Alkaline Igneous Rocks
Geological Society Special Publications Series Editor
K. C 0 E
GEOLOGICAL
SOCIETY SPECIAL ...
347 downloads
3423 Views
56MB Size
Report
This content was uploaded by our users and we assume good faith they have the permission to share this book. If you own the copyright to this book and it is wrongfully on our website, we offer a simple DMCA procedure to remove your content from our site. Start by pressing the button below!
Report copyright / DMCA form
Alkaline Igneous Rocks
Geological Society Special Publications Series Editor
K. C 0 E
GEOLOGICAL
SOCIETY SPECIAL PUBLICATION
Alkaline Igneous Rocks E D I T E D BY
J. G. F I T T O N & B. G. J. U P T O N Grant Institute of Geology University of Edinburgh Edinburgh EH9 3JW
1987 Published for The Geological Society by Blackwell Scientific Publications OXFORD LONDON
EDINBURGH
BOSTON PALO ALTO MELBOURNE
N O 30
Published by Blackwell Scientific Publications Editorial offices: Osney Mead, Oxford OX2 0EL 8 John Street, London WC1N 2ES 23 Ainslie Place, Edinburgh EH3 6AJ 52 Beacon Street, Boston Massachusetts 02108, USA 667 Lytton Avenue, Palo Alto California 94301, USA 107 Barry Street, Carlton Victoria 3053, Australia
DISTRIBUTORS USA and Canada Blackwell Scientific Publications Inc PO Box 50009, Palo Alto California 94303 Australia Blackwell Scientific Publications (Australia) Pty Ltd 107 Barry Street, Carlton, Victoria 3053
9 1987 The Geological Society. Authorization to photocopy items for internal or personal use, or the internal or personal use of specific clients, is granted by The Geological Society for libraries and other users registered with the Copyright Clearance Center (CCC) Transactional Reporting Service, provided that a base fee of $02.00 per copy is paid directly to CCC, 27 Congress Street, Salem, MA 01970, USA. 0305-8719/87 $02.00
British Library Cataloguing in Publication Data
First published 1987
ISBN0-632-01616-7
Typeset, printed and bound in Great Britain by William Clowes Limited, Beccles and London
Library of Congress Cataloging-in-Publication Data
Alkaline igneous rocks.--(Geological Society special publications, ISSN 0305-8719) 1. Alkalic igneous rocks I. Fitton, J.G. II. Upton, B. G. J. III. Series 552'. 1 QE462.A4
Alkaline igneous rocks. (Geological Society special publication; no. 30) Bibliography: p. Includes index. 1. Alkalic igneous rocks. I. Fitton, J. G. II. Upton, B. G.J. III. Geological Society of London. IV. Series. QE462.A4A43 1987 552'. 1 86-26364 ISBN0-632-01616-7
Contents Preface Introduction: FITTON, J. G. & UPTON, B. G . J . BAILEY, D. K. Mantle metasomatism--perspective and prospect
vii ix 1
MENZIES, M. Alkaline rocks and their inclusions: a window on the Earth's interior
15
EDGAR,A. D. The genesis of alkaline magmas with emphasis on their source regions: inferences from experimental studies
29
LE Bhs, M. J. Nephelinites and carbonatites
53
TWYMAN, J. D. & GITTINS, J. Alkalic carbonatite magmas: parental or derivative ?
85
DAWSON, J. B. The kimberlite clan: relationship with olivine and leucite lamproites, and inferences for upper-mantle metasomatism
95
BERGMAN, S. C. Lamproites and other potassium-rich igneous rocks: a review of their occurrence, mineralogy and geochemistry
103
ROCK, N. M. S. The nature and origin of lamprophyres: an overview
191
CLAGUE, D. A. Hawaiian alkaline volcanism
227
WEAVER, B. L., WOOD, D. A., TARNEY, J. & JORON, J. L. Geochemistry of ocean island basalts from the South Atlantic: Ascension, Bouvet, St. Helena, Gough and Tristan da Cunha
253
HARRIS, C. & SHEPPARD, S. M. F. Magma and fluid evolution in the lavas and associated granite xenoliths of Ascension Island
269
FITTON, J. G. The Cameroon line, West Africa: a comparison between oceanic and continental alkaline volcanism
273
BAKER, B. H. Outline of the petroIogy of the Kenya rift alkaline province
293
MACDONALD,R. Quaternary peralkaline silicic rocks and caldera volcanoes of Kenya
313
WOOLLEY, A. R. & JONES, G. C. The petrochemistry of the northern part of the Chilwa alkaline province, Malawi
335
BOWDEN, P., BLACK, R., MARTIN, R. F., IKEI E. C. KINNAIRD, J. A. & BATCHELOR, R . A . Niger-Nigerian alkaline ring complexes: a classic example of African Phanerozoic anorogenic mid-plate magmatism
357
LI/~GEOIS, J. P. & BLACK, R. Alkaline magmatism subsequent to collision in the Pan-African belt of the Adrar des Iforas (Mali)
381
FLETCHER, C. J. N. & BEDDOE-STEPHENS, B. The petrology, chemistry and crystallization history of the Velasco alkaline province, eastern Bolivia
403
BARKER, D. S. Tertiary alkaline magmatism in Trans-Pecos Texas
415
EBY, G. N. The Monteregian Hills and White Mountain alkaline igneous provinces, eastern North America
433
vi
Contents
UPTON, B. G. J. & EMELEUS, C. H. Mid-Proterozoic alkaline magmatism in southern Greenland: the Gardar province
449
LARSEN, L. M. & SORENSEN, H. The Ilimaussaq intrusion--progressive crystallization and formation of layering in an agpaitic magma
473
NIELSEN,T. F. D. Tertiary alkaline magmatism in East Greenland: a review
489
DOWNES, H. Tertiary and Quaternary volcanism in the Massif Central, France
517
KOGARKO, L. N. Alkaline rocks of the eastern part of the Baltic Shield (Kola Peninsula)
531
Index
545
Preface The papers contained in this volume were presented at a symposium held in Edinburgh in September 1984, which marked the passage of ten years since the publication of The Alkaline Rocks edited by Henning Sorensen. In organizing the symposium and compiling this volume we aimed to review recent developments in the petrology and geochemistry of alkaline igneous rocks. We have, for example, paid particular attention to work on lamprophyres and carbonatites which are rock associations of current interest not covered in Sorensen's book. Reviews of recent work on some of the classic alkaline provinces, such as East Africa, southern Greenland and the Kola Peninsula, are included together with reviews of less wellknown areas. Other papers discuss the impact of experimental, geochemical and isotopic studies on our understanding of the generation and evolution of alkaline magmas. We are indebted to the contributors for their collaboration in producing this volume and it is with sadness that we note the death, on 14 February 1986, of Brian Baker, whose pioneering field studies formed the basis for much of our knowledge of the tectonic and volcanic evolution of the East African Rift. An obituary and appreciation of his work is published in the Journal of Volcanology and Geothermal Research (28, v-vii). We are grateful to The Geological Society and The Royal Society of Edinburgh for their generous assistance with the symposium costs, to Lucian Begg and Dodie James for their help with organizing the symposium and producing this volume, and to our colleagues for the care and enthusiasm with which they reviewed the manuscripts. The efforts of Edward Wates and his staff at Blackwell Scientific Publications are also gratefully acknowledged. To all these we offer our sincere thanks. J.G.F. B.G.J.U.
vii
Introduction J. G. Fitton & B. G. J. Upton Alkaline igneous rocks may be defined as those which have higher concentrations of alkalis than can be accommodated in feldspars alone, the excess appearing as feldspathoids, sodic pyroxenes, sodic amphiboles and other alkali-rich phases. These rocks are, therefore, deficient in silica and/or alumina with respect to alkalis and will have nepheline and/or acmite in their norms. In practice the term 'alkaline' is used to encompass a wide range of igneous rocks, not all of which conform to this rigid definition. Carbonatites, for example, are certainly silica-deficient but are rarely alkali-rich. True (nepheline-normative) alkali basalts grade into hypersthene-normative transitional basalts without any obvious change in mineralogy. Since transitional basalts are often closely associated with alkali basalts in the field, they are traditionally regarded as alkaline. It is now usual practice to define alkaline igneous rocks simply in terms of their alkali ( N a 2 0 + K20) and silica contents (see, for example, Le Bas et al. 1986). We have not attempted to review the classification of alkaline igneous rocks in this volume as this has been dealt with elsewhere (e.g. Sorensen 1974; Streckeisen 1967, 1980). The only alkaline rocks not covered in previous reviews are those hydrous mafic to ultramafic hypabyssal rocks known as the lamprophyres. The present volume includes three papers on this group. A comprehensive overview of lamprophyres is given by Rock and of the sub-group of lamproites by Bergman. The relationship between lamproites and kimberlites (which arguably belong to the lamprophyres) is discussed by Dawson. Volumetrically, alkaline rocks account for less than one per cent of all igneous rocks. Despite this, their remarkable mineralogical diversity has brought them repeatedly to the attention of petrologists and mineralogists, with the result that alkaline rocks account for about half of all igneous rock names. Sorensen (1974) lists no fewer than 400 alkaline rock types. This diversity springs largely from an abundance of alkalis and deficiency in silica which together generate a large number of mineral species not stable in more silica-rich, alkali-poor magmas. However, a large part of the attention given to alkaline rocks is due to their characteristic high concentrations of incompatible or large-ion lithophile elements (LILE). These are often of more than academic interest as most of the world's resources of niobium, tantalum and the rare-earth elements are found in or around alkaline igneous rock bodies. The economic importance of alkaline igneous rocks is further enhanced by their association with economic deposits of apatite (Kogarko) and with diamonds (Dawson;
Bergman). Evidence for continental alkaline magmatism can be found as far back as the late Archaean. For example, biotites from the Poohbah Lake syenite in north-western Ontario have been dated at around 2.7 Ga (Mitchell 1976) and a similar age has been reported by Larsen et al. (1983) for the Tupertalik carbonatite in western Greenland. At the present time, alkaline magmas are erupted in all tectonic environments with the possible exception of mid-ocean ridges. Even here, though, mildly alkaline lavas are sometimes erupted from off-axis volcanoes, as in the Vestmann Islands of Iceland. Alkaline igneous rocks are found on all the continents and on islands in all the ocean basins. Their occurrences may be classified on the basis of tectonic setting into three categories; continental rift valley From: FITTON, J. G. & UPTON, B. G. J. (eds), 1987, Alkaline Igneous Rocks, Geological Society Special Publication No. 30, pp. ix-xiv.
ix
x
Introduction
magmatism, oceanic and continental intraplate magmatism without clear tectonic control, and alkaline magmatism related to subduction processes. In practice, however, this classification is not always easy to apply. Continental rift valleys provide, volumetrically, the most important occurrences of alkaline igneous rocks although continental rifting is not always accompanied by magmatism. The best known example (arguably the type example) is the East African Rift which, in the course of its long history, has yielded almost the entire spectrum of alkaline magmas. Three papers in this volume are devoted to various aspects of magmatism in the East African Rift. Baker reviews its magmatic associations with respect to tectonic development and discusses the origin of the magmas, particularly in relation to the problems presented by the strongly bimodal distribution of basic and salic lava compositions. He concludes that the salic magmas evolved from basic parental magmas by processes of crystal fractionation (cf. Bailey). Macdonald focusses attention on the peralkaline silicic central volcanoes of Kenya and also favours an origin by crystal fractionation for most of the evolved magmas. There is little evidence for contamination of the evolving magmas with ancient continental crust except in the case of the Naivasha comendites. It is not always possible to demonstrate a genetic link between basic and evolved magmas in the East African Rift, however. The Chilwa alkaline province in Malawi, at the southern end of the rift, is an essentially intrusive province in which salic rocks predominate. The scarcity of basic rocks in this part of the rift has led Woolley & Jones to suggest that the evolved magmas were produced directly by melting of metasomatised mantle and lower crust. Insight into the processes occurring at depth beneath rift valleys may be gained by studying ancient and deeply eroded examples. The Proterozoic Gardar province in SouthWest Greenland is probably the best studied of these and is reviewed by Upton & Emeleus. One of the most striking features of the province is the presence of giant dykes, up to 800 metres wide. These are dominantly basic but in places show in situ differentiation into more salic rocks. Salic magma generated in the wider portions of these dykes migrated upwards and may ultimately have accumulated to produce central complexes in which basic magma was subordinate or absent (e.g. the Ilimaussaq intrusion, Larsen & Serensen). The giant dykes, therefore, play a crucial role in understanding the relationship between basic and salic magmas in this and possibly other rift systems. The separation of continents to form ocean basins must always be preceded by a phase of continental rifting, leaving volcanic and intrusive complexes stranded along passive continental margins. The vigorous magmatism which accompanies continental separation is generally tholeiitic in character as, for example, in the Karoo and Deccan flood basalt provinces. Alkaline magmas, however, may be emplaced along the trailing continental margin during the waning phase of magmatism, long after the spreading centre is established off-shore. The Tertiary volcanic rocks exposed along the east coast of Greenland (described by Nielsen) provide an excellent example of such an alkaline province. A second major occurrence of alkaline igneous rocks is provided by intraplate magmatic provinces whose activity and siting are not subject to any obvious tectonic control. In the ocean basins such magmatism manifests itself as ocean islands which are sometimes aligned in chains with ages increasing away from the active centres, as in the Hawaiian islands. In these cases it is possible to relate the magmatism to convective plumes within the asthenosphere. The Hawaiian islands (reviewed by Clague) show clearly defined
Introduction
xi
magmatic cycles starting with alkaline magmas (represented by Loihi seamount), passing through a voluminous tholeiitic shield-building stage and returning to alkaline magmatism during the waning phases of individual volcanic centres. These cycles seem to result from movement of the oceanic plate over a rising plume of partially molten asthenosphere in which the degree of melting increases towards the centre. They may be typical of ocean islands in general and are broadly analogous to similar cycles seen in flood basalt provinces preserved on passive continental margins. Continental intraplate magmatism may also show age progressions as in the NigerNigeria province (Bowden et al.). These progressions are, however, very rare and not so clearly defined as in ocean island chains, probably because the continental lithosphere is thicker and less easily penetrated than oceanic lithosphere. The Monteregian Hills and White Mountain provinces of eastern North America (Eby), for example, show no obvious progression but their seaward extension, the New England seamounts, show a regular decrease in age eastwards. Reviews of other continental intraplate alkaline provinces are given by Fletcher & Beddoe-Stevens (Velasco province, Bolivia) and Kogarko (Kola Peninsula). The Cameroon line in West Africa (Fitton) includes both continental and oceanic alkaline volcanic centres. None of these examples shows any clear progression of ages. Some continental provinces undergo repeated alkaline magmatism in one place over long periods. For example, the Kola Peninsula (Kogarko) was the site of alkaline magmatism in the mid Proterozoic and again in the Devonian. Such examples could be the result of coincidence but are more likely the result of the repeated exploitation of zones of weakness in the lithosphere. Destructive plate boundaries provide the third tectonic setting in which alkaline igneous rocks may occur. During the life of a subduction zone the characteristic calc-alkaline magmas tend to become more potassic with time and may give way to volcanic rocks of the shoshonitic association, some members of which may contain leucite. A discussion of subduction zone processes is beyond the scope of this volume and the reader is referred to the reviews of Gill (1981) and Ewart (1982). There are, however, two circumstances under which subduction processes can lead to the generation of more 'normal' alkaline magmas. Once the descending slab has become dehydrated at depth it loses its capacity to stimulate the generation of calc-alkaline magmas but it can still cause melting in the overlying asthenosphere. This can lead to the production of alkaline magmas from the mantle above the deepest parts of subduction zones. One such example of alkaline magmas erupted under a compressive regime is provided by the Trans-Pecos province of west Texas (Barker). The alkaline rocks in this area grade south-westwards into the calc-alkaline rocks of the Sierra Madre Occidental in Mexico and Barker relates both suites to subduction of the Farallon Plate. After the cessation of subduction, relaxation of the former compressive regime often results in extension and the generation of alkaline magmas. The resulting switch from subduction-related calc-alkaline to extensional alkaline magmatism appears to be a common phenomenon. It occurred, for example, in the western U.S.A. about 17 Ma ago and in parts of Africa and Arabia at the end of the Pan-African metamorphic episode during the late Precambrian. An example from the Pan-African belt in Mali is discussed by Liegeois & Black. The origin of alkaline magmas has attracted a great deal of interest among igneous petrologists over the last ten years or so. This interest has been stimulated by two important
xii
Introduction
and characteristic features of alkaline rocks. Firstly, they contain high concentrations of LILE and yet isotopic evidence suggests that their parental magmas had a mantle source which had been depleted in these elements for a long time. Thus alkaline igneous rocks may provide useful information about enrichment and/or melting processes in the mantle. Secondly, many mafic alkaline volcanic rocks contain xenoliths inferred to have originated within the mantle (Menzies). These are often enriched in LILE when compared with concentrations expected of chondritic mantle material and sometimes contain amphiboles and micas of metasomatic origin (Bailey). Such clear evidence for the existence of metasomatically enriched mantle, coupled with the problem of extracting LILE-rich magmas from LILE-poor mantle, has led to hypotheses involving mantle metasomatism as a precursor to alkaline magmatism. These hypotheses, reviewed by Bailey, have gained popularity over the past fifteen years and are invoked by several contributors to this volume. Mantle metasomatism neatly explains many of the features of alkaline magmatism. For example, the frequent association of alkaline magmatism with areas of large-scale regional uplift is consistent with the relatively low density of metasomatized mantle. An essential feature of all models involving a metasomatized mantle source for alkaline magmas is that this source must lie in the lithosphere. This is the only part of the mantle where enriched material can remain in one place for long periods without being swept away by convection. The lithospheric mantle beneath the continents is likely to be chemically and isotopically different from that beneath the oceans. Continental lithospheric mantle is old and will have had as complex a metamorphic and magmatic history as the overlying crust. Oceanic lithosphere, on the other hand, is relatively young and probably depleted in LILE. These differences should be reflected in the compositions of continental and oceanic alkaline rocks. However, alkali basalts erupted in continental and oceanic settings are generally identical both chemically (Fitton) and isotopically (Menzies). Since enriched mantle xenoliths are only commonly found in continental regions it follows that the enriched lithospheric mantle represented by these xenoliths is not the source of most continental and oceanic alkaline magmas. An asthenospheric source is therefore implied. This is not to say that enriched continental lithospheric mantle is never involved in the generation of alkaline magmas. There is good evidence (e.g. Edgar) that pockets of ancient enriched mantle beneath cratonic regions provide the source for LILE-rich mafic and ultramafic alkaline rocks such as micaceous kimberlite (Dawson), and lamproite and other potassic igneous rocks (Bergman). It is significant that these rock types are exclusively continental. More extensive melting may involve the continental lithosphere mantle in the production of less exotic rock types such as flood tholeiite and mildly alkaline basalt. Upton & Emeleus, for example, argue for a lithospheric mantle source for the Gardar alkaline magmas. If most alkaline magmas have an ultimate source in the asthenosphere then they must share this source with unequivocally asthenosphere-derived rocks such as mid-ocean ridge basalt (MORB). The consistent isotopic differences between MORB and alkali basalts (and indeed all intraplate basalts) requires that the asthenosphere be heterogeneous. This heterogeneity may result from the entrainment of lower mantle material in deep mantle plumes as suggested for the Hawaiian island chain (Clague). The entire convecting upper mantle may also be heterogeneous on a small scale and alkaline magmas may be generated by the selective melting of LILE-enriched streaks while more extensive melting produces MORB (Fitton). Geochemical studies on ocean island basalts from the South Atlantic
Introduction
xiii
(Weaver et a/.) suggest that one component of these enriched streaks is provided by subducted ocean-floor sediment. Derivation of LILE-rich magmas from an asthenospheric source depleted in these elements requires either very small degress of partial melting or extensive crystal fractionation. There can be no doubt that many alkaline rocks are the products of extensive low pressure crystal fractionation but this cannot be true of those alkaline rocks which host mantle xenoliths. Even the most magnesian alkaline rocks, which must represent nearprimary magmas, are rich in LILE. Small-degree partial melting ( < l ~ ) is therefore required to produce such magmas. McKenzie (1985) has recently shown that the extraction of melt fractions as small as 0.2~ is not only physically possible but inevitable where the melt viscosity is low, as it probably is in the case of alkaline magmas. Experimental studies on alkaline rocks and synthetic analogues (reviewed by Edgar) provide useful constraints on the feasibility of fractional crystallization and partial melting models and on the temperatures and pressures involved. Many lines of evidence suggest that volatile components form a significant part of alkaline magmas. The development of extensive zones of metasomatised country rock (fenite) around alkaline plutons, the abundance of chlorine and fluorine in some alkaline igneous rocks, and the frequently explosive eruption of alkaline magma all point to high concentrations of volatiles. These volatile components play an important role in the evolution of alkaline magmas and yet relatively little is known about them. Constraints on their composition have been provided by fluid inclusion studies (Harris & Sheppard) and by thermodynamic considerations (Kogarko). The effects of volatile components on the evolution of alkaline magmas can be seen clearly in both intrusive and extrusive rocks. Larsen & Serensen, for example, discuss the crystallization history of the Ilimaussaq intrusion in South-West Greenland and show how the upward migration of low-density, low-viscosity volatile-rich magma delayed crystallization under the roof of the intrusion. Silicic alkaline pyroclastic deposits around central volcanoes in Kenya often show striking variations in the abundance of some incompatible elements within a single vertical section, implying compositional zonation in the magma chamber before eruption. Macdonald shows that these variations are too large to be accounted for by crystal fractionation alone and suggests that some elements have been transported to the magma chamber roof zones as complex ions in a volatile phase. Carbonatites provide perhaps the best illustration of all of the influence of volatile components on the origin and evolution of alkaline rocks. There is now a consensus that their parental magmas originate by the separation of an immiscible carbonate liquid phase from a CO2-saturated nephelinite or phonolite magma. There is, however, some disagreement over the nature and subsequent evolution of this parental carbonate magma. Le Bas argues that the parental magma is rich in alkalis and similar in composition to the natrocarbonatite lavas erupted from Oldoinyo Lengai. This magma evolves at low pressure towards the more common calcite carbonatite (s6vite) by loss of alkalis to the surrounding country rocks which are metasomatized (fenitized) as a result. Twyman & Gittins offer an alternative scheme in which s6vite magmas are parental and natrocarbonatite magmas are derived from them by crystal fractionation. Most petrologists now believe that evolved alkaline magmas are produced by the fractional crystallization of basic magma. The more highly undersaturated parental magmas represented by basanite and nephelinite will produce undersaturated derivatives
xiv
Introduction
such as phonolite and foyaite. Mildly alkaline and transitional basalt m a g m a is likely to produce trachyte and, with extreme fractionation, alkali rhyolite. The production of peralkaline acid rocks by crystal fractionation alone is likely to be an inefficient process. The operation of this process, however, is clearly demonstrated by their association with transitional basalt on some ocean islands, such as Ascension (Harris & Sheppard). Peralkaline acid rocks only occur in a b u n d a n c e in continental environments, however, and here there is often good evidence that crustal contamination has a c c o m p a n i e d crystal fractionation. Well-documented examples of the operation of crustal c o n t a m i n a t i o n in the evolution of alkaline m a g m a s are presented by several of the contributors to this volume. Downes, for example, shows that the assimilation of lower crustal granulite has affected the evolution of alkaline m a g m a s in the F r e n c h Massif Central and uses isotope data to estimate the extent of this contamination. Other examples are presented by Bowden et al. ( N i g e r - N i g e r i a granite ring complexes), Eby (Monteregian Hills and White Mountain provinces, N o r t h America), Fitton (Cameroon line, West Africa) and Fletcher & BeddoeStevens (Velasco province, Bolivia). Other authors propose the derivation of evolved alkaline m a g m a s directly from m e t a s o m a t i z e d mantle or lower crust (Bailey; Woolley &
Jones). Our understanding of the origin and evolution of alkaline m a g m a s has come a long way since the publication of Sorensen's book in 1974, largely through the acquisition of a far larger geochemical and isotopic data base. The contributions to this volume review the current state of this understanding. Emphasis has shifted from crustal to mantle processes with the recognition of mantle m e t a s o m a t i s m and its possible role as a precursor to alkaline magmatism. More recently, though, there has been a swing towards the opposite view, that mantle m e t a s o m a t i s m is c a u s e d b y alkaline m a g m a t i s m . Theoretical and experimental studies on the migration and segregation of small-degree melts seem destined to accelerate this swing. Despite these advances, however, m a n y mysteries remain unsolved and alkaline rocks will still provide a fruitful field of research for m a n y years to come, yielding further insights into the nature of mantle processes and the evolution of magmas.
References EWART, A. 1982. The mineralogy and petrology of Tertiary-Recent orogenic volcanic rocks: with special reference to the andesitic-basaltic compositional range. In Thorpe, R. S. (ed.) Andesites. Pp. 25-87. John Wiley & Sons, London. GILL,J. B. 1981. Orogenic Andesites and Plate Tectonics, 390 pp. Springer-Verlag, Berlin. LARSEN,L. M., REX,D. C. & SECHER,K. 1983. The age of carbonatites, kimberlites and lamprophyres from southern west Greenland: recurrent alkaline magmatism during 2500 million years. Lithos 16, 215-21. LE BAS,M. J., LE MAITRE, R. W., STRECKEISEN,A. & ZANETTIN, B. 1986. A chemical classification of
volcanic rocks based on the total alkali--silica diagram. J. Petrol. 27, 745-50. MCKENZIE, D. 1985. The extraction of magma from the crust and the mantle. Earth planet. Sci. Lett. 74, 81-91. MITCHELL,R. H. 1976. Potassium-argon geochronology of the Poohbah Lake alkaline complex, northwestern Ontario. Can. J. Earth Sci. 13, 1456-9. SORENSEN,H. (ed.) 1974. The Alkaline Rocks. 622 pp. John Wiley & Sons, London. STRECKEISEN,A. 1967. Classification and nomenclature of igneous rocks. N. Jb. Miner. Abh. 107, 144-240. - - , 1980. Classificationand nomenclature of volcanic rocks, lamprophyres, carbonatites and melilitic rocks. Geol. Rundschau, 69, 194-207.
J. G. FITTON& B. G. J. UPTON,Grant Institute of Geology, University of Edinburgh, West Mains Road, Edinburgh EH9 3JW, U.K.
Introduction J. G. Fitton & B. G. J. Upton Alkaline igneous rocks may be defined as those which have higher concentrations of alkalis than can be accommodated in feldspars alone, the excess appearing as feldspathoids, sodic pyroxenes, sodic amphiboles and other alkali-rich phases. These rocks are, therefore, deficient in silica and/or alumina with respect to alkalis and will have nepheline and/or acmite in their norms. In practice the term 'alkaline' is used to encompass a wide range of igneous rocks, not all of which conform to this rigid definition. Carbonatites, for example, are certainly silica-deficient but are rarely alkali-rich. True (nepheline-normative) alkali basalts grade into hypersthene-normative transitional basalts without any obvious change in mineralogy. Since transitional basalts are often closely associated with alkali basalts in the field, they are traditionally regarded as alkaline. It is now usual practice to define alkaline igneous rocks simply in terms of their alkali ( N a 2 0 + K20) and silica contents (see, for example, Le Bas et al. 1986). We have not attempted to review the classification of alkaline igneous rocks in this volume as this has been dealt with elsewhere (e.g. Sorensen 1974; Streckeisen 1967, 1980). The only alkaline rocks not covered in previous reviews are those hydrous mafic to ultramafic hypabyssal rocks known as the lamprophyres. The present volume includes three papers on this group. A comprehensive overview of lamprophyres is given by Rock and of the sub-group of lamproites by Bergman. The relationship between lamproites and kimberlites (which arguably belong to the lamprophyres) is discussed by Dawson. Volumetrically, alkaline rocks account for less than one per cent of all igneous rocks. Despite this, their remarkable mineralogical diversity has brought them repeatedly to the attention of petrologists and mineralogists, with the result that alkaline rocks account for about half of all igneous rock names. Sorensen (1974) lists no fewer than 400 alkaline rock types. This diversity springs largely from an abundance of alkalis and deficiency in silica which together generate a large number of mineral species not stable in more silica-rich, alkali-poor magmas. However, a large part of the attention given to alkaline rocks is due to their characteristic high concentrations of incompatible or large-ion lithophile elements (LILE). These are often of more than academic interest as most of the world's resources of niobium, tantalum and the rare-earth elements are found in or around alkaline igneous rock bodies. The economic importance of alkaline igneous rocks is further enhanced by their association with economic deposits of apatite (Kogarko) and with diamonds (Dawson;
Bergman). Evidence for continental alkaline magmatism can be found as far back as the late Archaean. For example, biotites from the Poohbah Lake syenite in north-western Ontario have been dated at around 2.7 Ga (Mitchell 1976) and a similar age has been reported by Larsen et al. (1983) for the Tupertalik carbonatite in western Greenland. At the present time, alkaline magmas are erupted in all tectonic environments with the possible exception of mid-ocean ridges. Even here, though, mildly alkaline lavas are sometimes erupted from off-axis volcanoes, as in the Vestmann Islands of Iceland. Alkaline igneous rocks are found on all the continents and on islands in all the ocean basins. Their occurrences may be classified on the basis of tectonic setting into three categories; continental rift valley From: FITTON, J. G. & UPTON, B. G. J. (eds), 1987, Alkaline Igneous Rocks, Geological Society Special Publication No. 30, pp. ix-xiv.
ix
x
Introduction
magmatism, oceanic and continental intraplate magmatism without clear tectonic control, and alkaline magmatism related to subduction processes. In practice, however, this classification is not always easy to apply. Continental rift valleys provide, volumetrically, the most important occurrences of alkaline igneous rocks although continental rifting is not always accompanied by magmatism. The best known example (arguably the type example) is the East African Rift which, in the course of its long history, has yielded almost the entire spectrum of alkaline magmas. Three papers in this volume are devoted to various aspects of magmatism in the East African Rift. Baker reviews its magmatic associations with respect to tectonic development and discusses the origin of the magmas, particularly in relation to the problems presented by the strongly bimodal distribution of basic and salic lava compositions. He concludes that the salic magmas evolved from basic parental magmas by processes of crystal fractionation (cf. Bailey). Macdonald focusses attention on the peralkaline silicic central volcanoes of Kenya and also favours an origin by crystal fractionation for most of the evolved magmas. There is little evidence for contamination of the evolving magmas with ancient continental crust except in the case of the Naivasha comendites. It is not always possible to demonstrate a genetic link between basic and evolved magmas in the East African Rift, however. The Chilwa alkaline province in Malawi, at the southern end of the rift, is an essentially intrusive province in which salic rocks predominate. The scarcity of basic rocks in this part of the rift has led Woolley & Jones to suggest that the evolved magmas were produced directly by melting of metasomatised mantle and lower crust. Insight into the processes occurring at depth beneath rift valleys may be gained by studying ancient and deeply eroded examples. The Proterozoic Gardar province in SouthWest Greenland is probably the best studied of these and is reviewed by Upton & Emeleus. One of the most striking features of the province is the presence of giant dykes, up to 800 metres wide. These are dominantly basic but in places show in situ differentiation into more salic rocks. Salic magma generated in the wider portions of these dykes migrated upwards and may ultimately have accumulated to produce central complexes in which basic magma was subordinate or absent (e.g. the Ilimaussaq intrusion, Larsen & Serensen). The giant dykes, therefore, play a crucial role in understanding the relationship between basic and salic magmas in this and possibly other rift systems. The separation of continents to form ocean basins must always be preceded by a phase of continental rifting, leaving volcanic and intrusive complexes stranded along passive continental margins. The vigorous magmatism which accompanies continental separation is generally tholeiitic in character as, for example, in the Karoo and Deccan flood basalt provinces. Alkaline magmas, however, may be emplaced along the trailing continental margin during the waning phase of magmatism, long after the spreading centre is established off-shore. The Tertiary volcanic rocks exposed along the east coast of Greenland (described by Nielsen) provide an excellent example of such an alkaline province. A second major occurrence of alkaline igneous rocks is provided by intraplate magmatic provinces whose activity and siting are not subject to any obvious tectonic control. In the ocean basins such magmatism manifests itself as ocean islands which are sometimes aligned in chains with ages increasing away from the active centres, as in the Hawaiian islands. In these cases it is possible to relate the magmatism to convective plumes within the asthenosphere. The Hawaiian islands (reviewed by Clague) show clearly defined
Introduction
xi
magmatic cycles starting with alkaline magmas (represented by Loihi seamount), passing through a voluminous tholeiitic shield-building stage and returning to alkaline magmatism during the waning phases of individual volcanic centres. These cycles seem to result from movement of the oceanic plate over a rising plume of partially molten asthenosphere in which the degree of melting increases towards the centre. They may be typical of ocean islands in general and are broadly analogous to similar cycles seen in flood basalt provinces preserved on passive continental margins. Continental intraplate magmatism may also show age progressions as in the NigerNigeria province (Bowden et al.). These progressions are, however, very rare and not so clearly defined as in ocean island chains, probably because the continental lithosphere is thicker and less easily penetrated than oceanic lithosphere. The Monteregian Hills and White Mountain provinces of eastern North America (Eby), for example, show no obvious progression but their seaward extension, the New England seamounts, show a regular decrease in age eastwards. Reviews of other continental intraplate alkaline provinces are given by Fletcher & Beddoe-Stevens (Velasco province, Bolivia) and Kogarko (Kola Peninsula). The Cameroon line in West Africa (Fitton) includes both continental and oceanic alkaline volcanic centres. None of these examples shows any clear progression of ages. Some continental provinces undergo repeated alkaline magmatism in one place over long periods. For example, the Kola Peninsula (Kogarko) was the site of alkaline magmatism in the mid Proterozoic and again in the Devonian. Such examples could be the result of coincidence but are more likely the result of the repeated exploitation of zones of weakness in the lithosphere. Destructive plate boundaries provide the third tectonic setting in which alkaline igneous rocks may occur. During the life of a subduction zone the characteristic calc-alkaline magmas tend to become more potassic with time and may give way to volcanic rocks of the shoshonitic association, some members of which may contain leucite. A discussion of subduction zone processes is beyond the scope of this volume and the reader is referred to the reviews of Gill (1981) and Ewart (1982). There are, however, two circumstances under which subduction processes can lead to the generation of more 'normal' alkaline magmas. Once the descending slab has become dehydrated at depth it loses its capacity to stimulate the generation of calc-alkaline magmas but it can still cause melting in the overlying asthenosphere. This can lead to the production of alkaline magmas from the mantle above the deepest parts of subduction zones. One such example of alkaline magmas erupted under a compressive regime is provided by the Trans-Pecos province of west Texas (Barker). The alkaline rocks in this area grade south-westwards into the calc-alkaline rocks of the Sierra Madre Occidental in Mexico and Barker relates both suites to subduction of the Farallon Plate. After the cessation of subduction, relaxation of the former compressive regime often results in extension and the generation of alkaline magmas. The resulting switch from subduction-related calc-alkaline to extensional alkaline magmatism appears to be a common phenomenon. It occurred, for example, in the western U.S.A. about 17 Ma ago and in parts of Africa and Arabia at the end of the Pan-African metamorphic episode during the late Precambrian. An example from the Pan-African belt in Mali is discussed by Liegeois & Black. The origin of alkaline magmas has attracted a great deal of interest among igneous petrologists over the last ten years or so. This interest has been stimulated by two important
xii
Introduction
and characteristic features of alkaline rocks. Firstly, they contain high concentrations of LILE and yet isotopic evidence suggests that their parental magmas had a mantle source which had been depleted in these elements for a long time. Thus alkaline igneous rocks may provide useful information about enrichment and/or melting processes in the mantle. Secondly, many mafic alkaline volcanic rocks contain xenoliths inferred to have originated within the mantle (Menzies). These are often enriched in LILE when compared with concentrations expected of chondritic mantle material and sometimes contain amphiboles and micas of metasomatic origin (Bailey). Such clear evidence for the existence of metasomatically enriched mantle, coupled with the problem of extracting LILE-rich magmas from LILE-poor mantle, has led to hypotheses involving mantle metasomatism as a precursor to alkaline magmatism. These hypotheses, reviewed by Bailey, have gained popularity over the past fifteen years and are invoked by several contributors to this volume. Mantle metasomatism neatly explains many of the features of alkaline magmatism. For example, the frequent association of alkaline magmatism with areas of large-scale regional uplift is consistent with the relatively low density of metasomatized mantle. An essential feature of all models involving a metasomatized mantle source for alkaline magmas is that this source must lie in the lithosphere. This is the only part of the mantle where enriched material can remain in one place for long periods without being swept away by convection. The lithospheric mantle beneath the continents is likely to be chemically and isotopically different from that beneath the oceans. Continental lithospheric mantle is old and will have had as complex a metamorphic and magmatic history as the overlying crust. Oceanic lithosphere, on the other hand, is relatively young and probably depleted in LILE. These differences should be reflected in the compositions of continental and oceanic alkaline rocks. However, alkali basalts erupted in continental and oceanic settings are generally identical both chemically (Fitton) and isotopically (Menzies). Since enriched mantle xenoliths are only commonly found in continental regions it follows that the enriched lithospheric mantle represented by these xenoliths is not the source of most continental and oceanic alkaline magmas. An asthenospheric source is therefore implied. This is not to say that enriched continental lithospheric mantle is never involved in the generation of alkaline magmas. There is good evidence (e.g. Edgar) that pockets of ancient enriched mantle beneath cratonic regions provide the source for LILE-rich mafic and ultramafic alkaline rocks such as micaceous kimberlite (Dawson), and lamproite and other potassic igneous rocks (Bergman). It is significant that these rock types are exclusively continental. More extensive melting may involve the continental lithosphere mantle in the production of less exotic rock types such as flood tholeiite and mildly alkaline basalt. Upton & Emeleus, for example, argue for a lithospheric mantle source for the Gardar alkaline magmas. If most alkaline magmas have an ultimate source in the asthenosphere then they must share this source with unequivocally asthenosphere-derived rocks such as mid-ocean ridge basalt (MORB). The consistent isotopic differences between MORB and alkali basalts (and indeed all intraplate basalts) requires that the asthenosphere be heterogeneous. This heterogeneity may result from the entrainment of lower mantle material in deep mantle plumes as suggested for the Hawaiian island chain (Clague). The entire convecting upper mantle may also be heterogeneous on a small scale and alkaline magmas may be generated by the selective melting of LILE-enriched streaks while more extensive melting produces MORB (Fitton). Geochemical studies on ocean island basalts from the South Atlantic
Introduction
xiii
(Weaver et a/.) suggest that one component of these enriched streaks is provided by subducted ocean-floor sediment. Derivation of LILE-rich magmas from an asthenospheric source depleted in these elements requires either very small degress of partial melting or extensive crystal fractionation. There can be no doubt that many alkaline rocks are the products of extensive low pressure crystal fractionation but this cannot be true of those alkaline rocks which host mantle xenoliths. Even the most magnesian alkaline rocks, which must represent nearprimary magmas, are rich in LILE. Small-degree partial melting ( < l ~ ) is therefore required to produce such magmas. McKenzie (1985) has recently shown that the extraction of melt fractions as small as 0.2~ is not only physically possible but inevitable where the melt viscosity is low, as it probably is in the case of alkaline magmas. Experimental studies on alkaline rocks and synthetic analogues (reviewed by Edgar) provide useful constraints on the feasibility of fractional crystallization and partial melting models and on the temperatures and pressures involved. Many lines of evidence suggest that volatile components form a significant part of alkaline magmas. The development of extensive zones of metasomatised country rock (fenite) around alkaline plutons, the abundance of chlorine and fluorine in some alkaline igneous rocks, and the frequently explosive eruption of alkaline magma all point to high concentrations of volatiles. These volatile components play an important role in the evolution of alkaline magmas and yet relatively little is known about them. Constraints on their composition have been provided by fluid inclusion studies (Harris & Sheppard) and by thermodynamic considerations (Kogarko). The effects of volatile components on the evolution of alkaline magmas can be seen clearly in both intrusive and extrusive rocks. Larsen & Serensen, for example, discuss the crystallization history of the Ilimaussaq intrusion in South-West Greenland and show how the upward migration of low-density, low-viscosity volatile-rich magma delayed crystallization under the roof of the intrusion. Silicic alkaline pyroclastic deposits around central volcanoes in Kenya often show striking variations in the abundance of some incompatible elements within a single vertical section, implying compositional zonation in the magma chamber before eruption. Macdonald shows that these variations are too large to be accounted for by crystal fractionation alone and suggests that some elements have been transported to the magma chamber roof zones as complex ions in a volatile phase. Carbonatites provide perhaps the best illustration of all of the influence of volatile components on the origin and evolution of alkaline rocks. There is now a consensus that their parental magmas originate by the separation of an immiscible carbonate liquid phase from a CO2-saturated nephelinite or phonolite magma. There is, however, some disagreement over the nature and subsequent evolution of this parental carbonate magma. Le Bas argues that the parental magma is rich in alkalis and similar in composition to the natrocarbonatite lavas erupted from Oldoinyo Lengai. This magma evolves at low pressure towards the more common calcite carbonatite (s6vite) by loss of alkalis to the surrounding country rocks which are metasomatized (fenitized) as a result. Twyman & Gittins offer an alternative scheme in which s6vite magmas are parental and natrocarbonatite magmas are derived from them by crystal fractionation. Most petrologists now believe that evolved alkaline magmas are produced by the fractional crystallization of basic magma. The more highly undersaturated parental magmas represented by basanite and nephelinite will produce undersaturated derivatives
xiv
Introduction
such as phonolite and foyaite. Mildly alkaline and transitional basalt m a g m a is likely to produce trachyte and, with extreme fractionation, alkali rhyolite. The production of peralkaline acid rocks by crystal fractionation alone is likely to be an inefficient process. The operation of this process, however, is clearly demonstrated by their association with transitional basalt on some ocean islands, such as Ascension (Harris & Sheppard). Peralkaline acid rocks only occur in a b u n d a n c e in continental environments, however, and here there is often good evidence that crustal contamination has a c c o m p a n i e d crystal fractionation. Well-documented examples of the operation of crustal c o n t a m i n a t i o n in the evolution of alkaline m a g m a s are presented by several of the contributors to this volume. Downes, for example, shows that the assimilation of lower crustal granulite has affected the evolution of alkaline m a g m a s in the F r e n c h Massif Central and uses isotope data to estimate the extent of this contamination. Other examples are presented by Bowden et al. ( N i g e r - N i g e r i a granite ring complexes), Eby (Monteregian Hills and White Mountain provinces, N o r t h America), Fitton (Cameroon line, West Africa) and Fletcher & BeddoeStevens (Velasco province, Bolivia). Other authors propose the derivation of evolved alkaline m a g m a s directly from m e t a s o m a t i z e d mantle or lower crust (Bailey; Woolley &
Jones). Our understanding of the origin and evolution of alkaline m a g m a s has come a long way since the publication of Sorensen's book in 1974, largely through the acquisition of a far larger geochemical and isotopic data base. The contributions to this volume review the current state of this understanding. Emphasis has shifted from crustal to mantle processes with the recognition of mantle m e t a s o m a t i s m and its possible role as a precursor to alkaline magmatism. More recently, though, there has been a swing towards the opposite view, that mantle m e t a s o m a t i s m is c a u s e d b y alkaline m a g m a t i s m . Theoretical and experimental studies on the migration and segregation of small-degree melts seem destined to accelerate this swing. Despite these advances, however, m a n y mysteries remain unsolved and alkaline rocks will still provide a fruitful field of research for m a n y years to come, yielding further insights into the nature of mantle processes and the evolution of magmas.
References EWART, A. 1982. The mineralogy and petrology of Tertiary-Recent orogenic volcanic rocks: with special reference to the andesitic-basaltic compositional range. In Thorpe, R. S. (ed.) Andesites. Pp. 25-87. John Wiley & Sons, London. GILL,J. B. 1981. Orogenic Andesites and Plate Tectonics, 390 pp. Springer-Verlag, Berlin. LARSEN,L. M., REX,D. C. & SECHER,K. 1983. The age of carbonatites, kimberlites and lamprophyres from southern west Greenland: recurrent alkaline magmatism during 2500 million years. Lithos 16, 215-21. LE BAS,M. J., LE MAITRE, R. W., STRECKEISEN,A. & ZANETTIN, B. 1986. A chemical classification of
volcanic rocks based on the total alkali--silica diagram. J. Petrol. 27, 745-50. MCKENZIE, D. 1985. The extraction of magma from the crust and the mantle. Earth planet. Sci. Lett. 74, 81-91. MITCHELL,R. H. 1976. Potassium-argon geochronology of the Poohbah Lake alkaline complex, northwestern Ontario. Can. J. Earth Sci. 13, 1456-9. SORENSEN,H. (ed.) 1974. The Alkaline Rocks. 622 pp. John Wiley & Sons, London. STRECKEISEN,A. 1967. Classification and nomenclature of igneous rocks. N. Jb. Miner. Abh. 107, 144-240. - - , 1980. Classificationand nomenclature of volcanic rocks, lamprophyres, carbonatites and melilitic rocks. Geol. Rundschau, 69, 194-207.
J. G. FITTON& B. G. J. UPTON,Grant Institute of Geology, University of Edinburgh, West Mains Road, Edinburgh EH9 3JW, U.K.
Mantle metasomatism
perspective and prospect
D. K. Bailey S U M M A R Y : Mantle replenishment in lithophile elements has been discerned in the patterns of trace elements and isotopes in lavas. One replenishment process is identified as metasomatic replacement, seen in ultramafic xenoliths brought up in high-velocity alkaline eruptions. Thus alkaline magmatism provides the best primafacie evidence of metasomatism and open-system conditions in the upper mantle. The list of added lithophile elements includes the following: H, C, F, Na, A1, P, S, C1, K, Ca, Ti, Fe, Rb, Y, Zr, Nb, Ba and rare earths. Some metasomatism may be due to wall-rock alteration near magma bodies, but the evidence for metasomatism prior to melting opens the possibility that the process is a precursor to alkaline magmatism, giving the necessary source enrichment in lithophile elements. In some igneous provinces the metasomafism is widespread, intensive and pervasive; in others it appears as veining of variable intensity. Metasomatism as a largescale process is best indicated by the widespread distribution of alkaline magmatism in space and time: volatile flux through the lithosphere would then be the necessary precursor of metasomatism and magmatism. Volatile activity, metasomatism and melt enrichment clearly widen the scope for mafic magma generation in the mantle, but some long-standing problems of the alkaline associations (and indeed the calc-alkaline) also call for re-examination in terms of volatile activity in the lithosphere mantle. These include the diversity of magmas, the generation of large felsic volumes, and composition gaps in magma series. Experiments show that felsic minerals are stable to 30 kb, indicating the possibility of felsic-melt generation in the upper part of the mantle. A combination of volatile flux and melt percolation along geotherms that intersect the solidus at depths of less than 80 km would lead to enrichmentand metasomatism, providing distinct mantle sources for felsic magmas. Initial (or residual) melts from such a region, as distinct from those from greater depths, would be constrained by equilibria involving felsic minerals. Thus an igneous cycle could generate a bimodal association, with felsic melts forming in the upper regime and the mafic melts originating at depths below the range of felsic-mineral stabilities. Such a magma system is consistent with the observed eruptive characteristics, explains the typical ultramafic nodule and megacryst suites in the alkali olivine-basalt association and is free of difficulties with relative volumes of melts, with eruption timing and with rapid changes in erupted compositions.
