Advanced Methods in Material Forming
Dorel Banabic
Advanced Methods in Material Forming With 264 Figures and 37 Tables
Prof. Dorel Banabic Technical University Cluj-Napoca Research Centre on Sheet Metal Forming Technology – CERTETA 15 C. Daicoviciu 400020 Cluj-Napoca Romania
[email protected]
Library of Congress Control Number: 2007920904 ISBN 978-3-540-69844-9 Springer Berlin Heidelberg New York This work is subject to copyright. All rights are reserved, whether the whole or part of the material is concerned, specifically the rights of translation, reprinting, reuse of illustrations, recitation, broadcasting, reproduction on microfilm or in any other way, and storage in data banks. Duplication of this publication or parts thereof is permitted only under the provisions of the German Copyright Law of September 9, 1965, in its current version, and permission for use must always be obtained from Springer. Violations are liable for prosecution under the German Copyright Law. Springer is a part of Springer Science+Business Media springer.com c Springer-Verlag Berlin Heidelberg 2007 The use of general descriptive names, registered names, trademarks, etc. in this publication does not imply, even in the absence of a specific statement, that such names are exempt from the relevant protective laws and regulations and therefore free for general use. Typesetting: Integra Software Services Pvt. Ltd., Pondicherry, India Cover design: eStudio Calamar, Girona, Spain Printed on acid-free paper
SPIN: 11937197
42/Integra
5 4 3 2 1 0
Preface
The 8th International Conference of the European Scientific Association for Material Forming ESAFORM took place in Cluj-Napoca (Romania) at the end of April 2005 (http://conference.utcluj.ro/esaform2005). The conference was organised by the Research Centre on Sheet Metal Forming Technology CERTETA together with the European Scientific Association for Material Forming ESAFORM (http://www.esaform.org). The Technical University of Cluj-Napoca and the Romanian Academy were also co-organisers of that scientific event. The main purpose of the ESAFORM conferences is to bring together specialists from universities, research centres and industry interested in the forming processes of metallic as well as non-metallic materials. The conferences are organised each year by different European universities. The previous meetings were organised by the following academic institutions: 1998 – Ecole des Mines de Paris (Sophia Antipolis, France); 1999 – University of Minho (Guimaraes, Portugal); 2000 – University of Stuttgart (Germany); 2001 – University of Liege (Belgium); 2002 – AGH University of Science and Technology – Krakow (Poland); 2003 – University of Salerno (Italy); 2004 – University of Trondheim (Norway). The number of participants in the ESAFORM conferences increased continuously: from about 100 specialists registered in the first conference to 280 in the last one. The International Conference ESAFORM 2005 consisted in 24 minisymposia, each of them being coordinated by well-known specialists. The topics of the mini-symposia covered a variety of research domains: Identification of models, Numerical strategies, Optimisation, Multi-scale approaches, Constitutive models for metals and polymers, as well as technological problems specific to Sheet metal forming, Forging, Machining and cutting, Composite forming, etc. Some new mini-symposia included for the first time in the ESAFORM conference topics (Anisotropy and formability of materials, Rapid prototyping and rapid tooling, Nano-structuring of metals by severe plastic deformation, Semi-solid processing, etc.) were very successful. A number of 280 specialists from 35 countries (about 80% representing Europe) took part
VI
Preface
in the conference. In the frame of the conference, a number of 6 plenary lectures, 47 keynote papers, 210 session papers and 55 posters were presented. The abstracts (4 pages) were included in the conference proceedings published by the Romanian Academy. Some papers were also published in a special issue of the International Journal of Forming Processes. This volume gathers selected plenary and keynote papers presented in the conference, offering an up-to-date synthesis of the academic and industrial research in the fields of physical and numerical modelling of materials forming processes. The book is useful for the doctoral fellows, scientists and engineers involved in various domains of materials processing technology. I would like to thank the authors of the papers included in this book, as well as the scientific reviewers. I am also grateful to the members of the CERTETA centre (especially to Dr. D.S. Comsa) who substantially contributed to the success of the ESAFORM 2005 conference and to the preparation of the book. And last but not least I express my gratitude to Springer publishing house for accepting to publish this book. October 2006
Prof. Dorel Banabic
Contents
Constitutive Modeling for Metals F. Barlat . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
1
Material Forming and Dimensioning Problems: Expectations from the Car Industry G. Maeder . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 19 Optimization of the Phenomenological Constitutive Models Parameters Using Genetic Algorithms B.M. Chaparro, J.L. Alves, L.F. Menezes and J.V. Fernandes . . . . . . . . . 35 A Metamodel Based Optimisation Algorithm for Metal Forming Processes M.H.A. Bonte, A.H. van den Boogaard and J. Hu´etink . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 55 Modelling of Permeability and Mechanical Dispersion in a Porous Medium and Comparison with Experimental Measurements F. Loix, V. Thibaut and F. Dupret . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 73 Three-Dimensional Bending of Profiles by Stress Superposition S. Chatti, M. Hermes and M. Kleiner . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 101 Specimen for a Novel Concept of Biaxial Tension Test – Design and Optimisation W. Hußn¨ atter, M. Merklein and M. Geiger . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 119 Applications of a Recently Proposed Anisotropic Yield Function to Sheet Forming S. Soare, J.W. Yoon, O. Cazacu and F. Barlat . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 131
VIII
Contents
Modelling of the Forming Limit Diagrams Using the Finite Element Method L. P˘ ar˘ aianu, D.S. Com¸sa, J.J. Gracio and D. Banabic . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 151 Recent Advances in Process Design for Sheet and Tube Hydroforming J.C. Gelin, C. Labergere and S. Thibaud . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 167 Evaluating the Press Stiffness in Realistic Operating Conditions A. Ghiotti and P.F. Bariani . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 189 Fast Material Working: Wire Drawing N.D. Cristescu . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 199 3D-ECAP of Square Aluminium Billets A. Rosochowski, L. Olejnik and M. Richert . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 215 Computer-Aided Tool Path Optimization for Single Point Incremental Sheet Forming M. Bambach, M. Cannamela, M. Azaouzi, G. Hirt and J.L. Batoz . . . . . 233 Study on the Achievable Accuracy in Single Point Incremental Forming J.R. Duflou, B. Lauwers and J. Verbert . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 251 On the Finite Element Simulation of Thermal Phenomena in Machining Processes L. Filice, D. Umbrello, F. Micari and L. Settineri . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 263 Numerical Simulation of Wire Coating Pseudoplastic and Viscoplastic Fluids E. Mitsoulis and P. Kotsos . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 279 Experimental Study on Behaviour of Woven Composites in Thermo-Stamping Under Nonlinear Temperature Trajectories H.S. Cheng, J. Cao and N. Mahayotsanun . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 297 Thixoforming of Steel: Experiments on Thermal Effects P. Cezard, R. Bigot, V. Favier and M. Robelet . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 309 Study of the Liquid Fraction and Thermophysical Properties of Semi-Solid Steels and Application to the Simulation of Inductive Heating for Thixoforming J. Lecomte-Beckers, A. Rassili, M. Carton, M. Robelet and R. Koeune . . 321
Contents
IX
Simulation of Secondary Operations and Springback – The Implicit Shell Provides a Precise and Rapid Solution ´ Sch¨ E. onbach, G. Glanzer, W. Kubli and M. Selig . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 349 Author Index . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 361
Constitutive Modeling for Metals F. Barlat1,2 1
2
Alloy Technology and Materials Research Division, Alcoa Inc., Alcoa Technical Center, 100 Technical Drive, Alcoa Center, PA 15069-0001, USA,
[email protected] Center for Mechanical Engineering and Automation, University of Aveiro, Campus Universitario de Santiago, P-3810 Aveiro, Portugal,
[email protected]
Summary. This paper reviews aspects of the plastic behavior common in metals and alloys. Macroscopic and microscopic phenomena occurring during plastic deformation are described succinctly. Constitutive models of plasticity at the micro- and macro-scales, suitable for applications to forming, are discussed in a very broad fashion. Approaches to plastic anisotropy are reviewed in a more detailed manner.
Key words: alloy, anisotropy, constitutive model, forming, metal, microstructure, plasticity.
1 Introduction The life of a product follows the typical chronological order: material processing, product manufacturing, product service, failure, disposal or recycling. A product is a functional shape made of one or more materials, which results in a given set of properties and complies to specifications. The material selection process can be based on the designer experience or on a more analytical and comprehensive approach using databases and optimization methods (see Brechet in Lemaitre, 2001). Today, with advanced computer hardware and software, it is possible to model material processing, product manufacturing, product performance in service, and failure. Material design is somewhat more empirical but new analytical methods are emerging for this purpose (Raabe et al., 2004). Although the fine-tuning of a product manufacturing and performance is empirical, modeling can be an efficient tool to guide and optimize design, to evaluate material attributes, and to predict life time and failure. Moreover, modeling can be used as a research tool for a more fundamental understanding of physical phenomena that can result in the development of improved or new products. In any case, a constitutive model, a mathematical description of a material behavior, is needed. With more than 80000 engineered materials
2
Advanced Methods in Material Forming
(see Brechet in Lemaitre, 2001) used in various possible environmental conditions and temperatures, it is impossible to derive universal constitutive models applicable to them all. Restricting the discussion on metals and alloys, even in the context of forming, is still very broad. Therefore, this paper is an attempt to look at plastic deformation for metals and corresponding constitutive models for forming in a very synthetic way. Section 2 describes common aspects of the plastic deformation of metals and alloys and Sect. 3 briefly discusses relevant constitutive models and material parameters which are important for the simulations of forming operations. A slightly more detailed description of plastic anisotropy is provided as an illustration.
2 Plasticity of Metals and Alloys 2.1 Material Processing and Forming From its inception to its final realization, a product is subjected to a complex thermo-mechanical path that leads to a geometrical shape and a microstructure. For instance, Table 1 shows the different steps necessary to produce a sheet metal part from casting to forming. It involves a sequence of thermal and mechanical operations to which correspond a number of physical phenomena resulting in a material microstructure (Altenpohl, 1998). This table illustrates the complexity of the process. Both geometry and microstructure affect the functionality of the final product, its properties and its service performance. The goal of materials scientists and engineers is to develop and improve materials with respect to given properties such as the elastic modulus, strength, ductility, toughness, endurance and corrosion by a careful design of the microstructure. Materials designers are concerned with lattice imperfections, solute content, second-phases, grains and grain boundary structures,
Table 1. Typical flow path for aluminum alloy sheet processing product processing
physical phenomena
microstructure
• •
• •
• •
• • • • •
melting–casting homogenization (heat-treatment) hot rolling cold rolling solution heat-treatment stretching–aging forming
• • •
solidification phase transformation (liquid/solid) (solid/solid) plastic deformation recrystallization grain growth
• • • •
crystal structure grain and grain boundary structure crystallographic texture second-phases dislocation structure vacancies and solutes
Constitutive Modeling for Metals
3
crystallographic texture, and the distribution of all these features throughout the material. There are many possible ways to alter a microstructure by manipulating chemical composition and material processing. A given chemical composition itself does not reflect the final physical properties of a product, which is influenced by the whole material history after casting. In fact, it is important to note that memory effects can be very persistent. For instance, with reference to Table 1, the homogenization of an ingot at an unsuitable temperature for the particular chemical composition can lead to undesirable effects on its forming and service performances, even after several deformation and recrystallization cycles occurring during the whole process. Process engineers are usually more focused on the shape changes during forming, the appearance of geometrical defects and the existence of a macroscopic residual stress field. For instance, in forging, the material must completely fill a die. In hot rolling, a plate must achieve a certain gauge with an acceptable degree of flatness and a minimum amount of residual stresses. In sheet forming, a part is processed successfully if its final shape and dimensions fall within the dimensional tolerances after springback. These are only a few examples but in any case, the product must be achieved without fracture. Therefore, ductility is of major importance in forming. 2.2 Macroscopic Observations in Plasticity Aspects of the plastic deformation and ductility of metals and alloys at low and moderate strain rates, subjected to monotonic loading or to a few load cycles, are briefly discussed here. However, it is important to remember that beside plastic deformation, microstructure transformation is the result of temperature changes as well. Moreover, at very high strain rates, dynamic effects lead to additional phenomena that are not discussed here. The stress-strain behavior of metals and alloys at low strain is almost always reversible and linear. The elastic range however, is bounded by the yield limit, the stress above which permanent or inelastic deformations occur. In the plastic range, the flow stress, described by a stress-strain curve, usually increases with the total amount of plastic dissipation or a corresponding measure of accumulated plastic strain, and becomes the new yield stress if the material is unloaded. In general, it is considered that plastic deformation occurs without any volume change and hydrostatic pressure has virtually no influence on yielding. Experiments conducted at high confinement pressure showed that, though very small, a pressure effect is quantifiable and can explain the Strength Differential (SD) effect for high strength steels (Spitzig et al., 1984). The SD effect corresponds to the difference between tension and compression yield stresses when both tests are conducted independently from an annealed state. Confinement pressure can also significantly improve ductility.
4
Advanced Methods in Material Forming
The Bauschinger effect is a common feature in metals and alloys that occurs when a material is deformed up to a given strain, unloaded and loaded in the reverse direction, typically, tension followed by compression. Its signature is that the yield stress after strain reversal is lower than the flow stress before unloading from the first deformation step. Bauschinger and SD effects are two different phenomena. The flow stress of a material depends on the testing temperature. Moreover, at low absolute temperatures compared to the melting point, time has usually a very small influence on the flow stress and plasticity in general. However, at higher temperatures, strain rates effects are important. In fact, it has been observed that strain rate and temperature have similar effect on plasticity. Raising the temperature under which an experiment is carried out has a similar effect as decreasing the strain rate. Temperature has another influence on plasticity. When subjected to a constant stress smaller than the yield limit, a material can deform by creep. A similar phenomenon, called relaxation, corresponds to a decrease in the applied stress when the strain is held constant. Finally, solid state transformations can occur in materials due to an applied stress. These transformations lead to phase changes under stresses that are lower than the yield stress of either phase and can induce plasticity (Taleh et al., 2003). 2.3 Microscopic Observations in Plasticity Commercial metals and alloys used in forming operations are polycrystalline. They are composed of numerous grains, each with a given lattice orientation with respect to macroscopic axes. At low temperature compared to the melting point, metals and alloys deform by dislocation glide or slip and by twinning on given crystallographic planes and directions, which produce microscopic shear deformations. Therefore, the distribution of grain orientations, the crystallographic texture, plays an important role in plasticity. Because of the geometrical nature of slip and twinning deformations, strain incompatibilities arise between grains and produce micro-residual stresses, which are partly responsible for the Bauschinger effect. Slip results in a gradual lattice rotation as deformation proceeds while twinning leads to abrupt changes in lattice orientation. The number of available slip systems determines the nature of the deformation mechanisms. BCC and FCC materials tend to deform by slip because of the large number of available slip systems. However, HCP materials, in which the number of potential slip systems is limited, generally tend to twin as an alternate mechanism to accommodate an imposed deformation. After slip, dislocations accumulate at microstructural obstacles and increase the slip resistance for further deformation, leading to strain hardening with its characteristic stress-strain curve. At higher temperature, more slip systems can be available to accommodate the deformation (Perocheau et al., 2002) but grain boundary sliding, which in
Constitutive Modeling for Metals
5
a sense, is another type of shear, is becoming more predominant. For instance, superplastic forming occurs mainly by grain boundary sliding. In this case, the grain size and shape are important parameters. Atomic diffusion is also another mechanism that affects plastic deformation at high temperature and contributes to creep. Commercial materials contain second-phase grains or particles. These phases are present in materials by design in order to control either the microstructure such as the grain size or mechanical properties such as strength. However, some amounts of second-phases are undesired. In any case, the presence of these non-homogeneities alters the material behavior because of their differences in elastic properties with the matrix as it happens in composite materials, or because of their interactions with dislocations. In both cases, these effects produce incompatibility stresses that contribute to the Bauschinger effect. The mechanisms of failure intrinsic to metals and alloys are plastic flow localization and fracture. Localization tends to occur in the form of shear bands, either micro-bands, which tend to be crystallographic, or macro-bands which are not (Korbel, 1998). Necking in thin sheet occurs in plane strain deformation which, depending on the reference frame the strain is observed, is also a shear deformation mode. In forming, ductile fracture is generally the result of the mechanisms of void nucleation, growth and coalescence. The associated micro-porosity leads to volume changes although the matrix is plastically incompressible, and hydrostatic pressure affects the material behavior. At low temperature compared to the melting point, second-phases are principally the sites of damage. The stress concentration around these phases lead to void nucleation, and growth occurs by plasticity. Coalescence is the result of plastic flow micro-localization of the ligaments between voids. At higher temperature, where creep becomes dominant, cavities nucleate at grain boundaries by various mechanisms including grain sliding and vacancy concentration (Kassner et al., 2003). Generally, the materials subjected to creep and superplastic forming exhibit higher porosity levels than those deformed at lower temperature.
3 Constitutive Modeling 3.1 Modeling Scale In view of the previous section, it is obvious that it is impossible to develop constitutive models for forming applications that can capture all the macroscopic and microscopic phenomena involved in plastic deformation and ductile fracture. Plasticity can be studied at various scales but for forming applications, macroscopic models appear to be more appropriate. Because of the scale difference between the microstructure and an engineered component, the amount of microscopic material information necessary to store in a forming
6
Advanced Methods in Material Forming
simulation would be enormous. It is not possible anyways to track all of the relevant microstructural features in detail. Therefore, it seems more appropriate to integrate them all in a few macroscopic variables. Microscopic models are more suitable as a guide for material design, as a tool for fundamental understanding of plasticity and for inferring suitable formulations at the macroscopic scale. As mentioned above, memory effects in materials can be significant and, in principle, integral forms of the constitutive equations should be used to account for this history (Zhou et al., 2003). However, most of the constitutive equations describing plasticity have been developed in differential forms and have assumed to contain enough of the material history. Constitutive equations have been developed in scalar forms for uniaxial or shear deformation, particularly when coupled to microstructural evolution, and in tensorial forms for multiaxial loading as observed in forming operations. The constitutive equations are often developed in the framework of thermodynamics in order to prevent violation of physical principles. The constitutive laws generally consist of a state equation, sometimes referred to as the kinetic equation, (Krausz et al., 1996) and evolution equations. The state equation describes the relationship between the strain rate ε, ˙ stress σ, temperature T and state variables Xi , which represents the microstructural state of the material. This can be translated, for instance, as σ = f (ε, ˙ T, Xi )
(1)
The evolution equations describe the development of the microstructure through the change of the state variables and can take the form ˙ T, Xj ) X˙ i = f (ε,
(2)
However, the state variables do not need to be connected to a specific microstructural feature. In this case, (1) and (2) define a macroscopic model with state (or internal) variables. Since the temperature influences the kinetics of microscopic mechanisms, it has an effect on plasticity, as discussed above, similar to that of the strain rate. Therefore, in processes involving hot deformation such as rolling, forging or extrusion, these two variables are usually combined in a single quantity, the so-called Zener-Hollomon parameter Z (see Hosford et al., 1983) Z = ε˙ exp (−Q/RT ) (3) thus reducing the number of variables in the constitutive relationships. In (3), R is the gas constant and Q an activation energy, which is determined experimentally for a given material. 3.2 Microscopic Plasticity Modeling Because slip plays a major role in plasticity, it seems important to look at this mechanism in term of both its geometrical effect on anisotropy and its
Constitutive Modeling for Metals
7
effect on strain hardening. Polycrystal description of plasticity has been very successful over the last few decades. This approach is based on the geometrical aspect of plastic deformation, slip and twinning in crystals, and on averaging procedures over a large number of grains. The crystallographic texture is the main input to these models but other parameters, such as the grain shape, can also be included. It is a multiaxial approach and involves tensors. One of the outputs of a polycrystal model is the concept of the yield surface, which generalizes the concept of uniaxial yield stress for a multiaxial stress state. Polycrystal models are also very powerful to describe plastic anisotropy. Because polycrystal models can track the lattice rotation of each individual grain, the material anisotropy is naturally evolving, which makes this approach very attractive. They can be used in multi-scale simulations of forming but they are usually expensive in time and the relevant question is to know if their benefit is worth the cost. Polycrystal modeling aspects including twinning have been treated in a large number of books and publications such as, for instance, Kocks et al. (1978), Gambin (2001), Kalidindi et al. (2001) and Staroselski et al. (2003). Bishop et al. (1951) showed that, for a single crystal obeying the Schmid law, i.e. dislocation glide occurs when the resolved shear stress on a slip system reaches a critical value, the resulting yield surface was convex and its normal was collinear to the strain rate, i.e. that the yield surface is a convex potential. Furthermore, they extended this result for a polycrystal by averaging the behavior of a representative number of grains in an elementary volume without any assumption about the interaction mode between grains or the uniformity of the deformation gradient. Hecker (1976) reviewed a number of multiaxial experiments and did not find any significant contradiction to these assumptions about normality and convexity. After shearing individual grains, dislocations accumulate in the material, increasing their density which, in turn, leads to strain hardening. The Kocks and Mecking approach (Estrin, 1996) has laid the foundations for many subsequent studies by connecting the dislocation density ρ to the shear flow stress τ using the following state equation √ τ = τo + αμb ρ (4) where τo is the lattice friction stress, μ is the shear elastic modulus, b is the amplitude of the Burgers vector and α is a constant that takes dislocation interactions into account. The dislocation density represents the state of the material and its evolution, which depends on the dislocation production and annihilation rates, and can be represented for instance as (Estrin, 1996) √ dρ dt = k1 + k2 ρ − k3 ρ (5) where ki are coefficients, possibly depending on strain rate and temperature. With this type of approach, it is possible to model time dependent behavior such as creep, and time independent behavior by applying a strain proportional to time. Moreover, parameters describing the microstructure such
8
Advanced Methods in Material Forming
as grain size, second-phase and solute content can be incorporated into the formulation. In this type of approach, two or more state variables can be used such as the forest and mobile dislocation densities (Estrin, 1996). In that case, additional phenomena can be studied such as dynamic strain aging (Kubin et al., 1990; Rizzi et al., 2004) which produce, for instance, serrations in the stress-strain curves. This type of models contributes to the fundamental understanding of plasticity, to microstructure optimization and to the identification of relevant parameters that need to be directly or indirectly included in constitutive models. Dislocation models were also used to explain the small pressure effect on plastic deformation. Spitzig and Richmond (1984) showed that in high strength steels the uniaxial yield stress was larger in compression than in tension. They attributed this strength-differential (SD) effect to the sensitivity of steel to pressure. In fact, these authors conducted experiments under hydrostatic confinement and found a linear dependence between the mean stress (σm = σkk /3) and the effective stress σe (associated to the square root of √ the second invariant of the stress tensor σe = J2 ). To a reasonable approximation, Richmond and Spitzig (1980) used the following yield function to describe their experiments φ = σe + σ {3βσm − 1} = 0
(6)
where σ is the uniaxial flow stress and β is the pressure coefficient. This expression is similar to the yield condition proposed by Drucker et al. (1952) for soils. Spitzig and his co-workers (Spitzig 1979; Spitzig et al. 1976, 1984) conducted experiments for different steels and obtained approximately the same pressure coefficient, β = 20 TPa−1 . They also performed experiments on commercial purity aluminum and obtained β = 50 TPa−1 . The volume changes that they observed experimentally were negligible compared to those calculated with the classical flow rule, assuming normality between the yield surface and the strain rate. To explain the SD effect, Jung (1981) proposed a model based on the additional work needed to induce the motion of a dislocation due to the pressure (p) dependence of the elastic shear modulus (μ), expressing β in (6) as β≈
2 dμ 3μ0 dp
(7)
In the previous relationship, μ0 is the shear modulus at atmospheric pressure. This model leads to a pressure coefficient β equal to about 17 and 59 TPa−1 for steel and aluminum, respectively. These values are in good agreement with the experimental values mentioned above. Bulatov et al. (1999) used molecular static calculations with an embedded atom potential to simulate the effect of pressure on dislocation motion. They found that this phenomenon was the result of the interaction of the transient dilatation of moving dislocation with pressure. For aluminum, they computed values for the pressure coefficient
Constitutive Modeling for Metals
9
β of 48 and 63 TPa−1 for screw and mixed dislocations, respectively, which are consistent with the experimental value as well. Practically, for low to medium strength materials and low confinement pressure, this departure from the classical behavior can be neglected. However, this example shows how a parameter calculated using atomistic scale simulations can be transferred to the macroscopic scale. In multi-phase materials, the second phases, whose purpose is usually to increase strength, also contribute to plastic anisotropy. In heat-treatable aluminum alloys, precipitates are intimately linked to texture because they exhibit specific shapes and crystallographic relationships with the grains. They can influence anisotropy in a way that depends on their mode of interaction with dislocations. Wilson (1965) showed that binary Al-4%Cu alloys aged with different thermal treatments, i.e. containing different types of precipitates but the same crystallographic texture, exhibit Bauschinger effects of different magnitudes. As noted by Bate et al. (1981), a strong back stress builds up as deformation proceeds in alloys containing nonshearable precipitates. These authors used the results of the elastic inclusion model due to Eshelby (1957) to estimate the values of the back stress. This approach is based on the idea that dislocations accumulate around these particles and produce elastic/plastic strain incompatibilities at the precipitate interface. 3.3 Macroscopic Plasticity Modeling For time-independent plasticity, in a multiaxial stress space, plastic deformation is well described with a yield surface, a flow rule and a hardening law (Barlat et al., 2004). Plastic anisotropy is the result of the distortion of the yield surface shape due to the material microstructural state. In fact, here is an example where the microstructural model, crystal plasticity, guides the development of macroscopic descriptions. The flow rule can be assumed to follow the normality property as discussed by Bishop et al. (1951). Strain hardening can be isotropic or anisotropic. The former corresponds to an expansion of the yield surface without distortion due to an increase of the dislocation density. It is completely defined by a single stress-strain curve. Any other form of hardening, such as kinematic hardening, which corresponds to the translation of the yield surface, is anisotropic. Because stress states are multi-dimensional, it is necessary to describe yielding as a function of the stress tensor. Proper anisotropic plasticity formulations can be obtained if they are developed in the framework of the theory of representation for tensor functions (Boehler, 1978). In this theory, the constitutive equations are expressed such that the material symmetry conditions are automatically verified. The theorem of representation for a tensor function indicates that the constitutive equation can be expressed as an irreducible form of a set of invariants. Moreover, the theory of representation of tensor function includes the principle of isotropy of space, also called principle of material frame indifference or objectivity. A model based on this general
10
Advanced Methods in Material Forming
framework was developed for materials exhibiting the orthotropic symmetry such as sheets and plates (Cazacu et al., 2003). A drawback of the general approach is that it is generally difficult to check the convexity condition. However, a subset of this general theory, which is based on linear transformations of the stress tensor, is more suitable for developing convex formulations (Barlat et al., 2005). This approach is detailed below for incompressible materials for which a linear transformation is performed on the stress deviator, s, leading to the transformed stress deviator ˜ s ˜ s = Cs
(8)
C, a fourth order tensor, contains the anisotropy coefficients, accounts for the macroscopic symmetries of the material, and reduces to the identity for s are (Barlat isotropic materials. The associated 1st , 2nd and 3rd invariants of ˜ et al., 2005) sxx + s˜yy + s˜zz ) 3 H1 = (˜ H2 = s˜2yz + s˜2zx + s˜2xy − s˜yy s˜zz − s˜zz s˜xx − s˜xx s˜yy 3 (9) 2 2 2 H3 = 2˜ syz s˜zx s˜xy + s˜xx s˜yy s˜zz − s˜xx s˜yz − s˜yy s˜zx − s˜zz s˜xy 2 where x, y and z are the symmetry axes of the material. Using the variable 3 2 (10) θ = arccos 2H13 + 3H1 H2 + 2H3 2 H12 + H2 the principal values of ˜ s, which are themselves invariant tensorial quantities, are s˜1 =2 H12 + H2 cos θ 3 + H1 (11) s˜2 =2 H12 + H2 cos θ 3 − 2π 3 + H1 s˜3 =2 H12 + H2 cos θ 3 + 2π 3 + H1 In this theory, an anisotropic yield condition is expressed with an isotropic function of s˜1 , s˜2 and s˜3 . It is also possible to use two or more linear transformations, as long as the yield function is isotropic with respect to the 3n (1) (n) variables s˜k , . . . s˜k (for n linear transformations). In sheet forming, plastic anisotropy is an important aspect because it influences the strain distribution in a part and, consequently, the critical failure spots. In the absence of anisotropic hardening, plastic anisotropy is contained in the shape of the yield surface. For cubic metals, there are usually enough potentially active slip systems to accommodate any shape change. Moreover, compressive and tensile yield strengths are virtually identical. Yielding of such materials is usually represented adequately by an even function of the principal values of the stress deviator sk , such as (Hershey, 1954)
Constitutive Modeling for Metals a
a
a
φ = |˜ s1 − s˜2 | + |˜ s1 − s˜2 | + |˜ s1 − s˜2 | = 2σ a
11
(12)
Here, σ is equated to h (ε) a state variable, which is a function of the dissipated plastic work or the corresponding accumulated plastic strain ε, and correspond to strain hardening. The exponent a is connected to the crystal structure of the material, i.e. 6 for BCC and 8 for FCC (Hosford, 1993). This was established are a result of many polycrystal simulations. Therefore, although this model is macroscopic, it contains some information pertaining to the structure of the material. A recent variation of the yield function described by (12) with two linear transformations leads to a yield surface shown in Fig. 1 (Barlat et al., 2005). The general shape of the yield surface, with regions of high and low curvatures, is consistent with crystal plasticity computations. The anisotropy coefficients are calculated from mechanical tests results or polycrystal property predictions. The level of details of the anisotropic behavior captured by this model, illustrated in Fig. 2, might be excessive for many applications but in certain cases, for instance in the beverage can manufacturing industry, these details are significant. For most hexagonal closed packed metals (e.g. Ti, Mg, Zr, etc.), at low temperatures or high strain rates, twinning plays an important role in plastic deformation. The grains cannot accommodate certain shape changes because they lack the necessary deformation systems or because these systems require high activation stresses. Unlike slip, although pressure independent, twinning is sensitive to the sign of the applied stress, which is conducive to a strength differential (SD) effect. Furthermore, the strong crystallographic 1.5
TD normalized stress
1.0
Yld2004-18p Normalized shear stress contours in 0.05 increments
0.5
0.0
–0.5
–1.0 2090-T3 –1.5 –1.5
–1.0
–0.5 0.0 0.5 RD normalized stress
1.0
1.5
Fig. 1. Plane stress yield surface for a 2090-T3 Al-Li alloy sheet sample represented as contours of constant normalized shear stress σxy /σ
12
Advanced Methods in Material Forming 1.05 Exp. r value Yld2004-18p
Exp. stress Yld2004-18p
1.6
1.2
0.95 0.90
0.8
r value
Normalized stress
1.00
0.85 0.4 0.80 2090-T3 0.75
0
10
20
30 40 50 60 Tensile direction
70
80
0 90
Fig. 2. Uniaxial flow stress and r value (width to thickness strain ratio) directionalities with respect to the angle between tensile and rolling directions as predicted with the yield function Yld2004-18p for a 2090-T3 sheet sample
texture displayed by HCP materials leads to a pronounced anisotropy. To describe the yield asymmetry and anisotropy, Cazacu et al. (2004, 2005) proposed two yield functions, one based on the general theory of tensor representation and the other based on a linear transformation a
a
a
φ = ||s1 | − ks1 | + ||s2 | − ks2 | + ||s3 | − ks3 |
(13)
This formulation, although pressure insensitive, breaks the tension-compression symmetry and, similarly to the yield function in (12), includes anisotropy. For instance, Fig. 3 shows the corresponding yield surfaces at different strain levels predicted with this equation and applied to the case of a textured magnesium sheet. The non-isotropic hardening effect is captured by the evolution of the anisotropy coefficients and it corresponds to the rapid changes in texture due to twinning as deformation proceeds. Non-isotropic hardening effects can be described more classically by kinematic hardening and are usually related to the micro-stresses resulting from strain incompatibilities between grains or by the interactions between matrix and second-phases. This type of hardening describes the Bauschinger effect very efficiently and can be represented as φ (σ − α) = h (ε)
(14)
σ is the applied stress tensor and α is the back stress tensor, which controls the yield surfacetranslation. Evolution laws for this tensor can take many forms, including the following non-linear expression (Lemaitre et al., 1990) α ˙ =
C (σ − α) ε˙ − γαε˙ σ
(15)
Constitutive Modeling for Metals
13
200
σ yy(MPa)
100
0 1% 5% –100
10% –200 –200
–100
0
100
σ xx(MPa)
200
Fig. 3. Predicted yield locus for textured magnesium sheet. Experimental data (open circle) from Kelley et al. (1968)
where C and γ are the kinematic hardening coefficients. Barlat et al. (1998) used the non-linear kinematic hardening concept to develop a model that was able to explain the influence of non-shearable precipitates on plastic anisotropy for binary Al-Cu alloys deformed in tension and compression. In this case, the back stress was a function of the volume fraction, shape and habit planes of the precipitates, and of the crystallographic texture. Kinematic hardening can be successfully applied in forming simulations where the loading direction is changed abruptly such as, for instance, the prediction of springback in sheet forming. Other types of anisotropic hardening formulations, which account for the Bauschinger effect, are based on multiple plasticity surfaces. In the case of two surfaces (Dafalias et al., 1975; Hashiguchi, 2005), called loading and yield surfaces, respectively, the loading surface translates into stress space in a direction determined by the applied stresses or strains until it contacts the yield surface. The stress-strain relationships are determined by either surface depending whether contact between the surface is made or not. This concept appears somewhat physical since due to micro-residual stresses, the loading or reloading portion of the stress-strain curve involves the plastic contribution of only the grains that are favorably oriented for slip. A similar concept based on multiple surfaces was also proposed to model anisotropic strain hardening (see Mr´oz in Lemaitre, 2001). In this case, nested surfaces, each with a specific modulus, translate in stress space. The property of the active surface determines the stress-strain relationships until contact with the new active surface occurs. This type of models is suitable for the description of cyclic plasticity but its formulation might be too complex for forming simulations.
