ADVANCES I N CATALYSIS VOLUME 23
Advisory Board G. K. BORESKOV Novosibirsk, U.S.S.R.
P. H. EMMETT Baltimore, Maryland...
26 downloads
1107 Views
17MB Size
Report
This content was uploaded by our users and we assume good faith they have the permission to share this book. If you own the copyright to this book and it is wrongfully on our website, we offer a simple DMCA procedure to remove your content from our site. Start by pressing the button below!
Report copyright / DMCA form
ADVANCES I N CATALYSIS VOLUME 23
Advisory Board G. K. BORESKOV Novosibirsk, U.S.S.R.
P. H. EMMETT Baltimore, Maryland
M. BOUDART Stanford, California
J. HORIUTI Sapporo, J a p a n
G. NATTA
E. K. RIDEAL
Milan, Ztaly
London, England
H. S. TAYLOR Princeton, New Jersey
M. CALVIN Berkeley, California
W. JOST Gottingen, Germany
P. W. SELWOOD Santa Barbara, California
ADVANCES IN CATALYSIS VOLUME 23
Edited by D. D. ELEY The University iV ottingham, England
HERMAN PINES Northwestern University Euanston, Illinois
PAULB. WEISZ Mobil Research and Development Corporation Princeton, New Jersey
1973
ACADEMIC PRESS
NEW YORK AND LONDON
COPYRIGHT 0 1973, BY ACADEMIC PRESS, INC. ALL RIGHTS RESERVED. N O PART OF THIS PUBLICATION MAY BE REPRODUCED OR TRANSMITTED IN ANY FORM OR BY ANY MEANS, ELECTRONIC OR MECHANICAL, INCLUDING PHOTOCOPY, RECORDING, OR ANY INFORMATION STORAGE AND RETRIEVAL SYSTEM, WI T H O U T PERMISSION IN WRITING FROM THE PUBLISHER.
ACADEMIC PRESS, INC.
111 Fifth Avenue, New York, New York 10003
Unired Kingdom Edifion published by ACADEMIC PRESS, INC. (LONDON) LTD. 24/28 Oval Road. London N W l
LIBRARY OF CONGRESS CATALOG CARDNUMBER:49-7755
PRINTED IN TH E UNITED STATES O F AMERICA
Contents CONTRIBUTORS . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . PREFACE ................................................................
vii ix
Metal Catalyzed Skeletal Reactions of Hydrocarbons J. R. ANDERSON
I. 11. 111. IV. V. VI.
Introduction.. . . . . Catalyst Structure
....,........... 1 .......................... ......... 2 16 ....................... Isomerization and Dehydrocyclization 25 Hydrogenolysis on Metals. . . . . . , . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . _ . . . . . . . . . . . _ . . _ .62 Reactions over Chromium Oxide Catal 81 References. . . , , . . . . . , . . . . , . , . , , , , . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 84
Specificity in Catalytic Hydrogenolysis by Metals J. H. SINFELT
I. 11. 111. IV. V.
Introduction . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 91 General Discussion on Hydrogenolysis Reactions. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 92 Comparison of Metals as Hydrogenolysis Catalysts. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 97 Contrast between Ethane Hydrogenolysis and Other Reactions, . . . . . . . . . 106 116 Conclusion . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 116 References . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
The Chemisorption of Benzene R. B. MOYESAND P. B. WELLS
I. 11. 111. IV. V.
Introduction, . . . ....................... Chemisorption , , . . , , , , . , . , , , , , , , , . , , , . , , , . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
121 122 133 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 148 Some Aspects of Benzene Hydrogenation. . , . . 152 ......._........... Conclusions. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 154 References. . .
The Electronic Theory of Photocatalytic Reactions on Semiconductors TH.WOLKENSTEIN Introduction, . , . . . . . . . , . , . , , , , , . , , . , . , . , . . , . . . . , . , . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 157 I. The Mechanism of the Influence of Illumination on the Adsorption and Catalytic Properties of a Surface. . . . . . . . , . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 158 V
vi I1. 111. IV . V. VI .
CONTENTS
The Photoadsorptive Effect . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . The Reaction of Hydrogen-Deuterium Exchange . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . The Reaction of Oxidation of Carbon Monoxide . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . The Reaction of Synthesis of Hydrogen Peroxide . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Conclusions . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . References . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
170 179 189 197 203 206
Cycloamyloses as Catalysts DAVIDW . GRIFFITHSAND MYRONL. BENDER
I. I1. I11. IV . V. VI .
Introduction . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Physical Properties of the Cycloamyloses . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Reactions in Which the Cycloamyloses Participate Covalently . . . . . . . . . . . Noncovalent Catalysis by the Cycloamyloses . . . . . . . . . Catalytic Properties of Modified Cycloamyloses . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Concluding Remarks . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . References . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
209 210 222 242 249 258 259
Pi and Sigma Transition Metal Carbon Compounds as Catalysts for the Polymerization of Vinyl Monomers and Olefins D . G . H . BALLARD
I . Introduction., . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 263 I1. Soluble Transition Metal Alkyl Compounds as Polymerization Catalysts . . 266 111. Ligand Replacement in Transition Metal Alkyl Compounds and Polymeri...................................
288
erization Catalysts Derived from Tran Alkyl Compounds . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . V. Stereoregular Polymerization with Transition Metal Alkyls . . . . . . . . . . . . . . VI . Mechanism of Polymerization. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . VII . Conclusion ...................................... ... References .................................................
293 298 304 323 324
327 AUTHORINDEX ............................... SUBJECTINDEX ............................... . . . . . . . . . . . . 337 347 CONTENTS OF PREVIOUS VOLUMES ..........................................
Contri b u to rs Numbers in parentheses indicate the pages on which the authors’ contributions begin.
J. R. ANDERSON,CSIRO Division of Tribophysics, University of Melbourne, Parkville, Australia (1)
D. G. H. BALLARD,Imperial Chemical Industries Limited, Corporate Laboratory, The Heath, Runcorn, Cheshire, England (263) MYRONL. BENDER,Department of Chemistry, Northwestern University, Evanston, Illinois (209) DAVIDW. GRIFFITHS,Department of Chemistry, Northwestern University, Evanston, Illinois (209) R. B. MOYES,Department of Chemistry, The University, Hull, England (121) J. H. SINFELT,Corporate Research Laboratories, Esso Research and Engineering Co., Linden, New Jersey (91) P. B. WELLS,Department of Chemistry, The University, Hull, England (121) TH. WOLKENSTEIN, Institute of Physical Chemistry, Academy of Sciences, Moscow, U S S R (157)
vii
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
Preface Three months after the Fifth International Congress on Catalysis I still find my mind turning back to V. Haensel’s introductory remarks in which he pointed out the gap between the industrial art and the academic science of catalysis. At the present time, enzymologists are pulling ahead, and more real knowledge is available about the structures and mechanisms of macromolecules such as lysozyme, ribonuclease, hemoglobin than of any industrial catalysts. It is true that while chemical kinetics was the only weapon the enzyme field moved slowly and that the advance started with computcr-aided crystallographic studies (Perutz and Kendrew a t Cambridge, England). It is also true that the equivalent structural techniques for surfaces are only just emerging, i.e., Auger, ESCA, LEED, etc., and that a t present new techniques tend to be concentrated on single crystal surfaces. However, this is a hopeful sign as is the way in which the mechanisms of organometallic homogeneous catalysts are being decided and their possible relevance for heterogeneous catalysis investigated. So turning to our present volume, we refer first to the last article in the volume by D . G. H. Ballard. He concludes that our knowledge of catalytic mechanisms is limited “because the majority of useful catalysts for practical reasons are heterogeneous and therefore unsuitable for mechanistic studies.” Ballard’s article well illustrates the fact that where all the techniques are available to establish structure (as they are in homogeneous organometallics), kinetic studies take on a new depth and progress is rapid. The articles by J. R. Anderson, J. H. Sinfelt, and R. B. Moyes and P. B. Wells, on the other hand, deal with a classical field, namely hydrocarbons on metals. The pattern of modern work here still very much reflects the important role in the academic studies of deuterium exchange reactions and the mechanisms advanced by pioneers like Horiuti and Polanyi, the Farkas brothers, Rideal, Twigg, H. S. Taylor, and Turkevich. Using this method, Anderson takes ultrathin metal films with their separated crystallites as idealized models for supported metal catalysts. Sinfelt is concerned with hydrogenolysis on supported metals and relates the activity to the percentage d character of the metallic bond. Moyes and Wells deal with the modes of chemisorption of benzene, drawing on the results of physical techniques and the ideas of the organometallic chemists in their discussions. Th. Wolkenstein’s article provides mechanisms for certain light-accelerated catalytic reactions on solids. This is a field where very explicit ix
X
PREFACE
models may be constructed in relation to the band theory of semiconductors and where detailed mathematical treatments have been made and compared with experiment. Finally, we come to enzyme models. D. W. Griffiths and M. L. Bender describe the remarkable catalytic property of certain cycloamyloses which act through formation of inclusion complexes, and in this respect recall the clefts containing the active sites in enzymes such as lysozyme and papain. I believe these articles show that there is a general move forward over a wide field in catalysis and that in the future we may reasonably hope that the academic-industrial gap in the heterogeneous field will start to close.
D. D. ELEY
Metal Catalyzed Skeletal Reactions of Hydrocarbons J. R. ANDERSON CSIRO Division of Tribophysics University of Melbourne Parkville, Australia
I. Introduction. .................................. 11. Catalyst Structure. ............................. A. Evaporated Metal Films.. ....................... B. Supported Catalysts. ........................ C. Gas Adsorption Behavior. . . . . . . ........ 111. Experimental Techniques. ............................... A. Evaporated Metal Film ........................... B. Supported Catalysts.. ............... C. Use of Hydrocarbons rbon . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . IV. Isomerisation and Dehydrocyclisation Reactions on Metals. . . . . . . . . A. Reactions on Platinum. .....................................
V. Hydrogenolysis on Metals.. VI. Reactions over Chromium References. . . .
................................
14 16 20 25 26 62
1. Introduction It is the purpose of this article to review the mechanisms of reactions undergone by the carbon skeletons of aliphatic and alicyclic hydrocarbons in the presence of metallic catalysts. As well as skeletal isomerization reactions, we shall deal with cyclization, ring opening, and hydrogenolysis reactions, while recognizing that this last group necessarily also requires the net removal or addition of hydrogen atoms. Indeed, although our central concern is with the fate of the carbon skeleton, it is impossible to avoid a detailed consideration of the state of hydrogenation of the reacting species, particularly when discussing reaction pathways in terms of likely intermediates, and when discussing reactions which result in the formation of aromatic cyclization products. Catalytic reactions of this type have a long history, and a wide range of catalyst types have been used. However, we do not intend this review to be 1
2
J.
R. ANDERSON
exhaustive for all catalyst types. Our purpose is to emphasize those hydrobarbon reactions that are laregely confined to the metal. We do not propose to review catalysts for which dual-function activity is important. Such reviews are already available elsewhere (e.g., 1-6). Technical operating catalysts all consist, of course, of metal dispersed on a support. However, mechanistic studies have used both unsupported and supported metals, and we therefore will discuss in some detail the structure of various unsupported and supported catalysts upon which these reactions have been studied.
II. Catalyst Structure A. EVAPORATED METALFILMS Evaporated films are, of course, not “practical” catalysts. Their use as model catalysts is however justified by the insight which such work may give toward an understanding of catalytic reaction mechanisms. An initial state of high surface purity may be achieved with evaporated films using relatively straightforward techniques, and it is the elimination of initial surface contamination as a significant experimental variable which makes evaporated films desirable as model catalysts compared to bulk supported catalysts.
1. Continuous Films
It is often found that the ratio R (measured, for instance, by gas adsorption methods) of actual metal surface area accessible to the gas phase, to the geometric film area, exceeds unity. This arises from nonplanarity of the outermost film surface both on an atomic and a more macroscopic scale, and from porosity of the film due to gaps between the crystals. These gags are typically up to about 20 A wide. However, for film thicknesses >500 A, this gap structure is never such as completely to isolate metal crystals one from the other, and almost all of the substrate is, in fact, covered by metal. In practice, catalytic work mostly uses thick films in the thickness range 500-2000 A, and it is easily shown (7) that intercrystal gaps in these films will not influence catalytic reaction kinetics provided the half-life of the reaction exceeds about 10-20 sec, which will usually be the case. It is difficult to assess with high precision the crystal planes exposed to the gas phase in low temperature ( O O C ) polycrystalline films. The assumption has sometimes been made [e.g., Brennan, Haywood, and Trapnell (8)],that for fcc metals the surface consists of an equal exposure of ( l l l ) , (loo), and (110) planes, with a similar assumption for bcc metals with
METAL CATALYZED SKELETAL REACTIONS OF HYDROCARBONS
3
regard to (1lo), (loo), and (211) planes. However, for low-temperature polycrystalline transition metal films in the thickness range 500-2000 11, high index planes are undoubtedly present to an appreciable extent, and this is the more serious the more refractory the metal. This conclusion is clearly implicit from photoelectric work-function data (9-16) and gas adsorption data (7, 16, 17) for various evaporated films. Nevertheless, it must also be said that in low-temperature films grown to great thickness and thus consisting of very wide crystals, low index planes are probably dominant. For instance, in a polycrystalline nickel film deposited on glass at 20°C to a thickness of 3.1 pm and with an average crystal width in the region of 0.2 pm, surface replicas clearly show regular faceted crystal shapes with dominant (111) and (100) surface planes (It?), as expected from both thermodynamic (19) and kinetic arguments (9). Polycrystalline films deposited on amorphous substrates are of lower crystallographic surface heterogeneity the higher the temperature of annealing subsequent taodeposition or the higher the substrate temperature during deposition; again, photoelectric work-function data serve to empha size the point (9, 10,12,IS). The question arises of the extent to which, in polycrystalline films reactant gas has access to the substrate. It is clear that in high-temperature films the total absence of intercrystal gaps means that such access of gas is completely absent. In the case of films deposited a t O'C, one may estimate from the measured roughness factor and from transmission electron microscopic evidence that, of the total substrate area, more than 90% is in direct contact with metal; in any case, the substrate at the base of a gap is almost certainly covered with a thin layer of metal. Thus, even in this case the gas cannot have more than trivial access to the substrate. Deposition on glass or other amorphous substrate at higher temperatures may result in some degree of preferred crystal orientation (20,21). The tendency toward preferred orientation tends to be greater at larger film thicknesses, although it can undoubtedly occur in the initial stages of film growth (22).In general, however, the occurrence and extent of preferred orientation on glass is of poor reproducibility, and when preferred crystal orientation is deliberately required, glass is not the best choice as a substrate. Film deposition on a single crystal substrate can, in principle, lead to the formation of an epitaxed single crystal film. However, relatively limited use has been made of well-epitaxed single crystal films for catalysts for two reasons: In many instances the single crystal substrate is only available with very limited dimensions so that the film catalyst is also correspondingly restricted in its area; second, in most cases it is either inconvenient or impossible to design the single crystal substrate and the evaporation source
4
J. R. ANDERSON
so that evaporated metal falls only on the single crystal substrate. Failure to achieve the latter means that if the reaction is to be confined to the epitaxed film, some method has to be found for transferring the epitaxed specimen from the preparation chamber to reaction vessel without breaking the vacuum. One way of achieving this is with a UHV-compatible winch. Only two crystalline substrates have had appreciable use for the prepttration of the metal film catalysts. These are mica and rocksalt. Mica is a convenient substrate for film growth. A cleaved mica surface is extremely flat and it therefore obviates one uncertainty inherent in the use of glass: Although a freshly fire-polished glass surface has a high degree of smoothness, it is subject t o corrosion in aqueous media, particularly if acidic. Decoration of a cleaved mica surface shows the presence of only an extremely low concentration of surface imperfections, and the surface is mainly featureless. Such imperfections as do occur are so relatively infrequent as to be of negligible effect on the degree of surface perfection of a thick metal film. Mica has the added desirable property of being flexible in thin sheets, so that it is not difficult to arrange a cylindrical substrate geometry so that most, if not all, the evaporated metal is deposited on the mica. With some metals it is possible to obtain a high degree of single crystal epitaxy on mica [e.g., silver ( 2 3 ) ] . However, single crystal film catalysts have not been prepared on mica from transition metals such as those we are mainly concerned with in this chapter, no doubt because of temperature limitations imposed by glass apparatus. With these fcc metals, deposition on mica at 35O"40O0C in HV or UHV leads to polycrystalline deposits in which each crystal is oriented with a (111 ) axis normal to the substrate, but with the crystals oriented with rotational disorder about this axis (cf. 2.4). In some cases, rotational disorder is not completely random. Complete preferred crystal orientation is not obtained with total reproducibility. The microscopic results show that the exposed surface of each crystal is overall relatively flat, so that the whole exposed film surface must be close to (111). Presumably, some higher order planes are exposed to a relatively small extent in the immediate vicinity of the grain boundaries; nevertheless, the proportion of (111) surface exposed is estimated to be not less than 90% and this is very similar t o the estimate for the proportion of (111) surface exposed in completely epitaxed silver films ( 2 3 ) . This estimate is also in agreement with that obtained from a patch-model analysis of photoelectric work-function data for nickel films deposited on mica a t 320°C (12). Although the surface of such a high-temperature film may appear relatively flat and featureless to shadowed replication, decoration shows clearly
METAL CATALYZED SKELETAL REACTIONS OF HYDROCARBONS
5
that the surface is not completely smooth on a quasi-atomic scale, due to the presence of surface steps (cf. Fig. Id, p. 4 of ref. 7 ) ,and this would be the more important the more refractory the metal under similar temperature conditions of preparation. When deposited on mica at O"C, surface replicas show surface roughness comparable to that of films on a glass substrate, and the degree of preferred crystal orientation is also usually negligible. A wide range of metals has been grown epitaxially on a (100) rocksalt face, including (fcc) gold, silver, aluminum, nickel, copper; and (bcc) chromium, iron ( 2 3 , 2 5 ) .All can readily given an orientation of (100) metal planes parallel to rocksalt (loo), but gold, silver, copper, and aluminum can also give (111) metal planes parallel to rocksalt (100) depending on the conditions during metal deposition and during rocksalt cleavage, and this also affects the quality of epitaxy. As shown by decoration, a rocksalt cleavage face is far from absolutely smooth. Because of the convenience of using, for catalytic purposes, a film deposited on a relatively large area of substrate, a technique has been developed (24) for producing an evaporated layer of rocksalt as a substrate for subsequent film deposition. The evaporated rocksalt layer is of course microcrystalline, but consists largely of crystals exposing (100) faces upon which films of metals may then be deposited at elevated temperatures. By decoration, the presence of growth steps on the (100) surfaces is clearly revealed. To avoid problems due to sintering, thermal etching, and incipient evaporation of the rocksalt layer, and to maintain adequate vacuum conditions for surface cleanliness of the metal film, the substrate temperature is limited to about 250°C during metal deposition or subsequent annealing. Although a substrate temperature of 250°C will produce reasonably well epitaxed single crystal films of silver, with metals of higher melting point and greater cohesive energy, epitaxy is much more difficult (26, 2 4 ) . With this type of film, the exposed surface is far from perfect, due both to the microcrystallinity of the rocksalt substrate and to the imperfections in the surface of the epitaxed film. For a nickel film so prepared, the proportion of (100) surface exposed, as judged from rare gas adsorption data (11) is no more than 70% and is probably rather less than this with platinum. 2. Ultrathin Films
For the prescnt purpose, we take the term "ultrathin" to refer to an evaporated metal film where the concentration of metal on the substrate is low enough for the film to consist of small isolated metal crystals. If the average concentration of metal atoms on the substrate is of the order of a monolayer or less, the metal crystals are small enough for ultrathin films to serve as models for highly dispersed metal catalysts, but where surface cleanliness and catalyst structure can be better controlled.
6
J. R. ANDERSON
The degree of dispersion, i.e., the average crystallite size of the metal in supported catalysts, is important not only in controlling the surface area per unit weight of metal, but there is also the question of whether the nature of the catalytic process is dependent on metal crystallite size. Most interest here centers on extremely small crystallites, for instance <50 8 diameter. In practice, ultrathin films can readily be prepared with average crystallite diameters in the range from several tens of angstroms down to the practical limit of electron microscopic resolution of (say) 5 8. In actual catalytic experiments, ultrathin metal films have been used on mica, glass, and silica substrates (26-30). It would also be possible to use substrates such as cleaved or evaporated rocksalt or other crystallite substrate, but this has not yet been done. A mica substrate has the considerable advantage that it can be made to present a large and uniform surface, and that mica slivers carrying film crystallites can readily be cleaved from the mica sheet; since these slivers can be made thin enough to pass a 100-keV electron beam, the metal crystallites can be observed directly in the electron microscope. Detailed observation of the structure of ultrathin films deposited on glass is more difficult. In fact, it turns out that for platinum and nickel ultrathin films, the catalytic properties are much the same when deposited on mica, glass or silica. On the basis that small-particle catalytic effects are to be found for crystallites of less than about 50 8 diameter (e.g., Sl),catalytic interest in ultrathin platinum films concerns films with specific film weights <-0.3 X 10-8 mole cm-2. A range of ultrathin platinum films has been studied by Anderson and Shimoyama (29, SO). These were deposited in UHV on air-cleaved mica at 275°C at a deposition rate in the region of 0.5 pg min-I (ca. 2 8 min-' average). This deposition temperature was chosen since it was also the temperature at which similar films were to be used as catalysts in the reaction of n-hexane. In fact, no significant difference in film structure due to the catalytic reaction could be detected by electron microscopy. An electron micrograph of a typical ultrathin platinum film used in a n-hexane isomerization experiment is shown in Fig. 1. Here the average film thickness (obtained by chemical analysis after film deposition) is 0.12 pg For comparison, a close-packed monolayer of platinum atoms corresponds to 0.49 pg The individual platinum crystallites are clearly resolved, and the average diameter is about 20 8. Furthermore, the particle density on the mica is 1.3 X 10l2cm-2, and it follows that, if one assumes a model crystallite geometry of a cylindrical prism standing end-on to the mica, the average height is about 14 8. As the average film thickness grows, so does the particle size: a film of 0.60 pg cm-2, deposited under the same conditions as those described immediately above had, for instance, an average particle diameter of about 40 8.
METAL CATALYZED SKELETAL REACTIONS O F HYDROCARBONS
7
FIG.1. Electron micrograph of ultrathin platinum film: average platinum density 0.12 pg cm+, deposited on mica in UHV at 275°C. Film catalyst used in reaction of n-hexane a t 275°C before microscopic examination. Micrograph obtained by direct transmission through mica sliver. (X400,OOO).
Films with specific weights in the range 0.08-0.02 pg cm-2 were also studied, and these all have average crystallite diameters in the region of <20 8. Toward the lower end of this specific weight range, the apparent particle density is low, and the measurements are of poor accuracy due to inadequate electron microscopic resolution. In all cases, the average particle height appears to be about 10-15 8, although this estimate is again only very rough for films near the lower extreme of the specific weight range. In all films there is a distribution of crystallite diameters. An example is shown in Fig. 2 for the film with a specific weight of 0.12 pg cm-2. The smallest particles whose diameters can be measured in a micEograph (and then only very approximately) have diameters of about 10 A, and this is the lower size limit used in Fig. 2. However, particles smaller than this can readily be observed in the micrograph, and there is no doubt that this type of film contains some crystallites down to the limit of microscopic resolution (about 8 8 in our case), and presumably beyond. However, their number appears to be relatively small. It is interesting to compare the specific film weight of these ultrathin platinum films with the amount of platinum per unit actual surface area of support for typical supported platinum catalysts. A typical supported catalyst would have 1% (w/w) of platinum on a
8
J. R. ANDERSON
30
20
-
a,
0 0
C
B
u L
a,
a 10
0
I
10
20 30 C r y s t a l l i t e diameter
I
(x)
40
FIG.2. Platinum crystallite size distribution for 0.12 pg cm-2 ultrathin platinum film (Fig. 1). Full line, number distribution; broken line, surface area distribution.
support which has a specific surface area of a few hundred m2gm-'.Assuming all of the internal surface of the carrier is available (not always a valid assumption in practice) the concentration of platinum on the carrier surface is in the region of 0.0001-0.01 pg cm-2, which is rather lower than the range for the ultrathin films. The crystallites in Fig. 1 are too small to provide details of shape and structure. However, good evidence on this point is available (32-34) for ultrathin films of platinum, nickel, palladium, gold, and silver deposited in UHV on vacuum-cleaved mica at temperatures in the range ~00"-500"C, under conditions where relatively large crystallites (50-200 A diameter) are formed. With platinum, nickel, and gold ( 3 2 , 3 4 ) the films are found to consist of well-formed crystallites, mostly of regular geometric shapes, such as vertically truncated tetrahedra, or shapes derived from this by multiple twinning. All these expose only (111} facets. These films always contain a proportion, usually minor, or crystallites of indefinite shape, often approaching a circular plan shape. These presumably are multiply faceted but with individual facets not large enough to be resolved. Crystallites of this type become dominant at deposition temperatures approaching room tempera/ture.
METAL CATALYZED SKELETAL REACTIONS OF HYDROCARBONS
9
In contrast to platinum, palladium nickel, and gold, with silver only crystallites with an approximately circular plan shape are seen (33) and there is no worthwhile evidence of angularity; the likely general shape (33, 34) is that of a flatish curved dome. An examination of a dark-field micrograph of a field such as that of Fig. 1 confirms the presence of an appreciable proportion of multiply twinned particles, and also shows that most of the particles are orientated with a I1111 parallel to the substrate (29,30).
B. SUPPORTED CATALYSTS Practical catalysts using the group VIII metals always have the metal dispersed on a support or carrier. A wide range of carriers has been tried in
FIG.3. Electron micrograph of 2.5% (w/w)platinum/silica catalyst. Prepared by impregnation with chloroplatinic acid, reduced in hydrogen a t 210°C. Micrograph obtained by thin sectioning. The black dots are platinum particles. ( X 100,000). Reproduced with permission from T . A. Dorling and R. L. Moss, J. Catal. 7, 378 (1967); R. L. Moss, Platinum Metals Rev. 11 (4), 1 (1967), and British Crown Copyright.
10
J. R. ANDERSON
practice. However, no attempt will be made to catalog the great variety of modifications known for these technically important materials. 1. Metal/Silica Catalysts A range of platinum/silica catalysts has been studied by Moss and coworkers (35-39) mostly using a Davison 70 silica gel support'. The smallest average platinum particle size was obtained by adsorption of Pt (NH,) 2+: after reduction at 300°C the average diameter was 14 A. For comparison, a catalyst containing 2.5-3% (w/w) platinum, but prepared by impregnation with a solution of chloroplatinic acid gave an average particle diameter of about 45 after reduction at 210°C: the corresponding thin-section electron micrograph is shown in Fig. 3. Figure 4 shows the particle size distribution obtained for the sample corresponding to Fig. 3. Moss and co-workers also showed in some detail the influence of parameters such as platinum content, method of preparation, reduction temperature, air-firing, and surface area of the silica support. The temperature of hydrogen reduction of impregnated catalysts may influence the amount of halogen retained by the catalyst. This residual chlorine may have catalytic consequences. For instance, D o r h g , Eastlake, 40
-
L
d 10
0
C r y s t a l l i t c diameter
(8)
FIQ.4. Platinum crystallite size distribution for 2.5% (w/w)platinum/silica catalyst (Fig. 3). Full line, number distribution; broken line, surface area distribution. After T.A. Dorling, and R. L. Moss, J . Catal. 7, 378 (1967)and R.L. Moss, Platinum Metah Rev. 11 (41, 1 (1967).
METAL CATALYZED SKELETAL REACTIONS O F HYDROCARBON8
11
and Moss (56)found that the activity of a 10% platinum/silica catalyst for the test reaction of ethylene hydrogenation was dependent on the level of residual chlorine, presumably present on the platinum. Although nickel/silica catalysts are often prepared by impregnation or deposition with a nickel compound which would decompose thermally on calcining to give nickel oxide, these catalysts require hydrogen reduction at >500"C even though nickel oxide itself only requires 200'-300"C for complete reduction. Schuit and van Reijen (40) concluded that impregnation of a silica support by, for instance, nickel nitrate solution resulted on calcining, in the formation of particles of nickel oxide covered with a layer of nickel silicate, and it is the latter which impedes the reduction process. Nevertheless, some reduction to yield particles of metallic nickel clearly does occur, as is evident from magnetic and X-ray data. Catalysts prepared by nickel precipitation, and particularly those prepared by coprecipitation, are even more difficult to reduce than are impregnated ones. Even extended hydrogen reduction a t about 500°C may easily result in no more than about half the nickel being present as metallic nickel, the rest being present as nickel oxide and as some sort of nickel silicate (41, 4 2 ) . The range of composition is, however, highly variable. Clearly, the nickel silicate is highly resistant to hydrogen reduction or at the most, reduction to metallic nickel only occurs to a very limited extent in a surface layer of the silicate. For catalysts reduced at 400"-5OO"C, average nickel particle diameters in the range 3 0 4 5 A (40, 429, and 30-200 A (41) have been quoted. Coenen and Linsen (41) have assumed a roughly hemispherical shape for the nickel particles which expose ( l l l ) ,(loo), and (110) planes, and this is at least consistent with the very limited electron microscopic evidence. On the whole, it appears to be more difficult to produce a very high degree of metal dispersion with nickel than with platinum, and it is very difficult to obtain an average nickel particle diameter <30 A, although not impossible. Other metals on silica supports have been investigated less extensively than platinum and nickel, and average particle diameters have only been estimated by gas adsorption methods, supported in a few cases by X-ray line broadening data. Thus, rhodium, iridium, osmium, and ruthenium (44, 45) and palladiu? (46') have all been prepared with average metal particle diameters <40 A or so, after hydrogen reduction at 400'-500'C. The structure of the metal particles dispersed on a silica powder support ("Aerosil" 380, 70 average silica particle diameter) has been studied by Avery and Sanders (47) using electron microscopy in both bright and dark field, to determine the extent to which the metal particles were multiply twinned or of ideal structure. Platinum, palladium, and gold were examined. These catalysts were prepared by impregnation using an aqueous solution of metal halide derivatives, were dried at 100'-1 50'C, and were hydrogen
12
J. R. ANDERSON
FIG.5. Electron micrograph of 2.5% (w/w) platinum/alumina catalyst. Prepared by impregnation with chloroplatinic acid, reduced in hydrogen at 210°C. Micrograph obtained by thin sectioning. The black dots are platinum particles. ( X 100,000). Reproduced with permission from R. L. Moss, Platinum Metals Rev. 11 (4), 1 (1967) and British Crown Copyright.
reduced at 300OC. The proportion of metal was in the range 5-15%. The range of electron microscopically visible metal particle $ameters were platinum 10-80 A, palladium 20-100 A, and gold 100-350 A. In all cases metal particles were randomly oriented on the substratc and the proportion of multiply twinned particles was low, certainly not exceeding 2%.
METAL CATALYZED SKELETAL REACTIONS OF HYDROCARBONS
13
2. MetallAlumina Catalysts A thin section electron micrograph of a 2.5% platinum catalyst on a low area y-alumina has been obtained by Moss ( 3 5 ) . As shown by Fig. 5 the platinum particles are distributed rather less uniformly over the support surface than is the case with platinum/silica catalysts. Presumably, this is a result of the crystallographic heterogeneity of the alumina surface in contrast to which silica supports are amorphous. Wilson and Hall (48) showed, for instance, that 2.8y0platinum/alumina catalyst (140 m2 gm-l, probably y-alumina) reduced in bydrogen at 475°C had an average platinum particle diameter of about 11 A and the corresponding particle size distribution is shown in Fig. 6. In summary, it is clear that provided the temperature of hydrogen reduction is limited to 500°C or so, and provided high tempernture calcining in air or oxygen is avoided, platinum deposited on alumina is very finely dispersed with an average particle diameter in the region of 1015 8, for platinum contents <3%. With nickel/alumina catalysts (cf. 42) preparation by coprecipitation or by the decomposition of a high dispersion of nickel hydroxide on fresh alumina hydrogel, yields nickel aluminate exclusively. On the other hand, when, as in impregnation, larger particles of nickel compound are deposited, the calcination product is a mixture of nickel oxide and nickel aluminate. The proportion of nickel oxide increases when occlusion of the impregnation solution leads to a very nonuniform distribution (49). As in the nickel/silica case, the rate of hydrogen reduction of nickel oxide
n
-1 I I
4
6
8
10
12
14
16
1:
20
22
CrystaLLite diameter (A)
FIG. 6. Platinum crystallite size distribution for 2.5% (w/w) platinum/ahmina catalyst. Full line, number distribution; broken line, surface area distribution. After G. R. Wilson and W. K. Hall, J . Catal. 17,190 (1970).
14
J. R. ANDERSON
when this is present on an alumina support is very slow cornpared to th a t for pure nickel oxide, requiring prolonged hydrogen treatment a t 550°C for instance. Presumably, this is due to the presence of a thin skin of aluminate over the oxide particle. Nevertheless, reduction of oxide to discrete particles of metallic nickel certainly occurs. On the whole, with impregnated catalysts, nickel/alumina is more difficult to reduce than nickel/silica, (with nickcl/silica-alumina occupying an intermediate position). llorikawa et al. ( 4 2 ) suggest that nickel aluminate itself undergoes hydrogen reduction only to a superficial extent, and then produces extremely small nickel particles as the reduction product. In this circumstance, the nickel particle size distribution in a reduced nickel/alumina catalyst will obviously be much dependent on the preparative details that control the proportions nickel oxide and nickel aluminate and the size of the particles in which these substances exist before reduction.
