ADVANCES IN CHILD DEVELOPMENT AND BEHAVIOR
VOLUME 12
Contributors to This Volume Marc H. Bornstein
David Klahr
William J. Friedman
Howard V . Meredith
Howard Gadlin
Bruce M. Ross
Stephen M. Kerst
Robert S . Siegler
ADVANCES IN CHILD DEVELOPMENT AND BEHAVIOR
edited by Hayne W. Reese
Lewis P. Lipsitt
Department of Psychology West Virginia University Morgantown, West Virginia
Department of Psychology Brown University Providence, Rhode Island
VOLUME 12
@
1978
ACADEMIC PRESS New York
San Francisco London
A Subsidiary of Harcourt Brace Jovanovich, Publishers
COPYRIGHT @ 1978, BY ACADEMIC PRESS,INC. ALL RIGHTS RESERVED. NO PART OF THIS PUBLICATION MAY BE REPRODUCED OR TRANSMITTED IN ANY FORM OR BY ANY MEANS, ELECTRONIC OR MECHANICAL, INCLUDING PHOTOCOPY, RECORDING, OR ANY INFORMATION STORAGE AND RETRIEVAL SYSTEM, WITHOUT PERMISSION IN WFUTING FROM THE PUBLISHER.
ACADEMIC PRESS, INC.
111 Fifth Avenue, New York, New York 10003
United Kingdom Edition published by ACADEMIC PRESS, INC. (LONDON) LTD. 24/28 Oval Road, London N W l 7DX
LIBRARY OF CONGRESS
CATALOG CARD
NUMBER:63-23231
ISBN 0-12-009712-5 PRINTED IN THE UNITED STATES OF AMERICA
Contents List of Contributors Preface
................................................
....................................................
. . .. . . . . . .
vii
.......
ix
Research between 1960 and 1970 on the Standing Height of Young Children in Different Parts of the World I. I1 . I11 . IV . V. VI . VII . VIII . IX . X.
HOWARD V . MEREDJTH Introduction . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . ....... Comparisons Among Ethnic Groups . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . ................ National and Intranational Group Comparisons . . . . . . Rural and Urban Groups Compared . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Rural Groups Compared with Urban Socioeconomic Groups . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Intracity and Intercity Comparisons . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Female and Male Groups Compared . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Comparisons from Subgrouping for Other Variables . . . . . . . . . . . . Estimates of Population Variability and Their Uses . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . ................ Summary . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . References . . .............................................
2 3 11 17 20 25 36 39 43 48 50
The Representation of Children’s Knowledge DAVID KLAHR AND ROBERT S . SIEGLER ........................ 1. Introduction . . . . . . . . . . . . . . I1. From Behavioral to Cognitive Objectives . . . . . . . . . . . ......... I11 . IV . V. VI . VII . VI11. IX .
Some Criteria for Choosing a Representation . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Balance Scale Task . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Experiment I : Assessing Initial Knowledge . ........................ Experiment 2: Training on the Balance Scale ......... Revised Representations for Balance Scale Knowledge ........................ Experiment 3: Encoding Hypothesis . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Discussion: Some Answers and Some Further Questions ...................... X . Conclusion . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . References . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
62 63
64 66 69 74 77 95 102 105 113
Chromatic Vision in Infancy MARC H . BORNSTEIN I . Introduction . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . I1. Fundamental Data of Color Vision: Ontogeny . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
.. ...
117 123
vi
Contents
111. Summary . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . References . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
167 169
Developmental Memory Theories: Baldwin and Piaget 1. I1 . Ill . IV . V.
BRUCE M . ROSS AND STEPHEN M . KERST Introduction: Justification and Scope . . . . . . . . . . . . . . J . M . Baldwin’s Theory of Memory . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Piaget’s Theory of Memory . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Comparison Between Memory Theories . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Topical Memory Research ............................... References . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
184 186 195 210 212 226
Child Discipline and the Pursuit of Self: An Historical Interpretation HOWARD GADLIN I . Introduction . .......................................... II . The Nineteenth Century-The Transformation of the Traditional Family . . . . . . . . . 111. The Nature of Colonial Control . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 1V . Control in the Jacksonian Er.i . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . V . The Ideology of the Family . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . VI . Child Rearing in the Modem Era . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . VII . Child Rearing in the Modem Era-Child Discipline . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . VIII . Personhood and Child Discipline in Contemporary America . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . IX . Conclusion . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . X . A Note on the Role of Child Development and Psychology . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . References . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
23 1 235 236 238 240 244 248 253 259 260 261
Development of Time Concepts in Children WILLIAM J . FRIEDMAN Introduction . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . ..................... Logical Time . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Conventional Time . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Experiential Time . . . . . . . . ...... ........................... V . Summary and Conclusion . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . ....................... References . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . ........
I. I1. 111. IV .
267 269 280 286 294 296
Author Index . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
299
Subject Index . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
313
Contents of Previous Volumes . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
315
List of Contributors Numbers in parentheses indicate the page5 on which the authors’ contributions begin
MARC H. BORNSTEIN Department of Psychology, Princeton IJniversity, Princeton, New Jersey (117) WILLIAM J. FRIEDMAN Department of Psychology, Ohrlin College, Oberlin, Ohio (267) HOWARD GADLIN Department of Psychology, University (fMassachusetts, AmherAt, Mussuchusetts (231) STEPHEN M. KERST Boys Town Centerfor the Study of Youth Development of Cutholic University, Washington, D.C. (183) DAVID KLAHR Depurtment of Psychology, Carnegie-Mellon University, Pittsburgh, Pennsylvaniu (61) HOWARD V. MEREDITH College of Health und Physicul Education, University of South Curolina, Columbia, South Carolina ( 1 ) BRUCE M. ROSS Boys Town Center for the Study of Youlh Development of Cutholic University, Washington, D.C. (183) ROBERT S . SIEGLER Depurtment of Psychology, Curnegie-Mellon University, Pittsburgh Pennsylvania (61)
~
vii
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
Preface The amount of research and theoretical discussion in the field of child development and behavior is so vast that researchers, instructors, and students are confronted with a formidable task in keeping abreast of new developments within their areas of specialization through the use of primary sources, as well as being knowledgeable in areas peripheral to their primary focus of interest. Moreover, there is often simply not enough journal space to permit publication of more speculative kinds of analyses which might spark expanded interest in a problem area or stimulate new modes of attack on the problem. The serial publication Advances in Child Development and Behavior is intended to ease the burden by providing scholarly technical articles serving as reference material and by providing a place for publication of scholarly speculation. In these documented critical reviews, recent advances in the field are summarized and integrated, complexities are exposed, and fresh viewpoints are offered. They should be useful not only to the expert in the area but also to the general reader. No attempt is made to organize each volume around a particular th,-me or topic, nor is the series intended to reflect the development of new fads. Manuscripts are solicited from investigators conducting programmatic work on problems of current and significant interest. The editor often encourages the preparation of critical syntheses dealing intensively with topics of relatively narrow scope but of considerable potential interest to the scientific community. Contributors are encouraged to criticize, integrate, and stimulate, but always within a framework of high scholarship. Although appearance in the volumes is ordinarily by invitation, unsolicited manuscripts will be accepted for review if submitted first in outline form to the editor. All papers-whether invited or submittedreceive careful editorial scrutiny. Invited papers are automatically accepted for publication in principle, but may require revision before final acceptance. Submitted papers receive the same treatment except that they are not automatically accepted for publication even in principle, and may be rejected. We wish to acknowledge with gratitude the aid of our home institutions, West Virginia University and Brown University, which generously provided time and facilities for the preparation of this volume. We also wish to thank Drs. John Hagen, Patricia Self, Barbara Wilcox, and James Youniss for their editorial assistance. Hayne W. Reese Lewis P. Lipsitt ix
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
RESEARCH BETWEEN 1960 AND 1970 ON THE STANDING HEIGHT OF YOUNG CHILDREN IN DIFFERENT PARTS OF THE WORLD
Howard V . Meredith UNIVERSITY OF SOUTH CAROLINA
I . INTRODUCTION II . COMPARISONS AMONG ETHNIC GROUPS. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . A . GROUP DESCRIPTIONS . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . B . GROUP COMPARISONS . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
2 3 3 10
111. NATIONAL AND INTRANATIONAL GROUP COMPARISONS . . . . . . A . GROUP DESCRIPTIONS . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . B . GROUP COMPARISONS . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
II 11 16
IV . RURAL AND URBAN GROUPS COMPARED . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . A . GROUP DESCRIPTIONS . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . B . GROUP COMPARISONS . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
17 17 19
V . RURAL GROUPS COMPARED WITH URBAN SOCIOECONOMIC GROUPS . . A . RURAL GROUPS COMPARED WITH URBAN PRIVILEGED GROUPS . . . B . RURAL GROUPS COMPARED WITH URBAN UNDERPRIVILEGED GROUPS . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
20 20
VI . INTRACITY AND INTERCITY COMPARISONS . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . A . INTRACITY ETHNIC GROUPS COMPARED . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . B . INTRACITY SOCIOECONOMIC GROUPS COMPARED . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . C . INTERCITY COMPARISONS . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
25 25 27 33
VII . FEMALE AND MALE GROUPS COMPARED . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . A . GROUP DESCRIPTIONS . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . B . GROUP COMPARISONS . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
36 36 38
VIII . COMPARISONS FROM SUBGROUPING FOR OTHER VARIABLES . . . . . . . . . A . COMPARISONS FROM SUBGROUPING BY BIRTH WEIGHT AND BIRTH ORDER . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . B . COMPARISONS FOR SINGLE AND TWIN BIRTHS, AND SMOKING WITH NONSMOKING MOTHERS . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
39
23
39 40
I
2
Howard V . Meredith
C. COMPARISONS FOR PHYSICAL ABNORMALITY, ELEVATION OF HABITAT, HEALTH STATUS, AND HEALTH CARE . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 1X. ESTIMATES OF POPULATION VARIABILITY AND THEIR USES.. . . . . . . . . . A. CHOOSING A METHOD OF ESTIMATING POPULATION VARIABILITY IN STANDINGHEIGHT . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . B. STANDARD DEVIATION ESTIMATES OF POPULATION VARIABILITY. X. SUMMARY . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . REFERENCES . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
41
43
43 45
48 50
I. Introduction The central purpose of this chapter is to compile, systematize, and compare findings from worldwide research on a delimitable aspect of child growth. Consideration is restricted to data on standing height collected primarily during the calendar years from 1960 through 1970. There is further circumscription to the segment of human ontogeny commonly designated early childhood, or the preschool years; within this frame, the focus is on standing height at ages 3 and 5 years. Viewed with explicit reference to the species, calendar period, age span, and somatic dimension under study, the broad objectives of the chapter are as follows: 1. To bring together, in ordered and conveniently usable form, a large quantity of information widely scattered in scientific journals, research monographs, service reports, and unpublished documents. 2 . To provide, by pooling metric data gathered on similar samples of children, statistics adequate to support more precise factual statements and more tenable generalizations than are obtainable from the component studies taken piecemeal. 3. To discover, through alignment and intercomparison of statistics not previously placed in juxtaposition, new facets of biologic knowledge. All sections of the chapter pertain to the standing height of contemporary child populations at ages 3 and 5 years. Sections 11-VII present a substantial array of findings on similarities and differences i n average height among tribal and national groups, rural and urban groups, intracity ethnic and socioeconomic groups, and sex groups. Section IX treats within-group variability in height, and Section VlIl assembles studies, presently sparse, on relations of height in early childhood with birth weight, birth order, maternal use of tobacco during pregnancy, single versus twin delivery, and elevation of habitat. A few of the investigations drawn upon wed measures of body length in dorsal
Standing Height of Young Children
3
recumbency; averages computed from these measures were reduced 1.5 cm as an adjustment to estimated height when standing erect (Meredith, 1960; Roche & Davila, 1974; Smith & Brown, 1970a). Several studies provided averages from standing height at ages 2.5 years, 3.5 years, and so forth; averages for ages 3 years and 5 years were secured by rectilinear interpolation. Most studies reported means for each sex separately; in many parts of the chapter it was parsimonious to combine these means and present values for groups of children taken without regard to sex. Sex differences are dealt with (Section VII) in the same manner as socioeconomic and other subgroup differences within samples. Although more than 200 studies are drawn upon, the coverage of relevant investigations is not exhaustive. Some references were located that could not be procured through interlibrary loan service or by direct overseas correspondence. Moreover, it would be unwarranted to presume that any scholar attempting a colligation of worldwide scope had been able to locate every research report available.
11. Comparisons Among Ethnic Groups A.
GROUP DESCRIPTIONS
Table I presents statistics for standing height drawn from investigations on young children of 42 contemporary ethnic groups. Each row of the table is assigned a numerical tag (Column l), thereby facilitating later reference to either the content of the row or the text description of its source. Column 2 of the table indicates the ethnic group to which the row pertains. Column 4 lists, in ascending order of magnitude, means obtained at age 3 years; means at age 5 years are given in Column 6. The numbers of children measured at the two ages are specified in Columns 3 and 5. Before comparative findings are extracted from Table I, the ethnic group represented in each row will be described, and its bibliographic source(s) cited. Tug 1-1. The data analyzed in 1-1 were collected during 1962-1964 in three Guatemalan villages situated within 50 km of Guatemala City at elevations near 2.2 km; about 95% of the subjects were “indigenous Mayan” Amerinds (Guzman, Scrimshaw, Bruch, & Gordon, 1968; Scrimshaw, Guzman, Kevany, Ascoli, Bruch, & Gordon, 1967). At one of the villages, children “received a food supplement” and “their mothers were given advice on nutrition;” another village provided “improved sanitation and medical services;” while the third lacked these special dietary or health resources. In all three villages “signs suggestive of nutritional deficiency were relatively few. ” Tag 1-2. Malcolm (1 970) obtained the statistics in 1-2 from data gathered in 1967 at villages of the Bundi tribe located at altitudes between .6 and 2.2 km in
Howard V . Meredith
4
TABLE I Mean Standing Height (cm) for 42 Ethnic Groups of Young Children Measured Mainly Between 1960 and 1970 Age 5 years
Age 3 years
Tag
Group
I- I " 1-2 1-3 1-4 1-5
Mayan Bundi Lunda Burmese Lumi Landino Angus and Sura Quechua Shi Lufa Javanese Karkar Melanesian Nivkh Mandinka Antilles black Surinam Bushnegro Surinam Indonesian Antilles Indian and black Surinam lndustani Sumatra Javanese Surinam Amerind Chuvash Eskimo Yoruba Australian Aborigine Azerbaijani Fiji Melanesian Lebanese Surinam Creole Canadian Amerind Hawaiian Japanese Texan Spanish Tatar Lithuanian Blackfeet Hutu Assiniboine and Gros Ventres Kirghiz Lebanese Armenian United States white
1-6
1-7 1-8 1-9 I- 10 1-11 1-12 1-13 I- 14 I- I5 1-16 1-17 1- I8 1- I9 1-20 1-21 1-22 1-23 1-24 1-25 1-26 1-27 1-28 1-29 1-30 1-3I 1-32 1-33 1-34 1-35 1-36 1-37 1-38 1-39 1-40
-
Sample size
Mean
300 I08 1.543 35 40 316 ca. 35 14 237
81.16 83.2 83.6 83.8 83.9 83.9 85.0 85. I 85.2
ca.
ca.
ca.
ca.
ca.
-
-
100
85.4 86.6 86.8' 87.0 87.6 88.3 88.7 89.4 89.6 89.8 89.8 89.9 90.0 90.3 90.5
62 49 43 265 90 59 200 487 I00 95 417 324 480 158
-
-
193 43 838 26 60 67
90.5 90.7 91.3 91.5 91.8 92.4
-
-
34 195 21 357 I25 565
92.6 93.3 94.0 94.5 94.5 94.7
Sample size
ca.
-
-
87 1,640 89 44 294 35 24 367 84
93.3 96.4 96.7 95.6 97.8 101.1 95.4 97.6 98.4
-
ca.
ca.
52 43 34 275 142 565 200 1,838 100
ca.
Mean
124 434 16 660 67 323 178 88 1,539 26
99.8 102.3c 100.3 101.8 103.3 102.6 104.5 104.3 99.7 101.8 102.6 102.9 103.7 104.5 105.2 105.7 103.9 1065
104.0
-
-
89 219 240 37 217 20 873 I79 593
104.6 105.0 107.5 108.8 103.6 108.9 106.7 108.6 108.8 (continued)
5
Standing Height of Young Children
TABLE 1 (continued) Age 5 years
Age 3 years
Tag 1-41 1-42
Group
Sara United States black
Sample size
Mean
-
-
164
95.4
Sample size 63 161
Mean 109.0 110.0
“Read “1-1” as Table I , row I . ”At age 3 years, taking SD,, at 4.4 cni, SE,,,, is .70 cm where n=40, .40 crn where n = 120, .25 cm where n=300, and .11 crn where n = 1500. Corresponding SE,,,,, values at age 5 years, taking SD,, as 5.0 cm, are .79, .46, .29, and . I 3 crn. Woodbury (1921) obtained SD,, values of 4.4 and 5.0 cm from data on large samples of United States white children; sample size exceeded 6500 at each age. Section IX will present findings on variability of standing height in numerous populations. cN’s and means from data collected in 1968 at Sudanese villages about 19 krn south of Khartoum are 62 and 87.0 cm for age 3 years and, for age 5 years, 67 and 102.5 cm (Sukkar, Johnson, Gadir, & Yousif, 1971).
the Madang district of east-central New Guinea. Although physical signs of malnutrition were rare, diet was appraised as insufficient in protein. Tug 1-3. The values in 1-3 were reported by David (1972) on “melanodermic aborigines” of the Lunda tribe measured during 1962-1963 at villages in Angola. The children were described as “Congolese Negroes whose basic ethnic mixture is considered a true negro type strongly influenced by pygmoid elements.” Tug 1-4. In 1961, the data yielding the results i n 1-4 were collected at several widely scattered villages in Burma (Berry, 1963~).A survey team of the Interdepartmental Committee on Nutrition for National Defense (ICNND) found no clinical evidence of caloric insufficiency, protein inadequacy, or deficiency of vitamins A, C, or D; riboflavin and thiamine intakes were low. Tug 1-5. The samples of Lumi children characterized in 1-5 were measured between 1962 and 1967 in villages located at elevations near .5 km on foothills of the Toricelli mountains in the Sepik district (Lumi subdistrict) of north-central New Guinea (Wark & Malcolm, 1969). There were dietary inadequacies in protein and calories, but overt malnutrition was infrequent. Tug 1-6. Records for the study of Ladino (mixed Spanish and Amerind) children were amassed during 1969-1972 at “villages in the department of El Progreso,” Guatemala, situated at altitudes between 0.3 km and 1.1 km (Yarbrough, Habicht, Malina, Lechtig, & Klein, 1975). Although belonging to a group in which “mild-to-moderate protein-calorie malnutrition is endemic,” the children were evaluated as “in clinically good health.” A mean of 83.4 cm was
6
Howard V . Meredith
reported from records in 49 other Guatemalan children residing at villages in which malnutrition and infection were prevalent (Blanco, Acheson, Canosa, & Salomon, 1974). Tug 1-7. The statistics in 1-7 were obtained from measures taken during 1960-1961 on children of the Sura and Angus tribes living in the Pankshin area of the Jos plateau, northern Nigeria (Collis, Dema, & Lesi, 1962). The children were “in a good nutritional state.” Tug 1-8. The values in 1-8 were secured from measures taken during 19641966 on Quechua Amerind children living in the vicinity of Nuiioa, Peru, at altitudes of 3.9 to 4.4 km (Frisancho & Baker, 1970). Diet appeared adequate; the families were largely Andes pastoralists. Tug I-9. Data for the analysis in 1-9 were gathered between 1957 and 1967 on Bantu children of the Shi tribe residing in farming villages of the Ngweshe region, along the western shore of Kivu lake, Republic of Zaire (Vis, 1969, personal communications 1974 and 1975). Tug I-10. The mean in 1-10 was computed from measures taken in 1969 on Lufa children living in the vicinity of the Lufa subdistrict administrative center, eastern highlands, New Guinea (Harvey, personal communication 1974). Tug 1-11. Measures for the study in I- 11 were taken during 1963-1965 at five villages in central Java within a radius of 60 km from Semarang (Tie, Lian, Liong-Ong, & Rose, 1967). The subjects were “in moderately good health.” Tug 1-12. The records analyzed in 1-12 were obtained in 1969 on Melanesian children residing at villages on Karkar Island, northwest of New Guinea (Harvey, 1974, personal communication 1974). Tug 1-13. Arkhipova (1967) obtained the statistics in 1-13 from data collected in 1962 on Nivkh children residing on Sakhalin Island, an island off eastern Siberia, north of Japan. Tag 1-14. During 1962-1963, measures were made on black children, “mostly Mandinkas,” living at four hinterland villages-Jali, Kantongkunda, Keneba, and Manduar-situated about 160 km from Bathurst, Gambia (McGregor, Rahman, Thompson, Billewicz, & Thomson, 1968; Thomson, Billewicz, Thompson, Illsley, Rahman, & McGregor, 1968). Tug 1-15. 1-15presents aggregate sample sizes and weighted means obtained by combining statistics from three studies. The row pertains to children of “black African descent” residing on islands of the Greater and Lesser Antilles. At age 3 years, the component means were 90.4 cm on 67 children measured during 1967-1969 in the rural district of Belair, south central St. Vincent Island (Antrobus, 1971); 89.9 cm on 70 children measured during 1963 in a rural region of Jamaica (Ashcroft, Lovell, George, & Williams, 1965); and 85.0 cm on about 130 children measured in 1961 on the islands of St. Kitts (St. Christopher) and St. Lucia (Berry, 1962~).At age 5 years, component sample sizes and means were 146 and 104.5 cm for Jamaica and about 130 and 98.7 cm for St. Kitts and
Sranding Height o j Young Children
7
St. Lucia. The Jamaican subjects were “predominantly of West African ancestry,” about 95% of the Vincentian subjects had black progenitors, and fully 80% of the subjects from the other islands were members of black families. An ICNND team appraised the diet of children on St. Kitts and St. Lucia as inadequate in protein and riboflavin. For the children of Jamaica, there were “no overt and unequivocal signs of malnutrition,” but dietary intake was low in protein and calories. Tag 1-16. Findings from three studies were poold in deriving the statistics for 1-16. At age 3 years, means of 87.1, 87.6, and 93.1 cm, respectively, were reported on 21 Bushnegroes living along the Surinam river (Luyken & LuykenKoning, 1961), 56 Bushnegroes living along the Tapanahony river (Doornbus, Jonxis, & Visser, 1968), and 13 Bushnegroes described as seminomadic residents of the interior (Van der Kuyp, 1967). At age 5 years, corresponding component means were 99.3, 101.1, and 105.0 cm, with sample sizes of 18, 34, and 90.The Van der Kuyp records were collected during 1964-1965, and the other records between 1958 and 1964. Surinam Bushnegroes are descendants of African slaves who moved to inner regions of Surinam. Tag 1-17. The statistics in I- 17 were obtained on children of Indonesian ancestry measured during 1964-1965 at rural and urban locations in Surinam (Van der Kuyp, 1967). Rural children comprised about 70% of the sample for age 3 years, and about 80% of that for age 5 years. Tug 1-18. Measures taken in 1961 on the islands of Tobago and Trinidad gave the results in 1-18 (Berry, 1952~). The sample was about 50% black, 40% Indian, and 10% mixed; diet was evaluated as inadequate in protein and riboflavin. Tag 1-19. Van der Kuyp (1967) secured the values in 1-19 from measures taken during 1964-1965 on children of Indian and Pakistani descent residing in rural regions and towns of Surinam. At ages 3 and 5 years, respectively, the percentages for children drawn from rural regions approximated 75 and 83%. Tag 1-20. The sample sizes and means in 1-20, reported by Shattock (1968), were computed from measures taken between 1960 and 1965 on offspring of Javanese immigrant families living at a rubber plantation on Sumatra; laboring families at the plantation received “good rations” and “free medical service.” Tug 1-21. Van der Kuyp (1967) obtained the statistics in 1-21 from data collected during 1964-1965 on Amerind children inhabiting the savannah zone of Surinam. Tag 1-22. The Chuvash (predominantly Turko-Tatar) records analyzed in 1-22 were amassed in 1961 on children residing at Cheboksary and on collective farms in the Kanashsky region of the Chuvash Autonomous Soviet Socialist Republic (Goldfeld, Merkova, & Tseimlina, 1965). Each age sample included nearly equal numbers of urban and rural children. Tag 1-23. Records for standing height at age 3 years were accumulated between 1961 and 1965 on 324 Eskimo children living at villages in southwest
8
Howard V . Meredith
Alaska (Heller, Scott, & Hammes, 1967). At age 5 years, a mean of 103.4 cm was obtained on 16 Eskimo males measured during 1968-1969 in the northern part of Upernavik district, Greenland; 103.4 minus .5 cm was taken as the estimated mean at age 5 years for children of both sexes (Drenhaus, SkrobakKacznski, & Jprgensen, 1974). Tug 1-24. Three samples of Yoruba children were pooled. At age 3 years, sample means were 88.0 cm for about 280 children measured during 1957-1963 at Imesi, a village in western Nigeria (Morley, Woodland, Martin, & Allen, 1968), and from measures taken between 1962 and 1970,89.9 cm for 89 children living in the poorest section of Ibadan, and 96.6 cm for 114 children living in well-to-do Ibadan homes (Janes, 1974, personal communication 1975). Corresponding means and sample sizes at age 5 years were 100.1 cm, around 240; 102.0 cm, 236; and 110.2 cm, 185. Tug 1-25. Kettle (1966) secured the statistics in 1-25 from measures on “fullblood aborigines” gathered between 1961 and 1965 at three coastal missions in the Northern Temtory, Australia. Tug 1-26. Data for computation of the mean in 1-26 were accumulated in 1961-1962 on native Azerbaijani children living at Baku, Azerbaijan Autonomous Soviet Socialist Republic (Goldfeld et al., 1965). Tug 1-27. Measures for the analysis in 1-27 were taken during 1959-1968 on Melanesian children residing in coastal villages of the Fiji archipelago (Hawley & Jansen, 1971). About 6% of the subjects showed signs of “borderline malnutrition. ’’ Tug 1-28. The subjects in 1-28, measured in 1961, were largely village children drawn from widely distributed locations in Lebanon. They were “predominantly Arabs,” although the sample included small numbers of “Armenians, Syrians, Egyptians, Palestinians, and Europeans” (Berry, 1962b). An ICNND team appraised the diet as adequate in calcium, marginal in thiamine, and deficient in iron, riboflavin, iodine, and vitamins A and D . Tug 1-29. The large samples of Creole (mixed black and mulatto) children in 1-29 were studied during 1964-1%5 “in Paramaribo, the Coronie district, and Para settlements” of Surinam (Van der Kuyp, 1967). Between 60 and 65% of the children measured at each age were urban residents. Tug 1-30. The means in 1-30 were secured from measures taken on Amerind children living at Ahousat, a Nootka reserve on “Flores Island, off the coast of Vancouver Island,” and at Anaham, a Chilcotin reserve “west of Williams Lake, British Columbia” (Birkbeck, Lee, Myers, & Alfred, 1971). Tug 1-31. The mean in 1-31 was computed from records collected during 1966-1967 on children of Japanese ancestry attending preschools in Honolulu (Smith & Brown, 1970b).
Standing Height of Young Children
9
Tug 1-32. The statistics in 1-32 were obtained on Spanish American children measured during 1%8 in several counties of Texas (McGanity, 1969, personal communication 1974). Tug 1-33. Goldfeld ef ul. (1965) reported the mean in 1-33 on Turkic Tatar children measured during 1961-1962 at Kazan, Tatar Autonomous Soviet Socialist Republic. Tug 1-34. The statistics in 1-34 were computed from records collected at Kaunas and Vilnius during 1961-1962 on native children of the Lithuanian Soviet Socialist Republic (Goldfeld et af., 1965). Tug 1-35. Fisk (1964a) reported the means in 1-35 from measures taken in 1961 on children of the Blackfeet tribe living on the Blackfeet reservation in northwest Montana. Diet was appraised as inadequate for calories, protein, calcium, iron, and vitamins A and C. Tag 1-36. The records for the study in 1-36 were accumulated during 19661967 on children of the Hutu tribe inhabiting the Butare region of Rwanda, along the eastern shore of Lake Kivu; about 70% of the children were “Bantu/Nilotic halfbreeds” and 30% “pure Nilotes” (Vis, 1969, personal communications 1974 and 1975). Tug 1-37. The subjects for the study in 1-37 were Amerinds of the Assiniboine and Gros Ventres tribes living on the Fort Belknap reservation, north-central Montana; they were measured in 1961 (Fisk, 1964d). Dietary evaluation revealed deficiencies in calories, protein, calcium, iron, and vitamins A and C. Tug 1-38. Between 1961 and 1964, data on Kirghiz (largely Mongoloid) children were collected at three urban centers in the Kirghiz Autonomous Soviet Socialist Republic. At age 3 years, sample sizes, means, and sources were 103, 93.1 cm, Naryn (Kudaiarov, 1966); 163, 94.6 cm, Dzhalal-Abad (Kozhonazarov, 1966); and 91, 95.8 cm, Frunze (Kudaiarov, 1966). Sample sizes and means at age 5 years were 197 and 104.6cm for children of Naryn, 404 and 106.7 cm for children of Frunze (Goldfeld et al., 1965; Kudaiarov, 1966) and 272 and 108.3 cm for children of Dzhalal-Abad. Naryn is situated at an elevation near 2.0 km; elevations of the other towns were given as near .8 km. Tug 1-39. The records analyzed in 1-39 were obtained on children of Armenian ancestry belonging to “upper and middle class” families residing at Beirut (S. J. Karayan, personal communication 1976). Tug 1-40. Two samples were combined at each age in 1-40. At age 3 years, component means were 94.3 cm for 186 children measured at several locations selected to yield samples “representative” of the United States white “noninstitutionalized population” in 197 1-1972 (Abraham, Lowenstein, & O’Connell, 1975), and 94.9 cm for 379 white children of all socioeconomic classes measured during 1968-1970 at urban and rural locations in 36 states and the District of Columbia (Owen, Kram, Garry, Lowe, & Lubin, 1974; Owen &
10
Howard V . Meredith
Lubin, 1973). Corresponding means and sample sizes at age 5 years were 109.3 cm, 214; and 108.5 cm, 378. Tag 1-41, The values at age 5 years in 1-4 1 were secured from measures on Sara children gathered in 1965 at preschools in Fort Archambault, Republic of Chad (Hiernaux & Asnes, 1974). The children were from homes of middle and upper socioeconomic classes; they showed no signs of malnutrition. Tag 1-42. At each age in 1-42, samples were pooled from the investigations discussed in 1-40. Means at age 3 years were 95.1 cm on 98 United States black children measured during 1971-1 972, and 95.8 cm on 66 United States black children measured during 1968-1970. Means and sample sizes at age 5 years were 110.1 cm, 96; and 109.8 cm, 65. B . GROUP COMPARISONS
Among the comparative findings of average standing height that can be drawn from Table I, are the following: 1. At age 3 years, the mean of 95.4 cm on black children of the United States exceeds the mean of 8 1.1 cm on Mayan village children of Guatemala by about 14 cm, or 17%. At age 5 years, the mean for United States black children exceeds that for Bundi village children of New Guinea by almost 17 cm, or 18%. The means obtained on Hutu rural children age 3 years and Bundi rural children 2 years older are identical; a similar relationship holds for United States black children age 3 years and Peruvian Quechua children 2 years older. 2. Lunda rural children of Angola are much shorter than black children of the United States. One-tailed significance tests a t p = .01 allow the inference: During the childhood period between ages 3 years and 5 years, average height in the Lunda rural population is more than 10 cm below that of the United States black population. 3. The means in Table I for Amerind groups are dispersed at each age across a 13 cm range. At age 3 years, means are 81.1 cm (Mayan), 85.1 cm (Quechua), 89.8 cm (Surinam Amerind), 91.5 cm (Canadian Amerind), 92.6 cm (Blackfeet), and 94.9 cm (Assiniboine and Gros Ventres). Corresponding means at age 5 years, beginning with the Quechua tribe, are 95.4, 101.8, 104.0, 108.8 cm, and 108.9 cm. Since most of these Amerind populations are represented by small samples, the variation of 13 cm among sample means may be as much as one-third larger than the greatest difference between the population means. 4. At age 3 years, means are near 84 cm for Ladino rural children of Guatemala; near 90 cm for Chuvash children of Chuvashia, Eskimo children of southwest Alaska, and Industani children of Surinam; and near 94 cm for Kirghiz urban children of Kirghizia. At age 5 years, means approximate 98 cm for Shi rural children of Zaire; 103 cm for Hutu rural children of Rwanda and Indonesian
Standing Height cf Young Children
11
children of Surinam; and 107 cm for Creole children of Surinam and Kirghiz urban children. For each of these groups the number of children measured exceeds 200.
111. National and Intranational Group Comparisons A.
GROUP DESCRIPTIONS
Presmted in Table I1 are statistics for standing height drawn from investigations on samples of contemporary young children representative of 14 nations and 14 geographical sections of countries. The term “intranational group” is used to denote those members of a nation living in a particular province, prefecture, state, department, county, or other geographical section of the country that has both urban and rural residents. The source and composition of the groups named in successive rows of Table I1 are as follows: Tug 11-1. The means in 11- 1 were derived from measures of standing height collected during 1962-1963 on a sample of Pakistani children considered to represent “all geographic and economic sections” of East Pakistan; about 30% of the subjects were urban residents and 70% lived in rural areas (Rosenberg & Reiner, 1966). Malnutrition was prevalent; the children’s diets were appraised by an ICNND team as commonly deficient in calories, protein, vitamin A , riboflavin, and iron. Tag 11-2. The means in 11-2 were secured from measures taken in 1962 at locations in several regions of Hashemite Jordan (Berry, 1963a). An ICNND nutrition team found that among Jordanian children there was considerable calorie-protein malnutrition, and insufficient intake of vitamin A and riboflavin. Tag 11-3. The statistics in 11-3 pertain to children of the Federation of Malaya; data were gathered in 1962 at representative geographic locations, urban and rural, and from all socioeconomic strata of the Malayan peninsula and the island of Panang (Fisk, 1964~).Diet was evaluated by an ICNND team as adequate in niacin, ascorbic acid, and vitamin D, but commonly inadequate in calcium, riboflavin, and thiamine. Population composition for the Federation of Malaya in 1960 approximated: Malays, 50%, Chinese, 40%, and Indians, 10%. Tag 11-4. 11-4 gives sample sizes and means obtained from a broad sampling of children made during 1965 in the savannah, plateau, rain forest, and coastal regions of the Republic of Nigeria (Darby & Edozien, 1967). Diet was appraised as “severely deficient” in riboflavin. Tag ZI-5. The means in 11-5, based on records amassed in 1965, were considered to represent the Paraguayan child population except for “the Mennonites at
Howard V . Meredith
12
TABLE I1 Mean Standing Height (cm) for 28 National and lntranational Groups of Young Children Measured Largely Between 1960 and 1970 Age 3 years
Tag
Country (whole or portion)
Sample size
Age 5 years
Mean
Sample size
Mean
~
11- 1
11-2 11-3 11-4 11-5 11-6 11-7 11-8 11-9 11- 10 11-1I
11-12 11- I3 11-14
11- 15
11- I6 11- I7 11- I8 11- I9 11-20 11-2I 11-22 11-23 11-24 11-25 11-26 11-27 11-28
East Pakistan Jordan Malaya Nigeria Paraguay Venezuela Uruguay China Republic Romania Bulgaria United States Finland East Germany Netherlands
Bolivian regions Tanzanian region Philippines region Tunisian region Brazilian states Cambodian region Indian province Singapore region Japanese prefecture Italian provinces Italian department Belgian province United States region Australian state
National samples 25 I I40 20 I 72 28 1 I86 130 1,188 >3,900
-
-
729 485
94.8 94.9
-
-
1,252
97.2
lntranational samples I66 34 433 93 158 ca. 200 79 389
ca.
82.3 83.6 85.0 85.2 88.2 89.0 90.9 92.4 93.5
1,040 42 1
82.7 83.9 85.3 85.3 85.9" 88.4 89.7 91.1 93.9 94. I
-
-
580 1,114
94.5 95.9
-
-
200
97.1 97.8 105.3 102.4 102.0 106.0 105.0
164
42 299 253 145 2,862
ca.
ca.
-
-
1.923 754 420 3,697 1,624
107.2 109.0 108.5 110.0 111.3
220 56 452 92 166 200
98.4 99.7 97.5 100.7 98.6 100.9
-
-
100
103.1 104.0 107.0 108.4 108.5 109.5
6,014 1,410 588 625 659
-
-
=A mean of 86.3 cm at age 3 years was obtained from measures taken in 1970 on 146 African children living at villages in the Lower Shire area of southern Malawi (Burgess, Burgess & Wheeler, 1973).
Standing Heighr oj Young Children
13
Sommerfeld and Filadelfia, the Japanese at Pirapo, and the Indians in the Chaco” (Centurion, Miranda, & Watkin, 1967). Tug If-6. The means in 11-6 for this 1963 study of Venezuelan children were drawn in the areas of Los Andes, Lake Maracaibo, Central Zone, Los Llanos, Crinoco-Caroni, and Isle de Margarita (Fisk, 1964e). About 65% of the subjects were mestizo, 20% white, and 15% black or Amerind. Data gathered by an ICNND nutrition team showed that diet was adequate for vitamins A, C, and niacin, but moderately substandard for protein and calories. Approximately 40% of the subjects lived in rural areas and 60% were urban residents. Tug 11-7. 11-7 displays means reported as representative of Uruguayan children in 1962; measures were accumulated from six scattered locations between Colonia Lavalleja in the north and Montevideo in the south (Berry, 1963b). The subjects were largely of Spanish and Italian descent; about 10% were offspring from white-Amerind or white-black intermarriages. The ICNND nutritionists evaluated the diet as adequate in calories, protein, riboflavin, niacin, and iron, borderline in vitamins A, C, and thiamine, and frequently inadequate in iodine. Tug 11-8. The statistics in 11-8 were obtained from data amassed during 1970-1972 at “randomly selected nurseries and kindergartens” in “rural and urban areas of Taiwan and Penghu (Pescadores);” the most prevalent signs of nutritional deficiency indicated riboflavin and niacin insufficiencies (Chen, Chiang, Huang, & Chen, 1974). Tug If-9. The large sample of Romanian children characterized in 11-9 were measured in 1964 (Tinisescu, Chiriac, Stinciulescu, Domilescu, & Jelezneac, 1970). About 44% of the subjects lived at urban centers and 56% in rural communities. Tug If-10. During 1960-1961, measures on Bulgarian children age 5 years were amassed at Sofia and throughout the country at “towns and villages determined in a stochastic manner” (Bulgarian Academy of Sciences, 1965). Subgrouped by population density, 37% of the measures in 11-10 were taken in Sofia, 38% in other towns, and 25% in villages. Tug I f - 1 1 . Statistics from two studies of United States children were combined in 11- 11: At age 3 years, component means were 95.0 cm on 445 white and black children of all socioeconomic classes measured during 1968-1970 at urban and rural locations in 36 states and the District of Columbia (Owen & Lubin, 1973; Owen et ul., 1974), and 94.6 cm on 284 white and black children measured during 1971-1972 at 35 locations selected to yield samples “representative of the total. . . noninstitutionalized population” (Abraham et ul., 1975). Listed in the same order, component means and sample sizes at age 5 years were 108.7 cm, 443; and 109.5 cm, 31 1. The composite samples were about 78% white and 22% black.
14
Howard V . Meredirh
Tug 11-12. The means in 11-12 were considered to typify the child population of Finland in the early 1960s; data accumulation occurred between 1955 and 1969 at urban centers and in rural regions (Backstrom & Kantero, 1971). Tug 11-13. The large sample in 11-13, measured in 1967, was reported as representative of East German kindergarten children age 5 years (Oehmisch, 1970). Tug 11-14. Van Wieringen (1972) secured the statistics in 11-14 from data amassed during 1964-1966 in a large-scale Netherlands survey. The mean of 1 11.3 cm at age 5 years practically coincides with the mean of 1 11.4 cm obtained by Van der Kuyp (1967) on ‘70 white children, primarily of Dutch lineage, measured during 1964-1965 in Surinam. Tug 11-15. Two samples in 11-15 were pooled at each age, one drawn in 1962 from eight departments of southwest Bolivia, and the other in 1964-1967 from rural communities and small towns of west-central Bolivia. Both included children of Amerind (largely Quechua and Aymara), Spanish, and Amerind-Spanish ancestry. The west central sample sizes and means were 44 ana 80.9 cm at age 3 years and 64 and 97.9 cm at age 5 years (Omran, McEwen, & Zaki, 1967); these children lived at altitudes varying from .2 km to 4.1 km, their diet was fairly poor, and infections were common. Sample sizes and means from the southwestem study were 122 and 83.3 cm at age 3 years and 156 and 98.6 at age 5 years (Fisk, 1964b); an ICNND team evaluated the diet of these children as frequently deficient in calcium, protein, vitamin A, riboflavin, and iodine. Tug 11-16. The mean in 11-16 was computed from data collected during 1966-1967 on Bantu children of the Pare, Shambala, and Chagga tribes living at highland and lowland villages in the Kilimanjaro and Tanga zones of northeast Tanzania (Kreysler and Schlage, 1969). Tug 11-17. Records for the study in 11-17 were accumulated between 1958 and 1966 in connection with nutrition surveys in nine regions of the Philippine Islands considered representative of “Luzon and the Visayas” (Matawaran and Gervasio, 197 1; Matawaran, Gervasio and de Gala, 1966). Tug 11-18. The statistics in 11-18 pertain to children of “Arab, Negro, and Berger” ancestry living at villages around the Chott el Djerid, a large lake in southern Tunisia bordering the Sahara desert (Boutourline, Tesi, Kerr, Stare, Kallal, Turki, & Hemaidan, 1972). The primary dietary staple of these children was unfortified wheat, “animal protein was consumed in extremely small amounts. ’ ’ Tug 11-19, The means in 11- 19 were computed from data gathered during 1963 in six states of northeast Brazil; about 85% of the children were residents of urban communities and 15% lived in rural areas (Fisk, 1965). Although “physical manifestations of nutritional deficiencies were not highly prevalent,” dietary intakes were appraised as insufficient for calories, protein, and vitamin A, and
Standing Height of Young Children
15
marginal for riboflavin and thiamine. Respiratory infections, bleeding gums, and diarrhea were fairly common. Tug 11-20. Data for the study in 11-20 were gathered during 1964-1966 on offspring of Cambodian parents residing in Pnompenh and the surrounding region (Nouth-Savoeun, 1966). Tug 11-21. The mean in 11-2 1 was obtained on Indian children measured at child development clinics and nursery schools “scattered over Agra province,” Uttar Pradesh; subjects had neither “a history of illness likely to retard growth,” nor “any serious abnormality detected on examination” (Prasad, Kumar, & Dayal, 197 1). Tug 11-22. These children in 11-22 were drawn from the south-central part of Singapore Island (Wong, Tye, & Quek, 1972). The ethnic composition of the sampling was about 68% Chinese, 16% Malayan, and 11% Indian; the socioeconomic grouping of the children’s fathers approximated 12% professional and managerial, 36% clerical and skilled, and 52% semiskilled and unskilled. Tug 11-23. In 1963, the large sample of Japanese children in 11-23 was measured in ‘‘municipal, coastal, agricultural, mountainous, and insular” areas of Kagawa prefecture (Kambara, 1969, personal communication 1973). Kambara reported that the national mean for Japanese kindergarten children measured in 1963 was 105.0 cm at age 5 years. Tag 11-24. The aggregate sample sizes and weighted means in 11-24 were derived from samples of Italian children studied between 1960 and 1968 in seven northern and central provinces. Component sample sizes, means, and sources at age 3 years were 147, 92.7 cm, Padua province (Bussadori, 1965); 350, 93.4 cm, Grosseto province (Terrosi, 1968); about 100, 93.9 cm, Pisa province (Vizzoni & Baldini, 1964); about 85, 94.4 cm, Trento province (Marzot, Colombini, & Vedovello, 1966); about 185, 94.6 cm, Teramo province (ZauliNaldi, 1963); 14, 94.6 cm, Fruili province (DeLuca, Bearzotti, & Cozzi, 1965); and 159, 95.0 cm, Aquila province (Vesi & Cantalini, 1972). From the same sources, sample sizes and means at age 5 years were 378 and 105.5 cm (Padua); 453 and 106.0cm (Grosseto); about 85 and 106.2 cm (Trento); 149 and 108.5 cm (Aquila); about 185 and 108.9 cm (Teramo); about 100 and 109.4 cm (Pisa); 67 and 11 1.4 cm (Fruili). Tug 11-25. Tonelli (1963) reported the statistics in 11-25 on children living in the Italian department of Emilia, a department situated about midway between the center of the Italian mainland and its northern boundary. Tug 11-26. Data for the study in 11-26 were collected during 1970-1971 on physically normal, healthy children measured at 20 centers of preventive medicine in the province of Liege, eastern Belgium (Geubelle, Lambrechts, Sabatier, & Baltia, 1974).
16
Howard V . Meredith
Tug 11-27. The means in 11-27 were obtained from records accumulated during 1968-1970 in 12 states: Illinois, Indiana, Iowa, Kansas, Michigan, Minnesota, Missouri, Nebraska, North Dakota, Ohio, South Dakota, and Wisconsin (Fryer, Lamkin, Vivian, Eppright. & Fox, 1972). The composite samples were considered “representative” of the “heterogeneous population” residing in the north central region of the United States. Tug 11-28. The measures analyzed in 11-28 were amassed during 1970-1971 at child health centers in urban and rural areas of Tasmania (Coy, Lewis, Mair, Longmore, & Ratkowsky, 1973). Occupation of the children’s fathers was about 15% professional and managerial; 22% skilled, nonmanual; 38% skilled, manual; and 25% semiskilled and unskilled. B . GROUP COMPARISONS
Examples of comparative findings that can be deduced from Table 11, separately and in conjunction with Table I, are as follows: 1. In the period between 1960 and 1970, averages for human standing height at age 3 years approximated 82, 85, 88, 93, 95, and 97 cm, respectively, on children of East Pakistan, Malaya, Paraguay, Romania, Finland, and the Netherlands. On using one-tailed statistical procedures to determine, a t p = .01, fiducia1 limits for population means, the ensuing generalization appears tenable: During the l%Os, average standing height at age 3 years was less for children of East Pakistan than for their age peers of Romania by 10 cm or more, and of the Netherlands by 13 cm or more. 2 . At age 5 years, averages near 97, 102, 105, 108, and 11 1 cm, in this order, were obtained for children of Jordan, Venezuela, the Republic of China, Finland, and the Netherlands. Averages near 98, 104, 107, and 110 cm characterized Bolivian children residing in southwest and west-central Bolivia, Japanese children inhabiting Kagawa province, Bulgarian children, and children of East Germany. In the early 1960s the typical Jordanian child age 5 years was no taller than the typical Dutch child at age 3 years. 3. Tables I and I1 carry averages for standing height at age 3 years near 85 cm on Shi, Malayan, and Filipino groups (1-9, 11-3, 11-17); near 88 cm on Antilles black, Paraguyan, and Cambodian groups (1-15, 11-5, 11-20); near 91 cm on Surinam Creole and Singapore groups (1-29, 11-22); and near 94 cm on Kirghiz and Italian groups (1-38, 11-24, 11-25). Similar averages at age 5 years are tabled for Ladino, Shi, and Filipino groups (1-6, 1-9, 11-17); Antilles black, Surinam Indonesian, Chuvash, Paraguayan, and Venezuelan groups (I- 15, I- 17, 1-22, 11-5, 11-6); and Surinam Creole, Kirghiz, Bulgarian, and Italian groups (1-29, 1-38, 11-10, 11-24). Sample size for each of the groups referred to in this paragraph and in the two preceding paragraphs was 200 or more.
17
Standing Height cf Young Children
IV. Rural and Urban Groups Compared A.
GROUP DESCRIPTIONS
Averages for standing height on contemporary groups of children living in rural areas and urban communities are assembled in Table 111. The upper part of the table pertains to children age 3 years, the lower part to children age 5 years, and the column at the extreme right to differences between paired urban and rural groups. Information on the content in successive rows of Table I11 is provided below.
TABLE 111 Mean Standing Height (cin) for Rural and Urban Groups of Young Children Measured Mainly Between 1960 and 1970 Rural
Tag
Group
111-1 111-2 111-3 111-4 111-5 111-6 111-7 111-9 111-10
Indian Nigerian South African Bantu Polish Czechoslovak Romanian Chuvash Russian Surinam Hindustani Surinam Creole
111-1 I 111- 12 111- I3 111-14 111-15 111-16 111- I7 111- I8 111-19 111-20
Nigerian Chuvash Bulgarian Polish Czechoslovak Russian South African Bantu Surinam Hindustani Surinam Creole Surinam Indonesian
Sample size Age
111-8
ca.
1,529 315 151
365 61 >2,200 201 ca. 440 367 300
Urban
Mean
Sample size
Mean
Difference"
3 years 19.5 87.7 89.3 92.7 94.6 92.4 88.8 93.9 89.6 91.9
324 282 265 ca. 785 1,032 > 1,700 2 I6 ca. 655 120 538
86.4 92.5 91.8 95.2 97.0 94.7 90.9 93.9 89.0 90.9
6.9 4.8 2.5 2.5 2.4 2.3 2. I .0 -.6 -1.0
49 I 211
105.1 104.5 107.9 108.4 111.0 107.8 104.3 104.5 106.6 102.0
4.9 3.7 2.6 2.4 2.2 1.3 .8 .3 .2 - .7
Age 5 years
"Urban mean minus rural mean
ca.
ca.
275 223 479 423 124 440 128 1,516 599 463
100.2 100.8 105.3 106.0 108.8 106.5 103.5 104.2 106.4 102.7
1.444
ca. ca. ca.