14
Advanced Methods in Material Forming
Viscoplasticity describes the time-dependent material behavior when temperature is less than typically half of the absolute melting point. Plastic deformation occurs by the motion of dislocations and the models used for plasticity are still valid. However, it is necessary to include terms containing the strain rate. Therefore, crystal plasticity and yield surface plasticity concepts can be applied in rate-dependent form. In this case, the critical resolved shear stress on the slip systems or the effective stress in the yield function formulations need to be modified with a viscous term such as m σ = h (ε) ε˙ ε˙0 (16) where ε˙0 is a reference strain rate. Both h (ε) and m depend on the temperature. m is also called strain rate sensitivity parameter. Of course, other viscous terms can be used in constitutive equations. Another approach to viscoplasticity is to assume that there is no yield surface and that any level of stress produces some amount of inelastic deformation, possibly extremely small when the stress is small (Krempl, 1996). In crystal plasticity, this approach is very useful because it eliminates the problem of slip system ambiguity in crystals where more systems than necessary are potentially active. In the continuum approach, the inelastic strain is an increasing function of the difference between the applied stress and the kinematic stress. Here the kinematic stress is similar to what is called the back stress in the kinematic hardening theories and can be associated to the microresidual stresses that need to be overcome to deform a material plastically. At temperatures that are roughly higher than half of the melting point, diffusion and grain sliding mechanisms are more dominant. This is the domain of creep and superplastic deformations. The so-called unified theories such as that briefly described above for viscoplasticity do not distinguish between the different plasticity mechanisms and are therefore able to describe creep as well. For superplastic (Khaleel et al., 2001) and creep (Hoh et al., 2004) forming, the microporosity formed at grain boundaries is a dominant factor, which is necessary to integrate in the constitutive equations of plastic deformation (see Murakami, in Lemaitre 2001). Constitutive models, such as the model proposed by Gurson (1977) and later extended by Tvergaard et al. (in Lemaitre, 2001) σe2 3q2 σm φ (σij , f, σ) = 2 + 2q1 f cosh − 1 + q12 f 2 = 0 (17) 2σe σ contain the porosity as an internal variable. Here, q1 and q2 are constant coefficients and f is the void volume fraction which, along with σ, is a second state variable. The evolution equation for f does not depend on the specific form of (17). It is the same for all models containing porosity, whether void nucleation takes place or not (Leblond, 2003) f˙ = (1 − f ) ε˙kk
(18)
Constitutive Modeling for Metals
15
F F
Fig. 4. Schematic of microstructural features within a shear localization band
Other aspects of the void growth can be included in this type of formulation, including the presence of hard inclusions in the microvoids or the coalescence of cavities (Siruguet et al., 2005a and b, respectively). To account for porosity or other form of material degradation, another approach consists in using a damage tensor D that modifies the applied stress tensor σ (see Chow in Lemaitre, 2001) −1 σ ˜ = [I − D] σ (19) The resulting effective stress tensor σ ˜ can be used in the classical mechanics formulations and constitutive equations to describe plasticity of damaged materials. Although discussed only briefly in this paper, strain localization and fracture are material intrinsic failure modes that are very important to consider. Shear localization is of particular interest because it can occur in any deformation state, either compressive as in rolling or tensile as in sheet forming. The modeling of shear localization is usually based on the existence of an imperfection in a material (Chien, 2004), which is physically reasonable considering the non-homogeneity of a material microstructure. All the microscopic features described above can contribute to localization through local hardening or softening (Fig. 4). In particular, porosity accounts for additional softening in the shear band. Ductile fracture can be predicted to occur with a Gurson type of constitutive equation by defining a critical porosity level fc above which fracture occurs. In the damage mechanics approach, a critical parameter Dc can be defined for failure as well.
4 Conclusions This paper illustrates the importance of material and process interactions. In principle, modeling of forming and microstructure evolution should be a concurrent process. However, in view of the size of forming simulations and the complexity of materials and physical phenomena occurring during plastic deformation, it seems more efficient to use macroscopic constitutive models
16
Advanced Methods in Material Forming
with one or more internal variables to account for the microstructure. Constitutive models at lower scale are, of course, very important for the understanding of the microstructure evolution and to provide a basis for the development of more advanced macroscopic material models.
Acknowledgements The author gratefully acknowledges Professor O. Cazacu, The University of Florida, for fruitful discussions and for providing Fig. 3, and Drs. M.E. Karabin and H. Weiland, Alcoa Technical Center, for their careful reviews of the manuscript.
References Altenpohl D.G., Aluminum: Technology, Applications and Environment, Warrendale, PA, TMS, 1998. Barlat F., Aretz H., Yoon J.W., Karabin M.E., Brem J.C., Dick R.E., “Linear transformation-based anisotropic yield functions”, Int. J. Plasticity, vol. 21, 2005, p. 1009–1039. ˙ Barlat F., Cazacu O., Zyczowski M., Banabic D., Yoon J.W., “Yield surface plasticity and anisotropy”, Continuum Scale Simulation of Engineering Materials – Fundamentals – Microstructures – Process Applications, Raabe D., Roters F., Barlat F., Chen L.-Q., (eds.), Berlin, Wiley-VCH Verlag GmbH, 2004, p. 145–177. Barlat F., Liu J., “Modeling precipitate-induced anisotropy in binary Al-Cu alloys”, Mat. Sci. Eng., vol. A257, 1998, p. 47–61. Bate P., Roberts W.T., Wilson D.V., “The plastic anisotropy of two-phase aluminum alloys – I. Anisotropy in unidirectional deformation”, Acta Metall., vol. 29, 1981, p. 1797–1814. Bishop J.W.F., Hill R., “A theory of the plastic distortion of a polycrystalline aggregate under combined stresses”, Phil. Mag., vol. 42, 1951, p. 414–427. Boehler J.P., Lois de Comportement anisotropes des milieux continus , J. M´ecanique, vol. 17, 1978, p. 153–190. Bulatov V.V., Richmond O., Glazov M.V., “An atomistic dislocation mechanism of pressure-dependent plastic flow in aluminium”, Acta Materialia, vol. 47, 1999, p. 3507–3514. Cazacu O., Barlat F., “A criterion for description of anisotropy and yield differential effects in pressure-insensitive metals”, Int. J. Plasticity, vol. 20, 2004, p. 2027–2045. Cazacu O., Barlat F., “Application of the theory of representation to describe yielding of anisotropic aluminum alloys”, Int. J. Eng. Sci., vol. 41, 2003, p. 1367–1385. Cazacu O., Plunkett B., Barlat F., “Orthotropic yield criterion for Mg alloy sheets”, Proceedings of the 8th Conference of the European Scientific Association for Material Forming, Cluj-Napoca, Romania, April 27–29, 2005, Banabic, D., (ed.), Bucharest, The Publishing House of the Romanian Academy, p. 3–10.
Constitutive Modeling for Metals
17
Chien W.Y, Pan J., Tang S.C., “A combined necking and shear localization analysis for aluminum alloys sheets under biaxial stretching conditions”, Int. J. Plasticity, vol. 20, 2004, p. 1953–1981. Dafalias Y.F., Popov E.P., “A model of nonlinearly hardening materials for complex loading”, Acta Mechanica, vol. 21, 1975, p. 173–192. Drucker D.C., Prager W., “Soil mechanics and plastic analysis or limit design”, Quart. Appl. Math., vol. 10, 1952, p. 157–165. Eshelby J.D., “The determination of the elastic field of an ellipsoidal inclusion and related problems”, Proc. Roy. Soc. London, vol. A241, 1957, p. 376–396. Estrin Y, “Dislocation density-related constitutive modeling”, Unified Constitutive Law of Plastic Deformation, Krausz A.S., Krausz K. (eds.), Academic Press, San Diego, CA, 1996, p. 69–106. Gambin W., Plasticity and Texture, Amsterdam, Kluwer Academic Publishers, 2001. Gurson A.L., “Continuum theory of ductile fracture by void nucleation and growth – Part I: Yield criteria and flow rules for porous ductile media”, ASME J. Eng. Materials and Technology, vol. 99, 1977, p. 2–15. Hashiguchi K., “Generalized Plastic Flow Rule”, Int. J. Plasticity, vol. 21, 2005, p. 321–351. Hecker S.S., “Experimental studies of yield phenomena in biaxially loaded metals”, Constitutive Modelling in Viscoplasticity, Stricklin A., Saczalski K.C. (eds.), ASME, New-York, ASME, 1976, p. 1–33. Hershey A.V., “The plasticity of an isotropic aggregate of anisotropic face centred cubic crystals”, J. Appl. Mech., vol. 21, 1954, p. 241–249. Hoh K.C., Lin J., Dean T.A., “Modeling of springback in creep forming thick aluminum sheets”, Int. J. Plasticity, vol. 20, 2004, p. 733–751. Hosford W.F., Caddell R.M., Metal Forming-Mechanics and Metallurgy, Englewood Cliffs, NJ, Prentice-Hall, Inc., 1983. Hosford W.F., The Mechanics of Crystals and Polycrystals, Oxford, Science Publications, 1993. Jung J., “A note on the influence of hydrostatic pressure on dislocations”, Philos. Mag. A, vol. 43, 1981, p. 1057–1061. Kalidindi S.R., “Modeling anisotropic strain hardening and deformation textures in low stacking fault energy fcc metals”, Int. J. Plasticity, vol. 17, 2001, p. 837–860. Kassner M.E., Hayes T.A., “Creep cavitation in metal”, Int. J. Plasticity, vol. 19, 2003, p. 1715–1864. Kelley E.W., Hosford W.F., “Deformation characteristics of textured magnesium”, Trans. TMS-AIME, vol. 242, 1968, p. 654–661. Khaleel M.A., Zbib H.M., Nyberg E.A., “Constitutive modeling of deformation and damage in superplastic materials”, Int. J. Plasticity, vol. 17, 2001, p. 277–296. Kocks U.F., Tom´e C.N., Wenk H.-R., Texture and Anisotropy, Cambridge, University Press, 1998. Korbel A., “Structural and mechanical aspects of homogeneous and nonhomogeneous deformation in solids”, Localization and Fracture Phenomena in Inelastic Solids, P. Perzyna P. (ed.), Wien, Springer-Verlag, 1998, p. 21–98. Krausz A.S., Krausz K., “The constitutive law of deformation kinetics”, Unified Constitutive Laws of Plastic Deformation, San Diego, CA, Academic Press, (1996), p. 229–279.
18
Advanced Methods in Material Forming
Krempl E., “A small-strain viscoplasticity theory based on overstress“, Unified Constitutive Laws of Plastic Deformation, Krausz A.S., Krausz K. (eds.), San Diego, CA, Academic Press, (1996), p. 281–318. Kubin L.P., Estrin Y., “Evolution for dislocation densities and the critical conditions for the Portevin-Le Chatelier effect”, Acta Metall. Mater., vol. 38, 1990, p. 697–708. Leblond J.-B., M´ecanique de la rupture fragile et ductile, Paris, Lavoisier, 2003. Lemaitre J. (ed.), Handbook of Materials Behaviour Models, San Diego, Academic Press, San Diego, 2001. Lemaitre J., Chaboche J.-L., Mechanics of Solid Materials, Cambridge, University Press, 1990. Perocheau F., Driver J., “Slip systems rheology of Al-1%Mn crystals deformed by hot plane strain compression”, Int. J. Plasticity, vol. 18, 2002, p. 185–203. Raabe D., Roters F., Barlat F., Chen L.Q. (eds.), Continuum Scale Simulations of Engineering Materials – Fundamentals – Microstructures – Process Applications, Berlin, Wiley-VCH Verlag GmbH, 2004. Richmond O. and Spitzig W.A., “Pressure dependence and dilatancy of plastic flow”, IUTAM Conference, Theoretical and Applied Mechanics, Proc. 15th International Congress of Theoretical and Applied Mechanics, Amsterdam, North-Holland Publishers, 1980, p. 377–386. Rizzi E., H¨ ahner P., “On the Portevin-Le Chatelier effect: Theoretical modeling and numerical results”, Int. J. Plasticity, vol. 20, 2004, p. 121–165. Siruguet K., Leblond J.-B., “Effect of void locking by inclusions upon the plastic behavior of porous ductile solids – I: Theoretical modeling and numerical study of void growth”, Int. J. Plasticity, vol. 20, 2004a, p. 225–254. Siruguet K., Leblond J.-B., “Effect of void locking by inclusions upon the plastic behavior of porous ductile solids – part II: Theoretical modeling and numerical study of void coalescence”, Int. J. Plasticity, vol. 20, 2004b, p. 255–268. Spitzig W.A, “Effect of hydrostatic pressure on plastic flow properties of iron single crystal”, Acta Metall., vol. 27, 1979, p. 523–534. Spitzig W.A, Sober R.J., Richmond O., “The effect of hydrostatic pressure on the deformation behavior of Maraging and HY-80 steels and its implication for plasticity theory”, Metall. Trans., vol. 7A, 1976, p. 1703–1710. Spitzig, W.A., Richmond, O., “The effect of pressure on the flow stress of metals”, Acta Metal., vol. 32, 1984, p. 457–463. Staroselski A., Anand L., “A constitutive model for hcp materials deforming by twinning: Application to magnesium alloy AZ31B”, Int. J. Plasticity, vol. 19, 2003, p. 1843–1864. Taleh L., Sidoroff F., “A micromechanical model of the Greenwood-Johnson mechanism in transformation induced plasticity”, Int. J. Plasticity, vol. 19, 2003, p. 1821–1842. Wilson D.V., “Reversible work-hardening in alloys of cubic metals”, Acta Metall. vol. 13, 1965, 807–814. Zhou Z.-D., Zhao S.-X., Kuang Z.-B., “An integral elasto-plastic constitutive theory”, Int. J. Plasticity, vol. 19, 2003, p. 1377–1400.
Material Forming and Dimensioning Problems: Expectations from the Car Industry G. Maeder Renault s.a.s., Materials Engineering Department, FR TCR LAB 1 36, 1 avenue du Golf – 78288 Guyancourt Cedex, Phone: 33(0)1 76 56 372, Fax: 33(0)1 76 85 03 35,
[email protected] Summary. An automotive project is now based on numerical validation to reduce the development time between the project preparation and the start of production. That is particularly true to predict the formability of materials and solve dimensioning problems. But some problems remain and we will give examples of limitations in the case of steel sheet stamping, of tubes or profile bending, of polymer injection. We will also show that the main difficulty relates to constitutive equations that require to be more and more representative of the real behaviour of materials.
Key words: automotive project, simulation, stamping, bending, injection.
1 Introduction When choosing a material for designing a part or a set of parts for a particular function, the engineer should consider several factors: the vehicle has to fulfil technical, economical and regulation requirements. However, the main factor claimed by the designer relates to the properties of the part once the materials have been formed and/or assembled. The automobile product changes under the influence of factors that are internal or external to the company, and the time allowed for development shortens with the contribution of representation and virtual design. This is not without consequence on the choice and validation of the material-process couple. In particular, modelling and simulation of forming and assembling processes are becoming compulsory tools for the engineer to accompany development of an automotive project. In this article, we would first like to show what an automotive project is today with its major guidelines, its main stages and the evolution factors. We shall then see what are the consequences for the material-process couple with, in particular, the contribution of numerical simulation. Lastly, from a few examples taken from stamping, bending, injection techniques, we shall show
20
Advanced Methods in Material Forming
that important progress remains to be accomplished to make the numerical calculation and experimental validation results to coincide.
2 Development of an Automotive Project 2.1 Major Guidelines Simultaneous Engineering: the important change in organization is the passage from a sequential engineering giving way to styling, product design, process design, industrialization, purchasing, suppliers, logistics, after-sales, towards a simultaneous engineering in which all these different activities are implemented in parallel. Then, the development process starts from technical requirements to lead to components or physical parts available for assembly, going through functional customer requirements, via the simultaneous product/process design widely making use of simulation, numerical calculation, etc. with different steps marked by milestones with well-defined content. Vehicle Breakdown: this development process applies to the elementary functions making up the vehicle. In the case of Renault, there are 24 groups of elementary functions, each placed under the responsibility of a pilot. These functions are, for example, the dashboard, the exhaust line, the axles, the external accessories, etc. The power train is itself considered as a function that is external to the vehicle and has its specific development logic. Piloting by Customer Requirements: the customer requirements correspond to what a manufacturer can propose to the customer to meet expectations that are more or less formulated: performance/consumption, comfort/behaviour/braking, soundproofing/vibration, reliability/durability. The material-process couple contributes to the achievement of targets of a greater number of customer requirements. 2.2 Main Project Stages The design of a vehicle is divided into two major phases: the upstream phase (project preparation) and the development phase (Fig. 1). –
the upstream phase (project preparation) corresponds to the definition of the company’s strategy in terms of research of concepts, choice and feasibility of innovations: “State what will be done”.
This upstream phase is divided into two stages. From the “orientations” milestone given by the Product – Planning department, we study several car concepts and different technological innovations. Some hypotheses are frozen at the “hypotheses freeze” milestone and the preparatory studies stage leads toward one choice of concept, to the choice of innovations, and to the choice
Material Forming and Dimensioning Problems Project Preparation
Project Development
21
Production
Vehicle Approval to Marketing Entry in Build Try-out Approval Factory Tooling Manufacturing Go Ahead Approval
Styling Freeze 100% Orientations
Hypotheses Freeze
Exploratory Studies
PreContract
Preparatory Studies
Contract
First Design
Detailed Design
Product/ Process Development
Manufacturing
Standard Production
1 2 3 4 5 Digital Mock-up Design Reviews
Fig. 1. Development schedule of a project
of suppliers. The end milestone of this upstream phase is the “precontract milestone”. That is also the first milestone of the project development phase. –
the development phase forms the actual vehicle project, with a digital convergence process of the vehicle (design phase) and a physical convergence process leading to the definition of parts, systems and finally the vehicle (industrialization phase): “Do what was stated”.
These different phases are divided into different stages separated by different milestones. It is important to point out that, during the “first design” and “detailed design” phases, the various milestones scheduled are essentially based on digital validations and design representations (plus a few partial physical test supports). The “contract milestone” determines the Quality-Cost-Delivery objectives of the project. At the “styling freeze” milestone all definitions corresponding to geometry and interfaces are frozen. The “tooling go ahead” milestone shows the beginning of the physical achievement part of the design. The “product/process development stage includes the manufacturing of the tools. The “vehicle entry in factory” milestone marks the end of the product/process try-out and formalizes the transfer of the engineering responsibility towards the manufacturing responsibility. All Quality-Cost-Delivery objectives are obtained. The “manufacturing approval” milestone marks the beginning of the production, and the “marketing approval” milestone marks the beginning of the standard production stage with the volume asked by the marketing. We must note that the physical achievement of the parts only starts at the “Tooling Go Ahead” milestone and ends at the “Approval to build tryout”. This is possible only by means of highly detailed studies based on the exclusive use of numerical simulation and dimensioning by calculation. And we have to add that this development process imposes the suppliers to integrate it, in the various phases described, for the parts developed outside the company.
22
Advanced Methods in Material Forming
2.3 Evolution Factors Evolution of Customer Requirements: the requirements change as a function of market competition, customer expectations and regulations. The consequences of such evolution result in numerous specifications in which the materials – and therefore the simulation of their behaviour – are representative. For example: – –
– – –
Lightening: processing of new materials, multi-materials, assembly of different materials, etc. Durability: determination of methods (simulation and accelerated tests) to predict the change of properties in materials over time under fatigue solicitations, etc. Safety: taking into account the dynamical properties of materials and assemblies, etc. Acoustics: knowing the acoustic properties of materials after their processing, etc. Perceived Quality: regular clearances and perfectly geometrical fitting between bodywork parts are fundamental elements of perceived quality of a vehicle. These two parameters are directly connected with the final geometry of the parts after forming by sheet stamping or polymers injection.
Dimensioning to the Closest Value: a vehicle is now designed more and more in a virtual manner, in order to reduce the development time and the number of actual prototypes that are very expensive. Calculation models are more and more performing with, as a consequence, the necessity to very accurately define the mechanical, physical and chemical characteristics of materials to introduce them into the calculation models of parts, or in the calculations related to the transformation processes and to the assemblies. This requires that the engineers and the design departments have a good knowledge of the characteristics of the materials, their limitations, and the impact on the durability. This means that no value can be supplied without its confidence interval linked to measurement uncertainties and to the variability of production facilities. Reduction in Vehicle Scheduling: accelerated renewal of models is made with a development schedule that is shorter. For example, the time between “design freeze” (a few weeks before Tooling Go Ahead) and “start of production” milestones has passed from 55 months to 42 months from Laguna I to Laguna II, and from 53 months to 29 months from M´egane I to M´egane II. It is therefore indispensable to freeze the material-process solutions more and more earlier in the development phase, and to reduce the tool definition time to the minimum. For this last point, numerical simulation is primordial. Internationalization: manufacturers are grouping themselves together in view of globalization. Vehicles are manufactured in several countries, in all five continents where the regulations, customer expectations, competitive markets are different. It is also necessary to have a strong local integration: this is very
Material Forming and Dimensioning Problems
23
important because it should often call for local material suppliers, that will have grades that do not necessarily correspond to those in initial specifications. Adaptation of materials and transformation processes to the local conditions is an important point for internationalization of manufacturers. This adaptation cannot be achieved without numerical simulation. Supplier Relationships: the increase in the diversity of materials and transformation processes associated to them, the increase in the complexity of assemblies between materials lead to outsourcing the transformation processing activities, this outsourcing may be partial or total. In the Renault group, only stamping, painting, assembly, injection of plastic fenders, machining and heat treatment activities remain partially integrated. It is obvious that part suppliers are becoming function or system integrators. They need to master all the numerical simulation tools required in the reduction of development times.
3 Consequences for Materials-Processes 3.1 General Consequences Related to Vehicle Development Outside Project: Innovation Development. Due to shortening of all the development phases of a project, all research or innovation works, – may these be conducted within the manufacturer, within a supplier, or in association with laboratories –, will only be done outside all project framework. Preliminary Project: Introduction of Innovations and Solutions Retained. In the exploratory phase, different material-process solutions are studied in parallel. Risk analysis is an important process that comes up against difficulties of assessing reliability and durability of the new solution, as well as its final cost. In the preparatory phase, the material-process solution is chosen. This solution is validated essentially by modelling and numerical simulation. This means that, as already stated, the characteristics of materials (mechanical, physical data, constitutive equations of static and dynamic behaviour, at various temperatures, etc.) are known to be introduced in the calculation models. Project: Numerical and Experimental Validations. Numerical validation, already initiated in the preparatory phase, is pursued and several milestones correspond to reviews on digital mockups (Digital Mockup Design Review). The design of the parts is finalized, the materials-processes are specified, the industrialization scheme is defined. The “product-process production and definition” is the physical convergence phase that comes after the simulation convergence phase. Any change in the plan of a part, any modification in the material-process solution will then have exorbitant consequences on deadline and cost.
24
Advanced Methods in Material Forming
Let us point on, in particular, the time for producing tools that can extend over several months. It should and shall not have any problem at this stage, if the work conducted upstream was of quality. Series: Validation Under Actual Conditions. Follow-up of series-produced vehicles is the best means of validating the reliability and durability of the selected material-process solutions. 3.2 Importance of Numerical Simulation: Case of Stamping All that was stated earlier shows the importance of numerical simulation in the present development of vehicles. Stamping of steel sheets is doubtless the process that opened the way to modelling and numerical simulation. We shall take this example to demonstrate the progress approach. Figure 2 summarizes the progress made from 1985 up to the present day, in the field of software applications and their use. However, remember that the correct use of such software applications passes through their “ergonomics” and the training quality of users. Let us give two examples of use in the two main phases of a project. Preliminary Project: simulation enables passage from an initial design in three parts, to a design in a single part (Fig. 3). Project: simulation enables display of the risks of cracks and enables the necessary corrections to be made (Fig. 4). Risks of cracks are indicated by the anows. And the experimental intrinsec charactericstics determined for applying the digital simulation can be also seen on the figure. Simulation also enables easier anticipation of material changes: substitution from classical steels to very high strength steels or passage to aluminium.
2000 2000 Process Processsurface surfacecreation creation software: software: - -adapted, adapted,robust, robust, - -user 1995 userfriendly, friendly,...... 1995 DieDesigner -> -> DieDesigner Meshing ... ... Meshingsoftware: software: DieMaker, DieMaker ,Simex2000, Simex2000, - -automatic, automatic, - -robust, fast, ... robust, fast, ... 1990 -> 1990 ->Deltamesh Deltamesh Stamping. Industrial Stamping, Industrialsoftware: software: AutoForm, - -validated AutoForm… ,… validated/ /robust robust - -user friendly user friendly -> ->Optris, Optris, Pam PamStamp, Stamp, - compensation of spring back Simex, Simex..., ... - nesting
1985 1985 Research: Research: - -formulas formulas - -finite finiteelements elements - -algorithms algorithms - -......
- ... - - > powerful optimisation software
Fig. 2. Evolution of numerical simulation
2005
Material Forming and Dimensioning Problems
25
Simultaneous engineering Final Design: 1 part
Initial Design: 3 parts
Fig. 3. Integration of simulation in preliminary project phase
Fig. 4. Integration of simulation in project phase
4 Manufacturer’s Expectations in Terms of Forming and Assembling Simulation: Some Examples We pointed out the progresses made by means of numerical simulation. Nevertheless, problems still subsist that are incorrectly or not solved. Their enumeration can serve as a clue towards research work. But, before describing some examples, note the three limitations that are common to all the examples: –
calculation times should be reduced,
26
– –
Advanced Methods in Material Forming
the constitutive equations of materials should be known, boundary conditions are always physically poorly known and numerically not correctly taken into account.
4.1 Limitations of Sheet Stamping Calculations Springback Effect. The sprinkback effect is well known and appear on the Fig. 5 with the exemple of the B section of the part. A positive deformation on one side and a negative deformation on the other side appear compared with the theoretical geometrical form. A method compensating for this springback was developed with Arcelor (Munier, 2004), by designing stamping dies whose die geometry is different from that of the final part. The first applications were encouraging, however, two conditions remained to be fulfilled: – –
the numerical accuracy of springback prediction should be whithin 1 mm the calculation time of springback and of the stamping process should be shorter than 1 hour.
Friction Coefficients. In a real stamping operation, friction occurs at the interfaces of sheet-punch, sheet-die, sheet-blankholder, etc. The impact of friction is considerable and the stamping feasibility is directly dependent thereon. The article referenced in (El-Mouatassim, 2002), reviews all the problems related to such friction and proposes a few approaches to reduce Sheet stamping Spring back 3.06
Section A
2.55
2.8
0.151
Section B
Section B 1.3
Section C Y Z
–3.09
–2.15
X
–3.0
Déplacemt norm. –2.1
–1.3
–0.4
0.4
Fig. 5. Example of sheet stamping spring back
3.0 1.3
2.1
Material Forming and Dimensioning Problems
27
them. The present conclusion is that “common sense” remains the best guide. However, sensitivity studies on different parameters can help understanding stamping feasibility. Constitutive Equation for TRIP Steels. TRansformation Induced Plasticity steels (TRIP) have a multiphase microstructure constituted by a ferritic matrix, hard bainite and retained austenite. This austenite leads to a martensitic transformation when strain is applied during transformation. Constitutive equations currently used to characterize “classical” materials during forming process don’t take into account this phase transformation. Consequently, forming simulations for TRIP steels are not sufficiently predictive especially for thickness. The “cross die test” uses a stamping tool which reproduces most of the industrial strain paths. RENAULT uses it to study and classify deep drawability of sheets, roughness, lubricants and coatings (Fig. 6). A square metal sheet is stamped at a given punch depth and blankholder force. A good way to evaluate the robustness of constitutive equations is to compare simulation results with experimental results on cross die test . We use thinning curves to make this comparison on the Fig. 7. The constitutive equations are established by using several mechanical characterization tests (tensile and shearing test,. . . . . . .) to identify quadratic yield criteria associated with isotropic work hardening model – upper curve on the Fig. 7 – or isotropic + kinematic work hardening model (Armstrong– Frederik for example) – bottom curve on the Fig. 7. These results show that we don’t find a general rule concerning constitutive equations to have a good prediction of thickness: the accuracy depends on the material and the direction. One way to improve constitutive equations and consequently increase simulation accuracy is to develop a specific approach for TRIP steel. Renault has been studying different ways to do that by developing a mixing law with phase transformation (coupled with quadratic yield criterion) or replacing isotropic work hardening term in Armstrong–Frederick model by a coupled isotropic – kinematical hardening law.