Perspective From its Greek origins the term metasomatism should imply a 'change of body' or a change of substance. It must indicate a chemical change in a pre-existing rock or mineral, and traditionally has been used to make the distinction from metamorphism ('change of form') indicating reconstitution without chemical introduction. Unfortunately, early definitions of metasomatism are not rigorous, but common usage applies to cases where material has been transferred through a vapour or fluid without melting. More recently, in reference to the mantle, the usage has widened considerably, sometimes referring to simple melt infiltration, and even unspecified enrichment processes of a pre-existing mantle composition. Obviously the latter usages are not justified but there is a boundary problem. W h e n melt is introduced into a rock it may react with its surroundings and metasomatism may correctly describe the alteration process in the wall-rocks;
this borderline condition is perhaps part of the reason for some of the current ambiguity. There is at present a need for general agreement about terminology and it would certainly help to retain scientific precision if 'metasomatism' could be restricted to those cases where there is petrographic evidence of replacement of a pre-existing rock. Certainly the term should not be used to describe simple melt injection, producing a hybrid mixed rock, nor when there is no petrographic evidence that there has been replacement of an earlier mineralogy. In other words, the term should be applied only when there is unequivocal evidence of the previous substance--otherwise, to say that a rock has changed its chemistry is supposition. If there is a case for chemical introduction but the process is unclear or unknown, it would be better, and more straightforward, to use the term enrichment. Evidence for metasomatism in the mantle has
From: FITTON, J. G. & UPTON, B. G. J. (eds), 1987, Alkaline Igneous Rocks, Geological Society Special Publication No. 30, pp. 1-13.
2
D.K.
been steadily accumulating during the past 10 years (Harte et al. 1975; Lloyd & Bailey 1975) and the topic has provoked such interest that some surveys and reviews have already appeared (e.g. Boettcher & O'Neil 1980, Introduction and tabulation; Bailey 1982). The cited examples are relatively succinct and in some ways complementary, and may be taken as constituting a comprehensive starting point for the following discussion which aims to sketch an overall perspective to the subject. Occurrence and distribution Mantle samples showing evidence of metasomatism are provided in ultramafic nodules carried to the surface by high-speed volcanic eruptions. Some peridotite massifs (e.g. Lherz) contain veins of less refractory minerals, while others also contain evenly distributed minerals such as phlogopite and amphibole (e.g. Finero). These are sometimes cited as examples of 'enriched' and even metasomatized mantle but the evidence that such minerals have been introduced from an external source while the peridotite was part of the mantle has still to be established. Even in volcanically derived mantle fragments there may still be problems in distinguishing reaction products produced after incorporation in the magma; various criteria can be applied, however, and it is clear that in many cases minerals were introduced into the peridotite prior to eruption (Bailey 1982). Mantle nodules showing signs of metasomatism are brought to the surface exclusively by alkaline activity, especially in ultramafic and mafic eruptions. These range from kimberlites, which are characteristically fragmental, through to magmas in the alkali olivine-basalt association (basanites through to mugearites) which may occasionally carry ultramafic nodules. Hence, in terms of distribution, samples may be found in any parts of the stable plates, both oceanic and continental, where there has been alkaline igneous activity; such activity is usually associated with uplift and dislocation, in other words with some kind of lesion in the lithosphere. Compositions Metasomatism is recognized when there is replacement of a pre-existing peridotite mineralogy, new minerals being characterized by their content of mobile and volatile elements, as listed in Table 1. Introduction of the listed minerals into garnet or spinel peridotite (generally taken as representing average mantle composition) signifies mantle enrichment in lithophile ele-
Bailey TABLE 1. Lithophile-element-bearing m&erals in peridotite xenoliths which either may show metasomatic replacement of pre-existing peridotite mineralogy or are associated with metasomatism a (Major) b (Minor)
biotite, amphibole, clinopyroxene, carbonate phosphate, titanates, oxides, sulphides
Possible candidates for higher-level metasomatic minerals c (< 25 kb) feldspathoids, alkali feldspars ments. Most descriptions of mantle metasomatism deduce the introduction of some or all of the following elements: H, C, F, Na, A1, P, S, C1, K, Ca, Ti, Fe, Rb, Y, Zr, Nb, Ba, rare earths. If metasomatism were wholly a replacement process then there should be subtraction of equivalent material, balancing the introduction of the above elements. As yet this aspect has received little attention and this may be because the fabric of the rocks showing metasomatism is characteristically veined, with metasomatism proceeding along grain boundaries and fissures: hence the introduced material could be largely accommodated by an increase in rock volume, with redistribution rather than removal of the displaced elements. A parallel case may be seen in alkaline metasomatism in the crust (fenitization) which is characteristically marked by the introduction of new minerals along a close network of cracks. Timing In many cases the indications are that the metasomatic introduction of new minerals, although it must have preceded eruption, is part of the cycle of igneous activity, and there is isotopic harmony between the nodules and the magmas. In some instances there is evidence of an earlier metasomatic event (Erlank & Shimizu 1977; Menzies & Murthy 1980a) and there are cases of possible complex metasomatism and/or enrichment dating as far back as 3 Ga (Erlank et al. 1980; Menzies & Murthy 1980b). No doubt the picture will become still more complex as new data become available; this may be expected because alkaline activity has often been repeated through the same segment of lithosphere (Bailey 1977) and even if metasomatism were nothing more than a minor part of igneous activity there should be samples showing complex histories. Conditions of metasomatism Using a combination of experimentally determined mineral stabilities and solidi it is possible
Mantle metasomatism
3
to put limits on the pressures and temperatures of metasomatism, and hence on the conditions in the source mantle. Figs 1 and 2 summarize the conditions for stability of phlogopite, amphibole, clinopyroxene and felsic minerals in the mantle, and by reference to Fig. 4 the relative stability of carbonates can readily be envisaged. Obviously the diagrams must be generalizations because the individual mineral stabilities will depend on bulk composition (mineral and rock), coexistence with other metasomatic minerals, and the presence or absence of vapour, fluid or melt. In spite of these reservations the diagrams offer useful limits and indicate the following relationships. 1 Amphibole is stable near the peridotite solidus only in the upper part of the mantle, its lower boundary corresponding approximately to that of spinel and showing broad equivalence to the lower stability boundaries of feldspars and feldspathoids and the upper stability boundary of carbonate (see Figs 1, 2 and 4). 2 Phlogopite stability extends to higher temperatures and greater depths than amphibole, its
FIG. 2. P-T relationships of mineral stabilities and solidi, and geotherms. Solidi: as in Fig. 1 with the addition of WE, the solidus in the system KA1SiO4MgO-SiO2-H20-CO2 (Wendlandt & Eggler 1980). WE is used to provide a measure of phlogopite stability in peridotite mantle; its extrapolation to intersect KS at point P indicates a depth limit for phlogopite in the presence of melt (this is similar to the boundary given by Wyllie (1979)). Geotherms: as in Fig. 1. Mineral stabilities: C, coesite: Ks, kalsilite; AB, albite + nepheline; (AB), albite (jadeite + quartz); OR, K-feldspar; SC, solvus crest for alkali feldspars. stability limit at the solidus approximately coinciding with the inflexion region in some kimberlite geotherms (about 180km). Phlogopitebearing nodules or lavas from greater depths would therefore seem to be ruled out (Bailey 1986). 3 Clinopyroxene stability can extend up to the vapour-absent solidus and this mineral is arguably the most important but least appreciated metasomatic mineral.
FIG. 1. P-Trelationships of solidi, and geotherms. Solidi : PSD, peridotite vapour-absent solidus; KS, kimberlite solidus (Eggler & Wendlandt 1978); OE, peridotite solidus in the presence of H20 and CO2 (limited) (Olafsson & Eggler 1983). For convenience the stability region of spinel peridotite, with or without amphibole, is shown here rather than in Fig. 2. D is the diamond stability boundary (Kennedy & Kennedy 1976). Geotherms: S and O, shield and ocean (Clark & Ringwood 1964); 180, oceanic lithosphere 180 Ma old (Sclater et al. 1980); 30, oceanic lithosphere 30 Ma old (Oldenburg 1981). If geotherms should converge more rapidly in the depth range around 200 km as proposed by Tozer (1967) the geometry of the melt systems would change but the principles would remain the same.
From the above it may be deduced that carbonate and clinopyroxene may appear in any metasomatic regime, but the geological and experimental evidence suggests that high-pressure, low-temperature conditions (e.g. kimberlitic) favour carbonates while low-pressure hightemperature conditions (basanitic) favour clinopyroxene (see Fig. 5). Consideration of the magmas and their nodule suites also points to the fact that ultramafic alkaline magmas such as kimberlites, melilitites and nephelinites are characterized by phlogopite (in melts and xenoliths) while other magmas such as some nephelinites, but especially basanites, are characterized by xenoliths containing amphibole. Basanites in particular are likely to carry ultramafic nodules containing both spinel and amphibole, which
4
D.K. Bailey
may be an indicator of a generally shallower source depth for the nodules compared with ultramafic melts.
Outstanding issues While the reality of mantle metasomatism seems to have found wide acceptance, some differences may be perceived concerning such questions as the following: 1 Which comes first, the magmatism or the metasomatism? 2 Is metasomatism always a local phenomenon (in the vicinity of alkaline intrusions) or can it develop regionally? 3 What is the source of materials erupted at the surface, e.g. are they from the lithosphere or the asthenosphere ? The last question seems irresolvable until the nature of the asthenosphere can be unequivocally defined. At the moment, the ascription of a rock to an asthenosphere source (on the basis of selected aspects of its trace-element or isotope chemistry) is a convoluted way of saying that it has some attributes of mid-ocean ridge basalt; it would be wholly inappropriate to digress into this minefield. The first two questions are related, and controversy on these issues seems likely to be fruitless. Obviously, samples showing recognizable metasomatism can do so only on a local scale, and because volcanically transported fragments of metasomatized mantle must be small the evidence for metasomatism on a large scale must be sought in other ways. Appropriate lines of evidence, indicating large-scale metasomatism, have been described elsewhere (Bailey 1982) but may be summarized as follows: (a) an ultramafic nodule population dominated by metasomatized fragments throughout an igneous province; (b) a range of samples showing various degrees of metasomatism through to completely transformed nodules (alkali clinopyroxenites); and (c) the chemical equivalence of extensively metasomatized nodules and erupted melt compositions. Much of the cogency of the case for large-scale metasomatism is lost if discussion is allowed to focus just on laboratory data: it is then easy to lose sight of the wider geological perspective, where alkali- and volatile-rich magmatism has to be seen in the context of the geothermal and tectonic conditions of stable plates (Bailey 1983). This larger-scale (geological) evidence must be taken together with that of metasomatism on a small scale if we are to retain a balanced view. Both kinds of evidence exist (O'Reilly & Griffin 1984; Wilshire 1984) and they are not mutually exclusive. No amount of evidence or
argument in favour of one can, of itself, falsify the case for the other. Good petrographic evidence of local metasomatism is obviously immune to rebuttal, and no evidence has yet emerged to reject the case for regional development of the process; until such evidence emerges it is important that the argument should not become polarized (as in some older geological disputes) lest we end up with a controversy without roots in nature. The dilemma of the relationships between melting and metasomatism has been highlighted by Hawkesworth et al. (1984), who distinguish two enrichment processes, one typified by subsolidus metasomatism in kimberlite nodules and the other typified by injection of small-volume melts (typically associated with basanitic magmatism). These are essentially expressions of the effects of pressure and temperature, and it will be shown that they may be explained by the interplay of geothermal gradient, mantle solidus and mineral stabilities. It will be seen there that subsolidus metasomatism can also play a vital role in basanitic magmatism. Although it is valuable to identify the chemical characteristics of the two types of enrichment (Hawkesworth et al. 1984) it should be remembered that there is a spectrum of alkaline magmatism between kimberlites and basanites, and a spectrum of enrichment processes may be expected (see Fig. 5 and Bailey 1986).
Geological factors If all the observed metasomatism were a localized consequence of alkaline igneous activity, then the quantities of metasomatized mantle and the petrological significance of the process would be essentially trivial. It is when the geological picture is seen in total that such a conclusion becomes most suspect. Association with alkaline magmatism signifies the high activities of alkalis, mobile elements and volatiles, and the high-velocity eruptions that bring the samples to the surface emphasize the role of gases in this type of magmatism. When the tectonic framework, especially the connection between alkaline magmatism and lesions in stable lithosphere (and the repetition through time), is taken into account, it is difficult to escape the conclusion that we are observing a process in which volatiles must play a vital role. Alkali rich means volatile rich and, although there may be room for debate about whether the metasomatism is a precursor to magmatism in any particular instance, there can be little doubt that volatile migration may have far reaching effects without the necessary intervention of magma. One of the most graphic examples is in kimberlite peridotite
Mantle metasomatism nodules containing phlogopite: these were sampled from points on the geotherm well below the kimberlite solidus (Bailey 1982, Fig. 3) and hence well outside conditions where any melt could exist. Certainly there are strong grounds for supposing that volatile influx is a natural precursor to both metasomatism and alkaline magmatism.
Prospect Given an outline of present concepts of mantle metasomatism it becomes fruitful to look beyond and to consider other consequences of volatile movement through the mantle. One aspect, of immediate relevance to a volume on Alkaline Rocks, has been largely neglected in discussion of mantle metasomatism: this concerns the broader spectrum embracing not just mafic and ultramafic compositions but felsic alkaline magmas. At what has been described as the limiting case of cratonic magmatism (Bailey 1980a) there is kimberlite with no felsic associates, and closely related must be the lamproites and melilitites with very limited, if not uncertain, felsic connections. These and the ultramafic lamprophyres share other common features, such as style of eruption, that require special consideration in terms of petrogenesis; they have been discussed elsewhere (Bailey 1986). The more voluminous expressions of alkaline mafic magmatism are essentially basanitic (having some connections with nephelinites) grading through to transitional basalts, and these typically form major volcano complexes and have associated felsic magmas. Such alkali basalt magmas show evidence of mantle enrichment and characteristically may carry mantle nodules, which themselves show signs of metasomatism and/or enrichment. Their mantle source is hardly in doubt, and the possibility that this source may have undergone metasomatism raises the question whether the felsic magmas could be part of the same process. Some of the problems of alkaline felsic magmatism, such as regional magma development and comparative volumes, could be resolved in the context of regional metasomatic processes (Bailey 1972, 1974) and there have been no data on relevant mineral stabilities to exclude the possibility of sources in the upper mantle (Bailey 1976); more recent data lend credence to this possibility and allow a more penetrating look at the question. Before embarking on an examination of the more recent experimental information it is useful to look over the case in geological terms. The popular view for a long time has been that
5
felsic alkaline rocks are products of differentiation from mafic parents at relatively shallow (usually crustal) depths. Processes such as fractional crystallization are still currently in vogue in spite of many difficulties (see for instance Yoder 1979; Bailey 1981) and discussions of felsic magmas in particular seem impervious to contrary evidence. When the various pieces of evidence are assembled together, however, the case for low-pressure differentiation as a universal mechanism for producing felsic magmas can be seen to be without foundation. Essentially, evidence contrary to continuous differentiation at low pressure takes two forms: (1) felsic and intermediate volcanics carry ultramafic nodules; and (2) there are substantial composition and volume discrepancies in the igneous products of a given complex or province. As will be seen later, the first could be considered as the evidence from the high-energy ranges of the magmatic system and the second from the lower-energy ranges. Nodules
In addition to the dramatic examples of felsic lavas carrying ultramafic nodules (Wright 1966, 1969), mugearites and hawaiites are commonly reported as the hosts in ultramafic-nodule localities (see Boettcher & O'Neil (1980) for an informative listing). High-speed eruption is essential, and these are unequivocal examples of the existence of felsic and intermediate melts in the mantle: it is clear that low pressure differentiation is not essential for the formation of magmas in the range hawaiite-trachyte-phonolite. In fact, the composition of these melts may be a direct indication of physical and chemical conditions in the mantle source. Composition gaps
Daly (1925, 1927) first drew attention to the basalt-trachyte bimodality of oceanic lavas, a finding later supported by Barth (Barth et al. 1939) and statistically verified by Chayes (1963) who suggested that this raised doubts about the evolution of trachyte from basalt by continuous differentiation. Quite naturally, this suggestion provoked spirited opposition from advocates of fractional crystallization; the case was reviewed by Yoder (1973) who concluded that the gap was real and that this was not a realistic outcome of continuous fractional crystallization. More recent studies (e.g. Zielinski 1975) still invoke this mechanism, however, without apparent question, and so it is permissible to cite some additional geological facts.
6
D.K. Bailey
1 In deeply exposed continental sections revealing syenite plutons, comparable alkaline mafic and intermediate plutons are rare or absent. 2 Zoned plutons are rare, and where known are relatively small and generally considered to be composite (e.g. Monteregian Hills). 3 In keeping with 1 and 2, the common nodules in felsic volcanics are typically cognate, e.g. syenite in trachyte, peralkaline granite in comendite. To the above it may be added that the typical nodules in basanites are peridotite and gabbro. Hence it is hardly reasonable to argue that the basalt-trachyte bimodality in the ocean basins is an artefact of exposure level, eruption characteristics or sampling bias: the continental plutonic bodies and the nodule suites confirm the scarcity of intermediate magmas. Perhaps the most vivid evidence of magmatic bimodality lies on Graciosa in the Azores. Here there have been alternating eruptions of felsic and mafic pyroclastics, without detectable time breaks, requiring the simultaneous coexistence of contrasting magmas within the one volcanic system (Maund & Bailey 1982; Maund, 1985). This is simply a graphic example of the contemporaneous eruption of trachyte and basalt on oceanic islands generally, to which Daly called attention so long ago. Other composition gaps are present in other magma associations, such as basanite-phonolite and nephelinite-nephelinitic phonolite, but it may be relevant that even among the felsic rocks themselves there seem to be marked distribution maxima, as between phonolites, trachytes and rhyolites (and the plutonic equivalents). These gaps, too, militate against continuous differentiation, tending to favour partial melting or at least multiprocess origins (see Bailey (1976) for a full discussion).
Volumediscrepancies Another major problem for continuous differentiation at low pressure lies in the volume relations of the magmas in many provinces. The usual image of a large alkali basalt centre with small spines and flows of trachyte may be reasonable for some oceanic volcanoes, but it is a dangerous generalization, even for the oceans, e.g. Azores and Canaries. On the continents it is probably the exception rather than the rule: here again we have deep sections providing plutonic evidence. In major syenite provinces, such as Kola and Malawi, the basic and intermediate rocks required by continuous differentiation are not merely insufficient--they are lacking altogether.
Large syenite plutons (and large monotonic trachyte and phonolite volcanoes, as in the Kenya rift) are further evidence against low-pressure evolution of felsic magmas from a basaltic parent. Indeed, to suppose such differentiation has occurred when there is no sign of the earlier stages is to assume that syenite can form in only one way. In the volcanic regime the volume discrepancy can be seen in the Miocene-Recent activity of the East African rift zone where the calculated volumes of felsic and mafic volcanics are approximately equal (Williams 1972) and there have been regional floods of phonolite and trachyte. The latter are difficult to provide for in any process of magma generation but pose an acute problem for high-level differentiation (Bailey 1974, 1978). It should be said, too, that detailed studies of particular trachyte and pantellerite suites have not only failed to find any links with basalt (Bailey 1978) but have even revealed distinctive differences between felsic volcanoes erupting contemporaneously in the same province. In the area around Lake Naivasha in Kenya, there are Holocene phonolite, trachyte, pantellerite, comendite and basalt eruptions from overlapping centres that provide not only a series of major composition gaps but also distinctive major and trace-element patterns that are inexplicable in terms of continuous differentiation (Bailey & Macdonald, 1987). Clearly, there is commonality in that the magmas are part of a cycle of igneous activity, but the need is for a multisource/ multiprocess system of magma genesis. Yoder's solution (1973) to the dilemma of the Daly gap was the production of two contrasting magmas by fractional melting, along lines indicated by Presnall (1969). This envisages a source composition with two invariant points which by continuous melt extraction during an igneous cycle yields two contrasting magmas. Melt generation from two distinct invariant points would clearly alleviate some of the problems of alkaline magmatism and would explain composition gaps, but the generation of large volumes of felsic magma from a peridotite mantle source remains a difficulty, and a new problem is introduced of irreversibility and timing. Either the source volume would have to keep changing or the liquid from the lower-temperature invariant point could be erupted only at the start of a melting cycle. These difficulties could be solved through replenishment of felsic components by metasomatism or other forms of enrichment. At the very least therefore Yoder's solution requires an open system with melting pulses acting on periodically enriched sources (cycles of melting and enrichment). Even so the volume problem remains, and
Mantle metasomatism an additional factor is introduced by alternating mafic-felsic volcanism, exemplified by Graciosa, where there is effectively simultaneous eruption of felsic-mafic magmas poor in phenocrysts. Such activity implies the need for two (or more) distinctly different source compositions to be melted and tapped during the same igneous cycle. Geological evidence indicates that felsic sources richer than normal peridotite are feasible in the mantle and recent experimental evidence confirms that appropriate mineral stabilities extend into the upper part of the mantle. When these are taken together with eruption characteristics, depth indicators in the nodule suites and evidence of metasomatism, it becomes possible to propose a scheme of magma genesis that can reconcile all the seemingly conflicting observations and give an integrated pattern to the activity.
Metasomatism and the development of separate felsic sources Peridotites containing minor amounts of plagioclase, trachytes containing peridotite nodules, and sanidine-coesite eclogite nodules are some of the evidence indicating that felsic melts and sub-solidus felsic mineralogies are possible in the mantle, and it has been clear for some years that there is no a priori reason to suppose otherwise (Bailey 1976). In view of the problems with felsic magmatism, it is appropriate to update the evidence on mineral stabilities and then to enquire whether and how two sources could develop, and how magmas could be generated and erupted. In Figs 1 and 2 some of the relevant stability fields are plotted. Obviously the bulk mantle composition must influence some of these, but broadly speaking felsic minerals could exist to depths of about 100 kin, the exact limit depending also on the prevailing temperature. The special importance of the stability ranges shown in Figs 1 and 2 lies in the fact that the upper mantle within the felsic stability zone has the potential to yield melts of felsic character at a relatively low-temperature invariant point. No such invariant melting point is possible at greater depths, so that the first melts (from a phase assemblage containing no felsic minerals) must of necessity be different, and in all probability distinctly mafic. Thus the possibility of two distinct sources with completely different first melts is evident. Could their potential for producing contrasting magmas be established and enhanced by processes of enrichment and/or metasomatism ? Starting from the critical observation that high
7
volatile activity is a hall-mark of alkaline magnatism, it has been possible to develop a hypothesis relating magmatic variations to melting and metasomatism by volatile flux along different geothermal gradients (Bailey 1970, 1980a). Further consideration of the effects of the processes along low geothermal gradients has been given elsewhere (Bailey 1984, 1986). For the generation of felsic melts, it is necessary to look to activity along steeper geotherms more appropriate to oceanic conditions (or those away from continental craton nuclei). On steeper geotherms, such as those that would cross the solidus at high levels in the mantle (in the felsic stability region), volatiles could migrate along the geotherm only if the channelways were lined (Olafsson & Eggler 1983); melting is then more likely. When the possibility of flux melting along steeper geotherms was discussed previously (Bailey 1980a, 1983) attention was focussed on the eruption of melt through the overlying lithosphere with increasing departure of melt temperature from that of the wall-rocks, i.e. an intrusion, or melt diapir, rising as a detached thermal anomaly. In recent years, however, the concept of migration of very small percentage melts has found increasing favour (Walker et al. 1978; Waft 1980; Stolper et al. 1982). Essentially the melt is envisaged as percolating through the mantle, in which case it should maintain thermal equilibrium with its path, and in the simplest case could be envisaged as migrating along the geothermal gradient. Where the melt is generated by volatile flux, it would effectively extend the path of flux migration. Gradual percolation over a long distance would mean that the melt must also maintain phase equilibrium with the mineralogy through which it moves: most alkaline ultramafic melts are of alkali clinopyroxenite composition (Lloyd & Bailey 1975; Lloyd 1981) and could percolate only along channelways akin to the source mineralogy. Either there must be pervasive distribution of all the required phases or the movement must be restricted to channelways lined with these phases. As the initial melting is seen here as resulting from volatile influx, the pathways are more likely to be enriched by interaction with the melt, which may be contrasted with the scavenging process of melt percolation envisaged by Fitton & Dunlop (1985). In the higher section of the path the percolating melt will, in any case, start to reapproach the solidus and will then progressively precipitate solids such as clinopyroxene and, closer to the solidus, minerals such as amphibole, phlogopite, carbonate, feldspar and feldspathoids. Consequently the melt channels will be further lined or plated with minerals containing lithophile ele-
8
D.K. Bailey
ments. This may lead to occlusion of the percolation holes, requiring changes of course for subsequent percolating melt and thus extending and intensifying an enriched zone in the mantle. At the same time the temperature will be raised by the release of latent heat of fusion so that continuing percolation will act as an effective means of heat transfer and gradually steepen the geothermal gradient. Under conditions of 'equilibrium' percolation, melt will be used up where the geotherm passes back through the solidus, leaving only residual volatiles to continue along the sub-solidus path. These may be expected to produce an intense zone of metasomatism in the immediately overlying lithosphere segment indicated in Fig. 3. Melts or volatiles migrating along steep geotherms will not encounter the stability regions of either phlogopite or amphibole (see Fig. 2) so that most of the trapping of lithophile elements would be in clinopyroxene and/or carbonate until the solidus is approached. Thus, most of the mobile constituents such as Na, K, OH, F and C1 will be concentrated into any surviving lowtemperature melts and fluids, leading to enrichment in felsic minerals and amphibole at nearsolidus conditions. During the early phase of a new igneous cycle along steeper geotherms, therefore, there would be enrichment and meta-
800
IO00
1200
T ~
-,o
5o-
~.:/..-..: ~ u s
I 0 0 --
. ..........
I
"~" ~.~ : ~ ACCUMULATION "<':;: ~].. :.i ::.. ? AND ,,,~,-~1::. i .) ENRICHMENT "20
I ~~.
h
l;. : S.::" ~::!~i:, ~ i
I ' IY'~ ._./ LUX
I
,
I\
"50
t Depth km
FIG. 3. The consequences of flux migration and melt percolation along an initial geotherm G1 (similar to O in Fig. 1) so that continued flux would develop alkaline ultramafic and/or mafic melts. As melt (arrows) percolates back towards the solidus (OE, as in Fig. 1) it precipitates lithophile-element-bearing minerals and releases heat, 'instantaneously' steepening the channel geotherm (G2). Vapour released, on solidification of melt, heats and metasomatizes the sub-solidus sector. With time, G2 will be smoothed by exchange with the greater mass of the surrounding mantle, and ultimately will be restored to a steady-state geotherm when activity ceases. (See text for further discussion.)
somatism in the amphibole-felsic zone of the upper mantle. Furthermore, the conditions would locally favour pegmatitic formation, with scope for the development of large megacrysts of amphibole, alkali felspars and soda-rich plagioclase; near-solidus volatile accumulation could then lead to small, explosive high-velocity eruptions, bringing such megacrysts to the surface. Melt percolating along grain boundaries obviously cannot penetrate below the solidus boundary, but continued percolation towards the solidus may lead to melt accumulation in this sector of the path, through a combination of steepening geothermal gradient and channel occlusion. The solidus boundary may thus act as a melt dam allowing the development of near-solidus melt pockets, capable of diatremic eruption, of which a typical manifestation would be lamprophyric breccias (see Bailey (1986) for further details). Accumulation of felsic melts would also be possible at temperatures below the peridotite solidus shown in Fig. 3 whenever the mantle becomes extensively modified so that the peridotite solidus no longer applies and other lowertemperature solidi become appropriate. In the strict sense this should take effect as soon as felsic minerals are present, but in the initial stages any melt would be volumetrically insignificant; these interstitial melts may themselves percolate, however, and accumulate into eruptible volumes at temperatures below the peridotite solidus. The preceding discussion provides the framework for generation of felsic melts in the alkaline magma association; it remains now to examine the conditions under which the mafic melts are generated, and in particular how some of these melts achieve the conditions necessary for highvelocity eruption.
Mafic melt diatresis Under the peridotite near-solidus conditions described above, the distinctive products are felsic magmas, high-velocity diatremic eruptions (felsic to mafic) carrying megacrysts and nodules, and lamprophyric breccias. In contrast, it is implicit in the discussion that many associated mafic volcanics originate below the felsic stability zone and in general will be at higher temperatures (the latter is also an essential element of Yoder's solution). Alkaline ultramafic and mafic rocks are indeed sometimes erupted as liquid, examples being available from lamproite through melilitite and nephelinite and extending to basalts; such melt eruptions present a fundamentally different facet of alkaline igneous activity. In addition to nearsolidus melts, the magma system has to permit
Mantle metasomatism melt accumulation at a temperature well above the vapour-saturated peridotite solidus, such that the eruption trajectory in P - T space intersects the Earth's surface above the solidus, as seen in Fig. 4. Some ultramafic eruptions may take the form of lapillae sprays in which the lapillae are lava droplets (Lloyd 1985); the associated pyroclastic deposits may also contain ultramafic nodules testifying to high-velocity eruption from a great depth. This must represent the case of a fluidized system originating in the mantle with a high liquid content and presumably driven by rapidly exsolved gas. Elsewhere ultramafic nodules are also to be found in lava flows, which must indicate more coherent high-velocity eruptions of melt plus fragments, and this style of eruption seems to apply most commonly in the case of nodule-bearing basanitic eruptions. The last factor, along with other basanite-eruption characteristics, is consistent with generally lower gas contents compared with nephelinite-melilitite magmas. High-velocity eruption requires a mechanism or agent of acceleration, and the only plausible 60(
800 I
I000 I
Deplh
T ~ IA
1200 I
OE/
km
G-_
""
CS
~ ~
T~\
\
1400 I |
',
\
L
5O
. I00
~
\
Ao;TN;X2E kb ] .... - 20 -30
~,B~\ \~
- 40 ,,
150 \1/ ~ 0 ~ -- MELT DIATRESIS
~ ~
'~'~ ,,
-- 5 0
FIG. 4. P-Trelations of detached melt bodies rising from a region of accumulation on a geotherm (G) along an adiabatic path (A, an adiabat line with its origin at 1100~ from the Nyiragongo lava lake). Carbonate peridotite solidus is CSQR, with TQ the decarbonation boundary of Wyllie (1979); the equivalent boundary of Olafsson & Eggler (1983) is shown by the parallel (broken) line originating in OE (as in Fig. 1). Basanitic melt B accumulates and starts buoyant ascent from a point on the geotherm around 1200~ (approximating the asthenosphere boundary). High-velocity eruption ('melt diatresis') is triggered by massive gas exsolution as the magma passes through the melt structure transition where CO32- becomes unstable (taken as approximating the decarbonation boundary TQ). The pressure limit for amphibole and spinel peridotite stability (at near-solidus temperatures) is indicated at the right margin.
9
agent seems to be gas, either injected into an existing melt chamber or produced by rapid exsolution from the melt itself; at the moment the latter mechanism seems the logical candidate. If vapour-saturated melt is rising through the lithosphere it is to be expected that depressurization will cause progressive gas release; this would tend to quicken the rate of ascent but may be partly offset by increasing viscosity due to melt structure changes resulting from falling temperature and loss of volatiles. The effectiveness of viscosity changes must depend on initial melt composition and temperature. Speeding u p by gas expansion will be a function of release rate and gas density. High-speed liquid eruptions carrying mantle nodules are not the norm, however, and it would be useful if some additional 'firing' or 'lift-off mechanism could be identified in addition to simple decompression vesiculation. One potential trigger for the rapid and massive emission of gas would be when a rising body of melt passes through a phase boundary or melt structure transition. In the case ofbasanitic melts, the most common nodule mineralogies are spinel lherzolite, frequently including amphibole, to which experimental evidence can be applied to give a clear indication of the typical sampling depths of nodule-bearing basanitic eruptions (Fig. 4). This characteristic association with spinel lherzolite strongly suggests that nodulebearing basanitic eruptions get a sudden acceleration (or lift-off) within or close to the spinel and amphibole stability fields, i.e. massive gas exsolution occurs at depths around 80 km. As shown in Fig. 4, there is a ready explanation for this particular case, because around this level carbonate becomes unstable, and the passage of basanitic melt containing dissolved CO2 (in the form of CO32 -) through the carbonate stability boundary could provide the necessary trigger for highvelocity eruption. For liquid diatresis, it is necessary to have melt accumulation to the point where it starts to rise independently through cooler lithosphere, i.e. detached from the ambient mantle geotherm. It is important to realize, however, that although the melt and wall-rocks may be thermally separated they may still be chemically similar. This is because melt piercement of the lithosphere is the probable culmination of a period of volatile flux and melt percolation. Thus, a rising mass of melt is likely to encounter earlier-enriched wall-rocks in its upward passage. Olafsson & Eggler (1983) and Brey et al. (1983) have pointed out that amphibole, phlogopite and carbonate disappear within a small temperature interval above the solidus, so an intrusive melt may be expected to consume more of these phases in any interaction
I0
D.K. Bailey
it may have with the wall-rocks. An ascending melt body would thus tend to develop and preserve similar characteristics to its enriched path zone, in keeping with the observation that the magmas in a given province are chemically similar to the metasomatized nodules that they bring to the surface (Lloyd & Bailey 1975). The conclusion drawn then, that the magmas were formed by direct melting of the nodule compositions, may be too simple. The eruption characteristics require that at the level from which the nodules were picked up the carrier melt was at a temperature well above the vapour-saturated peridotite solidus. Hence the initial melt must have a deeper source than the bulk of the ultramafic nodule population. Depending on the source depth, its initial chemistry might even have been alkaline ultramafic, but it attained its erupted chemistry by interactions with metasomatized wall-rocks up to the point of lift-off. Most of the nodules were derived from the wallrocks around and in front of the point of rapid gas exsolution, which provided the impetus for their high-velocity transport to the surface. In areas where the ambient geothermal gradient is steep, an alkaline magma system can now be envisaged as comprising two distinct source regions, distinguished on the basis of felsic mineral stability. One region, below the maximum depths of felsic mineral stability (approximately coincident with spinel and amphibole stability) is the potential source for mafic hypersolidus melts whenever there is volatile flux through the lithosphere. The overlying zone of felsic stability is the locus of intense melt enrichment and metasomatism at near- and subsolidus conditions during volatile fluxing: this forms the source region for the felsic and nearsolidus portions of the activity. Mafic and felsic magmas may thus both be primary products of the same igneous cycle: the first forms by volatile influx leading to melt diapirism (mafic) well above the peridotite solidus (Fig. 4), the second by melt percolation leading to melt diapirism (felsic) near or below the peridotite solidus (Fig. 3).
Conclusion By combining the geological and experimental evidence it is possible to produce a unified scheme for the generation and eruption of mafic and felsic alkaline magmas, constituting the range sometimes described as the alkali olivine basalttrachyte association. A combination of volatile and melt percolation along geothermal gradients appropriate to thicker oceanic and younger
continental lithosphere leads to enrichment and metasomatism in the P-Tregion of the amphibole peridotite solidus, providing the major source region for felsic magmas: the main source of mafic magmas is at depths below the stability range of felsic minerals, eruption resulting from melt accumulation and buoyant uprise. These conditions are summarized in sections 0 and 30 in Figs 5 and 6. Melt generation from two distinct sources can account for the following characteristics of this magmatic association: 1 Composition gaps. Intermediate compositions may be formed but are not essential to petrogenesis. 2 Volume discrepancies. The relative volume of mafic-to-felsic magma results from the interplay of melt percolation and mafic melt diapirism. 3 Timing. Characteristic magmatic diversity results simply from the fluctuating interplay of volatile flux and melt generation (irreversibility is not an issue). 4 Synchroneity. Both felsic and mafic magmas can be available for eruption at all times. 5 Megacrysts. These are typically erupted in explosive diatremic activity and show significant differences from megacrysts associated with ultramafic magmatism. They are commonly amphibole and feldspar in the alkali basalt association and are explicable in terms of near-solidus formation. 6 Basanites may be erupted in a highly liquid state, carrying nodules of amphibole and spinel peridotite which are indicative of higher-temperature generation from a deeper source than felsic melts. High-velocity eruption is 'fired' by gas exsolution when CO32- becomes unstable in the melt. 7 Characteristic abundance of lithophile elements. Volatile fluxing, metasomatism and enrichment provide the required concentration mechanism. All the above features are also consistent with the observation that alkaline magmatism is controlled by lithosphere structures acting as focussing zones for volatile escape to the Earth's surface (Bailey 1977, 1980b, 1983). In earlier discussions attention has been concentrated on continental examples where, in addition to the advantages of many different erosion levels, there is frequently evidence of repetition of the activity through the same lesion in the lithosphere. Since a crucial observation for the present paper has been the alternating mafic-felsic volcanism in the Azores, it is appropriate to conclude by pointing out that the Azores constitute an excellent oceanic case for lithosphere control.
Mantle metasomatism GEOTHERM : NEAR S (SHIELD)
S
BETWEEN
AND O
O
II (OCEAN)
Depth km + Amph(?)
! ( TOO COOL 9 ) II
50
740 ~
I
Phi + Cpx
I00
Phi +
150
--
Cpx + Carb + v
p ~180 o
200
+
880"11\1\11\\/1\\1/\//\\//\\//k\/
- -
-MANTLE
Corb 1030,~ + V
I 10750 (DIAMOND)
-T- V i 175*----
J" I I P OL-MELIL ? I K I M B T I - LAMPROITE I I K I M B T CARBONATITE I I MELTS
INCREASINGDECREAStNG "CPX"CARBONATE"
MAGMA
EVOLUTION
I DEVELOPS 402Ocpx + KS I +Ab(+Phl) I . . . . . . . + Melt UAbAr~,.r.. - ~ I NEPHELINITE 1200o* "
I I
,,
I
Me
Amph+Ab/Of I FELSICS (+Cpx) + v I AS CYCLE I GROWS
,o8o'c~
{-i-Phl)_+Melt }TRANSITIONAL-12OO=-T ', V ~ BASALT
IO 20 5O P kb 4O
Phi + Cpx + Carb +- Mell
I
I
Amph+Ab/Or IFELSICMELTS (+Cpx) +V II AS CYCLE
50
I NEPHELINITE 9 I I LEUCITITE II MELILITITE CARBONATITE - - --t (DIAMOND)
5O 6O
MANTLE }
IN M O D I F I E D
WITH
[
MELTS
MANTLE
MANTLE
1
MELTS
MANTLE
I MELTS
AND MELTS
CONTINUOUS
FLUX
THROUGH
LESION
FIG. 5. Sample lithosphere sections along four selected geothermal gradients, derived directly from Figs 1 and 2. In each case it is assumed that the initial mantle composition is peridotite. On the left of each column are indicated the mantle changes induced by volatile flux along the geotherm, and on the right the kinds of melt developed in this regime. 'Melt' is not mentioned on the left in column 1 to emphasize the limited melting expected when the geotherm S is in grazing incidence with the kimberlite solidus (KS in Fig. 1). The base of columns 3 and 4 has been set at 1200~ on the geotherms, as an approximation to the asthenosphere boundary. As the geotherm becomes steeper (columns 1-4) the melts become more siliceous, with increasing separation from the solidus, in the manner prescribed by Olafsson & Eggler (1983). Volatile fluxing along geotherm O could not produce strong phlogopite enrichment but instead gives rise to assemblages dominated by clinopyroxenes, felsics and (at higher levels) amphibole, i.e. directly related to basanitic melts.
Felsic volcanoes, especially trachytes, form a major component of the activity on some of the islands, notably those lying along the Terceira rift: Sao Miguel, Terceira and Graciosa. On these three islands not only are the composition gaps pronounced but the large volumes of felsic
_
JL
Z
Z THOSP
ERE
,!:i;i
MOBILE ELEMENTS FLOW TO LESION
Fio. 6. Sketch to illustrate the operation of volatile focussing through lesions in the lithosphere of different thicknesses and geothermal gradients. Columns correspond to those depicted in Fig. 5. Discussion of the relevant applications of channelling volatiles through a narrow zone in the lithosphere ('pie-funnel effect') can be found in Bailey (1980b; 1983).
magmas constitute major embarrassments for continuous differentiation. Explanations for individual volcanoes have been attempted, but the case for continuous differentiation is lost when the activity is seen in regional context. It is hardly conceivable that the volcanoes strung along the Terceira rift should all be spectacularly successful products of high-level differentiation while the volcanoes on the other islands outside the rift have effectively failed. It is more reasonable to assume that the Terceira rift volcanoes are the result of structural control that has permitted the formation, below the rift, of mantle source regions capable of providing felsic melts. Such a conclusion is consistent with the scenario whereby the rift zone acts as a focus for the release of volatiles through the Azores lithosphere. ACKNOWLEDGMENTS: My appreciation of magmatic composition gaps has been sharpened by discussions with Felix Chayes and Ray Macdonald, and by Julian Maund's systematic observations on the 'zebra-striped' tephra deposits of Graciosa. Constructive reviews of the manuscript were provided by Godfrey Fitton and Martin Menzies.
