ADVANCES IN PHOTOCHEMISTRY Volume 28 Editors
DOUGLAS C. NECKERS Center for Photochemical Sciences, Bowling Green State ...
36 downloads
1631 Views
4MB Size
Report
This content was uploaded by our users and we assume good faith they have the permission to share this book. If you own the copyright to this book and it is wrongfully on our website, we offer a simple DMCA procedure to remove your content from our site. Start by pressing the button below!
Report copyright / DMCA form
ADVANCES IN PHOTOCHEMISTRY Volume 28 Editors
DOUGLAS C. NECKERS Center for Photochemical Sciences, Bowling Green State University, Bowling Green, Ohio
THOMAS WOLFF Technische Universita¨t Dresden, Institut fu¨r Physikalische Chimie und Elektrochimie, Dresden, Germany
WILLIAM S. JENKS Department of Chemistry, Iowa State University, Ames, Iowa
A JOHN WILEY & SONS, INC., PUBLICATION
ADVANCES IN PHOTOCHEMISTRY Volume 28
ADVANCES IN PHOTOCHEMISTRY Volume 28 Editors
DOUGLAS C. NECKERS Center for Photochemical Sciences, Bowling Green State University, Bowling Green, Ohio
THOMAS WOLFF Technische Universita¨t Dresden, Institut fu¨r Physikalische Chimie und Elektrochimie, Dresden, Germany
WILLIAM S. JENKS Department of Chemistry, Iowa State University, Ames, Iowa
A JOHN WILEY & SONS, INC., PUBLICATION
Copyright # 2005 by John Wiley & Sons, Inc. All rights reserved. Published by John Wiley & Sons, Inc., Hoboken, New Jersey. Published simultaneously in Canada. No part of this publication may be reproduced, stored in a retrieval system, or transmitted in any form or by any means, electronic, mechanical, photocopying, recording, scanning, or otherwise, except as permitted under Section 107 or 108 of the 1976 United States Copyright Act, without either the prior written permission of the Publisher, or authorization through payment of the appropriate per-copy fee to the Copyright Clearance Center, Inc., 222 Rosewood Drive, Danvers, MA 01923, 978-750-8400, fax 978-646-8600, or on the web at www.copyright.com. Requests to the Publisher for permission should be addressed to the Permissions Department, John Wiley & Sons, Inc., 111 River Street, Hoboken, NJ 07030, (201) 748-6011, fax (201) 748-6008. Limit of Liability/Disclaimer of Warranty: While the publisher and author have used their best efforts in preparing this book, they make no representations or warranties with respect to the accuracy or completeness of the contents of this book and specifically disclaim any implied warranties of merchantability or fitness for a particular purpose. No warranty may be created or extended by sales representatives or written sales materials. The advice and strategies contained herein may not be suitable for your situation. You should consult with a professional where appropriate. Neither the publisher nor author shall be liable for any loss of profit or any other commercial damages, including but not limited to special, incidental, consequential, or other damages. For general information on our other products and services please contact our Customer Care Department within the U.S. at 877-762-2974, outside the U.S. at 317-572-3993 or fax 317-572-4002. Wiley also publishes its books in a variety of electronic formats. Some content that appears in print, however, may not be available in electronic format. Library of Congress Cataloging in Publication Data: Library of Congress Catalog Card Number: 63-13592 ISBN 0-471-68241-1 Printed in the United States of America 10 9
8 7 6
5 4 3 2
1
CONTRIBUTORS
Y. Alexeev Pacific Northwest National Laboratory 901 Battelle Boulevard P.O. Box 999 Richland, WA 99352 P. K. Chowdhury Biomedical Application Centre Centre of Advanced Technology Indore-452 013 India K. Das Biomedical Application Centre Centre of Advanced Technology Indore-452 013 India M. D. D’Auria Dipartimento di Chimica Universita´ della Basilicata Via N. Sauro 85 85100 Potenza Italy
Rolf Dessauer P.O. Box 3796 Greenville, DE 19807 L. Emanuele Dipartimento di Chimica Universita´ della Basilicata Via N. Sauro 85 85100 Potenza Italy Takashige Fujiwara Department of Chemistry Center for Laser and Optical Spectroscopy The University of Akron Akron, OH 44325 M. S. Gordon Pacific Northwest National Laboratory 901 Battelle Boulevard P.O. Box 999 Richland, WA 99352
v
vi
M. Halder Biomedical Application Centre Centre of Advanced Technology Indore-452 013 India Edward C. Lim Department of Chemistry Center for Laser and Optical Spectroscopy The University of Akron Akron, OH 44325 David C. Moule Department of Chemistry Brock University St. Catherines, ON L2S3A1 Canada
CONTRIBUTORS
J. Park Department of Chemistry University of Pennsylvania Philadelphia, PA 19104 J. W. Petrich Pacific Northwest National Laboratory 901 Battelle Boulevard P.O. Box 999 Richland, WA 99352 R. Racioppi Dipartimento di Chimica Universita´ della Basilicata Via N. Sauro 85 85100 Potenza Italy
PREFACE
Volume 1 of Advances in Photochemistry appeared in 1963. The stated purpose of the series was to explore the frontiers of photochemistry through the medium of chapters written by pioneers who are experts. Teh editorial policy has always been to solicit articles from scientists who have strong personal points of view, while encouraging critical discussions and evaluations of existing data. In no sense have the articles been simple literature surveys, although in some cases they may have also fulfilled that purpose. In the introduction to Volume 1 of this series, the founding editors, J. N. Pitts, G. S. Hammond and W. A. Noyes Jr. noted developments in a brief span of prior years that were important for progress in photochemistry: flash photolysis, nuclear magnetic resonance, and electron spin resonance. A quarter of a century later, in Volume 14 (1988), the editors noted that since then two developments had been of prime significance: the emergence of the laser from an esoteric possibility to an important light source and the evolution of computers to microcomputers in common laboratory use of data acquisition. These developments strongly influenced research on the dynamic behavior of the excited state and other transients. With the increased sophistication in experiment and interpretation since that time, photochemists have made substantial progress in achieving the fundamental objective of photochemistry: elucidation of the detailed history of a molecule that absorbs radiation. The scope of this objective is so broad and the systems to be studied are so many that there is little danger of exhausting the subject. We hope that this series will reflect the frontiers of photochemistry as they develop in the future. Rolf Dessauer’s contribution, ‘‘The Invention of Dylux1 Instant-Access Imaging Materials and the Development of Habi Chemistry—A Personal History,’’ is a departure from previously established patterns for Advances in vii
viii
PREFACE
Photochemistry chapters. Rolf’s personal history is of the development of one of the most important commercial contributions made by photoscientists in the twentieth century. We hope you’ll find his trials and tribulations from invention to commercial success along the path that led to a successful Dylux instructive and inspirational. Bowling Green, Ohio, USA Dresden, Germany Ames, Iowa, USA
Douglas C. Neckers Thomas Wolff William S. Jenks
CONTENTS
Hypericin and Its Perylene Quinone Analogs: Probing Structure, Dynamics, and Interactions with the Environment K. DAS, M. HALDER, P. K. CHOWDHURY, J. PARK, Y. ALEXEEV, M. S. GORDON, AND J. W. PETRICH
1
Thiophosgene: A Tailor-Made Molecule for Photochemical and Photophysical Studies DAVID C. MOULE, TAKASHIGE FUJIWARA, AND EDWARD C. LIM
27
1,2-Cycloaddition Reaction of Carbonyl Compounds and Pentaatomic Heterocyclic Compounds M. D. D’AURIA, L. EMANUELE, AND R. RACIOPPI
81
The Invention of Dylux1 Instant-Access Imaging Materials and the Development of Habi Chemistry—A Personal History ROLF DESSAUER
129
Index
263
Cumulative Index, Volumes 1–28
277
ix
HYPERICIN AND ITS PERYLENE QUINONE ANALOGS: PROBING STRUCTURE, DYNAMICS, AND INTERACTIONS WITH THE ENVIRONMENT M. Halder, P. K. Chowdhury, M. S. Gordon, J. W. Petrich Department of Chemistry, Iowa State University, Ames, IA 50011, USA K. Das Biomedical Applications Centre, Centre of Advanced Technology, Indore-452 013, India J. Park Department of Chemistry, University of Pennsylvannia, Philadelphia, PA 19104-6323, USA Y. Alexeev Pacific Northwest National Laboratory, 901 Battelle Blvd., P.O. Box 999, Richland, WA 99352, USA.
CONTENTS I. II.
Introduction: Excited-State Intramolecular H-Atom Transfer in HypericinLike Perylene Quinones Outstanding Questions Regarding Hypericin-Like Perylene Quinones
Advances in Photochemistry, Volume 28 Edited by Douglas C. Neckers, William S. Jenks, and Thomas Wolff # 2005 John Wiley & Sons, Inc.
1
2
HYPERICIN AND ITS PERYLENE QUINONE ANALOGS
A. Ground-State Heterogeneity 1. Recent Theoretical and Computational Approaches 2. Recent Experimental Approaches B. Are There Multiple H-Atom Transfers in the Perylene Quinones? C. Identifying the H-Atom Translocation III. Concluding Remarks Acknowledgments References
I. INTRODUCTION: EXCITED-STATE INTRAMOLECULAR H-ATOM TRANSFER IN HYPERICINLIKE PERYLENE QUINONES Hypericin and hypocrellin (Fig. 1.1.) are naturally occurring perylene quinones that have generated great interest recently owing to their biological activity [3–22], in particular, their light-induced biological activity [23–27]. The importance of light for their function has motivated our study of the photophysics of hypericin and its analogs [28–38]. By means of H/D substitution, investigation of O-methylated analogs, and complementary studies using both transient absorption and fluorescence upconversion spectroscopies, we have argued that the major primary photophysical process in hypericin and hypocrellin A in organic solvents is excited-state hydrogen atom transfer. We have suggested that the labile protons resulting from the intramolecular hydrogen-atom transfer reactions may be important for understanding the light-induced biological activity of hypericin and hypocrellin A. Notably, hypericin and hypocrellin A acidify their surroundings upon light absorption [39–41]. The role of photogenerated protons takes on significance in the context of the growing body of literature implicating changes in pH with inhibition of virus replication [42], antitumor activity [43, 44], and apoptosis (programmed cell death) [45–47]. Our argument for intramolecular excited-state H-Atom transfer in hypericin is as follows. The deshydroxy analog of hypericin, mesonaphthobianthrone (Fig. 1.1), is nonfluorescent, except in strong acids [29, 38] (e.g., sulfuric acid), where it produces a fluorescence spectrum that has nearly the same shape as that of hypericin in alcohols (Fig. 1.2). These results demonstrate the importance of a ‘‘protonated’’ carbonyl group for producing hypericin-like fluorescence. The hypericin emission spectrum grows in on a 6–12-ps time scale in all solvents, except in sulfuric acid where it is instantaneous. Thus the rise time for the appearance of the hypericin emission is taken as evidence for an excitedstate H-atom transfer [29, 48]. Confirming this interpretation are the fluorescence upconversion measurements of hypericin and O-methyl hypericin analogs [38, 48, 49], which are incapable of executing intramolecular excited-state
3
Figure 1.1. Hypericin (normal form, double tautomer, and monotautomer), mesonaphthobianthrone, hypocrellin A (normal form, double tautomer, and monotautomer), hypocrellin B, hypomycin B [1], and calphostin C [2].
4
HYPERICIN AND ITS PERYLENE QUINONE ANALOGS
Figure 1.2. Comparison of the fluorescence excitation and emission spectra of hypericin (a) and hypocrellin (b) in a 1:1 ethanol/methanol mixture at room temperature. The excitation spectra were measured at 295 K (solid line) and at 77 K (dashed line). The excitation spectra were monitored at 650 nm at 295 K and at 620 nm at 77 K.
H-atom-transfer reactions. Hypericin exhibits a rise in its fluorescence signal, whereas the methylated derivatives do not. Rising components of 10 ps, attributable to intramolecular H-atom transfer are clearly observed in the fluorescence upconversion traces of both hypericin and hypocrellin A (Figs. 1.3 and 1.4, respectively). For simplicity, in the rest of our discussion, we refer to this shorter-lived component as the ‘10-ps component.’ The amplitude of the rising component is emission wavelength dependent and occurs on the blue edge of the emission spectra. The clear and complementary observation in fluorescence of the 10-ps component in both hypericin and hypocrellin A is a crucial link in providing a unified model of the hypericin and
INTRODUCTION: EXCITED-STATE INTRAMOLECULAR H-ATOM TRANSFER
5
Figure 1.3. (Top) Fluorescence upconversion transient for hypericin in ethanol at lem ¼ 576 nm. The fit curve is described by the following equation (with background subtracted): FðtÞ ¼ 0:21 exp ðt=6:5 psÞ þ 1:00 exp ðt=1Þ. (Bottom) At lem ¼ 653 nm, however, there is no rising component in the fluorescence trace. Similar behavior is observed for hypocrellin A (Fig. 1.4). The excitation wavelength was the second harmonic of our unamplified Ti:sapphire oscillator, 414 nm. The panel below the kinetic trace displays the residuals between the fit and the data.
hypocrellin photophysics [34]. In addition to the 10-ps component in hypocrellin A, there is a longer-lived transient, also assigned to H-atom transfer, whose time constant ranges from 50 to 250 ps in the solvents we have studied [33]. The H-atom transfer rate in hypericin has no significant solvent dependence [29]. The H-atom transfer rate for the longer component in hypocrellin A has a strong dependence on the bulk viscosity [33]. The time constant for H-atom
6
HYPERICIN AND ITS PERYLENE QUINONE ANALOGS
Figure 1.4. A series of upconversion traces for hypocrellin A in octanol collected at different emission wavelengths. FðtÞ ¼ 0:10 exp ðt=4:1 psÞ þ 1:00 exp ðt=1Þ; lem ¼ 591 nm. Note that at redder emission wavelengths, the amplitude of the rising component is negligible.
transfer in hypocrellin ranges from 50 to 250 ps in the solvents we have studied. The viscosity dependence is remarkable not only because it is absent in hypericin but also because it is exceedingly well described by a bulk effect and does not require specific consideration of the structural aspects of the solvents, which vary considerably. It is often the case that trends are followed only for solvents of a given kind, for example, alkane or alcohols, primary alcohol or higher degree alcohol, and hydrogen bonding or nonhydrogen bonding. NMR results cited below lead us to suggest that the viscosity dependence on the excited-state transfer process is a consequence of the coupling of the H-atom transfer to conformational changes of the seven-membered ring in hypocrellin [50]. Hypericin does not have such a ring and does not exhibit such viscosity-dependent effects. We now consider two objections that may be raised to the assignment of the excited-state processes in hypericin and hypocrellin as H-atom transfer. These are the absence of a deuterium isotope effect for the 10-ps component of hypericin and hypocrellin and the mirror image symmetry between the absorption and the emission spectra in hypericin and hypocrellin.
OUTSTANDING QUESTIONS REGARDING HYPERICIN-LIKE PERYLENE QUINONES
7
The lack of a deuterium isotope effect [29, 32, 34, 38, 51] may be attributed to the reaction coordinate not being identified with the proton coordinate. There is precedent for this in other systems [52–54]. Requiring the absence of mirror image symmetry between the absorption and the emission spectra assumes that the potential energy surface of the emitting species is significantly different from that of the absorbing species. Such a displacement in the coordinate of the emitting species is clearly evident in the most commonly studied proton transfer systems (Fig. 1.5): methyl salicylate [55], 7-azaindole dimer [56, 57], 2-phenyl-benzotriazole [58], and 3-hydroxyflavone [59–63]. If, however, we consider systems in which the normal and tautomer species are symmetric, or nearly so, this disparity no longer exists or is significantly minimized. 5-Hydroxytropolone [64, 65] presents an excellent example of such a case. Other examples are the double H-atom transfer in naphthazarin [66] and in the 4,9-dihydroxyperylene-3,10-quinone subunit of hypocrellin, producing entirely symmetric structures (Fig. 1.5). We argue that hypericin and hypocrellin A have very similarly symmetric normal and tautomeric forms, as indicated by the highlighted bond systems in Fig. 1.1. That is, regardless of the tautomeric form in which the molecule finds itself, there is always conserved an aromatic core to which is attached a hydroxyl group peri to a carbonyl group. Even in the case of the monotautomerized species, it is possible to draw resonance forms that, upon superposition, restore the aromatic character of the substructure involved in the H-atom-transfer reaction. Consequently, we conclude that the mirror image symmetry observed in hypericin and hypocrellin is not at all surprising. If, on the other hand, the excitedstate reaction were a genuine proton transfer, then the resulting charge-separated species would be expected to exhibit an emission spectrum significantly different from that of the absorption spectrum, as in 3-hydroxyflavone, and the rate of reaction should be very sensitive to solvent polarity, which is not the case for hypericin or hypocrellin.
II. OUTSTANDING QUESTIONS REGARDING HYPERICIN-LIKE PERYLENE QUINONES A. Ground-State Heterogeneity As noted above, a possible objection to our assignment of the excited-state reaction to H-atom transfer in these perylene quinone systems is the observation of mirror image symmetry between the absorption and the emission spectra, which indicates minimal structural changes between the absorbing and the emitting species. Our first attempt to explain this symmetry was to suggest that the
8
HYPERICIN AND ITS PERYLENE QUINONE ANALOGS
Figure 1.5. Proton-transfer and H-atom-transfer species. In the upper half of the figure, the product of tautomerization is structurally and electronically different from the reactant. In contrast, H-atom transfer in 5-Hydroxytropolone results in nearly identical species, and double-tautomers of naphthazarin and 4,9-dihydroxyperylene-3,10-quinone are the ‘‘mirror’’ images of ‘‘normal’’ structures.
OUTSTANDING QUESTIONS REGARDING HYPERICIN-LIKE PERYLENE QUINONES
9
ground state of hypericin was populated with at least one other species, for example, a monotautomer [29]. This seemed to be reasonable, especially given the breadth of the visible absorption spectrum: There are no ‘‘gaps’’ of zero absorbance anywhere between the ultraviolet and 600 nm. Temperature-dependant 1H NMR and 2D-ROESY studies of hypericin, however, indicate that there is only one conformer/tautomer for hypericin in the ground state [50]. On the other hand, the NMR measurements indicate that three ground-state species are significantly populated for hypocrellin A [48, 50], owing largely to the flexibility of the seven-membered ring. That the seven-membered ring plays an important role in determining the populations of conformers and tautomers in the ground state is demonstrated by the NMR study of hypocrellin B. The seven-membered ring of hypocrellin B contains a double bond and is consequently more rigid than that of hypocrellin A. Only one ground-state conformer/tautomer is observed by NMR for hypocrellin B.
1. Recent Theoretical and Computational Approaches Previous quantum mechanical calculations also indicate that for hypericin the ground state is much less heterogeneous than we had believed. Based on ab initio calculations, (RMP2/6-31G(d) level of theory, using geometries obtained with the 3-21G basis and Hartree-Fock wavefunctions) only one hypericin species, the ‘‘normal’’ form, is populated in the ground state for an unionized gas phase species [67] (Fig. 1.6). Here we present more recent calculations using analytical instead of numerical Hessians, as was done in the earlier calculation. The initial structure used for hypericin was taken from previous work [67]. The structure was then reoptimized at the restricted Hartree-Fock (RHF) level theory, using the 6-31G(d) basis set. The Hessian (matrix of energy second derivatives with respect to Cartesian coordinates) of the optimized structure was calculated using a recently developed analytic Hessian method [68]. Diagonalization of the Hessian provides harmonic normal modes and corresponding vibrational frequencies [69]. Transition states and minima are indicated by 1 and no imaginary frequency mode, respectively. Hessian calculations provide vibrational frequencies and a diagnostic for the nature of a stationary point. There are two types of Hessian calculations: seminumerical, using a finite difference of analytic gradients, and fully analytic. The analytic approach employed in our method is usually preferable due to the significantly increased accuracy of the calculated vibrational frequencies as well as its considerable time savings. The relative efficiency and accuracy of analytic Hessians increase with the size of the molecule. All calculations presented were performed with the quantum chemistry program GAMESS [70].
10
HYPERICIN AND ITS PERYLENE QUINONE ANALOGS
Figure 1.6. (Left) Optimized structures for potential-energy minima of hypericin based on the RMP2/6-31G(d) level of theory, using geometries obtained with the 3-21G basis and Hartree-Fock wavefunctions. At the top, two views are shown for the ‘‘normal’’ form (Fig. 1.1), which is here referred to as the minimum energy structure (MIN). M1 and M2 are monotautomers; D1 and D2 are double tautomers. (Right) Estimated relative energies (kcal/mol) of minima and transition states. Energies including zero-point corrections are given in parentheses.
The structure of hypericin in its ‘‘normal’’ form is presented in Figures 1.7 and 1.8. It was established [67] that this C2 structure is the global minimum on the ground electronic state. The functional groups on carbon atoms 1, 13, and 14 (Figs. 1.1 and 1.7) are of primary interest. In particular, the distances between the oxygen atoms are crucial in understanding the H-atom-transfer kinetics and has been discussed by us in detail in our considerations of a unified picture of the hypericin and hypocrellin photophysics [34, 48, 71]. In the present calculation, ˚, the distances of the hydrogen bonds involving both O-H bonds are about 1.75 A slightly longer than in the previous work in which the 3-21G basis set was used [67]. 2. Recent Experimental Approaches Our most recent attempt to investigate the problem of ground-state heterogeneity experimentally uses tunable pump laser pulses derived from a home-made optical parametric amplifier (Fig. 1.9). A white light continuum is used to seed a two-stage optical parametric amplifier pumped by the second harmonic of a regeneratively amplified Ti-sapphire laser
OUTSTANDING QUESTIONS REGARDING HYPERICIN-LIKE PERYLENE QUINONES
11
Figure 1.7. Structure of hypericin in the ‘‘normal’’ form (7,14-dioxo tautomer). See the text for details.
operating at 815 nm. Our system is based on the design by Greenfield and Wasielewski [72]. A 10% beam splitter is used to divert a small fraction of the compressor output for continuum generation. A combination of a l/2 plate (HWP) and a thin-film polarizer (TFP) are used to control the exact intensity of the red before focusing it into a 1-mm-thick fused silica. The continuum generated is passed through a short-pass filter to eliminate any remaining fundamental
Figure 1.8. Side-on view of the hypericin ‘‘normal’’ form (7,14-dioxo tautomer). See the text for details.
12
HYPERICIN AND ITS PERYLENE QUINONE ANALOGS
Figure 1.9. The optical parametric amplifier (OPA). BS, beam splitter; TFP, thin-film polarizer; HWP, half-wave plate; LWP, dichroic beam splitter or long wave pass filter; F, filter.
and then through a HWP to obtain the right polarization for type II phase matching for the 3-mm-thick type II BBO crystal. The remaining IR is then reduced with a 2 telescope and passed through a 2-mm-thick LBO-I. The blue light generated at 407 nm is split into two parts by a combination of HWP and TFP. We used roughly equal amounts of blue to pump the first and second stage of the OPA. In the first stage, we used a single 500-mm lens to control the spot size of the blue at the crystal. Care was taken to avoid continuum generation by the blue itself, by not focusing it directly at the crystal. We have found that using a single long-focal-length lens in the first stage instead of using a telescope significantly increases the stability of the output of the first stage. The white light and the blue were combined with a dichroic beam splitter and spatially and temporally overlapped in the BBO-II. In the second stage, the residual blue spot size was reduced with a 3 telescope and passed through a HWP to have the matching polarization for type-I phase matching. The parametric output from the first stage and the residual blue were again combined with a dichroic beam splitter and spatially and temporally overlapped at the 2-mm-thick type-I BBO. Finally, a filter is used to select the tunable output in the visible region by rejecting the idler and the residual blue. Typically, the OPA
OUTSTANDING QUESTIONS REGARDING HYPERICIN-LIKE PERYLENE QUINONES
13
gives about 1 mJ of energy and is tunable from 475 to 700 nm. Tunability is achieved by angle tuning of the two BBO crystals simultaneously. This tunable source was used to investigate the transient absorption kinetics of hypericin in DMSO as a function of pump wavelength (Fig. 1.10). The startling result is that using pump wavelengths from 495 to 600 nm, the data can be fit globally by a sum of two exponentials, which except for two traces exhibits the 10-ps component characteristic of H-atom transfer. Fit results are compiled in Table 1.1. Thus, both experimental and theoretical work continue to point toward the remarkable conclusion that hypericin in the ground state exists in only one tautomeric or conformational form, as indicated by both optical and NMR spectroscopies.
Figure 1.10. Transient absorption kinetics for hypericin as a function of pump wavelength. In each panel, the first value corresponds to the pump wavelength; the second, to the probe wavelength. The significant feature of these data is that they can be uniformly fit to two time constants, of which one corresponds to the characteristic H-atom-transfer time of 10 ps. The results of a global fit to these data are compiled in Table 1.1.
14
HYPERICIN AND ITS PERYLENE QUINONE ANALOGS
Figure 1.10. (Continued)
OUTSTANDING QUESTIONS REGARDING HYPERICIN-LIKE PERYLENE QUINONES
15
TABLE 1.1 Absorption Transients for Hypericin in DMSO as a Function of Pump Wavelengtha l Pump (nm) 495 495 495 495 520 520 520 520 600 600
l Probe (nm) 560 600 610 660 560 600 610 660 610 660
a1 0.09 0.23 0.39 0.20 0.15 0.13 0.22 0.20 — —
a2 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1
a
The absorption transients are fit globally to a sum of two exponentials: AðtÞ ¼ a1 exp ðt=t1 Þ þa2 exp ðt=t2 Þ. The two time constants are kept fixed for all the kinetic traces at values of 10 and 5000 ps for t1 and t2, respectively. The value of 5000 is approximately the value of the fluorescence lifetime of hypericin, which is long on the time scale used to acquire these kinetic traces and may be considered to be infinite.
B. Are There Multiple H-Atom Transfers in the Perylene Quinones? Given the structure of the perylene quinones of interest here (Fig. 1.1), with either one (hypocrellin A) or two (hypericin), hydroxyl groups peri to a carbonyl on either end of the molecule, one is naturally inclined to inquire how many hydrogen atoms are transferred in the excited state. And, if more than one is transferred, one must necessarily inquire whether the process is stepwise or concerted. (It is useful to note the difference between a concerted and a synchronous reaction. A concerted reaction takes place in a single kinetic step, with no reaction intermediate, in which some of the changes in bonding take place to different extents in different parts of the reaction. A synchronous reaction is one in which all the bond-making and bond-breaking processes take place at the same time and proceed at the same extent during the reaction [73, 74]. It is a common error to assume that concertedness implies synchrony.) The availability of hypomycin B [1], where there is only one peri hydroxyl group and only one intramolecular hydrogen bond, provides an excellent means to investigate these questions. Hypomycin B is unique in that it has only one intramolecular hydrogen bond as opposed to the two in hypocrellin A and the four in hypericin (Fig. 1.1). Picosecond transient absorption data for hypomycin B fail to reveal any stimulated
16
HYPERICIN AND ITS PERYLENE QUINONE ANALOGS
Figure 1.11. Comparison of the kinetic traces of hypomycin B in MeOD (solid lines) and in MeOH (dashed lines). The probe wavelengths are given in the top right hand corner of each panel. A global fit was carried out to fit the decays of the several wavelengths. In MeOH, the global time constant was 82 ps, whereas that in MeOD was 75 ps; lex ¼ 407 nm.
emission, let alone rise time in stimulated emission (unlike hypocrellin and hypericin), which we have interpreted in terms of excited-state H-atom transfer (Fig. 1.11). Furthermore, a global analysis of the excited-state kinetics at four different probe wavelengths in MeOD and MeOH yields no significant difference in the excited-state kinetics: The time constants are 82 and 75 ps, respectively. Transient absorption data for hypomycin B in other solvents, such as DMSO and buffer-DMSO mixtures (data not shown), also failed to reveal any rise time in the stimulated emission. In the context of our previous arguments and criteria for identifying H-atom transfer in hypericin, hypocrellin, and their analogs, one might hastily conclude that hypomycin B does not undergo this process.
OUTSTANDING QUESTIONS REGARDING HYPERICIN-LIKE PERYLENE QUINONES
17
If subsequent experiments do indeed demonstrate that excited-state H-atom transfer does not occur in hypomycin B, then one may draw the conclusion that multiple transfers (either concerted or stepwise) must occur in these perylene quinones and that by frustrating the process in one half of the molecule, the process in the other half is impeded. At this point, such reasoning is speculative and contrary to the growing body of evidence provided by theory and experiment. As indicated above, quantum mechanical calculations indicate that the double-H-atom transfer in hypericin [67] and in the perylene quinone nucleus [75] of hypocrellin is energetically unfavorable compared to the single-transfer event. Experiments for hypericin in which one half of the molecule cannot participate in H-atom transfer owing to protonation of the carbonyl group (or even perhaps complexation with a metal ion) [76] also indicate that the transfer process can still occur. Given the richness of the photophysics of these perylene quinones and their attendant complexity, it is premature to conclude that hypomycin B does not execute an excited-state H-atom transfer. Certainly, much more work is required to reach a proper judgment. This will include fluorescence upconversion experiments with picosecond resolution in order to interrogate the entire time scale of relevance as well as to monitor only emission, which can simplify the analysis [48]. For example, the failure to detect stimulated emission for hypomycin B may simply be the result of the presence of a strongly absorbing species in the same spectral region. Also, experiments must be performed to determine if hypomycin B, like hypericin and hypocrellin A, acts as an excited-state acid. It is clear, however, that hypomycin B is an important system with which to test and refine our current understanding of these naturally occurring perylene quinones. One of the most important questions that the study of hypomycin B might fruitfully address is the elucidation of the reaction coordinate in the H-atom-transfer process in the perylene quinones. As we have discussed in depth elsewhere, despite the similarities in the structures of hypericin and hypocrellin, which are centered about the perylene quinone nucleus, their excited-state photophysics exhibit rich and varied behavior. The H-atom transfer is characterized by a wide range of time constants, which in certain cases exhibit deuterium isotope effects and solvent dependence. Of particular interest is that the shortest time constant we have observed for the H-atom transfer is 10 ps. This is exceptionally long for such a process, 100 fs being expected when the solute H atom does not hydrogen bond to the solvent [62]. That the transfer time is so long in the perylene quinones has been attributed to the identification of the reaction coordinate with skeletal motions of the molecule [48, 50]. We have previously observed that when hypericin is bound to human serum albumin, it no longer undergoes an excited-state H-atom transfer. Assuming that the binding occurs through the interaction of one of the two carbonyl groups of hypericin and the N1-H of the single tryptophan residue (W214), which would
18
HYPERICIN AND ITS PERYLENE QUINONE ANALOGS
necessarily impede H-atom transfer on this half of the hypericin molecule, we suggested that the absence of H-atom transfer in the complex indicated concerted, double-H-atom transfer in the excited state of hypericin [36]. We suggested that H-atom transfer is completely impeded when hypericin binds to HSA because skeletal motion is coupled to the H-atom transfer [48, 50]. Fluorescence anisotropy measurements of the HSA–hypericin complex indicate that the hypericin is rigidly bound and that there is no rapid restricted motion of hypericin relative to the protein. By analogy, one might argue that if H-atom transfer does not occur in hypomycin B, it is not because the process requires that two H atoms be in flight but because the required skeletal motion is restricted by the presence of the O-C-O bond. Although this response is plausible, it is not easy to reconcile it with the observation that hypericin undergoes Hatom transfer in a glass at low temperatures (the energy of activation is 0.05 kcal/mol) [37], where the amplitude of skeletal motion would seem to be less than that in the HSA matrix. These sorts of problems and questions continue to illustrate the need for further elucidation of the reaction coordinate for the H-atom transfer in hypericin and its analogs. To conclude this section, we note that our assignment of excited-state H-atom transfer to the primary photoprocess in hypericin, hypocrellin, and their derivatives has occasioned some objections, to which we refer in the introduction and that we address in detail elsewhere [48, 71]. An additional concern, which has been brought to our attention and which is relevant in the light of the previous discussion, is the following. As we note above, we have measured the energy of activation for the H-atom transfer in hypericin to be 0.05 kcal/ mol (or 20 cm1). The absence of an isotope effect for the hypericin reaction (and for the 10-ps reaction in hypocrellin A) indicates that the reaction coordinate is not the hydrogen atom coordinate (which theoretical and experimental results suggest is 1450 cm1 in the hypericin triplet [77]) and consequently must involve the skeletal motions noted above. It has been suggested by an anonymous colleague that if there is a slow H-atom transfer that is not limited by the H-atom coordinate, ‘‘then it must be that vibrational excitation of oxygen or ring modes is what limits the rate. This would correspond to a significant vibrational barrier and hence large activation energy.’’ We disagree with the last statement. Quantum mechanical calculations [67] (see also www.msg.ameslab.gov/Group/ Supplementary_Material/Hypericin/) indicate that there are four calculated frequencies (unscaled) below 100 cm1: 40 cm1, out-of-plane motion of oxygens and carbons; 48 cm1, oxygen and carbon displacements; 80 cm1, mostly OH oxygen motion; and 84 cm1: mostly OH oxygen motion. There is no dearth of low-frequency vibrations in large biological molecules, as the calculations and many experiments suggest [78–80], and we believe that such motions may indeed be coupled to the H-atom transfer in these perylene quinone systems.
OUTSTANDING QUESTIONS REGARDING HYPERICIN-LIKE PERYLENE QUINONES
19
Our previous results on hypericin indicate that excited-state H-atom transfer occurs even when one of the carbonyls is prohibited from accepting a hydrogen. The presence of such a transfer is apparent under very acidic conditions in AOT reverse micelles and cannot be excluded upon chelation of Tb3þ [76]. There is thus no evidence for a concerted H-atom-transfer mechanism in hypericin. In the present study, contrary to our initial expectations, we are not even able to demonstrate that hypomycin B executes an excited-state H-atom transfer; hence our investigation sheds no light on the general question of how many H atoms are transferred in the perylene quinones and whether the transfer is concerted or stepwise. On the other hand, if further investigation reveals that H-atom transfer does not occur in hypomycin B, the result would have considerable implications for an understanding of the reaction coordinate for the H-atom transfer.