Diagonal direction Rolling direction
Fig. 6. “Cross-die test” geometry
T R IP 800
T R IP 700
T R IP 600
Thickness (mm)
1.10
1.30
1.50
1.70
1.90
2.10 1.90 1.70 1.50 1.30 1.10 0.90
0
1
1.2
1.4
1.6
1.8
2
2.2
0
0.90 –20 0
Thickness (mm)
Thickness (mm)
20
20
20
Experimentation Isotropic work hardening simulation Isotropic + kinematic work hardening simulation
60 80 100 120 140 160 180 200 Curvilinear abscissa (mm)
1.1
1.2
1.3
1.4
1.5
1.6
1.7
1.1
1.2
1.3
1.4
1.5
1.6
1.7
1.1
1.2
1.3
1.4
1.5
1.6
1.7
0
0
0
50
250
250
100 150 200 Curvilinear abscissa (mm)
250
Experimentation Isotropic work hardening simulation Isotropic + kinematic work hardening simulation
100 150 200 Curvilinear abscissa (mm)
Experimentation Isotropic work hardening simulation Isotropic + kinematic work hardening simulation
100 150 200 Curvilinear abscissa (mm)
50
50
Experimentation Isotropic work hardening simulation Isotropic + kinematic work hardening simulation
Graph of thickness - Diagonal direction
Fig. 7. Comparison experimentations/simulations on thickness (TRIP steels)
40 60 80 100 120 140 160 180 200 Curvilinear abscissa (mm)
Experimentation Isotropic work hardening simulation Isotropic + kinematic work hardening simulation
40 60 80 100 120 140 160 180 200 Curvilinear abscissa (mm)
40
Experimentation Isotropic work hardening simulation Isotropic + kinematic work hardening simulation
Graph of thickness - Rolling direction
Thickness (mm) Thickness (mm) Thickness (mm)
28 Advanced Methods in Material Forming
Material Forming and Dimensioning Problems
29
4.2 Limitations of Bending Calculations for Tubes or Profiles Tubes: Numerical simulation is now operational for bending exhaust line tubes. To achieve this, several years were necessary for searching on: – – –
identification of constitutive equations specific to tubes characterization of tube/tool friction factors definition of robust numerical simulation methods.
However, it is still not possible to do away fully with tests. In fact, we still do not have a feasibility factor that would allows us to know if the numerically optimized solution will generate tube rupture or not. Aluminium Profiles: Using aluminium profiles space frame structure is an efficiency method to lighten vehicle compared to a steel Body-In–White. These profiles must be bent to allow shapes compatible for assembling with other parts of the body structure (see Fig. 8). In this study, applied to doorframe profile, we focus on stretch-wrap process with pre-deformation. The main problem of profile bending is to control the geometry distorsion after unloading especially springback. To evaluate springback predictivity of constitutive equations and codes, we made simulations with three different softwares (PAMSTAMP2000, PAMSTAMP2G and ABAQUS).These results are compared with experimentations, Fig. 9. Figure 9 shows a difference between simulations (for the three codes) and experimentations especially for high bending angle and medium predeformation. Material parameters sensitivity study made with Pamstamp2G allowed to consider some ways to increase springback predictivity: –
improve accuracy of mechanical characterisation tests
Fig. 8. Profile bending machine
30
Advanced Methods in Material Forming 12 Sim.,Pam2000,β=10° Sim.,Pam2000,β=20° Sim.,Pam2000,β=30° Sim.,Pam2G,β=10° Sim.,Pam2G,β=20° Sim.,Pam2G,β=30° Exp.,β=10° Exp.,β=20° Exp.,β=30°
10 8 6 4 2 0 0.2
0.3
0.4
0.5
0.6
0.7
0.8
Pre-elongation δF (%)
0.9
1
1.1
Springback gap c(mm)
Springback gap c(mm)
12
Sim.,Pam2000,β=10° Sim.,Pam2000,β=20° Sim.,Pam2000,β=30° Sim.,ABAQUS,β=10° Sim.,ABAQUS,β=20° Sim.,ABAQUS,β=30° Exp.,β=10° Exp.,β=20° Exp.,β=30°
10 8 6 4 2 0 0.2
0.3
0.4
0.5
0.6
0.7
0.8
0.9
1
1.1
Pre-elongation δF (%)
Fig. 9. Simulations & experimental results for springback (Aluminium profiles)
– – –
develop new process for the constitutive equations identification develop new identification tests (bending-unbending test) evaluate new yield criteria (like BBC criterion from Prof. BANABIC)
4.3 Limitations of Polymer Injection Simulation Polymer injection is simulated using rheologic calculations. This simulation should enable to predict without testing, the risks inherent to the production of a part, and to modify the drawing, at its design stage, and/or the injection conditions. Thus, it should be possible to avoid reworking of tools and carrying out time-taking debugging operations by correctly clearing all preliminary risks. The current rheology software applications will predict the injection process at these different stages: filling the die, compacting the part including the thermal history of the tools with filled materials or not, and post-moulding deformation. However, today, a great number of behaviours are still difficult to predict because difficult to model. Part Deformation: Figure 10 shows the case of the wheel cap of Modus, made of polypropylene, filled with 40% of mineral fillers. A negative deformation of 1.5 mm is obtained on the post-moulded part whereas simulation provides for a positive deformation of 2.45 mm; this induces a contact between the wheel cap and the wheel itself. This difference can be explained by a calculation of volumetric shrinkage and moulding stresses from mechanical data, without taking into account the experimental shrinkage data measured on plates. Appearance Defects: On a side protection strip of the SCENIC, made of modified EPDM polypropylene with 15% of mineral fillers, we obtained flow lines and marks of waves on the part. Such appearance defects, to which can be added veins, burns, shrink marks, welding lines, are not quantified by rheology software applications. Analysis of the results of temperature and pressure provides a tendency only, knowing that
Material Forming and Dimensioning Problems
31
Fig. 10. Comparison simulation/experimentation on deformation after injection
the origin of formation of waves (or tiger stripes) is poorly known (unstable progression of the edge of the die in contact with the wall of the mould?). Pressure Prediction: Figure 11 summarizes the wheel cap of Fig. 9. This figure compares the experimental and calculated pressure evolution during injection. It can very clearly be seen that the simulated pressure is 30% lower than measured pressure. This overpressure results in inaccuracy of deformation prediction and in the choice of the force to be applied to close the press tooling. The source of the difference is doubtless the incorrect viscosity value used for the simulation. Shrink Mark Prediction: This concerns the case of PMMA reflectors. On these parts, shrink marks can be seen on the edges and on the surface. The volumetric shrinkage is therefore incorrectly predicted by an incorrect integration
Fig. 11. Comparison simulation/experimentation on injection pressure
32
Advanced Methods in Material Forming
of the thickness and by a lack of quantitative results in terms of appearance description. Flow Leaders Prediction: These flow leaders result in deformation due to acceleration of the material in certain areas of the part. This appears in the example of a polycarbonate headlight glass, or also of rear-view mirror shells. However, 2D, 2D1/2 or 3D simulations, even with a local modification of the thickness in the radius do not show any deformation. This difference between experience and simulation is due to the extrapolation of viscosity curves with high and low shear values, as well as the non-integration of the material’s elongational viscosity. Source of Problems: Several applications are available on the market, with meshing as a key point: neutral fibre meshing, dual skin meshing, 3D meshing. Of course, there is a technical know-how for using such applications (and knowledge on their limitations), but the main problem is related to the constitutive equations of materials which are inaccurate. The following can be mentioned as influencing parameters: – – –
–
–
–
elongational viscosity is very difficult to determine experimentally crystallization can be taken into account but with calculation times multiplied by ten the glass transition temperature (PVT), measured at very low cooling rates (1◦ C/ min) whereas the cooling rates are much higher during injection (200◦ C/ min) the viscosity that is measured over a too small shear strain range and whose values are extrapolated by high and low shear values by means of constitutive equations. the results, calculated from the glass transition temperatures (PVT) obtained from the constitutive equations with approximations, and that use thermo-mechanical data that are far beyond the injection conditions. the orientation of glass fibres (particularly in the thickness) that occurs at the end of flow, at a moment that is difficult to predict by the know-how in simulation today. Furthermore, the applications do not take into account the orientation in thickness nor the anisotropy of the shrinkage.
5 Conclusions The development of an automotive project takes place over a shorter and shorter period, with an increasing and necessary role played by numerical simulation. Numerical simulation for forming is even more important as production of tools requires a time period that is difficult to reduce: the tools should produce parts in accordance with modifications that are as low as possible. To bring down this calculation time, or to increase the accuracy, it is necessary to have more and more powerful hardware facilities.
Material Forming and Dimensioning Problems
33
But the most important works relate to constitutive equations that require to be more and more representative of the real behaviour of materials. The knowledge of these constitutive equations conditions the use of new materials or the use of assembly of different materials. This requires numerous research works that should be developed outside an automotive project, but in universities laboratories, keeping close relationships with the end user (who can be the car manufacturer or the supplier) to limit the sophistication level of results in view of short and medium-term applications.
Acknowledgements The author would like to thank M. El-Mouatassim, R. Vollet, E. Crouan, P. Lory, F. Moussy and E. Vaillant for the examples given in the drafting of this article.
References El-Mouatassim M., Nobile D., Friction and numerical simulation of stamping, Proc. Conf. IBEC 2002. Munier M., Devin J.M., El-Mouatassim M., New Approach for Springback Compensation in Die Design Application for High Strength Steel, Proc. Conf. IDDRG 2004, ed. G. Steinbeck, Sindelfingen 2004.
This page intentionally blank
Optimization of the Phenomenological Constitutive Models Parameters Using Genetic Algorithms B.M. Chaparro1 , J.L. Alves2 , L.F. Menezes3 and J.V. Fernandes3 1
2
3
Departamento de Engenharia e Gest˜ ao Industrial, Escola Superior de Tecnologia de Abrantes, Instituto Polit´ecnico de Tomar, Rua de 17 de Agosto de 1808, 2200-370 Abrantes, Portugal,
[email protected] Departamento de Engenharia Mecˆ anica, Departamento de Engenharia Mecˆ anica, Escola de Engenharia da Universidade do Minho, Campus de Azur´em, 4800-058 Guimar˜ aes, Portugal,
[email protected] CEMUC – Centro de Engenharia Mecˆ anica da Universidade de Coimbra, Departamento de Engenharia Mecˆ anica, Universidade de Coimbra, Polo II, Pinhal de Marrocos, 3030-201 Coimbra, Portugal,
[email protected],
[email protected]
Summary. The lack of accuracy of numerical results is still nowadays one of the main drawbacks of sheet metal forming process simulation. One of the main reasons for such a lack of accuracy is the constitutive models used to describe the real material’s mechanical behavior. The most widely used phenomenological constitutive model is based on the classical Hill 1948 yield criterion. In the last decade several new yield criteria have been proposed, with the constraint that a parameter identification procedure has not always been clearly set. This study presents a general approach to optimize anisotropic plastic description. A weight-based optimization procedure is presented in order to perform the optimization of several constitutive models based on experimental results. Using this procedure is expected to improve the plastic description with a global optimum solution.
Key words: plasticity, yield function, anisotropy, hardening, genetic algorithms.
1 Introduction The numerical simulation of sheet metal forming processes is particularly sensitive to the numerical modelling of the elastoplastic behaviour of the metallic sheets used in these sorts of processes. It is nowadays accepted that the numerical results of either the thickness reduction or the springback phenomena, among others, are particularly sensitive to the constitutive models
36
Advanced Methods in Material Forming
(Thuiller et al., 2002), (Chaparro et al., 2004). In recent decades, to overcome such difficulties, several new yield criteria have been proposed in the literature, in order to improve the description of the plastic behaviour of the metallic sheets (Barlat et al., 1991), (Karafillis et al., 1993), (Cazacu et al., 2001), (Bron et al., 2004), (Cazacu et al., 2004). In fact, enhanced constitutive models including a high number of parameters are needed to improve the accuracy of sheet metal anisotropy description. However, when the number of constitutive parameters increases, the amount and type of experimental tests necessary for their identification also increases. In this case, the parameter identification procedure for each material becomes highly complex and often the results can be inconsistent. The aim of this study is to present a new identification procedure, which allows the material parameters to be identified automatically based on a minimum error functional approach. To minimize the error functional, a methodology based on a hybrid algorithm is used. The new tool, named DD3MAT, was developed to automatically carry out the identification of the full set of material parameters for several enhanced constitutive models, based on an adequate set of experimental results. In the future, this code will be integrated in the main finite element code DD3IMP, (Menezes et al., 2000), which is dedicated to the numerical simulation of the sheet metal forming processes and has been continuously developed at CEMUC (“Centro de Engenharia Mecˆanica da Universidade de Coimbra”).
2 Plastic Behaviour Description Phenomenological models are usually used to describe the anisotropic behaviour of sheet metals. For each of the so-called yield criteria or yield functions, which describe the yield locus and thus the plastic behaviour, and for each material, it is necessary to determine the ‘right’ set of values of material parameters. In this study the identification methodology consists of a best fit procedure between each yield function and the full set of available experimental results (tensile tests, simple shear tests, biaxial tests, etc.). The parameters of the yield criteria proposed by (Hill, 1948), (Barlat et al., 1991), (Karafillis et al., 1993) and one of the two models proposed by (Cazacu et al., 2001) can be identified by the methodology proposed here. The work-hardening behaviour is described by the Swift law, (Swift et al., 1952). In this study, only the results concerning the isotropic work-hardening are presented. However, the same approach can be easily widened to the identification of the kinematic hardening law’s parameters. 2.1 Anisotropic Yield Surfaces A yield function is generally described by the equation, F = K − Y = 0,
Phenomenological Constitutive Models Parameters Optimization
37
where Y is the flow stress, whose evolution is given by a work-hardening law, and K is the equivalent stress computed from the expression of the selected yield criterion. To describe K, and so the anisotropic plastic response of the rolled metallic sheets, several orthotropic yield criteria proposed in the literature were implemented in both DD3IMP and DD3MAT codes, which are briefly reviewed in the next sections. Hill, 1948 The Hill 1948 yield criterion is a generalization of the von Mises’s distortional energy criterion to orthotropy, (Mises, 1913). The yield function is expressed by the quadratic function, (Hill, 1950): 2
2
2
F (σyy − σzz ) + G (σzz − σxx ) + H (σxx − σyy ) + 2Lτyz2 +2M τzx2 +, +2N τxy2 = K 2
(1)
where σxx , σyy , σzz , τxy , τxz and τyz , are the components of the Cauchy stress tensor defined in the orthotropic frame and F , G, H, L, M and N are the Hill coefficients that define the anisotropy. Barlat, 1991 (YLD91) (Barlat et al., 1991) proposed an extension to orthotropy of the isotropic yield criterion proposed by (Hersey, 1954) and (Hosford, 1972). This criterion, usually referred as YLD91, can be expressed by the following non-quadratic function: m
m
m
|S1 − S2 | + |S1 − S3 | + |S2 − S3 |
= 2K m ,
(2)
where S1 , S2 and S3 are the principal values of the Isotropic Plasticity Equivalent (IPE) stress state, defined by the stress tensor s = L : σ which is obtained from the linear transformation L applied to the Cauchy stress tensor σ. The new IPE stress state can be introduced directly in any of the proposed isotropic yield criteria, since the anisotropy is modelled by the linear transformation L. In case of YLD91 yield criterion, the isotropic yield criterion proposed by (Hosford, 1972) is used. The exponent m characterizes the shape of the yield surface and depends on the material. From (Logan et al., 1980), m is 6 and 8, for BCC and FCC materials, respectively. The material parameters to be identified are the components of the linear transformation L. Karafillis & Boyce, 1993 (KB93) The yield criterion proposed by (Karafillis et al., 1993) is an extension of the Yld91 yield criterion, using the same linear transformation L. This criterion
38
Advanced Methods in Material Forming
considers two different isotropic yield functions, ϕ1 and ϕ2 , and a weighting factor c ∈ [0, 1]: 32k ϕ = (1 − c) ϕ1 + k−1 (3) = 2k 2k +1 2 ϕ1 is the isotropic yield function proposed by (Hosford et al., 1972), 2k
ϕ1 = (S1 − S2 )
2k
+ (S2 − S3 )
2k
+ (S3 − S1 )
,
(4)
where S1 , S2 and S3 are the principal values of the isotropic plasticity equivalent stress tensor and k is a material constant, and ϕ2 is the isotropic yield function given by: 2k 2k 2k (5) ϕ2 = |S1 | + |S2 | + |S3 | . The linear transformation can be expressed by: s = L : σ,
(6)
where s is the deviatoric stress tensor defined in the “isotropic plasticity equivalent” stress space, L is the linear transformation tensor and σ is the Cauchy stress tensor. The linear transformation operator can be expressed as: ⎤ ⎡ −c2 /3 0 0 0 (c2 + c3 ) /3 −c3 /3 ⎢ −c3 /3 (c3 + c1 ) /3 −c1 /3 0 0 0⎥ ⎥ ⎢ ⎢ −c2 /3 −c /3 (c + c ) /3 0 0 0⎥ 1 1 2 ⎥, ⎢ (7) L=⎢ 0 0 0 c4 0 0 ⎥ ⎥ ⎢ ⎣ 0 0 0 0 c5 0 ⎦ 0 0 0 0 0 c6 where c1 , c2 , c3 , c4 , c5 and c6 are the parameters of anisotropy. The unknown parameters for this model are the parameters of the linear transformation and the weighting factor c. k can be a parameter to identify, but (Karafillis et al., 1993), proposed for this parameter a high value. In this study k is considered equal to 15. Adaptation of Drucker for Anisotropy, DL 2001 This criterion, proposed by (Cazacu et al., 2001), is an extension of Drucker’s isotropic yield criterion (Drucker et al., 1949) to orthotropy using the previously given linear transformation L. The extension of Drucker’s yield criterion to orthotropy using the linear transformation approach is given by: 3 2 6 1 2 1 3 K tr s − c tr s = 27 , (8) 2 3 3 where tr (s) is the trace of the stress tensor s obtained after the linear transformation, and c is an additional material parameter. The parameters of the linear transformation and the weighting constant c are the parameters to be identified.
Phenomenological Constitutive Models Parameters Optimization
39
2.2 Work Hardening For simplicity, only the isotropic work-hardening will be taken into account in this study. For steels, the most commonly used law to describe the isotropic work-hardening is the power law proposed by (Swift et al., 1952), which is most suitable for describing the mechanical behaviour of all materials that do not present saturation behaviour, such as the majority of steels. The Swift law is expressed by: n σ = C (ε0 + εp ) , (9) where C, ε0 e n are material parameters, and εp is the equivalent plastic strain.
3 Material Parameter Identification The proposed material parameter identification procedure is basically a best fit operation in order to minimize the comparative errors between numerical results, obtained from the constitutive equations (yield criterion and work hardening law), and the available experimental data. A possible way to determine the material’s yield criteria parameters is to adopt some kind of minimization strategy involving the corresponding equation [(1), (2), (3) or (8)] and its derivatives (to evaluate the r-values) for some well defined strain paths. On the other hand, to identify the material’s work-hardening parameters, an analogous strategy can be followed involving (9). If only the isotropic work-hardening is taken into account, the optimization procedure can be carried out independently: first the material parameters related to the anisotropic behaviour are identified and, then, the material parameter identification of the isotropic work-hardening law is performed. The number and type of experimental results needed for the above-mentioned parameter identification procedure is a function of the used constitutive model. In fact, if the number of experimental values is equal to the number of unknowns, the problem can be solved using a set of equations. However, if the number of experimental values is larger than the number of unknowns, the problem becomes an optimization problem, and several numerical algorithms can be adopted to solve it. In this study a population based (evolutionary-genetic) approach is adopted in order to solve the optimization problem, which is combined with a direct search method. The proposed scheme consists of a hybrid optimizer: a genetic algorithm (Holland, 1975), (Furukawa et al., 1995), (Pal et al., 1996), (Furukawa et al., 2002), (Feng et al., 2004) for the definition of the population based algorithm, and the Powell algorithm (Powel, 1964) as a direct search method. It must be noted that the best optimization procedure is strongly linked to the characteristics of both the problem and the population. The optimisation problem under study is strongly non-linear and presents several local minima. Even if it is possible to use gradient based algorithms, the
40
Advanced Methods in Material Forming
results depend on the user skills, and additional stochastic mechanisms are needed to lead with the local minima. The proposed algorithm is expensive in terms of CPU time, but it presents the advantage of being user-independent. The choice of a direct search method associated with the genetic algorithm is related to the sub-optimal solution associated with the genetic algorithms.
3.1 Yield Criteria Parameters Identification A very effective strategy for the identification of yield criteria parameters is the definition of an error function (objective function), used in the optimization procedure. In this study, the error function is based in the summation of the squares of the errors defined from a comparison between the results obtained from the constitutive equations for a given set of parameters to be identified and the corresponding experimental values. Such procedure can be considered a generalization of the optimization procedure proposed by (Banabic et al., 2002), (Banabic et al., 2005). The proposed error function also includes some weighting factors which can be different for each kind of experimental test (and thus for each kind of strain path). The proposed expression is: 2 2 2 σα στ β σb − 1 + w − 1 + w − 1 2 3 σα exp σb exp στ β exp 2 2 rb rα + w4 − 1 + w − 1 , 5 rα exp rb exp (10)
erroranis =w1
where σα exp and rα exp are the experimental yield stress and r-values, respectively, obtained from the uniaxial tensile tests for a specific orientation (α) with RD, σb exp is the experimental yield stress obtained from the equibiaxial tensile test, στ β exp is the experimental yield stress under simple shear for a specific angle (β) with RD, rb exp is the experimental r-value obtained from the equibiaxial tensile tests (or from a compression test normal to the sheet plane) and σα , σb , στ β , rα and rb are the correspondent values but predicted from the constitutive equations. wi (i = 1, .., 5) are weighting factors.
3.2 Work Hardening Parameters Identification The identification of the work hardening parameters can be performed using several experimental strain paths. In this study, the optimization procedure is carried out using the equivalent values. Such “equivalent values” are computed from the experimental data and from the definition of the stress states associated with each experimental strain path, using the formulations of the chosen yield criterion, whose parameters must already be identified. The
Phenomenological Constitutive Models Parameters Optimization
41
stress states associated with each experimental strain path are converted into the equivalent values, which are used in the proposed quadratic error function: 2 nα (i) u σαj 1 errorhard = w1 exp − 1 n (i) j=1 σαj i=1 α 2 nb (k) σbl 1 − 1 nb (k) σ bl exp k=1 l=1 2 nτ (m) w στ βn 1 +w3 −1 , n (m) n=1 στ βn exp m=1 τ
+w2
v
(11)
where u, v and w are the number of experimental values obtained from the uniaxial tensile tests, equibiaxial tensile test and simple shear tests, respectively, nα (i) (for i = 1, .., u) is the number of experimental points for a specific experimental tensile test, nb (k) (for k = 1, .., v) is the number of experimental points for a specific experimental equibiaxial tensile test, nτ (m) (for m = 1, .., w) is the number of experimental points for a specific experimental exp simple shear test, σαj is the equivalent stress value for the point j obtained exp is the equivalent stress for the point l obtained in in the i tensile test, σbl exp is the equivalent stress for the point the k equibiaxial tensile test and στ βn n obtained in the m simple shear test. σαj , σbl and στ βn denote the values computed from the work hardening law for the correspondent experimental point.
4 Optimization Algorithm The material parameter identification problem can be considered an inverse optimization problem. This study makes use of a hybrid algorithm for the identification of constitutive model parameters. The choice of the hybrid algorithm is based on the properties of the optimization problem. The evolutionary algorithm presents the robustness needed for dealing with local minima, but the solution is a sub-optimal solution. As the genetic algorithm doesn’t involve the formulation of derivatives, a direct search method was chosen to perform the local optimization, which avoids also the computation of the derivatives of the functions involved in the formulation of the problem.
4.1 Evolutionary Algorithm – Genetic Algorithm The Genetic Algorithm (GA) is a selective random search algorithm to achieve a global optimum within a large space of solutions proposed by Holland (Holland, 1975). The genetic algorithm is a population based scheme algorithm
42
Advanced Methods in Material Forming variable a solution (individual)
solutions (population)
1 1 0 0 1
1 0 0 1 0
0 1 0 1 0
0 0 1 1 0
0 0 0 0 1
1 1 0 1 1
1 0 1 0 0
1 0 1 1 1
0 0 0 1 0
0 0 0 1 1
0
1
0
1
1
1
1
0
1
0
1
1
1
position (locus)
(…) 1
0
number of genes
0
1
0
1
0
gene (gene) chromosome (chromosome)
Fig. 1. Biological – genetic algorithm analogies
analogous to natural selection in biological systems. Figure 1 highlights the genetic – biological systems notation analogies. It is possible to see, in Fig. 1, a set of solutions that in biological systems can be considered analogous with the population. Each solution, which in the biological systems is an individual, has a set of genes (genes in biological systems). The position of a given gene is identified with the locus in genetic and in biological systems. In the numerical application of a genetic algorithm, each solution has a number of genes needed to obtain the solution characteristics, as in biological systems each individual has a number of fixed genes that determine their biological characteristics. From the set of genes of a solution it is possible to calculate a value for the objective function. This value is known as ‘fitness function’ and measures the robustness of the solution. The number of genes needed to keep the solution characteristics is related, in our optimization problem, with the number of variables of the models and the accuracy for each variable, with var maxi −var mini nbitsi = ints logc +1 , (12) pri where nbitsi is the number of bits needed, pri the precision required for the variable i, ints () the superior integer of the argument, c the cardinality of the codification, var maxi and var mini the minimum and maximum values for variable i, respectively. For example, if a three variables function is the fitness function (as in case of the Swift model), a solution is obtained from the three variables genes. On the other hand, if for variable a the required accuracy is 0.01, with a ∈ [0, 1], using binary codification the expression (12) gives 7 as the minimum number of bits needed to obtain the required accuracy. The used evolutionary algorithm scheme is presented in Fig. 2. For starting the iterative process of the genetic algorithm an initial population is needed. The initial population is usually randomly generated, but it is possible to insert a ‘good’ initial population, if known, in an operation known as a seeding process.
Phenomenological Constitutive Models Parameters Optimization Evolutionary Algorithm
Initial Population Population random generator
Seeding
Cycle Optimization Cycle
Decoding
Evaluation of the fitness function
Selection
Crossover
Mutation
N
Elitism S Test Stop Condition
Fig. 2. Genetic Algorithm
43
44
Advanced Methods in Material Forming
In the iterative process, the population is coded using an alphabetic code, and so a decoding procedure is necessary in order to identify its value. In the present case, the value of each variable is not coded, and as alternative the index array of each variable is used. The variable arrays are created before the iterative procedure and have all possible values of each variable. This is done because computationally it is very efficient to decode integer variables. Then, for all the intermediate solutions, the fitness of each solution is calculated using [10] and [11], for the optimization of the yield criterion and work hardening parameters, respectively. The minimization-based technique is applied to the current population in order to select the parents for the definition of the subsequent population (and next iteration). In this study the selection process is stochastic, the members being chosen for the matting pool using a fitness based roulette. The next generation is obtained combining the solutions in the mating pool. The one point crossover scheme is used. In order to assure genetic diversity, a mutation operator is used. The mutation operator consists of modifying a gene value. This is set to a low probability, less than 5%, in order not to perturb the convergence. It is possible to maintain some members of the population, in order to increase the influence of the best solution in the overall population, what is called as elitism strategy. If an elitism strategy is used, the number of solutions needed in the mating pool is the population less the number of solutions that go directly to the next generation. The algorithm presented in Fig. 2 is repeated until the end condition is reached. The influence of each mechanism presented in the convergence and quality of the solution is object of many theoretical and empirical studies (Grefenstette, 1986), (De Jong, 1987), (Goldberg, 1989), (David, 1991), (Koza, 1992), (Back, 1996) beyond the scope of this study. Many of the above studies point out that genetic algorithms works well for a large range of the principal probability parameters. 4.2 Hybrid Algorithm The GA is a sub-optimal solution technique; to find the optimal solution an additional search algorithm is needed. The local minimum search algorithm used is based on the Powel algorithm (Powel, 1964). This algorithm basically applies perturbations to the genetic algorithm’s best solutions, using the variable GA arrays, Fig. 3. The best solution of the GA works as starting point for this local minimum optimizer. The variable perturbation is done at a random variable and in a random direction, if the fitness function decreases. The perturbation is done until the fitness function increases. If for the initial random direction the fitness function doesn’t decrease, other direction is tried. This is done until the perturbation doesn’t involve lower fitness functions for all variables.