I2
D. K. Bailey
References BAILEY, D. K. 1970. Volatile flux, heat focussing and the generation of magma. Geol. J. Spec. Issue No. 2, 177-86. - 1972. Uplift, rifting and magmatism in continental plates. J. Earth Sciences (Leeds), 8, 225-39. - - 1 9 7 4 . Continental rifting and alkaline magmatism. In: SORENSON, H. (ed.) The Alkaline Rocks, pp. 148-59. Wiley, New York. - - 1 9 7 6 . Applications of experiments to alkaline rocks. In: BAILEY, D. K. & MACDONALD, R. (eds) The Evolution of the Crystalline Rocks, pp. 416-69. Academic Press, London. --1977. Lithosphere control of continental rift magmatism. J. geol. Soc. London, 133, 103-6. - 1978. Continental rifting and mantle degassing. In: NEUMANN, E.-R. & RAMBERG, I. B. (eds) Petrology and Geochemistry of Continental Rifts, pp. 1-13. Reidel, Dordrecht. - 1980a. Volatile flux, geotherms, and the generation of the kimberlite-carbonatite-alkaline magma spectrum. Mineralog. Mag. 43, 695-9. - 1980b. Volcanism, Earth degassing and replenished lithosphere mantle. Phil. Trans. R. Soc. A 297, 309-22. - - 1 9 8 1 . Bowen and the Post-Impressionists. Geol. Mag. 118, 311-8. - 1982. Mantle metasomatism--continuing chemical change within the Earth. Nature, Lond. 296, 525-30. 1983. The chemical and thermal evolution of rifts. Tectonophysics, 94, 585-97. - 1984. Kimberlite: 'the mantle sample' formed by ultrametasomatism. In: KORNPROBST, J. (ed.) Kimberlites. 1 : Kimberlites and Related Rocks, pp. 323-33. Developments in Petrology 11 A, Elsevier, Amsterdam. - 1986. Fluids, melts, flowage and styles of eruption in alkaline ultramafic magmatism. Trans. geol. Soc. S.Afr. 88 (2), 449-57. -& MACDONALD, R. 1987. Dry peralkaline felsic liquids and carbon dioxide flux through the Kenya rift zone. In: MYSEN, B. O. (ed.) Magmatic Processes: Physiochemical Principles. Geochem. Soc., Spec. Pub. No. 1, in press. BARTH, T. F. W., CORRENS, C. W. & ESKOLA, P. 1939. Die Entstehung der Gesteine, 422 pp. Springer, Berlin. BOETTCHER,A. L. & O'NEILL, J. R. 1980. Stable isotope, chemical, and petrographic studies of high-pressure amphiboles and micas: evidence for metasomatism in the mantle source regions of alkali basalts and kimberlites. Am. J. Sci. 280A, 594621. BREY, G., BRICE, W. R., ELLIS, D. J., GREEN, D. H., HARRIS, K. L. & RYABCHIKOV, I. D. 1983. Pyroxene-carbonate reactions in the upper mantle. Earth planet. Sci. Lett. 62, 63-74. CHAYES, F.1963. Relative abundance of intermediate members of the oceanic basalt-trachyte association. J. geophys. Res. 68 (5), 1519-34. CLARK, S. P. & RINGWOOD, A. E. 1964. Density
distribution and constitution of the mantle. Rev. geophys. 2, 35. DALY, R. A. 1925. The geology of Ascension Island. Proc. Am. Acad. Arts Sci 60, 1-80. -1927. The geology of St. Helena Island. Proc. Am. Acad. Arts Sci. 62, 31-92. EGGLER, D. H. & WENDLANDT, R. F. 1978. Phase relations of a kimberlite composition. Cam. Inst. Wash. Yr Bk, 77, 751-6. ERLANK, A. J. & SHIMIZU, N. 1977. Strontium and strontium isotope distributions in some kimberlite nodules and minerals. Extended Abstracts, 2nd Int. Kimberlite Conference. - - A L L S O P P , H. L., DUNCAN, A. R. & BRISTOW, J. W. 1980. Mantle heterogeneity beneath southern Africa: evidence from the volcanic record. Phil. Trans. R. Soc. A297, 295-307. FITTON, J. G. & DUNLOP, H M. 1985. The Cameroon line, West Africa, and its bearing on the origin of oceanic and continental alkali basalt. Earth planet. Sci. Lett. 72, 23-38. HARTE, B., COX, K. G. & GURNEY, J. J. 1975. Petrography and geological history of upper mantle xenoliths from Matsoku kimberlite pipe. Phys. Chem. Earth, 9, 389-416. HAWKESWORTH, C. J., ROGERS, N. W., VAN GALASTEREN, P. W. C. & MENZIES, M. A. 1984. Mantle enrichment processes. Nature, Lond. 311 (5984) 331-5. KENNEDY, C. S. & KENNEDY, G. C. 1976. The equilibrium boundary between graphite and diamond. J. geophys. Res. 81, 2467-70. LLOYD, F. E. 1981. Upper-mantle metasomatism beneath a continental rift: clinopyroxenes in alkali mafic lavas and nodules from S. W. Uganda. Mineralog. Mag. 44, 315-23. - - 1 9 8 5 . Melting experiments on glassy olivine melilitites from strongly potassic mafic volcanics ofS. W. Uganda. Contrib. Mineral. Petrol. 90, 23643. - & BAILEY, D. K. 1975. Light element metasomatism of the continental mantle: the evidence and the consequences. Phys. Chem. Earth, 9, 389-416. MAUND, J. G. 1985. The volcanic geology, petrology and geochemistry of Caldeira volcano, Graciosa, Azores, and its bearing on contemporaneous felsicmafic oceanic island volcanism. Ph.D. Thesis, University of Reading (unpublished). - - , J. G. & BAILEY, D. K. 1982. Caldeira volcano, Graciosa, Azores: Progress Report. J. geol. Soc. Lond, 139, 658. MENZIES, M. & MURTHY, V. R. 1980a. Mantle metasomatism as a precursor to the genesis of alkaline magmas--isotopic evidence. Am. J. Sci. 280A, 622-38. - & 1980b. Nd and Sr isotope geochemistry of hydrous mantle nodules and their host alkali basalts: implications for local heterogeneities in metasomatically veined mantle. Earth planet. Sci. Lett. 46, 323-34. OLAFSSON, M. & EGGLER, D. H. 1983. Phase relations of amphibole, amphibole-carbonate, and phlogo-
Mantle metasomatism pite-carbonate peridotite: petrologic constraints on the asthenosphere. Earth planet. Sci. Lett. 64, 305-15. OLDENBURG, D. W. 1981. Conductivity structure of oceanic upper mantle beneath the Pacific plate. Geophys. J. R. astron. Soc. 65, 359-94. O'REILLY, S. Y. & GRIFFIN, W. L. 1984. Sr isotopic heterogeneity in primitive basaltic rocks, southeastern Australia: correlations with mantle metasomatism. Contrib. Mineral. Petrol. 87, 220-30. PRESNALL, D. C. 1969. The geometrical analysis of partial fusion. Am. J. Sci. 267, 1178-94. SCLATER, J. G., JAUPART, C. & GALSON, D. 1980. The heat flow through oceanic and continental crust and the heat loss of the Earth. Rev. Geophys. Space Phys. 18, 269-311. STOLPER, E., WALKER,D., HAGER, B. H. & JAYS, J. F. 1982. Melt segregation from partially molten source regions: the importance of melt density and source region size. J. geophys. Res. 86, 6261-71. TOZER, D. C. 1967. Towards a theory of mantle convection. In: GASKELL, T. F. (ed.) The Earth's Mantle, pp. 325-53. Academic Press, New York. WAFt, H. S. 1980. Effects of the gravitational field on liquid distribution in partial melts within the upper mantle. J. geophys. Res. 85, 1815-25. WALKER, D., STOLPER, E. & HAYS, J. F. 1978. A numerical treatment of melt/solid segregation: size of the eucrite parent body and stability of the
13
terrestrial low-velocity zone. J. geophys. Res. 83, 6005-13. WENDLANDT,R. F. & EGGLER, O. H. 1980. The origins of potassic magmas: 2. Stability of phlogopite in natural spinel lherzolite and in the system KA1SiO4-MgO-SiOE-H20-CO 2 at high pressures and high temperatures. Am. J. Sci. 280, 421-58. WILLIAMS,L. A. J. 1972. The Kenya Rift Volcanics: A note on volumes and chemical composition. Tectonophysics, 15, 83-96. WILSHIRE, H. G. 1984. Mantle metasomatism: The REE story. Geology, 12, 395-8. WRIGrtT, J. B. 1966. Olivine nodules in phonolite of the East Otago Alkaline Province, New Zealand. Nature, Lond. 210, 519-20. --1969. Olivine nodules and related inclusions in trachyte from the Jos Plateau, Nigeria. Mineral. Mag. 37, 370-4. WYLLIE, P. J. 1979. Petrogenesis and the physics of the Earth. In: YODER, n . S., Jr (ed.) The Evolution of the Igneous Rocks, pp. 481-520. Princeton University Press, Princeton, NJ. YODER, H. S. Jr. 1973. Contemporaneous basaltic and rhyolitic magmas. Am. Mineral. 58, 153-71. --(Ed) 1979. The Evolution of the Igneous Rocks. Fiftieth Anniversary Perspectives, 588 pp. Princeton University Press, Princeton, N.J. ZIELINSKI, R. A. 1975. Trace element evaluation of a suite of rocks from Reunion Island, Indian Ocean. Geochim cosmochim. Acta, 39, 713-34.
D. K. BAILEY, Department of Geology, University of Reading, Whiteknights, Reading, RG6 2AB, U.K.
Alkaline rocks and their inclusions: a window on the Earth's interior Martin Menzies S U M M A R Y : The majority of inclusion-bearing alkaline rocks have a source region identical with that of ocean island basalts regardless of whether they were erupted through oceanic or continental crust. Models have been proposed where oceanic alkaline rocks are derived from the asthenosphere and during passage to the surface there have occurred variable amounts of interaction with lithosphere of the mid-ocean ridge basalt type. A similar scenario would account for most inclusion-bearing continental alkaline rocks. Genesis of micaceous kimberlites and lamproites, however, may require that asthenospheric plumes have impinged on 'nuggets' of aged heterogeneous enriched sub-continental lithosphere. This would lead to mixing of isotopicallydistinct asthenospheric and lithospheric melts.
Introduction Inclusion-bearing alkaline rocks are erupted at the Earth's surface in the ocean basins and on the continental crust. They include basanites, nephelinites, hawaiites, alkali olivine basalts, phonolites, Group I and Group II kimberlites and lamproites. All these magmas or melts are known to transport spinel- or garnet-bearing peridotites and/or high-pressure megacrysts to the surface (e.g. diamond, sapphire, garnet etc.). The fact that they have disrupted and entrained mafic and ultramafic fragments stable at mantle pressures and temperatures argues very strongly for an ultimate mantle source. Important information about the geochemistry of the upper mantle is retained in the host magmas. Moreover, the inclusions provide added insight into the nature of the mantle occurring at shallower depths than the source of the host magma. Early research into the possible origins of alkaline rocks stressed the 'mantle-type' 87Sr/ S6Sr < 0.706) and 'crustal-type' (s 7Sr/S6Sr > 0.710) isotope ratios as a means of identification of possible source regions (Powell & Bell 1974; Rock 1976). Any similarity between isotope ratios measured in alkaline rocks and mid-ocean ridge basalts (MORBs) or ocean island basalts (OIBs) was taken as unequivocal proof that the particular rock in question was mantle derived (e.g. East African rift). Similarly, any alkaline rock with an isotopic composition similar to crustal values was assumed to be a crustal derivative or to have experienced crustal contamination (e.g. Kimberley, Australia). For example, Rock (1976) commented that in certain alkaline rocks the Sr isotopic ratios were 'so high (>0.710) that a significant contribution from crustal material was inescapable'. It is implicit in these models that interaction with a 'crustal' component occurred after magma
formation. More recently, alkaline rocks with radiogenic Sr (and non-radiogenic Nd) isotopic ratios have been interpreted as extracts from mantle source regions where addition of a crustal component to the mantle occurred prior to magma production (Chase 1981; Hofmann & White 1982; Zindler & Jagoutz 1987) by recycling processes involving subduction and/or delamination of aged sub-continental mantle (McKenzie & O'Nions 1983). Alkaline rocks may include components from the following:
1 Lower mantle." below the boundary layer (about 670 kin). 2 Upper mantle." oceanic lithosphere; continental lithosphere; convecting asthenosphere. 3 Recycled components." oceanic and continental crust and mantle. In this review isotopic data pertinent to inclusion-bearing alkaline rocks and their cargo of mantle inclusions erupted in ocean basins, continental rift valleys and stable cratonic regions will be used to construct an Earth model. Earth models will be considered where the structural elements that form the upper mantle below both oceans and continents are lithosphere (crust and mantle) and asthenosphere. These in turn are underlain by the lower mantle below the 670 km boundary layer.
Alkaline rocks and their mantle inclusions Random fragments of mantle are transported to the surface in alkaline rocks. The inclusions entrained in alkaline rocks range from garnet
From: FITTON,J. G. & UPTON,B. G. J. (eds), 1987, Alkaline Igneous Rocks, Geological Society Special Publication No. 30, pp. 15-27.
15
M. Menzies
[6
and spinel peridotites to mica clinopyroxenites, glimmerites, apatite-amphibole pyroxenites and mica-rutile-ilmenite-diopside (MARID) rocks. It is useful to think of the variety of inclusions as disrupted mantle pegmatites viz. pieces of mantle wall-rock (i.e. peridotites) and fragmented conduits of silicate melts or aqueous fluids (i.e. pyroxenites, glimmerites etc.). Analogues can be found in inclusion suites for the various melts or fluids that have migrated through the mantle. A m p h i b o l e - a p a t i t e - p y r o x e n ites found as veins in spinel lherzolite inclusions are believed to be a product of silicate-melt migration (Hawkesworth et al. 1984; Menzies et al. 1985c). A by-product of this magmatism is the Fe-Ti metasomatism observed in wall-rock peridotites. In other words, upwelling basanitic or nephelinitic melts may have crystallized in the mantle as these vein networks. It can be shown that their isotopic and trace-element characteristics are consistent with such an interpretation (Irving and Frey 1984; Roden et al. 1984). M A R I D rocks (Kramers et al. 1983; Smith 1983) found in kimberlite inclusion suites are believed to be portions of the conduit lining left after passage of a hydrous fluid enriched with incompatible elements. Glimmerites and micaceous pyroxenites (Erlank et al. 1987; Menzies et al. 1987) may also represent disrupted vein systems formed by crystallization of LIL- (LIL stands for large
05132 ~ N I V A K ~ " 1 0
o.51~L__~ 0.702
~
Ocean basins Before any discussion of the isotopic variability of alkaline basaltic and kimberlitic rocks erupted in continental regions, it would seem logical to review the data on alkaline rocks from ocean basins (Fig. 1). Although not strictly oceanic, the Nunivak data are included in Fig. 1. Alkaline rocks associated with disruption and entrainment of fragments of oceanic mantle have a very narrow range of Sr and Nd isotopic ratios (i.e. STSr/86Sr < 0.706 and 143Nd/144Nd > 0.51270 (Fig. 1, Table 1)). These magmas are clearly derived from mantle depleted in the light REE for a considerable period of time. A concomitant depletion in Rb is also apparent, but in the case of Tahiti and Malaita the magmas have slightly higher SVSr/86Sr ratios. This could result from (a) mixing of MORB mantle with a recycled radiogenic component or (b) influx of a high Rb/Sr fluid.
0.513211
j-5
|
I
TAHITII|
|A / ~10
|
I
07.02
i
I
0.704
I
0.706
Inclusions
Host Magmas
0.513211_
'
0.51~4t-,
0.706
0.704
(~
ion lithophile elements) and LREE-enriched hydrous fluids in the mantle (LREE stands for light rare-earth elements). Mantle inclusions provide a very important record, not only of ancient depletion events (more than 103 Ma ago) related to crust formation, but more importantly of the passage of silicate melts and hydrous fluids from the mantle to the surface.
3 0.5132~,inlcl "-
~
i
HAWAllli
+10
-5 "O 0.5128 z
Z-O 9-
0.5128
_
9
0.5124 I 0.702 87Sr/86S
I
I 0.704
I
I 0.706
o
0.5124
-I 0.702
1
I 0704
I
I 0.706
-5
-o Z
uo
r
FIG. 1. Nd versus Sr isotopic variation (present day) in mantle ultramafic and mafic inclusions and their host basaltic rocks from oceanic basins. Note the following: (i) the host magmas are derived from mantle depleted in Rb and light REE; (ii) the inclusions exhibit a greater range of Nd and Sr isotopes than the host magmas: (iii) the high 8VSr/a6Srratios in the Malaita and Tahiti inclusions. The vertical and horizontal reference lines in this and other diagrams define the generally accepted values for undifferentiated or chondritic mantle or bulk earth (87Sr/S6Sr= 0.7045 and 143Nd/144Nd=0.51264). Data are taken from several sources. Nunivak : Menzies & Murthy (1980a); Roden et al. (1984a). Malaita: Bielski-Zyskind et al. (1984). Tahiti: Vidal et al. (1984); Menzies & Hawkesworth (1987). Hawaii: Chert & Frey (1983).
Alkaline rocks and their inclusions
I7
TABLE 1.87Sr/S6Sr, 143Nd/144 Nd, R b / S r a n d S m / N d ratios f o r inclusion-bearing alkaline, kimberlitic a n d lamproitic m a g m a s
Locality
87Rb/86Sr
esra
/;Ndb
147Sm/
Ref
144Nd Afar (Assab) - 17 to - 10.0 -Africa (Tanzania) - 14.2 -Alaska (Nunivak) - 2 8 . 4 to - 17 0.049-0.121 Antarctica Foster Crater - 13.8 to - 11.4 - Ross Island - 19.2 0.089-0.165 Arizona Geronimo - 23.4 to - 17 0.118-0.240 San Carlos - 22.7 0.091 Australia Kiama - 7.1 0.051-0.164 Kimberley + 85 to + 218.6 0.593-9.855 Victoria - 28.4 to + 4.3 -California (Sierran Province) c + 4.3 to + 34.1 0.056-1.28 Fiji - 13.4 -France (Massif Central) - 14.2 to 0 0.153-1.225 French Polynesia (Tahiti) d + 7.1 to + 34.1 -Hawaii (Honolulu Series) - 18.5 to - 17.03 0.015-0.103 Scotland (Midland Valley and N W High- - 4.3 to + 25.6 0.077-0.203 lands) Solomon Islands (Malaita) + 1.4 to + 2.8 0.059-0.183 South Africa (various localities) Group I kimberlites - 11.4 to + 14.2 0.038-1.52 Group II kimberlites + 41.2 to + 90.8 0.140-0.786 South Yemen (Ataq) - 17.0 to - 2.8 0.028-0.692 Mantle xenoliths Keel e - 3 5 . 5 t o +1867.0-Asthenosphere -35.5to+21.3 --
+4.7 to +7.2 + 1.4 + 4 . 9 t o +7.8
-0.096 0.119-0.133
+3.3
--
to
+4.7
1 2 3
--
--
4
+ 4 . 9 t o +8.0 +7.6
0.101-0.126 0.130
5 6
- 0 . 6 t o +0.4 - 16.2 to - 8 . 0 - 4 . 7 to +5.0 - 9 . 6 to +2.9
0.116-0.120 0.065-0.082 0.112-0.119 0.103-0.140
+3.7
--
+ 7 . 0 t o +7.6 - 6 . 6 t o +3.1
0.120-0.168 0.068-0.108
7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15
+ l . 9 t o +2.9
0.102-0.121
16
- 4 . 1 to +1.0 - 12.9 to - 8.8 - 2 . 3 to +8.0
0.085-0.098 0.062-0.087 0.100-0.130
17 18
- 2 4 . 2 t o +14.8 -4.7to+14.8
---
19
+2.1 to +4.1
0.087-0.119
-
--
1.9
to
+2.5
"es~ represents the present-day 87Sr/86Sr ratio assuming a bulk earth s 7Sr/86Sr of 0.7045. beyo represents the present-day 143Nd/144Nd ratio assuming a bulk earth 143Nd/144Nd of 0.51264. cRange in Rb/Sr and Sm/Nd given for the Sierran Province lavas are for basaltic rocks that are not necessarily host to the xenoliths. The isotope data and trace-element data are for different samples. aTahitian samples are not the host magmas to the xenoliths. eThe range given for the 'keel' inclusions excludes inclusions found in diamonds (Richardson et al. 1984). 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10
Betton & Civetta 1984; Cohen et al. 1984; Menzies & Murthy 1980a; Roden et al. 1984a; Stuckless & Ericksen 1976; Menzies et al 1985b; Menzies et al. 1985a; Evans & Nash unpublished data; Zindler & Jagoutz 1987; Wass & Rogers 1980; Menzies & Wass 1983; McCulloch et al. 1983 ; Frey & Green 1974; McDonough & McCulloch 1985; Van Kooten etal 1985;
T h e spinel a n d g a r n e t p e r i d o t i t e s a n d p y r o x e n i t e s e n t r a i n e d b y t h e s e m a g m a s (Fig. 1) h a v e a s i m i l a r r a n g e o f Sr a n d N d isotopes e x c e p t t h a t t h e i n c l u s i o n s do r e c o r d s o m e h i g h e r 87Sr/S6Sr ratios (e.g. M a l a i t a a n d Tahiti). It is v e r y difficult to state u n e q u i v o c a l l y t h a t t h e c h e m i c a l c h a r a c t e r istics o f t h e inclusions are n o t a n a d j u n c t o f
11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19
Gill 1984; Chauvel & Jahn 1984; Downes 1984; White & Hofmann 1982; Clague & Frey 1982; Chen & Frey 1983; Stille et al. 1983; Thirlwall 1982; Menzies & Halliday 1984; Bielski-Zyskind et al. 1984; Smith 1983; Menzies & Murthy 1980a; Menzies et al. 1987, and references cited therein; Menzies & Hawkesworth 1987.
m a g m a t i c processes, i.e. r e p e a t e d cycles o f m a g m a t i s m in t h e m a n t l e . R e g a r d l e s s o f this d i l e m m a , the basalt and inclusion data reveal mantle r e g i o n s d e p l e t e d in t h e light R E E a n d v a r i a b l y d e p l e t e d or e n r i c h e d in Rb. T h e latter e n r i c h m e n t m u s t be a r e l a t i v e l y r e c e n t p h e n o m e n o n (less t h a n 0.2 x 103 M a ago) w i t h i n t h e l i f e t i m e o f t h e
18
M. Menzies I
I
0.5132
I
I
I
t
/
MIDDLE EASTt!10 (Jd~ ~L'T-----":~ ~?-al ,.? --ETHIOPIA
I..~--~ I iFRANCE i I&4+1o /
0.5132~.~ , ~ I~-
~
GERMANY|
"
0.5128 0.5124 1 0.702
I
0.704
,'
l
o.51241-,
I
,
0.702
0,706 I I I -]40
I ~
F,
,
0.704 ~
'
I '
, 4-5
0.706 ' |
sw u
~ 0,5124[1
0.702
l
0704
0.5130
l
; 1-s
0706
TANZANIA
1
L I
I
-
0.5124 [-1 I 0.702 5
,o
-25 t
0.750
t
0.800
I ~ I 0704
2 I ~ -5 0.706
Magmas
-15 -20
~
II I
0.700
0 . 5 1 2 8 ~
[ 1_0
. . . .
F 05110t
o
L
0.850
-30
(j
Inclusions z
%9
87Sr/86Sr
FIG. 2. Nd versus Sr isotopic variation (present day) in mantle ultramafic and mafic inclusions and their host basalts from rifted continental regions. Note the following : (i) the continental host magmas are derived from source regions not unlike the oceanic magmas in Fig. 1 ; (ii) in the majority of cases the host magmas and inclusions are derived from different mantle source regions; (iii) in the case of the African rift valley, fragments of heterogeneous mantle have been entrained. Data are taken from several sources. Middle East-Ethiopia: Menzies & Murthy (1980a); Betton & Civetta (1984); Menzies & Hawkesworth (1987). France and Germany: Stosch et al. (1980); Chauvel & Jahn (1983); Downes (1984). Eastern Australia: Menzies & Wass (1983). SW U.S.A. : Jagoutz et al. (1980); Stosch et al. (1980); Menzies & Hawkesworth (1987); Menzies et al. (1985a); Van Kooten et al. (1985); Zindler & Jagoutz (1987). ocean basin. It can be deduced from these data that the source regions of alkaline magmas and of the overlying mantle as represented by the inclusions are isotopically quite similar. Exposures of peridotite in the ocean basins (Roden et al. 1984b) exhibit isotopic variability that falls within the limits of the data in Fig. 1. Roden et al. (1984b) believe that the St Paul's rocks contain evidence of a recent (less than 0.2 • 103 Ma ago) trace-element enrichment related to alkaline magmatism.
Continental rift valleys Inclusion-bearing alkaline rocks erupted in the major rift valleys of the world have present-day Sr and Nd isotopic ratios not unlike those of the inclusion-bearing alkaline rocks from ocean basins. 87Sr/S6Sr ranges from 0.7027 to 0.7055, and 143Nd/144Nd ranges from 0.51305 to 0.51245 (Table 1). Interestingly, however, the marked disposition of the oceanic data towards high 87Sr/ S6Sr ratios is not evident in the continental
alkaline rocks. In fact, these data are more inclined to plot towards lower 143Nd/144Nd ratios (Fig. 2). Again, the alkaline host magmas are derived from a mantle source depleted in Rb and the light REE for a considerable period of time. Modifications to this mantle source have clearly occurred and account for the scatter of the data. For example, alkaline rocks from the Middle East (Betton & Civetta 1984; Menzies & Hawkesworth 1987) and SW U.S.A. (Van Kooten et al. 1985) plot towards more radiogenic 87Sr/86Sr ratios, a fact that indicates input of Rb into the source region or mixing of end-members with diverse 8VSr/86Sr ratios. The variety of mafic and ultramafic inclusions entrained in alkaline magmas erupted in rift valleys exposes a complex mantle structure that is at first glance extremely heterogenous for both Sr and Nd isotopes and is thus distinct from oceanic mantle. It is apparent, however, that the majority of inclusions have 87Sr/86Sr ratios ranging from 0.702 to 0.7065 and t43Nd/t44Nd ratios ranging from 0.51330 to 0.51240. Considering the paucity of data from ocean basins and the prolific number of isotopic
Alkaline
rocks and their inclusions
analyses from continental rift valleys, these data are only marginally different from oceanic-basin data. However, isotopic data from Tanzania appears to complicate matters (Fig. 2) since the inclusions display an extreme range in Sr and Nd isotopic composition. Nothing of this type has been seen in the ocean basins or in most of the continental rift valleys (compare Figs 1 and 2). These extremely radiogenic Sr and non-radiogenic Nd isotopic ratios record ancient (more than 103 Ma ago) trace-element enrichments involving addition of the light R E E and/or Rb to the mantle. With the passage of time, the isotopic ratios have adjusted so as to record the modified
0.5120
~
/
19
trace-element ratios. It is unlikely that such old trace-element enrichment events would be preserved in actively convecting asthenosphere, A mantle layer with fundamentally different isotopic characteristics clearly exists beneath the continents and not beneath the ocean basins. Furthermore, the similarity between oceanic and continental rift valley alkaline basalts points to a similar mantle source at depth for the host magmas. While most of the inclusions record an old depletion in both Rb and the light REE not unlike the oceanic mantle, certain fragments of 'anomalous' enriched mantle are occasionally entrained within continental rift valley magmas.
~-10 0'5125I
0,110
'
1o
0.702 Q704 0.706 0.708 0.710
0.700 0.710 0.720
( •Host Magmas 0.5132 0.5130 0.5128 0.5126
!
~
I
~
0.5124
0.740
( ~ Inclusions
I
~ t
0.730
I
...
-,10
I
SOUTH
AFRICA
-+~
o ~
' ,NOLUS,O,S
/
o.5122 o.5120 t Z ,r,-~., 0.5118 ~- I "O z
OY02
-
GROUP II~ K,MBERL,TES garnet inclusions in diamonds I
I
I
I
0.706
0.710
0.714
0.718
-lO
-15 "t~ Z
87Sr / 86 Sr
FIG. 3. Nd and Sr isotopic variation (present day) in mantle ultramafic and mafic inclusions and their host basalts and kimberlites from other continental regions. Note the following: (i) the host alkaline magmas from Scotland and Antarctica and the basaltic kimberlites (Group 1) from S Africa have Sr and Nd isotopic compositions not unlike OIBs; (ii) the mantle inclusions display, in most instances, a greater range of Sr and Nd isotopic ratios than the host magmas; (iii) a greater proportion of the inclusions than were entrained in oceanic basalts are from regions of the mantle enriched in Rb and light REE for a considerable time period; (iv) micaceous kimberlites (Group II) have Sr and Nd isotopic ratios distinctly different from those of OIB and similar to some of the inclusions. Data are taken from several sources. Scotland: Menzies & Halliday (1984); Halliday et al. (1985). Antarctica: Stuckless & Ericksen (1976); Kyle et al. (1985); Menzies et al. (1985b). South Africa: Menzies & Murthy (1980b); Kramers et al. (1981 ; 1983); Erlank et al. (1982, 1987); Smith (1983); Menzies et al. (1987).
M. Menzies
20
Although the source regions of the host magmas may be similar, clearly the potential exists in rift valleys for magmas to entrain fragments of mantle that does not exist under ocean basins.
istries. The range in isotopic composition is extreme, particularly with respect to Sr isotopic ratios (Fig. 3). These isotopic data record a timeintegrated response to (a) major partial melting or depletion events (similar to that observed in the alkaline volcanic rocks erupted in the oceans and rift valleys) and (b) ancient enrichment or metasomatic events caused by infiltration of silicate melts and aqueous fluids that have not as yet been reported from the ocean basins.
Other continental regions Alkaline basalts, lamproites, lamprophyres and kimberlites intrude regions of old crust. The alkaline basalts have Sr and Nd isotopic ratios consistent with derivation from either enriched (e.g. Scotland) or depleted (e.g. Antarctica) portions of the Earth's mantle (Fig. 3). Moreover, most of these continental alkaline basalts and basaltic kimberlites (Group I) are isotopically indistinguishable from ocean island alkaline basalts or rift valley basalts (Table 1). In contrast, micaceous kimberlites (Group II) and lamproites have more radiogenic Sr and less radiogenic Nd isotopic ratios than anything erupted in the ocean basins or rift valleys. In the case of the Group II kimberlites and lamproites we must invoke a source region distinctly different from that of alkaline rocks erupted in the ocean basins or continental rift valleys. It is perhaps to be expected that the petrographically and chemically diverse mafic and ultramafic inclusions entrained from below regions of old crust would display heterogeneous isotopic chemI
I
Asthenosphere-lithosphere The available host magma and inclusion data can now be integrated into some kind of Earth model. To assist us, the Sr and Nd isotopic data for continental and oceanic alkaline basaltic rocks (excluding Group II kimberlites) are compared with available data from several ocean islands and MORB (Fig. 4). The first point to be made is that the source is identical (Fig. 4) regardless of whether the rocks are erupted in continents or ocean basins. Their source must therefore lie not in the lithosphere but in or below the convecting asthenosphere since (a) the oceanic lithosphere is relatively sterile and not capable of producing large volumes of alkaline magma and (b) the I
I
I
+15
0.5134 MORB 0.5132
+1o
~Nd
0.5130 4"
A
+5
V
0.5128
<>
erguelen It
0.5126 9
A9 ~9
9
"-~
,O-
0.5124 I
0.702
0.703
-5
I
0.704
0.705
0.706
87Sr/86Sr
FIG. 4. Nd versus Sr isotopic variation in alkaline volcanic rocks and basaltic kimberlites. Comparative basalt data are taken from Dosso & Murthy (1980), Cohen & O'Nions (1982), Chen & Frey (1983) and Stille et al. (1983). Other sources of data are: o, San Quintin, Mexico (De Paolo 1978); , San Carlos, Arizona (Zindler & Jagoutz 1987); o, Geronimo, Arizona (Menzies et al. 1985a); O, Pisgah Crater, California (De Paolo 1978); ~ Nunivak, Alaska (Menzies & Murthy 1980a); ,t, Ataq, South Yemen (Menzies & Murthy 1980a); 4, Kiama, New South Wales (Menzies & Wass 1983); ~, Afar, Ethiopia (Betton & Civetta 1984); in, Massif Central, France (Chauvel & J ahn 1984); ~ , Malaita, Solomon Islands (Bielski-Zyskind et al. 1984); 4,, Victoria, Australia (McDonough & McCulloch 1985); ~, Sierran Province, California (Van Kooten et al. 1985); ~, Ross Island and vicinity, Antarctica (Menzies et al. 1985b); V, Tanzania (Cohen et al. 1984); v, Tahiti (White & Hofmann 1982); v, Hawaii (Stille et al. 1983); , , Scotland (Menzies & Halliday 1984; Halliday et al. 1985); *, South Africa (Smith 1983).
Alkaline rocks and their inclusions continental lithosphere is heterogeneous and differs markedly from the oceanic lithosphere. The second point to note concerns the similarity between mantle sampled by volcanic rocks erupted in ocean basins and continental rift valleys (summarized in Fig. 5). Essentially this fragmented and entrained lithosphere has a prehistory not unlike the source regions of alkaline magmas ultimately responsible for the transport of inclusions to the surface. This can be interpreted to mean that lithosphere has been rehomogenized by impingement of asthenospheric melts. Since rift valleys are relatively young (less than 0.2 x 10a Ma) any trace-element enrichment locked into the lithosphere would have had insufficient time to evolve isotopically or would have been obliterated by recent rehomogenization of the isotope systems. The third point has relevance to the presence
+1!
+10 I
+5 I E~
r ANTARCTICA
<~ISCOTLAND
0 I
-5 I
21
of aged isotopically heterogeneous lithosphere below the stable continental cratons. This is sampled during eruption of magmas through stable cratons or in some rift valleys (e.g. Tanzania) (Fig. 5). As a group, ultramafic and mafic inclusions from alkaline and kimberlite host rocks erupted through cratonic regions have a considerable range in Nd and Sr isotopic composition (Fig. 3). These values encompass mantle both enriched and depleted in light REE for a prolonged period of time (Menzies & Murthy 1980b; Erlank et al. 1982, 1987; Kramers et al. 1983; Cohen et al. 1984). Inclusions with the least radiogenic Nd isotopic composition were entrained by kimberlitic and alkaline magmas erupted through old stable cratonic regions (Menzies & Murthy 1980b; Cohen et al. 1984; Menzies & Halliday 1984; Richardson et al. 1984). Diopsides sepa-
-10 I
-15 I
-20 I
-25 I
s
-30 I
Nd
] ] ULTRAMAFIC
O~LSOUTH AFRICA
XENOLITHS
(Lithosphere)
F TANZANIA
1
CALIFORNIA-
i
] COL::A:~N-A NEW MEXICO
I
......
I
El AUSTRALIA ~:
[ EUROPE k S.YEMEN RED SEA GUADALUPE HAWAII
~
~ ~
HOST
MAGMAS
(Asthenosphere)
TAHITI MALAITA NEW ZEALAND
t
i
' ULTRAMAFIC HOST
ALASKA ALPINE
PERIDOTITE 0.5135
I 0.5130
I 0.5125
I 0.5120
1 0.5115
XENOLITHS
MAGMA
I 0.5110
84
I 0.5105
0.5100
143Nd / 144Nd
FIG. 5. Nd isotopic variation in host magmas and mantle inclusions erupted through stable cratons, in rift valleys and ocean basins. Note that, regardless of the tectonic setting, the alkaline host magmas are derived from a mantle source region with a narrow end range of + 8 to -- 7, similar to that observed in oceanic basalts. The inclusions exhibit a considerable range of eNdrelative to the host magmas. Mantle entrained from below stable cratons (e.g. Antarctica, Scotland and South Africa) is heterogeneous, whereas mantle sampled in rift valleys and ocean basins is not unlike MORB-OIB. Rift valleys formed through regions of old crust (e.g. Tanzania), however, appear to sample both types of mantle. Arguments can be put forward for the presence of old heterogeneous lithospheric mantle below stable cratons, which tends to be disrupted and replaced by asthenospheric processes during rift formation. Well established rift valleys would eventually rupture this carapace of aged lithosphere by upwelling of asthenospheric melts. Data are taken from the sources given in the captions to Figs 1-3 and data for Guadalupe and New Zealand (Menzies, unpublished data) and alpine peridotites (Menzies 1984, and references cited therein).
M. Menzies
22
formed by asthenospheric processes. Similarly, in the ocean basins the relatively young age of the crust makes the widespread survival of aged cold stable lithosphere somewhat unlikely.
rated from garnet peridotites have model Nd ages of less than 3.0 x 103 Ma (Menzies et al. 1985b; Erlank et al. 1987). Such ages indicate stabilization and isolation of the continental lithosphere for a considerable portion of the Earth's history. Furthermore, the isotopic variability of the lithospheric mantle overlaps that of the crust. Inclusions with an isotopic signature equivalent to M O R B or OIB have been found in oceanic regions and in continental regions that have experienced recent extension and presumably upwelling (i.e. rift valleys). Inclusions with isotopic ratios distinct from MORB and OIB are sampled by kimberlite or alkaline magmas erupted through old cratonic regions. In the case of stable cratons, the host magma is isotopically equivalent to OIB while the inclusions display a distinct isotopic signature unlike anything recovered from regions of young crust or the ocean basins (Fig. 5). It seems logical to infer that the difference must be that an aged heterogeneous component exists below regions of old crust. During rift valley formation this lithospheric carapace was presumably ruptured and trans-
Models for genesis of alkaline rocks The identification and characterization of the continental lithosphere, tectosphere or keel (Jordan 1975; Brooks et al 1976; Oxburgh & Parmentier 1978) has added a new dimension to our interpretation of the isotopic and traceelement characteristics of volcanic rocks erupted through continental crust. The continental lithosphere is defined as that portion of the upper mantle that moves as a coherent mechanical unit with a velocity similar to the surface crustal plate. Thermal and/or diapiric accretion may be responsible for stabilization of this region of the mantle (Jordan 1978; Oxburgh & Parmentier 1978). The thickness of the lithosphere below continental regions remains the subject of some debate (Jordan 1978; Oxburgh 1981). It is generally
TABLE 2. Source regions of inclusion-bearing alkaline and kimberlitic magmas Locality Afar (Assab) Africa (Tanzania) Alaska (Nunivak) Antarctica Foster Crater Ross Island Arizona Geronimo San Carlos Australia Kiama Kimberley Victoria California (Sierran Province)
Ref.*
Source region
1 Mantle mixing sources MORB and subducted lithosphere 2 Depleted mantle source 3 Mantle sourceOIB 4 Asthenospheric processes=OIB source 5 OIB source 6 OIB source 7 8 9 10
Mantle source modified by CO, MORB-enrichedmantle mixing Sub-continental heterogeneous mantle Subduction component in mantle-micaceous source
Fiji France (Massif Central) French Polynesia (Tahiti) Hawaii (Honolulu Series) Nigeria (Bokkos) Scotland (N Highlands) Solomon Islands (Malaita) South Africa (Various localities) South Yemen (Ataq)
11 OIB pods or dykes in MORB 12 Metasomatizedmantle source 13 Mantle source with recycled component 14 Multistage history of lithosphere-asthenosphere mixing 19 Fractionation in mantle, crustal contamination of evolved rocks 15 Old enriched sources: lithosphere-asthenosphere mix 16 Young depleted mantle plus recycled component 17 Lithosphere (enriched)--asthenosphere (depleted) sources 18 Mantle heterogeneity
* References 1-18 as in Table 1 ; 19, Irving & Price 1981.
Alkaline rocks and their inclusions accepted, however, that the sub-continental lithospheric mantle is considerably thicker than the crust and is of the order of 100 km or more compared with tens of kilometres beneath ocean basins. While the lithosphere below oceans is relatively young (less than 0.2x 103 Ma) and geochemically uncomplicated, the continental lithosphere retains a complex history that has been preserved in the stable non-convecting environment below the cratons. It has been suggested (Oxburgh & Parmentier 1978) that the lithosphere records the last major thermal event in the overlying crust. If so, aged heterogeneous mantle should be restricted to regions of Proterozoic and Archean crust. The prolonged stability of this region throughout geological time has important implications for the geochemical evolution of the sub-continental mantle. Brooks e t al. (1976) proposed that the keel soaked up fluids and melts from the asthenosphere and as a consequence the subcontinental lithosphere may contain a significant fraction of the incompatible-element inventory of the Earth. In theory, upwelling of silicate melts and aqueous fluids from the asthenosphere will modify the trace-element inventory of the lithospheric mantle. These enhanced trace-element
23
ratios will eventually register as modified isotopic ratios in regions of the mantle left undisturbed for considerable periods of time (more than 103 Ma). Extremely heterogeneous mantle will be produced by such processes. Any study of the evolution of continental alkaline (and tholeiitic) magmas must acknowledge the presence of aged heterogeneous lithosphere that may attain thicknesses in excess of 200 km below continental regions. Any magma believed to have been generated in the asthenosphere or lower mantle must first rupture this carapace of lithospheric mantle and then the crust, and establish by magma fracture a network of conduits to the surface. Since lithospheric mantle will be considerably thicker than crust, it presents a potential source of 'mantle contamination' for the asthenospheric melts. Mixing of asthenospheric and lithospheric melts may be a more significant process than crustal interaction in determining the isotopic and chemical characteristics of alkaline magmas (Table 2). Group II kimberlites and lamproites have Sr and Nd isotopic ratios distinctly different from those of OIB and more akin to those of crustal rocks or ultramafic xenoliths disrupted from the mantle below regions of old crust (Fig. 6).
I
~Nd
'
....MORB ~---~ASTHENOSPHERE 0.5130
~
R
-+10
BASALTS
m
0
OUP i K]-MBERLITES GROUP II KIMBERLITES
"O
z
"-~. 0 . 5 1 2 0
-
-10
-
-20
-
-30
LAMPROITES ~ "" ~
"O
z ,r-
'
[LITHOSPHERE I MANTLE INCLUSIONS
\MANTLE INCLUSIONS 0.5110 I,
I
I
I
0700
0750
0~00
0.850
87Sr/86Sr FIG. 6. t43Nd/~44Ndversus 878r/S6Sr variation in mantle inclusions and inclusion-bearing alkaline rocks. The extreme range in Nd and Sr isotopic composition defined by minerals separated from ultramafic inclusions encompasses the variation in Nd and Sr isotopic composition observed in alkaline rocks. Alkaline basalts and Group I kimberlites have isotopic characteristics identical with those of OIB derived from asthenosphere. In contrast, lamproites and Group II kimberlites may have a lithospheric component in their source regions. Data are taken from Menzies & Murthy (1980a, b), Erlank et al. (1987), Menzies (1983, and references cited therein), Menzies & Wass (1983), Cohen et al. (1984) and Menzies & Halliday (1984). Other data are taken from the references given in the caption to Fig. 4.
z4
M. Menzies
Contamination with significant amounts of crust is unlikely because of the rapidity with which these melts must reach the surface in order to maintain their load of high-density inclusions and diamonds. Furthermore, the extremely high concentrations of Sr (678-1845 ppm) and Nd (48-336 ppm) would require mixing with a highly radiogenic crustal component or stoping and assimilation of considerable amounts of crust. This is believed to be very unlikely. Now the problem arises of exactly which structural elements in the sub-continental mantle contribute to the genesis of these rocks. The isotopically heterogeneous nature of lamproites compares well with the heterogeneities recorded in continental lithospheric mantle inclusions (Fig. 6). Arguments could therefore be presented for a source region solely within the lithospheric mantle. This is rather unlikely as an asthenospheric component or influence may be needed to provide heat and volatiles and to trigger anatexis. Impingement of an asthenospheric plume on the continental lithosphere is believed to elevate the isotherms and induce melting in the lithospheric mantle immediately above the plume. The column of mantle above the plume may display a considerable range of Sr, Nd and Pb isotopic composition. To illustrate this it is
worth noting that ultramafic inclusions from the Bultfontein pipes, S Africa (Fig. 3), have an extreme range in Sr and Nd isotopes. If we accept that these inclusions represent a random vertical profile through the lithosphere, melts extracted from such a heterogeneous mantle would tend to be distinctly different from OIBs and the bulk of continental basalts particularly with regard to their isotopic ratios. If lamproites and micaceous kimberlites contain a major contribution from the lithospheric mantle it follows that their isotopic variability could theoretically be as great as that observed in lithospheric inclusions (Fig.
6). As more data become available, the range of Sr, Nd and Pb isotope ratios observed in mantle rocks is continually revised. Therefore a unique solution to the origin of lamproites and Group II kimberlites is impossible. It is perhaps prudent to limit comments on their origin to interaction between relatively homogeneous asthenosphere and extremely heterogeneous aged lithospheric mantle. The observed isotopic ratio in erupted lamproite or micaceous kimberlite will depend on (1) the mixing proportions of asthenosphere and lithosphere, (2) the Sr/Nd ratio in the asthenospheric and lithospheric end-members and (3) the isotopic ratio of these end-members.
FIG. 7. Earth models pertinent to the origin of inclusion-bearing alkaline rocks (IBAR). The primordial hotmantle plume (PHMP) and depleted low velocity layer (DLVL) model of Schilling (1973) and the model of Tatsumoto (1978) are based on REE and Pb isotopes. The third model is modified after Wasserburg & De Paolo (1979) and incorporates ideas from McCulloch et al. (1983), Smith (1983) and Chen& Frey (1983). The most significant aspect of this model is the involvement of the continental lithospheric mantle (CM) in the genesis of lamproites and Group II kimberlites. Wasserburg & De Paolo (1979) believe the CM to be 'sterile', but this is not compatible with geochemical data on inclusions. Continental flood basalts may have a contribution from CM early in their evolution while upwelling of asthenosphere triggers melting in the lithosphere and encourages mixing of the melts. Eventually, once the volcanic conduits are well established, continental flood basalts will essentially have the isotopic signature of OIBs. (CC, continental crust; OC, oceanic crust; IBAR, inclusion bearing alkaline rocks.)
Alkaline rocks and their inclusions McCuUoch et aL (1983) pursued a somewhat similar line of reasoning in their interpretation of the isotopic and trace-element variation observed in Australian lamproites. Mixing of a depleted end-member, not unlike OIB in isotopic composition, and an enriched mantle end-member, not unlike average crust in isotopic composition, produced the required range of St and Nd isotopes observed in the diamond-bearing lamproites. Similarly, in a detailed study of Group I (basaltic) and Group II (micaceous) kimberlites, Smith (1983) outlined a model of asthenosphere-lithosphere interaction. Since Group I kimberlites are isotopically identical with OIBs, their evolutionary history was believed to involve derivation from asthenospheric sources with little or no lithospheric mantle input. In contrast, Group II kimberlites require a more dominant lithospheric mantle component because of their radiogenic Sr and non-radiogenic Nd isotopic composition. McCulloch et al. (1983) defined a unique composition for the enriched mantle end-member. As more and more data become available, it is obvious that the sub-continental lithospheric mantle is extremely heterogeneous and could provide a variety of end-members for mixing models. To use the terminology of Powell and Bell (1974), several suites of garnet peridotites and pyroxenites stable at mantle pressures and temperatures have 'crustal-type' St, Nd and Pb isotopic compositions. As a consequence of this, the isotopic variability in the continental mantle is almost as diverse as in the overlying crust,
25
perhaps owing to incorporation of subducted melts or fluids over billions of years. Continental lithospheric mantle is in part transitional between M O R B - O I B type mantle and the crust. In its trace-element geochemistry and ultimately in its isotope geochemistry certain portions of the lithospheric mantle have more similarity to the crust than to M O R B - O I B mantle. It remains to be seen whether this is due to diapiric upwelling related to subduction of continental material or to other recycling processes.
Summarizing comments Impingement of asthenospheric or lower mantle plumes on oceanic or continental lithosphere is believed to initiate anatexis and promote mixing of isotopically distinct melts. Interaction with MORB-like lithosphere in ocean basins and continental regions gives rise to inclusion-bearing alkaline magmas and basaltic kimberlites (Group I) with isotopic signatures not unlike M O R B and OIB ( e N d = 8 to -- 9 ; eSr = -- 28 to + 34) (Table 2). Interaction with aged enriched continental lithospheric mantle may produce a more diverse suite of melts with isotopic characteristics unlike M O R B - O I B and more like that of ultramafic inclusions entrained in alkaline and kimberlitic melts (eNd= -- 24 to + 15 ;/3Sr= - - 35.5. to + 1867). Magmas believed to be produced by this process are micaceous kimberlites (Group II) and certain lamproites (Table 2).
References BETTON,P. J. & CIVETTA,L. 1984. Sr and Nd isotopic evidence for the heterogeneous nature and development of the mantle beneath Afar (Ethiopia). Earth planet. Sci. Lett. 71, 59-70. BIELSKI-ZYSKIND,M., WASSERBURG,G. J. & NIXON,P. H. 1984. Sm-Nd and Rb-Sr systematics in volcanics and ultramafic xenoliths from Malaita and Solomon Islands and the nature of the Ontong Java Plateau. J. geophys. Res. 89, 2415-24. BROOKS,C., JAMES,D. E. & HART,S. R. 1976. Ancient lithosphere: its role in young continental volcanism. Science, 193, 1086-994. CHASE, C. G. 1981 Oceanic island Pb: two-stage histories and mantle evolution. Earth planet Sci. Lett. 52, 277-84. CHAUVEL,C. & JAHN, B.-M. 1984. Nd-Sr isotope and REE geochemistry of alkali basalts from the Massif Central, France. Geochim. cosmochim. Acta, 48, 269-78. CHEN, C.-Y. & Frey, F. A. 1983. Origin of Hawaiian tholeiite and alkalic basalt. Nature, Lond. 302, 785-9.
