris 1992a. Although the book investigates primarily early Greek material and treats at some length funerary monuments of the archaic and classical periods, the chapter on epitaphs (pp. 156-173) deals exclusively with late Latin funerary inscriptions. 7 Diepolder 1931; Johansen 1951; Richter 1960, 1961 and 1968; Clairmont 1970, and CAT, which is a monumental work that deserves the gratitude of scholars, despite its numerous infelicities. 8 Kathryn Gutzwiller's influential book which investigates the Hellenistic epigram in its broader historical context was published in 1998; in 2000 the Department of Greek and Latin at the University of Groningen conducted a workshop on the Hellenistic epigram, the proceedings of which appeared two years later (Harder et al. 2002); for the past few years the University ofLeiden has been supporting and updating a web site with an extensive bibliography on Greek epigrams (http://www.gltc.leidenuniv.nl/). 9 E.g., Molyneux 1992, Ceccarelli 1996, Boedeker and Sider 2001. 10 Bowie 1986 and 1990, Lewis 1987, Cassio 1994. 11 Svenbro 1993, Sourvinou-lnwood 1996. 12 Day 1989. 13 Ecker 1990. 14 Breuer 1995. 15 Although Hansen does not provide archeological information, he usually refers to the relevant publications. 16 It is noteworthy that Merkelbach and Stauber's new collection of inscriptional verses from Asia Minor (1998--) perhaps best resembles the collection ofFriendlander and Hoffleit.
Reproduced with permission of the copyright owner. Further reproduction prohibited without permission.
INTRODUCTION
5
3. Chronological Divisions
My study of Attic verse epitaphs is divided chronologically into three parts which correspond to three chapters. In Chapter One I treat the period from the earliest attested Attic sepulchral inscription in the second quarter of the sixth century to the cessation of the practice of inscribing verse epitaphs in Attica ea. 500. During this period verse epitaphs were associated with monuments of grandeur, and the tradition of inscribing them was practiced by elite Athenian families. In Chapter Two I concentrate on the fifth century, a period which exhibits some interesting developments: no Athenian verse epitaph is attested from ea. 500 to the mid fifth century, but during this time there emerges a special genre of commemorative epigrams, unassociated with either funerary or dedicatory monuments, which celebrates the achievements, primarily military, of the Athenian state; by the middle of the fifth century the tradition of inscribing verse epitaphs is seen to resume, but these inscriptions are initially restricted to public monuments set up by the Athenian state to honor those who fell at war and who were honored with public burials. In Chapter Three I examine later classical developments, concentrating on the period from the end of the Sicilian disaster, when the practice of inscribing private grave markers with epitaphs resumed in Athens, to the legislation of Demetrios of Phaleron between 317 and 307 BC. 4. Categories of Analysis of Private Verse Epitaphs
The material covered in Chapters One and Three permits similar treatment, and I have therefore divided the two chapters into similar categories. This arrangement will, I hope, highlight similarities and differences between the archaic period, when the practice of inscribing verse epitaphs was engaged in by elite families at Athens, and the later classical period, when families of various social strata opted for verse epitaphs. I also hope to illustrate some of the reasons for the appearance and disappearance of the practice in Athens, which when viewed against the background of the rest of Greece is a remarkable phenomenon: during the sixth and fourth centuries the tradition of inscribing verse epitaphs was nowhere as widespread as at Athens, yet no other state seems to have abstained from this practice to the degree that the Athenians did during the major part of the fifth century. The pattern exhibited at Athens can be interpreted only through better understanding of what commemoration with verse signified at various times, how it was carried out and what circles of people would practice it. In order to assist this understanding my analysis of Chapters One and Three has been framed by the following categories:
Reproduced with permission of the copyright owner. Further reproduction prohibited without permission.
INTRODUCTION
6
Appearance and Reappearance of Verse Epitaphs. I investigate the concomitant social and historical factors that preceded and accompanied the appearance (in the sixth century) and reappearance (at the end of the fifth century) of the tradition of inscribing verse epitaphs. Context. I discuss the locations and typology of grave monuments associated with verse epitaphs, the principles of display of an inscription, its legibility and other aspects of architectural epigraphy. The grandeur of monuments in the archaic period points to the class of people that could afford them; in the later classical period, however, the correlation between the grandeur of a monument and the status of the family that commissioned it is more ambiguous, since a simple stele with a verse epitaph could be set up over the grave of a member of a propertied family. Despite this ambiguity, I offer a methodology that to some extent identifies features of the kinds of verse epitaphs that were commissioned by affluent families in the later classical period and, by identifying these features, helps to define what was normative for those with few financial constraints who could presumably afford whatever was considered finest. Commemorated Deceased. Verse epitaphs generally praise and lament the deceased, as well as include some biographical information that was deemed especially memorable, such as the deceased's origin, age, occupation, or cause of death.
While death on the
battlefield is always praised and death at a young age is always lamented, other patterns in the expressions of grief and praise and in the characterization of the deceased change over time and reflect changes in the circles of people who inscribed verse epitaphs, as well as changes in what people perceived to be most memorable and appropriate for a gravestone. Chief Mourner. From a legal point of view, the heir or kyrios ofthe deceased was generally responsible for funerary arrangements, as well as for setting up the funerary monument. From a practical standpoint, however, several members of the family could participate, as well as individuals outside the family, such as friends or compatriots. References to these people in verse epitaphs would enhance the social aspect of commemoration, since the epitaph might mention the grief of people who had neither legal nor practical involvement in actually setting up the monument. I call those who are said to mourn the deceased the chief mourners. In the archaic period, epitaphs usually identify the person who was responsible for the monument, and parents by far outnumber other relations as chief
Reproduced with permission of the copyright owner. Further reproduction prohibited without permission.
INTRODUCTION
7
mourners. In the later classical period, Athenian verse epitaphs often mention various relations of the deceased but avoid singling out the person responsible for the burial, rather speaking of those who have been left behind to grieve the loss of the deceased. Address to the Passer-by and Reflections. Monuments and verse epitaphs were generally designed to be seen and read not only by the family but by any literate passer-by. The epitaphs, especially archaic, would directly address the passer-by and ask him to lament the deceased, sometimes supplying a reason for the request. Reflections and gnomic expressions were perhaps also meant to emphasize the universality of the message on the gravestone. In the later classical period, the address to the passer-by became rare, while the address to the deceased was widespread and seems to have been one way of creating a more private atmosphere in the implicit dialogue between the reader and the deceased. Monument. Verse epitaphs identify the object on which they are incised, and not surprisingly they usually include such pointers as T68e
crfi~-ta,
or
~-tVfi~-ta,
or demonstratives such as
ev86:8e or Tij8e, among others. Archaic epitaphs more often draw attention to the monument (T68e
crfi~-ta,
or
~-tVfi~-ta):
"this is the monument of so-and-so," "so-and-so set up this
monument for so-and-so," etc., while later classical epitaphs mention the burial site in relation to the deceased and employ the demonstratives ev8a8e or Tijbe, "so-and-so lies here," "the earth here covers the body of so-and-so," etc. The monument can sometimes be described as beautiful, especially in archaic verse epitaphs, and archaic grave markers are sometimes signed by sculptors, which is never the case in the later classical period. Meter and Poetic Diction. Here I discuss the literary quality of the epitaphs, which can vary from outstanding to barely an awareness of formal metrical conventions. It becomes clear, for example, that in the archaic period those who chose to have a verse epitaph inscribed could ensure that it complied with the requirements of content, diction, and meter; when there are serious flaws in the "meter" of an archaic epitaph, I believe that the inscription was not intended to be verse. The situation is very different in the later classical period, when we have epitaphs which the composers clearly intended as verse, but failed to execute as such. Departures from the formal requirements of literary poetry reflect, in my view, the incompetence of the composer and not conscious literary experimentation. The fact that
Reproduced with permission of the copyright owner. Further reproduction prohibited without permission.
INTRODUCTION
8
"higher" genres of poetry did influence verse epitaphs will become clear, and, in Chapter One, I attempt to analyze the relation between literary elegy and elegiac epitaphs. 5. Public Epitaphs and Commemorative Epigrams in the Fifth Century
Chapter Two of my thesis investigates Athenian public verse inscriptions. In it, I suggest that the practice of inscribing private verse epitaphs in archaic Athens was so firmly associated with elite families during the time of the Peisistratids that after liberation from tyranny and the reforms of Kleisthenes it was either forbidden or simply considered inappropriate. I hope to demonstrate, moreover, that the practice was not simply transferred from the realm of private to public commemoration, but was entirely avoided for approximately half a century.
During that period there developed a specific genre
of commemorative monuments with epigrams that celebrated the achievements of the Athenian state, or its best representatives, but that were neither dedicatory nor funerary. In addition to this, I investigate in this chapter the tradition of public burial of the war dead and the emergence in the mid fifth century of verse epitaphs honoring those who received public funerals; from here I proceed to discuss in some detail extant public verse epitaphs. 6. Material
The main body of material under study here are the verse epitaphs found in the two volumes of CEG; unless otherwise indicated, I reproduce the texts of CEG (the numbers of which are printed in bold), with the omission of Hansen's metrical signs in the lacunae, which I render simply with dashes.
The dates are also those of CEG unless
specified otherwise. Texts which are not in CEG (mainly prose epitaphs or verse epitaphs that were made public after the publication of the collection) will be referred to by their IG or SEG numbers. In my study of public Athenian epigrams from the fifth century, I
also include a few texts that survive only in the literary tradition, primarily in the Simonidea. These texts are cited as Simonidea (Simon.) in accordance with Denys Page's Further Greek Epigrams (FGE). Translations of verse epitaphs are mine; for other sources,
translations are mine unless specified otherwise. My criteria for considering an inscription to be an Athenian verse epitaph are, for the archaic material, more rigorous than those of CEG. I include only those epitaphs about which we can be fairly certain that they were metrical (whereas Hansen appears to include
Reproduced with permission of the copyright owner. Further reproduction prohibited without permission.
INTRODUCTION
9
all texts that might have been metrical). 17 For fourth century epitaphs, I follow Hansen's corpus, without the addition of any new categories. My policy may seem to be somewhat of a double standard and is explained by the difference in nature of archaic verse inscriptions from those of the later classical period. In the former period, verse epitaphs consistently comply with certain formal requirements of content, diction and meter, and those which fail to do so are most likely not to have been intended as metrical. In the latter period, there is a fair number of epitaphs that are clearly intended as verse but have numerous metrical flaws or anomalies (such as the employment of a single pentameter). The intention to produce a verse epitaph is revealed in some cases only by the employment of certain words and expressions that are generally characteristic of verse epitaphs, while the rest of the epitaph may not conform at all to elementary metrical norms. Whereas CEG is the primary source for the inscriptions, information on the physical appearance of a monument and the layout of an inscription is drawn either from IG or from publications of individual texts. Where possible, I also try to refer to reproductions of monuments in the recent Catalogue of Attic Tombstones by Clairmont, as well as to those in other editions. I give measurements for most of the archaic stones, because with them the dimensions are often important for understanding the type and grandeur of the monument. For the later classical material, however, I describe the type of monument where possible, but offer fewer details about physical features. The reason for the different approach to the two periods is that in the later classical period we encounter a higher number, greater variety and more complicated typology of monuments; a survey of the material is therefore more effective than detailed analysis. For the fifth century, I provide some description of and archeological information about better preserved monuments (as in the case of the socalled Metro Stele), but generally avoid going into detail about those monuments that survive fragmentarily (e.g. the Koroneia or Potidaia monuments).
As with archaic
monuments, the study of each monument here is accompanied by references to more detailed archeological reports.
17
I also apply such categories as "unclear," "likely verse," ''prose with poetic color" for archaic Attic verse epitaphs about which little can be said with any certainty. The category of each archaic text is, moreover, identified in the table {Table 1) that is appended to my study.
Reproduced with permission of the copyright owner. Further reproduction prohibited without permission.
CHAPTER ONE. ARCHAIC ATTIC VERSE EPITAPHS
1. Early Archaic Attic Burial Practice to ea. 600 BC
A brief survey of some features of the burial customs in Attica during the early archaic period is needed, in order to provide context for our understanding of the practice of marking grave sites with monuments bearing verse epitaphs. First, I will outline archaic Attic burial customs prior to the appearance of grave markers with verse epitaphs, and then will attempt to point out some significant changes in burial customs that occurred ea. 600 BC and contributed to the emergence of a certain typology of grave markers which came to be associated with verse epitaphs. To pinpoint the peculiarity of the Athenian practice of material display at burial sites after 600 BC, I will need to discuss the evidence both at the local (Athenian) and at the panhellenic level. Prior to ea. 600 BC Early Attic archaic burial sites fall short of the grandeur of burials of the previous epoch, the Geometric period. 1 Although cremation remained the most common type of burial in seventh century Attica, its typology changed from the so-called secondary (in which the corpse was cremated on a pyre outside the burial pit) to the so-called primary cremation (in which the corpse was cremated inside the pit). As a result of this change, "both the ash amphora and the stately vase above the grave pit were eliminated. " 2 The wealthiest burials comprised elaborately constructed pits, in which the cremation was performed, which were subsequently covered by a low and broad tumulus or rectangular mound. At some distance from the grave, under or beside the earthen mound, there could be an offering trench. The offerings were deposited and burnt during the funeral ceremony, and the trenches were closed and never used again. The size of some of the offering trenches, which reached 12 m in length, and the fmds, which included the fmest examples of Protoattic pottery, testify to the grandeur of the funeral ceremonies. 3 Earthen mounds, which covered the most distinctive burials, 1
Knigge 1991, pp. 16-24; Kurtz and Boardman 1971, pp. 49-67. Knigge 1991, p. 26. 3 Whitley 1994, pp. 213-30; Kurtz and Boardman 1971, pp. 68-90. The rich finds from funerary deposits contrast with the poor votive deposits found in seventh century Attica, which, in turn, look especially meager in comparison with seventh century votive deposits in such places as Corinth, Argos or Olympia. Whitley (1994, pp. 217-218, 224 and passim) points out that this fact, coupled with the lack of evidence for major temple or 2
10
Reproduced with permission of the copyright owner. Further reproduction prohibited without permission.
I. ARCHAIC ATIIC VERSE EPITAPHS
ll
were large constructions, varying in size from 4 to 10 m in diameter, and were often crowned by relatively small ceramic markers, craters or libation vessels; some tumuli were marked by modest stone stelai. In comparison, in some other areas of Greece material display at seventh century burial sites attained greater grandeur and elaboration than in Attica; for example, the grave of Menecrates in Corcyra (143) was marked by a large tumulus which was covered with dressed stone and which was probably surmounted by a figure of a lion. 4 In the practice of marking gravestones with epitaphs, some areas of Greece such as Corinth and her northwestern colonies were more advanced than Attica, too. At some point in the early seventh century the Greeks started to employ not just gravestones, which they must have had earlier (Homeric epic clearly attests the use of grave markers), but also inscribed grave markers. 5 The practice of inscribing grave markers with the name of the deceased dates in Greece to an early period and is illustrated by a primitive type of ofn..ta, a rough stone marker bearing the name of the deceased; these were found, for example, in Thera, and date to the seventh century. 6 Jeffery compares the practice of marking the grave of the dead with the instinct of "marking ... personal property, of men or of deities," 7 which accounts for the majority of the earliest Greek inscriptions, and can be also compared to the identifying inscriptions that accompany depictions on vases. This type of inscription I will call a record or label type, since it identifies the object on which it is written as the grave marker of the person who was buried there. In the majority of cases these inscriptions provide the name of the deceased and sometimes also the name of the one who carried out the burial and set up the monument.
Almost simultaneously with the
appearance of the practice of recording the name on a grave marker, there appeared an interest in doing something more than simply labeling. Along with record type epitaphs, there existed in the seventh century more elaborate verse epitaphs in hexameters such as, for example, the very epic sounding epitaph for Amiades from Corcyra (145, ea. 600?):
sanctuary constructions, indicates that the Athenians of the seventh century may have had little concern for public cult. Public cult practice, however, might have involved use of perishable items, such as cattle; but it is an important consideration that whatever concern the Athenians had for public cult, they did not use their wealth to express it in any lasting material form. 4 For restoration of this impressive monument, see Mataranga 1994. 5 Scodel (1992, pp. 60-61) even argues that the passages in Homer that are reminiscent of epitaphs, such as//. 6.459-60 or 7.89-91, reflect an already existing tradition of sepulchral inscriptions, which might have come to Greece from the Near East. 6 E.g., /G XII 3.771 1-aBi!la, /G XII 3.783 'ETE6KATJIO. 7 LSAG, p. 62.
Reproduced with permission of the copyright owner. Further reproduction prohibited without permission.
I. ARCHAIC ATTIC VERSE EPITAPHS
12
001-la T6Be 'ApvtaBa· xaponos T6vB' OAEicrev "Apes (3apvci~-tevov napa vavcrllv en' 'Apa8801o phofatm, TIOAAolv aplOTEV(f)ovTa KaTa OTOVOfEOav CxfVTcXV8 This is the grave of Arniadas. Ares with flashing eyes destroyed him as he fought by the ships at the streams of Aratthos, displaying the valor amid groaning shouts of war.
Seventh century Attic inscriptions of various genres are not particularly impressive m comparison with inscriptions from other parts of Greece. A couple of seventh century Attic epitaphs are in the tradition of the record type, and are cut on unpretentious grave markers. One is a crude marble stele which bears an epitaph on the shaft beside what might be the traces of a rudimentary relief, IG 13 1194: 'EvtaAo 8vyaTpos 2novBiBol Kepa~-tos crTeAe. The inscription gives the name of a deceased female, followed by two male names, one of which is her father's and the other perhaps her husband's.
The second one is a rough
triangular slab of limestone that bears the name of the deceased in the genitive case, IG 13 1247: 'EmxapiBo. Both stelai are small and roughly finished; their lettering is, to borrow the expression from IG 13, haud dissimilis. They are much closer to the tradition of crude record inscriptions on Thera than to the more refined practice of sepulchral inscriptions in Corinth and her northwestern colonies. In respect to funerary inscriptions, therefore, Attica appears to have been a backwater in the seventh century, but this situation changed drastically in the sixth century. As writing became more widespread, a stone epitaph was increasingly used. Approximately in the second quarter of the sixth century, Athenians started to have funerary epigrams incised on grave markers, and after that archaic Attica ended up producing by far the highest number of sepulchral verses in Greece. Changes ea. 600 BC Ca. 600 Attic funerary practice began to change.
Large tumuli became rare; 9
rectangular mounds were substituted with so-called built tombs (or house-tombs), which became smaller towards the middle of the century, especially in Athens. 10 The number of offering trenches declined, first in Athens and then in the Attic countryside, and beginning in 8
For epic phrasing of the type found in this epitaph, see I/. 16. 669: ... lTOTOI-IOlO po1Jot; 24.256:
... [3opVcXI-IEVOV lTEpl OOTV; 7.89-90: avSpos 1-lEV T65e Oi'j!-10 ... ov lTOT' CxplOTEVOVTO; Od. 11. 383: ... OTOV6EOOOV CxOTi)V. 9
There are some exceptions, the most notable of which is the so-called South Hill in the Kerameikos, see Section 8. It has, however, no offering trench. 10 Kurtz and Boardman 1971, pp. 79-83.
Reproduced with permission of the copyright owner. Further reproduction prohibited without permission.
I. ARCHAIC ATIIC VERSE EPITAPHS
13
the mid-sixth century they became very rare. 11 At the same time, more attention started to be paid to lasting elaborate grave markers. In the Late Geometric period monumental grave markers were represented by Dipylon vases, which disappeared in early archaic times and were replaced by smaller kraters during the seventh century. The renewal of interest in monumental form is first attested towards the end of the seventh century in the employment of larger ceramic grave markers, which reached approximately one meter in height, 12 and slightly later in the appearance of large limestone stelai. In the early sixth century, marble kouroi began to serve as grave markers, 13 and the most advanced, of which numerous examples exist, are dated to the period from ea. 575 on. 14 The changes that occurred around 600 in the funeral complexes in the area of the Kerameikos have been explained as a problem of space: there was little room for large tumuli, and built tombs were being constructed directly adjacent to and on top of each other and earlier structures. 15 This explanation also suggests that the number of people who opted to bury their dead in certain areas such as by the city gates increased in the first half of the sixth century, that is that certain burial grounds (such as the Kerameikos) at certain centers (such as Athens) gained some special significance and prestige, and consequently were running out of space, since too many people wanted to have burial plots there. The same tendency, however, is visible outside the city of Athens in the Attic countryside, where space should not have been a consideration, and this fact suggests that simply different patterns of display were adopted. Grave markers, which had now been scaled down in size, acquired grandeur by other means. They were set up at prominent locations, such as along roads, and featured either stelai, often with a statue of a sphinx on top, or statues of kouroi or korai, which were set up on a pillar or stepped base. These monuments were meant to be observed by any passerby, whom they would impress more by the quality of their artwork than by their sheer 11
For discussion of the development of offering trenches in the Kerameikos, see Ktibler 1959, pp. 87-92. Knigge 1991, p. 27 and fig. 22. 13 It is still an open question when marble kouroi started to be used as grave markers. Knigge (1991, p. 27) casts doubt on the idea that the so-called Dipylon Gate Head, ea. 600-590?, belonged to a funerary statue, since the size of this statue would have been considerably greater than life-size, which puts it rather in the company of statues of youths from sanctuaries. The recent finding of the so-called "Kuros vom Heiligen Tor," in the opinion of Niemeier, proves that this kouros, which is also over life-size, along with the Dipylon Gate kouros and the kouros from the Metropolitan Museum in New York, form a series ofkouroi that were used as grave markers as early as ea. 600 (Niemeier 2002, pp. 47-53). The new kouros (and also the Dipylon and New York kouroi), however, was found reused, which prevents us from securely establishing both the original context and date of the statue. 14 Richter 1960, p. 59. 15 Kurtz and Boardman 1971, p. 82. 12
Reproduced with permission of the copyright owner. Further reproduction prohibited without permission.
I. ARCHAIC ATIIC VERSE EPITAPHS
14
scale. In the preceding century, the finest grave goods were deposited in offering trenches and were not meant to be seen ever again. The splendid monuments of the early sixth century were designed for the permanent display of the taste, status and wealth of the families to whom they belonged. As at any period, reverent burial constituted part of the duty that the living owed the dead, but only a fraction of the population could and would articulate this duty by means of an enduring and splendid grave marker. In both the seventh and sixth centuries this fraction of the population in Athens was perhaps fairly small, and the change in funerary display pertained probably not to the number of families who could and would spend lavishly on funerary arrangements but rather to kinds of material display. It appears to be significant that the increasing employment of the written word in the second quarter of the sixth century to identify a grave marker followed closely or coincided with the shift in emphasis from a grandiose funeral ceremony with rich offerings to an elaborate and prominently located grave marker, that is from a display confined in time (rituals) and to a particular audience (those present at the ceremony) to one that was permanent (statue or stele) and publicly accessible (for any passerby to behold). Solon's Funeracy Legislation Changes observed in the archeological evidence for funerary practices in Athens naturally lead scholars to seek a correlation between these changes and the Solonian funerary legislation16 which is attested in three separate, albeit relatively late, sources, [Demosthenes] 43.62, Cicero De legibus 2.59, and Plutarch Solon 21. [Demosthenes] alludes to Solon's stipulation concerning funerary arrangements (such as place and time) and to the restrictions on the participation of women in the prothesis and ekphora; Cicero claims that 16
Morris' attempt to demonstrate that the existence of Solon's funerary legislation finds no support in the archeological record since "[t]here is no particular break in Athenian burial customs around 600 B.C." (1992b, p. 37) is not convincing. Such phenomena as the disappearance of offering trenches and diminution in the size of the tumuli and built tombs, coupled with the appearance of sculptured stelai and statues, seem undeniable, even if they cannot be dated precisely. Morris' argument for the continued increase from 700 through the late sixth century in the scale of grave markers in Athens rests on the existence of the so-called Mound G (for a short description of this tumulus see Knigge 1991, pp. 105-106), which is dated ea. 560, and appears to provide evidence that sixth century tumuli were no smaller than their seventh century predecessors. This tumulus in fact can be seen as a counter example to Morris' argument. Although there have been various suggestions for the identity of the family whose members were associated with this mound, all scholars agree that the burial was exceptional and Kiibler, who excavated the mound, even thought that it might have been Solon's own tomb (Kiibler 1959, p. 85; Kiibler 1976, pp. 5-21). The mound stands out, precisely because the practice of erecting large tumuli was by then no longer current. The development of archaic Attic grave stelai, from the earlier composite to later monolithic type, also contradicts the theory of continuous increase of material display at burial sites.
Reproduced with permission of the copyright owner. Further reproduction prohibited without permission.