3. Metal/Carbon Catalysts X-Ray studies confirm that platinum crystallites exist on carbon supports at least down to a metal content of about 0.03% ( 2 ) .On the other hand, it has been claimrd that nickel erystallites do not exist in nickel/carbon catalysts (50). This rrquires verification, but it does draw attention to the fact that carbon is not inert toward many metals which can form carbides or intercalation compounds with graphite. In gcneral, it is only with the noble group VIII metals that one can feel reasonably confident that a substantial amount of the metal will be retainrd on the carbon surface in its elemental form. Judging from Moss’s ( 3 5 ) rlectron micrographs of a reduced 57’ platinum charcoal catalyst, the platinum crystallites appear to be a t least as finely dispersed on charcoal as on silica or alumina, or possibly more so, but both platinum and palladium (51) supported on carbon appear to be very sensitive to sintering. There can be no doubt that w r n with a noble metal such as platinum, the surface can be hravily contaminatrd with carbon when the latter is used as a supporting material ( 5 1 ) . This may be amrliorated by cautious treatment with oxygen which oxidizes this carbon impurity to carbon dioxide. Neverthelrss, it is extremely doubtful if any platinum surface in platinum/carbon can be prrpared without an appreciable, and perhaps substantial, amount of impurity.
C. GAS ADSORPTION BEHAVIOR Hydrogen chemisorption has frequently been used for catalyst characterization. Considerable detailed information is available for hydrogen
METAL CATALYZED SKELETAL REACTIONS OF HYDROCARBONS
15
adsorption on nickel, including films (52-55), some typical supportcd catalysts (40, 56, 57) and metal powder (58, 59). A comparison between the behavior of these adsorbents has been made by Roberts (58, 59). On a clean nickel surface, a relative coverage of unity with a surface stoichiometry Hc,)/Nics)= 1 is achieved a t >lo+ Torr from -195°C at least to 20°C; i.e., the uptake is very little dependent on pressure at Torr at these temperatures. Adsorption is very fast (time scale of the order of a few seconds to one minute), On supported nickel and nickel powder, hydrogen uptake has both fast and slow (time scale of the order of many minutes) components. The relative importance of the slow component decreases with increased rigour of surface purification, but is never eliminated; this is an activated adsorption which is effectively completely suppressed a t - 195°C. A slow uptake component has been observed in virtually every study made of hydrogen adsorption on supported transition metals, even a t quite high temperatures [e.g., t o 400"C, with rhodium/alumina (60)], and we believe that in all cases these metal surfaces are never completely clean. The end result of slow hydrogen uptake on a nickel surface carrying oxygen is the conversion of O ( # )to OH(,) (58). Thus, when hydrogen uptake has gone to completion the resultant adsorption stoichiometry H (,)/Ni is again in the region of unity. Completion of this slow hydrogen uptake is facilitated by highish hydrogen pressures ( > 1 Torr) and temperatures ( >20°C) and, in practice, these are the conditions usually used to measure the total surface areas of metallic nickel in supported catalysts (e.g., 61-63) . The effect of other surface impurities may be more severe than that of oxygen. For instance, adsorbed sulfur strongly inhibits hydrogen adsorption on nickel ( 5 8 ) ,while chlorine adsorbed on nickel is also likely to be a tenaciously held surface contaminant. The general comments made above concerning the character of hydrogen adsorption in relation to surface cleanliness apply to platinum. Again, and for similar reasons to those given for nickel, total hydrogen uptakes on supported platinum are generally measured a t >1 Torr and >20"C, often about 100 Torr and 200°C (e.g., 64-66). Under these conditions adsorbed oxygen reacts with hydrogen according to (65, 67). (@)
Pt-O(,)
+ N Hz
+
Pt-Hw
+ HzO
( 1)
the water being taken up by the support. On clean platinum surfaces (e.g., for a surface evaporated films), the surface stoichiometry H(,,/Pt saturated with adsorbed hydrogen is unity a t 0"-20°C (68,69) ; at - 195°C the ratio rises somewhat due to further adsorption of more weakly bound molecular hydrogen ( 7 0 ) . At >20"C and > 1 Tow, one would expect a supported platinum specimen saturated with hydrogen to have a H ( e ) /
16
J. R . ANDERSON
Pt ( 8 ) ratio of about unity, and a recent critical survey of the situation by Wilson and Hall (48) indicates that this is, in fact, the case. Reaction (1) is the basis of the technique for the titration of chemisorbed oxygen by hydrogen (67). Hydrogen chemisorption a t 20°C has been used with ultrathin platinum films (29,SO). I n general it is found that the hydrogen uptake is rather larger (by about 20%) than can be reasonably accounted for by the particle size as determined by the electron microscope. It is found that on this type of surface, hydrogen adsorption isotherms are very similar in character to those observed with known clean platinum (e.g., thick films), thus confirming their surface cleanliness. Pure silica appears to be inert to hydrogen, but a t >1 Torr adsorption may occur on alumina and carbon and various workers have reported proportions of the total hydrogen uptake attributable to the support in the following ranges : alumina O-25%, and carbon 50% or more. I n addition to adsorption occurring directly onto the support, there is also the possibility that when metal is present, adsorption on the support may be augmented by the transfer of dissociatively chemisorbed hydrogen from metal to the support. This possibility was envisaged by Spenadel and Boudart (64) who concluded however, that it was unimportant, a t least with platinum/silica catalysts. However, there is a substantial body of evidence, based on hydrogen chemisorption studies (71-74) as well as on catalytic reactions over supported metals (for a summary of references see Sancier (75) to show that this sort of hydrogen transfer can occur with silica, alumina, and carbon supports, particularly a t highish temperatures ( >300"C). The effect is particularly severe with carbon. It also seems likely to occur with ultrathin platinum films. With highly dispersed platinum catalysts this behavior is not unexpected in view of the activation energy for surface mobility of H on platinum of 4.5 kcal mole-' (69), so that a t 20°C the migration of H through a distance of (say) 50 could occur very quickly (<<1sec). Ill. Experimental Techniques A. EVAPORATED METALFILMS Many of the various techniques associated with metal film preparation have recently been reviewed by Klemperer ( 7 6 ) . Much of the catalytic work with thick continuous films has used a cylindrical reaction vessel (Fig. 7a). This cylindrical geometry permits a cylindrical sleeve of mica sheet to be inserved and used as the film substrate for epitaxial film growth (24). As will be apparent from the subsequent discussion, a very thin discontinuous film such as occurs in the fringe region of a film formed in a
METAL CATALYZED SKELETAL REACTIONS OF HYDROCARBONS
17
FIG.7. (a) Conventional reaction vessel for preparation and use of thick evaporated metal film catalysts; (b) reaction vessel for preparation and use of thick, fringe-free evaporated metal film catalysts.
vessel of the type shown in Fig. 7a, can have different catalytic properties from a continuous film, particularly if the latter is deposited a t a high substrate temperature. For this reason, the reaction vessel shown in Fig. 7b has been designed (28) in which virtually no fringe film is present a t reaction temperature. Recently, ultrathin evaporated films have been used as models for dispersed supported metal catalysts, the main object being the preparation of a catalyst where surface cleanliness and crystallite size and structure could be better controlled than in conventional supported catalysts. I n ultrathin films of this type, an average metal density on the substrate equivalent to >0.02 monolayers has been used. The apparatus for this technique is shown schematically in Fig. 8 ( 2 7 ) . It was designed to permit use under UHV conditions, and to avoid depositing the working film on top of an “outgassing film.” Evaporated film catalysts are virtually always used with a static gas phase, and with reactant gas pressures less than about 100 Torr. One thus relies upon gaseous diffusion and convection for transport to the catalyst surface. However, provided one is dealing with reaction times of the order of minutes to tens of minutes, gas phase transport has but a negligible effect on the reaction, provided none of the reaction volume is separated from the film by small bore tubulation. Beeck et al. (77) in fact originally used an all-glass magnetically coupled turbine for gas circulation, but this is only
18
J. R. ANDERSON
VACUUM
b GAS HAN DL I N G
FIG.8. Apparatus for preparation and use of ultrathin film catalysts. W, windlass for moving evaporation filament; S, substrate for film deposition; V, sliding valve to separate ultrathin film region from region used for filament outgassing (outgassing position of filament as shown); L, leak to mass spectrometer; reactant introduction and sample extraction are made via the gas handling ports. The materials and valving are made UHV compatible. After J. R. Anderson and R. J. Macdonald, J . Catal. 19, 227
(1970).
necessary if one wjshes to use a film catalyst with a very large volume of reactant gas mixture a t a pressure approaching one atmosphere. The most important gas phase analytical techniques are mass spectrometry and gas phase chromatography. If the total gas pressure is Torr, a mass spectrometer such an omegatron or a quadrupole instrument may be inserted into the reactant volume. However, in most cases, the pressure is in excess of this, and gas must be delivered to a mass spectrometer via a leak, such as a “Metrosil” pellet or a capillary constriction, situated as closely as possible to the reaction volume. Sampling for gas phase chromatographic analysis can be readily achieved by a grease-free, rotatable, multiple-ported gas sampling valve. Various commercial units of this sort are available. However, the author’s laboratory preferred to fabricate to its own design (Y. Shimoyama, 1970) ; the result is a valve containing only stainless steel and PTFE and spccifications
METAL CATALYZED SKELETAL REACTIONS OF HYDROCARBONS
19
are available from the author on request. The only critical requirement is to achieve satisfactory vacuum and leak-free performance without the use of grease lubricants (which adsorb hydrocarbons).
B. SUPPORTED CATALYSTS A tubular flow reactor is the standard technique, and much laboratoryscale experimental work has been done with quantities of catalyst in the region of 1gmto a few tens of grams operated at atmospheric pressure. Blending reaction components into the reactant gas stream, and sampling of reactor effluent are readily done by obvious and well known techniques, while scaling up this style of reactor for operation at higher pressures or higher throughputs involves standard engineering procedures (e.g. 78, 79). Pulse operation (80) is an alternative mode with a flow reactor, and is particularly convenient for use with reactants which are only available in very small quantities (e.g. W-labeled substances). It also has the advantage that the pulse of reaction products may, if desired, be passed directly to a GPC column for analysis. The pulse technique may also be conveniently extended to include stages of reactant preparation. Figure 9 shows a schematic representation of a pulse reactor system recently used by Gault et al. (81), which includes stages for alcohol (the reactant precursor) dehydration and subsequent olefin hydrogenation, the resulting saturated hydrocarbon being the material of catalytic interest. A method has been described (82) which allows the use of a pulse reactor a t above atmospheric pressure.
F
FIG.9. Pulse microreactor system for use with W-labeled hydrocarbons. D, E, and J are microreactors; J contains the catalyst to be used for hydrocarbon skeletal reaction; D and E are used, when necessary, to generate the required reactant hydrocarbon from a non-hydrocarbon precursor (e.g., alcohol dehydration in D and olefin hydrogenation in E); reactant injected a t C. F is a trap which allows the accumulation of products from several reaction pulses before analysis; G is a G.P.C. column, K a katharometer. Traps H collect fractions separated on G for subsequent mass spectrometric study. When generating reactant hydrocarbon in D and E, a two-step process is preferable in which, with J below reaction temperature, the purified reactant hydrocarbon is collected in H, and this is recycled as reactant with D and E below reaction temperature but with J a t reaction temperature. After C. Corolleur, S. Corolleur, and F. G. Gault, J. C u t d 24, 385 (1972).
20
J. R. ANDERSON
C. USE OF HYDROCARBONS CONTAINING ISOTOPIC CARBON Both 13C- and 14C-labeledhydrocarbons have been used in mechanistic studies. In either case, the task is the determination of the position of the labeling atom in the molecules of the reaction product. With 13Clabeling this is always done by studying the fragmentation patterns in a mass spectrometer, while with 14C-labeling,conventional degradative and radiochemical procedures are used. By combining the convenience of GPC for the separation of structural isomers, with mass spectrometry, 13C-labeling provides a highly convenient technique which is particularly suitable to experiments which use only very small quantities of reactant, as for instance with evaporated metal film catalysts or with a pulse flow reactor. If one is committed to working on a fairly large scale, as might be the case for instance in a reaction carried out a t high pressure, one will be forced to use 14Crather than 13Cbecause the latter must be used a t fairly high concentration for mass spectrometric structure determination to be possible with reasonable accuracy, and the cost would be prohibitive. The main disadvantages of the use of 13C labeling are, in some cases a t least, a degree of ambiguity in the interpretation of the mass spectra and the need for detailed auxiliary information on the mass spectra of W-substituted molecules of known structure. Preparation of the latter may well require a substantial amount of synthetic work. On the other hand, the use of 14Clabeling usually requires degradative procedures of some tediousness. Indeed a comprehensive examination of the 14C content of every position in a molecule would, in many cases, involve mammoth labor, and is usually not attempted; in those cases to which 14Chas been applied, i t is generally not needed either. Thus much 14Cwork has involved no more than a determination of the isotopic content of ring and side-chain in aromatic products from alkane dehydrocyclization. The information so obtained would be available at least as easily using 13Clabeling together with mass spectrometry, while the latter would be much easier when dealing with aliphatic or alicyclic molecules. When working with alkyl-substituted aromatic molecules, reduction to the corresponding alicyclic before mass spectrometric study may be needed to avoid intramolecular isotopic positional scrambling via the trqpylium-type ion which is formed in the ion source. 1. Preparation
A variety of standard synthetic methods have been used. Table I, which is not intended as an exhaustive compilation, lists some C3-Cs hydrocarbons which have been prepared (mainly in the last ten years or so) substituted with either 13C or 14C. Preparative details are given in the original literature. The route choice often depends on the available starting material.
21
METAL CATALYZED SKELETAL REACTIONS OF HYDROCARBONS
TABLE I Some Labeled Hydrocarbonsa
Reference Ca
A
Propane-1-*C
88
c 4
d v
n-Butane-1-*C n-Pentane-1-*C 2-Methylbutane-l-*C
24 84 85
2-Methylbutane-3-*C n-Hexane-1-*C n-Hexane-2-*C 2-(Methyl-*C) pentane
85 85 85 85
2-Methylpentane-2-*C
85
2-Methylpentane-4-*C
86
2-Methylpentaned-*C
85
3-(Met hyl-*C) pentane
86
3-Methylpentane-3-*C
85
3-Methylpentane+*C
85
3-Methylpentane-l-*C
85
(Methyl-*C) cyclopentane
86
n-Heptane-1-*C n-Heptane-4-*C 2-Methylhexane-6-*C
88 89
3-(Methyl-*C) hexane
89
(Methyl-*C) cyclohexane
90
n-Octane-1-*C n-Octane-4-*C
91 92
4- (Methy1-*C) heptane 3-(Methyl-*C) heptane
93 93
2,%-DimethyL4-(methyl-*C) pentane
94
2,4-Dimethyl-3-(methyl-*C) pentane
95
C6
0-
87
96
Continued
22
J. R. ANDERSON
TABLE I-Continued
Reference
'
I
1 ,2-(~imethyl-*C)cyclohexane
96
CP
(TEthyl-1-*C) cyclohexane
97
'0
(Eithyl-2-*C) cyclohexane
97
(M ethyl-*C) cycloheptane
98
The dot in the skeletal representation indicates the position of the labeled atom.
2. Mass-Spectral Analysis of W-labeled Hydrocarbons For CrCs (C,) saturates, mass spectrometric results show that the C,+ ions have mass spectral sensitivities independent of 13C content, and the formation of fragment ions by the loss of hydrogen is independent of 1 3 C content [Stevenson (99) ; Anderson and Avery ( 2 4 ) ] . If no skeletal rearrangements occur in the mass spectrometer ion source, it is very easy to see how the position of the 13Catom can be obtained from the relative peak heights of the fragment ions resulting from C-C rupture by electron impact. The general approach may be illustrated by supposing that the mass spectrum is recorded for a mixture containing n-butane-l-13C and n-butane-2-13C. All C3f fragment ions from n-butane-2-13C must contain a 13Catom, whereas from n-butane-l-13C only half the C3+ions will contain a atom. Thus, assuming for the moment that peaks a t masses 43 and 44 are due entirely to ions 12C3H7+(mass 43) and 12C213CH7+ respectively, one would obtain
where R is the 44/43 peak height ratio.
METAL CATALYZED SKELETAL REACTIONS OF HYDROCARBONS
23
I n practice, other factors have to be taken into account. Corrections for naturally occurring deuterium (0.02% natural abundance) and naturally occurring 13C (1.1% natural abundance) need to be made to the raw data. More than one type of fragment may occur a t a given mass. For instance; 1zC213CH6+ also has mass 43: correction for this is readily made using the fragmentation patterns appropriate to the light parent hydrocarbon. The chance of 12C-13C bond rupture under electron impact is greater than that for the 12C-12C bond, the ratio of the bond rupture probabilities being variously given as 1.2 (85) and 1.12 (24). This ratio, is, to some extent, instrumentally dependent and should be determined for each experimental situation using a hydrocarbon of known isotopic content ana qtrwture. The labeled molecule is never isotopically pure since an enrichment of about 60% is the maximum commonly available. Correction for this is easily made. The most serious assumption in the above treatment is that no skeletal rearrangements occur in the ion source. This was shown by Stevenson (99) to be true for the production of C3+ ions from the butanes. However, in general it cannot be assumed without experimental verification, and with this object in mind an extensive study has been made by Corolleur (84) with various hexane isomers. The outcome of this is that this assumption is valid for the branch-chain hexanes, but rearrangement makes a serous contribution with n-hexane. The assumption that with branch-chain hydrocarbons (e.g., 2- and 3-methylpentane) fragmentation occurs exclusively a t the tertiary carbon atom, is well followed. Thus, with 2- and 3-methylpentane the interpretation of mass spectral data along the relatively straightforward lines indicated above for butanes, would not be in serious error but with n-hexane the use of reference data from known 13Cpositional isomers is imperative. One general conclusion is obvious: in the use of mass spectrometry for the analysis of mixtures of 13Cpositional isomers, a prior study of pure compounds of known structure is essential. This being so, one might as well use the reference data from known compounds directly in the interpretation of analytical data from mixtures since this reference data has built into it the factors mentioned explicitly with the butanes such as the relative chance of 12C-12C and 12C-13C rupture, as well as the obvious statistical factors. The analytical procedure for 13C positional isomers in the hexanes has been described by Gault and co-workers (81,84,100) and serves as a good illustration. In practice, analysis is usefully done in terms of ions "C6H;4, 12C513CHt4, i2C5Hfl,12C413CH&,12C4H$12C313CH$. The intensities of these are obtained after making the usual corrections for naturally occurring 13C and deuterium, and for fragmentation contributions. Suppose a particular
24
J. R. ANDERSON
positional isomer is designated X. Measurement on this reference substance would yield the following peak height ratios:
and from these we may obtain the relative abundances of the ions 12C413CH;tl and l2C3l3CHfl,a5x and atx, respectively, corrected to the basis of 100% isotopic purity, and relative to a8x = 1. Thus
If a CE reaction component of known skeletal configuration has been separated by (say) GPC from a reaction mixture, it will consist of a mixture of 13Cpositional isomers which we may designate X, Y, Z , . ., with corresponding mole fractions x, y, z , . .. If a, ( n = 4,5 ) is the ion abundance determined for this mixture, it follows that
a4 = xa4x 1
=
x
+ y a 4 ~+ za4z +
+y+x +
*. *
(5)
..*
For each of the hexanes, more than one singly substituted I3C positional isomer is possible: there are five for 2-methylpentane, four for 3-methylpentane, and three for n-hexane. Clearly, if only RE,R5, and R4 are determined, so that only a5and a4are available, Eqs. ( 5 ) cannot give the proportions of all the positional isomers in 2- and 3-methylpentane. This could, in principle, be achieved by extending ( 5 ) to include a3and a2.However, it turns out that a2 is very dependent on source conditions, and thus is unreliable, while, particularly with 3-methylpentane, a3 is very insensitive to positional isomer composition. The result, in practice, is that one is limited to determining
METAL CATALYZED SKELETAL REACTIONS OF HYDROCARBONS
25
In the case of n-hexane, the three positional isomers can, in principle be determined from the three equations in (5). However, the results in this case are very sensitive to ion source conditions, presumably because of ion rearrangement processes, so the evaluated proportions are subject to greater errors than with 2- or 3-methylpentane. 3. Analytical Procedures with %!-labeled Hydrocarbons
As pointed out previously, controlled degradation reactions are very difficult with aliphatic or alicyclic hydrocarbons, and most of the 14Clabeling work has been concentrated on aromatic reaction products. Procedures have been extensively described by Pines and co-workers (e.g., 97, 96, also 87,89-93, 95,98). For the present purpose, it suffices t o note that the 14Ccontents of the methyl side-chains and the rings in aromatic reaction products are readily estimated by oxidation of the methyl to carboxyl, followed by decarboxylation, while ethyl side-chains may be oxidatively degraded one carbon atom at a time. Radiochemical assays may be made on C02 either directly in a gas counter, or after conversion to barium carbonate, while other solid degradation intermediates (e.g., benzoic acid or the phthalic acids) may be either assayed directly as solids or burned to COZ.Liquids are best assayed after burning to C02. Schemes for systematic degradation of a benzene ring have been given (e.g. 88, 101-103). The results are by no means completely unambiguous, and the processes are of not inconsiderable complexity. An extensive general account of conventional techniques with isotopic carbon has been given by Murray and Williams (104).
IV. lsomerization and Dehydrocyclization Reactions on Metals More than three decades ago, skeletal rearrangement processes using alkane or cycloalkane reactants were observed on platinum/charcoal catalysts (105); inasmuch as the charcoal support is inert, this can be taken as probably the first demonstration of the activity of metallic platinum as a catalyst for this type of reaction. At about the same time, similar types of catalytic conversions over chromium oxide catalysts were discovered (106, 107). Distinct from these reactions was the use of various types of acidic catalysts (including the well-known silica-alumina) for effecting skeletal reactions via carbonium ion mechanisms, and these led
26
J. R. ANDERSON
to the development of dual function catalysts of the platinum/silicaalumina type. Doubtlessly prompted by the commercial potential to be seen, these processes have been very extensively studied over a wide range of catalysts. However, in recent years the commercial success of dual function catalysts has tended to obscure the activity of platinum alone as a catalyst for skeletal reactions. The subsequent discussion in this chapter deals with selected topics in this field, and the selection is designed to illuminate the basic chemical reactions which occur.
A. REACTIONS ON PLATINUM Subsequent to the discovery of skeletal rearrangement reactions on platinum/charcoal catalysts, the reality of platinum-only catalysis for reactions of this sort was reinforced with the observation of the isomerization of C4 and C5aliphatic hydrocarbons over thick continuous evaporated platinum films (68,108,24).As we have seen from the discussion of film structure in previous sections, films of this sort offer negligible access of gas to the substrate beneath. Furthermore, these reactions were often carried out under conditions where no glass, other than that covered by platinum film, was heated to reaction temperature; that is, there was essentially no surface other than platinum available a t reaction temperature. Studies have also been carried out (109, 110) using platinum/silica catalysts in which the silica is catalytically inert, and the reaction is undoubted confined to the platinum surface. In addition to this work on charcoal- and silica-supported catalysts and on evaporated platinum films, a number of studies have been made on alumina-supported platinum catalysts (e.g., 111-1 14,81, 115 ) in which the aim has been the study of reactions a t the platinum alone. In these cases, one cannot automatically dismiss the possibility of participation of the alumina support (i.e., of dual function behavior of the catalyst) because it is known that alumina may have acidic properties, particularly when retained halogen is present. In general terms, there is no immediate answer to this problem because the nature of this sort of catalyst will be much dependent on the details of catalyst history, preparation, and use. However, there can be little doubt that in many experimental studies using platinum/alumina, and in which the assumption has been made that the alumina support is inert, this assumption is essentially valid. For instance, one may note the “inert” alumina used by Davis and Venuto (111) and the justification provided by Gault et al. (116) for the inertness of the alumina used in a substantial body of previous work irrespective of whether the catalyst was
METAL CATALYZED SKELETAL REACTIONS OF HYDROCARBONS
27
prepared by impregnation with a chlorine-containing or a chlorine-free platinum compound, a t least provided the reactions are confined to relatively low temperatures (say <350"C). This temperature limitation may well be generally very important in confining reactions to the metal with catalysts which, a t higher temperatures, may exhibit appreciable dual function behavior. It is useful to consider the relative ease of skeletal reactions compared with adsorption and desorption indicated by deuterium exchange. Here one must ensure that exchange and skeletal reactions involve the same adsorbed intermediate, and this requires working a t comparable temperatures, and assessing the adsorbed intermediate from the initial exchange . important intermediates appear, for inproducts (cf. 1 1 6 ~ ) Skeletally stance, to be reversibly adsorbed on platinum and palladium, but irreversibly adsorbed on iron and cobalt. There is a general trend for reaction rates in skeletal isomerization and related processes, to decrease with increasing reaction time. One needs to distinguish irreversible catalyst poisoning from a reversible inhibition in rate. The difference is only one of the strength and permanency with which the adsorbed species that are responsible, are bound to the catalyst surface. The extent to which these phenomena occur is much dependent on the nature of the reacting hydrocarbon and the reaction conditions. In the reaction of the butanes over platinum film catalysts a t 260"-300" (24), there was no evidence for inhibition or poisoning with a hydrogen/hydrocarbon ratio of 12/1, but poisoning became significant when this ratio was less than 3/1. On the other hand, with the hexanes inhibition of the rate occurred a t 270"-280°C with a hydrogen/hydrocarbon ratio of 10/1 on all of a variety of platinum film catalysts ranging from thick to ultrathin (SO). This inhibition was reversible on the removal of reactant, provided the catalyst with the adsorbed inhibitor was not maintained near reaction temperature in the absence of a substantial hydrogen partial pressure; in the latter circumstance the catalyst became irreversible poisoned, due no doubt t o further dehydrogenation of the adsorbed inhibiting residues. Csicsery (109) found that the rate of reaction of n-butylbenzene on a platinum/silica catalyst a t 316"-482°C (hydrogen/hydrocarbon ratio -3) decreased as the extent of reaction increased, and very plausibly ascribed this to inhibition in the reaction rate by relatively strongly adsorbed naphthalene, which was one of the main reaction products. Extensive catalyst poisoning results from the deposition of carbon in or on the catalyst surface. I n technological parlance, this is usually referred to as the formation of "coke." At temperatures in excess of those normally used for catalysis, hydrocarbon decomposition a t metal surfaces is known
28
J. R. ANDERSON
to give graphite [e.g., methane a t 700°C on nickel (117 and cf. 118)]. It is thus probable that “coke” is a poorly crystalline or noncrystalline carbon polymer, part-way toward the graphite structure. This is in accordance with the results of Muller and Gault (119) who showed that, in the reaction of 1 ,1 ,3-trimethylcyclopentane on a series of thick evaporated metal film catalysts a t 250”-320°C (hydrogen/hydrocarbon, 10/1), the extent of “coke” formation (assessed as carbon lost from the reaction mixture) paralleled the extent to which aromatics occurred in the reaction products, and the latter can clearly be regarded as general precursors for polymerization toward a graphitelike structure. These tendencies increased in the order Co < Fe < Pd < Pt. It is also interesting that Muller and Gault’s results indicate little carbide formation with cobalt and iron and, for their reaction conditions, this agrees with the relevant thermodynamics (120). I n technical hydrocarbon reforming processes using platinum catalysts, high hydrogen pressures are usually used to inhibit catalyst poisoning and coke formation as far as possible, for instance a total pressure of several atmospheres to several tens of atmospheres, with a several-fold excess of hydrogen in the reactant mixture. I n the mechanistic discussion which follows, it should be assumed unless otherwise specified, that the reaction mixture contained a large excess of hydrogen and that the reaction was carried out a t atmospheric pressure or below. Furthermore, distributions of reaction products to which we shall refer correspond to low reactant conversion (
The isomerization of the butanes and of neopentane has been studied over various types of evaporated platinum films by Anderson and Baker (68) and Anderson and Avery (108,24). Table I1 gives some typical results. It is clear that the proportion of parent hydrocarbon reacting to isomeric rather than to hydrogenolytic product is considerably smaller for a hydrocarbon with an unbranched as opposed to a branched chain containing a n isostructural unit; indeed, neopentane was studied as the archetypal molecule of the latter class. The isomerization of neopentane has also been observed on a variety of dispersed platinum catalysts, including supported platinum as wcll as platinum powder, by Boudart and co-workers (121, 122). On a 1% plati-
TABLE I1 Reactions of C1 and CSAliphatics over Platinum Film Catalysts
Reactant hydrocarbon
Catalyst
Reaction temperature ("C)
Activation energy (kcal mole-')
Proportion of reaction by Initial product distribution (mole percent) isomerization (mole isonisonneologld" percent) CH, C Z H ~C& C,Hlo CaH1, C5H12 C5H12 C6HlZ
5el b d
$
2 6
neopentane thick polycrystalline Pt film deposited 0°C isopentane thick polycrystalline Pt film deposited 0°C thick polycrystalisobutane line P t film deposited 0°C thick polycrystaln-butane line P t film deposited 0°C (111) P t film isobutane deposited 300°C (111) P t film n-butane deposited 300°C isobutane (100) Pt film deposited 250°C (loo) Pt film n-butane deposited 250°C a
239-295
21( <27OoC) 21.2 ( <270"C)
278
78
14
5
4
10
33
31
13
13
14
-
256-299
21
21.0
68
24
6
20
256-299
21
21.1
20
32
29
28
294-305
91
8
3
6
320
22
30
30
28
299
74
15
13
13
300
28
29
32
23
A , frequency factor, molecules sec-l cm-2. From Anderson and Avery (24).