Phenomenological Constitutive Models Parameters Optimization Hybrid Algorithm
Evolutionary Algorithm
GA
Variable random selection
Sign random selection
Variable perturbation Evaluation of the fitness function FT is better
N
S Change of actualization sign
Variable actualization Evaluation of the fitness function FT is better
N
S
N
FF function unchanged
S
Fig. 3. Hybrid optimization algorithm
45
46
Advanced Methods in Material Forming
5 DC06 Steel Parameters Identification In order to test the proposed methodology, the material parameter identification for 1 mm thick DC06 steel is presented. This steel was characterized in the framework of 3DS European Project. For this identification typical values were used for the probably of crossover and mutation, 75% and 5% respectively. For the yield criterion parameter identification, the population has 100 solutions and 500 iterations were performed. For the work hardening law parameter identification the population has 70 solutions and 120 iterations were made. When experimental data was not available for the identification of some specific parameters, the isotropic values were assumed. 5.1 Yield Parameter Identification The yield criterion parameter identification was carried out for the constitutive models described in Sect. 2. In order to understand the models’ behaviour, three conditions were used to identify the anisotropy parameters: using only the r-values (Condition A); using the r-values and the initial yield stress (Condition B); and using the r-values and the average of the σα /σ0 values during deformation (0-34% true plastic strain) (Condition C). Table 1 shows the values used for the anisotropic model parameter identification. The initial yield stress for the RD direction is 123.6 MPa. Tables 2, 3 and 4 present the parameters found for the three identifications Conditions, A, B and C, respectively. Figure 4 presents the variation of the r-values in the plane of the sheet. The figure shows the experimental data points (EXP) and the results obtained with the Hill yield criterion with the parameters identified using the classical relationship between the Hill parameters and the r0 , r45 and r90 values (HILL48 r0 r45 r90). HILL48 3DS corresponds to the Hill yield criterion results obtained with the parameters delivered in the framework of 3DS European Project, using a gradient based optimisation algorithm (Bouvier et al., 2001). The HILL48, YLD91, KB93 and DL2001 criteria correspond to the results obtained with the parameters identified with the test procedure of Condition A. Table 1. Experimental data for the DC06 steel (1mm thickness) angle with RD [o ]
r-value
initial yield stress σα /σ0
average of σα /σ0
0 15 30 45 60 75 90
2.530 2.055 1.875 1.840 2.220 2.620 2.720
1.000 1.006 1.005 1.009 1.011 1.027 1.026
1.000 1.016 1.023 1.027 1.017 1.015 0.990
Phenomenological Constitutive Models Parameters Optimization
47
Table 2. Identified material parameters for the optimization tests Condition A HILL48 YLD91 KB93 DL2001
F 0.249 c1 0.818 c1 0.801 c1 0.772
G 0.301 c2 0.858 c2 0.841 c2 0.824
N 1.286 c3 1.127 c3 1.155 c3 1.201
c6 0.956 c6 0.965 c6 1.077
m 8 c 0.835 c 0.837
K 15
Table 3. Identified material parameters for the optimization tests Condition B HILL48 YLD91 KB93 DL2001
F 0.256 c1 0.846 c1 0.825 c1 0.777
G 0.305 c2 0.888 c2 0.866 c2 0.829
N 1.358 c3 1.163 c3 1.187 c3 1.209
c6 0.990 c6 0.995 c6 1.084
m 8 c 0.835 c 0.835
K 15
From Fig. 4 is possible to conclude that none of the presented yield criteria parameters could perfectly describe the in plane variation of the r-values. The YLD91 and the KB93 are almost coincident. The curve obtained from the classical relationship between the Hill parameters and the r-values (HILL48 r0 r45 r90) is the worst solution. Figure 5 shows the experimental and numerical yield stress points for the identification procedure of Condition A. The results obtained with the DL2001 yield criterion are quite close to the experimental data. On the contrary, all other yield criteria behave badly in the yield stress prediction. The Condition A procedure corresponds to the ‘usual’ set of data used to perform yield parameter identification. This procedure is suitable for identifying parameters that will be used in simulations where the accuracy of the ‘strain’ distribution is a major factor as in the prediction of the draw-in, blank dimensions or thickness reduction. However, when the accuracy Table 4. Identified material yield parameters for the optimization tests Condition C HILL48 YLD91 KB93 DL2001
F 0.256 c1 0.839 c1 0.814 c1 0.771
G 0.304 c2 0.879 c2 0.854 c2 0.822
N 1.343 c3 1.153 c3 1.173 c3 1.201
c6 0.980 c6 0.981 c6 1.073
m 8 c 0.835 c 0.837
K 15
48
Advanced Methods in Material Forming 3.00 2.75 EXP HILL48 YLD91 KB93 DL2001 HILL48 r0 r45 r90 HILL48 3DS
r value
2.50 2.25 2.00 1.75 1.50 0
15
30
45
60
75
90
Angle with RD [º]
Fig. 4. Distribution of r-ratios in the sheet plane for the optimization tests of condition A
of the final stress state is mandatory, as for example in springback or wrinkle prediction, the Conditions B or C procedure is preferable once the yield stress experimental data for parameter identification is taken into account. The variation of the r-values and the yield stress in the plane of the sheet, as obtained with the sets of parameters delivered with the optimisation procedures Conditions B and C, is very close to the results presented in Figs. 4
1.20
Equiv. Stress [Ya/Y0]
1.15
EXP HILL48 YLD91 KB93 DL2001 HILL48 r0 r45 r90 HILL48 3DS
1.10
1.05
1.00
0.95
0
15
30 60 45 Angle with RD [º]
75
90
Fig. 5. Distribution of yield stress in the sheet plane for the optimization tests of condition A
Phenomenological Constitutive Models Parameters Optimization
49
Table 5. Average errors for each experimental point obtained for all yield parameter identification conditions
HILL48 YLD91 KB93 DL2001 HILL48 3DS HILL48 r0 r45 r90
Condition A
Condition B
Condition C
0.189 0.191 0.199 0.188 0.199 0.396
0.304 0.146 0.154 0.108 0.346 0.461
0.236 0.124 0.130 0.123 0.262 0.370
and 5. To emphasize the differences between the three procedures of optimization, it is preferable to analyse the average error (10) obtained with the various sets of parameters. Table 5 presents the average error obtained with the optimization Conditions A, B and C for all the models. The table shows also the average error obtained with the set of parameters identified with the classical relationship between the Hill parameters and the r-values (HILL48 r0 r45 r90) and with the parameters delivered in the framework of 3DS European Project (HILL48 3DS). For all identification procedures the larger error is less than 0.5% and is obtained with the parameters of the set HILL48 r0 r45 r90. The yield criterion that presents the lowest error is the Drucker corrected to orthotropy (Cazacu et al., 2001). The code DD3MAT delivers a Hill48 set of parameters close to the Hill48 3DS result. It is clear from the above data that the proposed hybrid optimization algorithm behaves quite well in the identification of yield criteria parameters. It also, by considering in the optimisation procedure both r-ratio and yield stress experimental data, improves the description of the
Equiv. Stress [MPa]
500 400 300 200 100 0 0.0
Exp 0° Exp 30° Exp 60° Exp 90°
0.1
0.2 Equiv. Strain
0.3
0.4
Exp 15° Exp 45° Exp 75° DD3MAT Hill Swift
Fig. 6. Equivalent stress-strain curves obtained with Hill48 yield criterion, identified with Condition A, for tensile and shear test at 0, 15, 30, 45, 60, 75 and 90◦ with RD direction
50
Advanced Methods in Material Forming Equiv. Stress [MPa]
500 400 300 200 100 0 0.0
0.1
0.2 Equiv. Strain
Exp 0° Exp 30° Exp 60° Exp 90°
0.3
0.4
Exp 15° Exp 45° Exp 75° DD3MAT YLD91 Swift
Fig. 7. Equivalent stress-strain curves obtained with YLD91 yield criterion, identified with Condition A, for tensile and shear test at 0, 15, 30, 45, 60, 75 and 90◦ with RD direction
material behaviour: the yield stress predictions are clearly improved with low influence on the r-ratio. 5.2 Work Hardening Parameter Identification The work hardening material parameter identification made use of all the experimental data available, i.e. seven tensile tests and seven shear tests oriented at 0, 15, 30, 45, 60, 75 and 90◦ with the RD direction. Figures 6, 7, 8 and 9 shows the equivalent stress/strain curves for all the seven directions with RD,
Equiv. Stress [MPa]
500 400 300 200 100 0 0.0
0.1
0.2
0.3
0.4
Equiv. Strain Exp 0° Exp 30° Exp 60° Exp 90°
Exp 15° Exp 45° Exp 75° DD3MAT KB93 Swift
Fig. 8. Equivalent stress-strain curves obtained with KB93 yield criterion, identified with Condition A, for tensile and shear test at 0, 15, 30, 45, 60, 75 and 90◦ with RD direction
Phenomenological Constitutive Models Parameters Optimization
51
Equiv. Stress [MPa]
500 400 300 200 100 0 0.0
0.1
0.2 Equiv. Strain
Exp 0° Exp 30° Exp 60° Exp 90°
0.3
0.4
Exp 15° Exp 45° Exp 75° DD3MAT DL Swift
Fig. 9. Equivalent stress-strain curves obtained with DL2001 yield criterion, identified with Condition A, for tensile and shear test at 0, 15, 30, 45, 60, 75 and 90◦ with RD direction
obtained with the HILL48, YLD91, KB93 and DL2001 criteria, respectively. The yield criteria parameters used in this case were identified with Condition A procedure. The identified parameters are shown in Tables 6, 7 and 8. In general, the work hardening material parameter identification could be performed using just the stress-strain curve obtained in tension for 0◦ with the RD direction, if the anisotropy can be well described with the yield criterion. In the present case, DC06 material, this is not true as can be seen in Table 6. Hardening parameters for the Swift model obtained for all the yield stress models identified with Condition A model
Y0 [MPa]
C [MPa]
n
error [%]
HILL48 YLD91 KB93 DL2001
123.6 123.6 123.6 123.6
525.6 546.1 551.0 552.1
0.308 0.304 0.303 0.299
0.271 0.163 0.183 0.111
Table 7. Hardening parameters for the Voce model obtained for all the yield stress models identified with Condition B model
Y0 [MPa]
C [MPa]
n
error [%]
HILL48 YLD91 KB93 DL2001
123.6 123.6 123.6 123.6
530.2 562.5 565.9 555.7
0.306 0.300 0.301 0.299
0.195 0.147 0.169 0.109
52
Advanced Methods in Material Forming
Table 8. Hardening parameters for the Voce model obtained for all the yield stress models identified with Condition C model
Y0 [MPa]
C [MPa]
n
error [%]
HILL48 YLD91 KB93 DL2001
123.6 123.6 123.6 123.6
529.1 558.2 559.2 551.6
0.306 0.301 0.302 0.300
0.209 0.152 0.176 0.109
Figs. 4 to 9. The identification can also be done using an isotropic criterion, such as the Von Mises criterion, but this procedure does not consider the anisotropy in stress. In order to overcome these difficulties, it is preferable to perform the material parameter identification for the work hardening using all the available experimental data and considering the anisotropic criterion identification that will be used later in the numerical simulation of the sheet metal forming process.
6 Conclusions This study presents and discusses the material parameter identification procedures for the yield criterion and the work hardening law. An automatic tool for parameter identification has been developed based on a Hybrid algorithm. The proposed tool was applied to identify the material parameters of deepdrawing DC06 steel. The material parameter identification was performed for several yield criteria and using several identification conditions. The plastic behaviour description presents lower error if a global optimization is performed instead of the traditional r-value based procedure. The best solution for the work hardening identification considers all the available experimental data and the chosen anisotropic criterion identification. The proposed identification technique, easy to be used, presents efficient and robust performance.
Acknowledgements The author’s are indebted to the Portuguese Foundation for Science and Technology – FCT for financial support through the POCTI program.
References Barlat F., Lege D.J., Brem J.C., “A six-component yield function for anisotropic materials”, International Journal of Plasticity, Vol. 7, 1991, p. 693–712. Bron F., Besson J.A., “Yield function for anisotropic materials: Aplication to aluminium alloys”, International Journal of Plasticity, Vol. 20, 2004, p. 937–963.
Phenomenological Constitutive Models Parameters Optimization
53
Banabic D., Cazacu O., Barlat F., Comsa D.S., Wagner S., Siegert K., “Description of anisotropic behaviour of AA3103-O aluminium alloy using two recent yield criteria”, Proceedings of 6th European Mechanics of Materials Conference, Ed. S. Cescotto, 2002, p. 265–272. Banabic D., Arets H., Comsa D.S., Paraianu L., “An improved analytical description of orthotropy in metallic sheets”, International Journal of Plasticity, Vol. 21, 2005, p. 493–512. Back T., Evolutionary algorithms in theory and in practice: evolutionary strategies evolutionary programming, genetic algorithms, Oxford University Press, 1996. Bouvier S., Teodosiu C., ”Selection and identification of elastoplastic models for the materials used in the benchmarks”, Project Digital Die Design (3DS) Progress Report, Laboratoire des Propri´et´es M´ecaniques et Thermodynamiques des Mat´eriaux (LPMTM) – CNRS, University of Paris Nord, France, 2001. Cazacu O., Barlat F., “Generalization of Drucker’s yield criterion to orthotropy”, Mathematics and Physics of Solids, Vol. 6, 2001, p. 613–630. Cazacu O., Barlat F., “A criterion for description of anisotropy yield differential effects in pressure-insensitive metals”, International Journal of Plasticity, Vol. 20, 2004, p. 2047–2045. Chaparro B.M., Oliveira M.C., Alves J.L., Menezes L.F., “Work hardening models and the numerical simulation of the deep drawing process”, Materials Science Forum, Vols. 455–456, 2004, p. 717–722. Drucker D.C., “Relation of experiments to mathematical theories of plasticity”, Journal of Applied Mechanics, Vol. 16, 1949, p. 349–357. De Jong K. A., “On using genetic algorithm to search program spaces”, Proceeding of 2nd International Conference on Genetic algorithm and Their Applications, Hillsdale, Ed. Lawrence Erlbaum, 1987, p. 210–216. Davis L. D., The handbook of genetic algorithms, Van Nostrand Reinhold, 1991. Feng, X.T., Yang, C., “Coupling recognition of the structure and parameters of non-linear constitutive material models using hybrid evolutionary algorithms”, International Journal for Numerical Methods in Engineering, Vol. 59, 2004, p. 1227–1250. Furukawa T., Yagawa G., “Parameter identification of inelastic constitutive equations using an evolutionary algorithm with constitutive individuals”, Proceedings ASME/JSME PVPC Conference, Vol. 305, 1995, p. 437–444. Furukawa T., Sugata T., Yoshimura S., Hoffman M., “An automated system for simulation and parameter identification of inelastic constitutive models”, Computer Methods in Applied Mechanics and Engineering, Vol. 191, 2002, p. 2235–2260. Grefenstette J.J., “Optimization of control parameters for genetic algorithms”, IEEE Transactions, Vol. SMC-16, 1986, p. 122–128. Goldberg D. E., Genetic algorithms in search, optimization and machine learning, Addison-Wesley, 1989. Hill R., “A theory of the yielding and plastic flow of anisotropic metals”, Proceedings of Mathematical, Physical and Engineering Science, Royal Society London, Vol. A193, 1948, p. 281–297. Hill R., The mathematical theory of plasticity, Oxford, Clarendon Press, 1950. Hersey A.V., “The plasticity of an isotropic aggregate face centered cubic crystals”, Journal of Applied Mechanical Transactions ASME, Vol. 21, 1954, p. 241–249. Hosford W.F., “A generalized isotropic yield criterion”, Journal of Applied Mechanics, Vol. 39, 1972, p. 607–609.
54
Advanced Methods in Material Forming
Holland J.H., Adaptation in neural and artificial systems, Ann Arbor, University of Michigan Press, 1975. Karafillis A.P., Boyce M.C., “A general anisotropic yield criterion using bounds and a transformation weighting tensor”, Journal of the Mechanics of Physics of Solids, Vol. 41, 1993, p. 1859–1886. Koza J. R., Genetic programming: on the programming of computers by means of natural selection, MIT press, 1992. Logan R.W., Hosford W.F., “Upper-bound anisotropic yield locus calculations assuming (111)-pencil glide”, International Journal of Mechanical Sciences, Vol. 22, 1980, p. 419–430. Menezes L.F., Teodosiu C., “Thee-dimensional numerical simulation of deepdrawing process using solid finite elements”, Journal of Material Processing Technology, Vol. 97, 2000, p. 100–106. Mises R., “Mechanik der festen korper im plastic-deformablen zustand“, Nachrichten vos der koniglichen gellesschaft des winssenschaften zu Gottingen, Mathematisch-physikalische klasse, 1913, p. 582–592. Pal S., Wathugala G.W., Kundu S., “Calibration of a constitutive model using genetic algorithms”, Computer and Geotechnics, Vol. 19, 1996, p. 325–348. Powel M.J.D., “An efficient method for finding the minimum of a function of several variables without calculating derivatives”, Computational Journal, Vol. 7, 1964, p. 155–162. Swift H.W., “Plastic instability under plane stress”, Journal of the Mechanics of Physics of Solids, Vol. 1, 1952, p. 1–18. Thuiller S., Manach P.Y., Menezes L.F., Oliveira M.C., “Experimental and numerical study of reverse re-drawing of anisotropic sheet metals”, Journal of Materials Processing Technology, Vol. 125–126, 2002, p. 764–771.
A Metamodel Based Optimisation Algorithm for Metal Forming Processes M.H.A. Bonte, A.H. van den Boogaard and J. Hu´etink University of Twente, Faculty of Engineering Technology, P.O. Box 217, 7500 AE Enschede, The Netherlands,
[email protected];
[email protected];
[email protected] Summary. Cost saving and product improvement have always been important goals in the metal forming industry. To achieve these goals, metal forming processes need to be optimised. During the last decades, simulation software based on the Finite Element Method (FEM) has significantly contributed to designing feasible processes more easily. More recently, the possibility of coupling FEM to mathematical optimisation algorithms is offering a very promising opportunity to design optimal metal forming processes instead of only feasible ones. However, which optimisation algorithm to use is still not clear. In this paper, an optimisation algorithm based on metamodelling techniques is proposed for optimising metal forming processes. The algorithm incorporates nonlinear FEM simulations which can be very time consuming to execute. As an illustration of its capabilities, the proposed algorithm is applied to optimise the internal pressure and axial feeding load paths of a hydroforming process. The product formed by the optimised process outperforms products produced by other, arbitrarily selected load paths. These results indicate the high potential of the proposed algorithm for optimising metal forming processes using time consuming FEM simulations.
Key words: optimisation, metal forming, finite element method, metamodelling, hydroforming.
1 Introduction During the last decades, Finite Element (FEM) simulations of metal forming processes have become important tools for designing feasible production processes. In more recent years, several authors recognised the potential of coupling FEM simulations to mathematical optimisation algorithms to design optimal metal forming processes instead of only feasible ones. The basic concept of mathematical optimisation is presented in Fig. 1. Basically, it consists of two major phases: the modelling and the solving of the optimisation problem. The modelling phase consists of:
56
Advanced Methods in Material Forming
1. Selecting a number of design variables the user is allowed to adapt 2. Choosing an objective function, i.e. the optimisation aim 3. Taking into account possible constraints These three items are closely related to each other as depicted in Fig. 1. Both the objective function and the constraints should be quantified by the design variables. The objective function and constraints are also related to each other in the sense that they are often exchangeable. Consider for example that we would like to make a metal formed product and two relevant properties are the product quality and the costs. Then two approaches can be followed: either the quality is maximised while putting a certain limit on the allowed production costs, or the costs could be minimised while ensuring a certain minimum level of the product quality. In the former case, the quality is clearly the optimisation objective and the costs are constraints, whereas it is just the other way around in the latter case. Next to the modelling phase, mathematical optimisation’s second phase is solving the optimisation problem. This comprises applying an optimisation algorithm to the modelled optimisation problem. The arrows between the modelling and the solving parts in Fig. 1 denote that both phases cannot be seen separately from each other. One should select the right optimisation algorithm for a certain modelled optimisation problem and one should model the optimisation problem cleverly to adjust it to the optimisation algorithm one is planning to apply. If the optimisation model does not match the algorithm, it is likely that the optimisation problem is not solved efficiently or cannot be solved at all (Papalambros et al., 2000). This paper focuses on the solving part of optimisation problems in metal forming using time consuming nonlinear FEM simulations. One simulation can easily take hours or even days to execute. It is important to keep this fact in mind when selecting a suitable optimisation algorithm for metal forming processes. One way of optimising metal forming processes is using classical iterative optimisation algorithms (Conjugate gradient, BFGS, etc.), where each function evaluation means running a FEM calculation, see e.g. Kleinermann et al., (2003), Lin et al., (2003) and Naceur et al., (2001). As mentioned above, in case of metal forming these FEM calculations can be extremely time consuming and need to be sequentially evaluated. Furthermore, many classical algorithms require sensitivities, of which the efficient calculation is not straightforward
Fig. 1. The basic concept of mathematical optimisation: modelling and solving
Metamodel Based Algorithm for Metal Forming Processes
57
for FEM simulations. A third difficulty concerning iterative algorithms is the risk to be trapped in local optima. Alternatively, several authors have tried to overcome these disadvantages by applying genetic or evolutionary optimisation algorithms, see e.g. Castro et al., (2004), Fourment et al., (2005) and Schenk et al., (2004). Genetic and evolutionary algorithms look promising because of their tendency to find the global optimum and the possibility for parallel computing. However, the rather large number of function evaluations that is expected to be necessary using these algorithms is regarded as a serious drawback (Emmerich et al., 2002). Yet another way of optimisation in combination with expensive function evaluations is using approximate optimisation algorithms, of which Response Surface Methodology (RSM) is a well-known representative. RSM is based on fitting a low order polynomial metamodel through response points, which are obtained by running FEM calculations for carefully chosen design variable settings and finally optimising this metamodel (Myers and Montgomery, 2002). Metamodels are sometimes also referred to as Response Surface models or surrogate models. Allowing for parallel computing and lacking the necessity for sensitivities, RSM is appealing to many authors in the field of metal forming, see e.g. Jansson (2002), Jansson et al., (2005) Naceur et al., (2004). Although the practical effectiveness of RSM has been frequently demonstrated, statisticians claim that RSM, being developed for stochastic physical experiments, is theoretically not applicable to deterministic computer experiments such as FEM: running a simulation twice with exactly the same input will generally result in exactly the same answer. They propose the field of “Design and Analysis of Computer Experiments” or DACE instead (Sachs et al., 1989a, Sachs et al., 1989b, Santner et al., 2003). DACE is similar to RSM, but interpolates a metamodel through the response points. Allowing for no error at the response points, interpolation better suits the deterministic nature of computer experiments. However, DACE is rarely used for metal forming problems, probably due to its complex statistical nature and the lack of readily available software (Santner et al., 2003). In this paper an optimisation algorithm incorporating both RSM and DACE metamodelling techniques is proposed for metal forming. Section 2 introduces the basic concept of metamodelling and provides a more detailed description of RSM and DACE. The proposed optimisation algorithm is presented in Sect. 3 and the applicability to metal forming is demonstrated in Sect. 4 where it is applied to the optimisation of a hydroforming process. Conclusions are presented in Sect. 5.
2 Metamodelling The principle of metamodelling is presented in Fig. 2 (Kleijnen and Sargent, 2000). The basic idea is to evaluate a certain problem entity, in our case a metal forming process. This problem entity can be modelled by some sort of a simulation model. For metal forming, this simulation model is usually
58
Advanced Methods in Material Forming
Fig. 2. The principle of metamodelling
a nonlinear Finite Element Model (FEM). These nonlinear FEM calculations are very time consuming to evaluate. Therefore, a metamodel or a model from a model (Simpson et al., 2001) is made, which can be quickly evaluated. An accurate metamodel should be valid with respect to both the Finite Element Model and the metal forming process and if it is, it forms a very useful substitute for both the process and the FE model. Kleijnen and Sargent (2000) distinguish four goals that can be served by metamodelling: (i) Understanding the problem entity, (ii) Predicting values of the output or response variable, (iii) Optimisation and (iv) Verification and Validation of prior qualitative knowledge on the simulation model with respect to the problem entity. For the optimisation of metal forming processes, the primary interest lies in optimisation as a metamodelling goal. However, the other goals additionally come at no or low computational costs, which is seen as a major advantage of using metamodelling techniques for optimisation purposes. In the next sections, two metamodelling techniques, Response Surface Methodology and Design and Analysis of Computer Experiments or Kriging, are shortly introduced. Prior to fitting the metamodels, a Design Of Experiments (DOE) strategy carefully selects a number of design variable settings for which FEM simulations are being run. These simulations provide a number of response measurements. 2.1 Response Surface Methodology (RSM) Starting with RSM, the response measurements y are presented as the sum of a lower order polynomial metamodel and a random error term ε (Myers and Montgomery, 2002): y = Xβ + ε (1) where X is the design matrix containing the experimental design points and β are the regression coefficients obtained by least squares regression: ˆ = (XT X)−1 XT y β
(2)
Metamodel Based Algorithm for Metal Forming Processes
59
Although (1) seems to be a linear relation of the design variables, the design matrix X can also incorporate terms that are nonlinear with respect to the design variables. Equation 1 should, however, be linear with respect to the regression coefficients (Myers and Montgomery, 2002), which is clearly the case. The metamodel is ˆ y ˆ = Xβ (3) Four possible shapes are commonly applied. They are in ascending complexity: • • • •
linear linear + interaction pure quadratic or elliptic (full) quadratic
A second order RSM metamodel dependent on one design variable is shown in Figure 3(a). The cross marks represent the response measurements. 2.2 Design and Analysis of Computer Experiments (DACE) DACE was proposed by Sacks et al., (1989a), and (1989b) to fit metamodels using deterministic computer experiments. Kriging is used to interpolate between the response measurements. Using Kriging, the random error term ε in (1) is replaced by a Gaussian random function Z(x), which forces the metamodel to exactly go through the measurement points: y ˆ = Xβ + Z(x)
(4)
The first part of (4) covers the global trend of the metamodel. The Gaussian random function Z, which accounts for the local deviation of the data from the trend function, has zero mean, variance σ2z and covariance cov (Z(x1 ), Z(x2 )) = σ2z R (x1 − x2 )
(5)
where R is the correlation function and x1 and x2 are two locations, which are determined by the design variable settings at these locations. For the proposed algorithm, a Gaussian exponential correlation function is adopted: R(ϑ, x1 , x2 ) = exp−ϑ(x1 −x2 )
2
Fig. 3. Metamodels based on (a) RSM; (b) DACE
(6)
60
Advanced Methods in Material Forming
As opposed to other possibilities for the correlation function like e.g. cubic splines and ordinary exponential functions, see e.g. Koehler and Owen (1996), Lophaven et al., (2002a), (2002b), and Santner et al., (2003), Gaussian exponential functions are intuitively attractive because they are infinitely differentiable. Moreover, Gaussian exponential functions are frequently used in literature (Santner et al., 2003) and have been found to give accurate results (Lophaven et al., 2002a). Assume k design variables are present. Then the total correlation function R depends on the k one-dimensional correlation functions Rj as follows (Sacks et al., 1989a): k R (x1 − x2 ) = Rj (x1j − x2j ) (7) j=1
This implies that it is assumed that there is no relation between the different dimensions. Adopting the Gaussian correlation function introduced in (6), the total correlation function becomes: R (x1 − x2 ) =
k
exp−ϑj (x1j −x2j )
2
(8)
j=1
Thus, one ϑ is present for each design variable (each dimension). Figure 3(b) presents a Kriging interpolation metamodel, which is fitted through the same response measurements as the RSM metamodel in Fig. 3(a). Note the differences: the Kriging metamodel’s shape is more complex than the second order polynomial shape of the RSM metamodel. However, the Kriging metamodel interpolates through the response points, whereas the RSM metamodel allows for random error. As was stated in the introduction, it is argued whether allowing for random error is appropriate in case of deterministic computer experiments such as FEM.
3 A Metamodel Based Optimisation Algorithm for Metal Forming The proposed metamodel based optimisation algorithm for the optimisation of metal forming processes using time consuming FEM simulations is presented in Fig. 4. Several steps mentioned in the figure are explained in the Sects. 1 through 4. Section 5 contains a few words on the implementation of the algorithm. 3.1 Modelling The first step is to start with modelling the optimisation problem, i.e. quantifying objective function and constraints and selecting the design variables.
Metamodel Based Algorithm for Metal Forming Processes
61
Fig. 4. A metamodel based optimisation algorithm for metal forming processes
Regarding the constraints, a distinction is made between explicit and implicit constraints. To explain the difference, running a FEM simulation can be seen as an input-throughput-response model such as the one depicted in Fig. 5. Certain quantities are known beforehand: there is no necessity to run a FEM calculation for evaluating them. The design variables are clear examples of these quantities and there can also be constraints that explicitly depend on the design variables. These constraints are called explicit constraints. In case of metal forming explicit constraints are related to the undeformed product, e.g. constraints on the initial shape of a blank. Quantities that depend on the response require a FEM simulation for evaluating them: they implicitly depend on the design variables. The objective function is generally such an implicit quantity and it is also possible to have implicit constraints. For metal forming, implicit constraints are related to the deformed product, e.g. excessive thinning is not allowed to exceed a specified limit. It is stressed again that the modelling of an optimisation problem is formally not part of an optimisation algorithm: the algorithm is solely a mean for
Fig. 5. FEM as an input–throughput–response model
62
Advanced Methods in Material Forming
solving the optimisation model. Clever modelling and solving are both crucial for mathematically optimising a problem as was already emphasised in the introduction. 3.2 Design Of Experiments (DOE) When the optimisation problem has been modelled, Fig. 4 shows that the first step of the algorithm is to carefully select a number of design sites by a Design Of Experiments (DOE) strategy. A spacefilling Latin Hypercube Design (LHD) is a good and popular DOE strategy for constructing metamodels from deterministic computer experiments (McKay et al., 1979 and Santner et al., 2003) and has been selected for the optimisation of metal forming processes. However, when a metamodel is used for optimisation, it is important that the metamodel gives accurate results in the neighbourhood of the optimum. Often, this optimum will be constrained, i.e. lies on the boundary of the design space. Therefore, an accurate prediction is needed on the boundary, which implies performing measurements on that boundary. An LHD will generally provide design points in the interior of the design space and not on the boundary. To compensate for this lack of points on the boundary, the LHD is combined with a full factorial design, which puts DOE points right in the corners of the design space. This method was also proposed by van Beers and Kleijnen (2004) and Kleijnen and van Beers (2004). Figure 6(a) presents the LHD modified with a full factorial design for a two dimensional rectangular design space. Unfortunately, the design space will often not be rectangular when explicit constraints are present. In this case, the proposed algorithm will: 1. 2. 3. 4.
check which points of the LHD + full factorial design are non-feasible skip the non-feasible points replace the non-feasible points with new points repeat the above procedure until all points are feasible
Fig. 6. (a) LHD + full factorial design; (b) LHD + full factorial design including explicit constraints
Metamodel Based Algorithm for Metal Forming Processes
63
Replacing the non-feasible points is also done in a spacefilling way by selecting a large number of sets of additional design points. The new set of points is the one for which the minimum point to point distance is maximised. This socalled maximin criterion is used for both the initial DOE and for the case when the user wants to generate additional experimental design points, for example for improving the accuracy of the metamodels. The final DOE strategy incorporated in the proposed optimisation algorithm is presented in Fig. 6(b) for two design variables (x1 and x2 ) and two explicit constraints (g1 and g2 ). 3.3 Running the FEM Simulations and Fitting the Metamodels Subsequently, using the settings indicated by the DOE strategy, a number of FEM calculations is run on parallel processors and the response points (objective function and implicit constraint values) are obtained. Following Fig. 4, the next step is to fit for each response seven metamodels: 1. 2. 3. 4. 5.
