Alphonse de Châteaubriant: Catholic Collaborator
Kay Chadwick
PETER LANG
Alphonse de Châteaubriant: Catholic Collaborator
Modern French Identities Edited by Peter Collier
Volume 14
PETER LANG Oxford • Bern • Berlin • Bruxelles • Frankfurt a.M. • New York • Wien
Kay Chadwick
Alphonse de Châteaubriant: Catholic Collaborator
PETER LANG Oxford • Bern • Berlin • Bruxelles • Frankfurt a.M. • New York • Wien
Die Deutsche Bibliothek – CIP-Einheitsaufnahme Chadwick, Kay: Alphonse de Châteaubriant: catholic collaborator / Kay Chadwick. – Oxford ; Bern ; Berlin ; Bruxelles ; Frankfurt a.M. ; New York ; Wien : Lang, 2002 (Modern French Identities ; Vol. 14) ISBN 3-906766-94-2 British Library and Library of Congress Cataloguing-in-Publication Data: A catalogue record for this book is available from The British Library, Great Britain, and from The Library of Congress, USA
ISSN 1422-9005 ISBN 3-906766-94-2 US-ISBN 0-8204-5610-1
© Peter Lang AG, European Academic Publishers, Bern 2002 Jupiterstr. 15, Postfach, 3000 Bern 15, Switzerland
[email protected], www.peterlang.com, www.peterlang.net All rights reserved. All parts of this publication are protected by copyright. Any utilisation outside the strict limits of the copyright law, without the permission of the publisher, is forbidden and liable to prosecution. This applies in particular to reproductions, translations, microfilming, and storage and processing in electronic retrieval systems. Printed in Germany
‘The past is not dead. It’s not even past.’ William Faulkner
Contents
Acknowledgements Abbreviations
9 11
Introduction
13
1
Out of the Catholic Humus
21
2
A Collaborator in Waiting
47
3
The Quest for a New Christendom
73
4
Gesta Dei per Germanos
105
5
La France devant la collaboration
147
6
Liberation and the New Europe
195
7
Châteaubriant and the (Re)Writing of History
241
Conclusion
281
Bibliography Index
285 311
This page intentionally left blank
Acknowledgements
Thanks are due to the librarians and curators at the following institutions in Paris, without whose interest and assistance this book could not have been written: the Archives Nationales; the Bibliothèque nationale de France (Tolbiac and Richelieu sites); the Bibliothèque de Documentation Internationale Contemporaine at the Université de Nanterre; the Centre de Documentation Juive Contemporaine; the Institut Catholique; and the Institut d’Histoire du Temps Présent. I would also like to thank the Ministère de la Culture in Paris, for permission to reproduce the photograph of Alphonse de Châteaubriant; the University of Liverpool, for a period of study leave which enabled me to complete the majority of the manuscript; the editorial team at Peter Lang, for their assistance throughout the publication process; David Curtis, for his long-standing support; John Flower, for his interest and helpful interventions; friends and family who have lived through the project with me; and finally, Tim Unwin, whose incisive comments have benefited the final book, and whose encouragement is much appreciated. All previously published materials (see Bibliography) have been reworked and updated in the light of subsequent research. All errors remain my own.
This page intentionally left blank
Abbreviations
Throughout this book, the abbreviations given below are used to identify quotations from Alphonse de Châteaubriant’s writings. Where an unbroken series of quotations from the same text occurs, the abbreviation is given only after the first reference, and all subsequent immediate references give the page number alone. All other abbreviations used are explained on their first appearance. Unless otherwise stated, the place of publication is Paris for books in French and London for books in English. AI BC C FC GF
L’Acte intérieur Bulletin Collaboration Cahiers, 1906–1951 Fragments d’une confession La Gerbe des forces (Nouvelle Allemagne) ILD Itinéraire vers la lumière divine IPB Instantanés aux Pays-Bas LAG Lettres des années de guerre, 1914–1918
LB La Brière LCM Lettre à la chrétienté mourante LG La Gerbe LM La Meute ML Monsieur des Lourdines PC Les Pas ont chanté PPV Procès posthume d’un visionnaire RS La Réponse du Seigneur UA L’Un et l’autre
This page intentionally left blank
Introduction
On 25 October 1948, at the Cour de Justice in Paris, Alphonse de Châteaubriant (1877–1951) was tried in his absence on a charge of treason based on his wartime collaboration with Germany. The verdict of guilty on all counts was delivered before the end of the day, and Châteaubriant was sentenced to death and dégradation nationale in accordance with article 75.5 of the French Penal Code.1 But the death sentence was never carried out, for Châteaubriant had escaped France for Germany in July 1944, before moving on to Kitzbühel in Austria during April 1945, where he lived in exile under an assumed name until his death on 2 May 1951. That day marked the end of a life lived largely in the public eye as a writer and journalist, distinguished in its early years by his first two novels – Monsieur des Lourdines (1911), which won the prestigious Prix Goncourt, and La Brière (1923), which was awarded the Grand Prix du Roman de l’Académie française – but better known at its end for the infamous collaborationist essay La Gerbe des forces (1937) and the equally ignominious collaborationist newspaper La Gerbe, published weekly throughout the Occupation, of which Châteaubriant had been director. The question of what makes a collaborator has continually occupied minds and energies since Jean-Paul Sartre first famously
1
Dossier de la Cour de Seine: van Brédenbec de Châteaubriant, Alphonse (Archives nationales, Z6 402 no. 41,30), hereafter referred to as Dossier Châteaubriant. Article 75.5 of the French Penal Code stipulates that ‘sera coupable de trahison et puni de mort, tout Français qui, en temps de guerre, entretiendra des intelligences avec une puissance étrangère ou avec ses agents, en vue de favoriser les entreprises de cette puissance contre la France’ (Code pénal, livre III, chapitre premier; décret-loi du 29 juillet 1939).
asked ‘Qu’est-ce qu’un collaborateur?’ in August 1945.2 With the war in Europe only recently at an end, Sartre’s study of ‘le personnel de la collaboration’ paints a disturbing picture of the collaborator as ‘un ennemi que les sociétés démocratiques portent perpétuellement en leur sein’ (p. 60), but whose tendencies will lie dormant until awakened in times of crisis, as during the Second World War.3 Collaboration is located within an existentialist framework of freedom, choice and responsibility which suggests that ‘on ne collabore pas par hasard mais sous l’action de certaines lois sociales et psychologiques’ (p. 44), and which holds that collaboration is ‘une décision individuelle’ (p. 46). Motivated by environment and character, and thus neither aberration nor deviation, the decision to collaborate is made in complete freedom, and the resultant words and deeds remain the responsibility of the individual, and the means by which he or she may be judged. With this in mind, the aim of this book is to analyse the motivation for Alphonse de Châteaubriant’s collaboration and to examine the true nature and extent of words and deeds which serve to condemn him as a diehard racist, a prominent and idiosyncratic collaborator, and a clear-cut traitor. To date, the truth of Châteaubriant’s thought and career has been lost beneath the elementary and fragmentary character sketches employed in numerous histories of the Second World War and collaboration, or – worse still – beneath a sympathetic, ‘sanitised’ version promoted by his negationist assessors particularly since his death. A fully documented and proper elucidation of Châteaubriant’s complex behaviour is therefore essential, if explanation is to overturn justification, if truth is to prevail over whitewash and denial, and if his story is to be accurately and adequately written within the broader history of modern France. 2 3
14
Jean-Paul Sartre, ‘Qu’est-ce qu’un collaborateur?’, in Situations, III (Gallimard, 1949), pp. 43–61. It is clear from the text of the essay that Sartre’s main focus is the collaborationist personalities such as Drieu la Rochelle, Déat, Darnand, and Châteaubriant himself, rather than ordinary French people who may have collaborated.
History judges Châteaubriant a minor collaborator in contrast to such luminaries as Robert Brasillach and Pierre Drieu la Rochelle, although that verdict seems to result more from the absence rather than the existence of any post-war in-depth study of his case. This lack of detailed critical analysis has contributed to the construction and maintenance of a simplistic ‘Châteaubriant myth’, that of a bearded, prophet-like figure whose allocation of religious credentials to National Socialism forms the basis for his swift dismissal on the grounds of religious and political naïvety and instability, and whose collaboration is deemed an aberration in his career. Study of what others say about Châteaubriant reveals little of substance and little variation from the myth. His collaborationist contemporaries set the tone with their post-war categorisation of him as ‘romantique et mystique’,4 or their mockery of his religious fervour.5 Later historians draw on these character sketches in their portrayal of Châteaubriant as a ‘prophète’ and ‘mystique barbichu’,6 or as ‘a fervent Nazi, a champion of collaboration and an admirer of Hitler’,7 or else as an ‘admirateur fanatique du nazisme et homme de confiance des Allemands’,8 or, most dismissively, as a man who held ‘a quasimystical, if not crackpot, vision of Nazism’.9 It is rightly (although rarely) suggested that he believed in ‘la parfaite compatibilité du nazisme et du christianisme’, but this is insufficiently explained in its
4 5 6 7 8 9
Marcel Déat, Mémoires politiques (Denoël, 1989), p. 633. Lucien Rebatet, Mémoires d’un fasciste, 2 vols (Pauvert, 1976), p. 96. Pascal Ory, ‘Sept hauts lieux de la collaboration’, L’Histoire, 80 (1985), 80–81 (p. 81). Patrick Marsh, ‘The Theatre: Compromise or Collaboration?’, in Collaboration in France: Politics and Culture during the Nazi Occupation 1940–44, ed. by Gerhard Hirschfeld and Patrick Marsh (Oxford: Berg, 1989), pp. 142–61 (p. 155). Henry Rousso, La Collaboration. Les Noms, les thèmes, les lieux (Éditions MA, 1987), p. 67. David Pryce-Jones, Paris in the Third Reich: A History of the German Occupation 1940–1944 (Collins, 1981), p. 51.
15
ascription to ‘une sorte de perversion mystique’.10 His collaboration is weakly defined as ‘un certain type de collaborationnisme de passion’,11 while his intervention in politics is simply described elsewhere as ‘incompréhensible’.12 Many of these references, included as they are in general studies of the period, betray a simple lack of knowledge and are not intended deliberately to mislead. But such unfamiliarity with Châteaubriant’s profile on the part of some is matched more worryingly by sympathy and discretion on the part of others, as is the case with the only monograph on Châteaubriant published to date which – despite its title – continually emphasises his spiritual persona and plays down his political ideas and activities, resulting in a negligent, partial study which whitewashes its subject.13 Study of what Alphonse de Châteaubriant himself says and does not only reveals an altogether different portrait of the man as collaborator, but also indicates that the impetus behind his collaboration can be cogently elucidated. Châteaubriant was motivated throughout his life by his Christianity. His words and deeds prove not only that he collaborated because he was a Catholic, but also that he was a collaborator in waiting as early as 1918 rather than – like many others – a 1930s convert to the National-Socialist cause. His origins cannot be divorced from his later thought and activity. He was born and brought up in the conventional Catholic provincial gentry in a young and rapidly evolving Third Republic. His early writings are littered with anti-modern, anti-Revolutionary, anti-capitalist, anti-liberal, antiindividualist and pro-organicist themes which indicate that his roots lay in an intransigent Catholicism. Of course, many contemporary 10 11 12 13
16
Paul Christophe, 1939–1940. Les Catholiques devant la guerre (Les Éditions ouvrières, 1989), p. 51; see also William Halls, Politics, Society and Christianity in Vichy France (Oxford: Berg, 1995), p. 345. Henri Amouroux, La Grande Histoire des Français sous l’occupation, 10 vols (Laffont, 1976–93), III (1978), 213. Paul Sérant, Le Romantisme fasciste (Fayard, 1959), p. 122. Louis-Alphonse Maugendre, Alphonse de Châteaubriant 1877–1951: dossier littéraire et politique (André Bonne, 1977).
Right-wing Catholics shared this mentality, and the real interest of Châteaubriant’s case lies less in that mentality per se than in the development and expression of his Catholic convictions in response to the events and evolution of the modern world. Disappointed with what he saw as the sterility and weakness of popular, institutional Catholicism, Châteaubriant looked outside the Church for a fresh approach to Christianity (a nouvelle chrétienté, or a New Christendom, a common quest among Catholics from the 1920s), and advocated complete spiritual renewal and regeneration through the rediscovery and reactivation of medieval values. The feudal, pre-capitalist Germany he saw matched his Christian requirements, for he viewed Hitler as a spiritually guided leader and the National Socialists as an elite group of reborn heroic warriors who would re-evangelise a newly unified Europe, rid of its agents of dechristianisation (the Bolshevists and the Jews) and in which the French would play a significant role, associated with the Germans on the grounds of race. Châteaubriant’s spiritualisation of politics resulted in his unconventional reception of National Socialism as the concrete incarnation of his desired brand of nouvelle chrétienté, and culminated in his collaboration with Germany during the Second World War. Châteaubriant’s collaboration was therefore in no way a sudden aberration from his own convictions, but was rooted instead in his long-standing interpretation of Christianity. Fascism played little, if any, role in his commitment.14 Far from being the mystical, otherworldly figure generally portrayed, Alphonse de Châteaubriant was in reality a militant and resolute collaborator. He was active and well known in major 14
It is possible to identify in Châteaubriant many of the Fascist preoccupations which motivated the collaboration of other contemporary intellectuals, as will be seen later. However, the prominence of such themes in his thought does not provide conclusive evidence that Châteaubriant was a Fascist, if only because many of these themes were shared by other Right-wing Catholics who were conservative and not Fascist (for example, Robert d’Harcourt and Louis Bertrand). Collaboration cannot be defined by adherence to or sympathy for Fascism, as Sartre argues (Qu’est-ce qu’un collaborateur?, p. 44).
17
collaborationist circles, as witnessed by his directorship of La Gerbe and his frequent contributions to its columns, as well as by his presidency of the Groupe Collaboration, formed in September 1940, and his regular participation in its lecture programme.15 He served on the central and honorary committees of a range of wartime organisations, such as the Légion des volontaires français contre le bolchevisme, set up in July 1941 and whose troops fought in Russia for the German cause;16 Marcel Déat’s Front révolutionnaire national, founded in September 1942 with a view to unifying the collaborationist camp;17 and the Cercle européen, otherwise known as the Cercle de collaboration économique européenne.18 He was a member of the Institut d’études des questions juives which organised the exhibition ‘Le Juif et la France’ staged in Paris in September 1941; and he openly condoned the anti-Semitic Comité pour l’épuration de la race française.19 He sympathised with Joseph Darnand’s Milice française, created in January 1943 to guarantee internal order.20 Through La Gerbe, Châteaubriant came into contact with writers such as Brasillach, Drieu la Rochelle, Céline and Rebatet. He corresponded with Jacques Doriot, leader of the Parti populaire français, and contributed articles to his collaborationist newspaper Le Cri du peuple.21 He knew many leading members of the Vichy government, including the Head of State, Philippe Pétain; Premiers Pierre Laval and François Darlan; Philippe Henriot, named Minister of Information and Propaganda in January 1944; and Fernand de Brinon, Vichy’s Ambassador to the German occupier. He also knew and socialised with influential 15 16 17 18 19 20 21
18
See the bibliography for details of Châteaubriant’s articles in La Gerbe and his lectures for the Groupe Collaboration. Dossier Châteaubriant. Henry Coston, Partis, journaux et hommes politiques d’hier et d’aujourd’hui, special number of Lectures françaises, December 1960, p. 148. Dossier Châteaubriant. Ibid. ‘L’Heure de la Milice’, Collaboration, March–April 1943, p. 19. Articles by Châteaubriant are published in Le Cri du peuple on 19 October 1940, 29 January 1942, 18 February 1943, 26 March 1943.
Germans in Paris, including Otto Abetz, the Reich’s Ambassador to France, and Karl Epting, director of the Institut allemand in Paris. He was a ‘name’ of use to the Germans and evidently allowed his name to be used. He spoke on Radio-Paris,22 a propaganda vehicle controlled by the Germans, regularly attended German Embassy parties, and even operated officially for the Germans, working on the translation committee based at the Institut allemand.23 There can be no doubt that Châteaubriant acted in a political sense during the Occupation. He was not an opportunistic collaborator, but rather one of vocation. He co-operated willingly and extensively with the Germans, and freely condoned and became increasingly actively engaged in those organisations in which he saw his preferred form of politics. He knew both what these groups stood for as well as the full nature of their activity, and he did not stray from his chosen path throughout the war. Châteaubriant’s spiritualisation of politics may have been eccentric, but it was neither naïve nor harmless, as his attitudes and activities prove. His life and this book serve to illustrate the very dangerous pathway down which idealism can lead.
22 23
See the bibliography for details of Châteaubriant’s wartime radio broadcasts. Dossier Châteaubriant.
19
This page intentionally left blank
1 Out of the Catholic Humus Roots and influences Alphonse de Châteaubriant was born in 1877, a year of political import which culminated in the crushing defeat of the Right by the Republicans in the October general election. Victory for the Republicans marked the beginning of the end of the conservative Dukes’ Republic (1873–77), headed by Marshal de MacMahon, which had aimed to restore a monarchy to France, and heralded the foundation of the Republicans’ Republic (1879–85), in which men such as Léon Gambetta and Jules Ferry would shine. Châteaubriant’s early years coincided with the establishment of some of the principal features of the Third Republic, many of which claimed their source in the Revolutionary tradition. Parliamentary democracy emerged to dominate the political stage; the Republicans swiftly extended their power-base to both local and Senate level; and the State set out to formulate and inculcate a Republican identity to challenge and replace the Catholic Church’s authority and influence with its own. For the Church, the Third Republic was synonymous with hostility and godlessness. The modern and ‘godless’ times in which Châteaubriant lived had grown out of the 1789 Revolution and developed over the course of the nineteenth century, sweeping aside many of France’s traditional structures and principles, including those upheld by the Church. The end of the Ancien Régime, and the accompanying decline in the power of the conservative aristocracy, which rested on tradition, hierarchy and order, was matched by the growth of new political forces based on democratic and liberal principles, which had an impact particularly in the second half of the nineteenth century. The period also witnessed radical industrial and social change: rapidly increasing industrialisation brought a rural
exodus and a concomitant spread of urban civilisation, while the material advances of the Industrial Revolution modernised society and offered the prospect of expansion, wealth and improved quality of life. At the same time, scientific progress had profound effects on intellectual life. Scientisme (an unqualified admiration for science combined with the belief that science was a powerful force for good) suggested that science alone represented ‘truth’ and ‘progress’, and was therefore the only legitimate way to understand the world, while religion was deemed incompatible with the scientific approach to life on the grounds that it was not based on ‘genuine’, scientifically proven knowledge. As the nineteenth century progressed, the Catholic Church came to be, in Robert Tombs’s words, ‘politically discredited as the apologist for reaction at home and abroad, and intellectually discredited as the pedlar of obscurantism and popular superstition’.1 With the prize of the government of minds in its sights, the Third Republic set out to supplant the Church by founding a Republican ‘religion’ which promoted scientific rationalism, national unity, progressive and reformist political attitudes, and a new secular morality divorced from religion and based instead on civic duty and responsibility. In the struggle for influence, instituteur and maire – representatives par excellence of the Republic – were pitched against curé and notable. The Republic created its own festivals and quasi-religious symbols to rival and replace those of the Church; public religious ceremonies were sometimes disrupted, and priests were often harassed as they went about their religious business.2 Republicanism’s supreme incarnation was Jules Ferry’s secular école de la République (otherwise labelled the école sans Dieu), the Third Republic’s own ‘church’ and training-ground for the citizens of the future, and easily the most controversial vehicle in the ideological battle for the hearts and minds of France, attacked by 1 2
22
Robert Tombs, France 1814–1914 (Harlow: Longman, 1996), p. 134. See ibid., pp. 138–42, for these and other details of the establishment and consolidation of Republican identity.
the Church as an école sans foi.3 By 1882, instruction morale et civique had replaced instruction morale et religieuse, and the Republicans’ Republic had marked its arrival by designating the previously banned Marseillaise as the national anthem (1879), and 14 July – a date of Revolutionary significance – as the national holiday (1880). A minority of ‘liberal’ Catholics refused to condemn the Third Republic unreservedly, arguing that ‘l’Église devait s’accommoder du “régime moderne” et relever le défi des anticléricaux qui reprochaient aux catholiques de n’être “ni de leur temps, ni de leur pays”’.4 But most Catholics, whether Church representatives or lay members, were intransigent in their rejection of the Third Republic and the modern world which had spawned it, believing that there could be no possible compromise between ‘les deux puissances […] en lutte dans le monde moderne, la Révélation et la Révolution’.5 Born with the Revolution, intransigent Catholicism upheld traditional and corporatist ideas, based as it was on ‘un refus total de la société née de la Renaissance, de la Réforme et de la Révolution, dominée par l’individualisme et le rationalisme, la sécularisation de l’État, des sciences et de la pensée’,6 and took its lead in this from the Syllabus of Errors, published by Pius IX in 1864, which had rejected the view that the Church should ‘become reconciled with and compromise with progress, liberalism and modern civilisation’.7 In listing its quarrels with the modern world and restating traditional principles, the Syllabus encapsulated the tone of Pius IX’s long pontificate (1846–78). But with the appointment of Leo XIII (1878–1903) as his successor, the Church shifted from a 3 4 5 6 7
An excellent analysis of the Third Republic’s secularisation of state education can be found in Mona Ozouf, L’École, l’Église et la République 1871–1914, 2nd edn (Seuil, 1982 [1963]). Jean-Marie Mayeur, Catholicisme social et démocratie moderne: principes romains, expériences françaises (Cerf, 1986), p. 20. Yvon Tranvouez, Catholiques d’abord: approches du mouvement catholique en France (XIXème–XXème siècle) (Les Éditions ouvrières, 1988), p. 44. Mayeur, Catholicisme social, p. 20. Pius IX, Syllabus of Errors (James Miller, 1864), proposition 80.
23
passive to an active condemnation of the modern world. Based on the content of two encyclicals – Aeterni patris (1879), which called in neoThomist terms for the restoration of a Christian civilisation in the modern world, and the more widely known Rerum novarum (1891), which dealt with the condition of workers in modern, capitalist society – Leo XIII is credited as the architect of ‘un catholicisme intégral, déterminé à investir la société pour en reprendre la tête’.8 Integral Catholicism represented the foundation of a Social Catholicism, which called Catholics to social action and cast Leo XIII as ‘le pape de la mobilisation des forces catholiques pour la reconstruction d’une société chrétienne sur [l]es ruines de la modernité’ (ibid.). Aeterni patris and Rerum novarum together embodied a means of modernisation for Catholicism and a concrete illustration of a refusal to accept the marginalisation of the Church within an increasingly secular society. Many Catholics wanted to see the implementation of a Catholic social doctrine which would reconstruct a Christian society based on traditional principles. But there was no general agreement on how this might be achieved, and, as Yvon Tranvouez notes: Une cassure fondamentale s’est produite entre sociaux et démocrates, entre tenants de l’esprit ‘hiératique’ et adeptes de l’esprit ‘progressif’, entre ceux pour qui le peuple restait l’objet d’un dévouement et ceux pour qui il devait être le sujet de la rénovation sociale. (ibid.)9
Further divisions followed in 1892 when Leo XIII, keen to end his diplomatic isolation in Europe, published the encyclical Inter sollicitudines, in which he urged Catholics to accept the Republic and to work within its system, but also to strive by all lawful means to change its legislation. The Ralliement, as it was known, divided Catholic opinion. Obedience to the Pope dictated the response of some. At one extreme, however, it found a small but sympathetic audience among Catholics keen for accommodation, who wanted to turn the 8 9
24
Tranvouez, Catholiques d’abord, p. 79. The italics are the author’s.
Republic into an honest and Christian regime. At the other extreme, it also outraged those many Catholics for whom the Republic was obdurately anticlerical, as evidenced by its action against the Church which had permeated the previous decade. Their opinion of the Republic was subsequently entrenched by their interpretation of the Dreyfus Affair (1894–99), a ‘moral, ideological and political crusade’10 whose importance far transcended the fate of Dreyfus himself to score deep divisions between intransigents of Left and Right and threaten the very survival of the Republic. For the Dreyfusards (mainly Republicans), the Affair encapsulated the struggle against reaction, as symbolised by the Church, the aristocracy and the army; while, for the anti-Dreyfusards (mainly anti-Republicans), it was a struggle against forces which threatened national unity and national institutions (again, Church and army), fuelled by an anti-Semitic paranoia which was fostered particularly by Édouard Drumont’s La France juive (1886). By the end of the nineteenth century, it had become common to speak of les deux France, one Catholic, one Republican, which opposed ‘two ideologies, two political cultures, two traditions, two histories, two patriotisms’.11 As the twentieth century began, Church–State relations disintegrated further during the anticlerical Bloc des Gauches. Eager to resolve the Church question once and for all, the Government moved relentlessly towards the formal separation of Churches and State, which finally passed into law on 9 December 1905, thereby abrogating the 1801 Concordat which had recognised Catholicism as the religion of the great majority of French people. In 1905 Third Republic France completed the creation of its secular morality. In 1905, at the age of twenty-eight, Alphonse de Châteaubriant was beginning to establish himself as a writer. His first published piece 10 11
Tombs, France 1814–1914, p. 144. A full account of the Dreyfus Affair can be found in Eric Cahm, The Dreyfus Affair in French Society and Politics (Harlow: Longman, 1996). Tombs, France 1814–1914, p. 145.
