ADVANCES IN FOOD RESEARCH VOLUME 24
Contributors to This Volume
Sally Hudson Arnold W . Duane Brown Reiner Hamm Klau...
34 downloads
1678 Views
19MB Size
Report
This content was uploaded by our users and we assume good faith they have the permission to share this book. If you own the copyright to this book and it is wrongfully on our website, we offer a simple DMCA procedure to remove your content from our site. Start by pressing the button below!
Report copyright / DMCA form
ADVANCES IN FOOD RESEARCH VOLUME 24
Contributors to This Volume
Sally Hudson Arnold W . Duane Brown Reiner Hamm Klaus Hofmann Walter M. Urbain Jonathan W. White, Jr. Robert L. Wickremasinghe
ADVANCES IN FOOD RESEARCH VOLUME 24
Edited by C. 0. CHICHESTER The Nutrition Foundation, Inc. New York. New York and University of Rhode Island Kingston. Rho& Island
E. M. MRAK
G . F. STEWART
University of California Davis, California
University of Calif(omia Davis, California
Editorial Board S. LEPKOVSKY EDWARD SELTZER W . M. URBAIN J . R. VICKERY
E. C. BATE-SMITH J . HAWTHORN M. A. JOSLYN J . F. KEFFORD
1978
ACADEMIC PRESS
New York
San Francisco
A Subsidiary of Harcourt Brace Jovanovich. Publishers
London
C O P Y R I C l i T @ 1978, BY ACADEMIC PRESS, INC. ALL RIGHTS RESERVED. N O PART O F THIS PUBLICATION MAY BE REPRODUCED OR TRANSMITTED IN ANY F O R M OR BY ANY MEANS, ELECTRONIC OR MECHANICAL, INCLUDING PHOTOCOPY, RECORDING, OR ANY INFORMATION STORAGE AND RETRIEVAL SYSTEM, WITHOUT PERMISSION IN WRITING FHOM T H E PUBLISHER.
ACADEMIC PRESS, INC.
111 Fifth Avenue, New York, N e w York 10003
Uiiifcd Kiii,stlorir Edifioti prrblislred b y ACADEMIC PRESS, INC. ( L O N D O N ) LTD. 24/28 Oval Road, London NW1 7DX
LIBRARY O F CONGRESS CATALOG CARD
ISBN
NUMBER: 48-7808
0-12-016424-8
PRINTkD IN 1 H E UNITED STATES 01: AMERICA
CONTENTS Contributors to Volume 24 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
vii
Sulfhydryl and Disulfide Groups in Meats Klaus Hofmann and Reiner H a m
I. 11 .
111. I \. . V. VI . VIl . VrII . IX .
Introduction . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Methods for the Determination of SH and SS Groups . . ................... SH Groups in Muscle Proteins and Their Role in the Fu n of Muscle . . . . . . . . SH and SS Content of Meats and Meat Fractions . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Intluence of Processing on the SH and SS Groups of Meat . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Influence of the SH Groups on the Shelf Life of Meat and Meat Products . . . . . . . . Toxicological Aspects . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Summary . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Research Needs . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . References . . . . . . . . . ........................................
2 3 30 43 58 84 84 86 88 88
Histamine (7) Toxicity from Fish Products Sally Hudson Arnold and W . Duane Brown
I. 11. I11. IV . V.
Nature of the Problem . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Mechanisms of Formation of Histamine in Fish . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Detection and Determination of Levels of Histamine in Fish . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Relationship o f Spoilage to Histarnine Formation . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Unresolved Problems . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . ................... References . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
114 121 130 135 139 147
Food Irradiation Walter M . Urbain
I. I1 I11 IV . V. VI . VII
Introduction-Historical Background . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .......... ....... Radiation and Radiation Sources . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . General Effects of Radiation . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Applications of Food Irradiation . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Economics of Food Irradiation . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Wholesomeness of Irradiated Foods . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . ............ The Future of Food Irradiation . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . References . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
155
163 168 174 205 209 213 216
V
vi
CONTENTS
lea Robert L. Wickremasinghe I. U. UI . IV . V. V. VI. VI.
vu .
VIII . IX . X.
......_......... Introduction . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Composition of Tea .. . . . . . . . . . .... Changes during the Processing of Tea . . . . .. .. .......... . . Organoleptic Properties .. . ....... . .. .. . .. ....... . .. .. ........ . .. . Storage of Tea . . . . . . . . .. ..... . . . . . . . . . . . . ................. Potential By-Products . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Clinical Effects .. .. .. .. .. .. .. . . . . . . . Host Plant-Pest Relationships .................... Instant Tea . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Additional Research Needs . . . . . . . . . . . . . . ........................ ........................ References . . . . . . . ............................. .. ... .... .. ... ......... References.
229 232 25 I 263 266 268 269 27 1 272 213 273
Honey Jonathan W. W. White, Jr. Introduction ........................... Production and Processing ....................... Market Forms of Honey. . . . . Analysis and Composition Compositio . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Analysis Physical Characteristics . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Storage of Honey . . . . .. .. . . . . . . . vn. Nutritive Value . ....................... ......................... VUI . Uses . . . . . . . . . . . . VUI IX , Standards, Specifications, an IX X. Research Needs . .................... X References.. . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . .................... References
288 289 295 291 333 344 352 354 358 363 364
Subject Index . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
375
I. U. U. Ill. IV. V. V VI. VI.
I
CONTRIBUTORS TO VOLUME 24 Numbers in parentheses indicate the pages on which the authors' contributions begin.
SALLY HUDSON ARNOLD, Institute of Marine Resources, Department of Food Science and Technology, University of California, Davis, California 95616 (113) W. DUANE BROWN, Institute of Marine Resources, Department of Food Science and Technology, University of California, Davis, California 95616 (113) REINER HAMM, Bundesanstalt fur Fleischforschung, Kulmbach, Germany ( I ) KLAUS HOFMA", Bundesanstalt fur Fleischforschung, Kulmbach, Germany (1)
WALTER M. URBAIN ,* Michigan State University, East Lansing, Michigan 48824 (155) JONATHAN W. WHITE, JR., Eastern Regional Research Center, Philadelphia, Pennsylvania I91 18 (287) ROBERT L. WICKREMASINGHE, Tea Research Institute of Sri Lanka, Coombs, Talawakelle, Sri Lunka (229)
St.
*Present address: 10645 Welk Drive, Sun City, Arizona 85351.
vii
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
ADVANCFS IN FOOD RL-%ARCH
.
VOI .
24
SULFHYDRYL AND DlSULFlDE GROUPS IN MEATS* KLAUS HOFMANN AND REINER HAMM
I . Introduction . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . I1 . Methods for the Determination of SH and SS Group:, . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . A . General Problems in the Determination of SH Groups in Soluble and Insoluble Proteins . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .................... B . Methods for the Determination of SH Group Meats . . . . . . . . . . . . . . C . Determination of SS Groups . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 111. SH Groups in Muscle Proteins and Their Role in the Function of A . Myofibrillar Proteins . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . B . Proteins of the Sarcoplasniic Reticulum (SR) . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . C . Proteins of the Sarcolemma . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . D . Proteins of Mitochondria . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . E . Proteins of the Sarcoplasmic Matrix . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . IV . SH and SS Content of Meats and Meat Fractions . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . A . SH and SS Content of Muscles . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . B . Cysteine plus Cystine Content of Muscles .............. C . SH Content of Organs . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . D . Fdctim Influencing the SH Content of Raw Meat . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . V . Influence of Processing on the SH and SS Groups of Meat . . . A . Influence of Heating . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . B . Freezing and Frozen Storage . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . C . Freeze-Drying . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . D . Curing . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . E . Ripening of Dry Sausages . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . F . Smoking . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . G . Irradiation . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . V1 . lnfluence of the SH Groups on the Shelf Life of Meat and Meat Products . . VII . Toxicological Aspects . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . VIII . Summary . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . IX . Research Needs . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . References . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
2 3 3 6 28 30 31 41 41 42 42 43 4.5 50 52 5.5 58 58 13 77 77 80 80 81 84 84 86 88 88
.
*Dedicated to Professor Dr . Alfons Schiiberl Hannover (Germany). a pioneer in the chemistry of organic sulfur compounds .
Copyright 0 1978 by Academic Press Inc . All righn of reproduction in any form rebewed. ISBN 0-12-016424-8
.
2
KLAUS H O F M A N N A N D REINER H A M M
I. INTRODUCTION Reviews on the occurrence, properties, and functional importance of SH groups in biological systems were recently presented in three comprehensive monographs (Jocelyn, 1972; Friedman, 1973; J. M. Tortschinski, 1974). However, the research on SH and SS groups in muscle tissue used for food has not yet been reviewed, although a considerable amount of work has been done in this field. SH groups are usually considered to be the most reactive functional groups in proteins (Wallenfels and Streffer, 1964); but under certain conditions the reactivity of these groups can be more or less inhibited. It is understandable, therefore, that SH groups in proteins have attracted the attention of many research workers and that the role of SH groups in proteins has been the subject of a large number of investigations. SH groups can easily be oxidized to SS groups, the SH/SS redox equilibrium 2 R-SH
+t
0 2
R-SS-R
+ H20
or 2 R-S- - 2e
* R-S-S-R
being of great biological importance. Consequently, in any discussion of the role of SH groups, a consideration of SS groups must also be included. It is the purpose of this review to discuss the methods for the determination of SH and SS groups in proteins and to assess the importance of these groups in meat quality and meat processing. Most of the work taken into consideration here is related to red meats (muscles from cattle, pigs, and sheep) and poultry; fish is only occasionally mentioned. Amino acids, cysteine and cystine, are the carriers of the SH and SS groups in proteins. Knowledge on the reactions of these amino acids is therefore indispensable for an understanding of the reactivity of SH and SS groups in biological systems. Most of the SH (and SS) groups in meat are located in the muscle proteins (see Table V). Because only a small proportion of these groups exists as low molecular SHES compounds, mainly glutathion, the research discussed in this review is primarily related to protein SH. Cysteine and cystine content is of great importance for the nutritive value of meat, as it is for most foods. Although cysteine and cystine do not belong to the essential amino acids, a deficiency of “total cystine” (sum of cysteine and cystine) in nutrition increases the requirement of one of these essential amino acids, methionine, which can be metabolized to cysteine. The methionine content of food proteins also limits their nutritive value. For this reason, a sufficient
SULFHYDRYL AND DISULFIDE GROUPS IN MEATS
3
supply of “total cysteine” helps to spare methionine in the intermediate metabolism. Any destruction of cysteine or cystine during the treatment of foods as indicated by the disappearance of SH plus SS groups represents a detrimental effect on nutritive value. It is evident, therefore, that studies of SH (and SS) changes during the storage and processing of meat are of particular interest for the nutritionist. It should be mentioned that reliable information on changes in the SH and SS content of proteins can be obtained by direct determination of these groups in the intact system. This approach is preferable to amino acid determination after hydrolysis because the problem of an exact determination of these amino acids after hydrolysis by acids or enzymes has not yet been satisfactorily solved. The importance of SH and SS groups in sensoric quality as well as for the processing of foods has been investigated for many years. This research has related mainly to milk and other dairy products (particularly cheese), cereals, doughs, and beer (Hofmann, 197 la). Corresponding work on meats started about 15 years ago. The assay of SH and SS groups is extremely difficult for a number of reasons. We will, therefore, discuss the various methods of SH and SS analysis available and examine the interpretation of the results of each in detail. Our lack of knowledge on the role of SH and SS groups in meat is mainly due to the difficulties in the determination of protein SH. It is our hope that the gaps and contradictions in our understanding of SH and SS groups which are presented in this review will initiate further research in this field.
II.
METHODS FOR THE DETERMINATION OF SH AND SS GROUPS
This chapter will present a review of methods which are used or which may be useful for the quantitative assay of SH and SS groups in animal tissues and muscle proteins. Histometrical methods for the demonstration of the location of SH groups using dyes are briefly discussed. A. GENERAL PROBLEMS IN THE DETERMINATION OF SH GROUPS IN SOLUBLE AND INSOLUBLE PROTEINS The complicated problems of SH assay in proteins have been thoroughly presented and critically discussed in several review articles (e.g., Cecil and McPhee, 1959; Benesch and Benesch, 1962; Leach, 1966; Hofmann and Hamm, 1974a; Ashworth, 1976). With nondissolved proteins, e.g., muscle homogenates, additional difficulties arise which should be examined in detail (Hamm and Hofmann, 1966a). It has been observed that, in certain proteins in the native state, the total
4
KLAUS HOFMANN AND REINER HAMM
number of sulfhydryl groups is not available to chemical reagents. Not all proteins, however, demonstrate this behavior. Moreover, the number of SH groups which react depends on several internal and external factors: the nature of the protein, the presence or absence of denaturing agents, temperature, pH value, the kind and concentration of SH reagent used, and the time of reaction. There are, therefore, several degrees of availability of protein SH groups. The difficulties in SH determination in proteins are due partly to the methods themselves and partly to differences in the reactivity of those groups. Many times the SH values determined are lower than the actual SH content; in some cases they are higher. For the confirmation of a certain result, several reagents should be applied for SH determination as has been recommended by Benesch and Benesch (1962). If the results of these various analyses differ from each other, additional investigation is necessary. In Table I the different factors leading to incorrect results are summarized. An incomplete reaction of protein SH groups can be due to three different reasons: (a) steric hindrance of SH groups by the specific structure of the protein, (b) interaction of SH with other functional groups (combined function), and (c) repulsion between hydrophilic reagents and hydrophobic groups (particularly TABLE I FACTORS LEADING TO WRONG RESULTS IN THE DETERMINATION OF SH GROUPS IN PROTEINS"
SH value too low Nonreactive (inaccessible, inavaiI able, masked, hidden) SH groupsb Incomplete reaction (slowly reacting groups; reaction time is too short. e.g., at direct titration)
SH groups are partially oxidized by oxygen (air) before or during the determination (SH -+ SS)
SH value too high Unspecific SH reagent (reaction or complex formation with other functional groups of protein) Interference by substances which consume SH reagent (e.g., ascorbic acid if an oxidizing reagent is used; or J-, Br- and S2- at titration with AgNO,) Cleavage of SS to SH groups by the SH reagent or by hydrolysis
After Hofmann and Hamm (1974a). The reasons for an unsufficient reactivity of SH groups need only a brief summary in the text because they were discussed in detail by Hofmann and Hamm (1974a). a
SULFHYDRYL AND DISULFIDE GROUPS IN MbATS
5
alkyl residues) located in the vicinity of SH groups (hydrophobic environment). Denaturing agents (urea, guanidine, dodecyl sulfate) or heating usually cause an elimination of these inhibiting influences. This might be due to an unfolding of the peptide chains of protein which makes the SH groups accessible to SH reagents. Because of the powerful reducing field required for such a reaction (Chibnall, 1943), the old supposition that SH groups are produced by the actual cleavage of the S-S linkage is no longer satisfactory. Chibnall(l943) suggested a hydrolytic cleavage of thiol ester linkages (R-CO-S-R’) during denaturation, but this type of linkage has not yet been demonstrated in proteins. In addition, the assumption that the formation of free SH groups during denaturation is due to an opening of thiazoline ring systems present in proteins (Linderstr@m-Langand Jacobsen, 1941) has not been confirmed by studies with model systems (Martin el al., 1959; Kolthoff and Shore 1964; Hofmann, I966a). According to another hypothesis, proteins contain isothiuronium residues which can react with amino groups to cause SH formation (Brush ef al., 1963). It is certain that the binding of some SH reagents (such as Ag+ ions or PCMB) to easily available SH groups can result in a denaturation of the protein which makes other hidden SH groups easily available (Bocchini et al., 1967; Jeckel and Pfleiderer, 1969). The denaturation of a protein usually makes the SH groups more easily oxidizable by oxygen. This can be prevented by the addition of EDTA (Sakai and Dan, 1959; Calcutt and Doxey, 1962). which sequesters catalyzing traces of heavy metals; 0.02 M EDTA is sufficient for the protection of SH groups (Sedlak and Lindsay, 1968) although 0.2 M EDTA was normally used in the preparation of homogenates (Tarnowski et al., 1965). According to their reactivity, protein SH groups are usually divided into three categories: fast reacting, slowly reacting, and nonreacting. However, this schematic classification is quite arbitrary. It does not take into consideration that the reactivity of an SH group is not an absolute property of this group. This reactivity depends essentially on the type of reagent used as well as other factors, e.g., pH or buffer systems. For this reason, very different SH values are often obtained after the reaction of the native protein with different reagents (Cecil and McPhee, 1959). The same is true for SH determination in meat (see Section IV). A great number of SH reagents are available (more than one hundred), which indicates the lack of a universally applicable method which is satisfying in every respect. The choice of method depends on the type of investigation in question because the determination of SH groups can have several different purposes: (1) Determination of total cystine content (cysteine plus half cystine) after complete reduction of SS groups in the course of the analysis of amino acids. Such an SH assay with the nonhydrolyzed protein prevents losses of cysteine and cystine from occurring during hydrolysis (Friedman, 1974) as already mentioned. (2) Investigation of the role of SH groups in the biological function of proteins.
6
KLAUS HOFMANN A N D REINER HAMM
(3) Study of the process of protein denaturation connected with a change (usually an increase) in the reactivity of SH groups. (4) Study of the reaction of protein SH groups with lead, mercury, other heavy metals, toxins, carcinogenic compounds, and other substances which are of relevance for environmental pollution, health hazards, and residue analysis. In this respect the protective effects of and the detoxification by SH groups in foods are of particular interest. Considering these different purposes of SH research, it is not always necessary to determine the total amount of SH groups in proteins; in some cases the determination of only the easily available SH groups of the native protein by a convenient reagent is intended (e.g., in cases 2 and 3 above). But other factors are also important for the correct selection of an SH assay method. Not all SH reagents are suitable for the SH determination in proteins, and only a small part of the reagents suggested for the SH determination in proteins can be used for the unsoluble proteins of muscle tissue (Hamm and Hofmann, 1966a). Reagents which can be used for studies on meat must fulfill the following requirements: (1) Because organic solvents cause the denaturation of muscle proteins, the SH reagent must be soluble in water. (2) The pH of the reagent solution should be approximately 7 in order to prevent denaturation by an acid or a base. (3) It must be possible to measure the excess of a reagent or a soluble reaction product after the reaction. (4) The SH reagent or the reaction product has to be stable because the reaction with undissolved proteins requires a relatively long amount of time. (5) The method has to be sensitive because of the low SH content of animal tissues. The determination of SS groups is usually based on the determination of SH groups before and after reduction of SS to SH. Here, both the complete reduction of all disulfide groups as well as the prevention of an oxidation of SH groups formed are necessary. Generally, a complete unfolding of the proteins by denaturing agents (e.g., urea, guanidinium hydrochloride) is important in order to provide a complete reduction of the S S groups.
B. METHODS FOR THE DETERMINATION OF SH GROUPS IN MEATS The number of reagents that are used or are suitable for the determination of SH groups in proteins, peptides, and amino acids is so great that it is not possible to discuss all of the possibilities in this review. Fortunately, this is also not necessary because of several excellent publications. A review on the function and analysis of SH groups in proteins was given by Heide (1955), who described in detail a modem assay based on amperometric titration with silver nitrate. Vol-
SULFHYDRYL AND DlSULFlDE GROUPS IN MEATS
7
uminous reports were presented by Cecil and McPhee (1959), Cecil (1963), and Leach (1966). Benesch and Benesch (1962) discussed the problems in the determination of SH groups, particularly in regard to the mercaptide formation with AgNO, and mercury compounds. The comprehensive publication of Lumper and Zahn ( I 965) includes important analytical aspects of the biochemistry of the disulfide exchange. Kakai: and Vejddek (1 974) summarized methods for the photometric determination of SH and SS groups, including a discussion of interfering factors. The application of organic mercury compounds for the chemical analysis of sulfur compounds (including SH and SS groups in proteins) was described by Wronski (1965). A further review article on the determination of SH and SS groups in proteins was published by Mesrob and Holesovsky (1967). The most recent information can be found in the monographs of Jocelyn (1972), Friedman (1973), and Ashworth (1976). This review first discusses the methods for the determination of SH and S S groups in meats and muscle proteins. Furthermore, those methods are considered which seem to be generally applicable for the determination of SH groups in insoluble material but which have been used thus far only for other biological systems such as flour or keratine. The determination of SH groups after complete reduction of SS groups allows the determination of the content of “total cystine” (cysteine plus cystine) without hydrolysis of the protein. The problems in cystine determination associated with the hydrolysis of proteins are described by Friedman (1974): “Direct assay of cystine by ion-exchange chromatography usually gives low values.. . . Consequently, many attempts have been made to change cystine residues to acid stable derivatives. . . . However, most of these attempts do not prevent complete destruction of the modified residues during acid hydrolysis, and the new derivatives are sometimes incompletely resolved on the chromatogram of an amino acid analyzer.” A further disadvantage in the application of protein hydrolysis is the fact that in most cases it is impossible to differentiate between SH groups and SS groups originally present. In this review the discussion of SH assay is therefore focused on methods applicable to the intact, nonhydrolized proteins. Such procedures present the additional advantage of allowing the study of the process of denaturation by following the changes in the reactivity of SH groups. The availability of the SH groups of a protein depends on its state in the protein structure and on the type of reagent used. Usually a denaturing agent [concentrated solutions of urea, guanidinium hydrochloride or, in our opinion the most suitable, diluted sodium dodecyl sulfate (also named lauryl sulfate or Duponol) solutions] has to be used in order to determine the total quantity of protein SH groups. With Ag+ ions, however, all SH groups can also be determined in the native meat protein ( H a m and Hofmann, 1965).
8
KLAUS H O F M A N N A N D REINER H A M M
The SH reagents can be divided into (1) oxidizing agents (2 RSH + RSSR), (2) mercaptide-forming agents (RSH .+ RSMe’, (RS)2Me”), (3) alkylating agents (RSH + RSR), and (4)other reagents. The reactions are usually measured either by spectrophotometry (including fluorometry) or by titration. The end-point of titration is mostly determined by means of electrometric methods (potentiometry, polarography , or amperometry). 1. Oxidizing Agents, Including Disiilfides
In most earlier research oxidizing agents known from oxidimetric methods were most often used, including iodine, ferricyanide, o-iodosobenzoate, porphyridin, 2,6-dichlorophenol-indophenol(Barron, 1951) and phosphoric tungstic acid (Folin and Morenzi, 1929).The desired reaction 2 RSH
- 2e + R-SS-R + 2H+
does not always occur in a stoichometric way because the sulfur of the SH group can be oxidized to a valence higher than that of disulfide. Furthermore, the influence of other reducing substances present in biological material (e.g., ascorbic acid or thiamine) can interfere in the reaction. More recently, the use of N-bromosuccinimide for the determination of cysteine and cystine has been described (Thibert et al., 1969;Bachhawat el af., 1973).However, this reagent is not highly specific. A different type of oxidation is the reaction of SH groups with disulfides encompassing an SH-SS exchange: R’SH
+ R-SS-R + R‘SS-R + R-SH
Numerous methods for the determination of SH groups in proteins are based on this type of reaction. Mirsky and Anson (1935)have treated protein SH groups with cystine and determined the obtained cysteine by reaction with phosphoric tungstic acid. Protein-bound SH groups in tissue slices can be visualized with 2,2’-dihydroxy-6,6’-dinaphtyl disulfide; a procedure introduced by Barnett and Seligman (1952). After the SH-SS exchange, the naphtol residue bound to the protein is coupled with tetrazotized diorthoanisidine to a red dye. It is also possible to extract the excess reagent from the tissue and to determine it after coupling to the red dye (Flesch et al., 1954). Ellman (1959) introduced the disulfide 5,5’-dithiobis (2-nitrobenzoic acid) (DTNB, Ellman’s reagent) which is now widely used for the determination of SH and SS groups in tissues (Ellman. 1959;Gabay et al., 1968;Khan el al., 1968;Sedlak and Lindsay, 1968;Dube, 1969; Caldwell and Lineweaver, 1969; Dzinleski et al., 1969; Yuan, 1970; Randall and Bratzler, 1970;Buttkus, 1971;Bowers, 1972;Boyne and Ellman, 1972;Dub6 et al., 1972;Habeeb, 1972;Hay et al., 1973;Miller and Spencer,
9
SULFHYDRYL AND DISULFIDE GROUPS I N MEATS
197.5; Usunov and Zolova, 1976). In basic solution, the disulfide DTNB (I) reacts quickly with dissociated SH groups in proteins as follows:
COO-
COO-
+
protein-SS &NO2-
[-S&NOz -
-
S
COO-
e p Q
-
(11)
H s -&Noz (111)
The resulting anion of the mesomeric 3-carboxy-4-nitro-thio-phenolate(II)* imparts the solution a lemon-yellow color which can be photometrically measured at 412 nm. The advantages of this reagent are its high specificity for SH groups and the high sensitivity of the resulting color reaction (eM = 13,600). As Klotz and Carver (1961) have pointed out, the stoichemistry of this method is not clear because Ellman's reagent (E-SS-E) can react also in another way: 2 Protein-SH
+ E-SS-E
---f
Protein-SS-Protein
+ 2E-SH
But this possibility involves no disadvantage for SH determination, because, in this case, 1 mole of the yellow thiophenolate is also formed from 1 mole proteinSH. The same is true if the mixed disulfide, primarily formed, reacts with a further protein SH group (Habeeb, 1972): Protein-SS-E
+ Protein-SH
-
Protein-SS-Protein
+ E-SH
The reaction of DTNB with protein SH groups is faster and more complete when the protein is allowed to be denatured by 8 M urea solution (Srere, 196.5). *Only by utilizing this nomenclature is it clear that the SH group is present in the ionized state (as thiophenolate). This is important because the nondissociated reaction product (111) is colorless (it fades by acidification). Consequently the Ellman's reagent should be termed bis(3-carboxy-4nitrophenyl) disulfide.
10
KLAUS HOFMANN AND REINER HAMM
Therefore, the determination of total protein sulfhydryl requires that the protein be denatured, preferably with sodium dodecylsulfate (Diez et al., 1964). The pH of the reaction mixture has a marked effect on the rate of color development. At pH 8, color development is complete in 5 minutes for all proteins tested (Beveridge ef d., 1974). Although the color reaction also occurs in solutions of weak acidity (above 4.7, Sedlak and Lindsay, 1968), pH values not lower than 8 are required in order to obtain complete reaction; Ellman (1959) suggested pH 8.2. Higher pH values accelerate the SH disulfide exchange (Lumper and Zahn, 1965), but they also induce a hydrolytic cleavage of the reagent causing a strong increase of the blank. According to our own experience, the original light-yellow color continuously deepens even in solutions of DTNB in phosphate or tris buffer of pH 7.5. We therefore recommend solutions of DTNB in ethanol, without addition of buffer, which are stable for a longer time (Hofmann and Bliichel, unpublished observations). Sedlak and Lindsay (1968) used methanol as a solvent for DTNB probably for the same reason. Calvin (1954) has shown that in basic solution two symmetrical disulfides can react with each other and form a mixed disulfide. In the case of the protein disulfide (PSSP) and Ellman’s reagent (ESSE), the reaction would be as follows: PSSP
+ ESSE + 2 PSSE
This reaction would not influence the results of the estimation of SH groups with ESSE because no thiolate anion (ES-) is formed. Furthermore, after Robyt ef al. (1971), mixed disulfides may also be formed by a series of reactions between ESSE and proteins which contain SH and SS groups. After the initial reaction PS-
+ ESSE + PSSE + ES
the released thiol ES- reacts with protein SS*, forming a second molecule PSSE and PS- which reacts again with ESSE. Altogether 3 moles PSSE and 1 mole ES- result. The derivatized protein PSSE can be separated, and the addition of a thiol (dithiothreitol) or adjustment of the pH to 10.5 releases a corresponding amount of ES- which can be measured at 412 nm. With this method Robyt et al. (1971) estimated the number of SH and SS groups in several proteins. Although ES- reacts immediately with protein SS groups, the number of ES- ions released is equal to the number of protein SH groups. Thus SS groups do not limit the specificity of the estimation of SH groups by Ellman’s reagent as it was postulated by Jocelyn (1972). Diez et al. (1964) concluded from their experiments that Ellman’s reagent in comparison with SH reagents such as N-ethylmaleimide, p-chloromercuri*In contrast, Weitzman (1975) reported, that thionitrobenzoate (ES-) would not react with disulfide groups in proteins. Therefore, the postulated mechanism of reaction seems to be in question.
SULFHYDRYL AND DISULFIDE GROUPS IN MEATS
11
benzoate, and iodine is the most useful reagent for routine determination of the total content of protein SH groups. A turbidity in the reaction solution can be eliminated either by filtration (Sedlak and Lindsay, 1968; Boyne and Ellman, 1972) or by centrifugation in the ultracentrifuge (Hofmann and Bliichel, unpublished observations). The precipitatin of proteins by TCA is not recommended (Dube, 1969). Dube found that the yellow color of the solution, obtained after reaction of GSH with DTNB, disappears after the addition of TCA, but comes back completely after adjusting the pH to 8; however, this is not the case in reaction mixtures of meat proteins and Ellman’s reagent because the formed carboxy-nitro-thiophenolateis partly adsorbed by the precipitate. This can be recognized by the strong yellow color of the washed precipitate after adjusting to pH 8 (Hofmann and Bluchel, unpublished observations). Since the reagent itself, as well as the tissue suspension after separation of the insoluble constituents show some absorbance, both blanks have to be measured separately and to be subtracted from the absorbance of the sample solution. Contrary to Dube (1969), we found that, in the determination of SH groups in meat with DTNB, myoglobin does not seriously disturb the measurement because the absorbance caused by myoglobin is extremely small, particularly with pork. Even with beef, the blank absorbance amounts to not more than 10% of the total absorbance (Hofmann and Bliichel, unpublished observations). It is often necessary to differentiate between protein-bound and nonbound SH groups in tissues. The latter groups are soluble in TCA and can be determined after the precipitation of proteins; the former can be calculated as the difference between the total SH content, measured after denaturation of the proteins by SDS, and the nonprotein SH content. Furthermore, the content of “available protein SH” can be determined by DTNB using the nondenatured sample (Habeeb, 1972). Under special conditions, DTNB reacts quickly with nonprotein SH and slowly with protein SH so that both types of SH groups can be determined in the same mixture. After Gabay et al. (1968), tissue homogenates are allowed to react with DTNB for 2 minutes at pH 6.8 giving nonprotein SH, and for 20 minutes at pH 7.6 giving total SH. Protein SH is then estimated by subtracting nonprotein SH from total SH. Boyne and Ellman (1972) described a kinetic analysis which allows the differentiation between (a) soluble, rapidly reactive SH (GSH-like), (b) soluble, slowly reactive SH (BSA-like*), (c) soluble, unreactive SH, (d) insoluble, reactive SH, and (e) insoluble, unreactive SH. Butterworth et al. (1967) suggest another method for the determination of protein SH in the presence of nonprotein SH: from the mixed protein disulfide, which is separated from the system after reaction with DTNB, the thiophenolate anion is released by the addition of dithiothreitol and then measured. *BSA
=
bovine serum albumin.
12
KLAUS HOFMANN AND REINER HAMM
Under the conditions used in the SH determination, DTNB also reacts with sulfite, thiosulfate (Man and Bryant, 1974), hydrogen sulfite, cyanide, and sulfide (Benedict and Stedman, 1970); therefore, such compounds interfere in the SH determination. Principally, all substances carrying a sulfur containing anion at pH 8 react with DTNB. Thiamine is another interfering factor which has not been taken into consideration up to now. In basic solution a cleavage of the thiamine ring occurs resulting in the formation of a S - group (Zima and Williams, 1940; Vogel and Knobloch, 1953):
By the reaction of thiamine with DTNB at pH values as low as 8.2 (i.e,, under the conditions of the SH determination), a yellow color is obtained. Actually, this reaction can be used for the determination of thiamine (Hofmann, 1974~). However, the thiamine content of meat is not sufficient to cause a noticeable error in the SH determination by DTNB. The maximum thiamine content of meat is about 0.9 mg per 100 gm of meat (Schweigert and Payne, 1956), whereas the total SH content varies between 60 and 80 mg SH per 100 gm of meat (see Section IV, A). For certain investigations, DTNB cannot be used. An example is the study of the reaction of patulin with the SH groups of meat (Hofmann et al., 1971): Patulin
+ RSH
-+
Patulin-SR
Following an addition of DTNB to measure the SH concentration after a certain time of reaction, first an equivalent amount of E-SH is obtained (see above). The E-SH, however, can react with patulin, and, consequently, the SH content measured in this manner will be too low. The determination of SH groups with other disulfides was suggested by Bitny-Szlachto et al. (1963), Drabikowski and Bitny-Szlachto (1963, I964), Kakol et al. (1964), Drabikowski and Nowak (1965), Grassetti and Murray (1969), Kakol (197I), and Swatditat and Tsen (1972). The use of thiamine disulfide (Kiermeier and Hamed, 1962; Kohno, 1965, 1966) allows a particularly sensitive SH assay: The thiamine formed by the SH-SS exchange is measured with the fluorometric thiochrome method. Here the relatively great error (+ 10%) of the thiochrorne method is a disadvantage. Bis(p-nitropheny1)-disulfide(Maier, 1969) is suitable for the determination of the sum of volatile mercaptans and hydrogen sulfide which arise, e.g., during heating of meat (see Section V, A, 4).