3
59
5
-
9
-
19
5
0
-
-
M
u
-
N
CD
30
J. R. ANDERSON
num/carbon catalyst which had been sintered to 900°C, an activation energy for isomerization of 49 kcal mole-' was found (370"-410°C). This value is very much higher than that found on platinum film catalysts (21 kcal mole-', <27O"C, cf. Table 11). It is hardly possible to avoid the conclusion that these two catalyst surfaces must be considerably different in a chemical sense, and this is a conclusion which is also reached from an examination of the concurrent hydrogenolysis reactions (Section V) , and which agrees with the results from hydrogen adsorption measurements (Section 1I.C). It is interesting that the rate of the reaction over platinum films decreased a t >270"C, probably due to self-poisoning by strongly adsorbed hydrocarbon residues. The high temperature range for the reaction over the platinum/carbon catalyst would be consistent with the presence of a high concentration of strongly adsorbed material. The temperature dependence of the selectivity for isomerization versus hydrogenolysis depends on the type of catalyst. Thus, over thick platinum film catalysts this selectivity was temperature independent for the reaction of the butanes and neopentane ( 2 4 ) . However, in Boudart and Ptak's (122) reaction of neopentane over platinum/carbon the selectivity to isomerization decreased slightly with increasing temperature while Kikuchi et al. (123) found an increased trend for isomerization in the reaction of n-pentane over platinum/silica and platinum/carbon catalysts. I n addition to this skeletal isomerization reaction, Anderson and Avery (24) showed that in a suitable isotopically labeled hydrocarbon, a reaction leading to positional isomerization occurred. Thus, with n-butane-l-13C as the reactant, the isomerization products were 2- (methyl-W) propane, and n-butane-2-13C:
The ratio of the amount of n-butane-2-13C to the amount of isobutane produced was, provided measurements were made under conditions where secondary reactions were unimportant (i.e., initial reaction products), constant and independent of temperature, and this ratio was 1/4. At the same time, no scrambling of the 13C occurred; i.e., all of the isotopically substituted molccules remained singly labeled. Anderson and Baker (68) speculated that the butane isomerization might have occurred by a recombination of adsorbed surface residues produced by fragmentation of the
METAL CATALYZED SKELETAL REACTIONS OF HYDROCARBONS
31
parent molecules, this proposal having been prompted by evidence for recombination processes adduced from extensive Russian work on platinum/charcoal catalysts [Shuikin (124)1. If these recombining residues possessed appreciable surface mobility, and some mobility would be needed for structural isomerization to occur, some 13C scrambling would be expected in the reaction product and parent. From the absence of scrambling it was concluded that the butane isomerization reactions were entirely intramolecular. This conclusion was confirmed by the total absence of any 13Cincorporation when a reaction was carried out in the presence of 13CH4. We shall return to a consideration of Shuikin’s recombination processes subsequently. We shall refer to the type of simple process exemplified by (6) as a “bond-shift” process. It will be clear a t once that this sort of transformation could be accounted for by postulating a C3 cyclic reaction intermediate (with the ring reopening in a position different to that of closure). A mechanism of this sort has been proposed in certain circumstances on platinum catalysts (119, and cf. 114) as well as on chromium oxide catalysts (e.g., 3, 125). In its simplest and most obvious form, a C, cyclic intermediate amounts to something approaching an adsorbed cyclopropane ring, and if this sort of intermediate were a reality, one would expect to be able to correlate this isomerization reaction with the ring opening behavior of the corresponding cyclopropane derivative. At least with Cq molecules this correlation does not occur. Thus, it was shown (24,126) that methylcyclopropane a t 280°C on platinum catalysts gives the ratio of ring opening probabilities (al a z ) / b in (A)
+
b (A)
equal to 0.3, whereas an adsorbed cyclic reaction intermediate of similar geometry for reaction (6) requires a ratio of 1.28 to account for the observed product distribution. It is also relevant to consider the free energy changes accompanying the formation of cycloalkane rings of various sizes, since one may use these values as indices for the ease of formation of the corresponding adsorbed cyclic reaction intermediates. The data are shown in Fig. 10. In interpreting these data to the present problem, the important point to note is that bond shift reactions with the butanes or neopentane occur on platinum with comparable facility to reactions with larger molecules which proceed via adsorbed Cg cyclic intermediates (v.i.). Thus, if bond shift
32
J. R. ANDERSON
c3
c4
c5
c6
CI
CS
Carbon number FIG.10. Standard free energy change for cycloalkane formation a t 550°K. -0-, alcycloalkane Hf; - X-, l-alkene =: cycloalkane.
kane
+
were to occur via an adsorbed C3cyclic intermediate, one would expect this to be formed with roughly comparable facility to an adsorbed Cscyclic intermediate. In view of the much larger free energy increase accompanying cyclization to a C3 cycloalkane ring compared to a Csring (Fig. 10) equal facility of formation seems unlikely. There is an important qualification to this argument. If, in addition to cyclization, there was partial electron transfer from the adsorbed intermediate to the platinum, one would then expect the difference between the ease of formation of C( and Cg cyclic intermediates to be considerably less than the value indicated (about 18 kcal mole-') from Fig. 10, since the ionization energy of cyclopropane is some 0.8 eV less than that of cyclopentane ( 1 2 7 ) .This comment is relevant to the cyclopropane-type mechanism proposed by Lester ( 11 4 ) . I n the end, chemical data are matters of fact, but mechanisms are matters of opinion; on balance, we believe an adsorbed cyclopropane-type intermediate to be unlikely for bond-shift processes on platinum catalysts. Anderson and Avery (24, 128) have proposed a bond shift mechanism based upon a 1-3 adsorbed species which, when formed from neopentane, is HSC, ,CH, C H , C ' 'CH I II Pt Pt (B)
METAL CATALYZED SKELETAL REACTIONS OF HYDROCARBONS
33
The mechanism was then formulated as an extension to the general theory of ionic rearrangements discussed by Zimmerman and Zweig (129). The proposed slow step in the reaction scheme is shown in (7)
The species (C) in (7) corresponds to (B) , and C1 is double bonded to the surface: the species (D) is a bridged intermediate in which CZhas been rehybridized to sp2, and the r-system extends over C2, CI and a surface platinum atom. The likelihood of isomerization (converting the bond C1-CZ into C1-C3) was assessed by Anderson and Avery in terms of the bridging energy (energy difference between (C) and (D) ) , using Zimmerman and Zweig's isomerization criterion that the energy of the bridged intermediate should be lower than that of the precursor (negative bridging energy). It was shown that isomerization was favored by partial electron transfer from the adsorbed hydrocarbon residue to the metal. Thus, Fig. 11 shows the bridging energy computed by a simple Huckel method as a function of the overlap integral between the p. orbital of C3 and the platinum orbital. If the surface platinum atom participating in the r-bond is assumed to contribute no electrons to the r-system in addition to the three contributed by the carbon skeleton, the bridging energy is favorable for isomerization a t all values of the overlap integral. On the other hand, if the platinum contributes one electron, the bridging energy is only favorable when the overlap integral is less than 0.07. The true situation would probably be somewhat more favorable than these computations would indicate when two additional factors are considered, (i) hyperconjugative stabilization of the bridged intermediate by free methyl groups, and (ii) the greater electronegativity normally associated with platinum atoms (2.2) as compared with sp2-hybridized carbon (1.7). It is of interest to note that the direction of partial electron transfer required for this model is in agreement with the polarity of the bond by which a CH2 group is adsorbed on nickel (11); the double bond by which CHZis held to the surface is very probably similar t o Ghat proposed in (D), and since the work function of platinum is higher than that of nickel, one would expect greater electron transfer to the metal with the former. The calculations also showed that the effect of methyl group hyperconjugation on the
34
J. R. ANDERSON
0
0.1
0.2
0.3
0.4
S FIG.11. Top: molecular orbital energies for precursor, structure C (broken lines) and €or bridged intermediate, structure D (full lines). Bottom: bridging energy ( A E ) for N = 0 (full line) and N = 1 (broken line), where N is the number of electrons transferred from the carbon residue to the platinum. The energies are plotted as functions of the TCa-to-platinum overlap integral (S). The energy unit I B 1 is the absolute value of the exchange integral between a pair of p , orbitals in benzene. For structures C and D, cf. reaction (7). After J. R. Anderson and N. R. Avery, J. CalaZ. 7,315 (1967).
bridging energy leads to the following decreasing order of predicted isomerization activity: neopentane > isobutane > n-butane, and this agrees with experimental results. The type of intermediate shown in structure (B) has also been supported by Muller and Gault (119) who showed that in the reaction of 1,l-dimethylcyclopropane with deuterium over a series of thick evaporated metal film catalysts, it was only on platinum that 1 , l ,3-da-neopentane (and 1,1,3,3-d*-neopentane) were dominant products. On palladium, iron, rhodium, nickel, and cobalt the major product was 1,5-dz-neopentane. Anderson and Avery's bond shift mechanism has the consequence of predicting that a quaternary carbon atom cannot be generated in the hydrocarbon product. In fact, Anderson and Avery (24) showed that in the isomerization of isopentane over platinum films, only a very small amount ( < 1%) of ncopentane was produced (although the equilibrium constant for isopentane neopentane is 0.16 a t 27SOC). Furthermore,
METAL CATALYZED SKELETAL REACTIONS O F HYDROCARBONS
35
in a large number of experiments with n-hexane, 2-, and 3-methylpentane over various types of platinum film catalysts (28, 29),neohexane has never been observed in the reaction products. On the other hand, other workers have found small but significant amounts of neohexane in the isomerization products from the hexanes; for instance, about 0.1% from 2-methylpentane ( 8 4 ) , and <5% from 3-methylpentane ( I l S ) , both over polycrystalline platinum films. These results are probably most reasonably interpreted as being due to a small contribution from another reaction pathway involving an adsorbed CQcyclic intermediate. For instance, from 2-methylpentane
and the following more explicit reaction path, also involving adsorbed species of the same type as (B) , has been suggested (119,ISO)
r\/:-y-Y->nf-R-/L Pt
Pt
Pt
Pt
Pt
(9)
The small extent to which this reaction apparently occurs is in agreement with the high energy of the C1ring. Reaction (9) is closely related to (13) which, as we shall see, is a possible route for dehydrocyclization to form Cg ring compounds. The importance of this reaction path appears to be highly variable and is presumably dependent on the nature of the catalyst surface. It is of interest that no neohexane was observed from reactions of the hexanes over platinum/alumina catalysts (0.2 and 10% platinum) ( 8 4 ) . Since Anderson, Macdonald and Shimoyama (28, 29) failed to observe any neohexane on UHV platinum film catalysts ranging from highly sintered, thick films to ultrathin films consisting of discrete, very small metal crystals, it seems likely that the feature required to generate neohexane may well not be the structure of the platinum surface per se, but may be an impurity-generated site. The relative rate of isobutane isomerization has been shown by Anderson and Avery (24) to be markedly increased by using a (111) platinum film surface. On the other hand, this did not occur with n-butane, nor did it occur with either iso- or n-butane over a (100) platinum surface (cf. Table 11).A triangular array of adjacent sites on a (111) platinum surface can be readily fitted by an adsorbed isohydrocarbon, and this structure also fits to allow the carbon orbitals to be directed normally to the surface. On simple geometric grounds, this adsorbed structure is specific to the (111)/
36
J. R. ANDERSON
isohydrocarbon system. The extra residue reactivity from this structure can be understood in terms of the bond shift mechanism already discussed. Thus, if double bonding with the surface occurs a t two out of the three carbon atoms, by comparison with the two-point adsorbed structure, e.g., (B) , st'ructure (E) can provide for an increase in isomerization rate on
CfC\(
IIPt
Pt
II
Pt
purely statistical grounds by a factor of two. However, a more important factor may well br the extent to which (E) allows electron removal from the r-system thus lowering the energy of the bridged structure. AS discussed in previous sections, the extent to which polycrystalline evaporated metal films expose (111) planes in the surface will be heavily dependent on the conditions of preparation. I n particular, deposition or sintering a t high substrate temperatures will lead to an increased proportion of low index planes. This is also true for supported metal catalysts, and has recently becn explored by Boudart et al. (121) who have correlated a n increasing facility for neopentane isomerization with the increasing temperature of platinum catalyst pretreatment (425"-900°C). We have so far tacitly assumed that an adsorbed hydrocarbon molecule undergoes only a single bond shift process in one period of residence on the surface. However, this is not necessarily the case. I n fact it was shown (24) that about 8% of the total isomerization product from neoprntane was n-pentane, the balance being isopcntane (cf. Table 11).Since we are considering only initial reaction products, the chance of n-pentane being formed by the readsorption of isopentanc already produced, is very small, and the only reasonable conclusion is that two consecutive bond shifts occur during one residence period. In fact, as we shall see from the subsequent discussion, consecutive reactions during a single residence period form a very important and general feature of platinum catalyzed isomerization reactions. A reacting molecule has, as an alternative to isomerization, reaction by hydrogenolysis in which lower molecular weight products are formed. This latter process will be discussed in detail in a subsequent section. However, we note hcre that the relative importance of isomerization versus hydrogenolysis decreases as the partial pressure of hydrogen in the reaction mixture increases. This has been demonstrated by Kikuchi et al. (123) for
METAL CATALYZED SKELETAL REACTIONS O F HYDROCARBONS
37
TABLE 111 Proportion of Reaction of n-Pentanea by Zsomerization at 4SO"C
Catalyst
Partial pressure of hydrogen (atm)
Proportion of Reaction by isomerisation (mole percent)
5
19.9 8.0 3.9 14.3 8.2 4.2
Pt/silica
10 20 Pt/carbon
5
10 20 a
n-Pentane partial pressure 0.5 atm. From Kikuchi et al. (123).
reaction of n-pentane over 5% platinum/silica and platinum/carbon catalysts. Conversion to isopentane would be expected to occur by a bond shift process. Some typical results are shown in Table 111. 2. Larger Molecules
When the reactions of alkane molecules larger than the butanes or neopentane are studied, and in particular when the molecule is large enough to form a C5 or a Cs ring, the complexity of the reaction pathway is considerably increased and an important feature is the occurrence, in alddition to isomerization product, of important amounts of cyclic reaction products, particularly methylcyclopentane, formed by dehydrocyclization; this suggests the existence of adsorbed cyclic species. The question is whether the reaction paths for dehydrocyclization and isomerization are related. There is convincing evidence that they are. Skeletal interconversions involving n-hexane, 2- and 3-methylpentane may be represented. 3- Methylpentane
[&-] C
2-Methylpentane
n-
38
J. R. ANDERSON
If this were so, one would expect a correlation between, the ring-opening behavior of methylcyclopentane and the distribution of reaction products in the isomerization of the hexanes. A reasonable correlation of this sort has bcen shown to exist for various reactions on supported platinum and platinum film catalysts (113, 131, 132, 115, 84, 133, SO) and some typical data are shown in Table IV. Because there are complications arising from multiple reaction pathways for isomerization, one does not necessarily expect exact agreement in the values for the isomer ratios. However, the data in Table IV can leave no doubt that an adsorbed Cs cyclic intermediate provides an important reaction path. It is interesting that the agreement is poorest with thick film catalysts (massive platinum) and best with highly dispersed catalysts. This accords with the model that will emerge from the subsequent discussion as to the relative importance of an adsorbed C5cyclic intermediate as a function of catalyst structure. The use of 'V-labeled reactant molecules for mechanistic studies has recently been extended to reactions of the hexanes by Gault and his collaborators (84, 81, 115), using 0.2%, 10% platinum/alumina, as will as platinum film catalysts. The results are quite strongly dependent on the type of catalyst used. The results, which indicate the proportions of the TABLE IV Isomer Distributions in Initial Products from Hydrogenolysis of Methylcyclopentane and from Isomerizalion of Hexanes over Platinum Catalysts" Reactant hydrocarbon Catalyst
MCPb n-H 2-MP/3-MP ratio
Ultrathin Pt film, 0.02 p g om-2 2.44 (273°C)" Ultrathin Pt film, 0.13 pg cm-2 -2.7 (273°C)c 0.274 Platinum/alumina (300°C)" 2.20 10% Platinum/alumina (270°C)" 3.3 Thick fringe-free polycrystalline P t films, deposited 28O0-30O0C (273°C)" 1.90
MCP
2-MP
3-MP/n-H ratio
2.61
0.80 0.67
2.18 2.20
-0.6 0.55 0.55 3.1 4.5
-
2.05
12
5.3
MCP
3-MP
_______ 2-MP/n-H ratio
1.95
-
-1.6 1.41 1.10 1.10 10.3 16
23
5.1
Data: film catalysts (SO);platinum/alumina catalysts (113, 116, 84). MCP = methylcyclopentane; 2-MP = 2-methylpentane; 3-MP = 3-methylpentane; n-H = n-hexane. Reaction temperature. a
METAL CATALYZED SKELETAL REACTIONS OF HYDROCARBONS
39
various isotopically labeled isomerization products, are contained in Tables V, VI, and VII. Referring first of all to the reactions over 0.2% platinum/alumina (Table V) the major features of the product distributions may be explained by a simple reaction via an adsorbed C5 cyclic intermediate. For instance, if reaction had proceeded entirely by this path, 2-methylpentane-2-13C would have yielded 3-methylpentane labeled 100% in the 3-position (instead of 73.4%) and would have yielded n-hexane labeled 100% in the 2-position (instead of 90.2%). Similarly, 3-methylpentane-2-13C would have yielded a 2-methylpentane labeled 50% in the methyl substituent (instead of 42.6%), and would have yielded n-hexane labeled 50% in the 1-and 3-positions (instead of 43.8 and 49% respectively). The other expectations are very easily assessed in a similar manner. On the whole, the data of Table V lead to the conclusion that some 80% or so of the reacting hydrocarbon reacts via a simple one step process via an adsorbed C5 cyclic intermediate. The departures from the distribution expected for this simple process are accounted for by the occurrence of bond shift processes. It is necessary to propose that more than one process (adsorbed Cg cyclic intermediate or bond shift) may occur within a single overall residence period on the catalyst; Gault’s analysis leads to the need for a maximum of three. The number of possible combinations is large, but limitations are imposed by the nature of the observed product distributions. If we designate a bond shift process by B, and passage via an adsorbed (3.5 cyclic intermediate by C, the required reaction paths are C (dominant reaction), B, CB, BB, BC, BCB, CBB, BBB where CB, for instance, means reaction via a C process followed by a B process without intervening desorption. These all represent parallel reaction pathways. Even so, not all possible bond shifts occur and, in particular, the ones that are absent include those leading to a 2,3-dimethylbutane skeleton (an insignificant type of reaction product), as well as those which convert between 2-methylpentane and n-hexane skeletons (a conclusion from the distribution of the labeled isomers). Unlike the behavior over 0.2% platinum/alumina, the main features of the labeled product distributions obtained over 10% platinum/alumina and over platinum film catalysts (Tables VI and VII respectively) cannot be explained in terms of a single dominant reaction pathway via an adsorbed C5 cyclic intermediate. Again, parallel, multiple-step reaction pathways are involved. The results from 2-methylpentane-2-13C have been qualitatively accounted for (84) by the pathways
C, B, CB, BC, BCB.
TABLE V Proportions of Isotopically Labeled Products from Isomerizaiion of Hexanes over 0.2% Platinum/Alumim Catalyst at B7S°Ca Initial products (mole percent) 3-methylpentanes
2-methylpentanes
n-hexanes
Reactant hydrocarbon
n/v 4.1
73.4
22.5
-
-
-
9.8
90.2
0
49.4
4.9
45.7
-
-
-
68.5
4.3
27.2
L
5.9
1.4
92.7
-
-
-
-
-
-
r
-
-
-
1.3
90.8
7.9
-
-
-
"r
-
-
-
42.6
50.0
7.4
43.8
7.2
49.0
v
-
-
-
7.5
0
92.5
-
-
-
AA
LA
a
fw
Corolleur, Corolleur, and Gault (81).
METAL CATALYZED SKELETAL REACTIONS OF HYDROCARBONS
41
TABLE VII Proportions of Isotopically Labeled Producta from Zsomerizatiun of 8-Methylpentane-8-13C over Thick Polycrystalline Platinum Films at 87S"Ca Initial productsb(mole percent) ?
3-methylpentanes Reactant hydrocarbon
/L Corolleur (84).
T
n-hexanes
Y T+T
Arv
F
hr\/
w
63-64
17-18
P
3M z
0-2
57-61
3W1
20
METAL CATALYZED SKELETAL REACTIONS OF HYDROCARBONS
43
A more detailed analysis of the results obtained over 10% platinum] alumina (115) leads to an extended array of parallel, multistep reaction paths, and it was concluded (for 273°C) that a n adsorbed species had a chance of reacting via an adsorbed CS cyclic intermediate of about 0.3, of reacting via a bond shift of about 0.2, and a chance of desorption of about 0.5. One would expect these probabilities to be temperature dependent, but to different extents, so that the nature of the product distributions should also be temperature dependent. An immediate conclusion from this work with the 13C-labeled hexanes is that the reaction is strongly dependent on catalyst structure. This conclusion is also evident from the product distribution data summarized in Table VIII. With 0.2 and 10% platinum/alumina catalysts [inert alumina (116)1,the former gave considerably greater proportions of cyclic reaction products than the latter. With the film catalysts, the ultrathin films gave greater proportions of cyclic products than fringe-free thick films, and within the ultrathin films the proportion of cyclic products decreased with increasing average platinum particle size. Inasmuch as one expects the average platinum particle size to be greater with 10% than with 0.2% platinum/alumina, all of these results are consistent. It was previously argued (28) that an enhanced proportion of methylcyclopentane indicated an enhanced formation of adsorbed C5 cyclic reaction intermediate, suggesting that reaction pathways via the latter are more important the smaller the average platinum particle size. This argument assumes, of course, that the ease of product desorption is not too different on the various catalysts. The proportion of cyclic product varies more strongly with particle size from n-hexane reactant than from 2- or 3-methylpentane. (The failure reported previously (28) to observe a dependence on average platinum particle size of the proportion of cyclic product from 2-methylpentane when using ultrathin films, was due to a failure to use films of sufficiently low mass per unit substrate area.) That ultrathin platinum films favor reaction via an adsorbed C5 cyclic intermediate agrees with preliminary results (134) from reaction of 2-methylpentane-2-13C on ultrathin and thick films. The same trend with particle size was reported (115) for this reaction with supported catalysts. Work with ultrathin and thick fringe-free platinum films has shown that not only does the product distribution change with catalyst structure, but the specific rate of raction (per unit platinum area) changes also (SO). The data in Fig. 12 for the reaction of 2-methylpentane and n-hexane show a decrease in the specific rate with increasing particle size. Other work has been reported in the literature on the influence of platinum particle size (in supported catalysts) on isomerization and dehydrocyclization reactions. However, the reaction conditions tend to vary widely
TABLE VIII Distribution of CsReaction Products from Hexanes over Platinum Catalysts Proportion of cyclic product (mole C H + B percent) Reference
Reaction temperature ("C)
2-MPb
3-MP
n-Hexane 0.8% Pt/silica 0.2% Pt/alumina 10% Pt/alumina ultrathin Pt film, 0.02 pg cm-2 ( < i5A)d ultrathin Pt film, 0.13 pg cm-2 (20A)d ultrathin Pt film, 0.5 pg cm-2 (38b)d thick polycrystalline Pt 6lms,c deposited 0°C thick fringe-free polycrystalline Pt' films deposited 275"-30O0C
295 303 298 273 273 273 273
46c 55 62 4.7 8.7 14.5 28
20 31 1.8 4.0 5.0 13
25 7.3 77 79 75 46
8.3 5.5 13
25 7.3 93 87 81 59
273
33
17
30
20
50
2-Methyl- 0.8% Pt/silica pentane 0.2% Pt/alumina 10% Pt/alumina ultrathin Pt film,0.02 pg cm-2 (
295 301 297 273 273 273 273
66' 30 47 4.2 5.7 9.0 20
34 37 25 90
Reactant hydrocarbon
Catalyst
Initial product distributiona (mole percent)
-
-
-
n-H
MCP 54
81
72 76
-
16
-
54
34 37 25 90 81 72
76
3-Methyl- 0.8y0Pt/silica pentane 0.2% Pt/alumina 10% Pt/alumina ultrathin Pt film, 0.13 pg cm-* (201L)d ultrathin Pt film, 0.6 pg cm-e (40A)d thick fringe-free polycrystalline Pte films, deposited 280°C
295 303 298 273 273 273
790 58 76 12 24 37
-
-
-
22 17
8.5 12 7.3
-
21 20 6.5 79 64 55
Product from Zmethylpentane over film catalysts also contain up to 1%2,3-dimethylbutane. 2-MP = 2-methylpentane; 3-MP = 3-methylpentane; n-H = n-hexane; CH = cyclohexane; B c 2-MP plus 3-MP. d Average Pt particle diameter. Average for a number of experiments. f 3-MP plus n-H. 0 Z M P plus n-H.
-
-
-
7Ee5 64 55
110 84
}
84
K
M 4 50
k D
c)
$
5
b
21 20
=
benzene.
3 ti U
F M 4
k
46
J R. ANDERSON
.
500 0
.
400
0
I
300
0
.*
. .
200
0
0
100 0 0
0
FIG.12. Variation with average platinum particle diameter of the initial rate of reaction (isomerisation plus dehydrocyclization) of n-hexane (-@-) and 2-methylpentane (-0-) over ultrathin film catalysts a t 275°C. Hydrogen/reactant hydrocarbon, 10/1; total reactant pressure 100 Torr.
so that a useful comparison is difficult. Maat and Moscou (31) varied the average platinum particle diameter in the range 10-450 A by sintering a t 780°C : the catalyst was 0.6% platinum/alumina and contained (nominally) 0 5 0 . 7 % chlorine. The reaction of n-heptane was studied at 500°C and an increased platinum particle size resulted in an increased relative proportion of dehydrocyclization and reduced isomerization. However, this catalyst almost certainly had some dual-function character due to an acidic alumina. On the other hand, Dautzenberg and Platteeuw (133) studied the reaction of n-hexane and 2-methylpentane over a 0.5% platinum/ alumina catalyst in which the average platinum particle diameter was varied in the range 15-50 8 by sintering at 500"-650°C; the catalysts were chlorine free and reactions were carried out, at 440"-490 "C. No dependence of product distribution or specific reaction rate on average particle size was found. When one considers the various results from the reactions of labeled and unlabeled hexanes over supported catalysts and over thick and ultrathin films, the conclusion emerges that catalysts with very small platinum particles (ultrathin films or 0.20/, platinum/alumina) strongly favor reactions via an adsorbed Cs cyclic intermediate, but at large particle size
METAL CATALYZED SKELETAL REACTIONS O F HYDROCARBONS
47
(thick films or 10% platinum/alumina) bond shift processes are of increased importance, although the cyclic intermediate appears never to become of insignificant importance, a t least with the catalysts that are currently available. It will be clear from the bond shift mechanism which was discussed in Section IV.A.l that the required catalytic site is either two or three adjacent surface platinum atoms, and that three adjacent atoms (as occurs, for instance, on a (111) crystal face) is the preferred type of site for isomeriaation from a iso-hydrocarbon structure. Furthermore, since bond shift is favored by partial electron transfer from the adsorbed residue to the metal, these sites can be expected to be the most effective when they occur on low index platinum surface planes with high work functions. If one were dealing with crystallites of simple geometrically ideal shapes, and for which only the size was a variable, the proportion of surface atom! existing in crystal faces would not change very much for diameters > 15A since, even a t 15A this proportion is already high ( 4 0 % ) . However, catalysts with differing thermal histories would undoubtedly have differing degrees of crystalline nonideality, as well as possibly having differing average crystalline sizes. The higher the temperature of thermal treatment, the higher would be the proportion of low index planes in the surface. This behavior has been made use of by Boudart et al. (121) with supported platinum catalysts sintered a t various temperatures in the range 425”900°C.
The possible effects of particle size per se on the ease of “bond shift” is rather uncertain. Electron removal is expected to be more difficult from very small clusters of only a few atoms than from large crystals. Surface geometric factors aside, one might expect more extensive electron transfer from an adsorbed residue to the metal with such a cluster particle. However, the ease of electron removal is influenced both intrinsically by the particle size, and also by the surface geometry, so predictions are hazardous. The results of Anderson and Shimoyama (135) with hexanes over ultrathin films cannot be reconciled with a strong change in the specific bond shift rate with increasing platinum particle size, and these authors concluded that, in the light of such limited data as were available, it is best to assume that this rate is approximately independent of particle size. A study of the bond shift reaction with neopentane over ultrathin film catalysts would probably offer the best hope for further illuminating this question. Our conclusion regarding the importance of reaction via a n adsorbed carbocyclic intermediate, together with the data in Fig. 12, lead to the conclusion that over ultrathin film catalysts, the specific rate of isomerization via the carbocyclic pathway decreases as the average platinum particle
48
J. R . ANDERSON
size increases. It was previously suggested (28) that reaction via an adsorbed Cscyclic intermediate occurs preferentially (but not necessarily) a t a platinum atom of low coordination to other platinum atoms, such as a corner atom in a crystal. The proportion of corner atoms decreases rapidly as the crystallite size increases. The exact behavior depends on the assumed crystallite geometry. However, assuming geometrically simple and ideal crystallite shapes, the proportion of surface atoms existing in corner positions falls from the region of 20% to about 1% or so, for an increase in crystallite diameter from roughly 15 to 40 A. It is thus obviously tempting to associate the fall in isomerization rate via a carbocyclic intermediate with the decrease in the proportion of corner atoms. In fact this decrease in the proportion of corner atoms with increasing size is of the same order as the decrease in specific rate. However, there are other factors which, in principle, cannot be ignored, but the magnitude of whose effects is at present unknown. One question is the way in which the proportion of surface atoms with low coordination in real crystallites (as opposed to ideal crystallites) varies with crystallite size. It would be reasonable to suppose that real crystallites would have a higher proportion of atoms in low coordination positions than ideal crystallites. However, the relative magnitude of this surplus could itself depend on crystallite size, and if it decreased with decreasing size the overall result would be to offset the trend expected from considerations based on ideal crystallites. The extent to which this sort of compensation occurs might be dependent on the temperatures used in catalyst preparation. It is interesting that those catalysts which have clearly shown a dependence of product distribution and specific rate on average platinum particle size were not subjected to high temperatures ( >3OO0C) during preparation, while the catalysts used by Dautzenberg and Platteeuw (133) which showed no such particle size dependence were subjected to high-temperature treatment. I n this less than satisfactory situation it would obviously be desirable to find an independent way of assessing the detailed fine structure of the metal surface in highly dispersed metal catalysts. However, with particles of interest in the diameter range 15-50 A, there does not seem much hope of achieving this with currently available electron (or scanning) microscopic techniques. One is probably left with the interpretation of reaction pathways themselves as the only available indicator of surface structure. In addition, one cannot discount the possibility that the catalytic activity of a surface site of specified geometry may change with particle size as a result of changing electronic properties of the metal. Several mechanisms for ring closure a t a catalyst site consisting of a single metal atom have been suggested. Shephard and Rooney (156) pro-
METAL CATALYZED SKELETAL REACTIONS OF HYDROCARBONS
49
posed the two alternatives (11) and (12) based on
analogous processes in organometallic chemistry. Alternatively, Barron et al. have suggested
These types of mechanisms would be generally applicable provided the required dehydrogenation is possible. Muller (130) has recently shown that the dehydrocyclization of 2,2,4,4tetramethylpentane t o 1,1,3,3-tetramethylcyclopentaneoccurs on thick polycrystalline platinum film catalysts with a rate that is comparable to the formation of 1,1,3-trimethyIcyclopentane from 1,2,2-trimethylpentane. As Muller points out, reactions (10)-(12) cannot occur from 2,2,4,44etramethypentane,and it is clear that either these mechanisms are inadequate, or a t least there must be an alternative mechanism available. Muller suggests mechanism (14) which requires two adjacent platinum sites. HC
FH2
II
Pt
Pt ( L)
-
HC-CH, I
Pt
Pt
(MI
50
J. R. ANDERSON
Alternatively, it is of course possible to formulate this using only a single platinum atom
If mechanism (14) is correct, it is to be expected that the cyclization of this reactant should not be affected by a change in platinum particle size, while the converse should be true if reaction (15) occurs. This has not yet been checked experimentally. There is now a large body of data from r-olefin and/or r-ally1 coordination chemistry which relates to C-C bond-forming reactions, and which can therefore be used to suggest mechanistic models for ring closure. Much of this data has recently been summarized (137-139) : C-C bond-forming reactions similar in type to those used in rcactions (11) and (12) are well known, and this is particularly true for reaction (11) which amounts to a r-olefin ligand insertion reaction. In addition there are also known various C-C bond-forming processes involving reaction between two 7-ally1 ligands, or between a r-olefin and a r-ally1 ligand. However, for the present purpose there is little point in further proliferation of mechanistic speculation; the important point is that there is good evidence to support the belief that a single metal atom can act as a catalytic center for C-C bond formation leading to ring closure, provided prior dehydrogenation t o suitable r-olefin and/or r-ally1 adsorbed (coordinated) species occurs. The reverse of these ring closure reactions can obviously result in ring opening. In the case of reactions (11)-(13) the position of opening can be different to that of closure. A shift in the position of bonding of species (G), (I), and ( K ) to the catalyst may be needed, but this should be easy. Reaction (13) would not allow ring closure or opening a t a carbon atom carrying two (gem) methyl groups. In fact, hydrogenolytic ring opening with 1,l-dimethylcyclopentane on a platinum/carbon catalyst shows a low propensity for ring opening adjacent to the quaternary carbon atom [cf. Newham’s (1.60) summary of Kazanskii’s data]. However, this does not rule out reactions (11) and (12) since the reason could also be a purely steric one. The reactions (11)-( 13) required dehydrogenation to olcfinictype species. At the temperatures required for skeletal isomerization over platinum, this is a rapid process, as is the reverse hydrogenation step; neither can be rate limiting for skeletal rearrangement reactions. There is a good deal of evidence (e.g., 109, 141, 14.2, 136) that equilibrium with
METAL CATALYZED SKELETAL REACTIONS O F HYDROCARBONS
51
respect to olefin formation is reached : however, whether olefin is experimentally detectable depends on the conditions of temperature and pressure (particularly hydrogen partial pressure). Thus, for instance, in the reaction of the Cd and CSalkanes on platinum film catalysts a t 260"-310°C with a hydrogen/hydrocarbon ratio of 1211, no olefins could be detected down to the limit of GPC analysis, although they became detectable a t lower hydrogen partial pressures. Since this reaction is relatively rapid, the rate of skeletal isomerization is independent of whether the starting material is alkane or alkene (143). Bearing in mind the comment made earlier that dissociative adsorption and desorption processes are relatively fast, one concludes that the rate of isomerization must be controlled by the step in which the C-C bond is either formed or ruptured in the formation or destruction of the cyclic reaction intermediate. However, if ring closure were slow and ring opening fast, the steady state concentration of cyclic intermediate would be very low, so that one should be unable to detect the presence of the corresponding cyclic reaction product resulting from desorption. In fact, of course, sizeable amounts of this product are formed, so it is reasonable to conclude that the slow step is that in which the C-C bond is broken in the cyclic intermediate. It is interesting to compare this conclusion with the activation energies observed on platinum/ carbon catalysts of about 35 kcal mole-' for ring opening from cyclopentane, and about 20 kcal mole-' for the C5-dehydrocyclization of various aliphatic hydrocarbons (144). The latter has also been reported as a zero-order process in hydrocarbon pressure (144). On the present model if one had a reaction path of the type BC, and if the steps B and C each occurred on its optimum type of catalytic site, a reacting entity would have to be transferred between a site on a crystallite face to a single corner atom site. This transfer could occur via physically adsorbed reactant, or possibly by a migration of a chemisorbed molecule involving interconversions between species bound to the surface a t one and then a t two carbon atoms. In a multistep process such as this, involving transfer between different catalyst sites, the pore structure of a supported catalyst may be of great importance. For instance, if transfer between sites occurs via a physically adsorbed layer, this transport is competitive with desorption and the relative importance of these processes will depend on pore structure. This is analogous to the influence of pore structure on exchange kinetics recently discussed by Dwyer et al. (146). In any case, an effect of this type may well contribute to the variability in product distribution that can occur in the reaction of saturated hydrocarbons over platinum catalysts with varying types of (inert) supports (84) and it represents an effect which is additional to the influence of the variability in the surface structure of the platinum crystals.