C. Identifying the H-Atom Translocation Above we addressed the absence of a deuterium isotope effect for the 10-ps component of hypericin and hypocrellin and the mirror image symmetry between the absorption and the emission spectra in hypericin and hypocrellin. We recognize, however, that no matter how satisfactory one finds our reasoning, a direct demonstration of an excited-state H-atom transfer is required, which entails measurements of the carbonyl or hydroxyl stretching frequency as a function of time subsequent to laser excitation. A first step in this process is the identification of vibrational modes that indicate translation of the H-atom between the enol and the keto oxygens. We have addressed this problem by employing time-resolved infrared spectroscopy to hypericin and to two of its analogs that cannot undergo excited-state H-atom transfer (Fig. 1.12) [77]. The salient feature of these spectra is in the region between 1400 and 1500 cm1, where a strong band is present for hypericin and is absent in both O-hexamethoxy hypericin, which lacks hydrogen atoms that can coordinate to the carbonyl, and in the reduced analog, which lacks the necessary carbonyls. The ground-state infrared spectrum of hypericin is included at the top of Figure 1.12. Ab initio quantum mechanical calculations, at the Hartree-Fock 3-21G level [77], reveal strong normal modes in this spectral region for the triplet species of the normal form of hypericin and the 6,14- and 7,13-dioxo monotautomers (Fig. 1.1). Calculations were not performed for the triplet species of the double tautomers. Assignments of these modes have been given elsewhere [77]. Our most recent calculations on the ground-state 7,14-dioxotautomer using the analytical Hessian method and the 6-31G basis set provide the results compiled in Table 1.2 and the corresponding theoretical infrared spectrum depicted in Figure 1.13.
20
HYPERICIN AND ITS PERYLENE QUINONE ANALOGS
Figure 1.12. Comparison of the transient infrared spectra on the microsecond time scale of hypericin, O-hexamethoxy hypericin, and a hypericin analog that lacks carbonyl groups (the hexaacetoxy analog). The salient feature of the data is that the latter two compounds, which cannot execute excited state H-atom transfer owing to the absence of either labile protons or appropriate carbonyl groups, lack the feature at 1450 cm1. Ab initio calculations at the Hartree-Fock 3-21G level for the normal and two monotautomeric forms of the hypericin triplets indicate normal modes with substantial O...H...O character in the region 1400–1460 cm1 [77]. While these preliminary results do not demonstrate a time-resolved H-atom transfer, they do clearly point to a region of the spectrum that must be investigated in further studies. Hypericin and hexamethoxy hypericin, solid line, 0–1 m,s and dashed line, 14–18 ms; reduced analog, solid line, 0–0.5 ms, and dashed line, 7–9 ms.
OUTSTANDING QUESTIONS REGARDING HYPERICIN-LIKE PERYLENE QUINONES
21
TABLE 1.2 Calculated Frequencies of the Normal Mode Vibrations of the Ground State 7,14-Dioxotautomer Hypericin Species Freqency (cm1) Scaled Frequencya IR Intensity
a
b
1262
1123
16
1341 1523
1194 1356
20 13
1741
1550
14
1840
1638
53
3835
3413
12
4107
3655
6
Descriptionb C(3)-O-H, C(4)-O-H, C(2)-O, C(5)-O; motions and ring breathing Ring breathing C(1)-O-H, C(6)-O-H, C(8)-O-H, C(13)-O-H; motions and planar ring breathing Peripheral carbons stretch in plane and ring breathing Peripheral carbons stretch up and down in phase O-H stretches on C(1), C(6), C(13) O-H stretches on C(3), C(4)
The calculated frequencies are scaled by a factor of 0.89 [81]. See Figure 1.7 for atom labelling.
The major finding of this study is that a vibrational mode corresponding to H-atom translocation can been identified in hypericin by the joint contributions of synthetic, computational, and spectroscopic methods. Identification of this mode is only a first step in providing a direct demonstration of excited-state intramolecular H-atom transfer in hypericin and its analogs. There is considerable work to be accomplished. As indicated elsewhere [77], ab initio calculations predict that the normal modes in this region of the spectrum are close for the normal and the monotautomeric forms. The direct observation of the formation of the tautomer will require both adequate temporal and spectral resolution. It must be remembered, furthermore, that the identification of the H-atom translocation mode is not equivalent to the identification of the reaction coordinate. We have attributed the absence of a deuterium isotope effect on the excited-state H-atom transfer (for the 10-ps component in hypericin and hypocrellin A) to the zero-point energy in the proton coordinate lying above the barrier, with the H-atom being effectively delocalized between the two oxygen atoms. Consequently, the reaction coordinate for the excited-state H-atom transfer cannot be identified with the proton coordinate, and it must be concluded that other intramolecular motions are in fact responsible for the process. Temperature-dependent measurements indicate that these motions are extremely low amplitude, Ea ¼ 0.05 kcal/mol for hypericin [37]. Because the nature of this motion is not yet identified, we refer to it as the skeleton coordinate [48, 71, 82]. We propose that it is the time scale for this latter conformational change
22
HYPERICIN AND ITS PERYLENE QUINONE ANALOGS
Figure 1.13. Theoretical infrared spectrum of hypericin. The agreement with the experimental spectrum, presented in Figure 1.12, is quite good. Hypericin has 156 vibration frequencies. All these frequencies are presented in this simulated IR spectrum. The calculated frequencies were scaled by a factor 0.89 [81]. Frequencies in the range of 1100–1800 cm1 correspond to C-H stretches and backbone breathing. Toward the high end of the spectrum, from 3200 to 4100 cm1, the frequencies correspond to O-H stretches. The description of highest calculated frequencies is presented Table 1.2. The majority of the vibrations correspond to internal bending and stretching in the backbone of hypericin (ring breathing).
that determines the observed H-atom-transfer time. The exact nature of the conformational changes that are coupled to the H-atom-transfer reaction in hypericin and hypocrellin has yet to be identified [82].
III. CONCLUDING REMARKS We presented an overview of what we consider to be the current outstanding problems in understanding the photophysics of hypericin and its analogs. Many questions remain unanswered, and a wealth of theoretical and experimental techniques will be required to address them. It is surprising that given the richness of the physical, chemical, biological, and physiological behaviors of hypericin and
REFERENCES
23
the class of molecules to which it belongs, their importance has not been widely appreciated.
ACKNOWLEDGMENTS This work has been supported by NIH grant GM57351 and NSF grants BIR9413969 and CHE-9613962. We are grateful to J. Toscano and P. Jardon for their assistance and their helpful discussions. We thank W.-Z. Liu and H.-Y. Zhang for providing us with hypomycin B. M. Gordon thanks the Air Force Office of Scientific Research for its support.
REFERENCES 1. P. K. Chowdhury, K. Das, A. Datta, W. Z. Liu, H. Y. Zhang, and J. W. Petrich, J. Photochem. Photobiol. A Chem. 2002, 154, 107. 2. A. Datta, P. Bandyopadhyay, J. Wen, J. W. Petrich, and M. S. Gordon, J. Phys. Chem. A 2001, 105, 1057. 3. D. Meruelo, G. Lavie, and D. Lavie, Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA 1988, 85, 5230. 4. J. Lenard, A. Rabson, and R. Vanderoef, Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA 1993, 90, 158. 5. J. B. Hudson, J. Zhou, J. Chen, L. Harris, L. Yip, and G. H. N. Towers, Photochem. Photobiol. 1994, 60, 253. 6. W. T. Couldwell, R. Gopalakrishna, D. R. Hinton, S. He, M. H. Weiss, R. E. Law, and M. L. Apuzzo, Neurosurgery 1994, 35, 705. 7. L. Anker, R. Gopalakrishna, K. D. Jones, R. E. Law, and W. T. Couldwell, Drugs Future 1995, 20, 511. 8. W. Zhang, R. E. Law, D. R. Hinton, and W. T. Couldwell, Cancer Lett. 1997, 120, 31. 9. K. Linde, G. Ramirez, C. D. Mulrow, A. Pauls, W. Weidenhammer, and D. Melchart, Br. Med. J. 1996, 313, 253. 10. O. K. Suzuki, M. Oya, S. Bladt, and H. Wagner, Planta Medica 1984, 50, 272. 11. I. N. S. Takahashi, E. Kobayashi, H. Nakano, K. Suziki, and T. Tamaoki, Biochem. Biophys. Res. Commun. 1989, 165, 1207. 12. A. Andreoni, A. Colasanti, P. Colasanti, M. Mastrocinique, and P. Riccio, Photochem. Photobiol. 1994, 59, 529. 13. C. Thomas, R. S. MacGill, G. C. Miller, and R. S. Pardini, Photochem. Photobiol. 1992, 55, 47. 14. A. L. Vandenbogaerde, E. M. Delaey, A. M. Vantieghem, B. E. Himpens, W. J. Merlevede, and P. A. deWitte, Photochem. Photobiol. 1998, 67, 119. 15. P. Agostinis, A. Donella-Deana, J. Cuveele, A. Vandenbogaerde, S. Sarno, W. Merlevede, and P. deWitte, Biochem. Biophys. Res. Commun. 1996, 220, 613.
24
HYPERICIN AND ITS PERYLENE QUINONE ANALOGS
16. A. L. Vandenbogaerde and P. A. deWitte, Phytother. Res. 1996, 10, S150. 17. A. L. Vandenbogaerde, J. F. Cuveele, P. Proot, B. E. Himpens, W. J. Merlevede, and P. A. deWitte, J. Photochem. Photobiol. B Biol. 1997, 38, 136. 18. A. Mirossay, L. Mirossay, J. Tothova, P. Miskovsky, H. Onderkova, and J. Mojzis, Phytomedicine 1999, 6, 311. 19. L. Mirossay, A. Mirossay, E. Kocisova, I. Radvakova, P. Miskovsky, and J. Mojzis, Physiol. Res. 1999, 48, 135. 20. A. Mirossay, J. Mojzis, J. Tothova, M. Hajikova, A. Lackova, and L. Mirossay, Phytomedicine 2000, 7, 471. 21. A. Mirossay, H. Onderkova, L. Mirossay, M. Sarissky, and J. Mojzis, Physiol. Res. 2001, 50, 635. 22. A. Mirossay, L. Mirossay, M. Sarissky, P. Papp, and J. Mojzis, Physiol. Res. 2002, 51, 641. 23. N. Duran and P.-S. Song, Photochem. Photobiol. 1986, 43, 677. 24. J. W. Lown, Can. J. Chem. 1997, 75, 99. 25. Z. Diwu, Photochem. Photobiol. 1995, 61, 529. 26. G. A. Kraus, W. J. Zhang, M. J. Fehr, J. W. Petrich, Y. Wannemuehler, and S. Carpenter, Chem. Rev. 1996, 96, 523. 27. H. Falk, Angewandte Chem. Int. Ed. 1999, 38, 3117. 28. F. Gai, M. J. Fehr, and J. W. Petrich, J. Am. Chem. Soc. 1993, 115, 3384. 29. F. Gai, M. J. Fehr, and J. W. Petrich, J. Phys. Chem. 1994, 98, 8352. 30. F. Gai, M. J. Fehr, and J. W. Petrich, J. Phys. Chem. 1994, 98, 5784. 31. K. Das, D. S. English, M. J. Fehr, A. V. Smirnov, and J. W. Petrich, J. Phys. Chem. 1996, 100, 18275. 32. K. Das, D. S. English, and J. W. Petrich, J. Phys. Chem. A 1997, 101, 3241. 33. K. Das, D. S. English, and J. W. Petrich, J. Am. Chem. Soc. 1997, 119, 2763. 34. K. Das, A. V. Smirnov, M. D. Snyder, and J. W. Petrich, J. Phys. Chem. B 1998, 102, 6098. 35. K. Das, E. Dertz, J. Paterson, W. Zhang, G. A. Kraus, and J. W. Petrich, J. Phys. Chem. B 1998, 102, 1479. 36. K. Das, A. V. Smirnov, J. Wen, P. Miskovsky, and J. W. Petrich, Photochem. Photobiol. 1999, 69, 633. 37. K. Das, K. D. Ashby, J. Wen, and J. W. Petrich, J. Phys. Chem. B 1999, 103, 1581. 38. D. S. English, K. Das, K. D. Ashby, J. Park, J. W. Petrich, and E. W. Castner, J. Am. Chem. Soc. 1997, 119, 11585. 39. M. J. Fehr, M. A. McCloskey, and J. W. Petrich, J. Am. Chem. Soc. 1995, 117, 1833. 40. F. Sureau, P. Miskovsky, L. Chinsky, and P. Y. Turpin, J. Am. Chem. Soc. 1996, 118, 9484. 41. R. Chaloupka, F. Sureau, E. Kocisova, and J. W. Petrich, Photochem. Photobiol. 1998, 68, 44. 42. L. H. Pinto, L. J. Holsinger, and R. A. Lamb, Cell 1992, 69, 517.
REFERENCES
25
43. K. J. Newell and I. F. Tannock, Cancer Res. 1989, 49, 4447. 44. K. J. Newell, P. Wood, I. Stratford, and I. Tannock, Br. J. Cancer 1992, 66, 311. 45. R. A. Gottlieb, E. Skowronski, and B. M. Babior, Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA 1996, 93, 654. 46. J. E. Li, J. Biol. Chem. 1995, 270, 3203. 47. M. A. Barry, J. E. Reynold, and A. Eastman, Cancer Res. 1993, 53, 2349. 48. A. V. Smirnov, K. Das, D. S. English, Z. Wan, G. A. Kraus, and J. W. Petrich, J. Phys. Chem. A 1993, 103, 7949. 49. D. S. English, W. Zhang, G. A. Kraus, and J. W. Petrich, J. Am. Chem. Soc. 1997, 119, 2980. 50. A. Smirnov, D. B. Fulton, A. Andreotti, and J. W. Petrich, J. Am. Chem. Soc. 1999, 121, 7979. 51. D. S. English, K. Das, J. M. Zenner, W. Zhang, G. A. Kraus, R. C. Larock, and J. W. Petrich, J. Phys. Chem. A. 1997, 101, 3235. 52. W. Frey, F. Laermer, and T. Elsaesser, J. Phys. Chem. 1991, 95, 10391. 53. J. L. Herek, S. Pedersen, L. Banares, and A. H. Zewail, J. Chem. Phys. 1992, 97, 9046. 54. L. Peteanu and R. A. Mathies, J. Phys. Chem. 1992, 96, 6910. 55. J. Goodman and L. E. Brus, J. Am. Chem. Soc. 1978, 100, 7472. 56. C. A. Taylor, M. A. El-Bayou, and M. Kasha, Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA 1969, 63, 253. 57. S. Takeuchi and T. Tamara, Chem. Phys. Lett. 1997, 277, 340. 58. Y. R. Kim, J. T. Yardley, and R. M. Hochstrasser, Chem. Phys. 1989, 136, 311. 59. T. C. Swinney and D. F. Kelley, J. Phys. Chem. 1991, 95, 10369. 60. G. A. Brucker, D. F. Kelley, and T. C. Swinney, J. Phys. Chem. 1991, 95, 3190. 61. D. McMorrow and M. Kasha, Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA 1984, 81, 3375. 62. B. J. Schwartz, L. A. Peteanu, and C. B. Harris, J. Phys. Chem. 1992, 96, 3591. 63. A. J. G. Strandjord and P. F. Barbara, J. Phys. Chem. 1985, 89, 2355. 64. R. Croteau and R. M. Leblanc, Photochem. Photobiol. 1978, 28, 33. 65. F. A. Ensminger, J. Plassard, T. S. Zwier, and S. Hardinger, J. Chem. Phys. 1993, 99, 8341. 66. S. Mazzini, L. Merlini, R. Mondelli, G. Nasini, E. Ragg, and L. Scalioni, J. Chem. Soc., Perkin Trans. 1997 2, 2013. 67. J. W. Petrich, M. S. Gordon, and M. Cagle, J. Phys. Chem. A 1998, 102, 1647. 68. Y. A. Alexeev, M. W. Schmidt, T. L. Windus, and M. S. Gordon, unpublished data. 69. W. D. Gwinn, J. Chem. Phys. 1971, 55, 477. 70. M. W. Schmidt, K. K. Baldridge, J. A. Boatz, S. T. Elbert, M. S. Gordon, J. H. Jensen, S. Koseki, N. Matsunaga, K. A. Nguyen, S. Su, T. L. Windus, M. Dupuis, and J. A. Montgomery Jr., J. Comp. Chem. 1993, 14, 1347. 71. J. W. Petrich, Int. Rev. Phys. Chem. 2000, 19, 479. 72. S. R. Greenfield and M. R. Wasielewski, Opt. Lett. 1995, 20, 1394.
26 73. 74. 75. 76. 77.
78. 79. 80. 81. 82.
HYPERICIN AND ITS PERYLENE QUINONE ANALOGS
M. J. S. Dewar, J. Am. Chem. Soc. 1984, 106, 209. Y. Chen, F. Gai, and J. W. Petrich, J. Am. Chem. Soc. 1993, 115, 10158. D. Z. Chen, D. P. Wang, H. Y. Zhang, and B. Tang, Chem. Phys. Lett. 2002, 353, 119. J. Park, A. Datta, P. K. Chowdhury, and J. W. Petrich, Photochem. Photobiol. 2001, 73, 105. B. M. Showalter, A. Datta, P. K. Chowdhury, J. Park, P. Bandyopadhyay, P. K. Choudhury, S. Kesavan, Y. Zeng, G. A. Kraus, M. S. Gordon, J. P. Toscano, and J. W. Petrich, Photochem. Photobiol. 2001, 74, 157. L. Zhu, P. Li, M. Huang, J. T. Sage, and P. M. Champion, Phys. Rev. Lett. 1994, 72, 301. M. H. Vos, J. C. Lambry, S. J. Robles, D. C. Youvan, J. Breton, and J. L. Martin, Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA 1991, 88, 8885. U. Liebl, G. Lipowski, M. Negrerie, J. C. Lambry, J. L. Martin, and M. H. Vos, Nature 1999, 401, 181. A. P. Scott and L. Radom, J. Phys. Chem. 1996, 100, 16502. A. Datta, A. V. Smirnov, J. Wen, G. Chumanov, and J. W. Petrich, Photochem. Photobiol. 2000, 71, 166.
THIOPHOSGENE: A TAILOR-MADE MOLECULE FOR PHOTOCHEMICAL AND PHOTOPHYSICAL STUDIES David C. Moule Department of Chemistry, Brock University, St. Catharines, ON L2S3A1, Canada Takashige Fujiwara and Edward C. Lim* Department of Chemistry and the Center for Laser and Optical Spectroscopy The University of Akron, Akron, OH 44325-3601
CONTENTS I. II.
III.
Introduction Electronic States A. Molecular Orbitals and Electron Configurations B. S0, Ground Electronic State C. S1 (n,p*), First Excited Singlet State D. T1, First Triplet Electronic State E. S2, Second Singlet Excited State Photophysical Properties A. S1 Thiophosgene B. S2 Thiophosgene
*Holder of the Goodyear Chair in Chemistry at The University of Akron. Advances in Photochemistry, Volume 28 Edited by Douglas C. Neckers, William S. Jenks, and Thomas Wolff # 2005 John Wiley & Sons, Inc.
27
28
THIOPHOSGENE
IV. Concluding Remarks Acknowledgments References
I. INTRODUCTION Thiophosgene is a tailor-made molecule for studying the spectroscopic and photophysical properties of medium-size systems. The double bonding of the S, sulfur to the carbon atom, in the form of the thiocarbonyl chromophore C has the effect of red shifting the positions of the electronic transitions to longer wavelengths, where the spectra are often discrete (sharp features in the structure). Moreover, the electronic transitions lie in the visible and near-ultraviolet regions of the optical spectrum and are easily accessible by tunable dye lasers. The molecule also exhibits highly unusual photophysical properties in that both the first (S1) and the second excited singlet (S2) states exhibit fluorescence with very high efficiencies. The understanding of the spectra, the assignments, and analyses is aided by the high-molecular symmetry of Cl2CS. With only degrees of freedom of vibrational freedom, the assignments of the vibrational structure is a tractable though nontrivial problem. These size and symmetry factors allow for high level ab initio Hartree-Fock calculations from which the spectroscopic and dynamical properties can be inferred. Some of these unique spectroscopic and photophysical properties stem from the lack of a vibrational mode of a2 symmetry that is needed to couple the two ~ 1A2(n,p*) vibronically and ~ 1A1(n2) and S1: A lowest electronic states, S0: X allows for the S1 ! S0 internal conversion [1]. This lack of a radiationless pathway leads to the alternative fluorescence deactivation of S1 with high quantum yield. But the unusual feature is that this same a2 internal motion (rotation about ~ 1A1 (p,p*) electronic state S bond) is needed to couple the higher S2: B the C with the S1 state, such that the a2 vibrational deficiency also prohibits the radiationless decay from the S2 state to the S1 state [1]. The net result is that both the S2 and S1 singlet electronic states fluoresce with high quantum yields. This fluorescence from the second excited electronic state is in violation of Kasha’s rule [2]. It is this intense fluorescence from the S2 and S1 singlet electronic states that is used as a powerful diagnostic tool for elucidating the excited-state relaxation rates and mechanisms. This feature of the photophysics/spectroscopy allows not only for direct one-photon S2 ! S0 and S1 ! S0 laser-induced fluorescence (LIF) spectroscopies but also for two-photon optical-optical double resonance (OODR) experiments involving pump–probe experiments between the S0 (ground state) and intermediate S1/T1 states and the target S2 state, S2 S1 S0, or S2 T1 S0, respectively. The differing selection rules for the one- and sequential two-photon vibronic transitions allow for spectral
ELECTRONIC STATES
29
comparisons, a valuable tool for the assignment and understanding of the observed levels. In addition, the energies of these three singlet states are positioned such that the spectroscopies can be explored with dye lasers that operate efficiently in the visible region of the spectrum. Aside from the vibrational wavenumber intervals, Ev, the other tools that are available as an aid in the assignment are (1) the vibronic band intensities within the envelope of the band progressions (Franck-Condon factors); (2) the g ¼ Cl(35,35) Cl(35,37) built-in chlorine isotope effects; (3) ¼ () (þ), the inversion doubling splittings that are created by the quantum penetration of the molecular barriers; and (4) the differing selection rules for the one- and two-photon processes. The final and equally significant advantage is that Cl2CS is the only small thiocarbonyl species that is commercially available, and it does not have to created and detected in a flash pyrolysis system, as do the other thiocarbonyl transients. For these reasons, thiophosgene has been the subject of extensive spectroscopic and photophysical interest in both the gaseous and the condensed phases. Two reviews provide a useful background. The first, by Clouthier and Moule [3], describes the spectroscopy of small carbonyl, thiocarbonyl, and selenocarbonyl molecules and compares their structural and spectroscopic properties. A more recent review of the photophysics and physical photochemistry was given by Maciejewski and Steer [4], who treated a wide range of thiocarbonyl systems in the vapor and condensed phases. In this chapter, we present recent developments in the experimental and theoretical studies of the structure and excited-state dynamics of gaseous thiophosgene. A major emphasis of the chapter is the OODR and other experiments in supersonic jet that probe and characterize dark electronic states and their coupling with the bright states. The paper is organized as follows: We begin with a brief discussion of molecular orbitals and energy-level dispositions of electronic states. We next describe the spectroscopy of individual electronic states in sequence: ground (S0) state, first excited singlet (S1) state, first triplet (T1) state, and second excited singlet (S2) state. In addition to the standard one-photon spectroscopy, the S2 X S0 OODR spectroscopy involving S1 and T1 as an intermediate (X) state is included in the presentation. We conclude the chapter by describing photophysical properties of the S1, S2, and T1 thiophosgene. Nonradiative transitions to dark states, bound as well as dissociative, are presented in this section.
II. ELECTRONIC STATES A. Molecular Orbitals and Electron Configurations Thiophosgene possesses the planar molecular structure of Figure 2.1 in the ground electronic state and can be classified by the symmetry operations of
30
THIOPHOSGENE
Figure 2.1. The molecular structures and symmetry axes for the planar S0 (ground) and S1 (first excited) electronic states of thiophosgene.
the C2v point group. With the symmetry axes taken to conform to the Herzberg notation [5] (z-axis directed along the C S bond; x-axis in the out-of-plane direction), the symmetry properties can be classified according to one of the four irreducible representations, A1, A2, B1, and B2 (Table 2.1). The starting point for the analyses of the various electronic spectra and the corresponding photophysical decay processes begins with a consideration of the electronic states and the electronic configurations in the excitation processes. A schematic view of the molecular orbitals [6] is given in Figure 2.2, along with the symmetry species of the individual orbitals and their approximate descriptions. In order of increasing energy, the outermost orbitals associated only with the C S chromophore are (s), (n0 ), (p), (n), (p*), and (s*), where n is the thiocarbonyl nonbonding orbital, and n0 a second nonbonding orbital, (chlorine orbitals are excluded). The electronic configuration of the ground state can be written (s)2(n0 )2(p)2(n)2(p*)0(s*)0, where each of the inner orbitals are doubly occupied by an electron pair and the outer orbitals (virtual) are empty. The symmetry species of each of these MOs can be inferred from the orbital diagram of Figure 2.2 and the transformation properties of Table 2.1 The s and s* orbitals lie in the molecular plane, have the full structural symmetry of the
TABLE 2.1 C2v
E
A1 A2 B1 B2
þ1 þ1 þ1 þ1
Character Table for the C2v Point Group C2 (z) þ1 þ1 1 1
s (x,z)
s (y,z)
þ1 1 þ1 1
þ1 1 1 þ1
Tz Rz Tx, Ry Ty , Rx
ELECTRONIC STATES
31
~ ~ 1A1(n2), A Figure 2.2. The p, n, p*, and s* molecular orbitals that create the X 1 1 1 ~ ~ A2(n,p*), B A1(p,p*), and C B2(n,s*) states along with the first three low-energy singlet-singlet transitions. (Reprinted with permission from ref. [6].)
static molecule, belong to the totally symmetric A1 representation. The p and p* orbitals project from the plane, transform as translations in the x direction, and are of B1 species. The last of these orbitals, the nonbonding n orbital resides on the sulfur atom and is antisymmetric with respect to a reflection in the xz plane. It belong to the B2 representation. The symmetry of the ground state electronic wavefunction is derived as the direct product of the representations of the occupied one electron orbitals. A1 ðsÞ A1 ðsÞ B1 ðpÞ B1 ðpÞ B2 ðnÞ B2 ðnÞ ¼ A1 ~ 1A1(n2) in the Herzberg This state is labeled S0 in photophysical notation or X notation [5]. There are two notations for labeling the electronic states: In the notation used by photochemists, the singlet and triplet states are labeled S0, S1, S2, . . . and T1, T2, T3 . . . in order of increasing energy. The alternative nota~, B ~ . . . for the singlet states and ~a, ~b, ~, A ~, C tion, by Herzberg, uses the symbols X ~c . . . for triplet states. In this review, we will use both notations as appropriate. The first excited electronic state is created through an electron promotion from the least binding n nonbonding orbital to the lowest antibonding orbital p*, . . . (p)2(n)1(p*)1(s*)0. As the n orbital is of B2 symmetry and p* of B1 symmetry, it follows that the S1 state is of B2(n) B1(p*) ¼ A2 electronic symmetry. ~ 1A2(n,p*). The second S2 This state then bears the spectroscopic designation A excited electronic state is the result of an electron promotion from the p bonding orbital to the p* antibonding orbital to give an S2 state of B1(p) B1(p*) ¼ A1 ~ 1A1(p,p*). The final state for consideration, S3, is brought about by symmetry, B ~ 1B2(n,s*). n to s* excitation, B2(n) A1(s*) ¼ B2, and is labeled C
32
THIOPHOSGENE
Figure 2.3. The Walsh correlation diagram illustrating the changes in the p, n, and s* orbital energies as thiophosgene is distorted from a planar to a pyramidal conformation.
The change in molecular structure that comes about when an electron is lifted from the n orbital and placed into the p* orbital can be understood from the Walsh correlation diagram [7] (Fig. 2.3). The diagram shows the changes in orbital energy as the molecular structure deforms from the plane (C2v symmetry) to a 90 pyramid (Cs symmetry). When the molecule distorts, the B1(p) atomic orbital on the carbon center that forms the p* antibonding orbital mixes with the A1(sp2) s orbitals to create totally symmetric a0 orbitals of the Cs point group. This mixing of p and sp2 orbitals to form an sp3 hybrid reduces the energy of the p* antibonding orbital and destabilizes the planar structure of the ground state to a pyramidal conformation. Walsh’s rules [7] work on the basis that sp3 hybrid orbitals are more stable than the p–sp2 orbital combination. Thus it is the presence of the electron, which is promoted to the antibonding p* orbital, that is responsible for nonplanar structure of S1 thiophosgene. This diagram can also be ~ 1A1(p,p*) state. In this case, the structure is expected to applied to the S2 B be further deformed because the p bonding orbital is destabilized (upward sloping one electron energy curve) while the p* orbital is stabilized (downward ~ 1B2(n,s*) without an sloping curve) during the bending process. The S3 state, C occupation of the p* orbital would assume a planar conformation. The other major change is in the bonding between the sulfur and the carbon atoms. These changes can be neatly summarized by an inspection of the potential energy curves shown in Figure 2.4. This is a CASSCF ab initio study [6] of the first four electronic states, in which a slice of the potential surfaces is plotted against the CS bond length (all other coordinates are fixed). The plots for the first
ELECTRONIC STATES
33
~ 1A2(n,p*), B ~ 1A1(n2), A ~ 1A1(p,p*), and Figure 2.4. The potential energy of the X 1 ~ C B2(n,s*) electronic states of thiophosgene as a function of the CS bond distance. ~ state equiInset: The height of the barrier to molecular inversion along rCS from the B ~ intersection. (Reprinted with permission from ref. [6].) ~ C librium geometry to the B
~ 1A2(n,p*), show that upon excitation, the CS bond ~ 1A1(n2) and A two states, X ˚ . This increase can be understood in terms length increases from 1.64 to 1.79 A of the bond order concept. A s bond, created through the sharing of a pair of s electrons has a bond order of 1, whereas a double bond formed from a s and p combination has a bond order of 2. In the n to p* excitation process, the loss of the electron from the n orbital does not alter the bond order, whereas the place~ 1A2 (n,p*) ment of an electron into the p* orbital contributes 12. Thus, the A state has a CS bond order of 1.5. A lower order reduces the strength and results in a longer bond. A weaker bond also would be more elastic with a smaller force constant. As the curvature of the molecular potential is controlled by the force constant, the potential wells are broader and shallower. These differences in the two potential functions manifest themselves in different fundamentals for the CS stretching mode: n001 ¼ 1139:0 cm1 for the S0 ground electronic state and n01 ¼ 907:4 cm1 for the upper S1 state. The equilibrium position for the S2 third electronic state is further extended. The model applies here as well, because the loss and gain of electrons from and to the p and p* orbitals each contribute 12
34
THIOPHOSGENE
Figure 2.5. Energy level diagram for Cl2CS and its dissociation products. The state at about 30,000 cm1 is a dark, doubly excited state. (Reprinted with permission from ref. [8].)
to the bond order, leaving the S2 state with a nominal single CS bond of order 1. Thus it is not too surprising that the v01 frequency drops to 505.1 cm1 for this state. The final state, S3, derived from n to s* electron excitation does not have a calculated potential minimum and it appears that this state could be dissociative. The energy level diagram [8], which includes predissociation energies and dissociation limits, is shown in Figure 2.5.
B. S0, Ground Electronic State Early on, a molecular structure for the ground electronic state was derived from electron diffraction studies by Pauling and co-workers [9], who demonstrated that the molecule possessed a planar C2v equilibrium structure. Precise structural parameters (bond lengths and bond angles) were determined much later from the microwave spectra of four separate isotopomers of thiophosgene at their natural abundance [10]. The structure may be regarded as a set of three heavy atoms: S þ 2 Cl placed at the corners of an equilateral triangle with the lighter C atom at the center (Table 2.2). This conformation creates an oblate ellipsoid of revolution with the symmetric top c-axis projecting from the molecular plane in
35
ELECTRONIC STATES
TABLE 2.2 The Structural Parameters for Thiophosgene in the Lower S0, S1, T1, ˚ , degrees, and cm1) and S2 Electronic States (in A State
a(ClCCl) y(oop) Barrier
r(CS)
r(CCl)
Reference
1.601
1.729
111.19
0
0
rz microwave [10]
1.605
1.736
111.1
0
0
MP2/6-311G(d) [11]
1.73
1.745
112.3
27.2
—
1.704
1.751
119.2
32
1.729
1.723
112.3
32.2 640.6
UMP2/6-311G(d) [11]
—
—
—
32
726
fit to V(Q4) [14]
—
—
—
45
1650
S0 Band contour [12]
S1 622
Franck–Condon [13]
T1 S2
fit to V(Q4) for n1 ¼ 0 [15]
the B1 (x)-symmetry direction. Thus the moments of inertia are so close to a pure oblate limit that a substitution of the 35 for 37 isotopes of chlorine is sufficient to switch the a and b principal axes. For the planar ground state, the vibrational representation decompose as v ¼ 3A1 B1 2B2 , where the A1 modes transform as a translation along the z (C S) axis and the B1 mode as the single out-of-plane displacement along the x-direction. The last two modes lie in the molecular s (y,z) plane and are antisymmetric to the s (x,z) plane. Figure 2.6 gives a schematic view of the
Figure 2.6. A schematic representation of the six vibrational modes of planar thiophosgene.