SULFHYDRYL AND DISULFlDE GROUPS I N MEATS
13
2 . Mercaptide-Forming Reagents and Amperometric Titration Unsatisfactory results with oxidation methods lead to the study of reactions with heavy metals, which react with SH compounds forming undissociated mercaptides in which the H of the SH group is replaced by a heavy metal. Reagents frequently used for the determination of SH groups in tissues are silver salts, mercury salts, and organic mercury compounds of the composition R-HgX(R = alkyl or aryl residue; X = halogen or OH). The procedures preferred are titrations with amperometric or potentiometric end-point determination using platinum or dropping mercury electrodes. This type of indication is based on the reducibility of heavy metal ions at the surface of the electrode. AS to the theory and application of the use of electrometric methods in biochemistry, we refer to the special literature (Kolthoff and Lingane, 1952; Konopik, 1953; Ewing, 1960; Brezina and Zuman, 1956; Purdy, 1965). a. The Amperometric Titration with Silver Nitrate. The amperometric titration of SH compounds with AgNO, was introduced by Kolthoff and Harris (1946) and first applied to the investigation of proteins by Benesch and Benesch (1948). Benesch et al. (1955) improved this assay essentially by using tris(hydroxymethy1)aminomethane as a buffering agent instead of ammonia and by the use of Hg/HgO/Ba(OH), reference electrode. Due to the potential of this electrode (-0.1 V against saturated calomel electrode), air oxygen cannot be reduced at the indicator electrode and, therefore, a complete elimination of oxygen (which could not be realized) is unnecessary (Kolthoff et al., 1965b). (Another reason for eliminating oxygen is the prevention of SH oxidation; such an oxidation. however, can be extensively prevented by addition of EDTA.) From that time, the amperometric titration with AgNO, was widely used for the determination of SH-(and SS-) groups in proteins and tissues. Important work on the methodology-other than animal tissues-was carried out by Rosenberg el a f . (1950), Heide (1953, Kolthoff et al. ( I 957, 1965b), Stauff and Duden (1958), Carter (1959), Staib andTurba (1956), Gruen and Harrap (1971), Harrap and Gruen (1971) (Ag/S specific ion electrode), and Mildner et ul. (1972). The great stability of the titration agent AgNO,, the simplicity of the apparatus (which can be easily built in each laboratory), the exact end-point determination (see Fig. I ) , and the small number of interfering factors involved are the reasons that this method was applied to practically all SH-containing materials including tissues. Animal tissues which have been investigated include liver, kidney, heart (Bhattacharya, 1958, 1959; Lastovskaya, 1969; Pavlyuk and Genyk, 1970), tumor tissues (Neogy et al.. 1961a,b), nerves (Krasnov, 1962), myofibrils from skeletal muscle (Hofmann, 1964, 1971a; Hamm and Hofmann, 1965, 1 9 6 6 ~Tinbergen, ; 1970), whole muscle tissue (Krylova and Kusnezowa, 1964; Hamm and Hofmann, 1965; Lastovskaya, 1969; Hofmann et al., 1969, 1974; Bolshakov and Mitrofanov, 1970; Bognar, 1971a; Hofmann, 1971b; Bow-
14
KLAUS HOFMANN AND REINER HAMM
FIG. 1. Amperometric titration curves: (A) Direct titration of SH groups with silver nitrate. Values of current (marked by circles) recorded 30 seconds after each addition of the reagent (0.1 ml AgNO,). (B) Titration of SH protein as in A, but with a continuous registration of the current (notice the decrease in current after the early additions of reagent which indicates the retarded reaction of the SH groups of protein). (C) AgNO, is titrated with an SH compound or KJ (reverse SH titration).
ers, 1972; Kortz, 1973; RaheliC et al., 1974), canned meat products (Bem et al., 1970; SusiC et al., 1974), and freeze dried meat (Potthast, 1972). Furthermore, the SH and S S groups in wheat flour were determined by amperometric (Rohrlich and Essner, 1966) and potentiometric titration (Kiihbauch and Wunsch, 1971). When compared with the amperometric titration, the potentiometric titration has two notable disadvantages: (a) the end-point determination is less exact because the point of inflection of the S-shaped titration curve is not very sharp, and (b) the air oxygen has to be removed as completely as possible because the use of a stronger negative electrode (calomel electrode) is necessary, the potential of which allows the reduction of oxygen. Several authors used the amperometric titration with AgN03 for the determination of SH groups in the isolated muscle proteins such as actin, myosin, tropomyosin, etc. (Azzoneef al., 1956; Staib and Turba, 1956; Tortschinski, 1959; Poglasov and Baev, 1960; Kofman, 1963; Berg et al., 1965; Hamm and Hofmann, 1965; Lytvynenko er al., 1963; Lusty and Fasold, 1969; Yuan, 1970; Brennock and Read, 1972; Hofmann, 1972a). The principle of the amperometric titration is as follows: a platinum wire indicator electrode is placed in the solution to be titrated; an electric connection is made with the reference electrode. The diffusion current flowing through the cell (caused by free Ag+ ions) is read on a microamperometer. During the titration of SH groups with silver nitrate, the current is near zero until the end-point because the Ag+ ions added are still being consumed by the formation of silver mercaptide: R-SH
+ Ag+ * R-SAg + Ht
After the end-point is reached, the diffusion current of silver rises because of an excess of silver ions in the solution. This diffusion current is proportional to the concentration of silver ions. By plotting the current reading during the titration
SULFHYDRYL AND DISULFIDE GROUPS IN MEATS
15
against the volume of silver nitrate solution, two straight lines are obtained which intersect at the end-point (Fig. 1A). By replacing the microamperometer with the recorder of a polarograph, a stepwise course of the current is obtained corresponding to the added portions of silver nitrate solution (Fig. 1B) (Beneschet af., 1955; Hofmann, 1972b). Instead of the rotating platinum electrodes which were originally preferred (Kolthoff and Harris, 1946), the use of a more simple stationary platinum electrode is recommended (Staib and Turba, 1956; Carter, 1959; Hofmann , 1964; Mallik, 1965; Hamm and Hofmann, 1966c) whereby the medium is agitated by means of a magnetic stirrer or by the use of a rotating beaker (King and Morris, 1967). The stationary electrode is even more sensitive than the rotating platinum electrode (Mallik, 1965; Richmond and Somers, 1966). If only small volumes of fluid are available for the demonstration, the titration can be carried out using a vibrating platinum electrode (Rosenberg et af., 1950). In addition to the platinum electrode, an AgS specific electrode was also suggested (Gruen and Harrap, 1971; Harrap and Gruen, 1971). Figure 2 shows the schema of a titrations apparatus with a stationary indicator electrode (after Staib and Turba, 1956; modified by Hamm and Hofmann, 1966~).The apparatus is only slightly susceptible to interference; the platinum electrode has to be cleaned only after a great number of titrations by dipping it into warm 20% nitric acid (contrary to information in the literature, e.g., Leach, 1966, p. 19). A direct titration of tissue homogenates is difficult because tissue particles adhere to the indicator electrode and cause an irregular influence on the diffusion current. Therefore, no regular titration curves are obtained (Hamm and Hofmann, 1966c; Bolshakov and Mitrofanov, 1970; Pavlyuk and Genyk, 1970). The direct titration of dissolved proteins with slowly reacting SH groups also implies problems. These difficulties can be overcome by the “indirect titration”: In this procedure an excess of AgNO, is first added to the sample; after the time required for a complete reaction, the excess of AgNO, is titrated with a SH compound (Neogy et al., 1961 a; Lusty and Fasoid, 1969; Bolshakov and Mitrofanov, 1970) or with KJ (Hofmann, 1969, 1971b; Bem et af., 1970; SusiC et af., 1974) (see titration curve Fig. 1C). The “double-indirect titration” procedure (Hofmann, 1964; Hamm and Hofmann, 1966c), which also allows the use of SH reagents such as NEM or PCMB (Hofmann and Hamm, 1967b; Hofmann, 197 Ic), is even more variable. The applicability of phenylmercuric acetate for this method was also examined (Mildner et al., 1972). This method of “double-indirect titration” should be briefly described because of its general applicability. The meat or protein sample, which should contain between 0.2 and 0.8 pmole SH (e.g., 25 mg tissue) is first incubated with I .O pmole of the SH reagent (AgNO,, PCMB, NEM, etc.). After the reaction, the mixture is filtered and 1.0 pmole of SHglutathion is added to the filtrate. The glutathion remaining after reaction with the excessive SH reagent is finally titrated amperometrically with IOp3M AgNO,
16
KLAUS HOFMANN AND REINER HAMM
iE 'I
17-
-4 IndKO tor
Reference electrode
2 3
FIG. 2 . Schema of the apparatus for the amperometric titration of SH groups (Hamm and Hofmann. 1966~).( I ) Indicator electrode (glass tube with platinum wire. 0.5 mm in diameter and I cm in free length). (2) Reference electrode (platinum wire, 0.5 mm in diameter and 2 cm in free length. dipped in mercury which is covered by a thin layer of HgO and Ba(OH), and a solution saturated by both substances. (3) Conductive connection (saturated KCI solution). (4) Porous diaphragm (clay). (5) Measuring instrument. (6) Magnetic stirrer with a constant speed of rotation. (7) Coated magnetic rod. The platinum wires of the two electrodes can be connected with the measuring instrument by either a drop of mercury or by welding them together directly. The content of the electrode vessels is 100 ml each; the volume of the sample solution 36 ml. Through the open tube in the top of the titration vessel, an inert gas can be led into the sample solution by means of a small rubber tube.
solution in tris buffer pH 7.4 (Fig. 3). As Fig. 3 shows, the consumption of AgNO, in the double-indirect titration procedure corresponds exactly to the amount of SH present. Therefore, the result is the same as would be obtained with a direct titration, if that method could be applied at all. Another essential advantage of this procedure is the fact that the titration of GSH with Ag+ ions results in an ideal titration curve, as shown in Fig. IA and B. With the direct titration of proteins, however, curves are sometimes obtained, the first part of which is not horizontal but at a slight incline. The problem of the evaluation of such titration curves was recently discussed by Hofmann and Hamm (1974b). We have applied this method to investigations about the role of SH groups in meat during heating, curing, freezing, storage, etc. (Hofmann, 1971d). The method has also been successfully used by other research workers for the deter-
17
SULFNYDRYL A N D DISULFIDE GROUPS IN MEATS
I
I
1 - 1
SH reagent ( 1 ml lO-3M
21
prnole)
protein SH (eg. 0 6 p r n ) remaining
m -
SH reagent (04p m f
SH glutathion (1 mllO-3 M
91 pm)
remaining SH glutathion (0.6 +m)
AgN03 consumed during titration (0.6+m)
L ’
I
I
1 pMd
1
*
FIG. 3 . Principle of the determination of SH groups by the double-indirect titration method (Hofmann. 1964; Hamm and Hofmann, 1 9 6 6 ~ )At . top of illustration, SH reagent. is valid for SH reagents which bind I SH group per molecule. c . g . . AgNO,. NEM. o r PCMB.
mination of SH groups in meat and myofibrils (Tinbergen, 1970; Bognar, I97 1 a; Potthast. 1972; Bolshakov and Mitrofanov, 1970; RaheliC et al., 1974). Doubleindirect titration permits a great variety in both reaction conditions and in the types of the SH reagent primarily used. The application of different reagents using the same technique is recommended for checking results obtained with one special reagent, for example AgNO,. This possibility is of particular interest because the specificity of SH reagents is not always certain. As a result, the specificity of Ag+ ions for SH groups in proteins has often been questioned (cf. Kolthoff and Stricks. 1950; Cecil and McPhee, 1959; Benesch and Benesch, 1962; Leach, 1966; Burton 1958), although this criticism was founded on investigations with low molecular compounds (mainly with cysteine). This problem was discussed in detail by Hofmann and Hamm (1974a). They concluded that results obtained with low molecular SH compounds cannot simply be transferred to proteins. On the contrary, studies using proteins with defined SH and SS content showed that under the conditions of the amperometric titration (tris buffer pH 7.4), Ag+ ions can be considered as being specific for protein SH groups (Hofmann and Hamm, 1975). It should be mentioned, however. that the direct titration of SH proteins with AgNO, in the presence of 8 M urea may lead to overly high SH values. This occurs because of a cleavage of SS groups with the excess of silver ions as Kolthoff et al. (1965b) found with bovine serum albumine. In absence of urea, however, they obtained correct SH values. In order to increase the specificity of the titration, a “blank” titration has been carried o u t using an excess of PCMB to block the protein SH groups (Bhattacharya, 1958, 1959). But the “blank” obtained in this way seems to be questionable because PCMB reacts more slowly and less completely with the SH groups of tissue than
18
KLAUS HOFMANN AND REINER HAMM
AgNO, (Hamm and Hofmann, 1967). Therefore, instead of a real blank, it is the SH groups unavailable for PCMB which are determined. From results obtained with several cysteine derivatives it can be concluded that Ag+ ions and mercaptide form a complex: R-SAg = x Ag+ -+ (R-SAg)Ag$
Therefore, the possibility of an excess of Ag+ consumption during the titration depends on the conformation of the SH compound. Complex formation apparently occurs if a cysteine derivative of Type I or I1 is present, while Type 111 does not form complexes (after Hofmann and Hamm, 1974a). +
HaN-CH-CGR
I
r* SH
Type 1
R-NH-CH-COO-
I
TH2
R-HN-CH-C&R
I
CHp
I
SH
SH
Type I1
Type 111
The use of AgNO, for the SH determination in muscle tissue does not result in inflated SH values as has been shown by comparison with other SH reagents (Tinbergen, 1970; Hofmann, 1 9 7 1 ~ cf. ; Section IV, A). During elaboration of the procedure for the SH determination in tissues by amperometric titration with AgN03 (described previously), Hamm and Hofmann (1 966c) investigated several possible influences. The results are as follows: (1) Between 10" and 40" C, the temperature of the GSH solution during titration has no influence on the titration end-point.* At 5"C, however, an elevated end-point was observed. (2) The titration of GSH in 8 M urea leads to the same result as the titration in the absence of urea. (3) An increase in the excess of AgN0, (over SH) from 100 to 200% does not influence the result of the indirect titration of myofibrils. (4) After 1 hour's reaction of AgNO, with myofibrils and subsequent titration, the same results are obtained whether these procedures are carried out in the presence or in the absence of air (under nitrogen). (5) Denaturation of the myofibrils with 8 M urea does not result in a significant increase of SH groups; therefore, all SH groups present in the native muscle proteins seem to react with AgNO,. (6) The recovery of GSH added to myofibrils and to the total tissue was 97% and 100% respectively. The accuracy of this amperometric titration is 97-98% (Krasnov, 1962). The error in the estimation of SH in animal tissues with this method has been deter*This was also found by Hoch and Vallee (1960).
SULFHYDRYL AND DISULFIDE GROUPS IN MEATS
19
mined to be from I .5% (Pavlyuk and Genyk, 1970) to 3% (Hamm and Hofmann, 1966~). The presence of Ca2+,Mg’+, Zn”, Fe3+, NO,-, Pod3-, lactate, and ATP at levels found in meat and meat products does not influence the amperometric titration of GSH with AgNO,. However, the presence of Cu2+and Mn2+ ions at higher levels results in low SH values, probably by a catalytic oxidation of the SH groups which cannot be prevented by the addition of 0.5% EDTA (Hofmann, 1970). Concentrations of sodium chloride higher than 0.1 M cause a change in the normal titration curve and, therefore, make the determination of the end-point less exact. Titrations in a 0.6 M KCI solution also result in abnormal curves; thus the amperometric titration of actomyosin in this solution is not useful (Hofmann, 1970). Finally it should be mentioned that free amino acids other than cysteine, which are always present in tissues, do not interfere in the amperometric titration (Benesch er al., 1955; Hofmann and Hamm, 1975). The same is valid for NAD, hemin chloride, ascorbic acid, and oxidized glutathion (Benesch et al., 1955). b. Mercury Compounds as SH Reagents. Numerous Hg compounds have been suggested for the determination of SH groups in proteins; we will discuss only the most important of these compounds. In addition to Hg2+ salts, organic mercury compounds have been used. Here the organic residue R‘ in reaction ( I ) contains hydrophilic groups for increasing the solubility in water and chromophoric groups for producing a measurable color. The reactions of protein SH (I) with an excess of the mercurial reagent (11) are as follows:
+
(I)
x R-SH
(2)
2~ R-SH
(1)
(X
+ Y)
R’-Hg+
+ (X + y) Hg2+ (W
-H+ + - H+ 4
x R-S-Hg-R‘ x (R-S)2Hg
(111)
+ yR’-Hg+
+ y Hg2+ (IV)
Three different principles are used for measuring these reactions: (a) Determination of the reaction product (111) in reaction (1) and (2): (i) Measurement of the increase in optical density at 250-255 nm which occurs if p-chloromercuribenzoate (PCMB) reacts with SH groups (Boyer, 1954). This method is only possible if the SH protein is dissolved and if the solution remains clear during reaction with PCMB. In order to correct for slight changes in opacity, the difference in readings at 255 and 320 nm was used (Yasui et al., 1968). By stepwise addition of the mercurial, a spectrophotometric titration can also be carried out (Katz and Mommaerts, 1962; Tonomura and Yoshimura, 1962; Arai and Watanabe, 1968). (ii) By coloring the tissue or insoluble proteins with 1-(4-chloromercuriphenylazo)-naphtol-2 (Flesch and Kun, 1950; Burley, 1954; Szydlowska et al., 1967), a subsequent, semiquantitative evaluation is possible. Further reagents suggested
20
KLAUS HOFMANN AND REINER HAMM
for labeling SH groups are 2-chloro-mercuri-4-phenylazophenol and 2-chloromercuri-4-(p-nitrophenylazo)-phenol(Chang and Liener, 1964), and fluorescein1,3,6,8-tetramercuric acetate as a sensitive spot reagent (Havir et al., 1966). (iii) Reaction of the SH proteins with I4C-PCMB and measurement of the radioactivity of the product (Erwin and Pedersen, 1968; Krabow and Golosby, 1971). (b) Determination of the reagent in excess (IV): ( i ) Measurement of the absorption of the reagent used, e.g., of PCMB at 232 nm after separation from the insoluble proteins (Hamm and Hofmann, 1967). (ii) Transformation of the reagent in excess into a colored complex, e.g., by the reaction of PCMB with dithizon (Fridovich and Handler, 1957; Sasago et al., 1963), or the reaction of o-hydroxymercuribenzoic acid with thiofluorescein (absorption maximum of 588 nm) (Wronski, 1967). ( i i i ) Titration of the reagent in excess with cysteine after reaction with the tissue using sodium nitroprusside as an indicator. The end-point of the titration is the appearance of a red color (MacDonnell et al., 1951; Zahn et al., 1962). Another possibility is the potentiometric titration of the excess of PCMB with cysteine (Calcutt and Doxey, 1959, 1961; Calcutt, 1961; Calcutt et al., 1961; Doxey, 1961) and the indirect back-titration of excessive SH reagents such as phenyl mercuriacetate (Mildner et al., 1972) and other suitable Hg reagents using the technique described by Hamm and Hofmann (1966~). (iv) Polarographic determination of the reagent in excess such as CH,HgJ or CH,HgCl (Maclaren et al., 1960; Leach, 1960a,b; Hird and Yates, 1961; Jamieson et al., 1963; Forbes and Hamlin, 1968; Mrowetz and Klostermeyer, 1972; Mrowetz et al., 1972; Marsalova and Roozen, 1973). (c) Estimation of reagent consumed (11) minus (IV): Direct titration of the protein SH groups in the presence of sodium nitroprusside until the purple color disappears. Reagents suggested for this titration are CH,HgNO, (Katchalski et al., 1957; Barany et al., 1964; Dworschak, 1970), NEM (Tsao and Bailey, 1953; Connell, 1957), PCMB (Connell, 1960a,b) and phenyl mercurihydroxyde (Meichelbeck, 1963). The titrations must be carried out at a temperature near 0°C because of the instability of the color. Furthermore, titrations with o-hydroxy mercuribenzoic acid and thiofluorescein (with which the color changes from blue to clear) (Wronski, 1963) or with salyrganic acid (mersalyl) and azopyridine (pyridine-2-azo-p-dimethylaniline)(Klotz and Carver, 1961; Ehrlich, 1967; Parker and Kilbert, 1970) as indicators are possible. Amperometric titration with HgClz is often used because of its very exact end-point determination (Kolthoff et al., 1957, I965b; Oganessjan and Dschanibekova, 1958; Matsumoto et al., 1960; Sullivan et al., 1963). Amperometric titrations can also be carried out with methylmercuric and ethylmercuric chloride (Kolthoff and Tan, 1965; Kolthoff et al., 1965b). Two advantages
SULFHYDRYL AND DISULFIDE GROUPS IN MEATS
21
of these two mercurials are the ease of preparation of extremely pure ethyl mercuric salts and the high level of water solubility of methylmercurinitrate. A disadvantage of the use of Hg2+ salts for SH determination is the fact that it is not certain whether the bivalent Hg cation reacts with one SH group only, forming RSHgX(X = halogen). or with two SH groups, forming (RS),Hg (Benesch and Benesch, 1962). Therefore, the application of organic mercurials, which can react with one SH group only, is generally preferred. PCMB is the most frequently employed compound of this type. It is extremely stable and, contrary to most of the other mercurials, has a low level of toxicity. Its low solubility in water and the difficulty of preparation of PCMB of high purity are disadvantages of this reagent (Benesch and Benesch, 1962). Impurities in commercial preparations can cause a catalytic oxidation of SH groups as has been demonstrated in the following example. When Bendall (personal communication) tried to block a part of the SH groups of the isolated myosin with PCMB, he found that the amount of SH groups decreased more strongly than had been expected from the amount of PCMB added. Hofmann and Bendall (unpublished observations) used the following experiment in order to find the reason for this phenomenon: They added to GSH solution in tris buffer pH 7.4 (a) unpurified PCMB, (b) purified PCMB (twice recrystallized in NaOH), and (c) unpurified PCMB and EDTA (final concentration 0.01 M ) . The molar proportion SH: PCMB was 4: 1 in all cases. A stream of air was passed through each solution for 30 minutes. Before and after aeration the SH content in an aliquot of the solutions was determined by Ellman’s reagent. The solution of the unpurified PCMB (without EDTA) showed a decrease in the SH content of 21%, the other two solutions a decrease of 2 and I % , respectively. This result indicates that the unpurified preparation contained traces of heavy metals which are known to catalyze the oxidation of SH groups. The spectrophotometric assay of SH groups in myofibrils by PCMB (estimation of the excess of the reagent by measuring the optical density at 232 nm) involves a relatively high error factor (12.6%) (Hamm and Hofmann, 1967); therefore, this method does not allow an exact SH determination in tissue or in myofibrils. Finally some methods should be mentioned which may be of interest for analytical as well as for preparative purposes. An insoluble reagent formed by the binding of PCMB to Dowex-2 resin has been used for the selective removal of thiols from solutions or from tissue homogenates (McCormack er al., 1960). It was possible to remove the bound thiol from the reagent by exchange with other SH compounds. This reagent might be valuable for concentrating or isolating these thiols. An organomercurial-polysaccharide has been synthesized and successfully applied to the separation of protein mixtures into an SH-fraction and a fraction containing no SH groups (Eldjam and Jellum, 1963). This material has been applied as a purification step in the isolation of SH enzymes as well as for concentrating dilute solutions of these enzymes. It is particularly well suited for
22
KLAUS HOFMANN AND REINER HAMM
the chromatographic fractionation of individual SH proteins. Furthermore, an organomercurial resin has been prepared which is capable of binding low molecular SH compounds and SH proteins, which can then be recovered almost quantitatively by elution with cysteine (Liener, 1967).
3.
N-Ethylmaleimideand Its Derivatives
N-ethylmaleimide (NEM) contains a reactive double bond causing an absorption maximum in the UV range of 300-302 nm. At pH values around 7, an addition of SH groups to the double bond occurs.
R-SH
+
R-S,H
HC=CH O(L,,,CO I
I -
C-CH,
I
1
,co
oc, I?
During this reaction the absorption maximum in the UV disappears because of the transition of the double bond into a single bond. The measurement of this decrease in absorbence at 300 nm permits a quantitative determination of SH groups. Principal studies on this method were camed out by Friedmann (1952), Gregory (1955), Alexander (1958), Roberts and Rouser (1958), and Leslie (1965). The formation of additive compounds by the reaction of thiols with NEM was demonstrated by Smyth et al. (1960) and Lee and Samuels (1961). The extreme stability of the C-S bond in the reaction product is an important advantage of this method. But NEM also shows some disadvantages which limit its application: (a) the sensitivity of the measurement is relatively small (eM = 620 at 300 mm); (b) in an aqueous solution, NEM is gradually disintegrated because of a hydrolytic cleavage of the CO-NH bond and the product of this hydrolysis reacts very slowly with SH groups (Gregory, 1955); (c) under certain conditions, several non-SH containing amino acids may react with NEM (Riggs, 1961), therefore, NEM is not always specific; (d) if proteins are not removed from the reaction mixture before SH determination, high blanks may appear because of the high absorbance of proteins around 300 nm. Nevertheless, NEM is widely used for blocking or determining protein SH. According to our experience, NEM is a suitable SH reagent provided that there is not too great an excess of the reagent and that the reaction time is not too long. Leslie et al., (1962) found NEM suitable for the determination of mercapto groups in proteins when they were denatured. Using NEM for the determination of SH groups in tissue and muscle proteins, Hamm and Hofmann (1966b) came to the following conclusion. The titration after Tsao and Bailey (1953) with sodium nitroprusside as an indicator is not appropriate because the change in color is indistinct due to the slow
SULFHYDRYL AND DISULFIDE GROUPS IN MEATS
23
reaction of the SH groups. But the following spectrophotometric procedure is quite suitable: 0.5 gm myofibrils of finely minced tissue (containing about 0.1 gm protein) is weighed into a 12-ml test tube and mixed with 5 ml 0.1 M phosphate buffer pH 6.0 and 5 m12 10-3M aqueous NEM solution. After shaking for 2 hours at 2 5 T , the main part of the proteins is removed by centrifuging at 15,000 X g for 5 minutes. The remaining proteins are precipitated in 5 ml of the clear supernatant by the addition of 1 ml 20% TCA. After centrifugation (15,000 X g for 5 minutes), the optical density of the supernatant is measured against a blank at 300 nm. In the calculation of the SH content, the partial hydrolysis of NEM (decrease in absorbence 0.003) and the moisture content of the sample (0.4. lop3 1) have to be taken into consideration. The SH content is calculated from the extinction E measured in a 1-cm cuvette by the following equation: pM01 SH = 10.00 - 20.12 x (E + 0.003). The presence of TCA does not interfere in the measurement of optical density. The protein precipitate does not include measurable amounts of NEM, provided that the water insoluble proteins are removed before as described above. With this method 3.5 moles SH/105 gm protein were found in myofibrils, whereas with AgN03 9.2 moles SH/l05 gm protein were determined in the same preparation. Therefore, NEM reacts only with a part of the SH groups which are defined as “easily available SH groups” of muscle proteins. A preceding denaturation of proteins, either by 8 M urea or by heating (cf. Section V,A, l), results in an increase in SH groups reacting with NEM; but the total number of SH groups in myofibrils which react with AgNO, cannot be achieved (Hamm and Hofmann , 1966b). An almost equal number of SH groups detectable with AgNO, can be determined by reaction with NEM if the NEM reacts at pH 7.4instead of pH 6.0 and if the subsequent SH determination is carried out by indirect amperometric titration (Hofmann, 1 9 7 1 ~ )It. follows from this result that at a higher pH the SH groups are more easily available for NEM. But the determination of the partially available SH groups with NEM at pH 6.0 is still of value because it allows one to follow the process of protein denaturation (unfolding) (see Section V,A, 1). Weitzman and Tyler (1971) found that NEM gives a well-defined polarographic reduction wave and that measurement of this can form the basis of a more sensitive procedure for estimating SH groups. Numerous N-substitution products of maleimide were synthetized in order to obtain derivatives which are more sensitive for optical measurement than NEM. These derivatives cannot be discussed in detail. Some of them were used for studying protein conformation because the reaction products of SH groups with NEM derivatives are resistant against protein hydrolysis by acids. Holbrook et af. (1966) studied the influence of the size of the substituents in N-substituted maleimides on their reactivity against SH groups in proteins. They found that the larger the substituent the slower the reaction. Colored or fluorescent compounds were obtained by the
24
KLAUS HOFMANN A N D REINER HAMM
introduction of chromophoric groups into the NEM molecule (Witter and Tuppy, 1960; Riordan and Vallee, 1972; Kanaoka et a / . , 1967, 1968, 1973; Sekine and Ando, 1972; Nara and Tuzimura, 1973). Such derivatives can be used for the histochemical demonstration of SH groups (Tsou et al., 1955). Furthermore, NEM and its derivatives were labeled by substituents containing I4C (Kielley and Barnett, 1961; Tkachuk and Hlynka, 1963; Lee and Samuels, 1964; Lee and Lai, 1967), 3?S and 35S(Merz et a l . , 1965). Maleimides were used for the determination of SH groups in myofibrils (Hamni and Hofmann, 1965; Hofmann, 1971 c), poultry muscles (Gawronski et a l . , 1967), fish muscle (Connell, 1957), and in muscle proteins, particularly in myosin and actin (Tsao and Bailey, 1953; Kielley and Barnett, 1961; Katz and Mommaerts, 1962; Groschel-Stewart and Turba, 1963; Martonosi, 1968; Seidel, 1969). According to Schoberl (1958), in addition to maleimides, vinylsulfones, which also bear reactive double bonds, are very suitable for the blocking and determination of protein SH groups, e.g., in keratins. 4 . Other SH Reagents Of the reaction types not described in the preceding sections, the nitroprusside reaction has been known for the longest time. The sensitivity of its reaction with SH groups in alkaline solution forming a red color is very great: (Fe(CN),NO]'-
+ R-S- + [Fe(CN),NO.S-R]'
In a strong alkaline solution, the color fades very quickly, while in an ammoniacal solution, it is quite stable. However, the color stability is insufficient for an exact quantitative determination of SH groups. Nevertheless, sodium nitroprusside has often been used for the assay of SH groups in meat (Chajuss and Spencer, 1962b; Khan et a l . , 1963; Khan and van den Berg, 1964, 1965; Motoc and Banu, 1968; Davidkovli and Davidek, 1971; Khan and Nakamura, 1971). Numerous efforts for increasing the color stability with additives or variation of reaction conditions have had only limited success. An addition of cyanide improves the color stability (Schoberl and H a m , 1948); but in this case a cleavage of SS groups occurs which might result in overly high SH values. Sodium nitroprusside has also been used as an indicator for the titration of SH groups of proteins with other SH reagents (Connell, 1960a,b); but such procedures imply problems which must not be overlooked. The discoloration of the protein-SH-nitroprusside complex in such titration methods is due to a replacement of the nitroprusside anion by the added SH reagent: [Fe(CN),NO. S-Protein]
+ reagent
-
[Fe(CN),NO]'-
+ reagent-S-Protein
SULFHYDRYL A N D DISULFIDE GROUPS IN MEATS
25
The sodium nitroprusside often reacts with only a limited number of the protein SH groups. Consequently, the change in color from red to almost clear will have already occurred if the titration reagent has reacted with the SH groups that participate in the nitroprusside color complex of the protein. So, rather than all the SH groups reacting with the titration reagent, only the groups which react with sodium nitroprusside are determined. Sodium nitroprusside is specific for SH groups in proteins as well as generally in animal tissues. The sodium nitroprusside reaction provides an excellent and very sensitive spot test for the qualitative indication of SH groups. With meats, the red myoglobin color disturbs the test; but with washed muscle tissue, myofibrils. or with meat which is pale by nature (e.g., poultry or fish muscle), good results are obtained. The SH test with sodium nitroprusside can be carried out also in ZnCI, solution (instead of ammonia) which causes a low acidification of the reaction mixture (Pohloudek-Fabini and Papke, 1964). Myofibrils take o n an intensively pink color, whereas, with solutions of SH compounds such as cysteine or glutathion, a pink precipitate is formed. The use of B mixture of I % sodium nitroprusside solution and a 30% ZnClz solution has been recommended (Hofmann, 1965a). An intensive color reaction is obtained with native muscle proteins. Serum albumin or egg albumin reacts only after denaturation by urea or heating (Hofmann, 1965a, 1966a). Contrary to the SH test in ammoniacal solution, creatine and acetone do not interfere. Sulfite and thioesters, however. do react. The presence of sufficient amounts of ammonium ions or EDTA prevents the color reaction of nitroprusside ZnC1, by the formation of Zn complexes (Hofmann, 1965a). This result suggests that zinc participates in the color formation. The spot test with iodine azide represents a very sensitive SH reaction (see Feigl, 1960): 2NaN,
+ JB
('")
>
3 N4
+ 2 NaJ
This reaction, which occurs in a sufficient rate only in presence of SH groups, can be recognized by the formation of small gas bubbles (nitrogen). SH reagents which have been known for a long time are iodoacetamide, iodoacetate, and iodoacetic acid. They are used for the alkylation of SH groups of the cysteine residues in proteins. After hydrolysis of the S-alkylated protein the cysteine residues are present as carboxymethyl cysteine which can be determined in the course of the amino acid analysis. Under certain conditions these reagents can react with methionine, histidine, and lysine residues of proteins (Gundlach ez ul., 1959). In many investigations, iodoacetamide, iodoacetate, and iodoacetic acid have been used for blocking and determination of SH groups in muscle proteins (Mirsky and Anson, 1935; Mirsky, 1936; Barany and Barany. 1959; Barany et al., 1964; Stracher, 1964).