25
had appeared in 1898, and subsequent years saw the publication of a series of poems and short stories primarily in provincial journals such as La Revue nantaise, La Revue de l’Anjou and La Revue du Bas-Poitou, but also – from 1904 – in well-known Parisian journals such as La Revue de Paris, La Revue bleue and La Revue des poètes.12 Growing recognition of his literary ability led to the opportunity to join the editorial team at the weekly Chroniqueur de Paris. This prompted a move to the capital in 1903,13 the year of his marriage to Marguerite Bachelot-Villeneuve, the daughter of a well-to-do family from Piriac, near Saint-Nazaire, which had long-established connections with the navy and the law. But Châteaubriant never felt settled in Paris. Truly the homme de terroir, he spent increasingly lengthy periods of time in Brittany (where his two sons, Guy and Robert, were born in 1904 and 1906), either at his marital home, Le Petit Portail, near Nantes, or else in the Brière region where, as his Cahiers 1906–1951 (1955) reveal, he travelled and gathered notes for an early version of his second full-length novel, La Brière (1923) (C, pp. 11–55). A Breton by origin, Châteaubriant was born near Rennes into a Catholic family of prosperous gentilshommes campagnards, in a world far removed from the Republicans’ Republic. The tensions and crises of the Third Republic meant that his childhood and formative years coincided with significant events which would have far-reaching consequences for modern France, and his roots in the provincial Catholic humus operated both to influence his response to his environment and to mould him into the man he became. In 1879, when Châteaubriant was just two years old, the family moved to Nantes. Here he was educated privately rather than in Ferry’s newly established secular école de la République, attending the Catholic Externat des enfants nantais from 1883 to 1891, and the Catholic lycée in Nantes, 12 13
26
See the bibliography for details of these publications, which concentrate on natural themes and thereby bear out Châteaubriant’s self-portrait as a ‘chasseur des paysages’ (Instantanés aux Pays-Bas, 1906, p. 8). Frédéric Lefèvre, ‘Une heure avec Alphonse de Châteaubriant’, Les Nouvelles littéraires, artistiques et scientifiques, 37 (1923), 1–2.
where he passed the two-part examination for the baccalauréat de lettres in 1894 and 1895. By all accounts, Châteaubriant was a competent if not outstanding student, achieving mention assez bien for the bac overall and winning prizes for French composition and philosophy. After an similarly adequate year in rhétorique supérieure, and like many others of his class and education, he embarked on a preparatory course for entry to Saint-Cyr military college (near Versailles) and the army career expected by his father. But studying for Saint-Cyr failed to capture Châteaubriant’s interest, and he would regularly miss classes in order to explore the surrounding countryside, as he admits in his autobiographical work Les Pas ont chanté (1938, pp. 99–100). Not surprisingly, he failed the entrance examination for Saint-Cyr, and carried out his military service as an ordinary soldier, serving in the thirteenth army division based in Chartres between September 1898 and November 1900.14 Châteaubriant’s religious, regional and class origins represent significant formative influences in his life. Les Pas ont chanté recalls such features of a traditional Catholic upbringing as learning the catechism around the age of six (p. 43), studying Bible stories (pp. 53–54), and attending mass each Sunday where he acted as an altar boy (pp. 61– 63). His confirmation and first communion also took place at the conventional age of eleven in June 1888. His was an education based on instruction morale et religieuse, which made consistent reference to the teachings of the Church, offered a conservative reading of the modern world and rejected the ideals of the Third Republic. In terms of his regional origins, Châteaubriant acknowledges the formative effect of milieu, writing in a June 1931 entry in his diaries that: On ne peut guère se faire une idée des complexes commencements qui sont à l’origine de la personnalité et de l’œuvre d’un poète, si l’on ne sait en quel pays de la terre il a vécu ses premiers jours […]. Ce n’est pas l’homme qui fait le pays, c’est le pays qui fait l’homme. (C, p. 105, p. 106) 14
See Maugendre, Alphonse de Châteaubriant, Chapter 1, for details of Châteaubriant’s early life.
27
His descriptions of his native and family regions of Brittany and the Vendée, both provinces classified as predominantly practising Catholic,15 confirm the influence of his source environment. Châtelet, his childhood home in Brittany, is described as a place of ‘déterminisme divin [qui] influençait nos esprits’ (PC, p. 56), while his preface to La Meute (1927) evokes the Vendée as a ‘terre maternelle, qui me donna mon premier fourrage’ (p. 16). Provincial and family roots are enduringly interdependent, as suggested by Châteaubriant’s description of the family’s château, Mothe-Saint-Sulpice, near Fontenay-le-Comte in the Vendée as: […] la vieille commanderie à quatre tours dans laquelle est né mon père et où j’ai été amené enfant. C’est là que s’élève l’antique berceau qui échut dans notre patrimoine par ma grand-mère, dernière héritière des vieux marquis de SaintSulpice. (LM, p. 18)
As a child, Châteaubriant was captivated by stories of his family’s past, especially those relating to his paternal grandfather, Gaspard de Châteaubriant (1795–1880), who had left Louis XVIII’s service around 1822 in order to settle on his wife’s estate at Mothe-SaintSulpice, thereby becoming a gentilhomme campagnard (p. 21). A gentilhomme campagnard is generally defined as ‘[quelqu’un] de petite noblesse qui vit sur ses terres’,16 although Châteaubriant provides his own fuller interpretation which immediately marks him out as an antiRevolutionary and indicates that his own reading of his class origin represents an important starting-point for an understanding of his evolution. The term, he writes, not only suggests communion with and dependence on the land, but also incorporates a sense of ‘noblesse’, and signifies ‘tout un complexe social, qui n’existe plus de nos jours’ (C, pp. 67–68). This complexe social is based on mutual duty between seigneur and serviteurs, itself the primary element in what 15 16
28
Roger Price, A Social History of Nineteenth-Century France (Hutchinson, 1987), pp. 288–89. Le Nouveau Petit Robert (Dictionnaires Le Robert, 1996), p. 1013, p. 1094.
Châteaubriant calls ‘la cellule patriarcale […] dans le grand être rural qu’est la France, la féconde cellule qui nourrit tout l’organisme’ (p. 74). The sense of regret at the loss of this complexe social is strikingly communicated in several of Châteaubriant’s early works. The short stories Le Baron de Puydreau (1908), Monsieur de Buysse (1909) and La Meute (1927),17 along with the novel Monsieur des Lourdines (1911), all represent a fusion of regional, class and family influences through their portrayal of the ‘monde finissant’ (LM, p. 22) of the gentilshommes campagnards in Brittany or the Vendée, and their exploitation of events from his family’s past, particularly around the time of the Restoration.18 But neither this nor the immediate pre-Revolutionary period embodies the golden age of Châteaubriant’s gentilhomme campagnard. Châteaubriant is no admirer of the Ancien Régime and the modern state as created by Richelieu from the mid-1620s, then extended under Louis XIV from 1643 to 1715. Rather, he is opposed to the establishment of the Court as a fixed institution, since this promoted administrative centralisation and effectively uprooted the nobility from the provinces, undermining its status by making it dependent on the king’s royal favours for its existence rather than on its seigneurial position (C, p. 70). Châteaubriant’s true regret is the death of feudal society, which he locates in the mid-sixteenth century. This, he believes, irrevocably damaged the key values of mutual duty and solidarity between community and leader, which had fostered an 17
18
Although not published until 1927, at least a preliminary version of La Meute had been written by 1911, as Châteaubriant confirms in a letter to Romain Rolland, dated 13 August 1911 (L’Un et l’autre: correspondance entre Romain Rolland et Alphonse de Châteaubriant, 1906–14, Cahiers Romain Rolland, 26 (Albin Michel, 1983), p. 36). Page references are to the 1935 edition of La Meute, which includes the stories Le Baron de Puydreau and Monsieur de Buysse. The preface to La Meute (p. 19, pp. 27–28) indicates that the opposing political sympathies of Monsieur and Madame de Néris, and the killing of the pedigree dogs by a pack of local hounds are both true events from Gaspard de Châteaubriant’s life at Mothe-Saint-Sulpice. The violin-playing Timothée des Lourdines in Monsieur des Lourdines is also based on Gaspard de Châteaubriant (PC, p. 219).
29
organic definition of the nation as a living assemblage of ‘cellules naturelles, dont chacune réunit sa collectivité d’hommes, avec son noble au centre’ (p. 71), and a reading of the leader as ‘l’esprit qui régularise la circulation dans tout le corps de la communauté’ (p. 74).
The organic community: an ideal in embryo Châteaubriant’s promotion of the ‘organic’ features strongly in his early writings, where it represents an important indication of an embryonic theme, propagated in his Catholic origins, now in gestation, and awaiting the moment of its maturation in his encounter with Hitler’s Germany in the 1930s and 1940s. His short stories and first novel together introduced a substantial readership (no doubt augmented by the award of the Prix Goncourt) to his vision of an ideal community, one which was anti-modern, patriarchal and corporatist, anti-individualist and anti-capitalist, and which thereby betrays convictions typical of a late nineteenth-century intransigent Catholic mindset opposed to the France of the Revolution. Monsieur des Lourdines (1911), as its subtitle indicates, tells the ‘histoire d’un gentilhomme campagnard’ in the Poitou around 1840, opposing the threat of modern society – symbolised by Paris – with the benefits of patriarchal society as lived on Des Lourdines’s estate, Petit-Fougeray.19 Master and people are bound by mutual duty. Des Lourdines is ‘notre monsieur’ (p. 18), the orchestrator of the community, so harmonised to his environment that he and the estate ‘sortaient bien du même sol; ils étaient presque de la même couleur’ (p. 17). Des Lourdines is as devoted to his peasants as he is to the land: 19
30
Châteaubriant probably took the name Petit-Fougeray from a commune located twenty-five kilometres south of Rennes, his birth city. There is no real place of this name in the Poitou.
his right-hand man, Célestin, is not only his employee but also ‘son vieil ami’ (p. 19), and each evening he spends time in the kitchen with the estate’s workers. But the modern world invades this traditional, stable society in the form of the Des Lourdines’s son, Anthime. Two years before the story takes place, Anthime had left the family home for Paris following a quarrel with his parents over his racing and gambling debts, which his father had been forced to settle. His parents hope that he will return to take up his rightful place at Petit-Fougeray. Not surprisingly, however, Anthime has succumbed to the delights of life in the cosmopolitan capital. He has no desire to return to his roots and maintains little contact with his parents, thinking only of pleasure and spending more and more money. Anthime’s money-lender, Muller, finally writes to Monsieur des Lourdines to call in debts of 600,000 francs, thereby triggering the chain of events which leads to the sale of Petit-Fougeray and the death of Madame des Lourdines, killed by shock at the extent of her son’s debts. Anthime returns home to his mother’s deathbed, unaware of the reality of the situation. At PetitFougeray, Anthime is as dépaysé as his Russian greyhound, the symbol of his hedonistic life in Paris. His father finally announces that he has had to sell most of Anthime’s expected inheritance to settle the debts, and that their future income will be severely reduced. Anthime realises that he cannot return to Paris. He contemplates suicide, but is saved by the musical message of his father’s violin, and the rest of the novel deals with his reintegration into provincial life. Châteaubriant’s portrayal of the ideal community in Monsieur des Lourdines suggests a certain affinity of thought with two of the most influential Right-wing nationalist writers of the fin de siècle period, Maurice Barrès and Charles Maurras, who, from the early 1890s, employed their pens to formulate an assault on what they saw as the political and moral decline of the Third Republic, opposing this with a programme of integral nationalism. The reaction against decline was given momentum by the Boulanger crisis (1886–89), but their real stimulus was the Dreyfus Affair, which provided them with the 31
opportunity to promote an interpretation of the nation which was traditional, corporatist and xenophobic in inspiration, and which – in Maurras’s case – detached France from the Republic on the grounds that the Republic and grandeur were mutually exclusive. France, they argued, was a unique, self-sufficient nation, superior in culture and civilisation. The nation must be defended from non-French elements such as Jews, Freemasons, Protestants and ‘foreigners’, in other words, all those considered to lack the ancestral roots of the true French (in Barresian terms, the non-moi or the barbare). Catholicism was reconciled to this brand of patriotism: France, Barrès and Maurras declared, should remain Catholic, for Catholicism had always been the religion of the majority. But both allocated a primarily social role to the Catholic Church, seeing it principally as an instrument of social order and discipline, and therefore of institutional rather than religious importance. Indeed, Maurras himself was an avowed agnostic. Each was intent on the interests of the nation, although not always in defence of the same traditions. Barrès’s aspirations lay mainly in the moral domain, and focused on re-energising decadent France through the theory of la terre et les morts, ancestors and soil, which proclaimed cultural and racial rootedness as the essence of the nation. He dreamt of a charismatic, heroic leader who would form a mystical bond with the masses rather than just represent the interests of a privileged few. Maurras, however, viewed integral nationalism more in political terms, and focused on the need for appropriate institutions, advocating a social order similar to that of the Ancien Régime and calling for the restoration of the monarchy as the means to recover national grandeur. Both men tapped into a sympathetic audience of conservatives and traditionalists, among whom was Alphonse de Châteaubriant, whose intellectually formative years coincided with the genesis and development of integral nationalism in fin de siècle France.20 20
32
On Barrès and Maurras, see Zeev Sternhell, Maurice Barrès et le nationalisme français (Presses de La Fondation Nationale Scientifique, 1972), and Raoul Girardet, Le Nationalisme français, 1871–1914, 2nd edn (Seuil, 1983 [1966]).
Parallels can readily be drawn between Barrès, Maurras and Châteaubriant. The Petit-Fougeray estate in Monsieur des Lourdines appears as a hermetic, self-sufficient unit, and therefore a possible microcosm of an independent nation along the lines of Maurras’s ideal of la France seule. Anti-capitalism and anti-Semitism find their expression when capitalist, ‘foreign’ forces threaten the purity and survival of the organic ‘nation-estate’ (or pays réel, as opposed to pays légal, in Maurrassian terms) in the person of Muller, the money-lender, just as the Jews would later be seen by the Nazis as a threat to the purity of the German nation. As a ‘financier véreux’ (p. 86) and an ‘odieux exploiteur’ (p. 155), Muller can easily be read as a stereotyped representation of a Jew, one of Barrès’s non-moi, whose transient and destructive presence in the novel throws into sharp relief and threatens the enduring, rooted presence of the Des Lourdines family ‘qui naissait et mourait au Petit-Fougeray depuis des siècles’ (p. 17), and who illustrate perfectly Barrès’s theory of la terre et les morts. Where Muller is an archetypal Barresian non-moi by origin, Anthime is a classic Barresian déraciné. Barrès’s novel Les Déracinés (1897) extols integral nationalism and la terre et les morts in its portrayal of the dangers of physical and psychological déracinement. The novel focuses on the lives of seven young men from the Lorraine, whose move to Paris causes their lives to disintegrate to such an extent that, at one point, two of them brutally murder their friend Sturel’s foreign lover, Astiné. As a foreigner, Astiné represents the non-moi, and Sturel allows her killers to go free because they are fellow Lorrainers, thereby sacrificing the non-moi to the moi. In Monsieur des Lourdines, Anthime’s déracinement is symbolised by the uprooting and destruction of the healthy elm tree at the beginning of the novel (pp. 11–24), for, just as the tree has been cut off from its soil – the source of its nourishment – so Anthime has been separated from his ‘soil’, the organic community of Petit-Fougeray. His loss of his roots entails the loss of his community identity, and he becomes a mere individual who is no longer part of a corporate group (p. 220), thereby aptly illustrating Châteaubriant’s organicist and anti-individualist tendencies. The 33
harmful effects of Anthime’s déracinement are evident. He joins the ranks of the non-moi and, alongside Muller, becomes instrumental in the destruction of traditional life at Petit-Fougeray, for it is the financial ruin which he brings that causes the sale of the land and fragments the estate. Barrès believed that France was morally decadent, ‘dissociée et décérébrée’,21 and that resurrection was only possible if the nation returned to its roots. Anthime’s life has made him into a hedonistic dandy, a decadent ‘hero’ in the manner of Huysmans’s Des Esseintes (A rebours, 1884), and he seems to lack the vitality which Barrès regarded as necessary for moral regeneration. But Châteaubriant offers hope of redemption, for he hints that Anthime’s roots have not been totally destroyed, since ‘à son insu, le chasseur campagnard n’était pas en lui complètement mort’ (p. 157), so indicating the possibility of an appropriate and salutary ‘reawakening’ process. Indeed, the fact that Anthime is saved from suicide and reintegrates into provincial life at the end of the novel (an outcome of which Barrès would approve), is to be read as the reaffirmation of rootedness and thus as a victory over modern and ‘foreign’ influences, this despite the loss of PetitFougeray. The theme of leadership as handled by Châteaubriant suggests parallels with the Barresian notion of the chef rather than with Maurras’s call to restore the monarchy, and foreshadows his treatment of the same issue in his later encounter with National-Socialist Germany. Des Lourdines is the benevolent seigneur of the PetitFougeray estate, which serves as a mystical bond between master and peasants. He is sensitive both to the needs and problems of his tenants and to what is best for the estate as a whole. He is a leader who ‘awakens’ and ‘saves’ others, as seen in his relationship with his son. What matters most is his standing in the community as monsieur, rather than his individual status as Timothée des Lourdines. The theme of the benevolent seigneur is given further expression in La Meute, where it 21
34
Maurice Barrès, Les Déracinés (Fasquelle, 1897), p. 101.
is developed to exemplify the necessity of what Châteaubriant calls ‘le régime des hiérarchies’ (p. 120). If this is not preserved, he argues, then ‘l’homme animal’ (ibid.) will be unleashed. He illustrates his point by contrasting the behaviour of a group of farm dogs with that of the pedigree dogs belonging to Monsieur de Néris, the owner of the estate depicted in the story. The two pedigree dogs, aristocratic symbols of the Restoration, ‘savaient dominer leur instinct’ (pp. 99–100). In contrast, the farm dogs are nothing more than a rabble, approximated to a basic, uncivilised state, while the lead dog, Hugues, is spurred on by the same ‘démon hideux’ as the Revolutionaries of 1793 (p. 102). La Meute is an allegory of Châteaubriant’s view of mass human psychology. Lacking an aristocratic leader-figure to inspire them with honour, loyalty, selflessness and courage, the farm dogs instead follow Hugues, ‘une sorte de Danton à quatre pattes’.22 The subsequent fatal attack on the pedigree dogs represents a negative explosion of misdirected mass instinct, illustrative of the anti-Revolutionary thrust of Châteaubriant’s early writings. But La Meute should not be read as a statement championing a return to the monarchy, despite its positive opposition of the ‘Restoration’ dogs to the ‘Revolutionary’ dogs, for Châteaubriant, as we have seen, is no enthusiast of the Ancien Régime. The real theme of the story lies instead in its promotion of the principle of appropriate aristocratic leadership as illustrated by the opposition of Louis XVIII to Napoleon. In the story, Monsieur de Néris draws a distinction between his wife’s adoration of Napoleon as a heroic individual, ‘un être d’exception’ (p. 115), and his own veneration for the principle of aristocratic leadership represented by the King. This both demands and offers devotion and loyalty, and acts as a model of perfection in which the masses can believe and which they should strive to imitate. The ‘divine right’ monarch, whose authority is seen to come from God, requires a ‘respect de la Chose qui règne au-dessus de vous’ and 22
André Rousseaux, ‘Les Châteaux en Vendée d’Alphonse de Châteaubriant’, La Revue universelle, 63 (1935), 83–86 (p. 86).
35
a ‘dévouement à la personne représentant cette autorité sacrée’ (p. 117). Obedience to this principle is presented as the only method for human salvation. This theme of a higher authority to be contemplated and imitated in the name of salvation recurs throughout Châteaubriant’s writings, and would take on its full significance in later years when Adolf Hitler would become its incarnation par excellence. There exists, then, an identifiable proximity of thought between Châteaubriant, Barrès and Maurras, for Châteaubriant can persuasively be classified as a writer of works which unveil reactionary and traditionalist tendencies, and intimate a sympathy with integral nationalism.23 In the early years of the twentieth century, the natural political outlet for many on the nationalist and Catholic Right was the counter-Revolutionary and extra-parliamentary leagues, such as the anti-Republican Ligue de la Patrie française, founded in 1899, or the Action française movement, which was converted to monarchism by Maurras around 1900. Maurras himself may never have been a believer, but Action française drew massively on Catholic support and came to embody political Catholicism, since many Catholics shared its authoritarian and traditionalist sentiments, and identified their own and the movement’s enemies as one and the same.24 But, although sickened by France’s debasement and keen to act, no political movement or party attracted Châteaubriant’s interest or support, for, as he explained to Romain Rolland in 1911, he considered them to be ‘tous plus mesquins, plus égoïstes, plus tarés les uns que les autres’ (UA, 1983 p. 80). Action française especially did not fit the bill, for 23
24
36
It is interesting to note here that historians such as Zeev Sternhell and Robert Soucy have identified a number of significant common points between Barrès’s thought and later Fascist thought (see Sternhell, Ni droite, ni gauche. L’idéologie fasciste en France (Seuil, 1983), and Soucy, ‘Barrès and Fascism’, French Historical Studies, 1 (1967), 67–97). Others, like René Rémond, dispute a specifically French heritage of Fascism (see Rémond, Les Droites en France (Aubier, 1982)). Georges Bernanos, for example, found much to attract him in Action française. See John Cooke, Georges Bernanos: A Study of Christian Commitment (Amersham: Avebury, 1981).
Châteaubriant felt alienated not only by its enthusiasm for the Ancien Régime, but also – and particularly – by its subordination of all things to politics, as illustrated by its maxim of politique d’abord.25 So, although not politically without origin or direction, as seen by the counterRevolutionary interpretation which can be applied to his works, at this point in his career Châteaubriant was politically inactive in the sense of concrete engagement, principally because he was unable to find what he was looking for, namely, a suitable outlet for his particular beliefs. The meaning of Châteaubriant’s early writings evidently stretches beyond their repeated classification as regional texts which simply extol nature and the gentilhomme campagnard.26 But it is equally inappropriate to rest at a political interpretation of his works, for Châteaubriant was considerably less attracted by the political application of integral nationalism than by its poetic and ‘spiritual’ aspects, especially in terms of its regenerative capacity. The moral and spiritual decline of the gentilhomme campagnard detailed in his early writings serves to indicate that his primary message was the necessity of spiritual regeneration, thus confirming that his interests more nearly matched Barrès’s regenerative aspirations than Maurras’s political ambitions. The Baron de Puydreau’s moral decline is illustrated by his abuse of his power in his relationship with both his timid wife and his frail father-in-law (LM, pp. 145–61). Monsieur de Buysse shows little of the gentilhomme campagnard’s traditional interest in his lands, while his wife, a Parisienne dépaysée, longs to leave the confines of their estate and return to her former life in the capital (pp. 165–208). The De Néris’s also demonstrate little commitment to their lands, for the story depicts their first visit to the estate since it was inherited by Madame de Néris some ten years before the story takes place (p. 44). And the seeds of 25 26
On Action française, see Eugen Weber, Action française: Royalism and Reaction in Twentieth-Century France (Stanford: Stanford University Press, 1962). On the Ligue de la Patrie française, see Cahm, The Dreyfus Affair, pp. 133–38. Readings of the early writings as regional texts include Maurice Gauchez, Romantiques d’aujourd’hui (Brussels: Renaissance d’Occident, 1924), p. 112, and Gilles Nélod, Panorama du roman historique (Éditions Sodi, 1969), p. 261.
37
Anthime’s hedonism are shown to lie in his upbringing as a spoilt child at Petit-Fougeray (ML, pp. 40–41), indicating that his degeneration was not wholly caused by his life in Paris. None of these stories indicates that the succession will be assured: it seems unlikely that the impoverished Anthime will ever marry, and there are no children in any of the other three stories. Spiritual concerns manifestly dominate political, temporal and ‘national’ themes at this stage in Châteaubriant’s life. In Monsieur des Lourdines, for example, Anthime’s spiritual regeneration is Châteaubriant’s prime concern, and the only possible means to his redemption. Material losses are minor matters when compared with spiritual gains, for Châteaubriant is prepared to sacrifice PetitFougeray, indicating that the loss of this ‘nation-state’ is a small price to pay for the salvation of Anthime, the ‘enfant prodigue’ (p. 42) brought back from the brink of spiritual ruin. In later years, however, the spiritual and the political would be more closely entwined and eventually equated in Châteaubriant’s reception of National Socialism, as he came to believe in a potential for wider human regeneration through that ideology. The roots of that evolution lie in his religious thought as communicated through his early writings, for these carry layers of meaning which explain his attitudes and behaviour, and which therefore contribute substantially to an understanding of his later development as a collaborator.
Spiritual regeneration: seeking a pathway The anti-Revolutionary thrust of Monsieur des Lourdines indicates that the novel is to be read as a reaction against the modern and ‘godless’ times in which Châteaubriant lived, and confirms that he was a product of an intransigent Catholic humus. The novel further underscores that heritage in the prominence accorded to the theme of 38
spiritual regeneration, which can be seen to echo the broader Catholic integrist goal of the rechristianisation of society as recommended since Aeterni patris. But the text, alongside Châteaubriant’s diaries and his letters to Rolland, also serves to illustrate that he did not evolve in typical fashion, for together they offer solid evidence of the beginnings of a search for spiritual regeneration outside of the institutional Catholic Church, rather than evidence of support for the restoration of the traditional social role of the Church. Aspects of Monsieur des Lourdines indicate a shared mentality with the authors of what Richard Griffiths has termed the Catholic Revival, embodied by prominent writers such as Huysmans, Bloy, Claudel, Péguy, Barbey d’Aurevilly and Bourget, and defined as ‘a reaction of the Right […] taking an intransigent, reactionary attitude in relation to matters of both faith and politics’.27 These writers’ response to late nineteenth-century France was to defend traditionalism, patriotism, and political and religious order in the face of the onslaught of the turbulent, modern world. In their intransigence, they were also trenchant critics of their Church, charging it with mediocrity and weak sentimentalism, attacking the clergy and laity alike for their ‘compromise’ with the modern world and their lack of opposition to anti-Catholic forces (not the least of which was the Third Republic itself), and denouncing moderate, ‘modern’ Catholics, such as those within Marc Sangnier’s Sillon movement, which was influential from the 1890s and is widely regarded as the forerunner of Christian Democracy in France (pp. 231–39). Generally, the writers of the Catholic Revival favoured Ultramontanism, which had been the dominant tendency in Catholicism since Pius IX’s 1870 declaration of papal infallibility, Pastor aeternus. Their reactionary attitude was such that Leo XIII was attacked as a ‘liberal’ for his attempts to deal with the secular power, as at the time of the Ralliement, while, under the 27
Richard Griffiths, The Reactionary Revolution: The Catholic Revival in French Literature 1870–1914 (Constable, 1966), p. 4. Subsequent immediate references to this book are given in the text.
39
more reactionary Pius X (1903–14), their intransigence became stronger still, rivalling even that of the Pope (p. 20). These Catholics desired to see Christianity afresh, their reaction finding expression in ‘an immense nostalgia for a time when the world was different, and when society was nearer to perfection’ (p. 230), namely the Middle Ages, a period of ‘a hard asceticism, a heroic acceptance of suffering and an intransigent intolerance of compromise’ (p. 232). The enthusiasm and intensity of many of their number has been seen to stem from their status as recent converts to Catholicism, on the basis that converts are often more intransigent believers than those born into a faith. This enthusiasm sometimes found expression in exaggeration and apocalyptic predictions (as, for example, in the case of Bloy), and rendered them susceptible to dangerous pathways such as occultism and satanism, thereby illustrating the tendency of some ‘towards heresy founded on misunderstanding or distortion of Catholic doctrine’ (p. 143). The medieval atmosphere which impregnates Monsieur des Lourdines through the presentation of idealised feudal structures and the saintly, contemplative figure of Timothée des Lourdines suggests that Châteaubriant holds a view of the period which is as similarly stylised as that of the Catholic Revival. He also shares their dissatisfaction with the institutional Catholic Church and their enthusiastic desire to see Christianity afresh. Griffiths even roots Monsieur des Lourdines directly in the Catholic Revival, describing it as an example of ‘nostalgic literature’ on the basis of its depiction of the struggle between ancient and modern in a regional setting (p. 269). But the novel carries a far deeper message than a simple expression of regret for times past. Monsieur des Lourdines looks to the past as a way of looking to the future, for, as will be seen shortly, it contains the seeds of Châteaubriant’s search for a new approach to religion, imbued with elitist and medieval flavours, which would develop to dominate his spiritual and political thought during his later encounter with Adolf Hitler and National-Socialist Germany.
