ADAPTIVE OPTICS ENGINEERING HANDBOOK
EDITED IY
ROBEIT K. TYSIN The University of North Carolina at Charlotte Charlotte...
189 downloads
2744 Views
9MB Size
Report
This content was uploaded by our users and we assume good faith they have the permission to share this book. If you own the copyright to this book and it is wrongfully on our website, we offer a simple DMCA procedure to remove your content from our site. Start by pressing the button below!
Report copyright / DMCA form
ADAPTIVE OPTICS ENGINEERING HANDBOOK
EDITED IY
ROBEIT K. TYSIN The University of North Carolina at Charlotte Charlotte, North Carolina
Copyright 2000 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved. MARCEL
D D E K K E R
MARCEL DEKKER, INC.
NEW YORK • BASEL
ISBN: 0-8247-8275-5 This book is printed on acid-free paper. Headquarters Marcel Dekker, Inc. 270 Madison Avenue, New York, NY 10016 tel: 212-696-9000; fax: 212-685-4540 Eastern Hemisphere Distribution Marcel Dekker AG Hutgasse 4, Postfach 812, CH-4001 Basel, Switzerland tel: 41-61-261-8482; fax: 41-61-261-8896 World Wide Web http:/ /www.dekker.com The publisher offers discounts on this book when ordered in bulk quantities. For more information, write to Special Sales/Professional Marketing at the headquarters address above. Copyright 2000 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved. Neither this book nor any part may be reproduced or transmitted in any form or by any means, electronic or mechanical, including photocopying, microfilming, and recording, or by any information storage and retrieval system, without permission in writing from the publisher. Current printing (last digit): 10 9 8 7 6 5 4 3 2 1 PRINTED IN THE UNITED STATES OF AMERICA
Copyright 2000 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
OPTICAL ENGINEERING Founding Editor Brian J. Thompson University of Rochester Rochester, New York
Editorial Board Toshimitsu Asakura Hokkai-Gakuen University Sapporo, Hokkaido, Japan
Nicholas F. Borrelli Corning, Inc. Corning, New York
Chris Dainty Imperial College of Science, Technology, and Medicine London, England
Bahram Javidi University of Connecticut Storrs, Connecticut
Mark Kuzyk Washington State University Pullman, Washington
Hiroshi Murata The Furukawa Electric Co., Ltd. Yokohama, Japan
Edmond J. Murphy JDS/Uniphase Bloomfield, Connecticut
Dennis R. Pape Photonic Systems Inc. Melbourne, Florida
Joseph Shamir Technion–Israel Institute of Technology Hafai, Israel
David S. Weiss Heidelberg Digital L.L.C. Rochester, New York
1. Electron and Ion Microscopy and Microanalysis: Principles and Applications, Lawrence E. Murr 2. Acousto-Optic Signal Processing: Theory and Implementation, edited by Norman J. Berg and John N. Lee 3. Electro-Optic and Acousto-Optic Scanning and Deflection, Milton Gottlieb, Clive L. M. Ireland, and John Martin Ley 4. Single-Mode Fiber Optics: Principles and Applications, Luc B. Jeunhomme 5. Pulse Code Formats for Fiber Optical Data Communication: Basic Principles and Applications, David J. Morris 6. Optical Materials: An Introduction to Selection and Application, Solomon Musikant 7. Infrared Methods for Gaseous Measurements: Theory and Practice, edited by Joda Wormhoudt 8. Laser Beam Scanning: Opto-Mechanical Devices, Systems, and Data Storage Optics, edited by Gerald F. Marshall 9. Opto-Mechanical Systems Design, Paul R. Yoder, Jr. 10. Optical Fiber Splices and Connectors: Theory and Methods, Calvin M. Miller with Stephen C. Mettler and Ian A. White 11. Laser Spectroscopy and Its Applications, edited by Leon J. Radziemski, Richard W. Solarz, and Jeffrey A. Paisner 12. Infrared Optoelectronics: Devices and Applications, William Nunley and J. Scott Bechtel 13. Integrated Optical Circuits and Components: Design and Applications, edited by Lynn D. Hutcheson 14. Handbook of Molecular Lasers, edited by Peter K. Cheo 15. Handbook of Optical Fibers and Cables, Hiroshi Murata 16. Acousto-Optics, Adrian Korpel 17. Procedures in Applied Optics, John Strong 18. Handbook of Solid-State Lasers, edited by Peter K. Cheo 19. Optical Computing: Digital and Symbolic, edited by Raymond Arrathoon 20. Laser Applications in Physical Chemistry, edited by D. K. Evans 21. Laser-Induced Plasmas and Applications, edited by Leon J. Radziemski and David A. Cremers 22. Infrared Technology Fundamentals, Irving J. Spiro and Monroe Schlessinger 23. Single-Mode Fiber Optics: Principles and Applications, Second Edition, Revised and Expanded, Luc B. Jeunhomme 24. Image Analysis Applications, edited by Rangachar Kasturi and Mohan M. Trivedi 25. Photoconductivity: Art, Science, and Technology, N. V. Joshi 26. Principles of Optical Circuit Engineering, Mark A. Mentzer 27. Lens Design, Milton Laikin 28. Optical Components, Systems, and Measurement Techniques, Rajpal S. Sirohi and M. P. Kothiyal 29. Electron and Ion Microscopy and Microanalysis: Principles and Applications, Second Edition, Revised and Expanded, Lawrence E. Murr
30. Handbook of Infrared Optical Materials, edited by Paul Klocek 31. Optical Scanning, edited by Gerald F. Marshall 32. Polymers for Lightwave and Integrated Optics: Technology and Applications, edited by Lawrence A. Hornak 33. Electro-Optical Displays, edited by Mohammad A. Karim 34. Mathematical Morphology in Image Processing, edited by Edward R. Dougherty 35. Opto-Mechanical Systems Design: Second Edition, Revised and Expanded, Paul R. Yoder, Jr. 36. Polarized Light: Fundamentals and Applications, Edward Collett 37. Rare Earth Doped Fiber Lasers and Amplifiers, edited by Michel J. F. Digonnet 38. Speckle Metrology, edited by Rajpal S. Sirohi 39. Organic Photoreceptors for Imaging Systems, Paul M. Borsenberger and David S. Weiss 40. Photonic Switching and Interconnects, edited by Abdellatif Marrakchi 41. Design and Fabrication of Acousto-Optic Devices, edited by Akis P. Goutzoulis and Dennis R. Pape 42. Digital Image Processing Methods, edited by Edward R. Dougherty 43. Visual Science and Engineering: Models and Applications, edited by D. H. Kelly 44. Handbook of Lens Design, Daniel Malacara and Zacarias Malacara 45. Photonic Devices and Systems, edited by Robert G. Hunsperger 46. Infrared Technology Fundamentals: Second Edition, Revised and Expanded, edited by Monroe Schlessinger 47. Spatial Light Modulator Technology: Materials, Devices, and Applications, edited by Uzi Efron 48. Lens Design: Second Edition, Revised and Expanded, Milton Laikin 49. Thin Films for Optical Systems, edited by François R. Flory 50. Tunable Laser Applications, edited by F. J. Duarte 51. Acousto-Optic Signal Processing: Theory and Implementation, Second Edition, edited by Norman J. Berg and John M. Pellegrino 52. Handbook of Nonlinear Optics, Richard L. Sutherland 53. Handbook of Optical Fibers and Cables: Second Edition, Hiroshi Murata 54. Optical Storage and Retrieval: Memory, Neural Networks, and Fractals, edited by Francis T. S. Yu and Suganda Jutamulia 55. Devices for Optoelectronics, Wallace B. Leigh 56. Practical Design and Production of Optical Thin Films, Ronald R. Willey 57. Acousto-Optics: Second Edition, Adrian Korpel 58. Diffraction Gratings and Applications, Erwin G. Loewen and Evgeny Popov 59. Organic Photoreceptors for Xerography, Paul M. Borsenberger and David S. Weiss 60. Characterization Techniques and Tabulations for Organic Nonlinear Optical Materials, edited by Mark Kuzyk and Carl Dirk
61. Interferogram Analysis for Optical Testing, Daniel Malacara, Manuel Servín, and Zacarias Malacara 62. Computational Modeling of Vision: The Role of Combination, William R. Uttal, Ramakrishna Kakarala, Sriram Dayanand, Thomas Shepherd, Jagadeesh Kalki, Charles F. Lunskis, Jr., and Ning Liu 63. Microoptics Technology: Fabrication and Applications of Lens Arrays and Devices, Nicholas F. Borrelli 64. Visual Information Representation, Communication, and Image Processing, Chang Wen Chen and Ya-Qin Zhang 65. Optical Methods of Measurement: Wholefield Techniques, Rajpal S. Sirohi and Fook Siong Chau 66. Integrated Optical Circuits and Components: Design and Applications, edited by Edmond J. Murphy 67. Adaptive Optics Engineering Handbook, edited by Robert K. Tyson 68. Entropy and Information Optics, Francis T. S. Yu 69. Computational Methods for Electromagnetic and Optical Systems, John M. Jarem and Partha P. Banerjee 70. Laser Beam Shaping: Theory and Techniques, edited by Fred M. Dickey and Scott C. Holswade 71. Rare-Earth-Doped Fiber Lasers and Amplifiers: Second Edition, Revised and Expanded, edited by Michel J. F. Digonnet 72. Lens Design: Third Edition, Revised and Expanded, Milton Laikin 73. Handbook of Optical Engineering, edited by Daniel Malacara and Brian J. Thompson 74. Handbook of Imaging Materials, edited by Arthur S. Diamond and David S. Weiss 75. Handbook of Image Quality: Characterization and Prediction, Brian W. Keelan 76. Fiber Optic Sensors, edited by Francis T. S. Yu and Shizhuo Yin 77. Optical Switching/Networking and Computing for Multimedia Systems, edited by Mohsen Guizani and Abdella Battou 78. Image Recognition and Classification: Algorithms, Systems, and Applications, edited by Bahram Javidi 79. Practical Design and Production of Optical Thin Films: Second Edition, Revised and Expanded, Ronald R. Willey 80. Ultrafast Lasers: Technology and Applications, edited by Martin E. Fermann, Almantas Galvanauskas, and Gregg Sucha 81. Light Propagation in Periodic Media: Differential Theory and Design, Michel Nevière and Evgeny Popov 82. Handbook of Nonlinear Optics, Second Edition, Revised and Expanded, Richard L. Sutherland
Additional Volumes in Preparation
Optical Remote Sensing: Science and Technology, Walter Egan
From the Series Editor
The field of adaptive optics as a focused activity is now over 25 years old. The first concepts appeared in the 1950s; however, to see it as a really active field with significant progress, we look to the literature starting in the 1970s. Adaptive optics originated from the desire to correct images degraded by atmosphereic turbulence before detection. The approach contrasts, but in many ways complements, the techniques available for postdetection processing; i.e., both pre- and postdetection processing can be used in conjunction with each other. Clearly the initial problem was with earthbound telescopes; telescopes with large apertures collect more light than smaller-diameter intruments but do not necessarily provide any greater resolution. Adaptive optics methods require that an incoming wavefront be sensed and evaluated in a time interval shorter than the fluctuation rate of the wavefront. Once the distortion of the wavefront has been determined, a real-time correction is needed to compensate for that distortion. It is the fundamental science, engineering, and technology of these methods and their implementation that have allowed adaptive optics to become a reality. Although adaptive optics started with the desire to control and improve image formation in earth-based telescopes, its methods can be applied to a variety of other systems that suffer from time-varying effects, for example, interferometric sensing, speckle systems, radiant energy delivery systems, and holographic systems, among others. The Adaptive Optics Engineering Handbook provides a detailed description and discussion of the methods of adaptive optics, including the key topics of wavefront sensing and wavefront correction, and how they are applied in practice. Brian J. Thompson
Preface
Adaptive Optics Engineering Handbook is a practical guide to the development and implementation of adaptive optics systems and technology. Chapters by experts in the various subfields of adaptive optics have contributed detailed descriptions of system design techniques, the use of wavefront sensors, deformable mirrors and wavefront estimators (reconstructors), and advanced technologies and applications. The Handbook is a unique compendium of work from 16 authors that has never before been published in book form. Chapter 1 provides a survey of the history of adaptive optics and starts the Handbook with a ‘‘how-to’’ guide by referencing many operational systems showing ‘‘how it was done by the best in the business.’’ Chapters 2 and 3 provide a detailed description of system considerations for modeling, analyzing, and designing a conventional adaptive optics system with laser guide stars. Chapters 4, 5, and 6 describe the three major subsystems and components of a system: the wavefront sensor, the deformable mirror, and the control system wavefront estimators. Chapters 7, 8, and 9 describe state-of-the-art technology in high-speed wavefront correction devices. Chapter 10 gives an overview of cutting-edge research in medical imaging using adaptive optics, and Chapter 11 covers innovative techniques for wavefront compensation that overcome field-of-view limits common to many system configurations. The Adaptive Optics Engineering Handbook is intended for scientists, astronomers, engineers, and technicians working with adaptive optics systems, or those developing optical components and associated technologies such as highresolution cameras, high-speed computers, diffractive and micromachined optics, active mirrors, and high-power lasers. Robert K. Tyson
Contents
From the Series Editor Preface Contributors 1. Introduction Robert K. Tyson 2. System Design and Optimization Ronald R. Parenti 3. Guide Star System Considerations Richard J. Sasiela and John D. Shelton 4. Wavefront Sensors Joseph M. Geary 5. Deformable Mirror Wavefront Correctors Ralph E. Aldrich 6. Innovative Wavefront Estimators for Zonal Adaptive Optics Systems Walter J. Wild 7. Micromachined Membrane Deformable Mirrors Gleb Vdovin
viii
8. Surface Micromachined Deformable Mirrors William D. Cowan and Victor M. Bright 9. Liquid Crystal Adaptive Optics Gordon D. Love 10. Wavefront Sensing and Compensation for the Human Eye David R. Williams, Junzhong Liang, Donald T. Miller, and Austin Roorda 11. Wide Field-of-View Wavefront Sensing Erez N. Ribak
Contents
Contributors
Ralph E. Aldrich, Ph.D. Technology Consultant, Acton, Massachusetts Victor M. Bright, Ph.D. Department of Mechanical Engineering, University of Colorado at Boulder, Boulder, Colorado William D. Cowan Air Force Institute of Technology, Wright-Patterson AFB, Ohio Joseph M. Geary, Ph.D. Center for Applied Optics and Department of Physics, University of Alabama in Huntsville, Huntsville, Alabama Junzhong Liang* University of Rochester, Rochester, New York Gordon D. Love, Ph.D. Department of Physics and School of Engineering, University of Durham, Durham, United Kingdom Donald T. Miller‡ University of Rochester, Rochester, New York Ronald R. Parenti, Ph.D. Optical Communications Technology, Massachusetts Institute of Technology Lincoln Laboratory, Lexington, Massachusetts
Current affiliations * Intel Corporation, Santa Clara, California. ‡ Indiana University, Bloomington, Indiana.
x
Contributors
Erez N. Ribak, Ph.D. Department of Physics, Technion–Israel Institute of Technology, Haifa, Israel Austin Roorda, Ph.D.* College of Optometry, University of Rochester, Rochester, New York Richard J. Sasiela, Ph.D. Radar Systems Engineering, Massachusetts Institute of Technology Lincoln Laboratory, Lexington, Massachusetts John D. Shelton, Ph.D. Massachusetts Institute of Technology Lincoln Laboratory, Lexington, Massachusetts Robert K. Tyson, Ph.D. Department of Physics, University of North Carolina at Charlotte, Charlotte, North Carolina Gleb Vdovin, Ph.D. Information Technology and Systems, Delft University of Technology, Delft, The Netherlands Walter J. Wild† University of Chicago, Chicago, Illinois David R. Williams University of Rochester, Rochester, New York
* University of Houston, Houston, Texas. † Deceased.
1 Introduction Robert K. Tyson University of North Carolina at Charlotte, Charlotte, North Carolina
Adaptive optics are used to enhance the capability of optical systems by actively compensating for aberrations. These aberrations, such as atmospheric turbulence, optical fabrication errors, thermally induced distortions, or laser device aberrations, reduce the peak intensity and smear an image or a laser beam propagating to a target. Normally, increasing the aperture size decreases the diffraction angle and makes an image sharper. However, for many optical systems, the beam or image quality is limited, not by the aperture, but by the propagation medium. The twinkling of stars or distorted images across a paved road on a hot summer day is caused by turbulence in the atmosphere. Distortions like these can be corrected by adaptive optics. The result of more than three decades of technology development, adaptive optics systems are being used at observatories around the world. This Handbook is a guide to the implementation of adaptive optics, a collection of analysis tools for system design and development, and an introduction to up-to-date developments in the multidisciplinary adaptive optics field. The principal uses for adaptive optics are improving image quality in optical and infrared astronomical telescopes, imaging and tracking rapidly moving space objects, and compensating for laser beam distortion through the atmosphere (1). Although these missions differ, the techniques used to compensate for the underlying distortions are similar. Adaptive optics are real-time distortion-compensating systems (2). Although many types of adaptive optics systems have been tried in the laboratory or field, the most common adaptive optics system in use today consists of three subsystems. Figure 1 shows the subsystems in an observing application. A wavefront sensor measures the distortion induced by the atmosphere by evaluating the light from a natural source or an artificial beacon placed high above the telescope.
Copyright 2000 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
2
Tyson
Figure 1 Basic components of an adaptive optics system.
An active mirror, called a deformable mirror, can rapidly change its surface shape to match the phase distortions measured by the wavefront sensor. A control computer is used to evaluate the wavefront sensor measurements and translate the signals into control signals to drive the actuators of the deformable mirror. Over large apertures, like those used in modern astronomical telescopes, the wavefront tilt is a dominant effect which, as it varies rapidly during the exposure time, further distorts the image. Adaptive optics systems often offload the tilt wavefront measurement to a specialized tilt control mirror to remove the large stroke requirements from the deformable mirror. Because the adaptive optics compensation is performed by macroscopic movement of an optical element, the system is called inertial. Because the compensation is linearly proportional to the disturbance, the system is considered linear. These terms are in contrast to nonlinear phase conjugation techniques which employ atomic or molecular changes in optical materials and exploit their nonlinear phase compensation properties. Nonlinear systems are discussed elsewhere in the literature and will not be a topic of discussion in this practical examination of adaptive optics. While most adaptive optics systems look like Fig. 1, there are innovative variations on the standard design. For example, the 6.5-m Smithsonian Institution–University of Arizona Monolithic Mirror Telescope located at the Steward Observatory in Arizona will put the deformable mirror on the Cassegrain second-
Copyright 2000 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
Introduction
3
ary mirror surface instead of using the separate deformable mirror like that shown in Fig. 1. In astronomy, adaptive optics provide the means for increasing the angular resolution in direct imaging, and they provide higher performance for many spectroscopic, interferometric and photometric measurements. For example, if the scientific goal is to make a simple detection of a faint point source such as a star in the presence of a bright sky background, the final detected signal-to-noise ratio is proportional to D/α, where D is the aperture diameter of the telescope’s primary mirror and α is the angular resolution at the time of detection. Large telescopes now have apertures up to 10 meters, today’s practical engineering limit. From the above ratio, decreasing α is just as important as increasing D. Adaptive optics provides the opportunity to decrease α to the theoretical limit.
I. THE EARLY HISTORY There was no one inventor of adaptive optics. Systems and technology have evolved over the past 30 years to become a major subset of modern astronomical telescopes and high energy laser propagation systems. More than 2000 research papers have been published, and hundreds of investigators, engineers, and technicians have provided advances in theory and technology that support the multidisciplinary field of adaptive optics. Because of the recent, rapid rise in interest, usage, and development of adaptive optics (see Fig. 2), we find that technological advances, experimental results, and even breakthroughs are reported almost on a weekly basis. The concept of adaptive optics is not particularly new, and like many excellent ideas it seems to have been discovered more than once. In 1953 Horace Babcock (3), then director of the Mount Wilson and Palomar observatories, was the first to suggest how one might build an astronomical adaptive optics instrument. Independently, in 1957 Vladimir P. Linnik (4) described the same concept in the Soviet journal Optika i Spektroskopiya. Although Babcock was very specific in his design concepts and had the resources of Mount Wilson and Palomar at his fingertips, his adaptive optics system was not built. It was simply beyond the technological capabilities of the 1950s. The first practical developments in adaptive optics technology followed in the late 1960s when American industry, driven by requirements to image satellites and project high energy laser beams into space, created the first operational systems. The first fully operational adaptive optics system was installed on a surveillance telescope at Haleakala Observatory in Maui, Hawaii, where it imaged satellites (5) launched by the Soviet Union. Components and full closed-loop systems were developed during the 1970s and early 1980s under various programs by companies such as Itek, Hughes, Ford Aerospace, United Technologies,
Copyright 2000 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
4
Tyson
Figure 2 Adaptive optics-related publications in the open literature are rising at an increasing rate. This sample from two domestic sources, Optical Engineering and Proceedings of the SPIE (both published by SPIE, Bellingham, WA), shows the trend in interest, proliferation, and advancement of adaptive optics throughout the world. The excursions in 1994 and 1998 are due to the quadrennial space- and ground-based astronomy meeting held in each of those years that draws large international participation.
Lockheed, Perkin-Elmer, MIT Lincoln Laboratory, Ball Aerospace, and Adaptive Optics Associates. By the mid-1980s, Thermotrex Corporation, United Technologies Optical Systems, Laserdot, and the European consortium ONERA were building and supplying wavefront sensors, deformable mirrors, and control systems. Through acquisitions and corporate spinoffs, companies like Hughes Danbury Optical Systems (later Raytheon Optical Systems) and Xinetics continue to advance the state of the art in adaptive optics. During the development period from 1965 to the mid-1980s, theoretical developments paralleled the progression of more sophisticated hardware. David Fried developed much of the theory to understand the phenomena of adaptive optics phase conjugation and provided a number of tools for performance prediction and assessment (6). Darryl Greenwood wrote a seminal paper describing the temporal nature of adaptive optics compensation (7). Supporting work by Tyler (8) and Lukin (9) contributed greatly to the understanding and practical analysis methodology of system requirements and performance parameters. Many others
Copyright 2000 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
Introduction
5
contributed volumes on adaptive optics theory and analysis, primarily in the areas of thermal blooming compensation, wavefront control algorithms, and temporal control theory applied to multichannel adaptive systems. The need for a bright stellar source was always a concern for astronomical applications of adaptive optics. To operate, a wavefront sensor must have sufficient light to overcome photon noise and background noise with enough light left over to form the image. In astronomy, there are few stars of scientific interest that are sufficiently bright. For imaging uncooperative satellites, reflected light is often too dim or nonexistent. In 1985, French astronomers Foy and Labeyrie published work detailing how one might use backscatter from a laser focused to a point in the atmosphere as an artificial beacon (a guide star) for astronomical adaptive optics (10). As work progressed in the astronomy community to build and test a laser powerful enough to have sufficient backscatter for the FoyLabeyrie method, the political changes in eastern Europe began to have an effect upon adaptive optics. Since the beginning of the 1980s, classified U.S. military work was addressing the problems of projecting high energy laser beams from the ground to space for missile defense and secure communications. Suggestions by Adaptive Optics Associates founder Julius Feinleib and alternative concepts suggested by Richard Hutchin (11), with theoretical support from Fried, showed how laser guide stars would be a means to avoid the problems associated with uncooperative targets or point-ahead angles for space relays. The research from 1982 at the U.S. Air Force Starfire Optical Range directed by Robert Fugate advanced the laser guide star concept and produced a wealth of information about laser performance requirements, adaptive optics system operation, atmospheric physics, and closed-loop images of spaceborne objects (12). By 1991, the bulk of the military work on laser guide starts was declassified and made available to astronomers around the world. Low altitude Rayleigh scattering has a serious drawback for guide star applications. All the atmosphere above the guide star, nominally at 20 km altitude, is undetected and still distorts the image. In 1982 Will Happer of Princeton University suggested using resonant backscatter from mesospheric atomic sodium for a high altitude (90 km) laser guide star. This suggestion was experimentally demonstrated at the Starfire Optical Range once a laser with sufficient power was obtained at the 589 nm sodium line. One wants the guide star to be close enough in the sky to the target object so that their light is affected by the same atmospheric path. Otherwise the coherence between the reference wavefront and the light from the target object will be lost. The time scale for readjusting the electro-optics is therefore about r0 /ν, where ν is the wind velocity in the turbulent atmosphere and r0 is the coherence length of the atmosphere. On an average night at an astronomical observatory, r0 /ν is of order 30 ms at visual wavelengths. To monitor and then remove the turbulence,
Copyright 2000 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
6
Tyson
an electro-optic control system must operate about 10 times faster than the atmospheric changes. While these restrictions discouraged the development of visual-light astronomical adaptive optics systems before 1980, there was a clever solution for the military system designed for satellite surveillance. At the Haleakala Observatory the adaptive optics system was used primarily in twilight hours. During twilight, sky background contamination is relatively low, yet an Earth-orbiting satellite is still illuminated by sunlight. Bright glints of sunlight reflected off the satellite itself provide the reference wavefront. There are many cases where the object itself, such as a sunlit satellite, is insufficient for wavefront sensing. In astronomy, there are billions of stellar objects too dim for sensing and not near enough in the sky to bright objects. For high energy laser propagation to uncooperative targets or satellite tracking and imaging, an artificial source must be placed above, or high in, the atmosphere to provide photons for the wavefront sensor and subsequent compensation. Lasers actually provide only partial correction, because a natural star still is required for the lowest-order (tip-tilt) correction. The laser light experiences equal and opposite overall tilt upon travelling up into the atmosphere and returning. Chapter 2 has a detailed discussion and explanation of a number of system design tools for laser guide star systems.
II. ADAPTIVE OPTICS SUBSYSTEMS: WAVEFRONT SENSORS The wavefront sensor (located at the bottom of the adaptive optics system shown in Fig. 1) aims to squeeze from a minimal number of photons the maximum amount of wavefront information possible. Dividing the available light into the image and the wavefront measurement instrument is a balancing act. If fewer photons can be used, fainter guide stars can be used, and the amount of light becomes available for interesting targets. Laser guide stars do their best work correcting higher order wavefront irregularities. To achieve this goal it is important that the detector have the highest quantum efficiency and the lowest system induced noise. While some researchers considered avalanche photodiodes to be the detector of choice, newer systems rely on custom-designed charge-coupled devices with quantum efficiencies approaching 80–90%. These CCDs use on-chip amplifiers designed in such a way as to match the CCD readout rates to the time scale of the variations in the wavefront (13). Early military adaptive optics systems used both shearing interferometers and those of the Shack-Hartmann design (see Fig. 3). The most common type
Copyright 2000 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
Introduction
7
Figure 3 Three principal types of wavefront sensors.
now being used is a Shack-Hartmann sensor which relies on a lenslet array to create a grid of subimages, each of which measures the local slope of the wavefront. The rectangular grid geometry ordinarily used with the Shack-Hartmann sensor is conceptually simple. For measuring the most common atmospheric disturbances, radially symmetric low order aberrations, a curvature sensor can be used. It compares the signal strength from two equally defocused images, one just inside and the other just outside the focal plane (14). The two-dimensional difference between these signals provides information on low order wavefront perturbations. In addition to the imaging system configuration with a separate wavefront sensor, systems can make use of the image signal itself for sharpening the images. When there is no explicit wavefront measurement and the sharpness of the image is measured in the image plane, varying the correction process can converge toward the ‘‘best image.’’ This is analogous to trying on a number of pairs of glasses to find out which one is best. Trial and error, with a ‘‘sharp’’ image as the figure of merit, is the basis of this approach. Other approaches, such as multidither, have been used in laser propagation but are range and sensitivity dependent.
Copyright 2000 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
8
Tyson
Details of wavefront sensing techniques and associated electro-optical instrumentation can be found in Chapter 4. The important parameters regarding the state of technology of wavefront sensors are • Number of subapertures (a measure of spatial resolution) • Type of sensor: Hartmann, shearing interferometer, or curvature (determines complexity; enabling technologies, processor requirements) • Sensor geometry (affects spatial resolution and processor requirements). • Detector type and characteristics, quantum efficiency and noise (specifies source brightness and determines bandwidth) • Wavelength (related to atmospheric parameters and detector choice) • Readout rate or frame rate (constrains closed-loop bandwidth) III. ADAPTIVE OPTICS SUBSYSTEMS: DEFORMABLE MIRRORS Once the wavefront is measured and the control signal determined, an optical element must be moved to change the phase of the beam of light. The tilt of a beam can be removed with fast tilting or scanning mirrors. For larger beams, particularly those required for transmission of high energy lasers, specialized designs are used. For correcting higher order aberrations, there are three dominant deformable mirror (DM) types (see Fig. 4). A segmented mirror, with individually controlled tip, tilt, and piston motion on the segments can be used. These mirrors have the advantage of segments being easily replaced, matching closely to a geometrically registered wavefront sensor, and having an unlimited aperture (by being able to just add more segments). Its primary drawback is the gap between segments which can scatter and diffract energy in an undesired and uncontrolled manner. The gaps can be avoided by using a continuous faceplate with an array of actuators behind it. The actuators push and pull on the surface. Since the surface is continuous, there is some mechanical crosstalk from one actuator to the next (called the influence function), but that can be controlled by mechanical design and through software within the control computer. Because most deformable mirrors have regular arrays of actuators, either square or hexagonal geometries, the alternate pushing and pulling of adjacent actuators can impart a patterned surface resembling a waffle. The ‘‘waffle mode’’ can appear in images because of its regular pattern which acts as an unwanted diffraction grating. Computer processing can be employed to avoid or eliminate this drawback. Curvature wavefront sensors measure the second derivative (Laplacian) of the wavefront. A bimorph mirror is made up of PZT material capable of deforming when voltage is applied across a region. The natural shape of the bimorph
Copyright 2000 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
Introduction
9
Figure 4 Three principal types of deformable mirrors.
is also in the shape of curvature, making it ideal for operation in conjunction with a curvature sensor. The computer reconstructor is very simple because there is a one-for-one relationship between the sensor signals and the mirror commands. Unfortunately, bimorphs are limited in their ability to compensate very high order spatial frequencies. Details of deformable mirrors and their construction can be found in Chapter 5. The important parameters regarding the state of technology of deformable mirrors are • Number of actuators (specifies spatial resolution). • Type: segmented, continuous faceplate, or bimorph • Actuator, or segment, separation (related to spatial resolution and manufacturing complexity). • Faceplate material and cooling requirements (determines application and total power) • Type of actuators (related to drive voltages, speed, heat buildup, total stroke, and hysteresis).
Copyright 2000 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
10
Tyson
• Total stroke and hysteresis (limits aperture, total amount of compensation, and bandwidth)
IV. ADAPTIVE OPTICS SUBSYSTEMS: LASER GUIDE STAR PROJECTION A third major technology issue is how to create and project laser guide stars in the atmosphere. The two atmospheric scattering processes that can provide the brightest laser guide star return signal are Rayleigh scattering of photons off molecules in the stratosphere and resonance scattering off sodium atoms in the mesosphere. For Rayleigh scattering, there are two laser systems suited to the task: a 530-nm/550-nm copper-vapor laser and a 351-nm excimer laser working with XeF (15). Both systems are available as reliable commercial products capable of delivering, respectively, 200 W and 50 W output power, sufficient for each to create a tenth magnitude star at 10–20 km altitude. The second laser guide star technique relies on resonant scattering at 589 nm off the neutral sodium atoms present in abundance at an altitude of about 92 km. For this technique, special experimental lasers must be built and tailored to the requirements of the sodium excitation. The copper-vapor and excimer systems operate in the pulsed mode, while sodium-wavelength lasers are either pulsed or continuous wave. Laser guide star systems produce a reference wavefront that emanates from a finite altitude in the Earth’s atmosphere, and this leads to complications that have been given the name focal anisoplanatism. Because the laser guide star is not at infinite focal distance, all of the atmosphere is not sensed and there is an error in the focus component of the wavefront. Sodium laser guide stars have less focal anisoplanatism because they are created 5–10 times higher in the atmosphere than Rayleigh laser guide stars (see Fig. 5). Trades must be performed to properly design a laser guide star. If the raw laser beam has poor beam divergence properties, which is generally the case for commercial excimer and copper-vapor lasers, the telescope’s full primary mirror must be used as a primary element in the laser project system. If the laser emits a near-diffraction-limited output beam, the projection system becomes simpler. A side-mounted projection system can be placed on the telescope structure and boresighted with the main telescope (the current design of Keck and one of two proposals for the NOAO’s Gemini 8.5-m telescope). Alternatively, the laser beam can be sent to the top of the telescope structure, where it can be projected along the telescope’s optical axis from behind the Cassegrain secondary mirror; this setup has been proposed for the monolithic mirror telescope (MMT). In the MMT design, low-altitude scattered light that would otherwise be a contaminant remains in the shadow of the secondary mirror as viewed from the astronomy detectors. Details of laser guide star systems considerations can be found in Chapter 3.
Copyright 2000 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
Introduction
11
Figure 5 Laser guide stars can be produced with Rayleigh scattering at an altitude of about 20 km or with resonant sodium backscatter at an altitude near 90 km.
The important parameters regarding the state of technology of laser guide stars are • Laser wavelength (specifies altitude, Rayleigh at 20 km or sodium at 90 km). • Laser power (specifies brightness of LGS) • Pulse repetition rate and pulse length (related to brightness, altitude, and sensor bandwidth)
V.
ADAPTIVE OPTICS SUBSYSTEMS: CONTROL COMPUTERS
The control computer, often called a wavefront reconstructor, takes the signals from the wavefront sensor. Images from a curvature system, spot intensity pat-
Copyright 2000 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
12
Tyson
terns from a Hartmann sensor, or interferograms from a shearing interferometer are used to compute appropriate drive signals for the deformable mirror. The speed and accuracy of this computation directly affect the closed-loop bandwidth of the system. Early systems used analog resistor matrices to do the calculations and did not limit bandwidth. Current systems, to make better use of changing conditions, variations in the wavefront sensor configuration, high noise conditions, and programmability, use digital signal processors to convert wavefront sensor signals to drive signals. For ‘‘thousand-channel systems,’’ and the like, the multiple control processors act in parallel to keep the overall bandwidth in the range of atmospheric time scales. Most commonly, combinations of Intel i860 chips or Texas Instruments TMS320C40 or TMS320C50 DSP chips are used on VME boards or other interfaces. Processors with hundreds of MFLOPS (millions of floating point operations per second) are required for atmospheric compensation systems. The important parameters regarding the state of technology of control computers are • Type: analog or digital (relevant to system complexity and flexibility). • Processor brand and number of units (related to parallelism and bandwidth) • MFLOPS (relates to system complexity and ultimate processor delay time)
VI. ADAPTIVE OPTICS TECHNOLOGIES Adaptive optics historically developed because of advances in various engineering fields that came together and progressed at the right time. Better visible and infrared sensors and detectors, high speed digital electronic processing, reliable and low-cost electromechanical actuators, and rugged and powerful lasers all advance the adaptive optics systems where they are used. New technologies provide for advances and breakthroughs in adaptive optics beyond mere improvements in existing ground-based imaging systems or laser propagation systems. These technologies will make it possible for a proliferation of miniature, lowcost adaptive optics systems in medicine, communications, surveillance, weather and climate monitoring, astronomy, and tactical military systems. Wavefront sensors are dependent upon the device that converts photons to an electronic signal. Many systems use avalanche photodiodes, but, because of their versatility, speed, wavelength range, and small size and weight, two-dimensional CCD, CID, or CMOS cameras are used as the focal planes for wavefront sensors. Rapid improvements in size (number of pixels), sensitivity, residual noise, and quantum efficiency allow for operation with fainter wavefront beacons.