A linear polynomial using RSM A linear + interaction polynomial using RSM A pure quadratic or elliptic polynomial using RSM A full quadratic polynomial using RSM A Kriging interpolation metamodel with a 0th order polynomial as a trend function 6. A Kriging interpolation metamodel with a 1st order polynomial as a trend function 7. A Kriging interpolation metamodel with a 2nd order polynomial as a trend function
3.4 Validation and Optimisation Metamodel validation based on cross validation (see e.g. Martin and Simpson, 2003) is used to select the best metamodel for the observed response. Using cross validation, one leaves out one, say the ith , of the response measurements and fits the metamodel through the remaining response measurements. The difference between the real value yi and the value predicted by the metamodel at this location yˆ−i is a measure for the accuracy of the metamodel. One can repeat this procedure for all say n measurement points and calculate the cross validation Root Mean Squared Error (RMSECV ): n 2 (yi − y ˆ−i ) (9) RMSECV = n i=1 As RMSECV approaches 0, the metamodel becomes more and more accurate. Cross validation can also be visualised in a cross validation plot. An example of such a plot is presented in Fig. 7. If the measurements follow the line x = y, the metamodel fits the data well.
64
Advanced Methods in Material Forming
Fig. 7. A cross validation plot
For each response (objective function and implicit constraints) the metamodel outperforming the other six metamodels is selected. These best metamodels for objective function and implicit constraints are added to the explicit constraints in the optimisation model, which is subsequently optimised using a standard Sequential Quadratic Programming (SQP) algorithm, see for example (Haftka and G¨ urdal 1992). In case constraints or Kriging metamodels are present in the final optimisation problem, there is a risk of ending up in a local optimum. This problem is overcome by initialising the SQP algorithm at multiple locations. This implies performing many function evaluations, but this is hardly a problem since both RSM and DACE metamodels, being explicit mathematical functions, can be evaluated thousands of times within a second. The DOE points are used as initial locations for the SQP algorithm. The obtained approximate optimum is finally checked by running one last FEM calculation with the approximated optimal settings of the design variables. The difference between the approximate objective function value and the real value of the objective function calculated by the last FEM run is a measure for the accuracy of the obtained optimum. If the user is not satisfied with this accuracy, the algorithm allows for sequential improvement (e.g. zooming near the optimum) and repeating the procedure presented above until one is satisfied with the accuracy. Hence the proposed algorithm incorporates all the advantages of sequential approximate optimisation algorithms.
Metamodel Based Algorithm for Metal Forming Processes
65
3.5 Implementation The optimisation algorithm presented in Fig. 4 and the previous sections was implemented in MATLAB and can be used in combination with any Finite Element code. For the fitting of the DACE/Kriging metamodels, use was made of the MATLAB Kriging toolbox implemented by Lophaven et al., (2002a), (2002b) and Nielsen and Søndergaard (Nielsen).
4 A Metal Forming Application The optimisation algorithm introduced in the previous section is applied to a simple hydroforming process. The product to be hydroformed is presented in Fig. 8(a). Figure 8(b) presents the dimensions. For metal forming, several groups of design variables can be distinguished: 1. Geometrical parameters: (a) Final product geometry (b) Initial workpiece geometry (c) Tool geometry 2. Material parameters 3. Process parameters The group of geometrical parameters is divided further into variables belonging to the final, deformed product, e.g. product radii, thicknesses, etc. variables
Fig. 8. (a) a simple hydroformed product; (b) dimensions; (c) typical load paths for hydroforming
66
Advanced Methods in Material Forming
related to the initial, underformed workpiece (blank shape, blank thickness, etc. and variables related to the tool geometry (drawbeads, tool radii and so on). Examples of material parameters are strain hardening coefficients, the initial yield stress or simply several discrete materials in itself. The group of process parameters includes process forces, pressures, tool displacements, friction coefficient, process temperature, etc. For the simple metal forming example considered here, we are interested in optimising the time variation of the internal pressure p and axial feeding u. These are typically process parameters for the hydroforming process. A typical time dependent load path for hydroforming is shown in Fig. 8(c). The velocity of pressure increase α is set to 10 MPa/s during a total hydroforming time of 10 s. Hence, three design variables remain: the time when axial feeding starts t1 , the time when axial feeding stops t2 and the total amount of axial feeding umax . As an optimisation objective, it was chosen to minimise deviations from the initial tube wall thickness. One implicit and one explicit constraint were formulated. The implicit constraint ensures that the final product fills out the die nicely, the explicit constraint makes sure that the time when axial feeding stops is larger than the time when it starts. Convergence problems of the FEM simulations have been encountered when t2 approaches t1 and the amount of axial feeding is high (large umax ). Methods to handle non converged simulations are lacking and is a field of open research. An extra explicit constraint has been formulated to overcome the convergence problems. The second explicit constraint makes the first explicit constraint redundant, as one can see in the model of the optimisation problem: h − h0 min f (t1 , t2 , umax ) = h0 2 s.t.
gimpl = V ≤ 0 gexpl1 = t1 − t2 ≤ 0 gexpl2 = umax − 9 (t2 − t1 ) ≤ 0 0 s ≤ t1 ≤ 5 s
(10)
3 s ≤ t2 ≤ 10 s 0 mm ≤ umax ≤ 9 mm where h is the final wall thickness in the hydroformed product, h0 is the wall thickness of the initial tube and V is the volume between the final product and the die. If this volume is larger than zero, there is a gap between the final product and the die and the final shape of the product is not satisfactory. The 2D FE model of the axisymmetric part is presented in Fig. 9(a). The contact between the product and the die is modelled by contact elements using a penalty formulation. The calculations were performed on 16 parallel processors, which limited the total time to the run time of one calculation,
Metamodel Based Algorithm for Metal Forming Processes
67
Fig. 9. (a) FE model of the initial tube; (b–e) final product formed with several arbitrary selected load paths; (f) final product formed with optimised load paths
i.e. a couple of minutes for the 2D FE model we are considering. Before the optimisation algorithm is applied, we will first arbitrarily select some combinations of the design variables and investigate the effect on the final product, the objective function and the implicit constraint. Subsequently, the algorithm is applied and the optimised results are compared to the results obtained with the arbitrarily selected load paths. Figures 9(b) through (e) present the final products deformed with the arbitrarily selected load paths. The design variable settings for t1 , t2 and umax and the response values for the objective function f and the implicit constraint gimpl are presented in Table 1. Note that product (a) is the initial undeformed product, which is seen as the product with the perfect wall thickness distribution by the objective function quantified in (10). For the perfect product, the objective function equals 0. Also note that products (c) and (e) do not satisfy the implicit constraint gimpl , which can also clearly be seen from Figs. 9(c) and (e). The metamodel based optimisation algorithm presented in Sect. 3 is now applied to optimise the wall thickness distribution. The DOE strategy introduced in Sect. 3.2. was applied to generate 16 initial design variable settings
Table 1. Design variable settings and response values Product
t1 (s)
t2 (s)
umax (mm)
f
gimpl
(a) (b) (c) (d) (e) (f)
− 0 0 0 4.8 0
− 0 3 10 6.2 2.5
− 0 9 9 7.7 8.3
0 1.39 0.52 1.42 1.37 0.37
− −0.29 1.79 −0.34 32.64 −0.47
68
Advanced Methods in Material Forming
for which 16 FEM calculations were performed with the in-house code DiekA. Subsequently, the four Response Surfaces and three Kriging metamodels were fitted for both responses (the objective function and the implicit constraint). Based on cross validation, a 0th order Kriging metamodel appeared to be the most accurate metamodel for the objective function. In a similar way, a 1st order Kriging metamodel was identified to be most accurate for the implicit constraint. Both were included in the optimisation problem, which was subsequently solved using the multistart SQP algorithm described in Sect. 3.4. Several local optima were observed; the global optimum was located at (t1 , t2 , umax ) = (0, 3, 7.9) and the corresponding objective function value was observed to be 0.66. Figure 10(a) shows the approximate optimum located on the metamodel of the objective function. The metamodel is depicted dependent on x2 = t2 and x3 = umax at the constant, optimal level of t1 = 0. Figure 10(b) presents a contour plot of the objective function and the constraints, where one can easily observe that the optimum is constrained by the implicit constraint and the box constraint t2 ≥ 3. To validate the optimum, a FEM calculation was performed with the optimal design variable settings. The actual objective function value was found to be 0.47. The large difference between the approximate and the actual objective function values at the approximate optimum motivates to sequentially improve the results. Making use of the metamodel visualised in Fig. 10, it was decided to zoom in near the optimum and to relax the box constraint t2 ≥ 3: it was replaced by the new box constraint t2 ≥ 2.5. In total, six batches of each 16 FEM calculations were performed. Each time, the design space was reduced and/or shifted with the aim to fit accurate metamodels in the vicinity of the optimum. The results of all batches are presented in Table 2.
Fig. 10. (a) metamodel of the objective function after batch 1; (b) contour plot of the objective function after batch 1
Metamodel Based Algorithm for Metal Forming Processes
69
Table 2. Optima of the DoC after the 6 batches of 16 FEM calculations each # FEM
t1 (s)
t2 (s)
umax
fopt
factual
16 32 48 64 80 96
0 0 0.8 0 0 0
3.0 1.5 2.5 3.0 3.1 2.5
7.9 7.9 9.0 7.7 8.2 8.3
0.66 0.37 −0.06 0.31 0.37 0.30
0.47 – 0.55 0.50 0.49 0.37
Fig. 11. (a) metamodel of the objective function after batch 6; (b) contour plot of the objective function after batch 6
Figure 11 presents the metamodel of the objective function as well as a contour plot of the objective function after having run the sixth batch of simulations. The obtained optimum (t1 , t2 , umax ) = (0, 2.5, 8.3) is constrained by the box constraint t2 ≥ 2.5. A final 97th FEM calculation was performed with the optimised design variable settings. This calculation resulted in a real objective function value of 0.37, which is fairly close to the approximate objective function value of 0.30. Although there is still a small difference between the approximate and the actual value of the objective function, it was decided to be satisfied with the approximate optimum obtained by the metamodel based optimisation algorithm. The optimised settings found by the proposed optimisation algorithm are presented in Table 1 as product (f). The final shape of this product is shown in Fig. 9(f). Figure 12 shows the wall thickness throughout the final product for all load paths. It can be concluded from the Figs. 9 and 12 and Table 1 that the product deformed with the optimised load paths outperforms the other products formed with arbitrary settings, which demonstrates the good applicability of the proposed algorithm to metal forming.
70
Advanced Methods in Material Forming
Fig. 12. Wall thickness distribution of several hydroformed products
5 Conclusions An optimisation algorithm based on metamodelling techniques is proposed for the optimisation of metal forming using time consuming FEM calculations. It uses both Response Surface Methodology and DACE (or Kriging) as metamodelling techniques. As a Design Of Experiments strategy, a combination of a maximin spacefilling Latin Hypercubes Design with a full factorial design was implemented, which takes into account explicit constraints. Additionally, the algorithm incorporates cross validation as a metamodel validation technique and uses a Sequential Quadratic Programming algorithm for metamodel optimisation. To overcome the problem of ending up in a local optimum, the SQP algorithm is initialised from every DOE point, which is very time efficient since evaluating the metamodels can be done within a fraction of a second. The proposed algorithm allows for sequential improvement of the metamodels to obtain a more accurate optimum. As an example case, the optimisation algorithm was applied to obtain the optimised internal pressure and axial feeding load paths to minimise wall thickness variations in a simple hydroformed product. The product formed with optimised load paths outperforms several products formed with
Metamodel Based Algorithm for Metal Forming Processes
71
arbitrarily chosen load paths, which demonstrates the good applicability of metamodelling techniques to optimise metal forming processes.
Acknowledgements This work is conducted within the framework of project MC1.03162, Optimisation of Forming Processes, which is part of the research programme of the Netherlands Institute for Metals Research (NIMR). The NIMR and its industrial partners are gratefully acknowledged for their support and useful input.
References Castro, C., Ant´ onio, C., Sousa, L., “Optimisation of shape and process parameters in metal forging using genetic algorithms”, International Journal of Materials Processing Technology, Vol. 146, 356–364, 2004. ¨ Emmerich, M., Giotis, A., Ozdemir, M., B¨ ack, T., Giannakoglou, K., “Metamodelassisted evolution strategies”, in Proceedings of the International Conference on Parallel Problem Solving from Nature, 2002. Fourment, L., Do, T., Habbal, A., Bouzaiane, M., “Gradient, non-gradient and hybrid algorithms for optimizing 2D and 3D forging sequences”, in Proceedings of ESAFORM, Cluj-Napoca, Romania, 2005. Haftka, R., G¨ urdal, Z., Elements of structural optimization, Kluwer academic publishers, Dordrecht, Netherlands, 3rd ed., 1992, ISBN 0-7923-1504-9. Jansson, T., Optimization of Sheet Metal Forming Processes, Licentiate thesis, Universitet Link¨ oping, Link¨ oping, Sweden, 2002. Jansson, T., Andersson, A., Nilsson, L., “Optimization of draw-in for an automotive sheet metal part – an evaluation using surrogate models and response surfaces”, Journal of Materials Processing Technology, Vol. 159, 426–234, 2005. Kleijnen, J., Sargent, R., “A methodology for fitting and validating metamodels in simulation”, European Journal of Operational Research, Vol. 120, 14–29, 2000. Kleinermann, J. P., Ponthot, J. P., “Parameter identification and shape/process optimization in metal forming simulation”, Journal of Materials Processing Technology, Vol. 139(1–3), 521–526, 2003. Kleijnen, J., Van Beers, W., “Application-driven sequential designs for simulation experiments: Kriging metamodelling”, European Journal of Operational Research, submitted in 2004. Koehler, J., Owen, A., Handbook of Statistics, chap. Computer Experiments, 261– 308, Elsevier Science, New York, USA, 1996. Lin, Z., Juchen, X., Xinyun, W., Guoan, H., “Optimization of die profile for improving die life in the hot extrusion process”, Journal of Materials Processing Technology, Vol. 142(3), 659–664, 2003. Lophaven, S., Nielsen, H., Søndergaard, J., “Aspects of the MATLAB Toolbox DACE”, Technical Report IMM-REP-2002-13, Technical University of Denmark – Department of Informatics and Mathematical Modelling, Lyngby, Denmark, 2002.
72
Advanced Methods in Material Forming
Lophaven, S., Nielsen, H., Søndergaard, J., “DACE – A MATLAB Kriging Toolbox”, Technical Report IMM-TR-2002-12, Technical University of Denmark – Department of Informatics and Mathematical Modelling, Lyngby, Denmark, 2002. Martin, J., Simpson, T., “A study on the use of Kriging models to approximate deterministic computer models”, in Proceedings of the ASME Design Engineering Technical Conferences DETC, 2003. McKay, M., Beckman, R., Conover, W., “A comparison of three methods for selecting values of input variables in the analysis of output from a computer code”, Technometrics, Vol. 21, 239–245, 1979. Myers, R., Montgomery, D., Response Surface Methodology: Process and Product Optimization Using Designed Experiments, John Wiley and Sons, Inc., New York, USA, 2nd ed., 2002, ISBN 0-471-41255-4. Naceur, H., Guo, Y. Q., Batoz, J. L., Knopf-Lenoir, C., “Optimization of drawbead restraining forces and drawbead design in sheet metal forming process”, International Journal of Mechanical Sciences, Vol. 43(10), 2407–2434, 2001. Naceur, H., Ben-Elechi, S., Knopf-Lenoir, C., Batoz, J., “Response surface methodology for the design of sheet metal forming parameters to control springback effects using the inverse approach”, in Proceedings of NUMIFORM, Columbus OH, USA, 2004. Nielsen, H., “DACE, A MATLAB Kriging toolbox”, http://www.imm.dtu.dk/ hbn/dace/. Papalambros, P. Y., Wilde, D. J., Principles of optimal design, Cambridge University Press, New York, USA, 2000, ISBN 0-521-62727. Sacks, J., Schiller, S., Welch, W., “Design for computer experiments”, Technometrics, Vol. 31, 41–47, 1989. Sacks, J., Welch, W., Mitchell, T., Wynn, H., “Design and analysis of computer experiments”, Statistical Science, Vol. 4, 409–423, 1989. Santner, T., Williams, B., Notz, W., The Design and Analysis of Computer Experiments, Springer-Verlag, New York, USA, 2003, ISBN 0-387-95420-1. Schenk, O., Hillmann, M., “Optimal design of metal forming die surfaces with evolution strategies”, Computers and Structures, Vol. 82, 1695–1705, 2004. Simpson, T., Peplinski, J., Koch, P., Allen, J., “Metamodels for computer-based engineering design: Survey and recommendations”, Engineering with Computers, Vol. 17, 129–150, 2001. van Beers, W., Kleijnen, J., “Kriging interpolation in simulation: A survey”, in R. Ingalls, M. Rossetti, J. Smith, B. Peters, eds., Proceedings of the 2004 Winter Simulation Conference, 2004.
Modelling of Permeability and Mechanical Dispersion in a Porous Medium and Comparison with Experimental Measurements F. Loix1 , V. Thibaut and F. Dupret2 Universit´e Catholique de Louvain Unit´e MEMA – Bˆ atiment Euler, 4, avenue G. Lemaˆıtre, B-1348 Louvain-la-Neuve, Belgium 1
[email protected] 2
[email protected] Summary. A continuous model for the non-isothermal flow in a non-isotropic porous medium is presented and a mechanical dispersion model is proposed. An experimental device is set up in order to measure the permeability and mechanical dispersion components in a typical transversely isotropic cubic block consisting of polymeric needles. Finally, a micro-macro model for the flow of a Newtonian fluid in a porous medium is developed. The micro-model consists of a geometrical network of connectors and junctions. Integration and assembly of the equations provides a macroscopic model which obeys the Darcy or Forchheimer model depending on the dimensionless flow rate. Some peculiarities of the Brinkman model are addressed.
Key words: porous media, darcy model, forchheimer model, brinkman model, mechanical dispersion, micro-macro modelling.
1 Introduction Liquid moulding technologies (Rud et al., 1997) such as the filling of fiber mats represent very attractive forming processes to produce composite parts of the highest quality. The fibers can be of unlimited length, their arrangement and orientation are perfectly controlled, and the principal price to pay when dealing with industrial production is the rather long filling time needed (this time being much longer than a typical injection moulding cycle for example). Considering the particular cases of Structural Reaction Injection Moulding (SRIM) and Resin Transfer Moulding (RTM), where a reactive mixture activated either by heat or by mixing is injected into the fiber mat inside the mould, optimizing these processes requires accurate knowledge of the governing transfer mechanisms during the filling stage.
74
Advanced Methods in Material Forming
Therefore a relevant model for the flow in a porous medium is needed (Tucker and Dessenberger, 1994). We here focus on the physics of non-isothermal flows in non-isotropic porous media (such as fiber mats), possibly with chemical reactions. Therefore, the material constants governing the flow as well as the heat and mass transfer are replaced by appropriate 2nd -, 4th -, or even higher-order tensors (Loix, 2005a), with a significant increase of complexity for (i) the experimental and theoretical validation of the governing laws, and (ii) the characterization of the material constants. Two particular effects are present in flows in porous media: (i) permeability, and (ii) mechanical dispersion. First, the medium permeability is characterized by a 2nd -order tensor which plays a key role in momentum transfer. Accordingly and depending on the flow regime, the momentum conservation law can be expressed by means of the Darcy, Forchheimer, or Brinkman model (Lage, 1998 and Tucker, 1994). Secondly, the tortuosity of the porous network causes heat and mass mixing – or mechanical dispersion – which is most often modelled by adding supplementary terms to the molecular thermal and species diffusion coefficients. In the work of Mal et al. (Mal et al., 1998 and Mal, 1999), mechanical dispersion is assumed to be governed by a 4th order tensor but this model still needs experimental validation and theoretical justification. The first objective of this paper (Sect. 2) is to develop a complete continuous model for the flow in a porous medium. The physics of both permeability and mechanical dispersion effects is addressed. Whereas dispersion is wellknown to strongly increase heat and mass diffusion, it is besides assumed that this effect could be responsible for the modified viscosity observed in the Brinkman model, taking into account an increased momentum mixing. Our dispersion model is illustrated by means of typical flows in an anistropic and non-homogeneous medium. The second objective of the paper (Sect. 3) is to describe a set of experiments performed in the anisotropic case (Thibaut, 2004). Three issues are addressed: (i) the conception of a porous medium of controlled symmetry ; (ii) the design of the experimental device ; and (iii) the obtention of permeability or dispersion tensor components from the measurements in order to validate the model. The third goal of this paper (Sect. 4) is to propose a micro-macro model in order to better understand the flow in a non-isotropic porous medium and to draw a link between micro-parameters and macro-properties. It is shown that macroscopic laws can be deduced from a simple microscopic model. For example, Darcy’s model is retrieved from Poiseuille’s assumption at the pore scale. Finally, the relation between the physical properties (permeability, hydrodynamic dispersion) measured in our experiments and the corresponding micro-parameters is investigated.
Modelling of Permeability and Mechanical Dispersion
75
2 A Continuous Model for the Flow in a Porous Medium At the macroscopic scale, the liquid and solid phases (resin and fibre mat in SRIM and RTM processes) form a single continuous medium. The physical assumptions of the present paper are: (i) local thermal equilibrium; (ii) rigid solid phase; (iii) no exchange of material between the phases; (iv) constant material properties in both phases; (v) Newtonian fluid rheology; and (vi) no consolidation. Our model has been developed on the basis of the work of Tucker and Dessenberger 1994 and the researches of Mal and Dupret (Mal et al., 1998 and Mal, 1999). Most details have been published in Loix et al., 2002. 2.1 Pressure and Velocity Equations Using the notations of Tucker and Dessenberger (1994), the average mass equation writes as: ∇ · v f = 0, (1) where v f is the Darcy or seepage velocity. Letting Pf f denote the intrinsic average reduced pressure within the liquid and K stand for the permeability ¯ tensor, the average momentum equation can often be expressed by means of the Darcy model: 1 vf = − K · ∇Pf f . (2) ¯ η¯ where η is the fluid viscosity. However, when the flow rate increases, inertia effects can become more important and generate a form drag in addition to the viscous drag. In this case, the Forchheimer model generally provides better results (Lage, 1998), as expressed for an isotropic medium in the form: 0 = −∇Pf f −
η v − Cρ v f v f , K f
(3)
where ρ is the fluid specific mass, C is a material constant and K is the scalar permeability. When bulk viscosity effects are important with respect to inertia (Tucker and Dessenberger, 1994), the Brinkman model can be used. In the absence of form drag, it writes as: 0 = f ∇Pf f + f ηK−1 · v f + ∇ · ηˆ ∇v f + ∇v f T , (4) ¯ Brinkman term
where ηˆ is the modified viscosity and f the medium porosity. Although several authors consider that ηˆ = η, some experimental results show that the “fitting” viscosity can in fact differ from the molecular viscosity (cf. Gilver and Altobelli (1994), with ηˆ = 7.5η). Following Loix (2005a), we will here show that momentum mechanical dispersion could be responsible for the observed increased viscosity. In fact, this effect can be expressed by means of a 4th -order
76
Advanced Methods in Material Forming
tensor MD which takes into account the geometry of the porous medium and ¯ ¯ the influence of velocity. An important observation is that the presence of a divergence term gives to (4) the appropriate mathematical type in such a way that no-slip boundary conditions can be imposed at the medium border. The equation type indeed requires that stress or velocity be imposed along the domain boundary. However, these conditions will generate a flow boundary layer whose thickness is determined by letting in (4) thedrag force beof the same order of magnitude as the Brinkman term, which is O (ˆ η K/f η)1/2 . The latter expression is usually very small since, for common porous materials, the permeability is about 10−5 to 10−8 m2 (Nield and Bejan, 1998) and since ηˆ/η is moderately high (Gilver and Altobelli, 1994). Hence, the influence of this parameter could be very local in the flow solution, while it could have a higher effect on the heat transfer. 2.2 Temperature and Conversion Degree Equations The energy and species concentration conservation equations write as: ∂T (ρC)f + (ρC)s + (ρC)f v f · ∇T = ∂t ∇ · Ke + KD · ∇T + (ρ)f HR fc (c , T ) , ¯ ¯ and ∂c f + v · ∇c = ∂t f
(5)
De + DD · ∇c + f fc (c , T ), (6) ¯ ¯ where T and c stand for the intrinsic average temperature and concentration, C and ρ denotes heat capacity and specific mass, Ke and De stand ¯ ¯ for the average molecular thermal and species diffusion tensors, HR is the reaction enthalpy, fc denotes the reaction kinetics and the subscripts ‘s’ and ‘f ’ refer to the solid and fluid phases, respectively. The mechanical mixing conduction and diffusion tensors KD and DD can ¯ ¯ be modelled by means of a 4th -order dispersion tensor L (Loix et al., 2002, ¯¯ Mal et al., 1998, Mal, 1999): ∇·
1 1 vv (7) K = DD = L : ¯ ¯ . ¯ (ρC)f ¯ D f ¯
v
¯ ¯ Typically, for an isotropic medium, L can be expressed as follows (Loix and ¯ ¯ Dupret, 2003): 1 Lijkl = L⊥ δij δkl + L − L⊥ (δik δjl + δil δjk ) , (8) 2 with 2 non-negative material coefficients L and L⊥ (Rutherford, 1962). On the other hand, a transversely isotropic medium is symmetric for all rotations
Modelling of Permeability and Mechanical Dispersion
77
around a given direction, here denoted by l. In this case, the dispersion tensor is characterized by 6 parameters (Loix and Dupret, 2003): Lijkl = L li lj lk ll +L⊥ li lj (δkl − lk ll ) +L⊥ (δij − li lj ) lk ll +L⊥ (δij − li lj ) (δkl − lk ll ) 1 + (L⊥⊥ − L⊥ ) [(δik − li lk ) (δjl − lj ll ) + (δil − li ll ) (δjk − lj lk )] 2 +L [li lk (δjl −lj ll ) + lj lk (δil −li ll )+li ll (δjk −lj lk ) + lj ll (δik − li lk )] . (9) In order to respect the physics of diffusion, the tensors K D and DD must be positive definite and hence (Loix and Dupret, 2003) the coefficients L , L⊥ , L⊥ , L⊥ and L⊥⊥ must be non-negative while L must satisfy the inequality (10) 2 |L | ≤ L⊥ L⊥ + L L⊥⊥ . 2.3 Appication: Flow in a Thin, Non-Homogeneous, Anisotropic Plate Let us here analyze the flow in a thin stratified medium consisting of a superposition of homogeneous layers (Fig. 1), typically a set of differently oriented fiber mats. The porous plate dimensions are L > l h > 0 along the x, y, and z axis, respectively. We will show that the flow through this kind of medium exhibits mass transfer between the different layers. As a particular case, we consider a 2-layered medium with symmetric permeabilities, corresponding to a pair of symmetric mats with respect to the xz plane: ⎤ ⎡ Kxx Kxy 0 (11) [Kij ] = ⎣Kxy Kyy 0 ⎦ for 0 ≤ z ≤ h/2, 0 0 Kzz Medium 1
ez
Upper impermeable border
Pin
ex Pout
ey
h L
l Impermeable lateral borders Medium 2 Lower impermeable border
Fig. 1. Scheme of a thin stratified porous plate with 2 layers
78
Advanced Methods in Material Forming
⎤ Kxx −Kxy 0 [Kij ] = ⎣−Kxy Kyy 0 ⎦ 0 0 Kzz ⎡
and
for h/2 < z ≤ h.
(12)
It can be shown that, for a transversely isotropic medium, the permeability is characterized by only 2 parameters, K and K⊥ (Rutherford, 1962, Loix and Dupret 2003 and Loix, 2005a). Hence the permeability tensor can be expressed in the alternative form: Kij = K li lj + K⊥ (δij − li lj ).
(13)
To illustrate the competition between dispersion and mass transfer effects, let us consider the flow through a cavity of dimensions 1 m×0.2 m×0.01 m, whose 2 layers are each of 5 mm thickness (Fig. 2). The inlet and outlet pressures are 1.05 bar and 1 bar while the constant resin viscosity is 0.2 kg m−1 s−1 . The lower and upper initial and inlet relative concentrations are c(1) = 0.25 and c(2) = 0.75 (Fig. 3). The porosity is 0.86 for both layers, which are assumed to be transversely isotropic with K⊥ = 10−8 m2 and K = 10−7 m2 while the larger permeability direction l (associated with the fiber mat orientation and the symmetry direction of the medium) is parallel to the midsurface of the cavity and oriented in the lower and upper layers at −45◦ and 45◦ with respect to the x-axis: √
(1)
√
(li ) = (li ) = ( √22 , 22√, 0), (2) (li ) = (li ) = ( 22 , − 22 , 0).
(14)
By considering gap-averaged equations, it can be shown that this 2-layered configuration generates a three-dimensional (3D) flow while the pressure field will remain one-dimensional (1D). Typical pathlines are depicted in Fig. 2 while the velocity field is illustrated in Fig. 4. In order to investigate the
Z
X
0
Y
0.1 0.2 0.3 0.4
[m] 0.01
0
0.5 0.6
0
0.1 [m]
[m]
0.7 0.8 0.9 0.2
1
Fig. 2. Pathlines of 2 selected material points through a 2-layered medium
Modelling of Permeability and Mechanical Dispersion (0,0,0.01)
Z
Pin
(0,0,0)
c(2) c(1)
c(2)
Y
X
79
(0,0.2,0) c(1)
Pout
c(2)
c(2)
c(1)
c(1)
Pin
(1,0,0)
Fig. 3. Mesh cross-sections for x = 0.5 m and y = 0.1 m
hydrodynamic dispersion effect and its competition with mass convection, a coefficient L = 0.17 mm has been used to represent the order of magnitude of the tensor Lijkl in (9). This rather low value as compared to the estimates provided by the experimental analysis of Sect. 3 was selected in order to enhance the competition between dispersion and transport effects.