585 765 1,920 208 322 940 I02
18
Howard V . Meredith
Tug 111-1. The statistics in 111- 1 on Indian rural children were obtained from measures taken at villages within a radius of 50 km beyond Hyderabad; 40% of the children showed nutritional deficiency signs for vitamin A, vitamin B complex, or calorie-protein intake (Madhavan, Susheela, & Swaminathan, 1967; Rao, Singh, & Swaminathan, 1969; Swaminathan, Jyothi, Singh, Madhavan, & Gopalan, 1964). The urban values were secured using data collected in Bombay on Indian children of all socioeconomic strata; the sample was heavily weighted with children from the lower and lower middle classes (Shiddhaye, Shah, & Udani, 1972; Udani, 1963). An alternative rural-urban analysis was made; this yielded a difference between means of 7.4 cm. A rural mean of 80.1 cm resulted from pooling the study at villages around Hyderabad with studies at villages in the Lubhiana district of Punjab (Neumann, Shanker, & Uberoi, 1969) and villages in the vicinity of Poona (Phadke, Deodhar, & Kulkarni, 1971). An urban mean of 87.5 cm was obtained on combining the Bombay sample with samples studied in Delhi (Banik, Krishna, Mane, Raj, & Tasker, 1970c), Burla (Mohanta, Pande, & Praharaj, 1972), Bhopal and Gwalior (Sharma, 1970), and Kerala (Gokulanathan & Verghese, 1969). Socioeconomically, these samples were from all levels (Delhi), the lower and middle levels (Burla), the middle classes (Bhopal and Gwalior), and the middle and upper classes (Kerala). Composite sample sizes were 2100 and 1050 for rural and urban children, respectively. Tug 111-2. In 111-2, the rural mean was derived from data accumulated at villages in northern and western Nigeria (1-7, 1-24), and the urban mean from data accumulated at Ibadan (1-24) and at Lagos on Ibo and Yoruba children of all socioeconomic classes measured during 1963-1965 (Rea, 1971). Tug 111-3. Between 1968 arid 1970, records for the analyses in 111-3 were collected on rural children of northeastern and eastern Transvaal, and on urban children of Johannesburg (Richardson, 1973, personal communication 1974). Tug 111-4. Sample sizes, means, and sources used to obtain the values in 111-4 for Polish rural children were 98, 92.0 cm, Nowy Targ district (Migsowicz & P y h k , 1967); 172, 92.8 cm, Lublin district (Chrzastek-Spruch, personal communication 1974); 33, 92.5 cm, Ostroleka and Suwalki districts (Wolanski & PyBuk, 1973); and 62, 93.5 cm, Puck district (PyEuk & Wolanski, 1968). For urban children, component materials were 189, 94.4 cm, Lublin (ChrzastekSpruch & Szajner-Milart, 1973); and about 600, 95.4 cm, Warsaw (Kurniewicz-Witczakowa, Migsowicz, Mazurczak, & Eska, 1973; Wolanski, 1964). Tug 111-5. The rural values in 111-5 were computed from measures taken in 1965 on children living in a rural region near Olomouc, Czechoslovakia (Holibkova & Holibka, 1968). Sample means used in deriving the composite urban mean were 96.5 cm on 469 children measured at Brno during 1964-1972 (Gerylovova & Bouchalova, 1974); 97.4 cm on 434 children measured at Prague during 1961-1964 (Kubat, Novakova, Koufim, & Syrovatka, 1969); and 97.6
Standing Height of Young Children
19
cm on 129 children measured at Bratislava during 1961-1967 (BakiEova & SevEikova, 1973). Tugs 111-6 and 111-7. See 11-9 and 1-22. Tug 111-8. Samples of Russian children for 111-8 were combined from two studies. Component sample sizes and means were 242 and 93.8 cm for data collected in 1966 at villages of the Belgorod-Dnestrov and Tatarbunarsk districts of the Odessa region (Kravchenko, 1968) and about 200 and 94.0 cm for data gathered in 1970 at villages in the Michurinsky and Sampursky areas of Tambov province (Arkhipova, 1972). Four urban samples studied between 1960 and 1963 were pooled: their sample sizes, means, and sources were about 170, 93.8 cm, Ivan-Frankovsk (Kutsenko, 1965); 261,93.6 cm, Rostov-on-Don; 161,94.0 cm, Kursk; and 65, 95.5 cm, Ryazan (Goldfield et al., 1965). Tugs 111-9 through 111-13. See 1-19, 1-29, 111-2, 1-22, 11-10. Tug 111-14. Rural particulars in 111- 14 were 87 and 106.5 cm, Cracow county (Gastol, 1966); 58 and 104.4 cm, Suwalki and Ostroleka districts; 182 and 105.6 cm, Lublin district; 43 and 106.6 cm, Nowy Targ district; and 54 and 107.6 cm, Puck district (see 111-4). Urban subgroup sample sizes, means, and places were 308, 107.9 cm, Lublin (Chrzastek-Spruch & Szajner-Milart, 1973); and about 280, 108.9 crn, Warsaw (Kumiewicz-Witczakowa, Migsowicz, & Mazurczak, 1974). Tug 111-15. See 111-5. Urban subgroup sample sizes and means in 111-15 were 279 and 110.7 cm (Prague); about 100 and 110.7 cm (Bratislava); and 390, 11.3 cm (Brno). Tug 111-16. Refer to 111-8. The component statistics at age 5 years in 111-16 were 243 and 106.5 cm, Odessa region; about 200 and 106.6 cm, Tambov region; 265 and 107.1 cm, Ryazan; 599 and 107.5 cm, Kursk; about 370 and 107.7 cm, Ore1 (Belousov, Kardashenko, Kondakova-Varlamova, Prokhorova, & Sgromskaia, 1968); and 689 and 108.4 cm, Donetsk (Goldfeld et ul., 1965; Pokatilo, 1974). Tugs 111-17 through 111-20. See 111-3, 1-19, 1-29, and 1-17. B. GROUP COMPARISONS
Inspection and evaluation of Table 111, togelher with reference to other pertinent findings, reveals: 1. Averages for standing height of young children residing in cities are neither consistently higher nor lower than those of age peers residing in rural areas. 2. The three Indian and Nigerian comparisons, appraised statistically at p = .01, support the inference that mean height for each urban population was greater than mean height for the corresponding rural population by more than 3.5 cm.
20
Howard V . Meredith
3. Values from the samples in 111-4 and 111-14, subjected to significance tests at p = .01, allow the generalization: During the period 1960-1970, population means for height at ages from 3 to 5 years for Polish urban children surpassed those for Polish rural age peers by amounts likely between 1.4 and 3.5 cm. Direction and magnitude of the rural-urban differences appear similar for Romanian and Bulgarian young children. 4. Rural-urban differences between sample means for standing height of Surinam Hindustani and Creole children do not allow rejection of the hypothesis that the rural and urban population means for these groups were alike. Moreover, earlier large-scale studies in England (Tuxford & Glegg, 191 1) and the United States (Woodbury, 1921) found “averages for children in rural areas” were slightly “above those for children i n urban areas.” Records for standing height at age 5 years were amassed in England during 1909-1910 on 44,200 children living in 17 rural regions and 38,600 children living at 44 urban centers; the rural mean was 1.3 cm higher than the urban mean. Data were collected in 1918 on offspring under age 6 years of parents born in the United States and residing in “Iowa and eastern North-Central states”; comparison of means for 45,000 rural and 23,700 urban children showed the rural children were taller by .6 cm.
V.
Rural Groups Compared with Urban Socioeconomic Groups
In the present section, averages for standing height of children living in rural areas are compared with averages on “urban privileged” children (Table IV) and “urban underprivileged” children (Table V). The category “urban privileged” encompasses samples of urban children drawn from high income families, elite residential neighborhoods, professional and managerial occupational groups, or private schools; the category ‘ ‘urban underprivileged” includes samples of urban children drawn from low income families, slum districts, unskilled occupational groups, or the indigent social class. A.
RURAL GROUPS COMPARED WITH URBAN PRIVILEGED GROUPS
Materials complementing the contents of Table IV are as follows: Tag IF‘-I. “Rural” component sample sizes and means in IV- 1 were 1529 and 79.5 cm from data amassed at 37 villages of Andhra Pradesh in the region around Hyderabad (Rao ef al., 1969) and, from measures taken at randomly selected villages in all directions around Poona, 556 and 81.8 cm (Phadke, personal communication 1973; Phadke et al., 1971); both samples were drawn largely from “poor homes” in which food, sanitation, and personal hygiene were “far from satisfactory.” For the “urban privileged,” component sample sizes and
21
Standing Height of Young Children
TABLE IV Mean Standing Height (cm) of Rural and Urban Privileged Groups of Young Children Measured Mainly During 1960- I970 Rural
Tag
Group
1v-I IV-2 IV-3 1V-4 IV-5 1V-6 1V-7
Indian Thai Nigerian Turkish Malayan South African Bantu Russian
IV-8 IV-9 1v-I0 1v-1I IV-12 IV-13 1V-14 1V-15 1V-16
Indian Turkish Nigerian Thai Spanish Ethiopian Jamaican white South African Bantu Russian
Sample size
ca. ca. ca.
ca. ca. ca. ca.
Urban privileged
Mean
Age 3 years 2,085 80.1 185 83.0 31.5 87.7 21 86.9 4.5 83.7 151 89.3 177 93.2 Age 5 years 300 95.7 19 97.7 275 101.2 165 96.4 12,187 103.9 SO 101.3 171 106.4 128 103.5 192 108.2
Sample size
Mean
Differencen
ca. 295 156 133 ca. 70 ca. 140 178 92
94.9 93.2 96.4 93.3 88.8 93.3 96.8
14.8 10.2 8.7 6.4 5. I 4.0 3.6
ca. 280 ca. 70 196 243
107. I 107.8 110.2 104.6 110.9 104.1 109.1 105.8 109.5
11.4 10.1 9.0 8.2 7.0 2.8 2.7 2.3 1.3
100
81 76 134 122
“Urban privileged mean minus rural mean.
means were about 34 and 94.0 cm on children of “the best socioeconomic group” in Bombay (Udani, 1963); 62 and 95.0 cm on “well-privileged’’ children of wealthy families in Delhi (Banik, Nayar, Krishna, & Raj, 1972); and, on healthy children from upper and upper-middle income families of Poona, about 200 and 95.0 cm (Limaye, Chouhan, Lakhani, & Phadke, 1974). Tug W - 2 . The rural values in IV-2 were obtained by combining sample sizes and means of 95 and 8 1.5 cm on children measured in 1960 at villages scattered throughout Thailand (Berry, 1962a) and, on children measured some years later at two villages in northeast Thailand, about 90 and 84.5 cm (Migasena, Thumham, Pongpaew, Hongthong, & Harinasuta, 1974). The adjacent sample sizes and means in IV-2 were secured from records accumulated during 1967-197 1 on well-nourished children from “middle and professional class homes” in Bangkok (Khanjanasthiti, Supachaturas, Mekanandha, Srimusikapodh, Choopanya, & Leesuwan, 1973).
22
Howard V . Meredith
Tug ZV-3. For sources of the rural statistics, see 1-7 and 1-24. Sample sizes and means in IV-3 for the “urban privileged” samples were 19 and 95.5 cm on children of “upper class” families in Lagos (111-2) and, on children of “wellto-do” families in Ibadan, 114 and 96.6 cm (1-24). Tug ZV-4. Values in the rural part of IV-4 were obtained on children measured at a village 120 km from Istanbul (Neyzi, 1967) and those in the urban privileged part on children of wealthy families residing in the Nisantasi area of Istanbul (Neyzi & Gurson, 1966). Tug ZV-5. These paired means in IV-5 for “the Malay ethnic group” were secured on village children measured in 1968 at Ulu Trengganu, a district about 480 km from Kuala Lumpur, and on healthy children of above average socioeconomic status-a few of the latter were “urban elite” measured in 1969 at Kuala Lumpur, the bulk were measured in !968 at a nearby military base (Dugdale, MacKay, Lim, & Notaney, 1972; McKay, Lim, Notaney, & Dugdale, 1971). Tug ZV-6. Refer to 111-3. The “privileged” children in IV-6 attended nursery schools in Soweto, Johannesburg; they ate 10 meals each week at the schools. Tug ZV-7. The statistics on rural children in IV-7 were computed from data gathered during 1970-1971 in the Udor region of the Komi Autonomous Soviet Socialist Republic (Martirosian, 1973). From two tripartite analyses of 3 13 measures taken in 1971 at Petropavlovsk, Nekisheva (1974) reported subgroup means of 96.5 cm on 71 children of high income families, and 96.8 cm on 92 children reared under superior living conditions. Tug ZV-8. Items 3 and 4 in IV-8 were derived from measures made between 1960 and 1965 at “villages in all directions around Poona”; more than 80% of the children lived in “poor homes” (Phadke & Kulkarni, 1971). Sources for the “urban privileged” values were the same as in IV-1; their sample sizes arid means at age 5 years were 46 and 1C6.7 cm (Delhi); about 200 and 107.1 cm (Poona); about 34 and 107.1 cm (Bombay). Tug ZV-9. Same sources as IV-4. Tug ZV-10. Sources were the same as IV-3; sample sizes and means for urban privileged children in IV-10 werc 11 and 109.7 cm (Lagos); 185 and 110.2 cm (Ibadan). Tug ZV-I I. Same sources as IV-2; sample sizes and means for rural children in IV-11 were 78 and 95.0 cm (Berry, 1962a); about 90 and 97.7 cm (Migasena et ul., 1974). Tug ZV-12. The rural values in IV-12 were secured from records accumulated during 1963-1968 at villages in 48 Spanish provinces (Palacios & Vivanco, 1965; Palacios-Mateos, Garcia-Almansa, Vivanco, Fernandez, Garcia-Robles, & Moreno-Esteban, 1972), and the urban privileged values from measures taken in 1968 on “healthy and well-nourished” girls attending two schools in Madrid (Garcia-Almansa, Fernandez-Fernandez, & Palacios-Mateos, 1969). To obtain an
Standing Height of Young Children
23
estimated mean for Madrid children of both sexes, the reported mean on girls was raised .5 cm. Tug IV-13. Eksmyr (1971) reported findings in IV-13 from data collected during 1965-1967 at Ijaji, a village in a typical agricultural highland area of Ethiopia, and at two private schools in Addis Ababa. Tug 1V-14. The rural statistics in IV- 14 were obtained from measures gathered during 1965-1966 in an agricultural region surrounding the village of Lawrence Tavern, about 24 km from Kingston (Desai. Miall, & Standard, 1969; Standard, Desai, & Miall, 1969). The corresponding urban privileged values were computed from records collected in 1963 at private schools “in the wealthier suburbs of Kingston” (Ashcroft & Lovell, 1964). Tug IV-15. See IV-6. Tug 1V-16. Refer to IV-7. Statistics in 1V-16 were taken from a sample of 554 children age 5 years, subgroup means were 109.5 cm for 122 subjects classified as offspring of high income families, and 109.4 cm for 186 subjects judged to be growing under superior environmental conditions. Table IV yields the following comparative findings for the period 1960-1970. 1. Children living in rural areas were shorter i n average standing height than ethnically comparable urban children of the upper and upper-middle socioeconomic classes. 2. On the average, Indian young children residing in the rural areas sampled were shorter than their age peers of the urban privileged groups studied by more than 10 cm. 3. Nigerian and Thai young chi!dren of the upper classes were taller, on the average, than their respective age peers inhabiting rural villages by at least 7 cm. 4. Thai and South African Bantu young children of urban privileged groups were no taller than Russian rural children. Compare IV-2 and IV-8 with 111-8 and IV-7; also compare IV-11 and IV- 15 with 111-16 and IV-16. B.
RURAL GROUPS COMPARED WITH URBAN UNDERPRIVILEGED GROUPS
Proceeding to Table V, the first requisite is itemization of the complementary information basic to understanding its content. Since the rural groups in Table V were discussed in explaining Table IV, only the “urban underprivileged” samples require specification. Tugs V-I and V - 5 . The composite mean of 83.7 cm at age 3 years was derived for V-1 from sample sizes and means of about 150 and 82.6 cm for children living in slum areas of Bombay (Udani, 1963); 563 and 83.4 cm for children of the lower classes measured in 1966 at Vellore (Pereira, 1971); and 206 and 85.4 cm for children of Delhi from families in the unskilled occupational category (Banik, Krishna, Mane, & Raj, 1970a). Component values used in
24
Howard V. Meredith
TABLE V Mean Standing Height (cm) of Rural and Urban Underprivileged Groups of Young Children Measured Largely Between 1960 and 1970 Urban underprivileged
Rural
Tag
Group
v- I v-2 V-3 v-4
Indian Russian Nigerian Turkish
v-5 V-6 v-1 V-8
Indian Nigerian Russian Turkish
Sample size
Mean
Sample size
Mean
Difference'
Age 3 years
2,085 I17 ca.
315
21
80.1
93.2 87.1 86.9
ca. 915 77 I22 I06
83.1 95. I
89.0 84.7
3.6 I .9 I .3 -2.2
ca. 200 265 I43 I22
98.6 101.8 107.8 91.2
2.9 .6 -. 4 -.5
Age 5 years
ca. ca.
300 215 192 19
95.7 101.2 108.2 97.7
"Urban underprivileged mean minus rural mean
securing the weighted mean at age 5 years were 52 and 98.0 cm (Delhi); about 150 and 98.8 cm (Bombay). Tags V-2 and V - 7 . Refer to IV-7. From the two analyses cited earlier on 313 records at age 3 years, subgroup sample sizes and means were 95.1 cm for 77 children reared under poor living conditions, and 96.3 cm for 59 children of low income families. Corresponding values from the 554 measures at age 5 years were 107.8 cm for 143 children living under poor environmental conditions, and 107.1 cm for 1 1 1 children of low income families. Tags V-3 and V-6. Refer to 111-2 and 1-24. At age 3 years, sample sizes and means for subgroups were 33 and 86.6 cm for Lagos children of the lower classes and 89 and 89.9 cm for children inhabiting the poorest section of Ibadan. Listed in the same order, component values at age 5 years were 29, 100.0 cm; and 236, 102.9 cm. Tags V-4 and V - 8 . The statistics in V-4 and V-8 for urban underprivileged children were obtained from measures on progeny of unskilled factory workers living in the Murat district of Istanbul (Neyzi, Tanman, & Saner, 1965). Table V shows that during the 1960s: 1. Average standing height was less for Indian young children living in rural regions around Hyderabad and Poona than for Indian young children of low socioeconomic status living at Bombay and Delhi.
Standing Height cd Young Children
25
2. Nigerian young children of low socioeconomic status residing at Ibadan and Lagos were no shorter than their rural age peers residing in the Pankshin area of northern Nigeria and the village of Imesi in western Nigeria.
VI. Intracity and Intercity Comparisons The present section deals with two types of intracity variables, ethnic and socioeconomic, and with variations between city populations in several parts of the world. A.
INTRACITY ETHNIC GROUPS COMPARED
Table VI pertains to seven cities in each of which, during the 1960s, at least two ethnic groups of young children were studied. Particulars on the groups paired in this table are as follows. Tugs VZ-l and VI-2. Data for the analyses in VI-I and VI-2 were collected during 1968-1970. The source of the South African Bantu statistics was given in 111-3; the companion values were obtained by Richardson ( 1 973) from measures on white nursery school children residing “on the East Rand, between 10 and 30 km east of Johannesburg,” including children from “low, middle, and upper” socioeconomic levels. Tags VI-3 through Vl-6. The means in VI-3 through VI-6, all computed from records accumulated between 1961 and 1963, were reported by Goldfeld et al. (1965). Refer to 1-26, 1-33, and 1-22, Tug VI-7. The measures on both of these groups in VI-7 were gathered during 1966-1967 at preschools in Honolulu. Tag 1-31 cited the reference for the Hawaiian Japanese values. The “Hawaiian” sample was described socioeconomically as “from low and middle income families,” and ethnically as about 43% part-Hawaiian, 19% Japanese, 6% white, and 32% Chinese, Filipino, Korean, Puerto Rican, Samoan, or non-Hawaiian mixtures (Smith & Brown, 1970a). Tags Vl-8 and Vl-9. Both VI-8 and VI-9 were based on data amassed between 1962 and 1972 on offspring of parents residing in the San Francisco East Bay area and participating in the Kaiser Foundation Health Plan. Neither sample included children toward the extremes of the socioeconomic continuum, that is, there were no subjects from affluent homes or from homes in the unskilled and indigent categories. The white sample was limited to single-born children (Wingerd, personal communication 1974; Wingerd & Schoen, 1974), and the other sample was composed of children weighing about 2.5 kg at birth, 60% white and 40% black (Beck & van der Berg, 1975).
26
Howard V . Meredith
TABLE V1 Mean Standing Height (cm) on Paired Ethnic Groups of Young Children Living in Specified Cities Dunng 1960-1970
Tag
Age (years)
Mean
Sample size
Johannesburg: Bantu, South African white 91.8 69 265 104.3 133 208
v1- 1 VI-2
5
VI-3
5
V1-4
5
219
V1-5 V1-6
3 5
Cherboksary: Chuvash, Russian 90.9 208 2 I6 104.5 259 211
V1-7
3
VI-8 V1-9
3 5
VI-I0
3
Sample size
<
_I
Mean
110.6
4.6 6.3
Baku: Azerbaijani, Russian 323 105.2 282
107.4
2.2
Kazun: Tatar, Russian 105.0 286
107.0
2.0
92.4 105.6
i .5 1.1
Honolulu: Japanese, Hawaiian 60 91 .8 I38
93.0
1.2
San Francisco: white, black and white 94.5 235 3,057 3,707 109.2 263
94.9 109.8
.6
106.7
.o
404
Frunze: Kirghiz, Russian 106.7 267
96.4
Differencea
.4
“The mean in column 6 minus the mean in column 4.
Tug 1/1-10. The pair of means in VI-10 was obtained from measures taken during 1961-1963. Refer to 1-39 for particulars regarding the Kirghiz statistics. The Russian statistics were reported by Goldfeld et ul. (1965). The intracity ethnic groups juxtaposed in Table VI lead to the following findings: 1 . Of the differences in average standing height displayed, the largest are those between Johannesburg Bantu and white children. One-tailed significance tests at p = .01 allow the inference: In the late 1960s, the Johannesburg white population was taller than its Bantu population by at least 2.5 cm at age 3 years, and 4.5 cm at age 5 years. 2 . In the early 1960s, average height of Russian children age 5 years living at Baku was greater, at 99:1 probability, than that of the Azerbaijani age peers
Standing Height of Young Children
27
residing in this Asian city by an amount likely between .9 and 3.5 cm. There was a similar relation between Russian and Tatar children living at Kazan. 3. Samples of young children studied in the 1960s at Cherboksary, Honolulu, and San Francisco do not warrant acceptance of the hypothesis that in any one of these towns the ethnic groups compared differed in average standing height. Possibly larger samples would have indicated dependable differences in one or more instances, particularly in average height of Russian and Chuvash children residing at Cherboksary. B.
INTRACITY SOCIOECONOMIC GROUPS COMPARED
Intracity statistics on samples of young children drawn to represent one or more socioeconomic categories are presented in Tables VII and VIII. Table VII assembles means for standing height that allow comparisons among lower, middle, and upper socioeconomic groups i n four cities, and comparisons between lower and upper socioeconomic groups in eight cities. Assembled in Table VIII are means on groups of children studied in 19 cities, the means for a specific city relating to one of five segments of the socioeconomic continuum. Notations on the sources used in constructing these tables are as follows: Tags Vll-I and Vll-2. The values for Bombay children of low socioeconomic status in VII-1 and VII-2 were obtained by pooling samples studied in the early 1960s (Udani, 1963), and late 1960s (Shiddhaye et al., 1972). The Udani study supplied the values for Bombay children of middle class and well-to-do families. Tags Vll-3 and Vll-4. Refer to IV-4 and V-4. Tags VII-5 and Vll-6. See 111-2. Tags Vll-7 and Vll-8. The statistics in VII-7 and VII-8 were computed from measures taken during 1964-1965 (Barja, LeFuente, Ballester, Monckeberg, & Donoso, 1965). Tags Vll-9 and Vll-10. Analyses in VII-9 and VII-10 for all three socioeconomic groups were available from one study (Banik et al., 1970a), analyses for middle class children from another (Ghai & Sandhu, 1968), and analyses for “well privileged” children from a third (Banik et al., 1972). It follows that the Delhi values in Table VII for middle class children are aggregate sample sizes and weighted means derived by combining two samples, as are the values for children of the upper classes. Tags VII-11 and Vll-12. The measures used in obtaining the means in VII-11 and VII-12 were collected during 1965-1968 on children belonging to the “lowest” and “highest” socioeconomic classes of Bogod (Luna-Jaspe, Ariza, Rueda-Williamson, Mora, & Pardo, 1970 Rueda-Williamson, Luna-Jaspe, Ariza, Pardo & Mora, 1969). Tags VII-13 and Vll-14. Refer to 1-24.
Howard V . Meredith
28
TABLE V11 Mean Standing Height (cm) of Lower, Middle, and Upper Socioeconomic Groups of Young Children Measured Between 1960 and 1970 in Seven Cities ~
Lower
Middle
Age (years)
Sample size
VII-I Vll-2
3 5
ca. 235 ca. 200
83.0 99.0
VII-3 Vll-4
3 5
106
I22
84.7 97.2
Vll-5 VII-6
3 5
33 29
86.6 100.0
Lagos, Nigeria 27 89.2 30 102.0
Vll-7 Vll-8
3
5
ca. 120 ca. 120
85.6 99.8
Santiago, Chile ca. 410 90.9 ca. 410 104.5
Vll-9 VII- I0
3 5
206 52
85.4 98.0
Delhi, India 328 87.3 110 101.6
VII- 1 I VII-12
3 5
66 66
v11- 13 VI1- 14
3 5
89 236
89.9 102.0
VII- 15 VII- 16
3 5
45 30
89.8 103.2
Tag
Mean
Sample size
Mean
Bombav. Indiu ca. 90 91.2 ca. 90 107.7
Upper Sample size
Mean
Differencea
ca. ca.
34 34
94.0 109.7
11.0 10.7
ca. ca.
70 70
93.3 107.8
8.6 10.6
19 II
95.5 109.7
8.9 9.7
35 35
94.5 109.0
8.9 9.2
81 55
94.2 106.7
8.8 8.7
62 64
94.4 107.5
7.0 8.0
114 I85
96.6 110.2
6.7 8.2
87 85
92.3 105.7
2.5 2.5
Istanbul, Turkey
Bogota, Colombia 87.4 99.5
ca. ca.
Ibadan, Nigeria
Baghdad, Iraq
‘Mean for upper socioeconomic subgroup minus mean for lower socioeconomic subgroup.
Standing Height of Young Children
29
TABLE VIII Mean Standing Height (cm) of Contemporary Groups of Young Children Each Representing an lntracity Socioeconomic Subgroup ~
Age 3 years
Age 5 years
Sample size
Mean
Sample size
VIII- 1 VIII-2 VIll-3 VIII-4 VIII-5
Lower classes Indian, Vellore 563 Peruvian, Lima 39 Dominican, Santo Doming0 ca. 90 United States black, New Orleans 1 I8 United States black, Washington, D.C. 145
83.4 86. I 91.6 93.7 93.9
-
-
50 ca. 90 186 I29
99.3 105.9 107.9 108.6
VIII-6 VIII-7 VIII-8
Indian, three towns Chinese, Hong Kong Chilean, several towns
Lower and middle classes 90 208 80
83.2 90.3 90.9
98 I26 694
97.5 104.7 105.0
Vlll-9 VIII- I0 VI1I-l I
Chinese, Tainan French, Paris Ugandan, Kampala
90
91.8
-
-
91 275 379
104. I 107.0 107.6
v111- 12 VIII-13 V111- 14 VIII- 15 V111- 16 VII1- 17
Thai, Bangkok Armenian, Beirut Indian, Poona Chilean, Santiago Indian, Kerala Sara, Fort Archambault
243 I79 ca. 200 141 ca. 60 63
104.6 108.6 107.1 107.6 109.0 109.0
V111- 18 VIII-19
Ethiopian, Addis Ababa Chinese, Kingston
104.1 105.9
Tag
Ethnic group and city
Mean
Middle classes
Middle and upper classes 156 125 ca. 200
-
93.2 94.5 95.0
-
-
ca. 60
95.2
-
-
Upper classes
-
-
81
-
-
21
Tags VZI-15 and V11-16. These children were born in Baghdad; they were “mainly of Arab ancestry, with variable Kurdish, Turkish, and Persian contributions;’’ one socioeconomic class resided in “slum areas” and the other in “fashionable residential areas” (Shakir & Zaini, 1974). Tag VZIZ-Z. The mean in VIII- 1 was computed from data gathered at Vellore in 1966 on children “belonging to the lower socioeconomic groups” (Pereira, 1971).
30
Howard V . Meredith
Tug Vlll-2. Records for the study in VIII-2 were accumulated during 19661970 on children from “extremely poor homes, primarily mestizo families living in the peripheral slums of Lima” (Blanca-Adrianzen, Baertl, & Graham, 1973). The children were “in apparent good health and had no history of severe malnutrition. ” Tug Vlll-3. Hernandez (1966) reported the values in VIII-3 on children “belonging to the underprivileged class” of “la zona urbana y periferica de Santo Domingo. ” Tug VIII-4. The means in VIII-4 were secured from measures made during 1963-1965 on children of indigent families residing in New Orleans (Cherry, 1968). Tug VM-5. During 1963-1965, the data analyzed in VIII-5 were collected on children of “low income families” living in the District of Columbia (Verghese, Scott, Teixeira, & Ferguson, 1969). Tug Vlll-6. The values in VIII-6 are aggregate sample sizes and weighted means derived from combining records on children of “middle and low socioeconomic strata” measured during 1967-1968 at Burla (Mohanta et al., 1972), and children of “lower-middle socioeconomic status” measured during 1967-1968 at Bhopal and Gwalior (Sharma, 1970). The Sharma subjects showed “no signs of malnutrition or vitamin deficiency.” Tug VIU-7. Low (1971) reported the statistics in VIII-7 using records amassed between 1963 and 1967 on children from families of Chinese lineage and low to middle socioeconomic status living “in the urban areas of Hong Kong Island.” Tug Vlll-8. In 1960, measures for the study in VIII-8 were taken at several cities in Chile (Berry, 1961); the samples included “all ethnic groups except the Araucanian Indians ,” and were considered ‘‘representative of the urban population in the middle and lower income brackets.” Tug Vlll-9. During 1963-1964 the measures analyzed in this row were taken at Tainan, Taiwan, on children of Chinese middle class families (Kimura & Tsai, 1967). Tug VIII-10. The mean in VIII-I0 was obtained from data accumulated between 1958 and 1964 on physically normal children residing in a middle class suburb of Paris (Sempe, Sempe, & Pedron, 1972). Tug Vlll-11. Rutishauser (1965) secured the mean in VIII- 11 from data collected during 1962-1965 on ‘‘healthy middle class Baganda children” attending nursery schools in Kampala. (Included in the Rutishauser report was a mean of 91.1 cm at age 3 years; this mean was obtained from measures taken during 1962-1965 on 114 Baganda rural children living in areas around the child health center at Namulonge, 26 krn from Kampala.) Tug Vlll-12. Refer to IV-2 and IV-11. Tug Vlll-13. Refer to 1-38.
Standing Height oj’ Young Children
31
Tug Vlll-14. The means in VIII-14 were secured from data gathered during 1970-1972 on healthy children of “above average socioeconomic status” showing “no clinical signs of malnutrition”; see 1V-1 and IV-8. Tug Vlll-1.5. The measures for the study in VII- 15 were taken at Santiago in 1963 on kindergarten children of “upper middle” socioeconomic status (Montoya & Ipinza, 1964). Tug Vlll-16. In VIII- 16 are sample sizes and means on children from families of “high and middle” socioeconomic status living in the Cochin-EmakulamAlwaye zone of Kerala; the children were measured at a health guidance clinic (Gokulanathan & Verghese, 1969). Tug Vlll-17 and Vlll-18. Refer to 1-41 and IV-13. Tug VIU-19. The measures used in computing the mean in VIII- 19 were taken in 1963 on children of Chinese ancestry attending private schools “in the wealthier suburbs of Kingston”; many of the grandparents were born in southern China (Ashcroft & Lovell, 1964). The contents of Tables VII and VILI, conjoined with findings from other sources, indicate: 1. With respect to young children studied between 1960 and 1970 at Bombay, Delhi, Lagos, and Santiago, there was a positive relation between standing height and socioeconomic status (Table VII). Taking the four cities together, average standing height of children from poor families was less than that of children from middle class families by about 4.5 cm, and average height for children of middle class families less than that for children of well-to-do families by about 5.0 cm. 2. Children of high socioeconomic status measured during the 1960s at Bogota, Bombay, Delhi, Ibadan, Istanbul, Lagos, and Santiago were taller than their city neighbors of low socioeconomic status; at ages from 3 to 5 years, the overall difference approximated 9.5 cm (Table VII). Except at Baghdad, the differences in the last column of Table VII are at least twice those obtained by several earlier investigators in Great Britain and North America. Data at ages 3 and 7 years were collected in 1950 at Newcastle-upon-Tyne, England (Miller, Court, Walton, & Knox, 1960) and at Eugene, Oregon (Meredith, 1951). Both of these studies compared children whose fathers were in the “professional and major managerial” category with children whose fathers were “semiskilled or unskilled“ differences of 2.6 and 2.2 cm were secured. Menzies (1940), Hopkins (1947), and Weisman (1935) analyzed measures at ages between 5 and 7 years on children attending schools in the “better” and “poorer” districts of Ottawa, Ontario; London, England; and Minneapolis, Minnesota: the differences reported were 1.7, 2.5, and 3.3 cm, respectively. 3. Specific for the period 1960-1970 and for ages between 3 and 5 years, Turkish children of wealthy families residing in Istanbul were no taller in average
32
Howard V . Meredith
standing height than American black children of indigent families residing in New Orleans (VII-3, VII-4, VIII-4). Indian children of the “professional and major managerial strata” living at Delhi under “well-privileged” conditions were no taller than American black children living in “poverty areas” of several states or in “low income families” at Washington, D.C. (VII-9, VII- 10, VIII-5). Dominican children of “the underprivileged class’ ’ in Santo Doming0 were no shorter than Chilean middle class children in Santiago (VII-7, VII-8, VIII-3). Ethiopian and Chinese children attending private schools in Addis Ababa and Kingston, respectively, were shorter than Russian children of low income families living under poor environmental conditions at Petropavlovsk (IV- 13, v1n- 18, v-7). 4. During the 1960s, average standing height at age 3 years on children of low socioeconomic status was near 83 cm in Bombay and Vellore, near 87 cm in Bogod and Lagos, near 90 cm in Ibadan, and near 94 cm in Washington, D.C. (Tables VII and VIII). A mean near 80 cm was cited earlier on Indian rural children (In-l), and a mean roughly 10 cm higher than this was reported as “representative” of the Puerto Rican rural population (Fernandez, Burgos, Asenjo, & Rosa, 1969). The Puerto Rican report, based on data gathered during 1963-1965 at isolated communities, gave a mean of 89.6 cm, and evaluated the rural diet as deficient in calories, calcium, vitamin A, riboflavin, and iron. Several analyses of measures taken in the United States during 1968-1972 yielded means between 93 and 94 cm for children of low socioeconomic status. On “poverty area children” measured in health projects of the United States Children’s Bureau, sample sizes and means were 261 and 93.0 cm for white subjects and 517 and 93.6 cm for black subjects (Systems Development Project Staff, 1968). On children of “lower income families” measured in eight states-California, Kentucky, Massachusetts, Michigan, New York, South Carolina, Washington, and West Virginia-sample sizes and means were 320 and 93.1 cm for white subjects and 245 and 94.2 cm for black subjects (United States Center for Disease Control, 1972). On Mexican children of migrant farm families in Colorado (Chase, Kumar, Dodds, Sauberlich, Hunter, Burton, & Spalding, 1971) and “low income families” in Texas (United States Center for Disease Control, 1972); sample sizes and means were 63 and 93.1 cm (Colorado); 47 and 93.7 cm (Texas). A mean of 94.0 cm was obtained from a sample (TI = 95) considered to represent United States black and white children in families “below the poverty level” (Abraham er al., 1975). For children of low socioeconomic status age 5 years, averages were between 97 and 100 crn at Bogod, Bombay, Delhi, Istanbul, Lagos, Lima, and Santiago (Tables VII and VIII), and above 107 cm from studies on black children at New Orleans (VIII-4) and Washington, D.C. (VIII-5) and the studies on black and white children cited above. Specific sample sizes and means on “poverty area,” “lower income,”
33
Standing Height of Young Children
and “poverty level” children, listed in the same order as above, were 280, 107.1 cm; 538, 109.3 cm; 442, 107.2 cm; 329, 108.7 cm; and 88, 107.9 cm. C.
INTERCITY COMPARISONS
Table IX brings together statistics for standing height of contemporary groups of young children residing in 25 cities. The table is illustrative, not exhaustive; as will be disclosed later, 50 or more city populations were sampled between 1960 and 1970. Information complementing the successive rows of Table IX follows: Tug I X - I . The small samples of Iranian children in IX- 1 were measured at the capital of Fars province (Forbes, personal communication 1972; Forbes, Ronaghy, & Majd, 1971). TABLE IX Mean Standing Height (cm) of Young Children Measured During 1960-1970 at 25 Cities Ape 3 years
Tag
City and country
IX- I IX-2 LX-3 1X-4 IX-5 IX-6 IX-7 IX-8 IX-9 IX-I0 1x-11 IX-12 IX-13 IX-14 1X-15 1X-16 1X-17 IX-18 IX-19 IX-20 IX-21 1x-22 IX-23 1X-24 1X-25
Shiraz, Iran Delhi, India Lagos, Nigeria Santiago, Chile Naples, Italy Astrakhan, U.S. S . R. Yaroslavl, U.S.S.R. Brussels, Belgium Rome, Italy Sofia, Bulgaria London, England Courtrai, Belgium St. Louis, U.S.A. Budapest, Hungary San Francisco, U.S.A. Moscow, U .S.S.R. Murmansk, U.S.S .R. Riga, Latvian S.S.R. Sydney, Australia Warsaw, Poland Petrozavodsk, U.S.S.R. Amsterdam, Netherlands Lvov, Ukrainian S.S.R. Brno, Czechoslovakia Prague, Czechoslovakia
Sample size
ca. ca.
Age 5 years
Mean
31 504 79 565 240 332 683
85.5 86.6 89.4 90.0 91.8 92.0 93. I
-
-
-
-
498 160
93.2 93.6
-
-
205 414 3,057 818 272 200 1,890 ca. 600 I90 I08
94. I 94.2 94.5 94.5 94.6 94.7 95.0 95.4 95.8 96. I
-
-
469 434
96.5 97.4
ca.
Sample size
ca. ca.
ca.
40 124 70 565 230 229 397 546 600 714 160
1,221 205 520 3,707
Mean
98.1 101.6 102.4 103.8 105.3 105.6 105.9 107.4 107.8 108.1 107.8 108.9 109.0 109.2 109.2
-
-
255 200 2,919 ca. 280 252 92 ca. 280 390 219
108.0 109.8 109.3 108.9 108.1
ca.
110.6
110.8 111.3 110.7
34
Howard V . Meredith
Tug IX-2. The values in IX-2 were taken from the 1970 report cited in VII-9 and VII- 10. Another report, based essentially on the same data, gave means of 86.6 cm on 541 children age 3 years, and 100.9 cm on 135 children age 5 years (Banik, Krishna, Mane, & Raj, 1970b). Tug IX-3. See 111-2. Tug 1 x 4 . Refer to VII-7 and VII-8. Tug I X - 5 . IX-5 presents statistics on children of Naples measured in 1963 (Tatafiore, 1965). Tugs IX-6 u n d I X - 7 . The means in IX-6 and IX-7 were reported by Goldfeld et al. (1965); the records used were accumulated during 1960-1962 at the two European cities specified. Tug 1x4. Twiesselmann ( 1969) collected the measures for the analysis in IX-8 during 1960-1961. Tug IX-9. These values i n IX-9 were obtained from data gathered during 1966-1967 in the schools of Rome (Gabrielli, Lucchetta, Chiurazzi, DiGiorgi, & Cuni, 1967). Tug I X - 1 0 . See 11- 10. Tug I X - 1 1 . The records analyzed in IX- 1 1 were made between 1960 and 1965 on children from families living in the central region of London (Tanner, Whitehouse, & Takaishi, 1966). From measures amassed in 1959 at representative London schools, Scott (1961) secured a mean of 108.3 cm on 1120 children age 5 years. Tug IX-12. The mean in IX-12, computed from data collected during 19671968, was reported by Franckx (1%9). Tug IX-13. The sample sizes and means in IX- 13 pertain to children born and reared at St. Louis, Missouri, and measured between 1967 and 1972. Ethnic composition of the samples was 64% white and 36% black children at age 3 years (Jordan & Spaner, 1972) and 60% white and 40% black children at age 5 years (Jordan & Spaner, 1974). Tug IX-14. Data collection for the study in IX-14 took place in 1968-1969 (Eiben, Hegedus, Banhegyi, Kiss, Monda, & Tasnadi, 1971). Data at age 5 years were collected simultaneously at Kormend, yielding a mean of 109.4 cm on a sample of 55 children (Eiben, personal communication 1969). Tug IX-15.See VI-8. Tug I X - 1 6 . IX-16 is a composite mean derived by pooling records on 355 Moscow children measured in 1962 (Goldfeld et ul., 1965) and on 463 Moscow children measured during 1963-1964 (Kogan, 1969). Tug I X - 1 7 . The statistics in IX- 17 were secured from data collected in 1969 at age 3 years, and in 1964 at age 5 years (Lapitskii, Belogorskii, Nemzer, Pogorely, Sinopalnikov, & Zolotareva, 1970; Lapitskii, Belogorskii, Nemzer, & Zolotareva, 1967).
Standing Height of’Young Children
35
Tug IX-18. Goldfeld ef ul. (1965) reported the statistics in IX-18 on native Latvian children measured during 1962-1963. Tug IX-19. The means in IX-19 were obtained on large samples of children measured between 1970 and 1972 at child health centers, preschools, and kindergartens in the “Sydney metropolitan area” (Jones & Hemphill, 1974; Jones, Hemphill, & Meyers, 1973). Tug IX-20. Refer to 111-4 and 111- 14. Tug IX-21. This analysis in IX-21 was made from measures taken in 1966 (Kuz’min, 1970). Tug IX-22. The samples analyzed in IX-22 were measured in 1963 (Oppers, 1964). Tug IX-23. The mean in IX-23, based on data collected during 1970-1971, was reported by Zhaglina ( 1974). Tugs ZX-24 and IX-25. See 111-5. The statistics in Table IX, colligated with findings on the standing height of young children in other cities, warrant the following statements: 1. At age 3 years, the mean in IX-2 for Indian children of Delhi is 10.8 cm, or 1 I%, lower than that for children of Prague. Generalizing at 99: 1 probability: During the 1960s, the Indian population of children age 3 years living at Delhi was shorter in average standing height than the Czech population of age peers living at Prague by an amount likely between 9.8 and 11.8 cm. Compared with the “all India” mean of 84.5 cm at age 3 years, obtained from 5700 measures gathered in several Indian states during 1956-1965 (Indian Council of Medical Research, 1968), the Delhi mean i n IX-2 is 2.1 cm higher. 2. Average standing height at age 3 years for city children of the 1960s was near 90 cm at Santiago, Chile, and Lagos. Nigeria; near 92 cm at Naples, Italy, and Astrakhan, Soviet Union; near 94 cm at St. Louis, Missouri, and Budapest, Hungary; and near 95 cm at Sydney, New South Wales, and Warsaw, Poland. Means between 92 and 94 cm were obtained at several cities in the Soviet Union. Specific sample sizes, means, times of data collection, and places are: 267, 92.2 cm, 1962, Saratov; 512, 92.8 cm, 1960-1961, Minsk; 185, 92.9, 1962, Pskov; 261, 93.6 cm, 1960, Rostov-on-Don; 161, 94.0 cm, 1962, Kursk (Goldfeld et ul., 1965); about 400,92.7 cm, 1962-1963, Kemerovo (Kaganovich, Kraeba, & Bogachanov, 1966); and about 170, 93.8 cm, 1963, Ivano-Frankovsk (Kutsenko, 1965). Means above 95 cm, in addition to the five in Table IX, are 95.6 cm on 51 West German children measured at Kiel (Spranger, Ochsenfarth, Kock, & Henke, 1968), and 97.6 cm on 129 Czechoslovak children measured at Bratislava (111-5). 3. At age 5 years, the means in Table IX are higher for Lvov than for Santiago by 7 cm, higher for Brno than for Naples by 6 cm, higher for Amsterdam than for Astrakhan by 5 cm, and higher for Riga than for Yaroslavl by almost 4 cm. It is
Howard V . Meredith
36
highly probable that during the 1960s the population of children age 5 years at Santiago, Chile was at least 6 cm shorter in average standing height than the population at this age in Brno, Czechoslovakia. 4. Means between 106 and 108 cm were obtained from investigations in the 1960s at Brussels (IX-8), Kursk (111-16), Lublin (111-14), Murmansk (IX-l7), Ore1 (III-l6), Rome (IX-9), Ryazan (111-16), and several additional cities in the Soviet Union. Particulars, following the same procedure as at age 3 years, are: 332, 106.0 cm, 1960, Tomsk; 292, 106.3 cm, 1961, Orenberg; 217, 106.6 cm, 1962, Pskov; 638, 107.2 cm., 1962, Blagovyeschensk-on-Amur; and 201, 108.0 cm, 1962, Saratov (Goldfeld et al., 1965). Means of 105.7 and 107.4 cm, respectively, were secured on 178 Italian children measured during 1960-1961 at Bari (Pirk & Meli, 1962), and on 124 Italian children measured during 19621964 at Bolzano (Dattoli, 1965). 5. Continuing for age 5 years, means between 108 and I10 cm characterized children at Budapest (IX-l4), Courtrai (IX-l2), Donetsk (111-16), Dzhalal-Abad (I-38), Kormend (IX- 14), Petrozavodsk (IX-21), Riga (IX- 18), San Francisco (IX-l5), Sofia (IX-lo), St. Louis (IX-l3), Sydney (IX-l9), and Warsaw (IX-20). Materials from five other studies yielding means in this category are: about 500, 108.0 cm, 1960-1962, Vienna (Stracker, 1963); 502, 108.3 cm, 1961, Kalinin (Goldfeld et af., 1965); about 170, 108.3 cm, 1963, Ivano-Frankovsk (Kutsenko, 1965); about 225, 108.5 cm, 1969, Gorki (Dorozhnova, 1973); and 554, 108.6 cm, 1971, Petropavlovsk (Nekisheva, 1974).
VII. Female and Male Groups Compared The present section is based entirely on averages for standing height computed from measures on 200 or more children of a particular age and sex. A.
GROUP DESCRIPTIONS
Table X displays paired means for males and females of 16 populations sampled at age 3 years, and 18 populations sampled at age 5 years. Source identifications are as follows: Tags X - 1 and X - 2 1 . See 1-29. Tags X-2 a n d X - 2 2 . The values in X-2 and X-22 were obtained on “poverty area children” measured during 1968 in connection with health projects of the United States Children’s Bureau (Systems Development Project Staff, 1968). Tags X - 3 a n d X - 1 7 . See 1-3. Tags X - 4 and X - 2 3 . Studies made at Minsk and Yaroslavl provided data for the analyses in X-4 at age 3 years (Goldfeld et al., 1965).,The measures used
37
Standing Height of Young Children
TABLE X Mean Standing Height (cm) of Male and Female Young Children Measured Largely Between 1960 and 1970 ~~
Males
Tag
Group
Sample size
x-1
X-16
Surinam Creole United States black Angolan Lunda Russian Romanian Indian Filipino Dutch Spanish Bulgarian United States white Tasmanian Czech Australian Chinese Finnish
414 263 74 3 598 > 1,980 834 217 627 776 677 1,576 560 460 96 I 650 245
X-17 X- 18 X-19 x-20 x-2I x-22 X-23 X-24 X-25 X-26 X-27 X-28 X-29 X-30 X-31 X-32 x-33 x-34
Angolan Lunda Hungarian East German Filipino Surinam Creole United States black Russian Italian Bulgarian Spanish Japanese Chinese Dutch United States white Belgian Australian Surinam Industani Finnish
799 276 953 236 757 279 1,298 808 1,002 5,941 3,118 1,532 820 1,896 913 1,440 777 208
x-2 x-3 x-4 x-5 X-6 x-7 X-8 x-9
x-10 x-ll x-I2 X-I3 X-14
X-15
Females
Mean
Sample size
Mean
Difference"
Age 3 years
91 .0 93.7 83.6 93.3 93.9 84.3 85.7 97.6 91 -0 93.3 95 .0 96.5 97.6 95.7 93.4 96.0
424 254 800 597 > 1,980 789 216 625 739 699 1,481 554 443 929 538 240
91.4 93.5 83.5 92.8 93.1 83.4 84.8 96.7 89.9 92.2 93.9 95.3 96.2 94.3 91.4 93.7
- .4
84 I 244 895 216 782 259 1,130 833 92 I 6,246 2,896 1,330 804 1,811 854 1,479 739 212
96.4 109.1 109.8 97.3 106.3 109.0 107.5 107.2 105.8 103.5 103.6 104.5 110.8 108.7 107.9 108.7 103.6 107.9
-.I .I .3 .4
.2 .3 .5
.8 .9 .9 .9 1.1 1.1 1.1
I .2 1.4 I .4 2.0 2.3
Age 5 years
"Mean for males minus mean for females.
96.3 109.2 110.1 97.7 106.8 109.5 108.1 107.9 106.6 104.4 104.5 105.4 I 1 1.7 109.6 108.9 109.8 104.8 109.1
.5 .5
.6 .7 .8 .9 .9 .9 .9 .9 1 .0 1.1
1.2 1.2
Howord V . Meredith
38
at age 5 years (X-23) were gathered at Blagovyeschensk-on-Amur, Donetsk, Ka!inin, and Kursk (Goldfeld er ul., 1965; Pokatilo, 1974). Tug X-5. See 11-9. Tug X - 6 . The means in X-6 were obtained from measures taken at Delhi (Banik er ul., 1970c), Vellore (VIII-l), and Maharashtra villages in the vicinity of Poona (Phadke er ul., 1971). Tugs X - 7 and X - 2 0 . See 11- 17. Tags X - 8 and X-29. See 11-14. Tugs X - 9 and X - 2 6 . See IV- 12. Tugs X - 1 0 and X-25. During 1960-1961, records for these analyses were accumulated at Sofia and other urban communities in Bulgaria (11- 10). Tags X-11 a n d X - 3 0 . See VI-8. Tug X-12. See 11-28, Tag X - 1 3 . Measures taken at Brno and Prague were used in computing the weighted means in X-13 (111-5). Tugs X-14 and X-32. See IX- 19. Tags X - 1 5 and X-28. See 11-8. Tugs X - 1 6 andX-34. See 11-12. Tug X - 1 8 . See IX-14. Tug X - 1 9 . See 11-13. Tug X - 2 4 . Data in X-24 were pooled from studies in the department of Emilia (11-25), the province of Grosseto (11-24), and Rome (IX-9). Tug X-27. See 11-23. Tug X - 3 1 . See IX-8 and IX- 12. Tug X - 3 3 . See I- I 9. 13.
GROUP COMPARISONS
The column in Table X farthest to the right shows the amount by which each of the means for males exceeds its adjacent mean for females. It is found: 1. Collectively, the 34 paired samples of young children indicate that during the 1960s males were taller than females by aboat .8 cm. This overall figure, considering the strength of its foundation, can be taken as a reasonably precise estimate of the human sex difference in standing height for the age period from 3 to 5 years. 2. For the 16 differences at age 3 years, the obtained average is 1 .O cm. This value appears spuriously inflated, due principally to the differences of 2.0 and 2.3 cm i n X-15 and X-16, respectively. The Chinese study (X-15) reported means higher for males than for females by 1.3 cm at age 4 years, and .9 cm at age 5 years; in the Finnish study, obtained differences were 1.5 cm at age 2 years, 2.0 cm at age 4 years, and 1.2 cm at age 5 years.