Copyright 2000 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
Introduction
13
Being able to divide the wavefront into smaller and smaller regions for higher and higher resolution links the advances in wavefront sensor technology to the advances in visible and infrared cameras and focal planes. In 1996, a breakthrough in technology made it possible to consider very low cost and even ‘‘throw-away’’ adaptive optics. For decades, advances in sensors and electronic processing have helped to bring down the cost of adaptive optics. Only one subsystem, the deformable mirror, remained at a costly level because of the difficulty in manufacturing multiple units and the large size of the mirrors themselves. A few researchers in the microelectromechanical (MEM) field have recently developed prototype deformable mirrors using conventional CMOS microchip technology. The result has been demonstrations of small (1 cm) mirrors with hundreds of actuators, a few microns of stroke, an optical wavefront surface better than λ/20, actuator bandwidths up to 10 kHz, and projected production cost of about $200 per unit. This reduction in cost (by 3–4 orders of magnitude) and reduction in required power and weight (by 3 orders of magnitude) make possible many new applications of adaptive optics that were once considered prohibitive. Chapter 7 has details about these devices and applications. In recent years, there have been considerable advances in phase modulators such as liquid crystals, which can be used for low-cost adaptive optics. The first devices were only able to extend the on-off characteristics of spatial light modulators to make crude inroads into adaptive optics applications. For example, ferroelectric liquid crystal devices had one wave of throw in 10 µs, but were limited to only bistable operation (on-off). Now, nematic liquid crystals with up to 10 waves of throw with analog (continuous) control are possible. Although the nematic devices are slower (40 ms for one wave, i.e., 25 Hz), they are polarization independent and show high optical quality (λ/15). Devices up to 127 pixels have been reported (16). Technology improvement is expected by changing the viscosity of the crystal, varying its operational thickness, and optimizing the control voltage. See Chapter 7 for the details on recent liquid crystal adaptive optics development and construction. In addition to devices used for wavefront correction, new advances in optics, primarily binary optics and diffractive optics, have application directly in wavefront sensors and beam shaping applications. Diffractive optics can be applied to make very efficient, high fill factor lenslet arrays for the input aperture of Hartmann wavefront sensors. By making these devices accurate and repeatable, wavefront sensors can be integrated with small correction devices (liquid crystals or MEMs) to make complete single-chip adaptive optics systems for a fraction of the cost of labor-intensive discrete systems. Although lasers themselves are nearly 40 years old, and their use as potential weapons has been under study for nearly that long, the applications of new types of lasers and advances in new materials for lasers remain a strong element of adaptive optics technologies. Lasers with internal adaptive optics, either linear
Copyright 2000 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
14
Tyson
or nonlinear, remain a very intense area of development. By increasing the wavefront quality of an emerging beam, the extraction efficiency is improved, thereby making the resultant application cheaper and more useful. Specialized lasers for adaptive optics, such as mid- to high-power lasers for Rayleigh beacons and tuned lasers for 589-nm sodium laser beacons, are the subject of much of the work at institutions developing adaptive optics. Faster detectors and faster deformable mirrors will not be the bandwidthlimiting components of adaptive optics. With hundreds of channels of information to process at kilohertz rates, the numerical bottleneck may be the digital signal processing. Two costs are related to driving up the speed of the wavefront control system. Parallel processing requires multiple special purpose electronic boards and processors along with software that can be adaptable and robust to make use of the flexibility of the processors. Although the current state of electronic processing can handle closed-loop adaptive optics bandwidths of 100–200 Hz, high resolution imaging or high speed modulation of communications traffic while tracking fast moving low-Earth-orbit satellites requires bandwidths of 10 times that (⬃2500 Hz). Processing delays, for hundreds of floating point matrix multiplies, must be reduced to less than 100 µs.
VII. A SURVEY OF OPERATIONAL SYSTEMS Rather than presenting the engineering details of existing operational adaptive optics systems in this volume, which would be impractical and outdated within months, we present here a summary of the systems, subsystems, technologies, and developers. Specifics about each system can be obtained in working documents and current literature by each of the investigators. At the present time there are many new adaptive optics programs in the design and construction phase. By far, the most common application of adaptive optics is for imaging. Since 1982, adaptive optics (AO) have been used for imaging through the atmosphere using the basic components that consist of a wavefront sensor (WFS), a corrector like a deformable mirror (DM), a control computer to perform the real-time numerical calculations, and sometimes a laser guide star (LGS). A. U.S. Air Force Starfire Optical Range The Starfire Optical Range (SOR) now consists of a 3.5-m telescope, built by Contraves Brashear Systems (Pittsburgh, PA), with a high speed, multielement adaptive optics system. The deformable mirror (Xinetics, Devon, MA) has 941 lead-magnesium-niobate (PMN) actuators. A 700-channel Hartmann-Shack wavefront sensor provides 1400 slope commands to the wavefront reconstructor
Copyright 2000 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
Introduction
15
and signal processor. The wavefront sensor operates at a wavelength between 0.45 and 1.0 µm. The processing electronics, wavefront reconstructor, wavefront slope processor and most other associated electronics were built ‘‘in house’’ at SOR by USAF or contractor employees. The imaging camera is a 2000 ⫻ 2000 pixel CCD. The reported frame rate for the wavefront sensor is 2500 Hz. The reported closed-loop bandwidth is 80 Hz. Because the SOR is used primarily for satellite imaging (SOR reports only 10% usage for astronomy), the pseudowind as the telescope slews across the sky induces very high speed aberrations. The SOR 3.5-m system has operated near diffraction-limited at 0.8 µm wavelength. SOR also has a 1.5-m telescope with an adaptive optics system that is ‘‘mostly decommissioned.’’ The SOR 1.5 m was clearly the state-of-the-art (577 actuators, 500 subaperture wavefront sensor, 1-kHz frame rate) until the completion of the 3.5-m system. The 1.5-m system had a 128 ⫻ 128 pixel CCD (MIT/ Lincoln Lab) with 10 electrons read noise and 90% quantum efficiency. At the SOR site there is a 200-W Cu vapor laser (Oxford Lasers, UK) to produce a Rayleigh guide star. The current 3.5-m telescope has a number of beam paths that can be used to alternately select various lasers for atmospheric probing, guide star generation, or other testing (17).
B.
Canada-France-Hawaii Telescope
The most advanced operational nonmilitary adaptive optics system is installed on the Canada-France-Hawaii 3.6-m telescope (CFHT) on Mauna Kea (18). CFHT is a consortium that includes Canada, France (including French industries such as ONERA), and the University of Hawaii Institute for Astronomy. The adaptive optics system installed on CFHT has evolved over the past six years. The original system was an experimental adaptive optics system with a 13-element bimorph mirror and a curvature sensor. The second generation, called Pueo (Hawaiian for ‘‘owl’’) or the AO Bonnette, had a 19-element bimorph deformable mirror built by CILAS (formerly Laserdot in France). The wavefront sensor was a 19-channel curvature sensor using avalanche photodiodes as the detectors. The computer was also built by Laserdot. About 1996, the system was again upgraded to a 36channel system called Hokupa’a (Hawaiian for ‘‘immovable star’’). The curvature wavefront sensor operates in the band 0.5 to 1.0 µm. The sensor readout rate is 1.2 kHz. The SPARC2 wavefront processor has 0.2-ms delay, resulting in a reported closed-loop bandwidth of 120 Hz. Near-diffraction-limited imaging has been achieved near 1.0 µm with diffraction-limited observations at 2.2 µm. CFHT plans to install a sodium laser guide star within the next few years. The projected brightness from a 5-W Na LGS will be magnitude 11. A Strehl ratio of 0.1–0.3 at 1.2 µm is expected, 0.3–0.5 at 1.6 µm, and 0.4 to 0.8 at 2.2 µm with essentially 100% sky coverage.
Copyright 2000 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
16
Tyson
C. European Southern Observatory The European Southern Observatory (ESO) has developed adaptive optics for incorporation on the 3.6-m telescope at La Silla, Chile. The architecture of the telescope-adaptive optics system was developed mostly in Garching, Germany, the headquarters of ESO, in conjunction with Max Planck Institute. Laboratories also are located in Garching. French and Italian collaborators, primarily the Observatoire de Paris, ONERA, CILAS, LEP, and Shakti are responsible for the principal adaptive optics hardware components, the wavefront sensor and the deformable mirror. The WFS has evolved from a series of systems, first called COME-ON (19) (an acronym of the collaborators), to COME-ON⫹ (20), and now to the current generation, ADaptive Optics for Near Infrared Systems (ADONIS). COME-ON had a first generation Laserdot bimorph deformable mirror and an ONERA-built WFS with 20 subapertures (5 ⫻ 5 configuration with corners cut off) and an intensified Reticon array (QE ⫽ 0.1). The processor was a hardwired device with sampling at about 100 Hz, resulting in a closed-loop bandwidth of 10 Hz. The computational delay in the processor was 2–4 ms. The science wavelength was primarily in the infrared at 1–5 µm. ADONIS is being built for the 3.6-m ESO New Technology Telescope (NTT) at La Silla (21) and as a test bed for the ESO 8.2-m Very Large Telescope (VLT) (22), an array of four 8-m telescopes at Paranal, Chile. ADONIS has a 52-actuator CILAS DM with piezoelectric (PZT) actuators. The WFS is a 32subaperture (7 ⫻ 7 array with corners cut off ) system with a Reticon array for wavefront sensing in the band 0.4–0.9 µm. For low flux conditions, the WFS will use an EBCCD array (LEP, France) that has a QE of 0.1 and 0.27 electrons/ pixel noise. The sample rate can be varied from 25 to 200 Hz with a closed-loop bandwidth specified at 33 Hz. The delay in the EBCCD is reported to be less than 1 ms. The wavefront processor uses Texas Instruments C40 processors. The highest Strehl ratio reported for the system is about 0.2 in the K band with a magnitude 10.5 guide star brightness (23). The system for the VLT will be coordinated with the French company SFIM Industries Etablissement d’Asnieres.
D. Telescopio Nazionale Galileo (TNG) The most significant program within Italy is the adaptive optics module for the Telescopio Nazionale Galileo (TNG) (24). The program is named AdOpt@TNG (25). The bulk of the work is performed at Asiago Astrophysical Observatory. Groups in Milano-Merate are developing the tip/tilt system. The wavefront sensor prototype is being tested at Arcetri (Firenze, Italy). The system consists of the following elements (26): The wavefront sensor is either a 4 ⫻ 4 Shack-Hartmann configuration, an 8 ⫻ 8 Shack-Hartmann,
Copyright 2000 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
Introduction
17
or a flexible, but slower Shack-Hartmann configuration. The wavefront control computer is a VME-based design with TI C40 boards to measure centroid, estimate slopes, and command the deformable mirror. An ELTEC EUROCOM-7 68040 CPU is the basic processor, and a Loughborough Sound Images (UK) DSP 56001 board is used. The wavefront sensor will use an EEV39 80 ⫻ 80 CCD array with 1-kHz frame rate readout electronics from ElettroMare (La Spezia, Italy). The maximum anticipated read noise is 10 electrons at 500 Hz. The 96actuator deformable mirror will come from Xinetics. In addition to the hardware development at Asiago, a large amount of unique work on determining global tilt from artificial laser guide stars is done by the astronomers at the Astronomical Observatory of Padova (Ragazzoni et al.) and collaborators at Arcetri. E.
ALFA, Calar Alto
In addition to ESO, the Max-Planck Institutes for Astronomy (Heidelberg, Germany) and the Max Planck Institute for Extraterrestrial Physics (Garching, Germany) have installed a laser guide star and adaptive optics system on the 3.5-m telescope at Calar Alto, Spain. The AO system, adaptive optics with a laser for astronomy (ALFA), is one of only three operational sodium laser guide star astronomical telescopes in the world (27). The AO instrumentation was integrated as a turnkey system by Adaptive Optics Associates, Inc. (AOA). The first generation deformable mirror built by Xinetics has 97 PMN actuators and 2-µm maximum stroke. The wavefront sensor, built by AOA, is a 100-subaperture system using an MIT/LL focal plane array with 64 ⫻ 64 pixels with a 1206 frame/s readout rate and 6 electrons/pixel noise. For dim guide stars, this chip can be read out at 60 Hz, but the electron read noise increases to nine electrons because of higher dark current. The processor uses 20 Texas Instruments TMS320C40 boards and Motorola 68060 CPUs. It can calculate 15 aberration modes in 0.7 ms (900 Hz closed loop) from a subset of 20 subapertures. A 350-actuator Xinetics DM is expected to replace the earlier version. ALFA also has a state-of-the-art sodium laser guide star. The LGS is a 3.75-W dye laser from Coherent (Santa Clara, CA) pumped by a 25-W Ar ion laser (28). This produces a magnitude 9–10 LGS. A natural guide star is used for tip/tilt, stabilization in a 5–10 Hz control loop. The tip/tilt camera is a EEV CCD39 (80 ⫻ 160 pixel) camera from AstroCam Ltd., Cambridge, UK (29). F.
Lick Observatory
Lawrence Livermore National Laboratory (LLNL) supported the Lick observatory in finding usage for technologies such as the AVLIS laser used in laser isotope separation. The adaptive optics system (30) consists of a 127-actuator (61-active) deformable mirror built by LLNL. The DM was reported to have a 4-
Copyright 2000 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
18
Tyson
µm stroke. Adaptive Optics Associates built the 37-subaperture Shack-Hartmann wavefront sensor using a 64 ⫻ 64 pixel CCD array built by MIT/LL. The array was reported to have seven electrons read noise at 1200 fps. The controller used a 160 MFLOP Mercury VME board with four Intel i860 chips. The closed-loop bandwidth was reported to be 30 Hz. The Lick adaptive optics system was the first commercial/university observatory to use a sodium guide star (31). The LLNL laser guide star is a frequency doubled Nd:YAG operating on the Na line (589 nm), with 18W power, 100-ns pulses, 11-kHz rep rate, and projected out of a 30-cm projection telescope. An updated LGS is based on the Oxford Lasers (UK) Cu vapor pumped dye laser. This system has a pulse repetition frequency of 26 kHz with 32-ns pulse length and a peak power of 1100 W. The LGS was supported by a natural guide star tilt loop operating at 120 Hz. G. Mt. Palomar The Mt. Palomar adaptive optics system was retrofitted to the 50-year-old 200inch (5 m) Hale telescope (32). The system consists of a Xinetics 349-actuator DM with PMN actuators and 4-µm stroke. The 241-subaperture wavefront sensor was built by AOA. The WFS contains a MIT/LL 64 ⫻ 64 pixel CCID with six electrons read noise and 600 fps readout rate. The system was integrated at the NASA Jet Propulsion Laboratory and placed on the telescope in 1997. H. Mt. Wilson The University of Illinois Seeing Improvement System (UnISIS) adaptive optics system (33) on the Mt. Wilson 2.5-m telescope contains a 177-actuator Xinetics DM and a 351-nm Rayleigh guide star. For natural guide stars a 64 ⫻ 64 pixel MIT/LL sensor is used. The sensor has 6.4 electrons read noise and approximately 90% peak QE at 700 nm. For the 351-nm LGS the detector is an EEV model 39A 80 ⫻ 80 pixel CCD (34). I. Monolithic Mirror Telescope Retrofit of the 6.5-m multiple mirror telescope (MMT) on Mt. Hopkins, AZ, with a monolithic 6.5-m primary mirror becomes the monolithic mirror telescope (MMT) (35). The adaptive optics system is a unique implementation. To keep the number of reflective surfaces at a minimum, the staff has designed a 300actuator deformable secondary mirror. (Most other adaptive optics implementations use existing primary and secondary mirrors, reimage the pupil to a position within the optical train either in the Coude´ path or along the Cassegrain focus path, and place a nominally flat DM in that location.) The curved DM is being built by Thermo Trex Corp. (San Diego, CA). The wavefront sensor is a Shack-
Copyright 2000 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
Introduction
19
Hartmann design with an EEV CCD39A 80 ⫻ 80 pixel chip with 3.6 electrons read noise operating at 390 kHz. The wavefront control computer uses Texas Instruments TMS320C40 DSPs for slope processors and matrix multipliers. The LGS is a Lite Cycles (Tucson, AZ) doubled Nd:YAG Raman shifted with CaWO4 to achieve 10-W output at 589 nm at 108 Hz and 0.73-ns pulse length. The laser will be upgraded to a doubled Raman-shifted fiber laser to operate CW at 10 W. J. National Solar Observatory The National Solar Observatory, Sacramento Peak, NM, experimented with adaptive optics on the 76-cm vacuum tower telescope (VTT) in 1991. The early system used a Lockheed segmented deformable mirror and a Shack-Hartmann WFS based on an array of quad-cell detectors. The system that is being designed now will use a 97-actuator Xinetics deformable mirror and a ‘‘correlating Shack-Hartmann’’ wavefront sensor that uses arbitrary scenes like solar granulation as targets for wavefront sensing (36). The control computer uses off-the-shelf digital signal processor components. The unique advance of this system is the ability to use a non-point-like source as the wavefront beacon that is imaged on a focal plane array. Each subaperture is a 12 ⫻ 12 pixel array with a 6-arcsec square field-of-view. The individual images are cross correlated to extract the wavefront modes for driving the deformable mirror. K.
W. M. Keck Telescope
The two 10-m telescopes on Mauna Kea will be fitted with adaptive optics (37). Keck II will be fitted first in 1998–1999, followed by Keck I in 1999–2000. The Keck AO system allows the science beam to reach the detector suite with the same F/# with or without the adaptive optics in place. The laser guide star system, built by Lawrence Livermore National Laboratory, was delivered in February 1998. The adaptive optics system has a 349-actuator Xinetics DM. The wavefront sensor, built by Georgia Tech Research Inst. (Atlanta, GA) and AOA, uses a 64 ⫻ 64 pixel array CCD, built by MIT/LL, with 11 electrons read noise at 2-kHz frame rate. The reconstructor is based on 16 i860 Mercury boards. The tilt sensor uses an EG&G avalanche photodiode. The sodium LGS is a Nd:YAG-pumped three-stage LLNL dye laser. It has a 30-kHz PRF, 100-ns pulses, 20 W to create a tenth magnitude star from a 50-cm projection telescope. L.
Apache Point Observatory—Chicago Adaptive Optics System
Adaptive optics has been installed on the Apache Point 3.5-m ARC telescope (38). It is primarily operated at 0.85 µm using a MIT Lincoln Laboratory 64 ⫻ 64
Copyright 2000 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
20
Tyson
element CCD array and an Adaptive Optics Associates lenslet array for wavefront sensing. The University of Chicago built the deformable mirrors with 201 actuators and 4-µm stroke. M. Alpha LAMP Integration The Alpha LAMP Integration (ALI) program is the United States’ technology demonstration system for space-based high energy laser (HEL) weapons. The program, under the direction of the U.S. Ballistic Missile Defense Organization (BMDO) and the U. S. Air Force, has resulted in a number of demonstrations of technology, including the successful firing of a high energy hydrogen fluoride laser in a vacuum, wavefront control of the HEL using adaptive optics, beam pointing and jitter control, and development, manufacture, and operation of a 4-m segmented, active HEL primary mirror. The adaptive optics make use of the unique characteristics available to a space-based device. Without the atmosphere to be compensated, the disturbances of the laser and optics are the principal problems. The wavefront is sampled from the final optical element of the beam train, the LAMP primary mirror (PM). LAMP has 404 holographically etched gratings on it that transmit a part of the outgoing beam (a small fraction of 1%) through a hole in the center of the secondary mirror. Behind the hole is the outgoing wavefront sensor (OWS) with a series of transfer optics and two orthogonal focal plane arrays. A total of 512 centroids are measured in a Hartmann configuration. In addition to the outgoing wavefront measured at the OWS, 8 centroids from the autoalignment system are measured for boresighting the tracker to the HEL pointing optics, and 100 null centroids are measured for calibration. The centroid processor then transmits the information to the control computer, which multiplies the centroid signals by an estimation matrix and produces 241 deformable mirror commands and offloads the global tilt commands to a fast steering mirror. System focus is an open-loop command to the secondary mirror based on target range or, in the case of the ALI experiment, the focal point of the diagnostics. The system is designed to work at near 500 Hz. Other active elements of the system include the actuators on the segments of the LAMP primary mirror, a series of beam walk mirrors to keep the HEL beam on the clear aperture throughout the optical train, and the jitter control between the laser resonator and the beam control system. N. U. S. Air Force Airborne Laser The Airborne Laser (ABL) is a demonstration USAF high energy laser weapon system designed for endoatmospheric destruction of missiles in their boost phase. To compensate for atmospheric distortion in the long slant paths between the ABL and the target, the system has three adaptive optics systems which are
Copyright 2000 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
Introduction
21
interconnected. The beam path where compensation takes place is 30 cm in diameter. There are three deformable mirrors. The atmospheric compensation deformable mirror (ACDM) and the beam cleanup deformable mirror (BCDM) are identical. Both are 256-actuator PMN designs with 1.67 cm interactuator spacing and a silicon or ULE facesheet. There is an 18 ⫻ 18 array where 196 actuators are controlled and 60 are slave actuators. The stroke is specified at ⫾4 µm with a 1-kHz bandwidth at 0.8-µm wavelength. The third DM is the focus offload DM (FODM), which is designed to compensate for just the focus aberration to offload that correction from the ACDM and BCDM. The FODM will have 15-µm stroke, interactuator spacing of 3.34 cm, and a 10-Hz bandwidth. The PMN actuators of the FODM are in a 9 ⫻ 9 array with 69 actuators (44 active, 25 slave). The baseline wavefront sensor detector is an EBCCD with 20% QE and 128 ⫻ 128 pixels. Two illuminators are used in the ABL. The beacon illuminator is a 7.5-kHz, 1.9-cm beam, ⬍100-ns pulse laser. The power level is classified. The beacon is split into eight smaller beacons to avoid scintillation effects on the target that reduce the wavefront compensation performance by causing dropout of the wavefront signals. The Tracker illuminator is to operate at 5 kHz with 1.75cm beam and ⬍100-ns pulse. O.
Gemini
Gemini, an astronomy consortium of the United States, Canada, United Kingdom, Chile, Brazil, and Argentina, is building two identical 8.1-m telescopes, one on Mauna Kea (G-MK) the other at Cerro Pachon, Chile (G-CP) (39). The adaptive optics system for Gemini-Mauna Kea is being designed by the Herzberg Institute of Astrophysics, Dominion Astrophysical Observatory, Canada. The system consists of a 8 ⫻ 8 subaperture Shack-Hartmann wavefront sensor and continuous faceplate DM. The sensor uses a 64 ⫻ 64 pixel CCD with up to 200-Hz readout for tilt. One unique characteristic of the G-MK adaptive optics system is the configuration where the pupil of the DM is imaged to the strongest atmospheric turbulence layer at 6.5-km altitude (40). This was done to maximize the isoplanatic angle and, therefore, sky coverage. All other astronomical imaging systems and laser projection systems image the DM pupil to the primary mirror for simplicity of design and flexibility with a changing atmosphere. P.
Subaru
The Subaru telescope, the Japanese National Astronomical Observatory effort on Mauna Kea, is an 8.3-m telescope with an adaptive optics system consisting of a French CILAS bimorph deformable mirror with 185 actuators (41). The system will use a wavefront sensor with 144 subapertures for bright guide stars and
Copyright 2000 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
22
Tyson
detuned to 36 subapertures for dim guide stars. Both a visible wavefront sensor (500-Hz frame rate) and an IR sensor (200-Hz frame rate) will be used. The system is expected to be operational by the year 2000. Q. United Kingdom Adaptive Optics Program The UK Adaptive Optics Programme (42) is the coordinating entity for a number of university astronomy efforts throughout the United Kingdom. The most developed is the ELECTRA deformable mirror system, used with the Nasmyth adaptive optics for multi-purpose instrumentation (NAOMI), which is installed on the 4.2-m William Herschel telescope at La Palma, Canary Islands. The adaptive optics system consists of a 76-element segmented DM with each segment having tip-tilt-piston motion. The result is a 228-degree-of-freedom system. The mirror is driven by a Shack-Hartmann wavefront sensor with 8 ⫻ 8 subapertures operating in the 0.5–0.8 µm band. The system can be detuned to a 4 ⫻ 4 subaperture array for dim guide stars. The wavefront sensor camera is an EEV Ltd. (UK) device. The system uses natural guide stars and a 2.2-µm science camera (43). The principal investigators are at the University of Durham, the Royal Observatory Edinburgh, the Royal Greenwich Observatory, the University of Kent, and Imperial College London. R. Mexican IR-Optical New Technology Telescope (TIM) A collaboration between the Instituto de Astronomia, Universidad Nacional Autonoma de Mexico (UNAM) in Ciudad Universitaria D.F. Mexico, the Departement d’Astrophysique de l’Universite de Nice, France, the European Southern Observatory, Santiago, Chile, and the Institute for Astronomy, University of Hawaii, Honolulu, HI, has resulted in a design for an operational adaptive optics system for the 6.5-m segmented Mexican IR-optical new technology telescope (TIM) (44). The proof-of-principle AO system is composed of a 19-element bimorph with curvature sensing tested on the 2.1-m San Pedro martir (SPM) telescope. The system, named GUIELOA (Zapotec language for ‘‘our eyes’’), is very similar to the CFHT Pueo system. The Mexican AO program will use EG & G active quenching APDs for sensing and will be controlled by two Force SPARC5 computers and a SPARC workstation. Another less ambitious system is being built for the Observatoro Astronomico Nacional in Tonantzintla, Puebla, Mexico. The tip-tilt only system is built at the Instituto de Astronomia (National Autonomous University of Mexico), Coyoacan, Mexico. The system contains an EG & G C30927E-03 chip for a quadrant detector with Physik Instrumente (Germany) E-809.00 piezodrivers on a 2-cm tilt mirror (45).
Copyright 2000 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
Introduction
S.
23
Gran Telescopio Canarias (GTC)
The Instituto de Astrofisica de Canarias is designing an adaptive optics system for the Gran Telescopio Canarias (GTC) to be installed within the next few years (46). The telescope is a 10-m aperture with 36 segments, similar to the Keck telescope. There will be either 10 ⫻ 10 or 16 ⫻ 16 subapertures for the wavefront sensor and 11 ⫻ 11 or 17 ⫻ 17 actuators. The wavefront sensing band is 0.4– 0.8 µm with a variable sampling rate between 10 and 1000 Hz. The wavefront error from optical aberrations has been minimized to 122 nm. The system is being designed for diffraction limited performance (0.94 Strehl ratio) at 2.2 µm using a 280-actuator DM.
T.
Yunnan Observatory
A second-generation adaptive optics system is operating at the 1.2-m Yunnan telescope. The wavefront sensor is a 838-Hz Shack-Hartmann sensor. It contains a Chinese-built lenslet array and wavefront processor. The image intensifier for the WFS is a Hamamatsu C2166-1. The focal plane array for the WFS is a Dalsa (Waterloo, Ont., Canada) CCD CA-0128A. The wavefront processor uses 12 Texas Instruments TMS320C50 DSP chips. The closed-loop bandwidth is 50 Hz (47). The deformable mirror is built from PZT stacks, with an 8.8-cm clear aperture; the actuators are on 1.2-cm spacing, with ⫾2.2-µm stroke and 3% hysteresis. The Rayleigh laser guide star is still under development. The laser will be a frequency doubled Nd:YAG, 100-mJ/pulse, device operating at 838 Hz to match the WFS. The first-generation adaptive optics system was demonstrated previously on the Yunnan 1.2 m telescope. The 21-actuator system operated for stellar imaging in visible wavelengths. This system had a 300-Hz open-loop bandwidth, with 700-V DM and separate tilt mirror. The WFS was the 32-subaperture shearing interferometer, with λ/59 wavefront detection error, and a digital 65-Hz control system. This same system operated on the Yunnan 0.375-m telescope at Phoenix Hill and Xinglong. The wavefront sensor used 0.4–0.9 µm photon counting PMTs with 95 photons/subaperture sensitivity (48). To support the observatory work, the Institute of Optics and Electronics, Chengdu, has developed a number of prototype deformable mirrors and demonstrated closed-loop performance. A 21-actuator DM and tilt mirror with a 32-subaperture shearing interferometer and an analog 300-Hz control system was used to demonstrate atmospheric turbulence compensation in a horizontal path experiment (49). Other technology included a 55-actuator, 10-cm 400V DM that used the inner 37 actuator (50) and a larger 69-actuator, 12-cm DM (51).
Copyright 2000 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
24
Tyson
U. Beijing Observatory On the Beijing Observatory 2.16-m telescope, stellar imaging in the visible and IR was reported using the Chengdu-built 21-actuator DM and tilt mirror, 32subaperture shearing interferometer, operating at 2.2 µm with a digital 25-Hz control system (52). In 1988, on this same telescope, a 19-actuator Chengdubuilt DM (1.5 µm/600V) with a 37-subaperture 380 frames/s, 8-bit wavefront sensor was used to demonstrate atmospheric compensation. The WFS had 16 ⫻ 14 pixels/subaperture, an EG & G Reticon 128 ⫻ 128 camera, operating at 1.315 µm. The control computer used five Texas Instruments TMS320C25 processor chips. There have been supporting adaptive optics technology experiments at the National University of Defense Technology, Changsha (53). A deformable mirror with 63 actuators was integrated with a 52-subaperture WFS containing a CCD camera. The camera readout is 1 ms. The 104 slopes from the WFS are processed with eight TMS320C50 chips by a control algorithm with 500 computations/frame, 250 µs/frame, using a computer with two TMS320C50 chips.
V. U.S. Air Force Advanced Electro-optic System The advanced electro-optic system (AEOS) is a U.S. Air Force telescope placed on Mt. Haleakala, HI, to replace the AMOS compensated imaging system. AEOS will use a Xinetics 941-actuator DM, identical to that in use at SOR, with an advanced control system to allow variations in the reconstructor matrix during observations to optimize the bandwidth, constrained by guide star brightness and site conditions.
W. Anglo-Australian Telescope Because Australia has no high altitude sites suitable for high resolution astronomy, most of the science is accomplished through sky mapping and other widefield efforts. The Anglo-Australian Telescope will employ a basic adaptive optics system (54) consisting of a 19-element bimorph, 7.5-cm (3.5-cm active) diameter with a 22-µm stroke for a 500-V drive signal. The WFS is a 19-element curvature sensor with 100-Hz closed-loop bandwidth. The system is designed to maximize sky coverage by conjugating the phase at different altitude layers. However, since the data on the atmospheric layers is sparse, the system must be flexible to adjust the conjugation distance. This process requires intensive computer processing, but it has been determined that an off-the-shelf SPRC workstation is capable of tip-tilt computations.
Copyright 2000 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
Introduction
25
REFERENCES 1. M. C. Roggemann, B. Welsh, Imaging through Turbulence, CRC Press, Boca Raton, FL, 1996. 2. R. K. Tyson, Principles of Adaptive Optics, 2nd ed., Academic Press, Boston. 1997. 3. H. W. Babcock, Publ. Astron. Soc. Pac. 65, 229 (1953). 4. V. P. Linnik, Opt. Spektrosk. (USSR) 3, 401 (1957); English translation in F. Merkle, ed., Active and Adaptive Optics, European Southern Observatory Conf. and Proc. 48, European Southern Observatory, Garching bei Munchen, Germany (1994), p. 535. 5. J. W. Hardy, Sci. Am., June (1994), p. 60 6. D. L. Fried, J. Opt. Soc. Am. 56, 1380 (1966). 7. D. P. Greenwood, J. Opt. Soc. Am. 67, 390 (1977). 8. G. A. Tyler, J. Opt. Soc. Am. A, 1, 251 (1984). 9. V. P. Lukin, Atmospheric Adaptive Optics, SPIE Opt. Engr. Press, Bellingham, WA, 1995. 10. R. Foy, A. Labeyrie, Astron. Astrophys. 152, L29 (1985). 11. R. A. Hutchin, OSA Annual Mtg., San Jose, CA, Paper FH2, 1991. 12. R. Q. Fugate, D. L. Fried, G. A. Ameer, B. R. Boeke, S. L. Browne, P. H. Roberts, R. E. Ruane, L. M. Wopat, Nature (London) 353, 144 (1991). 13. B. M. Levine, J. R. Janesick, J. C. Shelton, Proc. SPIE 2201, 596 (1994) C. D. McKay, J. E. Baldwin, J. Rogers, G. Cox, Proc. SPIE 2201, 613 (1994). 14. F. Roddier, Appl. Opt. 27, 1223 (1988). 15. R. Q. Fugate, Top. Mtg. on Adap. Opt. Soc. Am. Tech. Dig. Series 13, 90 (1996); L. A. Thompson, R. M. Castle, Opt. Lett. 17, 1485 (1992). 16. S. R. Restaino, D. Payne, M. Anderson, J. T. Baker, S. A. Serati, G. C. Loos, Proc. SPIE 3353, 776 (1998). 17. J. M. Spinhirne, J. G. Allen, G. A. Ameer, J. M. Brown II, J. C. Christou, T. S. Duncan, R. J. Eager, M. A. Ealey, B. L. Ellerbroek, R. Q. Fugate, G. W. Jones, R. M. Kuhns, D. J. Lee, W. H. Lowrey, M. D. Oliker, R. E. Ruane, D. W. Swindle, J. K. Voas, W. J. Wild, K. B. Wilson, J. L. Wynia, Proc. SPIE 3353, 22 (1998). 18. R. Arsenault, D. Salmon, F. Roddier, G. Monnet, J. Kerr, J. Sovka, ‘‘The CanadaFrance-Hawaii Telescope Adaptive Optics Instrument Adaptor,’’ Proc. SPIE 1920, 364 (1993); J. E. Graves, M. J. Northcott, F. J. Roddier, C. A. Roddier, L. M. Close, Proc. SPIE 3353, 34 (1998). 19. F. Rigaut, ESO Conf. Prog. Telesc. Instrum. Tech., 479, 1992. 20. G. Rousset, J. L. Beuzit, N. Hubin, E. Gendron, P.-Y. Madec, C. Boyer, J.-P. Gaffard, J.-C. Richard, M. Vittot, P. Gigan, P. J. Lena, Proc. SPIE 2201, 1088 (1994). 21. J. L. Beuzit et al., Proc. OSA Top. Mtg. Adap. Opt., ESO, p. 57, 1996. 22. D. Bonaccini, F. J. Rigault, A. Glindemann, G. Dudziak, J.-M. Mariotti, F. Paresce, Proc. SPIE 3353, 224 (1998). 23. D. Bonaccini, E. Prieto, P. Corporon, J. C. Christou, D. le Mignan, P. D. Drado, R. Gredel, N. N. Hubin., Proc. SPIE 3126, 589 (1997).