40
Châteaubriant’s intransigence in religious matters, although similar in intensity to that of a Bloy, a Claudel, or a Péguy, was not based on the enthusiasm of the convert, since he had been born and brought up in the Catholic Church – an essential distinction which sets him apart from many other unorthodox Catholic writers. But in 1893, one year after the Ralliement and on the eve of the Dreyfus Affair, the sixteen-year-old Châteaubriant lapsed from Church-based religious practice (C, p. 324).28 This lapse was no failing of his personal commitment to Christianity, however, for his diaries and correspondence confirm that he maintained a keen interest in the religious developments of the day, and that he was aware of the appropriate papal encyclicals and of the thrust of contemporary debate. Rather, it is persuasive to interpret his lapse as the first clear sign of his dissatisfaction with the methods and evolution of the Catholic Church. Looking back on his religious formation from some fifty years’ distance, Les Pas ont chanté later records Châteaubriant’s complaint with the mediocrity of the institutional Church, as expressed in its methodology for the communication of faith through what he bills as its ‘lowest common denominator’ sacraments: Mais, mon âme […] garde toujours à l’intérieur une odeur de sanctuaire. Ce qu’on vous apprend a tellement besoin d’être appris autrement! L’essence de la vérité est tellement plus auguste que l’étrange petite formule offerte à la faim moyenne de la foule… (pp. 120–21)
Illustrating his tendency towards spiritual elitism, Châteaubriant considers the traditional ritual ceremony adequate to satisfy the masses but insufficient for himself. He judges his religious education to have been sterile, based on ‘un bon catholicisme de tradition et de respect qui n’avait pénétré de son enseignement que les couches superficielles’ (Fragments d’une confession, 1953, p. 18). This failed to awaken his ‘moi actif et religieux’, because ‘le Dieu que l’on m’avait appris ne s’était pas 28
Châteaubriant returned to Church-based religious practice on 25 December 1948 (C, p. 324).
41
formé en moi’ (PC, p. 266). He defines the God he seeks as ‘un Dieu beaucoup plus puissant que ce Dieu de l’éducation, un Dieu héréditaire, un Dieu légué dans mon sang’ (p. 267), thereby indicating his susceptibility to the idea of what the National Socialists would later define as a God beyond the Catholic God. Châteaubriant may have shared in the Catholic Revival’s accusation of Church mediocrity, their desire to renew Christianity and their reference to the Middle Ages, but his methodology for regeneration was ultimately to differentiate his approach. Unlike the authors of the Catholic Revival, Châteaubriant did not bow to papal infallibility, but was instead prepared to question the authority of the Pope, as seen in his response to Pius X’s condemnation of Sangnier’s Sillon movement in 1910. Its brand of integral Catholicism rested on a ‘soyons peuple’ approach which emphasised fraternity and equality, rather than on the ‘allons au peuple’ stance which characterised the more paternalistic and hierarchical forms of Catholicism. The Pope’s condemnation had resulted from his objection to the increasingly secular nature of the movement, illustrated by its co-operation with both non-Catholics and non-believers, and which led it to claim freedom of action outside Church control. Châteaubriant would clearly not have supported the Sillon movement on the level of principles, since its ‘soyons peuple’ approach would have been far too democratic and egalitarian for his liking. Nor would he have been in sympathy with its secularisation, just as he rejected Action française for the prominence it accorded to secular matters. But he did support its claim to freedom of action, and viewed the condemnation as an expression of the negative nature of the Pope’s absolute authority – a reaction markedly different in tone to that of the Catholic Revival authors who welcomed such rigorous papal direction. Writing on this matter to Rolland in September 1910, he comments that ‘ce qui me révolte, c’est que cela soit fini de par l’autorité d’un seul homme; que ce seul homme ait le pouvoir d’éteindre en des milliers de consciences le don sacré de la vie’ (UA, 1983, p. 52). He holds that papal infallibility is nothing short of intellectual despotism, but he is also confident that this can be 42
successfully challenged, for ‘il faudra bien que le pouvoir d’un seul finisse par se fondre dans le pouvoir de tous’ (p. 53). He takes comfort from Renan’s Vie de Jésus (1863), in which he has read that ‘l’enseignement de Jésus se renouvellera sans cesse’;29 but, while hoping that this will happen, he writes that ‘pour le moment apprenons-nous à nous passer de ceux qui le représentent si mal’ (ibid.). In Châteaubriant’s opinion, spiritual vitality and the potential for spiritual regeneration do not reside in what he considers to be the mediocre, sterile, rigidly structured and tightly controlled institutional Catholic Church. He evidently does not share the enthusiasm of those working for a New Christendom through neo-Thomism, as the Church had upheld since Aeterni patris, while his willingness to question the Church’s structures and systems suggests a tendency to heterodoxy. Certainly, his rejection of papal infallibility does not make him a Gallican, for his criticisms applied equally to Rome and to the French Catholic Church; nor does it permit his classification alongside other unorthodox Catholic writers whose acceptance of papal authority conditioned their response. As Châteaubriant’s writings confirm, by the early twentieth century he was already in the process of searching for a new approach to religion, for a ‘direct line’ to God outside the institutional Church. Monsieur des Lourdines offers a preliminary exploration of that quest. The novel provides a vision of what Châteaubriant calls ‘la présence divine en toutes choses’ (C, p. 44), illustrated in the text by a representation of God in nature and music (significantly, this is a theme which would later be promoted in National-Socialist Germany). This is not in itself a new approach to religion (it recalls, for instance, the religious individualism of Rousseau),30 but it does nonetheless provide the point of departure for Châteaubriant’s ideas. The estate’s 29 30
This is a paraphrase of part of the final sentence of Renan’s Vie de Jésus, which reads ‘son culte se rajeunira sans cesse’ (Michel Lévy, 1863), p. 459. Châteaubriant acknowledges Rousseau’s influence in Les Pas ont chanté, p. 83.
43
forest is compared to a holy place (ML, p. 27), and a huge cross stands on a high plateau beyond the forest, representing the fusion of nature and religion. For Des Lourdines, the plateau is his Mount of Olives (p. 184), while his violin is compared to a sacred object whose music takes him onto a higher religious plane, as indicated by his eyes, ‘des yeux transportés hors du monde, et comme, seuls, peuvent en avoir les saints’ (p. 246). It is in the development of Des Lourdines’s role in the novel that Châteaubriant begins to travel a different religious pathway, for the major role of spiritual redeemer is allocated to Des Lourdines himself, since he ‘saves’ Anthime, while the priest (Madame des Lourdines’s confessor) has a purely cameo role and is seen to function simply along traditional, institutional lines (pp. 130–32). Redemption and communication with God are therefore seen to occur without the traditional intermediaries of priest or religious dogma, and outside the usual boundaries of church buildings. Reviews of Monsieur des Lourdines have defined a major theme of the novel as ‘le rachat de l’homme par ses propres efforts’,31 although Châteaubriant himself was to introduce a more explicit elitist tone, writing in April 1933 that ‘ce n’est qu’une élite chrétienne qui peut sauver le monde’ (C, p. 128), a role traditionally performed by monks in monasteries, especially in the Middle Ages. In La Meute, Châteaubriant explains that appropriate aristocratic leaders receive their authority from God. In Monsieur des Lourdines, Timothée des Lourdines embodies that authority, and is thus a potential member of Châteaubriant’s Christian elite. He fulfils a social and political role as the natural leader of the organic community of Petit-Fougeray, a leader who represents the principle of mutual duty and commands the loyalty and deference of his people in much the same way as the King does for De Néris in La Meute. But, significantly, he is also
31
44
Maugendre, Alphonse de Châteaubriant, p. 112, and André Niderst, Dictionnaires des littératures de langue française (Bordas, 1984), p. 438.
‘l’instrument inconscient de la Divinité’,32 ready to be awakened to a spiritual role as his son’s redeemer. In bearing both roles, Des Lourdines represents an early incarnation of Châteaubriant’s fusion of the spiritual and the political. In later years, Châteaubriant would accord Adolf Hitler many of the qualities attributed to Des Lourdines. He would also see the need for a Christian elite and the theme of salvation through the contemplation of God by that elite in the process of realisation within the Nazi pseudo-monasteries for the infamous Schutzstaffelen (SS). Châteaubriant’s future spiritualisation of politics in his treatment of Hitler’s Germany therefore has readily identifiable roots in his early writings, which, in turn, are easily sourced in his interpretation of the Catholic faith. To sum up, Alphonse de Châteaubriant shared the intransigent and reactionary mentality of many of his fellow-travellers of similar background and tendencies who would themselves follow the pathway of integral nationalism. A corresponding classification of Châteaubriant is tempting, given the thrust of his early writings. However, as his record of the First World War will confirm, Châteaubriant’s brand of nationalism did not develop into the full-blown extreme nationalism of a Barrès or a Maurras, but rather turned him into a committed Europeanist who advocated cross-national cooperation. Châteaubriant ultimately journeyed neither the pathway of integral nationalism nor that of the integral Catholicism upheld by the Catholic Church. He was an anti-Revolutionary and an antiRepublican, but no devotee of the Ancien Régime. He was neither one of Maurras’s ultras, nor one of Sangnier’s ralliés. He was no monarchist, but nonetheless upheld a notion of aristocracy and betrayed definite elitist tendencies. Heterodox but not heretical – in similar fashion to those writers of the Catholic Revival, men such as Bloy, Claudel and Péguy, who themselves travelled dangerous pathways – Châteaubriant was repeatedly critical of the structures and 32
Jean de Lassus, ‘L’Ame des pays et le pays des âmes dans l’œuvre romanesque d’Alphonse de Châteaubriant’, La Revue européenne, 45 (1926), 16–25 (p. 25).
45
systems of the traditional, institutional Roman Catholic Church, and disappointed with the sterile religion of his birth and education. He too, like many others, desired to see Christianity afresh, but personally began to look outside rather than to the Church for spiritual regeneration. By the eve of the First World War, Châteaubriant had embarked on the dangerous pathway which would lead to his journey’s end across the Rhine. As the war and its immediate aftermath would soon confirm, Alphonse de Châteaubriant was a collaborator in waiting.
46
2 A Collaborator in Waiting The First World War At the outbreak of the First World War in August 1914, President Poincaré’s rallying-call for a union sacrée met with almost universal acceptance. Internal political quarrels and rivalries were shelved as the nation faced the prospect of a fresh conflict against Germany, the old enemy whose defeat of France in 1870 had been neither forgotten nor forgiven. Patriotic duty commanded national solidarity. France, so Poincaré proclaimed, would be defended by all her sons.1 Bolstered by the belief that right was on France’s side, that war would offer delivery from the many dissatisfactions of civilian life and create an opportunity for moral, social and political renewal, and that a short war would suffice to ensure victory, the national mood in the summer of 1914 was one of widespread optimism, enthusiasm and exhilaration. But the nightmarish reality of the conflict would soon tell an entirely different story, for it quickly became clear that the war was in fact an unparalleled crisis of civilisation, a ‘traumatic experience which permanently changed, or indeed destroyed, values and beliefs as well as men and materials’.2 Germany declared war on France on 3 August 1914. Alphonse de Châteaubriant was mobilised the following day and stationed in barracks in Nantes until his departure on 15 August for Maubeuge, on 1 2
Raymond Poincaré, Au service de la France, 10 vols (Plon: 1926–34), IV (1928), 546. John Cruickshank, Variations on Catastrophe: Some French Responses to the Great War (Oxford: Clarendon Press, 1982), p. 27. The causes of the First World War need not be rehearsed here. For a lucid analysis of France’s decision to go to war, see John Keiger, ‘France’, in Decisions for War, 1914, ed. by Keith Wilson (UCL Press, 1995), pp. 121–49.
the border between France and Belgium, as a corporal with the eleventh transport corps. Châteaubriant’s unit was operational within the military ambulance service rather than as fighting soldiers, and was responsible for the transfer of the injured and dying from front-line ambulance stations to the field hospitals. Promoted to the rank of sergeant in May 1915, Châteaubriant would see the war through to its end, drafted to various postings across the grim battlefields of the Marne, Verdun and the Somme which scarred north-eastern France. On the eve of active service, Châteaubriant shared the mood of national enthusiasm. Recent illness could have spared him the conflict, but he was determined to participate in ‘cette formidable Iliade’, which he imagined to be a spiritually and physically elevating Homeric adventure from which he would return (if he returned) transformed, ‘bronzé, plus fort, plus grand, meilleur’.3 This expectation of personal renewal was matched by a conviction that the war represented a means to regeneration on a wider moral, spiritual, social and political level. Two years before the outbreak of war, as the international situation worsened, Châteaubriant had proclaimed to Rolland that ‘la barbarie […] est le salut et le moyen de toute civilisation’ (UA, 1983, p. 138). In July 1915, one year into the bloodiest conflict of modern times, he was still prepared to justify violence, arguing that ‘il faut qu’un retour à la barbarie nous sauve de la bestialité du civilisé’, and adding that ‘j’espère que des guerres sont à la veille de bouleverser la face du monde, de façon que le monde puisse reprendre à piedd’œuvre son ascension’ (Lettres des années de guerre, 1914–1918, 1952, p. 104). War therefore becomes both necessary and positive, ‘belle, grandiose, justicière’ (p. 82). Such allusions to the Nietzschean themes of the Übermenschen (the ‘supermen’ strengthened in war), purification through violence and the construction of a new, nobler world are
3
48
Letter to Romain Rolland dated 14 August 1914, L’Un et l’autre: correspondance entre Romain Rolland et Alphonse de Châteaubriant, 1914–1944, Cahiers Romain Rolland, 30 (Albin Michel, 1996), p. 31.
unmistakeable.4 The fact that Nietzsche would later be claimed by the Nazis as a forerunner of National Socialism (albeit unjustifiably) shows with hindsight how some who shared Nietzsche’s views could develop, as would be the case with Châteaubriant.5 Reshaping life and the world anew was Châteaubriant’s goal, vigourously promoted throughout the war. To that end, he exploited the war as a startingpoint for a critique of the ‘civilisé’, examining the state of contemporary society and delineating his programme for the creation of a new post-war Europe.
La bestialité du civilisé Protest against physical suffering and the dehumanisation caused by the First World War was common to writers such as Henri Barbusse (Le Feu, 1916), Roland Dorgelès (Les Croix de bois, 1919) and Georges Duhamel (Vie des martyrs, 1917; Civilisation, 1918). All held, as Barbusse wrote in Le Feu, that the war was ‘aussi hideuse au moral qu’au physique’ (p. 275). But, for Châteaubriant, the physical suffering inflicted on the world was nothing when compared with the moral decline revealed by the bloodshed (LAG, p. 50). Although haunted in similar fashion by the war’s consumption of human flesh (p. 138), Châteaubriant – like Pierre Drieu la Rochelle in his retrospective novel on the war, La Comédie de Charleroi (1934) – interprets the conflict
4
5
The popularity of Nietzsche’s ideas across Europe during the First World War was such that his most famous work Also sprach Zarathustra (1883) became a best-seller (see James Joll, Europe since 1870, 2nd edn (Harmondsworth: Penguin, 1976 [1973]), pp. 165–68). As Joll notes (ibid., p. 167), Nietzsche’s sister Elizabeth reworked her late brother’s ideas to fit her own and her husband’s extreme nationalist views. This was the Nietzsche claimed by the Nazis.
49
primarily as the confirmation rather than the cause of humanity’s moral decline and mediocrity, defining it as: […] le spectacle extérieur d’un drame plus profond, du drame de la consomption qui nourrit dans la conscience de l’homme la décadence des essences et l’abaissement incalculable de toutes les valeurs de l’esprit. (p. 166)
The nature of modern humanity, rooted in selfishness, blind materialism, unlimited greed and a total ignorance of the divine, has convinced Châteaubriant that ‘l’ère du Christ a pris fin et que celle de l’ogre ne fait que commencer ses ravages’ (pp. 159–60). This notion of the end of the spiritualised world, illustrated by the decline of âme and esprit, is the principal element of Châteaubriant’s critique of the modern world, and would underpin his search for a fresh spiritual beginning and the foundation of a regenerated world. This he would ultimately choose to find in Hitler’s Germany, defining the National Socialists as ‘l’apparition humaine d’un recommencement de l’œuvre de Dieu’ (La Gerbe des forces, 1937, p. 161). Châteaubriant, as Drieu would later do, roots humanity’s mediocrity in modern scientific society, spawning what Drieu would ironically call ‘cette guerre de civilisation avancée’.6 Humans have sold their souls to the machine, and the First World War is the price to be paid. Like many cultivated in the intransigent Catholic humus, Châteaubriant is highly critical of ‘l’homme issu du “progrès scientifique moderne”’ (LAG, p. 96). Modern science may have improved the material world in practical, concrete ways, but, he argues, it is not evidence of real human progress, which must be ‘par essence moral et intérieur’ (ibid.). The worst mistake that society can make, Châteaubriant asserts, is to confuse the two. Any society which has faith purely in science, material advances and rational thought is heading for disaster, and carries with it such damaging consequences as class struggle, a dampening of creative activity and the debasement of human nature (p. 98). Moreover, the speed of scientific advance is 6
50
La Comédie de Charleroi, p. 81.
such that humans have had no time to formulate an appropriate moral response, the result of which is that ‘l’âme ainsi devancée cesse de progresser, demeure immobile, si elle ne rétrograde’ (pp. 98–99). Democracy, abhorred by many Catholics, is defined by Châteaubriant as the political manifestation of destructive modern ‘progress’ (p. 236), and an ideology which therefore has equally damaging consequences for âme and esprit as science and rational thought. He contrasts democratic society with ancient societies, which are ‘plus morales que les nôtres, plus respectueuses en fait de la personnalité humaine’ (p. 58), and argues that there is no comparison between ancient societies based on centuries of culture and discipline and those based on ‘modern’ democracy (pp. 196–97). Although slavery formed an integral part of ancient societies, Châteaubriant contends that this only curtailed freedom of action and that the inner being remained essentially free. In contrast, although modern democracy may have freed humans from such external chains, he holds that it controls the inner being since it promotes temporal, human principles over eternal, divine principles. Slavery, he claims, is no longer physical, but spiritual (p. 58). Châteaubriant’s roots in an intransigent Catholicism are further confirmed by his attitude towards the bourgeoisie, a section of modern society he equates with liberalism and materialism and which he consequentially deems to be particularly bereft of âme and esprit.7 Châteaubriant condemns ‘les futilités qui font le pâle et vague bonheur de la société bourgeoise’ (p. 103), contrasting the simplicity of his existence in war with the ‘formes puériles’ (p. 86) of bourgeois life and criticising their ‘course folle au bien-être et au confortable’ (p. 151). He comments that he feels much closer in spirit to the ordinary men he encounters at the front line than to any of his bourgeois acquaintances (p. 105). This is no statement of equality with his fellow soldiers, for Châteaubriant, as will be seen, believed himself superior to those 7
On this theme, see Émile Poulat, Église contre bourgeoisie: introduction au devenir du catholicisme actuel (Casterman, 1977).
51
around him, but rather a striking expression of distance from the bourgeoisie. In contrast to modern, democratic society, dominated by the bourgeoisie, Châteaubriant admires disciplined and hierarchically structured societies which he believes prioritise what is eternal and essential in human beings rather than focus on temporal, ephemeral existence. As later chapters will elucidate, he would elect NationalSocialist Germany as his desired society.
Nationalism and Europeanism The First World War was a conflict of nations, in which patriotism was widely equated with nationalism. Men like Barrès and Maurras, the gurus of integral nationalism since late nineteenth-century France, saw the war in purely national terms and trumpeted their Germanophobia to the skies, confident that their words would find sympathy with a population keen to avenge itself on the old enemy.8 But many writers and intellectuals of different social and political convictions soon began to criticise not only the war, but also the nationalism which sustained it. Barbusse, for example, for whom the conflict was a class war, wrote in Le Feu that ‘les chauvins, c’est d’la vermine’ (p. 277), since ‘à la vérité éternelle ils substituent chacun leur vérité nationale’ (p. 284). Bernanos, a Catholic and a supporter of Maurras’s Action française movement, distanced himself from integral nationalism, choosing on humanitarian grounds to view the war more as a spiritual than a political issue. And Drieu, who did not publicly record his view of the war until 1934, at the time of his conversion to Fascism, offers a 8
52
Barrès, for instance, wrote in 1917: ‘Il nous faut relever la patrie de son abaissement et la guérir de sa mutilation. Il faut que les crimes soient vengés, les dommages indemnisés, les sacrifices récompensés. Le tout aux dépens des Allemands’ (Maurice Barrès, Mes cahiers, 14 vols (Plon, 1929–57), XI (1938), 228).
clue to the source of his Europeanism when he brands nationalism as ‘l’aspect le plus ignoble de l’esprit moderne’, announcing that ‘je voudrais voir une patrie européenne triompher sur les autres’.9 Châteaubriant’s exploration of the question of nationalism during the First World War provides the key to the source and tenor of his Europeanism. His stark denunciation of ‘nos vieilles nationalités pourries’ (LAG, p. 82) rests on their definition as ‘monstres dévorants, institutions purement humaines, exclusivement politiques même, dans notre monde moderne’ (p. 68). This not only indicates his rejection of purely temporal and political institutions, but also, by implication, reveals his quest for a world shaped and guided by factors beyond the temporal and political. Châteaubriant’s quarrel lies with the extreme ‘negative’ nationalism gingered by the newspapers and by writers such as Barrès (p. 35) and Péguy (p. 209). But he is equally keen to defend the retention of national identity, defining this as a positive form of resistance to ‘l’égalisation ethnique qui s’opère progressivement entre tous les peuples du monde’, the effect of which is that ‘la vie va du simple au composé: Bretagne–France–Europe’ (p. 243). This combination of a rejection of extreme nationalism and a defence of national identity underpins Châteaubriant’s brand of Europeanism, based as it was on the retention of national (even regional) identity within the larger entity that is Europe, and hints at an early ‘federal’ interpretation of Europe. The First World War hence confirms that the Maurrasian concept of la France seule is insufficient for Châteaubriant, and that, as suggested earlier, he was no integral nationalist. In Monsieur des Lourdines, Châteaubriant had introduced the theme of the salvation of humanity through individual spiritual regeneration, as illustrated by Anthime, which was seen to be more important than any political interpretation of the text. The war letters then register an evolution on Châteaubriant’s part, revealing a potential political application for the spiritual ideas of the novel, for he now also treats the wider issue of human salvation in a specifically European political 9
La Comédie de Charleroi, p. 219, p. 220.
53
context, arguing that ‘la grande coopération européenne serait actuellement, pour les peuples épuisés et intérieurement détruits dans leurs hiérarchies, la seule arche de salut’ (p. 254). In a letter written to his wife shortly after the 1918 Armistice, and therefore in the light of the demands placed on Germany by the Allies, Châteaubriant emphasises his conviction that, no matter what, ‘nous marchons vers une Europe une, de plus en plus une’ (p. 252). He deplores the strictly national interpretation placed on the outcome of the war, and the weakening of Germany which resulted from the terms of the Armistice. Instead of pursuing an ideal of ‘entraide mutuelle et collaboration’, Europe’s governments – controlled by the hated bourgeoisie – are accused of retreating into an old-style politics based on ‘faux nationalismes impénitents’ (p. 253). They are capable only of interpreting conflict ‘sous la forme des guerres de peuple à peuple’, and thus fail to comprehend that the real issue at stake is ‘[le] salut de l’Humanité’ (p. 254). The ‘new’ politics Châteaubriant wants to see in operation is based neither on ‘false’ nationalisms nor on what he calls the total ‘compénétration des nations’ (p. 253). Rather, he is committed to ‘la réalisation du grand organisme européen’ (p. 253), constructed of interdependent ‘cells’, or nations, thereby reinforcing and developing the organic theme introduced in Monsieur des Lourdines and voicing this in a precise political context. Châteaubriant was not alone in his advocacy of collaboration between nations, for the theme appealed to many who wished to see an end to this and all wars, and who called for co-operation between those of similar ideological persuasion rather than a retreat into separate national units. For example, Romain Rolland (Châteaubriant’s friend and regular correspondent) placed human interest above national interest, calling in Au-dessus de la mêlée (1914) for European unity and an end to war and militarism, goals he still upheld at the end of the conflict. And Henri Barbusse, who defined the war as ‘la Révolution française qui continue’, held internationalism as an ideal and looked forward to ‘l’entente des démocraties, l’entente des immensités, la levée du peuple du monde’ (Le Feu, p. 340, p. 348). In 54
the inter-war period, both Rolland and Barbusse would eventually travel the pathway of Communism, although neither without some hesitation and disquiet at times. Communism, however, was Châteaubriant’s nightmare. Like his fellow Catholics, he was horrified by its rejection of God; and he also abhorred its ‘democratic’ political system, which in his view reduced all of humanity to its lowest common denominator. His particular preferred model for European unity was constructed instead on conservative and aristocratic principles, mobilised precisely to combat what he calls the ‘démence populaire’ (LAG, p. 252) of Bolshevism. Writing in 1918, a year after the October Revolution in Russia, he argues that the time has come for conservative governments to act together against the common enemy that is international Bolshevism, and he predicts a fresh conflict between ideologies rather than nations, between ‘les deux éléments, aristocratique et démocratique, autorité et prolétariat’ (p. 252). At the dawn of the post-war era, his preference is clearly for a non-democratic, Communist-free Europe, where nations function in harmony. This Europe, he proclaims, must be led by an elite, made up of ‘hommes instruits et éclairés’ (p. 252), for only this can bring about the salvation of humanity from the debasing effects of Bolshevism. Moreover, he specifically advises co-operation with Germany, whose ‘principe aristocratique et militaire’ (p. 253) he believes should have been preserved rather than crushed at the end of the war. In so doing, Châteaubriant travels further down the pathway which would lead to his advocacy of collaboration with NationalSocialist Germany, for in later years he would interpret National Socialism as the rebirth of aristocratic Germany. His elitist Europeanism voiced at the end of the war, coupled with his specific call for Franco-German co-operation, stand as a telling indication that in 1918 he was already a collaborator in waiting. Indeed, as subsequent chapters of this study will underline, of the future collaborators, none was so clearly attracted by Germany at this stage as Alphonse de Châteaubriant.
