ADVANCES IN ELECTRONICS AND ELECTRON PHYSICS
VOLUME 37
CONTRIBUTORS TO THISVOLUME K. M. Adams E. F. A. Deprettere Br...
121 downloads
1122 Views
15MB Size
Report
This content was uploaded by our users and we assume good faith they have the permission to share this book. If you own the copyright to this book and it is wrongfully on our website, we offer a simple DMCA procedure to remove your content from our site. Start by pressing the button below!
Report copyright / DMCA form
ADVANCES IN ELECTRONICS AND ELECTRON PHYSICS
VOLUME 37
CONTRIBUTORS TO THISVOLUME K. M. Adams E. F. A. Deprettere Bruce D. McCombe Kohzoh Masuda Susumu Namba J. 0. Voorman Robert J. Wagner P. K. Weimer
Advances in
Electronics and Electron Physics EDITEDBY L. MARTON Smithsonian Institution, Washington, D.C. Assistant Editor CLAIRE MARTON
EDITORIAL BOARD E. R. Piore T. E. Allibone M. Ponte H. B. G. Casimir W. G. Dow A. Rose L. P. Smith A. 0. C. Nier F. K. Willenbrock
VOLUME 37
1975
ACADEMIC PRESS
New York San Francisco London
A Subsidiary of Harcourt Brace Jovanovich, Publishers
COPYRIGHT 0 1975, BY ACADEMIC PRESS, INC. ALL RIGHTS RESERVED. NO PART O F THIS PUBLICATION MAY B E REPRODUCED OR TRANSMITTED I N ANY FORM OR BY ANY MEANS, ELECTRONIC OR MECHANICAL, INCLUDING PHOTOCOPY, RECORDING, OR ANY INFORMATION STORAGE AND RETRIEVAL SYSTEM, WITHOUT PERMISSION I N WRITING FROM T H E PUBLISHER.
ACADEMIC PRESS, INC.
111 Fifth Avenue, New York, New York 10003
United Kingdom Edition published by ACADEMIC PRESS, INC. (LONDON) LTD. 24/28 Oval Road. London N W l
LIBRARY OF CONGRESS CATALOG CARD NUMBER:49-7504 ISBN 0-1 2-014537 -5 PRINTED I N T H E UNITED STATES OF AMERICA
CONTENTS CONTRIBUTORS TO VOLUME37 .
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
vii
FOREWORD.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
ix
.
.
.
.
.
Intraband Magneto-Optical Studies of Semiconductors in the Far Infrared. I I. I1. I11. IV .
BRUCED. MCCOMBE AND Introduction . . . . . . . Theoretical Background . . . . Experimental Techniques . . . Free Carrier Resonances . . . . . . . . . . References
ROBERT J . WAGNER . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
.
.
.
.
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
i 2 17 28 75
The Gyrator in Electronic Systems K . M . ADAMS. E . F. A . DEPRETTERE, A N D J . 0. VOORMAN I . Introduction . . . . . . . . . . I1 . Reciprocity in Physical Systems . . . . I11. The Gyrator as Network Element . . . . IV . Filters . . . . . . . . . . . . V. Principles of Realization of the Gyrator . . VI . Basic Electronic Design . . . . . . . VII . Basic Gyrator Measurements . . . . . VIII . Trends in Gyrator Design and Applications . IX . Conclusion . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . References
. . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . 80 . . . . . . 80 . . . . . . 86 . . . . . . 94 . . . . . . 109 . . . . . . 128 . . . . . . 145 . . . . . . 170 . . . . . . 176 . . . . . . 177
Image Sensors for Solid State Cameras P. K . WEIMER I. I1 . 111. IV . V. VI . VII . VIII . IX . X. XI . XI1 .
Introduction . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Photoelements for Self-scanned Sensors . . . . . . Principles of Multiplexed Scanning in Image Sensors . . Early XY Image Sensors . . . . . . . . . . Multiplexed Photodiode Arrays . . . . . . . . Principles of Scanning by Charge Transfer . . . . . Charge-Transfer Sensors Employing Bucket Brigade Registers Characteristics of Charge-Coupled Devices (CCDs) . . . Experimental Charge-Coupled Image Sensors . . . . Performance Limitations of Charge-Coupled Sensors . . Charge-Transfer Sensors as Analog Signal Processors . . Self-scanned Sensors for Color Cameras . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . .
.
.
. .
. .
. . . . . . . . .
182 183 187 193 198 202 208 213 225 . 236 . 247 . 251
vi
CONTENTS
XI11 . Peripheral Circuits for Solid State Sensors . . . . . . . . 253 XIV . Conclusions . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 257 References . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 259 Ion Implantation in Semiconductors
SUSUMU NAMBA A N D KOHZOHMASLDA I. I1. I11. I V. V. VI .
Introduction . . . . . . . . Concentration Profiles of Implanted Ions Enhanced Diffusion . . . . . . Annealing and Electrical Properties . Measurement Technique . . . . Devices . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . References
.
.
.
.
.
.
and Defects . . . .
.
.
.
. .
. .
. .
. .
. .
.
.
.
.
.
.
264 271
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
. .
. .
. .
. .
. .
. .
. .
. .
2x9 299 . 310 . 325 . 328
.
.
.
ALTHOR
INDEX .
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
331
SC RJtCT
INDEX
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
339
CONTRIBUTORS TO VOLUME 37 Numbers in parentheses indicate the pages on which the authors’ contributions begin
K. M. ADAMS(79), Department of Electrical Engineering, Delft University of Technology, Delft, Netherlands E. F. A. DEPRETTERE (79), Department of Electrical Engineering, Delft University of Technology, Delft, Netherlands BRUCED. MCCOMBE (11 Naval Research Laboratory, Washington, D.C.
KOHZOHMASUDA(263), Faculty of Engineering Science, Osaka University, Toyonaka, Osaka, Japan SUSUMUNAMBA(263), Faculty of Engineering Science, Osaka University, Toyonaka, Osaka, Japan J. 0.VOORMAN(79), Philips Research Laboratories, N. V. Philips’ Gloeilampenfabrieken, Eindhoven, Netherlands
ROBERTJ. WAGNER(1), Naval Research Laboratory, Washington, D.C. P. K. WEIMER (181), RCA Laboratories, Princeton, New Jersey
vii
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
FOREWORD
Our present volume starts with the first part of a review by B. D. McCombe and R. J. Wagner on “Intraband Magneto-Optical Studies of Semiconductors in the Far Infrared.” In a much broader survey of farinfrared radiation, Professor L. C. Robinson* confines magneto-optical effects in semiconductors necessarily to barely three pages. In their review, McCombe and Wagner offer an in-depth treatment of this important subject leading to a better knowledge of intraband transitions. A potentially very important device is discussed by K. M. Adams, E. F. A. Deprettere, and J. 0. Voorman in their review of “The Gyrator in Electronics Systems.” They point out that the electronic gyrator, as it now exists, is limited in industrial applications for several reasons. Nevertheless the subject is important enough for a thorough treatment and the reviewers’ presentation will, no doubt, stimulate thinking toward improved solutions. An entirely new trend in image pick-up and reproduction is the subject of P. K. Weimer’s review. Under the title “Image Sensors for Solid State Cameras,” he discusses the new devices more from a research viewpoint “with much greater emphasis on principles of operation, than on details of construction.” The five-year-old discovery of charge coupling has produced a tremendous growth of new devices, which shall be covered soon in a separate monograph presented as a supplement to this series. Weimer’s review is a detailed treatment of one aspect of this growing field. The technology of “doping” semiconductors has progressed considerably since the early days. A very interesting technique, permitting rather precise introduction of impurities, is discussed by S. Namba and K. Masuda in their article on “Ion Implantation in Semiconductors.” The method, which started as a laboratory operation, developed into an important industrial one, allowing large-scale production of semiconductor devices. Many important and interesting reviews are scheduled to appear in future volumes. The list on the next page indicates the contents of the volumes to come.
* L. C. Robinson, “Physical Principles of Far-Infrared Radiation,” Meth. Exp. Phys. (L. Marton and C. Marton, eds.), Vol. 10. Academic Press, New York, 1973. ix
x
FOREWORD
lntraband Magneto-Optical Studies of Semiconductors in the Far Infrared. 11 The Future Possibilities for Neural Control Charged Pigment Xerography The Impact o f Solid Statc Microwave Devices: A Preliminary Technology Assessment Signal and Noise Parameters of Microwave FET Advances in Molecular Beam Lasers Interpretation of Electron Microscope linagcs of Defects in Crystals Development of Charge Control Concept Energy Distribution of Electrons Emitted by a Thermionic Cathode Time Measurements on Radiation Detector Signals The Excitation and Ionization of Ions by Electron Impact Nonlinear Electron Acoustic Waves. 11 The Photovoltaic Effect Semiconductor Micro8ar.e Power Devices. 1 and IT Experimental Studies of Acoustic Waves in Plasmas Auger Electron Spectroscopy 11) S i r i r Electron Microscopy of Thin Films Afterglow Phenomena in Rare Gas Plasmas Between 0 and 300 K Physics and Tcchnologies of Polycrystaliine Si i n Semiconductor Devices Charged Particles as a Tool for Surface Research Electron Micrograph Analysis by Optical Transforms Electron Beam Microanalysis Electron Polarization in Solids X - R a j Imagc Intensifiers Eiectron Bombardment Semiconductor De\ ices Thermistors High Power Electronic Devices Atomic Photoelectron Spectroscopy Electron Spectroscopy for Chemical Analysis Laboratory Isotope Separators and Their Applications Recent Advances in Electron Bcam Addressed Memories Supplementary Volume: Charge Transfer De\ ices
B. D. McCombe and R. J. Wagner K . Pi-ank and F. T. Hanibrccht F. W. Schmidlin and M. E. Scharfe J . Frey and R. Bowers R. A. Haus, R. Pucel, and H. Statz D. C. Lame M. J. Whelan J. te Winkel W. Franzen and J . Porter S. Cova John W. Hoopcr and R. K. Fecney
R. G. Fowler Joseph J. Loferski S. Teszner and J. L. Teszner J. L. Hirschfield and J. M. Buzzi N. C. MacDonald and P. W. Palmberg A. Barna. P. B. Barna. J . P. Pbcia, and I. Pozsgai J. F. Delpech J. Kobayashi J . Vennik G. Donelli and L. Paoletti D. R. Beaman M. Canipagna, D. T. Pierce. K. Sattler, and H. C. Siegmann J. Houston D. .I.Bates G. H. Jonker G. Karady S. T. Manson D. Berenyi S. B. Karmohapatro J. Kelly C. H. Sequin and M. F. Tompsett
Throughout the years we have enjoyed the wholehearted cooperation of many friends. O u r warmest thanks go to them for the help they gave us. We would like to invite, as in the past. comments on the published volumes and suggestions for future ones. L. MAKTON CLAIRE MARTON
ADVANCES IN ELECTRONICS AND ELECTRON PHYSICS
VOLUME 37
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
Intraband Magneto-Optical Studies of Semiconductors in the Far Infrared. I BRUCE D. McCOMBE
AND
ROBERT J. WAGNER
N a d Research Luhorutory, Washingrun, D.C.
I. Introduction.. ........................................................................................... 11. Theoretical Background.. ............................................................................ A. Optical Properties ....................... ............... B. Quantum Theory of Free Electrons in a Magnetic Field .............................. C. Electron in a Periodic Pote : The Effective Mass Approximation ............... 111. Experimental Techniques ..... ................................................................ A. Sources and Spectrometers ..................................................................... B. Methods of Detection ........................................................................... IV. Free Carrier Resonances ........................................................................... A. Electron Cyclotron Resonance ..... ..................... ................ B. Spin-Flip Resonances ........................................................................... C. Hole Cyclotron Resonance ..................................................................... References.. ..............................................................................................
1 2 3 6 11
17 17 25
28 28 42 55 15
I. INTRODUCTION The experimental and theoretical determination of the electronic structure of semiconductors has been of considerable interest for a number of years. Optical and magneto-optical studies have proved extremely valuable in such investigations. The optical experiments divide naturally into two categories according to whether the transitions involve quantum states in only a single energy band, intraband transitions, or states in two bands, interband transitions. Due to the nature of the energy bands, effective masses, etc. and available magnetic fields, this natural division also carries over to the spectral region in which the two types of transitions are observed; interband transitions occur in the near infrared through the ultraviolet while intraband transitions occur typically in the far infrared (FIR) or microwave region. Although interband optical and magneto-optical measurements have provided a great deal of useful information (I, Z), intraband magneto-optical studies provide more detailed and precise information concerning effective masses and g-factors of both electrons and holes, impurity I
2
BRUCE D. MCCOMBE A N D ROBERT J. W A G N E R
states, and interactions among the single particle states and collective excitations such as phonons and plasmons. In recent years significant advances in FIR instrumentation have made possible the detailed investigation of a wealth of intraband phenomena with an attendant increase in information and understanding of the quantum electron (or hole) states and their interactions. This rapid evolution and expansion in knowledge indicates the need for an up-to-date in-depth review of this field.* On the one hand, it is important to understand what has been accomplished and what remains poorly understood; on the other hand, the rapid proliferation of experimental data has led to the publication of some misleading and/or erroneous results. In this article we present a review of the recent developments in intraband magneto-optics of semiconductors with emphasis on the above points. In order to achieve these aims it is necessary to ignore for the most part other useful experimental approaches and also similar studies of other material types, e.g. metals and insulators. In addition, we have made a number of subjective judgments concerning the material to be included and the method of presentation. For example, classical magnetoplasma effects are not discussed since these studies have been extensively reviewed by Palik and Furdyna (5). Finally, although the title delineates a rather precise spectral region (the FIR is usually defined to be between 50 and 1000 pm), in the interest of clarity and cohesiveness we have overstepped these spectral boundaries in several instances. The rationale for these judgments will be apparent in the discussion of experimental results. This review will be divided into two parts. The first part, presented here, treats both theoretical and experimental investigations of free carrier magneto-optical transitions in semiconductors. In addition, a brief section on experimental techniques is included in this part. Part 11, to be published in the next issue of this series, will discuss bound carrier magneto-optical studies and the interactions of both bound and free carriers with collective excitations, e.g. phonons and plasmons.
BACKGROUND 11. THEORETICAL In order to obtain information about the electronic states of semiconductors, one must be able to relate the macroscopic information provided by experiments, e.g. the sample transmission or reflection versus magnetic field, to the microscopic states and optical transition probabilities of the charged particles under investigation. In this section we present a brief description of * F o r a review of early, primarily microwave, intraband studies, the reader is relerred to Lax and Mavroides ( 3 ) . A recent review of magneto-optical experiments in general by Mavroides ( 4 ) has some information concerning the subject of this present work.
INTRABAND MAGNETO-OPTICAL STUDIES OF SEMICONDUCTORS. I
3
the macroscopic optical properties of solids, proceeding from Maxwell’s equations, and we then show how these are related to the microscopic energy levels, wavefunctions, and transition probabilities. We also present a quantum mechanical discussion of the motion of a nonrelativistic electron in the presence of a uniform external magnetic field. This discussion is initially confined to free electrons, and then the necessary generalization to include the effects of the periodic array of ions in a crystalline solid is sketched. The nature of the energy levels and the selection rules for electromagnetic (EM) transitions (cyclotron resonance and spin resonance) are discussed in some detail. This provides a sound basis for the examination of the various experiments and the extensions of theory necessary to include the effects of impurities, more complicated energy bands, and the interactions of electrons (or holes) with other elementary excitations (e.g. phonons and plasmons) in semiconduct ors. A . Optical Properties
For a continuous isotropic medium characterized by a real conductivity, and a real dielectric constant, c R ,the following wave equation is obtained from Maxwell’s equations in unrationalized Gaussian units :
(T,
Here E‘ is the electric field vector of the EM radiation, c is the velocity of light in free space, and the magnetic permeability has been set equal to unity since only nonmagnetic or weakly magnetic materials are considered. In an anisotropic medium or in the presence of a magnetic field the tensor character of (T or cR serves to couple the different vector field components. However, for the purposes of exposition and in the interest of simpler notation it is sufficient to consider the isotropic case where (T and cR may be viewed as scalars. The equations are easily generalized when the tensor character must be made manifest. For propagation in the z-direction a solution of Eq. (1) for transverse waves is given by E’ = Eb exp i(mt - K z ) where
Here K is the complex propagation wavevector, o is the angular frequency, and u is the phase velocity of the wave in the medium.
4
BRUCE D. MCCOMBE A N D ROBERT J. WAGNER
A complex refractive index may be defined by ti
- iti' = cKJcu,
(3)
where K2
-
2 1 ~= ~ '471010.
/('2 -F ~ :
It is frequently desirable to describe the optical properties in terms of a complex dielectric function, E = eR + iE, defined by I-: = (ti
-
(4)
iK')2
with
c,
=
(5)
21t-h-'.
With these relationships the electric field of the wave may be written
E' = Eb exp ( - W K ' Z / C ) exp iw(t - t i z / c ) ; hence the amplitude of the wave is attenuated exponentially with an attenuation constant o t i ' / c . Experimentally the quantity of interest is the attenuation of power or intensity rather than amplitude. The ratio of the intensity, 1, at a distance z to the initial intensity 1, is I/l,
=
exp ( - 2 w t i ' z / c )
=
exp ( - q,z).
(6)
The absorption coefficient, M , , has the significance that the intensity falls to lie of its initial value in a distance l/xn. The single surface power reflectivity, R, between the medium and vacuum for normal incidence may be written in terms of the real and imaginary parts of the index of refraction
A=
(ti - 1 ) 2
(ti
+
1)2-+
+ tif2 KZ
'
(7)
and the transmission through a thickness d of the medium assuming ti' <
ti
1s
The various relationships for the macroscopic optical properties ( R , T', cq, , ti, etc.) must now be related to the microscopic properties of the system
under investigation. The total Hamiltonian of a system consisting of charged
INTRABAND MAGNETO-OPTICAL STUDIES OF SEMICONDUCTORS. I
5
particles plus radiation can be written as
1 (9)
where A‘ and cp’ are the vector and scalar potential of the radiation field respectively, e is the magnitude of the electronic charge, and the momentum operator p = -ihV. The electric and magnetic fields of the EM wave are given by E’ = - V p ’ - (l/’c)(ZA’/dt) and B’ = V x A‘ in terms of these potentials. In this treatment the particles are treated quantum mechanically and the EM field semiclassically. The radiation field could also be quantized and written in terms of creation and annihilation operators for photons. The result for the transition rate between unperturbed levels of the system of charged particles is the same in both cases. If a gauge is chosen such that V - A ’ = 0 and
p‘ = 0,
the interaction term between the EM field and the particles is found to be given by
The transition probability per unit time from state j’ to state j of the unperturbed particle Hamiltonian is obtained in second-order perturbation theory as
where
q;: = d X y v x i ” t Y y= ( j
I .wintI ,?),
Y j is the wavefunction of the unperturbed state, and dx
= dx d y dz. If A‘ is taken to be a simple harmonic field of amplitude Ah and polarization vector the transition rate is given in the dipole approximation by
p,
w . . ,= jJ
-
2ne2At I [t . p].., J J 12 qcl, h2 &c2
(0. J - cl,.,)]. J
The power absorption coefficient, c t 0 , for this transition is simply the power absorbed per unit volume divided by the energy flux (power/area) in the wave. Hence to obtain a o , w j j , is multiplied by the photon energy per transition and divided by the volume times the time-averaged Poynting
6
BRUCE D. MCCOMBE A N D ROBERT J. WAGNER
vector. With the occupation factors for initial and final states and the correction for stimulated emission included, a, is given by
Here j i is the probability that state ,j is occupied, Q is the volume, and the sum goes over all initial and final states of the system which satisfy energy conservation. The b-function in Eq. (12a) implies statesj andj' that are infinitely sharp. In practice the energy states are broadened to some degree. This may be taken into account by replacing the &function with a normalized broadening function usually of Lorentzian form, i.e.
( 12b) where ;represents a phenomenological broadening constant.
B. Quantum Theory of'Free Electrons in a Magnetic Field 1. Eizeryy Leuels
We consider a single electron of mass mo confined in a cubic box of sides Lo and volume R = L:. (The intrinsic electron spin is neglected for the present for simplicity. It is easily included at a later point.) The electron is subjected to a uniform dc magnetic field of induction B in the presence of an EM disturbance of frequency to. The vector and scalar potentials of the harmonic EM disturbance are A' and cp' as in Section II,A, and the same gauge is chosen. The dc magnetic induction is taken parallel to the z-axis with vector potential *
A
=
( -+BJ,~ B x0). ,
Under these conditions the Hamiltonian for a single electron is given by
F
=
2mo j p + ' A C +eAr)2. C
"This gauge (the symmetric gauge) IS particularly useful in probiding a clear picture of the ph)sics iinderlying the energy levels and the section rules for E M transitions [see. e.g.. Dicke and Wittke (6) and Johnson and Lippmann (7)]. It is also convenient for discussing the hydrogenic impurity states in a magnetic field to be considered in a later section. Another. more commonly used gauge, is the Landau gauge ( 8 ) A = ( - BJ,0. 0).
INTRABAND MAGNETO-OPTICAL STUDIES OF SEMICONDUCTORS. I
7
where the fact that the electronic charge is negative has been used. Neglecting terms of order A”, we may write
X o = - - 1( p 2 + 2m0
2e
v
+ eA/c)
C
and
In Eq. (14b) =X =
(l/mO)(p
P/mo .
Explicitly making use of the symmetric gauge, we have No =
1 ~
2m0
(p:
+ p?) +
(2+ y’) +
eB --L, 2mo c
+
Pt 2m0
___
where L, = ( x p y - y p x ) = z-component of the total orbital angular momentum. The first two terms of Eq. (15) represent the Hamiltonian for a twodimensional simple harmonic oscillator. It is easily shown that p,, YFsH0, and L, are three independent mutually commuting operators ; hence eigenfunctions may be chosen which are simultaneous eigenfunctions of all three. The energy can thus be separated into three parts: (1) the energy associated with motion in the z-direction, which is unchanged by the presence of the magnetic field; ( 2 ) the energy associated with motion in the x- and ydirections, which is the sum of energies of two linear simple harmonic oscillators of frequency 0,,/2 = eB/2mo c, where o,,is the cyclotron frequency; and (3) the energy associated with the operator L, , the angular momentum about the magnetic field. The wavefunctions may be written schematically as*
*The symbol k,, is taken to be the electron wavevector along the magnetic field, i.e. the eigenvalue of p,/h in this case.
8
BRUCE D. MCCOMBE AND ROBERT J. WAGNER
where the three quantum numbers are defined by the eigenvalue equations
Thus the total energy eigenvalue is given by
where 17,
20
and
M,2
-in,
2 -x.
From parity considerations it may be shown that no and in, are either both even or both odd integers. Hence the more commonly used “Landau” quantum number, 11, may be defined by no
+ i n 1 = 2n 2 0,
and the wavefunctions specified equivalently by familiar form for the energy levels is obtained,
(21)
1 iz, in, , k H ) . Thus the more
Equation (22) for the energy levels is found directly if one uses the Landau gauge for A; however, the physics of the EM transitions among these levels is much more clearly seen in the symmetric gauge. A useful energy level diagram which shows the relationship among the three quantum numbers n, n o , and m, is given in Fig. 1 for kH = const. Since for any value of M there are a large number of combinations of no and m, which satisfy Eq. (21) (an infinite number for nz, -+ m) each energy state specified by n and kH in Eq. (22)is highly degenerate, as is indicated in Fig. 1. Thus far the intrinsic electron spin, s, has been omitted from the discussion. The effect of including spin is easily found by adding a term
INTRABAND MAGNETO-OPTICAL STUDIES OF SEMICONDUCTORS. I
-
n= 5 -
-
-
/
/
0
2
I
-,
/ -
/
3
9
4
5
p = n-ml= %-n
FIG. I . Schematic energy level diagram showing the relationship among the various quantum numbers described in the text. Typical cyclotron resonance transitions are indicated by the bold vertical arrows. The parity of the state is odd when both no and 111, are odd, and even when both no and m, are even. Each cyclotron resonance transition satisfies the selection rule for parity (An = odd) and for the z-component of angular momentum (Am, = + I).
to X o[Eq. (15)]. Since s commutes with all other operators of the Hamiltonian, the total wavefunction may be written as a simple product wavefunction
k , m,> = I m, k H ) I m,>, where Im,) is a two component spinor. The spin operators are 2 x 2 matrices which may be written in terms of the Pauli spin matrices as
I fi, m,
I
3
3
s
=
(h/2)o
with 0 1
1 0
0 -i
The energy eigenvalues of spin are Emv =
eh - Bm, m0 C
=
msgpBB,
where pB = I eh/2mo c I is the Bohr magneton, y is the electron g-value (= 2), and m, = k 1/2 is the spin quantum number. (The spin quantum number m, = +1/2 for the z-component of spin parallel to B, and ms = - 1/2 for the z-component of spin antiparallel to B.) Hence the total
10
BRUCE D. MCCOMBE A N D ROBERT J. WAGNER
electron energy is
The energy levels including spin are thus described by two sets of parabolas as a function of k,, one for spin parallel and one for spin antiparallel to the magnetic field. For a given n, the energy displacement between the two sets is gpBB, the spin energy, while for a given s, the energy displacement between adjacent levels within a set is ~ c J J the ~ ~ cyclotron . energy. 2. Optical Transitioi? urid Selrctioii Rules ci. Electric-dipole iiiteraction. The EM selection rules are most easily obtained from a consideration of the *' raising" and "lowering" operators for Landau levels, at and u, defined by
u' with
d =
=
[ P x + iP,]/h(Za)' l ; a
=
[P,
-
iP,]/h(2a)'/2
(28)
eB/hc. These operators have the following commutation rules
[a, u + ] = (aa'
-
a+a) =
I ;[n , u']
=
hco,at
;[ X
, a] = hcoc, a.
It is easily established that
I I?, 111, , k , , m,) a 1 11, 117, , k, , m,)
ut
= (I7 = 17'
+1
y I It
+ 1, + 1, k,
I 17 - 1, I T Z ~
112,
-
1, k , , tn,),
, n1J, (29)
that is, operation on an eigenfunction by at(.) yields a new eigenfunction with both n and i i i l increased (decreased) by unity. This corresponds to a vertical transition between adjacent levels on Fig. 1. Since in the presence of an external magnetic field the radiation interaction term is proportional to P (rather than p) [Eq. (14b)], the transition probability is proportional to matrix elements of P. For a circularly polarized wave propagating parallel to the z-axis the relevant quantities are P' = P, & iP,. . The operators P' can be rewritten in terms of at and u in order to obtain the selection rules from Eq. (29). For left circular polarization" (P' ) the selection rules are:
A I I=
+ I,
A I I I= ,
+ 1,
AUI,\= 0,
(30)
* In the circular polarization convention used here left circular polarization corresponds t o counterclockwise rotation of thc electric field vector of the wave 111 time when the wave is vie\\ed head on by an observer. i.e. with the magnetic field vector pointing or the observer [see. e.g.. Klein (9): this is a useful reference for general macroscopic optical properties]. To avoid an? possihle confusion over conventions, howcvcr, it is simpler to refer to cyclotron resonance active ( C R A ) and cyclotron resonance inactive (CRI) senses of circular polarization for electron,. This terminology will be used throughout the remainder of the article. For conipariwn. in
11
INTRABAND MAGNETO-OPTICAL STUDIES OF SEMICONDUCTORS. I
and for right circular polarization ( P - )
0. (31) Since the linear momentum of the FIR photon is typically small, conservation of momentum yields AkH z 0. These selection rules have a simple physical interpretation in terms of conservation of parity and z-component of angular momentum (in,). h. Muynetic-dipole interaction. The interaction of the spin angular momentum with the EM radiation is taken into account by adding a term An
= - 1,
Ant, =
-
1,
Am,
=
to the particle-radiation interaction Hamiltonian, Eq. (14b), where ;7 is a unit vector along B' and B, = I B 1. The optical magnetic induction, B , is polarized perpendicular to E' (and A') for linear polarizations; the sense of circular polarization is the same for B' and E'. This term can be treated in the same way as the equivalent term for electric-dipole interaction, and the transition probability is proportional to the square of matrix elements of fi . s. For circularly polarized radiation the quantities of interest are .s* = s, is,. It is easily shown that .s' are raising and lowering operators for the zcomponent of spin. Hence, the selection rules for CRA circular polarization are
A I ~=, 0, and for CRI circular polarization An
=
0,
A11
=
0,
AIR,= 0,
Ams = - 1,
(33)
+ 1.
(34)
Am5 =
This result again derives physically from conservation of the zcomponent of angular momentum. From conservation of linear momentum we have the additional condition AkH z 0. C. Electron in a Periodic Potential: The E f f c t i v e Mass Approximation 1. Eliergy Letlels
In the absence of spin and any external perturbations the solutions of the Schrodinger equation for an electron placed in the periodic potential, V(x), of a crystal lattice are given in terms of Bloch functions [see, e.g., Kittel (lo)] by yk(x) = eik'ylfk(x), (35) the above convention left circular polarization is CRA and right circular polarization is CRI for electrons.
12
BRUCE D. MCCOMBE AND ROBERT J. WAGNER
where uk(x) is a function with the periodicity of the lattice (cell periodic function) and k is the wavevector (hk is the crystal momentum). Substitution of the Bloch functions for band r into the Schrodinger equation yields an equation for the cell periodic functions of the form
x, =
h2k2 p2 + - + V(x), 2m0 2m,
and
For small k around a band extremum, taken to be k = 0 for simplicity, Zk. may be treated as a perturbation. The energy is given to order k2 as
and
with R, the volume of a unit cell, u,, the band edge (k = 0) cell periodic functions, and E,(O) the energy of band r at k = 0. Here, (2m0/h2)@ is the reciprocal effective mass tensor for band r, and 6,, is the Kronecker delta. In the presence of an external magnetic field and the crystal potential, a more realistic Hamiltonian for a single electron including spin and the spinorbit interaction is given by X =
P2 ~
2m,
+ V(X) + 4mih c2 - V V ( X ) x P + ~~
e
(r
m, c
B
S.