Copyright 2000 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
26
Tyson
24.
R. Ragazzoni, D. Bonaccini, ‘‘The Adaptive Optics System for the Telescopio Nazionale Galileo,’’ Proc. Top. Mtg. on Adaptive Optics, ESO Conf. and Workshop Proc. 54, 17 (1996). R. Ragazzoni, A. Baruffolo, J. Farinato, A. Ghedina, S. Mallucci, E. Marchetti, T. Niero, Proc. SPIE 3353, 132 (1998). R. Ragazzoni, ed., AdOpt@TNG Yearly Status Report, Dec. 1997. Some summaries are also available in Proc. SPIE 3126 (1997) and Proc. SPIE 3353 (1998). S. Hippler, A. Glindemann, M. Kasper P. Kalas, R.-R. Rohloff, K. Wagner, D. P. Looze, W. K. Hackenberg, Proc. SPIE 3353, 44 (1998). A. Quirrenbach, Proc. SPIE 3126, 35 (1997). A. Glindemann et al., Publ. Astron. Soc. Pac. 109, 688 (1997). H. D. Bissinger, S. S. Olivier, C. E. Max, ‘‘Conceptual Design for a User-Friendly Adaptive Optics System at Lick Observatory,’’ Top. Mtg. on Adap. Opt., Opt. Soc. Am. Tech. Dig. Series 13, 37 (1996). D. T. Gavel, H. W. Friedman, Proc. SPIE 3353, 254 (1998). R. G. Dekany, ‘‘The Palomar Adaptive Optics System,’’ Top. Mtg. on Adap. Opt., Opt. Soc. Am. Tech. Dig. Series 13, 40 (1996); R. G. Dekany, G. Brack, D. Palmer, B. R. Oppenheimer, T. L. Hayward, Proc. SPIE 3353, 56 (1998). C. Shelton, S. Baliunas, Proc. SPIE 1920, 371 (1993). L. A. Thompson, R. M. Castle, S. W. Teare, P. R. McCullough, S. L. Crawford, Proc. SPIE 3353, 282 (1998). M. Lloyd-Hart, J. R. P. Angel, D. G. Sandler, T. K. Barrett, P. C. McGuire, T. A. Rhoadarmer, D. G. Bruns, S. M. Miller, D. W. McGarthy, M. Cheselka, Proc. SPIE 3353, 82 (1998). T. R. Rimmele, R. R. Radick., Proc. SPIE 3353, 72 (1998). D. S. Acton, P. L. Wizinowich, P. J. Stomski, J. C. Shelton, O. Lai, J. M. Brase, Proc. SPIE 3353, 125 (1998). E. J. Kibblewhite, M. R. Chun, J. E. Larkin, V. Scor, F. Shi, M. F. Smutko, W. J. Wild, Proc. SPIE 3353, 60 (1998). L. K. Saddlemyer, G. Herriot, J.-P. Veran, J. M. Fletcher, Proc. SPIE 3353, 150 (1998). G. Herriot, S. Morris, S. Roberts, J. M. Fletcher, L. K. Saddlemyer, G. Singh, J.P. Veran, E. H. Richardson, Proc. SPIE 3353, 488 (1998). H. Takami, N. Takato, M. Otsubo, T. Kanzawa, Y. Kamata, K. Nakashima, M. Iye, Proc. SPIE 3353, 500 (1998). R. Myers, A. Longmore, R. Humphreys, G. Gilmore, B. Gentiles, M. Wells, R. Wilson, ‘‘The UK Adaptive Optics Programme,’’ Proc. SPIE 2534, 48 (1995). A. J. Longmore, M. Wells, M. Strachan, C. Dixon, T. Peacocke, R. M. Myers, R. A. Humphreys, A. B. Gentles, S. P Worswick, A. J. Weise, Proc. SPIE 3126, 18 (1997). S. Cuevas, P. Sotelo, F. Garfias, A. Iriarte, L. A. Martinez, V. G. Orlov, V. V. Voitsekhovich, O. Chapa, S. J. Tinoco, J. Vernin, R. Avila, F. Marchis, J. E. Graves, M. J. Northcutt, F. J. Roddier, C. A. Roddier, Proc. SPIE 3353, 531 (1998). P. Sotelo, R. Flores, F. Garfias, S. Cuevas, Proc. SPIE 3353, 1202 (1998). N. Devaney, C. D. Bello, J. Keen, L. Jochum, Proc. SPIE 3353, 561 (1998).
25. 26. 27. 28. 29. 30.
31. 32.
33. 34. 35.
36. 37. 38. 39. 40. 41. 42. 43.
44.
45. 46.
Copyright 2000 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
Introduction
27
47. W. Jiang, N. Ling, G. Tang, M. Li, F. Shen, C. Rao, Y. Zhu, B. Xu, Proc. SPIE 3353, 696 (1998). 48. W. Jiang et al., Proc. SPIE 1920, 381 (1993). 49. W. Jiang et al., Sci. Engr. Frontiers for 8–10 m Telesc., Tokyo (1994). 50. Z. Zhige et al., High Pwr. Laser & Part. Beams, 8, 88, 1996. 51. N. Ling, Proc. SPIE 2828, 472 (1996). 52. R. Changhui, High Pwr. Laser Part. Beams, 8, 469 (1996). 53. J. Yongmei et al., J. Nat. Univ. Def. Tech., 18, 90 (1996). 54. J. J. Bryant, J. W. O’Byrne, R. A. Minard, P. W. Fekete, ‘‘Low Order Adaptive Optics at the Anglo-Australian Telescope,’’ Proc. Top. Mtg. on Adaptive Optics, ESO Conf. and Workshop Proc. 54, 23 (1996).
Copyright 2000 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
2 System Design and Optimization Ronald R. Parenti Massachusetts Institute of Technology Lincoln Laboratory, Lexington, Massachusetts
An adaptive-optics system for real-time phase conjugation can be characterized as a highly parallel servo device capable of sensing and correcting the incoming wavefront at the pupil plane of an imaging sensor. Performance close to the diffraction limit of the input aperture can be achieved in the limit that the angular separation between the turbulence probe and the target object is small (⬍θ 0 ), the spacing between control elements on the active optical element is well matched to the turbulence coherence length (⬍r0 ), and a sufficiently high update rate is maintained (⬎1/τ 0 ). However in most practical implementations of this concept, performance compromises are necessary to reduce component costs and improve the sensitivity of the wavefront sensor. The four principal elements of a conventional adaptive-optics system are shown in Fig. 1. Light originating from an exoatmospheric source is corrupted in both amplitude and phase as a result of random fluctuations in the refractive index of the intervening air. The quality of the image formed at the focus of a ground-based telescope is largely driven by phase distortions, which can be corrected through the insertion of an optical surface having the conjugate optical path difference (OPD). Most compensation systems apply this conjugate phase with a pair of active elements consisting of a high-speed tilt mirror and a deformable mirror that removes the figure (tilt-removed) component of the distortion. Error signals are generated by the phase sensor, which actually measures the first derivative of the phase of the incoming wavefront. A phase-computation device, referred to as a reconstructor, transforms the output of the wavefront sensor into a set of drive signals that control the active optical elements. Each of the components just described has a unique set of error mechanisms that together establish the overall effectiveness of the adaptive-optics system. In
Copyright 2000 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
30
Parenti
Figure 1 Essential components of an adaptive-optics phase compensation system. Error signals developed from the phase difference between the incoming wavefront and the deformable mirror are measured by the phase sensor and subsequently applied to the two active optical elements. The overall performance of the system is primarily a function of the correction bandwidth, mirror actuator density, and measurement noise.
the following sections the first-order effects of these errors are quantified; the most important effects are then combined in a servo loop model that provides a concise description of the dynamic performance characteristics. I. ATMOSPHERIC MODELS To motivate this discussion it will be useful to refer to a specific set of atmospheric models so that numerical results can be generated. During the past two decades, several dozen models have been developed in an attempt to describe refractive-index measurements made at a variety of locations throughout the world. For daytime conditions at inland sites, the SLC-Day (1) (standardized under the Submarine-Laser Communications program) and the Hufnagel-Valley (2) turbulence models are frequently employed for systems analysis. For nighttime viewing at good astronomical sites a more benign model is probably appropriate; the following formulation is based on the Hufnagel-Valley profile: C 2n (h) ⫽ 8.16 ⫻ 10⫺54 h 10 exp ⫹ 1.90 ⫻ 10⫺15 exp
冢 冣 冢 冣
冢 冣
⫺h ⫺h ⫹ 3.02 ⫻ 10⫺17 exp 1000 1500
⫺h 100
where the units of the altitude, h, is meters.
Copyright 2000 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
(m⫺2/3)
(1)
System Design and Optimization
31
Temporal fluctuations in the cumulative phase distortion are somewhat less critical to this analysis; therefore, the standard wind-velocity profile proposed by Bufton (3) is probably appropriate for most calculations:
冦冤
h ⫺ 9400 v(h) ⫽ 5 ⫹ 30 exp ⫺ 4800
冥冧 2
(m/sec)
(2)
The turbulence and wind models are plotted as a function of altitude in Fig. 2 and 3, respectively. The physical properties of turbulence and its effect on optical systems can usually be described in terms of the turbulence and wind-velocity moments, defined by the integrals µ n ⬅ ∫ C 2n (h) h n dh
and
v n ⬅ ∫ C 2n (h) v n (h) dh
The zeroth-order turbulence moment provides a measure of the spatial coherence length (4): r0 ⫽ {0.423 k 2 sec(ζ) µ 0 }⫺3/5
(m)
(3)
and the atmospheric time constant is derived from the 5/3 velocity moment (5): τ 0 ⫽ {2.91 k 2 sec(ζ)v 5/3 }⫺3/5
(sec)
(4)
Figure 2 Comparison of the Hufnagel-Valley model that is typically used for calculations of daytime turbulence, and the modified HV model that was developed by the authors to represent nighttime turbulence conditions at good seeing locations.
Copyright 2000 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
32
Parenti
Figure 3 The Bufton wind velocity profile.
where k ⫽ 2π/λ is the optical wavenumber and ζ is the zenith angle. Astronomers prefer to characterize turbulence strength by the seeing angle, which is inversely related to r0 : θ seeing ⫽ 1.22
λ r0
(rad)
(5)
Angular coherence effects can be estimated from the 5/3 turbulence moment: θ 0 ⫽ {2.91 k 2 sec 8/3 (ζ)µ 5/3 }⫺3/5
(rad)
(6)
where the parameter θ 0 is known as the isoplanatic patch. A numerical tabulation of these quantities for the three turbulence models introduced earlier in this section is provided in Table 1. The performance of closed-loop servo systems is somewhat dependent on the power spectrum of the input disturbance, and it is useful, therefore, to specify nominal spectra for the figure (tilt-removed) and tilt components of turbulence. The figure component of turbulence is developed from a paper by Greenwood and Fried (6). This spectrum, which is plotted in Fig. 4, can be approximated by a function having two segments: Ffig ( f ) ⫽
⫺7/5 4/3 0.132 sec(ζ)k 2 D 4 µ 12/5 , 0 v 5/3 f
冦0.0326 sec(ζ)k v 2
5/3
f ⫺8/3,
Copyright 2000 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
f ⱕ 0.705 D⫺1 µ ⫺3/5 v 3/5 0 5/3 f ⱖ 0.705 D⫺1 µ ⫺3/5 v 3/5 0 5/3
(7)
System Design and Optimization
33
Table 1 Summary of Turbulence Parameters for Imaging Systems Operating at 0.55 µm Model SLC-Day HV-21 Modified HV
Zenith
r0 (cm)
θ seeing (arc-s)
θ0 (µrad)
τ0 (ms)
0° 45° 0° 45° 0° 45°
5.7 4.6 5.6 4.5 20.0 16.2
2.4 3.0 2.5 3.1 0.69 0.85
13.8 8.0 7.8 4.5 20.0 11.5
2.7 2.2 2.1 1.7 6.3 5.1
The units are rad 2 of phase error per Hz. A concise treatment of full-aperture tilt was recently published by Tyler (7). This spectrum also has a simple form in its low- and high-frequency limits that can be joined at their intersection to give Ftilt ( f ) ⫽
冦0.028 sec(ζ) D
1.60 sec(ζ)v ⫺1/3 f ⫺2/3, ⫺5
v 14/3 f ⫺17/3,
1/5 f ⱕ 0.445 D⫺1 v ⫺1/5 ⫺1/3 v 14/3 1/5 f ⱖ 0.445 D⫺1 v ⫺1/5 ⫺1/3 v 14/3
(8)
Figure 4 Power spectrum for turbulence-induced figure error. This model incorporates atmospheric moments developed from the modified Hufnagel-Valley turbulence profile and the Bufton wind profile.
Copyright 2000 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
34
Parenti
Figure 5 Power spectrum for turbulence-induced tilt error, given in units of rad 2 of single-axis tilt per Hz. This model incorporates atmospheric moments developed from the modified Hufnagel-Valley turbulence profile and the Bufton wind profile.
where the units here are rad 2 of single-axis tilt per Hz and normalized for integration over positive values of f. A plot of this function for a 4-m aperture is given in Fig. 5.
II. PHASE SENSOR AND TRACKING SENSOR MEASUREMENT NOISE Phase sensors and tracking systems have a number of similarities, and a good first-order analysis of both can be made by investigating the properties of a simple quadrant detector. The results given in this discussion are equivalent to those derived elsewhere (8), except for minor differences in the multiplicative constants. In the one-dimensional view of a motion detector shown in Fig. 6a, light from a lens of diameter d s is focused on a pair of detectors that meet in the null position of the focal spot. The off-null position is determined by measuring the difference between the signals generated by the two detectors, i.e., x⫽C
⫺n L ⫹ n R nL ⫹ nR
Copyright 2000 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
System Design and Optimization
35
Figure 6 One-dimensional view of tracking sensor (a) and a Hartmann phase sensor (b) show that they are functionally equivalent in that they convert aperture-averaged tilts into spot displacements at the focus of the lens. The wavefront sensor measures local gradients of the phase of the incoming radiation with a spatial resolution that is comparable to the turbulence coherence length.
where n L and n R represent the number of photoelectrons collected by the left and right detector elements, respectively, and C is a constant determined by the geometry of the optical system. If the focal spot is assumed to be approximately square and to have a diffraction-limited width of f λ/d s , then C⫽
fλ 2d s
and the angular displacement, θ, of a point source with respect to the boresight of the sensor is equal to θ⫽
冤
x λ ⫺n L ⫹ n R ⫽ f 2d s n L ⫹ n R
冥
For most tracking scenarios the size of the focal spot will not be diffractionlimited, but will instead be dominated by an effective collection aperture established by the turbulence coherence diameter, r0 , or determined by the angular extent of the object, θ obj . To first order, the increase in beam diameter due to
Copyright 2000 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
36
Parenti
these two effects can be incorporated into the displacement equation in the following manner: θ⫽
1 2
√冢 冣 冢 冣 2
λ ds
λ r0
⫹
2
⫹ (θ obj ) 2
冤⫺nn ⫹⫹nn 冥 (radians of tilt) L
R
L
(9)
R
A Hartmann phase sensor incorporates an array of quadrant trackers, each of which has a collection diameter comparable to r0 so that the local phase gradient, g, can be accurately measured; a single subaperture element is illustrated in Fig. 6b. In this case the object does not physically move with respect to the system boresight, but only appears to be displaced by an angle, θ, as a result of a phase shift across the subaperture of magnitude 2πθd s /λ. Under some conditions an artificial beacon of wavelength λ b may be necessary to provide an adequate light source for the wavefront sensor, whereas image compensation is optimized for the object wavelength, λ; for these systems an appropriate scaling factor must be included in the gradient equation. The final expression for the phase-gradient measurement is
冢 冣√ 冢 冣 冢 冣 冤 λb
ds
2
ds
2
⫺n L ⫹ n R
冥
(radians of phase) (10) λ r0 λb nL ⫹ nR where r0 is computed for the beacon wavelength. The calculation of the measurement errors associated with Eqs. (9) and (10) is straightforward as long as the signal fluctuations are random and independent. When the focal spot of the motion detector is near its null position, on average the same number of electrons will be collected by each detector so that n L ⫽ n R ⫽ n. The variance of the difference calculation, n R ⫺ n L , is twice the individual measurement variance, σ 2n , thereby yielding the following descriptions of the tilt and phase noise:
g⫽π
1⫹
⫹
θ obj
冦冢 冣 冢 冣 ⫹ (θ ) 冧 (radians of tilt) π σ λ d d σ ⬇ 1⫹ ⫹ θ 冦 冢 冣 冢 冣 冢 冣 冧 (radians of phase) 2n λ r λ σ 2θ ⬇
σ 2n
8n 2
2 n
2
2 g
λ ds
2
2
⫹
λ r0
2
obj
2
b
2
2
2
(11)
2
s
s
0
b
obj
2
(12)
At this point all of the important parameters have been defined, with the exception of σ 2n . Although optical sensors are subject to a wide range of noise mechanisms, the most important of these effects can be characterized by a noise model containing two terms. For an ideal detector, photon noise, which results from the random arrival of photons, determines the sensor’s performance. Photon noise is governed by Poisson statistics, in which case the variance in the number of photoelectrons is equal to the average number collected (9). The readout process for nonideal detectors generates an additive noise contribution that is usually
Copyright 2000 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
System Design and Optimization
37
described in terms of equivalent rms electrons, n rms . This noise source is independent of the input light level, but may be a function of operational factors such as the readout frame rate. The relative impact of additive noise on the output signal can be significantly reduced if an optical intensifier having a photoelectron gain of G e is placed in front of the detector, although this optical configuration can adversely affect the detector’s quantum efficiency, η. For a detector exposed to N photons from which n ⫽ ηN photoelectrons are generated, its measurement variance will be σ 2n ⫽ ηN ⫹
n 2rms
(13)
G 2e
In order to correctly apply Eqs. (11) through (13) to the behavior of a twodimensional quadrant detector, it is necessary to specify the manner in which all of the photons captured by the sensor, represented by Np , are distributed among the individual detectors and subsequently processed. In the case of the tracking sensor, the object’s motion along one dimension is determined by first summing the detector outputs along the orthogonal direction and then forming their difference, as shown in Fig. 7a. Each detector receives Np /4 photons, and the summation process doubles the noise variance from the left and right outputs, so the final error expression is σ 2θ ⬇
G 2e ηNp ⫹ 4n 2rms 4(G e ηNp ) 2
冦冢 冣 冢 冣 ⫹ (θ ) 冧 λ ds
2
⫹
λ r0
2
obj
2
(radians 2 of single-axis tilt)
(14)
Figure 7 Comparison of the data processing for a quadrant motion detector (a) and a Hartmann phase sensor (b). The motion detector can provide signals for the orthogonal direction by interchanging the processing of the four elements. Hartmann sensors typically incorporate a second camera to compute phase gradients along the orthogonal axis.
Copyright 2000 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
38
Parenti
Hartmann sensors can be constructed in a variety of ways. In one of the more common configurations, separate cameras are used to obtain tilts in the two orthogonal directions as a means of reducing the net readout bandwidth. On-chip summation techniques are used, which effectively provide elements having a 2to-1 aspect ratio, as indicated in Fig. 7b. As a result of the initial division of light between two cameras, each of the detector elements within a single subaperture collects Np /4 photons; therefore, σ 2g ⬇
冢 冣 冦 冢 冣 冢 冣冧
2π 2 (G 2e ηNp ⫹ 4n 2rms ) λ b (G e ηNp ) 2
2
λ
1⫹
ds r0
2
⫹
ds
λb
2
θ obj
(radians 2 of phase) (15) Although Eqs. (14) and (15) are only first-order approximations of a very complex noise process, they accurately describe the more important parametric relationships.
III. PHASE RECONSTRUCTOR ERROR PROPAGATOR As the servo model described in Fig. 1 indicates, the error signals that are input to the deformable-mirror servo system are the result of phase estimates generated by the phase reconstructor. This component introduces an estimation error that is proportional to the gradient variance described by Eq. (15). To compute the constant of proportionality (also known as the error propagator, ε p ), the form of the reconstructor algorithm must be specified. In the limit of infinite spatial resolution, the relationship between the phase, φ, and the phase gradient, g, is described by the Poisson equation with Neumann boundary conditions, i.e., ∇ 2 φ ⫽ div g
(16)
For a discrete-measurement system, this relationship can be represented by the matrix product g ⫽ A
(17)
in which g and are the gradient and phase vectors, respectively; A is a twodimensional matrix that uniquely associates each gradient element with two or more phase points. In the Hudgin sensor geometry (10), shown in Fig. 8a, the incoming radiation is sampled by a pair of wavefront sensors that separately measure one-dimensional x and y gradients. The sampling regions of the two sensors are displaced such that each measurement is centered at the midpoint of a horizontal or vertical line drawn between two adjacent phase points. The Fried geometry (11), illustrated in Fig. 8b, can be realized by a single camera that
Copyright 2000 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
System Design and Optimization
39
Figure 8 Separate one-dimensional x and y gradient measurements may be made between two adjacent phase points, as specified by the Hudgin sampling geometry (a), or two-dimensional gradient samples can be obtained within a region centered at the midpoint of four phase points according to the Fried geometry (b).
makes collocated two-dimensional gradient measurements at the center of a region defined by four nearest-neighbor phase points. Fried’s approach requires an array of quadrant detectors, similar to the tracking sensor shown in Fig. 7a. For reasons relating primarily to sensor readout bandwidth, the Hudgin scheme is the more popular of the two sensor implementations. For either sampling geometry, the least-square solution to Eq. (17) is equivalent to the generalized inverse of the A matrix, ⫽ {(At A)⫺1 At } g ⫽ Bg
(18)
where A⫺1 and At represent the inverse and transpose, respectively. Since B is invariant for a given sensor geometry, this operation can be precomputed and permanently programmed into the reconstruction device. The structure of the B matrix provides a complete description of the noise characteristics of the phase reconstructor. Herrmann (12) has shown that the error propagator for a compensation system having Na phase elements is εp ⫽
1 Trace[(At A)⫺1 ] Na
(19)
Numerical calculations performed by Herrmann indicate that when Na is larger than 50, εp ⬇
冦0.24 ln(N ),
0.12 ln(Na ), a
Hudgin geometry Fried geometry
Copyright 2000 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
(20)
40
Parenti
Although the error propagator for the Hudgin reconstructor is a factor of 2 smaller than that for Fried’s reconstructor, the net phase error associated with the two computational techniques is essentially identical. This is due to the fact that the former collects fewer photons due to the need to divide the light between two cameras, whereas the latter has a higher readout noise since each subarray incorporates twice as many detectors. Thus, the phase error, σ 2φ , for either geometry is approximately equal to σ ⬇ 0.24 ln(Na ) 2 φ
冢冣
2π 2 (G 2e ηNp ⫹ 4n 2rms ) λ b (G e ηNp ) 2
λ
冦 冢 r 冣 ⫹ 冢λ θ 冣 冧
⫻ 1⫹
ds
2
2
ds
2
(21)
obj
0
b
The error propagator is approximately equal to unity for deformable-mirror systems having about 100 actuators. IV. THE DEFORMABLE MIRROR The active component of the figure-control servo system is the deformable mirror, which imposes both spatial and temporal limitations on the operation of the compensation system. A one-dimensional cross section of a typical structure is shown in Fig. 9. A thin facesheet is bonded to an array of actuators, each of which is capable of moving a distance equivalent to several optical wavelengths. Many types of actuators have been successfully employed in these structures; some of the more recent designs have included stacks of an electrostrictive material, which can be displaced by several microns by applying a voltage of a few hundred volts. The time required to achieve full-stroke displacement is typically a few
Figure 9 Cross section of a typical deformable mirror employing a flexible facesheet and a two-dimensional array of actuator stacks. The actuators are cemented to the facesheet so that the surface can be deformed by either extending or contracting the actuator dimension.
Copyright 2000 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
System Design and Optimization
41
hundred microseconds. Mirrors have been constructed with the actuator elements arranged in rectangular or hexagonal patterns (zonal control) (13,14) as well as in nonuniform distributions designed to allow independent control of the Zernike modes (modal control) (15). The choice of actuator density is one of the principal drivers in the cost of an adaptive-optics system. Light-collection efficiency is also an important tradeoff when imaging dim sources, since the phase-sensor noise decreases as the subaperture collection area is increased. When the subaperture dimensions become too large, however, the high-frequency components of the turbulence-induced phase distortion cannot be accurately compensated. The resulting spatial distortions in the corrected wavefront are known as fitting error. The uncorrected phase error due to the figure (tilt-removed) component of turbulence is a function of the ratio of the aperture diameter and the turbulence coherence length (16): σ 2fig ⫽ 0.134
冢冣 D r0
5/3
(22)
which corresponds to an rms phase distortion of several wavelengths for a nominal astronomical installation. The correction achievable by an adaptive-optics system having a specified actuator density has been investigated extensively. Some of the earliest work in this field was conducted by Greenwood (17), who derived the following expression to relate the fitting error to the number of actuators, Na: 2 fig fitting
(σ )
冢冣
5/3
D ⬇ 0.274 r0
N ⫺5/6 a
which is perhaps more conveniently expressed in terms of the subaperture spacing, d s : (σ 2fig ) fitting ⬇ 0.34
冢冣
5/3
ds r0
Subsequent experiments have shown that the mechanical constraints applied at the mirror boundaries can significantly increase the value of the leading constant. For this reason, a somewhat more conservative estimate is probably more appropriate for system optimization studies: 2 fig fitting
(σ )
⬇ 0.5
冢冣 ds
5/3
r0
Copyright 2000 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
(23)
42
Parenti
V. SERVO BANDWIDTH LIMITATIONS In the temporal domain, the selection of the correction bandwidth involves cost and light-collection trade-offs that are very similar to those encountered in the determination of actuator density. High bandwidths provide better phase correction, but require higher pixel readout rates that necessitate more expensive sensor designs. Shorter integration times also reduce the number of photons collected per integration cycle, which increases the phase-sensor noise. The complex interaction of these effects is most easily investigated through the use of a simplified servo model. The servo model illustrated schematically in Fig. 10 incorporates the essential components of a CW control loop. The input wavefront is reflected from the deformable mirror and a fraction of the output is sensed by the wavefront sensor. In addition to the residual phase error, a noise component is also generated by the wavefront sensor, and the composite output is averaged for a dwell time, τ d .
Figure 10 Servo loop diagram for a digital control system employing a boxcar averaging device and a digital accumulator. The error signal at the wavefront sensor is averaged for a period of τ d . The accumulator provides the deformable mirror with an impulse drive signal at the end of each integration interval, which is subsequently held until the next drive signal.
Copyright 2000 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
System Design and Optimization
43
The averaged error signal is input to an accumulator, which has an adjustable gain parameter, g l , that is used to vary the loop bandwidth. The mirror response is modeled as having an exponential time constant, τ m . The overall performance of the phase-conjugation system can be characterized by its ability to simultaneously suppress turbulence-induced phase distortions and wavefront sensor noise. The properties of individual components of the system are most conveniently described by a frequency-domain transfer function, which is applied to the power spectrum of the input disturbance; these transfer functions are described in Fig. 10. The net transfer function of the loop also depends on the point at which the disturbance is applied (18). The transfer function with respect to an optical disturbance inserted at the deformable mirror is Tt ( f ) ⫽
冷
1 1 ⫹ H av ( f ) H acc ( f )Hm ( f )
冷
2
(24)
whereas the transfer function for noise generated by the wavefront sensor has the form Tn ( f ) ⫽
冷1 ⫹ H ( f ) H
H av ( f ) H acc ( f ) H m ( f ) av
acc
( f ) Hm( f )
冷
2
(25)
The functions H av , H acc and Hm represent the averager, accumulator, and mirror component transfer functions, respectively. The power spectrum of the residual error is the sum of the turbulence and noise outputs: Ferror ( f ) ⫽ Tt ( f ) Ffig ( f ) ⫹ Tn ( f ) Fnoise ( f )
(26)
where F fig corresponds to the function defined by Eq. (7). This analysis can also be applied to the tilt correction system by replacing the turbulence power spectrum with F tilt and applying the appropriate dwell-time and mirror-response parameters in the component transfer functions. To a limited extent, the response of the servo system can be tuned by adjusting the loop gain setting, although care must be taken to avoid an instability condition. As the accumulator gain is increased, rejection of low-frequency turbulence improves but high-frequency components are amplified; this behavior is illustrated in Fig. 11. The transmission function for noise (examples of which are shown in Fig. 12) is essentially a low-pass filter, which has a cutoff frequency that increases with increasing gain. Parametric investigations similar to those shown in Figs. 11 and 12 indicate that a good compromise between turbulence suppression and noise transmission is achieved when the gain is [g l ] optimal ⬇
1 1 ⫹ 2(τ m /τ d )
Copyright 2000 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
(27)
44
Parenti
Figure 11 Turbulence transfer function for closed-loop compensation as a function of loop gain. In this example, the mirror-response time constant is assumed to be negligible.
Figure 12 Noise transfer function for closed-loop compensation as a function of loop gain. In this example, the mirror-response time constant is assumed to be negligible.
Copyright 2000 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
System Design and Optimization
45
When the servo gain is set to this value, the effective servo time constant, τ s , is τ s ⬇ τ d ⫹ 2τ m
(28)
Since servo performance is commonly described in terms of an equivalent compensation bandwidth, it is useful to relate the turbulence and noise transfer functions given in Eqs. (24) and (25) to a characteristic bandwidth parameter. To first order
冦冢 冣 冧 1⫹冦 冢53冣 2π f τ 冧
{2π f τ s} ⫹ 2
Tt( f ) ⬇
3 2π f τ s 5 4
4
(29)
s
and 1
Tn( f ) ⬇ 1⫹
冦冢 冣
冧
3 2π f τ s 5
4
(30)
where the temporal frequency, f, is in Hz. The low-frequency behavior of the turbulence transfer function approximates that of a two-pole high-pass filter of bandwidth 1/(2 πτ s ), whereas the noise transfer function is equivalent to a fourpole low-pass filter of bandwidth 5/(6πτ s ). When the integrals of Eqs. (29) and (30) are compared to those for ideal binary filter functions, the following approximate relationships are obtained: Bt ⬇
1 10 τ s
(31)
Bn ⬇
1 3 τs
(32)
and
It is perhaps surprising that the noise bandwidth is a factor of 3 larger than the turbulence-correction bandwidth; however, both of these expressions are in good agreement with the usual design guidelines for a discrete servo system operating at a sample rate of 1/τ s . The transfer functions just derived can now be combined with the power spectra discussed in Sec. I and the noise expressions derived in Secs. II and III to develop a composite description of the servo output. The system’s affect on noise generated within the sensing device is most easily understood by recognizing that the relationships given in Eqs. (14) and (15) assume a simple photon integrator having a dwell time of τ d . It is easy to show that the equivalent band-
Copyright 2000 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
46
Parenti
width of this type of integrator is approximately 1/(2 τ d ); therefore, the bandwidth indicated in Eq. (32) represents a noise-throughput reduction corresponding to a multiplicative factor of 2τ d /3τ s . The figure component of turbulence derives from the integral σ 2fig ⫽
冮
∞
Tt ( f )Ffig ( f ) df
0
⬇ 0.0326 sec(ζ) k 2 v 5/3
冮
∞
0
冦冢 冣 冧 f 1⫹冦 冢53冣 2π f τ 冧
{2π f τ s}2 ⫹
3 2π f τ s 5 4
4
⫺8/3
df
s
where the assumption has been made that the low-frequency turbulence component given in Eq. (7) does not contribute significantly to the residual error. The result of this integration yields the approximate expression σ
2 fig
⬇
冢冣 τs
5/3
(33)
τ0
which incorporates the turbulence time constant, τ 0 , defined in Eq. (4). An approximate expression for the tilt component of turbulence is obtained by ignoring the high-frequency component of the tilt power spectrum given in Eq. (5): σ 2tilt ⫽
冮
∞
Tt ( f ) Ftilt ( f ) df
0
⬇ 1.60 sec(ζ) v⫺1/3
冮
1/5 0.445 D⫺1 v ⫺1/5 ⫺1/3 v 14/3
(2π f τ st )2 f ⫺2/3 df
0
where τ st ⫽ τ dt ⫹ 2τ mt represents the effective tilt-servo time constant for a measurement dwell time of τ dt and a mirror time constant of τ mt . The result of this integration is σ 2tilt ⬇ 0.20
冢 冣冢 冣 λ D
2
τ st
2
τ 0t
(34)
where the characteristic tilt time constant is defined to be 7/15 ⫺1/3 ⫺1/2 τ 0t ⬅ {0.512 k 2 sec(ζ)v 8/15 } ⫺1/3 v 14/3 D
(35)
The leading constant in Eq. (35) is chosen such that the beam area due to tracking jitter is approximately twice the diffraction-limited value when τ st /τ 0 t ⫽ 1. The subject of tilt jitter will be treated in more detail in Sec. VI. The analytical development presented in the last four sections can be con-
Copyright 2000 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
System Design and Optimization
47
cisely summarized by a pair of relationships that provide an estimate of the uncorrected servo error. The figure component of the residual error is 2 fig total
(σ )
冢冣 冢冣 冢 冣
1 ds ⬇ 2 r0
5/3
⫹
fitting error
τs
5/3
τ0
2τ d
⫹
servo lag
3τ s
σ 2φ (rad 2 of phrase)
(36)
sensor noise
and the tilt component is 2 tilt total
(σ )
冢 冣冢 冣 冢 冣
1 λ ⬇ 5 D
2
τ st
τ 0t
servo lag
2
⫹
2τ dt 3τ st
σ 2θ (rad 2 of single-axis tilt)
(37)
sensor noise
These two expressions represent the first step in the optimization of an adaptiveoptics system. To complete the process, a relationship must be developed between correction error and overall performance.