26
K L A U S H O F M A N N A N D REINER H A M M
4-Iodobutanesulfonate was also recommended as an SH alkylating agent in the analysis of amino acids (Jermyn, 1966). 4,4’-Bisdimethylaminodiphenylcarbinol is a new, highly sensitive SH reagent, which shows in an acidic solution an intensive blue color (cM = 70800 at 612 nm). The product of the reaction between the dye cation and SH groups is colorless, probably because of the following reaction (Rohrbach et al., 1973): 1+
r
colorless
This decrease of optical density caused by SH groups can be used for the quantitative determination of protein SH. Urea and cyanate disturb this reaction because they also cause a discoloration; 4 M guanidine, however, does not interfere, Another sensitive test for cysteine, glutathion, and other SH compounds is possible by means of chloranil (I), bromanil (11). or 2, 3 dichloronaphtoquinone (111) (Hofmann, 1965b).
(11
(11)
(1x1)
For this test, the SH containing solution is alkalized by the addition of K,CO, and shaken with a solution of I, 11, or 111 in chloroform. After the separation of the aqueous and organic phases, the colored reaction products appear in one of these two phases (see Table 11). Disulfides and SH-free amino acids do not interfere in this reaction. The color of the solutions is very stable and is suitable for quantitative SH determination (Hofmann, 1965b).
27
SULFHYDRYL AND DISULFIDE GROUPS I N MhATS TABLE I1 COLOR REACTION OF HALOGENIZED QUINONES WITH SH COMPOUNDS I N ALKALINE (K,C03) SOLUTION“.”
SH compound
Chloranil bromanil
2.3-Dichloronaphtoquinone
Cysteine Glutathion Thioglycolic acid Eth ylmercaptane Thiamine (SH form) Thiamine pyrophosphate
Green (H,O) Reddish brown (H,O) Yellow (H,O) Red (CHCI:,) Reddish brown (CHCI:,) Yellowish brown (H,O)
Yellow (H,O) Pink (H,O) Orange (H,O) Yellow (CHCl3) Yellow (CHCI,) Pink (H,O)
(’ From Hofrnann (1965b). The color appears in the phase indicated in parentheses
Fontana et al. (1968) suggested azobenzene-2-sulfenyl bromide as an SH reagent specifically for cysteinyl residues; in this reaction asymmetric disulfids are formed:
/ S -Br
/
S-S-R
Friedman (1973, 1974) found that protein SH groups can be transferred quantitatively to acid-stable S-P-pyridyl ethyl cysteine residues by reaction with 4-vinylpyridine. The corresponding cysteine derivatives released by hydrolysis elute as discrete peaks from an amino acid analyzer. A related assay was also developed in which half-cystine residues are changed to S-P-(2-quinolylethyl)cystine residues. These side chains can be estimated by ultraviolet spectroscopy in intact or hydrolyzed proteins. Recently new fluorescent reagents, N-dansylaziridine and NBD-chloride (7-chloro-4-nitrobenzo-2-oxa1,3-diazole) have been described as selectively reacting with protein thiols (Scouten et al., 1974; Price and Cohn, 1975). These reagents may be used to label SH portions of proteins, to differentiate between buried and exposed sulfhydryls, and to determine the nature of the region (hydrophobic, hydrophilic) surrounding a given sulfhydryl group. In certain instances, the possibility of a specific determination of the content of reduced and oxydized glutathione in tissues is of interest. This can be done by means of enzymatic spectrophotometric methods (Klotsch and Bergmeyer, 1962; Lack and Smith, 1964; Srivastava and Beutler, 1968; Tietze, 1969).
28
KLAUS HOFMANN AND REINER HAMM
C.
DETERMINATION OF SS GROUPS
Usually the determination of disulfide groups in protein is carried out in two steps: (1) by reduction or cleavage of the SS groups to SH groups, and (2) determination of the SH groups formed. Since the methods for the determination of SH groups have been discussed, we will only consider the reduction of S S groups here. The reagents frequently used for this purpose are: (a) mercaptans such as P-mercaptoethanol (Anfinsen and Haber, 1961 ; Thompson and O’Donnell, 1961; Christian and Schur, 1965; Habeeb, 1972; Beveridge et al., 1974), thioglycolate (Katchalski et al., 1957; Sela et a/., 1959; White, 1960; Leach and O’Donnell, 1961), dithiothreitol (Cleland, 1964, 1968) or dithioerythritol (Habeeb, 1972); (b) sodium borhydride (Stahl and Sigga, 1957; Moore et al., 1960; Stauff and Duden, 1958; Brown, 1960; Seon et al., 1965; Cavallini ef al., 1966; Glaseretal., 1970); (c) sulfite (Kolthoff e t a l . , 1958, 1965a; Carter, 1959; Christian and Schur. 1965; Rohrlich and Essner, 1966); (d) cyanide (Grote, 1931; Wronski, 1964; Roberts and Rouser, 1958; De Marco ef al., 1966); (e) Tri-n-butylphosphine (Harrap and Gruen, 197I); and (f) electrolytical reduction (Leach ef al., 1965, see also Friedman, 1973). The corresponding reaction mechanisms are as follows: (a) 2 R-SH + Prot.-SS-Prot. + 2 Prot.-SH + R-SS-R Prot.-SS-Prot. 4 2 Prot.-S- H, or* (b) 2 H4 R-SS-R NaBH, 3 H,O + 8 R-SH + NaH,BO, (c) SOa2- Prot.-SS-Prot. 4 Prot.-SSOg Prot.-S(d) CNRot.-SS-Prot. 4 Prot.-SCN + Prot.-S(e) Bu,P Prot.-SS-Prot. H,O 4 2 Pro[.-SH + Bu,PO (9 2e Rot.-SS-Prot. -+ 2 hot.-.!-
+
+ + + + +
+
+
+
+
The reagents most frequently used are types a, b, and c. Mercaptans also are often added to proteins in order to protect SH groups. For a complete reduction of protein SS groups, the presence of a denaturing agent such as 8 M urea, 4 M quanidine, or 0.5% SDS solution and a considerable excess of the reducing agent are generally necessary. Therefore, in most cases, after reduction but before the SH determination, the excess of the reducing agent must be removed. This is an easy process in the case of NaBH,; by acidification of the alkaline reaction mixture, the reagent is completely destroyed. An excess of mercaptans has to be eliminated, e.g., by precipitation of the proteins. Sulfite has often been used for the cleavage of SS groups and subsequent determination of SH groups by amperometric titration with AgN03, which is not disturbed by an excess of sulfite. *The reaction mechanism seems to be unclear. In the first reaction, hydrogen is released; in thc second, no hydrogen appears (see Jocelyn, 1972; Friedman, 1973).
SULFHYDRYL A N D DISULFIDE GROUPS IN MEATS
29
The fact, however, that, after reaction of SS with sulfite, only one SH group is obtained is disadvantageous (see reaction c). Well-proved methods for the SS determination in proteins using NaBH,, P-mercaptoethanol, and dithioerythritol as reducing agents and subsequent SH determination with Ellman's reagent are described by Habeeb (1972). Reduction of SS by NaBH, has been shown to be convenient for the determination of SS in animal tissues (Hamm and Hofmann. 1965, 1966c; Dubi, 1969; Bognar, 1971a; Habeeb, 1972; Dubeet ul., 1972). A description of the SS determination in tissue (after Hamm and Hofmann, 1966c) follows: The sample, containing about 5 mg protein (e.g., 25 mg minced muscle tissue) is weighed into a conical centrifuge tube (10 ml), mixed with 0.5 ml reducing agent (0.12 gm NaBH, in 5 ml of 8 M urea), and kept for 1 hour at room temperature. Foaming can be prevented by the addition of a drop of octanol or by putting traces of a silicon defoamer on the glass wall of the tube. Then the NaBH, is destroyed by a stepwise addition of 0.15 M HNO, until a pH of 6 . 7 4 . 4 is obtained. After keeping the mixture under nitrogen for 30 minutes, 28 ml of water and 5 ml of a tris buffer pH 7.4 are added. In this mixture the SH groups are determined by amperometric titration. The use of hydrogen selenide allows a direct histochemical demonstration of SS groups (Olszewska et al., 1967); the sections on the slides are saturated with water vapor and treated with gaseous H,Se for 2 hours. The areas containing SS groups stain yellow-brown. The test is based on the reaction: R-SS-R
+ H,Se -+
2 R-SH
+ Se
The presence of thiol groups does not influence the results of this reaction. Another method which is appropriate for the determination of SS groups is based on the fluorescence quenching of fluorescein-mercury(I1)-acetate by SS groups (Karush et al., 1964). SH groups, which also react, are blocked beforehand with iodoacetamide. Maeda et ul. (1970) developed a method for visualization of cystinecontaining peptides in peptide maps. The chromatogram is sprayed with an NaBH, solution in ethanol and the excess of NaBH, is decomposed by dipping it in acid. The paper is dried, neutralized by exposure to ammonia vapors, and then sprayed with Ellman's reagent. Yellow spots appear immediately. These can be eluted and analyzed to establish the amino acid composition of the cystinecontaining peptides. A combination of the methods for demonstrating SH groups by means of 2,2'-dihydroxy-6,6'-dinaphthyldisulfideor Fast Blue B (Gabler and Scheuner. 1966) with Mercury Orange permits simultaneous color differentiation between SH groups (blue or purple) and cystine disulfide bonds (red-orange) (Szydlowska and Junikiewicz, 1973).
30
KLAUS HOFMANN A N D REINER HAMM
Ill. SH GROUPS IN MUSCLE PROTEINS AND THEIR ROLE IN THE FUNCTION OF MUSCLE The muscle cell consists of the myofibrils, the sarcoplasmic reticulum, and some cell organelles such as nuclei, mitochrondia, lysosomes, and ribosomes. This structural material is embedded in the fluid matrix of the sarcoplasma. The cell is surrounded by the cell wall, the sarcolemma. The structural cell elements including the membranes are to a large extent built up by proteins. A great variety of other proteins is dissolved in the sarcoplasmic matrix o r loosely attached to cell structures. The bulk of the sulfhydryl groups in muscle is bound to proteins. Nonprotein thiol is rather low and consists largely of glutathion ( I .5 pmole/gm tissue in rabbit skeletal muscle) (Jocelyn, 1972; see also Section IV,A). Most of the numerous proteins of the muscle cell contain sulfhydryl groups of physiological importance. It is not the purpose of this review to discuss in detail the role of SH groups in muscle physiology. For a better understanding of the reactions that occur in muscle as a food, however, some knowledge of the most important facts from the extensive field of muscle research might be necessary, particularly in future meat research, because thus far not much use has been made of the results from this research. With regard to the great number of different protein SH groups in the muscle, to the numerous effects of these sulfhydryls on enzyme activity, protein interactions, membrane transport reactions, etc., it might be very difficult to elucidate the importance of a particular type of sulfhydryl for meat quality or in changes in meat protein. Most of the information on the biochemical and physiological role of SH groups in muscle proteins has been obtained by studying the effect of blocking these groups with specific reagents during enzyme activity or protein interactions. Chemical modification of sulfhydryls has been extensively used for elucidating the structure of the active sites of adenosinetriphosphatase (ATPase) and other enzymes. In this type of study, the chemical modification must cause stoichiometric inactivation, and there must have been specific protection by the substrate or by competitive inhibitors against the inactivation. Even so, the possibility remains that this particular modification occurs other than at the catalytic site and that specific protecting agents induce a change in confinnation at a location other than the catalytic site (Tonomura, 1973). These points have not always been taken into account. Hence, not all the results mentioned in this chapter can be regarded as irrevocable. A.
MYOFIBRILLAR PROTEINS
The proteins which build up the myofibril are shown in Tables I11 and IV. Although all myofibrillar proteins are related to the contractile mechanism of the
SULFHYDRYL A N D DlSULFlDE GROUPS IN MEATS
31
muscle fiber, their functions are distinctly specialized (Table 111). The fundamental process of contraction is known to be carried out by myosin and actin, but these two proteins alone cannot bring about the contraction process of living muscle. The recognition of the physiological role of tropomyosin and troponin has further stimulated the discovery of new myofibrillar proteins. On the whole, the idea of regulatory proteins (proteins that enable myosin and actin to perform the contraction-relaxation cycle under physiological conditions) has been established (Ebashi and Nonomura, 1973).
TABLE 111 MYOFIBRILLAR PROTEINS OF THE SKELETAL MUSCLE"
'
/Myosin
Contractile proteins
\
Actin
I /
Troponin Functional Regulatory proteins
Structural M-Protein 'I
After Ebashi and Nonomura ( 1973)
TABLE IV CONTENTOFCONTRACTION AND REGULATORY PROTEINS IN RABBIT MYOFIBRIL"
Proteins
Percentage of protein by weight
Myosin Actin Tropomyoain Troponin &-Actinin P -Actinin M-Protein
55-60 20
'I
4.5
3 -5 1-2
-0.5 -0,s
After Ebashi and Nonornura (1973)
32
KLAUS HOFMANN A N D REINER HAMM
I , SH and SS Group Content of Myofbrillar Proteins Table V shows the data for SH and SS content of the single myofibrillar proteins. All myofibrillar proteins contain SH groups. Disulfide groups have been found only in tropomyosin and troponin. No reliable data for SH groups could be found in the literature for p-actinin. The results of the estimates of SH groups in myofibrils are listed in Table VI. Some of the values determined in native myofibrils with NEM, PCMB, and DTNB obviously do not represent the total SH content but rather the SH groups available under the conditions used in the reactions. The average SH content of the different myofibrils is 9.1 moles SH/I05gm protein (values lower than 6 were omitted). This value corresponds very well to the sum of SH groups of the single myofibrillar proteins, calculated from the values of Table VII. As the average SH content of whole muscles was 10.2 (pork) and 10.5 (beef) (see comments on Tables IX and X), it is evident that the SH groups in meat are generally about 90% bound to myofibrils. Table VII provides the figures for mg SH and SS content of the major proteins per 100 gm of the total myofibrillar protein. These TABLE V SULFHYDRYL AND DlSULFlDE GROUPS IN MYOFIBRILLAR PROTEINS. EQUIVALENTS OF SH AND SS GROUPS PER lo5 gm PROTEIN
Protein
Molecular weight
SH
SS
8-9!,.c.d.?J
0u.d.~
8.4' 7.3' 8.6' 7 - 10"
0
SH
+ SS"
~~~~~~~~~~~
Myosin
HMM
220.000
320-360,000
8.4'
7.4" 10' 6.4"
Subfragment I Subfragment 2 LMM Actom yosin
4b.P
n.n"
0 0 0'
7 .5' ) I 8.5'
Actin
Actinin
46.OO0-47.000
I2"."
-95,000
13' 30.3" 7.8' 9-1 I " 5.1'
O"."
7.W 9.3'
33
SULFHYDRYL AND DlSULFlDE GROUPS I N MEATS TABLE V
Protein Tropomyosin
Molecular weight
( L ontinued)
SH
SS
SH
+ SS"
3-5" 4.31 4.7"
70.000 ( o r 35.000)
3. I'
Troponin
8 1 .OOO
5" 5.4"'
Troponin I
24,000
13.9.' 12.0"
Troponin T
37.000
Troponin C
1 8 .OOO-20 .OW
M-Protein
165.000
I .6.r 0. I " 0.4'' 8.9' 5.0'' 3.8" 4.4""
I"
3.7' 4" 4.3" 4.6' 4"
10"
12.2'
10.2''
" Usually determined as cysteine acid by amino acid analysis. in some cases also as SH after reduction 0 1 SS. " Ebashi and Nonomura (1973). ' Woods and Hartley (1967). " Bariny P r t i / . (1964). " Tonomura (1973). Robson and Zeece (1973). "Connel (1961). * Buttkus (1971). a Brennock and Read ( 1972). Hofmann (l972a). Ehrlich (1967); Hamm and Hofmann ( 1965). Staib and Turba (1956). ''I Kofman (1963). " Drabikowski and Nowak (1970). " Carsten (1966). Martonosi (1968). Cohen et a / . (1973). Suzuki P I N / . (1973). Yasui et a / . (1968). Hodges and Smillie (1970). ' Hodges and Smillie (1972). ' Ebashi er d.(1968). Arai and Watanabe (1968). Wilkinson et cd. (1972). ' Greaser EI a / . (1973). Schaub et a / . (1972). "" Masaki and Takaiti (1974).
'
'
34
KLAUS HOFMANN AND REINBR HAMM TABLE VI ESTIMATES OF SH GROUPS IN MYOFlBRlLS
SH reagent
Moles SH (per lo5 gm protein)
Original SH data"
AgNOS NEM NEM PCMB PCMB DTNB DTNB DTNB DTNB DTNB CH3HgN03 o-iodobenzoic acid
8.5-9.0 9.5 7.8-12.9" 3.5-4.0 8.9-9.7
85-90 pmoleslgm protein (1) 3.14 mg/gm protein (2) 2.59-4.27 mg/gm protein (3) 1.16-1.31 mglgm protein" (2) 2.95-3.21 mglgm protein (3) 5.4 moles/105 gm protein (4) 3.06-3.09 mg/gm protein (3) 0.59 pmolelmg N ( 5 ) 3.0-3.9 moles/105 gm protein (6) 8.6-9.6 moles/105 gm protein" (6) 60-65 pmoledgm protein ( I ) 85-90 pmoledgrn protein' ( I ) 8.8 mole/105 gm protein (7) 2.75-4.32 mg/gm protein (3)
''
5.4
9.2-9.3 9.4 3.0-3.9 8.6-9.6 6.0-6.5 8.5-9.0 8.8 8.3-13. I
Numbers in parentheses correspond to the following investigations: ( I ) Tinbergen (1970): (2) Hofmann and Hamrn (1966); ( 3 ) Hofmann, Miiller. and Baudisch (unpublished observations); (4) Arai and Watanabe (1968); (5) Khan rt al. (1968); (6) Hay rr a / . (1973); (7) Barany rt ( I / . ( I 964). " Mean value: 10.3 t 1.26 (n = 20). ' Reaction at pH 6.0. " Reaction at pH 7.4. " Myofibrila denatured. "
TABLE VII DISTRIBUTION OF THE SULFHYDRYL AND DISULFIDE GROUPS UPON THE MAJOR MYOFIBRILLAR PROTEINS
Protein Myosin Actin Tropomyosin Troponin
mg SH/100 gm total myofibrillar protein
%
mg SS/lOO gm total myofibrillar protein
%
I56 70 3
65 29
-
-
-
1
10
4
12 11
48 52
SULFHYDRYL AND DISULFIDE GROUPS IN MEATS
35
figures were obtained by combining the mean values of Tables Wand V. As Table VII shows, more than 95% of the sulfhydryls of myofibrils are located in the actinmyosin system, whereas all disulfide bonds are built into the tropomyosintroponin system.
a . Myosin. There are about forty-two SH groups in the myosin molecule. Many authors have found that the number of SH groups in myosin which are titratable with PCMB is approximately equal to the halfcystine content found by amino acid analysis. Myosin probably, therefore, contains no SS bridge (Tonomura, 1973). In Table V,the values for the myosin subunit heavy meromyosin (HMM). including its components, subfragments 1 and 2 and the subunit light meromyosin (LMM), are also listed. The amino acid sequence around the SH residues of myosin has been extensively studied. The conclusion that myosin contains at least 16 and probably between 20 and 22 unique thiol sequences indicates that the molecule consists of two chemically equivalent components (Weeds and Hartley, 1968). There is remarkable agreement that purified myosin has three distinguishable light chains (C,, Cqr C3). SH groups seem to participate in the interaction between the chains, because the blocking of SH groups of myosin with 5,5'dithiobis(2-nitrobenzoic acid) (DTNB) tends to release light chain C,. C, and C3 appear to have similar peptide chains. each containing a single cysteine peptide; C2 contains two cysteine residues. The amino acid sequence of these peptides has been clarified (Taylor, 1972). b. Actin. The SH groups of actin, which are titratable with PCMB or 2.3dicarboxy-4-iodoacetamide azobenzene are found to be approximately equal to the number of halfcystines in the molecules as determined by amino acid analysis. Like myosin, actin contains no SS-bridge (Tonomura, 1973). Only 1 mole of SH per mole of G-actin binds rapidly with SH reagents, and subsequently there is a slower reaction. The same holds true for F-actin: Only I mole per mole G-actin unit binds with SH reagents, while the remainder reacts even more slowly than with G-actin (Tonomura, 1973). Several SH-containing peptides have been isolated from the tryptic hydrolysates of actin (Young, 1969). Now the positions of the reactive and not available cysteine SH groups in the peptide chain of the G-actin molecule have been elucidated (Elzinga and Collins, 1973).
c. Tropomyosin. The molecular weight of tropomyosin was found to be about 70,000. In the presence of reducing agents, e.g., of P-rnercaptoethanol, tropomyosin dissociates into two similar subunits, each of the molecular weight of about 34,000. It has been suggested that a disulfide bond is involved in the association of the two subunits (Tonomura, 1973). In the procedures for isolation
36
KLAUS HOFMANN AND REINER HAMM
of tropomyosin, a reducing environment is usually provided in order to prevent oxidation. Therefore, it is not yet clear whether the tropomyosin is present in the myofibril as the SS-lined dimere or as the SH monomeres. In samples of rabbit tropomyosin from different animals, Woods (1968) found, in the absence of SH reagents, molecular weights between 40,000 and 85,700. After treatment with mercaptoethanol, molecular weights around 34,000 were obtained. Therefore, in some preparations, SS bridges seem to occur, while, in other preparations, they do not. d . Troponin. From the 5 moles SH/105 gm troponin, 1.8-2.5 do not react with NEM (Ebashi et al., 1968). In Table V the halfcystine (SH SS) figures of the three troponin subunits TN-I, TN-T, and TN-C are listed. TN-I inhibits ATPase activity of myosin, TN-T binds to tropomyosin, and TN-C binds Ca2+. In the troponin, these subunits are supposed to be present in the molar proportion 1:I : I . If this proportion of the three troponins is correct, the halfcystine figures obtained by Greaser et ul. (1973) (Table V) should result in 3.9 moles SH + SSlmole troponin. Drabikowski and Nowak (1970), however, found 8.1 moles SH + SSlmole. The latter figure seems to be more probable because it corresponds to the sum of SH and SS groups obtained by others (Table V).
+
2 . Sulfhydryl Groups Involved in the Function of Myofibrillar Proteins Several hundred publications deal with the role of SH groups of myofibrillar proteins in enzymatic activities, in the interaction with ions, substrates, and other proteins, and in the process of muscular contraction and relaxation. It is impossible to quote all these papers in this brief review. But in addition to the more recent research work, research papers and review articles will be cited which mediate the access to all the other literature. a . Myosin. SH groups are important for the adenosine triphosphatase (ATPase) activity of myosin because SH reagents modify this enzyme in various ways (Bendall, 1969; Young, 1969; Ebashi and Nonomura, 1973; Seidel and Gergely, 1973; Tonomura, 1973; Taylor, 1972). Fifty percent of the ATPase activity is lost when five groups of 42 SH groups per molecule are blocked, and inactivation is complete if seven per molecule are blocked. These groups are located in the head region of the molecule, probably fairly close to the active site. It is known that there are two kinds of particularly reactive cysteine residues per subunit of myosin, generally referred to as S, and S2 (or SH1 and SH2). These groups are located at or near the active site of the HMM moiety and near the binding site for ATP. Blocking of the S, sulfhydryls results in an increase in the Ca2+- activated
SULFHYDRYL AND DISULFIDE GROUPS IN MEATS
37
ATPase activity with a simultaneous loss in the K+ (EDTA) activated ATPase. Blocking of both sulfhydryls, S, and S2. eliminates both types of ATPases. If the S2 groups alone are modified, the enzyme activity is similar to that of the &-modified myosin; namely, Ca-activated ATPase is activated and K+ (EDTA) activity is lost. The requirement of both sulfhydryls for the inhibition of myosin ATPase in the presence of MgATP has also been demonstrated (Seidel, 1972; Reisler et al., 1974a). Measurements of the binding of nucleoside di- and triphosphates by native, S, or S,-blocked myosin revealed that all three forms bind ATP equally well. Thus, although SH blocking does not alter the binding of a substrate. it does interrupt the catalytic process. In the resting muscle, myosin contains bound MgATP which decreases its reactivity with NEM, an effect which is not reproduced by adenosine diphosphate or any other nucleotide (Barany and Barany, 1973). It has been suggested that maximum inhibition and maximum activation of ATP hydrolysis in vivo occurs in the millimolar range of Mg2+ through the formation and disruption of a cyclic MgATP ternary complex with myosin, involving coordination with the S, and S2 sites. This idea could be confirmed by crosslinking the two essential SH groups with a bifunctional dimaleimide reagent (Reisler et al., 1974b). The results of Petuskova (1973) also indicate a paired arrangement of these SH groups. Petaskova suggested that the role of SH groups in myosin probably consists of maintaining the structural integrity of the molecule and not in the direct participation in the hydrolysis of ATP. The S, groups react more rapidly with NEM or PCMB than the S2 groups. There is only one S , and S, group per heavy chain of myosin. The S, and S2 groups are generally presumed to be in subfragment 1 of the HMM. Phenolic SH reagents were found to activate Ca2+-ATPase and to inhibit K+(EDTA)-ATPase of both HMM and subfragment I , which make up the head of the myosin molecule. The S,-blocking of subfragment 1 proceeds much faster than that of HMM. ATP-induced conformational changes around the active site of myosin and HMM which were caused by the modification of the S2 group were preserved in subfragment 1. Therefore, the effect of phenolic SH reagents on myosin ATPase and that of ATP on the conformation around S2 cannot be interpreted in terms of subunit-subunit interaction (Kameyama et al., 1974). The reaction of myosin SH groups with DTNB liberates a single class of light chains of 18,000 daltons from HMM without a significant loss of ATPase activity. The other light chains. however, cannot be removed without a reduction in such activity (Weeds and Frank, 1973). Kakol (1971) suggested that the SH groups of the light chains of myosin are essential in preserving ATPase activity. The sequences reported for peptides containing the S, and S2 groups, however, are different from the sequences around the SH groups of the light chains (Taylor, 1972). Myosin contains about 2 moles of “intrinsic” Ca2+which cannot be removed
38
KLAUS HOFMANN A N D REINER HAMM
by the usual purification methods but which can be irreversibly removed by treatment with PCMB followed by P-mercaptoethanol. The latter reagent completely removes the PCMB from the myosin so that ATPase activity is completely recovered. The ATPase activity of actomyosin reconstituted from this myosin and actin is very different from that containing Ca2+ (Tonomura, 1973). In addition to ATPase activity, the ability of myosin to combine with actin is essential for the process of muscular contraction. SH groups are involved in this interaction between myosin and actin (Needham, 1973; Tonomura, 1973). Since myosin masked with certain SH reagents can bind with actin, even though its ATPase activity has been completely eliminated, the active sites for two functions must be different. Other results, however, are not consistent with this idea. Out of the 15 SH groups contained in 200,000 gm myosin, two are necessary for ATPase activity, while three are essential for actin combination; one of these groups is supposed to take part in both phenomena. The effect of F-actin on S,-blocked HMM (with NEM) as shown by Kameyama and Sekine (1973) suggests that the S2 region may be involved in the successive and cyclic conformation changes in the contractile protein system thought to occur in the sliding process of filaments. Other experiments have revealed an involvement of the S, group in the actin binding of myosin, because the binding of actin to myosin causes a conformational change of myosin by influencing the S, groups (Seidel, 1973). Therefore, it is not surprising that, at physiological ionic strength, the binding of actin to myosin has the same effect as the activation of myosin ATPase by the modification of the S, group (Burke et al., 1974). Treatment of actomyosin in the absence of salt, i.e., in the gel state, revealed that actin protects the S, group from reaction with NEM. That the Mg-activated ATPase also remains unaffected implies that the same sulfhydryls are necessary for the functioning of the Mg-activated reaction when the ionic forces involved in the overall interactions are in effect. In the presence of salt and Ca2+,however, treatment with increasing NEM concentrations produces stepwise inactivation of both Ca- and Mg-activated ATPases. The protein unit of one myosin and two actins may react first with about 7-8 NEM molecules without effect (Bkiny and Merrifield, 1973; Schaub and Watterson, 1973). 6 . Acfin. Sulfhydryl groups are also involved in the functional properties of actin (Drabikowski and Bitny-Szlachto, 1964). It was shown that mercurials inhibit the polymerization of G-actin to F-actin and also cause the release of bound nucleotides. By the use of various SH reagents, it was possible to separate these processes and to show that the actin molecule contains at least three kinds of SH groups: The first, which apparently is not connected with any specific property of actin, reacts directly with NEM; the second kind is involved in the polymerization of this protein; and the third is more or less directly connected with the nucleotide binding. It was suggested that two SH groups per mole are required for binding ATP.
SULFHYDRYL AND DISULFIDE GROUPS I N MEATS
39
The different effects obtained by blocking the same SH groups of G-actin with various SH reagents on polymerization, however, lead to two questions: Can different SH groups be assigned to polymerization and nucleotide binding sites and are the SH reagents specific (Taylor, 1972). From spin labeling experiments, it has been concluded that, in addition to tyrosine, lysine, and histidine, sulfhydryls are involved in the configurational changes during polymerization of actin. Laki and Alving (1973) found that one SH group of the G-actin moiety of F-actin participates in the dephosphorylation of ATP by actin. Modification of actin by treatment with SH reagents (PCMB, iodoacetamide, NEM) did not interfere with actin-myosin combination. Modification of HMM with PCMB, however, inhibited combination. These results of Heazlitt et al. (1973) confirmed the observation of Kuschinsky and Turba (195 I ) that while SH groups from myosin are necessary for the symplex formation of actin and myosin, those from actin are not.
c. “Natural Actomyosin, Troponin, Tropomyosin. “Natural actomyosin,” extracted from muscle fibers or myofibrils, is a complex of the proteins actin, myosin, tropomyosin, troponin, and some minor protein components. This complex represents the contractile system of the myofibril. A mixture of tropomyosin and troponin (“natural tropomyosin”), when added to a purified system of actin and myosin, confers upon the ATPase activity of the latter system the extreme sensitivity against Ca2+ ions which is a marked feature of the intact fiber and fibrillar preparations. Pure tropomyosin, even with SH groups carefully protected against oxidation, fails to do so (Bendall, 1969). SH groups are involved in the Ca-sensitizing effect of the tropomyosintroponin system on myosin (Daniel and Hartshorne, 1972). SH reagents can remove the Ca-sensitive response of “natural actomyosin. This effect has been shown both by the measurement of ATPase activity and by superprecipitation. In either case the inhibitory effect of the troponin-tropomyosin complex in the absence of Ca2+ is blocked. A similar effect has also been shown with muscle fiber in that the reaction with NEM caused tension development under Ca2+-free conditions which normally favored relaxation (Kuriyama et al., I97 1). Troponin was originally considered as a likely site of the critical SH group, and experiments with PCMB suggested that this was the case. However, it has been shown that PCMB can be transferred between different muscle proteins; one therefore cannot be certain of this hypothesis. From labeling experiments with NEM it was concluded that the critical SH site might be on the myosin molecule, and PCMB or NEM treatment of troponin did not produce a marked effect on either its Ca-sensitizing activity or Ca-binding activity (Ebashi and Nonomura, 1973). Hartshorne and Daniel (1970) also came to the conclusion that SH groups of troponin are not essential for its function. So the postulation of Fuchs (1971) that Ca-sensitive SH groups exist at a site of troponin, which is essential for its regulatory function, may be incorrect. I’
”
40
KLAUS HOFMANN A N D REINER H A M M
The integrity of certain SH sites on myosin seems to be essential for the normal Ca-sensitizing effect of “natural actomyosin.” Daniel and Hartshorne (1972) demonstrated that the SH groups, which are essential for Ca sensitivity of the normal “natural actomyosin,” are located in the heavy chains of the myosin molecule and that the critical SH groups are not identical with the S, sulfhydryl groups of myosin. Seidel and Gergely ( 1 973) also concluded from spin labeling experiments that the SH groups, whose blocking has been shown to abolish Ca-sensitivity, are not the S, groups. SH groups appear to play no essential role in the attachment of troponintropomyosin to myosin. As to tropomyosin, carboxymethylation of the SH groups reduced the inhibitory effect of this protein on the Ca-stimulated ATPase of desensitized actomyosin but did not effect the Mg-stimulated ATPase (Cummins and Perry, 1973). The supposition that SH groups of tropomyosin may be involved in the polymerization of this protein could nor be confirmed by Drabikowski and Nowak (1 965). d. Actinins. The substitution of about half of the SH groups of myosin by 2-aminoethyl isothiuronium makes the resulting actomyosin unresponsive for a-actinin (no activation of ATPase activity or of the turbidity response by a-actinin); the same substitution of actin does not affect the response to a-actinin. Either substitution diminishes the binding of c-w-actinin to actomyosin; neither substitution abolishes contractility measured in terms of gel syneresis (Seraydarian et al., 1968). PCMB did not affect the shortening in length of F-actin particles by p-actinin (Maruyama, 1971).
e . Muscle Fibers. In the presence of Ca and Mg ions, ATP is split rapidly by the actomyosin filaments. The free energy from this process is used for contraction and for the development of power through the mediation of the sliding of actin and myosin filaments over one another. By modifying the enzyme sites on the actin and myosin filaments (e.g., by the addition of the SH reagent salyrgan to a fiber which develops tension in the presence of ATP, Mg’+ and Ca2+), the ATPase activity and the tension immediately drop to zero and the fiber releases. This effect of salyrgan can be reversed by the addition of cysteine, restoring the SH groups on the enzyme center once more and allowing ATP to split and tension to be redeveloped (Bendall, 1969).