CLAGUE, D. & FREY, F. A. 1982. Petrology and trace element geochemistry of the Honolulu volcanics, Oahu: implications for the oceanic mantle below Hawaii. J. Petrol. 23, 447-504. COHEN, R. S. & O'NIONS, R. K. 1982. The lead, neodymium and strontium isotopic structure of ocean ridge basalts. J. Petrol. 23, 299-324. , & DAWSON,J. B. 1984. Isotope geochemistry of xenoliths from East Africa: implications for development of mantle reservoirs and their interaction. Earth planet. Sci. Lett. 68, 209-20. DE PAOLO,D. 1978. Nd and Sr isotopic systematics of young continental igneous rocks. Short Papers of the 4th ICGCIG. Geological Survey Open File Report 78-701, pp. 91-3. United States Department of the Interior, Geological Survey, U.S. Printing Office. Dosso, L. & MURTHY, V. R. 1980. An Nd isotopic study of the Kerguelen islands: inferences on enriched oceanic mantle sources. Earth planet Sci. Lett. 48 268-76. DOWNES, H. 1984. Sr and Nd isotopic geochemistry of co-existing alkaline magma series, Cantal massif
26
M. Menzies
Central, France. Earth planet Sci. Lett. 69, 221334. ERLANK, A. E., ALLSOPP, H., HAWKESWORTH, C. J. & MENZIES, M. A. 1982. Chemical and isotopic characterization of upper mantle metasomatism in peridotite nodules from the Bultfontein kimberlite. Terra Cognita 2, 261-3. --, WATERS, F. G., HAWKESWORTH, C. J., HAGGERTY, S. E., ALLSOPP, H. L., RICKARD, R. S. & MENZIES, M. A. 1987. Evidence for mantle metasomatism in peridotite nodules from the Bultfontein floors, Kimberley, S. Africa. In : MENZIES, M. A. & HAWKESWORTH, C. J. (eds) Mantle Metasomatism, Academic Press, New York, 221311. FREY, F. A. & GREEN, D. H. 1974. The mineralogy, geochemistry and origin of lherzolite inclusions in Victorian basanites. Geochim. cosmochim. Acta, 38, 1023-59. GILL, J. B. 1984. Sr-Pb-Nd isotopic evidence that both MORB and OIB sources contribute to ocean island arc magmas in Fiji. Earth planet. Sci. Lett. 68, 44358. HALLIDAY,A. N., MENZIES,M. A. PALACZ,Z., HUNTER, R. H. & HAWKESWORTH, C. J. 1985. Hebridean mantle geochemistry. Trans. Am. Geophys. Union, 66, 414. HAWKESWORTH, C. J., ROGERS, N., VAN CALSTEREN, P. W. C. & MENZIES, M. A. 1984. Mantle enrichment processes. Nature, Lond. 311, 331-55. HOFMANN, A. & WrotE, W. M. 1982. Mantle plumes from ancient oceanic crust. Earth planet Sci. Lett. 57, 421-36. IRVING, A. J. & FREY, F. A. 1984. Trace element abundances in megacrysts and their host basalts: constraints on partition coefficients and megacryst genesis. Geochim. cosmochim. Acta, 45, 1201-21. & PRICE, G. 1981. Geochemistry and evolution of Iherzolite-bearing phonolitic lavas from Nigeria, Australia, East Germany and New Zealand. Geochim. cosmochim. Acta, 45, 1309-20. JAGOUTZ, E., CARLSON, R. W. & LUGMAIR, G. 1980. Equilibrated Nd, unequilibrated Sr isotopes in mantle xenoliths. Nature, Lond. 286, 708-10. JORDAN, T. H. 1975. The continental tectosphere. Rev. Geophys. space Phys. 13, 1-12. - 1978. Composition and development of the continental tectosphere. Nature, Lond. 274, 544-8. KRAMERS, J., RODDICK, J. & DAWSON, J. 1983. Trace element and isotope studies on veined, metasomatic and 'MARID' xenoliths from Bultfontein, South Africa. Earth planet. Sci. Lett. 65, 90-106. - - , SMITH, C. B., LOCK, N. P., HARMON, R. S. & BOYD, F. R. 1981. Can kimberlites be generated from ordinary mantle? Nature, Lond. 291, 53-6. KYLE, P., KIRSCH, I., GAMBLE, J. & MENZIES, M. 1985. Metasomatised ultramafic xenoliths from Foster Crater, Antarctica. Trans. Amer. geophys. Union 66, 409. MCCULLOCH, M. T., JAQUES, A. L., NELSON, D. R. & Lewis, J. D. 1983. Nd and Sr isotopes in kimberlites and lamproites from Western Australia: an enriched mantle origin. Nature, Lond. 302, 400-3. MCDONOUGH, W. F. & MCCULLOCI-I, M. T. 1985.
Isotopic and geochemical systematics in TertiaryRecent basalts from southeastern Australia and implications for the evolution of the sub-continental lithosphere. Geochim. cosmochim. Acta 49, 205168. MCKENZlE, D. P. & O'Nions, R. K. 1983. Mantle reservoirs and ocean island basalts. Nature, Lond. 301, 229-31. MENZlES, M. A. 1983. Mantle ultramafic xenoliths in alkaline magmas: evidence for mantle heterogeneity modified by magmatic activity. In: HAWKESWORTH, C. J. & NORRY, M. J. (eds) Continental Basalts and Mantle Xenoliths, pp. 111-38. Shiva, U.K. - - 1 9 8 4 . Chemical and isotopic heterogeneities in orogenic lherzolite massifs. In: GASS, I. G., LIPPARD, S. J. & SrIELTON, A. W. (eds), Ophiolites and Oceanic Lithosphere, Geol. Soc. Spec. Pubi. 13, pp. 231-40. - & HALLIDAY,A. N. 1984. Enriched mantle below the Scottish Highlands: Sr and Nd isotope and rare earth elements in peridotite and pyroxenite xenoliths from Loch Roag, Streap Comlaidh and Kilchatten, Scotland. Abstracts of 27th Int. Geological Cong., Moscow, p. 348. - - & HAWKESWORTH, C. J. 1987. Mantle xenoliths and upper mantle structure. In: NIXON, P. (ed.) Mantle Xenoliths, Wiley, New York, in press. --& MURTHY, V. R. 1980a. Nd and Sr isotope geochemistry of hydrous mantle nodules and their host alkali basalts: implications for local heterogeneities in metasomatically veined mantle. Earth planet Sci. Lett. 46, 323-34. - - & 1980b. Enriched mantle: Nd and Sr isotopes in diopsides from kimberlite nodules. Nature, Lond. 283, 634-6. --& WASS, S. Y. 1983. COz rich mantle below eastern Australia: REE, Sr and Nd isotopic study of Cenozoic alkaline magmas and apatite-rich xenoliths, Southern Highlands Province, New South Wales, Australia. Earth planet. Sci. Lett. 65, 287-302. - - , KEMPTON, P. & DUNGAN, M. 1985a. Interaction of continental lithosphere and asthenospheric melt below the Geronimo Volcanic Field, Arizona, U.S.A.J. Petrol., 26, 663-93. - - , KYLE, P. & GAMBLE,J. 1985b. Fragments of aged enriched sub-continental lithosphere entrained in asthenospheric magmas erupted at Foster Crater, Antarctica. Trans. amer. geophys. Union, 66, 409. - - - , ROGERS, N., TINDLE, m. & HAWKESWORTH,C. J. 1987. Metasomatic and enrichment processes in lithospheric peridotites, an effect of asthenosphere-lithosphere interaction. In: MENZlES, M. A. & HAWKESWORTI.I,C. J. (eds) Mantle Metasomatism, Academic Press, New York, 313-61. OXBURGH, E. R. 1981. Heat flow and differences in lithospheric thickness. Phil. Trans. R. Soc. Lond., Ser. A, 310, 337-46. - & PARMENTIER,E. M. 1978. Thermal processes in the formation of continental lithosphere. Phil. Trans. R. Soc. Lond., Set. A, 288, 415-29. POWELL, J. L. & BELL, K. 1974. Isotopic composition of strontium in alkalic rocks. In: SORENSEN, H.
Alkaline rocks and their inclusions (ed.) The Alkaline Rocks, pp. 412-420. Wiley, New York. RICHARDSON, S. H., GURNEY, J. J., ERLANK, A. J. & HARRIS, J. W. 1984. Origins of diamonds in old enriched mantle. Nature, Lond. 310, 198-202. ROCK, N. M. S. 1976. The comparative strontium isotopic composition of alkaline rocks: new data from southern Portugal and East Africa. Contrib. Mineral. Petrol. 56, 205-28. RODEN, M. F., FREY, F. A. & FRANCIS, D. i . 1984a. An example of consequent mantle metasomatism in peridotite inclusions from Nunivak Island, Alaska. J. Petrol. 25, 546-77. - - , HART, S. R., FREY, F. A. & MELSON, W. G. 1984b. Sr, Nd and Pb isotopic and REE geochemistry of St. Paul's Rocks: the metamorphic and metasomatic development of an alkali basalt mantle source. Contrib. Mineral. Petrol. 85, 379400. SCHILLING,J-G. 1973. Iceland mantle plume: geochemical evidence along the Reykjanes Ridge. Nature, Lond. 242, 565-571. SMITH, C. B. 1983. Pb, Sr and Nd isotopic evidence for sources of southern African Cretaceous kimberlites. Nature, Lond. 304, 51-4. STILLE, P., UNRUH, D. & TATSUMOTO,M. 1983. Pb, Sr, Nd and Hf isotopic evidence of multiple sources for Oahu, Hawaii basalts. Nature, Lond. 304, 259. STOSCH, H. G., CARLSON, R. W. & LUGMAIR, G. W. 1980. Episodic mantle differentiation: Nd and Sr isotopic evidence. Earth planet. Sci Lett. 47, 26371.
27
STUCKLESS, J. S. & ERICKSEN, R. L. 1976. Strontium isotope geochemistry of the volcanic rocks and associated megacrysts and inclusions from Ross Island and vicinity, Antarctica. Contrib. Mineral. Petrol. 58, 111-26. TATSUMOTO, M. 1978. Isotopic composition of lead in oceanic basalts and its implication to mantle evolution. Earth planet. Sci. Lett. 38, 63-87. THIRLWALL,i . 1982. Systematic variation in chemistry and Nd-Sr isotopes across a Caledonian calcalkaline volcanic arc: implications for source materials. Earth planet. Sci. Lett. 58, 27-50. VAN KOOTEN, G., LEEMAN, W. P. & MENZIES, M. A. 1985. Lithospheric peridotites and pyroxenites in alkaline basaltic rock from the Sierra Nevada, California, U.S.A. Trans. Amer. Geophys. Union, 66, 414. VIDAL, P., CHAUVEL, C. & BROUSSE, R. 1984. Large Mantle Heterogeneity beneath French Polynesia. Nature, Lond. 307, 536-8. WASS, S. Y. & ROGERS, N. K. 1980. Mantle metasomatism--precursor to continental alkaline volcanism. Geochim. cosmochim. Acta, 44, 1811-23. WASSERBURG, G. J. & DE PAOLO,D. J. 1979. Models of earth structure inferred from neodymium and strontium isotopic abundances. Proc. Natl Acad Sci. 76, 3594-8. WHITE, W. M. & HOFMANN, A. W. 1982. Sr and Nd isotope geochemistry of oceanic basalts and mantle evolution. Nature, Lond. 296, 821-5. ZINDLER, A. & JAGOUTZ, E. 1987. Trace element and Nd and Sr isotope systematics ofperidotite nodules from Peridot Mesa San Carlos, Arizona. Geochim. cosmochim. Acta, in press.
MARTIN MENZIES, Department of Geology, University of London, Royal Holloway and Bedford New College, Egham, Surrey, TW20 0EX, U.K.
The genesis of alkaline magmas with emphasis on their source regions: inferences from experimental studies A. D. Edgar SUMMARY: Experimental studies bearing on the genesis of alkaline magmas are reviewed, with emphasis on alkaline mafic-ultramafic magmas and the nature of their mantle sources. In contrast with previous experiments on simplified systems mainly at low pressures, more recent experiments under mantle pressures have resolved some of the problems of the earlier work. Inadequacies of petrogenetic schemes based on the model pyrolite mantle source for the generation of alkaline magma are also partly resolved by recent studies which suggest that with increasing alkalinity the possibility of deriving mafic-ultramafic magmas from a dry lherzolitic mantle source, or one with H20 as the only volatile, becomes increasingly difficult. The addition of CO2 and H20 to the source regions allows generation of magmas such as olivine melilitites, but few magmas of the olivine leucitite kindred can be generated from lherzolitic sources. Such magmas appear to be partial melts of clinopyroxenite or orthopyroxenite sources containing both volatiles. Preliminary experimental modelling of mantle metasomatism suggest that this process may readily occur. Experiments on felsic alkaline rocks with emphasis on liquid immiscibility and halogens and experiments aimed at solving specific problems are briefly considered.
Introduction Experiments on systems pertinent to alkaline rocks have undoubtedly made an immense contribution to our understanding of the genesis of these rocks, particularly in problems such as the attainment of peralkalinity, the depth of derivation of alkaline magmas and, most recently, the variation in the source materials from which alkaline magmas are derived relative to nonalkaline varieties. Some of the major experimental studies carried out since the publication of The Alkaline Rocks by Sorensen (1974) are reviewed in this paper. The term 'alkaline rocks' will be used to denote rocks containing feldspathoidal minerals (modal or normative) or rocks not necessarily containing a feldspathoid but with low SiOz and high alkali contents. Such a definition clearly precludes alkali granites but could include certain kimberlites and carbonatites which are not discussed in any detail. Within the past decade a number of reviews of the role of experimental petrology in our understanding of the genesis of alkaline rocks have been published. Edgar (1974) included data on alkaline systems published up to the early 1970s, while Bailey (1974) reviewed the application of experimental petrology to oversaturated peralkaline volcanic rocks and later (Bailey 1976) discussed experiments applicable to a wide spectrum of alkaline rocks ranging from strongly SiO2-undersaturated mafic varieties to undersaturated and oversaturated felsic types. More recently, the Basaltic Volcanism Study Project
(1981) (see particularly pp. 529-30, 561-2 and 564--7) has reviewed experiments on alkaline and highly undersaturated potassic basalts. Zyryanov (1981) discussed phase relations in feldspars and feldspathoids with some emphasis on petrological aspects, and Kogarko & Romanchev (1982) discussed phase equilbria in alkaline melts. Both of these papers include important references to the Russian literature. Writing from a petrologist's viewpoint, Edgar (1984) discussed the chemistry, occurrence and paragenesis of feldspathoids, including experiments bearing on the origin of pseudoleucites, the formation of melilite in nephelinites, melilitites and alkaline lavas of comparable compositions, geothermometry and the question of the origins of primary analcite. In the past 10-15 years the emphasis of experimental studies bearing on alkaline rock genesis has changed from low-pressure experiments in relatively simple synthetic systems to studies using rock compositions under mantle conditions in excess of 100 km depth and controlled partial pressures of volatiles. As a result of these high-pressure experiments the importance of H20, CO 2 and other volatiles on the genesis and evolution of alkaline magmas is much better known than it was a decade ago. The hypothesis that alkaline magmas as well as kimberlites, carbonatites and lamproites are partial melts of slightly to vastly modified lherzolite mantle sources has been strongly supported by experimental studies and has led to experiments in which processes of mantle metasomatism are being simulated. Investigations
From : FITTON,J. G. & UPTON, B. G. J. (eds), 1987, Alkaline Igneous Rocks, Geological Society Special Publication No. 30, pp. 29-52.
29
30
A. D. Edgar
have been undertaken to determine the compositions of liquids produced from partial melting of metasomatized mantle nodules. Results of such experiments, combined with major-element, trace-element and isotope geochemistry, have changed many of the models based on a pyrolitetype mantle source proposed in the late 1960s and early 1970s (e.g. O'Hara 1968; Green 1971) for basalt genesis, and particularly for the origin of alkali basalt magmas. Many experiments have also been carried out on the structures of silicate melts, many of alkaline affinities, which have important implications on the physical properties of magmas. Although these studies are beyond the scope of this paper, they are now being incorporated into petrology texts (e.g. Barker 1983). Other important advances in experimental petrology pertinent to alkaline rocks include studies on liquid immiscibility, the role of halogens and traceelement partitioning between crystals and melts. This review concentrates on experimental studies pertinent to the genesis of alkaline basalts and mafic rocks of extreme alkaline affinities. The implications of these studies on the mantle source regions of alkaline magmas are emphasized. Experiments at lower pressures pertinent to felsic alkaline magmatism are briefly considered.
Alkali mafic and ultramafic magmas--background studies Synthetic systems at low pressures Alkali basalts, in which potassium is a minor element, can be represented in the expanded basalt system (CaSiO3 (Wo)-NaA1SiO4 (Ne)Mg2SiO4 (Fo)-SiO2) by recalculating the rock composition into the CIPW normative minerals representing this system. In this system (Fig. 1) mildly alkaline basalts and associated rocks plot within the D i - N e - F o - A b volume and are separated from the more alkali-rich nephelinites and melilitites, plotting within the A k - D i - F o - N e volume, by the F o - D i - N e pseudoternary join. Experiments at low pressure within these two sub-systems of the expanded basalt tetrahedron and in systems with additional components such as CaA12Si20 8 (An) resulted in discrepancies in the paragenesis of the minerals, based on the interpretations of the experimental results and on textural observations on mildly alkali-enriched to highly alkali-enriched rocks. Part of this problem was due to treating the expanded basalt system on flow sheets as a quaternary system
Lo
Ne~
Fo
Mol per cent
FIG. 1. The expanded basalt system. Abbreviations for the CIPW normative minerals are as follows: La, larnite; Ne, nepheline; Fo, forsterite; Qz, quartz; Ab, Albite; En, enstatite; Di, diopside ; Ak, akermanite; Wo, wollastonite; Sm, soda-melilite; Mo, monticellite; Mer, merwinite; Ra, rankinite. Shaded joins represent planes of critical SiO2 undersaturation. when it is at least quinary (Schairer et al. 1969; Schairer & Yoder 1970). For similar reasons, the CaO-MgO-AI203-SiO 2 system (O'Hara & Biggar 1969; Schairer et al. 1969; Schairer & Yoder 1970) cannot be used to model alkaline mafic magmas. The obvious chemical deficiencies of the CaO-MgO-A1203-SiO2 system relative to the compositions of nephelinites and melilitites, and the now accepted hypothesis that nephelinites and melilitites form from the mantle-derived magmas at considerable depth make experiments at 1 atm in either the expanded basalt tetrahedron or the CaO-MgO-AI203-SiO 2 system quite inadequate for investigating the genesis of these rocks ( c f Thompson 1972). Although low-pressure experiments are largely inappropriate in explaining the genesis of alkaline magmas, some features such as the incompatibility of melilite and plagioclase in the same lava can be accounted for by using the schematic representation of liquidus volumes in the WoD i - A b - N e sub-system of the expanded basalt tetrahedron (Fig. 2). Data for this diagram are given by Yoder (1979). Along the Di-Ne join in this system diopside and nepheline do not coexist as liquidus phases but are separated by a field of
Genesis o f alkaline magmas olivine (Bowen 1922: Schairer et al. 1962; Yoder & Kushiro 1972). At sub-liquidus temperatures melilites with compositions comparable with those of melilite in melilitites and melilite nephelinites (E1-Goresy & Yoder 1974) occur. Extension of the primary olivine field into the D i - N e - W o - A b volume (Fig. 2) separates the primary fields of melilite and plagioclase and accounts for the incompatibilityof these minerals in nature. The stability of melilite molecules in various sub-systems of the expanded basalt tetrahedron and in other systems in which Ne and Di are components has been used by Yoder (1979) to explain the genesis of melilite-bearing rocks and associated lamprophyres. The limitations of the expanded basalt and CaO-MgO--A1203-SiO2 systems to explain the genesis of Na-rich mafic magmas become more pronounced for K-rich varieties of these magmas. Although not as common, K-rich mafic and ultramafic lavas may be more important than Na-rich varieties in holding the key to heterogeneities in the mantle source regions. Yoder (1975) has modelled these K-rich magmas using the system Ca2SiO 4 (La)-KA1SiO4 (Ks)Mg2SiO4 (Fo)-SiO2_H20. Figure 3(a) shows the relationship of leucite and akermanite to other major constituents of these rocks, whereas in Fig. 3(b) the system with H20 as an additional
31 Ks
o
LO
Met
Mo
Fo
Mol per cent
Ks
(b) Ne
Sm
Lo-
, Pl ~'"
wo wo
Ab
D. FIG. 2. The CaSiO3 (Wo)-CaMgSi206 (Di)NaA1Si308 (Ab)-NaA1SiO4(Ne)system. Abbreviations are as in Fig. 1 and as follows: Mel, melilite; O1, olivine; Pl, plagioclase; SS, solid solution. (After Yoder 1979.)
Mb
Mo Mol per cent
Fo
FIG. 3. The system Ca2SiO4 (La)-KA1SiO4 (Ks)MgzSiO4(Fo)-SiO2(Qz) (a) without H20 and (b) with H20. Abbreviations are as in Fig. 1 and as follows: Lc, leucite; Sa, sanidine; Phlog, phlogopite. (After Yoder 1979.) component has phlogopite, a common constituent of K-rich mafic lavas, as an additional phase. Many joins in this system have been investigated up to high pressures and, despite the obvious lack of Na20, the results provide some explanations for the genesis of K-rich alkaline mafic rocks. Using this system, Yoder (1975) related ugandite (olivine melilite leucitite) to mafurite (olivine kalsilite pyroxenite) by the reaction
A. D. E d g a r
32
2[Ca2MgSi207] (Ak) 4- 3[KA1Si206] (Lc) 4- (x 4-1)[MgzSiO4] (Fo) ugandite
4[CaMgSi206] (Di) + 3[KA1SiO4] (Ks) + x[MgzSiO4] (Fo) mafurite
As shown in Fig. 3(a)), the leucite + akermanite assemblage (bold lines) reacts to give the kalsilite + diopside assemblage (broken line). Both ugandite and mafurite contain olivine. If the reaction based on relationship in Fig. 3(a) is correct the simplified ugandite assemblage must be richer in olivine than the mafurite assemblage as indicated by the unknown value x. Highpressure experiments on these rocks (Edgar et al. 1980; Arima & Edgar 1983a) suggest that these magmas are not interrelated but may be derived independently from different metasomatized mantle sources. Using the relationship in Fig. 3(b) and adding COz, Yoder (1975) indicated a possible relationship between mafurite magmas and kimberlite magmas by the reaction CaMgSi206 (Di) + 3[KAISiO4] (Ks) 4- (x + 4) [Mg2SiO4] (Fo) 4- CO2 4- 3H20 rnafurite
3[KMg3A1Si3Olo(OH)2] (Phlog) + CaCO3(Ct) + x[Mg2SiO4] (Fo) kimberhte
In this reaction x represents the amount of olivine required to balance the equation and indicates that a kimberlitic groundmass will have less olivine than a simplified mafurite. On the basis of these equations, Yoder (1975) proposed that melilite-bearing magmas should be transformed to kimberlitic magmas. Melilite-bearing magma might be produced at low pressures under dry conditions (Fig. 3(a)) caused by volatile loss during ascent or by low-pressure crystallization. With the addition of H20 and CO2, such a melilite magma could be transformed to kimberlite. Although the kimberlite-melilitite association is not uncommon, kimberlites are only rarely associated with highly K-rich mafic volcanics such as mafurite. However, kimberlites are associated with lamproites sensu stricto (Bergman 1987) but probably not by the mechanism proposed by Yoder (1975). Many mafurites contain both kalsilite and primary phlogopite (Holmes 1950; Edgar 1979) which cannot be explained by this mechanism.
Rock systems--the pyrolite model As an alternative to the chemically simplified synthetic systems, experiments on rocks of alkali
olivine basalt, basanite, nephelinite and melilitite compositions (el Green & Ringwood 1967; Bultitude & Green 1968, 1971; Green 1969, 1970a, b, 1973a; Green & Hibberson 1970; Brey & Green 1977) under conditions ranging from crustal to upper-mantle depths clearly indicated the importance of mantle processes in the genesis of alkaline mafic magmas. Based on these studies and assuming a model pyrolite mantle source for these magmas (Ringwood 1975), Green (1970a, b) developed a petrogenetic grid for basaltic magmas (Fig. 4). For a model pyrolite with 0.1 H20 and no other volatile component, Fig. 4 shows that progressively more alkali-rich mafic to ultramafic magmas, ranging from alkali olivine basalts to olivine melilitites, might be produced at progressively greater depths with decreasing degrees of partial melting and increasing amounts of H20 in the melt. The grid shown in Fig. 4 can be used to divide fractionation trends, based on the liquidus and near-liquidus minerals, according to depth of generation of the magma. Green & Ringwood (1976), Green & Hibberson (1970) and Merrill & Irving (1977) proposed that mildly alkali basalts could be formed at approximately 45-60 km by fractionation of aluminous enstatite 4- aluminous subcalcic clinopyroxene from an olivine basalt magma to yield alkali olivine basalt magma with about 25~ normative olivine and 1 ~ - 2 ~ normative nepheline (Fig. 4). Green & Ringwood (1976) extended this fractionation scheme by suggesting that further fractionation of aluminous clinopyroxene_ aluminous enstatite from this magma can produce an olivine basanite with about 5~ normative nepheline. The absence of orthopyroxene as a liquidus phase at any pressure under dry conditions in alkali olivine basalt compositions (Ito & Kennedy 1968; Bultitude & Green 1971; Arculus 1975) makes this scheme highly unlikely. At greater depths (60-120 km) no fractionation trends linking the more extreme alkali magmas of nephelinitic and basanitic affinities could be found on the basis of results of experiments in the absence of H20. However, hydrous experiments on nephelinitic compositions with an estimated 5-7~ H20 in the melt (Bultitude & Green 1968, 1971; Green 1969, 1970a, b, 1973b; Green & Hibberson 1970) indicated that between 18 and 27 kb the primary field of orthopyroxene crystallization was extended, in contrast with anhydrous experiments in which liquidus phases were olivine, clinopyroxene and garnet. These experiments suggested a fractionation scheme whereby less extreme alkali basaltic magmas could be linked to more alkali-rich compositions, provided that H20 was available in their source regions. This scheme has
Genes& of alkaline magmas
33
% MELTING 5
I0
15
20
25
Qz.' Tholeiite Tholeiite/ ~ -----.__ 0-5 / i '
olivine
/,
,
~ ~
~
C\~e'/Oliv in 9 Th ole iit 9
\
5-10
?\~High AI203
.
20
Or tho'~vr ~
9OXene~
High AI2I~3
Hawc(iite"/"Alkaline Olivine
35
Tholeiite
5-15
High-AI203 e~ ~
30
Olivine
Olivine
Olivine Tholeiite
Tholeiite
~" 40
Olivine-rich ~-/~<~Y
.13
So.sanite
/
/
Alkaline Olivine Bo.satt 20 - 30
~s-25 / / ~O~ine Olivine-rich NL:phelinite Bosonite 2o-3o
@ L
D20
//2o-2s
U~ @
Otiv/ne Basalt 2~-25
5O
Otivine Thoteiite 20-25
Alkc{t'ine Picrite ~ 3o-35
Thoteiitic Picrite -3o
L
n
-~344v].Qe ~ M e t i t i t e ~ -~ Olivine Nepheti~te i . . o,~ ~30-35 / 3O Nephetln~te %, 25-35
I O,iv,ne
J~lMel.ilitit e ~ /
I~
.~35-~0
10 4
2
-O'[ivine N~.|i rite Nephelin'i, te ~35-40\
i
Picritic Basonite 30-35
Atkotine Picrite 30-35
E
60 v,
Thoteiitic Picrite -35
t70 .~ n 80 ~J
90 100
110 120
0%
0',3
%H20 in melt for simple m e l t i n g of p y r o l i t e c o n t a i n i n g
0.1~ H20
FIG 4. Green's (1970a, b) petrogenetic grid based on a model pyrolite mantle containing 0.1% H20 (the numbers below each rock represent normative olivine): - - - , stability limits of minerals indicated.
now been abandoned for highly alkaline magmas in favour of their being primary melts. The petrogenetic scheme for alkali basalt genesis outlined above differs considerably from that of O'Hara (1968) who suggested that alkaline magmas were generated at a greater depth (at least 100 km) by higher degrees of partial melting (up to 30%) and by a more complex fractionation scheme in which as much as 40% garnet+ clinopyroxene and 40% olivine are fractionated from a tholeiitic picrite at various stages of ascent. Ringwood (1975, pp. 166-71) gave a (biased?) review of the differences between O'Hara's scheme and that of Ringwood, Green and coworkers. His principal criticisms of O'Hara's hypotheses are the oversimplification of O'Hara's four-component system relative to natural conditions, the inconsistency in the Mg/ (Mg+Fe), Ni, Cr and incompatible elements required by the large amount of fractionation involved in O'Hara's hypothesis and those observed in alkaline olivine basalts, and O'Hara's lack of quantitative assessment of his petrogenetic scheme. The genesis of alkaline mafic-ultramafic magmas based on Green's petrogenetic grid (Fig. 4)
presents a number of difficulties. None of the compositions represents rocks with K20 > Na20 and those with high Na20 contents, e.g. olivine melilite nephelinites, require very small degrees of partial melting. The genesis of these highly alkaline SiO2-undersaturated magmas is much more likely to be the result of direct partial melting than of fractionation processes as these magmas have a primitive chemistry which precludes even moderate fractionation and they are in equilibrium with a pyrolitic mineral assemblage (cf Ringwood 1975). Because these magmas have much greater abundances of incompatible, major and trace elements than are present in less alkaline types, very low degrees of partial melting seem to be required (cf Kay & Gast 1973). Nevertheless the problem of segregation of these very small amounts of partial melt and their subsequent ascent from 100 km or greater is formidable (see Yoder 1976). This difficulty is even greater if, as Ringwood (1975, p. 153) suggests, less than 1% partial melting of a hydrous source may be required for the generation of olivine nephelinite, olivine melilitite and kimberlite magmas. More recently McKenzie (1984) has developed models based on equations involving
34
A. D. Edgar
the movement of melt and matrix in partialmelts. Based on his calculations, very low degrees of partial melting (less than 3~) at depths commonly accepted for alkali basalts can readily allow melts to ascend to the surface. For highly alkaline magmas derived by direct partial melting of a mantle source the grid shown in Fig. 4 may not be as valuable as for less alkaline types. The grid is based on a pyrolite (lherzolite) source in which H20 is the only volatile component. Recently the concept that alkaline magmas are partial melts of mantle sources metasomatized to produce regions of quite different compositions from that of pyrolite and the importance of volatiles other than H20 in such source regions has been widely discussed ( c f Bailey 1982). Much of the remainder of this review is devoted to experiments pertinent to these concepts.
Recent experimental studies on alkaline mafic-ultramafic magmas Alkaline olivine basalts
The Basaltic Volcanism Study Project (1981, chapter 3) defines alkali olivine basalts as those with not more than 5~ normative nepheline and lists (Appendix 3.1, pp. 614-15) 11 experimental studies carried out on natural or synthetic samples up to 1978. The pressures varied from 1 atm to 33 kb under dry to H20-excess conditions, many with controlled or reasonably estimated oxygen fugacity (fO2) and temperatures from nearliquidus to solidus. Experiments performed at low pressures are not pertinent to the problems of the generation of alkali magmas under mantle conditions, but are important in establishing the sequence of mineral crystallization particularly near the liquidus and possible parental magma compositions (see Thompson 1973). These experiments have also been important in determining the effects offO2 on the stabilities of minerals in alkali olivine basalts (see Helz 1973, 1976). Unfortunately, fewer data are available for the effects offO2 on alkali magmas than are available for other basalts. Thompson (1974) studied a primitive alkali olivine basalt composition from Skye, Scotland (Mg number, 65; ne, 2.84~), between 8 and 31 kb at fOz>iron-wustite (IW) buffer under dry conditions. Because of its high Mg value it is unlikely that this alkali olivine basalt could be derived from a tholeiitic parental magma by fractionation; it is more likely to represent a pristine melt as suggested by Green (1970a) for similar alkali olivine basalts. Near-liquidus rela-
tionships in these experiments are very complicated at about 17kb (see Thompson 1974) suggesting that liquids must be saturated in olivine + clinopyroxene_ pigeonite. On the basis of these results Thompson proposed that this alkali olivine basalt was either a direct partial melt of an Fe-rich lherzolite at about 50km depth or a partial melt of a more Mg-rich lherzolite from deeper sources which underwent some olivine fractionation. Frey et al. (1978) estimated that 11~-15~ partial melting of garnet-free lherzolite can produce an alkali olivine basalt magma. Experiments without volatiles give no information on the roles of amphiboles and micas on the genesis of alkali olivine basalt. Allen et al. (1975) studied a Hualalai, Hawaii, alkali olivine basalt under pressure conditions similar to those used by Thompson (1974) but with excess H20 and f O 2 approximating those of the hematitemagnetite (HM), nickel-nickel oxide (NNO) and magnetite-wustite (MW) buffers. This composition has a comparable Mg number (67) but a lower ne (0.20~) than the sample used by Thompson (1974). Their experiments are shown in Fig. 5 which indicates that under HzO-excess conditions amphibole + olivine + clinopyroxene are near-liquidus phases around 13 kb, olivine is a liquidus phase up to 25 kb and garnet is present between 18 and 23 kb (Fig. 5(a)). The main differences between the results of the dry experiments (Thompson 1974) and the H20-excess conditions used by Allen et al. (1975) are the presence of amphibole and absence of pigeonite in the HzO-excess experiments (Fig. 5(a)). Allen et al. (1975) found that a n f O 2 corresponding to the N NO buffer produced amphibole at higher temperatures relative to the HM and MW buffer conditions (Fig. 5(b)). The absence oforthopyroxene in the experiments reported by Allen et al. places some constraints on the potential of orthopyroxene fractionation in the genesis of these basalts under H20-saturated conditions. The experiments support the concept that andesitic magmas are derived from basaltic magmas by amphibole-liquid fractionation processes as amphibole is stable at temperatures greater than the H20-saturated liquidus of andesite. Thus fractionation of amphibole from basaltic liquids during partial melting or fractional crystallization processes would lead to SiO 2 enrichment. Melting at depths corresponding to pressures greater than 23 kb, where amphibole is no longer stable (Fig. 5), would enrich liquids in Na20 and H20. Figure 6 shows the results of dry experiments performed by Takahashi (1980) on a primitive alkali olivine basalt from Oki-Dogo Island, Japan (Mg number, 63; ne, 3.40~), under low-fO2
Genesis o f a l k a l i n e m a g m a s
[--,
| I"
O I + C p x + G a + Ru + O p
25 ~-rA'mphibo'0"~ "
~
9 f, . / LOlivine Out] "4="
35
, ~
,
,
Y+
x 20
13_
10
,, ,,'
800
900
,
+ Cpx
o
__ J
1000 1100 800
900
1000
1100
Temperature, ~ (b)
(o)
FIG. 5. Phase relations of an alkali olivine basalt from Hawaii : (a) under H20-saturated conditions; (b) effects of variousfO2 on amphibole stability. Abbreviations are as in Fig. 2 and as follows : Cpx, clinopyroxene; Am, amphibole; Ga, garnet; Ru, rutile; Op, opaque; N-NO, nickel-nickeloxide buffer assemblage; M-H, magnetite-hematite buffer assemblage ; M-W, magnetite-wustite buffer assemblage. Liquid(s) coexist with all assemblages. (Modified from Allen et al. 1975.) conditions within the wustite stability field. This basalt, which contains spinel lherzolite nodules, gives results similar to those obtained by Thompson (1974) with orthopyroxene+clinopyroxene on the liquidus at 14-15kb and olivine+orthopyroxene (pigeonite) + clinopyroxene + liquid between 13.5 and 14 kb. This suggests that the
i
I
I
magma could have coexisted with the latter assemblage at depths corresponding to this pressure. This assemblage, along with spinel, also occurs at an isobaric invariant point within the D i - A n - F o tetrahedron between 7 and 20 kb (Presnall et al. 1978, 1979). Kushiro (1973), Presnall et al. (1978, 1979) and Mysen & Kushiro
i
i
I
i
1500
ou 1 4 0 0
Ga§
.
OL+Opx
~
+ Cpx+L t
d
OL+Cpx+L
\Opx+Cpx+L
/
_ /
r 1300 n
E
r
1200
1100
j
~
OL§
0
n 5
n 10
n 15 Pressure,
n 20 kb
~ 25
I 30
35
FIG. 6. Phase relations in an alkali olivine basalt from Japan (abbreviations as in Figs 2 and 5). (Modified from Takahashi 1980.)
36
A. D. E d g a r
(1977) suggest that liquids in more complex natural systems become nepheline normative between 10 and 20 kb. All these results suggest that the alkali olivine basalt lay on the SiOz-poor side of the A b - F o - D i plane (Fig. 1) at 14 kb. Based on these experiments Takahashi (1980) proposed that alkali olivine basalt magmas can be partial melts oflherzolite at depths corresponding to 14 kb provided that H20 and CO2 are unimportant in the melting relations, or that they were generated at greater depths but remained in equilibrium with lherzolite in the upper mantle. Alkali olivine basalts and systems of corresponding composition have also been investigated experimentally at crustal pressures under a variety of conditions. Duke (1974) studied an alkali olivine basalt (Mg number, 57.3; he, 1.63~) from the Azores at 1 atm and withfO2 determined using CO2 and C O + C O 2 mixtures. He found that oxidation increased the stability of spinel and clinopyroxene but decreased that of olivine and plagioclase, promoted crystallization of magnesioferrite-rich spinel and acmitic pyroxene, and caused nephetine-normative liquids to become SiO2 saturated or oversaturated. Using the system CaO-MgO-AlzO3-SiO2-Na20-H2 O at 5 kb to model various basalt types, Cawthorn (1976) found that nepheline-normative liquids could crystallize amphibole___ olivine + Ca-rich clinopyroxene to produce quartz-normative residual liquids of andesitic composition.
Green (1973a) investigated a lherzolite-bearing olivine basanite composition from Mount Laura, Victoria, with 10% added olivine (Mg number, 70; ne, 10.5%) between 5 and 36 kb and over a range of H20-undersaturated liquid conditions. As shown in Fig. 7, liquids from this composition are saturated with olivine + orthopyroxene + clinopyroxene+garnet only under very limited conditions corresponding to 25-30kb, 12001300~ and 2 - 7 ~ H20. Based on these experiments, Green (1973a) concluded that basanites could be generated from a lherzolite mantle with 0.2-0;4% H20 by 6 ~ partial melting at a depth of around 100 km. He suggested that the excess olivine fractionated from the liquid prior to the incorporation of lherzolitic mantle xenoliths, presumably during ascent. Using a kaersutite eclogite nodule from Kakanui, Hawaii, of composition corresponding to olivine basanite (Mg number, 63; ne, 6.4~), Merrill & Wyllie (1975) showed that orthopyroxene+ clinopyroxene + garnet coexisted at 20 kb under HzO-excess conditions, and at greater than 30 kb with progressively lower H=O contents. With the addition of normative olivine to their bulk composition, they found a more extensive field of olivine + orthopyroxene + clinopyroxene+ garnet in equilibrium with liquid than that reported by Green (1973a) and they also found that kaersutite was stable on the H20-undersaturated liquidus between 12 and 21 kb for liquids 40
Basanites and nephelinites Basic rocks more alkaline than alkali olivine basalts are generally defined as those with more than 5% normative nepheline. They may also contain normative leucite and a few have normative kalsilite. These magmas have primitive Mg numbers and other chemical features indicative of an origin by direct partial melting from a mantle source. Some are extremely rich in K and other incompatible and large-ion-lithophile (LIL) elements. Because of the many problems involved in the genesis of these rocks, including the fact that many cannot apparently be derived by partial melting of a (normal) lherzolitic mantle source, a large number of experiments on these magma compositions have been carried out in recent years. Those experiments particularly applicable to the nature of the source regions are concentrated on in this section. Over a decade ago it was recognized that highly alkaline magmas could not be derived by partial melting of volatilefree mantle peridotite but that some of these magmas could represent partial melts of an HzOand CO2-bearing peridotitic mantle (see Basaltic Volcanism Study Project 1981, pp. 529-30).
Ol
/
,/ go+'~px,/ I
I
~1 t 'IX
l +wx/ l + opx /
I go
~',,~ + ol l
I
go
/o,/// /op,+.l
:~ 20
!
,/ I g ~
/
/
/
/
/
/
J
/
/ /
l,,
II
I/ II
I jq.~
/
/
~'~
~ ~
Olivine/
/
,~
\1
!9
/ O........ livine
\//
o
L 1100
,
J
"-.I 1300
/ ,
. 1500
TEMPERATURE, ~ FIG. 7. Phase relations in an olivine basanite + 10~ olivine under dry to HzO-saturated conditions: - - -, percentage HzO added. Abbreviations are as given in Figs 2 and 5. (After Green 1973b).
Genesis of alkaline magmas containing at least 2-3% H20. From this Merrill & Wyllie (1975) inferred that basanites with kaersutite megacrysts may contain 2-3% H20 at depths corresponding to these pressures. Arculus (1975) investigated basanites from Mount Shadwell, Victoria (Mg number 68; ne, 11.92%), and from Grenada, Lesser Antilles (Mg number, 74; ne, 7.84%), under dry conditions between 10 and 35 kb. Owing to the absence of liquidus assemblages compatible with a dry peridotitic source (notably orthopyroxene), he concluded that basanites could not be derived from such a source unless H20 and CO2 were present; the former stabilizes olivine relative to pyroxene, and the latter stabilizes orthopyroxene relative to olivine and clinopyroxene (Eggler 1974). Arculus (1975) also concluded that oxides of polyvalent cations such as TiO2 and P205, commonly abundant in basanites, might lower the olivine stability field by 2-3 kb. Thus the absence of volatiles and such polyvalent cations in previously proposed models (e.g. O'Hara & Yoder 1967; Kushiro & Yoder 1974) suggests that such models might be inapplicable for natural systems of basanitic affinities. Evolved alkali basalts Evolved alkali basalts with lower Mg numbers and less normative nepheline than the primitive basanites and nephelinites may be produced from these more primitive magmas by various fractionation mechanisms. Bultitude & Green (1971) suggested that many basanites and nephelinites might be products of olivine fractionation of lowSiO2 picritic magmas. Irving & Green (1972) demonstrated that kaersutite was a near-liquidus mineral at 14 kb from a nepheline mugearite composition with about 3.5% H20 which contained lherzolite nodules. These studies indicate that fractionation of olivine+kaersutite from basanitic magma could produce nepheline hawaiites and nepheline mugearites at depths around 40-45 km. Although experimental data are lacking, it seems likely that further fractionation of clinopyroxene+biotite could produce nepheline benmoreites and phonolites (cf Irving & Price 1981). Olivine-rich nephelinites and melilitites In experiments with olivine nephelinites and comparable compositions up to 36 kb and under dry to H20-excess conditions (Bultitude & Green 1968, 1971; Allen et al. 1975; Merrill & Wyllie 1975) it was shown that such magmas could not be in equilibrium with a lherzolitic mantle source. In all cases clinopyroxene rather than orthopyrox-
37
ene appeared on the liquidus. Bultitude & Green (1971) indicated the improbability that tholeiitic picrite or alkaline picritic magmas are related to olivine and olivine melilite nephelinites by fractionation processes, thus implying that these magmas are primary. Brey & Green (1975, 1976, 1977) and Brey (1976, 1978) conducted a very detailed study of olivine melilitite compositions to investigate the effects of H20:CO2 ratio a n d f O 2 up to 40 kb on the genesis of these magmas. These authors used an olivine melilitite from Laughing Jack Marsh, Tasmania (Mg number, 74; ne, 17.2%; lc, 6.6%), and a synthetic Ca- and Mg-rich olivine melilitite (Mg number, 75; ks, 4.4%). In addition to analyses of the solid phases, the H20 and CO2 contents of the liquids were also determined. Using the Laughing Jack Marsh sample Brey & Green (1975) found no combination of pressure, temperature and percentage H20 conditions under which this olivine melilitite could be in equilibrium with a pyrolite mantle assemblage. In the presence of H20 the solubility of CO2 is high in the olivine melilitite liquid, and it suppresses olivine and clinopyroxene and promotes orthopyroxene and garnet as liquidus or near-liquidus phases. These results, using an external HM buffer assemblage, are summarized in the 30 kb section shown in Fig. 8. With increasing COz (decreasing HzO/(H20 + CO2)) the liquidus temperature rises almost 200~ between 0.5 H20/ !
!
! 1400
? e
\
13oo
0
ox
§
0
9
~ 9
0.'25 0.~5
- 1200
0
0175
C02
38wt7.
T*C
H20 H20 * C02 mole fraction in c h a r g e
1100 H20 20wt7.
Fla. 8. Phase relations in an olivine melilitite showing variations in the liquidus phases at 30 kb and at f O 2 = HM buffer with varying HzO/(HzO + C02). Liquidus and near-liquidus phases are indicated above the liquidus: O ; garnet; +, orthopyroxene; 0, clinopyroxene; o, all liquid. (Modified from Brey & Green 1975.)
38
A.D.
(H20 + CO2) and CO2-only experiments. Based on these results, Brey & Green (1975) inferred that olivine melilitite magmas could be derived at 30kb and 1150-1200~ by less than 5~ equilibrium partial melting of pyrolite containing 0.5-1.0 H20/(H:O+CO2). They suggested low fO2 values (less than the N N O buffer) as most appropriate. Brey & Green (1977) refined the results of their earlier study by systematic investigation of the liquidus and near-liquidus relations with varying H 2 0 / ( H 2 0 + C O 2 ) and f O 2 conditions. The resuits shown in Fig. 9 represent near-liquidus phases at 30 kb andfO2 = HM buffer. Of particular importance is the narrow field of clinopyroxene separating the garnet+orthopyroxene+ clinopyroxene field from the olivine + clinopyroxene field for varying CO2 and H20 contents. Experiments at 27 kb with a composition containing 0.92 H20/(H20 + CO2) closely approached a near-liquidus olivine + orthopyroxene + clinopyroxene+garnet assemblage, compatible with equilibration of the olivine melilitite magma with a pyrolite source. Brey & Green (1977) proposed that the additon of 5% olivine (implying fractionation of a similar amount of olivine from the primary magma) would produce this four-phase assemblage. They also determined that liquidus and near-liquidus assemblages were not appreciably different at more realistic mantlefO2 values corresponding to those less than the N N O buffer assemblage. Based on these results, Brey & Green (1977) proposed that olivine melilitite magmas could be derived at depths corresponding to 27 kb at 1160~ by partial melting of a pvrolite mantle source containing both H20 and CO2 equivalent to 6 - 7 ~ CO2 and 7-8~o H20 dissolved in the melt. Brey (1978) proposed that olivine melilitites which were more SiO2-undersaturated than the ,
/ O~
4Q
O~. /"'f I"j1~
20
Laughing Jack Marsh sample might be derived at greater depths and with higher CO2 in the source region. Experiments at 30-35 kb with higher CO2 contents using a very SiO2-undersaturated synthetic olivine melilitite composition produced olivine+clinopyroxene as liquidus phases. At 30 kb this assemblage is clearly separated from the garnet + orthopyroxene field by an orthopyroxene field. He found that garnet stability increased at lower H20/(H20+CO2) and suggested that highly SiO2-undersaturated olivine melilitites could be derived at deeper levels (corresponding to 35 kb) by partial melting of a more CO2-rich pyrolite source. Although Brey & Green (1975, 1977) and Brey (1978) demonstrated the role of CO2 in addition to H20 for the genesis of olivine melilitite magmas, Eggler (1974, 1978), Huang & Wyllie (1974), Wyllie & Huang (1975, 1976) and Wendlandt & Eggler (1980a, b) proposed that CO2 was an essential component in the source regions for mafic SiO2-undersaturated magmas. Reviews of the experimental evidence for the role of CO2 are given by Eggler & Holloway (1977) and Wyllie (1977, 1979). Eggler (1978) studied joins in the system Na20-CaO-A1203-MgO-SiO2CO2 up to 30 kb and showed that orthopyroxene stability increased relative to that of olivine, thus producing liquids containing less SiO 2 than those formed in the absence of CO2. He suggested that nephelinites and melilite nephelinites could be partial melts of a peridotitic source at 50-90 km provided that CO2 was the predominant volatile component. If the total volatile contents (H20 + CO2) of the mantle source region are greater than 0.5 wt.% all variations between H20-saturated and CO2-saturated melts can occur, whereas with low total vapour concentrations in the source regions the compositions of the vapour a r e restricted and hence solidus temperatures and near-solidus melt compositions are also restricted. As an example of the role the amount of H20 and CO2 plays in the composition of melts. Eggler (1978) proposed that partial melts of an amphibole-peridotite in the presence of both H20 and CO2 (not exceeding 0.37 wt.%) will produce a nephelinitic melt composition at 15 kb.