VI. HEURISTIC MEASURES OF SYSTEM RESOLUTION The ability of a phase compensation system to correct for the effects of atmospheric distortion can be characterized by a variety of metrics, including the Strehl ratio, beam area, point spread function (PSF), and modulation transfer function (MTF). The Strehl, which is defined as the ratio of the measured onaxis beam intensity to the diffraction-limited intensity, is a convenient and easily defined quantity that is frequently employed by the high-energy laser community. For imaging systems, the PSF and MTF are more relevant measures of performance, but for the purpose of design optimization it would be preferable to define a single scalar quantity to represent focal-plane resolution. The image of a point source viewed through the atmosphere evolves from a simple Airy shape with elevated sidelobes under weak turbulence conditions to a complex speckle pattern as the turbulence becomes more intense; these two limiting conditions are illustrated in Fig. 13. Both pictures are representative of short-exposure data, which means that the sensor integration time is small compared to the atmospheric time constant. When many short-exposure images are averaged, the random speckle patterns merge to form a beam profile that contains a diffraction-limited core having an angular width of approximately λ/D and an extended skirt of dimensions λ/r0 , see Fig. 14. Unfortunately, there is no simple and unambiguous definition of resolution that can be assigned a point spread function of this complex shape. The form indicated schematically in Fig. 14 suggests a description of resolution that evolves from the main-lobe width to the skirt diameter as the strength
Copyright 2000 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
48
Parenti
Figure 13 Comparison of typical far-field beam shapes for (a) weak turbulence and (b) strong turbulence conditions. The main-lobe beamwidth for the weak-turbulence example is approximately λ/D and the Strehl is 0.37. The Strehl for the strong-turbulence irradiance distribution is 0.02 and the linear extent of the beam is roughly λ/r0 .
of turbulence is increased. To investigate the nature of this transition it is useful to begin with the extended Mare´chal approximation, which provides a relationship between the figure error and the Strehl under weak-turbulence conditions Strehl ⬇ exp(⫺σ 2fig )
weak-turbulence conditions
(38)
When the turbulence becomes sufficiently strong, nearly all of the energy is contained in the skirt, in which case the Strehl is better described by a form suggested by Yura (19):
Figure 14 Point-spread function obtained by averaging many short-exposure images corrupted by atmospheric turbulence. The fraction of the energy contained in the outer skirt is a function of the ratio D/r0 .
Copyright 2000 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
System Design and Optimization
Strehl ⬇
49
1 strong-turbulence conditions 1 ⫹ (D/r0 ) 2
(39)
A composite short-exposure Strehl can be developed by assuming that all of the energy lost from the central core of the beam is scattered over a region of width of λ/r0 : [Strehl] SE ⬇ exp(⫺σ 2fig ) ⫹
1 ⫺ exp(⫺σ 2fig ) 1 ⫹ (D/r0 ) 2
(40)
The net resolution afforded by a beam of this description will be greatly dependent upon the nature of the object being imaged. Although it may be possible to accurately determine the separation of two closely spaced point sources when only a small fraction of the total energy is contained in the main lobe of the beam, for more complex scenes the resolution will be limited by sidelobe smearing effects. For these more general conditions, an energy-weighted average of the main-lobe and sidelobe contributions may provide a reasonable working definition of resolution, which yields the following result: [Resolution] SE ⬇ 1.22
冢冣
λ 1 D √ [Strehl] SE
(41)
As indicated in Fig. 15, this representation predicts a transition from the diffraction-limited Rayleigh criterion to a turbulence-dominated resolution that occurs at a figure variance of approximately 2.5 rad 2. This transition value corresponds to an rms figure error of about 1/4 wavelength, which may be regarded as an upper limit on the tolerable error for a compensated imaging system. For most viewing applications it is necessary to employ a camera dwell time that is much longer than the atmospheric time constant in order to collect sufficient light to form a high signal-to-noise image. Under these conditions, the residual tilt jitter of the compensation system must be incorporated into the Strehl and resolution calculations to derive the appropriate long-exposure quantities. When the residual jitter is small, its effect can be modeled as the convolution of a Gaussian profile with the main lobe of the short-exposure beam. The width of the Gaussian distribution is defined by the single-axis tilt jitter, σ tilt , and it is observed that its shape approximates the core of the Airy function when σ tilt ⫽ 0.45(λ/D). Therefore, the addition of tilt jitter to the short-exposure Strehl can be modeled in the following manner: [Strehl] LE ⬇
exp(⫺σ 2fig ) 1 ⫹ 5(D/λ) 2 σ 2tilt
⫹
1 ⫺ exp(⫺σ 2fig )
Copyright 2000 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
1 ⫹ (D/r0 ) 2
(42)
50
Parenti
Figure 15 Composite short-exposure resolution for uncorrected turbulence as a function of figure error. The transition from diffraction-limited resolution to turbulence-dominated resolution occurs in the range of 3–6 rad 2.
and the long-exposure resolution is developed according to the same logic used for the short-exposure case: [Resolution] LE ⬇ 1.22
冢冣
λ 1 D √ [Strehl] LE
(43)
Using Eq. (42) or (43), a system designer can specify a tolerable degradation factor that can subsequently be used to establish an appropriate error budget. A baseline procedure for design optimization is outlined in the next section.
VII. DESIGN GUIDELINES FOR ADAPTIVE-OPTICS SYSTEMS Design strategies for adaptive-optics systems are strongly dependent on the operational environment. High-energy laser beam propagation systems for military applications require near-unity Strehl ratios to achieve good performance; therefore, all sources of compensation error must be kept to a minimum. For astronomical imaging applications, the goals are usually much more modest, and budgetary
Copyright 2000 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
System Design and Optimization
51
constraints are a primary consideration. The design problem for astronomers is further complicated by a requirement to image extremely dim objects, so care must be taken to make optimal use of all available light. Since the design criteria for military systems are more easily developed, this problem will be addressed first. When developing component specifications, the usual approach is to begin with a performance goal and then work backwards through the list of degradation factors to assign a tolerance factor to each. The flowchart shown in Fig. 16 embodies the design relationships assembled earlier in this chapter. Although the formulation of the matrix that minimizes technical risk and monetary cost typically requires extensive iteration, the process can be initiated by making all of the contributions roughly equivalent. As a further refinement of this process, it is observed that when appropriate approximations are applied, the error variance can usually be rewritten as σ 2 (x, y) ⫽ ax m ⫹ by n ⫹ cx⫺r y⫺s
(44)
where x and y are the independent design parameters. The third term in this expression is the noise contribution, which may be represented by the variable z. Equation (44) is minimized when x⫽
冢 冣 rcy⫺s ma
1/(m⫹r)
and
y⫽
冢 冣 scx⫺r nb
1/(n⫹s)
(45)
Figure 16 Flowchart showing the interaction of component performance factors on the net operation of an adaptive-optics system.
Copyright 2000 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
52
Parenti
When these conditions are simultaneously satisfied for a specified performance goal, σ 2goal , the following design guidelines are developed: xⱕ
冤冢
冣 冥
zⱕ
冢
冣
σ 2goal nr nr ⫹ ms ⫹ mn a
1/m
yⱕ
,
冤冢
冣 冥
σ 2goal ms nr ⫹ ms ⫹ mn b
1/n
(46)
and mn σ 2goal nr ⫹ ms ⫹ mn
(47)
Consider, for example, a military system in which the Strehl, S, must be nearly unity. In this case the second term of Eq. (42) may be safely ignored and an equal division of the figure and tracking errors yields the following pair of equations: 2 fig total
(σ )
1 ⱕ ⫺ ln(S) 2
2 tilt total
(σ )
and
冢 冣冤 2
1 λ ⱕ 5 D
1
√S
冥
⫺1
(48)
By incorporating judicious assumptions regarding the dominant resolution and noise effects for high-Strehl operation, one obtains the following forms for the figure and tilt errors: (σ 2fig ) total ⬇
冢冣 冢冣 冦 冢 冣冧
1 ds 2 r0
5/3
⫹
τs
5/3
τ0
2
π D ⫹ 0.24 ln 4 ds
(49)
16π 2 n 2rms 3[(λ/hc)G e ηγτ s d 2s I p ] 2
and (σ 2tilt ) total ⬇
冢 冣冦 冢 冣 λ D
2
1 τ st 5 τ0 t
2
⫹
2 1 3π (λ/hc)ηγ τ r 20 τ st I p
冧
(50)
where I p is the photon irradiance and the γ parameters represent throughput factors for the individual subsystems. When Eq. (46) is applied one obtains d s ⱕ 0.68 [⫺ln(S)] 3/5 r0 ,
τ s ⱕ 0.29 [⫺ln(S)] 3/5 τ 0 , and
Copyright 2000 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
τ st ⱕ 0.58
√
1
√S
⫺ 1 τ 0 t (51)
System Design and Optimization
53
To satisfy the wavefront sensor noise requirement for sensor-noise-limited operation, the number of photons collected per subaperture per dwell time must exceed Np ⱖ
18n rms η
√
ln(D/d s ) ⫺ln(S)
(52)
Thus, the beacon requirement is critically dependent upon the sensor noise and quantum efficiency. For a system incorporating a high-efficiency CCD array having a 10-electron readout fluctuation, the achievement of near-unity Strehl requires about 500 photons per subaperture per dwell time. Methods for achieving adequate target illumination are one of the principal concerns for the designers of directed-energy systems. The design of adaptive-optics systems for astronomical telescopes is strongly driven by the brightness of the more interesting target objects, and economic factors may constrain the affordable actuator density and bandwidth. The optimization process for this case is somewhat more complex and is likely to involve an adaptive adjustment of operational characteristics in order to achieve best performance under all conditions. When necessary, the effective servo bandwidth of a high-performance system can be reduced by introducing analog or digital filters, and the spatial resolution of the applied compensation can be degraded through an appropriate modification of the phase-reconstruction matrix. To illustrate the optimization process for a low-brightness object, Figs. 17 and 18 trace the characteristics and performance of a compensation system for an 8-m-class telescope, for which the following parametric values are assumed: D λ r0 τ0 τ0 t τm
⫽ ⫽ ⫽ ⫽ ⫽ ⫽
8m 0.55 µm 16 cm 5 ms 12 ms 1 ms
τ mt η n rms γ t /γ γ ⫹ γt
⫽ ⫽ ⫽ ⫽ ⫽
10 ms 0.8 10 electrons 0.1 0.5
The last of these assignment represents an allocation of 50% of the available light for the science camera. Source intensity has been converted to stellar magnitude, m ν , by way of the relationship I p ⫽ 10 ⫺(m ν⫹21.2)/2.5
(53)
Figure 18 suggests that, for high-quality visible imaging, one needs to locate or generate an eighth magnitude source to serve as the reference beacon for the wavefront sensor. The likelihood of finding a star of the requisite brightness in the vicinity of the target object is the subject of the next section.
Copyright 2000 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
54
Parenti
Figure 17 Spatial and temporal design parameters for an optimized adaptive-optics system as a function of target-object intensity. Beyond 12th magnitude, no significant improvement of the high-spatial-frequency (figure) component of turbulence is achieved for this system.
Figure 18 Resolution and Strehl as a function of target-object intensity for an optimized adaptive-optics system. Loss of signal necessitates the use of larger subapertures and a lower correction bandwidth, which results in a rapid degradation of resolution for objects dimmer than eighth magnitude.
Copyright 2000 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
System Design and Optimization
55
VIII. OPERATIONAL UTILITY OF NATURAL GUIDE-STAR SYSTEMS Adaptive-optics systems are inherently high-light-level devices that cannot function usefully below some minimum signal threshold. When the target object fails to exceed this brightness requirement, a nearby star may provide a suitable reference. The maximum allowable displacement between the target and reference objects is established by the isoplanatic angle. The effect of a reference offset on the quality of phase compensation is most easily treated as an additional figure error, which can be appended to the expression given in Eq. (36). The magnitude of the figure error due to a referencesource offset of θ is 2 fig reference offset
(σ )
冢冣
θ ⬇ θ0
5/3
(54)
where θ 0 is the isoplanatic angle defined in Eq. (6). Since it has been demonstrated that the total phase error can be no more than a few rad 2 in order to maintain a moderate level of correction, it is reasonable to assume that the reference star can be displaced from the target object by no more than θ 0 . This criterion is strongly wavelength dependent, because the turbulence coherence length, time constant, and isoplanatic angle are all proportional to λ 6/5. Estimates of star densities may be extracted from the Infrared Handbook (20), which tabulates average population values as well as numbers for the galactic pole and equator; this information is summarized in Fig. 19. For first-order
Figure 19 Comparison of stellar densities for the galactic pole, the galactic equator, and the average density as a function of visual magnitude.
Copyright 2000 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
56
Parenti
numerical calculations it is convenient to use the following approximation for the average stellar density: Ψ(m ν ) ⬇ 1.45 exp(0.96 m ν ) (stars/rad 2 )
(55)
which can be combined with Eq. (53) to rewrite the density as a function of the received visible-wavelength irradiance: Ψ(I p ) ⬇ 2.02 ⫻ 10 ⫺9 I p⫺1.04 (stars/rad 2 )
(56)
The final step in the operational utility calculation involves the combination of the density expressions and the isoplanatic angle. To first order, the probability of finding a star of brightness I p within an angular displacement of θ is P(θ, I p ) ⬇ πθ 2 Ψ(I p )
(57)
By applying the optimization process discussed in the previous section, this probability function can be plotted as a function of the short-exposure Strehl enhancement and the wavelength of the viewing system, as shown in Fig. 20. In this comparison, the phase error due to beacon-offset anisoplanatism is permitted to be comparable to the total phase distortion computed from Eq. (49). The operational utility analysis summarized in the previous figure emphasizes one of the most stressing issues facing the designers of adaptive-compensa-
Figure 20 Operational utility as a function of the achievable enhancement of the shortexposure Strehl. The operational utility defines the likelihood that a suitable reference star can be found within a small angular separation from the target object. In this analysis, the reference offset error was allowed to be comparable to the error due to the compensation system.
Copyright 2000 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
System Design and Optimization
57
tion systems for astronomical applications. Although all of the essential hardware and data processing techniques required to achieve substantial improvements in resolution have been developed, the illumination requirements severely limit its practical utility at short wavelengths. This restriction can be eliminated, however, if provision is made to generate a synthetic beacon of sufficient intensity. Issues associated with synthetic beacon production and utilization are addressed in Chapter 3.
REFERENCES 1. M. G. Miller and P. L. Zieske, ‘‘Turbulence Environmental Characterization,’’ RADC-TR-79-131, Rome Air Development Center, Griffiss Air Force Base, NY, 1979. 2. R. E. Hufnagel, ‘‘Variations of Atmospheric Turbulence,’’ in Digest of Technical Papers, Topical Meeting on Optical Propagation Through Turbulence, Optical Society of America, Washington, DC, July 9–11, 1974. 3. J. L. Bufton, ‘‘Comparison of Vertical Profile Turbulence Structure with Stellar Observations,’’ Appl. Opt. 12, 1785–1793 (1973). 4. D. L. Fried, ‘‘Limiting Resolution Looking down through the Atmosphere,’’ J. Opt. Soc. Am. 56, 1380–1384 (1966). 5. D. P. Greenwood, ‘‘Bandwidth Specification for Adaptive Optics Systems,’’ J. Opt. Soc. Am. 67, 390–393 (1977). 6. D. P. Greenwood and D. L. Fried, ‘‘Power Spectra Requirements for Wave-FrontCompensation Systems,’’ J. Opt. Soc. Am. 66, 193–206 (1976). 7. G. A. Tyler, ‘‘Bandwidth Considerations for Tracking through Turbulence,’’ The Optical Sciences Company, Report No. TR-887 (March 1988). 8. G. A. Tyler and D. L. Fried, ‘‘Image Position Error Associated with a Quadrant Detector,’’ J. Opt. Soc. Am. 72 (1982). 9. R. H. Kingston, Detection of Optical and Infrared Radiation, Springer-Verlag, 1978. 10. R. H. Hudgin, ‘‘Wave-front Reconstruction for Compensated Imaging,’’ J. Opt. Soc. Am. 67, 374–378 (1977). 11. D. L. Fried, ‘‘Least-Squares Fitting a Wave-front Distortion Estimate to an Array of Phase-Difference Measurements,’’ J. Opt. Soc. Am. 67, 370–375 (1977). 12. J. Herrmann, ‘‘Least-Squares Wave Front Errors of Minimum Norm,’’ J. Opt. Soc. Am. 70, 28–35 (1980). 13. J. H. Everson, ‘‘New Developments in Deformable Mirror Surface Devices,’’ Proc. SPIE 141, Adaptive Optical Components (1978). 14. J. E. Harvey and G. M. Gallahan, ‘‘Wavefront Error Compensation Capabilities of Multi-actuator Deformable Mirrors,’’ Proc. SPIE 141, 50–57 (1978). 15. F. Roddier, ‘‘Curvature Sensing and Compensation: A New Concept in Adaptive Optics,’’ Appl. Opt. 27, 1223–1225 (1988). 16. R. J. Sasiela, Electromagnetic Wave Propagation in Turbulence, Springer-Verlag, 1994.
Copyright 2000 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
58 17.
Parenti
D. P. Greenwood, ‘‘Mutual Coherence Function of a Wavefront Corrected by Zonal Adaptive Optics,’’ J. Opt. Soc. Am. 69, 549–553 (1979). 18. A. D. Poularikas and S. Seely, Signals and Systems, PWS, 1985. 19. H. T. Yura, ‘‘Short-Term Average Optical-Beam Spread in a Turbulent Medium,’’ J. Opt. Soc. Am. 63, 567–572 (1973). 20. W. L. Wolfe and G. J. Zissis, Eds., The Infrared Handbook, Environmental Research Institute of Michigan, 1985.
Copyright 2000 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
3 Guide Star System Considerations Richard J. Sasiela and John D. Shelton Massachusetts Institute of Technology Lincoln Laboratory, Lexington, Massachusetts
I. INTRODUCTION Adaptive-optics system design must take into account many factors. The beacon that provides a measure of the atmospheric turbulence may be in a different direction from the one that needs the correction. In this case the performance depends on the isoplanatic patch size, which is the region over which the turbulence is fairly constant. This patch size can be different for different Zernike modes. The rate of change of turbulence with time affects the acceptable servo bandwidth. The target must be tracked through turbulence and the effect of tilt on system performance is very important. Apertures tend to smooth out some effects, and this affects system design. The system performance with artificial beacon is affected by the beacon height and the number of beacons. Formulas to determine all these effects to enable one to design a system are developed in this chapter. The solution of most turbulence problems of practical interest involving wave propagation rely on applying the theory in the region in which the Rytov approximation applies. Generally, these are cases in which the scintillation caused by turbulence is small. It is also assumed that the turbulence can be represented in the spatial Fourier domain as an isotropic spectrum. If one also assumes that the turbulent cells do not change rapidly, then observed changes in the turbulence are caused by the transport of the turbulent eddies by the local winds. This is called the frozen turbulence assumption. With this assumption one can readily transform the spatial spectrum into a temporal spectrum. Adaptive-optics systems are generally used under conditions in which these approximations apply. Adaptive-optics performance depends on the characteristics of turbulence that affects the tilt jitter, other Zernike modes, and how these
Copyright 2000 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
60
Sasiela and Shelton
modes change with direction, displacement, and time. Formulas that enable one to calculate these effects are given in this chapter. In adaptive-optics system design one is interested in the effect that turbulence has on system performance. The turbulence spectra is modified by the aperture and the subsequent processing to obtain the tilt or other Zernike modes or some function of the difference between the turbulence seen in different directions. All these processes are linear and can be represented in the Fourier domain as a filtering operation on the turbulence spectrum. The aperture operations decrease the observed turbulence strength for some spatial frequencies and increase it at others. Often one is interested in the resulting phase variance or correlation, which is the sum of the contributions at individual frequencies. Since any aperture operation can be viewed as a filtering operation, it is not surprising that there is a general way to solve these problems. One can set up a general problem to find the variance or correlation function of the aperture amplitude and phase functions. The expression contains a sixfold integration. With reasonable assumptions three of these integrals can be evaluated in general. The reduced expression has just three integrals—two over the transform of the coordinates perpendicular to the direction of propagation, and the third along the spatial coordinate in the direction of propagation. A specific problem is solved by inserting the appropriate filter function in the general formula. To complete the solution, the triple integral must be evaluated. The double integral in the transverse Fourier coordinate can be expressed as an integral over angle and magnitude. Either because the problem has circular symmetry or because of a relatively simple angular dependence, for most problems, the angular integration is easily evaluated. Surprisingly, for all the common filter functions the integral over the magnitude of the spectrum can be evaluated and the answer expressed in terms of analytic functions; thus, one need not resort to numerical integration. The Mellin transform is the vehicle for performing these integrals. For the simplest problems in which there is only one parameter that varies, the solution is found by a table look-up. Pole-residue integration using the Cauchy residue theorem is used to find the solution when there are two parameters that vary. The evaluation of the integral in this case can also be obtained with computer algebra programs such as Mathematica or Maple. The results are expressed as a sum of generalized hypergeometric functions. Luckily, computer algebra programs can readily plot these functions. The programs also calculate power series for these solutions so that one can calculate results easily for small parameter values and observe their dependence. For large values of the parameter, the Mellin transform technique can be used to obtain asymptotic series, which are very useful in determining trends and performing system calculations. For even more complicated problems where there are more than two parameters one can use the Mellin transform technique to obtain the solution as multiple infinite series. Asymptotic solutions can also be obtained in these cases.
Copyright 2000 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
Guide Star System Considerations
61
After evaluating the integral in the Fourier spectral domain, the last remaining integration along the propagation path can often be evaluated so that the solution is expressed as a sum of one or more moments of the turbulence distribution along the propagation path.
II. GENERAL SOLUTION OF TURBULENCE PROBLEMS Most turbulence problems of interest are concerned with the turbulence effects on a single beam or the difference in effects between two beams. The singlebeam case is a special case of the double-beam case if different amplitudes are allowed for the two beams. In this section the general solution to the turbulence problem in which the phase variance between two beams that can be of different size, different direction, and have different aperture functions applied is given. Diffraction effects are included. Either beam can be collimated or focused at the aperture or any point in space. The background and detailed derivation of the general solution are given in Sasiela and Shelton [1993a,b] and Sasiela [1994a]. Tatarski [1961, 1971] uses the Rytov approximation to obtain formulas for phase and log-amplitude variances. His method is generalized here to obtain an expression that can be applied to many problems and particularly those associated with adaptiveoptics system design. In order to cover the cases of collimated and spherical waves, the derivation for the expression for variance of the log-amplitude and phase is done on a Gaussian wave using the approach of Ishimaru [1969]. The results given here apply to the case in which the beam radius is allowed to go to infinity. These results can be generalized to the finite radius case. Beam-wave theory is developed by using the scalar wave equation, the paraxial approximation (beam-propagation vector is close to the z-axis), and the Rytov approximation to find the Green’s function for the problem. From the Green’s function one can write an expression for the phase, φ(rជ, L), or logamplitude, χ(rជ, L), of an infinite Gaussian beam propagating between z ⫽ 0 and z ⫽ L as φ(rជ, L)
冤χ(rជ, L) 冥
⫽ k0
冮
L
0
dz′ ∫ dv(κជ, z′)
冤sin[P(γ, κ, z′] 冥 exp[i γκជ ⋅ rជ] cos[P(γ, κ, z′]
where k0 λ κ dν(κជ , z)
⫽ ⫽ ⫽ ⫽
2π/λ wavelength of the propagating wave spatial wavenumber transverse to the z-direction turbulence-induced refractive index variations
Copyright 2000 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
(1)
62
Sasiela and Shelton
γ
⫽ propagation parameter that distinguishes between collimated and focused beams P(γ, κ, z) ⫽ diffraction parameter defined below For a source at z ⫽ 0 centered on the origin, one finds γ ⫽ 1 for the plane wave case, and γ ⫽ z/L for the spherical wave case. For a source at z ⫽ L centered on the origin, γ ⫽ 1 for the plane wave case, and γ ⫽ (L ⫺ z)/L for the spherical wave case. For Gaussian beams, in general, γ is complex. Here γ is taken to be real. For propagation from z ⫽ 0 to z ⫽ L, the diffraction parameter is P(γ, κ, z) ⫽
γ κ 2 (L ⫺ z) 2k 0
(2)
and for propagation from z ⫽ L to z ⫽ 0, it is P(γ, κ, z) ⫽
γ κ2 z 2k 0
(3)
For many problems the weighted average of phase or log-amplitude over a receiving aperture is wanted. If g(rជ ) is a normalized weighting function that multiplies the above expression, the integral over the aperture of diameter D is recognized as the Fourier transform of the aperture function and is given by G(γ κជ) ⫽ ∫ d rជ ′ g(rជ ′) exp[i γκជ ⋅ rជ ] (4) where G(γ κជ) is called the complex aperture filter function. We choose the normalization such that 4 ∫ d rជ ′ g 2 (rជ ′) ⫽ 1 (5) πD 2 Using these results, the phase or log-amplitude related difference between two waves with different propagation and diffraction parameters and aperture weightings, and where the second wave has a relative amplitude A(κជ , z) with respect to the first as illustrated in Fig. 1, is
Figure 1 Geometry of focused and collimated beams of different diameters propagating in different directions with a separation that depends on the axial coordinate.
Copyright 2000 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
Guide Star System Considerations
φR(rជ, L)
冤χR(rជ, L) 冥
⫽ k0
冮
63
L
dz′ ∫ dv(κជ, z′)
0
冦
⫻ G 1 (γ 1 κជ)
冤 sin[P (γ , κ, z′)] 冥 cos[P1 (γ 1 , κ, z′)] 1
(6)
1
⫺ A(κជ, z′)G 2 (γ 2 κជ)
冤 sin[P (γ , κ, z′)] 冥冧 cos[P2 (γ 2 , κ, z′)] 2
2
If the two beams have the same amplitude, but one is displaced from the other by a distance dជ, which can vary with axial distance, then A(κជ, z) ⫽ exp[iκជ ⋅ dជ ]
(7)
Care must be exercised in using this relation with focused beams. For a point source at z ⫽ L, one has γ ⫽ 1 ⫺ z/L. A displacement of dជ means that the waves propagate from the point at z ⫽ 0 and rជ ⫽ 0 to two receiving apertures separated by dជ. In this case A(κជ, z) ⫽ exp[i(1 ⫺ z/L)κជ ⋅ dជ ]. If one wanted the difference between two focused beams in which the beam focus points and receiving apertures were each separated by dជ, then A(κជ , z) ⫽ exp[iκជ ⋅ dជ ]. To find the variance, this expression is multiplied by its complex conjugate and the expected value is found. The techniques that have been used in the past [Strohbehn, 1978] to perform three of the six integrations are used to obtain the final expression: σ 2φR
冤σ 冥 ⫽ 0.2073 k 冮 dz C (z) ∫ dκជ f (κ) cos[P (γ , κ, z)] ⫻ 冦G (γ κជ) 冤 sin[P (γ , κ, z)] 冥 cos[P (γ , κ, z)] ⫺ A(κជ, z)G (γ κជ) 冤 sin[P (γ , κ, z)] 冥冧 L
2 0
2 χR
2 n
0
1
2
冦
1
1
1
1
1
⫻ G*1 (γ 1 κជ)
2
2
2
2
2
(8)
冤 sin[P (γ , κ, z)] 冥 cos[P1 (γ 1 , κ, z)] 1
1
⫺ A*(κជ, z)G*2 (γ 2 κជ)
冤 sin[P (γ , κ, z)] 冥冧 cos[P2 (γ 2 , κ, z)] 2
2
where f(κ) is the normalized two-dimensional turbulence spectrum and C 2n (z) is turbulence strength along the propagation path.
Copyright 2000 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
64
Sasiela and Shelton
This expression assumes that the wave is infinite. For a finite size beam, for which γ is complex, a similar expression can be found. This expression can be evaluated by Mellin transform techniques for specific problems. The beamwave case is discussed in detail in Sasiela [1994a]. If the inner and outer scales are negligible, then the spectrum is the normalized Kolmogorov spectrum given by f (κ) ⫽ κ⫺11/3
(9)
The coefficient 0.033 that normally multiplies this spectrum has been absorbed into the coefficient of the variance expression. This spectrum requires infinite energy because the turbulence becomes unbounded as the wavelength gets large. The behavior at large wavelengths or outer scale depends on the generation mechanism of the turbulence, and it can have a different dependence in different circumstances. Spectrums have been proposed by von Ka´rma´nn and Greenwood [1974]. The von Ka´rma´nn turbulence spectrum is given by f (κ) ⫽ [κ 2 ⫹ κ 20 ]⫺11/6
(10)
and the Greenwood spectrum is f (κ) ⫽ (κ 2 ⫹ κκ 0 )⫺11/6
(11)
where κ 0 ⫽ 2π/L 0 , and L 0 is called the outer scale of turbulence; it can depend on the axial coordinate. There are also difficulties with large wavenumbers. From the hydrodynamic equations it can be shown that the above spectra require infinite energy dissipation due to the rapid increase in dissipation with decreasing scale size. Physically, below a certain scale size dissipative effects force the velocity to be laminar, leading to a rapid decrease in the spectrum with decreasing scale size. Several ad hoc models have been given for the spectrum in this inner scale region; the Gaussian form was proposed by Tatarski. A spectrum with both inner scale and von Ka´rma´nn outer scale—the modified von Ka´rma´nn spectrum—is Ψ(k) ⫽ 0.033 C 2n (k 2 ⫹ κ 20 )⫺11/6 exp[⫺k 2 /κ 2i ]
(12)
where κ i ⫽ 2π/L i ⫽ 5.91/L in , and L in is the commonly used inner scale. The spectrum is shown in Fig. 2. Greenwood and Tarazaro [1974] and Gurvich et al. [1974] noted that the turbulence does not decay as rapidly as that predicted by the Kolmogorov spectrum in the region just before it starts its rapid decay due to inner scale effects. Hill and Clifford [1978] did a hydrodynamic analysis to derive a spectrum in the region where inner scale is significant, and found a slight peak before an exponen-
Copyright 2000 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
Guide Star System Considerations
65
Figure 2 Von Ka´rma´n spectrum with inner and outer scale present. The value of κ i is equal to 2π/0.1, and the value of κ o is equal to 2π/10. The presence of the outer scale causes the spectrum to approach a constant at low wavenumbers. The inner scale causes the spectrum to decay faster than Kolmogorov turbulence at high wavenumbers. The spectrum has an ⫺11/3 power law behavior in the inertial subrange at intermediate wavenumbers.
tial decay. Frehlich [1992] has modeled the spectrum as Ψ(k) ⫽ 0.033 C 2n (k 2 ⫹ κ 20 )⫺11/6 g(k)
(13)
where a four-term approximation for g(k) is 4
g(k) ⫽ exp(⫺δ | k| L in )
冱 a (|k| L ) n
in
n
(14)
n⫽0
The constants are δ ⫽ 1.1090, a 0 ⫽ 1, a 1 ⫽ 0.70937, a 2 ⫽ 2.8235, a 3 ⫽ ⫺0.28086, and a 4 ⫽ ⫺0.08277. This function is plotted versus the Tatarski function exp[⫺(kL in /5.92) 2 ] in Fig. 3. Scintillation measurements agree more closely with the Hill spectrum.
Figure 3 Factor that multiplies the Kolmogorov turbulence spectrum in the Tatarski and Hill models of inner scale.