0.01 Z
X
Y
0.1 m/s z = 2.5 mm
.1
0.2 0.1 0 [m] 0.2
0.1 m/s
z = 7.5 mm
0.1 0 0
0.1
0.2
0.3
0.4
0.5
0.6
0.7
0.8
0.9
1
Fig. 4. Cross-sections of the velocity field for x = 0.5 m (top), z = 2.5 mm (middle) and z = 7.5 mm (bottom)
80
Advanced Methods in Material Forming 0.01
0 0 0.01
1
0 0.01
2
0 0.01
3
0 0.01
4
0 0.01
5
0 0.01
6
0 0.01
7
0 0.01
8
0 0.01
9
0 0.01
10
0 0.01
15
0 0.01
20 [s]
0 0
0.1 x = 0.5 m
0.2 0
0.1
0.2
0.3
0.4
0.5 y = 0.1 m
0.6
0.7
0.8
0.9
1
Fig. 5. Cross-sections of the relative concentration for y = 0.1 m and x = 0.5 m at different times from 0 to 20 s (from 0.25 : dark gray, to 0.75 : light gray). All Lijkl coefficients are 0, except L⊥ = 0.17 mm
Modelling of Permeability and Mechanical Dispersion
81 0.01
0 0 0.01
1
0 0.01
2
0 0.01
3
0 0.01
4
0 0.01
5
0 0.01
6
0 0.01
7
0 0.01
8
0 0.01
9
0 0.01
10
0 0.01
15
0 0.01
20 [s]
0 0
0.1 x = 0.5 m
0.2 0
0.1
0.2
0.3
0.4
0.5 y = 0.1 m
0.6
0.7
0.8
Fig. 6. Same as Fig. 5 with L⊥ = 0.017 mm
0.9
1
82
Advanced Methods in Material Forming
Several simulations have been performed with different values of the dispersion tensor Lijkl . Isotropic dispersion was first tested with L = L⊥ = L. Subsequently, a transversely isotropic dispersion was investigated by setting to 0 chosen dispersion coefficients (L , L⊥ , L⊥⊥ . . .) (Figs. 5 and 6). From these numerical experiments, it was observed that a significant role is here played by L⊥ only. This can be demonstrated by a detailed analysis of our particular problem. In Figs. 5 and 6, it also appears that, when the L⊥ dispersion parameter is increased, the dispersion effect becomes more and more important and finally dominates mass transport (which is indeed too slow to play any role). In conclusion, complex transfer effects are generated (i) by a jointly nonuniform and non-isotropic permeability, and (ii) by a non-isotropic mechanical dispersion. Experimental validation is needed to assess our mechanical dispersion model.
3 Experimental Analysis 3.1 Principles and Design The focus is here on anisotropic porous media and, more particularly, on transversely isotropic media. Therefore the experimental apparatus must be designed in such a way that the medium orientation can be easily changed with respect to the mean flow direction. Porous Medium Conception The conception of an experimental transversely isotropic porous medium has been led by different considerations, viz. (i) that the medium anisotropy must be controlled, (ii) that the relative dimensions of the pores and of the entire medium must be well-chosen, and (iii) that the production of several similar media should be easy. We have chosen to build the medium as an assembly of small elements resulting in a porous cubic block. To get a transversely isotropic medium, the shape of these constitutive elements had to be the same after any rotation around their symmetry direction, keeping in mind that statistical averaging must be taken into account to reach the desired symmetry (in such a way that the orientation of the individual elements can slightly vary around the macroscopic symmetry direction). “Needles” and “discs” answer this objective. For practical reasons, only the medium consisting of needles has been selected in our tests. In order to build a representative macroscopic medium, the length of the “needles” had to be at least one order of magnitude smaller than the entire block. Fibers of 1 mm diameter and 15 mm length and a 10 cm× 10 cm × 10 cm porous block seemed to be a pertinent compromise. With these dimensions
Modelling of Permeability and Mechanical Dispersion
83
and shape, one block contains about 50000 to 60000 needle elements and the porous block is easy to design and build. Finally, in order to facilitate the medium assembly process, thermoset polymeric needles were selected. Indeed, with this material, the formation of a coherent medium is automatically obtained by heating and reticulation. Of course care had to be given to almost identically orienting the needles in the appropriate cubic container before starting the reticulation process in the drying oven. Apparatus To produce a flow through a porous medium, the underlying principle consists in imposing a pressure gradient or to replace it by the effect of gravity, thereby resulting in an equivalent loss of head. In our experiment, the fluid is water and the loss of head is induced by a water height difference between the flow entry and exit whereas the porous block is inserted at a given orientation into a square column, taking care of watertightness near the borders. Moreover, as flows in saturated porous media are to be considered, the exit level is roughly situated at the same height as the middle of the block and a siphon is introduced (Fig. 7). A runoff system is built in order to maintain a constant pressure on the top side of the block. The pressure on the other side is controlled by the height of a barrier in a collector. The latter is designed in such a way that the fluid velocity is sufficiently low. The flow rate measurement can then be accurate enough. In order to quantify the mixing effect of mechanical dispersion inside the porous medium, the device has been further adapted. First of all, in order to enable the flow of 2 distinctly coloured fluids, watertight separations were Runoff
Fluid Porous medium block Collector
h1
h h2
Draining
Fig. 7. Experimental apparatus – Flow rate resulting from an imposed loss of head
84
Advanced Methods in Material Forming
(a)
(b)
Fig. 8. (a) Siphon system to avoid void formation and to maintain a constant exit pressure; (b) separated zones at the entry and the exit of the porous medium
introduced on the top side of the block (Fig. 8). Mixed fluid is then collected at the bottom of the block in 12 separated zones. A siphon system is still used in order to avoid void formation. 3.2 Measurements and Results Permeability Since the experiments described in Fig. 7 deal with a 1D mean flow, the Darcy equation can be written in macroscopic terms as: V =−
K ΔC , η h
(15)
where V is the macroscopic seepage velocity, η the fluid viscosity, ΔC the loss of head along the block depth (h) and K the permeability in the flow direction. (15) is further rewritten as: Q=−
K ΔC S, η h
(16)
where Q denotes the volumic flow rate across the block cross-section S. Knowing the porous cube dimension, the fluid viscosity, the pressure drop (and hence the loss of head), and the measured flow rate, the permeability component in the mean flow direction can be written as: K=−
Qη h . ΔC S
(17)
Since the permeability tensor for a transversely isotropic medium is characterized by 2 parameters only (Rutherford, 1962 and Loix, 2005a), one for the
Modelling of Permeability and Mechanical Dispersion
85
permeability along the symmetry axis (K ) and the second one for the permeability along any perpendicular direction (K⊥ ), these two components can be determined by aligning the needle direction parallel or perpendicular to the mean flow direction. The experiments were repeated several times on 2 macroscopically similar porous blocks (Medium 1 and Medium 2) in order to assess the validity of the measurements, and the entire averaging procedure was repeated twice (noted Exp1 and Exp2). To determine the flow rate, the time for a fixed fluid volume to run across the porous block was measured. Table 1 summarizes the detailed measurements for all handlings. Let us first observe that both classes of measurements are consistent. This seems to validate the procedure. Moreover, the running time is clearly higher in the “perpendicular” case than in the “parallel” case. This indicates that the perpendicular permeability component is lower than the parallel component. This assertion is confirmed by the results of Table 2, where we observe that K is from 13% to 14% higher than K⊥ . Even if this difference is low, it is the same in both cases. In order to validate the Darcy law, this experiment should have been repeated for different pressure drops. Nevertheless, it must be noted that our experimental flows are expected to well lie in the linear regime. Indeed, the pore-sized Reynolds number (Tucker and Dessenberger, 1994) is much lower than unity: √ ρV K Rep = ≈ 0.05 < 1. (18) η Table 1. Mean time (s) taken by 1 water liter to flow across the porous medium medium 1 exp 1 exp 2 mean time
medium 2
case
⊥ case
case
⊥ case
29.2284 29.7313 29.4799
33.5436 33.7776 33.6606
28.0563 27.5484 27.8024
32.2741 32.3534 32.3138
Table 2. Permeability components obtained from the measurements medium 1 case viscosity η [Pa.s] flow rate Q[m3 s−1 ] loss of head ΔC [Pa] resulting permeability K[m2 ]
medium 2 ⊥ case
−3
1.12 10 3.4 10−5 1.2753 103 2.96 10−10
case −3
1.14 10 2.97 10−5 1.2753 103 2.65 10−10
⊥ case −3
1.14 10 3.6 10−5 1.2753 103 3.21 10−10
1.14 10−3 3.09 10−5 1.2753 103 2.76 10−10
86
Advanced Methods in Material Forming
Mechanical Dispersion In order to analyse the mixing effect induced by mechanical dispersion, two equivalent but distinguishable fluids are injected at the medium entry. The fluids are made distinct by the adjunction of 99.5 ppm potassium permanganate in one of them (Fig. 8), and the observations are based on measuring the concentration of this substance at the exit of the porous block. Two cases are again studied, with the mean flow perpendicular or parallel to the needle direction, respectively (Figs. 9 (a) and (b)). In a first step, we focus on the perpendicular case (a) and examine the equation governing concentration evolution. Choosing the x-axis as aligned with the symmetry direction of the medium, the macroscopic equation for concentration (6) can be written in the steady case and without any source term in the form: ∂C ∂2C ∂2C V = Dx,y 2 + Dy,y 2 , (19) ∂y ∂x ∂y where Dx,y and Dy,y denote the appropriate total diffusion components (induced by molecular diffusion + dispersion) and V is the macroscopic seepage velocity as aligned with the y-axis. The total diffusion tensor is indeed diagonal. The boundary conditions are: ! ! C = C0 , 0 ≤ x < l/2 y = 0, ∂C/∂x = 0, x = 0, and (20) C = 0, l/2 ≤ x < l y = 0, ∂C/∂x = 0, x = l. l
Impermeable walls C0
C0 x
0
y
0 l
y
x
Separated collectors (a)
(b)
Fig. 9. Experimental scheme and axes for the determination of mechanical dispersion: (a) flow perpendicular to the needle direction; (b) flow aligned with the needle direction
Modelling of Permeability and Mechanical Dispersion
87
In order to easily draw first conclusions from our experiments, we will in addition assume in what follows that the total diffusion in the flow direction is negligible in front of the total diffusion in the perpendicular direction. This is a quite strong hypothesis that needs confirmation from further work. In this first attempt, (19) can be rewritten as: V
∂C ∂2C = Dx,y 2 . ∂y ∂x
(21)
This equation is easily solved by variable separation and Dx,y is finally obtained by fitting the solution to the measurements. In order to measure the outlet concentrations, the spectrometry technology was used. Samples of colored liquid were collected in 12 separated zones at the porous block exit when the steady-state flow regime was reached. The concentration of each sample was measured while noting its position in the exit zone. Hence, graphs of concentration distribution were finally drawn. This procedure was again repeated four times for the two blocks in order to validate the measurements (Fig. 10). Since the results are very close together with Medium 1 and Medium 2, this tends to validate the experimental procedure. Fitting the solution to the experiments finally gives the coefficient Dx,y for both blocks: Dx,y = 1.984 10−5 m2 s−1
and Dx,y = 2.076 10−5 m2 s−1 .
(22)
A similar approach has been applied in the parallel case. Again, the total diffusion in the flow direction was assumed to be negligible in front of the total diffusion in the perpendicular direction. Hence, with the axes of Fig. 9 (b), the transport-diffusion equation V
∂C ∂2C ∂2C = Dx,x 2 + Dy,x 2 , ∂x ∂x ∂y
(23)
∂2C ∂C = Dy,x 2 . ∂y ∂x
(24)
simplifies as V
The related measurements are again consistent for both blocks (Fig. 11) and the fitting of the experimental results to the simplified solution gives: Dy,x = 6.095 10−6 m2 s−1
and Dy,x = 6.864 10−6 m2 s−1 .
(25)
Analysing the experimental results (Figs. 10 and 11) shows that the “perpendicular” case induces more mixing than the “parallel” case. The diffusion components determined in (22) and (25) confirm these observations. However, recalling that these results are based on the assumption of negligible
88
Advanced Methods in Material Forming
Fig. 10. Concentration distribution at the exit of the porous block in 12 separated zones (Thibaut, 2004). The flow is perpendicular to the medium symmetry direction (Fig. 9 (a)). The experiments were performed with the first and the second block (left and right figures)
total diffusion in the flow direction, a more accurate approach should consist in removing this assumption and determining the total diffusion components by detailed fitting of the calculated results to the measurements. However, it is not clear that the experiments can be accurate enough to provide the required information. Therefore additional experiments might be needed.
Modelling of Permeability and Mechanical Dispersion
89
Fig. 11. Same as Fig. 10, with the flow parallel to the medium symmetry direction (Fig. 9 (b))
4 A New Micro-Macro Model 4.1 Framework and Justification for the Development of a New Model There is a strong lack of models for (possibly reactive) flows in porous media. This issue is however complex since a large number of physical phenomena are involved. First, the law governing the relationship between loss of head and seepage velocity is not always obeying the simple linear Darcy law. In particular, when the shape of the porous network plays a non-negligible role in stress
90
Advanced Methods in Material Forming
generation, additional losses of head must be introduced and the Forchheimer law should be considered (Lage, 1998), with supplementary quadratic terms. Let us recall that this quadratic law is subject to discussion – without complete agreement in the literature – at low flow rates, where a cubic law seems to better agree with experimental results (Firdaouss et al., 1997). In addition, deviations from the Darcy law can mean that inertia effects are non-negligible. In this case, the Brinkman equation (with or without Forchheimer terms) is better suited to model the momentum equations than simple drag forces. However, applying the Brinkman model requires to introduce an additional viscosity, whose presence might be attributed to momentum mixing inside the porous network. The constitutive law governing this additional viscosity remains incompletely known as it was explained in Sect. 2. A second class of phenomena associated with the physics of porous media pertains to the modelling of non-isothermal flows, possibly with chemical reactions. In this case, the tortuosity of the porous network generates an additional heat and mass mixing – the mechanical dispersion – which is assumed in the work of Mal et al. (1998) and Mal (1999) to be governed by a 4th order dispersion tensor. Further complications in the momentum, energy and species conservation equations can result from the porous medium anisotropy. Therefore, the material constants governing the flow as well as the heat and mass transfer must be replaced by appropriate 2nd -, 4th -, or even higher order tensors (Loix, 2005a). In view of these very high modelling difficulties, the objective of this section is to develop a micro-macro model and to derive relevant macroscopic constitutive laws in order to accurately understand and predict the phenomena taking place in flows in porous media and in particular in the filling of fiber mats (Loix et al., 2002 and Loix and Dupret 2003). For this purpose, a simple model is developed at the pore microscopic scale by considering a network of “connectors” and “junctions” where all the transfer phenomena are modelled in the simplest way (Loix, 2005a). In other words, the flow complexity is addressed by means of an assembly process at each junction while the flow across each connector is assumed to be governed by simple laws. Hydraulic similarities are used and new variables are introduced. Let us note that a similar approach was developed by Wang et al. (1999). 4.2 Development of a Micro-Macro Porous Medium Model Our microscopic model is inspired from general considerations about flows in porous media. Clearly, a porous medium consists of more or less tortuous pores in which the fluid can flow. While detailed knowledge of the pathlines is impossible and essentially unnecessary, basic analysis indicates that these pathlines can be quite intricate. For instance the flow can separate around some obstacles while some pathlines can meet again after skirting these obstacles.
Modelling of Permeability and Mechanical Dispersion
91
Let us emphasize that, in order to build a relevant micro-macro model, it will not be necessary to model the full complexity of the real medium at the micro-scale since this complexity will result from the assembly of a very large number of micro-components. Therefore the simplest model is considered at the micro-scale, in order to only capture the principal phenomena involved and satisfy the basic conservation equations. Consequently, our micro-model is based on considering a network of “connectors” and “junctions” (Fig. 12) defined by the following properties: –
A connector is a cylindrical or curved tube of length L and radius R across which the fluid flows from a junction to another junction. The connector volume is assumed to be πR2 L whatever its shape. – A junction is a point of negligible volume where several connectors meet, any flowing direction being possible across each associated connector.
In order to construct the simplest possible micro-scale model, some considerations arising from elementary hydraulics will be used given the similarity between pipe networks and our porous medium network model. First of all, focusing in this study on the steady flow of an incompressible fluid, the basic unknowns will be flow rate and head. The (volumic) flow rate Q[m3 /s] across a connector is defined as " Q= (26) v · n dS, S
where n and S stand for the unit normal and area of any cross-section of the connector, while v denotes the velocity field. The head C at a cross-section of a given connector is the averaged sum of dynamic, pressure and elevation contributions: p v2 + z S , C= + (27) 2g ρg where the average of any physical quantity F across S is defined by " 1 F S = F v · n dS, Q S
Ci i
(28)
k Qik
Ck
Fig. 12. Micro-scale model for the flow in a porous medium, as consisting of a network of connectors and junctions
92
Advanced Methods in Material Forming
and where v denotes the velocity norm, g the acceleration of gravity, p the pressure, ρ the fluid specific mass and z the local elevation. Here, the head is expressed from (27) as an equivalent height [m], while in Sects. 2 and 3, it was expressed as an equivalent pressure [Pa]. The approach presented in this paper provides the simplest way to take mass and momentum conservation laws into account for viscous fluids. It is easy to show that, in the steady incompressible case, the sum of the entering flow rates into any network subset is zero, while the head flux (as calculated as the sum of the products of the entering flow rates by the associated heads) is exactly the power dissipated by friction in this network subset. In order to completely specify the micro-macro model, a connector model, a junction model, and a network model will be successively defined. Connector Model Each connector is a duct across which the loss of head ΔC is governed by the following simple law: 8Lη ΔC = Q, (29) ρgπR4 which can be directly derived from the well-known Poiseuille flow governing laminar loss of head in a cylinder. It is easy to show that a very similar law applies in the case of a curved pipe and this justifies the use of the model provided by (29) in all connectors without loss of generality. Junction Model The simplest possible model consists in assuming that no losses of head take place in the junctions. In fact, Darcy’s law directly derives from this approach at the macro-scale through the linear relationship between loss of head and flow rate provided by (29) in every connector. In order to define a more complex physics and to represent additional effects such as those of Forchheimer’s or Brinkman’s models, supplementary losses of head must be introduced in the junction model. In a first attempt, an entry loss of head from each connector into the associated ending junction is considered, as governed by the following law: ΔC =
gπ 2 R4
Q|Q|,
(30)
where is a dimensionless loss factor which is here, for the sake of simplicity, common to all connectors and which takes its values in the [0, 1] interval. Indeed, in order to avoid model contradictions such as back-flows, we impose that the entry loss of head should not be higher than what we call the disposal head in the connector C d , corresponding to the kinetic part of the total head:
Modelling of Permeability and Mechanical Dispersion
#
2
v v S 2g
C = # d
S
· n dS
v · n dS
=
Q2 . g π 2 R4
93
(31)
The ratio between the entry loss of head, (30), and the connector loss of head, (29), is: ρ|Q| R (32) = Re = Ff Re, 8ηLπ 16L where Re = 2ρ|Q| πRη is a characteristic Reynolds number of the flow in the pores R and Ff = 16L is a shape factor. (32) provides an easy way to interpret the loss of head nonlinearity as associated with pore shape effects (Lage, 1998). It is easy to show that law (30) is sufficient to generate Forchheimer’s (but not Brinkman’s) model at the macroscopic level.
Network Model The following notations are adopted: – Cik denotes the connector from junction i to junction k; – Sik is the cross-sectional area of connector Cik ; – Junc(i) stands for the set of junctions linked to junction i by a connector; – Qik stands for the (volumic) flow rate from junction i to junction k; – Ci denotes the head at junction i as calculated after subtraction of all entry losses (therefore, in the present model, this head is unique at each junction). Mass conservation in every junction writes as: Qik = 0,
(33)
k∈Junc(i)
while applying the Poiseuille and entry losses of head provides the following equation in every connector: Ci − Ck =
8Lik η Qik + 2 4 Qik |Qik |. 4 ρgπRik gπ Rik
(34)
The system of (33) and (34) is closed by appropriate boundary conditions, which consist in imposing either the flow rate or the head at each boundary junction. The solution is easily found by applying the Newton-Raphson algorithm. 4.3 Numerical Results Our micro-macro model has been applied to investigate the flow of water (η = 10−3 Pa.s, ρ = 103 kg/m3 ) in the previous experimental 10 cm × 10cm ×
94
Advanced Methods in Material Forming Δhx Δhz
=
+ Lx , Rx
Δhy
+
Lxy , Rxy
+ Ly , Ry
+
+
Lxz, Rxz
Lz , Rz
Lyz , Ryz
Lxyz , Rxyz
Fig. 13. Geometry of an elementary cell as a set of connectors and junctions
10cm porous medium. Therefore, a network of equal parallelepipedic cells was designed as shown in Fig. 13, with Δhx = 16 mm, Δhy = Δhz = 2.12 mm, Rx = 0.2285 mm, Ry = Rz = Ryz = 0.25 mm, Rxy = Rxz = 0.135 mm, Lx = 16 mm, Ly = Lz = 2.12 mm, Lyz = 3 mm, Lxy = Lxz = 16.1 mm, while internal connectors were removed (Rxyz = 0 mm). These parameters were selected to approximately represent the geometry and the average topology of the medium to be modelled (Thibaut, 2004). From this micro-macro model, the associated macroscopic relationship between loss of head and seepage velocity has subsequently been determined for various values of (Fig. 14). A least square best fit technique was applied to approximate this relation by means of Darcy’s or Forchheimer’s model. When = 0, the Darcy model is recovered with a permeability Kxx equal to 3.510−10 m2 . This value is very close to the parallel permeability component obtained from the experiments (cf. Table 2). It is important to note that Kxx is strongly linked to the model microscopic parameters. In some cases an analytical relationship between macroscopic and microscopic parameters can even be established. For the linear case ( = 0), with a head gradient along the x axis, the following result is obtained: 4 4 4 Rxy Rxyz Rx4 πΔhx Rxz . (35) +2 +2 +4 Kxx = 8Δhy Δhz Lx Lxy Lxz Lxyz Using similar formulas, the other permeability components are easily determined. However, the agreement with experimental measurements (Table 2) is of much lower quality. When is increased, nonlinear effects play a more and more important role and a kind of Forchheimer’s regime is reached (Fig. 14). However, the Brinkman model cannot be generated by this approach since no momentum mixing effect appears. Moreover, due to the local nonlinearities associated with the assembly process, identifying the exact relationship between the microand macro-scales is more complicated than in the linear case. Hence, this nonlinear regime should be further analysed.
Modelling of Permeability and Mechanical Dispersion
95
× 104 12
grad P = 6.36E8*vv2Darcy + 3.2E6*vDarcy ε = 0.1
10 ε=0 grad P [N/m3]
8
grad P = 2.85E6*vDarcy
6 ε=1 2 grad P = 6.29E9*vDarcy + 3.3E6*vDarcy
4
2
0
0
0.005
0.01
0.015
0.02 0.025 vDarcy [m/s]
0.03
0.035
0.04
0.045
Fig. 14. Macroscopic relation between head gradient (= pressure gradient if g = 0) and seepage velocity for different values of
4.4 Momentum Mixing The fluid arriving from one or more upstream connectors at a junction is redistributed into one or more downstream connectors. Momentum conservation is ensured by the reaction of the solid matrix on the fluid (Fig. 15 (a)) in order to generate a flow obeying the applied model. Assuming now that the additional viscosity of the Brinkman model is generated by momentum mechanical dispersion, it is relevant to introduce directional effects in the new model. The main idea of the law we here investigate relies on the introduction of a flow self-organization such that it minimizes in some way the action of the matrix at the junctions. From Fig. 15 (a) to Fig. 15 (b) for example, the incoming flow has been reduced together with the flow in the vertical connector in order to reduce the matrix reaction. The objective is hence to find flow rates Qik that minimize the expression: F= F i · F i, (36) i
where F i is the solid force acting on the fluid at junction i and where the summation is carried out on the set of junctions. In a first attempt, we choose
96
Advanced Methods in Material Forming C1
Q14
C4
Q42
C2
C1
Q14
α F4
Q42
C4 α
Q43
C2
Q43
F4
C3
C3
(a)
(b)
Fig. 15. Momentum redistribution after a junction and corresponding reaction acting on the fluid: (a) linear model ; (b) modified model to generate momentum dispersion
for the connector flow the simple previous nonlinear law (34), except that the unknown loss of head parameter ik may now differ from connector to connector. The law then writes as: 2 Q2ik ρg Sik Ci − Ck − sign(Qik ) Qik = (37) 2 ik , g Sik 8Lik η or, after some algebraic manipulations, as: ρg S 2
2 8Likik η (Ci − Ck )
Qik = $ 1+
ρg S 2 4 8Likik η |Ci
−
Ck | g Sik2 ik
.
(38)
+1
In order to complete the formulation, the reaction force F i is developed as a function of Qik : –
The second Newton law applied at junction i provides the relation: " " ∂ (ρv) dV + ρv v · n dS. (39) Fi = Vi ∂t Sik k∈Junc(i)
The 1st term in the right-hand side vanishes because of stationarity while the 2nd term represents the momentum flux due to mass fluxes. Hence, the force is: Fi = − (40) P˙ik , k∈Junc(i)
where P˙ik is the incoming momentum flux across surface Sik . –
Keeping the assumption of a Poiseuille flow in the connector, it can easily be shown that the momentum flux is equal to: ρ Q2ik n . P˙ik = − 3π Sik ik
(41)
Modelling of Permeability and Mechanical Dispersion
97
Therefore, the complete formulation is finally given by: & % % Determine ik ∈ [0, 1] minimizing the expression F = i F i · F i , % ⎧ 2 & ρ Qik % F i = k∈Junc(i) 3π ⎪ % ⎪ Sik nik , ⎨ % ρg S 2 2 8L ik (Ci −Ck ) % with ik η % Q = . ik ⎪ 2 % ⎪ ρg S ik ⎩ 1+4 8L ik |C −C | +1 % i k 2 g S ik η
(42)
ik
9 1
× 10−8
8 7 Objective [N²]
0.8
ε
0.6 0.4
6 5 4 3
0.2
2
0
1 0
0.5
1
1.5
2
2.5
0
3
0
0.5
1
1.5
3.5
2.5
3
3.5
2.5
3
3.5
× 10−6 0.04 0.035
3
0.03 2.5 Head [m]
Flow rate [m³/s]
2
α (b)
α (a)
2 1.5
0.025 0.02 0.015 0.01
1 0.5
0.005 0
0.5
1
1.5
2
2.5
3
3.5
0
0
0.5
1
1.5
2
α
α
(c)
(d)
Fig. 16. Same problem as in Fig. 15 for α ∈ [0, π]: (a) values of ij generated by the modified algorithm. 14 is plotted with ‘+’ symbols, 42 with ‘o’ symbols, and 43 with ‘×’ symbols; (b) objective function F. The continuous curve represents the objective reached by means of the modified algorithm, while symbols ‘+’ refer to the case 14 = 1; 42 = 0; 43 = 0, and symbols ‘×’ to the case 14 = 1; 42 = 0; 43 = 1; (c) flow rates obtained with the modified algorithm. Q14 is plotted with ‘+’ symbols, Q42 with ‘o’ symbols, and Q43 with ‘×’ symbols; (d) Head generated at junction 4 by the modified algorithm. The ‘+’ symbols represent the head generated by the linear model.
98
Advanced Methods in Material Forming
With this formulation, the goal is to let the flow re-arrange itself by a selection of appropriate values of ik in order to increase momentum mixing and by this way to retrieve the Brinkman equation at the macroscale. Unfortunately, at this point, we are not able to confirm that our model reaches this goal. In order to solve the minimum problem (42), a Lagrangian multiplier formulation could have been used. However, the associated system is very complicated to solve. Therefore, the iterative gradient method (which can be very easily implemented) was used. It should be noted that none of these methods ensures to reach the global minimum. Fig. 16 (a) and (b) illustrates the values of ij and of the objective function F as generated by the modified algorithm for the problem defined in Fig. 15, for different angles of the adjacent connector. In each problem, the extremity heads are imposed (C1 = 0.1 m, C2 = C3 = 0 m) and the connector parameters are the same in each branch (R = 0.001 m and L = 0.01 m). It can be observed that the modified algorithm results in decreasing the incoming flow rate and hence diminishing the incoming momentum flux and the reaction at the junction. The initial objective function F (as calculated from the linear model) is then decreased by a factor 125 ! Fig. 16 (c) and (d) further shows the related flow rates and head.
5 Conclusions and Perspectives This work can be seen as representing a step in the difficult theoretical and experimental analysis of non-isothermal flows in non-isotropic porous media, taking into account the combined effects of permeability and mechanical dispersion. The classical equations of the continuous model governing flows in porous media have been presented. A 4th -order tensor has been introduced to model mechanical dispersion and has been developed in the transversely isotropic case. The flow in a thin, non-homogeneous and transversely isotropic plate has been investigated and the associated transport phenonema have been highlighted. An original experimental set-up has enabled us to perform various permeability and dispersion experiments. The main goals were (i) to demonstrate the possibility of performing experiments on media with controlled anisotropy, (ii) to validate the governing laws for permeability and dispersion in such media, and finally (iii) to deduce the medium material properties from the measurements. Whereas the analysis is not complete at this stage, it indicates that our method is appropriate for these goals. Typically, we have been able to measure the two permeability components of a transversely isotropic medium consisting of almost aligned polymeric needles. Moreover, assuming that molecular diffusion is negligible in front of hydrodynamic dispersion, we have been able to determine some components of the dispersion tensor. Indeed in this case, the fitting of Dx,y and Dy,x to
Modelling of Permeability and Mechanical Dispersion
99
the dispersion model (9) for a transversely isotropic medium gives: L⊥ = 6.5 10−3 m
and L⊥ = 2.15 10−3 m.
(43)
The unique values we have found in the literature are given by Mal et al,. (1998), who propose coefficients 2 orders of magnitude lower than these values. Obviously, the considered medium is different. In further work, the permeability measurements should be repeated for different losses of head in order to validate Darcy’s law and to exhibit the onset of Forchheimer’s or Brinkman’s regime. The tensorial form of permeability should also be verified by performing experiments with the medium symmetry direction oriented at different angles with respect to the mean flow direction. Concerning mechanical dispersion, the experimental procedure should be refined in order to determine all the dispersion tensor components. To remove the assumption of negligible total diffusion in the flow direction, supplementary experiments (including unsteady experiments) should be carried out and various boundary conditions should be implemented. In order to model the flow in a porous medium and to better understand the related physical effects, a micro-macro model has been developed on the basis of a hydraulic analogy. In a first attempt, linear losses of head in the connectors (inspired from the Poiseuille flow in a straight pipe) were introduced while mass conservation provided the way to correctly assemble the equations. It has been shown that these assumptions are sufficient to generate Darcy’s flow. Further, the simplest nonlinear loss of head was added at the junction entries in order to generate Forchheimer’s flow. It has been shown that this additional term is appropriate for this goal. Finally, with a view to reproducing the additional viscosity of Brinkman’s model and the (assumed) associated momentum dispersion, a more sophisticated law has been introduced in each connector. However, no definite conclusions could be drawn as far from this first study and hence further work is needed. Numerical experiments have been performed with the parameters adjusted to the needle-made experimental medium. In these experiments, the boundary conditions were first imposed in such a way that the parallel permeability component was playing the major role. The calculated value K = 3.5 10−10 m2 was found as very close to the experimental result (Table 2). Similar calculations for the perpendicular component gave K⊥ = 6.710−11 m2 , which is by far smaller than the experimental value. In fact, the fitting required to determine the parameters of the micro-macro model is not obvious and probably not unique. Hence, more tests are simply required to correctly determine the model parameters. In order to validate our hypothesis, which consists in interpreting the additional viscosity of Brinkman’s model as a momentum mechanical mixing effect, the present study should be extended to more refined models and supplementary tests should be carried out. Another important goal will be to deduce relevant relations between the microscopic parameters and the macroscopic physical coefficients.