/"
~i~ 20
Olivine Melilitite
,,
Edgar
Kimberlites "
ga + opx
i 40
ga + opx + cpx C pX ol § c p x ol 60 H20
FIG. 9. Phase relations in the system olivine melilititeH20-CO 2 at 30 kb andfO 2= HM buffer. Abbreviations are as in Fig. 5. (Modified from Brey & Green 1977).
The role of CO2 in the genesis of magmas is particularly relevant to kimberlites and carbonatites. Eggler & Wendlandt (1979) determined phase relations in a kimberlite with variable H20 and CO2 contents at 30 and 55 kb. At the higher pressure they found that kimberlite-like liquids coexisted with a lherzolite assemblage in experiments with 5% H20 and 5% CO2, but kimberlites
Genesis of alkaline magmas
could not be derived from a lherzolite source at the lower pressure. At 30 kb phlogopite and dolomite were sub-solidus phases in experiments with HzO-rich buffered vapour, whereas magnesite solid solution was a sub-solidus mineral at 55 kb. On the basis of phase relationships in the peridotite-COz-H20 system, particularly those determined by Eggler (1978), Wyllie (1977, 1978, 1979) and Ellis & Wyllie (1980), Wyllie (1980) suggested that kimberlite originated by partial melting of peridotitic mantle near 260 km in which solidus temperatures were reduced by upward migration of volatiles. This melting causes a density inversion and results in a diapiric uprise under adiabatic conditions with subsequent crystallization of the partially melted diapiric material beginning at depths of 10080 kin. Leucitites and olivine leucitites With the exception of kimberlites, all the alkali magmas so far described have N a z O > K 2 0 . Mafic-ultramafic rocks with K z O > N a 2 0 are essentially leucitites and olivine leucitites, but with a plethora of varietal names. Most of these rocks fall within the broad category of lamproites (cf. Bergman 1987). They commonly have normative leucite but may be SiO2-saturated to oversaturated and contain normative quartz. Problems involved in the genesis of these often highly LIL-element-rich rocks have been summarized by Bell & Powell (1969). Edgar et al. (1976) have pointed out some of the improbabilities of the older theories given by Bell & Powell. These theories fall into three categories. Firstly, differentiation of basaltic or peridotitic magma with fractionation of olivine (Wade & Prider 1940), eclogite and olivine (Holmes 1932), or eclogite (O'Hara & Yoder 1967). Secondly, assimilation of magmas of such diverse compositions as granite, carbonatite, nephelinite and monchiquite by a wide variety of crustal materials (cf Daly 1910; Bowen 1928; Williams 1936; Holmes & Harwood 1937; Larsen 1940; Holmes 1950, 1965; Turner & Verhoogen 1960). And thirdly, partial melting of biotites and hornblendes (Waters 1955) and kimberlite (Harris, quoted by Bell & Powell 1969). Any hypothesis involving basaltic magma seems unlikely, as in most occurrences of rocks of the leucititic kindred basalts are sparse or absent. Even if basaltic material was involved, very extreme degrees of crustal contamination or assimilation would be required to account for their high incompatibleelement content and to maintain their high MgO and CaO values. The theories involving partial melting of some types of mantle material are now widely accepted by most workers. Recent wide-
39
spread interest in these rocks has been prompted by the possibility of greater heterogeneity in the mantle source regions than previously proposed and by the current popularity of the process of mantle metasomatism (cf Bailey et al. 1980; Bailey 1982). In general, the similarities in high Mg number, low SiO2 content and high volatile contents of olivine leucitites, olivine basanites, olivine melilitites, olivine nephelinites and kimberlites suggest that these magmas are primary rather than derivative and hence can only be evolved from a mantle source containing H20 and CO2. Cundari & O'Hara (1976) conducted dry experiments on a mafic leucitite from New South Wales, Australia (Mg number, 79; lc, 0H; ne, 9.08%). They found clinopyroxene as the only liquidus phase between 20 and 40 kb and olivine at lower pressures. Absence of the assemblage olivine + orthopyroxene+ clinopyroxene _+garnet_+ spinel as near-liquidus assemblages precludes this magma's being derived by partial melting of dry lherzolite. Cundari & O'Hara (1976) concluded that this rock may have formed by partial melting of an olivine pyroxenite source containing essential phlogopite. Absence of normative leucite or quartz in this composition sets it apart from other compositions. Thompson (1977) conducted experiments under similar conditions on an apparently less-primitive leucitite from the Alban Hills, Italy (Mg number, 63; lc, 32.5%; ne 13.6%), with the same results. High-pressure experiments using H20 and H20 + CO2 have been carried out for compositions ranging from potassic intermediate to ultramafic from SW Uganda (Edgar et al. 1976, 1980; Ryabchikov & Green 1978; Arima & Edgar 1983a), from the Leucite Hills, Wyoming (Barton & Hamilton 1979, 1982), and from the W Kimberley area, W Australia (Arima & Edgar 1983b). All these compositions have primitive Mg numbers (70-78) but widely varying degrees of K enrichment (K/(K + Na) mol = 0.41-0.86). In Fig. 10 these rocks are plotted on the Mg2SiO4 (Fo)-KA1SiO~ (Ks)-SiO2 system which indicates the variable degrees of SiO2 saturation. The three compositions from SW Uganda (olivine ugandite, katungite and biotite mafurite) and the madupite from the Leucite Hills are all SiO2 undersaturated, whereas the orendite from the same locality and the wolgidite from W Kimberley are SiO2 saturated and slightly oversaturated respectively. The SiO2-undersaturated group shows distinctly different liquidus to near-liquidus phases from the group which is SiO 2 saturated to oversaturated. The primary phase fields at 3 kb PH2o (Luth 1967) and 28 kb Pmo (Green et al. 1984) in this system are also included in Fig. 10. With
40
A . D. E d g a r Oi
Sil wt.% FIG. 10. K-rich mafic-ultramafic rocks (O), for which experimental data are available, plotted as CIPW normative minerals in the system Mg2SiO4-KA1SiO4-SiO2 together with phase relations at PHzo of 3 and 28 kb (Luth 1967; Green et al. 1984)" HI, phlogopite composition. Abbreviations are as in Figs t, 2 and 3" Hy, hypersthene. Ks
Lc
So
increasing pressure the fields of phlogopite and enstatite expand relative to olivine. Thus partial melting of a mantle source with H20 as the only volatile phase results in liquids which may crystallize these minerals. With H20 as the only volatile phase neither orthopyroxene nor garnet crystallize from any of the SiO2-undersaturated compositions. Thus these magmas cannot have equilibrated with a normal lherzolitic mantle source. Figure 11 is a schematic diagram of near-liquidus phase assemblages for these compositions with H20 contents between 3 and 15 wt.~, representing vapourabsent conditions above about 10 kb. Clinopyroxene___phlogopite are the commonest near-liquidus minerals at high pressures and olivine+ clinopyroxene are the commonest at lower pressures. Based on these near-liquidus phase assemblages, possible source regions for these magmas range from a slightly K-enriched wehrlite for the least K-rich olivine ugandite magma to a phlogopite-rich clinopyroxenite for the highly K-rich mafurite magma (Fig. 11). The appearance of
phlogopite as a near-liquidus assemblage is directly correlated with the degree of K enrichment (Edgar & Arima 1983). Figure 12 shows near-liquidus assemblages for the SiO2-saturated (orendite) and SiO2-oversaturated (wolgidite) compositions in which only H20 has been added. Orthopyroxene is a common near-liquidus mineral for these compositions. In the orendite the near-liquidus assemblage of olivine + orthopyroxene + clinopyroxene + garnet + phlogopite (trace) at 30 kb suggests that this magma could be derived from a phlogopitebearing garnet lherzolite containing small amounts of H20. A phlogopite orthopyroxenite and a phlogopite harzburgite seem the likeliest sources for the wolgidite composition at high and low pressures respectively. The nature of the source materials and the depth of generation depend on the amount of H20 in the source. Ryabchikov & Green (1978) studied the effects of CO2 and H20 at 30kb on the mafurite composition used by Edgar et al. (1976). Figure 13 shows that, with total volatiles equivalent to 5
Genesis of alkaline magmas
40-
Madupite OI-ugandite Katungite Mafurite (Barton 8~ (Edgar e/o/. (Arima 8~ (Edgar elo/. Hamilton 1980) 1980) Edgar 1983a) 1976)
41
OI-ugandite (Edgareta~. 1980)
Katungite Mafurite (Arima & (Edgar et o/. Edgar 1983a) 1976) -140
T
T
35
t
30-
s_HlightlyK-enriched wehrlite (ol+cpx)
K-bearing clinopyroxenite (cpx) a_ 2 5 -
I
3%
-
RI---#-~ h g~ phlog_o_pite clinopyroxenite clinopyroxenite (cpx+phl) (cpx+ phi)
p_hloggRitewehrlite (cpx + ol + phi)
phlogopitewehrlite (cpx +ol+phl)
20-
, ]
P_h I._9_og_opit e___: clin.~_opyroxenite (cpx+phl)
t
120
slightly K-enriched wehrlite (ol+ cpx)
(ol only) p_hl og_op_it_eewehrlite (ol+cpx+phl)
I
~
(ol only)
l
5%
4
H20
p_hlogo!it.__eewehrlite (ol.cpxephl)
I
added
l
p_hl og_opit_.ee wehrlile (cpx + ol + phi) 15%
I00
80
I
60 I
FIG. 11. Schematic diagram showing near-liquidus phases for SiO2-undersaturated K-rich magmas in which H20 is the only added volatile. The underlined rock names are approximately equivalent to the near-liquidus assemblages in brackets. wt.% H20 , olivine+clinopyroxene are liquidus phases at CO2/(CO 2 Jr H 2 0 ) mol < 0.50, whereas orthopyroxene stability increases above this value. For CO2/(CO2 + H20) mol between 0 and 0.50 phlogopite is stable but clinopyroxene rapidly becomes unstable at higher ratios. For CO2/(CO2+H20 ) equivalent to 15 wt.% H20 , phlogopite and clinopyroxene stability decrease at low ratios, with orthopyroxene as the liquidus phase over most of the range of CO2/(C0 2 Jr H20) values. These relations and the absence of garnet suggest that a lherzolitic source may be possible for this highly K-rich composition. Figure 14 is a schematic diagram of three SiO 2undersaturated SW Ugandan lavas at CO2/ (CO2+H20) mo1=0.75 (equivalent to 15 wt.% H20 added). Only the low-K ugandite with orthopyroxene + clinopyroxene_+ garnet 4- spinel as near-liquidus phases from 22 to 40 kb can be derived from a lherzolitic source under these conditions. The katungite liquidus relationships suggest a garnet clinopyroxenite or a clinopyroxenite as the likeliest source compositions. Although phlogopite does not occur in these highCO2 experiments, the source regions must be K enriched in order to produce the K enrichment in the magmas provided that these are direct mantle melts. No experiments with high CO2 have been carried out on the SiO2-saturated to SiO 2oversaturated orendite or wolgidite.
Wendlandt & Eggler (1980a, b) modelled the genesis of potassic magmas based on melting relations in the systems KAISiO4-Mg2SiO4SiO2, KA1SiO~-MgO-SiO2-CO2 and KA1SiO4MgO-SiO2-H20-CO2 as simple mantle sources at pressures up to 50 kb. In these systems they were able to determine a large number of reactions producing a wide variety of possible liquids ranging from simplified tholeiites to carbonatites. On the basis of previous studies they suggested that the absence of Ca (as CaMgSi206) and Na (as NaA!SiO4 and NaA1Si3Os) would not appreciably alter their conclusions. The expansion of the primary phase fields of enstatite and sanidine in the KA1SiO~-Mg2SiO,~SiO2 system with increasing pressure is illustrated by the schematic diagrams given by Wendlandt & Eggler (1980a, Fig. 6). This results in liquids becoming progressively enriched in K20 and depleted in SiO2 at pressures ranging from 5 kb to greater than 30 kb. In the KA1SiO4-MgOSIO2-CO2 system, phase relations are similar but occur at lower pressures than in the CO2-free system. The trends of liquids with increasing pressure are schematically shown in Fig. 15 which is based on the variation in the extent of the primary solid phase fields with pressure in the systems KA1SiO4-MgO-SiO2-CO2 and KA1SiO4-Mg2SiO4-SiO 2 (Wendlandt & Eggler 1980a). The approximate pressures at which the
A. D. Edgar
42 Orendite {Barton 8 Hamilton 1982)
Wolgidite (Arima 8 Edgar !983b)
40 -f
-140
35
120 ph Iogopite
orthopyroxenite (opx+phl)
p_h I__qgo_pite ?garnet- Iherzolite {ol+opx+cpx+gt+ph)
30
Io0 T s s
25
ph I__0_ogo_pit3 orthgpy_roxenite (opx+phl)
p hl_#_ogop~t__e harzbuEgit__e (oi+ opx + phl)
K3
H. p_ ogoplte harzburqit._ee (opx +ol + phi)
80
20
(ol Only) I te p.hi ogopj harzburglte (o1+ opx+ phi) 5%
1'2%
60 15%
H20 added FIG. 12. Schematic diagram showing near-liquidus phases for SiO2-saturated and SiO2-oversaturated K-rich magmas in which H20 is the only added volatile. The underlined rock names are approximately equivalent to the near-liquidus assemblages in brackets. 1400
m
L
Iq
o
1400 1 30 kb (equiv to 15 wt% H20)
.+v/
J+FTa 1300
,,'
(bq~//
1300 -
,,
r
OI
,p
/
-....--
/ /
L O
/
~ ~ +
Xtols
/ /
1200
_
/
1200
-
,., C~4\\
-
L+Xtals
-% \\ \ \ \,o. \ \ \-o \%
30 kb {equiv. to 5 wf% H20) I100 H20 5 wt~
I
0.25
I
0-5
I
0.75
C02/(C%+ H20} mole fraction in charge
CO2 12.2 wt~
I100 H20 15 w1%
I
0.25
\
I
0"5
I
0.75
C02/(C02-1- H20) mole fraction in charge
C% 36.7 wt%
F]G. 13. Phase relations in the biotite mafurite system with varying C02/(H20 --kC O 2 ) contents equivalent to 5 and 15 wt.% H20 at 30 kb. Abbreviations are as in Figs 2-4. (Modified from Ryabchikov & Green 1978.)
Genesis of alkaline magmas Katungite (Arima a Edgar 1983a)
OI-ugandite (Edgar et 0/ 1980
40
t
:55 -
Mafurite (Ryabchikova Green 1978)
I
garnetIherzolite ? (cpx + opx + ga)
43
i
' ' garnet' clinopyroxenite (cpx + ga)
-
140
'
120
,r
E
v (D
50
Iherzolite (cpx + opx + ol)
clinopyroxenite (cpx)
r
ioo
d3
13._
25
_
garnet or spinel Iherzolite (opx + cpx + ol + ga + sp) 80
wehrlite (ol +cpx)
20 COz H201
27.4 3-5
27.5 3.8 % CO2 and H20 added
27.5 5"8
FIG. 14. Schematic diagram showing near-liquidus phases for SiO2-undersaturated K-rich magmas with CO2/(CO2 + H20) mol = 0.75 (equivalent to 15 wt.% HzO). The underlined rock names are approximately equivalent to the near-liquidus assemblages in brackets.
Mag Pressure (kb) of appearance of liquids Vol absent 19 34-5 --
CO2 satd. 14 27.5 > 29
Liquids Lc normative Ks normative Mag normative Carbonatitic
/
/
/
/
~.// 7
/
7
// "
~
/
/
/ 9
/
/
/~hl
/
Olivine tholeiitic
~/
/
/
/ //
/ /
/
/
Quartz.. tholeiitic
\
/
7
/.. Ks
/ Lc [ Sa (Ks normative] Alkali basaltic / Lc normative}
Qz
FIG. 15. Trends of liquids with increasing pressure in the systems KAISiO4-MgzSiO4-SiO2 and KA1SiO,-MgOSIO2-H20-CO2 (modified from Wendlandt & Eggler 1980a). Abbreviations are as in Figs 1 and 3 ; Mag, normative magnesite. The inset shows the normative nature of liquids at increasing pressures (as indicated by the line on the diagram) under volatile-free and CO2-saturated conditions.
44
A. D. Edgar
compositions of the residual liquids on partial melting become leucite, kalsilite and magnesite normative are shown in the inset to Fig. 15. At approximately 14 kb for CO2-saturated conditions and 19 kb for volatile-free conditions, liquids in equilibrium with sanidine, enstatite and forsterite are leucite normative and change from tholeiitic to alkali basaltic with increasing pressure. At greater than 27.5 kb under CO2saturated conditions and greater than 34.5 kb in the volatile-free system, sanidine is no longer stable and melts become extremely K20 rich and SiOz poor, yielding kalsilite-normative liquids. At pressures above 29 kb in the KA1SiO4-MgOSIO2-CO2 system melts are actually magnesite normative. Based on these results Wendlandt & Eggler (1980a) concluded that quartz tholeiitic liquids cannot fractionate to alkali basaltic ones. Liquids generated at high pressures with some fractionation could result in increasingly SiO2poor residual liquids. In contrast, fractionation at lower pressures could result in SiO2 enrichment. Wendlandt & Eggler's (1980a) experiments have been used by Kuehner et al. (1981) to model the Leucite Hills, Wyoming, magmas which show this trend of SiO2 enrichment. Although it is theoretically possible that leucite-normative rocks could be products of fractionation rather than direct partial melting, Wendlandt & Eggler (1980a) consider this to be unlikely. Using the KA1SiO4-MgO-SiO2-CO2-H20 system in which phlogopite is an additional phase, Wendlandt & Eggler (1980b) modelled the melting behaviour of phlogopite peridotite and its role in the genesis of K-rich magmas, kimberlites and carbonatites. Peridotite with small amounts of H20 + CO2 undergoes univariant melting in which H20 and CO2 vapour compositions are buffered by phlogopite and magnesite respectively. Such buffering is pressure dependent and hence the compositions of liquids produced by various reactions depend on the pressure of melting. With increasing pressure up to 30 kb, melting of a phlogopite peridotite with insufficient CO2 and H20 to hydrate all the potential phlogopite involves four reactions between combinations of phlogopite, enstatite, sanidine (or kalsilite), forsterite, liquid and vapour. As the pressure increases up to 30 kb the liquids change in composition progressively from quartz to enstatite to leucite to kalsilite normative. These relations are comparable with those for the KA1SiO4-Mg2SiO4-SiO2 system (Wendlandt & Eggler 1980a). Above 30 kb magnesite becomes stable and melting occurs by two reactions involving combinations of phlogopite, enstatite, magnesite, forsterite, kalsilite, liquid and vapour. The liquids produced are carbonatitic. With
increasing pressure phlogopite has decreased hypersolidus stability and at 50 kb ceases to be a solidus phase. Thus between 30 and 50kb, melting of phlogopite peridotite will produce increasingly K20-rich SiO2-poor liquids.
Mantle metasomatism Experimental studies and other data indicate that as the alkalinity of mafic to ultramafic magmas increases there is a decreasing possibility that these magmas are partial melts of a 'normal' pyrolitic model mantle composition. Although there are a number of mechanisms whereby local heterogeneities can occur in the mantle source, the concept of heterogeneities being caused by mantle metasomatism (cf. Lloyd & Bailey 1975; Bailey 1982) is now widely accepted. Experimental modelling of metasomatic processes is extremely difficult, particularly at mantle depths where very little is known of either the composition or the speciation of the fluids involved. Among the many elements considered to be responsible for metasomatism (Bailey 1982), K and Na are very important. Ryabchikov & Boettcher (1980) showed that the solubility of potassium (as K/O) in aqueous fluids increased about sixfold between 11 and 30 kb in the range 1050-1100~ Their values, ranging from 4 to 25 g K20 per 100 g H20, indicated that the solubility of K:O is sufficiently high to produce radical changes in the mantle. Ryabchikov et al. (1982) determined that the amount of sodium silicate leached by hydrous fluids at constant temperature from omphacitic pyroxenes increases with decreasing pressure. On the basis of both sets of experiments, Ryabchikov et al. (1982) proposed that K/Na fractionation in the upper mantle might produce K-rich metasomatism at deeper levels and Na-rich metasomatism at shallower levels which, on partial melting, would result in K-rich magmas generated at greater depths than Na-rich magmas. Edgar & Arima (1984; unpublished data) have carried out preliminary metasomatism-modelling experiments involving the system pyroliteK2Oaqueou s and pyrolite-(K20+Na20)aq ..... at 2 0 - 3 0 kb and between 850 and 950~ In these experiments K20 , as dried K2CO3, was dissolved in deionized H20. Na20 was added as Na2CO 3. This resulted in an aqueous solution containing negligible amounts of dissolved CO2. Figure 16(a) shows that at 30 kb an increased concentration of K20 in solution produces an initial increase in the proportions of phlogopite relative to orthopyroxene, clinopyroxene and olivine. Although
Genesis of alkaline magmas not in sufficient quantity to be observed in the Xray diffraction patterns (Fig. 16) garnet (at 30 kb) and spinel (at 20 kb) decrease with increasing K20 as observed optically. At about 3.8 g K20 per 10 g of solution, liquid appears at both 850 and 950~ indicating a decrease in the amount of phlogopite with K partitioning preferentially into the liquid. These results are in accordance with those of Takahashi & Kushiro (1983). Edgar & Arima (1984) were unable to analyse their run products using the electron microprobe because of the fine grain size, but they speculated that at 30 kb the formation of phlogopite involved a reaction between olivine, orthopyroxene and garnet in the approximate proportions ofpyrolitetype mantle at 30 kb (Wyllie 1975) with the K20 in solution to produce a product with less garnet and olivine and more orthopyroxene. Clinopyroxene is probably not involved in the formation of phlogopite. These results are in accordance with the observed decrease in the olivine/orthopyroxene and olivine/clinopyroxene intensities (Fig. 16(a)). In contrast with the results at 30 kb, at 20 kb an amphibole of pargasitic composition as analysed by microprobe shows an inverse relationship to phlogopite which remains the dominant 'metasomatic' product (Fig. 16(b)). On the basis of the relative proportions of phlogopite to the other mineral phases (Fig. 16(b)) and the ratios of olivine to orthopyroxene, olivine to clinopyroxene and orthopyroxene to clinopyroxene (Fig. 16(c)), the formation of phlogopite at 20 kb and at K20 concentrations where amphibole is no longer present (more than 2.0 g K20 per 10 g of solution) may involve a complex reaction between olivine, orthopyroxene, clinopyroxene, amphibole and spinel, together with K20 in solution, to form a product containing a higher amount of olivine and clinopyroxene and lower amounts of orthopyroxene relative to the reactants. A few preliminary experiments at 20 kb and 950~ in which both Na and K have been added in various proportions equivalent to 3.8 g total alkali per 10 g of solution show that, with increasing Na relative to K, the field of amphibole stability increases as phlogopite decreases. Although vastly simplified, these experiments indicate that alkali metasomatism can readily occur. Nodules with mantle mineralogy found in alkali basalts, kimberlites and related rocks often contain phlogopite and amphibole and range in overall composition from lherzolite to pyroxenite. Lloyd & Bailey (1975) and Lloyd (1981) studied nodules mainly of phlogopite clinopyroxenite composition from the K-rich volcanic province of SW Uganda and proposed that they might represent metasomatized mantle sources for these
45
lavas. Alternatively these nodules could be depleted residual source materials. Lloyd et al. (1985) determined the compositions of liquids produced from varying degrees of partial melting at 20 and 30 kb of an average nodule with no added volatiles (based on analyses of 84 nodules from this area). Figure 17 shows the compositions of liquids produced by various degrees of partial melting at 30 kb together with the coexisting minerals. At approximately 25% partial melting of this nodule, the liquid corresponds closely with that of an average katungite composition found in SW Uganda. Although this is a higher degree of partial melting than generally considered likely for the production of such K-rich magmas, it seems feasible in the light of the upwarped mantle isotherms, postulated in rifted areas such as SW Uganda (Bailey 1970), caused by mantle degassing (Bailey 1980), and in view of the high proportion of radioactive elements associated with these magmas.
Felsic alkaline rocks Although experiments pertinent to felsic alkaline rocks have been less numerous than those carried out on mafic varieties in the past decade, studies have been undertaken on liquid immiscibility, on the role of C1, F and P20 5 in alkaline magmas and on the problems of the genesis of pseudoleucites and primary analcites.
Liquid immiscibility Roedder (1979) reviewed the role of experimental work on the concept of liquid immiscibility as a viable process in the genesis of igneous rocks. Only studies applicable to alkaline rocks are considered here, most of which concern silicatecarbonatitic magmas. Freestone (1978) showed that the liquid immiscibility field in the fayalite-leucite-silica system was extended to more K-rich compositions by the addition of 1 mol ~ P205 and 3 mol ~ TiO2. He suggested that this expansion supports the liquidunmixing origin suggested by ocelli textures in syenites and sheets within alkali gabbro intrusions. The role of liquid immiscibility on the genesis of carbonatites was considered by Hamilton et al. (1979) and Freestone & Hamilton (1980). These workers used lavas ranging in composition from felsic nephelinites to phonolites comparable in composition with those in the Oldoinyo Lengai volcano, Tanzania. These were mixed with synthetic Na- and Ca-rich carbonatites. Experiments at 0.7-7.6 kb and 900-1250~ showed that
46
A. D. Edgar 8
_- q~p
/
6
"~ ~
o
o=~=I=ua 2 0
-
@
o
k
,~ ~
~ H
o
1.5~ I'0
o
u H
4
\ Iamph 2
o
oI
0
1"5~~I'0
9
-~---I
H
0.5 8
4
q,t-fl~p
4
6 n
"~
3 2 I
0
v
I'0
2.0
3-0
4-0
I
~
6.0
5.0
1
i0
2. 0
50
l
4-0
g K20/IO g sOIn.
g K 2 0 / I O g soln.
(a)
(b)
I 5.0
I 6,0
3-0 -
2o' I.O
o
u
-6
1.5
0"5
2"0 I-0 I ~ - -
0
a-
1
I-O
o
@ I
2.0
I
3.0
I
4-0
g K20/IO g soln. (C)
I
5-0
I
6-0
FIG. 16. Results of experiments in the pyrolite-K20 aqueous solution system plotted as ratios of X-ray diffraction intensities (I) of minerals against K 20 concentrations: (a) runs at 30 kb, 850~ ( 0 ) , and at 30 kb, 950~ (O); (b) runs at 20 kb, 950~ showing variations in the ratios of phlogopite and amphibole relative to other minerals; (c) runs at 20 kb, 950~ showing variations in the ratios of olivine, orthopyroxene and clinopyroxene. Abbreviations are as in Figs 2 and 3 ; q, quench phlogopite; p, primary phlogopite. (After Edgar & Arima 1984.)
Genesis of alkaline magmas
~_ApI
(not used in Freestone & Hamilton's experiments) liquid immiscibility could account for the carbonate-rich groundmass in kimberlites and the latestage associated carbonatite dykes and diapirs.
Phi C p x ~
Im. . . .
37
Halogen-bearing
I0
~
8-
u
/
-
e
-
systems
Hards (1976) determined the distribution of certain elements between the melt and vapour phases in granite and nepheline syenite compositions at 1 kb between 680 and 850~ in the presence of C1 and F. He found that C1 was more strongly concentrated in the vapour phase in granitic melts than it was in nepheline syenite melts, whereas F was concentrated preferentially in the liquid phase for both compositions and only entered the vapour phase after crystallization
O
~
6-
NazO
0 ~- ~ 9
e
O~
xcr..-"
if
0
47
J
w,o,o
II
L
I
i
I
~
I
20 40 60 80 Degree of melting (wt.%)
i
I
I00
FIG. 17. Compositions of liquids with varying degrees of partial melting of an average clinopyroxenite nodule from SW Uganda at 30 kb : - - , determined compositions; - - - , calculated compositions based on analyses of minerals. The phases present are given at the top of the figure. Cpx, clinopyroxene: Phi, phlogopite: Ilm, ilmenite: Ap, apatite. (After Lloyd et al. 1985)
Si% + AiaO3
CaO (a)
Na20
the miscibility gap expands with increasing Pco2 and decreasing temperature (Fig. 18). Results at 0.7 kb and l l00~ are plotted on the N a 2 0 (SiO2+AlzO3)-CaO system (Fig. 18(a)). Under the miscibility gap inincreasing P t o t a l = P c o 2 , creases and there is a rotation of tie-lines resulting in more CaO-rich liquids (Fig. 18(b)). From the compositions of the melts, Freestone & Hamilton (1980) concluded that the natrocarbonatites from Oldoinyo Lengai separated from a phonolitic rather than a nephelinitic magma. Because the miscibility gap closes away from the Na20-rich compositions (Fig. 18), exsolution of a carbonatitic melt is more likely in salic than in mafic silicate magmas. Freestone & Hamilton's (1980) results do not support the idea that kimberlite sills and dykes form by an immiscibility process at crustal pressures. Bedson & Hamilton (1981), however, showed that in the presence of H 2 0
SiOa + Ala03
CaO
(b) FIG. 18. Liquid immiscibility in the system NazOCaO-(A1203 + SiO2) at (a) 0.7 kb and 1100~ and (b) 1100~ and varying pressures Pc% = Ptotal. (After Freestone & Hamilton 1980.)
A. D. E d g a r
48
was completed. Sodium was the most common element in the vapour phase of both compositions. These experiments may explain the presence of Cl-bearing sodalite in SiO2-undersaturated rocks but the absence of Cl-bearing minerals from granitic rocks. On the basis of Hard's experiments the presence of F-bearing minerals in both types of rocks is to be expected. On the basis of experiments at 1 kb in the system NaA1SiO4 (Ne)-SiO2-NaC1-H20, Barker (1976) found that in the SiO2-undersaturated portion of the system NaC1 stabilized sodalite whereas in the SiO2-oversaturated part it has no effect on phase relations because of immiscibility between NaCl-rich liquid and SiO2 melt. These results suggest that the high C1 content of feldspathoidal rocks is not a cause of their SiO 2 undersaturation and that such rocks are unlikely to be produced by anatexis or assimilation of halite-bearing sediments (Appleyard 1974; Ayrton 1974). For the SiO2-undersaturated part of the same system, Binsted (1981) showed that sodalite might exist as a primary mineral between about 25% and 60% Ne in the pseudobinary ( A b + Ne)gs(NaC1)5 join (Binsted 1981, Fig. 13). He found that melts crystallizing sodalite follow a non-linear trend (Binsted 1981, Fig. 14) owing to partial replenishment of NaCI in the melt from the fluid reservoir. With increasing NaC1, nepheline will crystallize as the second phase following albite. These relationships may be important in the genesis of agpaitic rocks such as the lujavrites in Ilimaussaq, Greenland, where sodalite is a primary mineral.
sial for many years. Taylor & Mackenzie (1975) studied differences in leucite morphologies with different cooling methods at 2 kb Pnz o in the system NaA1SiO4-KAISiO4-SiOz-H20. As shown in Fig. 19 the compositions of the leucites produced appeared to depend on their morphologies. From the common occurrence of natural pseudoleucites along the leucite-analcite join, Taylor & MacKenzie (1975) suggested that metastable Na-rich leucites are produced by extremely rapid alkali-ion exchange rather than by the breakdown of high-temperature leucites or by leucite breaking down to nepheline+ feldspar at the reaction point in this system.
Primary versus secondary origin of analcites Experimental studies bearing on the problem of the origin of analcite phenocrysts in a few rare volcanic rocks have been carried out by Roux & Hamilton (1976) in the system NaA1SiO4KA1SiO4-SiO2. They found that analcite coexisted with liquid above about 5 kb PH2o and 600~ supporting the concept of primary analcites. In contrast, Gupta & Fyfe (1975) found a very rapid reaction between leucite and saturated NaCI solutions at 1 kb Pn2 o at low temperatures. This supported the idea that these natural analcite phenocrysts could be transformed from leucites in a low-temperature hydrothermal environment. The plausibility of both of these mechanisms occurring in nature has been discussed by Edgar (1984).
Other experiments on felsic alkaline rocks Pseudoleucites The origin of pseudoleucites has been controver-
Dolfi et al. (1978) and Ruddock & Hamilton (1978) investigated the KA1Si206 (Lc)-
Zoned
c Ne
"x,~~Ks Greatly exsolved
leucite
Slightly ( I11r-='_lib IIIII
exsolved I--'l
leucite
~
FIG. 19. Recalculated microprobe analyses and morphologies of leucites crystallized from a bulk composition (+) crystallized in part of the system NaA1SiO4-KA1SiO4-SiO2-H20. Lines join spots probed on leucite crystals to compositions in the system. (After Taylor & Mackenzie 1975.)
Genesis of alkaline magmas CaMgSi20 6 (Di) and KA1Si206-CaMgSi20 6S i O 2 - H 2 0 - C O 2 systems respectively. In the former system, Dolfi et al. showed that increasing pressure up to 12 kb increased the primary diopside field at the expense of leucite. In experiments at 4 kb in the system KA1Si20 6CaMgSizO6-H20, Ruddock & Hamilton (1978, Fig. 19) indicated that with increasing pressure the fields of leucite and quartz contract while those of diopside and sanidine expand. Phlogopite is restricted to compositions with low diopside contents. On the basis of these results they explain the common phenocryst assemblage of diopside and phlogopite along with groundmass quartz and potash feldspar in many lamprophyres. High-pressure experiments up to 30 kb on the composition Lc60DisQ35 with H 2 0 and CO2 (Ruddock & Hamilton 1978, Fig. 19) confirmed these conclusions. These experiments also suggested that minettes are derived by partial melting of the mantle and that primary carbonate minerals in these rocks could have formed at mantle pressures. In order to determine the effect of CaA12Si2Os
49
(An) on phase relations in the system NaA1SiO4KA1SiO4-SiOz-H20, Norris & MacKenzie (1976) and Whiteley (1981) have determined phase relations at 1 kb PH20 with 3, 5 and 10 wt.% CaA12SizOs. With increasing An contents, the leucite and alkali feldspar fields are reduced as the plagioclase field expands. For the 3% An plane, Norris & MacKenzie (1976, Fig. 30) located a eutectic between nepheline, K-rich feldspar and Na-rich feldspar. For the 5% and 10% An planes (Norris & MacKenzie 1976, Figs 31 and 32) the projected phase volumes of Kfeldspar and Na-feldspar cut the leucite phase volume at progressively more K-rich compositions as the K-rich feldspar field contracts. In the absence of a Ca-bearing mafic mineral, such as diopside, these systems more closely approximate felsic magmas.
ACKNOWLEDGMENTS: I am grateful to M. Arima and A. Kolisnik for their assistance in the preparation of the diagrams for this paper. The Natural Science and Engineering Research Council of Canada provided financial support.
References ALLEN,J. C., BOETTCHER,A. L. & MARLAND,G. 1975. Amphiboles in andesite and basalt: I. Stability as a function of P - T - f 0 2 . Am. Mineral. 60, 1069-85. APPLEYARD,E. C. 1974. Syn-orogenic igneous alkaline rocks of eastern Ontario and northern Norway. Lithos, 7, 147-60. ARCULUS, R. J. 1975. Melting behaviour of two basanites in the range 10-35 kbar and the effect of TiO 2 on the olivine-diopside reactions at high pressures. Yearb. Carnegie Inst. Washington, 512-15. ARIMA, M. & EDGAR, A. D. 1983a. High-pressure experimental studies on a katungite and their bearing on the genesis of some potassium-rich magmas of the west branch of the African rift. J. Petrol. 24, 166-87. & - - 1983b. A high pressure experimental study of a magnesian-rich leucite-lamproite from the West Kimberley area, Australia: petrogenetic implications. Contrib. Mineral. Petrol. 84, 228-34. AYRTON, R. 1974. Rifts, evaporites and the origin of certain alkaline rocks. Geol. Rundsch. 63, 430-50. BAILEY, D. K. 1970. Volatile flux, heat focussing and the generation of magma. Geol. J. Spec. Issue 2, 177-86. 1974. Experimental petrology relating to oversaturated peralkaline volcanics, a review. Bull. Volcanol. 38, 637-52. Applications of experiments to alkaline rocks. In: BAILEY,D. K. & MACDONALD,R. (eds) The Evolution of the Crystalline Rocks, pp. 419-69. Academic Press, New York. 1980. Volatile flux, geotherms, and the generation 74,
-
-
-
-
- - 1 9 7 6 .
-
-
of the kimberlite-carbonatite-alkaline magma spectrum. Mineral. Mag. 43, 695-9. - 1982. Mantle metasomatism--continuing chemical change within the earth. Nature, Lond. 296, 525-30. --,TARNEY, J. & DUNHAM, K. C. (eds) 1980. Evidence for chemical heterogeneity in the earth's mantle. Phil Trans. R. Soc. Lond. Ser. A, 297, 134493. BARKER, D. S. 1976. Phase relations in the system NaA1SiO4-SiO2-NaC1-H20 at 400-800~ and 1 kilobar, and petrologic implications. J. Geol. 84, 77-106. - - 1983. Igneous Rocks, 417 pp. Prentice-Hall, Englewood Cliffs, NJ. BARTON, M. & HAMILTON,D. L. 1979. The melting relationships of a madupite from the Leucite Hills, Wyoming, to 30 kb. Contrib. Mineral. Petrol. 69, 133-42. & - - 1 9 8 2 . Water undersaturated melting experiments bearing upon the origin of potassiumrich magmas. Mineral. Mag. 45, 267-78. BASALTIC VOLCANISMSTUDY PROJECT, 1981. Basaltic Volcanism on the Terrestrial Planets, 1286 pp. Pergamon Press, Oxford. BEDSON, P & HAMILTON, n. L. 1981. Kimberlites, carbonatites and liquid immiscibility. Prog. Exp. Petrol., NERC Publ. Set. D, 29-32. BELL, K. & POWELL, J. L. 1969. Strontium isotopic studies of the Burunga and Toro-Ankole regions, east and central equatorial Africa. J. Petrol. 10, 536-72. BERGMAN,S. C. 1987. Lamproites and other potassium-
5o
A. D. Edgar
rich igneous rocks: a review of their occurrence, mineralogy and geochemistry. In: FITTON, G. J. & UPTON, B. G. J. (eds) Alkaline Igneous Rocks, Geol. Soc. Spec. Publ. 30, pp. 103-90. BINSTED, N. 1981. The system Ab-Ne-NaC1-HzO. Prog. Exp. Petrol., NERC Publ. Ser. D, 34-35. BOWEN, N. L. 1922. The reaction principle in petrogenesis. J. Geol. 30, 177-98. --1928. Evolution of the Igneous Rocks, 251 pp. Dover, New York. BREY, G. 1976. CO2 solubility and solubility mechanisms in silicate melts at high pressures. Contrib. Mineral. Petrol. 57, 217-21. 1978. Origin of olivine melilitites--chemical and experimental constraints. J. Volcanol. geotherm. Res. 3, 61-88. & GREEN, D. H. 1975. The role of CO2 in the genesis of olivine melilitite. Contrib. Mineral. Petrol. 49, 93-103. & -1976. Solubility of COz in olivine melilitite at high pressures and the role of CO2 in the earth's upper mantle. Contrib. Mineral. Petrol. 55, 217-30. & -1977. Systematic study of liquidus phase relations in olivine melilitite + H20 + CO 2 at high pressures and petrogenesis of an olivine melilitite magma. Contrib. Mineral. Petrol. 61,141-62. BULTITUDE, R. J. & GREEN, D. H. 1968. Experimental study at high pressures on the origin of olivine nephelinite and olivine melilite nephelinite magmas. Earth planet. Sci. Lett. 3, 325-37. & -1971. Experimental study of crystal-liquid relationships at high pressures in olivine nephelinite and basanite compositions. J. Petrol. 12, 12147. CAWTI-IORN, R. G. 1976. Melting relations in part of the system CaO-MgO-A1203-SiO2-Na20-H20 under 5 kb pressure. J. Petrol. 17, 44-72. CUNDARI, A. & O'HARA, M. J. 1976. Experimental study at atmospheric and high pressures of a mafic leucitite from New South Wales, Australia. Prog. Exp. Petrol., N.E.R.C. Publ. Ser. D, 260-2. DALY, R. A. 1910. Origin of the alkaline rocks. Geol. Soc. Am. Bull. 21, 87-115. DOLFI, O., HAMILTON,D. H. & TREGILA, R. 1978. The system KA1Si206-CaMgSi206 at 4 and 12 kilobars. Prog. Exp. Petrol., NERC Publ. Ser. D, 21-2. DUKE, J. M. 1974. The effect of oxidation on the crystallization of an alkali basalt from the Azores. J. Geol. 82, 524-8. EDGAR, A. D. 1974. Experimental studies. In: SORENSEN, H. (ed.) The Alkaline Rocks, pp. 355-89. Wiley, New York. 1979. Mineral chemistry and petrogenesi: of an ultrapotassic-ultramafic volcanic rock. Contrib. Mineral. Petrol. 71, 171-5. 1984. Chemistry, occurrence and paragenesis of feldspathoids: a review. In: BROWN, W. L. (ed.) Feldspars and Feldspathoids, pp. 501-32. Reidel, Dordrecht. & ARIMA, M. 1983. Conditions of phlogopite crystallization in ultrapotassic volcanic rocks. Mineral. Mag. 47, 11-19. -& -1984. Experimental studies on K-metasomatism of a model pyrolite mantle and their -
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
bearing on the genesis of ultrapotassic magmas. Proc. 27th Int. Geological Cong. on Petrology (Igneous and Metamorphic Rocks), Vol. 9, 509-41. V N U Science Press, Utrecht. CONDLIFFE,E., BARNETT,R. L. & SHIRRAN, R. J. 1980. An experimental study of an olivine ugandite magma and mechanisms for the formation of its K-enriched derivatives. J. Petrol. 21,475-97. - - , GREEN, D. H. & HIBBERSON, W. O. 1976. Experimental petrology of a highly potassic magma. J. Petrol. 17, 339-56. EGGLER, D. H. 1974. Effects of CO2 on the melting of peridotite. Yearb. Carnegie Inst. Washington, 73, 215-24. 1978. The effect of CO2 upon partial melting of peridotite in the system Na20-CaO-A1203-MgOSIO2-CO2 to 35 kb, with an analysis of melting in a peridotite-H20-CO2 system. Am. J. Sci. 278, 305-43. --& HOLLOWAY, J. R. 1977. Partial melting of peridotite in the presence of H20 and CO2: principles and review. Oreg. Dep. Geol. mineral Industries Bull. 96, 15-36. • WENDLANDT, R. F. 1979. Experimental studies of the relationship between kimberlite magmas and partial melting of peridotite. In: BOYD, F. R. & MEYER, H. O. A. (eds) Kimberlites, Diatremes and Diamonds: Their Geology, Petrology and Geochemistry, pp. 330-8. American Geophysical Union, Washington, DC. EL-GORESY, A. & YODER, H. S. 1974. Natural and synthetic melilite compositions. Yearb. Carnegie Inst. Washington, 73, 359-71. ELLIS, D. E. & WYLLIE, P. J. 1980. Phase relations and their petrological implications in the system MgOSIO2-H20-CO2 at pressures up to 100 kbar. Am. Mineral. 65, 540-56. FREESTONE, I. C. 1978. Liquid immiscibility in alkalirich magmas. Chem. Geol. 23, 115-23. --& HAMILTON, D. L. 1980. The role of liquid immisciblity in the genesis of carbonatites--an experimental study. Contrib. Mineral. Petrol. 73, 105-17. FREY, F. A., GREEN, D. H. & ROY, S. D. 1978. Integrated models of basalt petrogenesis: a study of quartz tholeiites to olivine melilitites from southeastern Australia utilizing geochemical and experimental petrological data. J. Petrol. 19, 463-513. GREEN, D. H. 1969, The origin of basaltic and nephelinitic magmas in the earth's mantle. Tectonophysics, 7, 409-22. 1970a. A review of experimental evidence on the origin of basaltic and nephelinitic magmas. Phys. Earth planet. Inter. 3, 221-35. The origin of basaltic and nephelinitic magmas. Trans. Leicester Lit. Phil. Soc. 44, 26-54. 1971. Composition of basaltic magmas as indicators of conditions of origin: applications to oceanic volcanism. Phil. Trans. R. Soc. Lond. Ser. A, 268, 707-25. 1973a. Conditions of melting of basanite magma from garnet peridotite. Earth planet. Sci. Lett. 17, 456-65. Experimental melting studies on model -
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
1
9
7
0
b
.
1
9
7
3
b
.
