An Engineering Archive
An Engineering Archive A Selection of Papers From the Proceedings of the Institution of Mechan...
43 downloads
2269 Views
49MB Size
Report
This content was uploaded by our users and we assume good faith they have the permission to share this book. If you own the copyright to this book and it is wrongfully on our website, we offer a simple DMCA procedure to remove your content from our site. Start by pressing the button below!
Report copyright / DMCA form
An Engineering Archive
An Engineering Archive A Selection of Papers From the Proceedings of the Institution of Mechanical Engineers
Edited by Professor Desmond Winterbone Archive assistance from Keith Moore
Published by Mechanical Engineering Publications Limited, for the Institution of Mechanical Engineers, Bury St. Edmunds, and London.
First Published in this Edition 1997 This publication is copyright under the Berne Convention and the International Copyright Convention. All rights reserved. Apart from any fair dealing for the purpose of private study, research, criticism or review, as permitted under the Copyright, Designs and Patents Act, 1988, no part may be reproduced, stored in a retrieval system, or transmitted in any form or by any means, electronic, electrical, chemical, mechanical, photocopying, recording or otherwise, without the prior permission of the copyright owners. Reprographic reproduction is permitted only in accordance with the terms of licences issued by the Copyright Licensing Agency, 90 Tottenham Court Road, London W1P 9HE. Unlicensed multiple copying of the contents of this publication is illegal. Inquiries should be addressed to: The Publishing Editor, Mechanical Engineering Publications Limited, Northgate Avenue, Bury St. Edmunds, Suffolk, IP32 6BW, UK. Tel: 01284 763277. Fax: 01284 704006.
The Institution of Mechanical Engineers 1997
Leather Bound Edition Hardback ppc Edition
ISBN 1 86058 052 1 ISBN 1 86058 053 X
A CIP catalogue record for this book is available from the British Library. Printed by Lavenham Press, Suffolk, UK.
The Publishers are not responsible for any statement made in this publication. Data, discussion, and conclusions developed by authors are for information only and are not intended for use without independent substantiating investigation on the part of potential users. Opinions expressed are those of the Author and are not necessarily those of the Institution of Mechanical Engineers or its Publishers.
Contents Foreword Preface Historical notes on the Proceedings of the Institution IMechE Library Bookplate Note on Subjects for Papers Subjects for Papers - Call for Papers for the Proceedings of the IMechE -1849 George Stephenson - On the fallacies of the rotary engine - 1848 John Scott Russell - Notice on the life and character of the late George Stephenson - 1848 Richard Peacock - On the workshops for the locomotive carriage and waggon departments of the Manchester, Sheffield, and Lincolnshire Railway - 1851 William Menelaus - Description of the large blowing engine and new rolling mill at Dowlais Iron Engineering Works - 1857 William George Armstrong - On water pressure machinery - 1858 Charles William Siemens - Description of a machine for covering telegraph wires with India-Rubber - 1860 Henry Bessemer - On the manufacture of cast steel and its application to constructive purposes - 1861 Francis William Crossley - On Otto and Langen's atmospheric gas engine, and some other gas engines - 1875 Thomas Russell Crampton - On an automatic hydraulic system far excavating the Channel Tunnel - 1882 Beauchamp Tower - First report onfrictionexperiments - 1883 Hiram Stephens Maxim - Description of the Maxim Automatic Machine-Gun - 1885 William Thomson - On ship waves - 1887 Charles Algernon Parsons - Description of the compound steam turbine and turbo-electric generator - 1888 Richard Francis Trevithick - Locomotive building in Japan - 1895
vii ix xiii xv xvi 1 5 13 27
37 51 79 95 115 135 151 177 201 233 249
Works Visits The Eiffel Tower - 1889 Daimler motor mills,, Coventry - 1897 The Colonial Consignment and Distributing Co.'s Frozen Australasian Meat Store, Lambeth - 1900 Henry Selby Hele-Shaw - Road locomotion - 1900 Rudolph Christian Karl Diesel - The Diesel oil-engine, and its industrial importance, particularly for Great Britain - 1912 Frederick William Lanchester - Theflyingmachine: the aerofoil in the light of theory and experiment - 1915 William Henry Bragg - The application of x-rays to the study of the crystalline structure of materials - 1927 Arthur Stanley Eddington - Engineering principles in the machinery of the stars - 1929 Herbert Nigel Gresley - High-pressure locomotives - 1931 Ernest Rutherford - Atomic projectiles and their applications - 1932 Reid Anthony Railton - Racing motor car design - 1937 Frank Whittle - The early history of the Whittle jet propulsion gas turbine - 1945 Harry Ralph Ricardo - Piston aeroengines - 1947 John Douglas Cockcroft - The possibilities of nuclear energy fir heat and power production - 1947
270 271 277 279 283 341 381 421 449 473 513 539 581 613 623
Foreword The 150th anniversary of the Institution, offers an excellent opportunity to look back at the contribution made by the Proceedings of the Institution to the whole area of mechanical engineering. The Institution has a number of complete sets of Proceedings, which are a record of the papers and reports presented to the members and others. These date back to 1848, when the founding president, George Stephenson, wrote his paper On the fallacies of the rotary engine. During the succeeding 150 years, most of the famous engineers who have made major contributions to our life and wealth, have published papers in Proceedings. This volume contains a selection of papers which have been chosen from the first 100 years of the Proceedings to exemplify both landmark accounts of engineering technology and science, and contributions from famous authors. This volume concentrates on the first 100 years, as it is possible to gauge the impact of these papers in a true historical context. The papers reproduced here are in facsimile, to show their original form. Some pages have been enlarged, and others slightly reduced in size for presentation in this volume. The quality of the diagrams is impressive, and these were often produced in the Institution's own drawing office. A number of the most memorable plates are included here and show the Institution's contribution to graphic representation. An Engineering Archive is a fitting commemoration of our Institution's history. I hope that those who use this interesting and fascinating book will enjoy reading this selection from the Institution's unique archive. Ernest Shannon, FEng President, IMechE January 1997
vii
This page intentionally left blank
Preface The IMechE reached its 150th anniversary in 1997 and one of the ways proposed to celebrate this occasion was to publish a compilation of papers from the Institution throughout its history. I was invited to act as Editor for this volume because at that time I was Chairman of the meeting of Editors of the Proceedings. It was obvious that the task was too big for one person to undertake, especially one who was not a specialist in the archives of the Institution. I invited Keith Moore, the Institution Archivist, to act as a coeditor. The task of selecting the most appropriate papers was a daunting one, as can be imagined. In the years to 1950 alone, the Proceedings contained written work from over 1,880 engineers, and the rate of publication has increased enormously in recent years. The problem was reduced somewhat when Professor Duncan Dowson, FRS, FEng, and ex-president, suggested that it might be advisable to restrict consideration to the first 100 years of the Proceedings, on the grounds that it is difficult to judge the impact of papers until they have stood the test of time. This proposal rendered the task more manageable. The whole of this period is summarised in "A Brief Index of Papers 1847-1950", which was compiled in 1951 by Alfred Stock, FLA, who was the Institution's Chartered Librarian. The proposal was that the compilation should contain the "best" papers published over this period, but it soon became apparent that it would be impossible to bring together a set of papers that all readers would class as the best. In consultation with a number of senior members of the Institution, I put together the following guidelines to be used in selecting papers, they should: i. ii. iii. iv. v.
come from the first 100 years (i.e. 1847-1947); reflect as fairly as possible the full range of Institution activities and interests; be papers which made a significant contribution to engineering at their time of publication; be distributed reasonably evenly over the first 100 years; contain contributions from eminent engineers.
These terms of reference have given us reasonable freedom to include the papers which are contained herein, and to some extent these papers reflect our interpretation of how various sectors of engineering developed during the formative years of the Institution. We were greatly helped by the Fellows of the
ix
Royal Academy of Engineering to whom we wrote at the beginning of the task. They suggested a large number of papers, many of which are included in this volume. We thank all those who made suggestions for their help and hope that we have not offended anyone by not including their recommendations. We must also thank those at MEP and IMechE, both past and present, for their help in this task. The Librarians at Birdcage Walk have maintained a number of complete sets of proceeding over the past 150 years and during two World Wars, a true testimony to their stewardship during this time. Turning now to the 24 papers which have been selected for this volume. We have taken advantage of this opportunity to include brief biographies of the authors and, where possible, we have included portraits. We hope that these are interesting additions to the material from the Proceedings, and they help to place the individual papers in context. Obviously, the small number has been a major restriction on the papers which can be included, and every attempt has been made to get a good coverage of the subject of mechanical engineering, and of the contribution made by the Institution. We trust that readers will agree with our choice. The papers published during this first hundred years differ significantly from those of today in a number of aspects. The phrasing and presentation obviously mirror those of the era, and contrasting styles of the first two papers are fine examples of their time. The explanation of the operation of the slider crank mechanism by Stephenson is relatively tortuous but shows that even 150 years ago engineers were aware of the fallacy of the argument that reciprocating motion was inefficient. The second paper, the obituary of George Stephenson by Scott Russell is an eloquent appreciation of the impact of one life on a whole way of life. It is difficult now to appreciate how the railway improved communication. Before the advent of rail travel many journeys were unique events in a lifetime. Afterwards they became commonplace. The "information technology" of the 1850s was achieved by transporting the people to meetings and distributing the printed word by post. The great advances in mechanical engineering could not have come about without the production of inexpensive steel. The contribution of the mechanical engineer in this area is exemplified by the descriptions of the Dowlais Iron Works (Menelaus), and the Bessemer process. As Scott Russell says, "most of us can remember when the idea of laying wrought-iron bars of 50, 70, or 90 Ibs. weight per yard, for continuous miles, was an expense so utterly beyond the conception of the time as not to be entertained for a moment... At this early stage power was provided either manually or by steam engine and line drive. This was to change
x
with the development of "water pressure machinery" by W G Armstrong, the introduction of the internal combustion engine by Crossley, and later the steam turbine by Parsons. The motive power to drive the British economy had now been put into place, and there were no major new inventions in powerplant until Whittle made his first successful jet engine, and Cockcroft realised the potential of civil nuclear power. However, British mechanical engineers continued to make major contributions to the development of state of the art through the work of Lanchester on aircraft, Railton on racing cars, and Gresley (and others), on locomotives. In the area of transport in general, it is fascinating to see the presentation by Crampton (1882) on a scheme for excavating the Channel Tunnel - it took well over a century to achieve this dream! In addition to making artefacts, mechanical engineers also took an interest in the "science" of their subject, and this is demonstrated by a number of the papers included. The early work by Beauchamp Tower gives an interesting insight into the study of hydrodynamic lubrication, and laid the foundation of a whole area of tribology. The excellent paper on ship waves by Thomson, better known as Lord Kelvin, shows how engineers were attempting to improve the "efficiency" of marine transport by detailed hull design. The vote of thanks to this paper is fascinating, where it is stated 'lt has always been said that "Britannia rules the waves"; and when it is considered how Great Britain does three-fourths of the carrying trade of the world...'. This shows the enormous influence Britain had in the world at that time, and mechanical engineering played a major role in maintaining this. Later, Bragg described his work on crystallography, which revealed the internal structure of materials to the engineers who needed them to achieve their designs - new materials are still an area of great potential for mechanical engineers, and we must continue to maintain our interest in this area. Two other scientific papers which testify to the catholic interests of engineers are those by Eddington, who described the machinery of the stars, and Rutherford who reported his experiments on the atomic scale. Very soon after these scientific presentations, mechanical engineers had taken advantage of this knowledge and ventured into space on the one hand, and harnessed the power of the atom on the other. Finally, we turn to two completely different papers, those of Siemens and Maxim. The first, by Siemens, who came to Britain from Germany in 1843, and made his fortune from the invention of the water-meter. We have chosen to include his paper describing the manufacture of insulated cables which revolutionised telegraphic communications - again mechanical engineers made a major contribution to the transfer of information. The second is by Maxim on the machine-gun, which epitomises the way in which mechanical engineers approach a problem. Maxim carefully analysed the problems of the existing guns
xi
and devised a fail-safe mechanism by which the energy released by the explosive charge in the bullet could be used to drive the gun. The detailed design shown in his drawings is a fine testament to the draughting skills existing at that time. We hope you will have as much pleasure reading this selection from the Proceedings as we had putting it together. The mechanical engineer played a major role in developing our society, and improving the standard of living for all. Engineers provide the means of generating the wealth that enables politicians to achieve their dreams and ours. This collection of papers shows the impact that was made in the first century which continued through the next fifty years. It is the challenge which we must pass to the next generation. Undoubtedly engineering will become more interdisciplinary, but there is still a major role for mechanical engineers to play in nano-technology, fluid mechanics and heat transfer, the efficient use of energy, the use of new materials, and the protection of the environment. The challenges are still there for all mechanical engineers to tackle. We hope this volume encourages modern engineers to pick them up. We would like to thank the President and Council of The Royal Society for permission to reproduce photographs of W H Bragg and Lord Rutherford, and The Royal Astronomical Society for permission to use the photograph of A S Eddington. Thanks also, to Sandra Cumming of the RS, and Peter Hingley of the RAS for their kind assistance, and to Mike Claxton at the IMechE for all other photography. The editors are also indebted to Mr D Gillespie, of Crossley Engines, for providing biographical material. Special thanks to Judith Entwisle-Baker and her team at Mechanical Engineering Publications for all the hard work needed to turn the idea for the book into this fine volume. Desmond Winterbone, FEng UMIST January 1997
xii
Historical notes on the Proceedings of the Institution The Proceedings of the Institution of Mechanical Engineers had their genesis in the earliest of the Ordinary Meetings of members. At the inaugural session on the 27th of January 1847, rules for the conduct of business at the IMechE were approved. These included, as the principle objective: ...to enable Mechanics and, Engineers engaged in the different Manufactories, railways, and other establishments, to meet, correspond, and by mutual interchange of ideas respecting improvements in the various branches of mechanical science to increase their knowledge and give an impulse to invention likely to be useful to the community at large.
There was no explicit commitment to publish engineers' discussions. However, advertisements for IMechE events, placed in local and national newspapers, and the circulation to members of journalists' accounts of meetings, suggest that this was the intention. George Stephenson's Presidential Address, read at the first meeting, was not printed. His career reminiscences were fascinating, but contained no technical detail. In addition, the Institution's early financial difficulties ensured that his paper did not go into print. Membership subscriptions were sought to remedy the problem and Stephenson himself donated £100 to the fledgling organisation. This prompted Council to authorise the Treasurer to seek further funds in this way. By May 1847, Council was in a position to order the printing of what became the first official Proceedings. To encourage the submission of dissertations, a list of potential topics was circulated. In response, the Secretary received papers including: from Mr Chesshire, Surgeon, of Birmingham - On a system of railway carriage buffers, from Mr Johnson, of the Manchester and Leeds Railway and Henry Bessemer - Models of improved train mechanisms; and from Alfred Knight and Mr Crawford - Notes on Brakes. The choice for the first published paper was William Buckle's Series of experiments relative to the fan blast. The Institution published three further papers in 1847. The Buckle essays were sent out to members by 20 November, in all 42 copies posted at a cost of 6d. each. Proceedings were issued in parts, accompanied by large separate sheets of lithographed illustrations. John Turner of Birmingham was the printer. George Falkner of Manchester provided the artwork. This
xiii
Birmingham-Manchester axis reflected the centres of active membership in these formative years. The Institution experimented with various printers, reaching a regular arrangement in 1854, with Billing's Steam Press Offices where the Proceedings were printed until 1877. By the 1860s, over 1,000 copies of each Proceedings part was being produced for circulation. Responsibility for this workload fell to the Secretary. While the IMechE was based in Birmingham, this was William Prime Marshall (1814-1906). From 1877, in London, Walter Raleigh Browne (1842-1884) and Alfred Bache (1835-1907) suceeded to the post. Although the original manuscript versions of papers have not survived, the Institution's archives contain some information from each of the Secretaries on how technical papers reached the press. A book of "sundry memoranda" from the 1860s and 1870s provides notes on what the Secretary expected of authors. Papers best not to exceed a, dozen pages for reading, say...20 minutes. None to exceed 18 pages or 30 minutes. Any longer paper to be condensed for reading, by preparation of written abstract....
The Proceedings were not limited to papers. Reports of annual provincial meetings and descriptions of engineering works visits were added. Memoirs of deceased members appeared from 1862. The Institution's research committees, commencing in 1878, generated reports on specific topics. The increasing size and complexity of the Proceedings prompted Alfred Bache to draft a memorandum in 1889 to acquire assistants who should aid with calculations, reports, minutes, and correspondence, for Research Committees on mechanical subjects. Abstracting and indexing of papers. Preparation of manuscripts for printer. Correction of printer's proof.
In 1906, the Institution of Automobile Engineers followed IMechE from Birmingham to London. From that time, the Autos read their papers in the Mechanicals' meeting rooms in Birdcage Walk. Papers such as Frederick Lanchester's were heard here, forming a "shadow" Proceedings until the official merger of the two bodies in 1947. This merger gave rise to the first subject-based, independent Institution journal which evolved into the multi-part Proceedings of today.
xiv
IMechE Library Bookplate The library bookplate of the Institution of Mechanical Engineers was commissioned from J R G Exley in 1935. An approved design was completed by 1937. The original version incorporated stars and a biplane. These features were omitted in the now-familiar plate, shown here.
xv
Note on SUBJECTS FOR PAPERS From the first meetings of the Institution of Mechanical Engineers in 1847, catalogues of important engineering topics were compiled, both to guide members' discussions and to solicit Proceedings papers. These "Subjects for papers" were circulated as offprints, and as preliminaries to the printed journal. Growing from nine subjects at first, up to 96 sub-divided headings 30 years later, these lists show the areas which interested the engineers of the day.
xvi
InstitutionofMechanicalEngineers. SUBJECTS FOB PAPERS. STEAM ENGINE BOILERS, particulars of construction—form—heating surface—cost—consumption of fuel—evaporation of water—pres sure of steam—steam gauges, high pressure and low pressure— explosion of boilers and means of prevention—effects of heat on the metal of boilers, low pressure and high pressure—incrustation of boilers and means of prevention—evaporative power and economy of different kinds of fuel, coal, wood, charcoal, peat, patent coal, and coke—smoke consuming apparatus, best plan and results of working. STEAM, expansive force and best means of using it—power obtained by various plans—comparison of double and single cylinder engines— indicator figures from engines, with details of useful effects, consumption of fuel, &c.—contributions of indicator figures for a general book of reference to be kept in the Institution. PUMPING ENGINES, particulars of various constructions—size of cylinder, strokes per minute, and horse power—number and size of pumps and strokes per minute—application of pumps—fen draining engines. BLAST ENGINES, best kind of engine—size of cylinder, strokes per minute, and horse power—number of boilers—size of blowing cylinder and strokes per minute—means of regulating the blast— improvements in blast cylinders. MARINE ENGINES, power of engines in proportion to tonnage—different constructions of engines—comparative economy and durability of different boilers, tubular boilers, &c.—weight of machinery and boilers—kind of paddle wheels—speed obtained in British war steamers, in British merchant steamers, and in Foreign ditto, with particulars of the construction of engines and paddle wheels, &c.— screw propellers, particulars of different kinds, number of arms, material, means for unshipping, horse power applied, speed obtained, section of vessel. ROTARY ENGINES, particulars of construction and practical application— details of the results of working. LOCOMOTIVE ENGINES, express, passenger, and luggage engines—general particulars of construction, details of experiments, and results of working—speed of engines, cost, power, weight, steadiness— consumption of fuel—heating surface, length and diameter of tubes —experiments 011 size of tubes and blast pipe—comparative expense of working and repairing—best make of pistons, valve gear, &c. WATER WHEELS, particulars of construction and dimensions—form and depth of buckets—head of water, velocity, per centage of power obtained—scoop wheels for draining—turbines, construction and practical application, power obtained, comparative effect and economy. 1
2
WIND MILLS, particulars of construction—number of sails, surface and form of sails—velocity, and power obtained. FLOUR MILLS, particulars of improvements—power employed—application of steam power — results of working with an air blast — advantages of regularity of motion. SUGAR MILLS, particulars of the construction and working—results of the application of the hydraulic press. SAW MILLS, particulars of construction—mode of driving—power employed—particulars of work done—best speeds for vertical and circular saws—form of saw teeth. OIL MILLS, facts relating to the construction and working. COTTON MILLS, information respecting the construction and arrangement of the machinery—power employed, and application of power— cotton presses, mode of construction and working, power employed. ROLLING MILLS, improvements in machinery for making iron and steel —mode of applying power—steam hammers—piling of iron— plates—fancy sections STAMPING AND COINING MACHINERY, particulars of improvements, &c. PAPER MAKING AND PAPER CUTTING MACHINES, ditto ditto PRINTING MACHINES, ditto ditto CALICO PRINTING MACHINERY, ditto ditto WATER PUMPS, facts relating to the best construction, means of working, and application—best forms—velocity of piston. AIR PUMPS. ditto ditto ditto HYDRAULIC PRESSES, facts relating to the best construction, means of working, and application. FIRE ENGINES, ditto ditto ditto SLUICES, ditto ditto ditto CRANES, ditto ditto ditto LIFTS FOR RAISING TRUCKS, &c. ditto ditto ditto BLOWING FANS, particulars of the best construction, and results of experiments. LATHES, PLANING, BORING, AND SLOTTING MACHINES, &c., particulars of improvements—description of new self-acting tools. TOOTHED WHEELS, best construction and form of teeth—results of working. DRIVING BELTS AND STRAPS, best make and material, leather, rope, gutta percha, &c.—comparative durability and results of working— power communicated by certain sizes. STRENGTH OF MATERIALS—facts relating to experiments on ditto, and general details of the proof of girders, &c.—girders of cast and wrought iron, particulars of different constructions, and experiments on them—best forms and proportions of girders—best mixtures of metal. DURABILITY OF TIMBER of various kinds—best plans for seasoning timber and cordage—-results of Kyan's, Payne's, and Burnett's processes—comparative durability of timber in different situations. CORROSION OF METALS by salt and fresh water, and by the atmosphere, &c.—facts relating to corrosion, and best means of prevention. ALLOYS OF METALS—facts relating to different alloys. FRICTION OF VARIOUS BODIES—facts relating to friction under ordinary 2
3
circumstances—friction of iron, brass, copper, tin, wood, &c.—proportion of weight to rubbing surface—best forms of journals, &c.— lubrication, best materials and means of application, and results of practical trials—best plans for oil tests. IRON ROOFS, particulars of construction for different purposes—durability in various climates and situations—comparative cost, weight and durability—roofs for slips of cast-iron, wrought-iron, timber, &c., best construction, form, and material. FIRE-PROOF BUILDINGS, particulars of construction—most efficient plan —results of trials. CHIMNEY STACKS of large size, particulars, mode of building, &c. BRICKS, manufacture and durability—fire-bricks and fire-clay. GAS WORKS—best form, size, and material for retorts—construction of retort ovens—quantity and quality of gas from different coals— improvements in purifiers, condensers, and gas-holders—wet and dry gas-meters—pressure of gas, gas exhauster—gas pipes, strength and durability, and construction of joints—proportionate diameter and length of gas mains, and velocity of the passage of gas—experiments on ditto, and on the friction of gas in mains and loss of pressure. WATER WORKS—facts relating to water works—application of power, and economy of working—proportionate diameter and length of pipes—experiments on the discharge of water from pipes, and friction through pipes — strength and durability of pipes, and construction of joints. WELL SINKING and ARTESIAN WELLS, facts relating to. COFFER DAMS and PILING, facts relating to the construction. PIERS fixed and floating, and Pontoons, ditto ditto. PILE DRIVING APPARATUS, particulars of improvements—use of steam power. DREDGING MACHINES, particulars of-improvements — application of dredging machines—power required, and work done. DIVING BELLS, facts relating to the best construction. CAST IRON LIGHTHOUSES, ditto ditto MINING OPERATIONS, facts relating to mining—means of ventilating mines, use of steam jet and ventilating machinery—mode of raising materials. BLASTING, facts relating to blasting under water, and blasting generally —use of gun cotton, &c. BLAST FURNACES — consumption of fuel in different kinds—burden, make, and quality of metal—pressure of blast—horse power required—economy of working—improvements in manufacture of iron—comparative results of hot and cold blast. HEATING FURNACES, best construction—consumption of fuel, &c. SMITHS' FORGES, best construction—size and material—power of blast. COKE and CHARCOAL, particulars of the best mode of making. RAILWAYS—construction of permanent way—section of rails, and mode of manufacture—experiments on rails, deflection, deterioration, and comparative durability—material and form of sleepers, size, and distances—improvements in chairs, keys, and joint fastenings. 3
4
SWITCHES and CROSSINGS, particulars of improvements, and results of working. TURNTABLES, particulars of various constructions and improvements. SIGNALS for Stations and Trains, and self-acting signals. BREAKS for Carriages and Waggons, best construction. BUFFERS for Carriages, &c., and Station Buffers—different constructions and materials. SPRINGS for Carnages, &c., buffing and bearing springs—particulars of different constructions, and results of working. RAILWAY WHEELS, wrought iron, cast iron, and wood—particulars of different constructions, and results of working—comparative expense and durability—wrought iron and steel tires, comparative economy and results of working. RAILWAY AXLES, best description, form, material, and mode of manufacture. The Council invite communications from the Members and their friends, on the preceding subjects, and on any engineering subjects that will be useful and interesting to the Institution; also presentations of engineering drawings, models, and books for the library of the Institution. The communications should be written on foolscap paper, on one side only of each page, leaving a clear margin on the left side for binding ; and they should be written in the third person. The drawings illustrating the communications should be on so large a scale, as to be clearly visible to the meeting at the time of reading the communication, or enlarged diagrams should be sent for the illustration of any particular portions. W. P. MARSHALL, Secretary. Temple Buildings, New Street, Birmingham, 6th October, 1849.
Printed by B. Hunt and Sons. 75, High Street, Birmingham. 4
George Stephenson (1781-1848) Lauded in his own lifetime, he was described as "a humble mechanic (who) had raised himself to a position which kings or emperors might envy". Stephenson's reputation as "Father of the Railways" has tended to obscure his very real achievements as an engineer. Born at Wylam near Newcastle-upon-Tyne, Stephenson followed his father's example by becoming a colliery fireman and, later, brakesman. A talent for the repair and improvement of pumping engines combined with a desire for self improvement allowed him to prosper, and at one stage he planned to broaden his horizons by emigrating to America. Stephenson was courageous too. He would later relate how his action in saving a mine from fire earned him a horse and two additional rooms for his cottage. His early awareness of the effects of fire was behind his first wholly original invention, a miners' safety lamp, tried at Killingworth in 1815. By that time, Stephenson had also witnessed local attempts at introducing locomotive engines for coal haulage and had built his first colliery train. Many design improvements followed, leading to the machines which powered the Stockton to Darlington line (from 1822) and the Liverpool to Manchester railway (from 1830). From the time the Rocket had triumphed in the Rainhill speed trials, Stephenson's life was "a history of the railway progress of the country". He was employed as chief engineer to many railway companies, but never lost his interest in mining. When he later moved to Derbyshire he turned his hand to developing the coal stocks in that county. Throughout a distinguished career, George Stephenson steadfastly refused to be honoured. His acceptance of the Presidency of the Institution of Mechanical Engineers was a rare concession to his chosen profession in the final year of his life. His acceptance speech was directed at young engineers; one of those present would later recollect that Stephenson still spoke in the strong accent of his own youth.
5
PROCEEDINGS. The usual GENERAL MEETING of the Members was held in the Theatre of the Philosophical Institution, Cannon-street, Birmingham, on "Wednesday, the 26th of July, 1848; GEORGE STEPHENSON, Esq., President, took the chair at four p. M. The minutes of the previous meeting were read by the Secretary, Mr. Kintrea, and confirmed. The PRESIDENT said, that the first Paper to be read, according to the programme, would be his own, "On the Fallacies of the Rotary Engine;" and,—having alluded to the model of a Rotary Engine before the meeting, by a Mr. Onion, then present,—he invited the fullest discussion on his Paper, and on that model. He would show that no power was either gained or lost by the crank; and that, in effect, it was precisely the same as a simple lever. He then exhibited a diagram explanatory of his views ; and read the following Paper:—
ON THE FALLACIES OF THE ROTARY ENGINE. " As all levers give out their powers at right angles to their fulcrums, it will be seen that the right angle line I, (referring to the accompanying diagram) from the connecting rod to the centre of the beam, will be the true measure of the length of the beam, when the crank is at half stroke ; therefore,1/20of half the length of the beam will be gained by the piston end of the beam. The crank being 3 feet long, the up and down stroke of the piston will be 12 feet; the crank pin will, of course, have passed through a space of nearly 19 feet. " Now, a weight hanging upon the drum, which is nearly 4 feet in diameter, will balance the same weight on the piston end of the beam; each will move at the same velocity, and pass through the same space in the same time. " It will be observed, that from C to D is a little more than 1/3 longer than from G to D; it will, therefore, be seen, that the weight at the piston end of the beam has a little more than1/3advantage over the weight at the drum. And it will also be seen, that from C to E is half way from half stroke to the bottom centre; at this portion of the stroke, the leverage of the crank will be nearly 2 feet. The increased power that existed in the crank from half stroke to this point, will gradually be lost from E to H : it is, therefore, clearly proved, that no power is lost by the crank motion,—as the weights resolve themselves into a simple lever. 7
2 There will be a little loss of power when the engine is turning the centres, which is compensated for at the connecting rod end of the beam, by the segment of the right angle line I. " Now, a rotary engine can only give out its power on the arm, like any other lever; and if the piston passes through a space of 19 feet, it will just balance a weight equal to the same power passing through the same space. " GEOEGE STEPHENSON." Tapton House, 23rd July, 1848.
The PRESIDENT went on to observe, that the fallacy of Mr. Onion's principle was pretty conclusively proved by the fact, that fifty patents, at least, had been taken out for Rotary Engines, every one of which had failed. No man who ever lived could improve on the lever principle, as there was no power but in the lever. He would now be glad to hear the opinions of the members, and also any explanation that Mr. Onion might wish to offer. Mr. ONION then stated, that his engine had been working for some weeks at the Derby station, by permission of Mr. Kirtley, the Locomotive Superintendant of the Midland Railway; and, during that trial, experiments with his and another engine had proved that his effected a material saving in fuel. A statement to that effect, authenticated by Mr. Kirtley, was now in the possession of Mr. M'Connell, at whose suggestion he attended that meeting. The PRESIDENT said, that it appeared to him to be impossible that such could be the case. The engine might have answered at one trial, but it might fail at the next; and one trial was by no means a sufficient proof. Mr. SLATE observed, that there was one important desideratum which he desired to see obtained in the Rotary Engine,—namely, some method of packing tightly. That had never yet been found. He had paid much attention to the Rotary Engine, and had seen approaches made to an efficient system of packing, but none had been so perfect as to render the rotary principle equal to the crank. Mr. Onion had told them that his engine was more simply packed than the common engine, and he should like to have that made quite clear to the meeting. Mr. ONION said, that Mr. Scott Russell, who had written on and patented several Rotary Engines, confessed to him, that he 8
3
(Mr. Onion) had succeeded in overcoming difficulties which had hitherto been found to be insurmountable; such as making his engine steam-tight; and, also, doing away with the usual noise of the Rotary Engine. He was satisfied that his engine would bear a comparison with one upon any other principle. Mr. JOSEPH MILLER said, that one great advantage of the Rotary Engine, supposing it to be thoroughly efficient, was the small space which it occupied. If it were made as perfectly tight as the ordinary engine,—admitting, that tightness was one of the advantages of the common crank,—a useful result would be accomplished. He had never yet seen a Rotary Engine rendered sufficiently tight, but he would not go the length of saying, that it could not be done. As a practical man, however, he saw great difficulties in the way. He had never seen a Rotary Engine which remained tight for any length of time; and he should as soon expect to discover the perpetual motion as to make one which would. The PRESIDENT observed, that if he believed there was any thing in Mr. Onion's engine, he would be very happy to give his assistance in bringing it before the public ; but he really could not see any thing of value in it. Mr. MILLER thought that the question of the crank and the Rotary Engine ought now to be finally settled. It was very desirable that that should be done. On being referred to, Mr. HENRY ROBINSON said, that the Government had a Rotary Engine (Lord Dundonald's) working in the Portsmouth dock-yard for the last seven years. Mr. Onion claimed the credit of being the first who had ever succeeded in packing efficiently, but it was only the same as he (Mr. Robinson) had been in the habit of using for years; Mr. Onion had not therefore, advanced anything at all new. If Mr. Onion would call upon him in London, he would show him an engine similar to his own, and packed in the very same way. It was one that was applied to a locomotive, and commonly known as the " Jim Crow Engine,"—from its having been painted black. The difficulty with Rotary Engines had hitherto been in keeping them tight9
4
The difference between Mr. Onion's engine and the one at Portsmouth dock-yard was,, that in the latter, the packing did not depend upon springs. All that he (Mr. Robinson) was prepared to say about that engine (Lord Dundonald's) was, that it had hitherto done the work which it was intended to do. The PRESIDENT asked if any member was of opinion that there was a loss of power by the use of the crank ? they had heard e/ his reasons for asserting that their was no loss; and he wished that those who entertained a contrary opinion should declare it. A Member having spoken of Beale's Rotary Engine, the President stated, that he had been concerned in having a trial made of that engine, in a steam boat intended to carry passengers a short distance of only half a mile, to Yarmouth; but when the engine was put to work, he could not get the boat to move forward, and so the experiment failed. He managed to get the boat to sea, and it cost him and his party £40 to bring her back again. As to Lord Dundonald's engine, he was invited, on one occasion, to see it tried on the Liverpool and Manchester railway; but he refused to go, because he was convinced that a failure would be the result; and so it was,—for the engine could not be made to draw a train of empty carriages. Mr. ROBINSON :—But I think you will agree with me, sir, that there is no loss of power consequent upon the principle of the Rotary Engine. The PRESIDENT :—Not if you make it tight. Mr. ROBINSON :—The object of the Rotary Engine is to economise space and power; and if we cannot attain that end, there is something wrong in the mechanical means which are made use of. Mr. BENJAMIN GIBBONS said, that the only difficulty with the Rotary Engine was to keep it tight; but after trying many experiments to overcome that objection, he had never succeeded. The PRESIDENT then called on Mr. Buckle, who read the following Paper; having first premised, that he had chosen the subject in order to give variety to the proceedings. 10
This page intentionally left blank
John Scott Russell (1808-1882) Born at Parkhead near Glasgow, Russell followed many of his fellow Scots into shipbuilding, although by an unusual route. A good scholar, Russell graduated with an MA from Glasgow University and was made temporary Professor of Natural Philosophy on the death of John Leslie in 1832. He commenced a series of researches into wave theory which resulted in his discovery of the "wave of translation". In practical terms, this allowed Russell to devise a wave-line system for the design and construction of ships which would revolutionise naval architecture. Russell's wave researches (summarised in a succeeding paper by William Thomson in this volume, q.v.) earned him the Gold Medal of the Royal Society of Edinburgh. More importantly, vessels were built to his specifications: these were initially small iron steamers such as the Wave, but the years 1839-1840 saw the launch of larger ocean-going ships, the Flambeau and Fire-King. Eventually, Russell's ideas were used in the design of a fleet of transatlantic Royal Mail ships, plying the West Indies route. Russell's reputation is indelibly associated with two projects from the 1850s - his preliminary work with the Great Exhibition in 1851, and his involvement in the building of I K Brunei's Great Eastern. As Secretary to the Society of Arts in the years 1845-1850, Russell energetically promoted the idea of an international trade fair which was triumphantly realised at the Crystal Palace. The Leviathan, as Brunei's ship was originally called, provides a more controversial legacy. Some writers, particularly L T C Rolt, have rather one-sidedly held Russell to account for construction delays. In 1860 a Russell-designed vessel as revolutionary as Great Eastern took to the water - this was the Warrior, the first armoured, ocean-going fighting ship of the Royal Navy. Non-maritime projects also provided scope for Russell's originality of mind. The rotunda used at the Vienna Exhibition of 1873, then the largest dome ever built, was Russell's swansong and a fine rival to Joseph Paxton's better-known feat of structural engineering at Crvstal Palace.
13
PROCEEDINGS. THE usual GENERAL MEETING of the Members was held in tho Theatre of the Philosophical Institution, Cannon Street, Birmingham, on Wednesday, the 25th of October, 1848; J. E. M'CONNELL, Esq., V. P., in the Chair. The minutes of the former meeting having been read by Mr. Kintrea, the Secretary, were confirmed. The CHAIRMAN, in opening the business of the meeting, said they were met for the first time since the death of their lato lamented President; an event which, he was sure, all of them deplored most nnfeiffnedlv. He was a man who raised himself by his own talents to a distinguished position in society, and whose nanie, so long as railways existed, would endure. A member of Council, Mr. Scott Russell, had kindly undertaken the task of writing a memoir of their late President, and had intended to have been present, that evening, to read it. The Secretary had, however, received a letter from Mr. Russell stating, that illness prevented him coming; it was therefore left to him, (Mr. M'Connell) to read it.
NOTICE OF THE LIFE AND CHARACTER OF THE LATE
GEORGE STEPHENSON, FIRST
PRESIDENT
OF THE
INSTITUTION OF MECHANICAL
ENGINEERS ;
Prepared, by desire of Ike Council,
BY J. SC'OTT R U S S E L L , ONE OF THE M E M B E R S OF THE COUNCIIL.
" I wish I could address myself to the business of this evening with a feeling that the duty which you have devolved upon me were less inevitable, or more worthily performed. We have met to deplore the loss, not merely of one of the Founders of our Society, but, also, of a personal friend, whom we have long regarded with reverence and affection. Had these feelings of affection been alone regarded, perhaps our mournful silence would have formed the most expressive exponent of our grief; but the expression of our grief is the least of our duties. In our late President, England has lost one of her most distinguished men,—the world one of its great Benefactors.
15
4 " It is not as our President merely, standing as such at the head of the Mechanical Engineers of Britain, that the name of Stephenson will be known to posterity ; he will he known to posterity as the presiding Genius of our times; for of this we may be firmly assured, that the times in which we live will be known to posterity as the era in which Railways and the Locomotive Engine were first introduced as elements of social progress. It will be recorded, that about the middle of the nineteenth century Locomotives first began to run upon Railways, and that George Stephenson, the President of the Institution of Mechanical Engineers, was the Man to whose original genius chieiiy the world was indebted for the discovery. " It is difficult for us, to whom the words Railway and Locomotive are household words, to us who live, move, and have our being among Railways and their manifold social results, to go back again, even in imagination, to the beginning of the twenty years ago when were without them. So fast, indeed, we may be said to have lived through those twenty years ; so much we have been able to travel over, and see, and learn, and do, that it seems longer to go back over these twenty years, than over centuries of the slower times that went before. We, who have each of us this day come our hundreds of miles to this meeting, and may still have to return hundreds of miles to our homes this night, will find it hard to believe in the records of perils, privations, and delays, which but a few years ago made a journey from Newcastle to Birmingham one of those serious undertakings of life which were anticipated with apprehension, and recollected with congratulation. We now do more work and see more society, acquire more knowledge, by personal observation, in one day of railway life, than we were wont to do in weeks of ' the good old time.' It will be necessary, however, to task our imaginations, and go back to the times before Stephenson, in order duly to appreciate the full value of the benefits which his labors have conferred upon us. " It is not, however, alone with what George Stephenson did, that we are concerned ; still more important it is for us to consider that George Stephenson was. His title to our gratitude is no doubt great; but his claim to our admiration, as a man, is still greater. As a plain labouring workman we first find him distinguished by his untiring industry, by his zeal for the interests of his employers, and by his steadiness, sobriety, and honesty. We next find him, after having mastered all the details and drudgery of his business, continually on the watch for improvements, cultivating habits of accurate observation, and spending every leisure moment in classifying and comparing the results of his own observation, and in deducing from them hints for future improvement. Did an accident occur in his mine, his whole thoughts were immediately directed to the means of preventing its recurrence. His business, in the humble capacity of a breaksman, took him casually to the vicinity of a condensing steam engine, where the property of his master, through ignorance and mismanagement, was in danger of suffering serious damage. The young breaksman had already carefully studied the nature of its parts, and thought over the principles of its construction; the regular engineer had been baffled in his remedies, and despaired of a cure; but the youthful breaksman confided in the strength of his convictions and boldly undertook the task of refitting the machine ; the stubborn engine became at once, in his hands, obedient and useful; he had discovered for himself the secrets of the steam engine ; and at five and twenty the young coal-worker had become a Mechanical Engineer. " Thus early were the results of his self-education manifest. He had mastered the discoveries of Watt. It is true, indeed, his whole life had been one of discovery;
16
5 but as yet he had discovered no more than those who had gone before him. His had been the best of all education,—the education which a truth-loving mind, working its way among dead matter, and wrestling with the laws of nature, receives directly from nature herself,—an education far more profound and prolific than words, books, or lectures can ever impart. He had learned the laws of nature at first hand, and by experience; he knew partially what the true properties of matter were ; he felt that what they were, was exactly what they ought to have been; and however indefinitively he might be able to give reasons to others for his belief, yet one of the most valuable results of his practical self-education was to give him that implicit confidence in his own right understanding of nature, which carried him so boldly through the herculean undertakings of his future life. The whole first years of his early life were, in this way, one continued chain of discovery. Who can tell the pleasure, or weigh the profit, which such an education bestows on the simple and correct student,—compared to the formality of written dissertations, and the dryness of second-hand knowledge. " As yet, we have had said he discovered nothing new; but he was now on the eve of making a discovery, the reputation of which has enobled the name of one of our greatest chemical philosophers. A mechanic, James Watt, had already anticipated the philosophers Cavendish and Lavoisier in the analysis of water; and another was now about to anticipate Sir Humphrey Davy in the invention of the Safety Lamp. " That Stephenson was the original inventor of the Safety Lamp is now happily beyond doubt. Like most other inventions which seem to make their appearance in several places simultaneously, at the moment when the want of them has come to be deeply and generaly felt, the Safety-Lamp seems to have started into being at the same moment, nearly, in London and Newcastle. Stephenson and Davy had both discovered the principle 011 which they proposed to proceed, before either had made the lamp; but Stephenson's was made and used the first. That Stephenson first invented the lamp admits of no doubt, however much the question may remain as to how far Davy may not also be entitled to the merit of equal originality : priority to Stephenson no one can justly lay claim. " It is as a professional Engineer and a practical Mechanic that we here have chiefly entrusted to us to do justice to the memory of our distingished president. But we should do violent injustice to our own feelings if we were to pass altogether without notice his social character and private life. It is well for us all to recollect, that mere eminence as mechanics, or mechanical inventors, is not enough in the social world to make us either command the love or respect of our fellows. It is as men, chiefly, that we respect one another; it is moral character and social virtue for which we chiefly love each other. It has, indeed, been remarked, by some, on the character of our profession, that the continual struggle with tough, hard, and refractory substances, which form the business of the engineer, has the effect of communicating a hardness of character, an obstinacy of disposition, and a rigidity of temper, to men of our craft, which does not add to their excellence as members of society. It must be remembered, however, as a palliative for such faults, where they exist, that every Inventor is at first in a minority of one ; all the rest of the world is, for the time, against him; and it is often only by a long and hard fight that he at last succeeds in converting his minority into a majority.
17
6 "Invention is, therefore, a battle with the world ; and it is not easy, always, for the inventor to again consider with complacency his enemies in the field, and to adopt them as his companions in the closet. The antagonism "between the inventive man and the sceptical world is apt to extend itself to the social state. But Stephenson was, happily for himself and the world, a man endowed with no common share of the endowments which make the intercourse of life useful to himself and delightful to his friends. His energies had been sufficient to cany him through much opposition without cooling the ardour of his affections, originally warm and genial, and, above all, without chilling the enthusiasm, or closing the openness of disposition, which characterized the sanguine youth. In his latter clays he was distinguished for the childlike simplicity of his character, for the transparency of his intentions, for the singleness of his purposes, and for the straightforward manly honesty of his conversation and dealings. If he could hate an enemy, he never masked his antipathy by hypocrisy; but he was a warm and earnest friend. "Greatly, however, as Stepheiison's name will continue to "be distinguished among us as the inventor of the safety-lamp, and as a youthful mechanic of wonderful shrewdness and sagacity, it is as the first constructor and chief inventor of Locomotives and Railways that he will be known to posterity. It is in this capacity that he has conferred on society blessings which are rapidly extending to the widest limits of civilization, and which already cover Europe and one half of America. The introduction of railways is the great distinguishing event of the thirty years peace; and to them must principally be attributed the strong bonds of amity which are continually drawing nations closer and closer together; it is to railways, and the unity of international interests arising from them, that we are indebted for maintenance of that peace, unbroken for thirty years, and for the very remarkable events we are now witnessing in the existence of a casus belli in the heart of Europe, and yet of the invincible reluctance of the great powers to supply the fuel for a general war. The peace of Europe will now, we may trust, by the progress of railways and the consequent multiplication.of intercourse, be rendered as substantial as the peace of the nations of the heptarchy of England;—for we have nearly reached that period of railway intercourse, when the capitals of different nations of Europe are not separated so far from one another, either in the length of time, or in the rarity and peril of intercourse, as were the five capitals of the Anglo-Saxon kingdoms of our ancestors: Canterbury, York, and Gloucester were then more distant than are now London, Berlin, and Vienna. " How all this was early brought about, how much George Stephenson had to do with it, is now too familiar to every mind to need repetition. You all know how he early got permission from Lord Ravensworth and the proprietors of the Killingworth collieries to make an iron substitute for the horses which drew his coal waggons; how he succeeded in driving teams of waggons some six miles an. hour; but all of you who recollect these huge unweildy-looking monsters of that early time, and especially those who, like myself, then had to do with them, must remember how little we dreamed of seeing these clumsy affairs go 10 or 20, much less 50 or 60 miles an hour. Indeed, whether we look at the railway or the machine, both would have immediately been smashed to pieces had any force accelerated their speed to 10 miles an hour. It was never dreamed of, except by one dreamer, who believed in 10, 20,50, and 100 miles an hour, and who had recently determined to do it.
18
7 " The two inventions which have been combined to produce the modem Railway system may be said to be, the malleable iron rails and the locomotive engine. These were the two elements of high velocity,—each of which formed the absolute condition of the existence of the other. Without the system of laying a continuous wrought-iron rail, the notion of a velocity of 50 miles an hour could not have been entertained; and without the locomotive engine, such an expensive line could never have proved remunerative. " Most of us can remember when the idea of laying wrought-iroii bars of 50, 70, or 90 Ibs. weight per yard, for continuous miles, was an expense so utterly beyond the conception of the time, as not to be entertained for a moment; and this for an obvious reason, that no particular amount of traffic would have paid for it. I think I am warranted in saying, that no amount of traffic which horses, merely, could convey along a line of modem railway could yield a remunerative return, unless, perhaps, under peculiar circumstances, which are exceptional; I am therefore, I think, safe in saying, that the wrought-iron railroad was essentially dependent on the locomotive engine. " But that the modern locomotive engine could not subsist without the wrought-iron rail and its multifarious appendages of chains, keys, locks, sleepers, switches, crossings, sidings, and turntables, is too evident to need proof. Without the smoothness of the rail, the engine would be jolted to pieces, and without the easy motion which it gives, the engine could not be made to draw a sufficient profitable load to pay; and further, unless made of wrought-iron, it would be impossible to attain the high speed of the locomotive without iminent danger. It therefore appears that the continuous wrought-iron railway and the locomotive engine were inventions intimately related to each other, and each a condition of the other's success. To Stephenson we are indebted for the chief features of improvement in both. It was the joint perfection of the road and the engine which created the Liverpool and Manchester line, and all the progeny of that wonderful and gigantic experiment; an experiment whose complete success now bears incontrovertible testimony to the genius of the man. " There are several lessons which the life of Stephenson should enforce upon us, the members of a profession which he advanced, and of a society which he so materially assisted in founding, and in the promotion of which he took a constant and deep interest. Indeed, we cannot cast even a hasty glance back over the events of his life, without perceiving that the foundation of our Society was an act most appropriate to the termination of a career so arduous and successful. Let us endeavour to define some of those objects, and then consider how we can best accomplish them. " In the first place, then, one of the great objects of our Society is the encouragement of mechanical invention and the promotion of scientific improvement. Thus it becomes our duty to supply to this generation a great want, chiefly felt by Stephenson in his early career. The unhappy moments of his youth were those in which his inventions encountered the opposition of prejudice and interest, and when his propositions were decried because of their very originality,—because they were new, strange, unheard of, and, therefore, contrary to verified opinion. What he wanted and could not find in his youth, this Society presents to the youthful genius of this generation,—an enlightended, unprejudiced, and first ordeal, where every youthful inventor, every mechanic of original talent, every proposer of that which is new and promises to be useful, will find a body of experienced practical
19
8 men, to whom the country looks up as her wisest men, ready and willing to listen to the plans, to test the proposals, to weigh the value, and to award the praise and approbation to which the rising Stepheiisons of this generation may aspire; but which the old Stephenson could no where find, and in the want of which he was compelled to expend many years of vigour and energy in obscurity and penury. Let us see that in our hands no youthful genius, however little known, shall find his genius obscured, or his energies discouraged, eclipsed, or extinguished. If I rightly interpret the feelings of this Society, they would hail with welcome any discovery, and cooperate heartily and disinterestedly in giving to the world its benefit, and to genius its honors and rewards. " Another circumstance must have greatly impaired the means of usefulness of Stephenson in his early life, and one that he most deeply felt,—viz., the want of knowing that which other men were doing, and had done before him, in subjects allied to those in which he was occupying his mind. Thus much we know with certainty, that no man was more happy to communicate, in after life, to others the abundant stores of practical knowledge he had accumulated, and that no one felt a more kindly interest in the inventions and plans of younger men, or was more disposed to promote their interest and forward their views. Let us regard it as a part of his legacy so to impart, liberally, to all younger members of the profession, what more knowledge or greater experience may have enabled us to acquire. After all, there is no tribute more gratifying to the members of our profession than the due appreciation by each other of that which each of us may have done to advance the interests, and increase the resources of mechanical science. "It would not be fair to the character of our late President to omit from our recollection the very large and original views which he entertained on general science. It has been too common in our profession to place science and practice in opposition to one another; as if true science and hard practice could possibly be opposed. If science mean that which is carefully ascertained, and accurately defined, and truly demonstrated,—then it is impossible that any sound practice can possibly stand in opposition to, or independent of, it. If practice mean the knowledge which is founded on the actual facts and experience of intelligent men, it is impossible to see how the largest amount of that knowledge possessed by any one man can differ from the extensive and generalised facts in which science embodies the experience of all mankind. Stephenson is a remarkable freedom from this prejudice. He was eminently a practical man. He wrought early, and much, with his own hands. He had wrestled with matter, and knew all its qualities by feeling it and pushing it and pulling it, by cutting and filing and chipping it. He had hammered it hot and hammered it cold, he had melted it and moulded it, planed it and sawn it, broken it across, pulled it asunder, and twisted it round. He knew its action and its reaction, its inertia and its momentum, its vis mortua and its vis una. His was a supremely practical and personal acquaintance with the laws and property and phenomena natural to matter, whether solid or liquid, fluid or gaseous, mineral or aerial, more than any man who has ever risen to eminence. Stephenson was entitled to rank as a consummately practical man. But was he not equally, or more, a scientific than a practical Engineer ? Was there ever a bolder theorist than he was ? Were there ever more daring scientific speculations than those wild flights in which his genius delighted to break forth ? In chemistry' in vegetable physiology, in vital mechanism, in electricity, in galvanism, in the theories of the gases, on the inert constitution of matter, and of heat, and even
20
9 on the mechanism of the mind itself, he had deeply thought, profoundly read, and boldly and fearlessly speculated. Every step in his life was the realisation of what had before been a theory. It is true he was not educated early in the rudiments of science, at school or at college; but what of that ? what is life but a great school ? Is not the press our school, and necessity our school of invention ? Stephenson read and studied science ;—he was not ignorant, but he was self-taught. Before he became a great man he had studied profoundly, and he does not appear to have ventured on any construction or invention, before having accurately, and generally truly, calculated by the principles of science, its probable and actual results. In all his works, Stephenson exhibits to us embodiments, eminently practical, of the profoundest principles of mechanical science. Let the men among us who desire to emulate him most, endeavour to combine, in the greatest degree, the truest science with the soundest practical sense. These are not times in which any of us can afford to dispense with any science, or any practice, that it may be in his power to obtain. " I will now venture upon an illustration of the advantage of uniting high science with extensive practice, which has often occurred to me as an excellent illustration of Mr. Stephenson's scientific knowledge, and also as an illustration of the advantage he would have derived, as a practical man, from having been still more profoundly scientific than he was. Stephenson, we know, invented the fishbellied rail, and a great invention it was thought in its day. The Liverpool and Manchester Railway was opened with it. It was an invention to give, with a small addition of metal to the under middle side of the rail, nearly double the strength, and this it successfully accomplished. But here he stopped short: he had not science enough to see, that by making the wrought-iron bar in long lengths, stretching over a number of blocks, or sleepers, he had brought it into a new condition, to which a much higher rule was applicable ;—he neglected the difference between a rail having a joint at every chair, and one having only a joint at every fifth or sixth chair; had he perceived that, he would have invented the parellel rail, and would have learned that the joint chairs require to be nearer together than those removed from the joint by a fixed proportion. The fish-bellied rail was a failure. It was the result of science ; but of science of which there was not enough. It was also the result of practice ; but of practice under different conditions. It was reserved for Mr. Buck, a profoundly scientific pupil of Stephenson.'s, to develope the true science of the wrought-iron rail. Where not a little science had failed, a little more made the invention perfect. Let us learn from this to be always trying to obtain a little more science, as well as a little more practice, than we have got,—remembering that Stephenson continued his education of himself to his dying day. " The best testimony, however, which Mr. Stephenson has borne to the value of scientific education for a practical man, is to be found in the course he adopted for the training of his son to our profession. The assiduity with which he laboured at clock-making, the cleaning of watches, or any other industry, in the intervals of his regular business, in order that he might be able to afford to him those blessings of education of which he himself so deeply felt the want, is one of the most charming features in his character. His most earnest desire, in early difficulty, was to give Robert all those precious thoughts and truths which he himself only acquired late and too labouriously. And how admirably his plan succeeded, his son's unclouded successes, both as a Mechanical and a Civil Engineer, are the B
21
10 evidence to us, as indeed they were the subject of just pride to himself, who never spoke of his son without strong emotions of joy and pride. There are none of us who will question either the justice of his pride or the soundness of his plan of education. " It is one of the peculiarities of genius to inspire those within its influence with some of its own fire. This was peculiarly the case with Stepheiison. Nearly all the present ornaments of our profession have been his pupils. He was the founder of a school of eminent engineers, who in England, Europe, and India, are now extending, amongst all portions of the human race, the blessings of those great bonds of civilization and social intercourse which he first fabricated. It is to his labours, and theirs, that this country owes the addition of £200,000,000 to its productive wealth, the opening up of a host of new branches of industry, the quickening and invigorating influence of rapid and cheap intercourse ; and to him that the poor everywhere owe the blessings of cheapened coal, and the facilities of social enjoyment and healthful recreation. " In this brief notice of the chief features and character of our late president, which I have thus imperfectly, although most earnestly, sketched amid the bustle of business, I have dwelt mainly upon such features and characteristics as were peculiarly interesting or instructive to us, as members of an institution founded, in a great measure by himself, for professional purposes. I have regarded, therefore, chiefly his professional character; but I cannot conclude without expressing an earnest wish, that his life as a man, exhibiting the beauty and excellence of his character in all its cheering aspects, as a boy, as a workman, as an engine-man, as a viewer, as an engine builder, as an improver of mineral railways, as the engineer of the Liverpool and Manchester Railway, should be written by some one who has leisure to collect from his many friends all their recollections of him, while they remain fresh and accessible. I should desire also to see a detailed account given of his progress, his difficulties and his means of success in any one of his labors. This would be a most valuable and instructive work; and I do not know on whom it should devolve more properly to see such a work executed faithfully and judiciously than on this society, whom he made the favoured recipients of his knowledge and experience, and who ought to consider themselves as his literary and scientific executors, to whom the world may naturally look to see justice done to the memory of one of England's greatest men, the founder of our railway system and of the Institution of Mechanical Engineers."
The memoir, which, both at the close and during the time of reading, elicited expressions of admiration, having been read, the CHAIRMAN said, he presumed it would be unnecessary to put it to the vote, that the members return their best thanks to Mr. Scott Russell, for his very able memoir. The vote was carried with acclammation. Mr. GEACH rose and said, it was with melancholy satisfaction he begged to move, that they place on the minutes of their proceedings an expression of the regret they all felt at the loss of so excellent a man as their late friend, Mr. George Stephenson,— apart from his having been the President of this Institution. He
22
11 well recollected Mr. Stephenson, on the last occasion of their meeting, filling the place which Mr. M'Connell now so worthily occupied, in high spirits and in good health. The recollection of the circumstance cast a gloom over his feelings, and he was sure it would have the same effect on every member present. He had known Mr. Stephenson a shorter time, perhaps, than many of them; but he had known him well enough not only to entertain respect for him, but affection also. There was something so endearing about his manners, so open and kind, and so encouraging to all those less experienced than himself,—there was so much of kindheartedness about him, that no one could help entertaining for him a high respect. He would quite allow that his manners were sometimes rough,—he would quite allow that there were peculiarities in his character, which had to be considered as peculiarities; but he was quite sure those who knew him best considered that these very peculiarities gave him a greater claim on their regard. He was willing to allow that he had seen in Mr. Stephenson what in other men might subject them to criticism; but when it came from Mr. Stephenson, it came from a privileged person. Mr. Stephenson was proud of his own early life, and he never lost any opportunity of expressing it,— he never attempted to conceal that he came from the lowest grade of society, and had raised himself to his high station; and he ever evinced the same pleasure in meeting an associate of his early life, in humble circumstances, as he did to meet the peers of the realm, with many of whom he associated in later life. He had the same gratification on meeting one whom he had known in early life, or the son, or connection, of such a one, and in referring back to the time when they had struggled together through difficulties, as he did in referring to the occasion when he was taken by the hand by the highest in the land. Although oppressed with these recollections, he could not content himself without making the few remarks he had; and he now begged to move,— " That the members of this Institution desire to express their deep regret at the decease of their late President, George Stephenson, whose early support of the Institution so greatly contributed to bring it to its present state of prosperity and success." Mr. FOTHERGILL, in seconding the resolution, expressed his great sorrow that such a duty should devolve on him. After the 23
12
observations of Mr. Geach he should content himself with merely seconding the resolution, for he was sure that every one participated in the same feelings of deep regret. The resolution was put and carried unanimously. The CHAIRMAN then rose and said, that immediately on hearing of the death of their late President, the Council met, at Manchester, and, after forwarding a letter of condolence to his widow, for the irreparable loss she had sustained, they resolved, that the best tribute they could pay to the late Mr. Stephenson's memory, and the best way in which they could testify their appreciation of his merits, besides at the same time the best selection of a future president they could make from among the eminent men of the dav, would be to invite Mr. Robert Stephenson to become his father's successor, as president of this institution. The Council did so feeling assured that the members would entertain the same opinion. Accordingly, two of the Council were appointed a deputation to wait on Mr. Stephenson. Owing to an accident they were prevented from seeing Mr. Stephenson, but a most satisfactory and pleasing correspondence ensued, which would be read by one of the deputation. Afterwards it would be his duty to nominate Mr. Robert Stephenson, as the future president. Mr. FOTHERGILL said, that Mr. Buckle and himself were the deputation appointed to wait on Mr. Stephenson; but for the reason stated by the Chairman, they had not been able to see him. They had, however, a correspondence, and Mr. Stephenson's reply did equal credit to his character as a man, and to his feelings as a dutiful son. He had not the letter with him; but the substance of it was, that, if elected, nothing would be wanting on his part to discharge the duties of the office in a manner satisfactory to the members, and that he would endeavour to watch over the interests of the Institution as earnestly as his lamented father had done. The CHAIRMAN then begged to propose Robert Stephenson, Esquire, as President of the Institution. He felt certain that every member would agree with him, that a better choice could not be made. Mr. Robert Stephenson was a worthy son of a worthy father; and the Institution would gain additional lustre by having that gentleman as its President. The resolution was
24
13
seconded by Mr. Fbthergill, and carried unanimously, amid every demonstration of satisfaction.
25
This page intentionally left blank
Richard Peacock (1820-1889) From Swaledale, West Yorkshire, Peacock was a true child of the railway age - it is said that with his father, he witnessed the opening of Stephenson's Stockton to Darlington line. Thereafter, Peacock served his apprenticeship with Fenton, Murray, and Jackson of Leeds, who were then engaged in locomotive building for the Liverpool to Manchester Railway. Under the management of Peter Rothwell Jackson, the firm also manufactured engines, pumps, and hydraulic machinery of various types. At the age of eighteen, he became locomotive superintendent of the LeedsSelby Railway, beginning a long and distinguished career in the railway industry. Following some experience at I K Brunei's Great Western Works, Peacock took up the position of superintendent on the Manchester and Sheffield Railway, expanding and developing the new concern in the years 1841-1854. Like his mentor P R Jackson, Peacock became one of the founding members of the Institution of Mechanical Engineers during this period. His earliest contribution to the Proceedings describes his other great endeavour, the design and laying out of the Gorton locomotive workshops. Peacock's association with Gorton in Greater Manchester shaped the remainder of his career. He partnered Charles Beyer, another IMechE founder, in creating the Beyer-Peacock company in 1854, so founding one of the great locomotive-building firms. Peacock's extrovert nature found him involved with local affairs: he was in turn a banker, magistrate, and Member of Parliament. Peacock served as President of various organisations, notably the Manchester Steam Users' Association, the Royal Manchester Institution, and the Locomotive Manufacturers' Association. His belief in the engineering future of his region prompted him to serve as an original director of the Manchester Ship Canal Company - a project he did not live to see completed.
27
ON THE WOKKSHOPS FOR THE LOCOMOTIVE CARRIAGE AND WAGGON DEPARTMENTS OF THE MANCHESTER, SHEFFIELD, AND LINCOLNSHIRE RAILWAY. These works are erected at the first point from Manchester where the Railway and the land take the same level, viz.: at Gorton, about two miles from Manchester, this being considered the best position from its being near the principal terminus of the Company's Lines, and from the facility with which materials can be procured and workmen engaged ; and though it is a terminal establishment, with the advantage of being situated near enough to a First-class Mechanical Town to secure any benefit that may be had therefrom, it is sufficiently far out of it to be clear of the heavy local taxes with which such establishments in all large Towns are burdened. The site was fixed upon, and land purchased to construct Workshops for the Sheffield and Manchester Railway only; but subsequent to the amalgamation of that Company with the net-work of Lincolnshire lines, and which now form the Manchester, Sheffield, and Lincolnshire Railways, more land was purchased and the Workshops increased in size to meet the wants of the joint Companies. The total quantity of land purchased is nearly Twenty Acres, about Nine of which is occupied by the Workshops and Storeyard, and the remainder is being used for the construction of Reservoirs for supplying the works with water, and for erecting Cottages upon for the workpeople in the Company's service. The block plan, Plate 21, shows the general arrangement and relative positions of the Shops, Cottages, Reservoirs, &c., the plot of land being bounded on the south by the Railway, on the east by the Peak Forest and Macclesfield Canal (also belonging to this
29
LOCOMOTIVE WORKSHOPS.
28
Company), and on the north adjacent to the Manchester and Ashtonunder-Lyne highroad. The Reservoirs are calculated to hold a month's consumption of water, and are supplied from the adjoining Canal, the water passing through filter beds in its course from the Canal to the Reservoirs. These Reservoirs from their elevated position supply the water directly into the Tenders upon the Railway and throughout the Workshops, their position being sufficiently high to do this, and the Canal high enough to supply the Reservoirs. The Cottages shown on the plan are 140 in number, arranged in four blocks ; and between the Cottages and Reservoirs, and the Workshops, is a plot of vacant land that may be used for increasing the number of Cottages, or for any other purpose that may be hereafter required. The plan of the works is nearly that of a square, the Watchhouse or entrance being situated towards the Cottages on the east side of the works, as also is the rail entrance, and adjoining are the Offices and General Stores. The Engine-house or shed for working Engines, Plate 22, is a rotunda of 150 feet in diameter inside, and will hold seventeen Engines with their Tenders, leaving the entrance and exit lines clear. The advantage in this description of building over the ordinary polygon is in the absence of pillars for supporting the roof, there being but one in the rotunda, while in the polygon, say of twelve sides, there would be twelve, and the number of pillars would determine the number of lines and consequently the number of Engines it will hold, while in the rotunda the number of lines is with the number of Engines, influenced only by the clearance required for each other; thus, the polygon would hold eleven engines with the entrance clear, while the rotunda will hold seventeen. To the left of the entrance is a furnace for lighting up the Engines from, and the points for the two lines to the table are set so that the Engines will (on entering) go upon the right hand side of the pillar ; and thus, supposing them to enter Engine first, they must be backed into each line, which will cause the smoke box, or chimney end of the Engines, to be always nearest the table, and consequently in a right position for the tubes &c. being cleaned. The turntable in the centre is 40 feet diameter, with two lines of rails upon it, one upon each side the Centre Pillar around which it moves The centre pillar is of cast iron, the base forming the bed
30
24
LOCOMOTIVE WORKSHOPS.
for the inner rollers of the turntable to revolve upon ; the top of the pillar is sufficiently large to receive the shoes for carrying the principals of the roof, and to which they are secured by bolts, each principal radiating from the centre of the pillar, and its opposite end resting upon the outer wall of the building. A collar is cast upon the pillar about 8 feet from the top, which was intended to carry one end of a circular travelling frame; the frame being intended to revolve round the pillar, and the opposite end having a carriage running upon a circular rail beam, which was to have been supported by the pilasters built on the inside of the walls, the frame being surmounted by a travelling crane in the usual way; this however has not yet been carried out. The roof is of wrought iron, surmounted by a louvre, the top of which is glazed; the whole forming a beautifully ventilated and well-lighted building. To the left of the rotunda are the workshops, with Engine-house, boiler, &c. The Fitting and Tool Shop is 120 feet by 60 feet, and contains the whole of the Tools, with the exception of the Punching and Shearing Machines. Two rows of Fitter's Benches are erected near the far end; the Lathes, Drills, &c., are placed down each side, and have their counter shafts carried by wall plates, built into the side walls, and the Planing Machines are placed in the centre, the whole being driven from two lines of Main Shafting passing longitudinally down the shop, one over the vertical shaft from the Engine, and the other equidistant from the opposite wall, this shaft being continued over the Shop Stores and passing over the Travelling Platform into the Carriage Shed for- driving the Hoist therein. The Smith's Shop is next to the Fitting Shop, and is of the same dimensions, 120 feet by 60 feet; it contains a Fan and sixteen Smiths' Fires, eight of which are placed upon each side of the Shop, and if necessary three more can be placed at the ends. Next to this is the Boiler Shop, the same size as the Smithy, in which are erected eight smiths' fires, on the side next to the Smiths' Shop; four boiler fires are placed upon the opposite side, and the punching and shearing machines at the entrance end, these and the fan being driven by a shaft passing from the Engine transversly across the ends of the shops. Adjoining to the left and at right angles with these is the Erecting Shop, which is 150 feet by 60 feet, in this are nine transverse lines of rails, each line holding two engines, down each side and the centre are pillars supporting longitudinal beams for carrying the Travelling Cranes one
31
LOCOMOTIVE WORKSHOPS.
25
upon each side ; both these Cranes traverse the full length of the shop, and are each calculated to lift an Engine and move it to any part of the shop, if necessary. To the left, and bounding the west side of the works, are the Waggon and Carriage Shops, the Waggons being on the ground-floor and the Carriages above; the carriages are lifted up and down by a self-acting worm-hoist, worked by the shop Engine. These rooms are 320 feet by 70 feet, the Carriage shop will hold thirtyeight carriages, and the ground-floor about fifty waggons ; at the end of these are the lifting-room below, and the Trimming and Saddlery room above, each 60 feet by 70 feet. The lines in the lifting and waggon shops are served in common with the erecting shop by a travelling platform, SO feet by 12 feet, running upon three rails at right angles with the lines in the shops. Opposite the lifting-shop, and formingpartof the south boundaiy, is a paint shop, 60 feet by 40 feet, and in continuation of this is a shed for working stock not required for present use; this shed is 165 feet by 40 feet, and may be used for working engines if necessary. In a line with this and at the south east corner of the works is the Coke Shed, 100 feet by 40 feet; this is so constructed that the Coke Waggons are on one side and the Engine on the other, the Coke being filled into baskets upon a platform between the Engines and Waggons, and transferred from thence to the Engines, the waggon line side of the shed is closed, as also the ends, but the Engine line inside of the shed is open, the roof merely projecting over the Engines, where they are being coked. The arrangement of the lines into and in the works, with the four sidings running parallel with the railway outside, is shewn by the block plan, Plate 21.
Mr. PEACOCK observed, they had never experienced the slightest difficulty with the turn-table in the rotunda, or the two lines, during the two years that they had been at work. There was no danger arising from a want of balance on the turn-table when only one line was loaded with an engine, because each line of rails was carried by an independent pair, of girders, supported by rollers, and joined together in the centre. They could turn an engine upon the table in about a minute, with three men, D 32
26
LOCOMOTIVE WORKSHOPS.
and it was sometimes done by two cleaners. The object in the arrangement had been to get as many engines in as small a space as possible, and they could find no other shape so well adapted for the purpose, or into which so many engines could be got in proportion to the area, with the same convenience and room for getting about them. The total area of the floor of the building is a little over 17,000 square feet, which is equal to 1,000 square feet of shed surface per Engine accommodated, with ample room to get conveniently around each, and leaving the entrance and lines clear. Mr. DOCKRAY did not see what was gained by the oblique arrangement. At Camden-town the rotunda was 160 feet in diameter, and held 24 engines on the old arrangement, the space allowed for an engine and tender being 50 feet in the centre to turn. If the columns in that arrangement were placed sufficiently far back to get a clearance between the engines, he considered they would not lose any space. Mr. PEACOCK observed, that although the columns might be put so far back as to clear the lines, columns were always very objectionable and inconvenient at the side of the engines, and he thought the central column much preferable. Mr. COWPER suggested, that with a roof of only 150 feet span, the columns might be entirely done away with, and the cost not be increased more than £1 per square. Mr. PEACOCK observed, with respect to lifting the carriages into the upper shop, that it was effected in two minutes by the worm hoist; the time was not an object of importance, as there were only about two carriages raised per day. Mr. GIBBONS suggested, that the air-lift might be very advantageously employed for the purpose. By a. very small abstraction of power continuously going on they would procure a reservoir of power of large amount ready to be applied when requisite, and be enabled to lift the carriages in a quarter of a minute. There was one advantage in the employment of compressed air, that it was more under command than any other power, and more easily regulated. Mr. PEACOCK did not think that plan could be applied economically in the present case, as it would involve the expense 33
IMPROVED VACUUM GAUGE.
27
of a large reservoir; the object had been to get something to answer the purpose as simple and cheap as possible, and the only apparatus employed was a 1-foot worm working into a 4-feet worm-wheel. The CHAIRMAN proposed a vote of thanks to Mr. Peacock, which was passed ; and the following paper, by Mr, F. Bramwell, of London, was then read :—
34
LOCOMOTIVE
WORKS.
Plate
21
LOCOMOTIVE WOKKS Plate22. Manchester, Sheffield £ Lincolnshire Railway
Fig. 1.
Fig. 2. Plan,
Section of Engine Shed
William Menelaus (1818-1882) Although forever associated with Welsh engineering, in particular with the iron and steel industry of the Dowlais Iron Works of Merthr Tydfil, Menelaus originally hailed from Edinburgh. He worked as an engineer and millwright in Scotland and in London before undertaking a successful consulting exercise on a corn-mill belonging to Rowland Fothergill of Cowbridge. This led to a permanent appointment at the iron works of Messrs Fothergill and Scales at Abernant. By 1851, Menelaus was engineer at Dowlais, taking over management of the whole plant in 1856. The works were already famous, having produced rails for the Stockton to Darlington Railway, and by this date occupied a large complex, employing over 7,000 people. Menelaus was the first British engineer to take up the challenge of large-scale manufacture of Bessemer steel, shortly after Henry Bessemer's preliminary description of the (as yet unperfected) process. Early results were unpromising, but Menelaus had sufficient belief in the idea to ensure its eventual success. By 1870, Dowlais had six Bessemer converters each with a capacity of five tons. On other occasions, the engineer's venturesome qualities were far ahead of his contemporaries. His trial of steel girders was rebuffed in the marketplace. The reason given was that "English architects would not adopt girders...in their buildings". Menelaus turned the Dowlais Works from a loss-making operation, £52,907 on the debit side in 1856, to a hugely successful business, earning £229,836 profit in 1872. His contributions to the understanding of his profession were of like proportions. Menelaus founded the South Wales Institute of Engineers at Merthr in 1857, and was similarly instrumental in the establishment in 1869 of the Iron and Steel Institute, becoming its President in 1875-6.
37
112
DOWLAIS IRONWORKS ENGINES.
DESCRIPTION OF THE LARGE BLOWING ENGINE AND NEW ROLLING MILL AT DOWLAIS IRON WORKS. The large Blowing Engine and Rolling Mill forming the subjects of the present paper are remarkable particularly for their great size, the blowing engine being the largest of its class hitherto erected either in this country or abroad; and were designed with a view to turning out a large quantity of work with the greatest possible security from risk of failure or deficiency of the blast or of breakage of the machinery. The Blowing Engine was erected in 1851, and is shown in Figs. 1, 2, and 3, Plates 119 and 120. Fig. 1 is a side elevation of the engine, and Fig. 2 an end elevation. Fig. 3 is an enlarged vertical section of the blowing cylinder. The blowing cylinder A is 144 inches diameter with a stroke of 12 feet, making 20 double strokes per minute, the pressure of the blast being31/4Ibs. per square inch. The discharge pipe B is 5 feet diameter and about 140 yards long, thus answering the purpose of a regulator. The area of the entrance air valves is 56 square feet, and of the delivery air valves 16 square feet. The quantity of air discharged at the above pressure is about 44,000 cubic feet per minute. The steam cylinder C is 55 inches diameter and has a stroke of 13 feet, with a steam pressure of 60 Ibs. per square inch, and working up to 650 horse power. The steam is cut off when the piston has made about one-third of its stroke, by means of a common gridiron valve D near the back of the slide valve E, as shown enlarged in Figs. 4 and 5, Plate 120 ; there is also on one side of the nozzle a small separate slide valve F for moving the engine by hand when starting. The cylinder ports are 24 inches wide by 5 inches long, and the slide valve E has a stroke of 11 inches with 1/2 inch lap. The engine is non-condensing, and the steam is discharged into a cylindrical heating tank, 7 feet diameter and 36 feet long, containing the feed water from which the boilers are supplied. Under the steam cylinder C there are about 75 tons of cast iron framing G, and 10,000 cubic feet of limestone walling in large blocks, some of them weighing several tons each.
39
DOWLAIS IRONWORKS ENGINES.
113
The beam H is cast in two parts of about161/2tons each, the total weight upon the beam gudgeons being 44 tons; it is 40 feet 1 inch long from outside centre to outside centre, and is connected to the crank on the flywheel shaft I by an oaken connecting rod K strengthened from end to end by wrought iron straps. The beam is supported by a wall L across the house, 7 feet thick, built of dressed limestone blocks, to which the pedestals M are fastened down by twelve screw bolts of 3 inches diameter. The flywheel I is 22 feet diameter, and weighs about 35 tons. Eight Cornish boilers are employed to supply the steam, each 42 feet long and 7 feet diameter, made of 9/16 inch best Staffordshire plates, and having from end to end a single 4 feet tube in which is the firegrate 9 feet long. For some time this engine supplied blast to 8 furnaces of large size, varying from 16 to 18 feet across the boshes; it is now blowing, with three other engines of small dimensions, 12 furnaces, some of which make upwards of 235 tons of good forge pig per week, the weekly make of the 12 furnaces being about 2000 tons of forge pig iron. With the exception of the cylinders, made and fitted at the Penan Foundry, Truro, this engine and boilers were made at the Dowlais Iron Works, and erected according to the design and under the superintendence of Mr. Samuel Truran, the Company's engineer. The engines for driving the new Boiling Mill now in course of erection at the same works are a pair of high pressure engines coupled at right angles, shown in Figs. 6 and 7, Plates 121 and 122. Fig. 6 is a side elevation, and Fig. 7 an end elevation of the engines. Fig. 11, Plate 123, is a general plan of the rolling mill to a smaller scale. The steam cylinder C is 45 inches diameter with a stroke of 10 feet, making 24 double strokes per minute. Each cylinder has a common slide valve of brass worked by an eccentric on the main shaft. The expansion valves are of the gridiron sort, worked by a cam on the main shaft, the steam being cut off at about one-third of the stroke; an arrangement is made for throwing these valves out of gear when the engines are doing heavy work. Each engine is furnished with a small slide valve to be worked by hand for the purpose of starting and reversing. The steam is supplied by six Cornish boilers, 44 feet long and 7 feet diameter, having a 4 feet tube in each; the whole of the plates are best Staffordshire 9/16 inch thick, and the total weight is 120 tons.
40
114
DOWLAIS IRONWORKS ENGINES,
The framing G under the engines and machinery is of cast iron, and consists of four lines, each 75 feet long, 12 feet high, and 21 inches wide; the whole weighing about 850 tons. Each beam H is in two parts, the sides weighing about 17 tons, making the total weight of each beam when complete about 37 tons. The two beams are supported upon eight columns L, 24 feet long and 21/2 feet diameter, securely fastened at the bottom in deep jaws cast upon the framing. Upon the top of each group of four columns is a large and heavy entablature plate N, which carries the plummer blocks M under the main gudgeons. Each column passes through the entablature, the bosses at the junction being 24 inches deep ; these are bored and the tops of the columns turned so as to ensure a perfect fit. The plummer blocks M are secured by wrought iron keys in jaws cast on the entablature N in the usual manner. The connecting rods K are of oak with wrought iron straps. The driving wheel shaft I is of cast iron with bearings 24 inches diameter; the flywheel shaft 0 is also of cast iron with bearings 21 inches diameter. The diameter of the driving wheel is 25 feet to the pitch line, width on the face 27 inches, and pitch 7 inches. The diameter of the spur wheel or pinion on the flywheel shaft is 6 feet, and the teeth are strengthened by a flange running up to their points on each side. The flywheel 0 on the mill shaft is 21 feet diameter and weighs about 30 tons, making upwards of 100 revolutions per minute. The whole of the fastenings both of the wheels and framing are of dry oak and iron wedges, as shown enlarged in Figs. 8, 9, and 10, Plate 121. These engines will drive one rail mill capable of turning out 1000 tons of rails per week, another mill capable of making 700 tons of rails or rougheddown per week, and one bar or roughing-down mill capable of making 200 tons per week; they will thus readily turn out 2000 tons of iron per week. Two blooming mills with three-high rolls and two hammers will also be worked by the same engines. The saws and small machinery will be driven by separate engines, as will also the punching and straightening machines. The roofs cover a space of 240 feet by 210 feet, and are to be covered with corrugated black plates of No. 14 wire gauge thickness. The span is 50 feet, the roofs being supported upon lattice girders of an average length of 45 feet. The position of the columns is shown on the ground plan, Fig. 11, Plate 123; and it will be observed that the entire mill floor is free from obstruction. The flooring will be of cast iron plates 1 inch thick.
41
DOWLAIS IRONWORKS ENGINES.
115
It has long been felt that the power of rolling wrought iron of large section and great lengths has not kept pace with the requirements of engineers, who are hampered in their designs by the impossibility of obtaining iron of sufficient dimensions. For engineering works of any magnitude, bars of great length, considerable width, and moderate thickness, are frequently required. In the ordinary mode of rolling, the length and width of the bar are measured by the power of the engine and the time occupied in rolling. It is obvious that to finish a bar quickly it is necessary that it should be rolled in two directions to prevent delay; and long and heavy bars can be thus rolled only by an engine of enormous power. This object is designed to be attained by the large combined engines now described. A simple arrangement of rolls for working in two directions is shown in Figs, 12, 13, and 14, Plate 123 ; the lower pair of rolls P is driven from the flywheel shaft, and under ordinary circumstances will be worked in the usual manner, rolling the bars in one direction and lifting them over the top roll in coming back. When it is necessary to make extra sized bars the rolls RR will be put in the standards, and driven from the flywheel shaft by the pair of wheels SS, Fig. 6, Plate 121, thus giving the means of working the iron in both directions, as shown by the arrows. By this arrangement the mill is expected to be able to roll iron of such sections and lengths as have been hitherto unattainable.
Mr. E. JONES said he had had an opportunity of seeing the large blast engine at work at the Dowlais Iron Works, and was much struck with it. It was a very remarkable and interesting sight to see 40 tons of iron in the main beam moving at the high speed of 520 feet per minute at the extremities, a much greater speed than had been contemplated when the engine was first erected. The whole working of the engine was so smooth and quiet, that its great magnitude was not apparent at the first glance. Mr. McCoNNELL thought the engine was one of great interest, and the excellent drawings that were exhibited of it would form a valuable addition to the collection in the Institution; he hoped that some indicator diagrams from the engine would be also supplied, as they would be of particular value from an engine so remarkable for size and speed.
42
116
DOWLAIS IRONWORKS ENGINES.
Mr. MENELAUS said he would be happy to supply diagrams of the working of the engine ; it had now continued regularly working six years without any failure, and had proved very satisfactory. The CHAIRMAN observed thai the engine appeared not to be a condensing one, and enquired the reason for such an engine being made non-condensing. Mr. MENELAUS replied that a high pressure non-condensing engine had been adopted, because of the difficulty in getting a sufficient supply of water for condensing in that situation; it was worked with 60 Ibs. steam, expanding through about 2-3rds of the stroke. The CHAIRMAN asked whether the waste gases from the blast furnaces were used for heating the steam boilers. Mr. MENELAUS replied that they did not make use of the waste gases for that purpose, not having been able as yet to get a completely satisfactory result from their use; raw coal was used in most of their furnaces with cold blast, and was not so suitable as in other cases for taking off the waste gases from the furnace; the make of the furnaces was very large, as much as 235 tons per week being obtained from one furnace working with raw coal and cold blast. Mr. HENRY MAUDSLAY observed that an oak connecting rod was used in the engine, and enquired the reason for its adoption, as he was surprised to see that construction in an ironworks, all the rest being so massive. Mr. MENELAUS said the result of 40 years' experience had led them to prefer oak with wrought iron straps, having found it the best on the whole for the purpose. A cast iron connecting rod was liable to break, and it was of particular importance to guard against risk of breakage, as the consequences of such an accident would be very serious; and wrought iron would be very expensive when of that extreme size. They found the oak connecting rod very durable, and easy to repair, whilst it was a much less expensive construction and considerably lighter than iron. Mr. COCHRANE enquired what was the total weight of metal in the two engines described, as they appeared to be very massive in their proportions and considerably stronger than they would be by the usual calculations. Mr. MENELAUS replied that the blowing engine of 650 nominal horse power weighed about 300 tons, including the bed-plates; and the pair of rolling mill engines of 1000 nominal horse power would have about
43
DOWLAIS IRONWORKS ENGINES.
117
1000 tons of metal in them. These were probably nearly double the ordinary proportions; but it was their practice to make their engines very strong, and they generally put in three times the calculated weight of metal, as it was of the first importance to them to have no stoppages of the works from any break-down of the engines. They expected their engines when once fairly started to go on working week after week without stoppage or delay, and expense of construction was not a consideration compared with this object; if they could arrive at a machine that would never break, it would be considered perfection. The CHAIRMAN asked what was the object of having the set of four rolls that was shown in the new rolling mill. Mr. MENELAUS said that the limit as to length in making very large bars of thin section was the time required for the rolling, as they had to be completed at one heat, in consequence of the impossibility of getting such long bars into the furnace to reheat; in the ordinary rolling so much time was lost in bringing back the bar over the top of the rolls that it was found impossible to make the larger sizes that were wanted in modern work. The plan was therefore contrived of having a second pair of rolls running in the opposite direction, placed at the back of the first rolls, the lower one of the second pair being raised just enough above the upper one of the first rolls to clear the bar in coming through; and the bar was passed back through the second rolls as readily as over the top roll in the ordinary arrangement. By this plan half the time was saved, and the rolls were all as handy for adjustment as the ordinary ones; and they gained the great advantage of being enabled to manufacture bars up to 60 feet length for deck beams and keels of iron ships in one length without a weld. They had rolled already quite successfully bars 46 feet long and 10 inches wide and only1/2inch thick, and expected to go up to 60 and even 70 feet length when the new rolling mill was got to work; the only chance of rolling such extreme lengths was by having a high speed of the rolls, so as to complete the work before the bar got too cold, and this necessitated the great power of the engines described, as the full power required for rolling had to be exerted at this increased speed. Mr. COCHRANE remarked that reversing gear had been very successfully employed at the Patent Shaft Works, Wednesbury, for rolling long links for suspension bridges ; the motion of the ordinary rolls being reversed by a lever shifting an ordinary reversing clutch, the engine shaft running
44
118
DOWLAIS IRONWORKS ENGINES.
always one way, returning the bar through the rolls in the opposite direction without any delay and without requiring it to be lifted at all; this plan had been at work several years with complete success, and was a more simple arrangement than the double set of rolls now described. Mr. MENELAUS replied that the objection to reversing gear was that it limited the speed at which the rolls could be driven, and he believed that it was not found applicable to rolls running above 45 revolutions per minute, on account of the violent shock in reversing the motion at a higher speed. They were obliged to employ a much higher speed in order to roll the lengths contemplated, and were working at nearly three times that speed at the Dowlais Iron Works; the ordinary rail rolls running at 120 revolutions per minute, and the other rolls for large sections at 110 revolutions, the rolls being of the full ordinary size, 21 inches diameter. He considered the speed of 120 revolutions per minute was necessary to obtain the long bars of 1/2 inch or even3/8inch thickness that were now required to be made, and they had now doubled the speed of the old Welsh rail mills which was only 60 revolutions per minute. Mr. COCHRANE asked whether the quality of the bars was interfered with by the increase in speed, and whether the rolls running at such a high speed turned.out as good work. Mr. MENELAUS did not know of any necessary difference in the quality of the bars on account of the speed ; an inferior quality of iron was found to stand the rolling better at the high speed than at the old speed. The CHAIRMAN remarked that several specimens of wrought iron of great section and weight were shown at the Paris Exhibition, of French manufacture, which showed that an important advance had there been made over what had previously been practicable. It was a great desideratum to avoid the necessity for angle iron in the deck beams for iron ships and similar constructions, by getting the iron rolled complete with the required flanges, and also to obtain the beams in one length without a joint; and the new rolling mill that had been now described appeared to be a highly important step in accomplishing that object. He thought the paper was a very interesting and valuable one, and proposed a vote of thanks to Mr. Menelaus, which was passed.
45
Fig.l. Side Eleration.
Fig.2. End
Eleration:
Jig. 4*. Plan.
Fig. 3. Vertical Section of Blowing
cylinder.
Fig. 6. Side Eleration:
Fig.8.
Kg. 9.
Fig.10.
Fig.7. End
Eleration.
Fig.11. GeneralPlanofRolling
Mill.
Eg. 12. Front Elevation.
Fig.13. Transrerse Section.
Fig.14. Plan 0f Standard.
William George Armstrong (1810-1900) William George Armstrong, later to become Baron Armstrong of Cragside, was a yeoman's son who demonstrated his early promise by constructing miniature corn mills from discarded spinning wheel parts. Although he joined a law firm in Newcastle-upon-Tyne as his first profession, Armstrong's continuing interest in hydraulics led him to publish papers on the possible uses of water-powered machinery in the Mechanics'Magazine of the 1830s and 40s. Over the next ten years, Armstrong's interest in water gave rise to hydroelectric power generation, the provision of clean water for the population of his home city, and the invention of the velocity-activated pipe valve. His thinking turned to the use of water in distributing power, which he achieved by patenting a hydraulic crane, the first example of which worked the Tyne quayside. Such was the demand for Armstrong's machinery that he was enabled to open his first manufactory, at Elswick. The date of his preliminary business partnership, January 1847, was a propitious one, coinciding as it did with the creation of the Institution of Mechanical Engineers, where Armstrong would later become President. His new position as engineer allowed his permanent retirement from the legal profession. Armstrong continued to invent. He improved upon the efficiency of hydraulic machines, freeing them from dependency on conventional reservoirs by the invention of the high-pressure accumulator. With the advent of the Crimean War, however, Armstrong turned his attention to munitions and armaments. He virtually reinvented the artillery piece, championing the use of steel-jacketed breech-loading guns with rifled barrels. His Elswick Ordnance Company produced weapons of all types. A related enterprise commenced the building of ships. Later mergers would create the well-known firms of Armstrong, Mitchell & Co. (1882), for shipbuilding and Armstrong, Whitworth & Co. (1897), for weapons manufacture. Armstrong's later years were occupied with electrical researches at his home, Cragside, and by distinguished public service. A contemporary obituary noted, without exaggeration, that "by his death Newcastle lost her greatest citizen".
51
126
ON WATEK PBESSURE MACHINEKY.
The subject of Water Pressure Machinery first attracted the writer's attention about twenty-three years ago, on occasion of his noticing a small stream of water which flowed from a great elevation down a steep declivity and turned a single overshot wheel near the end of its course. Observing that the portion of the fall which was thus utilised by the wheel was not more than a twentieth part of the whole descent, he was forcibly struck with the inadequacy of the wheel as a means of realising the power of such a fall ; and conceiving it practicable to render the entire head available by bringing down the water in a pipe, and causing it to act by pressure upon a suitable machine at the bottom, he applied himself to devising an engine to be worked by such a pressure. Other inventors, guided by the same idea, had been previously led to apply water pressure in various ways to driving machinery, although the employment of that power had never been extensively adopted; but with these applications the writer was at the time wholly unacquainted. After meeting with many difficulties and discouragements, the machine was produced, which after many years of seclusion in a lumber room has now been brought out for inspection upon this occasion. It is, as will be perceived, a species of rotary engine, admitting of a continuous and uniform flow of water through it, and exempt from all contracted passages. This machine was tried first in Newcastle, with the pressure from the street pipes equivalent to a column of about 200 feet; then in Gateshead with a still greater pressure; and in both cases it yielded a very high effect in relation to the theoretical power of the moving column. Up to this time the writer's object had been merely to provide a machine for turning to profitable account the power which great altitude gives to mountain streams; believing then, as now, that when roads and railways have rendered accessible the valleys where such
53
WATER PRESSURE MACHINERY.
127
streams abound, the water which descends from the heights will ultimately prove an efficient source of motive power. But having then had practical experience of the power residing in street water pipes, he conceived the idea of applying such power to the cranes at that time so slowly and expensively worked by hand upon the quay of this town. Accordingly after duly considering the means of effecting this purpose, a working model of a hydraulic crane was constructed, and exhibited at a meeting of the Literary and Philosophical Society of Newcastle, where it was connected with the town water pipes, and went through the several operations of lifting, lowering, and slewing in a very satisfactory manner. The next step was to carry this scheme into actual practice; and in the year 1846 the first hydraulic crane was erected at the upper end of the Newcastle Quay, where it has ever since continued to do good service in discharging ships. The crane model exhibited to the present meeting is nearly identical with the original model, and does not differ materially from the first actual crane erected in this town. The writer was soon enabled to introduce the hydraulic crane at Liverpool, and shortly afterwards at the New Dock at Grimsby, where, at the instance of his friend, the late Mr. Rendel, the engineer who constructed that dock, he also applied the same kind of machinery for opening and closing the lock gates and sluices. An extensive system of water pressure machinery was accordingly carried out at that dock ; and .the result afforded the first practical demonstration that the pressure of a column of water could be advantageously applied as a substitute for manual labour, not merely for the cranage of goods, but also for various mechanical operations in connexion with the entrances to docks. At all these places the effective column of water was about 200 feet head. At Newcastle and Liverpool the supply was derived from the pipes communicating with the town reservoirs; but at Grimsby a tower was built for supporting a tank, into which water was pumped by a steam engine. In the former cases the irregularity of pressure, consequent upon the variable draught from the pipes for the ordinary purposes of consumption, proved a serious disadvantage ; but this objection was not experienced at Grimsby, where the tank upon the tower furnished a separate source of power, undisturbed by
54
128
WATER PRESSURE MACHINERY.
any interferences. But the erection of a tower was a formidable undertaking, and so long as it remained a necessity, a great extension of the principle could not be anticipated. The writer therefore resorted to another form of artificial head, which possessed the advantage of being applicable at a moderate cost in all situations, and of lessening the size of the pipes and cylinders by affording a pressure of greatly increased intensity. The apparatus by which this is effected is named the " accumulator," from the circumstance of its accumulating the power exerted by the engine in charging it. The accumulator is in fact a reservoir giving pressure by load instead of by elevation; and its use, like that of every provision of this kind, is to equalise the duty of the engine in cases where the quantity of power to be supplied is subject to great and sudden fluctuations. The construction of the accumulator is shown in the vertical section, Fig. 1, Plate 30. It consists of a large cast iron cylinder A fitted with a plunger B, from which a loaded weight case C is suspended to give pressure to the water injected by the engine. The load upon the plunger B is usually such as to produce a pressure in the cylinder equal to a column of 1500 feet head; and the cylinder is made sufficiently capacious to contain the largest quantity of water which can be drawn from it at once by the simultaneous action of all the hydraulic machines connected with it. Whenever the engine pumps more water into the accumulator than passes to the hydraulic machines, the plunger rises and makes room in the cylinder for the surplus; but when, on the other hand, the supply from the engine is less for the moment than the quantity used, the plunger with its load descends and makes up the deficiency out of store. The accumulator serves also as a regulator to the engine; for when the plunger rises to a certain height, it begins to close the throttle valve in the steam pipe so as gradually to reduce the speed of the engine, until the descent of the plunger again calls for an increased production of power. With regard to the pumping engine used for charging the accumulator, the most approved form is that of two high pressure cylinders fixed horizontally, with double-acting pumps directly connected with the piston rods. At first a simple plunger pump at each
55
WATER PRESSURE MACHINERY.
129
end of the cylinder was used; then, with a view to",greater compactness, the pump behind the cylinder was discontinued, and the other made a double-acting one upon the combined bucket and plunger system. Finally a modification of this form of pump was adopted, by dispensing with the clack in the bucket and substituting an external delivery valve D, as shown in Fig. 2, Plate 30. In this arrangement the out-stroke of the pump causes the water contained in the annular space surrounding the plunger E to be forced into the accumulator, while a further supply of water enters behind the piston F through the suction valve G; in the in-stroke the water behind the piston is discharged through the delivery valve D, and half of it passes round into the annular space on the other side of the piston, while the remaining half is forced into the accumulator, the area of the plunger E being exactly half that of the piston F. Each stroke of the pump thus delivers the same quantity of water into the accumulator. This neat modification of the bucket and plunger principle, by which equally easy access is given both to the suction and the delivery valves, was the suggestion of Mr. Henry Thompson, the writer's late intelligent foreman. The introduction of the accumulator in the year 1851 removed all obstacles to the extension of water pressure machinery, which has since been applied in nearly all the principal docks, and in many of the government establishments in this country. Nearly 1200 hydraulic cranes, hoists, and other machines of that description have been applied; and 125 steam engines, collectively of more than 3000 horse power, are now daily at work to supply the pressure for working them. The system has also been adopted in many of the principal railway stations, not only for cranage, but also for working turntables, traversing machines, wagon lifts, hauling machines, &c. It is also extensively used for raising and tipping wagons in the shipment of coal, for opening and closing swing bridges, and for many other purposes. New forms of application are continually being developed, and no doubt can be entertained of its capability of further extension. The form of mechanism which prevails to the greatest extent in these various applications of water pressure consists of a hydraulic press
56
130
WATER PRESSURE MACHINERY.
with a set of sheaves used in the inverted order of blocks and pulleys, the object being to obtain an extended motion in the chain from a comparatively short stroke of piston. The general arrangement of the machinery for working a hydraulic crane is shown in Figs. 4 and 5, Plate 31; Fig. 4 being an elevation and Fig. 5 a plan. The pressure cylinder A for lifting the load is fixed horizontally below the surface of the ground in a chamber at the foot of the crane, and is fitted with the ram B carrying the pulleys C at its outer extremity. The lifting chain is made fast at one end to the cylinder A, and passes alternately round the moveable pulleys C and the fixed pulleys D at the inner end of the cylinder A; and is then led round the guide pulley E up the crane post F and along the jib to the load. The motion of the lifting chain is controlled by means of the handle G, acting upon the inlet and outlet valves which are kept closed by the weights H and I: by opening the inlet valve H the water is let into the cylinder A from the pressure pipe J, and raises the load; and by opening the outlet valve I the water escapes from the cylinder into the exhaust pipe K, allowing the load to descend. The travel of the ram B in the outward stroke is prevented from exceeding the proper limit by the pulley block C coming in contact with a stop connected with the handle G, which closes the inlet valve H and prevents the load from being raised too high. The return stroke of the ram is effected by the load suspended from the chain; and in the absence of any load a small supplementary ram L is employed to force the main ram B back, the slack chain being made to run out by the weight M. To meet variation of load it was formerly the practice to combine three of the pressure cylinders so as to act either separately or collectively upon the lifting chain; but the writer has more recently introduced a method by which a variation of power is obtained with a single bored cylinder fitted with a combined piston and ram. Fig. 7, Plate 32, is a longitudinal section of the cylinder and valves of a double power hydraulic crane; Fig. 8 is a section of the piston enlarged; and Fig. 9 shows the valves in detail. A is the cylinder fitted with the piston E and ram B; the water from the accumulator enters the valve chest F through the pressure pipe J and the inlet valve H. For the lower power the water is admitted
57
WATER PRESSURE MACHINERY.
131
to both sides of the piston E by opening the valve L, as shown in the drawing, in which case the power exerted and the water expended are each proportionato to the area of the ram B. For the higher power the valve L is closed and the valve M opened, so that the front side of the piston E is thrown open to the exhaust K, and the result both as regards power and expenditure is then proportionate to the full area of the cylinder A. It is seldom necessary to have more than a double power ; but where a lower or third power is required a smaller ram may be inserted within the other, but in this case it is necessary to make fast the larger ram while the smaller one is at work. For lowering the load the valves H and M are closed and the outlet valve I opened, allowing the water to escape from the cylinder A into the exhaust pipe K; at the same time the valve L is also opened to allow the water to follow up the piston in the inward stroke. In hydraulic cranes the power is applied not only for lifting the load, but also for swinging the jib, which latter object is effected by means of a rack or chain acting on the base of the moveable part of the crane, and connected either with a cylinder and piston, or with two single-acting cylinders applied to produce the same effect by alternate action. Figs. 4 and 5, Plate 31, show the arrangement of the two cylinders N and 0 for turning the crane, fitted with rams, acting by a chain passing round the base of the crane post F. The motion is controlled by means of a slide valve worked by a handle situated beside the handle G, so that while the water is admitted to one cylinder the other is open to the exhaust. The travel of the rams is limited by means of a tappet rod connected with the handle of the slide valve, whereby the crane is prevented from being turned round too far. The absence of any sensible elasticity in water renders the motions resulting from its pressure capable of the most perfect control by means of the valves which regulate the inlet and outlet passages; but this very property which gives so much certainty of action tends to cause shocks and strains to the machinery by suddenly resisting the momentum acquired by the moving parts. Taking for example the case of a hydraulic crane swinging round with a load suspended from the jib, the motion being produced by the water entering into one cylinder and
58
132
WATER PRESSURE MACHINERY.
escaping from the other, it is obvious that if the water passages be suddenly closed, the ram of the latter, impelled forwards by the momentum of the loaded jib but met by an unyielding body of water deprived of outlet, would be brought to rest so abruptly as to cause in all probability a fracture of the machine. So also in lowering a heavy weight, if the escape passage be too suddenly closed, a similar risk of injury would arise from the sudden stoppage of the weight, if a remedy were not provided. But these liabilities are effectually removed, in the case of a single-acting cylinder, by employing a relief valve in connexion with the water passages, consisting of a small clack valve N, Fig. 9, opening upwards against the effective pressure, so as to permit the pent up water in the cylinder to be forced back into the pressure pipe whenever it becomes subject to a compressive force exceeding the pressure given by the accumulator. In the case of a double-acting cylinder fitted with a piston and slide valve, or where two single-acting cylinders with rams working alternately are controlled by a slide valve, as in the instance of the cylinders N and 0, Fig. 5, for turning the crane, relief valves are employed in connexion with the slide valve, consisting of four small leather flap valves arranged as shown in Fig. 6, Plate 31. The passages PP communicate with the pressure pipe J,and he passages EE with the exhaust K. When the slide valve is moved in the direction of the arrow, the pressure is first cut off from the port R by the lap of the valve, the port S being still open to the exhaust K; at the same instant the flap valve T opens upwards and allows a small quantity of water to pass from the exhaust K into the port B to follow up the ram until brought to rest. When the slide valve arrives at the centre position, as shown in the drawing, the port S is closed to the exhaust; and the pressure in the port S being increased by the further motion of the ram before it is completely stopped, the second flap valve U is raised and a small quantity of water forced back into the passage P communicating with the pressure pipe J. When the slide valve is moved in the opposite direction, the two remaining relief valves are called into action in the same manner. By these means all jerks and concussions are avoided, and perfect control over the machine is combined with great softness of action.
59
WATER PRESSURE MACHINERY.
133
The method which the writer has most generally adopted for opening and closing lock gates by means of hydraulic pressure consists in applying to each gate a pair of cylinders with rams and multiplying sheaves similar to those constituting the hoisting apparatus in hydraulic cranes. One of these cylinders opens the gate and the other closes it, the whole of the machinery being placed in chambers beneath the ground, as shown in Figs. 10 and 11, Plate 33. The water is admitted from the pressure pipe J to the cylinder A through the inlet valve H by means of the handle G; the same motion of the handle also opens the outlet valve of the other cylinder B. The opposite motion of the handle G opens the outlet valve I, allowing the water to escape from the cylinder A into the exhaust pipe K, and at the same time admits the pressure to the cylinder B. A stop M connected with the handle G prevents the ram from travelling too far in the out-stroke, by closing the inlet valve ; and the return stroke of the ram is effected by means of the weight L. This arrangement is in use at the Sunderland Docks, the London Docks, the Victoria Docks, and the West India Docks, and is now being applied to the new 100 feet entrance to the Liverpool Docks. Another method has also been adopted for this purpose in some instances, which has been found to answer extremely well; Fig. 12, Plate 34, is a general plan of a dock entrance showing the arrangement of the lock gate machinery. Instead of connecting hauling cylinders with each gate, a line of shafting A, driven by a small water pressure engine B, is laid beneath the surface of the ground parallel with the coping on each side of the entrance, and by means of clutches is thrown into or out of gear with each gate crab. A wire from the engine extends the whole length of the shafting, so that the motion of the engine can be governed from the point where the work is being done. This method is already in use at several of the ports in South Wales, and is in course of being applied at the Jarrow Docks and the new dock at Silloth. The rapidity with which dock gates can be opened and closed by these appliances is limited only by considerations of safety to the gates, and the operation is in practice usually performed in about two minutes. The water pressure engines most recently constructed for driving the shafting consist of a combination of three oscillating cylinders u
60
134
WATER PRESSURE MACHINERY.
working cranks inclined at 180° to one another, with slide valves simply arranged, as shown in Figs. 13 and 14, Plate 35 ; and a small engine of this description is exhibited to the meeting. The cylinders A are fitted with plungers B instead of pistons, and are therefore only single-acting. The slide valves V are worked by the oscillation of the cylinders, communicated through the levers L. When the back end of the cylinder is depressed, the slide valve is lowered and allows the water to enter from the pressure pipe P through the pipe C to the cylinder, where it acts upon the plunger in the out-stroke. In the return stroke, the back end of the cylinder being raised, the cylinder port C is closed to the pressure pipe P and open to the exhaust E. A small relief valve is provided in connection with the cylinder pipe C, opening against the pressure, which prevents any shock when the communication with the exhaust is closed at the end of the return stroke. These engines have occasionally been made with pistons, so as to be double-acting; but for the heavy pressures employed where accumulators are used the single-acting arrangement with plungers is preferred. In nearly all cases in which hydraulic pressure has been applied for the moving of dock gates, it is also used for opening and closing the levelling shuttles, and in many cases also for working the capstans. The former purpose is effected by the direct application of a cylinder and piston fixed above the shuttle ; and the latter is accomplished by throwing the capstan C, Fig. 12, Plate 34, into gear with the shafting A, or by applying to it a separate engine similar to that which has been described. A good example of the application of hydraulic pressure to the opening and closing of scouring shuttles may be seen at Sunderland Docks, where by means of this power the enormous area of nearly 500 feet is opened in a few seconds and closed with equal rapidity. At the same place an example may also be seen of a heavy drawbridge worked by water pressure. The bridge is supported upon wheels, and is first lifted from its bearings to such a level as to enable the wheels to roll back upon a suitable railway, both operations being performed with great steadiness by the action of the water in little more than a minute.
61
WATER PRESSURE MACHINERY.
135
In working swing bridges by means of water pressure, a central press is applied to lift the entire bridge clear of its supports, and it is then turned by an application similar to that used for slewing a crane. The most remarkable specimen of a bridge of this description is one erected by the writer at Wisbech under the direction of the late Mr. Rendel. In this case an opening of 85 feet is spanned by a double roadway bridge in one leaf weighing about 450 tons. At present it is but little used as a moveable bridge; but notwithstanding its great length and weight it can be lifted and turned in less that two minutes. The power is derived from an accumulator charged by hand labour, and it is expected that one man by continued working will be able to store up sufficient power for opening and closing the bridge as often as necessary. This system of using an accumulator in connection with a hand force pump has also been successfully applied to a drawbridge erected by the writer near Carmarthen on the main line of the South Wales Railway ; and it might be advantageously adopted for many other purposes requiring a concentrated exertion of power with intervening periods of inaction. Amongst the numerous applications that have been made of water pressure for the purpose of rapidly lifting and lowering heavy loads, there is one which calls for special remark on account of its growing importance: namely, its application in connection with an accumulator for working vertical hoists at the landing stations of steam ferries, in cases where a railway traffic is required to be passed over a river or estuary not easily crossed by a bridge. The traffic of the Aix-laChapelle, Dusseldorf, and Rhurort Railway is by this means shipped and unshipped at the ferry across the Rhine ; and such is the rapidity and facility of the operation that a train of 12 coal wagons, weighing collectively 133 tons, can be transferred from the deck of the steamer to the railway, a height of about 20 feet, in 12 minutes. Each hoist lifts two wagons at a time, and raises its load in 10 or 12 seconds. These hoists are so arranged as always to accommodate themselves to the level of the boat, and always to stop at the exact level of the railway. It is not necessary to say more upon that branch of the subject which embraces the two important principles of accumulation and
62
136
WATER PRESSURE MACHINERY.
transmission of power, by means of which a steam engine can be economically applied to give safe and rapid motion to a multiplicity of machines intermittent in their action and distant from each other. But it remains to notice the applications made by the writer of the pressure derived from natural falls. When the moving power consists of a natural column of water, the pressure rarely exceeds 250 or 300 feet; and in such cases he has employed to produce rotary motion, in preference to the original scheme of a rotary engine, a pair of cylinders and pistons, with slide valves resembling in some degree those of a high pressure engine, but having relief valves to prevent shock at the return of the stroke, as shown in Fig. 6, Plate 31, already described. Where the engine is single-acting, with plungers instead of pistons, as in the water pressure engine already described, the relief valves are greatly simplified, and in fact are reduced to a single clack in connexion with each cylinder, opening against the pressure, which is the same as the relief valve N, Fig. 9, in the valve chest of the hydraulic crane. The water pressure engines erected by the writer at Mr. Beaumont's lead mines at Allenheads in Northumberland present examples of such engines applied to natural falls. They were there introduced under the advice of Mr. Sopwith, and are now used for the various purposes of crushing ore, raising materials from the mines, pumping water, giving motion to machinery for washing and separating ore, and driving a saw mill and the machinery of a workshop. In all these cases nature, assisted by art, has provided the power. Small streams of water, which flowed down the steep slopes of the adjoining hills, have been collected into reservoirs at elevations of about 200 feet, and pipes have been laid from these to the engines. Another application of hydraulic machinery at the same mines is new being made in situations where falls of sufficient altitude for working such engines cannot be obtained, which from its novelty deserves special notice. For the purpose of draining an extensive mining district and searching for new veins, a drift or level nearly six miles in length is now being executed. This drift runs beneath the valley of the Allen nearly in the line of that river, and upon its course three mining establishments are being formed, At each of these
63
WATER PRESSURE MACHINERY.
137
power is required for the various purposes above mentioned, and it was desired to obtain this power without resorting to steam engines. The river Allen was the only resource, but its descent was not sufficiently rapid to permit of its being advantageously applied to water pressure engines. On the other hand it abounded with falls suitable for overshot wheels, but these could not be applied to the purposes required without provision for conveying the power to many separate places. Under these circumstances it was determined to employ the stream through the medium of overshot wheels in forcing water into accumulators, and thus generating a power capable of being transmitted by pipes to the numerous points where its agency was required. In this arrangement intensity of pressure takes the place of magnitude of volume, and the power derived from the stream assumes a form susceptible of unlimited distribution and division, and capable of being utilised by small and compact machines. A somewhat similar plan is also adopted at Portland Harbour, in connexion with the coaling establishment there forming for the use of the navy. The object in that case is to provide power for working hydraulic cranes and hauling machines, and more particularly for giving motion to machinery arranged by Mr. Coode, the present engineer of the work, for putting coal into war steamers. A reservoir on the adjoining height affords an available head of upwards of 300 feet; but in order to diminish the size of the pipes, cylinders, and valves connected with the hydraulic machinery, and also with a view of obtaining greater rapidity of action, a hydraulic pumping engine and accumulator are interposed, for the purpose of intensifying the pressure and diminishing the volume of water acting as the medium of transmission. In concluding this survey of the system of water pressure machinery which has grown to such large proportions, chiefly during the last seven years, the writer feels that the present occasion has afforded the fittest opportunity he could have taken of communicating the particulars contained in this paper; and he trusts that the details of the progress of this system may not have proved uninteresting.
64
138
WATER PRESSURE MACHINERY.
Mr. W. G. ARMSTRONG exhibited a working model of a hydrauliccrane, and a specimen of the most recently constructed water pressure engines of 8 horse power, together with the original model engine that was first contrived for the purpose. He observed that the application of water pressure to produce rotary motion in an engine was not successful until the relief valves were designed; the great difficulty experienced being the stubbornness of the water and its want of elasticity. The relief valves were almost equally important in hydraulic cranes and other machines of that class: if in lowering a weight by the crane, the outlet valve for the escape of the water were suddenly closed, the piston would be still driven onwards by the momentum of the weight in motion; and as the water was prevented from escaping in front of the piston by the valve being shut, something would inevitably give way or burst to relieve the sudden pressure, on account of the water jammed up in the end of the cylinder being incompressible. This was however entirely obviated by the adoption of the relief valves, and the effect of the momentum of the moving weight acting upon the piston was simply to force open the relief valve at the instant of the pressure in the cylinder becoming any greater than that in the pressure main, allowing a little of the water to be squeezed back into the main through the relief valve. In consequence a heavy weight could be lowered rapidly, and the outlet valve be then suddenly closed; but the weight still proceeded a little further, and was stopped softly, without any shock or jerk, the motion being gradually retarded by the resistance of the uniform pressure of the water column acting upon the front of the piston through the opening of the relief valve into the pressure main ; this caused the non-elastic water to act as if elastic, and with the advantage that the pressure could never exceed that of the original water column. In slewing the crane round in either direction the same cushioning action was obtained; the crane could be swung round quickly and the valve suddenly closed shortly before reaching the required spot, when the whole moving weight was safely brought to rest without any shock, by the effect of the resisting pressure steadily opposing its motion. The action of the relief valves gave the water in fact a sort of fictitious elasticity, which was just what was wanted in stopping the motion of
65
WATER PRESSURE MACHINERY.
139
heavy bodies; and there was no waste attending this action, as the water was simply forced back into the store of the pressure main. In the case of slewing the crane round, the moving weight dragged the piston forwards a little after the water was shut off, leaving a vacancy behind the piston which was filled by the entrance of a little water from the escape pipe through the second relief valve, so as to allow the weight to come to rest gradually and without any recoil. Mr. T. SOPWITH considered that very important advantages were gained by this application of water pressure to drive machinery, as it admitted of the power being collected in reservoirs where it could be obtained without cost, and then conveyed to any distance where it might be wanted. The first of these engines had been applied under his own advice for drainage of water, and for raising, crushing, and washing the ore, at lead mines in a hilly district at Allenheads, Northumberland, belonging to Mr. Beaumont, where steam power would have been impracticable from the great cost of conveying coals to the works. Four of these water pressure engines had now been working in that neighbourhood for six years with complete success. He could bear testimony to the admirable working and the efficiency of these engines; and the results were so satisfactory that he was having three others erected at the newr works now in progress in the same district. Mr. W. FAIRBAIRN considered the country generally was greatly indebted to Mr. Armstrong for having worked out so completely this very useful and efficient engine, which would prove of great advantage in a number of cases where water power was supplied without cost by mountain streams, but had been hitherto lost from the want of suitable means for making the power available at places where it could be usefully applied for driving machinery. The system of relief valves that had been introduced was a very ingenious and beautiful plan for preventing the shock of the water at the stoppage of the piston, and removing the serious defect of non-elasticity in the water. He remembered having, about 20 years since, constructed an engine for forcing water under heavy pressure, and had experienced much difficulty from that cause; and was obliged to admit a little air under the piston in order to obtain a certain extent of elasticity, or the
66
140
WATER PRESSURE MACHINERY.
engine would otherwise have knocked itself to pieces by the severe shock produced at each stroke. These water pressure engines were certainly of great value for situations where coals could not be obtained for steam power, inasmuch as they were calculated to work economically; he would however like to ask their comparative value in cases where steam was available, and under what range of circumstances water could be applied direct as the driving power. He remembered in one of the early applications of Newcomen's steam engine, at Hebburn Colliery in that neighbourhood, the engine was employed to pump water on to a water wheel for driving the winding drum, before any attempt was made to apply the steam power direct to winding. The plan of a hydraulic hoist for a ferry was a valuable application for crossing railway trains over a river that could not be spanned by a bridge, from its great safety and certainty of action; and for working cranes the water pressure machinery was highly advantageous on account of the complete control that it afforded, and its soft action which greatly facilitated the lifting of heavy loads. Mr. J. ANDERSON had several of the water pressure cranes in constant employment at Woolwich Arsenal, and great success and advantage had attended their working. He noticed one point that had not been referred to in the paper, the objection likely to be felt at first of liability to stoppage or accident of the machinery from the water freezing in winter time; but he could state that during two winters' work no difficulty had been experienced from this cause at Woolwich, and he had found that a single jet of gas kept burning under each crane in the frosty weather was sufficient to prevent any risk of its occurrence. Another point to be noticed was the construction of the joints of the pipes, as the success of such an apparatus mainly depended upon the perfection of the joints for standing under the heavy pressure to which they were exposed; but the very simple and perfect make of joint had proved completely successful, and they had no trouble from leaky joints. There was also an important point of advantage in the great economy of working that was obtained by the use of water power cranes instead of hand labour; and a great saving was effected in
67
WATER PRESSURE MACHINERY.
141
the cost of the work, as well as an important advantage in the expedition with which it was done. There had been £30,000 expended at Woolwich Arsenal for fitting up 10 hydraulic cranes with their pumping engines and boilers, during the Crimean war, for the purpose of loading vessels direct from the quay side by powerful self-acting cranes; instead of the previous plan of loading most of the vessels by means of barges, which involved two transfers of all the load and incurred very heavy expense and serious delay. The saving effected in the demurrage charge per day for the vessels whilst loading was found alone sufficient to clear off the whole of this outlay upon the machinery in a short time. Mr. T. SOPWITH observed in reference to the comparative economy of water power and steam, that it would depend entirely upon the local circumstances of the situation as to the cost of coals, and the extent of water supply. Wherever the carriage of coal became expensive, and water pressure could be obtained even at a considerable distance, there would be a great economy in employing water power, as the current expenses of working would be only the interest of the outlay in pipes for bringing the water to the place required. The water engines at Allenheads, already referred to, were situated at a height of 1300 feet above the sea, where a supply of coal could be obtained only with great difficulty and at a heavy cost; but there was an abundant and constant supply of water from the mountains, from a great height above. In such a case the relative economy of water power was of course very great, and it was in fact the only power practically attainable in some of the situations where hydraulic engines were employed in the Allendale mines. Mr. T. E. HARRISON had used the water pressure cranes extensively for several years, and could speak very highly as to their value and efficiency ; at the Newcastle station this power had been constantly used for seven years in lifting all the coke for charging the locomotive tenders, the chaldron wagons being each raised by a hydraulic lift to an upper platform for discharging by shoots into the baskets on the coke stage so as to save all hand labour. The same power was also used for working the large engine turntable and the cranes in the goods warehouse. In the case of these cranes the pressure of water from v
68
142
WATER PRESSURE MACHINERY.
the town waterworks reservoir was the only pressure required, and the water used was afterwards supplied to the locomotive engines, having spent its pressure in working the cranes and been then discharged into the engine water tank; the power for working the cranes was thus obtained without additional cost, excepting a nominal annual payment to the Water Works Company for the use of the water in transit. This water power was also more economical than any other for such cases as the extensive goods warehouses now constructing by the North Eastern Railway at Hull, with water pressure hoists and cranes; and they had in consequence come to the conclusion of doing away with all the cranes worked by steam power, and employing the water power throughout. Besides the greater economy in working, the water pressure machinery had also important advantages in convenience of application over a large extent of premises, and simplicity in construction and keeping in order. In the construction of this machinery there was not only great novelty in the details, but great mechanical skill was shown in perfecting the several portions so as to make the whole thoroughly satisfactory in working and durability ; it certainly formed one of the greatest steps in the application of water as a moving power for machinery, and they could not too highly estimate the ingenuity displayed in working it out so completely, and the great value of this contribution to engineering science. Mr. W. G. ARMSTRONG observed that in the application of the water pressure machinery where an artificial head of water had to be obtained, as in the case of working dock cranes, the real source of the power was the steam engine employed in pumping water into the accumulator, and the water acted simply as a convenient means of storing up the power and applying it whenever wanted at the distant points where the work had to be done. In the early application of a steam engine to pump water for driving a water wheel, it would of course have been more economical to drive the machinery direct by the steam power, avoiding the loss of power attending the intervening water wheel; but that was not the present question, which in the majority of cases was simply as to the mode of transmitting power where the direct application of steam was not available, the power
69
WATER PRESSURE MACHINERY.
143
having to be applied at numerous points, many of them a long way removed from the source of the power, and in different directions. At the Victoria Docks, in London, the area over which the power was extended was so great as to require four miles' length of mains to convey the water to the several cranes and hoists and the lock gates; and any system of shafting for the purpose was of course quite out of the question long before that extent of length was reached. Then it was not practicable to have steam engines in the warehouses, nor to extend steam pipes over the premises : so that there was no other plan than water pressure available for working the whole by power, excepting the use of compressed or exhausted air ; but both these latter involved serious practical objections, such as the extent of power lost in the compression of an elastic medium by the liberation of heat and the increased defect of pumps, and the circumstance that the leakages could not be detected by sight as in the case of water or steam. With the water pressure system there was of course some loss of power from the friction of the water in the mains, &c., but in transmitting power to a distance some sacrifice was unavoidable ; and this plan appeared to involve the least proportion of loss. But it was not so much a question of comparative economy of power as of safety and convenience; and in these respects no other means of transmitting power was to bo compared with water pressure. In the application to natural heads of water, it was an important consideration that these were generally met with in situations inaccessible for the erection and working of machinery, and where the power was not wanted; but by obtaining the power there free of cost, they could well afford to convey it to a distance where it could be employed for work, at the expense simply of the interest on the outlay for pipes and machinery. And as the means of communication by railways extended, no doubt this application of water power would become greatly extended, by enabling the work to be brought within reach of the source of power. In reference to the construction of the joints in the hydraulic machinery, that point had been the subject of much attention, as the pressures employed kept increasing progressively; and the result was that he found no plan stood so well as a small ring of gutta percha
70
144
WATER PRESSURE MACHINERY.
compressed into the joint, which was turned with a projection on one side fitting accurately into a corresponding recess on the other side of the joint, like a spigot and faucet, as shown in Fig. 3, Plate 30. The gutta percha ring was put into the bottom of the recess, which was in a dovetail form expanding outwards to confine the gutta percha in its place, and the ring was then compressed by screwing up the joint, which compelled the gutta percha to fill up the recess completely ; and it was found that the water was unable to pass the joint at the greatest pressure that was employed in working. The gutta percha, so long as it was protected from the air and exposed only on the edge to the water, appeared to be imperishable; and this was found to be the best joint for the hydraulic machinery, and gave no trouble under any pressure that they worked to, amounting now to as much as 700 Ibs. per square inch; the joints also admitted of being readily opened and re-made if desired. As to the liability of accident from freezing of the water in the engines or mains, he had found that when they were buried in the ground the hardest winters had never affected them; and consequently no precaution was required in the ordinary cases, as the whole of the portion of the apparatus containing water was generally sunk below the surface of the ground. In the cases where any portion was raised above the ground, the simple precaution of a gas burner as had been described was quite sufficient to prevent any risk of freezing. A still more simple and equally effective method was to employ a cock for emptying the cylinder of water after each time of using in frosty weather; so that there was no water exposed to freezing, the pipes underground being sufficiently protected by their position. Mr. W. FAIRBAIRN observed that they had now in Manchester a pressure of about 200 feet head of water in the street mains, and the introduction of water power for driving certain descriptions of machinery was well worthy of consideration, to avoid the inconvenience and risk of accident attending the use of steam power in many situations, such for instance as hoists in warehouses, even where from the low cost of coals the water power might not be less expensive than steam power. From the improvements already effected in the application of water power he thought a further extension of the system might confidently be anticipated.
71
WATER PRESSURE MACHINERY.
145
The CHAIRMAN observed they were greatly indebted to Mr. Armstrong for the very valuable and interesting paper he had given them, and the excellent models and specimens he had exhibited to the meeting; and he proposed a vote of thanks to Mr. Armstrong for his paper, which was passed.
72
WATER
PRESSURE MACHINERY.
Fig.1
Plate30.
Vertical' Section of Accumulater.
73
WATER
PRESSURE
Hydraulic Crane. General Arrangement of Machinary.. Fig.4. Elevation.
74
MACHINERY.
Plate31.
Fig.8. Section of Piston,
WATER
enlarged.
PRESSURE
Fig 7. Double .power Hydraulic Longitudinal of Cylinder
section
and
Valves.
MACHINERY.
fig.9. Detail.of Valves enlarged.
Fig.10. Eleration of
Fig 11. Plan,.
Prassurecylindersfor
cpening and closing Lock Gates.
WATER
PRESSURE
MACHINERY.
Plate.34.
Fig.12. Arrangement
of
Lock
General
Gate
Machiney.
Plan.
77
WATER
PRESSURE
Fig. 15. Vertical Section "through, Cylinder and Valve Chest.
Fig.14. Plan,.
78
MACHINERY,
plate35
Charles William Siemens (1823-1883) Carl Wilhelm Siemens was born near Hanover into a family which would become famous for its scientific attainments. One of several brothers, William was destined to become the engineer of the group, commencing his technical training at the age of fifteen at Magdeburg, and then Gottingen University. To further his knowledge of electroplating, William travelled to England in 1843, where he settled and prospered. After selling an improved electroplating process to Elkingtons of Birmingham, Siemens entered a phase of productive invention. The Society of Arts awarded a prize for his steam engine governor in 1850. The inventor's struggles to gain acceptance for his regenerative steam engine and condenser (1847) met with little success. However, Siemens' idea for a water-meter in 1851 published in Proceedings', secured his financial independence. Experiments in furnace design, made in association with his brother Frederick, resulted in the use of regenerative heat exchange and gaseous fuel. What became the Siemens-Martin process for steel manufacture was a tremendous innovation in terms of the temperatures achieved and the fuel economy. Appointed London agent for his brother Werner's telegraph company Siemens & Halske, William Siemens began to contribute to the new field of electrical engineering. Insulating cabling with gutta-percha proved to be an interesting engineering project, which had enormous consequences for communications. International links to India and America were made possible with incalculable benefits. The Siemens Brothers' Company, established in 1858, also produced electrical lighting, famously illuminating the British Library in 1879. With over a hundred patents to his name, Siemens was a prolific and energetic engineer. Once elected to the Institution of Mechanical Engineers, he contributed thirteen papers to the Proceedings, many of which outlined key discoveries or processes for which he was responsible. Siemens served as President in 1872-73.
79
137
DESCRIPTION OF A MACHINE FOR COVERING TELEGRAPH WIRES WITH INDIA-RUBBER. BY MB. C. WILLIAM SIEMENS, OF LONDON.
A submarine telegraph cable is composed of three essential parts:—1st, the conductor, which generally consists of a strand of seven copper wires twisted together, to give it strength and pliability: 2nd, the insulating coating, which consists almost without exception of several coatings of gutta percha put on while hot and in a semifluid state by means of piston and cylinder machines analogous to the presses used for making lead pipes; with intervening coatings of a bituminous compound, called Chatterton's mixture, to establish a more intimate union of the different layers of gutta percha : 3rd, the sheathing, which is added to protect the insulated conductor and to give strength to the cable, and consists generally of a hemp serving and a spiral covering of iron or steel wire. Respecting the conductor, it is important that it should consist of the best conducting material, in which quality pure copper far surpasses all but some of the precious metals and possibly pure aluminium. If the conductivity of silver is expressed by 100, that of pure precipitated copper may be taken at 90. The conductivity of the copper of commerce varies however between extraordinary limits; and it may be accepted as a rule that all foreign matter contained in it, whether metallic or otherwise, diminishes its conductivity. Thus 2 per cent, of alloy is known to reduce the conductivity of copper from 90 to 13, and even the best selected copper used for telegraph conductors varies in practice as much as 20 per cent, in conducting power. The foreign substance which it is most difficult to remove from the copper is oxygen; and a process to effect this would be of considerable value. The insulating covering of the conductor is the most delicate and essential part of the telegraph cable. It has to form an effectual barrier against escape of the current throughout the whole length, for v 81
138
INDIA-RUBBER COVERING MACHINE.
a single flaw in this coating causes the failure of an entire cable. Nor does a flaw show itself always in testing cables however thoroughly previous to their submersion ; for experience has proved that flaws are produced gradually by the chemical action of the galvanic current itself in any places where the thickness of insulating coating has been considerably below the average, either owing to an air bubble forced open by the pressure of the water, or owing to an eccentric position of the conductor. The latter defect may be produced either in the covering machine, or afterwards by exposure of the cable to the heat of the sun, or to a strain producing a permanent elongation of the copper; in consequence of such elongation the gutta percha endeavours to return to its original length and causes the copper core by degrees to assume a serpentine position in the covering. Gutta percha was till lately thought almost a perfect non-conductor of electricity; but in dealing with long lines of submarine electric telegraph its conductivity has become well established and is often a source of painful anxiety to the electrical engineer, obliging him to search for other insulating materials. Glass and other vitreous substances, which possess the highest insulating properties, are of course inapplicable; and amongst the resinous insulators there is none that combines insulating quality with tenacity and other desirable mechanical properties in so high a degree as india-rubber. The accompanying table shows the respective non-conducting or insulating power of gutta percha, india-rubber, and Wray's mixture, which last is a compound of india-rubber with shellac and pounded flint; and of the two latter substances combined :— Specific Non-conducting and Inductive Power of Gutta percha, India-rubber, &c. Specific Non-conducting Power. Temperature Fahrenheit
82
Specific Inductive Power.
52°
72°
92°
52°
72°
92°
Gutta percha
3.01
1.20
0.38
1.00
1.00
1.00
India-rubber
50.70
45.10
27.60
0.68
0.62
0.70
Wray's mixture
23.60
26.00
38.40
0.77
0.63
0.96
Combination of India-rubber and Wray's mixture
38.40
40.55
38.40
0.77
0.78
...
INDIA-RUBBER COVERING MACHINE.
139
The great superiority of india-rubber and its compounds over gutta percha in insulating power is at once apparent, india-rubber itself being 16 times better than, gutta percha as a non-conductor at a temperature of 52°, and 70 times better at 92°; and the combination of india-rubber and Wray's mixture is on the average as good a nonconductor as india-rubber, while its inductive power, which causes retardation of the electric current in its passage along the wire, is only three quarters that of gutta percha. To these advantages the greater tenacity of india-rubber and its greater power to resist heat have to be added. India-rubber has been tried for the purpose of insulating telegraph conductors more than -twenty years ago, when it was employed by Jacobi of St. Petersburg for underground telegraphic lines. In. 1846 Dr. Werner Siemens employed it for the same purpose, previous to his application of gutta percha. About the same time india-rubber was put to the same use in this country, and it is said remains still in good condition in Portsmouth harbour. There is nothing new therefore in substituting india-rubber and its compounds for gutta percha in insulating submarine or other telegraph conductors : the present paper has special reference to a new method of effecting the covering. The method hitherto adopted consists in cutting the indiarubber into strips, and winding these strips spirally upon the wire to be insulated : a tedious and expensive operation, which has to be repeated several times to afford any security that the water is entirely excluded from the wire. The insulation of the wire depends in fact upon a perfect joint being formed throughout between the strips; for it is evident that where the strips overlap a spiral channel is formed, which, if in any one place penetrated will allow the water to spread till it may chance to find a transverse passage into the spiral channel of the next lower coating, and so forth until it reaches the wire. Formerly the layers of india-rubber simply touched one another, and could readily be displaced; but lately a process of soldering the spiral layers has been introduced by Messrs. Silver, which greatly increases the security of the coating, although it does not remove the objections to the spiral channels which must always be formed in lapping. This
83
140
INDIA-RUBBER COVERING MACHINE,
process of soldering consists in exposing the covered wire to boiling water for about half an hour, when a most perfect cohesion between adjoining surfaces is produced. The india-rubber so treated adheres to the fingers, or feels sticky; it also loses part of its elasticity and strength. It may therefore be inferred that -the heat produces some chemical alteration in the material, changing the gum into an oil. It has been observed that india-rubber so heated has gradually changed bodily into a viscid liquid, where it is in contact with the metal conductor, so as to render it unsafe to be used. The method of covering which it is proposed to substitute for the above combines the advantages of comparative cheapness and certainty of result with that of rendering the application of heat unnecessary. The operation is based on the well known adhering property of india-rubber, when two fresh-cut surfaces are joined together under considerable pressure. The mechanical problem consisted in the construction of a machine which would draw the india-rubber tight upon the wire, so as completely to exclude air; and would then cut the india-rubber at the proper inclination, and join the fresh-cut edges together at the same instant under a sufficient pressure to make the joint perfect. The machine finally arranged for this purpose is shown in Figs. 1 to 5, Plates 27, 28, and 29, one quarter full size. Fig. 1, Plate 27, is a side elevation; Fig. 3, Plate 28, an end elevation partly section ; and Fig. 5, Plate 29, a plan partly sectional; The machine consists of two grooved pressing rollers A and B, Figs. 1, 2, and 3, Plates 27 and 28, and of two cutting or shearing rollers CC, all of which are of hardened steel, and are shown enlarged to half full size in the section, Fig. 4, Plate 28. On each side of the groove in the pressing rollers A and B is a small cylindrical portion, as shown enlarged to double full size in Figs. 9 and 10, Plate 30, of a breadth equal or nearly so to the thickness of the intended coating to be applied; but these cylindrical sides must be slightly rounded off towards the groove and sharp on the outer edge, as shown at DD. The cutting rollers C are so placed on each side of the grooved rollers that in turning round their cutting edge crosses the edges of the grooved rollers a little before the centre line of the machine, as shown
84
1NDIA-RUBBER COVERING MACHINE.
141
double full size in Figs. 7 and 9, Plate 30, at a point where the distance between the edges of the grooved rollers is about equal to half the thickness of one of the strips of india-rubber used. The axis of the cutting rollers is slightly inclined to the axis of the grooved rollers, as shown in the end elevation, Fig. 3, and plan, Fig. 5; so that being pressed against the latter by means of set screws they only touch hard at the shearing point, as seen in Figs. 9 and 10, Plate 30 The wire to be covered and the two strips of india-rubber for covering it are guided into the machine by suitable guides E, Figs. 1 and 5. The two strips in closing upon the wire are drawn tight over it by the inner edges of the grooved rollers A and B; and being caught between the closing cylindrical portions of the grooved rollers are compressed to one fourth their original thickness, the material being forced outwards from the middle; the cutting rollers C then suddenly intersect them, as in Fig. 9, Plate 30, cutting off the superfluous breadth of strips and at the same time preventing further escape of the material towards the sides. As the edges of the grooved rollers continue to close upon one another, the material remaining between them can only escape inwards, by which means the two fresh-cut edges are brought one upon the other under a heavy rolling pressure, from which they glide inwards towards the groove, as in Fig. 10, and in so doing form a complete and permanent joint, Fig. 11. In order to effect several successive coatings, a train of machines is provided, as shown in Fig. 6, Plate 29, so placed that the wire to be coated passes in a straight line through them all, receiving in each successive machine an additional coating, with the longitudinal seams at right angles to those of the previous and succeeding coatings, as seen in Fig. 11, Plate 30, which is effected by the different angular positions in which the machines are placed. The last machine in the train is supplied with strips of cloth or felt covered with india-rubber, which is also capable of being joined by compression of the fresh-cut edges, and is extremely useful in adding firmness and protection to the insulated conductor. This machine is also applicable, with certain modifications of details, for covering wire with the compound of india-rubber, shellac, and pounded flint, known by the name of Wray's mixture, which
85
142
INDIA-RUBBER COVERING MACHINE.
possesses in common with india-rubber very remarkable insulating properties. The machine is also applicable, with great apparent advantage, for the manufacture of india-rubber tubes, and for several other similar purposes. In producing tubes by this process, a spiral or tube of wires is first prepared, which is coated with india-rubber in one or several layers, with or without intermediate layers of canvas previously coated with india-rubber. The spiral wire is then either withdrawn or left to support the tube, which is finally subjected to the vulcanising process. In order to produce a submarine cable, an outer covering is required for protection and strength. Instead of the ordinary hemp serving and iron sheathing, the author proposes to saturate hemp yarn with a cement consisting of ordinary marine glue mixed with a certain proportion of pitch and shellac, applied to the yarn in a fluid state and under pressure so as to penetrate the fibre completely. Two or more layers of this yarn are put upon the insulated conductor by means of a train of machines, which cause each strand to be drawn tight uniformly, and to pass separately through a heated chamber, so as to soften the cement and unite the yarn in complete layers upon the core, winding alternately right and left. The covering thus produced combines great tensile strength and lightness with the power to exclude the sea water from the core. It thus adds very considerably to the insulating coating, whereby the retarding effect of induction is greatly diminished; and forms a thorough protection to the more tender coating of highly insulating material. The necessity for a metallic sheathing is however not entirely avoided, in order to afford protection against abrasion and against marine animals; and this sheathing is proposed to consist of very thin brass or iron wire wound on in the form of a tight lapping while the cement is still soft, so as to be imbedded completely in it. The cable is then drawn through a hot die, which causes the superfluous cement to cover the wires completely and to preserve them from rusting. A cable so prepared combines the qualities essential for crossing deep and broad oceans. Its specific gravity will not exceed 1.5, which experience has proved to be the most desirable weight for submersion,
86
INDIA-RUBBER COVERING MACHINE.
143
and its tensile strength is such that it will support 15 miles of its own length in sea water, instead of only 3 miles which is the length an ordinary iron-sheathed cable will support. The sheathing of this cable will not be acted upon by sea water, and will retain its full strength therefore in case it should have to be taken up for repairs : it will not be liable to form kinks, which are fraught with danger to the insulation. The chief advantage however is supposed to reside in the insulating coating, which consisting of a succession of perfect tubes of the most highly insulating and tenacious material known, unaltered by heat or solvents and thoroughly protected against external injury, offers the greatest chances for permanent efficiency that could well be realised. For shore ends this cable should receive an additional external covering of strong wires to resist the effects of anchors and violent abrasion; and these wires in their turn should be covered with saturated fibre to render them durable. The experience with long submarine cables has hitherto been anything but satisfactory; but there is in the writer's opinion no reason to prevent their being made very permanent and valuable property, if only the experience now gained is turned to good account.
Mr. SIEMENS exhibited the machine in action, covering pieces of wire with india-rubber, showing that the joint made by rolling the two fresh-cut edges together under a heavy pressure was so strong that the india-rubber covering would tear at any other part as readily as at the joint. He showed also a number of specimens of the different descriptions of telegraph cable now in use. The process of joining the strips of india-rubber by the machine depended on the well known property of india-rubber, that when two perfectly clean fresh-cut surfaces were pressed together with great force they would unite as completely as two pieces of iron welded together. After many trials for effecting this by machinery, he had now succeeded perfectly with the machine exhibited, in which the two cut edges made by the cutting wheels on each side were instantly pressed together between
87
144
INDIA-RUBBER COVERING MACHINE.
the pressing rollers and joined without having been ever exposed to the atmosphere. This was the essential point in the machine, as any exposure of the cut surfaces however momentary interfered with the perfection of the joint. In putting on a series of coats of india-rubber for making telegraph cables, a train of machines was employed through which the wire was passed in a continuous line, the joints in each successive covering being in a line at right angles to those in the previous covering, which gave a greater security against failure at the joint. This insulating covering had been subjected to severe tests, and proved highly satisfactory and superior to any other mode of insulation. Gutta percha, which had hitherto been the material used for covering telegraph wires, was a good non-conductor; but its resistance to the passage of an electric current was only relative, like that of all other insulating materials, and it would conduct to a certain extent, the conducting power being about 3 trillion times less perfect than that of mercury, which was adopted as the standard of comparison. But india-rubber had much less conducting power than gutta percha, being 16 times better as a non-conductor at a temperature of 52°, and 70 times better at 92°. The insulating power of india-rubber was moreover less affected by difference of temperature than was the case with gutta percha; and in the combination of india-rubber and Wray's mixture, which he had produced, the average insulating power was not less than that of india-rubber, while it was to a less extent affected by change of temperature. Before however a current of electricity could pass along the wire, it had to induce a statical charge in the insulating material throughout the whole length of the wire, as in a Leyden jar; and the delay or retardation thus produced depended on the inductive power of the insulating material, which was independent of its insulating or non-conducting power, but affected by its thickness, the inductive power diminishing as the thickness was increased. A thicker coating of the insulating covering therefore offered less resistance by induction to the passage of an electric current, and allowed of more rapid speaking. In this respect also india-rubber and its compounds had an advantage over gutta percha, its inductive power being about three quarters that of the latter.
88
INDIA-RUBBER COVERING MACHINE.
145
In the use of gutta percha as the insulating material, a great amount of care was necessary in the process of coating the wire, and there was great risk of imperfection in the covering. In the submarine telegraph between Rangoon and Singapore the cable was very good for many miles, but a point was then found to exist where the insulation failed from a defect in the original construction of the gutta percha coating ; and such defects were liable to arise in the manufacture from various causes. In covering the wire the gutta percha was squeezed forwards in a semifluid state through the die, by means of a piston in a cylinder; and air bubbles were liable to get enclosed within its substance, which were so minute as not to be detected at the time of manufacture, though the cable was tried under a pressure of 600 or 1000 Ibs. per square inch; but they were sufficient to impair the insulation at the part where they occurred, and ultimately cause the failure of the cable. Moreover the manufacture was a hot process, as the gutta percha had to be kept soft in coating the wire; and if a slight delay took place in the operation, the gutta percha was too much softened at that part, and the weight of the wire cable itself made the coating thinner on one side than the other, so that the insulation was defective; the electric current afterwards sent through the wire was constantly leaking out more or less at the imperfectly protected parts, and caused a chemical action on the gutta percha, gradually decomposing it at the leak and increasing the amount of leakage. If the finished cable were allowed to lie for only a quarter of an hour exposed to a hot sun, it would be completely spoiled, as the heat would soften the covering and the core would take an eccentric position by sinking through the gutta percha by its weight \ and in the event of a strain coming on the cable in laying it, the copper core being non-elastic would remain permanently stretched, while the gutta percha would be constantly endeavouring to regain its original length, forcing the copper by degrees into a serpentine curve. These difficulties had at present caused failures to a greater or less extent in all submarine cables constructed with gutta percha. But in the process now described it was expected that the chances of failure through defects of manufacture would be much diminished, as there was less liability to accidental imperfections in the work, and the durability of the cable was not affected by the temperature to which it was exposed.
w 89
146
INDIA-RUBBER COVERING MACHINE.
Mr. E. A. COWPER observed that the Rangoon and Singapore telegraph cable would support only 3 miles of its own length in water, and its specific gravity was 3 times that of water; but the new indiarubber cable had a specific gravity of only 11/2 times that of water, and would consequently support 12 miles of its length in water, if of only the same tensile strength ; it appeared really to support 15 miles of its length, which was a most important advantage in point of safety, as submarine cables were liable to have great lengths suspended between the summits of mountains at the bottom of the sea. The CHAIRMAN asked what would be the difference in cost per mile between the new cable and one covered with gutta percha. Mr. SIEMENS replied that for equal efficiency, or the same speed of speaking, the new cable would be the cheapest, because a thinner coating of india-rubber would be sufficient to produce an equal insulating effect: but if estimated by weight, a gutta percha cable would be the cheapest 011 account of the greater cost of india-rubber. The first cost of the cable was however a secondary question, the great object being to obtain a cable that could be depended upon for a number of years. In a gutta percha cable, if the covering were thin at any one place, then each successive current passing along the wire produced an alteration, since the gutta percha conducted at the leak by decomposition of the water contained in its substance ; and this action gradually disintegrated its substance and destroyed its insulating power at that part, so that the electric current soon made its escape there. The CHAIRMAN asked how long the new cable would last at work. Mr. SIEMENS replied that there was not one of the new cables laid at present, and it required that several hundred miles should have been down for some years in order to show practically its durability in work; but some miles had been made and tested with very satisfactory results, and there was good reason for expecting this construction of cable would prove far more durable than those hitherto laid. The CHAIRMAN moved a vote of thanks to Mr. Siemens for his paper, which was passed.
90
Plate 27 Fig 2. Side Elevation of Rollers. Fig 1 Side Eleration.
Fig 3. End Elevatio partly Section Scale, 1/4.th
Fig 4. Vertical Section enlarged. Scale 1/2 full size..
Fig 5. Plan Partly Sectional,
Fig 6. General; Arrartgement
of
Train
of
Machines.
Fig 7. Longitudinal Sections through, Pressing Rollers
Fig 9. Section at Fig 8. Section, at
C. C.
Fig
10. Section at H. H.
F. F. Fig 11 Section at II.
Henry Bessemer (1813-1898) Bessemer's well-known facility for metalworking was apparently inherited. His father had escaped the French Revolution, settling in Charlton, Hertfordshire, and eventually entered the chain-making and type-founding business. The young Bessemer was trained at his father's works. His early inventions included a forgery-proof deed stamp, a method of compressing plumbago for pencil-making and a process for the liquid rolling of glass. Henry Bessemer contributed to meetings of the fledgling Institution of Mechanical Engineers, showing a model railway axle in only the second official meeting on 28 April 1847. His paper on this axle pre-dated the creation of the Proceedings, and was therefore never published. Since Bessemer did not become a full member of the Institution until 1861, this lost connection must rank as one of the great missed opportunities of early IMechE history. The inventor continued to produce a stream of practical and profitable ideas, but his most important work on steel arose from investigations into guns during the Crimean War. The steelmaking process which bore Bessemer's name was the subject of a series of patents in the years 1854-69, including in 1855 a description of the Bessemer converter. The first announcement of his discoveries was given before the British Association in the following year. Bessemer steel was produced under license immediately, and at Bessemer's own works, built in Sheffield. It was in Sheffield, during the Institution of Mechanical Engineers' Summer meeting of 1861, that he read the Proceedings paper on that topic, one of the very few technical papers he produced. The widespread adoption of Bessemer steel, in railways particularly, ensured world-wide recognition for the author of the process. Many Institution members - William Menelaus, John Ramsbottom and Daniel Adamson particularly - were instrumental in perfecting Bessemer's ideas and ensuring their practical application. Towards the end of his life in 1897, over 10,500,000 tons of Bessemer steel were being produced, on an annual basis, internationally. Bessemer himself preferred more simple statistics: "picture...a giant armour plate, 100 miles long, 5 feet thick and 20 feet high as representing the output of steel every year".
95
133
ON THE MANUFACTURE OF CAST STEEL AND ITS APPLICATION TO CONSTRUCTIVE PURPOSES. BY MR, HENRY BESSEMER, OF LONDON. The mode of manufacturing Cast Steel, which now forms so important a branch of the Sheffield trade, was discovered in the year 1740 by Mr. Benjamin Huntsman of Handsworth near Sheffield; who subsequently established steel works at Attercliffe, where his most valuable invention has ever since been successfully carried on. In its early stages many difficulties had doubtless to be overcome : materials for lining the furnaces and for making the crucibles had to be sought for and tested ; the peculiar marks of iron most suitable for melting had to be determined on by numerous experimental trials; and such was the difficulty at that time of making crucibles which would stand the excessive heat of melted steel that for a long period only very highly carbonised or "double converted" steel, which required the lowest temperature, could be successfully melted. The first products of a new manufacture, even while the invention still remains in a partially developed state, but too frequently stamp its subsequent character. Thus Huntsman's cast steel, although it was acknowledged to be a pure homogeneous metal of great value for certain purposes, was still looked upon as a hard and brittle material of very limited use, not bearing a high temperature without falling to pieces, and quite incapable of being welded : even within the last few years this has been the popular idea of cast steel. Improvements in its manufacture have however from time to time been introduced; and steel of a milder and less brittle character has long been made, capable of welding with facility and working at a high temperature without falling to pieces. Its uses have consequently been greatly extended, and the employment of cast steel for the best cutlery and edge-tools has now become universal; indeed the excellent quality of the cast steel at present made in Sheffield for these purposes is u
97
134
BESSEMER STEEL.
scarcely to be surpassed. Of late years several of the most enterprising manufacturers have sought to introduce cast steel for a variety of other purposes besides those for which it was originally employed, and it is now used in some form or other in almost every first class machine. Its employment as a material for founding bells and various other articles in clay moulds, as carried out by Messrs. Naylor and Vickers, and the introduction of a valuable material by Messrs. Howell and Shortridge, under the name of homogeneous metal, are prominent examples of the successful adaptation of cast steel to engineering purposes. The manufacture of cast steel by Huntsman's process is so extensively practised and is so well known that it is unnecessary to do more than recall to mind that crude pig iron has first to go through all the stages of melting, refining, puddling, hammering, and rolling, in order to produce a bar of malleable iron as nearly pure as the most careful manipulation in charcoal fires can make it. Bar iron, on which so much labour, fuel, and engine power have been expended, thus becomes the raw material of this most expensive manufacture. In order to convert the wrought iron bars into blister steel, they are packed with powdered charcoal in large firebrick chests, and are exposed to a white heat for several days ; the time required for heating and cooling them extending over a period of 15 to 20 days. When thus converted into blister steel they are broken into small pieces and sorted according to the quality of the steel, which sometimes differs even in the same bar. For melting this material powerful air furnaces are employed, containing two crucibles, into each of which are put about 40 Ibs. of the broken blistered steel. In about 3 hours the pots are removed from the furnaces, and the melted steel is poured into iron moulds and formed into ingots of cast steel, from31/2to 4 tons of hard coke being consumed for each ton of metal thus melted. When large masses of steel are required, a great many crucibles must be got ready all at the same moment, and a continuous stream of the melted metal from the several crucibles must be kept up until the ingot is completed, since any cessation of the pouring would entirely spoil it: hence in proportion to the size of the ingot are the cost and risk of its production increased. The ordinary manufacture of cast steel is
98
BESSEMER
STEEL.
135
therefore obviously conducted at a great disadvantage. If cast steel is to supersede wrought iron for engineering purposes, it will be necessary to cease employing wrought iron as a raw material for this otherwise most expensive mode of manufacture. The extremely high temperature requisite to maintain malleable iron in a state of fusion has from the earliest period of the history of iron down almost to the present day rendered its purification in a fluid state practically and commercially impossible. Hence arise all those imperfections to which bar iron is subject, every small piece consisting of numerous granules partially separated from each other by scoria, and every large mass being produced only by piling together small bars, with the inevitable result of increasing the former imperfections ; for no two pieces of iron can be brought to a welding heat without becoming coated with oxide, and when this coating is rendered fluid by welding sand a fluid silicate of the oxide of iron is formed, covering the entire surface to be united. The heavy blows of the hammer or the pressure of the rolls may and do extrude the greater portion of this fluid extraneous matter, but it is never wholly removed from between the welded surfaces, and hence a portion of the cohesive force of the metal is lost at every such junction. When a bar of iron is nicked on one side and bent, the rending open of the pile clearly shows this want of perfect cohesion. Nor is this the only difficulty to be encountered; for in the production of large masses of wrought iron it is necessary to raise the temperature nearly to the fusing point, in order to render each additional piece sufficiently soft and plastic to become united to the bloom : this softening of the iron induces a molecular change in the structure of the metal; its natural tendency to crystallise is so powerfully assisted by the long continuance of the high temperature that its whole structure undergoes a change ; large and well defined crystals are formed almost independent of each other, and cohering so feebly to the other contiguous crystals as in some cases to separate with as little force as would overcome the cohesion of ordinary cast iron. In the substitution of cast steel for malleable iron, both these sources of difficulty are escaped : for the mass whether of 1 ton or 20 tons weight may be formed in a fluid state into a single block, wholly free from admixture of scoria, while
99
136
BESSEMER STEEL.
it is perfectly and equally coherent at every part; and the forging of such a solid block of metal into shape is only the work of a few hours, and as there is no welding of separate pieces it may be worked under the hammer at a temperature at which no molecular change will take place, the metal being far below its fusing point and much too solid to undergo that destructive crystallisation so common in large masses of wrought iron. Thus the difficulties and uncertainty attending the production of all large masses of wrought iron are wholly avoided in producing equally large masses of cast steel. But however desirable in the abstract it may be to employ cast steel as a substitute for malleable iron for engineering purposes, it must not be forgotten that there are several important conditions indispensable to its general use. Firstly, the steel must be able to bear a good white heat without falling to pieces under the hammer ; otherwise the process of shaping it will not only be expensive, but the partly finished forging may be spoiled at any moment by being overheated. Secondly, the steel should be of such a tough character as to admit of being twisted or bent into almost any form in its cold state before fracture takes place, whether the force be applied as a gradual strain or by a sudden impact. Thirdly, it should have a tensile strength at least 50 per cent, greater than that of the best marks of English iron. Fourthly, it must especially be soft enough to turn well in the lathe, to bore easily, and to yield readily to the file and chisel, so as not to enhance its original cost by the difficulty of working it into the requisite forms. The last is both commercially and practically an important condition, and one which will in future greatly determine the extent of its use. Steel to the engineer has hitherto stood in much the same relation as granite to the builder : the superior hardness, beauty of polish, and durability of granite as compared with other building stone are universally acknowledged, nature has provided it in great profusion, and it has only to be lifted from the earth and made use of; but the practical man has found that to drill a hole in granite for blasting takes days of labour to accomplish, that the stone blunts all the chisels, defies the saw, and is faced only at a great cost 5 hence the builder goes on using an inferior soft stone over which the tools have perfect command. The
100
BESSEMER STEEL.
137
problem to be solved therefore is how to produce cast steel that will take any form in the mould or under the hammer, that will yield quickly and readily to all the present cutting and shaping machines, and will retain all the toughness of the best iron with a much greater tensile strength, and all the clearness of surface, beauty of finish, and durability that so eminently distinguish the harder and more refractory qualities of the steel in common use. These desirable objects are believed by the author to be fully accomplished by his process of converting crude pig iron into cast steel at a single operation, forming the subject of the present paper. This process has now been in daily operation in Sheffield for the last two years. The apparatus by which it is effected is shown in Plates 30 to 33, which represent the arrangement at Messrs. John Brown and Co.'s, Atlas Steel Works, Sheffield : Fig. 1, Plate 30, is a side elevation, and Figs. 3 and 4, Plate 31, a front elevation and plan. The crude pig iron chiefly used in this process has been the hot-blast haematite pig smelted with coke, which is melted in a reverberatory furnace adjoining, and is then run into the converting vessel A, Figs. 1 and 3, Plates 30 and 31, in which its conversion into steel is to be effected. The converting vessel is shown enlarged in section in Fig. 5, Plate 32, which represents its position in filling, the melted pig iron being run into it by the spout B direct from the furnace. It is made of stout boiler plate and lined with a powdered silicious stone found in the neighbourhood of Sheffield below the coal and known as " ganister." The rapid destruction of the lining of the converting vessel was one of the great difficulties met with in the early stages of the invention : the excessive temperature generated in the vessel together with the solvent action of the fluid slags was found to dissolve the best firebrick so rapidly that sometimes as much as 2 inches thickness would be lost from the lining of the vessel during the 30 minutes required to convert a single charge of iron into steel The ganister now used however is not only much cheaper than firebricks, costing only about 11s. per ton in the powdered state, but it is also very durable : a portion of the lining of the vessel is shown which has stood 96 consecutive conversions before its removal. The converting
101
138
BESSEMER
STEEL.
vessel A is mounted on bearings which rest on stout iron standards CC, Figs. 3 and 4, and by means of the gearing and handle D it may be turned into any required position. There is an opening at the top for filling and pouring out the metal; and at the bottom of the vessel are inserted seven fireclay tuyeres, Fig. 9, Plate 33, each having seven holes, as shown enlarged in the longitudinal section and plan, Figs. 10 and 11. The blast from the engine is conveyed through one of the bearings E of the vessel, Fig. 3, Plate 31, into the tuyere box F, and enters the tuyeres at a pressure of about 14 Ibs. per square inch, which is more than sufficient to prevent the fluid metal from entering the tuyeres. Before commencing with the first charge of metal, the interior of the converting vessel is thoroughly heated by coke, with a blast through the tuyeres to urge the fire ; when sufficiently heated it is turned upside down and all the unburnt coke falls out. The vessel is then turned into the position shown in Fig. 5, Plate 32, and the melted pig iron is run in from the furnace by the spout B, the vessel beingkept in such a position during the time it is being filled that the holes of the tuyeres are above the surface of the metal. When the proper charge of iron has been run in, the blast is turned on and the vessel quickly moved up into the position shown in Fig. 6. The blast now rushes upwards into the fluid metal from each of the 49 holes of the tuyeres, producing a most violent agitation of the whole mass. The silicium always present in greater or less quantities in pig iron is first attacked, and unites readily with the oxygen of the air. producing silicic acid : at the same time a small portion of the iron undergoes oxidation, and hence a fluid silicate of the oxide of iron is formed,, a little carbon being simultaneously burnt off. The heat is thus gradually increased until nearly the whole of the silicium is oxidised, which generally takes place in about 12 minutes from the commencement of the process. The carbon of the pig iron now begins to unite more freely with the oxygen of the air, producing at first a small flame, which rapidly increases, and in about 3 minutes from its first appearance a most intense combustion is going on : the metal rises higher and higher in the vessel, sometimes occupying more than double its former space, and in this frothy fluid state it presents an enormous surface to the action
102
BESSEMER STEEL.
139
of the air, which unites rapidly with the carbon contained in the crude iron and produces a most intense combustion, the whole mass being in fact a perfect mixture of metal and fire. The carbon is now burnt off so rapidly as to produce a series of harmless explosions, throwing out the fluid slag in great quantities ; while the combustion of the gases is so perfect that a voluminous white flame rushes from the mouth of the vessel, illuminating the whole building and indicating to the practised eye the precise condition of the metal inside. The blowing may thus be left off whenever the number of minutes from the commencement and the appearance of the flame indicate the required quality of metal. This is the mode preferred in working the process in Sweden. But at the works in Sheffield it is preferred to continue blowing the metal beyond this stage, until the flame suddenly drops, which it does just on the approach of the metal to the condition of malleable iron : a small measured quantity of charcoal pig iron containing a known proportion of carbon is then added, and thus steel is produced of any desired degree of carburation, the process having occupied about 28 minutes altogether from the commencement. The converting vessel is tipped forwards and the blast shut off for adding this small charge of pig iron, after which the blast is turned on again for a few seconds. The vessel is then turned into the position shown in Fig. 7, Plate 33, and the fluid steel run into the casting ladle G, which is carried by the hydraulic crane H, being counterbalanced by the weight I on the opposite end of the jib. When all the metal is poured out of the converting vessel, the crane is raised by water pressure and turned round, as shown in Fig. 2, Plate 30, for the purpose of running the steel into the ingot moulds K. Instead of tilting the casting ladle for pouring into the moulds, it is made with a hole in the bottom fitted with a fireclay seating L, Fig. 8, Plate 33, and closed by a conical plug of fireclay M, forming a conical valve. The valve rod N is coated with loam and bent over at the top, and works in guides on the outside of the ladle, as shown in Fig. 7, with a handle 0 for opening and closing the valve. By thus tapping the metal from below, no scoria or other floating impurities are allowed to run into the mould, and the stream of fluid steel is dropped straight
103
140
BESSEMER STEEL.
down the centre of the mould right to the bottom, without coming in contact with the sides of the mould. The moulds are made of a slightly tapered form,' as shown in Fig. 8, so that as the ingot contracts in cooling it liberates itself from the mould completely on all sides; and the mould is removed by being lifted off the ingot when sufficiently set. The moulds are arranged in the moulding pit in an arc of the circle described by the casting ladle, as shown in the plan, Fig. 4, Plate 81. By this process from 1 to 10 tons of crude iron may be converted into cast steel in 30 minutes, without employing any fuel except that required for melting the pig iron and for the preliminary heating of the converting vessel, the process being effected entirely without manipulation. The loss on the weight of crude iron is from 14 to 18 per cent, with English iron worked in small quantities ; but the result of working with a purer iron in Sweden has been carefully noted for two consecutive weeks, and the loss on the weight of fluid iron tapped from the blast furnace was ascertained to be only 8| per cent. The largest sized apparatus at present erected is that in use at the Atlas Steel Works, Sheffield, as shown in the drawings already described, the converting vessel being capable of converting 4 tons at a time, which it converts into cast steel in 28 minutes. In consequence of the increased size of the converting vessel in this case no metal is thrown out during conversion ; and the loss of weight has fallen as low as 10 per cent., including the loss in melting the pig iron in the reverberatory furnace. Specimens of this manufacture as carried on at the author's works in Sheffield are exhibited, consisting of a piece of the pig iron employed, which is No. 1 hot-blast haematite made with coke ; also a portion of an ingot of very mild cast steel, broken under the hammer to show the purity and soundness of the metal in its cast unhammered state ; and an ingot partly forged to show how little work with the hammer will produce a forging from these solid blooms of steel. There are also two pieces of steel of the quality employed for making piston rods, which have been bent cold under a heavy steam hammer to show the toughness of the metal: it requires very
104
141
BESSEMER STEEL.
much more force to bend it than would be required to bend wrought iron, but notwithstanding this additional rigidity it yields to any extent without snapping. The tensile strength of this soft and easily wrought metal is as much as 40 tons per square inch, or from 15 to 18 tons greater than that of best Yorkshire iron. In turning, planing, boring, and tapping, it will be found that the uniformity of its quality will be less trying to the cutting tools than the hard reeds and sand cracks met with in the common qualities of malleable iron. The above tensile strength of the piston-rod steel however is by no means the maximum, but on the contrary is nearly the minimum strength of the steel converted by this process ; but at the same time it possesses nearly a maximum degree of toughness, for every additional ton in tensile strength obtained by the addition of carbon hardens the steel for working, renders it more difficult to forge, and brings it nearer to that undesirable state when a sudden blow snaps it like a piece of cast iron. The extreme limits of tensile strength of the converted metal are shown in the following tables, which give the results of many trials made at different times at the Royal Arsenal at Woolwich under the superintendence of Colonel Wilmot:—
BESSEMER STEEL. Tensile Strength per square inch. Bessemer Steel.
Various trials.
In the cast unhammered state.
42,780 48,892 57,295 61,667 64,015 72,503 77,808 79,223
63,023 lbs. = 28.13 tons per square inch.
After hammering or rolling.
136,490 145,512 146,676 156,862 158,899 162,970 162,974
152,912 Ibs. = 68.26 tons per square inch.
Mean Tensile Strength.
Lbs.
V
105
142
BESSEMER STEEL.
BESSEMER IRON. Tensile Strength per square inch, Bessemer Iron.
Various trials.
Mean Tensile Strength.
Lbs.
In the cast unhammered state.
38,197 40,234 41,584 42,908 43,290
41,243 lbs. = 18.41 tons per square inch.
After hammering or rolling.
64,059 65,253 75,598 76,195 82,110
72,643 lbs. = 32.43 tons per square inch.
Flat Ingot rolled into Boiler Plate without piling.
63,591 63,688 72,896 73,103
68,319 lbs. = 30.50 tons per square inch.
From these tables it is seen that, after hammering or rolling, the steel or highly carbonised metal exhibits a mean tensile strength of 68 tons per square inch, but from its hardness and unyielding nature it is totally unfit for many purposes ; while the iron or entirely decarbonised metal is so soft and copper-like in its texture as to yield to a mean tensile strain of 32 tons per square inch, a point unnecessarily low except in cases where a metal approaching copper in softness is required. The soft easy-working tough metal of the quality used for piston rods is therefore believed by the author to be the most appropriate material for general purposes, while the hard steels that range up to a tensile strain of 50 or 60 tons per square inch should be avoided as altogether too expensive to work and too dangerous to be employed in any case where sudden strains may be brought upon them. With reference to the employment of the mild cast steel for constructive purposes, there are few applications of more importance than that which has recently and successfully been made to the construction of steam boilers. The Cornish boiler, as improved by Mr. Adamson of Hyde near Manchester, has a large flue tube constructed
106
BESSEMER STEEL.
143
with narrow plates more than 12 feet long, extending round the flue in one length, and flanged at each edge in a manner which, while it adds greatly to the stability of the flue, demands such qualities in the material employed for its manufacture as are completely found only in metal that has undergone fusion and has become perfectly homogeneous throughout. A practical illustration of the excellence of this mode of constructing boilers and the powerful strains which the new steel is capable of sustaining safely is afforded by the steam boilers employed for some time past at Messrs. Platt's works at Oldham, where six of these boilers are in daily use ; they are 30 feet long and 61/2 feet diameter, and the flue is 4 feet diameter; the plates are5/16inch thick, and the working pressure 100 Ibs. per square inch. The advantages of cast steel are still more marked in the construction of the fireboxes of locomotive engines. The difficulty of flanging and shaping this work in plate iron without splitting the metal at some part is so great as to have rendered the employment of copper necessary hitherto for this purpose ; but the shape required can now be obtained with ease and certainty by hammering up a sheet of metal rolled from one of the cast ingots, such as that now exhibited. One of these firebox plates flanged by Mr. Adamson is also shown, and clearly illustrates the facility with which the new metal may under skilful hands be wrought into any required form. The perfect continuity of the material and its entire freedom from joinings or weldings also obviously render it specially suitable for the tube plates of locomotive engines ; for however near the holes are made to one another, there is no danger of their having a flaw or other weak place between them. This is exemplified in the piece of plate now exhibited, in which rivet holes have been punched so close as to remove almost all the metal, without splitting the narrow piece still left between the holes. Nor is it in the construction of the boiler alone that the cast steel may be employed with advantage in locomotives : the axles whether plain or cranked, the piston rods and guide bars, and last but not least the wheel tyres, are all exposed to so much abrasion and to such sudden and powerful strains that a tough strong material capable of withstanding this destructive wear and tear is imperatively
107
144
BESSEMER
STEEL.
demanded for the satisfactory construction and economical working of the engine. The special aim of the author during the first year of his labours, which throughout the last six years has never been lost sight of, was the production of a malleable metal peculiarly suitable for the manufacture of ordnance. By means of the process that has been described solid blocks of malleable cast steel may be made of any required size from 1 to 20 or 30 tons weight, with a degree of rapidity and cheapness previously unknown. The metal can also with the utmost facility be made of any amount of carburation and tensile strength that may be found most desirable : commencing at the top of the scale with a quality of steel that is too hard to bore and too brittle to use for ordnance, it can with ease and certainty be made to pass from that degree of hardness by almost imperceptible gradations downwards towards malleable iron, becoming at every stage of decarbnration more easy to work and more and more tough and pliable, until it becomes at last pure decarbonised iron, possessing a copper-like degree of toughness not found in any iron produced by puddling. Between these extremes of temper the metal most suitable for ordnance must be found ; and all qualities are equally cheap and easy of production. From the practice now acquired in forging cast steel ordnance at the author's works in Sheffield it has been found that the most satisfactory results are obtained with metal of the same soft description as that employed for making piston rods. With this degree of toughness the bursting of the gun becomes almost impossible, its power of resisting a tensile strain being at least 15 tons per square inch greater than that of the best English bar iron. Every gun before leaving the works has a piece cut off the end, which is roughly forged into a bar of 2 inches by 3 inches section, and bent cold under the hammer in order to show the state of the metal after forging. Several test bars cut from the ends of guns recently forged are exhibited. The power of this metal to resist a sudden and powerful strain is well illustrated by the piece of gun muzzle now shown, which is one of several tubular pieces that were subjected to a sudden crushing
108
BESSEMER STEEL.
145
force at the Royal Arsenal, Woolwich, under the direction of Colonel Wilmot; the pieces were laid on the anvil block in a perfectly cold state, and were crushed flat by the falling of the steam hammer, but none of them exhibited any signs of fracture when so tested. Probably the best proof of the power of the metal to resist a sudden violent strain was afforded by some experiments made at Liege by order of the Belgian government, who had one of these guns bored for a12 Ibs. spherical shot of 4f inches diameter, and made so thin as to weigh only 91/4 cwts. This gun was fired with increasing charges of powder and an additional shot after each three discharges, until it reached a maximum of 63/4 Ibs. of powder and eight shots of 12 Ibs. each or 96 Ibs. of shot, the shots being thus equal to about one tenth of the weight of the gun. It stood this heavy charge twice and then gave way at about 40 inches from the muzzle, probably owing to the jamming of the shots. The employment of guns so excessively light and charges so extremely heavy would of course never be attempted in practice. Some idea of the facility of this mode of making cast steel ordnance is afforded by the time occupied in the fabrication of the 18 pounder gun now exhibited, which was made in the author's presence for his experiments on gunnery. The melted pig iron was tapped from the reverberatory furnace at 11.20 A.M., and converted into cast steel in 30 minutes ; the ingot was cast in an iron mould 16 inches square by 4 feet long, and was forged while still hot from the casting operation. By this mode of treating the ingots their central parts are sufficiently soft to receive the full effect of the hammer. At 7 P.M. the forging was completed and the gun ready for the boring mill. The erection of the necessary apparatus for the production of steel by this process, on a scale capable of converting from crude iron enough steel to make forty of such gun blocks per day, will not exceed a cost of £5000, including the blast engine; hence the author cannot but feel that his labours in this direction have been crowned with entire success : the great rapidity of production, the cheapness of the material, and its strength and durability, all adapt it for the construction of every species of ordnance.
109
146
BESSEMER STEEL.
For the practical engineer enough has already been said to show how important is the application of cast steel to constructive purposes, and how this valuable material may be both cast and forged with such facility and at a cost so moderate as to produce by its superior durability and extreme lightness an economy in its use as compared with iron. The construction of cast steel girders and bridges, and of marine engine shafts, cranks, screw propellers, anchors, and railway wheels, are all deserving of careful attention. The manufacturer of cast steel has only to produce at a moderate cost the various qualities of steel required for constructive purposes to ensure its rapid introduction ; for as certainly as the age of iron superseded that of bronze, so will the age of steel succeed that of iron.
110
Figl. Side Elevation of
Cenverting
Casting Ladle, and, Crane.
Vessel,
Fig.2.
Casting the Steel into Ingots.
Fig 5. Front Elevation of Converting Vessel-
fig. 4. Plan of
Converting Vessel
and Moulding Pit.
112
Fig. 6. Blowing. Fig. 5. Fitting.
Pig. 9. Plans of
Tuyeres.
Fig 10. L ongitudinal Section, of a Tuyere.
Fig 11. Plans.
Fig. 8. Vertical Section of Casttrbg Ladle and Ingot Mould. Fig. 7. Pouring out the Steel into Casting Ladle.
Francis William Crossley (1839-1897) Francis (Frank) Crossley was born in Dunmurry, Co Antrim. He came to England at the age of eighteen and became an apprentice in Robert Stephenson's works in Newcastle-upon-Tyne. His younger brother, William (1844-1911), became an apprentice with Sir W G Armstrong and Company at Elswick. Both brothers worked closely together, and formed Crossley Brothers in Manchester in 1867. The Crossley brothers originally manufactured a range of equipment associated with the Manchester cotton industry. They also developed and patented machinery for the rubber and flax industries. However, the emphasis of the company changed irrevocably when William, on his honeymoon, saw a demonstration of Otto's engine in Cologne. Frank saw an Otto-Langen engine in 1866, and was convinced of its potential. The engine was demonstrated in the Paris Exhibition of 1867, where it was a centre of attraction. Crossley Brothers acquired the patents for OttoLangen engines world-wide, with the exception of Germany, and entered into agreements to manufacture the engines in Britain in 1869. The company built 1400 engines, and made significant improvements to the design. In 1876 the Crossley Brothers company was offered the sole rights for the Otto "silent" four stroke cycle engine, which they took up. Frank made many improvements to the Otto engine, particularly in the areas of valves and ignition systems. The engines were a tremendous success for low power applications and in this size range quickly supplanted the steam engine. Frank was the technical expert of the company and had the duty of defending the patents in court against any infringements. This patent was defended very robustly and successfully, and was applied not only to the four stroke cycle but to any compression engine. A measure of the strength of the patent was that the two stroke engine of Dugald Clerk was also a casualty of an infringement threat. In 1882 the company moved from Great Marlborough Street, Manchester, to new premises in Pottery Lane, Openshaw, which it occupies to this day. In 1897, on the death of Frank, the company became a public limited company with William as the head. The Crossley brothers introduced the internal combustion engine into Britain and made a major impact on its development. The company went on to manufacture both cars and heavier vehicles, and later built engines for aeroplanes.
115
Plate from Crossley Bros, advertisement.
191
ON OTTO AND LANGEN'S ATMOSPHERIC GAS ENGINE, AND SOME OTHER GAS ENGINES. BY MR. FRANCIS W. CROSSLEY, OF MANCHESTER. The Otto and Langen Atmospheric Gas Engine is not only an exceedingly ingenious, but also a well tried and now largely used machine. The attempt to obtain a steady rotary motion from a series of either regularly or irregularly fired explosions—irregular in point of time—and to do this also in accordance with scientific principle, is no easy task ; but here it has been accomplished. The main characteristic of the engine is the "free piston"; the piston when impelled by the explosion rises freely upwards in the vertical cylinder, without at that moment actuating the machine, the motive power being obtained indirectly during the descent by atmospheric pressure acting on the upper side of the piston, in consequence of there being a partial vacuum below it, following the explosion. In the other type of gas engines, on the contrary, the force of the explosion is employed as the motive power, acting direct on the piston. Upon this principle were the two principal gas engines introduced in this country a couple of years previously to 1868, when the Otto and Langen engine appeared. They were both partially successful at the outset, but owing to numerous defects they never came into much use in this country. They were both very similar in appearance to the ordinary horizontal steam engine, and the principal difference between them was that the explosive charge was fired in the one engine by electricity and in the other by an arrangement of gas lights. A further difference was added when a jet or spray of water was admitted into the cylinder of the latter, which was evaporated there by the heat generated by the explosion, and somewhat aided in propelling the piston.
117
192
ATMOSPHERIC GAS ENGINE.
The principle of both these gas engines however was entirely wrong in the writer's opinion, for the following reason. In both of them the explosion delivers its force upon a piston connected to a crank and flywheel, exactly as is done by steam in a steam engine; but therein lies the evil. Steam gives a steady and sustained thrust against the piston, and the gradual motion of the piston is suited to this; but it is quite otherwise with an explosion, as in that case the stress is intense but instantaneous only. The effect of delivering this sudden blow against a piston, connected rigidly with a heavy flywheel, is simply that, instead of the heat, set at liberty by the union of the oxygen and hydrogen in the explosion, being converted into mechanical motion, it remains in the form of heat, and has to be got rid of by a very large external supply of cold water, lest it should destroy the surfaces of the cylinder and piston, and even lead—as it has often done—to the buckling of the piston-rod when it has grown red-hot. In consequence the common steam-engine pistons of these engines, with their connecting-rods and cranks, will not, under any circumstances conceivable by the writer, enable them economically to utilise the suddenly generated and suddenly expiring force of an explosion. The blow given to the piston by the explosion is received by the heavy mass of the necessarily heavy flywheel, which cannot rapidly yield to it; and just as when a cannon ball strikes a massive target which it cannot carry along with it, a flash of fire is the result in which the energy of the shot disappears, so in these engines heat instead of motion is the result of releasing the stored energies of the gases, and in this case heat is not what is wanted. The flame of carburetted hydrogen, when the combustion is perfect, is intensely hot; and when repeated discharges take place— say 150 a minute, as in the case of these horizontal engines— it is easy to see how much cold water must be circulated through the jacket of the cylinder in order to keep the temperature down to something below that at which oil oxidises, so as to prevent the destruction of the piston. It is possible however to keep the temperature sufficiently low even in these engines by supplying
118
ATMOSPHERIC GAS ENGINE.
193
water enough; but it takes a great deal, and where constant working is required it often adds much to the cost of running, and all the heat taken up by the water is carried off without doing work. There is yet another element of difficulty connected with these engines, and that is the deposit left by the gas after explosion. Their cylinders are very much smaller, say less than one fourth the volume of the Otto and Langen engine for the same power. This is in their favour in cost of construction, but it is a drawback in working. The difference in consumption of gas for the same power is found to be about as 1 to 6 in favour of the Otto and Langen engine, and as the cylinder in which this is burnt is also about 4 to 1 in volume, there is twentyfour times the space per unit of gas consumed in the Otto and Langen engine relatively to the others. There is consequently less liability to clog from deposit; and in order to become equally dirty the engine should require twenty-four times as many hours' work. There have been however some favourable reports of one of the horizontal engines in this particular, and perhaps the quality of the gas may often be such as to cause no difficulty from deposit even in them: though when the gas is dirty it is obvious the Otto and Langen engine has the advantage. Some of the disadvantages accruing from using a common steam engine as a gas engine have now been shown ; and this is practically what is done in the horizontal engines, excepting as regards the arrangements made for the firing of the charge and for the supply of the gas and air, in place of the valve for the passage of the steam. It has been pointed out that great waste of fuel, great generation of heat as a necessary consequence, a large supply of cold water as a further necessary consequence, and sometimes if not often a heavy deposit of carbon and tar in the cylinder and passages, are the results obtained from this principle of gas engine. Now in the Otto and Langen engine, the idea of a "free piston" involves great constructive difficulty. The engine is really a gun, which stands vertically, with open mouth pointing upwards; the
119
194
ATMOSPHERIC GAS ENGINE.
explosive compound of gas and air takes the place of the powder, and the piston represents the shot. The charge measured off is however not sufficient to drive the shot or piston out of the gun, and only to within an inch or two of its mouth. The engine is shown in Figs. 1 to 3, Plates 23 to 25, which represent a1/2H. P. engine. It is single-acting, the upper side of the piston B being continuously exposed to the pressure of the atmosphere through the open mouth of the cylinder C; and this arrangement greatly aids in keeping the cylinder cool. The pistonrod A is a rack, and it gears into a toothed wheel D on the main shaft E of the engine, which is mounted on the top of the cylinder. The length of the rack is about equal to twice the circumference of the wheel, so that the single-acting effect of the engine is very different from what it would be in a steam engine. The toothed wheel D however is not keyed fast upon the shaft E, but is attached to it by a friction clutch, which permits the rack to rise without moving the shaft at all, and connects them in the downstroke only. Thus the shock of the explosion is not sustained by the shaft, and the piston is able to move freely in the upstroke independently of it, being arrested only by the resistance of the atmosphere at the end of the upstroke. The following is the series of operations in each stroke, commencing with the piston at the bottom, as shown in Fig. 1. First the piston is lifted through a space of about 1-11th of the length of stroke, as shown in Fig. 2, in order to draw in the charge of gas and air; and the power to effect this movement is obtained from the momentum of the flywheel. The charge is then fired by contact with a gas light, and the piston flies up freely to the top. As it ascends, the plenum caused by the explosion is changed to a partial vacuum, which reaches about 22 in. of mercury at the top of the stroke, and thus the motion of the piston is quickly reversed, and the downstroke is performed under a pressure of about 11 Ib. per sq. in. derived from the atmosphere; this driving power is communicated through the rack and toothed wheel to the shaft. When the piston has reached within a short distance of the bottom, the vacuum, which has been gradually decreasing, is
120
ATMOSPHERIC GAS ENGINE.
195
again changed to a plenum, and the weight of the piston and rack expels the burnt gases during the last few inches of the stroke, thus completing the cycle of operations. The friction clutch, used to connect and disconnect the piston-rod rack with the driving shaft, is shown in Figs. 6 and 7, Plate 26. It consists of a pulley G keyed on the shaft E and surrounded by a ring D, on the interior of which are cut three inclined surfaces. On each of these inclined surfaces a set of live rollers is free to travel, and to press against a corresponding curved wedge I while the piston is descending; and at the same time the opposite side of the wedge, which is faced with leather, presses against the pulley G. While the piston is ascending, no pressure is put on these wedges by the ring, and hence in the upstroke the ring can freely revolve backwards upon its bearings on the shaft; but as soon as the downstroke commences, a firm hold of the shaft is immediately gained by the ring, and the shaft thereby becomes connected direct with the toothed wheel which gears with the piston-rod rack. As by this means the piston is free to take any length of stroke within the limit of the cylinder, it is impossible to determine exactly at what moment it shall reach the bottom ; and as the apparatus for lifting it to draw in the next charge is not required to move until the return of the piston, an intermittent motion is provided for lifting the piston, which is started at the right moment by a tappet fixed to the rack. The mechanism consists of a pair of eccentrics H and K, Figs. 1 and 2, one of which H moves a lever L, which lifts the piston by means of a tappet M projecting on the side of the rack A; and the other eccentric K moves the slide-valve N of the engine. These eccentrics, which are made fast to each other, are carried loose upon an independent shaft T driven by spur wheels from the main shaft E of the engine; and they are started and stopped by an arrangement of ratchet-wheel R and catch P. The catch or paul P is carried by the eccentric H, and is made with a projecting tail opposite to the hook; and a stop S is arranged to strike the tail of
121
196
ATMOSPHERIC GAS ENGINE.
the paul at a fixed point of its revolution, thus arresting it by throwing it out of gear with the ratchet-wheel B, which is keyed upon the shaft T. When the paul is in gear with the ratchet-wheel, it carries the eccentrics round with it; and when out of gear, all stop together. The stop S for disconnecting the paul is held up in position by a spring; but when the rack A descends to the bottom, the tappet M on the rack depresses the stop out of the way, and allows the paul to fall into gear with the ratchet-wheel. A revolution of the eccentrics now takes place, and when this is completed the stop arrests them until the next descent of the piston again effects their release. But while the piston is lifted to draw in the charge, it is necessary to give the valve the power both of admitting the explosive mixture of gas and air, and also of applying the light to fire it when received by the cylinder. The valve for this purpose consists of a flat plate N, which moves between two faces attached to the cylinder base, the outer face being a moveable plate kept up to its place by springs. The valve is provided with ports, adjusted for proportioning the gas to the air so as to form the required compound; and it is further made with a small chamber, Fig. 2, having an opening both to the inside and to the outside; and an independent gas-pipe is carried into this chamber, so that a light may burn in it. Whilst the valve is at rest during the downstroke of the piston, the opening on the outside of the valve is exposed to the atmosphere, and close to it burns constantly a small gas-light, by which the gas fed into the chamber in the valve is ignited ; but on motion being given to the valve, the communication of the chamber with the outside is cut off and is opened with the inside of the cylinder, and the flame that remains in the chamber explodes the charge. This is not effected until the gas and air supply are also cut off by the same movement of the valve. The release of the exhaust or burnt gases is effected by the valve being provided with an independent exhaust port, which is open while the valve is at rest awaiting the descent of the piston, and so permits the escape to take place as soon as the vacuum has changed to a plenum.
122
ATMOSPHERIC GAS ENGINE.
197
It is necessary however to provide a clack valve V in the exhaust pipe, closing inwards, as shown in Fig. 3, Plate 25, otherwise the atmosphere would enter the cylinder and destroy the vacuum, the exhaust port being open during the entire downstroke; and this leads to an interesting point in the action of the engine. It is clear that another explosion cannot take place until the piston has arrived at the bottom and given motion to the eccentrics, and so shifted the valve; but the piston cannot get to the bottom until the escape of the burnt gases is effected, and therefore by simply preventing this escape the interval between the explosions may be indefinitely prolonged, and thus the power and speed of the engine is controlled. This is done by arranging a common governor to press upon the clack valve V in the exhaust pipe, as shown in Fig. 3, and so delay the escape of the gases. This is one of the most important features of the engine, and is the invention of Mr. Otto. To take an example of its effect, suppose an engine is employed in hoisting, and that the load demands the exertion of the full power to accomplish the work; in this case the governor will not press upon the exhaust valve at all, and explosions will take place as rapidly as possible—say at the rate of 30 per minute—whilst the load is being raised. Now suppose the load gets to the top, and all the work is suddenly thrown off, the effect of this will be to increase the speed of the engine sufficiently for causing the governor to close the exhaust valve; and until this is re-opened by the speed dropping, the engine will not make another stroke or explosion. In some of the best of these engines there will be a pause of one minute before this takes place; or in other words only l-30th of the power of the engine is required to move itself whilst doing no work. Perfect as the above method of governing the engine is in principle, it was found in practice to present a drawback. When the piston became leaky through wear, the exhaust was not obliged to escape only through the clack valve V; and thus by going out another way, evaded the action of the governor, and so " running away" of the engine was possible. The necessity for something G2
123
198
ATMOSPHERIC GAS ENGINE.
better has now led to a great improvement in this detail, as shown in Figs. 4 and 5, Plate 26. Instead of preventing the piston from descending by closing the clack valve V, it is now allowed to descend, but its descent is not allowed to release the paul that puts the eccentrics in gear and moves the slide-valve N, unless the governor also permits it. The governor now controls a second stop, which keeps the paul from falling into gear with the ratchetwheel and moving the eccentrics, not only until after the piston has descended to the bottom, but until the speed of the engine has dropped to the desired limit. There are points of comparison between this gas engine and a steam engine in which the latter has the advantage. A steam engine does not necessarily make a noise in working; and the noise has hitherto proved to some extent an insurmountable difficulty with these gas engines, on account of the rapid and intermittent character of their movements. But on the other hand it is a very beautiful and advantageous feature in these gas engines that the governor is able, as described, to stop all motion of the parts, except the flywheel and shaft, as soon as the work is thrown off or less than full work is required. Instead of the piston continuing to rush to and fro while no useful duty is being done, as is the case with steam, it is here at perfect rest; and there is consequently economy both in fuel and wear and tear, as compared with steam. The gas engine has other advantages, in the power of starting at a moment's notice, and starting too at full power: in the fact that while the engine is standing no fuel at all is burnt: and in the very trifling attendance required, which is very much less than with steam. There is no trouble with coals and ashes, nor in many cases is any water consumed. The engine not having any boiler, no boiler explosion can take place; and thus insurances are not affected by its use, or are only very rarely affected. Lastly, the economy of fuel is perhaps the most important difference. Where gas can be had at low rates, the 1 II. P. engine will often run for 2s. 6d. or 3,9. per week; it has not been known to exceed an average cost of Id. per H. P. per hour, with gas at 4s.
124
ATMOSPHERIC GAS ENGINE.
199
per 1000 cub. ft., and it is generally much below this consumption, though no doubt not exerting its full power continuously. Though 1d. cost of gas per H. P. per hour will not appear an economical consumption when compared with the value of say 2 Ib. of coal per H. P. per hour, it has to be borne in mind that this comparison is made between the best and largest steam engines and the gas engine; whereas its practical opponents are the smallest and least perfect ones, in which the fuel burnt will probably be 15 or even 30 Ib. of coal per indicated H. P. per hour. Also gas compared with coal is of course greatly more expensive in cost per heat unit. Taking all into consideration however, the commercial side of the question is entirely in favour of the gas engine in the matter of economy of fuel. When the fuel lost in raising steam and while a steam engine is standing, and the cost while running, are all taken into account, it is found that the gas engines have sometimes saved upwards of 15s. or even 20s. per week in fuel alone where they have replaced small steam engines, besides the saving in attendance, which is often nearly as much more. But the most interesting question is the consideration of the engine from a purely scientific point of view. How many foot-lbs. are obtained on the break per heat unit supplied by the fuel? Here the best steam engines are surpassed by this gas engine. Were pure hydrogen the fuel, instead of adulterated coal gas, no less than 2-5ths of the theoretical efficiency of the fuel might be realised on the break; coal gas however is less productive. Taking the proportion of coal gas to air for complete combustion as 1 vol. of gas to61/2vols. of air, and the theoretical efficiency of the gas as equal to 24,000 heat units per Ib. weight consumed, one heat unit being equal to 772 ft.-lbs.,—and taking the density of the gas as 40 per cent. that of air, or 1 cub. ft. of gas = 0.03 lb. weight,—then the heat units supplied to the engine per minute are equivalent to 584,000 ft.-lbs., the consumption of gas being 1.05 cub. ft. per min.; and the return for this on the break is about 70,000 ft.-lbs., or 12 per cent. Now to compare this with the best steam engine, allowing for air pumps and feed pumps and friction, is it not even too much to
125
200
ATMOSPHERIC GAS ENGINE.
say that 2 Ib. of coal will give under the most favourable conditions of a trial trip 1 H. P. per hour on the break ? But taking it at that figure, and taking 1 Ib. of coal to supply 15,224 heat units or 11,752,928 ft.-lbs., then = 990,000ft.-lbs., or only81/2per cent, of the theoretical efficiency of the fuel: while the gas engine realises 12 per cent., or nearly 1| times the amount. Some careful indicator diagrams lately taken from the gas engine, one of which is shown in Fig. 8, Plate 27, fully illustrate the fact that it is impossible to get a good result from the sudden force of an explosion except by some such means as a free piston. The very sudden and extreme rise in pressure at the moment of explosion is due simply to the expansion of the gases under the temperature of the flame. If this temperature be taken at 5000° Fahr., and divided by 520 for the rate of expansion from an initial temperature of about 60°, it gives an expansion of about 10 times; and as the gas compound occupied 1-11th of the cylinder at the moment of ignition, if it expands 10 times it gives very nearly the stroke actually taken by the piston. The 5000° is an assumption only, but seems to be confirmed by the amount of expansion which follows it. After the explosion the temperature falls almost instantaneously, as shown by the sudden drop of pressure in the diagram. The driving pressure in the return or working stroke varies from 11 Ib. per sq. in. at first, to nothing at about 4-5ths of the stroke, averaging 9 Ib. during the time of action, or a mean of about 7 Ib. per sq. in. effective pressure throughout the stroke. The steady and long sustained pressure during the return stroke, as shown by the diagram, is a proof of the continued fall in temperature even during the contraction of the gases, and is a testimony to the efficiency of this remarkable form of engine. Its spasmodic and intermittent movements are not what can at first sight prove palatable to engineering taste; but experience of its working shows that its faults lie almost wholly on the surface, consisting chiefly of noise, while its advantages are deeper seated, and make it in its very limited sphere a formidable rival of steam.
126
ATMOSPHERIC GAS ENGINE.
201
The second indicator diagram, shown in Fig. 9, Plate 27, is taken from one of the other type of gas engines, using the explosive force of the gas as the direct driving power, and shows the inefficiency of that mode of employing gas. Nearly half the length of stroke is occupied in this engine by drawing in the charge of mixed gas and air, which is then exploded, and the pressure caused by' the explosion propels the piston through the remainder of the stroke; the return stroke is an open exhaust into the atmosphere. The driving pressure indicated varies from 57 Ib. per sq. in. at first, to nothing at the end of the stroke, averaging131/2Ib. per sq. in. during the time of action, or a mean of about 6 Ib. per sq. in. effective pressure throughout the stroke, which singularly coincides with the mean effective pressure in the Otto and Langen engine. In the horizontal engine 146 explosions, each burning about as much gas as one explosion in the 1 H. P. Otto and Langen engine, result in no better effect in driving power on the shaft than about 30 explosions in the latter engine.
Mr. E. A. COWPER said he had had an opportunity of seeing this gas engine at work; and in reference to the application of the explosion of gas for the production of power, he remembered an attempt was made many years ago to produce power, or rather to raise water, by the explosion of gas in an experimental engine, known as Brown's gas vacuum engine, in which the gas and air were mixed in a vessel having a loose cover; the cover was blown up by the explosion and then fell back into its place, and the vacuum produced was made to suck up water from a reservoir below, into the vessel, from which it was afterwards run out for use. That was an attempt to do away with the evils of the tar and dirt which resulted from the explosions of the gas in a closed vessel. A few explosions did not dirty a cylinder very much, but after working for some time there was an accumulation of condensed sulphurous acid and other substances, including tar, and these after some time
127
202
ATMOSPHERIC GAS ENGINE.
generally caused the leakage of the piston, which was so exceedingly objectionable in an engine upon that principle. In the engine now described this difficulty seemed to have been got over to a considerable extent; but when the cylinder became worn, there would be an escape past the piston at the moment of the explosion. He had hoped that this leakage past the piston had been entirely overcome; he understood it had been overcome to a certain extent, and he should be glad to know how far. This plan of gas engine had been spoken of as applicable only to produce a small amount of power. Now it was much more easy to work a small engine than a large one on such a plan, as the quantity of heat developed by the explosion of the gas was much greater in a large engine than in a small one. He should be glad to hear of further attempts and success with this engine constructed in a larger size; and to know what was the largest size yet made or in contemplation. In reference to the mode of utilising the explosion of the gas, a larger space was evidently required in this engine for obtaining the power by means of the weight lifted by the explosion, than if the exploded gas were confined in a smaller space so as to drive by direct pressure. The exploded mixture of gas and air produced at the moment of explosion a pressure of about 150 Ib. per sq. in. under favourable circumstances, but it was difficult in any engine to take full advantage of a sudden pressure of that amount. If it were possible to cut off the exploded gas neatly in the cylinder, and expand it thoroughly, a good indicator diagram would be obtained; but one of the chief difficulties was to explode the gas neatly and properly, and in order to produce a good diagram the stroke of the piston would have to be inconveniently long; besides which there were certain inconveniences connected with the application of the pressure in an efficient manner as a direct driving pressure. But with the vacuum, principle the arrangement was greatly simplified; the piston made its upstroke freely, like a shot, and the power was obtained by the vacuum in the downstroke. He wished that more power could be obtained by that principle in a given space, so
128
ATMOSPHERIC GAS ENGINE,
203
that the engine might be made more powerful and of larger size. The pressure of 7 Ib. per sq. in. in the downstroke alone was equivalent to only31/2Ib. in the double stroke, which was rather a small amount of pressure for a cylinder of the size shown; and he should be glad if an increased pressure could be obtained, so as to get more power from the same size of engine. Great credit was due for the very ingenious construction of the driving clutch, which he had no doubt was efficient in utilising the whole length of the stroke of the piston of a small engine, as long as it was kept in order; and the engine was altogether a highly ingenious arrangement. Mr. A. PAGET considered the main principle of the engine was admirable for utilising the full effect of an explosion. The earlier gas engines had been as great anomalies as would be the use of a sledge-hammer with a cushion interposed between itself and the work on which it was employed; for in those engines the piston, piston-rod, connecting-rod, crank, and shaft, had each formed a cushion, which altogether absorbed and threw away the greater portion of the force of the explosion. The proper plan for utilising the power of an explosion was to store it up by some spring arrangement and give it out gradually; and in the engine now described this had been well carried out, so far as it went. He remembered seeing this engine in Paris in 1867, and its present appearance was certainly very similar to what it bore then, though some of the details had been modified since it was first brought out; but there were others which he thought still seemed capable of being modified with advantage. He enquired what was the width of the driving clutch, and whether there was not a very considerable amount of wear upon the leather of the clutch; and also whether the leather as an elastic material interposed in the clutch might not cause a large amount of back-lash or slip before the clutch got a complete hold, and thus account for what was spoken of as a great annoyance,—the noise : and he enquired whether the amount of back-lash was not greater in this clutch than in many other forms of clutch in constant use.
129
ATMOSPHERIC Fig. 1.
130
Fartical
Section.
GAS ENGINE.
Plate.23.
Piston at bottom of stroke.
ATMOSPHERIC GAS ENGINE. Fig.
2.
Plate
24.
Vertical Section.
131
ATMOSPHERIC Fig. 3.
132
Side
GAS
Elevation.
ENGINE.
Plate 25.
ATMOSPHERIC
Fig.
4.
GAS ENGINE. Fig.
Fig.
Plate 26. 5.
6. Transverse Section.
Fig. 7. Sectional Plan .
133
ATMOSPHERIC Fig. 8.
Fig. 9.
134
Indicator
GAS
Diagram,
Indicator Diagram acting by direct
Otto
from force of
ENGINE. and
Plate
Langen Engine.
Horizontal Gas Engine explosion.
27.
Thomas Russell Crampton (1816-1888) T R Crampton spent his post-apprenticeship years working with some of the best-known Victorian engineers. He was personal assistant to Marc Brunei, of Thames Tunnel fame, during the period 1839-1844. Later, under the direction of Daniel Gooch, he prepared drawings for the first locomotive built for the Great Western Railway. Crampton was rated as "a clever fellow" by Gooch. However, his locomotive designs, awarded the highest class medal at the Great Exhibition above Gooch, were dismissed as "most faulty in construction". Crampton's earliest papers for the Institution's Proceedings were all on railway matters following his election in 1847. His own designs typically incorporated such features as a long boilers, outside cylinders, and drive wheels set behind the fire-box. Although never accepted on British railways, such engines found favour on the Continent, particularly in France. Crampton's lack of orthodoxy probably meant that he was wellsuited for his eventual working life as a consulting engineer. His reputation was enhanced by a second achievement completed shortly before the closing of the Great Exhibition. This was the laying of the first practical submarine cable between Dover and Calais. He not only supervised the work but raised most of the capital, taking a substantial risk. As a consequence, Crampton has been described as "the father of submarine telegraphy". The remainder of a varied career included constructing the Berlin Water Works and Broadstairs Gasworks. Crampton never lost his interest in railway development, laying out lines as far away as Russia and the Near East, but he often worked in South-East England. Several of the tracks that merged to form the London Chatham and Dover Railway were the result of his labours. As to the subject of this Proceedings paper, one can view his visionary interest in physically linking Britain and France by channel tunnel as the natural outcome of his personal history. From Brunei's tunnelling, to telegraph contact, and his efforts on French and British railways, Crampton's involvement appears to be particularly apt.
135
440
AUGUST 1882.
ON AN AUTOMATIC HYDRAULIC SYSTEM FOR EXCAVATING THE CHANNEL TUNNEL. ![Lecture delivered by Trios. R. CRAMPTOX, Esq., Member of Council, at the Conversazione at Leeds, IGth August, 1882, and published by order of the Council.]
The question of constructing tunnels of considerable length has of late been brought more prominently into public notice by the successful completion of the tunnels through the Mont Cenis and the St. Gothard. In both cases the nature of the rock through which the tunnel had to be cut was such that the rate of advance was comparatively slow, and the quantity of debris which had to be removed daily was inconsiderable; consequently the traffic by trucks or wagons, which the removal of such debris necessitated, offered no serious difficulties, and did not to any great extent interfere with the operation of lining such portions of the tunnel as had already been excavated. But when the material through which the tunnel has to be cut is of so soft a nature that blasting operations can be dispensed with, and ordinary appliances, such as boring or cutting tools, can be employed, then the rate of advance may become practically unlimited —being, in fact, controlled mainly by the greater or lesser facility with which the debris from the face can be removed from the tunnel. So far as I am aware, there is not now in practical use any other mode of dcaling with the debris of tunnel perforation, than that of transport by means of trucks and wagons running on rails, as employed in coal mines. The system of removal which I propose to use, and which will be more particularly treated in this lecture, is applicable only in the case of tunnels through chalk or similar materials; and for the purpose of illustration, I may be allowed to connect it for the moment with one of the most prominent engineering problems of the day, namely the proposed submarine tunnel between England and France.
137
AUGUST 1882.
CHANNEL TUNNEL.
441
This is supposed to pass for its whole length through a uniform stratum of grey chalk without water. I eliminate therefore all questions of meeting with hard rock, or with any large quantities of water during construction. Such questions will have to be dealt with in any case as they arise, and by ordinary means. The tunnel is assumed to be 20 miles long, independent of approaches on either side; to be excavated 36 feet in diameter in one operation, which, with an internal lining of 3 feet all round, will leave a clear tunnel 30 feet in diameter; and the work to be commenced simultaneously at both ends. It follows therefore, since the approaches may be made at the same time as the main tunnel, that we need only consider here a length of 10 miles of excavation worked from one face. Practical trials made with machines in chalk many years since, established the fact that a rate of advance may be easily maintained of one yard per hour, or 24 yards per day; at which rate the work of excavating 10 miles of tunnel would take 21/2years to accomplish, taking the year at 300 working days. With the simple apparatus now exhibited, 12 in. in diameter, as much as 5 yards forward per hour has been cut, The advance of one yard forward per hour in a 36-foot tunnel will necessitate the removal of 113 cubic yards of chalk per hour. In order to ensure the due performance of the necessary work, I will add 50 per cent, to the figures here given, and shall henceforth deal with other items in the same proportion. We have to provide then for the removal of 170 cubic yards of debris per hour, equal in weight to 250 tons—a greater quantity than is lifted in two of our greatest collieries together, in the same time. If we now assume the use of the ordinary system of removal by trucks, we find that the transport of 170 cubic yards of debris per hour would require the passage of 85 trucks of two cubic yards each per hour, or one truck every 42 seconds: thus, if trains are made uo of ten wagons each, there will be one such train every seven minutes passing out, and a similar train of empties coming back continuously. Of course heavier or lighter trains may be used as thought most desirable.
138
442
CHANNEL TUNNEL.
AUGUST 1882,
Arrangements must then be made for raising these wagons to the surface up the vertical shaft, 450 feet in height; and this means the lifting of 255 tons per hour, or 6000 tons per 24 hours, independent of the weight of wagons, men, tools, stores, &c. The wagons may of course be drawn up inclined approaches, but I assume they will be lifted. The lining of the tunnel three feet all round requires materials to the amount of 34 cubic yards per hour, or, with 50 per cent, added for contingencies, 50 cubic yards per hour. These materials will, of course, be introduced by the empties going back to the working face of the tunnel, and will be discharged where required at different parts of the tunnel. It will be easy, without entering further into details, to understand the difficulties to be overcome in accomplishing a task of such magnitude as the lining of the tunnel, at a rate keeping pace with the advance of the boring machinery, while so great a traffic of debris, &c., in trucks is going on in both directions almost uninterruptedly. The system by the use of which I would propose to obviate some of these difficulties eliminates four-fifths of this movement in trucks. It is founded upon the employment of hydraulic power for driving all the machinery required to cut down the chalk at the tunnel-face, and to remove the debris out of the tunnel to the surface, or to any place where it can be disposed of. For the moment the question of different levels in the tunnel will be disregarded, and I will treat the question on the assumption that the whole length of 10 miles is executed on a level 400 feet below the level of the sea ; and further, that the arrangements are such as if the work of excavation and the removal of the debris had all to be carried on at a distance of 10 miles from the starting point. Near the mouth of the upright shaft, A, Fig. 1, Plate 82, powerful machinery will be erected to pump water from the sea, to compress it, and to hold it under pressure, by means of force pumps and accumulators. The water will be compressed at the top to 512 Ibs. per sq. in., and the fall through 400 feet from the sea-level will add another 188 Ibs. per sq. in.—producing thus at the bottom of the shaft 700 Ibs. per sq. in., a pressure commonly employed.
139
.AUGUST 1882.
CHANNEL TUNNEL.
443
The inlet pipe B, which conducts the water under high pressure down the shaft and to the face, will be lengthened as required by the advance of the boring machinery; and this operation will be facilitated by the interposition between the end of the inlet pipe and the boring machinery of an ordinary telescopic joint C, with a free run of say 72 feet, or 24 yards, whereby only one stoppage will become necessary in 24 hours. The cutting machinery at the face, Figs. 2-5, Plates 83 and 84, will be driven by an ordinary hydraulic motor D, direct and without the intervention of gearing. The debris of the chalk cut down will be taken up by a series of cups, and thrown into a shoot E, to the top of which the waste water from the hydraulic motors is conducted. The water flowing down carries with it the chalk debris, and both pass into an ordinary cylindrical revolving drum F, where it is reduced to sludge. The quantity of water used by the hydraulic motors will be so calculated that it will amount to about three times the quantity of chalk debris by weight. When mixed with the water in the revolving drum, the very fine debris almost instantly dissolves, and the result is a cream or sludge, which, passing through small apertures on the face of the drum, is taken up by ordinary pumps G, worked by hydraulic motors H, and forced through the main outlet pipe J, Fig. 1, to the bottom of the shaft A, or direct up the shaft to the sea if required. The pumps G are placed upon the main frame of the boring machine, and the motors H are driven by high-pressure water, taken from the main inlet pipe B. The main outlet pipe J is provided with a telescopic joint similar to the one described for the main inlet pipe. These two telescopic lengths, being attached to one another, are moved forward together. Between the telescope and main pipe two valves UV are placed, one 011 the telescope, the other on the main pipe. When the ram is run out, these valves are closed, and the joint I between the valves broken; the telescope is then moved forwards on the ram by opening a small cock K, connecting the ram with a vacuum chamber. The water in the ram will then flow into the vacuum chamber, and the telescope will be drawn over the ram close up to the machine by the air-pressure behind it. The space thus left between the valves UV is filled up by an extra length of pipe, with a valve attached : the small 2 N
140
444
CHANNEL TUNNEL.
AUGUST 1882,
cock K is shut, the valves U and V opened, and the working resumed. When the machine is required to be brought back, e.g. to change the cutters, the rack and pinion will be thrown out of gear, and an ordinary hydraulic ram (not shown) will be used for the purpose. The cream is forced by the pumps through the excavated portion of the tunnel to the bottom of the shaft, and thence may be raised by pumps or other suitable means to the top, and discharged into the sea. or disposed of in other ways. It will now be perceived that the space lying between the boring machinery and the shaft is left entirely free, excepting the small portion of it occupied by the two pipes—the pressure-water inlet pipe and the cream outlet pipe. The operation of lining the tunnel may therefore be carried on with the greatest facility, there being notraffic upon the rails, and no hoisting up or lowering in the shaft, except that necessary to transport the workmen and the building materials for lining the tunnel, amounting to only one-fifth of that required on the ordinary system: in other words four-fifths of the whole weight to be disposed of is carried through pipes, instead of by locomotives and trucks. A few details regarding the power required for the various operations, the size of inlet and outlet pipes, and other data in connection with the hydraulic machinery, may be interesting. Cutting the Clialk.—A Cutting Machine of the most simple construction will be used, for the purpose of excavating the chalk. As shown in Pigs. 2-6, Plates 83 and 84, designed for an 8-ft. heading, it consists of a number of small discs L, placed at an angle, and attached to a large boring head M, made to revolve at any given speed. Each cutting disc removes at each revolution a concentric ring from the face of the chalk, of 1/16 in. or any other required thickness, and of a width equal to one-fourth of the diameter of the disc ; and the discs are arranged to follow each other in such a manner that while they are all continuously in action, yet none has ever more to remove than its apportioned width and thickness of cut. The disc-spindles, Fig. 6, Plate 84, turn freely in their sockets, and as the discs cut only a width about one-quarter of their diameter,
141
AUGUST 1882.
CHANNEL TUNNEL.
445
they turn in an opposite direction to that in which the large disc or head M revolves, and act by rolling into the chalk. The cutting edge is thus changed continually, whereby the wear and tear of the edges is reduced to a minimum; and at the same time they do not require sharpening, a most material feature. I have cut with a similar machine at the rate of 5 yards forward per hour, without injury to the cutters. By trials I have ascertained that 2 HP. per cubic yard of chalk excavated per hour would be more than ample power ; hence if, in piercing a tunnel 36 feet in diameter, 170 cubic yards of chalk per hour have to be cut down, 340 HP. will be necessary for this part of the work. The pressure of the incoming water upon the area of the telescopic joint on the one hand, and the back pressure of the cream, forced towards the exit, on the other, will always push the machine forward automatically; and it becomes necessary to provide an arrangement to control this speed, and allow the machine to advance only at the desired speed. There are various simple means of effecting this object: that shown is by screw gear and pinion, working into a rack. To cut a clear face 36 feet in diameter will require 72 12-inch cutting discs fixed upon the arms or cross-beams, each cutter in one revolution of the machine taking off a concentric ring 3 inches in width, and1/16of an inch thick. Supposing the head M to turn at the rate of 10 revolutions per minute, this would give the outside cutter a periphery speed of 1130 feet per minute, which has been found to be well within practical limits. It will be understood that the cutters turn at different speeds, those near the outer periphery doing considerably more work than those near the centre. With chalk the revolving cutters are found to be equally effective at all speeds. The sleepers on which the machine slides or runs, and the rack by which its advance is regulated, are made in pieces of convenient length ; and as the last piece of the set is left behind, it is continually shifted forward and put down in front. This is effected (see the cross-section, Pig. 5, Plate 84) by means of two arms N N, Figs. 3 and 5, mounted in a line with the main shaft in rear of the machine. These arms are lowered, and bolted to the cross-sleeper P, which has attached 2 N2
142
446
CHANNEL TUNNEL.
AUGUST 1882.
to it lengths of the rails R and rack S. By means of a small hydraulic engine or other means the arms with the sleeper are made to revolve and lifted into the higher position, where they deposit the sleeper &c. on two small carriages T T, running on rollers upon girders Z. These carriages have hooked brackets, as shown, on which the pieces of rail are caught and rest. The arms are then unbolted, and the carriages, with the sleeper &c. upon them, are pushed by hand, or run by gravitation, along the girders Z to the front of the machine, where the sleeper &c. is picked up by exactly similar arms or levers, and brought down and deposited in its place at the bottom of the heading. The girders, with the carriages upon them, can be traversed endways through a short distance, so as to be out of the way while the sleeper is being raised or lcwered. Reduction of the Chalk debris to Sludge or Cream.—Some years since it became necessary for me to design an apparatus which in a small compass could produce large quantities of chalk-cream, such as is used in all cement works. The apparatus, which has been long in operation, is a plain cylindrical drum, 4 feet in diameter, and 2 feet 8 inches long inside, revolving at the rate of 32 revolutions per minute. One face of this drum is made of a strong wire grating, except in the centre, where a hole of 15 inches diameter is left. Through this central aperture the chalk debris and the water, in whatever quantities may be required, are introduced, and as the drum revolves, the particles of chalk, saturated and softened by contact with the water, are quickly dissolved; a cream or sludge, of more or less consistency, is thus produced, which escapes through the meshes of the wire grating and collects in a reservoir. It is then taken up by a pump, and forced to any place required. In this small apparatus a quantity of chalk debris, amounting to 14 cubic yards, or 21 tons, was reduced to cream within one hour. Fig. 2, Plate 83, shows a drum of the dimensions first given, placed in an 8-foot tunnel, a space considerably larger than is necessary to contain it. It will be a simple question of proportion to determine the size of the cylindrical drums capable of reducing
143
AUGUST 1882.
CHANNEL TUNXEL.
447
the 170 cubic yards of chalk debris per hour, resulting from the cutting of a tunnel 36 feet in diameter. As a