52
J. R. ANDERSON
Although 2,3-dimethylbutane is never a major isomerization product from the other hexanes, it is sometimes produced in nonnegligible amounts. It is, however, highly variable. Thus, over platinum/alumina catalysts, only very small amounts (>1-2%) are obtained. I n many cases with platinum films it is also a negligible product, although instances have been reported (113) when it was an appreciable product. As with neohexane, it seems likely that it may well be formed a t impurity generated surface sites. 2 ,&dimethylbutane itself undergoes isomerization less readily than do the methylpentanes, n-hexane or neopentane. For geometric reasons, 2,3-dimethylbutane would be limited in its available reaction paths to bond shift and an adsorbed C4 cyclic intermediate. The relative inactivity suggests that a Cq cyclic intermediate cannot be formed as readily as a C5, and this aggrees with other evidence obtained from the reactions of 2(methyl-13C)-3-methylbutane and 2 ,3-dimethylbutane-2-13C and n-pentane-l-13C (84)that C, cyclic is of little importance. This is also a conclusion to be expected from the ring energies represented in Fig. 10. It is not apparent why bond shift with 2,3-dimethylbutane should be more difficult than with neohexane or, say, isobutane. It will be clear from the results so far presented that both C5 and c6 dehydrocyclization products can be formed, with aromatization proceeding (one would expect) by further dehydrogenation of the initially formed c 6 ring-closure species. There is another pathway for the production of aromatics based upon cyclization of a linear triene (133), but this is of relatively small importance, and is only significant a t all a t quite high temperatures and low hydrogen partial pressures. If the temperature is low enough, the extent to which the cyclic-CS product consists of aromatic rather than cycloalkane, can be thermodynamically dictated. Thus for reaction (16) the equilibrium constants a t cyclohexane (g) Fr! benzene (g)
+ 3 Hz (g)
(16)
550°K (277°C) and 650°K are 0.63 and lo3 atm13respectively. Above about 350°C the equilibrium constants for this type of reaction are such that the aromatic is always highly favored thermodynamically over the corresponding cycloalkane. Moreover, olefin which is itself capable of further dehydrogenation to an aromatic (e.g., cyclohexme) is never observed in significant amounts under isomerization conditions. In work under very mild reaction conditions ( <300"C) cyclic C5 products always strongly predominate over cyclic c6 products. This is kinetic rather than thermodynamic in origin, since a t 277°C and starting with a reaction mixture containing 50 Torr hydrogen and 5 Torr n-hexane, for instance, equilibrium in the formation of methylcyclopentane would yield 1.86 Torr of the latter, in benzene 4.99 Torr, and in cyclohexane 0.59 Torr
METAL CATALYZED SKELETAL REACTIONS O F HYDROCARBONS
53
(API Project 44 thermochemical data). I n fact, the proportion of ( 2 6 product observed under these conditions over various platinum film catalysts tends to be rather irreproducible for reasons that are not a t all apparent; it is probably associated with some variable feature of catalyst surface structure. The question arises as to whether the cyclization reaction paths to C5 and C6 products are related, or whether they occur independently. For instance, although n-hexane could cyclize directly to either a C5 or a c6 ring, direct cyclization of 2- or 3-methylpentane could only yield a C6 ring, and a C6 ring would have to be formed either by prior isomerization of the reactant to a linear chain, or by cyclization to a C5ring (with methylcyclopentane skeleton) followed by ring enlargement. I n fact, in experiments over a variety of ultrathin and thick platinum film catalysts, at 270"-280°C cyclohexane and benzene were never detected in any more than very small amounts in the initial reaction products from 2- and 3-methylpentane, although substantial amounts were formed from n-hexane (28, 30, 84, 113); the same is true for reactions on 0.2 and 10% platinum/ alumina catalysts a t similar temperatures (111). These results suggest that when a linear C6 chain is present, the formation of cyclic c6 products mainly occurs by direct ring closure. The results of Dautzenberg and Platteeuw (133) on the reaction of n-hexane over a platinum/alumina catalyst a t 440°C agree with this. Nevertheless a t higher temperatures, the proportion of cyclic Cs product (benzene) from 2- and 3-methylpentanes tends to increase. The prior conversion of the reactant to a linear chain can certainly occur readily since n-hexane is a substantial initial reaction product. On the other hand, one could readily conceive of ring enlargement via a bond shift process. There is a quantity of evidence that, a t least on highly dispersed (supported) platinum catalysts, the preferred route is prior conversion to a species containing a c6 linear chain. This evidence includes the distribution of aromatization products from a variety of alkanes (121,146) as well as some kinetic data and the distribution of aromatic products from some polymethylcycloalkanes (133). Neverthcless, the data do not conclusively exclude ring closure to a Cg ring followed by ring enlargement as a contributing reaction path, even if albeit a minor one. There is no doubt that, under suitable circumstances, ring enlargement by a bond shift reaction can occur. Thus, Muller and Gault (119) have studied the reaction of 1,1,3-trimethylcyclopentane over thick platinum film catalysts, and concluded that aromatization proceeds by ring enlargement using a bond shift process a t the gem dimethyl group. The essence of the argument is that the main product was the xylenes (presumably m- and p-) and to form these by ring opening followed by closure as two distinct processes, would require ring opening
54
J. R. ANDERSON
adjacent to the gem dimethyl group, and this is known to be difficult compared to the alternative of ring opening adjacent to the single methyl substituent ; ring closure subsequent to the latter would yield 1 , l-dimethylcyclohexane from which the main aromatic product would be toluene after monodemethylation. The route by which the adsorbed cyclic C6 species which results from ring closure is further dehydrogenated to aromatic is presumably simply the reverse of that for aromatic hydrogenation, and for this a sequential addition of hydrogen atoms seems the most probable involving r-adsorbed residues (except for the ultimate fully hydrogenated residue such as adsorbed cyclohexyl) (147, 148). Horescu and Rudenko (149) have suggested that dehydrogenation from the (adsorbed) cyclo-olefin to the aromatic may, when carried out in the absence of added hydrogen, occur via the disproportionation reaction which is rapid and is known when cyclo-olefin is used as a reactant. This sort of disproportionation is really only a hydrogen transfer between closely adsorbed cyclo-olefins. Since it is inhibited by hydrogen, it is probably not important when there is excess hydrogen present in the reaction mixture. A pair of gem substituents in a c6 ring would, of course, block aromatization. In fact, Fogelberg et al. (146) found that in reaction over a platinum/ alumina catalyst at 4OO0-525"C, aromatization of 2 ,2- and 3,3-dimethylhexane did occur, but only at a considerably lower rate than the other aliphatic octanes; the rate decreased in the order octane > methylheptanes > ethylhexanes > 3,4-, 2,4-, and 2,3-dimethylhexanes > 2,2and 3,3-dimethylhexanes. Two sorts of reaction paths are possible for the aromatization of the 2,2- and 3,3-compounds. One is a bond shift process in the parent, followed by ring closure and dehydrogenation. The other is cyclization to 1,1-dimethylcyclohexane, followed by methyl group migration or removal and then dehydrogenation. Both paths probably occur. The isomerization reactions in the skeleton of the reactant prior t o aromatization clearly involve the basic processes which we have already discussed in some detail. I n passing we may note that conversion to aromatic is so favorable a t any temperature (say) >350°C that this would be, of itself, sufficient reason for an adsorbed cycbC6 intermediate to be of negligible importance compared to cyclo-Cs as a pathway for skeletal isomerization a t these temperatures. Further isomerization reactions may occur with alkyl-substituted aromatic reaction products, and a considerable study has been made of the reactions of this typc of molecule. The following are the main types of skeletal reactions involving alkyl substituents on an aromatic ring: (a) If the substituent chain is sufficiently large, there may occur within it all of the processes we have already discussed for aliphatic hydrocarbons them-
METAL CATALYZED SKELETAL REACTIONS OF HYDROCARBONS
55
selves. (b) There is the possible formation of a c6 ring fused to the aromatic ring. This entity may lead either to a bicyclo desorption product, or the c 6 ring may reopen, leading to possible isomerization. Clearly, this may also be combined with bond shift processes either prior to ring closure, or subsequent to reopening. (c) A fused Ca ring may be formed and this will generally be rapidly dehydrogenated to a fused aromatic ring. An extensive study of the reactions of the alkyl-benzenes has been made by Csicsery (150,109, 151, 141) particularly with C4 and Cg substituents and by Shephard and Rooney (136). For example the reaction of n-butylbenzene was studied (109) on a 2% platinum/silica gel catalyst a t 316"-427"C. Both methylindan (Q) (together with some methylindenes) and naphthalene (P) are major products, with the former in rather larger amounts,
and no tetraline could be detected. The activation energy for the formation of naphthalene is considerably higher than for methylindan, the difference being 8-10 kcal mole-' (109, 152): Csicsery's data for the temperature range 310"-400°C are about 43 and 33 kcal mole-', respectively. This latter figure may be compared with about 28 kcal mole-' reported by Liberman et al. (153) for a similar reaction over platinum/carbon catalysts. Although the formation of naphthalene involves ring closure with a primary carbon atom, while methylindan involves a secondary carbon atom, this is not the reason for the difference in rates, since methylindan is formed with about the same ease from n-butylbenzene as is indan from n-propylbenzene. It appears that the rates may be desorption controlled, and this would be in agreement with a previous conclusion (154) reached for the dehydrogenation of methylcyclohexane over a platinum/alumina catalyst at 3 15'-372"C. The possible isomerization products from ring opening in a n adsorbed
56
J. R. ANDERSON
intermediate with the methylindan skcleton are sec-butylbenzene (R) , 1,2-diethylbenxene (S) and l-methyl-2-isopropylbenzene (T), Of these, (S) is totally absent from the reaction products, while (T) is never more than a very minor product. On the other hand, (R) is produced in substantial amounts and one must conclude that opening in the fused Cs ring is strongly favored in a position adjacent to the benzene ring. Isobutylbenzene (U) is also produced in amounts somewhat in excess of sec-butylbenzene and this cannot be formed via a Cg carbocyclic route; it is no doubt a product of a bond shift reaction
from the parent. A portion of the sec-butylbenzene is also probably produced via a bond shift process. The picture which emerges from Csicsery’s work with n-butylbenzene is fully confirmed by a study with n-pentylbenzene and 2-phenylpentane (141). In the case of n-pentylbenzene, phenylcyclopentane is an additional type of product, and this, as an adsorbed species, provides a further route for isomerization in the chain. Aromatization from n-pentylbenzene yields l-methylnaphthalene and over platinum/silica the rate of conversion of this to 2-methylnaphthalene is extremely slow; this is probably a conclusion general t o all alkyl substituents on an aromatic ring, since it is substantiated by the work of Fogelberg et al. (146) on the aromatization of Cs aliphatics. Ring closure between an adjacent pair of aromatic substituents is also possible; an example is the formation of indan from l-methyl-2-ethylbenzene (11,109).I n fact, Csicsery (109) found that the rate of cyclization of l-methyl-2-ethylbenzene to indan over platinum was somewhat faster than that of n-butylbenzene to methylindan, indicating that kinetically there is nothing to be gained by having ring closure a t an aromatic carbon atom. Silvestri, Naro, and Smith (142) have shown that cyclization reactions are strongly poisoned by adsorbed sulfur, although the activity for olefin formation was not much affected. This agrees with the conclusions of Shephard and Rooney (136).
METAL CATALYZED SKELETAL REACTIONS OF HYDROCARBONS
57
3. Increase in Carbon Number There are instances of reactions over platinum catalysts leading to the formation of some products with a higher carbon number than the parent. Thus Csicsery and Burnett (150) have reported the formation of small smounts of diethylbenzene, l-methyl-2-isopropylbenzene, l-methyl-2-npropylbenzene and 1,4-dimethy1-2-ethylbenzene from the reaction of 1-methyl-2-ethylbenzene over a 2% platinum/silica catalyst a t 400°C. Methyl groups appear to be added practically in any position on the parent with equal probability. Csicsery and Burnett suggested that these products are formed by a reaction between adsorbed parent molecules and methyl radicals ( .CHr). We consider that this is unlikely, since it seems very unlikely that a methyl radical (with an unpaired electron) could have a sufficient lifetime on a metal surface; it would be converted very rapidly to a covalently bonded species, and it is by no means clear how these radicals might be formed in the first place. A number of similar cases have been reported by Shuikin (224) in the reactions of cycloalkanes on a variety of supported platinum catalysts, the supports including silica, alumina, and carbon. Typical reaction conditions were 460"C, -20 atm pressure. Instances include the occurrence of methylcyclopentane, toluene, and xylenes in the reaction of cyclopentane, and analogous processes from reactants such as methylcyclopentane, ethylcyclopentane, methylcyclohexane, and ethylcyclohexane. Shuikin suggested a mechanism in which an adsorbed species reacted with an adsorbed CH2 residue, the latter having been generated by hydrogenolytic fragmentation of the parent; for instance
Of course, a proposal such as (17) is not without its difficulties. At 460°C and 1 atm pressure, the reaction CHd (g)
+ cyclo-CsHio
(g) ---t cyclo-CJh-CHa
k) + Hz (g)
(18)
is accompanied by a standard free energy change AGO of 4-11.6 kcal mole-'. Thus, in order to make reasonably favorable a process which results in the enlargement of carbon number by reaction with a Cl residue such as CH2(,),one has to find a way of coupling the bond forming reaction with some other reaction which is highly favorable thermodynamically. One general sort of possibility is that, rather than the bond forming process involving a discrete C1 residue as in (17) the new bond is formed in some
58
J. R. ANDERSON
cooperative way as one or more other C-C bonds are being broken. We have no information on how this might occur in a mechanistic sense, but in overall thermodynamic terms, one should note that the AGO value for reaction (19) at 460°C CZHo (g)
+ ~y~10-CsHio (g)
-+
c~c~o-C~TQ-CHI(g)
+ CHI (g)
(19)
is -5.3 kcal mole-'. If C-C bond rupture in ethane progresses by way of a 1-2 adsorbed intermediate, one could propose that (19) resulted from attack on this intermediate by an adsorbed cyclopentane species; in the sense in which we are looking a t these reactions, one would expect adsorbed Cz residues to be present on the surface (along with others) as a result of fragmentation reactions in the parent hydrocarbon. These reactions involving an increase in carbon number from alkane or cycloalkane reactants are very poorly understood and warrant further study, possibly by the use of isotopic labeling. 4. Dehydrocyclodimerization We have seen how an alkane may be converted into an aromatic by cyclization requiring the formation of a single C-C bond, followed by dehydrogenation. In principle it should be possible for cyclization to occur as a result of forming two C-C bonds, again followed by dehydrogenation to an aromatic. The overall reaction can be thermodynamically favorable, as the following data quoted by Csicsery (166) show. For the reaction 2 iso-C4H10 (9)
-+
?CsHa(CH&
(g)
+ 5 H2 (9)
(20)
the equilibrium constant a t 427°C is 16.23 atm4 and is 1.23 X lo4 atm4 at 527°C. Csicsery has termed this type of reaction dehydrocyclodimerization. Although it occurred to an enhanced extent on supported platinum catalysts in which the support had acidic properties, the reaction was still quite substantial on platinum/inert alumina. Our immediate concern is with nonacidic catalysts. Because the equilibrium concentration of aromatics is inversely proportional to the fifth power of the hydrogen concentration, the reaction is carried out without dilution by added hydrogen. However, under these conditions, the rate of catalyst deactivation due to coking is high, and frequent regeneration is required for process operation. I n addition to the aromatic product from the dimerization of the parent, a wide range of other products are also produced as a result of fragmentation, isomerization, and dehydrogenation reactions. Csicsery has also examined similar reactions with propane and pentane, as well as the butanes, and showed that the aromatic yield increases with increasing carbon number in the reactant. It was also shown that, using butanes as
METAL CATALYZED SKELETAL REACTIONS OF HYDROCARBONS
59
reactant, there occurred the expected rapid dehydrogenation t o butenes, and that the latter reach a maximum at quite low reactant residence times, while the concentration of aromatics in the reactor output increased more slowly with increasing residence time. Csicsery points out that this behavior is consistent with the olefin being a reaction precursor for dimirezation. This is generally consistent with the mechanism suggested here, which is that bond formation in dimerization (at least on nonacidic catalysts) occurs essentially by reactions of the type described by reactions such as (11)-( 13). B. REACTIONS ON METALS OTHERTHAN PLATINUM Platinum is by far the most active metal yet found for skeletal isomerization as judged by its selectivity for this reaction versus hydrogenolysis. Nevertheless, isomerization activity has been reported for some other metals; namely, palladium, gold, iridium, tungsten, and ruthenium. All of these (except ruthenium) have had demonstrated some activity for bond shift reactions. Thick polycrystalline films of tungsten (68) and palladium (24) have been found to produce small amounts of isomer from n-butane and isobutane reactant in the region of 150°C; however most of the reaction (>95%) led to hydrogenolysis. Boudart and Ptak (122) have reported that among all the metals of group VIII plus copper and gold, which they tested for neopentane isomerization, only iridium ( 18O0-2OO"C) and gold (440"-480°C) were active in addition to platinum. They studied this reaction in a flow system, using gold as an unsupported powder, and a 10% iridium/silica supported catalyst. The selectivity on iridium and gold for bond shift found in this work was, although a good deal lower than on platinum, still very appreciable (-15% for Ir, -18% for Au, and -9Oo/, for P t ) . It is interesting that Anderson and Avery (24) could not detect any isomerization products from reaction over a thick iridium film. As Boudart and Ptak suggested, this difference may be a result of the use of a static reaction system with evaporated films compared with a flow system with the supported catalyst. However, we believe a more likely reason is an actual difference in the nature of the catalyst surfaces. From the comments made in earlier sections concerning the nature of the surface of supported catalysts, one would expect the surface of the supported iridium to carry a greater concentration of adsorbed contaminant than the surface of the evaporated film, and it is very probable that the effect of this would have been to diminish the rate of hydrogenolysis (v.i.) . The activity of gold for both the hydrogenolysis and isomerization of neopentane reported by Boudart and Ptak is remarkable because gold (as evaporated films) is inactive for exchange between aliphatic hydrocarbons and
60
J. R. ANDERSON
deuterium, and no chemisorption of aliphatic hydrocarbons on the surface of clean gold has been detected. At the moment we are unable to offer a a conclusive explanation for this apparent conflct in the behavior of gold surfaces. Nevertheless it is worth considering the possibility that the activity observed by Boudart and Ptak had its origin in surface impurity. The gold powder used by these workers was 99.99yo pure, and was extensively reduced at 500°C in hydrogen before use. However, it is possible that the activity might have resulted from the segregation of some active transition metal impurity at the surface of the gold particles. Since it is known (156) that the lack of chemisorptive activity of gold as a barrier to catalytic activity can be overcome if molecular species are dissociated first, prior to their presentation to the gold surface, it is possible that the impurity on the gold surface may serve as a site for dissociative adsorption, the species then being transferred to the gold surface. Kikuchi et al. (123) failed to detect isomerization products from n-pentane over silicasupported iron, cobalt, nickel, ruthenium, rhodium, and iridium, or over carbon-supported ruthenium and rhodium. Of these metals, other work (122, 157) has shown that rhodium, ruthenium, and iridium possess some isomerization activity. It is reasonable to suppose that this result by Kikuchi et al. stems from the relatively high hydrogen partial pressures used, which were generally > 5 atm (cf. Table 111). The activity of metals other than platinum for skeletal reactions of larger molecules is not well documented, particularly in a mechanistic sense. Carter, Cusumano, and Sinfelt (157) have recently studied the reaction of n-heptane on a series of group VIII metals in the form of hydrogen-reduced (300°C) metal powders. The nature of the reaction pathways is summarized in Table IX. Although many metals have been TABLE IX Reaction of n-Heptane over Reduced Metal Powdersa Percentage of reaction
Catalyst Platinum Palladium Rhodium Ruthenium Iridium a
Reaction temperature ("C)
Hydrogenolysis Isomeriaation
275 300 113 88 125
Carter, Cusumano, and Sinfelt (167).
37 91 93 92.5 87
47
6 7 7.5 13
Dehydrocycliaation
16
3
-
METAL CATALYZED SKELETAL REACTIONS OF HYDROCARBONS
61
used in dual-function catalysts, there are relatively few cases studied in detail where the support is known with some confidence to be nonacidic, and where the reactions can be ascribed to the metal alone. Shuikin's review (124) mentions a number of silica-supported catalysts which have activity for skeletal isomerization and for which, by analogy with the behavior of platinum, one would expect a carbocyclic reaction path to be important. I n these instances, cyclic reaction products, including aromatics, are produced. These catalysts include the use of palladium, rhodium, and ruthenium. From Shuikin's account it appears that, as would be expected by comparison with Table IX, for rhodium and ruthenium hydrogenolysis is a very important reaction. Sinfelt, Carter, and Y a k s (157a) have studied the dehydrogenation of cyclohexane to benzene over a range of unsupported nickel/copper catalysts a t 316°C. There was a relatively small increase in specific activity on increasing the copper content from zero to about 5 at. %; following this, the activity remained constant for copper contents in the range 5-80 at. %, but it fell by a factor of about lo2on going from 80 to 100 at. % copper. It was concluded from the nature of hydrogen adsorption isotherm data that a t low copper contents the surface was considerably richer in copper than was the bulk, so that on changing the bulk concentration from zero to about 10 at. % copper, the surface composition changed from zero to about 50 at. % copper: further, from about 10 to 80 at. % copper in the bulk, the surface composition remained roughly constant a t about 50 at. copper. Clearly, the dehydrogenation activity does not parallel the nickel content of the surface, and single surface nickel atoms alone do not apparently constitute the only catalytically active dehydrogenation sites. Solymosi (158) has studied the reaction of cyclohexane over a wide range of supported nickel catalysts, and has particularly examined the influence of additives such as oxides of zinc, cadmium, and titanium, on the nature of the reaction. In the absence of additive it was reported that a t 400"-5OO"C, reaction proceeded essentially to 100% methane over catalysts variously using magnesia, alumina, or silica supports. However, by the addition of zinc oxide to any of these catalysts, hydrogenolysis was strongly suppressed, and the reaction product was reported as consisting of 8&98% benzene. The addition of cadmium oxide or titanium dioxide had a similar, but less marked, effect. Solymosi has interpreted these effects as resulting from the behavior of the additive as a dopant on the semiconducting properties of the oxide support, and that this in turn controls the electron concentration in the nickel particles which reside on the support. We are skeptical about this suggestion. For one thing, the amount of additive is enormous by comparison with the limits where the theory of impurity doping of semiconductors can be expected to be valid, while
62
J. R. ANDERSON
the expected change in electron concentration in the metal would be minute (cf. 158a) unless the particle was a cluster of only a few atoms, so the loss of only a single electron to a trap could significantly alter its electronic properties. A change in the chemical composition of the metal surface is also possible.
V. Hydrogenolysis on Metals The simplest hydrocarbon hydrogenolysis reaction is that with ethane which can yield methane as the sole reaction product. On the other hand, with larger molecules a range of reaction products is possible since the adsorbed reactant may fragment a t more than one C-C bond and, furthermore, even if only one such bond is broken in the reaction of a given molecule, the reactant will often contain more than one stereochemically distinguishable type of C-C bond. The nature of the hydrogenolysis process as revealed by the distribution of reaction products is much dependent on both the metal from which the catalyst has been prepared, and upon its structure and history. Thick metal films have been used as model catalysts for the vehavior of massive metal under conditions where adventitious surface contamination is of negligible importance. The two extremes of behavior consist, on the one hand, of total fragmentation of an adsorbed molecule to give methane as the only product, and, on the other hand, the rupture of only a single C-C bond in a reacting molecule. A comparison of the tendency for various metals, as thick film catalysts, to promote total fragmentation to methane, is available from the data of Muller (130) for the hydrogenolysis of 1 , 1 , 3 trimethylcyclopentane. This tendency is highest for cobalt (at 300°C) over which 97% of the initially reacting parent yielded methane ; with rhodium, nickel, iron (all a t 300"C), and tungsten (at 250"C), the proportion reacting to methane decreased in the listed order from 55 to 43y0; with palladium (at 320°C) and platinum (at 300°C) the proportions were 11 and Oyo,respectively. The behavior of iron was very strongly temperature dependent, and it was found that at 200°C the proportion reacting to methane was only 0.7%. Reactions over nickel films have been extensively studied, and Table X shows some typical product distributions in which the predominance of methane is evident. These data also demonstrate a tendency for the proportion of methane to increase with increasing reaction temperature, and the latter is a trend which is also apparent from the data of Kikuchi et al. (12s) for n-pentane hydrogenolysis on silica-supported iron, cobalt, and nickel catalysts. The implication of extensive fragmentation to methane is that there is little differentiation bctwecn thc reactivity of various types of C-C bonds. It will be seen from Table X that on
63
METAL CATALYZED SKELETAL REACTIONS OF HYDROCARBONS
TABLE X Initial Products from Hydrogenolysis on Thick Polycrystalline Nickel F i l m
Products (mole percent)
P r ~ p a n e223°C ,~ pro pane,^, * 273°C Neopentane,' 210°C Neopentane,a 250°C n-Hexane,b 273°C Methylcyclopentane," 200°C Neohexane,a 180°c Neohexane,a 200°C
88.0 12.0 99.4 0 . 6
-
-
87.5
9.0
3.5
-
98.7
1.3
-
-
-
-
-
94.3
3.3
1.0
0.7
0.1
0.5
0.1
-
-
80
10
10
-
32
13
5
-
16
34
80
4
3
-
5
8
Anderson and Baker (68). Shimoyama (SO).
nickel film catalysts, neohexane is the only molecule where an appreciable reactivity differentiation exists, and then only if the reaction temperature is low enough; in this case, rupture of the Csec-Cprimbond is considerably more facile than any of the other bonds in the molecule which all have a quarternary carbon atom in them. The same is true for neohexane hydrogenolysis over evaporated films of rhodium (68). Platinum is an important example of a metal where, even on an uncontaminated surface such as is offered by an evaporated film, there is a strong tendency for only one C-C bond t o be ruptured in any particular reacting molecule. On this basis, one may express the distribution of reaction products in terms of relative C-C bond rupture probabilities. Some data of this sort are contained in Table XI for thick and ultrathin film catalysts, and for comparison there are included some data for reactions on a silicasupported catalyst containing 0.8% platinum. These data all refer to reactions carried out in the presence of a large excess of hydrogen, although the results of Kikuchi et al. (12s) indicate that on platinum catalysts the position of C-C bond rupture (in n-pentane) is very little dependent on hydrogen pressure. The data in Table XI show that, on the whole, the 0.8% platinum/silica catalyst used by Matsumoto et al. (110) was inter-
TABLE XI Relative C-C 1
2
3
c-c-c-c
Bond Rupture Probabilities on Platinum Catalysts 4
1
2
3
c-c-c-c
4
1
2
3
4
c-c-c-c-c-c
I
5
6
C 6
1
2
3
c-c-c-c-c
4
5
1
2
3
c-c-c-c-c
4
5
I
I
i? 1 2 s I c-c-c-c
:
2 1
2
3
5
4
I
:
F
*
4
3M
c-c-c-c I
$:
I
E Z
Hydrocarbon n-Butane Isopentane n-Hexane
Catalyst thick polycrystalline Pt filmn thick polycrystalline Pt film. thick polycrystalline Pt film" thick fringe-free polycrystalline Pt filmb ultrathin Pt film, 0.06 pg cm-% 0.8% Pt/silica
Reaction temperature ("C)
1-2
2-3
2-5
270 280 310 273
0.33 0.38 0.34 0.24
0.33 0.38 0.14 0.12
-
0.33 0.12 0.12 0.26 0.26 0.28 -
273 295
0.13 0.16 0.12 0.17
-
0.40 0.42
Relative C-C
-
bond rupture probabilities
3 4
3-5
3 4
4-5
4-6
-
-
-
0.12
-
0.16 0.17
-
-
-
-
-
5-6 Reference
-
0.24
SO
-
0.13 0.12
110
-
24 24
34 SO
2-Methylpentane
thick fringe-free polycrystalline Pt filmb thick fringe-free polycrystalline Pt filmb ultrathin Pt film, 0.08 pg om+ 0.8% Pt/silica %Methylthick fringe-free polycrystalline pentane Pt film" ultrathin Pt film, 0.13 pg cm-2 0.8y0Pt/silica 2,3-Dimethyl- 0.8% Pt/silica butane Neohexane thick polycrystalline Pt film" 0.8% Pt/silica
b
273
0.10
0.41
-
0.43
-
-
0.03 0.03
30
325
0.08 0.51
-
0.37
-
-
0.02 0.02
30
273 295 273
0.14 0.33 0.20 0.26 0.17 0.29
-
0.25 0.32 0.29
-
- 0.14 0.14 - 0.11 0.11 0.08 0.17 -
110 90
273 295 295
0.30 0.11 - 0.11 0.22 0.21 - 0.21 0.12 0.52 0.12 0.12
0.18 0.30 0.14 0.22 0.12 -
-
110 110
286 295
0.11
-
-
68 110
0
0.89 0.76
-
-
-
0 0 0 0.08 0.08 0.08
so
SO
Deposited 0°C. Deposited 270°C.
0
66
J. R. ANDERSON
mediate in its behavior between that of massive platinum (thick films) and ultrathin films although, as would be expected, the resemblence was greater between the ultrathin film and the supported catalysts. Matsumoto et al. also examined these reactions over a 0.4% platinum/alumina catalyst a t 285°C: again the behavior fell between that for massive platinum and ultra-thin film platinum catalysts, although with n-hexane the behavior more closely resembled that of massive platinum, while with 2- and 3-methylpentane the behavior more closely resembled that of ultrathin films. In comparison with these catalysts, the behavior of platinum/ carbon is appreciably different. Thus, Matsumoto et al. (159) also studied hydrogenolysis of the hexanes over a 5% platinum/carbon catalyst a t 386"C, and there was a marked tendency to favor rupture of those C-C bonds containing a primary carbon atom (C-Cprim bonds). The only qualification here is that with neohexane, reaction was confined specifically to Cquart-Cprim bonds. A generally similar trend is also apparent from the data due to Kikuchi et al. (123) for the hydrogenolysis of n-pentane. The latter work also showed that increasing reaction temperature tends relatively to diminish fragmentation a t C-Cprim bonds, and this leads to the conclusion that the trend observed by Matsumoto et al. is not due to the difference in reaction temperature. It is difficult to escape the conclusion that the surface of a platinum/carbon catalyst is qualitatively distinguished from that of other platinum catalysts, possibly as a result of a heavy concentration of carbon on the metal surface. This is a conclusion which coincides with that already reached in a previous section devoted to catalyst structure. Bond rupture probabilities have also been reported by Myers and Munns (160) for hydrogenolysis reactions over a number of supported catalysts containing platinum in the range O.l-l%. The reactions were carried out in the region of 350'-480°C. Provided one confines the comparison to nonacidic supports, these results are in tolerable agreement with the data in Table XI. It is both interesting and important to note that, judged from the behavior of neohexane, hydrogenolysis over platinum, in contrast to nickel, strongly favors rupture of C-Cquart bonds. The mechanistic implications of this will be discussed subsequently. The work of Kikuchi et al. (123) with silica-supported catalysts also shows the high tendency of iron (370"-400"C), cobalt (330"-360OC) and nickel (330"-370°C) to catalyze fragmentation (of n-pentane) to methane. This work also showed that with cobalt and nickel, the extent of methane formation tended to decrease with increasing hydrogen partial pressure. Some data are listed in Table XII. As indicated from Table X, nickel film catalysts favor extensive frag-
METAL CATALYZED SKELETAL REACTIONS OF HYDROCARBONS
67
TABLE XI1 Variation with Hydrogen Pressure of Proportion of Methane in Products from n-pentane Hydrogenolysisa
Reaction temperature ("C)
Partial pressure of hydrogen (atm)
Proportion of methane in hydrogenolysis products (mole percent)
5%Co/silica
350
5%Ni/silica
350
5 30 5 15 30
91.1 76.1 86.6 62.5 50.0
Catalyst
Kikuchi et al. (123).
mentation to methane. However, with supported nickel catalysts other behavior is possible, and is well documented. I n particular, there is a trend with supported catalysts for successive degradation to methane plus a hydrocarbon containing one carbon atom less than the starting material (161-1635). It was shown (162) that on this type of catalyst, ease of bond rupture decreases in the sequence Csec-Cprim
> Ctert-Cprim > Cqusrt-Cprim
and indeed, any nickel catalyst is relatively inefficient for the rupture of a C-C bond containing a quarternary carbon atom. Again we note that with conventional supported nickel catalysts, it is very difficult to disentangle effects due to variations in the chemical composition of the surface. However, recent work with nickel films (SO) has shown that nickel particle size does influencc the nature of the hydrogenolysis product distribution, but only to a relatively small extent; the tendency is for extensive fragmentation to methane to be maximized with large nickel crystals (massive metal). Some comparative data are cont,ained in Table XIII. The ease of rupture of C-C bonds in the ring of cycloalkanes depends on the size of the ring and on the presence of ring substituents, as well as on the nature of the catalyst. I n general, a Ca ring reacts a t a temperature some 100" lower than a C4ring, which in turn reacts some 50°C lower than a Cs ring (cf. Table XV). These differences are undoubtedly due to the strain energy in the smaller rings. C-C bonds in Cg and CSrings approach the alkanes in their resistance to hydrogenolysis. The influence of alkyl substituents on the ease of ring hydrogenolysis depends on ring size. Thus, over a platinum/pumice catalyst a t 100°c,
TABLE XI11 Product Distributions from Hydrogenolysisof Propane and n-Hexane over Nickel Film Catalystsa Initial product distribution (mole percent)
Reactant hydrocarbon and catalyst Propane Thick fringe-free polycrystalline Ni film, deposited 275°C Thick polycrystalline Ni film, deposited O°Cb Ultrathin Ni film, 0.17 pg cm-* n-Hexane Thick fringe-free polycrystalline Ni film,deposited 275°C Ultrathin Ni film, 0.17 pg omp2
Reaction temperature ("C)
CH,
CzHs
C3Hs
273
99.4
0.6
273
99
273
n-CrHio
i-CdHlo
WCgHiz
i-CsHlz
Other total >CS
-
-
-
-
-
-
1
-
-
-
-
-
-
93.5
6.5
-
-
-
-
-
-
250
94.3
3.3
1.0
0.7
0.1
0.5
0.1
-
250
73.9
4.2
5.6
5.8
0.3
8.3
0.4
1.5
All data from Shimoyama (SO), except bAnderson and Baker (68).