Genesis of alkaline magmas upper mantle compositions at high pressure under both water-saturated and water-undersaturated conditions. Earth planet. Sci. Lett. 19, 37-53. - - , GUPTA, A. K. & TAYLOR, W. R. 1984. Experimental studies on the effects of H20 and CO2 on liquidus relations in Fo-Ks-SiO2 and F o - N e SiO2 at 28 kb. Abstracts, Workshop on Experimental Geochemistry, Monash University, Melbourne. HmBERSON, W. O. 1970. Experimental duplication of conditions of precipitation of high pressure phenocrysts in a basaltic magma. Phys. Earth planet. Inter. 3, 247-54. & RINGWOOD, A. E. 1967. The genesis of basaltic magmas. Contrib. Mineral. Petrol. 15, 103-90. GUPTA, A. K. & FYFE, W. S. 1975. Leucite survival: the alteration to analcime. Can. Mineral. 13, 3613. HAMILTON, D. L., FREESTONE, I. C., DAWSON, J. B. & DONALDSON, O. H. 1979. Origin of carbonatites by liquid immiscibility. Nature, Lond. 279, 52-4. HARDS, N. 1976. Distribution of elements between the fluid phase and silicate melt phase of granites and nepheline syenites. Prog. Exp. Petrol., NERC Publ. Ser. D, 88-90. HELZ, R. T. 1973. Phase relations of basalts in their melting range at PH2o=5 kb as a function of oxygen fugacity. Part I. Mafic phases. J. Petrol. 14, 249-302. 1976. Phase relations of basalts in their melting ranges at PH2o = 5 kb. Part II. Melt compositions. J. Petrol. 17, 139-93. HOLMES, A. 1932. The origin of igneous rocks. Geol. Mag. 69, 543-58. 1950. Petrogenesis of katungite and its associates. Am. Mineral. 35, 772-92. -1965. Principles of Physical Geology (2nd edn), 623 pp. Ronald Press, New York. --& HARWOOD, F. 1937. The petrology of the volcanic rocks of Bufumbira. Mere. Geol. Surv. Uganda, 3 (2), 1-300. HUANG, W. L. & WYLLIE, P. J. 1974. Eutectic between wollastonite I1 and calcite contrasted with thermal barrier in i g O - S i O 2 - C O 2 at 30 kilobars with emphasis to kimberlite-carbonatite petrogenesis. Earth planet. Sci. Lett. 24, 305-10. IRVING, A. J. & GREEN, D. H. 1972. Experimental study of phase relationships in a high pressure mugearitic basalt as a function of water content. Geol. Soc. Am. Meet. Abstracts with Programs 4, 550-1. - - - & PRICE, R. C. 1981. Geochemistry and evolution of high pressure phonolitic rocks from Nigeria, Australia, Eastern Germany and New Zealand. Geochim. cosmochim. Acta, 45, 1309-20. ITO, K. & KENNEDY, G. C. 1968. Melting and phase relations in the plane tholeiite-lherzolite-nepheline basanite to 40 kilobars with geological implications. Contrib. Mineral. Petrol. 19, 177-211. KAY, R. W. & GAST,P. W. 1973. The rare earth content and origin of alkali rich basalts. J. Geol. 81, 65382. KOGARKO, L. N. & ROMANCHEV, B. P. 1982. Phase equilibria in alkaline melts. Zap. vses. mineral. Ova. 8, 167-182 (in Russian). -
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
&
51
KUEHNER, S. M., EDGAR, A. D. & ARIMA, M. 1981. Petrogenesis of the ultrapotassic rocks from the Leucite Hills, Wyoming. Am. Mineral. 66, 663-77. KUSHIRO, I. 1973. Origin of some magmas in oceanic and circum-oceanic regions. Tectonophysics, 17, 211-22. -& YODER, n . S. 1974. Formation of eclogite from garnet lherzolite: liquidus relations in a portion of the system MgSiO3-CaSiO3-A1203 at high pressures. Yearb. Carnegie Inst. Washington, 73, 266-9. LARSEN, E. S. 1940. Petrographic province of central Montana. Geol. Soc. Am. Bull. 51,887-948. LLOYD, F. E. 1981. Upper mantle metasomatism beneath a continental rift: Clinopyroxenes in alkalic mafic lava and nodules from South West Uganda. Mineral. Mag. 44, 315-24. & BAILEY, D. K. 1975. Light element metasomatism of the continental mantle: the evidence and the consequences. Phys. Chem. Earth, 9, 389-416. , ARIMA,M. & EDGAR, A. D. 1985. Partial melting of a phlogopite-clinopyroxenite nodule from south-west Uganda: an experimental study bearing on the origin of highly potassic continental rift volcanics. Contrib. Mineral. Petrol., 91, 321-9. LUTH, W. C. 1967. Studies in the system of KA1SiO4Mg2SiO4-SiO2-H20. I. Inferred phase relations and petrologic applications. J. Petrol. 8, 372-416. MCKENZlE, D. P. 1984. The generation and compaction of partially molten rock. J. Petrol. 25, 713-65. MERRILL, R. B. & IRVING, A. J. 1977. Chemistry and phase relations of an orthopyroxene-bearing transitional alkalic basalt (abstract). Los, 58, 526. --& WYLLIE, P. J. 1975. Kaersutite and kaersutite eclogite from Kakanui, New Zealand--water excess and water deficient melting relations to 30 kilobars. Geol. Soc. Am. Bull. 86, 555-70. MYSEN, B. O. & KUSHIRO, I. 1977. Compositional variations of coexisting phases with degree of melting of peridotite in the upper mantle. Am. Mineral. 62, 843-65. NORRIS, G. & MACKENZIE,W. S. 1976. Phase relations in the system NaA1SiO4-KAISiO4-CaA12Si2OsSiO2 at PH2o = 1 kb. Prog. Exp. Petrol., NERC Publ. Set. D, 79-81. O'HARA, M. J. 1968. The bearing of phase equilibria studies on synthetic and natural systems on the origin and evolution of basic and ultrabasic rocks. Earth Sci. Rev. 4, 69-133. & BIGGAR, G. M. 1969. Diopside-spinel equilibria, anorthite and forsterite reaction relationships in silica-poor liquids in the system C a - M g O A1203-SiO 2 at atmospheric pressure and their bearing on the genesis of melilitites and nephelinites. Am. J. Sci. 267A, 364-90. YODER, H. S. 1967. Formation and fractionation of basic magmas at high pressures. Scott. J. Geol. 3, 67-117. PRESNALL, D. C., DIXON, J. R., O'DONNELL, T. H. & DIXON, S. A. 1979. Generation of mid-ocean ridge tholeiites. J. Petrol. 20, 3-35. , DIXON, S. A., DIXON, J. R., O'DONNELL, T. H., BRENNER, N. J., SCHROCK, R. L. & DYCUS, D. W. 1978. Liquidus phase relations on the join diopside-forsterite-anorthite from 1 atm to 20 kbar; -
-
-
-
-
-
&
52
A. D. Edgar
their bearing on the generation and crystallization of basaltic magma. Contrib. Mineral. Petrol. 66, 203-220. RINGWOOD, A. E. 1975. Composition and Petrology of the Earth's Mantle, 618 pp. McGraw-Hill, New York. ROEDDER, E. 1979. Silicate liquid immiscibility in magmas. In: YODER, H. S. (ed.) The Evolution of the Igneous Rocks: Fiftieth Anniversary Perspectives, pp. 15-58. Princeton University Press, Princeton, NJ. Roux, J. & HAMILTON, D. L. 1976. Primary igneous analcite--an experimental study. J. Petrol. 17, 244-57. RUDDOCK, D. I. & HAMILTON, D. L. 1978. The system KA1SizO6-CaMgSi206-SiO2-H20 at 4 kilobars. Prog. Exp. Petrol., NERC Publ. Ser. D, 25-31. RYABCHIKOV, I. D. & BOETTCHER,A. L. 1980. Experimental evidence at high pressure for potassic metasomatism in the mantle of the earth. Am. Mineral. 65, 915-19. & GREEN, D. H. 1978. The role of carbon dioxide in the petrogenesis of highly potassic magmas. In: Problems of Earth's Crust and Upper Mantle, Trudy Instituta Geologii GeofizikL So An SSR 403, Nauka, Novosibirsk (in Russian). , SCHREYER, W. & ABRAHAM, K. 1982. Compositions of aqueous fluids in equilibrium with pyroxenes and olivines at mantle pressures and temperatures. Contrib. Mineral. Petrol. 79, 80-4. SCHAIRER, J. F. & YODER, H. S. 1970. Critical planes and flow sheet for a portion of the system CaOA1203-SiO 2. Yearb. Carnegie lnst. Washington, 68, 202-14. , TILLEY, C. E. & BROWN, G. M. 1969. The join nepheline-diopside-anorthite and its relation to alkali basalt fractionation. Yearb. Carnegie Inst. Washington, 66, 467-71. , YAGI, K. & YODER, H. S. 1962. The system nepheline-diopside. Yearb. Carnegie lnst. Washington, 61, 96-8. SORENSON, H. (ed.). 1974. The Alkaline Rocks, 622 pp. Wiley, New York. TAKAHASHI, E. 1980. Melting relations of an alkali olivine basalt to 30 kbar, and their bearing on the origin of alkali basalt magmas. Yearb. Carnegie Inst. Washington, 79, 271-6. - & KUSHIRO, I. 1983. Melting of a dry peridotite at high pressures and basalt magma genesis. Am. Mineral. 68, 859-79. TAYLOR, D. & MACKENZIE,W. S. 1975. A contribution to the pseudoleucite problem. Contrib. Mineral. Petrol. 49, 321-33. THOMPSON, R. N. 1972. The one atmosphere melting patterns of some basaltic volcanic series. Am. J. Sci. 272, 901-32. - - 1 9 7 3 . One atmosphere melting behaviour and nomenclature of terrestrial lavas. Contrib. Mineral. Petrol. 41, 197-204. - 1974. Primary basalts and magma genesis. I. Skye, North-West Scotland. Contrib. Mineral. Petrol. 45, 317-41.
Primary basalts and magma genesis. III. Alban Hills, Roman comagmatic province, central Italy. Contrib. Mineral. Petrol. 60, 91-108. TURNER, F. J. & VERHOOGEN, J. 1960. lgneous and Metamorphic Petrology, 694 pp. McGraw-Hill, New York. WADE, A. & PRIDER, R. T. 1940. The leucite-bearing rocks of the West Kimberley area, Western Australia. Q.J. geol. Soc., Lond. 96, 39-98. WATERS, A. C. 1955. Volcanic rocks and the tectonic cycle. Geol. Soc. Am. Spec. Pap. 63, 703-722. WENDLANDT, R. F. & EGGLER, D. H. 1980a. The origins of potassic magmas. 1. Melting relations in the systems KA1SiO~-Mg2SiO4-SiO2 and KA1SiO4-MgO-SiO2-CO2 to 30 kilobars. Am. J. Sci. 280, 385-420. - & 1980b. The origins of potassic magmas. 2. Stability of phlogopite in natural spinel lherzolite and in the system KA1SiO4-MgO-SiOz-H20CO2 at high pressures and temperatures. Am. J. Sci. 280, 421-58. WIalTELEY, C. 1981. Phase relations in the system NaA1SiO4-KA1SiO4-CaA12Si2Os-SiO2-HzO at 1 kb. Prog. Exp. Petrol., NERC Publ. Ser. D, 33-4. WILLIAMS, H. 1936. Pliocene volcanoes of the NavajoHopi county. Geol. Soc. Am. Bull. 47, 111-72. WYLLIE, P. J. 1975. The earth's mantle. Sci. Am. March 1975. - - 1 9 7 7 . Mantle fluid compositions buffered by carbonates in peridotite-CO2-H20. J. Geol. 8 5 , 187-207. - - 1 9 7 8 . Mantle fluid compositions buffered in peridotite-H20--CO2 by carbonates, amphibole and phlogopite. J. Geol. 86, 687-713. - - 1 9 7 9 . Magmas and volatile components. Am. Mineral. 64, 469-500. - 1980. The origin of kimberlite. J. geophys. Res. 8 5 , 6902-10. - & HUANG, W. L. 1975. Peridotite, kimberlite, and carbonatite relations in the system CaO-MgOSiO2-COz. Geology, 3, 621-4. - - & 1976. Carbonation and melting reactions in the system CaO-MgO-SiO2-CO2 at mantle pressures with geophysical and petrological applications. Contrib. Mineral. Petrol. 54, 79-107. YODER, H. S. 1975. Relationship of melilite-bearing rocks to kimberlite: a preliminary report on the system akermanite-CO2. Phys. Chem. Earth, 9, 883-94. -1976. Generation of Basaltic Magmas, 265 pp. National Academy of Sciences. Washington, DC. - 1979. Melilite-bearing rocks and related lamprophyres. In." YODER, H. S. (ed.) The Evolution of Igneous Rocks. Fiftieth Anniversary Perspectives, pp. 391-411. Princeton University Press, Princeton, NJ. - & KUSrtIRO, I. 1972. Composition of residual liquids in the nepheline-diopside system. Yearb. Carnegie Inst. Washington, 71,413-16. ZYRYANOV, V. N. 1981. Phase Correspondence in the Systems of Feldspars and Feldspathoids, 217 pp. Nauka, Moscow (in Russian). - - 1 9 7 7 .
A. D. EDGAR, Department of Geology, University of Western Ontario, London, Ontario, N6A 5B7, Canada.
Nephelinites and carbonatites M. J. Le Bas S U M M A R Y : Carbonatites found in strongly alkaline intra-plate petrographic volcanic provinces are associated with olivine-poor nephelinites and with phonolites. Olivine-rich nephelinites occur in basanitic and alkali basalt provinces, normally without carbonatites. These igneous provinces are marked by epeirogenic crustal uplift. Nephelinites, ijolites and carbonatites form discrete magmatic events within individual complexes and correspond to the silicate-carbonate conjugate immiscible liquids observed in the laboratory. Carbonate liquids of variable alkali content can separate from both nephelinitic and phonolitic liquids. The silicate liquids give rise to pyroxenites, ijolites, nepheline syenites and nephelinitic pyroclast-rich strato-volcanoes. The carbonate liquids lose alkalis and fractionate to s6vite, alvikite and ferrocarbonatite, each with increasing incompatible-element content. Further fractionation of carbonatite magma can produce mineralizing fluids rich in rare-earth elements, F, Ba, U and Th. Dolomite carbonatite forms only in the deeper parts of carbonatitic complexes, perhaps at depths greater than 2 km. Explosive carbonatite volcanism can occur giving widespread carbonate tufts, rarely with lavas. Fenitization characterizes ijolite-carbonatite intrusive complexes. Syenitic fenites containing alkali feldspars, sometimes perthitic, are formed as aureoles 500 m wide around ijolites in granitic terranes, with nepheline syenite commonly formed as a contact-reaction rock. The feldspar-rich syenitic fenite aureoles which develop around the early carbonatites usually contain pure orthoclase or pure albite.
Carbonatites achieved geological respectability only about 30 years ago, largely through the impact of work in Scandinavia and Africa. Br6gger's work (1921), at Fen in S Norway, which was strongly disputed by Bowen (1924) but later re-established by Saether (1957), demonstrated that calcite-rich rocks could have all the characteristics of intrusive magmatic bodies and that they alkali metasomatize (fenitize) their host rocks. In Sweden, von Eckermann (1948) conducted a meticulous study of the Aln6 complex. He maintained that alkali carbonatite magma was the prime intrusive material at Aln6, that the associated alkaline silicate rocks were all metasomatic products of fenitization and that the calcite-rich carbonatite was the residue of the intrusive carbonate magma. Dixey et al. (1935) were the first to identify carbonatites in Africa. Garson re-investigated the Malawi complexes of Chilwa, Tundulu, Kangankunde, Songwe and others, and wrote a series of memoirs culminating in a valuable summary account (Garson 1965). The association of carbonatites with nephelinitic volcanism was first recognized by King (1949) at the Napak complex in Uganda. Tuttle & Gittins (1966) and Heinrich (1966) wrote comprehensive accounts of intrusive carbonatites, but extrusive carbonatites have only recently become widely appreciated although they were first identified in 1960 by Dawson (1962).
Strongly alkaline igneous rocks are notorious for their diversity of rock type and abundance of names. Some names, such as ijolite and urtite, are necessary, but many can be discarded. The names used here are based on the work of the IUGS Subcommission on the Systematics of Igneous Rocks (Streckeisen 1976, 1978). Carbonatites are defined as igneous carbonate rocks with more than 50% modal carbonate minerals. If the carbonate is calcite, the rock is a calcite carbonatite which is called a s6vite if it is coarse grained with adcumulate texture or a micro-s6vite if it is medium or fine grained. Beforsite is equivalent to dolomite carbonatite. A less common variety of carbonatite is alvikite, which typically has a texture of small calcite rhombs packed together and is enriched in incompatible elements such as rare-earth elements (REE), Ba, Mn, Zn and commonly Nb. The boundary between s6vite and alvikite is still uncertain but may be set at 0.4% MnO, 1500 ppm Ba and 2000 ppm REE. The calcite of alvikite is slightly ferroan. Ferrocarbonatite is a ferroan calcite to ankeritic calcite carbonatite even more strongly enriched in some or all of REE, Ba, Mn, Fe, Zn, F and U, with possible lower limits of 1.0% MnO, 5000 ppm REE and 5000 ppm Ba. This rock type is very rare, but it is the main source for mineralization of these elements in carbonatites. Natrocarbonatite is carbonatite lava. It is fine grained, extrusive and composed of nyerereite ((Na,K)2Ca(CO3)2) and gregoryite
From: FITTON,J. G. & UPTON, B. G. J. (eds), 1987, Alkaline Igneous Rocks, Geological Society Special Publication No. 30, pp. 53-83.
53
54
M. J. Le Bas
((Na,K)2CO3). Some natrocarbonatites are richer in Ca and have calcite in place of gregoryite. The purpose of this contribution is to give a petrological synthesis of the nephelinite-carbonatite complexes, at both plutonic and volcanic levels. It begins with the rise of the primary magma through the uppermost mantle, then considers the processes suffered by the magma when it stops in reservoirs at or near the base of the crust and finally traces the passage of the different magmas, carbonate and silicate, through the crust to the ultimate products at the surface. Kimberlitic carbonatites are not included because they have recently been reviewed by Dawson (1980) and because they are different from nephelinitic carbonatites in their primary lack of alkalis, particularly Na. This lack is expressed by the absence of fenitization around the kimberlitic carbonatites. However, the zonation of the E African and E Siberian ultraalkaline provinces, recently compared by Le Bas (1986), indicates that these two types of carbonatite are genetically related in their mantle sources.
Distribution Although nephelinite-carbonatite complexes are rare, being only a fraction of 1~ of all igneous rocks, their distribution is worldwide (Fig. 1) with ages back to the early Proterozoic. Nephelinite-carbonatite complexes occur in intra-plate environments, both continental and, rarely, oceanic. For instance they occur in the Canary 150 r
I
120 I
I
90 ~
89
60 ~f",./
I
30 T
I
Islands and the Cape Verde Islands, where there is a clear regional association with ocean island basalts. Petrographically there is no distinction between the complexes that occur singly, for example as at Kaiserstuhl in S Germany, and those in groups such as the complexes composing the 20 Cenozoic carbonatitic volcanic centres of the inner portion of the E African province (Le Bas 1980). The E African province (Fig. 2) is zoned, with kimberlites in a central core about 300 km across. Carbonatites, olivine-poor nephelinites and ijolites, but not basalts, comprise the next inner concentric zone 100-300 km wide, and at the edge is a carbonatite-free outer zone ranging in width from 100 to 300 km which is composed of basanites, alkali basalts and some olivine-rich nephelinites (Fig. 3). The large Palaeozoic-Mesozoic E Siberian province is similarly zoned (Dawson 1980; Le Bas 1986). In the Angola province, or half-province if S Brazil is rejoined to it, the distribution is different. There the alkali basaltic centres cluster near the coast line, with carbonatitic complexes further inland and kimberlite diatremes furthest inland. Namibia is similar (Prins 1981). The scale of these distributions suggests deep-seated mantle processes. They are not related to plate motion or plume traces. These alkaline and ultra-alkaline provinces are also marked by epeirogenic uplift (Le Bas 1971, 1980; Baker 1987) which produces broad swells and plateau uplift both continental (e.g. the Rhine upwarp and the East African plateau) and oceanic (e.g. Cape Verde Rise). These uplifts
0 f
I
I
30 C~-/I
60 I
I
90 I
r~.....~,r~J
120 ]
150 [
I
180 I
9
b
~
9
"
';~.
~
FIG. ]. World distribution of nephelinite-carbonatRe complexes: I I , r215
or province of comple•
[
Nephelinites and carbonatites "J,.
SUDAN
..""
".... ...... .'" ~ ,~v
"9 ~ X \"
/
fl
''..
"-
55
"''..
A
ETHIOPI/~
A'"
'/ U "~'.
.....
'^~ "~/
-.""~/ "~ANDA u~
/ U ' ~ IIAI / ." U~ I " 1 ~ As~" ,I i
. /.. /."~
0*
-
/
K
i
;1:/\. - u3-'~."\ -r
~
\\
-/:/
",
KENYA
u
__-/~.'\- " :.
/
I 2 ~ i
TANZANIA
9
~
'
"q'/~'L I I I 3;"~I
"".
IIi1
A " ""
~
~ I~])
Ill
,
\\ \ I' 3\~ j
\
-/
~ ~'~ ~
/
. . . . ,' ,,I~176
,J
' 3 ""---
\
K
;-
-
'u\
,,
\\
L~"~
u)
I
\
x
" . . .A
K'
i
"'
(
\" L~ 250 km "
]'~
\
40~' t
FIG. 2. Map of the E African Alkaline Province (or Lake Victoria Province) showing the zonation ( - - - ) : 1, central zone of kimberlite diatremes (K); 2, inner zone of ultra-alkaline complexes (U); 3, outer zone of alkali basaltic volcanism (A). Radial lines indicate the edge of the E African uplift. Bold lines indicate rift faults. The faults show no apparent relation to the zonation. The inset square marks the area shown in Fig. 3. (RW, Rwanda; BU, Burundi.)
evidently relate to the same deep-mantle processes as those giving rise to the ultra-alkaline magmatism (Bailey 1987). Such up-arching produces tension in the upper crust which is quite independent of the motion of the whole tectonic plate. The two motions, the first vertical, covering an equidimensionat area and emanating from the mantle associated with ultra-alkaline magmatism, and the second essentially horizontal and related to plate motion, are interpreted to be distinct and not necessarily related (Le Bas 1986). It is argued that ultra-alkaline magmatism and regional uplift are not necessary initial stages of the Wilson cycle which describes the break-up of continents followed by sea-floor spreading.
Nephelinite magma There are nephelinites and nephelinites, the two varieties being distinguished by the properties given in Tables 1-3. Those defined as Group I
nephelinites are olivine rich, and are typically associated with alkali basalt and basanite volcanic provinces. Group II nephelinites are rarer and comprise olivine-poor nephelinites which occur with carbonatitic and ijolitic complexes (Fig. 3). The olivine-poor nephelinites commonly have abundant euhedral clinopyroxene phenocrysts, whereas the few olivine phenocrysts often show resorbed crystal margins, sometimes even reaction rims, indicating that olivine was no longer in equilibrium. The abundance of pyroxene usually means that these rocks are metanephelinites rather than nephelinites, and many could be better described as clinopyroxenephyric melanephelinites. Aphanitic varieties are rare. Olivine-poor nephelinite can fractionate to olivine-free nephelinite and to phonolite (Table 1). These phonolites are often glassy, commonly making abundant dykes and plugs, and Lippard (1973) distinguished them (his Gwasi-type phonolites) from the phonolites in and around the
56
M. J. Le Bas 134o +
--
+
r
t 3 8~
4-
ETHIOPIA
+ + +
,~
+
~1 40 ~
4- •
LODWAR
~t~
MOROTO
z
--2 0
NAPAK
~
KENYA
C e n o z o i c l a v a s and pyroclastic deposits
x +
NYAMBENI
I&UISHU
~ Kavirondo ~ M T .
~ A
KENYA
Olivine-poor volcanic A Olivine-rich volcanic
ABERDARES
nephelinitic centres nephelinitic centres
AL
Mixed nephelinitic volcanic centres
SJNGIR I
~
~
NAIROBI Z o n e of o v e r l a p of p r o v i n c e s
Rift
faults
SHOMBOLE
( L.N~tro~ OLDOINYO LENGA :::::K?IMASI
KILIMANJARO
SADIMAN 9 100 L
1
i !
I
ESSIMINGOR 4o
TANZANIA 134~
~
HANANG
~
1380
FIG. 3. Map of Kenya and adjacent areas showing the present distribution of the Group II olivine-poor nephelinitic (and carbonatitic) volcanic centres corresponding to a portion of the inner zone shown in Fig. 2, and the Group I olivine-rich nephelinitic (non-carbonatitic) volcanic centres corresponding to the Kenyan region of the outer zone shown in Fig. 2. Between these two zones lies a zone of mixed nephelinitic types resulting from an overlap or mixing of the inner- and outer-zone magmas.
Kenya rift valley (his Plateau and Kenya types). The latter are derived from basanitic and basaltic sources, and form extensive lavas evidently of low viscosity. The phonolites derived from the nephelinites are rich in Sr (more than 1000 ppm) and Ba (more than 100 ppm, and some more than 1000 ppm), and are richer in total alkalis (about 14%) relative to silica (about 53%) than those derived from plagioclase-bearing m a g m a s w h e n both Sr and Ba contents are less than 100 ppm.
The Miocene lavas of the Kisingiri volcano in W Kenya provide a good example of the normal fractionation trend from olivine-poor nephelinites and they are not dissimilar from those at other centres nearby except in detail. The early stages of fractionation are dominated by the precipitation of m u c h clinopyroxene plus a few oxides and some olivine at first (Fig. 4), producing only a m i n i m a l rise of Si in the m a g m a with fractionation. On some occasions Si falls, partic-
Nephelinites and carbonatites
-
~ e ~6
~ --'lk
57
\
,," /
~.
~09o'~0
9 9
10 : /
I
~
2.. 3
\ 1 phonolites
/
0
e ~.Nx :
l nephelinites
t-~
I
t
I
10
I
t
t
i
wt
I
20 %
t
I
t
t
I
30
I
I
[
40
MgO
FIG. 4. CaO-MgO plot of fields for olivine-rich nephelinites (Group I) and olivine-poor nephelinites or melanephelinites (Group II), and their mutual fractionation product of ordinary nephelinites and phonolites. • is the composition of olivine fractionated; + - - + are successive compositions of clinopyroxenes fractionated from melanephelinites, nephelinites and phonolites. Dotted lines are paths of fractionation, and to the right of the fields are crystal extracts with the pyroxene-to-olivine ratio indicated. (Data from Le Bas (1978), Varne (1968), Saggerson (1970), Spencer (1969), Strong (1972) and EAGRU data file (unpublished.)
ularly if no oxides are precipitated, and melilite nephelinite magma can form. Some data are given in Table 1, and further data can be obtained from the U K - I G B A data base which can be accessed via BGS (London) or the World Data Center-A (Colorado). They show that the production of phonolite from olivine-poor nephelinite is accompanied by a fall in Ca, Mg, total Fe, P and sometimes Ti, with a rise in Si, A1, Na, K and the ratios Fe/Mg and K/Na. The fractionation of trace elements from olivine-poor nephelinites can be shown on twoelement plots, but is best seen on primordial mantle-normalized plots (Figs 5 and 6). Figure 5 is a plot of four samples from Kisingiri (data in Table 1) and shows a marked relative increase in the incompatible elements Th, Nb and Zr, with depletion in Sr, P, Ti and V; the latter is pulled out by the precipitation of pyroxene, apatite and any titanomagnetite. The increase in the ratio Zr/Ti appears to be a sensitive index of fractionation, and a similar rotation of the Zr-Ti tie-line (i.e. Zr/Ti increases) is also seen from the trace data from other complexes. Figure 6 compares melanephelinites of carbon-
atitic complexes of different ages in E Africa and reveals that, while the high-field-strength elements Nd, P, Zr, Ti and Y remain closely similar, the others vary slightly, particularly the largeion-lithophile (LIL) elements. The younger complexes of Homa Mountain and Elgon both show a slight enrichment in Ba and Th, and Ba mineralization is seen at Homa (Le Bas 1977, p. 237). If data ranges were marked on Fig. 6(a), the values of Rb, Sr, Nb and REE would show overlap, except in the case of Homa Mountain where all the data consistently show higher REE and lower K values. This is not instrument bias since all the data were obtained on the X-ray fluorescence (XRF) spectrometers at both Edinburgh and Leicester University. If the Kisingiri and N a p a k averages plotted in Fig. 6(a) are taken as normal for nephelinitic rocks associated with carbonatites (but whether these are nephelinites from before or after possible liquid-immiscible separation from carbonate melt is not yet certain), they should be chemically comparable with other carbonatitic nephelinites. Appropriate data are sparse, but they do compare closely with the Triassic nephel-
58
M. J. Le Bas
TABLE 1. Selected nephelinitic lavas from carbonatitic and other provinces Elgon, WKenya
Kisingiri, W Kenya
Napak, EUganda
RR659 RR585 RR457 U1041
SUN6 SUN89 SUN21
ElK8
ElK6 ElK7
54.73 0.47 21.37 5.13 0.23 0.21 2.70 9.74 5.72 0.16
43.50 2.03 10.30 15.03 0.18 9.18 16.94 1.26 1.68 0.58
42.84 2.77 11.47 15.46 0.29 7.16 15.33 2.76 1.27 0.99
42.20 44.12 2.48 2.61 12.04 13.89 1 3 . 9 7 14.11 0.27 0.25 6.22 5.03 1 5 . 1 7 11.42 3.93 5.52 2.54 2.78 0.88 0.95
101.27 100.46
100.68
97.76
97.23
100.35
99.68
100.68
82 92 333 31 6 749 1098 46 49 88 38 135 18
19 121 291 54 7 1251 1167 67 69 132 50 184 25
12 133 260 55 8 1212 1267 73 74 133 56 206 26
29 117 286 60 15 1857 1946 163 96 154 57 271 36
29 114 211 45 12 1211 910 111 92 158 61 193 25
30 121 218 58 12 1128 684 123 94 157 57 214 28
Major elements (wt.%) SiO 2 TiO 2 AI20 3 Fe203 T MnO MgO CaO Na20 K20 P205
Total
41.99 3.08 12.94 15.22 0.24 7.43 13.65 3.46 1.58 0.89
45.42 49.73 2.56 1.95 1 4 . 8 8 16.72 13.46 10.62 0.23 0.22 4.39 2.36 9.17 6.75 7.26 8.35 2.80 3.82 0.93 0.75
100.48 101.10
40.38 42.56 2.52 2.48 1 1 . 6 8 13.62 1 6 . 2 7 14.48 0.25 0.23 6.27 5.52 1 2 . 5 3 10.76 4.42 4.58 2.33 2.50 0.81 0.79
Trace elements (ppm) Ni Zn V Rb Th Ba Sr Nb La Ce Nd Zr Y
47 114 323 40 12 1862 3135 119 105 194 79 284 32
25 119 238 63 11 1161 1342 111 92 174 70 317 29
9 129 143 81 15 1401 1448 132 95 161 132 362 30
4 168 52 141 56 1139 808 336 74 135 40 816 24
RR659, aphanitic melanephelinite lava, top of Kaniamwia, Kisingiri (Leicester XRF); RR585, nephelinite lava, Rangwe, Kisingiri (Leicester XRF); RR457, nephelinite dyke, with katophorite, Kiawindu, Kisingiri (Leicester XRF); U 1041, phonolite lava, trachytic texture, Nyamaji, Homa Bay (Leicester XRF); SUN6, pyroxene-phyric melanephelinite lava, Napak (wet analysis by R. C. Tyler 1966; traces Edinburgh XRF); SUN89, melanephelinite lava, Napak (Leicester XRF); SUN21, aphanitic melanephelinite lava, Okathim (Edinburgh XRF); ELK8, melanephelinite lava above Kitum Cave, E flanks Mount Elgon (Leicester XRF); ELK6, melanephelinite lava, Kitum Cave, E flanks Mount Elgon (Leicester XRF); ELK7, nephelinite lava, Kitum Cave, E flanks Mount Elgon TABLE 2. Worm average nephelinites
SiO2 TiO2 A1203 Fe203 FeO MnO MgO CaO Na20 K20 P205 H20
Group I (olivine rich) (wt.% (SD))
Group II (olivine poor) (wt.~(SD))
39.8 (1.5) 3.0 (0.3) 11.3 (0.9) 5.1 (1.9) 7.9 (1.2) 0.2 (0.01) 12.3 (1.8) 12.8 (1.3) 3.4 (0.3) 1.1 (0.3) 0.9 (0.6) 2.1 (0.6)
41.5 (2.0) 2.8 (0.3) 11.4 (1.6) 7.4 (1.5) 6.0 (1.0) 0.2 (0.01) 8.1 (2.0) 13.2 (3.2) 3.7 (1.9) 1.8 (1.5) 0.8 (0.6) 3.0 (1.1)
99.9 n=81
99.9 n--97
After Le Bas 1978.
inites of the Karoo province with w h i c h carbonatites are associated (Bristow & Saggerson 1983). The Miocene nephelinites of the southern portion (south of the equator) of the K e n y a rift valley, particularly those in the Kishalduga region, are almost identical (cf. Figs 6(a) and 6(b), and have olivine contents m i d w a y between the rich and poor types defined above (Kishalduga data from R. Tarzey, personal communication). Miocene nephelinites of N K e n y a are m a r k e d l y poorer in K and the more incompatible trace elements. N o olivine-free nephelinites have yet been observed in the northern rift. The few data that are available from the olivine-rich nephelinites of the Massif Central in France and of Greenland, Hawaii and the Comores Islands are all closely similar to the carbonatitic nephelinites, apart from variable K / T h ratios and Rb and K contents.
Nephelinites and carbonatites
Homa Mt., W. Kenya
N Kenya rift
S Kenya rift
59
HF566
HC42
11.108
8.428
15.591
17.548
Massif central 42466
Hawaii
Comores
65KAPAAI 1
Moh24
45.17 2.94 11.16 12.06 0.13 6.48 11.81 2.84 1.75 0.79
53.28 0.59 21.14 4.23 0.16 0.48 3.33 9.97 4.82 0.18
41.71 2.23 11.52 12.22 0.18 12.72 12.64 3.06 0.77 0.41
42.84 2.13 12.53 11.74 0.18 10.64 12.01 3.99 1.27 0.49
42.78 4.05 10.09 15.13 0.20 9.13 15.79 1.62 1.16 0.73
43.46 3.73 9.82 15.49 0.21 8.54 14.67 2.81 1.36 0.68
43.61 3.62 8.80 11.08 0.15 13.44 11.45 2.38 3.66 0.82
40.15 2.55 11.45 14.40 0.22 12.77 12.10 3.51 0.77 0.80
41.37 2.71 11.49 13.89 0.24 11.03 12.10 3.39 1.56 1.00
95.12
98.18
97.45
97.81
100.69
100.76
99.01
98.67
98.78
37 113 350 46 10 4668 1213 105 92 170 71 249 25
4 120 62 104 33 1224 1153 143 103 151 37 490 26
214 78 317 9 7 551 604 69 56 108 39 147 23
180 83 297 17 10 697 685 80 73 135 49 166 24
135 109 357 45 13 623 915 128 105 202 85 345 33
121 114 344 47 13 651 1075 116 96 183 74 335 29
309 80 -78 9 824 764 93 79 174 73 409 23
340 107 290 20 6 780 1050 -53 110 56 171 --
168 127 -47 -1250 880 ----257 --
(Leicester XRF); HF566, pyroxene-phyric melanephelinite plug, N flanks Homa Mountain (Edinburgh XRF); HC42, feldspar-phyric phonolite plug, S flanks Homa Mountain (Edinburgh and Durham XRF); 11.108, olivine nephelinite lava, Kasorogol, S Turkana (Edinburgh XRF); 8.428, olivine nephelinite, Nasaken, S. Turkana (Edinburgh XRF); 15.591, olivine nephelinite, S. Nakuru (Edinburgh XRF); 17.548, olivine nephelinite, Kishalduga, Narok (Leicester XRF); 42466, olivine nephelinite, Cantal, France (Downes 1984); 65APAAll, olivine nephelinite, Honolulu (Clague & Frey 1982); MOH24, olivine nephelinite, Moheli Island, Comores (Strong 1972). T h e similarities of the trace-element signatures in Fig. 6 and Table 1 indicate broadly similar chemical sources for the m a g m a s in the mantle, w h e t h e r or not carbonatites are associated. A c h a r a c t e r c o m m o n to all nephelinites is the e n r i c h m e n t in K , Th, N b and the light R E E w h i c h points to a m a n t l e source rich in the heatproducing elements, although the K / T h ratio does vary, indicating a variable m a n t l e source for these components. A further study of the detailed variation in nephelinitic and other primitive m a g m a s across the zoned alkaline igneous province of E Africa, c o m p a r i n g early Cenozoic with later Cenozoic m a n t l e m a g m a t i c products, is being carried out at present by R. Tarzey. A similar investigation of the Cape V e r d e m a g m a tism is being u n d e r t a k e n by N. Hodgson. The olivine-rich and olivine-poor nephelinites, in terms of their m a j o r - e l e m e n t chemistry, could
be derived from e a c h other, but their geographical separation by some h u n d r e d s of kilometres into the c o n t e m p o r a n e o u s outer and inner zones of the E A f r i c a n province shows that distinct processes occurred in the two cases.
Magma plumbing These two types of nephelinites are distinct chemically and physically (Table 3). The olivinerich nephelinites have high Mg and N i contents a n d few or no fractionation products. T h e y build small volcanic cones with an occasional abund a n c e of lherzolite nodules, w h i c h m a y be t a k e n to indicate that these m a g m a s c a m e directly from the m a n t l e with few or no intervening crustal reservoirs. In strong contrast, the olivine-poor nephelin-
M. J. Le Bas
6o
~
U
1041
RR 4 5 7
-----+
10 3
"
..
."
~
"...
102
o
i ...,.
101
KISINGIRI
LAVAS
W. K E N Y A
100
I
Rb
I
I
I
1
I
I
I
I
I
K Th Ba Sr Nb La Ce Nd
I
P
1
Zr Ti
I
Y
TI
V
I -
Zn
FIG. 5. Primordial mantle (PM) normalized plot of four selected lavas from the Kisingiri strato-volcano (Table 1). Note the decreasing coherence of distribution, particularly of the high-field-strength elements during fractionation. The PM values of Wood et al. (1979) were used; V was taken as 84 ppm.
ites make large central strato-volcanoes and almost never carry mantle-type xenoliths. They exhibit strong fractionation to phonolite and ijolite, which suggests that magma produced in the mantle must have stopped in a magma reservoir during its upward passage to the surface. This is corroborated by the low Mg number and Ni content of magmas that reach the surface. The question arises: why should one type of nephelinite consistently stop on its rise through the continental lithosphere, and the other not? Trace elements do not support the argument of mantle chemical heterogeneity as the cause. Therefore, either the physical conditions of passage of the two differ, i.e. one portion of the lithosphere is easier to penetrate than another, or the physical properties of the two types of magma must differ. No lateral variation of the lithosphere is apparent in any of the provinces and therefore the second alternative must be examined. The density of primitive nephelinite magma would be about 2.9-3.0 g cm- 3, whilst the density contrast across Moho from mantle to continental crust is about 3.4-2.8 g cm-3. Thus a nephelinite magma would be expected to stop rising in the lower continental crust, but perhaps not in the lower oceanic crust (density about 3.0 g cm-3). Why then do nodule-bearing nephelinites pass rapidly up through continental crust without stopping ? The answer may lie in the volatile content. Nephelinites associated with carbonatites by liquid immiscibility must be carbonated nephelinite magmas and hence have a high C O 2 / ( H 2 0 -kCO2) volatile fraction. If, however, the COz/ ( H 2 0 + C O 2 ) ratio is lower, the nephelinite magma would be more hydrous and less viscous
500
I.
/ I "t,,, /
~o
200
\\
/_
,R,
,?-~
i~
,
-
I00 o >o
q
d
50
1:;7 ;;2~ 20
-~0 x)\\_
i
]
I
L
i
I
i
I
b K Th Ba Sr Nb La Ce Nd P Zr Ti
Y
9 S Kenya rift
L-~'XX
[] N Kenya rift
\
-
'~
o Kisingiri (Miocene) I
-
s
9 Napak (Miocene)
I
[]
I0
Rb K Th Ba Sr Nb La Ce Nd P Zr Ti
Y
FIG. 6. (a) Normalized plot of average trace-element abundances for melanephelinites from four Tertiary carbonatitic volcanic complexes in E Africa (Fig. 3); (b) normalized plot of averaged values of trace elements in olivine nephelinites from the northern and southern sectors of the Kenya rift valley.
Nephelinites and carbonatites
6i
TABLE 3. Contrasts between nephelinites of Groups I and H Character
Principal phenocrysts Clinopyroxene MgO content of rock Mg no. (100Mg/(Mg+Fe2+)) at 100 K/(Na + K) at Associated basalts Chemical fractionation Volcanic structure Percentage pyroclastic Plutonic equivalents Mantle-type xenoliths Examples
Group I (olivine-rich nephelinites) Olivine and clinopyroxene Lilac and Ti rich > 10 wt.% 74 18 Abundant Very slight Small parasitic Moderate Rare Common Kenya Rift Comores Islands Hawaiian Islands Texas Massif Central
and would perhaps be able to rise through the lithosphere without stopping. Some dynamic fractionation during ascent may also have taken place. Now that the style of nephelinitic magmatism associated with carbonatites has been distinguished from other nephelinitic developments, the term nephelinitic volcanism in the remainder of this contribution will refer to the olivine-poor nephelinites and their derivatives. During or before retention in a magma reservoir, olivine was precipitated and hence largely lost to the remaining nephelinitic magma. Resorption and reaction rims on remaining olivine phenocrysts indicate that they were no longer stable in the magma. Augite was also being precipitated in abundance. It seems that the initial precipitation of olivine increased the already high CO2 content in the magma, which eventually destabilized any remaining olivine and widened the pyroxene stability field. Cumulate bodies of dunite within carbonatite complexes are rare (e.g. Kovdor, Kola, and Shawa, Zimbabwe), whilst alkali pyroxenites occur in most carbonatitic complexes.
Pyroxene fractionation Well over half the extrusive products of nephelinite volcanism are pyroclastic, indicating a volatile-rich source. Among the products in W Kenya are numerous megacrysts of clinopyroxene up to 3 cm long. The chemistry of these and other clinopyroxenes in nephelinitic rocks is revealing
Group II (olivine-poornephelinites (melanephelinites)) Clinopyroxene and rarely olivine Pale brown or greenish and Ti poor < 10 wt.% 67 24 None Strong Large central High Frequent Very rare W Kenya E Uganda Malawi Siberia Amba Dongar, India
in the deciphering of the upward passage of the magma. Table 4 gives the analyses of a range of pyroxenes as xenocrysts, phenocrysts and groundmass phases from melanephelinites, nephelinites and phonolites. Most of them have low Ti and A1 contents which, if they came from groundmass phases, would be at variance with the higher Ti and A1 contents normally encountered in strongly alkaline rocks (Thompson 1974). Instead, as pointed out by Thompson, the low Ti and AI appear to indicate a high temperature of formation. The high Ca content of these magmas would also favour partition of the Ti into perovskite or sphene, which are both quite abundant as microphenocrysts in these rocks. Until analysed by microprobe, the presence of Cr-diopside among the xenocrysts and phenocrysts in the melanephelinites was not appreciated (Table 4, column 1). Cr-diopside is typical of pyroxenes from mantle-type lherzolites, and sometimes forms whole xenocrysts. These xenocrysts can also be present as colourless to palegreen cores to more normal pyroxene compositions (Table 4, columns 4a and 4b) and fall in the mantle pressure field for chromiferous pyroxenes described by Onuma & Tohara (1984) where Na > A1vI. The presence of Cr-diopside is thought to indicate that the nephelinitic magma does record a history of passage through upper-mantle lherzolite. Olivine, with more than 90% Fo, has not been recognized among the xenocrysts or phenocrysts in the lavas, and the few olivines present range from 86% to 81% Fo. Olivine with Fo > 90% does occur in the cumulates, however.
62 TABLE 4.
M. J. Le Bas
Analyses of clinopyroxenes from melanephelinites, nephelinites and phonolites 2a
2b
53.08 0.62 0.58 . 3.19 0.11 16.16 24.31 0.39 0.00 0.14 98.58
51.67 0.87 1.61 . 6.73 0.13 13.58 23.80 0.66 0.00 0.15 99.20
51.25(0.55) 1.06 (0.19) 1.84 (0.26) . . 4.63 (0.28) 0.05 (0.02) 14.83 (0.34) 24.08 (0.09) 0.41 (0.03) 0.02 (0.00) 0.28 (0.07) 98.45
51.94 49.95 0.71 1.95 1.53 3.09
Total
53.20(0.45) 0.45 (0.07) 1.00 (0.14) . . 2.93 (0.13) 0.06 (0.01) 16.85 (0.18) 23.43 (0.37) 0.48 (0.07) 0.00 0.86 (0.27) 99.33
48.51 1.56 4.49 3.19 4.34 5.44 4.81 0.05 0.05 0.14 15.12 14.02 13.58 23.81 24.55 22.40 0.47 0.40 0.96 0.01 0.02 0.00 0.44 0.01 . 98.42 99.47 99.64
46.55 47.80 50.45 50.41 2.19 1.37 0.80 0.82 5.04 4.82 2.30 2.27 4.01 -12.80 13.51 7.19 17.00 8.45 8.27 0.30 0.65 0.55 0.52 10.29 6.05 4.87 4.53 22.07 19.20 13.98 13.43 1.22 2.79 5.08 5.89 0.18 -0.00 0.34 . . . . 99.04 99.68 99.28 99.99
Si Ti A1 Cr Fe 3+ Fe 2+ Mn Mg Ca Na K Ca Mg Fe* Na Mg Fe z+ + M n Mg/(Mg + Fe*)
1.956 0.013 0.046 0.025 . 0.090 0.002 0.924 0.923 0.034 . 47.6 47.7 4.7 3.4 91.2 5.4 91
1.971 0.017 0.025 0.004 . 0.099 0.003 0.894 0.968 0.028 . 49.3 45.5 5.2 2.8 90.0 7.2 90
1.940 0.025 0.071 0.005 . 0.211 0.004 0.760 0.958 0.048 . 49.6 39.3 11.1 5.0 79.1 15.9 80
1.923 0.030 0.081 0.008 . . 0.145 0.002 0.830 0.968 0.030 . . 49.8 42.7 7.5 3.1 86.9 10.0 85
1.943 1.867 1.817 0.020 0.055 0.044 0.068 0.136 0.198 0.013 . . . 0.090 0.136 0.170 0.151 0.002 0.002 0.004 0.843 0.781 0.758 0.954 0.983 0.899 0.034 0.029 0.070 . 49.3 50.8 47.3 43.6 40.3 39.9 7.1 8.9 12.9 3.5 3.2 7.8 86.5 85.9 84.9 10.0 10.9 7.3 86 82 76
1.786 0.063 0.228 . 0.116 0.231 0.010 0.589 0.907 0.091 0.009 48.9 31.8 19.3 10.9 70.5 18.6 62
1
SiO2 TiO2 A1203 Fe203 FeO MnO MgO CaO Na20 K20
Cr203
.