Copyright 2000 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
66
Sasiela and Shelton
Inner scale affects the scintillation but has little effect on the Zernike modes. For that reason its effects are normally neglected in adaptive-optics system design. For specific cases Eq. (8) can be simplified. If there is only one beam, the weighting function A(κជ , z) is zero, and the formula reduces to σ 2φR
冤 冥 σ 2χR σ
冮
⫽ 0.2073 k 20
冤
dz C 2n (z) ∫ dκជ f(κ)
0
2 φχR
⫻
L
cos 2 [P(γ, κ, z)]
sin 2 [P(γ, κ, z)] 0.5 sin[2P(γ, κ, z)]
冥
(15) F(γκជ)
where the aperture filter function is defined as F(γ κជ) ⫽ G(γ κជ) G*(γ κជ)
(16)
To find the phase or log-amplitude variance at a point, F(γ κជ) should be set to unity. In this equation σ 2φχR is the cross variance of phase times log-amplitude related quantities. A series of formulas based on the general equation that apply in different situations will now be given. If there are two beams with weighting on the phase or log-amplitude differing by a real constant, i.e., A(κជ, z) is real, and whose values of γ are the same, and of which the same aperture-averaged component is wanted, then
冤σ 冥 σ 2φR 2 χR
⫽ 0.2073 k 20 ⫻
冮
L
dz C 2n (z) ∫ dκជ f(κ)
0
{cos[P1 (γ, κ, z)] ⫺ A(κជ, z) cos[P2 (γ, κ, z)]} 2
冤{sin[P (γ, κ, z)] ⫺ A(κជ, z) sin[P (γ, κ, z)]} 冥 F(γκជ) 1
(17)
2
2
If there are two beams with equal weighting on the phase and log-amplitude whose values of γ are equal, but where different aperture modes are wanted, then
冤σ 冥 σ 2φR 2 χR
⫽ 0.2073 k 20 ⫻
冮
L
dz C 2n (z) ∫ dκជ f(κ)
0
冤sin [P(γ, κ, z)] 冥 | G (γ κជ) ⫺ G (γ κជ) | cos 2 [P(γ, κ, z)] 2
1
2
(18) 2
If there are two beams with equal weighting on the phase and log-amplitude
Copyright 2000 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
Guide Star System Considerations
67
whose values of γ differ, but where different aperture modes are wanted, and diffraction can be neglected, then σ 2φR ⫽ 0.2073 k 20
冮
L
dz C 2n (z) ∫ dκជ f (κ) | G 1 (γ 1 κជ) ⫺ G 2 (γ 2 κជ) | 2
0
(19)
If there are two beams displaced from each other by a distance dជ that have the same propagation constant, and for which the same aperture mode is wanted, one obtains D φR (dជ )
冤σ 冥 冤D (dជ ) 冥 σ 2φR
⫽
2 χR
⫽ 0.2073 k 20
χR
冮
L
dz C 2n (z) ∫ dκជ f(κ)
0
冤sin [P(γ, κ, z)] 冥 F(γ κជ) 2[1 ⫺ cos(κជ ⋅ dជ )] cos 2 [P(γ, κ, z)]
⫻
(20)
2
D φ (dជ ) and D χ (dជ ) are the phase and log-amplitude structure functions when F (γ κជ) ⫽ 1. Equation (17) can be used to find the phase and log-amplitude of a wave (called a beacon) that has propagated down through the atmosphere. If an adaptive-optics system is used in which a collimated beam has the conjugate of this phase applied at the origin, then the variances along the propagation path that is displaced by a distance dជ (the anisoplanatic offset) from the beacon path can be found from
冤σ 冥 σ 2φR 2 χR
⫻
⫽ 0.2073 k 20
冮
L
dz C 2n (z) ∫ dκជ f (κ)
0
冷 冤 冥 冤 冥 冤 冥冷 冷 sin 冤κ2kL冥 cos 冤κ2kz冥 ⫺ exp[i κជ ⋅ dជ ] sin 冤κ (L2k⫺ z)冥 冷
冤
cos
κ2L κ2z κ 2 (L ⫺ z) cos ⫺ exp[i κជ ⋅ dជ ]cos 2k 0 2k 0 2k 0 2
2
0
2
2
0
0
2
冥
F(κជ)
(21)
If the anisoplanatic offset is zero, the expression is
冤σ 冥 σ 2φR 2 χR
⫽ 0.2073 k 20
⫻
冮
L
dz C 2n (z) ∫ dκជ f (κ)
0
冷 sin 冤 冥 冤 冥 冷 冷 cos 冤κ2kL冥 sin 冤κ2kz冥 冷
冤
2
κ2L κ2z sin 2 2k 0 2k 0 2
2
2
2
0
Copyright 2000 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
0
2
2
冥
(22) F(κជ)
68
Sasiela and Shelton
To solve a specific problem, the relevant aperture filter function and turbulence spectrum must be inserted into the above equations. The next section contains filter functions relating to Zernike modes and gradient tilt on an unobscured and an annular aperture, and those due to a finite aperture or source distribution. The general formula for the power spectral density of phase, S φ (ω), or logamplitude, S χ (ω), in the frozen turbulence approximation can be found from the above expressions. Power spectral density, S(ω), is related to variance, σ 2, by
冤σ 冥 σ 2φR 2 χR
⫽
1 π
冮
∞
dω
冤S (ω)冥 S φ (ω)
(23)
χ
0
The integral over κ can be converted to one over frequency by making the substitutions κx ⫽
ω v(z)
(24)
and c2 ⫽
κ 2y v 2 (z) ω2
⫹1
(25)
where v(z) is the velocity profile along the propagation path. As an example, the case of a single wave is illustrated. It is assumed the spectrum is reduced by a system for which Fservo (ω) is the servo response. Recognizing that everything multiplying dω in the resulting integral over ω is the power spectral density, one finds
冤S (ω)冥 S φ (ω) χ
⫽ 2.606 k 20 ωFservo (ω)
冮
C 2n (z)
L
dz
v 2 (z)
0
冮
∞
c dc U(c ⫺ 1) √c 2 ⫺ 1
0
冤 冥 γωc 冤 冥 sin γω c (L ⫺ z) F 冤v(z) 冥 冤 2v (z) k 冥
ωc ⫻f v(z)
冤
cos
2
γω 2 c 2 (L ⫺ z) 2v 2 (z) k 0 2 2
2
2
0
冥
(26)
The Heaviside unit step function is defined by U(x) ⫽ 1
for x ⬎ 0
U(x) ⫽ 0
for x ⬍ 0
(27)
From the Huygens-Fresnel approximation the Strehl ratio for a circular
Copyright 2000 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
Guide Star System Considerations
69
aperture [Tyler, 1984] can be found by evaluating the beam profile at the origin to obtain
冤 1 D(αជ) ⫽ ∫ d αជ K(α) exp 冤⫺ 2π 2 冥
SR ⫽
1 αជ D(αជ D) ∫ d αជ K(α) exp ik 0 Dρជ ⋅ ⫺ 2π z 2
冥冷
ρជ⫽0
(28)
The integral is over a circular aperture of unit radius, D(αជ) is the structure function, and K(α) is the optical transfer function modified by a numerical factor such that 16 [cos⫺1 (α) ⫺ α(1 ⫺ α 2 )1/2 ] U(1 ⫺ α) π
K(α) ⫽
(29)
When the structure function is isotropic, the integration over angle in the aperture can be performed to yield SR ⫽
冮
∞
0
冤
D(α) α dα K(α) exp ⫺ 2
冥
(30)
III. FILTER FUNCTIONS The solution for the phase variance in the last section contained a filter function. This function depends on the particular problem that is being solved. For standard problems the filter function can be chosen from those given below. Filter functions to determine the Zernike modes on a full or annular aperture and the gradient tilt are listed below. The filter functions to calculate second moment quantities with a finite receive aperture or a finite size source are listed.
A.
Zernike Modes
The general formula for the filter function to find a Zernike component on a circular aperture of diameter D was given by Noll [1976] as Fm, n (κជ) x Fm, n (κជ) y F0, n (κជ)
冧
⫽ (n ⫹ 1)
(κD/2) 冤2 J κD/2 冥 n⫹1
Copyright 2000 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
2
冦
2 cos 2 (mϕ)
2
sin 2 (mϕ)
1
(m ⫽ 0)
(31)
70
Sasiela and Shelton
The formula for specific components is found from the general result. The piston, Zernike mode (0, 0), phase-variance filter function is F(κជ ) ⫽
冤
2 J 1 (κD/2) κD/2
冥
2
(32)
This filter function extracts the phase variance due to piston. To obtain the meansquared piston displacement in physical as opposed to phase space, the filter function must be multiplied by (1/k 0 ) 2. The filter function to determine the x, y, and total phase variance from the aperture tilt, Zernike mode (1, 1), is Fx (κជ) Fy (κជ ) F(κជ)
冧
⫽
(κD/2) 冤4 JκD/2 冥 2
2
冦
cos 2 (ϕ)
sin 2 (ϕ)
(33)
1
The filter functions to determine the x and y components and total tilt angle is obtained from the above by multiplying by (4/k 0 D) 2 where the local diameter must be inserted for an uncollimated beam. In some problems one requires the variance with some Zernike modes removed. This is easily done by subtracting the phase variance due to these components from the total variance. For instance, the filter function to remove piston and tilt variance from a single wave is F(κជ) ⫽ 1 ⫺
冤
2 J 1 (κD/2) κD/2
冥 冤 2
⫺
4 J 2 (κD/2) κD/2
冥
2
(34)
B. Gradient Tilt The gradient or G-tilt, in a geometric sense, is equal to the average ray direction that is obtained by finding the average x and y components and the total phase gradient over the aperture. The filter function of G-tilt variance is Fx (κជ ) Fy (κជ) F(κជ)
冧
⫽ J 21 (κD/2)
冦
cos 2 (ϕ)
sin 2 (ϕ)
(35)
1
The filter function to determine the tilt angle is obtained from the above by multiplying by (4/k 0 D) 2.
Copyright 2000 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
Guide Star System Considerations
C.
71
Tilt on an Annulus
Tilt filter functions for the Zernike and gradient tilts on an annulus can be derived from the expressions given in Yura and Tavis [1985]. The Zernike tilt filter function on an annulus with inner diameter D i is Fx (κជ) Fy (κជ) F(κជ)
冧
(κD/2) D J (κD /2) ⫺ 冤k D[1 ⫺16(D /D) ]冥 冤J κD/2 冢 D 冣 κD /2 冥 2
⫽
3
2
0
i
2
i
4
i
2
i
冦
cos 2 (φ)
sin 2 (φ)
(36)
1
The gradient tilt on an annulus is Fx (κជ) Fy (κជ) F(κជ)
D.
冧
冤k D[1 ⫺4(D /D) ]冥 冤J (κD/2) ⫺ DD J (κD /2冥 2
⫽
2
i
0
1
2
i
1
i
冦
cos 2 (φ)
sin 2 (φ)
(37)
1
Filter Functions for Finite Size Apertures and Distributed Sources
The coherent average of a quantity from a point source at a range L over a receive aperture is equal to the piston of the quantity, which is given by
冤
F(κជ) ⫽ 2
J 1 (κD(1 ⫺ z/L)/2) κD(1 ⫺ z/L)/2
冥
2
(38)
If the point source is at a very long range, this reduces to
冤
F(κជ) ⫽ 2
冥
J 1 (κD/2) κD/2
2
(39)
The filter function for an incoherent source of diameter D s is
冤
F(κជ) ⫽ 2
J 1 (κD s z/2L) κD s z/2L
冥
2
(40)
The filter function of an incoherent source of diameter D s received coherently by a receive aperture of diameter D is the product of the above two filter functions, which is
冤
F(κជ) ⫽ 2
J 1 (κD(1 ⫺ z/L)/2) κD(1 ⫺ z/L)/2
冥冤 2
Copyright 2000 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
2
J 1 (κD s z/2L) κD s z/2L
冥
2
(41)
72
Sasiela and Shelton
IV. TURBULENCE MOMENTS As mentioned above, the solution of the last integration along the propagation path is often expressed in terms of turbulence moments. The definitions of the full and partial turbulence moments are given. The zenith dependence is contained in the moments. The full moments are equal to µm ⫽
冮
∞
0
C 2n (z) z m dz ⫽ sec m⫹1 (ξ)
冮
∞
C 2n (h) h m dh
(42)
0
where ξ is the zenith angle. Looking directly up, ξ ⫽ 0. Consider propagation to a distance L, which is at a height H, such that L ⫽ sec(ξ)H. Define the partial moments as µ ⫹m (L) ⫽
冮
∞
冮
L
µ ⫺m (L) ⫽
L
C 2n (z) z m dz ⫽ sec m⫹1 (ξ)
冮
C 2n (z) z m dz ⫽ sec m⫹1 (ξ)
冮
∞
C 2n (h) h m dh
(43)
C 2n (h) h m dh
(44)
H
and
0
H
0
Often turbulence results are expressed in terms of the coherence diameter and isoplanatic angle. The coherence diameter for a plane wave, r 0 , is defined as ⫽ 0.423 k 20 µ 0 r ⫺5/3 0
(45)
and the isoplanatic angle, θ 0 , is defined as ⫽ 2.91 k 20 µ 5/3 θ ⫺5/3 0
(46)
V. MELLIN TRANSFORMS As pointed out in the section where a general formula for the variance was given, if a specific filter function is inserted into one of the equations for phase variance or correlation, then the variance is expressed as a triple integral. The integration over angle in the κជ-plane can usually be performed. The remaining expression contains integrations over spatial wavenumber and propagation direction. The techniques to be presented in this section apply to performing the kappa (spatial wavenumber) integration. The variables are first normalized, and the resulting integration has zero, one, or more parameters that are independent of the integration variables. If no parameters are present, the integration is performed simply by table look-up. If one or more parameters are present, one evaluates the integral
Copyright 2000 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
Guide Star System Considerations
73
by using a computer algebra program or by transforming the integral using the Mellin convolution integral into an integral in one or more complex planes. The highlights of the technique for evaluating the integral by pole-residue methods are discussed in this section. Tatarski considered the evaluation of integrals with one parameter in which inner scale was finite. The form of the inner scale was an exponential that decayed with decreasing scale size. This allowed him to expand the function multiplying the decaying exponential in a Taylor series, and integrate term by term. Since the integral over each term of the power series converged absolutely, the integration could be performed term by term. The resulting power series was then expressed as a hypergeometric function. This approach does not work with zero inner scale or with more than one parameter, thereby restricting the problems that can be solved. This limitation does not apply to the technique discussed below, which applies to every problem of finding second moments or spectral densities using the filter functions given above. The technique is also applicable to finding analytic solutions for the Strehl ratio given in Eq. (30). The Mellin transform pair is given by h(x) → H(s) ⬅ M[h(x)] ⬅
冮
∞
0
dx h(x)x s x
(47)
and h(x) ⫽
1 2πi
冮 ds H(s)x
⫺s
(48)
C
The integral in Eq. (47) will only converge when the value of s is within certain limits. The integration path in the inverse transform integral goes from ⫺i∞ to ⫹i∞, and the value of the real part of s along the integration path is determined by the convergence properties of the function being transformed. The Mellin transform of a function that has the first N terms of its power series subtracted from it is the same as the Mellin transform of the original function with the integration path moved past N poles of the function. This is useful for anisoplanatic problems. The gamma function notation used by Slater [1966] and Marichev [1983] means Γ
] Γ[α ] ⋅ ⋅ ⋅ Γ[α ] 冤 β , . . . , β 冥 ⫽ Γ[α Γ[β ] Γ[β ] ⋅ ⋅ ⋅ Γ[β ] α1, . . . , αm 1
n
1
2
m
1
2
n
(49)
Mellin transforms useful for turbulence problems are given in Table 1. There are many additional Mellin transforms that are tabulated. Mellin
Copyright 2000 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
74
Sasiela and Shelton
Table 1 Mellin Transforms Useful for Turbulence Problems a
冮
h(x) → M[h(x)] ⬅ H(s) ⫽
∞
dx h(x)x s x
0
(T1)
exp(⫺x) → Γ[s], Re s ⬎ 0
(T2)
sin(x) → 2 s⫺1 √ π Γ
冤 1 ⫺ s/2 冥 ,
|Re s | ⬍ 1
(T3)
cos(x) → 2 s⫺1 √ π Γ
冤1/2 ⫺ s/2冥 ,
0 ⬍ Re s ⬍ 1
(T4)
1/2 ⫹ s/2
s/2
冤
冥
s/2 √π Γ , ⫺4 ⬍ Re s ⬍ 0 sin 2 (x 2 ) → ⫺ 1/2 ⫺ s/4 8 Jν (x) → 2 s⫺1 Γ J 2ν (x) →
1 2 √π
s/2 ⫹ ν/2
冤ν/2 ⫹ 1 ⫺ s/2冥 , Γ
Jν (x) J ν⫹1 (x) → (1 ⫹ x)⫺p →
⫺Re ν ⬍ Re s ⬍ 3/2
s/2 ⫹ ν, 1/2 ⫺ s/2
冤ν ⫹ 1 ⫺ s/2, 1 ⫺ s/2冥 , 1
2 √π
Γ
⫺2 Re ν ⬍ Re s ⬍ 1
s/2 ⫹ ν ⫹ 1/2, 1 ⫺ s/2
冤ν ⫹ 3/2 ⫺ s/2, 3/2 ⫺ s/2冥 ,
Γ[s, p ⫺ s]
(T5)
⫺1 ⫺ 2 Re ν ⬍ Re s ⬍ 2
(T6)
(T7)
(T8)
, 0 ⬍ Re s ⬍ Re p
(T9)
(1 ⫺ x) a⫺1 U(1 ⫺ x) → Γ[a]Γ
冤s ⫹ a 冥 ,
Re a ⬎ 0, Re s ⬎ 0
(T10)
(x ⫺ 1) a⫺1 U(x ⫺ 1) → Γ[a]Γ
冤
冥,
Re a ⬎ 0, Re(a ⫹ s) ⬍ 1
(T11)
冥
(T12)
Γ[p]
s
1⫺a⫺s 1⫺s
冤
s/2 ⫹ 1/2, ⫺s/2 √π , cos⫺1 (x) U(1 ⫺ x) → ⫺ Γ s/2 ⫹ 1, 1 ⫺ s/2 4
Re s ⬎ 0
U(1 ⫺ x) → Γ
冤s ⫹ 1冥 ,
Re s ⬎ 0
(T13)
U(x ⫺ 1) → Γ
冤1 ⫺ s冥 ,
Re s ⬍ 0
(T14)
s
⫺s
Copyright 2000 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
Guide Star System Considerations
75
Table 1 Continued
Jµ (x) Jλ (x) →
1
Γ
2 √π
冤
µ⫹λ 1 s s s ⫹ , ⫺ ,1⫺ 2 2 2 2 2
1⫺
µ⫹λ µ⫺λ λ⫺µ s s s ⫹ ,1⫺ ⫹ ,1⫺ ⫹ 2 2 2 2 2 2
冥
,
⫺Re(µ ⫹ λ) ⬍ Re s ⬍ 1 (T15) K(x) → a
冤
冥
s/2 ⫹ 1/2 8 1 Γ , Re s ⬎ 0 s/2 ⫹ 2 √π s
(T16)
U(x) is the Heaviside unit step function, and K(x) is a constant times the optical transfer function on a circular aperture.
transforms exist for most of the functions that one normally encounters. A table of Mellin transforms may be augmented by using their following properties: h(ax) → a ⫺s H(s),
a⬎0
(50)
x b h(x) → H(s ⫹ b)
(51)
and h(x p ) →
H(s/p) |p|
p≠0
,
(52)
The parallel to the Fourier convolution integral is the Mellin convolution integral: h(x) ⫽
冮
∞
0
冢冣
dt x h 0 (t) h 1 → M[h(x)] ⬅ H(s) ⫽ H 0 (s) H 1 (s) t t
(53)
The original integral is equal to h(x) ⫽
1 2πi
冮 ds H (s) H (s) x 0
1
⫺s
C
This may be generalized to N complex planes as
Copyright 2000 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
(54)
76
Sasiela and Shelton
冮
h(x 1 , . . . , x N ) ⫽
∞
N
dy
0
y
h 0 ( y)
兿冢冣 hj
j⫽1
xj y
→ M[h(x 1 , . . . , x N )] N
⫽ H 0 (s 1 ⫹ s 2 ⫹ ⋅ ⋅ ⋅ ⫹ s N )
兿
H j (s j )
(55)
j⫽1
⫽ H(s 1 , s 2 , . . . , s N ) The original integral is equal to an integration in N complex planes given by h(x 1 , . . . , x N ) ⫽
1 (2πi) N
冮
⋅⋅⋅
C1
冮
1 ⋅ ⋅ ⋅ x ⫺s N ds 1 ⋅ ⋅ ⋅ ds N H(s 1 , s 2 , . . . , s N ) x ⫺s 1 N
(56)
CN
For the problems being considered here, the function H(s 1 , s 2 , . . . , s N ) is the product of ratios of Gamma functions. This fact allows these integrals to be readily evaluated. The analytic solution of all integrals that contain functions for which the Mellin transform is a ratio of Gamma functions can be found. The integrands for finding second moments, power spectral densities, or Strehl ratios using the filter functions given above contain the following functions: sin(x), cos(x), sin 2 (x), cos 2 (x), J ν (x), J ν (x)J µ (x), J 2ν , exp(x), (1 ⫹ x)⫺p, (x ⫺ 1)⫺p U(x ⫺ 1), and K(x). The Mellin transforms of every one of these functions are given in Table 1, thus making these problems amenable to an analytic solution. To evaluate the resulting integrals in κ-space, one uses Cauchy’s poleresidue integral theorem: f (z) ⫽
1 2πi
冮 ds s ⫺ z f(s)
(57)
C
where the contour encloses the pole at s ⫽ z, and the function f (s) is holomorphic (has no singularities) in the integration region. This can be generalized to N complex planes [Range 1986] as f (z 1 , z 2 , . . . , z N ) ⫽
1 (2πi) N
冮
C1
⋅⋅⋅
冮
ds 1 ⋅ ⋅ ⋅ ds N
CN
f (s 1 , s 2 , . . . , s N ) (s 1 ⫺ z 1 ) ⋅ ⋅ ⋅ (s N ⫺ z N )
(58)
where the contour encloses all poles, and the function f(s 1 , s 2 , . . . , s N ) is holomorphic in the integration region. These integrals are easy to evaluate for the problems considered here because the integrand is a ratio of Gamma functions. The only singularities are poles of the numerator Gamma functions. Each Gamma function has an infinite number of poles, one occurring at every negative integers (⫺n) where it has a
Copyright 2000 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
Guide Star System Considerations
77
residue equal to (⫺1) n /n!. To evaluate the integral in one complex plane, simply write two sets of power series corresponding to the poles on each side of the path of integration. The power series that converges for the parameter value of interest is the solution to the problem. If the series resulting from the poles on one side of the integration path is an asymptotic series, then the other solution is valid for all values of the parameter. That power series will converge slowly for large values of the parameter, and in that case, one can use the asymptotic series. A steepest-descent contribution sometimes has to be added to the asymptotic series. A similar method is used to find the solution when the integration is over multiple complex planes. The details are described in Sasiela and Shelton [1993a] and in Sasiela [1994a]. VI. LIST OF RESULTS A.
Tilt
In this section formulas that apply to the calculation of the performance of an adaptive-optics system are given. Most of the results in this section are taken from Sasiela and Shelton [1993b]. First, consider the calculation of Zernike tilt, which is the dominant aberration of the atmosphere. Since this is a single wave problem, Eq. (15) applies. It is assumed that diffraction effects are not important, thereby allowing the cosine term to be replaced by unity. Neglecting inner- and outer-scale effects, the Kolmogorov spectrum given in Eq. (9) applies. Using the filter function to find the two-axis Zernike tilt given in Eq. (33), one obtains for the two-axis tilt variance T ⫽ 0.2073 k 2 Z
2 0
冮
L
dz C (z) ∫ d κជ κ⫺11/3 2 n
0
冢 冣冤 16 k0 D
2
J 2 (γκD/2) γκD/2
冥
2
(59)
The integrand in the second integral does not depend on the angle in kappa space. With the substitution x ⫽ γκD/2 one obtains T 2Z ⫽
105.1 D 1/3
冮
L
dz C 2n (z) γ 5/3
0
冮
∞
0
dx ⫺11/3 2 x J 2 (x) x
(60)
Using the Mellin transform in Eq. (T7), one finds the two-axis tilt variance: T 2Z ⫽
6.08 µ 0 D 1/3
⫽ 0.3641
冢冣冢冣 D r0
5/3
λ D
2
(61)
where the coherence diameter, r 0 , is defined in Eq. (45), and the turbulence moments are defined in Sec. IV. Because the variance is proportional to the zeroth moment of turbulence, it varies as the secant of the zenith angle, sec(ξ). For a
Copyright 2000 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
78
Sasiela and Shelton
0.6-m-diameter aperture and HV-21 turbulence, the rms tilt is 4 µrad. This is four times the diffraction-limited resolution of the aperture in the visible. For larger apertures the tilt is a larger multiple of the diffraction-limited angle. The tilt phase variance can be converted into a tilt variance by dividing the phase variance by (4/k 0 D) 2 to obtain σ 2Tilt ⫽ 0.38µ0 k 20 D 5/3
(62)
The variance of any Zernike mode is given in the section on Zernike anisoplanatism. In a similar fashion the gradient tilt variance can be found by using the filter function in Eq. (35) and is given by T 2G ⫽ 0.2073 k 20
冮
冢 冣 冢 冣 γκD 4 J 21 k0 D 2 2
L
dz C 2n (z) ∫ d κជ κ⫺11/3
0
(63)
This is easily evaluated using the Mellin transform given in Eq. (T7) to give T ⫽ 2 G
5.675 µ 0 D 1/3
冢冣冢冣
D ⫽ 0.3399 r0
5/3
λ D
2
(64)
The variance of the difference between the Zernike and gradient tilts was studied by Yura and Tavis [1985]. It can be found by inserting the aperture filter functions in Eq. (33) and (35) into Eq. (19) to obtain T 2G-Z ⫽ 0.2073 k 20 ⫻
冤冢
冮
L
dz C 2n (z) ∫ d κជ κ⫺11/3
0
4 J 2 (κD/2) κD/2
冣
冥
冢 冣 4 k0 D
2
2
(65)
⫺ J 1 (κD/2)
Using the Mellin transform given in Eqs. (T7) and (T8), one finds T
2 G-Z
⫽
0.102 µ 0 D 1/3
冢冣冢冣
D ⫽ 0.0061 r0
5/3
λ D
2
(66)
If the turbulence is constant along the path of length L, the two-axis Zernike tilt variance is T 2Z ⫽
6.08 C n2 L D 1/3
(67)
For a point source propagating from the ground to space, the value of γ is z/L, and the Zernike tilt variance is
Copyright 2000 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
Guide Star System Considerations
T 2Z ⫽
6.08 µ 5/3 1/3
⫽
5/3
D L
79
0.169 λ 2 D 1/3 L5/3 θ 05/3
(68)
Therefore, a tilt sensor in space observing a point source on the ground is sensitive to the isoplanatic angle. The variance varies as sec 8/3 (ξ). The significant effect of outer scale on tilt jitter was pointed out by Valley [1979]. To set up this problem, the general expression in Eq. (15) is used with the filter function for Zernike tilt in Eq. (33) for a plane wave for which γ ⫽ 1. The von Ka´rma´nn turbulence spectrum given in Eq. (10) with diffraction neglected gives for the total tilt variance T ⫽ 0.2073 k 2 0
冮
2 0
L
0
dz C (z) ∫ d κជ [κ ⫹ κ ] 2 n
2 ⫺11/6 0
2
冢 冣冤 16 k0 D
2
J 2 (κD/2) κD/2
冥
2
(69)
It is assumed that outer scale does not depend on z. The integrations over angle and z are evaluated. The κ integral can be evaluated using Mellin transform techniques to give T 20 ⫽
6.08 µ 0 D 1/3
冦 冤 2
F3
11
/6 , 7/3 ; 5/6 , 29/6 , 17/6 ;
冢冣 冤 1/3
D ⫺ 1.4234 L0
冢 冣冥 2
πD L0
冢 冣 冥冧
πD 2 F3 2, /2 ; /6 , 5, 3; L0 5
7
2
(70)
These generalized hypergeometric functions can be evaluated and the results plotted by computer algebra programs. The lowest order terms of the summations in Eq. (70) are T 20 ⬇
6.08 µ 0 D 1/3
冦
冢冣 冢冣
1 ⫺ 1.42
D ⫺4.01 L0
D L0
7/3
1/3
冢冣 冢冣 冢冣 冧
⫹ 3.70
D ⫹ 4.21 L0
D L0 4
2
D ⫺ 4.00 L0
13/3
(71)
The tilt jitter is affected by outer scale, and the fractional decrease from the value with infinite outer scale is shown in Fig. 4. If outer scale is 100 times the aperture diameter, the rms tilt jitter is still decreased by 15%. This decrease occurs because the tilt jitter is caused mainly by the long wavelength turbulence. A finite outer scale decreases the turbulence at the long wavelengths and, thereby, decreases the tilt variance. The first two terms in braces give a very good approximation to the tilt variance if the outer scale is larger than several times the aperture diameter. This is an example of how to write the answer as a few terms of a power series. If
Copyright 2000 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
80
Sasiela and Shelton
Figure 4 Tilt variance for the von Ka´rma´n turbulence spectrum with outer scale, normalized to tilt variance with infinite outer scale. Notice that there is a significant reduction of tilt even if outer scale is 100 times the diameter. This curve is independent of the turbulence distribution along the propagation path.