Y
*
3tM 52
z
TABLE XIV Relative Bond Rupture Probabilities for Methylcyclopentane Hydrogenolysis on Platinum Catalysts 6
I
Relative C-C
Reaction temperature Catalyst Thick fringe-free polycrystalline Pt filma Thick polycrystalline Pt filmb Thick polycrystalline Pt filmb Ultrathin Pt film: 0.08 pg omp2 O.g(r, Ptlsilica 0.2% Ptlalumina Pt/carbon 6-20% Pt/alumina 0
b
Deposited 270°C. Deposited 0°C.
(“C) 273 266-285 272 273 295 250-310 21@260 315
bond rupture probabilities
F
3
1-2
2-3
3 4
4-5
5-1
1-6
Reference
0.01 0.05 0.06 0.15 0.10 0.21 0.04 0.06
0.32 0.30 0.29 0.25 0.28 0.23 0.33 0.30
0.34 0.30 0.30 0.17 0.23 0.12 0.27 0.28
0.32 0.30 0.29 0.25 0.28 0.23 0.33 0.30
0.01 0.05 0.06 0.15 0.10 0.21 0.04 0.06
0 0 0 0.03 0 0 0
SO, 135
0
68 113 SO,135 110 112 166 167, 168
$
#MP 0
2
0
5 oy
4 U
70
J. R. ANDERSON
methylcyclopropane reacts about 20% more rapidly than cyclopropane (164). On the other hand, over a platinum/carbon catalyst at about 3OO0C, the rate of hydrogenolysis in a series of cyclopentanes decreases with increasing methyl substitution, the relative rates being cyclopentane 1.0, methylcyclopentane 0.6, 1,3-dimethylcyclopentane 0.1, 1,2,3-trimethylcyclopentane 0.02 (165). There is, however, quite a big range possible for different isomers; thus, 1,l-dimethylcyclopentaneis of comparable reactivity to methycyclopentane. The cyclobutanes stand in an intermediate position in that the rate of ring hydrogenolysis does not much depend on alkyl substituents. There is a general trend, particularly evident on platinum catalysts, that irrespective of ring size, ring opening tends to be disfavored for C-C bonds adjacent to alkyl substituents, and particularly adjacent to gem dialkyl substituents. However, the extent to which this occurs is very much dependent on catalyst structure. Some typical data for relative bond rupture probabilities are given in Table XIV for a variety of platinum catalysts. On highly dispersed catalysts such as ultrathin films or silica and alumina-supported platinum containing < 1% metal, the chance of ring opening adjacent to the methyl group is comparable with other ring positions. However, on catalysts containing larger platinum crystallites such as those containing a larger proportion of platinum, or on thick films, the chance of ring opening adjacent to the substituent is quite low. With methylcyclopentane (166, 153) as with methylcyclobutane (112), there is a leveling effect with increasing temperature so that the ring opening probabilities become more nearly equal. As the data in Table XIV indicate, over platinum demethylation of a ring is slow compared to C-C bond rupture within a ring. On the other hand, it is well established [e.g., Kochloefl and Bazant (161)] that if one uses a supported nickel catalyst which is known to favor stepwise alkane degradation, reaction with an alkylcycloalkane is largely confined to the alkyl group(s) which are degraded in a stepwise fashion and are finally removed entirely from the ring. I n discussing the way in which hydrogenolysis occurs, it needs to be recognized a t the outset that more than one reaction pathway is possible, and their relative importance depends both on hydrocarbon structure and on the nature of the catalyst. Table XV summarizes kinetic parameters for hydrogenolysis reactions of alkanes and cycloalkanes over film catalysts and over supported catalysts for which i t can be reasonably assumed that reaction is confined to the metallic phase. These kinetic parameters refer to the overall reaction, i.e., to the rate of disappearance of the parent molecule. It will be evident from Table XV that the catalytic activity of a given metal with a given
TABLE XV Kinetic Parameters for Hydrogmlysis Reactions" Rate = Hydrocarbon Ethane
Propane
Catalyst
Eb
Ni film Ni/kieselguhr Ni on various support
58 52 28-42
W film Pt film Pt/silica Pd film Pd/silica Re/silica Ru/silica Os/silica R h /silica Ir/silica Co on various silica supports &/carbon Cu/silica Ni film W film
27 57 54 50 58 31 32 35 42 36 29-31 18 21 31 18
log,,Ac
X
35.8
-
-
0.7 0.9 to 1.0
P~H~PYHZ
Y -1.2 -1.7 to -2.4
26.2 34.2 31.8 31.9 33.6 26.3 28.1
-
-
N1.0 0.9 -1.0 0.9 0.5 0.8
-
31.8 28.7 -25.5
0.6 0.8 0.7 1.0
-
1.0 1.0
-
26.4 21.7
-
-2.5
-2.5 +O. 3 -1.3 -1.2 -2.2 -1.6 -1 t o 0
-0.6 -0.4
-
Temperature range ("C) 254-273 181-214 175-335
173-1 83 274-340 344-385 273-358 377-392 229-265 177-257 127-162 192-242 177-2 12 219-288 272-317 288-330 217-267 180-190
Reference 68 169 62, 63
170 I71 143 68 24 172
24 172
46 172 173 172 172 63, 174 176 174 63 68 68
Continued
TABLE XV-Continued Rate Hydrocarbon
Catalyst
P
logloAc
a
P’H,P~H~ Y
X
Temperature range (“0
Referenee
~
n-Butane
Isobutane
n-Pentane
Neopentane
Ni film W film Pt film P d film Ni film Pt film (111) Pt film P d film Ni/silica Pt/silica Pt/carbon Pd/silica Ru/silica Ru/carbon Rh/silica Rh/carbon Ir/silica Co/silica Fe/silica Ni film Wfilm Pt film Pt/carbon Ru/silica Os/silica
34 7 21 -38 30 21 19 21 31 28 34 49 29 37 30 31 32 31 23 32 11 21 59 36 32
28.5 16.4 21.1 -27 26.8 21.0 19.5 21 27.3 26.9 27.5 31.4 29.3 32.0 27.9 27.7 27.2 27.1 22.7 26.3 17.5 21.2 32.8 29.8 28.4
0.7 -0.3
0.5 -0.2 0.9 0.7 0.8 0.9 0.9 1.0 1.0 1.0 1.0 0.9 0.5
+1.4 -0
+1.4
-
+o.
1 -1.6 -1.4 -1.4 -1.4 -1.6 -1.5 -1.3 -1.3 -1.5 -1.5 -0.6 -
188-209 144-164 256300 276-310 201-221 265-299 294-305 270-311 315-360 360-435 36Ck-435 385-435 240-285 260-315 275-335 305-375 290-360 315-375 370-430 222-265 202-2 19 239-290 305-370 150-180 130-175
?
P
r
I
12s
Neopentane
Neohexane n-Heptane
Cyclopropane
Methylcyclobutane
Cyclopentane
Rh/silica Ir/silica Au powder Ni film Pt powder P d powder R u powder Rh powder I r powder Ni film Ni/silica Ni/pumice Pt film Pt/pumice P d film Pd/pumice Ir/pumice F e film Ni film Pt film P d film Pt/charcoal Pt/charcoal Pd/charcoal
53 46 51 >25 31 31 37 40 33 7.5
36.8 32.8 25.8
-
24.5 23.3 33.6 33.9 30.2 19.3
-
-
-
-
10.6
-
11
9 14.5 8 10 23 8 16.5 19.5 20 35 40
24.6
-
25.3
-
24.7
-
-
-
-
-
-
0.6 0.8 1
0.2 1 0.1 1 1 1 1 1 1 +ve -
-
-
-
-0.1 -0.1 0 -0.2 0 -0.9 0 0
-
1 -ve -ve -
170-200 180-200 44w80 181-200 255-305 255-355 75-100 1w200 125-200 -46 to 0 2742 130-200 -78 to -23 50-200 -46 to -8 70-200 50-150 150-170 85-200 50-150 13e210 vicinity of of 300°C
1
122 12.3 122 68
E4
157
d
k
126 176 177 126 177 126 177 177 126 178 153 179 153
I n all cases, film catalysts refer to thick polycrystalline films deposited at O"C,except for (111) Pt and (100)Pt which were deposited at 300°C and 250°C on mica and evaporated rocksalt substrates, respectively. b E, activation energy, kcal mol-l. Frequency factor, molecules cm-* sec-l. Q
5
k 3M
U
m B M
s r3
k
P2 d
0
5 0 q
4tl 6
E0 5 w
74
J. R. ANDERSON
hydrocarbon can be strongly influenced by the nature of the catalyst. The range of activation energies for ethane hydrogenolysis over various nickel catalysts is particularly large. Thus, on thick nickel films and on the nickel/kieselguhr catalyst (15% Ni), the activation energies are 52-58 kcal mole-'. Moreover the lower activation energies for supported nickel recorded in Table XV are associated with lower nickel contents (6'2, 143). On the other hand, for each of the metals platinum and palladium, the activation energies for ethane hydrogenolysis are quite similar for thick film and for highly dispersed catalysts supported on silica. The influence of the support is particularly evident with carbon supports for a number of the listed metals; the hydrogenolysis activation energy is, in most cases, considerably different from the value obtained for the corresponding silicasupported catalysts or film catalysts. Again it seems reasonable to suppose that this is due to the presence of carbon on the metal surface. An analogous comment with regard to the likely variability of the chemical composition of the metal surface is relevant to the changes which have been observed in the specific activity for ethane hydrogenolysis over nickel and cobalt catalysts, depending on the nature of the support, namely, silica, alumina, silica-alumina (and carbon) (170, 174, 180). We refer to the discussion of the nature of supported catalysts given in previous sections. Sinfelt and co-workers have presented evidence to show that with 10% nickel/silica-alumina and with various rhodium/silica catalysts, the specific activity for ethane hydrogenolysis varied with metal crystallite size. In the case of nickel/silica-alumina (143), the specific activity decreased by a factor of about 20 for an increa,se in average nickel particle size from 29 to 888, while with rhodium/silica 6181),increasing the average rhodium particle size from < 128 to about 40 A resulted in an increase by a factor of about 3-4 in specific activity, and a further increase in size to 127 8 resulted in a decrease in specific activity by a factor of about 11 relative to the value for the catalyst with rhodium particles of average size < 12 A. Nevertheless, we remain unconvinced that these results necessarily reflect real particle size effects, rather than effects due to variations in the chemical composition of the metal surface. The variability of surface composition has been emphasized in earlier sections of this review which deal with catalyst structure. I n this circumstance, we also find it difficult to be convinced that the range of activation energies listed in Table XV for ethane hydrogenolysis over nickel is not mainly due to changing chemical composition of the nickel surface. Nevertheless, the comparisons presented between the behavior of ultrathin and thick film catalysts (cf. Tables XI, XIII, XIV) where adventitious surface contamination is insignificant, makcs it clear that metal particle size can bc a real determinant to the course of these reactions, and
METAL CATALYZED SKELETAL REACTIONS OF HYDROCARBONS
75
we shall allude to this factor in more detail subsequently. It is useful to note that whereas most metal film catalysts show appreciable and sometimes serve evidence for self-poisoning in hydrogenolysis reactions, supported catalysts are generally much less affected in this way. This selfpoisoning is a feature of the behavior of clean metal surfaces. In discussing the reaction pathways, we believe that the general evidence leads to the conclusion that hydrogenolysis proceeds via adsorbed hydrocarbon species formed by the loss of more than one hydrogen atom from from the parent molecule, and that in these adsorbed species more than one carbon atom is, in some way, involved in bonding to the catalyst surface. In the case of ethane, this adsorption criterion is met via a 1-2 mode or a r-olefin mode. Mechanistically it is difficult to see how the latter could be involved in C-C bond rupture in ethane. With molecules larger than ethane, other reaction paths are possible: One is via adsorption into the 1-3 mode, and another involves adsorption as a r-allylic species. We shall first consider reactions occurring on platinum. The salient points to be considered are as follows. The activation energy for ethane hydrogenolysis is much larger than that for larger hydrocarbons. Hydrogenolysis occurs on thick film catalysts with about the same activation energy with neopentane as with Cs and C4 aliphatics, and in neopentane a 1-2 adsorption mode is impossible. I n neohexane where there can be completition between hydrogenolysis by 1-2 and 1-3 adsorption modes, reaction is limited almost entirely to within the neopentyl group (cf. Table X I ) , that is, the 1-2 mode is of a relatively very minor significance. Thus, at least with aliphatic hydrocarbons up to Cg, it is difficult to avoid the conclusion that, except for ethane, an important hydrogenolysis pathway is via 1-3 adsorption, and that this process is mechanistically related to isomerization by bond shift in that both these processes involve conversion of the 1-3 adsorbed species into a bridged intermediate. If this bridged intermediate is attacked by hydrogen, hydrogenolysis results, rather than skeletal rearrangement. The detailed manner in which this hydrogen attack occurs is uncertain, but overall we may write
L'
!
Pt
lji
in which a hydrogen has been added a t Cs and CZ,and this is followed by further reaction with hydrogen to give product desorption. This process could occur by attack by Hz either from the gas phase or physically ad-
76
J. R. ANDERSON
sorbed on an adjacent site. It is also possible to formulate sequential attack by two adjacent chemisorbed H atoms. The reaction of neohexane over thick tungsten film catalysts (68) a t about 160°C shows that there is litt,le specific C-C bond rupture within the ethyl group, so again one concludes that reaction occurs preferentially via the 1-3 adsorption mode. On the other hand, neohexane hydrogenolysis over thick nickel and rhodium film catalysts a t sufficiently low reaction temperatures clearly proceeds by C-C bond rupture within both the ethyl and neopentyl groups with roughly comparable facility ; under these conditions one concludes that reactions via 1-2 and 1-3 adsorption modes are of comparable importance. We shall refer to these two processes as 1-2 and 1-3 hydrogenolysis, respectively. On this model, the catalytic selectivity for 1-3 hydrogenolysis and isomerization by bond shift depends on a complex matrix of factors: First by the ability of the catalyst to promote 1-3 adsorption (or its triadsorbed alternative, cf. structure E ) , second by the catalyst’s ability to facilitate conversion to the bridged intermediate, and third by the concentration of adsorbed hydrogen which determines whether the bridged intermediate will yield isomcrization or bond rupture. Nevertheless, a s with isomerization by bond shift, one expects that 1-3 hydrogenolysis will occur preferentially on low index surface planes. Considerations of molecular geometry show that a reaction path additional to those via 1-2 and 1-3 adsorption modes is required. Thus, cyclopentane and cyclohexane undergo hydrogenolysis on platinum catalysts with a reactivity much greater than ethane, but comparable to the other aliphatics; hence, 1-2 hydrogenolysis is improbable, and adsorption into a 1-3 mode is sterically impossible. Simple ring opening from cyclopentane or cyclohexane can be formulated as the reverse of ring closure, and mechanisms for this have already been discussed [reactions (11)-( 13)]. These involve the use of r-ally1 and/or s-olefin adsorbed species with the catalytically active site consisting of a single platinum atom. However, there is no reason to believe that a s-ally1 or s-olefin mechanism for C-C bond rupture is limited to ring opening. Rather it should be a general process occurring in straight and branch-chain aliphatics as well. For the purpose of illustration, we write reactions (22) and (23) as generalizations of the reverse of (11) and (13), respectively. We shall refer to mechanisms such as (22) and (23) s-olefin/allyl hydrogenolysis
The species on the right-hand side of (22) and (23) are assumed to be
METAL CATALYZED SKELETAL REACTIONS OF HYDROCARBONS
77
hydrogenated off the surface to complete the reaction. One must also consider the possibility of the reverse of reactions (14) and (15) for hydrogenolysis, as recently emphasized by Muller and Gault ( 1 8 1 ~ ) . With catalysts such as nickel and rhodium for which it has been shown that 1-2 hydrogenolysis is seriously competitive with 1-3 hydrogenolysis, there is no need to assume that a-olefin/allyl hydrogenolysis occurs (but neither can it with certainty be excluded). This conclusion is likely to be true for other catalysts such as cobalt and iron which also favor complete hydrocarbon fragmentation to methane. Anderson and Shimoyama (135) have recently observed the variation in specific rate and in selectivity of hydrogenolysis of methylcyclopentane, 2-methylpentane, and n-hexane for changing average particle size in ultrathin (and thick) platinum film catalysts. The general trend is indicated by some typical data given in Table XVI and it is clear that, with this sort of catalyst, both the specific rate and selectivity decrease with increasing average particle diameter in the range <15 to -60 A. The behavior of methylcyclopentane is important because, from the model discussed above, we expect ring opening to occur over platinum mainly by a a-olefin/allyl mechanism, so we may conclude that the specific rate of this process certainly falIs with increasing average particle size. This conclusion is obviously complementary to the one discussed previously concerning the dependence on particle size of isomerization via a carbocyclic intermediate; the basic factor is the same for both, namely the dependence of the reactions on the proportion of low coordinated surface platinum atoms. With n-hexane, 2- and 3-methylpentane one must expect that both a-olefin/allyl and 1-3 hydrogcnolysis mechanisms occur. Again from the tentative arguments proposed previously concerning isomerization by bond shift, we also propose that 1-3 hydrogenolysis is independent of particle size, so the fall in the overall specific rate with increasing particle size is due to the a-olefin/allyl component. The change in hydrogenolysis selectivity with particle size will clearly be controlled by the relative rates of the individual isomerization and hydrogenolysis reactions for the two basic reaction pathways. A scheme, justified post hoc, to account for the observed data has been described (155): it requires the specific rate of a-olefin/allyl hydrogenolysis to fall rather more rapidly with increasing particle size than does the rate of isomerization by carbocyclic intermediate. It is by no means clear why this should be so.
TABLE XVI
Rate and Selectivity of Hydrogenolysis over Platinum Film Catalysts at 273°C
Average Pt particle diameter Catalyst (pg cm-2)
(A)
Initial hydrogenolysis rate (10l2molec ern+ sec-l)
n-Hb
2-MP
MCP
Proportion of reaction by hy drogenolysisa (mole percent)
n-H
2-MP 4
Ultrathin Pt film, 0.02 0.04 0.06 0.08 0.13 0.25 0.50 0.60 1.0 2.5 Thick fringe-free polycrystalline Pt film, deposited 273°C a
b
< 15 < 15 15 20 20 36 38 40 43 58 massive metal
16 4.0 2.2 1.45 0.55 0.53
29 -
0.35 0.35 0.37
13 8.5 5.0
Remainder of reaction by isomerization; Anderson and Shimoyama (SO, 136). n-H = n-hexane; Z M P = 2-methylpentane; MCP = met.hylcyc1opentane.
14
14 14
-
8.4
14 11 9.4 6.0 5.4
6.0 7.9 22
36 19
5.8
-
3.5 9.0 5.2 7.5
m * 3H 1:
METAL CATALYZED SKELETAL REACTIONS OF HYDROCARBONS
79
While we have in the previous paragraphs offered more or less specific proposals for the entities involved in 1-3 and s-olefin/allyl hydrogenolysis, that for 1-2 hydrogenolysis remains to be discussed. It has been generally proposed (182, 68, 183) that for a 1-2 adsorbed intermediate to lead to C-C bond rupture, it should preferably be extensively dehydrogenated. In this connection it is useful to note that with rhodium and nickel film catalysts for which 1-2 hydrogenolysis is known t o be important, there is evidence from deuterium exchange data for extensively dehydrogenated species, involving particularly the loss of two hydrogens from a carbon atom (for a summary cf. 120). A similar conclusion may be reached from the deuteroethane distributions given by Guczi et al. (18%) for reactions over nickel powder catalysts which resemble some of the distributions reported over nickel films (18%) and which were discussed in 120. Sinfelt, Carter, and Yates ( 1 5 7 ~ have ) studied the hydrogenolysis of ethane over a range of unsupported nickel/copper catalysts. The main feature of the results was a monotonic fall in specific activity with increasing copper content. The overall decrease on going from zero to about 80 at. % copper was a factor of about lo5, but the major part of this occurred a t low copper contents, the specific activity decreasing by a factor of about lo4 on going from a copper content of zero to 25 at. %. Bearing in mind the way in which the copper content of the surface varied as the bulk concentration varied (see previously under Section IV. B), this behavior is consistent with a model in which the formation of the adsorbed reaction intermediate requires a t least two adjacent nickel atoms : the chance of finding these would be expected to decrease rapidly with increasing copper content. We may say in summary that hydrogenolysis reactions of aliphatic and alicyclic hydrocarbons on metals have a t least three reaction pathways which can act both competitively and consecutively to extents that depend both on the nature of the hydrocarbon and the metal. As an example of consecutive reactions we may take the reaction of neopentane over nickel films where the initial C-C bond rupture must proceed via 1-3 hydrogenolysis, but the fragments initially produced may, before desorption, undergo extensive degradation: a t this stage all three reaction pathways are possible, although it is likely that the 1-2 and 1-3 pathways are the most important. I n a reaction scheme as complicated as hydrogenolysis, the identification of a rate controlling step is particularly difficult. Indeed, in a complex reaction sequence, a single specific and dominant rate controlling step need not necessarily exist. On the whole, it seems reasonable to propose by comparison with bond shift isomerization, that 1-3 hydrogenolysis is controlled by the rate of formation of the bridged intermediate. For 1-2 hydrogenolysis, the most frequently made assumption is that the
80
J. R. ANDERSON
rate is controlled by the step in which the C-C bond is ruptured, and the same is likely t o be true for ?r-olefin/allyl hydrogenolysis. While this assumption would seem to be reasonable, there are situations which make it necessary to consider the possibility that product desorption is rate controlling. Thus, it has been reported (18%) that on iron films, ethane exchange with deuterium does not occur: instead, as the temperature is raised, C-C bond rupture occurs. In this situation, if bond rupture were rate controlling, exchange should be relatively rapid. A recent re-examination of reactions of ethane, propane, and butane over iron film catalysts (1834 in the presence of deuterium has shown that some deuterated parent hydrocarbon is formed. Of the hydrocarbon molecules undergoing reaction, the proportions appearing as deuteroparent were 27%, 33%, and 53% for ethane, propane, and butane, respectively. I n all cases the perdeutero compound made up the bulk of the exchange product. The comments made above concerning ethane hydrogenolysis over iron films remain valid since exchange is a minor reaction pathway, and it is probable that similar conclusions apply to propane and butane. Again, with nickel film catalysts, Anderson and Baker (68) noted that the rate of methane production from ethane hydrogenolysis was lower than the rate of methane exchange with deuterium, and this would suggest hydrogenolysis to be desorption controlled provided it is assumed that exchange is desorption controlled. This conclusion has since been supported by Free1 and Galwey (183) but the answer must still be considered as in doubt. There is certainly no justification for assuming that the rate controlling step for a given metal/hydrocarbon system will necessarily be the same irrespective of the nature of the surface, since the chemical composition of the surface may well influence the extent of dehydrogenation in hydrocarbon adsorption. This is emphasized by the recently published results of Guczi et ul. (18%) for exchange (deuterium or tritium) and hydrogenolysis of ethane over hydrogen-reduced, unsupported nickel powder catalysts. The various reactions were studied over a wide temperature range (156"-315"). At lower temperatures where exchange was up to ten times faster than hydrogenolysis, one can hardly disagree with the conclusions reached by Guczi that C-C bond rupture is likely to be rate controlling. At higher temperatures where the rates of exchange and hydrogenolysis were comparable, this conclusion is less certain, but in the circumstances, is still probably the best estimate. In all cases, and a t low conversions, the methane was extensively deuterated with methane-& as the dominant species. This result is not diagnostic as it can be consistent with either methane desorption or C-C bond rupture as the rate controlling step : for the first alternative, extensive exchange within a C1 residue can occur before desorption, while for the second, extensive exchange in a C z residue can occur before
METAL CATALYZED SKELETAL REACTIONS OF HYDROCARBONS
81
C-C bond rupture takes place. One can obviously expect the composition of the catalyst surface to influence the relative importance of the three possible hydrogenolysis pathways. Observations which would support this are the variability of the hydrogenolysis product distribution with factors such as temperature and hydrogen pressure which are particularly evident with catalysts such as nickel. On a catalyst such as platinum where only one C-C bond is ruptured per reactant molecule, the fragments resulting from this bond rupture are apparently desorbed rapidly. On the other hand, if desorption is relatively difficult, extensive fragmentation becomes more probable. It will be clear from this sort of argument how the tendency of a catalyst to promote extensive fragmentation may be influenced by factors, including adsorbed impurity, which control the strength of adsorption of hydrocarbon residues ; the extent of residue dehydrogenation is obviously important.
VI. Reactions over Chromium Oxide Catalysts A wide range of nonacidic metal oxides have been examined as catalysts for aromatization and skeletal isomerization. From a mechanistic point of view, chromium oxide catalysts have been, by far, the most thoroughly studied. Reactions over chromium oxide have been carried out either over the pure oxide, or over a catalyst consisting of chromium oxide supported on a carrier, usually alumina. Depending on its history, the alumina can have an acidic function, so that the catalyst as a whole then has a duel function character. However, in this section, we propose only briefly to outline, for comparison with the metal catalyzed reactions described in previous sections, those reactions where the acidic catalyst function is negligible. Reactions over chromium oxide catalysts are often carried out without the addition of hydrogen to the reaction mixture, since this addition tends to reduce the catalytic activity. Thus, since chromium oxide is highly active for dehydrogenation, under the usual reaction conditions (temperature >500°C) extensive olefin formation occurs. In the following discussion we shall, in the main, be concerned only with skeletally distinguished products. Information about reaction pathways has been obtained by a study of the reaction product distribution from unlabeled (e.g. 89, 5, 118, 184-186, 58, 187) as well as from 14C-labeledreactants (89, 87, 88, 91-95, 98, 188, 189). The main mechanistic conclusions may be summarized. Although some skeletal isomerization occurs, chromium oxide catalysts are, on the whole, less efficient for skeletal isomerization than are platinum catalysts. Cyclic C5 products are of never more than very minor impor-
82
J. R. ANDERSON
tance. Skeletal isomerization and aromatization can occur sequentially within a single residence period. In the formation of a CS ring, direct ring closure to a Ca is the most important path (perhaps exclusively so), compared to the prior formation of rings of other sizes followed by ring contraction or expansion. Neopentane does not undergo isomerization (185) on chromia/alumina (non-acidic) a t 537"C, the only significant reaction been hydrogenolysis t o methane and iso-Cd. However, the reality of isomerization is made clear from, for instance, the formation of xylenes from 2,3,4-trimethylpentane. For 0- and p-xylene, the reactions are (24) and (25) (182,93). These processes are formally quite analogous to those we have described in previous c c c I) I I c-c-c-c-c
-[
v ]
c-c-c-c-c-c
(8
-&
(24)
sections as bond shift reactions over metal catalysts. It has frequently been proposed that the isomerization steps in reactions such as (24) and (25) occur via adsorbed cyclo-C, intermediates (89, 3, 185). We can do no more than offer the same comment here as was given in previous sections in relation to the high energy of a cyclopropane ring. This sort of reaction has been discussed in some detail by Pines and Goetschel (S), who compared it with vinyl insertion reactions studied by Raley and coworkers (i9Gi92)in the isomerization of hydrocarbons in the presence of iodine at about 500"C, and which are known to proceed by a type of free-radical mechanism. An important point of agreement is that both fail to give neopentane isomerization. There has long been evidence that the first step in alkane isomerization over chromium oxide is dehydrogenation to an olefin (not necessarily desorbed before further reaction). On this basis, Pines and Goetschel suggest that, starting with neohexane, dehydrogenation first occurs in the ethyl group, and skeletal rearrangement, ultimately to an iso-C5 skeleton, occurs via an adsorbed free radical of the type in (V) .
METAL CATALYZED SKELETAL REACTIONS O F HYDROCARBONS
83
With the evidence available a t the moment, it is the author’s opinion that Pines and Goetschel’s free-radical mechanism is well founded, and thus this mechanism is quite distinct from the bond shift reaction occurring over metals. In order to preserve this distinction, we shall retain the term vinyl insertion for the type of isomerization exemplified in (24) and (25). Observed product distributions, however, make it clear that there must exist reaction pathways in addition to those of the sort in (24) and (25). Thus m-xylene is also a product from 2,3,4-trimethylpentane. This is illustrative of a reaction for which an adsorbed cyclo-C4 intermediate has been suggested (89, 96, 98,S, 185, 188, 189).
c c c I l l c-c-c-c-c
-I??
c-c+c-c-c
-[
1,s)
c-c-c-c-c-c-c
I
(S)
Although providing a satisfactory rationale for experimental facts, an adsorbed cyclo-C4 intermediate still suffers from the problem of high energy, although this should be of lesser importance on chromium oxide catalysts because the reactions are carried out at much higher temperatures than on platinum. The products for which the cyclo-C*isomerization intermediate has been suggested, can also be explained by a sequence of vinyl insertions. Thus, two vinyl insertions would be adequate to explain the formation of m-xylene from 2,3,4-trimethylpentane. Although we have seen in previous sections that extensive reaction sequences are possible on platinum, isomerization by a single vinyl insertion process on chromium oxide is relatively difficult, and the chance of two occurring in sequence would therefore be expected to be very low. In fact, the proportion of m-xylene is comparable to that of 0- and p-xylene. The occurrence of adsorbed cyclo-C7 and CS intermediates has been
84
J. R. ANDERSON
adduced from various studies using 14C-labeled molecules (87, 91-93, 95, 98, 3, 188). For instance, aromatization of 3-methylhe~ane-5-’~Cgave toluene of which some 5% had the 14Catom in the methyl group (188), and this has been interpreted as due to the sequence I
c-c-c-c-c-c
vinyl
14
insertion
* c-c-c-c-c-c-c
14
14
c while aromatization of various 14C-labeled octanes (91-93, 95, 98) has indicated some contribution from an adsorbed cyclo-C8 intermediate. Nevertheless, the occurrence of cyclic reaction intermediates of ring size larger than Cg, does not remain unquestioned. Feighan and Davis (88) examined the aromatization of n-heptane-4-14C and, by comparison with the results of Pines and Chen (87) for n-heptane-l-14C, concluded that an adsorbed cyclo-C, intermediate was not involved. The origin of this disagreement remain unresolved. Inasmuch as the importance of cyclic C7 and C8 intermediates decreases strongly with catalytic usage, it is likely that the disagreement reflects real differences in catalyst properties. The detailed mechanism of ring closure to a Cs ring has long been the subject of speculation (3, 184, 187). For the present purposes we merely note that all of the cyclization processes (11)-(15) already discussed for platinum, are potentially applicable. Although reactions over nonacidic metal oxide catalysts possess some superficial similarities to reactions over platinum catalysts, on the whole, the two systems are sufficiently distinct that, at a mechanistic level, they are worth treating independently.
REFERENCES 1. Weisz, P. B. Advan. Catal. 13, 137 (1962). 2. Gil’debrand, E. I., Znt. Chem. Eng. 6,449 (1966). 3. Pines, H., and Goetschel, C. T., J . Org. C h m . 30, 3530 (1965). 4. Germain, J. E., “Catalytic Conversion of Hydrocarbons.” Academic Press, New York, 1969. 6. Ciapetta, G. F., Dobres, R. M., and Baker, R. W., in “Catalysis” (P. H. Emmett, ed.), Vol. 6, p. 492. Reinhold, New York, 1958. 6. Steiner, A. H., in “Catalysis” (P. H. Emmett, ed.), Vol. 4, p. 529. Reinhold, New York, 1956.
METAL CATALYZED SKELETAL REACTIONS O F HYDROCARBONS
85
7. Anderson, J. R., and Baker, B. G., in “Chemisorption and Reactions on Metallic Films” (J. R. Anderson, ed.), Vol. 2, p. 1. Academic Press, New York, 1971. 8. Brennan, D., Haywood, D. D., and Trapnell, B. M. W., Proc. Roy. SOC.Ser. A 256, 81 (1960). 9. Geus, J. W., in “Chemisorption and Reactions on Metallic Films” (J. R. Anderson, ed.), Vol. 1, p. 129. Academic Press, New York, 1971. 10. Suhrmann, R., and Wedler, G., 2. Angew. Phys., 14, 70 (1962). 11. Maire, G., Anderson, J. R., and Johnson, B. B., Proc. Roy. Soc. Ser. A 320, 227 (1970). 12. Baker, B. G., Johnson, B. B., and Maire, G., Surface Sci. 24,572 (1971). 13. Anderson, J. S., and Klemperer, D. F., Proc. Roy. SOC.Ser. A 256, 350 (1960). 14. Bouwman, R., van Keulen, H. P., and Sachtler, W. M. H., Ber. Bunsenges. 74, 32 (1970). 15. Bouwman, R., Ph.D. Thesis, University of Leiden, The Netherlands, 1970. 16. Baker, B. G., and Fox, P. G., Trans. Faraday SOC.61,2001 (1965). 17. Baker, B. G., and Bruce, L. A., Trans. Faraday SOC.64,2533, (1968). 18. Suhrmann, R., Gerdes, R., and Wedler, G., 2. Naturjorsch. A 18, 1208 (1963). 19. Drechsler, M., and Nicholas, J. F., J.Phys. Chcm. Solids 28,2609 (1967); Nicholas, J. F., Aust. J . Phys. 21, 21 (1968). 20. Evans, D. M., and Wilman, H., Acta Crystallogr. 5,731 (1952). 21. Adamsky, R. F., J.A p p l . Phys. 31,2895 (1960). 22. Bauer, E., in “Single Crystal Films” (M. H. Francombe and H. Sato, eds.), p. 43. Pergamon Press, London, 1964. 23. Jaeger, H., J . Catal. 9, 237 (1967). 24. Anderson, J. R., and Avery, N. R., J. Catal. 5,446 (1966). 25. Sella, C., and Trillat, J. J., in “Single Crystal Films” (M. H. Francombe and H. Sato, eds.), p. 201. Pergamon Press, London, 1964. 26. Macdonald, R. J., Ph.D. Thesis, Flinders University, Adelaide, Australia, 1970. 27. Anderson, J. R., and Macdonald, R. J., J . Catal. 19, 227 (1970). 28. Anderson, J. R., Macdonald, R. J., and Shimoyama, Y., J . Catal. 20, 147 (1971). 29. Anderson, J. R., and Shimoyama, Y., unpublished results, Flinders University, Adelaide, Australia (1970). 30. Shimoyama, Y., Ph.D. Thesis, Flinders University, Adelaide, Australia, 1971. 31. Maat, R. J., and MOSCOU, L., Proc. 3rd Znt. Congr. Catal., 1964 p. 1277 (1965). $2. Allpress, J. G., and Sanders, J. V., Surface Sci. 7, 1 (1967). 33. Jaeger, H., Mercer, P. D., and Sherwood, R. G., Surface Sci. 11,265 (1968). 34. Sanders, J. V., private communication (1970). 35. Moss, R . L., Platinum Metals Rev. 11 (4), 1 (1967). 36. Dorling, T. A,, Eastlake, M. J., and Moss, R. L., J. Catal. 14,23 (1969). 37. Cormack, D., and Moss, R. L., J . Catal. 13, 1 (1969). 38. Dorling, T. A., and Moss, R. L., J . Catal. 7,378 (1967). 39. Dorling, T. A., Lynch, B. W. J., and Moss, R. L., J. Catal. 20, 190 (1971). 40. Schuit, G. C. A., and van Reijen, L. L., Advan. Catal. 10,242 (1958). 41. Coenen, J. W. E., and Linsen, B. C., in “Physical and Chemical Aspects of Adsorbents and Catalysts” (B. G. Linsen, ed.), p. 471. Academic Press, New York, 1970. 42. Morikawa, K., Shirasaki, T., and Okada, M., Advan. Catal. 20,98 (1969). 43. Reinen, D., and Selwood, P. W., J . Catal. 2, 109 (1963). 44. Webb, A. N., Znd. Eng. Chem. 49,261 (1957). 45, Yates, D. J. C., and Sinfelt, J. H., J . Catal. 14, 182 (1969).