.
3
4a
4b
5
6
7
8
9
1.871 1.949 1.942 0.040 0.023 0.024 0.222 0.105 0.103 . . -0.372 0.392 0.557 0.273 0.266 0.022 0.018 0.017 0.353 0.280 0.260 0.805 0.579 0.554 0.212 0.381 0.440 --0.017 46.4 38.0 37.2 20.3 18.4 17.5 33.3 43.6 45.3 23.6 40.0 46.8 39.4 29.4 27.7 37.0 30.6 25.5 38 30 28
1, Cr-diopside xenocryst from strongly porphyritic olivine melanephelinite lava, Kisingiri volcano, W Kenya (RR710) (mean of six wavelength-dispersive microprobe analyses (WDMAs); standard deviation to 2tr given in parentheses); 2a, core of pale-green zoned pyroxene in block of pyroxenite ejected from Oldoinyo Lengai volcano, N Tanzania (24407) (energy-dispersive microprobe analysis (EDMA)); 2b rim of 2a; 3, euhedral megacryst (2 cm) of black diopside in agglomerate between melanephelinite lavas of Kisingiri volcano, Kenya (K79) (mean of four WDMAs; standard deviation given); 4a, core of colourless zoned Cr-diopside in phenocryst in normaltype melanephelinite lava, lower N flanks of Kisingiri volcano, Kenya (U16) (WDMA); 4b rim of 4a; 5, bulk pyroxene from fine-grained melanephelinite lava, S Ruri, W Kenya (S197) (wet analysis by H. Lloyd); 6, bulk pyroxene from nephelinite lava, S. Ruri ($33) (wet analysis by H. Lloyd); 7, Aegirine-augite phenocryst in feldspar-phyric phonolite lava of Kisingiri volcano, Wasaki Peninsula, W Kenya (U410) (EDMA); 8, Aegirineaugite microphenocrysts in glassy phonolite, volcanic plug, S Ruri (S 17) (wet analysis by H. Lloyd); 9, Aegirineaugite microphenocrysts in porphyritic phonolite, volcanic plug, S Ruri ($29/1) (wet analysis by H. Lloyd). Fe*, total F e + Mn. Titaniferous lilac-coloured Al-augite phenocrysts are exceedingly rare in these nephelinites, but are a b u n d a n t in the olivine-rich nephelinites and have been interpreted (Fodor et al. 1982) as being precipitated at pressures in the vicinity of 1520 kb during passage t h r o u g h the u p p e r mantle. Since Cr-diopside occurs but Ti-Al-augite is rare in the olivine-poor nephelinitic rocks, it is inferred that the latter were not precipitated during the passage of the p a r e n t m a g m a t h r o u g h the mantle. Similar chromiferous diopsides in pyroxenite (e.g. Table 4, c o l u m n 2a) are inter-
preted as cumulates, w h i c h further suggests that a c c u m u l a t i o n in a deep reservoir did occur. T h e more n o r m a l pyroxene phenocrysts in the m e l a n e p h e l i n i t e are a b u n d a n t low-Ti low-A1 augites (Table 4, columns 2b and 3) w h i c h zone out to more aluminous augites (Table 4, columns 4b and 5). They also show m o d e r a t e Fe enrichment, indicative of fractionation in a m a g m a chamber. Large euhedral black glistening megacrysts showing signs of resorption on the crystal faces also occur. T h e y have the same composition as
Nephelinites and carbonatites the phenocrysts (Table 4, column 3) and hence presumably have the same source. Evidently they were transported directly to the surface without stopping. The rare presence of pargasitic amphibole in some E African pyroclastic rocks (Varne 1968; Le Bas 1977) may be related to fractionation at mantle pressures as proposed by Varne, but they may also be the product of strongly hydrous conditions obtaining at only slightly lower pressures in a deep crustal magma chamber and the consequent explosive eruption of this magma to the surface. If this interpretation of the magmatic plumbing is correct, then the subvolcanic coarse-grained bodies of ijolite exposed by erosion at carbonatitic centres are products of nephelinitic magma rising from the lower crustal reservoir which stopped and crystallized. Therefore, the subvolcanic bodies would not mark the position of the main magma chambers feeding the volcanic structures above. Crystal fractionation of the melanephelinitic magma in the lower crustal reservoir produced nephelinitic and finally phonolitic liquids with increasingly Fe-rich sodic pyroxenes (Table 4, columns 6-9) as plotted in Fig. 7. Compositions richer in acmite than shown in
63
Fig. 7 do occur, but only rarely, and are confined to needles growing in late-stage fractionates. Also significant, with a bearing on the plumbing, is that some pyroxenes have green cores and show reverse zoning. They are quite common in melanephelinites and nephelinites. Table 5 lists analyses of three such zoned pyroxenes which have cores richer in Fe and Na than their colourless rims. The green cores correspond to pyroxenes from phonolites, while the rims correspond to the nephelinitic and melanephelinitic hosts. These give evidence for magma mixing, whereby pyroxene phenocrysts from phonolite are mixed into incoming magma to produce the reverse-zoned pyroxenes which can then be carried to the surface. Such a process necessitates a magma reservoir as proposed above. Analysis 3 in Table 5 further shows that mixing did not always lead to eruption, but that cumulative pyroxenites could be produced. Similar magma mixing revealed by green cores with reverse zoning is well known in many parts of the world. Brooks & Prinzlau (1978) give an excellent summary covering such mixed products from Antarctica, Africa, Europe, America and Greenland.
Crustal intrusive processes
\
~/
\
ee/
...:,.'.. Fe 2+ + Mn
FIG. 7. Na-(Fe 2+ + Mn)-Mg at.% plot of pyroxenes taken from Table 4 together with unpublished energy dispersive microprobe data on further E African samples: II, Cr-diopside from RR710 (Table 4, column 1); A, megacryst from K79 (Table 4, column 3); + - - +, zoned core-to-rim pale-green pyroxene in pyroxenite (Table 4, columns 2a and 2b); O, phenocryst and groundmass pyroxenes (the tie-line with the arrow indicates zoning); - - - , pyroxene trend for the sequence pyroxenite to ijolite to nepheline syenite in the sub-volcanic complexes of E Uganda (Tyler & King 1967) and W Kenya (Le Bas 1977, and unpublished data). The path from melanephelinite to nephelinite to phonolite corresponds to fractionation beginning with lowfO2.
Recent geochemical modelling by the author using major-element, trace-element and isotopic data shows that mixing of phonolite with melanephelinite magma can also produce lavas of mugearitic and trachyandesitic compositions. Such lavas are rare, but have been recognized in the nephelinitic volcanoes of E Africa (King 1949; Le Bas 1977). In the absence of any basalts in these volcanoes, they had been thought to be products of crustal contamination of melanephelinite magma. Another feature indicative of magma residing in a continental crustal chamber for long periods is that, the more extreme is the phonolitic fractionate from a nephelinite parent, the greater is the STSr/86Sr ratio. In W Kenya the 8781"/8651" initial ratios of melanephelinites are usually between 0.7032 and 0.7038 (Norry et al. 1980), whilst phonolites and trachyphonolites have values of 0.7046 and 0.7053 respectively (Le Bas 1977, p. 140). These higher values in the fractionates are interpreted as the product of crustal contamination. The density-contrast conditions cited above for arresting the upward passage of nephelinitic magmas near the mantle-crust boundary hold true only for continental crust. They cannot be applied to oceanic islands such as the Canary and
M . J. Le Bas
64
TABLE 5. Analyses of clinopyroxenes with green cores and reverse zoning 1
Core
2
Rim
SiOz TiOz A1203 FeO T MnO MgO CaO NazO CrzO 3 Total
51.12 0.52 1.96 15.50 0.36 8.47 19.44 2.21 . 99.58
50.80 1.50 2.19 6.50 0.12 14.36 23.42 0.45 . . 99.34
Si Ti A1 Cr Fe r Mn Mg Ca Na Na Mg Fe 2+ +Mn Mg/(Mg + Fe*)
1.972 1.903 0.015 0.042 0.089 0.098 . . . 0.500 0.204 0.012 0.004 0.487 0.802 0.804 0.940 0.165 0.033 16.2 3.4 47.8 82.3 36.0 14.3 57 85
3
Core
Rim
Core
Rim
47.56 1.53 5.12 17.90 0.39 5.32 19.98 1.88 . 99.68
48.32 2.15 4.67 7.58 0.12 12.53 22.58 1.02
51.26 0.37 1.07 15.69 0.35 8.31 20.36 2.09 0.16 99.66
50.43 0.87 2.19 10.11 0.22 11.45 22.88 0.76 0.19 99.10
1.987 0.011 0.049 0.005 0.509 0.011 0.480 0.845 0.157 15.8 48.2 36.0 57
1.924 0.025 0.098 0.006 0.323 0.007 0.651 0.935 0.056 5.9 67.9 26.2 72
98.97
1.866 0.045 0.237
1.830 0.061 0.208
0.587 0.013 0.311 0.840 0.143 15.4 33.5 51.1 40
0.240 0.004 0.707 0.916 0.075 8.3 78.5 13.2 86
.
1, Fine-grained nephelinite lava with occasional phenocrysts of pyroxene, mostly with green cores and colourless rims, showing reversed zoning, Kisingiri volcano, Kenya (K61) (EDMA); 2, hybrid fine-grained lava with scattered large phenocrysts of phonolitic pyroxene rimmed by groundmass composition pyroxene of melanephelinite host, NE flanks of Kisingiri volcano (U926) (EDMA); 3, apatite pyroxenite block from Oldoinyo Lengai volcano, N Tanzania (24420) containing subhedral pyroxenes with green cores and pale-green margins (EDMA). Cape Verde Islands, where nephelinites and carbonatites occur and where the distinction between the olivine-rich and olivine-poor nephelinites is not so clear. Green pyroxene cores exist, and so do mantle nodules. If a deep crustal reservoir is lacking, then fractionation must take place during ascent or in high-level chambers such as those now occupied by the subvolcanic plutonic complexes where fractionation and segregation can be seen to have occurred. A final question may be asked concerning the stage and depth at which magma chambers are formed in continental or oceanic crust. What relation do these feeders have to the onset of liquid immiscibility which, as will be shown below, affected the carbonated nephelinite magma and permitted the formation of conjugate silicate and carbonate magmas? If the unmixing of liquids is an exothermic process, its onset together with loss of carbonate fraction from the silicate liquid would temporarily raise the liquidus temperatures of the magmas until each had precipitated its more refractory phases, mainly
olivine and/or pyroxene +oxides and a p a t i t e + oxides respectively, until the remaining liquids were again buoyant. In summary, the following magma plumbing is envisaged. A carbonated olivine-rich magma is derived by partial melting of the asthenosphere. This rises through the mantle, gathering lherzolite fragments from the walls and perhaps precipitating some olivine. On passing into the base of the crust, the magma stops temporarily in a reservoir where olivine is precipitated, C02 builds up and the pyroxene stability field expands. The limit for liquid immiscibility is reached and carbonatitic magma separates. Pyroxene crystallizes to yield pyroxenite cumulates and the magma differentiates to phonolite. Influxes of new primitive magma mix with the phonolite producing reversezoned pyroxenes and, in extreme cases, new melts of mugearitic composition. All these magmas can rise directly to the surface and erupt as lavas, but some stop at subvolcanic levels and crystallize there, forming small plutons of ijolite and nepheline syenite.
Nephelinites and carbonatites
However, kimberlites do seem to produce a residual carbonatitic fraction in some cases, such as at Benfontein, S Africa (Dawson & Hawthorne 1973). Gittins (1978) likewise describes some carbonatitic and ultramafic rocks from the Cargill complex, N Ontario, as related by simple magmatic fractionation. The third possibility is that carbonatite and nephelinite magmas can be derived as independent melts in the asthenosphere, a view upheld by Woolley & Jones (1987), but, as Treiman & Essene (1983) point out, carbonatites emanating from partial melting of mantle peridotite would be Na-poor. Derivation of a carbonate melt from the mantle has been shown by the experimental work of Eggler (1978) and Wyllie (1978, 1980). They show that at about 30 kb in a phlogopitebearing mantle with a high CO2/H20 ratio the initial melt could be carbonatitic and associated with kimberlitic or melilitic magmas. Wyllie further showed that at lower CO2/H20 ratios the upper asthenosphere can produce an alkaline ultrabasic silicate partial melt from which an immiscible alkali-rich carbonate liquid would probably separate.
Liquid immiscibility The process of the separation of two immiscible liquids is considered to be central to the interpretation of the evolution of carbonatitic magmatism. Therefore liquid immiscibility must be examined to see whether it best accords with the petrological evidence. First, however, the alternatives for the production of carbonatite magma should be briefly considered, with the assumption that carbonatites are magmatic and not hydrothermal metasomatic deposits (Bulakh & IskozDolinina 1978). There are three possible styles of origin. First, the carbonatite magma is a product of melting of limestone in the crust. This was upheld by Shand (1949) among others, but experimental and geochemical work on synthetic systems, mainly by Wyllie (well summarized in his 1978 paper), has demonstrated the igneous nature of carbonatites. The second possibility is that carbonatite is the product by fractional crystallization of nephelinitic and ijolitic magma (King 1965). The discreteness of many ijolite and carbonatite intrusions and the almost complete lack of mineralogical and chemical continuity between the silicate and carbonate magmas is not in keeping with carbonatite as a residual magmatic fraction from nephelinite magma, a point discussed by Prins (1978). Volcanic rocks midway between nephelinite and carbonatite are unknown except for a few pyroclastic examples. Plutonic rocks midway between ijolite and carbonatite are uncommon, and bimodality can be demonstrated in most complexes. In the few complexes where transitional rock types occur, the structural and textural relations of these rocks in both the field and the laboratory usually show that ijolitic rocks have been invaded by carbonatite, producing hybrids. 900
L1
65
Experimental evidence In their study of possible liquid immiscibility, Koster van Groos & Wyllie (1966, 1968, 1973) observed liquid immiscibility along the join NaA1Si3Os-Na2CO3 above 870~ and at 1 kb or more, but not at atmospheric pressure (Fig. 8). Introducing water into the system (Koster van Groos & Wyllie 1968) Caused the field of liquid immiscibility to shrink. At lower temperatures (about 700-750~ albite is joined by cancrinite on the liquidus. The accompanying H20-COz vapour contained Na20 and SiO2, and such vapours are considered to be the synthetic
[
L 2----~ LI+L2
T~ 800
NO+L2
NC+LI+L 2
_
~
NC+L~
700 Albite
I
20
40 WT %
I 6o
I 8o
Na2CO3
FIG. 8. Highly simplified phase diagram of the join Ab-NC with 10% H20 at 1 kb pressure. The fields of cancrinite and vapour have been omitted. L1 and L2 are immiscibleliquids. (After Koster van Groos & WyUie 1973.)
66
M. J. Le Bas
equivalents of N a - K fenitizing fluids known to emanate from carbonatite magmas. In 1973 Koster van Groos & Wyllie added plagioclase (Abs0 and Abs0) to the runs and observed liquid immiscibility along both joins between the plagioclase and Na2CO3. Cancrinite lay on the solidus and the carbonate liquid was richer in Ca than the silicate liquid which was dominantly albite and nepheline normative. Watkinson & Wyllie (1971) studied the comparable system NaA1SiO4-CaCO3-H20 at 1 kb but found no liquid immiscibility along the join nephelinecalcite. Had higher pressures been used, the experiments of Freestone & Hamilton (1980) indicate that liquid immiscibility would have been observed. Besides revealing the extent of liquid immiscibility in certain silicate-carbonate systems, these experiments showed (Fig. 8) that the silicate melt could have moderate quantities of dissolved carbonates, the proportion varying with water and Ca contents. In contrast, the carbonate melt usually had only about 5~ dissolved silicates. The proportion of silicate in carbonate melts and carbonate in silicate melts decreases as the temperature reduces. These distributions of one component dissolved in another correspond closely to those seen in natural ijolites and carbonatites. Calcite is sometimes observed as a late-stage trace constituent in ijolites, urtites and nepheline syenites, and fluid inclusions trapped in apatites in ijolites also reveal the presence of carbonates early in the history of crystallization of those melts (Rankin & Le Bas 1974a). Introducing K into the phase system likewise permits liquid immiscibility (Wendlandt & Harrison 1979). P and Ti also enhance the occurrence of liquid immiscibilityby increasing the polymerization of the melt (Freestone 1978; Mysen e t al. 1981). P is particularly relevant to carbonatites which are often rich in apatite. Because previous experiments did not contain a pyroxene component, Verwoerd (1978) carried out melting experiments at 2 kb on compositions along the join synthetic ijolite (5acmite +3 nepheline + 2 Na-disilicate) and an Na-Ca-natrocarbonatite end-member in order to obtain synethtic melts close to those of natural compositions. The results confirmed the liquid immiscibility shown by Koster van Groos & Wyllie. Freestone & Hamilton (1980) furthered the study of liquid immiscibility by conducting experiments over the range 0.7-7.6 kb and 9001250~ Using natural nephelinite and phonolite starting materials from Oldoinyo Lengai, together with a simplified synthetic natrocarbonatite, they showed that liquid immiscibility occurs between relatively polymerized and depolymerized liquids
and that both nephelinite and phonolite magmas are immiscible with alkali-rich carbonate melts (Fig. 9). Increasing the pressure widened the immiscibilityfield and increased the partitioning of Mg into the carbonate fraction but decreased that of K. Decreasing the temperature also widened the immiscibilitygap. Most nephelinites and phonolites of carbonatite complexes plot near the solvus for 7.6 kb at 1100~ (Fig. 9). These conditions are interpreted as those closest to the natural ones. Bedson (1983) took the experiments further, extending the pressure range to 25 kb. Amongst various distribution coefficients measured, he found that the rare earths were approximately equally distributed between the silicate and carbonate liquids, but that Ta, and more particularly Hf, were enriched in the silicate liquid. Hence immiscible silicate melts coexisting with carbonate melts should have high Hf/Ta ratios, a feature which would not be consistent with crystal fractionation of carbonate melt from silicate (Bedson 1984). Not enough data exist to test this hypothesis at present. Some early experiments by Brey & Green (1976) suggested the possibility that liquid immiscibility might occur between olivine melilitite and carbonatite, but later work (Brey 1978) showed that this was not the case. Similarly, no evidence has been found that kimberlite and carbonatite are related by liquid immiscibility. Natural evidence
At Fen and Aln6 the ijolitic and carbonatitic components do not crop out as discrete intrusions. Instead, the early ijolites and associated fenites are intruded and refenitized by carbonatites. Since the intrusion of carbonatite is frequently A
NazO + K20
IX iquids
~/ /
II
0.7/ ~.> / / /,i L . ~ "
Si02 + AI205
r~o~_
~ i
wt. %
/SOl
X
\\ \
CaO
FIG. 9. Liquid immiscibilityplot showing silicate fields I-VIII (described in the text p. 68) and the natrocarbonatite field IX around the two-liquid boundaries for 0.7, 3.0 and 7.6 kb at 1100~
67
Nephelinites and carbonatites accompanied by extensive brecciation, the ijolites are fragmented and at Fen, where the original extent of the ijolite intrusion was at least 2 km across, relatively unaltered ijolitic and melteigitic rocks are now present only in a small area (less than 1 km across) around Melteig farm in the SW corner of the complex. The rest are permeated and veined by carbonatite, giving the impression that a complete spectrum of compositions from pure silicate to pure carbonate rocks exists with the carbonate as a late-stage component. Tveitasite, hollaite, kasenite and ringite are local names given to these mixed rocks, but since they are hybrid rocks the names are of little value. In some complexes the ijolite and carbonatite intrusions do not penetrate each other but form discrete intrusions. The type locality of ijolite at Iivaara in NE Finland (Lehijarvi 1960) is one such discrete 2 km wide plug, with no signs of carbonatite at the surface. Carbonatites can also form discrete intrusions, as in the 5 km diameter pipe at Sokli on the west flank of the Kola ultraalkaline province (Vartiainen 1980). The field relations in E Africa show distinct bimodality of the intrusions (Le Bas 1977). Most intrusions combine discrete ijolitic and carbonatitic components with few or no hybrids. The clearest example is the Usaki complex (Le Bas 1977) which is an ijolite ring complex 3 km across with micro-ijolite marginal facies but with no development of carbonatite or calcite ijolite (i.e. an ijolite with more than 10% calcite). A few samples do show late-stage interstitial calcite (about 1%) as well as a few calcite veins, and this calcite is interpreted as being the residue of the few per cent of carbonate remaining dissolved in the silicate melt after the immiscible separation of the carbonate melt. The carbonatite partner of this ijolite is the Wasaki subvolcanic complex which occurs 5 km away to the north. The bimodality is particularly well marked on the rare occasions when extrusive volcanic products are preserved. At Oldoinyo Lengai the lavas are either silicate (nephelinite to phonolite) or carbonate. Parallels of this bimodal behaviour are seen in the extrusive products of all other known volcanic structures, even the newly discovered structure on the Cape Verde Islands (Silva et al. 1981). Fluid inclusions provide another line of evidence that liquid immiscibility can separate carbonate and silicate magmas. During heating and homogenization experiments on fluid inclusions contained in the apatite crystals of E African ijolites, a sequence was observed showing liquid immiscibility actually taking place in the heating stage under the microscope (Rankin & Le Bas 1974b). At 960~ a homogeneous liquid
filled the negative-crystal-shaped cavity of the fluid inclusion, but at 950~ small globules appeared and by 800~ the globules had solidified to silicate glass. At 575~ the remaining liquid solidified and instantaneously crystallized to a strongly birefringent mesh of elongated carbonate crystals. Further evidence of immiscibility comes from fluid inclusions in apatites within ijolite, which have bulk compositions close to natrocarbonatite (Le Bas & Aspden 1981). The ijolite-inclusion tie-line (Fig. 10, Ij-IC) attests that the relation is one of liquid immiscibility. It is interpreted that nephelinite magma was constrained in its crystallization path by being on the solvus and that, as it progressively crystallized, so it lost by immiscibility more of its small content of dissolved carbonate. Since the change in bulk chemical composition of the silicate melt as it migrated along the solvus was governed by loss of Ca (precipitation of diopsidic aegirine-augite and apatite), it moved towards urtite (Fig. 10, Ur). During this process the carbonate liquid became richer in Ca (Fig. 10, UC). Hence it is recognized that not only do droplets ofcarbonatite liquid separate from crystallizing nephelinite magma but also the droplets change composition with fractionation of that magma. One criterion for liquid immiscibility is that, not only must the two liquids be in equilibrium with each other, but so also must any additional phase. Several s6vitic carbonatites contain olivine, e.g. Aln6, Jacupiranga, Kaiserstuhl, Mbeya, Oka and Palaborwa, and, where measured, they lie in the range Fo95_ss. This range is similar to those in co-magmatic olivine ijolites, olivinites and olivine-bearing nephelinites. Such composiA
84
Na20 + K20
t, NCb i
~iIc
/-.// / S[O2+ AI203
'JIj
/ ,liquid
\ CoO
FIG. 10. Plot as Fig. 9 showing joins of silicate host and carbonate fluid inclusions for ijolite (Ij-IC) and urtite (Ur-UC) compared with the solvus for 3 kb at 1100~ NCbl and NCb2 are the span of natrocarbonatite analyses from Oldoinyo Lengai.
68
M. J. Le Bas
tions are in keeping with the proposition that the carbonate and silicate magmas could be related by immiscibility. Liquid immiscibility is also demonstrated by cryptic variation in the apatites in carbonatites and ijolitic rocks. Apatites precipitating from ensuing fractions of silicate magmas take different paths from those in fractionating carbonatite magmas, although all commence at a composition common to both silicate and carbonate hosts (Le Bas & Handley 1979). If the ijolites and carbonatites were related by fractional crystallization, a solid-solution phase crystallizing throughout would be expected to show a continuous variation throughout. Lapin & Vartiainen (1983), in their study of apatites from Finnish orbicular carbonatites, also reached this conclusion.
Relation between magmas and the system (Si + AI)-(Na + K)-Ca The carbonate-saturated system (Si + A1)-(Na + K)-Ca reported by Freestone & Hamilton (1980) accounts for 75%-85~ of the components of ultra-alkaline rocks and is therefore suitable for discussion here. When the compositions of common igneous rocks as well as ultra-alkaline rocks are plotted on this phase system using solvus relations at 1100~ (Fig. 9), a significant distribution is seen. This temperature is chosen because melting experiments by Piotrowski & Edgar (1970) on W Kenyan nephelinites, ijolites and nepheline syenites showed that liquidus temperatures lay in the range 1100-1200~ at 1 arm pressure, with solidus temperatures of about 950-1000~ and liquid immiscibility operates only above solidus temperatures. Figure 9 shows that, apart from some unusual rock types (fields IIa and IIb), most compositions are confined to the (Si + A1) corner with fields II and III lining up along an apparent boundary parallel but lower down in the diagram than the 7.6 kb solvus. Assuming an approximately regular interval between the solvus isobars, the apparent boundary can be taken at about 10 kb. The first significant feature is that it is the nephelinites and ijolites (field II) and phonolites and nepheline syenites (field III) which abut the solvus, and that all the other common rock compositions plot away from the solvus. This distribution supports the proposition that, if experimentally determined tie-lines are used (Freestone & Hamilton 1980), only these strongly alkaline compositions are possible candidates for liquids which could be conjugate with C a - N a - K carbonate liquids (field IX).
A second feature is that olivine nephelinites, melanephelinites and melilite nephelinites (field I) do not apparently lie on the solvus, although they could do so at higher pressures or lower temperatures, both of which enlarge the twoliquid field. The latter case of a lower temperature is petrologically unrealistic, but having mafic magmas of field I on the solvus at higher pressure is quite possible in the conditions envisaged for magma chambers deep in the crust. Even if these nephelinitic compositions were not on the solvus, they could become so after slight fractionation to field II compositions. This distinction perhaps explains why melanephelinites are associated with carbonatites but olivine nephelinites, which seldom fractionate, do not have accompanying carbonatites, it being assumed that the nephelinites were carbonated in the first place. It is further possible that if an olivine nephelinite rose high into the crust and then did fractionate, the magma would not impinge on the solvus and carbonatite could be produced by fractional crystallization. Syenites (field IV) also plot away from the proposed solvus whilst nepheline syenites plot on it, and this relation corresponds to the known absence and presence respectively of carbonatites with these rocks in the field. A third feature is that melilitites (field V) and kimberlites (field VI) lie well away from the proposed solvus, in keeping with the known geology of melilitite and kimberlite occurrences. Likewise basalts, andesites and rhyolites (fields VII and VIII) cannot produce carbonatites by liquid immiscibility. Fields IIa (alnoite) and IIb (urtite) are interesting exceptions. Alnoite is a frequent accessory magma in carbonatitic complexes and is itself commonly strongly carbonated. It is suggested that alnoite could be the fractionated product of olivine-melilite nephelinite which had penetrated high into the crust and from which the late-stage carbonate-rich residue had not separated. Urtite (field IIb) is rare even when compared with the ijolite in which it occurs, usually as minor intrusions at relatively high levels in the ijolitic plutons. It is proposed that urtite can result from liquid immiscibility taking place in an ijolite pluton at mid-crustal levels. The low Ca content of urtite compared with ijolite (Fig. 9) is consistent with loss of a C a - N a rich carbonate fraction by liquid immiscibility. This is further corroborated by the composition of the carbonate fluid inclusions trapped in urtite which are relatively Ca-rich compared with those trapped in ijolite, as shown in Fig. 10. Many of these possibilities must remain speculative until the important constituents Fe, Ti, P, F and oxygen fugacity are incorporated into the system.
69
Nephelinites and carbonatites
TABLE 6. Analyses of typical carbonatites (wt.~)
Carbonatites Despite the fact that nearly all the carbonatites of the world are calcite or dolomite-rich, the primary and parental carbonatitic magmas produced by liquid immiscibility are considered to be strongly alkaline, akin to natrocarbonatite. Twyman & Gittins (1987), however, do not consider natrocarbonatite to be either primary or produced by liquid immiscibility. The close agreement between the experimental work described above leaves no doubt that liquid immiscibility must be significant and that the primary composition is rich in Na + K. The fact that fluid inclusions trapped in early apatites in carbonatites are alkali-rich (Rankin 1975, 1977) lends further support. Most carbonatitic complexes display a wide variety of carbonatites. Field work invariably shows that the earliest intrusions are s6vites, with later alvikites and then ferrocarbonatites. N a - K fenitization is usually confined to the s6vite. Alvikites rarely show fenitization and ferrocarbonatites never show it. S6vites occasionally form diatremes 1-3 km in diameter. More usually they are tens or hundreds of metres across, while alvikites and ferrocarbonatites occur in swarms of dykes and veins.
Natrocarbonatite
1
SiO2 TiO2
AI203 Fe203 MnO MgO CaO Na20 K20 P205 CO2 F C1 SO3 SrO BaO REE
2
3
4
0.05 0.88 0 . 1 6 6 . 1 2 0.01 0.18 0 . 0 7 0 . 6 8 0.11 0.37 0 . 1 7 1.31 0.41 2.62 4.04 7.55 0.48 0.39 0.41 0 . 7 5 0.48 0.31 0.67 12.75 14.43 53.60 51.20 29.03 33.89 0.09 0 . 2 5 0.14 8.39 0.03 0.01 0.79 0.93 3.18 1.52 2 . 6 6 30.53 38.38 39.50 37.03 0.09 2.71 0.06 - . . 3.81 Trace . -0.89 2.88 - 1.35 0.23 0 . 1 0 0.01 0.08 0 . 1 7 0.11 1.26 0.05 0.3 ND c.0.1
5
6
3.24 0.83 0 . 0 0 0.07 0.20 0.65 11.50 11.00 5.18 5.53 10.74 0.36 25.85 43.60 -0.05 -0.06 1.27 0.42 32.62 30.42 --. 0.49 - 0 . 7 3 0.07 2.48 >4.0 2.82 c. 1.5
All analyses sum to 100 __+1.7 (LOI included). 1, Natrocarbonatite lava, 1960 eruption, Oldoinyo Lengai, N Tanzania (Gittins & McKie 1980); 2, s6vite dyke, Tundulu, Malawi (Garson 1965, p. 24); 3, alvikite cone sheet, Homa Mountain, W Kenya (Le Bas 1977, p. 317 (HC629) traces by C. Barber, unpublished); 4, dolomite carbonatite (beforsite dyke), Aln6, Sweden (von Eckermann 1948, p. 122); 5, ferrocarbonatite (high Mg), Kangankunde, Malawi (Garson 1965, p. 54); 6, ferrocarbonatite (low Mg), Homa Mountain, W Kenya (Le Bas 1977, p. 318 (HF15) traces by C. Barber, unpublished).
magma
The chemical composition of parental natrocarbonatite is still uncertain. Table 6, column 1, gives the composition of natrocarbonatite extruded from Oldoinyo Lengai in 1960. This is the only known instance of fresh carbonatite lava, and its composition (CC, 30 wt.~; NC, 58 wt.%; KC, 12 wt.~o) when plotted on Fig. 9 (field IX) indicates that it is the conjugate melt with phonolite magma, as interpreted by Freestone & Hamilton (1980). The conjugate carbonate melt with nephelinite would, according to them, be more calcic, but no natural examples are known except perhaps at Kaiserstuhl (Keller 1981). O and C isotopes confirm the igneous nature of natrocarbonatite and indicate a temperature of crystallization in the range 400-800~ (Suwa et aL 1975). Natrocarbonatite has been described in detail by Dawson (1962), Du Bois et al. (1963), Cooper et al. (1975), McKie & Frankis (1977) and Gittins & McKie (1980). It is porphyritic with large clear platy crystals of nyerereite ((Na,K)2Ca(CO3) 2 solid solution) and large brownish rounded crystals of gregoryite (Na2CO3 with some Ca + K substitution for Na) in a glassy carbonate matrix containing quench needles of nyerereite.
Table 7 gives a modal analysis of a sample collected by N. J. Guest from the 1960 eruption. Older examples of carbonatitic lavas or their pyroclastic equivalents have recently been discovered. Deans & Roberts (1984) described carbonatite tufts and lava clasts from the Miocene volcano at Tinderet in Kenya in which flowaligned calcified nyerereite crystals were identified. At one time they were thought to be pseudomorphs after melilite, and although relict nyerereite has never been found (nor will it be since it is water soluble) further textural study leaves little doubt that the platy cavernous pseudomorphs, largely composed of myriads of small calcite crystals, are after nyerereite. Such pseudomorphs are now also known in lavas at Kerimasi in N Tanzania, and suspected at Homa Mountain and the Ruri Hills, W Kenya, at Kruidfontein, S Africa, and in the Cape Verde Islands. The platy pseudomorphs at Kerimasi volcano described by Mariano & Roeder (1983) were identified on textural features by Hay (1983) as former nyerereite crystals. They coexist with fresh tablet-shaped calcite phenocrysts. Although both pseudomorphs and phenocrysts are com-
7o
M. J. Le Bas
TABLE 7. Modes ofnatrocarbonatites (volume ~ ) Oldoinyo Kerimasi, Lengai, Tanzania Tanzania 82-8-15A2
Kerimasi, Tanzania 82-8-14C6
Kerimasi, Tanzania 83-7-26A
Tinderet, Kenya L. KIP 1
Tinderet, Kenya U. KIP 3
Kaiserstuhl, S Germany, and Fort Portal, W Uganda
A few Abundant
9.3 2.7
Very few Abundant
Abundant None
Phenocrysts Calcite Nyerereite Gregoryite
Nil 38.1 48.0
29.7 67.0 1
7.6 46.0 __
Groundmass Calcite Nyerereite Opaques Apatite Perovskite Pyrochlore
-6.02 1.1 ----
2.8 -0.3 0.2 Trace --
46.33 Trace Trace ---
Interstitial glassa
6.8
--
--
c.50 m
7.1 79.3 0.7 0.4
m
0.5 m
1, not identified in thin section; 2, may include groundmass gregoryite; 3, Cc" N y ~ 1 1 4, includes quench nyerereite. posed of calcite, electron diffraction microprobe analysis (Table 8) distinguishes the typical igneous calcite with high Sr from that in the pseudomorphs which have low Sr but detectable Mg and Na. This distinction, the interpretation that the pseudomorphs cannot be after calcite, the relations known from the C a - N a - K carbonate system (Fig. 11) and the probable liquid immiscibility relations shown in Fig. 9 all confirm the identification. The modal variation of natrocarbonatites (Table 7) shows that these lavas can have a wide range of compositions, assuming that the phenocryst phases are complete and cognate. By using the phase data of the synthetic C a - N a - K carbonate system at I kb (Fig. 11) determined by Cooper et al. (1975), it can be seen that the natrocarbonatite of Oldoinyo Lengai plots in field A on Fig. 11, but the Kerimasi and Tinderet
lavas are more calcic, since both nyerereite and calcite are precipitated, and plot in the field B. Clasts from the Cape Verde Islands also appear to plot in field B. The occurrences of carbonatite lava at Kaiserstuhl in S Germany (Keller 1981) and at Fort Portal in W Uganda (in samples kindly provided by P. H. Nixon) show phenocrysts of calcite alone. This cannot easily be reconciled with the two-liquid field system shown in Fig. 9 and the liquidus surfaces of Fig. 11 unless the lavas were relatively N a poor. It is concluded that a wide variety of natrocarbonatite magmas can exist. Some occur with gregoryite and nyerereite phenocrysts, indicating compositions appropriate to immiscible liquids conjugate with phonolite magma, as at Oldoinyo Lengai. Some have nyerereite phenocrysts alone or with calcite (Table 7), appropriate to immiscible liquids conjugate with nephelinite magma.
TABLE 8. Microprobe analytical data on Kerismasi natrocarbonatites Brown pseudomorphs
Clear calcite crystals 1
MgO CaO S~ Na20
BD 55.1• 0.7• BD
2
BD 54.8• 0.7• BD
3
BD 51.5• 0.6• BD
4
0.8• 48.3• BD 0.5•
5
0.4• 50.6• BD BD
1 and 2, Large phenocrysts in lava (samples 82-8-14C6 and 83-7-26A respectively); 3, groundmass quench prismatic crystal (sample 83-7-26A); 4 and 5, two large pseudomorphs replaced partly by granules of calcite and partly by voids (with 1 and 2 respectively). Each analysis is the mean of four points with standard deviation to 2tr. The energy dispersive microprobe analyses were performed using the Cambridge Microscan Mk.5 at the University of Leicester. BD = below detection limit.
Nephelinites and carbonatites
/
/
NazCOs
/ K2Ca(CO3)2
Gry/(~A"XNyr/~ \\ / ~ ) ~ ~/ .) CaCOs No2Co(C03)2 Na2C%(C05)3
FIG. 11. CC-NC-KC carbonatite system showing field of natrocarbonatites from Oldoinyo Lengai (A) and from Kerimasi and Tinderet (B). Gry and Nyr are plotted at the natural compositions of gregoryite and nyerereite minerals. NY is the end-member nyerereite Na2Ca(CO3)2. FC is fairchildite K2Ca(CO3)2. (After Cooper et al. 1975).
Natrocarbonatites contain few minerals apart from carbonates. The few include oxide and phosphate minerals, but no silicates apart from rare biotite. Deans & Roberts (1984) report 15 wt.~o SiO2 and up to 5~o modal silicates, often biotite, in the Tinderet lavas. Bedson (1983) too usually found 1-5 wt.~ SiO z in his experimental carbonate charges. A120 3 was also present but was even more weakly partitioned into the carbonate melt. Biotite is the most frequent silicate mineral encountered, but only in accessory proportions. In some s6vitic carbonatites, mica and other silicates, particularly mildly sodic augite sometimes rimmed by aegirine, become abundant, and these rocks are the metacarbonatites. Vartiainen (1980) described a collar 2 km wide of metacarbonatite (average SiO2 content, 25 wt.~) around the s6vite core 2 km in diameter at Sokli. Armbrustmacher (1979) described petrographically similar rocks in Colorado, and Robbins & Tysseland (1983) have described silicocarbonatites (metacarbonatites) derived from gabbros at Pollen in N Norway. Metacarbonatites are interpreted to be 'reaction rocks' between magmatic carbonatite and country rock; the resulting 'mixed rock' is often up to 70~o calcite. Similar reactions, but on a smaller scale, are known in nearly all s6vites, and the products are often incorporated as xenoliths in s6vite intrusions. The experimentally determined distribution coefficients of elements between immiscible car-
71
bonate and silicate melts (Freestone & Hamilton 1980; Bedson 1983) help explain some of the observed variability. P partitions strongly into the carbonate melt, and hence nephelinites are often poor in apatite while the early s6vites are rich in apatite. Carbonatite lavas, however, always have less apatite than predicted by the above. Apatite is a dense mineral (specific gravity, 3.1) whereas carbonatite magma has a very low density of 2.2 g cm- 3 (Nesbitt & Kelly 1977), and therefore it is not surprising that apatite attains eruption less commonly. The partition of Mg between silicate and carbonate melts depends mainly on Pco2. At 7.6 kb Mg appears to partition preferentially into the carbonate (the data are poor), but at low pressure (1-3 kb) it partitions into the silicate. The distribution coefficient of K is never far from unity, unlike Na and Ca which both partition strongly into the carbonate melt. This causes a fall in the Na/K ratio of the silicate magma after the separation of carbonatite. Sr also partitions preferentially into the carbonate melt, particularly in the lower-temperature range 600-700~ but the Ca/Sr ratio remains unaltered in all melts (Koster van Groos 1975). Greater pressures increase the partition of REE into carbonate melt, with more light REE than heavy REE. This gives the steep REE pattern typical of carbonatites, but the steepness can vary considerably depending on the temperature at the time of separation (Bedson 1984). Intrusive carbonatites
The intrusion of carbonatite in pipe-like structures usually follows that of the silicate rocks (Fig. 12). The commonest carbonatite is s6vite showing adcumulate texture, and it is normally composed of 90~-100}/o calcite (Table 6). Dolomite may occur instead, particularly in older and more deeply eroded complexes, in keeping with the fact that dolomite is not stable at depths less than about 2 km at carbonatite magmatic temperatures (600-800~ Periclase occurs in the Amba Dongar and Kerimasi shallow-seated carbonatites. Common accessory minerals in carbonatites are fluorapatite, magnetite, biotite, pyrochlore and olivine, and some less-common minerals are aegirine-augite, arfvedsonite, K-feldspar, pyrite, zircon, baddeleyite, perovskite, sphene, quartz, fluorite, baryte, bastnaesite, parisite and monazite. The last six minerals occur mainly in the late-stage carbonatites, the ferrocarbonatites, while the remainder can usually be found in the earlier and more abundant carbonatites. There is a noticeable lack of sodic minerals
M. J. Le Bas
72 0
~,
.
4 0 0 0 t_ |
L
3 0 0 0 [I
NAPAK
,
5 [
-...--~--J~--~
+ + + +'+
metres above sea-level
/ ~ o~\~
~\c 9~J . ~'G'
, ,~o\~~ ~ \ \ ~
.~,~'~ /I --oba b~e-~ ~ '
2ooo t - _ ~ 1000~+
, l .Km
+ -r+
\
~o.~;' . . . . . . . . . . 9
Vole~
I "] -
. . . . . . .
~
UI~ A / t-IIM
~..
LOKUPOI
~eg~,,z,~" ~~ .,e o4 s u b -
-~ .
.-.n,~ ~o~
"oo @
_I
~"
J ""
~
"--.. " - ~
J
- q
+ + + + + /
Fenitized
~.