Standing Height of Young Children
39
3 . In several instances, the hypothesis of identical population means for standing height of males and females in early childhood (the null hypothesis) cannot be rejected. Specifically, findings from statistical tests do not allow the inference of a highly dependable population sex difference in height for any of the following groups: East Germar,, Filipino, Hungarian, Lunda, Russian, Surinam Creole, or United States black. From samples of Lunda children as large as those in X-3, a difference between obtained means of at least .9 cm is a prerequisite to positing, at p = .01, differential male and female populations for standing height at age 3 years. 4. The samples of Dutch, Spanish, and United States white children lend consistent support to the generalization that during the 1960s preschool age females of these populations were slightly shorter than coeval males. Obtained differences are clustered between .9 and 1.1 cm for these groups at both ages and, at one age, for Australian, Belgian, Bulgarian, Chinese, Indian, and Japanese groups. Differences between 1.2 and 1.5 cm are shown for the Czechoslovak, Finnish, Surinam Industani, and Tasmanian groups.
VIII. Comparisons from Subgrouping for Other Variables A.
COMPARISONS FROM SUBGROUPING B Y BIRTH WEIGHT A N D BIRTH ORDER
1 . Birth Weight Four studies reported during the 1960s supported the generalization that there is a positive relationship between body weight at birth and standing height i n early childhood. Banik ef al. (1970b), using measures of standing height accumulated between 1964 and 1967 on Indian children of Delhi, obtained means of 85.1 cm at age 3 years and 98.5 cm at age 5 years for those subjects weighting 2.5 kg or less at birth. Means for the subjects weighing more than 2.5 kg at birth were higher by 2.1 and 3.3 cm at ages 3 and 5 years, respectively. Subgroup sample sizes were 155 and 386 at age 3 years and 39 and 100 at age 5 years. Mortison (1969), analyzing data on United States black “poverty area children” measured in 1968, secured means that were lower on children whose birth weights were 2.5 kg or less than on children weighing above 2.5 kg at birth by 1.0, 1.2, and .3 cm at ages 3, 4, and 5 years. The sample sizes were 99 and 375 at age 3 years, 72 and 334 at age 4 years and 67 and 316 at age 5 years. At age 3 years, records for standing height collected during 1961-1967 at Buffalo, New York gave a mean 4.6 cm higher on 93 white children whose birth weights were above 2.5 kg than the mean for 160 white children with birth
Howard V . Meredith
40
weights below 2.5 kg (Cruise, 1973). Means near 91.5 cm at age 3 years, and 104 cm at age 5 years, were reported from data gathered during 1963-1970 at Montreal, Quebec on white children who weighed less than 2.5 kg at birth and were singleton offspring of mothers with normal pregnancy periods (Fitzhardinge & Steven, 1972). These means, based on sample sizes of 96 and about 75, are lower than the means for white children in IX- 15 by 2.9 and 5.2 cm at ages 3 and 5 years, respectively. Body weight distributions for viable neonates of different ethnic populations vary considerably. Birth weights below 2.5 kg were found for 29% of 2695 Indian infants delivered during 1959-1961 at Delhi (Ghosh & Beri, 1962), 12% of 2997 United States black infants born in 1949 at Baltimore (Taback, 1951), and less than 7% of 14,390,000 United States white born during 1957-1%0 (Meredith, 1970).
2 . Birth Order Wingerd (personal communication 1974) classified in three birth rank categories a large number of standing height records at age 5 years on white children measured at San Francisco between 1964 and 1972. The means obtained were 109.5 cm for 1243 first-born children, 109.0 cm for 1783 children of second or third birth orders, and 108.8 cm for 681 children of fourth or higher birth ranks. Earlier studies in the United States, England, and Canada reported a similar negative association between birth rank and height in early childhood (Meredith, 1950). First-born children were taller than children of second to fourth birth orders by .8 cm for Iowa City children age 5 years, 1.5 cm for Middlesbrough children age 6 years, and .8 cm for Toronto children age 6 years. The difference obtained by Wingerd on comparing means at age 5 years for ranks 1 and 4 or more (.7 cm) is the same as that obtained in the Toronto study on comparing the mean for rank 1 with that for ranks 5 and above. The negative relationship of standing height and birth order found at childhood ages does not hold in infancy. It i s well established that at birth body length and birth order are positively related (Meredith, 1950). B.
COMPARISONS FOR SINGLE WITH TWIN BIRTHS, AND SMOKING WITH NONSMOKING MOTHERS
1 . Twin Pregnancy Wilson (1974) analyzed data amassed between 1960 and 1972 on white twins age 3 years “drawn from the entire socioeconomic range found in the metropolitan Louisville (Kentucky) area.” The obtained mean of 92.8 cm on 360 children was 1.7 cm lower than that secured at this age from 3057 white singleton births in San Francisco (IX- 15).
Stuntling Height
c?f’ Young Children
41
2. Maternal Smoking Wingerd and Schoen ( 1974) investigated maternal tobacco smoking during pregnancy in relation to standing height of offspring at age 5 years. They obtained means of 109.4 cm on 2404 children of mothers who did not use tobacco during pregnancy; 109.0 cm on 562 children whose mothers, during pregnancy, smoked from 1 to 14 cigarettes daily; and 108.5 cm on 741 children of mothers who smoked 15 or more cigarettes daily. Using measures of standing height amassed in 1965 on 1 1,500 children 7 years of age residing in different parts of England, Scotland, and Wales, Goldstein (1971) secured a mean 1.4 cm greater for offspring of nonsmoking mothers than offspring of mothers who smoked over 10 cigarettes daily throughout pregnancy. A similar relation between the height of children and maternal smoking during their prenatal development has been found in other studies (Meredith, 1975). C.
COMPARISONS FOR PHYSICAL ABNORMALITY, ELEVATION OF HABITAT, HEALTH STATUS, AND HEALTH CARE
I . Down’sSyndrome On Dutch children with Down’s syndrome (Mongolism) residing in NoordBrabant province, Swaak (1967) reported means of 87.4 cm at age 3 years and 98.4 cm at age 5 years. These means, based on sample sizes of 39 and 40, respectively, are lower than those at corresponding ages from the 1964-1966 Netherlands survey (11-14) by 9.8 and 12.9 cm.
2. Elevation of Habitat Two studies made during the 1960s lend support to the generalization that standing height in early childhood and elevation of abode are inversely related. Kirghiz children were measured during 1961-1964 in a town (Naryn) situated at an elevation near 2.0 km, and at two towns (Frunze and Dzhalal-Abad) whose elevations were near .8 km (1-38). Means for children of Naryn were lower than composite means for children of Frunze and Dzhalal-Abad by 1.9 cm at age 3 years and 2.7 cm at age 5 years. Sample sizes were 103 and 197 for the higher town and 254 and 676 for the towns located at elevations near .8 km. Kambara (1969) analyzed measures taken in 1963 on Japanese children age 5 years residing i n mountainous and coastal areas of Kagawa prefecture (11-23). Obtained means were 102.6 cm for about 360 children inhabiting mountainous areas, and 103.9 cm for about 690 children inhabiting coastal regions. Compare 1-8 and 1-35.
3 . Health Status During the 1960s, several studies were reported on young children of similar health status. When brought together these studies indicate that, with health
42
Howard V . Meredith
status held fairly constant, young children of different ethnic groups varied greatly in average standing height. At age 3 years, means near 85 cm were obtained on Indian children of Bhopal and Gwalior shcwing “no signs of malnutrition or vitamin deficiency” (V111-6), and on Nigerian Angus and Sura children “in a good nutritional state” (1-7); near 90 cm on Indian children of Agra province who were without “any history of illness likely to retard growth” (11-21) and Jamaican children showing “no unequivocal signs of malnutrition” (I- 15); near 93 cm on “well-nourished” Thai children (IV-2) and Italian children of Padua province living ‘‘under reasonably good conditions” (11-24); and near 97 cm on Russian (IV-7) and Yoruba (1-24) children reared under good to superior living conditions. There is a difference of 12 cm between the lowest (84.6 cm) and highest (96.6 cm) averages of this series. At age 5 years, reported means were near 89 cm for “healthy” Malayan children (IV-5), near 95 cm for Quechua Amerind children whose “diet appeared adequate” (I-8), near 99 ern for Peruvian children “in apparent good health” (V111-2), near 101 cm for Maharastra children showing “no signs of malnutrition or vitamin deficiency” ( V I I I ~ I )near , 105 cm for “well-nourished’’ Thai children (IV-I l ) , near 107 cm for “healthy” children of Poona manifesting “no clinical signs of malnutrition” (IV-l), near 109 cm for Sara children of Chad exhibiting “no signs of malnutrition” (I-41), and near 11 1 cm for “healthy and well-nourished” Spanish chiidren (IV- 12). This series of averages yields a range exceeding 20 cm.
4 . Health Care Guzman ct al. (1968) compared Mayan Amerind children reared in Guatemalan villages under the three conditions specified in 1- 1 . Average standing height at age 3 years was found to approximate 79 cm at the village deficient in dietary and health resources, 8 1 cm at the village providing “improved sanitation and medical services,” and 84 cm at the village where “children received a food supplement and their mothers were given advice on nutrition.” Means of 88.0 and 100.1 cm at ages 3 and 5 years, respectively, were reported by Morley el al. (1968) on Yoruba single-born children reared in ,a village that provided “the best medical services possible to any sick child” and “food supplements” to any child showing signs of malnutrition. The number of children measured at each age was more than 200. As indicated in 1-24, these means are 8 and 10 cm lower than the means obtained on Yoruba children of well-to-do Ibadan families. On 32 Indian children age 3 years measured at a child development center in New Delhi, a mean of 96.1 crn was secured (Khurana, Agarwal, Manwani, & Srivastava, 197 1 ) . The subjects were “apparently healthy”; they received health care, including immunizations, and their mothers were given advice on nutrition. Compared with the mean of 88.6 cm obtained by Banik ei al. (1970~)for 124
Standing Height of Young Children
43
Delhi children of the upper-middle and upper socioeconomic classes, this mean is higher by 7.5 cm. The living conditions of children residing at Petropavlovsk were classified by Nekisheva (1974) as poor, moderately satisfactory, and superior. From a total sample of 313 children at age 3 years, the mean (96.8 cm) for standing height of 92 children living under superior conditions was 1.7 cm higher than that for 77 children living under poor conditions. At age 5 years, the sample total was 554, and the mean for height of children living under superior conditions was higher than for children living under poor conditions by 1.6 cm. Assuming the difference of 5 cm in average standing height of the Guatemalan “control” and “nutritional guidance” groups is due entirely to improvement in health care, this difference is far less than the 12 cm difference between Mayan children reared with health guidance and the Russian children of Petropavlovsk reared under superior conditions.
IX. Estimates of Population Variability and Their uses A.
CHOOSING A METHOD OF ESTIMATING POPULATION VARIABILITY IN STANDING HEIGHT
If standing height were measured on all of the young children at a given age in a specified population, and the frequency distribution of the measures on this population were found to be a replica of the Gaussian or normal distribution, the mean and standard deviation of the measures would precisely describe the population in respect to standing height. Rarely does an investigator find it possible to measure the entire membership of a population. Instead, a sample is drawn from the population, each member of the sample is measured, and the measures are analyzed statistically to obtain estimates of population parameters. All of the means presented in earlier sections of this chapter are estimates of population central tendency, and all of the standard deviations that will be included in this section are estimates of population variability. Human biologists study samples for the purpose of gaining knowledge about populations and, on occasion, to construct aids (e.g., growth charts) that pediatricians, school health personnel, and others can use to enhance their services within populations. Measures of standing height taken on large samples of young children selected randomly from a population commonly yield frequency distributions that differ little from the Gaussian model. This assertion can be substantiated by comparing series of percentiles obtained directly from ordered measures of height with corresponding percentiles obtained through use of the standard deviation.
Howard V . Meredith
44
Studies on large samples of Dutch children (11- 14) and Australian white children (IX- 19) analyzed variability in terms of the standard deviation and in terms of percentiles, 3, 10, 25, 75, 90,and 97. Table XI reproduces percentiles from these reports and aligns them with percentiles secured by computing values above and below each age-sex-height mean at points .67, 1.28, and 1.88 sigma. The table shows almost complete agreement between the empirical percentiles (Method A) and the percentiles derived on the assumption that standing height TABLE X1 Percentiles (cm) for Standing Height of Young Children Obtained from Ordered Measures (A) and from Standard Deviations (B) Males
Females Method B
B minus A
Dutch children age 3 years 90.3 .I 89.8 .o 91.7 92.6 95.0 .o 94.0 100.2 .2 99.2 .I 101.6 102.6 -.I 103.8 104.9
89.4 91.7 94. I 99.3 101.7 104.0
- .4
Australian children age 3 years 87.6 .o 85.9 -.I 88.5 90.2 92.8 -.2 91.3 .o 91.5 98.6 101.2 .2 100.2 103.8 .I 103.3
85.5 88.3 91.2 97.4 100.3 103. I
- .4 -.2 -.l
97
87.6 90.3 93.0 98.6 101.0 103.7
3 10 25 75 90 97
102.9 105.8 108.4 114.6 117.5 120.2
Dutch children age 5 years 102.9 .o 101.8 -.I 104.9 105.7 108.6 .2 107.5 114.8 .2 113.9 117.7 .2 116.6 120.5 .3 119.6
102.0 104.8 107.7 113.9 116.8 119.6
3 10 25 75 90 97
100.6 103.5 106.3 113. I 116.2 119.2
Australian children age 5 years 100.6 .o 99.1 .o 102.3 103.5 106.5 .2 105.1 .o 112.1 113.1 I 16.1 -.I 115. I 119.0 -.2 118.2
99.3 102.3 105.3 112. I ,115.1 118.1
Percentile
Method A
3 10 25 75 90 97
90.2 92.6 95.0 100.0 102.5 105.0
3 10
25 75
90
Method B
B minus A
Method A
.o .I .I .I .2
-.I .I -.2
.2
-.I .2
.o .2 .O
- .4
.o .2
.o .o
-.I
Standing Height of Young Children
45
distributions at these ages closely approximate the Gaussian distribution (Method B). Some research reports in the 1960s included percentiles 10, 25, 75, and 90, each rounded to the nearest centimeter, and standard deviations rounded to the nearest millimeter. These statistics were supplied in studies of Italian children at ages 3 and 5 years (11-25), and Belgian children at age 5 years (IX-12). Sixteen percentiles from the Italian study (four on each sex at each age) and eight from the Belgian study were paired with percentiles derived from the standard deviations. Taken to the nearest centimeter, there was agreement in 21 of the 24 comparisons. With two methods suited to the same task, the appropriate course is to choose the one having the greater reliability and mathematical robustness. It follows that in early childhood the standard deviation is the preferred method to use when estimating the variability of a population in standing height, or when obtaining percentiles in the process of constructing graphic or tabular frames of reference for standing height. B . STANDARD DEVIATION ESTIMATES OF POPULATION VARIABILITY
It is a statistical commonplace that large samples yield more dependable estimates of population parameters than small samples. The 111 estimates of population variability in Table XII, with eight exceptions where sample size is between 135 and 188, are based on sample sizes exceeding 200. The sources of the estimates are as follows: Tags XII-I and XII-23. See IX-14. Tags XII-2 and XII-16. See 11- 12. Tags XII-3 and XII-17. See X-4. Tags XII-4 and X I I - 2 2 . See IX-24 and IX-25. Tags XII-5 and X I I - 2 1 . See 11- 14. Tags X U - 6 and XII-29. See 1-22. Tags XII-7 and X I I - 3 2 . See 11-24 (Bussadori study) and 11-25. Tags XII-8 and XII-18. See 1-6. Tags XII-9 and X I I - 3 4 . The population estimates in XII-9 and XII-34 were obtained using measures taken during 1958-1960 at the towns of Katowice, Szczecin, and Warsaw (Miesowicz, 1964). Tags XII-10 and XII-28. See IX- 19. Tags XII-11 and XII-20. See 11-8. Tag XII-12. Owen and Lubin (1973) reported the findings in XII- 12. Refer to
1-40. Tags XII-13 and XII-35. See 1-3. Tags X U - I 4 a n d X I I - 3 7 . The samples used to obtain the values in XII- 14 and XII-37 were considered representative for children of “all India”; data collection
46
Howard V . Meredith
took place between 1956 and 1965 in several states (Indian Council of Medical Research, 1968). Tugs XII-15 and XII-36. See 1-29. Tug XII-19. XII- 19 carries variability values based on measures amassed during 1970 under the auspices of the Japanese Ministry of Education (Kimura, personal communication 1973).
TABLE XI1 Standard Deviations (cm) for Standing Height of Young Children
Females
Males
Sample size
Tag
Group
x11- I x11-2 XI1-3 XII-4 XII-5 XII-6 XII-7 Xll-8 XII-9 XII- 10
XII- 12 XlI-13 X11- I4 XII- 15
Hungarian Finnish Russian Czechoslovak Dutch Chuvash Italian Ladino Polish Australian Chineseh United States white Lundah Indian'' Surinam Creole
177 245 598 460 627 213 301 170 305 961 5180 206 1,042 3,057 A14
XII- 16 XII-17 XI1-18 XII-19 XII-2G XII-21 XII-22 Xll-23 XII-24 XII-25 XI1-26 XII-27 XII-28
Finnish Russian Ladino Japanese' Chinese" Dutch Czechoslovak Hungarian Kirghiz East German Surinam lndustani Azerhiajani Australian
2108 1,298 144 10,:Ilo 1,964 804 327 276 469 1.906 938 I88 I.440
Standard deviation
Sample size
Standard deviation
Both sexes Sample size
Standard deviation
Age 3 years
XII- I 1
3.6 3.9 4.1 3.8 3.9 3.7 4.0 3.6 4.1 4.3 4.1 4.4 5.6 6.6 7.2
237 240 597 443 625 204 267 I46 31 I 929 872 173 1,024 2,956 424
3.1 3. I 3.6 3.9 3.9 4.2 4.0 4.4 4.2 4.7 4.3 4.5 5.4 6.3 6.8
414 485 1,195 903 1,252 417 568 316 616 1,890 1,852 379 2,066 6.013 838
3.7a 3.7 3.9 3.9 3.9 4.0 4.1 4.1 4.2 4.6 4.6 4.6 5.5 6.5 7.0
212 1.130 I 50 10.104 1,616 820 342 244 404 1,791 900 135 1,419
3.9 4. I 4.8 4.5 4.1 4.1 4.8 4.6 4.1 4.9 5.2 4.4 5.0
420 2,428 294 20,414 3,580 1,624 669 520 873 3,697 1,838 323 2.919
4.2 4.4 4.5 4.5 4.7 4.7 4.7 4.1 4.8 4.9 4.9 4.9 5.0
Age 5 vears
4.4 4.1 4.2 4.6 4.6 4.7 4.7 4.1 4.8 4.8 4.2 5.1 4.9
fcontinued)
Standing Herghr of Young Children
47
T A B L E XI1 (continued) Females
Males
Both sexes
-
Tag
Group
XII-29 Xll-30 Xll-31 XI1-32 XII-33 XII-34 XII-35 Xll-36 Xll-37
Chuvash Belgian Bulgarian Italian United States white'" Polish Lunda" Surinam Creole Indian"
Sample size
Standard deviation
22 I 913 1.002 807 2.169
50 5 0 5 3 51
300
5 3
742 757 3,413
hO
56
63 67
Sample size
213 854 92 I 759 2,596 300 790 782 2,940
Standard deviation
4.7 5.1 5.2 5.4 5.5 5.7 6.0 6. I 6.4
Sample size
434 1,767 1,923 1,566 4,765 600 1,532 1,539 6,353
Standard deviation
5.0 5.1 5.3 5.3 5.5 5.6 6.0 6.2 6.6
"For SD=4.0 em, SE of SD is .20 cm where n=200, .14 em where n=400, .09 cm where n=loOO, and .05 em where n=3000. For SD=6.0 e m , corresponding SEs are .30, .21, .13, and .08 em. *Age 3.5 years. 'Age 5 . 5 years. "Age 4.5 years.
Tugs XII-24 through XII-27. See 1-38, 11-13, 1-19, and 1-26, respectively. Tag XII-30. See IX-8 and IX- 12. Tug XII-31. See 11- 10. Tug XII-33. The standard deviations in XII-33 were obtained on data gathered during 1937-1939 in a Federal anthropometric project conducted in 16 states and the District of Columbia (O'Bnen, Girshick, & Hunt, 1941). Inspection and statistical evaluation of Table XI1 yield the following: 1. Estimates of variability i n standing height for different populations of young children are not consistently higher on one sex than the other. Among the 37 pairs of sex specific standard deviations, I7 are higher for males than females, 16 higher for females than males, and 4 are of equal magnitude for both sexes. 2. At age 3 years, 77% of the 30 standard deviations for the sexes separately are between 3.5 and 5.0 cm. For the sexes separately at age 5 years, 80% of the 44 standard deviatibns are between 4.0 and 5.5 cm. 3. Standard deviation estimates for both sexes together (Table XII, cclumn farthest right) are between 3.7 and 4.6 cm on the nine white populations represented at age 3 years. On the 12 white populations at age 5 years, the delimiting values are 4.2 and 5.6 cm. Other populations for whom standard deviation estimates are within these limits are Central American Ladino, South American Industani, European Chuvash, and Asian Azerbaijani, Chinese, Japanese, and Kirghiz.
48
Howard V . Meredith
4. At age 3 years, population standard deviation estimates for standing height are low (3.7-3.9 cm) for Czechoslovak, Dutch, Finnish, and Hungarian children in Europe, and high (5.5-7.0 cm) for Lunda children in Africa, Indian children in Asia, and Creole children in South America. Low (below 4.8 cm) and high (6.0 cm and above) variability in standing height is found for the same populations at age 5 years. 5. For the two sexes together, statistical significance tests a t p = .01 yield no dependable differences at age 3 years in variability of standing height among the eight populations of European children represented. There are dependable differences, at 99: 1 probability, between each of the European populations and the populations of Indian, Lunda, and Creole children. Standing height at age 5 years is more variable in the Indian, Lunda, and Creole populations than in the populations of East Germany, Japan, Republic of China, Soviet Union, and the Netherlands. There are no statistically dependable differences at this age among the Azerbaijani, Chinese, Czechoslovak, Dutch, East German, Hungarian, Japanese, Kirghiz, Ladino, and Surinam Industani populations.
X. Summary This chapter centers on recent advances in knowledge pertaining to the standing height of preschool children. It assembles and orders research findings from more than 200 investigations made in different parts of the world between 1960 and 1970. The ordering is problem oriented; comparisons and syntheses are presented for human standing height at ages 3 and 5 years in relation to ethnic and national origin; urban and rural habitat; socioeconomic and health status; sex, birth size, and birth order; and maternal pregnancy variables. Selected findings on children of the 1960s are as follows: 1. At ages 3 and 5 years, average height was more than 10 cm, or 11%, less for Lunda children of Angola than for United States white children. There were similar differences at age 3 years between Mayan children of Guatemala and Kirghiz children of the Kirghiz Soviet Socialist Republic, and at age 5 years between Shi children of Zaire and United States black children. 2. Average height at age 3 years was near 90 cm for black children of St. Vincent and Jamaica islands, Chuvash children of the Chuvash Socialist Republic, Eskimo children of Alaska, Industani children of Surinam, and Yoruba children of Nigeria. At age 5 years, an average of about 102 cm characterized Amerind children of Surinam, Indonesian children of Surinam, children of Paraguay, and children of Venezuela. 3. Bundi children of New Guinea were no taller in average height at age 5 years than Hum children of Rwanda age 3 years. The same relation was found for Jordanian children age 5 years and Dutch children age 3 years. Compared with
Standing Heighr of Young Children
49
children of East Pakistan, Malaya, and the Philippines, children of Finland, East Germany, and the Netherlands were taller in average height by more than 10 cm. 4. Indian and Nigerian children living at urban centers were more than 3 cm taller in average height than their respective age peers residing in rural regions. Urban-rural differences were near 2 cm for Bulgarian, Czechoslovak, Polish, and Romanian children. There were no differences in average height of rural and urban children belonging to the Creole, Hindustani, and Indonesiah ethnic populations of Surinam. 5. Indian children living in rural areas of Hyderabad state and Bombay province were, on the average, more than 10 cm shorter than upper class urban children of Bombay and Delhi, and about 3 cm shorter than children of low socioeconomic status at the same cities. Thai children residing in middle and upper class homes at Bangkok were no taller than Russian rural children living in the Udor region of the Komi Soviet Socialist Republic. 6. For young inhabitants of Santiago, Chile, and Lagos, Nigeria, average standing height was between 2 and 5 cm less on children of poor families than those of middle class families, and between 4 and 7 cm less on children of middle class families than those of well-to-do families. Turkish young children of wealthy families residing at Istanbul were no taller than American black children of indigent families living at New Orleans. 7. Intercity comparisons showed that at age 3 years children of Santiago, Chile, were about 6 cm shorter in average height than their age peers at Prague, Czechoslovakia. At age 5 years, average height was similar (near 109 cm) for children of Budapest, Hungary, Courtrai, Belgium, St. Louis, Missouri, Sydney, Australia, and Warsaw, Poland. 8. For Creole children of Surinam, black children of the United States, Lunda children of Angola, Hungarian children of Budapest, and East German children, standing height averages at ages 3 and 5 years were practically alike on males and females. Males were between . 8 and 1.2 cm taller than females in child populations of Belgium, Bulgaria, India, Japan, the Netherlands, Romania, Spain, and Tasmania. 9. At age 3 years, a study in the United States showed that twins were shorter than children from singleton pregnancies, and studies in Canada, India, and the United States showed that children weighing less than 2.5 kg at birth were slightly shorter than children who at birth weighed 2.5 kg or more. At age 5 years, studies in the United States found that first-born children were slightly taller than children of later birth order, and children of mothers who did not use tobacco during pregnancy were slightly taller than children whose mothers smoked 15 or more cigarettes daily throughout pregnancy. 10. Large samples drawn from more than 30 populations showed that variability in standing height was not systematically higher on one sex than the other. At age 3 years, standard deviations were near 4 cm in Chuvash, Czechos-
50
Howard V . Meredith
lovak, Dutch, Italian, Ladino, Polish, and Russian populations. Standard deviations at age 5 years were near 5 cm in Australian, Azerbaijani, Belgian, Bulgarian, Chinese, Chuvash, Czechoslovak, Dutch, East German, Hungarian, Italian, Kirghiz, and Surinam In’dustani populations. Greater variability, standard deviations near 6 cm at both ag,es, was found in populations of Indian, Lunda, and Creole children. ACKNOWLEDGMENTS Gratitude is expressed to the following persons who assisted with literature search, reference procurement, provision of unpublished material, language translation, verification of statistics, or manuscript typing: M. C. Bushey, H. Chrzastek-Spruch, 0. Eiben, R . Eksmyr, S . J. Foman, A. P. Forbes, J. E. Goettsch, R . G . Harvey, M. D. Janes, T. Kambara, S. J . Karayan, K. Kirnura, V. B. Knott, L. A. Malcolm, W. J. McGanity, E. M. Meredith, F . J. Miller, M. A. Ned, 0. Neyzi, M. V. Phadke, B. D. Richardson, M. Sempe, J. Spranger, M. Steffens, M. C. Swaminathan, A. M. Thomson, H. L. Vis, J. Wingerd, and N. Wolanski. For generous support in carrying forward the project, appreciation is tendered to Dean Warren K. Giese, Professors John H. Spurgeon, Steven N. Blair, and R . G . Sargent, all of the College of Health and Physical Education, University of South Carolina.
REFERENCES Abraham, S . , Lowenstein, F. W., & O’Connell, D. E. Preliminaryfindings of thejrst health and nutrition examination survey, United States, 1971 -I 972: Anthropometric and clinical findings (DHEW Publ. No. HRA-75-1229). Rockville, Md.: National Center for Health Statistics, 1975. Antrobus, A. C . K . Child growth and related factors in a rural community in St. Vincent. Journal of Tropical Pediatrics and Environmental Child Health, 197 I , 17, 188-210. Arkhipova, G . P. Physical development of children and adolescents of the minority nationalities of Sakhalin Island. Gigiena i Sunifariya. 1967, 32, 107-109. Arkhipova, G . P. Physical development of the rural population of Tambov province. Sovetskoe Zdravookhranenie, 1972. 31, 28--31. Ashcroft, M. T . , & Lovell, H. G. Heights and weights of Jamaican children of various racial origins. Tropical and Geographical Medicine, 1964, 4, 346-353. Ashcroft, M. T., Lovell, H. G . , George, M . , & Williams, A. Heights and weights of infants and children in a rural community of Jamaica. Journal of Tropical Pediatrics, 1965, 11, 5 6 4 8 . Backstrom, L., & Kantero, R.-L. Studies on growth of Finnish children from birth to ten years: 11. Cross-sectional studies of height and weight. Acta Paediatrica Scandinavica, Supplementurn, 1971, 220, 9-12. BakiEovi, Z . , & Sevfikova, A. Dynamika r a m mestskych a vidieckych deti od narodenia do troch rokov. Bratislavske L e E r s k Lisiy, 1973, 59, 84-94. Banik, N . D. D., Krishna, R . , Mane. S. I . S., & Raj, L. Longitudinal growth pattern of children during preschool age and its relationship with different socioeconomic classes. lndian Journal of Pediatrics, 1970, 37, 4 3 8 4 4 7 . (a) Banik, N. D. D., Krishna, R . , Mane, S . 1. S . , & Raj, L. A longitudinal study of physical growth of children of different birth weight groups from birth to 5 years. lndian Journal offediatrics, 1970, 37, 95-101. (b)
Standing Height o j Young Children
51
Banik, N. D. D., Krishna, R . , Mane, S . I. S . , Raj, L., & Taskar, A. D. A longitudinal study of physical growth of children from birth up to 5 years of age in Delhi. lndian Journal ofMedical Research, 1970, 58, 135-142. (c! Banik, N. D. D., Nayar, S . , Krishna, R.. & Raj, L. The effect of nutrition on growth of preschool children in different communities in Delhi. Indian Pediatrics, 1972, 9, 460-466. Barja, I . , LaFuente, M. E., Ballester, D., Monckeberg, F., & Donoso, G. Peso y talla de preescolares chilenos urbanos de tres niveles de vida. Revista Chilena de Pediarria, 1965, 36, 525-529. Beck, G . J., & van der Berg, B. J . The relationship of the rate of intrauterine growth of low-birthweight infants to later growth. Journal offediarrics, 1975, 86, 504-51 I . Belousov, A. Z . , Kardashenko, V. N.. Kondakova-Varlamova, L. P., Prokhorova, M. V., & Spromskaia, E. P. Dynamics of the physical development of children and adolescents in the city of Grel. Sovetskoe Zdravookhrunenie. 1968, 27, 25-28. Berry, F. B . Chile: Nutrition survey, 1960 (Report, Interdepartmental Committee on Nutrition for National Defense). Washington, D.C.: U.S.Government Printing Office, 1961. Berry, F . B. Kingdom of Thailand: Nurririon survey, 1960 (Report, Interdepartmental Committee on Nutrition for National Defense). Washington, D.C.: U . S . Government Printing Office, 1962. (a) 8erry, F. B. Republic of Lebanon: Nutrition survey. 1961 (Report, Interdepartmental Committee on Nutrition for National Defense). Wa\hington, D.C.: U . S . Government Printing Office, 1962. (b) Berry, F. B. West lndies (Trinidad, Tobago, St. Lucia, St. Christopher, Nevis, and Anguilla): Nurririon survey, 1961 (Report, 1nterdepartmen:al Committee on Nutrition for National Defense). Washington, D.C.: 1J.S. Government Printing Office, 1962. (c) Berry, F. B. Hashemite Kingdom of Jordan: Nirrririon survey, 1962 (Report, Interdepartmental Committee oil Nutrition for National Defense). Washington, D.C.: U.S. Government Printing Office, 1963. (a) Berry, F . B. Republic of Uruguay: Nutrition surve,y, 1962 (Report, Interdepartmental Committee on Nutrition for National Defense). Washington, D.C.: U . S . Government Printing Office, 1963. (b) Berry, F. B. Union of B u r m : Nutririon survey, 1961 (Report, Interdepartmental Committee on Nutrition for National Defense). Washington, D.C.: U.S. Government Printing Office, 1963. (Cf
Birkbeck, J . A , , Lee, M . , Myers, G . S . , & Alfred. B . M. Nutritional status of British Columbia Indians: 11. Anthropometric measureinents, physical and dental examinations at Ahousat and Anaham. Canadian Journal ojPublrc Health. 1971, 62, 4 0 3 4 1 4 . Blanca-Adrianzen, T . , Baertl, J . M . , & Graham, G. G. Growth of children from extremely poor families. American Journal of Clinicul Nuwitinn. 1973, 26, 926-930. Blanco, R. A., Acheson, R. M . , Canosa. C . , & Salomon, J . B. Height, weight, and lines of arrested growth in young Guatemalan children. American Journal of Physical Anthropology, 1974, 40, 3947. Boutourline, E., Tesi, G . , Kerr, G . I?.. Stare, F. J . , Kallal, Z., Turki, M., & Hemaidan, N. Nutritional correlates of child development i n southern Tunisia: I . Linear growth. Growth, 1972, 36, 4 0 7 4 2 4 . Burgess, H. J. L., Burgess, A., & Wheeler. E. F. Results and appraisal of a nutrition survey in Malawi. Tropical and Geographical Medicine, 1973, 25, 372-380. Bussadon, G. Valori anthropometrici ed auxologici di una popolazione infantile in alcuni comuni della provincia di Padova (Anno scolastico 1962-1963). Minerva Pediatrica, Monograph Series, 1965, pp. 122-127.
52
Howard V . Meredith
Centurion, C., Miranda, H., & Watkin, D. Republic of Paraguay: Nutrition survey, 1%5 (Report, United States National Center for Chronic Disease Control, Public Health Service). Washington, D.C.: U.S. Government Printing Office, 1967. Chase, H. P., Kumar, V., Dodds, J. M., Sauberlich, H. E., Hunter, R. M., Burton, R. S., & Spalding, V. Nutritional status of preschool Mexican-American migrant farm children. American Journal of Diseases of Children, 1971, 122, 3 16-324. Chen, M. L., Chiang, C. H., Huang, C. S . , & Chen, J. S. A study on the nutritional status and physical growth of Chinese childrem and young adults. Journal of Formosan Medical Association, 1974, 73, 374-386. Cherry, F. F. Growth from birth to five years of New Orleans underprivileged Negro children. Bulletin of the Tulane University Medical Faculty, 1%8, 24, 233-240. Chrzastek-Spruch, H., & Szajner-Milart, 1. Wskazniki rozwoju fizycznego dzieci i mJodziezy miasta lublina od 0 od 17 lat. Pediatria Polska, 1973, 48, 1495-1500. Collis, W . R. F., Dema, I., & Lesi, F. E. A. Transverse survey of health and nutrition, Pankshin Division, Northern Nigeria. West .4frican Medical Journal, 1962, 11, 131-154. Coy, J. F., Lewis, I. C., Mair, C. H., Longmore, E. A., & Ratkowsky, D. A. The growth of Tasmanian infants from birth to three years of age. Medical Journal of Australia, 1973, 2, 12-18. Cruise, M. 0. A longitudinal study of the growth of low birth weight infants: 1. Velocity and distance growth, birth to 3 years. Pediatrics, 1973, 51, 620428. Darby, W. J., & Edozien, J.Republic qfNigeria, Nutrition survey, 1965 (Report, Nutrition Section, Office of International Research, National Institutes of Health, United States Department of Health, Education, and Welfare). Washington, D.C.: U.S. Government Printing Office, 1967. Dattoli, A. Standards della statura a del peso dai 4 al 12 anni in bambini del gruppo etnico italiano di Bolzano. Rivista ltaliana di Medicina e Igiene della Scuola, 1%5, 11, 1 1 1-126. David, J. H. S. Height growth of melanodermic natives in northeastern Lunda (Angola). South African Journal of Medical Science. 1972, 37, 49-60. DeLuca, G., Bearzotti, L., & Cozzi, M. Valori auxologici medi normali del bambino friulano della Provincia di Udine. Minerva Pediatrica, Monograph Series, 1%5, pp. 209-210. Desai, P., Miall, W. E., & Standard, K. L. A five-year study of infant growth in rural Jamaica. Wesr lndies Medical Journal, 1969, 18, 210-221. Doornbos, L., Jonxis, J. H. P., & Visser, H. K. A. Growth of Bushnegro children on the Tapanahony River in Dutch Guyana. Humun Biology, 1968, 40, 396415. Dorozhnova, K. P. Shifts in physical development and changes of frame in preschool age children in connection with acceleration. Gigiena i Sanitariya. 1973, 38, 27-32. Drenhaus, U., Skrobak-Kacznski, J., c Jorgensen, J. 9 . Uber den sakularen trend der akzeleration bei gronlandischen Eskimos au!i dem nordlichen bezirk von Upernavik. Zeirschrifr fur Morphologie und Anthropologie, 1974, 65, 293-304. Dugdale, A. E., MacKay, D. A., Lim, R. K. H., & Notaney, K. H. Growth charts based on measurements of Malay preschool children. Medical Journal of Malaya, 1972, 27, 85-88. Eiben, O., Hegediis, G., Banhegyi, M., Kiss, K., Monda, M., & Tasnadi, 1. Budapest; ovodhsok es iskolasok resti fejlettskge (1968-1969). Budapest: Eotvos Lorand University, 1971. Eksmyr, R . Anthropometry in Ethiopi,an private school children. Nutrition and Metabolism. I97 1, 13, 7-20. Fernandez, N. A,, Burgos, J. C., Asernjo, C. F., & Rosa, 1. R . Nutrition survey of five rural Puerto Rican communities. Boletin de la Asociucion Medica de Puerto Rico, 1969, 61, 42-52. Fisk, S. C. Blackfeet Indian Reservation: Nutrition survey, 1961 (Report, Interdepartmental Committee on Nutrition for National Defense and Division of Indian Health, U.S. Public Health Service). Washington, D.C.: U S . Government Printing Office, 1964, (a)
Standing Height of Young Children
53
Fisk, S. C. Bolivia: Nutrition survey, 1%2 (Report, Interdepartmental Committee on Nutrition for National Defense). Washington, D.C.: U.S. Government Printing Office, 1964. (b) Fisk, S. C. Federation of Malaya: Nutrition survey, 1962 (Report, Interdepartmental Committee on Nutrition for National Defense). Washington, D.C.: US. Government Printing Office, 1964. (C) Fisk, S. C. Fort Belknap Indian Reservation: Nutrition survey, 1961 (Report, Interdepartmental Committee on Nutrition for National Defense and Division of Indian Health, U.S. Public Health Service). Washington, D.C.: U . S . Government Printing Office, 1964. (d) Fisk, S. C. Venezuela: Nutrition survey, 1963 (Report, Interdepartmental Committee on Nutrition for National Defense). Washington, D.C.: U.S. Government Printing Office, 1964. (e) Fisk, S. C. Northeast Brazil: Nutrition survey, I963 (Report, Interdepartmental Committee on Nutrition for National Defense). Washington, D.C.: U.S. Government Printing Office, 1965. Fitzhardinge, P. M . , & Steven, E. M. The small-for-date infant: 1. Later growth patterns. Pediatrics, 1972, 49, 671-681. Forbes, A. P., Ronaghy, H. A , , & Majd, M. Skeletal maturation of children in Shiraz, Iran. American Journal of Physical Anthropology. 197 1, 35, 449454. Franckx, H. Lengte en gewicht bij scholieren uit het kortrijkse. Archives Belges de Medecine Sociale, Hygiene, Medicine du Travail et Medecine Ligale, 1969, 27, 109-1 14. Frisancho, A. R., & Baker, P. T. Altitudeand growth: A study of the patterns of physical growth of a high altitude Peruvian Quechua population. American Journal of Physical Anthropology, 1970, 32, 219-292. Fryer, B. A,, Lamkin, G. H., Vivian, V. M., Eppright, E. S., & Fox, H. M. Growth of preschool children in the north central region. Journal ofthe American Dietetic Association, 1972, 60, 30-37. Gabrielli, G., Lucchetta, G., Chiurazzi, L., DiGiorgi, R., & Curri, P. Indagine auxologica sulla popolazione scolastica del comune di Roma: Nota I. Correlazione peso-statura in un campiore di 6,000 soggetti tra i 4 ed i 13 anni. Pediatria Internazionale, 1967, 17, 257-281. Garcia-Almansa, A . , Fernandez-Femandez, M. D., & Palacios-Mateos, J. M. Patrones de crecimiento de 10s nirios espafioles normales. Revista Clinica Espariola, 1969, 113, 4 5 4 8 . Gasto), B. Badania nad dynamizmen wzrastania dzieci wiejskich przedszkoli powiatu krakowskiego. Folia Medica Cracoviensia, 1966, 8, 191-210. Gerylovova, A , , & Bouchalova, M. The relation between children’s and parents’ heights in the age-range 0-6 years. Annals of Human Biology, 1974, 1, 229-232. Geubelle, F., Lambrechts, L., Sabatier, J., & Baltia, A. Poids et taille des enfants et adolescents sains de la province de Liege. Revue Medicale de Liege, 1974, 29, 582-590. Ghai, 0. P., & Sandhu, R. K. Study of physical growth of Indian children in Delhi. Indian Journal of Pediatrics, 1968, 35, 91-108. Ghosh, S., & Ben, S. Standard of prematurity for North Indian babies. Indian Journal of Child Health, 1962, 11, 210-215. Gokulanathan, K. S., & Verghese, K. P. Socio-cultural malnutrition: Growth failure in children due to socio-cultural factors. Journal of Tropical Pediatrics, 1969, 15, 118-124. Goldfeld, A . Y., Merkova, A. M., & Tseimlina, A. G. Materials on the physical development of children and adolescents in cities and rural localities of the U.S.S.R. Leningrad: Meditsina, 1965. Goldstein, H. Factors influencing the height of seven year old children: Results from the National Child Development Study. Human Biology, 1971, 43, 92-1 11. Guzman, M. A., Scrimshaw, N. S., Bruch, H. A , , & Gordon, J. E. Nutrition and infection field study in Guatemalan villages, 1959-1964: VII. Physical growth and development of preschool children. Archives of Environmental Health, 1968, 17, 107-1 18.
54
Howard V . Meredith
Harvey, R. G . An anthropometric study of growth and physique of the populations of Karkar Island and Lufa subdistrict, New Guinea. Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society of London, Series B , 1974, 268, 279-292. Hawley, T. G., & Jansen, A. A. J. Height and weight of Fijians in coastal areas from one year till adulthood. New Zealand Medical Journal, 197 1 , 73, 346-349. Heller, C. A., Scott, E. M., & Harmnes, L . M. Height, weight, and growth of Alaskan Eskimos. American Journal of Diseases ojChildren, 1967, 113, 338-344. Hernandez, L. E. Crecimiento y desarrollo normal de nifio pobre dominicano. Boletin de la Oficina Sanitaria Panamericana, 1966, 61, 27-39. Hiernaux, J., & Asnes, D. Le croissance des enfants Sara de 3 a 10 ans a Fort-Archambauh (Republique du Tchad). Bulletin et MPmoih de Soc dAnthropologie de Paris, 1974, 13, 427453. Holibkova, A , , & Holibka, V. Die korperliche entwicklung der kinder der Olomoucer landlichen. Acta Universitatis Palackianae Olomucensis Facultatis Medicae, 1968, 51, 127-138. Hopkins, J. W. Height and weight of Ottawa elementary school children of two socioeconomic strata. Human Biology, 1947, 19, 68-82. Indian Council of Medical Research. Growth and physical development of Indian infants and children: All India. New Delhi: Stalistics Division of Indian Council of Medical Research, 1968. Janes, M. D. Physical growth of Nigerian Yoruba children. Tropical and Geographical Medicine. 1974, 26, 389-398. Jones, D. L., & Hemphill, W. Height. weight and other physical characteristics of New South Wales children. Part 2 . Children underfive years of age. Sydney: Health Commission of New South Wales, 1974. Jones, D. L., Hemphill, W., & Meyers, E. S . A. Height, weighiand otherphysical characteristics of New South Wales children. Part 1 , Children age 5 years and over. Sydney: New South Wales Department of Health, 1973. Jordan, T. E., & Spaner, S . D. Biological and ecological influences on development at 24 and 36 months of age. Psychological Reports, 1972, 31, 319-332. Jordan, T. E., & Spaner, S . D. Biological and ecological influences on development at 48 and 60 months of age. Psychological Reports, 1974, 34, 119-126. Kaganovich, D. I . , Kraeba, N. A , , & Bogachanov, N. D. Physical development and hemoglobin level in children living i n Kemerovo age 1-7 years. Pediatrya (Moscow), 1966, 45, 81-82. Kambara, T. Studies on growth and nutritional intake of school children in Kagawa Prefecture: Regional differences in growth. Shikoku Igaku Zasshi, 1969, 25, 570-582. Kettle, E. S. Weight and height curves for Australian Aborigines infants and children. Medical Journal of Australia, 1966, 1, 972-971. Khanjanasthiti, P., Supachaturas, P., Mekanandha, P., Srimusikapodh, V.. Choopanya, K., & Leesuwan, V. Growth of infants and preschool children. Journal of the Medical Association of Thailand, 1973, 56, 88-100. Khurana, V., Agarwal, K. N., Manwani, A. H., & Srivastava, G . Physical growth in first five years. Indian Pediatrics, 1971, 8, 331 -335. Kimura, K., & Tsai, C. M. Comparative studies of the physical growth in Formosans: I . Height and weight. Zinruigaku Zassi, 1967, 75, 11-18. Kogan, R. B. Assessing the high level of physical development of young children. Zdravookhranenie Rossiiskoi Federatsii, 1969, 13, 29-32. Kozhonazarov, K. K. Physical development of children in nursery schools of the town of DzhalalAbad in the Oshsk region. Sovei'skoe Zdravookhranenie Kirgizi!, 1966, 6 , 18-22. Kravchenko, A. G. Physical development of rural children 3 to 7 years old in the Odessa district. Sovetskoe Zdravookhranenie. 1968, 27, 33-39.
Standing Height of Young Children
55
Kreysler, J . , & Schlage, C. The nutrition situation in the Pangani basin. In H. Kraut & H. D. Cremer (Eds.) lnvestigatiom into health and nutrition in East Africa. Miinchen: Weltforum Verlag, 1969, 85-178. & Syrovatka, A. NEkteradatao &tu skupiny dEti piedsikolKubat, K., Novakova, M., Kouiim, .I., niho vtku dlouhodobc sledovant. Ceskoslovenska Pediatrie, 1969, 24, 256-263. Kudaiarov, D. K. Principal indices of physical development of children 3 to 7 years old Permanent inhabitants of high mountainous (Naryr) and low mountainous (Frunze) regions of Kirghizia. Sovetskoe Zdravookhranenie Kirgizii, 1966, 6, 12-15. Kumiewicz-Witczakowa, R., Miqsowicz, I . , Mazurczak, T. Evaluation of certain features of somatic development of Warsaw children aged up to 6.5 years using centile grades and tables. Pediatria Polska, 1974, 49, 427437. Kurniewicz-Witczakowa, R., Miqsowicz, I . , Mazurczak, T., & Eska, H. J. Wskatniki rozwoju fizycznego dzieci warszawskich od 0 do 36 miesiaca tycia. Problemy Medycyny Wieku Rozwojowego, 1973, 3, 99-1 17. Kutsenko, V. V. Some indices of the physical development of Ivano-Frankovsk kindergarten children. Pediatrya (Moscow), 1965, 44,81-82. Kuz’min, E. M. Physical development of kindergarten pupils of Petrozavodsk. Gigiena i Sanitariya, 1970, 35, 105-107. Lapitskii, F. G., Belogorskii, V . Y., Nemzer, M. P., Pogorely, I. A , , Sinopalnikov, 0. V . , & Zolotareva, M. P. Basic indices of physical development of children in the second and third years in Murmansk. Zdravookhranenie Rossiiskoi Federarsii. 1970, 14, 28-3 I . Lapitskii, F. G., Belogorskii. V. Y . , Nemzer, M. P . , & Zolotareva, M. P. Physical development of children in nursery schools of Murmansk (transpolar region). Pedidrya (Moscow), 1967, 46, 62-63. Limaye, C . , Chouhan, C. N., Lakhani, S . M . , & Phadke, M. V . Optimal growth standards from Poona. Indian Pediatrics, 1974, 11, 673476. LOW,W. D. Stature and body weight of southern Chinese children. Zeirschrft fur Morphologie und Anthropologie, 1971, 63, 1 1 4 5 . Luna-Jaspe, H., Ariza, J., Rueda-Williamson, R., Mora, J . O . , & Pardo, F. Estudio seccional de crecimiento, desarrollo y nutricion en 12,138 nifios de Bogota, Colombia: 11. El crecimiento de niiios de dos clases socioeconomicas durante sus primeros seis aiios de vide. Archivos LatinoArnericanos de Nutricidn, 1970, 20, 151-165. Luyken, R., & Luyken-Koning, F. W. M. Studies on the physiology of nutrition in Surinam: 1X. Somatometrical data. Documenfa de Medicina Geographica et Tropica, 1961, 13, 123-130. Madhavan, S . , Susheela, T. P . , & Swaminathan. M. C. Association of growth status and the prevalence of nutritional deficiency signs among preschool children. Indian Journal qf Medical Research, 1967, 55, 497-503. Malcolm, L. A. Growth and development of the Bundi child of the New Guinea highlands. Human Biology, 1970, 42, 293-328. Martirosian, R. B. Physical development of preschool and school children of rural regions of the Komi A . S . S . R. Zdravookhranenie Rossiiskoi Federatsii, 1973, 17, 25-26. Marzot, G., Colombini, M., & Vedovello, R. Studio statistico sulla variabilita della statura e del peso in soggetti della Val de Fiemme (provincia de Trento). Clinica Pediarrica (Bologna), 1966, 48, 219-228. Matawaran, A. J . , & Gervasio, C. C. Average heights and weights of Filipinos. Philippine Journal of Nutrition, 1971, 24, 74-92. Matawaran, A. J . , Gervasio, C. C., & de Gala, A. B. Preliminary report on the average height and weight of some Filipinos. Philippine Journal of Nutrition. 1966, 19, 2 9 4 9 . McGanity, W. J . Nutrition survey in Texas. Texas Medicine, 1969, 65, 40-49.