86
J. R. ANDERSON
46. Aben, P. C., J . Catal. 10,224 (1968). 47. Avery, N. R., and Sanders, J. V., J . Catal. 18, 129 (1970). 48. Wilson, G. R., and Hall, W. K., J . Catal. 17, 190 (1970) 49. Hill, H. F., and Selwood, P. W., J . Amer. Chem. SOC.71,2522 (1949). 60. Nesterov, 0. V., and Evdokimou, V. B., Zh. Fiz. Khim. 35, 376 (1961). 61. Pope, D., Smith, W. L., Eastlake, M. J., and Moss, R. L., J . Catal. 22, 72 (1971). 68. Beeck, O., Advan. Catal. 2, 151 (1950). 63. Rideal, E. K., and Sweett, F., Proc. Roy. SOC.Ser. A 257, 291 (1960). 64. Anderson, J . R., and Baker, B. G., J . Phys. Chem. 66,482 (1962). 65. Brennan, D., and Hayes, F. H., Trans. Faraday SOC.60,589 (1964). 66. Schuit, G. C. A., and deBoer, N. H., REC.Trav. Chim. 70, 1067 (1951). 67. Schuit, G. C. A., and deBoer, N. H., Rec. Trav. Chim. 72,909 (1953). 68. Roberts, M. W., and Sykes, K. W., Proc. Roy. SOC.Ser. A 242, 534 (1957). 69. Roberts, M. W., and Sykes, K. W., Trans. Faraday SOC.54, 548 (1958). 60. Low, M. J . D., Can. J . Chem. 38,588 (1960). 61. Brooks, C. S., and Christopher, G. L. M., J . Catal. 10,211 (1968). 68. Taylor, W. F., Sinfelt, J. H., and Yates, D. J. C., J . Phys. Chem. 69, 3857 (1965). 63. Sinfelt, J. H., Taylor, W. F., and Yates, D. J. C., J . Phys. Chem. 69,95 (1965). 64. Spenadel, L., and Boudart, M., J . Phys. Chem. 64,204 (1960). 65. Gruber, H. L., J . Phys. C h m . 66, 48 (1962). 66. Cusumano, J . A., Dembinski, G. W., and Sinfelt, J. H., J . Catal. 5,471 (1966). 67. Benson, J . E., and Boudart, M., J . Catal. 4,704 (1965). 68. Anderson, J . R., and Baker, B. G., Proc. Roy. SOC.Ser. A 271,402 (1963). 69. Lewis, R., and Comer, K., Surface Sci. 17,333 (1969). 70. Mignolet, J . C. P., J . Chim. Phys. 54, 19 (1957). 71. Vannice, M. A., and Neikam, W. C., J . Catal. 20,260 (1971). 78. Boudart, M., Advan. Catal. 20, 153 (1969). 73. Yates, D . J . C., J . Colloid Interface Sci.29 (2), 196 (1969). 74. Robell, A. J., Ballou, E. V., and Boudart, M., J . Phys. Chem. 68, 2748 (1964). 75. Sancier, K. M., J . Catal. 20, 106 (1971). 76. Klemperer, D . F., i n “Chemisorption and Reactions on Metallir Films” (J. R. Anderson, ed.), Vol. 1, p. 39. Academic Press, New York, 1971. 77. Beeck, O., Smith, A. E., and Wheeler, A,, Proc. Roy. SOC.Ser. A 177,62 (1940). 78. Anderson, R. B., in “Experimental Methods in Catalytic Research” (R. B. Anderson, ed.), p. 1. Academic Press, New York, 1968. 79. Komarewsky, V. J., and Riesz, C. H., in “Technique of Organic Chemistry” (A. Weissberger, ed.), Vol. 2, p. 1. Interscience, New York, 1948. 80. Kokes, R. J., Tobin, H., and Emmett, P. H., J . Amer. Chem. SOC.77, 5860 (1955). 81. Corolleur, C., Corolleur, S., and Gault, F. G., J . Catal. 24, 385 (1972). 88. Steingaszner, P., and Pines, H., J . Catal. 5, 356 (1966). 83. Beeck, O., Otvos, J. W., Stevenson, D. P., and Wagner, C. I)., J . Chem. Phys. 16, 255 (1948). 84. Corolleur, C., Ph.D. Thesis, University of Caen, Caen, France, 1969. 85. Roberts, J . D., and Coraor, G. R., J . Amer. Chem. SOC.74,3586 (1952). 86. Stevenson, D. P., J . Amer. Chem. SOC.80, 1571 (1958). 87. Pines, H., and Chen, C-T., J . Org. Chem. 26, 1057 (1961). 88. Feighan, J . A,, and Davis, B. H., J . CataZ. 4, 594 (1965). 89. Pines, H., Goetschel, C. T., and Dembinski, ,J. W., J . Org. Chem. 30, 3540 (1965). 90. Pines, H., and Myerholtz, It. W., J . Amar. Chem. SOC.77,5392 (1955). 91. Pines, H., and Chen, C.-T., Actes 2nd Congr. Znt. Catal., 1960 p . 367 (1961).
METAL CATALYZED SKELETAL REACTIONS OF HYDROCARBONS
87
92. Pines, H., Goetschel, C. T., and Csicsery, S. M., J . Org. Chem. 28, 2713 (1963). 93. Pines, H., and Goetschel, C. T., J . Org. C h m . 30, 3548 (1965). 94. Canning, F. R., Fisher, A., Ford, J. F., Holmes, P. D., and Smith, R. S., Chem. Znd. (London). 228 (1960). 96. Goetschel, C. T., and Pines, H., J. Org. Chem. 29,399 (1964). 96. Pines, H., and Benoy, G., J. Amer. Chem. SOC.82, 2483 (1960). 97. Pines, H., and Shaw, A. W., J . Amer. Chem. SOC.79,1474 (1957). 98. Goetschel, C. T., and Pines, H., J . Org. Chem. 30, 3544 (1965). 99. Stevenson, D. P., J . Chem. Phys. 19, 17 (1951). 100. Corolleur, C., Corolleur, S., and Gault, F. G., Bull. Soc. Chhim. Fr. 158 (1970). 101. Steinberg, H., and Sixma, F. L. J., Rec. Trav. Chim. 79, 679 (1960). 102. Kilner, A. E. H., Turner, H. S., and Warne, R. J., in “Radioisotopes Conference, 1954,” Vol. 2: Physical Sciences and Industrial Applications, p. 29. Academic Press, New York, 1954. 103. Roberts, J. D., Semenov, D. A,, Simmons, H. E., and Carlsmith, L. A., J . Amer. Chem. SOC.78, 601 (1956). 104. Murray, A., and Williams, D. L., “Organic Syntheses with Isotopes.” Interscience, New York, 1958. 105. Kazanskii, B. A., and Plate, A. F., Ber. 69, 1862 (1936). 106. Moldavsky, B. L., and Kamuschev, H. D., Dokl. Akad. Nauk SSSR Scr. A 1, 355 (1936). 107. Grosse, A. V., Morrell, J. C., and Mattox, W. J., Ind. Eng. Chem. 32, 528 (1940). 108. Anderson, J. R., and Avery, N. R., J . Catal. 2, 542 (1963). 109. Csicsery, S . M., J . Catal. 9, 336 (1967). 110. Matsumoto, H., Saito, Y., and Yoneda, Y. J . Catal. 19, 101 (1970). 111. Davis, B. H., and Venuto, P. B., J . Catal. 15, 363 (1969). 112. Maire, G., Plouidy, G., Prudhomme, J. C., and Gault, F. G., J . Catal. 4, 556 (1965). 113. Barron, Y., Maire, G., Muller, J. M., and Gault, F . G., J . Catal. 5,428 (1966). 114. Lester, G. R., J. Catal. 13, 187 (1969). 115. Corolleur, C., Tomanova, D., and Gault, F. G., J . Catal. 24, 401 (1972). 116. Maire, G., Corolleur, C., Juttard, I)., and Gault, F. G., J. Catal. 21, 250 (1971). 1 1 6 ~ Kemball, . C. and Kempling, J. C., Proc. Roy. Soe. Ser. A 329,391 (1972). 117. Baird, T., Frycr, J. R., and Grant, B., Nature (London)233,329 (1971). 118. Robertson, S . D., Carbon 8,365 (1970). 119. Muller, J. M., and Gault, F. G., Proc. 4th Int. Congr. Catal. Paper 15, (1968). 120. Anderson, J. I{., and Baker, B. G., in “Chemisorption and Reactions on Metallic Films” (J. It. Anderson, ed.), Vol. 2, p. 63. Academic Press, New York, 1971. 121. Boudart, M., Aldag, A. W., Ptak, L. D., and Benson, J. E., J . Catal. 11, 35 (1968). 122. Boudart, M., and Ptak, L. I)., J . Catal. 16,90 (1970). 123. Kikuchi, E., Tsurumi, M., and Morita, Y., J . Catal. 22, 226 (1971). 124. Shuikin, N. I., Advan. Catal. 9, 783 (1957). 125. Pines, H., and Csicsery, S. M., J. Catal. 1, 313 (1962). 126. Anderson, J. It., and Avcry, N. It., J . Catal. 8 , 4 8 (1967). 127. Field, F. H., and Franklin, J . L., “Electron Impact Phenomena.” Academic Press, New York, 1957. 128. Anderson, J. It., and Avery, N. R., J . Catal. 7, 315 (1967). 129. Zimmerman, H. E., and Zweig, A., J . Amcr. Chcm. SOC.83, 1196 (1961). 130. Mullcr, J. M., Ph.D. Thesis, University of Caen, Caen, France, 1969. 131. Rarron, Y., Maire, G., Cornet, D., and Gault, F. G., .I. Catal. 2, 152 (1963). 132. Maire, G., and Gault, F. G., Bull. SOC.Chim.Fr. p. 894 (1967).
88
J. R. ANDERSON
133. Dautzenberg, F. M., and Platteeuw, J. C., J . Catal. 19, 41 (1970). 134. Gault, F. G., Anderson, J. R., Corolleur, C., and Shimoyama, Y., Unpublished results, University of Caen, Caen, France, and Flinders University, Adelaide, Australia (1972). 136. Anderson, J . R., and Shimoyama, Y., Proc. 5th Znt. Congr. Catal. 1972. Paper 48, In press. 136. Shephard, F. E., and Rooney, J. J., J . Catal. 3,129 (1964). 137. Chiusoli, G. P., i n “Aspects of Homogeneous Catalysis” (R. Ugo, ed.), Vol. 1, p. 77. Manfredi, Milano, 1970. 138. Lefebvre, G., and Chauvin, Y., i n “Aspects of Homogeneous Catalysis” (R. Ugo, ed.), Vol. 1, p. 107. Manfredi, Milano, 1970. 139. Heck, R. F., Advan. Chem. Ser. 49, 181 (1965). 140. Newham, J., Chem. Rev. 63, 123 (1963). 141. Csicsery, S . M . , J . Catal. 15, 111 (1969). 142. Silvestri, A. J., Naro, P. A., and Smith, R. L., J . Catal. 14,386 (1969). 143. Carter, J . L., Cusumano, J. A., and Sinfelt, J. H., J . Phys. Chem. 70, 2257 (1966). 144. Kazanskii, B. A., Kinet. Catal. 5, 841 (1967). 146. Dwyer, F . G., Eagleston, J., Wei, J., and Zahner, J. C., Proc. Roy. SOC.Ser. A 302, 253 (1968). 146. Fogelberg, L-G., Gore, R., and Ranby, B., Acta Chem. Scand. 21, 2041, 2050 (1967). 147. Rooney, J. J . , J . Catal. 2, 53 (1963). 148. Garnett, J. L., and Sollich-Baumgartner, W. A,, Advan. Catal. 16, 95 (1966). 149. Horescu, I., and Rudenko, A. P., Russ. J . Phys. Chem. 44, 1601 (1970). 160. Csicsery, S. M., and Burnett, R. L., J . Catal. 8 , 7 5 (1967). 151. Csicsery, S . M . , J . Catal. 12, 183 (1968). 152. Kazanskii, B. A., and Liberman, A. L., Proc. 6th World Petrol. Congr., 1969, Sect. IV, Paper 3, p. 29 (1960). 153. Liberman, A. L., Bragin, 0. V., Guryanova, G. K., and Kazanskii, B. A., Zzv. Akad. Nauk SSSR, Ser. Khim. p. 1737 (1963); Gostunskaya, I. V., Kuo, C. F., and Kazanskii, B. A., Zzv. Akad. Nauk SSSR, Ser. Khim. p. 1073 (1964). 164. Sinfelt, J. H., Hurwite, H., and Shulman, R. A., J . Phys. Chem. 64, 1559 (1960). 166. Csicsery, S. M., J . Catal. 17, 207 (1970). 156. Wood, B. J., and Wise, H., J . Catal. 5, 135 (1966). 167. Carter, J . L., Cusumano, J. A., and Sinfelt, J. H., J . Catal. 20, 223 (1971). 157a. Sinfelt, J . H., Carter, J. L., and Yates, D. J. C., J . Catal. 24, 283 (1972). 168. Solymosi, F., Catal. Rev. 1, 233 (1968). 168a. Baddour, R. F. and Diebert, M. C., J . Phys. Chem. 70,2173 (1966). 159. Matsumoto, H., Saito, Y., and Yoneda, Y., J . Catal. 22, 182 (1971). 160. Myers, C. G., and Munns, G. W., Znd. Eng. Chem. 50,1727 (1958). 161. Kochloefl, K., and Bezant, V., J . Catal. 10, 140 (1968). 161. Haensel, V., and Ipatieff, V. N., J . Amer. Chem. Soc. 68, 345 (1946). 163. Shuikin, N. I . , and T’ien, Hsing-Hua, I z v . Akad. Nauk. SSSR, Ser. Khim. p. 2046 (1960). 164. Bond, G. C., and Newham, J., Trans. Faraday Soc. 56, 1501 (1960). 166. Kazanskii, B. A., Usp. Khim. 17, 641 (1948). 166. Kaaanskii, B. A,, Probl. Kinel. Katal. 6, 223 (1949). 167. Gault, F. G., Ann. Chim. p. 645 (1960). 168. Gault, F. G., and Germain, J. E., Actes 2nd Congr. Znt. Catal., 1960, p. 2461 (1961). 169. Kemball, C., and Taylor, H. S., J . Amer. Chem. SOC.TO, 345 (1948).
METAL CATALYZED SKELETAL REACTIONS OF HYDROCARBONS
89
170. Taylor, W. F., Yates, D. J. C., and Sinfelt, J. H., J. Phys. Chem. 68, 2962 (1964). 171. Yates, I).J . C., Taylor, W. F., and Sinfelt, J. H., J . Amer. C h m . SOC.86, 2996 (1964). 178. Sinfelt, J . H., and Yates, D. J. C., J. Catal. 8, 82 (1967). 173. Sinfelt, J . H., andYates, I). J. C., J . Catal. 10,362 (1968). 174. Yates, D . J . C., Sinfelt, J. H., and Taylor, W. F., Trans. Faraday SOC.61, 20 (1965). 175. Sinfelt, J . H., and Taylor, W. F., Trans. Faraday SOC.64,3086 (1968). 176. Taylor, W. F., Yates, D. J. C., and Sinfelt, J. H., J. Catal. 4,374 (1965). 177. Bond, G. C., and Sheridan, J., Trans. Faraday SOC.48,713 (1952). 178. Maire, G., Ph.D. Thesis, University of Caen, Caen, France, 1967. 179. Kazanskii, B. A., and Bulanova, T. F., Zzv. Akad. Nauk S S S R , Ser. K h i m . p. 29 (1947). 180. Sinfelt, J . H., Catal. Rev. 3, 175 (1970). 181. Yates, D. J. C., and Sinfelt, J. H., J. Catal. 8, 348 (1967). 181a. Muller, J. M. and Gault, F. G., J. Catal. 24,361 (1972). 188. Cimino, A., Boudart, M., and Taylor, H. S., J.Phys. Chem. 58,796 (1954). 183. Freel, J., and Galwey, A. K., J. Catal. 10, 277 (1968). 183a. Guczi, L., Gudkov, B. S., and Tetenyi, P., J. Catal. 24, 187 (1972). 183b. Anderson, J. R., and Macdonald, It. J., J. Catal. 13, 345 (1969). 183c. Anderson, J. R., and Kemball, C., Proc. Roy. SOC.A223, 361 (1954). 183d. Dowie, R. S., Gray, M. C., Whan, D. A., and Kemball, C., Chem. Comm. 883 (1971). 184. Herrington, E. F. G., and Rideal, E. K., Proc. Roy. SOC.Ser. A 184,434,447 (1945). 185. Pines, H., and Csicsery, S. M., J. Catal. 1,313 (1962). 186. Mitchell, J . J., J.Amer. Chem. SOC.80,5848 (1958). 187. Twigg, G. H., Trans. Faraday Soc. 35, 1006 (1939). 188. Pines, H., and Dembinski, J. W., J.Org. Chem. 30,3537 (1965). 189. Chen, C.-T., Haag, W. O., and Pines, H., Chem. Znd. (London) p. 1379 (1959). 190. Raley, J . H . , Mullineaux, R. D., and Bittner, C. W., J . Amer. Chem. SOC.85,3174 (1963). 191. Mullineaux, R . D., and Raley, J. H., J . Amer. Chem. SOC.85,3178 (1963). 198. Slaugh, L. H., Mullineaux, R. D., and Raley, J. H., J. Amer. Chem. SOC. 85, 3180 (1963).
NOTEADDEDIN PROOF Some further relevant material has been published since the body of this review was written. Somorjai and co-workers ( A l ,A 2 ) have examined the dehydrocyclization of n-heptane to toluene over some platinum single crystal surfaces which had been characterized by LEED. The reactions were carried out at 100°-4000C at total pressures in the region of Torr, and with hydrocarbon/hydrogen ratios in the range 1/1 to 1/4. Over a (111) surface the reaction was found to be detectable at 250"-350°C. However, the reaction becomes self-poisoned due to strongly adsorbed residues which may include surface carbon. These self-poisoning residues are also evident from an increased diffuse backscattering of electrons when the surface is examined by LEED. Over some high index surfaces of orientations nominally close to (997) and (911) which have a step and terrace structure identifiable by LEED, the dehydrocyclization reaction was not only a good deal faster than over a (111) surface, but there was little evidence for a diminution in reaction rate, although an appreciable concentration of strongly adsorbed hydrocarbon
90
J. R. ANDERSON
residues was undoubtedly present. It is also known (AS, Ah) that hydrogen chemisorption is more difficult at a (111) platinum surface than at a stepped, high index surface. It seems reasonable to conclude that two effects are operating. I n the first place, platinum step atoms offer more favorable dehydrocyclization sites than do platinum atoms in a (111) face. This is in agreement with the general concepts outlined earlier in this review. In the second place, self-poisoning is minimized by features such as surface steps which promote hydrogen chemisorption. It should be pointed out that dehydrocyclization was only a minor component of the total reaction which also presumably involved isorneriaation and hydrogenolysis. It will be most desirable to extend this work to the entire reaction, because we have seen in previous sections how the importance of hydrogenolysis is likely to be influenced by the concentration of surface hydrogen. Rooney and co-workers ( A 6 )have studied interconversions between protoadamantane (A’) and adamantane (B’), bicyclo[3.2.2]nonane (C’) and bicyclo[3.3.l]nonane (D’), and between 1,7,7-trimethylbicyclo[2.2.l]heptane (E’) and endo- or ezo-2-methyl-3,3dirnethylbicyclo[2.2. llheptane (F‘ and G’, respectively), over a 2% palladium/silica catalyst in excess hydrogen at temperatures in the range 15O0-35O0C. More recently still there has been a report of the platinum catalyzed conversion of A’ to B’ (-46). Because of alleged steric difficulties in effecting bond shift via 1-3 adsorbed intermediate from molecules A’-G’, it was suggested that the reactions involved intermediates (or perhaps transition states) containing a sort of cyclic C) configuration, with the operation of a sort of quasi-carbonium ion mechanism. Examination of molecular models suggests that one’s expectations about the feasibility of 1-3 bond shift processes with these molecules are not unequivocal. There is no apparent impediment with D’; with A’ and C‘ (both of which are somewhat strained) there is some steric impediment, but a 1-3 adsorbed intermediate does not appear impossible; with E’, F’, and G‘ (all of which are highly strained) the required 1-3 adsorbed intermediate is certainly impossible. However, we have already seen in previous sections that there is evidence for more than one sort of bond shift mechanism, and it is by no means inconceivable that in special circumstances, such as with reactant molecules which are strained or which have other special steric requirements, a particular mechanism may be forced into prominence, although it may be relatively unimportant in less unusual circumstances. Somorjai, G. A . CataZ. Rev. 7( l ) , 87 (1972). Joyner, R. W., Lang, B., and Somorjai, G. A., J . Catul. I n press. Lang, B., Joyner, R. W., and Somorjai, G. A., Surface Sci. 30, 454 (1972). Morgan, A. E., and Somorjai, G. A., Surface Sci. 12,405 (1968). Quinn, H. A., Graham, J. H., McKervey, M. A., and Rooney, J. J., J . CataZ. 26, 333 (1972). A6. Sarnman, N. G. Proc. 6th Int. Congr. CataZ.,197B Comment topaper 48.In press.
Al. A2. A3. A4. A5.
Specificity in Catalytic Hydrogenolysis by Metals J. H. SINFELT Corporate Research Laboratories
Esso Research and Engineering Co. Linden, X e w Jersey
I. Introduction . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 11. General Discussion of Hydrogenolysis Reactions. . . ........ A. Mechanistic Aspects.. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . B. Kinetics . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . ............ 111. Comparison of Metals as Hydrogenolysis Cat A. Activity Patterns. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . B. Product Distributions in Hydrogenolysis. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . IV. Contrast between Ethane Hydrogenolysis and Other Reactions. . . . . . . A. Ethane Hydrogenolysis versus Cyclopropane Hydrogenation. . . . . . . B. Ethane Hydrogenolysis versus Cyclohexane Dehydrogenation.. . . . . V. Conclusion ................................... References . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . ..........
91 92 94
102 106 107 110 116 116
1. Introduction Hydrogenolysis reactions of hydrocarbons have been known for many years ( 1 4 ) . Such reactions involve the rupture of carbon-carbon bonds and the formation of carbon-hydrogen bonds. The reactions are exothermic and are catalyzed by various transition metals. There is a related type of reaction known as hydrocracking which combines the features of metal and acid catalysis (7-11). Bifunctional catalysts consisting of a metal component dispersed on an acidic carrier are commonly employed for this purpose. In general, the nature of the reaction on bifunctional catalysts is different from that on catalysts with purely metallic properties. Hydrocracking on bifunctional catalysts presumably involves a carbonium ion type of reaction mechanism generally associated with acid catalysis, whereas hydrogenolysis on metals is generally interpreted as involving adsorbed hydrocarbon radicals as reaction intermediates. The present article is limited to catalytic hydrogenolysis on metals, and does not consider the subject of hydrocracking on bifunctional metal-acidic oxide catalysts. *
I
92
J. H. SINFELT
In this treatment of the metal-catalyzed hydrogenolysis of hydrocarbons, a general discussion is given first of mechanistic and kinetic aspects of the reactions. The remainder of the article is then concerned with the specificity of metal catalysts for hydrogenolysis reactions. This includes an extensive comparison of the catalytic activities of various metals and an attempt to relate the resulting “activity patterns” to properties of the metallic state. Variations in the distribution of products obtained with different metal catalysts in the hydrogenolysis of selected hydrocarbon reactants are also considered. Finally, the marked differences in the “activity patterns” of metals for hydrogenolysis and certain other hydrocarbon reactions are emphasized. When the results of these several types of comparisons are considered together, there emerges a striking example of specificity in heterogeneous catalysis.
II. General Discussion of Hydrogenolysis Reactions Hydrogenolysis reactions of hydrocarbons on metal catalysts have been investigated in some detail. Extensive studies have been conducted on both alkanes and cycloalkanes. While a number of questions still remain with regard to mechanistic and kinetic details of the reactions, the general features seem reasonably clear. A. MECHANISTIC ASPECTS In discussing the mechanism of hydrogenolysis of saturated hydrocarbons, it is logical to begin by considering the mode of chemisorption of the hydrocarbon reactant. Available evidence indicates that the chemisorption involves rupture of carbon-hydrogen bonds (1.2). At temperatures much lower than are required for hydrogenolysis, the chemisorption of hydrocarbons on metals is accompanied by evolution of hydrogen (13). Furthermore, exchange reactions between paraffins and deuterium to yield deuteroparaffins occur a t similar temperatures. These results indicate that carbon-hydrogen bonds are activated more readily than carbon-carbon bonds, and that dehydrogenative chemisorption of the hydrocarbon is the initial step in hydrogenolysis (14-16). The hydrogen deficient surface species formed from the hydrocarbon then undergoes carbon-carbon bond scission. This is followed by hydrogenation and desorption to complete the reaction. As an example, the hydrogenolysis of ethane to methane can be dissected into the following sequence of reaction steps: CzHa
CzHs (ads)
+ H (ads)
CIH, (ads) + adsorbed
CZH, (ads)
HZ C1fragments + CHI
+ aHz
SPECIFICITY IN CATALYTIC HYDROGENOLYSIS BY METALS
93
The symbol (ads) indicates an adsorbed species, and the quantity a is equal to ( 6 - x)/2. The initial step in the sequence involves rupture of a carbonhydrogen bond to form adsorbed CzHs, which then dehydrogenates further to yield the surface species CZH,. The latter then undergoes carbon-carbon bond scission to form monocarbon fragments which are subsequently hydrogenated to methane. A further consideration in the mechanism of hydrogenolysis of hydrocarbons is the structure of the chemisorbed species that undergoes scission of the carbon-carbon bond. In the case of ethane hydrogenolysis, one readily visualizes bonding of the two carbon atoms in the species C2H, to adjacent metal surface atoms. It is convenient to refer to the adsorbed C2H, as a 1,2-adsorbed intermediate (17). If the intermediate is adsorbed CzH4,then each carbon atom could form a single bond with a surface metal atom. However, if adsorbed CzHz is the intermediate in question, it is conceivable that each carbon atom could form a double bond with a surface metal atom. I n any case, ethane hydrogenolysis is visualized as proceeding via a 1,2-adsorbed intermediate. By contrast, Anderson and Avery conclude that the hydrogenolysis of higher molecular weight alkanes involves 1,3adsorbed intermediates (18). This is based on their observation that neopentane, which can form a 1,3- but not a 1 ,2-adsorbed species, exhibits reactivity about the same as that found for n-butane, isobutane, and isopentane, but much higher than that found for ethane. The isomerization reaction of alkanes on platinum films (18-20) is also considered to proceed via 1 ,&adsorbed intermediates, but for this reaction it has been proposed that adsorbed intermediates involving bonding of three carbon atoms to the surface also play an important role on certain surfaces (18). Such surfaces are characterized by the presence of sites consisting of triplets of equally spaced metal atoms, e.g., triplets of atoms in the (111) face of platinum. As a result of studies on the reactions of various hexanes and methylcyclopentane on platinum catalysts, Gault and associates (21, 22) have proposed that isomerization of the former and hydrogenolysis of the latter are interrelated, both involving a common cyclic intermediate. This was based on a comparison of initial product distributions in methylcyclopentane hydrogenolysis and in the isomerization of n-hexane, 2-methylpentane, and 3-methylpentane. In other work on n-heptane isomerization on a platinum powder ( 2 S ) , it has been concluded that a reaction sequence involving cyclic intermediates is not the primary one, although it may play some role. In any casc, there is now abundant evidence for alkane isomerization on platinum, involving a form of catalysis which is different from that observed on common bifunctional catalysts (d4-26), where acidic sites of the carrier are involved. It has recently been reported that iridium and gold also catalyze the isomerization reaction ( 2 7 ) .
94
J. H. SINFELT
B. KINETICS The first reported work on the kinetics of hydrogenolysis reactions of simple hydrocarbons appears to be that of Taylor and associates a t Princeton (2-4, 14, 15), primarily on the hydrogenolysis of ethane to methane. The studies were conducted on nickel, cobalt, and iron catalysts. More recently, extensive studies on ethane hydrogenolysis kinetics have been conducted on all the group VIII metals and on certain other metals as well (16,28-33). Perhaps the most interesting result of kinetic studies of ethane hydrogenolysis is the strong inverse effect of hydrogen pressure on the reaction rate on most of the metals investigated (Table I). For example, the reaction rate is approximately inversely proportional to the second power of the hydrogen pressure on nickel, rhodium, palladium, and platinum. One explanation for this, originally suggested by the Princeton workers ( 1 5 ) , is that the concentration of the intermpdiate CZH, in the reaction sequence considered in the previous section decreases with inTABLE I Kinetic Parameters jor Ethane Hydrogenolysis on Silica-Supported Metals ( 16 )
Metal Fe co Ni Ru Rh Pd Re 0s
Ir Pt
Temperature range("C)
Ea
239-376 219-259 177-2 19 177-210 190-224 343-377 229-265 125-161 177-210 344-385
30 40.6 32 42 58 31 35 36 5-1
rolb
7LC
md
-
0.6 1.0 1.0 0.8 0.8 0.9 0.5 0.6 0.7 0.9
+ 0.5 -0.8 -2.4
3 . 0 x 1025 4 . 9 x 1031 1 . 3 X loz8 ~ i . 8x 1031 3.7 X 1 . 8 x 1028
7.0
x
1030
5 . 2 X lo2* 5 . 9 x 1031
-1.3 -2.2 -2.5 +0.3 -1.2 -1.6
-2.5
T ( n ,m ) ("C). 270 219 177 188 214 354 250 152 210 357
Apparent activation energy, kcallmole, determined from the temperature dependence of the rate T O a t ethane and hydrogen partial pressures of 0.030 and 0.20 atm, respectively. h Preexporiential factor, molecules/sec/cni2, in the equation, ro = To' exp (-E/RT). * Exponent on ethane pressure in experimental power rate law. d Exponent on hydrogen pressure in experimental power rate law. Temperature at which exponents on ethane and hydrogen pressures were determined.
SPECIFICITY I N CATALYTIC HMROGENOLYSIS BY METALS
95
creasing hydrogen pressure. In the original kinetic analysis of Cimino et al. (15), i t was assumed that equilibrium was maintained between adsorbed C2H, and ethane and hydrogen in the gas phase. It was further assumed that carbon-carbon scission resulted from the interaction of adsorbed CZH, with a molecule of hydrogen and that this step was rate determining. No allowance was made for a possible competition between hydrogen and hydrocarbon for the surface. The kinetic analysis led to a rate expression of the form
Here p~ and pH are the partial pressures of ethane and hydrogen, respectively, and the parameter a is equal to (6 - x)/2. This analysis was subscquently generalized to include cases in which equilibrium is not established betwccn adsorbed C2H, and gas phase ethane (16). Provided that surface coverage by adsorbed species is low, and that equilibrium is maintained between the surface species CZH5 and CZH,, and HZin the gas phase, a kinetic analysis leads to the rate expression
The parameter kl is the rate constant for the initial ethane chemisorption step leading to formation of adsorbed C2&, while the parameter b is equal to kl'lk3KZ. The rate constant kl' refers to the reaction step, CzHs (ads) H (ads) + CzH6, while the rate constant k3 applies to the step, CZH, (ads) Hz + adsorbed C1 fragments. The equilibrium constant KZ applies t o the reaction, CZH5 (ads) H (ads) CZH, (ads) aHz. The kinetic analysis accounts very well for the kinetic data on ethane hydrogenolysis on a cobalt catalyst over a wide range of temperatures and reactant partial pressures (16, 3 2 ) . I n this case the parameter b decreases with increasing temperature. At low temperatures the term bpH(a-l) is large compared to unity in the denominator, but a t sufficiently high temperatures it becomes negligible in comparison with unity. This means that a t low temperatures equilibrium is cff ectively maintained between adsorbed CZH, and gas phase ethane. However, at high temperatures the chemisorption of the ethane is effectively irrevcrsible, so that the overall reaction consists (wentially of a sequence of irreversible steps. This lattcr case is similar to the example of methylcyclohexane dehydrogenation on platinum discussed previously by the writer (26,34). In applying the foregoing kinetic analysis to data on ethane hydrogenolysis on the group VIII metals, one finds for most of the metals that the value of z in C2H, is equal to zero, i.e., the surface intermediate is a CZ species which is totally devoid of hydrogen ( 1 6 ) . This conclusion does not conflict with known facts. However, a value of zero for x for most of the
+
+
+
+
96
J. H. SINFELT
group VIII metals seems somewhat extreme, and may in part be a consequence of assumptions in the kinetic analysis. I n the analysis, it was assumed that a molecule of hydrogen participated in the rate-controlling step. If hydrogen were not involved in this step, ie., if the species CZH, decomposed into monocarbon fragments without interaction with a hydrogen molecule, rate equations (1) and ( 2 ) would become (34a, 34b)
With the revised kinetic analysis, a value of zero for x (i.e,, a = 3) gives the best fit for only platinum, palladium, and rhodium (Table 11). For iridium, osmium, ruthenium, and nickel, a value of 2 for x (a= 2 ) gives the best fit to the data, while for cobalt the best value of x is 4 (a = 1). I n considering the variation of x among the metals, it seems reasonable that x would decrease as the ratio of the dehydrogenation activity to hydrogenolysis activity of the metal increases. It is very likely that this ratio is higher for platinum, palladium, and rhodium than for the other metals in Table 11. In the case of platinum and palladium, the higher ratio is due primarily to the very low hydrogenolysis activities of these metals, TABLE I1 Analysis of Power Rate Law in Ethane HydrogenolysisComparison of Observed and Calculated Exponents on Hydrogen Pressure
Exponent on Hz Pressure
Catalyst Fe co Ni Ru Rh Pd Re 0s
Ir Pt 4
2"
ab
Observed (m)
4 2 2 0 0 2 2 0
1 2 2 3 3 2 2 3
+0.5 -0.8 -2.4 -1.3 -2.2 -2.5 +0.3 -1.2 -1.6 -2.5
Calculated (-nu)
-1.0 -2.0 -1.6 -2.4 -2.7 -1.2 -1.4 -2.7
Number of hydrogen atoms in the species C2H,. Defined by the expression, a = (6- 2)/2.
SPECIFICITY IN CATALYTIC HYDROGENOLYSIS BY METALS
97
to be discussed in a subsequent section of this article. In the case of rhodium, which has high hydrogenolysis activity, the higher ratio must then be due to higher dehydrogenation activity. This is supported by the particularly high activity of rhodium compared to other metals for ethane-deuterium exchange (35) and ethylene hydrogenation (36-38).Thus, for platinum, palladium, and rhodium it would appear that any intermediate dicarbon surface species formed in the reaction path from CzHe to the final dicarbon species CzH, has a high probability of undergoing further dehydrogenation as opposed to carbon-carbon scission. The metals iron and rhenium in Table I1 present a special case, in that both exhibit positive dependency of the rate on hydrogen pressure. Such a dependency on hydrogen pressure is inconsistent with rate equations (3) and (4),indicating that the presently revised kinetic analysis is not applicable to these metals. Perhaps in these cases the rate of hydrogenolysis is determined by the hydrogenationdesorption of the monocarbon fragments resulting from the scission of the carbon-carbon bond (39). The kinetic analyses leading t o rate equations (1)-(4) are based on the simplifying assumption that competition between hydrogen and hydrocarbon for surface sites is insignificant. This assumption may be challenged on general grounds (40). If such an effect were significant, it might conceivably alter our conclusions on the composition of the surface species CzH, in the general reaction scheme described here. Although there is uncertainty concerning the detailed nature of a surface intermediate such as C2H,, the general nature of the steps involved in the reaction sequence would appear t o be well established. I n any case, the simplified kinetic analyses of the hydrogenolysis reaction have proved to be very useful in interpreting data on a variety of metal catalysts, and have effectively guided investigations in this area.
111. Comparison of Metals as Hydrogenolysis Catalysts A comparison of various metals as catalysts for the hydrogenolysis of hydrocarbons reveals a wide variation in catalytic activity, even among such closely related metals as the noble metals of group VIII of the periodic table. Striking differences in the distribution of hydrogenolysis products have also been revealed in studies on selected hydrocarbon reactants. These features are emphasized in the following discussion of activity patterns and product distributions in hydrogenolysis.
PATTERNS A. ACTIVITY Specific catalytic activities of a number of silica-supported metals have been determined for the hydrogenolysis of ethane to methane (16, 29-31,
98
J. H. SINFELT
33). Data for the metals of group VIII and for rhenium in group VIIA are given in Fig. 1, which is divided into three fields separating the metals of the first, second, and third transition series. The specific activity is defined as the activity per unit surface area of metal. Metal surface areas required for the determination of specific activities are derived from measurements
108 -
- 44
Ni
- 42
106-
lo4
-
Mn
- 40
d---------
A
A
102 -
4. ' \ -
1
I
I
I
-38
\
I
0s
- 52 - 50 - 48
-
46
- 44
1I
PERIODIC GROUP NUMBER
FIQ.1. Catalytic activities of metals for ethane hydrogenolysis in relation to the percentage d character of the metallic bond. The closed points represent activities compared at a temperature of 205°C and ethane and hydrogen pressures of 0.030 and 0.20 atm, respectively, and the open points represent percentage d character. Three separate fields are shown in the figure to distinguish the metals in the different long periods of the periodic table.
SPECIFICITY IN CATALYTIC HYDROGENOLYSIS BY METALS
99
of the chemisorption of a simple gas, generally hydrogen or carbon monoxide (16, 29-31, 41), which adsorbs very selectively on the metal component of the catalyst. The chemisorption experiments are conveniently made a t room temperature. The method involves a determination of the number of molecules required to form a chemisorbed monolayer on a given amount of supported metal. This quantity is derived from an adsorption isotherm a t conditions such that saturation of the metal surface is achieved. If the stoichiometry of the adsorption process is known, i.e., the number of molecules adsorbed per surface metal atom, it is then a simple matter to determine thc number of metal surface atoms for a given amount of metal in the catalyst. By adopting an appropriate value for the area associated with a single atom in the metal surface, as derived from the lattice spacing of the metal, one can compute the surface area per unit weight of metal. The specific activities in Fig. 1 are relative reaction rates per unit surface area of metal at a temperature of 205OC and ethane and hydrogen partial pressures of 0.030 and 0.20 atm, respectively (16). Absolute values of the reaction rate ro at these conditions can be determined from the parameters E and ro' in Table I, using the experimentally determined relation
ro = rol exp( - E / R T )
(5)
Activities of the group IB metals (copper, silver, and gold) are not shown in Fig. 1, since they are too low to be measured satisfactorily in the same apparatus used for the other metals in Fig. 1. Measurable reaction rates could not be observed on these metals a t temperatures as high as 450°C, indicating that the activities arc pcrhaps several orders of magnitude lower than the activities of the least active group VIII metals. I n the case of copper, it had been reported previously that the hydrogenolysis activity, while small compared t o that of a metal such as nickel, was high enough to give measurable reaction rates at temperatures in the vicinity of 300°C (16, 29). Further work ( 4 2 ) ,however, has failed to confirm this result, and suggests that the copper catalyst used in the earlier work may have been contaminated with a small amount of an active impurity. Although the more recent work on copper indicates that the hydrogenolysis activity is much lower than was originally reported, this has had no important bearing on conclusions rcgarding the activity patterns of metals for hydrogenolysis. In comparing the catalytic activities of metals for ethane hydrogenolysis, it is instructive to consider the variation in activity as a function of the position of the metal within a given period of the periodic table. The data are most complete for the metals of the third transition series. Beginning with rhenium in group VIIA, and proceeding in the direction of increasing atomic number to osmium, iridium, and platinum in group VIII and on to gold in group IB, the hydrogenolysis activity passes through a maximum
100
J. H. SINFELT
value a t osmium. From osmium to platinum alone, the activity decreases by eight orders of magnitude. A similar variation is observed from ruthenium to palladium in the second transition series. It is also probable that the hydrogenolysis activity of the metals in the second transition series attains a maximum value a t ruthenium, much the same as it does a t osmium in the third transition series. This is supported by recent data on the group VIA metal, molybdenum, in the second transition series, which indicate that the hydrogenolysis activity of this metal is virtually negligible by comparison with that of ruthenium ( 4 3 ) . Indeed, the hydrogenolysis of ethane on molybdenum proceeds readily only a t temperatures high enough to cause carbiding of the molybdenum, i.e., about 375”-400°C. Thus, for the metals of the second and third transition series, there is a similar pattern of variation of catalytic activity for the hydrogenolysis of ethane. The pattern is observed also in n-heptane hydrogenolysis (23), as shown in Fig. 2, and in the hydrogenolysis of neopentane ( 2 7 ) . It is significant that the same pattern is observed with highly dispersed supported metals as with unsupported metals of much lower dispersion. The ethane and neopentane studies were made with supported metal catalysts, while the n-heptane studies were made with metal powders. While metal dispersion and support effects can have a significant influence in hydrogenolysis (16), they are still not of sufficient magnitude to have an important bearing on “activity patterns’’ observed in the comparison of various metals. I
I
I
Ru
Vllll
VlllZ
VlH3
PERIODIC GROUP NUMBER
FIQ.2. Catalytic activities of group VIII noble metals for n-heptane hydrogenolysis. The activities are compared at a temperature of 205” C at 1 atm pressure and a H*/nC? mole ratio of 5/1 (23).
SPECIFICITY IN CATALYTIC HYDROGENOLYSIS BY METALS
101
I n considering the kinetic parameters for ethane hydrogenolysis compiled in Table I, it may be noted for the metals of the second and third transition series that the enormous decrease in catalytic activity from ruthenium to palladium and from osmium to platinum within group VIII is accompanied by a large increase in apparent activation energy. Thus, for these metals it appears that the variation in activity is due primarily to changes in activation energy, although there is a n indication of some variation in the preexponential factor and a corresponding ‘(compensation effect.” I n the first transition series, the group VIII metals (iron, cobalt, and nickel) are much more active for hydrogenolysis than copper in group IB. In this respect, the first transition series is very similar to the second and third transition series just discussed. However, maximum catalytic activity in the first transition series is observed for the metal in the third subgroup within group VIII, i.e., nickel, whereas in the second and third transition series the maximum activity is observed for the metal in the first subgroup within group VIII, namely, ruthenium or osmium. Thus, the pattern of variation of hydrogenolysis activity among the group VIII metals of the first transition series is somewhat different from that observed for the corresponding metals of the second and third transition series. This could be considered as a reflection of the known differences in chemical properties between elements of the first transition series on the one hand, and the corresponding elements of the second and third transition series on the other (44). Included with the plots of hydrogenolysis activities of the metals in Fig. 1 are plots of the percentage d character of the metallic bond, a quantity introduced in Pauling’s valence bond theory of metals to represent the extent of participation of d orbitals in the bonding between atoms in a metal lattice ( 4 5 ) . For the metals within a given transition series, the pattern of variation of hydrogenolysis activity from one metal to another is very similar to the pattern of variation of percentage d character. On further consideration of the relation between hydrogenolysis activity and percentage d character for all the metals of Fig. 1, it can be seen that the metals of the first transition series (which include iron, cobalt, and nickel) behave as a separate class from the metals of the second and third transition series (which include the group VIII noble metals). For the metals iron, cobalt, and nickel in the first transition series, the hydrogenolysis activities are comparable to those of metals with significantly higher d character in the second and third transition series. Thus, while there is a degree of correlation between hydrogenolysis activity and percentage d character, it is clear that this parameter alone is not adequate for characterizing the catalytic activity of transition metals for hydrogenolysis (16).
102
J. H. SINFELT
In studies of the activities of metals for the catalytic hydrogenolysis of alkanes, the available data indicate that activity comparisons are not strongly affected by the particular alkane used as a reactant. However, the rate of hydrogenolysis increases with the carbon number of the alkane, as indicated by the results of several investigations (19,23, 4 6 ) . Thus, the rates of hydrogenolysis of n-heptane on unsupported metals in Fig. 2 are several orders of magnitude higher than the rates of ethane hydrogenolysis a t 205°C on the same metals supported on silica. Rates for the latter reaction can be found in reference 30 or calculated from the Arrhenius parameters in Table I. The comparison of ethane and n-heptanc hydrogenolysis rates can only be considered as a rough indication of the effect of molecular size on the rate of hydrogenolysis, since the possibilities of metal dispersion and carrier effects have been ignored. Nevertheless, an independent study of the hydrogenolysis of a series of alkanes on a supported ruthenium catalyst showed an effect of similar magnitude for varying molecular size ( 4 6 ) .The increase in rate with increasing molecular size would seem to be attributable, a t least in part, to lower average dissociation energies of carbon-carbon bonds in larger alkane molecules ( 4 7 ) .
B. PRODUCT DISTRIBUTIONS IN HYDROGENOLYSIS I n the hydrogenolysis of saturated hydrocarbons possessing a number of carbon-carbon bonds, which are not all identical, there is the possibility of different rates of rupture of carbon-carbon bonds a t different locations in the molecule. Of particular interest in catalysis is the observation that the distribution of primary hydrogenolysis products (i.e., the "cracking pattern") depends on the metal catalyst used. A classical example of specificity in metal-catalyzed hydrogenolysis is the highly selective attack of nickel catalysts on the terminal carbon-carbon bonds in alkanes (5, 48, 4 9 ) . For example, in the hydrogenolysis of n-hexane on a nickel-silica catalyst a t lSO"C, the only products observed a t very low conversion are methane and n-pentane, formed in cquimolar amounts ( 4 9 ) . Similarly, the hydrogenolysis of 2-methylpentane and 3-methylpentanc yields methane, n-pentane, and isopentane as the only primary products a t low conversions, the mole fraction of methane in the product corresponding closely to the combined mole fraction of normal and isopentanes. The ratio of isopentane to n-pentane in the products of hydrogenolysis of 2-methylpentane and 3-mcthylpentane is very close to 0.5 and 2.0, respectively, which is expected on the basis of purely statistical considerations of the products resulting from scission of terminal carbon-carbon bonds ( 4 9 ) . The situation with platinum catalysts contrasts markedly with that on nickel catalysts, in that the rupture of different carbon-carbon bonds is
SPECIFICITY IN CATALYTIC HYDROGENOLYSIS BY METALS
103
nonselective. Thus, in the hydrogenolysis of n-hexane over a platinumsilica catalyst, the rates of rupture of various carbon-carbon bonds are nearly the same, giving a spectrum of primary products comprising all of the normal alkanes from methane through n-pentane in comparable molar quantities ( 4 9 ) . The striking specificity possible in the hydrogenolysis of hydrocarbons on metals is clearly demonstrated by recent studies conducted in our laboratory on the hydrogenolysis of n-heptane on a number of group VIII noble metal catalysts ( 2 3 ) .To eliminate carrier effects of the kind which are operative in bifunctional metal-acidic oxide catalysts, unsupported metal powders were employed in the investigation. Hydrogenolysis was the predominant reaction on all the metals except platinum, on which extensive isomerization and dehydrocyclization were also observed. The extents of the various reactions at low total conversions are summarized for the different metals in Table 111. The products of the isomerization reaction are methylhexanes and dimethylpentanes, while the dehydrocyclization reaction yields dimethylcyclopentanes, methylcyclohexanc, and toluene. The data on the various metals in Table I11 were obtained a t widely different temperatures, as necessitated by the huge differences in the catalytic activities of the metals. At the conditions employed with the metals ruthenium, rhodium, and iridium, the thermodynamics are unfavorable for the occurrence of the dehydrocyclization reaction. However, in the case of platinum and palladium, for which the temperatures were high enough to obtain dehydrocyclization, the reaction occurred to a significant extent only on the platinum. In its ability t o catalyze isomerization and de-
TABLE I11 Reactions of n-Heptane on Metals in the Presence of Hydrogene ($3)
Metal Pd Rh Ru
a
Percent Percent Tempera- total con- hydroture ("C) version genolysis
rt
300 113 88 275
Ir
125
6.4 2.9 4.0 2.3 9.4 21.4 1.5
Percent isomerization
Percent dehydrocyclization
0.4 0.2 0.3 0.7 3.8 10.0 0.2
0.2 1.0 2.2 3.4 -
5.8 2.7 3.7 0.G 3.4 8.0 1.3
Conditions: 1 atm, H2/nC7mole ratio = 5.
104
J. H. SINFELT
hydrocyclization to a degree a t least roughly comparable to hydrogenolysis, platinum clearly distinguishes itself from the other metals. The distribution of products from the hydrogenolysis of n-heptane varies markedly among the group VIII noble metals, as shown clearly by the data in Table IV. On palladium and rhodium the terminal carboncarbon bond in n-heptane is attacked almost exclusively, yielding methane and n-hexane as the products a t low conversion levels. However, on the other metals, especially platinum and iridium, there is a much less selective type of cracking leading to a spectrum of primary products present in roughly comparable amounts. No simple relation exists between the level of hydrogenolysis activity and the type of “cracking pattern” observed. For example, platinum and palladium, despite their similar low hydrogenolysis activities, exhibit markedly different distributions of primary products. Furthermore, iridium and rhodium give widely different product distributions, although they are both highly active for hydrogenolysis. The highly selective rupture of the terminal carbon-carbon bond on palladium and rhodium has been observed by others, e.g., in n-hexane hydrogenolysis on a palladium-silica catalyst (50) and in n-butane hydrogenolysis on an evaporated rhodium film (19). The less selective type of “cracking pattern” on platinum has been observed repeatedly (23, 48-50). I n considering ways to rationalize the differences in product distribution in Table IV, it is speculated that the ability of the surface atoms of certain metals to exhibit different valence states may be important (2.3). It has previously been suggested by Boudart and Ptak (27) that the ability of platinum and iridium to catalyze the isomerization of neopentane could be a consequence of the variable surface valency of these metals proposed by TABLE IV Distribution of n-Heptane Hydrogenolysis Products Over Metalsa (23)
Metal Pd Rh Ru Pt Ir
Percent Tempera- total con- __ ture (“C) version C1 300 113 88 275 125
6.4 2.9 4.0 2.3 1.5
46 42 28 31 21
Distribution of hydrogenolysis products (Mole percent)* C2
CS
4 5 12 13 21
-
Conditions: 1 atm, H*/nC, mole ratio = 5. All products are n-paraffins.
4 13 17 15
nC4 nCs 3 12 16 14
nC6
4 46 5 4 1 10 25 9 14 14 15
SPECIFICITY IN CATALYTIC
/c C
I1
M
\ / C4H9 C
I
M
HYDROGENOLYSIS BY METALS
/ and
c\
/ C4H9
C
C
M
M
I
105
II
FIG.3. Structures of adsorbed intermediates formed from n-heptane on metals ($3).
Plummer and Rhodin ( 5 1 ) .The proposal of the latter workers was based on field desorption measurements of the energy of binding of various transition metal atoms to a tungsten single crystal tip. I n considering possible implications of this proposal with regard to “cracking patterns” on metals, it is useful to apply the ideas of Anderson and Avery (52) on the structure of the chemisorbed intermediates in the isomerization and hydrogenolysis of simple aliphatic hydrocarbons. According to these workers, a lf3-adsorbed intermediate is involved, with one of the carbon atoms being doubly bonded to a surface metal atom. In the hydrogenolysis of n-heptane, adsorbed species of the type shown in Fig. 3 may be visualized, where M refers to a surface metal atom. If the carbon-metal double bond is located primarily a t the terminal carbon atom, and if it is assumed that the carbon-carbon bond adjacent to the carbon-metal double bond cracks preferentially, it follows that methane and n-hexane will be the principal products of hydrogenolysis. If we propose that this is the case for palladium and rhodium, we are then left with the question of how these metals differ from metals such as platinum and iridium. If the surface atoms of these latter two metals can exist in different valence states, it seems possible that the carbon-metal double bond could shift readily from the terminal carbon atom to another carbon atom along the hydrocarbon chain, yielding a species such as the second one shown in Fig. 3. Scission of carbon-carbon bonds in the central part of the molecule, in addition to cracking a t the end of the molecule, could then occur readily. This leads to a nonselective “cracking pattern.” I n recent discussions of the mechanism of hydrogenolysis and isomerization of saturated hydrocarbons on platinum, it has been suggested that charge transfer from the adsorbate to the metal occurs (49, 52), with the result that a “carbonium ion-like’’ intermediate is formed. The extensive cracking of internal carbon-carbon bonds in alkanes, and the simultaneous skeletal isomerization reaction, are certainly consistent with such a suggestion. Reactions of this type are commonly observed on acid catalysts, and are generally associated with carbonium ion mechanisms ( 5 3 ) . I n the hydrogenolysis of the higher alkanes on the nonnoble group VIII metals (i.e., iron, cobalt, and nickel) , the mode of cracking is very different from that observed on the noble metals of group VIII ( 4 9 , 5 0 ) .On nickel,
106
J. H. SINFELT
for example, the products of hydrogenolysis are consistent with a reaction scheme involving successive demethylation of the hydrocarbon chain. According to this scheme, cracking occurs only a t terminal carbon-carbon bonds, so that one of the fragments is always a C1 species which is hydrogenated to form methane. The other fragment then has one of two fates. It can undergo further cracking at the terminal carbon-carbon bond to produce additional methane, or it can be hydrogenated and desorbed into the gas phase. I n the hydrogenolysis of various hexane isomers on nickel (@), the methane formation is approximated closely by the expression
Here C1,Cz, etc., represent the moles of alkanes of various carbon number in the product. According to this expression, one mole of methane is formed per mole of Cg, two moles are formed per mole of C,, etc. At the low to moderate conversions investigated, cracking of C2 fragments was apparently negligible. The expression also applies reasonably well to data obtained on cobalt, but not to data on iron (49).On moving from nickel t o cobalt to iron, one finds that the initial distribution of products shifts markedly in the direction of lower carbon number alkanes, suggesting that desorption of products becomes strongly limiting. In the case of iron, unlike that of nickel and cobalt, extensive cracking of Cz fragments must also occur, since the formation of methane is much higher than would correspond to the expression just considered. This is consistent with a low rate of desorption relative to carbon-carbon bond rupture. The successive demethylation scheme of hydrogenolysis just discussed for iron, cobalt, and nickel clearly does not apply to the noble metals of group VIII. This can be seen by examining the product distribution data in Table IV. The amounts of methane observed are much lower than would be expected if the hydrogenolysis occurred by successive demethylation steps. Thus, we have another indication that the noble and nonnoble metals of group VIII behave as two separate classes with regard to their catalytic properties in the hydrogenolysis of hydrocarbons.
IV. Contrast between Ethane Hydrogenolysis and Other Reactions Comparisons of the activities of various metal catalysts for reactions of hydrocarbons involving hydrogen as a reactant or product reveal activity patterns which are strongly dependent on the particular reaction considcrcd. Several examples are discussed in the following subsections of this article.
SPECIFICITY IN CATALYTIC
HYDROGENOLYSIS BY METALS
107
A. ETHANEHYDROGENOLYSIS VERSUS CYCLOPROPANE HYDROGENATION A reaction which provides an interesting contrast with ethane hydrogenolysis on the group VIII noble metals is the hydrogenation of cyclopropane to propane. The reaction has been investigated rather extensively by several groups of workers ( 5 4 4 5 ) . Cyclopropane hydrogenation occurs cleanly on platinum, palladium, rhodium, and iridium (63). However, on the rcmainder of the group VIII metals cyclopropane also undergoes a fragmentation reaction yielding methane and ethane as products (60, 61, 65-65). This fragmentation reaction appears to be a primary reaction occurring in parallel with the hydrogenation reaction. I n the case 106,
I
I
I
CYCLOPRDPANE HYDROGENATlOl -1O'C
-kI/-
1 -
I
I
I
I
I
a V
.'
n ul
Ru 0
w
0s
ETHANE HYDRDGENOLYSIS 205T
\
I-
K
\ lo4
I
\
\
\, I
1
Vllll
I
VII12
hp'
Pd
V11I3
PERIODIC GROUP NUMBER
FIa. 4. Comparison of activity patterns of the group VIII noble metals for cyclopropane hydrogenation and ethane hydrogenolysis. The activities were all determined at hydrogen and hydrocarbon partial pressures of 0.20 and 0.030 atm, respectively (63).
108
J. H. SINFELT
of the group VIII noble metals, it is interesting that the fragmentation reaction is limited to the two metals, ruthenium and osmium, which are most active for the hydrogenolysis of ethane. Comparisons of the group VIII noble metals as catalysts for the hydrogenation of cyclopropane to propane and for the hydrogenolysis of ethane to methane reveal striking differences in activity patterns ( 6 3 ) . Catalytic activities of the group VIII noble metals supported on silica are shown in Fig. 4.In the upper field of Fig. 4,the cyclopropane hydrogenation activities of the metals are compared, while in the lower field activities are compared for ethane hydrogenolysis. In the triad of metals comprising osmium, iridium, and platinum in the third transition series of the periodic table, the activity for cyclopropane hydrogenation increases in the direction of increasing atomic number from osmium to platinum. The pattern for ethane hydrogenolysis is exactly opposite, such that the activity decreases markedly from osmium to platinum. In the triad of metals comprising I
I
I
60 Pd a/
4 Pt 50
,/
ETHANE HYDROGENOLYSIS Rh
--
"/'
40
u
E
1 0
30 w
20
CYCLDPROPANE HYDROGENATION
\ 0s
-0
lr
\
Pd
o a
10
Ru
0 Rh
0
I Vllll
I
I
VII12
VlH3
Pt
PERIODIC GROUP NUMBER
FIG.5. Apparent activation energies of the ethane hydrogenolysis and cyclopropane hydrogenation reactions on the group VIII noble metals. The activation energies were determined a t hydrogen and hydrocarbon partial pressures of 0.20 and 0.030 atm, respectively (6'3).
SPECIFICITY IN CATALYTIC HYDROGENOLYSIS BY METALS
109
ruthenium, rhodium, and palladium in the second transition series, the catalytic activity for cyclopropane hydrogenation passes through a maximum a t rhodium, while the activity for ethane hydrogenolysis decreases continuously from ruthenium to palladium. The cyclopropane hydrogenation reaction occurs much more readily than ethane hydrogenolysis on all of the group VIII noble metals, as is evident from the much lower temperatures required ( - 10 versus 205°C in Fig. 4). In addition, the range of activities of the metals in Fig. 4 is much smaller for cyclopropane hydrogenation than for ethane hydrogenolysis, spanning three orders of magnitude for the former as compared to eight orders of magnitude for the latter. Correspondingly, the apparent activation energies of the cyclopropane hydrogenation reaction on the various group VIII noble metals are virtually identical, whereas the activation energies of ethane hydrogenolysis vary markedly on these same metals (Fig. 5). Furthermore, for all the metals in Fig. 5 the apparent activation energy is much lower for cyclopropane hydrogenation than for ethane hydrogenolysis. Within each of the two triads of group VIII noble metals (Ru, Rh, Pd and Os, Ir, Pt) , the activity pattern of the metals for ethylene hydrogenation is the same as that shown for cyclopropane hydrogenation in Fig. 4, and the range of variation of activities is even smaller (66). Furthermore, the activation energy for ethylene hydrogenation is about the same on the various group VIII noble metals (679, and is similar in magnitude to that found for cyclopropane hydrogenation. Similar statements are applicable to the hydrogenation of benzene on these metals (68). Thus, the hydrogenation reactions of cyclopropane, ethylene, and benzene all provide the same general picture when the catalytic properties of the group VIII noble metals are compared. However, these reactions as a group present a marked contrast with the hydrogenolysis of ethane. The fact th a t cyclopropane hydrogenation is grouped with ethylene and benzene hydrogenation, despite the fact that cyclopropane is formally a saturated hydrocarbon, is not particularly surprising. It is well known that the bonding in cyclopropane is very different from that in alkanes in general (69).The view is commonly held that the electrons of the cyclopropane ring are partially delocalized, which is consistent with the classification of cyclopropane as a n unsaturated molecule. As a catalytic probe for investigating differences in the properties of the group VIII noble metals, ethane hydrogenolysis is much more sensitive to differences among the metals than are the hydrogenation reactions of cyclopropane, ethylene, and benzene. This conclusion is derived simply from a consideration of the magnitudes of differences in catalytic activities and apparent activation energies obtained in comparisons of the metals. It is interesting that various metal-catalyzed hydrogenation reactions of hydro-
110
J. H. SINFELT
carbons have been classificd as “facile” reactions (62, 70-72), since the state of metal dispersion has essentially no effect on the specific catalytic activity of the metal for these reactions. By contrast, the specific activity of a metal for ethane hydrogenolysis is a function of the state of metal dispersion (16). The nature of bonding of intermediates to the surface must be quite different for the two kinds of reactions. Ethane hydrogenolysis is believed to involve dissociatively chemisorbed hydrocarbon intermediates (16) which are presumably multiply bonded to the surface. Hydrogenation reactions, however, do not require the formation of dissociatively chemisorbed hydrocarbon intermediates, and the suggestion has been made that such reactions proceed via pi-bonded intermediates ( 7 3 ) .
B. ETHANE HYDROGENOLYSIS VERSUS CYCLOHEXANE DEHYDROGENATION A second reaction which contrasts markedly with ethane hydrogenolysis is the dehydrogenation of cyclohexane to benzene, as demonstrated in a recent detailed investigation on copper-nickel alloy catalysts ( 7 4 ) . The use of alloys to investigate the relationship between catalytic activity and the electronic structure of metals dates back to early ideas of Schwab (75) and Dowden ( 7 6 , 7 7 ) .Alloys of a group I B metal with a group VIII metal, such as copper-nickel, have received particular attention, especially for reactions such as the hydrogcnation of benzene (7’8-83) and ethylene (83-86). One might reasonably anticipate that the dehydrogenation of cyclohexane to benzene would exhibit behavior similar to benzene hydrogenation when copper is added to nickel. However, it does not follow that conclusions based on studies of these reactions would necessarily be applicable to ethane hydrogenolysis. Indeed, the recent data obtained on ethane hydrogenolysis indicate a very different effect of adding copper to nickel. Specific activities of a series of copper-nickel catalysts for ethane hydrogenolysis and cyclohexane dehydrogenation are shown in Fig. 6 as a function of the catalyst composition ( 7 4 ) . The alloys were prepared by a method involving coprecipitation of metal carbonates, conversion to mixed oxides, and reduction in flowing hydrogen at elevated temperature. The alloys were characterized by X-ray diffraction and magnetic measurements, and reaction rates werc determined at low conversion levels in a quasidifferential reactor. Kinetic parameters for the ethane hydrogenolysis reaction are summarized in Table V. Thc specific activities in Fig. 6 are reaction rates a t 3 1 6 ° C . From the figure it is clear that the catalytic activity of nickel for ethane hydrogenolysis decreases markedly and continuously as copper is alloyed with it. Addition of only 5 at.% copper decreases the hydrogenolysis activity by three orders of magnitude. With further addition
SPECIFICITY IN CATALYTIC HYDROGENOLYSIS BY METALS
I
I
I
I
111
I
I
lot
lo5 I
0
T
CYCLOHEXANE DEHYDROGENATION
.-(
.-I 0
, " lo4 5 I
f
I
\
G
J
lo3
3
V w J
-z> 102 0
t > + V a
10
1
I
I
1
I
1
I
0
20
40
60
80
100
ATOM % COPPER
FIG.6. Activities of copper-nickel alloy catalysts for the hydrogenolysis of ethane to methane and the dehydrogenation of cyclohexane to benzene. The activities refer t o reaction rates a t 316" C. Ethane hydrogenolysis activities were obtained a t ethane and hydrogen pressures of 0.030 and 0.20 atm., respectively. Cyclohexane dehydrogenation activities were obtained at cyclohexane and hydrogen pressures of 0.17 and 0.83 atm, respectively ( 7 4 ) .
of copper, the activity continues to decline, such that the activity of a catalyst containing 63.3 at.% copper is five orders of magnitude lower than that of pure nickel. The activities of catalysts containing more than 95 at.% copper are too low to measure in the apparatus employed in the investigation. In marked contrast to the ethane hydrogenolysis results, the catalytic activity of nickel for cyclohexane dehydrogenation increases initially with addition of small amounts of copper. The activity is then fairly insensitive to alloy composition over a wide range, but finally decreases sharply as the composition approaches pure copper. Interestingly, the activity of a catalyst containing 95.6 at. % copper is about the same as that of the pure nickel catalyst, although the activity of the copper itself is about two orders of magnitude lower than that of the nickel. The initial promotional effect of
112
J. H. SINFELT
TABLE V Summary of Kinetic Parameters for Ethane Hydrogenolysis on Copper-Nickel Alloys ( 7 4 )
Composition ' Temperature (at. % CU) range ("C) 0 6.2 10.3 31.5 42.4 52.7 63.3 74.0
226-268 308-339 326-356 355-396 352-395 383408 383440 424455
Ea
rOf
n=
ma
T(n, m ) ("C).