1/
basement
/ Ijolite
~ Carbonatite
~, Basement
FIG. 12. Cross-section of Napak nephelinite-carbonatite volcanic complex in E Uganda. The structure is typical of such complexes. (After King 1949.) and few potassic ones, considering the abundance of Na and K in parental natrocarbonatite. The Na and K are lost by metasomatic reaction of the early carbonatites with country rock to form fenites. Therefore the carbonatites seen cropping out are not products of the complete magma less any volatiles but have also lost their original complement of alkalis (Table 6). In the case of adcumulate s6vites the loss could have accompanied the escape of the intercumulus material. The loss of alkalis unfortunately masks the original alkali content of the parental natrocarbonatite, and therefore it is not possible to decide whether the carbonate immiscibly separated from a nephelinite or a phonolite melt. However, in some complexes (e.g. Ruri Hills, W Kenya) there is a close temporal association of phonolite and carbonatite intrusions, which could thus be pairs of conjugate immiscible liquids. The immiscible separation of carbonate melt from silicate melt takes place at l l00-1000~ This is well above the liquidus temperature for the carbonate component of the melt, but not above that for olivine and apatite. Both olivine and prismatic apatite therefore precipitate from carbonatite magma and under these conditions form cumulates at the base of the intrusions such as those occurring in Kola. Not only are olivine and apatite much denser (specific gravity of 3.3 and 3.1 respectively) than carbonatite magma (specific gravity, 2.2), but carbonatite magma has an unusually low viscosity of 5x 10-2 P (Treiman & Schedl 1983) permitting efficient gravity settling. If oxidizing conditions prevail, magnetite may also precipitate and accumulate. The carbonate liquidus is encountered at 500600~ This temperature is gauged from homogenization studies on fluid inclusions trapped in apatites (Rankin 1975, 1977). These apatites are not the prismatic crystals which accumulated from the early phase of cooling but are the large ovoid apatite crystals which characterize s6vite. This temperature is in general agreement with the liquidus temperatures determined by Wyllie and others for carbonatite magma. The low
temperatures are also marked by fenitization of the thermal aureole around the carbonatite, in which low albite, orthoclase, microcline, phlogopite and arfvedsonite commonly occur. With cooling of a carbonatite intrusion, fractionation of s6vite to alvikite to ferrocarbonatite takes place, with a final small-scale development of calcite carbonatite which lithologically looks like s6vite but is devoid of the usual accessory mineralogy characteristic of normal s6vite. This sequence is observed in E Africa (Le Bas 1977), in the U.S.S.R (Kapustin 1981), the Chilwa Province of Malawi (Garson 1965) and elsewhere. A variant on this occurs when the carbonatite is dolomitic. In this case the sequence is s6vite to dolomite carbonatite to ferrocarbonatite. These sequences accord with Wyllie's (1965) experiments. Olivine (Foss_90), rarely monticellite and very rarely melilite are restricted to the earlier and deeper calcite carbonatites (s6vites). Apatite and pyrochlore can crystallize throughout the sequence of carbonatites but are most abundant in the early s6vites, with apatite sometimes being so abundant that it forms apatite rock. Such apatite deposits have been mined. Apatite rock also occurs as disrupted schlieren in s6vite and dolomite carbonatite where they are dragged and folded by the magmatic flow. These apatites are almost completely deficient in Sr and REE and can be matched with microfragments of similar textured apatite rock caught up in the nephelinitic lavas. The main apatite in the s6vites occurs as large slightly resorbed crystals which have much the same contents of Sr and La as the apatite phenocrysts in nephelinitic lavas, as is appropriate to the postulated liquid-immiscible relation. Lapin & Vartiainen (1983) similarly describe olivine, apatite and magnetite which have fractionated from carbonatite. Biotite can occur in all intrusive carbonatites, as can pyroxenes and amphiboles, but they are more frequent in the early s6vites and dolomitic carbonatiteso Biotite flakes, often with margins oxidized to opaque oxides, together with magne-
Nephelinites and carbonatites tite phenocrysts can also occur in carbonatite lavas such as those near Fort Portal in SW Uganda. Feldspar, usually potassic but sometimes sodic, occurs in the margins of s6vitic and dolomitic carbonatites and is derived from the enveloping feldspathic fenite. Many but not all s6vites carry 1%-2~ of euhedral magnetite microphenocrysts which often coexist with biotite, apatite and pyrochlore. The magnetite is Ti poor with usually only 1-2 wt.% TiO2, and at Jacupiranga, Brazil, the magnetites in the s6vites are zoned with decreasing contents of Ti towards the rims. MnO and MgO, both of which usually show contents of less than 1 wt.~ and less than 4 wt.~ respectively, also decrease with the zoning. Magnetites in the later intrusive phases of carbonatite have compositions comparable with these outer zones and are also pure magnetite (Prins 1972; Gaspar & Wyllie 1983a). Ilmenite is rare in carbonatites and has very variable Mg, Mn and Nb contents. At Jacupiranga, Brazil, where it coexists with magnetite in the reaction zone betweenjacupirangite (titaniferous pyroxenite) and later s6vite, Gaspar & Wyllie (1983b) have calculated an equilibration temperature of 570-595~ with oxygen fugacities of 10- lS'5-10-19.5 atm, which are similar to the values estimated by Prins (1972) for magnetites from a variety of African carbonatites (540-575~ 10- 23-10- 24 atm). Alvikites are medium grained compared with the coarse-grained s6vites and are less voluminous, although in some complexes they appear to be very abundant because they form numerous but thin minor dykes and cone-sheets which comprise the majority of the outcrop. The mineralogy of alvikites is similar to that of s6vite, with a tendency for alvikite to have fewer accessory oxide and silicate minerals. The principal difference lies in the calcite which, in alvikite, was slightly ferroan when it crystallized. Probe analysis of the calcite often fails to reveal this ferroan character, evidently because the iron has unmixed from the calcite structure as a result of late-stage processes to which all carbonatites are prone. In such cases the iron is visible only as minute black specks scattered throughout the carbonatite quite separate from any magnetite microphenocrysts, and as brown staining along the crystal boundaries of the calcites. Alvikites are also marked by slightly greater contents of Mn, Ba and REE (Table 6). These elements appear to be in solid solution in the carbonate minerals. The apatites in alvikites are also rich in REE as well as Sr. True alvikites usually have a pale brownish colour, reflecting the Mn and Fe contents. Some, however, are white, like s6vite, and these commonly do not
73
contain as much Mn, Fe, Ba and REE as true alvikites and are in fact micros~vites. The distinction in the field is not easy as the brown coloration is often obscured by secondary processes, but trace-element analysis of the rock or probe analysis of the apatite can reveal the distinction. Much of the economic wealth of carbonatites lies in the ferrocarbonatites. The primary carbonate mineral of ferrocarbonatite is ankeritic, but with weathering much of it breaks down to secondary calcite or dolomite rimmed by iron oxides. Ferrocarbonatite occurs in only minor quantities in most complexes, and appears as thin brown dykes and veins with chilled margins and cross-cutting relations against earlier carbonatites. There are many good examples in E Africa, Malawi, Aln6 and the Cape Verde Islands. In other cases ferrocarbonatites form diffuse veins and patches apparently replacing s6vites, and are considered to be a late-stage development of the magmatic ferrocarbonatite. This residue of carbonatite magma appears to have become so rich in volatiles that it no longer behaved as a melt but as a volatile-rich fluid. Brown ferrocarbonatitic material can be seen progressively penetrating coarse calcite and dolomite carbonatites, migrating along crystal boundaries and gradually replacing the calcite and dolomite. The replacement process can go to completion, and if it begins along a fracture, as it usually does, the end-product can be a parallel-sided zone a metre or so wide which can look rather like a crosscutting dyke. This process can be seen replacing s/Svite in Kenya, Malawi and Fen. At Newania, India, and Sarfartoq, W Greenland, it replaces dolomite carbonatite. The apatites in the ferrocarbonatites also provide evidence for the replacement process. The cryptic variation shown by apatite is usually recorded by increases in REE, which reach a maximum in the ferrocarbonatites, but often the apatite in ferrocarbonatite lies compositionally in the alvikite and sometimes s6vite fields. This is consistent with the interpretation that many ferrocarbonatites were formerly alvikites subsequently transformed and mineralized. Mineralization
Four stages of mineralization can be recognized, all following on the magmatic Fe-enrichment (and Mn-enrichment) stage of ferrocarbonatite development. The first stage of mineralization is the production of REE-rich carbonatites from residual Frich magmas (Moiler et al. 1980; Samoylov & Smirnova 1980; Viladkar & Dulski 1986). The
74
M. J. Le Bas
REE minerals segregate in pockets and fractures along sheet-like ferrocarbonatite bodies. The minerals, principally bastnaesite ((Ce,La)FCO3), appear as pale-brown streaks within the darkerbrown to black ferrocarbonatite, and show strong light REE enrichment with La/Yb ratios of 1001000. U - T h radioactivity and associated fluorite or baryte are usually indications of the presence of REE minerals. Nearly all carbonatite complexes show this mineralization to some extent. The largest is at Mountain Pass, California, where Sr-rich carbonatites have more than 10% bastnaesite and other REE fluorcarbonate minerals cut by barytebearing and silicified radioactive veins (Olsen et al. 1954). Experiments by Jones & Wyllie (1983) suggest that the bastnaesite could have been precipitated from a low-temperature carbonatite magma (perhaps about 500~ or less). The Kangankunde carbonatite in Malawi has a similar REE mineralization but with Sr > Ba. Following the formation of the replacement ferrocarbonatites is the second-stage mineralization associated with late-stage fluids and the precipitation of fluorite at lower temperatures (100-200~ (Roedder 1973). Massive fluorite usually forms along fractures, particularly in the roof zones of carbonatitic complexes. It is variously purple, yellow or colourless, and can also occur as scattered crystals in the early carbonatites adjacent to the fractures along which the fluids passed. Evidently, F-rich fluids penetrated into the wall-rocks. At Kruidfontein near Johannesburg and at Amba Dongar, India, the F-rich fluids rose to the top of the carbonatite complex and entered and mineralized the fractured rocks capping the complex. At Kruidfontein the fluids penetrated up into bedded carbonatitic tufts sitting in a volcanic caldera structure and formed fluorite-rich horizons interbedded with the tufts. The third stage is the formation of baryte. It is present in nearly all carbonatite complexes and follows closely on the formation of fluorite with which it commonly occurs but in much smaller quantities. Local concentrations do occur and have been mined (e.g. at Aln6, Sweden). The Ba, F and REE are all mantle derived. They are not products of assimilation of continental crust, as it is sometimes considered for the Curich mineralization at the Palaborwa carbonatite in S Africa, because exactly similar Ba, F and REE mineralization is known in the Cape Verde Islands which are seated directly on oceanic crust (Le Bas 1984). The fourth stage of mineralization is marked by the formation of U - T h minerals together with pervasive silicification. This mineralization is
never very extensive and is characterized by low U/Th ratios which makes some deposits uneconomic (e.g. Loe-Shilman, N W Pakistan (Jan et al. 1981)). This is often followed by late-stage calcite veining and reprecipitation of Fe oxides, usually hematite. The Fe is derived from ferrocarbonatites penetrated by hydrothermal fluids. If the fluids become locally all-pervasive, assisted by incursions of groundwaters, then large hematite deposits can form. The Rodberg iron deposit at Fen, S Norway, is an example of this process (Andersen 1984). These Fe deposits are distinct from the magnetite deposits such as that at Kovdor, Karelia, U.S.S.R., which is a product of primary magmatic precipitation.
Fenitization The products of fenitization are mineralogically syenitic, with the result that they are sometimes misidentified as igneous syenites. The chief points of distinction lie in the texture and structure. Syenitic fenites are often heterogeneous and show low-temperature deformation or shattering. With increasing metamorphic temperatures, schlieren and mechanical flow textures develop, and next to the igneous contact the fenites become coarse grained. The effects of fenitization are more extreme than those of ordinary contact metamorphism because the metasomatism causes strong chemical reactions which can totally obscure the original composition of the rock. As a result there are many theories of fenitic processes (King & Sutherland 1960; Woolley 1982). The key lies in the realization that fenitization is not a single process but is often multiple. The variables involved are (a) the geochemistry of the magma causing the metasomatism, (b) the nature of the fluids leaving the magma, (c) the depth profile of the magma (different reactions develop at different depths), (d) the porosity and structure of the country rocks being fenitized, (e) the mineralogy and geochemistry of the rocks being fenitized and (0 any water-rock reaction.
Syenitic fenites generated by ijolite Fenites are not seen around nephelinitic volcanic pipes and dykes, nor around xenoliths of country rock trapped in nephelinitic magma. Evidently time is insufficient for identifiable metasomatism to take place. However, fenites develop strongly around larger intrusive bodies of nephelinite magma that fractionate and crystallize to ijolite. Fenitic zones can often be identified around ijolite plutons, and Fig. 13 gives the typical
Nephelinites and carbonatites ORIGINAL MINE RA~.,~400
300
METRES 200
I
!
75 0
100 |
CONTACT
GRANODIORITE ZONE IT
ZONE I
=
ZONE 111"
ZONE
I
Quartz ~
Ae~i,rine- ou~lite Mognetite ]lmenite Oligoclose
'
Atbite (An3-s) i
Microcline
Orthoctose
_.
Biotite ,,, ~ Alk(:Ui FeldSpQr
Mesoperthlte & . . . . . o~tipe'rthite iNephetine . . . . .
.........
,
!
~
Pate brown biotite ,,I
; .
.
.
Phlogopite . . . .
.
W
I
I
i_j
tO Hornblende
~, s.0dic a..~hibote (,~Y,)
Sodic ;Qmphibote ' WoliQstonite ~"
~ SHATTERIN~L. w-
STRONG MORTAR
FENIT/ZEO
GRANULATION TEXTURES
GRANOOtoRITE
COMPLETE
& "-
GRANULATION
$YENtTh
FIG. 13. The mineralogical changes across the fenite zones surrounding ijolite in granodiorite. (After Rubie, in Le Bas 1977, p. 72.)
mineralogical changes that take place across the zones. The pyroxene grades from a weakly sodic aegirine-augite near the contact to almost pure aegirine in zone 1, and can form 5%-50~ of the rock. The feldspar near the contact is new hypersolvus alkali feldspar commonly in the range Orgo_6oAb60_40, but in the outer zones the original sub-solvus feldspars of the granitic basement survive. The hypersolvus character of the feldspars and sub-solidus texture of the fenites suggest fenitization temperatures of about 800~ Ijolite intrusion causes uplift of the country rocks. At one time it was thought that the uplift was related to the metasomatic transfer of material from magma to fenite, but Rubie (1982) has shown that in W Kenya the transfer of material, mainly SiOz, was from country rock to magma, and that granodiorite suffered a volume loss of up to 20~ near the contact. This results in the formation of feldspathized ijolite (petrographically equivalent to nepheline syenite) at the margin of ijolite intrusions (Fig. 14). Aluminium appears to have been almost immobile during fenitization, and the K / N a ratio
decreases slightly away from the contact with falling temperature (Rubie & Gunter 1983). Other studies have been based on the assumption that oxygen is immobile, a condition which approximates to a constant-volume fenitization (McKie 1966), but Appleyard & Woolley (1979) based their study of fenitization on a constant-specificgravity model which suggested, at the Borrolan syenite in N W Scotland and the Sokli carbonatite in N Finland, that modest volume increases had taken place. Carbonate 9minerals are rare in fenites around ijolites unless later carbonatite intrusions are present. Evidently the metasomatic solutions causing the fenitization were not carbonate bearing.
Syenitic fenites generated by carbonatite N a - K fenites around carbonatites are much more varied than those around ijolites. Only s6vites, dolomitic carbonatites and rarely micros6vites show fenitization. Alvikites and ferrocarbonatites almost never show fenitization, and this is
76
M. J. Le Bas +
+ +
+
BASEMENT IttLIIII IIIIIIIII1,, Nepheline-poor Nep~;~i;;-po, o:
_jr_
.....
+
--- =
,,
11111IT,iF-_--
x
lllrlll
-
--
•
IIII rr ;i-~-
Nepheline-ll
,,
x
•
'I[II[EIIJV-s'
+
" "
x "
inward d ffus on of Si during fenitization
Ii'/
~X_--~lllrelative
-.~
from less ldesilicified
~- '~1, basement
X
~/N,,~
/,, I
;^~J I
]l~lll(
~
~o.-o,,,o,,e
~'1
x
+
~
+
screen of chilled m c r o - j o te prevents diffusion of Si
X
-
-Jr-
Ix|/i!/
x
aegirine-rich
to
--~-_(!1 'jmore d e s i l i c i f i e d
rich fenite /
+ Jlil~
downward
-', =lllt~'"""~176o, ~,
lJ
I11111
from b a s e m e n t
FIG. 14. Schematic cross-section of ijolite intrusion with chilled margin and influx of silica during fenitization, and the development of feldspathized ijolite (mineralogicallyequivalent to nepheline syenite but texturally distinct) particularly along the upper parts of the margins. taken to indicate that early carbonatite magmas are alkali-rich but that these alkalis are lost during the early stages of carbonatite fractiona1 ~
0 + K20
/ -.6"D~ /
i' ;,,!gO + Fe20T
~k
~
A A
A
9
x X CaO
wt% FIG. 15. Carbonatite plot showing the path of
fractionation of carbonatite magma from natrocarbonatite (#) to s0vite (O) and alvikites ( x ) to beforsites and ferrocarbonatites (A): P, Fort Portal lava; T, estimated Tinderet lava; K, estimated Kerimasi lava (Table 7). (After Le Bas 1981.)
tion (Fig. 15). In some cases even the final phases of s0vite intrusion fail to cause fenitization. Evidently by that stage the s6vite magma has lost its alkalis, and instead could only brecciate the fenites formed earlier. This is contrary to the proposal that the concentration of alkalis increases during carbonatite fractionation (Twyman & Gittins 1987). Depth profiles are important. Fenitization around the topmost parts of a s6vite is strongly potassic, usually with the production of almost pure K-feldspar rock. Early records of this came from Malawi (Dixey et al. 1935), Songwe, Tanzania (Brown 1964), Kaiserstuhl, S Germany (Sutherland 1967) and Zambia (Bailey 1966). At Koga in Swat, N Pakistan, K-feldspar rock (plus rare aegirine) about 50 m thick completely caps a s0vite plug 500m across (Mian, personal communication). The K-feldspar is usually orthoclase Or87_9s, whereupon the rocks are termed orthoclasites (Sutherland 1965). Sometimes the K-rich feldspar is microcline, and Heinrich & Moore (1970) named such cases 'burnt rock' as they had that appearance. Commonly, the only other phase present is 1%-2~ of limonitic iron oxides, with calcite absent. The high K content is character-
Nephelinites and carbonatites istic of these fenites, whereas the K-feldspar developed in feldspathized ijolites and ijolitic fenites is less potassic (Or<87) (Le Bas 1984). When s6vites intrude mafic rocks, the fenites formed are phlogopite rich and not feldspar rich (Gittins et al. 1975), and it has been observed that, when s6vite cuts ijolite containing pyroxenite, the pyroxenite is phlogopitized and the ijolite is feldspathized, indicating that the Mg for the formation of phlogopite comes from the rock being fenitized and not from the carbonatite. Oxygen-isotope analyses on mineral pairs to determine temperature have yet to be made successfully, but X-ray diffraction of the K-rich feldspar indicates a low temperature of formation with obliquities up to 0.6 (Le Bas 1984). Haggerty & Mariano (1983) calculated a temperature of 500-550~ for the fenites around the Parana carbonatite, which agrees with that generally estimated from the mineralogy of carbonatitic fenites. In older and more deeply eroded complexes, the feldspathic fenites developed around so~ites are albite rich, sometimes coexisting with Mgarfvedsonite, aegirine and iron oxides. Such albitites occur around carbonatites in the fenitized quartzites at Turyi and in migmatites at Vuoriyarvi, both on the Kola Peninsula, and in gneisses at Novopoltavskoye between the Azov and Caspian Seas, U.S.S.R (Kapustin 1981). Albitite and aegirine-albite fenites are also formed from grits, granites and migmatites around the Sangu carbonatite in W Tanzania (Coetzee 1963). These albitite and albite-aegirine schists are lithologically similar to the syenitic fenites around the silicate complexes, but they can be distinguished mineralogically. The feldspar of fenites around carbonatites is almost pure albite (Ab>90) or almost pure orthoclase (Or>85), whereas the feldspar in the syenitic fenites around ijolite and syenite is an alkali feldspar Ab60_40 Or4o_60. The compositions reflect the low temperature of carbonatite fenitization (below 550~ in contrast with the higher temperatures of the silicate fenitization (more than 700~ Albitite also occurs as fragments brought up by carbonatitic volcanic breccias, e.g. Amba Dongar, India (Deans et al. 1972), and NyamajiWasaki, W Kenya (Le Bas 1977), indicating albite-rich fenites at depth whilst K-rich fenites are exposed at the surface. A similar zonation occurs around the Novopoltavskoye carbonatite, Azov, where inner zone fenites are albitic but the outer ones are microcline-rich (Kapustin 1982). The N a - K zonation is in accord with Orville's (1963) experiments on alkali-ion exchange between fluid and feldspar at falling low tempera-
77
tures, and finds support from Woolley's worldwide investigations (1982). S6vite and alvikite carry very little F, but the natrocarbonatitic magmas from which they were derived were probably F rich and C1 rich. Natrocarbonatite lava has 1.49-2.93 wt.% F and 0.77-4.15 wt.% C1 (Gittins & McKie 1980). Some minerals in carbonatites also show that they crystallized from halogen-rich magma, and Dawson & Fuge (1980) estimate that F > C1 was usual. In addition to apatite, biotite and Na-amphibole, which are the most important F-bearing minerals, clinohumite (Mg(F,OH)2.4MgzSiO4) has been reported at Cargill in Ontario, Jacupiranga in Brazil, Palaborwa in S Africa, Sokli in Finland and Gardiner in E Greenland (Gittins 1978). Even the residual nephelinitic glasses from Oldoinyo Lengai volcano have appreciable halogen contents (0.25-0.69 wt.% C1), and the F/C1 ratio for the whole rock is 1.6 (Donaldson & Dawson 1978). The F and C1 are evidently mantle derived, probably from phlogopite rather than apatite (Edgar & Arima 1985). However, at Oka, Quebec, Treiman & Essene (1984) calculate that the fluorine fugacity was low (10-44). If carbonatite magma were rich in halogens, particularly F, then all fenitic fluids emanating from it would also be F rich as would the residual fluids. Evidence for the former is seen in the fluorapatites and fluoramphiboles developed in fenites, and for the latter in the fluorite late-stage mineralization. Yardley (1985) also finds evidence from apatites that F might be important in metamorphic fluids. It is considered probable that a fluoride species is the main solvent of the fenitizing fluids.
Conclusions In this assessment of the main features of carbonatite-nephelinite volcanism, the following salient points can be made. The starting point is carbonated nephelinitic magma generated from an enriched mantle source such as that described by Cohen et al. (1984). Such magma rises through the lithosphere, zone refining as it rises, until it stops in the lower crust. Fractionation at that stage would permit olivine and pyroxene cumulates to form. At the same time the melt would fractionate to phonolite, and liquid immiscibility could take place forming a series of conjugate carbonatite magmas (Fig. 16). Nephelinitic magma is dense (about 2.7 g cm-3) and hence is not seen where the crust is composed of thick low-density unaltered sediments. Where nephelinitic magma has the buoyancy to penetrate the crust it can make
78
M. J. Le Bas
MELANEPHELINITE NEPHELINITEPHONOLITE LAVAS&PYROCLASTICS
PSEUDO-
DYKES
Rap,d
t /
IJOLITE
,
Ropid ascent
" "
I --.~
K.FEN!TE~A~ vK~TEE/
FenilizatiOn
IPER,DOTITE
/ /
FERROC,~BONATIT~
/I.SYE
I Slow / aster, I
I
LATE- STAGE CARB~NATITE
/
I:k/1 t oo.o
oscenl
o, .....
"~ "
TRACHYTE
URTITE & WOLL-URTITE LATE- STAGE ~11 ALKALINE FLUIDS/' CALCITE 1~ / IJOLITE -
SYE.,TES \
CARBONATED BRECCIASTUFFS & AGGLOMERATES
CARBONAIIELAVA & PYROCLASTC IS
.a
PQchonohon Low volahle ~ .
silicote melt
Volobie-rJch fluid
I lower crustal magma chamber
HELINITE I LIQUID FRACTIONATES I TO PHONOLITE I IMMISCIBILITY I
CUMULATES
? BASE OF CRUST
CARBONATED NEPHELINITIC MAGMA
PARTIAL MELT OF ENRICHED MANTLE SOURCE
FIG. 16. Schematic flow chart for the evolution of nephelinitic and carbonatitic magmas. (After Le Bas 1977, Fig. 24.2.) pyroxenite-ijolite-urtite plutons, with the ijolite perhaps developing an outer zone and capping of feldspathic ijolite (Fig. 14) as a result of the inward diffusion of silica from the country rocks undergoing fenitization. The country rocks are metasomatized to syenitic fenites with alkali feldspar and Na-pyriboles (Fig. 17). Although natrocarbonatite magmas of various (Na + K)/Ca ratios can be produced by the liquid
immiscibility, depending on whether the conjugate silicate melt is nephelinite or phonolite, the alkali loss to fenitization obscures the differences. All carbonatites follow similar paths producing s6vites, dolomite carbonatites, alvikites and ferrocarbonatites with REE enrichment, with the final production of residual mineralizing fluids which precipitate fluorite, baryte and U - T h minerals. F-rich alkali-bearing fluids cause feni-
Nephelinites and carbonatites
79
J
Cone-sheets~ plones of brecciation end K |enitizetion
'.?3
:"
+ +
/ ~_
.
I/0tite~, ~ + 1 ~ - I * +N'. ;, § i..I/."~ 4-
O,L
__.~.___,
- IN Cl i . r'." .I
FIG. 17. Schematic cross-section across an idealized nephelinite-carbonatite volcanic complex showing the normal structure and sequence of intrusion, the zonal fenitization around the ijolite, the deeper-level albitization (Na), the nearer-surface potassic feldspathization (K) accompanied by brecciation (A) and the emplacement of s6vite (CI), the cone-sheet fracture system of the alvikites (C2) and ferrocarbonatites (C3), and the final development of late-stage carbonate veins (C4) and a mineralized capping above the intrusive centre. (After Le Bas 1977, Fig. 23.1.) tization. Fluids e m a n a t i n g from early carbonatites cause albitization with albite-rich fenites +_ Na-pyriboles being developed at deeper levels around the carbonatite pluton. K-rich feldspathic fenites form towards the top and cap the s6vitic intrusions. They are often a c c o m p a n i e d by
brecciation and are usually followed by an F, Ba and U - T h mineralization. ACKNOWLEDGMENTS" I acknowledge most sincerely the many colleagues who have helped me reach these conclusions.
References ANDERSEN,T. 1984. Secondary processes in carbonatites: petrology of 'rodberg' (hematite-calcitedolomite carbonatite) in the Fen central complex, Telemark (South Norway). Lithos, 17, 227-45. APPLEYARD, E. C. & WOOLLEY,A. R. 1979. Fenitization: an example of the problems of characterizing mass transfer and volume changes. Chem. Geol. 26, 1-15. ARMBRUSTMACHER,T. J. 1979. Replacement and primary carbonatites from the Wet Mountains area, Fremont and Custer Counties, Colorado. Econ. Geol. 74, 888-901.
BAILEY, D. K. (1966) Carbonatite volcanoes and shallow intrusions in Zambia. In: TUTTLE,O. F. & GITTINS, J. (eds) Carbonatites, pp. 127-154. Wiley, New York. --1987. Mantle metasomatism--perspective and prospect. In: FtTTON, J. G. & UPTON, B. G. J. (eds) Alkaline Igneous Rocks, Geol. Soc. Spec. Publ. 30, pp. 1-13. BAKER, B. Iq. 1987. Outline of the petrology of the Kenya rift alkaline province. In: FITTON, J. G. & UPTON, B. G. J. (eds) Alkaline Igneous Rocks, Geol. Soc. Spec. Publ. 30, pp. 293-311.
8o
M. J. Le Bas
BEDSON, P. 1983. The origin of the carbonatites and their relation to other rocks by liquid immiscibility. Ph.D Thesis, University of Manchester (unpublished). - 1984. Rare earth element distributions between immiscible silicate and carbonate liquids. Prog. Exp. Petrol. NERC 6th Rep., pp. 12-19. BOWEN, N. L. 1924. The Fen Area in Telemark, Norway. Am. J. Sci. 8, 1-11. BREY, G. 1978. Origin of olivine melilitites--chemical and experimental constraints. J. Volcanol. geotherm. Res. 3, 61-88. - - & GREEN, D. H. 1976. Solubility of CO2 in olivine melilitite at high pressures and role of COz in the earth's upper mantle. Contrib. Mineral. Petrol. 5 5 , 217-30. BRISTOW, J. W. & SAGGERSON, E. P. 1983. A general account of Karoo vulcanicity in southern Africa. Geol. Rundsch. 72, 1015-60. BROGGER, W. G. 1921. Die Eruptivgesteine des Kristianiagebietes. IV. Das Fengebeit in Telemark, Norwegen. Vidensk. Skr. 1. Mat-Naturv. Klasse, 1920 (9). BROOKS, C. K. & PRINZLAU,I. 1978. Magma mixing in mafic alkaline volcanic rocks: the evidence from relict phenocryst phases and other inclusions. J. Volcanol. geotherm. Res. 4, 315-31. BROWN, P. E. 1964. The Songwe scarp carbonatite and associated feldspathization in the Mbeya Range, Tanganyika. Q.J. geol. Soc. 120, 223-40. BULAKH, A . G . & ISKOZ-DOLININA, I. P. 1978. Origin of carbonatites in the Central'nyy massif, Turig peninsula. Int. geol. Rev. 20, 822-30. CLAGUE, D. A. & FREY, F. A. 1982. Petrology and trace element geochemistry of the Honolulu Volcanics, Oahu: implications for the oceanic mantle below Hawaii. J. Petrol. 23, 447-504. COETZEE, G. L. 1963. Carbonatites of the Karema depression, western Tanganyika. Trans. geol. Soc. S. Afr. 66, 283-333. COHEN, R. S., O'NIONS, R. K. & DAWSON, J. B. 1984. Isotope geochemistry of xenoliths from East Africa: implications for development of mantle reservoirs and their interaction. Earth planet. Sci. Lett. 68, 209-20. COOPER, A, F., GxYrINS, J. & TUYrLE, O. F. 1975. The system Na2CO2-K2CO3-CaCO 3 at 1 kilobar and its significance in carbonatite petrogenesis. Am. J. Sci. 275, 534-60. DAWSON, J. B. 1962. The geology of Oldoinyo Lengai. Bull. Volcanol. 24, 349-87. --1980. Kimberlites and their Xenoliths, Springer, Berlin. --& FUGE, R. 1980. Halogen content of some African primary carbonatites. Lithos, 13, 139-43. -& HAWTHORNE,J. B. 1973. Magmatic sedimentation and carbonatitic differentiation in kimberlite sills at Benfontein, South Africa. J. geol. Soc. Lond. 12, 61-85. DEANS, T. & ROBERTS, B. 1984. Carbonatite tufts and lava clasts of the Tinderet foothills, Western Kenya: a study of calcified natrocarbonatites. J. geol. Soe. Lond. 141,563-80. - - , SUKHESWALA,R. N., SETHNA,S. F. & VILADKAR,
S. G. 1972. Metasomatic feldspar rock (potash fenites) asssociated with the fluorite deposits and carbonatites of Amba Dongar, Gujarat, India. Trans. Inst. rain. Metall. Sect. B, 81, 1-9. DIXEY, F., SMITH, W. C. & BISSET, C. B. 1935. The Chilwa Series of Southern Nyasaland. Geol. Surv. Nyasaland, Bull. 5 (revised 1955). DONALDSON, C. H. & DAWSON, J. B. 1978. Skeletal crystallization and residual glass compositions in a cellular alkalic pyroxenitic nodule from Oldoinyo Lengai. Contrib. Mineral. Petrol. 67, 139-49. DOWNES, H. 1984. Sr and Nd isotope geochemistry of coexisting alkaline magma series. Cantal, Massif Central, France. Earth planet. Sci. Lett. 69, 32134. DE BOlS, C. G. B., FURST, J., GUEST, N. J. & JENNINGS, G. J. 1963. Fresh natrocarbonatite lava from Oldoinyo L'Engai. Nature, Lond. 197, 445-6. VON ECKERMANN,H. 1948. The alkaline district of Alno Island. Sver. Geol. Unders. Ser. Ca, No. 36. EDGAR, A. D. & ARIMA, M. 1985. Fluorine and chlorine contents of phlogopites crystallized from ultrapotassic rock compositions in high pressure experiments : implication for halogen reservoirs in source regions. Am. Mineral. 70, 529-36. EGGLER, D. H. 1978. The effect of CO2 upon partial melting of peridotite in the system N a 2 0 - C a O A1203-MgO-SiO2-CO2 to 35 kb, with an analysis of melting in a peridotite-H20-CO2 system. Am. J. Sci. 278, 305-43. FODOR, R. V., BAUER, G. R. & KEIL, K. 1982. Ultramafic inclusions and megacrysts in olivine nephelinite. Aitutaki Island. Cook Islands. N.Z. J. Geol. Geophys. 25, 67-76. FREESTONE, I. 1978. Liquid immiscibility in alkaline magmas. Chem. Geol. 23, 115-23. & HAMILTON, D. L. 1980. The role of liquid immiscibility in the genesis of carbonatites--an experimental study. Contrib. Mineral. Petrol. 73, 105-17. GARSON, M. S. 1965. Carbonatites in Southern Malawi. Geol. Surv. Malawi, Bull. 15. GASPAR, J. C. & WYLLIE, P. J. 1983a. Magnetite in the carbonatites from the Jacupiranga complex, Brazil. Am. Mineral. 68, 195-213. - & -1983b. Ilmenite (high Mg, Mn, Nb) in the carbonatites from the Jacupiranga complex, Brazil. Am. Mineral. 68, 960-71. GITTINS, J. 1978. Some observations on the present status of carbonatite studies. Proc. 1st Int. Symp. Carbonatites, Ministerio das Minas e Energia, Departamento Nacional da Produ~ao Mineral, Polos de Caldas, Minas Gerais, Brazil, pp. 10715. -& McKm, D. 1980. Alkalic carbonatite magmas: Oldoinyo Lengai and its wider applicability. Lithos. 13, 213-15. , ALLEN, C. R. & COOPER, A. F. 1975. Phlogopitization of pyroxenite; its bearing on the composition of carbonatite magmas. Geol. Mag. 11,503-7. HAGGERTY, S. E. & MARIANO, A. N. 1983. Strontianloparite and strontio-cherkinite: two new minerals in rheomorphic fenites from the Parana Basin
Nephelinites and carbonatites carbonatites, South America. Contrib. Mineral. Petrol. 84, 365-81. HAY, R. L. 1983. Natrocarbonatite tephra of Kerimasi volcano, Tanzania. Geology, 11,599-602. HEINRICH, E. WM. 1966. The Geology of Carbonatites, Rand McNally, Chicago, I1. --& MOORE, D. G. 1970. Metasomatic potash feldspar rocks associated with igneous alkaline complexes. Can. Mineral. 10, 571-84. JAN, M. Q., KAMAL,M. & QURESHI,A. 1981. Petrography of the Loe Shilman carbonatite complex, Khyber Agency. Geol. Bull. Univ. Peshawar, 14, 29-43. JONES, A. P. & WYLLIE, P. J. 1983. Low-temperature glass quenched from a synthetic, rare earth carbonatite: implications for the origin of the Mountain Pass deposit, California. Econ. Geol. 78, 1721-3. KAPUSTIN, Y. L. 1981. Mineralogy of Carbonatites. Amerind, New Delhi. --1982. Fenitization around carbonatite bodies. Dokl. Akad Nauk SSSR, 249, 126-8. KELLER, J. 1981. Carbonatite volcanism in the Kaiserstuhl alkaline complex: evidence for highly fluid carbonatite melts at the Earth's surface. J. Volcanol, geotherm. Res. 9, 423-31. KING, B. C. 1949. The Napak area of southern Karamoja, Uganda. Geol. Surv. Uganda, Mem. V. --1965. Petrogenesis of the alkaline igneous rock suites of the volcanic and intrusive centres of eastern Uganda. J. Petrol. 6, 67-100. --& SUTHERLAND, D. S. 1960. Alkaline rocks of eastern and southern Africa. Sci. Prog., Lond. 48, 298-321,504-24, 709-20. KOSTER VAN GROOS, A. F. 1975. The distribution of strontium between coexisting silicate and carbonate liquids at elevated pressures and temperatures. Geochim. cosmochim. Acta, 39, 27-34. -d~ WYLLIE, P. J. 1966. Liquid immiscibility in the system Na20-A1203-SiO2-CO2 at pressures to 1 kilobar. Am. J. Sci. 26, 234-55. --& ~ 1968. Liquid immiscibility in the join NaA1Si3Oa-Na2CO3-H20 and its bearing on the genesis of carbonatites. Am. J. Sci. 266, 932-67. --&--1973. Liquid immiscibility in the join NaA1Si308-CaAI2Si2Os-Na2CO3-H20. Am. J. Sci. 273, 465-87. LAPIN, A. V. & VARTIAINEN,H. 1983. Orbicular and spherulitic carbonatites from Sokli and Vuoriyarvi. Lithos, 16, 53-60. LE BAS, M. J. 1971. Per-alkaline volcanism, crustal swelling and rifting. Nature, Lond., Phys. Sci. 230, 85-7. - - 1 9 7 7 . Carbonatite-Nephelinite Volcanism, Wiley, New York. --1978. Nephelinite volcanism at plate interiors. Bull. Volcanol. 41,459-62. --1980. The East African Cenozoic magmatic province. Acad. Naz. Lincei, Atti Convegni Lincei, 47, 111-22. --1981. Carbonatite magmas. Mineral. Mag. 44,
133-40. Oceanic carbonatites. In: KORNPROBST, J.
--1984.
81
(ed.) Kimberlites 1 : Kimberlites and Related Rocks, pp. 169-78. Elsevier, Amsterdam. -1986. Ultra-alkaline magmatism with or without rifting. Tectonophysics (Special Issue on Continental and Oceanic Rift Zones), in press. --& ASPDEN, J. A. 1981. The comparability of carbonatitic fluid inclusions in ijolites with natrocarbonatite lava. Bull. Volcanol. 44, 429-38. --& HANDLEY, C. 1979. Variations in apatite composition in ijolitic and carbonatitic igneous rocks. Nature, Lond. 27, 54-6. LEHIJARVI, M. 1960. The alkaline district of Iivaara, Kuusamo, Finland. Bull. Comm. Geol. Fin. 185. LIPPARD, S. J. 1973. The petrology of phonolites from the Kenya Rift. Lithos, 6, 207-34. McKIE, D. 1966. Fenitization. In: TUTTLE, O. F. & GITTINS, J. (eds) Carbonatites, pp. 261-94. Wiley, New York. - - & FRANKIS,E. J. 1977. Nyerereite: a new volcanic carbonate mineral from Oldoinyo Lengai, Tanzania. Z. Kristallogr. 145, 73-95. MARIANO, A. N. & ROEDER, P. L. 1983. Kerimasi: a neglected carbonatite volcano. J. Geol. 91,449-55. MOLLER, P., MORTEANI,G. & SHLEY, F. 1980. Discussion of REE distribution patterns of carbonatites and alkaline rocks. Lithos, 13, 171-9. MYSEN, B., RYERSON, F. J. & VIRGO, D. 1981. The structural role of phosphorus in silicate melts. Am. Mineral. 66, 106-17. NESmTT, B. E. & KELLY, W. C. 1977. Magmatic and hydrothermal inclusions in carbonatite of the Magnet Cove complex, Arkansas. Contrib. Mineral. Petrol. 63, 271-94. NORRY, M. J., TRUCKLE, P. H., LIPPARD, S. J., HAWKESWORTH, C. J., WEAVER, S. D. & MARRINER, G. F. 1980. Isotopic and trace element evidence from lavas, bearing on mantle heterogeneity beneath Kenya. Phil. Trans. R. Soc. Lond., Ser. A, 297, 259-71. OLSEN, J. C., SHAW, D. R., PRAY, L. C. & SHARP, W. N. 1954. Rare-earth mineral deposits of the Mountain Pass District, San Bernardino County, California. U.S. Geol. Surv. Prof Paper 261. ONUMA, K. & TOHARA, T. 1984. The join CaMgSi206CaA12SiO6-CaCrA1SiO6 with special reference to chrome clinopyroxene and chrome spinel. Lithos, 17, 289-98. ORVILLE, P. M. 1963. Alkali ion exchange between vapour and feldspar phases. Am. J. Sci. 261,20137. PIOTROWSKI, J. M. & EDGAR, A. D. 1970. Melting relations of undersaturated alkaline rocks from S. Greenland compared to those of Africa and Canada. Medd. Gronl. 181 (9). PRINS, P. 1972. Composition of magnetite from carbonatites. Lithos, 5, 227-40. s 1978. Geochemical aspects of the alkaline carbonatite complexes of Damaraland, South West Africa. Proc. 1st Int. Symp. on Carbonatite, Ministerio das Minas e Energia, Departmento Nacional da Produ~ao Mineral, Polos de Caldas, Minas Gerais, Brazil, pp. 179-88. 1981. The geochemical evolution of the alkaline and carbonatite complexes of the Damaraland
82
M. J. Le Bas
igneous Province, South West Africa. Annen. Univ. Stellenbosch, Ser. A1 (Geol.) 3, 145-278. RANKIN, A. H. 1975. Fluid inclusion studies in apatite from carbonatites of the Wasaki area of western Kenya. Lithos, 8, 123-36. -1977. Fluid-inclusion evidence for the formation conditions of apatite from the Tororo carbonatite complex of eastern Uganda. Mineral. Mag. 41, 155-64.
LE BAS, M. J. 1974a. Nahcolite (NaHCO3) in inclusions in apatites from some E. African ijolites and carbonatites. Mineral. Mag. 39, 563-70. - & -1974b. Liquid immiscibility between silicate and carbonate melts in naturally-occurring ijolite magma. Nature, Lond. 2 5 0 , 206-9. ROBBINS, B. &. TYSSELAND, M. 1983. The geology, geochemistry and origin of ultrabasic fenites associated with the Pollen carbonatite (Finnmark, Norway). Chem. Geol. 40, 65-95. ROEDDER, E. 1973. Fluid inclusions from the fluorite deposits associated with carbonatite at Amba Dongar, India and Okorusu, South West Africa. Trans. Inst. Min. Metall., Sect. B, 82, 35-9. RUBIE, D. C. 1982. Mass transfer and volume change during alkali metasomatism at Kisingiri, western Kenya. Lithos, 15, 99-109. - & GUNTER, W. D. 1983. The role of speciation in alkaline igneous fluids during fenite metasomatism. Contrib. Mineral. Petrol. 82, 165-75. SAErHER, E. 1957. The alkaline rock province of the Fen area in southern Norway. Kgl. norske Videns. Selsk. Skr. 1957 (1). SAGGERSON, E. P. 1970. The structural control and genesis of alkaline rocks in central Kenya. Bull. Volcanol. 34, 38-76. SAMOVLOV,V. S. & SMIRNOVA,Ye. V. 1980. Rare earth behaviour in carbonatite formation and the origin of carbonatites. Geochem. Int. 17, 140-52. SnAND, S. J. 1949. Eruptive Rocks. Thomas Murby, London. SILVA, L. C., LE BAS, M. J. & ROBERTSON, A. H. F. 1981. An oceanic carbonatite volcano on Santiago. Cape Verde Islands. Nature, Lond. 294, 664-5. SPENCER, A. B. 1969. Alkalic igneous rocks of the Balcones Province, Texas. J. Petrol. 10, 272-306. STRECKEISEN,A. 1976. To each plutonic rock its proper name. Earth Sci. Rev. 12, 1-33. -1978. IUGS Subcommission on the systematics of igneous rocks; classification and nomenclature of volcanic rocks, lamprophyres, carbonatites and melilitic rocks. Neues Jb. Mineral. Abh. 134 (i), 114. STRONG, D. F. 1972. Petrology of the island of Moheli, western Indian Ocean. Geol. Soc. Am. Bull. 83, 389-406. SUTHERLAND,D. S. 1965. Nomenclature of the potassicfeldspathic rocks associated with carbonatites. Geol. Soc. Am. Bull. 76, 1409-12. -1967. A note on the occurrence of potassium-rich trachytes in the Kaiserstuhl carbonatite complex, West Germany. Mineral. Mag. 36, 334-41. SUWA, K., OANA, S., WADA, H. & OSAKI, S. 1975. - - &
Isotope geochemistry and petrology of African carbonatites. Phys. Chem. Earth, 9, 735-45. THOMPSON,R. N. 1974. Some high-pressure pyroxenes. Mineral. Mag. 39, 768-87. TREIMAN, A. H. & ESSENE, E. J. 1983. Mantle eclogite and carbonate as sources of sodic carbonatites and alkalic magmas. Nature, Lond. 302, 700-3. --&--1984. A periclase-dolomite-calcite carbonatite from the Oka complex, Quebec, and its calculated volatile composition. Contrib. Mineral. Petrol. 85, 149-57. - - & SCHEOL, A. 1983. Properties of carbonatite magma and processes in carbonatite magma chambers. J. geol. 91,437-47. TUTTLE, O. F. & GITTINS, J. 1966. Carbonatites. Wiley, New York. TWYMAN, J. D. & GITTINS,J. 1987. Alkalic carbonatite magmas: parental or derivative. In: FITI'ON, J. G. & UPTON, B. G. J. (eds) Alkaline Igneous Rocks, Geol. Soc. Spec. Publ. 30, pp. 85-101. TYLER, R. C. & KING, B. C. 1967. The pyroxenes of the alkaline igneous complexes of eastern Uganda. Mineral. Mag. 36, 5-21. VARNE, R. 1968. The petrology of Moroto Mountain, eastern Uganda, and the origin of nephelinites. J. Petrol. 9, 169-90. VARTIAINEN, H. 1980. The petrology, mineralogy and petrochemistry of the Sokli carbonatite massif, northern Finland. Geol. Surv. Finland, Bull. 313. VERWOERD, W. J. 1978. Liquid immiscibility and the carbonatite-ijolite relationship: preliminary data on the join NaFea+Si206-CaCO3 and related compositions. Ann. Rep. geophys. Lab. Wash. 77, 767-74. VILADKAR,S. G. & DULSKI,P. 1986. Rare earth element abundances in carbonatites, alkaline rocks and fenites of the Amba Dongar complex, Gujarat, India. Neues Jb. Mineral. 1986, H.1, 37-48. WATKINSON,D. H. & WYLLIE, P. J. 1971. Experimental study of the composition join NaAISiO4-CaCO3H20 and the genesis of alkalic rock-carbonatite complexes. J. Petrol. 12, 357-78. WENDLANDT, R. F. & HARRISON, W. J. 1979. Rare earth partitioning between immiscible carbonate and silicate liquids and CO2 vapour: results and implications for the formation of light rare earthenriched rocks. Contrib. Mineral. Petrol. 69, 40919. WOOD, D . A . , JORON, J.-L., TREUIL, M., NORRY, M. J. & TARN~Y, J. 1979. Elemental and Sr isotope variations in basic lavas from Iceland and surrounding ocean floor. Contrib. Mineral. Petrol. 70, 319-39. WOOLLEY, m. R. 1982. A discussion of carbonatite evolution and nomenclature, and the generation of sodic and potassic fenites. Mineral. Mag. 46, 1317. - & JONES, G. C. 1987. The petrochemistry of the northern part of the Chilwa Alkaline Province, Malawi. In: FITTON, J. G. & UPTON, B. G. J. (eds) Alkaline lgneous Rocks, Geol. Soc. Spec. Publ. 30, pp. 335-55.
Nephelinites and carbonatites WYLLIE, P. J. 1965. Melting relationships in the system CaO-MgO-CO2-HzO, with petrological applications. J. Petrol. 6, 101-23. -1978. Silicate-carbonate systems with bearing on the origin and crystallization of carb0natites. Proc. 1st Int. Syrup. on Carbonatites, Ministerio das Minas e Energia, Departamento Nacional da
83
Produqao Mineral, Pogos de Caldas, Minas Gerais, Brazil, pp. 61-78. - - - 1980. The origin of kimberlites. J. geophys. Res. 85, 6902-10. YARDLEY,B. 1985. Apatite composition and fugacities of HF and HC1 in metamorphic fluids. Mineral. Mag. 49, 77-9.
M. J. LE Bks, Department of Geology, University of Leicester, Leicester, U,K.
Alkalic carbonatite magmas- parental or derivative? James D. Twyman & John Gittins S U M M A R Y : During the 1950s and 1960s the Tanzanian volcano Oldoinyo Lengai erupted a highly alkalic lava composed almost exclusively of the N a - K - C a carbonate minerals nyerereite and gregoryite and containing about 32~ Na20 and 7% K20. For many years the lava was considered a petrological curiosity but gradually the idea developed that alkalic carbonatite magmas might develop generally during the evolution of commoner carbonatite magmas. In 1981 Le Bas, followed in 1982 by Woolley, ascribed to the Oldoinyo Lengai magma a parental status and erected a scheme whereby other commoner carbonatite rock types are derived from it; the alkalic carbonatite magma is one of two derived by immiscible separation from a nephelinitic magma, the other being ijolitic. The carbonatite liquid has 500~ of superheat and loses alkalis progressively as the magma cools to its liquidus temperature of 400~176 by which stage it has become a calcitic-dolomitic liquid. This liquid then differentiates to produce the commoner types of carbonatite rocks. In rejecting such a scheme we argue as follows: such a scheme would require the magma to be water saturated at the moment of immiscibility, and progressive loss of water and alkalis would induce crystallization thus preventing the formation of a calcite-dolomite magma; the 500~ of superheat is a consequence of the design of the Freestone & Hamilton experiments and does not exist; carbonatite magmas generally begin to crystallize at temperatures greater than 900~ rare-earth-element compositions do not permit derivation of alkalic carbonatite magma from nephelinite magmas by liquid immiscibility; the mafic silicate mineralogy of carbonatites demonstrates alkali enrichment rather than depletion. We propose that the commonest parental magma of carbonatites is a mildly alkalic olivine s6vite composition and that most carbonatite rock types are derived from it by fractional crystallization, allowing the development of cumulates that are well lubricated by intercumulus liquid and capable of much subsequent movement, deformation and re-intrusion as a crystal mush. As this parental magma crystallizes, continued fractionation of alkalideficient and anhydrous minerals increases both its alkali and water contents until water saturation is reached. This in turn causes the development of an aqueous fluid which limits the alkali content of the magma. The composition of the magma at which water saturation develops is controlled by the rate of rise of the magma, and therefore aqueous fluids with various N a : K ratios can develop and control the type of fenitization that occurs. Under plutonic conditions alkalis in excess of the amount that can be fixed as silicate minerals are carried away as fenitizing fluids. Alkali loss does therefore occur, and through the medium of an aqueous fluid, but calcite and/or dolomite crystallize throughout the magmatic cooling history rather than simply at the low-temperature end of this history. The alkalic carbonatite magma