B. PROTEINS OF THE SARCOPLASMIC RETICULUM (SR) Several different protein SH groups are present in the SR. Some of them are clearly involved in the ATPase activity and the Ca-accumulation function of this
SULFHYDRYL A N D DISULFIDE GROUPS IN MEATS
41
system. It is believed that seven proteins are components of the Ca-transport system of SR, such as ATPase, proteolipid, calsequestrin, 54,000 dalton protein, and "acidic proteins." The proteolipid contains 24 halfcystine equivalents per lo5 gni protein. the 54,000 dalton protein 7.4/105 gm (detected as cysteic acid) (MacLennan p t al., 1973). Hasselbach and Seraydarian (1966) demonstrated that lo5 gm of the vesicular protein contained seven equivalents. of which three reacted readily with NEM without the impairment of Ca transport or of ATPase activity. Loss of the extra ATP splitting associated with Ca uptake, as well as loss of Ca transport and storage. followed blockage of the other four SH equivalents. The SH groups are located on the outer surface of the transporting membranes. According to Panet and Selinger (1 970). ten SH equivalents per 1 O5 gm membrane protein of the SR are titratable by DTNB in the absence of sodium dodecyl sulfate (SDS); however, in the presence of SDS, 14 SH groups were found. ATP protected SH groups essential for the ATPase activity of the SR. The asymmetric distribution of proteins in the SR membranes, containing 10-12 mole SH groups per lo5 gm protein. became symmetric if more than four SH groups were blocked by 2-chloromercuri-4-dinitrophenol: At this point, the Ca-dependent ATPase of the SR was completely inhibited, but Mg-dependent ATPase was slightly activated and Ca transport was inhibited (Dupont and Hasselbach, 1973). PCMB and p-chloromercuribenzene sulfonic acid (CMBS) increased the rate of Ca efflux from the whole frog muscle. While PCMB appeared to inhibit SH groups in the terminal cysternae of SR (causing a fractionating of the muscle twitch), CMBS seemed to act primarily at the surface sites with limited access to the cysternae (Kirsten and Kuperman. 19704. The muscle showed increased rigor tension irz v i m when incubated with 1 mM NEM, and Ca efflux from the whole muscle was increased. NEM apparently produces rigor by inhibition of Ca uptake through the SR (Kirsten and Kuperman, 1970b). So the effect of NEM o n muscle physiology seems to be detemiined not only by its reaction with myosin SH groups as mentioned above but also by the reaction with the SH groups of SR. C.
PROTEINS OF THE SARCOLEMMA
Modification of the SH groups of the sarcolenima with DTNB did not affect the Ca-dependent ATPase, but it decreased the Mg-dependent ATPase of these membranes. When the reagent was added in the absence of ATP, both enzymes were inhibited whether the divalent cations were present or not. Cysteine or dithiothreitol reversed this enzyme inhibition. Modification of the sarcolemma SH groups by NEM strongly inhibited the activity of both ATPases in the presence of ATP, and fully inhibited them in the absence of ATP. This inhibition was
42
KLAUS HOFMANN A N D REINER HAMM
not reversed by cysteine or dithiothreitol (Gimmelreikh and Koval, 1973). The activity of the Na+/K+-stimulatedATPase of the sarcolemma is inhibited by such SH reagents as PCMB or NEM (Matsushima, 1974). D.
PROTEINS OF MITOCHONDRIA
A substantial number of SH groups are present in the mitochondrial membranes (Jocelyn, 1972). Protein SH groups are involved in the electron transport. The flavoprotein and cytochrome components of the electron transport chain possess SH groups. The SH groups of NADH dehydrogenase appear to be mainly structural and not to have a catalytic function in accepting electrons. The SH groups of succinic dehydrogenase may be both structural and catalytic. The transfer of electrons from NADH dehydrogenase to coenzyme Q may require SH groups; the further transfer to cytochrome c does not, although the enzyme complex concerned contains several SH groups. The cytochrome itself contains SH and SS groups. Cytochrome oxydase contains some SH groups, but it is not known whether they are required for activity. Various observations have implicated SH groups in the yet unresolved mechanism of oxidative phosphorylation. Oxidative phosphorylation is inhibited not only by NEM and DTNB but also by arsenicals, suggesting that SH groups are required. The passive membrane transport of inorganic phosphate by a special mechanism, unlike the other mitochondrial exchange systems, is inhibited by SH-combining agents such as DTNB, mercurials, or NEM. As to the active transport, Ca2+ accumulation is partly inhibited by SH reagents such as mercurials, but the Na+/K+-exchange is stimulated for unknown reasons. The effect of mercurials on the ATPase of mitochondria varies from a stimulation at a low concentration to an inhibition at a higher concentration. E.
PROTEINS OF THE SARCOPLASMIC MATRIX
The supernatant, which is obtained after centrifugation of a muscle homogenate at about 100,000 X g, contains a great number of dissolved albumins and globulins. Not all of these contain SH groups. So it is known that no SH groups are present in the myoglobin from the mammalian skeletal muscles. SH groups are, however, involved in the activity of enzymes of the glycolytic chain. Glycolysis is inhibited by the SH reagent iodoacetate at a concentration which does not affect contraction (Jocelyn, 1972). Some of the SH dependent enzymes have been isolated. They include phosphofructokinase, glyceraldehyde-3phosphate dehydrogenase, lactate dehydrogenase, and phosphorylase. In addi-
43
SULFHYDRYL A N D DISULFIDE GROUPS I N MEATS
tion to these glycolytic enzymes, creatine phosphotransferase requires SH groups for its activity.
IV. SH AND SS CONTENT OF MEATS AND MEAT FRACTIONS The SS content of tissues is generally rather low. Therefore, most investigations have dealt with the estimation of the SH content only. Much confusion exists in literature concerning the term “SH content in tissue,” because there are different kinds of SH groups which are not always clearly differentiated from each other. Ellman (1959). who introduced DTNB for the assay of SH groups in biological material, entitled his publication, “Tissue Sulfhydryl Groups.” However, only the SH content in the tissue extracts was estimated; no similar estimate was made for whole tissues. Other authors (e.g., Khan) have used the term “SH groups in meat” quite generally, although only the nonprotein SH content of extracts was estimated. Therefore, it is absolutely necessary to explain what type of SH groups were estimated in each case. The total SH content of meat is distributed on protein and nonprotein substances as well. The different possible fractions are shown in the scheme of Table VIII. Boyne and Ellman (1972) used the term “total soluble SH” to refer to the sum of the SH content in the soluble proteins and in the nonprotein fraction. In the
TABLE VIII SCHEME OF THE DISTRIBUTION OF SH GROUPS IN MUSCLE TISSUE
Water insoluble proteins (e.g.. myofibrils)
e
-reactive SH slowly reacting SH
‘masked SH
,reactive
Water soluble proteins (e.g., sarcoplasmic proteins)
k
\
.Protein SH
SH
- total slowly reacting SH
masked SH cysteine SH
Nonprotein glutathione S H
SH
44
KLAUS HOFMANN A N D REINER HAMM
following tables, the total SH content of meat is generally given. In some cases, one cannot be sure if all SH groups or only a part of them were estimated by the reagent used. Therefore, the kind of reagent-whenever indicated in the literature-has been listed as well. Very different dimensions are used in literature for expressing the SH content in meat. Therefore, the original SH data were transformed to milligrams of SH/100 gm meat and/or to moles of SH/1OS gm protein for better comparison. Values given in parentheses correspond only approximately to the original data, because in these cases the protein contents were not indicated and the mean protein content of lean meat, which is about 18%, was taken as a basis for the calculation. In the following scheme, the factors used for the transformation of the original data are given.
[
mgSH 100 grn meat
X
1'
3.024
percent protein ~
[
1-
mole~H lo5 gm protein
3.024 x
[
mgSH
1
gm protein
097
The question of how the SH content in whole meat can best be expressed has no easy answer. It is not completely correct to relate the total SH content in whole meat to the protein content because a part of the SH groups in meat is not bound to protein. On the other hand, when the whole tissue (as wet weight) is used as a reference standard, the SH values are influenced by differences in concentrations of water, fat, and connective tissues (which are virtually free of SH groups), and the variations in the SH content of different meats can be attributed to changes in these factors. The answer to the question of what reference unit is to be employed depends on the kind and the aim of the investigations involved. There are cases in which statements can be contradictory depending on whether the results refer to meat or to protein. For instance, the SH content in cow and bull muscle was found to be 87.3 and 79.3 mg SH/l00 gm tissue, respectively, or 11.8 and 12.8 moles SH/105 gm protein, respectively. In the first case, the conclusion would be that the SH content in cow muscle was higher than in bull muscle; in the second case, it would seem to be lower. The reason for this apparent contradiction is the different protein content of both meats. This exam-
45
SULFHYDRYL AND DISULFIDE GROUPS IN MEATS
ple clearly shows that conclusions and comparisons of SH results must be drawn very carefully. There are many factors that influence the SH content of raw meat. It is not surprising, therefore, to find a considerable variation in the results of different literature in this field. These influences are discussed separately in Section IV,
D. A.
SH AND SS CONTENT OF MUSCLES
Values are listed for total SH content in pork and beef (Tables 1X and X), for muscles of various meat and test animals (Table XI), for nonprotein SH contents in muscles (Table XII) and for SS groups in muscles (Table XIII). Comrnenrs on Table IX: The SH figures in porcine muscles estimated with different SH reagents vary from 8 . 3 to 12.9 moles SH/I05 gm protein (49.6 to
TABLE IX SH GROUPS 1N PORCINE MUSCLES
Muscle
long. dorsib long. dorsi long. dorsi" long. dorsi" long. dorsi long. dorsi long. dorsi long. dorsi semimembr .'' semimembr. semimembr. psoas
SH reagent
&NO,
AgNO, DTNB NEM" NEMJ DTNB NEM' PNSS.*
SH (mg) per 100 gm tissue
Original SH data" 1 .SO pmolesll00 mg meat 1 I .6 moles/105 g prot. (2) 73.6 mg/lOO gm meat (3) 74.0 mg/100 gin meat (3) 3.14 mg/gm protein (4) 8.48 moles/lP gni protein 12.89 moles/105 gni protein 2.89 mglgm protein (4) 3.44 mg/gm protein (4) 1 1 .OX moles/105 gm protein 3.05 mg/gm protein (4) 283 pg/gm tissue (5)
(I)
(2) (2)
(2)
49.6 71 .O 73.6 74.0 (56.5) 50.5 76.7 (52.0) (61.9) 64.5 (54.9) 28.3
SH (moles) per lo5 gm protein (8.3) 11.6 11.2 11.3 9.5 8.5 12.9 8.7 10.4 11.1
9.2 (4.8)
Numbers in parentheses correspond to the following investigations: ( I ) Krylova and Kusnezowa (1964); (2) Hofmann. Bliichel. Miiller. Baudisch, and Hiinim (unpublished observations): (3) Hofmann CI ul. (1974): (4) Fischer and Hamm (1975); (5) Motoc and Banu (1968). 'I
M . /ongis.simits dorsi. Vacuum packaged after slaughter. " Air packaged after slaughter. In presence of dodecylsulfate. Reaction at pH 7.4. 'I M . semimembr-uriuc.eus. 'I Sodium nitroprusside. I'
46
KLAUS HOFMANN AND REINER HAMM
76.7 mg SHll00 gm tissue). The value of 4.8 moles SH, which was estimated with sodium nitroprusside, obviously does not represent the entire SH content. The average value is 10.2 moles SH/105 gm protein (62.2 mg SH/lOO gm tissue) when the low value is excluded. Figures estimated with AgNO, vary from 8.3 to 11.6, those estimated with NEM under different conditions from 8.7 to 12.9 and those estimated with Ellman’s reagent (DTNB) from 8.5 to 11.1 moles SH/105 gm protein. This shows that the values found with AgNO, are in the same range as the values found with NEM (at pH 7.4) and DTNB. No significant differences seem to exist between the SH contents of longissimus dorsi and semimembranaceus muscles. Comments on Table X : The values lower than 8 moles SH/105 gm protein do not seem to represent the normal total SH content in bovine muscle (even in some cases when AgNO, is used as a reagent). It is well known that sodium nitroprusside and NEM at pH 6.0 react only with one part of all SH groups in proteins (see Section 11, B,3 and 4). From the other values it can be concluded that the values for beef muscles vary from 8.5 to 12.1 moles SH/105gm protein (50.5-87.3 mg SH/l00 gm tissue); the mean value is 10.5 (65.9 respectively). These figures are virtually in the same range as those for pork. Therefore, contrary to the statement of Krylova and Kusnezowa (1 964), the SH content of pork is not generally higher than the SH content of beef. In addition there are no considerable differences in SH content between cow and bull muscles, between longissirnus dorsi and supra spinam muscle, or between vacuum-packed and air-packed muscles shortly after slaughter. The number of SH groups in calf muscles varying between 8.4 and 10.4 moles SH/1O5 gm protein (52.7-75.6 mg SH/lOO grn tissues) seems to be somewhat lower than those in beef. However, Krylova and Kusnezowa (1964) found that beef from animals at age 9-10 months gave higher SH values than that from animals at age 16-18 months. The differences in the SH content of longissimus dorsi and diaphragm muscles of calves were found to be significant (P < 0.01) (Fischer, Hofmann, and Hamm, unpublished observations). Comments on Table X I : All SH values estimated with PCMB, iodoacetate, and sodium nitroprusside (3.2-6.7 moles) are lower than those found with Ellman’s reagent or AgN03 (9.0-1 1.9 moles). The latter, which probably represent the total SH content in muscles, are within the range of the values estimated for pork and beef (see Tables IX and X). Therefore, the skeletal muscles of different animals (pigs, cattle, chickens, rats) contain approximately equal amounts of SH groups. The SH values of rabbit, rat, and frog muscles estimated with iodoacetate were also found to be comparable. The figure of 21.4 moles SH found by Caldwell and Lineweaver (1969) is certainly too high and is therefore not included in this discussion. Comments on Table XII: The content of nonprotein SH [respectively of glutathione (GSH)] in muscles varies in a wide range from 1.1 to 7.6 mg SH/100 gm meat (average 3.7). This may be due to the fact that the GSH content of
SULFHYDRYL AND DISULFIDE GROUPS IN MEATS
47
TABLE X SH GROUPS IN BOVINE MUSCLES
Sample. Muscle Beef, long. dorsi" Beef, long. dorsi" Beef, long. dorsi" Beef, ('?) muscle Beef, long. dorsi" Beef, long. dorsi' Beef, long. dorsi Beef, long. dorsi Beef, long. dorsi Beef, long. dorsi Beef, long. dorsi Beef, long. dorsi Beef, supra spinam Beef, psoas Bull, long. dorsi Cow, long. dorsi Calf, long. dorsi Calf, semimembr.' Calf. diaphragma Calf, long. dorsi Calf, semimembr. Calf, diaphragrna
SH reagent
Original SH data"
SH (mg) per 100 gm tissue
SH (moles) per 105 gm protein
8.8 moles SH/105 gm protein ( I ) 1.36 pmolesl100 mg meat (2) 1.03 pmolesll00 mg meat (2) 1.1 . moleslmg meat (3) 69.0 mg/IOO gm meat (4) 68.0 mgl100 gm meat (4) 11.25 moles/l05 gm protein (5) 61 pg/IOO mg tissue (6) 3.1-3.6 moles/105 gm protein (6) 106.0-1 15.8 pmoles/gm protein (7) 84.9-94.0 pmoles/gm protein (7) 9.11 moleslgm protein (5) 79.8 mgllOO gm meat (8) 273 pglgm tissue (9) 79.3 mgllOO gm meat (5) 87.3 mgllOO gm meat ( 5 ) 75.61 mg/IOO gm meat (10) 69.55 mg/lOO gm meat (10) 56.59 mgl100 gm meat (10) 9.08 moles/105gm protein (10) 8.99 moles/l05 gm protein (10) 8.42 molesil05 gm protein (10)
(52.4) 45.0 34.1 36.7 69.0 68.0 (67.0) 61.0 17.0-19.2 (63.1 -68.9) (50.5-55.9) 54.2 79.8 27.3 79.3 87.3 75.6 69.6 56.6 66.1 67.1 52.7
8.8 (7.6) (5.7) (6.2) 11.2 10.9 11.3 10.3 3.1-3.6 10.6-1 1.6 8.5-9.4 9.11 ( I 1.20) (4.54) 12.1 11.8 10.4 9.3 9.1 9.1 9.0 8.4
Numbers in parentheses correspond to the following investigations: ( I ) Hamm and Hofmann (1965); (2) Krylova and Kusnezowa (1964); (3) Bolshakov and Mitrofanov ( I 970); (4) Hofmann e r al. (1974): ( 5 ) Hofmann. Bliichel, Muller, Baudisch, and Hamm (unpublished observations); (6) Hamm and Hofmann (1966b); (7) Dzinleski er al. (1969); (8) Bognar (1971a); (9) Motoc and Banu (1968); (10) Fischer, Hofmann, and Hamm (unpublished observations). 'I M. longissimus dorsi . From 9-10-month-old animals. ' From 16-18-month-old animals. After slaughter. vacuum packaged. After slaughter, air packaged. " Reaction at pH 6.8. Reaction at pH 6.0; the meat samples were minced in different ways. i Sodium nitroprusside. j M . semimembrunaceus. ' Reaction at pH 7.4. 'I
('
'
TABLE XI SH GROUPS IN MUSCLES OF VARIOUS ANIMALS, INCLUDING TEST ANIMALS
Sample. Muscle"
SH reagent
Chicken, bright m. Chicken, dark m. Chicken, breast Chicken, breast Chicken, breast Chicken, pect. major Turkey, breast Turkey, breast Rabbit, unknown Halibut, whole m. Rat, gastrocn . Rat, unknown Frog, unknown
AgN03 AgNO, DTNB DTNB PCMB PrUSS.C DTNB AgN4 iodoac ." iodoac . DTNB DTNB iodoac.
Original SH data"
10.1 x moledmg protein (1) 11.1 x moleslmg protein ( 1 ) 0.4144.564 pmole SH/mg N (8) 1.34pmoles SH/mg N (9) 4.45moles x 10-8/mg protein (2) moles x IO-Vgm tissue (3) 5.8d-9.9r 0.491mmole/gm muscle (4) 2.73mmoles X 10-4/gm muscle (4) 0.79% cysteine in protein (5) 0.81 B cysteine in protein (5) 21.5pmoles/gm tissue (6) 1.63 mmoles/100 gm tissue (7) 0.724% cysteine in protein (5)
SH (mg) per 100 gm tissue
(60.1) (66.1) 39.3-53.7 (26.5) 19.2-32.7 1624' 0.W (38.8) (39.8) 71.1 53.9 (35.5)
per
SH (moles) lo5gm protein
10.1 11.1
6.6-9.0 21.4 4.5 3.2-5.5 6.5 6.7 (11.9) (9.0) 6.0
~~~~~
Abbreviations: m. = muscle; pect. = M . pectoralis; gastrocn. = M. gasrrocnemius. investigations: (1) Bolshakov and Mitrofanov (1970); (2)Bolshakov er af. (1972); (3)Chajuss and Spencer (1962b); (4) Bowers (1972); (5) Mirsky (1936);(6)Boyne and Ellman (1972);(7)Sedlak and Lindsay (1968);(8) Miller and Spencer (1975);(9)Caidwell and Lineweaver ( 1969). Sodium nitroprusside. " 0 hours postmortem. " 72 hours postmortem. The original data are obviously not correct. iodoacetate.
* Numbers in parentheses correspond to the following
'
49
SULFHYDRYL AND DlSULFlDE GROUPS IN MLATS TABLE XI1 NONPROTEIN SH A N D GSH CONTENT OF SKELETAL MUSCLES 01. MEAT A N D TEST ANIMALS
Sample
SH reagent
Pork Beef Beef Lamb Chicken" Chicken" Chic ken Rat Rat
ASNOS AgNOz DTNB HgC12 Prusside' Prusside Prusside DTNB DTNB
Original data"
2.6 mg SH/100 gm meat (1) 1.9 mg SHil00 gm meat ( I ) 3.94 mg GSH/gm protein (2) 15 rng CySH/100 gm tissue (3) 238" pg GSH/gm muscle (4) 395 eg GSH/gm muscle (4) 0.33"'pmoIc SH/gin muscle (5) 0.07 mmole SH/100 gni tissue (6) I .96 pmole SH/gm tissue (7)
SH (mg) per 100 gm meat
2.6 1.9 (7.6) (4.1)
2.6 4.3 1.1
2.3 6.5
Numbers in parentheses correspond to the following investigations: ( 1 ) Hofmann ef ul. (1974); ( 2 ) Dub6 ef ul. (1972); (3) Oganessjan and Dschani-
I'
bekova (1958); (4) Khan and van den Berg (1965); (5) Khan and Nakamura (1971); (6) Sedlak and Lindsay (1968); (7) Boyne and Ellman (1972). " Breast muscle. Sodium nitroprusside. " These data obviously represent nonprotein SH, although not characterized as such. " Leg muscle. This value was taken from a graph I'
'
animal tissues is influenced by several factors (see Section IV, D). Nonprotein SH related to total SH content of muscles (about 65 mg/100 gm tissue) varies from 2 to 12 %. Oganesjan and Dschanibekova (1958) found 12-16% nonprotein SH. Using the corresponding data given in Tables IX-XI, the following values for the nonprotein SH content of skeletal muscles were calculated: pork, 3%. beef, 4% (Hofmann et al., 1974), and rat, 4% (Sedlak and Lindsay, 1968). Hornsey (1959) found in the filtrate of the heat-cleared "emulsions" of pork leg muscle in water only 0 . 6 4 . 7 mg SH/100 gm meat. These values are low in comparison to those given in Table XII. The nonprotein SH groups were probably partly oxidized to SS groups during the heat treatment. The nonprotein SS was estimated to be 0.8-1.1 mg SS/l00 gm meat, and the sum of the SH and SS values in meat ( I .6-1.7 mg/lOO gm) corresponds quite reasonably t o some of the SH values listed in Table XII. Comnients on Table X I U : The SS content in muscles found by several investigators varies from 6.1 to 22.9 mg SS/loO gm meat (0.5-2.0 moles SS/105 gm protein). This significant variation may be due to the different degrees of oxidation of the SH groups. On the other hand, the SS content in muscle tissue can
50
KLAUS HOFMANN AND REINER HAMM TABLE XI11 SS GROUPS" IN MUSCLE
Sample, Muscle
Original data"
SS (mg) per 100 gm meat
SS (moles) per lo5 gm protein
Pork, long. dorsi" Pork, semimembr." Pork, long. dorsi Pork. long. dorsi Beef, long. dorsi Beef, long. dorsi Beef, supra spinam Calf, long. dorsi Calf, semimembr. Calf, diaphragm
I .27 mg SS/gm protein (1) 0.95 mg SS/gm protein (1) 6. I mg SS/IOO gm meat (2) 0.83 mg SS/gm protein (3) 1 . 1 1 mg SS/gm protein (3) 7.4 mg SS/lOO gm meat (2) I .23 mg SS/gm protein (4) 0.78 mg SSlgm protein ( 5 ) 0.67 mg SS/gm protein ( 5 ) 1.19 mg SS/gm protein ( 5 )
(22.9) (17. I ) 6 .I 14.9 20.0 7.4 (22. I ) (14.0) (12.1) (2 1.4)
2.0 I .5 (0.5) I .3 1.7 (0.6) I .9 I .2 I .o I .9
" For the assay of the SS values listed, NaBH, was used to reduce SS to SH and AgNO, was used to titrate the SH groups formed. " Numbers in parentheses correspond to the following investigators: ( I ) Fischer and Hamm (1975); (2) Hofmann, Baudisch. and Hamm (unpublished observations); (3) Hofmann, Muller. and Hamm (unpublished observations); (4) Bognar (1971a); ( 5 ) Fischer. Hofmann, and Hamm (unpublished observations). '' M. longissirnus dursi. M. semimembruniireus.
''
depend on the age of the animals tested. For example Oeriu (1962, 1964) reported that the aging process in animals (guinea pig, dog, rabbit, rat) leads to an increase in the SS content in blood and in several tissues. However, the variation in the SS content in beef and veal is so great that a similar tendency cannot be recognized. It should be emphasized that in any case the SS content is only a small proportion of the cysteine plus cystine content in muscles (see Table XIV).
B . CYSTEINE PLUS CYSTINE CONTENT OF MUSCLES Cysteine is the only amino acid in proteins which contains the SH group. Therefore, the cystine content can be estimated by determination of the SH content. As cystine can be reduced (e.g., with sodium borhydride according to the reaction CySSCy 2 H + 2 CySH), the content of cysteine plus cystine (total cystine) can be determined after the reduction of the protein. Table XIV shows the values for the (total) cyctine content of muscles. These estimations were carried out either by means of amino acid analysis after hydrolysis or by using the assay of SH (SH + SS/2) after reducing the SS groups. The factors for the transformation of the different terms are given in the following schema:
+
51
SULFHYDRYL AND DISULFIDE CROUPS I N MEATS mg SH red. [gm protein]
x 0 363 -+
1
gm cystine 0 120x mole (SH + SSI2) gm protein] + 105 gm protein
[
TABLE XIV CYSTEINE PLUS CYSTINE CONTENT (CALCULATED AS CYSTINE) OF MUSCLES
Sample
Assay
Beef Beef Beef Beef Beef Beef" Beef" Pork Pork Pork Lamb
Amino acid Amino acid Amino acid SH + SSIZ" SH + SSl2" SH + SS/2b SH + SW2" SH + SSI2" SH + SSI2" Amino acid Amino acid
Original data'' 1.0-1.3 gm cystindl6 gm N (1) 1.2-1.5 gm cystine/l6 gm N (2) 1.35 % protein (3) 4.93 mg SHlgm protein (4) 12.1 moles SH/IOs gm protein (5) 10.9-12.1 moles SH/105 gm protein ( 5 ) 10.7-10.8 moles SH/IOs gm protein (5) 12.4 moles SH/105 gm protein ( 5 ) 4.424.45 mg SH red.'/gm protein (6) 1.31 70protein ( 3 ) I .35 9% protein (3)
Cystine (gm) per 100 gm protein
I .o-I .3 I .2-1.5 1.35 I .79 1.45 1.31 - I .46 I .29-1.30 1.49 1.60-1.62 1.31 1.35
Numbers in parentheses correspond to the following investigators: ( I ) Bigwood (1960, cited in Bigwood. 1972); (2) Greenwood et ul. (1951); (3) Schweigert and Payne (1956); (4)Bognar (1971a); (5) Hofmann, Miiller, and Hamm (unpublished observations); (6) Fischer and Hamm (1975). Using AgN03. I ' Freeze-dried meat. " Using NEM. 1.03 x SS [mg]. SH red. = SH
+
The sum of SH and reduced SS is called SH red (calculation see footnotee, Table XIV). The values of the total cystine content in muscles estimated by amino acid analysis (Table XIV) vary from 1 .O to 1.35 gm/l00 gm protein, and the values obtained by determination of the SH groups vary from 1.29 to 1.79. The higher values for SH groups in the nonhydrolyzed protein may be explained by the fact that during hydrolysis cystine is partly destroyed (see Section 11, C ) , and in this respect the results obtained with myofibrils may be interesting. After reduction of the myofibrils with NaBH4 at different temperatures (20"-70°C), 4.26-4.43 mg SH/gm protein was determined, corresponding to I .55-1.60 gm total cystine/lO gm protein (Hofmann, 1964). On the other hand, the amino acid analysis after acid hydrolysis of the same material with 6 N HCl led to a value of 1.2 gm cystine/l00 gm protein, again demonstrating the detrimental effect of protein hydrolysis. Consequently, the most probable mean value of the cysteine plus
52
KLAUS HOFMANN AND REINER HAMM
cystine content of beef, pork, and lamb muscle seems to be 1.5 gm cystinef100 gm protein. This value corresponds to 12.5 moles SH/105 gm protein or 4.1 mg SH/gm protein. C. SH CONTENT OF ORGANS There is a great confusion in the literature in presenting SH values. In the earlier papers, very often the symbols pg, 7 , and u were used which should mean gm. However, the corresponding values would be too low by a factor of 103 in comparison to the values given in the more recent literature or to all the values for muscle tissue (Table IX-XI). Therefore the mentioned symbols were interpreted as gm. The total SH groups content in liver is listed in Table XV, and in several other inner organs in Table XVI. The nonprotein SH content in these organs are listed in Table XVII. The following comments are provided for these tables. Comments on Table XV: The SH content of the liver of pig, rabbit, mouse, and rat varies from 23.4 to 98.6 mg SH/lOO gm tissue. It should be mentioned that the average SH content of liver (47.2 mg SH) is lower than that of muscles (65 mg SH). This is somewhat surprising, but liver is rich only in nonprotein SH TABLE XV ESTIMATES OF SH GROUPS IN LIVER OF MEAT A N D TEST ANIMALS
Sample
SH reagent
Original SH data","
Rabbit Rabbit Mouse Mouse Mouse Mouse Rat Rat Rat Rat Rat
Ferricyanide CMPAN' FCMB PCMB Ferricyanide CMPAN
46.5 ?/I00 mg (I) 45.2 ? / I 0 0 mg ( I ) 23.4 ull00 mg (2) 30-35 $100 mg (3) 31.3-52.9-y/lOO mg (1) 35.6-59.4y/IOO mg (1) 55.4 mg/i00 gm (4) 2.03 mmole/100 gm (5) 29.8fimoleslgm (6) 35.648.4?/I00 gm ( I ) 36.7-53.8y/IOO gm (I)
DTNB DTNB Ferricyanide CMPAN
SH (mg) per 100 gm tissue
46.5 45.2 23.4 30-35 31.3-52.9 35.6-59.4 55.4 67.0 98.6 35.6-48.4 36.7-53.8
Numbers in parentheses correspond to the following investigators: ( I ) Flesch and Kun (1950);(2)Calcutt and Doxey (1959);(3) Calcutt (1961);(4)Bhattacharya (1959);(5)Sedlak and Lindsay (1968);(6)Boyne and Ellman (1972). * Related to tissue wet weight. However, some of the given dimensions are obviously not correct (see preliminary remark to Section 1V.C). CMPAN = I -(4-chloroniercuriphenylazo)-naphthol-2. a
53
SULFHYDRYL AND DlSULFlDE GROUPS I N MEATS TABLE XVI ESTIMATES OF SH GROUPS IN INNER ORGANS" OF TEST ANIMALS ~~
Sample, Organ
SH reagent
Original SH data".'
Rat. heat Rat. heart Rat. heart Rat, h e m Mouse. heart Mouse. heart Rat. kidney Rat, kidney Rat, kidney Mouse. kidney Mouse. kidney Mouse. kidney Rat. brain Rat. brain Rat, brain Mouse. brain Mouse, brain
DTNB Ferricyan ide CMPANd Ferricyanide CMPAN &NO, Ferric yanide CMPAN Ferricyanidc CMPAN PCMB &NO, Ferricyanide CMPAN Ferricyanide CMPAN
31.2 nig/100 grn (I) 1.54 mmoles/lOo grn (2) 20.1 y/lW mg (3) 48.9y/100 rng (3) 17.2 yll00 mg (3) 41.9 y/100 rng (3) 48.3 rng/100 gm (I) 25.2 $100 mg (3) 56.4y/IOO rng (3) 20.4y/lOO mg (3) 54.3 y/l00 rng (3) 9.9 v/lOO rng (4) 4.9prnoleslgrn ( 5 ) 15.6y/lOO mg (3) 59.2y/lOO mg (3) 14.0y/100 mg (3) 52.7 y/lW rng (3)
~
SH (nig) per 100 gni tissue 31.2 50.9 20.I 48.9
17.2 41.9 48.3 25.2 56.4 20.4 54.3 9.9 16.2 15.6 59.2 14.0 52.7
For liver. see Table X V . correspond to the following investigators: ( I ) Bhattacharya (1959);(2) Sedlak and Lindsay (1968);(3) Flesch and Kun (1950);(4)Calcutt and Doxey ( 1959);(5)Gabay et ul. ( 1 968). See Note b to Table XV. CMPAN = 1 -(4-chloromercuriphenylazo)-naphthol-2.