55
Regeneration through war: the elitist model Although clearly concerned to advocate the construction of a particular political future for post-war Europe, Châteaubriant also argues that the outcome of the war must be social and not simply political, and that, to that end, it must demolish ‘ce vieil édifice d’illusions et de mensonges où nos âmes traînent une vie précaire’ (p. 82). For Châteaubriant, this goal of the salvation of souls turns the First World War into a medieval-style crusade, indicating that he can envisage a militant form of religion. Based on his understanding of the Old Testament, he announces that the war is ‘la plus divine, la plus voulue par Dieu de toutes celles qui ont sévi sur notre monde depuis les grandes invasions’ (pp. 82–83). The spilling of blood, he declares, is the ‘rosée nécessaire aux renaissances de l’âme’ (p. 102), a small price to pay for the purification of humanity, just as the loss of PetitFougeray was insignificant in comparison with the redemption of Anthime. With the exception of authors of the Catholic Revival such as Péguy and Psichari (who, in any case, both died in the first year of the war), few Catholics who experienced battle at first hand viewed the conflict as a crusade,10 that response being largely reserved for many of the clerics and lay Catholics who stayed at home.11 And yet, Châteaubriant maintained his reading of the war as a guerre sainte until its end, evidence of a willingness to justify, bypass and undermine the horrific reality of a temporal event of which he was well aware in pursuit of his exploration of his view of the eternal and the universal. As we shall see later, Châteaubriant’s interpretation of the First World War as a crusade foreshadows his detailed and sustained spiritualisation of the Second World War. Throughout the First World War, Châteaubriant’s letters reveal the continuation of his quest for a different spirituality and a fresh 10 11
56
See Griffiths, The Reactionary Revolution, pp. 325–32. See Jacques Fontana, Les Catholiques français pendant la Grande Guerre (Cerf, 1990).
spiritual aristocracy from those offered by the Roman Catholic Church, a theme introduced in Chapter One. He is, he announces, the bearer of a message for the world, a message which predicts the advent of ‘la spiritualité appelée à gouverner le monde de l’avenir’ (p. 241). In what stands as an expression of his conviction of his own spiritual ‘superiority’, Châteaubriant announces that this fresh spirituality will be both ‘simple’ and ‘true’, purged of the trappings of popular, institutional Catholicism which, in his opinion, have created a ‘false’ view of Christianity from which he is protected by his ‘true’ understanding. The real meaning of the Gospel is, he declares, ‘aussi différent des compréhensions auxquelles la lettre a donné lieu, que le visage du charpentier de Nazareth des figures de cire qui prétendent le représenter’ (p. 48). His self-imposed separation from the Catholic Church is restated when, writing of Péguy (a convert and staunch follower of intransigent Catholicism), he describes him as ‘catholique’ rather than ‘chrétien’; he then attacks Péguy’s brand of Catholicism as a sterile religion which emphasises the Church as a building rather than a movement, and which is holding back the new brand of religion which Châteaubriant advocates (p. 209). The source of this new spirituality lies in what he defines as a so-far unexplored area of Christianity, his interpretation of which is clearly influenced by his reading of Nietzsche, as he admits: Le monde spirituel reparaîtra fondé et édifié sur une nouvelle pierre, pierre tirée d’une carrière inconnue du catholicisme, du christianisme même; pierre qu’il me semble bien que prophétiquement Nietzsche nous ait fait toucher du doigt. (p. 181)
Châteaubriant, it seems, already believes that he has the key to a future nouvelle chrétienté. This reference to Nietzsche further reinforces our earlier point that Châteaubriant’s advocated brand of spiritual regeneration is distinctly elitist. He remains convinced of the need for a new ‘aristocratie de l’esprit’ (p. 52), and firmly believes himself blessed with this attribute. He regards himself as both a prophet and a potential 57
redeemer of others, writing of ‘la lumière dont j’ai le dépôt sacré’ (p. 42) and classifying himself as ‘une âme qui ne se sent plus respirer que pour le salut de la multitude’ (p. 50). He also notes with a certain arrogance that he acts as spiritual guide to an actual priest, thereby revealing an odd notion of pastoral ministry: Quand on songe que les pasteurs comme les prêtres ont pour mission de soutenir les âmes, en ce qui nous concerne les rôles se sont retournés: c’est moi le pasteur et c’est lui qui écoute. […] Je lui ai fait certainement beaucoup de bien. Chose encore curieuse, le vrai sens de la figure du Christ ne s’est révélé à lui que depuis nos entretiens. (p. 48)
Châteaubriant’s reference to ‘le petit dieu intérieur avec lequel je m’entretiens’ (p. 211) represents an enthusiasm characteristic of the Catholic Revival writers, as is the vision of Christ he experienced in early 1915 which he believes singled him out from the anonymous masses, described disparagingly as ‘les grandes foules inconscientes et aveugles’ (p. 49). Writing of this event some twenty-five years later in Fragments d’une confession, Châteaubriant summarises the message of the vision as the theory of oubli de soi (pp. 32–33), that is, the necessity of selfless thought and action in order to find the love of God. As we shall see later, this notion would underpin Châteaubriant’s theory of contemplation, which, in turn, he would develop within his later appreciation of National-Socialist Germany. Châteaubriant’s elitism also finds justification in his reading of Arthur de Gobineau’s Essai sur l’inégalité des races humaines (1853–55), a copy of which he asked his brother Guy to send him in May 1916 (LAG, p. 137). Châteaubriant judges Gobineau’s arguments on race to be particularly powerful, but considers that ‘cette nourriture de vérité est d’une essence trop délicate pour être à l’usage de l’esprit public’ for ‘dans les démocraties, il est nécessaire que l’idée directrice soit à la mesure du plus grand nombre’ (p. 173). His reading of Gobineau leads him to classify human beings into two groups:
58
[…] de braves gens, ce qui n’est pas grand-chose, mais ce qui est tout de même quelque chose, au moins dans la vie, et […] des âmes d’élite, des âmes fortes, des âmes lumineuses, des âmes de maîtres, ceux que Gobineau appelait ‘des fils de roi’. (p. 234)
These âmes d’élite are, quite simply, the crusaders whose role will be to direct human regeneration. They are: […] des êtres qui portent une symbolique croix rouge entre les épaules, et ont à trouver Dieu, à arriver jusqu’à lui coûte que coûte, parce qu’ils ont à assurer […] une place de tête dans la grande caravane du troupeau humain. (FC, p. 20)
Gobineau’s racial theories would prove influential in both France and Germany, in the latter especially during the 1930s.12 During the First World War, Châteaubriant’s evident admiration of these theories is mobilised in justification of his notion of an elite made up of ‘hommes supérieurs’ (LAG, p. 232), possessing aristocracy of intelligence and authority from a higher force (clearly God), rather than in order to formulate a specific sense of a racial elite. He is, moreover, primarily concerned with ‘superior’ ideologies which he connects to certain nations, as in his association of Germany with the aristocratic principle. But Châteaubriant does already hold definite opinions on the question of race. He bemoans what he calls ‘le mélange incessant des races et des cartes [qui] a fini par créer dans l’ensemble de l’humanité une sorte d’égalité ethnique’, and counters this with his call for an aristocracy of spirit (p. 52) and for a great leader, ‘un homme politique, une intelligence et une énergie à la Cromwell’ (p. 75), someone he believes to be singularly lacking in the First World War. The distance between Châteaubriant’s promotion of an aristocracy of spirit – composed of men of merit and marked by the identification of his desired type of leader – and his adoption of a theory of an aristocracy of race is but a short one. And, indeed, rejection of ‘égalité 12
See George Mosse, The Crisis of German Ideology (Wiedenfeld & Nicolson, 1966), and Zeev Sternhell, ‘Les Origines intellectuelles du racisme en France’, L’Histoire, 17 (1979), 106–14.
59
ethnique’ coupled with his elitist tendencies would inevitably prompt him to begin to explore the question of racial superiority, an avenue soon travelled in his second novel, La Brière (1923). This, in turn, would lead him to conclude in later years that only those of a particular race possess ‘aristocratie de l’esprit’ and represent the authority of God, and are therefore suitable to lead. Such men he would find in National-Socialist Germany, while his Cromwell would be Adolf Hitler. Victory for the Allies in 1918 did not bring the social and political changes Châteaubriant desired. War, he believed, could have administered a short, sharp shock to wrest modern humanity from its decline. But by 1917 the war had already gone on too long for this to be achieved, leading him to conclude that ‘cette guerre au lieu de tout rajeunir aura tout usé’ (LAG, p. 183). Writing in his diaries in April 1919, he records his disillusion and bitterness at the world he sees around him, and notes that he feels isolated on an ideological level (C, p. 55). The ‘new’ post-war Europe, he laments, is no different to its pre-war counterpart. Lessons have not been learned, and France remains alarmingly blind to the ‘truth’. In a variation on his views first voiced in 1918 (LAG, pp. 253–54), he now recommends an alliance with Germany rather than England in order to ensure France’s peace and prosperity (C, p. 59). This, he believed, was the right way forward, and stands as a clear precursory indicator of where his sympathies and antipathies would lie when choices had to be made in 1940. Châteaubriant’s despair at ‘ce présent [qui] dégage un crapuleux éclat, qui me fait mal et m’inflige un douloureux désir d’autre chose’ (p. 58) was heightened by what he saw as the increasing Bolshevisation of contemporary society. In a move ‘qui me repose de la lecture de L’Humanité […] [et] me repose de la prose de ce Barbusse et de ses Clartés’ (p. 56), he chose to focus on re-writing La Brière, begun in 1906, shelved to allow work on Monsieur des Lourdines (UA, 1983, p. 39), and then lost during the war (PC, p. 338). On completing the novel in October 1922, Châteaubriant declared that ‘La Brière appartient à une autre époque de mon existence’ (C, p. 60), namely the 60
pre-war period, a claim which can be supported by the novel’s proximity of theme and approach to his pre-war writings, as will be seen in the next section. But, beyond these initial similarities, the novel in fact illustrates a further evolution in Châteaubriant’s thought, introducing an exploration of the question of race which confirms that, in the post-war period, his Europeanism swiftly acquired an explicit racial nature which carried him still further down the pathway towards collaboration with Germany.
La Brière: racial identity and racism La Brière (1923) provides additional proof of Châteaubriant’s roots in an intransigent Catholicism in its restatement of the antiRevolutionary and anti-modern stance of his earlier writings, seeming thereby yet again to illustrate integral nationalism.13 The novel’s regional location in Brittany corresponds to Châteaubriant’s previous choice of the Vendée, and the Brière region itself symbolises a hermetic unit, comparable in its self-sufficiency to the ‘nation-estate’ of Petit-Fougeray in Monsieur des Lourdines. As peat-diggers, the Briérons depend on the land for their existence in much the same way as the peasants at Petit-Fougeray. They, too, are formed by their soil, for the Brière is ‘la pâture de leur pauvre vie’ and ‘une âme subtile y nourrissait la moelle de leur os’ (p. 13). The novel details the conflict between tradition and progress in its representation of the region’s struggle to maintain its traditional way of life in the face of the modern, ‘foreign’ forces of the industrial firms of Saint-Nazaire ‘qui 13
La Brière’s serialisation in 1923 in Henri Massis’s journal La Revue universelle further corroborates our classification of Châteaubriant, for the journal ‘called Right-wing intellectuals to arms against the international of the revolution’ and was regarded as ‘one of the most significant publications of the Catholic Right’ (Weber, Action française, p. 503).
61
voudraient s’approprier la Brière, pour y installer leurs exploitations’ (p. 31). The defence of the ‘nation-region’ is entrusted to Aoustin, the aptly employed garde of the village of Fédrun, who is instructed to find the lost letters-patent of 1462, which grant permanency of tenure to the Briérons (p. 33), and whose recovery will thereby safeguard the region’s independent existence. Aoustin appears to be the personification of integral nationalism, ‘le fanatique de son pays et de sa race […], l’individu intégral, produit du milieu et du climat’.14 Not only is he rooted in his land, like Timothée des Lourdines, but he and the land actually become one. Taking the recovered letters-patent to a lawyer in Saint-Nazaire, he is shot by Jeanin – his daughter Théotiste’s lover, who is enraged at Aoustin’s refusal to allow them to marry – and subsequently loses a hand (p. 287). He extracts a section of tree embedded in the peat floor of his house from which he has a replacement hand fashioned (pp. 316–18). The new hand represents the fusion of the human form with its ‘soil’, namely the peat bog, and Aoustin now defies people ‘de me dire où la Brière finit, et où moi je commence!’ (p. 338). His devotion to the Brière is complete. He sees the region and its people as independent entities, separate from the rest of the world: Et la carte du globe décidément pour lui se divisait en deux parts: les continents d’un côté, et la Brière de l’autre. De même qu’il y avait deux espèces humaines: les hommes d’ailleurs, et ses compatriotes de la tourbe. (pp. 11–12)
Not surprisingly, therefore, he disapproves of those Briérons tempted by the wages offered by the industrial giants (p. 14), and who have uprooted their families to go and work in the town rather than stay on the marshes. Aoustin’s job is to oversee the extraction of peat from the marshes on behalf of the Government’s Département des Eaux et Forêts, and he thereby operates at the junction of the pays réel and the pays légal. He was appointed to the post after the previous three 14
62
Jean de Pierrefeu, ‘La Brière’, Le Journal des Débats, 4 July 1923, p. 3.
‘foreign’ gardes brought in from outside the region all disappeared in mysterious circumstances (p. 101). He holds that the land must be protected from excessive exploitation, but resents the Government’s dictates to the region and prefers to believe that in applying its laws he is acting in the interests of the Brière rather than serving the State (p. 102). Like Timothée des Lourdines, Aoustin has a special status in the region, for the population looks to him as ‘le meilleur homme’ (p. 37) and ‘l’homme nécessaire’ (p. 42) in the issue of the letters-patent. In serving the region, Aoustin works in the interests of both the land and the Briérons. He even subordinates individual, family concerns to those facing the community as a whole, for, on hearing of the threat to the Brière, the task of finding the letters-patent takes precedence over his domestic problems. Aoustin’s fanatical defence of the region’s independence is echoed in his attitude towards his own family. We learn that Aoustin has already cursed his son for marrying ‘sa Bretonne, une brezounec d’on ne savait où’ (p. 23). The son’s subsequent departure with his wife for Nantes mirrors Anthime’s departure for Paris in Monsieur des Lourdines, and the harmful effect of this uprooting, along with the result of Aoustin’s curse, can be seen in the death of the son’s wife (p. 70) and the paralysis of their child (p. 195). Aoustin’s refusal to allow Théotiste to marry Jeanin, a basket-maker from a neighbouring village, stems from the same reasoning. Like Muller in Monsieur des Lourdines, Jeanin is a non-moi, since he is not a ‘Briéron vieux sang, natif des îles’ but hails from Mayun, a village on the northern edges of the marshes, and whose men are described as ‘le type le plus accompli de ces garçons dont une fille de Fédrun n’aurait pu vouloir sans se coiffer de ridicule’ (p. 44). For Aoustin, Jeanin is the worst possible partner for Théotiste. His resistance to their marriage is ‘national’, in that he opposes family union with someone who is effectively ‘foreign’, being from a different village. Aoustin’s pride in the status of his family causes him to behave with prejudice towards outsiders, seemingly casting the novel as an expression of ‘chauvinisme du village’ or
63
‘xénophobie archaïque’,15 a conclusion ostensibly supported by Aoustin’s own maxim of ‘chacun chez soi’ (p. 12). Châteaubriant, of course, despaired at ‘guerres de peuple à peuple’ (LAG, p. 253), as his war letters confirm. It is, in fact, patently insufficient to interpret La Brière as an allegory of integral nationalism, compelling though this may seem from an initial reading of the text, since this both ignores Châteaubriant’s maturing Europeanism and does not accord adequate significance to the notion of race which permeates the novel. La Brière goes beyond a consideration of ‘nation’ alone. Rather, it is to be understood as an allegory of Châteaubriant’s Europeanism as outlined in his war letters, and so constructed on the basis of the preservation of national identity within the wider European organism, but within which he now also develops his notion of racial difference. The theme of racial difference was first introduced in Monsieur des Lourdines in the character of Muller, the Jewish money-lender, the nonmoi harmful to those originating from Petit-Fougeray. In La Brière, racial difference is explored through the representation of Jeanin, Théotiste’s lover. Their relationship has made Théotiste aware that other, different people exist beyond the confines of the Brière islands, and, as a result, she has come to dislike ‘la rudesse des hommes de son sang’ (p. 46). Her father, however, possesses an instinctive sense of racial difference: for him sang et sol dictate the choice of a future marriage partner, for ‘tout ce qui n’était pas Briéron vieux sang, natif des îles […] se trouvait à l’avance évincé de toute possibilité d’union’ (p. 44). The doctor who treats Aoustin’s wounded hand claims to have carried out an ethnological study of the region’s population, and represents an ‘educated’ view which lends weight to the notion of racial difference in the novel, contrasting in particular the ‘Briérons du 15
64
Georges Bergner, ‘Alphonse de Châteaubriant’, Alsace-Française, 20 (1923), 467– 68 (p. 467); André Thérive, ‘La Brière’, L’Opinion, 6 July 1923, pp. 8–9 (p. 9). Given France’s history, it is not surprising that a journal entitled Alsace-Française should view La Brière as an expression of integral nationalism.
centre’ (including Fédrun) and those from Mayun, on the edge of the region (pp. 246–47). Aoustin illustrates Barrès’s Darwinian vision that ‘racial pollution must be resisted at all costs lest the fit be made unfit’.16 He is proud of the previous racial purity of his family, for the men have always married Fédrun women (p. 153), and believes that his son has scorned his roots by marrying outside his blood group (p. 23), while the resultant new family is ‘unfit’ as indicated by their frailty. Aoustin will allow no further dilution of Fédrun blood, and so refuses his daughter’s marriage. Théotiste is sacrificed to her father’s ideal: accused of getting rid of her illegitimate child in the marshes and subsequently imprisoned (pp. 291–92), she is abandoned by Jeanin (p. 387) and eventually goes mad and dies as Aoustin takes her across the marshes in his boat to hospital (pp. 411–22). To view the Brière as a hermetic ‘nation-state’ is to underline its unity to the detriment of its obvious diversity. The Brière is made up of ‘dix-sept communes riveraines’ (p. 32), and so exists as a collective of individual but interdependent islands and villages (or ‘nation-states’) rather than a single ‘nation-state’ in itself. Their diversity is emphasised, for ‘chaque village de Brière a sa physionomie, ses mœurs, son métier’ (p. 110), and the people from each village have traditionally married their own kind, thereby preserving the ‘national’ and ‘racial’ identity of the group. Within the Brière, the racial group of the Saxonorigin Briérons vieux sang – ‘[ceux] du centre, ceux des îles’ (pp. 246–47) – is deemed superior, while the Mayun people – ethnologically different, of sallow skin (p. 247) and judged to be of inferior ‘esprit’ (p. 44) – are marginalised in the region both geographically and racially. The island people of true Brière stock therefore represent a community of ‘nations’ of the same blood origin, each retaining its individual ‘national’ identity within the broader racial collectivity of the Briérons vieux sang. The Brière region clearly illustrates Châteaubriant’s vision of Europe. It is united and yet diverse, representing an organism of 16
Soucy, ‘Barrès and Fascism’, p. 79.
65
interdependent cells with individual identities, working together through the ‘syndics’ (p. 31), and thus operating a system ‘d’entraide mutuelle et de collaboration’ as advocated by Châteaubriant in his war letters in pursuit of the goal of ‘une Europe une’ (LAG, p. 253, p. 252). Whereas Barrès’s resistance to racial pollution is mobilised solely in the interests of the French nation, with the French deemed superior to the Germans, Châteaubriant’s operates on a broader, European level which judges people of different nations but the same blood group superior to others. In La Brière, the Briérons vieux sang are Châteaubriant’s superior Europeans, the racially purest and the guiding focal group within the region, symbolically physically located at the heart of the Brière. Blood (or race) rather than village origin (or nationality) is the dominant determining factor in the operation and management of the region, indicating that Châteaubriant’s sense of the ‘appropriate’ construction and direction of his new Europe is also already distinctly racist. His subsequent reception of Hitler’s Germany, and his vision of the role that he would foresee for both France and Germany in his new Europe would in future years permit that racism to find concrete expression.
Leadership: the error of spiritual arrogance The question of leadership permeates Châteaubriant’s writings. As we have seen, by the end of the First World War he had developed a notion of leadership which emphasised principles above personalities, and wherein appropriate leaders are ‘hommes supérieurs’ (LAG, p. 232) who receive their authority from God and are bound to the masses by a sense of mutual duty and affection. Châteaubriant’s preferred leaders are men who, like Timothée des Lourdines, deserve their role on merit, whereas he is critical of those born to lead but who abuse their power and privilege, such as the Baron de Puydreau. 66
Timothée des Lourdines incarnates the spiritual aristocracy and benevolent authority which Châteaubriant considers essential in a leader, and aptly fulfils his role as head of the Petit-Fougeray community. In La Brière, in contrast, Aoustin is not one of Châteaubriant’s superior men, but represents instead an undesirable form of authority, one which is negative and despotic, which is exploited to advance an individual cause before that of the community, and which therefore serves to illustrate the divide between what Châteaubriant sees as spiritual arrogance and spiritual aristocracy. In La Brière, Aoustin is presented as ‘ce grand despote à l’œil de percette’, a man who is feared by those around him and who has no friends (p. 42), and for whom anger is ‘cette vieille compagne de sa vie’ (p. 304). He is accustomed to being in a position of authority, but, like the Baron de Puydreau, that authority is based on fear and force rather than on mutual duty and respect. His ability to inspire longstanding fear is shown particularly by his daughter, Théotiste, who, as a small child, would become anxious and hide when she heard her father’s approaching step (p. 43), while his wife, Aoustine, clearly harbours the grudges of thirty-five years of difficult marriage (p. 49). Châteaubriant himself indicated that La Brière represents an ‘étude de nuit, étude surtout de nuit humaine’,17 and images of darkness recur as a leitmotiv throughout the novel. For instance, the adjective noir features repeatedly in descriptions of Aoustin, and his dark character takes on a concrete form when, at the height of his arrogance, his substitute hand makes its first appearance, fashioned from black wood (pp. 338–39). Pride dictates his behaviour. Following his departure from the marital home and his sighting of Jeanin visiting Théotiste, the injury to Aoustin’s pride is described as a ‘sillon de chair vive’ (p. 136). His desire for revenge on Jeanin is, however, self-centred, since it becomes clear that he wants revenge for the shooting incident rather than for his daughter’s honour (p. 314). And wounded pride takes 17
In René Pichard du Page, ‘De Monsieur des Lourdines à La Brière: notes sur Alphonse de Châteaubriant’, La Revue du Bas-Poitou, 1 (1923), 1–8 (p. 8).
67
precedence over Théotiste’s misfortunes once more after the death of her child, for Aoustin is less concerned with her imprisonment than with the fact that his job as garde is given to another during his stay in hospital after the shooting incident (p. 308). Aoustin’s pride leads him to behave with arrogance on a spiritual level. Not only is he the garde of the Brière, he claims, but also the ‘garde de la Vérité’ (p. 154). He believes that his authority and his actions are justified by God, taking as evidence of this the curse against his son fulfilled by ‘le grand Berger’ (p. 70). In his dealings with Jeanin, Aoustin holds that God is also on his side: vengeance is his by right, and he finds consolation in its contemplation (p. 314). He declares that his substitute hand (with which it is implied he will attack Jeanin) has been given to him by God (p. 339), while the hand’s nickname of Sainte-Justice suggests his belief in an Old Testament, ‘eye for an eye’, vengeful religion rather than in the forgiveness and love advocated in the New Testament. Indeed, at one point Aoustin announces categorically that ‘il n’y a pas d’amour de Dieu’ (p. 7). As in Monsieur des Lourdines, Châteaubriant’s major concern in La Brière is again spiritual redemption from moral ruin. This theme is introduced with the choice of Lucifer as Aoustin’s nickname (p. 30), evoking the ‘prince des méchants’ (p. 224) and indicating that Aoustin is a ‘fallen’ character. Julie – a local woman known for her charity and one of the few people Aoustin respects – points to his pride as a sin and the source of his moral ruin, and introduces the prospect of punishment for his behaviour (pp. 91–92). She reminds Aoustin that ‘Dieu est le maître’ (p. 131) and asks him if he accepts that ‘il y a quelqu’un au-dessus de toi’ (p. 386). It is Julie who remarks that Aoustin’s substitute hand is ‘la main du diable […] la main de Lucifer’ (p. 344), thereby suggesting that the actions committed by the hand will be inspired by the devil in Aoustin rather than by God. And the hand does indeed symbolise Aoustin’s arrogance and desire for vengeance, for his moral decline is at its most serious when he imprisons Jeanin, telling him that he is nothing more than ‘un bouquet dans la main de Lucifer!’ (p. 397). 68
For the greater part of the novel, Aoustin refuses both to accept that there can be any truth other than his own, and to repent for his actions. He rejects forgiveness for Jeanin and denies any responsibility for Théotiste’s fate, entrenching himself in his anger and his desire for vengeance on Jeanin. It is only with the death of Théotiste that Aoustin is finally humbled and pardons Jeanin, realising that ‘il est une justice plus sainte que la sienne sous laquelle tous doivent s’incliner’.18 After a night on the marshes, Théotiste’s death is accompanied by the dawn, and the black world in which Aoustin has lived is countered by the light of redemption: Une lumière céleste brillait entre les nuages, ainsi qu’un regard éternel tombant sur sa misère! […] Ses yeux la voyait pour la première fois!… Cette lumière transperçait son âme, et la jugeait!… (pp. 422–23)
Both Monsieur des Lourdines and La Brière seem to end on a note of ruin, for they entail the deaths of Madame des Lourdines and Théotiste, the loss of Petit-Fougeray and the continuation of the modern threat to the Brière with the erection of the first telegraph pole at Saint-Joachim (p. 359). But both really end on what is intended to be a spiritually positive note, for La Brière confirms the conclusion drawn from our earlier analysis of Monsieur des Lourdines that, for Châteaubriant, material losses are insignificant in comparison with spiritual gains. Both also further indicate that he is prepared to accept human losses in the name of spiritual redemption. Just as Christ died in order to save humanity, so the deaths in both novels can be seen as necessary for the redemption of Anthime and Aoustin: Anthime’s return to Petit-Fougeray after his mother’s death and his reintegration into provincial life at the end of Monsieur des Lourdines signal his renewal; while Aoustin’s humbling at the end of La Brière after his daughter’s death signals his ‘rebirth’, significantly occurring as a new day dawns,
18
Louis de Mondadon, ‘Chronique des lettres: Alphonse de Châteaubriant’, Études, 18 (1923), 716–27 (p. 718).
69
and serves to make him a potentially suitable leader since it is indicated that henceforth he will be guided by God.