the outer-scale size were much smaller than the diameter, the series would converge slowly, and an asymptotic series would be appropriate. The Greenwood outer-scale model gives a similar tilt variation. The lowest order terms for this tilt variance are T ⬇ 2 0
6.08 µ 0 D
1/3
冦
冢冣 冢冣 冢冣 冢冣 冢 冣冧
D 1 ⫺ 1.85 L0 D ⫺5.24 L0
2
1/3
⫹ 1.76
D ⫹ 6.70 L0
D L0
7/3
D ⫺ 3.77 L0
3
(72)
Winker [1991] considered the effect of outer scale on all the Zernike modes. B. Zernike Anisoplanatism and Its Effect on Adaptive-Optics Systems Zernike anisoplanatism refers to the difference in the level of a Zernike mode seen from either two sources or viewed in two apertures. Because the two waves arriving at the aperture or apertures have traveled through different turbulence,
Copyright 2000 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
Guide Star System Considerations
81
there will be a difference in the level of each Zernike mode measured at any time. This difference will increase on average as the angle or displacement of the two apertures increases until the amplitude of the Zernike modes is uncorrelated for the two paths. In that case, the variance of the difference saturates at a level that is two times the variance of the mode measured in a single aperture. The variation of tilt jitter with separation of apertures has been applied in many applications. For instance, if one is sending a laser beam to a target that is being tracked, then the laser beam must lead the target that is being tracked to account for the finite speed of light. The arriving beam will jitter on the target due to tilt anisoplanatism. Anisoplanatism for higher order aberrations is important in applications such as adaptive-optics systems that correct for Zernike modes (modal) rather than local regions of the aperture (zonal). It is important to determine over what angle a correction applies and what error remains after the correction. It is shown that the angle over which any correction is possible decreases as the mode order increases and the aperture diameter decreases. This angle can be quite small. In one limit, if the angle over which the correction applies is less than the resolution of the system, then the correction is worthless. Even for larger angles there can be a severe degradation in performance in some applications. It is shown for some aperture separations that the phase variance for some Zernike modes more than triples when a correction is applied. Applying such a correction is counterproductive. 1. Derivation of Formulas for Zernike Anisoplanatism The calculation of the variance of Zernike anisoplanatism is a direct application of the technique described above. To find the total value of tilt anisoplanatism and both the components parallel and perpendicular to the displacement direction that is taken to be along the x-axis, Eq. (20) with diffraction neglected is used with the filter function for a Zernike mode given in Eq. (31) to obtain for the phase variance σ 2x
冦冧 σ 2y σ
2
⫽ 0.2073 k 20
冮
L
C 2n (z) dz ∫ d κជ
0
n, m
⫻ (n ⫹ 1)
冢
2 J n⫹1 (κD/2) κD/2
冣
冦
冧
cos 2 (mϕ) sin 2 (mϕ) 1
κ ⫺11/3
2
(73)
4[1 ⫺ cos{κd cos(ϕ)}]
where σ 2 is the total variance and is equal to the sum of the x and y variances. The bottom term is also the variance when m is equal to zero, in which cases the top two terms do not apply. There are the requirements that m ⱕ n and n ⫺
Copyright 2000 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
82
Sasiela and Shelton
m is even. Common aberrations expressed in terms of (m, n) are (0, 0) for piston, (1, 1) for tilt, (0, 2) for focus, (2, 2) for astigmatism, and (1, 3) for coma. The displacement is considered to be along the x axis and the top term is the x component of the aberration. Therefore, in a more general sense the top term is the phase variance due to a movement parallel to that component of the aberration, and the middle term is due to a perpendicular movement. This expression gives the phase variance for a particular Zernike mode. One can use this result to obtain other information; for instance, if the expression for tilt anisoplanatic phase variance is multiplied by (4k 0 /D) 2 then one obtains the tilt variance, which is the variance of the angular jitter of a signal that arrived with that displacement. The above integral, which has Kolmogorov turbulence, does not converge for piston; therefore the results are not valid for n ⫽ 0. If a turbulence model with finite outer scale is inserted into the integral, the results would be valid for piston. The angular integration can be written as
冮
Ia ⫽ 2
⫽
冮
2π
冦 冦
dϕ
0
cos 2 (mϕ) sin 2 (mϕ) 1
冧
[1 ⫺ cos{κ d cos(ϕ)}]
1 ⫹ cos(2mϕ)
2π
dϕ
0
1 ⫺ cos(2mϕ) 2
冧
(74) [1 ⫺ cos{κ d cos(ϕ)}]
The integral in Gradshteyn and Ryzhik Sect 3.715 # 19 can be extended over the full circle to give
冮
2π
0
cos[β cos(x)] cos(2mx)dx ⫽ (⫺1) m 2π J2m (β)
(75)
Use this to obtain σ 2x
冦冧 σ 2y σ2
⫽ 10.42 k 20 (n ⫹ 1)
冮
L
dz C 2n (z)
0
冮
∞
κ ⫺8/3 dκ
0
n, m
⫻
冦
1 ⫺ J0 (κ d) ⫺ (⫺1) m J2m (κ d )
1 ⫺ J0 (κd ) ⫹ (⫺1) J2m (κ d) 2[1 ⫺ J0 (κd )]
Copyright 2000 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
m
冧
冤
Jn⫹1 (κD/2) κD/2
冥
2
(76)
Guide Star System Considerations
83
This can be solved by Mellin transform techniques to obtain for displacements when d ⬍ D σ 2x
冦σ 冧 2 y
⫽ 0.9263 k 20 D 5/3 (n ⫹ 1)
冮
L
dz C 2n (z)
0
冦 冤n ⫹ / , / 冥 [ F [n ⫺ / , ⫺n ⫺ / , ⫺ / ; 1, ⫺ / ; ( / ) ] ⫺ 1] ⫺/ (/ ) F [n ⫹ / , ⫺n ⫺ / , / ; / , / ; ( / ) ] ⫺ Γ冤 /, /冥
⫻ ⫺Γ
n ⫺ 5/6 , 7/3 23
7
6
3
17
3
d
10
3
1
⫿ (⫺1) m Γ
5
2
17
6
11
6
4
6
d
3
D
2
6
D
14/3
3
3
2
1
2
2
1
10
2
3
10
d
3
D
2
2
冤2m ⫹ 1, n ⫺ m ⫹
m ⫹ n ⫺ 5/6 , ⫺m ⫹ 7/3 /6 , 17/6 ⫺ m
23
冥( / ) d
2m
D
(77)
⫻ 3 F2 [m ⫹ n ⫺ 5/6 , m ⫺ n ⫺ 17/6 , m ⫺ 11/6 ; 2m ⫹ 1, m ⫺ 4/3 ; ( d/D )2 ] ⫿ (⫺1) m Γ
冤m ⫹
m ⫺ 7/3 , n ⫹ 3/2 /3 , n ⫹ 3/2 , 1/2
10
冥( / )
d D 14/3
冧
⫻ 3 F2 [n ⫹ 3/2 , ⫺n ⫺ 1/2 , 1/2 ; m ⫹ 10/3 , ⫺m ⫹ 10/3 ; ( d/D )2 ] ,
d⬍D
For displacements when d ⬎ D, the result is σ 2x
冦σ 冧 ⫽ 0.9263 k D 2 0
2 y
(n ⫹ 1)
冮
L
dz C 2n (z)
0
n ⫺ 5/6 , 7/3
冦 冤n ⫹
⫻ Γ
5/3
23
/6 ,
n ⫺ 5/6 , n ⫹ 3/2
⫺ Γ冤 /冥 ⫺n ⫹
17
6
冥( / ) D
/6 , 2n ⫹ 3, n ⫹ 2
11
d
2n⫺5/3
⫻ 3 F2 [n ⫺ 5/6 , n ⫹ 3/2 , n ⫺ 5/6 ; 2n ⫹ 3, n ⫹ 2; ( D/d )2 ]
⫿ (⫺1) m Γ
n ⫹ m ⫺ 5/6 , n ⫹ 3/2
冤m ⫺ n ⫹
/6 , 2n ⫹ 3, n ⫹ 2
11
冥( / ) D
d
(78)
2n⫺5/3
冧
⫻ 3 F2 [m ⫹ n ⫺ 5/6 , n ⫹ 3/2 , n ⫺ m ⫺ 5/6 ; 2n ⫹ 3, n ⫹ 2; ( D/d )2 ] , d ⬎ D
The total variance and the variance when m ⫽ 0 are given by twice the x or the y variance with the ⫾-terms deleted. Note that the sum of the variances of the parallel and perpendicular components does not depend on m. For very
Copyright 2000 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
84
Sasiela and Shelton
large separations the x and y variances are equal, each being one-half the total variance (sum of the x and y components) of that Zernike component. Note that the expression for large separations diverges when n ⫽ 0; the only value of m that is possible for n ⫽ 0 is 0, since m ⱕ n; the (0, 0) mode is the piston. We know that the piston variance is infinite when outer-scale effects are not considered, so this result is expected. Even though this result looks like a formidable expression, it is easily plotted for any Zernike mode by a computer algebra program that evaluates generalized hypergeometric functions. The two-axis variance of a Zernike component for a single wave is given by the first term in Eq. (78) as σ 2m, n ⫽ 0.9263 D 5/3 k 20 (n ⫹ 1) ⫽ 0.6395 µ k D Γ 2 0 0
5/3
冮
L
dz C 2n (z) Γ
0
冤n ⫹
n ⫺ 5/6 , 7/3 23
/6 , 17/6
冥
(79)
冤n ⫹ / 冥 (n ⫹ 1) n ⫺ 5/6 23
6
C. Effect of an Angular Offset between the Waves The tilt-anisoplanatism problem with an infinite outer scale considered in the last section is generalized to allow a finite outer turbulence scale. We will see that it does not have as significant an effect as outer scale did on tilt. One uses Eq. (73) where von Ka´rma´nn outer-scale effects are included and m ⫽ 1. To find the tilt variance the equation is multiplied by (4/k 0 D) 2 to give σ 2x
冦冧 σ 2y
⫽ 0.4146
σ2
冢 冣冮 16 D
2
dz C 2n (z) ∫ d κជ
0
⫻ (κ 2 ⫹ κ 20 )⫺11/6
冦 冧 cos 2 (ϕ)
L
sin 2 (ϕ) 1
冢
J 2 (κD/2) κD/2
冣
(80)
2
[1 ⫺ cos{κ d cos(ϕ)}]
This can be evaluated using Mellin transform techniques in two complex planes. The result is the sum of three double power series. The lowest order terms are σ 2x
冦σ 冧 2 y
⫽
冢 冣 冦 冧冤
2.67 µ 0 d D 1/3 D
2
3
1
1 ⫺ 20.6
冢冣 D L0
2
⫹ 27.4
冢冣 D L0
7/3
冥
⫹ ⋅⋅⋅
(81)
The first term is the same as that in Eq. (77) in which the outer scale was neglected. In Sec. VI where tilt with outer scale was considered, the outer scale
Copyright 2000 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
Guide Star System Considerations
85
had a significant effect on the tilt because the leading term of the series with the ratio of the diameter to the outer scale was raised to the inverse one-third power. Here, the effect is small if the outer-scale size is significantly greater than the diameter because the leading term is the inverse second power of the ratio. The physical reason for this behavior is that for small relative aperture displacements the two beams see the same tilt from long-wavelength turbulence, which cancels when the tilts are subtracted from each other. Mathematically, this subtraction had the result of eliminating one term in the summations. The term that was eliminated has the one-third power-law dependence on outer scale. If the displacement between the two beams is an angle θ, then the expression for Zernike anisoplanatism is obtained by making the substitution d ⫽ θz into Eqs. (77) and (78). The solution for this important case is the sum of a lower and upper contribution expressed as σ 2x
σ 2x
σ 2x
冦σ 冧 冦σ 冧 冦σ 冧 2 y
⫽
2 y
⫹
2 y
L
(82) U
The lower contribution is found by integrating the expression for small displacements from 0 to H c , where H c ⫽ D cos(ξ)/θ, and ξ is the angle measured from zenith. The upper contribution is obtained by integrating the expression for large displacement from H c to L. The lower contribution is σ 2x
冦σ 冧 2 y
⫽ 0.9263 k 20 D 5/3 (n ⫹ 1) L
冮
Hc
dz C 2n (z)
0
冦 冤n ⫹ / , / 冥 [ F [n ⫺ / , ⫺n ⫺ / , ⫺ / ; 1, ⫺ / ; ( / ) ] ⫺ 1] ⫺/ ( / ) F [n ⫹ / , ⫺n ⫺ / , / ; / , / ; ( / ) ] ⫺ Γ冤 /, /冥
⫻ ⫺Γ
n ⫺ 5/6 , 7/3 23
7
10
3
6
3
1
⫿ (⫺1) m Γ
17
3
5
2
17
6
11
6
4
6
θz
3
D
2
6
θz
14/3
D
3
2
3
1
2
2
1
2
10
3
10
3
θz
D
2
2
冤2m ⫹ 1, n ⫺ m ⫹
m ⫹ n ⫺ 5/6 , ⫺m ⫹ 7/3 /6 , 17/6 ⫺ m
23
冥( / ) θz
D
2m
(83)
⫻ 3 F2 [m ⫹ n ⫺ 5/6 , m ⫺ n ⫺ 17/6 , m ⫺ 11/6 ; 2m ⫹ 1, m ⫺ 4/3 ; ( θz/D )2 ] ⫿ (⫺1) m Γ
冤m ⫹
m ⫺ 7/3 , n ⫹ 3/2 /3 , n ⫹ 3/2 , 1/2
10
冥( / ) θz
D
14/3
⫻ 3 F2 [n ⫹ 3/2 , ⫺n ⫺ 1/2 , 1/2 ; m ⫹ 10/3 , ⫺m ⫹ 10/3 ; ( θz/D )2 ]
Copyright 2000 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
冧
86
Sasiela and Shelton
The upper contribution is σ 2x
冦σ 冧 2 y
⫽ 0.9263 k 20 D 5/3 (n ⫹ 1) H
冦 冤n ⫹
⫻ Γ
n ⫺ 5/6 , 7/3 23
/6 , 17/6
冮
L
dz C 2n (z)
0
冥 冤⫺n ⫹ ⫺Γ
n ⫺ 5/6 , n ⫹ 3/2 /6 , 2n ⫹ 3, n ⫹ 2
11
冥( / ) D
θz
2n⫺5/3
⫻ 3 F2 [n ⫺ 5/6 , n ⫹ 3/2 , n ⫺ 5/6 ; 2n ⫹ 3, n ⫹ 2; ( D/θz )2 ] ⫿ (⫺1) m Γ
冤m ⫺ n ⫹
n ⫹ m ⫺ 5/6 , n ⫹ 3/2 /6 , 2n ⫹ 3, n ⫹ 2
11
冥( / ) D
θz
(84)
2n⫺5/3
⫻ 3 F2 [m ⫹ n ⫺ 5/6 , n ⫹ 3/2 , n ⫺ m ⫺ 5/6 ; 2n ⫹ 3, n ⫹ 2; ( D/θz )2 ]
冧
For small displacement angles such that H c is higher than the uppermost turbulence, the anisoplanatic Zernike variance is given solely by the lower contribution. For the parallel component of tilt anisoplanatism the small angle approximation is found by expanding the generalized hypergeometric function in a power series and integrating term by term to obtain
冢
Parallel Tilt Variance x ⫽
θ D
冣
⬇ 0.38 k 20 D 5/3 {1.31733 µ ⫺2 x 2 ⫺ 3.02397 µ ⫺4 x 4 ⫺ ⫹ 2.1965 µ 14/3 x 14/3 ⫹ 0.35035 µ 6⫺ x 6 ⫺ 0.38575 µ ⫺20/3 x 20/3 ⫺ 0.04160 µ ⫺8 x 8 ⫹ x 26/3 ⫺ 0.00096 µ ⫹10 x 10 ⫹ 0.027622 µ 26/3 ⫹ ⫹ 0.0018 µ 32/3 x 32/3 },
(85)
θ HU ⬍ D
H U is the minimum of either of upper height of the turbulence distribution or L. The upper and lower partial turbulence moments, µ m⫹ and µ ⫺m , were defined previously. The perpendicular component is
Copyright 2000 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
Guide Star System Considerations
冢
Perp Tilt Variance x ⫽
θ D
87
冣
⬇ 0.38 k 20 D 5/3 {0.43911 µ 2⫺ x 2 ⫺ 0.60479 µ 4⫺ x 4 ⫺ ⫹ 0.38761 µ 14/3 x 14/3 ⫹ 0.05005 µ ⫺6 x 6 ⫺ ⫺ 0.050315 µ 20/3 x 20/3 ⫺ 0.00462 µ ⫺8 x 8
(86)
⫹ 0.002857 µ ⫹26/3 x 26/3 ⫺ 0.000087 µ ⫹10 x 10 ⫹ ⫹ 0.0001586 µ 32/3 x 32/3 }
θ HU ⬍ D
Notice that for very small angular offsets the variance increases as the square of the angular offset. This is true for all Zernike modes. The upper contribution is found from Eq. (84) to be
冢
Parallel Tilt Variance x ⫽
θ D
冣
⬇ 0.38 k 20 D 5/3 {µ 0⫹ ⫺ 0.53234 µ ⫹⫺1/3 x ⫺1/3 ⫺ 0.024645 µ ⫹⫺7/3 x ⫺7/3 ⫺ 0.000874 µ ⫹⫺13/3 x ⫺13/3 ⫹ x ⫺19/3} ⫺ 0.00015 µ ⫺19/3
(87)
θH U ⬎ D
The perpendicular tilt for large angular separations is
冢
Perp Tilt Variance x ⫽
θ D
冣
⬇ 0.38 k 20 D 5/3 {µ 0⫹ ⫺ 0.79851 µ ⫹⫺1/3 x ⫺1/3 ⫹ 0.018484 µ ⫹⫺7/3 x ⫺7/3 ⫹ 0.000262 µ ⫹⫺13/3 x ⫺13/3 ⫹ 0.000028 µ ⫹⫺19/3 x ⫺19/3} θH U ⬎ D
(88)
Similar series expressions can be written for each of the Zernike modes. For large diameters the first series term for small displacements gives an accurate approximation. For total tilt variance the approximation is Tilt ⬇ 0.667 k 20 D ⫺1/3 µ 2 θ 2
(89)
For total astigmatism the one-term approximation is Astigmatism ⬇ 0.305 k 20 D ⫺1/3 µ 2 θ 2
(90)
For total coma the one-term approximation is Coma ⬇ 0.182 k 20 D ⫺1/3 µ 2 θ 2 The first term for any n is
Copyright 2000 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
(91)
88
Sasiela and Shelton
Total Variance ⬇ 1.759 (n ⫹ 1)Γ
冤n ⫹ / 冥 k D n ⫹ 1/6 17
6
2 0
⫺1/3
µ2 θ2
(92)
One is interested in the angular extent over which the correction is useful. There are many ways to define a characteristic angle. First we will define it so that it can be used to gauge when it is useful to apply a correction to an adaptiveoptics system. The angle will be defined as that which would produce the same variance as an aperture with no correction. If the anisoplanatic error is equal to or greater than the value with no correction, then it does no good to correct for that mode. With this definition, the characteristic Zernike anisoplanatic angle, θ nC , is found by setting to unity the ratio of the most significant term of the total Zernike anisoplanatism for small offsets given in Eq. (77) and the Zernike variance given in Eq. (94) to obtain θnC ⫽ 0.603 D
冢
µ0
冣
1/2
µ 2 (n ⫺ 5/6)(n ⫹ 17/6)
(93)
Notice that this is independent of the wavelength; therefore, for shorter wavelengths there are a larger number of pixels that are corrected. For a HV-21 turbulence model for which µ 0 ⫽ 2.23 ⫻ 10⫺12 and µ 2 ⫽ 1.91 ⫻ 10⫺5 this formula reduces to θ nC ⫽
206 D √ (n ⫺ 5/6)(n ⫹ 17/6)
µrad
(94)
For a 1-m-diameter aperture at 0.5-µm operating wavelength, the characteristic tilt anisoplanatic angle is 258 µrad, which is considerably larger than the 21 µrad one gets when the criteria is that the anisoplanatic tilt jitter is one-half a beamwidth. When n ⫽ 2 the angle is 87 µrad, and for n ⫽ 3 the angle is 58 µrad. For large n the angle is 206D/n; the angle gets very small at high Zernike numbers. If the diameter decreases to 0.5 m, then the angles are reduced by a factor of 2. Conversely, a larger diameter increases the angle. The angles above are the largest angles for which correcting that Zernike aberration does any good at improving the image. For the lowest order aberrations a much smaller angle is required if one wants to approach diffraction-limited performance. For a 1-m-diameter aperture operating at a wavelength of 0.5 µm that looks through HV-21 turbulence the variances of a wavefront for the first 14 values of n are 133.7, 6.92, 1.84, 0.73, 0.35, 0.20, 0.12, 0.075, 0.050. 0.035, 0.025, 0.019, 0.014, and 0.011 rad 2. Notice that the tilt variance far exceeds the other variances, which is the reason why tilt must be very well corrected before a correction for other Zernike modes is noticed. The other aberrations can also contribute a significant variance, and since the variance for any Zernike aberration
Copyright 2000 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
Guide Star System Considerations
89
varies as the square of the angular offset, one can easily determine how much the angles given above must be reduced in order to have the variance of a particular aberration drop below a certain level. For a well-corrected system the phase variances for each mode must be below a certain value. One can calculate the error for which the phase variance is under 1 by using the first series term of Eq. (77) to get θ(1 rad 2 ) ⬇ 0.17
λ D 1/6 µ 21/2 √ n ⫹ 1
冢冤 Γ
n ⫹ 17/6 n ⫹ 1/6
冥冣
1/2
(95)
For a 1-m-diameter aperture at 0.5-µm operating wavelength, the angle for n ⫽ 1 is 31.5 µrad; for n ⫽ 2 the angle is 46.6 µrad, and for n ⫽ 3 the angle is 60.3 µrad. For a requirement that the error in any mode be less than 0.1 rad 2, the angles must be reduced by a factor of 3.16. A 0.1-rad 2 requirement results in very small correction angles. These angles increase as the operating wavelength increases. This formula does not apply for all n since, as shown above, the variance never exceeds 0.1 rad 2 when n ⬎ 7. D.
Beam Movement at a Target
Turbulence causes the beam boresight to move at a target. This movement is found here for a source on the ground projected into space, and for a source in space projected to the ground. Tilt causes a beam to change position on a target as shown in Fig. 5. In this problem the filter function is found by considering the beam movement on target for a given tilt realization. It is assumed that scintillations are small, and the beam is not broken up. If there are significant scintillations, these will increase the movement calculated here. It is also assumed that diffraction is unimportant, thereby allowing a ray-
Figure 5 Beam movement at a target board
Copyright 2000 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
90
Sasiela and Shelton
optics calculation. With these assumptions, the amount of beam jitter at a target at L is equal to the tilt from turbulence at z times the distance over which it acts, L ⫺ z. The local diameter of the collimated beam must be used. Therefore, the tilt filter function for this problem is F(κជ) ⫽ (L ⫺ z)
冢 冣冢 16 k 0 γD
2
2
J 2 (γκD/2) γκD/2
冣
2
(96)
The variance of beam movement using the formula for one wave in Eq. (15) with Kolmogorov turbulence is X 2 ⫽ 0.2073 k 20
冮
L
0
dz C 2n (z) ∫ d κជ κ⫺11/3 (L ⫺ z) 2
冢 冣冢
16 ⫻ k 0 γD
2
J 2 (γκD/2) γκD/2
冣
2
(97)
This expression can be evaluated for the collimated case, for which case γ ⫽ 1, to give X2 ⫽
6.08 2 [L µ 0 ⫺ 2 Lµ 1 ⫹ µ 2 ] D 1/3
(98)
For distances at which the target is well above the turbulence, the first term in brackets is dominant, giving the physically reasonable result that rms movement is rms tilt times distance. For a 1-m aperture with HV-21 turbulence for which µ 0 ⫽ 2.23 ⫻ 10⫺12 the rms beam jitter is 37 cm at 100 km. If turbulence is constant along the path, one finds X2 ⫽
2.03 L 3 C 2n
(99)
D 1/3
For the beam focused at the target board, for which case γ ⫽ (L ⫺ z)/L, the movement variance is X2 ⫽
6.08 D 1/3
冮
L
dz C 2n (z)
0
(L ⫺ z)5/3 L 5/3
(100)
For constant turbulence along the path this is X2 ⫽
2.28 L 3 C 2n D 1/3
(101)
The movement variance is 112% that of a collimated beam, and the rms movement is 106% that of a collimated beam.
Copyright 2000 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
Guide Star System Considerations
91
For a source in space, the same argument as above gives a filter function F(κជ ) ⫽ z 2
冢 冣冢 2
16 k 0 γD
J 2 (γκD/2) γκD/2
冣
2
(102)
Variance of the beam movement for a collimated beam propagated from space to ground is X2 ⫽
6.08 µ 2
(103)
D 1/3
This movement is equal to 1 cm for the HV-21 model with a 1-m aperture. Thus, it is much easier to hit a target on the ground from space with a laser beam than vice versa.
E.
Scintillation for Collimated and Focused Beams
Expressions that are derived for scintillation are only valid when log-amplitude variance is not saturated, which occurs for values below about 0.5. The variance of log-intensity is four times the variance of log-amplitude. To calculate scintillation of a wave that propagates from 0 to L with inner and outer scales neglected, again use Eq. (15) with the propagation parameter given in Eq. (2), to obtain σ 2χ ⫽ 0.2073 k 20
冮
L
dz C 2n (z) ∫ d κជ κ⫺11/3 sin2
0
冤
γ κ 2 (L ⫺ z) 2k 0
冥
(104)
Using the Mellin transform in Eq. (T5) evaluated at s ⫽ ⫺5/3, one obtains σ 2χ ⫽ 0.5631 k 7/6 0
冮
L
0
dz C 2n (z)(L ⫺ z) 5/6 γ 5/6
(105)
This must be integrated numerically in general. For a receiver well above the turbulence, the approximate value of σ 2χ for a plane wave, for which γ ⫽ 1, is 5/6 σ 2χ ⬇ 0.5631 k 7/6 0 µ0 L
(106)
This varies as sec(ξ). The log-amplitude variance is greater than unity for ranges larger than 2.5 km for a propagation wavelength of 0.5 µm and for a typical turbulence strength of 10⫺14 m⫺2/3. Therefore, scintillation of a beam projected a modest distance along the ground or to space will be saturated.
Copyright 2000 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
92
Sasiela and Shelton
For a point source on the ground, for which γ ⫽ z/L, the scintillation observed in space is approximately equal to σ 2χ ⬇ 0.5631 k 07/6 µ 5/6
(107)
11/6
This varies as sec (ξ). If propagation were from L to 0, then L ⫺ z should be replaced by z in Eq. (104). For a plane wave, for which γ ⫽ 1, one obtains σ 2χ ⫽ 0.5631 k 07/6 µ 5/6
(108)
This is the scintillation level seen in space from a point source on the ground. It is also the scintillation observed on the ground from a star and is equal to 0.059 for the HV-21 model at 0.5-µm wavelength and zero zenith angle. Even though this value is small, it is significant. The variance of log-intensity is four times that of the log-amplitude, giving a variance of 0.236. Therefore, the threesigma intensity is twice the mean. Similarly, for a point source in space propagating toward the ground, one obtains σ 2χ ⫽ 0.5631 k 07/6
冮
L
dz C 2n (z)
0
(L ⫺ z) 5/6 z 5/6 L 5/6
(109)
For a point source well above the turbulence, the scintillation is the same as that for a plane wave propagating from space, as would be expected. This result is given in Eq. 108. F. Phase Variance with Finite Servo Bandwidth Greenwood [1977] has derived the phase variance of an adaptive-optics system having finite temporal servo bandwidth with either a one-pole filter or an infinitely sharp filter. All other errors are neglected. Residual rms-phase error from a finite frequency response is calculated here using the same servo filter treated by Greenwood. Consider the following filter:
冷
1 1 ⫹ i(ω/ω3dB ) n
Fservo (ω) ⫽ 1 ⫺
冷
2
(110)
The single-pole filter case corresponds to n ⫽ 1, and the sharp cutoff case corresponds to n ⫽ ∞. Use this filter function in Eq. (26) with diffraction neglected and insert the result into Equation (23). If one considers propagation from L 1 to L 2 , one obtains σ 2φ ⫽ 0.8295 k 20 ⫻
冮
∞
0
冮
L2
dz C 2n (z)
L1
dx x 2n⫺5/3 x 1 ⫹ x 2n
冮
∞
0
v 5/3(z) 5/3 ω 3dB
dc U(c ⫺ 1)c ⫺5/3 c √c2 ⫺ 1
Copyright 2000 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
(111)
Guide Star System Considerations
93
where x⫽
f ω ⫽ ω 3dB f 3dB
(112)
The Mellin transform is used to evaluate both integrals, and the phase variance is σ ⫽ 2 φ
冢 冣 fG
f 3dB
5/3
⫽
0.051 k 20 v 5/3
(113)
5/3 f 3dB n sin(5π/6n)
where the velocity moment is defined by vm ⫽
冮
L2
L1
dz C 2n (z) v m (z) ⫽ sec(ξ)
冮
H2
dh C 2n (h) v m (h)
(114)
H1
For propagation between any two points, the integration is over the propagation path, and the velocity is the component transverse to the path. For a single-pole filter (n ⫽ 1) one finds that the characteristic frequency, sometimes referred to as the Greenwood frequency, is f G (n ⫽ 1) ⫽ 0.254 k 06/5 v 3/5 5/3
(115)
For a sharp cutoff filter, the limit of the phase variance as n gets very large is found from L’Hoˆpital’s rule. This gives the same form for the Greenwood frequency; however, the coefficient is smaller. In this case f G (n ⫽ ∞) ⫽ 0.0945 k 06/5 v 3/5 5/3
G.
(116)
Variances for Beams Corrected by Adaptive Optics
If an adaptive-optics system applied the conjugate in both amplitude and phase of the beacon, then an outgoing wave propagating in a direction exactly opposite to the beacon would be perfectly corrected. This result can be derived from the reciprocity relations for wave propagation. Most adaptive-optics systems apply only the conjugate of phase, and the direction of the outgoing beam may be offset from that of the beacon. For this case the residual log-amplitude and phase variances after correction by an adaptive-optics system are given by Eq. (21)
Copyright 2000 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
94
Sasiela and Shelton
with F(γ κ) ⫽ 1 as
冤σ 冥 σ 2φc 2 χc
⫻
⫽ 0.2073 k 20
冮
L
dz C 2n (z) ∫ dκជ κ ⫺11/3
0
冷 冤 冥 冤 冥 冤 冥冷 冷 sin 冤κ2kL冥 cos 冤κ2kz冥 ⫺ exp[i κជ ⋅ dជ ] sin 冤κ (L2k⫺ z)冥 冷
冤
κ2L κ2z κ 2 (L ⫺ z) cos cos ⫺ exp[i κជ ⋅ dជ ] cos 2k 0 2k 0 2k 0 2
2
0
2
2
0
0
2
冥
(117)
For the case in which the offset between the outgoing and beacon beams, dជ, is zero, the variance is
冤σ 冥 σ
2 φc
2 χc
⫽ 0.2073 k 20
冮
L
dz C 2n (z) ∫ d κជ κ ⫺11/3
0
冤κ2kz冥 sin 冤κ2kL冥 κ z κ L sin 冤 cos 冤 2k 冥 2k 冥
冤
2
2
sin 2
2
0
0
2
2
2
2
0
0
冥
(118)
A simple relation is obtained from adding the phase and log-amplitude variances: σ 2φc ⫹ σ 2χc ⫽ 0.2073 k 20
冮
L
dz C 2n (z) ∫ d κជ κ ⫺11/3 sin 2
0
冤 冥 κ2z 2k 0
⫽ 0.5631 k 7/6 0 µ 5/6
(119)
This is the same value one obtains for scintillation of a point source propagating towards the ground, which was analyzed in Sec. VI.E. Therefore, total variance is equal to the variance of the scintillation on the beacon. This expression includes the effect of diffraction and is valid for distributed turbulence. The corrected beam in a phase-only adaptive-optics system can be distorted by several causes. Consider the distortion in a system that has an anisoplanatic error produced by offsetting the outgoing beam by θ from the beacon. The filter function for the total beam distortion can be found from Eq. (117) as Ft (κជ) ⫽ sin 2
冤κ2kz冥 ⫹ 2 cos 冤κ2kz冥(1 ⫺ cos[κជ ⋅ dជ ]) 2
2
2
0
(120)
0
The first term is the same one that was encountered above with correctly aligned beams, and the variance it causes is given in Eq. (107). It will be assumed that diffraction is negligible, enabling the first cosine to be replaced by unity.
Copyright 2000 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
Guide Star System Considerations
95
The integral can be evaluated by using the Mellin transform in Eq. (T6) and the definition of isoplanatic angle in Eq. (46) to obtain
冢冣
θ σ ⫽σ ⫹ θ0 2 c0
2 χ
5/3
(121)
The angle-dependent variance is equal to the variance of angular anisoplanatism.
H.
Power Spectral Density of Tilt
In this section, the power spectral density for tilt of a collimated wave is derived. Plane wave results have been discussed briefly in Tatarski [1971] and presented in more detail in Greenwood and Fried [1976]. Greenwood and Fried made a simplifying assumption in order to obtain simple, analytic results. Fields [1983] coined the term ‘‘parallel approximation’’ for this simplification. One consequence of the parallel approximation is that the rate at which spectra decay at high frequencies is underestimated. Tyler [1986] subsequently analyzed plane wave tilt spectra without making this approximation. However, his results remain in integral form, containing an integral over a dummy variable related to spatial frequency and an integral over altitude. In a subsequent report, Vaughn [1986] provided numerical techniques to solve the integrals presented by Tyler, but that solution relies heavily on numerical integration. A similar approach has been used in tilt spectra associated with a point source (spherical wave analysis). This leads to integral expressions that also must be evaluated numerically [Hogge and Butts, 1976, Butts, 1980]. Power spectral density of tilt is found here using the general expression for power spectral density given in Eq. (26), with the filter function for Zernike tilt given in Eq. (33). It is assumed that one is in the near field so that the cosine term can be replaced by unity. This assumption breaks down at sufficiently high frequencies, where the exact equation must be used. The effect of including the cosine term is to lower the high-frequency spectrum. The spectral density is S T (ω) ⫽ 2.606 k ω 2 0
冮
0
冢 冣冤
16 ⫻ k0 D
2
L
dz
C 2n (z) v 2 (z)
冮
∞
dc
cU(c ⫺ 1) √c2 ⫺ 1
0
J 2 (ωcD/2v(z)) ωcD/2v(z)
Copyright 2000 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
冥
2
⫺11/3
冢 冣 ωc v(z)
(122)
96
Sasiela and Shelton
The result of evaluating this expression is a series solution for the power spectral density:
冢冣
2 S T (ω) ⫽ 52.53 ω
∞
2/3
冱 n⫽0
(⫺1) n n!
冦 冤n ⫹ 3, n ⫹ 5, ⫺n ⫹ / 冥冢 冣 v n ⫹ 5/2 , ⫺n ⫹ 1/3
⫻ Γ
5
⫹Γ
冤n ⫹
ωD 2
6
n ⫹ 17/6 , ⫺n ⫺ 1/3 /3 , n ⫹ 16/3 , ⫺n ⫹ 1/2
10
2n
(123)
⫺2n⫺1/3
冥冢 冣 ωD 2
2n⫹2/3
冧
v⫺2n⫺1
For the slew-dominated case in which the velocity is proportional to axial position, the velocity moments in the above expression are infinite. The low-frequency asymptote comes from the first term of the first series, and the dependence is ω⫺2/3. For large frequencies, an asymptotic series can be found; thus, the power spectral density at high frequencies is S T (ω) ⬃ 52.53 D ⫻
冦冮
冢 冣
1/2
2v(z) √ π ωD
0
n⫽0
冢 冣
1
dz C 2n (z)
冱
17/3
2 ωD
L
n0
⫹
2/3
v 14/3 (z) cos
ωD 冤冢v(z) 冣 ⫺ π4冥
冤
n ⫹ 5/2 , n ⫹ 17/6 (⫺1) n Γ n ⫹ 10/3 , ⫺n ⫹ 1/2 , ⫺n ⫹ 5/2 n!
冥冢 冣 2 ωD
(124)
2n
v2n⫹14/3
冧
The high-frequency asymptote comes from the first series term, and it varies as ω⫺17/3. If velocity is constant along the path, spectral density for small values of ωD/2v is S T (ω) ⫽ 3.453 ⫻
µ 0 D 2/3 v
冦F冤 2
3
冢 冣 2v ωD
2/3
冢 冣冥
ωD /2 , /6 ; 3, 5, ⫺ /3 ; ⫺ 2v
5
1
2
冢 冣 冤
ωD ⫺ 0.5394 2v
2/3
2
F3
Copyright 2000 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
2
(125)
冢 冣 冥冧
ωD /6 , /2 ; /3 , /3 , /3 ; ⫺ 2v
17
1
10
16
4
2
Guide Star System Considerations
97
The spectral density for large values of ωD/2v is an asymptotic series given by S T (ω) ⫽ 52.53 n0
⫹
冱 n⫽0
fD v
µ 0 D 2/3 v
冢 冣 冦 冢 冣 冤冢 冣 冥 2v ωD
17/3
1
2v ωD √π
冤
1/2
cos
ωD π ⫺ v 4
n ⫹ 5/2 , n ⫹ 17/6 (⫺1) n Γ n ⫹ 10/3 , ⫺n ⫹ 1/2 , ⫺n ⫹ 5/2 n!
⬎1
冢
f⫽
ω 2π
冥冢 冣 冧 2v ωD
2n
(126)
冣
Typically, the number of terms of the asymptotic series, n 0 , necessary to get a good approximation is less than 6. Power spectral density is plotted in Fig. 6. The spectrum is normalized to give a value of unity when the fD/v is unity. In the figure both Taylor series (first 40 terms) and asymptotic solution (first 5 terms) are plotted. For fD/v ⬍ 1, the asymptotic series was set equal to unity since the series is very inaccurate
Figure 6 Log-linear plot of the power spectral density of tilt. The velocity and turbulence are constant along the path. Notice the agreement of asymptotic and Taylor series over a considerable range. This curve is independent of the turbulence distribution along the propagation path.