I. ARCHAIC ATIIC VERSE EPITAPHS
15
Solon limited expenditure on funerary attire and musicians, and forbade mourners from lacerating their cheeks and staging /essum funeris, which he explains as lugubris eiulatio. Plutarch gives the most detailed account of several laws that aimed to curb license and disorder at funerals (particularly that caused by women) by lessening funerary expenses and prohibiting mourners from lacerating themselves and from lamenting anyone else but the person being buried. 17 Literary evidence, therefore, depicts Solon's funerary legislation as a) curtailing expenses for the funerary ceremony; b) restricting the ceremony to a certain place and time; c) limiting attendance and restraining emotional outbursts of women. Plutarch explains the reforms as an attempt to end the feuding between the families of Kylon and Megakles which followed the assassination of the former by the latter (Solon 12). 18 Archeological evidence, as we saw, does suggest that the emphasis in material display at the burial site was, at least in some respects, transferred from funerary ceremonies to permanent and impressive grave markers. The scaling down of funerary ceremony would correspond to the spirit of the Solonian legislation, but I would be hesitant to assert that it was Solonian legislation that caused aristocratic funerary display to include grave markers of grandeur. Solon's laws and the archeologically documented changes in funerary display might well represent various facets of an emerging social and political situation in which restrictions on outbursts of human emotion and regulation of material display at certain ceremonies started to play a bigger role. 2. Archaic Attic Verse Epitaphs in Context
Typology of Monuments Associated with Verse Epitaphs The majority of archaic Attic epitaphs was inscribed on the bases of either a statue or of an elaborate stele. Earlier statues were primarily standing kouroi or korai, but in the last third of the sixth century there also appeared seated figures and equestrian statues. Marble and limestone were employed, but so far there is no evidence for the use of bronze statues in funerary markers. The stelai were tall, fairly narrow dressed slabs of marble or limestone with a depiction on the shaft that might be rendered in low relief, incision or paint. The stelai of the first three quarters of the sixth century comprised a separate base and fmial, 17
See the excellent and brief account in Garland 1989, pp. 3-5, as well as Engels 1998, pp. 77-96. Alexiou (1974, p. 21) puts it well: "In the inflammatory atmosphere of the blood feud between the families of Megakles and Kylon that was raging in Solon's time, what more effective way could there be to stir up feelings of revenge than the incessant lamentation at the tomb by large numbers of women for 'those long dead'?" 18
Reproduced with permission of the copyright owner. Further reproduction prohibited without permission.
I. ARCHAIC ATIIC VERSE EPITAPHS
16
often in the shape of a sphinx, whereas the stelai of the last third of the century had a simpler finial which was carved in one piece with the shaft, but retained separate bases. The height and thickness of these later so-called monolithic stelai were less than those of the earlier so-called composite stelai. The narrow shaft of a stele was most conducive to the depiction of a standing figure in profile; in the majority of cases it is a figure of a standing young man who is turned to the right. Mature men are also sometimes represented, and towards the end of the century there appeared the type of an older man leaning on a staff, occasionally accompanied by a dog. 19 In at lest one case the main male figure is attended by a smaller female one. 20 In the lower part of the stele, below the principal composition, there could be a separate field with another depiction in relief or painted; 21 these panels are sometimes called predellae, on the analogy with medieval altar compositions. Capitals of the composite stelai could be decorated additionally with carved or painted scenes. Women never appear on their own on the narrow shaft stelai, but at the end of the sixth century there developed a type of wide, thin stelai that did depict seated women, perhaps with attendants. Although a surviving epitaph can rarely be securely identified with a particular monument, the remaining base often preserves traces of joints from which it is possible to guess the original type and scale of the monument. The monuments that are associated with verse epitaphs in archaic Attica, primarily sculpture in the round and tall stelai, must have been distinguished by their cost. Indeed, many of these monuments are of island marble, which had to be transported to Athens. More importantly, they were often the best examples of sculpture of the period and were wrought by leading sculptors of the day, some of whom even signed their works. 22 Besides cost, setting up such grave markers required considerable knowledge and appreciation of aesthetic norms on the part of the families who would commission them. Inscribing a grave marker with a verse epitaphand virtually all archaic Attic verse epitaphs were inscribed on the grave markers of grandeur-was confined to a circle of people who knew poetic norms well and could afford conspicuous monuments, which were distinguished both by their cost and aesthetic qualities. 19
See the discussion of the man-and-dog type in Clairmont 1970, pp. 28-31. The so-called boy-and-girl stele from the Metropolitan Museum depicts a young man and a girl, see Richter 1961, pp.27-29, no. 37. 21 These scenes may include some cavalry motives (Richter 1961, figs. 128, 154, 159, etc.), or a depiction of a Gorgon (figs. 83 and 84). 22 See Section 6. 20
Reproduced with permission of the copyright owner. Further reproduction prohibited without permission.
I. ARCHAIC AITIC VERSE EPITAPHS
17
The proportion of these people to the entire population of Attica must have been small, and we may regard them as members of the elite. Display and Layout of Archaic Attic Verse Epitaphs Grave markers consisted of sculpture in the round or stelai, which were often mounted on stepped bases oflimestone or marble. Verse epitaphs were most often incised on the front surface of the upper block of a stepped base. A stepped base could have three or four blocks, each measuring approximately 0.3 m in height, which means that the surface that included the epitaph would be elevated enough to assist reading. Sometimes epitaphs were inscribed on the predella in the lower part of the main shaft. Archaic Attic funerary inscriptions never appear to have been placed on the sculpture itself, as is often the case with Attic dedicatory inscriptions or funerary inscriptions in other parts of Greece. Beginning with the earliest extant examples, the writing in verse epitaphs is neat and careful, and letters are generally large, ranging from 0.025 m to 0.04 m; sometimes traces of paint over the incised letters and guidelines are preserved. Punctuation marks might be employed to mark the end of a verse (e.g. 13, 19, 51), but more often they separate words or groups of closely joined words, for example XatpeOEI-lO
=T68e oe11a =TraTep eoTe[oe I 8]av6vTos =(14, line 1).
These
marks must have been meant to assist the reader, since the texts were continuous and empty spaces were avoided-a feature characteristic of the archaic "carpeting" style of writing. As a result of this style, both words and verses were often divided at line end. In a few cases, the splitting of words between lines is avoided by the calculated spacing of the letters (e.g. 24, 27), which must have required the investment of particular care in the arrangement of the inscription. At least in one case (24) the inscribed face of the base is framed with double incisions to underscore the decorative appearance of the inscribed surface. Generally, much effort was put into making a verse epitaph at once a decorative part of the tombstone and a presenter of the most legible text possible. The act of reading an early Attic epitaph did not require much deciphering or walking around the monument/3 and any passer-by, assuming he was literate, could quite easily see and read the inscription. 23
Contrast the Attic practice with, for example, the dedication at Delphi, LSAG, p. 103, no. 4.
Reproduced with permission of the copyright owner. Further reproduction prohibited without permission.
I. ARCHAIC ATIIC VERSE EPITAPHS
18
Verse vs Prose IG I3 lists 101 private epitaphs that date from the beginning of the practice to before
ea. 500-480, when the tradition of inscribing private epitaphs was interrupted. Three texts, 1245, 1264, and 1273 are of an entirely unclear nature and might well be non-sepulchral, while one epitaph (29) is not included in JG I3 because it is inscribed a clay tablet. Thus, there are 99 archaic epitaphs, which I divide into the following categories: verse (43), likely-verse (9), unclear (18), prose (26), and prose with some poetic features (3). 24 The ratio of verse epitaphs to all epitaphs in archaic Attica is between 53% and 64%, depending on whether we count only verse or both verse and likely-verse against the total number of epitaphs, excluding those that are unclear (that is either a proportion of 43 to 81 or 52 to 81). Although my criteria for considering an epitaph metrical are somewhat more restrictive than those in the collections of Peek or even Hansen, since I distinguish categories of "unclear" and "likely verse" epitaphs/5 the resulting ratio of verse to all epitaphs in archaic Attica (at the very least, halfl) is higher than it would be at any other time and in any other place in Greece. Notwithstanding the fact that precise dating is unattainable, the relative distribution of verse and prose epitaphs during the sixth century is clearly uneven, with patterns being different in the period before ea. 525 from those at the end of the century. 26 In the earlier period the percentage of verse to all epitaphs is higher than in the last decades of the century. A relatively high number of inscriptions in the "unclear" category might somewhat skew the results, but the general tendency for verse to outnumber prose epitaphs in the earlier period is undeniable.
It appears, therefore, that when the practice of inscribing grave markers
appeared and became widespread in Attica in the second and third quarters of the sixth century, most people who chose to commemorate their dead with a lasting inscription preferred to do so in metrical form. Towards the end of the century the practice of marking the grave monument with a prose epitaph (usually recording just the name of the deceased) became equally or even more common. 3. Commemorated Deceased
The primary purpose of any epitaph is to identify and lament the loss of the deceased, and to keep his or her memory alive. When archaic Attic verse epitaphs tell more than
24
See Table I. See Introduction and Table 1. 26 The date of ea. 525 is artificial and does not correspond to any historical date. 25
Reproduced with permission of the copyright owner. Further reproduction prohibited without permission.
I. ARCHAIC ATTIC VERSE EPITAPHS
19
the identity of the deceased and the chief mourner, they most commonly expand to add expressions of praise or grief. They can supply some personal information, such as the origin, if it was not Athens, of the deceased, and in some cases they address the passer-by and ask him or her to join in the lament. Some epitaphs also include references to and short descriptions of the burial or the monument. Analysis of the elements of verse epitaphs provides us with some idea of what was perceived to be most memorable and praiseworthy about the deceased and of what was felt most grievous about his or her fate. Death in War Death on the battlefield is the supreme sacrifice of self to society, the supremely memorable and praiseworthy act. It can fall to both the young and old, but when it comes to the young it is the most grievous fate. Death in war, that is on behalf of others, is more than a private family matter and arouses the grief of everybody; Tyrtaeus describes how the entire community of an archaic city laments the one who fell on the battlefield:
Tov
s· 6Ao
apyaAEc.vl Se n68c.vtncrcra KEKT)OE lTOAts. (12. 27-28) In two archaic Attic verse epitaphs praise and grief for the young man who perished at war is given more universal significance by a request to the passer-by, whoever he happens to be, to join in the lamentation. The first example is found in one of the fmest Attic verse epitaphs, which commemorates a certain Tettichos who perished at war (13, ea. 575-550?):
[ehe acrT6]s TlS avep ehe xcrevosl aAo8ev eA8ov : Thtxov oiKTipals avSp' aya8ov napho,: ev noAEI-lOl I
The inscription is incised on a block of island marble which was recovered in Sepolia, north of Athens. The block might have been the top block of a stepped base, which would have been surmounted by a tall stele representing a warrior, although a kouros remains a possibility. 27 Jeffery calls the lettering of this inscription delicate and fine, reminiscent of the inscribing style of the vase painter Sophilos in the second quarter of the sixth century: 27
IGAA, p. 133, no. 34, pl. 38:a. Richter thinks that the base consisted only of the surviving inscribed block, that is it was not a stepped base, and discounts the possibility of its carrying a statue (1961, p. 25, no. 36, fig. 203). The dimensions ofthe block are H. 0.29 m, W. 0.70 m, Th. 0.53 m.
Reproduced with permission of the copyright owner. Further reproduction prohibited without permission.
I. ARCHAIC A TIIC VERSE EPITAPHS
20
the epitaph is inscribed boustrophedon; the letters evenly cover the surface of the stone and, as a result, verses and even words are split between lines, while punctuation marks signal verse ends and thus assist reading. Words of lament (the request to the passer-by to lament the deceased) and grief (the reference to the youth of Tettichos) dominate the epigram. Praise is implied in the reference to Tettichos' death on the battlefield, but, otherwise, it is confmed to the formulaic avi]p aya86s, "noble and virtuous man." Tettichos' status as aya86s is also emphasized by the final verse in which the passer-by himself is urged to proceed to npO:y1-1' aya86v. Although the common meaning of the adjective aya86s might be "well-born," in the final verse it connotes something "praise-worthy," since it is to a praise-worthy act that the verse urges the passer-by to proceed. Another well known and well preserved epitaph commemorating a warrior is that for Kroisos (27, ea. 540-530?): crTe8t : Kal oiKTtpov : Kpoicro lnapa cre~-ta 8av6vTos : h6v I noT' ev\ lTPOI-ICxXOIS : oAeae I Sopos : , Apes. Halt and mourn by the tomb of the deceased Kroisos, whom, as he fought once 28 on the front lines, fierce Ares destroyed.
The verse is inscribed on the middle block of a stepped base of Parian marble, which was found in Southern Attica in Anavyssos, in an area that held numerous rich graves and yielded three kouroi. 29 The base is associated with the so-called Anavyssos, or Kroisos, kouros, a superb statue 2.01 m in height, which was found approximately in the same area and at
28
What TIOTE (translated here as "once") means in inscriptional epigrams has been the subject of some discussion. Wade-Gery (1930, pp. 72-82) suggests that the word indicates some significant lapse of time between erection of the inscribed monument and the event which the epitaph refers to. Page (FGE, pp. 270-271), however, argues that the composer of an epitaph intends it for posterity and is looking to the future reader, for whom the described event would have happened "once upon a time." Page adduces several examples of the employment of the word in private funerary inscriptions from various periods, which, he claims, "assure us that the composer was not including the word TIOTE in order to take account of some lapse of time between death and burial." The examples that Page cites, however, mask an important tendency in verse epitaphs before ea. 400, both at Athens as well as in other parts of Greece, namely that during this period TIOTE occurs almost exclusively in epitaphs for those who died in war; in later funerary verses the word can be used in various contexts. It seems, therefore, that in earlier verses TIOTE is employed to elevate the message which is conveyed by the epitaph, and Robbins (1990, pp. 308-309) offers the compelling suggestion that in early inscriptions the employment of TIOTE raises the commemorated men to the level of epic heroes. 29 IGAA, pp. 143-146, no. 57; for photographs of both the inscription and the kouros see, among others, Clairmont 1970, pi. 2; Viviers 1992, figs. 27, 47-48. The dimensions of the block, which forms the front half of the middle step ofthe base, are H. 0.24 m, W. 0.81 m, Th. 0.51 m.
Reproduced with permission of the copyright owner. Further reproduction prohibited without permission.
I. ARCHAIC ATTIC VERSE EPITAPHS
21
the same time as the base with the epitaph for Kroisos. 30 The inscription preserves traces of red paint which must have alleviated the task of reading the letters; the engraver inserted punctuation marks and ensured that words were not divided between lines. As in Tettichos' epitaph, the verse opens by addressing the passer-by with the request to stop and lament Kroisos, whom furious Ares-a rare reference to a god in archaic epitaphs--destroyed. The expression might have derived from Tyrtaeus' elegy in which immortal fame and memory is promised to a man who gives up his life in battle for the sake of his land and people:
miSe lTOTE KAEOS ea8Aov CxlTOAAVTat ovS' OVOI-l' a\JToO, aAA' VlTO yiis nep ewv yivETat 6:8avaTOS, OVTtv' aptOTEVOVTa 1-!EVOVTcX TE 1-!apVcXI-lEVOV TE yfis nept Kal nai8c.Jv 8o0pos "Aplls 6Aeallt. (12.31-34) Although the epitaph, much in the spirit of epitaphs for those who died in war (as we have already seen in the epitaph for Tettichos), says nothing about Kroisos' family, fortunately for us his very name might tell us something. J effery suggests that this Kroisos was a son of the famous Alkmeon and was named Kroisos after the Lydian king, the great benefactor of Alkmeon. 31 Of course, our Kroisos might have been not a son but some other relation of Alkmeon; nevertheless, as J .K. Davies concurs, "there is no Athenian family with a better claim on the name than the Alkmeonidai."32 This family of splendid means and fme taste presents us with a characteristic example of what class of people in archaic Attica would choose to inscribe a verse epitaph. A fragmentary epitaph found in an unrecorded place in Attica (30, ea. 535-530) must have commemorated a man who perished in war, but too little survives from what appears originally to have been a long verse inscription; even the meter of the epitaph cannot be determined. The epitaph seems to have had some form of the verb aptaTevc.J which was preceded by OTE, and the juxtaposition of these two words indicates that in its praise 30
Although the kouros has been mounted on the base in the National Museum, there remains some doubt whether the two actually belong together, see IGAA, p. 144. Furthermore, it cannot be ruled out that a base of these dimensions, which was inscribed on the wide surface, supported a stele rather than a statue, so J. Day, per ep. Richter is inclined to accept the joining of the base and the kouros (1960, pp. 115 and 118-119, no. 136). 31 IGAA, p. 144; cf. Herodotus 6.125 32 Davies 1971, p. 374. Viviers (1992, pp. 123-124) develops Richter's suggestion (Richter 1960, p. 116) that Kroisos was of Eastern origin and attempts to identify him with a foreign high scale mercenary who fought on the side of the tyrants ea. 513. Viviers notes that the absence ofK.roisos' patronymic is difficult to reconcile with the hypothesis that suggests that Kroisos was a member of the Alkmeonids. The absence of the patronymic is in fact characteristic of Attic verse epitaphs for those who died in war, and also for the epitaphs which address the passer-by. All in all, there does not appear to be enough evidence to support Viviers' conclusion that K.roisos was "un chefmilitaire a la solde du pouvoir" who was killed probably at the beginning ofHippias' tyranny (p. 124).
Reproduced with permission of the copyright owner. Further reproduction prohibited without permission.
I. ARCHAIC ATIIC VERSE EPITAPHS
22
of the deceased the epigram referred to death on the battlefield. The epitaph was inscribed on the marble base of a tall stele depicting a warrior in relief on the main shaft above quadrigae driven by two charioteers, which are incised in the predella; the stele was surmounted by a statue of a sphinx. 33 Virtues ofthe Deceased Words of praise in archaic Attic verse epitaphs are few in number, limited in variety, and vague in meaning. The commonest epithet to be applied to a man is aya86s, whether employed alone (13, 14, 42) or coupled with ow
IJVEIJCl T68' Aiveo oocp(as iaTpo ap(oTo. This is a memorial to the wisdom of Aineias, an excellent doctor.
The inscription is incised on a marble disk bearing a depiction of a seated bearded man. I think the disk might actually be a dedication, because the language is typical of dedications, 35 and there is no reference to the death of Aineias. Furthermore, the dimensions 33
For the sphinx, see Richter 1961, p. 29, no. 38, figs. 110-114, and for the stele, see pp. 32-33, no. 45, figs. 126-128. For the inscription, see Clairmont 1974, p. 224. 34 See the discussion of 67 below. 35 Cf. dedications 252, 270, 272, etc.
Reproduced with permission of the copyright owner. Further reproduction prohibited without permission.
I. ARCHAIC AITIC VERSE EPITAPHS
23
of this disk are much smaller (Dm. 0.27 m, Th. 0.02 m) than the only known inscribed disk that was certainly used to mark a grave (/G 13 1516; Dm. 0.49 m, Th. 0.05 m). 36 If Aineias' disk, however, is funerary, his epitaph is the earliest example from Attica of an epitaph to a doctor, which is one of the most frequently mentioned occupations both in literary sources, beginning with Homeric epic, and verse epitaphs from the fourth century on. 37 However few and vague are the words which are used in verse epitaphs to praise men, their variety is large in comparison with those used for a woman. Women, who are commemorated in at least seven verse epitaphs, are usually lamented but very seldom praised. Among inscriptional funerary verses, there is only one example, the epitaph for a non-Athenian named Lampito (66), who is called aiool11, "respectful" or "seemly"-a common Homeric epithet which can be applied to women of different ages.
Another
example of a verse epitaph that praises the woman it commemorates is the epitaph from Lampsakos for Archedike. 38 The two couplet epitaph is quoted by Thucydides (6.59), while Aristotle (Rhet. 1367b) cites only verse 3, which he assigns to Simonides. Although Aristotle's ascription might (or might not) be the result of a later anecdotal tradition, there is little ground to doubt that the verses cited by Thucydides were indeed inscribed at Lampsakos upon Archedike's tombstone:
avopos aptOTEVOOVTOS ev . EAAaOt TWV eq) eaUTOU · hrnlov 'ApxeBtKllV floe KeKev8e Kovts· f)naTpos TE Kat CxVOpos aOeAcpwv T' ovoa TVpcXVVc.JV natOc.JV T' OVK f}pe.., vouv es CxTao8aAtllV. (=Simon. 26a) Here the earth covers Archedike the daughter of Hippias who excelled those of his time in Hellas. Although she was a daughter, wife, sister and mother of tyrants, she did not lift her mind to arrogance.
This epitaph is quite different from archaic Attic verse epitaphs in that it is more poetic and more opaque than an archaic epitaph. In the opening verse Hippias appears to be highly esteemed, but the second couplet seems to imply that tyrannoi are prone to aTao8aAtll, from which Archedike, however, managed to abstain. If the epigram were composed before 36
Clairrnont provides a good survey of arguments on both sides; he himself argues that the disk was votive (1970, pp. 17-20). 37 Cf. Od. 17.384-387, and see Ch. 3 Section 3 for my discussion of activities commemorated in later classical
~fii·~phls.d · my anaIysis · o f praise · expressions . because It . IS . ctOr an Atheman . woman, aIthough I exc Iude It . me u e It· m from my count of archaic Attic verse epitaphs because it was probably composed later (that is after the Persian Wars) than the period we generally designate "archaic," and during the time when the tradition to inscribe gravestones with verse epitaphs came to a halt in Athens.
Reproduced with permission of the copyright owner. Further reproduction prohibited without permission.
I. ARCHAIC ATTIC VERSE EPITAPHS
24
the liberation of Lampsakos from tyrants, that is before 479, it would explain well the praise of Hippias but not the implication that Archedike's husband, brothers and sons were tyrants and inclined to aTao8aAtll. The latter is a strong word that denotes the committing of arrogant acts without regard for their consequences. In Herodotus 3.80 aTao8aAtll is directly connected with tyranny, and the speech of Otanes provides a background against which we can read Archedike's epitaphs: KCJs B' 8:v Eill XPiil..la KOTllPTlli..IEVOV I..IOUVapxlll, Tij E~EOTl aveu8vv~ lTOlEElV Ta (3ovAETat; Kal yap 8:v TOV aplOTOV avBpCJv lTClVTC..JV OTclVTa es TOVTllV TflV apxi]v EKTOS TWV ecu86TCUV VOlll..lclTCUV OTi]OElE. 'EyytVETat l..leV yap oi v(3pts V'TIO TWV nape6VTCUV aya8CJv, q>86vos Be apxii8ev El..lq>VETat av8pwn~. l:ivo B' excuv Ta0Ta EXEl m]oav KOKOTllTO" Ta I..IEV yap v(3pl KEKOPlli..IEVOS epBet lTOAAa Kat aT6:o8aAa, Ta Be q>86v~. "How can a monarchy be a suitable thing? The monarch may do what he pleases, with none to check him afterwards. Take the best man on earth and put him outside of the thoughts that have been wont to guide him. Outrageousness is bred in him by reason of the good things he has, and envy is basic in the nature of man. He has these two qualities, then, and in them he has all evil. Out of his satiety his outrageousness grows, and he does many appalling things out of that; but he does many out of envy, too." (trans. Grene)
With Herodotus in mind, let us explore the possibility that the epitaph for Archedike was composed and incised after the liberation of Lampsakos, perhaps even a considerable time later-Archedike may have lived into the 460s or even 450s, 39 or the epitaph could have been inscribed not immediately after Archedike's death. The reference to Hippias as aptoTevoas ev 'EAAaBt TWV eq>' eaUTOV might simply mean that he excelled all other men of Greece of his time; he was, that is, the most prominent man ofhis time. The expression eq>' EOUTOV
might be a very carefully chosen qualifier of Hippias' excellence and a strong pointer to the past. Hippias' reputation in Lampsakos might not have been that bad-after all, he was not a tyrant there. At Lampsakos he could even have had the reputation of "a good king" and of an exiled hero who, along with his family, was blackmailed into retreat when the children of the family were caught being secretly transported out of the country. 40 Archedike therefore was the daughter of a man who once was the most powerful man in Greece, in the distant and most famous city of Athens.
Archedike's brothers, husband and children,
however, were tyrants in Lampsakos or perhaps in some other cities in the region. 39
All what we know is that Archedike was married in or shortly after 514 (Thucydides 6.59), which suggests that she was born by ea. 528. 40 Herodotus 5.65.
Reproduced with permission of the copyright owner. Further reproduction prohibited without permission.