Spiritual vitality Despite the modern ‘ère de dégénérescence de toute fidélité’, Châteaubriant notes in his diaries in May 1924 that a certain freshness of religious expression still exists in rural Brittany, ‘[où] s’est gardée verte l’idée de Dieu, la croyance dans les valeurs de l’âme’ (C, p. 62). He is weary of ‘l’état de misère qu’est la condition de la vie de l’âme dans nos milieux de prétendue civilisation’, and considers that only in such a wholesome God-fearing environment is it possible that ‘on devient capable de la grande inspiration éternelle’ (ibid.). Religious expression in rural Brittany may be superstitious and pagan, as Châteaubriant admits, but he holds that ‘les pauvretés de la superstition ne sont pas plus indignes de l’homme – peut-être moins – que l’indifférence végétative de l’affreux matérialisme’, and describes the Bretons in positive terms as ‘êtres de fraîcheur’ (ibid.). The simple religious faith and activity of the rural Bretons is given expression in La Brière, where it represents yet further evidence of Châteaubriant’s preference and quest for a fresh approach to religion. Théotiste, we are told, was born on the feast of Corpus Christi, which inspires in her mother ‘la foi en une prédilection céleste’ (p. 47). Aoustine finds comfort in the repetition of prayers (p. 242). As a girl she had wanted to take the veil, and she sees the same destiny for her daughter, commenting on her rescue from the marshes at the age of four that ‘Jésus l’a nourrie, Jésus la mariera’ (p. 48). Julie’s simple compassion and humility provide a telling foil to Aoustin’s spiritual arrogance, for, although poor herself, she has taken in her sister’s orphan children and lives her life in true Christian fashion (p. 132). It is Julie’s function in the novel to ‘le ramener [i.e. Aoustin] dans la voie’ 70
(p. 289), this and Aoustin’s ‘conversion’ on the marshes reinforcing Châteaubriant’s representation of redemption outside traditional intermediaries and boundaries as introduced in Monsieur des Lourdines. The Briérons approximate events in their lives to stories from the Bible, for Julie interprets the region’s struggle to remain independent as an illustration of the story of Jacob, adding ‘c’est comme la Brière, pourvu qu’elle aussi soit la plus forte’ (p. 61). And, during the discussion of the prospective uses external forces (represented by ‘la grande ville’) may make of the region, one of the syndics refers to the parable of the fruitless fig tree in Luke 13 as a way of expressing his concerns about the Brière’s future if its traditional resources are exhausted (p. 330). The novel’s representation of religion underscores the importance of the Church in the life of the community, for the Briérons take their sick cattle to the church to be cured ‘le dimanche de la Sainte-Corneille, patron et guérisseur de bétail’ (p. 45), and the church is a meeting-place where discussions and important announcements concerning the Brière take place (pp. 56–57, pp. 319– 20). Such indications of the interpenetration of spiritual and temporal concerns provide a key to Châteaubriant’s view of the necessary role of the spiritual in the contemporary world, a point which will be developed in the next chapter through an examination of the elaboration of his notion of a New Christendom. In conclusion, the First World War served to confirm for Châteaubriant his overwhelming sense of the decadence of the modern world, rooted in individualism, materialism and inappropriate political systems and ideologies, such as democracy and Communism. His call for a radical transformation of the world focuses particularly on the need for spiritual regeneration. Dismissive of the traditional, institutional Catholic Church as the engineer of spiritual renewal, Châteaubriant has chosen to bypass the Church in his quest for a fresh spirituality to incarnate his vision and thereby confirms his tendency to spiritual arrogance, a characteristic he would have us believe he deplores. He has evolved to treat the issue of spiritual renewal in a specific social and political context, for he envisages that regeneration 71
can only occur within a framework which is distinctly elitist and racist in inspiration, and which forms the basis of his vision of a new, nobler Europe. Europe, he proclaims, needs men of merit and vision (in which category he includes himself) to lead the anonymous masses, men he would soon identify in ‘superior’ racial terms. Châteaubriant betrays clear evidence of hostility to the non-moi. In his demonisation of the Other, his animosity is formulated in racial rather than national terms: the purity of the blood group is all-important, while discrimination based on skin colour and esprit is evident from his categorisation of the Briérons vieux sang and the Mayun people. The war revealed that, for Châteaubriant, national concerns come second to his vision of a new, organic Europe constructed and led by those he judges the fittest in racial and intellectual terms. Unlike the integral nationalists, Châteaubriant was certainly no Germanophobe, but rather a committed Europeanist with a particular predilection for a Germany modelled on elitist lines, tendencies which made him a collaborator in waiting. As the critical inter-war years would show, Châteaubriant’s social, political and spiritual ideas were to become clearly fused as he pursued his chosen pathway in his quest for a New Christendom.
72
3 The Quest for a New Christendom Refaire une chrétienté The idea of a nouvelle chrétienté, or New Christendom, was already evident in the later nineteenth century, given impetus by Leo XIII’s encyclical Aeterni patris (1879) on the restoration of a Thomist-based Christian civilisation. In the twentieth century, as Yvon Tranvouez has shown, the inter-war period saw the re-emergence and triumph of nouvelle chrétienté, although it subsequently declined in influence and favour during the 1940s and 1950s, and then disappeared altogether around the time of Vatican II (1962–65), ‘victime certainement d’un nouveau langage’.1 In Aeterni patris, the Pope chose Saint Thomas Aquinas (1226–74) as the Christian doctor, and called on Catholics to uphold his systems as their model of Christian philosophy in the modern age. Catholic thinkers of both the late nineteenth and the twentieth centuries were therefore encouraged, as David Luscombe writes: […] to view the thirteenth century as the golden age of medieval scholasticism and Aquinas as the central point of a story for which earlier chapters were a preparation and later ones a postscript.2
The mainstream nouvelle chrétienté which re-emerged in the 1920s drew on the recommendations of Aeterni patris in its reaction against the modern world. In France, the atmosphere for its development resulted at least partially from the sense of crisis apparent in the immediate post-war period, for many Catholic thinkers emerged from the conflict with a common diagnosis, namely that ‘la guerre a montré 1 2
Tranvouez, Catholiques d’abord, p. 109. David Luscombe, Medieval Thought (Oxford: OUP, 1997), p. 3.
la faillite de la civilisation moderne, issue des principes de 1789’.3 The nature of the ‘cure’ varied, however, between the ‘évocation passéiste’ of the diehard reactionaries who advocated the mobilisation of Catholic forces to restore the Ancien Régime, and the ‘projet d’avenir’ of the Social Catholics who ‘cherch[aient] moins à détruire et restaurer qu’à épurer et baptiser’ (p. 103), and who therefore contemplated the construction of a new world risen from its ruins in which the spiritual would play a significant role. No less intransigent in their condemnation of the modern world, their way of being anti-modern was to bring about ‘une autre modernité, une vraie modernité, une version catholique de la modernité’ (ibid.).4 Social Catholics found much to interest them in neo-Thomism (pp. 237–38). Firstly, they identified therein a social and economic doctrine which could be marshalled equally against capitalism and socialism, and which emphasised such principles as the common good, a patriarchal interpretation of society and property, and the fair treatment of workers. Secondly, they found a theory of political power which could be applied in the new post-Revolutionary period, namely the doctrine of indirect power, defined as ‘[la] distinction du spirituel et du temporel, primauté du premier, impliquant une compétence latérale en tout ce qui, dans le domaine du second, peut toucher à la foi et à la morale’.5 Human regimes were thereby put into perspective through a reaffirmation of the primacy of the spiritual, which had been effectively eliminated by the Enlightenment. Thirdly, neoThomism offered a philosophical alternative to a Catholic traditionalism flavoured by obscurantism. It seemed thereby to favour thirteenth-century Christianised Aristotelianism, which endowed reason with its own domain, over earlier Augustinianism, which rested on the doctrine of the divine illumination of the human mind. Faith 3 4 5
74
Tranvouez, Catholiques d’abord, p. 114. Subsequent immediate references to this book are given in the text. The italics are the author’s. Émile Poulat, L’Église, c’est un monde. L’ecclésiosphère (Cerf, 1986), p. 231. Cited in Tranvouez, p. 237.
had long exercised authority over reason, but, for Aquinas, reason and faith were separate yet complementary. Reason therefore became neither independent nor supreme. Rather, it was used to support revelation, and thereby to supplement and complete faith. Several factors played a part in the successful establishment of nouvelle chrétienté in 1920s France (pp. 114–18). Firstly, the accession of a new Pope, Pius XI (1922–39), who was considerably more popular in France than his predecessor – the allegedly ‘pape boche’ Benedict XV (1914–22). Pius XI reactivated the goal of the restoration of a Christian social order in two early encyclicals, Ubi arcano (1922) and Quas primas (1925), the content of which was popularised and disseminated by the French Church through the youth movements within Action catholique spécialisée which developed from 1926. Their message was subsequently complemented by Quadragesimo anno (1931), which stood as the foundation of Catholic social teaching after Rerum novarum (1891). Secondly, the growth of Catholic activity against the secular State and the development of Catholic groups such as the antiGerman and anti-Communist Fédération nationale catholique (created in 1925 and popular among anciens combattants), indicated that there was a considerable Catholic element keen to defend the role of the Church in French society. Thirdly, French Catholic thinkers were influenced by the thought of the Russian philosopher Nikolai Berdiaev, whose call for the restoration of social order to combat liberalism and Communism was encapsulated in his Un nouveau Moyen Age, published in France in 1927. And last, but by no means least, in 1926 Pius XI famously condemned Maurras’s Action française movement – which had tried to harness the French Catholic Church to its cause – on the grounds of its philosophy of politique d’abord. The Pope’s action indicated the Church’s rejection of the temporal’s exploitation of the spiritual, and was instrumental in prompting some well-known French Catholic thinkers to debate and present a programme for the regeneration of society based on the primacy of the spiritual. Within France, nouvelle chrétienté’s most prominent theoretician throughout the inter-war period was Jacques Maritain, a convert to 75
Catholicism and a former member of Action française who, along with other notable Catholics such as Georges Bernanos, separated from the group over the years following the 1926 papal condemnation.6 Four years earlier, Maritain’s Antimoderne (1922) had summarised his critique of ‘le présent désordre’: […] il importe d’intégrer l’immense matériel de vie contenu dans le monde moderne, [mais] il convient de haïr le monde moderne pris dans ce qu’il regarde comme sa gloire propre et distinctive: l’indépendance à l’égard de Dieu. (pp. 216–17)
His subsequent work, La Primauté du spirituel (1927), represented a call to arms, ‘à une restauration intégrale des valeurs chrétiennes, à une universelle réinvention de l’ordre’ (p. 116), designed to combat the problems of modern society engendered, so he held, some five hundred years previously with the Reformation and the Renaissance, and evident to the present day. Maritain believed that the crisis of modern civilisation was rooted in the individualist and totalitarian regimes of the day. In Humanisme intégral: problèmes temporels et spirituels d’une nouvelle chrétienté (1936), the fruit of over a decade of reflexion on the theme, he wrote of the problems he associated with nineteenthcentury individualism, arguing that modern democracies erroneously promoted the individual above the common good, and often professed only symbolic respect for ‘la personne en chacun des individus de la masse’ (p. 206). The totalitarian regimes which had appeared in reaction to individualism were also tainted, for ‘le totalitarisme politique veut en tout cas que l’État devienne la réalité absolument souveraine de la vie temporelle des hommes’ (p. 286). They thereby prioritised the temporal and demanded ‘que le spirituel […] s’intègre, dans la conscience, à l’État ou à l’esprit du peuple, et les serve’ (p. 287).
6
76
On Maritain and Bernanos’s involvement in Action française, see Paul Sérant, Les Dissidents de l’Action française (Copernic, 1978), pp. 57–168.
Maritain held that spiritual regeneration could lead to what he called ‘une politique chrétienne’. In La Primauté du spirituel he argued that this should ‘choisir son analogue historique, non dans le siècle de Louis XIV, où tant d’orgueil de la vie pourrissait parmi tant d’éclat, mais dans la civilisation théologale du Moyen Age’ (p. 109). His intention, however, was not to make the twentieth century into a servile copy of the Middle Ages, but rather to adapt medieval principles to the contemporary context. As he later explained in Humanisme intégral: Nous pensons que l’idéal historique d’une nouvelle chrétienté, d’un nouveau régime temporel chrétien, tout en se fondant sur les mêmes principes (mais d’application analogique) que celui de la chrétienté médiévale, comporterait une conception profane chrétienne et non pas sacrale chrétienne du temporel. (p. 168)
Nouvelle chrétienté, he believed, should accept the evolved status of the temporal, which has its own strengths, aims and function which are distinct but not separate from those of the spiritual, while at the same time underlining that the spiritual possesses absolute primacy (p. 182). In this way, Maritain accorded the spiritual indirect power over the temporal in the modern context, in contrast to the direct power which the spiritual had exercised over the temporal in the Middle Ages. For Maritain, as for other important Catholic thinkers of the day (for example, Étienne Borne, Marie-Dominique Chenu, Étienne Gilson and Henri-Irénée Marrou),7 the reactivation of a medieval Christendom would be nothing more than a misguided attempt to go back in time, while its adaptation to the modern context turned nouvelle chrétienté into a forward-looking project for the restoration of a Christian civilisation in the modern age. 7
See Étienne Borne, ‘Pour refaire une chrétienté’, La Vie intellectuelle, 9 (1936); Marie-Dominique Chenu, ‘Dimension nouvelle de la chrétienté’, La Vie intellectuelle, 12 (1937); Étienne Gilson, L’Esprit de la philosophie médiévale (Vrin, 1932) and Pour un ordre catholique (Desclée de Brouwer, 1934); Henri-Irénée Marrou, Fondements d’une culture chrétienne (Bloud et Gay, 1934).
77
Maritain’s diagnosis of contemporary social disorder was shared by the so-called ‘non-conformist’ groups of young intellectuals of the 1930s: Esprit (the most influential, headed by Emmanuel Mounier), La Jeune Droite and L’Ordre nouveau. In their eyes, the modern world was intellectually, morally and spiritually bankrupt, and they identified the roots of the contemporary crisis in ‘une civilisation née au XVIème siècle avec la Renaissance, la civilisation de l’individualisme’.8 Their ideological proximity to Maritain is further reinforced by their elaboration of the notion of a necessary spiritual revolution, ‘conçue comme une rupture créatrice de l’homme avec le désordre établi pour susciter un “ordre nouveau” fondé sur la primauté des “valeurs spirituelles”’ (p. 296). In their opinion, as Mounier confirmed, ‘“révolution spirituelle d’abord” est le mot d’ordre indispensable aux chefs de demain’ (p. 300). Such a revolution would be directed by an elite and would engender ‘un homme transformé, un homme transfiguré, un homme “nouveau”’ (p. 301). The non-conformist groups were also critical of individual and totalitarian regimes, as illustrated by Mounier’s seminal article in the first number of Esprit, published in October 1932, in which he wrote that ‘la communauté n’est pas tout, la personne isolée n’est rien’.9 The theory of personalism which rested on this notion held that it was essential to appreciate the difference between the individu and the personne, between ‘ce qu’il y a en l’homme de matériel, de corporel et, ici, de social (l’homme-individu) et l’aspect raisonnable, spirituel et supérieur de son être (l’homme-personne)’ (p. 342). Mounier’s later Manifeste au service du personnalisme (1936) indicated his preference for ‘toute civilisation affirmant le primat de la personne humaine sur les nécessités matérielles et sur les appareils collectifs qui soutiennent son développement’ (p. 7). 8 9
78
Jean-Louis Loubet del Bayle, Les Non-conformistes des années 30: une tentative de renouvellement de la pensée politique française (Seuil, 1969), p. 266. Subsequent immediate references to this book are given in the text. Emmanuel Mounier, ‘Refaire la Renaissance’, Esprit, 1 (1932), 1–68.
Maritain’s ideas certainly bear comparison with those developed by Mounier and his young non-conformist contemporaries. But their respective goals differed, in that, as Michel Winock has pointed out: Maritain visait, selon la philosophie thomiste dont il était l’expression contemporaine la plus célèbre, à fonder les bases d’une nouvelle chrétienté; Mounier, lui, cherchait les voies d’une nouvelle civilisation où chrétiens et incroyants, sans mutilations réciproques, pussent trouver leur place et créer ensemble, sur la base d’une ‘primauté du spirituel’, une société d’hommes libres.10
Although Maritain could envisage co-operation between Christians and non-Christians, he believed that the initiative rested with Christians, precisely because his goal was to ‘refaire une chrétienté’. In contrast, Mounier’s goal of a new civilisation rested from the outset on collaboration between believers and non-believers (pp. 38–39). The quest for a New Christendom was apparently as much a feature of Alphonse de Châteaubriant’s life in the 1920s and 1930s as it was of the other Catholic thinkers discussed above. However, it is difficult to evaluate precisely to what extent his personal search was influenced either by those associated with mainstream nouvelle chrétienté or by the events of the time, or to what extent he was aware of but simply chose to ignore other writers and events, since his diaries from 1918 to 1936 contain little comment on the contemporary situation and all the entries for 1925 to 1928 were lost in 1944 (C, p. 78). There is, therefore, no direct indication of his response to Pius XI’s encyclicals, nor to the papal condemnation of Action française in 1926 and the implantation of Action catholique spécialisée within France from the same date. Nor does he refer directly to any of the various groups and movements of the day which attracted Catholic support and which represented the pluralism of Catholic thought, including the extreme Right-wing Action française, the Right-wing Fédération nationale catholique, the Croix de Feu (founded in 1927), the centrist Parti démocrate populaire 10
Michel Winock, Histoire politique de la revue ‘Esprit’, 1930–1950 (Seuil, 1975), p. 38. Subsequent immediate references to this book are given in the text.
79
(created in 1924), and the non-conformist groups which emerged in the late 1920s and early 1930s. Not surprisingly, given his reaction in 1919 against ‘toutes les politiques et tous les manifestes’ (C, p. 56), Châteaubriant appears to have remained withdrawn from this context of Catholic activity throughout the 1920s and into the 1930s. He concentrated instead on his literary output, writing and publishing a series of texts which indicate the continuing importance of regional themes in his works. In 1923 he published the rewritten La Brière, collaborating on a film version of the novel in 1924 and lecturing on la création littéraire in the same year.11 And in 1927 he published both a final version of La Meute in book format, publicising its appearance with a lecture, and a short work extolling the Dutch countryside, Instantanés aux Pays-Bas.12 However, in the late 1920s, Châteaubriant began to work on the manuscript of his third full-length novel, La Réponse du Seigneur (1933), and on what was intended to be the first volume of a meditative journal (C, p. 78). This volume, constructed of notes written between 1930 and 1938 (LCM, p. vii), was finally published posthumously in 1951 under the title Lettre à la chrétienté mourante.13 Together, these two books represent the elaboration of Châteaubriant’s search for his own nouvelle chrétienté (a quest begun in his earlier works, as we have seen), and confirm that, whether he was aware of it or not, he formed part of the broad contemporary movement seeking regeneration through respiritualisation. In their critique of modern society and their emphasis on the primacy of the spiritual as the necessary means to regeneration, both La Réponse du Seigneur and the Lettre à la chrétienté mourante contain elements common to mainstream nouvelle chrétienté 11 12 13
80
The text of the lecture is published in Les Nouvelles de Versailles, 17 April 1924, p. 1. The text of the lecture is published in Les Nouvelles de Versailles, 16 March 1927, p. 3. Although not published as a full-length book until 1951, major extracts from the Lettre à la chrétienté mourante were published in article form in La Revue universelle in 1933 and 1934. See the bibliography for details.
thought in the inter-war period. But, as we shall see, Châteaubriant’s own brand of nouvelle chrétienté was quite distinct from that of the mainstream since it promoted a very different project of regeneration and became increasingly idiosyncratic, especially in its relationship to 1930s National Socialism. La Réponse du Seigneur bears a striking initial resemblance to Monsieur des Lourdines on the level of regional, feudal and antiRevolutionary themes, for the society it depicts is provincial, patriarchal and traditional. The novel is set in Brittany (p. 21), on an estate surrounded by ‘une vieille muraille de clôture’ (p. 24), similar to the ‘nation-state’ of Petit-Fougeray. The owner, Félicien de Mauvert, another gentilhomme campagnard, resembles Timothée des Lourdines in appearance and status (pp. 36–37). At the beginning of the book, he leads the community in his sister’s funeral procession, ‘le premier et tout seul’ (p. 40), and it becomes evident as the novel progresses that this community operates along similar lines to that at Petit-Fougeray. De Mauvert’s exposition of the golden age of the nobility, which he roots in the pre-1600 period, restates an earlier Châteaubriant theme, evoking a time when masters and servants co-existed and co-operated to their mutual benefit (pp. 124–32). De Mauvert’s servants and peasants are his ‘family’ and he is their monsieur. The strength of the community lies in its collective sense, best illustrated by the servant Mariette’s grammatically incorrect ‘j’avons’ for ‘j’ai’ (pp. 133–36). Just as a wave cannot exist without the sea, so the individual is less important than the collective: society, De Mauvert proclaims, must ‘ne point diviser ce qui est indivisible, […] ne point séparer l’individu de la cohésion de ceux qui forment avec lui son espèce’ (p. 135). But, like Petit-Fougeray, the Mauvert community also illustrates the decline of the gentilhomme campagnard, for, with no direct heirs, De Mauvert’s succession is uncertain. La Réponse du Seigneur further echoes Monsieur des Lourdines in its promotion of the theme of human spiritual regeneration. However, in this novel, as in its theoretical partner, the synchronal Lettre à la chrétienté mourante, Châteaubriant’s critique of the modern world is 81
more outspoken, while the project envisaged operates on a much wider scale, in line with the development of his thought at the end of the First World War (LAG, p. 254). The titles of the two works alone are significant, for the Lettre à la chrétienté mourante suggests a theme of Catastrophism not only evident in the earlier works of the Catholic Revival writers but also common to contemporary Catholic thinkers,14 while La Réponse du Seigneur foregrounds Châteaubriant’s proposed spiritual answer to this crisis. In the early pages of the Lettre à la chrétienté mourante, he records the urgency of his ‘mission’ as an ‘ombre sommée de parler’ in whom ‘a été mis un secret qui est la réponse au mal de tous’ (p. 4), a response to the modern world ‘[qui] fait tout simplement l’effet d’un monde qui s’éteint, d’un monde qui se carbonise, où tout devient noir’ (p. 182). As we shall discover, Châteaubriant’s version of Maritain’s présent désordre rests on a criticism of the modern world’s emphasis on science, materialism, intellectualism and individualism to the detriment of intelligence, faith, essence, the collective sense and what he terms ‘la Substance’ (p. 143) or ‘la Vérité’ (p. 145). These themes, together with his limited but direct and eulogising references to the philosophy of Plato (c.427–347 BC) (pp. 60–63), and to the thought of such medieval luminaries as Saint Augustine (345–430) (pp. 49–50), Saint Bernard (1091–1153) (p. 179, p. 233), Saint Anselm (1033–1109) and Saint Bonaventure (c.1217–74) (p. 233) – who all saw faith as a starting-point for knowledge and emphasised the divine illumination of the human mind – suggest that Châteaubriant’s sympathies lie with his view of Augustinianism rather than with his interpretation of the Christianised Aristotelianism of such thinkers as Saint Thomas. His preference for a time before reason or ‘intellect’ permeated Christianity (as he sees it) and for universals above particulars, together serve to define him as an essentialist, a realist rather than a nominalist, one for whom form or essence or ‘species’ (or, in Châteaubriant’s case, the collective) comes 14
82
See, for example, Marcel Moré, ‘Notes sur le marxisme’, Esprit, 11 (1934), 453– 70.
before the individual. As we shall see, his ideas are based on his interpretation of medieval texts and debate, the meaning of which he believes has been ‘revealed’ to him. He considers himself a seer, a philosopher working on the principle of voyance and with a special insight into the higher truth of essences which the mass does not and cannot possess. This initial conclusion immediately suggests that Châteaubriant would not welcome any call for the restoration of Thomism, and that he is therefore looking for a different New Christendom than that sought by mainstream thinkers like Maritain.
The Lettre à la chrétienté mourante: a theory for a New Christendom Study of the Lettre à la chrétienté mourante confirms Châteaubriant’s allegiance to an intransigent Catholicism. His standard Catholic antimaterialism – introduced in his first two novels through the contrast drawn between countryside and city – is now emphasised by the equation of materialism with human destruction. In his opinion, ‘le développement d’une civilisation matérielle intégrale, c’est-à-dire sans vision métaphysique qui enfante dans les esprits la notion d’un principe spirituel, est une condamnation à mort’ (p. 170). This clearly illustrates his search for a ‘metaphysic’, a quest shared by others seeking a New Christendom. His abiding anti-materialism is matched by a restatement of the anti-science, anti-positivism and anti-machine approach of his war letters, all of which are traditional Catholic themes given a ‘mystical’ tinge by Châteaubriant.15 Humans, he writes, are ‘les victimes de la réduction du monde aux formules, de l’artificielle abstraction logique et scientifique’ (p. 77). He holds that ‘l’homme 15
Nikolai Berdiaev’s L’Homme et la machine (Éditions ‘Je sers’, 1933) also treats anti-machine and anti-industrial themes.
83
s’abêtit par sa science’ (p. 100), objecting to the scientific approach to life and its promotion of objectivity on the grounds that this takes no account of subjective esprit in its attempt to understand the world. In rejecting esprit, ‘la science veut savoir par elle-même au lieu de n’aspirer qu’à reconnaître ce qui est su éternellement’ (p. 115), the result of which is that ‘la science aboutit au vide’ (p. 149). His pessimistic conclusion is that: […] dans le ciel noir de ce vide, devant la formule mathématique à laquelle aboutit la science, nous demeurons sans espérance, comme dans le domaine des signes, dans la région de la représentation sans réalité, dans le cercle de la formule. (pp. 160–61)
Châteaubriant’s interpretation of intellectualism reinforces the conclusion that he is an essentialist. He defines the contemporary period as an intellectual age (p. 78), while intellectualism is ‘l’aboutissement d’une erreur de plusieurs siècles sur la définition de l’esprit’ (p. 77). In what is clearly a reaction against intellectualism, presumably rooted in his personal reading of Saint Thomas, Châteaubriant consistently opposes intellect (or reason) – humanity’s ‘faux dieu’ (p. 174) – with ‘intelligence’ (or illumination), the way of thinkers such as Saint Augustine, Saint Anselm and Saint Bonaventure, for whom all truth was revealed truth and for whom knowledge was dependent upon grace. Saint Thomas, of course, accepted the validity of revealed truth, but endowed reason with its own domain and held that reason supported revelation, not denied it. Châteaubriant, however, wrongly believes that Saint Thomas allowed reason validity independent of faith, and that he was therefore something of an empiricist. Châteaubriant evidently understands that his preferred thinkers distrusted reason when divorced from faith and pursued for its own sake, but he does not recognise that they accepted reason as an instrument in the demonstration of what they already believed. On this evidence, Châteaubriant’s true understanding of medieval thought is open to question.
84
Intellect, Châteaubriant writes, does not represent truth, but is an ‘image morte’ (p. 100) or ‘tout simplement l’image sans la substance’ (p. 190).16 Intellectual existence differs from ‘la vraie vie, qui est Dieu ou substance sans images’ (pp. 77–78). Those who have not truly found God toss and turn in a world beset by ‘représentations sans substance, représentations qui, sans la substance, ne correspondent à rien qui vive’ (p. 143). Châteaubriant’s reading of the Old Testament leads him to equate this world with the ‘chambre d’images’ described in Ezekiel 8.7–12. Humans live in chambres d’images, where ‘tout n’est que formules et figures’ (p. 134). They have no time for anything other than ‘les images que leurs passions ont fait naître en eux-mêmes’ (p. 31) and which they mistake for ‘substance’ (p. 133). They have lost the ability to recognise and serve higher principles, and have become wrongly focused both on ‘la chair et l’apparence [qui] sont mêmes choses que l’erreur’ (C, p. 138) and on their ‘moi psychologique’, their ‘moi des sensations et déroulements représentatifs’, their ‘fameux faux moi’ (LCM, p. 247). Châteaubriant’s reference to the chambre d’images in Ezekiel is echoed by his reading of Plato’s allegory of the cave in The Republic (pp. 60–63).17 He shares Plato’s conviction that there are two levels of reality – the everyday, physical world and the ‘superior’ level of eternals and absolutes – and that the temporal is only the shadow of the eternal. Plato’s cave is used by Châteaubriant to reinforce his argument that humans must close their eyes to the temporal, illusory world of shadows, and look within to discover ‘une autre réalité, une seconde évidence’ (p. 62) which will reveal what is essentially true and genuine. Châteaubriant exploits Dostoyevsky’s Karamazov brothers further to illustrate ‘le terrible élément humain’ (p. 23). Together, they incarnate ‘l’impulsivité, la sensualité, la bassesse, la violence, la haine, toutes les saletés les plus exécrables’ (p. 33), although the worst 16 17
The italics are Châteaubriant’s. Plato, The Republic, ed. and trans. by Desmond Lee, 2nd edn, rev. (Harmondsworth: Penguin, 1987 [1974]), pp. 316–25.