56
Howard V . Meredith
McGregor, I. A,, Rahman, A. K., Thompson, B., Billewicz, W. Z., & Thornson, A. M. The growth of young children in a Gambian village. Transactions of the Royal Society of Tropical Medicine and Hygiene, 1968, 62, 341-352. McKay, D. A,, Lim, R. K. H., Notaney, K. H., & Dugdale, A. E. Nutritional assessment by comparative growth achievement in Malay children below school age. Bulletin of the World Health Organization. 197 1, 45, 233-342. Menzies, F. Report on the average heights and weights of elementary school children in the County of London in 1938. London: London County Council, 1940. Meredith, H. V. Birth order and body size: 11. Neonatal and childhood materials. American Journal of Physical Anthropology. 1950, 8 , 195-224. Meredith, H. V. Relation between socioeconomic status and body size in boys seven to ten years of age. American Journal of Diseases of Children, 1951, 82, 702-709. Meredith, H. V. Methods of studying physical growth. In P. H. Mussen (Ed.),Handbookof research methods in child development. New York Wiley, 1960. Meredith, H. V. Body weight at birth of viable human infants: A worldwide comparative treatise. Human Biology, 1970, 42, 217 -264. Meredith, H. V. Relation between tobacco smoking of pregnant women and body size of their progeny: A compilation and synthesis of studies. Human Biology, 1975, 47, 451472. Miqsowicz, I. Porowanie rozwoju fizycnego dzieci i dodziety z trzech r6tnych Srodowisk miejskich. Prace i Muteriab Nlzukowe, 1964, 2, 125-137. Miqsowicz, I., & Pytuk, M. Rozwtjj fizyczny dzieci nowotarskich i helskich. Prace i Materialy Naukowe, 1967, 10, 19-32. Migasena, P., Thumham, D. I . , Pongpaew, P., Hongthong, K . , & Harinasuta, C. Anthropometric studies in preschool children of northeast Thailand. Journal of Nutritional Science and Vitaminology, 1974, 20, 127-132. Miller, F. J . W., Court, S. D. M., Walton, W. S., & Knox, E. G . Growing up in Newcusde-uponTyne. London: Oxford University Press, 1960. Mohanta, K. D., Pande, T. H., & Praharaj, K. C. Anthropometric measurements of children of western Orissa. Indian Journal of Pediatrics, 1972, 39, 12-14. Montoya, C . , & Ipinza, M. Peso y es(.aturade pre-escolares santiaguinos pertenecientes a dos estratos sociales diferentes. Revista Chilena de Pediatria, 1964, 35, 269-277. Morley, D. C., Woodland, M., Martin, W. J., & Allen, I. Heights and weights of West African village children from birth to the age of five. West African Medical Journal, 1%8, 27, 8-13. Mortison, J. Low birth weight study: Height and weight tables and charts. Systems Development Project, Study Series, 1969, 9/3(4a). Nekisheva, Z. I. Effect of certain social factors on the physical development of preschool children attending kindergartens. Gigiena i Sanitariya, 1974, 2, 58-61, Neumann, C. G., Shanker, H., & Uberoi, I. S. Nutritional and anthropometric profile of young rural Punjabi children. Indian Journal of Medical Research, 1969, 57, 1122-1 149. Neyzi, 0. Somatik gelizme indekslerinin tatbiki degeri. Haseki Tip Bulteni, 1967, 5, 1 4 1 . Neyzi, O., & Gurson, C. T. Physical measurements on two groups of Istanbul children: Normal and undernourished. Stockholm: Swedish Medical Research Counsil, 1966. Neyzi, O., Tanman, F., & Saner, G. Preliminary results of a child health survey in an underdeveloped area of Istanbul. Mimeographed report, 1965. Nouth-Savoeun, Confriburion a I'itude de la croissance physique des enfants cambodgiens de la naissance u 14 ans. Unpublished M.D. thesis, Universite Royale de Phnom-Penh, 1966. O'Brien, R., Girshick, M. A,, & Hunt, E. P. Body measurements of American boys and girls for garment and pattern construction (Bureau of Home Economics, United States Department of Agriculture, Publ. No. 366). Washington, D.C.: U.S. Government Printing Office, 1941.
Standing Height of Young Children
57
Oehmisch, W. Die enwicklung der korpermusse bei kindern und jugendlichen in der Deutschen Demokratischen Republik: Ergebnisse einer reprasentativen untersuchung in den jahren I9671 1968. Berlin: Deutschen Akademie fur Arztliche Fortbildung, 1970. Omran, A. R., McEwen, W. J . , & Zaki, M. H. Epidetniological studies in Bolivia. New York: Research Institute for the Study of Man, 1967. Oppers, V . M. Groeidiagrammen van amsterdamse kinderen. Op Grond van Cijfers, 1964, 2, 5 1 4 5 . Owen, G. M., Kram, K. M., Gamy, P. J . , Lowe, J. E . , & Lubin, A. H. A study of nutritional status of preschool children in the United States, 1968-1970. Pediatrics, 1974, 53, 597-648. (Supplement) Owen, G. M., & Lubin, A. H. Anthroponietric differences between Black and White preschool children. American Journal of Diseuses of Children. 1973, 126, 168-169. Palacios, J . M., & Vivanco, F. Datos de talla y peso de 128,000 nifios espafioles. Revista Clinica Espariola, 1965, 99, 230-238. Palacios-Mateos, J . M., Garcia-Almansa, A,, Vivanco, F., Fernandez, M. D., Garcia-Robles, R., & Moreno-Estaban, B. El crecimiento de 10s niiios espaiioles desde el nacimiento hasta 10s cinco aiios. Revista de Sanidud e Higiene Publicu, 1972, 46, 1093-1 105. Pereira, S. M. Growth and development of children in underprivileged communities, Tamil Nadu. Indian Journal of Medical Research, 197 I , 59, 156-163. (Supplement) Phadke, M. V., & Kulkarni, H. D . Growth and development in the underprivileged sections of the Bombay area. Indian Journal of Medical Research, 1971, 59, 164-176. (Supplement) Phadke, M. V., Deodhar, N. S . , & Kulkarni, H. D . The rural preschool child-his growth and nutritional status. Indian Journal of Medical Research, 197 I , 59, 748-755. Pire, E., & Meli, G. Rilevazioni auxologiche sulla popolazione scolastica della citta di Bari. Revista ltaliana de Medicina e Igiene della Sruola. 1962, 8, 307-318. Pokatilo, V. M. Dynamics of the physical development and physical training of kindergarten children. Gigiena i Sanitariya, 1974, 12, 93-94. Prasad, R., Kumar, R., & Dayal, R. S. Physical growth and development from one to five years. Indian Pediatrics, 1971, 8, 105-1 19. PyEuk, M., & Wolanski, N. Niektore wJasciwosci fizjologiczne dzieci i d o d z i e f y jako wynik adaptacji do rotaych warunkow Srodowiskowych: Doniesienie 11. Prace i Materialy Naukowe, 1968, 11, 129-151. Rao, N. P., Singh, D., & Swaminathan, M. C. Nutritional status of preschool children of rural communities near Hyderabad City. Indian Journal of Medical Research, 1969, 57, 2132-2146. Rea, J. N. Social and economic influences on the growth of preschool children in Lagos. Human Biology, 1971, 43, 4 6 4 3 . Richardson, B. D. Growth standards: An appraisal with special reference to growth in South African Bantu and White preschool children. South African Medical Journal, 1973, 47, 699-702. (Supplement) Roche, A. J . , & Davila, G. H. Differences between recumbent length and stature within individuals. Growth, 1974, 38, 313-320. Rosenberg, I . H . , & Reiner, M. L . Nutrition survey of E m Pakistan (Report, Ministry of Health, Government of Pakistan, with University of Dacca and Nutrition Section, Office of International Research, National Institutes of Health, United States Department of Health, Education, and Welfare). Washington, D.C.: U.S. Government Printing Office, 1966. Rueda-Williamson, R., Luna-Jaspe, H . , Ariza, J., Pardo, F., & Mora, J. 0. Estudio seccional de crecimiento, desarrollo y nutricion en 12,138 niiios de Bogoti, Colombia. Sociedad Colombiana de Pediarria y Puericultura, 1969, 10, 335-339. Rutishauser, 1. H. E. Heights and weights of middle class Baganda children. Lancet, 1965, ii, 565-567.
58
Howard V . Meredith
Scott, J. A. Report on the heights and weights of school pupils in the County of London in 1959. London: London County Council, 1961. Scrimshaw, N. S . , Guzman, M. A , , Kevany, J. J., Ascoli, W., Bruch, H. A,, & Gordon, J. E. Nutrition and infection field s.tudy in Guatemalan villages, 1959-1964. Archives of Environmental Health, 1967, 14, 787-801. SempC, P., SempC, M., & P d r o n , G. Croissance et maturation osseuse. Paris: Theraplix, 1972. Sharma, J. C. Physical growth and development of fhe Maharastrians, Lucknow: Ethnographic and Folk Culture Society, 1970. Shakir, A,, & Zaini, S. Skeletal niaturation of the hand and wrist of young children in Baghdad. Annals of Human Biology, 1974, 1, 189-199. Shattock, F. M. Heights and weights in a Javanese labour population of a north Sumatran rubber estate. Tropical and Geographical Medicine. 1968, 20, 147-158. Shiddhaye, S., Shah, P. M., & Udani, P. M. Physical growth and development of pre-term children during the first five years of life: Longitudinal study. Indian Pediatrics, 1972, 9, 282-289. Smith, D. S . , & Brown, M. L. Anthropometry in preschool children in Hawaii. American Journal of Clinical Nutrition, 1970, 23, 932-939. (a) Smith, D. S . , & Brown, M. L. Growth measures of a selected group of preschool children in Honolulu. Hawaii Medical Journal, 1970, 29, 375-377. (b) Spranger, J., Ochsenfarth, A,, Kock, H. P., & Henke, J. Anthropometrische normdaten im kindesalter . Zeitschrift fur Kinderheilkunde, 1968, 103, 1 - 12. Standard, K. L., Desai, P., & Miall, W. E. A longitudinal study of child growth in a rural community in Jamaica. Journal ofBiosocia1 Science, 1969, 1, 153-176. Stracker, 0. A. Korpermasse der kinder und jugendlichen im jahre 1962. dsterreichische Arztezeitung, 1%3, 18, 1-24, Swaak, A. J. Een onderzoek bij 125 kinderen met het syndroom van Langdon Down (mongoloidisme). Nederlands Tddschrift voor Geneeskunde, 1967, 111, I 10-120. Swaminathan, M. C., Jyothi, K. K . , Singh, R., Madhaven, S . , & Gopalan, C. A semi-longitudinal study of growth of Indian children and the related factors. Indian Pediatrics, 1964, 1, 255-263. Systems Development Project Staff. Height and weight charts and tables on poverty area children. Systems Development Project, Study Series. 1968, 819. Sukkar, M. Y., Johnson, D., Gadir, A. M. A,, & Yousif, M. K . The nutritional status of children in rural Khartoum. Sudan Mediral Journal, 1971, 9, 23-38. Taback, M .Birth weight and lenglh of gestation with relation to prematurity. Journal of rhe American Medical Association. 1951, 146, 897-901. Tinisescu, G., Chiriac, I . . Stinciulescu, E., Domi!escu, M., & Jelezneac, I . Nivelul dezvolt2rii fizice a copiilor de 0-3 ani din republica socialists romlnia. Pediatrirr (Bucharest), 1970, 19, 97-108. Tanner, J . M., Whitehouse, R. H., & Takaishi, M. Height, weight, height velocity, weight velocity: British children, 1965. Archives of Disease in Childhood, 1966, 41, 454-471, 613-635. Tatafiore, E. Indagini auxologiche sull’accelerazione dell’acaescimento e sulla statura definitiva. Minerva Pediatrica. Monograph Series, 1965, pp. 69-72. Terrosi, F. lndagine auxometrica nel bambino della provincia di grosseto. Archivio Italiano di Pediatria e Puericulrura, 1968, 26, 148-160. Thomson, A. M., Billewicz, W. Z . , Thompson, B., Illsley, R., Rahman, A. K . , & McGregor, I. A. A study of growth and health of young children in tropical Africa. Transacrions ofthe Royal Society of Tropical Medicine and Hygiene, 1968, 62, 333-340. Tie, L. T., Lian, 0. K., Liong-Chg, T. W., & Rose, C. S. Health, development, and nutritional survey of preschool children in central Java. American Journal of Clinical Nutrition, 1967, 20, 1260-1 266.
Standing Height oJ Young Children
59
Tonelli, E. Studio statistic0 sulla variabilita della statura e del peso nei soggetti emiliani di eta compresa fra 1 e 14 anni. Giornale di Igiene e Medicina Preventiva, 1963, 1, 3-17. Tuxford, A. W., & Glegg, R. A. The average height and weight of English school children. British Medical Journal, 191 I , 1, 1423-1424. Twiesselrnann, F. Diveloppement biometrique de l'enfant a I'adulre. Brussels: Presses Universitaires de Bruxelles, 1969. Udani, P. M. Physical growth of children in different socioeconomic groups in Bombay. Indian Journal of Child Health, 1963, 12, 593-6 I 1 . United States Center for Disease Control. Ten-State nutrition survey, 1968-1970. 111. Clinical, anrhropometry. dental (United States Department of Health, Education, and Welfare, Publ. No. HSM-72-8131). Washington, D.C.: U.S. Government Printing Office, 1972. Van der Kuyp, E. Body weights and heights of the Surinam people. Voeding, 1967, 28, 435469. van Wieringen, J . C. Seculaire groeiverschuiving: Lengte en gewicht surveys 1964-I966 in Nederland in historisch perspectief. Leiden: Netherlands Instituut voor Praeventieve Geneeskunde TNO, 1972. Verghese, K. P., Scott, R . B . , Teixeira, G . , & Ferguson, A. D . Studies in growth and development: XII. Physical growth of North American Negro children. Pediatrics, 1969, 44, 243-247. Vesi, G., & Cantalini, C. Indagine auxologica sul bambino aquilano della scuola matema (dal3" al6" anno di vita). Minerva Pediatrica, 1972, 24, 223-237. Vis, H. L. Protein deficiency disorders. Postgraduate Medical Journal, 1969, 45, 107-1 15. Vizzoni, L., & Baldini, G. lndagine statistica sulle alterazion dell'accrescimento del bambino della province di Pisa. Rivista di Clinica Pediatrica, 1964, 73, 185-198. Wark, L., & Malcolm, L. A. Growth and development of !he Luni child in the Sepik District of New Guinea. Medical Journal of Australia, 1969, 2, 129-136. Weisman, S. A. Contour of the chest in children: Environment. American Journal of Diseases of Children, 1935, 49, 52-59. Wilson, R . S . Growth standards for twins from birth to four years. Annals of Human Biology, 1974. 1, 175-188. Wingerd, J., & Schoen, E. J . Factors influencing length at birth and height at five years. Pediatrics. 1974, 53, 737-741. Wolanski, N. Ocena rozwoju fizycznego dziecka w wieku do trzech lat. Prace i Muterialy Naukowe, 1964, 2, 95-124. Wolanski, N., & PyBuk, M. (Eds.). Studies in human ecology. Warsaw: Polish Academy of Sciences, 1973. Wong, H. B., Tye, C . Y., & Quek, K. M. Anthropometric studies on Singapore children: I . Heights, weights and skull circumference on preschool children. Journal of the Singapore Paediatric Sociezy, 1972, 14, 68-89. Woodbury, R . M. Statures and weights of children under six years of age (United States Children's Bureau, Publ. No. 87, United States Department of Labor). Washington, D.C.: U.S. Govemment Printing Office, 1921. Yarbrough, C., Habicht, J.-P., Malina, R . , Lechtig, A , , & Klein, R . E. Length and weight in rural Guatemalan Ladino children: Birth to seven years of age. American Journal of Physical Anthropology, 1975, 42, 439447. Zauli-Naldi, G. Dati auxologici normali del bambino dai 3 ai 12 anni della provincia di teramo. Aggiornamento Pediarrico, 1963, 18, 69-75. Zhaglina, A. K. Anthropometric and hemodynamic indices of preschool children. Gigiena i Sanitariya, 1974, 2, 108-109.
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
THE REPRESENTATION OF CHILDREN’S KNOWLEDGE
David Klahr and Robert S . Siegler CARNEGIE-MELLON UNIVERSITY
I . INTRODUCTION
....
62
I1 . FROM BEHAVIORAL TO COGNITIVE OBJECTIVES . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
63
III . SOME CRITERIA FOR CHOOSING A REPRESENTATION . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
64
IV . BALANCE SCALE TASK . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . A . REPRESENTATION OF CHILDREN’S KNOWLEDGE ABOUT THE BALANCE SCALE . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . B . ASSESSING THE ACCURACY OF THE REPRESENTATIONS . . . .
66 67 68
V . EXPERIMENT I: ASSESSING INITIAL KNOWLEDGE . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . A . METHOD . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . B . RESULTS . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . C . EVALUATION OF DECISION TREE REPRESENTATION . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
13
VI . EXPERIMENT 2: TRAINING ON THE BALANCE SCALE TASK . . . . . A . METHOD . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . B . RESULTS . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
74 74 76
69 70 71
VII . REVISED REPRESENTATIONS FOR BALANCE SCALE KNOWLEDGE . . . . . . A . PRODUCTION SYSTEM REPRESENTATION ..................... . . . . B . EVALUATION OF THE PRODUCTION SYSTEM REPRESENTATION C . PROTOCOL ANALYSIS . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . D . REVISED PRODUCTION SYSTEM FOR A MODEL nr CHILD . . . . . . E. PRODUCTION SYSTEM FOR MODEL IlIA ....................... F . PRODUCTION SYSTEM INTERPRETATION ...................... G . EVALUATION OF REPRESENTATIONS FOR JAN’S KNOWLEDGE . . . . .
11 77 81 82 85 89 89
VIII . EXPERIMENT 3: ENCODING HYPOTHESIS . . . . . . . . . . . . I. . . . . . . .... A . RECONSTRUCTION PARADIGM . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .... B . SUMMARY . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
95 96
94
101
61
62
David Klahr and Robert S . Siegler
IX. DISCUSSION: SOME ANSWERS AND SOME FURTHER QUESTIONS . . . . . . . A. WHERE WE HAVE BEEN . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . B. WHERE WE ARE GOING . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
102 102
103
X. CONCLUSION . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
105
APPENDIX A . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
106
APPENDIX B . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
110
REFERENCES . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
113
I.
Introduction
In this chapter we will discuss two related issues. One issue concerns the ways that children from 5 to 17 years perform a scientific induction task. We will summarize a series of experiments designed to investigate questions about initial knowledge, instructional effectiveness, and individual differences in both initial performance and responsiveness to instruction. The second issue is methodological: its focus is not on what we can say about children’s knowledge of a task, but rather on how we can say it. That is, the second issue we will address is the representation of children’s knowledge. The two issues are related simply because the researcher’s decision about how to represent knowledge plays a central role in guiding both the kind of theory that gets formulated and the kind of experiment that gets run. We have found this to be the case in our own studies, and we believe that it might be worthwhile to direct attention to some properties of different representations and criteria for choosing among them. Our discussion will move back and forth between general conceptual issues and some very specific examples of both empirical techniques and theoretical statements. We will start by describing the historical trend in instructional psychology that has made the representation of knowledge a central issue, and then we introduce criteria that we believe might be useful in choosing and evaluating different representations. In addition to a set of evaluative criteria, we will list five central questions for research in developmental and instructional psychology. Next we will introduce a specific task that has interesting psychological and instructional properties: a variant of Piaget’s balance scale problem. We will present a formal model-using a particular representation-for different levels of knowledge that children might have about how to do the task. The task will provide the concrete reference for the rest of our chapter.
The Representation of Children’s Knowledge
63
Having described the formal properties of the task, and some predictions about the performance of different aged children on it, we will then describe our first experiment. Based upon the results of the experiment, we will evaluate the initial hypotheses, as well as examine the merits and limitations of the representation in which the initial models are stated. The initial representation and the associated experiment enable us to make certain predictions about the effects of an instructional sequence. In the second experiment we will explore some instructional issues, and this in turn will reveal some limitations of the initial representation. In particular, we find that older and younger children who are initially classified by our models as having identical task-specific knowledge show a striking differential responsiveness to instruction. This presents a serious challenge to our initial representation of children’s knowledge. It is clear that the initial formulation does not tell the whole story about differences in task-specific knowledge. A revised representation of the knowledge required to perform at different levels is introduced. The representation is a production system and some of the general properties of production systems are discussed. Then we will present an analysis of the problem-by-problem performance of two children during a training sequence, and formulate a more detailed production system model of the knowledge of one of them. The model is actually run as a computer simulation and its results are compared with the child’s performance. This fine-grained analysis suggests that the initial encoding of the stimulus may be a crucial difference between older and younger children, and that this may account for the results of Experiment 2. This encoding hypothesis states that differential responsiveness to training between 5- and 8-year-old children is due to differences in the way they encode the balance scale dimensions. The explanatory power of the hypothesis is illustrated in detail in Experiment 3. Finally, we will summarize the preceding discussion in terms of how well it answers our initial set of questions. Then we will briefly discuss the several types and levels of knowledge that might be important in instructional investigation. Different levels of aggregation of both model and data are obviously appropriate for different scientific questions. The direct and explicit consideration of some ways to represent knowledge will provide useful guidelines for further empirical work.
11. From Behavioral to Cognitive Objectives The goal of any instructional effort is the production of new knowledge in the learner. Over the last 15 years of instructional research there has been an increasing emphasis on stating such goals as clearly as possible. The trend was to move
64
David Klahr and Robert S . Siegler
from an emphasis on simply describing educational means-the sequence of instructional activities-to a prior statement of the desired ends of instruction. The elaboration of behavioral objectives was perhaps the most extensive formalization of this trend (Mager, 1962). Behaviors were typically specified in great detail, although the underlying processes were not. However, even behavioral objectives have implicit in them an underlying cognitive theory: Behavior is simply an observable indicator of underlying cognitive processes. One well-known normative model for instruction (Glaser, 1968) stresses the need to determine the learner’s initial state as well as the desired end state. In the original formulations of this approach, both initial and final learner states were described primarily in terms of tasks and subtasks arranged in a Gagne-like hierarchy. There was little mention of how one might characterize the underlying psychological processes that acted upon them to produce the task behavior in question. As that approach has developed, however, it has focused increasingly upon such cognitive representations (see Resnick, 1976, for a summary of this trend in the area of elementary mathematics instruction). Perhaps the strongest statement of the desirability and feasibility of describing the learner in terms of internal psychological representations is Greeno’s view of “cognitive objectives.” Greeno ( 1976) argued that cognitive psychology has now developed powerful and flexible methods for the representation of knowledge. Using an example from instruction in elementary fractions, Greeno showed how two different views of the conceptual content of the subject matter can be represented explicitly by two quite distinct cognitive structures, which in turn lead to differential predictions about problem difficulty, problem-solving strategies, and optimal procedures for instruction. Without such a representation, these predictions might never have been made. This is essentially the same point stressed by Klahr and Wallace (1976) with respect to the need for explicit and precise models in cognitive development: “A theory of transition can be no better than the associated theory of what it is that is undergoing that transition” (p. 14). According to this view, the first step in the formulation of developmental theories is the creation of a precise model of the initial and final form of the cognitive process under investigation. Studies by Baylor and Gascon (1974), Young (1973), Klahr and Wallace (1976), and several others, summarized in Siegler (1978), provide developmental models of this type.
111. Some Criteria for Choosing a Representation What considerations might guide us in the choice of a representation? What kinds of representations are available, and what are their relative merits? Knowledge representation has become an important topic in the emerging field of
The Representution o j Children’s Knowledge
65
“cognitive science” (Bobrow & Collins, 1975), and some initial attempts to address it can be found in Bobrow ( 1975), Becker ( 1975), Moore and Newell (1974), and Reddy and Newell (1974). These efforts constitute the first steps toward a full-fledged theory of representation, and they have already yielded a reasonable set of dimensions with which to characterize different representations. Although such taxonomic systems allow us to classify representations, they do not make any statements about their relative merits. Regardless of the final location of a representation along the dimensions of importance, the ultimate evaluation of the quality of a representation depends upon the set of questions being addressed. We believe that in the area of instruction and development the important questions are: Question 1: What are the differences in knowledge that underlie different levels of task performance? Question 2: What are the alternative strategies that might result in any given level of task performance? Question 3: For a given level of performance, what is the optimal level of difficulty for an instructional sequence? Question 4: What are the critical features of an instructional sequence that enable it to have any effect? Question 5: When and why will two learners at the same initial performance level learn differently from the same instructional sequence? Or, to summarize our concerns: What do children know about a task, how do they learn about it, and why do some know more and/or learn more than others? Given this set of questions, there are four criteria that we believe to be most important in choosing a representation: 1. The representation must be sufficient to account for behavior. Thus, it must have a clear mapping onto the empirical base it is supposed to account for. 2. It should be amenable to multiple-level analyses. That is, it should be easy to aggregate and disaggregate the grain of explanation. For the design of wellcontrolled experiments or curriculum design, the representation will have to be stated in terms of averages across many subjects; it must be a modal form. For detailed study of individual strategies and component processes, it must be capable of disaggregation without drastic revision. 3. The representation should conform to the relevant properties of the human information-processing system as determined by laboratory studies of human processing capacities. 4. The representation should have “developmental tractability” (Klahr & Wallace, 1970). It should allow us to state both early and later forms of competence and provide an easy interpretation of each model as both a precursor and successor of other models in a developmental sequence (see Resnick, 1976, for a similar viewpoint).
66
David Klahr and Robert S. Siegler
IV. Balance Scale Task The type of balance scale used throughout our investigation consisted of a two-arm balance, with several pegs located at equal intervals along each arm. Small circular disks, all of equal weight, were placed on the pegs in various configurations (as shown in Table I), while the balance was prevented from tipping. The subjects’ basic task was to predict the direction in which the balance scale would move if it were allowed to. In order to answer some of the questions listed above, several variations on this basic theme were introduced. These included: asking children to explain their predictions; allowing the scale to move to its equilibrium position (thus providing feedback about the accuracy of the predictions); observing an experimenter-controlled series of configurations and their effects; constructing one’s own configurations; and reconstructing initial configurations from memory. (A more complete report of these experiments is presented in Siegler, 1976.) The basic physical concept that underlies the operation of the balance scale is torque: The scale will rotate in the direction of the greater of the two torques acting on its arms. The total torque on each arm is determined by summing the individual torques produced by the weights on the pegs, and the individual torques are in turn computed by multiplying each weight by its distance from the fulcrum. Since the pegs are at equal intervals from the fulcrum, and the weights are all equal, a simpler calculation is possible. It consists of computing the sum of the products of number of weights on a peg times the ordinal position of the peg from the fulcrum. This is done for each side, and the side with the greater sum of products is the side that will go down. (If they are equal, the scale will balance .) The components of this knowledge are acquired over a remarkably long span of experience and education; even 5-year-olds often know that balances such as teeter-totters tend to fall toward the side with more weight, while many 16-yearolds do not know the appropriate arithmetic computations for determining the balance’s behavior (Jackson., 1965; Lee, 1971; Lovell, 1961). It even seems likely that most college-educated adults could not easily state the physical principles that underlie the sum-of-products algorithm. Furthermore, for many configurations, there are shortcuts that eliminate the need to do any arithmetic computation (e.g., identical configurations on each arm will balance; if both weight and distance are greater on one side, that side will go down). Note that the balance scale task shares a common property of many scientific problems: The universal rule for generating correct predictions is easy to describe, and once known, it is easily remembered and executed. However, the formulation of the rul-ither by induction from empirical examples or by deduction from general physical principles-is quite difficult.
67
The Representation of Children’s Knowledge
A.
REPRESENTATION OF CHILDREN’S KNOWLEDGE ABOUT THE BALANCE SCALE
Siegler (1976) suggested that the different levels of knowledge that children have about this task could be represented in the form of binary decision trees (see Fig. 1). The model of mature knowledge (Model IV, Fig. 1D) was suggested by a task analysis of balance scale problems; the models of less sophisticated knowledge (Models 1-111, Figs. 1A-C) were derived from the empirical results of Inhelder and Piaget (1958) and Lee (197 l ) , and from our own pilot studies. A child using Model I considers only the number of weights on each side: If they are the same, the child predicts balance, otherwise he predicts that the side with the greater weight will go down. For a Model II (Fig. 1B) child, a difference in weight still dominates, but if weight is equal, then a difference in distance is sought. If it exists, the greater distance determines which side will go down, otherwise the prediction is balance. A child using Model III (Fig. 1C) tests both
Model
Model
I9
m
(C)
(0)
Fig. 1A-D. Decision tree representations for Models I-IV of balance scale predictions. A , Model I ; B, Model II; C . Model I l l ; D . Model IV. D = distance; W = weight.
68
David Kluhr and Robert S . Siegler
weight and distance in all cases. If both are equal, the child predicts balance; if only one is equal, then the other one determines the outcome; if they are both unequal, but on the same side with respect to their inequality, then that side is predicted to go down. However, in a situation in which one side has the greater weight, while the other has the greater distance, a Model 111 child, although recognizing the conflict, does not have a consistent way to resolve it. This child simply “muddles through” by making a random prediction. Model IV represents “mature” knowledge of the task: Since it includes the sum-of-products calculation, children using it will always make the correct prediction. Note, however, that if they can base their prediction on simpler tests, they will do so. B . ASSESSING THE.ACCURACY OF THE REPRESENTATIONS
It is possible to determine which, if any, of these four models accurately characterizes a child’s knowledge about the balance scale task by examining his pattern of predictions for six types of problems (see Table I for an example of each type): (1) balance problems, with the same configuration of weights on pegs on each side of the balance; (2) weight problems, with unequal amounts of weight equidistant from the fulcrum; (3) distance problems, with equal amounts of weight different distances from the fulcrum; (4) conflict-weight problems, with more weight on one side and “more distance” (i.e., occupied pegs further from the fulcrum) on the other, and the configuration such that the side with more weight goes down; (5) conflict-distance problems, similar to conflict-weight, except that the side with more distance goes down; (6) conflict-balance problems, like other conflict probllems, except that the scale remains balanced. Children whose knowledge corresponded to different models would display dramatically different patterns of predictions on the six types of problems just listed. Those using Model I would consistently make correct predictions on balance, weight, and conflict-weight problems, and they would never be correct on the other three problem types. Children using Model I1 would behave similarly to those using Model I ton five of the six problem types, but they would correctly solve distance problems. Those following Model 111 would consistently make accurate predictions on weight, balance, and distance problems, and would perform at a roughly chance level on all conflict tasks. Those using Model IV would solve all problems of all types. To the extent that there is a correlation between age and the level of the model which best represents a child’s knowledge, there should be clear developmental patterns for each problem type. The most interesting is the predicted decrement in performance on conflict-weight problems. Children using Models I or I1 will get these problems right even though they do not see them as conflict problems, whereas children using Model 111 will attend to the conflicting cues of weight and distance, but they will have to muddle through, and their resulting predictions
The Representution of Children’s Knowledge
69
TABLE 1 Predictions for Percentage of Correct Answers and Error Patterns on Posttest for Children Using Different Models Models
Problem type
Predicted developmental trend
1
11
111
IV
Balance
100
100
100
100
No change-all at high level
children
Weight
100
I00
loo
100
No change-all at high level
children
Distance
0 (Should say “balance”)
I00
100
100
Dramatic improvement with age
100
100
33 100 (Chance responding)
Decline with age Possible upturn in oldest group
Conflict-distance
0 (Should say “rightdown”)
0 (Should say “right d o w n ” )
33 loo (Chance responding)
Improvement with ape
Conflict-balance
0 (Should say “rightdown”)
0 (Should say ’* right-down”)
33 100 (Chance responding)
Improvement with age
w w
w w w
Conflict-weight
will be at a chance level of performance. Another prediction, shown in Table I , is that performance on distance problems should improve dramatically with age. The youngest subjects, using Model I will err on every problem, while children using Models 11, 111, or IV will never err. By a similar logic each of the problem types yields a predicted developmental course, the results of which are shown in Table I. (See Siegler, 1976, for a complete analysis.)
V.
Experiment 1: Assessing Initial Knowledge
The purpose of Experiment 1 was to assess the validity of the foregoing analysis for a group of children spanning a wide age range.
David Klahr and Robert S . Siegler
70
A.
METHOD
Subjects were 120 female !students from a private school in Pittsburgh. Fifteen students from each of eight grade levels were grouped as shown at the top of Table 11. Materials included a wooden balance scale, 10 different colored metal weights, and two wood blocks. The balance scale’s arm was 80 cm long, with four pegs on each side of the fulcrum. The first peg on each side was 7.6 cm from the fulcrum and each subsequent peg was 7.6 cm from the peg before it. The arm could swing freely from the point of attachment to the fulcrum, 10 cm above the fulcrum’s base. Each metal weight weighed 40 gm, measured 2.5 cm in diameter, and had a hole in its middle so that it would fit on the pegs; as many as six weights could be placed on any one peg. The two blocks of wood, each 11.4 cm high, could be placed under the arm of the balance scale to prevent it from moving regardless of the configuration of the metal weights on the pegs. Children’s knowledge was assessed through a 30-item test. On each problem the experimenter started with an empty balance, the arms of which were supported by the two wooden blocks. Then the metal weights were placed on the TABLE I1 Developmental Trends Observed and Predicted on Different Problem Types in Experiment I“ ~~~
Grade K-1st Age (years) 5-6 Number of 73 each type Mean age (months)
4th-5th 9-10 120
8th-9th 13-14 169
1 Ith-12th
16-17 207
Predicted developmental trend (from Table 1)
Problem type 4
Balance
94
99
99
100
No change-All at high level
children
4
Weight
88
98
98
98
No change-All at high level
children
4
Distance
9
78
81
95
Dramatic improvement with age
6
Conflict-weight
86
14
53
51
Decline with agePossible upturn for oldest
6
Conflict-distance
I1
32
48
SO
Improvement with age
6
Conflict-balance
7
17
26
40
Improvement with age
46
61
62
67
Weighted mean %
“Percentage of problems predicted correctly
The Represenrarion of Children’s Knowledge
71
pegs on the two sides of the balance scale, and the child was asked to predict which side would go down or whether the scale would balance if the two wooden blocks, underneath the arms of the balance, were not there. Among the 30 items were four balance, four weight, four distance, six conflict-weight, six conflictdistance, and six conflict-balance tasks of the types shown in Table I; they were presented in the same random order for each child. Children were tested individually in a quiet room in their school. The experimenter’s initial instructions were: Today we are going to play with this balance scale. The balance scale has these pieces of wood that are all the same distance from each other [pointing to the pegs] and these pieces of metal that all weigh the same.
At this point the children were encouraged to hold the weights to see that they weighed the same amount and to observe the equal distances between adjacent pegs. Children’s knowledge was then assessed by presenting them with the 30 problems described above. The problems were introduced with the following instructions: Let’s see what you know about the balance scale. I’ll put the weights on the pegs in different ways and you tell me whether this side would go down or this side would go down or they would both stay like they are now if I took the wood blocks away. The balance scale won’t actually move, but you tell me how the scale would go if the pieces of wood were not there.
Following this test, children were asked to explain their responses.’ Children spent between 15 and 30 minutes on the entire task. B.
RESULTS
The percent of correct predictions for each problem type by each age group is shown in Table 11. A 4 (age) by 6 (problem type) analysis of variance revealed that both main effects and their interaction were significant (D < .OOl). Note that the developmental patterns are very close to those predicted in Table I. In particular there is a dramatic improvement in distance problems and a decrement i n conflict-weight problems. The conflict-weight problems never did show an upturn, although performance appears to have leveled off for the older age groups. Not apparent in Table I1 is the substantial consistency that existed in performance on items within each problem type. Only on conflict-weight problems did accurate prediction decrease with age, and within this category such decrements ‘See Siegler (1976) for the criteria used to classify explanations.
72
David Kluhr and Robert S. Siegler
occurred on all six problems. The magnitude of the improvement over age on the four distance problems was unmatched by that on any of the 26 other items. On all eight of the balance and weight items, but on no other tasks, was the developmental trend minimal. With one class of exceptions, the four models make exact predictions about which of the three possible responses (left-down, right-down, balance) the subject will make on each one Qf the 30 problems. (The exception class contains the 18 conflict problems for Model 111; here the prediction is a lack of consistency, i.e., essentially chance responding.) Thus, we can compare the response pattern of each child to the predicted patterns for each of the models, and classify the child according to which, if any, model she was using in making her predictions. Using very strict criteria that had vanishingly small probabilities of misclassifying a random responder, it was possible to classify 107 of the 120 children. The results are shown in Table 111. Children’s explanations were also used to determine which model the child was using. The criteria for classifying according to explanations were derived from a literal interpretation of the models. Altogether, 117 of the 120 children’s explanations fit one of the four models. As shown in Table IV, the two classifications-one derived from children’s predictions, the other from their explanations-were highly correlated (r = .89,p < .001). All of the 23 children judged to be using Model I by the predictions data were judged as using Model 1 by the explanations criterion, and all eight of the children classified as using Model IV on the predictions measure-and only those eight-were classified as using Model IV on the explanations measure as well. On the other hand, many children were classified as using Model I1 by the predictions measure who were placed in Model 111 by the explanations measure. One interpretation of this discrepancy between the explanations and predictions criteria is that there were some children who used Model 111 tests, but consistently resolved the conflict by relying on the weight cue. Further evidence that children knew more about the balance scale than is revealed by the predictions classification comes from an analysis of the content of their explanations.
TABLE 111 Percentage of Children in Each Age Range Fitting Each Model
Age (years) 5-6
9-10 13-14 16-17 Total
( n = 30) ( n = 30) ( n = 30) ( n = 30) ( n = 120)
Model I
Model I1
Model 111
Model IV
77 10 10
0 30 23.3 20 18.3
0 40 56.1 63.3 40
6.1 3.3 16.7 6.1
0
24.2
0
Unclassified
23 13.3 6.1 0 10.8
13
The Represeritcition of Children’s Knowledge
TABLE 1V Number of Children in Experiment 1 Fitting Each Model-Predictions and Explanations Criteria
Model Classified by Explanations Criterion
I
I
Model Used: Classified by Predictions Criterion
I
I1
111
IV
0 0 0 8
I I1
23
1
0
0
1
111
0 0
7 13 0
IV
46 0
Fully one-third of the children advancing Model 111 explanations cited the ratio properly of conflict-balance problems (e.g., one on the third peg equals three on the first peg), but not the composition rule necessary for a Model IV placement. C. EVALUATION OF DECISION TREE REPRESENTATIONS
How well do the decision trees used in Fig. 1 represent children’s knowledge on the balance scale task? The representation appears to fare well on the first, second, and fourth criteria listed earlier. With regard to the first criterion, the models are clearly sufficient to account for the predictions data: The problem type by model analysis provided an exhaustive and unambiguous mapping between behavior and theory. With regard to the second criterion, the data can be analyzed at the level of either individual subjects or group averages, and also can be considered at either the level of response patterns or sheer number of correct responses. Regarding the fourth criterion, the formal relationship between the models is one of strict inclusion: Model I tests are included in Model 11, etc. This logical structure predicts an invariant developmental sequence (although we could not test this directly in a cross-sectional study). In terms of the third criterion-integration of psychological parameters-the merits of the representation are less clear. Although a number of implications could be drawn, few explicit statements about psychological, as opposed to logical, properties of the knowledge required to do the task have yet been advanced. Another orientation from which to evaluate the representation is to ask how well it answers the five questions about instruction and development that were listed above. Thus far, it has answered only Question 1: The difference between high and low performers is represented by differences among the four models. The models are silent on Question 2, which addresses the issue of alternative paths to the same performance. This inadequacy was most noticeable in the discussion of the idiosyncracies that are masked by the “muddle through” category on Model 111. Since the models do not have any representation for their own
David KIahr and Robert S . Siegler
14
induction, they are unable to !jay anything about Question 4, which asks about critical features of the instructional sequence. However, the models do suggest some straightforward ways to empirically investigate Question 3 (How difficult should an instructional sequence be?), and they imply that there should be no differences in responsiveness to instruction, thus providing an assertion that refutes the premise of Question 5 (When and why will differential learning occur?). In Experiment 2, these issues suggested by Questions 3 and 5 were addressed.
VI.
Experiment 2: Training on the Balance Scale Task
In the second experiment, 5- and 8-year-olds were equated for performing at a level not beyond Model I. Then they were provided with experience on either distance or conflict problems. or with one of two control procedures. Distance problem experience focused on the type of problems solvable by Rule I1 but not by Rule I; it thus was geared one step above the learners’ initial level. Conflict problem experience, emphasizing problems not understood even qualitatively until Rule 111, was intended to be two or more steps advanced. According to Piagetian theory, the fit between a child’s existing knowledge and the new information presented is a critical determinant of when, how much, and what kind of learning will occur (Piaget, 1971). Support for this view has been found by Turiel (1966) and Blatt (197 1) in the area of moral development, and by Kuhn (1972) in class-inclusion training. Therefore, we predicted that our Model I children would benefit from distance problems, while they would learn little, if anything, from conflict problems. As we already noted, there is nothing in the models that would predict differential responsivity to instruction of older and younger children. But both intuition and empirical evidence support the notion that older children are more adept than younger ones at mastering many novel problems on which taskspecific knowledge is equally lacking (cf. Siegler, 1975; Siegler & Liebert, 1974, 1975). Thus, there were no clear grounds on which to base a prediction about age differences in response to the training sequences. A.
METHOD
Experiment 2 included three segments: pretest, experience, and posttest.
I. Pretest The pretest consisted of eight items: two weight, two distance, two conflictweight, and two conflict-distance. The tasks and apparatus were similar to those used in Experiment 1; on each trial, the child was shown a configuration and
The Represenrution of Children's Knowledge
75
asked to predict which of the three possible outcomes would occur if the wood blocks were removed. There was no feedback during the pretest.
2 . Experience All experiential conditions except the bias control (see below) included 16 trials on which children were presented a randomized sequence of various types of balance scale problems. Children were asked to predict what would happen and why they thought so; then the wood blocks supporting the scale were removed so that the prediction was confirmed or disconfirmed. After a 10-second interval the weights were removed and placed on the scale in a different arrangement. Conflict problem experience involved presentation of six conflict-weight, six conflict-distance, one distance, two balance, and one weight problem. Distance problem experience included 12 distance, 2 balance, and 2 weight problems. Thus, each experiential condition included 12 problems of the type being emphasized; the additional four problems of other types were intended to prevent children from acquiring strategies too narrowly suited to the demands of the majority of items. Within the control condition there were two subgroups: the exposure control and the bias control. The exposure condition was designed to control for the possibility that any experience with the balance scale could improve performance; children in this condition were presented a sequence composed of 14 weight and 2 balance items that would familiarize them with the balance scale's workings but would not directly engender knowledge of' Models I1 or 111. However, this control procedure might itself bias children toward a greater reliance on Model I than if they had been left untutored. Therefore, a bias control was included in which children simply received the pretest and posttest. Within each age group's control condition, one-half of the children were assigned to the exposure control and one-half to the bias control. 3 . Posttest The posttest included a randomly ordered, no-feedback presentation of 24 items, four each of balance, weight, distance, conflict-weight, conflict-distance, and conflict-balance types. The pretest took approximately 10 minutes, the experience 25 minutes, and the posttest 15 minutes. Eight-year-olds were given the three parts in succession; 5-year-olds were given the pretest one day and the experience and posttest in a second session within the next 48 hours. 4 . Participants Sixty children, 30 5-year-olds and 30 8-year-olds, all with less than Model I1 knowledge, were randomly assigned within age and sex to the three treatment groups.2 All groups had equal numbers of males and females except for the 'See Siegler (1976) for the details of this selection procedure.
David Klahr and Robert S. Siegler
16
8-year-old control group, which included four boys and six girls. The mean CA of kindergartners was 70 months (range = 66-75 months), while the mean CA of third graders was 106 months (range = 101-1 17 months). The experimenter, a 22-year-old female research assistant, served for all children. B. RESULTS
Responses to the 24-item posttest were classified according to a scheme similar to the one used in Experiment 1. (There were no differences between the two control groups, so the data from both of them were combined.) As shown in Table V , 45 of the 60 children behaved according to the models: 21 using Model 1, 17 using Model 11, and 7 using Model 111. A Chi-square test indicated that significant differences were present in the type of rules used by children in the six age-by-experience groups (x' = 45.54, df = 1, p < .001). More specific analyses revealed that 5-year-olds more often used Model I and 8-year-olds more often Models I1 or 111 (x' = 12.91, df = 1, p < .001), and that children exposed to the control procedure more often used Model I, while those exposed to conflict or to distance problems more often used Model I1 or 111 (x2 = 13.20, df = 1, p <.001). An interactive relationship between type of experience and age was also apparent. Fisher Exact tests indicated that among 5-year-olds, experience with distance problems led to more adoptions of Models I1 and 111 than did experience with conflict problems or the control conditions (p < .01). As can be seen in Table V, the effect was almost exclusively to promote attainment of Model 11; no condition led to many children attaining Model 111. Among the 8-year-olds, however, both distance and conflict problem experience led to more adoptions of TABLE V Number of Children Using Different Models-Experiment Age group
Model I
Model 11
Model I11
2 Unclassifiable
~~
5-Year-olds Control Distance training Conflict training Total
8 3 5 16
8-Year-olds Control Distance training Conflict training Total Grand total
3 8 2 13 21
17
15
The Representntion of Children’s Knowledge
I1
Models I1 and 111 than did the control procedures (p < .001), and conflict problem experience led to greater use of Model I11 than did the distance problems and control conditions (p < .01). In summary, then, Table V shows that both age groups can learn from training that is only one level beyond their current level (i.e., distance training). However, given training that is two levels beyond (i.e., conflict training), the 5-year-old children learned nothing, while the 8-year-olds benefited substantially. Thus, it is clear that older and younger children derived different lessons from the same experience, even when they had identical initial predictive knowledge about the task.
VII.
Revised Representations for Balance Scale Knowledge
These empirical results raise questions that reveal some of the limitations of the decision tree representation used thus far to represent children’s knowledge of balance scale tasks. Since the four models purport to represent all of what a child knows about the task, they predict that children classified according to one of the models should be identical on all task-related performance, including learning about the task. Thus, they predict that the differential responsiveness to experience with conflict problems that we observed between the two age groups should not have occurred. Of course, the models make this prediction by default, since they have no representation of the learning process as such. That is, they contain no representation of the way that positive and negative information obtained during the training sequence is treated, nor about the ways in which the models might undergo transformation from one level to the next. Another limitation of the representation is that it allows no way to describe the many different means utilized by subjects to amve at the same end. We have already alluded to this in our discussion of the Model 111 explanations data, and now it is time to address it directly. We need a representation that can account for not only the logical form of the decision rules used to make predictions, but also the psychological properties of the rules. That is, we need a representation that enables us to clearly indicate the perceptual and mnemonic demands of actually using the decision rules. In this section we will introduce such a representation for children’s knowledge about this task, and we will present examples of the kinds of questions the representation enables us to ask. Then, in the next section, we will describe an experiment that provides some answers to these questions. A.
PRODUCTION SYSTEM REPRESENTATION
In Fig. 2 we have restated the four models of Fig. 1 as production systems. [See Newel1 (1973) for an extensive introduction, and Klahr (1976b) for some
David Klahr and Robert S . Siegler
78
Model
I P1: ((Same W ) --> (Say " b a l a n c e " ) ) P2: ( ( S i d e X more W) --> (Say "X down"))
Model I I
P1: ((Same W ) -->
(Say " b a l a n c e " ) ) P2: ( ( S i d e X more W ) --> (Say " X down")) P3: ( (Same W ) ( S i d e X more 0) --> (Say " X d o u n " ) )
M o d e l 111
P1: P2: P3: P4: P5:
(Sam@ W ) --> (Side (Same (Side (Side
(Say " b a l a n c e " ) )
X more W) --> (Say "X down")) W ) ( S i d e X more 0) --> (Say " X down")) X more W) ( S i d e X less D) --> muddle t h r o u g h ) X more W ) ( S i d e X more 0 ) --> (Say "x d o u n " ) )
Model I V
P1: ( (Same W ) --> (Say " b a I ance") 1 PZ: ( ( S i d e X more W ) --> (Say " X down") 1 P3: ( (Saiiie W ) ( S i d e X more 0) --> (Say " X doun") ) P 4 ' : ( ( S i d e X more W ) ( S i d e X less 0) --> ( g e t Torques)) P5: ( ( S i d e X more W) ( S i d e X more 0) --> (Say "x d o u n " ) ) P6: ((Same Torquo) --> (Say " b a l a n c e " ) ) P7: ( ( S i d e X more Torque) --> ( s a y " X d o u n " ) )
T r a n s i t i o n a l requirements Productions Opera t o r s
I -> I 1
add P3
I1
111
add P4, P5
I l l -> I V
motli f g P 4 ; add P6, P7
->
add d i s t a n c e e n c o d i n g and compar i son
add t o r q u e computat i o n and compar i son
Fig. 2 . Production system ( P ) representations for Models 1-W. D = distance; W = weight. Written in a special language called PSG. See text for further explanation.
examples from cognitive devellopment.] A production system consists of a set of rules-called productions-written in the form of condition-action pairs; the conditions are symbolic expressions for elements of knowledge that might be present at some instant. A production system operates via a recognize-act cycle. During the recognition cycle, all the condition sides of all the productions are compared with the current contents of the immediate knowledge state. We will refer to this immediate knowledge as the contents of working memory (WM). It can be interpreted as primary or short-term memory (Waugh & Norman, 1965), M-space (Pascual-Leone, 1970), short-term plus intermediate-term memory (Bower, 1975; Hunt, 1971), or more generally as the currently activated portion of long-term memory, or simply as the current state of awareness of the system.
The Representrition of Children’s Knowledge
79
The productions whose conditions are matched by elements in WM are placed into the conflict set, a conflict resolution principle is applied, and one production fires. The act cycle executes the actions that are associated with the fired production. Then the next recognition cycle commences. Thus, the conditions are tests on the momentary state of WM. A sequence of condition elements on the left side of a production is interpreted as a test for the simultaneous existence of the conjunction of the individual knowledge elements. If, for a given production, all the condition elements happen to be true at some instant, we say that the production is “satisfied.” If only one production is satisfied, then it “fires”: the actions associated with it, written to the right of the arrow (see Fig. 2 ) are taken. These actions can modify the knowledge state by adding, deleting, or changing existing elements in it, or they can correspond to interactions with the environment-either perceptual or motor. If more than one production is satisfied at a given moment, then the system needs to invoke some conflict resolution principle. In the systems shown here all conflicts are assumed to be resolved such that special cases have priority over general cases. For example, suppose that the two productions in the conflict set are: PI: (a b-+ x) P2:(b -+ y) P1 is a special case of P2, since P2 is satisfied whenever P1 is satisfied, but not vice versa. That is, P2 is satisfied when element b is in WM, but P1 is satisfied only when both b and a are present. The special case conflict resolution principle will choose P1. [Further discussion of conflict resolution i n production systems can be found in McDermott and Forgy (in press), Newell (1973), Newell and McDermott (1975), and Rychener (1976).] Consider, for example, Model I1 in Fig. 2 . It is a production system consisting of three productions. The condition elements in this system are all tests for sameness or difference in weight or distance. The actions all refer to behavioral responses. None of the models in Fig. 2 contain a representation for any finer grain knowledge, such as the actual amount of weight or distance, or the means used to encode that information. Nor is there any explicit representation of how the system actually produces the final verbal output. It is simply assumed that the system has access to encoded representations of the relational information stated in the conditions. We will return below to further consideration of the way that this information becomes available to the system. Returning to Model 11, notice that on any recognize cycle, only one production will fire. If the weights are unequal, then P2 will fire; if the weights are equal and the distances are not, then both P1 and P3 will be satisfied, but since P3 is a special case of P 1, the conflict resolution principle will choose P3 to fire; finally, if both weights and distances are equal, then only P1 will be satisfied and it will fire. (The numbers attached to
80
David Klahr and Robert S. Siegler
the productions [e.g., PI, P2, etc.] are not supposed to have any psychological meaning. They serve simply as labels for the reader; note that a production maintains its label across the four models.) We can compare the four models to determine the task facing a transition model. At the level of productions the requisite modifications are straightforward: a transition from Model I to Model I1 requires the addition of P3; from Models I1 to III, the addition of P4 and P5; and from Models 111 to IV, the addition of P6 and P7 and the modification of P4 to P4’. (This modification changes the action side from random muddling through to “get torques”.) We can compare the four models at a finer level of analysis by looking at the implicit requirements for encoding and comparing the important qualities in the environment. Model I tests for sameness or difference in weight. Thus, it requires an encoding process that either directly encodes relative weight, or encodes an absolute amount of each and then inputs those representations into a comparison process. Whatever the form of the comparison process, it must be able to produce not only a same-or-different symbol, but if there is a difference, it must be able to keep track of which side is greater. Model I1 requires the additional capacity to make these decisions about distance as well as weight. This might constitute a completely separate encoding and comparison system for distance representations, or it might be the same system except for the interface with the environment. Model 111 needs no additional operators at this level. Thus, it differs from Model I1 only in the way it utilizes information that is already accessible to Model 11. Model IV requires a much more powerful set of quantitative operators than any of the preceding models. In order to determine relative torque, it must first determine the absolute torque on each side of the scale, and this in turn requires exact numerical representation of weight and distance. In addition, the torque computation would require access to the necessary arithmetic production systems to actually do the sum of products calculations. Although we have compared the four models at two distinct levelsproductions and operators-the levels are not really that easily separated. Missing from these models is a set of productions which would indicate the interdependence: productions that explicitly determine which encoding the system will make. That is, in these models, there are almost no productions of the form: (want to compare weights) (attend to stimulus and notice weight). The sole exception to this occurs in P4’ in Model IV. When this model is confronted with a nonconflict problem, either P I , P2, P3, or P5 will fire on the first recognize cycle. However, if it is a conflict problem, then P4’ fires, and the system attempts to “get torques.” The result of this unmodeled action, as described above, would be to produce a knowledge element that could satisfy either P6 or W on the next recognize cycle.