I. ARCHAIC ATTIC VERSE EPITAPHS
25
Their wrong-doings, their ul3pts and cXTao8aA(ll, would have been well remembered and perhaps often commented on in Lampsakos. After the fall of tyranny in Lampsakos and following the battle at Mykale, the tyrants presumably paid their TlotS (as I pointed out above,
CXTao8aA(ll denotes action with disregard for consequences and is often invoked in the context of retribution41 ), but Archedike had no share in their irresponsible actions and never put her mind outside of the proper bonds, although, theoretically, she might have been tempted by all the power that surrounded her. Having had no share in their arrogance, she was liable to no Ttots; still, her family affiliation was of course undeniable. Perhaps her burial was arranged by a relative who was apprehensive of her "tyrannical" origin and chose to address the touchy issue openly and to dispel at once all possible accusations, so that no wrongs associated with the tyrants of Lampsakos would thwart the memory of Archedike. The virtue of Archedike, which her epitaph praises, could have been described simply as
sophrosyne (which is the virtue most commonly singled out among women in verse epitaphs of the fifth and fourth centuries), but it would not have protected her memory from associations with tyranny. The open acknowledgement of her relations to the tyrants might have been the best way to mitigate the feelings of the people of Lampsakos towards a member of the family for which they were unlikely to feel much respect. Two more formal points should be mentioned. The author of Archedike 's epigram does not use the formulaic language of epitaphs, but may rather have offered innovations that would be imitated later,42 and thus Aristotle's ascription of the epitaph to a famous poet is not surprising, even if it is by no means trustworthy (although it is not entirely impossible, since Simonides might have died as late as the mid-460s). 43 The phrasing of the fourth verse is rather exceptional. While the deceased is often praised for his or her virtue, or in one case is said to have been virtuous in spirit and bravery (yap haml:oes vov Te Kal avo[pe]av
41
C£, for example, Theognis 735-736: miTov E-rretTa mx:\1v Teiom KaKa, llTJB' h' 6Tiioow lTOTpO) chao8aAi011TOIOl yeVOIVTO KOK6V. The word and its cognates are applied regularly to the suitors in the Odyssey. It denotes, on the one hand, their arrogance and irresponsibility, and, on the other, points to impending retribution. 42 The expression nBe KEKev8e K6VI), for example, does not appear on stone before 400 BC, but becomes common in later funerary epigrams-and might have been coined in Archedike's epitaph. 43 See Molyneux (1992, pp. 307-341) for a brief assessment of various ancient and modern chronologies of Simonides' life.
Reproduced with permission of the copyright owner. Further reproduction prohibited without permission.
I. ARCHAIC A ITIC VERSE EPITAPHS
26
exaoxos heAtKias, 31, ea. 540-520?), employment of the term voOs to describe the character or life of the deceased does not appear in archaic epitaphs. Origin of the Deceased As a general rule, epitaphs speak of the origin of the deceased only when it differs from the place of burial. Death far from home was viewed as a particularly deplorable fate, and it appears as one of the themes of special grief in the earliest Greek verse epitaphs (for example, 143). Earliest surviving archaic Attic verse epitaphs which explicitly refer to death far from the fatherland date to only the end of the sixth century; a few earlier epitaphs to foreigners were in prose (for example, IG I3 1344 for a Karian, ea. 525-520?, IG 13 1349 for a Delian, ea. 530?; IG 13 1372 for a Teian, ea. 525-500?), and they simply
stated the origin of the deceased. It might have been the case that foreigners in Attica did not start putting verse epitaphs on funerary monuments until the last decades of the century, or if they did follow the practice earlier, perhaps they preferred not to indicate their origin and thereby make their epitaphs virtually indistinguishable from those that the Athenians would inscribe for their dead. The latter scenario might be reflected in the epitaph for Neilonides, son ofNeilon, apparently a non-Athenian (42, ea. 525?): I.
II.
TiatOos NeAovos NeiAovioo eaT\ TO OEIJia os )(\Jot {To} a[ya]Sotl {t} IJVEIJO ETIOlEI (sic) xalpiev. "Evootos K[a]l T6vo' enoie.
I. This is the tomb of Neilonides son of Neilon who made a fine monument for his virtuous
son as well. 11. Endoios made this [tomb? statue? 44 ] too.
The epitaph seems45 to be somewhat below contemporary standards since Attic epitaphs of this period are generally executed with greater care. The monument which bore the epitaph, however, must have been of considerable grandeur since it comprised a statue of a kouros and a base with a depiction of a seated man either in low relief or painted incision,46 and it was signed by Endoios, a sculptor so famous that later tradition believed him to be the pupil
44
The masculine T6v5E is rather unusual since most words denoting a monument are neuter (aiiJJa, IJViiJJa, or even ayaAJJa); possible masculine words could be Kovpos (c£ 266) or TVJJ(3os. 45 The inscription was obliterated before or during construction of the Themistoklean Walls and is hardly legible, see IGAA, p. 127, no.19, and DAA, pp. 493-494. 46 For a detailed discussion, including photographs and drawings of the monument, see Keesling 1999. The dimensions ofthe base are H. 0.401, W. 0.715 m, Th. 0.631 m.
Reproduced with permission of the copyright owner. Further reproduction prohibited without permission.
27
I. ARCHAIC ATIIC VERSE EPITAPHS
ofDaidalos (Pausanias 1.26.4). Hansen suggests that Neilon was a Samian,47 and if this is so, it might perhaps explain the awkwardness of the verse: if it was Neilon who composed the epigram--or at least collaborated and looked after the composition-he would not perhaps have been as skillful as members of the Athenian elite, since there does not appear to have been a tradition of inscribing verse epitaphs on Samos. 48 Endoios was also responsible for the grave monument of Lampito, who was buried in Athens far from her fatherland (66, ea. 500?):
e[v8a]5e <1>1[--- ea. 10--- ]Ios KaTe8eiKE Savocrav : . J\[a!..rrr.I]To ai5oiev yes chrlo lraTpo·tes. : "Ev801os e1roiecrev. Here Phi-- from (?) --os buried seemly Lampito (?) who passed away far from her fatherland. Endoios made it.
The epitaph is inscribed on the front surface of the upper block of the stepped base that once carried a wide stele. 49 The name Lampito (which appears quite plausible since the letters/\, and TO are undoubtedly on the stone and are separated by enough space to accommodate four letters) is attested twice for a Spartan (Herodotus 6.71 and in Aristophanes Lys.) and in a later source for a Samian (Athenaeus 593 e-f). It is generally assumed that Samos is the likeliest origin of Lampito, because the epigram displays Ionic forms, namely ai5oiev and
TI"aTpotes; these forms, however, are Homeric and would probably be spelled so in the Attic dialect, too, since the spelling with alpha seems to be characteristic only of proper Doric dialects, such as that of Pindar or the Doric lyrics of Euripides. In other words, these adjectives are spelled with alpha in those dialects that would have spelled the genitive of yfi as yas, not yes, as we have in the epitaph. Thus, we can say that the dialect of Lampito's epitaph is not Doric, but it is impossible to determine whether it is Attic-Ionic or Eastern Ionic, as found on Samos. It would help if we could decipher more of the first line, and it has 47
The uncommon name Neilon is attested in the 5th and 3rd centuries BC on Samos, LGPN I, s.v. Nei:\c.uv. Viviers (1992, pp. 71-75) gathers a variety of evidence that plausibly suggests (although does not prove) that the family was oflonian, and more precisely Samian, origin. 48 No verse epitaph of the 6th or 5th centuries survives from Samos, and the two surviving 4th century verse epitaphs are likely (683) or certainly (684) for Athenians who died on Samos, and were composed under Athenian influence; I do not include 685 her because it dates to ea. 300? 49 See the detailed discussion of the base, with drawings and a photograph, in Vi viers 1992, pp. 84-86, figs. 8-10. The dimensions of the block, as in Viviers, are H. 0.157 m, W. 0.765 m, Th. 0.292 m, whereas JG 1380 provides somewhat smaller measurements, H. 0.14 m, W. 0.765 m, Th. 0.24 m, and these are in agreement with Jeffery's, IGAA, p. 130, no. 24.
e
Reproduced with permission of the copyright owner. Further reproduction prohibited without permission.
I. ARCHAIC ATIIC VERSE EPITAPHS
28
been proposed50 to restore the name of the chief mourner as
t[ATta8es LcXI-lhos or
naphos, but other ethnics could fit, too. Moreover, the first line of the text is very poorly preserved, and photographs show that only .8E and KA "fE6EKE (which can be either
KaTe8eKe or Ka\ e8nKe) are certain, and that the two letters following .8E might be <1>1, A, 61, or 6A. Didier Viviers, who examined the stone, reports that he was unable to find any traces of other letters. 51 The content of the first line is therefore unclear and is of no help in determining the origin of the chief mourner, which in any case could have been different from that of Lampito. In the end, all that we know is that Lampito died far from her fatherland, and this was felt to be a particularly mournful fate. 52 The epitaph for Leanax son ofHeragoras announces that he was Samian (52, ea. 510?). Leanax' grave monument comprised a marble statue mounted on a stepped marble base, but the type of the statue has been debated. Viviers convincingly argues that the statue likely represented a seated figure, because the original upper surface of the base and cutting for the stele were large and close to a square. 53 The epitaph reads thus: I.
11. Ill.
es Lal-ltOlS yevvaios avnp VlTO OTJI-laTl Twt8e I A@va~ 'Hpay6ps_c.:> KEtTat aTioTipo v. !Aepyos eTiolncrev. [Aeav ]~KTOS.
I. From among the Samians, a highborn man lies under this tomb, Leanax son of Heragoras, far from those dear to him. 11. Philergos made it. Ill. OfLeanax.
Leanax' foreign origin is proudly stated in the first verse; it is also emphasized by the consistent employment of Ionic script in the epigram, which is also a feature of other
50
Wilhelm 1909, pp. 33-35. Viviers 1992, pp. 86-86. 52 The words and expressions which are used to describe Lampito and her fate are highly poetic and frequently occur in Homeric epic (for example ev yailJ naTpwfl:l in Od. 13.189, aiSoiTJ napaKOITIS in Od. 3.451, etc.). 53 Viviers 1992, pp. 103-108. He restores (p. 106) the upper surface of the base as H. 0.306 m L. 0.945 m, Th. 1.01 m (p.Th. 0.474-0.505 m); and of the cutting as L. 0.705 m, W. 0.77 (p.W. 0.34-0.365 m), D. 0.02. In fact, they could be even closer to a square, and in any event are very close to the dimensions of the base of Anaxilas' monument (58) which must have represented a seated figure (base H. 0.30 m, L. 0.92 m, Th. 0.92 m; cutting L. 0.73 m, W. 0.73 m, D. 0.03 m). It is impossible to know how the statue was turned and thus it is indeterminable which surface of the base was the front, but I follow the convention to call the surface with the epitaph and the signature (I and 11) the front, and the one with the name of the deceased {Ill) the side surface. Viviers conveniently provides both a drawing and a photograph of the base of Leanax's monument (p. 104, fig. 17 and p. 108, fig. 18). 51
Reproduced with permission of the copyright owner. Further reproduction prohibited without permission.
I. ARCHAIC ATTIC VERSE EPITAPHS
29
surviving epitaphs to Samians in Athens (JG 13 1366, 1368, and probably 1367). The verse tells us that Leanax was buried far from his
ovBels yap o\hcu CxVOllTOS EOTl OOTIS TIOAEJ,lOV npo eipiJVllS aipeeTat" ev 11ev yap Tlj oi naiBes Tovs naTepas 86::nTovm, ev oe Tc';) oi naTepes Tovs naiBas. For no one is, of himself, so foolish as to prefer war to peace; in the one, children bury their fathers; in the other, fathers their children. (trans. D. Grene)
Untimely death and the burial of children by their parents represent the inversion of the natural order of life and death, a grievous fate which is frequently alluded to in verse epitaphs. In some cases, especially when no parent is mentioned as the chief mourner, the deceased is explicitly said to have been young at the time of death: Tettichos (13 line 3) "destroyed his tender youth," 55 Xenophantos (45), the deceased in 43 and that in 75 are called
acupos or 6:~ptos, and Phrasikleia is said to remain a kore forever (24). In verse epitaphs that tell us who was responsible for setting up the monument, parents by far outnumber other relatives as the chief mourners, and very few epitaphs say that the monument was set up by children for a parent, or by one spouse for another (see section 4). One of the earliest Attic verse epitaphs commemorates Chairedemos son of Amphichares (14, ea. 560-550?):
XmpeBeJ,lo = T6Be oe11a = naTep eoTE[oe I 8]av6vTos = 'Avs = 6:ya8ov = naiBa 6jAoaiBtllOS enoie. For the deceased Chairedemos, his father, Anphichares, set up this tomb, in grief for his noble son. Phaidimos made it.
54
55
For discussion of the theme of premature death in Greek verse epitaphs, see Griesmair 1966. Friedliinder and Hoffieit 1948, no. 135
Reproduced with permission of the copyright owner. Further reproduction prohibited without permission.
I. ARCHAIC ATTIC VERSE EPITAPHS
30
The epitaph was incised boustrophedon on a stepped limestone base of either a stele or statue. 56 Phaidimos' signature, added in prose, indicates that the sculpture was of high quality. The letters of the epitaph are well cut and punctuation marks separate words or small groups of words. Chairedemos is called 6:ya86s, the most commonly employed epithet in archaic Attic verse epitaphs. Most emphasis in the verse is placed not on praise but on lament for the deceased: the expression of mourning concludes the couplet. The inverted order of burying is emphasized through the
seemingly redundant references
to Amphichares as the father and Chairedemos as the child. Although untimely death is always one of the dominant subjects in epitaphs, it seems to find particular prominence in the archaic period. This impression might be partly due to the fact that other themes (such as, for example, death far from the fatherland, death at sea, death in childbirth) are rare or completely absent from archaic epitaphs, and partly, as I mentioned above, to the fact that parents are the predominant chief mourners in archaic verse epitaphs. Another important consideration might lie in the correlation between epigrams and the typology of grave markers that bore them: most archaic Attic verse epitaphs, especially earlier ones, are associated with monuments that probably included a depiction of the deceased, either sculptural, in relief/round, or painted. Epigrams not infrequently refer to the beauty of the monument, and even when they do not, it would be a fair guess that the sculptured grave markers that accompanied the epitaphs were intended to be impressive and pleasing to look at. For Greeks of the archaic period beauty was associated with men of young or mature, but not old, age. Only towards the end of the sixth century do there first appear dignified depictions of older men in monumental art, and only in the late fifth century do representations of both older men and women become common and iconographically developed. Burial sites of older people who were members of the elite must have been marked in some conspicuous but different, perhaps more conservative, way, such as, for example, with brick or limestone house-tombs, the construction of which continued throughout the sixth century, although on a smaller scale than in the seventh. 57 Or, there could have been a plain stele with a sphinx; the absence of inscriptions does not allow 56
It might have been found in the Kerameikos, but this information depends on dealers' stories and is unreliable, see IGAA, pp. 117-118, no. 2. For a photograph of the base, see IGAA, pl. 32:c; for a possible ' restoration of the monument as a composite stele, see Richter 1961, p. 26. 57 See my analysis of 61 below.
Reproduced with permission of the copyright owner. Further reproduction prohibited without permission.
I. ARCHAIC ATIIC VERSE EPITAPHS
31
one to interpret numerous fmds that might or might not have been associated with burials. What does survive suggests that in archaic Attica a verse epitaph was one of the elements that was integral to the beauty of the memorial as a whole, and consequently most of the epigrams accompanied what was believed to be a beautiful depiction, that is a depiction of a young or perhaps middle-aged person, whose untimely death the epigram would lament. Interestingly, archaic verse epitaphs in which children are said to have been responsible for the commemoration of their parents cluster around the end of the sixth century (57, 61, 64), at the time of the appearance of older men in funerary sculpture. 58 Nevertheless, no archaic epitaph explicitly refers, as far as I know, to the old age of the deceased. Epitaphs of this type first appear in the late fifth century, when they include, in addition to the reference to old age, reference to the deceased's long and happy life. There is, however, one epitaph (67=JG 13 1258, ea. 500?) that seems to contradict the statement that the elderly were not honored with epitaphs in the archaic period; for this epitaph has been thought to allude to "mature death." Three extant fragments have been assembled to form an unusually wide and thin stele or plaque (H. 0.515 m, W. 0.735 m, Th. 0.07 m), with the bottom part broken off.
The letters are very large (0.045 m) and
carefully incised. Hansen prints the following text:
[cr6]q>pov, eu[xcrvlv]ETOS, xcre[VtKI6]s. m[vu]:ros, TCx I Ka~· [eioo]s hopl[a(o eavaT]O J•.lOI[ipav hexeh Xcrl[-- non plus quam 6/itt. - -] Prudent, quick-witted, hospitable, discreet, knowing good ways, X-has the lot of mature death ...
Upon examination of the stone, Joseph Day reports that in line 3 restoration, is to be preferred;" 59 the editors of IG
"m[cr1~:r6s,
the old
e 1258, upon examination of a squeeze,
keep the restoration m[crcr]:ros. Hansen, however, rejects this restoration primarily on philological grounds and suggests that the deceased of this epitaph was a paterfamilias whom the word mvuT6S would better suit. The idea of the deceased being old in turn 58
Stelai of the man-and-dog type usually represent older men (for discussion of the type, see Clairmont 1970, pp. 28-31; see also Hiller 1975, pp. 152-154, 156-158, and 177-179, with pis. 5:1-3, 7:2, and 19:1 correspondingly); employment of the type of seated statues suitable for representation of older men becomes wider at the end of the century (57, 58, which are both incised on the bases of seated statues). 59 Day 1985a, p. 376. The "older" restoration in /G 12 1026b is actually m[oo]T6s, that is the same as accepted by the editors of IG 1258. Photographs of the stone (e.g. in /GAA, pl. 39:c; ~r Harder 1943, p. 114, who also provides a drawing of the inscription) seem to show no traces between m and T6s, and I can see no traces of a tau, either, which suggests to me that the squeeze (consulted by the editors ofiG 1258) is of less help than personal examination of the fragments (as done by Day).
e
e
Reproduced with permission of the copyright owner. Further reproduction prohibited without permission.
I. ARCHAIC ATTIC VERSE EPITAPHS
32
prompted the (supplemented) reference to "mature death" at the beginning of the second verse. 60 The inscription is very fragmentary and the restorations have to be accepted with caution, even though the text appears to have been incised stoichedon. 61
Although the
restoration of the pentameter appears convincing, it poses some difficulties. First, as stated above, no archaic epigram in Attica (or, for that matter, in other parts of Greece) refers to the old age of the deceased. Secondly, the expression "he has the lot of mature death" strikes me as odd and is unparalleled. Xenophon does employ the expression 8avaToc; wpaloc; in reference to Agesilaos, 62 but notably it goes along with evKAeilc; !3ioc;, that is it conforms to the diction of fourth century epitaphs in which the mentioning of the old age of the deceased is always accompanied by a reference to his or her long and happy or praiseworthy life. 63 Still, even in fourth century sources the word wpaloc; more often denotes the prime or blossom of youth. Although I cannot propose any convincing restoration, I want to point out that the existing one is very tenuous 64 and that if the first word of the second verse was related to or was some form of wpaloc;, it was likelier to denote a youth or adult (as opposed to a child), but not an old person. 65 If this is correct, m[cr1~:r6c;, as seen by Day, poses no problem since it is more than suitable for a young man. Death before marriage might have been perceived as the most grievous fate for a woman. One of the earliest and most heartbreaking Attic verse epitaphs is for Phrasikleia (24, ea. 540?): I.
11.
cre~-ta
pacrtKAeiac;. I K6pe KEKAEOOI-lat I aiel, CxVTl Ycll-lO ITiapa e~v TOVTO I Aaxocr' OVOIJO. 'AptcrT(ov Tlapt[oc; 1-l'ETI]o[ie]?E.
I. The tombstone of Phrasikleia: I shall always be called a maiden, having received, instead of marriage, 66 this name from the gods. 11. Aristion the Parian made me. 60
Defending m[vv1:r6s over m[oo]:r6s Hansen writes: 'in hoc titulo manifeste de patre familias agitur, non de iuvene cui monumentum ab amicis aut amatore positum est' (67). The argument appears to be a circular one. 61 As Jeffery notes, "(t]he stoichedon had failed by the sixth line" (IGAA, p. 141, no. 51), see pl. 39:c, and even a clearer illustration in Harder 1943, p. 114. 62 ElTEITa Se Tl Kat lTAEOV 8pTJVOV OlTEOTIV i1 (jios TE evi
Reproduced with permission of the copyright owner. Further reproduction prohibited without permission.
I. ARCHAIC ATIIC VERSE EPITAPHS
33
The left side surface of the base bears the signature of Aristion from Paros (II), who was also responsible for the monuments that bore verse epitaphs 34, 36, and 41. 67 The verse epitaph (I) decorates the front surface of the upper block of a stepped or pillar-base of limestone, which supported a kore of island marble. 68
Even though the letters were
somewhat obliterated when the block was reused, the high quality of engraving remains apparent. Neatly cut letters are arranged in what is sometimes referred to as the earliest example of Attic stoichedon: most letters are lined up vertically, and those few that are pushed together are the result of the stonecutter's successful attempt to finish each line with a complete word. In 1972, the kore from the monument was found not far from the Panaghia church in Merenda in the wall in which the block carrying the epitaph for Phrasikleia was once built.69 The kore is of very high quality and superbly preserved. The excellent state of preservation, including traces of paint, has permitted the formulation of an interesting interpretation. Jesper Svenbro thinks that the statue was buried shortly after it was completed by some people who wanted to protect it from being destroyed. 70 The threat, he thinks, could not have been coming from the Persians since the sherds discovered around the statue do not support such a late date. Svenbro suggests that Phrasikleia belonged to the Alkmeonid family and that it was with the return of Peisistratos to Athens in ea. 540 that the statue from Phrasikleia's memorial was hidden, in order to avoid the destruction wreaked by Peisistratos and his followers on anything associated with the Alkmeonid family. 71 Svenbro also points out that the -kleos part is common in the names of the Alkmeonids. While the hypothesis is attractive, the support is insufficient. No evidence yet discovered suggests any connection of the Alkmeonid family with the area (that is with the deme Myrrhinous), and names 67
Aristion's name is certain in 34 and plausibly restored in 36 (which is cut by the same letterer and employs the same formula as 34) and in 41 (in which the stone preserves ]ap1os perhaps from[' Ap1aTiov Tl]ap1os). 68 For a photograph of the base see IGAA, pi. 39:a, the dimensions of the base are H. 0.31 m, W. 0.567 m, Th. 0.585 m; for photographs of the statue, see Matsrokostas 1972. 69 Mastrokostas 1972. 70 Svenbro 1993, pp. 12-14. 71 Svenbro relies on Isocrates 16.26: "And during the forty years of civic discord the Alcmeonidae were hated so much more bitterly than all other Athenians by the tyrants that whenever the tyrants had the upper hand they not only razed their dwellings, but even dug up their tombs" (G. Norlin, trans., Cambridge, Mass./London 1980). Svenbro interprets Isocrates' remark as referring to the year 540, when "Peisistratos returned to Athens, expelling the Alcmaeonid family" (p. 12). It should be noted, however, that Isocrates' assignment of the destruction of the burials of the Alkmeonids (which Thucydides 1.126.12 associates with Kleomenes' intervention in 508) to the Peisistratid period is not trustworthy (see, e.g. Davies 1971, p. 374) and in any case could not be narrowed down to the year 540.
Reproduced with permission of the copyright owner. Further reproduction prohibited without permission.
I. ARCHAIC ATIIC VERSE EPITAPHS
34
that include the compound -kleos are numerous. 72 The family of Phrasikleia and the circumstances in which her grave statue was buried remain unknown. Another early verse epitaph which most likely commemorates a woman who died before marriage is also associated with a statue of a kore (18, ea. 550-540): [--- 9-10--]
.1.
[non plus quam 6-7 /itt.]l1..1e q>IAes :TimBos vvvvv(v)l KaTeBeKev:
KaAOV iBev I OfVTCxp : atBll..lOS : epyaaaiTo ... set me [as the tombstone?] of the dear daughter, beautiful to behold. Phaidimos worked it.
The epigram is incised on the upper block of a four-stepped base which was surmounted by a kore; all the fragments of the memorial were found in Vourva in central Attica. The statue and the upper block of the base are of island marble, and the rest of the base is limestone. The letters are carefully and deeply cut, and splitting of a word at line end is avoided (the last two letters ofthe inscription, TO, are inscribed boustrophedon at the right edge of the block). Punctuation marks are used to separate group of words. 73 Although the hexameter is badly preserved, it seems clear that the woman was commemorated by her parent(s), who lamented her as their q>tATJ Tiais. At least two early Attic verse epitaphs were inscribed on monuments for two children, brother and sister. Remarkably, both monuments are tall stelai of the early archaic type, which never features a depiction of a woman alone. It seems therefore that a woman could be commemorated on a stele only with a man, which might mean that the parents would choose this type of grave marker either in cases when both children died together (for example, in a shipwreck or from disease), or when a girl predeceased the man. I doubt that economic reasons played too significant a role in setting up one stele for two people. Perhaps more important was the extremely grievous loss that was expressed by the inclusion of both children in a single monument; combining the two also indicated that they were, in death, together in Hades. One of the most famous examples of archaic Attic funerary sculpture, the so-called boy-and-girl stele from the Metropolitan Museum, appears to commemorate a pair of siblings. The shaft of this magnificent stele, 74 which was surmounted by a sphinx, bears a relief 72 On the other hand, the name Phrasikleides is attested in a propertied family of the deme ofMyrrhinous in the fourth century, Davies 1971, p. 558, no. 14980. 73 For a good photograph of this inscription, see Richter 1961, fig. 200. The dimensions of the block are H. 0.295 m, W. 0.556 m, Th. 0.588 m. 74 Even apart from the artwork, the mere height of this monument, 4.234 m, is impressive. For photographs, measurements, and detailed discussion of the monument see Richter 1961, pp. 27-29, no. 37, figs. 96-109, 190, and 204.