85
brother by far is ‘le constructeur d’idées’ because ‘c’est l’intelligence sans Dieu qui est la coupable’ (p. 42).18 In Châteaubriant’s opinion, humans must strive to imitate Albrecht Dürer’s German knight, Stefan Baumgartner, who ‘a tué le Karamazov en lui’, thereby killing the dragon ‘qui porte toutes les têtes du mal’ (p. 24).19 This theme of the ‘beast within’ represents an important leitmotiv in Châteaubriant’s work, introduced with the theme of ‘l’homme animal’ in La Meute (p. 120) and further illustrated by the serpent Kaa (based on the serpent of Genesis 3) in his 1934 diaries (C, p. 147), and would find its most significant manifestation as the ‘Schwein’ in La Gerbe des forces (1937, p. 64), his eulogy of National-Socialist Germany. The Karamazov episode illustrates Châteaubriant’s conviction that humans must struggle to break free of the intellectual in order to attain the spiritual (LCM, p. 79), although the spiritual which he envisages is not to be found in institutional religion. Pascal Ory has written that, in the 1930s, La Réponse du Seigneur ‘révèle soudain l’état de manque d’un chrétien déçu’.20 But Châteaubriant’s disappointment with the Church was hardly sudden, as we have seen, since it can be clearly dated to his early writings. Rather, this theme is reinforced in 18
19
20
86
Châteaubriant’s acquaintance with Dostoyevsky’s work was long-standing, since he wrote in a letter to Jacques Copeau on 16 August 1912 that the author was ‘un des écrivains dans lequel j’ai le plus cherché’ (Louis-Alphonse Maugendre, ‘Alphonse de Châteaubriant et Copeau’, La Pensée catholique, 167 (1977), 73–78 (p. 74)). Dostoyevsky was also a reference for Berdiaev: see his L’Esprit de Dostoïevski (Éditions Saint-Michel, 1931). This is a reference to Albrecht Dürer’s (1471–1528) woodcut (c.1505), in which Baumgartner is depicted as a Saint George figure, standing over a slain beast. Châteaubriant evidently admired Dürer’s work, describing him as ‘un des compagnons de ma vie’ (LCM, p. 183). Other woodcuts referred to in the Lettre à la chrétienté mourante include Melancholia (p. 123), John the Baptist (p. 183) and Apocalypse (p. 248). Dürer’s works also feature in La Réponse du Seigneur and form the basis for illustrations in La Gerbe in 1943 and 1944, where Châteaubriant describes him as the newspaper’s ‘patron’, alongside Joan of Arc (20 April 1944). Pascal Ory, Les Collaborateurs 1940–1945 (Seuil, 1976), p. 15.
the 1930s, as witnessed by his 1931 diaries in which he writes that ‘Dieu est mort en nous de l’intellectualisation de l’idée de Dieu’ (C, p. 130), that religion is not simply ‘un code de croyances et de formalités à savoir et à pratiquer pour tâcher de couper à la damnation’ (p. 127), while ‘les vrais fonds baptismaux ne résident pas dans l’ombre froide des églises’ (p. 119). This is no denial of religion per se, for Châteaubriant’s disillusion with the modern Church is not accompanied by a rejection of the Bible, since paraphrases and direct quotations from both the Old and New Testaments feature in La Réponse du Seigneur and especially the Lettre à la chrétienté mourante. Instead, his comments amount to a restatement of his discontent with what he sees as the negative effect of intellectual society on contemporary religion, and with the Church’s complicity in that process, accompanied by a search for a fresh religious outlet. Where mainstream nouvelle chrétienté thinkers saw the creation of Action catholique spécialisée and the encyclical Quadragesimo anno as representative of a potential regenerative force, Châteaubriant makes no reference to these events and so effectively rejects the Church as a regenerative force. Instead, as we shall see, his project becomes a mission to be accomplished by an elite not operating through the institutional Church.
Rebirth through purification Based on his reading of Genesis, Châteaubriant argues that humanity’s problems began with Adam and Eve. As a result of their original sin – the consumption of the fruit of knowledge of good and evil (LCM, p. 138) – they ceased to be the image of God ‘pour être comme des dieux, les centres illusoires d’un faux univers’ (p. 140). The serpent of Genesis 3 promised intelligence but delivered only intellect (p. 190), and humanity’s task is to rediscover the being of Genesis 1, to ‘refaire l’homme des commencements […] reconstruire l’homme chrétien sur 87
l’homme primitif’ (p. 98). In a passage which plainly distinguishes Châteaubriant’s thought from that of mainstream thinkers, he confirms that his nouvelle chrétienté demands complete renewal rather than the partial adaptation recommended by men such as Maritain: ‘Le christianisme, dans son œuvre révolutionnaire et recréatrice, ne consiste pas […] en une simple application “nouvelle” des anciens principes humains connus; il est la révélation du monde totalement nouveau’ (p. 193).21 Châteaubriant was well aware of contemporary debate, but chose to consider this inadequate and to follow his own pathway. Rebirth is the key to rechristianisation, and a major theme of the Lettre à la chrétienté mourante, sourced in the requirement of John 3.7 that ‘il faut que vous naissiez de nouveau’ (p. 228). The type of rebirth envisaged supports our interpretation of Châteaubriant as a meditative voyant who places ‘revealed’ truths before rational truth, and who therefore rejects his reading of Saint Thomas in favour of his understanding of Augustinianism. He proclaims that ‘le grand christianisme […] ne se trouve pas dans l’intellectualité’ (p. 100) and argues for a redefinition of intelligence, ‘laquelle sera fondée enfin sur les possibilités de l’intelligence les plus hautes, et non sur les plus basses’ (pp. 55–56). The human being delivered from intellect is ‘le privilégié de la “nouvelle naissance”, le roi du royaume de l’intelligence’ (p. 63). Châteaubriant maintains that, without what he calls ‘naissance dans l’esprit’ – which offers the prospect of eternal life – humans remain ‘de pauvres fétus abominables’, rooted in their ‘naissance dans la chair’ (p. 244). He is convinced of the need to ‘devenir aveugle aux choses vieilles’ (p. 200) in order to ‘see’, and develops this theme through the opposition of ‘ceux qui “raisonnent”’ and ‘ceux qui “voient”’ (among whom he clearly counts himself), stating that ‘ceux qui voient n’ont point besoin de raisonner, […] parce que ce qu’ils voient est “la raison” même’ (p. 216). Voir is directly linked to what he terms connaissance, as opposed to reason or intellect. Blindness to the external 21
88
The italics are Châteaubriant’s.
contemporary world, symbolic of the rejection of that world, is therefore linked with ‘vision’, which will permit knowledge and intelligence of God, since ‘avoir l’intelligence, c’est connaître Dieu’ (p. 257). The form of vision recommended rests on the theory of contemplation. Christ is presented as the perfect model (p. 242) whom humans should ‘contempler sans cesse pour lui devenir semblable’ (p. 224) and thereby access eternal life. But, according to Châteaubriant, many humans want neither to see nor understand (p. 223, p. 259) and so ignore the call to rebirth. Given this apparent widespread dismissal of the call to rebirth, Châteaubriant prefers to address his words to those who understand what it means to ‘see’ (p. 215). Throughout the Lettre à la chrétienté mourante he emphasises the need for an intuitive elite composed of ‘grands intellectuels sanctifiés’ (p. 56) who will bring about spiritual regeneration. This notion of an indispensable elite operating to generate a nouvelle chrétienté finds its echo in, for example, the nonconformist groups who also emphasised that ‘la révolution nécessaire est la révolution aristocratique’,22 and who called French intellectual youth to action in pursuit of a spiritual revolution. For these groups, France was the ‘terre décisive’23 where the revolution to save Europe and the West would take place. In contrast, Châteaubriant’s desired revolution was not necessarily rooted in France, although he did recognise the need to regenerate ‘le pays de France perdu’ (p. 5). But in neither the Lettre à la chrétienté mourante nor La Réponse du Seigneur does he allocate this mission to France alone, preferring instead to call on a group composed of those broadly defined as ‘ceux dont la mission est de penser’ (LCM, p. 57), who are nowhere characterised in specific national terms. Châteaubriant’s nouvelle chrétienté, then, is to be led by an intelligent Christian elite. To this theme, he subsequently adds a hierarchical 22 23
Thierry Maulnier, La Revue française, 4 (1933), p. 548; in Loubet del Bayle, p. 319. Robert Aron and Arnaud Dandieu, La Révolution nécessaire (Grasset, 1933), p. 277; in Loubet del Bayle, p. 321.
89
notion of Christianity, announcing that although ‘le christianisme est la religion de tous’, it is also ‘au-dessus de cela, une religion pour une élite’ (p. 173), and that the Christian is ‘un homme au-dessus de l’homme, […] un homme en qui le Christ accomplit ses merveilles’ (p. 239). Châteaubriant thereby reactivates the Nietzschean theory of the superman which he initially explored during the First World War. In the Lettre à la chrétienté mourante, he applies this theory to the domain of religion, arguing that humans can only become real supermen through religion. Nietzsche’s ‘error’, he suggests, was to create his superman ‘aux lieu et place du Christ’ (p. 96), thereby constructing only ‘l’homme presque nouveau’ (p. 84), while his own ‘true’, totally new superman is defined as ‘le Christ dans l’homme’ (p. 91). The function of the religieux within Châteaubriant’s hierarchical Christianity is to ‘abandonner la foule et ne songer qu’aux élites’, devoting their prayers to the benefit of the elite, ‘pour que les élites sauvent la foule’ (p. 174). He thereby clearly makes his heroes take the place of the saints, and considers that his new Christian elite rather than the traditional religieux will save the masses. His nouvelle chrétienté demands of this elite ‘autre chose que des credo obéissants’ of traditional, institutional religion, advocating instead ‘l’héroïsme individuel’ (p. 168). The final section of the Lettre à la chrétienté mourante takes the form of Châteaubriant’s explanation of the book of Revelation, and largely summarises earlier themes raised. In what amounts to an idiosyncratic magnification of the usual crise mentality, he turns the common Catastrophism of a mainstream Catholic thinker like Marcel Moré into a full-blown Apocalypticism, a theme favoured in the Middle Ages. The Apocalypse, Châteaubriant contends, represents not only ‘la conclusion de toute une série d’événements mythiques et historiques, qui débutent avec la Genèse’, but also ‘l’exposé de la solution donnée par Dieu lui-même aux inextricables difficultés créées par le péché humain’ (p. 213). He believes that the modern world is currently in the period of Great Tribulation detailed in Revelation 7.14, describing this as ‘l’aventure terrible de l’illusion de la chair’ (p. 259). The world’s refusal to promote God first and foremost (p. 260) has led to the 90
wrath of God visiting the earth in the form of the earthquakes, war, fire, plague, pain, blood, sores and demonic spirits of Revelation 16 (p. 262). The Beast of Revelation is a manifestation of all humans who have not received revelation (p. 252), while those who come through the Great Tribulation and succeed in detaching themselves from their ‘première naissance’ are ‘les rachetés de la terre’ (p. 262), further defined as ‘les voyants et les hommes de la seconde naissance’ (p. 263), men who will experience the new Jerusalem promised by Revelation. As will be seen, Châteaubriant’s apocalyptic interpretation of Revelation, his definition of Christianity as a religion for an elite, and his theory of human salvation effected by a new Christian elite, would become major elements of his spiritualisation of National-Socialist Germany.
La Réponse du Seigneur: a blueprint for the future Châteaubriant’s theory of a nouvelle chrétienté detailed in the Lettre à la chrétienté mourante receives further expression and elucidation in his third novel, La Réponse du Seigneur. In what stands as a restatement of his self-allocated spiritual ‘superiority’, he notes that in writing the text ‘il avait pensé s’adresser à la masse ignorante et matérialiste pour lui rappeler l’urgence des problèmes spirituels’.24 In Monsieur des Lourdines and La Brière, spiritual regeneration is limited to its achievement in single characters, namely Anthime and Aoustin. In La Réponse du Seigneur, however, it becomes a more ambitious project intended to be implemented on a much wider scale than is suggested in either earlier novel. The ageing De Mauvert wishes to pass on his ‘message’ to the 24
Joseph Calvet, ‘Une interview de Monsieur de Châteaubriant à propos de La Réponse du Seigneur’, Bulletin de l’Institut catholique de Paris, March (1934), 57–64 (p. 64).
91
travelling student who witnesses Mademoiselle de Mauvert’s funeral and subsequently becomes a guest at the château. De Mauvert sees the student as a providential visitor, the man for whom he has been waiting all his life (p. 87). He intends him to understand and take forth his message and ‘me remplacer dans le monde… faire ce que je n’ai pu faire… porter aux hommes ce que je n’ai pu leur porter’ (p. 221). A considerable section of the novel is devoted to the preparation of the student for the transmission of the message, although for some time he misunderstands his host’s purpose, a technique which permits Châteaubriant space and time for the elaboration of his ideas. Romantically minded, the student finds a girl’s bonnet (p. 111) which, along with his host’s comment that ‘vous êtes déjà un peu ici comme mon fils’ (p. 88), he interprets as evidence that De Mauvert has a daughter, a Sleeping Beauty figure who lives in an old tower of the castle and whom he is destined to marry. It is only when De Mauvert eventually reveals his message towards the end of the novel that the student is finally disabused of his dreams. In the communication of the message, Châteaubriant employs De Mauvert as a channel through which to make substantial speeches directly related to his programme for regeneration. A major element of this programme is his notion of servir, which Châteaubriant develops within his theory of the collective unit, and which exalts the principles of order and mutual duty in contrast to the alleged harm caused by individualism. His belief in the benefits of feudal society was clearly expressed in his earlier writings, and he now builds on these themes in order to promote his vision of the ideal head of a community as leader, model and servant of the masses. De Mauvert’s praise for feudal society is rooted in the concept of servir. His understanding of the role of the gentilhomme campagnard emphasises that: On n’était pas sur terre pour se faire servir. On ne venait le premier que pour mieux servir soi-même. Tout le monde servait, selon la hiérarchie, chacun à sa place, ce qui est au-dessus de tous; et commander et obéir était le même grand acte commun. (p. 126)
92
And, in what stands as further evidence of Châteaubriant’s rejection of the Ancien Régime, he has De Mauvert regret ‘les habitudes salonnières que pour le plus grand mal du pays nous avons été prendre à la cour des rois’ (p. 125) and evoke in preference the period when ‘maîtres et serviteurs jouaient tous ensemble aux boules, et tous ensemble luttaient sur l’aire’ (p. 128). This reading of leadership would become especially significant within Châteaubriant’s later appreciation of National-Socialist Germany. The theme of the leader as an ideal model for ordinary people to aim to emulate provides an opening for Châteaubriant to explore his theory of contemplation, introduced in the Lettre à la chrétienté mourante (p. 224), and now given full development in La Réponse du Seigneur as the methodology for human salvation. Châteaubriant roots this theory in the Bible. He has De Mauvert suggest that ‘je trouverais tout dans ce synopsis de la vérité, si je savais le lire avec l’esprit que Dieu veut’ (RS, p. 207), and thus advocates a return to a particular reading of the Bible in the search for regeneration, which shows that he considers that there is a ‘right’ (and so equally a ‘wrong’) way to read God’s word. For De Mauvert, humans have wrongly contemplated themselves, centring their existence on themselves rather than on God and therefore ignoring the first commandment in Exodus 20.3 that ‘Tu n’auras pas d’autres dieux devant ma Face’ (p. 200). Verses from Deuteronomy, Isaiah and Kings follow in De Mauvert’s exhortation of the need to contemplate God and Christ (p. 201), which together underline the concept that ‘sans vision, le peuple périt’, written in Proverbs 29.18 and first referenced by Châteaubriant in La Meute (p. 118). De Mauvert believes that contemplation through prayer offers the key to salvation, proclaiming that ‘la perfection naît de la contemplation de la Perfection’ (RS, p. 284). Indeed, as he continues: ‘Quand l’homme contemple Dieu et devient semblable à Dieu, […] ce sont les lourdes chaînes du vieil homme qui tombent à ses pieds […]. Et alors, là se lève un géant chevelu’ (pp. 301–02). In order to explain his message to the student, De Mauvert offers three illustrations of his theory of salvation through contemplation 93
and prayer. The first exploits a story by Nathaniel Hawthorne set in a village at the foot of a rocky escarpment in which nature has sculpted a human face.25 Legend has it that one day a man resembling the rock sculpture will arrive in the village and carry out good works. A village child grows up entranced by this story, constantly watching the rockface and wondering when the promised hero will arrive. As the years go by and the child becomes an adult, he grows to resemble the rock sculpture, until one day his fellow villagers realise that the man predicted by the story is already among them. By dint of contemplation, says De Mauvert, the child became the object of his contemplation (p. 172). The student’s incomprehension of this tale leads De Mauvert to attempt a second illustration, this time based on the Dürer engraving The Knight, Death and the Devil (1513), which depicts a heavily-armoured knight forging his way forward, oblivious of the two grotesque images of Death and the Devil which try to accost him. De Mauvert’s interpretation suggests that the knight was saved from his human misery through contemplation of ‘le rempart de salut, […] la cité de Dieu’ (p. 179), and that, armed and transformed by prayer, he becomes ‘l’homme pardonné et nouveau’ (p. 180), while Death and the Devil become nothing more than vestiges of the old world. The student is somewhat sceptical, saying to De Mauvert that the Bible extracts he has used ‘ne sont que des textes’ (p. 183), that Hawthorne’s story ‘n’est qu’une légende’ (ibid.) and that ‘votre chevalier n’est qu’un conte’ (p. 184). Having thus far failed to convince the student of his message through abstract discussion, De Mauvert moves to a final concrete illustration based on his interpretation of mimesis, and shows the student a leaf on which a butterfly has alighted and remained, ultimately fusing with the leaf until the two are barely distinguishable (p. 193). De Mauvert has no interest in this as a scientific chameleonlike process, whereby the butterfly may have been trying to hide from 25
94
Châteaubriant provides no title, but the story referred to is The Great Stone Face, published in The Snow-Image and Other Twice-Told Tales (Edinburgh: Paterson, 1851).
its hunters, and suggests that the real interest lies instead in asking how rather than why the butterfly acted in this way (p. 196). He argues that ‘ce papillon a voulu devenir ce qu’il avait intérêt à devenir’, and that this came about because ‘le papillon n’a pas fait lui-même autre chose que prier’ (p. 199). The butterfly’s mimesis represents a lesson for all humanity, ‘que prier n’est pas demander à recevoir, mais demander à devenir’ (p. 205). Humans must adopt the butterfly’s state of total acceptance (p. 211), based both on ‘la foi simple, lucide, fondamentale, la foi des premières heures’ (p. 212) and on complete humility (p. 213). De Mauvert’s message thus offers an invitation to self-transformation through prayer and contemplation of an ideal, a message defined as ‘la clé peut-être du salut de tant d’hommes’ (p. 216).
Orthodoxy or heterodoxy? Châteaubriant’s dissatisfaction with the traditional, institutional Catholic Church, which we have traced to his early writings, features also in La Réponse du Seigneur, with De Mauvert’s comment that, for him, faith is something other than ‘la croyance aux dogmes qu’enseigne l’Église’ (p. 130). Moreover, references to the Church are as scarce in this text as in his other writings, for the Church is exploited as the location for Mademoiselle de Mauvert’s funeral (p. 41) but otherwise plays no direct role in the novel. With the publication of La Réponse du Seigneur in June 1933, contemporary critics openly deliberated for the first time over the orthodox or heterodox nature of Châteaubriant’s spiritual thought, based on an examination of his contemplation theory. None, however, saw the seeds of his development in his first two novels or his short stories, as we have argued, and none related his fictional exploration of his brand of nouvelle chrétienté to his theoretical examination of the theme in the articles published in La Revue universelle both before and after the novel 95
appeared, and which later formed part of the posthumous Lettre à la chrétienté mourante.26 The first reviews of La Réponse du Seigneur appeared in July 1933, and were generally cautious, if not openly critical. In L’Europe nouvelle, for example, Gabriel Marcel wrote that Châteaubriant’s contemplation theory represented ‘un raccourci qui pourrait éveiller certaines objections chez un théologien’, on the basis that, as André Billy argued in L’Œuvre, the novel suggests that ‘le mysticisme devient ainsi du mimétisme’, in other words, that what is science is presented as theology. Châteaubriant’s persistent lack of reference to the authority of the Church led Yves Gandon, writing in the Rightwing L’Intransigeant, to detect a ‘fumet d’hérésie’ in the novel, and caused Billy to conclude that ‘en d’autres temps, la Faculté de théologie eût certainement condamné et fait brûler le roman de Châteaubriant’.27 These reviews in the non-confessional press were matched in tone by an early review in the confessional press, published in the Dominican journal La Vie intellectuelle – set up to further Catholic social teaching in the modern world and to dialogue with it – where the contemplation theory is described as ‘une mystique dangereuse [qui] n’aboutit qu’à un chimérique égarement’, on the basis that it looks at ‘things’ rather than at God. Moreover, in his review, the Right-wing Catholic writer Robert Valléry-Radot questioned the novel’s hierarchical notion of Christianity, suggesting that ‘peut-être ce livre laisse-t-il se dégager de lui quelques vagues relents de théosophie’, a comment which undoubtedly refers to De Mauvert’s claim to
26 27
96
Twelve extracts from the future Lettre à la chrétienté mourante were published in La Revue universelle in 1933, and a further five extracts were published in 1934 (see the bibliography for details). Gabriel Marcel, ‘La Réponse du Seigneur par Alphonse de Châteaubriant’, L’Europe nouvelle, 16 (1933), 695–96 (p. 696); André Billy, ‘La Réponse du Seigneur’, L’Œuvre, 11 July 1933, p. 5; Yves Gandon, ‘La Réponse du Seigneur’, L’Intransigeant, 6 July 1933, p. 2.
personal divine inspiration (or illumination, as Châteaubriant would prefer) and to the emphasis on natural forces in the novel.28 Châteaubriant clearly did not consider his thought to be out of step with true Christian ideas, or at least with his reading of them. In a series of letters to Jacques Copeau in July and August 1933, he attacked his critics’ ‘failure’ to understand the novel (or, to employ his own style, to ‘see’ the truth contained therein), writing that: La plupart ne comprennent pas, parce qu’il faudrait faire un effort qu’ils ne savent pas faire. Quelques-uns ne veulent pas comprendre. Ils ont réussi à convaincre tout le monde de l’absurdité des idées contenues dans ma pitoyable élucubration.29
He further categorically refuted Valléry-Radot’s charge of theosophy, announcing that ‘mon livre n’a rien d’un livre de théosophie. Il contient exactement la métaphysique de saint Paul…, qui est la grande métaphysique chrétienne’ (p. 88), a claim no doubt justified in his eyes by Saint Paul’s emphasis on the idea of the ‘new man’ – a theme central to Châteaubriant’s own project for regeneration. Keen to cast La Réponse du Seigneur in a favourable light, Châteaubriant announced to Copeau that he had received several individual commendatory letters, some from ordinary priests and people, and others from well known writers, including ‘un mot très touché et significatif de M. [Henri] Bergson’ (author of Les Deux sources de la morale et de la religion, 1932) and ‘trois pages serrées très approbatrices et chaleureuses d’Ét[ienne] Gilson, directeur des Hautes Études Religieuses’ (p. 85),
28
29
G.S., ‘La Réponse du Seigneur’, La Vie intellectuelle, 23 (1933), 470–73 (p. 471); Robert Valléry-Radot, ‘La Réponse du Seigneur’, La Revue hebdomadaire, 32 (1933), 7. Mounier’s journal Esprit would also not have approved of the novel on the basis of its theory of nouvelle chrétienté, although there is no review to confirm this conclusion. Louis-Alphonse Maugendre, ‘Alphonse de Châteaubriant et Copeau’, La Pensée catholique, 169 (1977), 83–88 (pp. 84–85). Subsequent immediate references to this article are given in the text.
97
the latter’s approval being especially surprising since he is generally regarded as in the mainstream of nouvelle chrétienté.30 To counter the negative press La Réponse du Seigneur received, Henri Massis – the director of La Revue universelle – mobilised sympathetic writers like Copeau to an open defence of the novel,31 with the result that several reviews in the confessional press were distinctly more favourable, if somewhat general in their approach, and viewed the text as an illustration of spiritual conviction rather than heterodoxy. For José Vincent, writing in La Croix, the Catholic newspaper par excellence, the novel was ‘un avertissement providentiel à notre temps’; in his review for La Vie catholique (which had been rejected by Le Temps),32 Jacques Copeau argued that ‘après avoir lu ce livre, on prie mieux’; while in the Jesuit Études, Louis de Mondadon defined Châteaubriant as a ‘chrétien convaincu’.33 Châteaubriant welcomed these reviews, writing that ‘c’est dans les journaux et les revues de cette nuance que je désire être défendu, d’une façon qui porte et par des personnalités qui comptent’,34 and so clearly indicating that he wanted official Catholic acceptance in validation of his ideas. He was, therefore, particularly pleased at the appreciative reception he enjoyed on the occasion of an open interview on his book held in February 1934 under the presidency of Monseigneur Baudrillart at the Institut catholique in Paris, and reported in its bulletin a month later.35 Many Right-wing Catholics of the day disregarded elements of the Church’s social teaching but without moving into heterodoxy. 30 31 32 33
34 35
98
There is no hard evidence of the existence of these letters. Maugendre, Alphonse de Châteaubriant, p. 163. Massis published several articles by Châteaubriant in 1933 and 1934 (see note 26). Ibid. José Vincent, ‘La Réponse du Seigneur’, La Croix, 15 October 1933, p. 3 & p. 4 (p. 3); Jacques Copeau, ‘La Réponse du Seigneur’, La Vie catholique, 2 September 1933, p. 16; Louis de Mondadon, ‘Un roman mystique: La Réponse du Seigneur’, Études, 3 (1933), 587–99 (p. 599). Maugendre, ‘Châteaubriant et Copeau’, 169 (1977), p. 87. See Calvet, ‘Une interview de Monsieur de Châteaubriant’.
Châteaubriant is an exception, however, on the grounds that he did not simply ignore the Church, but chose to consider its modern teaching inadequate, to bypass its systems and recommendations, and to put forward his own programme for regeneration in its place, based on the framework of Catholic mentality he had acquired through his religious education and his reading of Christian texts and debate. Moreover, as a self-nominated seer with a special insight into ‘truth’ and ‘essence’, Châteaubriant certainly did not possess the modesty he recommended to others. He was a bad Catholic on the level of humility and obedience to the Church, and La Réponse du Seigneur must be read as an illustration of heterodoxy because of the brand of Catholicism it advocates. And yet there was no official criticism of the text, while other reviews – many of them published in the Catholic press – were evidently sympathetic. Châteaubriant’s earlier writings had signalled his heterodox tendencies, but with La Réponse du Seigneur he took for the first time a very public step further down his chosen pathway, openly walking the fine line between heterodoxy and orthodoxy.
Crusaders and heroes La Réponse du Seigneur overflows with references to the Middle Ages, from the link identified between the De Mauvert family and the Knights Templar, to the inclusion of the story of the Holy Grail, and the role allocated to the student as ‘le jeune Perceval, […] l’évangéliste attendu, […] le chevalier de la contemplation’,36 and whom De 36
Paul Audiat, ‘La Réponse du Seigneur’, La Revue de France, 4 (1933), 704–08 (p. 705, p. 708). In German literature, the character of Percival is named Siegfried, a name later used by Châteaubriant in La Gerbe des forces to describe the National Socialists.