36
THIOPHOSGENE
TABLE 2.3 Fundamental Vibrational Frequencies in the S0, S1, T1, and S2 Lower Electronic States of Thiophosgene (cm1) State S0 S1 T1 S2
T0
S) Q1(C a
— 1139.0 18,716.3a 907.4a 17,499e 923e g 34,277.3 505.1g
Q2(C Cl) Q3(ClCCl) b
497 480.0a 474f 495.0g
c
288.5 245.0a 247f 248g
Q4(oop) a
471.5 279.6a 298f 341.5g
Q5(C Cl) Q6(ClCS) 811d — — —
302d 189 193 212g
a
Visible absorption [18]. S2 fluorescence [19]. c S1 fluorescence [13]. d Raman [17]. e OODR [20]. MRS [25]. f T1 absorption [14]. g OODR [15]. b
vibrational modes along with an approximate description of the associated internal coordinates. The most noteworthy aspect of these vibrational modes is the absence of a mode of a2 symmetry. This representation transforms as a rotation about the z axis, Rz. The lack of a mode of a2 species creates a vibrational deficiency in thiophosgene, which has profound implications for the decay characteristics of the lower electronic states. The lower vibrational levels have been studied by infrared (IR) and Raman spectroscopies [16]. Normal coordinate analyses based on force constants transferred from other molecules (Urey-Bradley type) or from ab initio HF calculations have played a part in the construction of the vibrational assignments [17]. The observed fundamental frequencies are given in Table 2.3. Resolved S0 level structure at 15,000 cm1 of vibrational excitation has been observed from the band progressions contained in the fluorescence emission from single vibronic levels of the S1 and S2 electronic states [13, 21]. Figure 2.7 shows the resolved fluorescence along with selected regions recorded under much higher resolution with simulated emission pumping (SEP) [19]. Many of the eigenstates retain their identity at 10,000 cm1, which is somewhat surprising considering the onset of (intramolecular vibrational energy redistribution (IVR)) at this high level of vibrational excitation. These levels, along with the vibrational fundamentals, have been reduced to a set of second-order Dunham constants.
C. S1 (n,p*), First Excited Singlet State ~ 1A2(n,p*) or S1 state of thiophosgene comes about through the occuThe A pation of the p* orbital by an electron extracted from the nonbonding n
ELECTRONIC STATES
37
Figure 2.7. Resolved fluorescence spectra from selected vibronic levels of the 410 1 ~ 1A1(n2) vibrational structure. Insets: SEP spectra A1(p,p*) state, showing details of the X recorded under higher resolution. (Reprinted with permission from ref. [19].)
orbital. The direct product of these outermost electron orbitals transforms as ðnÞ ðp Þ ¼ B2 B1 ¼ A2 . For a purely allowed electric dipole transition, the transition moment MS01 ;S0 must be nonzero, cS1 jmjcS0 6¼ 0. This relationship requires that the product of the corresponding symmetry species transform as the totally symmetric representation, ðcS1 Þ ðmÞ ðcS0 Þ ¼ A1 . As the cS0 and cS1 electronic wavefunctions are of A1 and A2 species, it follows that (m) ¼ A2. This result creates a problem for thiophosgene since, for an allowed
38
THIOPHOSGENE
transition, the electric dipole moment operator must transform as a translation along one of the x, y, or z symmetry directions (B1, B2, or A1, respectively). The A2 representation transforms as a rotation about the z (C S) axis, and as a result the n ! p* electron promotion is forbidden as a purely electric dipole process. By this same reasoning, the magnetic dipole transition that transforms as rotation about the C S bond is fully allowed. A weak absorption system was observed in the visible region of the thiophosgene by Burnelle [18]. From its low oscillator strength in hexane, f ¼ 1.2 104, it was assigned to the n ! p* process. To account for this forbidden system, it is necessary to go beyond the symmetry properties of the electronic wavefunctions and consider higher-order effects brought about by distortions in the nuclear framework. When the molecular structure is displaced during the course of an antisymmetrical vibration, the symmetry of the C2v point group in Table 2.1 reduces to the Cs group with a0 and a00 representations. This relaxation in structure lowers the symmetry restrictions and allows for vibronic (electronic þ vibrational) interactions. In the Herzberg-Teller method [22] for accounting for induced vibronic intensities, the transition moment Me00 e00 between the ground e00 and excited e0 electronic states is expanded as a Taylor’s series in the normal coordinate Q for anitsymmetric mode k qMe0 e00 1 q2 Me0 e00 Me0 e00 ¼ Me00 e00 þ Qk þ Q2 þ ð1Þ 2 qQk 0 qQ2k 0 k For small-amplitude vibrations in which the transition moments are relatively smooth, the expansion can be terminated at the linear second term. A vibronic transition between a set of e0v0 e00v00 electronic/vibrational levels is defined by the transition moment qMe0 e00 0 Me0 v0 e00 v00 ¼ hcv0 jMe0 e00 jcv00 i ¼ Me0 e00 hcv0 jcv00 i þ hc 0 jQk jcv00 i ð2Þ qQk 0 v If the electronic transition is allowed, Me00 e00 is nonzero and the first term dominates the expression. This term can be viewed as a product of the electronic transition moment and the vibrational overlap integral, hcv0 jcv00 i, connecting the two vibrational wavefunctions, cv, in electronic states e0 and e00 . The Franck-Condon factors, which are the square of the vibrational overlap integral, determine the intensity distribution among the vibrational bands. The relative intensities of the band members within a vibrational progression is, therefore, given by the ratio of the Franck-Condon factors. If, through a symmetry restriction, the transition moment Me00 e00 vanishes, as in the present case, the band activity in the spectrum comes from the second term. When Qk is a nontotally symmetric
ELECTRONIC STATES
39
normal coordinate, the selection rules v ¼ 0, 2 govern the vibrational overlap integral, hcv0 jcv00 i, whereas the rules v ¼ 1, 3 are needed for a nonzero vibronic integral hcv0 jQk jcv00 i. Since the dipole moment operator, m, depends only on the electronic coordinates,
qMe0 e00 q hcv0 jQk jcv00 i ¼ hce0 jmjce00 i hcv0 jQk jcv00 i qQk qQk 0 qce00 qce0 ¼ c e0 m þ m c 00 hcv0 jQk jcv00 i qQk qQk e X qce00 qce0 ¼ c hci jmjce00 i þ hce0 jmjci i ci qQk qQk i i hcv0 jQk jcv00 i ð3Þ
To apply this result to thiophosgene, we consider the vibronic interaction induced by the activity of the antisymmetric out-of-plane vibrational mode Q4. The summation over states in Eq. (3) in the simplest case can be reduced to a single term, the state S2. q qMS1 ;S2 S2 hS2 jmjS0 ihcv0 jQ4 jcv00 i hc 0 jQk jcv00 i ¼ S1 qQ4 qQk 0 v
ð4Þ
This equation can be best understood by the three-state diagram in Figure 2.8, where S0 is the ground electronic state, S1 (n,p*) the first excited state, and S2 a state adjacent to S1 of appropriate symmetry for vibronic interaction. Before intensity can be induced into the forbidden electronic process, the symmetry requirements of the three factors of Eq. (4) need to be satisfied. Consider the first factor, hS1 j q=qQ4 j S2 i. This is a matrix element that describes the coupling between the optically forbidden S1 and the strongly allowed S2 excited states. For a nonzero coupling element, (S1) (q/qQ4) (S2) ¼ A1, and since (S1) ¼ A1 and (q/qQ4) ¼ B1, then (S2) ¼ B2. The second factor, hS2 j m j S0 i, represents the transition moment between the S0 and the S2 electronic states, with m the electric dipole operator. Again, the requirement is (S2) (m) (S0) ¼ A1, and since (S2) ¼ B2 and (S0) ¼ A1 then (m) ¼ B2. Thus, if the vibronic coupling is to a single electronic state, then S2 could be identified as the higher energy B2 (n,4s) Rydberg. The forbidden S1 S0 transition is said to borrow (or steal) oscillator strength from the highly allowed S2 S0 transition and hence is y (b2) polarized. Thus it is the proximity of the highly allowed S2 S0 transition that is responsible for inducing vibronic strength into the S1 S0 system.
40
THIOPHOSGENE
Figure 2.8. Energy level diagram illustrating the vibronic coupling between the 41 level of the S1(n,p*) state and the S2(n,4s) Rydberg state, which induces intensity into the S1 S0 transition.
The last factor in Eq. (4), cðQ04 Þj Q4 j cðQ004 Þ , represents the vibrational overlap between the cðQ04 Þ and the cðQ004 Þ wavefunctions of the S0 and S1 states. For a 0 nonzero integral, cðQ4 Þ ðQ4 Þ cðQ004 Þ ¼ A1 and for the transition from the vibrationally cold zero point level (v ¼ 0), cðQ004 Þ ¼ A1 . Since the distortion is in the out-of-plane direction, cðQ04 Þ ¼ B1 . The vibrational levels in the Qv manifold alternate between A1 and B1 species as v increases from v ¼ 0, 1, 2. . . . . Thus the vibronic transition that begins on the v ¼ 0 level of the S0 state terminates on the first quantum (v ¼ 1) of Q4 in the S1 excited state. This transition is given the notation, 410 , (Mab denotes a vibronic transition involving ‘‘a’’ vibrational quanta in the upper state and ‘‘b’’ quanta in the lower state, where M is the vibration mode number; 0ab with a ¼ 0 and b ¼ 0 would be the notation for the vibrationless 0–0 origin transition). To complete the analysis, it is necessary to consider distortions along the y symmetry direction. In this case, it would be the two modes Q5 and Q6 of B2 species that would mediate the vibronic coupling. By arguments similar to those given previously for x symmetry distortion, a Q5 symmetry distortion would lead to states of ðcðS1 ÞÞ ðcðQ05 ÞÞ ¼ A2 B2 ¼ B1 vibronic symmetry. The schematic arrangement is shown in Figure 2.9. Before entering into a discussion of the assignments and analysis of the observed band structure it is necessary to return to a consideration of the molecular geometry. Recall that Walsh’s rules predicted that the electron occupation of the p* orbital would render the S1 state nonplanar. Such a conformation would have two distinct equilibrium configurations that are related to each other
ELECTRONIC STATES
41
~ 1A2(n,p*) states ~ 1A1(n2) and A Figure 2.9. A schematic energy level diagram for the X of thiophosgene showing the vibronic transitions that give rise to the a, b, and c rotational band types.
by an inversion of the nuclei. The potential functions for an out-of-plane nuclear inversion would contain a double minimum with the height of the central barrier providing a measure of the stability brought about by the nonplanar distortion. Figure 2.10 shows the form of the potential function. This diagram
Figure 2.10. Potential energy diagrams showing the correlation between the vibrational energy levels as thiophosgene is bent from a rigid-planar to a rigid-pyramidal conformation.
42
THIOPHOSGENE
illustrates the changes in the level positions as the symmetry of the system changes from C2v for the rigid planar case (left side) to Cs for the pyramid case (right side). At the left of the diagram, the potential energy function is quadratic (harmonic), and the levels are equally spaced and are labeled by the quantum numbers 0, 1, 2, . . . . At the right side, the same quantum number description is applied; but in this case, the levels are degenerate. In the intermediate case, the levels split into doublets and are given the additional designation þ or , depending on whether the vibrational wavefunctions are even or odd. For a small doublet splitting, the even or odd levels of the zero point may be designated 0þ or 0 (high barrier notation), whereas the equally useful low barrier notation would be 0 and 1 for these same levels. Figure 2.11 combines the Herzberg-Teller coupling scheme of Figure 2.9 with the level patterns and symmetries expected for the double minimum potential of Figure 2.10 and presents an overall view of the inversion levels, their vibronic symmetries, and the rotational band types. For the lower S0 state, the equispaced v400 manifold of levels (00, 41, 42, . . .) bear the vibronic symmetries A1, B1, A1, . . . whereas the corresponding levels in the S1 state (00, 41, 42, . . .) are A2, B2, A2, . . . . The transitions between the ground state zero point level, 00,
Figure 2.11. An overall view of the vibrational level patterns, their vibronic symmetries, ~ 1A2(n,p*) state. ~ 1A1(n2) with the pyramidal A and the transitions connecting the planar X
ELECTRONIC STATES
43
and the 00, 41, 42, . . . levels of the S1 state result in a, b, a, . . . rotational band types. On other hand, transitions to the inversion levels in combination with quanta of v5 and v6 give rise to c-type and a-type bands. Thus it is possible that bands of all three polarizations are present in the spectrum. Transitions between the vibrational levels in the S0 and S1 combining states are governed by vibronic selection rules by which totally symmetric A1 levels of the S0 ground state (v ¼ 0, 2, 4,. . .) are forbidden to combine with the A2 (v ¼ 0, 2, 4) levels of the S1 state, whereas combinations are possible with the odd levels (v ¼ 1, 3, 5,. . .). These transitions require moments that are y-axis directed and are polarized along the b-principal axis. With this background, we now turn to the assignment and analyses of the visible spectrum of thiophosgene. Early on, the vibrational assignments were taken to a high level by Brand et al. [23], who photographically recorded the visible spectrum with a long (6-m) grating spectrograph. Under this dispersion, the individual 35Cl2CS and 35Cl37ClCS isotopomers of thiophosgene (abundance ratio of 9:6) were resolved as line-like doublets [23]. The starting point for the analysis came from the identification of ‘‘hot’’ bands (transitions from thermally excited vibrational levels in the S0 ground state). From the observed wavenumber intervals between the hot bands and associated higher energy cold bands, they were able to assign the hot structure to the activity of Q004 . These intervals were larger than the v004 ¼ 471.0 cm1 fundamental that had been established by IR measurements, and it was clear that the differences were related to the so-called inversion doubling splittings. The key to the vibrational analyses can be understood from the five critical bands illustrated as stick spectra in Figure 2.12. These stick spectra portray the band structure that would be anticipated for a vibronically allowed, but electronically forbidden, transition, where the planar ground electronic state is
Figure 2.12. A stick representation of the six bands in the S1 key to the vibrational assignments.
S0 spectrum that are the
44
THIOPHOSGENE
combined with a pyramidal excited state. The obvious feature of this diagram is the absence of the 000 band origin as would be expected for an allowed S1 (v ¼ 0) S0 (v ¼ 0) transition. The attachment of an odd quantum of the antisymmetric Q4 mode to the S1 state, S1(v04 ), would provide the vibronic symmetry for the Herzberg-Teller coupling, Ae2 Bv1 ¼ Bev 2 . The resulting vibronic e transition Bev A originating from the vibrationless S0 (v ¼ 0) state would 2 1 create a B2 (y directed) polarized band structure. It would bear the label 410 . The corresponding hot band transition that comes from the thermally populated S0 (v ¼ 1) and terminates on the S1 (v ¼ 0) level, 401 , would have a similar transition moment, although the strength would be reduced by the Boltzman factor for v004. These hot and cold bands allow the inversion doubling splittings to be evaluated by the method of combination differences. When the first cold band, 410 , is combined with the companion hot band, 401 , along with the v004 vibrational fundamental, the inversion splittings becomes 0 ¼ 0 0þ ¼ 41 40 ¼ 410 401 þ v004 ¼ 0:42 cm1 . The next doublet by this method, is 1 ¼ 1 1þ ¼ 43 42 ¼ 430 421 þ v004 ¼ 12:9 cm1 . This order of increase in the inversion doubling splitting with vibrational energy is the result of the low central barrier in the potential governing the Q4 normal mode. The shape of the potential for the out-of-plane motion can be extracted from the inversion splittings and the manifold of energy levels. A useful model potential for the double minimum potential function consists of a combination of quadratic and Gaussian terms: V ðQ4 Þ ¼ A Q24 þ B exp ðC Q24 Þ, where A, B, and C are shaping parameters. The quadratic first term creates the outer walls of the function, while the Gaussian describes the central barrier separating the double minima. Energy levels for the model potential are then calculated by a variational method through a diagonalization of the corresponding Hamiltonian matrix. The final stage of this process is a refinement of the parameters in the model function through a fitting of the observed and calculated levels. In the present case, the fitting process yielded a barrier height of 622 cm1 and an out-of-plane angle of 32.0 for the S1 state of thiophosgene. The adjustments in molecular structure that occur on S1 S0 excitation can be inferred from the band intensity relationships. The vibrational bands form patterns that can be grouped into progressions for each of the totally symmetric normal modes according to their intensity distribution. The lengths and strengths of these progressions relate to the differences in molecular structure in the combining electronic state defined by the multidimensional Franck-Condon principle. Very loosely, this principle states that the length (number of active members) of a progression is controlled by the changes in the location and the directions of the normal coordinates in the two electronic states. Thus, for example, the pyramidalization of the S1 state relative to the planar S0 state occurs along the Q4 normal coordinate (to a first approximation). As expected, the bands in the Q4 progression can be followed for several members, 410 , 430 , 450 , 401 , 421 , etc. consistent with the nonplanar structural displacement. These bands
45
ELECTRONIC STATES
that mark the transitions to the levels in Q4 act as a set of pseudo-origins for progressions in the remaining totally symmetric Q1, Q2, and Q3 modes. As every level serves as a suborigin for every other level, the level structure quickly becomes complex. It is this rapid buildup in the density of vibrational states that often is the limiting factor for establishing the band assignments at higher vibrational energies. The introduction of antibonding electron density that reduces the carbon sulfur bond order from 2 to 1.5 in the n ! p* process, results in an increased CS bond length and a decreased stretching force constant. Thus the quanta of 907 cm1 observed throughout the band spectrum are assigned to the activity of Q01 , the CS stretching mode in keeping with the corresponding ground state frequency v001 ¼ 1139 cm1. The totally symmetric modes Q02 and Q03 are also active in the spectrum and create lengthy progressions in 489 and 245 cm1, respectively. Structural differences between the S0 and the S1 states of ˚ rðCClÞ ¼ þ0:02 A ˚ and yðClCClÞ ¼ þ1:1 have been rðCSÞ ¼ þ0:13 A, obtained from a rotational band contour analysis [12]. A more accurate set of S1 structural parameters can be obtained from a fit of the rotationally resolved S1 S0 absorption. Recently, Fujiwara et al. [51] recorded high resolution S1 ð1 A2 Þ S0 ð1 A1 Þ fluorescence excitation spectrum of thiophosgene in supersonic free jet with a pulse-amplified ring laser system. A line-to-line analysis of rotational fine structures of a selected group of bands yields a refined structure of the molecule in the 1 A2 ðn; p Þ state [51]. The change ˚ for CS bond and – 0.007 A ˚ in the bond length upon S0 to S1 excitation is 0.094 A
for CCl bond. The out-of-plane ClCCl angle is about 24 , which is significantly smaller than the value of 32 derived from inversion splittings. Table 2.4 compares the structural parameters obtained from rotational analyses with those from Franck-Condon analyses and inversion splittings.
TABLE 2.4 A Comparison of the Structural Changes that Occur on Excitation S1 S0 , from Rotational Analyses, Inversion Splittings, and Franck-Condon Analyses
r CS r CCL yClCCl yoop a
S0a
S1b
c
Id
IId
1.600 1.727 111.2 0
1.694 1.720 117.6 23.9
0.094 0.007 6.4 23.9
0.103 0.022 8.0 32e
0.057 0.09 10.8 32e
From microwave spectrum [10]. Fujiwara et al. [51]. c rðS1 Þ rðS0 Þ. d From Franck-Condon analyses [23]. e From inversion splittings. b
46
THIOPHOSGENE
~ 1A2(n,p*) X ~ 1A1(n2) spectrum obtained as (a) the Figure 2.13. A comparison of the A one-photon S1(v0 ) S0(00) LIF excitation spectrum with (b) the two-photon S2(00) S1(v0 ) S0(00) OODR spectrum. (Reprinted with permission from Ref. [24].)
A different perspective of the vibrational structure of the S1 electronic state is illustrated in Figure 2.13b. This is an OODR that was obtained by sequentially exciting Cl2CS with two photons of different colors. In this experiment, a photon from the first laser (the pump photon) induces a S1 S0 vibronic transition that is followed after a short time delay by a second S2 S1, probe photon that carries the excitation to the S2 state. The pump laser is advanced to the blue and interrogates the bands of the S1 S0 system while the probe laser is scanned at the same rate to the red such that the total energy matches a selected vibrational level of the S2 state. In this way, an excitation spectrum of the vibrational band structure of the S1 state is constructed by monitoring the fluorescence that originates from the S2 state. What is not too surprising is that the one-photon LIF spectrum (Fig. 2.13a) and two-photon OODR spectra (Fig. 2.13b) are similar, since these spectra sample the same S1 level structure. The major differences between these panels lies in the intensity relationships of the bands within the progressions. These differences can be understood by recognizing that the OODR is a sequential process where a substantial time delay is introduced between the pump and the probe photons. Thus the Franck-Condon factors for the S2 S1 S0 process is a
47
ELECTRONIC STATES
product of the factors of the individual S1 S0 and S2 S1 transitions. The transition probabilities for the S1 S0 first stage can be inferred from the band intensities of the lower trace while the probabilities for the second S2 S1 stage must be estimated from a comparison of the upper and lower traces. The first photon pumps the system from a planar S0 to a nonplanar S1 state and is followed by the second photon, which lifts the nonplanar S1 to a nonplanar S2 state. Because the first stage is Franck-Condon forbidden (a nonplanar–planar transition) and the second stage is Franck-Condon-allowed (nonplanar–nonplanar) the ODDR spectrum has more of the characteristics of a Franck-Condon-allowed transition than does the one-photon LIF spectrum. The much stronger 410 pseudo-origin band and the shorter band progressions in the OODR spectrum relative to the corresponding bands in the one-photon LIF spectrum are a direct consequence of the Franck-Condon factors of the one- and two-stage OODR processes. New features do appear in the OODR spectra, but they are submerged into the background noise. Here the magnetic dipole band 420 can be identified at 1 1þ ¼ 43 42 ¼ 12:9 cm1 to red of the 430 band. Likewise, in this same region the 610 appears weakly. The position of this band can be fixed from the 611 sequence transition that is prevalent in the hot-jet spectrum leading to v06 ¼ 189 cm1.
D.
T1, First Triplet Electronic State
Singlet-triplet transitions are forbidden by the selection rule S ¼ 0, which states that the spin of the electron cannot change direction (spin flip) during an electronic transition. Intensity, however, can be introduced into the spin-forbidden transition by allowing the three levels of the T1 triplet state to mix with adjacent singlet states, S1, and thereby acquire the singlet character that is needed for an electric dipole transition. A mixing of the triplet and singlet ^ SO j Si , wavefunctions is accomplished by matrix elements of the form T1 j H ^ SO is the spin-orbit operator that couples the electron spin, S; with the where H ^ SO / L S. The spinorbital L (or spatial) part of the electronic wavefunction, H forbidden T1 S0 transition has a transition moment MT1 ;S0 that is given by perturbation theory as MT1 ;S0 ¼
X Si
X 3 1 ^ E1 E1 T1 ;Si cT1 j HSO j cSi mSi ;S0 þ T1 ;S0
1
^ SO j 3 cT mTi ;T1 cS0 j H i
Ti
ð5Þ
The first term in this expression represents the coupling between the T1 state in question and the higher Si singlet excited states. The second term is a mixing of
48
THIOPHOSGENE
~ 1A1(n2) Figure 2.14. The coupling scheme by which the spin-forbidden a˜ 3A2(n,p*) X 1 2 ~ ~ transition borrows oscillator strength from the B A1(p,p*) X 1A1(n ) electric dipole allowed transition.
the ground singlet S0 state with the higher triplet levels Ti. As the ground electronic state is energetically removed from the higher triplet states, the energy difference ET1 ;S0 ¼ ET1 ES0 (perturbation gap) is large and the second term ^ SO operator couples is usually disregarded. For the special case in which the H to a specific singlet excited state, S2, the summation can be reduced to the single term ^ SO j 1 cS mS2 ;S0 MT1 ;S0 ¼ ET11 ;S2 3 cT1 j H 2
ð6Þ
This expression can be understood from the coupling scheme of Figure 2.14 the three elements that control the transition strength are depicted: Here, 3 ^ SO j 1 cS , the coupling matrix element; ET1 ;S2 the perturbation cT1 j H 2 energy gap; and mS2 ;S0 , the transition moment of the singlet-singlet transition that supplies the induced intensity. Symmetry dictates that the representations of the direct product of the factors ^ SO j 1 cS transform under the group operations accordin the integral 3 cT1 j H 2 ^ SO spining to the totally symmetric representation, A1. The spin part of the H orbit operator converts triplet spin to singlet spin wavefunctions and singlet functions to triplet wavefunctions. As such, the spin function does not have a ^ SO . Rather, the control is embedded bearing on the symmetry properties of H in the orbital part. The components of the orbital angular momentum, (Lx, Ly , ^ SO have symmetry properties of rotations about the x, y, and z and Lz) of H symmetry axes, Rx, Ry , and Rz. Thus, from Table 2.1, the possible symmetry
ELECTRONIC STATES
49
^ SO are (Lx) ¼ B2, (Ly) ¼ B1 and (Rz) ¼ A2. For a sigrepresentations for H nificant coupling, the matrix elements must have electronic wavefunctions that rotate into each other. Rz transforms as a rotation about the C S bond (z-axis) and creates a coupling element of the type hnj Rz j pi. This operator is said to rotate the n orbital that y-projects from the side of the CS bond to the p (px) ^ SO, (H ^ SO ) ¼ A2, and for hS2 j out-of-plane orbital. With this choice for H ^ SO j S1 i 6¼ 0, then (S2) (H ^ SO ) (S1) ¼ A1 and (S2) ¼ A1, providing H the symmetry identity of the coupled singlet state. The allowed transition moment, mS2 ;S0 , which donates oscillator strength to the forbidden transition, would connect states of A1 species. The unique candidate for this donor S2 state would have the p,p* electron configuration and combines with the ground elec~ 1A1(p,p*) X ~ 1A1(n2) system not tronic state with high dipole strength. The B 3 1 2 ~ only donates strength to the ~a A2(n,p*) X A1(n ) transition, but it also provides the z-polarization (transition moment direction). The selection rules that govern the band patterns are those of an electronically allowed system. Transitions from the vibrationless level of the lower S0 (v ¼ 0) state terminate on the (þ) lower member of the inversion doublet rather than on the upper () level as in the case of the S1 S0 transition. The vibrational analysis of the T1 S0 system developed slowly from a series of independent experiments: the direct absorption at long path lengths [14], magnetic rotation spectra (MRS) [25], and cavity ring-down (CRD) [11]. OODR studies have provided the clearest view of the band structure. A roomtemperature, one-color, two-photon study by Clouthier et al. [26] showed that the T1 state could be mapped by the OODR process with T1 as the intermediate state, S2 T1 S0. A clearer view of the triplet vibrational band structure was obtained under jet-cooled conditions in a two-color, two-photon OODR study by Steer and co-workers [20]. This same spectra has been replicated by Fujiwara et al. [24] under improved conditions. In this experiment, the total energy of the two lasers (pump þ probe) was set at the vibrationless, v ¼ 0, level of the S2 state and monitored by fluorescence to the S0 state. The pump laser was scanned upward through the levels of the T1 state, while the probe laser was tuned in the opposite direction. This S2 (00) T1 (x) S0 (00) scan-up, scan-down spectrum is shown in Figure 2.15 and is compared to the analogous singlet–singlet S2 (00) S1 (x) S0 (00) spectrum. ~ The ~a 3A2(n; p ) electronic state may be regarded as a companion to the A 1 A2(n; p ) state since they are derived from the same electron configurations. Thus the triplet state would adapt somewhat the same pyramidal conformation and have an elongated carbon sulfur bond. The forgoing symmetry analysis of the spin-orbit coupling predicted that the vibronic selection rules would be those of a fully allowed electronic transition, with the 000 transition forming the origin band. The 410 transition with quantum addition of the antisymmetric Q4 mode would be forbidden by spin-orbit selection rules though allowed by the
50
THIOPHOSGENE
~ 1A2(n,p*) Figure 2.15. A comparison of the vibrational structure of the a˜ 3A2(n,p*) and A 0 0 0 0 states through (a) the S2(0 ) S1(v ) S0(00) and (b) S2(0 ) T1(v ) S0(00) OODR processes. (Reprinted with permission from Ref. [24].)
vibronic-spin-orbit process. The inversion doubling splittings, , can be derived from the ground state combination differences, viz., 1 ¼ 1 1þ ¼ 43 42 ¼ 431 420 þ v004 . Thus the v004 hot band intervals in the triplet state are smaller than v004 by 1 (in the S1 state they are larger by the corresponding value). This reversal in the direction of the splittings is often useful in establishing the assignment of band multiplicity. The assignments of the vibrational band structure can be quickly established by comparing the OODR (T1) and OODR (S1) spectra of Figure 2.15. The frequency and T0 values are collected in Table 2.3. The v1 C S stretching frequency at 923 cm1 is found to be slightly higher than the 907 cm1 value recorded for the S1 state. This frequency difference is the result of an avoidance by the two electrons of parallel spins (Fermi correlation) that reduces the p* antibonding repulsions (T1 lies below the S1 state by 1217 cm1). This reduction in antibonding character is reflected in a slightly stronger C S bond and higher force constants. The differences in v4 in the two states is also instructive because these intervals, along with the inversion splittings, define the shape of the double minimum potential functions. The higher vibrational frequencies and the smaller
ELECTRONIC STATES
51
inversion doubling splittings must be associated with steeper outer walls and a higher central barrier of 726 cm1 for the T1 state (Table 2.2). The photophysical properties of T1 thiophosgene are somewhat unexpected. As the molecular prototypes thioacetone, thioacetaldehdye, and thioformaldehyde all show strong phosphorescence emission from their lowest triplet electronic states [4], it should be reasonable to expect that thiophosgene should also be emissive. A number of experiments have been specifically designed to directly detect T1 phosphorescence. Clouthier and Moule [25] recorded an excitation spectrum over the requisite spectral region and compared the observed band positions to those of the MRS. From the lack of coincidences between the band patterns in the two spectra, they concluded that the 3A2(n,p*) state was nonemissive. Likewise, Bernath et al. [27] were unable to excite phosphorescence with a tunable dye laser or with 528.7-nm line of a CW argon ion laser. In an extension to this work, Kawasaki et al. [28] pumped the 420 and 310 420 transitions. After integrating more than 30,000 laser shots, they were unable to detect a useful signal. They also tested the possibility of intersystem crossing by pumping into levels of the S1 state without success. In the most recent of these experiments, Moule et al. [11] compared the excitation spectrum, under jet-cooled conditions, with the absorption spectrum recorded as a CRD spectrum, as shown in Figure 2.16. None of the T1 S0 bands in the CRD spectrum appeared in the excitation spectrum of total emission. The conclusions from all of these studies is that T1 thiophosgene decays almost exclusively by T1 ! S0 intersystem crossing (ISC).
Figure 2.16. Part of the CRD absorption spectrum and the excitation spectrum LIF/LIP in the T1 S0 and S1 S0 regions of jet-cooled thiophosgene. (Reprinted with permission from Ref. [11].)
52
THIOPHOSGENE
Figure 2.17. The V(Q4) potential energy functions for the S0 and T1 electronic states of thiophosgene along with the v ¼ (þ), even, inversion-wagging energy levels. (Reprinted with permission from Ref. [11].)
The T1 nonradiative lifetime (i.e., the inverse of the T1 ! S0 ISC rate) was estimated by using the T1 S0 spin-orbit coupling and the Franck-Condon factors for the T1 ! S0 ISC based on the ab initio equilibrium structures, as shown in Figure 2.17, and vibrational frequencies for the T1 and S0 states, computed at the MP2/6-31G(d,p) level of theory [11]. The nonradiative lifetime, calculated as the 1/e of the survival probability, is 20 ps for barrier heights of 770–845 cm1 and out-of-plane angles of 32.69 . (The thiophosgene adopts a pyramidal conformation with the C S bond bent from the ClCCl plane by about 32 .) The computed lifetime is comparable to the lower-limit lifetime of 50 ps obtained from the quantum yields P 103 F with F 1.0 and the measured S1 fluorescence lifetime of 4 ms [11]. The short T1 nonradiative lifetime of thiophosgene can be attributed to the large matrix elements of the T1 S0 spin-orbit coupling (V ¼ 150 cm1) and the strong out-of-plane deformation of the T1 state relative to the planar S0 state, that provides the large Franck-Condon factors for the T1 S0 ISC [11]. An estimate of the T1 lifetime can be made from the measured line width of the T1 S0 absorption. Figure 2.18 presents the S2(00) T1(00) S0(00) OODR spectrum measured under medium-frequency resolution ( 0.05 cm1) [29]. The rotational structure, depicted in Figure 2.18 consists of a prominent band with two satellites (50 times weaker) at 6 cm1 to lower energies. From
ELECTRONIC STATES
Figure 2.18. The 000 origin band of the T1 (Reprinted with permission from Ref. [29].)
53
S0 transition under etalon resolution.
a consideration of the spin-orbit couplings that induce strength into the singlettriplet transition, the strong band can be assigned to the C S bond polarized Tz spin component. A preliminary band contour analysis reveals that the two lower energy components are the parallel and perpendicularly polarized Tx and Ty spin components [29]. From the point of view of the spectroscopy of the T1 state, the spin and rotational constants are found to lie within their expected ranges. On closer inspection, the rotational structure of the Tz component is observed to possess a greater line width ( 0.1 cm1 under etalon resolution) than that of the Tx and Ty components ( 0.06 cm1). This line broadening must be associated with a reduced lifetime for the Tz component of 150 ps. These initial observations on the Tx, Ty , and Tz rotational structure go some distance toward understanding the unusual photophysics of the T1 state. The lack of a one-photon LIP signal, even under enhanced signal-to-noise conditions, now can be attributed to the picosecond radiationless deactivation of the Tz level through the ISC process. Transitions to the longer-lived Tx and Ty spin levels would not play a significant role in the direct phosphorescence emission of the LIP method because of their reduced oscillator strength. The only concrete information about the decay characteristics of T1 comes from time delay measurements in the two-stage OODR process, S2 T1 S0.
54
THIOPHOSGENE
Figure 2.19. Temporal profile of fluorescence trains from the S2(00) level via the S2(00) T1(31) S0(00) OODR probe as functions of time delay and spatial distance between the pump–probe lasers, showing the long trail contour of 4 ms indicates a longlived T1 state due to coupling to higher energy levels in the S0 state. Inset: Pump–probe laser configuration including a molecular jet. (Reprinted with permission from Ref. [30].)
