This content was uploaded by our users and we assume good faith they have the permission to share this book. If you own the copyright to this book and it is wrongfully on our website, we offer a simple DMCA procedure to remove your content from our site. Start by pressing the button below!
= Y7(p))
(1.17)
(1.18)
= (27t)3<53(p' - p). = X '\x')ai(p'{x') = Rijcp^{x)ajq>{x), (4)(P3)=(o) 0)(A) and given by (3.42): DU>(A(K)) = e-' e - J0) , and %, respectively. The direct-product representation (§, 0) + (0, i) has a carrier space of four-component "Dirac bispinors" \j/ = (£) upon which the 4 x 4 matrices @(i) operate. Such freeparticle momentum-space wave functions can be formally expressed in terms of the boost as ?(p) = D(L„) = 2£(t 3 (p'-p)5 (J . ff , , must obey V p < ^ > ( p ) = V'>(p), = \ d3x >'*(xK = 2E83(p' — p), follows from (4.14b) with the replacement apK-*-*2£S3(p-Pi) *\id^ - eAjcp = i0*5„cp - 2e<j>* U (r). 2r _ r dr r r J (4.30a) , current conservation implies, for p'2 = p2 = m2, qf' = «(p')y,«(p). which is also conserved in the sense of (5.79). As we have already noted in Section 4.C, such off-diagonal momentumspace currents play an important role in the theory in their own right. Consider first a useful identity called the Gordon reduction. Defining P = \{p' + p),q = p' — P and using the y-matrix property (5.31a), it is easy to show (Problem 5.8) that K*qv = P% + Y,P~2Pfl. (p(p). (5.91) Thus Dirac Zitterbewegung is nonvanishing to zeroth order in momentum. While unphysical consequences can be avoided for free particles by choosing either a positive- or a negative-energy packet as in (5.76) or (5.80), for bound states this cannot be done. We return to this latter problem shortly. (\V) • \ = -MP))V(1 + iys)MP')- = ^(9 2 )(p' + p i - = - eF(q2)(p' + p)„, 2 = eu(p')r,(p\ PHvl r>', = ( - e ) " c ( P T > ' , P)"C(P) 1 R and cpL in (5.17), as only p changes sign in
(1.25)
To streamline the notation a bit, we parallel the convention h = h/2n and define 3 3 3 d3p = d3p/(2n)3, (1.26a) ; t (p) = (27r) «5 (p), for then
J>P* 3 (P) = J>P<5 3 (P)=1-
(1.26b)
A similar convention will be used in n dimensions, with the crossed notation referring to an appropriate factor of (2n)n associated with 8 "(p) and d"p. This notation becomes extremely useful if we also normalize plane-wave solutions for a free particle of momentum p in a box of volume V,
(L27)
8
Introduction
for then the probability of the particle being somewhere in the box is unity. We can, of course, identify (1.27) with (1.23) by setting 7 = 1 . The advantage of using (1.27) will be apparent when calculating physical rates, lifetimes, or cross sections. The normalization volume 7 cancels out of the quantity of physical interest; any unphysical quantity will vanish or become infinitely large as V -*• oo. If we had employed the continuum normalization with periodic boundary conditions, then 7 -»(2n)3, and typical scattering amplitudes would contain as many as 12 powers of 2n, sometimes a bewildering situation indeed! Use of box normalization goes a long way toward "keeping the factors of 2n straight". One further modification, covariant box normalization, will be useful for relativistic particles. It will be discussed in Chapters 3-5 and used extensively in the latter part of this book. Selection Rules. Returning to the discussion of angular-momentum transformation coefficients, we observe that if the hamiltonian is independent of Lor depends only upon L2, then (1.5) implies i ^ = [ L , t f ] = 0,
(1.28)
i.e., L is conserved. As a consequence of (1.28) we have 0 = {I'm | [H, L2] | lm} = [/'(/' + 1) - /(/ + l)]'m | H | lm}, 0 =
(1.29)
The scattering operator S, called the S-matrix, is the scattering analog to H in the sense that energy conservation (magnitude of momentum conservation in the one-body nonrelativistic scattering case) and angular-momentum conservation lead to a selection rule similar to (1.29): {p'l'm' | S | pirn} = S,(p)<5(p' - p)dndm.m.
(1.30)
We shall have much more to say about the S-matrix later. Note now that the "reduced matrix element" S,(p) is independent of the L3 eigenvalue m; this will be verified in Section 2.C. For the moment we may treat (1.30) as another transformation coefficient like (1.15) or (1.17)—(1.20) and thus compute (suppressing summation indices and integrals)
0)3«5(/ - p) 4np2
X(2/+l)S,(p)P,(p'-p).
(1.31)
The factor (2n)3 in (1.31) is consistent with our momentum normalization. When S^p) is expressed as a phase exp (2i5t(p)), the relation (1.31) is referred to as the partial-wave or phase-shift expansion. It is hoped that the reader
Unitary Operators and Transformation Theory 9 appreciates the transparent simplicity of (1.31) when the transformationcoefficient technique is applied. A similar pattern is valid for other operator eigenfunction expansions.
l.C Unitary Operators and Transformation Theory While no mention of unitary operators was made in the postulates of quantum mechanics in Section l.A, they nevertheless play a significant role in the theory. If two observers view the state of a quantum system as 11/^> and 11//>, respectively, then they must of necessity measure the same quantum probability. The "off-diagonal" version of this statement is that for |^> and |i/f'> to have the same probability overlap to the respective states <(/>| and (
I W > | 2 = |<0|*>|2.
(1-32)
Unitary Operators. There are two solutions of (1.32), the obvious one being
< W > = <0|*>.
(1-33) t_1
This leads naturally to a unitary operator U = t / (where the adjoint operation * corresponds to transposition and complex conjugation of finitedimensional matrices) which transforms the state |i//> to the state |i//> as m
= U\
(1.34)
The relation (1.33) then follows from (1.34), the unitary property of U, and the adjoint property (cf>'\ =(Ucfi\ =
(1.35)
The latter is linked to the linearity of U, [ / | a 1 ^ 1 + a 2 ^ 2 > = a1C/|iA1> + a 2 [/|^ 2 >,
(1.36)
where a l j 2 are complex numbers. Antiunitary Operators. The second solution of (1.32) is < W > = <#|*>*
(1.37a)
= <
(137b)
The solution of (1.37a) is m
= A\^y,
(1.38)
where A is again unitary, ArA = I, but now "antilinear", satisfying instead of (1.36), >4|«1^1+«2^2> = « M | ^ 1 > + « ! ^ | ^ 2 > -
(1-^)
The antilinear analog of (1.35), consistent with the solution (1.37a), is W\=(A4>\=(\A\
(1.40)
10
Introduction
where A operating to the left corresponds to <0|.A|*> = O4ty|*>*
(1.41)
and the dot in .A is sometimes omitted. In effect we can replace the unitaryantilinear operator A (henceforth referred to as antiunitary) by a purely unitary operator U (now meaning unitary-linear) and a complex conjugation operator K, i.e., A = UK. It is also possible to define an antiunitary operator in a slightly different manner, following the form (1.37b) rather than (1.37a), but we shall not pursue this possibility in detail. Transformations. The active interpretation of (1.34) or (1.38), without reference to any observers, is that U (or A) represents the physical transformation which converts | ij/} to 11//>. As such, U (or A) is the primary quantity of interest in transformation theory. In particular, we can investigate the action of U (or A) on operators by generalizing (1.33) and (1.37a) to <*'|O'|tfO = < 0 | O k >
(1-42)
for unitary transformations and <0'|O'|i/O = <>|°l'>* (!-43) for antiunitary transformations. Owing to the properties (1.35) and (1.40), (1.42) and (1.43) imply the same operator behavior WO'U = 0,
A^O'A = O.
(1.44)
The unitary property of both U and A then leads to 0' = UOU~ \
O' = AOA~1
(1.45)
in the two cases, both equations taking the form of similarity transformations from 0 to 0'. It may be recalled that such similarity transformations as (1.45) leave the form of operator equations unchanged except in the case of complex numbers in the latter equation because the antilinearity of A means complex conjugation of "c-numbers", as in (1.39). For example, the commutation relation \X, Y] = iZ would become [X', Y'] = —iZ', for antiunitary transformations. A case in point would be the behavior of the commutator [x, px] = i under various transformations, thus determining the unitary or antiunitary nature of those transformations. Next, consider the case where the operator O is left invariant by the transformation, i.e., O' = O in (1.45). One may then conclude that [[/, 0] = 0.
(1.46)
However antiunitary operators will not obey (1.46), because, as we shall see, invariance under an antiunitary operation will not mean 0' = 0. Infinitesimal Generators. Let us now consider in more detail unitary (unitary-linear) transformations dependent upon a small parameter e and
Translations in Time
11
evolving continuously from the identity. In this case we may write Ut=l-
ieG,
(1.47)
where G is called the infinitesimal generator of the transformation. Clearly a unitary Ut = Uj~l implies an hermitian G = G1. Applying (1.47) to the operator transformation 0' = UOU1 leads to 0=0-
ie[G, 0],
(1.48)
so that if G commutes with 0, then 0 is left unchanged by the transformation, 0' = 0. If 0 as well as G is hermitian, both operators could be physical observables and [G, O] = 0 would then imply that G and 0 are simultaneously measurable. For noninfinitesimal unitary transformations (e->A), (1.47) can be exponentiated: Ux = e~UG.
(1.49)
By use of the operator Taylor series expansion e-ixGOeaG = 0 - a[G, 0] + ^^~
[G, [G, 0]]
+ ^ ) 3 [ G , [ G , [ G , 0 ] ] ] + -",
(1.50)
which follows by differentiating the left-hand side of (1.50) with respect to A, the form Ux OU\ can be evaluated and 0' is thus generalized from (1.48) to (1.50) for noninfinitesimal values of the parameter L
l.D Translations in Time Time-Translation Operator. The dynamical development of states governed by the Schrodinger equation can be recast in the form of a unitary transformation. For time-dependent states (d, = d/dt) (idt-H)\+(t)>
= 0,
(1.51)
a time translation of | \j/(t)} means, according to (1.34), that we may define a time-translation operator by
|#')> = ^.0I^(0>.
(1-52)
1
where U(t', t) is unitary, U~ = U\ Moreover U obeys the fundamental "closure" property, V(f, t) = U(t', t")U(t", t),
(1.53)
stating that two successive time translations constitute a time translation. In order to determine the explicit form of U, one notes from (1.52) that
12
Introduction
U(t, t) = 1. For t' = t + St, it is therefore clear that U(t'; t) evolves continuously from the identity, and following (1.47), one writes U(t + dt,t)=l-
iH 8t,
(1.54)
where the infinitesimal parameter 5t in (1.54) is required by (1.53). Then the infinitesimal generator of time translations can be identified as the hamiltonian of (1.51). In fact, (1.54) indicates that U itself satisfies a Schrodinger equation (id, - H)U(t, t0) = 0.
(1.55)
To proceed further, one must make a dynamical assumption concerning H. If the physical states are isolated between observations, then H is independent of t and (1.54) can be exponentiated to U(t',t) = e-ii'-')H.
(1.56a)
If instead the system is not isolated between observations, then H may be explicitly time dependent. In this case the differential equation (1.55) and the boundary condition U(t0, t0) — 1 can be combined into an integral equation U(t, t 0 ) = 1 - i f' df H(t')U{t', t0), which can be iterated successively (plug U = 1 into the integral to approximate U, etc.) to form the time-ordered infinite series (t1>t2>--> t„) U(f, t ) = l + I
( - 0 " f dtt f" dt2-
(' ' dt„ H(tl)H(t2) ••• H(t„). (1.56b)
Clearly (1.56b) becomes (1.56a) if H is time independent; alternatively if H(t) commutes with H(t'), then the upper limits tu ..., tn in (1.56b) can be extended to t' (accompanied by a factor of 1/n! due to a change of integration regions—see Chapter 7), leading to U(t', f) = e x p ( - i j
dt" H(t")\.
(1.56c)
Then again (1.56a) follows as a special case of (1.56c). Time-Development Pictures. The above formulation of time development makes no mention of the time dependence of observable operators (other than H). The time evolution of states |i/'(r)>s, combined with timeindependent observables Os, is referred to as the Schrodinger picture. An alternative but equivalent dynamical scheme, called the Heisenberg picture, involves stationary states | \j/yH along with observables 0H(t) which change with time according to the Heisenberg equation of motion (1.5). More
Translations in Time 13 specifically we may choose
\Ht)>s= l"A(0X 0S = 0(t0),
I«A>H=
|#o)>
0H(t) = 0(t),
(1.57a) (1.57b)
with t0 a fixed time (t — t0). These two pictures are related by
|„=t/- 1 (Mo)l'/'(0> S <«AH 10a(t) | >AH> = < M ) | O s | <Mr)>,
(l-58a) (1.58b)
where (1.58a) follows from (1.52), and (1.58b) is in the spirit of (1.42). Combining (1.58a) and (1.58b) leads to the similarity transformation relating the observables in the two pictures, OH(t)=U-1(t,t0)OsU(t,t0).
(1.59)
Interaction Picture. There is a third picture, called the Dirac or interaction picture, which makes use of the decomposition H = H0 + V with observables 0,(t) dynamically driven by H0 and states |tHf)>/ driven by V. In particular one defines L6
I #)>/ = *""* | *(0>,
( °)
iHo
which removes the e~ ' dependence from \*l/(t)},. Given (1.51), |^(t)>j satisfies a Schrodinger equation driven only by V,
(;a,-F;(t))|>A(0>/ = o
(i.6i)
with V, in turn driven only by H0, VI(t) = eiHotVe-iH°'
(1.62)
[note that the general identity (1.50) may be applied to (1.62)]. In fact (1.62) is one example of the general similarity transformation relating any observable in the interaction and Schrodinger pictures (Vs = V), obtained from (1.60) and the connection between matrix elements in the two pictures,
(i-63)
Finally, we may define a unitary time translatior operator in the interaction picture, C/,(t', t) [similar in nature to the Schrodinger-picture operator Us(f,t)=U(f,t)]: Like (1.61), U, obeys {id, - VkWk,
t0) = 0,
(1.65)
which, like (1.56b), can be iterated to the general time-ordered form U,{f, t) = 1 + t
(-if
( dt, [ ' dt2 ••• (' ' dtn VAtjVfa)-
V,(tn). (1.66)
14
Introduction
The interaction picture will play a fundamental role in the general formulation of the scattering problem discussed in Chapter 7. Even earlier in Chapter 6, however, we will make frequent use of the scattering operator S,= [/7(f = oo, t= -oo).
(1.67)
This is a form of the S-matrix which explicitly shows, as in (1.66), that S contains all the dynamics of the hamiltonian. For systems with no hamiltonian defined, which is usually the case in elementary-particle physics, S continues to describe the dynamics of the interaction. The material presented in this chapter is intended only as a brief review of the fundamentals of quantum mechanics needed as a basis for this book. For a more detailed exposition of this subject, the reader is referred to Pauli (1933), Ludwig (1954), Kramers (1957), Mandl (1957), Dirac (1958), Landau and Lifshitz (1958), Messiah (1962), Feynman et al. (1965), Gottfried (1966), Tomanaga (1966), Matthews (1968), Schiff (1968), Merzbacher (1970), Gasiorowicz (1974), and Mathews and Venkatesan (1976).
CHAPTER 2
Transformations in Space
The invariance of the laws of physics under time translations, space translations, and rotations is naturally linked with the conservation laws of energy, linear momentum, and angular momentum, respectively. In Chapter 1 we have briefly described time translations in terms of the time development operator; spatial transformations, however, can be expressed most compactly and elegantly in the language of group theory. The rotation-group operators are the infinitesimal generators of angular momentum; the group closure property then leads to the familiar commutation relations of angular momentum. We shall also consider in detail the structure of vector and spinor wave functions, spin matrices, tensor operators, and the WignerEckart theorem. Such a review of rotations will serve as a bridge between nonrelativistic and relativistic quantum theory. In particular it will serve as a basis for our treatment of Lorentz transformations in the next chapter.
2.A Continuous Symmetry Transformations and Group Theory Continuous symmetry transformations such as translations and rotations are generated in a passive sense by two observers viewing the same point and measuring the values x and x', respectively. In the case of rotations, these measurements are related by a rotation matrix R as xj = RijXj (Einstein summation convention used). A symmetry transformation will also alter the structure of quantum states, and we have seen in Section l.C that this is most naturally described by a unitary operator transforming the state | ij/} to 1>'> 15
16 Transformations in Space in an active sense (one observer looking at the system before and after the transformation). Continuous Symmetry Operators and Matrix Representations. These two operations (on coordinates and states) must be combined for wave functions <x | if/} = iA(x), i.e., for the transformations on functions of the symmetry variable, but the notions of passive and active must then be kept clear. Since the transformed state can take on three different forms [iZ'(x'), >A'(x), and i/f'(x'), where the primed notation ip'(x) indicates a change in the functional form], it will prove convenient henceforth to apply active transformations on coordinates as well as on states. In practice this simply requires coordinate transformations of the form x' = Rx, with R3Ciive = R ^ v e - The three types of transformations on the wave functions then involve the three operators (9, 2, and
(2.1a)
iA'(x) = @{R)»l/(x)
(2.1b)
\\i' (x') = 5f(R)il/(x).
(2.1c)
The operation (9 corresponds to a differential displacement in a Taylor series expansion of the argument x: i/^(x + Ax) = i^(x) + • • •. The & operation in (2.1b) is a finite-dimensional matrix representation of the unitary operator UR in the subspace of (spin) eigenvalues as Daa(R) = <
M*) = L, •+Ax)Da.0(R). Lastly, the operator £f(R) in (2.1c) represents the combined transformation of coordinates and states with i/C(*') = ^oa(R)^a(x), corresponding to matrix multiplication in the a subspace in a manner similar to the cartesian index representation x\ = RyXj with i, j = 1, 2, 3. Irreducible Group Representations. In mathematical terminology, the collection of operators R or (9R or UR satisfying (2.1) falls under the classification of a group. Finite-dimensional representations of the group correspond to the matrices D(R) and S(R) (or R itself, called the defining representation). Reducible representations can be broken down to block-diagonal form via a similarity transformation. Block-diagonal or irreducible representations in general satisfy the Schur lemma (only multiples of the identity operator commute with all members of an irreducible representation). With reference to (2.1), irreducible representations of 3>(R), y{R), and OR1 are essentially equivalent. Reducible representations always can be decomposed into a linear combination of irreducible representations (for "compact" groups). Closure. The theory of group representations is very abstract and beautiful, but it is not our central concern. From the standpoint of transformation
Translations in Space 17 theory, which is our major interest, the crucial property of a group is that of closure, i.e., a group operation on a group element always gives rise to another group element. This group closure property applied to the operations in (2.1) means that if Rt and R2 are symmetry transformations, then so is R1R2', likewise URiUR2=URlR2 with faithful representations D(K,)D(il2) = D(Rt R2), S(R1)S(R2) = S(Rt R2), and (9RlR^(x)
= iP(R2RlX)
(note the reversed order of operation in the latter case).
2.B Translations in Space Consider the effect of translating the coordinate vector x upon the wave function i^(x). The coordinate transformation x' = x + a can be interpreted as a passive translation of the coordinate system through — a or alternatively as an active translation of the system by + a. In either case the Taylor series expansion of the wave function is i^(x + a) = i^(x) + a • V^(x) + ---,
(2.2)
which can be exponentiated to the form tfr(x') = 0 . M x ) = e - V ( x ) .
(2-3)
v
where the displacement operator Ga = e"' serves to define the translation operation. Linear Momentum as Infinitesimal Generator. The unitary translation operator Ua measures the (active) evolution of the system away from the notranslation configuration in terms of the hermitian infinitesimal generator P as Ua= 1 - M - P + ---.
(2.4)
Since the order of performing any two translations is immaterial, U„ Ua. = Ua. Ua implies from (2.4) that [P ; ,P,] = 0.
(2.5)
Moreover the product of any two translations being a translation, Ua Ua. = Ua.+a, means that the hermitian operator P is additive. It is therefore natural to identify P as the momentum operator P = — iV. To further establish this relation, note that since P and Ua commute with the spin operator S, translations do not affect the spin (angular momentum) indices of a wave function. Consequently, we may treat any i//(x) as a scalar under translations,
n*')=HA
(2.6)
18 Transformations in Space corresponding to if {a) = 1 in (2.1c). Also, since the unitary translation of states is | i/O = Ua \ if/}, we may write f ( x ) = <x|l/ B | f /f> = t / ^ ( x ) .
(2.7)
Comparing (2.3) with (2.6) and (2.7) it is clear that P = — i\ and Ua = 0-1=e-i'-F.
(2.8)
That is, the displacement operator (9a acts on adjoint bra states <x |, while the Hilbert-space operator Ua acts on ket states 11//>. Translation Group. The set of translations in space forms a group, but the commuting infinitesimal generators (2.5) and the simple transformation property (2.6) make this group almost trivial. Evidently (2.8) or ^(a) = 1 indicates that the only finite-dimensional irreducible representation of the translation group is one-dimensional. A similar interplay between transformation properties (2.1) and group closure properties also plays the central role in the study of rotations and Lorentz transformations. In these latter cases the group structure is much richer by virtue of the noncommuting nature of the infinitesimal generators analogous to (2.5). In geometric terms this is because two successive operations, such as rotations, do not commute in three dimensions.
2.C Rotations in Space Rotation Matrix. An active rotation x\ = R\?]Xj about the z-axis through an angle 6 corresponds to a passive rotation of the coordinates through — 6 and is given by the cartesian rotation matrix <3)
i?
/cos0 = sin 9 \ 0
-sin0 cos 9 0
0\ 0 . 1/
(2.9)
For infinitesimal rotations, (2.9) and similar rotations about the x- and y-axes imply x' = x + <38 x x and Ru = Su - S9k ekij,
(2.10)
where ekij is the Levi-Civita symbol, antisymmetric in all pairs of indices ki and ij and normalized so that s123 = 1. Clearly (2.9) becomes (2.10) for 9 replaced by S93 in (2.10). For noninfinitesimal rotations, (2.10) can be exponentiated to the form p . 11) R .. = e -ie<s)y where the "vector" matrix (S)0 has components (S^-fey*.
(2.12)
Rotations in Space 19
The antisymmetry of (S)0- guarantees that the inverse of Rtj is equal to the transpose Rjt = Rfj, i.e., RuRji = tij, 1
(2-13)
T
or equivalently R' = R . This relation defines an orthogonal transformation, preserving the length of any vector (x|x| = RilRimxlxm = x,x;), as any rotation must. Orthogonal transformations include more than rotations, however, because (2.13) implies (det R)2 = 1. Reflections, on the other hand, obey (2.13) but have det R — — 1. In this chapter we shall restrict the discussion to pure rotations (det R = 1), in which case not only do polar vectors tranform like the coordinates {V'{ — Ru Vj), but so do axial vectors such as (V\ x V2)| = Rij(\i x V2)j. This latter transformation implies (for det R — 1; see Problem 2.1) which can be verified directly from R(3), etc., as given by (2.9). With the aid of (2.12) and (2.13), we can write (2.14) as a matrix relation in the space of the cartesian indices, R~lSiR = RijSJ.
(2.15)
_1
Interpreting R S,R as a similarity transformation in this space to the rotated S't, we can take (2.15) as further indication that the vector (spin) matrix S as defined by (2.12) does transform as a true vector. Angular Momenta as Infinitesimal Generators. For rotated wave functions, a Taylor series expansion can be developed for infinitesimal rotations x' = x + (56 x x: i^(x + <58 x x) = i//(x) + c58 x x • Vi^(x) + • • •.
(2.16)
Since the orbital-angular-momentum operator is L = — ix x V, we may exponentiate (2.16) for noninfinitesimal rotations to iA(x') = e i 0 V ( x ) = ^«i/'(x).
(2.17)
In Hilbert space the unitary operator for rotations, UR, is expected to be of the form of (2.11), and &RX as given by (2.17). Then we write UR = e-*s,
(2.18)
where the infinitesimal generator of rotations in (2.18), J, is presumably the angular-momentum operator in Hilbert space, and f ( x ) = URil/(x) = e"' e •>(*)•
(2-19)
Finally there exists a finite-dimensional matrix S(R) [not to be confused with S as given by (2.12)] obeying (2.1) in the space of spin indices. The rotation matrix itself as given by (2.11) is the spin-1 representation of £f(R). Ab-
20 Transformations in Space stracted as an operator in Hilbert space, we expect that S(R) = e~ies
(2.20)
by analogy with (2.11) and (2.18). Then, by use of (2.1)-(2.3), il,'(x')=URiJ,(x')=UR(9R
(2.21)
which implies that J = L + S.
(2.22)
This relation lends further credence to the physical interpretation of J as the total-angular-momentum operator and S as the spin-angular-momentum operator; while (9R operates on the coordinates, UR operates in Hilbert space, and S acts in the subspace of spin indices in such a way that (2.22) is valid. Note that (2.22) depended upon keeping straight the concepts of active vs. passive and UR vs. GRl. Having tied down the relation between the various angular momenta as infinitesimal generators, we are ready to investigate the more abstract structure of the rotation group as it pertains to transformation theory.
2.D The Rotation Group 0 ( 3 ) Closure. We now exploit the closure property that the product of any two successive rotations is also a rotation. More specifically, since the group closure property R1R2{R1R2)T = 1 holds if RYR\ = 1 and R2RT2 = 1, the set of all three-dimensional orthogonal rotation matrices with RRT = 1, det R = 1 forms a group, denoted by 0 + (3). While there is a continuous infinity of group elements corresponding to the values of Qu 62, 63 in (2.11), there are only three infinitesimal generators Jl9 J2, and J3. In order to characterize the rotation group, therefore, it will be most revealing to describe the behavior of J. To begin with, the spin-1 cartesian matrices (2.12) form a closed algebra [henceforth we display explicitly the spin-1 structure of(Sj%=-iefJJ [S\l\ Sf] = mijkS?\
(2.23)
These are, of course, the familiar commutation relations of angular momentum, which are in fact satisfied by all infinitesimal generators of rotations, Sh 1^, and J ; . This is a direct consequence of the Hilbert-space analog of the group closure property (choosing the phase to be unity) URlUR2=URlR2,
(2.24a)
which, when applied twice, gives UR URUR — UR-iRR.