100
Advanced Methods in Material Forming
The thermal problem has not been considered yet. Nevertheless, since the results obtained are very encouraging, a similar micro-macro method could be used to model the energy equation. However, in order to take into account the influence of the solid phase, a supplementary network of solid connectors and junctions should be added. Moreover transfer assumptions between the solid and fluid networks should be introduced to take into account the mixing due to microscopic transport. Investigation of the flow in a more complex geometry and, in particular, the filling of industrial fiber mats represents a typical application field that could provide possible comparisons between numerical results and experimental measurements.
References Firdaouss M., Guermond J., Quere P. L., “Non-linear corrections to Darcy’s law at low Reynolds numbers”, J. Fluid Mech., vol. 343, 1997, p. 331–350. Gilver R., Altobelli S., “A determination of the effective viscosity for the BrinkmanForchheimer flow model”, J. Fluid Mech., vol. 58, 1994, p. 355–370. Lage J., “Transport phenomena in porous media”, chapter The fundamental theory of flow through permeable media from Darcy to turbulence, p. 1–31, Elsevier Science, 1998. Loix F., Magotte O., Roger H., Dupret F., “A 3D numerical modelling of the RTM and SRIM processes”, 5th Int. ESAFORM Conf. on Material Forming, Krak´ ow, 2002, p. 307–310. Loix F., Dupret F., “Numerical Modelling of Liquid Moulding Processes”, srl N. I. E., Ed., 6th Int. Conf. on Material Forming, Salerno, 2003, p. 835–838. Loix F., “Modelling of transport phenomena in porous”, PhD thesis, UCL, Louvainla-Neuve, December 2005. Loix F., Thibaut V., Dupret F., “Micro-macro modelling of permeability and mechanical dispersion in a porous medium”, vol. 1, Cluj-Napoca, Romania, April 2005, The publishing house of the romanian academy. Mal O., Couniot A., Dupret F., “Non-isothermal simulation of the resin transfer moulding process”, Composites Part A, vol. 29, 1998, p. 189–198. Mal O., “Modelling and Numerical Simulation of Reaction Injection Moulding Processes”, PhD thesis, UCL, Louvain-la-Neuve, 1999. Nield D., Bejan A., Convection in porous media, Springer, 1998. Rudd C. D., Long A. C., Kendall K. N., Mangin C., Liquid Moulding Technologies, Woodhead, 1997. Rutherford A., Vectors, Tensors, and the Basic Equations of Fluid Mechanics, Prentice-Hall, Inc, 1962. Thibaut V., “Etude des ´ecoulements en milieux poreux anisotropes: approche th´eorique, num´erique et exp´erimentale”, Master’s thesis, UCL, 2004. Tucker C., Dessenberger R., “Flow and Rheology in Polymer Composites Manufacturing”, chapter Governing Equations for Flow and Heat Transfer in Stationary Fiber Beds, p. 257–323, Elsevier, 1994. Wang X., Thauvin F., Mohanty K., “Non Darcy flow through anisotropic porous media”, Chemical Engineering Science, vol. 54, 1999, p. 1859–1869.
Three-Dimensional Bending of Profiles by Stress Superposition S. Chatti, M. Hermes and M. Kleiner Institute of Forming Technology and Lightweight Construction, University of Dortmund, Baroper Str. 301, 44227 Dortmund, Germany,
[email protected],
[email protected],
[email protected] Summary. The paper shows a number of investigation results about threedimensional-bending of profiles. The investigations concentrated on two-dimensional bending using a conventional three-roll-bending machine with a simultaneous deflection of the profiles towards the third axis by means of a special device. The special device consists of a hydraulic cylinder giving the motion and the required force for bending in the third axis coupled with a guiding tool to guide the profile in the 3Dspace. The most important aspect of these tools is the use of the previous plastic deformation in the 2D-bending zone for an easier bending in the 3D-space through the superposition of lateral forces. By means of this machine set-up both symmetrical and asymmetrical profiles can be bent three-dimensionally and the unwanted torsion of asymmetrical profiles can be prevented through a compensation moment.
Key words: three-roll-bending, 3D-bending of profiles, superposition of stresses.
1 Introduction In recent years, the demand for aluminium and steel profiles as important structural elements in traffic systems as well as in civil engineering has increased strongly. These profiles are used in various fields of traffic engineering in a linear and bent contour (Fig. 1). Bent profiles, especially threedimensionally bent profiles, provide the design engineer with new degrees of freedom and allow the construction of structures with more advantages regarding e.g. space saving and aerodynamics. Furthermore, the lightweight construction aspect needs to be mentioned by means of which new ways, also through a three-dimensional flexibility in profile shaping, are opened up. For instance, complex parts, so far manufactured by joining different parts, can be formed from one piece with improved aerodynamic properties. In addition to their application in automotive engineering, three-dimensionally bent
102
Advanced Methods in Material Forming Traffic systems Multipurpose applications
Civil engineering
High precision requirements on straight and curved profiles Lifting and conveying systems
Machines and apparatus construction
Fig. 1. Fields of application of straight and bent profiles
profiles can be used in several fields of traffic systems like e.g. rail vehicles, utility vehicles, and aerospace. Also in the fields of architecture and design, for instance in the furniture industry, 3D-structures open up new shaping opportunities. Bent profiles as design elements have to meet highest quality demands concerning shape and measurement accuracy. A high bending quality is an important condition for subsequent production steps like assembly and welding, and can therefore reduce the costs of the entire production chain. In some of the above mentioned application fields, for instance in the automotive industry, high tolerances of curved profiles are required which can not be achieved by conventional bending procedures or only at large expenditure. In this case, the direct assembly of profiles after bending and their calibration by means of hydroforming before use have to be differentiated. By this procedure, complex three-dimensionally curved profiles can be manufactured in a single manufacturing step including reproducibility of highest quality claims. The quality of the hydroformed workpiece and the reliability of the process is, however, defined by the material and geometrical properties of the initial parts (Chatti 05). For the calibration process certain small shape deviations of the profile contour are sometimes allowed. However, this depends strongly on the complexity of the hydroforming tool contour so that keeping up high accuracy requirements in pre-bending operations represents an important precondition for reaching high process reliability in hydroforming. In case of direct assembly of the profiles after bending the quality requirements concerning
Three-Dimensional Bending of Profiles
103
shape and measurement accuracy need to be rated up. This proceeding offers, however, the advantage of economising the relatively expensive process step of hydroforming. Nowadays, three-roll-bending is one of the bending procedures mostly used in industrial manufacturing. With only one set of rolls and by setting only one axis it is possible to achieve different radii or a radii distribution along the profile length within the bending plane. In addition to the high flexibility, and thus economy of this procedure, it can achieve high quality standards, too, if suitable measures are used. Some of the measures developed in recent years at the Institute of Forming Technology and Lightweight Construction (IUL), University of Dortmund, aiming at the improvement of two-dimensional-bending of profiles are the simulation of three-roll-bending processes by means of semianalytical and finite-element programmes (Chatti 98, Chatti et al., 01), the conception and establishment of closed-loop process control systems based on algorithmic and neuro-fuzzy controllers (Chatti et al., 03), and the development of adapted methods for the reduction of the cross-sectional deformation during the bending process (Chatti et al., 99). For the three-dimensional-bending of profiles a second machine axis is required to deflect the profiles towards the third direction. At the IUL, a special device is developed for bending profiles in the 3D-space, benefiting from the previous plastic deformation in the 2D-bending zone of the threeroll-system.
2 State of the Art of the 3D-Bending of Profiles Machines for cold forming of profiles have already been used since the beginning of the twentieth century. With these machines almost all profile cross-sectional shapes can be formed to different workpiece shapes (Kajrup et al., 85). Due to the great number of possible profile cross-sections, bending shapes, demands on the component, and the lot sizes of mass-production, a variety of different bending procedures has been used in practice. Some of these procedures are limited in the applicability regarding the profile length, the profile cross-sectional shape, or the profile radius, others are not flexible and involve very high tooling expenses. The procedures of three- and fourroll-bending are universally applicable, whereby three-roll-bending represents the most frequent machine concept in industrial application because of the relatively low machine costs (Chatti et al., 99a, Chatti et al., 03a). Figure 2 shows some bending procedures which are suitable to bend profiles threedimensionally. The profile bending procedures can be subdivided into methods of “kinematic shaping” and such of “form-maintaining shaping” (shaping with shape-defining rigid tools) according to the way they are used to form the desired shape. Bending without lateral forces as well as the roll-bending procedures of two-, three-, and four-roll-bending rank among the first group.
104
Advanced Methods in Material Forming
Basic stretch bending
Tangential stretch bending
3D-unwind stretch bending
Three-roll-bending
Multi-roll bending
3D-Freeform bending
Profile bending with elastic pad
Laser bending
Rounding during extrusion
Fig. 2. Procedures for 3D-bending or rounding of profiles
The second group comprises of the procedures profile bending under presses, stretch bending, and wiper bending. Furthermore, there are more procedure variants of each procedure whose application opportunities are extended by the use of bending tools adapted to the bending task. These are partially procedures which combine bending processes of the two groups (Chatti 98). An exception is laser bending. Laser bending is a new forming technique which allows to form sheet metals and profiles by thermal residual stresses instead of external forces (Kraus 97). The kinematic bending processes are more flexible than the formmaintaining processes. The final shape of the part is not determined by the shape of the tool, but rather by the relative movements of tool and workpiece. Normally, the final shape is produced by a number of successive steps that can be changed easily from workpiece to workpiece, yielding the high flexibility of these processes. Form-maintaining shaping is defined as forming with shape-defining rigid tools that contain the desired workpiece geometry, especially with respect to the curvature, corrected by the springback of the profile during unloading. Due to the fixed geometry of the tool, the geometry of the workpiece is also fixed, leading to high reproducibility and a shorter processing time in many cases (Chatti 98, Vollertsten et al., 99). The following procedures and machine concepts have been developed under the aspect of a purposeful superposition of stresses aiming at the reduction
Three-Dimensional Bending of Profiles
105
of forming forces, profile springback, and/or cross-sectional deformation, or they have an especially high potential for bending profile components three-dimensionally. Stretch bending belongs to the procedure group with form-maintaining shaping and is mainly used in automotive industry for mass production. This procedure allows the manufacturing of three-dimensionally bent profiles as well as the insertion of an additional force for influencing the stress state in the forming zone. The principle of stretch bending, which is subdivided into the procedures tangential stretch bending and unwind stretch bending, is based on the fact that the material is completely plastified before or during bending by means of a tensile device stretching the profile in longitudinal direction. This stress superposition results in larger strains in the tensile zone and smaller strains in the compression zone of the workpiece during the subsequent bending process, leading to a displacement of the neutral fibre towards the compression zone and to reduced cross-sectional deformation and springback (Sp¨ ath 91, Sp¨ ath 91a, Sprenger 99, Weippert 97). The advantages of high shape and measurement accuracy as well as high reproducibility of stretch bending are faced, however, with the following disadvantages restricting the suitability of this procedure for mass production: – –
Low flexibility (for each profile a new tool is necessary). Very expensive tools and machines (high number of machine axes and complex tool shapes). – Increasing manufacturing costs when bending long profiles and big crosssections. A procedure variant for kinematic bending of flat materials and open profiles is the roll-bending procedure with superposition of compressive stresses. This procedure variant was carried out within the scope of a project at the IUL (at that time LFU) in the late eighties by Adelhof, Kleiner, and Liewald (Finckenstein et al., 88). In this project, a new bending variant was developed which combines both processes bending and rolling. The high efficiency of this bending variant consists in the local plastification of the bending cross-section through a longitudinal rolling process, which leads to a substantial decrease of the bending resistance and the bending forces. Figure 3 shows the principles of the roll-bending procedures with a superposition of compressive stresses. A sheet metal or angle profile is rolled between two rolls with adapted shapes and its sheet thickness is reduced in such a way that it reaches a plastification of the cross-section between the rolls. A bending device consisting of a bending roll is placed directly behind the rolling stand and moved horizontally or vertically perpendicular to the rolling direction. Following the bending roll motion, the profile is bent to the corresponding direction. The low force at the bending roll shows that the superposition of the compressive stress is mainly responsible for the creation of the profile curvature and not the bending moment.
106
Advanced Methods in Material Forming
Fig. 3. Combined rolling-bending processes
This bending variant showed the following advantages compared to a conventional bending process: – – –
Achievement of higher true strains. Reduction of the cross-sectional deformation. Improvement of the strength properties.
Regarding the 3D-bending, no investigations have been carried out so far using this procedure. In industrial manufacturing three-roll-bending is one of the most commonly used procedures for profile bending because of its high flexibility and its relatively low machine costs. With only one set of rolls and by setting only one axis it is possible to achieve different radii or a radii distribution along the profile length. Within a closed-loop process control only one axis has to be controlled as well in order to compensate material and cross-section variations (Chatti et al., 04, Chatti et al., 03). 3D-bending of profiles is not directly possible when using a conventional bending machine because the adjustment of the bending rolls leads to a profile bending in the working plane of the machine. However, some standard machines are provided with auxiliary adjustable guiding rolls which allow the bending of screws with a small pitch and hand rails for spiral staircases (through simultaneous rotation of the circular cross-section) or the compensation of twisting moments of asymmetrical profile cross-sections (N.N. 98, N.N. 05). These cases do not concern, however, 3D-bending. To bend stringer profiles for airplanes with radii between 5000 mm and 12000 mm, the company Boeing uses four-roll-bending machines of L&F (N.N. 98a). These machines are provided with a multi-axial adjustable exit roll for torsion compensation of strong asymmetrical stringer profiles and the production of small three-dimensional curvatures according to the shape of the plane fuselage. Although a superposition of stresses exists here during the 3D-bending the forming forces in the forming zone are not reduced because the third axis is still within the forming zone of the first bending plane. Here there is no division between the procedures plastification and creation of the curvature in the second plane. Due to the high forces acting on the profile only open profiles can be formed, but no profiles with undercuts like e.g. double-Tprofiles or C-profiles. Nor can Profiles with high true strains (tight radii, high webs) be bent by this procedure. Hollow profiles are not intended because
Three-Dimensional Bending of Profiles
107
of the expected high cross-sectional deformation. This procedure seems to be suitable for large radii used in airplane industry. However, it is not usable for complex contours with tight radii or radii distributions as those in profiles for automotive industry. To further improve the workpiece guidance during bending, also multi-rollbending machines are used in industry. These machines enable the bending of profile curvatures in opposite direction as well as the production of threedimensionally bent profiles. Such 3D-shapes (mainly alternate bending) can only be achieved, however, when bending tubes (circular cross-section). In recent years, also full flexible 3D-freeform bending machines have been developed which are based on the principle of kinematic shaping. The working principle of these machines consists in placing the profile within a guiding device before forming. The profile is afterwards pushed by means of a pusher through a fixed bending tool and through a movable die. The profile bending is produced by a given motion of the die at a simultaneous feed-in motion of the longitudinal profile axis. Due to the kinematic shaping a tool change is not necessary when changing the bending contour for the same profile crosssections, only a new definition of the relative motion between profile feed-in and fixed as well as movable tool is required (Neugebauer et al., 01). This machine concept is characterised by a restricted profile (tube) length due to the limited length of the pusher. In addition, the forming forces dependence of the profile stiffness and the lever arm length is relatively high compared to the kinematic procedure of three-roll-bending. Accordingly, the propulsion technology of the machine is very expensive. In coherence with the high forming forces, cross-sectional deformations and friction problems at the deflecting dies are to be taken into consideration. This procedure idea has been realised in different machine concepts. Well known examples are the Hexabend (Neugebauer et al., 01), MiiC (N.N. 05a, N.N. 05b), and Nissin (N.N. 05c, N.N. 05d) machines. During the kinematic procedure profile bending with elastic pad the profile is formed between a rigid roll and a polyurethane pad. The roll is pivoted and can be moved vertically. The die is embedded in a rigid steel retainer which can be moved horizontally. The profile is pressed into the pad by the vertical motion of the roll. The pressure on the profile produces the bending moment necessary for forming (Geiger et al., 95, Arnet 99). By using this process it is possible, in principle, to bend profiles to spiral shapes and, thus, 3D-contours. The profiles have to be placed on the pad with a certain angle to the motion direction of the retainer. A similar forming result could be achieved when the bending roll axis would be arranged not laterally, but inclined to the retainer direction. Here, the high control expenditure which is necessary for the production of reproducible components is problematic. When extending the procedure for 3D-profiles the variation of the influencing parameters will also increase inevitably. Another disadvantage for 2D- and 3D-shapes is the restricted profile length due to the limited pad. Furthermore, a second restriction to some kinds of profiles needs to be taken into account
108
Advanced Methods in Material Forming
due to the limited loadability of the polyurethane pad. Only profiles with low bending resistance can be bent by this procedure. For the manufacturing of curved profiles made of non-metallic materials the rounding during extrusion, which has been developed at the Institute of Forming Technology and Lightweight Construction of the University of Dortmund, competes with the above mentioned bending procedures. In this procedure with kinematic shaping the workpiece is directly rounded during bar extrusion. An external guiding tool applies a lateral force directly after the extrusion die to the leaving profile so that it is deflected (Arendes 99, Arendes et al., 99, Arendes et al., 00, Kleiner et al., 00, Klaus 02). The profile forms a circle with a radius depending on the position of the guiding tool in relation to the die. By varying the position of the guiding tool during the extrusion process it is even possible to form shapes with varying radii or combinations of curved and straight shapes. The rounding of the profile is provoked by the change of velocity distribution in the die due to superposed tensile and compression stresses as well as by lateral forces. Because the material in the extrusion die is fully plastic the procedure shows outstanding properties regarding the manufacturing of 2D- and 3D-curved profiles. In comparison with bending processes, rounding during extrusion shows some advantages like unreduced profile formability, low cross-sectional deformation, low residual stresses, and, above all, very low profile springback. However, the procedure is limited to certain minimum profile radii which do not cause a collision with the extrusion die opening. Thus, rounding during extrusion is not suitable for the manufacturing of very tight radii. Furthermore, only extrudable alloys (extruded profiles) can be formed, which strongly reduces the comparability with bending processes (Becker et al., 03). In these cases, the procedure rounding during extrusion can not replace the bending process. The basics of this procedure and the manufacturing of constant as well as variable two-dimensional curvatures have been already investigated. The production of 3D-curved profiles requires, however, the use of a multi-axial guiding tool and is being investigated within the scope of a part project of the Collaborative Research Centre Transregio (SFB/TR10) of the German Research Foundation (DFG).
3 Design of a Suitable Procedure for 3D-Bending The bending procedures mentioned in the state of the art chapter aim at solving the classical problems of profile bending. These are very complex and versatile; however, they can be listed simply in a few points: –
Cross-sectional deformations which can be wrinkles in the compression zone, wall thickness reductions in the tensile zone, reductions of the crosssection height, etc. To this group also belongs the problem of torsion when bending asymmetrical profiles.
Three-Dimensional Bending of Profiles
109
–
Inaccurate bending contour which results from an unknown bending behaviour often connected with variations of the profile material. – Technical material changes which arise during the bending process and have a significant influence on the component usability. Material hardening and, for example, too high residual stresses count to this phenomenon. For this problem list different solution approaches are available, whereby the procedure stretch bending, roll-bending with superposed compression stress, and rounding during extrusion can be evaluated as very promising. The common ground is the superposition of stress states in bending and rounding respectively. This leads to an additional plastification of the material in the bending zone, which is obviously advantageous for the forming process. Rounding during extrusion offers solution approaches for the whole problem spectrum, including the material and springback problems because the material in the die of the extrusion press is fully plastic. Thus, cross-sectional deformations are reduced and the material receives no significant hardening effects in forming. The other mentioned procedures try to approximate a plastic state at room temperature. In stretch bending, for example, this state is reached through a superposition of a tensile stress, in the combined rolling-bending procedure through the superposition of a compression stress. This proves the importance of a workpiece pre-plastification, whereby the three mentioned procedures also show obvious disadvantages or restrictions (see state of the art) which justify new considerations for the realisation of a new procedure variant. For these reasons it was necessary to carry out pre-investigations in order to develop a new bending procedure for the 3D-bending of profiles. It seemed to be reasonable to find and systematically investigate new opportunities for the purposeful influencing of the forming zone in the sense of superposition of stresses. The aim of designing a procedure which exhibits the advantages of kinematic shaping and which also keeps the cross-sectional deformations and springback low is achievable by the combination of a procedure for the purposeful plastification of the forming zone with a kinematic procedure for the creation of the desired curvature. Examples for such tendencies are described in the state of the art chapter. This advisement in conjunction with the second demand to develop a concept for the 3D-bending of profiles requires a systematic proceeding, taking into account the question: which combinations of bending procedures for the creation of the 3D-contour with the forming procedures according to DIN 8582 (Lange 90) for the plastification of the forming zone are reasonable? To create new procedure variants, a proceeding for design systematics recommended in (Pahl et al., 04) has been chosen. Thus, a schema could be established which arranges the procedures according to DIN 8582, belonging to the groups of compression, compression-tensile, tensile, bending, and shear forming in combination with a bending procedure. Due to the claimed
110
Advanced Methods in Material Forming
flexibility in the 3D-efficiency of the procedure the parameter of kinematic shaping of the actual bending process was kept constant in this combination strategy. As a result, already known procedures arose from this proceeding, but also new innovative approaches whose technical feasibility had to be evaluated afterwards. From these possible procedure combinations the superposition of the threeroll-bending for plastification of the forming zone with the flexible procedure of freeform bending for 3D-bending was selected for the realisation. Because bending represents the simplest forming variant for a profile, the insertion of a bending stress into a favourable plane involving the lowest cross-sectional deformation can be used in order to plasticize the material locally. Afterwards, a second bending procedure can be superposed which produces the desired profile contour. The selection of the three-roll-bending is justified by the wide industrial use, high flexibility, and low tool and machine costs of this procedure. Another advantage is the fact that the combination of these two procedures can be seen as an extension of a conventional three-roll-bending machine. The kinematic 3D-bending of the profile running through the rolls can be carried out by means of a deflecting device influencing the forming process between the three rolls. The profile curvature, which is normally created by three-roll-bending, could also be irrelevant so that the first process only serves the creation of the aforesaid plastic and partly plastic zone respectively. Irrespective of these aspects, the actual curvature is produced kinematically. The cost effectiveness given by this procedure idea should be emphasised. In all other possibilities found higher costs are expected due to more complex technology or higher forces. Figure 4 shows the tool arrangement of the combined procedure which has been realised at the Institute of Forming Technology and Lightweight Construction.
Three-roll arrangement
z
d x Movable deflecting tool
y
Motion direction of the profile
Fig. 4. Superposed three-roll-bending with subsequent profile deflection
Three-Dimensional Bending of Profiles
111
4 Machine Set-Up and Working Principle The experimental set-up for this new way of profile bending consists of two essential parts. First, there is a conventional CNC-three-roll-bending-machine available at the IUL used for the bending in the first plane. The only change made at this machine is a special drive system to couple and to drive the first roll by the middle roll. This is the solution for expected friction problems between profiles and rolls. The second important part of the set-up for the realisation of the experiments is a special device that makes it possible to deflect the profiles towards the third axis directly after the first bending process. The force for the bending in this axis is given by a hydraulic cylinder which is charged by a proportional valve controlled by a measuring PC. The path measurement is integrated in the cylinder. The controlling programme is realised with the lab software DIAdem. A hydraulic power unit produces the pressure for the cylinder. For the first experimental phase the only moving axis is the hydraulic cylinder (z-axis). The remaining degrees of freedom (x and y-axis) are realised without a drive. They are operated manually and then fixed by clamp-connections. This is satisfactory for the first experiments because they can be made in each position by moving only the z-axis. Figure 5 and 6 show the CAD-model of the machine with the designation of the axis and a photo of the machine during an early bending experiment. To reach a high stiffness, the machine frame is designed as a welded construction built of great hollow bending beams. This increases the accuracy of the whole machine and the reproducibility of the results. The guidance of the profile after leaving the three-roll-system works with a window fixed on the hydraulic cylinder axis and furnished with Teflon-plackets to reduce the friction at the contact zone.
Hydraulic axis
d z
y x
Three-roll-bending machine Machine frame
Fig. 5. Machine set-up
112
Advanced Methods in Material Forming
Fig. 6. Bending device for 3D-profiles
5 First Investigation Results The developed procedure and the realised machine set-up allow the investigation of following scenarios: – – – – –
2D-bending of symmetrical profiles with variable concave and/or convex curvature, 3D-bending of symmetrical profiles with constant or variable curvature, 2D-bending of asymmetrical profiles with twisting compensation, 3D-bending of asymmetrical profiles with constant or variable curvature, and 2D or 3D-bending of profiles with superposition of twisting stresses. This is possible with an additional twisting unit coupled with the hydraulic cylinder.
The objective of the procedure investigations was to prove the existence of certain effects which have the potential for improvements in the area of threedimensional bending of profiles. It was important to highlight some tendencies for solutions of classical bending problems which are not solved or only solved with high efforts by many other procedures. First experiments carried out at the IUL include investigations to achieve 2D and 3D-bent symmetrical profiles. As symmetrical profiles, a hot-rolled
Three-Dimensional Bending of Profiles
113
hollow section (20 × 20 × 2 mm) made of S 235 (EN 10 025), and an extruded profile with the same cross-section made of AlMgSi0.5 were chosen. The advantages offered by these simple and compact profiles are a small deformation of the cross-section and low bending forces causing no problems with the stiffness of the machine and no bending problems in first experiments, thus allowing to concentrate on the effects of the procedure. Due to the high number of degrees of freedom, and therewith the great variety of influencing factors, a lot of possibilities to set the machine parameters are available. To limit the investigation expenditure, the experiments had to be reduced to some significant combinations of influencing factors, but still allowing to get first statements about the combined process. The arrangement of the rolls and the deflecting tool is shown schematically in Fig. 7. Also important are here the machine zero points which should be selected in order to enable a comparison between the different experimental results. The zero point of the d-axis is defined as the position in which the profile has a force-free contact (no curvature) with all three rolls. The zero point for the x-axis is put on the axis of the second adjustable roll; the distance to the deflecting tool represents the axis value. The zero point of the y-axis is situated on the axis of the fixed middle roll. Similar to the d-axis, the
Three-roll arrangement
d=0 y=0
dpos
ycur
x=0
Rollenabstand a
xpos
xcur Deflecting device with hydraulic z-axis y pos
Profile position at d = 0 mm Machine frame
Fig. 7. Schematic representation of the axis system of the machine
114
Advanced Methods in Material Forming
z
5
force-free contact between profile and deflecting tool in the z-axis is the position of the zero point. For 3D-bending of profiles both the 3-roll-bending machine (d-axis in xyplane) and the hydraulic device (z-axis) have been adjusted and synchronised to each other in order to produce the desired profile contour (Fig. 8). The first profile bending in the xy-plane has been superposed with the second one, which is defined by the position of the hydraulic device and the leading window in the x, y, and z-axis. The most extreme position for the y-axis, for example, is the inversion of the contour reached in three-roll-bending. To use and to make evident the advantage of the previous plastic deformation in the three-roll-bending zone for an easier bending in the orthogonal plane, different roll adjustment values (d = 0 mm, 13 mm, and 16 mm) have been selected at the middle roll and a superposed force of the hydraulic cylinder with the same adjustment value for the z-axis of 40 mm has been used. In order to obtain a better comparability of the results, the adjustment of the y-axis has been selected in such a way that the bending within the
R 41
9
R 71
y x
Fig. 8. 3D-bending of profiles by superposition of bending stresses
x = const. y = const. z = const.
d = 16 mm d = 13 mm d = 0 mm
Radius in mm
2000 1500
d = 13 mm, z = 40 mm, y = –35 mm
1000 500 d = 16 mm, z = 40 mm, y = –35 mm 0
0
50
100 150 Profile length in mm
200
250
Fig. 9. Influence of previous plastification on bending radii
Three-Dimensional Bending of Profiles
115
three-roll-system is neutralised by the deflecting tool. This is reached by an adjustment of the y-axis of −35 mm. Thus, only a curvature in xz-plane is created. After an evaluation of the produced contours by means of the coordinate measuring machine PRISMO VAST 5 HTG of the company Zeiss the bending results in the form of radii distributions can be seen in Fig. 9. The radii variations are attributed to surface unevenness, variations of the friction ratio during the process, and variable profile properties. It was found out that the greater the middle roll adjustment causing a higher previous plastic deformation of the profiles the greater the profile curvature (smaller profile radius) in the third plane will be. A cause for the curvature increase is the decrease of the profile springback due to the stress superposition. A control of the profile contour and a minimisation of the springback values for all profiles would be possible in future developments after more precise investigations of the process parameters.
Ground plate with high stiffness
Force sensor 14
Force in z-axis in kN
12 10 8
d = 0 mm, z = 50 mm
6
d = 13 mm, z = 50 mm d = 16 mm, z = 50 mm
4 2 0
0
5
10
15 Time in s
20
25
30
Fig. 10. Force measurement set-up and influence of previous plastification on bending forces
116
Advanced Methods in Material Forming
In direct correlation with the produced radii it is of interest to make a statement about the forming forces prevailing in the machine axis which are responsible for the bending moment. To investigate the influence of the previous plastification on the bending forces, a device for force measurement consisting of a force sensor put on a stiff plate in the z-axis has been used (Fig. 10). This device allows the direct measurement of the force values in the deflecting tool. The investigations have shown that an increase of the d-adjustment causes a decrease of the bending force in z-axis. For comparison reasons two profiles have been bent without d-adjustment (without plastification, only use of the guiding characteristics of the rolls). In this case, higher force values are shown with the same selected adjustments of the z-axis. The force decrease due to pre-plastification should be related to a smaller crosssectional deformation of the profiles. These results emphasise the importance of the previous material plastification for reaching the advantages described in Sect. 2.