Figure 2.19 shows the intensity of the fluorescence emitted from the S2 monitor state as a function of the pump–probe delay time in which the pump and probe beams have been spatially displaced from each other [30]. Two observations demonstrate that the probe S2(00) T1 transitions emanate from the rotational levels of the T1(00) electronic state rather than from the isoenergetic density of S0 vibrational levels, S2 S0 (high v). The first factor is the up-down wavelength tracking of pump and probe laser beams that are needed for OODR method. These two tuned laser beams create conditions that are too stringent for probe transitions that use high-energy vibrational S0 levels as initial states. Second, the vibrational band spectra do not undergo significant changes when the pump–probe time delay is increased to several microseconds. The results of these OODR measurements, therefore, indicate that the T1 lifetime is several microseconds [30]. The lower limit of the quantum yield can be established by combining the observed and radiative lifetimes. In absorption, the T1 S0
ELECTRONIC STATES
55
transition has about one-sixth the strength [14] of the higher energy S1 S0 companion transition that has a measured [18] oscillator strength of f ¼ 1.2 104. From this ratio, the oscillator strength of the triplet-singlet transition can be estimated at 2.0 105 for a radiative lifetime of 231 ms. The loss in phosphorescence signal is then expressed as the quantum yield for phosphorescence, P 0.01. To understand the conundrum raised by the separate observations of two lifetimes for the Tz spin state that differ by five orders of magnitude (150 ps from the line widths and several microseconds from the OODR measurements with the pump–probe time delay), we turn to the high-energy vibrational structure of the S0 ground state observed by Strickler and Gruebele [31]. From the resolved S2 ! S0 dispersed fluorescence spectrum, these workers were able to show that half of the six-dimensional vibrational quantum space was highly structured at energies beyond the S0 dissociation limit of 20,000 cm1. Moreover, they observed that quanta of the Q1 (C S stretch) and Q4 (out-of-plane wag) were conserved as good quantum numbers throughout the spectrum. On the other hand, the levels derived from the remaining modes were found to be highly fragmented and susceptible to IVR. On Franck-Condon grounds, the T1 S0 structural changes in the C S and the out-of-plane coordinates lead to dominant progressions in Q1 and Q4 in the corresponding spectrum. If the Franck-Condon factors that control the spin-orbit coupling between the T1 and the S0 states can be approximated by the band patterns in the S2 ! S0 fluorescence spectrum, then the molecular eigenstate spectrum representing the coupling of T1(00) with the S0 (high v) levels could be grouped into two parts. The first part would be defined by the highly active Franck-Condon coupling of T1(00) to the levels in Q1 and Q4 and their combinations. The second part would consist of the coupling to the much weaker and denser fragmented background levels. The Fourier transform of this molecular eigenstate spectrum would result in a decay curve that would display nonexponential behavior [30]. The strong spin-orbit coupled lines derived from the good quantum numbers in Q1 and Q4 would Fourier transform to form the initial picosecond part of the decay curve, while the weaker background levels would transform to create longer microsecond tail [30]. In summary, the source of the anomalous photophysical behavior of the Tz spin component of the T1 electronic state can be found in the observation of structured vibrational states (Q1 and Q4) embedded in a dense set of fragmented background levels in S0 (high v) at the T1 S0 point of crossing, 17,499 cm1. The lack of phosphorescence from the T1 state, among other factors, is the result of the favorable Franck-Condon factors brought about by the planar– nonplanar nature of the ISC process. This behavior is to be contrasted to the related thiocarbonyl species, CHSCH3 and (CH3)2CS, which are emissive with measured lifetimes of 2 ms [29]. The pyramidal distortions that occur on
56
THIOPHOSGENE
excitation for these thiocarbonyl prototypes are less severe than for thiophosgene, and the coupling elements for the ISC process are substantially smaller due to the lack of heavy atom.
E. S2, Second Singlet Excited State ~ 1A1(p,p*) X ~ 1 A1(n2) or S2 S0 room-temperature Early studies of the B absorption spectrum were carried out by Farnworth and King [32], and then later in emission by Steer and co-workers [21]. Detailed analyses of the hot band structure were made by Judge and Moule [33], who located the origin for the system and identified several band progressions. In the course of recording the S1 S0, LIF excitation spectrum, Clouthier et al. [26] observed a UV emission that could be traced to the S2 state. This was attributed to a two-photon one-color OODR transition between the S2 and the S0 states, where the S1 and T1 levels played the roles of intermediates: S2 S1 S0 and S2 T1 S0. These experiments were followed by a two-color pump–probe study by Dixon and Western [34], who located a group of vibrational bands to the red of the origin that suggested the system origin lay to lower wavenumbers. This controversy was settled by a one-photon S2 S0, jet-cooled, LIF experiment by Steer and co-workers [35], who were able to assign a Q4 (out-of-plane wagging) progression that converged on the origin established earlier. The height of the barrier in v(Q4) extracted from these Q4 data was much lower than that suggested by the observed hot band activity in Q4, indicating that there were unresolved problems with the assignments. Fujiwara et al. [15] recorded one-photon and two-photon spectra under jet-cooled conditions and have reopened the question of the barrier height to molecular inversion. The electron configuration of the S2 state is created through a p to a p* electron excitation and with the direct product of these outermost orbitals of B1 species transforming as the A1 representation. The second singlet state can ~ 1A1(p,p*). The transition, B ~ 1A1(p,p*) X ~ 1A1(n2) or then be written as B S2 S0, is allowed by optical selection rules and is polarized in the z (C S bond) direction. Thus the vibronic transitions that form strong progressions in the excitation spectra will terminate on the (þ) lower member of the inversion doublets. From the Walsh correlation diagram (Fig. 2.3), this state should be nonplanar since the p* orbital energy decreases (stabilizes) with the pyramidal deformation, while the p orbital energy simultaneously increases (destabilizes). Both these changes favor a pyramidal structure. On this basis, the barrier should be higher in the S2(p,p*) state than in the S1(n,p*) excited state. Figure 2.20 shows a representation of the out-of-plane potential for the S0, S1, and S2 states, the barrier heights, and their effects on the inversion splittings. The other anticipated structural change occurs in the CS bond. Removal of an electron from the
ELECTRONIC STATES
57
Figure 2.20. Potential energy functions and vibrational levels for the out-of-plane displacements for the first three singlet states of thiophosgene. (Reprinted with permission from Ref. [15].)
p and its placement in an antibonding p* orbital has the effect of reducing the C S bond. This change in bond order S double bond order to that of a single C induces a large increase in the CS bond, reduces the stretching frequency, and results in the formation of a dominant progression in Q1 (CS stretching mode). These structural and dynamical changes are clearly illustrated in a recent ab initio treatment by Strickler and Gruebele [6], who developed a complete molecular potential for the S2 state from a series of CASSCF ab initio calculations. A segment cut from their sixfold potential is illustrated in Figure 2.21 as a plot of energy against increments in the CS bond and the out-of-plane angle. This three˚ and an outdimensional plot demonstrates that increases of r(CS) ¼ 0.39 A
of-plane displacement of 45 are needed to achieve the equilibrium position (bottom of the well). But what was not anticipated was that at extended CS bond lengths, the S2 electronic system encounters a new excited electronic state. This S3 state is attributed to s* n excitation, and as (s*) (n) ¼ B2 ~ 1B2(n,s*). The plot shows that with increasing A1 ¼ B2, this state is labeled C
58
THIOPHOSGENE
Figure 2.21. The potential energy calculated at the ab initio CASSCF level illustrating the intersection of the pyramidal and planar surfaces. (Reprinted with permission from Ref. [6].)
CS distance, the potential energy of the system increases from its S2 pyramidal ˚ , whereupon the strucequilibrium position to the point of S2–S3 crossing, 0.80 A ture converts to a planar conformation. The large distortions in the r(CS) and y (out-of-plane) directions that are needed to reach the equilibrium position of the S2 state result in long progressions in Q1 and Q4 modes that weaken the 000 band by about two orders of magnitude from the prominent bands at higher energies. Thus, in the room temperature absorption spectrum, the 000 origin band is not directly observed and its position must be established from the attached hot bands, 411 and 402 . This difficulty can be overcome in the one-photon LIF jet-cooled spectrum because (1) the quantum yield for fluorescence at the lowest vibrational energies, Ev ¼ 0, is very high, F 1; (2) the oscillator strength is that of a fully allowed electric dipole transition; and (3) under jet conditions the hot bands that strongly interfere with the clarity of the band patterns in the origin region are suppressed. The vibrational assignments are also greatly aided by the presence of the 35 Cl2CS and 35Cl37ClCS isotopomers that form doublets in the spectrum. Combination differences, 0 ¼ 0 0þ ¼ 41 40 ¼ 411 000 þ v004 and 1 ¼ 1 1þ ¼ 43 42 ¼ 431 420 þ v004 , extracted from hot band intervals are also invaluable in this regard. The vibrational assignments given in Figure 2.22 can be summarized as follows. The progression responsible for the bulk of the intensity comes from the activity of Q1. This is not unexpected and is the direct consequence of the changes in bond order within the CS bond. This progression is observed to
ELECTRONIC STATES
59
Figure 2.22. The one-photon LIF excitation spectra of Cl2CS recorded under (a) cooled (P ¼ 4 atm) and (b) warm (P ¼ 400 Torr) jet conditions. Leaders, denote the progression in quanta of the Q4 out-of-plane wagging mode; 0, 2, and 4, refer to the 000 , 420 , and 440 transitions attached to quanta n of the Q1 mode, 110 ; 1 and 2, designate the first and second hot band transitions 411 and 402 . (Reprinted with permission from Ref. [15].)
take the form of band clusters involving hot and cold transitions in Q004 and Q02 . The reduction in frequency from v002 ¼ 1139 to v02 ¼ 505 cm1 is consistent with the adjustment in C S bonding. The small differences in the C Cl stretching frequency, v002 ¼ 497 and v02 ¼ 495 cm1 would suggest that the activity in Q2 results from a mixing of the internal coordinates, rather than from displacements in the CCl bond. For the 00 (0þ zero point level) the observed hot band intervals in Ev ¼ 41 and 42 give a inversion splitting that is smaller than the measuring error allowing the inversion splitting 0 ¼ 0 0þ to be set to 0.00 cm1. The next two quanta of the Q4 mode, 42 and 44 at 341.4 and 682.4 cm1, display very small splittings, 1 ¼ 0.03 and 2 ¼ 0.16 cm1, respectively. Thus within the manifold of Q4 levels that attach to the vibrational zero point, the level splittings are very small, and it is clear that the barrier to inversion must be very high. Bands involving combinations of Q4 with Q1, however, do show appreciable splittings.
60
THIOPHOSGENE
The 110 transition forms a strong suborigin band along with an attached cold band progression in Q4, 110 , 110 420 , and 110 440 . While 110 by itself has a very small inversion splitting, 0 ¼ 0.07 cm1, a clear splitting of 2 ¼ 6.53 cm1 can be derived from the cold 110 440 band and its hot 110 451 partner band. When this same process is repeated for v4 built on the second quanta of n1, 120 , a 0 of 9.85 cm1 is observed for 110 420. This behavior suggests that while both Q1 and Q4 are involved in the inversion process, neither is truly an inversion mode. The correct picture should use, as a starting point, the potential energy surface shown in Figure 2.21. The high fluorescence yield from the S2 (v ¼ 0) level creates an opportunity to observe three unique excitation spectra: the one-photon S2 S0 and the twophoton processes S2 S1 S0 and S2 T1 S0. The selection rules for these transitions are different and the three spectra reveal different aspects of the structure and dynamics. In the case of the two OODR spectra (Fig. 2.23), it should be appreciated that the pump–probe time delay of 150 ns reduces the two sequential transitions in the OODR process to a single step. Although it is the function of the pump photon to initially populate the intermediate S1 or T1 states, the properties of the OODR spectra are defined by the second step, S2 S1, or S2 T1. Thus we label the two photon spectra OODR(S1) or OODR(T1), depending on whether the intermediate step is the singlet or the triplet intermediate. The OODR(S1) spectrum may be regarded as a stepwise singlet–singlet transition, S2 S1, between the 1A1 and the 1A2 electronic states, which is followed, after a fixed time delay, by the pump transition S1 S0 connecting the 1A2 and 1A1 states. The first transition excited by the probe photon in the OODR(S1) process is electric dipole forbidden, which gains its strength through vibronic coupling to the B2(n,4s) Rydberg state. The pump photon uses this same B2(n,4s) coupling mechanism for its strength, and it might be expected that the transition probabilities of the pump and probe processes should be about the same. The selection rules for the OODR(S1) pump, S1(41()) S0(00(þ)), and probe, S2(00(þ)) S1(41()), yield an overall transition S2(00(þ)) S0(00(þ)), with the result that only the S2(þ) manifold of levels are interrogated. If, on the other hand, the hot band transition is pumped, S1(00(þ)) S0(41()), then the probe transition will terminate on a manifold of S2() symmetry, S2(41()) S1(00(þ)). In this way, it is possible to build up an excitation spectrum for the S2 state in which the either the (þ) or () manifold of states is selected. When the two spectra are scaled to the same electronic origin, the two manifolds may be directly compared as illustrated in Figure 2.24. Here, the two sets of inversion spectra have similar appearances; and as the inversion doubling splittings come from the displacements of one set relative to the other, it is clear that the inversion splittings within the S2 vibrational manifolds are very small indeed.
ELECTRONIC STATES
61
Figure 2.23. A comparison of the vibrational structure of the S2 state from OODR spectra recorded with the S1(2141) and T1(21) states as intermediates. (Upper panel) S2(v0 ) S1(2141) S0(00). (Lower panel) S2(v0 ) T1(21) S0(00). (Reprinted with permission from Ref. [15].)
The OODR(T1) transition may be viewed in somewhat the same way as the OODR(S1) process in that the vibronic operator is replaced by a spin-orbit operator connecting T1 triplet levels with adjacent singlet states of an appropriate symmetry. Thus the pump transition T1 S0 is forbidden by the S ¼ 0 rule, and gains its intensity by borrowing from the adjacent S2 S0 transition through a T1 $ S2 coupling. This one-photon process has the vibrational symmetry properties of a z-polarized transition connecting sets of (þ) levels, T1(00 (þ)) S0(00(þ)). The probe transition S2 T1 is also spin forbidden, with T1 spin-orbit coupled to the S0 ground singlet state. Both the pump and
62
THIOPHOSGENE
Figure 2.24. A comparison of the vibrational structure of the S2 state from OODR spectra recorded with the S1(00) and S1(41) states as intermediates. (a) S2(v0 ) S1(41) S0(00). (b) S2(v0 ) S1(00) S0(41). (Reprinted with permission from Ref. [15].)
the probe transitions gain their strength from a borrowing from the same S2 S0 transition. As the perturbation gaps and the coupling elements are of the same magnitude, each step in the two-photon process should have similar transition strengths. The vibronic levels in combination will be of (þ) inversion symmetry, S2(00(þ)) T1(00(þ)) S0(00(þ)). A simple comparison of the two panels in Figure 2.23 reveals that the OODR(S1) spectra has twice the band density as the OODR(T1) spectra. This difference must be associated with the differing selection rules for the two cases. In the OODR(T1) process, the vibrational activity of single quanta of the Q4(B1) or Q5/Q6 (B2) modes requires a second-order vibronic-spin-orbit coupling mechanism, and these bands are expected to be weak. The strong band in the OODR(S1) spectrum at Ev ¼ 212 cm1, which is absent in the OODR(T1) spectrum, is then given the assignment v6. With this assignment, the next band at Ev ¼ 248 cm1 is then attributed to the low-frequency mode v3 by process of elimination.
ELECTRONIC STATES
63
Figure 2.25. Temporal profiles of polarization-dependent OODR transitions to (a) the 00 and (b) the 61 levels in the S2 state, S2(00) S1(41) S0(00) and S2(61) S1(41) S0(00), showing the differences in intensity of the emission from the S2 state with the electric vectors (Es) of the pump and probe lasers that are parallel (E1 // E2) and perpendicular (E1 ? E2).
To add further credence to these critical assignments, the polarization-dependent OODR(S1) spectrum was recorded for the 000 and 610 bands with implement of photoelastic modulator (PEM). This device alters the polarizations of the probe and pump beams with each laser pulse in a shot-by-shot fashion. For the 000 transition, the two beams would have parallel polarizations (pump and probe transition are both y (B2) polarized). For the 610 transition, the two photons would be perpendicularly polarized to each other, with y and z polarization, respectively. The temporal profiles of polarization-dependent OODR spectra in Figure 2.25 show the expected behavior, where the signals of the parallel and perpendicular polarizations for the S2(00) S1(41) S0(00 ) and S2(61) S1(41) S0(00 ) are plotted against the delay time. The effects of reversing the polarizations is not too pronounced in these experiments, as the rotational coherence lifetimes are very short and the overall rotation of the molecule quickly scrambles the polarizations of the signals. At very short delay
64
THIOPHOSGENE
times, the two traces do change in the expected directions, giving credence to the assignments. The concern about these critical assignments relates to the crossing of the ~ 1B2(n,s*). Figure 2.4 shows that stable S2 state is crossed ~ 1A1(p,p*) and C B ˚ . As these states are of A1 and B2 symby an unstable S3 state at r(CS) ¼ 2.44 A metry, they would not interact with each other in the planar C2v conformation. These states, however, would engage in a vibronic interaction induced by distortions in the B2 y-direction. Such a distortion could be brought about by the Q6 mode. The intensity of the 620 band in the OODR(S1) spectrum is very low, and the Ev ¼ 421 cm1 interval is twice the fundamental, 212 cm1, indicating that the V(Q6) potential is nearly harmonic. This observation is in accordance with the calculated vibronic interaction Vev of <0.2 cm1 [6]. This low value may be related to the lack of a common molecular orbital between the interacting state configurations p,p* and n,s*.
III.
PHOTOPHYSICAL PROPERTIES A. S1 Thiophosgene
In the so-called statistical limit of radiationless transitions (where the molecule undergoes an irreversible, exponential decay), the rate constant knr of nonradiative decay from the initial electronic state jsi to the final electronic state j li is given by [36] knr ¼
2p j hsj ^ v j li j2 rl h
ð7Þ
where ^v represents the perturbation responsible for the radiationless decay and rl is the state density of j li. To the first order, ^v is the nuclear kinetic energy operator (T^N ) for internal conversion (a radiationless transition between two electronic ^ SO ) for intersysstates of the same multiplicity) and spin-orbit coupling (H tem crossing (radiationless transitions between states of different spin multiplicity). Within the Condon approximation, which assumes that the electronic matrix elements are a slowly varying function of coordinates, the the nuclear matrix elements for the internal conversion sj T^N j l between adiabatic Born-Oppenheimer states, j si fs ðq;QÞws ðQÞ and j li fl ðq; QÞwl ðQÞ, can be written in the form [37] h2 Vsl ¼
E X q q Y D fl fs w j w w w sui suj lvj qQ q Q lvi i
i
i
j6¼i
ð8Þ
PHOTOPHYSICAL PROPERTIES
65
where f and w represent electronic and vibrational wavefunctions respectively, u and v are the vibrational quantum for modes i and j. Qi represents the massweighted normal coordinate for mode i. Note that the matrix elements responsible for the internal conversion are composed of two factors: an electronic integral hfs j q=qQi j fl i, representing nonadiabatic coupling between the two electronic states; vibrational integrals containing a nuclear integral hws j q=qQi j wl i; and an overlap integral hws j wl i. Following Lin and Bershon [38], the vibrations for which the electronic matrix elements are finite are designated as ‘‘promoting modes,’’ whereas those for which overlap integrals are nonvanishing are classified as ‘‘accepting modes.’’ Since the Franck-Condon factors (which are the squared sum of the vibrational overlap integrals) decrease with increasing Es-Ee energy gas, Eq. (8) accounts for the decrease in the measured rate constant with increasing energy difference between the initial and the final electronic states, viz., the energy-gap law. To the lowest order, the electronic matrix elements in Eq. (8) are determined by the vibronic coupling integral [37, 38] qUðq; QÞ f f ðq;QÞ ðq;QÞ s qQ l q fs ðq;QÞ fl ðq;QÞ ¼ ð9Þ El ðQÞEs ðQÞ qQ where U is the potential energy of interaction between the electrons and nuclei and E represents the energy of the electronic state. Eq. (9) forms the basis for selection rules for radiationless transitions. The vibronic coupling operator qU/qQ transforms as the nuclear coordinate Q, (qU/qQ) ¼ (Q); and for internal conversion (IC) between the initial electronic state j si and the final electronic state j li, the requirement is that the direct product (j li) (Q) (j si) contain the totally symmetric representation of the point group. Despite the important implications, this selection rule for the electronic matrix elements has not been put to a rigorous experimental test. The reason is that, for polyatomic molecules with relatively low symmetries, the normal coordinates usually encompass all irreducible representations of the symmetry group, and a separation of the mode structure into promoting and accepting modes is not feasible. A critical test of the selection rules requires a rather special molecule with very special energy level dispositions and normal coordinates that do not span the entire irreducible representation of the symmetry group. The term vibrationally deficient was suggested by Gardner and Kasha [39] for the class of molecules that fail to span the vibrational irreducible representations. The six normal modes for thiophosgene (Fig. 2.6) show the decomposition of the six normal modes into the three in-plane totally symmetric modes, 3A1, the one out-of-plane mode, B1, and the two in-plane, antisymmetric modes, 2B2:
66
THIOPHOSGENE
(v) ¼ 3A1 B1 2B2. Lacking in this collection is a mode of A2 species. Somewhat fortuitously this vibrationally deficient mode has the correct symmetry to create the selection rules for the IC process. Thus if we return to Eq. (9) and identify the initial state with the singlet n,p* excited state and the final state with the ground state, j si ¼ S1, and j li ¼ S0, then for the S1 to transfer energy to the S0 state, the direct product (S0) (Q) (S1) ¼ A1 (Q) A2 ¼ A1; and as a result, (Q) ¼ A2, identifying the promoting mode as a mode that transforms as a rotation about the z-axis (C S bond). While such modes are available for larger thiocarbonyl C2v , systems, such as thioacetone or thiocyclobutanone, they are not found in tetra-atomic molecules, such as thiophosgene [1,40]. Without a promoting mode, the normal IC process is symmetry restricted, allowing for photon energy deactivation through the alternative pathway of fluorescence emission. The extent to which the IC process is blocked by vibrational deficiency can be ascertained by the quantum yield for fluorescence, F. Such information can be extracted from the measured fluorescence lifetimes, tF, of the vibronic levels of the S1 state, providing the oscillator strength of the S1 S0 transition is known. The radiative lifetime, based on the transition strength, tr, can calculated from the oscillator strength through the expression, tr 1.5/fv2. With a measured oscillator strength of f ¼ 1.2104 and an average transition frequency of v ¼ 19,000 cm1 the radiative lifetime is estimated to be tr ¼ 35 ms. This value is identical to the room-temperature fluorescence lifetime of McDonald and Brus [41]. With equal values of the calculated and observed lifetimes, the quantum yield for fluorescence is unity, F ¼ 1, demonstrating that internal conversion is completely blocked by the absence of a promoting mode, and it does ˜ 1A2(41) level. Thus the not play a role in the photophysical behavior of the A strong fluorescence from the first excited state of thiophosgene can be directly attributed to the absence of a vibrational mode of A2 species within the set of irreducible representations that span the C2v point group. In summary, the high fluorescence quantum yield demonstrates the critical role of the promoting mode and the Gardner-Kasha supposition [39] that vibrational deficiencies may create selection rules that hinder radiationless transitions. These early lifetime results, obtained from bulb conditions, (room temperature) were compared to similar data recorded under jet-cooled conditions. Analyses of the decay characteristics of the 41 level fluorescence at Ev ¼ 0.42 cm1 yielded a lifetime of 1.5 ms and was found to be internally consistent with the value derived from the OODR pump–probe method with beam displacement [42]. Both of these lifetimes are considerably shorter than the 35 ms value accepted for the S1 state [41]. Since it is highly unlikely that nonradiative decay, unimportant at room temperature, would become significant under the lowtemperature conditions of the supersonic jet, the much longer lifetime at room temperature must have its origin in a reduced radiative decay at elevated
PHOTOPHYSICAL PROPERTIES
67
Figure 2.26. Quantum beat–modulated fluorescence decay and its Fourier transform for the 11213141 level of S1 thiophosgene. (Reprinted with permission from Ref. [42].)
temperatures. It has been proposed that this temperature dependence arises from a Coriolis coupling that mixes the Q4 active mode with the other modes of the S1 manifold of vibrational levels [42]. It is interesting that thiophosgene exhibits quantum beats in emission [42] when it is excited into the vibronic levels lying in the vicinity of 20,340 cm1. Figure 2.26 displays the beat-modulated fluorescence decay of the S1(11213141) level. Fourier analysis reveals major frequency components at 6.8 and 12.0 MHz. Similar, but more complex beat patterns were also observed for higher vibronic levels. This quantum beat structure was attributed ˜ 1A2(n,p*) singlet state with the ~b 3A1(p,p*) to singlet-triplet interaction of the A triplet state, from the estimate of 20,160 cm1 based on the electron-impact
68
THIOPHOSGENE
energy loss spectrum [43]. As the radiative transition T2 ! S0 is nearly forbidden due to the lack of T2S2 spin-orbit coupling and since T2T1 internal conversion is symmetry forbidden owing to the absence of an A2 promoting mode, the perturbation of the S1 state by the T2 state is expected to have a negligible effect on the S1 lifetime. Based on the threshold energy for the observation of beat-modulated fluorescence decay, the ~ b 3A1(p,p*) state was placed at about 1 20,340 cm , in excellent agreement with ab initio predictions [44]. Decay curve lifetime measurements were extended for number of the higher S1 vibronic levels. Levels 41, 43, 2141, 1141, 112141, 11223141—levels at (Ev, cm1) 0.42, 292.5, 480.4, 907.8, 1387.4, and 1632.2—were found to have lifetimes, respectively, of (tf, ms ), 4.8, 4.3, 3.9, 3.5, 2.6, and 2.9. What is interesting is that the lifetimes shortens uniformly with increasing vibrational excitation throughout the S1 S0 system until the fluorescence extinguishes at Ev ¼ 3484 cm1. From a free-radical scavenging experiments Okabe [45] attributed this loss of fluorescence to the onset of chlorine free-radical production ~ ) process withbrought about by the fragmentation Cl2CS ! Cl(2P3/2) þ ClCS(X out an impeding dissociation barrier. A wide spectral view of the time-resolved fluorescence excitation spectrum of thiohosgene, ranging from the visible (18,700 cm1) to the UV (37,700 cm1), at different gate widths is presented in Figure 2.27. This LIF spectrum encompasses the transitions from the S0 ground state to both the S1 and the S2 states as well as mapping the intervening spectral region. The upper spectrum (Fig. 2.27a) recorded with short-gate width (0–20 ns), is identical to the LIF S2 S0 system in Figure 2.22a. The spectrum in Figure. 2.27b, recorded with the longer gate width (140–440 ns), is lacking the shorter-lived S2 S0 spectrum, although it now contains the complete S1 S0 system at lower energies. Somewhat surprising, is the emergence of a new excitation spectrum in the intermediate region. This new spectrum was assigned to an extension of the first singlet-singlet ~ 1A1(n2) from considerations of the dis˜ 1A2(n,p*) X transition, S1 S0, A persed fluorescence and fluorescence lifetime measurements. Figure 2.28 shows the extreme contrasts in the decay curves that are observed for the three regions of the LIF spectrum. These decay curves from exciting the S2(00), S1(v), and S1(41) levels at (Ev, cm1) 0.00, 12,658, and 0.42 have lifetimes of 50 ns, 1.6 ms, and 1.5 ms, which mirror the behavior of the variable gate-delay data depicted in Figure 2.27. Indeed, the lifetimes of the two low-energy systems fluctuate by only 2–5 ms over excitation energies that range to Ev ¼ 18,984 cm1 and allow the level patterns to be classified as members of the same ˜ 1A2(n,p*) vibrational manifold. The second aid to the electronic assignment A is shown in Figure 2.29 as a comparison of the dispersed fluorescence from the S1(2141) level at 19,196 cm1 with the excited vibronic levels of the intermediate state at 29,106 cm1. What is immediately apparent is the complexity of the resolved vibrational structure in the fluorescence of the lower panel. The length
69
Figure 2.27. Time-resolved S1 S0 and S2 S0 fluorescence excitation spectra of jet-cooled thiophosgene in the energy range 17,700– 37,700 cm1, recorded with different gate time arrangements: (a) First 20 ns, (b) starting at 140 ns with a 300 ns width, (c) all time integrated. Total emissions were monitored and normalized to input laser powers. The broad unstructured feature at about 37,000 cm1 is believed to be the S2 S0 transition of the thiophosgene dimer, as its intensity is much weaker in warmer supersonic beams. Inset: Schematic energy level diagram of thiophosgene. (Reprinted with permission from Ref. [42].)
70
THIOPHOSGENE
~ (S2) state Figure 2.28. Fluorescence decay from a low-lying vibronic level (00) of the B ~ (S1) state. (Reprinted with and that from the 41 and high-lying vibronic levels of the A permission from Ref. [42].)
of this spectrum is partially the result of a long-wavelength tail that contains features that closely mimic resonance fluorescence from the 2141 level. This correspondence can be accounted for if the excited S1 level undergoes extensive IVR [46] to populate levels that contain low degrees of excitation in the optically modes (v4, in particular). The dispersed fluorescence from other high lying vibronic levels also bears the spatial characteristics of levels that undergo extensive IVR. The most striking feature of the excitation spectra of Figure 2.27 is the breaking off of the S1 ! S0 fluorescence at Ev ¼ 3484 cm1 above the S1 origin and its reappearance at about 9284 cm1 [42]. Thus, over a range of about 5800 cm1, there is no detectable emission from the S1 state. This behavior is consistent with the occurrence of predissociation, leading to the production of Cl (2P1/2) and ~ ) (Fig. 2.27, inst). The characteristic feature of the predissociation, as ClCS (X
PHOTOPHYSICAL PROPERTIES
71
Figure 2.29. Comparison of the low-resolution dispersed fluorescence spectra of S1 obtained after excitation of the 2141 vibronic level and a high-energy vibronic feature at 29,106 cm1. (Reprinted with permission from Ref. [42].)
probed by the S1 ! S0 fluorescence is that there is a region of Ev in which the emission intensity (or lifetime) would is extremely weak (or extremely short) due to the transition to the repulsive exit channel. For Ev far above or far below the intersection region, the fluorescence intensity (or lifetime) is expected to be normal due to very small nonadiabatic interactions between the bound and the repulsive states (Fig. 2.27, inset). To state it somewhat differently, below the crossing point, the molecule has insufficient energy to dissociate, whereas above the crossing point the area occupied by the dissociation channel within the six-dimensional vibrational hypersurface is sufficiently small that vibrational structure is preserved. Based on the observed onset of the fluorescence breakoff, we place the curve crossing (leading to predissociation) at 3484 cm1 above the electronic origin of the S1 state, in excellent agreement with the existing assignment of 3454 cm1. The occurrence of the intensity maximum in the S1 S0 excitation spectrum ˜ 1A2(41) is consistent with this at about 12,000 cm1 above the false origin A 1 1 assignment for two reasons. First, the B2 A2 coupling which induces the S1 S0 transition strength is expected to more efficient for the higher lying vibronic levels of the S1 state because of the smaller 1B2 1A2 perturbation energy gaps. Second, owing to the nonplanarity of the S1 state and the change
72
THIOPHOSGENE
in the C S bond length relative to the ground state, vertical (adiabatic) transitions would likely occur to high-lying vibrational levels of the excited state as a consequence of the Franck-Condon overlap factors. The essential identity of the fluorescence lifetime at very small and very large Ev indicates that the S1 state in thiophosgene does not exhibit significant radiationless decay to the bound S0 ground electronic state, even when the molecule is endowed with very high degrees of vibrational excitation. The lack of S1(A2) ! S0(A1) internal conversion from the vibrationally highly excited S1 state implies that the higher order promoting modes, Q4 with Q6, (b1 b2) with a2 symmetry, are not efficient in inducing a radiationless process. The near constancy of the fluorescence lifetime also indicates that S1 ! T1 intersystem crossing from the manifold of S1 is also inefficient. This behavior is in total contrast to the T1 ! S0 ISC process, discussed earlier, and can be attributed to the small Franck-Condon factor for the radiationless transition that arises from the small S1 T1 energy gap and the similar geometries for the two electronic states. The forbidden nature of the direct S1 T1 spin-orbit coupling is also a factor. As intersystem crossing from the S1 state to the higher lying T2 state is not possible for collision-free thiophosgene, as a consequence of the much smaller vibrational density of the interacting states, the only available decay channel of S1 thiophosgene is the radiative transition (fluorescence) to the ground S0 state.