43 51 51 50 51 50 48 47
2 . 1 x 1031 3 . 2 X 1031 1.1 x 1 0 3 1 6 . 0 X 1029 5 . 2 X 1029 2 . 0 X 1029 1 . 8 X lo** 6 . 5 x 1027
1.0 0.9 0.9 0.8 0.8 -
-2.1 -1.3 -1.3 -1.3 -1.2 -1.2
238 33 1 377 384 399 420
Apparent activation energy, kcal/mole. Preexponential factor, molecules/sec cm2, in the equation r,, = r: exp( -E / R T ) . c Order with respect to ethane. d Order with respect to hydrogen. Temperature at which the reaction orders were determined. a
b
copper on nickel has also been reported for the hydrogenation of benzene and ethylene (81, 85,8486). I n considering the effect of copper on the activity of nickel for ethane hydrogenolysis, we note first the previously mentioned correlation of hydrogenolysis activity with the percentage d character of the metallic bond for metals within a particular transition series (Fig. 1 ) . According to this correlation, the hydrogenolysis activity of nickel should decrease when copper is alloyed with it, since the percentage d character decreases (Fig. 7 ) . However, examination of Figs. 6 and 7 reveals that the hydrogenolysis activity decreases much more sharply than percentage d character with the initial incremental additions of copper to nickel. This could be reconciled if there was a surface region in the alloys with a much higher copper content than that which corresponds to the bulk composition. One might then consider the pcrcentage d character corresponding to the surface region, rather than the bulk. If copper concentrates strongly in the surface region of dilute copper-nickel alloys, the percentage d character in this region would also decline sharply on addition of small amounts of copper to nickel. The hydrogenolysis activities of copper-nickel alloys may also be considered from a different point of view. In studies of the kinetics of ethane hydrogenolysis on nickel and many other metals, it has been concluded that chemisorption of ethane occurs with extensive dissociation of carbon-
SPECIFICITY IN CATALYTIC HYDROGENOLYSIS BY METALS
113
hydrogen bonds to give a highly unsaturated dicarbon surface residue as the reaction intermediate. It is probable that such an intermediate would be multiply bonded to metal atoms in the surface. If a site involving a number of adjacent nickel atoms is required for the chemisorption, the restriction in the number of such sites available on a surface in which copper concentrates so markedly could severely limit the formation of the intermediate. Evidence for a marked difference between the surface and bulk compositions of dilute copper-nickel alloys has been reported recently by a number of investigators (82, 87-90). Much of the experimental evidence comes from hydrogen adsorption data (7'4, 82, 87, 90). The conclusions of van der Plank and Sachtler were based on the premise that nickel chemisorbs hydrogen while copper does not (82, 87). The total adsorption of hydrogen at room temperature was taken as a measure of the amount of nickel in the surface. However, in hydrogen adsorption studies on the catalysts used to obtain the catalytic results in Fig. 6, the amount of adsorption on the copper catalyst, while small compared to the adsorption on nickel, is not negligible ( 7 4 ) . However, the amount of strongly adsorbed 40
39
E
+ W
38
V
a E
I
Y P
s
37
36
35
I
I
I
I
0
ATOM 70 COPPER
FIG.7. Percentage d character of the metallic bond in copper-nickel alloys as a function of composition (74, 84).
114
J. H. SINFELT
hydrogen on the copper catalyst is negligible, and may provide a better basis for estimating surface composition. Data comparing total adsorption with the amount of strongly adsorbed hydrogen are shown in Fig. 8. The strongly adsorbed hydrogen refers to the amount not removed by a 10-min evacuation a t room temperature following the completion of the initial adsorption isotherm a t room temperature. The amount is determined simply as the difference between the initial isotherm and a second isotherm obtained after the evacuation ( 7 4 ) . Figure 8 shows that on nickel the strongly adsorbed hydrogen constitutes a very high fraction of the total I
I
I
1
I
I
ADSORPTION
I
I
--
I
----
S T R O N G L Y ADSORBED H 2
\
1\
I
I
I
0
20
40
I 60
I 80
\A
100
A T O M % COPPER
FIG.8. The adsorption of hydrogen on copper-nickel catalysts as a function of the copper content. The circles represent the total amount of hydrogen adsorbed a t room temperature at 10-cm pressure. The triangles represent the amount of strongly adsorbed hydrogen, i.e., the amount not removed by a 10-min evacuation a t room temperature following the completion of the initial adsorption isotherm. The amount of strongly adsorbed hydrogen is determined as the difference between the initial isotherm and a subsequent isotherm obtained after a 10-min evacuation (74).
SPECIFICITY IN CATALYTIC HMROGENOLYSIS BY METALS
115
and declines much more sharply than the total adsorption when a small amount of copper is added to the nickel. This is consistent with a strong concentration of copper in the surface, since on copper the amount of strongly adsorbed hydrogen is clearly negligible. In the range of catalyst composition between about 10 and 70 at. % copper the variation in adsorption is relatively small, suggesting that the surface composition does not vary much in this region. As the overall composition of the catalyst approaches 100 at. % copper, the copper content of the surface, of course, increases correspondingly, and the amount of hydrogen adsorption again decreases sharply. I n summary, the hydrogen adsorption results appear to be consistent with the conclusion that copper concentrates markedly in the surface of copper-nickel catalysts of low overall copper content. In the analysis of the very different effects of copper on the catalytic activity of nickel for ethane hydrogenolysis and cyclohexane dehydrogenation, it appears that differences in the nature of the rate-determining steps may be involved. In proceeding with a discussion along these lines, it will be assumed that the strength of adsorption of hydrocarbons on nickel is affected directionally in the same way as the strength of adsorption of hydrogen when copper is added to nickel. If the surface coverage by the reaction product is very high, such that desorption controls the reaction rate, a decrease in the heat of adsorption would increase the rate. It appears that this may be the case in cyclohexane dehydrogenation, i.e., desorption of the benzene product controls the reaction rate. Thus, on addition of copper to nickel the heat of adsorption of benzene would be expected to decrease, leading to a corresponding decrease in the activation energy of the desorption step. The suggestion here is prompted by previous work on the dehydrogenation of methylcyclohexane to toluene on platinum (34), where it was concluded that the reaction rate was limited by desorption of the toluene product. This reasoning would account for the initial enhancement of the rate of cyclohexane dehydrogenation observed on addition of the first increments of copper to nickel. The range of composition (6-740/, copper) over which the rate was essentially constant is likely characterized by a somewhat smaller variation of the heat of adsorption of the hydrocarbon and by a gradual change in the rate determining step of the reaction, such that a t very high copper content the reaction rate is limited by a step prior to the final product desorption step. It is reasonable that the reaction rate could then be adversely affected by a decrease in the heat of adsorption of a hydrocarbon intermediate formed prior to benzene on the surface, thus leading to a decrease in rate as the catalyst composition approaches pure copper. For the case of ethane hydrogenolysis, in which the reaction intermediate is probably a highly unsaturated, dicarbon surface residue with both carbon atoms bonded to metal surface atoms, the results can also be
116
J. H. SINFELT
rationalized in a general way. It seems reasonable that the strength of bonding between the two carbon atoms in such a surface intermediate would vary in an inverse manner with the strength of bonding of the carbon atoms to the surface. Consequently, the rupture of the carbon-carbon bond would be facilitated by an increase in the heat of adsorption, and inhibited by a decrease. If such carbon-carbon bond rupture is the rate-limiting step in the reaction, the rate of reaction should decrease as the heat of adsorption decreases, corresponding to addition of copper to nickel. This would appear to be the case over the whole range of composition in the copper-nickel catalyst system. Presumably, the rate of rupture of the carbon-carbon bond would have to be even higher than that obtained on the base nickel catalyst to permit desorption of the methane product to be the ratecontrolling step.
V. Conclusion A strong clement of specificity is readily apparent in the hydrogenolysis reactions of hydrocarbons on metals. Extensive investigations of hydrogenolysis reactions on a variety of metals have revealed an enormous range of catalytic activities, amounting to a variation of seven to eight orders of magnitude among the group VIII metals alone. Characteristic activity patterns have been clearly identified, relating the activity of a metal to its position in the periodic table. For the metals of a given transition series, there is a close correspondence between the patterns of variation of hydrogenolysis activity and percentage d character of the metallic bond. Another aspect of specificity in hydrogenolysis is the striking variation among metals in the selectivity of rupture of specific carbon-carbon bonds in higher alkanes. The variation ranges from a completely selective rupture of the terminal carbon-carbon bond of an alkane to a completely random rupture of all carbon-carbon bonds a t similar rates. A final aspect of specificity is the marked difference in activity patterns among metal catalysts for alkane hydrogenolysis and various hydrogenation or dehydrogenation reactions of hydrocarbons. The marked difference in the two classes of reactions applies to activity patterns observed with various pure metals or with alloys of varying composition. REFERENCES 1. Zelinskii, N. D., Kazanskii, B. A,, and Plate, A. F., Chem. Ber. 66B, 1415 (1933). 2. Morikawa, K., Benedict, W. S., and Taylor, H. S., J . Amer. Chem. Soe. 58, 1795 (1936).
SPECIFICITY IN CATALYTIC HYDROGENOLYSIS BY METALS
117
3. Morikawa, K., Trenner, N. R., and Taylor, H. S., J . Amer. Chem. SOC.59, 1103 (1937). 4. Taylor, E. H., and Taylor, H. S., J . Amer. Chem. SOC.61, 503 (1939). 6. Haensel, V., and Ipatieff, V . N., J . Amer. Chem. SOC.68,345 (1946). 6 . Haensel, V., and Ipatieff, V . N., Znd. Eng. Chem. 39, 853 (1947).
7. Archibald, R. C., Greensfelder, B. S., Holzman, G., and Rowe, D. H., Znd. Eng. Chem. 52,745 (1960). 8. Flinn, R. A., Larson, 0. A., and Beuther, H., Ind. Eng. Chem. 52, 153 (1960). 9 . Coonradt, H. L., Ciapetta, F. G., Garwood, W. E., Leaman, W. K., and Miale, J. N., Znd. Eng. Chem. 53, 727 (1961). 10. Larson, 0. A., MacIver, D. S., Tobin, H. H., and Flinn, R. A., Znd. Eng. Chem. Process Design Develop. 1(4), 300 (1962). 11. Coonradt, H . L., and Garwood, W. E., Znd. Eng. Chem. Process Design Develop. 3( l ) , 38 (1964). 12. Bond, G. C., “Catalysis by Metals,” p. 395. Academic Press, New York, 1962. 13. Wright, P. G., Ashmore, P. G., and Kemball, C., Trans. Faraday SOC.54, 1692 (1958). 14. Kemball, C., and Taylor, H. S., J . Amer. Chem. SOC.70, 345 (1948). 16. Cimino, A., Boudart, M., and Taylor, H. S., J . Phys. Chem. 58,796 (1954). 16. Sinfelt, J. H., Catal. Rev. 3(2), 175 (1969). 17. Burwell, R. L., Chem. Rev. 57, 895 (1957). 18. Anderson, J. R., and Avery, N. R., J. Catal. 5, 446 (1966). 19. Anderson, J. R., and Baker, B. G., Proc. Roy. SOC.(London), Ser. A271, 402 (1963). 20. Anderson, J. R., and Avery, N. R., J . Catal. 2, 542 (1963). 21. Barron, Y., Maire, G., Cornet, D., and Gault, F. G., J . Catal. 2, 152 (1963). 22. Barron, Y., Maire, G., Muller, J. M., and Gault, F. G., J . Catal. 5 , 428 (1966). 23. Carter, J. L., Cusumano, J. A., and Sinfelt, J. H., J . Catal. 20, 223 (1971). 84. Mills, G. A., Heinemann, H., Milliken, T. H., and Oblad, A. G., Znd. Eng. Chem. 45,134 (1953). 26. Sinfelt, J. H., Hurwitz, H., and Rohrer, J. C., J. Phys. Chem. 64, 892 (1960). 26. Sinfelt, J. H., Advan. Chem. Eng. 5, 37 (1964). 27. Boudart, M., and Ptak, L. D., J . Catal. 16, 90 (1970). 28. Sinfelt, J. H., J . Phys. Chem. 68, 344 (1964). 29. Sinfelt, J. H., Taylor, W. F., and Yates, D. J. C., J. Phys. Chem. 69, 95 (1965). 30. Sinfelt, J. H., and Yates, D. J. C., J . Catal. 8, 82 (1967). 31. Sinfelt, J. H., and Yates, D. J . C., J . Catal. 10, 362 (1968). 32. Sinfelt, J. H., and Taylor, W. F., Trans. Faraday SOC.64,3086 (1968). 33. Yates, D. J. C., and Sinfelt, J . H., J . Catal. 14, 182 (1969). 34. Sinfelt, J. H., Hurwits, H., and Shulman, R. A., J . Phys. Chem. 64, 1559 (1960). 34a. Sinfelt, J. H., Div. Petrol. Chem. Amer. Chem. SOC.,Preprints 17(3), A53 (1972). 34b. Sinfelt, J. H., J . Catal. 27, 468 (1972). 36. Anderson, J. R., and Kemball, C., Proc. Roy. Soc. (London) Ser. A 223,361 (1954). 36. Beeck, O., Discuss. Faraday SOC.8, 118 (1950). 37. Kemball, C., J . Chem. SOC.p. 735 (1956). 38. Schuit, G. C. A., and van Reijen, L. L., Advan. Catal. 10, 242 (1958). 39. Dowie, R. S., Gray, M. C., Whan, D. A., and Kemball, C., Chem. Commun. p . 883 (1971). 40. Kemball, C., Discuss. Faraday SOC.41, 190 (1966). 41. Sinfelt, J. H., Chem. Eng. Progr. Symp. Ser. No. 73 63, 16 (1967).
118
J. H. SINFELT
42. Sinfelt, J. H., and Cusumano, J. A., unpublished data. 43. Sinfelt, J. H., and Yates, D. J. C., Nature Phys. Sci. 229, 27 (1971). 44. Cotton, F. A., and Wilkinson, G., “Advanced Inorganic Chemistry,” pp. 661, 760. Interscience, New York, 1962. 45. Pauling, L., Proc. Roy. Soc. (London),Ser. A 196, 343 (1949). 46. Kempling, J. C., “Hydrogenolysis of Small Paraffins Over Ruthenium,” Ph.D. Thesis, McMaster University, Hamilton, Ontario, 1971. 47. Semenov, N. N., “Some Problems in Chemical Kinetics and Reactivity” (M. Boudart, transl.), Vol. I, p. 19. Princeton Univ. Press, Princeton, New Jersey, 1958. 48 Myers, C. G., and Munns, G. W., Ind. Eng. Chem. 50, 1727 (1958). 49. Matsumoto, H., Saito Y., and Yoneda, Y., J. Catal. 19, 101 (1970). 60. Matsumoto, H., Saito Y., and Yoneda, Y., J. Catal. 22, 182 (1971). 61. Plummer, E. W., and Rhodin, T. N., J. Chem. Phys. 49, 3479 (1968). 59. Anderson, J. R., and Avery, N. R., J. Catal. 7, 315 (1967). 63. Greensfelder, B. S., in “The Chemistry of Petroleum Hydrocarbons” (B. T. Brooks et al., eds.), Vol. 2, Chapter 27, pp. 137-164. Reinhold, New York, 1955. 64. Bond, G. C., and Sheridan, J., Trans. Faraday SOC.48, 713 (1952). 65. Addy, J., and Bond, G. C., Trans. Faraday SOC.53, 368 (1957). 66. Addy, J., and Bond, G. C., Trans. Faraday SOC.53, 383 (1957). 57. Addy, J., and Bond, G. C., Trans. Faraday SOC.53,388 (1957). 58. Bond, G. C., and Newham, J., Trans. Faraday Sac. 56, 1501 (1960). 69. Benson, J. E., and Kwan, T., J. Phys. Chem. 60, 1601 (1956). 60. Taylor, W. F., Yates, D. J. C., and Sinfelt, J. H., J . Catal. 4, 374 (1965). 61. Sinfelt, J. H., Yates, D. J. C., and Taylor, W. F., J. Phys. Chem. 69, 1877 (1965). 62. Boudart, M., Aldag, A., Benson, J. E., Dmgharty, N. A., and Harkins, C. G., J. Catal. 6, 92 (1966). 65. Dalla Betta, R. A., Cusumano, J. A., and Sinfelt, J. H., J. Catal. 19, 343 (1970). 64. Knor, Z., Ponec, V., Herman, Z., Dolejsek, Z., and Cerny, S., J . Catalysis 2, 299 (1963). 66. Anderson, J. R., and Avery, N. R., J. Catal. 8, 48 (1967). 66. Bond, G. C., “Catalysis by Metals,” p. 246. Academic Press, New York, 1962. 67. Bond, G. C., “Catalysis by Metals,” p. 242. Academic Press, New York, 1962. 68. Bond, G. C., “Catalysis by Metals,” pp. 315, 320. Academic Press, New York, 1962. 69. Lukina, M. Y . , Russ. Chem. Rev. 31, 419 (1962). 7’0. Boudart, M., Aldag, A. W., Ptak, L. D., and Benson, J. E., J. Catal. 11, 35 (1968). 71. Boudart, M., Advan. Catal. 20, 153 (1969). 72. Boudart, M., Amer. Sci. 57 ( I ) , 97 (1969). 73. Rooney, J. J., and Webb, G., J. Catal. 3, 488 (1964). 7’4, Sinfelt, J. H., Carter, J. L., and Yates, D. J. C., J. Catal. 24,283 (1972). 7’5. Schwab, G. M., Discuss. Faraday Soc. 8, 166 (1950). 7’6. Dowden, D. A., J. Chem. Soc. p. 242 (1950). 7’7. Dowden, D. A., and Reynolds, P., Discuss. Faraday SOC.8, 184 (1950). 7’8. Long, J. H., Fraser, J. C. W., and Ott, E. J., J . Amer. Chem. SOC. 56, 1101 (1934). 7’9. Emmett, P. H., and Skau, N. J., J. Amer. Chem. Soc. 65, 1029 (1943). 80. Reynolds. P. W., J . Chem. Soc. p. 265 (1950). 81. Hall, W. K., and Emmett, P. H., J . Phys. Ghem. 62, 816 (1958). 82. van der Plank, P., and Sachtler, W. M. H., J . Catal. 12, 35 (1968). 83. Best, R. J., and Russell, W. W., J . Amer. Chein. SOC.76, 838 (1954). 84. Hall, W. K., and Emmett, P. H., J. Phys. Chem. 63, 1102 (1959).
SPECIFICITY I N CATALYTIC HYDROGENOLYSIS BY METALS
86. Gharpurey, M. K., and Emmett, P. H., J . Phys. Chem. 65, 1182 (1961). 86. Campbell, J. S., and Emmett, P. H., J . Catal. 7, 252 (1967). 87. van der Plank, P., and Sachtler, W. M. H., J . Catal. 7, 300 (1967). 88. Sachtler, W. M. H., and Jongepier, R., J. Catal. 4, 665 (1965). 89. Sachtler, W. M. H., and Dorgelo, G. J. H., J. Catal. 4, 654 (1965). 90. Cadenhead, D. A., and Wagner, N. J., J . Phys. Chem. 72, 2775 (1968).
119
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
The Chemisorption of Benzene R. B. MOYES AND P. B. WELLS Department of Chemistry, The University, Hull, England
I. Introduction.. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 11. Chemisorption. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . A. Volumetric and Gravimetric Methods B. Flow and Radiotracer Methods.. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . C. Spectroscopic, Magnetic, and Other Instrumental Methods. . . . . . . . D. Evidence from Field Electron Emission Microscopy and from LowEnergy Electron Diffraction. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 111. Exchange Reactions. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . ... A. Reactions of Benzene with Molecular Deuterium.. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . B. Reactions of Benzene with Deuterium Oxide and with DeuteriumLabeled Benzene. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . IV. Some Aspects of Benzene Hydrogenation V. Conclusions. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .......... References. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
121 122 122 124 128 131 133 134 141 148 152 154
1. Introduction In any branch of catalysis, the chemisorption and reactivity of the simplest member of a family of substances is an intriguing field of study. For example, examinations of the interactions of simple alkanes and of ethylene with metal surfaces have provided much material for debate. The accumulation of large bodies of information has enabled many fundamental questions to be answered, although others remain unresolved. In this review we survey the literature that describes the chemisorption of the simplest of the aromatic substances, benzene. A cursory consideration will reveal that its behavior is likely t o be enigmatic. It is an unsaturated hydrocarbon, and as such it may undergo associative chemisorption in a manner not dissimilar to that of olefins and diolefins. However, disruption of the six r-electron system, leading to loss or partial loss of the resonance energy of stabilization, might be so unfavorable as to reduce the likelihood of, say, hydrogen atom addition, and so the typical reactions of aliphatic unsaturated hydrocarbons may not be observed. Dissociative chemisorption with no interaction of the r-electron system with the surface is the extreme alternative, in which case the basic reactivity is formally similar to 121
122
R. B. MOYES AND P. B. WELLS
that exhibited by the alkanes. Thus, from the standpoint of their chemisorption, aromatic compounds are best considered in a class on their own. The literature to be reviewed is restricted to reports concerning the chemisorption of benzene itself and its reactivity in the adsorbed state. The chemisorption of substituted benzenes is considered only insofar as it throws light on the mode of reaction of the benzene ring. For example, the reactivity of hydrogen atoms of the ring ortho to a substituent will not be discussed (because this is primarily an effect of substitution) even though this topic has been given much attention, and interesting disputes concerning the experimental evidence and its interpretation exist in the literature. There are few reviews on this subject. That by Bond (1) deals only with material to 1961, and that by Garnett and Sollich-Baumgartner ( 2 ) sets out to present only a proportion of the information covered in the present account. Nevertheless, each should be read along side this review, because the detail in the latter will not be repeated here, and the former remains a useful account of benzene hydrogenation. Section I1 will summarize experimental work designed to determine the extent and manner of benzene chemisorption by the use of physical methods and the radioisotope carbon-14. In Section 111, evidence obtained by use of deuterium as a tracer is examined. The relatively small amount of information concerning the mode of benzene chemisorption that is afforded by studies of its hydrogenation is presented in Section IV.
II. Chemisorption A. VOLUMETRIC AND GRAVIMETRIC PI/IETHODS Few studies have been made of benzene chemisorption by the volumetric method. Zettlemoyer et al. (3) have examined the adsorption of benzene vapor a t 0°C on powders of nickel and of copper. First, the monolayer coverage of argon ( v , ) ~ was ~ measured. The argon was then removed by pumping and the amount of benzene required to form a monolayer, (vml) B ~ , was measured. Weakly adsorbed benzene was then removed by pumping, after which further benzene adsorption provided the value ( v , ~ ) B ~ Some . results are reproduced in Table I. On the assumption that the same extent of surface is accessible both for argon and for benzene adsorption, i t is clear that complete monolayers of benzene were not achieved, that some (Ni) or all (Cu) of the benzene was adsorbed reversibly. It was considered that only the irreversibly adsorbed benzene was chemisorbed, the remainder being physically adsorbed. Thus chemisorption of benzene on copper appeared not to occur. The heat of adsorption of benzene on nickel a t zero
123
CHEMISORPTION OF BENZENE
TABLE I Adsorption of Benzene at 0°C on Nickel and Copper Powders
Metal
Ni CU
(Vrn~)~#/(Orn)~r
0.68 0.34
(Um2)Bz/(Vrn)Ar
0.51 0.34
Percent of monolayer reversibly adsorbed 76 100
coverage was low, being about 25 kcal mole-', and the value diminished with increasing coverage. The authors subscribed to the then current view that chemisorption occurred at the cost of the resonance energy of benzene, and on this basis the primary interaction may have involved a heat of about 65 kcal mole-l. Vacua in the region of Torr were employed in this work, and thus the cleanliness of the surfaces, as defined by present-day standards, is questionable. The heat of chemisorption of benzene on nickel fell with increasing coverage such that, a t about 0.5(u,) B ~ it , had fallen to the value for benzene adsorption on oxidized metal. It would be wise, therefore, to consider the values in Table I to be an indication rather than a quantitative measure of the extent of benzene chemisorption on these metals. The chemisorption a t 0°C of benzene on evaporated films of Ti, Cr, Mn, Fe, Co, Nil and Mo has been examined by Moyes, Baron, and Squire who also used a volumetric method ( 4 ) . The films were prepared a t pressures in the range 10-6-10-7 Torr. Surface areas of Fe, Co, and Ni films, as measured by deuterium chemisorption, were similar to those reported by other workers. The amount of benzene chemisorbed per milligram of metal film decreased on passing from titanium to nickel although, as will be shown in Section 111,the reactivity of adsorbed benzene (as displayed by the rate of hydrogen exchange a t 0°C between CaH6and CeD6)increased on passing from titanium to nickel. Thus, the extent of chemisorption and the reactivity of the chemisorbed material are not simply related. Gravimetric determinations of benzene adsorption using McBain balances have been made by Volter et al. (6) and by Shopov et al. (6). The former authors examined benzene adsorption on cobalt-magnesia. Isotherms (obtained a t 89°C over the narrow relative pressure range p / p " = 0.01 to 0.08) were discussed in terms of the Langmuir equation but, in common with other investigations, it was found that adsorption was not completely reversible. The latter authors (6) investigated benzene adsorption a t 25°C on nickel-silica, the sample being prepared in normal high-vacuum before
124
R. B. MOYES AND I?. B. WELLS
benzene admission. Weight changes showed that up to 24% of the metal surface was occupied by benzene, and that about one-third of this benzene could not be removed by hydrogen at 25°C. Slow deposition of carbonaceous residues occurred at room temperature, but this process could be partially reversed by the action of hydrogen. B. FLOW AND RADIOTRACER METHODS Benzene chemisorption on platinum-alumina in the range 26"-470°C has been measured in a flow system by Pitkethly and Goble ('7). A small dose of benzene was injected into a stream of inert carrier gas and transported to the reactor; the efRuent was then sampled repeatedly and analyzed by gas-liquid chromatography. Information concerning the adsorption and desorption of benzene was obtained from the shape of the subsequent benzene concentration versus time curves. Evidence was obtained for four types of adsorption of benzene: (i) a small extent of reversible adsorption (less than 5% of the total) on platinum; (ii) extensive irreversible adsorption on the platinum the extent of which was independent of benzene pressure and of temperature over a wide range (26"430"C for some catalysts) ; (iii) fast reversible adsorption on the support below 200°C; (iv) additional slow adsorption on, or reaction with, the support. Chemisorption was accompanied by some cracking to C1-C4 hydrocarbons a t high temperatures and by a diminution in the surface area available for benzene chemisorption. Again, partial regeneration of the surface was achievable by purging with hydrogen at elevated temperatures, typically 475°C. 0.22 molecules of benzene were chemisorbed per surface platinum atom on certain of the catalysts studied. The authors calculated that chemisorption of benzene on a (100) face of platinum surface should accommodate 0.185 molecules per surface atom. For adsorption on the (111) face, the number would be 0.143 (carbon atoms over interstices, no interference between hydrogen atoms) or 0.333 (dehydrogenation or distortion to accommodate the carbon skeleton over the interstices). For comparison, physical adsorption of benzene in a monolayer would accommodate 0.166 molecules of benzene per surface platinum atom. Thus, chemisorption with the geometry described above is consistent with the observed extent of chemisorption. It should be noted that these calculations assume that full surface coverage by benzene is achieved, the experimental evidence being as described in (ii) above. However, the investigation next
125
CHEMISORPTION O F BENZENE
described suggests that benzene achieves only low surface coverage on platinum over a wide range of temperature. The use of 14C-labeledbenzene provides a sensitive and powerful method for estimating the extent of benzene chemisorption on metal surfaces. It has, however, been little used until recently. I n principle, the method provides a means of estimating all fates of adsorbed molecules. I n favorable cases, measurements can be made of the total amount adsorbed by counting the surface layer, of the number of molecules displaced from the surface by various treatments, and of the concentration of material that is irreversibly chemisorbed. Tetenyi and Babernics have examined the adsorption of 14C-labeledbenzene on powdered nickel, platinum, and copper (8) and on cobalt (9). Nickel was examined in the greatest detail, and this system will be considered first. A flow system was used in which 14C-labeledbenzene was injected into an argon stream and carried over the catalyst. The system was operated in the range 100"-350°C and at one atmosphere pressure. As temperature was varied, the extent of adsorption was observed to pass through a maximum at 140"-180°C for all but one of the four nickel powders studied (Fig. 1). The exception was Raney nickel, for which the authors suggested that the maximum might have been observed below 100°C had experimentation been extended to that region of temperature. The maxi-
I
1
I
0
g
0.5-
E
6
0.4-
k 1
0.3-
P
3
n
3 ag
.--6
0.2
n
0.1-
o 0.0 100
150
m
200 Temperature
=
o U
-
n
U
I
I
250
300
("C)
FIG.1. The variation of the amount of benzene adsorbed on nickel and on platinum as a function of temperature. From Tetenyi and Barbernics (8),with permission.
126
R. B. MOYES AND P. B. WELLS
mum coverage thus achieved was calculated to be 23-63% of the total surface area depending upon the method of preparation of the adsorbent. However, in the range 250"-3OO"C, the fraction of the surface covered by chemisorbed benzene appeared to be only 2-10%. Displacement of this chemisorbed benzene was achieved using unlabeled benzene or hydrogen. I n one experiment, 20% of the radioactive benzene chemisorbed a t 150°C could be replaced by unlabeled benzene at the same temperature, and a further 54% was removed by hydrogen at 150°C; the remainder (6%) was removable by hydrogen at 380°C. Alternatively, the entire quantity of adsorbed material could be removed by hydrogen a t 380°C. Thus, benzene appeared not to achieve full surface coverage on nickel. Indeed, its surface coverage was less than that achieved by hydrogen as measured in a separate series of experiments. Values of the ratio &/0Benzene were generally in the range 2-5. The temperature dependence of the extent of adsorption was not interpreted, except that the results were considered to be consistent with the magnetic measurements of Selwood (see Section I1,C) which indicate that the number of carbon-metal bonds between adsorbed species and the surface increases threefold between 120"and 200°C due to extensive dissociative chemisorption. The authors proposed that two forms of chemisorbed benzene exist a t the nickel surface, (i) an associatively adsorbed form which can be displaced by further benzene, and which may be T- or hexa-aadsorbed, and (ii) a dissociatively adsorbed form that requires the presence of hydrogen t o bring about its removal from the surface. Analogous studies of the chemisorption of I4C-labeledbenzene on copper powder and on platinum powder showed no chemisorption on the former, and the establishment of a low surface coverage over a range of temperature on the latter (Fig. 1).Again the surface coverage of hydrogen on platinum appeared to be about three times that achieved by benzene. Babernics and Tetenyi (9) used the flow method described above (7) together with the radioactive labeling technique, for their examination of benzene adsorption on cobalt powder in the range 35"-200"C. At the lower temperatures, 35"-85"C, the surface was almost fully covered with reversibly adsorbed benzene when the equilibrium pressure was 0.05 atm. The adsorption obeyed the Freundlich equation, and the enthalpy change on adsorption was 8.6 kcal mole-' a t a fractional coverage of 0.125 falling only slowly with increasing extent of adsorption to 7.5 kcal mole-' a t a fractional coverage of 0.500. This adsorption was considered to be entirely physical in nature. I n the range 160"-200°C the extent of adsorption, which was reduced by a factor of ten, again obeyed the Freundlich equation and the enthalpy change for adsorption decreased rapidly with increasing coverage from 10.5 kcal mole-' at a fractional coverage of 0.025 to 5.5 kcal mole-'
CHEMISORPTION O F BENZENE
127
at a value of 0.225. The use of 14C-labeledbenzene showed that about half of the benzene adsorbed at 200°C was irreversibly chemisorbed at the surface and was only removable by hydrogen treatment at 380°C. According to these authors the extent of benzene chemisorption falls in the series Ni > Pt > Co > Cu = zero. This sequence differs from that for activity in benzene hydrogenation, which is Pt > Ni > Co. A careful study of the kinetics of the exchange reaction between I4Clabeled benzene and unlabeled benzene catalyzed by platinum powders at temperatures up to 150°C has been made by Brundege and Parravano (10).The heterogeneity of the surface was examined in the range4O0-100"C and the activation energies relevant to a wide range of surface sites were estimated, the values being about 9 kcal mole-' at the lower limit and greater than 50 keal mole-' at the upper limit. Pre-exponential factors and activation energies showed a compensation effect. Carbon-14 exchange between labeled benzene and a variety of Cehydrocarbons (e.g., cyclohexane, cyclohexene, n-hexane, 1 , Zdimethylbutane, and methylcyclopentane) was studied using alumina- and silica-supported noble group VIII metals as catalysts (11). For the benzene-cycIohexane combination, for example, the relative activity fell in the sequence Pt > Pd > Ir > Ru > Rh and the rate at 117°C was not dependent upon crystallite size over the range 12-2000 A. This study serves to demonstrate the wild range of interrelated reactions that benzene can undergo, and highlights some of the difficulties involved in attempting to identify the various adsorbed species formed when benzene chemisorbs at a metal surface. The chemisorption of 14C-labeledbenzene at 0°C on evaporated films of Ti, Cr, Mn, Fe, Co, Ni, and Mo has been studied by Moyes et al. ( 4 ) .The extent of adsorption was determined by recovering the material not adsorbed and measuring its activity. The quantity so determined agreed with that obtained by the standard volumetric procedure. Only S-lO% of the chemisorbed material was recoverable by heating the films in hydrogen to 200" or to 350°C. A larger proportion of the chemisorbed material was displaced from the surface, even at O"C, by a further dose of (unlabeled) benzene. For example, the fraction of the chemisorbed material so displaced in 15 min was found to be 20-30% depending upon the metal used