(2.24b)
The Rotation Group 0(3) 21 For infinitesimal rotations of R', (2.18) becomes UR, = l - i<58' • J,
(2.25)
and so UR lUR.UR = l - W\UR %UR,
(2.26)
whereas UR-IRR
= Ui-im-R-iSiii)R
= 1 — i dO'i RijJj
(2.27)
follows from the group closure property and (2.15). Comparing (2.26) and (2.27) we see that URlJiUR = RijJj.
(2.28)
Then take R in (2.28) as an infinitesimal rotation, so that (1 + i 30k J t )J ( (l - i 89, J,) = (dy - 59k ekiJ)Jj + • • •, which, for arbitrary 50k, implies the angular-momentum commutation relations [J„ Jj] = ieiJkJk.
(2.29)
Thus, the group closure property generates a closed algebra for the infinitesimal generators, called a Lie algebra, which is governed by "structure constants", in this case sijk. This completes the description of the infinitesimal generators for rotations. Irreducible Representations. Next we investigate the representations of the rotation group. Given the structure of UR as e~'° J and the properties of J as operators in the infinite-dimensional Hilbert space, we can search for faithful finite-dimensional representations of the group. Clearly the general property (2.28) is reproduced by the three-dimensional matrix relations (2.15). Similarly, the general commutation relations (2.29) are faithfully reproduced by the three-dimensional commutation relations (2.23), and likewise the general angular-momentum eigenstates J2 | jrri> = j(j + 1 ) | jm>,
J 3 1 jm> = m | jm)
(2.30)
are represented by the orbital eigenstates (1.9) and (1.10). Such eigenstates represent the "carrier space" for the rotation operators UR. For a given j , the action of UR on j jm} serves to "reshuffle" the eigenstates among the 2/ + 1 different values of m, and the reshuffling coefficients DlJ)m(R) are collectively called the jth irreducible representation of the rotation group of dimension 2j + 1. That is, for D$m(R) = (jm'\UR\jm>
= {jm' | C - i e j \jm>
(2.31)
we have for; = 0, \, 1, | , ... andy' > \m\, | jm}' = UR | jm) = £ | jm'yD$m(R),
(2.32)
22 Transformations in Space
where the finite-dimensional unitary matrices satisfy D$m(R) = DV>*(R->)
(2.33)
and transform according to the general relation (2. lb). [We shall continue to include the summation symbol in relations like (2.32).] For integer j = /, (2.32) can be converted into the transformation law for spherical harmonics by applying
(2.34)
m'
This relation has important consequences, such as the addition theorem (1.16). (See Problem 2.2.) To exploit such properties in detail, it is useful to express D$m(R) in terms of the conventional Euler angles, i?^,9,^ = R^RgR^, corresponding to three successive, active, counterclockwise rotations: First rotate by > about the z-axis (c - '* 53 ), then by 6 about the new /-axis {e~ieSl), and finally by \\> about the new z"-axis (e~'*S3'). In terms of the original fixed axes, the unitary operator has the form e-i*^e~iej2e~i'l'J\ (See Problem 2.3.) Taking 9 and > as the usual spherical angles, 0 < 6 < n, 0 <
(2.35)
so that for (Re
WM*)
(2.36)
J
dUP) = <J»*\e-» >\jtri>,
(2.37)
J
where the rotation functions d m.m satisfy the general formula (see, e.g. Wigner 1959) dj
(e] =
y ( - H ( / + w)! Q- ~ m)\ (j + m')\ (j - m')\]* n (j ~ m' - n)\ (j + m- n)\ (n + rri - m)\ n\ x (cos i0) 2 j ' + m - m '- 2 n (-sin $8)m-m+2n, w
(2.38) (1)
satisfying CSR phase conventions. We tabulate D and £> in Appendix II. Nonetheless it is instructive to derive some of the important properties of the d(9) from first principles (see Problem 2.4). Spin-1 Defining Representation. The defining representation of the rotation group is given by the cartesian transformation of the coordinates, x\ = i?(Jx7. It is also possible, however, to formulate this representation in the irreducible spherical basis. Introducing the spherical coordinates for j — 1, rm =
(2.39)
it is clear that the analog of x\ = Rtj Xj is r'm=Rmmrm-
(2.40)
The Rotation Group 0(3) 23
On the other hand, YT(f) = < r | l m > ~ r * ,
(2.41)
so a comparison of (2.40) with the transformation law (2.34) for / = 1 and using (2.33) reveals that Rm,m = D^m(R),
(2.42)
which proves that R is the faithful spin one-dimensional representation of UR. Next define a spin-1 polarization vector e|m)(p3) proportional to a spin-1 wave function with momentum dependence in the z-direction and transforming like yj1, i.e., 4 1 ''(Pa) = T - ^ (I ±i, 0),
£!
0)
(P3) = (0, 0, 1),
(2.43)
we conclude from the fact that e|m) does not change its functional dependence upon rotation (see Problem 2.5) that ei"W3) = RijePfa). a
(2.44)
{l)
Thus R acts like D \R) in (2.42) but like S (R) in (2.44). The vector e!m>(p3) is referred to as a polarization vector and will be needed to describe spin-1 relativistic wave equations in Chapter 4. Spin-j Spinor Representation. It is also possible to represent the cartesian spin-1 angular-momentum matrix (Sj1')^ = —i£iJk in the spherical basis by coupling two spin-1 states to form a spin-1 vector. In general, coupling two spin-s states with magnetic quantum numbers m and m', a (2s + 1) x (2s + 1) vector matrix can be formed as (see Problem 2.6) ( S £ U = [(2s + l)( s + l)s/3]*(-)- m <ssm', -m\ 1M>.
(2.45)
Here (ssm', — m 11M> is a Clebsch-Gordan or Wigner angular-momentum coupling coefficient (with the CSR phase convention). While (2.45) is not the only way to form higher-spin matrices, for s = 1 it is indeed the spherical analog of (Sj1*),* = — ieiJk. For s = \, the 2 x 2 spin-one matrices which are a direct consequence of (2.45) can be written as (see Problem 2.6) S(*> =
fr,
(2.46)
where at are called the Pauli spin matrices with cartesian components,
- U
-(?"4 Hi-") ™
and the matrices are in the spin space of spherical indices \ and —\, respectively. As faithful representations of J, the spin matrices (2.47) must, and do, obey the angular-momentum commutation relations, i.e., [ff„ aj\ = 2ieijkak.
(2.48)
24 Transformations in Space Furthermore, computation with (2.47) reveals that the Pauli matrices also obey the anticommutation relations {ah oj} = 2,5;,,
(2.49)
where {A, B} = AB + BA. Combining (2.48) with (2.49) we see that teijkak-
°i<*j = ^.j +
(2-50)
This decomposition holds in general for any representation of the spin-^ matrices and corresponds to the direct product of angular momenta,
i x i = 0+ 1. Given these spin-^ matrices, it is possible to describe the spinor representations of the rotation group. Since (2.50) implies a\ = 1, a\ — au etc., the spin4 representations of UR can be separated into even (cosine) and odd (sine) functions of the rotation angle according to SW(R) = e~ie•*' = cos \9 - itf • a sin # .
(2.51)
Then (2.50) leads immediately to the spin-^ analog of (2.15), [S«>(R)]-1
(2.52)
Next, identify q>a as an entry in the spin column {q>i/(p^i). Such coordinatespace wave functions transform as faithful representations of the rotation group cp'(x') = S(i)(R)
(2.53a) (2.53b)
where (2.53b) follows from (2.53a) and (2.52) and explicitly demonstrates the vector character of a. The analogs of the spin-1 polarization vectors e(m,(p) are the spin4 momentum-space spinors
and
9 <-*>(fc)=^J.
(2.54a)
Since these spinors do not change their functional forms under rotations, they transform similarly to (2.44), i.e., cp™(Rp3) = S«\R)
(2.54b)
It is also well to point out that e^Rp^) and
Tensor Operators and the Wigner-Eckart Theorem 25
2.E Tensor Operators and the Wigner-Eckart Theorem Vector Operators. To pursue the connection between transformation theory and the properties of the rotation group, note that the transformation law for spherical harmonics (2.34) can be interpreted as one for a scalar operator, because the left-hand side can be thought of as i//'(f) or alternatively as \p(R~ lr). The extension of (2.34) to vector operators Vt transforming like the coordinates x[ = RijXj must be
< * ' I W > = Ky<
(2-55)
where the left-hand side can be interpreted as the expectation value of V\ with respect to the unrotated states. Applying 11//> = UR 11/') to (2.55) then yields UllVlUR = Ri}VJ,
(2.56)
for which (2.15) is a particular group realization. This relation can be verified directly by the use of (1.50) and (2.18). (See Problem 3.3.) It should be noted that the active rotation (2.56) appears not to have the same similarity transformation structure as (1.45). The latter can be emulated by converting R to R~l in (2.56), corresponding to a passive rotation, U^U^^iR-^jVj.
(2.57)
Then proceeding as in the derivation of the fundamental group commutation relations (2.29), an infinitesimal rotation in (2.56) or (2.57) leads to [Ji,Vj] = ieiJkVk,
(2.58)
for which (2.29) is a special case with V replaced by J in (2.58). Tensor Operators and Higher-Spin Wave Functions. The generalization of a vector operator to a cartesian tensor operator is straightforward. First recall that a second-rank nonoperator (c-number) rotation tensor Tu must transform like the product of coordinates, TiJ = RikRjlTkl.
(2.59)
An irreducible cartesian tensor must be symmetric and "traceless", Tti=Tfit
- 5 ^ = 0,
(2.60)
such as X; Xj — \xk xk Stj, which has only 5 independent components and corresponds to the cartesian analog of Y^(f). Tensor wave functions describing a particle with higher spin must also be symmetric and traceless as in (2.60). The spin-2 wave function is proportional to rank-2 polarization tensors e\f) obeying (2.60) and related to the spin-1 polarization vectors (2.43) as (see Problem 2.8) e\f=
£
(2.61)
26 Transformations in Space
Likewise, a spin-| polarization vector can be constructed from spin-1 polarization vectors and spin-^ spinors as (pf) = £ < l i m'm||M>£!m'Vm).
(2.62)
m'm
While this one-index (pt cannot be constrained by (2.60), it must instead obey (see Problem 2.9) <x;(p, = 0.
(2.63)
The extension to tensors of rank higher than | or 2 is straightforward but always involves the "irreducibility conditions" (2.60) and (2.63). Cartesian tensor operators are further complicated by the noncommutativity of the operator components, such as S„ which obey (2.23). The construction then becomes quite tedious. Spherical Tensor Operators. It is more natural instead to generalize spherical representations as in (2.45). Consider then combinations of vector operators built up to form irreducible spherical tensor operators Tf. For J = 1, these tensor operators must transform like Yf, i.e., with CSR phases, Ti±1 =
_(j^±3) ;
n =K
(264)
Since YT transforms like |/w>, Tf must transform like \JM}. We recall from (2.41), however, that spherical components of vectors, in this case Vm, transform according to the complex-conjugate representation. This subtlety means that the spherical analog of the transformation law (2.57) for general J can be written as URTfURl
= D*M%{R-')Tf,
(2.65)
since for J = 1, D(1) = R as in (2.42) reduces (2.65) to the spherical form of (2.57). It is conventional to use the unitary property of D in (2.65) and rewrite this transformation law for tensor operators as (reinstating the summation sign) UnTfU^^^TfD^iR).
(2.66)
M'
With hindsight, (2.66) appears to be the operator extension of the transformation law for spherical harmonics, (2.34), with the left-hand side of both equations expressed in passive form. Given (2.66), an infinitesimal rotation leads to the general commutation relations [J±, Tf] = N ± (M)75 f ± 1 ,
[J 3 , Tf] = MTf,
(2.67)
where J± = J x + U2 and N±(m) = [j(j+l)-m(m±lj\\ J± \jm} = N±(m)\j, m ± 1>
(2.68) (2.69)
Tensor Operators and the Wigner-Eckart Theorem
27
defines the angular-momentum raising and lowering operators and determines the CSR phase convention. The commutation relations (2.67) are the spherical generalization of the vector commutation relations (2.58). Wigner-Eckart Theorem. At this point it is natural to discuss the WignerEckart theorem, which is satisfied by these tensor operators Tf. This follows immediately from the Clebsch-Gordan completeness expansion \jm'>= Z
\Jd2'nlm2yij1j2m1m2\jmy.
(2.70)
mim2
The realization that Tf transforms like |JM> means that its matrix elements are proportional to <Jm' | Tf | jm} = £
\Tf\jm}
oc £ 4,. 7 4,. M 6ri8M..m. Since the Clebsch-Gordan coefficients are taken to be real (CSR phase convention), the Wigner-Eckart theorem is usually written as
|| T3 ||j>,
(2.72)
where || Tj ||j> is the "physical part" of Tf, independent of magnetic quantum numbers, and is called the "reduced matrix element". The only magnetic-quantum-number (geometrical) dependence of the matrix elements of Tf is via the Clebsch-Gordan coefficient (2.71). An alternative derivation of (2.72) relies upon a comparison of (2.66) with the ClebschGordan series for direct-product representations with J = j t + j2,ji +72 — !>•••> \ji — 72 | ( s e e Problem 2.10), DWmi(R)DV%2(R) = X
<Jd2mlm2\JMXJ1J2m'1m'2\JM'}D^M(R).
j
(2.73)
A more transparent and useful special case of (2.72) is sometimes referred to as the "little" Wigner-Eckart theorem for scalar operators S = T%. For J = M = 0 in (2.72), the Clebsch-Gordan coefficient is proportional to djj3mm; it therefore remains to verify that (jm\S\jm} is independent of m. To this end, consider SJ + between states with m values differing by 1 (and delete the) dependence): <m+ l | S J + | m > = N + (m)<m+ l | S | m + 1>,
(2.74)
by use of (2.69). Now S being a scalar operator means [S, J] = 0, so that S commutes with J + and N+(mXm+
l\S\m+
1> = <m +
l\J+S\m}
= /Y_(m+ l)Oi|S|m>.
(2.75)
However, N+(m) = N_(m + 1), which implies that (2.75) becomes <m+ l\S\m+
l> = <m|S|m>,
(2.76)
28 Transformations in Space
meaning that the reduced matrix element, (jm \S \jm} = Sp is independent of m. Thus we write the little Wigner-Eckart theorem as
(2.77)
Assuming S to be the 5-matrix of Section l.B (also a scalar operator in the Wigner-Eckart sense), (2.77) is proof of the assertion (1.30), the latter being diagonal in energy as well. As such, (2.77) is justification for the partial-wave expansion (1.31). Another example of a scalar operator is J2 itself, since [Jh J2] = 0. On the other hand, the vector operator T, = J2St — (S • J)J ; , where S, is the spin, does not commute with J 2 ; instead [[ri,j2],j2]
= 2{ri,j2}.
(2.78)
This operator identity serves to generate selection rules when sandwiched between angular-momentum eigenstates, as in the little Wigner-Eckart theorem above or in the selection rules leading to (1.29). The vector model in atomic physics then follows from (2.78) or equivalently from the WignerEckart theorem (2.72) for Tf (see Problem 2.10). For higher-spin cases, the general Wigner-Eckart theorem certainly is easier to apply than identities like (2.78). For general references on the rotation group, see Condon and Shortley (1951), Rose (1957), Wigner (1959), Messiah (1962), Brink and Satchler (1968), Bargmann (1970), and Merzbacher (1970).
CHAPTER 3
Transformations in Space-Time
The review of translations, rotations, and the rotation group being completed, we are prepared to investigate their relativistic generalizations: translations, rotations, and velocity transformations in space-time, along with the homogeneous and inhomogeneous Lorentz groups. We shall again stress group closure properties and the resulting transformation laws and commutation relations. The new concept of a "boost" operation, a form of active Lorentz velocity transformation, is particularly useful for the construction of relativistic wave functions describing particles with spin. Helicity is another important notion which we shall develop. Spin4 helicity spinors and spin-1 helicity polarization vectors are covariantly generalized from their rotation-group form. Massive-particle helicity states are contrasted with massless-particle helicity states with an eye to their use in later chapters.
3.A Lorentz Velocity Transformations We begin at the beginning—the origins of the theory of relativity. Briefly stated, the measured aberration of starlight, the observed independence of the velocity of light upon the motion of double star sources, and the absence of fringe shifts in the Michelson-Morley experiment led to the conclusion that light traveled in a manner independent of any "aether". The "logical" consequence was the Einstein postulates (Einstein 1905): i. all physical laws are covariant (frame independent); ii. the constancy of the speed of light, vh as measured by all observers; Vi = c = 1 (recall our units h = c = 1). 29
30 Transformations in Space-Time
Velocity Transformation Matrix. In the language of transformation theory, postulate ii links time and space together by the four-vectors (note that this is not the convention used in most texts on general relativity) x„ = (x0, x),
x" = (x0, - x ) ,
(3.1)
where x 0 = t and n = 0, 1, 2, 3, such that the scalar product x„x" = XQ — x 2 = x • x = x 2
(3.2)
is invariant from frame to frame, x;x'" = x„x".
(3.3)
Postulate i then implies that there must exist a linear transformation connecting x„ and xj, obeying (3.3). For a passive Lorentz velocity transformation, vx= —v, of an observer measuring an event at x' relative to an observer measuring the event at x, (3.3) is satisfied provided (see Problem 3.1) t' = y(t + vx), x' = y(x + vt),
/ = y,
z' = z,
(3.4)
where y = (1 — i; 2 ) - *. We prefer the active interpretation of (3.4), whereby a single event is transformed through space-time from xM = (t, x) to x'p = (t', x') via the velocity vx = v. In matrix language, x^ can be taken as a column vector satisfying the transformation law *; = A/x v ,
(3.5)
where A / is the active Lorentz velocity transformation matrix A(v) with /z referring to the rows and v to the columns. For v in the x-direction, (3.4) implies 'y yv 0 0 yv y 0 0 0 0 1 0 ,0 0 0 1 Since the linear transformation (3.5) has the same form as a lengthpreserving rotation x\ = Rq Xj, it is useful to regard (3.2), or more generally the proper-time interval ds = dx^ dx*, as a squared "length" in space-time. The analog to an orthogonal rotation RRT = 1 is the length-preserving constraint obtained from (3.3) and (3.5), A/A", = S\,
(3.7)
where S\ = lifv = k{ = 0, 1, 2, 3) and 5\ = 0 for v # A. The matrix A"v, defined by x'" = A\x*,
(3.8)
is the same as A(v) except that v is replaced by — v in (3.6), consistent with (3.7), or equivalent^, (A -1 )" v = A / .
Lorentz Velocity Transformations 31 The velocity transformation also preserves the causal nature of events, transforming timelike separations (Ax)2 = (At)2 — (Ax)2 > 0 into timelike separations, because v
&.»=
0 0 0n -1
1 0 0 0 - 1 0 n n _ i 0 0 - 1 0 0 0
(3-10)
and x" = #"vxv, with g^ given by the same matrix as (3.10). With the aid of g^, it is possible to express the length-preserving constraint completely in terms of the matrix A(v):
V A ' =j", T
(3.H)
vfl
or A gA = g, since g^ = g is the inverse of g^, g"ag.v = s\.
(3.12)
In general relativity, the "metric" g^ is not constant as in (3.10), and it plays a central role in the theory. In that case the raising and lowering matrix (3.10) is relabeled as r\^ and referred to as the "flat space" limit of g^. We shall make use of this distinction only in Chapter 14. Infinitesimal Transformations. Returning to the velocity transformation (3.6) and paralleling the structure of rotations as much as possible, one gains further insight into the origin of A(v) by investigating infinitesimal velocity transformations. Starting with an infinitesimal Newtonian transformation in the x direction, x' = x + t 8v, one writes [see e.g. Bjorken and Drell (1964)]
A/ = V + CV,
(3-13)
where /0 /v_ 7
"
-
1 0 0\
i o o o
/l {/2)v = / a / v =
[
x
0 0 0'
o loo.
1 0 0 0 0 I' '" " I0 0 0 0 ' ' \0 0 0 0/ \ 0 0 0 0, and (7 3 )/ = / / . Exponentiation of (3.13) then leads to A(w) = e£/,
( 14) {
'
(3.15)
or equivalently, employing the projection-operator character of (3.14) along with the even (odd) parity of cosh CI (sinh £7), as in cosh CI = 1 — jC2I2 H—,
32 Transformations in Space-Time we find A / = (cosh C/)„v + (sinh £/)/
= V - ( /2 V + ( /2 V
cosh
C + i; sinh £.
(3.16)
2
Since (3.14) means 1 — J is nonvanishing and unity only in the yy and zz entries, it is clear that (3.16) is identical to the original form of the velocity transformation (3.6) provided y = cosh £,
yv = sinh £,
(3-17)
which implies v = tanh £ or y = (1 — v2)~i (see Problem 3.1). One can generalize (3.13)—(3.16) to include velocity transformations in an arbitrary direction by replacing £/,,„ with the sum of three terms, one corresponding to each of the three space directions. It is also possible to invert (3.17) as £ = tanh" 'v = \ log ( | ^ j ,
(3.18)
with the "Lorentz angle" £ sometimes referred to as "rapidity". It has the simple property that under a combination of Lorentz velocity transformations in the same direction (A12 = A t A2), the rapidities add (£12 = £ t + £2). Boost Transformation. The Lorentz velocity transformation is a covariant operation in that any four-vector V^ = (V0, V) must transform like the coordinates, i.e., V'p = A/F v . The only limitation to this statement is that a causal event described by ds2 > 0 can never be transformed out of the "light cone" to the spacelike region, ds2 < 0, because v < c. In particular, the energy-momentum four-vector describing a free particle, pM = (£, p), has an invariant length p2 = p„p* = E2 - p 2 = m2,
(3.19)
where m is the rest mass. Since p^ must transform like the coordinates (pj, = A/p v ), it is possible to find a Lorentz velocity transformation which "boosts" the particle from rest with four-momentum m^ = (m, 0) for m j= 0 to the momentum p; it is denoted as L/(p): p„ = V(p)m v .
(3.20)
The boost transformation L(p) is the specific Lorentz velocity transformation A(v) with y = E/m = cosh £ and yv — \ p | /m = sinh £, or equivalently from (3.20) L0°(p)=^
L/>(p) = £
(3.21a)
and then from (3.7),
MP) =-, m
W = 5ij+
PiP
J
m(E + m)
(3.21b)
Homogeneous Lorentz Group if 33 It is important to stress the covariant nature of the boost operation; in particular, its manifest covariant representation implied by (3.21) is (see Problem 3.1)
where m- (p + m) = m(E + m). It is clear that (3.22) satisfies (3.20) and (3.21) and also evolves continuously from the identity, since L„v-»0„v as Pn -* "V Note too that the third term in (3.22) accounts for the intrinsic nonsymmetric structure of the boost LMV. This boost operation will play a fundamental role in the construction of quantum-mechanical wave functions describing particles with spin, but first it will be necessary to investigate the group-theoretical structure of Lorentz transformations, a subject to which we now turn.
3.B Homogeneous Lorentz Group i? Closure. While two successive rotations are a rotation, two successive velocity transformations (or boosts) are not, in general, a pure velocity transformation. However, the notion of closure can be enlarged to include both boosts and rotations. For velocity transformations Ax and A2 obeying the "lengthpreserving" constraint ATgA = g, we have (A, A2)Tg(Al A2) = AjAfrA, A2 = AT2gA2 = g.
(3.23)
Now rotation matrices R satisfying RRT = 1 also satisfy ATgA — g and (3.23) provided we extend R to space-time as A/(K)^V=(1
R
\
(3-24)
with coordinates x„ transforming according to x' = Ax.
(3.25)
Now it can be shown that, in addition, the discrete transformations of space reflection, time reversal, and space-time reflection also obey (3.23) and (3.25). The complete set of velocity transformations A(v), rotations A(R), and the aforementioned discrete transformations all obey (3.23) and (3.25), are called in general Lorentz transformations, and form a group called if, the homogeneous Lorentz group. Infinitesimal Generators. To restrict the discussion to the continuous Lorentz transformations A(v) and A(R) which evolve continuously from the identity, we constrain A to satisfy not only (3.23) and (3.25), but also A0° > 1, det A = 1. Then the set of A(v) and A(R) make up the proper orthochronous homogeneous Lorentz group Z£\, a subgroup of <£. It is then possible to
34 Transformations in Space-Time
represent any Lorentz transformation in jzfj as a product A(v)A(R). To express this fact in the most compact manner, it is useful to combine infinitesimal transformations for rotations, (2.10), and for velocity transformations, (3.13). To this end we write for small a)„v \y = 9w +
(3-26)
where the six-compnent tensor
(3-27)
combines (ou(R) = eijkOk,
(3-28)
for rotations and velocity transformations, respectively. While it is clear that (D^R) is antisymmetric as required by (3.27), co^v) acquires its antisymmetry by virtue of the metric tensor applied to (3.14a), JMV = I*g„ = —Ivll. The six continuous parameters 6xyz and Cx>y,z in (3.28) indicate the existence of six infinitesimal generators of i?J. To explore this possibility, we follow the transformation-theory analysis of the rotation group, first displaying the exponential form of the defining representation of !£\, (3.26), A = exp (-bw^Sj,
(3.29)
where SMV = — Sv/J is the covariant analog of the spin-1 matrix S, with the cartesian representation (Problem 3.2)
(S.vV'^.V-VW,
(3-30)
analogous to (S,)jk = —iEijk. The Hilbert-space unitary operator expressing the action in Z£\, \l/'(x) = UA\l/(x), must be similar in form to (3.29): C/A = e x p ( - ^ V , V ) ,
(3.31)
where l/A = t/A \ and is a six-component hermitian angular-momentum tensor operator. Likewise the Lorentz displacement transformation, \p(x') = $ A i//(x), corresponds to a Taylor series expansion with an exponential form 0A = exp (iiw^Lj,
(3.33)
and L^v = — L^ = i{xfldv — xvdfl) is a six-component orbital-angularmomentum tensor operator. Finally, since a spin-1 wave function transforms like the coordinates [i/^(x') = A/i/^x)], the infinitesimal form of (3.29), (3.31), and (3.33) immediately leads to J„v = LMV + S^v for spin-1 wave functions, as expected. A half-integral-spin angular-momentum decomposition must await a discussion of Dirac matrices in Chapter 5. It is therefore clear that if J is a six-parameter continuous (Lie) group with six infinitesimal generators composing the angular-momentum tensor operator J To determine the Lie algebra for the group (i.e., the commuta-
Homogeneous Lorentz Group if
35
tion relations satisfied by the generators J^), we again follow the pattern of 0(3) and extend the group closure property (3.23) to Hilbert space (up to a phase), UAlUAl=UAlAl.
(3.34)
1
Applying (3.34) twice to obtain C/^ t/A- UA = t/A_1A.A, an infinitesimal Lorentz transformation for A', and UK. = 1 — fyco^J^, we then obtain (Problem 3.2) C/A 1 ^»1/A = A | 1 " A V % ,
(3.35)
similar to (2.28) except that J^v is a second-rank tensor, transforming like the product of two coordinates. An infinitesimal Lorentz transformation for A and I/A then leads to the fundamental commutation relations a form satisfied by the spin-1 tensor matrix (3.30), as must be the case for all representations of the group (see Problem 3.2). Irreducible Representations. Next we investigate the irreducible representations of if J, similar in some sense to 0(3) x 0(3) because velocity transformations can be made formally to look like rotations. Given J^, define •>i ~ lEijkJjki
K-i — Joi>
(3.37)
so that the Lie algebra (3.36) becomes (Problem 3.2)
[Jt, K.j] = iZijkKki [Kt,K^=-iBtJkJk.
(3.38)
It can be seen from (3.28) and (3.31) that the hermitian angular-momentun operator J generates rotations and the hermitian "boost" operator K generates velocity transformations, represented by the active unitary transformations UMR) = e-«J,
C/L(p) = e - V K
(3.39)
Each operator in (3.39) has the structure of an 0(3) rotation, but the analogy is not complete, because the commutation relations (3.38) are coupled together. While (3.39) are infinite-dimensional unitary representations of <£\, the finite-dimensional irreducible representations of if J are not unitary (except in one dimension). The nonhermitian generators defined by A = i[J + iK],
B = i[J - iK],
(3.40)
decouple the commutation relations (3.38) according to (Problem 3.2) [Al,Aj] = ieUkAk,
[BhBj] = ieijkBk,
[At,Bj] = 0.
(3.41)
36 Transformations in Space-Time It is then possible to label the irreducible representations of jz?J as (A, B), where the operators A and B satisfy angular-momentum commutation relations (3.41a), (3.41b), but are decoupled by (3.41c). Inverting (3.40) and substituting in (3.39) gives t/A W = e~' e(A+B) > t/,
Dw(L(p)) =
(3.43)
If instead A = 0, so that B = J 0) , the (2/ + l)-dimensional irreducible representation (0,;') with Ul°,J) written as DU)(A) satisfies SU)(A(R)) = e~ie'
,0)
,
D0)(L(p)) = e c ' J0) .
(3.44)
We see from (3.43) and (3.44) that in general D°)(A) = D (J)t (A- 1 ).
(3.45)
For mixed representations (A, B) of j£?<j>, the Clebsch-Gordan composition (2.73) applied to A + B in (3.42) leads to effective rotation-group angular momenta A + B, A + B — 1,..., \A — B\. This fact will be useful for the construction of relativistic wave functions, to be discussed shortly. Matrix Representation. It is clear from (3.42) that direct-product representations such as (j, 0) + (0, j) will often occur, and it will be useful to combine them into a 2(2/ + l)-dimensional irreducible representation corresponding to the matrix
While Z)0)(A) and D0)(A) are not equivalent irreducible representations of J?}), the larger matrices S>U) and ^ 0 ) are equivalent because of the similarity transformation ®{1\A) = ^(A-1)
= p~ 1&Ui{A)P,
(3.47)
which follows from (3.45) along with
The significance of (3.46) is further reinforced by the space reflection operation (to be discussed in Chapter 6) under which D 0) -* 5 0 ) . Therefore the 3>a) of (3.46) are the finite, nonunitary irreducible representations of the larger group 5£, including the velocity transformations, rotations, and also space, time, and space-time reflections.
Homogeneous Lorentz Group 5£ 37
It is worthwhile to consider some specific representations of these boost operators. Later we shall demonstrate that the boost operator itself [i.e., LMV(p) as given by (3.22)] can represent the spin-1 boost. For the spin-i case, the (\, 0) boost is obtained from (3.43) as (Problem 3.3) Dw(Lp) = e-iia
= cosh & - o • p sinh #
(3.48)
in a manner similar to (2.51), where cosh if =
E+m 2m
sinh if =
m 2m
(3.49)
follows from cosh f = E/m. Combining (3.48) and (3.49), we see that £>(i)(Lp) = [2m(E + m)]-*(E + m-o-
p).
(3.50a)
D(i)(Lp) = [2m(E + m)]"*(£ + m + a • p).
(3.50b)
Likewise, the (0, \) boost found from (3.44) is
Since 2(2/ + 1) = 4 for j = \, the four-dimensional spin 4 boost constructed from (3.46) and (3.50) is 0<±>(I„) = [2m(E + m)\
(E + m)
oX
0 (3.51)
These spin-i boosts will play a fundamental role in the construction of the Dirac equation in Chapter 5. Carrier Space. The finite-dimensional irreducible representations of 5£ can also be characterized by the vector space of wave functions (carrier space) on which the Lorentz transformations act (analogous to \jm) for the rotation group). For example, the one-dimensional irreducible representation (0, 0) is specified by a scalar wave function
38 Transformations in Space-Time We now turn to more specific details concerning the group theoretical structure of relativistic wave functions with spin by first investigating the inhomogeneous Lorentz group.
3.C Inhomogeneous Lorentz Group 0> Group Properties. Enlarging <£ to include translations as well as Lorentz transformations, as in xj, = L/ia, A)xv = A„vxv + a„,
(3.53)
we obtain the inhomogeneous (a =/= 0) Lorentz group, known as the Poincare group &. This group is generated in Hilbert space by the unitary operator Ua,A=UaAU0>A=UaUA (3-54) with the closure properties
uQ. ua = ua.+a,
uA uA = uA.A,
t/ a , A . [/..A = t/„,+A.fl,A,A. (3.55)
The last result follows from successive applications of (3.53): Ua', K')Ua, A)x = L(a', A')[Ax + a] = A'Ax + A'a + a'.
(3.56)
From our prior experience with translations, rotations, and boosts, it is clear that the unitary operators in (3.54) have the exponential form Ua =Uatl=
expOaT„),
UA = l/0, A = exp( - ito'V,,),
(3.57)
where JMV is again the hermitian six-component antisymmetric tensor operator including the angular-momentum generators J and the boost generators K, and Pll is the hermitian energy-momentum vector operator, which generates time and space translations according to P„ = i d „ = ( i ^ , - i v j .
(3.58)
The significance of the minus sign in the space components of (3.58), dictated by quantum mechanics, as opposed to the plus sign in x„ = (x 0 , x), is that dM transforms like d/dx11 rather than like d/dx^. As such, the minus sign in the space component of (3.58) can be regarded as due to the metric tensor g^. Following the development of rotations and homogeneous Lorentz transformations, we now combine the infinitesimal forms of (3.57) with the closure relations (3.57). The resulting commutation relations are (see Problem 3.5) [ P „ J \ ] = 0, (3.59a) [J, v , P,] = iiP.g^ - P v „„), J
Vw Jpo] = i( n<,9vP + hP9w - J^dva - Jv„9np)-
(3.59b) (3.59c)
Inhomogeneous Lorentz Group 0> 39 Therefore the 10-parameter Poincare group (4a„, 6a»„v) has 10 infinitesimal generators (£, P, J, K) obeying the Lie algebra (3.59). Little Group. The irreducible representations of & must, of course, incorporate the representations of y discussed in Section 3.B. The inclusion of the momentum operator Pfl as an infinitesimal generator of ^ introduces the notion of a "little group" (Wigner 1939), defined by a subgroup of Lorentz transformations which leave the momentum of a particle invariant, A / A = p„,
(3.60)
where pM is an eigenvalue of the operator P^. An infinitesimal Lorentz transformation in (3.60) of the form of (3.26), A„v = 0„» +
(361)
< . p v = 0.
(3.62)
implies This latter condition is manifested if we choose «&*v = hvp°e"P° = -«&»,.» (3-63) where Qa is an arbitrary four-vector and E^,pa is the covariant extension of the Levi-Civita eijk, antisymmetric in each pair of adjacent indices, with £oo* = e .j*'
£
oi23 = 1-
(3.64)
The little-group transformations (3.60) are therefore described in Hilbert space by the unitary operator U'x = exp(-iid>MV J"v) = exp(i0„ W)
(3.65)
%=-K^PvJ^
(3-66)
with referred to as the Pauli-Lubanski four-vector and playing the role of a covariant angular momentum in (3.65). The latter analogy can be sharpened by searching for operator invariants (Casimir operators) which commute with every infinitesimal generator of the group. For 0(3) the only operator invariant is J 2 = j(j + 1), while for i£, only J 2 — K2 and J • K commute with all the group generators J, and Kt. For the inhomogeneous Lorentz group J", however, neither J 2 , J 2 — K2, nor J • K is an operator invariant; instead P^P* = P2 and Wu W = W2 commute with all group generators Jh Kh P{ (see Problem 3.6) and so are the Casimir operators for &. Since these quantities are also Lorentz invariants, they can be evaluated in any frame. In particular, in the rest frame of a particle with mass m and spin s, P^m„
= (m, 0),
WJm = (0, s),
(3.67)
and so the little group of 3? associated with a massive particle is the rotation group 0(3) with eigenvalues of the Casimir invariants P2 = m2 and
40 Transformations in Space-Time
W2 = — m2s(s + 1). These operator invariants are significant because all members of an irreducible representation of & must be eigenstates of P 2 and W2 with the same eigenvalues, P2(UaJil,}) = Va,sP2m W2(Ua^})
= m2(Ua,^»,
(3.68a)
= t4,A^2l = -m2s(s + l)([/ fl>A |^».
(3.68b)
The eigenstates or carrier space of this little group can therefore be labeled as | [m, s]p, er>, where [m, s] denotes the little-group irreducible representation (usually deleted) and p, a are the specific momentum and spin components in analogy with the 0(3) carrier space labeled by |// 3 >. Next we define spin-state wave functions as the spin-state matrix elements of the boost operator in (3.52), e ) ( p ) = < ^ | P ^ > = <^'|t/Lpk>,
(3-69)
where a refers to the spin-state row index and a' corresponds to the spinorcomponent column index. In this way, one sees that the rotation-group rest-frame eigenstates |
(3-7°)
a'
where l/A both Lorentz-transforms | p> and reshuffles the spin indices a in (3.70). The matrix D(s)(/?Ap p) is the usual spin-s rotation matrix with /?Ap,P (called the Wigner rotation) corresponding to the series of Lorentz transformations 17i (Ap)AL(p) and satisfying ^ s , f f (R A p , P )=<ApW|C/ A |p, f f > = W\UL-HJir)UJ,ULp\o\ 1
(IT (Ap)AL(p))/mv = ( r '(ApMAp), = m„
(3.71a) (3.71b)
where (3.71b) is a special case of the little-group transformation (3.60). The significance of this little-group analysis is that the simple rotation-group matrices, D(S)(R), are sufficient to describe the irreducible representations of the inhomogeneous Lorentz group 3>. Covariant Normalization. Finally we note that relativistically covariant states | pa} generated in this way are most naturally normalized in a covariant sense [recall (1.25)]:
(3.72)
where the factor of E = ym explicitly compensates for the Lorentz contraction of the momentum component parallel to the velocity transformation in the normalization integral of (3.72), and the accompanying factor of 2 is
Helicity Formalism 41 included for convenience. More specifically, the identity (recall p2 = pi — p2, E = VP 2 + m2) 0(PoMP2 - m1) = 9(p0)8[(p0 - E)(p0 + £)] = (IE)' M(p0 - E) (3.73) means that the normalization integral (recall dp = dp/In)
i S = I$* ( P o -E) = l^P^P2 - m2WPo)
(3-74)
is manifestly covariant. The factors of 2£ and 2n in (3.72) and (3.74) therefore cancel, and one is again left with a delta-function (three-dimensional) integral normalized to unity.
3.D Helicity Formalism While the rest-frame z-component of spin can be used to parametrize both the spin states and spinor components of the relativistic wave function (3.69), it is not a Lorentz invariant, but transforms according to a Lorentz transformation when the particle is boosted from rest. Another drawback to the rest-frame spin eigenstates is that they cannot be used to describe massless-particle wave functions, because E = p and v = c for m = 0, so that it is not possible to transform to a rest frame. On the other hand, the component of spin along (or against) a particle's momentum has a simple meaning in any frame and is a valid concept even for a massless particle. Thus one is led to the concept of "helicity", defined as X = s p,
(3.75)
where s is the spin of a particle and p its momentum direction. Helicity is a manifest rotation invariant; helicity states also transform simply under Lorentz transformations, as we now demonstrate. Massive Particles. Consider first the construction of a general helicity state for a massive particle m ± 0. Starting with the rest-frame spin eigenstate | (M> = | X}, where X is the J3 eigenvalue, first rotate | A> along the new z-axis p 9i0 = /?p3 as |p*> =
tf«»3l*>.
<3-76)
which leaves X unchanged [an 0(3) invariant]. Next boost the particle from rest to momentum p along the p-direction, obtaining the general helicity \pX) = ULf>\pX) = ULpURPi\X},
(3.77)
where again X remains unaltered. Using ULp URp = URp ULpi, it is also possible to reverse the order of the operation in (3.76), first boosting the particle along the p3-direction and then rotating p 3 to the general state p = p0 ^.
42 Transformations in Space-Time Massless Particles. Turning next to the construction of helicity states for massless particles, a solution in this case for the general little-group equation is Kv£*=h>
£„ = (*; 0,0, ±K),
(3.78)
which corresponds to a massless particle never at rest. As in the massive case, an infinitesimal A„v = g^ + cb^v has an antisymmetric (b^ which now obeys, instead of (3.62), cy„v£v = 0.
(3.79)
This relation constrains d)^v to only three (rather than six) independent values (e.g. a>l2,6ixo = (al3, d>20 = d)2i with associated infinitesimal generators J 3 , Ki — J2, K2 + J j , and the corresponding little group is E(2), the Euclidean group in two dimensions [and not 0(3)] (Wigner 1963). Evidently the action of Kx — J2 and K2 + J ± upon physical states has no physical significance, since they can be represented by zero, whereas exp( — iu>l2J3) corresponds to a simple rotation in two dimensions about the z-axis. To proceed further, it is useful to note the relation connecting the operators P„ and W,,: W„ = 1P„.
(3.80)
This relation follows from the definition of W^, (3.66), and the m = 0 limit of (3.68), i.e., P2 = W1 = P • W = 0. The proportionality constant in (3.80) can be interpreted as helicity, because the time component of (3.66) is W0=-$e0iJkP'JJk
= V-J,
(3.81)
so that the eigenvalues of (3.80) imply (P^ -+ /c„) X = J • k//c0, which is the definition of helicity (3.75) for massless particles, k = kk0. Since the eigenmomenta must be of the form of the little-group momenta (3.78b), it is clear that A = J-£=±|J3|.
(3.82)
Thus, a massless particle with spin is specified by only two independent helicity states, no matter how large s2 = s(s + 1) may be. This result is independent of the boost operation for massless particles defined by fc„ = ^/(k)£ v ,
|kA>=l/^ (k) |A>,
(3.83)
which boosts the two helicity states from momentum | K | = K0 = K up to |k| = k0 via exp( — i[,K3) with £ = log(|k|/K) and rotates k away from the K3-direction (Problem 3.8). We shall not, however, dwell upon the details of massless-particle boosts (see Weinberg 1964b). Common Properties. Even though there are 2s + 1 helicity states for a massive particle of spin s but only two states for a massless particle, it can be shown that the m = 0 limits of the massive states (3.77) are indeed massless states (3.83), with the corresponding if irreducible representation (A, B)
Helicity Formalism
43
giving X = B — A in the massless limit (Weinberg 1964b). There are, in fact, many properties which the massive and massless helicity states have in common, such as covariant normalization, < P T|pA> = 2E<5 3 (p'-p)<W
(3.84)
which will be a necessary condition in order to pass from m =/= 0 to the m = 0 limit. It is also possible to combine a state containing two particles with helicity (either massive or massless) into a single helicity state, | Pi Aip2 A2> ~ I Q^X in the "center-of-momentum" system p : + p 2 = 0, where px = qe ^, p 2 = — q = qn_fl n+(l>, and X = Xt — X2. Furthermore, an angular-momentum helicity state can be obtained from a massive or massless helicity state as | pjmX} oc J dQ. Dll\*(ReJ | p ^ X \
(3.85)
which in turn can be used to form a covariant partial-wave expansion analogous to (1.31) without reference to the nonrelativistic decomposition J = L + S, by replacing P, with D^\ instead. Helicity states have definite drawbacks, however, not the least of which is the problem of selecting proper phases. Fortunately, we shall be able to avoid these subtleties in practice by summing over all helicity states in a coherent fashion for quantities such as £ i//wil/*w. Projection-operator techniques also will be developed to select out specific helicity states from such a helicity (spin) sum (see Section 5.C). M-Function. An important link between Lorentz invariance and Poincare invariance is provided by helicity states (or rest-frame spin states for massive particles) and the S-matrix. In Sections l.B and 2.D we have exploited the rotational invariance of the S-matrix, and in Section l.D we have alluded to its dynamical content. Now we wish to explore its behavior under Lorentz transformations. Consider the helicity-state S-matrix elements
(3.86)
the helicity matrix elements (X\ X'2\S\ Xt X2} have rather complicated transformation properties under the action of the Lorentz group, the helicity components being "shuffled" by the Wigner rotations (3.70). It is customary to display this helicity dependence by factoring out of S the helicity wave functions of each particle, the remaining "M-function" then transforming simply under J? (dropping any energy- or momentum-conserving delta functions and assuming each particle has spin 1), (X\ X'2\S\ X, X2} = ^'»*^ 2 V»*M'"'«>-'' 2 ^V^ 2 ) -
(3-87)
Thus Mfll.fl2.pilfl2 is called the M-function for the process, transforming according to the homogeneous Lorentz group (spinor transformations will
44 Transformations in Space-Time
be considered in Chapter 5), M' • . 1 J
= A .V1'A .V2'A
flC2 >if2
'Vi
'V2
Vi
V1
V2
A 'V2
M . . m
»iv2v1v2-
(3 88) y->.oo)
As such, AfM1.M2>1/12 is a covariant cartesian tensor, composed of particle momenta and spin tensors, to be constructed in detail later. In (3.87) the momentum dependence of the S-matrix and wave functions has been deleted for brevity. Restoring it corresponds to expressing initial wave functions = •A^HP) I P^> a n d final wave functions IA* with the covariant cartesian tensor index (j. acting like a bra state for a spin-1 Poincare-group state iff p. For higher-spin particles, a higher-rank traceless and symmetric covariant tensor can be constructed along the lines of the rest-frame tensor wave functions of Section 2.E. Spin4 Helicity States. It will be useful to display spin4 and spin-1 helicity eigenstates explicitly, in parallel with the rotation eigenstates of Section 2.D. The s = -j helicity rest-frame eigenspinors for massive particles,
(3.89)
where X = ±\. These wave functions must also transform according to the irreducible representation of 0(3); in particular (3.76) implies
(3-90)
where D{£\ is the rotation-group matrix, given by (2.37) and (2.38) for) = \ and m -> X = +-j (see also Problem 2.5 or Appendix II), and ^ M - U s m * * }
*
< M ( |
H
cosi/)'
<3'91>
where we have taken (for 9 =
^*)(P3)=(i),
(3-92)
according to (3.89) and the Pauli matrices (2.48). Next apply the boost operators for j = ^, obtaining [for example from (3.50a)] the (j, 0) wave function describing a free particle moving with momentum p, helicity X, and covariantly normalized:
(3.93)
Here we have explicitly removed a factor (2m) - * from the boost (3.50a) because the covariantly normalized rest-frame spinors are ^Jlm <pa){p). Then
(3.94)
Helicity Formalism 45 by virtue of (3.89). Clearly only the X = —\ left-handed state survives for the (j, 0) representation in the massless limit, because the X = \ state must vanish by (3.94). Replacing p by - p in (3.93) and X by — X in (3.94) converts the (\, 0) to the (0, \) representation. Therefore only the X = j right-handed state survives for the (0, \) representation in the massless limit. Consequently, while massive spin4 particles (e.g., electrons, positrons) can have both helicity states X = +\, massless spin4 particles (e.g., neutrinos, antineutrinos) must have their momenta lined up along or against their spin, with only one configuration allowed for each irreducible representation of i£. We shall conclude later that nature chooses the (j, 0) representation for the (left-handed) neutrino and the (0, ^) representation for the (right-handed) antineutrino. Spin-1 Helicity States. Turning to the construction of spin-1 helicity eigenstates, it is most convenient (but not required) to choose (^, | ) helicity polarization vectors ef] in parallel with 0(3) polarization vectors sSm) and S£ wave functions (f)^. Identifying £^](p3) with rest-frame helicity states |p3A> for s = 1 and X = ± 1, 0, the covariant analogs of (2.43) are (again following the CSR phase convention) < ± 1 ) ( P 3 ) = + ( 0 ; 1 , ±U0)/y/2, 40,(P3) = (0; 0, 0, 1),
(3.95a) (3.95b)
where X = + 1 (— 1) corresponds to a right-handed (left-handed), transverse, circularly polarized helicity state, and X = 0 is a longitudinal state polarized in the z-direction for massive spin-1 particles. Note that with the rest momentum m^ = (w, 0), (3.95) leads to the "subsidiary condition" for X = ± 1, 0, "•"^(Pa) = 0-
(3-96)
Next rotate p 3 to p = Rp3 according to (3.76), giving (as in Section 2.D, the functional form of the polarization vectors remains unchanged) ^(P) = K^](U
(3.97a)
since e^ is a covariant four-vector, or alternatively, ^ ) (P) = I ^ ' ) ( P 3 M 1 1 ( ^ ) ,
(3.97b)
A'
similar to (3.90). Either (3.97a) or (3.97b) generates ef 10) (p) f° r general pfl>), but to simplify these expressions it is convenient to choose pe 0 with > = 0, corresponding to an active rotation by 9 about the y-axis in the x-z plane (see Problem 2.5 or Appendix II): elr M(P) = + (0; cos 9, ± i, - sin 0)1J% eJP'tP) = (°; s i n 0> 0, cos 6).
(3.98a) (3.98b)
46 Transformations in Space-Time
Not only is the meaning of helicity preserved by such a rotation, but so too is the subsidiary condition m"£^(p) = 0,
(3.99)
since the particle is still at rest. Finally, boost the particle along p from rest to momenta p via p^ = L^v(p)mv with L^v(p) given by (3.22): « ! » = V(p)e<*>(p). 2
(3-100)
2
This gives (with E = p0 = ^Jp + m , p= | p |, and
(3.101a)
^ ' ( P ) = + ( ° ; cos 9, ±i, -sin 9)1^/2,
(3.101b)
0)
4 (P) = (P; £ sin 0, 0, E cos 0)/m,
(3.101c)
with a corresponding subsidiary condition p"<>(p) = 0.
(3.102)
Thus, at all stages in the construction of the general spin-1 helicity states, a subsidiary condition naturally arises which guarantees that only 3 out of 4 components of d*) are independent, with the spin-0 part of the (^, ^) representation of J5f projected out according to the Clebsch-Gordan decomposition by (3.102). Photon Helicity States. It is also possible to pass to the m = 0 limit for spin-1 particles (i.e., photons), with only two helicity states X = ± 1 by virtue of (3.82). The little-group standard four-momentum (3.78b) is associated with eJ, ± 1 ) (K 3 )=T(0;l, ±U 0)1^/2.
(3.103)
After a boost and rotation to k = kfl 0 (with a> = k0 = | k |), (3.78b) and (3.103) become, in analogy with (3.101), kli= {a>;a) sin 9, 0, a> cos 9), <*"«-*.•«•?'*.>
(3.104a) (3104b)
= +(0; cos 9, ±i, -sin 6)/y/2, so that k»e(ll±1)(k) = 0. (3.105) As (3.105) only reduces the number of independent components of e„ from 4 to 3, it is not sufficient for describing a massless spin-1 photon, which can only have 2 independent components in e^. In group-theoretical terms, this problem arises because e„ transforms according to the (^, ^) representation of !£ with an 0(3) little-group structure when k-e — 0. A massless spin-1 wave function, however, is supposed to have a little-group transformation structure of E(2), the Euclidean group in two dimensions. The problem can
Helicity Formalism
47
be resolved by first noting the simple transformation law satisfied by e^ for transverse polarized helicity state (3.104b), #= u(A(R)k) = RJe? "CO = e 1 8 * ^ 1}(k),
(3-106)
where R is an active rotation by 0A about the £-axis. For little-group Lorentz transformations of the form (3.78), a transformation law similar to (3.106) holds for massless polarization vectors: A/ei* "(K3) = e™h?
1
>(K3)
+
z±
£>,
(3.107)
which satisfies (3.79) for infinitesimal A^v = g^ + 01^, with 0 = d>12 and X± = +(cbio ± i
(3.108)
it is possible to recast the transformation law (3.107) in terms of a general Lorentz transformation A as (Weinberg 1964c; see Problem 3.8) A/ - A o ' M e ^ A - ' k ) = e + ' ^ ^ f k ) .
(3.109)
The nonmanifest covariant nature of the A0V term in (3.109) corresponds to the radiation or transverse "gauge" for 4 ± n > namely e^*1' = 0, which was assumed in (3.103) and is now a consequence of (3.109) as well. It is possible to choose a different gauge for ej,11) and obtain a transformation law similar but not identical to (3.109) with a modified /cM term. This ambiguity will be resolved later by demanding that a choice of gauge cannot lead to physical consequences (gauge in variance); this will be the needed constraint, along with the subsidiary condition (3.105) which reduces the four spin states of eJ,A) to two for massless photons. General references on Lorentz transformations and the Lorentz group are: Schweber (1961), Bjorken and Drell (1964), Weinberg (1964a-c), Akhiezer and Berestetskii (1965), Gasiorowicz (1966), Martin and Spearman (1970), and Bargmann (1970).
CHAPTER 4
Boson Wave Equations
The dynamical quantum-mechanical wave equations of spin-0 pions, spin-1 vector particles, and massless spin-1 photons are formulated in a consistent one-particle fashion. For the spin-0 Klein-Gordon equation, the interpretation of negative-energy states as describing antiparticles is stressed. The relativistic bound-state Coulomb problem is then solved forrc-mesicatoms. The parallel is made between the massive spin-1 and photon wave equations. The notion of currents, current conservation and gauge invariance for photon amplitudes is discussed in detail and linked to the principle of minimal replacement. Minimal coupling of photons to charged particles will be the basis of the general electromagnetic interaction to be considered in later chapters. Second-quantized field theories are briefly described, and an analogy is made between (relativistic) photons and nonrelativistic phonons.
4.A Spin-0 Klein-Gordon Equation Derivation. For a particle moving at relativistic velocities (i.e., having a kinetic energy that is a substantial fraction of its rest mass), the nonrelativistic approximation for energy, E = m + p2/2m, is no longer valid and one must use instead the exact relation £ = (p2 + m2)*. The formal quantummechanical replacement p -» — iV would then result in the Hamiltonian H = ( - V 2 + m2)* 48
(4.1)
Spin-0 Klein-Gordon Equation 49 and a free particle Schrodinger-type equation id,il/ = ( - V 2 + m2)H.
(4.2)
Since the square-root operation in (4.1) and (4.2) is difficult to interpret, it would seem more reasonable to construct a relativistic wave equation associated with the square of the Hamiltonian operator, (idt)2(p = H2
(4.3)
where pM = id^, one is naturally led to the free-particle Klein-Gordon equation ( • + m2)(t>(x) = 0,
(p2 - m2)
(4.4)
2
Such a particle is said to be "on its mass shell", p = m . Covariance. The manifest covariance of (4.4) for a quantum-mechanical (Lorentz) scalar wave function, >'(x') = >(x), i.e., for | = l/A \
(4.5a)
4>'{x) = <x |
(4.5b)
implies that (a;3'" + m2))'(x') = (d^d" + m2)
(4.6)
Due to these transformation properties, the wave function + (x)oce- ip ' x = e' p "e- , ' £ ', f ( x ) o c c i ' J = e"ipV£'.
(4.7)
These equations are special cases of the general solutions of the KleinGordon wave equation containing a possible interaction term, cP±(x) = (t>±(x)e+iEt.
(4.8) 2
It is therefore clear that the use of the operator H in forming a wave equation leads to seemingly unphysical negative-energy solutions e+,Et as well as physical positive-energy solutions e~'E' for the quantum mechanical state of the particle. While this problem led to a temporary discarding of the Klein-Gordon equation in the late 1920s and early 1930s, we have since learned to live with it, as will be discussed shortly. Probability Current. Another problem which arises with solutions of (4.4) is the construction of a positive definite probability density. Paralleling postulate v in Section LA, one searches for a covariant probability current density
50 Boson Wave Equations h — (P> J) which obeys a continuity equation d% = 8% + dlh = 8, j0 + V • j = 0,
(4.9)
where we have used (3.60), 3" = (d„ V). The obvious candidate for j^ is the hermitian form 7„(x) = 4>*iS,4> = 4>*tt>4> - ' K >*)>,
(4-10)
because this current is conserved (d • j = 0) for states > and »* obeying the Klein-Gordon equation (4.4): d-j = id"(c/>*5M>) - i5"(05>*) = i>*D<£ - *'>•>* = 0.
(4.11)
Furthermore, since the spatial part of (4.10), j , is identical in form to the nonrelativistic current density (1.6) except for normalization, we are obliged by covariance arguments to accept the timelike component of (4.10), p, as the probability density. When combined with the general solutions (4.8), this probability density becomes ? + (x) = c/>*;30(K=2£|(/> + ( x ) | 2 > 0
(4.12a)
for positive-energy solutions, and p.(x) =
(4.12b)
for negative-energy solutions, with E > 0. Clearly a negative probability density is unacceptable; we shall contend with (4.12b) shortly. Wave Packets. Construct general spin-0, free-particle wave packets in the Hilbert space of positive and negative energy states as (normalized in a box—see Section l.B) , + (x) =
I2£^a'e"""JC'
*-W-J2§* *'*"'*
(4-13)
where the complex conjugation of bp follows the usual convention. The factor of 2£ (E > 0) in (4.13) is a manifestation of our covariant normalization of states. From (4.13) it is clear that the evolution of these packets does not alter their positive- and negative-energy character. Consider then a scalar product defined over the positive-energy states (4.13a) as (see Problem 4.1) <<*>'+,
(4-14a)
= j ^ 4 %
(4.14b)
= J d*p 8(p2 - m2)9(p0)a?ap/V,
(4.14c)
where 8(p2 — m2)6(p0) in (4.14c) indicates that only positive-energy states with p2 = m2 are allowed. Note that this norm is time independent [differen-
Spin-0 Klein-Gordon Equation 51 tiate (4.14a) with respect to time and use the Klein-Gordon equation; the result is obvious for (4.14b) and (4.14c)]. Note too that the norm (4.14) is a Lorentz invariant. Also, the covariant normalization of states,
(4.15)
for a plane wave of momentum p,. Interpretation of Negative-Energy States. Historically, the resolution of the negative-energy and negative-probability-density problems led to a reformulation of the Klein-Gordon theory in a many-body context. It is possible, however, to stay within a single-particle framework (Stuckelberg 1941; Feynman 1949) by interpreting (4.12a) as the charge density of a positively charged, positive-energy particle "propagating" forward in time (t > 0, E > 0) via the plane-wave phase e~iEt. Similarly, one interprets (4.12b) as the charge density of a positively charged, negative-energy state propagating backward in time (t = — |r| < 0) via eiEt = e~im. Alternatively (4.12b) is the charge density of a negatively charged, positive-energy particle propagating forward in time via the complex conjugate of the phase, e'E' = (e~'E')*. For neutral particles which are their own antiparticles (i.e., 7t" = n°, where c refers to the "charge conjugate" antiparticle—see Section 6.A), one can choose the wave function to be purely real or imaginary. In this case the probability density (4.12) vanishes, consistent with treating p as a charge density. Unfortunately, a thorough understanding of this interpretation must await a discussion of charge conjugation in Chapter 6 and "backward propagation in time" in Chapters 7 and 10. The Stiickelberg-Feynman interpretation is ideally suited for scattering processes, where the particle is free and unlocalized before and after the collision. For bound-state wave packets, however, a particle constrained to Ax < m"l and Ap ~ 1/Ax ~ m demands a superposition of all Fourier components, negative as well as positive energy:
>(*) = J ~ i K e - i r , +
fcpV'-).
(4-16)
Then (f)*4> contains interference terms e±2lEl which produce violent oscillations, referred to as "Zitterbewegung". Since such "jittery-motion" plays a more significant role for spin4 particles, we postpone a detailed discussion of it until Chapter 5. Suffice it to say that as E -> m, such interference between positive and negative energy components could have physical consequences. Feshbach-Villars Formulation. It is possible to circumvent these interference terms by constructing a Klein-Gordon bound-state wave function which has no negative-energy component in the nonrelativistic limit (Feshbach and Villars 1958). For (p satisfying the Klein-Gordon equation with time
52
Boson Wave Equations
derivative fy, define
»"i(* + s 4
x
(417)
-i(*-i*\
Because (j> = 0 + -+ e~iml as £ -*m implies q> -*• e~imt and x -* 0 by (4.17), (p is called the "large" and x the "small" positive energy component of <j>. Moreover q> and x satisfy coupled first-order equations in time, V2 iq> = -—
((p + x) + m(p,
V2 ix ^ , (•? + *) _ =
m
*-
(418)
These equations can be unified into one matrix equation satisfied by the column vector *=(*)'
(419)
and resembling the Schrodinger form ia,
(4.20)
where H0 is the 2 x 2 matrix "hamiltonian" H0 = ^(1 + a)p2/2m + pm,
(4.21)
with
'-(1-tt —C i> While the positive- and negative-energy states are coupled in this scheme, the problems associated with negative energy are not completely eliminated, because H0 as given by (4.21) is not hermitian in that
This links the large and small components q> and x together, implying as in (4.12) that the probability density p is not positive definite. If nothing else, however, this approach indicates that a second-order equation in time can be reduced to a first-order equation by doubling the Hilbert space of states via the column vector (4.19). [From an historical standpoint, Dirac learned this fact 30 years earlier when he discovered the first-order Dirac equation for spin-j particles (Dirac 1928).] Furthermore this formalism is ideally suited for nonrelativistic reductions. We will exploit a similar pattern in the case of the Dirac equation in Chapter 5. External Fields. Next we consider the modification of the Klein-Gordon equation for spin-0 particles in the presence of an electromagnetic field, specified by the vector and scalar potentials A and A0 as the four-vector Ap = (A0, A). Following the minimal substitution procedure of classical
Spin-0 Klein-Gordon Equation 53 physics, we take #„ = p„ - p„ - *Ki (4-23) where e is the electric charge of the particle, taken as positive unless otherwise specified. The Klein-Gordon equation then becomes [(id - eAf - m2](f>(x) = 0,
(4.24a)
or (O + m2)(p(x) = -J(x),
(4.24b)
where J(x) is a scalar current "source" density J(x) = 2ieA • d
(4.25)
or J = V
(4.26)
The doubling of the A, term in (4.26) is a consequence of A^ being real. Following the procedure (4.11), one can demonstrate that (4.26) is also conserved, since in this case d • j = i
d((p*
by use of (4.24b) and (4.25). Bound-State Coulomb Atom. Finally we consider the specific bound-state Coulomb problem of a spin-0 n~ particle with charge —e bound to a heavy nucleus with charge Ze (n-mesic atom). The static potential for this configuration is (a = e2/4n) eA, = Vd^o = - ^ 8,0.
(4.28)
Writing the positive-energy wave function as (p(r, t) = cp(r)e~iE', the spatial part obeys a Klein-Gordon equation obtained from (4.24):
K)
+ V2 - m2 4>(r) = 0.
(4.29)
This latter equation is solved by the standard method of separation of variables with 0(r) =
(4.27)
54 Boson Wave Equations In the limit £ -» m, E2 — m2 -»• 2m£NR, and Ztx
1(1 + 1) r
2mZ«" <j>{r)= -2m£ NR ^(r). r
(4.30b)
We are familiar with the solutions of (4.30b) for integer values of n — / = 1, 2, ..., corresponding to the Bohr energy levels for n. = 1, 2, ..., m(Za)2
E - m = £NR =
(4.31)
Given (4.31), we can infer the Klein-Gordon energy levels by replacing m-> E, £NR -»(£ 2 - m2)/2E [by inspection of (4.30a)], and n -> n' [see Schiff (1968)]: £ 2 - m 2 = -£ 2 (Za) 2 /n' 2 .
(4.32a)
This relation can be solved explicitly for the relativistic energy as £ =m 1+
(Za)2
(4.32b)
„'2
Here ri is a new relativistic principal quantum number with ri — I' equal to the usual nonrelativistic quantum-number difference n — I, assuming only the integer values ri — l = 1,2, 3, ...; and /' is the effective relativistic orbital angular momentum, inferred from (4.30a) to be /'(/'+l)=/(/+l)-(Za)2.
(4.33)
Solving (4.33) for /' gives ' ' = - i + [(' + i ) 2 - ( Z a ) 2 ] * , „' = „ _ / + / - = „ _ ( / + -y + [(/ + 1)2 _ (Za)2]*,
(434a) (4.34b)
where the positive sign of the square root has been chosen in order that /' may be nonnegative as Za -• 0, corresponding to bound radial solutions r' regular at the origin. This form of ri, (4.34b), is to be applied to the energy levels (4.32). For Za <^ 1, both (4.32b) and (4.34) can be expanded in the form of (4.31) with n = 1, 2, ... (see problem 4.2), £ —m
J
NR
m(Za)2 ~~2rF
1+
(Za) n V+ i
An)
(4.35)
This removes the / degeneracy of £ in the 0(a 4 ) relativistic fine-structure term. For large Z, (4.34) provides the constraint that for /' and ri real, the discriminant of the square root must be positive (of course, it cannot vanish) and for s-waves (/ = 0) this means that „, Z <
1 2a
=
137 lT
(4.36)
Spin-1 Wave Equation
55
If instead Z > l/2a, the centrifugal barrier term in (4.30) becomes attractive for s-waves and the energy becomes imaginary, so that the wave function has a damped exponential part and the particle orbits become unstable. The situation is similar to the classical relativistic situation for the Coloumb potential; for L2 < (Za)2 the centrifugal barrier also becomes attractive and the particle spirals in to the origin. Multiparticle quantum states then presumably play a role, with short-distance corrections such as vacuum polarization by pair creation (see Chapter 15) modifying the single-particle wave function. In the next chapter we shall again return to this strong-field limit for the case of bound electrons.
4.B Spin-1 Wave Equation Derivation. Starting with a three-component wave function >, describing a massive spin-1 free particle in its rest frame, two possible rest-frame covariant forms exist: a covariant four-vector ^ = (0, >,) and a rank-two antisymmetric (field) tensor >MV given by (recall the angular-momentum tensor operators LMV and J//v in Chapter 3) 0 Oi = — c/>l0 = 5f <^; and cf)00 = (frjj = 0. In a general frame, the boosted form of »/JV can be obtained from (/>M as ^v = 3 ^ v - 5 v ^ .
(4.37)
The free-particle dynamical relation between <\>^ and >/lv is called the Proca equation: <^„ v = m2tfv
(4.38)
Owing to the antisymmetric structure of (j)^, the derivative of (4.38) implies the subsidiary condition 5 " ^ = 0.
(4.39)
Since 0„ must transform according to the (^, j) representation of if, we know that (4.39) is required to rule out the spin-0 component in (/>,, (see Section 3.B). This in turn provides a group-theoretical justification for the dynamical equation (4.38). Moreover, using (4.37) to eliminate (j)^ in (4.38) and applying (4.39), we are led to a Klein-Gordon equation for the vector wave function, ( • + m2)
(4.40)
which, as in the spin-0 case, guarantees the correct dynamical relation between energy and momentum for a free particle. Current Densities. Given the wave functions (^v and >„, it is possible to construct a conserved, hermitian current density analogous to (4.10) but describing spin-1 probabilities:
56
Boson Wave Equations
The field equation (4.38) along with (4.37) then manifests 8 • j = 0. As was the case for the spin-0 probability density, j0 = p obtained from (4.41) is not a positive definite quantity. Likewise, negative energy and Zitterbewegung problems again arise, to be handled in a manner similar to spin-0 particles. We therefore proceed to indicate the new aspects associated with spin-1 wave functions. In the presence of an electromagnetic field, the minimal replacement (4.23) converts the field equation (4.38) from the spin-1 free-particle Klein-Gordon equation (4.40) to a similar equation containing a vector source current (see Problem 4.3), (a+m2)
(4.44)
with the polarization vector further specified by the helicity eigenvalues, E^\p) and k= ± 1, 0. The subsidiary condition d • (f> = 0 is therefore equivalent to p • e = 0, as derived earlier in (3.102). As in the spin-0 case, a factor of (2£)~* in (4.44) has been absorbed into the covariant normalization of the states, and a one-particle volume normalization factor of V - * has been set equal to unity. The orthogonality of the wave functions (4.44) then demands eW')*(p^>(p)=-^.A,
(4.45)
a result which can be verified from the specific forms (3.98) and (3.101). Likewise, in the rest frame of the particle, the completeness property of the polarization vectors implies £#>(PMA)*(P) = <5.7. >. and since <5y can be expressed in four-dimensional ~(9w — mllmv/m2), the boosted form of (4.46a) is I^)(PKA)*(P)=-(^V-^).
(4.46a) language as
(4.46b)
Spin-1 Maxwell Equation
57
The p-meson (mp « 776 MeV) and the co-meson (m„, « 783 MeV) are examples of spin-1 particles occurring in nature. They are significantly heavier than the spin-0 7t-meson (m, x 140 MeV).
4.C Spin-1 Maxwell Equation A massless spin-1 photon obeys a quantum-mechanical wave equation somewhat similar in structure to the massive one, with 0M and <^/JV respectively replaced by the four-vector potential A^ and the antisymmetric field tensor F /lv , where (4-47)
F„v = d„4 v - M M The Maxwell free-field equation is then [setting m = 0 in (4.38)] -d*F„v = nA„-dft(d-A)
= 0.
(4.48)
We take this as the dynamical wave equation for noninteracting photons. Existence of Gauges. Note now that a subsidiary condition d A = 0 is no longer a direct consequence of the field equation itself, as was (4.39). Rather, an ambiguity now exists, and the value of d • A is correlated with the way we restrict the number of spin states of the photon to two, as required by the helicity constraint X = ± 1. For plane waves, the representation for A^ satisfying (4.48) for a noninteracting photon with k2 = co2 — k 2 = 0 has the general form Att(x) = sli(k)e-ikx.
(4.49)
In Section 3.D we chose the "transverse gauge" for ej,* 1}(k) in order to insure only two independent components in e^: £f)
±1)
(k) = 0,
k-£ ( ± 1 ) (k) = 0.
(4.50)
But we cannot separately choose both conditions (4.50) in a frameindependent manner. A Lorentz-invariant choice is the combination k • s(k) = 0, and (4.49) then corresponds to the Lorentz gauge for (4.48): d-A = 0,
D ^ = 0.
(4.51)
While (4.51) is not the only gauge decomposition of (4.48), it is the natural choice for free photons, paralleling massive spin-1 particles. The transverse or radiation gauge is d • A = 0. In any case, the orthogonality and completeness relations for photon polarization vectors are analogous to (4.45) and (4.46): (4.52) e*w')(k)-ew>(k)=-^, valid in any gauge, while X e^(k) £ f*(k) = < 5 . v - ^ x= ± i
is valid only in the transverse gauge (4.50).
(4-53)
58 Boson Wave Equations
Gauge Invariance. It is possible to transform A^ to a different gauge so that (4.50) and (4.51) no longer hold but (4.48) remains an identity. This is achieved by a gauge transformation A^A^
+ B^ix),
e„-> e„ + ?*„,
(4.54)
kx
for a plane wave;
with £(x) an arbitrary scalar function becoming i^e~' thus d • A and k • e are transformed to d-A-»nt(x),
fc-e-»0.
(4.55)
1
Consequently, while k • e must always vanish for k = 0, d • A vanishes only in the Lorentz gauge (4.51). The connection between the minimal coupling replacement id^ -> id^ — eA^ and the gauge transformation (4.54) is the principle of "gauge invariance of the second kind". This is the coordinatedependent phase transformation of a charged-particle wave function,
(4.56a)
"where £(x) generates the gauge transformation (4.54), under which the canonical momentum transforms simply: (id„ - eA,M>{x) - g" «M(i3„ - d > ( x )
(4.56b)
Observables such as the current densities (4.26) and (4.43) are built up from bilinear products as >*> and >*(«?,, — eAjcj), manifestly invariant under the phase transformations (4.56); thus current conservation is naturally extended by this principle to include interactions in the presence of electromagnetic fields. From our viewpoint this is further justification for considering minimal replacement as a fundamental principle which generates the only interaction between charged particles and photons. In the context of lagrangian field theory, the principle of gauge invariance of the second kind [the first kind corresponding to a constant phase in (4.56) and linked to charge conservation] plays the central role and is sometimes considered the raison d'etre for the existence of A^ itself and its interaction with charged matter. Gauge principles recently have been used to generate other fundamental interactions (strong and weak), but such topics are beyond the scope of this book. One final fact about gauge invariance of significant import for us later will be the manner in which the two physical spin states of the photon are realized for a general interaction with matter. This is most conveniently stated by the Lorentz-invariant S-matrix element, itself expressed in terms of the M-function of (3.87). Accordingly, we may write Sw(k) = e^(k)M"{k), w
(4.57)
where S (k) and the polarization vector ef(k) represent a photon of momentum k and helicity L While M^ transforms like a simple four-vector under £?, we recall that e^ has a slightly modified transformation law (3.109) because a photon really behaves like an E(2) [and not an 0(3)] object under a little-group transformation. Applying (3.109) to (4.57) and using
Spin-1 Maxwell Equation 59 A / = (A" 1 )^ then leads to (see Problem 4.5) Sw(k): = eikB A / - A
0
^
eiX)(A~
^M^k)
CO
= eue £ W(A- 1 k)M"(A" 1 k) - A 0 v el A) (A" 1 k)^M' i (k) (4.58) Aside from an overall phase factor (of no consequence for physical probabilities), the Lorentz-invariant S-matrix transforms as a simple scalar (Weinberg 1964c) Sw(k) = ea@Sw(\~1k). (4.59) Then comparing (4.59) with (4.57) and (4.58), we see that MM must satisfy an additional constraint, *"M„(k) = 0.
(4.60)
This condition is sometimes referred to as "on-shell" gauge invariance (onshell refers to physical, as opposed to virtual or off-shell, energy or momentum—more about this later). It guarantees that e^l) transforms properly under little group transformations. The reference to gauge invariance means that (4.57) is invariant under the gauge transformation
(4.61a)
or in terms of the dynamical (Klein-Gordon-type) equation for /4„ in the Lorentz gauge (d • A = 0), OA,(x) = ejll(x)^rir(x).
(4.61b)
Note that the sign of the spin-1 source current in (4.61b) is opposite to that of the spin-0 source current in (4.24b). As a consequence we shall show later that this sign change is linked to a fundamentally attractive spin-0 force (e.g., the pion-exchange strong force) and a fundamentally repulsive spin-1 force (e.g., the photon-exchange electromagnetic force between particles of like charge). It is clear from the divergenceless nature of the left-hand side of (4.61) that this charged-matter current must be conserved: d • j(x) = 0. As noted after (4.56), this result is also a consequence of the quantum-mechanical structure of the probability current density, as given for charged spinless particles in (4.26), coupled with the principle of gauge invariance of the second kind as
60
Boson Wave Equations
applied to such particles via (4.56). The connection between current conservation and gauge invariance takes on further significance when formulated in momentum space. For a free, spinless, charged particle absorbing the four-momentum q = p' — p from a photon, the current density constructed from positive-energy packets (4.13a) becomes, via (4.15),
= \ji\jf
and the differential operator id^ in (4.62) requires the off-diagonal momentum-space current to be
(4-63a)
2
for a free photon, q = (p' — p) = 0. On the other hand, in the presence of an external electromagnetic field, q1 = (p' — p)2 ± 0; and on grounds of Lorentz covariance and current conservation, the off-diagonal momentumspace electromagnetic current must have the form e
(4.63b)
Here the charged particle is still considered as free, as in initial- and finalstate scattering configurations. Since d • j oc ^
+ p)
= F(q2)(m2 - m2) = 0,
(4.64)
which demonstrates the absence of the only other possible covariant in (4.63b), q^ = (p' — p)^ The dimensionless Lorentz-invariant function F(q2) is called a form factor. It represents all possible interactions between the charged particle and photons, altered only by "strongly interacting" particles also interacting with the spinless particle in question. At q2 = 0, (4.63a) demands that F(0) = 1, regardless of the type of interacting particles present. The conversion of the free-particle current [(4.10) in coordinate space or (4.63a) in momentum space] to the interacting forms (4.26) or (4.63b) for q2 41 0 is a complicated dynamical process which we shall attempt to explain in the latter half of this book. At the present level of discussion the interesting connection is between the dynamical current-conservation statement (4.64) and the kinematical on-shell gauge-invariance constraint (4.60). For a free photon with momentum k and k2 = 0, (4.64) is a special case of (4.60) (with q replaced by k). An analogous situation exists for spin-1 matter currents based upon (4.43) and also spin4 matter currents to be described in the next chapter.
Second Quantization: Photons and Phonons 61
4.D Second Quantization: Photons and Phonons Thus far we have treated a photon as a "particle" having a quantummechanical wave function obeying the dynamical wave equation (4.48) for a free photon and (4.61) for a photon interacting with charged matter. Needless to say, these quantum field equations are identical in form to Maxwell's equations for the classical electromagnetic field tensor, related to physical electric and magnetic fields as -Ei = F0i = dtAt-dtA0, Bt = hijkFjk = eiJkdjAk.
(4.65a) (4.65b)
This complementarity relation between a quantum particle and a classical wave or field can be extended one step further, to a quantum field, then referred to as second quantization. Noninteracting Photons. In such a quantum field theory, the vector potential of the radiation field is scaled to the space-time-averaged energy flux (Poynting vector), which in rationalized units (restoring h and c here) is <S> = c<ExB> = £ — |Ak|2fc,
(4.66)
c
k
where Ak is the Fourier component of the vector potential A(r, t) = X (A k e*- r e -to « + Aj
(4.67)
k
[Note that we have anticipated that A will be treated as an operator and have used Af instead of A* in (4.67).] If (4.66) is to represent a flux of photons of density N/V with energy hco and angular momentum h, then <S> = hcocN/V implies |A k | 2 = ^
-
(4.68)
In a second-quantized theory, (4.68) is interpreted as a matrix element
and
= Nk.
(4.70)
We see that the second-quantized field operator Ak has the same structure as the single-photon wave function (4.49), now noncovariantly normalized, except for the second-quantized operator ak, where a[ a^ is a number operator according to (4.70).
62 Boson Wave Equations
To proceed more rigorously, one treats (4.67) as a normal-mode harmonic-oscillator expansion and expresses the field energy as E = \ \d3x(E2 ^
+ B2y = YJh(o(Nk + $),
J
(4.71)
k
where use of (4.65), (4.67), and (4.69) leads to (4.71) with the identification (now being careful to respect the order of the operators A and Af)
= 2Nk + l.
(4.72)
Then abstracting (4.71) to a hamiltonian operator expressed in terms of canonical coordinates and momenta, the commutation relation [xk, pk] = ih leads to the second-quantized commutation relations (see Problem 4.6) [ak, al] = (5k,k.,
K , Ok-] = 0.
(4.73)
It is therefore clear from (4.72) and (4.73) that ak is an annihilation operator and al a creation operator in Fock space satisfying
(4.74)
and consistent with a^ ak being the number operator as expected in (4.70). Spin and Statistics. Second quantization is a natural way to build in the Bose statistics of the photon field from the outset via the commutation relations (4.73). Likewise the Bose statistics of spin-0 or spin-l massive particles can be built in by commutation relations such as (4.73) to form a similar free quantum field theory. A field theory of fermions also can be constructed in this way, with the commutation relations (4.73) replaced by anticommutation relations in order to manifest the Fermi statistics. This connection between spin and statistics follows in a natural way from the requirement of positive definiteness for the free-field hamiltonian (Pauli 1940). Interacting quantum fields are described in terms of coordinate-space lagrangian densities. While the methods of quantum field theory are elegant and powerful, we shall follow the simpler and intuitive (one-particle) methods of Feyman for the greater part of this book. This means we will be investigating the structure of (one-particle) current and hamiltonian densities (usually in momentum space) rather than lagrangian densities (in coordinate space). The connection between spin and statistics will be invoked as a postulate, as elsewhere in quantum mechanics (postulate vi, Section l.A); no reference will be made to the second-quantized commutation relations (4.73). Phonons. Before leaving this subject, it will prove useful to consider a nonrelativistic quantum field construct, that of phonons, corresponding to boson quanta but associated with lattice vibrations in a solid. Like photons, phonons have no mass—but this is not dynamically relevant. Instead the relation between phonon energy (frequency) and momentum (wave number) depends upon a "dispersion law" resulting in cwq « constant at small q for "optical phonons" and coq = cs | q | at small | q | for "acoustical phonons",
Second Quantization: Photons and Phonons
63
where cs is the velocity of sound in a solid, cs ~ 105 cm/sec. Since phonons are induced by displacements of lattice-site ions, they can be associated with a vector "spin", having longitudinal as well as transverse components. The scale of the phonon displacement amplitude A with Fourier coefficients Aq and expansion (4.67) is set by the time-averaged displacement energy of a spring with spring constant k = Mco2, where M is the lattice ion mass, <£> = 2xiMo; q 2 |Aj 2 .
(4.75)
Since this classical energy represents only half the energy of the spring (the kinetic energy accounts for the other half, by the virial theorem), the quantum analog of (4.75) is \ha>q Nq for Nq phonons of angular frequency u>q, giving
l A 'l 2 = 2 * ^ '
<4J6)
Paralleling the photon case (4.68) and (4.69), it would appear that the second-quantized phonon displacement field operator is
with aq and aq satisfying the commutation relations (4.73) and a\ aq is the number operator similar to (4.70). In Chapter 9 we shall employ the oneparticle phonon wave function (noncovariantly normalized) A(x l) =
'
V ipoTve{q)eiq'
Xe_iM,
''
(4J8)
where the ion mass M in (4.77) is expressed as pV in (4.78) so that the amplitude displays the usual one-particle box normalization. The ion density p varies from 2 to 20 g/cm3 in a solid, a typical value being 5 g/cm3. General references for boson wave equations are Hamilton (1959), Roman (1960), Schweber (1961), Bjorken and Drell (1964), Bethe and Jackiw (1968), Schiff (1968), Baym (1969), and Berestetskii et al. (1971).
CHAPTER 5
Spin-i Dirac Equation
What the Schrodinger equation is to nonrelativistic physics, the Dirac equation is to relativistic physics. We begin this chapter by describing three alternative ways of deriving this spin4 wave equation—the more the merrier, in order to develop as much intuition as possible about this fundamental dynamical tool. Next we formulate the Dirac equation in a manifest covariant manner and emphasize the structure of y-matrix algebra and the positive and negative free-particle solutions. The Dirac equation in the presence of external fields is then generated by minimal replacement, and the resulting electron bound-state energies are obtained for the one-particle Coulomb atom and for a constant external magnetic field. We pay particular attention to the difference between the Dirac atom and the fine-structure level shifts in the Schrodinger atom. Finally, we develop free-particle Dirac equations for spin-j massless neutrinos and spin-f massive particles.
5.A Derivations of the Dirac Equation The Dirac equation plays a fundamental role in any relativistic quantum theory, not only because it circumvents many of the problems arising from an unphysical interpretation of the Klein-Gordon equation, but also because it naturally describes the basic spin4 constituents of matter at the atomic and nuclear level—electrons and nucleons (protons and neutrons). To appreciate the significance and beauty of the Dirac equation, it is well to describe three alternative derivations: the original relativistic approach of 64
Derivations of the Dirac Equation
65
Dirac, the ad hoc but elegant derivation via a Pauli spin-matrix replacement, and finally the group-theoretic derivation. Dirac's Derivation. In order to obtain a positive definite probability density for spin4 particles, Dirac searched for a relativistic differential equation which was first order in time (Dirac 1928, 1958). To this end he interpreted the Schrodinger equation, (id, — HQ)^/ = 0, as generated for spin 4 particles by a free-particle matrix hamiltonian H0, first order in momentum for relativistic considerations: H 0 = a p + /?m.
(5.1)
Here a; (i = 1, 2, 3) and /? are four matrices to be determined, and p is the usual quantum-mechanical momentum operator — iV for a particle of mass m. Since the single-component spin-0 Klein-Gordon equation leads to a rwo-component first order matrix (Feshbach-Villars) equation (4.20), it is natural to suppose that a two-component spin4 equation, second order in time, should be linked to a four-component matrix equation, first order in time. Such a "guess" was all the more impressive at the time because Dirac did not have the hindsight of the Feshbach-Villars equation. Thus one assumes that a, and ]8 are 4 x 4 matrices and that the Dirac wave function \// -»\j/„ is a four-component (Dirac) bispinor. The second-order equation in time for a free particle must, of course, be of the Klein-Gordon form, which in momentum space is obtained from the first-order equation via multiplication by E + H0: (E - H0)iP = 0 -> (E2 - H2)^ = 0.
(5.2)
Dirac then demanded that the square of the 4 x 4 matrix hamiltonian (5.1) be constrained to E2 = p 2 + m2 by (5.2), i.e., Hi = i(a,o, + ajOifapj + (/fat, + a,/*)p, + P2m2 = p 2 + m2.
(5.3)
This leads to the defining properties of the matrices a, and /?: {a„a,} = 2S y , {/J,al} = 0, a2 =/? 2 = 1.
(5.4)
Furthermore, since H0 must be an observable hermitian operator, so must a; and /? be hermitian:
a/ = «„
P = P.
(5.5)
The adjoint row bispinor i/^ can be combined with the column bispinor xf/ to form a positive definite probability density P
= ^V= I Ma,
(5-6)
now naturally linked with the hermitian probability current density j = i/^ai/f.
(5.7)
66 Spin-i Dirac Equation
A justification for the form (5.7) is the resulting continuity equation 8,p + V • j = 0, which follows from (5.6), (5.7), and the Dirac equation (id, - H0)i}> = 0,
(5.8)
where H0 obeys (5.1) and (5.3) (see Problem 5.1). From the properties (5.4), it is clear that at = — /?<x,/? and /J = — a.l^a.l, which means that these matrices are traceless (Tr ft = YZ=i PooYTr otj = Tr p = 0,
(5.9)
since Tr BA = Tr AB. It is then useful to describe at and /? by a specific representation, such as the Dirac-Pauli representation, a =
C »)• H i -")•
[which, of course, satisfies the general properties (5.4), (5.5), and (5.9)], where the elements, a and 1, are themselves the 2 x 2 Pauli and identity matrices, obeying oiOj = 8ul + isiJk(Tk. (5.11) Dirac used this representation (5.10) to obtain the first (but by no means the last) profound prediction of the Dirac equation. Making a two-component reduction of (5.8) in the presence of an electromagnetic field via the DiracPauli representation (5.10), he discovered that the electron must have the unique magnetic (dipole) moment ^
= 2X
^neX2=2me°>
<5"12>
i.e., the Lande g-factor is ge = 2, a result in almost perfect agreement with experiment and assumed ad hoc up to that time. We shall return to Dirac's method of predicting ge = 2 in Section 5.D and to the small but important corrections to this result in Chapter 15. Derivation via Pauli-Spin-Matrix Replacement. This leads naturally to the second derivation of the Dirac equation with ge = 2 as input [see, e.g., van der Waerden (1932), Sakurai (1967)]. Recall from (5.11) that the square of any vector such as p 2 is equivalent to the Pauli-spin-matrix replacement (a • p)2. The question then arises as to when this substitution is required, i.e., for all or only a few problems involving spin-^ particles. Furthermore, while (o • p)2 = p 2 , it is clear that in the presence of an electromagnetic field, the minimal replacement p -»• n = p — eA means (
(5.13)
Need nonrelativistic or relativistic momentum operators be subject to this Pauli-spinor replacement ? Consider first a nonrelativistic free-particle hamiltonian with p2/2m -»• (
Derivations of the Dirac Equation
67
field, (5.13) then leads to the Pauli hamiltonian H = ~(ap)2^^n2-~aB. (5.14) 2m 2m 2m The spin-dependent term in (5.14) has the form — u • B, with \i = gnBJ where J = a/2 and g = 2, a very desirable result. Given this success as input, we are encouraged to apply this mnemonic to all problems involving p 2 and spin \. In particular we modify the spin4 Klein-Gordon equation to [E2 - (a • p)2]> = m2<$>,
(5.15a)
which then has the time-dependent factored form (id, — a • p)(idt + a • p)> = m24>.
(5.15b)
Now we parallel the discussion of the Feshbach-Villars version of the Klein-Gordon equation (Section 4.A) by defining
(5.16)
and expressing the second-order equation (5.15) as two coupled first-order equations, (id, + a • p)(pL = mcpR,
(id,-o
-p)(pR = m
(5.17)
Further defining (p =
X =
(5-18)
and using the Dirac-Pauli representation (5.10), the first-order equations (5.17) for these two-component spinors can be put into the four-component Dirac-equation form (id, — H0)\f/ = 0, with ty = (£) and
again the Dirac free-particle hamiltonian. Setting p = 0 in (5.17) means that
#M0)=±M0),
(5-20)
stating that the Dirac-Pauli representation diagonalizes the bispinor energy states in the extreme nonrelativistic limit. Alternatively we may use another representation for a, and /?, called the Weyl representation
68 Spin-^ Dirac Equation also satisfying the defining relations (5.4), (5.5), and (5.9). Given (5.21), the two-component equations (5.17) again can be combined into the fourcomponent Dirac form (5.8) provided that
in this representation (Problem 5.1). In Section 5.E we shall show that for m = 0, (5.17) indicates that
(5.22a)
Ml>) = D(Lp)(pR(0) = [2m(E + m)]-*(£ + m + a • v)
(5.22b)
from which one can derive the coupled relations (5.17) (see Problem 5.1). Now use (5.22) along with the matrix boost obtained from (3.51) in the Weyl representation as 9{L>) = ( D ( ^ }
5(°^})
= [2m(E + m)]-*[(E + m)l + a • p], (5.23)
where 1 denotes the 4 x 4 unit matrix (sometimes deleted). Again expressing the Dirac bispinor in the Weyl representation as \j/ = (££), (5.22) and (5.23) boost i/f(0) from rest to *(p) = ®(I*M0). (5.24) Finally, to recover the Dirac equation, operate on (5.24) with id, — H0, obtaining (id, - H0)iA±(p) oc [±E - (a • p -I- j8m)][±£ + a p + m]il/±(0) = (£2-p2-ro2)>M0) + m(±E + m-<x- p)(l + P)il/±(0). (5.25)
Covariant Formulation 69 The first term on the right-hand side of (5.25) vanishes by the energymomentum relation, and the second term is zero by (5.20). Thus the Dirac equation (id, — H0)i// = 0 is equivalent to the Klein-Gordon constraint plus (5.20), which projects out the positive- or negative-energy parts of \p. Put another way, the Dirac equation is the boosted form of the rest-frame energyeigenvalue relation (5.20) subject to the energy-momentum (mass-shell) constraint E2 — p 2 = m2 for p in an arbitrary direction. In Chapter 6 we shall learn that (5.20) has invariant meaning as the spatial-inversion (parity) eigenvalue relation. Combining two-component spinors which transform into one another under spatial inversion as in (5.23) means that 3) is again equivalent to the parity transform via (3.47), P&(Lp)P = .@(L_P). This is sometimes considered the main motivation for the four-component Dirac formalism. Another is the fermion mass; if it is zero then the two-component equations (5.17) suffice.
5.B Covariant Formulation Covariant y-Matrices. It is possible to formulate this relativistic fourcomponent formalism in manifestly covariant language by expressing the Dirac matrices /} and a in terms of covariant ^-matrices y„ = (y0, y), defined as y0 =
fi,
y = /fa. 2
(5.26) 2
These matrices have the "lengths" (y? = y = y| = y .) y2o=-yf=l
w' = r p 4
(5.27)
and satisfy fundamental anticommutation relations following from (5.4): {y^y,} = y^v + y,y^ = ^9^-
(5-28)
Note that (5.28) has the form of a covariant symmetric tensor equation; this implication will be discussed shortly. Next combine the hermitian and antihermitian relations yj = y0 and y/ = — y, into a "Dirac adjoint" matrix operation iv = 7o7j7o = y„,
(5.29)
where in general the Dirac adjoint (barred operation) of any 4 x 4 matrix is A = y0 A*y0 with AB = BA. That is, (5.29) implies that y„ is "self-barred". Then define the new y-matrices 7s = 70 7172 73
(5.30a)
satisfying 75 = 7s,
7s = - 1 ,
7s 7„ = -7„7s,
(5.30b) (5.31a)
70
Spin4 Dirac Equation
satisfying a^ = a^, since i = —i and Gij — £;jfc
°i = kijk°jk>
ffoi = iyo y.- = '«,- = - 7s
(5.31b) ffi.
(5-3 lc)
where a{ are now 4 x 4 matrices, built up from the 2 x 2 Pauli matrices as (" „). In the latter case, a = iy5o follows from a t = iyoTi^ysiyz73 — yo7i, etc. Since 4 x 4 matrices have 16 possible elements, there must be 16 independent y-matrices. We may choose these independent matrices as the selfbarred set r , = 1, y„ < v , iy„y5, y5 = S(l), v(4), T(6), ,4(4), P(l),
(5.32)
where 1 is the one scalar (S) unit matrix, yM are the four vector (V) matrices,
(5.33a)
( 5 - 33b )
y5^ = i w ^ y„ yv yP = 0M. yP - gw y, + g,P y» - « w V"TS >
(5.33c)
w y V Y = -3!y,y 5 ,
(5.33d)
£,vpffy/'yYy''=-4!y5, y^/vyp/ff
CT/iv/p/ff
(5.33e) y^pivia
• yvpinto
• yparptv
yvo/n/p
+ y5 W "
(5-33f)
etc., where the y-matrix products on the left-hand sides have been expressed as linear combinations of the 16 Tt on the right-hand sides of (5.33), and we have used the fundamental properties of the Levi-Civita pseudotensor ( e 0123
=
1)> pnvpa — _ 4 |
(5.34a)
F
f '">" =
(5.34b)
P
P
F
etc.
— 3 I Jim'
P" — — "> 1
9m
9v«
9»t>
9vp
(5.34c)
Covariant Formulation 71 As regards the matrices /? and a, the y-matrices satisfying only (5.27) and (5.28) then have many possible representations. The representationindependence (Pauli-Good) theorem states that all representations of ymatrices are equivalent up to a similarity transformation, y'tl = S~lyflS. The Dirac-Pauli representation, diagonalizing energy via y0 in the extreme nonrelativistic limit, is 1 0\ . 10 1) 7o= 0 -1 ' ^ 5 = 11 0 (5.35) 0
"
\0
whereas the Weyl representation, diagonalizing helicity via y5 in the extreme relativistic limit, is 0 1\ / - l 0^ y =
°
'i o '
H-:;>
iy5
'~\
o ir
(5.36)
-[i:\
Other representations, including the Majorana and the light-plane representation, are worked out in Problem 5.3. Covariant Transformation Laws. To put the Dirac equation (id, — H0)i// = 0 on a covariant footing so as not to single out time via d„ multiply the equation on the left by y0—obtaining (iy0 d0 — y • p — m)i// = 0—and use p = — iV. This results in the covariant form of the Dirac equation, (iy • d - m)\jj(x) = 0.
(5.37)
Henceforth it will be convenient to define a "slash" operation 4 = y 'A so that (5.37) takes on the compact form (i) — m)i// = 0. To verify that (5.37) is indeed covariant under homogeneous Lorentz transformations x' = Ax, we rely upon the discussion in Chapters 2 and 3 to obtain a 4 x 4 spinor matrix ^(A) which transforms the bispinor wave functions in a fashion analogous to (2.1c), IA'(X') = ^(A)^(x). (5.38) Since the Hilbert-space operator is (7A = exp( —jo»''vJ/lv/2), the obvious identification J/iV -» <J/1V /2 in the spin4 Dirac space means we can write y(A) = exp(-ia/V„ v /4).
(5.39)
An infinitesimal transformation A„v -> g^ + OJ^ induces (5.39) to become y(A)-» 1 — ict/v<7„v /4, and the y-matrix identity (see Problem 5.2) [ff„v, yP] = 2i(gpvyli-gPflyv)
(5.40)
then leads to the transformation law for y-matrices,
(5-41)
72
Spin-j Dirac Equation
[Note that (5.41) bears the same relation to the Lorentz group as (2.15) and (2.52) do to the rotation group.] It is in the sense of (5.41) that yll transforms like a four-vector; since y^ is a constant matrix, yj, has no meaning other than (5.41). Then we establish the covariance of (5.37) by multiplying it on the left with y(A): 0 = y(A)(iy • d - m)iA(x) = [ ^ ( A ^ y ' H A K - mMA)iA(x)
(5-42)
= (iA-Vd» - mty'(x') = (iy • d' - mW{x% where we have used d'v = (dx^/dx'^d* = A'/S". Thus, (5.42) implies that the Dirac equation (5.37) is valid in any frame x' = Ax, an explicit demonstration of the meaning of covariance. Now we extend the Dirac adjoint or "bar" operation to bispinor column vectors. Define the row bispinor $ =
(5-43)
If if/ satisfies (5.37), then $/ satisfies the adjoint Dirac equation (# - m)«A = ifr{ -1? - m) = 0,
(5.44)
_1
since ytt = y^. Then using £?(A) = 5^ (A), which follows from (5.39) and d^ = a^, we have from (5.38) ^'(x') = $(x)?(A) = $(x)&-
X
(A).
(5.45)
Combining (5.38), (5.41), and (5.45), we can obtain the transformation laws for the bilinear covariants ^ r , \p (now "c-numbers" in the Dirac space, since a row times a column matrix is a pure number—see Problem 5.4), S: ^'(x')iA'(x') = #(*M*)
(5.46a)
V: ^'(x')y^'(x') = A/.A(x)y>(x)
(5.46b)
T: ^(x'K v ^'(x') = A/A v ^(x)a a/! V(x)
(5.46c)
A-
(5.46d)
^'(x')iy,y 5 *'(*') = (det A)A„>(x)iyvy5iftx)
P: ^(x')y5
(5.46e)
It is in this sense that the r ; transform like integral representations of if, indicating, for example, that the Dirac probability current (5.6) and (5.7), expressed in covariant form as ;„ = ^ ( 1 , atyr = ^(y 0 , y)* =
fa^,
(5.47)
transforms as a four-vector, j'^x') = A/;'v(x), with a continuity equation d • j = 0 which is invariant from frame to frame. Dirac Trace Algebra. The bilinear covariants just discussed can be used not only to construct the probability current;^, but also to form the S-matrix or transition-probability matrix elements for a process involving a spin-j parti-
Covariant Formulation
73
cle. In analogy with (3.87) we write <^'|S|A> = ^W'>M^W),
(5.48)
where i//A) and \j/(X"> are column and row bispinors which are eigenstates of helicity, and M is a scalar 4 x 4 matrix composed of invariant products of momenta and y-matrices. The complex conjugate (*) of (5.48) can be expressed in terms of the Dirac adjoint matrix, M = y0 M^y0, according to * = (^'>M^ W ) ) t = ^ttt>Mtj£ttt'> = iAtU)yo7oMty0'u') = VX)M\l/(X'\ The physical quantity of interest is the transition probability, which corresponds to the product of (5.48) and (5.49); summing over all possible helicity states (unpolarized spin sum), we write
X |a'|S|A>| 2 = X^u')M^A?iAu'), k',k
(5.50)
k'
where SP is a Dirac "projection" operator gp = £ ^wyw (5.51) x obeying SP1 = SP for orthonormal bispinors ij/u 'tyU) = 5XX. Rearranging the bispinors in (5.50) to the form (M^,M)(7-
|| 2 = T r M ^ M ^ ' .
(5.52)
Now we shall show shortly that the projection operators & and 3P' can be expressed in terms of y-matrices, so (5.52) represents in principle a trace over the product of many y-matrices. Consequently it will prove useful to describe the trace algebra of y-matrices. To begin with, in the Dirac space Tr 1 = 4.
(5.53a)
Inspection of the Dirac-Pauli or Weyl representation [(5.35) and (5.36)] or application of the defining relations (5.28) and (5.4) along with the property Tr AB = Tr BA gives Tr y„ = Tr y5 = 0, (5.53b) Tr yMyv = i Tr{y„, yv} = 0(IV Tr 1 = 4 ^ v ,
(5.53c)
and from (5.30b) and (5.33b), Tr y5y„ = 0,
Tr y5y„yv = -\iz^
Tr &" = 0.
(5.53d)
Next, note that (5.33c) then implies Tr y^ yv yp = 0, which can be extended to a product of any odd number of y-matrices y ^ (excluding y5, which is an even product y0 yx y2 y3) via multiplication of (5.33c) by successive pairs of y-matrices, implying that Tr yM = 0. (5.53e)
74 Spin-j Dirac Equation
For even numbers of y-matrices, (5.53a) and (5.53c) are nonvanishing; for four y's, use of (5.33c) or (5.33f) leads to Tr y»yvypy„ = Mg^Qpa - g^g*. + g^g,P\ Tr y5 y„ yv yp ya = - 4£„VP(T,
(5.53f) (5.53g)
with £0123 = 1- The l a s t identity may be verified by choosing /i = 0, v = 1, p = 2, a = 3, and using (5.30a). Multiplication of (5.33f) by y„ yx leads to the trace of six y-matrices, but at this point and thereafter it is easier to apply repeatedly the anticommutation relation (5.28) to permute y„ from one side of an even number of y-matrices to the other and then use Tr Ay^ = Tr y„ A to find in general (see Problem 5.5) Tr y„yvypyB • • • = g„v Tr ypyff • • • - g^ Tr yvyn • • • + 0^Tryvyp
etc.
(5.53h)
It is clear from the algebra (5.53) that including two additional y-matrices in a trace can lead to a considerable complication. Quite often, however, the indices of two of the y's are summed (contracted), in which case repeated applications of (5.28) results in (see Problem 5.5) ^y„f =-2y„, y*y„7vf = 40„v, y. )V ?v yPf=-
2
)V 7v y„,
y*y*y*ypy.f = 2(yffy„yvyP + yPyvy„y,x),
(5.54a) (5.54b) (5.54c) (5.54d)
etc. The identities (5.54) should be applied before computing y-traces according to (5.53). The y-matrix traces can be used to verify the completeness of the 16 Dirac covariants r, of (5.32), with Tr r , r , = 4 ^ ,
(5.55)
where */, = + 1 for T, = 1, y0, iy,y5, a, and r\{ = - 1 for T, = y5, yh iy0y5, o0i. Then any 4 x 4 matrix can be expanded as M = £ a, T; with the coefficients from (5.55) found to be 4a; = JJ, Tr Mr,. Also the completeness relation (5.55) is needed to develop Fierz "reshuffling" matrices (see Problem 5.6).
5.C Free-Particle Solutions of the Dirac Equation Positive- and Negative-Energy Spinors. In the spirit of the free-particle spin-0 analysis, we now examine the positive- and negative-energy solutions of the covariant free-particle Dirac equation ( # - m t y ± ( x ) = 0.
(5.56)
Free-Particle Solutions of the Dirac Equation
75
For the positive-energy solution corresponding to a particle of momentum p (with V = 1), we write il/+(x) = u{p)eivxe-iEt,
(5.57a)
while for the negative-energy solution with energy — E (E = ^/p2 + m2 > 0) associated with momentum — p, ^Mx) = w(p)e-' p •V £, .
(5.57b) 2
In both cases we require the spin-^ particle of mass m to obey E — p 2 = p2 = m2. Substituting (5.57) into (5.56) then leads to the momentum-space Dirac equations {p - m)u(p) = 0,
it(p)(p - m) = 0,
(p + m)v(p) = 0,
v(p)(p + m) = 0.
(5.58a) (5.58b)
It is convenient to normalize the positive-energy spinors u(p) and the negative-energy spinors v(p), choosing the signs according to (5.20), so that u(p)w(p) = 2m,
v(f)v (p) = — 2m,
(559)
while i//± are normalized covariantly in analogy with the spin-0 KleinGordon solutions (4.7). To obtain the free-particle solutions in the rest frame, we evaluate (5.58) in the limit p0 = m, p = 0, obtaining yo«(0) = u(0),
yov(0)=-v(0).
(5.60)
[Recall that the notation u(0) emphasizes the p = 0 aspect of the rest-frame wave functions; rest-frame two-component spinors will be written as >(p) as a reference for rotations.] In the Dirac-Pauli representation with y0 diagonal, (5.60) diagonalizes the energy (mass, in the rest frame) with the spinors expressed as
u(0) = y/2^fe\
r(0) = V2^(°J,
(5.61)
where q> and i are two-component spinors, both normalized to unity in order that (5.59) may remain valid. In particular, we further specify these two component spinors as helicity eigenstates
VP?W(P) = V1P)
(5-62)
and represented by the rotated spinors (3.91). The reason for the choice of phase e T '* for k = ±\ in /(p) will be explained in Chapter 6. We may also recognize (5.60) as equivalent to the boost constraint (5.20) in the Lorentz-group derivation of the Dirac equation. In this case, the
76 Spin-^ Dirac Equation
covariant version of the Dirac boost matrix (5.23) is, since E + a • p = 1>y0, ®(L,) = [2m(E + m)]-*(fiy0 + m) , x
(5-63)
so that @(L„) = y(Lp)- Application of this boost to (5.61) and using (5.60) with X = ±j then leads to
^)-»W^)--^i( , , 7 W ).
(5.64a)
^-*^>^>-7S^UA-J
(564b)
From the form of (5.64) it is clear that these bispinors satisfy the free-particle Dirac equations (5.58), since /*/> = \{p, p} = p2 = m2 implies that [p - m)wU)(p) oc (p - m){p + m) = p2-m2 w
2
= 0, 2
{p + m)v {p) az(p + m)(p - m) = p - m = 0. Further, the bispinors (5.64) are indeed helicity eigenstates, obeying by virtue of (5.62) and [a • p, p] = 0 & • p«(A)(p) = Xu^(j>),
(5.65a)
• pVA)(p) = *»w(p)
-\e
(5.65b)
for X = ±\, where a in (5.65) is now the four-component Dirac spin matrix. Thus, the advantage of the explicit boost construction in the Dirac-Pauli representation (5.64) is that it manifests both the Dirac equation and helicity constraints satisfied by positive- and negative-energy bispinors. Moreover, the connection between u(p) and r(p) for momentum states — p in the latter case is made readily apparent by (5.64). There is another use for the boost operator, that of "de-boosting" u(p) and v(p) back to the rest frame, sometimes referred to as the "nonrelativistic reduction" procedure. Recalling that — Yy0 =fys<*> w e express the boost (5.63) and its Dirac adjoint in terms of the even (diagonal) operator 1 and the odd (off-diagonal) operator y5 a • p in the Dirac-Pauli representation, converting the bispinors to the form
^(p)=^ ,y/E"::+/sm: p (
( 5 - 66a )
E + m + iy5 a
«(>) = ( /
(
1 p ) , 0 ) £ ^ t o yJE + m E + m + iy5a • p yjE + m
)
^-""^•"UA-J *«« = (0, e± V u , (-P)) £
+ m
/F|y5
(5.66b)
(Mfc) (5.66d)
Free-Particle Solutions of the Dirac Equation
77
The nonrelativistic reduction of bilinear covariants such as ur ; u can be easily obtained using (5.66) to identify the net even operators (in the DiracPauli representation) of ® r ; ® . For «r,H and vT^, only net even operators (two-component diagonal) contribute, while for ur ; v and vrt u only net odd operators (two-component off-diagonal) do (see Problem 5.7). Free-Particle Projection Operators. Recalling that the two-component spinors satisfy the completeness relation
X>WWW)(*)=1,
(5.67)
x we expect the four-component bispinors to obey some sort of analogous relation. Given (5.64) and (5.67), we may compute
(E + m)i «w(p)iiw>(p) = {i> + m) I1 °) (P + m) \U U / = i(/> + m){\ + y0)(p + m).
*
(5.68)
With the help of the anticommutation relations (5.28) and p2 = m2, we see that py0 i> + m2y0 = 2Ep, (y0 /> + py0) = IE, and (p + mf = 2m(p + m). Then the factor of (E + m) cancels from both sides of (5.68) and we obtain 2
X wa)(p)"U)(p) = /* + ™,
(5.69a)
x and similarly 2
X vU){p)vw{p) = t-m. (5.69b) x These useful relations can be verified by applying the Dirac operator (/> — m) to (5.69a) and (p + m) to (5.69b); the normalizations are easily confirmed in the rest frame via (5.61). The identities (5.69) define respectively positive and negative projection operators in the sense of (5.51). That is,
M r i - ^
("0)
are normalized energy projection operators obeying A+ = A+ and A + A_ = 0 for p2 = m2. The additional identity A + + A_ = 1, or equivalently from (5.69), X («U)(p)tiU)(p) - «W,(P)»W,(P)) = 2w (5.71) x is the Dirac analog of the two-component completeness relation (5.67). The usefulness of the energy projection operators (5.69) is that, for an S-matrix specified by positive- or negative-energy free-particle bilinear co-
78
Spin-^ Dirac Equation
variants, the general unpolarized-spin sum (5.52) becomes in particular X |u U) (p')Mu a) (p)| 2 = Tr M(p + m)M(p' + m),
(5.71a)
A',A
£
|DU)(p')Mi;U)(p)|2 = Tr M(p - m)M(p' - m),
(5.71b)
x'.x
and similarly for uMv and vMu. It is also possible to construct a covariant spin projection operator. In the rest frame of the spin4 particle, such a spin projection operator is j(l + a • s), where s is the direction of spin polarization (s -» p corresponds to a helicity projection operator). Defining sM = (0, s) and m^ = (m, 0) in the rest frame, so that m • s = 0, it is clear that in a boosted frame p • s = 0. Then, replacing a by — iysyy0 and dropping the noncovariant factor y0 (since py0 does not change sign when applied to either u or i;), we obtain the covariant spin projection operator E(s) = i(l + iy 5 /). 2
(5.72)
2
The invariant length s = — 1 means that £ (s) = Z(s), characteristic of any projection operator. We may then compute positive- or negative-energy polarized spin sums using the Dirac trace algebra by simply replacing, say, p ± m in (5.71) with Z(s)(p ± m) (or (p ± m)L(s), since [y5 £ p] = 0) for a particle whose spin is not unobserved, but pointing in the "direction" s. Specific helicity states can then be generated using s^ = + (p, Ep)/m in (5.72), whereas spin representations other than helicity follow from a different choice for sM. Finally, a third set of Dirac projection operators P±=i(l±iy5)
(5.73)
will prove useful for our later work. They too obey P\ = P±, P+ P_ = 0, and P+ + P_ = 1. One immediate application of (5.73) stems from P + 7n = y^P-> which means that for free particle bispinors \jj = m'1^^ we have P± ip = m~ iii/)P+ i//, so that ij, = P+il/ + P_il/ = m~l(i$ + m)P+il/.
(5.74)
Thus for (j) = P+ i//, ( $ - w)i//= - m _ 1 ( n + m2)
(5.75)
which says that, given > obeying the less restrictive Klein-Gordon equation (for bispinor wave functions), one may obtain \p via (5.74) which satisfies the more restrictive Dirac equation provided (j> = P+ if/. This is reminiscent of our second derivation of the Dirac equation built up from two-component spinors related by the differential operator in (5.16), here equivalent to (5.74) in the Weyl representation. In the above approach, the Dirac-Pauli representation reduces (5.75) to two identical two-component spinor equations. This is true even in the presence of electromagnetic fields, and we shall take advantage of this fact shortly.
Free-Particle Solutions of the Dirac Equation 79 Free-Particle Probability Current. We have noted in (5.6), (5.7), and (5.47) that the bilinear covariant i?y„i/' is the natural choice to represent a conserved probability current density. Consider the current density constructed from the free-particle positive-energy wave packet similar in structure to the Klein-Gordon form (4.13a), normalized in a box: «A + W = J 2 ^ 4 « P « ( P K ' P J C
(5-76)
(where we have deleted the helicity summation for clarity), giving j ; ( x ) = * + (x)y> + (x) = U l l \ w
< ° P < P U + |P>e*"' (5.77)
with q = p' — p. The off-diagonal momentum-space current is then
(5.78)
In this language, current conservation d • j(x) = 0 is equivalent to
m)uu = 0, (5.79)
by the free-particle Dirac equations (5.58a). An analogous negative-energy packet with E = >/p 2 + m2 > 0, +-(*) = j^b*v(VW*,
(5.80)
leads to a
(5.81)
Sandwiching this identity (5.81) between free-particle positive-energy bispinors, we note that p' operating to the left and f> to the right both become m in (5.81), again by the free-particle Dirac equations (5.58a). Rearranging this result, we obtain a form of the Gordon reduction, U(P% u(p) = «(P') (~+ifff)
«(P)>
(5-82)
where the P^ and a^ qv terms in (5.82) are called the convection and spin currents, respectively. Clearly, relations similar to (5.82) can be generated by sandwiching (5.81) between v and v, or u and v, or v and u.
80 Spin4 Dirac Equation As a by-product of (5.82), the diagonal matrix element can be obtained with q = 0 and P = p:
"(PK «(p) = (P„H"(PMP) = 2p„.
(5.83a)
This result is "obvious" from covariance considerations alone, because the left-hand side of (5.83a) must be a simple four-vector and the only candidate depending upon p is p^, with a normalization factor following from the contraction with p^, using p2 = m2 and the Dirac equations (5.58). In a similar manner we deduce that «(P))V«>(P) = (-Pjrn)v(p)v(p) = 2p„.
(5.83b)
We may now calculate the expectation value of the Dirac velocity operator a. Noting that the spatial integral of (5.77) generates # 3 (p' — p), which in turn picks out the diagonal matrix elements of j * , we use (5.83a) to write [a similar relation holds for the Klein-Gordon current (4.62)] \d>xj;(x,t) = \^\ap\2pJE,
(5.84)
with an analogous relation for j ~ , where ap is replaced by bp. For /j = 0we see that p0/E = 1 in (5.84) as well as for the jo integral. Since these jo integrals are j d3x \j/\{x)^i±(x), the latter integrals normalized to unity as the total probability, we learn that V) 2£ K
l
~2E | b p l ~L
'V)
(5 85)
-
Next we evaluate d3x j ± (x, t) = j d3x \j/i(x)aal/±(x) = ± ,
(5.86)
and from (5.84) conclude that <«>± = ^
+
=
(5-87)
where the latter two averages in (5.87) are weighted over the momentumspace probabilities (5.85). The important result (5.87) simply states that the positive- or negative-energy wave-packet expectation value of the current is just the relativistic group velocity vg, a conclusion paralleling the nonrelativistic situation (1.6), and expected in this case because in the Heisenberg picture, ^
= i[H, rj] = iak[pk, rj] = a,,
(5.88)
Zitterbewegung. It turns out, however, that both positive- and negativeenergy states must be included in the construction of the eigenfunctions of a.
Dirac Equation in an External Field 81
Consider then the general packet (again suppressing the helicity summation)
* ( x ) = I 2^K* k»(PK"" x + b*vW<\,
(5-89)
and computing as before leads to <«> = ( | ) + j ^
[a*b%u(P>tv(-v)e2iE'
+ apb_pD(-pMP)^2'£']-
(5.90) As was the case with the Klein-Gordon equation, the cross terms between the positive- and negative-energy states oscillate violently in time. Unlike the Klein-Gordon situation, however, the free-particle amplitudes multiplying the oscillating phases in (5.90) need not vanish as p -> 0. To see this, use a = iy5 a and the forms (5.66) to obtain the nonrelativistic reductions (Problem 5.7) i i ( p M - p ) -* 2m
5.D Dirac Equation in an External Field Covariant Electromagnetic Interactions. Following the procedure used in the Klein-Gordon analysis of a particle in the presence of an electromagnetic field, we consider for spin-^ particles the minimal replacement of id^ by id^ — eA^ in the Dirac equation (5.37), giving (# -eA-
m)i//(x) = 0, or (# - m)tfr(x) = eA\p(x).
(5.92)
We will assume that this minimal coupling eA represents the fundamental interaction between the spin4 particles and photons. As in Dirac's original approach, the bispinor equation (5.92) obeys a Klein-Gordon constraint, obtained by multiplying (5.92) on the left by the operator i$ — eA + m: [(id - eA)2 -m2-
e\a^vF^(x)
= 0,
(5.93)
where we have used the anticommutation relations of the y-matrices to write Ui> + m
= i[y„, y,]F"V + d • (Aij,).
We see from (5.93) that the Dirac wave function also obeys the KleinGordon equation in the presence of an external field (4.24a) apart from the spin-dependent factor i^vF^ = ia-E-
82 Spin4 Dirac Equation which couples E and B respectively to the electric and magnetic dipole moments of the spin4 particle. In particular, an energy eigenstate of ^(x) in (5.93) obeys, for E2 — m2 = 2mENR + • • •, (5.95)
£ N R " A = - ^ - B < A + ---,
showing once again that \i = ea/2m and g = 2 are natural consequences of the Dirac equation. It is also interesting to investigate the Dirac probability current, j^x), in the presence of an external field. In spite of the absence of a derivative term in ij/y i/f, one may consider the Gordon decomposition in coordinate space analogous to (5.82) and then make a minimal replacement to find (see Problem 5.8) h(x) = ^
^(x)a>(x) - ~ MxWWAAx)
+~
fl1f(XKi(4 (5.96)
It is clear that the first two terms in (5.96) have the same form as the nonrelativistic and Klein-Gordon current density (4.26), covariantly normalized in the latter case. The first and third terms in (5.96) correspond to the Gordon decomposition for A^ = 0. As in the spinless case (4.27), current conservation d • j(x) = 0 is an obvious consequence of (5.96). Dirac Form Factors. Following now the discussion in Section 4.C, the probability current density j„(x), whether due to nonrelativistic, Klein-Gordon, or Dirac particles, plays a dual role because ejj^x) represents a chargedmatter current density which is a source for the electromagnetic field, \3A^ = ejp (in the Lorentz gauge). Thus the spin-j analog of the momentumspace current (4.63b) in the presence of an electromagnetic field for positiveenergy scattered particles, obtained from (5.96), is e<9'\tf \p> = eufa')
2m
«(P).
(5-97)
This is the most general form consistent with Lorentz covariance and the Dirac equation. The four-momentum transferred from the photon to the spin-j particles is q = p' — p, and the dimensionless invariant form factors Flt2(q2) parallel F(q2) in (4.63b) for spinless particles. For free photons, q2 = 0 and we must have F t (0) = 1 in order that the coefficient of uy^u in (5.97) may be simply the charge e, consistent with the free-particle probability current density (5.78). Thus F^q2) is called the charge form factor. For q2 ± 0, the photon is not free, and the second term of (5.96) contributes to both Fx(q2) and F2(q2) of (5.97) in a complicated dynamical manner. We shall return to the q2 dependence of these form factors in later chapters. Concerning the magnetic form factor F2(q2) in (5.97), since the y^ current already consists of a convection and magnetic moment part as given by
Dirac Equation in an External Field 83 (5.82), with g = 2 in the latter case, the additional magnetic-moment term in (5.97) described by F2(q2) represents an anomalous correction to g = 2. That is, at q2 = 0, F2(0) = ic = i(flr - 2)
(5.98)
is the dimension less, anomalous magnetic moment of a spin4 particle. For the electron (e < 0),
or Ke ~ 0.001, due totally to electromagnetic interactions. For the proton (e > 0), ^ =^ ( 1 + ^(2.79)^,
(5.99b)
or KP ~ 1.79, primarily due to strong interactions—as is the anomalous magnetic moment of the chargeless neutron, /i„ = ^ - ( 0 + « „ ) * ( - 1 . 9 1 ) - ^ - , (5.99c) 2m„ 2m„ or K„ ~ — 1.91. In Chapter 15 we shall show that the minimal (QED) coupling in (5.92) ultimately generates Ke = cc/2n + 0(cc2), in perfect agreement with experiment. It will also turn out that we can estimate KP and K„ better than we have a right to expect. Lastly, the form factors Fl2{q2) a r e not a unique description of the dynamics of spin-| particles interacting with an external electromagnetic field. Two different but equivalent descriptions in terms of the Sachs form factors GE(q2) and GM(q2) are worked out in Problem 5.8. Constants of the Motion. For a free-particle hamiltonian a • p + fim, the fundamental commutation relations (5.4) lead to [H, r x p] = — ia x p,
[H, oj = 2ia x p,
(5.100)
and it is therefore clear that the total angular momentum J = r x p + \a and helicity ^a • p are conserved operators. In a central, spherically symmetric field V = V(r) = eA0 with A = 0, the Dirac hamiltonian becomes H = a - p + j?m+ V(r),
(5.101)
and while commutation relations similar to (5.100) become more cumbersome to apply (see, e.g., Sakurai 1967), group-theory arguments alone tell us that the total-angular-momentum operator must remain conserved. To simplify the search for constants of the motion and their eigenvalues for spin-^ particles, it will prove convenient to reduce the four-component Dirac analysis back to two-component form. We consider then the less restrictive second-order equation (5.93) satisfied by a Dirac bispinor i/r for
84
Spin-j Dirac Equation
positive-energy stationary states with n = p — eA and eE = — V V, B = 0, (t + m){i - m)il/ = [(£ - V)2 + V2 - m2 + id • VFty = 0. (5.102) Multiplying (5.102) on the left by the projection operators P± = i(l ± iy5) of (5.73), we see that the four-component wave function <> / = P+ ip satisfies (5.102), and the more restrictive Dirac wave function, obeying H\p = E\\i, is then recovered from (p by i/> = m~ x{t + m)4> = m~ l[y0(E - V) - y • p + m]>,
(5.103)
a situation similar to the free particle case (5.74). Next we work in the Dirac-Pauli representation with P+ = ^(} \), giving
(5.104)
Then the four-component equation (5.102) reduces to two identical twocomponent equations [for V = V(r)], (£ _
V{r))2
_
2
m2 +
1 3 2r - -j+ia L 2 . • ^dV f
r or
r
dr
(5.105)
equivalent to the Klein-Gordon form (4.29) except for the last spindependent term. If all we are interested in is the quantized energy levels, then we need only deal with (5.105), converting it to the form of the Schrodinger equation as in the Klein-Gordon case. We need not bother with recovering 4i from
(5.106)
This suggests that we define the two-component spin operator - A = (l + « - L ) + (Zo)w f,
(5.107)
A 2 = (1 + a • L) 2 - (Za)2,
(5.108)
which has the square
the cross terms in (5.108) dropping out because of the identity (see Problem 5.9) {(1 + a • L), o f} = 0.
(5.109)
Combining (5.106)-(5.108), we see that the coefficient of — r~2 in (5.105) has the simple form of an angular-momentum operator L 2 - (Za)ia • f - (Za)2 = A2 + A = A(A + 1).
(5.110)
Dirac Equation in an External Field 85 Next we obtain the eigenvalues of A2 and A by squaring J = L + ja, to write for states j = I ± \ =j± (<,-L)j± = (J2-V-i)j±
= {_{ll+{)\
(5.111a)
(l + c r - L ^ j ' + ^ t O + i), where the upper (lower) cases in (5.111) correspond toj=l Then we have
(5.111b) + \(j = l — j).
(A2)J± = () + i ) 2 - ( Z a ) 2 , (A)J± = + [ 0 + i ) 2 - (Za)2]* - +A,
(5.112a) (5.112b)
where the signs in (5.112b) are determined by (5.107) and (5.111b) with - A intrinsically positive for ;' = / + \ and Za -> 0. Following the Klein-Gordon analysis, we may now express the radial equation for the Dirac atom in the form of (4.30a), 1 d2 r dr
/'(/' + 1) r
2EZa q>(r) = -(E2 - m2)cp{r), r
(5.113)
with (5.110) and (5.112) giving, for) = / ± i l'±(l'± + 1) = [A(A + l)]J± = A(A + 1).
(5.114)
Solving (5.114) for the effective orbital-angular-momentum eigenvalue, we see that
r*-f-l\
(5.U5)
As before, we have chosen the nonnegative solutions of /' in (5.114) as Za -»0, for otherwise the radial solution r' will not be regular at the origin. The orbital constants of the motion now being understood for the Dirac atom, we proceed as in the Klein-Gordon atom to find the energy eigenvalues. Since the radial equations are identical in the two cases except for different values of /', we may conclude that the energy levels of the Dirac atom also are of the form (4.32b), (Za)2 E=m 1 + 2 n'
(5.116)
with ri — I' = n— I constrained to the integer values 1, 2, ... as before. Substituting /' given by (5.114) then leads to n- = n - l + r ± = n - 0 - + i) + [(/ + W ~ (^ff (5.117) for both j = I ±\. [Note that this two-component analysis eliminates the need for an auxiliary quantum number k, appearing in the four-component analysis. See e.g. Sakurai (1967).] We see that the energy levels of a Dirac
86
Spin-5 Dirac Equation
atom are identical in form to the Klein-Gordon levels, but with / in (4.34b) replaced by) in (5.117). Note too that for s-waves andy = \, the square root in (5.117) becomes imaginary unless Z < 1/a. In the strong-field limit, Z > 1/a ~ 137 and the breakdown of the boundstate Dirac solutions is similar to the Klein-Gordon case with Z > l/2a. Once again, the breakdown has a classical analog for (Za)2 > L2 with multiparticle quantum states modifying the single particle orbit at short distances. These effects are not fully understood, nor have they been detected experimentally. For Za <^ 1, one can expand (5.116) and (5.117) in powers of (Za) to find the fine-structure corrections to the Bohr formula for a single-electron atom ( n = l , 2 , ...), m(Za)2 r | (Za)22 / 1 (5.118) ^ N R — *• — j 7 m
n V+ \
now degenerate for a given value of j . We shall return to a detailed study of the hydrogen energy levels shortly. Finally, an analysis of the Dirac wave functions (proportional to associated Laguerre functions), based upon this two-component approach, depends upon (5.103). [See Auvil and Brown (1977).] Alternatively, the entire (and more complicated) four-component analysis of Hip = Exjj can be carried out in a straightforward manner [see e.g. Bethe and Salpeter (1957)]. For our purposes, the above analysis of the energy levels alone will suffice for our later work. Before leaving this topic, it is worth mentioning that the two-component form of (5.93) also can be used to obtain the constants of the motion for spin4 problems other than the one-electron Coulomb atom. Consider, for example, an electron of momentum p moving through a region of constant magnetic field, B = Be3 and A = \E x r = \B( — ye1 + xe2) with A0 = 0. Applying the projection operator (5.104) in the Dirac-Pauli representation, the four-component equation (5.93) once more decouples into two identical two component equations: [E2 - (p - eA)2 - m2 + eBo3]q> = 0.
(5.119)
Since V • A = 0 and A • p = ^B • L, we may write (5.119) in the form [p2 + p2 + (eB/2)2(x2 + y2)]q> = [E2 - p2 - m2 + eB(L3 + a3)]
(5.121)
Dirac Equation in an External Field 87 corresponding to an angular frequency of a) = y/k/^n=
\eB\/2m.
(5.122)
Since the eigenvalues of such an harmonic oscillator are known to be of the form Eh.a. = (nx + ^,)(o + (ny + \)a> = nw,
(5.123)
where n = nx + ny + 1 = 1, 2, 3, ..., we may identify the right-hand side of (5.120) as 2mEho. This leads to the constant of motion E2 = pj + m2 + n\eB\ - (*3 ± \)eB,
(5.124)
with E2 > pi + m2 implying n > | /3 | + 1. Thus we see that the energy and angular-momentum eigenvalues of a spin4 particle in a magnetic field can be found from (5.93) in a manner similar to those for the Klein-Gordon or Dirac atom. The two-component and four-component bispinor wave functions for this problem are proportional to Hermite polynomials, as might be expected from the structure of (5.120). (See Problem 5.10.) Nonrelativistic Reduction. While the exact energy eigenvalues for a relativistic spin4 particle in an external field can always be obtained as in the last section, it is nonetheless of interest to expand the Dirac equation (5.92) in powers of ENK/m, where £NR = E — m. Starting with the Dirac hamiltonian (V = eA0, n = p - eA) H = an + pm+V,
(5.125)
we may express Hi]/ = Exjt in the Dirac- Pauli representation as E
- m - V - " ' * ) ( * ) = <>. - a n E+ m-V)\x) This results in two coupled two-component spinor equations (E — m — V)q> = a • nx,
(5.126)
(E + m — V)% = a • nq>. l
(5.127)
l
For weak potentials V
(5.128a)
Assuming (£NR — V)/2m <^ 1, we expand 1 +
^NLHZr1*i_fcL^. 2m } 2m
(5.129) '
K
88 Spin~j Dirac Equation
The leading term in (5.129) then converts (5.128b) to
where we have used (5.13) to obtain the Pauli magnetic-moment term with g = 2, a result now expected. To next order in the expansion (5.129), we set A = 0 to isolate the correction terms due to a weak electrostatic potential V:
Hi
™ = hr+V
4m2H' = -
+H
(5131a)
''
P(£NR - V)a p
= - (£NR - V)p2 + io • (pK) x p + (pK) • p, (5.131b) 2
where a^ = <50- + ieijk<jk and pt Vpt = Vp + (p; V)p{ have been used to obtain (5.131b). The first term in (5.131b) represents a relativistic momentum correction, since to leading order £NR — V ~ p2/2m means that H^-iEn-V)^*-^.
(5.132)
This potential then corresponds to the usual kinetic-energy correction
The second term in (5.131b) can be written for a spherically symmetric potential V = V(r) as w " (fV) >< P = ( ^ ) ° • (* >< P) = ( l ^ y
• L-
(5134)
Consequently this term generates the familiar spin-o.bit interaction in (5.131),
Note that this relativistic derivation of H'so includes the troublesome factor of \ referred to as the Thomas precession, a factor which must be introduced in a subtle manner in the usual nonrelativistic derivation of (5.135) when transforming from the rest frame of the electron to the laboratory i.e. rest frame of the nucleus (Problem 5.9). Finally, we interpret the third term in (5.131b), but first note that (pK) • p = — (VK) • V is not an hermitian operator. To convert it tohermitian form, we sandwich this term between a spatial integral over wave functions q>* and q> in a symmetric fashion and then integrate by parts.
Dirac Equation in an External Field 89
Discarding the resulting surface term, we are led to the real integrand (pj/) . p _^ -i[jp*(VK) • V
(5.137)
While this hamiltonian does not have an obvious analog in the usual nonrelativistic formulation, it can be understood as a consequence of the relativistic effect of Zitterbewegung. To see this, account for the electron jittery motion to order of the Compton wavelength, Sr < m~\ by the expansion Hzitt. = V(r + Sr) - V(r) = \ br{ 5r} ^
+ • • • * i(<5r)2V2F, (5.138)
where symmetry dictates that the first-order term in (5.138) vanishes and the second-order derivatives are ^V2. Comparing (5.138) with (5.137), we see that (m 5r ~ 1) HLr. *!(»t &r)-2Hziu. ~ Hzitl..
(5.139)
Fine-Structure Energy Levels of Hydrogen. To cap the discussion on bound states, we return to the Coulomb energy levels (5.118) for a Dirac atom, now specializing to the hydrogen atom with Z = 1: ma2 "2M2
1+
(5.140)
To understand how (5.140) arises in the context of Schrodinger theory, we write HNR = H0 + H', where H0 is the lowest-order Schrodinger hamiltonian with V = — cc/r, which generates the Bohr energy levels for n = 1, 2, ... (structure): .2
ma n=-^2=-^T2In1 2a0n2
E
(5-141)
The small splittings of (5.141) to 0(<x2) are the fine-structure corrections caused by H' as given by (5.131b), viz., H' = H'nl + H;.0. + H'Dar,
(5.142a)
generating the first-order perturbation-theory shifts A£ft = (nl|H' |nV> = (nl\H'rel.|n/> +
90 Spin-j Dirac Equation where | n/> refers to the usual unperturbed Laguerre eigenfunction solutions To calculate the relativistic momentum-correction shift, note that (5.143a)
S J P V - - ( « + ?)« implies the square ^2
= (nl
(*« + ? ) ' nl\
(5.143b)
where one may easily verify that 1 1
(5.144)
Then combining (5.143) and (5.144) with (5.132) we find 1
4
< n / | # ; e l > / > = - ^ - 3
- ~
1
3
(5.145)
which breaks the /-degeneracy and is in fact the entire fine-structure shift for the Klein-Gordon atom (4.35). The spin-orbit shift is found from (5.111a), (5.135) with dV/dr = a/r2 and 3
<«/|r" 3 |n/> =
3
3
m a.
n /(/ + i ) ( / + l ) '
(5.146)
giving
=
~2
nl
nl
1
ma -4» 3 C/ + i)(/ + ni) (1 - <5/,o)
(5.147)
for j = I ±\, but zero for / = 0. Lastly, V2V = 47ta^3(r), and at the origin
ll»)|
m3a3
nn which converts (5.137) to the Darwin shift
(5.148)
<5|,o>
net (nl\S3(r)\nl} 2m2
= ^ma. dlt0.
(5.149)
While this Darwin shift is nonvanishing only for s-states, the important point is that it is precisely what the spin-orbit shift would be for / = 0 if 1 — <5, o were replaced by 1 in (5.147). In a sense then, the effect of Zitterbewegung on the Dirac atom corresponds to a "continuation in /" of the spinorbit energy shift down to / = 0.
Dirac Equation in an External Field 91 Next, we combine (5.145), (5.147), and (5.149) according to (5.142b) to obtain the total fine-structure energy shift ma. "2^
A£ft
4
mot. =
1
_
1
1 +
l + 2 2(j
_J
+ m + l)
_3_" 4n|
_
/ r i
_3_
~Jn* j + i
4n ' now breaking the) = I ±j degeneracy but preserving the / degeneracy. Note that (5.150) is identical to the relativistic momentum shift but with; replaced by /. Finally, adding (5.150) to £° as given by (5.141), we are led to the relativistic form (5.140)—a necessary but nonetheless satisfying conclusion. The Dirac theory therefore predicts excited states with fine structure splitting for n = 2 and different j of the order \ x 10" 4 eV, or equivalently, v = E/h ~ 104 Mc/sec. Hyperfine Splitting. Aside from fine-structure splitting, one must account for hyperfine shifts due to the interaction of the proton and electron magnetic moments via the dipole magnetic field of the proton (in rationalized units):
V
'
(5.151)
where the proton is assumed localized at the origin. Since iie\ip = — gegpe2/4memp with ge x 2, gp = 2(1 + KP) x 5.6, and since spherically symmetric s-states imply didjr'1 -+jdiJ'S71r~1, (5.151) becomes for s-states H" = ^Lae-ap53(T).
(5.152)
This splits every line of given j for / = 0 and S = \(ae + op) according to ("e • <*P)S=I ~ (««' °„)s=o = 1 - ( - 3 ) = 4.
(5.153)
Then applying (5.148) and (5.153) to the matrix elements of (5.152), the net hyperfine shift for s-states is AJ?h.f._
8„
m
e
m
e«*
/
S 1 s
.x
mp 2n with the singlet spin state shifted down three times as much as the triplet state is shifted up from the fine-structure energy level. For the ground state, (5.154) corresponds to a 6 x 10"6-eV or 1420-Mc/sec shift. In wavelength language this is the 21-cm line for which astrophysicists search in order to detect the existence of neutral hydrogen in the intergalactic medium. The story is not yet complete, however, because it was experimentally verified (Lamb and Retherford 1947) that, contrary to the Dirac theory, the
92 Spin-^ Dirac Equation
El
n=2
-v \
n>/z
2Si/2 2P,/2
2S|/2 , 2 P | / 2
Structure ma2
Fine Structure ma4
Lamb Shift ma5
Figure 5.1 The n = 2 energy-level splittings in hydrogen.
2Si and 2P± energy levels are not degenerate. Rather, the 2Si line is shifted upward relative to the 2Pi state by some 1058 Mc/sec, as pictured in Figure 5.1. While the theory of this "Lamb shift" is now well understood, a detailed explanation must be postponed until Chapter 15. Qualitatively speaking, this shift is caused by the "cloud" of photons and virtual electron-positron pairs which surround the bound electron, modifying its form factors as given in (5.97) and the resulting Coulomb interaction with the proton nucleus. Suffice it to say now that theory and experiment agree exactly to five significant figures, a truly remarkable result rarely equaled in modern science.
5.E Wave Equations for Other Fermi Particles Thus far we have explored the consequences of the Dirac equation for massive, spin4 fermions (e.g., electrons, protons). We now consider wave equations for massless spin-^ fermions (neutrinos) and also massive spin-f fermions (e.g., the A, 33 "resonance"). Massless Spin4 Particles. Recall from the discussion in Section 3.D that the two helicity states for a massive spin-^ particle, k = +-j, become reduced to just one helicity state as m -»• 0. The explicit structure of the two-component spinor boost operator in (3.94) shows that the 1 = \ right-handed massless state (with spin parallel to the momentum) survives for the (0, \) representation, while X = — \ survives for the (j, 0) irreducible representation of the homogeneous Lorentz group. Experiment alone (see Chapter 13) has determined that the massless neutrino is left handed and the antineutrino is right handed. Consequently the two-component (j, 0) free-particle wave function >Lv for a neutrino satisfies a wave equation inferred from the boost in (3.94): {id, + a • p)(pLv(x) = 0,
(5.155a)
whereas the (0, j) right-handed antineutrino wave equation is {id, -
(5.155b)
Wave Equations for Other Fermi Particles 93
While these wave equations were first obtained by Weyl (1929), they were rejected for 28 years because of noninvariance under spatial reflection {cpL -> cpR, q>R -»cpL). We shall return to this subject in Chapter 6. To link (5.155) with helicity eigenstates, note that the plane-wave solution of (5.155a) for positive-energy states, proportional to e~ipx with E= | p | , satisfies <*P
(5.156a)
in accordance with a left-handed neutrino. Likewise, the plane-wave solution of (5.155b) for positive-energy states, proportional to (e~ip '*)* with E = | p | , obeys «" P
(5.156b)
corresponding to a right-handed antineutrino. On the other hand, the planewave solution of (5.156b) for negative-energy neutrino states, also proportional to eip'x with E = | p |, satisfies « - p > , - ( - p ) = ?v-(-p)-
(5.156c)
Comparing (5.156b) and (5.156c), we see that
(5.157)
This is our first concrete example of the Feynman interpretation, identifying a negative-energy particle state with a positive-energy antiparticle state. More examples will be given in Chapter 6. It is possible, and extremely useful, to couch these two-component neutrino equations in four-component Dirac language. One way to proceed is to note that (5.155) corresponds to (5.17) with m = 0 along with the identification cpL-KpLv, (PR-+
Then we define the Weyl-representation bispinors uLv(P)-P-uLv(v)=(q>L^)\
(5.159a)
^(p) = P + M p ) = ( g - i V ° _ ( _ p ) )
(5.159b)
with the positive-energy bispinor uLv(p) describing a left-handed neutrino and the negative-energy bispinor vm(p) describing a right-handed antineutrino, and both having momentum p. As for the four-component dynamical equations that these bispinors satisfy, since P + projects out the lower negative-energy components in the Weyl representation and uLv has no such component, it is obvious that P + » L v = i(l + iy5)uLv = 0,
(5.160a)
94
Spin-i Dirac Equation
and similarly, P-vFf, = $(l-iys)v»,
= 0.
(5.160b)
We may also proceed by starting with the free-particle Dirac equations (5.58) for m = 0, M P ) = M P ) = 0,
(5-161)
then multiplying (5.161) on the left by iy5 y0 and using iy5 y0 y = a, E = | p | we obtain
a • pu(p) = - iy5 v(p).
(5.162)
Next observe that the bispinor helicity eigenstates (5.65) become in this case « ' P"ZJP) = - « £ » »
- 5 ' W P )
= ^V(P)-
(5163)
Combining (5.162) with (5.163), we are once more led to (5.160). Another useful bispinor expression for massless fermions is the probability current density j ^ — ^iy^- Applying (5.159), we may write the momentum-space current for Weyl neutrinos obeying (5.155) as (dropping the factor of \ in P_ by convention)
= tUp'Wi - iysWM
(5-164)
Since yM(l — iy5) = (1 + iys)yll, the latter y-matrix combinations used in (5.164) can also be expressed as uF- = uP+. For an antineutrino current, it turns out that the analog of (5.164) is
(5165)
The projection operator P+ in (5.165) again follows from (5.159), but the reason for reversing the momentum in the spinors in (5.165) must await the discussion of charge conjugation in Chapter 6. Finally, note that even for q2 = (p' — p)2 / 0, we assume that (5.164) and (5.165) do not develop anomalous magnetic-moment contributions or form factors, because neutrinos interact only weakly with matter (Chapter 13). Such weak interaction experiments detect two types of neutrinos, associated with electrons and muons, respectively. Spin-§ Particles. It is also possible, and again useful, to construct a Dirac bispinor wave function for a spin-| free particle. In Section 2.E we built up a spin-f two-component spinor by the Clebsch-Gordan combination (2.62) of a spin-1 polarization vector and a spin4 spinor, with the spin-! combination (1 x \ = | -(- \) removed by the condition (2.63),
(5.166)
Wave Equations for Other Fermi Particles 95 where such spin-| covariant bispinors satisfy a free-particle Dirac equation (Rarita and Schwinger 1941, Auvil and Brehm 1966) (P - m)M„(p) = 0,
(5.167)
with (2.63) replaced by (see Problem 5.11) y"H„(p) = 0.
(5.168)
Given (5.167) and (5.168), u^ automatically obeys the weaker conditions (p2 - m2)uJp) = 0,
(5.169)
/?X(P) = 0-
A polarization or spin sum can then be formed from these spin-| bispinors in analogy with the spin-1 polarization sum (4.46) and the Dirac projection operator (5.69). In the rest frame this projection operator is
^; i =i d > r = * u - ^
(5.170)
because (2.63) requires CT,^ = ^ijOj = 0, a condition obviously satisfied by (5.170), since aiai = 7>. The normalization of (5.170) is chosen so that ^ijSPjk = SPik- Then the boosted version of (5.170) is (see Problem 5.11) (5.171a)
^
+ m)+>(r, +
^_„,)(v,
+
O + my
£;)
(5.171b) (5.171c)
As long as the particles are on mass shell, this scheme can be extended to arbitrarily high spin [see e.g. Fronsdal (1958), Scadron (1968)]. There are, however, alternative formulations of spin-| wave functions. Moreover, for p2 # m2 or for wave equations involving interactions, ambiguities arise and such theories are no longer unique. In the context of lagrangian field theory, interactions involving massive particles with spin-| and higher (and sometimes even spin 1) are "nonrenormalizable" (see Chapter 15). Luckily, nature has been kind enough to see to it that most of the fundamental particles detected so far have low spin. General references on the Dirac equation are: Dirac (1958), Hamilton (1959), Schweber (1961), Bjorken and Drell (1964), Muirhead (1965), Sakurai (1967), Pilkuhn (1967), Bethe and Jackiw (1968), Schiff (1968), Baym (1969), Berestetskn et al. (1971), Jauch and Rohrlich (1976).
CHAPTER 6
Discrete Symmetries
In Chapters 2 and 3 we discussed in detail the space-time continuous symmetries: translations, rotations, and Lorentz velocity transformations. We now consider the discrete (not generated from the identity) transformations of space-time: space reflection P and time reversal T, along with the charge conjugation (particle-antiparticle) transformation C. It turns out that C and P are unitary operations which have conserved hermitian observables as in continuous-symmetry cases. While they have no classical analogs, they do generate physically significant selection rules. On the other hand, T and CPT are antiunitary operations which give rise to neither conserved quantities nor selection rules. Instead the latter transformations lead to reciprocity or phase relations, which do have important physical consequences. These discrete symmetries (and especially CPT) will be needed to build up the proper covariant (Feynman) scattering diagrams in Part III of this book.
6.A Charge-Conjugation Transformation We have seen that in the presence of an electromagnetic field, the KleinGordon and Dirac equations are modified by the minimal replacement factor idp -> id^ — eA^ and the Maxwell equation is then driven by a source current ej^. The factor e = ± | e | represents the charge of the particle in question, but its sign does not appear to be of fundamental significance. In fact, we have become accustomed to assigning negatively charged electrons e~ and positively charged protons p as particles, and positrons e+ and anti96
Charge-Conjugation Transformation
97
protons p as antiparticles, simply because of the observed preponderance of e~ and p in nature. Defining Properties. The charge conjugation operation converts particle to antiparticle. In quantum mechanics it is defined by the transformation laws UclQUc=-Q, Uc I = 1c I >Ac>,
(6.1)
Uc I p, A> = tic I p, A>,
(6.2)
generating the charge conjugate state up to a phase t]c. Since |\j/ \2 = \i//c\2, the operator Uc is unitary with | rjc \2 = 1. Obviously t/ c commutes with x and p, and therefore with the commutator [x, px] = i, implying that Uc is a linear operator in the sense that cucp^ + a2>2 -> «i >? + v-ifti ( see Section l.C). Then if Uc is applied twice to a state, it will reproduce that state. For such a linear operator it is always possible to choose phases so that U2=l,
WCUC=L
(6.3)
That is, the unitary, unimodular operator Uc can always be taken from (6.3) as hermitian, [/£ = Uc. Thus Uc is an observable operator, with eigenvalues which are simultaneously measurable along with energy eigenvalues, provided Uc commutes with H—that is, if H is invariant with respect to C. The catch is that Uc must also commute with the charge operator Q since the latter commutes with H and has measurable eigenvalues. Then the phase rjc in (6.2) can also be an observable eigenvalue, r\c = ±1. But we know from (6.1) that Uc and Q anticommute; only for neutral states, Q = 0, do Uc and Q effectively commute. Thus it is meaningful to define charge-conjugate eigenstates and a "charge parity" r\c = ± 1 for neutral states alone. It turns out, however, that this class of states is further restricted by the existence of other (additive) internal quantum numbers such as strangeness S and baryon number B which transform like Q under Uc as in (6.1). Thus only neutral "self-conjugate" states with Q = B = S = 0 have a well-defined charge parity t]c = + 1 . The choice in these cases between r\c = + 1 and r\c = — 1 is determined by experiment. We now turn to the finite-dimensional representations of Uc which have a complex-conjugation part consistent with minimal electromagnetic coupling with Ap taken as real, as well as a spin-dependent part to be determined. Spin-0 Particles. In the presence of an electromagnetic field, the KleinGordon equations for spinless particles and antiparticles are [(id - eAf - m2j>(x) = 0, 2
2
[(id + eA) - m ]4>c(x) = 0.
(6.4a) (6.4b)
It is clear that (6.4b) can be obtained from (6.4a) with A^ real provided 0cM = 1c
(6.5)
98
Discrete Symmetries
with positive- and negative-energy parts related by 4>c±(x) = fc#*( x ) a s expected. From (6.5) we see that the finite-dimensional spin-0 representation of Uc is just the unit matrix. Given (6.5), a self-conjugate particle with e = 0 and r\c = ± 1 has a vanishing probability current, >*i^ (j>. It is also clear that the spin-zero electromagnetic current density fj" = ej^ changes sign under charge conjugation (Problem 6.1), but the manner in which this relates the positive and negative energy currents in momentum space is worth pursuing for our later work. Consider, therefore, the form of 7™ for free, scattered, positive-energy states (4.63b),
(6.6)
The charge-conjugate current for positive-energy states is then
= eF(q )(-p'-p)fl,
(6.7a) (6.7b)
where (6.7a) has the form of (6.6) but with e replaced by — e for the antiparticle current. The form (6.7b) corresponds to the particle current, but for negative-energy states with p and p' replaced by — p and —p' (traveling backward in space-time). It is this latter interpretation rather than (6.7a) that will prove more useful in subsequent chapters. Spin-1 Particles. Since the charge-conjugation operation changes the sign of the electromagnetic current, the Maxwell equation C\Afl= y'*m requires that if we want A^ to transform simply under C, we must take A real (since the photon has zero charge) with 4(x)=-^(x).
(6.8)
While this choice is an empirical one, it is consistent with the C-invariant dynamical equations (6.4), as Uc converts (6.4a) to (6.4b) using (6.8). Also note that (6.8) is similar to the Klein-Gordon form (6.5), but with the photon intrinsic charge parity uniquely specified as ^c(y) = — 1. Massive spin-1 particles likewise obey a Klein-Gordon-type equation (4.42), and so #(x)=f/c*:(4 (6-9) As is the case for spinless particles, the charge parity of massive spin-1 particles must be determined from experiment. Furthermore it turns out, that the spin-1 electromagnetic current can in principle have an "anomalous" part with charge conjugation rjc = 1 (Lee 1965). Spin-2 Particles. In a similar fashion, we observe that the Dirac equations for spin-^ particles and antiparticles of the same mass in an external field are [# -eA-
m]il/(x) = 0,
[# + eA - m]\l/c(x) = 0.
(6.10a) (6.10b)
Charge-Conjugation Transformation
99
Since \j/ is the Dirac analog of an adjoint, ij/T (T means transpose) corresponds to the complex-conjugate operation (actually ij/T = y0 \j/*) which is necessary to transform ijt to i//c. Taking the "barred transpose" of (6.10a) and using ABT = ATBT and y^ = y^, we see that [-{id + eA)-yT-m]iJtT(x)
= 0.
(6.11)
It is therefore natural to search for a Dirac matrix C such that CylC-'
= -y„
(6.12)
for then, operating on (6.11) to the left by C gives [(id + eA) • y - m]C\]/T = 0,
(6.13)
which is identical to the charge-conjugate Dirac equation (6.10b) provided
M*) = fcC-FM-
(6-14)
Comparing (6.14) with (6.5), we observe that Cy0 is the Dirac [(^, 0) + (0, ^)] representation of the operator Uc. To determine further the structure of the matrix C beyond the defining property (6.12), we note that since Uc is unitary in Hilbert space, C must be unitary in the Dirac space: CC< = 1. Moreover, (6.14) can have i//c and ifr interchanged, since t// is no more fundamental than \\ic according to (6.2); so # c ) = ijcC#?(x).
(6.15)
Comparing (6.15) with (6.14), we find C" x = CT = y0C*y0. Next, evaluate (6.12) for pL = 0 and use the (representation-dependent) relation yj = To which leads to C = — y0Cy0. Combining these last three constraints gives C=-CT,
C = - C _ 1 = -Ct.
(6.16)
It is sometimes convenient to obtain a specific (but not unique) representation for C, which we choose to be real while obeying (6.16): C = iy5io2 = -iy2y0-
(6-17)
Paralleling the discussion for Klein-Gordon particles, we now write positive-energy antiparticle bispinors in terms of negative-energy particle bispinors as
(6.18)
for a free antiparticle of momentum p. The conjugate bispinor satisfies, for A, = 0, V - m)uc(p) = (p - m)u(p) = 0, (6.19) so that we may choose «c(P) = «(P)(6-20) p x Then combining (6.20) with (6.18), (6.16), and \j/_ -> ve' , we conclude that t;(p) = Cur(p),
u(V) = CvT(p).
(6.21)
100
Discrete Symmetries
As a specific check of (6.17) and (6.21), we evaluate the latter in the DiracPauli representation using (5.64):
=
(6-22)
7rriH
Note then the property of two-component spinors for k = ±\, ia2(p*a)(p) = e ¥ i V U ) ( - P ) ,
(6.23)
obtained from (3.91) with p = p9i^, — p = p„_flin+^ (also see Problem 3.7). Applying (6.23) to (6.22), we recover v = CuT from (5.64b). Finally we find the Dirac analog of the off-diagonal momentum-space current (6.7), with
2
(6.24a)
2
p) = FM )y, + F2(q )™^l2m,
(6.24b)
where we have used (5.97). The charge-conjugate positive-energy current is then
r
(6.25a)
= ^(p')C- r M (p',p)Ct) (p)
(6.25b)
= e(-v(p))r„(p',p)v(v'),
(6.25c)
where (6.25b) is a consequence of (6.21) and (6.25a). Because the transpose of a number is a number, (6.25c) follows from (6.25b) and the defining property of C, (6.12). Note that while (6.25a) is similar to (6.7a), (6.25c) is similar to (6.7b), the latter two both becoming — elp^ for p' — p. The fact that the momentum dependence of the negative-energy spinors in (6.25c) is reversed is characteristic of "backward propagation in space-time." Since uc = u, we learn from (6.25a) that^ m c = -;^ m , while (6.25c) indicates that^ m c + =^ m _ (see Problem 6.1). Note too that of the 16 fundamental ^-matrices, only y^ and a^ change sign under C: C M 1 ' V ffM»' ty.Vs. 7s)C = (1, -y„, -a„v, iy^y5, y5)T.
(6.26)
A subtle but important point is that the minus sign in \j/c = —r]*\j/C~l is associated with the sign of ( — v) in (6.25c) or the antineutrino current (5.165), not to be included in (6.26). For hamiltonian densities this sign is linked with the connection between spin and statistics; in field-theory language it occurs because of the antisymmetric nature of fermion fields. Representations for Higher Spin. The action of Uc on a single-particle helicity state of higher spin continues to follow (6.2), but the identification of charge-conjugate positive-energy states of spin ;' with negative-energy particle states still necessitates complex conjugation coupled with momentum
Charge-Conjugation Transformation 101 inversion. A further complication is that charge conjugation converts an irreducible representation (A, B) of J2? to (B, A). In particular, by analogy with the second derivation of the Dirac equation in Section 5.A, given states
(6.27)
A particular representation of C 0) is (see Problem 2.4) Ci?m = <Jm'\e-*J*\jm> = ( - T ^ - m ,
(6-28a)
which possessses the general properties C 0)t C 0) = lf
cU)*CU) = (-) 2 j '.
(6.28b)
This matrix transforms spin matrices according to a unitary rotation by n in (2.28), accompanied by complex conjugation, C U)-ijU) C 0) =
_jO')*
=
_jO)T
(629a)
It also complex-conjugates rotation matrices as well as inverting the momentum of (j, 0) boosts [following directly from (3.43)]: c u>- ' / ) 0 ) ( K ) C C 0)-
U)
= Dij)*(R),
(6.29b)
(J)
W
(6.29c)
iZ)«^(L_p)C = D *(L„),
thus justifying (6.27). Of particular interest is the construction of the Dirac C using the Weyl representation for the y matrices, with (6.12) paralleling (6.29a) (see Problem 6.1). Denning ip = (££) in this representation, we recover f/*i^c = Cij/T = Cf}\jj* with C constructed in the usual manner [exp( — ina2/2) = —ia2 = C (i) = — C(i)],
C
-(T;HT:J-^-
<-»
This is perhaps a more revealing construction of C than in the Dirac-Pauli representation (6.21)-(6.23). For more details on high-spin representations, see Weinberg (1964a). Charge-Conjugation Invariance. Applying the unitary operator Uc to the Klein-Gordon, Dirac, and Maxwell equations converts A^ to — A^ and the charged current densities (constructed from matter wave functions) f™ to —fj". Aside then from noninteracting parts of the hamiltonian density, there are interacting terms such asf^A* which remain invariant under the chargeconjugation operation. Converting such dynamical relations as the Dirac equation in an external field (6.10a) into Schrodinger-equation language, application of Uc results in Uc(id, - H)| = (id, - UCHU-Cl)\,c> = 0.
(6.31a)
102
Discrete Symmetries
Then invariance under C means that UcHUc
l
= H, or [Uc, H] = 0.
(6.31b)
For many interactions of interest, however, the form of the hamiltonian is unknown. It is therefore of interest to formulate invariance laws in terms of the general S-matrix operator [recall from (1.66) and (1.67) the relation between H7 and S,]. Charge-conjugation invariance then corresponds to [Uc, S] = 0, or S = U^CSUC
(6.32)
with matrix elements whose absolute squares are measurable, |S|»> = »J?/»ta
(6.33)
where | Ci} is the charge conjugate of the state | i>. To be more specific, for i and/corresponding to spin4 plus spin-1 (positive-energy) free particles, the S-matrix elements can be expressed in terms of M-functions as (see Section 3.D) | S | i> = s^kJu^Mjf, iMp^),
Ci)v(pfy(kf),
(6.34a) (6.34b)
and we again note the reversed order of the negative-energy wave functions and the minus sign associated with v in (6.34b). Then C-invariance leads to the relation between M-functions, Ci C Mjf> 0 = IcCMlM ) ~ '> (6-35) where rjc = r\*{ r\ci is the total charge-conjugation phase for the process. We see that (6.34) and (6.35) are a generalization of the transformation law for currents (see Problem 6.2). The obvious test for C-invariance would be to check the equivalence between particle and antiparticle cross sections and lifetimes. This is not always easy, however, because of the difficulty in preparing antiparticle targets in our particle-dominated world. Nevertheless certain tests do exist which lead us to believe that strong and electromagnetic interactions are invariant under C (but weak interactions break C-invariance). It is therefore useful to assign C-parities to neutral particles. Under C, not only the charge Q but also the baryon number B and strangeness S change sign; therefore eigenstates of C are not all neutral particles, but only those "self-conjugate" mesons with Q = B = S = 0: n°, rf, p°, a>°, (p°, etc. Given rjc(y) = - 1 , a multiplicative quantum number, the existence of the spin-0 electromagnetic decays n° -»• 2y and rf° -* 2y requires that r]c(n°) = r]c(t]°) = rjc(y) = +1. This in turn leads to the selection rules n° -f* 3y, rf -/> 7t°7r°y—decays as yet undetected. In a similar way the existence of the decays p° -» n°y, a>° -* n°y, and ($)0-+rfy requires r\c(p°) = t]c(a)°) = t]c((f>0) = — 1 for these spin-1 mesons. Particle-antiparticle (aa) configurations are also self-conjugate, possessing the C-parity (see Problem 6.2)
t]c(ad)={~r\
(6.36)
Space-Reflection Transformation
103
where / is the relative orbital angular momentum and S is the total spin of the ad system (to be derived in Section 6.B). A list of the common elementary particles, along with their masses, spins, and quantum numbers, is given in Appendix III.
6.B Space-Reflection Transformations Defining Properties. A spatial reflection of the coordinates of a system means x -* x' = — x and t-*t' = t. Such a reflection can be interpreted as an improper rotation Rn converting xfl<#) to x „ _ M + ^ but with det Rn = — 1; alternatively it can be thought of as an improper Lorentz transformation x l = (xo> _ x ) with A£v = #„v and det A„ = — 1. For true 0(3) and ¥ scalars such as p 2 or p2, or polar vectors p or p^, improper rotations or Lorentz transformation have no effect on the transformation laws different from proper transformations with det R = det A = 1. For pseudoscalars p • J or $y5 \jj, or axial vectors L = r x p or ij/y^ y5 \\i, the transformation laws contain an additional sign change corresponding to a factor of det RK or det A„ appearing in these laws [see e.g. (5.46)]. In quantum mechanics the spatial reflection is defined by the action of the unitary operator Up on operators and states [see e.g. Wick (1959)]: VplxllUP = xl = {x0, - x ) , UP\
U~PlJUP = Jn = J,
t/p|pA> = M - r ^ | - p , -A>,
(6.37) (6.38)
where the helicity phase for a particle of spin s follows from (3.77) for p e 0 . Since x and p change sign under a space reflection, the commutator [x, px] = i remains unchanged, and therefore UP is a linear unitary operator, as is Uc. If UP is applied twice to a state, it will reproduce this state; so again, like Uc, the space reflection operator is also unimodular: Uj=l,
UPUP=l.
(6.39)
As a consequence, UP (like Uc) is also hermitian, with eigenvalues which are simultaneously measurable with the energy provided UP commutes with H. This results in the phase t]Pm (6.38) becoming the intrinsic space parity (or simply the parity) of the state. Integer-Spin States. Consider first spin-0 solutions of the free Klein-Gordon equations for a particle in its normal and space-reflected state: (p2 - m2)
(p2 - m 2 )0 P (xJ = 0.
(6.40)
Since p2 is a true Lorentz scalar, these solutions are related by
(6.41)
In a similar fashion, the spin-1 wave function satisfies
(6-42)
104
Discrete Symmetries
where the minus sign associated with tjP in (6.42) denotes the rest-frame behavior of vector particles, and where g{0) = 1, gr(1 2 3) = — 1 (not summed over) distinguish between the time and space components of a four-vector, which transform differently under space reflections according to (6.37). Herein lies a key difference between C and P: applying P twice with (j>{xnn) ~
(6-44)
Note that the overall minus sign in (6.44) is similar to (6.42), while the factor ( — f~x is the same as for the helicity state in (6.38). For (integer) orbital-angular-momentum states,
= f7,i'lT(r).
(6.45a)
But - r ^ = r„_ 9> „ + , and 17(71 - 6, n + $) = (-)lY?(0, <j>) then require the phase in (6.45a) to be m = (-)'• (6.45b) This orbital parity must be included along with intrinsic parities to determine the total parity of a system. Spin-j States. While spinors change sign under a complete rotation R2K, they do not change sign under two successive space reflections. To see this, note that the spin or analog of (6.44), obtained from (3.91) by inspection is, for P = Pe,tf,>
Space-Reflection Transformation 105 these dynamical relations. Put another way, the (j, 0) irreducible representation of if transforms under a space reflection into the (0, ^) irreducible transformation. This is sometimes considered the major reason for combining (j, 0) and (0, j) two-component spinors into a Dirac (\, 0) + (0, %) bispinor \jj in the Weyl representation. Then the action of P is modified by
H::H:KX:K
<->
Alternatively, in the Dirac-Pauli representation with cp ->
(6-49)
for p = p„ 0 , as can be verified from (6.46) and (5.64a). In spite of the simple transformation law (6.48), the presence of the y0 matrix precludes a double reflection from leading to t\\ = 1. Thus rjP is in general complex for spin \ and all other fermions. While rjP is therefore not absolutely measurable for fermions, the relative parity of any two such fermions can be determined, and this is adequate for all physical processes because angular-momentum conservation requires an even number of fermions to interact. Further, baryon (nucleons, hyperons, etc.) and lepton (electrons, muons, neutrinos) number are found to be conserved independently in any reaction (particles — antiparticles = constant). We may therefore define an absolute intrinsic parity for baryons and choose by convention the normality n = t]P( — ) J ~* so that normal spin-./ baryons satisfy n = 1 and Jp = \+, | _ , j + , ... while abnormal baryons have n= — 1 and J
JP — I " — 2
1+ i i
5> 2
>
—
Space-Reflection Invariance. Paralleling the discussion for C-invariance, space-reflection invariance or parity conservation for a system driven by a hamiltonian means that H(\) = H( — x), so that UPHUp 1 = H,
or [Ur, H] = 0.
(6.50)
Alternatively, in terms of an S-matrix, parity conservation corresponds to [UP, S] = 0, or S = UpSUp,
(6.51a)
with matrix elements whose absolute squares are measurable {t]P = Jj*/f/pj), < / | S | i > = fj,
(6.51b)
For a representative process involving spins \ 4- 1 -* \ + 1, the transformation law under P for the M-function (6.34a) follows from (6.51), and employ-
106
Discrete Symmetries
ing (6.44) and (6.49), we have M„v(/. 0 = WwdMyoM^iPf, Pi)y0
(6.52)
[note that the helicity phases in (6.38), (6.44), and (6.49) cancel in (6.52)], where n is the total normality n = nfnh nf = t1Pf( — )Jf, ni = rjPi(—)Ji. This just means that if the reaction is normal (n = 1), then M must be expanded in terms of "true" scalars, vectors, and tensors. For an abnormal process with n = — 1, M must instead be expanded in terms of "pseudo" scalars, vectors, and tensors, containing an odd number of y5 or e^^ symbols, since for example in the spinor case y0 y5 y0 = — 7sGeneral tests of P-invariance include the absence of pseudoscalar terms like o • p in cross sections and specific relations between various polarization and asymmetry measurements. It now appears that strong and electromagnetic interactions are invariant under P. This in turn leads to selection rules correlated with a parity assignment for every particle—an assignment which must remain unchanged from process to process. It is conventional to choose the proton and neutron as having the same relative intrinsic parity. Then from the experimental fact that the strong interaction n~ capture in n~ + d -» n + n is in the s-state, P-invariance holds provided t]P(n') = — 1. [That is, the initial total angular momentum of the spinless n~ and spin-1 deuteron is J, = 1, since /, = 0. Identical neutrons have spins antiparallel, so Sf = 0 requires Jf = lf = I by angular-momentum conservation. Finally, the intrinsic parity of d, a pn bound state, must be the same as for nn, so that the initial and final relative parities are t]Pi = t]P(n")( — )'' and t\Pf = ( —)(/ = — 1; P-invariance (t]Pi = r\P}) then requires rfP(n~) = — 1.] In a similar fashion, the final-state photons in n° -> 2y are observed to have perpendicular polarization vectors, implying a decay matrix element proportional to the pseudoscalar E' x £ • k in the n° rest frame. Then P invariance requires n° also to be a pseudoscalar, so that (6.50) or (6.51) is valid if rjP(n°) = — 1. For strange particles, the relative ApK+ parity is observed to be negative. It is conventional to choose r]P(K+) — — 1, in agreement with pions, and also take A to have the same relative parity as nucleons. We further choose the spin-*r+ p, n, A particles to have t]P{p, n, A) = 1 and normality n = 1. The remaining intrinsic parities of the other elementary particles are then uniquely determined (see Appendix III). Selection rules for nuclear transitions such as a-particle emission are also a consequence of P-invariance, as are electromagnetic nuclear and atomic transitions with photon emission. In the latter case, electric-multipole radiation of rank J corresponds to r\P = ( — )J, an effective normal (n = 1) spin-J particle. Then for initial and final orbital-angular-momentum states (in nuclei or atoms) lt and lf, P-invariance requires (-)lf+J = ( — )'', or lf + /; + J to be even. For magnetic-multipole radiation, corresponding to abnormal r\P = — (— )J transitions, P-invariance requires lf + /; + J to be odd. The combination of C and P gives further restrictions on spatial and charge parities. In particular, the charge-conjugate (j, 0) + (0, j) wave func-
Space-Reflection Transformation 107 tion has the Dirac form (6.14) with C given by (6.30) in the Weyl representation for spin j with CU) = (— )2jCU). The space-reflected wave function is likewise given by (6.48). Then for particle a and antiparticle a, UP^c = r]p{a)nMPCV, Ucxl>P = r,c(a)^(a)CliV,
(6.53a) (6-53b)
and since (6.53a) and (6.53b) both must give the same result, the identity Cp = ( - )2j'j?C requires that r,P(a)nP(a) = (-)2J=±l
(6-54)
for bosons and fermions, respectively. The charge parity for the aa system (6.36) then follows from (6.54) along with the factors ( —)' for spatial exchange r -> — r under P and + (— ) s for spin exchange s + s -> s -I- s under C, where S is the total spin (see Problem 6.4). It is useful to construct eigenstates of CP. Since r\c(n°) = ~ / 7P( 7C °) — U it is clear that rjCP(n°) = — 1. Extending this to non-self-conjugate kaons, we choose by convention UCP\K°> = - |K°>, U_CP\K°y = - \K°>, and then define CP eigenstates KLS = 2"*(|X°> + |-K°>) for CP-conserving reactions so that ricr(n°) = flcp(KL) = -riCP(Ks) = - 1 .
(6.55)
Violation of C and P. For a long time it was thought that the discrete symmetries C, P, and T were—indeed had to be—invariant for each of the fundamental forces of nature: strong, electromagnetic, and weak interactions. (We shall postpone a discussion of the gravitational force until Chapter 14.) Due to the pioneering work of Lee and Yang (1956), however, it was discovered that P and C are not separately invariant for weak interactions, although the combination CP appears to be an approximate symmetry operation. For example, in the /?-decay of 60 Co (see Wu et al. 1957), the emitted electron has a preferred direction with respect to the spin of the 60 Co nucleus, violating P. In fact,
108
Discrete Symmetries
C. Using (6.36), it can be shown that the charged pion decays Ks — n+n~ etc. follow a similar pattern. Finally, it was discovered in 1964 that a small component of the CP-violating decay KL -* 2n does exist, about 0.1% relative to the weak decay amplitude of Ks -*• 2n. Consequently, even CP is not an exact symmetry in nature.
6.C Time-Reversal Transformation Defining Properties. The operation of time reversal (T) or motion reversal is of fundamental significance, underlying the laws of classical as well as quantum physics, because in the former case Newton's laws are invariant under T. On coordinates, time reversal means t -+ — t and x -» x or xj, = — g(fl) x„, again an improper Lorentz transformation A^ = —g^ with det A' = — 1. Also p -> — p, J -v — J, and j^ -* (j0, — j) under time reversal. The quantum-mechanical time-reversal operator
(6.57b)
<<£/1 >A,> = <>r/1 >Ar;>* = <
(6.57c)
Writing 9~ = UTK, where UT is unitary and K is a complex-conjugation operator (changing i ->• — i), a time-dependent spinless state transforms according to
^•\Ht)> = nTK\H-t)>,
(6-58)
2
where r\T is a time-reversal phase with | r\T | = 1. It is not possible, however, to interpret rjT as a "time parity", because | i^(t)> is not an eigenstate of 9~. Put another way, for 2T1 = el the antilinear property of ST prevents a rescaling of the phase e to unity, and 3~3 = E3~ = 3~s implies only that e* = E is real, so that 5" 2 = ± 1 , ^3- = 1. (6.59) Integer-Spin Particles. To acquire a feeling for how to deal with an antiunitary operator in practice, consider first a plane-wave state for a spinless particle <x |p> oc eipx. Then for r\T = 1, we have 9~ |p> = | — p> and <x|^|p> = <x|-p> = e-'px,
(6.60a)
this expression being equal to <,T t x|p>* = <x|p>* = < r i p ' \
(6.60b)
Time-Reversal Transformation
109
A similar argument applied to partial waves leads to
(6-61)
Looking then at a spinless Klein-Gordon particle in the presence of an electromagnetic field, we compare [(id0 - eA0(x))2 - (N - eA(x))2 - m2]4>(x) = 0, [ ( - id0 - eA0,T(xt))2 - (iV - eAr(xt))2 - m2]<M*,) = 0,
(6.62a) (6.62b)
and applying (6.61) to (6.62b), conclude that <M*«) = 1T4>*(X\ In a similar fashion, spin-1 wave functions transform as
(6-63) (6-64)
0M.r(*«) = >7r0M >*(*)•
With p-> — p and X -»A, the corresponding polarization vectors (3.101) transform according to (for p in the 1-3 plane,
(6-65)
consistent with the general time-reversal transformation of a single-particle helicity state of spin s and p 9 0 , • ^ | M > = >7r(-)2sK|-MX
(6-66)
and the identification UT = exp( — inJ2)- (See Problem 6.5.) Spin-£ Particles. Since the time-reversed Klein-Gordon wave function corresponds to a complex conjugation, also needed in charge conjugation, it is not surprising that the Dirac wave function and its time-reversed partner satisfying [y0(id0 - eA0(x)) - Y • (iV - eA(x)) - m]tfr(x) = 0, (6.67a) bo(-ido - eA0>T(xt)) - y • (iV - eAr(x,)) - » # r ( * ) = 0
(6.67b)
T
are related as in charge conjugation through the form \[i = y0 \j/*. That is, ^T{xt) = nTW{x),
(6.68)
where T is the Dirac matrix obeying T ^ T " 1 = <,,„, V
(6.69)
This behavior is necessary to maintain the correct transformation property of the current,^ = ij/y^i^ -> g^j^, under time reversal. The positive-energy free-particle bispinor (5.64a) then satisfies (see Problem 6.5) ul»{-p)={-)2'TuWT{p)
(6.70)
110 Discrete Symmetries
in accordance with the helicity state (6.66) for p 9 0 . The representationdependent form for T consistent with (6.17) and (6.48) is T= -io2y0
= y2lyxy0.
(6.71)
General Spiny. For angular-momentum states \jm}, the transformation law $~~1J$~ = - J leads to £T\jrriy = rjj(-)~m\j, — m>. Alternatively, from (6.71) we may infer that the (j, 0) if representation of UT is —ia2, and the (j, 0) representation exp( - nrJ^) = CU) by (6.28a). This gives ST2 = ( - ) 2 s for a particle of spin s, corresponding to the additional phase occurring in (6.66) and (6.70). Note that both operations C and T have representations related to exp( — inJ2), while P and T transform coordinates and fourvectors in a similar fashion, employing gw. We will demonstrate shortly that it is the CPT theorem that supplies the vital link between these three inversion operations. Time-Reversal Invariance. For a nonrelativistic spinless particle, 9~ = K, so that under the time-reversal operation the hamiltonian governing the particle's motion transforms as ^H{t)^~l
= H*(-t),
(6.72)
consistent with the transformation law for Schrodinger states (6.58). Further, if H is real and time independent, then the state of the system is invariant under all time translations (including time reversal) and (6.72) becomes [JT, H] = 0.
(6.73)
Because 3~ is antiunitary, no conservation law, such as exists for space reflections, follows from (6.73). Alternatively we may formulate time-reversal invariance in terms of the S-matrix which transforms in the interaction picture S, = U,(co, — oo) according to ZTS,^-1
= U,(-oo, oo) = Si
(6.74)
Since S is unitary and not hermitian, a commutation relation like (6.73) will not be valid. Nevertheless the matrix elements of (6.74) lead to dynamical constraints on "motion reversal". Referring to states i and / as initial and final states of the system and suppressing the interaction-picture index (other pictures give the same result—see Chapter 7), we find
\s |0 = (f \jrwr\ /> = nT
Time-Reversal Transformation
111
While it is difficult to verify T-invariance, at the present time observations are consistent with T-invariance for strong and electromagnetic interactions. A principal tool is the reciprocity relation (6.75) coupled with rotation invariance of the partial-wave expansion (or alternatively P-in variance), which converts the time-reversed momenta p' = — p back to p. The effect of the helicities is removed by summing the absolute square of (6.75) over all spin states. Since the latter quantity is proportional to the product of the initial spin multiplicities 2s + 1 times the initial flux [proportional to the square of the CM three-momentum] times the unpolarized differential cross section (we shall see many examples of this in Chapter 7 and thereafter), we are led to the "detailed balance" relation for two-body reactions,
For example, cross-section measurements of the strong-interaction process p + p->n+ + d and its time-reversed partner 7t+ + d-> p + p are consistent with (6.76). Originally the T-invariance of (6.76) was used to infer the spin of the pion, Sn+ = 0. An interesting application of T-invariance is Kramers's theorem, stating that the stationary states of a T-invariant system containing an odd number of fermions are pairwise degenerate. This follows because the Schrodinger states | if/} and | i^r> = ST 11//} are then simultaneously measurable with the same energy. For each fermion 2T1 = ( —)2s = — 1, a multiplicative result that remains unchanged for an odd number of fermions, so that
(6.77) Such orthogonal states cannot be proportional; they are therefore independent but degenerate. Kramers's theorem is used extensively in atomic and nuclear physics. In solid-state physics time-reversal invariance leads to inversion symmetry of energy bands associated with periodic-potential problems; i.e., £,(k) = £,( —k). Finally, in astrophysics and cosmology, time-reversal invariance plays a central role in the equilibrium dynamics of Saha's equation. This ultimately explains why primordial nucleosynthesis occurs at T ~ 8 x 108 °K rather than at the deuteron binding energy of kT ~ 2.2 MeV, T ~ 1010 °K. It also justifies the recombination of primordial hydrogen at a much lower temperature than the ionization energy kT ~ 13.6 eV. As for T-violation, one way to observe it is to detect an electric-dipole moment of an elementary particle or bound system, because T- and also P-invariance require that such a dipole moment must vanish (see Problem 6.5). Since P is known to be violated at the level of weak interactions, a nonvanishing electric dipole moment at this level then could indicate T-
112
Discrete Symmetries
violation. To date the neutron electric dipole moment vanishes to a high degree of measured accuracy, of order 10" 2A e-cm. As with CP violation, the K°-K° system is also a place to observe T-violation. A recent experiment in fact detects a T-violating amplitude of order 10" 3 relative to the weak interaction [see Kleinknecht (1976)].
6.D CPT Invariance The weakest discrete symmetry is the product CPT, which turns incoming particles into outgoing antiparticles while flipping helicities. From a theoretical standpoint, this is a "natural" symmetry because it does not appear possible to construct a "reasonable" interaction which violates CPT. It is therefore worthwhile to give special attention to this operation, first discussing the CPT theorem and then its direct consequences. CPT Theorem. In the presence of an electromagnetic field, the spinless and spin-1 Klein-Gordon and spin4 Dirac equations are left invariant under the antiunitary operation sd = CP2T. This is a direct observation from Sections 6.A-C with ^ ( x ) - > -?™{-x) and A*A-x)=
-(gw)(gw)Afl(x)=
-A^x),
(6.78a)
4>A~X) = VCPT4>{X\
(6.78b)
4>n.A -x)=- r\CPT >„(*),
(6.78c)
whereas for the Dirac particles CPT = iy5 ia2 7o{ — ^i)yo = ! 7s' s o that ^A-^^Vcpriys^x).
(6.78d)
For a general hamiltonian H(t), the CPT transformation requires stf-1H(t)*/
= H*P(-t).
(6.79)
To link HCP with HT, consider relativistically covariant hamiltonian densities Jf(x) such that H{t) = J d3x Jf(x). Then JfPT(x) -> Jf*(-x), whereas the charge-conjugate j f c (x) is built up, as in the case of external electromagnetic fields, in terms of scalar products such as f™c(x)A£(x). The complexconjugation operation due to T in (6.79) is canceled by the complex conjugation inherent in the charge-conjugate wave functions, as in (6.78), with the additional constraint that no extra factors of i occur in H; i.e., the density J^(x) is real and the operator H is hermitian. As for the spindependent part of the CPT operation, from (6.78) we see that boson wave functions are even for even-rank tensors (spin 0,2, ...) but odd for odd-rank tensors (spin 1, 3,...), as are the derivatives d-d, d^, d^dv, etc. since dp-* —3^ under CPT. Further, the spinor bilinear covariants transform in the same fashion, with the inverse of the CPT operator (ry5)~l = iy5 leading to (see Problem 6.6)
iysih y„, v 'VMTS. yshs = (l, -y„, *„„ -»%y 5 .ys\
(6.80)
CPT Invariance 113 so that again even-rank tensors are even and odd-rank tensors are odd under CPT. Note that a sign has been removed from ij/^ = — ij/iys, as was the case for the operation C in (6.25) and (6.26). [Strictly speaking, this version of the CPT theorem should be proven in a field-theory context to manifest the connection between spin and statistics and also to employ lagrangian densities J£?(X) instead of J^(x), because there can be a problem with Lorentz invariance in the latter case.] Thus for a Lorentz-invariant interaction hamiltonian density, for which an even number of tensor indices (of wave functions, derivatives, and ymatrices) must be contracted to form a scalar, we have Jf *(*) = JV{x) provided Jf (x) is local and hermitian, with phases chosen for each particle such that 1CPT=1(6-81) Then the CPT theorem follows (Liiders 1954, Pauli 1955, Lee et al. 1957): s/~1jr(x\s/ = jf(-x).
(6.82)
The S-matrix version of the CPT theorem following from (6.82) and (7.48) is < / IS |i> = < / | ^ ' S V |i> = r,CPT(CPT i\S\CPTf),
(6.83)
with incoming particles becoming outgoing antiparticles with flipped helicities, where we have used the antiunitary property of s/ as in (6.75) and t]CPT is the product of the CPT phases of all the particles in the interaction. In terms of M-functions similar to (6.34) for the representative process i + l - » i + l , the CPT relation (6.83) with p->p, A->-A, and (see Problem 6.6) «<-»(p)=(-r*»y 5 «<»(p),
e*<-«(p)= - ( - r ^ P ) .
(6-84)
(valid for p = pe 0 ) leads to the CPT condition for M-functions, M,M i) = (-YricrriVsMjCi, Cf)iy5.
(6.85)
Here J is the total number of vector indices in the reaction (two in this case). Under what assumptions is (6.85) valid? First, consider "crossing" all particles from the initial to the final state and vice versa, while preserving momentum, energy, and charge conservation as in Pi + Pi = P3 + P* -* P2 = (-Pi) + Ps + P4 etc.,
(6.86a)
ex -I- e2 = e3 + e 4 ->• e2 = ( — *i) + e3 + e 4 etc.
(6.86b)
Interpreting — px and —er as corresponding to a negative-energy particle traveling backward in time, or alternatively as an outgoing antiparticle (as opposed to an incoming particle), it is clear the kinematics of "total crossing" is the same as the CPT transformation. If the Lorentz-covariant dynamical amplitudes in MMV are in some sense "analytic" in the particle momenta— roughly linked with a local lagrangian density through "causality" (to be
114 Discrete Symmetries
discussed in detail in Chapter 15)—then they do in fact obey the dynamical total crossing relation Mjf,
i; {p}) = MjCi, Cf; {-p}),
(6.87)
where { — p} refers to all four momenta reversed. We shall see in Part III of this book that individual covariant Feynman graphs indeed obey (6.87). The general proof, however, is related to the analytic structure of "complex" Lorentz transformations (Jost 1957). Then since the mechanics of (6.85) converts y^ to — y^, etc., according to (6.80), and p^ to — ( — p j , every vector index in (6.85) has a sign change associated with it which cancels the ( — )J factor while transforming the CPT transformation law (6.85) to the total crossing relation (6.87). Thus if riCpT = 1, then the CPT theorem, proved originally for a local, hermitian hamiltonian density, is also linked with total crossing in momentum space applied to a unitary S-matrix. We shall return to the concept of crossing in later chapters. Consequences of the CPT Theorem. Considering the few and weak assumptions employed in the CPT theorem, its implications are significant indeed: i. The existence of antiparticles follows from CPT invariance even if charge-conjugation invariance is violated in nature. It is not necessary to invoke a "Dirac sea"—a ground-state vacuum filled with antiparticles—in order t