Reproduced with permission of the copyright owner. Further reproduction prohibited without permission.
I. ARCHAIC AITIC VERSE EPITAPHS
35
depicting a youth and a girl. The monument is exceptionally well preserved, but unfortunately the epitaph which is incised on the base, survives only fragmentarily (25, ea. 540-535): 1-lVEI-la
It has been suggested that the monument was connected with the Alkmeonid family. The
hypothesis is based on two considerations: first, it seems that the stele was destroyed soon after it was erected; secondly, the restoration 1-lE[yaKAei in the first line, which has been accepted by several scholars, points to the Alkmeonids (this consideration seems to involve a degree of question-begging).
The suggestion has been convincingly challenged by
Margherita Guarducci who shows that the restoration of the name Megakles is but one of numerous possibilities.75 Davies is certainly right too in his conclusion that "since moreover the fmd-spot is uncertain, the question remains open."76 The relationship of the epitaph to the relief has been much discussed. The father is clearly said to be responsible for the monument, but the role of the mother-whether she is commemorated along with the children, or commemorates them, along with the fatherhas been the subject of debate. 77 It seems most plausible that the monument was set up to commemorate both the brother and the sister, which explains her presence on the relief and appearance as a young girl. The sculptor here employs the iconography of a standing youth, which was common at this time, and the figure of a girl is a clear addition to the existing scheme. The female figure could hardly have been decorative or subsidiary since such figures were generally depicted either in the predella or on the capital of the stele. It seems more likely therefore that the relief represents the deceased who were buried where the stele stood. As for the sister's name, Guarducci believes that it was in the lost part of verse 1, since, she claims, "there is no doubt that it must have appeared in the inscription."78 This is 75
See Guarducci's discussion (in the appendix to Richter 1961, pp. 159-164), in which she summarizes well earlier interpretations. 76 Davies 1971, p. 374; Clairmont 1970, pp. 13-15; JGAA, pp. 146-147, no. 48. 77 For the latter interpretation, see Peek 1942, p. 86, Clairmont 1970, pp. 13-15, et al. Clairmont follows Peek (who believes that the monument was for a mother and son) in understanding oliv as joining the references to the individuals who were buried together, but he suggests that the hexameter mentioned the brother and the sister, while the pentameter introduced their mother, who was also buried with (oliv) them. 78 Guarducci in Richter 1961, p. 159.
Reproduced with permission of the copyright owner. Further reproduction prohibited without permission.
I. ARCHAIC ATIIC VERSE EPITAPHS
36
not necessarily the case, since, as we will see in Section 3 below, other epitaphs do not always name the commemorated children. I think that 25 could therefore have had a reference to the sister without naming her. The 1-lirrnp in the epitaph then is one of the commemorating parents, along with the father, and not the commemorated deceased; the lost half of the pentameter could have been a formula of grief, such as Tiailia 6Aocpup61..levos (or
6Aocpup61..lEVOl or 6Aocpupl-lEVTJ), the expression employed in the epitaph for Chairedemos (14). 79 Although the surviving text of 25 has no explicit verb of lament, the repetition of cp(A-
words and the description of one of the commemorated children as 8avwv contribute to the expression of grief on the part of the parents. The fragmentary monument with epitaph 26, which also commemorates siblings, preserves the entire text of the epigram but the shaft of the stele is lost. The inscription is incised on the lower part of a broken stele; 80 the surviving fragment is well picked on the back side, which suggests that it was likely the bottom panel of a tall monolithic stele. The epitaph was probably engraved in the predella of the stele, the shaft of which might have carried a depiction of a man and a girl in relief, as in the boy-and-girl stele (25), or a painting; it could also have depicted only the boy. 81 Obviously, we carmot assess the quality of the artwork of the lost shaft, but the fact that a famous sculptor, Phaidimos, signed the work suggests that it could hardly have been of poor quality. 82 The epigram consists of three iambic trimeters (26, ea, 540-530?):
T68' 'Apxlo 'oTt oel-la: Kal8eAcpes cp!Aes,: EvKoviOI..llOES : Se TOOT' eTiolleoev KaA6v,: OTEAelv: 8' eTI' miTot : 8eKe la(Oll-lOOOcp6s. This is the tombstone of Archias and his dear sister. Eukosmides built this tomb well, and skilled Phaidimos placed a stele on it.
79
If we were to fit in two children, I would suggest something like TeKv' 6:\ocpvp6J.1EVOS (or 6Aocpvp6J.lEVOI or 6:\ocpvpOJ..lEVTJ), but I have reservations about the word TEKVOV in an epitaph of such an early date and in reference to a youth. 80 IGAA, pp. 139-140, no. 48, pi. 38:c; Harrison 1956, p. 29, note 7, and p. 33, note 22. The dimensions of the fragment are H. 0.51 m, W. 0.46-0.48 m, Th. 0.165-0.17 m. 81 If the surviving fragment is in fact the predella, its height suggests to me that the original stele was of the early type in which the height of the predella exceeds its width. A parallel can be seen in the stele of a warrior from the National Museum in Athens (inv. no. 2687), which measures H. 2.395 m, W. 0.37-0.44 m, Th. 0.1450.166 m, and dates to ea. 560, see Richter 1961, p. 22, no. 27, figs. 83-85. 82 See my discussion of artists' signatures in Section 6.
Reproduced with permission of the copyright owner. Further reproduction prohibited without permission.
37
I. ARCHAIC ATTIC VERSE EPITAPHS
The lettering is not superb, but punctuation marks are employed to assist reading. The verse is metrically correct, and the choice of meter was presumably dictated by the names Eukosmides and Archias, which could theoretically have fit dactylic meter but could scan much more easily in iambic. The name of Archias' sister was not included; perhaps the identification of her through her bother was felt sufficient.
She is described as "dear,"
(KaTa
as, for example, in the short iambic epitaph for Myrrhine (49, ea. 520-500?): [oiJ~-tot 8av6oes ei~-tll [oe]~-ta Mvpives. Alas! Of a deceased woman I am the tomb-marker, one named Myrrhine.
This epitaph curiously displays some affinity to the oil-lOt-type epitaphs from Selinus. 84 Perhaps Myrrhine was a foreigner, or there could have been an independent tradition in Attica of epitaphs that started with an exclamation of lament: there survives a prose epitaph for Pediarchos which also opens with oi~-tot. 85 The stone with Myrrhine's epitaph is lost and thus it is impossible to judge what type of monument it once belonged to; it appears that even the dimensions of the stone were not recorded, although there exists a drawing of the inscription. 83
These references are characteristic of the archaic period and are fairly uncommon in verse epitaphs of the later classical period. 84 Wallace 1970, pp. 95-97. 85 In epitaphs from Selinus o'h.101 usually employed with the vocative of the name of the deceased, "Alas, o so-and-so!" or separately as an absolute cry "Alas!" (see IGLPa/ermo 78,79, 82, 82, 84, 86, 88, 89, 92, 95-97; but LSAG, p. 276, no. 21 from Hyb1a Heraia has the name of the deceased in the genitive). The construction of oi1.101 with the genitive seems to mean "0, alas for thee (or for him or her)!" as in the epitaph for Pediarchos, IG 1267, cf. Sophocles Ant. 82. Jeffery thinks that in Myrrhine's epitaph there is "a conflation of two stock formulas: oi1.101 MvppiVl')) (KTA.) and Mvppivl')) ei1.11 ofilla (KTA.)" (IGAA p. 142 no. 54). I wonder, however, whether a full stop is intended after oi1.101 which was to be understood as an absolute exclamation "Alas!" Cf. 'Ayaoia El.lli TO oCi1.1a Tlo Kapia. oil1.101, JGLPalermo 84).
e
Reproduced with permission of the copyright owner. Further reproduction prohibited without permission.
I. ARCHAIC ATIIC VERSE EPITAPHS
38
An interesting verse epitaph for a foreign resident86 of Athens, Anaxilas from Naxos, describes the monument as lamenting the deceased (58, ea. 510-500?):
OaKpv6ev 1TOAV1TEV8es 'AvaxoiAa eo' 6Ao
Anaxilas' tomb was in the Kerameikos and his grave marker consisted of a large base of island marble which was probably surmounted by a seated statue. 87 Anaxilas is praised on account of the "conventional" virtues of ocu
6Ao
noAvnev8es are elevated Homeric epithets which are often employed in archaic poetry. The word 6Ao
describe the Mnvov
~ve~a,
which suggests the metaphorical equation of Aatvov and enos,
deftly appropriate for a monument with a verse epitaph.
4. Chief Mourner Identitv of the Chief Mourner When a person dies, one or more persons take charge. The "paradigm case" is when a man dies and there is an adult son at home or within reasonable distance who steps in. His legal position is that of the heir who enters upon the property; he becomes the kyrios of the oikos of the deceased and of his widowed mother, if she is alive. Funerary disbursements 86 87
For discussion of the possible meaning of~ETEOtKov, see Whitehead 1977, p. 64, note 44, and p. 168, note 24. For the dimensions of the base see note 53.
Reproduced with permission of the copyright owner. Further reproduction prohibited without permission.
I. ARCHAIC ATIIC VERSE EPITAPHS
39
are made by him; he arranges for the funerals, supervises the workmen, and negotiates with a sculptor (these are his practical responsibilities). He is acting on behalfofthe whole oikos, and so he is referred to in the epitaph, but other prominent members of the oikos may be mentioned too in any extended epitaph (this reflects social concerns). Certainly, there were numerous cases that did not conform to this paradigm, because, for example, a man had no male children or they were not around, or children predeceased their parents (and many other scenarios can be thought of). Furthermore, the legal, practical and social position could coincide but could also be different and reflect a departure from the paradigmatic situation which I just described. In fact, it appears that the case in which parents bury their children, which was perceived as abnormal, was the most common situation referred to in a verse epitaph. Approximately 30 archaic Attic epitaphs refer in some way, explicitly or implicitly, to the chief mourner who buried the deceased and set up a grave marker over the burial. When the father is the chief mourner, as in twelve epitaphs, he is acknowledged as such, or his role is referred to indirectly (for example, through calling the deceased a child and mentioning the father's name) (14; 25; 32; 41; 42; 46; 50; 51; 53, 55, 68; 71); references to mothers occur in four epitaphs (33, 35, 43, 54); in two cases it is not entirely clear whether the epitaph refers to both parents or only to one (18, 25); in one verse epitaph the mourner is the husband, along with the mother of the deceased (54); one mourner is the brother (70); in three verse epitaphs children bury their parent(s) (57, 61, 64); in nine more cases the relation of the chief mourner to the deceased is either not stated (26, 40, 58, 66) or cannot be determined from the surviving fragments (15, 16, 45, 65, 74). Thus, in 17 out of 25 (we have to disregard five fragmentary epitaphs), that is in 68%, parents are referred to as chief mourners, whereas children are said to bury their parents in 3 verse epitaphs (12%). These figures show that putting up a verse epitaph must have been a means to commemorate particularly grievous deaths, that of children, and not part of any common "duty to the dead," such as a proper and reverent burial, which would have been rendered to both young and old. From a legal point of view the burial and marking of the burial with a monument should have been carried out by the heir of the deceased, and a woman could not be responsible for these arrangements. Practically speaking, though, women were likely to have
Reproduced with permission of the copyright owner. Further reproduction prohibited without permission.
I. ARCHAIC ATTIC VERSE EPITAPHS
40
had a say or even played a part in these arrangements; socially, they could be mentioned in the epitaph as responsible for the monument and lamenting the dead. Several verse epitaphs refer to a woman as the chief mourner along with a another male family member. As we have seen, in two epitaphs mothers join fathers in lamenting their children; in one epitaph the mother seems to join her son-in-law in commemorating her daughter and his wife (54, ea. 510-500?):
"O
I.
I. Opsios for his wife and Apsynthie for her daughter set this memorial up for the deceased Oinanthe. 11. And this too Aristokles made.
Some scholars suggest that the deceased is Oinanthe, wife of Opsios 88 and daughter of Apsynthie; 89 others that the deceased Oinanthe is the daughter of Opsios, while Apsynthie, who is also deceased, is his wife and the mother of Oinanthe. 90 The first interpretation seems more plausible since the name of Oinanthe is certainly in the genitive case and tied closely to the expression 1-lVEI-la KaTa
The
typology of this stele, which is wide 92 and likely to have represented a seated figure (perhaps with an attendant), is consistent with a few other grave memorials for women from the latter part of the sixth century; 93 the monument is signed by Aristocles who is securely attested in at least three more inscriptions. Reference in an epitaph to a woman acting together with a man as chief mourners is by no means surprising. It is more surprising to encounter in archaic Attica an epitaph 88
The name is perhaps attested in two dedicatory inscriptions, IG 13 754 and 763, both ea. 500-480? but the three might well be different people. 89 So Stauropoullos 1965, p. 86, no.1; Daux 1973, pp. 249-251; Viviers 1992, pp. 133-139. 90 Robert 1968, p. 448, no. 195; Clairmont 1970, p. 15, note 13. The editors of LGPNII also consider Oinanthe to be the daughter ofOpsios and daughter(?) of Apsynthie, s.v. Oivav6n (1). 91 Davies 1971, pp. 299-300. Viviers (1992, pp. 138-139) suggests that both Apsynthie and Oinanthe were Ionians, but there is little ground for this hypothesis. 92 The dimensions of the base are H. 0.235 m, L. 0.845 m, Th. 0.355 m; and those of the cutting: L. 0.68 m, W. 0.11 m; for a detailed description and a photograph, see Viviers 1992, pp. 133-139, fig. 32 93 IGAA, pp. 149-150, Vivers 1992, pp. 208-218.
Reproduced with permission of the copyright owner. Further reproduction prohibited without permission.
I. ARCHAIC ATIIC VERSE EPITAPHS
41
in which no male mourner is mentioned and only a woman is said to be responsible for the burial, which, from a strictly legal point of view, she could not have been. The mother of Aisimides (?)94 had her son's tombstone inscribed with an hexameter (35, ea. 530?): ~imp[{8o T6]8E [ae]h..ta
The epitaph is inscribed on a large block of limestone (perhaps the top block of a stepped base), 95 which bears traces of stucco and has a cutting for a thick stele. It was found in the Kerameikos. The lettering is not particularly careful but, as Jeffery points out, is somewhat close to the boy-and-girl inscription (25), which stood on a magnificent monument. 96 Yet, in Aisimides' epitaph, which resembles a metrically arranged label, no punctuation marks are employed, and line and word ends do not correspond. As a result, the word at the end of each line is interrupted and carried over to the next, and the resulting appearance could not have been very impressive. The quality of the sculpture is impossible to assess, but the sheer size of the surviving base must indicate a costly monument. Epigram 43 (ea. 525?) probably spoke of the mother of the deceased as either the sole chief mourner or as eo-mourner, along with another male relation, but the inscription is so poorly preserved that little can be deduced from it. Only half of the marble base on which the text was inscribed survives. The long base97 most likely supported two columns or two vases with a stele situated between them. The inscription consists of three lines written stoichedon, and fifteen letters survive from each line. Hansen98 believes that originally it was an epigram in three couplets, which, if so, would make it one of the longest elegiac epitaphs in early archaic Attica (another one being 58, of a slightly later date, ea. 510-500?) and second in Greece only to the Ambracia epitaph (SEG 41.540), which consisted of five couplets. Because 43 is so fragmentary, the possibility cannot be excluded that the base bore two independent inscriptions commemorating two deceased individuals, or, on the contrary, that the epigram was hexametric and consisted only of three or four verses. The preserved part of the text undoubtedly has the word J.l.TlTllP in the nominative case preceded Jeffery rules out Peek's suggestion to read Tl]a~~::n~[axot, which would require an ypsilon of a very archaic shape, IGAA, pp. 119-120, no. 7. 95 The dimensions of the block are H. 0.39 m; L. 0.8 m; Th. 0.91-0.92 m; for a photograph see IGAA, pi. 33:c. 96 JGAA, pp. 119-120, no. 7. 97 The dimensions ofthe preserved part are H. 0.267 m, p.L. 1.105 m, Th. 0.967 m. 98 For a detailed discussion of this epitaph and the monument, see Hansen 1976. 94
Reproduced with permission of the copyright owner. Further reproduction prohibited without permission.
I. ARCHAIC ATTIC VERSE EPITAPHS
42
by the demonstrative T6Se (line 2) and the first person verb 6.Aoqnipol-!at (line 3). It may be, therefore, that the mother was mentioned in the text as the chief mourner, but there is no way to know whether there was also a reference to the father or some other person, as in the boy-and-girl monument. Although it is tempting to see the nominative 1-ltlTllP as the subject of 6.Aocpvpol-!at, one should remember that these words might have been separated by one and a half verses, in which a subject of the first person verb could have been introduced. 99 In total, there are six Attic archaic verse epitaphs that mention surviving females, 100
but in only one of them (35) is a woman singled out as responsible for the burial. Perhaps an epitaph from Troezen (138, ea. 550-525?), the first verse of which resembles the epitaph to Aisimides, 101 offers some insight into occasions in which mothers would assume the responsibility for setting up the grave monument: .6ai-!OTii-!Ol : ToSe Ocll-!0 :
Amphidama would not have been responsible for the burial if there were other children in the house, brothers ofDamotimos. We may also assume that Damotimos' father had passed away before him. Perhaps, Aisimides' mother was in a similar situation and participated actively in the arrangements for his burial, although she, being an Athenian, must have had a kyrios who legally would have been in charge of the commemoration of Aisimides. He might have delegated funeral arrangements to her and did not object to an epitaph which referred only to her. Archaic Attic verse epitaphs never mention relatives beyond parents, children, siblings and spouses, although there must have been situations when an oikos (and so the responsibility for burying the deceased head of this oikos) would be passed to an uncle or cousin or nephew. Perhaps in this case the mother could have had greater involvement 99
Hansen (1976, p. 160) suggests that the reader of the inscription could be the intended subject of the firstfterson verb. 00 25, 33, 35, 43, 54, 61. Theosemos' epitaph (74, ea. 500-480?) might have included a reference to his wife, but it also could have been to a friend, who was named at the end of the verse, so I cast this epitaph with other "undeterminable" chief mourners; I follow Wallace in considering 37 and 38 to be prose (1985, pp. 316-317), and furthermore I am unsure whether 37 is sepulchral. 101 This resemblance, of course, does not suggest any direct influence, but shows once again that hexametric record-type epitaphs display little variety throughout different parts of Greece during the sixth and even fifth centuries.
Reproduced with permission of the copyright owner. Further reproduction prohibited without permission.
I. ARCHAIC ATTIC VERSE EPITAPHS
43
in the funerary arrangements-and would have been likelier to refer to it in the epitaphthan in those cases when the oikos was passed to immediate kin. One epitaph is particularly interesting in offering insight into funerary arrangements after the death of the head of the oikos (61, ea. 510-500?): ~[i]y~e.e[---
-ea. 10--- J.epvAioo,
ho Tooe oe11a I
[TI]~iOes
eTioieoav [1-le]T[p]os
e
Radiant (?) ... -erulides, for whom this tomb his children made at the command of their mother.
Even though the first line is badly preserved, the general sense and construction of the epigram is clear. It provides a conventional record stating that the children set up the tomb for their father, but also adds that the children did so at the command of their mother. 102 The epigram is one of only three archaic Attic verse epitaphs in which children are said to commemorate parent(s), but it might reflect the situation that I called in the beginning of this section "paradigmatic."
The sons would be legally and practically responsible for the
monument, and in the eyes of the law the mother could only express her wishes; in real life, however, her wishes in such a matter as the funeral arrangements and grave monument for her deceased husband were perhaps rather a behest than a request. The sons might have been still young and wished to emphasize their compliance to their mother's will, while she might have wanted the epitaph to emphasize the fact that the sons were adult and capable of carrying out funerary responsibilities. The type of monument on which this epitaph is inscribed is rather uncommon for grave monuments with epigrams: the epitaph is incised on "two adjoining blocks [of limestone] from the lower course of a large monument, perhaps, a 'house-tomb' or a long stepped base." 103 The limestone is stuccoed. The dimensions of this praegrandis base, as the editors of JG 13 1226 call it, are H. 0.49 m, L. 2.40 m; the monument is likely to have been set up in the Kerameikos, because the base was built into and still is in the Themistoklean wall by the Sacred Gate. 104 Peek relates that at least eighteen more limestone blocks, some with traces of stucco, were found built into the wall nearby, and these finds have led him to propose the restoration of a house-tomb type memorial. Jeffery contends that a stepped 102
For the expression, cf. a fifth century dedicatory (?) inscription from Thessaly (343): [- - - I ?BeKchav 6e]oav I ['A1TOAA]c.:lVI vv(v)l [1TaiO]es enpolll[a]xo: 1TaTpos V I E
Reproduced with permission of the copyright owner. Further reproduction prohibited without permission.
I. ARCHAIC AITIC VERSE EPITAPHS
44
base could be a possibility, for example, for an equestrian statue. Still, the dimensions appear too big even for the lower course of a stepped base; furthermore, as a rule, the upper and not the lower block of a stepped base carried the inscription. The base of the equestrian monument of Xenophantes (50, ea. 510?), also found built into the Themistoklean wall/ 05 has the dimensions H. 0.26 m, W. 0.57 m, Th. 1.655 m, and the inscription is placed on the shorter side, while 61 is incised on the long side of the base. A house-tomb, therefore, is the likelier candidate for 61. This type was perhaps considered more appropriate for the grave of an older man. It was perhaps also viewed as more traditional: the surviving evidence shows little change in the construction of house-tombs throughout the sixth century. Although house-tombs must have been decorated, 106 they were conspicuous mainly for their size and for the space around the tomb, much the same as the tumuli and brick tombs of the earlier period, and this type of memorial permitted a certain grandeur that did not rely on sculpture, which in the archaic period tended to depict only the young. It might well be the case, therefore, that the widow of the deceased in 61 opted for what was viewed as a more traditional monument befitting the grave of an older man. Grief of the Chief Mourner In many archaic verse epitaphs the reference to the chief mourner, either by name or by relation (for example, naTfJp or J..ITJTTJP ), is accompanied by an expression of his or her grief. In the epitaph for Chairedemos (14) his father Amphichares is 6Ae
It was discovered after the publication of IGAA. It is not entirely clear how they were decorated. Boardman (1955, pp. 51-58) suggests that numerous surviving painted clay plaques were placed, in series or singularly, on the house-tombs, but confesses that there is no material evidence for this practice. 106
Reproduced with permission of the copyright owner. Further reproduction prohibited without permission.
45
I. ARCHAIC ATTIC VERSE EPITAPHS
5. Address to a Passer-by and Reflections Verse epitaphs often directly address the reader by asking him to lament the deceased and also by reminding him of his own inevitable death. Addressing a passer-by seems to have appeared in Greek verse epitaphs with the advance of elegiac meter in inscriptional verse.
The earliest surviving Attic epitaph-the one for Tettichos (13), which is also
probably the earliest surviving inscriptional elegiac couplet, addressed and admonished the passer-by; Kroisos' epitaph (27) also asked the passer-by to stop and lament the deceased. As mentioned above, Attic epitaphs that address the passer-by do not name the chief mourner. Perhaps the very address to the reader with the request to lament the deceased was thought to ensure that the reader assumed the role of the mourner and, with the mourner no more confined to a certain person from the family of the deceased, the epitaph was elevated to the level of a public message. This is probably why commemoration of death in war was especially conducive to epitaphs containing the address to a passer-by (13, 27, SEG 41.540), and perhaps it was in fact first employed in an epitaph for a man who fell on the battlefield. Having appeared in Attic epitaphs in the second quarter of the sixth century, the address to the passer-by eventually became used in elegiac verse epitaphs in other parts of Greece (SEG 41.540 from Ambracia; 159 from Thasos; 117 from Thessaly-a patchwork of somewhat later date, ea. 480-450?), and in Attica itself. Thus, the expression with which the passer-by is addressed in Kroisos' epitaph appears in the pentameter of the epitaph for Thrason (28, ea. 540-530?):
av8po1TE hO<JTElXE[I]S: Ka8' ooolv :
The reason why the passer-by should lament the deceased is formulated in Thrason's epitaph in one word, io6v (=iowv), with the implication that, having beheld the monument, the passer-by would naturally lament the loss of such a man.
The monument most likely
featured a tall stele with a relief depicting Thrason, and probably stood at the side of the Dromos or the Sacred Way, 107 and thus it was observed by numerous wayfarers. The epitaph 107
The epitaph is carved on the upper block of a stepped base (H. 0.205 m, W. 0.79 m, Th. 0.53 m; the cutting for the stele measures L. 0.48 m, W. 0.166 m, D. 0.10 m), which was built into the Themistoklean wall by the 37:e-f; Viviers 1992, p. 122, fig. 28. The measurements Dipylon Gate, IGAA, pp. 132-133, no. 33, pl. of the base and the cutting for the stele suggests that the latter was a tall stele similar to, for example, the stele from the National Museum in Athens (inv. no. 2687}, Richter 1961, p. 23, no. 27, figs. 83-85.