-
The Representation of Children’s Knowledge
B.
81
EVALUATION OF THE PRODUCTION SYSTEM REPRESENTATION
Each of the four production system models in Fig. 2 makes precisely the same prediction as its counterpart i n the decision tree representation of Fig. I . Thus, on the first of the evaluative criteria listed above-accounting for behavior-the production system model fares as well as the decision tree model. With respect to the second criterion-multiple-level analysis-and the fourth-developmental tractability-the production systems are somewhat more explicit than the decision trees about the requirements for both the encoding operations and the rules (i.e., productions) that utilize the symbolic elements produced by the operators. They also clarify the developmental differences between models in terms of these two kinds of entities. The major advantage of the production system representation lies in its integration of general psychological principles-the third of our evaluative criteria. Production systems of the type used here incorporate a theory of the control structure and general representation that underlies a broad range of human problem-solving ability (Newell & Simon, 1972). As Newell (1973) put it: “The production system itself has become the carrier of the basic psychological assumptions-the system architecture of. . . [the production system] is taken to be the system architecture of the human information processing system” (p. 516). Thus, models written in this form can be viewed as variants within a general psychological theory, and to the extent that such a general theory is consistent with the empirical results from experimental psychology, then these models are also consistent with them. With respect to the five questions listed earlier, the production systems have enabled us to be very explicit about Question 1 (differences that underlie performance), and in particular about the important role of encoding operators. They have indicated some potential sources of variation for each level of performance (Question 2), although since they are written as modal types, this is merely suggestive at this point. Similar comparisons of the relative efficacy of the two forms of representations for answering the other three questions yield the same result. Thus, while the new representation does not provide much of an advantage over the old for understanding the results of Experiment 2, it does provide some guidance about where to look for an explanation-in the encoding of the stimulus. In order to model the conditions under which one or another aspect of the stimulus is attended to and encoded, we would need to augment the models in Fig. 2 with productions like P4’. These productions would transform the models from simple discrimination nets into active problem solvers, and they would enable us to make predictions about such things as eye movements and solution latencies for different classes of problems. However, before we can make such
82
David Klahr and Robert S. Siegler
an extension, we must first determine the varieties of possible encoding schemes that subjects are actually using. As a first step in that direction, we undertook a detailed examination of the problem-by-problem protocols of a few children in a training sequence. C.
PROTOCOL ANALYSIS
Several children, ranging in age from 5 to 10 years, were unsystematically selected to be run individually in a conflict training sequence. They were given instructions about the balance scale and about the fact that there were rules underlying the balance scale’s behavior that they could discover if they “watched carefully and thought about it.” In addition, following their prediction on each trial, they were asked to state their reasons for the prediction. Then the blocks were removed, the children observed the scale’s movement and if they were incorrect, they were again asked, “Why do you think that happened?” These entire sessions were videotaped, and then all the verbal comments, as well as major physical activities, were transcribed into the form shown in Appendix A. At the beginning of each problem, there is an indication of the problem number, the configuration, and the elapsed time (in minutes and seconds) since the start of the session. Problem numbers T I , T3, etc., correspond to items from the training sequence, and problem numbers E7, E8, etc. (see lines 11300 and 14700) are from an exploratory session which followed the training sequence. In the exploratory session, the children were edcouraged to build interesting problems or to explain to the experimenter what kinds of problems would achieve certain outcomes. The problem configuration is indicated by a numerical code that is a near-pictorial representation of the problem. In TI (line 00400) the code 0001/2000 indicates one weight on the first peg (from the fulcrum) on the left side, and two weights on the first peg on the right side. In T3 (line 02200), the code 0100/1OOO indicates a single weight on the third peg on the left, and a single weight on the first peg on the right. Excerpts from the protocol of Lisa, a 5-year-old female, are shown in Appendix A. The protocol provides a rich data source from which to select “observations.” However, in this discussion we will focus only on those aspects that indicate the kind of encoding of distance and weight that Lisa appears to use. Lisa was first given the standard instructions and pretest described earlier. Her response pattern did not conform to any of the four models. However, if Model I were modified such that heavy things went up instead of down, then she was a perfect Model I subject. The first problem in the training sequence confirms this interpretation (lines 00400-01200). Lisa knows which side has more weight, but her prediction is based upon the assumption that more weight goes up. However, when confronted with the contrary evidence, she changes the “sign” of the correlation between weight and direction of tipping. This single-feedback trial
The Representation of Children’s Knowledge
83
was sufficient: For the remainder of this half hour session, she never again errs in her understanding of the direction of the effect of weight differences. As we will see, the correct encoding of distance and its effect required a much longer series of trials. The second training problem (not shown) was a balance problem, so T3 (0100/1000) was the first instance in which Lisa received feedback indicating that equality of weight is not a reliable predictor. Her own verbalization of the problem captures her puzzlement: “Well why are they both the same thing [same weight] and one’s up and one’s down?” (line 3300). Another distance problem followed immediately (T4: 0020/0020), and Lisa’s first response is to say balance, but she quickly corrects herself, having detected the distance difference. Her encoding of distance is correct in that it is based on the fdcrum, rather than the end points, as the zero reference point (lines 0440004500). However, she incorrectly associates greater distance with the side that goes up rather than the opposite, in the same way that she initially had the sign wrong for weight effects. This is her first attempt to utilize distance information, and she gets negative feedback. At this point she might abandon distance as a useful cue, or she might-as she did with weight-simply change the sign of the relation. As we will see, she does neither. T5 was a complex distance problem (0101/1100) (not shown), and T6 (0102/ 2010) a balance problem, neither one of which yielded a useful protocol. In T7 (0200/2000) we return to a distance problem. It is clew from the protocol that Lisa is still attempting to use distance (lines 09600-10000). She still encodes direction of distance from the f u l m m correctly, but she has not changed her erroneous assumption about the effect of this difference. Note also that she has not yet made any statement about absolute amount of distance; all her statements are about relative distance. In order to focus on the issue of distance encoding, we skip over about 15 minutes of conflict training in which the problems were mainly complex conflict-weight and conflict-distance (i .e., two or more pegs occupied on each side) from which no clear pattern emerged. We pick up the protocol again in an excerpt from the exploratory phase in which Lisa was allowed to construct problems according to various experimenter requests or hints. In E7 (lines 11300-14400), she has been asked to construct some problems such that she will not be quite sure what the result will be. In general, Lisa does no such thing, and instead tends to construct problems about which she is very confident. Thus, her initial configuration is 0003/0004, a problem in which both weight and distance indicate that the right side will go down. Then the experimenter modifies it to a distance problem (0004/0004), and Lisa apparently forgets all about distance differences, reverting to a Model I prediction of “balance” (lines 12000-12300). With a little prompting from the experimenter (lines 13500-14000), she invokes a (post hoc) distance explanation (lines 14100-14200). Notice that the distance
84
David Klahr and Robert S . Siegler
description is not just a relative judgment, but instead is stated in terms of two absolute (albeit approximate) quantities. It appears that, even after almost 30 minutes of experience with the balance scale, Lisa knows that distance is an important factor, but she has not yet developed a reliable rule about the effect of distance differences. Then, over the next 2-minute period, she begins to demonstrate a stabilizing grasp of this concept. First she creates a balance problem and makes the correct prediction (lines 14900-15900). Then a new experimenter enters, and feigning ignorance, asks how the scale works. Lisa creates (0003/0003) and predicts correctly, and for the right reasons (lines 16800-17300). Then, at the experimenter’s request, she correctly creates a balance problem (0003/3000). It is interesting that she does this in the “easiest” way, given the configuration from which she was starting, but it is also the case that this is the same balance configuration that was used in the preceding problem. Then she creates a distance problem such that the scale tips in a desired direction (19000-19400) and gives the correct explanation and, finally, she initiates yet another balance problem, one unlike any she has ever seen before (3000/0003). Recall that this protocol analysis was undertaken after a discussion of the production system representation of knowledge about the balance scale (Fig. 2). In that representation, we tried to emphasize the differences between the encoding of information about the environment (the undefined operators) and the combination rules [cf. Gelman’s (1972a, 1972b) operator+stimator distinction, and Klahr and Wallace’s (1973) operator-rule dichotomies] for acting on that information (the productions). The protocols tell us something about the nature of the representations that are being used by the child, and hence something about the encoding operators that produce them. It is clear that Lisa extracts information from the training series that will enable her to improve both the encoding operators and the combination rules. With respect to weight, she has no difficulty in formulating an appropriate encoding based on counting the number of weights. Although there is an initial error with respect to the relation between weight differences and the direction of the scale, this is quickly corrected and remains stable for the rest of lhe session. Distance encoding follows quite a different course. Initially it is ignored. Then differences i n distance are noted, but their effect is quite unstable in the face of negative feedback, and as we saw, they are occasionally ignored well into the training sequence. However, it appears that by the very end of the exploratory trials, an appropriate encoding of distance, and a concomitandy appropriate rule for utilizing it (at least on disunce problems), has been formulated. Learning about the balance scale, then, would seem to require much more than is suggested by a comparison of adjacent models in Fig. 1. The production system representation of Fig. 2 has enabled us to make explicit the difference between encoding operators and decision rules, and it has guided our search for
The Representtrtion of Children‘s Knowledge
85
instances of both of these kinds of learning in the protocol. The analysis suggested that there is a point in the development of knowledge about this task during which the dimensions may be encoded in idiosyncratically incorrect ways, and that the form of the encoding may depend upon trial-to-trial feedback. In the next section we will introduce a model that attempts to capture these phenomena for an individual subject. D.
REVISED PRODUCTION SYSTEM FOR A MODEL III CHILD
Thus far, the production system representation has been used only to suggest some of the complexities of learning about the task. In this section we will work toward the creation of a production system model of a single child’s behavior during a training sequence. The representation will be more than suggestive, for it will be specific enough to run as a computer simulation. The simulation will serve two purposes. First, it will demonstrate the sufficiency of the model to account for the data it purports to explain. Second, the particular simulation language in which the model is stated is based upon, and incorporates in its structure, very specific assumptions about the nature of the human informationprocessing system. Thus, the model to be described here is a particular instance of a much broader theory of human problem solving. Our subject, Jan, was a female second-grader, age 7 years, 11 months. Her performance on an 8-item pretest and a 16-item training series is shown in Table VI. In Table VI, each row corresponds to a problem. The columns indicate, respectively, problem number, problem configuration, problem type (Distance (D), Balance (B), Conflict-Weight (CW), Weight (W), etc.), Jan’s response (Left (L)- or Right (R)-down, Balance (B)), feedback from the scale (if the subject’s prediction was inconsistent with what the scale did, it is indicated by a -), predictions from three of the previously described models (Models IV, 11, and I), and finally, two columns corresponding to the model to be described in this section. The first of these columns-IIIA-contains the model’s prediction, and the second contains the value of a variable criterion that is used to make the prediction. For example, Problem 7 has three weights on the first peg on the left and two weights on the third peg on the right; it is a conflict-distance problem. Jan predicted that the left side would go down, but as Model IV (which is always correct) predicted, the right side went down so the subject got negative feedback. The other three models shown here (Models 11, I , and IIIA) all make the same prediction as the subject: left-down. The number at the bottom of each of the four model columns shows the number of mismatches between Jan’s predictions and the model’s. Jan’s responses to the pretest make her a perfect Model I1 subject. Her responses during the training sequence provide a poor fit to Models I, 11, and IV. Recall that the criterion for fitting Model I11 was that the responses be essentially
David KIahr and Robert S.Siegler
86
TABLE VI Jan on Training Sequence, and Predictions from Four Models
Problem
Prediction
Number Configuration Type S2 Feedback Model IV Model I1 Model I Pretest I 2 3 4 5 6 7 8
100~100
0 I01300 1001200 010~020 0201002 2001400 1001200 030(020
Training series 1 020010200 2 002010200 3 002013000 4 000310100 5 0200(0400 6 0102120I0 7 000310020 8 0100~0200 9 0040~1020 II= 000112000 12 001311020 13 012012200 14 020011300 15 0002~0010 16 002311110
D CW CD W D CD CD W
D
B CD
cw cw B CD
cw cw W CD CD
cw CD CW
Model IIIA Criterion
L R
R R R R R L
L B R L L B L L L R L L L R R
B B
R R L R R L R R L
L B R L R B L R L R L R R L L
70
6b
76
L B L L R B
“Problem 10 was omitted. Abbreviations: B = balance; C == conflict; D = distance; W ONumber of mismatches between Jan and model.
=
L B R L L B L L L R L L L R L
R L R B L R L R L R R L L
weight; R
W
D W D W
D W
Ib
=
right; L
=
left.
random for conflict problems. Thus, although the “muddle through” prediction of Model III does not make: an exact prediction on any trial, it predicts the absence of a consistent pattern over the set of conflict problems. And indeed, this is what we find in Table VI: On 5 of the 11 conflict problems Jan responds as if she were relying on the weight cue, and on the other six she conforms to the distance cue. Thus, we could simply classify Jan as a Model 111 subject and leave it at that. Such an interpretation has several deficiencies. First, the classification scheme itself is unsatisfactory when compared with the others. Model I11 subjects get so
The Represenrution of Children’s Knowledge
87
classified as a residual category, by the absence of any pattern in their responses to conflict problems, while all other classification is based on the Occurrence of things that were predicted to happen, rather than the absence of things that should not. In addition to this “taxonomic” weakness, Model 111’s “muddle through” prediction tells us nothing about the psychological processes that actually operate when subjects detect conflict but do not yet know how to deal with it correctly. We have already cited some of the idiosyncratic strategies that different subjects bring to bear on this situation. Finally, it is important to emphasize that Table V1 represents responses during a training sequence, a situation in which the child was presumably attempting to integrate the feedback from the balance scale’s actual behavior with her current hypothesis about how it worked. None of the four models described thus far have any mechanism to represent and utilize such information. Thus, the model to be described represents our first steps toward remedying these deficiencies. Jan was run under the same conditions as Lisa, and an analysis of her trial-bytrial explanations provided the initial evidence for the model that we eventually formulated. The most striking feature of her comments was the way she appeared to represent distance and weight on conflict problems. Both of them were treated as dichotomous: More than two weights was treated as “big,” otherwise weight was “little,” and if the third or fourth peg were occupied, then distance was “big,” otherwise it was “little.” Rather than present another lengthy protocol analysis here, we will show just two examples of this dichotomous encoding of distance. On Problem 12 (0013/1020), the child predicts left-down; upon seeing the result, she says: Oh, now I think I know why. . . . I think I know because. . . it’s supposed to be a rule that they usually go down more if they’re on that side [pointing to the extreme right of the balance scale]. So that one went down cause it’s two there [pointing far right] and none there [pointing far left].
If we encode each arm of the balance scale into a near segment (Pegs 1 and 2) and a far segment (Pegs 3 and 4), then this protocol is easily interpreted. “They usually go down more if they’re on that side” means that if the far segment is occupied (“big distance”) then the scale will tip in that direction. “Two there and none there” means that the far segment on the right is occupied by two weights, whereas the far segment on the left is unoccupied. The second example comes from Problem 14 (0200/1300), just before the child gets feedback. She says: This side’s gonna g o down [pointing left] . . . Even though this one has four [pointing right] and this one only has two [pointing left]. . . . Even though this one has [pointing right] twice as much as this [pointing left], that means that because this one’s more [waves to far left] over, and that’s [pointing right] all on that side.
88
David Klahr and Robert S . Siegler
In this case, we garner support for the dichotomous distance encoding from the comment that the weights on the right arm of the scale are “all on that side.” “That side” of what? By our interpretation, they are on “that side” of the midpoint of the right arm, thus making distance “little,” rather than “big” on the right. In order to determine whether this interpretation of the protocols is valid, we need to construct a model that is consistent with Jan’s actual predictions on each trial, as well as her explanations. Based upon many such comments and our interpretations of them, we constructed the model whose predictions are shown in Table VI. In order to provide a clear overview of the model we will describe it first in terms of a binary decision tree, plus a few ad hoc mechanisms. Then we will present a running production system for a more complete model based on the same underlying logic. Figure 3 shows the binary decision tree representation for Model IIIA; Jan’s performance on the training sequence is shown in Table VI. The numbers under the terminal nodes correspond to the problems from Table VI that are sorted to those nodes. The first three tests are the same as those in Model I11 (Fig. l ) , and they account for balance, weight, and distance problems. If neither weight nor distance is “same,” then the model begins to test for “big” values. If either
Same ?
8,13.15
: I n i t i a l l y : Weight
Down 3.4
Down 7 , 9 , 1 2 , 1 6 (Weight) 5,14 (Distance1
W e i g h t : O n Any Single P e g , n Z 3
Weight -Distance
Or Distance -Weight
Fig. 3. Decision tree representalionfor Jan’sprediction model. D = distance; W = weight. The numbers under the terminal nodes correspond to the problems from Table VI that are sorted to those nodes.
weight or distance-but not both-is big, then the side with the big value determines the prediction. If both are big. then Model IIIA favors whichever one is currently its criterion value. The criterion value starts as weight, but whenever negative feedback is received the criterion switches from one value to the other. The state of the criterion value is indicated in the last column in Table V1. Note that it changes after any negative feedback, not just on conflict trials with negative feedback. (The terminal node labeled “?” in Fig. 3 is never reached by the set of problems in Table VI. Such a problem would be a conflict problem with neither weight nor distance “big.” We have no evidence upon which to base a prediction about what the subject would do with such a problem.) E.
PRODUCTION SYSTEM FOR MODEL IlIA
The production system for Jan is shown i n Fig. 4. The representation contains the actual computer listing (with a few inessential details not shown) for the production system, which is written in a special language called PSG (Newell & McDermott, 1975). Appendix B contains a trace of this model running on a sequence of four problems from Table VI; one of them-Problem 7-is also shown in Fig. 5. Before we embark on a detaiied description of the model, we will make a few comments about the properties of this rather complex representation of knowledge about the balance scale task. This model represents, in addition to the child’s knowledge about how the balance scale operates, her knowledge about the immediate experimental context in which she is functioning. The trial-by-trial cycle during the training phase comprises (1) observation of the static display, (2) prediction of the outcome, (3) observation of the outcome, (4) comparison of the outcome with the prediction, and (5) revision if necessary, of the criterion. The production systems shown previously (Fig. 2) represented knowledge sufficient to execute only the second of these five steps, while the present model (Fig. 4) explicitly represents all of this task-relevant knowledge in a homogeneous and integrated manner. This model utilizes, in one way or another, representations of knowledge about when and how to encode the environment, which side has more weight or distance, which side has a big weight or distance, what the current criterion value is, what the scale is expected to do, what the scale actually did, whether the prediction is yet to be made or has been made, and whether it is correct or incorrect. F . PRODUCTION SYSTEM INTERPRETATlON
Some general properties of production systems were described earlier. In this section we will add a few more details about how the model in Fig. 4 operates. Recall that the basic cycle for a production system is recognize-act. During a recognition cycle, all the productions compare their condition elements with an
90
David Klahr and Robert S . Siegler
:(CLASS weight distance) <side. I>:(CLASS left right both)
:(CLASS weight distance) <side,2>:(CLASS left right both)
:(CLASS u p down level)
Pl:((predict) (weight same) --> (made **) (expect both level) say.b) P2:((predict) (weight more <side.l>) --> (made **) (expect <side.l> down) say.d) P3:((prcdict) (weight same) (distance more <side.l>) --> (made **) (expect <side.l> down) say.d) P4:((predict) (weight morc)(distance more) -->
find.bie)
P5:((prcclict) (criterion )(big <side. I > ) ( big <side.2>) --> (made *t) (expect <side.l> d0wn)say.d) PG:((predict) (weight big <side.l>) --> (made **) (expect <side.l> down) say.d) P7:((prechct) (distance big <side.l>) --> (made **) (expect <side.l> down) say.d) P8:((predict)() abs --r ATTEND)
El:((expcct) --> look) E2:((cxpcct <side.l> )(see <side.l> ) --> (did **)(see ===> saw)(result correct)) E3:((expect <side.l> )(see <side.l> ) abs (see) --> (did **)(see =-=> saw) (result wrong))
weight)) SW1 :((result wrong)(criterion distance) --> (old **)(distance ==a SW2:((rcsult wrong)(criterion weight) --> (old *:)(weight
-==> distance))
SW3:((result corrcct)(criterion) --> (old * t ) )
find.big:(OPR CALL) ;returns (weightldistance big leftlright), one or two such. looh:(OPR CALL) ; looks for result of balance tipping; returns (see leftlright down) attend:(OPR CALL) : initial encotling. of same or difference on distance g! weight; returns (wcightldistance samclmoro Icftlright)
Fig. 4 . Production system ( P )for Jan. ABS = Absent. Written in a special language called PSG. See text for further explanation.
ordered list of elements in VlM.The trace in Fig. 5 shows the state of WM after each cycle. For example, at the beginning of the second cycle in Fig. 5 , we see that WM has four elements in it: (DISTANCE MORE RIGHT), (WEIGHT MORE LEFT), (PREDICT), and (CRITERION WEIGHT). An examination of the productions in Fig. 4 reveals that P1 is the only production whose condition elements are completely matched by working memory elements, so in this case, it fires. We can interpret
The Representation of Children’s Knowledge
91
(030310020) Cycle 1 WM: ((PREDICT) (CRITERION WEIGHT)) F i r e P8: ((PREDICT) () AES --> ATTEND) Output from ATTEND (input t o WM) ::> (weight more lett)(distance more right) Cycle 2 WM: ((DISTANCE MORE RIGHT) (WEIGHT MORE LEFT) (PREDICT) (CRITERION WEIGHT) ) CONFL1CT.SET: (P2 P4) F i r e P4: ((PREDICT) (WEIGHT MORE) (DISTANCE MORE) --> FIND.BIG) Output from FINl3.01G (input t o WM) ::> (distance big right)(weight big left) Cycle 3 WM: ((WEIGHT BIG LEFT) (DISTANCE BIG RIGHT) (PREDICT) (WEIGHT MORE LEFT) (DISTANCE MORE RIGHT) (CRITERION WEIGHT)) COIJFLICT.SET: (P2 P4 P5 P6 P7) CONFC1CT.SET: (P4 P5) AFTER SPECIAL.CASE.ORDER CONrLICT.SET: (P5) AFTER WM.ORDER F i r e P5: ((PREDICT) (CRITERION ~DIMENSION.l>)( BIG <SIDE.l>) ( BIG CSIDE.2.) --> (MADE 4 4 ) (EXPECT <SIDE.l> DOWN) SAY.0)
w#**w*** LEFT d o w n Cycle 4 WM: ((EXPECT LEFT DOWN) (MADE (PREDICT)) (CRITERION WEIGHT) (WEIGHT BIG LEFT) (DISTANCE BIG RIGHT) (WEIGHT MORE LEFT) (DISTANCE MORE RIGHT)) F i r e E l : ((EXPECT) --> LOOK) Output f r o m LOOK (input to WM) ::> (see right down) Cycle 5 WM: ((SEE RIGHT DOWN) (EXPECT LEFT DOWN) (MADE (PREDICT)) (CRITERION WEIGHT) (WEIGHT BIG LEFT) (DISTANCE BIG RIGHT) (WEIGHT MORE LEFT) (DISTANCE MORE RIGHT)) CONFCICT.SET: (E1,E3) F i r e E3: ((EXPECT -4IDE.1, ) (SEE <SIDE.l> (DID **) (SEE ===> SAW) (RESULT WRONG))
Cycle 6 WM: ((RESULT WRONG) (DID (EXPECT LEFT DOWN)) (SAW RIGHT DOWN) (MADE (PREDICT)) (CRITERION WEIGI-IT) (WEIGIdT BIG LEFT) (DISTANCE BIG RIGHT) (WtIGHT MORE LEFT) (DISTANCE MORE RIGHT)) F i r e SW2: ((RESULT WRONG) (CRITERION WEIGHT) --> (OLD **) (WEIGHT ===> DISTANCE)) Cycle 7 WM: ((OLD (RESULT WRONG)) (CRITCRION DISTANCE) (DID (EXPECT LEFT DOWN)) (SAW RIGHT DOWN) (MADE (PREDICT)) (WfIGI4T BIG LEFT) (DISTANCE BIG RIGHT) (WEIGHT MORE LEFT) (DISTANCE MORC R l i l i T ) )
Fig. 5 . Trace of Jan’s production system ( P ) running on a conflict-distance problem. ABS = Absent; WM = working memory, Written in a special language called PSG. See text f o r further explanation.
92
D n i d Klnhr. and Robert S. Siegler-
a production P:(ABC-+DE) as “If you know A and B and c (i.e., if they are currently in WM, in any order), then do actions D and E . ” There are two conflict resolution principles. The first one to be applied, special case order, has already been described. If, after applying special case order, there are still two or more productions in the conflict set, then a second resolution principle, WM order, is applied. This principle chooses the productions with the frontmost element in WM. New information always enters the “front” of WM, pushing all else down a “notch.” Furthermore, when a production fires, its evoking elements are moved to the front of WM (automatic rehearsal). Thus, the WM order conflict resolution principle says, in effect, “when in doubt, respond to the most recently important information.”3 There are several different types of actions: 1 . WM additions. These isimply add new elements to the front of WM. For example, if E3 fired, (result wrong) would be added to the front of WM. Other sources of new information are the encoding operators (described below). 2. WM modifications. Elements in WM can be altered directly. The action (A -+ B) changes symbol A to symbol B in the second element in WM. The action (x**) changes the first element in working memory from A to (X (A)), [e.g., (OLD**) would change (DOG) to ( O L D (DOG))]. 3 . Output. These actions are surrogates for action on the external environment. The only ones used here are say.b (say “balance”) and say.d (say “left [or right] down”).
1. Description of Model (Fig. 4 ) There are three major functional groups of productions.
a . Pn. These correspond to the major nodes in the decision tree representation. PI-P4 are essentially the same as Pl-P4 in Fig. 2; P5, P6, and P7 correspond to the tests for “big” values in Fig. 3. Some of the productions use variables that can be matched by specific values in WM elements. These variables are defined in the first three lines of Fig. 4 in terms of the members of the class on values that the variable can take on. Thus, and can take on the values “weight” or “distance”; <side. 1> and <side.2> can take on the values of “left,” “right,” or “both”; and cdirection> can take on the value “up,” “down,” or “level.” b. En. These control the model’s viewing of the balance scale after it tips, and compare what it expectled to see with what it actually sees.
c . SWn. These change the criterion whenever the system determines (via the E productions) that it has made an incorrect prediction. There are three ’In Fig. 5 and Appendix B , special case order is usually adequate to resolve conflicts. All instances in which WM order is also used are explicitly indicated in the trace.
The Representution of’Children’s Knowledge
93
encoding operators. None are modeled, but their conditions of evocation are explicit, as is the form of the encoding they produce.
d . Attend. “Attend” does initial encoding of weight and distance. This operator can detect sameness or difference of weight or distance and can indicate the side on which weight or distance is greater. Thus, it is only an encoding of relative quantity. The model assumes that i n the first instance this is all that is encoded. e . Find.big. “Find.big” encodes big weight or big distance and side on which they occur (if they occur).
f. Look.
“Look” encodes direction of tipping of scale.
2 . Dynamics of the Model The general procedure is as follows. First weight and distance differences, if any, are encoded. If there is no conflict, then a prediction is made, an expectation is formed, and the scale’s actual behavior is observed. If it is inconsistent with the prediction, then the criterion is changed. If initial encoding reveals no clear prediction, then a second encoding is effected, this time in terms of big distance or weight. Then the rest of the process follows exactly as in the case of a single encoding. Figure 5 contains a trace of the model working on one of the problems from Appendix B. The trace shows the state of working memory at the start of each cycle, as well as which production fired. Conflicts are shown when they occur, as are the results of the encoding operators. The system starts with an element in WM (PREDICT) indicating that it has a goal of making a prediction, and another element representing the current value of the criterion. Since there is no element representing weight or distance, the only production whose conditions are completely satisfied is P8, which tests for (PREDICT) and the absence (ABS) of a weight or distance element (DISTANCE. I ) . ATTEND, P8’s only action, is an encoding operator that is modeled only up to the point of its inpudoutput specifications. In this case the input is presumed to be the physical arrangement of disks on pegs in the configuration (0003/0020), and the outputs, as shown in the trace, are two comparative symbols indicating more weight on the left and more distance on the right. They are directly provided by the model builder. Thus, at the beginning of Cycle 2, WM contains four elements, and these elements satisfy both P4 and P2 (see Fig. 4). P4 is a special case of P2, so it fires. It recognizes that neither weights nor distances are equal, so it attempts a second encoding (FIND.BIG) to determine some absolute amounts of distance andor weight. Once again, an unmodeled encoding operator is assumed to produce two elements, indicating a big distance on the right and a big weight on the left. The results are shown at the start of the third cycle.
94
Datmid Klahr and Robert S . Siegler
Five productions are satisfied by the elements now in WM. P2 and P4 are still satisfied since none of the elements that satisfied them on the previous cycle have been changed. P5, P6, and P 7 are satisfied because they test for either big weight or big distance. Since P4 is a special case of P2, and P5 of P6 and P7, the special case order principle leaves P4 and P5 in the conflict set. But the elements that match P5 are newer than those that match P4, so WM order selects P5 to fire. P5 matches whatever the current value of the criterion is (in this case, it is weight) with the corresponding “big” element (in this case [WEIGHT BIG LEFT]) and then uses the value of the directional variable (LEFT) to form its expectation (EXCEPT LEFT DOWN) and to “say” its prediction. What the system knows at this particular momeilt is revealed by the contents of WM at the start of the fourth cycle. It knows that: It expects the left side to go clown (EXPECT LEFI DOWN);
It already made a prediction (MADE (PREDICT)); The current criterion is weight (CRITERION WEIGHT); And it knows the enccdings (WEIGHT BIG LEFT) (DISTANCE BIG LEFT), and (DISTANCE MORE RIGHT).
RIGHT), (WEIGHT MORE
The rest of the trace is straightforward. During Cycle 4, the system seeks an encoding of what the scale actually did, and it sees that the right side went down. On Cycle 5, it recognizes that what it saw is discrepant with what it expected (E3), so it knows that it got the problem wrong. Finally, on Cycle 6, it recognizes that it was wrong while using the weight criterion, so it changes it to distance. G . EVALUATION OF REPRESENTATIONS FOR JAN’S KNOWLEDGE
The decision tree in Fig. 3 and the production system in Fig. 4 are logically equivalent: Both account for all but the last of Jan’s predictions during the training series. As described above, they differ from the representations in Figs. 1 and 2 in that they model that subject’s response to feedback, and because they both represent idiosyncratic encodings of the stimulus. Thus, both models have certain advantages over the previous ones. However, the models are not equivalent in all respects, and the psychological properties of the production system-properties previously just alluded to-can now be clarified. The production system, since it embodies a general model of the human-information prccessing system, forces us to form very explicit hypotheses about things that the decision tree lets us finesse. There is no separation of control information from data in a production system. Every relevant piece of information is explicitly represented in WM, and all task-specific knowledge for acting on that information is represented by productions. As indicated by the final list of elements, we are postulating a sizable amount of
The Representation of Children’s Knowledge
95
material floating around in WM. It is clear that the size of WM is well beyond the estimated short-term memory capacity of from seven (Miller, 1956) to as little as three or four (Broadbent, 1975) items, or the “M-space” estimates (PascualLeone, 1970) in the same range. However, it is unclear how a system that did not have immediate access to all of this momentary knowledge could ever d o the task. Questions about the amount of control information sufficient to perform the task are not addressed by the decision tree representation. For all their emphasis on the importance of the outputs from the encoding operators, however, the production system models do not describe the encoding process itself. Neither do they indicate precisely what sort of encoding deficit might affect response to instruction. A remedy to the former limitations would take the form of a model of encoding, and we leave that for future investigation. The second issue, that of the nature and effect of encoding deficits, is directly related to Questions 4 and 5 of our initial set. The specific questions are (1) whether encoding deficits are in fact typical of the younger children, and (2) if such deficits exist, whether they account for the younger children’s inability to benefit from instruction on conflict problems. These questions were investigated in Experiment 3.
VIII. Experiment 3: Encoding Hypothesis Recall that the results of Experiment 2 indicated that older and younger children, equated for initial task-specific knowledge about the balance scale, responded quite differently to the training sequences. This finding motivated a shift in the representation and in the level, or grain, of our analysis of what was going on during training. Lisa’s protocol analysis revealed her difficulty in determining the appropriate encoding of the two relevant dimensions, and the analysis of Jan’s responses during training led to a production system which incorporated two levels of encoding-one relative, one absolute (bighot big)-for both dimensions. Analysis of other protocols revealed many such stimulus misencodings. This, together with the sizable literature on the development of attentional strategies (cf. Pick, Frankel, & Hess, 1975; Zeaman & House, 1963) suggested to us that differential encoding might be the cause of the differential responsiveness to instruction. Siegler (1976) described three steps that are necessary to test this hypothesis rigorously. ( 1) Assess encoding independently of predictive performance and establish the hypothesized encoding differences. (2) Show that the appropriate manipulation can eliminate or at least reduce encoding differences. (3) Demonelimistrate that when the difference on the explanatory variable-encoding-is nated, the initially observed difference on the to-be-explained variableresponsiveness to instruction-is also eliminated. In summary, then, the goal
David Klahr and Robert S. Siegler
96
was to show that i n a group of older and younger children who were all using Model I initially, there would be a consistent encoding deficit in the younger children, then to eliminate this deficit, and finally to expose both groups to the training sequence and to produce identical learning in both age groups. Attempting to do this at the fine-grained level of the preceding section would have led to a mass of detailed variation that would make it very difficult to verify the general properties of encoding differences; it also would have been prohibitively expensive in terms of time and effort. Therefore, in this section, we move back up to a more aggregated level of analyses. A.
RECONSTRUCTION PARADIGM
Chase and Simon (1973) utilized a reconstruction paradigm to study the differential ability of chess masters and nonmasters to extract meaningful information from briefly presented board configurations. This procedure suggested to us a means by which differences between older and younger children’s encoding of balance scale configurations could be assessed independently of their predictions about the effect of these configurations on the scale’s behavior. In the third experiment in this series, 5- and 8-year-old children were presented with various configurations of weights on a balance scale for a few seconds (the scale was not free to tip). Then the scale was removed from view, and the children were required to reconstruct the initial configuration as accurately as possible on an empty scale. Note that this procedure allowed independent assessment of encoding on both weight and distance dimensions. For example, when given an initial configuration (0300/0200) the child might reconstruct it, for example, as (0300/0200), or (0030/2000), or (0200/0100), or (0010/0003), revealing, respectively, no mi,sencoding, distance only misencoding, weight only misencoding, and both weight and distance misencodings. Our protocol analyses led us to expect that the older children would be accurate on both dimensions, while the younger children would do well on weight but poorly on distance.
1. Basic Procedure The same basic procedure was followed in all phases of Experiment 3, and the full details are given in Siegler (1976). Here we will only describe the major features. Overall, 40 kindergartners (“5-year-olds”) and 30 third-graders (“8year-olds”) from two public schools in Pittsburgh participated in Experiment 3. Two identical balance scales were used. They were slightly different from the one used previously, having seven rather than four pegs on each side of the fulcrum, and having a built-in lever rather than wood blocks to keep the scale from tipping until the experimenter released it. A large Styrofoam board was used to hide one of the balance scales during the reconstruction phases.
The Representiirron of Children’s Knowledge
97
The encoding test included 16 problems, on each of which there were from three to five weights on each side, all located on either the third, fourth, or fifth peg from the fulcrum. On any given problem, only one peg on each side was occupied. Children were tested individually in a vacant room in their school. Each child was presented the encoding test first, and then presented the same 24-item predictions task (without feedback) used in the Experiment 2 posttest. For the encoding test, the children were told: The idea of the first game is for you to look how the weights are set on the pegs on my balance scale and then make the same problem by putting the weights on the pegs on yours. First 1’11 put the weights on the pegs on my scale. You should watch closely to see how the weights are set on the pegs. Then I’ll put the Styrofoam board hack up so you can’t see my scale. You will then need to put the weights on the pegs on your scale in the same way that you saw them on my scale. Just put the weights on the pegs so it’s just like the problem you saw on my scale.
After the first trial, children were again told, “Remember, you should watch closely to see how the weights are on the pegs on my scale so that you can put the weights on your scale in the same way.” Children were allowed 10 seconds to observe the initial configurations, and then they were allowed to reconstruct the arrangement immediately on the other scale. There was no time limit for reconstruction, although children usually finished quickly. Following the last encoding trial, children were told that they were to play another game, and instructions similar to the previous predictions trials were given. The encoding and predictions tasks were given in a single session lasting about 25 minutes. There were several variations on this basic procedure. We will describe each variation and its results in sequence. The results from all phases are shown in three forms. Table VII shows the percentage of correct distance and weight encoding for both age groups. A strict criterion of perfect reconstruction of both sides of the scale was used for both weight and distance scoring. Table VIII shows the percentage correct predictions for each type of problem, and Table IX shows the classification by model type for each age group in each phase of Experiment 3.
2 . Experiment 3a Ten children from each age level participated in the experiment exactly as described above. As shown in Table V11, the results were consistent with the encoding hypothesis. The younger children showed a great disparity between their ability to reproduce weight and their ability to reproduce distance while the older children did not show a significant difference. This pattern held for individual subjects in each age group, and is not the result of aggregating over subjects (see Siegler, 1976, for more extensive statistical analyses of these re-
98
David Klahr and Robert S . Siegler
sults). Notice that these encoding differences between older and younger children were not accompanied by a corresponding difference in ability to predict how the balance scale would behave. A s shown in Tables VIIl and IX, there was virtually no difference in the percentage of different types of problems passed or in the distribution of children using each model.
3. Experiment 3b In this variant, 10 5-year-olds were given 15 rather than 10 seconds to view the initial configuration during the encoding tests. This was done to explore the possibility that the younger children were simply a bit slower than the older ones in encoding the configuration;s. If they were attempting to encode both dimensions, and had a preferred noticing order of weight first, then giving them more time would be expected to improve their distance scores. As shown in Table VII, this “insufficient time” explanation is unsupported by the results. 4 . Experiment 3c
Perhaps the younger children did not understand what was meant by “make the same problem.” In this variant, the children were told explicitly what to encode, and what constituted the experimenter’s criterion for the “same” problem. Ten children of each age level participated. The instructions for the encoding task were changed to the following: The idea of the first game is for you to look how the weights are set on the pegs on my balance scale and then to make the same problem by putting the weights on the pegs on yours. You want it to be the same problem in two ways. You want the same number of weights on each side of your scale a s 1 had on my scale, and you want the weights on each side of your scale to be the same distance from the center as they were on my scale.
Later in the instructions, children were again told that they should “watch closely to see how the weights. are set on pegs-how many there are on each side
TABLE VIl Percentage Correct Encodings-Experiment
3
5-year-olds
Experiment 3a 3b 3c 3d
8-year-olds
Weight encodings
Distance encodings
Weight encodings
Distance encodings
51 54
73
56
54
16 9 19
52
51
64 72
73 76
TABLE VIII Percentage Correct Predictions-Experiment
Experiment 3a
3h 3c 3d 3e
3
Age (years)
Balance
Weight
Distance
Conflict-weight
Conflict-distance
5 8
95 98
100 100
8 5
100 100
2 0
5 5
85 72 100
18 18 30
92 12 90
8
8
5 8 5 8
72
85 90 98 92 100 89 I00
22 22 12 94
86 100
100
92 100
89 61
12 20 17 0 33 50
Conflict-balance 0
0 2 15
0
6 0 0 0
Davi,d Klahr and Robert S . Siegler
I00
TABLE IX Number of Children Using Different Models-Experiment
3
Models
Experiment 3a 3b 3C
3d 3e
Age (years) 5 8 5
5 8 5 8 5 8
1
I1
111
Unclassifiable
9 8 7 7 6 6 6 1 0
0 1 0 0 2 0 1 3 3
0 0 0 0 1 0 0 4 7
I
I 3 3 I 4 3 2 0
and how far from the center the weights on each side are.” Finally, at the end of the instructions, children were asked to indicate the two ways their arrangements should be like the experimenter’s. This was to ensure that they understood what they had been told. The few children who did not understand were presented the instructions again and asked the identical question until they could answer appropriately. In all other ways, the procedure was the same as that used in Experiment 3b, with a 15-second viewing period. Once again, as shown in T,ables VII, VIII, and IX, the results differed hardly at all from those of Experiments 3a and 3b. Telling children what to encode did not reduce the discrepancy between their encoding of weight and distance, nor did it improve their performance on the predictions task.
5 . Experiment 3d This time, children were told not only what to encode, but also how to encode it. If the problem lay in the inability of the younger children to correctly encode distance, or to handle two dimensions simultaneously, then perhaps direct instruction might help them. Ten children of each age group were given the following additional instructions during the encoding trials: You do it like this. First you count the number of weights on this sid-ne, two, three, four. Then you count the number of pegs the weights are from the center-first, second, third. So you say to yourself “four weights on the third peg.” Then you would do the same for the other sid-ne, two, three, four, five weights on the first, second, third peg. So it would be five weights on the third peg. Then you would say “four weights on the third peg and five weights on third peg.” Then you would piut the right number of weights on the right pegs on each side. Let’s practice one.
The Represen!urron 01 Children's Knowledge
101
This was followed by seven practice trials on which the child received feedback on the correct counting of weights and distances. This procedure was expected to reduce or eliminate the weight-distance discrepancy for the younger children, but since the older children presumably already knew how and what to encode, it was not expected to affect their performance. No effect was expected on the predictions performance of either group. All of these expectations were confirmed. Table VII shows that the younger children performed equally well on weight and distance, and that the older children performed better overall, but with no weightdistance discrepancy. Tables VIII and IX show that the predictions performance of both groups was indistinguishable from previous results.
6 . Experiment 3e Having finally eliminated the younger children's encoding deficit, we next asked whether that deficit really was the cause of the initial differential responsiveness to instruction. In this final experiment, the same children who participated in Experiment 3d were given the conflict training sequence used in Experiment 2 a few days after they completed Experiment 3d. According to the encoding hypothesis, both older and younger children should now benefit from experience with conflict problems that previously had benefited only the older children. Following the training sequence, the predictions test (without feedback) was again given to the two groups. The results of this posttraining predictions test are shown in Row 3e of Tables VIII and IX. Note that Rows 3d and 3e are based on the same set of subjects at different times. The sequence of manipulations and their corresponding results were: ( 1 ) instructions about what and how to encode; ( 2 ) encoding task (Table VII, Row 3d); (3) predictions task (Tables VIIl and IX, Row 3d); (4) conflict training with feedback, a few days later; and (5) repeat of predictions task (Tables VIII and IX, Row 3e). Comparison of Rows 3d and 3e i n Tables VIII and IX shows that training now aided both age groups. Although there appears to be a slight advantage overall for the older children, there were no significant effects for either age alone, and no age-problem type interaction. It seems clear that the qualitative differences in responsiveness to training were eliminated by prior training in encoding. Although the younger children did not benefit as much as the older, it should be remembered that their encoding performance also did not reach the level of the older children. B.
SUMMARY
The results of Experiment 3 provide strong support for the encoding hypothesis: Younger children clearly do not tend to encode the distance dimension in this task. Without such encoding, they can derive little benefit from the instruction series. However, if given careful and explicit instruction on encoding,
102
David Klahr and Robert S . Siegler
they do begin to do it correctly, and such improvement subsequently enables them to benefit spontaneously from a training sequence.
IX. Discussion: Some Answers and Some Further Questions In this final section we will briefly summarize the work reported thus far, and give some indication of possible future efforts. A.
WHERE WE HAVE BEEN
Let us summarize where this series of investigations has taken us in our attempt to address the five questions posed at the outset. Question 1: What are the differences in knowledge that underlie different levels of task performance? The results of Experiment 1 indicated that the four models, in either decision tree or production system fomiulation, could accurately represent different kinds of knowledge that underlie distinct behavior patterns. Question 2: What are the alternative strategies that might result in any given level of task performance? Our analysis defined levels in terms of four modal forms of rule systems. Thus, neither representation could account for alternative means by which a subject might be generating the pattern of responses that led to his classification according to the models. However, the comparison of predictions and explanations for the Model I11 children suggested that such variations were indeed occurring. Detailed analysis of Lisa’s protocol further indicated the need to account for individual variations, and with the construction of Model IIIA for Jan we began to demonstrate how these representations could account for highly idiosyncratic processes underlying Model I11 response patterns. As we argued earlier, the advantage of the production system representation for this individual level lay in its explicit set of psychological assumptions, assumptions that are consistent with a developing general view of some of the properties of the human information-processing system. Question 3: For a given level of performance, what is the optimal level of difficulty for an instructional sequence? The results of Experiment 2 provided a specific example of the general view that “near” training is better than “far” training. Although the particular definitions of “near” and “far’” were clearly derived from the underlying representation for knowledge on the task, we did not do enough parametric variation
The Representution of Children’s Knowledge
I03
to be able to claim true optimality. However, the dimensions along which an investigation of such variation could take place are very clear. Question 4: What are the critical features of an instructional sequence that enable it to have any effect? The results of Experiment 2 demonstrated that experience with particular types of problems is critically important for improving subsequent performance. This sensitivity was derivable from the initial modal forms of the models. In addition, the role of negative feedback was specified in Jan’s model, which is responsive to a mismatch between expectations and the actual outcome of each trial. Question 5 : When and why will two learners at the same initial performance level learn differently from the same instructional sequence? Most of the development of the protocol analysis and the final production system model for Jan was stimulated by our attempt to answer this question. In Experiment 2 we detected the differential response to experience; Lisa’s protocol suggested the encoding hypothesis; Jan’s production system indicated the potential complexity and importance of encoding operators and suggested the operational form of the encoding hypothesis, for which the results of Experiment 3 provided strong support. B.
WHERE WE ARE GOING
These investigations have suggested further explorations in two interacting domains: conceptualization of models and experimental studies. 1 . Types of Knowledge in the Human Information-Processing System
Our exploration of the issues surrounding the evaluation of different representations for knowledge has revealed that it is possible to distinguish between several different types of knowledge. The suitability of a representation depends upon the particular type of knowledge in which we are interested. In this section, we will briefly indicate what appear to us to be distinctly different kinds of knowledge. The order in which they are described corresponds roughly to their degree of permanence and stability in the human information-processing system. a. K1: Knowledge About the Momentary State of Affairs. This is the knowledge represented by the elements in WM in a production system, or in the more general concept of “active memory” in other cognitive theories. In a production system, all the productions are continually attempting to recognize familiar elements of K1, and to act upon it through modification. K1 represents what is “going on” from one moment to the next. It contains information about the environment-information that has been produced by encoding operations
104
David Klahr and Robert S. Siegler
and by the actions of satisfied productions. It constitutes a record of the system's immediate past. 6 . K2: Knowledge About h'ow to Do a Task or Solve a Problem. This type of knowledge is represented by decision trees of the sort used in Figs. 1 and 3 , or by the productions in a production system. The knowledge in K2 typically consists of tests for the type of knowledge represented by K1. A production system provides a convenient
The Repre.wnrtirion of Children’s Knowledge
I05
capacity refer to changes in the amount and type of K I (Chi, 1976; Huttenlocher & Burke, 1976), while studies of “metacognition” (Flavell, 1976) would appear to be primarily addressed to the development of the interaction between K2 and K3. Questions about “readiness” refer to the K2-K4 interaction and issues related to the competence-performance distinction seem to involve the interplay between K5 and K3, that is, between the “deep” interpretive capacity of the system and particular task-specific knowledge.
2. Experimental Extensiotis The results of our experiments suggest a number of directions for further research. One would be to examine problem isomorphs-tasks similar to the balance scale in formal properties but differing in specific characteristics. Efforts in this direction have already been made. Decision tree models have been formulated and tested on Inhelder and Piaget’s (1958) projection of shadows task, Bruner and Kenney’s (1966) fullness of a water jar task, and Chapman’s (1975) probability learning task. In each case the models have been found to accurately represent children’s predictive perfonnance. The experiments have also revealed a rich variety of reactions to feedback and encoding strategies (Siegler & Vago, in press). Another approach would be to construct and test more detailed production system models of exactly how children encode balance scale and other problems: Detailed analyses of reaction times might provide the appropriate test for such models. Finally, a host of instructional issues might be examined such as: When should tasks be taught directly and when should appropriate encoding strategies be taught first? Can procedures be devised to teach effective encoding on a variety of problems, or must instruction in encoding proceed on a task by task basis? Do differences i n encoding account for individual differences among children of a given age, as well as developmental differences? Pursuing these problems will almost certainly lead to new insights about the five questions posed at the outset of this paper, and also to new questions.
X.
Conclusion
Representation of children’s knowledge requires that we make testable assertions about both the basic encoding of the environment and the processes that operate on those encodings. Cognitive development and instructional procedures involve changes in both the encoding operators and the rule systems. Instruction will tend to be ineffective if the instructional situation is encoded by the learner in a manner that is unexpected by the instructor. In a limited domain, we have demonstrated that such misencoding was indeed occurring, that we could locate the point of difficulty, eliminate it, and have instruction proceed as we expected it to.
David Klahr and Robert S . Siegler
106
From a broader viewpoint, we have tried to show that the appropriate representation for knowledge depends upon the goals of the scientific endeavor. Different kinds of knowledge are best represented by different formalisms, and are best investigated by different empirical procedures. This pluralistic view of knowledge representation ma,y facilitate our understanding of, and influence upon, what it is that children know.