Copyright 2000 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
98
Sasiela and Shelton
in that region, and above 5 the Taylor series was discarded because it becomes inaccurate with the 40-term approximation. The two series give virtually the same answer in the parameter range between 1 and 5. Notice the strong influence of the cosine term on the spectrum. If velocity is allowed to vary along the path, various cosine terms for different velocities tend to average to zero, and the spectrum does not exhibit nearly as strong an oscillatory behavior. I. Scintillation from a Finite Size Receive Aperture and a Finite Size Source Scintillation in a receiver is considerably reduced from that of a point source receiver if the aperture is a few inches in diameter. Also, the scintillation from a finite size object, such as a planet, is considerably lower than that from a point source, such as a star. Both of these averaging effects can be calculated using the filter function approach. In these problems one is interested in the average scintillation over an aperture or at a point receiver from a finite source. One has to average the intensity, but the statistical expressions are given in terms of the log-intensity. The Rytov approximation, upon which this work is based, is valid for low levels of scintillation, and in that approximation the normalized intensity is well approximated by the log-intensity. Therefore, the average of the log-intensity approximates the average of the intensity. The scintillation from stars is low, and the approximation holds for that practical problem. The exact solution was found by Fried [1967], using a numerical integration. The scintillation averaged over an aperture, using the filter function in Eq. (39) for a source at infinity in the formula for variance given in Eq. (15), is σ 2χA ⬇ 0.2073 k 20 ⫻
冤
冮
L
dz C 2n (z) ∫ d κជ f(κ)sin 2 [P(γ, κ, z)]
0
2 J 1 (γκD/2) γκD/2
冥
2
(127)
For propagation toward the receiver, the diffraction parameter is P(γ, κ, z) ⫽ γκ 2 z/2k 0 . For most situations in which diameter is larger than the source, the parameter in the previous equation is very large, and the answer can be approximated by the first term of the asymptotic series, which is σ 2χA ⬇
4.34 D 7/3
冮
L
0
dz C 2n (z)
z2 γ 1/3
(128)
For propagation from space to ground γ ⫽ (L ⫺ z)/L. If the source is well above the atmosphere, then this is close to unity. In this case the scintillation is
Copyright 2000 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
Guide Star System Considerations
99
equal to σ 2χA ⬇
4.34 µ 2
(129)
D 7/3
The aperture-averaged scintillation does not depend on the wavelength. That is the reason that no scintillation-induced color is evident in a star image as seen in a telescope. The aperture-averaged scintillation depends on the second moment of turbulence, which is close to the five-thirds moment that is needed to calculate the isoplanatic angle. By modifying the aperture function using masks in their isoplanometer, Walters et al. [1979] were able to have the aperture-averaged scintillation closely approximated by the five-thirds moment of turbulence. In this manner the instrument is used to estimate isoplanatic angle. If turbulence is constant along the path, for plane wave propagation the variance is σ 2χA ⬇
1.45 C 2n L 3
(130)
D 7/3
Scintillation with no averaging is given in Eq. (107) as σ 2χ ⫽ 0.5631 k 7/6 0 µ 5/6
(131)
The scintillation reduction ratio is σ 2χA σ 2χ
⬇ 7.7 ⫽
µ2 µ 5/6 D 7/3 k 7/6 0
冢 冣 Dc
⫽ 0.902
µ2 µ 5/6
冢 冣 λ D2
7/3
D
D ⬎⬎ D c
,
7/6
(132)
where D c , the characteristic diameter for scintillation averaging, is given by D c ⫽ 0.957
冢 冣 µ2
3/7
µ 5/6
√λ
(133)
For the HV-21 model, the values of the turbulence moments are µ 2 ⫽ 1.91 ⫻ 10⫺5 and µ 5/6 ⫽ 5.45 ⫻ 10⫺10. At a wavelength of 0.5 µm the characteristic diameter is 6 cm. If turbulence is constant along the path, Eq. (132) becomes σ 2χA σ 2χ
⬇ 0.109
冢 冣 √ λL D/2
7/3
,
D ⬎⬎ √ λL
Copyright 2000 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
(134)
100
Sasiela and Shelton
This formula agrees with the power-law dependence given in Tatarski [1971]. For this case the characteristic diameter is D c ⫽ 0.774 √ λL
(135)
Next, the case of a source of finite angular extent viewed by a point receiver is considered. In this case the filter function for a finite size source of diameter D s given in Eq. (39) is rewritten in terms of the angle subtended by the source, θ s , where θs ⫽
Ds
(136)
L
The filter function is thus F(γ κជ) ⫽
冤
2 J 1 (γκθ s z/2) γκθ s z/2
冥
2
(137)
The analysis proceeds in the same manner as above. Once again the first term of the asymptotic series is the most significant for larger angles, and it is σ 2χA ⬇
4.34 θ s7/3
冮
L
dz C 2n (z)(γz)⫺1/3
(138)
0
The negative moment of turbulence is finite. The leading term for scintillation from a finite source, just as for aperture averaging, does not depend on the wavelength. For propagation from space to the ground γ ⫽ (L ⫺ z)/L. If the source is well above the atmosphere, then this is close to unity. For large source sizes the scintillation reduction ratio is σ 2χA σ 2χ
⬇ 7.7
µ ⫺1/3 7/6 µ 5/6 θ 7/3 s k0
⫽ 0.902
冢冣 冢冣
µ ⫺1/3 λ µ 5/6 θ 2s
7/6
⫽
θc
θs
7/3
, θ s ⬎⬎ θ c
(139)
where θ c , the characteristic angle of the source for scintillation reduction, is θ c ⫽ 0.957
冢 冣 µ ⫺1/3 µ 5/6
3/7
√λ
(140)
For the HV-21 model µ ⫺1/3 ⫽ 5.50 ⫻ 10⫺13, and the characteristic angle is equal to 35.2 µrad at a wavelength of 0.5 µm. If turbulence is constant along the path,
Copyright 2000 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
Guide Star System Considerations
101
the reduction factor is σ 2χA σ
2 χ
⬇ 2.48
冢 冣 λ Lθ 2s
7/6
,
θ s ⬎⬎
√
λ L
(141)
The characteristic angle in this case is θ c ⫽ 1.48
√
λ L
(142)
J. Focal Anisoplanatism for Point Sources Analytic expressions can be obtained for the phase variance with point, distributed, and offset beacons. The analysis approach is to use a general formula for variance, which applies to a wide variety of problems, and insert filter functions appropriate for each situation. The resulting integrals can be evaluated analytically using Mellin transform techniques. The general formula for a function of the phase variance between two waves that can have different propagation characteristics was given in Sec. II. Different problems are solved by using the same general formula and inserting different filter functions of the transverse turbulence spectrum. Filter functions appropriate to the synthetic beacon problem are derived. This formula is applied to find analytical expressions for the phase variance with a single point source beacon in this section, for a distributed beacon in Sec. VI.K and for an offset beacon in Sec. VI.L. In Sec. VII, systems using more than one synthetic beacon are analyzed. For large apertures, a large phase residual remains in using a single synthetic beacon in the atmosphere. This error can be reduced by using multiple beacons. Because wavefront sensors measure phase gradient rather than tilt, the measurement of the wavefront from each beacon has a tilt error. The measurements from the various beacons must be ‘‘stitched’’ together. The analysis is complicated because tilt errors are correlated. Tilt errors and their correlation are calculated and inserted into a least squares reconstructor to obtain estimates of the errors associated with multibeacons systems. The net results of this analysis are simple formulas to obtain the figure variance for systems with one or more beacons. Phase variances are obtained for a 60-cm system that was fielded in Maui [Primmerman et al., 1991; Murphy et al., 1991] and for a larger 4-m system. Focal anisoplanatism refers to errors made in using a phase disturbance measured by a focused beam to correct for turbulence effects on a collimated beam or one focused at a different altitude. Some authors refer to this as focus anisoplanatism. If a point source is very far away, the error is very small. For closer sources, such as those using a synthetic beacon in the ‘‘guidestar’’ concept,
Copyright 2000 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
102
Sasiela and Shelton
the effect can be significant and may result in a low Strehl ratio. For these systems, the maximum beacon altitude proposed is at the height of the sodium layer at 90 km, which can provide significant scattering of yellow light [Humphreys et al., 1991]. Fugate et al. [1991] used another type of beacon. The phase variance from focal anisoplanatism is calculated in this section. First, an expression for variance from turbulence below the beacon is obtained that has both piston and tilt components present. Next, expressions for piston and tilt variances are obtained. Subtracting the last variances from the total, gives piston- and tilt-removed phase variances due to focal anisoplanatism from turbulence below the beacon. The phase variances from turbulence above the beacon are added to these variances to get the total variances. The technique to find the variance is the same one that has been used in previous problems. The filter function for a distributed, circular, uniform beacon of diameter D s and offset dជ that is at a range L and altitude H is inserted into the formula for phase variance of a single wave given in Eq. (15). Assume one is operating in the near field, allowing the cosine term to be replaced by 1. Doing the angle integration, one obtains for the aperture-averaged phase variance σ 2⫺d ⫽ 1.303 k 20
冦
⫻ 1⫺
冮
L
dz C 2n (z)
0
冮
∞
dκ κ ⫺8/3
0
2 J1 (κ D s z/2L) 2 J1 (κDz/2L) κ D s z/2L
冤
⫹ 2
κ Dz/2L
J1 (κD s z/2L) κ D s z/2L
J0
冢 冣 κbz L
(143)
冥冧 2
The subscript d on the variance refers to a distributed source. The negative subscript means that it is the component from turbulence below the beacon. The component above the beacon will be added to this to obtain the total variance. If the d subscript is missing, it means a point source is being considered. Piston and tilt are present in σ 2⫺d . This equation is the starting point for the evaluation of the total phase variance for all cases considered in this and the next two sections. The problem is solved in steps since the results for a point source, a distributed source, and a displaced source are of interest for different situations. The phase variance of a point source on the aperture center with piston and tilt present can be found from Eq. (143) by setting the source diameter and displacement equal to zero to obtain σ 2⫺ ⫽ 2.606 k 20
冮
L
0
dz C 2n (z)
冮
∞
0
冤
dκ κ ⫺8/3 1 ⫺
Copyright 2000 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
2 J1 (κ Dz/2L) κDz/2L
冥
(144)
Guide Star System Considerations
103
The integrals can be evaluated, and the phase variance is equal to σ 2⫺ ⫽ 0.5 k 20 µ ⫺5/3
冢冣 冢 D L
5/3
⫽
0.348D Lθ 0⫺
冣
5/3
(145)
The partial isoplanatic angle is defined as (θ ⫺0 )⫺5/3 ⫽ 2.91 k 20 µ ⫺5/3
(146)
The phase variance results from an angular offset of the collimated and focused rays. The phase variance varies with radius; however, one can consider the average phase variance to be due to an angular offset equal to that of the ray that emanates from the point that is about 0.7 of the radius from the center. This angle is 0.348D/L. This phase variance with piston included is finite, unlike the result for unfiltered turbulence, which is infinite. The infinite result comes from the zero spatial wavelength term. This infinity cancels out in the subtraction of the collimated beam phase from that of a focused beam. Even though the above result is finite, it might be possible that the major component of this variance is due to the piston, which is no practical interest. It can be shown that at satellite altitudes the piston contribution is less than 10% of the variance. At 10 km it can be as large as 20%. Therefore, the above simple expression is a reasonable zero-order approximation to phase variance. A 60-cm aperture looking at a point source at 300 km would have the same phase variance as two beams with angular offset of 0.7 µrad. For typical isoplanatic angles, this will produce a very small variance. For a 4-m system with a beacon at 90 km the corresponding offset is 15 µrad, which is typically larger than the isoplanatic angle. Often one is interested in phase variance with piston or piston and tilt removed. The phase variance due to piston and tilt can be calculated separately and subtracted from the total phase variance to obtain these variances. Piston and tilt phase variances are found by using Eq. (19) with filter functions given in Eq. (31). σ 2⫺Z ⫽ 0.2073 k 20 ⫻
冤
冮
L
dz C 2n (z) 4ν 2 ∫ d κជ κ ⫺11/3
0
J ν (κD/2) κD/2
冤
冥
z Jν (κ D(1 ⫺ z/L)/2) 2 J1 (κD s z/2L) ⫺ exp i κជ ⋅ bជ L κ D(1 ⫺ z/L)/2 κ D s z/2L
冥
(147) 2
where D s is the source diameter, and bជ is displacement of the source from boresight. The value of ν is 1 for piston and 2 for tilt. First consider the case of zero source size and no offset. The piston phase variance due to turbulence below the beacon is
Copyright 2000 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
104
Sasiela and Shelton
冮
σ 2⫺P ⫽ 0.5 k 20 D 5/3
L
dz C 2n (z)
0
冦 F [⫺ / , ⫺ / ; 2; (1 ⫺ / ) ] ⫺ 1 ⫹ √(1π ⫺2 z/L) Γ 冤 / 冥冧 5/3
⫻
2
1
5
11
6
z
6
L
2
⫺8/3
(148)
7
/3
23
6
This can be integrated numerically; however, to express this as turbulence moments, the expression in braces is expanded in a Taylor series about the point. Some care must be taken in expanding this series to obtain a short series that is a good approximation to the exact calculation. It has been found that a good approximation to the exact result for typical turbulence models and aperture diameters is σ 2⫺P ⬇ 0.0833 k 20 D 5/3
µ ⫺2 (H )
(149)
L2
The integrations can be performed for tilt to obtain σ 2⫺T ⫽ 0.8345 k 20 D 5/3 ⫻
冦
冮
L
dzC 2n (z)
0
1 ⫹ (1 ⫺ z/L) 5/3 √ π 2⫺11/3
冤 /冥 7
Γ
/3
29
(150)
6
冧
⫺ (1 ⫺ z/L ) 2 F1 [1/6 , ⫺11/6 ; 3; (1 ⫺ z/L ) 2 ]
After expanding this in a Taylor series in the same way as piston, the tilt variance is closely approximated by σ 2⫺T ⬇ 0.368 k 20 D 5/3
µ ⫺2 (H ) L2
(151)
The piston-removed variance is σ
2 ⫺PR
冢
0.348D ⫽ Hθ 0⫺
冣
5/3
⫺ σ 2⫺P
(152)
The piston- and tilt-removed variance is σ 2⫺PTR ⫽
冢
0.348D Hθ ⫺0
冣
5/3
⫺ σ 2⫺P ⫺ σ 2⫺T
(153)
With the above results, a good approximation to the piston-removed phase is
Copyright 2000 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
Guide Star System Considerations
σ 2⫺PR ⫽
冢
0.348D Hθ ⫺0
冣
5/3
⫺ σ 2⫺P ⬇
105
冤
k 20 D 5/3 µ ⫺5/3 (H) 2
L 5/3
⫺ 0.167
µ ⫺2 (H ) L2
冥
(154)
Similarly, a good approximation to the piston- and tilt-removed phase is σ 2⫺PTR ⫽ ⬇
冢
0.348D Hθ ⫺0
冣
冤
5/3
⫺ σ 2⫺P ⫺ σ 2⫺T
k 20 D 5/3 µ ⫺5/3 (H ) 2
L 5/3
⫺ 0.903
µ ⫺2 (H ) L2
冥
(155)
For changes in zenith angle, when the beacon is kept at the same altitude, it is clear from the variation of each term in brackets that the zenith dependence is simply sec(ξ). The effect of turbulence above the beacon is obtained by modifying the standard results for piston or piston- and tilt-removed phase variance. The phase variance with piston removed is σ
2 ⫹PR
冢冣
D ⫽ 1.033 ⫹ r0
5/3
(156)
where the coherence diameter looking up from the beacon altitude is (r ⫹0 )⫺5/3 ⫽ 0.423 k 20 µ 0⫹
(157)
The expression for phase variance from turbulence above the beacon with piston and tilt removed is σ 2⫹PTR ⫽ 0.134
冢冣 D r ⫹0
5/3
(158)
The contribution due to the unsensed turbulence increases with increasing aperture size, and one will find that the beacon altitude must be increased for larger diameters in order to keep this distortion manageable. The total phase variance with piston removed is σ 2PR ⫽ σ 2⫺PR ⫹ σ 2⫹PR
(159)
The total phase variance with piston and tilt removed is σ 2PTR ⫽ σ 2⫺PTR ⫹ σ 2⫹PTR
(160)
In Fig. 7 the total, piston-removed, and piston- and tilt-removed phase variances due to turbulence below the beacon are plotted for a single beacon operating with a 60-cm-diameter aperture with the HV-21 turbulence model. In Fig. 8 the
Copyright 2000 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
106
Sasiela and Shelton
piston-removed, and piston- and tilt-removed phase variances of the entire atmosphere are plotted for the same conditions.
K. Focal Anisoplanatism for Distributed Sources The artificial beacon source is adequately approximated by a point source for very distant beacons. This, however, is a poor approximation for some closer beacons. In trying to use resonant sodium backscatter from the sodium layer at about 90 km, one wants to project as large a beacon as possible that does not significantly increase the phase variance over that of a point source. A large beacon is desirable because the return from a given area saturates at a certain power. To increase the return signal not only must the beacon power be increased but the focused spot size must be increased. The expression for the phase variance for a distributed source centered on the aperture with piston and tilt present can be found from Eq. (143) by setting bជ equal to zero to obtain, for D s /D ⬍ 1, σ 2⫺d ⫽ 1.303 k 20
冮
L
dz C 2n (z)
0
冦
⫻ 1⫺8
冮
∞
dκ κ ⫺8/3
0
J1 (κ D s z/2L) J1 (κDz/2L) κ D s z/2L
κDz/2L
冤
⫹ 2
J1 (κ D s z/2L) κ D s z/2L
冥冧 2
(161)
Use Mellin transform techniques to evaluate the integral and obtain σ
2 ⫺d
冢
0.348D ⫽ Lθ 0⫺ ⫻
冣
5/3
(162)
冤 F 冤⫺ / , ⫺ / ; 2; 冢 D 冣 冥 ⫺ 0.872 冢 D 冣 冥, 2
1
5
11
6
Ds
2
Ds
5/3
Ds
6
D
⬍1
The first few terms of this solution are σ 2⫺d ⬇
冢
0.348D Lθ ⫺0
冣 冤 5/3
冢 冣 冢 冣 Ds
1 ⫺ 0.872
⫺ 0.0177
D
Ds D
4
5/3
⫹ 0.764
冢 冣 冢 冣冥
⫺ 0.000287
Ds
2
D
Ds
6
(163)
D
The first three terms in brackets give a good approximation to the phase variance when D s /D ⬍ 1.
Copyright 2000 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
Guide Star System Considerations
107
Figure 7 Phase variance of turbulence below the beacon. The total, piston-removed, and tilt- and piston-removed phase variances are plotted.
Figure 8 Piston-removed phase variance and piston- and tilt-removed phase variance caused by turbulence of the entire atmosphere.
Copyright 2000 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
108
Sasiela and Shelton
When D s /D ⬎ 1, the variance is σ
2 ⫺d
⫽
冢
0.348D s Hθ
⫺ 0
冣 冦 5/3
冤
冢 冣 冥冧
D ⫺0.128 ⫹ 2 F1 ⫺ /6 , ⫺ /6 ; 2; Ds 5
11
2
,
Ds D
⬎1
(164)
The first few terms of this solution are σ
2 ⫺d
⬇
冢
0.348D s Lθ 0⫺
冣 冤 5/3
冢 冣 冢 冣
D 0.872 ⫹ 0.764 Ds
D ⫺ 0.0177 Ds
4
2
冢 冣冥
D ⫺ 0.000287 Ds
6
(165)
The normalized variance is plotted in Fig. 9. Initially, the phase variance caused by the turbulence below the beacon decreases as source size increases, then it increases. L. Focal Anisoplanatism for Offset Sources The beacon may not be placed in the exact location that the correction is wanted, resulting in a decreased Strehl ratio. This misplacement can be caused by errors in positioning the beacon and in knowing which direction to point the beacon. If a laser beam is to be projected in the point-ahead direction, which is typically
Figure 9 Phase variance below the beacon. Effect of beacon diameter on the phase variance due to focal anisoplanatism normalized to the phase variance due to focal anisoplanatism from a point source with piston and tilt present.
Copyright 2000 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
Guide Star System Considerations
109
about 50 µrad, there is an error in pointing the mirrors due to tilt anisoplanatism. This error can be as much as a microradian. The phase variance with a point source offset from the origin is obtained by setting the source diameter equal to zero in Eq. (161). After performing the angular integration one obtains σ 2⫺0 ⫽ 1.303 k 20
冮
冤
L
dz C 2n (z)
0
⫻2 1⫺
冮
∞
dκ κ ⫺11/3
0
2 J1 (κDz/2L) κ Dz/2L
J0
(166)
冢 冣冥 κbz L
For this case, phase variance from turbulence below the beacon is σ
2 ⫺0
⫽ 0.5 k µ 2 0
⫺ 5/3
冢冣 冤 D L
5/3
冢 冣冥
2b 2 F1 ⫺ /6 , ⫺ /6 ; 1; D 5
11
2
2b ⬍1 D
,
(167)
The variance normalized to that of an on-axis source is σ 2⫺0 σ 2⫺0 (b ⫽ 0)
冤
冢 冣冥 冢冣 冢冣 2b D
⫽ 2 F1 ⫺5/6 , ⫺11/6 ; 1; 2
b ⫽ 1 ⫹ 6.12 D
2
b ⫺ 0.848 D
(168)
4
2b ⬍1 D
⫹ ⋅ ⋅ ⋅,
When the displacement is zero, the hypergeometric function is equal to unity, and one obtains the previous result: σ (b ⫽ 0) ⫽ 0.5 k µ 2 ⫺0
2 0
⫺ 5/3
冢冣 D L
5/3
(169)
When the displacement is larger than the radius, the variance normalized to that with no offset is σ 2⫺0 σ 2⫺0 (b ⫽ 0)
⫽ 1.836
冢 冣 冤 2b D
5/3
5 5 2 F1 ⫺ /6 , ⫺ /6 ; 2;
冢 冣冥 D 2b
2
,
2b ⬎1 D
(170)
This is plotted in Fig. 10. For larger source displacements than those plotted, one can use the approximation σ 2⫺0
冢 冣
2b ⬇ 1.836 2 σ ⫺0 (b ⫽ 0) D
5/3
,
2b ⬎3 D
Copyright 2000 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
(171)
110
Sasiela and Shelton
Figure 10 Total phase variance below the beacon for focal anisoplanatism with a displaced point source. The variance is normalized to that of a source on axis. Piston and tilt are present. It is plotted versus twice the displacement divided by the aperture diameter.
The phase variances in this and the last sections can be used to determine the importance of beacon size and placement; however, the piston and tilt terms are included. The evaluation of the integrals to determine the phase variance with these components removed is complicated and lengthy and is not given here.
VII. ANALYSIS OF A MULTIBEACON SYSTEM If an astronomical source is very bright, one can use part of the light coming from the object in a wavefront sensor to measure the phase gradient due to turbulence. The wavefront can be reconstructed, and the distortions can be corrected with a deformable mirror. Unfortunately, the sky is not populated with a sufficient number of bright objects to be able to correct much of the visible sky. To overcome this limitation, one can use synthetic beacons produced by projected laser beams. They can be located at any angular position in the sky and can, therefore, provide a means to get a corrected image of dim objects. The errors made in correcting the turbulence with one or more synthetic beacons are analyzed. The approach differs from previously published results [Thompson and Gardner, 1987, 1989; Foy and Tallon, 1989; Gardner et al., 1989,
Copyright 2000 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
Guide Star System Considerations
111
1990; Welsh and Gardner, 1989a, b; Welsh et al., 1989; Welsh and Thompson, 1991] in that analytic expressions are obtained for the phase variances. The results are expressed as a function of aperture diameter, turbulence moments, zenith angle, operating wavelength, and beacon height. Results for a different system configuration are obtained by simply changing the parameters in analytic expressions. Much of the analysis presented here is taken from Sasiela [1994b]. Parenti and Sasiela [1994], Gavel et al. [1994], Esposito et al. [1996], and Stroud [1996] contain more recent analysis using some of the ideas presented here. The single beacon results can be extended to a multibeacon system. With several beacons, each beacon may be used to correct the phase over a portion of the aperture, thus reducing the isoplanatic error. However, since the wavefront sensor measures phase gradient, not actual phase, the phase surface reconstructed from the phase gradients under each beacon must be ‘‘stitched’’ with the other phases. Errors are introduced into this process because of the incomplete knowledge of the overall tilt in each section of the aperture. This error comes from two sources; the turbulence-induced tilt is incorrectly measured in each section due to focal anisoplanatism, and the measurement of the relative position of the beacons has an error due to anisoplanatic effects. The magnitude of each error is calculated and a least-squares estimate of the error in putting together the phases of the individual sections is calculated. The multibeacon analysis is performed for point source beacons. The model used to calculate the phase variance assumes that it is composed of two major parts as shown in Fig. 11. The first part is the focal anisoplanatic error which, of itself, has the phase variance due to the unsensed turbulence above the beacons, plus the error made in sensing the turbulence below the beacons. If there were only one beacon, the sum of these two errors with piston and tilt removed would give the total phase variance with piston and tilt removed. For the case of more than one beacon, there is a tilt error made in measuring the turbulence below the beacons that can be different for each section. These tilt errors combine in the stitching operation of putting together the phases of each
Figure 11 Contributions to the phase variance of a multibeacon system include focal anisoplanatism below the beacon, unmeasured turbulence above the beacon, and errors in determining the relative positions of the beacons.
Copyright 2000 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
112
Sasiela and Shelton
section to increase the error. The tilt error is composed of two parts: the first is due to the tilt difference between the collimated beam and the focused beacon beam. The second is due to the misplacement of the beacons above the center of each section. It will be assumed that the relative beacon positions are measured with the full aperture of the receiver. Because the ray paths through the atmosphere are different for the various beacons, there will be a measurement error associated with the evaluation of the relative beacon positions. Both tilt jitters are stitched together to obtain the phase profile across the entire aperture. Each component mentioned above is evaluated separately using Mellin transform techniques combined with the use of the appropriate filter functions. Analytic expressions were found for the components of the focal anisoplanatism with piston and tilt removed above and below the beacon altitude in Sec. VI. The tilt components below the beacon, also evaluated in Sec. VI, are used in the stitching analysis. It is assumed in this analysis that the sections are circular in order to get analytic expressions for the results. In actuality, the butted sections are square on some sides. The error resulting from this assumption should be small. Next, the error made in measuring the beacon position will be shown to be equivalent to finding the tilt anisoplanatism of focused beams. An analytic expression for this tilt error will be found, and it is shown that it is considerably less than tilt error due to focal anisoplanatism. To stitch the individual sections together, a least-squares estimation procedure is used. This approach is similar to that of stitching together tilt errors measured in a wavefront sensor in an adaptive-optics system to obtain the phase profile [Herrmann, 1980]. The difference in this case is that the tilts can be correlated; this modifies the formula for the error. Expressions for the correlation coefficients of the focal anisoplanatic tilts are derived. From these correlation coefficients, the error propagator for stitching of the tilts is found. The error propagator is the multiplier of tilt phase variance whose product gives the phase variance of the stitching process. Finally, the phase variances due to focal anisoplanatism and stitching are added to get the total phase variance. This computation is performed for various altitudes. The results are in good agreement with the results obtained by ray tracing. A. Beacon Position Measurement Error If more than one beacon is used, the tilt of individual sections must be measured. Errors in the measurement are important because the tilt component of turbulence is 87% of the turbulence-induced phase variance with piston excluded. There are
Copyright 2000 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
Guide Star System Considerations
113
two errors in measuring tilt. The first arises from the difference in ray paths between a collimated and focused beam. This was calculated in Sec. VI. The other is due to the beacons not being directly over the center of the sections. Here, it will be assumed that the beacons are projected up into the sky by some system, and their relative positions are measured by the full aperture of the system. Because of the difference in paths between the measurement rays through the turbulence, there will be a measurement error in the apparent relative position of the beacons. The variance of tilt difference between focused displaced rays whose focus points are separated in space by bជ is found by using Eq. (20) with diffraction neglected and with the filter function for tilt of a ray focused at z ⫽ L given by
冮
T 2Z ⫽ 0.2073 k 20 ⫻
冢
L
冢 冣 冣 冤 冦 冧冥 16 k0 D
dz C 2n (z) ∫ dκជ κ ⫺11/3
0
J2 (κ D[1 ⫺ z/L]/2) κD[1 ⫺ z/L]/2
2
2
(172)
bជz 2 1 ⫺ cos κជ ⋅ L
The tilt variance is evaluated using Mellin transform techniques to give T 2Z ⬇
10.68 D 1/3 ⫻
冮
zt
dz C 2n (z)
0
冤冢 冣 冢 冣 bz DL
2
⫺ 1.472 ⫹
12.16 D 1/3
冮
L
zt
⫺1/3
⫺7/3
冢 冣冢 冣 冢 冣 冢 冣 冢 冣冢 冣 冥 冤冢 冣 冢 冣冢 冣 冢 冣冢 冣 冢 冣 冢 冣 冢 冣 冢 冣冥
1⫺
z L
bz DL
⫺ 2.067
14/3
dz C 2n (z)
1⫺
z L
1⫺
z L
bz DL
1⫺
⫺3
⫹ 0.339
5/3
⫺ 0.6657
DL ⫺ 0.00308 bz
⫺ 3.06 ⫻ 10
⫺6
⫺ 6.15 ⫻ 10⫺6
Copyright 2000 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
4
7/3
DL bz
DL bz
z L
6
bz DL
1⫺
DL bz
z 1⫺ L 13/3
z L
1/3
1⫺
4
z 1⫺ L
19/3
1⫺
z L
6
8
⫺13/3
z L
2
(173)
114
Sasiela and Shelton
Figure 12 Jitter variance caused by turbulence below the beacon resulting from focal anisoplanatism for a 60-cm aperture with 30-cm beacon spacing at 0.5-µm wavelengths for HV-21 turbulence.
The transition altitude between the low- and high-altitude solutions is zt ⫽
L b/D ⫹ 1
(174)
Tilt variances are converted to phase variances by multiplying by (k 0 D/4) 2. The tilt variance due to this effect is less than one-third that due to the tilt component of focal anisoplanatism. The smaller effect results from the low weighting given to turbulence-induced tilts close to the beacon altitude for this problem compared to the almost unity weighting of the difference in tilt between focused and collimated beams. Therefore, it will be neglected, thereby simplifying the analysis. It was assumed in the analysis that the beacon positions were measured with the full aperture. If a smaller aperture is used or other sources of jitter are introduced, the error in estimating the position of the beacons can be considerably larger. In Figs. 12 and 13, the phase variances of the tilt component of focal anisoplanatism are plotted for 30-cm and 2-m sections of the aperture for Hufnagel-Valley 21 turbulence with the system operating at 0.5-µm wavelength. B. Correlation Function of the Tilt Component of Focal Anisoplanatism In calculating the error in stitching together the tilt errors of the individual sections, the correlation of the tilt is very important in determining the resulting tiltremoved phase variance. For instance, Fig. 14 shows the results from stitching together perfectly correlated one-dimensional tilts and tilts that are partially correlated. The figure error is the phase with piston and tilt removed. In the perfectly correlated case, the resultant phase is composed solely of
Copyright 2000 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
Guide Star System Considerations
115
Figure 13 Jitter variance caused by turbulence below the beacon resulting from focal anisoplanatism for a 4-m aperture with 2-m beacon spacing at 0.5-µm wavelength for HV-21 turbulence.
tilt, and the tilt-removed variance is zero. The correlation function of parallel components of tilt is a function of the displacement angle with respect to the tilt. The correlation function versus angle is calculated in Sasiela [1994b] and plotted in Fig. 16 for parallel, perpendicular, and 45° displacements. The perpendicular components of tilt are also correlated in certain directions. There is no correlation if the displacement is parallel to either tilt component. The correlation function for a displacement 45° to the tilt is plotted in Fig. 17. C.
Stitching Model and Results
Using the correlation functions that were found, one can find the error propagator for the tilt stitching process. A model of an aperture with four beacons is given
Figure 14 Stitching difference between correlated and uncorrelated tilts.
Copyright 2000 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
116
Sasiela and Shelton
Figure 15
Aperture model for stitching.
in Fig. 15. The circled numbers are phase values in the center of the nine subapertures. The eight tilts with arrows are measured in each of the four subapertures. The measurement model has the gradient, m, equal to a matrix multiplying the N phase points plus a measurement noise, n g , in the tilts given by m ⫽ Aφ ⫹ n g
(175)
It is assumed that the signal-to-noise ratio is infinite, and the measurement noise is due to the phase-variance error incurred in propagating through turbulence. Each gradient is the average of the difference of the four phase points around that gradient, and is given by
Figure 16 Correlation function for parallel components of tilt in which the displacement is parallel, perpendicular, and at 45° to the tilt.
Copyright 2000 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
Guide Star System Considerations
117
Figure 17 Correlation function for perpendicular components of tilt in which the displacement is 45° to the tilt.
A ⫽ 0.5
⫺1
1
0
⫺1
1
0
0
0
0
0
⫺1
1
0
⫺1
1
0
0
0
0
0
0
⫺1
1
0
⫺1
1
0
0
0
0
0
⫺1
1
0
⫺1
⫺1
0
1
1
0
0
0
0
0
1
0
0
0
0
0
1
1
0
0
1
1
⫺1 ⫺1
0 0
0
0
0
0
0
⫺1 ⫺1 0
⫺1 ⫺1
⫺1 1
(176)
The noise correlation matrix of the gradients is C n ⫽ 〈n gn Tg 〉
(177)
and is explicitly equal to
Cn ⫽
1
i
p q
i
1 q
0 0 0
p 0 0
r
r 0
p q
1
i
0
r
0 0
q p
i
1
r
0
0 0
0 0
0
r
1
i
p q
0 0
r
0
i
1
q p
0
r
0
0 p q
1
i
r
0 0
0 q p
i
1
Copyright 2000 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
(178)
118
Sasiela and Shelton
Figure 18 Figure variance of a 60-cm aperture with four beacons at various altitudes for the HV-21 turbulence model at 0.5-µm wavelength.
where the correlation values i ⫽ 0.558, p ⫽ 0.778, q ⫽ 0.594, and r ⫽ 0.109 are taken from Fig. 16 and 17. The least-squares solution for the phase is ⫹ T ⫺1 φ˜ ⫽ (A T C ⫺1 n A) A C n m ⫽ Lm
(179)
where the superscript ⫹ denotes the generalized inverse. A generalized inverse is required because the matrix has some singular values. It is easy to show that the least-squared phase has zero piston. The tilt- and piston-removed phase is ⫹ T ⫺1 φ˜ TPR ⫽ Λ(A T C ⫺1 n A) A C n m ⫽ ΛLm
(180)
L is the tilt removal matrix that is a combination of x- and y-tilt removal given by Λ ⫽ 1 ⫺ t Tx t x ⫺ t Ty t y
(181)
where t x ⫽ 0.5[⫺1 0 1
⫺1 0 1
⫺1 0 1]
(182)
1 1 1]
(183)
and t y ⫽ 0.5[⫺1 ⫺1 ⫺1
0 0 0
The error in the estimate can be shown to be Error ⫽ LC n LT
(184)
and the error propagator, which is the fraction of the tilt error appearing in the stitched phase, is
Copyright 2000 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
Guide Star System Considerations
119
Figure 19 Figure variance of a 4-m aperture with four beacons at various altitudes for the HV-21 turbulence model at 0.5-µm wavelength.
E⫽
1 ⫹ T Trace[Λ(AT C ⫺1 n A) ⌳ ] N
(185)
The error propagator with four beacons is 0.426, which means that less than half the phase variance due to tilt jitter is effective in causing a figure variance of the stitched beam. The error propagator is 0.465 and 0.957 for 9- and 16-beacon systems, respectively. Setting the correlation function of perpendicular components of tilt to zero changes the error propagator by only a few percent. The performance of the system can be calculated from the above result and Eqs. (155), (151) and (158). The total piston- and tilt-removed phase variance is σ 2 ⫽ σ 2PTR ⫹ Eσ 2⫺T
(186)
The diameter of a section rather than the aperture diameter has to be inserted into the expression for σ 2⫺PTR . The performances of a four-beacon 0.6-m and 4-m system operating in the visible at 0.5-µm wavelength at zenith and at 45° off zenith is found and plotted for various altitudes in Fig. 18 and in Fig. 19, respectively.
REFERENCES Butts, R. R., Spectra of Turbulence Induced Wavefront Aberrations, AFWL-TR-80-107 (Air Force Weapons Laboratory, 1980). Esposito, S., Riccardi, A., Ragazzoni, R., Focus anisoplanatism effects on tip-tilt compensation for adaptive-optics with use of a sodium laser beacon as a tracking reference, J. Opt. Soc. Am. A, 13, (1996), 1916–1923.
Copyright 2000 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
120
Sasiela and Shelton
Fields, D. A., High frequency behavior of the tilt spectrum of atmospheric turbulence, Appl. Opt., 22, (1983), 645–647. Foy R., Tallon M., ATLAS Experiment to Test the Laser Probe Technique for Wavefront Measurements, SPIE, vol. 1114, Active Telescope Systems (1989). Frehlich, R., Laser Scintillation Measurements of the Temperature Spectrum in the Atmospheric Surface Layer, Journal of the Atmospheric Sciences, 49, (1992), 1494– 1509. Fried, D. L., Aperture Averaging of Scintillation, J. Opt. Soc. Am., 57, (1967), 169–175. Fugate, R. Q., Fried, D. L., Ameer, G. A., Boeke, B. R., Browne, S. L., Roberts, P. H., Ruane, R. E., Tyler, G. A., Wopat, L. M., Measurement of atmospheric distortion using scattered light from a laser guide star, Nature, 353, (1991), 144–146. Gardner C. S., Welsh B. M., Thompson L. A., ‘‘Sodium Laser Guide Star Technique for Adaptive Imaging in Astronomy,’’ SPIE, vol. 1114, Active Telescope Systems (1989). Gardner, C. S., Welsh, B. M., Thompson, L. A., Design and Performance Analysis of Adaptive Optical Telescopes Using Laser Guide Stars, Proc. IEEE, 78, (1990), 1721–1743. Gavel, D. T., Morris, J. R., Vernon, R. G., Systematic design and analysis of laser-guidestar adaptive-optics systems for large telescopes, J. Opt. Soc. Am. A, 11, (1994), 914–924. Gradshteyn, I. S., Ryzhik, I. M., Table of Integrals, Series, and Products, Academic Press, New York, 1980. Greenwood, D. P., Tarazano, D. O., A Proposed Form for the Atmospheric Microtemperature Spatial Spectrum in the Input Range, RADC-TR-74-19 (ADA 776294/1GI) (Rome Air Development Center, 1974). Greenwood, D. P., Fried, D. F., Power spectra requirements for wave-front-compensative systems, J. Opt. Soc. Am., 66, (1976), 193–206. Greenwood, D. P., Bandwidth specifications for adaptive optics systems, J. Opt. Soc. Am., 67, (1977), 390–393. Gurvich, A. S., Time, N. S., Turovtseva, V. F., Turchin, V. F., Reconstruction of the temperature fluctuation spectrum of the atmosphere from optical measurements, Izvestiya, Atmospheric and Oceanic Physics, (1974). Herrmann, J., Least-Squares Wave Front Errors of Minimum Norm, J. Opt. Soc. Am. 70, (1980), 28–35. Hill, R. J., Clifford, S. F., Modified spectrum of atmospheric temperature fluctuations and its application to optical propagation, J. Opt. Soc. Am., 68, (1978), 892–899. Hogge, C. B., Butts, R. R., Frequency Spectra for the Geometric Representation of Wavefront Distortions Due to Atmospheric Turbulence, IEEE Trans. Antennas Propaga, AP-24, (1976), 144–154. Humphreys R. A., Primmerman C. A., Bradley L. C., Herrmann J., Atmospheric-Turbulence Measurements using a Synthetic Beacon in the Mesospheric Sodium Layer, Optics Letters, 16, 1991, 1367–1369. Ishimaru, A., Fluctuations of a beam wave propagating through a locally homogeneous medium, Radio Sci., 4, (1969), 293–305. Marichev, O. I., Integral Transforms of Higher Transcendental Functions, Ellis Horwood Limited, Chichester, England, 1983.