* Numbers in parentheses
compounds (see comments on Table XVlI). The SH contents in liver of the different animals, as far as they were cstimated by the same author, do not diffcr considerably. Commmfs on Table X V I : The SH values listed in Table XVI are very different from each other due to the use of different SH reagents. The following ranges were found for rat and mouse: heart 17.2-50.9, kidney 9.9-56.4, and brain 14.0-59.2 mg SH/100 gm tissue. It is obvious that the SH content of these inner organs is generally lower than that of muscles. In fact, even the maximum value for organs is lower than the average value for muscles (65 mg SH/lOO gm tissue). Comments on Table XVII: The highest nonprotein SH contents for all organs were found in liver (average value 22.7 mg SH/lOO gm tissue) and the lowest in heart, stomach, diaphragm, and lung (4.9-8.6 mg SH/100 gm tissue). The values for kidney lie in between. It is noteworthy that the nonprotein SH content of the organs of trained animals is generally higher than that of untrained ani-
54
KLAUS HOFMANN AND REINER HAMM TABLE XVII NONPROTEIN SH AND GSH CONTENT IN ORGANS OF TEST ANIMALS
SH (mg) per ~
Animal -
Pig Rabbit Mouse Rat Rat Rat Rat Rabbit Rat Rat Rat Rat Dogd Dog' Rat Rat Dogd Dog' Dogd Dog' Dogd Dogp Dogd Dog"
Organ
SH reagent
Liver Liver Liver Liver Liver Liver Liver Liverb Kidney Kidney Spleen Brain Brain Brain Heart Heart Heart Heart Stomach Stomach Diaphragm Diaphragm Lung Lung
PCMB PCMB PCMB PCMB AgNO 3 DTNB DTNB DTNB &NO, PCMB PCMB DTNB lodine Iodine DTNB Iodine Iodine Iodine Iodine Iodine Iodine Iodine Iodine
Original data" 21.4 pg/IOO mg ( I ) 25.2 pg/lOO mg ( I ) 32.4 pg/IOO mg ( I ) 26.4 pg/lOO mg (1) 26.4 mg SH/100 gm tissue (2) 0.10 mmole SH/100 gm tissue (3) 6.00 pmoles SH/gm tissue (4) 8.1 pmolesc/gm tissue ( 5 ) 1 I .3 mg SH/100 grn tissue (2) 18.2 pgll00 mg ( I ) 9.6 pg/l00 mg (1) 2.6 pmoles SH/gm tissue (6) 45.6 mg % GSH (7) 56.6 mg % GSH (7) 0.22 mmol SH/lOO gm tissue (3) 7.2 mg SH/100 gm tissue (2) 54.0 mg % GSH (7) 69.3 mg % GSH (7) 49.5 mg % GSH (7) 53.9 mg % GSH (7) 56.8 mg % GSH (7) 65.1 mg % GSH (7) 4.57 mg % GSH (7) 55.2 mg % GSH (7)
100 gm tissue
21.4 25.2 32.4 26.4 26.4 3.3 19.8 26.8 11.3 18.2 9.6 8.6 4.9 6. I 7.3 7.2 5.8 7.5 5.3 5.8 6. I 7.0 4.9 5.9
Concerning the dimensions of the original datas see Note b to Table XV. Numbers in parentheses correspond to the following investigators: ( I ) Calcutt and Doxey (1962); (2) Bhattacharya (1959); (3) Sedlak and Lindsay (1968); (4) Boyne and Ellman (1972);( 5 ) Ellman (1959);(6) Gabay et al. (1968);(7) Wachholder and Uhlenbrook (1935). * Extracted with 5% TCA. The values for water and alcohol extracts were much lower. The original dimension (mmoles) is obviously not correct. Untrained. ' Trained.
mals. Since the nonprotein SH content in liver, kidney, and heart is markedly higher than the average nonprotein SH content in muscles, the relation of nonprotein SH to total SH is higher in these organs than in muscles. Bhattacharya (1959) showed that rat liver contains 48% and that both kidney and heart contain 23% nonprotein SH (related to the total SH content). By summarizing the SH contents given in Tables IX-XVII, we can conclude that in most cases the total SH as well as the nonprotein SH contents of the same
SULFHYDRYL AND DISULFIDE GROUPS IN MEATS
55
organs of different species vary less than the SH contents of different organs of the same species.
D. FACTORS INFLUENCING THE SH CONTENT OF RAW MEAT In this section, some natural factors that can possibly influence the SH content of meat will be discussed. The influences of processing, freezing, and other treatments are discussed separately. 1. Postmortem Aging
Chajuss and Spencer (l962b) reported a rapid decrease in the SH group content of chicken muscle during the development of rigor mortis. Gawronski et al. ( 1 967) also observed a decrease in the SH content and in the ratio of SH to SS in excised chicken breast muscle during the first hours postmortem. After Pavlovskij and Grigoreva (1966) and Golovkin and Korzhemanova (l973), the number of SH groups in muscle decreases during rigor and then increases again during relaxation. Motoc and Banu (1968) reported that the SH content of muscles would decrease due to a denaturation of the myosin. On the other hand, Kolodziejczyk (1965) found an increase of free SH groups in pork and beef during aging. These apparent contradictions may be due to differences in the availability of the SH groups based on the use of different types of reagents in the methods of measurement. (More work has to be done in order to elucidate the role of SH groups in the presence of rigor mortis and aging.) In order to find out whether the preparation of tissue was responsible for this variation in results, Miller and Spencer (1975) investigated aged samples of chicken muscle prepared in the different ways described by the other investigators. Analysis of variance showed that the SH concentration did not change significantly with aging time within any of the homogenate preparation methods. Caldwell and Lineweaver (1969) have found that no change in the SH content of chicken breast muscle occurs during postmortem aging. Furthermore, determination of the SH content with AgNO, has indicated that the postmortem storage at +2"C of beef and pork for up to 1 1 days does not change the SH content of muscle tissue (Hofmann and Schael, 1966; Hofmann et al., 1969). Further studies with different skeletal muscles of pork and beef from numerous animals have confirmed this result (Hofmann, 1971d). Finally, Hay et al. (1972, 1973) found that the aging of chicken muscle fibrils was not accompanied by a decrease in the total SH content; this indicates that there has been no oxidation of SH groups throughout the aging process. It should be mentioned that significant changes in the SH content were never found until at least 5 days after preparation in numerous cases when the SH content of myofibrils of pork and beef muscles was controlled during cold storage (Hofmann and Hamm, unpublished observations).
56
K L A U S H O F M A N N A N D REINER H A M M
2. Other Factors a. Meat Quality. Fischer and Hamm (1975) investigated the influence of the quality of pork on the number of SH groups which react with NEM (easily available SH groups) and with AgNO, (total SH groups content). The so-called pH, value, 45 minutes postmortem, and the water-holding capacity of the meat were measured as criteria of meat quality. The number of easily available SH groups decreased significantly with increasing PSE (pale, soft, exudative) conditions, i.e., with an increasing rate of glycolysis postmortem, but no correlation between total SH or SS groups content of the tissue and PSE properties was observed. In accordance with these results, Usunov and Zolova (1976) reported that rapidly reacting SH groups were drastically reduced in PSE muscle. It seems possible that the decrease in these easily available SH groups is attributable to the masking of the SH groups of myofibrillar proteins by sarcoplasmatic proteins, precipitated at low pH values on the myofibrils (Fischer and Hamm, 1975). Bendall and Wismer-Pedersen ( I 962) give a similar explanation for the finding that in PSE muscle a smaller amount of charged groups were titratable than in normal muscle.
b. Variation in rhr GSH Content. The content of SH glutathion (GSH) in muscles and organs is not constant but is, in vivo, depending on numerous metabolic factors which have been comprehensively discussed in the review of Santavy (1965). Therefore, it may be sufficient to summarize only a few of the most important influences on the GSH content and, consequently, the total SH content of tissues. GSH activates several enzyme systems which participate in the metabolism of carbohydrates. It is also important for aerobic glycolysis and is a cofactor of some dehydrogenases. The ATPase activity of myosin in the muscle is increased by GSH. Furthermore, GSH may play an important role in maintaining the activity or in the reactivation of several SH enzymes. Thus it is not surprising that the GSH level in muscles and organs is increased by training. During stress the GSH content in muscles decreases (more with untrained animals than with trained animals). The GSH level in muscle and liver is influenced by the vitamins C and BP,which are involved in the carbohydrate metabolism. c. fnfluencr ofAge. With the increasing age of animals, an accumulation of disulfide groups in tissues has been observed (Oeriu, 1962; Harisch and Schole, 1974). Lastovskaya (1969) reported that the SH content of rat liver decreased slightly during the first 12 months of age and significantly during 1-2 years of age. However, Harisch and Schole (1974) found that the GSH content of rat liver increased continuously with age, causing a rise in SH and SS groups as well.
SULFHYDRYL AND DISULFIDE GROUPS I N MEATS
57
The reactivity and the SH content of myogen A of rats were reported to increase with age, especially in young animals. This protein showed the highest enzyme activity in older rats (Goldshtein and Khilko. 1969). A significant age associated decline in the SH content of serum albumin has been demonstrated in both men and rats (Leto er a l . , 1970). I t seems that the effect of age on the SH and SS content depends on the kind of organs and proteins investigated as well. Some results concerning beef are mentioned in Section IV,A. An increased synthesis of GSH has been shown to be associated with growth hormones (Shacter and Law, 1956). SH groups are involved in cell division and play an important role in carcinogenesis (for review, see Harington, 1967). d. Deboned Meat. The production of volatilc sulfur compounds during storage in mechanically deboned poultry meat has been investigated by O’Palka (1973). In this study he found that cysteine destruction was closely correlated with methyl mercaptane production. This was an unexpected result, because Cascy et al. (1965) and Grill et u f . (1967) have shown methionine to be a precursor of methylmercaptane. The formation of volatile S-containing compounds (I6 were estimated) during storage of deboned meat is probably due to bacterial activities, because many types of microorganism are present in poultry products as a result of contamination (Kraft, 1971).
e . Unsaturated Fatty Acids. Robinson (1966) reported that SH groups are able to react with unsaturated fatty acids, the SH group probably being added to the double bond. Furthermore, SH groups can be oxidized by fatty peroxides, which may be formed during the storage of meat. f. T r u c ~ of ~ sHeavy Metals. Finally the possibility of traces of heavy metals (which are absorbed by meat animals from the environment) decreasing the SH content of meat will be examined. This question may be considered for lead, one of the widest spread trace metals, which can react with SH groups: 2 R - SH
+ Pb’+
-2H’
Pb (RS),
The maximum Pb levels in beef, veal. and pork were reported (Holm, 1976) to be 0.53 I , 0.372. and 0.158 ppm, respectively. The highest values for beef and calf liver were 0.40 and 0.26 ppm Pb, respectively. As a comparison with the SH content of meat shows, these Pb levels are very low. For instance. 0.5 ppni Pb is equal to 0.05 mg Pb in 100 gm meat, which contains about 65 mg SH. Consequently, such Pb2+ levels cannot bind more than 0.024% of the SH groups in muscle (calculated in moles). Therefore, traces of lead which can occur in meats are neglegible in respect to the determination of SH groups. The same may be valid for traces of other heavy metals. An exception is the presence of Cu2+ ions,
58
KLAUS HOFMANN A N D REINER HAMM
which are known to catalyze the autoxidation of SH groups, and which, therefore, can have a strong influence on the results of SH determination.
V. INFLUENCE OF PROCESSING ON THE SH AND SS GROUPS OF MEAT A . INFLUENCE OF HEATING Heating of meat is accompanied by changes in appearance, smell, taste, texture, and nutritive value. The cysteine and cystine moieties of proteins are particularly involved in these alterations. Therefore, the changes in and possible reactions of SH and SS groups in meat proteins during heating must be considered. The thermal formation of volatile sulfur compounds, which are important flavor components, will also be discussed.
I.
Effect of Heat Denaturation on the Availability of SH Groups
Biochemists define denaturation as a change in the specific steric conformation of a protein, i.e., a change in the secondary and tertiary structure without a chemical modification of the amino acids (Fasold and Turba, 1959). Thus, denaturation is a physical process, not a chemical one. One has to be careful in using the term “denaturation” instead of “heating,” because stronger heating results not only in denaturation but also in chemical modifications of the proteins such as reactions of the functional groups and the cleavage of covalent linkages. According to the definition of denaturation mentioned above, the oxidation of SH to SS groups and the reduction of SS to SH groups should not be called “denaturation” because these reactions are chemical modifications; this is also true for the inactivation of SH enzymes caused by auto-oxidation. Therefore, the oxidation of SH-groups by heating will be discussed in the next chapter. Dry heating of myofibrils for 30 minutes at temperatures from 30” to 70°C under both nitrogen and air resulted in an irreversible increase in the SH groups reacting with NEM at pH 6.0, as shown by Fig. 4 (Hamm and Hofmann, 1965). Using the same method for measuring the SH-groups, Schrott (1974) also observed a substantial increase in the available SH groups in actomyosin (from 1.41 to 2.41 mg SH/gm protein) when it was heated to 65°C. The SH increase was explained by the fact that NEM reacts only with a part of the SH groups in the native meat protein and that heating causes an unfolding of the protein molecule during heat denaturation (Haurowitz, 1950), making more SH groups available for NEM (Hamm and Hofmann, 1965). The release of reactive protein SH groups, which were hidden within the native folded protein
SULFHYDRYL A N D DISULFIDE GROUPS I N MEATS
59
FIG. 4. Effect of heating (30 minutes) myofibrils on the amount of SH groups reacting with NEM at pH 6.0 (Hamm and Hofmann, 1965).
structure by denaturation. was first discussed in the case of ovalbumine (Anson, 1945). An increase in the heating temperature to 120°C did not cause a further increase in the available SH groups, even though only about 70% of the SH groups are available to NEM after heating to 70°C. The total number of SH groups is obtained by reaction with AgNO, (see Fig. 4 and Table XVIII). As Fig. 4 shows, oxygen has no remarkable effect on the number of SH groups available for NEM in raw or mildly heated meat. The role of SH groups in the temperature-induced denaturation of muscle proteins was investigated by Jacobsen and Henderson ( 1 973). With actomyosin they found, after heating the protein to 60°C. a marked irreversible increase in the sulfhydryl groups which were titratable with PCMB. These authors did not give any explanation for this increase; but there is no doubt that it may also be due to an unfolding of the protein molecules induced by heating. TABLE XVIII SH LEVELS IN MYOFIBRILS AFTER 30 MINUTES HEATING"."
SH reagent
30°C
50°C
70°C
AgNOa DTNB NEM
8.5-9.0
8.4-9.0
8.5-9.0
6.04.5 3.5
6.5 5.0
8.5 7.0
"
In moles SH/105 gm protein
* After Tinbergen (1970).
60
KLAUS HOFMANN A N D REINER H A M M
Tinbergen (1970) studied the influence of heating myofibrils (from 30" to 70°C) on the number of SH groups reacting with different SH reagents. His results are in good agreement with those obtained by Hamm and Hofmann (1965); they demonstrate that the number of SH groups which react easily with NEM and DTNB increases with increasing temperature, whereas the total number of SH groups (reacting with AgNO,) remains unchanged (see Table XVIII). The heating of whole meat in a superhigh frequency electromagnetic field to an internal temperature of 65°C also led to an increase in the number of SH groups (Malyutin, 1969). Frying meat decreased the total SH content but increased the number of easily reacting SH groups titratable with CH3HgN03. using nitroprusside as an indicator (Dworschak, 1969). Increases in the available SH groups were also found after the mild heating of pork (Randall and Bratzler, 1970), turkey breast muscle (Bowers, 1972), and frog sartorius muscle (Kovaleva, 1967). Contrary to the results reported here, Dub6 (1969) found a decrease in the number of available SH groups using Ellman's reagent after cooking myofibrillar extracts of beef at temperatures between 60' and 90°C. He suggested that this disagreement might be due to the fact that in these experiments the proteins were already denatured by urea, and thus heating did not allow any further conformational change that would have made more SH groups of the molecules available to the reagent. However, not only was there no increase, but rather a decrease in the SH groups (about 6% at 60°C and 16% at 70"), which was explained by the assumption that the SH groups could be oxidized into SS groups. In the case of heating the meat to 70"C, this explanation does not agree with the results of Hofmann (1964) (see Fig. 5), Samejima et al. (1969), Tinbergen (1 970) and Bognar (1 97 I a), who showed that there is no decrease in the total SH content in meat proteins after heating to that temperature. Samejima ef at. (1969) found that neither disulfide reducing nor SH-blocking reagents prevented the heat coagulation of myosin. This supports the conclusion of Hamm and Hofmann (1965) that the heat coagulation of myofibrillar proteins is not due to an oxidation of SH to SS groups but to an intermolecular association of other sidechains of the protein molecules. However, we have to concede that the protein SH groups in different meats and myofibrils may not always react in the same way. It is well known that traces of certain heavy metals are able to catalyze the autoxidation of SH groups. Hence, differing contents of such trace elements in meat could result in an oxidation of SH groups to a different extent (for further discussion of the previous results see next section). Malyutin ( 1 969) found a decrease in the SH groups in meat after heating to 85"C, suggesting an aggregation of proteins. SH groups have indeed been shown to be involved in this heat aggregation of proteins (Connell, 1960a; Jaenicke, 1965a,b). The reaction
SULFHYDRYL AND DISULFIDE GROUPS IN MEATS
61
mechanism is suggested to be a SH-SS exchange according to the following equation (Lumper and Zahn, 1965):
HS-Prot/i
f
' S
HS-Prot
__
SH HS-Prot-SS-Prot /
However, as this reaction demonstrates, the SH-SS exchange would not lead to a change in the number of SH and SS groups. The decrease of SH groups established after heating does not necessarily indicate protein aggregation caused by SH-SS exchange. But it may be that the SH groups formed are less reactive than those originally present. No investigations have been attempted as yet to test this hypothesis. It should be pointed out that denaturation alone is not able to increase the number of S S groups. The formation of SS groups is, in any case, the result of an oxidation of SH groups. Neither can the reverse reaction, namely, the formation of SH from SS, be caused by denaturation itself alone, as has been postulated previously (Grau, 1968). It may be concluded that heat denaturation of meat proteins leads to an increase of available SH groups, depending on the temperature applied. There obviously exists a wide temperature range rather than one special temperature in which SH groups, previously masked in the native state, are exposed. This finding is in accordance with denaturation therrnoprofiles of beef muscle tissue which show that molecular changes occur between 49" and 94°C (Karmas and De Marco, 1970). The total amount of SH groups in meat with AgNO, is not effected by heating up to 70°C (Hofmann, 1964; Hamm and Hofmann, 1965; Kovaleva, 1967;
Lob 5 0 5 0 7 0 9 0
1X)OC
FIG. S. Effect of heating myofibrils (30 minutes) on the amount of SH groups reacting with AgNO, at pH 7.4 (Hofmann, 1964).
62
KLAUS HOFMANN AND REINER HAMM
Tinbergen, 1970; Bowers, 1972), whereas at higher temperatures the SH content falls (Fig. 5). The curve in Fig. 5 is quite similar to the temperature-SH curve for actomyosin presented by Hamm and Hofmann (1965; in Fig. 2 of the publication the word “myofibrils” should be corrected to read “actomyosin”). The decrease of SH at higher temperatures is due to oxidation and will, therefore, be discussed in the next section.
2 . Influence of Heating on the Total SH and SS Content Dube (1969) observed that the SH content of myofibrillar extracts of beef decreased on cooking at temperatures up to 90°C. The SH values of the heated and then reduced samples obtained after treatment with NaBH, were lower than the SH values of the raw samples. It is not clear whether the reduction of the disulfide groups was incomplete or if other oxidation products which cannot be reduced by NaBH, were formed during heating. Krylova and Kusnezowa (1 964) heated pork and beef for 30 minutes at 75” to 80°C. Using an amperometric titration with AgNO,, they found a decrease in the SH groups ranging from 27 to 29%. Figure 5 also shows that heating to temperatures higher than 70°C decreases the number of SH groups in muscle proteins. In the presence of air, the SH content dropped more than when exposed to pure nitrogen. At 120”C, the decrease under air was 40%, under nitrogen 25%;at the same time, the SS content rose by 36% and 20% respectively. These changes evidenced that the SH groups were mainly oxidized into SS groups (Hofmann, 1964; Hamm and Hofmann, 1965). Since the oxidation also occurred with the exclusion of atmospheric oxygen, it was suggested that oxidation in the presence of nitrogen is due to residual molecular oxygen included in or bound to the sample, from which it can hardly be removed. In experiments of Schweigertet al. (1949), the total cystine content of pork and lamb has proved stable during normal cooking, but not during heating at 120°C. As is evident from percentages mentioned above, there is a difference between the decrease in SH and the increase in SS (about 5%). which means a loss of the total cystine (CySH CySSCy) content. After heating the samples for 5 hours, the deficit reached 26%and 13% under air and nitrogen, respectively (Hamm and Hofmann, 1965). Bognar (1971a) found a loss of as much as 33% total cystine after the heating of beef for 1 hour at 120°C. He was able to show that this loss was due to the formation of cysteine acid. That the decrease stated by Bognar was more pronounced than the decrease in the case of myofibrils may be attributed to the different experimental conditions: The beef was heated in water in which the oxidation was probably more effective than in the dry-heated myofibrils. The formation of lanthionine, which is also discussed as a possible product of
+
SULFHYDRYL AND DlSULFlDE GROUPS IN MEATS
63
cystine destruction, seems to be unlikely under the conditions used because it occurs only in a basic medium (Hupf and Springer, 1971). Marchenko (1968) found that sterilization of beef and lamb at 120°C lowered the SH content by 62% and 50%, respectively, whereas the SS content increased for 72% and 62%, respectively. However, this hardly explains why in this case the increase in SS was higher than the decrease in SH. Bem rt al. ( I 970) and SusjC rt al. ( 1 974) extensively investigated the influence of the canning of meat which contained various amounts of nitrite, nitrate, and ascorbic acid. It was to be expected that nitrite affects the SH content because of the possible formation of nitrosothiols (Mirna and Hofmann, 1969). Canned meats with the highest addition of nitrite (0.35%) exhibited both the lowest SH content and highest SS content. Nitrate and ascorbic acid did not influence the SH content. The SH content of canned meats which were sterilized at 1 10”-115”C was much lower than that of meat pasteurized at 76°C. The total cystine content of the high-temperature canned meat products was also reduced; consequently, the nutritive value of the meat protein was lowered (see also Section V, A, 3). During the storage of both the sterilized and the pasteurized meats, the SH content decreased continuously, demonstrating that the reaction between the SH groups and nitrite advanced. Finally, a paper published by Khan and van den Berg (1965) in which the use of incorrect terms caused some misunderstanding will be briefly discussed. The authors talk about “sulfhydrylgroup content of muscle proteins,” but it is evident from the procedure described in a previous paper (Khan et a l . , 1963) that in all cases the SH group assay was carried out in an extract of muscle obtained by using 2.25% metaphosphoric acid. Such an extract. free of protein, contains only about 3% (see Section IV) of the total meat SH, mainly as GSH. Therefore, the statement of these authors that the cooking of chicken muscle decreased the SH content of “muscle protein” by about 50% is not correct. 3 . Influence clf the Thermal Destruction of Cysteine Plus Cystine (Total Cysrine) on the Nutririw Value of Meat Protein As was shown in the previous section. heating induces losses of total cystine when meat is heated to high temperatures. This has already been demonstrated in previous work by means of amino acid analysis (Beuk et ul., 1948; Donoso et ul., 1962). However. hydrolysis of the proteins causes losses of total cystine as well. It was later shown (Bognar, 1971a, b) that heating beef for I hour at 120°C caused an average loss of 28.3% methionine and 15.9% total cystine. The decrease in the other amino acids ranged from 5.0 to 8.9% (the amino acids of the meat broth were included). The relatively high losses of the sulfur amino acid content clearly demonstrates the sensitivity of these amino acids to wet heating.
64
KLAUS HOFMANN A N D REINER HAMM
Bjarnason and Carpenter (1970) studied the mechanism of heat damage in proteins using bovine plasma albumin as a model. The protein, which contained 14% moisture, lost 50% cystine when heated for 27 hours at I 15°C. Miller er al. (1965) found a similar loss (60%) for vacuum-dried cod after heating for 27 hours at 1 16°C. Methionine and cysteine plus cystine are involved in many essential functions of every living cell. This should be noted with respect to the fact that the deficiency of the sulfur-containing amino acids in human diets is a critical problem of worldwide importance (Allaway and Thompson, 1966). The nutritive value of meat protein is limited by its content of methionine and cysteine plus cystine (Donoso et a l . , 1962; Hofmann, 1966b). Therefore, any damage of total cystine diminishes irrevocably the nutritive value of meat protein (see Section I). In the heat treatment of meat during cooking and processing, the thermal sensitivity of the sulfur-containing amino acids must therefore be taken into consideration. Time and temperature of heating should not exceed certain limits (Hofmann 1966b, 1 9 7 2 ~ )There . is a formula which states that the time necessary for killing microorganisms can be shortened to a tenth when the temperature is increased by 10°C (Beuk et al., 1948). On the other hand, the rate of chemical reactions (including the damage of amino acids) is only increased about 3-fold by the same increase in temperature (van't Hoff's rule). Thus, heating the meat at a higher temperature for a shorter time (high-short heating) is preferable to heating it longer at a lower temperature. Moreover, in order to reduce the time necessary for sterilization, the cans should not be too large and should be as flat as possible. In the presence of fluid constituents (as in cans containing goulash, beef and pork in their own juices, sausages in brine, etc.), the time of heating can be shortened by rotating the cans (rotation sterilization; Rievel and Reuter, 1955; Heidtmann, 1966; Wirth, 1967; Christiansen, 1968). The quality of canned products can be improved by estimating and using the so-called F-values (Takacs ef al., 1969; Heidtmann, 1970). A loss of total cystine may be compensated by the addition of cysteine (N. N., 1970). It may also be of interest to note that it is possible to introduce SH groups into proteins and, therefore, to increase their SH content (Schoberl, 1948). Perhaps in this way the nutritive value of proteins may be improved. 4. Release of Hydrogen Sulfide During Heating
During the heating of meat numerous volatile compounds which contribute to the formation of meat flavor are split off (Hornstein et a l . , 1960; Brennan and Bernhard, 1964). Some of those volatiles are sulfur-containing compounds; the simplest and most investigated one is hydrogen sulfide. In low concentrations,
SULFHYDRYL A N D DlSULFlDE GROUPS IN MEATS
65
H,S is usually associated with high mean food acceptance scores (Olson rt d., 1959). For the determination of H,S which is released during heating, Hamm and Hofmann (1965; for details, see Hofmann, 1964, 1967) used a modified method of Marbach and Doty ( I 956). The H,S passes into a trap containing NaOH and is determined by photometric measurement (670 nm) of the blue color which develops after reaction with p-aminodimethylaniline and FeCI, in HCI. Optimum conditions for the formation of the dye and its measurement are realized by a moderate excess of FeCl, and by an HC1-concentration of I-3%. Under these conditions, the solution of the dye formed is stable (Hofmann and Hamm, 1967a). For estimation of H,S formed during the production of canned meat, test tubes, called Drager-Riihrchen, have proved useful (Bloeck Y t ul.. 1970). The odor threshold of this compound in water is as low as 10 ppb (Pippen and Mecchi. 1969). In low concentration, H,S has a favorable effect on the meat aroma and probably contributes to the flavor of all heated proteinaceous foods such as chicken, beef, fish, eggs, and milk. At higher concentrations. the objectionable odor of H,S is detrimental to the flavor (Johnson and Vickery, 1964). Fraczak and Pajdowski ( 1 955) first studied the development of H,S during the thermal processing of meat. Their results suggested that 80°C might be the temperature at which the formation of H2S in remarkable amounts begins. The aniount of H2S produced increases drastically with increasing temperature (Fraczak and Pajdowski, 1955; Parr and Levett, 1969). Hamni and Hofmann (1965) showed that the release of H,S induced by heating myofibrils increases exponentically with rising temperature (Fig. 6). The amount ofH,S formed by heating the myofibrils at 120°C for 30 minutes ranged from 16.8 to 18.7 p g H,S/gm protein. This is almost the same amount as was formed during the heating of total muscle tissue (18.4 to 19.3 pg). Therefore, at least 90% of H2S released during heating originates from myofibrillar proteins. This result agrees with the findings of Mecchi ef a / . (1964). With adipose tissue, the reverse was found; i.e., approximately 2% times as much H,S was evolved from the water soluble as from the water insoluble fractions (Pepper and Pearson, 1969). It was demonstrated that, after blocking the SH groups by Ag+ or NEM, myofibrils did not release detectable amounts of H,S during heating (Hamni and Hofmann. 1965).This evidenced that hydrogen sulfide originates from the protein SH groups rather than from disulfide groups or methionine. The same conclusion was reached by Parr and Levett (1969) in the case of chicken meat, whereas Fraczak and Pajdowski (1955) and Mecchi c’t a / . (1964) postulated that H2S might be split off from cysteine and cystine as well. An additional source of the development of H,S induced by the heating of meat is thiamin (Dwivedi and Arnold. 1971). The reported decrease of the SH content due to the formation H2S is relatively small
66
KLAUS HOFMANN AND REINER HAMM
0
70
90
110 120
O C
FIG. 6 Effect of heating (30 minutes) on the formation of H,S from inyofibrils (Hamm and Hofmann. 1965).
(2 to 3%). Therefore, it is not surprising that maximum H,S production at 120°C was reached only after more than 15 hours (Lendvai et al., 1973). The oxidation of SH groups during the heating of meat does not prevent the development of H,S, because enough residual SH groups are still present. Parr and Levett (1969) reported a disappearance of free H,S from freshly cooked meat left standing, which was mainly due to oxidation by atmospheric oxygen. After Sowa (1968), the amount of H,S does not increase significantly when the temperature is extended above 120°C. During the heating of meat with microwaves (27.4 mHz) the H,S formation was reduced (Sowa, 1968). Bloeck et al. (1970) studied the production of H2S during sterilization of fish (sardines). They found the same curve given in Fig. 6. The transformation of this curve into a half-logarithmic coordinate system resulted in a straight line, enabling the prediction of the amount of H,S formed, whereupon the calculation was brought about analogously to determine the F-value. It was found that using the “high-short heating” procedure limited the amount of H2S formed during sterilization (Bloeck er al., 1970). In general, the release of hydrogen sulfide during the sterilization of meat is a serious problem. Possible disadvantages are corrosion of the cans, discoloration of the cans (marbling) and of the content, and an unfavorable or even offensive smell when the can is opened. The marbling (see Andrae, 1969; Dahlke, 1969; Gruenwedel and Patnik, 1971) is due to the formation of iron sulfide or tin sulfide. In canned meats, which are only pasteurized, the activity of surviving microorganism may contribute to the H2S formation (Baumgartner and Baum, 1960). Cheftel (1958) established that metal ions such as Fe2+, Fe3+, A13+, Sn2+,and Sn4+,which may be exposed by corrosion effects, are able to accellerate catalytically the release of H,S. Furthermore, the pH value has a strong effect on the formation of H,S caused not only by heating but also by
SULFHYDRYL AND DISULFIDE GROUPS I N MEATS
67
bacterial action. High pH values support the release of H,S during the heating of meat (Johnson and Vickery, 1964; Krylova and Marchenko, 1969). Figure 7 shows the amount of H2S released from heated meats as influenced by the pH value. Irrespective of the type of meat used (mutton, beef, or pork), or of whether or not the pH was adjusted by artificial or natural means, all H2S values were located on the same curve, suggesting that the same mechanism was acting in each case. Muscles from animals in poor condition sometimes contain only small amounts of glycogen at the time of death; consequently, only a small amount of lactic acid arises postmortem, and, therefore, the ultimate pH of the meat is high. Such meat produces more H,S during heating than does the meat from normal animals. A decrease in carcass grade is also accompanied by an increase of both pH and H,S production (Johnson and Vickery, 1964). The addition of polyphosphate increased the concentration of H,S in canned broiler meat (Rao et al., 1975), a result which could not be attributed to the increase in pH caused by the addition of phosphate. Furthermore, it was found that the heating of meat with a high fat content produced significantly more H,S than the heating of lean meat (Kunsman and Riley, 1975).
PH
FIG. 7 . The effect of variation of pH on H,S content of volatilea produced by heating meat (Johnson and Vickery, 1964). (0. mutton; 0 , beef; W . pork.)