Appendix A Protocol Excerpts from Lisa, a 5-Year-Old, on Training Sequence 00400 TI
0001/2000
4:46
00500
00600 E. Okay, Let’s put these two here, and this one here. 00700 S . This side will go down (points left). 00800 E. Which side? Touch the side that will go down. 00900 S . (Touches left side) 01000 E. Okay. Let’s see if you were right. (Removes blocks. Scale tips left-up; right-down.) 0 1 100 Were you right? 01200 S . (Nods no) 01300 E. Which side went down? 01400 S . (Points right) 01500 E. Okay. Why do you think that was? Why did you think before this side would go down? Oi600 01700 S . ’Cause that one (points left) didn’t have as much as that one (points right). 01800 01900 E. Uh-huh. But what actuallj happened? 02000 S . This side went down because that one’s heavier (points right). 02100 02200 T3 0100/1OOO 6:lO 02300 02400 E. Okay. What do you think will happen this time? 02500 S. They will both stay up. 02600 E. Why do you think that? 02700 S. ’Cause they are both the same. 02800 E. Let’s see if you are right. (Removes blocks. Scale tips left-down.) Were you right? 02900 03000 S. (Nods yes) 03100 E. You were? Look. Do they both. . , Are they balanced? Is it like it was before? 03200 03300 S . Well, why are they both the same thing and one’s up and one’s down? 03400 E. Why do you think that is? 03500 S . I don’t h o w . 03600 03700 T4 0020/0020 7:00 03800 03900 E. Okay. What do you think will happen this time?
The Representation of Children’s Knowledge
107
04OOO S . The same again. 04100 E. They will stay the same again. why do you think that? 04200 S. ’Cause. Wait a minute. It won’t. 04300 E. It won’t? 04400 S. ’Cause this one (points left) is closer to this one (points to fulcrum). And this one (points right) is closer to this one (points to fulcrum). 04500 04600 E. So what will happen? 04700 S. This side (points right) will go up. 04800 E. This side will go up? 04900 S. Uh-huh. 05000 E. Okay. What do you mean by “up”? Point which way it will go. 05100 S. I think.. . 05200 E. Which? 05300 S. . . . it will go down. 05400 E. This side will go down (points left)? 05500 S. Uh-huh (nods yes). 05600 E. And this side. , . and so it will be like this? (Tilts balance manually left-down; right-up.) 05700 05800 S. Uh-huh. 05900 E. Is that right? 06OOO S. Uh-huh. 06100 E. Okay, let’s see if you are right. (Removes blocks, Scale tips right-down.) Were you right? 06200 06300 S. (Nodsno) 06400 E. What happened? 06500 S. This went down (points right). 06600 E. Why do you think that is? 06700 S. I don’t know! 06800 E. Well, think about it. 06900 S . Ummmm. 07000 E. Okay. 07100 S . I just don’t know why. 07200 E. You just don’t know why. 07300 S. Uh-huh. 07400 E. Well, we’ll keep on working and maybe you’ll figure it out. 07500 07600 07700 0102/2010 943 07800 T6 07900 08000 E. Okay, what will happen on this one? 08100 S. Yes. This side (points right) will both stay the same (points to both sides). 08200 08300 E. Let’s see i f . . . Why do you think that? 08400 S. Because they both look the same. One is empty in the middle and one is empty in the 08500 middle. 08600 E. Okay (scale balances). . . , Were you right‘? 08700 S. (Nodsyes) 08800 E. Uh-huh. You were. That’s right. 08900 S. 1 was right!
David Klahr and Robert S. Siegler
I08
09OOO 09100 09200 09300 09400 09500 09600 09700 09800 09900
E. That’s right.
T7
0200/2000
10:25
E. All righty. Now, what will happen this time? S. This side (points left) is farther away from this (indicates fulcrum), and this side (points right) is closer to this (indicates fulcrum). So, I think this side (points left) will go up. And this side will go down (points right).
IOOOO E. Let’s see if you are right. (Removes blocks left-down.) Were you right?
10100 S. Uh-uh (no). 10200 E. What happened? 10300 S. (Points left, center, right, and up) 10400 E. What? 10500 S. This went up (points right:) and this went down (points left). I thought this would go up 10600 (points left). 10700 E. Okay. Try to figure out what’s happening. 10800 S. Hm. 1 don’t know why. 10900 E. Well you just keep on trying to figure out. 1 1000 11100 11200 11300 E7 OOO3/0004 26:46 11400 11500 S. I’m ready. Ha, wait a minute, 1 forgot. 1 did it wrong. I gotta think. . . (can’t hear). This is four. This is three. This one will go down (points right). I1600 11700 I1800 E. What do you think would happen if we put one more here? What do you think would I1900 happen? [0004/0004] 12000 S. Both stay the same. This lone is crooked a little bit (adjusts right weights). 12100 12200 E. What do you think’ll happen? 12300 S. Stay the same. 12400 E. Yeah? Let’s see if you’re right. (Removes blocks. Scale tips rightdown, with sharp rap as it hits table.) Did they? 12500 12600 S. No! 12700 E. No? No, they didn’t. Did they? 12800 S. Plunk. Plunk. 12900 E. Plunk! Why do you think that was? 13000 S. I don’t know. They both ‘had four. See, one, two (counts left): one, two, three, four; 13100 (counts right): one, two, three, four. 13200 E. They both have four. Is that what made this side go down so much and this side go up SO 13300 much? 13400 S. No. 13500 E. What do you think it was? 13600 S. I don’t know. 13700 E. Think about it. What could it be? 13800 S. I just don’t know.
The Represvnrtirron of Children’s Knowledge
I09
13900 E. Just don’t know. Look at it for a moment and b y to figure out what it could be. Real 14000 carefully. 14100 S. This one is far away (points right) and this one is close (points left). 14200 14300 E. Okay. Have any other ideas? 14400 S. Uh-uh (no). 14500 14600 14700 E8. 0003/3000 28:40 14800 14900 E. Okay. Now, want to make up another problem? 15000 S. Uh-huh. 15100 E. Okay. 15200 S. This one is gonna be a good one. Stay the same. 15300 E. You think so? 15400 S. Uh-huh. 15500 E. Okay, let’s see if you’re right. (Removes blocks. Scale balances.) Were YOU right? I5600 15700 S. Uh-huh! 15800 E. Yeah, you were. 15900 S. I’m being right and right and right, but one time I was wrong. 16000 16100 16200 16300 E9 0003/0003 2926 16400 16500 16600 E. (Requests information on how scale works, and about what would happen on this trial.) 16700 16800 S . There’s three, and this side (points right) would go down, I guess. 16900 E. That side would go down? 17000 S. And this side would go up (points left). 17100 E. Why? 17200 S. Because this is far away (points right) and this is close (points left). So 1 think it would. 17300 17400 E. Think so? 17500 S. Uh-huh. 17600 E. Let’s see if you’re right. 17700 S. Ohh! Right! 17800 17900 E. What would you do to make it balance, now? (S. starts to move scale manually to balance 18000 position.) No. , . . I mean by moving the little, . . little circles around. What could you do 18100 to make that balance? 18200 18300 S. This three here (points to right, first peg), and this three stay here (points left). 18400 [0003/30001 18500 E. Let’s see if that’s right, what you do. 18600 S. I have to hold this up. (Lifts right side and moves weights.) [0003/3000] 18700 E. Are you right?
David Klahr and Robert S. Siegler
110
18800 S. 18900 19OOO E. 19100 S. 19200 E. 19300 S. 19400 19500 E. 19600 19700 S .
(Nods yes) What would you do to make the other side go down? Whoops. [3000/3000]That side will go up (points right). Whoops, there. Why does that happen? Because that one’s far away (points left) and that one’s close (points right).
I see. But if both had them far away. [3000/0003]Both sides would go down (giggle). They balance.
Appendix B Trace of production system for Model IIIA on four problems from Table VI. Assume that at start of Problem 5, criterion is set to distance, and retain final criterion value when moving on to next problem. Start with Problem 5. (Notation: Production system written in a special language called PSG. Numbers shown are counts of actions taken since start of each problem. Abbreviations are used for terms such as weight, distance, (etc.) Problem 5
(8288/8488)
0. WM: ((PRED) (CRITERION DST) ) Fire P8: ((PRED) (DI) ABS --* ATTEND) (wgt more right) (dst more left) ATTENDING-INPUT NEXT STIMULUS 1. WM: ((DST MORE LEFT) (WGT MORE RIGHT) (PRED) (CRITERION DST) ) CONFL1CT.SET: (P2 P4) Fire P4: ((PRED) (WGT MORE) (DST MORE) FIND.BIG) ATTENDING-INPUT NEXT STIMULUS 3 (wgt big right) (dst big left) 2 . WM: ((DST BIG LEFT) (WGT BIG RIGHT) (PRED) (WGT MORE RIGHT) (DST MORE LEFT) (CRITERION DST) ) CONFLICT.SET: (P2 P4 P5 P6 P7) CONFLICTSET: (P4 P5) AFTER SPECIAL.CASE.ORDER CONFLICT.SET: (P5) AFTER WM.ORDER (MADE **) (EXPECT XI Fire P5: ((PRED) (CRITERION DI) (D1 BIG XI) (D2 BIG X2)-+ DOWN) SAY.D)
+
-
6 . WM: ((EXPECT LEFT DOWN) (MADE (PRED)) (CRITERION DST) (DST BIG LEFT) (WGT BIG RIGHT) (WGT MORE RIGHT) (DST MORE LEFT) ) Fire E l : ((EXPECT) - 4 LOOK) ATTENDING-INPUT NEXT STIMULUS = (see right down)
Ill
The Representation of Children’s Knowledge
7. WM: ((SEE RIGHT DOWN) (EXPECT LEFT DOWN) (MADE PRED)) (CRITERION DST) (DST BIG LEFT) (WGT BIG RIGHT) (WGT MORE RIGHT) (DST MORE LEFT) ) CONFLICT.SET: (El E3) CONFLICT. SET: (E3) AFTER SPECIAL .CASE. ORDER Fire E3: ((EXPECT XI X2) (SEE X1 X2) ABS (SEE) --+ (DID **) (SEE SAW) (RESULT WRONG))
==+
10. WM: ((RESULT WRONG) (DID EXPECT LEFT DOWN (SAW RIGHT DOWN) (MADE (PRED)) (CRITERION DST) (DST BIG LEFT) (WGT BIG RIGHT) (WGT MORE RIGHT) (DST MORE LEFT)) Fire SW1: ((RESULT WRONG) (CRITERION DST) --+ (OLD **) (DST WGT))
==+
12. WM: ((OLD (RESULT WRONG)) (CRITERION WGT) (DID (EXPECT LEFT DOWN)) (SAW RIGHT DOWN) (MADE (PRED)) (DST BIG LEFT) (WGT BIG RIGHT) (WGT MORE RIGHT) (DST MORE LEFT) )
Now do Problem 6 . Keep criterion.
TE: ((010212010))
8. WM: ((PRED) (CRITERION WGT) ) CONFLICT.SET: (P8) Fire P8: ((PRED) (Dl) ABS -+ ATTEND) ATTENDING-INPUT NEXT STIMULUS j (dst same) (wgt same) 1. WM: (WGT SAME) (DST SAME) (PRED) (CRITERION WGT)) Fire P1: ((PRED) (WGT SAME) -+ (MADE **) (EXPECT BALANCE EVEN) SAY.B)
5. WM: (EXPECT BALANCE EVEN) (MADE (PRED)) (WGT SAME) (DST SAME) (CRITERION WGT) ) Fire E l : ((EXPECT) -+ LOOK) ATTENDING-INPUT NEXT STIMULUS j(see balance even) 6 . WM: ((SEE BALANCE EVEN) (EXPECT BALANCE EVEN) (MADE (PRED)) (WGT SAME) (DST SAME) (CRITERION WGT) ) CONFLICT.SET: (El E2) CONFLICT.SET: (E2) AFTER SPECIAL.CASE.ORDER SAW) (RESULT Fire E2: ((EXPECT X1 X2) (SEE XI X2) -+ (DID **) (SEE ==j CORRECT)) 9. WM: ((RESULT CORRECT) (DID (EXPECT BALANCE EVEN)) (SAW BALANCE EVEN) (MADE (PRED)) (WGT SAME) (DST SAME) (CRITERION WGT))
10. Wh4: ((OLD (RESULT CORRECT)) (CRITERION WGT) (DID (EXPECT BALANCE EVEN)) (SAW BALANCE EVEN) (MADE (PRED)) (WGT SAME) (DST SAME) )
I12
David Klahr and Robert S. Siegler
Problem 7 (888318820)
0. WM: ((PRED) (CRITERION WGT) ) ATTENDING-INPUT
NEXT STIMULUS j (wgt more left) (dst more right)
1. WM: ((DST MORE RIGHT) (WGT MORE LEFT) (PRED) (CRITERION WGT) )
C0NFLICT.SET: (P2 P4) C0NFLICT.SET: (P4) AFTER SPECIAL.CASE. ORDER Fire P4: ((PRED) (WGT MORE) (DST MORE) -+ FIND.BIG) AlTENDING-INPUT NEXT STIMULUS 3 (dst big right) (wgt big left) 2. WM: ((WGT BIG LEFT) (DST 131G RIGHT) (PRED) (WGT MORE LEFT) (DST MORE RIGHT) (CRITERION WGT) ) CONFLICTSET: (P2 P4 P5 P6 P7) C0NFLICT.SET: (P4 P5) AFTEiR SPECIAL.CASE.ORDER C0NFLICT.SET: (P5) AFTER WM.ORDER Fire P5: ((PRED) (CRITERION DI) (D1 BIG X1) (D2 BIG X2) -+ (MADE **) (EXPECT X1 DOWN) SAY.D)
6. W M ((EXPECT LEFT DOWN) (MADE (PRED)) (CRITERION WGT) (WGT BIG LEFT) (DST BIG RIGHT) (WGT MORE LEFT) (DST MORE RIGHT) ) CONFLI(JT.SET: (El) Fire El: ((EXPECT) -+ LOOK) A'ITENDING-INPUT NFXT STIMULUS j (see right down) 7. WM: ((SEE RIGHT DOWN) (EXPECT LEFT DOWN) (MADE (PRED)) (CRITERION WGT) (WGT BIG LEFI') (DST BIG RIGHT) (WGT MORE LEFT) (DST MORE RIGHT ) ) CONFLICTSET: (El E3) CONFLICT.SET: (E3) AFTER SPECIAL.CASE.ORDER AW Fire E3: ((EXPECT XI X2) (SEE XI X2) ABS (SEE) - + (DID **) (SEE = =Sj (RESULT WRONG))
18. W M ((RESULT WRONG) (DID (EXPECT LEFT DOWN)) (SAW RIGHT DOWN) (MADE PRED)) (CRITERION WGT) (WGT BIG L E W (DST BIG RIGHT) (WGT MORE LEFT) (DST MORE RIGHT) ) Fire SW2: ((RESULT WRONG) (1CRITERION WGT) -+ (OLD **) (WGT ==3 DST)) 12. W M ((OLD (RESULT WRONG)) (CRITERION DST) (DID (EXPECT LEFT DOWN)) (SAW RIGHT DOWN) (MADE (PRED)) (WGT BIG LEFT) (DST BIG RIGHT) (WGT MORE LEFT) (DST MORE RIGHT) ) Problem 8 (0188/0288) [notice, this has big dst, but not big wgt]
0. W M ((PRED) (CRITERION DST) ) Fire P8: ((PRED) ( D l ) ABS -+ A'ITEND) ATTENDING-INPUT NEXT STIMULUS j (wgt more right) (dst more left) TE:((0188/0200))
The Repre.wnratron (JJ Children's Knowledge
I13
1. WM: ((DST MORE LEFT) (WGT MORE RIGHT) (PRED) (CRITERION DST) ) CONFLICTSET: (P2 P4) CONFLICT.SET: (P4) AFTER SPECIAL.CASE.ORDER Fire P4: ((PRED) (WGT MORE) (DST MORE) -+ FIND.BIG) ATTENDING-INPUT NEXT STIMULUS 3 (dst big left)
2. WM: ((DST BIG LEFT) (PRED) (WGT MORE RIGHT) (DST MORE LEFT) (CRITERION DST)) CONFLICT.Sm: (P2 P4 P7) CONFLICT.SET: (P4 P7) AFTER SPECIAL.CASE.0RDER CONFLICT.SET: (P7) AFTER WM.ORDER Fire P7: ((PRED) (DST BIG X1) -+ (MADE **) (EXPECT X1 DOWN) SAY.D)
********** LEFT down 6. WM: ((EXPECT LEFT DOWN) (MADE PRED)) (DST BIG LEFT) (WGT MORE RIGHT) (DST MORE LEFT) (CRITERION DST) ) Fire El: ((EXPECT) -+ LOOK) ATTENDING-INPUT NEXT STIMULUS 3 (see right down) 7. WM: ((SEE RIGHT DOWN) (EXPECT LEFT DOWN) (MADE (PRED)) (CRITERION WGT) (WGT MORE RIGHT) (DST MORE LEFT) (CRITERION DST) ) CONFLICT.SET: (El E3) CONFLICT .SET: (E3) AFTER SPECIAL .CASE. ORDER FireE3:((EXPECTXlX2)(SEEXlX2)ABS(SEE)(DID**)(DID**)(SEE 11 11SAW) (RESULT WRONG)) 18. WM: ((RESULT WRONG) (DID (EXPECT LEFT DOWN)) (SAW RIGHT DOWN) (MADE PRED)) (DST BIG LEFT) (WGT MORE RIGHT) (DST MORE LEFT) (CRITERION DST) ) Fire SWI: ((RESULT WRONG) (CRITERION EST)--+ (OLD **) ( D S T = = + WGT))
12. WM: ((OLD (RESULT WRONG)) (CRITERION WGT) (DID (EXPECT LEFT DOWN)) (SAW RIGHT DOWN) (MADE (PRED)) (DST BIG LEFQ (WGT MORE RIGHT) (DST MORE LEFQ )
ACKNOWLEDGMENTS This study was supported by grants from The Spencer Foundation, by Public Health Service Grant MH-07722 from the National Institute of Mental Health, and by a grant from the Sloan Foundation. Thanks to S. Famham-Diggory, C. Glenn, and A. Newell for comments on an earlier version.
REFERENCES Baylor, G. W., & Gascon, J. An information processing theory of aspects of the development of weight seriation in children. Cognitive Psychology, 1974, 6 , 1-40. Becker, J . D. Reflections on the formal description df behavior. In L. Bobrow & A. Collins (Eds.), Representation and.learning. New York: Academic Press, 1975.
114
David Klahr and Robert S . Siegler
Blatt, M. The effects of classroom discussion upon children’s level of moral judgment. In L . Kohlberg & E. Tunel (Eds.), Recent research in moral development. New York: Holt, 1971. Bobrow, D. G. Dimensions of representation. In D. G . Bobrow & A. Collins (Eds.),Representation and understanding. New York: Academic Press, 1975. Bobrow, D. G . , & Collins, A. (Eds.), Representation and understanding. New York: Academic Press, 1975. Bower, G.H. Cognitive psychology: An introduction. In W. K. Estes (Ed.), Handbook of learning and cognitive processes (Vol. I). Hillsdale, N.J.: Lawrence Erlbaum Associates, 1975. Braine, M. D. S. Development of a grasp of transitivity of length: A reply to Smedslund. Child Development, 1964, 35, 799-8110. Broadbent, D. E. The magic number s(:ven after fifteen years. In R. A. Kennedy & A . Wilkes (Eds.), Studies in long term memory. N I : ~York Wiley, 1975. Bruner, J. S., & Kenney, H. On relational concepts, In J. S. Bruner, R. R. Olver, & P. M. Greenfield (Eds.), Studies in cognitive growth. New York Wiley, 1966. Chapman, R . H. The development of children’s understanding of proportions. Child Development, 1975, 46, 141-148. Chase, W. G., & Simon, H. A. The mind’s eye in chess. In W. G . Chase (Ed.), Visual information processing. New York: Academic Press, 1973. Pp. 215-281. Chi, M. T. C. Short term memory limitations in children: Capacity or processing deficits? Memory and Cognition, 1976, 4, 559-512. Flavell, J . H. Metacognitive aspects of problem-solving. In L. B. Resnick (Ed.), The nature of intelligence. Hillsdale, N . J . : Lawrence Erlbaum Associates, 1976. Gelman, R. Logical capacity of very young children: Number invariance rules. Child Development, 1972, 43, 75-90. (a) Gelman, R. The nature and development of early number concepts. In H. Reese (Ed.), Advances in child development (Vol. 7). New York: Academic Press, 1972. (b) Glaser, R. Evaluation of instruction and changing educational models (Center for the Study of Evaluation of Instructional Programs, Occasional Report No. 13). Los Angeles, Calif.: University of California, 1968. Greeno, J. G . Cognitive objectives of instruction: Theory of knowledge for solving problems and answering questions. In D. Klahr (Ed.), Cognition and insrruction. Hillsdale, N.J.: Lawrence Erlbaum Associates, 1976. Hunt, E. What kind of computer is Man? Cognitive Psychology, 1971, 2, 57-98. Huttenlocher, J . , & Burke, D. Why does memory span increase with age? Cognitive Psychology, 1976, 8 , 1-31. lnhelder, B., & Piaget, J. The growth of logical thinking from childhood to adolescence. New York: Basic Books, 1958. Jackson, S. The growth of logical thinking in normal and subnormal children. British Journal of Educational Psychology, 1965, 35, 255-258. Klahr, D. Designing a learner: Some questions. In D. Klahr (Ed.), Cognition and ihtruction. Hillsdale, N.J.: Lawrence Erlbaum Associates, 1976. (a) Klahr, D. Steps toward the simulation of intellectual development. In L. B. Resnick (Ed.), The nature of intelligence. Hillsdale, N.J.: Lawrence Erlbaum Associates, 1976. (b) Klahr, D., & Wallace, J. G . Development of serial completion strategies: An information processing analysis. British Journal of Psychology, 1970, 61, 243-257. Klahr, D., & Wallace, J. G. The role of quantification operators i n the development of conservation of quantity. Cognitive Psycholo,qy, 1973, 4, 301-327. Klahr, D., & Wallace, J. G. Cogni,tive development: A n informarion-processing view. Hillsdale, N.J.: Lawrence Erlbaum Associates, 1976.
The Representation of Children’s Knowledge
115
Kuhn, D. Mechacisms of change in the development of cognitive structures. Child Development, 1972, 43, 833-844. Lee, L . C. The concomitant development of cognitive and moral modes of thought: A test of selected deductions from Piaget’s theory. Genetic Psychology Monographs, 1971,85, 93-146. Lovell, K . A follow-up study of lnhelder and Piaget’s “The growth of logical thinking.” British Journal of Psychology, I96 I , 52, I43 - 153. Mager, R. F. Preparing instructionul objectives. Palo Alto, Calif.: Fearon Publishers, 1962. McDermott, J. & Forgy, C. Production system conflict resolution strategies. In D. A. Waterman and F. Hayes-Roth (Eds.), Pattern-directedinference systems. New York: Academic Press (in press). Miller, G . A. The magical number seven, plus or minus two: Some limits on our capacity for piocessing information. Psychological Review, 1956, 63, 81-97. Moore, J . , & Newell, A. How can MERLIN understand? In L. W. Gregg (Ed.), Knowledge and cognition. Hillsdale, N.J.: Lawrence Erlbaum Associates, 1974. Newell, A . A note on process-structure distinctions in developmental psychology. In S . FarnhamDiggory (Ed.), Information processing in children. New York: Academic Press, 1972. (a) Newell, A. A theoretical exploration of mechanisms for coding the stimulus. In A. W . Melton & E. Martin (Eds.), Coding processes in human memory. Washington, D.C.: Winston, 1972. (h) Newell, A. Production systems: Mcdels of control structures. In W. G. Chase (Ed.), Visual information processing. New York: Academic Press, 1973. Newell, A,, & McDermott, J . PSG Manuul. Pittsburgh: Carnegie-Mellon Univetsity, Department of Computer Science, 1975. Newell, A,, & Simon, H. A. Human problem solving. Englewood Cliffs, N.J.: Prentice-Hall, 1972. Pascual-Leone, J. A mathematical model for the transition rule in Piaget’s developmental stages. Acta Psychologica, 1970, 32, 301 -345. Piaget, J . The child‘s conception of time. New York: Ballantine, 1971. Pick, A. D., Frankel, D. G., & Hess, V . L. Children’s attention: The development of selectivity. Chicago: University of Chicago Press, 1975. Reddy, R., & Newell, A. Knowledge and its representation in a speech understanding system. In L. W. Gregg (Ed.), Knowledge and cognition. Hillsdale, N.J.: Lawrence Erlbaum Associates, 1974. Resnick, L. B. Task analysis in instructional designs: Some cases from mathematics. In D. Klahr (Ed.), Cognition and instruction. Hillsdale, N.J.: Lawrence Erlbaum Associates, 1976. Rychener, M. D. Introduction to Psnlst. Pittsburgh: Camegie-Mellon University, Department of Computer Science, 1976. Siegler, R. S . Defining the locus of developmental differences in children’s causal reasoning. Journal of Experimental Child Psychology, 1975, 20, 5 12-525. Siegler, R . S. Three aspects of cognitive development. Cognitive Psychology, 1976, 8, 481 -520. Skgler, R. S . (Ed.). Children’s Thinking: Whaf Develops? Hillsdale, N.J.: Lawrence Erlbaum Associates, 1978. Siegler, R. S . , & Liebert, R. M. Effects of contiguity, regularity and age on children’s causal inferences. Developmental Psychology, 1974, 10, 574-579. Siegler, R. S., & Liebert, R. M. Acquisition of formal scientific reasoning by 10- and 13-year-olds: Designing a factorial experiment. Developmental Psychology, 1975, 11, 401-402. Siegler, R . d., & Vago, S . The development of proportionality concepts: Judging relative fullness. Journal of Experimental Child Psychology (in press, 1978). Smedslund, J. The development of transitivity of length: A comment on Braine’s reply. Child Deveio.oment, 1965, 36, 577-580. Turiel, E. An experimental test of the sequentiality of developmental stages in the child’s moral judgment. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 1966, 3 , 61 1-618.
I I6
David Klahr and Robert S.Siegler
Waterman, D. A. Adaptive production systems (CIP Working Paper No. 285). Pittsburgh: CarnegieMellon University, Department of Psychology, 1974. Waugh, N. C., & Norman, D. A . Primary memory. Psychological Review, 1965, 72, 89-104. Young, R . M. Children’s seriation behavior: A production-system analysis. Unpublished doctoral dissertation, Carnegie-Mellon University, 1973. Zeaman, D., & House, B . J . The role of attention in retardate discrimination learning. In N. R. Ellis (Ed.), Handbook of mental deficiency. New York: McGraw-Hill, 1963. Pp. 159-223.
CHROMATIC VISION IN INFANCY
Marc H . Bornstein PRINCETON UNIVERSITY
I. INTRODUCTION.. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . A. COLOR VISION AND PATTERN VISION, . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . B , EARLY INTEREST IN THE ONTOGENY OF COLOR PERCEPTION. . . . . . C . MODERN VIEWS . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
117 117 119 122
11. FUNDAMENTAL DATA OF COLOR VISION: ONTOGENY . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . A. BRIGHTNESS AND SPECTRAL SENSITIVITY . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . B. CHROMATIC VISION . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
123
111. SUMMARY . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
167
APPENDIX: TRANSLATION OF THE ADDENDUM TO DARWIN’S “BIOGRAPHICAL SKETCH OF A YOUNG CHILD” ......................
169
REFERENCES . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
169
125
132
I. Introduction A.
COLOR VISION AND PAlTERN VISION
Students of sensation and perception agree that vision predominates among the senses (e.g., Geldard, 1972; Marks, 1974). Specific examples from several different perspectives abound. The largest proportion of sensory neurons in the central nervous system is devoted to visual system function (e.g., 540 million, as compared to 100 million for the auditory system, according to Sinsheimer, 1971). Careful studies of human sensory dominance (e.g., Colavita, 1974; Pick, Warren, & Hay, 1969) and chronometric analyses of sensory information processing (e.g., Posner, Nissen, & Klein, 1976) agree that vision is prepotent. Vision is certainly the richest of the sense departments; the highly complex 117
1 I8
Marc H.Bornstein
structure of the eye differentiates and develops earliest in ontogeny; and vision mediates our most elaborate perceptual experiences. In the same way that vision dominates the sensory hierarchy in adulthood, so it does early in development. Literature evaluations and experience attest that vision is a principal factor in perceptual and cognitive development (Goodnow, 197 1; Gottesman, 1976), exploratory behavior (Nunnally & Lemond, 1973), and the development of social responsiveness (Walters & Parke, 1965) early in life. Tronick and Clanton (1971) and Bruner and Koslowski (1972) have shown the human infant to be “visually preadapted” for the “exploration and extraction of information from the environment” (Tronick & Clanton, 1971, p. 1483). “Babies grasp the world first with their eyes and then with their hands. Vision is therefore a prime constituent in the development of the total child.” The significance of visual perception in general in human infancy cannot be overstated, even by Gesell (1950, p. 3). For example, i n a direct test of Berkeley’s (1709/ 1901) view that touch teaches vision, Bower, Broughton, and Moore (1970) found that in infancy visual information predominates over tactile; likewise E. J. Gibson (1969) found that older infants favor visual cues over tactile on the visual cliff, and this pattern is continued in even older children who use visual information at the expense of other cues in intermodal matches (Abravanel, 1972; Bryant, 1974). For reasons like these vision has received extraordinary theoretical and experimental attention (e.g., C. H. Graham, 1965; Kaufman, 1974; Kling & Riggs, 1971; Osgood, 1953; Wyszecki & Stiles, 1967). Two aspects of visual information processing have been emphasized in research, pattern vision and color vision, and as a consequence of that research much is now known about these two visual functions in adults. Pattern vision obviously subserve! many basic visual differentiations, including those of form, shape, anld orientation, and therefore the question is sometimes asked, “Why color vision?” Whatever its original purpose or evolutionary significance (Polyak, 1957; Walls, 1942), color today fills our lives, and 96% of the human population possess normal color vision. For most, color has physical, chemical, physiological, psychological, aesthetic, commercial, natural, or agricultural interest. In perception and cognition, for example, colors enhance photocontrasts and thereby potentiate discrimination, identification, search, and recognition. Colors attract and maintain attention differentially. Moreover, hues ubiquitously symbolize and signify. Though the experimental sldlls of numerous developmental investigators have shown that human infants can see, process, remember, and act on patterned information within the environment (Cohen & Salapatek, 1975), relatively much less is known about the ontogeny of chromatic information processing. Yet the question of whether and how infants and young children see color and utilize chromatic information is of interest for perceptual, theoretical, and normative
Chrimcrrrc Vision in Infane?
I19
developmental reasons. First, color obviously functions as a salient perceptual cue: Children attend to, and hence order, environmental changes i n a hierarchy with color change more prominent than changes of size, number, or rotation (Dodd &Lewis, 1969; Lewis & Baumel, 1970). Second, Bornstein, Kessen, and Weiskopf (1976a) looked at the organization of hue in infancy, before language acquisition, to assess the relative primacy of language and perception, and Pollack (1970) tested hue- against lightness-contrast illusion figures in an experimental examination of Piagetian cognitive theory. Empirically, Baldwin ( 1895) saw “determination of the order of rise of the child’s perceptions of the different qualities of colour” (p. 39) to be exemplary of more general problems of experimenting with children. Finally, examination of the literature on chromatic development also continues a tradition of programmatic research in the development of sensory system capacities, while advances in techniques to assess visual status early have obvious clinical value. This chapter is intended primarily to review studies on the early ontogeny of chromatic vision in man for their several historical, theoretical, descriptive, and empirical values. Color serves obvious attentional, perceptual, cognitive, and aesthetic functions in vision. Each of these will be examined from a developmental perspective. B.
EARLY INTEREST IN THE ONTOGENY OF COLOR PERCEPTION
Interest in the development of color vision was prominent in the first observations of early baby biographers. Darwin’s (1877b) “A biographical sketch of an infant” began with observations on the early sensory development of his son, Doddy. Darwin reported that although Doddy fixated the light of a candle at nine days, he did not attend to color until his forty-ninth day.’ Preyer (1890), the nineteenth century developmental neurobiologist, introduced his two volume work on The Mind of the Child with notable discussions of his child’s developing “sensibility to light” and “discrimination of colors.” Though he observed that sensitivity to light was present at birth, Preyer was unable to demonstrate to his own satisfaction that his son could discriminate among basic colors until much later. Satisfactory demonstrations relied, in Preyer’s view, on successfully naming and recognizing colors, accomplishments that were not attained until his son’s second birthday. Early visual processes constituted very important subjects for Preyer and others in the nineteenth century since mental development was then believed to depend upon the activity of the senses. ‘Darwin’s benchmark “Biographical sketch of a young child” was published simultaneously in English in Mind (1877b) and in German in Kosnios (1877a). Intriguingly, the German edition contains an addendum, not included in the English version, that specifically concerns the early development of chromatic vision. An original translation of his addendum is given in the Appendix.
I20
Marc H . Bornstein
At the beginning of the twentieth century, observation turned to experimentation. In order to examine color and other perceptions in infancy, Baldwin (1893, 1895) invented his “dynamogenic” method. According to Baldwin, more dynamogenic stimuli should elicit more motor responses from infants than less dynamogenic stimuli. At 9 months Baldwin’s daughter, H., showed equal attraction to (i.e., grasping at) red and blue, somewhat less to green, and least to brown. Differential dynamogenic responsivity indicated to Baldwin that H. discriminated among these colors. Many of Baldwin’s quite sophisticated notions concerning this aspect of early behavior persist in contemporary infant research. Baldwin’s lead was immediately followed by several researchers. Holden and Bosse (1900) failed to find any differential reactions to colors in infants younger than 6 months; however, Marsden (l903a, 1903b), using preferential grasping and looking to indicate discrimination, found that his son attended to yellow and then red at approximately 4 months of age. On the basis of similar preference criteria, McDougall (1908) rnaintained that infants 5 months of age can discriminate among blue, green, and red. Myers (1908) concluded that his 6-month-old child “distinctly preferred” reds and yellows to blues, and Wooley (1909), using a paired-comparisons procedure, found that differential interest in colors definitely developed in the sixth month of life. Valentine (1913-1914), later author of books on The Psychology of Early Childhood (Valentine, 1942) and The Experimental Psychology cf Beauty (Valentine, 1962), studied looking at 4 months and grasping at 8 months in his own son. Using a paired-comparisons procedure, he found preference for yellow which was longitudinally stable. Baldwin’s idea that differential preference indicates discrimination failed to convince all developmental researchers (e.g., Nagel, 1906; Schallenberger, 1896). In a dissertation tbat included meticulous observations of one child’s reactions to colored flowers and book jackets, Shinn (1909) rejected her own observations of the infant’s differential attention to colors and concluded on the basis of language acquisition data that her niece, Ruth, passed through three distinct stages of chromatic development. The first, from birth to 15 months, was marked by sensitivity to light, but blindness to color. The second was a period of partial color vision as evidenced by Ruth’s errors in color naming, association, and recognition. The third, beginning at 3 years, characterized the child as adultlike in her color perceptions. Semantic development was the measure many other investigators depended upon. Before Shinn, Garbirii (1894) had suggested that because younger children are unable to name or match colors, total color deficiency must extend for the first 18 months of infancy. and partial color deficiency until the fourth year of life. Thus, color deficiency was widely believed to be “the normal condition of the newborn child” (Tracy & Stimpfl, 1909, p. 11). According to Major (1915), Baldwin’s tests tapped preferences, not discrimination, and R., Major’s son, truly discriminated black from red only at 3 years when he could name them
Chrornutic Vision
in
Infancy
121
correctly. This view persisted with inevitable consequences. Thus, Stern ( 1924) found 3-year-old children to be confused in their color naming and attributed the “legendary color blindness” of childhood to the late appearance of accurate color naming. Like views are with us still (Vernon, 1962). At least one vision researcher i n this period, Nagel (1906), himself a deuteranope, observed the color sense of a child, in this case his own 2-year-old son, Gerhard. Intrigued by contemporary opinions he termed “contradictory,” Nagel was interested in whether in fact children were color deficient. He deduced from Gerhard’s ability to learn the names of colors that by at least their second year children possessed normal color vision. The confusion yielded by the different methods, nonverbal and verbal, are manifest in Dearborn’s (1910) chronology of the development of his child, L. Paraphrased excerpts from his diary on the subject demonstrate what Dearborn himself called “the color-question in infant psychology.” Red stimulates the child’s attention. Distinct red-green discrimination. Visual preferences clearly based on hue rather than brightness. Failure to abstract redness indicates child has no idea of color qua color. Conduct gives evidence of discrimination, color naming evidence of confu. sion. 16-17 months: No appreciation of redness by name. 18.5 months: Distinguishes basic color names. Color discrimination “very certain and complete.” 24 months: Child orders a spectrum of eight Bradley sample-colors. 26 months:
3.5 months: 6 months: 7.5 months: 15 months: 15.5 months:
The development of L . from apparent preverbal hue discrimination to verbal confusion led Dearborn to wonder whether the child’s errors were perceptual or semantic in nature; L.’s early behavior notwithstanding, Dearborn conservatively accepted only the child’s later accurate color naming as satisfactory evidence of the presence of color vision. Historically, two questions have dominated the research interests of investigators in this area: When does color perception begin? and, Do the colors have an order of appearance? Clearly, the principal question, about when color vision begins, had not then been satisfactorily answered. In addition to the failure to establish a clear criterion, the confounding of hue discrimination with other perceptual variables, particularly with brightness, was responsible for a lack of progress. Natural stimuli in the world almost inevitably vary in brightness as well as hue. Quite early, Darwin and Preyer, among others, remarked on the infant’s keen sensitivity to light and changes in brightness. Many authorities, for example Nagel (1906), recognized the problem of stimulus control. Thus Baldwin (1895, p. 56) asked about such experiments “should not the colours be chosen to be equal in purity, intensity, lustre, illumination, etc.?” Because of their failure to eliminate these variations. or others such as movement
122
Marc H . Bornsfein
and contour, among chromatic stimuli, careful investigators hesitated to conclude when color vision began. The same problem has persisted in contemporary research. When Shirley (1933) tested color preference in babies 33 and 46 weeks of age and found a consistent preferential grabbing at yellow, she would conclude little since, by her own admission, yellow was the brightest color among her experimental stimuli. Previously, Valentine (1913-1914) had noted consistent yellow preferences when yellow was his brightest test color. Arlitt (1946) reported methodological difficulties of another kind. Her student, Luken, found children at 2 years unable to match colors to sample; because children at age 4 could, Luken concluded that 2-year-olds possess inadequate color perception. However, failure to demonstrate an ability, here color vision, does not necessarily imply its absence. Rather, inadequate test instruments, poor methods, or inappropriate psychological state may prevent or obscure a positive result. Researchers have, in general, been too willing to accept the null hypothesis in studies designed to demonstrate the existence of a phenomenon like color vision. The second research question focused on the order in which colors become discriminable. Most opinions accorded with one of two color theories. Peiper (1961/1963) summarizes diverse opinion on the ontogenetic sequence of color appearance. Myers ( 1908), for example, predicted from the Young-Helmholz theory that color receptors-and color perception-would mature in the order red, green, and blue. Garbini (1894) modeled his view of ontogenetic development on parallel views of phylogenetic development. According to Garbini, blue and yellow distinctions differentiate after red and green. Ladd-Franklin (1929) also proposed a stagelike development. She believed, however, that the differentiation of retinal elements would first permit only intensity discriminations, and later long (yellow) versus short (blue) hue discriminations. Finally, yellow would further evolve into red and green. Note that the speculative orders of chromatic development proposed by Garbini and Ladd-Franklin are mutually exclusive. Koffka (1927) thought that a “warm” color separates into red and yellow at the same time that a “cold” color separates into blue and green, and H. C. Smith (1943) supported this view. Despite the confusions which prevailed, the relative impoPance of color vision and color naming was not lost on nineteenth and early twentieth century thinkers. Indeed Binet’s (1890; Biner & Simon, 1908/1916) original IQ test included asking young children to name a color pointed to. In order to obtain any credit on this item, 8-year-olds were expected to identify correctly the four “fundamental” colors: blue, green, yellow, and red. C.
MODERN VIEWS
Since the second quarter of the twentieth century, experimental interest in the study of early color visual processes has gone unabated. Nevertheless,
Chromatic Vision in Infancy
123
psychophysical considerations such as stimulus control, methodological weaknesses such as reliance on preference measures where the presence or absence of preference indicates iittle about the quality or type of discrimination, and problems of interpretation such as acceptance of the null hypothesis, have severely limited scientific understanding of the young infant’s visual world and have colluded to insure persistent skepticism about infant capabilities. These and other shortcomings have been raised ir! early (Staples, 1931) as well as recent reviews of this literature (Kessen, Haith, & Salapatek, 1970; Kaye, cited in Reese & Lipsitt, 1970). Perhaps for these reasons, most contemporary developmental and perceptual discussions are practically devoid of reference to the topic of early color vision. Major developmental texts often omit the subject. Liebert, Poulos, and Strauss (1974), Mussen, Conger, and Kagan (1974), Hurlock (1972), and Jersild, Telford, and Sawrey (1975) all discuss perceptual development, including form, pat:ern, depth, the constancies, and attention, but omit color. Even more specialized works on early perceptual development do not cover color vision. Of 1 1 chapters in Cohen and Salapatek’s ( 1975) two-volume Infant Perception: From Sensation to Cognition, nine are devoted to studies of visual development. None concerns early color vision or its development. Likewise, the term “color” does not even appear in the index of Bower’s ( 1975) perceptual Development in Infancy or in the index of Rosinski’s ( 1977) The Development of Visual Perception. Nor is the developmental dimension usually included in more specialized essays on sensory or perceptual psychology. When it is, however, authors often lament a paucity of knowledge. Indeed, “Experts in color vision are frequently embarrassed to have to admit that there is little hard scientific fact about the nature of color vision in the young of our own species” (Jacobs, 1976, p. 81). In comparison, the twentieth century has witnessed remarkable growth in our understanding of the psychophysiology and the psychophysics of color vision in adult humans and various infrahuman species. In the following review of issues and advances in the ontogeny of chromatic vision, some knowledge of adult and comparative data as well as of the basic concepts of visual science is assumed; for further elucidation and elaboration, the reader is referred to Geldard (1972), C. H. Graham (1965), Kaufman (1974), Kling and Riggs (1971), and Wyszecki and Stiles (1967).
11. Fundamental Data of Color Vision: Ontogeny Light, the physical source of information in vision, varies in two principal ways, in wavelength composition and in intensity. Both influence the three psychological dimensions of color vision. Spectral wavelengths effective for human color vision vary between approximately 400 nm and 700 nm. The psychological correlate of wavelength and the first principal dimension of color vision is hue.
124
Marc H . Bornstein
Intensity, the second way light varies, is specified in radiance (the energy radiated by a light source) or in luminance (the energy which is effective for vision). The psychological correlate of intensity and the second principal dimension of color vision is brightness. Colors also vary in purity or chromaticness, the degree to which a light approaches monochromatic. The approximate psychological correlate of purity and the third principal dimension of color vision is saturation. Relationships among these three dimensions of color vision are best represented diagrammatically in a color solid (Fig. 1) that encompasses all possible chromatic experiences. Brightness is shown on the major axis from black to white. Hue is ordered as a circular prray that includes spectral and extraspectral colors. (Extraspectral colors are mixtures of spectral wavelengths.) Saturation is represented on the radii and shows the amount of color in a mixture. Nickerson and Newhall (1943) estimated that the number of discernible colors that fill this color space approximates 7,500,000. Color vision allows organisms to distinguish among stimuli that may or may not be the same size and shape. Judd (1951a) defined colors as those “characteristics of light other than spatial and temporal inhomogeneities” (p. 862). Color is not, however, a physical property of light; light itself has no color. Color is a sensation. The colors of objects in a natural scene depend, therefore, upon several factors, including (1) characteristics of the source of illumination on the scene, (2) the reflectance characteristics of the objects and their surround in the scene, and (3) the attenuation and sensitivity characteristics of the visual system to wavelength. Color vision thus exemplifies potential relationships among the physics of the natural world, the anatomy, neurochemistry , psychophysiology of the human body, and the psychology of the human mind. Several quantitative functions describe perception along the three color axes.z First, the absolute and differential thresholds for brightness perception are important to understanding the limits of color vision. The chromatic threshold as well as other suprathreshold measures of photopic spectral sensitivity define the overall sensitivity of the visual system to light, and the wavelength discrimination function describes the differential sensitivity of the visual system to hue. Hue categorization functions delimit the subjective organization of the spectrum and thus the extent and number- of qualitatively dissimilar hues experienced by an organism. Wavelength preference and color memory are equally important to a comprehensive description of color vision. Finally, different criteria define the *Although the physical dimensions associated with changes in brightness, hue, and saturation are independent, the psychological coirelates themselves are interdependent. Thus, the luminance of a wavelength must reach photopic levels for that wavelength to yield visible color. When intensity is increased, the hues of all but unique hues change, a phenomenon known as the Bezold-Briicke hue shift (Boynton & Gordon, 1965). Lightness and saturation are also integrally related (Davidoff, 1974), and changes in hue elicit concomitant changes in saturation (C. H. Graham, 1965). These natural interactions observed, we shall continue to discuss the three principal dimensions of color vision as though they were essentially separable continua of experience.
Chromatic Vision in Infancy
\
I25
\\
\
\
i Fig. I . The psychological color solid
quality of color vision that an organism possesses; among them hue categories and the spectral quality of light are prominent. The ontogeny of each of these standard functions in infancy, and the concepts associated with them receive further elaboration below. Treatments of each, however, incorporate one quite important assumption, namely, that adaptation, surround, retinal locus, and other state and physical variables surely influence the perception of color. The ensuing discussions therefore assume the following viewing conditions: foveal stimulation, neutral adaptation, absence of surround induction, and photopic levels of illumination. Under these viewing restrictions, each of the basic visual functions characterizes normal adult performance, that of an “ideal” or “standard” observer. In the ensuing considerations of developmental data, the results from studies of the very young are often compared against the performance of such a standard adult observer. A.
BRIGHTNESS AND SPECTRAL SENSITIVITY
I . Brightness The perception of brightness, from dark to light, varies with the luminance of a visual stimulus. Photopic luminance, associated with cone function and hence
126
Marc H . Bornstein
color vision, varies between chromatic threshold (- 10 mL) and the point at which light may cause visual damage (- lo9 mL). Darwin (1877b) first observed Doddy’s pronounced visual attention to candle light, and Champneys (1881:i as well remarked that neonates are sensitive to and experience pleasure from visual stimulation. Early experimental observations of infants’ sensitivity to brightness were indexed by preferential looking. Hershenson (1964) examined the newborn’s visual choice for pairs of grays of different lightnesses. Although Hershenson interpreted his results to indicate that infants prefer intermediate intensities to bright, and bright to dim, Thomas (1973) reanalyzed Hershenson’s data using Coomb’s (1964) unfolding model of choice preference and found that Hershenson’s babies actually preferred bright to intermediate to dim levels of illumination. Independent of the disputed monotonicity of these results, the infants’ differential visual preference strongly indicated that Hershenson’s infants discriminated among different levels of illumination, The newborn’s sensitivity to light has also been investigated by the measurement of reflexes and changes in steady-state activity. Preyer (1890), for example, began to document the newborn’s sensitivity to light quantitatively by studying the pupillary reflex: Preyer reported that in bright daylight his son’s pupils constricted to less than 2 mm. Likewise, Sherman, Sherman, and Flory (1936) used the pupillary reflex as a dependent measure of newborn infants’ sensitivity to light intensity. Peiper ( 1961/ 1963) investigated brightness sensitivity in infants by measuring the eye-neck reflex. When light is shined into an infant’s eyes, the child throws back his head; threshold for the reflex depends on the brightness of the stimulus. Peiper (1961/1963) reported a one-hundredfold increase in sensitivity following dark adaptation. Other investigators have looked at changes in the infant’s gross motility as indicative of his sensitivity to light. Hall ( I 891), for example, noted blinking and manifest movement to changes in sunlight on the first day of life. Watson (1925) discovered visual orienting in infants to light presented in the dark. Still others, notably contributors to the Iowa Studies of Infant Behavior (e.g., Irwin & Weiss, 1934; Redfield, 1939; J . M. Smith, 1936), typically measured gross movement with a stabilimeter. Under these conditions, Irwin and Weiss (1934) and Redfield (1939) found that movements during the first week of life could be elicited in infants with even a very dim stimulus, and Redfield (1939) and Irwin (1941) found that infant movements decreased with simple increases in photopic lighting conditions. More recently, discriminations along the intensity dimension have been examined in infants, and they have been shown to be surprisingly good. Two studies of simultaneous brightness discrimination have investigated the difference threshold (hl) among 2-month-olds. Doris and Cooper (1966) and Doris, Casper, and Poresky (1967) measured optokinetic nystagmus in young babies and thereby derived a difference threshold for brightness. They found that brightness sensitivity at a luminance of approximately 3.4 c d m 2 increased with
Chrotiiutic Vision it1 Infancy
127
age: the Weber fraction for a group of neonates was .50 and that for a group of 3-month-olds was .26. Peeples and Teller (1975) measured brightness discrimination in 2-month-old human infants by utilizing the infants’ visual preference for pattern over homogeneity (Bond, 1972). They showed infants two fields (luminance = 4.0 cd/m2) and observed that the infants preferred the field that contained a bar which differed from the background by only .02 log units. These data show that by 2 months infants are able to discriminate small differences in photopic luminance (Weber fraction = .05), and that infants do not differ greatly from adults. Under similar stimulus conditions, adults can discriminate a 1% luminance difference (Steinhardt, 1936). The detection of simultaneous contrast is more acute in the infant (as it is in the adult) than is the detection of luminance difference without contrast (successive discrimination). Kessen and Bomstein (unpublished observations) studied infants’ discrimination of lights presented in temporal succession. Their results show that 4-month-olds are insensitive to a doubling or halving of luminance. This amount is already considerably larger than the comparable adult changes, 8-10% approximately, but not unexpectedly so since the successive discrimination of brightness necessarily relies both on the infant’s memory and, in the habituation task used, on the novelty value of the luminance change. In this study narrow-band stimuli (A = 490 nm) were used in successive discrimination of luminance; among adults, differential sensitivity functions for spectral lights typically parallel that established for white light (J. L. Brown & Mueller, 1965), and there is little reason to believe that an infant comparison would be different. Studies of brightness perception therefore indicate that even young children can detect small differences in luminance. Certainly, they find brightness a ready cue in discrimination (Clifford & Calvin, 1958). In fact, as we shall see, the infant’s keen sensitivity to small changes in energy has presented the single most frequent stumbling block to the study of chromatic vision proper.