B. S2 Thiophosgene ~ 1A1(p,p*) 1A1(n2) photographic absorption spectrum of thiophosThe S2 B gene at room temperature consists of a series of sharp lines in complex patterns that quickly broaden and become diffuse at shorter wavelengths as the result of an early onset of a molecular predissociation. Under the emissive requirements of excitation spectroscopy this line broadening can be correlated to the diminution of the fluorescence signal strength with excess vibrational energy. The jet-cooled LIF spectra in Figure 2.27 with different gate widths clearly shows the variation in the temporal behavior associated with the line broadening at higher energies. The strength of the fluorescence emission, as measured by the quantum yield, can be judged from a comparison of the observed lifetimes of single vibronic levels, with the lifetime extracted from the measured oscillator strength. This procedure yields the remarkably high quantum yield of unity (F ¼ 1.0) for the 00 level (Ev ¼ 0.0) from the measured lifetime (tf ¼ 39.8 ns). That the deactivation of the v ¼ 0 level is completely radiative is a testimony of the law of vibrational deficiency. The first and second electronic states are in perfect juxtaposition, and it is only their electronic symmetries that prevent the onset of an S2 S1 IC. The matrix element connecting these electronic states, hS2 ðA1 Þj QP j S1 ðA2 Þi, however,
PHOTOPHYSICAL PROPERTIES
73
requires a promoting mode Qp to bear the symmetry A2 level. Within the C2v group, this representation is not present as one of the six normal modes (v ¼ 3A1 B1 B2), and it is the absence of such a mode that is responsible for blocking the radiationless IC route as a pathway for photon deactivation. It should be noted that the lack of a suitable promoting mode closes the two major IC pathways, S2 S1 and S1 S0 and is responsible for the fluorescence from the S2 state with high quantum yield, in violation of Kasha’s rule. For the higher vibronic levels, the fluorescence quantum yield was found to decrease from F ¼ 1.0 at zero excess energy, Ev ¼ 0.0, to F 0.5 at 835 cm1 and remain at <1.0 until the excess energy reaches 1300 cm1, at which point the S2 S0 fluorescence breaks off. The loss of LIF signal at Ev ¼ 1300 cm1 of vibrational energy has been interpreted in terms of C Cl bond dissociation [45]. Warsylewicz et al. [47] investigated the temporal characteristics of selected bands within the system under picosecond temporal resolution. They found that the fluorescence decay curves for the levels below the 1300 cm1 threshold consisted of a exponential component (30–40 ns) superimposed on a fast nonexponential decay (15 ns). From the area under the decay curve, they established that the fraction that decayed at the radiative rate varied from nearly unity (0.96) at Ev ¼ 0.0 cm1 to being completely absent at Ev ¼ 1211 cm1. The reduction in quantum yield of fluorescence and the onset of the picosecond nonradiative component over the short Ev energy span cannot be attributed to the excess energy dependence of an IC process between the S2 and the S1 states. Rather, the observation of the fast-decaying component suggests that an alternative radiationless process is responsible for depleting the bright states populated by the S2 S0 excitation. Such a process must be slow relative to the decay at zero excess energy and becomes equal to the radiative decay at 835 cm1. Thus the temporal characteristics of the fluorescence decay consist of one component that remains optically bright and gives rise to the exponentially decaying radiative fluorescence (30–40 ns) and a second component that evolves over a period of a few nanoseconds into a set of bound but dark states. ~ , that is Steer et al. [8, 48] have proposed that the dark state is a new state, C formed when two electrons are lifted from the n orbital and placed into the p* orbital in a doubly excited configuration, (n)0(p*)2. Multireference CASSCF calculations of Strickler and Gruebele [6] indicate, however, that this phantom state ~ 1B2(n,s*) electronic state, formed from the one electron is very likely the C ~ state is planar and intern ! s* excitation. Their calculations show that the C 1 ~ sects the nonplanar B A1(p,p*) state at increasing C S bond distances ( 2.5 ˚ ). The barrier separating the B ~ state ranges from 300 cm1 (y ¼ 0) ~ from the C A to about 1650 cm1 (y ¼ 45 ). Calculations of the transition dipole moments ~j m j X ~ , element is about three orders along the C S bond shows that the C ~ state ~j m j X ~ and provides the rationalization of C of magnitude smaller than B darkness.
74
THIOPHOSGENE
Figure 2.30. Schematic energy-level diagrams depicting the pump–probe (a) OODR and (b) OODR–fluorescence depletion (OODR–FD) experiments. The y and z directions denote the polarization vectors of the various transitions. (Reprinted with permission from Ref. [49].)
~ state and the identiSome progress has been made on the detection of the C fication of the associated electron configuration. As this state is dark, a nonradiative absorption technique rather than a fluorescence method is required. Figure 2.30 depicts the energy schematics of such an experiment where the optical–optical double resonance process is combined with fluorescence depletion (OODR–FD). The first step in this method, involves the excitation of jet~ state through a pumping ~ to the A cooled thiophosgene from the ground state X 1 0 3 of the 40 , 41 , or 40 vibronic transitions. This is followed by the time-delayed ~ states. The depletion of ~ or C probe laser, which induces transitions to the B ~ ~ ~ the A population signaling a C A transition is monitored by the resulting ~ !X ~ fluorescence. Under these conditions, the pump laser– reduction in A induced emission appears as a background of essentially constant intensity, on which the depletion induced by the probe laser is superimposed as a negativegoing signal. Figure 2.31 shows a four-panel comparison of the OODR–FD and OODR spectra [49]. The signals are the result of transitions that stem from the
PHOTOPHYSICAL PROPERTIES
75
~ (41) and A ~ (43) levels and terminate on one of the X ~ states. A ~, B ~ , or C populated A major problem with these spectra is to separate the signals and, by elimination, ~ ~ transitions that lead to the dark state. Those transitions to B ~ identify the C A that form strong dips at the high frequency end of in Figure 2.31b, d can be unscrambled and assigned by comparing the positive OODR and negative OODR–FD signals (Fig. 2.31a, c). Pumping the 41 and 43 levels yields the (þ) and () inversion components and reveals the inversion splittings (þ and ~ states. The assignments to the B ~ , and C ~ state were confirmed ~, B ) in the X by their negligibly small inversion doubling intervals. Finally, the FD transitions ~ state must be disentangled from the downward transitions to the upward to the C ~ state. It is important to point out that this is the third major source of fluoresX ~ and C ~ ~ ~ cence depletion in the OODR scheme and is unrelated to the B A A ~ absorptions. This interference is SEP (stimulated emission pumping) of the A state, which leads to depletion of the spontaneous emission. The SEP positions can be calculated from the effective Hamiltonian of Gruebele [19]. The locations of these bands are shown by leaders along with quantum number assignments. The two candidate electronic states lead to different predictions about the direc~ ~ transition moment absorption relative to the moment of the tion of the C A ~ ~ state of (n)0(p)2 configura~ A X absorption. As illustrated in Figure 2.30, a C tion would require pump and probe beams of parallel polarization, whereas perpendicularly polarized beams would be needed to create the (n)1(s )1 configuration. The unaccounted bands that remain after the elimination process ~ ~ transition, although are labeled with asterisks. They are ascribed to the C A their vibronic assignments have yet to be ascertained. ~ X ~ A ~ ) is con~ internal conversion (relative to C The importance of the C ~ firmed by the absence of fluorescence from the A state following excitation to ~ state. It is well known that the dominant accepting the higher levels of the B mode for the S1 S0 internal conversion in aliphatic carbonyls (or thiocarbonyls) is the C O (or C S) vibration [50]. The special role of the carbonyl stretching vibration is a consequence of its lower frequency in the S1 state relative to S0. The frequency and structural differences between the S1 and the S0 states render large Franck-Condon factors for the S1–S0 internal conversion. A simple model calculation has demonstrated that the internal conversion, which is already efficient at low excess energies, becomes even more pronounced with increasing vibrational excitation of the carbonyl stretching mode in the S1 state ~ X ~ IC to the ground electronic state to be [50]. One would expect the direct C ~ state as a significantly more important than a competing IC deactivation to the A ~ ~. result of the unusually long C S bond length in the C state relative to X Combined with the very small radiative decay rate resulting from the low oscil~ X ~ state essentially ~ transition, this would make the C lator strength of the C nonradiative.
76
CONCLUDING REMARKS
77
IV. CONCLUDING REMARKS The combination of supersonic-jet-laser spectroscopy and high-level ab initio calculations provides a powerful method for probing the geometrical structure and photophysical properties of small molecules. In this chapter, we described the experimental and theoretical characterizations of geometrical structures and elementary photoprocesses in supersonic free jet. The major focus of the review was on the OODR spectroscopy, which is designed to identify and characterize dark electronic states of the molecule. The main conclusions that emerge from the review can be summarized as follows. First, the equilibrium geometry of the molecule varies widely among the elec^ ) stats are planar, whereas ~ ) and the ns* singlet (C tronic states. The ground (X ~ ~ ) states are nonplanar. the np* singlet (A), np* triplet (~a), and pp* singlet (B 1 1 ~ ~ 1A2(S1) ! ~ Second, the absence of significant B A1(S2) ! A A2(S1) and A 1 ~ X A1(S0) internal conversion, as evidenced by the high quantum yields ~ !X ~!X ~ and A ~ fluorescence, is due to the lack of the pro(F 1.0) of the B ~ !X ~!X ~ and A ~ moting mode of a2 symmetry, which is required for the B radiationless transitions. ~ ) state, ~ ) thiophosgene to the S1 (A Third, one-photon excitation of the S0 (X followed by photodepletion of the S2 ! S0 fluorescence (fluorescence deple^ ) S 0 (A ~ ) excitation, by another photon, reveals the presence ~, C tion) by Sn (B ^ ~ state. The polarization as well as the of the dark C state in the vicinity of the B ^ inversion splitting patterns of the OODR–FD spectrum are consistent with the C 1 state being the planar B2 (ns*) state predicted by an ab initio calculation. Fourth, the S1 ! S0 fluorescence exhibits loss of emission at low S1 excess vibrational energy and reappearance at very large excess energies, consistent with predissociation. A quantum beat–modulated S1 fluorescence decay was observed at energies corresponding to the expected position of the T2 (p,p*) state. Fifth, the absence of significant phosphorescence is entirely consistent with ~ (S0) spin-orbit coupling and the nonplanar geometry of the ~a the large ~a (T1) X ~ state), which leads to highly efficient ~a ! X ~ interstate (vis a` vis the planar X system crossing. 3
~ !X ~ emission by the probe laser, Figure 2.31. Depletion of the pump laser–induced A ~ ~ ~ ~ ð41 Þ and (d) A ~ ð43 Þ. The B ~ ~ which induces the B A and C A transitions: (b) A 0 0 ~ )(v0 ) A ~ ð43 Þ ~ ð00 Þ OODR–FD spectrum is displayed with energy offset of (or C X ~ 1A2(n,p*): 2(43 –41 ). Also 2 291.62 cm1, which represents two quanta of v4 in the A 0 0 0 1 3 ~ ~ ~ shown for comparison are the B(v ) Að4 ; 4 Þ X ð00 Þ OODR fluorescence excitation ~ !X ~ emission: (a) and (c). The leaders represent the expected band positions of the of B OODR–FD features due to SEP, whereas the asterisks in the lower-energy region of the OODR–FD spectrum (upper panel) denote the stronger features of the bands assigned to ~ ~ transition. (Reprinted with permission from Ref. [49].) the C A
78
THIOPHOSGENE
~ ) ! T1 (~a) transitions to the three spin sublevels of the T1 state Finally, S0 (X were observed by fluorescence-detected S2 T1 S0 OODR experiments, and confirmed by rotational contour analyses. The transition to the Tz spin sublevel is much stronger and broader in linewidth, than the transitions to the Tx and Ty spin sublevels, consistent with the theoretical expectations. Highly differing T1 S0 interaction strengths for the three spin sublevels leads to T1 decay, which appears to be ‘‘biexponential’’ with vastly different lifetimes. Thiophosgene is one of the simplest and best-studied prototype systems for which accurate potential energy surfaces can be obtained through experiment and high-level ab initio calculations. As such, thiophosgene is a molecule tailormade for the fundamental understanding of electronic relaxation in polyatomic molecules. The results summarized in this chapter confirm the special role thiophosgene plays in the field of molecular photophysics and photochemistry.
ACKNOWLEDGMENTS The work performed in the authors’ laboratories was supported by the Office of the Basic Energy Sciences of the U.S. Department of Energy and the National Sciences and Engineering Research Council of Canada.
REFERENCES 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. 6. 7. 8. 9. 10. 11. 12. 13. 14. 15.
D. C. Moule and E. C. Lim, J. Chem. Phys. 1999, 110, 9341. M. Kasha, Disc. Faraday Soc. 1950, 9, 14. D. J. Clouthier and D. C. Moule, Top. Curr. Chem. 1989, 150, 167. A. Maciejewski and R. P. Steer, Chem. Rev. 1993, 93, 67. G. Herzberg, Molecular Structure and Molecular Spectra, vol. 1, Van Nostrand Reinhold, New York, 1945. B. Strickler and M. Gruebele, Chem. Phys. Lett. 2001, 349, 137. D. C. Moule and A. D. Walsh, Chem. Rev. 1975, 75, 67. R. P. Steer, Rev. Chem. Int. 1981, 4, 1. L. O. Brockway, Y. J. Beach and L. Pauling, J. Am. Chem. Soc. 1935, 57, 2693. J. H. Carpenter, D. F. Rimmer, J. G. Smith, and D. H. Whiffen, J. Chem. Soc., Faraday Trans. 1975, 71, 1752. D. C. Moule, I. R. Burling, H. Liu, and E. C. Lim, J. Chem. Phys. 1999, 111, 1. J. R. Lombardi, J. Chem. Phys. 1970, 52, 6126. J. C. D. Brand, J. L. Hardwick, and K-E Teo, J. Mol. Spectrosc. 1975, 57, 215. D. C. Moule and C. R. Subramaniam, J. Mol. Spectrosc. 1973, 48, 336. T. Fujiwara, E. C. Lim, and D. C. Moule, J. Chem. Phys. 2003, 119, 7741.
REFERENCES
16. 17. 18. 19. 20. 21. 22. 23. 24. 25. 26. 27. 28. 29. 30. 31. 32. 33. 34. 35. 36. 37. 38. 39. 40. 41. 42. 43. 44. 45. 46. 47. 48. 49. 50. 51.
79
A. J. Downs, Spectrochim. Acta. 1963, 19, 147. C. A. Frenzel, K. E. Blick, C. R. Bennett, and K. Neidenzu, J. Chem. Phys. 1970, 53, 198. L. Burnelle, Acad. R. Belg. Classe Sci. Mem. 1958, 30, 7. R. Bigwood, B. Milam, and M. Gruebele, Chem. Phys. Lett. 1998, 287, 333. B. Simard, V. J. MacKenzie, P. A. Hackett, and R. P. Steer, Can. J. Chem. 1994, 72, 745. T. Oka, A. R. Knight, and R. P. Steer, J. Chem. Phys. 1975, 63, 2414. R. M. Hochstrasser, Molecular Aspects of Symmetry, W. A. Benjamin, New York, 1966. J. C. D. Brand, J. H. Callomon, D. C. Moule, J. Tyrrell, and T. H. Goodwin, Trans. Faraday Soc. 1965, 61, 2356. T. Fujiwara, E. C. Lim, and D. C. Moule, unpublished data. D. J. Clouthier and D. C. Moule, J. Mol. Spectrosc. 1981, 87, 471. D. J. Clouthier, A. R. Knight, R. P. Steer, and P. A. Hackett, J. Chem. Phys. 1980, 72, 1560. P. F. Bernath, P. G. Cummins, J. R. Lombardi, and R. W. Field, J. Mol. Spectrosc. 1978, 69, 66. M. Kawasaki, K. Kasatani, and H. Sato, Chem. Phys. 1985, 94, 179. T. Fujiwara, D. C. Moule, E. C. Lim, and R. H. Judge, unpublished data. T. Fujiwara, D. C. Moule, and E. C. Lim, unpublished data. B. Strickler and M. Gruebele, unpublished data. E. R. Farnsworth and G. W. King, J. Mol. Spectrosc. 1973, 46, 419. R. H. Judge and D. C. Moule, J. Mol Spectrosc. 1980, 80, 363. R. N. Dixon and C. M. Western, J. Mol. Spectrosc. 1986, 115, 74. M. Ludwiczak, D. R. Latimer, and R. P. Steer, J. Mol. Spectrosc. 1991, 147, 414. P. Avouris, W. M. Gelbart, and M. A. El-Sayed, Chem. Rev. 1997, 77, 793. S. H. Lin, J. Chem. Phys. 1996, 44, 3759. S. H. Lin and R. Bersohn, J. Chem. Phys. 1968, 48, 2732. P. J. Gardner and M. Kasha, J. Phys. Chem. 1969, 50, 1543. D. C. Moule and E. C. Lim, J. Phys. Chem. A 2002, 106 3072. J. R. McDonald and L. E. Brus, Chem. Phys. Lett. 1972, 16, 587. T. Fujiwara, D. C. Moule, and E. C. Lim, J. Phys. Chem. A 2003, 107, 10223. W. M. Flicker, O. A. Masher, and A. Kupperman, Chem. Phys. Lett. 1978, 57, 978. M. Hackey, F. Grein, and R. P. Steer, Can. J. Chem. 1993, 71, 112. H. Okabe, J. Chem. Phys. 1977, 66, 2058. P. M. Felker and A. H. Zewail, Adv. Chem. Phys. 1988, 70, 265. A. M. Warsylewicz, K. J. Falk, and R. P. Steer, Chem. Phys. Lett. 2002, 352, 48. A. Maciejewski, M. Szymanski, and R. P. Steer, Chem. Phys. 1992, 165, 101. T. Fujiwara, D. C. Moule, and E. C. Lim, Chem. Phys. Lett. 2004, 389, 165. G. D.Gillispie and E. C. Lim, Chem. Phys. Lett. 1975, 34, 513. T. Fujiwara, E. C. Lim, J. Koset, R. H. Judge, and D. C. Moule, in preparation for publication.
1,2-CYCLOADDITION REACTION OF CARBONYL COMPOUNDS AND PENTAATOMIC HETEROCYCLIC COMPOUNDS M. D’Auria, L. Emanuele, and R. Racioppi, Dipartimento di Chimica, Universita` della Basilicata, Via N. Sauro 85, 85100 Potenza, Italy
CONTENTS I. II.
III.
Introduction The Paterno`-Bu¨chi Reaction on Furan Derivatives A. Furan B. Benzofuran C. 2,3-Dihydrofuran D. Synthetic Applications E. Asymmetric Reactions The Paterno`-Bu¨chi Reaction on Pentaatomic Heterocycles Different from Furan A. Thiophene B. Pyrrole C. Selenophene D. Imidazole E. Thiazole, Isoxazole, Isothiazole F. Indole
Advances in Photochemistry, Volume 28 Edited by Douglas C. Neckers, William S. Jenks, and Thomas Wolff # 2005 John Wiley & Sons, Inc.
81
82
1,2-CYCLOADDITION REACTION OF CARBONYL COMPOUNDS
G. Azaindole H. Possible Explanation of the Observed Reactivity IV Conclusions References
I. INTRODUCTION The Paterno`-Bu¨ chi reaction is a milestone in organic photochemistry (Scheme 3.1). Paterno` and Chieffi [1] reported obtaining oxetanes from the photocycloaddition of ketones to olefins in 1909, but this reaction was recognized as an important synthetic reaction only after the work of Bu¨chi et al. [2]. hv O
+
O
Scheme 3.1
After these pioneering works, several reviews cover the enormous number of papers published in this field [3–7]. The synthesis of oxetanes can have a great importance in the development of compounds with relevant biological properties: oxetane ring is present in the skeleton of taxol (1), an important drug used in the treatment of ovarian cancer [8]; in merrilactone A (2), a new sesquiterpene dilactone with neurotrophic activity [9]; and in several antiviral oxetanes, such as 3, 4, and 5, which have been described in literature (Scheme 3.2) [10–12].
O Ph
AcO
O OH
NH O
Ph
HO
O OH
O 2
O
NH2 N
O 3
NH
N N
RO
ON
NH2
O O
O 4
Scheme 3.2
O
O
O H OHOBz OAc 1
HOHO N
O
O
5
CO2H
` -BU ¨ CHI REACTION ON FURAN DERIVATIVES THE PATERNO
83
The Paterno`-Bu¨ chi reaction is a photocycloaddition reaction of a n,p* carbonyl compound to an alkene in the ground state from either the S1 or the T1 state. The reaction can occur through the initial C O bond formation or through a previous formation of the C C bond. A frontier orbitals approach can be used to explain the formation of oxetanes. We can observe the HSOMO-LUMO interaction in which the half-occupied p* carbonyl orbital interacts with the unoccupied p* molecular orbital of an electron-deficient alkene, and a C,O-biradical is formed. The LSOMO-HOMO interaction in which the half-occupied n orbital of the carbonyl O atom interacts with the p orbital of an electron-rich alkene, and a C,C-biradical is formed [13, 14]. More recently a theoretical study of the Paterno`-Bu¨ chi reaction was written. This study showed that there are two conical intersection points located near the C C and C–O bonded biradical regions of the ground state. These two conical intersections support a mechanism by which the decay from the excited state is accompanied by a geometric rotation of the terminal group, in the case of C O attack, and by an orbital rotation at the oxygen center, in the case of C C attack. Furthermore, for C O attack, the triplet surface must cross the singlet to reach a diradicaloid minimum. For C C attack, the triplet biradical minimum is located at the same geometry as the conical intersection between the two singlet states, and the efficiency of the intersystem crossing will be determined by the nature of the spin-orbit coupling. Thus, for the triplet, the reaction path can be predicted by the most stable biradical rule [15]. A conformational analysis of the biradicals was also published [16]. The biradical intermediate in the reaction between benzophenone and electron-rich alkene has been determined by using laser flash photolysis. An absorption with lmax 535 nm has been observed [17, 18]. The formation of exciplex is used to explain the reaction behavior of simple alkene. However, evidence of monoelectron-transfer processes are reported for electron-rich alkenes [19].
` -BU ¨ CHI REACTION ON FURAN II. THE PATERNO DERIVATIVES A. Furan The first report on the photochemical reactivity of furan toward carbonyl compounds appeared in 1963. Schenck et al. [20] reported that the irradiation of benzophenone in furan gave the corresponding adduct in 94% yield (Scheme 3.3). The structure assignment was confirmed by Gagnaire and Payo-Subiza [21]. On the basis of the NMR analysis of both the products of the same reaction and the reaction between 2,5-dimethylfuran and benzophenone. Two years later, furan
84
1,2-CYCLOADDITION REACTION OF CARBONYL COMPOUNDS
Ph + Ph2CO
Ph
hv
O O
O
Scheme 3.3
and 2-methylfuran were found to react with propanal and benzaldehyde. NMR spectral data supported the formation of the same type of products (Scheme 3.4) [22]. H + C2H5CHO
hv
O H O
88%
O
H
H + C2H5CHO
O
Ph
hv
O
H3C
80%
O
O
+ PhCHO
C2H5
hv
O H3C
O
C2H5
C2H5 O
+ O
CH3
Scheme 3.4
The structure of the products was confirmed also by NOE analysis [23]. The yields were very high. In this case, the authors did not specify the exo or endo stereochemistry at C-6 on the dioxabicyclo[3.2.0]heptene skeleton. This problem was solved some years later assigning the exo configuration to this carbon [24]. When 2-methylfuran was used, a mixture of regioisomeric products was obtained, but the authors did not report the regioisomeric ratio. In contrast with this result, other authors reported a complete regioselectivity in the reaction between substituted furans and benzophenone: in these reactions, the coupling occurred on the most hindered side of the molecule (Scheme 3.5) [25, 26]. The Japanese group supposed that the reaction involved the formation of the biradical 6, due to the attack of the n,p* triplet oxygen on the site of higher free valence or higher electron density of the furan ring (Fig. 3.1). Afterward, the same group tested the reaction on a large group of aliphatic and aromatic aldehydes and ketones [27]. They found that ketones reacted, giving lower yields than the corresponding aldehydes; in particular acetone, butanone, and acetophenone
` -BU ¨ CHI REACTION ON FURAN DERIVATIVES THE PATERNO
Ph
85
Ph
hv O CH3 Ph2CO
O 98% O CH 3 Ph H3C Ph
CH3 hv O
O O
Ph2CO
98% Ph
O
hv CH2OH Ph CO 2
Ph
O 80% O CH OH 2
Scheme 3.5
Ph
H O O 6
Figure 3.1. Biradical intermediate in the Paterno`-Bu¨ chi reaction between furan and benzaldehyde.
gave yields in the range of 0.9–1.7%. Furthermore, the oxetane yields increased with the number of carbon atoms. With acetaldehyde, they obtained 15% yield, while cyclohexylcarbaldehyde gave 27% yield, and benzaldehyde 35%. The kinetics of the reaction is in agreement with a mechanism involving the formation of the biradical 6 following Scheme 3.6, where B is benzophenone, F is furan, (B-F)* is the biradical 6, and Ox is the oxetane [28]. Subsequently, more complex carbonyl compounds were used to give the corresponding
Scheme 3.6
86
1,2-CYCLOADDITION REACTION OF CARBONYL COMPOUNDS
adducts. n-Butyl glyoxylate gave the adduct with furan in 77.3% yield, while diethyl ketomalonate gave the corresponding product in 30% yield [29]. Good regioselectivity was observed using silyl and stannyl furan derivatives. The reaction in this case occurred on the less hindered side of the molecule (Scheme 3.7) [30]. On the contrary, 2-furylmethanol and the corresponding silyl ether gave low regioselectivity [31, 32]. Ph
H + PhCHO
O
hv Me3Si
SiMe3
O
O
O
2.5
O
+ PhCHO Si(i-Pr)3
:
O
>20
+ PhCHO O
SnBu3
O O
O
SnBu3
Si(i-Pr)3
1 Ph
H
O
+ O
H 2.5
+ BuO2CCHO
: Ph
hv Bu3Sn
O
+
H
H
Ph
H
O O
SiMe3
1
Ph
hv i-Pr3Si
O
+
H
H
Ph
H
SnBu3
:
1
H
CO2Bu
hv
H
O
O + Bu3Sn
O
O
H
> 20
:
CO2Bu
SnBu3
1
Scheme 3.7
The high exo stereoselectivity of the reaction has been extensively studied. The formation of the product occurs on a triplet 1,4-biradical, which must be converted into the singlet biradical to give the product. Three mechanisms operate for the interaction between singlet and triplet states of 1,n-biradicals: electron-nuclear hyperfine coupling (HFC), spin-lattice relaxation (SLR), and spin-orbit coupling (SOC). HFC is an important control factor for biradicals with long carbon chains between the radical centers. SOC plays a dominant role in biradicals with shorter distances between the radical centers, whereas SLR seems to contribute only marginally. SOC strongly depends on the geometry of the triplet biradicals; in particular, SOC decreases with increasing distance
` -BU ¨ CHI REACTION ON FURAN DERIVATIVES THE PATERNO
87
R O H
O 7
Scheme 3.8
between the two spin-bearing atoms. The best geometry for SOC requires that the axes of the p orbitals at the radical centers are perpendicular to each other. To explain the pronounced exo stereoselectivity, a secondary orbital effect can be postulated: an interaction between the rather flexible a-oxy radical center and the allyloxy ring localized radical in 7, likely plays a major role (Scheme 3.8) [33, 34]. When the reaction was carried out in benzene, new products were obtained. Ogata et al. [35] reported that two 2:1 adducts are the product of the reaction (Scheme 3.9). When 2-methylfuran was irradiated in the presence of benzophenone
Ph H H Ph
Ph + Ph2CO O
hv benzene
H
O
O
Ph H
H
27%
+ Ph2CO H3C
O
Ph O O
+
O
O
CH3
H
19%
O
HH
Ph + Ph
14%
+ Ph2CO O
CH3
Ph O
Ph H
O
CH3
3%
Ph H H Ph
Ph
H3C
Ph
O
CH3
hv benzene
Ph O
O H3C
O
CH3
10%
Scheme 3.9
O
18%
hv benzene
Ph H H Ph
Ph Ph
Ph
O
+ Ph
O
O
H H Ph
Ph
H
88
1,2-CYCLOADDITION REACTION OF CARBONYL COMPOUNDS
Ph H H Ph
Ph O
Ph O
H
O
R
8
Figure 3.2. Double cyloadduct in the reaction between furan and benzophenone.
the 1:1 adduct was obtained with two 2:1 adducts (Scheme 3.9). On the contrary, 2,5-dimethylfuran gave only one 2:1 adduct (Scheme 3.9); benzaldehyde showed minor selectivity, and this behavior was attributed to the higher triplet energy of benzaldehyde (71 kcal mol1) in comparison with that of benzophenone (68.7 kcal mol1). The more energetic excited benzaldehyde would not entirely discriminate between the two double bonds. The formation of the major 2:1 adduct in the reaction of Ogata et al. was immediately questioned by Leitich [36]. He considered that structure 8 was more acceptable (Fig. 3.2). Evanega and Whipple [37] made the reaction obtaining the 1:1 adduct, the adduct 8 in 29% yield, and the other 2:1 adduct reported in Scheme 3.9 in 18% yield. Finally, the structure of the adduct 8 was confirmed through X-ray analysis [38]. Furan reacts with chloral to give unexpectedly the corresponding 2-furyl carbinols [39]. Furthermore, 2-cyanofuran did not react, while 2-furfural diacetate and furfural ethylene acetal showed low reactivity. In particular, furfural diacetate reacted with benzophenone in benzene, giving the monoadduct with high regioselectivity (only the adduct on the most hindered side of the molecule was obtained) but in low yield (21%), and in the presence of significant amounts of diadducts (two diadducts were obtained in 21% and 18% yields, respectively). Furthermore, furfural ethylene acetal reacted with benzophenone in benzene showing high regioselectivity because the ketone attacks the furan derivative only on the side bearing the substituent, but in low yield (22%) and in the presence of diadducts in 28% and 15% yields [39]. The cycloaddition reaction can be performed on esters. In this case, the adducts can be obtained in a few cases. In most of the examples, they underwent a cycloreversion reaction to give the ring opening products (Scheme 3.10) [40]. More recently, this result has been questioned and a 95:5 mixture of stereoisomeric adducts was identified as the product [34]. Coupling products can be obtained carrying out the reaction between an amide and furan. Also in this case the cycloadduct cannot be isolated, but the subsequent decomposition products can be isolated (Scheme 3.11) [41]. Furan quenches the fluorescence of the substrate, while a small new emission at 500 nm appears. This evidence is in agreement with a mechanism involving a reaction in the excited singlet state via the formation of an exciplex.
` -BU ¨ CHI REACTION ON FURAN DERIVATIVES THE PATERNO
O
H OCH3
OCH3
Ph OCH3
hv
+
O
Ph
hv ∆
O
O
89
O
H
31%
CHO
13%
CHO O
O OCH3
hv
+ O
OCH3 36%
Scheme 3.10 O O
O
N
N O
hv
+
O
O OCHO H H OCHO N
+
O 41%
N O
49%
Scheme 3.11
The Paterno`-Bu¨ chi reaction on furan has been studied from a theoretical point of view [42]. The HOMO of furan has an energy of 0.32 eV, and the atomic coefficients of this orbital (Fig. 3.3) are in agreement with an attack of the carbonyl oxygen on the a carbon. The structures of the possible adducts deriving from the attack of benzaldehyde in the a position of furan are depicted in Figure 3.4. The exo isomer is more stable (0.5 kcal mol1) than the other isomer, in agreement with the experimental results. The reaction between 2-methylfuran and benzaldehyde gave only the photoadduct deriving from the attack on the less hindered side of the molecule (Scheme 3.12) [42]. The HOMO of 2-methylfuran showed the atomic
90
1,2-CYCLOADDITION REACTION OF CARBONYL COMPOUNDS
0.21 0.32 O 0.00
Figure 3.3. HOMO’s atomic coefficients in furan.
6 5
7
4
1
2 3 exo adduct endo adduct
Figure 3.4. Possible cycloadducts in the reaction between furan and benzaldehyde.
H Ph hv O
CH3
PhCHO
O H3C
O
Scheme 3.12
coefficients reported in Figure 3.5. These data are in agreement with an attack of the carbonyl oxygen on the a carbon. The structures of the possible adducts deriving from the attack of benzaldehyde in the a position of 2-methylfuran are depicted in the Figures 3.6. The formation of the exo isomers of both 1,2 and 4,5 adducts is favored. Furthermore, the 4,5-adduct is favored for 0.14 kcal mol1. This low energy difference does not allow us to explain the observed regioselectivity. To explain this behavior, the energy of the possible biradical intermediates was considered (Fig. 3.7). −0.19 0.25 0.28 −0.29 O CH3
Figure 3.5. HOMO’s atomic coefficients in 2-methylfuran.
` -BU ¨ CHI REACTION ON FURAN DERIVATIVES THE PATERNO
91
1,2-exo
1,2-endo
Figure 3.6. Possible cycloadducts in the reaction between 2-methylfuran and benzaldehyde. H .
. Ph
H .
O
O O
CH3
. Ph
H3C
O
Figure 3.7. Biradical intermediates in the reaction between 2-methylfuran and benzaldehyde.
The second biradical intermediate is favored for 1.18 kcal mol1, thus allowing us to explain the observed regioselectivity. The HOMO of 2-furylmethanol showed the atomic coefficients (Figure 3.8). These data are in agreement with an attack of the carbonyl oxygen on the a carbon. The structures of the possible adducts deriving from the attack of benzaldehyde in the a position of 2-furylmethanol are depicted in the Figure 3.9. The exo stereoisomer is favored for all the regioisomers. On the basis of these data, the attack on the most hindered side of the molecule should be favored for 2 kcal mol1. However, considering the results obtained studying the reactivity of 2-methylfuran, we considered the relative stability of the possible biradical intermediates (Fig. 3.10). The calculations of these biradicals showed that the first is more stable than the other for 0.8 kcal mol1. This difference could account for the preferential formation of the product deriving from the attack on the most hindered side of the molecule. Furthermore, it can account for the formation of two regioisomers. In conclusion, the regiochemical behavior (the attack of the oxygen on an a-carbon or on a b-carbon of the furan ring) of the Paterno`-Bu¨ chi reaction on furan, 2-methylfuran, and 2-furylmethanol can be explained considering the −0.19 0.23 0.28 −0.29 O CH OH 2
Figure 3.8. HOMO’s atomic coefficients in 2-furylmethanol.
92
1,2-CYCLOADDITION REACTION OF CARBONYL COMPOUNDS
1,2-endo
1,2-exo
Figure 3.9. Possible cycloadducts in the reaction between 2-furylmethanol and benzaldehyde. Ph
H
H
O O CH2OH HOH2C
Ph O
O
Figure 3.10. Biradical intermediates in the reaction between 2-furylmethanol and benzaldehyde.
atomic coefficients of the HOMOs. Furthermore, the stereochemical behavior can be explained, on the basis of the Scharf’s hypothesis, considering the formation of the most stable stereoisomer. The origin of this behavior can be found in the spin control formulated by Griesbeck. Finally, the regiochemical behavior on monosubstituted furan can be explained on the basis of the relative stability of the possible biradical intermediates, where the most stable one is favored.
B. Benzofuran Schenck and co-workers [43] reported also the reaction of some aromatic carbonyl compounds (benzophenone, benzaldehyde) with benzofuran (Scheme 3.13). They showed that when high triplet energy compounds were used, dimers of Ph +
Ph2CO
O
hv O
O
75%
Scheme 3.13
Ph
` -BU ¨ CHI REACTION ON FURAN DERIVATIVES THE PATERNO
93
benzofuran were obtained, while oxetanes were the products of the reaction when low triplet energy carbonyls were used. As in the case of furan, they obtained only one product, showing that the reaction has a high regioselectivity. Reinvestigation of the reaction of benzofuran with acetophenone or propiophenone showed that, also in this case, oxetanes were obtained [44].
C.
2,3-Dihydrofuran
The irradiation of 2,3-dihydrofuran with benzophenone in benzene gave adduct 9 (Scheme 3.14). It should be noted that in this case a completely different regioselectivity was obtained in the coupling reaction [45]. The same behavior was observed irradiating 2,3-dihydrofuran with aliphatic aldehydes and ketones. By using acetone, the adducts were obtained in 52% yield in a 200:1 isomeric ratio (Scheme 3.15) [46]. When acetaldehyde was used, the adduct was obtained in 63% yield as a mixture of stereoisomers. When benzaldehyde was used as carbonyl compounds, the adducts were obtained with an overall yield of 98% as a > 98:2 regioisomeric mixture. The major isomer is 88:12 endo/exo mixture. The reaction showed a good regioselectivity and stereoselectivity (Scheme 3.16) [46–48]. This stereoselectivity is partially lost when benzaldehyde reacts with 2methyl-2,3-dihydrofuran [47]. Benzaldehyde reacts in its triplet state. This way, a triplet biradical is formed as an intermediate. For the formation of the products, intersystem crossing into O + Ph2CO O
Ph
hv benzene
O
Ph 9
Scheme 3.14 O hv
+ O
O
O
+ O
O 200
:
1 H
H H + O
O
O
O hv
H
+ O
H H 4 :
Scheme 3.15
O 3
H
94
1,2-CYCLOADDITION REACTION OF CARBONYL COMPOUNDS
H
H O
PhCHO hv 98%
O
O Ph
O
+
88
Ph
O
H :
H
12
H
H
O
O O
PhCHO CH3 hv 68%
O
Ph + 65
Ph
O
CH3 :
CH3
35
Scheme 3.16
the singlet manifold is necessary. The most important factor influencing an intersystem crossing for flexibile triplet biradicals is spin-orbit coupling. The angle between p orbitals at the radical centers is approximately 90 for maximun spin orbit coupling. For the pronounced endo selectivity in the reaction between aromatic aldehydes and 2,3-dihydrofuran, we can consider the two biradical conformers 10 and 11 to be responsible, with the alkyloxy substitutent localized in a pseudoequatorial position and 10 being more populated because of fewer steric interactions (Scheme 3.17). When a methyl group is present, the increasing gauche endo
exo
Ph
O
O
H H
H
O 10 Ph
O 11
O H
H
H CH3
O Ph
O 12
O 13
exo
endo
Scheme 3.17
CH3
Ph
` -BU ¨ CHI REACTION ON FURAN DERIVATIVES THE PATERNO
−0.36 −0.29
95
0.10 0.09 O 0.32
Figure 3.11. HOMO’s atomic coefficients in 2,3-dihydrofuran.
4 3
2
5
1
6
endo -adduct
exo-adduct
Figure 3.12. Possible cycloadducts in the reaction between 2,3-dihydrofuran and benzaldehyde.
interactions with the b-alkyloxy substituent lead to a certain concentration of 12 and 13, again with 12 being preferred because of fewer steric interactions. The a- and b-Naphthaldehydes, on the contrary, gave high exo selectivity. To understand this behavior we have to consider that they gave cycloadducts also in the presence of triplet quenchers, while the authors observed fluorescence quenching in the presence of dihydrofuran; in this case, singlet excited states are responsible for the high exo selectivity [33, 49]. The same theoretical approach was used to explain the photochemical behavior of 2,3-dihydrofuran. The HOMO of 2,3-dihydrofuran showed at 0.32 eV is reported in Figure 3.11. The atomic coefficients of the HOMO are in agreement with an attack of the LUMO (the carbonyl oxygen) on the b-carbon. On the basis of this result, the thermodynamic stability of the possible adducts was tested. The structures of these compounds are reported in Figure 3.12. The endo isomer is more stable for 2 kcal mol1 than the other isomer, in agreement with experimental results. When 2,3-dihydrofuran derivatives react with a,b-unsaturated carbonyl compounds, 2þ2 cycloaddition between the olefins occurs (Scheme 3.18) [50]. O
H
O H H H
O hv
+
O
O O
O
H
H
H
Scheme 3.18
O
H
96
1,2-CYCLOADDITION REACTION OF CARBONYL COMPOUNDS
D. Synthetic Applications Oxetanes can be converted into the corresponding 3-furylcarbinol through reaction with TsOH (Scheme 3.19) [29]. The formation of 14 is in agreement with H H
H CO2C4H9 O
TsOH O
O
OH CO2C4H9 O+ H
CO2C4H9 O
73%
14
Scheme 3.19
the high negative entropy of the activation found (Sz ¼ 141.6 J K1) [51]. If the irradiation was performed in the presence of an acid, 3-furylcarbinol can be obtained in a one-step procedure in better yields [52]. This procedure has been used in the synthesis of perillaketone, a naturally occurring 3-substituted furan [52]. Irradiation of furan with 4-methyl-pentanal in the presence of MsOH gave a mixture of 15 (18%) and 16 (5%). Oxidation of 15 with Collins reagent gave perillaketone (Scheme 3.20). It is noteworthy that this is the first report on a probable Norrish type II on the carbonyl compound. In fact, this type of reaction can be responsible for the formation of 16. The excited aldehyde can undergo 1,5-hydrogen shift to give acetaldehyde, and this aldehyde, through the cycloaddition reaction, gives the 3-furylcarbinol 16. OH + O
CHO
hv MsOH
OH
+ O
15 (18%)
O
16 (5%)
Collins O
O
66%
Scheme 3.20
On the contrary, Lewis acids catalyzed a different behavior. Treatment with BF3 Et2O gave only 3-substituted furan in THF and 89% of 2-substituted furan in acetonitrile (Scheme 3.21) [51]. This behavior is in agreement with the formation of a carbocation 17, which can be stabilized by splitting off a proton to
` -BU ¨ CHI REACTION ON FURAN DERIVATIVES THE PATERNO
97
OH H CO2C4H9
CO2C4H9 +
BF3.Et2O
O
O
O
CO2C4H9
O
OH H
H
CO2C4H9
CO2C4H9 + OA
+ O
O
+
OA
CO2C4H9
O
17
OA
Scheme 3.21
form 3-substituted furan or can undergo a 1,2-rearrangement to a more stable carbocation, which splits off a proton to form 2-substitued furan (Scheme 3.21). The oxetane derivatives can also be treated with KMnO4, and the resulting cis diol was treated with acetone in the presence of an acid. This catalysis induces a ring-opening reaction, giving two products (Scheme 3.22) [53]. The major product was obtained through a spontaneous epimerisation of intermediate 18 in these reaction conditions. This product was 3-deoxy-1,2-O-isopropylidene-b-DL-streptose. The same epimerisation reaction occurs on the trans diol obtained through treatment of the oxetane with mCPBA (Scheme 3.23) [53]. CH3
H
1) KMnO4
O O
2) Acetone, H +
H
CH3
HO H
CH3
HO H OHC
O HO
O
HO H
H CH3
HO H
HO
O
OHC
OH CHO
CH3
HO H
OH OH
O
O O O O
O 15%
OHC
OH OH
H3C OHC
OHC O
O H3C
O OH OH
O
H3C
O 33%
18
Scheme 3.22
98
1,2-CYCLOADDITION REACTION OF CARBONYL COMPOUNDS
CO2Bu
H O + H
Bu
O
O
hv
O O
O CH2OAc
H
H
LiAlH4 Ac2O
CH2OAc
HO H
MCPBA O O
O m-ClC 6H4CO2
H
O
1) MeO−
O
H
OMe
2) IR120 O H
O
OH
OMe
Scheme 3.23
The possible chemical modifications on the cycloadduct deriving from the reaction between an aldehyde and a furan was extensively studied by Schreiber et al. [54], and some results are reported in Scheme 3.24. Hydrolytic ring opening, reductions, hetero Diels-Alder, the reaction with mCPBA, and hydroboration-oxidation were the object of this work. The reaction with mCPBA was used by Schreiber and co-workers in the synthesis of asteltoxin 19, a potent inhibitor of E. coli BF1-ATPase activity used as a fluorescent probe for mitocondrial F1- and bacterial BF1-ATPase (Fig. 3.13) [55]. The synthetic sequence implies the photochemical coupling of 3,4-dimethylfuran with a functionalized aldehyde to give the corresponding adduct in 63% yield. The subsequent reaction with MCPBA gave the protected trans diol that was converted into 20 through acid hydrolysis. Then the aldehyde was converted into the corresponding hydrazone, and this substrate was treated with EtMgBr to give 21 with complete stereochemical control obtained through chelation. The subsequent conversion of the benzyl ether into a seleno derivative and the elimination of the selenoxide gave 22. Compound 22 could be treated with ozone to give the corresponding aldehyde, which was then converted into asteltoxin (Scheme 3.25) [56]. In fact, the aldehydic product could be alkylated with a vinyl anion, and the subsequent double [2,3] sigmatropic rearrangement at room temperature furnished 23 as a 3:1 mixture of epimers. Camphorsulfonic acid induced the transposition of the substrate into a bis(tetrahydrofuran) derivative. Pummerer
` -BU ¨ CHI REACTION ON FURAN DERIVATIVES THE PATERNO
Scheme 3.24
OH
OH
O
O
O
H
O 19 OCH3
Figure 3.13. Asteltoxin.
99
100
1,2-CYCLOADDITION REACTION OF CARBONYL COMPOUNDS
OBz
OBz HO
O MCPBA
hv
+ BzO
CHO
O
O
HO
OBz
O 20
BzO
HO
OBz
O
2) Acetone, CSA
o-NO2C6H4Se
O O
H
CHNNMe2 1) EtMgBr
HO
HO
O
HO Me2NNH2
CHO
HCl HO
O
m-ClC 6H4CO2
H
O
1) Li, NH3 SeCN
O H
O NO2
2)
O H
HO
O
H2O2 O
O H 22
21 OHC HO
O
1) O3 2) Me2S
O
O H
Scheme 3.25
rearrangement and hydrolysis gave aldehyde 24. Aldol condensation gave 25, and elimination gave asteltoxin (Scheme 3.26) [57]. The same research group reported a formal synthesis of avenaciolide, an antifungal metabolite (Scheme 3.27) [58]. In this case, the oxetane (obtained in multigram quantities in high yields and with complete stereochemical control) was treated with hydrogen to give the saturated compound. The key step in this synthetic procedure is a reaction with ozone followed by a basecatalyzed epimerization with potassium carbonate and cyclization in acidic medium. The reaction of tributylstannylfuran with butyl glyoxylate [30] was used in the synthesis of a ginkgolide B-kadsurenone hybrid of two inhibitors of a platelet-activating factor (Scheme 3.28). In the obtained oxetane, the stannyl substituent was used to give a coupling Stille reaction; the subsequent hydrolysis gave the corresponding carbonyl derivative, which was reduced with NaBH4 in the presence of CeCl3: this reaction allowed for the selective reduction of the aryl
` -BU ¨ CHI REACTION ON FURAN DERIVATIVES THE PATERNO
HO
OHC HO
SOPh
HO
O
O
BuLi O
O
PhSO
H
O
101
CSA
O H 23
OH
OH
O
O
1) CF3CO2COCH3, lutidine, Ac 2O
H
2) HgCl2, CaCO3 SOPh
O O OH
OH
O
O
OMe LDA
H
CHO 24
OH
OH
O
O
1) TsCl OH
H
O O
19 2) DMAP, Et 3N
25 OMe
Scheme 3.26
ketone in the presence of the aldehyde. The use of distannoxane transesterification catalyst gave a 1:1 mixture of the hybrid. Further elaborations of the stannyl substituents in the adduct can be obtained via reaction with RCOCl in the presence of Pd(0) to give the corresponding ketone, or via reaction with BuLi and reaction of the corresponding anion with PhCHO to give the corresponding alcohol [59]. Furthermore, the cycloadduct obtained from the reaction between furan and an aldehyde can be treated with an excess of Schlosser’s base (BuLi, t-BuOK) to give the corresponding
102
1,2-CYCLOADDITION REACTION OF CARBONYL COMPOUNDS
C8H17
H +
C8H17
H
O
hv O
O 1) HCl 96% H 2) H2C=CHMgBr 80%
H2
O
O
C8H17
H
Rh, Al 2O3
H
O
97% H
HO
C8H17 OH
H H
HO
H OH
1) Acetone, TsOH, 85%
K2CO3
H
HO
O
H MCPBA
O H
OMe
HCl
O
C8H17 O
MeO
H MeOH
H OH H
BF3.Et2O
O
C8H17 O
O
O3 Me2S
O H
C8H17
C8H17
OHC
2) PCC, 91%
OH
O O
H
O O H
OHC
OH
OHC
H
OH
H
C8H17 O
80'%
C8H17
O
O O H
O
C8H17
O
31%
Scheme 3.27
anion, which can react with carbonyl compounds or alkyl halides (Scheme 3.29) [59]. A possible further application of the Paterno`-Bu¨ chi reaction between carbonyl compounds and furan could be related to the use of the oxetane ring. The most important target in this field was oxetanocin (26), a nucleoside isolated from Bacillus megaterium NK 84-0218 showing anti-HIV activity (Fig. 3.14) [60, 61]. The treatment of the oxetane 27 with N-iodosuccinimide in the presence of methallyl alcohol gave the corresponding iodoacetals 28 (Scheme 3.30) [62]. The subsequent treatment of 28 with iodonium di-symcollidine perchlorate (IDCP) [63] gave 29 in low yields, as a relatively unstable mixture of diastereoisomers. Alternatively, treatment of 30 with dimethyl dioxirane gave the corresponding epoxide, and treatment with methallyl alcohol gave the hydroxy acetal 31. The treatment of 31 with IDCP gave 32 in moderate yields. Oxetanocin was obtained by carrying out the reaction between 2-methylfuran and benzoyloxyacetaldehyde. The corresponding adduct was treated with ozone, and the product was reduced with NaBH4. The obtained alcohols were protected.
` -BU ¨ CHI REACTION ON FURAN DERIVATIVES THE PATERNO
103 Br
CO2Bu
H
O
SnBu3
hv
+ BuO2CCHO
35%
O O
O Bu3Sn
Pd(PPh3)4, THF 55% OH H CO2Bu
H
H
1) HCl
MeO OMe
OMe
HO SCNBu2SnOSnBu2OH Toluene, 50°
OH
O
2) NaBH4, CeCl3 90%
MeO
O
CO2Bu
H
OMe OMe
O
MeO
O O
MeO
H
+
H
68% HO
O O
H O H
MeO
OMe
Scheme 3.28
Product 33 was treated with N-benzoyl-disilyladenine and SnCl4 to give 26 (Scheme 3.31) [64].
E. Asymmetric Reactions The reaction of glyoxylates with furan can also be performed using chiral glyoxylate. In particular, the use of R-(-)-menthol, chiral 2-octanol, and chiral 2,2dimethyl-3-butanol as chiral auxiliaries gave the corresponding oxetanes in high yields. These compounds can be converted into the corresponding
104
1,2-CYCLOADDITION REACTION OF CARBONYL COMPOUNDS
R
H
O O
BuLi, t-BuOK, THF
O
t-Bu
t-BuCHO
O
H
OH
R
BuLi, t-BuOK, THF O O
H
63−72%
H
R
H
R
H
O
MeI
O
H
H 41% R
H
R
H
BuLi, t-BuOK, THF O O
O Me3Sn
Me3SnCl
H
O
H
50−65%
Scheme 3.29
3-substituted furans. These furans showed low enantiomeric excess (Scheme 3.32) [65]. On the basis of the experimental data, the configuration of the oxetane was 1R, 5S, 6S. The low optical purity was explained considering that two conformers of the glyoxylate can approach furan (Fig. 3.15). The use of chiral phenylglyoxylate gave better results. The use of chiral alcohols gave diastereoisomeric excess in the range of 4–80% (Scheme 3.33) [66– 68]. The authors observed also an important variability of the diastereoisomeric excess in function of the temperature, with the presence of an inversion temperature. These results were explained assuming that the diastereoselection is produced on two levels: (1) the preferred formation of the diastereoisomeric 1,4biradical intermediate 34 and (2) the preferred retrocleavage of the energetically NH2 N
N
N
N HOH2C
O CH2OH 26
Figure 3.14. Oxetanocin.
` -BU ¨ CHI REACTION ON FURAN DERIVATIVES THE PATERNO
H
H
O
O
O
O
NIS
O
I
OCH3 O
O
IDCP
105
O H
Ph
27 H
Ph
28 H
H
O
O
O
O
O
O H
PhCO2H2C
H
I
29
O O
O
O PhCO2H2C
I
H
Ph
PhCO2H2C
I
30
H
OH
31
OAc O
O
1) Ac 2O
O
2) IDCP PhCO H C 2 2
OAc 32
Scheme 3.30
unfavored diastereoisomeric intermediate 35 to the starting materials (Fig. 3.16) [69]. The diastereoisomeric excess in the high-temperature region (T > Tinv) is dominantly controlled by steric effects of the chiral auxiliaries, whereas in the low-temperature region (T < Tinv), the nature of the olefin has a dominating influence. When the reaction is carried out on 2-methylfuran, a 2:1 regioisomeric H O
CH3
PhCO2CH2CHO N(TMS)2
45−50%
N
N OAc
N
N
O
OCOPh CH2OAc H
PhCO2H2C
CH3
H
PhCO2H2C
H
O
O
hv
SnCl4
33
Scheme 3.31
26
1) O3 2) Me2S 3) NaBH4 4) Ac 2O, Py
106
1,2-CYCLOADDITION REACTION OF CARBONYL COMPOUNDS
O H
O
O H
+
O
O
hv O
O
O
O
H+
O
OH O
Scheme 3.32 L O
M
S M
O
S H
H
O
O
L O
O S-trans
S-cis
Figure 3.15. Possible conformers of glyoxylate esters. O Ph
O
R*
+
O
hv
R*O2C
O
O
+
O
Ph
Ph
O
O R*O2C
O O
O
Ph
H H
CO2R*
H H major
Scheme 3.33
CO2R*
O
Ph
` -BU ¨ CHI REACTION ON FURAN DERIVATIVES THE PATERNO
O
O R*O2C
O
O Ph
Ph 34
107
CO2R*
35
Figure 3.16. Biradical intermediates in the reaction between furan and phenylglyoxylates. O Ph + CH3
O
hv
O O Ph
O
O Ph
O
Ph
Ph
O
O
Ph
O
+ CH3
O
O 2 de 96%
H3C :
1 de 96%
Scheme 3.34
mixture was obtained with a very high diastereoisomeric excess (Scheme 3.34) [70]. The reactivity of some chiral phenylglyoxylates was studied [71]. Three phenylglyoxylate esters were used (Fig. 3.17). All the reactions gave, in good yields, the corresponding oxetanes (Scheme 3.35). Considering the stereochemical behavior of the reaction, while the reaction with 8-phenylmenthol glyoxylate gave a high diastereoisomeric excess, the reaction with the glyoxylate ester of (S)-1-methyl-1-propanol gave only 15% de and the reaction with the glyoxylate ester of (S)-2-methyl-1-butanol resulted in no diastereoselectivity. In the reaction of the first glyoxylate ester with furan, we could obtain the observed diastereoisomer (10 R,1R,5S,6S) (Fig. 3.18A) and the other one (10 R,1S,5R,6R). These two stereoisomers showed a different energy for 0.07 kcal mol1, with the most stable one being the (10 R,1R,5S,6S) isomer. In the reaction of the
108
1,2-CYCLOADDITION REACTION OF CARBONYL COMPOUNDS
O
O
O
O O
O
O O O
Figure 3.17. Phenylglyoxylate [71]. O O O
Ph
O hv
O
O
O
H
O
O O O
hv
Ph
O O
O
O
H
O
O
O hv
Ph
O
O
O
O O
Ph
H
O
Scheme 3.35
second ester, we could obtain the observed diastereoisomers (10 S,1S,5R,6R) (Fig. 3.18B) and (10 S,1R,5S,6S) (Fig. 3.18C). These two stereoisomers showed a different energy for 0.14 kcal mol1, with the most stable one being the (10 S,1S,5R,6R) isomer. In the reaction of the third ester with furan, we could obtain the observed diastereoisomer (10 R,20 S,50 R,1R,5S,6S) (Fig. 3.18D) and
` -BU ¨ CHI REACTION ON FURAN DERIVATIVES THE PATERNO
A
109
B
C D
Figure 3.18. Possible cycloadducts in the reaction between furan (or 2-methylfuran) and chiral phenyl glyoxylates.
the other one (10 R,20 S,50 R1S,5R,6R). We calculated that these two stereoisomers showed a different energy for 3.05 kcal mol1, with the most stable one being the (10 R,20 S,50 R,1R,5S,6S) isomer. This high difference in the energy of the possible diastereoisomers could explain the observed diastereoisomeric excess; furthermore, the calculated differences in the energy of the possible diastereoisomers that can be obtained in the reaction of the other esters can explain the low diastereoisomeric excess observed when the first was used as substrate. However, the lack of diastereoselectivity when the second one was used as substrate
110
1,2-CYCLOADDITION REACTION OF CARBONYL COMPOUNDS
O
O Ph
O
Ph
O H
O O
O
O
Ph
Ph
H O
O O
O
H
O O
O O
H
O
O Ph
O
Ph
Ph H
O O
O O
O
H
Ph
Figure 3.19. Biradical intermediates in the reaction between chiral phenylglyoxylates and furan.
in the same reaction cannot be explained by these results, considering the differences in the energy of the possible diastereoismers are higher than those obtained using the first ester as substrate. The best results can be obtained considering the energy of the triplet biradical intermediates (Fig. 3.19). Calculations on these biradical intermediates showed that the first (the precursor of the observed product) was more stable than the other by 0.73 kcal mol1. Furthermore, the first and the second possible biradical intermediate in the reaction of the ester of (S)-2-methyl-1-butanol and differed by only 0.02 kcal mol1, in agreement with the observed no stereoselectivity of the reaction. Finally, the first biradical intermediate in the reaction of 8-phenylmenthol ester proved to be more stable than the other one by 21.9 kcal mol1. This result is also in agreement with the observed high diastereoisomeric excess. Isatine derivatives gave the corresponding cycloadducts with high stereoselectivity when irradiated in the presence of furan and benzofuran [72]. The reaction of furan with acyl cyanides yields the corresponding oxetanes, but both diastereoisomeric endo- and exo-oxetanes are formed (Scheme 3.36). When chiral acyl cyanides are used, low asymmetric induction is observed [73]. Furan also reacts with chiral ketones. In this case, an a-cleavage reaction before the 2þ2 cycloaddition modifies the expected products (Scheme 3.37). When ()menthone was used as a substrate, a chiral product was obtained as a 2:1 diastereoisomeric mixture; the most abundant product has the (1R, 3R) configuration [74]. When the reaction was performed on carbohydrate 36, a complex reaction mixture was obtained (Scheme 3.38) [74, 75].
` -BU ¨ CHI REACTION ON FURAN DERIVATIVES THE PATERNO
OAc
OAc NC
Ph
OAc CN
+ Ph
O
O
+
−55° 71%
O
CN
Ph
O
hv
O
O 6.2 : de 5%
111
1 de 13%
Scheme 3.36
O CHO hv AcO
AcO
O
O
O
HO
O H+ AcO
AcO
O
hv
H+ CHO
O
O O
OH
O
Scheme 3.37
Attempts to obtain stereoselective Paterno`-Bu¨ chi reactions were performed carrying out the reaction between 3,4-dimethylfuran and R-isopropylidene diastereoisomer. The coupling products were obtained with an overall yield of 35% as a 1.2:1 mixture of diastereoisomers. Furthermore, the compound 37 was obtained with 54% ee (Scheme 3.39) [76, 77]. This behavior suggests the operation of a mechanism that is insensitive to the substitution pattern of chiral aldehydes. Reaction between an excited aldehyde (singlet or triplet state) and furan
112
1,2-CYCLOADDITION REACTION OF CARBONYL COMPOUNDS
O
O
O O
O hv
O
O
O O
O
O
O
O
O
O
O O
O
O O 9.1%
O 36
16%
O
O
O
O O
O
O O O
O
O O
O O
55.3%
19.6%
Scheme 3.38
O
H O + OHC O
O
hv
O O
H
O
H
O
O O
+ O
H
37
Scheme 3.39
proceeds with initial carbon-oxygen bond formation to produce either of the two biradical species. The stereocenter adjacent to the carbonyl is now in a 1,4-relationship to the newly formed stereocenter at the acetal carbon and is expected to exert little influence as a stereocontrol device [76]. The extensive racemization observed probably reflects the photolability of the aldehydes toward racemization under the conditions of the reaction [77]. Nevertheless, compound 37 can be used in a chiral synthesis of the bicyclic part of asteltoxin, confirming the assigned absolute configuration [77]. In 1990, Griesbeck and Stadtmu¨ ller [46] found that the reaction of benzaldehyde with homoallylic alcohols did not show diastereoselectivity. Ten years later Adam and co-workers showed that allylic alcohols reacted with benzophenone to give the corresponding adducts with high regioselectivity and diastereoselectivity (Scheme 3.40) [78–80].
` -BU ¨ CHI REACTION ON FURAN DERIVATIVES THE PATERNO
OH
OH
OH
O
hv
O
+
Ph Ph
Ph2CO
90
Ph Ph
:
10
OH
OH Bu-t
hv Ph2CO
113
O
OH
Bu-t
O +
Ph Ph > 95
Bu-t
Ph Ph
:
5
Scheme 3.40
The diastereoselectivity dropped drastically in presence of protic methanol and totally disappeared for the corresponding silyl ethers. These data are in agreement with the presence of a hydroxy directing effect in the Paterno`-Bu¨ chi reaction. Threo stereoisomer can be favored through the formation of an hydrogen bond between triplet excited benzophenone and the substrate in the exciplex, while the formation of the erythro stereoisomer would be less favored due to allylic strain (Scheme 3.41). The formation of hydrogen bond to direct the Paterno`-Bu¨ chi reaction has been considered by other researchers. Diastereoselective cycloaddition has Ph2C O H HO R
H H OH H
Ph2C O H HO H
Ph Ph
O
R
H
H OH R
threo
R
HH R OH HH R
R O Ph2C O H
R
HH O Ph2C O H
erythro
Scheme 3.41
Ph Ph
O
H OH
114
1,2-CYCLOADDITION REACTION OF CARBONYL COMPOUNDS
been obtained using chiral enamide [81, 82], or in the reaction of allylic alcohols with naphthalene rings [83]. When unsymmetrical carbonyl partners, such as acetophenone or benzaldehyde, were used, high diastereoselectivity was observed to give the corresponding cis isomer. The regioselectivity was high with acetophenone but lower with benzaldehyde [79]. Cis diastereoselectivity can be explained by using the Griesbeck rule on the possible triplet biradicals formed in the reaction. Steric interactions are minimized when the biradical assumes the optimal conformation, and this conformation accounts for the formation of the observed stereoisomer [84]. When chiral allylic alcohols were used as substrates in the reaction, cis diastereoisomers were formed. Furthermore, also in this case, a pronounced threo diastereoselectivity was observed, in agreement with a less pronounced hydroxy-directing effect when acetophenone and benzaldehyde were used [79, 84]. Chiral allyl ether gave the corresponding adduct with high diastereoselectivity [85]. The reaction of allylic alcohols with carbonyl compounds was tested on a particular type of allylic alcohol, such as 2-furylmethanol derivatives. While the reaction of 2-furylmethanol with benzophenone showed low regioselectivity, the presence of larger substituents on the carbon bearing the alcoholic function allows a high regioselectivity (Scheme 3.42) [86]. Furthermore, when 2-furylethanol (38) was used as substrate, a 1:1 mixture of stereoisomers was obtained; Ph
O
CH2OH
+ Ph2CO
hv
O O
+
:
Ph Ph O
+ Ph2CO
hv
O O
OH 38
OH
CH3 1:1 diasteroisomeric mixture Ph Ph Ph + Ph2CO
O OH 39
O O
CH2OH 3
CH3
Ph
Ph
Ph
hv
O O
OH Ph
one diastereoisomer
Scheme 3.42
1
CH2OH
` -BU ¨ CHI REACTION ON FURAN DERIVATIVES THE PATERNO
115
whereas when 1-(2-furyl)-benzylic alcohol (39) was the substrate, only one diastereoisomer was obtained (Scheme 3.42) [86]. NOE experiments are in agreement with a (1RS, 10 RS, 5RS) configuration. The high diastereoselectivity observed was confirmed using optically active 39. The regioselectivity of the reaction was explained assuming that the reaction involves the formation of an exciplex with the following coupling to a zwitterionic intermediate. The polar nature of the intermediate is in agreement with the observed r value in a Hammett free energy correlation [86]. When 5-methyl-2-furyl derivatives were used as substrates, a different regioselectivity was observed. Compound 40 gave a 1:1 mixture of regioisomers, when irradiated in the presence of benzophenone, and a single regioisomer in the presence of benzaldehyde (Scheme 3.43) [87]. In agreement with the results obtained with 2-furyl derivatives, the products deriving from the attack on the side bearing the alcoholic function were obtained as a single diastereoisomer, while those deriving from the attack on the side bearing the methyl group were obtained as a mixture of diastereoisomers. Also in this case, the regioselectivity of the reaction can be explained on the basis of the different stability of the possible zwitterionic intermediates [87]. Ph Ph CH3
O
+ Ph2CO
hv
O H3C
O
OH
Ph O OH
+ PhCHO
hv
Ph
O H3C
O OH
Ph
Ph H3C
+ OH
Ph
40
Ph
Ph
Ph
Ph
O H3C
O OH
40
Scheme 3.43
The reaction of 2-furylmethanol derivatives with aliphatic aldehydes and ketones gave the corresponding adducts with high regioselectivity but no diastereoselectivity (Scheme 3.44) [88]. The observed diastereoselectivity in the reaction with aromatic carbonyl compounds clearly shows that it increases in relation to the nature of the substituents on the carbon bearing the alcoholic function, as described by Adam. However, while Adam considers the allylic strain with a methyl group as the driving force for the diastereoselectivity; in this case, the methyl group is not present. Therefore, allylic strain cannot be used to explain diastereoselectivity.
116
1,2-CYCLOADDITION REACTION OF CARBONYL COMPOUNDS
H CH3 Ph + CH3CHO
O
hv
O O
OH
OH Ph
Scheme 3.44
We supposed, on the basis of theoretical calculations, that 2-furylmethanols showed a preferential conformation able to induce, through the formation of a hydrogen bond between the alcoholic function and the carbonyl compound, the high diastereoselectivity observed (Scheme 3.45) [88]. The lack of diastereoselectivity in the case of aliphatic carbonyl compounds represents a problem. The results cannot be explained on the basis of 1,3-allylic strain as reported by Adam. In fact, the same ‘‘allylic’’ substrates were used giving high regioselectivity with aromatic carbonyl compounds. Furthermore, aliphatic and aromatic ketones could give the same hydrogen bond interaction with the hydroxy group in the furan derivatives. R' R'
O
pro-S
H O H
O R R
Scheme 3.45
` -BU ¨ CHI REACTION ON III. THE PATERNO PENTAATOMIC HETEROCYCLES DIFFERENT FROM FURAN A. Thiophene The reactivity of pentatomic aromatic heterocycles that are not furan toward carbonyl compounds to give the corresponding oxetanes was the object of other review articles [89]. These compounds show lower reactivity than furan. The reason for this behavior is not clear. It could be related to the different aromaticity of these compounds in comparison with that of furan or, as reported below, to the quenching properties of the heterocycles.
` -BU ¨ CHI REACTION ON PENTAATOMIC HETEROCYCLES THE PATERNO
Ph
Ph
Ph
Ph S
hv Ph2CO BF3
117
OH
O + S
S 10%
90%
Scheme 3.46
Thiophene does not react with benzophenone. It reacts only when irradiated in the presence of BF3 (Scheme 3.46) [90]. In this reaction, BF3 is able to catalyze the ring opening of the oxetane. Benzophenone BF3 complex, excited by light, leads to an exciplex whose excitation energy is lower than the lowest triplet energy level of thiophene, which under the circumstances cannot act as a quencher. On the contrary, 2,5-dimethylthiophene reacts with benzophenone at 10 to give the corresponding cycloadduct with high regioselectivity in 62% yield (Scheme 3.47) [26, 91]. Ph Ph
S
hv Ph2CO
O S
Scheme 3.47
The reaction product can be obtained also by using 1-naphthaldehyde (50%), 2-, 3-, and 4-benzoylpyridine (62%, 58%, and 60%, respectively), and 2-benzoylthiophene (50%), while 2-naphthaldehyde, benzaldehyde, and acetophenone do not react [92]. 2,3-Dimethylthiophene also gave the corresponding oxetane when irradiated in the presence of benzophenone (60%) [93]. On the contrary, 2,3-dimethyl- and 2,3,5-trimethylthiophene do not react.
B. Pyrrole Pyrrole, like thiophene, does not react with benzophenone to give the corresponding oxetane. However, pyrrole reacts with aliphatic aldehydes and ketones to the corresponding 3-pyrryl carbinols. The alcohols derive from the cleavage of the corresponding oxetanes (Scheme 3.48) [94]. The yields increase when N-methylpyrrole is used as substrate, while the reactivity is depressed in the presence of substituents on the pyrrole ring. Pyrrole can give the corresponding oxetane when irradiated in the presence of benzophenone only when an electron-attracting group, such as benzoyl, is bound
118
1,2-CYCLOADDITION REACTION OF CARBONYL COMPOUNDS
H3C
CH3 OH
hv N H
CH3COCH3 Vycor
6%
N H H3C
CH3 OH
hv N CH3
CH3COCH3 Vycor
92%
N CH3
H3C
CH3 OH
hv H3C
N CH3
CH3 CH3COCH3 Vycor
H3C
CH3 N CH3
56%
Scheme 3.48
to the nitrogen atom (Scheme 3.49) [95, 96]. When N-phenylpyrrole was used as substrate, the corresponding 2-pyrryl carbinol was isolated [95].
HH Ph hv N
Ph2CO
Ph
O
Ph H
hv N Ph
Ph Ph
N Ph
12%
N H COPh
COPh
Ph2CO
Ph
O
OH
Scheme 3.49
C. Selenophene Selenophene does not react with benzophenone [26]. On the contrary 2-methylselenophene gives the corresponding cycloadduct. Also in this case the reaction occurs on the most hindered side of the molecule (Scheme 3.50) [97].
` -BU ¨ CHI REACTION ON PENTAATOMIC HETEROCYCLES THE PATERNO
119
Ph Ph hv Se
O 34%
CH3 Ph2CO
Se
CH3
Scheme 3.50
D. Imidazole Imidazole, N-methylimidazole, and 1,2-dimethylimidazole react with aliphatic aldehydes and ketones to give the corresponding 4-imidazolyl carbinols in good yields (Scheme 3.51) [94, 98]. The carbinols are obtained through the formation of the corresponding oxetanes. However, the reaction gave only 7.7% yield of the corresponding alcohol when treated with benzophenone [98]. Furthermore, the reaction with acetophenone gave only 1.2% yield of the product [98].
N
hv
HO CH3 H3C N
CH3COCH3
N H
N N
hv
N H
HO CH3 H3C N
CH3COCH3
N
CH3
N
CH3 HO CH3 H3C N
hv CH3 CH3COCH3 N CH3
CH3 N CH3
Scheme 3.51
There is no agreement between the work of Jones et al. [94] and that of Matsuura et al. [98] on the behavior of N-methylimidazole. While Jones’s group reported that the corresponding imidazolyl carbinol was obtained in excellent yields, Matsuura’s group reported that N-methylimidazole gave the corresponding carbinol in 9% yield. They also reported that 2-methylimidazole gave a
120
1,2-CYCLOADDITION REACTION OF CARBONYL COMPOUNDS
N N H
hv
HO CH3 H3C N
CH3 CH3COCH3
HO CH3 H3C N + H3C N H3C OH H 14.5%
CH3
N H 8%
CH3
Scheme 3.52
mixture of two products with an overall yield of 22.5% (Scheme 3.52) [98]. 1,2Dimethylimidazole reacts with benzophenone, giving in low yield a reaction on the methyl in 2 position [99, 100]. N-Benzylimidazole, when irradiated in the presence of benzophenone in t-BuOH, gave a reaction on the methylene group [99, 100]. N-Acetylimidazole allows us to isolate the corresponding oxetane when irradiated in the presence of benzophenone (Scheme 3.53). The same result was obtained by using N-benzoylimidazole and N,N0 -carbonyldiimidazole [99, 100]. The oxetane can also be obtained in the reaction of N-methyl-2,4,5triphenylimidazole with aromatic ketones. It is noteworthy that, in this case, the reaction does not work in the presence of acetophenone and benzaldehyde [101]. Ph N N
Ph hv
N O
Ph2CO
COCH3
50% N COCH3
Scheme 3.53
E. Thiazole, Isoxazole, Isothiazole 2,4-Dimethylthiazole gives the corresponding oxetane when irradiated in the presence of benzophenone, while the same reaction fails when acetophenone is used as reagent (Scheme 3.54) [102]; 3,5- and 4,5-dimethylisoxazole give the corresponding oxetane in good yields. 4-Methylisothiazole give a reaction on the methyl substituent (Scheme 3.54) [102].
F. Indole Indole does not react with benzophenone under irradiation conditions. On the contrary, a benzoyl derivative reacts with it, giving the corresponding
` -BU ¨ CHI REACTION ON PENTAATOMIC HETEROCYCLES THE PATERNO
H3C hv Ph2CO
CH3
S
N
H3C
hv Ph2CO
O
40%
N
Ph N
CH3
O
Ph
H3C H3C
25% CH3
S
Ph hv Ph2CO
O
N O
Ph
CH3 H3C
Ph CH 3
Ph
N
O CH3
O
65%
N
H3C
121
O
Scheme 3.54
oxetane (Scheme 3.55) [102]. It does not react with acetophenone, benzaldehyde, acetone, and propionaldehyde. When methyl pyruvate is used as reagent, the corresponding 3-indolyl carbinol is isolated (Scheme 3.55) [102].
Ph
Ph O
hv
83%
Ph2CO
N
N O
O
Cl
Cl
H3C
OH
hv N
24%
CH3COCO2CH3
N O
O
Cl
CO2CH3
Cl
Scheme 3.55
122
1,2-CYCLOADDITION REACTION OF CARBONYL COMPOUNDS
G. Azaindole The same reaction has been described on N-acetyl derivative of 7-azaindole. Although the reaction represents a method able to obtain a new class of compound, the low yields of the product (4%) prevent from a synthetic use of this reaction [103].
H. Possible Explanation of the Observed Reactivity The reported results represent all the available data on the Paterno`-Bu¨ chi reaction on pentaatomic heterocycles that are not furan. There are very few data; in particular, (1) most of the unsubstituted compounds tested did not react and (2) only a few substituted derivatives showed a significative reactivity toward excited carbonyl compounds. This behavior may be due to different reasons. First, the different aromaticity of the compounds could play an important role to define the reactivity of the compounds. Furan is the lowest aromatic pentaatomic heterocyclic compound known, while the other compounds show higher aromaticity. However, this type of explanation cannot justify why thiophene does not react while simple dimethylthienyl derivatives react and why some dimethylthienyl derivatives react while some others do not show any reactivity. A different explanation was identified in the quenching properties of these heterocycles. Thiophene and monomethyl derivatives are efficient quenchers of triplet benzophenone. The Stern-Volmer plot showed a linear relationship [104, 105]. On the contrary, 2,5-dimethylthiophene (a compound able to give the cycloaddition reaction) is not a good quencher of benzophene [106]. NBenzoylpyrrole also does not act as a quencher of the triplet benzophenone [106]. On the contrary, pyrrole and selenophene are quenchers of the excited benzophenone [106]. In this case, the Stern-Volmer plot is not linear. This situation is commonly encountered when the quencher employed quenches two excited states. It seems reasonable that pyrrole acts as quencher of both triplet benzophenone and the exciplex between triplet benzophenone and pyrrole [106]. On the basis of these investigations, the common five-membered heterocycles may be classified in two categories in regard to their quenching properties: those with electron-donating groups, which give Stern-Volmer plots in the shape of straight lines, and those substituted with halogens and electron attracting groups, such as N-benzoylpyrrole, which give parabola-shaped curves. Those in the first category give oxetanes when they are bad quenchers. Since these compounds do not presumably form exciplexes, they should go from starting materials to products through a biradical intermediate. On the other hand, those in the second category most likely give oxetanes when they are good quenchers, as may be
REFERENCES
123
shown for 2,5-dibromothiophene, and furthermore they go from starting materials to products through an exciplex [107].
IV.
CONCLUSIONS
After reviewing these studies we think it could be useful to discuss some open aspects in the Paterno`-Bu¨ chi reaction on furan derivatives. The first problem is encountered in the regioselectivity of the reaction. By using substituted furans, in most of the cases the reaction occurs on the most hindered side of the molecule. This behavior could be explained assuming, on the basis of a theoretical description of the mechanism [15], the formation of the most stable biradical; in some cases, this assumption has been verified. However, the described regioselectivity was observed with both 2- and 3-methyl substituted furans, whereas a methyl group plays a role in the biradical stabilization only when present in position 2 on the furan. Furthermore, silyl- and stannyl-substituted furans showed inverse regioselectivity, in spite of the possible capto dative stabilizing effect of these substituents. Another open question is related to the diastereoselectivity of the reaction. We have shown that Adam’s rule cannot be used to explain the observed stereoselectivity in the reaction with 2-furylmethanol derivatives. If Adam’s hypothesis does not work, the diastereoselectivity of the Paterno`-Bu¨ chi reaction with allylic alcohols remains to be explained.
REFERENCES 1. E. Paterno` and G. Chieffi, Gazz. Chim. Ital. 1909, 39, 431. 2. G. Bu¨ chi, C. G. Inman, and E. S. Lipinsky, J. Am. Chem. Soc. 1954, 76, 4327. 3. D. R. Arnold, Adv. Photochem. 1968, 6, 301. 4. G. Jones, Org. Photochem. 1981, 5, 1. 5. H. A. J. Carless, In Synthetic Organic Photochemistry, W. M. Horspool, Ed., Plenum, New York, 1984, p. 425. 6. J. A. Porco and S. L. Schreiber, In Comprehensive Organic Synthesis, Vol. 5, B. M. Trost, I. Fleming, and L. A. Paquette, Eds., Plenum, New York, 1991, p. 151. 7. A. G. Griesbeck, In Handbook of Photochemistry and Photobiology, W. A. Horspool, and P.-S. Song, Eds., CRC Press, Boca Raton, FL, 1994, p. 550. 8. D. G. I. Kingston, Pharmac. Ther. 1991, 52, 1. 9. J. Huang, R. Yokoyama, C. Yang, and Y. Fukuyama, Tetrahedron Lett. 2000, 41, 6111.
124
1,2-CYCLOADDITION REACTION OF CARBONYL COMPOUNDS
10. Y. Wang, G. W. J. Fleet, R. Storer, P. L. Myers, C. J. Wallis, O. Doherty, D. J. Watkin, K. Vogt, D. R. Witty, F. X. Wilson, and J. M. Peach, Tetrahedron Asymmetry 1990, 1, 527. 11. C. O. Yang, W. Kurz, E. M. Eugui, M. J. McRoberts, J. P. H. Verheyden, L. J. Kurz, and K. A. M. Walker, Tetrahedron Lett. 1992, 33, 41. 12. Y. Kawahata, S. Takatsuto, N. Ikekawa, M. Murata, and S. Omura, Chem. Pharm. Bull. 1986, 34, 3102. 13. J. Kopecky´ , Organic Photochemistry, VCH, New York, 1992. 14. N. J. Turro, J. C. Dalton, K. Dawes, G. Farrington, R. Hautala, D. Morton, M. Niemczyk, and N. Schore, Acc. Chem. Res. 1972, 5, 92. 15. I. J. Palmer, I. N. Ragazos, F. Bernardi, M. Olivucci, and M. A. Robb, J. Am. Chem. Soc. 1994, 116, 2121. 16. A. G. Kutateladze, J. Am. Chem. Soc. 2001, 123, 9279. 17. S. C. Freilich and K. S. Peters, J. Am. Chem. Soc. 1981, 103, 6225. 18. S. C. Freilich and K. S. Peters, J. Am. Chem. Soc. 1985, 107, 3819. 19. J. Mattay, Angew. Chem., Int. Ed. Engl. 1987, 26, 825. 20. G. O. Schenck, W. Hartman, and R. Steinmetz, Chem. Ber. 1963, 96, 498. 21. D. Gagnaire and E. Payo-Subiza, Bull. Soc. Chim. Fr. 1963, 2623. 22. S. Toki, K. Shima, and H. Sakurai, Bull Chem. Soc. Jpn. 1965, 38, 760. 23. T. Nakano, C. Rivas, and C. Perez, J. Chem. Soc. Perkin Trans. 1, 1973, 2322. 24. E. B. Whipple and G. R. Evanega, Tetrahedron 1968, 24, 1299. 25. C. Rivas and E. Payo, J. Org. Chem. 1967, 32, 2918. 26. C. Rivas, R. A. Bolivar, and M. Cucarella, J. Heterocyclic Chem. 1982, 19, 529. 27. K. Shima and H. Sakurai, Bull. Chem. Soc. Jpn. 1966, 39, 1806. 28. S. Toki and H. Sakurai, Bull. Soc. Chem. Jpn. 1967, 40, 2885. 29. A. Zamojski and T. Koz´ luk, J. Org. Chem. 1977, 42, 1089. 30. S. L. Schreiber, D. Desmaele, and J. A. Porco, Tetrahedron Lett. 1988, 29, 6689. 31. H. A. J. Carless and A. F. Halfhide, J. Chem. Soc. Perkin Trans. 1, 1992, 1081. 32. M. Abe, E. Torii, and M. Nojima, J. Org. Chem. 2000, 65, 3426. 33. A. G. Griesbeck, H. Mauder, and S. Stadtmu¨ ller, Acc. Chem. Res. 1994, 27, 70. 34. A. G. Griesbeck, S. Buhr, M. Fiege, H. Schmickler, and J. Lex, J. Org. Chem. 1998, 63, 3847. 35. M. Ogata, H. Watanabe, and H. Kano, Tetrahedron Lett. 1967, 533. 36. J. Leitich, Tetrahedron Lett. 1967, 1937. 37. G. R. Evanega and E. B. Whipple, Tetrahedron Lett. 1967, 2163. 38. S. Toki and H. Sakurai, Tetrahedron Lett. 1967, 4119. tibranyi, Coll. Czech. Chem. Commun. 1984, 49, 71. 39. S. Sekretar, J. Ruda¯ , L. S 40. T. S. Cantrell, A. Allen, and H. Ziffer, J. Org. Chem. 1989, 54, 140. 41. Y. Kubo, M. Suto, S. Tojo, and T. Araki, J. Chem. Soc. Perkin Trans. 1 1986, 771.
REFERENCES
125
42. M. D’Auria, L. Emanuele, and R. Racioppi, J. Photochem. Photobiol., A: Chem. 2004, 163, 103. 43. C. H. Krauch, W. Metzner, and G. O. Schenck, Chem. Ber. 1966, 99, 1723. 44. S. Farid, S. E. Hartman, and C. D. DeBoer, J. Am. Chem. Soc. 1975, 97, 808. 45. H. A. Carless and D. J. Haywood, J. Chem. Soc., Chem. Commun. 1980, 1067. 46. A. G. Griesbeck and S. Stadtmu¨ ller, J. Am. Chem. Soc. 1990, 112, 1281. 47. A. G. Griesbeck and S. Stadtmu¨ ller, J. Am. Chem. Soc. 1991, 113, 6923. 48. A. G. Griesbeck and S. Stadtmu¨ ller, Chem. Ber. 1990, 123, 357. 49. A. G. Griesbeck, H. Mauder, K. Peters, E.-M. Peters, and H. G. von Schnering, Chem. Ber. 1991, 124, 407. 50. A. B. Smith III, G. A. Sulikowski, M. M. Sulikowski, and K. Fujimoto, J. Am. Chem. Soc. 1992, 114, 2567. 51. S. Jarosz and A. Zamojski, J. Org. Chem. 1979, 44, 3720. 52. T. Kitamura, Y. Kawakami, T. Imagawa, and M. Kawanisi, Synth. Commun. 1977, 7, 521. 53. T. Kozluk and A. Zamojski, Tetrahedron, 1983, 39, 805. 54. S. L. Schreiber, A. H. Hoveyda, and H.-J. Wu, J. Am. Chem. Soc. 1983, 105, 660. 55. M. Satre, Biochem. Biophys. Res. Commun. 1981, 100, 267. 56. S. L. Schreiber and K. Satake, J. Am. Chem. Soc. 1983, 105, 6723. 57. S. L. Schreiber and K. Satake, J. Am. Chem. Soc. 1984, 106, 4186. 58. S. L. Schreiber and A. H. Hoveyda, J. Am. Chem. Soc. 1984, 106, 7200. 59. S. L. Schreiber and J. A. Porco, J. Org. Chem. 1989, 54, 4721. 60. N. Shimada, S. Hasegawa, T. Harada, T. Tonisawa, and T. Fujii, J. Antibiot. 1986, 39, 1623. 61. H. Hoshino, N. Shimizu, N. Shimada, T. Takida, and T. Takeuchi, J. Antibiot. 1987, 60, 1077. 62. R. Hambalek and G. Just, Tetrahedron Lett. 1990, 31, 4693. 63. D. R. Mootoo, V. Date, and B. Fraser-Reid, J. Am. Chem. Soc. 1988, 110, 2662. 64. R. Hambalek and G. Just, Tetrahedron Lett. 1990, 31, 5445. 65. S. Jarosz and A. Zamojski, Tetrahedron, 1982, 38, 1447. 66. R. Pelzer, P. Ju¨ tten, and H.-D. Scharf, Chem. Ber. 1989, 122, 487. 67. R. Pelzer, H.-D. Scharf, H. Buschmann, and J. Runsink, Chem. Ber. 1989, 122, 1187. 68. S. Hu and D. C. Neckers, J. Chem. Soc. Perkin Trans. 2, 1999, 1771. 69. H. Buschmann and H.-D. Scharf, N. Hoffmann, M. W. Plath, and J. Runsink, J. Am. Chem. Soc. 1989, 111, 5367. 70. H. Buschmann, H.-D. Scharf, N. Hoffmann, and P. Esser, Angew. Chem., Int. Ed. Engl. 1991, 30, 477. 71. M. D’Auria, L. Emanuele, and R. Racioppi, Photochem. Photobiol. Sci. 2003, 2, 904. 72. Y. Zhang, J. Xue, Y. Gao, H.-K. Fun, and J.-H. Xu, J. Chem. Soc., Perkin Trans. 1, 2002, 345.
126
1,2-CYCLOADDITION REACTION OF CARBONYL COMPOUNDS
agar and H.-D. Scharf, Chem. Ber. 1991, 124, 967. 73. C. Z 74. S. Jarosz and A. Zamojski, Tetrahedron 1982, 38, 1453. 75. J. M. J. Tronchet and B. Baehler, J. Carbohydrates Nucleosides Nucleotides 1974, 1, 449. 76. S. L. Schreiber, Science 1985, 227, 857. 77. S. L. Schreiber and K. Satake Tetrahedron Lett. 1986, 27, 2575. 78. W. Adam, K. Peters, E. M. Peters, and V. R. Stegmann, J. Am. Chem. Soc. 2000, 122, 2958. 79. W. Adam and V. R. Stegmann, Synthesis 2001, 1203. 80. W. Adam and M. Prein, Angew. Chem., Int. Ed. Engl. 1996, 35, 477. 81. T. Bach, J. Schro¨ der, and K. Harms, Tetrahedron Lett. 1999, 40, 9003. 82. T. Bach, H. Bergmann, and K. Harms, J. Am Chem. Soc. 1999, 121, 10650. 83. A. Yokohama and K. Mizuno, Org. Lett. 2000, 2, 3457. 84. A. G. Griesbeck and S. Bondock, J. Am. Chem. Soc. 2001, 123, 6191. 85. T. Bach, Liebigs Ann. 1997, 1627. 86. M. D’Auria, R. Racioppi, and G. Romaniello, Eur. J. Org. Chem. 2000, 3265. 87. M. D’Auria and R. Racioppi, Arkivoc, 2000, 1, 145. 88. M. D’Auria, L. Emanuele, G. Poggi, R. Racioppi, and G. Romaniello, Tetrahedron 2002, 58, 5045. 89. C. Rivas and F. Vargas, in CRC Handbook of Organic Photochemistry and Photobiology, W. M. Horspool and P.-S. Song, Eds., CRC Press, Boca Raton, FL 1995, p. 536. 90. F. Vargas, C. Rivas, M. Navarro, and Y. Alvarado, J. Photochem. Photobiol., A Chem. 1996, 93, 169. 91. C. Rivas, M. Velez, and O. Crescente, J. Chem. Soc. Chem. Commun. 1970, 1474. 92. C. Rivas, and R. A. Bolivar, J. Heterocyclic Chem. 1973, 10, 967. 93. C. Rivas, D. Pacheco, F. Vargas, and J. Ascanio J. Heterocyclic Chem. 1981, 18, 1065. 94. G. Jones, H. M. Gilow, and J. Low, J. Org. Chem. 1979, 44, 2949. 95. C. Rivas, M. Velez, M. Cucarella, R. A. Bolivar, and S. E. Flores, Acta Cient. Venezolana 1971, 22, 145. 96. C. Rivas and R. A. Bolivar, J. Heterocyclic Chem. 1976, 13, 1037. 97. C. Rivas, D. Pacheco, and F. Vargas, Acta Sud Am. Quim. 1982, 2, 1. 98. T. Matsuura, A. Banba, and K. Ogura, Tetrahedron 1971, 27, 1211. 99. T. Nakano, C. Rivas, C. Perez, and J. M. Larrauri, J. Heterocyclic Chem. 1976, 13, 173. 100. T. Nakano, W. Rodriguez, S. Z. de Roche, J. M. Larrauri, C. Rivas, and C. Perez, J. Heterocyclic Chem. 1980, 17, 1777. 101. Y. Ito, M. Ji-Ben, S. Suzuki, Y. Kusunaga, T. Matsuura, and K. Fukuyama, Tetrahedron Lett. 1985, 26, 2093. 102. D. R. Julian and G. D. Tringham, J. Chem. Soc. Chem. Commun. 1973, 13.
REFERENCES
127
103. T. Nakano and M. Santana, J. Heterocyclic Chem. 1976, 13, 585. 104. R. A. Bolivar and C. Rivas, J. Photochem. 1981, 17, 91. 105. R. A. Bolivar and C. Rivas, J. Photochem. 1982, 19, 95. 106. R. A. Bolivar, R. Machado, L. Montero, F. Vargas, and C. Rivas, J. Photochem. 1983, 22, 91. 107. F. Vargas and C. Rivas, Int. J. Photoenergy 2000, 2, 97.
THE INVENTION OF DYLUX1 INSTANT-ACCESS IMAGING MATERIALS AND THE DEVELOPMENT OF HABI CHEMISTRY—A PERSONAL HISTORY Rolf Dessauer (Retired) Greenville, DE
CONTENTS I. II. III. IV. V.
Introduction My Background Dessauer at DuPont We Must Have Done Something Right! The Beginning A. Lawrence A. Cescon—An Inventor B. A New Phototropic Substance C. George R. Coraor—An Inspiring Leader VI. 1961—Permanent Color A. What Do You Do with This Stuff? B. What Is Needed? Advances in Photochemistry, Volume 28 Edited by Douglas C. Neckers, William S. Jenks, and Thomas Wolff # 2005 John Wiley & Sons, Inc.
129
130
THE INVENTION OF DYLUX
VII.
VIII.
IX.
X. XI.
XII.
XIII.
XIV.
C. Kay Looney—A Creative Spectroscopist D. Radiation Physics Laboratory and Al MacLachlan E. Chuck Yembrick, Peter Strilko, and Optimization F. Patents 1962—Improvements in Technology A. A New Opportunity—Foot Imaging B. Optical Printing C. Proofing? 1964—A Higher Speed System A. HABIs Really Are Photopolymerization Initiators B. Management Change 1965—Other Markets A. Microfilm B. Cathode Ray Tube Imaging 1966—We Become a Venture 1967—We Start a Marketing Effort: How Do You Get to the Market, Any Market? A. Harold Wilbur—The Electrician B. Point of Sales Opportunity C. The UVI Movie D. Another Trip to the West Coast E. The Name Dylux1 F. More Marketing G. Large Wall-Screen Displays 1. Project Apollo 2. Boeing H. Is There a Business Here? I. Opto-Magnetic Printing J. How to Get Rich? 1968—More Marketing Activities A. W. H. Brady Co. and the Kalograph1 B. John de Campi—An Enthusiastic Marketeer C. Mattel 1969—William S. Wartell: A Dynamic Decision Maker A. Proofing, for Certain B. Spring Boston SPSE Meeting C. What Is So Good about Dylux1 Proofpaper? D. Europe 1970—Expansion of Opportunities A. Military Applications B. What Is/Was Wrong with Dylux1 Proofpaper? C. Transfer of the Dylux1 Venture
131
XV. 1971—After the Venture A. Photodecoration XVI. 1972—What Else? XVII. 1973—Universal Product Code Opportunity XVIII. 1974–Philip Botsolas: A Breath of Fresh Air XIX. Progress A. Dylux1 DFF Filter B. Europe C. Medical Imaging Systems–‘‘aca’’ Automatic Clinical Analyzer XX. 1976—Still More Opportunities A. GTE-Sylvania Home Office Copier B. The End of Photodecoration C. Dylux1-4C Overlay Films D. Phenidone XXI. 1977—And Still More Opportunities A. New HABIs: TCTM-HABI B. Photomarker1 Corp. C. Miscellaneous Activities D. J. C. Penney—Inventory Control E. Tokyo SPSE Meeting F. X-Raylux: Instructional X-Ray Prints XXII. 1978—Transitions A. Another Dual Response System B. Transfer to the Photo Products Department XXIII. 1979—Black Dylux1 535 Proofpaper XXIV. 1981—Add-On Toning XXV. 1983—A New Wind Blows XXVI. 1984—China XXVII. 1984–2004 A. Xeroprinting B. Photoimaging, Ltd. C. Competition D. Commercial Products E. Watermarks F. Thermal Dylux1 Proofpaper G. HABIs in Photopolymer Products H. The HABI Literature I. Could We Have Done Better? J. HABI Statistics Acknowledgments Rewards and Awards
132
THE INVENTION OF DYLUX
I. INTRODUCTION Many publications in the literature describe the technical aspects of hexaarylbiimidzole (HABI) chemistry. The following is an attempt to put these and the reported patent literature into a historical perspective and to add my personal reflections about the times, the scientists, and the emotions that were involved. Although several publications preceded the DuPont work, I believe that it was work in industry that elucidated and commercialized products based on these unique compounds. I have attempted to put events in chronologic order and have relied on Chemical Abstracts and information derived from issued U.S. patents to support the technical details. This is not entirely satisfactory because the dates when patents are allowed may not actually relate to the date the work was done. I used the issue dates of the patents for chronologic order, although the work, of course, had to precede these dates. I have mentioned the names of the individuals who did the actual research and marketing, although there were many people who contributed to this work, who were not recognized in patents or whose names are now forgotten; to them, my apologies. To report this work accurately, it must be pointed out that there were supporters and detractors. In some cases, their deliberations were unknown to me. In summary, however, the DuPont Company supported a very exciting effort and was rewarded with financial returns. The Photo Products Department changed from a producer of silver films to an innovator and powerhouse in the prepress proofing and electronic products area. This work started around 1958, when the DuPont Company was organized very differently from the way it is organized now. To understand better some of the problems that occurred in the development of this chemistry, it is necessary to explain this structure and comment on some of the individuals who were involved in this work.
II. MY BACKGROUND I was born in Germany in 1926, and as a result of the rise of the Nazi Party, my family was forced to emigrate to the United States. My older brother arrived in America in November 1937, my father in December 1938, and my mother and I in June 1939. My father had been a physician in Germany and spent nearly four years in the United States taking language and medical state board examinations before resuming his career. I completed my schooling in New York City, enlisted in the U.S. Army in 1944, and in 1947 enrolled at the University of Chicago,
DESSAUER AT DUPONT
133
where I received BS and MS degrees in chemistry. In 1949, I transferred to the University of Wisconsin, where I received my Ph.D. in organic chemistry in 1952. In September 1952, I began my career as a chemist at DuPont, where I continued to work until 1991. I married Peggy in 1965, divorced in 1967, married Nicky in 1968, was widowed in 1981, and married Angela in 1991. I have two stepsons, Nicky’s children, neither of whom became chemists.
III. DESSAUER AT DUPONT At the time I joined DuPont, the company had a number of operating departments, which covered certain business areas, sometimes with considerable overlap and resulting conflicts. The largest of these then was the Textile Fibers Department, which conducted research on novel fibers, such as nylon, Dacron1 and Orlon1 fibers; manufactured these in a number of domestic plants; and sold them through sales offices throughout the United States. Other departments were the Organic Chemicals Department, which was in the dyes, petroleum additives, fluorinated, and elastomeric products businesses; the Pigments Department, which sold colored and white pigments; the Fabrics and Finishes Department, which sold coating materials and some coated products; the Photo Products sold a number of silver-based photographic products, including X-ray, graphic arts, and black and white motion picture films; the Film Department handled a series of film products, such as cellophane and polyester films; and the Polychemicals Department manufactured a number of polymeric products, such as nylon, Delrin1, and polyolefins. Other departments handled agricultural products (Grasseli), certain specialty chemicals (Electrochemicals Department), explosives (Explosives Department), etc. To assist in the research and develop new businesses, there were staff departments, such as the Chemical Department, later to become Central Research, the Engineering Department, the Development Department, the Treasurers Department, etc. The operating departments each had some similarity in structure; there were separate research, manufacturing, and marketing/sales divisions, each headed by directors, who reported to a general manager. These then reported to the company’s executive committee and president and chairman. At the upper levels of the company there were frequent shifts in personnel from one department to another in order to develop management with a broader background. On some occasions, this resulted in favorable results; but frequently it occurred that the leadership was lacking in experience in the areas that it was to manage. In my experience, I found very few individuals who had the breadth of intellect and energy to learn a business from the ground up, resulting in lack of positive leadership.
134
THE INVENTION OF DYLUX
DuPont had grown enormously after World War II and realized that the development of the company depended on the entry into new fields. The main research center, the DuPont Experimental Station, was enlarged significantly in the early 1950s. Each operating department had representation there, and transmittal of technology from the various research groups of the operating and staff departments was encouraged. Several thousand scientists were stationed there, and it was a great time to do research. At that time, the DuPont Company was still very much in the hands of the DuPont family, and then was more oriented toward growth than day-to-day changes in the value of the company’s stock. Hence there was less pressure then to think in terms of short-term objectives. In the mid-1960s, the venture concept, with a certain autonomy for groups inside an operating department was pursued. Typical of these were Corfam, DuPont’s leather replacement offering, and UVI, the ultraviolet imaging program; there were some 29 others. The ventures varied in size from a few to many employees. In the 1980s, there were major acquisitions; and later there were joint ventures with major companies, such as DuPont Merck and DXI (DuPont Xerox Imaging). In the 1990s, Apex programs, designed to identify major opportunities in new business areas were considered. In time, this changed; and the current structure, which had evolved as the company grew and later contracted, is better organized to take advantage of short-term new opportunities. When I joined the Organic Chemicals Department (Orchem), it had a very large staff of scientists working at Jackson Laboratory in Deepwater, New Jersey. It operated several highly profitable businesses, such as petroleum additives, for which the principal product was the gasoline additive tetraethyl lead; Freon1 propellants; elastomeric products, such as neoprene; and the dyes and chemicals business, which sold a broad range of colored materials to the textile and paper industries. During the immediate post–World War II period, DuPont developed a number of profitable novel fibers. The Textile Fibers Department supported research at Orchem to identify and manufacture novel dyes, which were required to impart color to these new materials. In some cases, the new dyes enlarged the business opportunities for these fibers, so that they became widely successful. In time, the textile dye field dominated the thinking of the department, until the market identified major opportunities in the coloration of paper products as well as consideration of related materials, such as fluorescent whitening agents, UV screening agents, and colorants for the graphic arts and other industries. In writing this story, years after much happened, I am struck by the fact that my colleagues and I developed some excellent chemistry in the Organic Chemicals Department, which resulted in myriad novel products that generated significant earnings for the DuPont Company, but that there was also much opposition—especially from some of the management of the Photo Products
THE BEGINNING
135
Department. Was it departmental envy or a not-invented-here attitude? Or was it that novel technologies always have to fight harder to get support? Were there personal animosities? For example, Dr. Robert Upson, the director of research for Photo Products Department, believed chemists should invent what their managers tell them, but Dr. M. L. Ernsberger, Director of Research of the Organic Chemicals Department (and I), favored a pragmatic approach—if a new and better opportunity arises—pursue it!
IV. WE MUST HAVE DONE SOMETHING RIGHT! My colleagues and I developed a novel imaging system, which resulted in products for the prepress proofing industry that were successful for over 35 years. They were ‘‘big earners’’ because the research was done with an eye on establishing a strong patent position, and no effective competition came along. The photo-oxidants that were developed became enormously successful as photopolymerization initiators, which allowed DuPont to manufacture a series of novel products of importance to the printing and electronics industries. Now, some 40 years after this work was done, these biimidazole derivatives still appear to be initiators of choice and are found to play a role in current patents.
V. THE BEGINNING It all began in 1958. I was assigned by the management of the Organic Chemicals Department of DuPont to examine chemistry that would lead to new products, which could use the facilities in the Chambers Works, which had been dedicated to the manufacture of dyes and related aromatic chemicals. At that time, automobiles were designed to have larger glass areas; and one possible application was to design glass that could automatically darken when sunlight became more intense. Such photochromic materials could also see application in the architectural field. DuPont manufactured Butacite1, a plastic material used to provide stability and protection to automotive window glass, and it was hoped that incorporation of a photochromic material in the automotive glass interliners would provide a ready market. I had earlier found that certain classes of metalized hydroxyazo dyes could be dissolved in Butacite1, and when sandwiched between glasses, exhibited extraordinary stability. This work led to a good relationship with the Butacite research group, who endorsed our work with photochromic materials.
136
THE INVENTION OF DYLUX
It may be useful to think of what we now accept as routine in 2004 that we had not seen, experienced, or anticipated in 1958. Here is a brief list: Personal computers Office and home copiers Digital music Compact disks Color television Video tape and recorders Audio tape recorders Photoresists GPS The Pill Cable TV Faximile Low-cost telephony e-mail and the Internet DNA Infrared lasers
In the summer of 1958, I was assigned to a group at the DuPont Experimental Station under Dr. W. R. Remington, with the objective of working with a very talented summer employee, John Harriman, who was then still an undergraduate at the University of Wisconsin. One of my colleagues, Dr. C. Wheaton Vaughn urged me to examine a reference to N-pyridylsydnone (N-PS) (Scheme 4.1). H N N
O O
N
Scheme 4.1 N-3-pyridylsydnone
which had recently appeared in the Journal of the American Chemical Society (J. M. Tien and I. M. Hunsberger, J. Am. Chem. Soc. 1955, 77, 6604). We prepared samples of this compound and examined it under a variety of conditions.
THE BEGINNING
137
Harriman and I had considerable encouragement from Dr. W. D. Phillips, a talented and highly regarded physical chemist then at the Chemical Department of DuPont. In the end, we concluded that N-PS was photochromic in the crystalline state but not in solution or in Butacite films; and by the end of the summer, we decided that other materials would be needed. Also in our group was Dr. C. F. Wahlig, a physicist formerly with the Photo Products Department, who had been transferred to help Harriman and me. Another chemist, Dr. Theodore Mill, was assigned this program; and after he left DuPont, Dr. L. A. Cescon, who had recently joined DuPont was asked to work in this area.
A. Lawrence A. Cescon—An Inventor Cescon obtained his Ph.D. at The Pennsylvania State University. He was born in Allentown, Pennsylvania, the son of Italian immigrants. He was a very methodical person, who studied the literature, endlessly purified every material he ever used in syntheses or evaluations, and seemed at times very slow. But he was very thorough. Cescon remained on this program only until 1965, and finished his career at the company’s Explosives Department, where he also made significant contributions in the field of emulsion-containing explosive compositions. During the 5 years of our collaboration, Cescon and I obtained many patents and continued to stimulate each other. As I had several years of experience in the dye field from earlier work, Cescon was content to accept many of my suggestions, and I in turn was stimulated by his perception of organic chemistry. I had found it very difficult to understand why he and I could not collaborate in developing better imaging systems, but his later work on waterborne explosives (L. A. Cescon and R. W. Trebilcock, U.S. Pat. 4,619,721, Oct. 28, 1986; L. A. Cescon, R. W. Trebilcock, and R. H. Moffett, U.S. Pat. 4,714,503, Dec. 22, 1987) was very successful, too. He contracted cancer and retired from DuPont in 1985 and moved to Italy, where his second wife had been a schoolteacher. He became interested in the effect of nutrition on cancer and was invited to give talks about his studies at many institutions. He taught chemistry at Italian universities. We remained friends and visited each other for many years, until he died in 1995.
B.
A New Phototropic Substance
One of the many benefits of working for the DuPont Company in the 1960s was the availability of a company-organized abstract publication that covered the technical and patent activities in areas of interest to the operating departments.
138
THE INVENTION OF DYLUX
Hence it was possible to be somewhat more abreast of the literature than if one had to rely on Chemical Abstracts, which then lagged considerably behind. It must be recalled that it was far more difficult during that period to obtain copies of articles that appeared in journals, because the electrophotographic copiers were not with us yet, and copies of a referenced article had to be microphotograped and reprinted on photographic paper in our excellent Lavoisier Library. Of course, there were then far fewer journals that had to be followed. Cescon saw a reference to work by T. Hayashi and K. Maeda, in which the Japanese scientists described a new phototropic substance, based on 2,4,5-triphenylimidazole (T. Hayashi, K. Maeda, and S. Shida, J. Chem. Phys. 1960, 32, 1568; T. Hayashi, and K. Maeda, Bull. Chem. Soc. Jpn. 1960, 33, 565). Cescon and I discussed this work, which required lophine or triarylimidazole as a starting material for this photochromic compound. As an experienced dye chemist, who had worked with aromatic heterocyclic compounds, I realized that lophine and its analogs were easy to prepare. As a matter of fact, we had found that they had been considered as fluorescent whitening agents earlier. At that time, I had laboratories at the Experimental Station and at Jackson Laboratory, where I was still involved with research on dyes and UV absorbers. Working for me were three very talented technicians, Robert Jenkins, John Willister, and Walter Balon. The latter was a self-taught chemist who possessed great synthetic skills; the former two were also very talented and enthusiastic to try new things. I asked Jenkins to make a sample of triphenylimidazole for Cescon, and delivered it to the Experimental Station, where Larry then studied the oxidation of this compound. About that time, the Organic Chemicals Department reassigned Dr. Remington; Dr. George Coraor, who came from the Explosives Department, took his place. I had been friends with Remington and was sorry to see him leave the program, but was encouraged by Coraor’s enthusiasm for new chemistry.
C. George R. Coraor—An Inspiring Leader The enthusiastic leader of Cescon’s and my endeavors was Dr. George R. Coraor, then in his mid-thirties. He had begun his career in DuPont’s Explosives Department in 1950 and had several promotions. Coraor was an immensely curious man and shared with me the idea that one should seek alternate routes toward success if and when management stood in our way. It appeared that much of our collaboration involved trying to bypass his overseers, who were more concerned with avoiding failure than encouraging success. Coraor was short and stout and did not fit the perception of DuPont management, who usually promoted tall, thin men. He was just plain smart and more supportive of his subordinates
139
THE BEGINNING
than anyone I had ever met. In time, his independence cost him the leadership of our group, which in turn almost killed our program. George asked me if I could spend more time on the program; as I enjoyed working with him, this was a pleasure for me. Cescon repeated Hayashi’s work and concluded that the compound synthesized by the Japanese workers, though not identified, was probably the dimer of the triphenylimidazolyl radical. We quickly did the requisite analytical work to confirm this. The radical formed by irradiation of the dimer was purple, and we decided that we should make related triarylimidazoles, a relatively simple task, considering that the Jackson Laboratory store room, under the dedicated supervision of Mrs. Cy Bleistine and Herb Dayton, had a large repertoire of aromatic aldehydes, benzils, and other necessary ingredients. The synthetic approach used is outlined in Scheme 4.2.
H CHO
O
OH O
CHO
O NH4 Ac
N
N H
N
N
2
Scheme 4.2
Cescon said that he would study the oxidation of these materials and, of course, purified everything that Jenkins and Balon made. Again, an historical note: In the 1960s, the Aldrich catalog was not as all-encompassing as it was to become later. DuPont’s Jackson Laboratory had a huge store room, where organic chemicals were stored according to the Beilstein classification system. Hence one could easily obtain samples of complex compounds with minimum effort. The structure of the dimer was believed to be as shown in Scheme 4.3. Before long we had prepared several biimidazoles, which gave rise to a wide range of colored radicals, including blues and greens. Coraor asked for more manpower, and Dr. Ernest Silversmith was assigned to study the physical chemistry of these materials. He in turn also synthesized some novel triarylimidazoles. I was promoted to senior research chemist and assigned to study applications of these
140
THE INVENTION OF DYLUX
N
N
N
N
UV
N
N
DIMER
N
N
RADICALS
Scheme 4.3
biimidazoles and, in general, provide some guidance to the group, which grew to five, while under Coraor. My days as a dye chemist were just about over! Our work was summarized in two patents: 2,4,5-Triphenylimidazole dimers. E. I. du Pont de Nemours & Co. (by Lawrence A. Cescon). Fr. 1,351,818 (Cl. C 07d, G l 02b, G 02c), Feb. 7, 1964; U.S. Appl. Mar. 21, 1962; 32 pp. Triphenylimidazoles were oxidized with K3Fe-(CN)6 in EtOH contg. KOH to give phototropic dimers. Thus, 1.4 parts o-ClC6H4CHO was added to a soln. of 2.1 parts benzil in 50 ml. HOAc contg. 6 parts NH4OAc, and the mixt. refluxed 2 hrs. and poured into 200 parts cold H2O to give 2-(o-chlorophenyl)-4,5-diphenylimidazole (I), m. 196–7 (EtOH). A soln. is prepd. from 1.1 parts I and 100 parts EtOH contg. 12 parts KOH, 450 parts 1% K3Fe(CN)6 added over 1.5 hrs., the mixt. filtered, and the ppt. solvated with EtOH (2 moles EtOH per 3 moles diimidazole) to give solvated I dimer, m. 95–110 , softens at 90 , lavender at 170 , red brown at 190 , red at 220 . Similarly prepd. were the following II and solvated II dimers: (X, Y, m.p. and softening point of solvated dimer given): Cl, Cl, 174.5 75 90 ; MeO, H, 207.5 8.5 , 160 ; MeO, MeO, 164 5 ,—Br, H 205.5-6.5 , 106 ; and F, H, 205.5–206 , 139 40 . 2-(Naphthyl)4,5diphenylimidazole (III) m. 289.5–90 ; solvated III dimer softened 153 . Dimers of IV were prepd. (R, R1 and softening point of solvated dimer given): 2-EtOC6H4, Ph, 138 ; 2,3-(MeO)2C6H3, Ph, 95 ; 9-phenanthryl, Ph, 165 ; 2,4,6-Me3C6H2, Ph, —; 2-MeOC6H4, 4-MeOC6H4, —; 1-C10H7, 4-MeOC6H4,—. Also prepd. was the solvated dimer of 2-(o-methoxyphenyl)-4-(p-methoxyphenyl)-5-phenylimidazole. Biimidazoles. E. I. du Pont de Nemours & Co. Belg. 635,804, Dec. 2, 1963, Appl. Aug. 2, 1963; 32 pp. I are phototropic. A mixt. of benzil 2.1, AcOH 50, NH4OAc 6, and 2 ClC6H4CHO 1.4 was refluxed for 2 hrs. to give 2-(2-chlorophenyl)-4,5-diphenylimidazole (II), 3.1 parts m. 196-7 . A 1 % aq. soln. of K3Fe(CN)6 450 was added at the rate of 5 parts/min. to II 1.1 in EtOH 100 contg. KOH 12, the ppt.1 part filtered off, washed, and vacuum-dried (0.1 mm.) at 50-6 for 8 hrs. to give I
141
THE BEGINNING
N
N
R1 R2
2
R3 I 1
2
3
(R ¼ Cl, R ¼ R ¼ H) (III), solvated with 2 mols. EtOH/3 mols. III, as pale yellow crystals, softening at 90 , forming a gel at 95–110 , becoming red-brown at 190 and red at 220 . A colorless 0.5% benzene soln. of III exposed to sunlight became purple immediately and the color disappeared in 1 min. after removal of the illumination. Comparison in a spectrophotometer with I (R1 ¼ R2 ¼ R3 ¼ H) (IV) showed that the color of III disappeared 16 times as rapidly as that of IV. Similarly, other I were
R1
R2
R3
color in sunlight
Cl OMe OMe CH:CH:CH:CH Br F
H H H
Cl H OMe H H H
purple blue greenish blue orange purple purple
H H
rapidity of decolorization compared with IV 35 17 2 2 16 13
prepd. (see Table). Also prepd. were 2,2,4-dichlorophenyl) (m. 174.5-75 ), 2-o-anisyl- (m. 207.5–8.5 ), 2-(2,4-dimethoxyphenyl)- (m. 164–5 ), 2-(1-naphthyl)- (m. 289.5–90 ), 2-o-bromophenyl)- (m. 205.5–6.5 ) and 2-(o-fluorophenyl)-4,5-diphenylimidazole (m. 205.5–206 )
We soon realized that others also found the reference to Hayashi and Maeda’s work intriguing, and a number of publications showed considerable activity in this new field. We scouted Chemical Abstracts for any work by any of the chemical or photographic companies, but only one publication from a major company, General Electric by White and Sonnenberg came to our attention. Was this only a scientific curiosity? Didn’t anyone else want to make photochromic materials commercially? Here is a sampling of references from 1960 to 1972.
142
THE INVENTION OF DYLUX
T. Hayashi and K. Maeda, Preparation of a new photochromic substance, Bull. Chem. Soc. Jpn. 1960, 33, 566. T. Hayashi, K. Maeda, S. Shida, and K. Nakada, A new phototropic substance and its ESR. J. Chem. Phys. 1960. 32, 1568. T. Hayashi and K. Maeda, Mechanism of chemiluminescence of 2,4,5-triphenylimidazole. Bull. Chem. Soc. Jpn. 1962, 35, 2057. H. Baumgaertel and H. Zimmermann, Synthesis of 1,10 -biimidazoles and dissociation into radicals. Z. Naturforsch. 1963, 18b, 406. T. Hayashi and K. Maeda, Storage of light energy by a solution of photochromatic-1,10 biorg(2,4,5-triphenylimidazyl) at low temperatures. Bull. Chem. Soc. Jpn. 1963, 36, 1052. J. Sonnenberg and D. M. White, Chemiluminescent and thermochemiluminescent lophine hydroperoxide. J. Am. Chem. Soc. 1964, 86, 568. E. H. White and M. J. C. Harding, The chemiluminescence of lophine and its derivatives.J. Am. Chem. Soc. 1964, 86, 5686. T. Hayashi, K. Maeda, and M. Morinaga, Mechanism of the photochromism and thermochromism of 2,20 ,4,40 ,5,50 -hexaphenyl-1,10 -biimidazole. Bull. Chem. Soc. Jpn. 1964, 37, 1563. T. Hayashi, K. Maeda, and M. Takeuchi, Kinetic study of the photochromism of 2,20 ,4,40 ,5,50 -hexaphenyl-1,10 -biimidazolyl with electron spin resonance. Bull. Chem. Soc. Jpn. 1964, 37, 1717. T. Hayashi, M. Kuyama, E. Takizawa, and M. Hata, The mechanism of dehydrogenation of 2,4,5-triphenyl-4,5-dihydroimidazole over solid catalysts. Bull. Chem. Soc. Jpn. 1964, 37, 1702. T. Hayashi and K. Maeda, Mechanism of the piezochromism of hexaphenylbiimidazole. Bull. Chem. Soc. Jpn. 1965, 38, 685. T. Hayashi, K. Maeda, and T. Kanaji, The mechanism of the photochromism and thermochromism of 2,20 ,4,40 ,5,50 -hexa-phenyl-1,10 -biimidazolyl in a solid state. Bull. Chem. Soc. Jpn. 1965, 38, 857. T. Hayashi and K. Maeda, Infrared absorption spectra of photochromic and piezochromic systems of the dimers of triarylimidazolyls. Bull. Chem. Soc. Jpn 1965, 38, 2202. H. Baumgaertel and H. Zimmermann, Triarylimidazolyls and triarylimidazole dyes. Chem. Ber. 1966, 99, 843. D. M. White and J. Sonnenberg, Oxidation of triarylimidazoles. Structures of the photochromic and piezochromic dimers of triarylimidazyl radicals. J. Am. Chem. Soc. 1966, 88, 3825. M. A. J. Wilks and M. R. Willis, Kinetics of the photochromic decay reaction of solutions of 2,20 ,4,40 ,5,50 -hexaphenyl-biimidazolyl. Nature 1966, 212, 500.
THE BEGINNING
143
T. Hayashi and K. Maeda, Mechanism of reversible photochemical color change of bis(triphenylimidazolyl) at low temperature. Bull. Chem. Soc. Jpn. 1967, 40, 2990. M. A. J Wilks and M. R. Willis, Kinetics of the photochromic decay reaction of 2,20 ,4,40 ,5,50 -hexaphenylbiimidazolyl. J. Chem. Soc. B 1968, 1526. M. A. J. Wilks and M. R. Willis, Interpretation of the high-resolution electron spin resonance spectrum of the 2,4,5-triphenylimidazolyl radical. J. Phys. Chem. 1968, 72, 4717. T. Hayashi and K. Maeda, Radical mechanism of the photochromism of bis (2,4,5-triphenylimidazolyl). Nippon Kagaku Zasshi 1969, 90, 325. A. L. Prokhoda and V. A. Krongauz, Photochromism of organic compounds. I. Kinetics and mechanism of photochromic reactions of 2,20 ,4,40 ,5,50 hexaphenyl-1,20 -biimidazole. Khim. Vys. Energ. 1969, 3, 495. B. S. Tanaseichuk, K. V. Stanovkina, A. N. Sunin, and L. G. Rezenova, Nitrogen-containing heterocyclic free radicals. VII. Use of diphenylpicrylhydrazine for studying the dissociation rate of dimers of triphenylimidazolyl radicals. Zh. Org. Khim. 1969, 5, 2054. H. Tanino, T. Kondo, K. Okada, and T. Goto, Chemiluminescence of organic compounds. I. Structures of three isomeric dimers of 2,4,5-triphenylimidazolyl. Bull. Chem. Soc. Jpn. 1972, 45, 1474. Soon after our initial experiments, we realized that we had something unusual, with potentially important opportunities. We were able to obtain some foreign patents on the biimidazoles and were concerned that these might tip off others in this field, for there was considerable activity, as can be seen from a listing of biimidazole work as reported in Chemical Abstracts. By 1964, we filed our first application on the leucodye oxidation. By then, we had a sufficient head start on this chemistry that we became less concerned about competitive activities. We had no equipment initially to do any photochemistry. We obtained a Cary recording spectrophotometer after a long wait, and our light sources inevitably were photographic flashguns, which I brought from home to work, and we used flashes of light, albeit of uncertain spectral distribution, to produce photochromic colors. In time, we were able to buy more powerful flashguns. Our initial attempts at making photochromic plastics for windows were not successful. In general, the radicals may have recombined, but they also underwent fatigue, i.e., they gave rise to compounds which no longer were photochromic. The Polychemicals Department, the business unit that marketed Butacite1 assigned Dr. Jean Paris to the program and, in time, Dr. Carleton Sperati. Both were enthusiastic supporters of the program and tried to provide us with media in which the biimidazoles, soon to be nicknamed HABIs were to be incorporated.
144
THE INVENTION OF DYLUX
Professor Dr. George Hammond, who then consulted for DuPont’s Film Department heard about our work and agreed to consult for us, too. He was the first photochemist of stature whom we sought as adviser. In time, Professors Ron Breslow and Nick Turro of Columbia University were also brought in. Hammond was then starting the series of books Advances in Photochemistry and suggested it would be good for me to write a literature survey about photochromism for the first volume of the series. I asked Paris if he would cooperate on this, and he agreed. I did a thorough literature survey, and Jean tried to put the theoretical aspects together. After about 6 months of this I began to question whether the type of photochromism that we required for windows was ever going to be possible with dye-like molecules. My reservations were based on the fatigue of the HABIs, the weak colors that were formed, and the likelihood that these colors would fade, rather than reverse themselves. I also suspected that the fact that no one had really succeeded in commercializing any photochromic materials was because the fatigue reaction was too considerable an obstacle. I said to some of my friends that the academic scientists who reported in this field were content with a few dozen reversals, which might be achieved by low quantum yields of formation, and so there was an ample reservoir of dimers, provided one did not push too hard. It became fairly obvious in our program that the development of automotive or architectural photochromic windows would be a lengthy task. Although we were a research group, we knew that sooner, rather than later, someone would ask the question: How soon can we make some money from all that? We thought that print advertising with photochromic inks might be an opportunity. We could spread solutions of HABIs onto paper, and with flashes of light, or even outdoor sunlight, produce blue or green coloration. We talked to Phil Wheeler, a printing expert in DuPont’s Philadelphia Printing Plant, and he gave us several ink vehicles to which we added HABIs. Initially we painted these onto paper and did produce photochromic images. These worked quite well in sunlight; but before long, we realized that people would not likely read magazines outdoors, and we either had to be able to generate color rapidly with indoor light, or forget this application. We were not yet familiar with sensitizing dyes that might have been useful in allowing our inks to work with indoor light! We analyzed the fatigue product of the photolysis of HABIs, and found these to be the parent triarylimidazoles (Scheme 4.4). At that time we became aware of photochromic sunglasses; Lord and Taylor’s (a New York City department store) offered some for around $16, and we bought a pair. But were not impressed with their performance. We thought that they employed some materials then available from American Cyanamid, which reported that they had photochromic materials for sale. We continued to dissolve HABIs in ever more purified solvents obtained from Paris and Sperati, and finally managed to fill some glass cells that actually lasted about 2 weeks,
145
1961—PERMANENT COLOR
N
N N
DIMER
N
N
.
N
IMIDAZOLYL RADICAL
N
NH
IMIDAZOLE
Scheme 4.4
when the photochrome was the dimer of 2-(p-methoxyphenyl)-4,5-diphenylimidazole. I took one such cell through the Holland Tunnel on the way to New York City, and it did discolor when in the tunnel and revert to the blue color on the sunny New York side. The solvent was a cyclobutane derivative especially purified for us. We analyzed the fatigue product of the photolysis of HABIs and found these to be the parent triarylimidazoles (Scheme 4.4). Could we have formulated a mixture in which air-oxidation of the imidazole could regenerate the dimer? Surprisingly, that may work. In order to establish the possible stability of the biimidazoles in a ‘‘window’’ environment, we poured a benzene solution of the dimer of 2-(p-methoxyphenyl)-4,5-diphenylimidazole into a hollow glass brick, and put in a rubber stopper to ‘‘seal’’ the system. We positioned the glass brick in a window, and watched it turn blue during the day and less blue when the sun set. It worked for several months; but by then, we had turned our attention to photo-oxidation.
VI.
1961—PERMANENT COLOR
Cescon and I had wondered if we could make polymeric HABIs. One proposed way was to make a biimidazole in which terephthaldehyde was used as starting material, and Jenkins provided us with this material. When Cescon oxidized this under his standard conditions, an intense bright blue color resulted (Scheme 4.5). I was impressed by it, but it would not reverse. Cescon said perhaps we should make permanent color from HABIs photochemically and not try to
146 N
H N
N N
N H
N
N
N
H N
N
Scheme 4.5
Biimidazole from terephthaldehyde
N H
N
N N
Blue-colored oxidation product
N N
147
1961—PERMANENT COLOR
achieve reversibility. I told him that perhaps we could oxidize leucodyes instead, remembering some work done earlier at DuPont, in which a series of novel leucodyes were made for a program related to spirit duplication, Until the development of electrophotography, a facile means of making multiple copies of a document was to type on a waxy stencil material, which permitted ink to penetrate through the typed and ruptured areas—this was called mimeographing. Another, less expensive process was called spirit duplication. Here one typed on a waxy sheet of paper, and the typing ruptured a coating, which was applied over a layer containing triarylmethane dyes, usually Crystal Violet. The rupture of the wax layer permitted transfer of the dye to a sheet of high holdout paper temporarily wetted with ethanol (spirits of methanol). With some of these, as many as 100 copies could be obtained. The process could also be repeated with other colors, and so a multicolored copy sheet could be obtained at relatively low cost. It is safe to say that most examinations in schools and colleges up to the 1950s were written to questions, which were printed out on Crystal Violet image papers. Major manufacturers of these products were the Ditto Corp. and Columbia Carbon and Ribbon. DuPont’s Organic Chemicals Department manufactured large quantities of Crystal Violet dye—many hundreds of thousands of pounds per year—it was the largest volume dye at one time. Someone in Orchem research management had conceived an idea for a better product. The weakness of spirit duplication systems was that the wax sheets inevitably leaked color onto the hands of the people who handled them. Secretaries hated them, as the intense colors in the wax matrix transferred to clothing, causing severe staining. Why not have a leucodye, i.e., a colorless precursor of a dye present in the wax layer, and moisten the receiver sheet with an alcoholic solution of an oxidant? For a variety of reasons, the preferred oxidant was chloranil (tetrachlorobenzophenone), an inexpensive, colorless, and effective material (Scheme 4.6). Unfortunately, this compound also gave rise to hydrochloric acid
(C 2 H5 )2 N
CH3
(C 2 H5 )2 N
N(C 2 H5 )2
CH3
CH3
C 2 H5
CH3 CHLORANIL
N
CH2
C 2 H5
CH3 N(C 2 H5 )2
(C 2 H5 )2 N DYE
LEUCODYE TLA-454
Scheme 4.6
148
THE INVENTION OF DYLUX
and thus caused corrosion of the metal parts of the duplicating machinery. Were other oxidants tried? I do not know. Just the same, the program was terminated; but Walter Balon, who had developed the leucodye tris(p-diethylamino-o-tolyl)methane, retained samples in his laboratory for several years. This dye had the code name TLA-454, which simply indicated that it was the 454th dye sample that had been submitted to the Technical Laboratory at the Chambers Works, which was in charge of evaluating materials that were considered for commercialization. I remembered Balon’s TLA-454 and thought it would be worth trying as a leucodye in combination with the radicals generated by photolysis of triarylimidazoles. To our great satisfaction, a solution containing HABI, and TLA-454, p-toluenesulfonic acid in acetone turned an intense blue in sunlight. We made fresh solution as above, dipped filter paper in it, let it dry, and produced an intense color with a flash of light. This ultimately lead to a number of patents, typical of which was U.S. Patent 3,585,038. Our goal was to cover all possible aspects of HABI-related photo-oxidation. During the period from 1964 to 1972, many leucodye oxidation patents issued to Cescon and his co-workers. We called this technology UVI–Ultraviolet Imaging. Photosensitive composition. Cescon, Lawrence. (du Pont de Nemours, E. I., and Co.) U.S. 3,445,233 (Cl. 6-90; G 03c), 20 May 1969, Appl. 16 Apr 1965; 9 pp. A simple, rapid, and dry process for the production of colored visible images is described. A light-sensitive compn. consisting of essentially colorless oxidizable N-contg. org. color-generator (I), a photooxidant (II), such as CBr4, a tetraarylhydrazine, etc., and a light-sensitive aromatic diazonium compd. (III) such as p-anilinobenzenediazonium sulfate, is irradiated with light of wavelength W1 to form the image. Deactivation achieved when irradiated with light of wavelength W2. A neg. image is formed when the compn. is irradiated in reverse order. Three types of I are: (a) leuco dyes, preferably aminotriarylmethane; (b) org. amines; (c) aromatic diamines with a coupling agent. II when mixed with I and irradiated with W1, of 200–420 nm oxidizes I to said-color permanently. Initiator and acceptor types of mechanisms are shown. III is added to compn. in order that the photosensitive compn. produced by I and II may be deactivated by exposure to light of wavelength W2, 200–550 nm, thus producing a reducing agent that is a 1,2- or 1,4-aminohydroxy- or -dihydroxybenzene or -naphthalene. Preferred ratios of II to I range from 1:1 to 2:1, and of III to II 0.2:01.0–10:1. Hexaarylbiimidazole oxidation systems. Cescon Lawrence A.; Dessauer, Rolf (du Pont de Nemours, E. I., and Co.) U.S. 3,585,038 (Cl. 96-90; G 03c), 15 Jun 1971, Appl. Apr 29, 1964–13 Nov 1967; 8 pp. Systems useful in photog. thermog., pattern layout, etc., are composed of a 2,20 ,4,40 ,5,50 -hexaarylbiimidazole (I) component and an oxidizable component. Methods for activating the I compd. are heat, pressure, light, electron beam which form a free radical that then oxidizes the oxidizable component. The aryl group for I may be Ph, phenyl, naphthyl, furyl, or thienyl groups having an ortho substituent of F, Cl, Br, lower alkyl, or lower alkoxy group. The oxidizable components are selected from the following classes of
1961—PERMANENT COLOR
149
compds.: p-arylenedi-tertiary-amines, p-phenylene diamines, hydrazones, o,o0 -disubstituted phenols or org. sulfhydryl compds. The 2 components are mixed by dissolving in a solvent or by mech. blending and can be used in a polymeric binder, coated on a substrate or on a film. Leuco dye photocopy system. Cescon, Lawrence A. (du Pont de Nemours, E. I., and Co.) Ger. l,772,534 (Cl. G 03c), 02 Mar 1972, Appl. P 17 72 534.7-51, 31 May 1968, 8 pp. A leuco dye photocopy system is based on photooxidn. of an aminotriarylmethane leuco dye by 1-2 moles of a hexaarylbisimidazole to the dye in uv (250–370 nm) radiation (U.K. 1,047,569; CA 66:50700m) and the inactivation of the oxidant at longer wavelengths by a redox combination of 1,6- or 1,8-pyrenequinone and (or) 9,10-phenanthrenequinone with 1–40 moles of a Cl–4 alkyl nitrilotriacetate (or -propionate) as reductant. When irradiated at 380–500 nm the quinone is reduced to a hydroquinone which then reacts with the photooxidant to form a colorless compd., thus inactivating the light-sensitive system. Either wavelength range may be used for the imagewise (1st) exposure. Thus, a paper support coated with an Me2CO soln. contg. polypropylene glycol, cellulose acetate butyrate, pyrenequinone, 2,20 -bis(o-chlorophenyl)-4,40 ,5,50 -tetraphenylbisimidazole, tris(4diethylamino-o-tolyl)-methane, tri-Me-3,30 ,300 -nitrilotripropionate, and p-MeC6H4SO3H, was imagewise exposed to radiation at 250–390 nm and then re-exposed to radiation >390 nm to give a clear sharp image on a white background. Further irradn. showed no visible effect on the background or the image. Storage-stable, light-sensitive compositions comprising an aminotriarylmethane and an organic photooxidant. Cescon, Lawrence A. (du Pont de Nemours, E. I., and Co.) U.S. 3,598,592 (Cl. 96-85; G 03c), 10 Aug 1971, Appl. 29 Apr 1964–07 Nov 1967; 7 pp. Mixts. of aminotriaryl-methane compds., such as tris-(4-diethylaminoo-tolyl)methane (I), and photooxidants, such as Cl2BrCCBrCl2, form light-sensitive compns. that develop color rapidly when exposed to light of certain wavelengths, but will not undergo color formation under ordinary darkroom conditions. Thus, 2.6 in.2 of Whatman No. 1 filter paper was treated with a soln. contg. 0.0125 M I and 0.025 M Cl2BrCCBrCl2 in 50/50 by vol. DMF-C6H6 and dried at room temp. to give per in.2 of dried paper 0.5 mg I and 0.8 mg Cl2BrCCBrCl2. After exposure of a portion of the sheet to a 275 W sun lamp, the paper was stored in a darkroom for 2 weeks. Upon removal and examn., the paper showed no color change in the unexposed areas. Hexaarylbisimidazole oxidation system. Cescon, Lawrence A.; Dessauer, Rolf (du Pont de Nemours, E. I., and Co.) Ger. Offen. 2,028,124 (Cl. CO9k, C 07), 16 Dec 1971, Appl. 08 Jun 1970; 42 pp. A free radical imaging system contains a bisimidazole I (R ¼ H, Cl ) and an oxidizable compd. with a formal oxidn. potential of 1.35 V vs. SCE. The oxidizable compd. is preferably p-(Me2N)2C6H4, PhNMe2, 2,6-(Me3C)2C6H30H, 2,6-(MeO)2C6H30H, hydroquinone, 3-methyl-2benzothiazolone hydrazone, or 2-thenoylacetonitrile. Flash photolysis of 0.01 104 II p-(Me2N)2C6H4.2HCl and 2 104 M I (R ¼ Cl) caused the formation of Wurster’s blue with a rate const. of 7 107 l./mole sec. The p-(Me2N)2C6H4 2HCI had a formal oxidn. potential of 0.96 V. Paper soaked in p-(Me2N)2C6H4 0.272, PhOH 0.094, and I (R ¼ Cl) 0.66) g, and dried turned blue on exposure to sunlight.
150
THE INVENTION OF DYLUX
N
N
R 2
I Hexaarylbiimidazole oxidation systems. Cescon Lawrence A.; Dessauer, Rolf (du Pont de Nemours, E. I., and Co.) Brit. 1,271,177 (Cl. G 03c, C 07cd, C 09b), 19 Apr 1972 Appl. 26,161, 70, 29 May 1970; 13 pp. Color copies are obtained with an imaging system comprised of a heat-, pressure-, light-, or electron beam-sensitive hexaarylbiimidazole and an oxidizable compd. having an oxidn. product that reacts with an admixed coupler to form a dye image. Upon activation the biimidazole forms the free radical triarylimidazolyl, which oxidizes the color producing compd. such as N-acylhydrazone oxidizable to diazonium compds., in combination with a coupler to form the dye. Thus, to 50 ml of a soln. contg. 20 parts by vol. of DMF and 8 parts MeOH are added 0.212 g of N,N-dimethyl-p-phenylene diamine, 0.094 g of PhOH, and 0.66 g of 2,20 -bis(o-chlorophenyl)-4,40 ,5,50 -tetraphenylbiimidazole. Unsized paper is impregnated with this soln. and dried by ir heating, the operation being carried out in dim light. Exposure of this treated paper to a sunlamp turns the paper blue.
Cescon and I repeated the experiment for George Coraor, who was duly impressed by it, as were others in our group. At that time, George reported to Dr. Alfred C. Haven, who initially was somewhat slow in sharing our enthusiasm for photo-oxidation, as we called our process, because he had sold his management on the fact that we were making photochromic materials that were to be reversible. This was one of many instances in my career with DuPont where I found that new applications, derived from programs that were expected to deliver another specified application, were not enthusiastically received by management. It was simply that to get a program started it had to be sold to too many people, who would then object to deviations from a selected path. In time, however, the idea of generating dyes with light was augmented with a program to generate dyes electrolytically. Still, Coraor said he saw that we had something more marketable than photochromic compounds, although we had a limited idea as to what to do with the light-induced color change. In any event, photo-oxidation did not lead to reversible, reusable materials, and conceptually, this would lead to a larger market than a product that was reversible. If only one could identify a market. A few weeks later, we were to have a research review, a session at which scientists
1961—PERMANENT COLOR
151
presented the results of their work to the entire research management of Orchem. This then included Ernsberger, the director of research; Dr. G. M. Whitman, the assistant director of research; Haven; and a few others. A few days before the review, on a ski trip, I met Tim Chilton, who was in the company’s Development Department. Tim’s father was a highly respected engineer, who was well known throughout the company. Tim had just completed a survey on office copying for the company and appeared knowledgeable in the reprographics field. I had told him what we had come up with, and he asked if he could come to our research review to learn more. I went to his home for dinner the night before, and he said he could probably sell this chemistry to our management. When the review began, Ernsberger asked Tim who he was and what he was doing there. Tim presented himself very positively, described his background and allowed that we might be on the verge of a great discovery, if it were properly pursued. He said that he knew of nothing like it, which may have been of ignorance, but it sounded as though he knew what he was talking about. After that, everyone wanted to expose filter papers to form colors with a flash of light; our color repertory was somewhat enhanced with leuco dyes that gave green, blue black and violet colors. Enthusiasm really ran high, and this was the only review in my career at which management people stayed around well after quitting time, suggesting what we should do. It looked like photooxidation had rescued HABI chemistry just in time! Even though our experimental work was crude, Ernsberger said that we should show what we had to the Photo Products Department, who after all were in charge of the company’s photographic business and were considered to have expertise in the field. Coraor and I went to see their director of research, Dr. Frank Signaigo, who in turn had invited a few of his subordinates to our show. They were not very impressed, explaining to us that the color-forming process requiring contact with a photographic flashgun was photographically slow, and that until we had good black-and-white images, we had little of interest to them. By that time we had made stencils and even obtained some photographic negatives, which we used to modulate the light from the flashgun. The photographic negatives inevitably fried when exposed with a flashgun, until we learned that the intense heat absorbed by the silver coating could be deflected by employing a cobalt blue or similar filter. We then made more respectable images of the photographic negatives, albeit, still onto filter paper.
A. What Do You Do with This Stuff? After our first research review, where Cescon and I demonstrated photo-oxidation with HABIs, Chilton was assigned to the program. He and I speculated for many hours about possible applications. Obviously, if we could apply this technology
152
THE INVENTION OF DYLUX
to re