Reproduced with permission of the copyright owner. Further reproduction prohibited without permission.
I. ARCHAIC ATTIC VERSE EPITAPHS
46
has no word of praise for the deceased because, presumably, the reference to the visual representation was felt sufficient to arouse grief and demand lament for the loss of such a man. It should also be noted that the inscription is very carefully executed: the letters are neatly carved, punctuation marks and guidelines are employed, and the text is evenly spread over three lines (the first two lines have 23 letters each, and in the third line, which has 27 letters, the cutter skillfully pushed the letters closer to each other). An appeal to the passer-by to lament the deceased could also be justified by a gnomic generalization, as seen in the following inscription (34, ea. 530?): 108 I.
[' A]VTIAOXO : lTOTt OE!l' aya8o I Kat a6cppovos avop6sl
II.
[oaKpv K1?:r~p[x1~ov, _e:ret K?t I ae 11evet 8avaTos. 'AptcrTiov I 11' eTI6eaev.
I. In front of the tomb of Antilochos, an excellent and wise man, shed a tear, since death awaits you too. 11. Aristion made me.
This epitaph includes little that might be considered specific to the deceased, and could have stood on the grave of any Athenian aristocrat. The fact that the deceased belonged to a certain type of men, the aya8ot Kat awcppOVES, appears to have been considered more important than any peculiar information about the deceased. The gnomic expression in the pentameter seems to encourage the passer-by to reflect on his own life and is reminiscent of the ending of the epitaph for Tettichos, vea8e eTit Tipay11' aya86v. Expressions of admonition and addressing the passer-by are confined in archaic Attica to elegiac epitaphs, but generalizations can be employed in hexametric epitaphs, too (40, ea. 530-520?): 109
:olTIKAEOS 1Tat00S ~a!lalatcrTpcXTO ev8aoe OE!la I Tletmavaxs KaTe8eKe· To I yap yepas ecrTt 8av6vTo[s]. This is the tomb of Epikles son of Damasistratos. Peisianax set it up, because this is what is due the dead.
The second verse employs a Homeric formula, 11. 16.457, 675 and 23.9, and Od. 24.190, 296; the first verse by itself would suffice as an epitaph, but the chief mourner evidently wanted 108
Epitaph (I) is incised on the front face of the upper block (H. 0.21 m, p.W. 0.68 m, Th. 0.70 m), and the signature (11) is on the left side face of the stepped base, which perhaps carried a column, IGAA, p. 120, no. 8, Pc!. 34:a-c. 09 The epitaphs is incised on the upper block (H. 0.22 m, W. 0.70 m, Th. 0.705 m) of the stepped base which preserves a cutting for a wide and thick (L. 0.53 m, W. 0.19 m, D. 0.085 m) stele, IGAA, pp. 144-145, no. 58, pi. 40:a. The text in line 4 (that starts with yap) is cut in rasura, but the reason why the original text had been erased is not clear.
Reproduced with permission of the copyright owner. Further reproduction prohibited without permission.
47
I. ARCHAIC ATIIC VERSE EPITAPHS
his name to be included, and inclusion of it gave him one and a half verses. The end of the second verse was then easily filled with an appropriate formula. 6. Monument
Sight of the Monument As we have seen in the epitaph for Thrason and others, the fact the monument was intended to be viewed could be taken into account by the composer of the verse epitaph. In some cases, the representation of the deceased is invoked as a way of praising the deceased 110 and is seen as strengthening the request to the passer-by to lament him or her; in others, reference to the sight of the monument, which must have featured a depiction of the deceased, emphasizes the impossibility of seeing the deceased himself, who is held by death (46, ea. 525-500?): 111 OEj..la
hov 8avaTo[s BaKpv]l6es Ka8[e]xet.
Diodorus set up for all to see this tomb to his dear son, Stesias, whom tearful death holds.
112
Another example in which the sight of the deceased's tomb is meant to elicit grief is found in an epitaph for Smikythos (51, ea. 510?): 113 oiKTtpo npoaopo[v] lnmBos T6Be ae~-ta I 8av6vTos : ~j..llKV8[o]
I h6s TE
Lament as you see the tomb of the deceased child, Smikythos, who destroyed the hope of those dear to him.
And we encounter a similar expression in the epitaph for Kleoites (68, ea. 500?t 4 : nat[Bo]s [an]?
Thus, for example, 19, the fragmentary epitaph for Xenokles, seems to say that "having seen" his tomb "one would know (or recognize) prowess." 111 The stone with the epitaph is lost, so it is unclear to what type of a monument it once belonged, IGAA, f·12 132, no. 31. An epitaph from Thasos is even more explicit (161, ea. 500-490?): Tj KaMv TO I.IVTU..IO [TTa]ITI)p EOTT]OE 8av6a[T]t]l A~pETT]I' ovyap [ET]h ~waav EOO<J>OOI.I[E8a]. 113
The epitaph is inscribed on the upper block of the stepped base (H. 0.398 m, W. 0.535 m, Th. 0.252 m) which carried a stele, the cutting for which measures L. 0. 45 m, W. 0.11 m. For a photograph, see Viviers 1992,p. 138,fig.33. 114 The epitaph is incised on a block (H. 0.19 m, W. 0.735 m, Th. 0.58 m) of the base, which perhaps carried a stele--since the epitaph is incised on a wide face of the block, Jeffery thinks that the base was probably surmounted by a stele rather than by a kouros, IGAA, p. 147, no. 67, fig. 41 c-d. The base of the monument of Neilonides (42) also had the epitaph inscribed on a wide face (W. 0.715 m, Th. 0.631 m) and supported a statue of a kouros; thus there is, in my opinion, a good possibility that the monument ofKleoites included a kouros. 115 I print the reading ofHansen, CEG 11, p. 301, no. 68, in which he adjusts his earlier text to accord with Day's examination of the stone.
Reproduced with permission of the copyright owner. Further reproduction prohibited without permission.
I. ARCHAIC ATIIC VERSE EPITAPHS
48
At the monument of the deceased Kleoites, child of Menesaichmos, as you look, lament, since he died in the flower of his beauty.
It has been much debated whether both epitaphs employ the imperative forms of the verb
oiKTipc.:> (oiKTtpov and oiKTtpe, respectively) or the first person oiKTipc.:>, but in either case the lamentation is accompanied and enhanced by the reader's viewing of the monument. The grief is also emphasized by additional descriptions of the deceased: Smikythos destroyed the hope of those dear to him; Kleoites was in the flower of his youth--presumably KaA6s refers to the age group, approximately 15 to 25 years old. It might be significant that the epitaphs for Smikythos and for Kleoites allude to the deceased as members of closer circlesthat of their families and friends-than is customary in those Athenian epitaphs which address the passer-by with the request to lament the deceased (13, 27, 28, 34). This consideration suggests to me that the verbs of lament in both epitaphs are rather employed in the first person form than in the imperative, and are meant to evoke some sense of the closeness of the circle of mourners, the friends and relatives of the deceased, who were responsible for burying and setting up the grave monuments. I will return to this question later. In a few other cases the monument itself is described with an epithet denoting beauty,
KaA6v (18, 26) or xapiev (42), and such a description seems to suggest some pride on the part of the chief mourner in setting up a seemly monument wrought by a famous sculptor. Interestingly, while KaA6s is a common word in archaic verse epitaphs, employed to describe either the deceased or his/her monument and burial, the word can hardly be found in later classical epitaphs. 116 Sculptors' Signatures on Monuments with Verse Epitaphs Many archaic funerary monuments, including those that bore verse epitaphs, are signed by sculptors, and in some cases a reference to the artist has been incorporated into the verse epitaph itself. The issue of artistic signatures on gravestones has been a subject of epigraphical, literary and archeological studies, and indeed it pertains to all these fields. The epigraphical approach to the question is exemplified by the groundbreaking study 116
Hansen lists three occurrences, of which one (548) is a possible restoration flagged by a question mark; the next one (ei TO KaAw<; EOTI Saveiv, 595, line 1) is in a line that is likely to have been borrowed from a literary piece, and in any case does not modify the monument or the deceased; and the last (578, line 3, KaAw<;) is in the badly preserved part of a bombastic epitaph for an actor and seems to modify some action on the part of some "heroes," that is it does not seem to be applied to the deceased.
Reproduced with permission of the copyright owner. Further reproduction prohibited without permission.
49
I. ARCHAIC AITIC VERSE EPITAPHS
of Jeffery, who attempted to identify some letter-cutters and trace their connections to workshops of particular sculptors, while also pointing out that the content of epitaphs inscribed on monuments signed by the same sculptor may display some stylistic unity. 117 The literary approach has recently been demonstrated by Ute Ecker who concludes in her study of the literary aspects of verse epitaphs that the artist's signature should be viewed as a guarantee of the quality of the monument and that its purpose is to contribute, along with the verse epitaph, to the glory of the deceased. 118
Scholars of art history and
archeology have investigated sculptors' signatures in order to assess the activities of workshops and schools of sculpture and to outline some artistic tendencies and influences. Two recent works, those of Viviers and Brunilde Ridgway, dealing with various facets of archaic sculpture offer insightful analysis of several issues surrounding the archaic custom of signing sculptural works. 119 I am much indebted to both studies, and would like to analyze what seem to me to be uniquely Attic tendencies in signing works of sculpture and to investigate the Attic phenomena in the broader context of lasting material display at archaic burial sites. The Aegean islands were the main centers for production of large works of round sculpture and relief during the seventh and sixth centuries. In Attica, the art of large marble sculpture was virtually unknown before approximately 600 BC, but within a quarter of a century or so Attica became a center for this art with a large output of works, and the Athenians clearly valued sculpture and individuals' achievements in sculpture. The pride a person took in commissioning a monument from a famous sculptor was so high that it was deemed possible and apparently desirable to have the sculptor sign his work. The fact that the artist would sign the artwork is by no means surprising-numerous vase-painters left their signatures, and the importance of authorship of a famous piece of art is clear from ancient literary sources. 120 It has been noticed, however, that in Athens "masters' signatures do not begin to appear on the citadel until ea. 530, while funerary monuments were already being signed almost thirty years earlier," 121 and that there appears to be some correlation 117
IGAA, pp. 149-153 and passim. Ecker 1990, pp.l32-149, esp. p.137. 119 Viviers 1992, and Ridgway 1993. 120 See, e.g., Stewart 1990, I, pp. 19-32 and pp. 65-72, and Ridgway 1993, pp. 421-431, for discussion of such issues as fame, rewards and self-esteem of Greek sculptors. 121 Ridgway 1993, p. 428. 118
Reproduced with permission of the copyright owner. Further reproduction prohibited without permission.
I. ARCHAIC ATTIC VERSE EPITAPHS
50
between signatures and verse epitaphs. 122 Phaidimos signed three monuments, all bearing verse epitaphs (14, 18, 26), and in two cases (18 and 26) his name was included in the sepulchral epigram along with the reference to the monument as KaA6v. Another sculptor, Aristion from Paros, signed four monuments, all with verse epitaphs (24, 34, 36, 41), three of which use similar expressions to describe the virtues of the deceased: cre1-1' 6:ya8o Kal
cr6
verse epitaphs, and this suggestion is certainly attractive. 123 There might have also been collaboration between the chief mourner and the sculptor or stonecutter. Although a funerary monument might seem to be an unlikely place for an artist's signature to appear, signatures were fairly numerous and often prominently displayed on gravestones in archaic Athens. The fact that signatures on gravestones preceded those on votive monuments is even more surprising. Indeed, prior to approximately 530 all surviving artistic signatures are associated with grave monuments and not with dedications. At least seven grave monuments that date to before ea. 530 are signed, three by Phaidimos and four by Aristion from Paros, while the earliest signed dedications date to the last third of the sixth century (/G 13 1009, which is dated by the editors to ea. 550-540?, is likely to be of later date 124), and only after ea. 510 do signatures on dedications become frequent. 122
IGAA, p. 140, no. 49. Wallace 1984, pp. 310-311; see also Wallace 1970, p. 100, note 16. 124 Jeffery thought that Aristokles worked from the mid- to the end of the sixth century, IGAA, pp. 126-127, no. 18 and p. 152; editors of IG 1009 suggest that there might have been two sculptors of the same name. Viviers (1992, pp. 139-141) dates JG 1009 to the end of the sixth century on the basis of the shape of the nu, and believes that the Aristokles of IG 13 1009 is the same one who worked at the end of the century. It does appear that the letters ofe 1009 are not unlike those ofe 1256, which is signed by Aristokles and is dated ea. 510. The main reason for the early dating of IG 13 1009, ea. 550-540?, is the fact that it is written boustrophedon. Although boustrophedon writing is more common in the middle of the century, there are examples dating to the late 6th and even early 5th cc. See, for example, IG 995, a dedication from Eleusis (ea. 500-450?), which is written from right to left; leges sacrae in the Eleusinion at Athens, JG 13 232, early 5th c., and an epitaph JG 1274bis (540-520?) are written boustrophedon. Another reason to suppose that there were two sculptors by the name Aristokles has been the theory that there was "apparent specialization of workshops and masons. The sculptors and letterers of funerary monuments seem by and large different from those who worked on the acropolis dedications" (Ridgway 1993, p. 425). The impression that sculptors who worked on funerary monuments did not work on dedications may derive from the fact that for about thirty years the signatures were 123
e
e
e
Reproduced with permission of the copyright owner. Further reproduction prohibited without permission.
e
I. ARCHAIC ATIIC VERSE EPITAPHS
51
The ratio 7:0 for the period before ea. 530 indicates perhaps something more than random survival and means that early archaic dedications were in fact less likely to be signed by an artist than grave markers. It should also be noted that, generally speaking, archaic Attic dedicatory verse inscriptions are much less susceptible to innovation than epitaphs. 125 The situation changes only towards the end of the century when there appear more dedications that bear an epigram and are signed, but until ea. 520-510 the practice is still more common with grave memorials. It is also noteworthy that the artist Endoios who flourished in the last quarter of the sixth century signed four works, two tombstones and two dedications. Both grave monuments bear verse epitaphs (42 and 66), while both dedications are in prose (IG I3 763 and 764).
Comparison with the rest of the Greek world underscores the peculiarity of Attic 'signing' practice. The earliest surviving artistic signatures elsewhere date to the end of the seventh century and the practice is not uncommon in the following century. 126 Most early signatures come from dedications at major religious centers such as Ptoion, Delos or Olympia, while funerary monuments are generally unsigned. This fact allowed Ridgway to conclude that outside Athens "all the signatures extant ... are on votive offerings. The funerary purpose of some pieces can only be assumed, not proved; nonetheless not even one of the possible candidates has preserved a master's signature." 127 In fact, a signed funerary stele from Orchomenos in Boiotia has long been known, and recently another grave stele with a verse epitaph and artist's signature was found in Akraiphia. I will return to these exceptions later. The following picture of artists' signatures emerges: in the early archaic period, that is during the seventh century, it was customary for a sculptor outside Attica to sign a piece of work which was designated as votive. In some cases sculptors themselves would
inscribed only on funerary monuments, and by the time the practice of signing votive sculptures was adopted at Athens the sculptors of the generation of Phaidimos or Aristion were no longer around. At the end of the sixth century, Endoios and Philergos signed both funerary and votive monuments, and Aristokles, I believe, also worked in both fields. 125 Many dedications, either hexametric or elegiac (the latter were not even employed on the Acropolis until the 520s), have a set of conventional elements (who dedicated it, to whom it was dedicated and a demonstrative pointing to the object of dedication) and they do not differ much from dedications elsewhere in Greece, see Wallace 1984, pp. 307 and 313. 126 For the earliest sculptors' signatures see LSAG, pp. 62-63, with references, and the valuable and concise survey "Signatures outside Attica" in Ridgway 1993, pp. 430-432. 127 Ridgway 1993, p. 431.
Reproduced with permission of the copyright owner. Further reproduction prohibited without permission.
52
I. ARCHAIC ATTIC VERSE EPITAPHS
vow the work to a deity, 128 but in the majority of cases the work would be dedicated by another person. In Attica, the first signatures appeared on funerary monuments, and only towards the end of the sixth century did the practice of signing votive monuments become widespread; the tradition of signing funerary sculpture was exclusive to Attica throughout the archaic period, with two Boiotian stelai being exceptions to this rule. This pictures raises at least two questions.
One of them was formulated by Ridgway, "Why to sign a grave
marker?" and the other one concerns Attic exclusivity and Boiotian exceptions. Many sculptors who worked in Attica in the sixth century might have come from the Greek East, particularly from the Aegean Islands. Although the custom of signing an artifact can be attested in various parts of Greece, some especially noteworthy examples are of Cycladic origin. A dedication from Delos dating to the late seventh century has the signature ofthe Naxian sculptor Euthykartides 129 who dedicated his work in the sanctuary of Apollo. 130 Four archaic dedications from Paros are signed (two of them accompany an epigram): 412, 413, /G 12.5.1.219, and /G 12.5.1.252. The monuments bearing 412 and /G 12.5.1.219 date
to the early sixth century, while those bearing 413 and /G 12.5.1.252 date to the last quarter of the sixth century; thus, the practice of signing votive sculptures was common on Paros both earlier and contemporary with the practice of signing grave monuments in Attica. The signature in 413 (ea. 525-500?) accompanies an elegiac couplet and is itself a single hexameter containing a boastful announcement: ToO Tlapio Tioirn.ta
KptTcuviB~ euxo~-t[at
eTvat]. This signature resembles one of the boastful signatures of Phaidimos, who is called oocp6s in 26 and praised for making the monument KaAov iBeiv in 18. Early sixth century island sculptors might have brought with them to Athens the practice of signing their works-one may only wonder how many works Aristion of Paros produced and signed in archaic Athens if there survives evidence of four signed monuments, all funerary. Summarizing various possible explanations of the phenomenon of artists' signatures on grave monuments in Attica, Ridgway concludes that "[i]t is difficult to escape the thought that artists signed as a form of advertisement, to prompt further commission." 131 If the sculptors
128
E.g. the Naxian Euthykartides, see below. LSAG, p. 291, no.3 130 The fact that Euthykartides could both make and dedicate his work to the Delian Apollo testifies to the sculptor's prosperity. 131 Ridgway 1993, p. 429. 129
Reproduced with permission of the copyright owner. Further reproduction prohibited without permission.
I. ARCHAIC ATIIC VERSE EPITAPHS
53
were the initiators of the practice and employed it for advertisement purposes, why would they not have signed votive monuments, as they were accustomed to do in their homelands? We should not, I think, overestimate the influence of the artist and underestimate the tastes and demands of those who commissioned the monuments. The latter must at least have consented to if not asked for the name of the sculptor to be displayed, sometimes as prominently as the names of the chief mourner and the deceased. In the eyes of Athenian aristocrats, a sculptor's signature must have contributed to the beauty and value of the monument and must have been one of the elements constituting the ideal complex of lasting commemoration at the burial site: a stele or statue mounted on a stepped base, with the latter bearing a verse epitaph and signature of the artist (the memorial for Phrasikleia (24), for example, would be an embodiment of such an ideal).
If we are to keep the word
advertisement in the explanation of signing practices, it should also be thought to denote advertisement of the status and tastes ofthe family of the deceased and not just the sculptor's attempt to prompt further commissions, even if the latter is not entirely insignificant. If signing were entirely up to a sculptor and served the purpose of advertising, we would, as I have indicated, expect the sculptors to have signed dedications, too, and this is an additional reason to believe that it must have been the Athenians who cared to have funerary, and not votive, monuments signed by the sculptors. But why? In what follows I only attempt to approach the question, and do not pretend to have the complete answer. Let me divide the period under consideration into two parts: prior to the 520s (the period during which the practice of signing sculptural works was confmed to funerary monuments) and the end of the century (when the votive statues start to bear artists' signatures). From what evidence remains, there does not seem to be any drastic difference in the artistic quality of funerary and dedicatory monuments throughout the sixth century; in quantity, however, there appears to be a sharp increase in votive sculpture, especially on the Acropolis, in the last quarter of the sixth century or even after the reforms of Kleisthenes in 508/7. 132 Since the quality of the artwork does not appear to explain the absence of sculptors' signatures, we have to look for other significant characteristics in which votive and funerary monuments and their inscriptions differ.
132
See Keesling's overview of the problem of dating the increase of votive statues on the Acropolis (2003, pp. 36-62).
Reproduced with permission of the copyright owner. Further reproduction prohibited without permission.
I. ARCHAIC AffiC VERSE EPITAPHS
54
a) Purpose. Dedications were meant for a god, or gods, and were intended to please them, while funerary monuments were meant to keep one's memory alive, but this seemingly important difference does not appear to have found much reflection in, for example, the iconography of kouroi or korai, which could be used in either votive or funerary contexts. b) Place. Archaic Attic funerary monuments were set up along the roads and were constantly accessible to numerous passers-by, with some epitaphs even stating that they were set by the road, and the prominence of the address to a wayfarer also demonstrates the dependence on a large audience.
The Acropolis might have been less accessible, and it has even been
suggested that during the time of the tyrants, who had a residence there, access to the Acropolis was limited. 133 c) Layout. Archaic Attic dedicatory inscriptions of the earlier period are often harder to read than epitaphs. Dedications, for example, are often inscribed downwards on the column which supported the offering. d) Poetic Originality. Dedications are quite formulaic, especially during the earlier period, and until the 520s they were composed in hexameters; the appearance of elegiac did not change the diction of dedicatory inscriptions in the same way that it did epitaphs. Departures from sheer record types do not appear until around the end of the sixth or beginning of the fifth century. e) Poetic Quality. Unlike verse epitaphs, archaic dedications sometimes fail to meet formal metrical requirements. To illustrate this and other points mentioned above, I would adduce a dedication by Alkimachos son of Chairion. He dedicated to Athena a statue of a seated man (Acr. 629) which might represent Chairion, who was a tamias or treasurer of Athena before the middle of the sixth century; 134 the statue was mounted on a column that bore the following inscription (195, ea. 525-500?): 'AAIKl!.lOXOS ~.t' ave{cr}8eKe ~lOS KOpEl T65' aya.A~.ta I evlxo.Aev ecr8.Ao Se lTOTpos hOs Xmp(ovos ElTEtJxETal
E.g. Langlotz 1939, p. 9. Cf. IG 13 590 and 1516; the first mentions Chairion the tamias of Athena, and the second (found in Eretria) appears to be his epitaph. See also DAA, no. 6; Kees1ing 2003, pp. 182-185. 134
Reproduced with permission of the copyright owner. Further reproduction prohibited without permission.
I. ARCHAIC ATTIC VERSE EPITAPHS
55
The quality of these verses is low compared to archaic Attic verse epitaphs of the same period, and the inscription is carelessly inscribed. There is no signature of the sculptor. On the other hand, the statue is of finest quality, and the family is likely to have been of the highest property class. 135 At the end of the sixth century the following changes occurred in dedications and dedicatory inscriptions on the Acropolis: --the number of dedications increased, and there began to appear dedications of people whose status could not have been high (e.g. IG 13 546, a dedication of a small shield by a female bread maker named Phrygia), but they did not eclipse dedications by the aristoi; leaving aside the question of a possible connection between this increase and the reforms of Kleisthenes, we just note that the "bulge" in dedications, as Anthony Raubitschek calls it, might have reflected the increased accessibility to the Acropolis; --verse dedicatory inscriptions became more elaborate, and elegiac meter started to be used; --sculptors' signatures appeared; --the layout of inscriptions became closer to that of epitaphs, with the inscriptions often placed on the front surface of the base. The different developments in archaic funerary and dedicatory verse inscriptions might be at least partly explained by the different purposes and contexts of funerary and votive monuments. Early dedicatory inscriptions simply identified the donor and recorded the act of offering; it was between the man (or woman) and the god (or, more often, goddess), and the latter perhaps was not perceived as caring much for the written word or in need of any catchy address; more importantly, votive offerings were not constantly accessible to viewers and readers in the way that funerary monuments were. Funerary monuments allowed men to have an enduring record of an address to other men; those who commissioned splendid grave markers with verse epitaphs announced to the community that they belonged not only to families of handsome means, but that they both knew and appreciated poetry and art, and valued achievements of particular artists. Herodotus' description of Kallias the Athenian (6.122) shows that to impress people through immense spending was an admirable feature of an Athenian aristocrat. Funerary art offered one opportunity for such lavish spending,
135
If the Chairion of Alkimachos' dedication is the same as the Chairion of the epitaph from Eretria (/G 13 590, and 1516), which is a probable assumption, he was also "of the Eupatrids."
Reproduced with permission of the copyright owner. Further reproduction prohibited without permission.
I. ARCHAIC ATTIC VERSE EPITAPHS
56
and insuring the presence of the artist's signature on the grave marker was perhaps meant as a way to attest to this lavishness, which in turn attested the excellency of one's family. Once the Acropolis became more accessible, inscriptions on votive offerings became both more reader-friendly and more imposing. In many cases, they started to expand from a mere record of what had been done, to a description of how and why it had been done; speaking to a deity started to involve looking over the shoulder at the audience of men. Now I wish to address the two Boiotian grave markers that appear to contradict the rule that sculptors signed funerary monuments only in Attica. Although they seem, prima facie, to be exceptions, they actually confirm the rule. The grave stele which is signed by Alxenor was found in Orchomenos.
It is made of local Boiotian marble and depicts a
bearded man leaning on a staff and offering a locust to a dog; the epitaph might have been inscribed on the base, which is now lost; the artist's signature is carved under the relief (150
= IG 7.3225, saec. V in.): 136 'A:\xcn1vop .ETTOlTJOEV ho Naxtos· aAA' eo(8eo[8e]. Alxenor from Naxos made it. But, you, behold!
Alxenor's pretentious signature (150) immediately reminds one of the signature of Kritonides (413) and of the signatures of the Athenian sculptors.
The stele, which Alxenor was
responsible for carving, is dated to the first quarter of the fifth century, that is to the period when the number of Attic grave monuments sharply decreased, and it has been suggested, on the basis of stylistic analysis of the stele, that the Naxian Alxenor came to Boiotia via Attica. The motif of an older man accompanied by a dog is first attested in Attica at the end of the sixth century, and in the first decades of the following century it spread north-east from Attica. 137 Alxenor, in the tradition of island sculptors and following the Attic practice of signing the grave monument, proudly signed the stele, and he did so very likely upon the demand of the Boiotian person who commissioned the monument and who perhaps wanted to imitate Attic tradition. 138 136
The dimensions of the stele are H. 2.04 m, W. 0.61-0.59, Th. 0.18 m; for a detailed description and a photograph, see Hiller 1975, pp. 177-179, pi. 19:1. 137 For discussion of several stelai of this type, see Clairmont 1970, pp. 28-31, no. 8, which is a man-and-dog stele from Apollonia Pontica. 138 Hansen calls the script of this inscription ''Naxia ... nisi quod H pro e primigenio at XI pro DI scribuntur." In fact, there are inscriptions in Athens in the first half of the fifth century which display similar script, that is with H for both eta and h, A for lambda, the three bar sigma (e.g. IG I3 865), and XI for chi is conventional Attic. It is impossible to determine, therefore, whether the script is Ionic or Attic.
Reproduced with permission of the copyright owner. Further reproduction prohibited without permission.
57
I. ARCHAIC ATTIC VERSE EPITAPHS
The new stele 139 which was found in Akraiphia is signed by Philorgos (Philourgos ), who, the editor contends, should be identified with Philergos, 140 an artist who worked in Athens in the last quarter of the sixth century and signed two monuments there (52, and a dedication, JG I3 763, which is eo-signed by Endoios ). The new finding is a marble stele with an anthemion and a depiction of a young man in relief (Fig.l ). The youth is turned to the left; he holds a rooster 141 in one hand and a flower in the other; a short pillar is depicted in relief on the lower left side of the stele; the pillar bears a verse epitaph (I) incised downwards; the signature of the sculptor (II) is engraved in the field below the relief on the main shaft (predella) and is conventionally written from left to right (SEG 49.505):
I Mvam8elo: ~ve~· eil~i e1r'68ot: KaAov 16::\a Tluptlxos : apxales : CxVTi I
~·eeeKev:
I. Placed by the road, I am a beautiful memorial to Mnasitheios.
But Pyrrhichos set me up because of his Iongstanding affection. 11. Philourgos made it.
The epitaph is incised in the Boiotian alphabet with the characteristic Boiotian chi, but its dialect is distinctly Ionic. Even if the forms apxales and
(for which
Figure 1. Outline of the stele of Mnasitheios from Akraiphia
139
Andreiomenou 1999; see also Andreiomenou 2000. The fmding is further publicized in SEG 49.505 and BE 113 (2001) no. 506. The dimensions of the stele are H. 1.65 m, L. 0.375 m, Th. 0.0985 m. 140 Andreiomenou asserts that the names !:Aopyos (=i:AoOpyos) is the Attic version of the Ionic names !:Aeopyos, 1Mepyos, and i:Aepyos (1999, pp. 98 and 105), which allows her, on the one hand, to identify IAOPrOI of the new Boiotian inscription with <1>1Mpyos the Athenian, and, on the other, to spell it as !:AoOpyos, this variant of the name being attested seven times in Attica in 51h-4th cc. (LGPN 1994, s.v. !:AoOpyos). I feel some reservation in accepting the equation of all these names. If the IAOPrOI (=i:AoOpyos) of the Boiotian monument is the same as the sculptor i:Aepyos from Athens, who (Andreiomenou follows Viviers' hypothesis) was originally from Samos, why would his name be spelled in the Ionic way in Attica but in the Attic way in Boiotia, where there was no contraction to secondary o? It might be, however, that the Attic name i:Aepyos would be spelled (pronounced?) in Boiotia as i:Aopyos, cf. Mvnoiepyos in Attica (LGPN 1994, s.v. Mvnoiepyos) and Mvaoiopyos in Boiotia (IG 7.538.11, 3rd c. BC). 141 Andreiomenou (1999, pp. 106-108) suggests that the rooster is a sign that Mnasitheios was the epw~evos of Pyrrhichos.
Reproduced with permission of the copyright owner. Further reproduction prohibited without permission.
I. ARCHAIC ATTIC VERSE EPITAPHS
58
compare 1-!VEI-Ia cplAEI-IOO\JVES in 32 from Attica) are simply poeticisms with Ionic endings, one would not expect in Boiotian the psilosis in
e1r' 68ol, since the spiritus asper is generally
retained in Boiotian inscriptions throughout the fifth century; secondly, the word 1-!VEI-Ia would generally be spelled in Boiotian as 1-!VOI-Ia--cf. the name of the deceased, Mnasitheios, which, with the alpha, reflects the normal Boiotian spelling. In addition to the Boiotian alpha in the first syllable, the name displays a Boiotian feature in having El instead of E in the penultimate syllable, with El remaining short. This peculiarity can be best explained, I think, as a Boiotian trait because there was a strong tendency in Boiotian for E to progress in the direction of the l, and E before other vowels (and in proper names even before consonants) had a more closed sound than in other positions and could consequently be spelled El, and later simply as
t.
142
Thus, the name of the deceased and the script conformed to local
Boiotian norms, but the verse was probably composed by an Ionian. The Boiotian norms are likely to have been dictated by the person who commissioned the monument, that is by Pyrrhichos, 143 who opted for a script and spelling of the name that was familiar to the audience (i.e. the Boiotians), while the Ionic dialect may be explained by the dialect of the composer of the verse, whom it is tempting to identify with Philergos, who was either an Athenian or Ionian. 144 The editor, Angeliki Andreiomenou, dates the new Boiotian relief to 520-510 primarily on the basis of its similarity to the monument of the children ofKylon (32, ea. 530?), which employs the word cplAEI-IOO\JVES, and on the basis of its letter form. 145 The latter is rather inconclusive because the inscriptions that Andreiomenou adduces as comparanda are dated vaguely to the last quarter of the sixth century, while the epitaph for Neilonides 142
Buck [1928] 1973, pp. 21-22. C£ also 327 (ea. 550-525) in which El is employed twice to designate a short closed e sound. 143 The name is fairly common all over Greece, but in the sixth and fifth centuries it does appear more in the Doric and Aeolic parts of Greece than in the Ionian. 144 Viviers believes that there is enough evidence to suggest that Philergos was from Samos (1992, pp. 103-114, esp. pp. 113-114). I would not argue for Samos in particular, but the suggestion that he was an Ionian is attractive, although in this case it seems strange to me that his name would have been spelled
Reproduced with permission of the copyright owner. Further reproduction prohibited without permission.
I. ARCHAIC ATTIC VERSE EPITAPHS
59
(on the monument signed by Endoios) which most scholars date to ea. 530-520 (42) is so badly preserved that it can be of little help for the comparison of letter form. The letters on the Boiotian stele might date, I think, anywhere from the end of the sixth century through the first quarter of the fifth. The composition and the style of the relief, however, suggest a date rather in the early fifth century. The layout of the relief in which the head of the figure breaks into the field of the palmette finial is unparalleled in archaic reliefs (Fig. 2). Archaic stelai, whether earlier
Figure 2. Upper part of the stele of Mnasitheios with reconstructed finial
composite or later monolithic, have horizontal divisions which clearly separate several fields such as the predella, the main shaft, and the finial. Each field may bear a figured or a decorative relief or painting. The depiction in the lower part of the shaft of a stele, if there is any, is separated by a lintel, and the palmette that surmounts the shaft is separated either by a mould or by a painted horizontal band. The depiction on the shaft of the stele is often surrounded by a frame, whether carved or painted, and the finial is separated from the main shaft by the upper horizontal part of the frame. 146 If there is no frame, a horizontal painted or moulded taenia separates the finial from the main shaft of the stele. The blurring of horizontal divisions of a stele seems to be more characteristic of funerary reliefs of the fifth century, as in the stele of a horseman from Thespiai 147 or the stele of an athlete from Nisyros, 148 both dating to ea. 450. Furthermore, the figure on the new Boiotian stele is turned to the left, the position which fmds no parallel in sixth century material but is attested in grave reliefs of the fifth century. 149 On archaic grave
146
See, for example, Richter 1961, pp. 40-45, figs. 140-141, 144-145. Kurtz and Boardman, p. 224, and pi. 54. 148 Hiller 1975, pp. 161-162, and pi. 10:2-3. 149 The editor of the new Boiotian stele discusses the turn of the figure and offers some parallels, all of which date to the early to mid fifth century, but does not consider this enough to warrant a date in the fifth century (Andreiomenou 1999, p. 93 and notes 74-76). Examples of early reliefs that depict figures turned to the left include Clairmont 1970, pp. 31-33, no. 9 with pi. 5, from Olbia, first quarter of the 5th c.; Hiller 1975, pp. 160-161 with pi. 10:1, from Rhodes, second quarter of the fifth century; Ozgan 1986, pp. 27-30 with pi. 89, from <;anakkale, first half of the fifth century, and some others. 147
Reproduced with permission of the copyright owner. Further reproduction prohibited without permission.
I. ARCHAIC ATIIC VERSE EPITAPHS
60
reliefs standing figures are always depicted with the left leg forward, which means that with the figure turned to the right (as they always are), the profile view almost resembles a two-dimensional has-relief. But when the figure is turned to the left, the necessity arises to create a deeper and more three dimensional image, especially in the area of the thighs and buttocks, since the advancing left leg leaves the right side of the rear partly open to the viewer. The right side, therefore, has to be depicted at a deeper level than the main surface of the relief (which corresponds to the surface of the left side of the body), and consequently the relief attains bigger depth; with greater depth, more variety in the postures of the depicted figures result, too. Both the depth of the reliefs and the variety of postures developed over the fifth and especially the fourth centuries, whereas archaic reliefs tend to have consisted of more two-dimensional and static representations, and this perhaps explains why the figures on the archaic reliefs are always turned to the right. But to return to Mnasitheios' gravestone, the turn of the figure to the left appears to me to be another indication of a date rather in the fifth than in the sixth century. This monument, therefore, was produced around the same time and in the same milieu as the monument signed by the Naxian Alxenor, and perhaps by a sculptor with a similar career, who started in Ionia, continued on and gained fame in Athens, and eventually moved north to Boiotia, probably ea. 500, when the demand for funerary sculpture in Athens decreased or ceased all together. Aristocratic Boiotians might have had high respect for sculptors who came from Athens and were proud of securing the employment of famous masters. It should also be noted that the practice of setting up a carved grave marker and inscribing it with an epitaph, either in prose or verse, had already had a long history in Boiotia, and the Ionian sculptors coming from Athens could have counted on a healthy demand for their services. The two stelai from Boiotia therefore attest the spreading of the Athenian practice of signing grave monuments to Boiotia shortly after the time when sculptured grave markers went out of use in Athens, and thus they confirm the rule that signing grave markers in the archaic period was a tradition peculiar to Athens. 7. Meter and Literary Context
Meters Employed in Archaic Attic Epitaphs Archaic Attic verse epitaphs can be broken down into the following metrical arrangements: at least twenty nine verse epitaphs are elegiac; six are hexametric; three are iambic; the meter of a few others is unclear but appears to be based on a dactylic foot, that is
Reproduced with permission of the copyright owner. Further reproduction prohibited without permission.
I. ARCHAIC ATTIC VERSE EPITAPHS
61
it is either hexametric or elegiac. Iso Long epitaphs are rare: most elegiac epitaphs consist of one couplet; four hexametric epitaphs consist of one verse, and two have two hexameters; two iambic epitaphs consist of three trimeters, and one is a single trimeter verse. Evidently, most archaic Attic verse epitaphs were composed either in hexameters or in elegiac couplets with apparent preference given to the latter. Archaic Attic epitaphs in hexameters can be characterized as metrically arranged record-type epitaphs, which usually contain a set of conventional elements. These elements are: a) the name of the deceased; b) verbs KaT-/em-T(8r)l. .ll,
'(cJTTUll,
ei11l, or no verb at all;
c) the word oi;1-1a or 1-lVfil-la; d) a "demonstrative" form such as ev80:8e or T68e; e) often the name of the person who erected the monument; f) in some cases brief descriptions of the deceased. 151 Record-type epitaphs were used in Attica as well as in other parts of Greece throughout the archaic period without much variation. 1s2 In three cases where iambic is employed (26, 49, and 70), the meter seems to have been resorted to in order to accommodate proper names that would not easily fit a dactylic foot. Archaic verse epitaphs always incorporate the name of the deceased or of one of the deceased (or at least a reference to the deceased as the child of the chief mourner), and often also the name of the chief mourner. There is no example of an archaic funerary inscription that would combine the name of the deceased in prose with a verse epitaph that does not include personal names, the device commonly employed in the later classical period. Thus, in the archaic period the challenge of fitting a proper name to a dactylic foot was met by the employment of iambic meter. The same was true of dedicatory verse inscriptions; for example, the dedication of Alkmeonides, son of Alkmeon, in the sanctuary of Apollo in Ptoion was inscribed with an epigram in four tetrameters (302). If not for the names, iambic inscriptions could have been composed either as couplets or as hexameters. As a rule, archaic Attic verse epitaphs are metrically correct in both the juxtaposition of long and short syllables within a foot and in the arrangement of the feet in metrical units
See Table 1. Wallace 1984, p. 307. s Thus, an Attic epitaph (53, ea. 510-500) reads: Avaem ev6a5e ae11-1a TTaTep LEIJOV eiTTe6eKev, a Boiotian one (109, ea. 600?) has: 'Ail
ISI 1 2
Reproduced with permission of the copyright owner. Further reproduction prohibited without permission.
I. ARCHAIC ATIIC VERSE EPITAPHS
62
(that is in a hexameter, iambic trimeter or elegiac couplet). In contrast, many later classical Attic epitaphs, although clearly intended as metrical, were not executed as such, but rather as prose with elements of poetic formulas. Instances of failed attempts to compose a correct verse epitaph are not infrequent in other parts of Greece during the archaic period; the metrical correctness of archaic Attic verse epitaphs stands out and indicates the literary competence of their composers. Archaic Attic verse epitaphs that appear to contain flawed meter are likelier to have been intended as prose than to have been written by poor versifiers who were incapable of producing a metrical inscription, and to clarify this thesis I would like to discuss apparent exceptions to the general rule. Metrical Anomalies First. I wish to survey briefly several cases of metrical anomalies in archaic Attic verse epitaphs. Two epitaphs, 14 (ea. 560-550?) and 470 (ea. 550-540?), have a cretic instead of a dactyl in the first foot of the first verse, and in both cases it is due to proper names: Xatpe8ru..tos (14) and AvToKAeiBTJs (470). 14 is signed by Phaidimos and might well have been composed by him, or at least with his participation. Phaidimos' s signature is incorporated in 26, which consists of three trimeters, and in the composition of which, with its praise for the sculptor, he is likely to have participated. Even if he did not compose this epigram, he would certainly have been aware of it and thus would have known that iambic epitaphs can accommodate a name such as Chairedemos. It must not have been deemed necessary, however, and this fact suggests that the first foot of 14 for some reason did not offend the ears. Perhaps the employment of a cretic in the first foot of a dactylic verse was not perceived as a metrical mistake in sixth century inscriptions. In the case of AliToKAeiBTJs, the composer could have made the name fit, e.g., with two spondaic feet, but chose not to do so, which seems to me to support the suggestion that either a cretic instead of the first foot dactyl did not offend the ears or that it was scanned with the shortening of the third syllable. 153 A proper name seems to have been the source of metrical flaws in 32, which fails to accommodate the name of the father of the deceased; it starts ae1..1a T68e: KvAov, which
153
Other examples of a cretic in the first foot are 138 and 320, although the latter is from the fifth century. Cf. West 1982, p. 27, where he discusses the metrical accommodation of proper names and adduces 380 which contains two names with cretics in the place of dactyls (although not at the beginning of the verse).
Reproduced with permission of the copyright owner. Further reproduction prohibited without permission.
I. ARCHAIC ATTIC VERSE EPITAPHS
requires scanning T6oe as
v
-.
63
This might not have been felt as a flaw because cre~-ta Tooe
was perceived as a complete unit, and even marked as such by punctuation marks. 31 is an elegiac couplet accompanied by a hexametric line, but the arrangement is different from frivolous combinations of hexameters and pentameters which are common in the later classical period. The third verse is separated from the couplet by a blank space; furthermore, it appears to include a sculptor's signature, and therefore constitutes an entity, separate from the elegiac epitaph. Excluded Inscriptions I have chosen to exclude from my study a few of the texts that Hansen includes in his collection, because I consider them to be either not metrical or not funerary. A puzzling inscription, which survives on a marble disc (37, ea. 530?), reads:
rva8ovos : TOOE OEI-la, : 8ho o' a\ITOV : I aoeA
The first three words and the beginning of the fourth scan--
I-
v
v
I-
v
v,
but then the
meter breaks down hopelessly, and I agree with Wallace that the inscription was not intended to be metrical. 154 Furthermore, I am not sure that it was an epitaph. The narrative part of this inscription is rather exceptional and does not comply with the features of known contemporary epitaphs. The beginning is clear: "this is the sema of Gnathon,»~
55
but what
follows is troublesome: "the sister put/set him." If miT6v refers to Gnathon, the choice of verbs is rather strange since T(8rn..tt more often governs words such as sema, mnema, or stele (see, for example, 26 or 46), and not the buried person (but 'A8r')Vaiot nv8ay6pTJV e8ecrav, in 6 verse 2, ea. 460-450?). The rest of the line has been interpreted as either "[buried] after nursing him [Gnathon] in mental disease," 156 or that she cared for him in vain,frustra. Leslie Threatte suggests reading heAI8tov as ..; i]AI8tov, 157 and I even wonder whether the sister's 154
Wallace 1984, p. 317. I also do not accept Hansen's classification as metrical ofthree other epitaphs which preserve only the name followed by the expression T6Be ofiiJa, with the rest lost, 23, 65 (which also has the name ofthe chief mourner and the verb emH8eKe(v) in the beginning of the first line), 73. 155 The word ofiiJa, however, does not always denote a tomb in inscriptions. Thus, Hansen argues that 459 is not an epitaph; Simon. 24 calls a dedication to Artemis OlliJOTa. In Homeric epic the word is used with a wide range of meanings. 156 Friedlander and Hoftleit 1948, p. 148, no. 161. 157 Threatte 1980, I, p. 428.
Reproduced with permission of the copyright owner. Further reproduction prohibited without permission.
I. ARCHAIC AITIC VERSE EPITAPHS
64
name, or rather nickname, could be 'HAfBtov. If, however, the inscription is an epitaph, it attests a single case of a sister burying her brother. Although legally impossible, practically speaking, this is an easily imaginable and socially acceptable responsibility that a woman could assume for herself, if, for example, their parents were dead or absent. 47 (ea. 525-500?), which is composed in three hexameters that are reminiscent of Homer
158
but full of mistakes, is unlikely to have been an epitaph. It starts with ev86:oe, which
is characteristic of epitaphs, but proceeds to say not that the deceased was buried here, but that he swore an oath (line 1). The expression htep6s eillt at the end of line 3 is perhaps intended to strengthen the oath (and such an expression seems unsuitable for an epitaph). Two people are involved, a man and a boy; when the inscription was carved, one of them, Gnathios, had died in war, but it is unclear whether Gnathios is the name of the boy or the man. What was the purpose of the inscription is also unclear to me. 159 It is inscribed negligenter on a lapis rudis, both features uncharacteristic of archaic Attic epitaphs. Perhaps, the purpose of the stone was just what the opening lines state, it marked the place where the oath had been sworn. Two archaic Attic epitaphs are generally believed to consist of a single pentameter. The first epitaph is 72 (=JG
e 1260, ea. 500-480?), and the text, as printed in IG, reads: ae1-1a Too' ei1-1l Kpi [To?] ~eAe<po ·~
Jeffery 160 and Peek161 believed that the line was an attempt at a pentameter, while Hansen 162 suggested that it was intended as a hexameter. The first editor of the inscription believed that the initial iota in ei1-1i was a correction of a sigma, and he concluded that the stone cutter must have had the more common eoTi in mind. The writing is badly preserved and, according to J effery, "is scored by the plough." There are no photographs of the stone, but there does exist a photograph of the squeeze and a drawing by James Oliver. On the basis of these reproductions I suggest that the correction could have gone the other way around: either the iota was corrected to sigma or what appears to be an iota was actually a random stroke
158
See Friedliinder and Hoffleit (1948, pp. 63-64, no. 59) for discussion of the Homeric parallels. See Friedliinder and Hoffleit (1948, pp. 63-64 no. 59) for the interpretation of this inscription; they believe that Gnathios was the man who died in war, and that the boy is unnamed. See also commentaries in /G 1399. 160 IGAA, p. 134, no. 36. 161 Peek 1942, pp. 84-85, no. 139. 162 Hansen 1975, no. 68. 159
e
Reproduced with permission of the copyright owner. Further reproduction prohibited without permission.
I. ARCHAIC ATTIC VERSE EPITAPHS
65
that interfered with the sigma; in either case, sigma is the first letter of the following word, which is in fact the name of the deceased. The text then should read:
oe1-1a T6Be Ll-ltKpij[- -]
~eAEcpo ·~cpt[Bvaio].
This is the tomb ofSmikri--, son ofTelephos of Aphidnai. 163
If my restoration is correct, it helps explain something else in the text. Usage of the word OEI-la with the demonstrative pronoun and the first person verb is unparalleled, and, generally
speaking, employment of the first person verb in archaic Attic epitaphs is relatively rare. In epitaphs outside Attica, the monument can speak in the first person, e.g. 146, but in those cases no demonstrative pronoun is employed. 164 The only exception is 174, a mid fifth century epitaph from Sinope, which appears to be the result of a rather unfortunate patchwork of prose and poetic formulas and can by no means be adduced as evidence of any norm. 165 There survive, however, prose epitaphs that include reference to the oe1-1a and the name of the deceased and do not employ any verb, i.e. ofil-la T6(5e) ToO Belva, e.g. /G I3 1259 and 1344 (and the earliest surviving epitaph from Attica, /G I3 1194). 60 (=/G I3 1227, ea. 510-500?) is another candidate for a single pentameter epitaph.
The text is written stoichedon; the editors of /G I3 1227 suggest the following reading and restorations:
[?8epo]vos : TiatBos [oe~-ta] T6Be : AvToKAEos. ~ Any discussion of meter depends on consideration of how much of the inscription is missing from the left side of the stone. The measurements of the stone are: H. 0.40 m, p.L. 0.50 m, Th. 0.67 m, and Jeffery suggests that it might have been the lower block of a stepped limestone base. She also points out that the surviving stone could have had an adjoining block on the left which would have carried part of the inscription, although she does not rule 163
For more detailed discussion of this epitaph and possible restorations, see Lougovaya 2003. The syntax of this epitaph troubled both Jeffery (IGAA, p. 134, no. 36) and Burzachechi (1962, p. 38) who independently came to the conclusion that two constructions, ofilla (1-!Viil-!a) T68' eOTi Tov Seiva and ToO Seiva ei1-11 oi;1-1a (1-!Viil-la) are confused here. 165 Pace Svenbro 1993, p. 37. The existence of epitaphs that include both the demonstrative T68e and first person verb ei1-1i is of crucial importance to his theory of "egocentric" epitaphs. He defends the text of /G 13 1260 from Jeffery's and Burzachechi's condemnations as having "perfectly normal syntax." Unfortunately, Svenbro claims that further examples of this type of syntactical construction are unnecessary and does not provide any, pp. 24-43, esp. pp. 32-33. 164
Reproduced with permission of the copyright owner. Further reproduction prohibited without permission.
66
I. ARCHAIC ATTIC VERSE EPITAPHS
out the possibility that there could have been only one stone which had been recut and that in this process only a few initial letters on the left side were lost. Thus, there are several possibilities: 1) if there was an adjoining block, 166 the inscription might have been much longer and the epitaph was an elegiac couplet; 2) if there was no adjoining block, the inscription was not much longer, and it was not metrical; 3) there were four more letters in each line, as supplemented in JG, and the inscription consisted of a single pentameter. The first two options seem more plausible to me than the third one, which presumes unconventional verse. There is another reason to discourage accepting (3) as an option: the resulting verse would have had no room for a verb. No "verb-less" archaic verse epitaph survives from Attica, 167 while there are a few examples of relatively long prose epitaphs that, while lacking a verb, make reference to the OEI-la and the name of the deceased, with the patronymic or place of origin or both. Finally, one may wonder whether ]T68e : AuToKIAeos could have been a part of the artist's signature, on analogy with the signature
in Oinanthe's epitaph (54, 11): Kat T68e 'AptoTOKAEos. Although no sculptor by the name AuToKAi)s is attested, the possibility of such a signature should remain open. 168
Literary Elegy and Verse Epitaph By the time verse epitaphs appear in archaic Attica, they had existed in other areas of Greece for at least a century. The meter of early verse epitaphs elsewhere, before the appearance of elegiac epitaphs in Attica in the second quarter of the sixth century, was hexameter. The earliest Attic verse epitaphs are elegiac and seem to have little in common with the hexametric epitaphs of the earlier period; in other words, there is no development (at least as far as our evidence suggests) from hexameteric epitaphs to elegiac. With the introduction of elegiac meter, some new features seem to have been brought into inscriptional poetry, such as the address to the passer-by, future tense verbs or explicit expressions of emotion. By the time verse epitaphs disappear in Attica at the end of the sixth 166
The length of the lower step of a stepped base could easily be over one meter, see, e.g., JGAA, p. 122, no. 14, in which two adjoining blocks form a lower course of some kind of a large monument with combined length of 1.20 m. Note that this monument displays some similarity to no. 17: both are made out of limestone, the writing is partly stoichedon, and Jeffery assigns both inscriptions to the same Mason E 1. 167 62 {=/G 13 1393, ea. 510-500?) is a possible exception, but it has not been agreed whether it is an epitaph or a dedication. 168 There are numerous incomplete signatures ofwhich only a few letters survive, e.g. IG 1218bis, /G 13 1222, etc., which might fit several names.
e
Reproduced with permission of the copyright owner. Further reproduction prohibited without permission.
I. ARCHAIC ATTIC VERSE EPITAPHS
67
century, the elegiac couplet is the meter of verse epitaphs throughout Greece, although hexameters never ceased to be used, and iambic continued to be employed for its usual purpose, to accommodate personal names.
There might well be no single, rational
explanation why the Athenian elite privileged elegiac meter for verse epitaphs, but we can attempt to assess some possible reasons for the introduction and popularity of elegiac couplets for verse epitaphs. This issue, which is generally of little or no concern to scholars, borders on another, much debated question, that of the connection between elegy and lament, or, in other words, the question of the possible existence of archaic elegy of lament, which might have been performed at funerals. Whether threnodic elegy existed in the archaic period is a crucial question for those who attempt to outline the development of elegiac poetry, because the existence of threnodic elegy, if proven, could explain the association of the word elegos with lament in the late fifth century. Up until now no surviving archaic elegy has been shown to be elegy of lament. Debate surrounding this issue has recently been revived by a couple of epigraphic discoveries, which were interpreted as evidence for the existence of archaic threnodic elegy. In what follows, I will first discuss threnodic elegy, with an aim to demonstrating that the inscriptional evidence does not attest the existence of a genre of threnodic elegy, and then proceed to discuss possible reasons for the employment of elegiac couplets in verse epitaphs. The Meaning of Elegos Ancient and some modem scholars have generally thought that there was an intrinsic connection between elegy and mourning. Indeed, the word elegos (or elegoi) is attested five times in Euripides and once in Aristophanes, 169 and in all these occurrences it seems to mean "sung lament," suggesting that there was a genre of elegy of lament. In Euripides, however, the word eAeyos is always modified by another word rendering the idea of lament, e.g. oaKpvc.uv eAeyous (Tr. 119), aAupov eAeyov (He/. 185), etc. Thus, the meaning ofeAeyos in these places should be "song" rather than "sung lament;" furthermore, in all the occurrences
the word eAeyos is employed in lyric meters, which casts doubt on the possibility of a connection between sung lament and elegiac meter. In support of the existence of a genre of threnodic elegy, Page argues that the Doric elegy found in Euripides' Andromache 169
Euripides, Tr. 119, I.T. 146 and 1091, He/. 185, Hypsip. 1 iii 9, and Aristophanes, Av. 217. See Page 1936, pp. 206-208, and West 1974, p. 5.
Reproduced with permission of the copyright owner. Further reproduction prohibited without permission.
I. ARCHAIC ATTIC VERSE EPITAPHS
68
(103-116), the only occurrence of couplets in Greek drama, is the sole survivor of a tradition of Peloponnesian threnodic elegy, which goes back to such poets as Echembrotos, Clonas, or Sacadas. 17° For Martin West, performance of elegies at funerals is rather a fact than a hypothesis. 171 In 1986 Ewen Bowie attempted to demonstrate "that little or no early Greek elegy was lamentatory," 172 arguing that there could have been a genre of elegy of consolation, such as Archilochus 13, which, as well as any other type of shorter elegy, including martial, would have been performed in a sympotic setting. Longer elegiac poems, Bowie contended, were intended to be performed at public festivals. 173 As for the word etegos, Bowie suggested that it meant either "what we mean by elegy" or "that it meant 'a song sung to the autos."' Although various types of songs in various meters could have been sung to the autos, the high proportion of songs in elegiac meter which were sung to this instrument resulted in the coinage of the term etegos. 174 In the same year that Bowie's influential article appeared, an Attic epitaph was published in which the verb oflament is employed in the first person (470, ea. 550-540?): 175 AvTOKAeiBo T615e OEIJa veo TIIpooopov 6:vhollat Kat 8alvaTOl TaVT(.]Ia.( ... 7-8 . .. I -------1-------]. Looking at this tomb of young Autokleides, I am distressed, and to death ...
This discovery and publication of the epitaph necessitated reconsideration of 51 (whether the first word of the epitaph should be restored as the imperative oiKTtpo or kept as oiKTipo for the first person form oiKTipc.u), and led David Lewis to suggest the existence
of a category of epitaphs with anonymous first person mourners. For Lewis, the two sixth century inscriptions, 51 and 470, were important for "breaking down the dividing line between the funerary epigram and hypothetical threnodic elegy." 176 The discovery of an epitaph from Ambracia, SEG 41.540 (av5pas [T]ovsB' [e]o.Aovs 6.Aocpvpo1Jat, KTA.), 170
Page 1936, with Bowie 1986, pp. 24-26. West 1974, p. 13. 172 Bowie 1986, p. 22. 173 Bowie 1986; see also Gerber 1997, pp. 91-96. West (1974, pp. 10-13) suggests eight various types of settings for performance of elegy. 174 Bowie 1986, p. 27. 175 See the ed. pr. by Matthaiou 1986, pp. 31-35, pis. 4-5, who provides detailed description of 470 and 471, which is a small fragment of a similar stele also with a verse epitaph of which only a few letters survive. Regarding the epitaph of Autokleides, Matthaiou believes that "[i]t is someone whose name is not preserved on the stone addresses the deceased in the first person, a rare example of its kind," p. 34. 176 Lewis 1987, p. 188. 171
Reproduced with permission of the copyright owner. Further reproduction prohibited without permission.
I. ARCHAIC ATIIC VERSE EPITAPHS
69
has further motivated attempts to establish the existence of archaic threnodic elegy, the traces of which, it has been argued, are most apparent in verse epitaphs spoken by an "anonymous first person mourner," or "lamentatore estemo," 177 who is to be identified with the reader of the epitaph. Let us reexamine the inscriptional evidence. Inscriptional Evidence for Threnodic Elegy First, we have to assess the validity of the claim that epitaphs 51, 470, SEG 41.540, and we may add here 43 and 68, attest the existence of the genre of threnodic elegy. When an epitaph (or indeed any inscription) is spoken in the first person, the identity of the speaker is usually clear. Most often it is the monument (KElllat, 153; eoTnKa, 58; llE pointing to the monument, numerous inscriptions); it might be the deceased (KEKAi)oollat, 24; KElllat, 80); it can also be the chief mourner in epitaphs and the "doer" in other inscriptions (oTfioa (?), 74; Sa\.l)a, 136; eoocpo611[e8a], 161; Tioinoa, 459). Albio Cassio argues that in those cases when an epitaph employs the first-person verb of lament, its subject is meant to be none of the above, but is instead the reader of the epitaph, who in the process of reading enacts the lament. In fact, this proposition generalizes an earlier interpretation by Hansen of the verb 6Aocpvpollat in a poorly preserved epitaph (43), for which Hansen suggests that "the best explanation is undoubtedly that the reader in front of the monument by reading (which of course in antiquity meant reading aloud) the inscription was automatically made to lament the deceased." 178 In 43 and SEG 41.540, however, the subject of the verb 6Aocpvpo11at may well be the monument (Hansen considers but dismisses this possibility for 43) or the chief mourner. 43 is, I think, too badly preserved and of little help; it is possible that it was meant to be spoken by the mother of the deceased, since the word llETEp, in the nominative case, occurs earlier in the epitaph. SEG 41.540, with its narrative and its appeal to the people, KaE llCxV 'Apa88iova KaE Eu~evov ioTE, TioAiTaE (verse 9), must be spoken either by the monument or by the chief mourner, whose identity is not clear to us but perhaps was made clear in the lost part of the epigram or by an inscription on the stele which is now lost; it could hardly have been intended as the discourse of an anonymous reader. 177
178
Cassio 1994. Hansen 1976, p. 160.
Reproduced with permission of the copyright owner. Further reproduction prohibited without permission.
I. ARCHAIC ATIIC VERSE EPITAPHS
70
Indeed, why would the anonymous reader be expected to reenact an address to the people of Ambracia? Epitaphs which combine the participles of "looking at" with the verb of grief or lament in the first person (51, 470, 68) cannot be, of course, explained as spoken by the monument, since the monument can hardly be described as npoaopov itself, but I do not see why both avtol-lat (470) and oiKTipo (51) cannot be spoken by the chief mourner, who, looking at the tomb, feels pity for the deceased, and has the epitaph record this grief. I discussed above that both 51 and 68 allude to the fairly narrow circle of family and friends of the deceased, which, I think enforces my suggestion that they were meant to have been spoken by the chief mourners. I think, therefore, that epitaphs with a first person verb of mourning record the lasting grief of the survivors, such as, for example, the father in the case of 51 and likely a parent in 470, rather than aim to make the reader reenact funerary lament, a ritual which would have been confined to a certain time and defined by certain rules. Furthermore, the type and layout of the inscription of Autokleides' stele finds a curious parallel in the stele of Pediarchos, which contains an exclamation of lament, IG I3 1267 (ea. 530-520?): 4
E~T~.
3 2
neoiapxos apXEl T00To 'Evneoiovos· Oll-lOl neotapxo
1
~
Alas for Pediarchos son ofEmpedion. Pediarchos begins these graves.
Here, the exclamation of sorrow and lament is followed by a dry record in lines 3-4 that Pediarchos begins(?) the afJI-laTa; if the lament were to be reenacted by the reader, what about the record? It seems more reasonable to suppose that the epitaph is spoken by the chief mourner. The stelai of Pediarchos and Autokleides are of similar, and otherwise uncommon, dimensions in width and thickness (JG I3 1267 has W. 0.32-0.345 m, Th. 0.095-0.105 m; 470 has W. 0.325-0.305 m, Th. 0.12-0.097 m); the inscriptions are cut retrograde and from the bottom up, which in the case of IG I3 1267 was tentatively explained by Jeffery who proposed that "perhaps the stele was set up high on a wall or mound, so that the lowest line was at eye-level, and stood on the right side of one entering the family precinct." 179 179
IGAA, p. 136, no. 42, fig. 13; for 470 see Matthaiou 1986, pp. 32-34, pis. 4-5.
Reproduced with permission of the copyright owner. Further reproduction prohibited without permission.
I. ARCHAIC ATTIC VERSE EPITAPHS
71
Autokleides' stele might well have come from a precinct, too, since a small fragment of another stele (471), also inscribed retrograde and apparently of close dimensions, was found at the same place as Autokleides' stele. Perhaps the context of the precinct would have clarified the identity of the chief mourner. In any case, the reader should have been expected to reenact a mourner at the funeral no more than he was expected to reenact the monument in those epitaphs in which the monument or the deceased is the speaker. Furthermore, epitaphs which address the passer-by clearly demonstrate that the reader is not expected to be identified with the speaker of the epitaph, although he is expected to feel pity for the deceased. Interestingly, the literary piece that is most similar to inscriptional verse epitaphs with the first person verb oflament is not a couplet but is in tetrameters (IEG2 Anacreon, iamb. 2):
aAKlJ.lCUV cr' (!) 'AplOTOKAElOTJ TIPWTOV oiKTtpcu
Page 1936, West 1974, p. 2, Bowie 1986,44.
Reproduced with permission of the copyright owner. Further reproduction prohibited without permission.
I. ARCHAIC ATIIC VERSE EPITAPHS
72
to lament and mourning. Some expressions, such as "shameless Pontos destroyed" (132) or "blazing Ares destroyed" (145) perhaps implicitly emphasize the pain of the loss, but one cannot find references to grievous feelings and lament in early epitaphs. It is with the appearance of elegiac epitaphs that we find in sepulchral verses such words as oiKTipc.v,
6Aocpvpol-lm, (c':nr)oBvpol-lm, 6AocpvBv6s, nev86s, KTA., whether they are used to express the feelings of the chief mourner, or are spoken in the address to the reader or the description of the monument. Archaic elegiac epitaphs, therefore, seem to admit of more explicit emotion than earlier epitaphs in hexameter, and these emotions are those of sorrow and grief. This change suggests to me that the switch to the employment of elegiac couplet for sepulchral verses was more than a random fad, and that there should be some connection between elegiac poetry and the development of verse epitaphs, but to identify this connection we do not need to postulate a genre ofthrenodic elegy. Literary Elegy and Verse Epitaph, Revisited Bowie argues for a sharp distinction between poetry of consolation and that of lament, convincingly demonstrating that while there was archaic elegy of consolation (for example, Archilochus 11 or 13) there was no elegy of lament. 181 The main difference between the two, besides content, is the occasion of the performance: while lament was performed at funerals, elegy of consolation, which could include elements of lament without being wholly threnodic, was performed, Bowie argues, in sympotic settings. Descriptions of death and lament for the dead can be found not only in elegies of consolation, but also in other types of elegy. Martial elegy, for example, describes universal grief over the death of a truly virtuous man (Tyrtaeus 12.27-28; Callinus 1.16-19) and thereby aims to inspire listeners to live up to the standards of true virtue; universal lament is presented as a reward for a praiseworthy life and glorious death. Other archaic elegiac poems, such as those of Mimnermus or Theognis, often refer to sorrow and grief, for example, at the approach of old age (Mimnermus) or at the baseness of contemporaries (Theognis), and this grief is expected to be shared by the listeners. Thus, we often find expressions of both lament and sorrow in elegiac poems which might overall be devoted to other major themes, such as military valor or one's moral standing, etc.
181
Bowie 1986, pp. 22-27.
Reproduced with permission of the copyright owner. Further reproduction prohibited without permission.
I. ARCHAIC ATIIC VERSE EPITAPHS
73
Although a simplification, one may perhaps say that in the archaic period choral lyric was public in content, performance and address, since it was performed by a chorus at public festivals. Individual lyric was private in content, performance and address, since it was performed within a narrow circle of close companions. Elegiac or iambic monodies, which were performed to the accompaniment of the flute fell somewhere in between public and private; monodies were delivered to audiences at formalized sympotic settings, which were narrower than those of public festivals but wider than a circle of close companions, and they were often personalized, insofar as they were delivered in the first person and intended to convey a personal message, although the message was of such a nature that it presupposed the agreement of the listeners. Most archaic elegy was performed at symposia, aristocratic drinking parties conducted in accordance with certain norms and restrictions that governed various aspects of a symposium, from the ratio of water to wine to games and topics of conversations or themes of songs. It has been proposed that performance of poetry at a symposium was one of the ways in which "those positive models (praise of a worthy man, the CxVDP aya86s) and those negative ones (through the psogos, censure of the KaKOl,
8etAoi, etc.) to which the group of companions subscribes" 182 were established. Elegiac poetry, therefore, was a medium for expression of normative attitudes and was well familiar to members of symposia. Participants in an archaic symposium were probably both able and expected to compose such poetry, arranging in a proper couplet some personal message that would have been welcomed by other participants, who tended to be members of the cultured elite. Composition of verse epitaphs in elegiac couplets might have arisen from this culture of symposia, and the elegiac couplet was perhaps viewed as an appropriate form to convey a personal message (record of the death of one's family member) to a public audience (any passer-by). The question remains why it was in Athens that elegiac epitaphs became so widespread. There is no evidence that symposia in early sixth century Athens were any more popular than those in, for example, Ionia. The poetry and culture of symposia would have been available during the seventh and sixth centuries to the cultured elite throughout Greece. It appears, however, that starting perhaps in the second quarter of the sixth century 182
Pellizer 1990, p. 180. Negative models are primarily those of iambic poetry, which, Pellizer argues, was also generally meant for sympotic gatherings.
Reproduced with permission of the copyright owner. Further reproduction prohibited without permission.
I. ARCHAIC ATTIC VERSE EPITAPHS
74
or somewhat earlier, Athens was a place where the display of one's tastes and means became particularly widespread. There seems, for example, to have been some mass production of artistic objects, such as sculptural works and vases, which were used by a large number of people outside the temple grounds, whereas in other parts of Greece the employment of artistic objects was concentrated in major sanctuaries.
Statues of kouroi
and korai were set up all over Greece, but only in Athens, it seems, were so many used as grave markers; moreover, grave stelai with reliefs were popular in no other place to the degree that they were in Athens.
Conspicuously inscribing verse epitaphs on a base
of a splendid grave monument must have been part of the public display favored by the Athenian elite, and these are likely to have been the same people who were well familiar with the culture of symposia and indulged in various elite activities. 183 It might have also mattered that the Peisistratids offered patronage to the arts, and perhaps they themselves had a special inclination to statues and elegiac inscriptions, which, for the most part, would not have outlived the tyranny. The fact that some evidence still did survive suggests to my mind that there were once many elegiac inscriptions in Attica which were connected with the Peisistratids: the anecdote about the Hipparchean Herms ([Plato] Hipparch. 228d-229b), which were set up between the city and the country demes and bore an elegiac couplet, has found support in archeological evidence (304); Peisistratos the younger had an elegiac inscribed on his dedication to Apollo (305), and perhaps also on the Altar of the Twelve Gods. 184 8. Disappearance of V er se Epitaphs in Attica ea. 500 BC
Post-Solonian Funerary Legislation Sometime around the turn of the century the massive output in Attica of carved gravestones with epigrams came to an end. It is impossible to date this interruption precisely: there are clearly a lot of monuments before 510, and virtually nothing after 480. 183
It is noteworthy, that three monuments with verse epitaphs (30, 50, and 53) feature depictions of equestrian scenes in relief or a horse statue. 184 Thucydides says that the Altar of the Twelve Gods had an E1riypallllO (6.57). The same word is used for the epitaph of Archedike and also seems to be implied for the dedication to Apollo, both in couplets; Herodotus employs the word three times, all three for verse inscriptions; and Euripides refers to an imaginative epitaph that a poet, 1-JOVOOTIOIOS, could have written on the tomb of Astyanax as an ETiiypallllO (Tr. 1189-1191). Thus, all the early attestations of the word ETiiypallllO mean inscription in verse, and if the dedication on the Altar of the Twelve Gods was in verse, it is quite likely to have been in elegiac couplet(s).
Reproduced with permission of the copyright owner. Further reproduction prohibited without permission.
I. ARCHAIC ATIIC VERSE EPITAPHS
75
The disappearance of monumental tombstones is usually associated with the so-called post aliquanto 185 law to which Cicero refers in Leges 2.64-65:
Sed post aliquanto propter has amplitudines sepulchrorum, quas in Ceramico videmus, lege sanctum est 'ne quis sepulchrum faceret operosius quam quod decem homines effecerint triduo;' neque id opere tectorio exomari nee hermas, quos vocant, Iicebat imponi, nee de mortui laude nisi in publicis sepulturis nee ab alio, nisi qui publice ad earn rem constitutus esset, dici licebat. sublata etiam erat celebritas virorum ac mulierum, quo lamentatio minueretur; auget enim luctum concursus hominum. But sometime later, on account of the grandeur of the tombs that we see in the Kerameikos, a restriction was passed as law that "no one shall make a grave which would require more work than ten people can accomplish in three days," and it was not allowed to decorate the tombs with opus tectorium, nor to set up the so-called hermae, nor to praise the dead with the exception of those buried publicly and only by the man chosen publicly to do it. Crowds of men and women were also forbidden, to diminish the amount of lament. Large gatherings of people increase grief.
Cicero surely speaks of some anti-luxury law, but the exact meaning is unclear. The prohibition against building a memorial that would require "more than ten men could accomplish in three days" might refer to the heaping of a mound over the burial site or to the preparation of the funeral enclosure; 186 but the practice of covering a grave with a huge earth mound does not seem to have been common towards the end of the sixth century, anyway: most of the big tumuli date to the preceding century and two exceptionally big and exceptionally late ones, to the middle of the sixth century. 187 Opus tectorium has been interpreted as referring to the practice of decorating built tombs with series of painted clay plaques. The series disappear, however, around 530, 188 and it is hard to believe that antiluxury funerary legislation forbidding clay plaques would allow the employment of free standing statues, which quite clearly continue after 530. Another theory suggests that opus tectorium means the covering of the earth tomb with stucco (for both decorative and
enforcement purposes), but the usage of plaster seems to continue through the fifth century. 189 Similarly, what Cicero means by hermae remains a complete mystery. Boardman suggests that it could refer to changes to the finials on stelai-from the figure of a sphinx to a simple
185 Earlier in 2.64 Cicero speaks of Solon's funerary legislation, consequently, post a/iquanto must mean "sometime after Solon." 186 Garland 1989, pp. 5-6. 187 The so-called South Hill and Mound G in the Kerameikos. 188 Boardman 1955, p. 51 and passim. 189 Kiibler 1976, p. 201, note 107.
Reproduced with permission of the copyright owner. Further reproduction prohibited without permission.
I. ARCHAIC ATIIC VERSE EPITAPHS
76
palmette, which occurs approximately at the same time as single plaques substitute series, but this requires us to date the legislation to the time of Peisistratos' reign, which Boardman himself believes to be too early a date! 90 I would add that an anti-luxury law that banned figured finials on stelai but still allowed equestrian statues, which are known to have existed as funerary monuments in the last quarter of the sixth century, is also hardly probable. Thus, we can still subscribe to the opinion of Kurtz and Boardman that Cicero's account "offers more problems than solutions." 191 No matter what Cicero's account means in detail (and Cicero could surely be confused, while Demetrios of Phaleron, Cicero's source, might be purposefully unclear), it appears that Demetrios, and then Cicero, talked of some anti-luxury funerary law which was passed in Athens after Solon but before Demetrios. If there was legislation concerning funeral display, it is tempting to connect it with the reforms of Kleisthenes, as was first done over a hundred year ago by Gustav Hirschfeld. 192 Since then scholars have challenged this suggestion by claiming that archaic grave stelai do not disappear abruptly ea. 507, but continue, albeit in very reduced numbers, to be employed until the 480s. Consequently, a more complicated theory has evolved that has tried to reconcile the apparent anti-aristocratic character of the law with the archeological evidence. Verena Zinserling has proposed that although Kleisthenes was behind the decree to ban funeral luxury, the law was not enforced until later, probably by Themistokles in 487, and Clairmont accepts this hypothesis. Karen Stears tentatively suggests that either Kimon, the son of Miltiades, or his associates were responsible for the legislation that restricted display at private burials, while promoting the custom of public burial of the war dead. 193 In his recent book on laws against funerary
°Kurtz and Boardman 1971, pp. 84-87, 90.
19
191
Kurtz and Boardman 1971, p. 90. Hirschfeld 1893, p. 13. 193 Stears believes that Kimon might "have put forward the post aliquanto law in conscious imitation of Spartan practice, whereby the right to commemorate the dead by means of inscribed funerary markers was a privilege granted only to those who had fallen in service to the polis" (2000, p. 45). This theory is based on the assumption that the legislation, while restricting the erection of private grave memorials, allowed public ones. The law as reported by Cicero, however, has no provision for public grave monuments, and so far no public inscribed grave monuments dating to before the mid-460s has been found. Virtually nothing is documented in archaic or contemp~rary sources about Spartan burial practice in the early fifth century, and this fact renders examination of the relationship between the two practices, Spartan and Athenian, futile. In those cases in which we do have some evidence, such as burial of the war dead, the practices diverge: the Spartans bury their war dead at the battle site and erect monuments with verse epitaphs, whereas the Athenians, apart from two exceptional situations, bury their dead at Athens and do not seem to commemorate the dead with verse epitaphs, see Ch. 2. 192
Reproduced with permission of the copyright owner. Further reproduction prohibited without permission.
I. ARCHAIC ATIIC VERSE EPITAPHS
77
luxury, Johannes Engels opts in the end to leave the question open, although he points out two periods of time as the likeliest possibilities for the institution of the law-either between 508 and 501 or between 488 and 481, connecting it thereby either with Kleisthenes or with Themistokles, and he notes that personally he finds the later date more attractive. 194 There are several problems with these explanations. The first is the assumption that the law, if it was in fact passed, had to be responsible for the disappearance of sculptured grave markers. Cicero actually reports restrictions, not a ban, and specifies what type of monuments were banned. Even though we do not know what types he meant, it is both unlikely that Cicero meant and indeed said that one was not allowed to set up a marble plaque with a verse epitaph-it would surely meet the 10 men/3 days stipulation. Thus, the existence of a law does not need to be proved by the complete and notable disappearance of enduring and inscribed grave markers. Secondly, it is impossible to show that a monument or epitaph dated to, let us say, ea. 500, cannot be moved to ea. 508, since we simply have no means to date with such precision. A different approach has been suggested by Morris who argues that the question of the post aliquanto law is not all that important, since around 500 material display of wealth in funerary practice declines everywhere in Greece, although not evenly in different regions, and that the "restraint from about 500 to 425 and rapid increase thereafter are genuinely panhellenic phenomena." 195 Consequently, there is no need to believe that a particular law could account for changes in Athenian burial practice, because in any case that law would be unable to explain parallel changes in other parts of Greece. While Morris' theory may be right, and there might have been some general decrease in funeral display throughout Greece during the fifth century, the problem remains that in other states people commemorated their dead with gravestones inscribed with verse epitaphs-in Boiotia, for example, they even welcomed artists from Athens. Furthermore, it is hard to say that commemoration with inscribed and sculptured gravestones continued in other areas of Greece-we can keep Boiotia as an example-in reduced numbers, because numbers had never been high there. The Athenian pattern of wide employment and the virtual disappearance of monuments of this type is without parallel. 194 195
Engels 1998, pp. 97-106, esp. pp. 105-106. Morris 1992b, pp. 41-42.
Reproduced with permission of the copyright owner. Further reproduction prohibited without permission.
78
I. ARCHAIC ATTIC VERSE EPITAPHS
Morris also offers an alternative to the "panhellenic" approach, in order to elucidate the change in Athenian burial practice. This approach is based on a theory proposed by Aubrey Cannon, who explains changes of abundance and restraint in funeral practice in various cultures as a cyclical process. 196 Cannon argues that when high funerary expenditure becomes conventional and widespread, it is among the wealthiest that expenditure begins to decline and modesty in display becomes a sign of good taste. He suggests that once the monuments reach some peak of grandeur and further elaboration fails to be impressive, it is the difference, that is restraint in place of grandeur, that signifies pretension. 197 While this theory attractively explains the cyclical nature of abundance and restraint, it cannot help date the turns of the cycles. It might well be the case that putting up expensive memorials with epigrams became a sign of bad taste and wealthy Athenians started to prefer more modest grave markers, but we are still faced with the question why they started preferring modest ways ea. 500. The idea that it was because the monuments reached such grandeur that there was no room for further impressive elaboration, would not work any better ea. 500 than at some other point in time. Furthermore, this theory does not explain the alleged decrease in funeral display in other parts of Greece, where there was no particular grandeur in the preceding period to begin with. While I have no solution to the problem, I may offer a few observations. First, the attempt to accommodate archeological dates to precise political dates might be futile, since it is impossible to achieve necessary precision. No Athenian epitaph yet found can be dated securely to, let us say, the year 500; one must allow for at least ten years on either side, e.g. 510-490. 198 Moreover, even those scholars who claim that it is possible to date some memorials with verse epitaphs to the period from 500 to 480 agree that the number would be very low. Still, it is to accommodate this archeological evidence that they prefer to place the anti-luxury law between 488 and 481, 199 or even more precisely in 487/00 in order to explain the complete disappearance of carved and inscribed gravestones, but, as I showed above,
196
Cannon 1989, p. 447. Cannon 1989, pp. 444-447; Morris 1992b, p. 42. 198 The long controversy over the date ofPeisistratos' dedication to Apollo ( IG 948) is an excellent example of an inscription which looks (i.e. in terms of its script) somewhat twenty years later than it should be on historical grounds. 199 Engels 1998, pp. 105-106. 200 Zinserling 1965, pp. 29-34, followed by Clairmont 1970, p. 12. 197
e
Reproduced with permission of the copyright owner. Further reproduction prohibited without permission.
I. ARCHAIC AITIC VERSE EPITAPHS
79
the law does not need to be supported by the complete disappearance of grave markers, and we do not know what types were banned, if the specification referred to certain types. It is undeniable that archaic tombstones with verse epitaphs were associated with
Athenian aristocracy. Theoretically, a verse epitaph could be inscribed on a small plaque, but in reality this was not the case in archaic Attica, where verses were put primarily on grave monuments of considerable grandeur. Even when towards the end of the century funerary epigrams became somewhat more standardized, they continued to be associated with magnificent memorials. A verse epitaph, as I discussed above, was viewed as an element of the status and excellence of an elite family. A monumental grave marker, especially one with a verse inscription talking about, for example, a father and son, represented a person who was to be praised, lamented, and admired qua member of his family. Of course, he might also have been virtuous and handsome, but the fact that his image could be set out in the form of a beautiful monument for everybody to see was owed to his family, which had the means to afford and taste to choose the particular monument and verse. It does seem that this form of public display of the position of a family was incompatible with Athens after Kleisthenes. The aristoi in the fifth century could set up dedications on the Acropolis, or could undertake liturgies, or could spend money in some other ostentatious way, but they could not record on stone private praise of a private man, which would be seen and read publicly. Much of Kleisthenes' reforms was intended to enervate the influence of elite families and install mechanisms prohibiting a family from excelling on the basis of the family network. While any tyranny can be viewed as relying heavily on the power amassed within and distributed among members of a family, it was especially so in the case of the Peisistratid extended family. The early Athenian democracy must have been anxious to divorce personal family interests from public political activity. This could not have been an easy task, because many distinguished families had prominent members and thus were extremely influential as a family. Probably no Athenian would disagree that the Alkmeonids or the Philaids had power as a family, but after the expulsion of the tyrants or the institution of Kleisthenes' reforms, honor which could have been bestowed on a prominent member of an influential family had to be justified in terms of the person's contribution to the public good of the state.
Reproduced with permission of the copyright owner. Further reproduction prohibited without permission.
I. ARCHAIC ATIIC VERSE EPITAPHS
80
Thus, we come to a suggestion that was proposed long ago, that if there was a law curtailing display in funerary practice, it dated to after Kleisthenes' reforms, and might even have been part of it. It might not have been enforced too strongly, but the old aristocratic practice of splendid grave markers could have become uncomfortable for rich Athenians in the new political situation, which valued a person for his achievements as a member of the state, and not for the fact that he belonged to a well-off and influential family. They may even have abhorred any display reminding them of the habits of the elite at the time of the tyrants. After the Disappearance: Athenians and Athenians (?) Outside Attica A separate, and rather complicated, topic that should be addressed here concerns verse epitaphs that appear to commemorate Athenians or persons connected in some way to Athens who died abroad, all of which date to the period after ea. 500, that is after the tradition of inscribing verse epitaphs came to a halt in Athens. Sometimes these epitaphs display features of the Attic tradition, while at other times they reflect local trends. Hansen includes under Attic epitaphs an inscription for Philon, who was a sailor and may have died in a shipwreck. The plaque with this epitaph was found in Eretria, and it is incised in Attic script (76, ea. 500-480?): 201
Figure 3. Drawing of the gravestone and epitaph for Philon, CEG 76
ev8a81e
The monument has been described as a shapeless slab with careless lettering/02 and the drawing in K. Kourouniotes' edition clearly shows that this gravestone was not executed in the tradition of archaic Attic grave monuments with verse epitaphs (Fig. 3). As for the verse, the first line stutters at the proper name and the formula KlaTa yai' eiKaAvcrcpev is unfortunately attached to a short syllable. It has been suggested that ev8a8e was mistakenly 201 202
Kourouniotes 1897, cols. 151-152. Fried1ander and Hoffleit 1948, p. 84, no. 79.
Reproduced with permission of the copyright owner. Further reproduction prohibited without permission.
I. ARCHAIC ATTIC VERSE EPITAPHS
81
written instead of TeiOe, and that TovSe = TOV Si). 203 The composer of this epitaph seems to have tried to put together a few formulas but was not entirely successful. The pentameter is somewhat surprising and finds no parallel in surviving Greek poetry, but I tend to doubt that a person who failed to solve metrical difficulties in the rather uncomplicated initial verse, could come up with such a poetic pentameter. The composer may have drawn on some source which has not survived. The epitaph says nothing about Philon's origin and, needless to say, the name gives no clue, since it is a very common name. It appears that Hansen includes it with Attic epitaphs on the basis of the fact that it is incised in Attic script. Jeffery, however, points out that "[i]n the first half of the fifth century a standardizing influence, which is probably that of the Attic alphabet, appears in Eretrian."204 Thus, the script in Philon's epitaph also appears to assist little in determining his origin. The type of gravestone, a marble plaque measuring
Figure 4. Drawing of the gravestone and epitaph for Pleistias, CEG 77
H. 0.50 m, W. 0.32 m, and the untidy layout of the inscription (Fig. 3) do little to support inclusion ofthis inscription in the tradition of archaic Attic gravestones. Another verse epitaph in apparent Attic script from Eretria which Hansen includes among Attic epitaphs commemorates a man who was born in Sparta, grew up in Athens, and died in Eretria (77, ea. 500-475?): l.
II.
TlAEIOTtas. LlTClpTa 1-lEV naTpfs EOTIV, EV evpvxlopOlOl <S') 'A86:vms e8p6:cp8e, 8avc1To I Se ev86:Se !lOip' EXI?(E. .
I. Pleistias. 11. Sparta is his fatherland, in spacious Athens he was brought up, and here the lot of death reached him. 203
See CEG 76 for discussion of various suggestions. Hansen cautions that no surviving inscriptional epigrams have Bi). 204 LSAG, p. 85.
Reproduced with permission of the copyright owner. Further reproduction prohibited without permission.
I. ARCHAIC ATTIC VERSE EPITAPHS
82
Pleistias perhaps died and was commemorated soon after the Persian Wars, and the chief mourner wanted to emphasize Pleistias' connection to the most glorious places in Greece. How are we to classify this monument and epitaph? The script appears to be Attic, but the type of the monument, a low base (H. 0.22) surmounted by a small tetragonal pillar (H. 0.74 m) with an abacus, and the way of inscribing, deorsum, is ostensibly non-Attic/05 the spelling, 'A8~vats,
as FriedHinder and Hoffleit suggest, is probably a poeticism rather than a Doric
form. 206 It is impossible to determine, I think, whether the composer of this epitaph imitated Attic or conformed to local traditions. Perhaps the chief mourner accepted the local typology of grave monuments, but opted for a verse epitaph in accordance with the old Attic custom of inscribing grave monuments with verses, although the custom was not by then employed any more in Athens. It is noteworthy that the name of the deceased, Pleistias, is not included in the verse. Although it is not a very easy name to put in a dactylic foot, it is not an impossible one, and exclusion of the name might also point to a different stage in the development of the practice of inscribing gravestones with verse epitaphs. In archaic epitaphs names are always included in the verse, but towards the end of the fifth century there develops a tendency to put names, especially those which are hard to incorporate in the dactylic meter, outside the verse epitaph. The beginning of this tendency may therefore date to the first half of the fifth century, and Pleistias' epitaph would be one of the early examples of"post-archaic" epitaphs. A verse epitaph from Aigina commemorates an Athenian (80, ea. 475-450?, the dates in JG 13 1503 are given as 450-431 ?): 207 I.
Il.
xafpETE oi Tiapt61vTes· eyo OE 'AvTtcnaiTes hvos 'ATap(3o KEil-lat I Tetoe 8av6v TiaTpfoa I yev TipoAm6v. 'AvTtOTCcTESI 'A8evaios.
I. Hail, passers-by! I, Antistates son of Atarbos, lie here, having died, and having left my
fatherland. 11. Antistates the Athenian.
The local Aiginetan tradition was perhaps not very elaborate: neither the chief mourner nor the composer of Antistates' epitaph apparently minded the fact that the first verse was rather a heptameter than a hexameter. The opening formula of 80 is paralleled in the epitaph for 205
For a photograph see LSAG, pl. 16:17. C£ 302, a dedication by an Alkmeonid at Ptoion. 207 For a photograph, see LSAG, pl. 17:19. The stele is not very big (H. 0.72 m, W. 0.52 m, Th. 0.08 m), and the inscription seems to be its sole decoration. The relatively neatly carved letters gradually decrease from huge letters of0.0042 m in the first line smaller ones of0.019 m towards the end. 206
Reproduced with permission of the copyright owner. Further reproduction prohibited without permission.
I. ARCHAIC ATTIC VERSE EPITAPHS
83
Mnesitheos from Aigina which was found in Eretria; the latter is inscribed on an "[i]rregular stele in unusual informal lettering"208 and belongs, I think, to the same milieu as the other three epitaphs under discussion here (108, ea. 450?):
5
xalpeTe TOt1Tapt61VTES,: eyo Se eavovl KOTOKEII..IOI.: oevplo iov clVOVEI..tat, avlep TlS TEOE Te8aTIITITar: ~evos aTI' Aiyllves, Mvecr(8eos 8' ovlv~..ta• Kat 1..101 1-tVEI..t' eTiel8eKe· q>(Ae 1-tETEp Tt~..tlaphe Tv~-tm e1r' aKpoTiaTot crTe.Aev aKa~-taTov, 1 haTIS epei TiaplOOI Otal~..tepes 01-tOTa lTOVTa· T~tpaphe p' ecrcrTecre q>I.Aiot eTilTimol eav6vTt
Hail, passersby! Having died, I lie here. Having come close, read what man is buried here: a foreigner from Aigina, named Mnesitheos. And the monument at the top of the tomb my dear mother Timarete set up for me, an enduring stele, which will be continually and forever (Sla!lepes = Sia!lTIEpes) announcing to the passers-by: Timarete set me up for her dear child, who died.
This epigram is a patchwork of various formulas and even dialects, and perhaps further demonstrates that inscribing verse epitaphs was not a developed tradition in either Aigina or Eretria. All four epitaphs display little affinity to the tradition of archaic Attic verse epitaphs; the monuments on which the epitaphs were incised also seem to stand in no relation to archaic Attic grave monuments. This diminution in the quality of monuments and sepulchral epigrams, which apparently were commissioned by or for people who stood in some relation to Athens and who were buried in areas of Greece that were closely connected to Athens, demonstrates that inscribing verse epitaphs was practiced at this time not by the cultured elite but by those people who, on the one hand, must have considered verse epitaphs to be a desirable sign of status, but, on the other hand, lacked the competence to compose or commission a metrically correct couplet.
208
Friedlander and Hoffleit 1948, p. 130, no. 140.
Reproduced with permission of the copyright owner. Further reproduction prohibited without permission.
CHAPTER TWO. PUBLIC VERSE EPITAPHS AND COMMEMORATIVE EPIGRAMS
Introduction The liberation of Athens from the tyrants and the reforms of Kleisthenes influenced the norms of funerary display in Athens and in particular the practice of inscribing verse epitaphs to commemorate deceased family members. The practice of inscribing private verse epitaphs came to a halt in Athens and did not resume until the end of the fifth century, but within that period there developed a tradition of public verse epitaphs to commemorate the war dead. This tradition of public verse epitaphs did not, however, directly evolve, following the Kleisthenic reforms, out of the archaic practice of elite burials, but was preceded by a period during which no verse epitaphs were inscribed in Athens.
In this chapter I will first discuss possible evidence for funerary epigrams
commissioned by the Athenian state for those who fell in battle. I intend to show that no verse epigram, whether inscriptional or literary, that purports to be a public verse epitaph for the Athenian war dead can be shown to date to the period between the reforms of Kleisthenes and the mid 460s. During this time, when neither private nor public verse epitaphs were inscribed in Athens, there appeared and developed a unique genre of inscriptional verses which I call commemorative or celebratory epigrams. The Athenian state commissioned a number of epigrams that commemorated the achievements of the entire state or of some Athenians, but that were neither explicitly funerary nor dedicatory (examples include epigrams for the tyrannicides and Athenian victories during the Persian Wars and subsequent campaigns). The second part of the chapter will be devoted to analysis of public verse epitaphs for the war dead; these inscriptions are well attested in Athens after the middle of the fifth century and, albeit transformed, into the fourth century.
Investigation of public
verse epitaphs for the Athenian war dead will require reexamination of the complex of procedures which are associated with the so-called Patrios Nomos, in accordance with which the Athenians buried and commemorated their war dead. Having reassessed the development of the Patrios Nomos, I will concentrate my discussion on extant public verse epitaphs for those who were granted public burials in Athens.
84
Reproduced with permission of the copyright owner. Further reproduction prohibited without permission.
Il. PUBLIC VERSE EPITAPHS AND COMMEMORATIVE EPIGRAMS
85
1. Literary Evidence to 479 BC It seems reasonable to assume that if the Athenians placed restrictions on lasting
display at private burial sites and banned certain practices from private funerals (such as funeral orations) while, at the same time, allowing them at public funerals, they should also have transferred the earlier practice of setting up an elaborate stone funerary monument inscribed with a funerary epigram (the ideal aristocratic grave monument) from private to public burials. This assumption, however, is false, and the purpose of what follows is to demonstrate that the early Athenian democracy did not in fact mark the public burial sites with monuments inscribed with verse epitaphs. Those epigrams which are sometimes classified as verse epitaphs commissioned by the Athenian state for those who fell in war turn out, upon closer examination, to have been either epitaphs for non-Athenians, or else non-funerary, if not from a significantly later period. Chalkis. ea. 507-501 BC The earliest epitaph sometimes considered to commemorate the Athenian war dead is Simon. 2: 8fpcpuos EOI-lTWru.tev UlTO lTTU)(l, Oi'jl-!a o' ecp' iJI-liV eyy\}Sev EupflTOU OTJI-lOOlc;x KEXUTat' OUK CxOlKC.VS, epaTi]v yap CxlTC.VAEOOI-lEV VEOTTJTO TPTJXEiav lTOAEI-lOU oe~cii-lEVOl vecpEATJV. We were slain under the glen of Mount Dirphys, and near the Euripos a mound has been heaped upon us by the people, and not unjustly, since lovely was the youth we destroyed under the onslaught of the harsh cloud of war.
The epigram survives only in Planudes, but, as Page asserts, "it is a fair guess, but only a guess, that it comes from that period [i.e., is contemporary with Simonides]."1 Nothing in this epitaph openly contradicts the supposition that the epigram is authentic, but interpreting the text poses difficulties. Most scholars agree that the epitaph refers to Athens' victory over Chalkis, the date of which lies between 507 and 501 (Herodotus 5.77). Opinions diverge, however, over whether the inscription was intended to commemorate the victorious Athenians or the defeated Chalkidians. Clairmont, following Felix Jacoby, states that the epigram commemorates the Athenians, since it refers to a public burial (OTJI-!Oofc;x KEXUTat) while Page insists that the dead must be the Chalkidians since E01-1Tl8TJI-IEV clearly points to 1
FGE, p. 189. Molyneux (1992, pp. 84-86) and Clairmont (1983, pp. 87-89), however, treat this guess as certainty.
Reproduced with permission of the copyright owner. Further reproduction prohibited without permission.
11. PUBLIC VERSE EPITAPHS AND COMMEMORATIVE EPIGRAMS
86
a defeat,2 Hugh Lloyd-Jones in his review of Page's FGE rightly points out that E0!-.1118111-lEV means simply "we were overwhelmed, slain,"3 and thus can be applied to either side. Notwithstanding connotations of this verb, the tone of the verse is certainly not triumphant, whereas we might expect the victorious Athenians to have said something at least to indicate that the fighting had been worthwhile. Indeed, their victory was fast and decisive, and the stakes-defending the new democracy-were high. Back in Athens, Herodotus tells us, they dedicated some chains in which they had bound the Boiotians and Chalkidians until they were ransomed, and from the tithe of the ransom they set up a bronze quadriga, the base of which bore an epigram, which survives, with some variants, in the literary tradition. Several small fragments of the inscription also survive (179=Simon. 3): 4 LOEOIJOI EV +axAvoeVTlt OlOEpEOl eaj3eaav hvi3JPIV : naiOELS 'A8eva(ov epy1-1aatv EI-ITIOAEI-IOJI Leevea BotoTov Ka\ XaAKtBeov Ba~-tacravTESJ, : TOV htlTlTOS ~LEKclTEV naAAaOl Taao' e8eaavj. In a dark, iron bond the sons of the Athenians checked hybris, taming in deeds of war the Boiotian and Chalkidian tribes, and from the tenth of their ransom they dedicated these horses to Pallas.
The splendid offering to the goddess was commemorated with no trite epigram. 5 The tone is exceedingly triumphant, and it appears to me that the people who celebrated their victory with this epigram would surely not be the same people who commemorated the dead in Simon. 2. If Simon. 2 was for the Chalkidian dead, we might better explain some of the peculiarities in the epitaph. The first couplet of the epigram rings of epic, as is not uncommon in archaic epitaphs,6 and provides some information about where the men perished. The second couplet has been suspected of being a later addition and detached, but it is defended by Page who points out the similarity in composition between these verses and the epitaph to Tettichos (13). I would like to add another consideration. If we 2
See Clairmont 1983, I, p. 89; Jacoby 1945, pp. 159-160; FGE, p. 190. Lloyd-Jones 1982, p. 141. 4 The history of this epigram is complicated; see FGE, pp. 191-193, for discussion of the literary tradition; for discussion ofthe epigraphical tradition, see ML, pp. 28-29, no. 15, and IG 13 501. 5 To appreciate the high quality of this verse, one need only look at the formulaic Attic dedications extant from throughout the sixth century, which, unlike some verse epitaphs, did not accommodate poetic innovation and did not display much originality. This dedication, however, shows great artistry, and the line SEOIJOI ev t<'xx:\v6evTit mSepe01 eoj3eoav hvj3p1v is so far from being formulaic that its exact wording and meaning continue to defy consensus. 6 See, e.g., 131, 139, 143, 145.
3
Reproduced with permission of the copyright owner. Further reproduction prohibited without permission.
Il. PUBLIC VERSE EPITAPHS AND COMMEMORATIVE EPIGRAMS
87
accept that the epigram stood on the memorial for the defeated Chalkidians, the overtly pessimistic tone might reflect Athenian presence in Euboia following the conflict. The most peculiar feature of the epitaph is the fact that it says nothing about the cause of the battle or the enemy, nor does it praise the valor of the fallen men. We do not necessarily expect an explicit reference to the cause for which the men died, but in public epitaphs we do usually encounter some, even if it is metaphorical or vague, reference to circumstances surrounding a battle. For example, the deceased are said to have died defending their fatherland, or some statement is made about how the men fought. Here, they are said to be buried by the people "not unjustly," because they yielded up their lovely youth to the violent cloud of war. No cause is cited. A reference, even an oblique one, to the nature of the conflict would not fit the situation in Chalkis after the conflict, and the Athenians would be unlikely to have tolerated it. But they probably would not oppose commemoration of the fallen foes, provided it was not expressed in a way that was offensive to the Athenians. The composer seems to have borne this in mind, as he found it important to incorporate justification for the burial, stating that it was carried out OUK a8iKws. Marathon 490 BC The Vita Aeschyli tells us that Aeschylus was defeated by Simonides "in the elegeion for those who died at Marathon." 7 Nothing here suggests that either Simonides or Aeschylus wrote an epitaph for the war dead at Marathon, and the work which is alluded to in the Vita Aeschyli could have been an elegiac poem, which might have included praise of and lament
for the Athenian heroes who fought and fell at Marathon. 8 Plutarch, drawing his information from Glaukias the rhetorician, refers presumably to the same poem (eAeyeiat) by Aeschylus, in order to provide historical evidence for the battle:
rAavKias 8' 6 pi)Twp Kai TO 8e~lOV Kepas AiavTi8ats Tiis ev Mapa8CJvt napaTCx~Ec.JS ano8o8i;vat, Tais AioxvAov tTTlV 11E8op(av eAeyeiats lTlCJTOVI-lEVOS, i)yc.JVlCJI-lEVOV Ti]v 1-lCx)(TIV EKElVTJV emcpavCJs (lEG II2