In the H,S assay, the hydrogen sulfide formed by heating of meat usually is transferred into the solution of the reagent. Marchenko and Kosenjasheva (1974) developed a procedure for the separate determination of the levels of hydrogen sulfide and mercaptans which are volatilized during meat cooking and those which remain in cooked meat. They found that, after heating meat to 80°C. the majority of the volatile sulfur compounds remained in the cooked meat. The hydrogen sulfide content in cooked pork was discovered to be 1.2-1.3
68
KLAUS HOFMANN AND REINER HAMM
times as much as that in cooked beef. This finding may be due to the fact that the pH value of the pork proved to be higher than that of the beef. The reaction mechanism of the H,S-formation is not yet fully understood. Schoberl (1941) attributed the development of H,S brought about by the influence of hot water on wool keratin to a hydrolytic splitting of disulfide bonds, which proceeds in two steps (Schoberl and Eck, 1936): R-CHZ-SS-CHZ-R + HZO -+ R-CHZ-SH + HOS-CHZ-R HOS-CHZ-R -,HZS + CHO-R
The same mechanism was discussed by Bjarnason and Carpenter (1970) in regard to the release of H2S during the heating of bovine plasma albumin. This reaction, however, needs an alkaline medium which is normally not present in meat. For the formation of hydrogen sulfide from SH groups, p-elimination (a) and hydrolysis (b) are possible reaction mechanisms. -NH,
-
-NH,
,,CH-CH2-SH
-co
-Cd
C=CH,
+
H,S
(a)
-NH,
,,CH-CH,-SH
-co
+HO -m, CH-W-OH 2 , -co
+
H,S
Fraczak and Pajdowski (1955) suggested a trimolecular reaction as an explanation for hydrogen sulfide formation; but trimolecular reactions are very rare; making this an unlikely possibility. In addition to hydrogen sulfide, small amounts of volatile mercaptans, thioethers, and other sulfur-containing conipounds are formed during heating and contribute to meat flavor. The best preventive way for reducing undesirable amounts of H2S and mercaptans which develop during sterilization is to select suitable meat which has been handled and stored under hygeinic conditions. Additionally thio-acceptors (e.g., zinc oxide) may be used as components of the inner lacquer of tins (Nehring, 1968; Bloeck ef al., 1970). Also the addition of weak acids such as lactic acid (Johnson and Vickery, 1964), ascorbic acid, or citric acid reduces the development of H,S (Hofmann, 1974a). The thermal formation of H,S and the oxidation of SH groups to SS groups in meat mentioned above necessarily result in a shift of the redox-potential, which is remarkably influenced by the SH/SS system (Hofmann, 1974b). The measurement of the redox-potential (Leistner and Wirth, 1965; Hofmann, 1974b) can be used to evaluate the quality of meat products. It is
SULFHYDRYL A N D DISULFIDE GROUPS IN MEATS
69
believed that each type of product has a characteristic redox potential range (Wirth and Leistner, 1970). 5 . Formation of Further S-Containing Flavor Components
Most of the typical flavor in meats is developed during heating. Raw meat. such as beef, pork, lamb or chicken, has little flavor (Crocker, 1948). The tlavnr of heated meat consists of a great number of different chemical components which are not present in raw meat but are developed from “precursors” by the influence of heat. None of the components identified in meat aroma has been described as uniquely “meaty” (Wasserman, 1972). The chemical pathways involved in the formation of meat flavor compounds during heating include Maillard browning reactions, fatty acid oxidation, and the formation of some low molecular volatile compounds, such as ammonia and hydrogen sulfide. But they also include inter- and intramolecular cyclization, as well as numerous mechanisms which are made possible by the reactivity of substances such as rnercaptans, hydrogen sulfide, ammonia. and other intermediates, especially at high temperatures (Wilson er a f . , 1973). Some of the first investigators who demonstrated the importance of several sulfur-containing volatiles for the flavor of meat were Yueh and Strong (1960) and Minor et al. (1965). The latter were able to show that the removal of the sulfur-containing components resulted in an almost total loss of meat flavor. The ability of fat to dissolve S-containing substances during cooking was demonstrated by Pippen et a / . (1969), who found that the fat of cooked poultry contains more sulfur than does the fat of raw poultry. Furthermore, it was shown that a reaction between H,S and acetaldehyde was involved, and that such reactions between H2S and carbonyls in fat could occur quite generally (Pippen and Mecchi, 1969). During the last few years, many authors have observed the formation of sulfur-containing compounds during the heating of meat which may be relevant to meat flavor (Kato et al., 1973; Mulders, 1973; Mussinan and Katz, 1973; Led1 and Severin, 1973; Scanlan et a / . , 1973; Schune, 1974; Garbusov et a / . , 1976; for reviews, see Herz and Chang, 1970; Schwimmer and Friedman, 1972; Wasserman, 1972). Boelens et a / . (1974) identified the reaction products between fatty aldehyds. H2S, thiols, and ammonia, which are normal constituents of meat, using a combination of gas chromatography and mass spectrometry. In addition. the organoleptic aspects of the reaction mixtures were discussed. Among the substances formed there were several heterocyclic S-compounds such as alkylated trithianes (I), oxadithianes (I]), dioxathianes (111), trithiolanes (IV), dithiazines (V). thiadiazines (VI), and some aliphatic thio compounds, particularly mercapto-thio-ethers (VII), dimercapto-thioethers (VIII), thiodisulfides (IX). thioaldehydes (X), and thioalkenes (XI and XII) (in the formulas the alkyl residues are omitted):
70
KLAUS HOFMANN A N D REINER HAMM
I
I
I
0
-CH-S I
-S-
S-
(IX)
-CH-CH,-CHO
I S-
4
-CH-CH=CH-SI
-CH=CH-CH
S-
(X)
(XI)
7\
S-
(XI0
Wilson et al. ( 1 973) identified forty-six sulfur-containing chemical compounds present in the volatiles of pressure-cooked beef. The main components were alkyl sulfides and alkyl disulfides, thiophenes, and sulfur-containing heterocycles (trithianes, trithiolanes, thiadiazines, and thiazoles). In addition to cysteine, cystine, and methionine, thiamine can also be a precursor of the volatile S-containing aroma components of meat: The formation of H,S (Dwivedi and Arnold, 1971), several thiazoles, and thiophenes (Arnold et al., 1969; Dwivedi and Arnold, 1972, 1973; Dwivedi et al., 1972, 1973) have been reported to be a result of the thermal degradation of thiamine. In spite of the fact that the content of carbohydrates in meat is very low, these substances may still be involved in the formation of the sulfur-containing aroma components of meat. Thus, Morton et al. (1960) found that the reactions of cysteine and other amino acids with sugar produced a flavor with a basic meat character. The reaction of cysteine with derivatives of hydroxy-dihydrofuranone (XIII) resulted in the formation of roasted meat flavor (van den Ouweland and Peer, 1975). Dihydrofuranones may be formed by the degradation of ribose-5-phosphate and have been found in a natural beef broth (Tonsbeek et al., 1968). The initial stage in the reaction of cysteine with the dihydrofuranones involves a substitution of the ring oxygen by sulfur giving derivatives of hydroxy-dihydrothiophenone (XIV). In this reaction, cysteine acts as an H,S donor. The odor components finally were identified as being derivatives of thiophene (XV), rnercapthothiophene (XVI), mercaptofurane (XVII), and mercaptodihydrofuranone (XVIII). Mulders (1973) heated mixtures of cysteine, cystine, and ribose for 24 hours
SULFHYDRYL AND DISULFIDE GROUPS IN MEATS
71
under reflux at 125°C and also identified volatile sulfur compounds such as thiophenes, thiazoles, trithione, alkylthiols, hydrogen sulfide, and carbon disulfide. Arroyo and Lillard (1970) heated mixtures of glucose and each of the sulfur-containing amino acids (methionine, cysteine, and cystine) for 2 hours at 98" C. However, none of these mixtures emitted an odor associated with meat flavor. On the other hand, a meat aroma for ready-to-eat meals could be produced by the reaction of monosaccharides with cysteine or cystine (N. N., 197 la). It may be concluded that the formation of meat flavor is not only due to Maillard-type reactions, the formation of ketones, aldehydes, amines, and heterocyclic N-compounds; it is also due to reactions in which sulfur is included in several ways. A number of patents exist for simulated meat aroma based on heating mixtures of a sulfur-containing compound, amino acids, and carbonyl compounds (Wasserman, 1972). A few patents have specified heating thiamine with various amino acids (Giacino, 1970; Yamamoto et u l . , 1970). It should be mentioned that volatile aroma components are involved not only in meat smell but also in meat taste, because the volatile compounds are, of course, soluble to some extent in meat juices and, especially, in the melted fats. This may be the reason for the fact that meat which contains a certain degree of fat gives a more aromatic taste after frying than does lean meat. It would be interesting to learn whether foreign metals (e.g., Pb, Hg, Zn, Cd) or other possible residues in meat, which are able to react with sulfur compounds, can influence the development of sulfur-containing aroma components during the heating of meat and thus influence meat flavor. As far as is known. this problem has not yet been investigated. 6 . The Texture of Meat as Influenced by Disuuide Groups Formed During Heating The ways in which meat texture is generally influenced by heating have already been discussed by Laakkonen (1973) in his review. One of the factors
72
KLAUS HOFMANN A N D REINER H A M M
that may influence the tenderness* of meat is the possible formation of disulfide bonds between protein chains induced by heating. Because this aspect is not considered in the review mentioned, it should be discussed in this section. Dub6 (1969) described the change in the texture of meat due to heat as follows: “It has been observed that upon heating meat develops a kind of rigidity that, in some ways, may compare with the resistance due to rigor. This hardening of the muscle tissue during heating is a reaction in which many substructural elements may be involved such as the proteins of the myofibrils with their chemically reactive groups. These elements may during the process contribute to the formation of different kinds of cross-bindings that might tighten the structure and increase the resistance to shear.” There is very little known about the chemical nature of the binding forces between actin and myosin during contraction. Szent-Gyorgyi (1966) did not support the assumption that the sulfhydryldisulfide bonds could be involved in the reaction between the two contractile proteins. [But SH groups of myosin are necessary for the myosin-actin interaction (see Section 111, A , 2, a).] Since the linkage can be broken by pyrophosphate and magnesium, Szent-Gyorgi suggested that there is probably an electrostatic interaction. It also seems that the analogy between muscle contraction and the hardening of muscle during heating is a superficial one. Therefore, the possibility of the tenderness of meat being influenced by the heat-induced formation of disulfide linkages should be considered independently of the process of muscular contraction. There are findings that demonstrate that the formation of disulfide groups does influence the texture of meat. Dodge and Stadelman (1959) observed that carcasses aged in air were less tender than those aged in water because of the greater opportunity for oxidation in the air. Treatment of muscle with potassium iodate, which is able to oxidize SH to SS, resulted in an increase of the shear values. The same result was found by Hird and Yates (1961) using several oxidizing agents. Chajuss and Spencer (1962a,b) exposed chicken muscles to a solution of sodium sulfite which is known to split SS bonds. After cooking these pretreated muscles, the shear values were found to be less than those of muscles stored in water only. However, treatment with hydrogen sulfite, surprisingly, did not significantly influence the shear values compared to treatment with sulfite (Chajuss and Spencer, 1962a). This finding signals caution in our interpretation of results obtained using sulfite. Because the authors did not use any buffer for preparing the solution, the solution of sodium sulfite reacted alkaline as a result of hydrolysis. Thus, this observation might be attributed to a swelling effect of the high pH of the solution. There is almost certainly a hardening effect of the oxidizing agents however. Such an effect has been suggested by Connell (1957). He emphasized the importance of cross-links between the protein peptide chains in *In this connection it may be of interest to note that the toughness of meat may be decreased by the injection of cysteine into the blood vessels of an animal 15 to 30 minutes before slaughtering. This treatment causes an activation of the proteolytic enzymes (N. N.. 1971b).
SULFHYDRYL AND DISULFIDE GROUPS I N MEATS
73
relation to texture and demonstrated that the SH content of dried fish is less than that of fresh products, assuming the fornmaticin of disulfide cross-links. In addition. Dube (1969) found that the decreasc in SH and the increase in SS in beef muscle proteins induced by heating were accompanied by an increase in the shear values of the muscle. Model experiments concerning the texture of SS-crosslinked gelatin gels were carried out by Okamoto et ctl. (1973). The relation between sensory properties, physical characteristics. and the forces maintaining gel structure were studied for gelatin thiolated t o 6.6 moles SS/I05gm protein. It was found that hardness was affected mainly by temperature, brittleness by disulfide bond content. The hardness was generally attributed t o hydrogen bonding, and the brittleness was attributed largely to disulfide bonding. Transferred to meat, this result would mean that an increase in the number of disulfide groups does not render the meat tougher but more crisp; in other words, the niasticatability of the meat would be influenced favorably rather than unfavorably by the formation of disulfide groups during heating. Indeed, it was observed that heating meat paste for a few minutes led to a product of gum-like consistency, whereas heating for a longer period of time so that the number of disulfide groups was drastically increased, resulted in the paste’s becoming increasingly crisper and more brittle (Hofmann and Hamm, unpublished observations). With whole meat, of course. the connective tissue also plays an important role for the tenderness or toughness. The significance of thiol and disulfide groups in the determination of the rheological properties of dough has been recognized by several workers (Frater et al.. 1960; Blocksma, 1972; Ewart, 1972; Jones et d.,1974). It may be that the thiol-disulfide system is also relevant to the rheological behavior of meat emulsions in the production of sausages. but no corresponding experiments have been carried out as yet.
B. FREEZING AND FROZEN STORAGE Husaini and Alm (1955) investigated the influence of the frozen storage (-4” to -20°C for 130 days) of egg white and cod fillets on the number of “masked” SH groups. Amperometric titration with AgN03 was used for the egg white and ferricyanide and o-iodosobenzoic acid for the fish muscle. The difference between the total SH content of proteins determined after the addition of a denaturing agent (dodecyl sulfate) and the amount of SH groups available in the proteins’ native state represented the number of masked SH groups. In the case of egg white, the values of masked groups showed a decrease during the first 28 days; they then began to rise and after 48 days became more or less constant. In cod muscle, the masked SH groups reached a minimum value after 50 days of frozen storage. Again, the masked SH groups then began to rise. After 90 days, the values were not constant but still varied. However. the number of masked SH
74
KLAUS H O F M A N N A N D REINER HAMM
groups finally decreased in all cases, or, in other words, the number of available SH groups increased during frozen storage. This result seems to show that the frozen storage of protein leads to protein denaturation, resulting in a release of reactable SH groups. Grau (1968) also reported that freezing meat would cause an increase in the SH groups, but no literature reference was given. According to Dzinleski et al. (1969). the amount of SH groups of proteins in both frozen beef muscle and drip increased during frozen storage (3 months at -18°C). The SH groups were determined with Ellman’s reagent. The authors postulated that frozen storage caused physical changes in the muscle tissue which resulted in a release of the reactive SH groups upon defrosting. The increases ranged from 41% to 103%. The maximum values found were 16-17 moles SH/105 gm protein. These values are certainly too high, because the total SH content of all investigated meats was found to be 10-12 moles SH/105gm protein, the maximum value being 14 moles SH (see Section IV, A). Nevertheless, it might be possible that the denaturation caused by freezing or frozen storage increases the number of SH groups which react with Ellman’s reagent, because this reagent does not seem to react with all SH groups of the native meat proteins (see Section 11, B, I ) . Connell (1960b), however, was not able to detect changes in either the easily reactable or the total SH groups in cod flesh during frozen storage for up to 3 years at - 14”, -22”, and -29°C. In an investigation by Hofmann et al. (1974) with lean beef and pork (musculus long. dorsi), one part of the samples was frozen in vacuum-sealed plastic bags, while the remainder was packaged in presence of air; both groups of samples were stored at -19°C for up to 24 months. While no significant changes in total SH content were found, the nonprotein SH content decreased (this will be discussed later in connection with results of Khan et al., 1963). Rahelid et al. (1974) also found no change in the total SH content of beef which was stored at - 18°C for I year. The SH content of pork, however, decreased considerably after 6 months. In these experiments, the stored meat samples were not protected against the influence of atmospheric oxygen by sealing them in plastic bags as was done in the experiments of Khan rt al. (1963) and Hofmann et al. (1974). Hence, the decrease in the SH content of pork might have been induced by the formation of fatty acid peroxides (less probable for beef). The oxidation of cysteine to cystine by autoxidizing lipids is well known (Wedemeyer and Dollar, 1964). A decrease of free SH groups in the protein of fish muscle (Sacramento blackfish) by freezing and to a greater extent during frozen storage was found by Mao and Sterling (1970). Khan et al. (1963) stated that a decrease in the “sulfhydryl group content of muscles” takes place during frozen storage of raw chicken muscle. This term is entirely misleading: In this investigation, “sulfhydryl group content of musc1es”refers to the SH content of a metaphosphoric acid extract of the muscle (containing only the nonprotein SH groups) rather than the total SH content of the
SULFHYDRYL A N D DISULFIDE GROUPS IN MEATS
75
muscle. Unfortunately this fact was ignored during the discussion of the results both in this and in later publications (Khan, 1965, 1966; Khan and van den Berg, 1965; Khan and Nakamura, 1971). At the end of 2 years the remaining SH content was found to be about 40% of the initial (nonprotein SH) value at - 10°C storage temperature and about 70% at - 18°C storage temperature. It was suggested “that the destruction of sulfhydryl groups can be used as an index of protein damage during frozen storage’’ (Khan e t a / . , 1963). However, in light of the fact that the SH groups of the protein were not actually estimated, this conclusion does not seem to be justified. During frozen storage, proteolytic enzymes are still active, causing an increase in the products of protein breakdown (Partmann, 1972). These products can be estimated by the Fohn-Ciocalteu reagent (sodium p-naphthoquinone 4-sulfonate) (Khan et d . , 1963; Khan and van den Berg, 1964). The ratio of SH groups and the Fohn-Ciocalteu reagent-positive nitrogen compounds of both breast and leg muscle tissue decreased progressively with time of frozen storage. Khan (1965), therefore, proposed the use of this ratio as a “quality index” for frozen stored poultry. This SH/N ratio decreased after 2 years of frozen storage at - 18”C, from about 2.8 to 1.9 for leg muscle and from about 1.8 to 0.9 for breast muscle.* The SH content was expressed as pg glutathionigm muscle, the N content as pg tyrosin-N/gm muscle. Davidkova and Davidek (1971) applied the index on pork, observing a decrease in the ratio from about 2.3 to 0.6* after 60 weeks of frozen storage at - 18°C. When the meat was stored at -S”C, the value of 0.6 was reached after only 2 months. In most cases, the meat was no more acceptable when the index fell below 0.8. Hofmann et a/. (1974) found a decrease of nonprotein SH and an increase of nonprotein N in both beef and pork after 2 years frozen storage at -19°C. The mean values ranged from 2.2 to 1.6 mg SH/lOO gm meat and from 3.4 to 5.4 gm N x 6.0/1OO gm meat. Consequently the SH/N ratio decreased by about 5070,corresponding to the values given by Khan et al. (1963). However, it seems to be questionable whether this change in the SH/N ratio is reliable for evaluating a loss in meat quality under practical conditions, because the ratio can vary in fresh meat in a wide range (1.2 to 2.2) (after Davidkova and Davidek, 1971). Furthermore, the initial SH content of frozen stored meat will normally not be known (in our opinion it should be) so that it would most often be impractical to judge meat quality by means of the SH/N ratio. Khan and van den Berg (1965) also stated that the frozen storage of cooked meat results in a gradual decrease in the SH content. Because the tenderness of the meat decreased simultaneously, it was concluded “that loss in this sulfhydryl-group content during storage may serve as an index of tenderness.” It should be pointed out that this statement was also based on the estimation of the nonprotein SH content. Since tenderness of meat is related to the properties of the *These values were taken from Fig. I in Davidkovi and Davidek (1971).
76
KLAUS H O F M A N N A N D REINER H A M M
structural proteins, this conclusion seems to be somewhat questionable. In our opinion, the results obtained with cooked meat indicate that the decrease in SH groups must be caused by an autoxidation (no participation of enzymes). However, Khan et al. (1968) attributed the decrease in the SH groups mainly to the so-called cryodenaturation, first postulated by Levitt (1962, 1966). We feel it is necessary to discuss this hypothesis in detail because it has often been adapted and discussed rather uncritically (Gaff, 1966; Khan et al., 1968; Partmann. 1968; DubC, 1969; Buttkus, 1974). Levitt (1966) points out “that SS groups are formed. and this has been explained by the SH SS hypothesis, according to which intermolecular SS bonds form between protein molecules during injurious freezing, leading to denaturation of proteins.” However, from the chemical point of view, the formation of SS from SH cannot occur without oxidation. This fact has not even been mentioned in the discussion. We read further: “That this postulated chemical change can be induced or at least accelerated by freezing has been shown in the case of the model system thiogel. When this SH-protein is frozen, intermolecular SS formation is greatly accelerated as compared with unfrozen gel. . . .” It should be pointed out that no experimental evidence was cited for an increase in SS groups induced by freezing. For that reason the following statement can be considered only as conjecture: “Thiogel . . . provides a system in which intermolecular SS bonds formation can be readily detected and measured quantitatively by the simple method of determining its melting point” (Levitt, 1965). Khan et al. (1968) also investigated the influence of frozen storage on SH groups content of chicken myofibrillar proteins using Ellman’s reagent. In fresh samples, the total SH content was found to be 0.59 pmole/mg N (equal to 9.44 moles SH/105 gm protein) and 0.15 pmole after storage at -5°C for 10 weeks. This unusually high storage temperature may have supported the autoxidation of SH groups. The decrease of protein solubility and the loss of tenderness in meat which is generally observed after freezing or frozen storage may be explained by an aggregation of protein molecules, whereby the native state may sometimes be maintained. This aggregation may be brought about by the formation of hydrophobic bonds, hydrogen bonds, ion bindings, and disulfide linkages (Jaenicke, 1964, 1965a,b). The last mentioned may be formed by a sulfhydryl-disulfide exchange reaction (Fig. 8). This principle mechanism of aggregation may be valid not only for mildly heated proteins, for which it was studied, but aIso for protein systems stored at lower temperatures. In this case, of course, the reaction velocity will be lower; however, long-time storage may cause the SH-SS-exchange reaction to some extent. The freezing of meat and other tissues, if it is done correctly, does not necessarily cause the denaturation of the proteins.
SULFHYDRYL A N D DISULFIDE GROUPS IN MEATS
77
FIG. 8. Sulfhydryl-disulfide exchange as a possible mechanism for the aggregation of nativc protein molecules.
C.
FREEZE-DRYING
Connell (1957) investigated the influence of dehydration on the texture and the
SH content of fish muscle. In fresh cod, he found 0.38 gm SH/100 gm protein using o-iodoso-benzoic acid, and 0.14 gm SH/100 gm protein using N ethyl-nialeimide (NEM). The corresponding values of the freeze-dried material were 0.30 gm SH and 0.13 gni SH, respectively. Both air-drying and vacuum contact-plate drying of cod yielded nearly the same results. Connell concluded: “The results do suggest in a general way that the sulfphydryl content of the dried products is less than that of fresh fish, a finding which is substantiated by the evidence from solubility measurements that disulphide links are formed on drying.” However, the latter statement has not been proved directly because experiments to determine SS groups had not been carried out. Connell further states that “the number of experiments is not sufficient to give a conclusive answer.” Potthast ( 1 972) studied the influence of freeze drying and the effect of storage of freeze-dried pork on SH content by means of an indirect amperometric titration method using NEM and AgN03. The results showed that the easily available SH groups. which were detected with NEM. clearly decreased, whereas the total SH content did not change significantly. This finding indicates that during the freeze-drying process the protein structure becomes tighter. There seems to be none of the unfolding of protein molecules (which results in an increase of the easily detectable SH groups) that Hamm and Hofmann (1965) found in the case of the heat denaturation of meat protein. The storage of freeze-dried mcat at 4 0 4 5 % relative humidity did not result in any change of available SH groups, although a decrease in the enzyme activity (Hamm, 1964; Yasui and Hashimoto, 1966) of some muscle proteins does take place during storage. Potthast has therefore suggested that this denaturation effect is not caused by unfolding the protein chains but by the blocking or chemical changes of the active centers.
D. CURING The chemical reactions involved in the transformation of niyoglobin (Mb) to nitrosomyoglobin (NOMb) after addition of nitrate or nitrite to meat, giving the meat-stable pink color of cured meat, are extremely complicated and have not yet been elucidated in complete detail. The different steps of the formation of NOMb
78
KLAUS HOFMANN AND REINER HAMM
may be formulated in a very simplified way: reduction
reduction
(bacterial)
(chemical)
NO,-NOC-NO
t Mb
-NOMb
There is no doubt that the SH groups of meat participate in this reaction chain. Theoretically the SH groups can agitate in three ways: (a) reduction of NO,- to NO, (b) protection of Mb against oxidation to metmyoglobin (MetMb), and (c) formation of Mb by reduction of MetMb (Fe3+ +. Fez+). The role of SH groups in changes in meat color and in the curing process has been studied by numerous workers (Watts and Lehmann, 1952; Watts etal., 1955; Kelley and Watts, 1957; Hornsey, 1959; Tarladgis, 1962a,b; Stewart et al., 1965; Szakaly, 1966; Reith and Szakaly, 1967; Fox and Ackerman, 1968; Mirna and Hofmann, 1969; Olsman and Krol, 1972; Kortz, 1973: Kubberad et af.,1974). The formation of cured meat color can be accelerated by ascorbic acid (or ascorbate) which is probably due to its reducing effect and/or to the protection of the SH groups against auto-oxidation. The first investigations on the relation of free SH groups to cured meat color were carried out by Watts et a / . (1955). They heated a model mixture containing 50% egg white (delivering SH groups), 0.4% hemoglobin (so-called meat pigment), and 0.1 % sodium nitrite in phosphate buffer pH 5.8. For comparison they added ascorbic acid to a second sample of the mixture and iodoacetamide (for blocking the SH groups) to a third sample before heating. The development of the color was most intense in the mixture containing ascorbic acid and was least intense in the mixture with iodoacetamide. The authors concluded: “The reduction of metmyoglobin and nitrite necebsary for the formation of the cured meat pigment may be brought about by SH groups of muscle protein rather than by reducing enzyme systems. In the absence of ascorbic acid, formation of the pink cured meat pigment parallels the appearance of free sulfhydryl groups.” However, because of the far-reaching consequences of this statement, it must be noted that the model system used here is very different from actual conditions in meat. Rather than myoglobin, the pigment of meat color, hemoglobin, whose oxygen affinity is very different from that of myoglobin, was used. On the other hand, the reactivity of the SH groups in egg albumin is very different from the reactivity of the SH groups in meat protein: In myofibrils the SH groups are already reactive in the native state (e.g., with sodium nitroprusside), whereas there are no SH groups detectable in native egg albumin (Hofmann, 1964, 1966; Hofmann and Hamm, 1966, 1975). Watts et al. (1955) stated further, “Whereas nitrite protects the cured meat pigment from oxidation in the presence of protein SH groups it accelerates oxidation in their absence. This interesting statement does not seem to be valid for meat because meat proteins always contain free SH groups in the native as well as in the denatured state. Kelley and Watts (1957) found that in addition to ascorbic acid, cysteine and glutathione were capable of catalyzing the production of nitric oxide hemoglobin and of protecting the sur”
SULFHYDRYL AND DISULFIDE GROUPS I N MEATS
79
face of cured meat from fading by light. The color of cured meat is also influencecl by SH groups which are not bound to proteins. Hornsey (1959) found a positive correlation between the color intensity of cured pork and its content of cysteine plus cystine and the ratio of cysteinelcystine as well. The following results demonstrate that SH groups can react directly with nitric acid, which may be an intermediate product during the formation of NOMb. It is well known that nitric acid can react with SH compounds of forming nitrosothiols (Beckurts and Frerichs, 1906). Ashworth and Keller (1967) established that while secondary and tertiary thiols would react in this way, thiols, such as cysteine and glutathione, would not. Nevertheless, Saville (1958) found that at pH 2- 3 a quantitative reaction between nitrite and cysteine takes place with the formation of the corresponding nitroso compound (S-nitroso-cysteine). The amount of nitrosothiol formed decreased with increasing pH value. In order to find out whether a formation of nitrosothiols is possible in meat at its natural pH (5-6). Mirna and Hofmann (1969) carried out experiments with meat and SH solutions: The addition of nitrite to minced beef and pork in amounts nearly equimolar to the SH content caused a decrease in both components of about 20-30% during storage for 1-2 weeks at +2"C and pH 5.6-5.8; in meat to which no nitrite was added the SH content proved to be stable during 12 days of storage at 2-3°C (Hofmann, 1971d). Thus, the decrease of SH in the presence of nitrite might be due to a reaction of the SH groups with nitrite or nitric acid. This explanation is supported by the observation of Olsman and Krol (I 972) that a smaller loss of nitrite occurred when the SH groups in meat had been previously b1ock:d by an SH reagent. A study of the reaction of nitrite with glutathione and with b.ysteine in watery solutions at different pH values led to the following resulis (Mirna and Hofmann, 1969): ( 1 ) At pH 7.4, no reaction takes place. At pH 2.3, the reaction is nearly complete after 15 minutes at 23°C. At pH 5.0 and IOO"C, only 16-18% of the SH groups of glutathione had reacted after 15 minutes. The pH dependence of the reaction shows that it is the free nitric acid rather than the nitric ion which reacts with the SH groups: R-SH
+ HO-NO
+
R-S-NO
+ H20
(2) The nitrosothiols are unstable. The half-life periods of S-nitroso cysteine and S-nitroso glutathione have been estimated to be 2 and 3 hours, respectively, at pH 5.5. (3) The nitrosothiol of cysteine was isolated in the form of red crystals. In water this compound is slowly decomposed under the splitting off of a gas (NO), while unsoluble cystine simultaneously precipitates. The decomposition is probably caused by the following reaction: 2 CyS-NO
+
CySSCy
+ 2 NO
80
KLAUS HOFMANN AND REINER HAMM
Because the NO group can be split off easily from the nitrosothiols formed, it was suggested that the role of the SH groups in the formation of the cured meat color may perhaps consist of a transfer of the NO group from the nitrosothiol primarily formed to the myoglobin (Mirna and Hofmann, 1969): 2 Mb
+ 2 Protein-S-NO + 2 NOMb + Protein-S-S-Protein
Kubberpd et al. (1974) studied the reaction of nitrite with the SH groups of myosin. The reaction was found to depend on the pH and the temperature much the same as the reaction with the low molecular SH compounds. The rate of the reaction was low under conditions similar to those in meat. However, curing takes days and therefore the reaction may occur to some extent. The formation of S-nitrosothiols has been also discussed by Gilbert ef ul. (I 975). Kortz (1973) presented a hypothetical mechanism for the role of the different SH fractions of meat in the development of cured meat color. According to this hypothesis, nonprotein SH compounds act as intermediates between myoglobin and the SH groups of the water-soluble protein fraction.
E.
RIPENING OF DRY SAUSAGES
Sandholm ef al. (1972) estimated the number of SH groups in dry sausages during the process of ripening using amperometric titration with AgNO,. The SH groups increased up to the twentieth day and declined by the twenty-ninth day to almost the initial value. The increase was assumed to be attributable to a bacterial reduction of the SS groups of the proteins in the sausages. However. this cannot be the case: The SS content in meat is low in relation to the SH content (see Section VI, A and comments to Table XIII) so that the SH content, after the proposed reduction of SS groups, could not rise to a value many times that of the initial SH content. The increase reported by Sandholm ef al. was higher than tenfold (for example, the values for the initial and maximum SH contents were 46 and 540 pmoles SH/gm wet weight, respectively). Furthermore, it must be noted that all these values were far too high in comparison with similar values given by other investigators (meat contains about 65 mg SH/IOO gm tissue, whereas the values reported here corresponded to 152 and 1786 mg SH/100 gm tissue respectively). Therefore, either the procedure of determination followed or the kind of calculation used may have been incorrect.
F.
SMOKING
There are a few results available concerning the question of how the constituents of smoke influence the SH groups of meat. Smoke contains about 300 different components (review: Mohler and Baumann, 1968), some of them very reactive. Among these are numerous phenols, aldehydes, and ketones (Tilgner,
SULFHYDRYL AND DISULFIDE GROUPS I N MEATS
81
1967) which are able to react with SH groups (see Cecil and McPhee, 1959; Friedman, 1973; Stauffer, 1974). The carcinogenic. benzo[a]pyren. can also react with SH groups (Harington, 1967; Reske. 1971). Because these reactive compounds occur in smoke, it is not surprising that smoking decreases the total SH content of meat (Randall, 1969; Randall and Bratzler. 1970). The number of SH groups in heated but unsmoked pork was (converted) 12.0 moles SH/105 gm protein; in the heated-smoked samples, the value decreased to 7.0 moles SH (smokehouse conditions of 60°C. 45% R.H.. 2.25 hours). This decrease was attributed to interactions of the smoke with various reactive groups of the meat proteins (Randall and Bratzler, 1970). Krylova and Kusnezowa ( 1 964) observed a drastic decrease in the SH groups found in smoke-cured meat. After smoking, only about 40% of the initial SH groups remained; the phenolic fraction was more active and the basic fraction was less active.