99
Mauvert hopes will travel the world to proclaim the message of spiritual regeneration, thereby acting as a modern crusader in the style of the medieval knights De Mauvert so esteems. Where Châteaubriant’s earlier writings offer indications of his admiration for the medieval age, La Réponse du Seigneur serves to illustrate and explain this appreciation in some detail, underlining the importance of the period in terms of his programme for human regeneration and the form that he predicts that this will take. Early in the novel, De Mauvert introduces the student to the ‘grandes époques’ of the Middle Ages and recommends that he read the stories of the Knights Templar, the Knights of Saint John, and the Knights of Malta and Rhodes (p. 66), as well as the story of the Holy Grail, ‘le plus beau roman qu’on pût lire’ (p. 69). Châteaubriant’s admiration for the medieval chevalier focuses particularly on the Knights Templar and the Knights of the Holy Grail. As the Knights of King Arthur, Galahad and his comrades are the elite incarnation of a temporal authority. But Châteaubriant underlines that their primary role is spiritual, resting on their quest to recover the Holy Grail, defined as ‘le divin trésor’ which represents ‘le Salut du monde’ (p. 70). De Mauvert suggests that their mission accords them ‘des airs de moniales’, each accomplishing ‘l’acte qui vient le premier de tous par excellence […], à regarder le vase sublime, à regarder devant soi le Graal’ (p. 71). Turning to the Knights Templar, De Mauvert notes that they are seen to have acquired power in the temporal domain through their military role and their administration of finance. But, in their case also, their primary role is deemed to be a spiritual one, since their temporal activities are carried out ‘sous l’emblème de la croix et la main sur l’Évangile’ (p. 102). They always wear the sign of the cross whether in times of peace or war, and are defined overall as ‘des moines guerriers, armés de foi dedans et de fer au dehors […] qui acceptaient jusqu’à la mort l’exil et la guerre sainte’ (p. 101). Both the Knights Templar and the Knights of the Holy Grail are used to represent a fusion of the spiritual and the temporal, but with the temporal subordinated to the primacy of the spiritual. The ‘warrior100
monk’ idea was clearly attractive to those on the Right as the Spanish Civil War drew nearer, and would also have a certain impact in France during the Vichy Regime.37 Châteaubriant, however, followed a different pathway with his own particular vision of the warrior-monks, since, as we shall discover, he would choose to see the German National Socialists – and especially the SS – as new Teutonic Knights, and so as modern-day warrior-monks. At the end of La Réponse du Seigneur, De Mauvert tells the student to direct his efforts at an elite group of sacrificateurs, defined as ‘ceux qui, par une contemplation infatigable, travailleront à recomposer au profit de l’espèce l’idéal dont elle a besoin’ (p. 300). The sacrificateurs, we are told, will save the world: ‘Voilà les hommes qu’il nous faut’, announces De Mauvert, adding that ‘et il est grand temps qu’ils apparaissent!’ (ibid.). Châteaubriant’s sacrificateurs are his incarnation of Nietzsche’s supermen and Thomas Carlyle’s heroes. His reading of Carlyle, referenced in his diaries in June 1931 (C, p. 110), indicates that he was influenced by Carlyle’s respect for strength and his conviction of a God-given mission as seen, for example, in his On Heroes, HeroWorship, and the Heroic in History (1841). Such themes find their echo in La Réponse du Seigneur where he predicts the imminent arrival of a new breed of elite warrior-monks, described as ‘des chevaleries humaines sublimées qui assureront bel et bien un ordre nouveau sur la terre’ (RS, p. 305), men who will carry out a new crusade to rechristianise the world and re-impose the primacy of the spiritual, thereby implementing a nouvelle chrétienté to replace the désordre établi. This elite will represent that predicted at the end of the story of the Holy Grail, which announced that ‘dans un certain avenir, d’autres temps paraîtront, marquant la fin de ces âges de l’aventure et l’heure prédestinée où les “chevaleries terriennes” seront devenues des “chevaleries célestiennes”’ (ibid.). But this new crusade will operate on
37
See John Hellman, The Knight-Monks of Vichy France: Uriage 1940–1945 (Montreal: McGill–Queen’s, 1993).
101
a much greater scale, for the new chevaliers will number far more than the eighteen Knights of King Arthur, consisting instead of: […] des centaines et des centaines de milliers, toute l’immense armée humaine devenue nécessaire, et contemplant non plus la substance orfévrée d’un vaisseau, mais la nouvelle naissance qui nous est promise. (ibid.)
For Châteaubriant, the hour of the new crusade would soon strike. In both its critique of the modern world and its project of regeneration, Châteaubriant’s nouvelle chrétienté can be profitably compared to that of other Catholic thinkers in the 1920s and 1930s, in particular the pre-1930s Maritain of Antimoderne and La Primauté du spirituel. Common points include anti-individualism and antimaterialism, an emphasis on the primacy of spiritual, on the need for a new order to replace the established order, and for hommes nouveaux and an elite to lead regeneration, as well as reference to the medieval period. And yet his programme does not correspond either in register or content to Maritain’s project as later expressed in Humanisme intégral. Châteaubriant’s emphasis on Christianity as a religion above all for an elite resulted in an uncommon hierarchical notion of Christianity, further defined by his call for a Christian elite group of warrior-monks to save the world and by his idea of what constituted appropriate leadership. His rejection of neo-Thomism and his preference for his reading of Augustinianism (based on his opposition of intelligence and intellect, of ‘essence’ and ‘existence’), as well as his emphasis on the total renewal of the world rather than the adaptation of former principles to the present situation, all served further to differentiate his idiosyncratic nouvelle chrétienté from the mainstream. Châteaubriant wrote in his diaries in June 1929 that his contemplation theory: […] contient tout un programme, je veux dire toute une philosophie, toute une religion, toute une conception individuelle et collective, c’est-à-dire toute une science de la vie en général et jusqu’à une méthode de direction politique. (C, p. 90)
102
Evidently able to conceive of his contemplation theory as a potential method of political direction, he also thereby revealed his conviction that the political could and should be spiritually inspired. The fact that La Réponse du Seigneur was completed on 31 May 1933 (RS, p. 313), just four months after Adolf Hitler became Chancellor of Germany on 30 January 1933, is, of course, a coincidence. With the advent of Hitler to power, 1933 marked the beginning of a turbulent period in European history. The period is equally significant in the telling of Châteaubriant’s history, for his particular nouvelle chrétienté would shortly find its incarnation in National-Socialist Germany.
103
This page intentionally left blank
4 Gesta Dei per Germanos
If ‘jadis, les Croisades furent des gesta Dei per Francos’,1 then, for Alphonse de Châteaubriant, National Socialism would represent a new crusade – or what can be termed gesta Dei per Germanos – for he would regard Hitler’s Germany as a salutary force not only for France but for Europe as a whole, a force capable of bringing about the renaissance and respiritualisation of nations and peoples floundering in the depths of the modern crisis of civilisation. This belief underpinned his collaboration with Germany during the Second World War. That Châteaubriant was a committed and active collaborator is without doubt, and his own words and deeds prove the point. But it is the nature of his personal response to Fascism which indicates the pathway he followed in his reading of National Socialism. His early writings raise certain themes which can be identified in 1930s Fascism, such as his anti-individualist, anti-modern, anti-democratic and anticapitalist tendencies, as well as his emphasis on spiritual regeneration and heroic leadership. But many shared such ideas without necessarily adopting Fascism as a result, as Marc Simard has shown,2 and Châteaubriant certainly did not see himself as a Fascist or openly support Fascism. It would be superficial to define Châteaubriant as a Fascist just because he endorsed Hitler’s Germany and became an active collaborator, for such a conclusion not only ignores Sartre’s accurate pronouncement that not all collaborators were by definition 1 2
Léon Poliakov, Le Mythe aryen: essai sur les sources du racisme et des nationalismes (Brussels: Éditions Complexe, 1987), p. 29. ‘Qu’ils se disent personnalistes, fascistes, nationalistes ou même spiritualistes, [beaucoup] ont en commun cette hantise de la modernité. […] Le fascisme ne serait qu’une des pousses ayant crû dans le terreau fertile de la pensée antimoderne’ (Marc Simard, ‘Intellectuels, fascisme et antimodernité dans la France des années trente’, Vingtième Siècle, 17 (1988), 55–75 (p. 73)).
Fascists, but also takes insufficient account of the true reasons behind Châteaubriant’s individual commitment. As we shall discover, despite the common ground he shared with a French intellectual Fascism, it is unsatisfactory to identify Châteaubriant as a Fascist in the manner of a Brasillach or a Drieu, for example, precisely because his principal theme is an original form and treatment of nouvelle chrétienté. In his case, the sensitive and shocking truth (especially for Catholics) is that he would collaborate because of his particular interpretation of his religious faith rather than because of any particular sympathy with Fascism. He was not interested in National Socialism as an end in itself, or as a manifestation of a temporal, contemporary political ideology (that is, as a German Fascism), as many others were, but instead chose to interpret and to endorse it as the modern-day incarnation of the eternal and universal Christian values he prized so highly. This is not to say that Châteaubriant was no Fascist (indeed, the evidence to the contrary is persuasive), but rather to note that he himself never acknowledged that his tendencies were fascist and never claimed Fascism as his motivation. What is certain is that his personal and idiosyncratic interpretation of National Socialism and his choice of pathway in the 1930s – expounded in La Gerbe des forces: Nouvelle Allemagne (1937) – set the seal on his future collaboration.
The turbulent Thirties and the rise of intellectual Fascism Within France, there was a widespread belief during the early years of the decade that the nation had ‘entered a period of crisis marked by a sense of political, social and moral, and economic malaise’.3 The world economic crisis engendered by the Wall Street Crash in 1929 began to 3
106
James McMillan, Twentieth-Century France: Politics and Society 1898–1991 (Edward Arnold, 1992), p. 102.
take effect in France from 1931 and sent economic confidence plummeting. A series of short-lived governments proved incapable of formulating a satisfactory solution to the nation’s difficulties, creating an atmosphere of general political incompetence. Then, during 1933 and 1934, a series of scandals served to level accusations of immorality and financial and political corruption at Third Republic society and its institutions. In Notre avant-guerre (1941), Brasillach records the nation’s fascination with the Violette Nozières case (1933), and exploits Nozière’s patricide and her alleged involvement in a seedy world of drugs and sexual depravity as illustrative of contemporary decadence and ‘un atroce monde sans Dieu’ (pp. 143–44). Other minor scandals followed, but paled into insignificance alongside the notorious Stavisky Affair. Stavisky was a financier of dubious honesty who had escaped prosecution for years, allegedly thanks to influential friends within the government itself, and who apparently committed suicide in January 1934 while wanted for questioning on fraud charges. The Right relished such indications of Republican corruption which they considered symptomatic of a weak parliamentary regime, and even claimed that Stavisky had been murdered in an attempt to shield his ministerial protectors. Indignation at the subsequent alleged cover-up by Premier Daladier turned the Affair into a major political crisis, sparking the events of 6 February 1934 when several extreme Rightwing leagues (including Pierre Taittinger’s Jeunesses patriotes, François Coty’s Solidarité française and the Camelots du Roi) staged violent antigovernment street demonstrations. Their identifiably fascist traits (anti-parliamentarianism, anti-liberalism, pro-nationalism and cult of order and action) prompted many Republican politicians to believe that they represented a broad-based Right-wing plot to overthrow the Republic and install a French-style dictatorship in its place. But the disparate nature of the groups involved, coupled with the low-key or non-involvement of other groups on the day (Colonel de la Rocque’s Croix de Feu and Marcel Bucard’s Francistes respectively), indicate that
107
the extreme Right actually lacked unity of plan and action, and historians widely agree that 6 February was no organised conspiracy.4 And yet the importance of these events in the development of Fascism in France should not be underestimated, for they revealed a significant level of dissatisfaction with the current regime and indicated, as James McMillan has pointed out, that ‘French democracy was […] vulnerable and by no means predestined to escape the fate of Italy, Germany or Spain’.5 For the purposes of this study in particular, however, the importance of February 1934 rests on its motivating role in the development and crystallisation of a French intellectual Fascism. This did not suddenly originate in the February 1934 events, but resulted instead from what Raoul Girardet has called a more gradual ‘phénomène d’imprégnation fasciste dans l’histoire du nationalisme français entre les deux guerres’.6 The appearance of a string of extreme Right-wing journals such as 1928, 1933 and 1934, in which antimodern, anti-capitalist, pro-order and pro-youth themes were major features, indicates that the scent of Fascism was definitely in the air in the late 1920s and early 1930s. But many intellectuals did not actually openly adhere to Fascism until after 6 February 1934, as evidenced by the case histories of Robert Brasillach and Pierre Drieu la Rochelle, both of whom were observers rather than participants in the events. For them, Fascism’s value was rooted in the potential it offered for spiritual regeneration from modern decadence. In Notre avant-guerre, Brasillach describes 6 February – despite its failure – as ‘une instinctive et magnifique révolte’, which represented the ‘espérance invincible d’une Révolution nationale, la naissance exacte du nationalisme social 4
5 6
108
See ibid., p. 107; Maurice Larkin, France since the Popular Front: Government and People 1936–1996, 2nd edn (Oxford: Clarendon Press, 1997 [1988]), p. 50; Jean Plumyène and René Lasierra, Les Fascismes français 1923–1963 (Seuil, 1963), p. 77. McMillan, Twentieth-Century France, p. 107. Raoul Girardet, ‘Notes sur l’esprit d’un fascisme français’, Revue française de science politique, 5 (1955), 529–46 (pp. 530–31). The italics are the author’s.
de notre pays’ (p. 161).7 Les Captifs, begun while Brasillach was a prisoner of war in Germany in 1940, provides a fictional account of his personal commitment to Fascism, recording the main character’s conversion following the 1934 riots, full of admiration for the passion and spontaneity he sees on the streets and convinced that he has found a new ‘faith’. Equally in direct response to 6 February, Drieu publicly proclaimed himself a Fascist in March 1934, and, later the same year, published Socialisme fasciste in which he expounds his theory of Fascism as spiritual regeneration. In his later novel, Gilles (1939), Drieu’s hero also views February 1934 and the emergence of Fascism in France in terms of renewal, saying of the events that ‘c’est la première fois que je vis depuis vingt ans’ (p. 597). For men such as Brasillach and Drieu, for the men of Je suis partout or L’Insurgé – extreme Right-wing publications par excellence8 – the appeal of Fascism lay in its esprit rather than in its potential as a political or economic doctrine. Poetry, romanticism and enthusiasm litter their individual accounts of their encounter with that spirit. In their eyes, Fascism was the realisation of a long-held regenerative aspiration, while fascist man was an almost mythical hero-figure embodying the élan vital necessary for human renewal. For these men, as Girardet has suggested, ‘c’est aux forces passionnelles, c’est à l’imagination et c’est à la sensibilité que le fascisme français prétend d’abord s’adresser’.9 Châteaubriant clearly shared such regenerative aspirations, although he was no card-carrying Fascist, as we have already suggested. No written evidence exists, for instance, of his personal response to the events of February 1934, or of any involvement in the leagues, or of any self-proclamation as a Fascist in the manner of Brasillach and Drieu. He did occasionally encounter Brasillach at the 7 8 9
The programme of the Vichy Regime would be termed the révolution nationale. Under the influence of Brasillach, Bardèche, Rebatet and others, Je suis partout (founded 1930) swiftly became the most violent extreme Right-wing, proFascist publication of the period. L’Insurgé was founded in 1937. Girardet, ‘Notes sur l’esprit’, p. 532.
109
offices of the journal 1933, as Brasillach records,10 but never contributed to its pages. He also signed the October 1935 Manifeste des intellectuels français pour la défense de l’Occident et la paix en Europe, which was produced in support of Italian nationalism and expansion into Ethiopia, and which was (not surprisingly) described by the Left-wing Europe as the ‘manifeste des intellectuels fascistes’.11 But signatories to the manifesto were not exclusively fascist, for Right-wing, non-fascist Catholics such as Henri Massis and Marcel Moré could be found among their number. Châteaubriant evidently operated on the edges of a French intellectual Fascism, motivated by the same desire for regeneration, but which – in his case – was set in a particular and highly individual ‘Christian’ context. His commitment to NationalSocialist Germany rested on his interpretation of Christianity.
Explorers of Fascism From 1934, young French fascist intellectuals like Brasillach, Drieu, Rebatet and Jouvenel travelled Europe, keen to discover foreign fascist countries and to witness Fascism in practice. Their numerous exploratory journeys took them to Italy, Germany, Belgium and Spain, but also to less obvious destinations such as Romania and England. Some travelled extensively, often making repeated trips to the same country.12 For many of the future collaborators, these journeys represented an initiation into the fascist experience, and functioned, as Pascal Ory has argued, ‘comme autant de préludes à l’engagement 10 11 12
110
Robert Brasillach, Œuvres complètes, ed. by Maurice Bardèche, 12 vols (Club de l’honnête homme, 1963–66), VI (1964), 608–09. Europe, 15 November 1935, p. 449. Brasillach, for instance, visited Spain (1934, 1938, 1939), Belgium (1935, 1936), Italy (twice in 1937) and Germany (1936, 1937); Drieu visited Germany (1934, 1936) as well as Italy and Spain (both in 1936).
décisif en terrain français’.13 But Alphonse de Châteaubriant, born in 1877 into a different generation, was not one of these young fascist explorers, and, in contrast to others at the time, his experience of foreign Fascism was limited. He did make a short trip to Belgium in 1935, but never travelled to Italy or Spain, focusing his attention instead on Germany, as we shall do here, which he visited initially in 1935 prior to an expedition of several months’ duration from May to December 1936, following which he produced his study of Hitler’s Germany, La Gerbe des forces.14 The end of the First World War had triggered a widespread conviction among intellectuals that Franco-German rapprochement was the only way to avoid another conflict between the two nations. In the first half of the 1920s, such conviction was expressed in, for example, Paul Colin’s Allemagne (1918–1921) (1923), an enthusiastic account of a visit to Germany, or André Lamande’s Ton pays sera le mien (1925), in which the author considered the prospects for a FrancoGerman ‘marriage’. In the later 1920s and early 1930s, further efforts were made in France to support intellectual rapprochement, notably the creation of new journals of pro-German tendencies such as La Revue européenne (which reviewed Monsieur des Lourdines and La Brière in 1926, and serialised La Meute in 1927), L’Europe nouvelle (which reviewed La Réponse du Seigneur in 1933) and La Revue d’Allemagne. Other significant events included a programme of exchange lectures given by such well known French and German writers as Jean Giraudoux, André Gide, Thomas Mann and Ernst Robert Curtius; and celebrations in France in 1932 to mark the hundredth anniversary of Goethe’s death.15 13 14 15
Ory, Les Collaborateurs, p. 24. Maugendre, Alphonse de Châteaubriant, p. 188, p. 190, p. 194. For details of these and other Franco-German cultural events, see Jean-Marie Carré, Les Écrivains français et le mirage allemand (1800–1940) (Boivin, 1947), pp. 176–79. Carré also notes French concerns about Germany’s activity and intentions, as indicated by, for example, Jacques Bainville’s articles in Action française between 1918 and 1933 (p. 179).
111
Adolf Hitler’s arrival in power in January 1933 was accompanied by a German eagerness to showcase National Socialism. A key figure in this process was the self-confessed Francophile Otto Abetz, who would be appointed Germany’s Ambassador to France during the Occupation, and who had been involved in the organisation of Franco-German youth meetings since 1930.16 From 1934, Abetz organised trips around Germany for invited French intellectuals and journalists, including Châteaubriant, during which they experienced showpiece events such as the annual Nuremberg Congress or the 1936 Berlin Olympic Games, all expenses paid. The almost inevitable result of such trips was the publication of the French visitors’ impressions of National-Socialist Germany and of Hitler himself, who sometimes gave appeasing interviews to his French admirers. The first of these was accorded to Fernand de Brinon on 19 November 1933, and an account of the event was published in the Right-wing daily Le Matin four days later. A string of books and articles on Germany followed, including Châteaubriant’s panegyric La Gerbe des forces, published in May 1937, and his enthusiastic account of his interview with Hitler on 13 August 1937, published in Le Journal on 2 September 1938.17 Had Châteaubriant died in 1933, upon the completion of La Réponse du Seigneur, he would have been remembered as a novelist in the traditional and regionalist mould and as an author of works with a 16
17
112
In 1935, Abetz was a prime mover in the relaunch of the Deutsch–Französische Gesellschaft and its French equivalent, the Comité France–Allemagne, and also played a part in the control of the associated journal, the Deutsch–Französische Monatshefte – otherwise known as the Cahiers franco-allemands – in which Châteaubriant would publish four articles between 1937 and 1943. Others who interviewed Hitler include Jacques Chastenet (Le Temps, 17 December 1933); Lucien Lemas (L’Intransigeant, 13 September 1934); Jean Goy (Le Matin, 18 November 1934); Bertrand de Jouvenel (La Flèche, 7 March 1936). Other publications by ‘explorers’ of National-Socialist Germany include Louis Bertrand, Hitler (Fayard, 1936); Robert Brasillach, ‘Cent heures chez Hitler’, La Revue universelle, 61 (1937), 55–74; Pierre-Antoine Cousteau, ‘Nuremberg, cœur de l’Allemagne’, Je suis partout, 10 September 1937, p. 9.
spiritual flavour.18 That persona was at least partially sustained by the fact that other significant writings – such as the Lettres des années de guerre 1914–1918, or his Cahiers 1906–1951, or the Lettre à la chrétienté mourante, all of which, as we have shown, contain important pointers to a full and proper understanding of Châteaubriant’s thought and earlier published works – did not reach the public arena until after his death in 1951. With the benefit of hindsight, it is clear that Monsieur des Lourdines, La Brière and La Réponse du Seigneur detail both Châteaubriant’s response to the modern world and the development of his project for regeneration, and are therefore integral to his evolution towards collaboration. But that conclusion could not have been drawn at the time, and no contemporary critic saw the path Châteaubriant was treading. In 1937, the content of La Gerbe des forces took intellectual France by surprise. Today, however, the combination of Châteaubriant’s pro-German stance, which we identified at the end of the First World War, and his search for a suitable incarnation of his nouvelle chrétienté, suggests that he was almost predestined to locate his quest in Germany, and that he was therefore incapable of objective investigation and report. Châteaubriant himself admits no such thing, of course, and argues instead that ‘je suis parti non point convaincu que je trouverais là-bas ce que je cherchai, mais animé énergiquement du désir d’interroger et de comprendre’ (GF, pp. 9–10). La Gerbe des forces does confirm his enthusiasm for inquiry. But, as we shall discover, it also demonstrates his swift acceptance of his hosts’ statements and explanations, betrays an obvious lack of reference to certain aspects of National Socialism, and simply dismisses others, suggesting that he saw what he wanted to see and heard what he wanted to hear, unaware of or ignoring everything else. Clearly the 1930s marks a period when Châteaubriant would become more directly involved in the events of the day, but his exploratory journeys across the Rhine serve to endorse long-held ideas rather than to generate new ones, while La Gerbe des forces stands as a mid-1930s 18
Pascal Ory makes a similar but undeveloped point (Les Collaborateurs, p. 15).
113
expression of his long-standing commitment to a policy of alliance with his particular Germany, exhibiting a single-mindedness which is confirmed by his general lack of reference to other fascist countries.19
France and the Popular Front: a diagnosis of errors The beginning of Châteaubriant’s second exploratory journey to Germany in late May 1936 followed hard on the heels of the April– May electoral victory of the Popular Front (a combination of the disparate forces of the Left – Socialists, Radicals and Communists – which had reorganised after 6 February 1934), and preceded by just a few days the installation of Léon Blum’s coalition government of Socialists and Radicals, the first Socialist-led government in France.20 Not surprisingly, most on the Right opposed the Front. For the fascist Right, political responsibility for the decadence of France lay with the regime, while the Right-wing majority of Catholics feared that the Front’s arrival in power would revitalise anticlericalism and la guerre religieuse, concerns which were played on by conservative Catholic newspapers such as L’Écho de Paris and La France catholique which were implacable in their opposition to the regime. At this time, most Rightwing Catholics simply ignored the Church’s social doctrine as detailed in Quadragesimo anno (1931) and their intransigent convictions naturally 19
20
114
In La Gerbe des forces, Châteaubriant makes one reference to Spain, suggesting that in the Spanish Civil War the nation was threatened by Bolshevism and that ‘le clergé d’Espagne n’a pu ni empêcher ni même pressentir ce qui le menaçait’ (p. 253). Right-wing intellectuals generally interpreted the Spanish Civil War as a crusade against the godless Republicans. There is no reference to Italy in the text. The Communists refused to participate in the Blum cabinet, believing that it could achieve little, and so chose to remain free to criticise as it saw fit (Larkin, France since the Popular Front, 2nd edn, p. 53).
dictated a negative response to the Front. But other Catholics judged the Front’s campaign against the social ills of poverty, unemployment and injustice to be not dissimilar to the Church’s programme of Action catholique, and hence adopted a more positive attitude to the Front. To the horror of the Right-wing Catholic press, several publications of Christian Democratic tendency, such as La Vie intellectuelle, Sept, L’Aube and La Vie catholique, subsequently activated a debate on the potential for co-operation between Catholics and the Left on specific social objectives.21 And a small minority of extreme Left-wing Catholics, mainly those on the journal Terre nouvelle, even reacted positively to the Communist Maurice Thorez’s main tendue, first proffered in 1936, seeking unity of action and looking to Communism as the implementation of Christian values.22 In common with the Catholic and the fascist Right, Châteaubriant rejected the Popular Front. Writing in 1941, he described 1936 as ‘exactement le temps où sévissait en France cet esprit diabolique qui fut le père de cet extraordinaire règne que connaîtra l’Histoire, sous le vocable non moins extraordinaire de Front populaire’.23 In words evocative of his Lettre à la chrétienté mourante, and which suggest that he viewed the Front as a modern-day incarnation of France’s longstanding failings, he further defined the regime as ‘rien qu’un grand vide de pensée, qu’un grand vide de dispositions, de conscience, de substance’ (ibid.). For Châteaubriant, Catholic co-operation with the 21
22
23
Sept, for example, published Léon Blum’s thoughts on this topic on 19 February 1937, noting that ‘s’il y a coïncidence entre certaines initiatives du Front populaire et les réformes demandées par l’école sociale catholique, nous ne voyons aucune raison pour ne pas leur donner loyalement notre appui’. René Rémond, ‘Les Catholiques et le Front populaire (1936–1937)’, Archives de sociologie des religions, 10 (1960), 63–69. Ecclesiastical intervention following the Blum interview resulted in Sept’s suspension in August 1937, while Terre nouvelle, the ‘organe des chrétiens révolutionnaires’, was placed on the Index in July 1936 (Claude Bellanger, Histoire générale de la presse française, 4 vols (PUF, 1972), III, 556). Jean Boissel, Mon discours de Nuremberg (Éditions du Réveil du peuple, 1941), preface by Alphonse de Châteaubriant, 3–6 (p. 3).
115
Popular Front under the aegis of Action catholique was simply not to be countenanced. He would, instead, promote collaboration with National Socialism, preferring to accept Hitler’s main tendue as the solution to the contemporary crisis.24 In La Gerbe des forces, Châteaubriant restates his familiar critique of the modern catastrophic world, but now specifically contrasts modern France’s decline to National-Socialist Germany’s vitality: ‘L’Allemagne n’a jamais été finie, la France est parachevée. La France est mesurée et tiède, et l’Allemagne démesurée et brûlante. […] L’Allemand comprend et vit l’Apocalypse; le Français se moque de l’Apocalypse’ (p. 41). France, he indicates, lacks direction and is worn out, and the causes of her decline are his customary enemies, namely ‘le développement monstrueux de la machine, la ruée des masses dans l’arène, l’usure totale des aristocraties historiques, l’effroyable déchristianisation de l’esprit moderne’ (p. 32). The French have been educated ‘non point pour élever et surélever des hommes, mais afin de confectionner des électeurs et aussi des champions de toute thèse ennemie de l’Idée de Dieu’ (pp. 21–22). Democracy has destroyed ‘Unanimité’ and encouraged humans to ‘s’aveulir dans les anarchies sans issues de la petite volonté individuelle’ (p. 158). Châteaubriant abhors the modern emphasis on equality and laments ‘cette mort de toutes les hiérarchies et de toutes les noblesses, cette extinction de toute cette force de sang et de cœur dans les anciennes classes’ (p. 247), arguing starkly that ‘nous manquons d’héroïsme’ (p. 114). And he contemptuously dismisses France’s many present-day mediocre leaders on the grounds that they are ‘simplement intelligents et simplement spécialisés dans leur technique professionnelle’ rather than intelligent in a much more fundamental way (p. 23). Reactivating his earlier evaluation of the medieval debate on reason versus faith, he denounces the French as a people ‘[qui] raisonne[nt] et ne voi[en]t pas’ (p. 119), who have chosen the pathway of objectivity and have therefore ‘mis le monde et Dieu en dehors d[’eux]’ (p. 135). In his 24
116
The title of Chapter 5 of La Gerbe des forces is ‘La Main tendue’.
view, individualism, objectivity and equality have combined to permit the implantation of Bolshevism and the proletarian society, which absorbs and depersonalises humans, reducing them all to the same base level (p. 255). But Bolshevism, he argues, is not simply a modern phenomenon, for it has surfaced whenever humanity has been deprived of an appropriate higher authority (pp. 257–58). It results from two factors, namely ‘la décomposition de la vie d’une culture, et la décadence de l’esprit religieux’ (p. 258). And since his typical intransigent Catholic anti-Revolutionary attitudes lead him to believe that ‘l’athéisme moscoutaire n’est qu’une accentuation dans le sens nihiliste de l’esprit jacobin de France’ (p. 259), then France is evidently susceptible to its influence and must raise her guard. Châteaubriant views the Republic as a vehicle of dechristianisation, and argues that France has been dominated by an ‘odieux esprit sectaire’ (p. 226) and ‘dévoré par l’anti-cléricalisme’ (p. 227) especially since the 1905 Loi de séparation des Églises et de l’État. In his opinion, the French ‘organism’ requires resurrection and new cohesion (p. 33), and the key to regeneration lies in the successful search for l’homme nouveau, while renewal must be guided by an appropriate elite (p. 114). They, in turn, must be led by an ultimate chef, for ‘personne autre qu’un homme de génie ne peut résoudre de façon grande ou heureuse la situation mondiale que les temps ont fait surgir’ (p. 24). These forces are to be mobilised in the fight against Bolshevism, and, to this end, he advocates ‘une épuration totale’ (p. 259). Respiritualisation through revolution and regeneration remains the necessary salutary path, but society’s traditional religious representatives are ‘disciple[s] affaibli[s], qui ne [savent] plus construire’ (p. 246), a theme raised in the Lettre à la chrétienté mourante. Furthermore, the institutional religious responses to Bolshevism within Europe have proved ineffective, as in Germany where ‘le Centrum n’a pu empêcher six millions de communistes de se constituer’ (p. 253).25 Faced with such weakness, Châteaubriant 25
The term Centrum refers to the German Catholic Centre Party, which played a key role in German politics until 1933.
117
continues to believe that the reimposition of order in the face of established disorder can only come about through a new form of Christianity, defined as ‘un christianisme autrement servi et conscient, autrement armé des forces de Dieu’ (p. 253), in other words, a New Christendom.
The view from abroad: French responses to National Socialism in the mid-1930s In broad terms, Châteaubriant’s critique of the modern world in La Gerbe des forces and his programme for salvation confirm that he shared a basic antimoderne attitude with many of his contemporaries. His antiindividualism, anti-Bolshevism and anti-capitalism approximate his thought to that of the conservative Catholic Right in France. Such themes, when added to his call for spiritual regeneration – designed to combat mediocrity, to create an homme nouveau and a new elite, and to reinvent order – indicate goals common also to Right-wing fascist intellectuals or to those seeking a nouvelle chrétienté. And yet, despite these similarities, the reviews of La Gerbe des forces in conservative, Catholic and fascist publications were largely negative. In Action française, L’Époque, L’Ordre, Le Temps and Vendémiaire, all on the conservative and Catholic Right, in the Jesuit Études and the nonconformist Esprit, and in the fascist Je suis partout, the reaction was the same: La Gerbe des forces, as André Thérive summarised in Vendémiaire, was ‘le panégyrique le plus effréné que vous puissiez imaginer de Hitler et du National-Socialisme’.26 As we shall learn, it was the precise 26
118
Pellisson (pseud. Charles Maurras), ‘La Gerbe des forces’, Action française, 4 July 1937, p. 1; Robert Brasillach, ‘Alphonse de Châteaubriant: La Gerbe des forces’, Action française, 8 July 1937, p. 3; François Porché, ‘Alphonse de Châteaubriant: La Gerbe des forces’, L’Époque, 26 July 1937, p. 5; Robert d’Harcourt, ‘L’Allemagne comme la voit Monsieur de Châteaubriant’, L’Époque, 1
nature of Châteaubriant’s interpretation of Germany and of his programme for regeneration which differentiated his thought from that of the majority of his contemporaries at this point in the mid1930s, and which earned him such widespread criticism. His reading of Germany was truly rare, for he chose openly and wholeheartedly to endorse Adolf Hitler and National Socialism at a time of significant Fascist hesitation, Catholic concern, papal condemnation and popular fear of National-Socialist Germany, and at a time when the nation was perceived as overly nationalistic, excessively revolutionary, basically pseudo-spiritual and even anti-Christian. Many fascist intellectuals were interested by Hitler’s Germany, but did not share Châteaubriant’s view that ‘le national-socialisme est, dans le monde moderne, la première forme d’État qui porte en sa constitution la volonté de lutter contre le mal’ (GF, p. 57), or his total commitment to ‘une renaissance et [un] salut européens par la renaissance germanique’ (p. 97). Drieu, for example, was impressed by Germany’s dynamism, but, in Robert Soucy’s words, ‘continued to dislike Hitler’s chauvinism, disapproved of a single leader wielding so much power, and regretted the privileges which big business still enjoyed in Germany’. In his wish to create a strong French fascist state, ‘[Drieu’s] Fascism was by no means subservient to Germany at this point’, and he favoured Jacques Doriot instead, joining his Parti September 1937, p. 1 & p. 2; Pierre Loewel, ‘La Vie littéraire: La Gerbe des forces’, L’Ordre, 19 July 1937, p. 2; André Thérive, ‘Un héraut du Troisième Reich: Alphonse de Châteaubriant’, Vendémiaire, 28 July 1937, p. 6 and ‘La Gerbe des forces: Nouvelle Allemagne’, Le Temps, 16 September 1937, p. 3; Henri du Passage, ‘La Gerbe des forces’, Études, 2 (1937), 564–55; Emmanuel Mounier, ‘Alphonse de Châteaubriant: La Gerbe des forces’, Esprit, 59 (1937), 687–88; Lucien Rebatet, ‘Alphonse de Châteaubriant: La Gerbe des forces’, Je suis partout, 3 September 1937, p. 8. A review in La Vie intellectuelle could have provided a useful Social Catholic angle, but, disappointingly, no such piece exists. Positive reviews of La Gerbe des forces are rare, notable exceptions being Tyl in the Fascist Choc, 30 September 1937, p. 4, and André Castelot, Cahiers franco-allemands, 10–11 (1937), 350–54, in which the author notes that the text was ‘violemment attaqué par les deux-tiers de la grande presse de France’.
119
populaire français in June 1936.27 Nor did the Je suis partout team (Brasillach, Cousteau, Rebatet and Daye) fall under the spell of National Socialism, for while their published accounts of Hitler’s Germany recognised and appreciated the appeal of National Socialism, they also expressed a degree of hesitation and concern about certain aspects, such as Germany’s potential ambition to annex Alsace-Lorraine. In the final analysis, all agreed, as Brasillach wrote in Notre avant-guerre, that Germany ‘ce pays, si voisin de nous […] est d’abord au sens plein du mot […], un pays étrange’ (p. 286).28 ‘Notre fascisme à nous’, he emphasised, ‘[…] n’était pas à l’imitation de l’étranger, et nos confrontations avec les fascismes étrangers ne faisaient que mieux nous convaincre des originalités nationales, donc de la nôtre’ (p. 290, p. 291). French intellectuals of all persuasions were struck especially by National Socialism’s quasi-religious aspects. Recognition of its potential as a new religion had been noted in France in July 1933, at the time of the Concordat between the Vatican and the German Reich, when Le Temps had argued that ‘loin de pouvoir influencer le régime hitlérien, la religion catholique va devoir combattre celui-ci, qui est une nouvelle religion’.29 France’s young fascist explorers subsequently widely reported National Socialism as a new religion, Germany as a pagan ‘cathedral’, and Nazi Party rallies as ‘ceremonies’, and suggested that – in Brasillach’s words – ‘qui ne voit pas dans la consécration des drapeaux l’analogue de la consécration du pain, une sorte de sacrement allemand, risque fort de ne rien comprendre à l’hitlérisme’ 27 28 29
120
Robert Soucy, Fascist Intellectual: Drieu la Rochelle (Berkeley: University of California Press, 1979), p. 75, p. 77, p. 76. The emphasis is Brasillach’s. Personally, Brasillach seems to have been more attracted by Degrelle’s Belgium and Franco’s Spain than Hitler’s Germany (See Notre avant-guerre, pp. 247–72). Christian Ponson, ‘L’Information sur le nazisme dans la presse catholique française entre 1933 et 1938’, in Églises et chrétiens dans la Deuxième guerre mondiale: La France, ed. by Xavier de Montclos (Lyon: Presses Universitaires de Lyon, 1982), pp. 17–32 (p. 20).
(NAG, p. 285).30 Definition of National Socialism as a false religion was a major feature of Catholic responses at this time. In December 1933, for example, Esprit published a special issue which denounced ‘les pseudo-valeurs spirituelles fascistes’, while, in its November 1933 ‘Lettre à Hitler’, L’Ordre nouveau attacked National Socialism’s false reference to the primacy of the spiritual.31 Three years later, the Rightwing Catholic Robert d’Harcourt wrote in the preface to his L’Évangile de la force: le visage de la jeunesse du Troisième Reich (1936) that ‘the youth of Germany have been given a “false God”’.32 In Humanisme intégral, published the same year, Jacques Maritain expressed concern over the persecution of the Church in Germany, attacking ‘les formes de totalitarisme qui prétend protéger Dieu’ and warning that they heralded ‘un retour offensif de l’antichristianisme et de l’athéisme ouverts’ (pp. 288–89). And Emmanuel Mounier wrote in his Manifeste au service du personnalisme (1936) that Fascism limited the spiritual to what he called ‘une ivresse permanente des ardeurs vitales’, and so implicitly eliminated ‘les valeurs supérieures pour les “spiritualités” les plus lourdes et les “mystiques” les plus ambigües’ (p. 502). The response of some Catholics to National Socialism was dictated by their attitude towards Bolshevism, which they widely identified as the absolute evil. Catholic anti-Bolshevism had already received recent papal confirmation in Quadragesimo anno (1931), in which Pius XI had written of the impious and unjust nature of Communism, and of its savage and inhuman practices in power (pp. 30 31
32
For further examples, see Pierre-Marie Dioudonnat, Je suis partout 1930–1944: les Maurrassiens devant la tentation fasciste (La Table ronde, 1973). Winock, Histoire politique de la revue ‘Esprit’, p. 82; Loubet del Bayle, Les Nonconformistes des années 30, p. 309. During the later 1930s, similar interventions featured in Catholic publications such as Le Voltigeur français, Études and La Vie intellectuelle (Paul Christophe, 1939–1940. Les Catholiques devant la guerre (Les Éditions ouvrières, 1989), pp. 53–57). Cited in Daniel Lindenberg, ‘French Intellectuals and a German Europe: an Aspect of Collaboration’, in Intellectuals in Twentieth-Century France: Mandarins and Samurais, ed. by Jeremy Jennings (St. Martin’s Press, 1993), p. 155.
121
88–89). This attitude was then reinforced in the encyclical Divini redemptoris, published on 19 March 1937, just five days after the Pope’s encyclical on the German situation, Mit brennender Sorge. The publication of these two documents naturally prompted front-page comment in the French press, both Catholic and non-confessional. But, while a handful of Catholic publications accorded equal coverage to both encyclicals (for example, Esprit), or chose to extend their reportage of the Pope’s condemnation of Germany’s violation of the Concordat into a debate on the doctrine of National Socialism itself, most others elected to emphasise the Communist threat, no doubt because of Catholic opposition to the Popular Front which was currently in power in France.33 And a minority of Catholics even openly preferred Hitler to Communism: for example, Jean Guirard, joint editor of La Croix, proclaimed ‘tout plutôt que le communisme, tout, même l’hitlérisme’, while Louis Bertrand, author of Hitler (1936), is credited with the pronouncement that ‘Hitler est notre seule planche de salut contre les bolchevistes et le communisme’.34 It would be simplistic to root Châteaubriant’s commitment to National Socialism purely in his deeply entrenched anti-Bolshevism, although, given the general Catholic definition of Bolshevism as a force for dechristianisation, this did play an important role in the formulation of his ideas. Nor is it satisfactory to conclude that Châteaubriant saw National Socialism as a new religion, as we shall discover. For Châteaubriant, such a judgement was superficial, since it failed to grasp the essence of National Socialism as the revelation of eternal spiritual truths, and, in that sense, as his desired New Christendom.
33 34
122
For further details on the treatment of these encyclicals in the French press, see Ponson, ‘L’Information sur le nazisme’. Cited in Christophe, Les Catholiques devant la guerre, p. 44, p. 50.
La Gerbe des forces: Châteaubriant’s lens on Germany Châteaubriant travelled extensively throughout Germany during the second half of 1936, and La Gerbe des forces is littered with references to the numerous cities and towns he visited, including Frankfurt, Cologne, Nuremberg, Heidelberg, Fribourg, Stuttgart, Bayreuth, Bamberg, and, of course, Berlin. His travels lead him to conclude that France neither knows nor truly understands modern-day Germany (GF, p. 342). France’s impression of Germany, he argues, is based on years of entrenched distrust and bitterness, but modern Germany is not the Germany of the Empire, and ‘il est de toute nécessité que les immenses changements survenus en Allemagne et dans l’esprit allemand arrivent à sa [France’s] connaissance’ (p. 343). La Gerbe des forces is Châteaubriant’s reading of those changes. As ‘l’homme que les circonstances ont placé aux avant-postes’, it is his duty to ‘recueillir tous les signes qui se peuvent interpréter et qui présentent un sens utilisable’ (p. 333). Evidently aware of Châteaubriant’s value to them as a French supporter of National Socialism, the Germans treated him as an important visitor, organising a timetable of stage-managed visits to German factories, churches, youth camps, rallies, concerts and sports events, including the 1936 Berlin Olympic Games, where he first set eyes on Hitler in person. Châteaubriant pleads impartiality as a witness, insisting that he went to Germany: […] vide de toute convoitise, de tout intérêt, de tout préjugé, de toute parole donnée, de toute compromission acceptée, de tout plan concerté, de toute malice inavouable, de toute réserve mentale, comme de toute insincérité professionnelle. (p. 342)
But, despite these claims, Châteaubriant was only interested in a particular reading of Germany, as shown by his enthusiastic endorsement of those aspects which he believed corresponded to his own previously defined ideas, by his ‘reasoned’ dismissal of objections and concerns, and by his omission of other extremely sensitive aspects. 123
His conclusions are therefore based on a skewed reading of his experiences which was moulded by what he wanted to see. In La Gerbe des forces, Châteaubriant raises many of the charges levelled at National-Socialist Germany, thereby creating a semblance of objectivity and debate. But his strategy is simply and swiftly to dismiss these concerns with the argument that France has misunderstood Germany’s intentions and activity. He insists not only that ‘l’Allemagne actuelle n’a aucun projet contre la France’ (p. 53), but also that ‘l’Allemagne désire une entente avec la France’ (p. 338), a goal close to Châteaubriant’s heart since at least 1918. Those who interpret National-Socialist rallies as ‘une danse de guerre déguisée’ (p. 34) or Hitler’s speeches as ‘des menaces de guerre’ (p. 339) have misread the Führer’s intentions, for Germany does not seek to go to war with France since Hitler believes that war would solve nothing (pp. 45–46). On the basis of these conclusions, Châteaubriant counters French disquiet over the anti-French sections of Mein Kampf (1923), and willingly accepts Hitler’s explanation in his 1933 interview with Fernand de Brinon that these sections were written in 1923 while he was in prison and at a time when French troops were occupying the Ruhr, and that he did not have the right to change what was essentially an historical document (p. 46).35 In conversation with an ardent supporter of Hitler, Châteaubriant easily embraces the view that within Germany the idea of revenge for past losses has no part to play, and that any threat of war targets only ‘les États qui se sont faits les champions des théories subversives du marxisme’ (p. 339). After all, he writes, Hitler is neither a warmonger nor a dictator, but rather ‘un édificateur d’esprits, un constructeur de volontés’ (p. 345). And concerns over Germany’s rearmament are similarly voiced and rejected, if somewhat feebly, for, Châteaubriant asks, ‘quel est le peuple, la nation d’Europe qui depuis vingt ans a vécu dans un rêve de 35
124
It has since been proven that Hitler actually wrote the anti-French sections of Mein Kampf in 1925, a year after his release from prison. See Eberhard Jäckel, La France dans l’Europe de Hitler, trans. by Denise Meunier (Fayard, 1968), p. 27.
tranquillité suffisament assis pour négliger de se forger des armes?’ (pp. 334–35). Rearmament, he is told, is not a threat directed at France, but – given the current European situation – just ‘le reflexe normal d’une collectivité qui veut vivre’; while the army is above all simply an instrument of discipline and a means of generating in German men ‘le maximum de force physique et de santé’ (p. 340). In 1930s France, many feared that Germany’s policy of Lebensraum (living space) would result in the annexation of land, and, more precisely, that she had her sights set once more on AlsaceLorraine. Châteaubriant again dismisses French concerns, exploiting as justification Hitler’s comment to De Brinon that ‘j’ai répété maintes fois que le sort de l’Alsace-Lorraine était réglé’ (p. 46). Hitler’s policy, he writes, is ‘avec les nations et non contre les nations’ (p. 97), while the Germans are alleged to have declared that ‘nous voulons que notre pays vive, mais nous ne voulons pas que ce soit aux dépens des autres’ (p. 290). For Châteaubriant, the National-Socialist revolution is much less important in terms of its German specificity than in terms of what he sees as its potential universal impact as a salutary force in the European context. Long opposed to extreme nationalism, but equally long committed to his ideal of Germany, he chooses to sidestep the issue of her nationalism and to maintain his identification of the nation as a key player in his proposed Europe. He therefore concludes, in language reminiscent of his First-World-War letters, that co-operation between European nations inspired by Germany will ensure that ‘la guerre des peuples sera évitée’ (p. 344). The subjugation of the working class and the suppression of trade unions in Hitler’s Germany were additional concerns for those wary of National Socialism, although Châteaubriant is scornful that ‘on fait croire en France que l’ouvrier allemand gémit sous le joug de la contrainte’ (p. 210). He contends instead that Hitler’s suppression of the unions and his creation of the single Arbeitsfront (labour front) system is based on the principle that, within National Socialism, ‘l’intérêt de tous passe avant l’intérêt de l’individu’ (p. 195). He argues that Hitler has thereby restored both the workers’ dignity and the idea 125
of a community founded on solidarity, responsibility and devotion (p. 196). Furthermore, he interprets the Kraft durch Freude (strength through joy) project as an illustration of state philanthropy in the creation and management of obligatory leisure activities and holidays for workers (pp. 200–04). For Châteaubriant, both the Arbeitsfront and Kraft durch Freude schemes incarnate his theory of a community based on collective activity, mutual duty and respect, as depicted in Monsieur des Lourdines published some twenty-five years previously. The most sensitive charge against which Châteaubriant vigourously defends National Socialism in La Gerbe des forces is that of dechristianisation and anti-Rome activity. He opposes what he sees as French religious sterility (one of his long-standing complaints) with Germany’s religious vitality, arguing that: Les leaders catholiques auront beau dénoncer et accuser l’antichristianisme hitlérien, ce qui fait la force de l’Allemagne hitlérienne, c’est son âme religieuse, et ce qui produit le marasme de la France, c’est le dessèchement religieux qui sévit dans son peuple et chez les dirigeants de France. (p. 122)
He develops this interpretation through his presentation of current Church–State relations in Germany, creating an appearance of debate by recording a supposed conversation between two confident and voluble National Socialists, and three rather hesitant Roman Catholic priests. He reports the formers’ denial that Germany is attempting to ‘édifier […] des cultes […] destinés à remplacer les enseignements de la vieille chrétienté’, alongside their argument that ‘Dieu et le Christ, on ne peut les enlever de l’âme allemande’ (p. 216). Moreover, they credit Hitler with the statement that: Je n’ai jamais combattu et ne combattrai jamais Rome… Nous exigeons la liberté de toutes les opinions religieuses dans l’État, pour autant qu’elles ne mettent pas l’existence de celui-ci en danger ou qu’elles n’offensent pas le sentiment moral et les mœurs de la race germanique. (p. 217)
This declaration manifestly subordinates universal religion to a ‘religion’ of the State, and the priests note their concern at the 126
apparent priority given by German officials to ‘un soi-disant élément religieux germanique sur l’enseignement de l’Église’ (ibid.), as well as their fear that Germany intends to free herself from the influence of the universal Catholic Church. They further charge that Germany rejects the notion of Christianity as a doctrine based on suffering and humility (p. 219), thereby repudiating the crucifixion, and argue that Hitler has not respected the terms of the 1933 Concordat since ‘en forçant la jeunesse catholique à faire corps avec la jeunesse hitlérienne, il a violé l’engagement pris par l’État de respecter l’existence des institutions catholiques’ (p. 222). Such accusations are plainly directed at the activity of Alfred Rosenberg, appointed in January 1934 to direct the spiritual and philosophical education of the Nazi Party.36 Robert Cecil has described Rosenberg as one of a ‘core of anti-Christians around Hitler […] [who] all believed that the Christian ethic was fundamentally opposed to Nazi ideology’, and summarised Rosenberg’s book Der Mythus des 20 Jahrhunderts (1930) as ‘at least as much an attack on Christian churches as […] upon Jewry’.37 But Châteaubriant evidently did not interpret National Socialism as an attack upon Christianity. Rather, he accepts the explanation that ‘Rosenberg n’a nullement reçu du Chancelier mission d’imposer un dogme à l’Allemagne religieuse’, and that ‘c’est en réalité d’une immense crise religieuse que souffre le monde… Et c’est ce que Rosenberg et les siens pressentent’ (GF, p. 218). This apparent diagnosis of a world religious crisis could not fail to win Châteaubriant’s approval, since it so clearly echoes his own ideas. And agreement on the diagnosis was accompanied by a wholehearted acceptance of the prescribed ‘cure’. Rosenberg ascribed the 36
37
Maugendre, Alphonse de Châteaubriant, p. 195, writes that Châteaubriant met both Goebbels and Rosenberg in Berlin in November 1936. It is unlikely that Châteaubriant could have failed to record such a meeting, given his enthusiasm for all things National-Socialist. However, nothing exists in his writings to confirm Maugendre’s claim. Robert Cecil, The Myth of the Master Race: Alfred Rosenberg and Nazi Ideology (Batsford, 1972), p. 84, p. 82.
127
decline of Christianity to its absorption of Jewish elements, and believed that the Christian message had been distorted by Saint Paul (himself a Jew), who had over-emphasised the importance of the crucifixion to the detriment of Jesus as ‘the hero, not the bruised one…’ and undermined the importance of aristocracy and race.38 Such themes corresponded to Châteaubriant’s heroic and aristocratic nouvelle chrétienté. He not insignificantly records the National Socialists’ claim to herald ‘une chrétienté nouvelle… nouvelle!…’ which emphasises both Christ as hero (p. 219) and the notion that ‘la Crucifixion et la Résurrection sont un seul et même acte que nous n’avons pas le droit de diviser’ (p. 220) – a reading which acknowledges suffering and death but simultaneously and ultimately lauds heroism and promises regeneration. The National Socialists conclude the conversation with the priests by attaching religious credentials to their regime, claiming not only that ‘l’État N.-S. se fonde sur les Églises, la catholique et la protestante’ (p. 221), but also that ‘aucun jeune homme ne serait admis dans la Hitlerjugend s’il ne croyait pas en Dieu’ (p. 223). Châteaubriant swallows such claims unquestioningly, indicating that he has fallen for the German Christus line as presented via the offices of Rosenberg, and, as we will see shortly, that his understanding of the true nature of both Christianity and National Socialism is defective. It is noticeable that the charges against National Socialism which Châteaubriant chooses specifically to refute also challenge the main aspects of his own previously defined programme for regeneration, namely Franco-German co-operation, Europeanism, the organic community and a heroic Christianity. Given this correspondence of theme, his claim to view National Socialism without prejudice and to write of his encounter lucidly and objectively is unconvincing. That claim is rendered even more implausible if, in addition to his dismissal of charges levelled at National Socialism, we consider his omission of other aspects. In particular, he makes no reference to any ‘destructive’ 38
128
Ibid., p. 85.
aspects of National Socialism, such as the May 1933 burning of books written by well-known German and foreign authors who were condemned by the Third Reich, and their subsequent ban, and the June 1934 blood purge of Hitler’s potential rivals and enemies. The two most remarkable omissions, however, given their significance, concern the Jewish Question and reference to documented and published Catholic opposition to National Socialism within Germany, remembering that the meeting of German and Catholic representatives examined earlier is simply Châteaubriant’s subjective and perhaps even invented record of that occurrence. Anti-Jewish activity intensified in Germany from 1933, with Jews discriminated against in economic, educational, professional and social terms. Many Jewish authors were among those whose works were banned in 1933,39 while the 1935 Nuremberg Laws criminalised marriages between Jews and non-Jews in the name of the preservation of German blood and German honour. La Gerbe des forces, however, makes no mention of such events. It is conceivable that Châteaubriant saw no evidence of anti-Jewish activities while on his tour of Germany, since his hosts would have rest