2 . Spectral Sensitivity Spectral sensitivity denotes the basic relation between the eye and visible radiation. Different wavelengths of light vary in the degree to which they stimulate the human eye, and spectral sensitivity is defined as the inverse of the energy necessary at different wavelengths to elicit a constant visual response. It therefore represents a measure of the apparent brightness of the natural spectrum as a function of wavelength, and the term spectral sensitivity is sometimes used interchangeably with luminosity or efficiency. Spectral sensitivities reflect photoreceptor function, and in the duplex retina like man’s, where two classes of photoreceptors (rods and cones) operate, at least two spectral sensitivity functions are prominent. One, associated with the rods, reflects sensitivity at very low light levels and is termed scoropic. Another, associated with the cones, reflects sensitivity at higher light levels and is termed photopic. Maximal scotopic sensitivity occurs in the neighborhood of 505 nm; maximal photopic
128
Marc
H.Bornstein
sensitivity near 555 nm; and a series of curves distributes itself in between at intermediate or mesopic light levels. The change from rod to cone vision that reflects the change from scotopic sensitivity to photopic sensitivity is called the Purkinje shift (Boynton, 1971; Wald, 1945). Knowledge of spectral sensitivity is prerequisite to the study of color vision on two grounds. First, as a basic psychophysical datum, spectral sensitivity defines the limits of vision across the photic spectrum and indexes maturation and function of the primary subsystem of vision. Second, the analysis of color vision per se depends on a knowledge of spectral sensitivity: To isolate hue (or saturation) as an object of experimental study, it is necessary to eliminate or minimize other visual cues, especially brightness differences based on spectral sensitivity. Several attempts have been made to measure spectral sensitivity in human infants, but early research in this area generated substantial controversy. Peiper (1927) obtained the first indication of a Purkinje shift in light- and dark-adapted preterm infants by measuring intensity thresholds for elicitation of the eye-neck reflex. Peiper found that in infants sensitivity values for long visible wavelengths are greater following light adaptation than following dark adaptation. To Peiper these data indicated that a duplex retina is functional before term, and they suggested to him that the newborn is capable of photopic vision. Moreover, Peiper maintained that perceived photopic brightnesses for different colors in infancy and adulthood were similar; in his own words, “brightness sensitivity in man does not develop after birth but. . . the ability to see in daylight and at dawn is present in the premature infant in the same way as is characteristic for adults” (Peiper, 1961/1963, p. 73). Trincker and Trincker (1955/1967) used Peiper’s startle method to perform more elaborate investigations on the characteristics of preterm and term spectral sensitivity. They tested 38 infants 1-10 weeks of age with five colors and found, like Peiper, that threshold sensitivities of the lightadapted newborn were similar to photopic threshold judgments of adults. Trincker and Trincker (1955/1967) also observed that to some extent scotopic sensitivity developed ontogenetically. Pratt, Nelson, and Sun (1930) recorded reactions of infants 1 - 1 1 days old to white and “colored lights” (red, green, yellow, and blue). They counted the number of specific movements per child per stimulation and the average number of millimeters children disturbed a stabilimeter on stimulation. From these measures., Pratt et al. concluded that neonatal sensitivity to light and color was well developed at birth and during the first 2 weeks. Likewise J . M. Smith (1936) measured the effectiveness of three wavelengths to inhibit activity among 20 newborns. J . M. Smith (1936) found that blue suppressed 50% of (baseline) movements, green 30%, and red 23% on the average, and she interpreted these results to iindicate no Purkinje shift. (In fact, J. M. Smith concluded from these “spectral sensitivity” data that infants were to one degree or another color deficient, and boys were more so than girls.) These studies have been criticized in several places (Banks & Salapatek, 1975; Bornstein, Kessen, & Weiskopf, 1976b; Dobson, 1976; Munn, 1955; Peeples &
Chromatic Vision in Infancy
I29
Teller, 1975; Peiper, 1937, 1961/1963; J . M. Smith, 1936; Wooten, 1975). Peiper ( 1927) and J . M. Smith (1936) used a small sample size, and they and the Trinckers (1955/1967) used only a small number of stimuli whose physical characteristics were not well specified. Two failed to report reliabilities of observing an otherwise quite subjective dependent measure. In addition, the comparison adult photopic function that the Trinckers derived in their own apparatus does not match Standard Observer luminosity as defined by the International Committee on Illumination. Smith’s measures, stabilimeter deflections and crying, were very gross and her data so unstable as to question their validity as measures of sensitivity (Munn, 1955; Peiper, 1937). Nevertheless, subjecting her data to reanalysis, Trincker and Trincker (1955/1961) suggested that J. M. Smith’s infants indeed displayed the Purkinje effect. More recent investigators (Dobson, 1976; Peeples & Teller, 1978) have measured photopic spectral sensitivity in infants with greater success. Both looked at 2-month-olds. Peeples and Teller (1978) used a constant behavioral criterion patterned on Fantz’s finding that infants will selectively fixate heterogeneous, in preference to homogeneous, stimulation. To measure white-adapted spectral sensitivity, they determined the radiance necessary to elicit tracking of a moving monochromatic grating on a white background. Dobson (1976) used a constant electrophysiological criterion, implicit time of the visually evoked cortical potential (VEP) (Wooten, 1972), to derive a measure of photopic spectral sensitivity. Data from Dobson (1976) appear in Fig. 2. Neither of these modem experiments is immune to criticism, however. Peeples and Teller’s (1978) observations were, like Dobson’s, derived using only a small number of wavelengths and only a small number of infants, and Dobson’s ( 1976) technique did not account for stray light, to which the VEP is sensitive, or for the infant’s attentional state. Both showed large individual differences. Nevertheless, their mutual concordance and psychophysical sophistication lend them a certain validity. Each of the experiments generated data from infants and adults in the same apparatus and under identical testing procedures. The two studies were, however, conducted under different adaptation conditions. They are, nevertheless, in fairly close agreement. When anchored with adult spectral sensitivity at 550 nm, both show a m.atch between relative adult and infant spectral sensitivities at wavelengths longer than about 550 nm, but the infants’ sensitivity is increasingly elevated at wavelengths shorter than 550 nm. Figure 2 shows photopic spectral sensitivities at three different ages and that of the average tritanopic (blue-deficient) observer (W. D. Wright, 1952). Bomstein (1977a) has termed the apparent ontogenetic change in short-wavelength visual sensitivity “developmental pseudocyananopsia.” As can be seen, with age spectral sensitivity approaches the function characteristic of a formal color defect. The developmental deficiency has a different etiology, however. Before light reaches the retina and becomes an effective stimulus for vision, it passes through several optical structures: the sclera, cornea, lens, aqueous and virtreous
130
Marc H . Bornstein
1
I
I
I
1
I
I
100
f
t
t
;
10
fn
z W
v)
TRITANOPE 1
400
500 WAVELENGTH
600 INM)
700
F i g . 2 . Photopic spectral sensitivities near birth (2 months) (Dobson, 1976), at midlife (26-30 years) (Ruddock, 1965b), and near the end of life ( 6 1 4 5 years) (Ruddock, 19656) in comparison with that of the average tritanope (CV. D . Wright, 1952). (From Bornstein, 1977a. Copyright The American Academy of Optometry. Vsed by permission.)
humors, and the macula lutetz. Because each of these structures is dense, each attenuates incoming light by scattering and absorption. Classic (Ludvigh & McCarthy, 1938) and modem (Norren & Vos, 1974) studies of the attenuation characteristics of the eye agree that intraocular structures combine selectively and cumulatively to absorb and scatter incoming short-wavelength (blue) radiation. In infancy, these optical media are transparent (Marg, Freeman, Peltzman, & Goldstein, 1976). During ontogeny, however, the intraocular structures thicken, increase in pigment density, or both: The sclera becomes denser and yellows (Vannas & Tier, 1960), the cornea yellows (Boettner & Wolter, 1962), and the vitreous (Balazs, 1961), the lens (Coren & Girgus, 1972; Walls, 1942; Weale, 1963), and the macular pigment all thicken (Chevallereau & Polack, 1907; Duke-Elder & Cook, 1963; Weale, 1963). Investigators who have examined these influences of age upon visual sensitivity have generally been satisfied to ascribe resultant differences in the perception of blue to optical pigmentation (e.g., Weale, 1963). Thus, Dobson (1976) suggested that infants’ shortwavelength hypersensitivity reflects primarily their lack of macular pigmentation, and Ruddock ( l965b) ascribed the elderly’s hyposensitivity principally to their excessive lenticular pigmentation. The two conclusions appear to be optically reasonable especially in the light of the foregoing physical and anatomical data
Chromutic Vision in Infancy
131
and Ruddock’s (1965a) studies which rule out age changes in the retinal receptor system. In all probability, however, these two (and other) sources of attenuation combine (Bornstein, 1977a). Future infant researchers may continue to invent behavioral or other techniques to measure spectral sensitivity, such as methods based on a flicker discrimination criterion (Bornstein & Marks, 1972), but this will be substantially difficult with newborns. Two passive procedures based on the electroretinogram (ERG) and pupillary reflex may, however, provide alternative means to calculate spectral sensitivity from neonates. Armington (1979, among others, has demonstrated that photopic spectral sensitivity may be derived from ERGS. However, following a successful, if difficult, experimental demonstration of the photopic ERG in the neonate (Barnet, Lodge. & Armington, 1965), no investigator has yet come forth with a derivation of neonatal spectral sensitivity based on the ERG. A second technique might be based on the pupillary reflex of the eye to light. Iris sphincter constriction is reflexively related to the brightness of a light, and some time ago Baldwin (1895, p. 43, n. 1 ) reported Ladd-Franklin’s (1894, cited in Baldwin, 1895), suggestion, based on Sach, that “reflex changes in the width of the pupil when certain colours are looked at might be used to test the colour sensations of very young children.” For Baldwin, the pupillary reflex represented a variation on the reaching theme. Peiper (1927; see Peiper, 1961/1963, p. 75) referred obliquely to experiments along these lines by De Rudder, but not until Mcnsinger and Banks (1974) was pupillometry tried as “an objective measure of visual sensitivity for infants” (p. 677). Testing over 4 log units of energy with three narrow-band wavelengths (486, 577, and 671 nm), these investigators showed that pupillometry was reliable and closely related to perceived brightness in 3-year-olds and in adults. One-year-olds in their study showed equal responsivity to 486 and 671 nm but more to 577 nm. In a follow-up study these investigators actually derived a photopic spectral sensitivity function pupillometrically from a 4-year-old (Banks & Munsinger, 1974). That subject showed a consistent decrement in long-wavelength (A > 546 nm) sensitivity and a small increment in short-wavelength (A < 500 nm) sensitivity relative to adults. As suggested, studies of infants’ spectral sensitivity are important and informative for two principal reasons. First, they provide a kind of psychoanatomic diagnosis. Photopic sensitivities indicate mature, color-normal functioning of retinal elements, and when measured by criteria such as VEP they suggest that cortical functions in the infant have developed. Indeed, behavioral measures of spectral sensitivity in monkeys indicate that only the scotopic system functions in the destriate preparation (Lepore, Cardu, Rasmussen, & Malmo, 1975). The behavioral and electrophysiological data presently available indicate that photopic spectral sensitivity operates normally by the second month of life. The same cannot yet be said of the neonatal period. Second, some measure of spectral sensitivity is critical to the accurate evaluation of other visual functions in chromatic perception. In many color studies, an
132
Marc
H.Bornstein
average measure of adult spectral sensitivity is used to equate stimuli for brightness for infants. In view of such widespread application, several caveats are in order. First, measures of spectral sensitivity are influenced by several parameters, including the criterion level, procedure, adaptation, state of the organism, and location on the retina. In addition, spectral sensitivities represent only single individuals or at best the central tendency of a small group of observers. Consequently, they do not apply equally well to each observer in a given study, nor do they apply to all observers, nor to every study. Finally, spectral sensitivities are not brightness matches pe:r se even if the two sets of data are closely related. Since “brightness matches” are usually suprathreshold and depend at minimum upon good experimenter-observer communication; matches are not likely to be derived from young infants. In practice it is unlikely that researchers will be able to derive individual spectral sensitivity functions from younger observers preliminary to color studies. The utility and hazards of applying mean spectral sensitivity measurements may, then, be obvious.
3. Summary Determination of brightness idiscrimination and spectral sensitivity describe two basic visual functions related to color perception. Studies reviewed in this section indicate that under conditions of simultaneous contrast, 2-month-olds, like adults, discriminate small brightness differences, but that they have not been shown to approximate adult behavior in situations that involve successive discrimination. Relative spectral sensitivity among 2-month-olds deviates from that of the adult only at the shortest visible wavelengths. The infant’s remarkable brightness sensitivity and his departures from adult sensitivity suggest that simultaneous discrimination of chromatic stimuli purportedly equated for luminance may not preclude responses to residual brightness differences instead of color differences. Data on spectral sensitivity are prerequisite to the study of color vision though they do not yield any information about the existence of color vision per se. Monochromatic, dichromatic, and trichromatic eyes all evidence roughly similar spectral sensitivity curves. Thus, establishment of spectral sensitivity in early infancy does not afford evidence that the newborn actually sees color. The next section first reviews several key studies which were specifically designed to demonstrate chromatic vision in infancy, that is discrimination between two stimuli differing in wavelength composition on the basis of that difference alone. A review of recent experiments of basic color visual functions then follows. B. CHROMATIC VISION
1. Attempts to Demonstrate Chromatic Vision in Infants Not all researchers have ignored the brightness problem. Typically, two strategies to eliminate the brightness confound have prevailed. In one, chromatic stimuli are equated for perceived brightness by adult spectral sensitivity coeffi-
Chromcrrrr Vision in Infancy
I33
cients. (At this writing, no researcher had adopted infant coefficients.) In the second, brightness controls are not based on prior assumptions about the infant's spectral sensitivity, but brightnesses of test stimuli are varied randomly and orthogonally to chromatic cues. Some researchers used visual discrimination paradigms-preferential paired comparisons and instrumental learning-that were intended to go beyond simple preference; others used electrophysiological measures. Notwithstanding these advances, the thrust of this set of research papers has been to demonstrate simple chromatic discrimination in infants. The main questions have been: Do infants see color'? and, When do they see it? In general, the scope of such an approach is limited since i t tells us little about the type, quality, or functions of such vision. Moreover, each of the following studies is, to a certain extent, inconclusive. Chase (1937) correctly intuited that infant tracking of a chromatic target against equally bright achromatic or chromatic backgrounds would evidence color vision. He therefore projected mobile chromatic discs (7.2" X 10.8') on a ground (53.1" X 40.1") and had two observers judge eye movements of 24 infants 15-70 days of age. Using a variety of color combinations, Chase found that disc-field color contrasts yielded pursuit on 90-100% of the trials. When he paired different intensities of the same hue i n a control condition, however, infants failed to pursue, and supposedly to differentiate, the target. Chase might have increased brightness in the control condition until tracking occured to provide proof that the brightness did not control pursuit in the hue-contrast condition; since his colors were equated for brightness, however, Chase's study stands as the first experimental indication that babies might distinguish hues. Using optokinetic nystagmus as an index, Trincker and Trincker (1955/1961) tested the hypothesis that infants would not discriminate hue. Over 100 babies between 1 and 11 weeks of age were exposed to a moving field of alternating colored and gray stripes. Babies 1 or 2 weeks old failed to show a response to colored and gray stripes of equal photopic brightness; by the third week blue was discriminated, then red, yellow, and green in succession. As part of a larger study of early visual preference, Spears (1964) measured the relative fixation times of 60 4-month-olds to pairs of equally bright Munsell Hues (22.4" squares of blue, yellow, red, and gray). Blue, red, and yellow were equally preferred, but blue and red were preferred to gray. Since his colors were matched for brightness, Spears concluded that 4-month-olds' preferences indicated discriminations among color patches not based on distinctions of brightness, but based on distinctions of hue. Fagan (1974) studied 124 infants 13-25 weeks of age. His stimuli were pairs of checkerboard patterns that subtended 24' of visual angle. One member of each pair alternated two Munsell Hues of equal Value and Chroma (4.8" square), and the other member was a single-hue pattern. Fagan's thesis, that hue discrimina-
134
Marc H . Bornstein
tion would be evident in infants’ preference for double-hued checkerboards, was based on previous demonstrations that infants prefer patterned to unpatterned stimuli, and indeed infants i n Fagan’s study looked longer at the two-hue patterns. Further, Fagan’s data suggested that fixation time was directly related to the degree of difference among hues; for example, infants looked longest at a red-green checkerboard. Fagan (1974, p. 974) concluded, therefore, that “infants are capable of discriminating on the basis of hues by 4 to 6 months.” Studying heart rate activity in newborns ( 1-4 days of age), Adkinson and Berg (1976) used two equally luminant colors, a blue (A = 472 nm) and a blue-green (A = 496 nm) as discriminative stimuli. They found in the older newborns that six exposures to one color resulted in reliable habituation of onset decelerations, and then two exposures to the other color elicited reliable dishabituation of onset declerations. These data provide some evidence of simple discrimination of color in the newborn infant. Brightness controls in these studies have proved problematical. Chase, the Trinckers, Spears, Fagan, and Adkinson and Berg all assumed that special sensitivity is the same in infants as in adults. Although, as we have seen, infant sensitivity is a good approxirnation of adult sensitivity (particularly at middle and long wavelengths), Peeples and Teller (1975) have shown that in simultaneous discrimination situations, such as color or brightness contrast, infants are so exquisitely sensitive that even small differences in brightness may provide sufficient discriminative cues. In many of these studies, using adult sensitivity to match brightnesses may not provide adequate stimulus control. In addition, Wooten (1975) argued that Fagan (1974) used inappropriate illumination on Munsell papers, which may have provided extraneous brightness cues even if relative spectral sensitivities of infants and adults were equivalent. Wooten then showed how Fagan’s results could be accounted for in terms of brightness differences among the ~timulli.~ Fagan (1975) countered Wooten’s criticism by pointing out that partial coirelations of Fagan’s original data substantiated the predominance of hue over brightness in determining preference, and Fagan showed further that hue preferences were maintained in follow-up tests in which colors were presented under appropriate (C) illumination. Beside the facts that Spears assumed infant-adult parity with regard to spectral sensitivity and did not specify the illuminant of his Munsell chips, his preference technique quite severely limited the conclus~ionsin his study. Although the pattern-preference paradigm provides an extraordinarily valuable index of discrimination, a lack of preference among chromatic stimuli [as, e.g., in Spears (1964) or Wickelgren (1967)l is consistent with but does not confirm a lack of discriminative capacity. 3The Wooten-Fagan exchange hauntingly echoes Eldridge-Green’s criticism of Marsden ( 1 903a, 1903b) some 70 years earlier. Martiden’s studies of infant color perception were based on Baldwin’s paired-preference method; Eldridg,e-Green suggested that the young child‘s “photoaesthetic and visive perceptions” of color were actually based on perceived brightness differences.
Cttronrcitic Vision in Infumy
I35
Peeples and Teller (1975) also based their assessment of infant color vision on the visual-choice paradigm. They modified their brightness discrimination approach and showed two 2-month-old girls a white screen on either side of which a red bar (A = 633 nm) of variable luminance could appear. The infants consistently discriminated the presence of the red bar at different luminances, one of which presumptively matched the white ground in brightness. Oster (1975) selected a camouflage strategy. She adopted von Frisch’s (1964) technique (as recommended by Peiper, 1961/1963, p. 71) of systematically varying the brightness context of a target stimulus and found that 10-week-olds will discriminate chromatic from achromatic patterns. Several conditioning procedures have involved hue discrimination in infants. Peiper cited Russian investigators, including Krasnogorski (1913, cited in Peiper, 1961/1963) and Rahlmann (1903, cited in Peiper, 1961/1963), who successfully conditioned sucking to colored milk bottles. Brackbill (1962) reported Zonova’s comparative studies of sucking and eye-blink conditioning to “red, green, and blue lights.” Fewer than 50% of the subjects discriminated at 3 months when the index response was sucking, while virtually 100% reached an analogous eye-blink criterion at 55 days. In 1935, Kasatkin and Levikova successfully conditioned a differential visual discrimination between red or yellow and green in six infants approximately 3.5 months of age. Although they were not interested in color discrimination per se, Kasatkin and Levikova concluded from this demonstration that infants can discriminate color. In a recent and worthy study, Schaller ( 1975) operantly conditioned differential eye movements in six of eight 3-month-olds to red and green stimuli that varied irregularly over a wide range of brightnesses. The quality and quantity of stimuli used in many of these infant studies have provoked consistent criticism. Most investigators used only two or three stimuli. The Russians used unspecified color bulbs, and Schaller (1975) apparently selected complex, wide band, bipeaked color filters. Like Chase, Schaller might also have varied the brightness of his stimuli until he was certain brightness was not a factor in conditioning. Finally, Milewski and Siqueland’s (1975) recent conditioning study is subject to the same brightness criticism. They instrumentally conditioned high-amplitude sucking in 10 1month-old infants with red (or blue) patterns and found that following habituation infants would dishabituate to (discriminate) a change to blue (or to red). However, Milewski and Siqueland’s red and blue slides differed by .5 log unit in luminance and therefore allowed discrimination to be based on brightness. Some investigators have used electrophysiological measures to investigate chromatic vision in infants. Such measures, which reflect the relationship between stimulus processes and electrochemical changes in nervous tissue, include the ERG and the VEP. Neither the ERG nor the VEP is particularly suited to studies that involve variation in wavelength. However, the wavelength parameter has been investigated in adults and in infants and, independent of other difficulties associated with gross electrophysiology , the results are illuminating. In
I36
Marc H . Bornsrein
general, wavelength affects the ERG only modestly but in response to longwavelength light, the adult ERG displays an early positive x-wave (Adrian, 1945). Bamet et a l . (1965) and Lodge, Armington, Barnet, Shanks, and Newcomb (1969) recorded this characteristic x-wave in ERGS from newborn infants exposed to “orange” light (A > 580 nm). They deduced from the existence of the x-wave that the retina in the human newborn is capable of photopic responses and that newborn humans possess chromatic vision. To these retinal data, Lodge et al. (1969) added neonatal VEPs recorded over occipital cortex. In their study. newborns, like adults, showed higher amplitude VEPs to orange than to white light, a result characteristic of photopic activity. Since Armington ( 1975) had demonstrated that the occipital potential in the adult primarily reflects foveal activity, from the Lodge data one may further deduce that the central retina functions at or soon after birth. Infantile evoked potentials to white as well as red, green, and blue stimuli were measured by Fichsel(l969). Preterm infants showed essentially no difference in waveform or latency to the different stimuli, but term newborns and older children evidenced systematic distinctions. Finally, Polikanina (1968) found different patterns of EEG in 2-week-olds to red and green Ilight. Thus, data from Lodge et al. (1969), from Fichsel (1969), and from Polikanina (1968) provide evidence that visual cortex functions soon after birth, and they implicate it in some higher order, central analysis of chromatic stimulation. These and behavioral data on color vision reviewed below specifically contradict Bronson ( 1974), whose view is that geniculostriate pathways are nonfunctional during the first month of life. In summary, although electrophysiological data are suggestive of chromatic vision in infancy, they do not prove behavioral function. Many of the behavioral studies of color vision in infants are, as we have seen, plagued by criticisms of stimulus control. Several of these studies are individually questionable; together, however, the better studies (e.g., Peeples & Teller, 1975; Schaller, 1975) provide strongly suggestive evidence of color vision. None of the studies cited above provides information about the quality, extent, or type of color perception in infancy. As a consequence, even the best investigations have been limited to claims that infants “must have some form of color vision” that is “at least dichromatic” (Peeples & Teller, 1975, p. 1102). More extensive data are necessary to delimit the type or qualiity of color vision that an organism possesses. The next sections review such data.
2 . The Neutral Zone Research with adults indicates that color-normal trichromats, possessing at least three cone types, see all wav’elengths in the spectrum as hued, saturated, and discriminable from white, but that color-deficient dichromats, possessing only two cone types, see at least one point in the spectrum in chromatic balance and therefore as achromatic or gray. Deficiencies in chromatic vision are typically
Chromatic Vision in Infancy
I37
characterized, indeed they are diagnosed, by the presence of this achromatic “neutral zone.” According to Hsia and Graham (1965, p. 396), the neutral zone, “is an important characteristic of dichromatic vision.. . . A true dichromat has no difficulty in selecting a spectral color to match white, a performance that is impossible for the normal trichromat.” Recently, Bornstein (1976a, p. 429) surveyed empirical and theoretical derivations of neutral points for the two major subclasses of dichromasy, protanopia and deuteranopia. For protans, estimates of neutral points extended from 489.0 to 497.0 nm, and for deutans they extended from 495.0 to 500.5 nm. For protan and deutan alike, however, a somewhat larger spectral region is desaturated and whitish in appearance. “The neutral point obtained in actual measurements is not invariably a sharp point but usually covers a range of several millimicrons [nanometers]” (Hsia & Graham, 1965, p. 396). Meyer (1932) estimated that the neutral zone for dichromats is 5.4-7.0 nm in width, and Kalmus (1972) obtained widths of 4-8 nm. The achromatic appearance of this region to a dichromat was quite strikingly evidenced in the color-naming behavior of the unilateral dichromat (C. H . Graham, Sperling, Hsia, & Coulson. 1961). This observer named 490 and 500 nm “blue-green” and “green, blue-green’’ respectively when viewed with her normal eye, but she named them “mostly grey, a little blue” and “yellowish grey” when viewed with her dichromatic eye. For these reasons, no doubt, several investigators of sensory processes have labeled this region the dichromats’ “neutral band” (Walls & Matthews, 1952), “grey band” (Geldard, 1972), or “neutral zone” (Kalmus, 1972). The existence of a neutral region is a diagnostic sign of dysfunction of chromatic vision, and its absence is diagnostic of trichromatic vision. It has been used to assess chromatic vision behaviorally in various infrahuman primates (Boothe, Teller, & Sackett, 1975; De Valois, Morgan, Polson, Mean, & Hull, 1974; Grether, 1939) and in human infants. Teller and her associates (Peeples, 1976; Peeples & Teller, 1975; Teller, Peeples, & Sekel, 1978) used a visual-choice paradigm, and Bornstein (1976a) used an attention-habituation paradigm, to discern whether or not infants could discriminate different spectral wavelengths from white. Bornstein’s habituation test was designed specifically to assess whether young infants would discriminate wavelengths in the region 490-500 nm from white of the same mean luminance, that is, to test whether infants would differentiate achromatic stimulation from chromatic stimulation selected from the spectral region which is perceived as achromatic in dichromatic vision. Infants 3 months old were first exposed on 12 familiarization trials to varying monochromatic lights selected randomly from the 490- to 500-nm wavelength range. During familiarization, stimulus luminance also varied randomly over nearly a log unit. White light (5100”K), whose luminance was held constant at the mean value for the spectral luminances, then appeared on two consecutive trials. The sequence
Marc H . Bornstein
138
ended with two trials on which spectral lights chosen under the same constraints as the first 12 appeared. Since the varying luminance of the familiarization stimuli had as a mean the luminance of the white stimulus, dishabituation to white could not be attributed to a change in brightness, as opposed to chromatic change. Analyses of the infants’ visual attention in terms of total looking time per trial and duration of first fixations yielded parallel patterns of responding. Figure 3 shows habituation (the decrement in looking) to repeated presentation of wavelengths in the 490- to 500-nm range, statistically reliable dishabituation (recovery of looking) to white, and rehabituation to wavelengths in the 490- to 500-nm range. The data indicate that even in the absence of brightness cues 3-month-olds can discriminate: white light from spectral light selected from the protanopic and deuteranopic neutral zone. These results strongly suggest that infants of this age are not classical dichromats, but may possess ‘trichromatic vision. Teller and Peeples (Peeples., 1976; Peeples & Teller, 1975; Teller et al., 1978) used infants’ visual preference for patterned stimulation to study whether or not they saw a neutral zone. Essentially, these investigators created a two-alternative forced-choice situation where a colored bar could appear embedded in a white screen in either the infant’s left or right visual field. They then varied the luminance of the bar systematically .4 log units around the luminancc of the background screen. For differlent infants they varied the wavelength composition of the bar. Their observations showed that 2-month-olds looked at blue, bluegreen, orange, red, and nonspectral purple bars in preference to the white screen
1-2
5-6
9-10
TRIALS
13-14
(w)
F i g . 3. Mean durations of infants’ total a d j r s t j x a t i o m on serial presentations of spectral (490 nm < A 5 500 nm) and white (W)light. The data are averaged over pairs of consecutive presentations. (From Bornstein, I976a. Copyright Academic Press, Inc. Used by permission.)
Chromatic Vision in Infancy
I39
with no pattern. Most important among these is the blue-green ( A = 496 nm) since, were human infants classical protanopes or deuteranopes, they would not be able to distinguish a blue-green bar against a white ground at every level of l ~ m i n a n c e Curiously, .~ some infants could not or would not pick out green or yellow-green bars in preference to white. On the basis of their results with this method, Peeples and Teller tentatively concluded that infants 2 months of age see a neutral zone in the green to green-yellow region of the spectrum. No classical dichromatic type can be characterized by such an achromatic placement; however, irregular neutral zones are not unknown. Color vision defects acquired in diseases of the optic nerve, for example, show a variety of neutral zones across the spectrum (Griitzner, 1972). The zones in acquired deficiencies tend to be quite wide, though wider than infants in the present study displayed. Two alternative explanations for this infantile behavior might be entertained. First, infants younger than 3 months may not be dichromatic but may be otherwise color weak; in specific they may be deuteranomalous trichromats, since insensitivity to the middle (green) region of the spectrum is endemic to deutan deficiencies. The trichromat’s specbum is more saturated overall than that of the dichromat or anolmalous trichromat (Bornstein, 1976a; Chapanis, 1944, Table IV). Consequently, young deuteranomalous trichromats might confuse midspectral greens with white. In support of this view, morphological studies show small differences between immature and mature retinal cones (Duke-Elder & Cook, 1963). Alternatively, infants may not like to look at these two colors. Indeed, a general result of color preference studies suggests that infants specifically avoid green and green-yellow (e.g., Bornstein, 1975d) (see Section 11, B, 6 ) . Thus; infants’ lack of preference for midspectral hues may have influenced their responding in the Peeples and Teller situation. In 2-month-olds, however, it is not yet possible to distinguish between these alternatives: Since the infants will look only very little at a greenish light, they give no indication that they can discriminate it from white which they also regard only very little. In summary, results of these two studies of the neutral zone suggest that human infants by 2-3 months of age are not classical dichromats (i.e., protanopes or deuteranopes) though they may be color weak. The results further suggest though that human infants may be color-normal at 3 months. Certainly additional research is desirable to clarify the nature of chromatic vision near birth. “Boothe el al. (1975) applied an operant discrimination paradigm to light- and dark-reared infant monkeys. They reported that, with brightness systematically varied and attention strategies controlled, macaques younger than 2 months of age discriminated all wavelengths from white, and that one monkey did so even though it had been light deprived between the second week and the third month of its life. These results provide an ontogenetic baseline for De Valois and De Valois’s (1975) research with adult macaques, which exhibit trichromatic vision like adult humans. Additionally, the Boothe et al. results provide an animal model for future work in the ontogeny of primate color vision.
140
M a r c H . Bornstein
Of course not all adults are trichromats. As infants, therefore, dichromats should give evidence of a neutral zone in their spectrum. Since dichromasy can be predicted on the basis of genetic linkage-for example, half the sons born to mothers whose fathers were dichromats should be dichromats themselves (Hsia & Graham, 1965)-it should be possible to correlate the results of behavioral approaches with genetic determinations. As part of the studies just described, Bornstein (1976a, n. 4) and Peeples (1976) tested infants who were identified as potential dichromats on the basis of family history. Although the results are themselves quite tentative because of diagnostic inadequacies and the failure to conduct the studies in an experimentally blind manner, some presumptively color-deficient children in both studies failed to discriminate white from wavelengths in the range 490-500 nm. This result gives some indication, then, that like methods could be useful (1) in further studies of the earliest ontogeny of chromatic vision and ( 2 ) in the identification and early diagnosis of genetically indicated dichromasy .
3 . Wavelength Discrimination When the spectral sensitivity of an organism is known so that brightness differences among wavelengths can be controlled, it is possible to ascertain how many different wavelengths the organism can discriminate. (The absolute number will actually depend upon a threshold criterion and upon stimulus conditions.) Derivation of a wavelength-discrimination (AX) function has threefold importance. First, the wavelength-discrimination function reflects differential discriminability of available visible radiation and thus defines the limits of visibility. In man, wavelength discrimination is best (AA is small) near 490, 565, and 610 nm. Wavelengths shorter than 490 nm and longer than 610 nm are increasingly i ndi sti ngui sh able . Second, wavelength-di scrimi nati on capacities must reflect the ontogenetic maturation and function of the visual system since lateral geniculate cell sensitivities have been directly implicated in discrimination capacity (De Valois, Abramov, & Mead, 1967; De Valois & De Valois, 1975). Finally, wavelength discrimination and hue perception are strongly related: Wavelength regions at which adults show their best discrimination correlate strongly with wavelength regions that represent the changes between hues, and regions where adults show their poorest discrimination reflect regions where hue perception is unchanging (e.g., B. V. Graham, Turner, & Hurst, 1973; D. P. Smith, 1971; W. D. Wright, 1947). The wavelength-discrimination characteristic of adults has been known for quite some time (Siegel, 1962, 1963, 1964; Siegel & Dimmick, 1962; W. D. Wright, 1947), and studies of several infrahuman organisms including the bee (von Helversen, 1972), the pigeon (A. A. Wright, 1972), and the monkey (De Valois & De Valois, 1975) have been reported. But no complete studies have been published of discrimination capability of the developing visual system in humans.
Chromatic Vision in Infancy
141
In general, investigators interested in ascertaining discriminability along the dimension of wavelength have utilized simultaneous-discrimination paradigms. Chase's ( 1937) stimulus-superposition, movement-detection paradigm tested simultaneous wavelength discrimination, though he made no attempt to measure minimal or constant discriminability. Teller and Peeples' ( 1974) patternpreference paradigm could as well be adapted to a simultaneous wavelengthdiscrimination task. Additionally, the attention-habituation technique lends itself to such a test. In a preliminary investigation, Bornstein (unpublished observations) used the attention-habituation paradigm to study simultaneous wavelength discrimination in one 5-month-old infant. First, the child habituated to one wavelength that appeared simultaneously in two juxtaposed fields (each 10") on 15 15-second trials. Then, on several subsequent test trials light in one field was varied at 5, 10, or 15 nm longer than light in the second field, which was held constant at the habituated wavelength. All wavelengths had been matched for luminance by Judd's ( 195lb) modification of Standard Observer spectral sensitivity, and the test wavelengths appeared an equal number of times in the left and right fields to control for effects of any position preference. The spectral loci of habituated wavelengths were varied on different days. Five spectral regions were explored; they correspond to wavelengths on the adult wavelength-discrimination function that represented two minima and three maxima. The infant in this study was observed generally to look more at wavelengths increasingly different from an habituated wavelength that corresponded to a point of good discriminability, and he was observed generally to distribute his attention equally among the series of test wavelengths that fell in regions of poor adult discriminability. That is, the infant in this preliminary study demonstrated wavelength discrimination similar to that of an adult trichromat. Other studies of simultaneous hue discrimination with children complement the infant research. Gaines ( 1972) tested hue discrimination in 47 kindergarteners (mean age 5.7 years) in a simultaneous oddity task with narrow ranges of Munsell Hues. She assessed subjects' errors and decision latencies when Value and Chroma were varied. Gaines determined that children found it easiest to discriminate among yellows and among oranges (which had 15 and 22% error rates), harder among purples and among blues, and most difficult among reds and among greens (with 42 and 43% error rates, respectively). Discrimination latencies followed the same pattern: Yellow and orange took 4.1 and 4.2 seconds, while red and green took 6.3 seconds each. A clear explanation of these hue differences lies in native discriminative capacity: Wavelength discrimination is superior in the yellow and orange and less acute in the central green and red regions of the spectrum. Although the children in this first study led Gaines to believe that the young are quite skillful at hue discrimination, i n a cross-sectional follow-up study Gaines and Little (1975) unearthed a developmental trend. There, fifth-graders
142
Marc
H . Bornstein
( 10.6 years), high-school sophomores (15.8 years), the kindergartener’s parents
(39.2 years), and a matched adult group of “master artists” (44 years) showed linearly increasing hue discrimination overall, although the error ranking by hue within each group was the same as had been found among the kindergarteners. Thus, the quality of hue discrimination may increase somewhat with age on account of learning, attention, or perceptual development, but discriminability continues to reflect biologically given wavelength-discrimination capacities. Other developmental studies of simultaneous wavelength or hue discrimination (e.g., Gilbert, 1957; Lakowski, 1958-1959; Verriest, 1963) have uniformly demonstrated a decline in discriminability, particularly in the blue, in old age. The results of these studies reflect the phenomenon of developmental pseudocyananopsia discussed above (Bornstein, 1977a). The transposition of discriminative judgment across space or time will certainly result in degraded discrimination performance, but results with successive procedures have been found to parallel the basic form of simultaneous wavelength discrimination. Bornstein ( 1976a) tested eight 3-month-olds for their ability to resolve differences imong three fixed wavelengths, 560, 570, and 580 nm. The three stimuli in this study were matched for luminance (at 3.4 cd/m*) by Standard Observer sensitivity; as noted above, Dobson (1976) and Teller and Peeples (1974) determined that the 2-month-olds’ relative sensitivity in this spectral region matched that of adults and was typical of the Standard Observer. In this successive-discrimination design, infants were shown a wavelength, 570 nm, serially on 15 trials during a familiarization phase, which was immediately followed by a test phase of nine additional trials. The test trials were divided into three triplets in which the thrce wavelengths, 560, 570, and 580 nm, appeared in one random order, then in a second, and finally in a third. Each infant saw different random orders of the test stimuli, and the infant’s attention was redirected with an auditory prompt to the position of the test stimulus prior to each stimulus onset. All trials lasted 10 seconds, and the intervals between stimuli averaged 5 seconds. The habituation criterion was looking on Trials 13-15 less than 80% of the maximum looking in the preceding three-trial block. Figure 4 shows the results of both the habituation and test phases. As can be seen, infant looking showed rapid habituation over the last three familiarization trials. Looking during the nine test trials has been reduced to three-trial blocks to correspond to the three test wavelengths. The mean times shown in Fig. 4 indicate a statistically reliable dishabituation to 560 nm relative to 570 and 580 nm. The results of this study thus suggest that 3-month-old infants habituated to 570 nm will, in a successive test, discriminate 560 from 570 nm, but not 580 from 570 nm. Although simultaneous wavelength discrimination among adults is quite good throughout this region of the spectrum, successive discrimination is somewhat poorer and there is a phenomenal hue difference among the three wavelengths. For the adult trichromat, 560 nm appears greenish, while 570 and
570 nrn W I I-
560 nm
5
I I I
I 1-3
4-6
I
10-12
7-9
I
I T
13-15
TRIALS
Fig. 4 . Mean durations of infants' fotul fixcltions on serial presentations of an habituation wavelength (570 nmj and three test (Tj wai,elengrhs (560, 570, and 580 nm). (From Bornstein, 1 9 7 6 ~Copyright . Academic Press, Inc. Used bv permission.)
580 nm are yellowish (Beare, 1963; Boynton & Gordon, 1965). In summary, after habituation to a predominantly yellow light (570 nm), infants looked significantly less at yellows (570 and 580 nm) than at a predominantly green light (560 nm). In his successive discrimination capacity, the infant qualitatively resembles the adult. In summary, developmental studies of simultaneous and successive discrimination of hue are few, but they tend to suggest that the adult form of the wavelength-discrimination function is present early in infancy. This would be expected on the view that wavelength discriminability actually reflects native visual system function, rather than learning or experience (Kopp & Lane, 1968). Studies with older children and adults also suggest that discriminability improves somewhat until old age when it may show decrements selective to short wavelengths. The foregoing data on wavelength discrimination help to define further the state of chromatic vision 3 months after birth. The protanopic or deuteranopic eye matches all visible wavelengths longer than about 500 nm (500-700 nm) with a wavelength seen in the normal eye lying near 570 nm (yellowish) and all visible wavelengths shorter than about 490 nm (400-490 nm) with a wavelength seen in the normal eye lying near 470 nm (blue) (C. H. Graham & Hsia, 1958; Hurvich, 1972). These classical dichromats, therefore, do not differentiate green from yellow the way trichromats do; that is, they do not see and respond to wavelengths just shorter than 565 nm as similar and yet as qualitatively different from wavelengths just longer than 565 nm. The 565-nm boundary is exclusive to the trichromat's green and yellow hue distinctions. The young infants' discrimination of
144
Marc H . Bornstein
560 from 570 and 580 nm (Bornstein, 1976a) tends therefore to corroborate by an independent converging procedure results from neutral-zone studies, and it confirms that by 3 months postpartum, infants are probably trichromatic observers. 4 . The Organization of Hue The psychological correlate of stimulus wavelength is perceived hue. Spectral hues derive from the prismatic dispersion of white sunlight, and discriminable spectral hues have been estimated to number approximately 128. Wavelength discriminability varies nonmonotonically along the wavelength continuum, and discriminability correlates strongly with the qualitative variations of hue. To quote W. D. Wright: The [wavelength discrimination] curves as a whole have the characteristics that might be anticipated from a qualitative examination of the spectrum. The part of the spectrum where a minimum exists must obviously occur where there is a rapid change of hue; thus in the yellow where the color turns redder on one side and greener on the other, in the blue-green where it turns bluer on one side and greener on the other, in the violet where it becomes redder or bluer, minimum steps would be expected. But beyond [610 nm] the colour changes steadily to a deeper and deeper red, and in the green where there is only a gradual change to either a blue-green or a yellow-green, the discrimination is poorer and the step consequently greater. (W. D. Wright, 1947, pp. 117-1 18)
W. D. Wright’s observation restates the inverse relationship between generalization (or categorization) and discrimination (Lashley & Wade, 1946; A. A. Wright, 1972). Although wavelength generalization and discriminability do not coexist in a perfectly correlated way, the relationship seems logical and, in the opinion of many investigators, empirically valid (e.g., Ekman, 1954; B. V. Graham et a l . , 1973; Jacobs 1Pr Gaylord, 1967; D. P. Smith, 1971). Because spectral hues are salient, interest in their differentiation has been sustained from ancient through modem times: Aristotle discussed the distinct color qualities of the rainbow (Loveday & Forster, 1913), and Newton (16711672) marvelled at perceptual discontinuities in the nature of light. Hue has served for some time as a focus of epistemological inquiry (Bomstein, 1975b), but only recently has the organization of hue come under direct psychophysical investigation in identification and discrimination tasks (Bornstein, 1975b; C . H. Graham, 1965). The results of several methods as diverse as color naming (Beare, 1963), color scaling (Boynton & Gordon, 1965), and the estimation of chromatic similarity (Ekman, 1963) confirm that the relationship between hue and wavelength is regular. When centrally viewed, at moderate durations and luminances, and under conditions of neutral adaptation, the spectrum is perceived to display a discontinuous, though orderly, array of hues. From the short to the long wave end, four principal qualities are commonly identified: blue, green, yellow, and red.
Chromatic. Vision in Infancy
145
Wavelengths of light differ from one another equally in physical terms; psychologically, however, some are unique (Berlin & Kay, 1969; Bornstein, 1973; Dimmick & Hubbard, 1939a, 1939b; Sternheim & Boynton, 1966). Unique hues represent psychologically pure and unmixed sensations; other colors in and outside the spectrum represent combinations of one or more unique hues green, and and may be so analyzed visually. Three “unique” hues-blue, yellow-are spectral; their dominant wavelengths fall approximately at 475,5 15, and 582 nm, respectively (Boynton, 1975; Dimmick & Hubbard, 1939a). All long wavelengths look yellowish; therefore, unique red is extraspectral, that is, a mixture of long and short waves, which cancel yellow (Dimmick & Hubbard, 1939b). Bornstein (1973, 1975b) has reviewed several lines of evidence that suggest that blue, green, yellow, and red are biologically, psychologically, and linguistically unique and meaningful. Although the three dimensions of the color solid generate more than 7,500,000 colors (Nickerson & Newhall, 1943), only four hue terms-blue, green, yellow, and red-are required to provide a comprehensive yet parsimonious qualitative description of the spectrum (Beare, 1963; Boynton & Gordon, 1965; Ekman, 1963; see also Gothlin, 1943, 1944; Sternheim & Boynton, 1966). In a color-naming task, when only basic terms such as red or yellow are allowed to describe a given wavelength, wide regions of the spectrum yield plateau-shaped naming functions (Beare, 1963). Narrower ranges i n between are marked by competing, complementary, and symmetrical use of two terms. When a combination of two basic terms is allowed, peaked generalization-type gradients result (Boynton & Gordon, 1965). Boynton and Gordon’s more sensitive color-naming technique demonstrates important facts about hue perception. First, hue “category” effects depend on method; increasing the number of allowable terms reduces the absoluteness of the category. This effect indicates, second, that adults can discriminate among wavelengths within hue categories, a fact not evident in Beare’s identification data but clearly manifest in wavelength-discrimination data. “Categories” of hue seem to exist, nevertheless, since color naming reflects the fact that discrimination among wavelengths within a hue is less acute than discrimination of wavelengths between hues. One of the common characteristics of color normalcy, then, is the adult’s predisposition to partition the spectrum into four regular and basic hue categories. Regardless of method, color-normal adult observers place hue boundaries near wavelength-discrimination minima. Since it has been suggested that infants 3 months of age also possess trichromatic vision, studies of the successive discriminati on of wavelengths should reveal that they also partition the physical spectrum into qualitative categories like hues. One indication that infants might distinguish less well within a hue than between hues came from Fagan (1974). Infants in his study looked longest at (discriminated best) checkerboards constructed of different hues, such as red and
I46
Marc H . Borrisrein
green; they looked less at checkerboards constructed of similar hues, such as red and yellow-red; and they looked least at checkerboards constructed of two samples of the same hue, such as two different reds. Bornstein et al. (1976b) used the attention-habituation paradigm with monochromatic spectral lights to assess the organization of hue in young infants. Fourteen different groups each with 10 4-month-olds looked at 10” spectral stimuli repeatedly until their visual attention waned. These habituation stimuli were selected from the four basic adult hue categories-blue, green, yellow, and red. After 15 habituation trials with the one wavelength, infants were shown a series of 9 test wavelengths that included 3 presentations each of the original light and two new lights. Several groups saw the original, a second wavelength selected from the same adult hue category, and a third wavelength selected from a different aduh. hue category. Other groups saw the original and two other lights selected from the same hue category as the orginal. For both types, the new wavelengths presented in the test phase were carefully selected to be equal physical distances (in nanometers) from the original habituation stimulus, in order that the infants’ differential disinhibition of attention to new lights could be attributed only to the psychological dissimilarity of the new and original hues. The original habituation hue appeared randomly in the test series, and statistical contrasts were made among all stimuli in the test phase. These two provisions contributed stringent intrainfant controls against alternative interpretations of dishabituation that implicated simple fluctuations of attention. Still another control group looked at the same light for 24 consecutive trials; these infants showed no selective disinhibition. The results of this study essentially represent swcessive hue discriminations, and they followed a course similar to those discussed previously (Bornstein, 1976a). As an example, the results of two groups are shown in Fig. 5. Those children who originally saw a blue of 480 nm and were tested with that blue, another of 450 nm, and a green of 5 10 nm paid most attention to the green. They treated the blue which they had not seen before (450 nm) as they did the blue which they had (480 nm). A complementary group of children who saw a green of 5 10 nm first paid the most attention to a blue of 480 nm during a test series that included the original green habituation stimulus ( 5 10 nm), another green (540 nm), and the blue of 480 nml. Together these two groups show that infants see 450 nm as similar to480 nm, 510 nm as similar to 540 nm, but 480 nm as distinct from 510 nm. Adults make similar distinctions and call them “blue” versus “green.” Three boundaries, at 490, 565, and 610 nm, were tested in this way with pairs of complementary infant groups: For one group, the habituation stimulus was selected from the category on the long-wavelength side of the boundary, and for the other group the habituation stimulus was selected from the category on the short-wavelength side of the boundary. In addition, related groups of infants tested the extents of individual hues between 430 and 660 nm.
I47
Chromtaic Vision in Infancy
450nm-
-
480nm
Group I 1
I
1.3 4.6
,
I
1
I
-
\
-
540nm
-
Group 2
I l l
I
1-3 4 6
7-9 10.12 13-15 T
510nm
I
I
I
I
I
I
7.9 1012 13-15 r
TRIALS
Fig. 5 . Same as Fig. 4 , but for two groups of infants who habituated and were tested with the wavelengths indicated.
Brightness was eliminated as a factor in these investigations . 5 Summary analyses of the infants’ visual attention to the different colors that were presented during testing are shown in Fig. 6 and compared with adult color-naming data (Boynton & Gordon, 1965). The results indicate that, on the whole, infants categorize wavelengths by their perceptual similarity very much the way adults do. That is, infants perceive four qualitatively distinct spectral categories or hues: blue (approximately 4 3 0 4 8 0 nm), green (approximately 5 10-560 nm), yellow (approximately 570-600 nm), and red (approximately 620-680 nm). As with adults, interhue boundaries for infants appeared around 490, 565, and 610 nm. Note that violet is not distinguished from blue. Nagel’s (1906) son Gerhard called purple, violet, and blue all “lilla,” and Ladd-Franklin (1901) also observed that children see colors in the short wave range as perceptually similar. Having noticed purples for the first time, Ladd-Franklin’s own daughter exclaimed: “B’u!-Wed!-Wed!-B’u!” “It was impossible to doubt that she, at least, saw in purple the blue and red of which it’s composed” (p. 398). ’Adult standard spectral sensitivity coefficients, in specific Judd’s ( 1951b) modification of Standard Observer sensitivity, were used to balance wavelengths (luminance = 3.4 cd/m2). Most groups in this study saw wavelengths longer than 550 nm, where relative infant and adult sensitivities closely match (Dobson, 1976; Teller & Peeples, 1974). For the groups who saw wavelengths shorter than 550 nm, Judd’s coefficients, which revised the too low weighting of the Standard Observer at shorter visible wavelengths, more closely approximate those shown for the infant. By design, independent groups experienced sets of wavelengths which spanned relatively short ranges, over which brightness differences are reduced, and the technique used in these s t u d i e d e t e c t i o n of hue boundaries-is one which minimizes the potential influence of brightness differences. Boynton and Gordon (1965). for example, have shown that although the absolute luminance level affects the apparent hue of some wavelengths (Bezold-Briicke shift), the wavelength boundaries between hues remain approximately constant over wide ranges of retinal illuminance or luminance. As Boynton (1971) has observed, color naming among color-normal observers shows much less dependence on luminance than on the wavelength of the stimulus.