G . IRRADIATION Barron (1946) postulated that ionizing radiation (X rays. alpha, beta, and gamma rays) would rapidly oxidize the thiol groups of cells. This oxidation was explained by the formation of oxidizing radicals when water is radiated in the presence of oxygen. This hypothesis has been supported by the finding that several thiol enzymes are inhibited by radiation, and that this inhibition was prevented or reversed on the addition of glutathione (Barron. 1951). Both the oxidation of thiols to disulfides and the reduction of disulfides to thiols have been observed by several authors during irradiation with ultraviolet light. Degradation of thiols and disulfides can also occur (for reviews, see Cecil and McPhee, 1959; Friedman, 1973). In aqueous solution, cysteine is oxidized to cystine under the influence of gamma radiation (Whitcher et a / . , 1953; AI-Thannon, 1968; Owen and Brown, 1969). Furthermore, hydrogen, hydrogen sulfide, hydroperoxide. and alanine was formed, depending on the pH, the concentration of oxygen, and the SH content in the cysteine solution radiated (Trumbore, 1967). Radiation of solutions containing cysteine and cystine produced also SO,. alkanes, and dimethyldisulfide (Merritt. 1966). When meat is irradiated with doses of gamma rays at the level required for the destruction of the most resistant microorganisms, one can see the development of irradiation odors and off-flavor (Wick, 1965) which may lower food acceptance and values. It is generally recognized that relatively high doses of this irradiation are accompanied by the denaturation of proteins, splitting of protein molecules, or the association of these molecular fractions (reported by Fujimaki ct al., 1961). By trapping the volatiles from irradiated meat in a solution of lead, zinc, and mercuric salts, Batzer and Doty ( I 955) obtained precipitates containing sulfur
82
K L A U S H O F M A N N A N D REINER H A M M
compounds thought to be the source of some of the undesirable odors in irradiated meat. Fractionation of some of the off-odors of beef revealed that they arise from water soluble compounds, mainly from glutathione (Batzer and Doty, 1955). Methods for estimating the amount of hydrogen sulfide and methyl mercaptane after gamma radiation of meat (based on the color reaction with N,N-dimethylp-phenylene-diamine) have been described by Marbach and Doty ( 1956), Batzer and Doty (1955), and Sliwinski and Doty (1958). Small doses below 0.8 mrad, which are used for radiopasteurization, did not influence the sensory qualities of meat, but the higher doses of I .5-5 mrad necessary for radiosterilization had a considerable detrimental effect. The specific undesirable flavor produced was due to the formation of sulfide, mercaptans, carbonyl compounds, and others (Palmin, 1970). The better method of preservation is, therefore, a combination of low dose radiation and heat processing. Several SH-containing compounds have a radioprotective effect on animal organisms, but the mechanism of this action is not yet completely understood (Modig, 1969). Graevsky er al. ( I 969) hypothesize that the radioprotective influence exerted by SH compounds is determined only by their SH groups. Experiments demonstrating distinct radiosensibilitation of mammalian cells and bacteria after blocking the SH groups by NEM or PCMB are in agreement with this conception. The treatment of meat with gamma rays (1.5-3.0 mrad) caused a moderate decrease in SH-glutathione, which was intensified drastically by atmospheric oxygen (Palmin and Breger, 1963). The freezing of minced pork and beef before irradiation with 5 mrad at various temperatures significantly protected SHglutathione, particularly if very low temperatures were used (Coleby et al., 1961). It seems that the freezing of water rather than the low temperature itself is responsible for the protection effect observed. In the investigations of Griinewald (1969), the cysteine content of freeze-dried beef and pork and of fresh beef did not decrease during radiation with less than 1 mrad; radiation with 5 mrad invariably caused a reduction in cysteine and to some extent an increase of the cystine content. On the other hand, the sum of cysteine plus cystine decreased. This shows that radiation with high doses lead to the oxidation of cysteine and to the decomposition of total cysteine plus cystine. However, in the case of fresh beef, cryogenic temperatures prevented these losses of cysteine by radiation. This finding coincides with the results of sensoric tests obtained by other investigators (Coleby et al., I96 1 ; Harland et al., 1967). In other cases the radiation of meat did not cause drastic changes in the SH content. Kardashev et al. (1970) treated fresh river sheatfish and Baltic cod with gamma rays (0.3 to 2 mrad and 0.5 to 10 mrad, respectively). This irradiation produced no change in the contents of SH groups in either the actomyosin
SULFHYDRYL AND DISULFIDE GROUPS IN MEATS
83
fraction or in the watersoluble fraction of muscle proteins. Fujimaki et al. (1961) treated meat (rabbit muscle) with gamma rays (about 4 mrad) before and after rigor mortis. There was no significant difference between the content of the sulfhydryl groups of actin from both irradiated and control meat samples. According to the investigations of Hamm et al. (1975), radiation of vacuum-packed lean pork with doses of 0.2, 1 and 5 mrad at 4°C did not significantly change the total SH content of the whole tissue. In this case, the unchanged SH content may be explained by the exclusion of atmospheric oxygen so that an oxidation of SH groups induced by radiation cannot take place. Metlitskii et al. (1968) stated that the radiation of pork, beef, and turkey with 3 mrad did not cause a significant decomposition of cysteine. Hedin et al. (1961) came to the conclusion that X irradiation decreased the SH content of a gelatinelike glucoprotein fraction of beef which produced “wet dog” odor when irradiated. The SH assay was carried out with mercuric chloride and Ellman’s reagent. It was clearly shown that mercuric chloride did not react with the SH groups of the irradiated protein, whereas Ellman’s reagent did. Using the latter reagent, the SH content decreased only by about 7% (from 1.37 to I .27 pmoleslgm). Furthermore, the amino acid analyses of the protein hydrolysate gave nearly the same cysteic acid values for both the irradiated and the untreated samples. There is no doubt that, generally, irradiation of meat causes formation of volatile hydrogen sulfide and mercaptans at the expense of the SH content. However, these amounts are very low in comparison with the total SH content of meat (less than 1%). This can be explained by the finding mentioned previously that the volatile compounds are formed solely from the water soluble components of meat, which are present in minor amounts. Kraybill et al. (1960) reported that gamma irradiation (to 9.3 mrad) resulted in an increase in the SH and SS contents of raw skim milk. Ultraviolet irradiation effected a similar increase in SS content, but no changes in SS bonds. To explain these findings, several mechanisms were discussed based on a degradation of methionine. However, it seems to us much more likely that the increase of available SH groups is due to the denaturation of the proteins, known to be accompanied by an increase of the availability of masked SH groups (see Section V, A, 1). The results of McArdle and Desrosier (1953, who found a liberation of SH groups in irradiated solutions of casein and egg albumin, may be explained in the same way. Neuwirt et al. (1964) found that, after treating rat liver nuclei with a dose of 750 roentgen, there was a significant decrease in protein disulfide groups but no decrease or increase in protein SH groups. In addition, they point out that, after ray treatment, no decrease in the activity of any SH-enzyme has ever been demonstrated.
84
K L A U S H O F M A N N A N D REINER H A M M
VI.
INFLUENCE OF THE SH GROUPS ON THE SHELF LIFE OF MEAT AND MEAT PRODUCTS
In the search for new compounds for the preservation of meat and meat products, it has been observed that several SH compounds, for example, cysteine and glutathione, are able to potentiate the microbial inhibition effect of known food preservatives such as sorbic acid, benzoic acid, fatty acids, and others. Mixtures with these SH compounds have proved to be effective for the preservation of meat, fish, and other foods (Troller, 1966). It is well known that SH compounds have an antioxidative effect which retards the rancidity of fats (Maloney et al., 1966). This effect may be due to the decrease in the redox potential by SH compounds. A direct inhibition of microorganisms by SH compounds would seem to be unlikely because the growth of microorganisms is usually inhibited by SHblocking reagents (Zsolnai, 1970). Cooked meat becomes rancid more quickly than unheated meat because the SH content in cooked meat is reduced as a consequence of the heating effect (Hofmann, 1964; Bognar, 197 1a). This preservation effect of the SH groups in meat may be of limited importance; nevertheless, it seems to be worthwhile to prevent SH oxidation during meat processing as far as possible.
VII. TOXICOLOGICAL ASPECTS SH groups are able to bind toxic heavy metals [Pb2+, (see V, D,2,f), Hg2+, and others] and may therefore play an important role in detoxification reactions (Clarkson, 1971). On the other hand, experiments with rats have shown that an increase in the protein content of diets resulted in a significant increase in the retention of lead (Milev et af., 1970). In this case the lead was probably also bound to the protein SH groups of the feed. Therefore, it is difficult to predict generally whether under practical conditions the SH groups in foods have a positive or negative effect on the contamination of living organism. Furthermore, SH groups interact with numerous carcinogens such as polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons (PAH), hormones, hepacarcinogenic substances (e.g., certain aminoazo dyes and amines, carbon tetrachloride, aflatoxins, thioacetamide, and ethionine), alkylating agents, nitroso compounds, 4-nitrochinoline N-oxide, lactones, quinones, metals, metalic derivatives, and arsenic (for review, see Harington, 1967). Therefore, SH groups in organisms and foods are important for anticarcinogenesis (for review, see Reske, 1971). Nemoto el al. (1975) reported direct evidence that conjugation with SH-glutathion is a significant
SULFHYDRYL A N D DISULFIDE GROUPS I N MEATS
85
100
-
5 80
E
x 60 U,
L
ul a
C
-
w
'0 A0 C
g
20
0 0
1
2
3 4 Tirnc(hrsl
5
24
FIG. 9. Reaction of GSH with patulin in equirnolar amounts at different pH values (20°C). (A: pH 7.4; B : pH 6.0; C: pH 5.0. (After Hofmann ct d..1971 .)
mechanism for the detoxification of the epoxides of PAH, which are mutagenic and may be the carcinogenic forms of the PAH. Hofmann et al. (1 97 1 ) observed that patulin (a potent mycotoxin produced under certain conditions by molds found on meat and meat products) reacts with SH-glutathion. In chick embryo and rabbit or mice skin test. the reaction product formed was proved to be nontoxic. The kinetics of the reaction of GSH and Patulin at different pH values are shown in Fig. 9. It was concluded that, at the pH of meat and meat products, most of the patulin produced by molds might be inactivated by the SH groups occurring in meat. It is also suggested that, in bread, the mycotoxin is inactivated by SHcontaining substances after a prolonged incubation period (Reiss, 1973). Another possibility of detoxification, which has not yet been discussed, is the reaction of SH groups with nitrite (Mirna and Hofmann, 1969). This may be a competitive reaction to the formation of carcinogenic nitrosamines from nitrite and amines. Finally it should be mentioned that there exists a protective action of sulfur compounds such as cysteine and glutathione against acetaldehyde toxicity arising from heavy consumption of alcohol and heavy cigarette smoking (Sprince et d., 1975). As these examples demonstrate, SH groups may be of importance in the detoxification mechanisms of the organism. As we have seen in Section V , the amino acids, cysteine, cystine, and methionine, the exclusive sources for SH compounds in the metabolism, are not very stable under meat processing. For this reason, careful preservation may be of importance not only for the nutritive value but also for the protection of the organism against several classes of toxic substances.
86
KLAUS HOFMANN AND REINER HAMM
VIII.
SUMMARY
Methods for the determination of SH and SS groups in meats and their advantages and disadvantages are discussed. The choice of determination method depends on the type of investigation in question. Numerous problems which may arise in the determination of SH groups in proteins are discussed in detail. Protein SH groups may react quickly, slowly or not at all (“masked” SH groups) depending on the type of reagent, on the protein’s state, and on the conditions of reaction. Meat contains both protein SH (soluble and unsoluble) and nonprotein SH groups. Results found in the literature do not always show clearly whether it is the total SH or the SH content only in a soluble fraction that was determined. This differentiation is important because most SH groups are bound to the water insoluble myofibrillar proteins. One of the most convenient and accurate techniques for the determination of SH groups in meat is a “double-indirect’’ amperometric titration method: this enables the application of different SH reagents (AgNO,, NEM, PCMB, etc.). The determination of SS groups is usually based on the determination of SH groups before and after the reduction of SS (preferably with sodium borhydride) to SH. The procedures are briefly described. The sum of SH and SS represents the “total cystine” (cysteine plus cystine) content. Tables are presented listing the amounts of SH and SS groups in meats (muscles and inner organs), in myofibrils, and in isolated muscle proteins. Although the results given in literature vary considerably (depending on the method of assay or on the type of material investigated), the following general conclusions may be drawn: the average SH contents of pork and beef muscle are nearly equal (62 and 66 mg SH/100gm tissue, or 10.2 and 10.5 moles SH/105 gm protein, respectively); the average SH contents of skeletal muscles from different species are very similar to each other; the nonprotein SH content in muscles varies in a wide range; muscles usually contain 3 to 4% nonprotein SH as compared to the total SH content; the average SH content of myofibrils prepared from the muscles of different animals is 9.1 moles SH/105 gni protein (this value corresponding very closely to the sum of SH groups of the single myofibrillar proteins). The SS content of muscles varies from 0.5 to 2.0 moles SS/I05 gm protein. This high variation may be due to a different degree of oxidation of the SH groups. The SS content may also depend on an animal’s age. The average total SH content of liver (47 mg SH/IOO gm tissue) and of other organs (such as kidney, heart, and brain) is lower than the average SH content of muscles; however, the nonprotein SH content (mainly glutathione) is much higher in liver and in other organs than in muscles. In general, the total SH as well as the nonprotein SH contents of the same organs of different species are less variable than the SH contents of different organs of the same species. Factors which influence the available SH content of raw meat may be training
SULFHYDRYL AND DISULFIDE GROUPS IN MEATS
87
and stress (influencing the content of glutathione), the age of animals, heavy metals, postmortem aging, and others. The role of the SH groups in muscle proteins (including the proteins of the sarcoplasmatic reticulum, sarcolemma, mitochondria, and sarcoplasmic matrix) in their physiological functions (ATPase activity, contraction, rigor mortis, and interaction of myofibrillar proteins) and in the tenderness of meat are discussed. Heating meat to 70°C increases the availability of SH groups for several SH reagents (DTNB, NEM, PCMB) as a result of denaturation; however, the total SH content does not change. At temperatures higher than 70°C the SH content decreases, chiefly because of an oxidation to SS groups. High temperatures as used for sterilization may also cause a loss of the cysteine plus cystine content, resulting in a decrease in the nutritive value of meat proteins. During heating, hydrogen sulfide and numerous other sulfur-containing volatile compounds contributing to meat flavor, are split off from the sulfur-containing amino acids of meat. The texture of meat is influenced by the formation of SS groups during heating. It seems more probable that SS groups influence brittleness rather than hardness, and that, therefore, an increase in SS groups does not render the meat tougher but crispier. Although the results to be found in literature are not uniform, freezing and frozen storage does not remarkably influence the total SH content of meat; however, there is a decrease in the nonprotein SH content during long-term frozen storage. As the nonprotein N content increases, the SH/N ratio decreases simultaneously. This ratio has been proposed as a quality index for frozen stored meat. The question of its usefulness is discussed. There is no experimental evidence for the statement that the freezing of proteins would cause an increase in SS groups. Freeze drying of meat does not decrease the SH content estimated with AgNO,, but the SH groups which are easily available for NEM decreased, demonstrating that the protein structure becomes tighter during freeze drying. It was demonstrated that SH groups are involved in the curing process. Different ways in which SH groups can react during the formation of the cured meat pigment, nitrosomyoglobin, are discussed. Smoking decreases the SH content of meat products because smoke contains many compounds (phenols, aldehydes, ketones) which are able to react with SH groups. Irradiation of meat causes the formation of hydrogen sulfide and volatile mercaptans at the expense of the SH content, but these amounts are low (< 1%) related to the total SH content. In the presence of atmospheric oxygen, higher doses of gamma radiation leads to an SH decrease. The freezing of meat before irradiation protects the SH groups. Several SH compounds are able to potentiate the microbial inhibition effect of known food preservatives. Because SH groups can bind toxic elements, toxic
88
KLAUS HOFMANN AND REINER HAMM
compounds, and carcinogens, SH groups in organisms and in foods are important for detoxification mechanisms. Therefore, careful preservation in order to maintain the cysteine content may be of importance not only for the nutritive value but also for the protection of the organism against several toxic substances.
IX.
RESEARCH NEEDS
( I ) Are the relation of SH to SS and the total SH plus SS content of muscle tissues of meat animals significantly influenced by the age of these animals? This question should be investigated with a number of younger and older animals sufficient for statistical evidence, or, more preferably, with the same animals at different stages of age using biopsy samples. (2) The binding forces participating in muscle contraction and rigor mortis are not yet understood. Is the SH-SS exchange reaction involved in these processes? (3) Is the SH-SS system relevant for the rheological behavior of minced meats and meat emulsions'? (4) Several hypothetical mechanisms have been discussed regarding the question of the way in which SH groups are involved in the curing process. What is the actual mechanism? (5) Do traces of metals such as Pb. Hg, Cu, Zn, Cd, and other possible residues in meat which are able to react with SH groups influence the development of sulfur containing volatiles, and, therefore, the development of meat flavor? ( 6 ) Does the introduction of SH groups into proteins (thiolation) improve the nutritive value of proteins which are poor in sulfur content?
ACKNOWLEDGMENTS We wish to express our sincere thanks to Mr. Erich Bliichcl and Mrs. E. Hofmann for their assistance during the preparation of this manuscript.
REFERENCES Alexander, N. M . 1958. Spectrophotometric assay for sulfhydryl groups using N-ethylmaleimide. Anal. Chem. 30, 1292. Allaway. W . H.. and Thompson, .I.F. 1966. Sulfur in the nutrition of plants and animals. Soil Sci. 101, 240. Andrae, W. 1969. Zur Marmorierung von Weilblech-Konservendosen. 2. Miu. Reaktion der Schwefelverbindungen. Nuhrung 13, 549.
SULFHYDRYL AND DlSULFlDE GROUPS IN MEATS
89
Al-Thannon. A. 1968. Kinetics of gamma radiolytic decomposition of aqueous cystcine solutinns. PhD Thesis. Univ. of Deleware. Newark. Anfinsen, C. B.. and Haber, E. 1961. Studies on the reduction and re-forrnation of protein disultide bonds. J . B i d . Chem. 236, 1361. Anson. M. L. 1945. Protein denaturation and the properties of protein groups. A h . Prorc4n Chrm. 2 , 361. Arai. K.. and Watanabe. S . 1968. A study of troponin. a myotibrillar protein from rabbit skelctal muscle. J . Biol. Chem. 243, 5670. Arnold. R. G.. Libbey, L. M., and Lindsay, R. C. 1969. Volatile flavor cornpnunds produced by heat degradation of thiamine (vitamin B,). .I. Agric,. Food. Chrm. 17, 390. Arroyo. P. T.. and Lillard, D. A. 1970. Identification of carbonyl and sulfur compounds from nonenzymatic browning reactions of glucose and sulfur-containing amino acids. J . Food S1.i. 35, 769. Ashworth. M. R. F. 1976. “The Determination of Sulphur-Containing Groups.” Vol. 2: Analytical Methods for Thiol Groups. Academic Press. New York. Ashworth. G. W . . and Keller. R. E. 1967. Ultraviolet determination of tertiary mercaptans as thionitrites. A n d . Cheni. 39, 373. Azzone. G. F., Carafoli. E.. and Barbolini. G. 1956. Ammetric detcrminatinn of SH groups of myosin and actomyosin. Ric. G i . 26, 3035. Bachhawat, J . M.. Ramegowda. N . S . , Koui. A. K . . Narang, C. K.. and Mathur. N. K . 1973. Determination of thiols by oxidation with N-bromosuccininiide. fncfinn J . Chem. 11, 614. BLany. M.. and Birany. K . 1959. Studies on “active centers” of L-Myosin. Biochim. Biophys. Actir 35, 293. Barany. M.. and BBrBny. K . 1973. A proposal for the mechanism of the contraction in intact frog muscle. Cold Spring Hnrhor Sym. Qltunr. Biol. 37, 157. Barany, M . , and Merritield. R. B. 1973. An ATP-binding peptide. Cold Spring Hurbor S.vmp. Quunt. Biol. 37, 121, Barany. M.. Gaetjens. E., Barany. K.. and Karp. E. 1964. Comparative studies of rabbit cardiac and skeletal myosin. Arch. Biochem. Biophys. 106, 280. Barnett. R. I.. and Seligman. A . M. 1952. Histochemical demonstration of protein-bound sulfhydryl groups. S & w P 116, 323. Barron. E. S. G . 1946. “Some Aspects of Biological Action of Radiations.” U . S . Declassified Doc. MDDC 484. USAEC, Oak Ridge, Tennessee. Cited in Barron (1951). Barron, E. S. C. 1951. Thiol groups of biological importance. Adv. Enzymol. R e h f . Suhj. Bioc.hem. 11, 201. Batzer. 0. F., and Dory, D. M. 1955. Nature of undesirable odors formed by gamma irradiation of beef. J . Agric. Food Chem. 3, 64. Baumgirtner, H.. and Baum, F. 1960. Beitrag zur Bildung von Schwefelwasserstoff in Fleisch durch Mikroorganismen beim Erhitzen. Ernuhrutib.s~~r.schung 5 , 40. Beckurts. H.. and Frerichs, G . 1906. Beitrage zur Kenntnis der Thiooxyfettsaureanilide. J . Prukf. C h e m 74, 24. Bem. Z . . Hofmann. D.. Malesevic. D.. and Glisin. B. 1970. Die Mengc an Sulthydryl- und Disulfidgruppen in Fleischkonserven. Proc. E u r . M e e f . Mear Res. Workers, / 6 f h , Vurncr p. 785. Bendall, J . R. 1969. “Muscle. Molecules and Movement.” Heinemann. London. Bendall. J . R.. and Wismer-Pedersen, J . 1962. Some properties of the tihrillar proteins of normal and watery pork muscle. J . Food. Sci. 27, 144. Benedict. R. C.. and Stcdman. R. L. 1970. Ellman’s reagent: Interference in mercapto group determination, with special reference to cigarette smoke. Anulysf 95, 296. Benesch, R.. and Benesch, R. E. 1948. Amperometric titration of sulfhydryl groups in amino acids and proteins. Arch. Biochern. 19, 35.
90
KLAUS HOFMANN AND REINER HAMM
Benesch. R., and Benesch, R. E. 1962. Determination of SH groups in proteins. Methods Biochcm. Anal. 10, 43. Benesch, R. E., Lardy, H. A.. and Benesch. R. 1955. The sulfhydryl groups of crystalline proteins. I. Some albumins, enzymes and hemoglobins. J . B i d . Chem. 216, 663. Bennett. H. S., and Watts. R. M. 1958. The cytochemical demonstration and measurement of sulfhydryl groups by azo-aryl mercaptide coupling with special reference to mercury orange. I n “General Cytochemical Methods” (J. F. Danielli. ed.). Vol. I . p. 317. Academic Press, New York. Berg. J . N . , Lebedeva, N . A , , Markina, J. A , . and Ivanov, I . I . 1965. EinfluBdes hohen Druckes auf einige Eigenschaften des Myosins. Biokhimiyu 30, 277. [Abstr.: Chem. Zentralbl. 137, No. 3 1 1428 (1966).] Beuk. J . F.. Chornock, F. W., and Rice, E. E. 1948. The effect of severe heat treatment upon the amino acids of fresh and cured pork. J . B i d . Chem. 180, 1243. Beveridge, T..Toma, S. J . . and Nakai, S. 1974. Determination of SH- and SS-groups in some food proteins using Ellman’s Reagent. J . Food Sci. 39, 49. Bhattacharya, S . K. 1958. Total sulphydryl (SH) content of blood and tissues. Biochem. J . 69, 43. Bhattacharya, S. K. 1959. Amperometric determination of sulphydryl content of blood and tissues. Nature (London) 183, 1327. Bigwood, E. J. 1972. Amino acid patterns of animal and vegetable proteins4ommon features and diversities. In “Protein and Amino Acid Function” (E. J . Bigwood, ed.), p. 238. Pergamon, Oxford. Bitny-Szlachto. S . . Kosinski, J . . and Niedzielska, M. 1963. Determination of sulfhydryl groups with 2,4-dinitrophenyl-2-hydroxyethyI disulfide. Acta Pol. Phurm. 20, 365. Bjarnason, J . . and Carpenter, K . J . 1970. Mechanism of heat damage in proteins. 11. Chemical changes in pure proteins. Br. J . Nurr. 24, 313. Blocksma. A. H. 1972. The relation between the thiol and disulfide contents of dough and its rheological properties. Cereal Chem. 49, 104. Bloeck, S . . Hofling, E., Baur, R . , and Susin, U. 1970. “Verhalten von H,S-abspaltenden Fullgutern in Steralcon.” Rep. No. 1310. AIusuisse Forschungsinst.. Neuhausen, Switzerland. Bocchini. V., Aloito, M. R., and Najjar, V. A. 1967. Sulfhydrylgruppen der Phosphoglucomutase aus Kaninchenmuskel. Biochemistry 6 , 313. [Abstr.: Chem. Zmtralbl. 139, No. 5-1235 ( I 968). ] Boelens, M . . van der Lindr. L. M.. de Valois. P. J . , van Dort, H. M . . and Takken. H. J . 1974. Organic sulfur compounds from fatty aldehyds, hydrogen sulfide. thiols and ammonia as flavor constituents. J . Agric. Food Chem. 22, 1071. Bognar, A. I97 la. Beitrag zur Ermittlung des ernahrungsphysiologischen Wertes von Fleisch in Abhsngigkeit von der thermischen Behandlung. PhD. Thesis, Univ. Hohenheim, Hohenheim, Germany. Bognar, A. 1971b. EinfluB der thermischen Behandlung auf den Gehalt an Aminosauren in Rindfleisch. Erniihr.-Umsch. 18, 200. Bolshakov, A. S . . and Mitrofanov, N . S . 1970. Evaluation of sulphydryl groups in meat by amperometric back titration (in Russ.). Prikl. Biokhim. Mikrobiol. 6, 606. Bolshakov, A . S . . Karpeev. J . J . . Mitrofanov, N. S . , and Khlebnikov, V. J. 1972. Determination of inertly reacting sulfhydryl groups in meat by their reaction with p-chloromercuribenzoate (in Russ.). Prik/. Biokhim. Mikrobiol. 8, 367. [Chem. Abstr. 77, 6 0 1 5 1 ~(1972).] Bowers, J . A. 1972. Eating quality, sulfhydryl content and TBA [2-thiobarbituric acid] values of turkey breast muscle. J . Agric. Food Chem. 20, 706. Boyer, P. D. 1954. Spectrophotometric study of the reaction of protein sulfhydryl groups with organic mercurials. J . Am. Chem. Soc. 76, 4331.
SULFHYDRYL AND DlSULFlDE GROUPS I N MEATS
91
Boyne. A. F . . and Ellman, G . L. 1972. A methodology for analysis of tissue sulphydryl components. A n d . Biochem. 46, 639. Brennan, M. J . . and Bernhard, R. A . 1964. Headspacr constituents of canned beef. Food Twhnol. 18, 149. Brennock. W . E.. and Read. W . V. 1972. Sulfhydryl and amino acid composition of actin and myosin in hereditary muscle dystrophy in chicken. Res. Commun. Chern. Parhol. Pharmucol. 3, 417. Brezina, M.. and Zuman, P. 1956. “Die Polarographie in der Medizin. Biochemie und der Pharniazie.” p. 607. Akad. Verlagsges.. Frankfurt a.M. Brown. D. W. 1960. Reduction of protein disulfidc bonds by sodium borohydride. Biochim. Biophys. Actu 44, 365. Brush. J . S., Jensen. E. V . . and Jacobsen. H. I . 1963. A study of t h r sulfhydryl group in bovine albumin. Biochim. Biophys. Actu 74, 688. Burke. M.. Reisler. E . , Himmelfarb, S . . and Harrington. W. T. 1974. Myosin adrnosintriphosphatase convergence of activation by actin and by SH, modification at physiological ionic strength. J . B i d . Chem. 249, 6361. Burley. R. W. 1954. Sulfhydryl groups in wool. Nurure (London) 174, 1019. Burton, H. 1958. The amperometrie titration of sulfhydryl groups at a rotating platinum electrode. Biochim. Biophys. Actu 29, 193. Butterworth, P. H., Baum. H.. and Porter. J. W. 1967. Arch. Biochem. Biophys. 118, 716. Cited in Jocelyn (1972). p. 149. Buttkus. H. 1971. The sulfhydryl content of rabbit and trout myosins in relation to protein stability. Can. J . Biochem. 49, 97. Buttkus, H. 1974. On the nature of chemical and physical bonds which contribute to somc structural properties of protein foods: A hypothesis. J . Food Sci. 39, 484. Calcutt. G. 1961. Sulphydryl levels of the liver and kidneys from rats fed dl. ethionine. Br. J . Cancer 15, 683. Calcutt. G . , and Doxey. D. 1959. The measurement of tissue-SH. Exp. Cell. Res. 17, 542. Calcutt. G . , and Doxey. D. 1961. The influence of thiamine and pantothenate upon tissue-SH-levels. Br. J . Cancer 15, 157. Calcutt. G . , and Doxey, D. 1962. The apparent glutathione content of some normal tissues and snme animal turnours. Br. J . Cuncer 16, 562. Calcutt. G.. Doxey. D., and Coates, J . 1961. Further studies uf the effects of chemical carcinogenis upon the SH levels of target and nontarget tissues. Br. J . Cancer 15, 149. Caldwell. K. A., and Lineweaver. H. 1969. Sultkydryl content of excised chicken breast muscle during aging. J . Sci. Food Chem. 34, 290. Calvin, M. 1954. In “Glutathione. A Symposium” (S. P. Colowick, A . Lazarow, E. Rackcr. D. R . Schwarz. E. R. Stadtman, and H. Waelsch, eds.). p. 33. Academic Press. New York. Cited in Lumper and Zahn (1965). Carsten. M. E. 1966. Actin. Its thiol groups. Biochemisrry 5, 297. Carter. J. R . 1959. Amperometric titration of disulfide and sulfhydryl in proteins in 8 M urea. J . B i d . Chem. 234, 1705. Casey. J . C.. Self. R.,and Swain, T. 1965. Factors influencing the production of low-boiling volatiles from food. J . Food. Sri. 30, 33. Cavallini. D., Graziani, M. T.. and Dupre, S. 1966. Determination of disulphide groups in proteins. Nuturr (London) 212, 294. Cecil, R. 1963. Intramolecular bonds in proteins. I . The role of sulfur in proteins. In “The Proteins” (H. Neurath, ed.), p. 379. Academic Press, New York. Cecil, R., and McPhee, J. R. 1959. The sulfur chemistry of proteins. Adv. Prorein Chem. 14, 255.
92
KLAUS HOFMANN AND RElNER HAMM
Chajuss. D.. and Spencer, J. V. 1962a. The effect of oxidizing and reducing aging media on the tenderness of excised chicken muscle. J . Food Sci. 27, 303. Cha.juss, D.. and Spencer. J. V. 1962b. Changes in the total sulfhydryl group content and histochemical demonstratibn of sulfonates in excised chicken muscle aged in air. J . F u o ~ Sci. . 27, 41 I . Chang. S. F., and Liener. J. E. 1964. New chromophoric reagents for labelling mercapto-groups of proteins. Narure (London) 203, 1065. Cheftel. H. 1958. Die Korrosion dcr Weibblechdose in der Konscrvenindustrie. W c v h f . Korros. 9, 630. Chibnall, A. C. 1943. Aminc)-acid analysis and the structure of proteins. Proc. R. Sor.. S u . , B 131, 136. Christian. G. D.. and Schur. P. H. 1965. The amperometric titration of total and interchain disulfidc bonds in y-globulin. Biochim. Eiophys. A m 97, 358. Christiansen, K . 1968. Versuche zur Anwendung der Umkehrrotation bei der Sterilisation von Fleischkonserven. F/eischwir/.schoj 48, 1 149. Clarkson, T. W. 1971. Epidemiological and experimental aspects of lead and mercury contamination of food. Food Cosmet. T O J X ~ C 9,O229. ~. Cleland. W. W. 1964. Dithiothreitol, a new protective reagent for SH groups. Biochemisrry 3, 480. Cleland, W. W. 1968. A specific and sensitive determination ofdisulfides. J . B i d . Chem. 243,716. Cohen, C . , Caspar, D. L., Johnson, J. P.. Nauss. K . . Margossian. S. S . . and Parry, D. A. D. 1973. Trapomyosin-troponin assembly. Cold Spring Harbor Symp. Quanr. B i d . 37, 287. Coleby B . , Ingram, M., Shepherd, H. J . . Thomley. M. J . . and Wilson. 0. M. 1961. Treatment of meat with ionising radiations. VI1. Effect of low temperatures during irradiation. J . Sci. Food Agric. 12, 483. Connell, J . J . 1957. Some aspects of the texture of dehydrated fish. J . Sci. F ~ o dAgric. 9, 526. Connell. J. J. 1960a. Studies on the proteins of fish skeletal muscle. VII. Denaturation and aggregation of cod myosin. Biochem. J . 75, 530. Connell. J. J. 1960b. Changes in the adenosinetriphosphatase activity and sulphydryl groups of cod flesh during frozen storage. J . Sci. F o ~ dAgric. 11, 245. Connell, J. J . 1961. The relative stability of skeletal muscle myosins of some animals. Bi<JchtW.J . 80, 503. Crocker. E. C. 1948. Flavor of meat. Food R m . 13, 179. Cummins, P., and Perry. J . V. 1973. Subunits and biological activity of polymeric forms of tropomyosin. Eioc+wm. J . 133, 765. Dahlke. H . 1969. Der EinfluS des Erhitzens verschiedener Eiweibe auf die Marmorierung durch das Freisetzen von Sulfhydrylgruppen und tliichtigen Schwefelverbindungen. F/ei.sch 23, 80. Daniel, J. L.. and Hartshomc, D. J . 1972. Sulfhydryl groups of natural actomyosin essential for the Ca2+ sensitive response: Location and properties. Biochim. Eiophys. A m 278, 567. Davidkova, E., and Davidek. J . 1971. Anwendung des Khanschen Qualitatsindexes zur Verfolgung der in gefrorenem und gekiihlt gelagertem Schweinefleisch eingetretenen Verlnderungen. 2. Lebensm. - Unters, -Forsch. 146, 6. De Marco, C.. Graziani, M. T . , and Mosti. R . 1966. The spectrophotometric determination of think and disulfides with N-ethylmaleimide. Anal. Eiochem. 15, 40. [Abstr.: 2. A n d . Chem. 218, 237 ( I 966). I Diez, M. J . F., Osuga, D. T.. and Feeney, R. E. 1964. The sulfhydryls of avian ovalbumins, bovine P-lactoglobulin, and bovine serum albumin. Arch. Eiochern. Eiophys. 107, 449. Dodge. J. W., and Stadelman. W. J. 1959. Postmortem aging of poultry meat and its effect on the tenderness of the breast muscles. Food Techno/. 13, 81. Donoso, G.. Lewis. 0. A. M.. Miller, D. S . . and Payne. P. R. 1962. Effect of heat treatment on the nutritive value of proteins: Chemical and balance studies. J . S(,i. Food Agric. 13, 192. Doxey, D. 1961. Measurement of the sulfhydryl content of tissue cultures. Er. J . Cancer 15, 146.