(38)
It is easily shown that with spin-orbit interaction the velocity operator becomes P
h
INTRABAND MAGNETO-OPTICAL STUDIES OF SEMICONDUCTORS. I
13
Generally this correction to P is small and it will be neglected in what follows. The inclusion of an external magnetic field presents some difficulty because the unperturbed wavefunctions (Bloch functions) extend throughout the crystal. Thus the effects on the Bloch functions cannot be considered small, even though on an atomic scale of energies the magnetic field energy is certainly small. Luttinger and Kohn (LK) (11) solved this problem by recognizing that if the electrons of interest occupy a small region of k-space a b u t some k where the energy is an extremum (taken to be k = 0 for simplicity) a perturbation treatment in powers of the wavevector about k = 0 could still be used to approximate the Hamiltonian. A suitable complete orthonormal set of basis functions (LK functions) in this case is (39) Hence the solutions of the Sclirodinger equation %'" = E", where .Pis the Hamiltonian of Eq. (38), may be expanded in the LK functions with expansion coefficients Ar(k) x r , k,
in,(.)
=
etk ' x L 1 r0. . in,(.)-
here the spin index has been included in the band index, r . An eigenvalue equation for Ar(k) is found in the form
i
1
dk' dxeik'X.#'r,,eik"XAr(k')
=
EAr(k),
(41)
1st
Brill. w n e
where the Hamiltonian matrix (12, 13) is given by
Here, h& = P^ = p" + eA,/c, the 1, are the direction cosines of the magnetic field, the difference between Paand pa is neglected in the matrix element, and repeated Greek indices are summed over. With the introduction of the Fourier transform of Ar(k), Fr(x)=
1
eik'"Ar(k)dk,
1 s t B.z.
and the assumption that both the vector potential and F,(x) are slowly varying over a unit cell, an infinite set of coupled equations in real space can
14
B R U C F D. MCCOMRF 4 N D RORFRT J. WAGNFR
be obtained
In this equation the F,(x) are the real space “envelope” functions. The total wavefunction is given by Y
c F,.(x)u,,o(x).
=
(44)
).’
The problem now is to remove the off-diagonal terms in the band index and obtain an “effective” Hamiltonian for a single band as was done in the zero field case. Luttinger and Kohn utilized a series of unitary transformations to accomplish this, and thereby obtained a transformed effective Hamiltonian and transformed wavefunctions. To second order they found an effective mass equation in real space for a simple, nondegenerate (except for spin) band given by [D:,!P, P, -tpB Bib,o;.]F,.(x)= ( E , - E,(O))F,(x),
(45)
where the total wavefunction for band r is given in lowest order by
(46)
Y,.@)2 F,(X)&*(X).
The “effective.’ Hamiltonian for a single band can be rewritten as .Y?
eff
=
Dg’{P, , Pal + D;O[P, , PSI
+ /lB B?,,cJ;,,
(47)
where the band index has been dropped to simplify notation. The terms have been separated into symmetric (S) and antisymmetric (A) parts to take account of the fact that the P,’s do not commute in general. This lack of commutativity can lead to some important differences in the energy levels and selection rules when compared to the free electron case as we shall see below. In Eq. (47) ; P I , P,)
and Dc”
+ P, P, .
= P, P,
=
i(D:B
PA’= i(DZ,!
+ Dff), -
D!,?).
I n order to compare directly with the free electron discussion, we specialize to the case of a cubic semiconductor having inversion symmetry and take the Cartesian axes along the cube axes with the magnetic field in the :-direction. For this case (14) Dgfl = 0:: 6,, ,
DY
= -Dpz
A.
INTRABAND MAGNETO-OPTICAL STUDIES OF SEMICONDUCTORS. I
15
and we have
It can also be shown that
where
The expectation values of [L,],.,for the two different spin states of band r (i.e. m, = 112 and m, = - 1/2) are equal in magnitude and opposite in sign. Hence [L,Jr,contributes to the effective spin magnetic moment of band r ; thus we may write
+
Y l eff =
D;:p, p ,
+ Y*VB
(Jz
B,
(48)
where g*
=
2(1
+ [L,],,).
(49)
The effective y-factor, g*, can be either positive or negative since [I,,],, can be large in magnitude and positive or negative. Thus the noncommutativity of the P,’s in a magnetic field may lead to an additional contribution to the spin magnetic moment and an effective y-factor which, in some cases, can be extremely large. This additional contribution vanishes in the absence of spin-orbit interaction. The effective Hamiltonian, Eq. (48), is identical to the free electron Hamiltonian with the free mass and g-factor replaced by the effective mass and effective g-factor. Hence the energy levels and wavefunctions can be found by simply taking the free electron energy levels and wavefunctions and making the appropriate substitutions. Although the simple effective mass Hamiltonian for a single band is not adequate to provide a quantitative description of the electronic states in all semiconductors, it does give a good qualitative picture for nondegenerate bands in most materials. This approach also yields quite good results for the problem of hydrogenic impurities discussed in Section V,A, and, with a minor extension, it gives a reasonable picture of the magnetic field states for the degenerate valence bands in diamond and zinc blende semiconductors. In addition, the basic theoretical development [through Eq. (43)] provides the basis for more extensive and detailed calculations which are sometimes necessary for a quantitative description. (See Sections IV,A,1 and IV,C,l.)
16
BRUCE D. MCCOMBE A N D ROBERT J. WAGNER
2. Matrix Elements The matrix element for electric dipole transitions between states 'Piand Y f is given in lowest order by
In the effective mass approximation with the zero-order wavefunctions of Eq. (39) this reduces to
c%
[Z.
PIif
.j.
dXFT(X)Fi(X)
crystal
unit cell
crystal
where
[ Z f PI,/
1 dxu$,(x)[?. p]u,,(x).
=
szo
";I1
cell
The first term of Eq. (50) is referred to as the interband term and the second is referred to as the intraband term. In the simple effective mass case under consideration, this separation is well defined ; thus we are concerned only with the second term. In the absence of spin-orbit interaction, the envelope functions Fi may be written in a form identical to the free electron functions of Section I1,B. Hence the selection rules are given by the free electron selection rules. Eqs. (30) and (31). A similar treatment may be carried through for magnetic-dipole interaction and the selection rules are again given by Eqs. (33) and (34). For a typical case of electrons in a crystal where there is nonzero spinorbit interaction, the situation is more complicated. In this case the antisymmetric term in the effective Hamiltonian can mix the spin and orbital parts of the wavefunctions as noted in the previous section. It follows that, even for a '' simple " band, electricdipole transitions involving a change in spin quantum number (and conversely magnetic-dipole transitions involving a change in Landau quantum number), can become weakly allowed. Such transitions are discussed in Section IV,B. In the case of several strongly interacting bands the lowest order
INTRABAND MAGNETO-OPTICAL STUDIES OF SEMICONDUCTORS. I
17
wavefunctions for a given band are, in general, composed of a mixture of products of band edge functions and envelope functions from all the interacting bands (15). In this case, a division into “ interband and “ intraband parts is no longer as useful, since both types of terms can contribute to the experimentally observed intraband transition (16). ”
”
111. EXPERIMENTAL TECHNIQUES Since much of the recent progress in semiconductor magneto-optical studies in the FIR has been a direct result of advances in experimental techniques, we include here a brief description of FIR methods. The intent of the present section is not to provide a detailed description of all the FIR instrumentation and equipment presently in use in the laboratory, but rather to give a short overview, comparing a number of the commonly used systems and pointing out their advantages and disadvantages. This allows the ensuing sections which are concerned with experimental studies of the physics of various magneto-optical effects to be relatively free of comments on experimental technique. For the reader interested in a more detailed description a number of excellent articles exist [see, e.g., Robinson (17), Houghton and Smith (It?), Chantry (19),and Moller and Rothschild (20)].In part A, the advantages and disadvantages of various FIR sources and spectrometers are discussed, and in part B, a number of devices and schemes for detecting FIR radiation are described and compared.
A . Sources and Spectrometers
Although FIR magnetospectroscopy has a long history ( 2 1 ) it has only recently become a popular experimental technique. This has been primarily due to the lack of radiant power available from classical, hot bodies in this spectral region. For example, an “ideal” blackbody of area 1 cm2 at a temperature of 2000°K provides less than 200 pW in the total spectrum of wavelengths longer than 50 pm with f l 3 optics. In contrast, FIR lasers now provide more power than this in many of the large number ( z 300) of lines a-Jailable in this region. Nonetheless, classical sources are still useful since they radiate continuously throughout the infrared, whereas a continuously tunable laser over any significant range in the FIR has not yet been achieved * *At present, a number of approaches to continuously tunable FIR laser radiation are under active laboratory investigation (22a-e); however, as of this writing a practical source for spectroscopy is not available.
18
BRUCE D. MCCOMBE AND ROBERT J . WAGNER
1. Grating Spectrometers
Historically, the first technique used in FIR magneto-optical studies of semiconductors was a classical source in conjunction with a monochromator. At its simplest, the monochromator consists of a prism or grating which disperses the radiation spatially with a slit (or slits) selecting a suitable small portion of the spectrum for the intended experiment. The obvious limitation of this procedure is that increased wavelength selectivity (resolution) brings with it a concomitant decrease in the amount of radiation in the selected wavelength increment. In practice, beyond 50 pm wavelength, only gratings are used since no adequate transparent dispersive materials exist. The use of gratings involves an additional complication since the radiation dispersed at a selected angle consists not only of the wavelength desired, but also higher orders (shorter wavelength submultiples A/2, A/3, etc.). Classical blackbodies such as a hot S i c rod or “globar” produce these higher order wavelengths with much greater intensity than the fundamental wavelength. A somewhat more useful source in the FIR is the “high pressure” (1-2 atm) Hg-arc. This source radiates much less than an equivalent black body in the near infrared since, in this region, the intensity is due to a continuum radiation resulting from electron-neutral atom collisions in the plasma. At longer wavelengths the plasma becomes self-absorbing, and the radiation spectrum approaches that of a blackbody at the plasma temperature (= 6000°K). In spite of this intensity reduction at higher frequencies, low (frequency) pass filters are still required to eliminate the unwanted higher orders. Although there are rather sophisticated filters in use (these range from transmission filters, such as capacitive metal meshes and crystal powder suspensions, to reflection filters, such as gratings and inductive metal meshes (23)) they are still somewhat lossy and thus reduce the power available. Consequently, monochromators are designed to collect a large solid angle of the radiant flux by using smallf-number optics. This necessitates the use of very large gratings and mirrors; and as a result, such spectrometers are large and bulky. Generally, these spectrometers are flushed carefully with dry air or evacuated in order to eliminate atmospheric absorption bands which occur throughout much of the FIR. In the latter case, the spectrometer is generally enclosed in a large cylindrical tank to withstand the resulting pressure difference. A grating spectrometer system designed for use in semiconductor, magneto-optical studies is shown in Fig. 2. Although many experiments can be performed by sweeping magnetic field with a fixed wavelength radiation incident on the specimen, it is frequently desirable to sweep the wavelength at fixed magnetic field. The latter is usually more difficult because the radiation intensity varies due to
INTRABAND MAGNETO-OPTICAL STUDIES OF SEMICONDUCTORS. I
19
FIG.2. A sophisticated FIR grating spectrometer system designed by D. Dickey. Here B is the Hg-arc source, G is a 7.5 x 8 in. grating. and the detector is located either at W (transmission experiment) or W' (reflection experiment). [From Johnson and Dickey (42).]
wavelength dependence of source intensity, filter response, detector response, and nionochromator throughput, in addition to possible atmospheric absorption bands. Thus it is necessary to remove the background variation by some means. This is usually accomplished by recording a spectrum with magnetic field on, and then a spectrum with field off, and dividing the two. Such a procedure has the additional advantage of removing field independent variations in the transmission of the sample itself. However, this advantage is obtained at the expense of doubling the noise and the requirements for system stability. In spite of the difficulties mentioned above it is possible with grating spectrometers to achieve a resolution of about 0.1 cmbetween 30 and 60 cm-' (24). 2. Fourier Transform Spectrometers
The ready availability of high speed digital computers has brought the technique of Fourier Transform Spectroscopy (FTS) into widespread use*
* For
an extensive and up-to-date general reference to this subject see Bell (25).
20
BRUCE D. MCCOMBE AND ROBERT J. WAGNER
Due to the development of Fast Fourier Transform computation methods (26) and “mini” computers with sufficient speed and storage capability, this technique has evolved to the stage where it can be utilized even in laboratories where a large digital computation facility is not available. The FT spectrometer includes an interferometer which can be of the Michelson or Lamellar type, associated source, detector, signal processing electronics, and some means of calculating the Fourier transform of the interferogram. The interferometer itself consists of collimating optics, some means of dividing the source beam (a beamsplitter in the case of the Michelson interferometer, and large interleaved gratings for the Lamellar interferometer), and a drive unit to vary the path difference between the two beams. At present, a number of interferometers and complete Fourier Transform spectrometers are available commercially. A commercial Michelson interferometer is shown schematically in Fig. 3. The basic operating principle of these systems can be stated simply as follows: the interference pattern of a two beam interferometer obtained as a function of the path difference, x, between the two beams is the Fourier transform of the spectrum of the light passing through the interferometer. For a monochromatic source the interference pattern is a simple cosine function, and the intensity reaching the detector may be written as “
”
9(X)
= S[ 1
+ cos (2713X)],
(52) where 3 is the frequency of the monochromatic source in inverse centimeters, S = 0/27cc. If there is some spectral distribution of radiation from the source, S(il), then by simple extension of Eq. (52),the intensity at the detector will be given by Y(,)
=
1
1
d?S(G)[l + cos
(27LGX)]
‘ 0 s^
= +Y(O)
+ ’(.0
dSS(3) cos (271ijx),
(53)
where Y ( 0 ) is the intensity for zero path difference. Since Y ( x )is an even function of x, one may use the Fourier cosine transform to obtain the spectrum of the radiation reaching the detector: S(C) = 4
I’
1
L/S[;jY(X)
- +
(276x).
(54)
‘ 0
This is the basic equation of Fourier transform spectroscopy (FTS). In practice, of course, infinite path difference cannot be obtained, and the interferogram must be terminated at some maximum value of path difference, x,, . This sharp cutoff can produce artificial, and undesirable, sidebands on
INTRABAND MAGNETO-OPTICAL STUDIES OF SEMICONDUCTORS. I
21
M
d
-
d
wc 0
L
a 0
L
d
m
i;l
22
BRUCE D. MCCOMBE A N D ROBERT J . WAGNER
narrow line structure in the spectrum; hence the sharp cutoff is generally removed in the computed spectrum by a technique called apodization,” i.e. multiplying the interferogram by a function which smoothly goes to zero. This removes the sidebands at the cost of reduced resolution. (The resolution is approximately given by A? z 1/xmax.) In addition, the sampling interval cannot be made infinitesimal, and data must be taken at discrete values of path difference such that N Ax = x,, ,where Ax is the sampling interval and N‘ is the number of samples. From information theory, it can be shown that Ax must be chosen such that Ax 5 1/2tmaX where is the maximum frequency of interest. With these limitations the desired spectrum is easily obtained by digital techniques from Eq. (54) after converting the integral to an appropriate sum. The primary disadvantage of this technique is the requirement of fairly complicated computer processing of the data as obtained from the instrument (the interferogram). This means that there is usually a significant time delay before the data can be seen in the desired, interpretable form (the spectrum). However, through the use of small “mini” computers, this processing can now be done essentially on line in the laboratory and the spectrum obtained almost immediately. In any case, this disadvantage is more than offset by two advantages which are obtained with FTS. The first of these is the increased throughput of the F T spectrometer as compared to a grating spectrometer. Since the grating monochromator uses slits, it is essentially a one-dimensional instrument. The interferometer, on the other hand, is a two-dimensional instrument and thus possesses an inherent advantage in terms of throughput. In addition, the filtering requirements are somewhat less restrictive for the FT spectrometer; this also increases the amount of power available. The second advantage of FTS is the so-called multiplex or Fellgett advantage (27).The grating spectrometer is a sequential instrument which “sees” only one spectral element at a time at the detector. On the other hand, the FT spectrometer simultaneously sees all spectral elements throughout the measurement with a single detector (hence the term multiplex), and the spectrum is unraveled later by taking the Fourier transform of the observed interferogram. The advantage is obtained from the fact that the integrated signal is proportional to t, the time available for the measurement, whereas the noise, being random, is proportipnal to t ’ l 2 . In the sequential system with In spectral elements there is a time Tpiz available for each element, where T is the total time for the measurement; hence the signal to noise is proportional to (T/m)’/’. In the simultaneous system with the same total measurement time, there is a tlme T available for every spectral element and the signal to noise is proportional to T’ ‘. Thus for a constant measurement time there is an improvement in signal to noise for the FTS “
“
”
INTRABAND MAGNETO-OPTICAL STUDIES OF SEMICONDUCTORS. I
23
system which is proportional to wz1I2. Alternatively, for a constant signal to noise the number of spectral elements (resolution) can be improved, or the time required to take the data can be reduced in the FT spectrometer compared with the grating spectrometer. The actual improvement in performance from the Fellgett and throughput advantages depends to some extent on a number of external parameters such as detector response and size, spectral region to be investigated, source, particular experiment, etc. However, it is safe to say that FTS is more advantageous for high resolution studies of large spectral regions in the FIR. The best interferometer resolution obtained in solid state studies appears to be 0.035 cm-' (28). The question of the best technique for specific experiments is often a matter of dispute and the choice depends to a large extent on the background and prejudices of the experimenter. Because of the nature of the technique, experiments must be done at a fixed magnetic field. As in the case with the grating spectrometer, source intensity, detector sensitivity, etc. may vary with wavelength, and again this makes it necessary to obtain background data (field off) with which to normalize the sample data. Although wavelength-dependent spectroscopy is generally less convenient than magnetic-field-dependent spectroscopy, one important advantage should be mentioned. Some magneto-optical phenomena have only a very weak field dependence; in such cases, studies in which the wavelength is varied give unambiguous results. In contrast, studies in which the field is varied can overlook or distort important structure.
3. F I R Laser Sources The discovery of FIR laser action in a large'number of gases" has provided the newest practical device for magneto-optic studies. Hundreds of intense, monochromatic laser lines constitute ideal sources for magnetic field dependent studies. The use of the laser in magneto-optics is probably the simplest of the experimental techniques described here. Essentially, the laser replaces the classical source-monochromator. While it is not appropriate to fully describe the various FIR lasers here, some of their characteristics which are relevant to magnetospectroscopy will be enumerated. Laser action takes place in a large Fabry-Perot cavity, typically 3-4 in. diameter and 6-15 ft long. The flowing low pressure gas of 0.1-2 mm Hg of HCN, H,O, D20, CH30H, CH3CN, etc. is contained in a glass or metal * For a tabulation of lines reported prior to 1971, see Pressley (2%). For more recently reported lines, see Chang and McCee (2Yb),Fetterman et ul. ( ~ Y c )Dyubko , et al. (294, Wagner ef al. (ZYe), Plant et ul. (29f), and Hodges er a/. (299).
24
BRUCE D. MCCOMBE AND ROBERT J. WAGNER
tube of 3-4 in. diameter with length equal to the Fabry-Perot cavity length. Population inversion occurs either through a high voltage discharge in the tube or by optical excitation with a near-infrared (CO,) laser. Both the discharge technique and the optically-pumped technique can be either continuous or pulsed. Each of the four possible variations has its advantages and disadvantages, depending on the needs of the experimenter for intensity, stability, and number of lasing lines. For example, while pulsed lasers typically produce many more lines than continuous lasers, they suffer from
SUPERCONDUCTING
INTEGRATOR
RATIO
€23 RECORDER
FIG.4. Schematic diagram of a pulsed FIR laser spectrometer used for magneto-optical studies of solids. Wavy lines indicate laser radiation. Boxcar” integration and electronic ratiometry are used in this system to reduce pulse-to-pulse instabilities and drift. [From Wagner and Prinz (30).] ‘I
pulse-to-pulse instabilities which are a source of noise. This problem can be overcome by utilizing averaging and ratio techniques. Such a pulsed F I R laser system used for magnetospectroscopy is shown schematically in Fig. 4. Practically, the resolution which can be obtained from this laser used in conjunction with a high homogeneity superconducting magnet is better than 0.01 cm- (30). FIR lasers are ideal for investigating selected spectral features which cannot be resolved through the use of the interferometer or for studying
INTRABAND MAGNETO-OPTICAL STUDIES OF SEMICONDUCTORS. I
25
magnetic field dependent absorption lines in the presence of strong background absorption or reflection, i s . in essentially opaque samples. Thus the FIR laser system and the FT spectrometer approach can be viewed as complementary techniques in the study of magneto-optical phenomena.
4. Light Pipes While focusing optical components can be used to direct the FIR radiation from source to sample to detector, more frequently light pipe techniques are utilized. It has been shown (31) that the transmission of FIR radiation through metal (brass, copper or stainless steel) tubes can be accomplished with moderate loss. Light pipes are easily purged or evacuated; thus energy loss due to strong atmospheric absorption is avoided. In addition, they are particularly convenient for use in cryogenic dewars and for magnetic field experiments where space is limited. On the other hand, the difference in reflectivity for E parallel and E perpendicular to the light pipe wall can lead to strong polarizing effects. These effects must be carefully considered when interpreting certain experimental results.
B. Methods of Detection * Frequently, the selection of the proper detector is as important to the success of an experiment as the selection of the radiation source/ spectrometer. The invention of sensitive new detectors during the last decade has contributed to the rapid increase in FIR magneto-optics. 1. Rooni Temperature Detectors
Prior to 1960, there existed only two reliable FIR detectors; the Golay cell and the optical thermocouple. In essence, the Golay cell depends on the expansion of gas in a pneumatic chamber when the gas is heated by infrared radiation. This flexes a mirror in the cell wall, and the mirror motion is converted to an electrical signal by a separate visible optical system. The primary advantage of this device lies in the fact that the gas cell absorbs radiation uniformly throughout the far infrared; hence it is a very “flat” detector. O n the other hand, the flexible mirror is quite fragile, which makes this device less reliable than the optical thermocouple. The optical thermocouple operates through the heating action of the infrared radiation incident on the thermocouple junction. The temperature *For a collection of reprints concerning all of the F I R detectors discussed in Sections III,B,I and 111,8,2 including performance characteristics see Arams (32).
26
BRUCE D. MCCOMBE AND ROBERT J. WAGNER
developed at the junction is proportional to the radiation absorbed. This detector, although comparable in sensitivity to the Golay cell for wavelengths shorter than 40 pm does not absorb well in the FIR. As a result it becomes very insensitive beyond 100 pm. Recently, a great deal of development work has centered on room temperature pyroelectric detectors. In these devices, the incident radiation causes a change in detector temperature which in turn causes a spontaneous electric polarization of the pyroelectric material. The time rate of change of the polarization induces a current in an external circuit, which can be amplified, etc. These detectors, while generally less sensitive than the previously discussed devices, can have a much faster time response. Hence they are finding increased application as laser radiation detectors. These detectors, although convenient since they operate at room temperature, have been replaced in most magneto-optical studies of semi-conductors by cryogenic detectors. This has come about for a number of reasons. First, these new detectors are much more sensitive. Second, a number of the cryogenic detectors are much faster. Two of the thermal detectors mentioned above have very long response times (zz 100 msec). As a result, they cannot be used conveniently with pulsed lasers or with fast chopping rates. High frequency chopping is desirable to eliminate the problem of llf noise. (It should be noted that whenever the radiation source is continuous in time, the radiation is turned on and off repetitively with a mechanical “chopper.” This allows the use of synchronous detection techniques, which are desirable to achieve the highest possible signal-to-noise.) Finally, since the sample under study is almost always at cryogenic temperatures, it is reasonably convenient to immerse the detector in the same liquid bath. 2. Cryogenic Detectors
The most frequently used cryogenic detectors are semiconductor bolometers (either Ge or Si), impurity photoconductors (Ge doped with Ga, B, or Zn; or GaAs), and the free electron bolometer (InSb). The bolometer operation depends on the fact that the resistance of the element, either Ge or Si, is a strong function of temperature at the operating temperature. This is achieved by careful doping of the material. The element is then isolated b y some suitable thermal resistance, and absorption of radiation causes a corresponding change in temperature, which is detectable as a change in resistance. It is usually designed to have a rather long response time but has the advantage that its response is very flat in the FIR. This makes it ideal for use with the interferometer. Most of the Ge bolometers which have been used to date have required operation at 1.5”K or lower to
INTRABAND MAGNETO-OPTICAL STUDIES OF SEMICONDUCTORS. I
27
obtain peak sensitivity. However, both Ge and Si can be used at 4.2"K with some reduction in sensitivity. For peak sensitivity, fastest response, and convenience (operation at 4.2"K), the impurity photoconductive detector or the free electron bolometer (Kinch-Rollin detector with no magnetic field; Putley detector with a magnetic field) are most frequently used. These detectors, however, have a distinct disadvantage; a strongly varying spectral dependence of sensitivity. An understanding of the physical mechanisms which make them useful as detectors will also point out this shortcoming. As discussed in Section V of this paper, donor or acceptor impurities can be introduced into Ge or GaAs. The ground state of these impurities lies 5.0-10.0 meV from the continuum (conduction or valence band). The absorption of an infrared photon by a bound electron (or hole) excites the carrier to the conduction (or valence) band where it is mobile and increases the sample conductivity. However, if the energy of the infrared photon is less than the impurity binding energy, the radiation is not absorbed and no photoconductivity is observed. As a result these detectors typically have sharp low frequency edges in the infrared where the response drops rapidly toward zero. At frequencies lower than the edge they are very insensitive. Recent studies have shown that it is possible to achieve some useful response beyond the photoconductive edge ; however, this is typically accompanied by a degradation of the peak response. The operation of the free electron bolometer depends on the fact that free electrons in InSb have a mobility which rises as T3I2,where T is the electron temperature. Free electrons absorb radiation in the FIR at a rate proportional to A2 ; consequently, at very long wavelengths sufficient radiation is absorbed to heat the electrons and increase their mobility. This is detected as a change in the resistance of the detector element. Because of the A2 dependence of the absorption, the response is very weak at wavelengths shorter than 130 pm, but rises rapidly to a broad maximum around 500 pm. Both the photoconductive detector and the free electron bolometer are very fast detectors, suitable for use with pulsed lasers. In the magnetic-fieldswept experiment, the variation in spectral response is of little importance provided the feature of interest falls within the proper spectral range. 3. Other Detection Techniques Although some variation of the detection schemes described above is generally used, in some cases unique properties of the sample allow it to function as its own detector. For example, a strong absorption occurs at an energy equal to the 1s to 2p hydrogen-like impurity transition in zero magnetic field in GaAs. Although an electron in the 2p state is not mobile, it may
28
BRUCE D. MCCOMBE A K D ROBERT J. WAGNER
be thermally excited into the conduction band and thus provide a photoconductive signal. This photoresponse persists as one applies a magnetic field, albeit at energies reflecting the 1s + 2p+ 1, Is + 2p,, and 1s -,2p- separations. As a result, one can map out the hydrogenic spectrum of the GaAs impurities simply by studying the photoconductivity of the sample (33a. 33h). Since this is a null technique (i.e. there is photoresponse only at the transitions of interest) it can be much more sensitive than transmission studies. A related technique has been used in studies of cyclotron resonance of alkali halides (34).In this case the high resistance of these materials makes it impossible to measure conductivity as such. However, electrodes can be placed on the sample; and when charges are generated in the bulk, the application of an electric field causes these charges to be swept to the electrodes. Here they are sensed with a charge-sensitive amplifier. Self-detection schemes such as those described above, although not universally applicable, can provide an approach to studies of phenomena that are inaccessible via conventional transmission or reflection methods.
IV. FREE CARRIER RESONANCES A . Electron Cyclotron Resonance I . Bobvers and Yafet Model
Far infrared magneto-optical techniques have been particularly successful when applied to the study of zone-centered electrons in zinc blende semiconductors. In many of these materials, the application of modest magnetic fields results in cyclotron resonance conditions in the FIR due to the light mass electrons. Although sophisticated theories have been developed to account for interband magneto-optical results (35, 3 6 ) the experiments discussed here can generally be understood in the light of simpler theoretical models. We will use a model for the conduction (and valence) band suggested by Kane (37) for the zero field case and suitably extended for the presence of a magnetic field by Bowers and Yafet (BY) (38). The relevant energy bands for this case in zero magnetic field are shown in Fig. 5. The top of the valence band (r,)is twofold degenerate (fourfold with spin included) and consists of light and heavy hole bands. The other valence band of interest (r,)is split off to lower energy an amount A by the spin-orbit interaction. The s-like conduction band (r,)and the light hole valence band interact strongly away from k = 0 via the k p interaction. For small E , this
-
INTRABAND MAGNETO-OPTICAL STUDIES OF SEMICONDUCTORS. I
29
gives rise to large curvatures and correspondingly small effective masses for these two bands. The BY model treats interactions among these four bands (eight with spin) exactly, neglecting interactions with all other bands and neglecting the (generally small) interactions which arise from the inversion asymmetry of the zinc blende structure. This approximation should be good when the energy separations among levels of this set of bands are much smaller than the separation between this set and all other interacting bands. The basis
I
-
k
FIG.5. Schematic energy-momentum relationship at the Brillouin zone center for a typical zinc blende or diamond structure semiconductor. Here the effects of inversion asymmetry are neglected. The group theory designations are those which apply to the zinc blende case.
functions are chosen as the complete set of Luttinger-Kohn functions [Eq. (39)]. With the Hamiltonian of Eq. (38), the equation in real space for the envelope functions, F,(x), is given by Eq. (43). This infinite set ofcoupled equations is now restricted to the eight bands of interest. By choosing as a basis set of cell periodic functions those which diagonalize the zero field Hamiltonian including the spin-orbit interaction, one can obtain an explicit set of equations for the envelope functions. The basis functions are given in Table I. The states of total angular momentum J, and its projection along the z-direction, m, , are also shown (x,y , z are chosen along the cubic axes of the crystal). Periodic functions which transform like atomic s and p functions, under the symmetry operations of the Tf group at r are represented by S and X , Y , 2, respectively. The symbols T and 1 denote the projection of the electron spin with respect to the z-direction. With this set of basis functions, the eigenvalue equations can be written in matrix form (38) as
30
BRUCE
PE0 -E 0 0
0 0 0
D. MCCOMBE (+)1'2fEZ
(3)1'2PE-
0 -E 0 0 0 0
AND ROBERT J. WAGNER
(+)'"P E , 0 0 -E 0
0 Pk + 0 0 0 -E'
0
0
0
0
(+)"2PE,
(3)' 2P I;,
(f)'"P K , - (:)1;2Pk-
0 0 0
0 -A
-
0
E'
(+)'i*P!iZ 0 0 0 0 0 -A-E
=
I
(55) In Eq. (55) = (Lxk i&)/(2)'I2,P is Kane's interband momentum matrix element, P = (-ih/rn,)((S I pz 12)); E' = E - h2e/2rno, and the matrix elements of the free spin term CJ$ have been neglected. TABLE I CELLPERIODIC FUNCTIONS FOR
THE
Function
BOWERSAI\D YAFET MODEL' J.
inJ
Energy
" T h e characterization of the functions by the total angular momentum quantum numbers J . i n J is indicated.