Copyright 2000 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
Guide Star System Considerations
121
Murphy, D. V., Primmerman, C. A., Zollars, B. G., Barclay, H. T., Experimental Demonstration of Atmospheric Compensation Using Multiple Synthetic Beacons, Opt Lett, 15, (1991), 1797–1799. Noll, R. J., Zernike polynomials and atmospheric turbulence, J. Opt. Soc. Am., 3, (1976), 207–211. Parenti R. R., Sasiela R. J., Laser Guide-Star Systems for Astronomical Applications, J. Opt. Soc. Am. A, Special Issue on Atmospheric Compensation Technology, Vol. 11, No. 1, Jan 1994, 288–309. Primmerman, C. A., Murphy, D. V., Page, D. A., Zollars, B. G., Barclay, H. T., Compensation of Atmospheric Optical Distortion Using a Synthetic Beacon, Nature, (1991), 141–143. Range, R. M., Holomorphic Functions and Integral Representations in Several Complex Variables, Springer-Verlag, Berlin, Germany, 1986. Sasiela R. J., Shelton J. D., Mellin Transform Techniques Applied to Integral Evaluation: Taylor Series and Asymptotic Approximations, J. Math. Phys., 2572–2617, (1993a). Sasiela R. J., Shelton J. D., Transverse Spectral Filtering and Mellin Transform Techniques Applied to the Effect of Outer Scale on Tilt and Tilt Anisoplanatism, J. Opt. Soc. Am. A, 10, 646–660, (1993b). Sasiela, R. J., Electromagnetic Wave Propagation In Turbulence: A Mellin Transform Approach & other applications of Mellin transforms, Springer-Verlag, 1994a. Sasiela R. J., Wavefront correction using one or more synthetic beacons, J. Opt. Soc. Am. A, Special Issue on Atmospheric Compensation Technology, Vol.11, No. 1, Jan 1994b, 379–393. Slater, L. J., Generalized hypergeometric functions, Cambridge University Press, LondonNew York, 1966. Strohbehn, J. W., Laser Beam Propagation in the Atmosphere, Springer-Verlag, Berlin, 1978. Stroud, Philip A., Anisoplanatism in adaptive optics compensation of a focused beam with use of distributed beacons, J. Opt. Soc. Am. A, 14, (1996), 868–874. Tatarski, V. I., Wave Propagation In a Turbulent Medium, Dover Publications, Inc., New York, 1961. Tatarski, V. I., The Effects Of The Turbulent Atmosphere On Wave Propagation, U. S. Department Of Commerce, 1971. Thompson L. A. and C. S. Gardner, Experiments on Laser Guide Stars at Mauna Kea Observatory for Adaptive Imaging in Astronomy, Nature, vol. 328 (16 July 1987). Thompson L. A., Gardner C. S., Excimer Laser Guide Star Techniques for Adaptive Imaging in Astronomy, SPIE, vol. 1114, Active Telescope Systems (1989). Tyler, G. A., Turbulence-induced adaptive-optics performance degradation: evaluation in the time domain, J. Opt. Soc. Am. A, 1, (1984), 251–262. Tyler, G. A., The Power Spectrum for G-tilt and Z-tilt, tOSC Report No. TR-700 (the Optical Sciences Company, Placentia, California, 1986). Valley, G. C., Long- and short-term Strehl ratios for turbulence with finite inner and outer scales, Appl. Opt., 18, (1979), 984–987. Vaughn, J. L., Calculation of the Power Spectra of Z-tilt and G-tilt, tOSC Report No. TR710 (the Optical Sciences Company, Placentia, California, 1986).
Copyright 2000 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
122
Sasiela and Shelton
Walters, D. L., Favier, D. L., Hines, J. R., Vertical Path Atmospheric MTF Measurements, J. Opt. Soc. Am., 69, (1979), 828–837. Welsh B. M., Gardner C. S., Thompson L. A., Effects of Nonlinear Resonant Absorption on Sodium Laser Guide Stars, SPIE, vol. 1114, Active Telescope Systems (1989). Welsh B. M., Gardner C. S., Nonlinear Resonant Absorption Effects on the Design of Resonance Fluorescence Lidars and Laser Guide Stars, Applied Optics, Vol. 28, No. 19, (1 October 1989a). Welsh, B. M., Gardner, C. S., Performance Analysis of Adaptive-Optics Systems using Laser Guide Stars and Slope Sensors, J. Opt. Soc. Am., 6, (1989b), 1913–1923. Welsh, B. M., Thompson, L. A., Effects of Turbulence-Induced Anisoplanatism on the Imaging Performance of Adaptive-Astronomical Telescopes using Laser Guide Stars, J. Opt. Soc. Am. A, 8, (1991), 69–80. Winker, D. M., Effect of a finite outer scale on the Zernike decomposition of atmospheric optical turbulence, J. Opt. Soc. Am. A, 8, (1991), 1568–1573. Yura, H. T., Tavis, M. T., Centroid anisoplanatism, J. Opt. Soc. Am. A, 2, (1985), 765– 773.
Copyright 2000 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
4 Wavefront Sensors Joseph M. Geary University of Alabama in Huntsville, Huntsville, Alabama
I. INTRODUCTION The imagery obtained from ground or spaceborne optical telescopes systems depends upon the shape of the wavefront emerging from their exit pupils. There are both extrinsic and intrinsic factors influencing wavefront shape (such as medium and/or optical system induced aberration). An instrument which measures wavefront shape is called a wavefront sensor. Wavefront sensor measurements provide a single pass end-to-end diagnosis of an optical imaging system. The aberration content of the beam in the exit pupil is determined and expressed mathematically in terms of a polynomial. Such information provides a convenient means for calculating far-field behavior such as Strehl ratio, encircled energy, and modulation transfer function. A comparison can then be made between theoretical and empirical values of these parameters. This chapter provides information on various techniques employed by wavefront sensors, and how such sensors can be used in optical metrology.
II. DESCRIPTION OF WAVEFRONT Before discussing wavefront sensors it is appropriate to understand and define the subject of the measurement, i.e., the wavefront. As is known from shadow casting phenomena and the pinhole camera, light travels in straight lines. The pinhole camera also helps define what is meant by a ‘‘ray of light.’’ Consider a point source of light emitting rays in all directions. Next, consider the ensemble of rays having a certain optical path length (OPL):
Copyright 2000 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
124
Geary
Figure 1 Example of basic monochromatic wave structure propagating along a ray.
OPL ⫽ (length) ⫻ (refractive index)
(1)
The OPL is a radius in this case and the ray tips lie on the surface of a sphere (centered on the point source). This surface is a basic example of what is meant by a wavefront. (Note that rays and their associated wavefronts are always orthogonal to one another.) The wavefront is also called a phasefront. Light is an electromagnetic wave phenomenon. A ray can be thought of as the path along which the electric field strength, u, propagates in a sinusoidal manner with velocity c as described by Eq. (2) and illustrated in Fig. 1: u ⫽ u 0 sin φ ⫽ u 0 sin
冤2π(xλ⫺ ct)冥
(2)
The field amplitude u is cyclic. Phase φ refers to some point in this cycle. For example, when φ ⫽ 90°, u ⫽ u 0. In an optical system, the temporal variation of the electric field is generally ignored. Ray paths connect the object and image, and the phase variations along those paths can be considered ‘‘frozen-in.’’ What is of interest is the phase differences (or optical path difference, OPD) between different parts of the ray path or between different rays. Such phase differences are constant in time. Consider the two rays from the point source in Fig. 2. (Note: It is the nature of a point source that all rays leave the source having the same phase.) Along the ray path, the cyclic nature of light is indicated by the number of wavelengths that fit the OPL. At the surface of the wavefront, both rays have the same phase, φ0. If the point source is moved to infinity, then the wavefront observed will be flat. The rays (normal to this surface) will be parallel. (The parallel rays are said to form a collimated beam.) The spherical wavefront and flat wavefront are ideal constructions against which other wavefronts will be compared. In that context they will be called reference wavefronts.
Copyright 2000 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
Wavefront Sensors
125
Figure 2 Phase relationship between two rays.
III. INTERACTION OF WAVEFRONTS WITH OPTICAL SYSTEMS Consider the ideal system in Fig. 3. At the entrance pupil of the system is a diverging spherical wavefront centered on the object point. It is a surface of constant OPL. At the exit pupil of the system there is a collapsing or converging spherical wavefront centered on the image point. It too is a surface of constant OPL, not only with respect to the image point but also with respect to the object point as well. A perfect optical imaging system is such that the OPL from the object point through the system to the image point is the same for any ray path! Define an OPL on the axial ray between object and exit pupil, and let all other rays have this same OPL. Only a wavefront with a spherical surface can converge to a point. For an imperfect optical system these other rays do not terminate on the surface of a sphere (centered on the image point), hence no point image can be formed. This is illustrated in Fig. 4. There is still a wavefront. All the rays terminating on its surface have the same phase. But this wavefront surface is nonspherical. Such a wavefront is said to be aberrated. The image formed by the aberrated wavefront will be spread out in a tiny volume about the ideal image point and cause a loss in resolution.
Figure 3 Wavefront manipulation by a perfect optical imaging system.
Copyright 2000 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
126
Geary
Figure 4 Rays from a converging nonspherical wavefront cannot form a point image.
IV. WAVEFRONT DESCRIPTION An aberrated wavefront can be described by comparing it to the ideal spherical wavefront, which we will call the reference wavefront (1, 2). The reference wavefront is set up with its vertex tangent to the exit pupil and with its center of curvature coincident with the ideal image point. For each point in the exit pupil, we measure the optical path difference, W, between the spherical reference surface (SRS) and the aberrated wavefront (AWF) along the radius of the spherical reference surface. This is shown in Fig. 5. A function W(x,y) is obtained over the pupil, which is now used as a description of the aberrated wavefront. The OPD function W(x,y) can be cast in a mathematical form by a polynomial. This
Figure 5 Exit pupil aberration W(x,y).
Copyright 2000 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
Wavefront Sensors
127
is useful because each term in the polynomial describes a specific aberration and how much of it is present. Two sets of polynomials have traditionally been used to describe aberrations in the exit pupil. In optical design the Seidel polynomial (1) series is typically used. In optical testing the aberration content of a measured wavefront must be deciphered. The procedure commonly used is to fit the data with a Zernike polynomial (2).
V.
ACCESSIBLE MEASUREMENT PARAMETERS
Wavefronts cannot be perceived because it is light intensity rather than phase that interacts directly with matter. Detectors such as our eye respond to brightness levels, not to differences in optical path length. Detectors in wavefront sensors also respond to light level. However, this response is related to some kind of length measurement. Figure 6 shows an aberrated wavefront and associated reference sphere in the exit pupil of a perfect imaging system. Also indicated in the figure are the three physical parameters that are accessible for measurement: (a) the optical path difference, W(x,y); (b) the differential phase, dW(x,y), between adjacent sampling points in the pupil; (c) the transverse ray aberration, T. The equation relating local wavefront tilt in the pupil to T is (3).
冢冣
dW nr ⫽⫺ T dρ R
Figure 6 Physical parameters measurable by wavefront sensors.
Copyright 2000 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
(3)
128
Geary
Figure 7 (a) Local tilt as a function of sampling location in pupil; (b) reconstructed wavefront estimate.
where dW/dρ is local wavefront tilt, R is the radius of curvature of the reference sphere, n is the refractive index, and r is the radius of the pupil. Wavefront sensors estimate the overall shape of the phasefront from a finite number of discrete measurements. These measurements are usually made at uniform spatial intervals. If the wavefront sensor measures T, Eq. (3) can be used to find the local wavefront tilt. All this yields is the local wavefront tilt as a function of the transverse ray aberration defined at specific pupil locations. The situation is illustrated in Fig. 7a along a radius. Since the wavefront is really continuous, the local tilts must be stitched together so that a contiguous wavefront profile is generated as shown in Fig. 7b. This process is called wavefront reconstruction and generates an estimate of W(y). If the wavefront sensor measures the differential wavefront dW, we obtain the local incremental OPD as a function of pupil position, as illustrated in Fig. 8a. To get the wavefront W(y), these dWs are sequentially stacked as shown in Fig. 8b. VI. WAVEFRONT SENSOR A wavefront sensor (WFS) is an instrument used to obtain the OPD function W(x,y). A generic system consists of an optical head, detectors, electronics, com-
Copyright 2000 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
Wavefront Sensors
129
Figure 8 (a) Differential phase, dW, as a function of pupil location; (b) reconstructed wavefront estimate.
puter controlled data acquisition and storage, and a sophisticated analysis software program. The latter is used to fit the OPD data, make various calculations (e.g., far-field performance), and display data in graphical format. This section will examine four WFSs utilized by NASA on the Hubble space telescope project, each of which measures one of the three basic parameters discussed in Sec. V. The Hubble OTA generates an f/24 beam. Hence, the WFS will be viewing a nominal point source. For a comparison of the relative performance of the WFS discussed here (except for Sec. VI. A.2), the reader is referred to Ref. 4.
A.
Direct Wavefront Measurements
This section will examine WFSs which measure the pupil OPD W(x,y) directly. The basic data will be in the form of an interferogram generated by the interaction of two wavefronts: a reference wavefront and an object wavefront. Whenever two coherent wavefronts overlap, interference takes place. The generic expression for interference is given by (5) I ⫽ I1 ⫹ I2 ⫹ 2√I 1 I 2 cos Φ(x,y)
(4)
The shape of the fringe is defined by Φ(x,y). Each fringe in the interference pattern is a contour of constant OPD or W(x,y) ⫽ mλ, where m is a fringe order
Copyright 2000 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
130
Geary
Figure 9 (a) Structure of PDI plate; (b) principle of operation.
number and λ is the wavelength. Please note that Φ(x,y) ⫽ kW(x,y), where k ⫽ 2π/λ. 1. Point Diffraction Interferometer (PDI) Wavefront Sensor The heart of the PDI WFS is the PDI plate, which is a self-referencing interferometer (6). The PDI structure is illustrated in Fig. 9a. It is a monolithic device consisting of two concentric circles (thin-film coated onto a thin transparent substrate). The fat annular region is semitransparent and acts like a neutral density filter. The small inner circle (pinhole) is a clear diffraction aperture and plays a spatial filtering role. PDI operation is illustrated in Fig. 9b. The aberrated wavefront is focused onto the PDI disk. Most of the beam passes through unhindered except for a reduction in intensity. The tiny part of the beam interacting with the pinhole is diffracted into a clean spherical wavefront; i.e., it has become the reference wavefront. Immediately on the far side of the PDI, interference takes place between the aberrated main beam and the reference beam. As with any interferometer good fringe contrast occurs when the intensities of the two wavefronts are about equal. For the PDI this depends on the size of the diffraction core in the far-field pattern relative to the size of the pinhole. The diffraction core size depends on the F-number and the amount of aberration on the incident wavefront. This intensity balancing also comes into play when the PDI plate is translated axially or laterally (for focus and tilt fringes respectively). Fringe contrast will decrease as these translation distances increase. Figure 10 is an optical schematic of a PDI WFS used to measure the ESA Hubble simulator (OSL). The configuration is quite simple. It consists of a lens, the PDI plate, and a CCD. The lens in front of the PDI plate serves two functions.
Copyright 2000 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
Wavefront Sensors
131
Figure 10 PDI wavefront sensor configuration for convergent slow beam.
First, it decreases the F-number (f/#) of the incident beam (or increases speed) into the operational f/# mid-range of the PDI. Second, it forms an image of the pupil (of the optical system responsible for the converging beam) onto the recording medium. Because of its location ahead of the PDI, aberrations picked up within the ‘‘speed lens’’ will be added to those of the incident beam. This difficulty can be eliminated by designing a well-corrected speed lens so that inherent aberrations are negligible. A lower cost approach would involve use of an off-the-shelf component whose aberration content for the given F-number is measured. This speed lens aberration would be saved as an error file for later subtraction from the actual beam data. The fringe pattern recorded on the CCD is transferred via a frame-grabber to a PC where the fringe analysis software is in residence. A standard commercially available code was used for the system depicted in Fig. 10. The OPD data from the interferogram was fitted with a 36-term Zernike polynomial from which aberration content of the beam could be extracted. 2. Radial Shear Interferometer Wavefront Sensor The radial shear interferometer (4) (RSI) wavefront sensor is a modified MachZehnder interferometer (5) with afocal telescopes in each arm. One telescope expands the beam while the other compresses it, as shown in Fig. 11. (Obviously both telescopes must themselves be of high quality in order for this method to work properly.) Interference occurs in the region of overlap, as also indicated in
Copyright 2000 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
132
Figure 11
Geary
Radial shear interferometer. Insert shows resulting interferogram.
Fig. 11. If the variations in phase of the expanded beam over the region of the compressed beam footprint are insignificant (a tenth wave or less), then this subregion of the expanded beam can be considered a reference wavefront. Wiggles in the fringe pattern can then be attributed solely to phase variations in the compressed beam which are due to the incident wavefront, W(x, y). At the recording plane, the fringe pattern is coincident with a pupil image. The resulting interferograms can be analyzed to yield the structure of the wavefront W(x, y) over the pupil. An RSI WFS resides aboard the Hubble space telescope as a separate instrument inside each of the fine guidance sensors. This WFS is designated as the optical control subsystem (OCS). The fine guidance sensor proper is unaffected by the eight waves of spherical aberration from the primary mirror. Unfortunately, this is well outside the operational range of the OCS. COSTAR correction applies to the axial scientific instruments, not to the radial instruments such as the FGS. B. Indirect Wavefront Measurements This section examines wavefront sensor schemes that measure either the local slope, dW/dy (or dW/dx), or the differential wavefront, dW, as a function of pupil coordinates. Recall that the former provides information like that contained in Fig. 7a; the latter, like that contained in Fig. 8a. 1. Shack-Hartmann Wavefront Sensor The Shack-Hartmann WFS is a modification of the classical Hartmann test (typically used to test astronomical primaries) (7). The Hartmann test measures the
Copyright 2000 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
Wavefront Sensors
133
Figure 12 Principle of operation of Hartmann test: (a) flat wavefront incident on Hartmann plate; (b) aberrated wavefront incident on plate.
parameter T (transverse ray aberration), as discussed in Sec. V. A simple Hartmann test is illustrated in Fig. 12. In Fig. 12a a perfect (flat) wavefront is incident on a perfect lens. A small hole in a movable plate defines a position in the pupil where a ‘‘ray’’ of light is admitted. This ray proceeds to the paraxial focal plane and arrives dead center. Now suppose the wavefront is imperfect. The ‘‘ray’’ admitted by the hole plate strikes the paraxial plane off-center, as shown in Fig. 12b. The separation between this ray pierce and the optical axis is T. This is directly related to the local slope of the wavefront at the hole location in the pupil through Eq. (3). The ensemble of such measurements over the entire pupil will yield information from which the shape of the wavefront in the pupil can be reconstructed. A simplified schematic of the Shack-Hartmann technique is presented in Fig. 13. Instead of a single hole, the Shack-Hartmann plate contains an array of holes each with its own ‘‘perfect’’ little lens (8). Each lenslet is identical and serves the same function as in the single hole Hartmann configuration in Fig. 12. Each lenslet samples the local wavefront tilt at its particular location in the pupil. Associated with each lenslet is a position sensitive detector (PSD). The ‘‘ray’’ from each lenslet strikes its PSD with an offset, T, directly related to the local slope of the wavefront at the lenslet location. A Shack-Hartmann wavefront sensor is shown in Fig. 14. The focus of a collimating lens is made coincident with the focus of the test system having a certain f/#. The beam is collimated and transferred to a lenslet array. The collimating lens also images the system exit pupil onto the lenslet array. A relay lens reimages the array of focal spots formed
Copyright 2000 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
134
Figure 13
Geary
Principle of operation of Shack-Hartmann wavefront sensor.
by the lenslets onto a CCD. The CCD is segmented so that a subarray of pixels is associated with each lenslet. This subarray behaves as a PSD and measures the local T for a particular lenslet. Figure 15 shows a photograph of a ShackHartmann WFS (9). Goddard employed a Shack-Hartmann WFS from the Adaptive Optics Association (AOA) for use on the Hubble recovery program. It was used to validate COSTAR performance (10). 2. Lateral Shear Interferometer Wavefront Sensor Lateral Shear interferometer WFSs are based on lateral shear interferometry (7), the simplest example of which is provided by a parallel plate. This is illustrated
Figure 14
Shack-Hartmann wavefront sensor.
Copyright 2000 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
Wavefront Sensors
135
Figure 15 Photograph of an AOAShack-Hartman WFS.
in Fig. 16. A nominally collimated but aberrated beam is incident on a parallel plate. The two reflected beams are parallel but laterally shifted. In the region of overlap there is a lateral shear interference pattern. This pattern provides information on OPD differences (as per Fig. 8a) at a pupil location but only in the direction of shear. To reconstruct a wavefront, two patterns sheared in orthogonal directions are needed. Diffraction gratings (5) can also generate lateral shear interferograms. For example, when a focused beam falls on a grating, the outgoing power is divided
Copyright 2000 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
136
Geary
Figure 16 Lateral shear interferometry: (a) by reflection from parallel plate; (b) interferogram showing a defocused wavefront; (c) sheared profile pair.
among several diffracted orders, as illustrated in Fig. 17a. If the grating is at the focus of a following lens as per Fig. 17b, the various diverging cones are collimated. If we place an observation screen downstream of this lens, we see a number of overlapping circles of light. This is illustrated in Fig. 17c. In the overlap areas lateral shear interference fringes can be observed. An example of a lateral shear interferogram for an f/3.1 wavefront with 45 waves of spherical aberration using a Ronchi grating (55 lines per millimeter) is shown in Fig. 18 for three different axial positions near paraxial focus. A wavefront sensor based on lateral shear interferometry using a grating
Figure 17 (a) Diffracted orders from focused beam incident on a grating: (b) collimation of the diffracted orders; (c) overlapping orders in plane of observation.
Copyright 2000 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
Wavefront Sensors
137
Figure 18 Grating lateral shear interferograms for three axial positions for a spherically aberrated wavefront (11).
is illustrated in Fig. 19. The optical schematic in Fig. 19a shows a focused beam from a Hubble simulator being captured by an auxiliary optic which collimates the beam. This beam is directed to a grating which creates several collimated diffraction orders. These orders are collected by a focusing lens and imaged in the far field (as an array of focal spots). In the focal plane a spatial filter blocks all orders except the zero and ⫾first orders. These passed orders form a lateral shear interferogram (similar to those shown in Fig. 18) at a pupil image where a CCD records the fringe information. As with the parallel plate, sheared interferograms are needed in orthogonal directions in order to have enough information to reconstruct the wavefront. This can be obtained simultaneously by placing a ‘‘crossed’’ grating at the grating location in Fig. 19a and using a square spatial filter. A WFS breadboard based on this crossed grating idea was built by ITEK for potential use by the Goddard IVT on the Hubble project. It was called the RTSI (real time shearing interferometer). A photograph of the back end of the RTSI (from the crossed grating to the CCD) is shown in Fig. 19b. Figure 20 shows crossed grating (55 l/mm) lateral shear interferograms for the same input beam as in Fig. 18 at three axial positions.
VII. INTENSITY-BASED WAVEFRONT SENSING All of the wavefront sensors discussed thus far have involved measurements of W, dW, or T. The metric was a dimensional value expressed in waves, microns, or millimeters. The amount of light present in the system (expressed in terms of irradiance or intensity) was of little concern as long as there was enough signal. Wavefront sensing schemes will now be investigated where irradiance (or intensity) is the key ingredient of the measurement.
Copyright 2000 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
138
Geary
(a)
(b) Figure 19 Grating based lateral shear interferometer wavefront sensor: (a) optical schematic; (b) photograph of ITEK RTSI.
Copyright 2000 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
Wavefront Sensors
139
Figure 20 Crossed grating lateral shear interferograms.
A.
Axial Intensity
People with backgrounds in optics are familiar with the appearance of the star image lateral irradiance distribution in and around paraxial focus for a system with and without aberration. An example is the Airy pattern in Fig. 21. Its lateral profile is shown in Fig. 22a. Less familiar perhaps is the axial intensity distribution for this very same pattern shown in Fig. 22b (11).
Figure 21 Star image or Airy pattern for aberration less imaging system.
Copyright 2000 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
140
Geary
Figure 22
(a) Radial and (b) axial intensity profiles for a system with no aberration.
Figure 23 shows corresponding point spread functions at equal axial focus offsets on either side of the focal plane. Note the positions where the axial intensity of the point spread functions are zero. In the axial intensity plot in Fig. 22b, zero intensity occurs for a focal shift of one wave as measured in the exit pupil. Most readers are probably not very familiar with the behavior of axial intensity profiles in the presence of spherical aberration. Experimental work on axial intensity stems largely from the 1980s (12–14). Much of the work concerned the influence of spherical aberration. Although the axial intensity pattern in the presence of spherical aberration changes shape and shifts away from paraxial focus, it nonetheless remains symmetric. This fact was not lost on those who saw this as a potential metrology tool (14). The separation between the plane of symmetry and the paraxial focal plane is directly related to the amount of spherical aberration present through the equation δ ⫽ ⫺8(f/#) 2W 040
(5)
where δ is the axial offset, f/# is the F-number, and W040 is the spherical aberration coefficient as determined in the exit pupil. Figure 24a shows an experimental axial intensity plot for a system with significant spherical aberration. The F-number of the system is f/10.3. The operating wavelength is 0.6328 micron. The separation between the plane of symmetry and the paraxial focal plane is 3.07 mm. (Note: Paraxial focus is established by a separate axial intensity scan with a small aperture in the entrance pupil.) Using Eq. (5), we find that the amount of spherical aberration is 5.7 waves! Figure 24b shows a theoretical plot with the same amount of spherical aberration.
Copyright 2000 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
Wavefront Sensors
141
Figure 23 PSF images in different focal planes for system without aberration. (From M. Cagnet, M. Franzon, and J. C. Thierr, Atlas of Optical Phenomena, Springer-Verlag, New York, 1962.)
Recent work on axial intensity (15) shows promise of utilizing this technique in a wavefront sensing scheme. Reference 15 discusses measurement of coma and astigmatism as well as spherical aberration in systems with and without central obscurations using uniform and Gaussian pupil irradiance distributions. A possible wavefront sensing configuration is illustrated in Fig. 25. A nominally collimated but aberrated wavefront is incident on a high quality focusing lens. The star image pattern is examined with a microscope objective (40⫻– 60⫻). In the magnified image, the central irradiance is sampled by an optical fiber. The output end of the fiber is fed into a PMT/radiometer. The signal from the radiometer is fed into the Y-axis of an XY-recorder. Strictly speaking, one should move the optical fiber entrance face longitudinally to generate the axial intensity scan. Its axial motion would be monitored by a linear transducer whose
Copyright 2000 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
142
Geary
Figure 24 Axial intensity where W 040 ⫽ 5.7 waves: (a) experimental; (b) theoretical. (Courtesy Dr. Qian Gong).
signal would drive the X-axis of the XY-recorder. However, it is also possible to move the microscope objective axially over a much shorter range if the magnification changes at the fiber optic input face remain very small. Although axial intensity can pull out the magnitude of pure Seidel aberrations, it also shows promise of doing so for mixed aberrations. However, the angular orientation of the asymmetric aberrations in the pupil cannot be determined from the axial scan alone. Additional information of some sort is needed. Techniques for doing so are currently being explored.
Figure 25 Wavefront sensor configuration for measuring aberration content via axial intensity scans.
Copyright 2000 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
Wavefront Sensors
143
Figure 26 Measuring irradiance at equidistances on either side of paraxial focus.
B.
Curvature Sensor (16,17)
Consider the situation in Fig. 26. We have a flat wavefront incident upon a perfect lens. At equal distances on either side of the focal plane, irradiance measurements will be made. The distance from the focal plane is large enough so that diffraction effects can be neglected; i.e., geometric optics dominates. In these measurements planes there is a one-to-one correspondence with positions in the pupil; i.e., they are geometrically scaled versions of the pupil. As a consequence, the flat wavefront can be replaced with a rectilinear array of parallel rays which pierce the pupil on a uniform grid, as shown in Fig. 27. At the two measurement planes, the ray pierces will also be uniform, as shown in Fig. 28, and the density of ray pierces will be identical. If irradiance measurements were being made in these two planes, the values obtained would be the same. Irradiance profiles across a diameter for both planes is shown in Fig. 29. If the two profiles were subtracted the result would be zero. Now suppose that that some defocus (say some slight convergence) is introduced on the incident wavefront. The image point moves away from the focal plane and toward the lens, as shown in Fig. 30. Now the distribution of ray pierces in the pupil is still uniform (as per a Hartmann test). This is still true for both the measurement planes. However, the ray pierce density is no longer the same for both. The density is higher in the front measurement plane. This should be obvious because the same number of rays are distributed over a smaller area (but there is still a one-to-one correspondence with points in the pupil). Since the ray density is higher, so is the measured irradiance. The irradiance in the rear
Copyright 2000 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
144
Geary
Figure 27
Uniform grid of rays at entrance pupil.
measurement plane will be lower. The two irradiance profiles are illustrated in Fig. 31. When subtracted, the result is no longer zero. Defocus as described in the pupil is the parabolic function W ⫽ W020y 2
(6)
The first derivative yields a linear function: dW ⫽ 2W020y dy
Figure 28
Ray pierces at the equidistant image planes on either side of focus.
Copyright 2000 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
(7)
Wavefront Sensors
Figure 29 wavefront.
145
Irradiance profiles across beam footprints at the two image planes for flat
This is local wavefront tilt and is the quantity that a Hartmann sensor measures indirectly through T. Taking the second derivative yields a constant: d 2W ⫽ 2W 020 dy 2
(8)
As seen in Fig. 31, the irradiance difference is a constant. Hence, there is a relationship between the second derivative of the wavefront and the irradiance difference between two equally spaced measurement planes. This is the basis of a ‘‘curvature’’ wavefront sensor developed at Kitt Peak by Francois and Claude Roddier (16–18). In a simple breadboard experiment using the test arrangement of Fig. 26, the Roddiers have demonstrated the ability to measure spherical aberration (whose second derivative is parabolic). The dotted line in Fig. 32 is the theoretical
Figure 30 Effect of converging wavefront.
Copyright 2000 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
146
Geary
Figure 31 Irradiance profiles across beam footprints at the two image planes for convergent wavefront.
OPD profile in the pupil for 1.3 waves. The experimental curve extracted from the irradiance measurements in the two defocus planes is given by the solid line. The Roddiers are currently using this technique to obtain atmospheric wavefront behavior for ground-based astronomical telescopes. C. Phase Retrieval In 1977, Southwell (19) suggested that it should be possible to determine W(x,y) in the exit pupil by measuring irradiance in both the exit pupil and far field. The
Figure 32 Comparison of experimental and theoretical OPD plots for spherical aberration using curvature sensing.
Copyright 2000 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
Wavefront Sensors
147
idea is to make a guess as to the nature of the phase in the pupil. This guess is quantified by arbitrarily selecting values for the Zernike coefficients for a polynomial of N terms. This initial phase estimate coupled with the measured pupil irradiance is then taken to the far field via a wavefront propagation code. The computer calculated far field is then compared to the measured far field. On the first iteration, the two far fields will not look very much alike. So a change is made in the Zernike coefficients according to some protocol, and the whole process is repeated again and again. The point of this is to walk the calculated far field ever closer to the measured far field. When the match is reasonably close (by comparing things like the volume under the PSF out to the first dark diffraction ring) the process is terminated. This final set of selected Zernike coefficients is then taken to represent the real phase existing in the pupil. As you can appreciate, the measurement side of this technique is very simple. Two irradiance maps are required. Some optics and two CCD cameras provide this as illustrated in Fig. 33, but this is just the tip of the iceberg. Massive computer power and very clever and sophisticated software are needed. Phase retrieval is largely a mathematician’s game. The major concern with this wavefront sensing scheme is uniqueness (20– 22). Given a random phase perturbation, it has yet to be proven with mathematical rigor that a specific final set of Zernikes alone yields the correct far field. There might be other Zernike combinations that could provide a reasonably close approximation. Empirically, however, phase retrieval appears to yield good agreement with known calibrated input wavefronts within the limits of measurement error. This is best illustrated by example. An experiment (23) was set up to mimic the Hubble telescope. The same F-number was used along with the same central obscuration ratio (including spiders). The entrance pupil was illuminated with a truncated Gaussian (HeNe). Pupil aberrations were directly measured by two methods: axial intensity (Sec.
Figure 33 Generic optical scheme for capturing pupil and image irradiance data for phase retrieval.
Copyright 2000 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
148
Geary
Table 1 Image # 1 2 3 4
Focus offset (mm)
W 040
⫺0.62 0.64 4.45 5.72
5.59 5.52 5.42 5.54
VII.A) and point diffraction interferometry (Sec. VI.A.1). These yielded values for Seidel spherical aberration of 5.45 and 5.50 waves, respectively. Next, irradiance measurements were made both in the pupil and at a defocused image plane. This data was fed into the phase retrieval software. The retrieved Seidel spherical aberration at four defocus planes is presented in Table 1. As can be seen, these
Figure 34 Comparison between measured (left) and computed (right) far-field images at four defocus planes.
Copyright 2000 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
Wavefront Sensors
149
estimates of aberration using the phase retrieval method are in good agreement with the direct measurements. The phased retrieved information just obtained was then used (along with the pupil irradiance measurements) to predict imagery in the far field. This is shown in the right-hand side of Fig. 34. The left-hand side of Fig. 34 shows photographs of the far-field patterns obtained at the four separate image planes about paraxial focus. A comparison of the measured and computed defocused images shows good agreement between the two. Fledgling phase retrieval had been used on the Airborne Laser Lab project by the Air Force (24) and on studies of the battlefield environment by the Army (25). However, its biggest boost came with the Hubble’s troubles. Soon after launch, Hubble operators discovered that something had gone terribly wrong. Imagery was severely degraded. Having isolated the problem to the telescope’s primary mirror, Hubble scientists and engineers employed (and refined) phase retrieval techniques to determine what aberrations were causing the problem, how big they were, and w