SULFHYDRYL AND DlSULFlDE GROUPS I N MEATS
93
Drabikowski. W.. and Bitny-Szlachto, S. 1963. The action of P-hydroxyethyI-2.4-dinitrophL.nyl disulphide o n sulphydryl groups of actin. Bull. Acuti. P O / . Sc,i.. S r r . S(,i. 11, 165. Drabikowski. W . . and Bitny-Szlachto. S . 1964. Studies o n the sulfhydryl groupa of actin. . 4 ~ . l u Bioc.him. Pol. 11, 421. Drabikowski. W.. and Nowak, E. 1965. Studies o n aulfhydryl groups of tropomyosin. A ~ . t Biochim. u Pol. 12,61. Drabikowski. W.. and Nowak. E. 1970. Thiol group content of tropomyosin and troponin. Al’rL7 Biochim. Pol. 17, 221. Dube. G. 1969. Tenderness evaluation of bovine niusclea and changes in sulfhydryl and dihulfidc contents of myofibrillar extracts cooked at different temperatures. PhD. Thesis. Purdue Univ., Lafayette, Indiana. (University Microfilms. Ann Arbor. Michigan. No. 70-3881 .) Dube. G.. Bramblett. V. D., Judge. M. D.. and Harrington. R . 9. 1972. Physical properties and sulfhydryl content of bovine muscles. J . Food Sci. 37, 23. Dupont. Y . , and Hasselbach. W. 1973. Structural changes in the sarcoplasniic reticulum membrane induced by sulfhydryl reagents. Nrtture (London) 246, 41. Dwivcdi. 9. K.. and Arnold, R. G. 1971. Hydrogen sulfide from heat degradation of thiamin. J . Agric.. Food Chem. 19, 923. Dwivedi, B. K.. and Arnold. R. G. 1972. Chemistry of thiamine degradation. Mechanisms of thiamine degradation in a model system. J . Food Sc,i. 37, 886. Dwivcdi, 9. K . , and Arnold. R. G . 1973. Chemistry of thiamine degradation in food products and inridel systems: A review. J . Agric,. Food C h e m 21, 54. Dwivcdi. B. K.. Arnold, R. G . , and Libbey. L. M. 1972. Chemistry of thiamine degradation: 4-methyl-S-(~-hydroxyl) thiazole from thernially degraded thiamine. J . Food Sc.i. 37, 689. Dwivedi. B . K., Arnold. R. G.. and Libbey. L. M. 1973. Some minor volatile components from thermally degraded thiamine. J. Food S i . 38, 450. Dworschak. E. 1969. Comparative chemical study of the proteins of raw and roasted meat from the point of view ofdiatetics. Elelmi.szrrvizsgukrri Kozl. 15, 263. [Abstr.: FSTA 2, 6 S 494 (1970). I Dworschak. E. 1970. Untersuchungrn iiber den biologischen Wert des EiweiRes in nihem und gebratcnrm Fleisch. Z . Lebensm.-Untersuch. -Forsch. 143, 167. Dzinleski. B. E.. Bratzler. L. J., Pepper, F. H.. and Pearson. A. H. 1969. Anderungen dcr SHGruppen in Proteinen von gefrorenem Rindermuskel und Tropfsaft (in Yugosl.). Techno/. Mew 2. 34. Ebashi, S . . and Nonomura. Y . 1973. Proteins of the niyofibril. / ! I “The Structure and the Function of Muscle” (G. H. Bourne. ed.). 2nd Ed., Vol. 3 . p. 28.5. Academic Press. New York. Ebashi. S . . Kodama. A,. and Ebashi. F. 1968. Troponin I . Preparation and physiological function. J . Biochrm. (Tokyo) 64, 465. Ehrlich. E. 1967. Technique de dosage automatique dc groupetnenta sulfhydriles. Application a I‘actomyosine. Bull. Sor. Chim. Biol. 49, X89. Eldjarn. L.. and Jellum, E. 1963. Organomercurialpolysaccharide, a chromatographic material for the separation and isolation of SH-proteins. Acru C h m i . S ~ t n d .17, 2610. Ellman. G. L. 1959. Tissue sulfhydryl groups. Arch. Bioc,hent. Biophys. 82, 70. Elzinga. M., and Collins. S. H. 1973. The amino acid sequence of rabbit skeletal muscle actin. Cold Spring Hurhor Symp. Quunt B i d . 37, I . Erwin. G. V.. and Pedersen. P. L. 1968. A sensitive gel-filtration method for determination of protein sulfhydryl groups with chloromercuribenzcratc -“C. A n d . Biochem. 25, 477. Ewart. J . 1972. A modified hypothesis for the structure and rheology of glutelins. J . S c i . Food Agric,. 23, 687. Ewing. G. W . 1960. “Instrumental Methods of Chemical Analysi McGraw-Hill, New York. Fasold. H.. and Turba, F. 1959. Denaturierung von Proteinen. Wiss. Ver6f. Dtsch. Gus. D n i i h r . 5, I .
94
KLAUS HOFMANN AND REINER HAMM
Feigl, F. 1960. “Tiipfelanalyse,” p. 233. Akad. Verlagsges. Frankfurt a.M. Fischer. C.. and Hamm, R . 1975. Sulfhydryl- und Disulfid-Gruppen in PSE-Fleisch. Fleischwirrschaft 55, 1295. Flesch, P . . and Kun, E. 1950. A colorimetric method for determination of sulfhydryl groups in tissue homogenates by I -(4-chloromercuriphenylazo)-naphthol-2. Proc. Soc. Exp. Eiol. Med. 74, 249. Flesch, P., Golomb, S . , and Satanove, A. 1954. Colorimetric determination of protein-bound waterinsoluble sulfhydryl groups with the Barmett-Seligman Reagent. J . Lab. Clin. Med. 43, 957. Folin. O., and Marenzi. A . D. 1929. An improved colorimetric method for the determination of cystine in proteins. J . Eiol. Chem. 83, 103. Fontana, A , , Veronese, F. M., and Scoffone. E. 1968. Sulfenyl halides as modifying reagents for polypeptides and proteins. 111. Azobenzene-2-sulfenyl bromide, a selective reagent for cysteinyl residues. Biochemistry 7, 3901. Forbes, W. F., and Hamlin, C. R. 1968. Determination of mercapto and disulfide groups in proteins. I . A reassessment of the use of methylmercuric iodide. Can. J . Chem. 46, 3033. Fox. J. B . , Jr., and Ackerman, S. A. 1968. Formation of nitric oxide myoglobin: Mechanisms of the reaction with various reductants. J . Food. Sci. 33, 364. Fraczak, R.,and Pajdowski, Z. 1955. The decomposition of sulfhydryl groups in meat by thermal processing. Przem. Spozyw. 9, 334. Frater, R., Hird, F. J . R.. Moss, H. J . , and Yates, J. R. 1960. A role for thiol and disulphide groups in determining the rheological properties of dough made from wheaten flour. Nature (London) 186, 45 I. Fridovich, I . , and Handler, P. 1957. Colorimetric assay for reaction of sulfhydryl groups with organic mercurials. Anal. Chem. 29, 1219. Friedman. M. 1973. ”The Chemistry and Biochemistry of the Sulfhydryl Group in Amino Acids, Peptides and Proteins.” Pergamon, Oxford. Friedman, M. 1974. Problems in assaying for half-cystine residues in proteins. Absrr. Pup. Am. Chem. S o ( , . , 168 AGFD 10. [Abstr.: FSTA 7, IA16 (1975)l. Friedrnann, E. 1952. Spectrophotometric investigation of the interaction of glutathione with maleimide and N-ethylmaleimide. Eiorhim. Eiophys. Acru 9, 65. Fuchs, F. 1971. The effect of Ca2+ on the sulfhydryl reactivity of troponin. Evidence for a Ca2+ induced confinnational charge. Eiochim. Eiophys. Acra 226, 453. Fujimaki, M., Arakawa, N., and Ogawa, G . 1961. Effects of gamma irradiation on the chemical properties of actin and actomyosin of meats. J . Food Sri. 26, 178. Gabay, S . , Cabral. A . M., and Healy, R. 1968. A chemical method for the estimation of brain sulfhydryl groups. Proc. Soc. Exp. Biol. Med. 127, 1081. Gabler. W.. and Scheuner, G. 1966. Specifity of dihydroxydinaphtyldisulfide (DDD) reaction. Acra Hisrochem. 23, 102. Gaff, D. F. 1966. The sulfhydryl-disulfide hypothesis in relation to desiccation injury of cabbage leaves. Ausr. J . Biol. Sci. 19, 291. Garbusov, V., Rehfeld, G., Wolm, R. V., Golovnaja, and Rothe, M. 1976. Volatile sulfur compounds contributing to meat flavour. I . Components identified in boiled meat. Nahrung 20, 235. Gawronski, T.H., Spencer, J. V., and Pubols, M. H. 1967. Changes in sulfhydryl and disulfide content of chicken muscle and the effect of N-ethylmaleimide. J . Agrir. Food Chem. 15, 781. Giacino, C. 1970. U.S. Patent 3,519,437. Cited in Wasserman (1972). Gilbert, J., Knowles, M. E., and McWeeny, D. J. 1975. Formation of C-and S-nitroso compounds and their further reactions. J . Sri. Food Agric. 26, 1785. Gimrnelreikh, N. G.. and Koval. Z. A. 1973. Effect of sarcolernma sulfhydryl group modification on activity of calcium- and magnesium-ion dependent ATPases. Ukr. Eiokhim. Zh. 45,587. [Chem. Ahsrr. 80, 46277a (19741.1
SULFHYDRYL AND DISULFIDE GROUPS IN MEATS
95
Glaser, C. B.. Maeda, H . , and Meienhofer, J. 1970. Chromatographic detection of thiols. disulfides. and thioesters with 5,5’-dithiobis (2-nitrobenzoic acid). J. Chromafogr. 50, 15 I . Goa, J . 1961. Micro determination of cysteine plus cystine in proteins. Aria Chem. Scand. IS, 853. Goldshtein, B. L.. and Khilko. 0. K. 1969. Change in the reactivity of sulfhydryl groups of proteins during aging of rats. Vesfn.Akad. Med. Nauk SSSR 24,3 I . [Chem. Absrr. 70, 1 1 3 0 0 8 ~(1969). 1 Golovkin, N. A., and Korzhemanova, L. 1973. Change in protein sulfhydryl groups during the storage of meat in a supercooled state (in Russ.). Myasn. Ind. SSSR 5 , 32. [Chem. Absrr. 79, 64718d 1973).) Golovkin, N . A.. and Meluzova, L. A . 1970. Changes of meat protein during long-temi storage in frozen state (in Russ.). Izv. VysS UP. Zav. Techn. 1, 65. Graevsky. E. Y., Konstantinova, M. M., and Tarasenko. A . G. 1969. Sulfhydryl groups and radiosensivity. S f u d . Biophys. 15/16, 163. Grassetti. D. R.. and Murray, J . F., Jr. 1969. Reagents for the spectrophotometric determination of sulfhydryl groups over a wide wavelength range. Anal. Chim. Acfu 46, 139. Grau. R. 1968. Einfliisse auf Beschaffenheit und Zusammensetzung des Fleisches. In “Handbuch der Lebensmittelchemie” (J. Schormiiller, ed.), Vol. 111/2. p. 1 I 10. Springer-Verlag. Berlin and New York. Gredser. M. L.. Yamaguchi. M., Brekke, C.. Potter, J., and Gergely, J . 1973. Troponin subunits and their interactions. Cold Spring Harbor S,yrnp. Quanf Biol. 37, 235. Greenwood. D. A,, Kraybill. H. R.. and Schweigert. B. S. 1951. Amino acid composition of fresh and cooked beef cuts. J . B i d . Chem. 193, 23. Gregory. J. D. 1955. The stability of N-ethylmaleimide and its reaction with sulfhydryl groups. J . Am. Chem. Soc. 77, 3922. Grill, H.. Patton. S., and Cone. J . F. 1967. Degradation of “5S-methionine to methyl mercaptan in surface ripened cheese. J . Agric. Food Chem. 15, 192. GrBschel-Stewart. U . , and Turba, F. 1963. “C-Markierung und Peptidkarten der SH-Regionen von Actomyosin, Myosin, Actin und H-Meromyosin. Biochem. Z . 337, 104. Grote, I . W . 1931. A new color reaction for soluble organic sulfur compounds. J . Biol. Chem. 93, 25. Gruen, L. C., and Harrap. B. S. 1971. Determination of thiols with a specific-ion electrode. Anal. Biochem. 42, 377. Griinewald, T. 1969. Untersuchungen iiber den EinfluD der Temperatur auf Bestrahlungsverluste von Cystin und Cystein in Lebensmitteln. Kalretech.-Klim. 21, 336. Gruenwedel. D. W.. and Patnik, R. K. 1971. Release of hydrogen sulfide and methyl mercaptan from sulfur-containing amino acids. J . Agric. Fund Chem. 19, 775. Gundlach, H. G.. Moore, S . , and Stein, W. H. 1959. The reaction iodoacetate with methionine. J . Biol. Chem. 234, I76 I . Habeeb. A. F. S. A. 1972. Reaction of protein sulphydryl groups with Ellman’s reagent. In “Enzyme Structure,” Pan B (C. H. W. Hirs, ed.), Methods in Enzymology, Vol. 25. p. 457. Academic Press. New York. Hamm, R. 1964. EinfluO der Gefriertrocknung auf die Qualitat des Fleisches. Dtsch. Lebensm: Rundsrh. 60, 97. Hamm, R.. and Hofmann, K . 1965. Changes in the sulfhydryl and disulfide groups in beef niuscle proteins during heating. Nature (London) 207, 1269. Hamm, R.. and Hofmann, K. 1966a. Schwefelhaltige Verbindungen des Fleisches. I. Uber die Problematik der Bestimmung von Sulfhydrylgruppen in FleischeiweiS. Z . Lebensm.-Unters.Forsch. 129, 143. Hamm. R.. and Hofmann, K . 1966b. Schwefelhaltige Verbindungen des Fleisches. 11. Bestimmung von Sulfhydrylgruppen in Muskelgewebe und Myofibrillen mit N-Athylmaleinimid. Z . Lebensm.-Llnters. -Forsch. 130, 85.
96
KLAUS HOFMANN AND REINER HAMM
Schwefelhaltige Verbindungen des Fleisches. 111. Bestimmung Hamm, R . , and Hofmann, K. 1966~. von Sulfhydryl- und Disulfid-Gruppen in Myofibrillen und Muskelgewebe mil Hilfe der amperometrischen Titration. Z . Lebensm.-Unters. -Forsch. 130, 133. Hamm, R., and Hofmann, K. 1967.Schwefelhaltige Verbindungen des Fleisches. IV. Bestimmung von Sulfhydrylgruppen in Myofibrillen mit Natrium-p-Chlorquecksilber(I1)benznat. Z . Lebensm.-Unrers. -Forsch. 136,7. Hamm, R., Hofmann, K.. Griinewald, T., and Partmann. W. 1975. Verandemngen yon Aminotransferasen und Muskelproteinen bei der Behandlung von Schweinefleisch mit ionisierenden Strahlen. Fleischwirfschuj? 55, 1 105. Harington, J. S. 1967.The sulfhydryl group and carcinogenesis. Adv. Cuncer RPS.10, 247. Harisch, G . , and Schole. J. 1974.Der Glutathionstatus der Rattenleber in Abhangigkeit vom Lebensalter und von akuter Belastung. 2. Nuturforsch.. Teil C 29, 261. Harland, J . W., Kauffmann, F. L., and Heiligman, F. 1967. Effect of irradiation temperature and processing conditions on organoleptic properties of beef and chemical yields in model systems. In “Radiation Preservation of Foods.” Advances in Chemistry Series, No. 65, p. 35. Am. Chem. Soc., Washington. D.C. Harrap, B. S., and Gruen, L. C. 1971,Application of a specific-ion electrode to the determination of disulfide groups in proteins. Anal. Eiochem. 42, 398. Hartshome, D. J., and Daniel, J. L. 1970.Importance of sulfhydryl groups for the calcium-sensitive response of natural actomyosin. Eiochim. Eiophys. Acru 223, 214. Hasselbach, W.,and Seraydarian. K. 1966. The role of sulfhydryl groups in calcium transport through the sarcoplasmic membranes of skeletal muscle. Eiochem. Z . 345, 1.59. Haurowitz,nF. 1950. Internal structure of globular proteins. In “Chemistry and Biology of Proteins,” p. 127. Academic Press, New York. Havir, J., Fidler, A,, and Husak, R. 1966. Nachweis von Schwefelverbindungen mit FluoresceinI .3.6.8.-tetraquecksiIbertetraacetat. Acru Chim. Acud. Sci. Hung. 51, 39.[Abstr.: Chem. Zentrulbl. 139, No. 21-2229(1968).] Hay, J. D., Currie, R. W . , and Wolfe, F. H. 1972.The effect of aging on physiochemical properties of actomyosin from chicken breast and leg muscle. J . Food. Sci. 37, 346. Hay, J. D., Currie, R. W., Wolfe, F. H., and Sanders, E. J. 1973.Effect of postmortem aging on chicken muscle fibrils. J . Food Sci. 38, 981. Heazlitt, R., Conway, G., and Montag, J. 1973. The role of actin sulfhydryls in actin-myosin interactions. Biochirn. Eiophys. Actci 317, 3 16. Hedin, P. A.. Kurtz. G. W.. and Koch. R. B. 1961. The chemical composition of beef protein fractions before and after irradiation. J . Food Sci. 26, 112. Heide, K. 1955. Funktion und Analyse von SH-Gruppen in Proteinen. Eehringwerk-Mirt. 30, 97. Heidtmann, R. H. 1966.Vorteile neuzeitlicher Konservierungsverfahren. Fleischwirrschuj? 46, 761 . Heidtmann, R. H. 1970.F-Werte fur konservierte und haltbare Nahrungsmittel. Fleischwirrschuji 50, 153. Herz, K. 0.. and Chang. S. S. 1970.Meat flavor. Adv. Food Res. 18, I . Hird, F. J. R., and Yates. J. R. 1961. The oxidation of cysteine. glutathionc and thioglycollatc by iodate, bromate, persulphate and air. J . Sci. Food Agric. 12, 89. Hoch, F., and Vallee, B. L. 1960. Sulfhydryl groups of some mono- and dimercaptans and yeast alcohol dehydrogenase. Arch. Eiochem. Eiophys. 91, 1. Hodges, R. S . , and Smillie, L. B. 1970.Chemical evidence for chain heterogenity in rabbit muscle tropomyosin. Eiorhem. Eiophys. Res. Commun. 41, 987. Hodges. R. S . , and Smillie, L. B. 1972.Cysteine sequence of rabbit skeletal tropomyosin. Can. J . Eiochem. 50, 330. Hofmann. K. 1964. Untersuchung des Einflusses der thermischen Behandlung von Fleisch auf die funktionellen Gruppen der strukturellen Muskelproteine. PhD. Thesis, Justus Liebig-Univ., Giessen, Giessen, Germany.
SULFHYDRYL AND DlSULFlDE CROUPS IN MEATS
97
Hofmann. K . 1965a. Uber den Nachweis von Sulfhydrylverbindungen mit Nitroprussidnatrium und Zinkchlorid. Jahresher. Bundesunsr. F1rischfiirsc.h. Kulmbach p. I 10. Hofmann, K . I965b. Neue Farbreaktionen auf Sulfhydrylgruppen. Ntirurivisspiisc.hirj?en 52, 428. Hofmann. K . 1966a. Zur Reaktionsfahigkeit von SH-Gruppen in Proteinen. Naruri~,isrensc.hufic.,t53, 432. Hofmann. K . 1966b. Uber den Nlhrwert des Fleisches und seine Versnderung beim Erhitzen Fleiwhwirrschuj? 46, I I2 I . Hofniann. K . 1967. Methode zur Bestimmung vim Schwefelwasserstoff in Fleisch. Juhresher. Bundrstin.71. F1rischf)rsc.h. Kulmbach p. S I . Hofmann. K . 1969. Anwendung von Kaliumjodid bei der amperometrischen Titration. Jahresher. Bunrlesunsr. Fleischfmch. Kulint~urhp. 66. Hofmann, K . 1970. Beeinflussung der amperometrischen Titration vim Sulfhydrylgruppen mit Silbernitrat durch Salze. 2. Anal. Chrin. 250, 256. Hufniann. K. I97 la. Sulfhydrylgruppen in Lebensmitteln und ihre Bestimmung. Mirrcilung.sh1. GDCh (Ges. Dlsrh. Chetn. I-Fuchgruppe Let?ensnlirr~,l~~hem. Gerii,htl. Chem. 25, 109. Hofniann. K . I97 Ib. Bestimmung von SH-Gruppen im Muskelgewebe durch indirekte amperometrische Titration mit Silbernitrat unter Anwendung von Kaliumjodid. Z . Lrhensm.-Unrcw. -Forsch. 147, 68. Hofmann. K. 1 9 7 1 ~Bestimmung . von Thiolgruppen nlit AgNO,, NAM und PCMB unter Anwcndung der amperometrischen Titration. Z . Anal. Chem. 256, 187. Hofmann. K . I97 Id. Untersuchung schwefelhaltigcr Verbindungen im Muskel und ihre Bedeutung bei der Lagerung und Verdrbeituny von Flcisch. Diskussionstag. For-srhungskr. Erniihrungsind. No. 30, p. 78. Hofmann. K . 1972a. Bestimmung des Sulfhydryl-Cehaltes in den myofibrillaren Muskelproteinen. Juhresher. Bundesansr. Fleisi~hforsch.Kulinbui~hp. 7 I Hofmann. K . 1972b. Ampawnetrisehe Titration der SH-Gruppen in Milch mit Silbernitrat. Nuhrung 16, 197. Hofmann. K . 1 9 7 2 ~ Der . EinfluB der Konservierungsverfahren auf die Qualitat von Fleisch und Fleischerzeugnissen. Flf,;~ch~,irr.~(.h~ij? 52, 1403. Hofmann. K . 1974a. Schwefelwasserstoffbildung in Fleischerzeugnihsen. Fleisc~hwirrschufi54, 1297. Hofmann. K . 1974b. Das Redoxpotential-sein Wesen und seine Bedeutung fur Fleisch und Fleischwaren. Fleischwirrsrhuj? 54, 465. Hofmann. K . 1 9 7 4 ~Eine . neue Methode zur Vitamin-B,-Bestimmung i n Fleischwaren. Juhresher. Bundesanst. Fleischfmch. Kulmbuch p. 48. Hofmann, K . , and Hamm, R. 1966. Sulfhydryl- und Disulfidgruppen des Fleisches und ihre Bestimmung. Flei.rc,h~virrsr,hu~ 46, I 125. Hofmann. K . . and Hamm, R. 1967a. Zur Bestimmung von Schwefelwasserstoff mit N,NDimethyl-p-phenylendiaminund Eisenchlorid. Z . Anal. Chem. 232, 167. Hofmann, K . , and Hamm. R. 1967b. Methode zur Bestimmung von Sulfhydryl- und Disulfidgruppen in Proteinen unter Anwendung verschiedener Reagentien. Z . A n d . Chem. 231, 199. Hofmann, K . . and Hamm. R. 1974a. Bestimmung von Sulfhydryl- und Disulfid-Gruppen in Proteinen mit Hilfe der amperometrischen Titration. I , Uber die Reaktionsfahigkeit von ProteinSH-Gruppen und die SH-Spezifitat von Silber-lonen. Z . Lrbensm.-Unters. -Forsch. 156, 100. Hofmann, K . . and Hamm. R. 1974b. Bestimmung von Sulfhydryl- und Disulfidgruppen in Proteinen mit Hilfe der amperometrischen Titration. 11. Kritische Betrachtung der Methoden zur amperometrischen Titration von Protein-SH-Gruppen mit Silbernitrat. Z . Lehensm-Unrers. -Forsch. 156, 139. Hofmann. K . , and Hamm, R. 1975. Bestimmung von Sulfhydryl- und Disulfid-Gruppen in Proteinen n i t Hilfe der amperometrischen Titration 111. Untersuchung der Spezifitat von Ag+-Ionen fur Protein-SH-Gruppen, 2. Lebensm.-Unters. -Forsch. 159, 205.
98
KLAUS HOFMANN AND REINER HAMM
Hofmann, K.. and Schael, U. 1966. EinfluB der Lagerdauer auf die Sulfhydrylgruppen des Rindfleisches. Jahresber. Bundrsansr. Flrischforsch. Kulrnbuch p. 50. Hofmann, K.. Schael. U . . and Hamm. R. 1969. EinfluR der Lagerung von Rind- u. Schweineflcisch auf den Gehalt des Gewebes an Sulfhydryl gruppen. Fleischwirrschufr 49, 1502. Hofmann. K., Mintzlaff, H.-J., Alperden. I., and Leistncr, L. 1971. Untersuchung iiber die Inaktivierung des Mykotoxins Patulin durch Sulfhydrylgruppen. Fleischwirtschufr 51, 1534. Hofmann. K.. Bliichel. E.. and Baudisch. K. 1974. lnvestigation of chemical changes during storage of frozen meat. Proc. Eur. M w r . Meat Rcs. Workers, 20rh, Dublin p. 262. Holbrook, J. J., Pfleiderer. G., Schnetgcr, J., and Diemar, S. 1966. The importance of SH-groups for enzymic activity. Biochrm. Z . 344, I . Holm, J. 1976. Untersuchungen auf den Gehalt an Blei und Cadmium in Fleisch- und Organproben bei Schlachttieren. Fleiwhwirrsc.hqfr 56, 413. Homsey, H. C. 1959. The colour of cooked cured pork. 111.-Distribution and relationship of pigments. pH and cysteine. J . Sci. Food Agric. 10, 114. Hornstein, 1.. Crowe, P. F . , and Sulzbacher, W. L. 1960. Constituents of meat flavor: Beef. J . Agric. Food Chem. 8, 65. Hupf, H . . and Springer, R. 1971. Bildung von Lanthionin in Nahrungsproteinen. Z . Lebensm: Linters. -Forsch. 146, 138. Husaini, S. A.. and A h . F. 1955. Denaturation of proteins of egg white and of fish and its relation to the hberdtion of sulfhydryl groups on frozen storage. Food Res. 20, 264. Jacobsen, A. L., and Henderson, J . 1973. Temperature sensitivity of myosin and actomyosin. Can. J . Biochem. 51, 71. Jaenicke. R. 1964. Zum Mechanismus der Warmeaggregation globdarer Proteine. Ber. Bunsenges. Phys. Chem. 68, 857. Jaenicke, R. 1965a. lntermolekulare Wechselwirkungen bei der Warmeaggregation globulkrer Proteine. Z . Naturforsch., Teil B 20, 2 I . Jaenicke. R. 1965b. Warmeaggregation und Warmedenaturierung von Proteinen. In “Wlrmebehandlung van Lebensmitteln,” DECHEMA-Monographie. No. 56. p. 207. Verlag Chemie, Weinheim. Jamieson, D., Ladner, K . , and van der Brenk, H. A. S . 1963. Pulmonary damage due to high pressure oxygen breathing in rats. 4. Quantitative analysis of sulphydryl and disulfide groups in rat lungs. Ausr. J . Exp. B i d . Med. Sci. 41, 491. Jeckel. D.. and Pfleiderer. U. G. 1969. Anderung der optischen Rotationsdispersion von LactatDehydrogenase aus Schweineherzmuskel nach Zugabe von Hamstoff, Coenzym und SHblockierenden Reagenzien. Hoppe-Seylrr’s Z . Physiol. Chem. 350, 903. Jermyn, M. A. 1966. lodoalkanesulphonates as thiol reagents. Aust. J . Chem. 19, 1293. Jocelyn, P. C. 1972. “Biochemistry of the SH group.” Academic Press, New York. Johnson, A. R., and Vickery, J. R. 1964. Factors influencing the production of hydrogen sulphide from meat during heating. J . Sci. Food Agric. 15, 695. Jones, 1. A., Phillips. J. W., and H i d , F. J. R . 1974. Theestimation of rheologically important thiol and disulfide groups in dough. J . Sci. Food Agric. 25, I . Kakat, B., and Vejdtlek, 2 . J. 1974. Thiole und strukturverwandte Schwefelverbindungen. In “Handbuch der photometrischen Analyse organischer Verbindungen,” Vol. I , p. 175. Verlag Chemie, Weinheim. Kakol, I. 1971. The location of the thiol groups of myosin that are protected against reaction with 2,4-dinitrophenyl P-hydroxyethyl disulphide. Biochem. J . 125, 261. Kakol, I . , Gruda, J . , and Bitny-Szlachto, S . 1964. A study on the role of SH groups of myosin by means of P-hydroxyethyl-2,4-dinitrophenyI disulphide. Acra Biochim. Pol. 11, 41 I . Kameyama, T.. and Sekine. T. 1973. The effect of F-actin on the reactivity of a specific sulfhydryl group (S,) in heavy meromyosin. J . Bbchem. (Tokyo) 74, 1283. Kameyama, T . , Ayakawa, A , , and Sekine, T. 1974. Effect of phenol derivatives and chemical
SULFHYDRYL AND DISULFIDE GROUPS I N MEATS
99
modification on the ATPase activities of heavy meromyosin and subfragment I . J . Biochem. (Tokyo) 75, 381.
Kanac.ka, Y.. Machida. M.. Ban, Y., and Sekine. T. 1967. Fluorescence and structure of proteins as measured by incorporation of fluorophore. 11. Synthesis of maleimide derivatives a. fluorescencelabeled protein-sulfhydryl reagents. Chem. Phurm. Bull. 15, 1738. Kanacika, Y.. Machida. M.. Kokubun. H.. and Sekine, T. 1968. Fluorescence and structure of proteins as measured by incorporation of fluorophore. 111. Fluorescence characteristics of N-[p-(2-Benzoxazolyl)phenyl]maleiniide and the derivatives. Chem. Pharm. Bull. 16, 1747. Kanaoka. Y.. Machida. and Sekine. T. 1973. Fluorescent thiol reagents. VI. N( 1 -Anilinonaphthyl-4)1naleImide;a fluorescent hydrophobic probe directed to thiol groups in protein. Biwhim. Biophys. Actu 317, 563. Kardashev. A. V.. Bobrovskaya. N. D.. Klyashtorin, L. B.. and Maslennikova. N . V. 1970. Biochemical changes in y-irradiated fish. Tr. Vses. Nuucho-Isslrd. Inst. Morsk. Rybn. Khoz. Okranogr. 73, 53. [Abstr.: FSTA 3, 5 R 215 (1971).1 Karmas. E., and DeMarco. G. R. 1970. Denaturation thermoprofiles of some proteins. J . Food Sci. 35, 725. Karush. F., Klinman. N . R.. and Marks. R. 1964. An assay method for disulfide groups by fluorescence quenching. A n d . Biochem. 9, 100. Katchalski. E.. Benjamin. G . S . . and Gross, V. 1957. The availability of the disulfide bonds of human and bovine serum albumin and of bovine y-globulin to reduction by thioglycolic acid. J . A m . Chetn. S o c 79, 4096. Kato. S . . Kurata. T.. and Fujinraki. M . 1973. Volatile compounds produced by the reaction of L-cysteinr or L-cystine with carbonyl compounds. Agric. B i d . Chem. 37, 539. Katz. M.. and Mommaerts. W. F. H. M. 1962. The sulphydryl groups in actin. Biochim. Biuphys. Actu 65, 82. [Abstr.: C h e x . Zentrulhl. 136, No. 9-1580 (1965).1 Kelley. G . G.. and Wans. B. M. 1957. Effect of reducing agents on curcd meat color. Food Techno/. 11, 114. Khan, A. W. 1965. Objective evaluation of quality in poultry meat. Nuture (London) 208, 204. Khan. A. W. 1966. Cryochemistry of animal tissue. Cryobiolugy 3, 224. Khan. A. W., and Nakamura, R. 1971. Quality and biochemical changes during frozen storage of meat from epinephrine-treated and untreated chickens. J . Food Sci. 37, 145. Khan. A. W.. and van den Berg, L. 1964. Some protein changes during post-mortem tenderization in poultry meat. J . Food Sci. 29, 597. Khan. A. W., and van den Berg. L. 1965. Changes in chicken muscle proteins during cooking and subsequent frozen storage. and their significance in quality. J . Food Sci. 30, 151. Khan. A. W.. van den Berg. L., and Lentz, C . P. 1963. Effects of frozen storage on chicken muscle proteins. J . Food Sci. 28, 425. Khan. A. W.. Davidkova. E.. and van den Berg. L. 1968. On cryodenaturation ofchicken myofibrillar proteins. Cryobiology 4, 184. Kielley. W. W., and Barnen. L. M. 1961. The identity of the myosin subunits. Biochim. Biophys. A C ~ U51, 589. Kiermeier. F.. and Hamed, M. G. E. 1962. Zur Bestimmung der Sulfhydrylgruppen in Milch und Milchprodukten. Nahrung 6 , 639. King, T. E., and Morris, R. 0. 1967. Determination of acid-labile sulfide and sulfhydryl groups. In “Oxidation and Phosphorylation” (R. W. Estabrook and M. E. Pullman, eds.), Methods in Enzymology, Vol. 10, p. 634. Academic Press, New York. Kirsten. E., and Kuperman, A. S. 1970a. Effect of sulfhydryl inhibitors on frog sartorius muscle: p-chloromercuribenzoic acid and p-chloromercuribenzene sulfonic acid. Br. J . Pharmacol. 40, 814. Kirsten, E., and Kuperman, A. S. 1970b. Effect of sulfhydryl inhibitors on frog sartorius muscle:
1.00
KLAUS HOFMANN AND REINER HAMM
N-ethylmaleimide. Br. J . Pharmacol. 40, 827. Klotsch, H., and Bergmeyer. H. U. 1962. Glutathion. In "Methoden der enzymatischen Analyse" (H. U. Bergmeyer. ed.). p. 363. Verlag Chemie, Weinheim. Klotz, 1. M.. and Carver, 8 . R. 1961. A spectrophotometric titration for the determination of sulfhydryl groups. Arch. Eiochem. Biophys. 95, 540. Kofman. E. B. 1963. With silver titratable sulfhydryl groups in actomyosin gel at syneresis. Biokhimiya 28, 774. [Chrm. Abstr. 60, 4364a (1964).] Kohno, K. 1965. Interaction of thiamin or related compounds with proteins. XI. Micro-determination of protein SH and low molecular SH groups by means of different thiamin disulfides as reagents. Viramins 31, 470. [Abstr.: Chem. Zentralbl. 137, No. 20- 1489 (1966).] Kohno, K . 1966. Microdetermination of protein-SH and low molecular SH-groups using various thiamine disulfides as reagent. J . Vitaminol. 12, 137. Kolodziejczyk, J. 1965. Entstehung und Verschwinden von Sulfhydrylgruppen bei der Gefriertrocknung von Fleisch (in Pol.). Przem. Spozyw. 19, 31. [Abstr.: Chem. Zenr