6 Summary For the manufacturing of 3D-curved profiles with arbitrary contours, as e.g. significant lightweight structure elements, expensive procedures and machines as well as procedures with low flexibility regarding contour changes are used at present. These negative aspects affect the field of prototyping and the trend to reduce the number of parts because of an increasing individuality request by the customer. This leads to the demand for a profile bending procedure allowing a free definable contour which can be manufactured and changed at anytime without high tool costs. In this paper, a new procedure variant for the flexible 3D-bending of profiles, based on the aspect of stress superposition, is presented. The procedure variant is based on the superposition of the kinematic three-roll-bending with a procedure of freeform bending. The combination of these procedures creates a design division between a plastification of the profile in the forming zone of three-roll-bending and a kinematic production of the bending contour by a subsequently arranged deflection device. The aim of the superposition of stresses is the extension of the procedure limits, i.e. the increase of the maximal achievable curvatures at a simultaneous reduction of the forming forces, and thus of the cross-sectional deformations. The efforts aim at the change of the producible shape with high flexibility and without high tool expenditure by means of the kinematic shaping. The feasibility of the procedure and the use of the previous plastic deformation to improve or facilitate the threedimensional-bending of profiles have been shown in this paper. To achieve accurate profile contours in the 3D-space which meet the high demands of the industrial practice, a specific control of the bending device adjustment is necessary.
Three-Dimensional Bending of Profiles
117
References Arendes D., Direkte Fertigung gerundeter Aluminiumprofile beim Strangpressen. Dr.Ing. thesis, University of Dortmund, Shaker Verlag Aachen, 1999. Arendes D., Chatti S., Kleiner M., “Forming of Aluminium Extrusions for Structural Elements”, 6th ICTP – International Conference on Technology of Plasticity, Nuremberg, 1999, p. 2337–2342. Arendes D., Kleiner M., Kalz S., Kopp R., “Strangpressen gerundeter Aluminiumprofile”, Aluminium, vol. 76 (2000) no. 3, p. 141–148. Arnet H., Profilbiegen mit kinematischer Gestalterzeugung, Dr.-Ing. thesis, University of Erlangen-Nuremberg, Meisenbach Verlag Bamberg, 1999. Becker D., Klaus A., Kleiner M., “Innovative Fertigung von 3D-gekr¨ ummten Strangpressprofilen”, ZWF, issue 9, 2003. Chatti S., Optimierung der Fertigungsgenauigkeit beim Profilbiegen, Dr.-Ing. thesis, University of Dortmund, Shaker Verlag Aachen, 1998. Chatti S., Finckenstein E. v., Kleiner M., “Reduktion der Querschnittsverformung beim Biegen von Profilen”, Blech Rohre Profile, vol. 46 (1999) no. 3, p. 38–42. Chatti S., Finckenstein E. v., Kleiner M., “Verfahrenskombination steigert Flexibilit¨ at beim Biegen von Profilen”, Maschinenmarkt, vol. 11 (1999) no. 3, p. 26–30. Chatti S., Klimmek Ch., Kleiner M., “System for Optimisation of Product and Process Design in Profile Bending”, Proceedings of the 4th International ESAFORM Conference on Material Forming, Liege, April 23–25, 2001, vol. 2 (2001), p. 785– 788. Chatti S., Dirksen U., Kleiner M., “Process Control Strategies for Profile Bending”, Proceedings of the 10th SheMet International Conference on Sheet Metal, Ulster, Northern of Ireland, April 14–16, 2003, p. 313–320. Chatti S., Heller B., Ridane N., Kleiner M., “Anpassungsf¨ ahig – Prozesskette zur Herstellung von Leichtbaustrukturen aus Tailor Rolled Blanks”, Maschinenmarkt, vol. 7, 2003, p. 24–27. Chatti S., Dirksen U., Kleiner M., “Optimization of the Design and Manufacturing Process of Bent Profiles”, Journal of the Mechanical Behaviour of Materials, vol. 15, no. 6, 2004, ISSN 0334-8938, p. 437–444. Chatti S., Production of Profiles for Lightweight Structures, habilitation thesis, University of Franche-Comt´e, France, books on demand, 2005. Finckenstein E. v., Adelhof A., Kleiner M., “Erweiterung der Verfahrensgrenzen beim Hochkantbiegen im Walzrundverfahren”, Blech Rohre Profile, vol. 35 (1988) no. 10, p. 783–787. Geiger M., Arnet H., Engel U., Vollertsen F., “Flexibles Biegen stranggepresster Aluminium-Profile”, Blech Rohre Profile, vol. 42 (1995) no. 1, p. 31–34. Kajrup G., Klein W., “Profilrundbiegen – Anwendung und Entwicklung”, Blech Rohre Profile, vol. 32 (1985) no. 8, p. 419–423. Klaus A., Verbesserung der Fertigungsgenauigkeit und der Prozesssicherheit des Rundens beim Strangpressen, Dr.-Ing. thesis, University of Dortmund, Shaker Verlag Aachen, 2002. Kleiner M., Arendes D., Klaus A., “Verfahren und Vorrichtung zur Ver¨ anderung der Austrittsrichtung des Pressgutes beim Strangpressen” German Patent, 10.02.2000.
118
Advanced Methods in Material Forming
Kraus J., Laserstrahlumformen von Profilen, Dr.-Ing. thesis, University of ErlangenNuremberg, Meisenbach Verlag, 1997. Lange K., Umformtechnik, Handbuch f¨ ur Industrie und Wissenschaft, vol. 3: Blechumformung, Springer, Berlin, 1990. Neugebauer R., Blau P., Drossel W-G., “3D-Freiformbiegen von Profilen”, ZWG, 2001, p. 11–12. N. N., Vorrichtung zum Wendelbiegen, company brochure, Franz Thoman Maschinenbau, 1998. N.N., General Overview CNC Contour Roll Forming Machine, company brochure, October 1998, USA. N. N., www.kaercher-zell.de, Website K¨ archer GmbH, 2005. N.N., www.miic.de. Website of MiiC & Co GmbH, 2005. N.N., Multi-Bender, company brochure, MiiC & Co GmbH, 2005. N.N., Highly improved Functions and Productivity for Tube Bending, company brochure, Nissin Precision Machines Co., Ltd., 2005. N.N., www.nissin-precision.de, Website Nissin Precision machines Co., Ltd., 2005. Pahl G., Beitz W., Feldhusen J., Grote K.-H., Konstruktionslehre, 5th edition., Springer, 2004. Sp¨ ath W., “Gute Chancen – Gebogene Rahmenprofile aus Magnesium mit komplizierten Querschnitten automatisch herstellen in Großserien”, Maschinenmarkt, W¨ urzburg, vol. 97 (1991) no. 29, p. 56–61. Sp¨ ath W, “Biegen großer Strangpressprofile f¨ ur Aluminiumwagen”, Aluminium, vol. 67 (1991) no. 6, p. 556–557. Sprenger A., Adaptives Streckbiegen von Aluminium-Strangpressprofilen, Dr.-Ing. thesis, University of Erlangen-Nuremberg, Meisenbach Verlag Bamberg, 1999. Vollertsten F., Sprenger A., Krause J., Arnet H., “Extrusion Channel and Profile Bending – A Review”, Journal of Materials Processing Technology, vol. 87 (1999) p. 1–27. Weippert R. G., Das adaptive Streckbiegen von Aluminiumhohlprofilen, ein Beitrag zum integrierten Technologie-und Innovationsmanagement, VDI Report, 2: Fertigungstechnik, no. 438, Dr.-Ing. thesis, ETH Zurich, 1997.
Specimen for a Novel Concept of Biaxial Tension Test – Design and Optimisation W. Hußn¨ atter, M. Merklein and M. Geiger Chair of Manufacturing Technology, Friedrich-Alexander-University of Erlangen-Nuremberg, 91058 Erlangen, Germany,
[email protected],
[email protected],
[email protected] Summary. Although in times of highest significance of process modelling and numerical simulation yield loci get more and more important, these characteristic values do only exist for a few materials primarily at room temperature. In this paper a novel concept of an experimental setup is introduced, with which plastic yielding of sheet metal can be examined also at elevated temperatures. The design of specimen is of great importance for the quality of experimental results, because stress conditions and with it forming behaviour are constituted. Thus, it must be optimized in consideration of stress singularities at corners and for achieving stress states, which are comparable to those of previous yield locus examinations. Most information and details can be obtained from finite element simulation.
Key words: sheet metal forming, FE-simulation, yield locus.
1 Introduction Numerical simulation by using finite element method is state of the art not only at scientific institutes but also in industry. However, the quality of computational results is just as good as the abstract model, i.e. modelling of geometry, kinematics and of course material properties, which are of primary importance in case of mechanical simulation of forming process. Depending on the specific theory which is used to describe the material behaviour several variables (e.g. tensile strength, anisotropy, yield locus and others) can be taken into account for modelling sheet metal forming. In comparison with parameters that are determined in uniaxial experiments (e.g. uniaxial tensile test) yield locus defines a starting point of plastification as a function of biaxial stress condition (Fig. 1). Since a priori calculation of this material curve is not possible, experimental investigations are necessary. Although determination of yield locus
120
Advanced Methods in Material Forming
Fig. 1. Experiments necessary for determination of yield loci
requires great efforts and no internationally standardized procedure is established, it is mostly used in favour because of its consistent representation of material characteristics according to real sheet metal forming process. Additionally, application of yield loci enables the qualification and even quantification of hardening behaviour of unknown materials (Grewolls et al., 01; M¨ uller 96).
2 Novel Experimental Setup A novel experimental setup was designed at the Chair of Manufacturing Technology (LFT) to determine yield loci of sheet metals and in particular at elevated temperatures (Geiger et al., 03). A scheme of it is shown in Fig. 2. Since an international standardisation of procedure for determination of yield locus is still missing several different techniques have been developed. But they all use identical strategy for specimen’s loading: in plane (Banabic et al., 98; Hoferlin et al., 98; Kuwabara et al., 02). Contrary to them, the setup which is introduced in (Geiger, van der Heyd et al., 05) is based on a punchmotion perpendicular to the sheet. Clamping the sheet causes reaction forces in the specimen arms and consequently leads to an elongation. Assuming that the central region of the sheet over the punch is ideal rigid and therefore undilated and neglecting the radii of die and punch the extension of the specimen within this stretch-forming process (Fig. 3) can be exclusively expressed by geometrical values: 2 h2 + li2 = (li + Δli ) , (1a) and so the elongation can be calculated with
Novel Concept of Biaxial Tension Test
121
Fig. 2. Scheme of the novel experimental setup developed at LFT
Δli =
h2 + li2 − li .
The strain is defined as the elongation related to the initial length: + 2 h Δli εi = = + 1 − 1. li li
(1b)
(2)
Equation 2 shows that the strains in a specimen are only depending on each arm length. Thus, a systematic selection of different geometries allows variable settings for stress conditions in the specimen. A very important feature of this setup is the possibility of local heating of the specimen. Experimental investigations up to 300◦ C can be realised to achieve material data at elevated temperatures. As heating source a 210 W-diode laser with a special optical characteristics is used, which enables a ring-profile of the beam, where the inner (di ) and the outer diameter (do ) are continuously variable (see Fig. 4).
Fig. 3. Elongation of the specimen due to clamping between die and blank holder
122
Advanced Methods in Material Forming
Fig. 4. Scheme of a profile of the laser beam used for the LFT-setup
3 Specimens’ Geometry Using a completely new experimental set-up means to design a novel and special specimen. Starting with theoretical and analytical investigations on the stress distribution in the origin cruciform geometry the notch effect of the cross is determined. In order to achieve homogenous stress distribution the specimen’s design is optimised based on FE-simulation.
3.1 Analytical Modelling Notch Effect Stress concentration in consequence of notch effects is a common problem for components dimensioning. Standard load cases like the uniaxial tension test are listed in tables and diagrams or can be calculated with a so called shape number (αk ), which defines the well known relation between the maximum stress (σmax ) and the nominal stress (σn ) in (3) and Fig. 5. σmax = αk · σn
(3)
The shape number depends on geometrical quantities and some special factors, which differ for each load case. As it is shown in (Geiger, Hußn¨ atter et al., 05) it can be calculated to αk = 12.95, i.e. the maximum stress in the corner is about 13 times higher than the nominal stress in the centre of the specimen. Stress Analysis The stress distribution in the sheet can be expressed by analysing the linear elastic stress state. Using a complex variable Green and Zerna were able to state the solution of the basic equations of theory of elasticity in a simplified way (Green et al., 54). England formulated the stress singularity in the corner
Novel Concept of Biaxial Tension Test
123
Fig. 5. Stress singularity in a tensile specimen due to the notch effect
basing on an adequate description for the stress analysis of a wedge (England 71). Applying the boundary conditions of the loaded cruciform specimen the stress along an edge can be given as a logarithmic function of the distance to the notch base (Geiger 2 et al., 05): σx = X + Y log (r)
(4a)
with the two constants
2 2 1+ + log (e) 3π 3π σn ≈ 0.905σn and X= 1 1 2 1+ + log (e) 1− 3π 3π 2 4 − 3π σn ≈ −0.590σn . Y = 1 2 1 1+ 1− + log (e) 3π 3π 2 1−
(4b)
Figure 6 illustrates the standardised stress calculated with the stress analysis in comparison to the simulated stress of a FE-model. Both curves show a similar characteristic: The raise of the nominal stress at the origin (r = 0) is followed by a distinct decrease with growing distance to the corner. Deviations of both curves are caused by simplifications of modelling the analytical and simulative approach. Recapitulating, the theory of elasticity is very extensive and the results achieved do not fit with the results of FE-simulation. Therefore, it is not an adequate tool for analysing the stress state of biaxial sheet metal tensile testing.
124
Advanced Methods in Material Forming
Fig. 6. Standardised stress for analytical and FE-model
3.2 Numerical Simulation Main Parameters of FE-Simulation Figure 7 shows the real specimen and its model for FE-simulation. In the left picture the specimen is coated with a stochastic pattern necessary for optical strain measurement. Obviously, its geometry is double-symmetric and therefore reduction on a fourth of the model is aspired. The diameter of the outer circle is 230 mm, that of the inner one is 200 mm. The cross-arms have a width of 30 mm, they are arranged perpendicular to each other and so build an angle of 90◦ . This break causes stress concentrations which have to be avoided by developing a special designed geometry for specimen. The,essential data of different FE-model types are compared in Table 1, where symbolises the modelling of the whole specimen. Other shapes of geometry are the cruciform specimen (+), where the round area which is clammed during the experiment is omitted, and only a quarter of the specimen (L) because of its double-symmetric property.
Fig. 7. Real cruciform specimen (left) and corresponding FE-model (right)
Novel Concept of Biaxial Tension Test
125
Table 1. Real cruciform specimen (left) and corresponding FE-model (right) + + + L element type no. of elements no. of nodes friction no. of increments CPU-time (h)
C3D8I 16012 32017 no 49 2.65
C3D8R 20925 41038 no 55 2.42
C3D8I 14898 30580 no 73 4.40
C3D8R 14898 30580 no 40 0.95
C3D8I 14898 30580 yes 94 4.92
C3D8I 8246 12936 yes 117 1.73
It is a fact, that the lower the invest for computation is the faster a numerical result can be calculated, even though it is more imprecise. Therefore an optimised net of finite elements must be determined for each work piece that is investigated. Bigger elements can be used in parts of the geometry of marginal stress and strain gradients, whereas smaller elements are necessary in regions of high expected gradients for the exact calculation. In case of the cruciform specimen (Fig. 7), which is drawn by the rolls of the punch two regions are of special interest: On the one hand the central part of the specimen with stress concentration due to the 90◦ -angle between the arms and on the other hand that part of each arm, where contact with the punch occurs. All models are built up by 8-node linear brick elements (C3D8), but for those two different integration methods can be used. Equilibrium is aimed at 8 integration points (i.e. one for each node) for type C3D8I, whereas C3D8Relements use the reduced integration, i.e. only one integration point in the centre. Of course this method leads to a decreasing calculation time which is comparable to a reduction of elements’ number. But at the same time the results become inexactly due to averaged values in fields of large stressgradients. Therefore, it is not acceptable to calculate with reduced integration, so simplification of the model itself is the only way to achieve higher computational speed. For further investigation that geometry which represents only a quarter of the specimen is chosen. Since the punch is moved with a velocity of only a few tenth of a millimetre per minute the process is quasi-static and therefore the implicit solver of ABAQUS standard is used. Friction is included as pure rolling and can be calculated with a friction coefficient μR = 0.00625, i.e. 2.5% of μH , the coefficient for dynamic friction. It has no influence on convergence behaviour and no significant effects on calculation time. Improvement of Stress Distribution Biaxial loading of a cruciform specimen let expect stress-concentration where two arms coincide. Bending effects by the force transmission of the punch can
126
Advanced Methods in Material Forming
Fig. 8. FE-simulation of loading an AA 6016
also cause major stresses where the punch gets in contact with the specimen, on the rotating rolls. This fact is confirmed by a FE-simulation (Fig. 8). The calculations have been done for the aluminium alloy AA 6016 which is not only a well known, but also very important material for automotive industry and other fields of light weight applications. The simulations are based on flow curves which were experimentally determined in tensile tests according to DIN 10002. Moving the punch 5 mm a maximum von Mises stress of 42 N/mm2 occurs at the corner and also the stresses on the rolls (34 N/mm2 ) highly exceed that in the centre of the specimen (12 N/mm2 ). Thus, this origin cruciform shape is not qualified for the novel setup. As a consequence different strategies are applied to influence the distribution of stresses and strains. Maximum strains should occur in the centre of the specimen and stress concentrations should be reduced to a minimum. Achieving these aims four different alternatives are calculated: To defuse the 90◦ -angle each arms are connected with a 4 mm radius in model A. Besides, different shapes of kerfs – a circle of 1 mm diameter for model B and a special designed kerf with radii of 2 mm and 15 mm for model C – are integrated to achieve some release in the corner region. Six slits (width 0.5 mm, length 30 mm) in each arm are supposed to control strain distribution in model D, as it is in principle also used in (Kuwabara et al., 02). Figure 9 illustrates the shapes of the different models and their effects on stress distribution. Each calculation is based on the same preconditions and material data as the FE-simulation in Fig. 8. Obviously, the radius of model A has no significant influence on the distribution of von Mises stress in the specimen’s centre, but maximum stress in the corner region is explicitly reduced. The circle-kerf in B does not release the corner, even in contrast the maximum stress increases. The variation of the kerf in model C leads to higher strains in the centre region, but stress
Novel Concept of Biaxial Tension Test
127
Fig. 9. Different geometry shapes and calculated stress distributions
is still to low outside this area. An adequate arrangement of the six slits in each arm – as it is done for model D – allows a precise control of maximum stresses and strains to the centre. Of course stress concentration still appears at the end of slits next to the centre. But these values are – related to the stresses in the centre – the smallest compared to the other models (origin, A–C). In addition, the maximum stresses are localised on a surrounding of 0.5 mm. Table 2 emphasizes the impressions of Fig. 9. Some characteristic values of the models A–D are compared to the origin shape of the cruciform specimen. Although model A is the only alternative which reduces the absolute value of maximum stress in the corner, it is not qualified due to the high strains on the rolls that are of about 2.5 times higher than the strains in the centre. Also the maximum stresses in model B are not acceptable. Some progress can be seen in the transfer of the kerf from model B to C, but still inadequately. Major problem in this case are the strains on the rolls, which lead to starting plastification outside the forming zone.
Table 2. Stresses and strains of different specimen shapes
2
σcorner (N/mm ) εcenter (%) σcorner /σcenter εroll /εcenter σcorner /σorigin εcenter /εorigin
origin
A
B
C
D
42 0.24 3.47 1.81 1.00 1.00
37 0.23 3.26 2.56 0.94 0.96
63 0.26 4.97 1.71 1.43 1.06
46 0.30 3.08 1.54 0.88 1.24
59 0.41 2.89 0.97 0.83 1.70
128
Advanced Methods in Material Forming
The slits in model D are the preferred solution. It is the only sample on which the strains in the center are less than on the rolls. This is an important precondition for successful determination of a yield locus diagram. This fact is punctuated by the very high εcenter /εorigin -rate of 1.70. In addition the ratio of stresses in the center and in the corner of the specimen is significantly reduced compared to the origin cruciform one of only 83%.
4 Conclusions and Outlook In this paper a novel experimental setup for biaxial tension test is introduced. Therefore, a new approach of specimen is designed and investigated with analytical methods. For further optimisation of the geometrical shape first a FE-model has to be created and after that geometrical variations of specimen are analysed. It must be pointed out, that stress singularities resulting from the cruciform shape of the specimen can not be modelled only by the usage of a separately calculated shape number or the very extensive theory of elasticity. Thus FE-simulation promises a great potential for the most realistic modelling of the process and the occurring stresses. Calculating only a quarter of specimen’s geometry has no influence on simulation results, but leads to a much higher performance of calculation (about 2.85 times) due to the lesser number of finite elements and nodes. Although the new developed experimental set-up minimises friction effects, some influence does still remain. This is included in the calculations with a friction coefficient of 6.25 · 10−3 . In order to optimise the specimen’s shape for experimental investigations the origin cruciform specimen is not satisfactory. Thus, several FE-simulations are done to enhance the distributions of stress and strain with the aim to achieve maximum and homogenous strains in the centre and acceptable stresses in the region of the corner, where two arms coincide. An especiallydesigned specimen with six slits in each arm fulfils these requirements very good. For further investigations these theoretical results have to be verified by experiments. An additional improvement of stress ratio in the centre can be achieved by weakening the cross section, either directly by reducing the sheet thickness or indirectly by a local heating of the forming zone.
Acknowledgements The authors would like to gratefully thank the German Research Foundation (DFG) for founding this work. The results are carried out of the research project entitled “Characterisation of yielding of magnesium sheet at elevated temperatures”.
Novel Concept of Biaxial Tension Test
129
References Banabic D., M¨ uller W., P¨ ohlandt K., “Experimental Determination of Yield Locus for Sheet Metals”, Proceedings of 1st International ESAFORM Conference, Sophia Antipolis, 17–20 March 1998, Paris, CEMEF, p. 179–182. England A.H., “On stress singularities in linear elasticity”, International Journal of Engineering Science, vol. 9 no. 6, 1971, p. 571–585. Geiger M., Hußn¨ atter W., Kerausch M., Merklein M., Pitz M., Verfahren und Vorrichtung zur Durchf¨ uhrung von Fließortkurven-Tiefungsversuchen an BlechProbek¨ orpern, German patent application DE 103 40 125.3. Germany, 2003. Geiger M., van der Heyd G., Merklein M., Hußn¨ atter W., “Novel Concept of Experimental Setup for Characterisation of Plastic Yielding of Sheet Metal at Elevated Temperatures”, Journal of Advanced Materials Research, vol. 6–8, 2005, p. 657–664. Geiger M., Hußn¨ atter W., Merklein M., “Specimen for a novel concept of the biaxial tension test”, Journal of Materials Processing Technology, vol. 167 no. 2–3, 2005, p. 177–183. Green A.E., Zerna W., Theoretical Elasticity, Oxford, Oxford University Press, 1954. Grewolls G., Kreißig R., “Anisotropic Hardening – Numerical Application of a Cubic Yield Theory and Consideration of Variable r-Values for Sheet Metal”, European Journal of Mechanics – A/Solids, vol. 20 no. 4, 2001, p. 585–599. Hoferlin E., van Bael A., van Houtte P., Steyaert G., De Mar´e C., “Biaxial Tests on Cruciform Specimens for the Validation of Crystallographic Yield Loci”, Journal of Materials Processing Technology, vol. 80–81, 1998, p. 545–550. Kuwabara T., Ikeda S., “Plane-Strain Tension Test of Steel Sheet Using ServoControlled Biaxial Tensile Testing Machine”, Proceedings of 5th International ESAFORM Conference, Krakow, 18–21 April 2002, Krakow, Akapit, p. 499–502. M¨ uller W., Beitrag zur Charakterisierung von Blechwerkstoffen unter mehrachsiger Beanspruchung, Berlin, Springer, 1996.
This page intentionally blank
Applications of a Recently Proposed Anisotropic Yield Function to Sheet Forming S. Soare1 , J.W. Yoon2 , O. Cazacu1 and F. Barlat2 1
2
University of Florida, REEF, 1350 N. Poquito Road, Shalimar, FL 32579, U.S.A., soare@ufl.edu,
[email protected]fl.edu Material Science Division, Alcoa Technical Center, 100 Technical Drive, Alcoa Center, PA 15069-0001, U.S.A.,
[email protected],
[email protected]
Summary. In this paper the predictive capabilities of a recently proposed yield criterion, CB2001, are assessed. Also, a numerical scheme for identifying the material coefficients is presented. It is shown that although convexity is not a default property of the criterion, it can be achieved numerically. Applications to two sheet forming operations are presented. Using the commercial FE code ABAQUS, simulations of the deep-drawing of a cylindrical cup and springback analysis for unconstrained bending are performed. Two aluminum alloys were considered and modelled with Hill’48 (ABAQUS) and CB2001 (UMAT). The results are also compared with another popular criterion, Yld’96. We conclude that for sheet forming operations were large plastic deformations are involved, accurate fit of the initial plastic anisotropy is a basic condition for successful FE simulations.
Key words: plastic anisotropy, generalized invariants, sheet forming.
1 Introduction Traditionally, metal forming processes have been developed based on expensive experimental trials. In recent years, Finite Element (FE) simulations have been extensively used to reduce the amount of experiments and trial and error involved in the process development. Key for the success of simulations of forming processes is the constitutive model used for description of the plastic behavior. Hill’s (1948) quadratic yield criterion is still the most widely used anisotropic yield criterion. The validity of this yield function has been explored by numerous experiments, the consensus being that it is well suited to specific metals and textures, especially for steel. Formulations that were particularly intended to improve the description of yielding of materials with a FCC crystal structure, in particular aluminum and its alloys have been subsequently
132
Advanced Methods in Material Forming
proposed. An extensive review of most recent contributions to the description of plastic anisotropy of materials with pronounced texture can be found in Barlat et al., 2003. Within the framework of the theory of representation of tensor functions, Cazacu et al., 2001, 2003, have proposed a general and rigorous method to extend any given yield criterion such as to include any type of material symmetry. Using this method, Cazacu et al., 2001, have proposed an extension of Drucker’s yield criterion (Drucker, 1949) to orthotropy. This yield criterion is defined for fully three-dimensional state of stresses and involves 17 coefficients. Thus, this yield criterion can capture accurately both the yield stress and r-values directionality. The main objective of this paper is to assess the predictive capabilities of this yield criterion. The paper is organized as follows. In Sect. 1 is presented the constitutive framework and the algorithmic aspects related to finite element discretization. In Sect. 2, Cazacu and Barlat (2001) yield criterion is briefly summarized and examples of application of this criterion to the description of the plastic response of AA 2090-T3, an aluminum alloy with strong anisotropy, and of AA 6111-T4, an alloy with moderate anisotropy, are presented. It is shown that if the material presents strong anisotropy, convexity of the yield function should be added as an additional constraint for the minimization problem associated with the identification of the material parameters. Section 3 presents cup drawing simulations for AA 2090-T3. The simulations were done with the commercial finite element package ABAQUS using a solid model, in order to fully exploit the 3-D formulation of the newly proposed yield function. Predicted results based on Cazacu and Barlat (2001) are further compared with experimental results, simulation results obtained using Hill (1948), and Barlat et al (1996) yield criteria. Finally, in Sect. 4 we present a springback analysis for AA 6111-T4 using Cazacu and Barlat (2001), and Hill (1948) yield criterion, respectively. The results are further compared with data and analysis results reported in Yoon et al., 2002.
2 Constitutive Framework and Stress Update Algorithm In what follows we adopt an updated Lagrangian description, which is adequate for simulating large plastic deformation behavior. First, the initial configuration is taken as reference configuration. Then, the reference configuration is updated to the last converged configuration in a step-by-step procedure. The material particle in its initial configuration is denoted X , whereas its spatial position is denoted by X . Let σ denote the Cauchy stress, and σ˙ denote its Jaumann rate. The deformation gradient is denoted by F and is decomposed as F = ∂u/∂X = RU = VR, with R being the rigid body rotation at the material point, and U and V the right and left stretch tensors. The (spatial) rate of deformation tensor is defined as d = [∂v /∂x +(∂v /∂x )T ]/2, where v is the velocity field of the body, and the T superscript means transposed.
Applications of Anisotropic Yield Function to Sheet Forming
133
In metal forming applications, the elastic strains are usually much smaller than the plastic strains (two to three orders of magnitude) and this motivates an additive decomposition of the rate of deformation into elastic and plastic parts. Thus, we shall write: d = de + dp However, to account for rigid body rotations all the spatial quantities of interest will be rotated by R with respect to the reference configuration. Thus, we define Σ = RT σR, D = RT dR D e = RT d e R, D p = RT d p R This rotated tensors are defined on the updated reference configuration and so they are objective. We note here that the time derivative of Σ (see, for example, Simo and Hughes, 1989, or Yoon et al., 1999, for a development based on minimal plastic work deformation paths) is: ˙ = RT σR, ˙ Σ
(1)
˙ is also the rotated Jaumann rate of the Cauchy stress which shows that Σ tensor, and so it is objective. In the space of stress tensors, a yield function in the form f = f (Σ, α) = Σ − K(α) is introduced, satisfying the requirements that it be pressure insensitive, convex, and contain the origin (zero stress) inside its initial level set. The yield function defines the boundary of the elastic domain: {Σ|Σ < K(α)} If the stress tensor belongs to the elastic domain, the deformation process is entirely reversible (elastic). The equivalent stress Σ = Σ(Σ) will define the shape of the elastic domain in the stress space (see next section), whereas the hardening function K will define its size. We further assume an associate flow rule and isotropic hardening. The hardening parameter is identified by the condition that the plastic work rate associated with a three-dimensional stress-strain state be equivalent with the plastic work rate associated with the one-dimensional experimental hardening curve (usually a uniaxial stress-strain curve): ˙ p = Σ · D p = Σ · γ˙ ∂f = Σ γ˙ ⇒ α˙ = γ˙ W (2) ∂Σ Then the constitutive equations take the form: f := Σ − K(γ) ≤ 0 ˙ = C [D e ] = C [D − D p ] Σ ∂f D p = γ˙ ∂Σ where, above, C is the fourth order tensor of elasticity.
(3) (4) (5)
134
Advanced Methods in Material Forming
The multiplier γ˙ is subject to the restrictions: γ˙
= 0, if f < 0, or if f = 0 and Σ · ∂f /∂Σ ≤ 0 > 0, if f = 0 and Σ · ∂f /∂Σ > 0
(6)
and is determined, as usual, from the consistency condition f˙ = 0. Finally, we notice that the entire set of evolution equations can be recast into the form: ˙ = C ep [D] Σ where the (theoretical) elasto-plastic tangent modulus is given by: ⎧ ⎪ C , if λ˙⎡ = 0;⎤ ⎡ ⎪ ⎪ ⎤ ⎪ ⎪ ∂f ∂f ⎪ ⎨ ⎦ ⎣ ⎦ ⎣ ⊗C C ∂Σ ∂Σ C ep = (7) ⎪ C− ⎡ , if λ˙ > 0. ⎤ ⎪ ⎪ ∂f ∂f ⎪ ⎪ ⎦· ⎪ C⎣ +K ⎩ ∂Σ ∂Σ where