Since all the Fi in Eq. (55) except F , and F , can be eliminated, the following two uncoupled equations are obtained: [ ( E , - E)E(E + A ) + P 2 C ( E + 2A/3) + P 2 h 2 A d /3 ]F , ( = ~ )0, [ ( E , - E ) E ( E A ) P 2 e ( E 2A/3) - P2h2Arr/3]F,(x)= 0.
+ +
+
(56) Here the small diagonal terms h 2 c / 2 m ocontaining the inverse free electron mass have been neglected. They can be included in the final results for the effective mass and g-factor. The functions F , and F , are orthogonal and solutions to Eq. (56) are obtained as harmonic oscillator functions. In the Landau gauge, E,
*Frequently, the momentum matrix element, P, is replaced by E , which is defined as 2m, P2/h'.
=
0.
INTRABAND MAGNETO-OPTICAL STUDIES OF SEMICONDUCTORS. I
A
=
31
( - B y , 0,O)
+
Fl, r= exp (ik,x ik,z)@.,[(y - y,,)~ll/~], (57) where O,, is a normalized harmonic oscillator function and y o = k&. From Eq. (55) it is easily seen that the other F , are also described by harmonic oscillator functions. Thus the total wavefunctions for a given band are characterized by quantum numbers k,, n, and a “spin” projection along the magnetic field, & . The two different orthogonal solutions are labeled - and for the cases F , # 0, F , = F , = 0 and F 2 # 0, F , = F , = 0, respectively. The energy eigenvalue equations for the two orthogonal solutions for the conduction, light hole and split-off hole bands are obtained from Eq. (56) and (57) as
+
E“. +(En.&
-
Eg)(En,i-
+A)
- P2[4(2n
+ 1) + ki][E,, i + 2A/3]
P20A/3 = 0. ( 5 8 )
The heavy hole band which is flat and spin degenerate in this approximation has the eigenvalue E = 0. A useful approximate solution for the conduction band energy levels is obtained for En,+ < E, + 2A/3, where energy is measured from the bottom of the conduction band in zero magnetic field. This approximation is suitable for FIR studies of a number of 111-V and 11-VI semiconductors and has the advantage of yielding a simple expression for the energy levels. The result for the conduction band energy levels is
where o,= eB/m*c, and, neglecting the free electron contribution to the effective mass and g-factor, 1
m*
-
4P2 A + 3E,/2 3E$z2 A + E , ’
and S* =
mo m*A
A
+ 3E9/2’
The cyclotron resonance selection rules discussed in Sections II,B and II,C [Eqs. (30) and (SO)] hold for this nonparabolic model. Here the “spin” state is denoted by (+ ) or (-). However, due to the nonparabolicity, the
32
BRUCE D. MCCOMBE A N D ROBERT J. WAGNER
+
t-
w/o spin
w/ spin
FIG.6. Schematic energy level diagram depicting the Bowers and Yafet solution of Eq. (59) for the conduction band at k , = 0. Solid arrows-cyclotron resonance transitions for the two spin states of the lowest Landau level; dashed arrows-spin resonance transitions for the lowest two Landau levels; dot-dashed arrow-combined resonance transition.
separation between adjacent Landau levels of a given spin becomes progressively smaller as the Landau quantum number is increased. These features are illustrated in Fig. 6.
2. Experimental Studies o f Line Positions The initial infrared experiments on cyclotron resonance of electrons in 111-V semiconductors were performed with monochromators and globars or mercury arc lamps as sources of radiation. Here the wavelength limit was about 100 pm. Thus it is not surprising that most early experiments were performed at laboratories with high magnetic fields which were required to bring o,into the range of the monochromator. While these measurements tended to be crude by present standards of instrumentation, they yielded reasonably good values for the band edge effective masses. Furthermore, these experiments indicated the general applicability of the Bowers and Yafet model described above. As an example of the experimental results, some of the data and analysis on InSb will be presented. A brief discussion of experimental results for other materials will be given as an indication of the extent to which FIR cyclotron resonance methods have been used in electron effective mass determinations. a. InSb. The initial observations of infrared cyclotron resonance of electrons in InSb were made by Burstein et a/. (39). More extensive measurements by Palik er d . (40) and Lax et d.(41) followed somewhat different experimental approaches. In the case of Lax and co-workers, extremely high pulsed magnetic fields permitted the use of short wavelength radiation of 10-22 pm. While these measurements were performed at room temperature, they clearly showed the variation of effective mass with magnetic field predicted by the Bowers and Yafet model. Since Lax et al. observed cyclotron resonance only at fields 2 50 kG, it was somewhat difficult to deduce a
INTRABAND MAGNETO-OPTICAL STUDIES OF SEMICONDUCTORS. I
33
band edge effective mass. O n the other hand, a detailed fit of the theory to the high field results was carried out. The experiments of Palik and co-workers utilized somewhat different instrumentation. Facing a limitation of continuous magnetic fields with a maximum of 70 kG, they required longer wavelength radiation. Out to about 50 pm, radiation from a prism (CsI) or grating monochromator was used. From 50 to 170pm, a series of alkali halide reststrahlen reflection filters were used to isolate narrow ( + 2 c m - l ) bands of radiation. This approach was taken to provide a larger amount of FIR radiation. The cyclotron resonance line in this experiment was significantly narrowed by cooling the sample to 25”K, thus increasing z and w, 5.5 This resulted in a more accurate measurement of line position and, hence, effective mass. The most detailed study of cyclotron resonance in InSb is the work of Johnson and Dickey (42). These workers used a high resolution grating monochromator, a sensitive cryogenic bolometer, and lightly doped, high mobility InSb to study both cyclotron resonance transitions, 0, + 1, and 0, - -+ 1, - (see Fig. 6 ) , as well as one of the spin-flip transitions discussed in the next section. from 4 to 40 kG. A compilation of these results is presented in Fig. 7. The qualitative effect of the k p interaction is apparent, i.e. the plot of E versus B is not linear and the cyclotron resonance transitions from the ( + ) spin state occur at higher energy than those for the ( - ) spin state at the same magnetic field. Johnson and Dickey analyzed these results using a calculation of the four energy levels (0, + ; 0, - ; 1, + ; and 1, - ) from a generalized Bowers and Yafet model. The generalization was to relax the assumption that m* and g* are only affected by the interaction of the conduction band with the p-like valence bands and to include interactions with all other remote bands. These remote band terms were treated as a small perturbation in the calculation and provided corrections to the BY expressions for m* and g*. The calculated cyclotron resonance energies were fit to the experimental data of Fig. (7). The results of the best fit are shown by the solid lines. In obtaining the best fit only data below 18 meV were used due to polaron effects at higher energies (see Section V1,B). From these results JD obtained a band edge effective mass of (0.0139 k 0.0001) m,. While they also obtained a value of E,, care must be exercised in comparing this value with values obtained from the basic BY model previously described. The introduction of FIR lasers has led to a large number of papers reporting studies of cyclotron resonance of electrons in InSb. Some of these studies are primarily concerned with impurity effects and will be discussed in
+
+
-
*Equation (12b) may be used to describe a broadened cyclotron m o n a n c e line by replacing the transition frequency Q,- 01, , by coC.
34
BRUCE D. MCCOMBE A N D ROBERT J. WAGNER
the hydrogenic impurity section. Of the studies of free electron cyclotron resonance, several experiments have been performed which yield additional information about carrier properties. Kobayashi and Otsuka ( 4 3 ) have studied cyclotron resonance as a function of bias electric field applied to the
MAGNETIC FIELD ( k G )
FIG. 7. Variation of electron cyclotron resonance transition energies with magnetic field for InSb. The highest energy data points are due to impurity levels to be discussed in Section V.A: the intermediate energy points correspond to 0, + + 1, + ; and finally the lowest energy points correspond to 0. - + 1, - (see Fig. 6). [From Johnson and Dickey ( 4 2 ) . ]
sample. They noted changes of line intensity of the various cyclotron transitions, 0, + + 1, + ; 0, 1, - ; 1, + + 2, +, as the electric field is increased. From this they were able to deduce the effective electron temperature as a function of electric field. Cyclotron resonance has been used by Murotani and Nisida ( 4 4 ) to obtain information about nonequilibrium electron populations and lifetimes. In this work, the electron population was presumed to be shifted from impurity states into free carrier Landau levels by the high intensity laser radiation. This shifts the intensity of the photoconductive or photoHall response at free electron cyclotron resonance relative to the intensity at --f
INTRABANII MAGNETO-OPTICAL STUDIES OF SEMICONDUCTORS. I
35
impurity cyclotron resonance. Utilizing these results, Murotani and Nisida deduced qualitative information about the electron concentration and mobility compared to the low intensity (no carrier heating) laser data. They then constructed rate equations to attempt to understand the concentrations and lifetimes that exist for the various free electron and impurity states. They concluded that the intensity of the impurity absorption drops with increasing radiation flux because the carrier population has been shifted to the p2 = 0, Landau level. The experiments discussed above do not provide any basically new information about the properties of InSb. However, they point toward a potentially fruitful application of cyclotron resonance techniques, namely the study of nonequilibrium properties of free and bound carriers. b. InAs, InP, GaAs, and their alloys. As a result of its small energy gap, effects of the k p interaction are strongly revealed in InSb as discussed above. All other 111-V compounds with the same zone center band structure have larger energy gaps, E,; thus the BY model is not expected to provide as accurate a description of the conduction band for these materials. In spite of this a number of cyclotron resonance studies of 111-V semiconductors have been interpreted using the BY model, and it generally appears to provide an adequate description. Cyclotron resonance of electrons in InAs was first studied by Keyes et al. (45), Palik et al. (46), and Palik and Wallis (47). Later, with the aid of continuous magnetic fields to 150 kG, Palik and Stevenson (48) observed both spin-up and spin-down cyclotron resonance and cyclotron resonance involving higher Landau levels. Some of this data is shown in Fig. 8. The calculated line positions from the BY model are indicated by the vertical lines. Most recently, Litton et al. (49) have confirmed the earlier effective mass measurements with m* = (0.0230 k 0.003) m, at 15°K. Cyclotron resonance of electrons in InP has been studied by Palik et al. (46)and Palik and Wallis ( 4 7 ) . More recently Chamberlain et al. (50) using a laser spectrometer have obtained a value of rn* = (0.0803 0.0003) rn, at
-
9°K.
The first infrared cyclotron resonance study of GaAs was performed by Palik et a/. (51). Since this experiment, which utilized bulk material, considerable success has been achieved in the preparation of high purity epitaxial films. As an example, both spin-up and spin-down cyclotron resonance in GaAs have been resolved by Fetterman et al. (52) as shown in Fig. 9. The percentage energy (magnetic field) separation of these two lines is only 0.25 % at 60 kG. These workers found a band edge effective mass of (0.0665 k 0.0001)rn0at 4.5"K. Similar results have been obtained by Chamberlain et ul. (50). In both these experiments the lines are so sharp that laser techniques were required to avoid instrumental broadening.
-
N O
.:-
INTRABAND MAGNETO-OPTICAL STUDIES OF SEMICONDUCTORS. I
37
W
m
z
0
a v)
W
Lz
W
I + V 3
0 Z 0 V
0
c
0
I 5
MAGNETIC F I E L D
FIG.9. Photoconductive response as a function of magnetic field through the cyclotron resonance region in GaAs. The two lines are associated with 0, + + 1, + and 0, - + 1. cyclotron resonance transitions. [From Fetterman er nl. (52).]
Recently interest has arisen in effective mass measurements on pseudobinary alloy systems with end members InAs, GaAs, InSb, and GaSb. This interest derives in part from the theoretical prediction that the inevitable disorder of Ga and In atoms in GaJn, -,As alloys, for example, will result in disorder-induced valence-conduction band mixing and observable departures of the effective mass from that predicted from k * p theory. While the first measurements of effective mass in these alloys did not use magnetooptical techniques, this seems to be the ideal approach to the problem. In the first magneto-optical measurement, Fetterman et al. (52) studied cyclotron resonance for Ga,In,-,As (0.846 < x < 1) samples. They calculated the anticipated mass values presuming a knowledge of E , , A, and nz* for the end members InAs and GaAs. An empirical relation obtained from other work was utilized to estimate E , for the alloys, and A was assumed to vary linearly across the alloy system. With this input the effective masses were calculated using the BY model and compared with the experimental results. While their calculated mass values involve a poor choice of E,(InAs) and apparent computational errors, it appears that there is a real disagreement between theory and experiment. Berolo ef al. ( 5 3 )have suggested that compositional disorder results in an increase in effective mass over that anticipated from k * p theory, in qualitative agreement with the experiments. It would be interesting to extend these measurements throughout this alloy system as well as to other systems as a more stringent test of the predictions.
38
BRUCE D. MCCOMHE AND ROBERT J. WAGNER
c. CdTe and Cd, H g , -, Te. A number of cyclotron resonance studies have been performed on the IILVI alloy system Cd,Hg, -,Te. While CdTe has the InSb-type zone center band structure (see Fig. 5 ) with an energy gap of about 1.6eV, the effect of alloying with HgTe is to reduce the (conduction)-I-, (valence band) separation. As these bands approach with increased alloying, a very strong k p interaction occurs. For T = 4 K and x = 0.16, T6 and Ts become degenerate at k = 0 with extreme band repulsion of the conduction and light hole bands. For x < 0.16, the r6 band is
-
l- IG. 10. Schematic energy-momentum relationship at the Brillouin zone center for the
.. inverted band structure. Here inversion asymmetry effects are neglected; the group theory ”
designations are those which apply to the zinc blende case.
lower than the Ts bands at k = 0. The repulsive k * p interaction causes the T, light valence band to invert to a TS light conduction band. On the other hand, the r6 conduction band now becomes a light valence band. The heavy mass T, valence band is not affected by the k p interaction with the rb band, and hence the Ts valence and conduction bands remain degenerate at k = 0. This new arrangement of bands, first suggested for a-Sn (54),is shown in Fig. 10. While electron cyclotron resonance experiments for HgTe could be discussed in this section, the degeneracy of the Ts bands requires a more complicated theoretical framework for proper analysis. This framework is discussed in the hole cyclotron resonance section. Hence the experimental studies of HgTe will also be discussed there. Infrared electron cyclotron resonance in CdTe has been observed by Waldman et al. (55). In this material, a strong electron-phonon coupling complicates the analysis of the data. However, the band edge value, m* = 0.0965 nz, at 4.2”K, is obtained after accounting for the coupling. This
-
INTRABAND MAGNETO-OPTICAL STUDIES OF SEMICONDUCTORS. I
39
is in good agreement with microwave cyclotron resonance results. Additional studies of this material will be discussed in Section VI. The first observations of cyclotron resonance in the Cd,Hg, ._,Te alloys appears to be due to Strauss et al. 56). In a magneto-reflection experiment in Cd,Hg, -,Te (x = 0.17 and 0.14) these authors observed both interband and intraband resonances. Using the Bowers and Yafet model they obtained a band edge effective mass of 4.0 x 10-4m,. Due to the range of photon energies used (40-60 meV) this experiment did not reveal the striking nonlinear behavior of E p h o t o n versus B (w,) that should result from the close approach of conduction and light mass valence bands. More recent FIR data by Kinch and Buss ( 5 7 ) shown in Fig. 1 1 demonstrate this behavior
FIG. 11. Variation of cyclotron resonance (0. + + 1. + ) frequency with magnetic field for The dashed line is calculated from the BY model. [From Kinch and Buss Cd, ,,,Hy,,,,,Te. (571.1
very clearly. The effective mass obtained by fitting to the BY model is m* = 4.66 x 10-3rno.These data also show an “offset” due to the electronphonon interaction which is discussed in Section VI,B. For the above materials a listing of the most reliable band edge effective masses obtained from FIR cyclotron resonance experiments is given in Table 11. d. Other materials. In some cases, the use of far infrared lasers for observing electron (or hole) cyclotron resonance provides an unique advantage over microwave sources. For a given material, higher magnetic fields are required to obtain resonance in the far infrared than in the microwave region. At these higher magnetic fields, it is more likely that w,z > 1 and hence that a clear resonance absorption can be distinguished. With the availability of far infrared lasers and high magnetic fields, one can contemplate studying low mobility materials with relatively short scattering lifetimes.
40
BRUCE D. MCCOMBE A N D ROBERT J. WAGNER
TABLE I1
EFFECTIVF MASES FROM FIR CYCL O T R O ~RESOZANCI. Mnteii‘il
T ( K)
InSb
10
0.0139 f 0.0001
InAs
15
0.0230 t_ 0.0003
Johnson and Dickey (42) Litton a at.
I nP
9
0.0803 f 0.0003
Chamberlain
CaAs
4.2
0.0665 f 0.0001
CdTe
4.2
0.0965 i 0.0005
Fetterman er ti/. ( 5 2 ) Waldman Y r d.( 5 5 )
rn*lm,
Reference
(49) (’1
(50)
Few experiments of this type have been reported, but the work of Button
er 01. (58) on SnO, is a good example of the utility of the technique. While previous estimates of electron mass in SnO, varied from 0.1 m, to 0.4 i n o , these workers, using a far infrared laser and high magnetic field solenoids, found a single anisotropic electron band with m* (Bllc) = (0.234 f 0.002) m, and m* (B I e ) = 0.299 4 0.002) m, . The SnO, sample was of quite high quality with a mobility at 97°K of z 9000 cm2/V-sec. In fact, the experiment could have been done using material of much lower mobility. This experiment suggests that useful characterization measurements may be performed on material previously classed as “unsuitable for cyclotron resonance studies. Obviously many large gap, heavy mass semiconductors fall into this category. However in these materials, an additional dilemma frequently arises. In order to obtain the longest scattering time 5, the experimental temperature is frequently less than 100’K. A t these temperatures, large gap semiconductors have very few free carriers. Thus, special detection and (or) carrier generation techniques are required to observe the resonance. In this regard, the microwave work of Hodby ( 3 4 ) on electron cyclotron resonance in the alkali halides is particularly suggestive. Although this optical pumping/photocapacitance approach may not be directly applicable to the FIR, adaptations of this technique seem to be possible. ”
3. Lirie Shape Studies In addition to measurements of peak positions to determine transition energies, the advent of high resolution methods in FIR spectroscopy has made possible detailed studies of cyclotron resonance line shapes. Since the
INTRABAND MAGNETO-OPTICAL STUDIES OF SEMICONDUCTORS. I
41
linewidth depends sensitively on the scattering mechanism (or mechanisms), such measurements provide an opportunity to obtain selective information concerning the detailed nature of these mechanisms. Thus far, however, very little experimental linewidth data has been obtained in the FIR. In addition there are only a few theoretical calculations [see, e.g., Kawabata (59), and Shin et al. (60)] that have considered the most important scattering mechanism for pure semiconductors (ionized impurity scattering) under the experimental conditions appropriate to FIR cyclotron resonance. A recent calculation by Shin et al. (60) has emphasized the importance of screening of the ionized impurities. For a screened Coulomb scattering potential these authors find that when the magnetic length, 1 = 1/ p = (hc/eB)1/2,is somewhat less than the screening length, a, of the ionized impurities, the cyclotron resonance linewidth in the quantum limit (all electrons in the lowest Landau level) should increase with increasing magnetic field. This is in disagreement with earlier results of Kawabata (59) obtained for an unscreened Coulomb potential. However, the latter calculation is for nonadiabatic (inter-Landau level) scattering; whereas the results of Shin et al. (60) are valid when “adiabatic” (intra-Landau level) scattering predominates. The question of the relative importance of the two types of scattering as a function of magnetic field is an important one. Shin et al. have shown that for l/a < 1 (high magnetic field) “adiabatic” scattering should predominate. The case for l/a B 1 is still not settled theoretically, but *‘ nonadiabatic scattering should certainly be more important in this regime. Experimental results bearing on these calculations are rather limited at this time. The experiments of Ape1 et al. (61) showed a linewidth that narrowed as the magnetic field was increased from 4 to 20 kG. However, this data may be misleading for several reasons: (1) The sample was not of the highest quality, as evidenced by the inagrritude of the linewidths; (2) it was several absorption lengths thick which made precise linewidth measurements difficult due to the exponential nature of the absorption; (3) only three useful data points were obtained; (4) the lowest frequency data were complicated by an impurity absorption line that overlapped the free carrier cyclotron resonance. More recently, Kaplan et a ] . (62) have obtained cyclotron resonance data on thin samples of higher quality InSb. These data converted to scattering times T = ~ / A W ~where ,~, is the equivalent angular frequency h~rlfwidth at half-maximum absorption, is shown in Fig. 12. These data are compared with the calculation of Shin et al. and Kawabata discussed above. The experimental data show a peak in scattering time near l/a = 0.5; i.e., for fields below this maximum in z, the linewidth decreases with increasing field, while at fields above the maximum the width increases with increasing field. “
”
”
42
BRUCE D. MCCOMBE AND ROBERT J. WAGNER
This appears to demonstrate the critical importance of the parameter Ela in determining the field dependence of the linewidth. However, recent measurements on InP (50)show a decrease in linewidth as a function of field over a region where l/a is apparently less than 1, in contrast to the above results.
1008 06 0 5
0.:
04
0.80.7 -
-c m
0
0.60.50.4-
0.3-
/
0
0
5
10
MAGNETIC
15
20
25
FIELD (kOe)
F I G . 12. Cyclotron resonance linewidth expressed as a relaxation time (as defined in the text) as a function of magnetic field for InSb. The solid lines represent the calculations of Kawabata (59) (NONADIABATIC) and Shin er al. (60)(ADIABATIC). An error in the l/a scale and in the ADIABATIC theoretical curve due to neglect of the background dielectric constant has been corrected. [After Kaplan et al. (62).]
It thus appears that additional work, both experimental and theoretical, is required to explain these puzzling results before the full potential of the FIR techniques in elucidating scattering mechanisms can be realized. B. Spin- Flip Resonances
As mentioned in Section I1 the spin-orbit interaction can have a large effect on the energy levels and allowed transitions in a magnetic field. In addition to modifications of the g-factor due to interband coupling of orbital angular momentum into the spin states, the simple selection rules for EM transitions are changed. In general, transitions which change both the '' spin " and Landau quantum numbers become weakly allowed. These tran-
I N T R A B A N D MAGNETO-OPTICAL STUDIES OF SEMICONDUCTORS. 1
43
sitions can be excited by either the electric or magnetic components of the incident radiation. = eEd1, is typically much larger The electric-dipole interaction, P,,, than the magnetic dipole interaction, &?,,,.d. = g*ehBb/rno c. (For n-InSb in a field of 50 k G I x c . d . l2 = 4 x 10’ I i%fm.d. 12. ) Consequently, in most practical situations it is necessary to consider only transitions excited by electricdipole interaction. Thus in the remainder of this section only electric-dipole spin-flip transitions are discussed, keeping in mind that magnetic-dipole transitions, although allowed, are typically orders of magnitude weaker. The precise nature of the coupling which allows electric-dipole spin-flip transitions via the spin-orbit interaction depends upon band structure details of the particular material considered. For the conduction band of zinc blende semiconductors it has been shown theoretically that electric-dipole spin-flip transitions can arise from two possible sources: (1) the lack of inversion symmetry (63); and (2) a small fundamental energy gap (64,65). For valence bands of diamond and zinc blende semiconductors the application of uniaxial stress removes the degeneracy of the upper valence bands and greatly reduces the complicated mixing of the magnetic energy states. In this case electric-dipole spin-flip transitions can also be identified (66). Additional theoretical calculations for other materials include those for the conduction band of Ge and Si (67), Bi (68), and a-Sn type semiconductors having the inverted zone center band structure (69). While experimental studies of spin-flip resonance have been somewhat limited due to the weak nature of the transitions, in several instances the mechanisms causing the transitions have been unambiguously identified. In addition, studies of these resonances can yield precise and useful band parameters, particularly effective g-factors, and hence provide information complementary to that obtained from the usual cyclotron resonance measurements. “
”
1. Conduction Band of Zinc Blende Structure Semiconductors
Since the most extensive and detailed experimental data exist for the conduction band of zinc blende semiconductors, it is useful to discuss briefly the wavefunctions and matrix elements for this situation. Experimental studies on InSb (70) have shown that the small gap mechanism (64,65) dominates the inversion-asymmetry mechanism (63) for this small gap semiconductor. Transitions due to the latter mechanism have never been conclusively identified experimentally (71) ; hence inversion-asymmetry effects are not included in the following discussion. The conduction band wavefunctions derived from the BY model (see Section IV,A) have been given explicitly by Zawadzki (72):
44
BRUCE D. MCCOMBE A N D ROBERT J. WAGNER
INTRABAND MAGNETO-OPTICAL STUDIES OF SEMICONDUCTORS. I
45
As a result of the admixture of valence band states, the wavefunction for is composed of both a given Landau quantum number n and “spin” spin-up (I) and spin-down (1)states as well as harmonic oscillator states of quantum numbers n and n _+ 1. Thus it is clear that matrix elements of P (electric-dipole transitions) are now allowed in which the “spin state changes (from + to - ”), or in which both the “spin” and orbital states change (by -t 1). As mentioned previously, the matrix element may be expressed as a sum of “interband” and “intraband” terms analogous to those of Eq. (50). However, due to the strong admixture of cell periodic and envelope functions in Eqs. (62) and ( 6 3 ) the predominant contribution to the matrix element for the intraband spin-flip transitions comes from the so-called “interband” terms (72), i.e. terms like (S I ? . p I X f iY). The first type of transition (pure spin-flip) arises from the first term of Y + and the fifth term of Y - (and vice versa), and the second type (both spin and orbital states change by f 1) is due to the first term of Y + and the sixth term of Y (and vice versa). The pure spin-flip resonance is excited in this case by the electric component of the radiation field. This transition, termed electric-dipole excited electron spin resonance (EDE-ESR), absorbs radiation in the CRI polarization at the energy En, - En,+ = hvs(n). The momentum matrix element (for E,,, 4 Eg)is given by ”
“
”
“
~
~
The combined resonance involves a change in both spin and Landau quantum numbers and occurs for the radiation electric field polarized parallel to the dc magnetic field (E’JjB)at an energy E,,+l,- - En.+ = hv,,,(n). The matrix element is
These are the results obtained by Sheka (65)who used a canonical transformation to eliminate interband terms and obtained an effective electron velocity operator. As is evident from Eqs. ( 6 6 ) and (67) the spin-flip matrix elements are quite similar in form. They differ in their dependence on electron wave vector; the EDE-ESR matrix element depends on k, (the wave vector parallel to the magnetic field) while the combined resonance matrix element is
46
BRUCE D. MCCOMBE AND ROBERT J. WAGNER
proportional to d1’2 x B”’. On the other hand, the prefactors are identical in both cases; hence both matrix elements depend strongly on the inverse energy gap. Since the absorption coefficient is proportional to the matrix element squared, the possibility of observing such transitions decreases extremely rapidly with increasing energy gap. In practice, electric-dipole spin-flip transitions of this type have been observed only in quite narrow gap semiconductors. Indium antimonide ( E , = 0.235 eV) is the largest gap material in which these spin-flip resonances have been positively identified. The initial observation of combined resonance was made by McCombe et al. (73). In these experiments the transmission of n-type InSb was studied as a function of magnetic field using a conventional infrared monochromator, linear polarizers, and high magnetic field provided by Bitter-type solenoids. These high field measurements took advantage of the magnetic field dependence of the matrix element [Eq. (67)]. From these studies, the E’/JBselection rule was clearly established. Subsequently, detailed comparison of the calculated and observed magnetic field, carrier concentration, polarization, and orientation dependence of this transition (70) demonstrated conclusively that the small energy gap mechanism discussed above, and not the inversion-asymmetry mechanism, was responsible for the observed resonance in InSb. The EDE-ESR was not observed in these studies. The latter resonance was first reported by Bell (74) who utilized microwave techniques; however, no comparison with theory was presented in this work. McCombe et al. (75)have observed the EDE-ESR in the FIR using a pulsed gas laser spectrometer. The material investigated was the alloy semiconductor Cd,Hg, -,Te (x = 0.193). At this composition Cd,Hg, _,Te has the ‘‘ normal” zinc blende zone center band structure depicted in Fig. 5 with an energy gap of less than 60 meV. Figure 13 shows the results of a polarization study at two laser wavelengths. Again the polarization selection rules discussed above are clearly obeyed. From measurements of EDE-ESR, combined resonance and cyclotron resonance accurate band parameters for materials such as Cd,Hg, -,Te may be obtained. McCombe and Wagner (76) have studied these transitions in an alloy with x = 0.193 and fit their energy versus magnetic field dependence to that calculated from the BY model [Eq. (%)I. The results are shown in Fig. 14 with the indicated values of the parameters used for the calculated curves. These band parameters are in quite reasonable agreement with recent interband measurements (77);however it should be emphasized once again that care must be exercised when comparing band parameters obtained from two different models. It is worth mentioning here that intraband magneto-optical studies utilizing both cyclotron resonance and spin-flip resonances can provide a more accurate set of band parameters for a given
INTRABAND MAGNETO-OPTICAL STUDIES OF SEMICONDUCTORS. I
47
model, since both the separation between Landau levels and the separation between “spin” states are measured. Subsequent to the EDE-ESR measurements in Cd,Hg, -,Te this resonance was observed in InSb (78). Due to its larger energy gap the total
FIG. 13. Magnetic field dependence of the transmission of circularly polarized radiation through a sample o f Cd,Hg, _,Te ( Y = 0.193). The laser wavelengths are indicated in the figure. [From McCombe (79).]
I 20c
1oc C
FIG. 14. Transition frequencies versus magnetic field for several intraband transitions in Cd,Hg,_,Te (x = 0.193) with n = 3 x l o L 5c r K 3 and T = 4.5”K: combined resonance (0); cyclotron resonance ( 0 ) ;and EDE-ESR (A). The solid lines are derived from the Bowers and Yafet model with E , = 0.058 eV and E , = 19.1 eV. [From McCombe and Wagner (76).]
intensity is more than 200 times weaker in InSb for the same carrier density. The observed lines are also much narrower in TnSb, and the widths are strongly dependent on carrier concentration and temperature (76). At present, the theoretical explanation for the linewidths is in an unsatisfactory
48
BRUCE D. MCCOMBE AND ROBERT J . WAGNER
state. The observed lines in InSb are more than a factor of ten narrower than would be expected simply from broadening due to the nonparabolicity combined with the kH dependence of the transition matrix element [Eq. (66)] in the absence of scattering (79). Recent theories (80-82) which can be interpreted physically in terms of dynamical or "motional " narrowing, and which have been used to explain the linewidths of spontaneous spin-flip Raman scattering, give qualitatively reasonable results for the EDE-ESR linewidths in some cases. However, they do not correctly describe the observed temperature dependence in higher concentration samples. It is clear that further experimental and theoretical work is required to attain a quantitative understanding of the line shapes.
I " " " " '
00
Fic,. 15. Electron ~/-\alucsversus magnetic field for InSb. Experimental points werc obtained a t 4.3 K with Bi'[1 1 I]. The calculation of Pidgeon PI t i / . (83) (solid line) is for B [ l 1 I]. while that of Johnson and Dickey ( 4 2 ) (dashed line) is for BIl[1101. [From McCombe and Wagner (78).]
Nonetheless, in the quantum limit at low temperature the position of the EDE-ESR line yields a precise determination of the energy separation between the two spin states of the lowest Landau level and hence the y-value of this level. Such precise measurements can be used to test the quality of energy band models and parameters obtained for these models by other experimental methods. As an example of this the y-values for the lowest Landau level in InSb obtained from EDE-ESR measurements (78) are compared with values calculated from fits to two different band models in Fig. 15. Both models include effects of remote band interactions. Here the y-value is defined by y(n) = hvs(r7)/pBB. In the PMB model parameters were
49
I N T R A B A N D MAGNETO-OPTICAL STUDIES OF SEMICONDUCTORS. 1
obtained from interband measurements, while in the J D model parameters were obtained from intraband measurements. The experimental points deviate from both calculated curves. The deviation from the Johnson and Dickey calculation is not quite as large as it appears, due to an anisotropy in the g-factor. On the other hand, the disagreement with the interband results (solid curve) is greater than 8% between 30 and 80 kG. This is well outside the combined experimental errors, and it is of the same order as the discrepancy between the calculated zero field g-factor and that measured by standard microwave ESR (84) (indicated by the triangle in Fig. 1s).Similar discrepancies between inter- and intraband measurements have been noted in the band edge electron and hole effective masses of several small gap semiconductors (85). At present, these discrepancies are not well understood.
2. Valence Bands of Zinc Blende and Diamond Structure Semiconductors under Uniaxial Stress
As mentioned above, the r-point valence bands of diamond structure or zinc blende structure materials under uniaxial stress also provide a system in which electric-dipole spin-flip resonance can be identified. For zero stress, the valence bands are degenerate in zero field (see Fig. 5). In the presence of a magnetic field the resulting energy levels may be grouped into four sets (see the following Section IV,C,l), which can be labeled for large quantum numbers as ‘‘ light holes ( + ) a and b or heavy holes ( - ) a and b, according to the separation between neighboring levels in a set. If the effects of the inversion-asymmetry of the zinc blende lattice are neglected, this discussion applies equally well for Ge or InSb. As shown in the following section, under certain approximations the wavefunctions for the degenerate Ts(J = 3/2) valence band (15,66) can be written: ”
“
Y : ( u ) = aF(n)@n-lI3/2, - 3 / 2 )
‘Y’(b)
=
b: (n)mn-
”
+ L Z ; ( ~ ) @ , , +1312, ~
-
1/2),
I 3/2, 1/2) + b: (.)a,,+ 1 3/2, - 3/2).
(68)
(69)
The correspondence between the band edge functions in the angular momentum notation and the notation used in the BY model is given in Table I. The energy levels are shown schematically in Fig. 20. The various a’s and b’s are approximately the same size for small n; hence, no unique “spin” state can be identified for a given level (i.e. rn, is not a good quantum number). In general, transitions between the two sets (a set s b set) as well as transitions between different states of a given set are allowed.
50
BRUCE D. MCCOMBE AND ROBERT 3. WAGNER
In zero field the presence of uniaxial stress lowers the cubic symmetry and removes the degeneracy of the f 3 / 2 and k t/2 valence bands. The bands are split into two pairs of Kramer doublets, m, = k 1/2 and ~n= , 3/2, which are separated by a small “energy gap” proportional to the magnitude of the stress. Under compressive stress the splitting is such that the M , = ~ f 1/2 states lie at higher energy than the m, = f 3 / 2 states, i.e. the i ~ i , = , &fstates (upper band) remain populated at large values of stress
v
c.b.
7-
n=-1
n= ____-----1-
2-
3-
1-
I
2-
4-
3-
2%
4-
‘&’ A
m, = -112
.112 (n-1)
n’= (n.1)
312
a-set
n.1
-
2-
3-
5.0.
b-set
n = -1
1-
2-
4-
m
- 412
(n-1)
- 312 (n.1)
t - 1 ~ 16. . Schematic energy-momentum relationship for the relevant bands of a zinc blende (neplecting inversion asymmetry) or diamond structure semiconductor in the presence o f uniaxial compressive stress (left). The first feu energy levels at k, = 0 in the presence of uniaxial stress and an applied magnetic field (right).
(see Fig. 16). For sufficiently large stress the strong admixture of wavefunctions is removed, and with the magnetic field and stress both along the (001) axis the wavefunctions for the upper band can be written
YY,(b)=d,,~,,-,(3/2,-3/2)+~,,+,/3/2,1/2),
M =
1,2.3. (71)
INTRABAND MAGNETO-OPTICAL STUDIES OF SEMICONDUCTORS. I
51
Here d,, is the ratio of the energy of the nth level to the stress splitting of the valence bands. For n = - 1 and 0, d, = 0 and for n 2 1, d, 6 1 in the above approximation. Thus Yn-( a )is predominantly composed of effective “ spin projection m, = - 1/2 with a small admixture of m, = + 312; and ’Y,-(b) is predominantly m, = 1/2 with a small admixture of in, = -312. Clearly for this situation m, is a “good” quantum number, and “spin”-flip transitions can be meaningfully discussed. The corresponding energies for these states at k , = 0 referred to the top of the upper band in the presence of stress are
”
+
Ed. f
= fio,(iz’
* +glPlg B,
+ 4)
(72)
where n’ = 0, 1, 2, . . . (see Fig. 16) ho, = ( y l - y2)z2wco,and y1 = 2 ~Here . w,, is the free electron cyclotron frequency, and yl, y 2 , and K are the Luttinger effective mass and effective g-value parameters discussed in the next section. Similar expressions are obtained for the tn, = & 312 levels. In order to calculate the momentum matrix elements for the “spin”-flip transitions in such degenerate bands, it is first necessary to determine the momentum operator appropriate to this situation. From the general expression pop = (m,/fi) d#/dk the proper momentum operator for this specific case has been determined (66,86). In the limit of large stress the combined resonance matrix element (An’ = + 1, AntJ = - 1) for E / \ B(86) is given by <(n’
+ I ) ~ m,, = -4 1 popI (n’)b,m,
=
++) cc (n’ + i ) i ’ 2 ~ 3 ’ 2 / 2 6, , (73)
where 28, is the stress splitting of the valence bands. This expression may be compared with Eq. (67) for the conduction band case. Note the much stronger magnetic field dependence of Eq. (73). The combined resonance originating on the 12‘ = 0 level is indicated on the right-hand side of Fig. 16 by the dashed arrow. It should also be noted here, by way of comparison, that the above treatment neglects k p interactions with the conduction band of the type which produces the spin-flip resonances described previously for InSb and Cd,Hg, -,Te. Transitions of similar origin are expected to be present in the valence bands for zero stress (6Y)* However, they are typically much weaker than the combined resonance of Eq. (73) since the strength of the former is roughly proportional to 1/E: while that of the latter is proportional to 118:. For InSb the maximum value of 28, attainable is about 60 meV while E, is about 235 meV. Combined resonance in the stress split valence bands was first observed
-
*This calculation was done for the “inverted” r-Sn band structure. It should provide an adequate description only for large Landau quantum numbers, since the r8 (light hole)-r, (heavy hole) band mixing is neglected by using the BY model.
52
BRUCE D. MCCOMBE A N D ROBERT J. WAGNER
by Hensel (86) using a microwave spectrometer as part of an extensive study of the valence bands of Ge under uniaxial stress. This work is discussed in more detail in the next section. Recently, Ranvaud (87) has extended these measurements to higher fields using a FIR HCN laser. Combined resonance as well as cyclotron resonance was observed in both Ge and InSb. Due to the strong dependence of the combined resonance matrix element on magnetic field [Eq. (73)], this transition is more easily studied in the FIR. Transmission data for Ge with E’IJBare shown in Fig. 17 for various values of
goL (K) ?O
0
MAGNET,?’
FIELD
FIG. 17. Transmission of 337 pni laser radiation through p-type Ge iis it function of magnetic field for several values of uniaxial stress. The combined resonance transition is labeled 3. The zero transmission point for each of the curves is indicated to the left. Values of stress are in units of 10’ dyn cm2. E 11 B 1, stress 11 1 I]. [After Ranvaud (H7).]
uniaxial stress along the [ 11 11 axis. Note that the combined resonance intensity decreases with increasing stress as predicted above. From the difference between the energies of the lowest combined resonance transition (0, 1/2) + (1, - l/2) and the adjacent cyclotron resonance transition (0, - 1/2) + (1, - 1/2) [levels are labeled by (n’, m,,)] one obtains the y-factor of the mJ = & $ states. This is given by g1 = 21c in the above approximation which neglects the Luttinger q parameter. As pointed out in the following section this parameter is related to the anisotropy of the g-factor. For example for stress I/ B 11 [ 11 11, when the effects of q are included, the g-factor is given by 9 , = 21i + (13/2)q. From a careful study of the small anisotropy of the above transitions Hensel and Suzuki (88) were able to
INTRABAND MAGNETO-OPTICAL STUDIES OF SEMICONDUCTORS. I
53
obtain values for both of these parameters in Ge for the first time. Their results are: K = 3.41 0.03, and q = 0.06 i- 0.01, which corresponds to a maximum anisotropy (between (111) and (001)) of about 5%.
3. Bismuth Apparently, the initial experimental observation of electric-dipole spin-flip resonances in the FIR was made by Burgiel and Hebel (BH) in Bi (89). Bismuth is semimetallic and crystallizes in a rhombohedra1 structure consisting of two interpenetrating face-centered cubic lattices which have been slightly distorted by elongation along a (1 11) axis. There are two atoms per unit cell, and pure Bi has three equivalent anisotropic conduction band minima at the L-points of the Brillouin zone and an overlapping valence band maximum at the T-points. The conduction band minima are separated from the valence band maxima at the L point by a direct energy gap of approximately 12 meV (90). The magnetic energy levels are shown in Fig. 18 for a magnetic field of 50kG directed along the threefold (trigonal) axis. For this orientation the spin-splitting is approximately half the Landau level separation. Also note that the (+) spin state lies at a higher energy than the ( - ) state in contrast to the InSb case discussed earlier. In the experiments of BH the transmission of 125--200pm thick Bi samples was measured as a function of frequency for a number of fixed values of magnetic field using a Fourier transform spectrometer. Experimental data are shown in Fig, 19 for the magnetic field oriented parallel to the threefold axis and light propagation parallel to the field (longitudinal or Faraday geometry). A rather complicated spectrum consisting of a number of transmission minima is observed. Cyclotron resonance occurs at approximately 50 cm-I for this field, and the general decrease in transmission is due to the wing” of this relatively very strong absorption line. The weak absorption lines were attributed by BH to various pure spin (Ams = k 1, An = 0) and combined (Ams = T 1, An = 1 ) transitions. Possible transitions from hole levels were ruled out from a comparison with the known spacing of the hole levels derived from studies of Shubnikovde Haas oscillations (91). The presence of several spin and combination frequencies was ascribed to the large nonparabolicity which makes the energy of a given transition a decreasing function of the Landau quantum number of the initial state. A number of possible initial states are populated at these magnetic fields as can be seen in Fig. 18. Burgiel and Hebel did not attempt to provide theoretical justification for the assignment of the various transitions. The matrix elements and selection rules have been calculated by Wolff “
54
BRUCE D. MCCOMBE A N D ROBERT J. WAGNER
(O,+)
?oo l -200 -
-I&
0
108
kZ (CM-0
FIG. 18. Energy-momentum relationship for Bi at the L-point of the Brillouin zone in the presence of a magnetic fieid along the threefold axis. [Calculated from Smith PI ui (91).] €,denotes the level to which the electrons fill the conduction band (the Fermi level). [From Burgiel and Hebel (89).]
B = 35.7kG
[L 2
16
18
20
22
24
2h
28
3O
FREQUENCY (cm-' )
FK. 19. Far infrared transmission of bismuth with B parallel to the trigonal axis. Arrows indicate the resonances discussed in the text. [From Burgiel and Hebel (KY).]
INTRABAND MAGNETO-OPTICAL STUDIES OF SEMICO&DUCTORS. I
55
(68) from the two-band model for Bi (92). This calculation yielded an allowed pure spin-flip transition (Ams = k 1, An = 0 ) for the two senses of circular polarization. The combined resonance is also allowed for E‘((B between states (n, + ) and ( i t 1, -); however these pairs of states are degenerate in the two-band model (hence the transition would not be experimentally observable). On the other hand, for B along the trigonal axis in Bi (the experimental configuration of BH) the two-band model breaks down, i.e. the spin splitting is only about halfthe Landau level separation (Fig. 18). Hence it is clearly not profitable to attempt a comparison with theory in this case. In the absence of polarization studies and a proper theory for ihe experimental configuration, it is not possible to precisely identify the various transitions and hence to obtain quantitative band structure information from these experiments.
+
C. Hole Cyclotron Resonance The progress of cyclotron resonance studies of holes has been considerably hampered by the complexity of the valence band structure of many semiconductors. While FIR studies should be productive of detailed information concerning band parameters for light and heavy hole valence band levels, most of the useful information about these materials has been obtained using microwave techniques. To a certain extent, this reflects the recent development of FIR techniques. O n the other hand it may indicate some potential limitations of the present infrared approach by comparison to established microwave methods. In this section, the Luttinger and Kohn (LK) formalism (Section 11) as applied by Luttinger to the case of the degenerate valence bands of Ge is sketched, and the success and limitations of the theory are indicated. The recent work of Hensel and Suzuki (HS) (88, 93-95) who have produced a prodigious experimental and theoretical study of microwave cyclotron resonance in Ge is then presented. It is in the light of this work that the few reported FIR studies of degenerate hole bands are discussed. Cyclotron resonance measurements of the conduction band of HgTe are also described in this section. Since HgTe has the “inverted band structure, conduction band studies are intimately related to valence band studies in semiconductors with the “normal band ordering. Finally, cyclotron resonance of holes in tellurium is reviewed. In this case, for free carriers, very complete and useful FIR experiments have been performed. ”
”
56
BRUCE D. MCCOMBE A N D ROBERT J. W A G N E R
1. Degenerate Bands in Zinc Blende and Diamond Structure Semiconductors The valence bands of diamond and zinc blende semiconductors at the Brillouin zone center are constructed from a set of sixfold degenerate p-like states (three Kramers doublets). In the presence of spin-orbit interaction, the states are split into an upper fourfold set and a lower twofold set. The formal effective mass theory for the case of degenerate bands was first worked out by LK ( I I). Luttinger subsequently calculated energy eigenvalues for valence band Landau levels using the LK approach of coupled equations involving harmonic oscillator envelope functions (1.5). In this set of coupled equations the interaction of a given band in the set with all other farremoved bands is included to second order. The starting equation (15) is
2 [D$P"Pp + pg B)L,o,]F,,(~)= EFr(x),
(74)
?-'
where r, r' run over the degenerate set of bands. The effective mass matrix D$! includes interaction momentum matrix elements p",,, with other bands, r", outside the set r' as follows:
where E , is the energy of the degenerate band and pR,, is defined by Eq. (37b). Again, one may identify symmetric and antisymmetric effective mass matrices in a fashion similar to the single band case, with the antisymmetric part reflecting the hole g-factor. When the spin-orbit interaction is included, the 6 x 6 matrix, D:? (including spin), can be reduced to a 4 x 4 component (for the upper degenerate p-states) and a 2 x 2 component (for the lower spin-orbit split p-state). Using group theoretical arguments Luttinger has given the general form of D for the upper fourfold bands of a diamond structure semiconductor
where c.p. denotes cyclic permutations, {a, b ) = i ( a b + ba) indicates the symmetrized product, and the five Luttinger parameters y l , y 2 , y 3 , K , and q are related to sums of interband momentum matrix elements of the form of
INTRABAND MAGNETO-OPTICAL STUDIES OF SEMICONDUCTORS. I
57
Eq. (7.5). (They are generally treated as adjustable parameters to be determined by a fit to experiment.) The parameters yl,y 2 . and y 3 are related to the effective masses of the holes, while K and q determine the effective g-factors as discussed previously. In Eq. (76) the J’s are the 4 x 4 angular momentum matrices for spin 3/2 and I is a unit matrix. Although the 4 x 4 matrix equation [Eq. (76)] i s not easily solved in general, an approximate solution yielding analytic expressions for the eigenvalues may be obtained by making two rather restrictive assumptions; namely, y 2 = y 3 = 7 and q = 0. While the latter assumption was thought to be reasonably good (the g-factor anisotropy is only about 5 % as measured by HS), the former is known to be a drastic one. These parameters reflect the degree to which the magnetic energy level structure varies with the orientation of B relative to the crystal axes. For j12 = -y3 all directions are equivalent (the “spherical” assumption) and the energy levels are the same for all directions of B. Early cyclotron resonance experiments in Ge indicated that the energy surfaces were not spherical ; however. this approximation reveals some noteworthy general features which justify its presentation. With k , set equal to zero;” the 4 x 4 matrix decouples into two 2 x 2 matrices given in Table 111. The operators at, u in this table are creation and annihilation operators for harmonic oscillator functions, and utu is the harmonic oscillator “number” operator, i.e. utuQn = nQn. The upper block is TABLE 111
THELU TTINGER D MATRIXIN
THE SPHERLCAL
APPROXIMATION“
* The assumption that k, = 0 implies that when comparing calculated energy level separations with experimental transition energies, the observed transitions occur at k , = 0. The case k , # 0 was originally investigated by Wallis and Bowlden (96), and HS (88, 94, 9 5 ) have demonstrated the importance of nonzero k , for a quantitative understanding of the cyclotron resonance spectra.
58
BRUCE D. MCCOMBE AND ROBERT J . WAGNER
denoted “ a ” and the lower block .‘b.” The eigenvalues and eigenfunctions are E(a), $(a) and E(b), $(b) for the a- and b-sets, respectively. The two 2 x 2 matrices of Table I11 are reduced to numerical matrices, which may be solved directly, by the following choice of wavefunctions
where the On’s are harmonic oscillator functions and a,, u 2 , h,, h2 are the eigenvector components of the numerical matrices associated with the band edge functions having m, = + 312, - 1/2, + 112, and - 312, respectively. The choice of n is arbitrary to within a constant [the choice here is that of Pidgeon and Brown (35)].The energy eigenvalues in units of heB/m, c for the a-set are:
E-,(a)
-
=
-
y)
-
+ti,
The eigenvalues for the h-set are:
Thus, the energy levels fall into four “ladders,” u-set ( + or - ) and h-set ( + or -). In the limit of large quantum number, n, the + levels correspond to light holes and ‘’ - levels to heavy holes (according to their splitting in a magnetic field). The total wavefunctions for these four ladders are given in Eqs. (68) and (69) and the energy levels are shown schematically in Fig. 20. Although the levels / I = -1, 0 in the u-set have a separation more characteristic of the ) ? I , , = +3/2 levels, they are shown grouped (by the dotted lines) with the n i , , = - 1/2 levels. The reason for this grouping is easily seen. For / I = - 1, 0 the coefficient a: = 0 and Y ? ,(u) = @, 13/2, - 1/2) [see Eq. (68)]; hence the band edge component of the wavefunction is strictly m, = - 112 in this approximation. The grouping of levels in the b-set is straightforward. Note that the energy separation between the n = 0 and n = - 1 levels in ”
”
INTRABAND MAGNETO-OPTICAL STUDIES OF SEMICONDUCTORS. I
59
the a-set and b-set are particularly simple combinations of parameters :
E;(U) - E?,(u)
=
71
7, + 7. -
E , f ( b ) - E T , ( b ) = y1 (80) Transitions between these pairs of levels are called fundamental transitions and are indicated by the solid arrows in Fig. 20. The form of the transition energy of these fundamental transitions is unchanged even for y 2 # ;’3 and q 0 provided B is in the ( 1 11) or (001) direction. In these cases, 7 must be set equal to y 3 or y 2 , respectively. “
”
+
FIG.20. Schematic energy-momentum relationship for the relevant energy bands of zinc blende (neglecting inversion asymmetry) or diamond structure semiconductors neai- k = 0 (left). The first few energy levels for the valence bands in the presence of an applied magnetic field at k, = 0 (right). The dotted lines along with the niJ label indicate the grouping of states according to the dominant hand edge contribution. The Landau quantum number, n’, for each l e d is related t o its labeled harmonic oscillator quantum number, i~, as specified i n the figure.
A most important feature of these energy levels is the fact that for large ii’ both light and heavy hole levels are uniformly spaced, whereas for small n’ the energy separation between adjacent levels is strikingly nonuniform. This results from the strong admixture of harmonic oscillator states near the point of degeneracy. The distinction between what has been termed “classical” and “quantum” cyclotron resonance derives from this feature. Experimentally, the distinction arises from the difference in distribution of carriers among the quantum levels for different temperature regimes. For
60
BRUCE D. MCCOMBE AND ROBERT J. WAGNER
k, T + h a , the holes are distributed according to Boltzmann statistics over a large number of Landau levels. Thus there are many overlapping cyclotron resonance “contributions” (n’ + n’ + 1) for the light and heavy holes, each of which has a different energy (or magnetic field) for small n’. The transition energy approaches a constant for large n’. The resulting spectrum consists of two “classical” cyclotron resonance lines ; one for light holes and one for heavy holes. On the other hand, for k , T 5 ho,, holes are distributed only in small n’ Landau levels. This results in a small number of cyclotron resonance “contributions,” each of which has a different frequency (or field); these may be resolved into separate lines experimentally. Evidence of the many constituent lines (Luttinger effects) was first observed by Fletcher et al. (97), and this indicated the need for a theory of the degenerate bands as described above. Attempts to analyze the low temperature cyclotron resonance spectra of holes in Ge, however, have met with little quantitative success until recently, primarily due to the neglect of kH-effects. The continued experimental and theoretical work of HS (88, 93-95) has succeeded in unraveling the complex cyclotron resonance spectra of Ge.” Theoretically, they extended Luttinger’s effective mass Hamiltonian to include the r7split-off valence band in the basic manifold, and took into account the effect of uniaxial stress in a general way. Furthermore, they made no assumptions about the relative sizes of the Luttinger parameters, about the k,-dependent contribution to the spectra, or about the direction of the magnetic field. Utilizing symmetry arguments, they developed a scheme for classifying eigenstates and electric-dipole selection rules. Rather than the relatively simple wave functions of the form of Eqs. (68) and (69) which occurred in the Luttinger treatment, HS assumed wavefunctions of the general form x)
yflh.
kff
+3;2
1
= n,=O
m,,=-3 2
amj(nU)$fla.
flh.
kr,
I J , “J>,
(81)
where I J , m J ) are the LK cell periodic functions for the p3,2 and p1 states and a,,(n,) are numerical coefficients. The symmetric gauge is used to specify the Landau functions $I,, n h , k H ; hence the wavefunctions are described by the two “harmonic oscillator” quantum numbers 17, and nb ( I T , is equivalent to the Landau quantum number, II, and nb is equivalent to I I - i n1 of Section 11). By substituting the wavefunction [Eq. (Sl)] into the effective mass equation &Tflh. k f f = EYI,,. k H , a secular matrix for the um,,(na)is generated. This infinite matrix is solved numerically by truncat111
* Fujiyasu r f a!. (Y8) have also reported microwave studies of cyclotron resonance of holes Ge under uniaxial stress.
INTRABAND MAGNETO-OPTICAL STUDIES OF SEMICONDUCTORS. I
61
y 2 , y 3 , q, ing to an 80 x 80 matrix. An arbitrary selection of values for the K , and strain (deformation potential) parameters allows the matrix to be diagonalized, energy levels determined, and the anticipated spectra computed. However, with this approach it would be impossible to match theory uniquely with experiment. The large number of lines, their potential k,-dependence, and broadening effects would make it impossible to determine the constants unambiguously. In order to surmount part of the problem HS made use of the fact, previously noted, that the application of uniaxial compressive stress results in a considerable simplification of the degenerate bands and thus of the experimental results. Figure 21 is illustrative of this simplification. First, the light hole transitions below 1 kOe disappear as the stress is increased to 1900 kg/cm2; second, the large number of heavy hole transitions in the region 2-8 kOe are “reduced ” to a series of about 5 lines near 8 kOe; finally, and most importantly, the line (0, - 1/2) + (1, - 1/2) moves only slightly as stress is increased from 490 to 1900 kg/cm2. This is one of thefundamental transitions. These developments can be qualitatively understood from a consideration of the hole wavefunctions and energy levels as described previously. The compressive stress splits the k = 0 valence band degeneracy. This has the effect of reducing the hole population and cyclotron resonance strength for the lower band. In addition, the stress reduces the admixture of band edge wavefunctions. With magnetic field applied, four series of levels develop; two associated with the m, = f 1/2 states and two with the m, = & 312 states as shown in Fig. 16. In the high stress limit these ladders become equally spaced, and the cyclotron resonance series approach ellipsoidal low and high mass values. The lowest transitions, (0, -3/2) --t (1, -3/2) and (0, - 1/2) (1, - 1/2), are virtually independent of stress and simply related to the parameters y l , y 2 , and y 3 . These relationships are shown in Table IV for two high symmetry directions. The reason for the stress independence of these lines in lowest order is easily seen by examining the zero stress wavefunctions in the spherical approximation. For example, as mentioned above, both \ r l l ( u )and ‘ Y i ( a ) are proportional only to /3/2, - 1/2) and have no contribution from 13/2, +3/2). Hence, since the predominant effect of the stress is to “decouple” m, = - 312 from m, = + 1/2 and m, = 3/2 from m, = -- 112 states, the stress has no effect on the 0 1 transition in this approximation. By studying the stress dependence of the many cyclotron resonance lines which were observed, HS were able to identify the two fundamental transitions. They found that these lines were extremely sharp and, as a result, they were able to make the following very precise determinations of the Luttinger .--f
+
.--f
62
BRUCE D. MCCOMBE AND ROBERT J . WAGNER
m o
i
d
un
d
0
0
I
I
MAGF(ETK: FIELD IN OERSTEDS
FIG. 21. Valence band cyclotron resonance spectra in Ge showing the effects of iiniaxial siress. The data were obtained at 1.2' K and 52.9 GHz with B~~[111]1! stress. Hole resonances at
zero stress are designated by their effective mass values. For finite stress the transitions are labeled by the (17~. +ni,,) notation abbreviated to n'+ (all transitions shown are r n , = i 1,2). [From Hensel and Suzuki (95).]
parameters: =
13.38 f 0.02;
;'2
=
4.24 +_ 0.03;
;a3
=
5.69 & 0.02.
Hensel and Suzuki also noted that while the transition (0, -312) + (1, - 3 i 2 ) was stress independent to the limits of their experimental resolution, the transition (0, - 1/2) + (1, - li2) showed an extremely weak ( 1 '!()), but clearly observable. stress-dependence. From this dependence they were able to determine values for the valence band spin-dependent uniaxial deformation potentials.
INTRABAND MAGNETO-OPTICAL STUDIES OF SEMICONDUCTORS. I
63
The spin-flip transitions which occur for E’IIB allowed a determination of the K and q parameters as discussed in the previous section. Using all of the Luttinger parameters determined in this manner HS proceeded to calculate the stress-free cyclotron resonance spectrum of holes in Ge on the basis of
TABLE IV EFFECTIVE MASS TENSORCOMPOKENTS FOR LOWESTTRANSITIONS I N EACH LADDERIN HIGH STRESSLIMIT".^ Stress
rn, =
1’2
m,
=
THE THE
i312
The parallel axes of the tensors are along the stress direction. After Hensel and Suzuki (Y5).
the theoretical model previously described. Assuming each component line to have Lorentzian shape with z = 2.7 x 10- l o sec, they calculated the integrated intensity of each line as a function of crystal momentum in the direction of the field, k,, and were thus able to synthesize the zero stress spectra. From this calculation they found that the dominant contribution to many of the cyclotron resonance lines did not come from transitions at k, = 0. As a result the lines were broadened and actually shifted from their k, = 0 positions. In view of this it is clear why early attempts to understand the spectra with the k , = 0 assumption were unsuccessful. In earlier FIR work, Button rt al. observed “Luttinger” effects in the hole cyclotron resonance spectra in InSb (99) and Ge (100) using an HCN laser. However, these experiments did not make use of uniaxial stress to clarify the data and lines were identified only on the basis of the spherical Luttinger model with k, = 0. At this writing a FIR magneto-optical study
64
BRUCE D. MCCOMBE AND ROBERT J. WAGNER
comparable to the microwave work of HS has not been published. A detailed comparison of the techniques and experimental conditions for the two types of experiments is illuminating in this regard. Ranvaud's recent uniaxial stress measurements on hole cyclotron resonance in Ge and InSb using a FIR HCN laser (87) allow a direct comparison of the two methods. In the microwave work, the high purity sample is maintained at a temperature of 1.2"K while holes (and electrons) are optically excited with near infrared radiation. A high Q cavity is used in conjunction with a microwave bridge to increase sensitivity. Adequate cyclotron resonance signals can be detected with hole densities of only 108-10'ocm-3 in a thin layer only a few microns thick. In the FIR, a single pass transmission method is generally '
TABLE V COMPARISON OF THFRMAL A N I I PHOTONE \ ~ K G I EFSO R THE MICROWAVEA N D FIR LASER EXPFRIMENTS
DISCUSSED ic THE TEXT
Microwave
0.2 19
0.103 ( T = 1.2"K)
2.126
Laser
3.618
1.124 (T = 20'K)
2.133
used. This requires a significantly larger number of carriers in order to obtain an observable cyclotron resonance signal. Thus Ranvaud utilized samples 2-3 mm thick which were intentionally doped with 10'4-1016 acceptor impurities per cubic centimeter. Free carriers were thermally excited at temperatures 2 20°K. The two techniques are compared in Table V. Note that the condition ho > k , T is equivalently satisfied in both, even though the FIR frequency is 17 times the microwave frequency. In addition the necessity of using rather highly doped material to obtain sufficient carriers for the FIR experiments serves to degrade the carrier scattering time, 5, and to broaden the cyclotron resonance lines. In fact, where HS observed a dozen lines, Ranvaud (87) was able to resolve only four. O n the other hand, for materials such as InSb, where the inherent purity is significantly worse than that of Ge, the advantages of the microwave technique are lost and the necessary condition for sharp resonances, w c s >> 1, is better satisfied in the FIR. For the case of Ge Ranvaud was able to achieve a good fit to his uniaxial stress data using Luttinger parameters that agree well with those of HS.
INTRABAND MAGNETO-OPTICAL STUDIES OF SEMICONDUCTORS. I
65
However in InSb Ranvaud found a qualitatively unexplained stress dependence for one of the fundamental transitions. In the absence of a suitable explanation for the stress dependence of this crucial transition, it is difficult to obtain a reliable set of Luttinger parameters from these measurements. As in the case of electron cyclotron resonance, FIR laser sources can be extremely useful for the measurement of classical hole cyclotron resonance when material quality is poor, i.e. when w,z < 1 in the microwave region. With sufficiently high magnetic fields wCoccurs in the FIR and the condition w, z > 1 can often be achieved. This is the approach recently used by Bradley et al. (101) in their measurement of the “classical” light and heavy hole masses in Gap, a typical zinc blende structure semiconductor. Using pulsed magnetic fields up to 200 kG these authors were able to resolve the cyclotron resonances for carriers with effective masses of 0.16 mo and 0.54 m, . This application o f F I R laser techniques promises to be extremely fruitful in the characterization of semiconductors with heavy mass valence bands; to date very few such materials have been investigated in any detail. “
”
2. 1nl;erted Band Ordering: HgTe
As discussed previously HgTe and alloys of Cd,Hg, -,Te with x 5 0.16 possess the “inverted” zone center band structure (Fig. 10). Due to the relatively small energy gap ( E , = 0.3 eV) and the degeneracy of the T, conduction and valence bands, a more general treatment than either the BY model or the Luttinger model for degenerate bands is necessary to properly account for both the nonparabolicity of the conduction band at higher energies and the “Luttinger” effects (similar to those just discussed for Ge) at lower energies. Groves et al. (16) have provided such a generalization based on the earlier work of Pidgeon and Brown (35) for InSb. In this treatment states at k = 0 are divided into two groups. One group (A) consists of the strongly interacting (closely bunched) states of interest, Ts,T8,and r, ; the other group (B) includes all the other states. Interactions of the k * p type between a given state in A and the states in B are removed to second order in k by the LK approach. The resulting renormalized interaction among the states in A gives an 8 x 8 interaction Hamiltonian which is diagonalized exactly by computer for k , = 0. Groves et al. have used this approach to fit their interband magnetoreflection data for both r6+ T8 and T8-+ Ts transitions in HgTe and to obtain an appropriate set of band parameters. Leung and Liu (102) have generalized the theoretical approach of Groves et al. (16) to include the effects of k, # 0. Experimental studies of interband (r, valence + T, conduction) and intraband (T, conduction) magnetoabsorption in HgTe in the spectral region between 2 mm and 100 pm have been reported by Tuchendler et al. “
”
66
BRUCE D . MCCOMBE A N D ROBERT J. WAGNER
(103). In addition transitions which did not extrapolate to zero energy at zero magnetic field were observed. The latter lines were attributed to transitions involving “resonant acceptor impurity states which are degenerate with the r; band continuum in zero field. Both carcinotron and FIR laser sources were used in these experiments. Examples of some of these data are shown in Fig. 22. Experiments were performed in both the Faraday (longitudinal) and Voigt (transverse) geometries. In the Voigt geometry, due to the ”
FARADAY CONFIGURATION
c
c
2’
e w
a
CR
I
0
I
10
20
1
I
I
30
40
50
B(kG) FIG. 22. Transmission versus magnetic field for a thin sample ( 5 10 pm) of HgTe. The trace at 775 pm was obtained with a carcinotron source while the other two traces were obtained with HCN (311 pm) and H,O (1 18.6 pm) laser sources. The line labeled CR is cyclotron resonance and that labeled S is “spin” resonance. [After Tuchendler er a / . (103).]
significant number of free carriers, the cyclotron resonance at lower frequencies was found to be “plasma-shifted” to lower fields as compared to the position of the cyclotron resonance in the Faraday geometry. At higher photon energies the positions of these lines coincided. The position of the plasma-shifted cyclotron resonance is usually given by = 47~Ne~/&,m* is the plasma frequency, N is where wpcr= [ m i + the carrier concentration, and E~ is generally taken to be the low frequency dielectric constant, independent of frequency. However, in a zero gap semiconductor such as HgTe the ri --+ ri interband transitions contribute a frequency dependent term to the dielectric function which can extend to zero frequency. Only by taking this contribution into account were these authors able to obtain agreement between the calculated and observed positions of the plasma-shifted cyclotron resonance.
INTRABAND MAGNETO-OPTICAL STUDIES OF SEMICONDUCTORS. I
67
Tuchendler et a/. also identified an electric-dipole “spin resonance for ”
E IB (labeled “ S ” in Fig. 22) and a “combined” resonance for E’IIB (not shown). The spherical Luttinger model was used to provide a theoretical framework for the interpretation of these low energy transitions. As discussed in Section IV,B “spin” is not a good quantum number in these degenerate bands for the lowest levels; thus spin-flip transitions are not well defined. The “spin” transition is presumably a transition from state (1, - 1/2) in the a-set to state (1, -3/2) in the b-set. Again states are specified by ( H ’ , mJ).By reference to the discussion of Section IV,B it is easily seen that the total wavefunctions for these states are Y t ( a ) = (Dl I3/2.
-
1/2)
and
Y’,+(b) = (D, I3/2, -3/2),
respectively. It is not clear, however, why a transition matrix element between these states should be non-zero, since both initial and final states have odd parity. It is possible that inversion asymmetry (which has been neglected) may allow this transition by relaxing the parity selection rule. From a fit to the various observed transitions Tuchendler et a/. have obtained a set of Luttinger parameters which adequately describe their results as well as the interband rz + rC, results of Guldner et a/. (104). In the latter work low energy transitions ( h ~ - oE, < ~ 30~meV) ~ were ~ ~fit using ~ the spherical Luttinger model, while higher energy transitions were fit with the BY model. There is some justification for the use of the spherical approximation, since from the work of Groves et al. the anisotropy is not large (yz - y3)/yz = 0.12. However, the parameters obtained from these experiments, which are mutually consistent, are in some disagreement with the results of Groves et aI. except for the low temperature energy gap. The parameters are compared in Table VI. As can be seen from the table the largest discrepancy is in y1 (35%). The reasons for the discrepancy are not clear. Certainly the theoretical approach of Groves et a/. is more rigorous than the “marriage” of two models used by Guldner et a/. and Tuchendler et a/.; on the other hand, the experimental work of the latter authors is more extensive and detailed (especially since it includes intraband measurements for the r: band). It is possible that k, effects which were found to be very important in Ge by Hensel and Suzuki could account for this discrepancy since such effects were neglected in the interpretation of the experimental data by both groups. However, Guldner et a/. have calculated the k,-dependence of the r energy levels for high symmetry directions. These effects appear to be unimportant for the Ts band levels, and by intrainterband transitions as well as the implication for the P6+ band transitions. In view ofthis it seems that additional work is required for a complete understanding of the degenerate valence-conduction bands of HgTe.
68
BRUCE D. MCCOMBE A N D ROBERT J . WAGNER
TABLE VI
BAND PARAMETERS FOR HgTe"
0.3025 0.3025
- 12.8
- 10.5
8.4 -9.9
~
- 16.98
- 11.29
(103. 104) (16, 105)
" Luttinger parameters are calculated from the higher band parameters of Groves et a/. (16)as follows: 7, = j,2
=
~, , -
=
with E ,
=
?!b.
-
= - 16.98
;.;.b. .,hb.
-
=
~
&b
Ep/3E, Ep/6E, EP/6E, - E,/6E,
10.49 9.32 - 11.29 ~
= -
=
18.1 eV.
3. Tellurium n. Theoretical background. Recently, a large number of FIR magnetooptic experiments have been performed on tellurium. This is in part due to its relatively unique and interesting energy band structure, and in part due to the availability of high quality single crystal material. The crystal structure consists of atoms arranged in spiral chains with three atoms per spiral and spirals situated in a hexagonal arrangement. The Brillouin zone is a hexagonal prism with the crystal c-axis perpendicular to the prism face. In contrast to the diamond or zinc blende zonecentered valence bands, the valence band maxima of tellurium are located at the H-points, corners of hexagonal faces of the Brillouin zone. H u h (106) has suggested a description of the valence bands using a k * p perturbation approach. When the effects of spin-orbit interaction are included, two possible energy band schemes can occur as shown in Fig. 23. These two cases simply reflect different choices of the parameters in the energy-momentum relations (hole energies are measured positive downward with the energy zero taken to be the position of the valence bands at H in the absence of spin):
E E
= 3 , 4=
+ Bok: [ S : k ; + 4Af]1'2 - A 2 . Ak2L + B OkZ, f [S\kt + a2k:]' + A2 , Akt
(82)
where k: = k: + k : . In Fig: 23 and Eqs. (82) we have used a slightly modified version of the notation of Doi et al. (107) who have presented a rigorous calculation using the k p formulation. A comparison between these parameters and those used by other workers is given in Table VII. In Eqs. (82) the z-direction is
-
INTRABAND MAGNETO-OPTICAL STUDIES OF SEMICONDUCTORS. I
69
,
taken parallel to the c-axis, and El, E,, and E3, correspond to the H,, H , , and H, states, respectively. The parameters A , B o , S1, and S , represent momentum matrix elements between the valence bands and higher bands, and A 1 and A2 are proportional to the spin-orbit splittings of the valence bands. As is apparent from Eqs. (82) the curvature of H, in the z-direction
H
kz
+kZ
(a 1
(b)
FIG. 23. Schematic E versus k , relationship showing the valence band structure of tellurium in the neighborhood of the H-point of the Brillouin zone (this point is also designated M by some workers (108, 1 2 I ) ) with spin-orbit interaction included. In (a) ( I S : / B , I > 4 1 A , I ) the uppermost valence band exhibits the “camelback” structure. I n (b) ( I S : / B , I < 4 I A 1 I ) it has a single maximum at the H-point. The H, and H, bands are nondegenerate as are the H, bands (except at k , = 0) since their Kramers conjugate states occur at the nonequivalent point H’ due to the lack of inversion symmetry of the tellurium structure.
depends critically on the size of I S:/Bo I relative to 4 I A l I . With I S:/Bo I > 4 1 A 1 1 , the “camelback” of Fig. 23a results. If I S:/Bo 1 .< 4 1 A1 1 , a single maximum at the H-point occurs as in Fig. 23b. In the case of Fig. 23a, 1 kzO1, the magnitude of kZ at the maximum, is [Sf - 16Bg A:]”*/2 1 Bo S1 1 and the energy difference E(k,o) - E ( 0 ) 5 6
=
S:( 1
-
4Bo I A 1 I /S:)/4
I Bo I.
TABLE VII A
NOTATION FOR TELLURIUM BAND PARA METERS^
COMPARISON OF THE
Doi er a/. (107)
Betbeder-Matibet and H u h ( I 1I )
Weiler (108)
In order to avoid confusion with the magnetic induction, B, has been used instead of B in Doi er al. (107).
70
BRUCE D. MCCOMBE AND ROBERT J. WAGNER
Unlike the rather dramatic changes in shape of the H, band, the shape of
H, and H, remain relatively insensitive to changes in the parameters. Thus since the H, band lies highest and is easily populated with free holes, it provides an ideal situation for intraband magneto-optical studies to determine the band parameters. Rather than outline the detailed calculations of the upper valence band structure of tellurium in the presence of a magnetic field (108-210), we present here a simplified description of the upper (H4) band which is due to Betbeder-Matibet and H u h (111). This simple approach provides a good deal of physical insight into the energy levels and selection rules, while it avoids the mathematical complexities of the more rigorous treatments. Two cases can be distinguished: (a) BJIc,and (b) B Ic. For case (a) the energy in the z-direction is not modified by the presence of the magnetic field. Since the energy in the transverse direction is a quadratic function of k , the transverse motion goes over directly to the Landau quantization as in Section 11, i.e. Ak: + ( a l/;?)ho,. , where ha),, = -2AeB/h. In this somewhat simplified model the separation between adjacent Landau levels is a constant independent of either 11 or k , . However, when higher order terms in the E-k relationship are taken into account, this no longer holds true. The effects of including the higher order terms will be discussed later. For case (b) (B Ic) one must distinguish between the two possibilities shown in Fig. 23. The choice of parameters leading to Fig. 23b would not yield any qualitatively different effects in the presence of an applied magnetic field. O n the other hand the “camelback of Fig. 23a demands special attention. Betbeder-Matibet and H u h (111) have shown that for an electron in the “camelback” band with Bilk, one can obtain an effective onedimensional Schrodinger equation by making the following substitutions in the expression for E , [Eq. (82)]:
+
”
k,
---f
(AIB,)’ 4(eB/H)112X, k,
+
(B,/A)”4(eB/”)’ 2(d/dX)
and E
+ (AB,)’
2(eB/h)c
+ ,412;.
The resulting one-dimensional equation, which yields a good approximation to the energy levels. is d2Y -
dX2
+ V ( X ) Y = EY,
with V ( X )= x 2 - (A;
+ 4(2X2)’/2 + A,
INTRABAND MAGNETO-OPTICAL STUDIES OF SEMICOKDUCTORS. 1
7I
and
A,
=
2(AB,)- ' / 2 ( e B / h ) -'/,Al,
A,
=
( A l l , ) - "'(eB/h)- 1/2A2,
t2 = (Bo/A)"2(eB/h)-'(S,/2Bo). It should be noted that V ( X ) remains unchanged under inversion; X + - X ; hence parity is a good quantum number. For small values of B, V ( X )appears as two separated, harmonic oscillator-like potential wells with minima at
X
=
iX,,
where
X,
=
(Bo/A)'~4(~B/h)-''2k,o.
In the low field limit the iiiterwell barrier is 8 = ( A & - '/'(eB/h)- '6. In this case there is only a slight coupling between potentials. As a result, the two sets of Landau levels are nearly degenerate with E,,t
=
E n = ( n + +)(heB/m.c)
(84)
and the wavefunction can be written Y,,
= 2- 1'2[Qn(X
-
X,) i @),(X + X,)],
(85)
where Qn is a harmonic oscillator function. As B is increased, the separation 2 X , and barrier height 8 of the two wells decreases. This results in increased coupling of the two sets of Landau levels and a splitting of the previously degenerate n' states into n+ and y1-. It is clear that if the camelback condition prevails in tellurium, it will be apparent in the splitting of cyclotron resonance transitions at high fields. Electric dipole selection rules require n' + ( n + 1)-, i.e. allowed transitions are those between states of odd parity with respect to X . The inclusion of higher order terms in k, as done in the more rigorous treatments (108, 110) relaxes this rule somewhat. b. Esperimental results. The availability of high quality p-type tellurium has resulted in very detailed investigations of the valence band structure described above. From early low magnetic field sub-millimeter work (I12), it was concluded that the band was anisotropic with m* (Bilc) = 0.11 m, and m* (B Ic) = 0.26 mo . However, oscillatory magnetoresistance (Shubnikovde Haas) measurements suggested the presence of the camelback condition (113, 114) as did later microwave cyclotron resonance (115). Couder (116), using carcinotron sources from 405-1080 pm (740-278 GHz) and fields to 55 kG, first observed the splitting which is expected from the "camelback" condition. As shown in Fig. 24 for B Ic the primary cyclotron absorption F, observed at 278 and 308 GHz splits into F, and F, at 353 GHz. In addition to these free carrier resonances other lines S,, S, ,and I observed by Couder were attributed to transitions involving impurity states.
72
BRUCE D. MCCOMBE A K D ROBERT J . WAGNER
Following Couder's early work, a number of authors have employed submillimeter lasers (I 17,118) and FIR nionochromators ( I 19) to study the higher energy/magnetic field region of the E versus B plot. The data obtained prior to 1971 have been compiled by Nakao et al. (110) and these data are shown in Fig. 25. The calculation of Nakao et a/. for the transition
I
20
1
BkG)
55
FIG.24. Experimental traces o f transmitted power versus magnetic lield for Te with B i c at the indicated frequencies. The primary low frequency absorption line, F,, splits into two lines, F F z , at higher frequencies. Additional lines. S S,, and I, were attributed t o impurity state transitions. [After Couder (116).]
,,
,,
CY CLOIRON RESONANCE ( H i c)
MAGNETIC FIELD (kOe)
FIC;.25. Transition energies of cyclotron resonance in Te for the case of H I c'. The solid 0,x . and 0 and dashed curves are the calculations of Nakao et a/. (110).The symbols 0, represent the experimental data of Yoshizaki and Tanaka (119) Dreybrodt era[.(118), Couder (116), and Radoff and Dexter (115), respectively. The solid lines correspond to allowed transitions and the dashed lines correspond to forbidden transitions. [From Nakao et irl. (110).]
INTRABAND MAGKETO-OPTICAL STUDIES OF SEMICONDUCTORS. I
73
energies is indicated by the solid (allowed) and dashed (forbidden) lines. Their choice of parameters yielded an energy of 2.54 meV for the height of the camelback ” maximum above the H-point energy. The forbidden transitions O + -+ I + and 0- + 1- have also been observed. These transitions were first identified by Dreybrodt et al. (118). When warping terms of the form k,(k: - 3k:) are included in the k p Hamiltonian, these forbidden transitions become allowed for B I/ bisectrix (B parallel to the hexagonal face of the Brillouin zone and perpendicular to the side of the prism); they remain unallowed for B 1 binary axis (108) (B parallel to the hexagonal face and parallel to the prism side). Experimental results have shown these forbidden transitions in both orientations. The reason for their appearance with B /I binary is not yet understood. Recent work by Couder et al. (120) has clarified the region of 1-2 meV and 10-40 kG. These measurements have confirmed the assignments shown in Fig. 25. Couder et al. also explored the dependence of cyclotron resonance on the angle between B and the c-axis for frequencies both above and below the splitting region. They were able to describe all aspects of their results satisfactorily with the simple camelback model. In the light of the above discussion, it is somewhat surprising that the B/lc orientation seems to have been a greater source of interpretational difficulty than B Ic. Although Couder observed a single absorption line as might be anticipated for low concentration samples, Yoshizaki and Tanaka (119) have reported a much more complicated spectrum for their samples with p z 10’4-1016cm-3. They argued that, although some of the observed spectral features were due to impurity transitions, two of the lines were free hole cyclotron resonance lines, one arising from transitions at the H-point and one from transitions at the valence band maxima, k k,, . It should be reiterated that for the simplified model described above there is no dependence of ho,,Il on k,; thus with this model there could be only one cyclotron resonance line irrespective of where the transitions originate. In the more sophisticated models (108, 110) higher order terms (k: and k t k : ) enter, and these terms give rise to a dependence of hw,, lI on k , as well as on n. At low energies (e.g., the work of Couder et a/.) these terms are unimportant. Bangert and Dreybrodt (121) have calculated the absorption coefficient for cyclotron resonance for the B/lc geometry. Using the model and band parameters of Nakao et al. (110), they found that if a weak broadening mechanism exists, the density of states singularity at the H-point is washed out, and the dominant contribution to the absorption coefficient comes from transitions near the peaks of the “camelback” ( k k , , ) rather than the H-point. This conclusion is in agreement with calculations by von Ortenberg et al. (122). On the basis of these calculations and the other experimental results, it must be concluded that the additional line observed “
-
“
”
74
BRUCE D. MCCOMBE A N D ROBERT J. WAGNER
by Yoshizaki and Tanaka was not an H-point cyclotron resonance transition. As discussed below, in less pure samples interference” effects can give rise to additional structure near cyclotron resonance, and this may be the explanation for the additional line. Bangert and Dreybrodt also noted that a significant line shift should occur on heating from 4.2” to 77°K. von Ortenberg et al. (122) have studied the line position for both BI/c and B Ic as a function of temperature up to 120°K. In order to avoid complications due to interference and (or) impurity effects, they were careful to use the highest purity samples available ( p “v 4 x cmp3). They attempted to fit the experimental results with three different models (108, 110, 123) each based on Doi’s zero field k * p formulation. They found that even qualitative agreement required the introduction of a temperature-dependent broadening factor. von Ortenberg et al. concluded that the model of Weiler (108) provided the best fit to their data. Although all experimental workers have reported some evidence of impurity lines, the results are frequently inconsistent with each other as well as with shallow acceptor results in other materials. Probably the most reliable information has been obtained by Couder et at. (120) using material with p z 1013 ~ m - From ~ . the field dependence of three impurity lines, they concluded that an impurity bound state exists with ionization energy of 1.24 meV. As in the case of shallow acceptors in most Groups IV or IIILV semiconductors, they find the intensity of the inpurity lines weakens with increased temperature. Similarly, Dreybrodt et ul. (118) have studied the temperature dependence of a number of lines, both cyclotron resonance transitions and impurity transitions. They found a dramatic difference in the temperature dependences of these two types of lines and made use of this to identify the impurity transitions. However, the impurity binding energy deduced from these measurements was 0.4 meV. In contrast to the above work, Yoshizaki and Tanaka (119,124). using more heavily doped material, found that the lines that they attributed to impurities increased in intensity with increasing temperature. Yoshizaki and Tanaka (119) and von Ortenberg et al. (122) both found that increased impurity concentration increased the intensity of the subsidiary (impurity) structure relative to the cyclotron resonance lines. It seems more likely that this is indicative of the presence of “interference” effects similar to those described by Cronburg and Lax (125), and not representative of impurity effects in the higher concentration samples. “Interference effects can arise when the index of refraction, K , of the material under investigation varies with respect to photon energy or magnetic field in the neighborhood of a strong absorption line. This change of index can manifest itself in at least two distinctly different ways. On the one hand, the effective sample “
”
INTRABAND MAGNETO-OPTICAL STUDIES OF SEMICONDUCTORS. I
75
thickness, ~ dcan , change with an attendant constructive or destructive interference when A(icd) is some multiple of a quarter wavelength. However, this effect requires a sample with parallel faces, a condition usually purposely avoided in the experiments. O n the other hand, “Faraday” rotation of the light polarization by the sample (which results from the difference between K ~ and ~ K, , - ~ ~can ) cause marked effects when light pipe techniques are used. If the radiation is asymmetrically distributed across the cross section of the light pipe, it is possible for the walls of the pipe between the sample and detector to act as an analyzer of Faraday-rotated light. This can also give rise to oscillations in the apparent sample transmission which resemble weaker absorption lines on the shoulder of the main line. It is clear that further work is required to clarify the situation concerning acceptor impurity transitions in Te. Some information about the conduction band at the H-point has been obtained from interband magneto-optical measurements. For this work, Doi et al. (126) have performed a k p calculation for the conduction band. In fitting their data, they obtain m* (B//c)= 0.05 m, and m” (B i c ) = 0.145 i n , . In the only apparent observation of electron cyclotron resonance Button et al. (117) found m* (B Ic ) = 0.135 m, at 200”K, in fair agreement with the interband results.
-
ACKNOWLEDGMENTS We have benefited from helpful discussions with S. Teitler, J. C. Hensel, R. Kaplan, R. Ranvaud, K. L. Ngai, and W. Dreybrodt during the course of this work. J. C. Hensel and R. Ranvaud kindly provided figures and manuscripts prior to publication. Wc would like to express our gratitude to Mrs. L. Graham, Mrs. G. Garrett, Mrs. L. Blohm, Mrs. C. Hepler, and Miss I. Lajko for their efforts in typing various drafts of the manuscript. One of us (B.D.M.) would like to thank the Max-Planck-lnstitut fur Festkorperforschung, Stuttgart for hospitality extended during a sabbatical year while part of the manuscript was prepared.
REFERENCES I. 2. 3. 4. 5.
6. 7. 8. 9.
M. Cardona, Solid State Pkxs., Suppl. 11 (1969). R. L. Aggarwal, in “Semiconductors and Semimetals” (R. K. Willardson and A. C. Beer. eds.), Vol. 9, p. 151. Academic Press, New York, 1972. B. Lax and J. G. Mavroides, Solid Slate Phys. 11, 261 (1960). J. G. Mavroides, in “Optical Properties of Solids” (F. Abelks, ed.). p. 351. North-Holland Publ., Amsterdam, 1972. E. D. Palik and J. K. Furdqna, Rep. P m p . Phys. 33, 1193 (1970). R. H. Dicke and J. P. Wittke, “Introduction to Quantum Mechanics.” p. 260. AddisonWesley, Reading, Massachusetts, 1960. M. H. Johnson and B. A. Lippmann, Pl7j.s. Rev. 76, 828 (1949). L. D. Landau, 2. Pkys. 64, 629 (1930). M. V. Klein, “Optics,” p. 487. Wiley, New York, 1970.
76
BRUCE D. MCCOMBE AND ROBERT J. WAGNER
10. C. Kittel, “Quantum Theory of Solids,” p. 179. Wiley, New York, 1963. 11. J. M. Luttinger and W. Kohn, Phys. Rev. 97, 869 (1955). 12. T. Kjeldaas and W. Kohn, Phys. Rec. 105, 806 (1957). I?. Y. Yafet, Sofir! State P/IJ.\. 14, 15 (1963). 14. C. Kittel. “Quantum Theory or Solids.” p. 279. Wiley. New York, 1963. 15. J. M. Luttinger, Phys. REG.102, 1030 (1956). 16. S. H. Groves. R. N. Brown, and C. R. Pidgeon. Phys. Rec-. 161. 779 (1967). 17. L. C. Robinson, “Physical Principles of Far-Infrared Radiation,” Meth. Exp. Phys. (L. Marton and C. Marton, eds.), Vol. 10. Academic Press, New York, 1973. IX. J. Houghton and S. D. Smith, ”Infrared Physics.” Oxford Univ. Press (Clarendon), London and New York, 1966. 19. G. W. Chantry. *‘ Submillimeter Spectroscopy.’’ Academic Press, New York, 197 I. 20. K. D. Moller and W. G. Rothschild, “Far-Infrared Spectroscopy.” Wiley, New York, 1971. -71. E. D. Pdlik, “A Far-Infrared Bibliography,” Appendix to Moller and Rothschild, Ref. 20. -7Ztr. P. P. Sorokin, J. J . Wynne, and J. R. Lankard, A p p l . Ph!.s. Lett. 22, 342 (1973). 22h. V. T. Nguyen and T. J . Bridges, Pkys. Rer. Lett. 29. 359 (1972). -72c. R. L. Aggarwal, B. Lax, and G. Favrot, Appl. Phys. Lerr. 22, 329 (1973). 22d. D. H. Auston, A. M. Glass, and P. LeFur. Appl. Phys. Leu. 23, 47 (1973). 22e. E. Gornik, Phys. Rec. Lett. 29, 595 (1972). -73. K. D. Moller and W. G. Rothschild, “Far-Infrared Spectroscopy,” pp. 19-41. Wiley, New York, 1971. 24. F. Kneubiihl, Appl. Opt. 8, 505 (1969). 25. R. J. Bell, “Introductory Fourier Transform Spectroscopy.” Academic Press, New York. 1972. 26. J. W. Cooley and J. W. Tukey, Murh. Compurcrt. 19, 297 (1965). 27. P. Fellgett, J . P k ~ xRadium 19, 187 (1958). -78. S. D. Secombe and D. N. Korn. Solid State Comtnun. 11, 1539 (1972). 2%. R. J . Pressley, ed., “Handbook of Lasers.” pp. 334-349. Chem. Rubber Publ. Co., Cleveland, Ohio, 1971. -7Yb. T. Y. Chang and J . D. McGee, Appl. Phys. Lett. 19, 103 (1971). Z9c. H. R. Fetterman, H. R. Schlossberg, and J. Waldman. Opt. Cornmun. 6 , 156 (1972). 3 t f . S. F. Dyubko, V. A. Svich, and L. L. Fesenko, SOL..Phys.--JETP Lett. 16, 418 (1972). ?Ye. R. J. Wagner, A. J. Zelano, and L. H. Ngai, Opt. Cotnrnun. 8, 46 (1973). 29f: T. K . Plant, P. D. Coleman, and T. A. DeTemple, I E E E J . Quantum Electrot?. 9. 962 (1973). 2Y~q. D. T. Hodges, R. D. Reed, and D. H. Barker, fEEE J . Q ~ r u ~ t ~ iElrcfroti. ini 9. 1159 (1973). 30. R. J . Wagner and G. A. Prinz, Appl. Opt. 10, 2060 (1971). 31. R. C. Ohlmann, P. L. Richards, and M. Tinkham, J . Opt. Soc. Amer. 48, 531 (1958). 32. F. R. Arams, ed., “ Infrared to Millimeter Wavelength Detectors.” Artech House, Ded ham, Massachusetts, 1973. 33tr. R. Kaplan, M. A. Kinch, and W. C . Scott, Solid Store Conmun. 7, 883 (1969). 33h. G. E. Stillman, C. M. Wolfe, and J. 0. Dimmock, Solid S f a t e Cornrnun. 7, 921 (1969). 34. J. W. Hodby. iri ‘‘ Polarons in Ionic Crystals and Polar Semiconductors” (J. T. Devreese, ed.). p. 389. North-Holland Publ.. Amsterdam, 1972. 35. C. R. Pidgeon and R . N. Brown, Phys. Rec. 146, 575 (1966). 36. R . L. Bell and K. T. Rogers, Phys. Rer. 152, 746 (1966). 37. E. 0. Kane, J . Phys. Chern. Solids 1, 249 (1957). 38. R. Bowers and Y. Yafet, Phys. Rev. 115. 1165 (1959). ZY. E. Burstein, G. S. Picus. and H. A. Gebbie, Phys. Rev. 103, 825 (1956). 40. E. D. Pahk, G. S. Picus, S. Teitler, and R. F. Wallis, Phys. Rev. 122, 475 (1961). 41. B. Lax, J. G. Mavroides, H. J. Zeiger. and R. J . Keyes. Ph!..s. Ret:. 122, 31 (1961).
INTRABAND MAGNETO-OPTICAL STUDIES OF SEMICONDUCTORS. I
42. 43. 44. 45. 46. 47. 48. 49. 50. 51. 52.
53. 54. 55. 56. 57. 58. 59. 60. 61. 62. 63. 64. 65. 66. 67. 68. 69. 70. 71. 72. 73. 74. 75. 76. 77. 78. 79. 80. 81. 82. 83. 84. 85. 86.
77
E. J. Johnson and D. H. Dickey, Phps. Rec. B I, 2676 (1970). K. L. I. Kobayashi and E. Otsuka, Solid State Cownnun. 11, 815 (1972). T. Murotani and Y. Nisida, J . Pkys. Soc. J a p . 32, 986 (1972). R. J. Keyes, S. Zwerdling, S. Foner, H. H. Kolm, and B. Lax, Phys. Rev. 104, 1804 (1956). E. D. Palik, G. S. Picus, S. Teitler, and R. F. Wallis, Phys. Rec. 122, 475 (1961). E. D. Palik and R. F. Wallis, Phys. Rev. 123, 131 (1961). E. D. Palik and J. R. Stevenson, Pbys. Rec. 130, 1344 (1963). C. W. Litton, R. B. Dennis, and S. D. Smith, J . Phjis. C 2, 2146 (1969). J. M. Chamberlain. P. E. Simmonds, R. A. Stradling. and C. C. Bradley, Proc. Int. Conc P/ij.s. Setnicond., l l t b , Warsaw, 1972, p. 1016. PWN-Polish Sci. Publ., Warsaw, 1972. E. D. Palik, J. R. Stevenson, and R. F. Wallis, Pkys. Rev. 124, 701 (1961). H. Fetterman, J. Waldrnan, and C. M. Woife, Solid State Cornrnun. 11, 375 (1972). 0. Berolo, J. C. Woolley, and J. A. Van Vechten, Phys. Rev. B 8, 3794 (1973). S. H. Groves and W. Paul. Phys. Rev. Lerr. 11. 194 (1963). J. Waldman, D. M. Larsen, P. E. Tannenwald, C. C . Bradley, D. R. Cohn, and B. Lax, Pl7I.s. Rev. Left. 23, 1033 (1969). A. J. Strauss, T. C. Harman, J . G. Mavroides, D. H. Dickey, and M. S. Dresselhaus, Proc. I n t . Conj: PI7ys. Sernicond.. Exeter, Eng. p. 703. Inst. Phys., Phys. Soc., London, 1962. M. A. Kinch and D. D. Buss, .I. Phys. Chern. Solids 32, Suppl. 1; 461 (1971). K. J. Button, C. G. Fonstad, and W. Dreybrodt, Phys. Rev. B 4, 4539 (1970). A. Kawabata, J . Phys. SOC.Jap. 23, 999 (1967). E. E. H. Shin, P. N. Argyres, and B. Lax, Phj,.s. Rev. Left. 28, 1634 (1972); Phys. Rru. B 7, 3572 (1973). J. R. Apel, T. 0. Poehler. C. R. Westgate, and R. A. Joseph, Phys. Rea. B 4,436 (1971). R. Kaplan, B. D. McCornbe, and R. J. Wagner, Solid State Cornn~un.12, 967 (1973). E. I. Rashba and V. I . Sheka, Soc. Pby.s.-Solitf Sttrte 3. 1257. 1357 (1961). Y. Yafet, Solid Stare Pl71.s. 14, 41 (1963). V. 1. Sheka, Sou. Phys.-Solid State 6, 2470 (1965). G. E. Gurgenishvilli, Soc. Php.-Solid Srate 5, 1510 (1964). I. I. Boiko, SOC.Phps-Solid State 4, 1558 (1963). P. Wolff, J . Phys. Clzern. Solids 25, 1057 (1964). D. Kacman and W. Zawadzki. Pbys. Status Solitli 47, 629 (1971). B. D. McCombe, Phys. Rec. 181, 1206 (1969). A. S. Saleh and H. Y. Fan, Phys. Rev. 182, 790 (1969). W. Zawadzki, in “New Developments in Semiconductors” (P. R. Wallace, R. Harris, and M. J. Zuckermann. eds.), p. 441. NoordhoK, Leyden, 1972. B. D. McCombe, S. G. Bishop, and R. Kaplan, Phys. Rev. Lett. 18. 748 (1967). R. L. Bell, Phys. Reu. Lett. 9, 52 (1962). B. D. McCombe, R. J. Wagner, and G. A. Prinz. Phys. Rev. Lett. 25. 87 (1970). B. D. McCombe and R. J. Wagner, Proc. I n r . Conj. Pliys. Sernimnd.. I l t h , Wtrrsuw, 1972, p. 321. PWN-Polish Sci. Publ., Warsaw, 1972. S. H. Groves, T. C. Harman, and C. R. Pidgeon, Solid Stare Cornrnun. 9, 451 (1971). 3.D. McCombe and R. 1. Wagner, Phyx Rec. B 4, 1285 (1971). B. D. McCombe, Proc. I n f . Con$ Sernicond.-Seiiiimetal Transiriori, *Vice, 1973. S. R. J. Brueck and F. A. Blum, Phys. Rec. Lett. 28, 1458 (1972). R. W. Davies, Pbys. Rev. B 7, 3731 (1973). Y. C. S. Auyang (S. Y. Yuen), Ph.D. Thesis, Mass. Inst. of Technol., Cambridge, Massachusetts, 1971. Also S. Y. Yuen. P. A. WolH: and B. Lax. Pb1.s. Rer. B 9, .1394 (1974). C. R. Pidgeon, D. L. Mitchell, and R. N. Brown, Phys. Rea. 154, 737 (1967). R. A. Isaacson, Phys. Rer. 169. 312 (1968). S. H. Groves, J . Phys. Chetn. Solids 32, Suppl. I. 447 (1971). J. C . Hensel. Phys. Rev. Lett. 21, 983 (1968).
78 X7. XK.
X9. 90. Y1.
97. Yj. Y4. 95. Y6. Y7.
98. YY. 100. 101.
B R U C E D. MCCOMBE A N D ROBERT J. W A G N E R
R. Ranvatid. P1i.D. Thesis. Brown Unit.. Providence, Rhode Island, 1973. J . C. Hensel and K. Suzuki. Proc. f r i r . Cord. Phys. Semicond., 10tl7, Cu!tihr.it/yr, Mussuchusetts. p. 541. USAEC. DIV.of Tech. Info.. Oak Ridge. Tenn., 1970. J. C. Burgiel and L. C. Hebel, Phys. Rev. A 140, 925 (1965). E. J. Tichovolsky and J. G . Mavroides, So1id Stute Cornrizzrrl. 7. 927 (1969). G . E. Smith. G . A. Baraff. and J. M. Rowell, Plzys. Rer. 4 135. 1118 (1964). M. H. Cohen and E. 1. Blount, Phil. May. 5, 115 (1960). J. C. Hensel and K . Suzuki. N u t . Birr.. S f a n d . ( U S ) . Spec. Pirhl. 323, 431 (1971). K . Suzuki and J . C. Hensel, Phys. Rer. B 9, 4184 (1974). J. C. Hensel and K. Suzuki, PIrj..s. Rer. B 9, 4219 (1974). R. F. Wallis and H. J. Bowlden, Phjx Rev. 118, 456 (1960). R. C. Fletcher, W. A. Yager, and F. R. Merritt, Phys. Rec. 100, 747 (1955). H. Fujiyasu, K. Murase, and E. Otsuka. J . Phys. Soc. J a p . 29, 685 (1970). K. J . Button, B. Lax. and C. C. Bradley, Phys. Rei,. Lett. 21, 350 (1968). K. J. Button. in “Optical Properties of Solids” (E. D. Haidemenakis, ed.), p. 253. Gordon & Breach. New York. 1970. C. C. Bradley. P. E. Sinimonds, J. R. Stockton, and R. A. Stradling, Solid Srufe Cotiirtitr?z.
12, 413 (1973). 102. W. Leung and L. Liu, Phya. Rer. B 8. 381 I (1973). 103. J . Tuchendler, M. Grynberg. Y. Couder, H. Thome. and R. LeToullec. Ph!..\. Rr~i..B 8, 3884 (1973). 104. Y. Guldner, C. Rigaux. M. Grynberg, and A. Mycielski. Phj,s. Rec. B 8, 3875 (1973). 1 0 5 . C. R. Pidgeon and S. H. Groves. iri ”11-VI Semiconducting Compounds; 1967 International Conference” (D. G . Thomas. ed.). p. 1080. Benjamin. New York. 1967. 106. M. Hulin, J . Phys. Chem. Solids 27, 441 (1966). 107. T. Doi, K. Nakao. and H. Kamimura, J . P h y . SOL..Jtrp. 28, 36 (1970). 108. M. H. Weiler. Solid Sture Cor~nzurz.8, 1017 (1970). 109. M. S. Bresler and D. V. Mashovets. Phys. Sfatus Solidi 39. 421 (1970). 11(J. K. Nakao, T. Doi, and H. Kamimura. J . Phys. Soc. J u p . 30. 1400 (1971). 1 1 1 0. Betbeder-Matibet and M. Hulin. P/iy.\. Sicitu.< Solid; 36. 573 (1969). 112. J. C. Picard and D. L. Carter, J . PI1j.s. Soc. Jup. 21, Suppl., 202 (1966). 113. E. Braun and G. Landwehr, J . P h n . Soc. Jup. 21, Suppl., 380 (1966). 114 C . Guthmann and J. M. Thuillier. Soiitl State Corm7irn. 6. 835 (1968). 115. P. L. Radoff and R. N. Dexter. Pkrs. Srrriir.s Solid; 35. 261 (1969). 116 Y. Couder, Phy,$. Rec. Leu. 22, X90 (1969). 117. K. J. Button, G . Landwehr, C. C. Bradley, R. Grossc, and B. Lax. Phys. Rec. Lerr. 23. 14 ( 1969). 118 W. Dreybrodt, K. J. Button, and B. Lax, Solid Srure ~ O ~ J l i J i8,i ~ 1021 ~ . (1970). 1 1Y. R. Yoshizaki and S. Tanaka. .I. Phjx SOP.Jap. 30, 1389 (1971). 1-70. Y. Couder, M. H u h , and H. Thome. Phys. Reo. B 7, 4373 (1973). 121. E. Bangert and W. Dreybrodt, Solid Srare Corn~nurz.10, 623 (1972).
122.
M. von Ortenberg, K. J. Button. G. Landwehr, and D. Fischer, Phjx Rc’c. B 6. 2100 (1972).
123
W. Dreybrodt. M. H. Weiler. K. J . Button. R. Lax. and G. Landwehr. P r o c I u / . C’orif P / J ~ . .Sernicomi.. s. IOtk, Cumbrirlye. !2.luz.\cicliir.sert\, p. 347. USAEC. Div. of Tech. Info.. Oak Ridge. Tenn.. 1970. 1-74. R . Yoshizaki and S. Tanaka, Solid Srure Curnnnrri. 8. 17x9 (1970). 125. T. L. Cronburg and B. Lax, Plzr.s. Lett. A 37, 135 (1971). 126. T Doi. H. Kamimura, H . Shinno. R. Yoshizaki, and S. Tanaka. Prot.. 1 i i r . C O ~ JPhi.\. /. Se!nicoiid., I 1 f l i . Warsuw, 1972. p. 761. PWN-Polish Sci. Publ., Warsaw. 1972.
The Gyrator in Electronic Systems K . M . ADAMS
AND
E . F. A . DEPRETTERE
Depirrtnient of’ Elecrrictrl Engginerring Dert Unioersity of’Technology. Del$. Netherlands
.
AND
J . 0. VOORMAN Philips Research Laboratories. N .V . Philips’ Gloeilanipvilfubrieken. Eindhouen. Netherlands
I . Introduction .......... ....... .......... I1 . Reciprocity in Physic s ...... .......... A. Some Historical Background ..................................... B. Nonreciprocity ................................................................................. C . The Origin of Antireciprocity .............................................................. D . Further Generalizations ..................................................................... ......... 111. The Gyrator as Network Element ......... A . Historical Introduction .................................... B. Basic Properties of the Gyrator ............................................................ IV . Filters ................................................................................................... A . Introduction ............ B. Basic Configuration ........................... C . The Scattering Matrix ........................................................................ D . Ladder Filters .................................................................................... E . Resonance in Filters ........................................................................... F. Sensitivity ....................................................................................... G . The Gyrator in Filters .............. ..................................................... V . Principles of Realization of the Gyrator ........................ A . Physical Effects ...... ................................. B. Active Circuits .................................................. C . Ideal Active Network Elements .......................................... D. The Nullor ....................................................................................... E. Gyrators Constructed from Nullors and Resistors .................................... VI . Basic Electronic Design ........................................................................... A . Realization Based on Two Resistors in the Signal Path .............................. B. Realizations Based o n Four Resistors in the Signal Path ........................... C . Noise ............................................................................................. VI1 . Basic Gyrator Measurements ..................................................................... A. Introduction .................................................................................... B. The Gyrator as n-Port ........................................................................ C . The Gyrator in Its Applications ............................................................ 79
80 80 80 82 83 85 86 86 88 94 94 94 96 99 101 107 109 109 109 111
113 113 116 128 129 141 143 145 145 146 155
80
K. M. ADAMS. E. F. A. DEPRETTERE A N D J. 0. VOORMAN
VIII. Trends in Gyrator Design and Applications ................................................ A. Introduction ..................................... ......................................... B. Gyrators for Application in Consumer Pro s ...................................... C. Gyrators for Professional Use .............................................................. IX. Conclusion.. ..................................................................... References ............................................................................................
170 170 170
171 177
I. INTRODUCTION Recent developments in electronic technology combined with increasing insight into the theoretical basis of physical systems have led to a growing interest in the gyrator and its applications. On the one hand, theoretical results which have been known for more than twenty years are beginning to be applied in earnest to real systems. O n the other hand, the new technology which has made these applications possible has stimulated a reexamination of the theory and has led to new and interesting results, which in their turn can stimulate further developments in technology itself. In this survey article we report and comment on some of these developments. Our approach will be based on an attempt to extract unifying principles from the mass of data now available rather than to give an encyclopedic account of the state of the art. By so doing we cannot fail to adopt a somewhat subjective point of view, approving of some developments, disapproving of others, and being noncommittal on some questions which we d o not yet feel capable of resolving but which certainly deserve attention. We hope that by stating our premises and reasoning clearly, interest in this fascinating field will be further stimulated. Our survey will touch on historical matters, go into various theoretical questions, as well as be concerned with thoroughly practical matters such as system specification and actual hardware. The following sections are so arranged that they can be read largely independently of one another. We would emphasize, however, that for the reader who wishes to be able to apply the existing technology intelligently to his own particular system, a thorough grounding in the theory is essential. 11. RECIPROCITYI N PHYSICAL SYSTEMS
A . Some Historical Background
During the eighteenth and nineteenth centuries, mechanical systems were studied in great detail and in various degrees of generality. It was noticed that in nearly all these systems a reciprocity relation held which
THE GYRATOR IN ELECTRONIC SYSTEMS
81
manifested itself in certain symmetry relations in the coefficients of the constitutive equations of the system, and which ultimately depended on Newton’s third law of motion: the action of a particle A on a particle B is equal and is oppositely directed to the reaction of particle B on particle A.” This reciprocity relationship can be expressed in various forms such as: Let an infinitesimal external force F , acting on a system at a location P, give rise to an infinitesimal displacement x2 at a location P, when no other external force acts on the system. If now the same force F , acts externally on the system at P2 and no other external force is present, then the displacement occurring at P, is equal to x 2 . When it is possible to derive the forcedisplacement relationships from a potential energy function, then the reciprocity follows automatically as a consequence of the commutativity of the operations of partial differentiation with respect to different coordinates. Another example from classical mechanics is the reciprocity between impulsive forces and velocities, which follows from the existence of a kinetic energy function. A corresponding electrical analogue is the reciprocity relation between currents and flux linkages in a linear network of magnetically coupled coils, which follows from the existence of a magnetic energy function. As a result of relations of this type many people erroneously came to regard reciprocity as essentially connected to the concept of energy. From this point it was not difficult to infer (also erroneously) an apparently essential connection between passivity and reciprocity. This idea that passivity and reciprocity are somehow related has played an important role in the evolution of the concepts relating to reciprocity between force and velocity, but has also led to considerable harm. Thus when one comes to consider the reciprocity between voltages and currents in an electrical network, a new difficulty arises. There is no a priori reason for expecting the existence of a function which plays the same role as the energy functions already mentioned. It is true that in the case of a particular type of linear system the situation could be saved by the introduction of a dissipation function (Rayleigh, 1894). However, this step really involved begging the question, since the dissipation function could only be deduced knowing that the system (expressed in network theoretical terms) consisted of linear resistances and ideal transformers; from network theory it is known that such a system is reciprocal since it consists of reciprocal elements. In the case of nonlinear networks, for which either a content or a cocontent function exists (Millar, 1951), we find a similar reciprocity relation between the deviations of the voltages and the currents from a particular distribution of voltages and currents in the network. But again the existence of the content function can only be a priori guaranteed for a network of ideal transformers and one-port resistors with characteristics representing a “
82
K. M. ADAMS, E. F. A. DEPRETTERE A N D J . 0. VOORMAN
single-valued mapping of the currents on the voltages or of the voltages on the currents. Another development which has taken place is based on completely different considerations resulting from the study of reversibility in thermodynamic systems. Since 1931 attempts have been made to deduce symmetry relations on the basis of microscopic reversibility (de Groot and Mazur, 1962) in which the reversibility of time in the microscopic equations of a thermodynamic system is supposed to hold. However, in order to make the theory work, terms depending on a magnetic field strength have to be reversed when the time is reversed, and there are grave difficulties in deciding which variables should be regarded as thermodynamic forces and which as affinities. Further, the question of whether time should have a preferred direction of flow or be reversible and why this should be so, as well as the relation to the concepts of order and disorder (Prigogine et al., 1972), has not been satisfactorily resolved. The whole matter has been trenchantly criticized (Truesdell, 1969) as being devoid of a logical structure based on a set of sound and physically acceptable axioms. Even so it is not impossible that new studies of thermodynamics will shed light on this whole question. B. Nonreciprocit)) The physical evidence available to date indicates that there is no a priori reason for expecting any form of symmetry in the equations of general physical systems. If a symmetry does exist, then it is a result of the form of the constitutive equations of the system under investigation and not of any general physical principle. Thus the reciprocity principle as commonly understood is not a principle at all but a property of certain special classes of systems. As we have already seen in the previous section, there is a close relation between reciprocity and energy when certain other very restrictive conditions apply. There are two very simple physical situations where reciprocity does not apply. The first occurs in a mechanical context and concerns the relation between the velocities and the corresponding torques arising in the motion of a gyrostat about mutually orthogonal axes perpendicular to the spin axis. Here, as has been known since the eighteenth century, the matrix expressing this relation for an idealized gyrostat is antisymmetric (Pars, 1965), instead of symmetric as in the case of a mechanical system consisting for example of particles, rods, and dashpots, and which possesses the reciprocity property. In spite of the reality of such gyroscopic systems, many theorists persisted in ignoring their existence in their single-minded search for symmetry, or else quietly excluded gyroscopic terms from the equations of motion as an inconvenient detail.
THE GYRATOR IN ELECTRONIC SYSTEMS
83
The second example concerns the Lorentz force experienced by a charged particle moving in a uniform magnetic field. Here again the relation between the components of the forces and velocities along orthogonal axes in a plane normal to the direction of the magnetic field is given by an antisymmetric matrix.
C. T h e Origin of Antireciprocity If one has been brought up on the premise that symmetry and reversibility should always be present in some form in general physical systems, then it is rather startling to be confronted by an antireciprocal system. The natural reaction is to try to preserve the symmetry or reciprocity at all costs. In the more general form of the reciprocity relation (Rayleigh, 1894), one considers two different “states of the system, corresponding to two different sets of variables satisfying the system equations. Further one distinguishes various types of variables from one another, such as forces from displacements, velocities, and accelerations, or voltages and flux linkages from charges and currents. Denoting the states by A and B and the two types of external system variables by the vectors u and i respectively, the reciprocity relation becomes ”
Now in the case of the gyrostat we can satisfy this relation by taking for state B any member of the set of possible states A transformed by time reversal. (Here u and i represent the torque and velocity vectors respectively.) Then the spin direction is automatically reversed in state B as compared to state A. We can also regard state B as being a member of the set of possible states A but now referring to a d g t r e n t gyrostat, namely with the spin direction reversed, but with otherwise identical characteristics. The important distinction between the t w o approaches lies in the difference between what one regards as the state. In the first case the state refers to all relevant parameters, both internal and externally observable, and thus includes the spin vector of the gyrostat, which, however, is assumed constant. In the second case, only the “external” variables which enter explicitly in (1) are considered. Similar relations hold for a charged particle moving in a magnetic field, provided we reverse the direction of the magnetic field in state B. Of course one can argue that the magnetic field itself is caused by current flow, either macroscopic or microscopic, and if the time is reversed the current flow and thus the magnetic field will be reversed.
84
K. M. ADAMS, E. F. A. DEPRETTERE A N D J. 0. VOORMAN
It is tempting to speculate as to what is the basic cause of the antireciprocity in systems of this type.* Two important facts emerge which are evidently closely connected with antireciprocity and with the skew-symmetry of the system matrix. First of all we note that the basic equations in both systems include a vector product which is anticommuting. Thus for the gyrostat we have the equation of motion T
= Cnr
+ Ar
x r,
(2)
where T is the torque vector, r is a unit vector along the spin axis, A and C are principal moments of inertia, and n is the spin velocity. If the spin velocity is sufficiently large, we can neglect the last term and write
T = Cni.
(3)
The projection of the total angular velocity vector on the plane normal to the spin axis is Q=rxr. (4) The total power absorbed by the gyrostat as a result of the action of the external torques is T * Q= 0, (51 by virtue of ( 3 ) and (4). This is an example of what is known as a ??oneneryic 1927). We also note from (3) and (4), that the component of angular velocity which is proportional to a given component of torque is perpendicular to that torque component. These two properties are sufficient to guarantee antireciprocity of the system and lead automatically to an antisymmetric system matrix. In the same way, we have for the charged particle, moving in a uniform magnetic field and in the absence of an electric field, the equation of motion: system (Birkhoff,
F
= ev x
B,
(6)
where F is the force, e the charge, v the velocity, and B the magnetic flux density. Then the power absorbed by the particle as a result of the force is
F - v = 0. (7) Again the system is nonenergic and the force components are perpendicular to the velocity components to which they are proportional. We thus can see the intimate connection between antireciprocity, nonen* Antireciprocity is a special case of nonreciprocity. I f the normal reciprocity relation can be restored by a simple change of sign in some of the describing equations, then we refer to the system as antireciprocal.
THE GYRATOR IN ELECTRONIC SYSTEMS
85
ergicness, and the properties of three-dimensional Euclidean space, as exhibited by the properties of the vector product. D . Further Generalizations The concepts embodied in Eq. (1) can be applied to far more general systems than those so far mentioned. For example, if one considers linear time-invariant systems in which all the system variables are functions of time and of the form A iexp ( p t ) , with A iindependent of time and p a constant for all the system variables, then the reciprocity relation applies to a large class of such systems (Rayleigh, 1894). An example is a linear n-port network consisting of resistors, capacitors, inductors, and transformers. When the reciprocity concept is applied to three-dimensional field problems, the summation in Eq. (1) is replaced by a spatial integral and a relation between a volume integral and an integral over the bounding surface results. Such relations form the basis of the solution of integral equations by means of Green’s functions and are applicable to a wide class of problems (de Hoop, 1966). Other developments have been concerned with the application of relations like Eq. (1) to two specially related systems which are termed interreciprocal or adjoint (Penfield et d., 1970). The resulting equations lead to useful results for deducing general properties, for network computations, or for the numerical solution of integral equations. All of these developments, however, are special cases of the properties of linear operators and their adjoints in the theory of abstract spaces (Dunford and Schwartz, 1958). For example, in the theory of Hilbert spaces one has the relation
where T denotes a linear operator mapping a Hilbert space $ into itself, T* is the corresponding adjoint operator, x and y are elements of 9, and the symbol (, ) denotes the inner product in 5. Because of the importance of concepts like power and energy in physical systems, the Hilbert space concept with its inner product is especially relevant. Depending on the definition of the inner product that is chosen, a wide variety of reciprocity results of which (1) is the prototype can be obtained. These can refer to variables in the time domain, frequency domain, or spatial domains. The operator T and the space 9 form the abstract representation of the system equations; corresponding to the adjoint operator one can either construct a real system or postulate a fictitious one. As a result of (8) various terms can be made to disappear in the describing equations. It is precisely
86
K . M. ADAMS, E. F. A. DEPRETTERE A N D J . 0. VOORMAN
the desirability for the disappearance of such terms and the resulting simplications that have led many physicists to attach such importance to symmetry. Symmetry, however, is only one way to get rid of unwanted terms and corresponds to self-adjoint operators. The really important point to note, however, is that there is no reason to expect the existence of some universal physical principle that guarantees self-adjointness and that the correct use of the adjoint operator will usually allow one to achieve what is desired without having to impose the symmetry condition.
111. THEGYRATOR AS NETWORK ELEMENT A . Historical Introduction In view of Section lI,C, there is no fundamental objection to postulating the existence of an electrical two-port device described by the equations
where u1 and il are the input voltage and current and u2 and i, are the output voltage and current. Such a device is called the ideal gyrutor and is represented by the symbol shown in Fig. 1. The gyrator was introduced as a
FIG. 1. The ideal gyrator.
postulated electrical network element (Tellegen, 1948a) representing the simplest linear, passive nonreciprocal system, before it was clear whether such an element could be a reasonable approximation to some physically real, purely electrical system. I t is true that at about this time, the idea of an antireciprocal passive device was becoming quite clear to several people. Thus an antireciprocal two-port, electromechanical system and its cascade connection with a reciprocal magnetomechanical two-port was considered. The resulting two-port is an antireciprocal electrical two-port (Jefferson, 1945; McMillan. 1946). Indeed gyrator devices based on this principle were built and marketed in the 1960’s, but have not enjoyed much popularity. The ideal gyrostat was
THE GYRATOR IN ELECTRONIC SYSTEMS
87
also proposed as a mechanical element (Bloch, 1944), and several of its important properties when used in conjunction with other mechanical elements were deduced. Bloch came very close to formulating the electrical gyrator concept, especially in his considerations of the analysis of mechanical networks. However, it was Tellegen who first clearly recognized the fundamental importance of the gyrator as an element, deduced its most important properties, and showed how to employ it in the synthesis of electrical networks (Tellegen, 1948b, 1949; Tellegen and Klauss, 1950, 1951). As a result, electrical network theory and especially network synthesis gained enormously in breadth. In fact as a recent text (Belevitch, 1968) shows, electrical network theory today without the gyrator would be inconceivable. Tellegen, however, not only developed the theory of the gyrator, but also considered possible realizations. This work led him to consider a hypothetical medium in which the electrical polarization can be influenced by the magnetic field strength and the magnetic polarization can be influenced by the electric field strength (Tellegen, 1948a). Such a medium was later found to exist physically (Astrov, 1960, 1961). He also considered the gyromagnetic effect in ferromagnetic materials as a basis for a possible realization. Further calculations by Polder (1949) and experimental work by Hogan led to the first practical gyrator device, operating at microwave frequencies (Hogan, 1952). In spite of all these and many recent developments, the gyrator has not been readily accepted by the electrical engineering and physics communities. Even among network theorists, with a few notable exceptions, there was considerable hesitation in accepting the element and doing theoretical work with it until about 1960. And today one can still find teachers of electrical engineering who prefer their students to remain in complete ignorance of the gyrator concept. We suggest that a major cause of such phenomena is the widespread and deeply-rooted misconception of the true nature of reciprocity. Amongst the designers and users of electronic apparatus, the erroneous notion that a nonreciprocal system cannot be passive is still persistent. It has arisen because all the devices these people came in contact with were either passive and reciprocal or active and nonreciprocal even though by a suitable combination of such devices, passive and nonreciprocal systems could be constructed, at least in principle. Matters have not been helped by references to the reciprocity theorem.” When formulated with any degree of rigor, this “theorem ” either reduces to the tautologous statement that reciprocal systems are reciprocal or to the deduction that a certain specific system constructed from components with certain specified constitutive equations possesses the reciprocity property. The authors of too many books and “
88
K. M. ADAMS, E. F. A. DEPRETTERE A N D J. 0. VOORMAN
papers give the impression that they are appealing to some very general physical principle when they cite the reciprocity theorem or reciprocity principle.” “
”
“
B. Basic Properties of’the Gyrator 1. Siyri Concentions
Figure 2 shows the symbol for the gyrator with various reference voltagepolarity and current-direction signs. These signs and their interpretation as stated here now have fairly general usage. The interpretation is that a quantity such as u , ( t ) is representated by a positive number if the potential of terminal 1 is higher than the potential of terminal 1’ at the instant of time t.
FIG.
2. S i p conventions
Similarly a quantity such as il(t) is represented by a positive number if the current of port 1 flows in the direction indicated by the arrow at time f. In the opposite case the quantity is represented by a negative number. The functions u ( . ) and i(. ) are then the sets of these numbers ordered on the continuous set {t). We are free to choose these reference polarities and directions as we please. Once chosen, however, these references determine the signs to be attached to the algebraic symbols in the describing equations.
2. Noneneryicness The gyrator is an example of what is known as a norieneryic sjxstern (Birkhoff, 1927). That is to say, the instantaneous power absorbed by the element is always zero. Thus from the defining equations (91 we have u l ( t ) i l ( t )+ u 2 ( t ) i 2 ( t= ) 0, The ideal transformer, with defining equations
Vr.
(10)
THE GYRATOR IN ELECTRONIC SYSTEMS
89
in conjunction with the reference polarities and current directions of Fig. 3, is also nonenergic. The only other nonenergic, linear, time-invariant twoports are two-port combinations of the nonenergic one-ports : the short circuit and the open branch. The proof of this result is a simple exercise in linear algebra.
FIG.3. The ideal transformer with its sign convention in relation to thedefining equations: u I = n u 2 , i2 = - n i l .
The concept of nonenergicness has important uses in much more general contexts (Adams, 1974), but for our present purposes, it is not necessary to go into these details. It is clearly a special case of passivity.
3. Isolation and Power Transmission Consider the two-port networks shown in Fig. 4. If the gyrator is defined by Eq. (9), then the two-port resistance matrix of two-port a is
With the sign conventions of Fig. 2, this means that the power absorbed by port 1 is u,i, = Ri: 2 O
(13) if R > 0. On the other hand, the power absorbed by port 2 can be either positive or negative, depending on the ratio i l / i 2 . Since the resistor is passive, this means that power can be transmitted only in one direction through the two-port. Thus port 2 can deliver power to its surroundings but port 1 will always absorb power. In the same way we find for two-port b that the two-port conductance matrix is
[
G -2G
G O1
(G
=
1/R)
and that the same conclusions regarding power transfer apply. It is as a
90
K. M. ADAMS. E. F. A. DEPRETTERE AND J.
0. VOORMAN
result of this property that the arrow associated with the gyrational resistance R in Fig. 2 is employed. This arrow can now be interpreted in two ways. Either we can agree that R is always positive, in which case the arrow denotes the actual direction of power flow in the gyrator-resistor two-port and Eq. (9) applies with R always positive, or we can regard the arrow as a reference direction which corresponds to the direction of power flow when R is positive, or is opposite to this direction when R is negative. If we then agree to introduce the reference voltage polarities and current directions of
=====P
FIG.4. The isolator and power flow
the ports in such a way that the arrow is directed between the terminals associated with plus signs of the two ports, and further choose the current references such that ui is positive when the port absorbs power, then the equations of the gyrator are given by (9). The use of the arrow alone thus enables us to write down the equations with the correct signs and to adopt a consistent reference for voltage polarities and current directions. If for any reason we wish to change any of these references then the corresponding equations can be obtained by replacing the appropriate voltages or currents by their negatives.
THE GYRATOR IN ELECTRONIC SYSTEMS
91
The gyrator-resistor combination discussed here is known as an isolator and has important applications in microwave technology (Beljers, 1956). 4. Antireciprocity If, as in Section II,C, we consider two states denoted by A and B, then we find that the defining equations yield
This relation can be obtained from Eq. (1) by converting a single minus sign to a plus sign, and thus corresponds to an antireciprocal system. When the impedance or the admittance matrix of an n-port exists, then the matrix is skew-symmetric if the n-port is antireciprocal. Antireciprocity is the simplest form of nonreciprocity. No other nonreciprocal element than the gyrator is required to characterize linear, time-invariant, nonreciprocal n-ports. It is one of the basic results of network synthesis that any passive n-port, which is characterized by linear ordinary differential equations with constant coefficients in the port voltages and currents, can be synthetized from the elements: resistor, capacitor. inductor, ideal transformer, and gyrator (Oono and Yasu-ura, 1954; Belevitch, 1968). As we shall see in the following sections, the ideal transformer and inductor can be deleted from this list. 5. Ideal Transformers A cascade connection of two gyrators is equivalent to an ideal transformer (Fig. 5). Conversely, any ideal transformer can be synthetized by a network of two gyrators with suitably chosen gyrational resistances.
hd t FIG.5. Ideal transformer synrhetized from two gyrators
6. Iininittance Inversion
Perhaps the most important property for engineering applications is the inversion of an impedance or admittance, as shown in Fig. 6. In particular, a capacitance with impedance llpC is converted by a gyrator into an impedance pR2C, corresponding to a self-inductance L = R 2 C . Especially this
92
K . M. ADAMS, E. F. A. DEPRETTERE A N D J. 0. VOORMAN
property has led to increased interest in applying the gyrator concept to integrated circuits. More generally, any one-port network N is equivalent to a one-port formed by the cascade connection of a gyrator and a network N’, which has the structure of the dual network of N (if it exists) and with element values proportional to those of the dual network. Another generalization is the two-port equivalence shown in Fig. 7.
-Jj-=j
JY=;;.
FIG.6. Demonstrating the immittance inversion property
7. Iiiterclzange
of’ Variables and Duality
A generalization of the foregoing applies to n-ports. Let IZ gyrators, with gyrational resistors of 1 Q, be connected to the ports of an n-port network N as shown in Fig. 8. There results an 17-portnetwork N’, which is described by 1R
3-c 3-c
n-port
IQ
FIG. 8. Interchange of port variables
93
THE GYRATOR IN ELECTRONIC SYSTEMS
equations obtained from those of N by interchanging the port voltages and the corresponding port currents. If the equations are expressed in terms of other electrical quantities, then these quantities are interchanged according to their relation to voltages and currents. Thus, for example, charges and fluxes are interchanged. Then network N ’ is equivalent in the n-port sense to the dual of N (when it exists). Thus we can use the gyrator as a dualizing converter in design or analysis. A simple application of this principle is shown in Fig. 9.
FIG.9. A special case of dualizing.
When the gyrator can be used freely, the distinction between current and voltage as ‘‘ through and “across variables disappears, since the topological structures inherent in these concepts and their duals are freely interchangeable. This is one of the reasons for the difficulties in attempts to lay the foundations of nonequilibrium thermodynamics in the conventional manner (de Groot and Mazur, 1962). ”
”
8. Reactioe Power Although the gyrator is nonenergic, this does not mean that the complex power absorbed by the gyrator is zero, but only that the real part of the complex power is zero. The imaginary part, or the reactive power, is given by Qc,
=
f Im ( U ,IT +
U 2IT) = Im ( R I , IT).
(16)
This is not surprising when we consider the relation of reactive power to stored energy, Thus the reactive power absorbed by an inductor is QL = -$ Im (jwLII*) = &wLI Z I z
=
20W, > 0
(w
> 0),
(17)
where W, is the mean stored magnetic energy. For a capacitor we find that Q c = -‘C 2 a (U12 = -2wW, > 0
(0>
O),
(18)
where We is the mean stored electric energy. Since reactive power is conserved in networks (Tellegen, 1952; Penfield et al., 1970), if an inductor is simulated by a gyrator terminated in a capacitor, the difference of the reactive powers absorbed by the capacitor and the simulated inductor must be equal to the reactive power absorbed by the
94
K. M. ADAMS, E. F. A. DEPRETTERE A N D J. 0. VOORMAN
gyrator. It is readily verified from Eqs. (16)-( 18) that QL
= QC
+QG~ 7
when account is taken of the sign convention for currents and voltages and of the interconnection of the elements. This property of storing reactive power is in sharp contrast to the properties of the ideal transformer, for which both the absorbed active and reactive powers are zero. Once the gyrator has been introduced, the distinction between total stored electric energy and total stored magnetic energy of a system disappears. The total stored energy, electric and magnetic, is still relevant but the difference between the two types of energy disappears. In the Lagrangian formulation of networks, this disappearance is compensated by the appearance of linear terms in the Lagrangian function to account for the presence of gyrators (Adams, 1968).
IV. FILTERS A . Introduction
A filter is an apparatus that, when presented with a mixture of certain “things,” allows some of these “things” to pass through it in a specified manner and prevents the passage of the other “things.” In electrical engineering the “things” are usually signals which can be regarded as consisting of various components, some of which are desirable and are to be retained as far as is possible, and others which are undesirable and are to be rejected. Historically, the first filters consisted of linear, time-invariant networks, and were designed for separating the signal components in various frequency bands from one another. Today, the word filter has come to mean almost any signal-processing apparatus or algorithm or program that is remotely connected with the idea of separation of desirable from undesirable quantities. In many of these generalizations from the original simple filter networks, concepts such as reciprocity and antireciprocity apply. The gyrator concept then automatically appears and plays an important role (see, e.g., Fettweis, 1971). In this section we shall concentrate on the classical network filter from which these other more recent developments have evolved. B. Basic Configuration
The classical filter-network configuration consists of a signal source which is capable of delivering a certain maximum quantity of signal power, a passive transmission two-port network which is the actual filter, and a load
95
THE GYRATOR IN ELECTRONIC SYSTEMS
where the filtered signal is further processed and its accompanying electrical power is finally dissipated into thermal power (Fig. 10). The signal (energy) source can be represented by an ideal voltage source in series with an impedance (Thevenin circuit), or equivalently, an ideal current source in parallel with an admittance (Norton circuit). We shall restrict our discussion to the simplest but very important practical case in which both the source and the load impedances are pure resistances. We shall further restrict ourselves to the case where the signal source strength varies sinusoidally with time.
n a ,
Source
-
Load
Source
Filter I
Load
I I
FIG. LO. Basic filter configuration
Then one of the very important parameters for judging the performance of the filter is the ratio of the power received by the load to the maximum available power of the energy source as a function of frequency (Geffe, 1963; Saal, 1963; Skwirzynski, 1965).* The quality of such a filter is then often judged by such parameters as the closeness with which this ratio approaches unity in certain frequency bands (the passbands), the smallness of the ratio in certain other bands (the stopbands) and the narrowness of the frequency intervals in the remaining portions of the spectrum (the transition bands). These terms are illustrated in Fig. 11. T w o other points should be noted at this stage. The first is that intuitively we should expect the most efficient transmission in the passband, when the filter proper is lossless. At these frequencies the filter is ideally transparent to signals. Secondly, filtering is often connected with such matters as improving the signal-to-noise ratio. This is a power ratio and the noise power of a source is a maximum available noise power, so that, provided the filter itself does not generate any noise, the transmission parameter shown in Fig. I I is most appropriate.
* A filter theory based on this power ratio as primary characteristic is often referred to as the insertion-loss theory. Unfortunately, not all authors mean the same thing by this term, which is the reason why we prefer not to use it in this article.
96
K. M. ADAMS. E. F. A. DEPRETTERE A N D J. 0. VOORMAN
FIG. 1 I . A typical filter characteristic. o is the ratio of the power dissipated in the load to the maximum available power of the source, A and E are the stop bands, C is a passband. and B and D are transition bands.
C. The Scattering Matri.u When analyzing and synthetizing transmission ti-ports, the scattering matrix S is frequently the most suitable tool to use. Amongst its advantages are the fact that it always exists if the n-port is passive, in contrast to most of the other network matrices (Carlin rf id., 19591, and that it is directly related to power transfer and thus to the specification of filter characteristics (Belevitch, 1968). The n-port equations are written in the form
b
=
Sa,
(20)
Here U and 1 are the (complex) port voltages and currents while R is a diagonal matrix with positive diagonal elements, and R'12 is also a diagonal matrix with positive diagonal elements which are equal to the square root of the corresponding elements of R. Then it is clear that
The network relations between the various quantities are illustrated in Fig. 12. The elements of a and b are called wave variables; a is the incident and b is the reflected wave vector. In ordinary (lumped-element) networks this terminology is rat her artificial, but in transmission lines and waveguides these quantities correspond to actual waves. The elements of R are called the
97
THE GYRATOR IN ELECTRONIC SYSTEMS
normalizing resistances or preferably the reference resistances of the ports. They are real and positive. The diagonal elements S j j of S are called the reflection factors ; the other elements are the transmission factors. If the n-port is lossless, and the signals are sinusoidal, then S is unitary:
STS*
=
(251
1, ,
where 1, denotes the unit matrix of order n. In the more general case of exponential signals, S is para-unitary, i.e. STS* =
1,
(26)
where S, denotes S( - p ) . R.
h,
R2
FIG. 12. Scattering variables of a two-port. u1 = 4R;' ' D o , - Ri ' 1 , .
=
$R;' ' ( U ,
+ R , I,).
=
1. The Canonical Forin In the important special case of a lossless two-port constructed of a finite number of real, lumped, passive elements, S can be written in the form (Belevitch, 1968)
where g, h, f are polynomials in the complex frequency p ; f , , h , denote = & 1. In the case of sinusoidal signals, p = j w and h, = h*. From the defining equations, we see that the zeros of g are the natural frequencies of the network of Fig. 12 when the source intensities are zero, i.e. the original two-port network with the ports terminated in the reference resistances. This terminated network is evidently passive, so that the zeros of g must lie in the left-half of the complex plane, i.e. 9 is a Hurwitz polynomial. The para-unitary condition can now be expressed in the particularly simple form (Belevitch, 1968)
f(-p), h( - p ) , and
98
K. M. ADAMS, E. F. A. DEPRETTERE A N D J. 0. VOORMAN
If now we choose U,, = 0 in Fig. 12, then a, = 0 and we have the basic filter configuration of Fig. 10. Then
U,
=
R;”(U, -I-b,)
=
R:”b,.
(29)
In the case of sinusoidal signals, the (average) power absorbed by the load is
5 I U2 I2/R2 = 4I b, 1.’
(30)
The maximum available (average) power from the source is
I uoi I2/8R, = 4I 12, a1
(31)
so that the fraction of the available power transmitted is
by (27). The fraction of the available power which is not transmitted is “reflected” back into the source. This is (33) by (25) and (28). A filter characteristic is often specified by the so-called characteristic function ) I defined by
I? * = j ,
(34)
which exhibits explicitly the zeros of the reflection and of the transmission factors. As a result of (28) and the fact that y is a Hurwitz polynomial, g is determinable once 1 $ I is known and the procedures of network synthesis then guarantee that a realization can be found (Belevitch, 1968; Youla, 1971).
2. The Circulator The gyrator as a lossless two-port has a particularly simple form of S-matrix if we choose the reference resistances equal to the gyrational resistance. We find
where q
=
+ I . From the gyrator we can construct a certain three-port in
THE GYRATOR IN ELECTRONIC SYSTEMS
99
either of the ways shown in Fig. 13. This three-port has an S-matrix
where y = 1 for network (a) and y = - 1 for network (b). In both cases the three-port is known as a circulator and has important uses especially in microwave engineering (Bosma, 1964). R
36 30
d
3
b
(cl
FIG. 13. The circulator: (a) the admittance matrix exists, (b) the impedance matrix exists, (c) symbol for the circulator.
D. Ladder Filters Most high-performance filters are realized in the form of an LC ladder network if this is at all possible. It has been found through long years of experience that ladder filters are relatively easy to build and to adjust so as to conform to the filter specification. The theoretical basis for this effect was
100
K. M. ADAMS, E. F. A. DEPRETTERE A N D J. 0. VOORMAN
not fully realized until quite recently (Orchard, 1966). It was brought into focus through the difficulties arising from attempts to construct high performance active RC filters. There are two reasons for the favorable properties of the LC ladder network (see Fig. 14). First, the zeros of transmission are separately determined by the resonance frequencies of the arms of the ladder. Thus at such a transmission zero
FIG. 14. A ladder network. According to popular usage the arms labeled with Z ‘ s are termed the “series” arms and the arms labeled with Y’s are termed the “shunt“ arms.
(or attenuation pole) either one of the “series” arms of the ladder has an infinite reactance or one of the “shunt” arms has a zero reactance. The transmission zeros can thus be accurately adjusted by tuning the arms of the ladder. Since the frequency of the source can be accurately set, it is a simple matter to tune the appropriate ladder arm by adjusting the capacitor or inductor so as to produce a minimum in the output. In practice, because of the particular construction of ferrite pot cores, this tuning is easily carried out by a simple adjustment of the air gap of the core. Thus the zeros offare then accurately determined and we find that the stopband characteristic conforms very closely to the specification. The adjustment of the transmission zero(s) closest to the passband is especially important, since these zeros substantially determine the transition region(s). The second reason is that in the passband the first-order sensitivity of 1 S2 1’ to element-value variations at a zero of S1 is zero. It is very easy to see how this arises as a consequence of the losslessness property. Thus if the element values vary for any reason from their nominal values, the network still remains lossless (we suppose for the moment that the filter is constructed of ideal inductors and capacitors) so that Eq. (25) is still valid. In particular.
,
Is11
l2 +
IS21
l2 = 1
(37)
and a first-order variation yields
,
,
If 1 S , I = 0, then 6( I S,, I ) = 0, since 1 S z 1I and I S, I cannot simultaneously be zero. Further since S,, I 5 1, 16 I S , 1 I 5 1 and is thus finite.
I
THE GYRATOR IN ELECTRONIC SYSTEMS
101
Thus in the neighborhood of a reflection zero, the transmission characteristic varies little with variations in the element values. Furthermore, in the passband, the reflection factor will not normally differ much from zero if the filter is well designed, so that even at a maximum value of the modulus of the reflection factor, the variation in 1 S,, I will be small. Experience shows that the most sensitive region is near the passband edge, and is closely related to the resonance effect (Section IV,E). It is important to note that (37) and (38) remain valid if the terminating resistors deviate from their nominal values, so that the conclusions regarding the sensitivity also apply here. In practice one finds that very high quality filters can be built with components with 1 tolerance and that for many purposes a tolerance of up to 5 % is good enough. The ladder filter thus en-joysa remarkable property which is not known to hold for any other configuration except those which simulate the ladder exactly or which in some sense combine the properties of losslessness and the ability to set the attenuation poles very accurately (see, e.g., Bruton, 1973). If the reactive components have parasitic losses, then the performance and the sensitivity of the filter deteriorate (Neirynck and Thiran, 1967). It is thus important to reduce the losses as much as possible; the sharper the discrimination between the pass and stop bands, the higher needs to be the quality factor of the components. As a result of these considerations it would seem very attractive to consider replacing the inductances in a ladder filter by a gyrator-capacitor combination. Particularly since it is now possible to simulate inductances in this manner with extremely high and relatively stable Q's in the range 100010,000, this technique would seem to have much to recommend it. There are, however, some grave difficulties in practice which we shall discuss in the following sections. However, the same difficulties appear in many other proposals for filter circuits. E . Resonance in Filters
As already mentioned in Section IV,C, the natural frequencies of the free oscillations of the filter are the zeros of the polynomial g, i.e. the poles of S1 S,, , S, , Szl.If such a network is excited at a frequency which is close to one of the natural frequencies, resonance will occur and large voltages and currents will appear in the various components. Using Eq. (28), we can readily see qualitatively in what region this effect will be most pronounced. Thus for sinusoidal signals ( p = ,jw), Eq. (28) becomes
,
+ Ifl'=
(39) At a point on the j-axis of the complex plane near a zero of g, I g I is small 1912>
yo.
102
K. M. ADAMS. E. F. A. DEPRETTERE A N D J. 0. VOORMAN
and thus I h I and I f 1 are small. Thus this point on thej-axis must be close to zeros of h and$ The only possibility which allows this to occur is for the resonance frequency to lie near the edge of the passband or in the transition band, between a reflection zero and a transmission zero (see Fig. 15). It
1
O
IS2,l-
IS,l-
1
x
+4
i
0
1
IW
Oh xf
t t
-a
FIG. 15. Relation between poles and zeros and the filter characteristic
follows that the narrower the transition band, other parameters being equal, the more pronounced will be this effect. We can give a simple quantitative relation for this effect (Dicke, 1948; Kishi and Nakazawa, 1963; Carlin, 1967; Kishi and Kida, 1967, 1970) based on Tellegen’s theorem (Tellegen, 1952; Penfield ef al., 1970), which is valid for any lossless two-port terminated in the reference resistances. We employ Tellegen’s theorem in the form
1 (U,* A l x + 1: AU,) = 0, a
where a is taken over all branches of a complete network, ( U , } and [I,) refer to a possible network distribution of voltages and currents obeying Kirchhoff’s laws, and (AU,) and (AI,} refer to a variation of voltages and currents about that distribution, also obeying Kirchhoff’s laws. We consider next the situation that port 1 of the lossless network is excited by an energy source while port 2 is terminated in the reference resistance. This results in a certain { U,, la}distribution. For the variational state we allow all the reactances to undergo a small variation but keep the other elements constant. From (40) we find after some calculation, correct to the first order of small quantities,
103
THE GYRATOR IN ELECTRONIC SYSTEMS
where 8, = -arg (S,) (i,j = I, 2), T is taken over all reactances, P is the available input power, and suffix 1 refers to the fact that port 1 is excited by the source. If the variations of U , and I , result from a variation of the frequency, then we obtain from (41)
where W is the average total stored energy, or in derivative form,
In the same way, if port 2 is excited by a source and port 1 is terminated in its reference resistance, we have
From (43) and (44) we obtain, using (25),
where 5 is referred to as the total transmission time (group delay) from port 1 to port 2 and back to port 1. But
0 1 2+ 8,,
=
-arg (S12S21) = -arg
(F),
so that T =
d 2 d o arg (y) ~
( p = J'LU).
(47)
( j w - .io, + xs),
(48)
We can factorize g as Y =
I<
iI (P - PA = 5
n 5
where K is a constant and the zeros p, of g are -a, becomes
+ jw,.
Then (47)
From this expression we see that T is large for those points on the imaginary axis which are close to zeros of g, i.e. when a, 4 1 and 1 w - w, I 4 1. Thus T is large when the network is in resonance or close to resonance.
104
K. M. ADAMS, E. F. A. DEPRETTERE A N D 3. 0. VOORMAN
If one of the zeros of g dominates in the frequency range of interest, then
where Q is the quality factor of the dominant zero of g, viz.
and - a O
+ jtno is the dominant zero of 61 I
C
FIG. 16. A typical low-order bandpass filter characteristic. showing the attenuation 70 log,, (I,’I S,, I ) and the group delay i = -(t//tfru) arg (.S2,).
We can also obtain another energy relation from (40), viz. for the case that only one reactance component varies. Then, denoting the element value of this component by xk,we obtain instead of (43)
THE GYRATOR IN ELECTRONIC SYSTEMS
105
where W, is the average energy stored in the component. Corresponding to (45) and (47), we obtain
This last result shows that the energy stored by component k is greatest when the argument of g is most sensitive to variations in the component. Various other formulas for the energy functions and their relation to sensitivity and to the scattering parameters can be given (Kishi and Kida, 1967, 1970) but they are of not much help in obtaining a good estimate of the necessary dynamic range of the components. For example, in gyratorless networks, or in networks in which the gyrator is used only to simulate an inductance, we can distinguish between the magnetic and the electric energies. However, near resonance these energies are nearly equal and the extra complication of the resulting expressions does not contribute significantly to further insight. Further, as (43) and (44) show, the difference between ( W / P ) ,and ( W / P ) ,is not great if the reflection factor is small. Thus
where i refers to either of the differential operators we have used, with appropriate interpretation of the left-hand side of the equation (E: = 0 or 1). If all the zeros of the reflection and transmission factors lie on the imaginary axis, as is the case for the important class of filters with Chebyshev characteristics, then the difference between the two energy-power ratios is zero. If now all the components of one type, and especially the inductances, have the same energy-handling capacity, then the most favorable configurations will be those in which the stored energy is equally distributed over the components. This unfortunately is seldom approximated in practice. As (53) shows, the optimum obtainable results when, at resonance, arg ( 9 ) varies equally as nearly as possible with respect to each reactive component value. In practice it will be necessary to calculate this variation, or some equivalent parameter, for the specific configuration being considered. We can, however, remark that in general it is preferable in this connection to choose a network in which the natural frequencies depend on all the components. This is in sharp contrast to the case of cascaded second-order systems containing isolating amplifiers, where the total energy at resonance is largely concentrated in two components. The limited energy-handling capacity of the reactive components presents the designer of sharply selective filters with various problems. If he chooses to use an LCR network, he will need to examine the deterioration of the quality factor of the coils with increasing amplitude, due to the nonlinear
I06
K. M.
ADAMS, E. F.
A. DEPRETTERE A N D J. 0. VOORMAN
characteristic of the magnetic material. It turns out that the filter characteristic near the band edge deteriorates rapidly with decreasing Q. If electronic components are used in conjunction with energy storing elements, the input signal of the filter must be kept sufficiently low to prevent overloading or saturation of the electronic components. In such a case the signal level may not be sufficiently above the noise level. One must remember that in any practical situation noise will be generated by the terminating resistors and any electronic circuitry that is present. If gyrators, and especially electronic gyrators are used, the designer will be confronted with the fundamental limitation of signal-to-noise ratio, selectivity of the filter, and dynamic range of the gyrators (which in turn is limited by the maximum allowable dissipation in the electronic circuitry). At the present state of electronic technology, it is not possible to build filters in this way with the most rigorous performance characteristics which modern communication systems demand and at the same time to stay within the power limits." Nevertheless there are many situations in telecommunications and electronic engineering where the highest performance is not called for or where the allowable power dissipation in the electronic circuitry need not be extremely low. Two examples of what is possible in this respect are given by Sheahan and Orchard (1967)and Orchard and Sheahan (1970):
Filter degree
Bandwidth
16 16
16-20 kHz 104-108 k H z
~
Max. output S,/N ratio
Maximum power consumption
YO dB 86 dB
85 mW 960 mW
~~
~~
If both filters had the same degree of absolute selectivity (equal transition width measured in Hz and equal minimum attenuation in the stopbands) we should expect the second filter to require 5 to 6 times the power consumption of the first filter in order to achieve the same signal-to-noise ratio, since with equal absolute bandwidths the Q of the zeros of g and thus the resonance effect is proportional to the upper band edge frequency. However, the electronic gyrators generate noise internally in the filter, which is transmitted to the output of the filter, with a power level at the resonance frequency, which is proportional to Q 2 . Since this noise is in general much greater than the noise produced by the signal source, we see that the signal-to-noise ratio per watt of supplied power should be proportional to 1/Q2. The above * Very recent work shows that with adaptively controlled power supplies it is now possible to satisfy some of the most stringent specifications. See Section VIII.
THE GYRATOR IN ELECTRONIC SYSTEMS
107
figures are indeed in close agreement with this expectation, namely 85 960
10‘8.6 9 . 0 )
2:
1 28 ’
which is very close to the square of the ratio of the upper band edge frequencies. We shall go into the whole question of noise generation in a later section.
F . Sensitivity We have seen in Section IV,D that the modulus of the power transmission factor is largely insensitive to variations in the component values. In fact, using Tellegen’s theorem it is possible to give a precise relation between the sensitivity of this transmission factor with respect to an element variation Axk and the stored energy in the element (Kishi and Kida, 1967):
This expression holds for any reciprocal lossless two-port with resistive terminations and subject to variations in the reactive elements. In the important special case that all zeros of S, and S,, lie on the imaginary axis, the right-hand side of (55), as a result of the remark following (54) reduces to
,
P’ so that
by (53). This sensitivity at the band edge can be quite high, depending on the magnitude of the characteristic function, but is further in accordance with the resonance effect. However, in the case of ladder networks, if the zeros of transmission are accurately adjusted, a deviation in the value of an inductance in a branch responsible for a transmission zero is accompanied by a corresponding deviation in the capacitance of that branch. We can see the consequences of this adjustment for the sensitivity as follows. Kishi’s and Kida’s derivation depends on an application of Tellegen’s
108
K. M. ADAMS, E. F. A. DEPRETTERE A N D J. 0. VOORMAN
theorem in the form
C (AUrZ, - U , AZ,)
=
0.
I
The contribution of a branch, consisting of an impedance Z,, to the lefthand side of (58) is AZ,I,?. Using this expression, the relation between energy and the derivative of IS,, I is established as in (55). If now z k consists of an inductance and capacitance in series, both of which vary, but with invariant resonance frequency, then
where coo is the resonance frequency of the branch. Thus in Kishi and Kida’s derivation, when L, alone varies, we now have to replace AL, by ALk(l - o$02). The result is that the energy function wk is replaced by
w,1 1 - Lc);/w2 1 .
Similarly, when in Kishi and Kida’s derivation, C, alone varies, we have k is now to replace AC, by AC,(oj2/wc - I), so that the energy function w replaced by W, 1 0 2 / w i - 1 I . In the case of a parallel resonant circuit, L and C are interchanged in these relations. We thus see that the sensitivity of 1 S,, I with respect to variations in a reactive component of a branch responsible for a transmission zero is considerably less for a ladder with accurately adjusted transmission zeros than for a general lossless network in which this possibility is not readily available (see also the recent work of Temes and Orchard, 1973). Not all filters have their reflection and transmission zeros on the imaginary axis. In such cases the sensitivity relations are more complicated and the energy distribution at resonance is in general less uniform. Further, in the case of complex transmission zeros, the ladder network is not available. Other things being equal, the sensitivity of the power transmission of such filters is greater than for the case of the simple ladder with Chebyshev characteristics. Also for all lossless filters, the sensitivity of the group delay is high in the region of sharp selectivity, as can readily be seen by differentiating (52) or (53) with respect to LL). There is little that can be done to ameliorate this effect. If an amplitude or phase equalizer is required, the sensitivity and resonance effect can be quite tolerable, since in general the zeros of g do not lie close to the imaginary axis. Furthermore many networks of this type are not terminated lossless two-ports so that the preceding theory does not apply without modification. The necessary formulas can in any specific case be readily developed by the methods of Kishi and Kida (1967, 1970).
THE GYRATOR IN ELECTRONIC SYSTEMS
109
G. The Gyrator in Filters
The consequences of the foregoing discussion are that any reciprocal passive network, which by experience or analysis has been shown to be an acceptable filter network, can be considered as being fit for replacing the inductances by gyrator-capacitor combinations. If, however, sharp selectivity is required, then the necessary dynamic range of the components will certainly need to be checked. If the network contains transformers, then their simulation by gyrators and capacitors can be considered but the sensitivity will need to be investigated by a separate analysis. Further, any parasitic effects associated with the gyrator realization will need to be taken carefully into account. It may often be better to use an equivalent network with negative capacitors or inductors, thereby eliminating the transformers. This has been successfully done by Orchard and Sheahan (1970). There is, however, another more recent development which certainly deserves more attention than it has received to date. That is to design a truly nonreciprocal filter from first principles and to implement it with gyrators, capacitors, and resistors. There are various synthesis procedures available (see, e.g., Oono and Yasu-uru, 1954; Fettweis, 1969, 1970, 1971). Fettweis’ method in particular can provide interesting networks. Generally speaking such realizations demand a better realization of the gyrator than is needed for simple inductance simulation. Nevertheless, the technology has now progressed so far that some of these nonreciprocal realizations can be taken seriously.
V. PRINCIPLES OF REALIZATIONOF
THE
GYRATOR
A . Physical Efects
In this section we shall briefly discuss various physical effects which could form the basis of a practical gyrator deoice, as opposed to the theoretical rlenzent discussed in the preceding section. Some of these effects have already been mentioned in Section 11. We begin by listing the physical effects which correspond to linear passive systems. 1. Gyroscopic Forces
In a purely mechanical context, a well constructed gyrostat can be a good approximation to the ideal gyrostat, which is the mechanical analogue of the gyrator. Such systems lie outside the scope of this survey, which is devoted to electronic systems. Gyroscopic forces, however, are important in
110
K.
M. ADAMS, E.
F.
A.
DEPRETTERE A N D J. 0. VOORMAN
the gyromagnetic effect. This effect really involves two effects, viz. the gyroscopic relation between torques and angular velocities and the Lorentz force. The effect is responsible for the nonreciprocal Faraday rotation of the plane of polarization of electromagnetic waves passing through a magnetic medium subject to a constant bias magnetic field. At microwave frequencies and in the uhf band, practical gyrator-like devices based on these effects have been built and successfully operated (Hogan, 1952; Bosma, 1964). The design and application of such devices, however, have been extensively described in the microwave literature and will thus not be discussed further in this survey. There are also various other effects in the solid state involving the coupling between mechanical and magnetic moments, which, however, have not resulted in the development of a significant gyrator-like device.
2. Lorentz Force The Lorentz force plays a role in the gyromagnetic effect (Beljers and Snoek, 1950). It is also responsible for the Hall effect, which has been employed in the design of gyrator-like devices (Arlt, 1960). However, any device of this type is accompanied by high resistive losses so that it is a poor approximation to the ideal gyrator. Although the ratio of the gyrational resistance to loss resistance is proportional to the magnetic field strength at low intensities of the magnetic field, at higher values the nonlinear magnetoresistance effect comes into play and effectively prevents a gyrator of high quality from being realized. One could consider reducing the unwanted resistance by employing negative resistances, but then the realization would not be entirely based on passive system behavior, which is the subject of this section. Other working devices which effectively employ the Lorentz force are not known. 3. Electromechanical, Mechanico-magnetic Transducers
If an electrostatic microphone is acoustically coupled to an electrodynamic loudspeaker, the relation between the voltages and currents of the electrical terminals of the microphone and loudspeaker is nonreciprocal. In order to understand how this comes about, we consider an idealized situation in which the current in the electrical port of the loudspeaker is proportional to the mechanical force exerted on the acoustical medium. In the microphone the mechanical force at the acoustical medium interface is proportional to the voltage over the electrical port. If the whole system is lossless and incapable of storing energy, i.e. nonenergic, then it is readily shown using the results of Sections II,C and III,B,2 that the voltages and
THE GYRAFOR IN ELECTRONIC SYSTEMS
111
currents of the two ports must satisfy the gyrator equations. In fact the loudspeaker voltage and the microphone current are proportional to the particle velocity in the acoustical medium. The difficulty with devices of this type is to prevent the occurrence of various resonances in the system. Some energy storage is inevitable and the problem is to ensure that in the case of sinusoidal excitation the ratio of the product of stored energy and frequency to transmitted power is small in the frequency range of interest. Losses can also be a problem, but with careful design of the acoustical medium (e.g. a solid-state material with much higher acoustical impedance than that of the surrounding air), the losses can be largely limited to the electrical transducers. Devices of this type have been produced (Silverman, 1962, 1963; Silverman et al., 1961) with a relative bandwidth of about 10% but have not enjoyed much popularity. It is possible that with the present flourishing interest in mechanical surface-wave devices for signal processing in electronic systems, a high quality gyrator device in microform and based on this principle would be feasible, although realization of a suitable magnetomechanical transducer would not be easy. 4. Tellegen Medium Tellegen (1948a) in his original article on the gyrator proposed a medium with constitutive equations of the form
D=&.E+y*H,
B = y* . E +
*
H,
where Y* is the tensor adjoint to y. The coefficients y are responsible for the nonreciprocity of such a medium and the quality of any gyrator-like device constructed with such a medium as working material will depend on the ratios Although media with constitutive equations of this form are known, e.g. Cr,O, (Astrov, 1960; O’Dell, 1966), the desired effect is too small for forming the basis of a practical gyrator.
B. Active Circuits
The foregoing exhausts the known basic physical effects which correspond to passive systems and which could conceivably be used for practical gyrator realization. We consider next the possibilities offered by active
112
K. M. ADAMS, E. F. A . DEPRETTERE A N D J. 0. VOORMAN
systems. Before going into a detailed discussion of these matters, it is as well to recall what is meant by active and passive systems. According to popular usage, a resistor or a capacitor is regarded as a passive component, whereas a transistor is regarded as an active component because it is capable of power amplification. However, from the point of view of network theory, this is not an entirely satisfactory division of properties. Passivity is an observable property of a system. In order to make an observation, the system must have ports which form the interface with the environment, and in particular with the measuring instruments. We define an n-port network to be passive if it is incapable of delivering more energy to its surroundings through its ports than it has already absorbed from the surroundings through its ports during its previous history. Thus
1
I
u(.)”i(.) LIZ 2 0;
Qt, Qu(.), i ( . ) E N,
(61)
.--r
where u( . ) and i ( . ) are vectors of any simultaneously allowable port voltage and current functions, belonging to the class N which is determined by the network. An active ti-port is then an n-port which violates this condition for some u(. ) and i( . ) belonging to N. Viewed in this way, a transistor, which is a two-port, is passive. The transistor does not in itself produce electrical energy. It is a nonlinear system that converts electrical power in one form (the supply) into another distinctly recognizable form (output signals). This distinction between the supply and the signal power is possible because in the normal mode of amplifier operation, the characteristics are such that the signals correspond to the deviation of the voltage and current distribution in the transistor from some specified distribution, which is due to the power supply in the absence of any signals. This is the well-known situation of small”-signal operation. Amplification of signals can occur and it then makes sense to talk about a locally active system or network, because the source of energy supply and the conversion process are being ignored in the further discussion. The word local serves to remind us that we are only considering the situation about a fixed operating point on the characteristics. O n the other hand, the transistor is also used in situations where there is no separate supply, e.g. in certain pulse and logic circuits, in which case there is no possibility of amplification of signal power. Thus, whether a system or device is active or passive depends on the point of view of the observer; to be specific, on how the ports and their accompanying variables are chosen, as well as the mode of operation (i.e., the class N to which the port variables may belong), rather than on some absolute intrinsic property of the device itself. “
THE GYRATOR IN ELECTRONIC SYSTEMS
113
These considerations must be borne in mind when we come to consider the realization of electronic devices, which in some sense approximate the ideal gyrator. Any such device will be a two-port as far as the signals are concerned and may or may not be passive. If it is not passive, we shall have to be very careful about what we regard as an acceptable approximation, since an active system can be unstable and thus display a very different behavior from the passive system it is intended to approximate. On the other hand, we may choose to construct the device by interconnecting active devices together in such a way that the resulting two-port is passive. What happens is that the interconnections constrain the mode of operation of the active component devices in such a way that any power produced by some of the components is absorbed by the others and is not delivered to the ports of the device that we wish to construct. In the preliminary stages of design we can work with active components. We must not forget, however, that at some later stage the power supply and power conversion process will have to be taken into account and translated into hardware, and that particularly as a result of the power conversion, various unpleasant parasitic effects can occur.
C. Ideal Active Network Elements The number of electronic circuits that have been proposed for the realization of gyrators is so vast that we would be unable to compare them and discuss their design without having available some general and simplifying principles. The first simplification we can adopt is to introduce a set of basic active elements from which, in conjunction with the passive elements, resistor, and capacitor, all other active networks can be constructed. There are various ideal active elements in common use amongst theoreticians, such as ideal voltage and current sources (which are one-ports), transactors (ideal controlled sources, which are two-ports), the negative resistance, negative impedance converter, negative impedance inverter, and the nullor. This last element is especially interesting since it is the only active element from which all the other active elements can be constructed in conjunction with the passive elements, and since it is also a very natural first idealization of the basic building block of modern integrated circuits, viz. the transistor. Accordingly, we shall develop all our discussion in terms of the nullor. D. The Nullor The nullor concept was introduced into network theory by Tellegen (1956) under the name of ideal amplifier. The same concept was independently treated by Keen (1959) who called it the unitor. Finally the present,
114
K. M. ADAMS. E. F. A. DEPRETTERE A N D J. 0. VOORMAN
generally accepted name of nullor was given by Carlin (1964).The use of this concept in a theoretically responsible fashion was in the early stages not very widespread. More recently, however, the whole matter has been thoroughly discussed (Tellegen, 1966) and the correct use of the nullor concept is now fairly generally understood. The nullor is a two-port described by the equations u , = 0, i , =
0,
where for convenience port 1 is called the null-port and port 2 the )lor-port. The voltage and current of port 2 are arbitrary, which seems a rather strange and generally unsatisfactory state of affairs. However, the nullor only has network significance when it is used in conjunction with some other two-port network, in such a way that all the voltages and currents throughout the complete network are uniquely determinate when the initial state of energy distribution is specified. If, for example, the ports of the nullor are connected in parallel to the ports of another two-port, which may or may not contain certain sources, and with scattering matrix S, then the voltage and current distribution in the complete network is determinate if and only if S , , # 0. That is to say, there must be some feedback path from the nor-port to the null-port via the auxiliary network. This may seem a rather restrictive condition, but is really no stranger than the restrictions placed on the use of voltage sources, viz. voltage sources may not be connected together to form a closed loop if the algebraic sum of their source intensities is nonzero. The nullor does not possess a scattering matrix. However, we can take as the auxiliary network a second nullor connected with its null-port parallel to the nor-port of the first nullor and vice versa. Then all voltages and currents are determinate, viz. zero, but the result is not very interesting. For convenience in drawing circuits and also in analyzing them, we can split the nullor into two one-ports known as the nullator (null-port) and the norator (nor-port). These elements were introduced by Carlin and Youla (1961) and have been the source of some confusion. Provided, however, we recognize the nullator and norator always as a pair and as a shorthand for
null - p o r t
nor - p o r t
nullator
norator
FIG.17. The nullor and its equivalent nullator-norator form
THE GYRATOR IN ELECTRONIC SYSTEMS
115
the nullor, the theory will be in order (Tellegen, 1966). On no account can we consider networks in which the number of nullators is not equal to the number of norators. The advantage of using the norator and nullator is that various alternative realizations, involving different ways of combining the norators and nullators into nullors, can readily be seen from the same circuit diagram. As already mentioned, the nullor is a natural idealization of the transistor. Thus in Fig. 18, if we imagine the current amplification factor p of a
FIG. 18. The nullor derived as idealization of a transistor (three-terminal form) or of two transistors (galvanically separated two-port form).
transistor to tend to infinity, we obtain the condition i, = 0. If we also allow the differential emitter-base resistance to tend to zero, we obtain the condition u1 = 0. The collector-emitter voltage and collector current are then determined by the external circuitry. In fact modern integrated circuit techniques enable us to fabricate an artificial transistor which very closely approximates the nullor condition. As Fig. 18 shows, we can either approximate the three-terminal nullor or the two-port nullor, with galvanic isolation between the ports, by using one or two (artificial) transistors (Voorman and Biesheuvel, 1972). We can also regard the nullor as an idealization of the operational amplifier. In such an amplifier the gain is very high. Hence if the output voltage or current remains reasonably limited, both the input voltage and current will be very small. Again, the nullor equations seem a very reasonable idealization. Furthermore, the operational amplifier is always used in
116
K. M. ADAMS, E. F. A. DEPRETTERE AND J. 0. VOORMAN
conjunction with some kind of feedback network, which is in complete agreement with what the theory demands of the nullor. It matters little what the value of the gain A is, provided it is high. However, the frequency dependence of this factor, as well as other parameters of the amplifier, are of course important for the stability of the complete network in which the amplifier is embedded, and in such considerations, because A is not infinite,
FIG.19. The nullor derived as idealization of rhe operational amplifier
its argument as a function of the frequency is important. Nevertheless, in the preliminary design we can neglect all such considerations and check at a later stage of the actual hardware design whether the complete system is stable or not. E . Gyr-utors Constructed fiom Nullors and Resistors
It is evident that we cannot construct a gyrator from nullors alone, since the nullor equations and Kirchhoff's laws alone cannot lead to a relation connecting voltages with currents. In order to obtain the gyrator equations as the eliminant of the complete set of network equations, it is necessary to add some element that relates voltages to currents and the resistor does this in the simplest possible way. The next question that arises is: how many nullors and resistors d o we need? It has been proved that at least two resistors and at least two nullors are needed for the realization of a gyrator." Further, it is known that a gyrator can be realized using two resistors and three nullors or by using two nullors and four resistors. It has also been 'Recent work by the authors, submitted for publication.
THE GYRATOR IN ELECTRONIC SYSTEMS
117
conjectured that it is impossible to realize a gyrator from two resistors and fewer than three nullors or from two nullors and fewer than four resistors. A complete proof of this conjecture has recently been obtained.* 1. Networks with Two Resistors We shall now examine the circuits containing only two resistors. a. Parallel type. Consider first the equation u1 = - R i , . (62) Evidently a two-port network can satisfy this relation if we ensure that port current 2 flows through the resistor and that the voltage thus developed over the resistor is made equal to the voltage of port 1. In order to effect this equality of voltages without influencing the currents, we need to use the nullator. If galvanic isolation between the ports is required, then two norators will be needed. If we use two norators, then we must also employ two nullators, and we thus obtain the subnetwork of Fig. 20a. In the same way we obtain the subnetwork of Fig. 20b, which realizes the equation
u 2 = Ri,,
and finally we obtain the complete realization of the gyrator by connecting these subnetworks in parallel as shown in Fig. 20c. There are various interesting points to note about this realization. First, the galvanic isolation between ports and resistors is complete. If we are prepared to sacrifice this isolation, we can short-circuit a norator and a nullator, thereby rendering one nullor superfluous. We can thus devise three-nullor networks of four different types (Fig. 21), depending on whether (i) the ports have a common terminal (Fig. 21a), (ii) both resistors are incident to a terminal (Fig. 21b), (iii) one resistor is incident to terminals of different ports (Fig. 21c), or (iv) the two resistors are incident to different terminals of the same port (Fig. 21d). Secondly, a large number of gyrator circuits have appeared in the literature based on the antiparallel connection of two voltage-controlled current sources. Such a structure is an alternative way of regarding the networks of Figs. 20 and 21, since the network of Fig. 20a is the nullor-resistor equivalent of the voltage-controlled current source. If galvanic isolation can be sacrificed, one nullor in each such equivalent network can be replaced by short circuits. However, an extra nullor is still required for the 180" phase difference of the transconductances, or if one prefers it, the antiparallel connection. The final result is that one of the networks of Fig. 21 must result * Recent work
by the authors, submitted for publication.
118
K. M. ADAMS, E. F. A. DEPRETTERE AND J. 0. VOORMAN
0
1
FIG. 20. Realization of the gyrator equations: separately (a) and (b). of the combined gyrator equations; (c). by two resistors and four nullors. This is the basic parallel-connection form.
if each controlled source is replaced by its nullor-resistor equivalent and if the ports are not completely galvanically isolated. The third point to note is that since two physically distinct resistors are necessary, which in practice can never be exactly equal, we in fact synthetize a two-port with admittance matrix
which corresponds to a passive two-port, only if G I = G , . Otherwise the two-port is active. Thus we see that even in this early stage of design, where we assume that the nullors are ideal, a fundamental difficulty arises. This means that the behavior of any such two-port will have to be analyzed in
THE GYRATOR IN ELECTRONIC SYSTEMS
119
FIG.21. Three-nuilor, two-resistor realizations. There are just four distinct types.
detail in the context of the application for which it is intended before one can say whether it is an acceptable approximation to the ideal gyrator or not. However, there is one simple situation in which one of the primary properties of the ideal gyrator also applies to the two-port under discussion. Namely, if port 2 is terminated in an admittance Y, an impedance at port 1 can be observed satisfying
Z = R,R,Y.
(65)
That is, the impedance-inversion property of the gyrator applies and the resulting one-port is passive. Use of this type of circuit in conjunction with a capacitance for the simulation of an inductance is thus feasible (Orchard, 1970). As we shall see later, this basic circuit can be implemented electronically with excellent results.
120
K. M. ADAMS. E. F. A. DEPRETTERE A N D J. 0. VOORMAN
The fourth property to note is that the ports and the resistors of the circuit of Fig. 20 can be interchanged without the properties or the configuration changing. In the practical implementation, such an interchange does have an effect due to the imperfections of the components used to realize the nullors. We note in passing that if one port and one resistor are interchanged, a positive impedance converter results.
7 (a)
2
1
2'
1'
(b)
FIG.22. Realization based on the series connection.
As has already been noted, the basic configuration can be regarded as the parallel connection of two voltage-controlled current sources. One may ask whether it is possible to realize a gyrator by the series connection of two current-controlled voltage sources. The answer is that it is possible but that apparently six nullors are required. The current-controlled voltage source with complete galvanic isolation between the ports is shown in Fig. 22a. The series connection of two such controlled sources is shown in Fig. 22b. It is not possible to reduce the number of nullors in a controlled source without losing galvanic isolation of the ports, and galvanic isolation is required for at least one of the controlled-source circuits for the series connection to be valid. However, in the complete network two of the nullors are superfluous.
THE GYRATOR IN ELECTRONIC SYSTEMS
121
Thus in Fig. 22b, the nullators A , and A , serve only to constrain one terminal of R , to have the same potential as node 1. The norators B , , B, serve only to constrain the current in R , to be equal to the current through terminal 1’. We can thus eliminate A , and B , as shown in Fig. 23. Similar considerations apply to the nullators C , and C,
FIG.23. Derivation of the basic form from the series connection
and the norators D , and D , . The result of these operations shown in Fig. 23 is that the basic configuration of Fig. 20 is obtained. Thus the fifth point to note is that the approach via the impedance matrix does not offer anything new except the use of two superfluous elements. The sixth point to note is that in the configuration of Fig. 20, each port current flows through two norators and a resistor, which are separate circuits without common branches. The voltages developed across the resistors are brought over to the ports by distinct pairs of nullators. In the various three-nullor circuits of Fig. 21, this separation of signal paths is maintained; the only difference is that one of the signal paths requires only one norator or only one nullator. This property is of considerable importance when the electronic realization of the nullors is being considered. Various other forms o f three-nullor two-resistor configurations have been proposed which realize the defining equations directly (Daniels, 1969) but which involve signal paths containing more than the minimum number of norators and with branches common to both signal paths. From the point of view of practical realization such circuits, as a result of imperfections in the electronic circuitry, are much more likely to be adversely affected by undesirable and uncontrollable parasitic effects than the configuration of
122
K. M. ADAMS, E. F. A. DEPRETTERE A N D J . 0. VOORMAN
Fig. 20 and its derivatives in Fig. 21. Some of these less interesting circuits, which can all be derived from Fig. 21 by changing a norator connection, are shown in Fig. 24.
a
0
n
0
v
0
L '
0
A
0
4
b. Hybrid type. Another way to realize the gyrator is to use a mixed form of equations whereby the voltage of one port is expressed in terms of the voltage of the other port and the currents, or whereby a relation between the two port currents and a voltage is used. Thus we can write it1 =
-Ri,,
u2
u1
=
+ R(i, + i2),
(66)
(67)
THE GYRATOR I N ELECTRONIC SYSTEMS
123
or
i,
=
-Gu,,
il = i,
+ G(ul + u,).
These equations can be realized by controlled sources. Since, however, any gyrator realization based on nullors requires at least two distinct resistors, a direct realization of Eqs. (66) and (67) really results in realizing the equations
u1 = - R , i 2 , u,
R2(i1+ i,)
+ u1 = R,il + ( R , - Rl)i,.
(70) Since the resistances are never exactly equal, we obtain an impedance matrix with a nonzero diagonal element. If port 1 of such a two-port is terminated by a capacitor, then we observe at port 2 an impedance given by =
Z
=
R, - Rl
+ pR,R,C,
(71) which represents the series combination of an inductor and a resistor, which may be positive or negative. This is an undesirable parasitic effect which is not present in the realization of Section V,E,l,a. If port 2 is terminated by a capacitor, then an impedance equivalent to an inductance in parallel with a resistance (negative or positive) is seen at the other port. In order to get an idea of the magnitude of this parasitic effect, let us choose two nominally equal resistors with 1% tolerance. In the worst case then
If we now terminate both ports of the gyrator-like device in equal capacitors, we obtain a resonant circuit with resonance frequency given by
The Q of such a tuned circuit at resonance is
This means that with arbitrarily chosen resistances within the 17; tolerance For range, the Q can have any value in the ranges (50, a )and ( - 50, - a). this reason, realizations of a gyrator based on Eqs. (66)-(70) are less interesting than those based on Fig. 20, and will not be discussed further in this survey. For completeness, however, we give some of these realizations in Fig. 25 (Mitra, 1969).
124
K. M. ADAMS, E. F. A. DEPRETTERE A N D J. 0. VOORMAN
.
FIG. 25. Some hybrid realization forms. [The right-hand circuit satisfies Eqs. (68) and (69) if the polarity of i i 2 is reversed.]
2. Networks w i t h FOLWResistors One of the first electronic circuits for the realization of a gyrator was proposed by Klein (1952). This circuit involved three ideal pentodes and one resistor. When reduced to its fundamental form, this results in a network consisting of three nullors and four resistors, which thus contains one more than the minimum number of nullors. A similar circuit, but with floating ports, was given by Sharpe (1957). This circuit contains four ideal pentodes and this is equivalent to a network of four nullors and four resistors. Since this early work, large numbers of gyrator circuits based on four resistors have been proposed. Here we restrict the discussion to those circuits containing the minimum number of nullors. Nonminimal circuits would appear to have little, if any advantage to offer above minimal circuits. The use of extra nullors means in general that in the electronic realization more supply power will be needed; also the use of extra nullors and extra resistors in the main signal paths of the circuit will usually result in extra noise superimposed on the signals. We now consider the basic type of minimal circuit based on four resistors. In view of the discussion of Section V,E,l,b, any realization in which the admittance matrix contains diagonal terms depending on the difference of two resistances will not lead, in conjunction with two capacitors, to a resonant circuit with a high and stable Q. Accordingly, any such realizations should be avoided. Two of these unsuitable circuits are shown in Fig. 26. It has been shown* that when the diagonal terms of the admittance matrix are always zero independently of the resistance values, and the resistors are suitably numbered, then one transfer admittance must be equal to * G I , *Recent work by the authors, t o bc submitted for publication.
THE GYRATOR IN ELECTRONIC SYSTEMS
125
FIG.26. Two two-nullor. four-resistor realizations with nonzero diagonal terms in the Z-matrix. For network (a), u , = -R,i,, u 2 = R , i , + ( R , R , Rb/R,)i,. For network (b) i d 1 = R , i,, 11, = - R , i, + ( R 2 - R , R h / R a ) i 2 . -
while the other is equal to G, GJG, . The synthesis of the first port equation
i,
=
-Gli12,
(75)
does not present a new situation in respect to the discussion of Section V,E,1. The second port equation, however,
strongly suggests that some form of current or voltage conversion, given by the ratio G3/G4, must take place. Such a voltage or current ratio, involving the values of the conductances in this simple way, cannot be generated by a network of positive resistances. Accordingly, we need one nullor to effect this operation on the voltages and currents. That leaves one nullor and two resistors available to establish a relation between currents and voltages. Since a gyrator cannot be synthetized from a nullor and two resistors alone, the relations which the subnetwork of one nullor and two resistors determine must be of the form i, = EG,Zf, ,
i,
=
EG~LI,,
(77)
(78)
126
K. M. ADAMS, E. F. A. DEPRETTERE A N D J. 0. VOORMAN
where 6 = 1. These equations define a two-port known as a negative impedance inverter. It can be realized as shown in Fig. 27, whereby E can be either + 1 or - 1 according to the choice of reference polarity and current direction of one of the ports.
FIG.27. Negative-impedance inverter
It is evident that with such a simple circuit of two resistors and one nullor, complete galvanic separation of the ports is impossible. Furthermore, this network is the only configuration of these components which can correspond to Eqs. (77) and (78), as can readily be verified by investigating all the possible interconnections of two resistors, a nullator, and a norator. The subnetwork responsible for the current or for the voltage inversion must be capable of inducing a change of sign in one of the equations (77) and (78). Such a network is known as a negative impedance converter and can be
+
F u r
JG=+
u4
+"4
u2
FIG.28. Negative-impedance converter: (a) voltage inversion. (b) current inversion
realized either according to Fig. 28a (negative voltage inverter), thus corresponding to the equations
i,
= - i,
,
THE GYRATOR IN ELECTRONIC SYSTEMS
127
or according to Fig. 28b (negative current inverter)
A cascade connection of the network of Fig. 27 and of one of the networks of Fig. 28 in any of the four ways (Antoniou, 1969) shown in Fig. 29 results in a realization of the gyrator when
(d)
(C)
FIG.29. Gyrator realizations resulting from a cascade connection of the networks of Figs. 27 and 28.
B (a)
FIG.30. Gyrator realization resulting from Fig. 27 and a negative resistance.
Although there are eight different ways of combining these subnetworks in cascade, only four of them are distinct. There are, however, two other distinct possibilities, obtained by replacing one of the resistors in Fig. 27 by a negative resistor, which in turn can be effected by a combination of a negative impedance converter and a positive resistor. Although there appear to be many ways of doing this, the two networks of Fig. 30 are the only distinct possibilities (Antoniou, 1969). One can also realize the negative resistor by a combination of a positive resistor and a negative impedance inverter, but this does not lead to any new circuits.
128
K. M. ADAMS, E. F. A. DEPRETTERE A N D J . 0 . VOORMAN
The networks of Figs. 29d and 30b are particularly interesting from a practical point of view, since both norators are incident to a terminal node. In the operational-amplifier implementation of these circuits, this terminal can be connected to the earth or to a special current source of the power supply. Both networks are nullor-resistor equivalents of operational amplifier circuits which have been successfully employed in practice. Figure 29d shows a network due to Antoniou (1969) and further developed by Trimmel and Heinlein (1971). Figure 30b is a simple variant of the wellknown circuit due to Riordan (1967), which has been frequently applied to filter realizations (Orchard and Sheahan, 1970). 3. Comparison q f the Two-Resistor and Four-Resistor- Cor$gurution.s The question now arises, which of the various nullor-resistor networks is likely to lead to the best final realization? We cannot answer this question properly until we have considered the electronic design of the nullors and the accompanying supply circuits. This in turn will depend on the application and involves questions such as earthing. However, there are two advantages which the two-resistor configurations have over the four-resistor configurations. If an inductance is to be simulated, the accuracy will depend on the tolerance of the resistance values. Thus with 1% components, the maximum deviation in the inductance value will be 2% for the two-resistor configuration and 4% for the four-resistor configuration (assuming ideal nullors). Also, as we shall see later, the noise generated by the resistors and observable at the ports is in the optimum case twice as great for the fourresistor as for the two-resistor configuration. However, the total noise includes that generated by the electronic circuitry, and it is possible that, depending on the electronic realization, a twonullor four-resistor circuit will have a lower total noise power than a four- or three-nullor, two-resistor circuit with the same basic electronic realization of the nullor and supply circuits. Only the configuration of Fig. 20 has complete galvanic separation of the ports and is thus suitable for the realization of fully floating gyrator circuits. However, the question of floating ports is also intimately connected with the supply circuitry, and some of the other configurations with their proper power supply circuits can provide satisfactory realizations of gyrator circuits with semifloating ports.
VI. BASICELECTRONIC DESIGN In this section we shall consider the electronic realization of the nullors and their associated supply circuits. We can, however, discuss these matters separately and in general terms only to a limited extent, since the perfor-
THE GYRATOR IN ELECTRONIC SYSTEMS
129
mance of the complete circuit depends on the interaction of the various parts in a rather complicated way and involves such matters as input impedances, frequency response, stability, dissipation, noise, intermodulation distortion, offset voltages, and ‘‘ latch-up (multiple stable states). This interaction will vary from circuit to circuit so that it is necessary to consider all of these effects in the context of a specific design. ”
A . Realizations Based on Two Resistors in the Signal Path In order to get an idea of the problems involved let us first consider a very simple circuit (Blom and Voorman, 1971) based on Fig. 21a and shown in Fig. 31. Here, we approximate the nullor by a single transistor. In order to supply the transistors with direct current and at the same time to preserve the low short-circuit input admittances at the ports, current sources are needed. Simple circuits for realizing these current sources are shown in Fig.32. Because the circuit is directly coupled, we need both P N P and N P N transistors for both the signal processing and the supply current sources. We can judge the performance of the circuit in the first instance by determining the quality factor of a tuned circuit