Marc H . Bornstein
I48 I
9-
rn
5
-+
:
4 -
Z
5 6-
-
4 a
1;1
I00
20
50
1
1
1
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
l
l
I
+ -
-
H b -
ltl H
C
+ t l
13 -
INFANT SUMMARY
1
1
2 3 -
0
4
-
,~ H
+---I
H
-
H
-
BLU’E
-
I-
\
z W u
,“
I
I - 4
1 -
:
2
I
0-
I
e I
I
,
I
,
I
I
I
I
,
I
1
1
,
I
I
In a follow-up to this experiment, rate of habituation was used to index the organization of hue in comparable groups of young infants (Bornstein et al., 1976b). It is known that habituation to re-presentation of the same stimulus is faster than it is to varied stimulation (Cornell, 1974; Fantz, 1964; Friedman, 1972; McCall & Kagan, 1967). In this study three groups of 10 4-month-old infants were seen under stimulus conditions used previously: One group was shown the same wavelength (480 nm) repeatedly; a second group was shown, in quasi-random alternation, two wavelengths (480 and 450 nm) which had been selected from the same infant hue category as determined in Bornstein et al. (1976b); and a third group was shown serially two wavelengths (480 and 5 10 nm) which had been selected from different infant hue categories. The one stimulus which was common to all three groups, 480 nm, appeared to each group in the same sequential positions. Consequently, experimental treatments for all three groups differed only by the context in which 480 nm appeared. Again, as in the
Chromatic Vision in Infancy
149
original category study, wavelengths of 450 and 510 nm were selected so that physical differences between each and 480 nm were equal but the psychological distances varied; this choice controls for potential response variation ascribable to simple physical (wavelength) change rather than psychological (hue) change. The results of this study, plotted in Fig. 7, showed that (1) visual attention to spectral light waned with stimulus repetition in each group, ( 2 ) the courses of habituation for Group 1 (same-wavelength) and Group 2 (same-hue) were indistinguishable, but (3) the two-hue group (Group 3) exhibited more overall looking than Groups 1 and 2 and a slower rate of habituation. Figure 7 shows the course of habituation only on the 480-nm trials for the three groups. In summary, the intergroup comparisons indicate that rates of habituation to physically identical and to psychologically similar stimuli are the same, but that rate of habituation is reduced when psychologically dissimilar stimuli are intermixed. Since order effects and group heterogeneity were not factors, these data also can be taken to indicate corroboratively that infants perceive and respond to 480 nm as though it were the same as or highly similar to 450 nm but different or highly dissimilar from 5 10 nm. These results therefore provide independent converging evidence for the existence of an organization of hue in infancy. That preverbal infants organize the visible spectrum into perceptual categories like adult hues may be somewhat surprising. Commonly, psychologists (Beare, 1963; C. H. Graham, 1965), psycholinguists (Lenneberg, 1967), and an-
c
.~
o--o
GROUP I
4
10
W
E
I-
W
zY 0
sz
5
4
W
I
-
0 2 5 6 7 11 12 14 17 18 19 23 24 TRIAL NUMBER
Fig. 7. The course of habituation of visual attention in three groups over the 12 trials (of 24) on which the common wavelength, 480 nm, was presented. (From Bornstein et al., 19766. Copyright American Psychological Association. Used by permission.)
150
Marc H . Bornstein
thropologists (Carroll, 1964; Ray, 1952, 1953; Whorf, 1952) have maintained that categories of hue reflect arbitrary discriminations, and they have previously associated regularities in hue categorization (and even wavelength discrimination, see Kopp & Lane, 1968) with common cultural training. The fact that preverbal infants organize wavelengths into perceptual categories is, however, not unexpected from the points of view of biology or ethology. The neural processes through which visual information about color is analyzed begin at the retina and follow the main geniculostriate pathways in the brain. Different lines of evidence suggest that specific cells in the lateral geniculate nucleus decode the hue information in the color signal. They are selectively sensitive to the four principal hues of the spectrum, and De Valois and De Valois (1975) have suggested that these cells account for wavelength discrimination in man and other primates. The relationships between wavelength discrimination and hue categorization, and between, underlying lateral geniculate cell sensitivities and wavelength discrimination (De Valois & De Valois, 1975), indicate that to a large degree hue categorization reflects indigenous visual function. Significantly, hue categorization (related to wavelength discrimination) has been found in three norhuman species that possess color vision. Von Frisch (1964) demonstrated the organization of hues in the European honey bee (Apis mellifera), A. A. Wright (1972; A. A. Wright & Cumming, 1971) in the pigeon (Columba liviu), and Grether (1939) and Essock (1977) in the chimpanzee (Pan). This ethological perspective makes the assumption of a biological basis for qualitative chromatic distinctions more plausible than alternative assumptions about learning and language. In summary, color-naming or other hue-categorization studies of centrally and photopically presented monochromatic lights yield normative and verifiable data about the ways in which humans and infrahuman species perceive and organize color in their world. As it is for other organisms that possess color vision, the color world is organized into basic hues in infancy, that is before language acquisition. These basic hues number four: blue, green, yellow, and red. Hue naming or categorization has come to play an important role in the assessment of color vision and related perceptual phenomena in recent years. Using color naming, C. H. Graham and Hsia (1958) and Scheibner and Boynton (1968), for example, discovered the important fact that neither protans nor deutans typically perceive boundaries between basic hues at 565 and 610 nm. The data on hue organization in infancy argue that insofar as infants distinguish four hues across the spectrum, a color-normal or trichromatic “adult” view prevails quite early in life. It is a curious fact, in this light, that accurate color naming is so late in developing (see Section I, B, above). Goodenough and Anderson (1931), for example, reported that according to Merrill-Palmer test norms, only 4- to 5-year-olds will name a wide range of colors with some accuracy. Norsworthy and Whitley (1920) gave 5 years as the age when children know all four colors in
Chromtrtic Vision in Itfuncj
151
the Binet test, although Binet and Simon themselves reported a norm older than 7 years on the average (G. A. Miller, 1974). Naming seems not to stabilize until approximately the fourth year (Dale, 1969; Yendovitskaya, Zinchenko, & Ruzskaya, 1964/1971), and it remains problematic even late into development: witness psychophysical data from Boynton and Gordon (1965). One of three subjects in that study was M. B., Boynton’s 12-year-old son. Despite the fact that blue and yellow are mutually exclusive visual perceptions (Hering, 1878/1964), he named a few of the same wavelengths blue, yellow, or some combinations of blue and yellow. Late color naming is striking; recall that i n the absence of other information early investigators took the paucity of color vocabulary to indicate a lack of development of color vision in infants and young children (e.g., Shinn, 1909; Stern, 1924). Bornstein (1977d) evaluated four hypotheses to account for this discrepancy. First, younger children may simply have a problem with or have a lack of experience in associating color terminology with color percepts. Second, the slow acquisition of color vocabulary may reflect a bipartite process, conceptual on the one hand and linguistic on the other. Conjoining these processes requires time. Third, semantic development may proceed in such a way that names are attached to certain classes of words, such as entities, before others, such as attributes. Last, the color categorizationxolor naming schism could reflect physiological immaturity leading to the absence of percept or organization of color independent of color discrimination. The existence of different cell types functionally segregated by a cortical region (De Valois & De Valois, 1975) raises the possibility that i n ontogeny color differentiations could occur in the absence of the accurate utilization of other color information. The infant’s perception of color may serve several functions toward his eventual understanding of an otherwise visually complex world. The fact that early in life colors are organized and segregated by hue must increase their cognitive utility and value. At a sensory level, colors provide for more varied stimulation about the environment. At a perceptual level, color, in addition to luminance, subserves visual contrast and promotes spatial detection (Boynton & Greenspon, 1972; McFarland & M u m , 1975; Walls, 1942). Cognitively, colors provide a unique type of information about the environment (Conklin, 1973), and color similarities provide a basis for structuring the perceptual world. Aesthetically, colors please and differentially influence attention. Thus, hue perception may facilitate different mental operations and aid memory. It is compelling, for example, that the preverbal child must utilize purely sensory information, like color, in coding and remembering objects. The infant’s capacity to remember colors is the subject of the next section.
5 . Color and Memory Development Historically, memory has been thought to reflect verbal reprocessing of physical stimulus information. Memory researchers since Ebbinghaus ( 1885/1964) have used linguistic or pseudolinguistic stimuli, and even when nonlinguistic stimuli
I52
Murc H . Bornstein
have been used, both adults (e.g., Glanzer & Clark, 1962) and older children (e.g., Perlmutter & Myers, 1975) have often been found to use verbal codes to remember. More recently, ‘however, studies of adult memory have evidenced retention of nonverbal or “physical” information about a stimulus (e.g.. Melton & Martin, 1972). As Posner (1973) has observed, memory cannot be characterized as solely verbal since our ability to recognize is vastly superior to our ability to categorize and label. This observation is significant from a developmental viewpoint since memory processes for stimulus features are important, especially in infancy. They are integral to the growth of the child’s knowledge about the physical world. The early development of object recognition, for example, must depend wholly on the child’s encoding, processing, and retention of physical properties of the object. Nonverbal encoding must assume ontogenetic priority to verbal encoding. Like other dimensions of sensation, adult memory for color has been thought to reflect verbal skills (e.g., R. W. Brown & Lenneberg, 1954; Lenneberg, 1967; Siegel & Siegel, 1976). Recent research (e.g., Berlin & Kay, 1969; Bornstein, 1973, 1974; Rosch, 1973) has suggested, however, that color coding and color memory may in many instances operate independently of language labels; that is, there may be universal, sensory-based codes for color. Color therefore qualifies as one of the physical characteristics especially available to early memory encoding. That human infants about 4 months of age already categorize surface colors supports this view. Reasonably, then, infants’ perceptions of various surface qualities, such as hue, shoulld not only function in early perceptual differentiation but should also be subject to useful recollection. Theories of habituation (Cohen & Gelber, 1975) usually imply the constmction of some internal representation of a stimulus that can be compared with a test stimulus later. In this sense.,habituation tests tap the infant’s recognition memory as well as his discriminative abilities. If the temporal interval between the familiarization and test phases in the attention-habituation paradigm is expanded, longer term recognition memory is emphasized. Several investigators have studied infants’ recognition of color subsequent to habituation. In most experiments, however, color variations have been confounded with variations in form. For example, Martin (1975) showed that older infants can retain a color-form pattern up to 24 hours, and De Loache (1976) showed that a change in two or four of four color-form elements used in habituation will reexcite infants’ discriminative fixation. Because color and form were not varied orthogonally in these studies, they provide little information about color retention per se. In other investigations color and form were vaned orthogonally. Between 3 and 4 months, 4.5 minutes of familiarization are sufficient to elicit preferential attention to a change in both color and form, but insufficient for a change in color alone or form alone (Saayman, Ames, & Moffett, 1964; Welch, 1974). Cohen (1973) has suggested that after approximately 4 months,
Chrotiiiiric
Visiorr rn Iiifiincy
153
infants store information about color and form as separate components independent of their compound, since when tested with a novel form, novel color, or novel color-form configuration, they exhibit dishabituation to changes Lither in the color or in the form and exhibit the most dishabituation to a pattern novel in both color and form (Cohen, Gelber, & Lazar, 197 I ) . The critical age suggested by Cohen can be questioned, however, because Milewski and Siqueland (1975), using an operant measure, habituation of high-amplitude sucking, showed that I-month-olds can discriminate red from a blue with which they have been familiarized. Other studies have demonstrated color recognitior! at 6, 8 , and 12 months (e.g., Miranda & Fantz, 1974; Schaffer & Parry, 1969, 1970). Schaffer and Parry (1969) observed a sharp rise in visual attention among 6- and 12-montholds at the introduction of a test object identical in size and shape to a familiarization object but different from it i n color. These objects, whose presentation was counterbalanced across subjects, were predominately red or predominately blue. In a follow-up study, similar results were reported with yellow and blue objects equated for size, shape, and contour (Schaffer & Parry, 1970). In none of the above studies was there any attempt to control stimulus qualities such as bandwidth or brightness. I n fact, complex, unspecified colors continue to be used in developmental studies. Yet without such stimulus control it is possible, though not likely, that young infants excerpt brightness or some other dimension of the stimulus from the “color” and base their memory for the stimulus on it. The use of brightness-equated hues in the category studies with infants (e.g., Bornstein et a l . , 1976b) suggests that babies can use hue alone in immediate memory. Immediate-recognition data in Bornstein et al. (1976b) and Bornstein (1976a) evidence an important aspect of infant color memory. In the serial habituationtest paradigm, exact stimulus (wavelength) information is apparently lost, while gross category (hue) information is retained. Theories of habituation (e.g., Sokolov, 1958/1963) suggest that habituation reflects the construction of an internal representation or neuronal model of stimulus properties based on repeated experience with those properties. The existence along the visual pathway of neural tissue specifically sensitive to different regions of the spectrum suggests that Sokolov’s theory should be modified. Not all cell assemblies or neuronal models need be constructed experientially. Rather, the neurological equipment for some properties, like hue, may exist i n the absence of specific experience. Moreover, the child’s categorical response to color, that is his failure to recognize one wavelength following habituation to another wavelength of the same hue, fleshes out the nature of these cell assemblies for hue. Hue-sensitive cell types may respond to a variety of wavelengths that fall within a given hue class. Presentation of a wavelength from any one hue class may mean excitation of the hue assembly in toto, so that only a change to a wavelength in another hue class
I54
Marc H.Bornstein
will excite a different cell assembly and activate attention. The corollary of this “category effect” is that, for color at least, neural coding in habituation is not physically exact. If exact neural coding subserved habituation, then infants should dishabituate to a new wavelength which represents a familiarized hue. However, the data from immediate- and delayed-recognition studies indicate that infants process chromatic information categorically using qualitative “hue codes” rather than exact “wavelength codes.” Data from adult studies of color memory suggest that color is recoded verbally for long-term retention (Bornstein, 1976c; Hochberg, 197 l ) , and analogous evidence suggests that color memory in infancy may be lost in several minutes. After habituating two groups of 4-month-olds to a color-form geometric configuration, for example a green circle, Pancratz and Cohen (1970) tested them with the original pattern and also novel color-form configurations, for example a blue triangle. The group tested immediately after habituation remembered, the group tested 5 minutes after habituation did not. Infants in Bornstein’s (1976a) study gave a pattern of recognition responses which suggested that by 3 months of age immediate visual memory lor pure hue alone has begun to develop; infants recognized 570 nm immediately following habituation to it. A follow-up study that employed the same stimuli and procedures (Bornstein, 1976b) showed that 4-month-old infants’ recognition of the habituation hce resisted 3 minutes of retroactive interference from the same visual dimension (different hue) and from different visual-auditory dimensions (mother’s face and voice), but was not so resistant to 5 minutes of interference. Infants therefore show good immediate recognition of hue, and this result further substantiates reports of nonverbal coding of (chromatic) information in memory. Bryant (1974) has argued that the coding in juvenile or infantile memory is relative in nature and that successive discriminations depend upon a constant frame of reference rather than an absolute internal code of a stimulus. Results from infantile color memory suggest that young children can and do code wavelengths absolutely by apparent hue; that is, infants successfully discriminate hues in the absence of alternatives other than inferred internal categories of information (Bornstein, 1 9 7 5 ~ ) . In 1924, Stern questimed whether young children actually use color codes in memory at all, bct at the time children were generally thought to be “color blind.” Certainly, young children classify objects by color (Brian & Goodenough, 1929; Suchman & Trabasso, 1966), aild the studies outlined above show that absolute c d o r codes for this purpose are available to them from infancy. Not unexpectedly, therefore, researchers who have carefully manipulated chromatic discriminative cues have demonstrated that color can facilitate memory. Daehler, Bukatko, Benson, and Myers (1976), for example, found that the addition of color cues f,acilitated 18- to 36-month-olds’ performance on a delayed hidden-object task, and having established the perceptual salience of
color over number and position among 5 % - , 8%-, and 11%-year-old children (Odom & Guzman, 1972), Odom (1972) found that this salience was directly related to recall accuracy in problem solving. Normally, the number of colors recalled increases linearly with age, between 8 years and adulthood, regardless of reterdion interval or the nature of interference (Belmont, 1972). Belmont (1972), however, found retardates (MA = 56-83) deficient in short-term (0-12 seconds) memory for color relative to normal children (MA = 96-104), and he attributed this difference to increases in information-processing capacity with age and mental ability. Sinson and Wetherick (1972, 1973, 1975) also observed a specific deficit in short-term retention of color information in Down’s syndrome children relative to a group of MA- and CA-matched controls: Down’s syndrome children consistently averaged nine times the number of successive color matching errors as normal children, though these same groups performed comparably in successive form matching and in simultaneous color matching. Sinson and Wetherick ascribed this color-memory deficiency to unidentified genetic origins; intriguingly, Miranda and Fantz (1974), who tested discrimination and recognition memory for color and form in Down’s syqdrome and normal infants, found a similar deficit pattern: In their habituation study, Down’s syndrome infants failed to recognize a change in color at 3 0 4 0 weeks of age, when normal infants did. The extent to which Miranda and Fantz’s (1974) results are ascribable to abnormal memory or to abnormal development of color vision is unknown. From other results in their study it is clear that the development of recognition memory in Down’s syndrome infants lags behind that i n normal infants generally; also the distribution of color deficiency i n retarded populations does not differ from that i n the normal population (Courtney & Heath, 1971). The stimuli used in the study were, however, not equated for brightness or saturation. In addition, the two colors used were red and blue, two hues which infants prefer nearly equally, and the influence of color preference in developmental studies of color vision may be significant. In summary, infants remember colors i n “hue codes” rather than as exact physical information. Early in life, memory for color is comparatively tenuous. The fact that infants do recognize colors, though, strongly suggests that color memory is not language dependent or necessarily relational and that infants may use the chromatic information about a stimulus toward its future identification. 6. Color Preference Experimental observations of the ontogeny of color vision began with studies of color preference (Baldwin, 1895), and interest in the development of chromatic vision has been sustained by continued investigation in this area (e.g., Bornstein, 1975d; Dashiell, 1917; Gesell, Ilg, & Bullis, 1949; Myers, 1908; Spears, 1964; Staples, 1932). In consonance with a belief that children were color deficient,
I56
Mort H . Bornstein
early researchers concluded that no color preference was discernible before the fourth year of life (e.g., Dashiell, 1917; Major, 1915). Later studies with babies, however, confirmed preferences for colored objects. Staples ( 1932), for example, studied preferences for the Atlas series of Munsell colors in different groups of children. The youngest (imean age, 3 months) looked more at primary colors (red, yellow, green, and blue) than at a neutral gray. Older infants (mean age, 13.3 months) generally reached or pointed more at red than at other colors. Spears (1964) paired Munsell colors in front of 4-month-olds and found blue reliably preferred to (regard’edlonger than) gray, but blue, red, and yellow were equally preferred. Indeed, reliable color preference of a general sort has received clear experimental support in adults and infants (Bornstein, 197%; Guilford, 1940) and even in neonates (Jones-Molfese, 1977). Preference methodologies can yield data with multiple interpretations; frequently they have been applied to issues i n attention and discrimination, infrequently in aesthetics. Often and unfortunately, investigators interested in color preference have not been schooled in psychophysics or color science, and investigators with psychophysical credentials have not been interested in the study of preference. Therefore, historically, stimulus control has been inadequate in preference studies, and this fact, perhaps more than any other, has contributed to variable results. I n ontogenetic studies of color preference, as in other color psychophysics, the control of brightness has been a perennial problem, since preferences for brightness vary in infancy (cf. Hershenson, 1964; Thomas, 1973). One experimental course has been to assume infant-adult parity in matching colors for brightness. Notwithstanding the questions associated with this assumption (see Section 11, A , 2 ) , hue is a more influential factor than brightness in adult judgments of color preference (Guilford, 19341, and therefore the results of these studies merit consideration. Two principal findings have emerged from color-preference tests with infants and adults: ( 1 ) primary or focal colors, that is category centers, tend to be preferred to mixed or boundary hues, and (2) the spectrally extreme hues tend to be preferred to midspectral hues. One study (Bornstein, 1975d) exemplifies both these trends. Bornstein ( l975d) monitored 4-month-olds’ looking at eight equally bright monochromatic spectral lights: violet (430 nm), blue (460 nm), blue-green (490 nm), green (520 nm), green-yellow (560 nm), yellow (580 nm), yellow-red (600 nm), and red (630 nm). These stimuli subtended lo” of visual angle and were presented at a luminance of 55 cd/m2. The eight colors span the visible spectrum and represent “centers” of and “boundaries” between infants’ color categories. Infants in paired-comparisons groups saw all possible pairs of the eight wavelengths twice; infants in a comparable single-stimulus group saw two random presentations of each of the eight. The babies in these two conditions
157
-37.
-z,
-
w
r
23
-11)
z
0 k-
- 1 4
a
X - 9
LL
Fig. 8 . Mertn c/urritions ofit$itnts’ totiilfiwtiom and meat1 adult pleasantness rutings as a function ofwavelength. Letters B (blue), G (green). Y (wllo w), iinci R ( r e d ) . indicate the upparent hue of the wavelength: see te..rtfbrfirrther e.xpl(ttuttron /‘he two orilinute scales have been udjjusted by a double linerrr-regression terhniytie (Bornsrein. I075d. p p . 41 I 4 1 2 ) so as to he equrvulent. (From Bornstein, 1975d. Copyright Acudemic Pr.e.s.3, I n c . U . w I by permission.)
provided separate replications of the same basic relationship between fixation time and wavelength: rank order correlation ( p ) = +.92. The pairedcomparisons data are displayed in Fig. 8. Although not all color-category centers were looked at more than all interhue boundaries, the attention infants in both conditions paid to category centers as a group reliably exceeded that paid to boundaries as a group.‘ Other investigators, including Jastrow ( 1897), Guilford (1934), and Eysenck (1941), have previously found center hues preferred to boundary or mixed hues. Second, the Bornstein study showed that blue and red were most preferred. Although space limitations prevent a complete review of the plethora of studies of color preference, it is worthwhile to look at a recurrent trend among some of the better studies that shows consistent observer preferences for the spectral extremes red and blue, relative to midspectral green and yellow. Baldwin’s infant daughter, H . , showed an equal number of “dynamogenic” responses (see Section I , B) to red and blue and fewer to white, green, and brown (Baldwin, 1893), ‘Has this infant perference an influeiice beyond immediate attention, say to habituation and memory’? C. J. Brown (1974) found that X-week-olds preferred an 8 X 8 checkerboard to a more “complex” 24 X 24 pattern; her infants also showed less habituation to the 8 X 8 than the 24 X 24. Habituation was a linear function of prefercnce for complexity. Intriguingly, habituation data from the hue-category study (Bornstein et i i l . , 1976b) show the opposite result: Slopes of habituation for more preferred, purer blue (450 nm) and red (630-660 nm) stimuli averaged - 1.84 and - I .63, respectively, while habituation slopes for wavelengths near less preferred, mixed hue boundaries averaged - 1 .18.
I58
Marc
H. Bortlstern
and Holden and Bosse (1900) found blue and red preferred to yellow and green. The same trend emerged in infant studies by Staples (1932), Stirnimann (1944), and Spears (1964). A preference for blue over yellow also appeared in Schaffer and Parry’s (1970) study of infant discrimination. In tests with older children, Dashiell (1917) found that kindergartners ranked blue and red as more pleasant than yellow and green, as did the college sophomores he asked. Garth and Porter (1934) found that 1032 children 1-7 years of age generally preferred red and blue Milton Bradley colors to green, yellow, or white. Likewise, Bradbury and Nelson (1974) found the 7-, 9-, and 1 I-year-olds preferred red to blue to green. Adults display similar consistent patterns of color preference. Bornstein (1975d) asked 24 adults (mean age, 24 years) to judge the pleasantness of spectral lights his infants had seen. In general, adults’ ratings of the pleasantness of the colors paralleled infants’ differential attention to them ( p = .80; see Fig. 8). Among the most careful and extensive adult studies of color preference are those of Guilford, who used Milton Bradley colored papers (Guilford, 1934, 1940; Walton, Guilford, & Guilford, 1933). The rank-order correlation coefficient between the adult data in Bornstein’s (1975d) study and the averages for men and women (n = 10) tested by Guilford (1934, Table 11) was calculated at .66, which is statistically significant. The data for Bornstein’s adults also replicated Waltonetal. ’s (1933) extensive (n = 1279) paired-comparisons data (p = + .74). These studies confirm that adults prefer centers to boundaries and that they prefer the spectral extremes. Jastrow (1897) and Eysenck (1941) also found that the red-blue-green preference hierarchy was a general result in adults. Although color preference has often been viewed as susceptible to fluctuating influences, the resilience clf these preference findings to diachronic change, development, laboratory method, and investigator bespeaks their robustness. Often with such data in hand, the psychologist will begin to think in terms of biological influences. Certainly the infant data support this view. Two additional sources of information are (crucial to tendering of such an argument. One is a cross-cultural confirmation. For the red-blue color preference Garth (193 1) and Eysenck (1941) have provided just the appropriate data. Garth conducted tests among 1000 Caucasian, Negro, Filipino, American Indian, Japanese, and Mexican children. He found similar color preferences among the young of all six populations: Red and blue were favored over other colors. Eysenck’s (1941) review provides overwhelming confirmation of the effect. The second source is a plausible biological basis for these two preference phenomena. Perhaps preferences among infants and adults are stable because infants process color like adults or because color perception at all ages is founded on a similar neurological basis. The degree of infant attention may relate quite directly, then, to the activity level of color-sensitive neural tissue. Each of the eight stimuli used by Bornstein (1975d) was a hue-category center or boundary, and as suggested infants looked reliably longer at category centers
+
+
Chrornritic. Visiorr in Infancy
IS9
than at boundaries just as adults rated centers more pleasant than boundaries. The lateral geniculate cells that analyze chromatic information and subserve wavelength discrimination have spectral sensitivities that are relatively narrow, and they fire at maximum frequency in four select regions of the visible spectrum: the blue, green, yellow, and red. De Valois, Abramov, and Jacobs (1966) have argued that as “hue is signalled by differences in response magnitudes among the various cell types, then those spectral regions which appear red should be those producing maximal responses in [red-sensitive] cells, and so on” (p. 976). Additionally, correlational analysis (Bornstein, 1973) has shown a remarkable correspondence between ( 1 ) the wavelength regions of maximal response for the four spectrally opponent geniculate cell types and (2) the wavelength regions which mark category centers or universal “foci” of “blue,” “green,” “yellow,” and “red” color designations from cross-cultural studies (Berlin & Kay, 1969). The idea that attractiveness or attention relates to the level of excitation or firing rate of stimulus-sensitive neurons is not new. Karmel (Karmel & Maisel, 1975) has formally proposed that infants’ attention to patterned stimulation (checkerboards) varies as a function of the density of contour in the stimulus. Moreover, Karmel, Hoffman, and Fegy (1974) recorded VEPs from surface electrodes on the scalps of infants who looked at differently patterned checkerboards. These investigators found that contour densities that elicited the longest epochs of infants’ looking were the same as those that evoked the greatest amplitude of gross electrical excitation in the cortex. In their analysis infant fixation time and the amplitude of the cortical electrical potential represent interchangeable ordinates against the independent variable, contour density. Perhaps, then, both contours and colors (here hue centers) that produce more central stimulation also tend to hold attention longer. Among the different colors, infants and adults display distinct and reliable preference for the spectral extremes, blue and red. Does this preference also have a basis i n neurological function? Perhaps so, as it is related to saturation perception. Even though hue is the principal dimension of color preference (Child, Hansen, & Hornbeck, 1968; Guilford, 1934), it is ceferisparibus the saturation of a color that is striking. Saturation detines the degree of chromaticity of a color, or the percentage of monochromatic light in a mixture with white. The spectrum appears unevenly colored to the eye, and the spectral extremes (red and blue) naturally appear more saturateddifferent from white-than does yellow (C. H. Graham, 1965). Shrnimann (1944) suggested that infants stared more at more saturated colors, and Bornstein (1975d) found that the pattern of infant attention to spectral lights paralleled the way adults discriminate the saturation of different wavelengths (C. H. Graham, 1965). Vernon (1962) believed that children are attracted to more saturated colors; indeed, to Beebe-Center (1932, p. 306) early studies of infant
160
Marc H . Bornstein
and juvenile color preference seemed to imply that “in the first half-year, preference depends only upon saturation and brilliance.” Recently, Bornstein (1978) investigated infant discrimination and preference for various levels of saturation, Chroma in Munsell terms. Bornstein showed 20-month-olds two Munsell Chroma levels (/2 and /lo) of each of three equally bright hues, blue, green, and red. Each baby saw each color once in a random order and once in reverse order; no babies saw the same order. The results showed that infants distinctly and reliably prefer the higher saturation level of each hue. The few preference investigations with older children in which saturation was varied in a controlled way, such as Child et al. (1968), have consistently revealed preferences for high levels of saturation, and these results agree with major adult color-preference studies, such as Eysenck (1941), Granger (1955), Guilford and Smith (1959), and Helson and Lansford (1967), in that i n each “preference is a positive function of chroma” (Child et al. 1968, p. 244). Why should the saturation of a color so influence attention? How is saturation preference related to preference for the spectral extremes? Perhaps reasons exist similar to those explaining preference for exemplars of color categories. The same model that Karniel (Karmel & Maisel, 1975) relied on to show that infant looking time and the: amplitude of the VEP in infants systematically depend upon contour density may be invoked to explain the infants’ attention to saturation. Since infants attend longer to more saturated colors, one might ask, Do variations in saturation produce systematic changes in the amount of electrical activity in the visual system? The opponent cells that De Valois and his associates (De Valois & De Valois, 1975; De Valois et al., 1966) have identified in the geniculate bodies of the macaque have been shown by De Valois and Marrocco (1973) to increase monotonically in frequency of cell output with the chromaticity of wavelength input. A physiological theory of attention would predict, therefore, that as infants are exposed to a variety of saturation levels, they will attend increasingly to purer (more saturated) colors. This is what Bornstein (1978) found. This outcome generalizes the neural model of infant attention to color and further elucidates infants’ selective preference for the spectral extremes, since red and blue are naturally more saturated hues than are midspectral green and yellow. Insofar as information in the brain is coded as the frequency of nerve action potentials (Stubbs, 1975), the response characteristics of specialized receptors may provide a biological basis for attention. Such results imply that saturation acts as a salient stimulus dimension involved in the mediation of visual attention to color. Saturation is also a key dimension in memory coding of color. For example, Bartleson (1960) found strong evidence that adults increase the saturation of colors in memory, as Gilbert (1894) had found that children 6-17 years typically code colors into higher levels of saturation in memory. In summary, preferences are usually not thought to bespeak an exquisite amount of consistency, and it is widely believed that they must be subject to fad,
Chromcitic Visiori in
Inhincv
161
fancy, and (cultural) context. Consistent results of color-preference tests in infancy and the developmental stability of such results help to refute such beliefs; they show that simple or pure hues are preferred to mixed hues and that the spectral extremes-blue and red-are preferred to midspectral hues. Further they suggest that more saturated hues are preferred to less saturated hues. Each of these findings relating attention to color is predictable from a neurologically based model of central processing of chromatic information.
7 . Coloratura The range of subject areas related to the development of chromatic vision is not limited to those discussed above. Other diverse issues are of interest either for the advancement of our understanding of color vision and visual development, or because the unique characteristics of color offer theory testing possibilities. a. Chromatic Visual Acuity. The ability to resolve a visual target depends upon both its luminous intensity and color (Bornstein, 1975b; C. H. Graham, 1965); acuity is worse in dimmer illumination and, because of the chromatic aberration of the eye, worse in general under short-wavelength and longwavelength illumination. Pollack and his associates (Holmes, Kelton, & Pollack, 1973; Kelton & Pollack, 1974; Skoff & Pollack, 1969) have reconfirmed in children 7-14 years of age the effects of hue contrasts on visual acuity. Pollack also uncovered an age trend toward better acuity. This trend reflects in part ontogenetic changes that occur in optical pigmentation (see Section 11, A). Because intraocular pigments selectively absorb, and thereby reduce or eliminate out-of-focus short-wavelength visible light, acuity would tend to increase. Since Fantz, Ordy, and Udelf's (1962) studies of the early ontogeny of visual acuity, several other investigators have focused on the early practical and empirical importance of visual acuity (e.g., Marg et al., 1976; Salapatek, 1975). Yet no investigators have extended the study of visual acuity in infants to chromatic contrasts. Given that such contrasts are important early to visual resolution and to detection, such an extension would appear to be a logical development. b. Peripheral Color Vision. We are moved from one part of the visual environment to another by stimulation in the peripheral visual field. Studies of infantile looking patterns (e.g., Tronick & Clanton, 1971) clearly demonstrate that the visual system is adapted to environmental exploration and information extraction through continuous attention deployment to new loci. Still open to investigation are the processes and parameters that govern the young child's detection of and orientation to peripheral chromatic stimulation. How do central and peripheral chromatic stimuli compare in their attention-getting and featureextraction characteristics? L. G. Williams ( 1967), for example, found that adults select objects in the extrafoveal field much better on the basis of chromatic cues than on the basis of achromatic cues, such as size or shape. Chromatic vision depends initially upon the existence and operation of &he
162
Marc H . Bornstein
retinal cones. In the adult, the cones are distributed unequally across the retinal surface; they are concentrated centrally, particularly in the macula. Important questions related to physiological maturation concern the extent of the effective visual field in newborns and young infants, whether the child’s effective visual field grows, and whether that growth varies for different hues. Results from Tronick (1972), Harris and MacFarlane (1974), and A s h and Salapatek (1975) suggest that between 2 days and 2 weeks the child’s visual world is narrowly central, but over the coursc: of the first 2 months of life it begins to grow peripherally. None of these investigators used chromatic stimulation. Earlier, however, Luckey (1893) documented visual field growth in color perception. Although observer decision processes almost certainly influenced his data, Luckey reported that, like adults.,children (7-13 years of age) saw peripheral stimuli as exclusively blue or yellow. Trichromasy, the inclusion of red and green with yellow and blue discriminations, was reserved to the central visual field. Characteristics of the young child’s attention to chromatic information outside his momentary focus may thus provide additional information about physiological maturation, stimulus control, and environmental influence on perception. The study of peripheral color vision has secondary methodological implications, since both central-stimulus and paired-comparisons techniques call for some degree of spatial distribution of visual stimuli. Results of infant studies that are interpreted in terms of higher perceptual or cognitive functions might alternatively be explained by sensory limitations on peripheral vision. c. Color Constancy. Although the appearance of an isolated surface depends upon the manner in which it reflects light, in everyday perception surface colors are actually not influenced very much by variation in lighting. This subjective phenomenon is known as color constancy. In color constancy, brightness and chroma seem to become stable properties of the object. Two explanations of such constancies have been cognitive and structuralist. Helmholtz (1866/1962), for the cognitive approach, maintained that relative brightnesses are invariant because sensation is always followed by a judgment based on past experience in the environment. Hering (1878/1964), for the structuralist view, maintained that brightness and color constancies reflect retinal responsivity and adaptation. Since these alternative explanations disagree about whether experience is a prerequisite for constancy, a test of color constancy in infants would help to resolve a long-standing theoretical question in perception. Because color constancy represents a visual phenomenon with enormous adaptive significance, one might expect to find it present in infants near birth.
d . Perceptual Salience and Color. It is unknown how the three dimensions of chromatic experienc-hue, saturation, and brightness-zompete in perception for dominance. Chase (1937) observed that hue constrasts were more interesting than brightness contrasts, that is, they elicited longer looking in young
Chromatic Vision in Infancy
163
infants. However, Clifford and Calvin (1958) suggested that attention to brightness relative to chromatic aspects of a stimulus eased color discriminations and, similarly, Corah and Gross (1967) found that brightness was a most important variable in children’s color perception. H . C. Smith (1943) and Gaines (1972) have both observed that all three dimensions contribute to the chromatic experience and to the salience of color. It is certain that some dimensions of color covary (e.g., see Davidoff, 1974) and are perceptually integral (Garner, 1974). Others are perceptually separable. Garner has argued that integrality of dimensions affects not only discrimination, but also classification and memory. Whether the integrality-separability distinction is learned or innate is presently open to question and may find a solution in infant color discrimination experiments. It is also certain that solutions to many discrimination problems are influenced by attention to one dimension or to the compound of two or more dimensions (Zeaman & House, 1963). Which dimension(s) the infant chooses to attend in preference, discrimination, and memory obviously constitutes a central question in perceptual development. Perhaps the kind of componential habituation advocated by D. J. Miller (1972) will be useful in distinguishing among the visual dimensions to which infants attend and will help to establish their relative order of salience. One of the best examples of this issue derives from recurrent questions concerning the relative salience of color and form. Objects in the natural world are defined by patterns that consist of both physical extents and surfaces qualities, that is, forms and colors. Interest in the relative salience of color versus form derived from early philosophical views on the relative dominance of touch over vision in infancy and from the kinds of information thought to be available through these different modalities (e.g., Berkeley, 1709/1901; Bryant, 1974; Preyer, 1890; Stern, 1924). Several writers believed that the young child’s interest in color vis-a-vis contour, form, or shape more generally was weak (Shim, 1909; Stem, 1924; Valentine, 1942) and, in choice-preference tests, both Baldwin (1895) and Fantz (1961) found that young infants reached for or looked longer at the contour patterning of newspaper print than at a patch of color. However, with little consideration of children’s preferences for particular forms and colors, results such as Baldwin’s and Fantz’s are only suggestive (cf. Spears, 1964). In fact, consideration of the several dimensions of color-form matching, dominance, or salience indicates that color is at least as salient as form at the beginning of life. For example, a task analysis of the requirements associated with matching by color as opposed to matching by form points up the relative ease, rapidity, and facility in color matching. A single glance at any one point on a chromatic stimulus is sufficient to apperceive its color, but inspection of the entire perimeter of a shape may be necessary in accurate matching by form.
164
Marc H . Bornstein
Typically, then, among both children and adults (Farnham-Diggory & Gregg , 1975; Peeke & Stone, 1973), matching by form requires more time and many more eye movements than matching by color. In this sense, chromatic information is more readily available. Discrimination and memory studies conducted with infants as young as 1 month indicate further that they attend to the chromatic information in a colorform pattern (Cohen, 1973; Milewski & Siqueland, 1975). Cohen et al. (1971) showed that infants attend to a novel color or to a novel form, and, as also found by Saayman et al. (1964), novel colors and forms combine to increase attention. For infants, then, color and pattern both seem to represent dimensions relevant to visual information processing. Controlled discrimination studies reviewed above suggest, however, that hue (Bornstein, 1975a), in contradistinction to form (Bryant, 1974), can operate as an absolute code in infantile perception and memory. The preferred dimension of classification, color or form, changes ontogenetically (Katz, 1913; Werner, 1940), as shown by Brian and Goodenough (1929) who performed an extensive color-fonn classification study (n = 474) with subjects 2 years of age through adulthood. They plotted form and color choice as a function of age and found that although form was at first favored, color was preferred by children approximately 4 and 5 years of age, after which form was increasingly preferred. Forty years later, Suchman and Trabasso (1966) found that 4 years and 2 months wa:j the median age of the color-form transition. It has been suggested that exposure to educational institutions and, in particular, to the form-dominant requirements of reading may underlie this critical shift in dimensional attention. For example, Ghanaian children who do not attend school do not change from color to form responding (Davidoff, 1972). Likewise, better problems solvers (Suchman & Trabasso, 1966) and children with higher IQs (Brian & Goodenough, 1929) prefer form earlier. Goesling (1973) also found that retardates tend to sort by color, arid the level of school achievement for deaf children who sort by color lags approximately 3 years behind that for hearing children (Suchman, 1966a). Monkeys tend, too, to sort by color (Warren, 1954), as do adults under stimulus-degraded (i.e., tachistoscopic) conditions (Peeke & Stone, 1973). Independent of the support they afford one or another explanation of the color-form transition, the special-group data and the reading explanation favor the natural priority of color over form in the perceptual hierarchy of young children. Form dominance in 2-year-olds’ classification behavior (Brian & Goodenough, 1929) has been replicated (Melkman, Koriat, & Pardu, 1976); whether color or form predominates as the dimension of preference in infancy is, however, still open to experimental investigation. The relative salience of color or form may be important to establish for their respective roles in learning and early cognitive development. Preference focuses attention on one dimension, and increased attention serves to increase discrimination among instances along that dimension (Suchman, 1966b). Moreover, learn-
Chromaric Visioti in Infancy
I65
ing is hastened when a subject’s preferred attribute is relevant (Trabasso, Stave, & Eichberg, 1969). The implication of this line of research is, then, that among younger children color cues may be valuable in learning situations. Preschool children certainly take greater advantage of color cues than of form cues in concept attainment (Colby & Robertson, 1942; Lee, 1965) and in memory (Daehler et al., 1976). Like Clark (1973), Farnham-Diggory and Gregg (1975) have argued persuasively that perceptual dimensions, such as color, must operate prior to and act to structure conceptual or semantic categories in early congitive development. In support, they demonstrated that young children classify by color faster and more accurately than by other perceptual dimensions or more abstract properties of objects such as function or class equivalence. Color concepts are available even to babies. Bornstein ( 1977c) recently found that 16-week-olds habituated to a single hue would discriminate a novel hue but that comparable babies habituated to a variety of hues would generalize habituation to a novel hue. These results demonstrate “concept” formation and utilization in very young infants (Bourne, 1966). Later in development form appears to be a more salient dimension than color. Children older than age 5 and adults tend to utilize form properties to classify objects in everyday life (Brian & Goodenough, 1929; Farnham-Diggory & Gregg, 1975; Suchman & Trabasso, 1966). At this time, red and blue triangles are both classified as triangles since “of course it’s what the thing is that matters, not what color it happens to be” (Brian & Goodenough, 1929, p. 200). Even though they prefer to focus on forni, children as old as age 9 or 12 will, nonetheless, readily shift their attention to the color component of a pattern if its shape is nonsensical or task irrelevant (Hale & Green, 1976). Likewise, Underwood, Ham, and Ekstrand (1962) found that adults will use the meaning of a word printed in color as a principal memorial cue but will use the color of a nonsense syllable. Among older children and adults, then, color may not be principal, but it certainly represents an important addidional cue and one that is readily available for stimulus discrimination and learning.
e . Color as a Perceptual Cue. among children reading maps:
Nault observed the following propensities
children associate hue change (as from green to brown to blue) with change in quality, and they associate value change (light to dark) with change in quanriry, amount or intensity. For example, many children said that light blue areas indicated shallower water and dark blue areas indicated deeper water. But when a purplish or reddish-blue was used to depict the deepest water category, two-thirds of the children did not associate this with a further depth change, but rather guessed at all sorts of qualitative changes-islands, coral reefs, and so on. (cited in Arnheim, 1971, p. 311)
In general, various of the dimensions of color act as cues to other perceptual phenomena i n vision (Payne, 1964). For example, color influences judgments of weight, size, temperature, and distance. It is certain from research conducted by
166
Marc
H.
Bornstein
McKenzie and Day (1972) that the absolute distance of an object critically determines an infant’s visual attention to it. McKenzie and Day, however, used white cubes only. It is not yet known whether perceptual distance might vary with hue in infants as it does in adults (J. J. Gibson, 1966; McCain & Karr, 1970; Oyama & Yamamura, 1960), and whether the color-depth effect reflects structuralist function or, as Edwards (1955) maintained, experience with objects in the natural world. Hypothesis-testing questions such as these are potentially answerable by color studies with infants and young children. Two experiments provide contrasting opinions on this point. Morgan, Goodson, and Jones (1975) argued from cross-sectional data thai conventional color-temperature assocations, such as hodred, warm/yellow, codgreen, and coldhlue, are acquired relatively late in development and are therefore founded on a “loosely held cultural norm rather than an evolutionary or physiological basis.” Contrasting this domain, Lawler and Lawler (1965) argued on the basis of the consistency of preferences of preschoolers (mean age, 3.7 years) that color-mood associations, such as sad/ brown and happy/yellow, are “biological in nature.”
f . Color Vision Defect and Development. One in twelve (8.2%)Caucasian males is color deficient: This statistic translates into one boy in every classroom in the United States. (Only .4% of Caucasian females are color deficient.) Elsewhere, Bornstein (1977b) has reviewed the effects of color vision deficiency on scholastic, psychosocial, and career development. For example, most commentators, like Gardiner (1973), Heath (1963, 1974), Shearron (1965), Sloan (1963), Snyder (1973), Thuline (1972), and H. Williams (1975), have seen the colordeficient child as at a disadvantage in the classroom. Preschool and primarygrade classrooms are usually quite colorful; texts are typically illustrated with colors; and the teachers often emphasize color. Many preschool and school materials are color coded and thus integrally tied to the child’s color discrimination capacities (Mandola, 1949; Thuline, 1972). Knowing which child is color deficient is obviously beneficial in the school context. Assessment of color deficijency as early as infancy, however, may be beneficial for several other reasons. For example, color vision deficiencies have been used by geneticists and clinicians for purely medical diagnostic purposes, such as marking associated hereditary difficulties (McKusick, 1962; Mendlewicz, Fleiss, & Fieve, 1972). Additionally, diagnosis in infancy is related to theoretical questions in color vision and to the ontogeny and early function of chromatic vision. Both behavioral or electrophysiological assessment of the status of color vision in infancy may be possible. Determination of a neutral region (see Section II,B,2) has, historically, been regarded as a satisfactory diagnostic sign of the status of color vision (Hsia & Graham, 1965; Walls & Heath, 1954) and has been extensively used in animal sensory psychophysics (e.g., De Valois, 1973; Grether, 1939). Because of the desaturated nature of the anomalous trichromat’s spec-
Chrorncrtic Vision in Injuncy
167
trum, examination for the neutral zone is, as well, sensitive to color-weak (anomalous) deficiencies (Chapanis, 1944; Hurvich, 1972; W. D. Wright, 1947). Using the neutral zone as an index, Peeples (1976) addressed the question of whether hereditary color vision deficiencies are congenital by testing five male infants whose maternal grandfathers were reputed dichromats. Three of these 2-month-olds failed to discriminate 496 nm from white. Peeples therefore concluded that color deficiency is present at or near birth and represents a life-long characteristic. Similarly, Bornstein ( 1976a) employed the neutrai-point test to assess the status of color vision in 3-month-olds. This habituation procedure could also provide an accurate and reliable behavioral measure of the status of color vision in early infancy. Although neither method discriminates the type or degree of color deficiency, both adeqtiately discriminate normal from abnormal visual functions and could be relatively easy to operationalize, administer, and interpret. Other “objective” tests of deficiency now available are based on more complicated electrophysiological measures (e.g., Regan & Spekriejse, 1974), and they may be adaptable to early infancy (Barnet et ul., 1965; Lodge et ul., 1969), but only under special circumstances. In children, as in adults, color represents an immediate perceptual dimension, a system of classification, and an often utilized symbolic code. How many of these advantages the color-deficient child lacks during his cognitive development may be questioned. The data suggest that neither IQ nor achievement in school is hampered in color-deficient children (Lorenz & McClure, 1935; Mandola, 1969; Shearron, 1965). As those reared on black-and-white television know, much of the visual information in life is adequately conveyed independent of color. In reality, however, the world of the color deficient is a world apart (Goodenough, 1945); the dichromatic child is indeed part of a minority culture. As he grows he must develop a set of alternative skills: He may utilize brightness, position, or other visual cues to compensate for his color deficiency. The course of this adaptation is essentially unstudied.
111. Summary General interest in the nature of man’s first perceptions is as old as philosophical inquiry, and during the last half century experimental interest in early visual processes has grown steadily. In this time, investigations of pattern vision in infants have dominated the study of the ontogeny of perception, and researchers in developmental psychology have made enormous strides in understanding this facet of early behavior (Cohen & Salapatek, 1975). The history of interest and research in the metaphorical complement of early pattern perception, infant color vision, is nearly as long but, anti1 recently, has not been so successful.
168
Marc H . Bornsrein
The significance of color in perceptual development is patent. Objects in the visual world mainly differ in four ways-location, size, shape, and color-and in visual animals color facilitates signal detection, localization, tracking, and recognition (Walls, 1942). These visual functions are all-important in biological evolution. The human factors literature shows that color coding reduces search time and facilitates identification better than coding based on brightness, size, or geometrical shape (Christ, 1975). Investigators of every hue, then, agree that color enhances common visual functions, including intrinsic contrasts, visibility, object evaluation, and constancy, in the different species that possess it. In addition to its information content, color is known to have influential affective qualities. Colors therefore clarify and accentuate and by their attractiveness are thought to induce vigilence in attention. By virtue of both its salience and information content, color surpasses black and white or monochrome. This chapter has surveyed behavioral data on the early ontogeny of chromatic vision and infomation processing in man. Since detailed pattern perception and color vision are mutually segregated to central vision, and since visual patterns can be differentiated or resolved either by brightness or hue, a major question motivating developmentalists has been, “Do infants see color?” Most early investigations of the development of color vision constituted essentially color preference studies with brightness or other variables uncontrolled. The brightness problem aside, simple color preference studies fell far short of describing or evaluating the basic sensory or perceptual functions characteristic of early perceptual development. Recent anatomical, electrophysiological, and behavioral observations indicate, however, that central vision in infants and young children is primary and that photopic vision in man is functional near the beginning of extrauterine life. Moreover, contemporary investigators have adapted psychophysical techniques and controls to the study of the development of chromatic vision with manifest success. In specific, we have reviewed psychophysical studies (e.g., of brightness discrimination, spectral sensitivity, the neutral zone, and wavelength discrimination) as well as early perceptual and cognitive studies (e.g., of hue categorization, color memory, and color preference). These studies show that infants can see, process, remember, and act on chromatic information in their environment. Much of the young infant’s behavior parallels mature behavior and conforms with expectancies of a trichromatic model of color vision. Indeed, the young child is early adapted to process and use the chromatic information in his environment in reasonably sophisticated ways. His first knowledge of the world grows out of the distribution of his visual attention, and the child, as we have seen, differentiates and responds to different features in his world according to their color, organizes his world by color, just as h e may remember different aspects of it on the basis of their color. Intriguingly, two central questions in this
Chron7citic Vision in infancy
I69
research area, namely, whether the neonate sees color and whether the quality of color vision changes early in life, remain unanswered.
Appendix Addendum to C. H. Darwin’s “Biographical sketch of a young child” (Kosrnos, 1877, I , 367-376. [a]) “Darwin, who has previously criticized Geiger’s color theory in the pages of Kosmos, included in a cover letter to the above article the following observations on the development of the color sense in his own children. The author’s intent is to encourage further observation [Ed.] “Darwin wrote: “ ‘I carefully followed the mental development of my small children, and I was astonished to observe in two or, as I rather think, three of these children, soon after they had reached the age in which they knew the names of all the ordinary things, that they appeared to be entirely incapable of giving the right names to the colors of a color etching. They could not name the colors, although I tried repeatedly to teach them the names of the colors. I remember quite clearly to have stated that they are color blind. But afterwards this turned out t o be an ungrounded apprehension. When I told this fact to another person, he told me that he had observed a rather similar case. The difficulty which small children feel, whether in discrimination or, much more probably, in naming the colors, seems therefore to merit further investigation. 1 will add that formerly it looked to me as if the sense of taste, at least with my own children when they were still very young, differed from the adult Sense of taste; this shows itself by the fact that they did not refuse rhubarb with some sugar and milk which is for us an abominably disgusting mixture and by the fact that they strongly preferred the most sour and most tart fruits, as for instance unripe gooseberries and Holz apples.’ ”
ACKNOWLEDGMENTS Much of the research reported in this chapter was supported by the Grant Foundation, the Carnegie Corporation of New York, and the National Institutes of Health (Grant Nos. 1 F22 MH58197-01 and 1 R03 MH28734-01). Helen G. Bornstein. Charles G . Gross, Lawrence E. Marks, Margaret Ruddy, Davida Y. Teller, Anthony A. Wright, and Michael Lewis all contributed valuable comments to an earlier version of this chapter; Rose Fioravanti, Sharon Olsen, and Carol Smith each aided in its preparation.
REFERENCES Abravanel, E. How children combine vision and touch when perceiving the shape of objects. Perception & Psychophysics, 1972, 12, 171-175. Adkinson, C. D., & Berg, W. K. Cardiac deceleration in newborns: Habituation, dishabituation, and offset responses. Journal of Experimental Child Psychology, 1976, 21, 46-60. Adrian, E. D. The electric response of the human eye. Journal of Physiology (London), 1945, 104, 84-104. Aristotle. De coloribus. In W. D. Ross (Ed.), The works of Arisrotle (T. Loveday & E. S. Forster, trans.). (Vol. 6 ) . Oxford: Clarendon, 1913. Arlitt, A. H. Psychology of infancy and early childhood. New York: