A Terribly Wild Man-TEXT PAGES 22/12/01 7:01 AM Page i
A TERRIBLY WILD MAN
A Terribly Wild Man-TEXT PAGES 22/12/01 7:01 AM Page ii
Christine Halse has a life-long fascination with the social, cultural and psychological forces that shape identity, and has been immersed in the life and work of Ernest Gribble for more than ten years. An Associate Professor at the University of Western Sydney, Christine is married, revelling in life with her teenage daughter and currently working on a biography of a young woman with anorexia nervosa.
A Terribly Wild Man-TEXT PAGES 22/12/01 7:01 AM Page iii
A TERRIBLY WILD MAN
Christine Halse
A Terribly Wild Man-TEXT PAGES 22/12/01 7:01 AM Page iv
First published in 2002 Copyright © Christine Halse 2002 All rights reserved. No part of this book may be reproduced or transmitted in any form or by any means, electronic or mechanical, including photocopying, recording or by any information storage and retrieval system, without prior permission in writing from the publisher. The Australian Copyright Act 1968 (the Act) allows a maximum of one chapter or 10 per cent of this book, whichever is the greater, to be photocopied by any educational institution for its educational purposes provided that the educational institution (or body that administers it) has given a remuneration notice to Copyright Agency Limited (CAL) under the Act. Allen & Unwin 83 Alexander Street Crows Nest NSW 2065 Australia Phone: (61 2) 8425 0100 Fax: (61 2) 9906 2218 Email:
[email protected] Web: www.allenandunwin.com National Library of Australia Cataloguing-in-Publication entry: Halse, Christine. A terribly wild man. ISBN 1 86508 753 X. 1. Gribble, E. R. B. (Ernest Richard Bulmer), 1869–1957. 2. Church of England—Clergy—Biography. 3. Clergy—Australia—Biography. 4. Aborigines, Australia—Missions. I. Title. 283.42092 Index compiled by Russell Brooks Maps by Ian Faulkner Typeset in 11.5/15 pt Caslon by Midland Typesetters, Maryborough Printed by South Wind Productions, Singapore 10 9 8 7 6 5 4 3 2 1
A Terribly Wild Man-TEXT PAGES 22/12/01 7:01 AM Page v
For Martin and Sarah
A Terribly Wild Man-TEXT PAGES 22/12/01 7:01 AM Page vi
This page intentionally left blank
A Terribly Wild Man-TEXT PAGES 22/12/01 7:01 AM Page vii
C ONTENTS
Acknowledgements Introduction A note on language
ix xiii xv
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9
1 22 48 74 93 112 127 154 170
Mostly of tears Clasping their children tightly Porridge for every meal Horse-thieves and harlots When native fruits are ripe Dark deeds in a sunny land Ghosts crying in the dark A complete outsider Punishment place
Endnotes Sources and a select guide to reading Index
VII
193 205 209
A Terribly Wild Man-TEXT PAGES 22/12/01 7:01 AM Page viii
This page intentionally left blank
A Terribly Wild Man-TEXT PAGES 22/12/01 7:01 AM Page ix
A CKNOWLEDGEMENTS
M
any Aboriginal and non-Aboriginal people encouraged the writing of this book. They generously shared memories and stories about Ernest Gribble and mission life, and gave me permission to use papers and photographs in their possession. Many have since passed on. They are not identified in A Terribly Wild Man, in accordance with the custom of many Aboriginal communities, but the insights they provided into Ernest Gribble’s private world continue to help illuminate his public life. The account of Gribble’s life and work presented here may not correspond with the views of everyone or with the image of Gribble they would like to see portrayed for the public. It is hoped, however, that this account sheds light on the life of a man who had a profound impact on the lives of Aboriginal Australians and on Australian race relations. Special thanks are due to the people of Yarrabah, Oombulgurri (formerly Forrest River Mission) and Palm Island for their hospitality and kindness during my visits, and to the Australian Board of Missions (ABM) for granting permission to use material from its archives. A particular debt is owed to Joan Hunter, former ABM librarian, who first urged me to write Gribble’s biography. I would also like to thank the staff of the Mitchell Library and Sydney IX
A Terribly Wild Man-TEXT PAGES 22/12/01 7:01 AM Page x
X
A T E R R I B LY W I L D M A N
University Archives in Sydney; the Oxley Library and State Archives in Brisbane; the diocesan offices of the Anglican Church in Brisbane and Townsville; the Australian Institute of Aboriginal Studies in Canberra; the Battye Library and Departments of Aboriginal Affairs and Community Services in Western Australia; and Columbia University, New York, home of a valuable collection of early Australian anthropological publications. Noel Loos always believed that Gribble’s story was an important one that needed to be told and encouraged me from the start. Psychiatrist Sarah Mares provided invaluable help in understanding Gribble’s psychosocial profile. Doctors Michael Skinner and Judy Kirk shared their medical expertise to help diagnose Gribble’s ailments. Bishop Arthur Malcolm and his wife, Colleen, kindly arranged accommodation on Palm Island, and Bishop John Lewis’ generosity in allowing me access to the Townsville Diocesan Archives is greatly appreciated. Linda Lawson, from Koombal Park near Yarrabah, was both a guide and a mentor through Gribble’s years at Yarrabah. Susan Hunt and Dr Bill Louden provided friendship and moral support in Perth and when serendipity had us all living in North America at the same time. Duncan Waterson and George Parsons introduced me to Australian History at Macquarie University. The scholarship of Raymond Evans from the University of Queensland provided invaluable guidance during the PhD research on which this book is based. Henry Reynolds read an early version and urged Allen & Unwin to publish Gribble’s life, but the book would not have been written without the sustaining encouragement of publisher John Iremonger and the gentle but meticulous efforts of editor Emma Cotter. Permission to reproduce photographs from their collections was generously provided by Gwyn Gribble, Linda Lawson, the ABM, the Battye Library and the North Queensland Diocesan Archives. For their advice at different stages, I am grateful to Neil Baumgart, Geoffrey Bolton, the late Brian Dalton, Rob Dixon, Neville Green, Annette Hamilton, John Hay, Rob Hinxman for
A Terribly Wild Man-TEXT PAGES 22/12/01 7:01 AM Page xi
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS
XI
his knowledge of James Noble, Christopher Kelen, John Lewis, Dawn May, the late Stephen Shortus, Mary-Louise Slattery, Tom Stannage and Peter Yeend. Vicki Fox painstakingly formatted the book and relieved me of many administrative burdens during the final stages of production. Martin Debelle’s unfaltering forbearance and faith in the project was a precious, sustaining force, and my daughter Sarah’s patient acceptance of a life filled with ghosts from long ago has been both motivating and inspiring. As is custom and obligation, my deepest apologies to anyone who deserves acknowledgement but has inadvertently been omitted. Every effort has been made to ensure the accuracy of Ernest Gribble’s story—any errors of fact or interpretation are mine alone.
A Terribly Wild Man-TEXT PAGES 22/12/01 7:01 AM Page xii
This page intentionally left blank
A Terribly Wild Man-TEXT PAGES 22/12/01 7:01 AM Page xiii
I NTRODUCTION
T
he stale, pungent odour of musty paper eclipses my earliest memories of Ernest Gribble. Buried deep in the basement under the offices of the Australian Board of Missions (ABM), adjacent to the elegant forecourt of St Andrew’s Cathedral in Sydney, were fragile journals, aged letters, sepia photographs and stacks of records bundled together with tightly knotted red cord. Cemented by decades of dust, the personal papers of Ernest Gribble had been deposited and deserted. The gracious librarian with a canny eye for history asked hopefully: ‘Can you do something with this?’ Sifting through the disarray brought more questions than answers: Why would someone write six autobiographies? How could a solitary priest inflame such intense national and international controversy? Whose lives did he wound and heal? What happened in the years when the records abruptly ceased? Why were there so many contradictions and inconsistencies in the vast, chaotic collection? As the riddles unravelled so did the poignant, passionate themes of Australian history, and the consequences of combining noble intentions with human frailty in forging an identity in the blurred boundaries between culture and race. XIII
A Terribly Wild Man-TEXT PAGES 22/12/01 7:01 AM Page xiv
XIV
A T E R R I B LY W I L D M A N
Humanitarians are often naively portrayed as saints or sinners. The life and work of Ernest Gribble exposes the private traumas and secrets that haunted the public persona of a prominent humanitarian who challenged the moral conscience of white society. Gribble embodies both the virtues and sins of the past. In doing so, his life presents an opportunity to salvage perspective in the current historical debates about Aboriginal and nonAboriginal relations, and to mould a future framed by the hope of reconciliation, rather than the ruin of repression and retaliation.
A Terribly Wild Man-TEXT PAGES 22/12/01 7:01 AM Page xv
A
NOTE ON LANGUAGE
T
he word ‘Aboriginal’, rather than local terms like Murri or Koori, has been used because it best reflects the terminology used by the elderly Aboriginal people interviewed for the book to describe themselves and their ancestors. For the sake of brevity, ‘Anglican Church’ is used rather than the more correct but cumbersome ‘Church of England in Australia’. The spelling of Aboriginal names and words varies widely. For simplicity and consistency, the spelling that appears most frequently in the written sources has been adopted. In accordance with the practice of the day, and to make Gribble’s story easier to follow, several other naming conventions have been adopted. Gribble’s missions are described by their geographical location rather than their religious title, for example, ‘The Mission of St Michael and All Angels at Forrest River’ appears as ‘Forrest River Mission’. Ernest Gribble’s father, John Brown Gribble, is described by his nickname, ‘JB’ Gribble. Amelia, the name preferred by Gribble’s wife, is used rather than her birth name of Emilie, which she loathed.
XV
A Terribly Wild Man-TEXT PAGES 22/12/01 7:01 AM Page xvi
This page intentionally left blank
A Terribly Wild Man-TEXT PAGES 22/12/01 7:01 AM Page 1
1
M OSTLY
OF TEARS
E
rnest Richard Bulmer Gribble died on 18 October 1957, a month and five days before his 89th birthday. Wizened, wasted and worn out by life. He had been fond of historical parallels and would have liked the neatness of ending his life’s work where it had begun, in the Aboriginal community of Yarrabah, near Cairns on the Queensland coast. The wife of the mission Superintendent nursed him as he waited for death, and she later wrote to Gribble’s wife in Sydney, describing his final weeks: I think everyone at Yarrabah came to see him and knelt by his bed as if it was an altar. At one time about 50 young boys and youths passed through his room noiselessly bowed to him or kissed him softly and whispered ‘Good-night’ or ‘God bless you Dadda Gribble’. There couldn’t have been more reverence if it had been a church. Indeed it reminded me of the passing of the late King George VI in England and his subjects coming to pay homage . . . It would take pages to describe the grief and sorrow of Yarrabah and yet all were glad that his sorrows were over and knew of the glory awaiting him on the other side . . . It would have taken a Cathedral to hold all the people who came to his funeral mostly coloured people.1
The Reverend Ernest Gribble was laid to rest with full Anglican rites in the graveyard buried in the hills behind St Alban’s Church, Yarrabah, but in death, as in life, peace eluded him and 1
A Terribly Wild Man-TEXT PAGES 22/12/01 7:01 AM Page 2
2
A T E R R I B LY W I L D M A N
Gribble continued to inflame passion and controversy. Was he a kindly and conscientious man who tempered zeal with tact; or a reckless, tortured tyrant who ruled his remote kingdom with a Bible in one hand and a whip in another?2 Loved like a saviour and despised like the Devil, the enigma of Ernie Gribble lived on in the public mind. The legend of Ernie Gribble began soon after he was born. It was a well-worn fable that his parents plotted the future of their first born while he was still in the cradle: he would follow in his father’s footsteps and become an Anglican clergyman and missionary to the Australian Aborigines. The fact that John Brown (JB) Gribble was still a coalminer when Ernie was born in Geelong, Victoria, on 23 November 1868 was irrelevant. It was a family trait to spice up a story when spinning a yarn. In truth, the Gribble past, unlike its future, was unremarkable. The family sprang from solid, Cornish mining stock and escaped to Australia when JB was nine months old and barely old enough to justify the sacred bond he later imagined for ‘mother England’. His father found and quickly lost a fortune after the family settled in the disarray, ruined dreams and revolutionary fervour of the Victorian goldfields. JB, the youngest of the brood, was a voracious reader with a natural talent for turning a phrase. Later in life his writing would menace the soul of colonial society but in his youth the brutal necessity of surviving outweighed book-learning, and he followed generations of Gribbles by going down the coalmines young. JB’s spirit found liberation in his evangelical zeal. He was barely a teenager when he started honing his skills as a preacher on the street corners of Ballarat, and bailing up thirsty patrons outside pubs to harangue them to abandon the drink that would lead to perpetual hellfire, brimstone and damnation. JB grew into a tall, strikingly handsome man with a patrician profile, a thick mane of swarthy dark hair and a luxurious beard that swept down over his chest. He exuded a sensual, magnetic charisma that drew women to him and was almost indecent in a
A Terribly Wild Man-TEXT PAGES 22/12/01 7:01 AM Page 3
M O S T LY
OF
TEARS
3
Bathurst Island
TIMOR
SEA
DARWIN
Weipa
ARNHEM LAND
C A R P E N TA R I A
FORREST RIVER MISSION Vic
Marndoc Reserve
Broome
Fi
tzr
oy R
Fitzroy Crossing
Ord R
Moola Bulla Government Cattle Station
e
Victoria River Downs
Cairns Mareeba YARRABAH MISSION
R
Ord River Halls Creek
CORAL
MITCHELL RIVER Cooktown MISSION M Port Douglas it ll
Wyndham Turkey Creek
KIMBERLEY Derby
Great
Peninsula
ch
to
ria River
INDIAN
Cape York
GULF OF
Atherton
Innisfail
Palm Island Group
NORTHERN
Charters Towers
Bowen
Whitsunday Islands
Hughendon
G
E
Rockhampton
A T
QUEENSLAND
Nulla Nulla Station
AUSTRALIA
NEW
BRISBANE
Armidale
E
SYDNEY
N Jerilderie
VIC
Newcastle Gosford
G
WALES ADELAIDE
Goulburn
A
G R E AT A U S T R A L I A N BIGHT
Esperance
R
PERTH Freemantle
Fraser Island
SOUTH
Ceduna
OCEAN
V I D I N G D I
WESTERN
Geraldton
PA C I F I C
Hervey Bay Bundaberg
Carnarvon
SOUTH
Reef
Maryborough
R
Alice Springs
AUSTRALIA
SEA
Townsville
TERRITORY
Port Hedland
Barrier
Normanton
OCEAN
CANBERRA
Maryborough
Albany
SOUTHERN
OCEAN
Ballarat
Geelong
MELBOURNE
TA S M A N
AUSTRALIA 0
1000 km
BASS STRAIT
SEA
TA S HOBART
preacher. His weedy son did not inherit his manly, good looks. Even at his best, Ernie never managed to cast off the air of a skinny kid who never got quite enough food. There was a touch of his father’s nobililty in Ernie’s high forehead and aquiline nose but it was ruined by unnaturally heavy eyelids that gave him a misleading look of indolent self-indulgence. His eyes were what everyone remembered. They were the intense, icy, blue of a flawless Ceylonese sapphire. They penetrated your very core. There was little of his mother, Mary Ann (née Bulmer), in Ernie’s looks nor in his childhood, which was ruled by JB’s devotion to the noble Victorian icons of duty, family and work. Ernie’s first memory of his father was receiving a sound whipping, for JB’s dauntingly rigid puritanism would not tolerate human weakness or neglect of duty. Two foes menaced JB’s world and Ernie’s destiny. The first was the Church of Rome. According to JB the Pope was the Anti-Christ. At the age of ten, Ernie’s father
A Terribly Wild Man-TEXT PAGES 22/12/01 7:01 AM Page 4
4
A T E R R I B LY W I L D M A N
conscripted him into the Orange League and the Protestant fight against Roman Catholicism. The second peril in JB’s world was carnal desire. He was only twenty when he married the goodly Mary Ann and they had thirteen children—nine survived to adulthood—during their 25-year marriage, but JB lived his life in constant vigilance against women. He considered them temptresses who plotted to injure the spiritual life by stirring men to lust and sin. Young Ernie was nearly eight in 1876 when his father abandoned the coalmines to become a Methodist minister. JB’s flock was scattered between Melbourne and the New South Wales border, and Ernie’s childhood unfolded as a nomadic blur of rural settlements, homesteads and schools. Life was slightly more settled after JB left the Methodists and joined the Congregational Union of Victoria. Mary Ann and her young family set up house at Rutherglen on the Murray River, while JB spent much of his time traversing rural Victoria and New South Wales in a rickety horse and buggy, forming temperance societies and ministering to the souls of squatters and selectors. In nineteenth-century Australia religion was a pervasive presence that was both revered and disdained. The Anglican Church was the dominant faith and the Roman Catholics and Protestants battled it out for a distant second place. Most people pledged allegiance to one creed but the number of genuine faithful was less certain. Not infrequently, religion was merely the reason for Sunday socialising and a family lunch, the expected routine for commemorating births, deaths and marriages, and there the matter ended. Ernie got his first taste of the contradictory place of religion in the Australian psyche soon after he started school. A parson’s son was easy prey for the scorn and contempt of irreverent youths. The experiences during these formative years burned deeply, and even as an old man, Ernie recalled that his: little life was made miserable by the bigger boys putting me up on a stump and compelling me to preach a sermon before allowing me to proceed home after school hours. The sermon could hardly have
A Terribly Wild Man-TEXT PAGES 22/12/01 7:01 AM Page 5
M O S T LY
OF
TEARS
5
been called ‘dry’ for it consisted mostly of tears, until I was rescued by the girls and by them escorted home. No wonder I grew up with a distaste for the ministry, a distaste which took a very long time to disappear.3
JB worked hard to instil his own religious zeal in his eldest son and insisted on taking Ernie and his brother Arthur, younger by two years, on his trips around the countryside to minister to the faithful. It was their job to leap from the buggy and open the massive gates that guarded the properties of JB’s rural congregation. For the boys, these expeditions meant weeks of endless plains, scorching summer heat and rain, mud and boggy roads in winter. The experience battered their spirits and bruised their souls. At night, all Ernie could dream of was ‘gates and mud’.4 JB’s ministry lay amidst the sheep and parched, blond grasses of the Riverina plains of southern New South Wales in the upper reaches of the dominion ruled by Ned Kelly and his gang of bushrangers. In 1879, JB was the minister of Jerilderie when the Kelly gang laid siege to the sleepy, rural township. The exploits of the larrikin band were already legendary and wildly romanticised in popular wisdom and the collective imaginings of 11-year-old boys like Ernie: skilled horsemen, reckless rebels and courageous champions of the oppressed rural poor. The gang won the instant veneration of Ernie and his mates by taking their schoolmaster hostage. The children of Jerilderie spent their welcome burst of unexpected freedom ogling the gang as they put on a flamboyant show of talented horsemanship. JB did not share the children’s admiration. He considered the gang’s flagrant disrespect for authority, property and life inexcusable, and gave Ned Kelly a stern dressing-down for his ‘unmanly behaviour’. When the outlaw Steve Hart relieved JB of his pocket watch—on loan from the local watch maker—the spirited bush parson strode up to Kelly and demanded its return. The leader of the gang obliged. After all, Kelly said dismissively, the timepiece was a ‘bloody turnip’.5 For a long time afterwards, bushranging was the favourite game in the Jerilderie schoolyard and the role of Ned Kelly
A Terribly Wild Man-TEXT PAGES 22/12/01 7:01 AM Page 6
6
A T E R R I B LY W I L D M A N
was greatly coveted. Ernie never got to play the part of his cherished hero, and was always relegated to the pitiful role of the protesting parson whose second-rate watch was pinched by the daring renegade. It was in the same year, 1879, that JB announced he would forsake the comforts of the ‘civilised’ world and become a missionary to Aboriginals. He liked to attribute his evangelical commitment to a formative childhood experience when he got lost and was befriended by local Aboriginals, but a visit to Maloga mission, run by the renowned missionary Daniel Matthews, had fired his humanitarian zeal. Life as a missionary would mean sacrifices: quitting his job as a Congregational minister, forgoing a steady income and taking on the task with £5 in savings and five young children. JB weighed up the implications, searched his soul and decided to forge ahead, oblivious to the hardships and firm in his faith that the Lord would provide. Thus, Warangesda mission was born. It lay on the wide, muddy Murrumbidgee River, surrounded by sprawling sheep stations, eucalypts, kangaroos and endless skies. The local selectors quickly decided that JB was a bit mad: ‘he had blacks on the brain’.6 They shook their heads and mostly kept their distance. For Ernie, town life had been a distasteful period of disagreeable regulation and mortifying humiliation by schoolyard bullies. Warangesda could not be more different. He loved the space and the isolation. At last he was free. He and his younger brothers, Arthur and John, ran wild and unfettered in the open spaces and filled their days with endless, boyish adventures—exploring the crevices and she-oaks that lined the Murrumbidgee, fishing for Murray cod and shooting kangaroos so that Mary Ann could make kangaroo-tail soup, the mainstay of the family diet. The fun could not last forever. Within a month, Ernie’s father had organised his offspring into a well-disciplined army of labourers. JB was a stern task-master with an insatiable passion for work and complying with his orders was compulsory. The first task was to build a family home. Trees were felled by hand and the
A Terribly Wild Man-TEXT PAGES 22/12/01 7:01 AM Page 7
M O S T LY
OF
TEARS
7
children stripped them of bark before the sap dried so they could be placed upright and saplings nailed alongside to make slots for stacking the logs for the walls. A bark slab sufficed as a roof, held down with timber and tied with strips of untanned bullock skin, known as green-hide. The children replicated this lengthy process for each building on the mission: the school, huts for the married people and a dormitory for the Aboriginal girls. Ernie was still only a child and it was monotonous, back-breaking but gratifying work. This was the labour of men but he found satisfaction in the rewards of hard work well done, in watching a community materialise from the untamed landscape and in the fellowship of working alongside his father. Mesac Thomas, the first Anglican Bishop of Goulburn, visited Warangesda twelve months after it was established. He was moved by JB’s humanitarianism but horrified by the primitive conditions endured by the family and mission residents. If JB could see his way clear to take Holy Orders, Bishop Thomas proposed, he would take Warangesda into the Anglican fold and fund the mission. Poverty and pragmatism ruled. In 1880 and without relinquishing his evangelical zeal, JB was deaconed. He was ordained a priest three years later. Ernie later described Warangesda as one of the happiest times of his childhood. There was little space for feminine influences and the stoic Mary Ann, shackled by perpetual pregnancy and her precious brood, occupied a separate, domestic realm. Of Ernie’s sisters, Amy was seven years old and Ethel merely a newborn when the family moved to Warangesda. Evangeline arrived three years later, in 1881, but the others—Illa and Muriel (Stella)—were born in 1889 and 1890 and never knew the mission. JB shaped this phase of Ernie’s life. His was a world built around physical labour and male companionship, and JB leaned heavily on his first born for support and to lead the younger children. Sharing the toil and vision of Warangesda nurtured a new level of intimacy between father and son. The plight of Australia’s Indigenous peoples,
A Terribly Wild Man-TEXT PAGES 22/12/01 7:01 AM Page 8
8
A T E R R I B LY W I L D M A N
missionary methods and the need for reform dominated their conversations as they worked together by day. At night, in the haunting silence of the open plains, Ernie listened while JB read chapters of the Bible by the light of burning pine bark. As Warangesda developed, Ernie’s life settled into a predictable rhythm that became his idealised vision for all Aboriginal settlements. The Aboriginal and non-Aboriginal children mixed together freely. In the morning they worked around the mission. In the afternoon they attended lessons in the mission school. On weekends they worshipped and played together: hunting, building canoes and sharing meals of witchetty grubs. Ernie was the leader of the little group. In the sheltered isolation of an Aboriginal mission, he at last found a place where he was master of his domain. His bliss was shattered when an official inspection of Warangesda by the Aborigines Protection Board concluded that all the children were virtually illiterate. With this discovery, JB’s denominational switch proved timely. Supported by a scholarship for the sons of poor clergy, Ernie was promptly dispatched to boarding school. He spent 1882 at a preparatory school in Geelong, followed by two years at The King’s School, an Anglican boarding school for the sons of graziers housed on a comfortable rural spread at Parramatta on the outskirts of Sydney. Ernie did not want to go. The bush and Warangesda were the sanctuary that protected him from the unknown, uncontrollable forces of the outside world, and his inadequate, disrupted schooling had left him with little interest or enthusiasm for study. He knew his chances of winning academic accolades were slim, and he did not relish the prospect of failure. In a childish, petulant act of defiance, he blew up his new school hat with a box of Chinese crackers. Nevertheless, boarding school unfolded new vistas. For the first time Ernie stepped outside JB’s orbit and discovered a hopeful alternative to his father’s sterile evangelism. The King’s School was Anglo-Catholic in tenor and its spiritual life was a
A Terribly Wild Man-TEXT PAGES 22/12/01 7:01 AM Page 9
M O S T LY
OF
TEARS
9
vibrant spectacle of liturgy, processions and angelic, surpliced choirs. Regular ritual and methodical progression through the Anglican rites of passage provided Ernie with a predictable, comforting doctrine that liberated him from the tiresome obligation for individual fervour and biblical inspiration demanded by JB’s spiritual zeal. Ernie also discovered excitement in the sacrificial role of the priest. Here was God’s direct intermediary—an earthly surrogate for the Heavenly Father. Such omnipotent authority was awe inspiring, if somewhat sacrilegious, for a young lad and the puritanism that was his inheritance by birth and habit. The King’s School mimicked the ethos of Britain’s great public schools and tutored the sons of the establishment in the sacred canons of Victorian manliness: the importance of character, the virtue of service, the rewards of self-sacrifice and the worship of work, duty and earnestness. The first Headmaster, George Fairfowl Macarthur, was a former military chaplain and established the School Cadet Corps in Australia. This quasi-military organisation was designed to instil discipline, obedience, patriotism and submission to authority. All students at the King’s School were cadets. They vowed faithful service to the school, wore a military-style uniform, were tried by courts-martial for breaches of discipline and enjoyed regular sham battles conducted with the passion of a reallife conflict—except that they started with prayers, stopped for midday service and ended with a celebratory display of fireworks. Anglicanism and British imperialism were inextricably linked in Australia until well into the twentieth century. The Australian Anglican Church was legally tied in doctrine and worship to the Anglican Church in England until 1962, and the first Australianborn Archbishop was not elected until 1966. Any imperial celebration, like Empire Day or a coronation, was accompanied by a state service in an Anglican cathedral. In national crises, church leaders led the nation in vowing unswerving loyalty to their monarch and the Empire. Young Ernie found the union of imperialism and muscular Christianity both enticing and familiar. He had often heard his father proclaim his pride at being a ‘son of Britain,
A Terribly Wild Man-TEXT PAGES 22/12/01 7:01 AM Page 10
10
A T E R R I B LY W I L D M A N
that land which . . . is . . . the very centre of truth and righteousness’ and listened to him praise Britain’s soldiers going ‘forth . . . to death for their country’s good’.7 Ernie devoured the culture of The King’s School. The marriage of the sword and cross solidified his belief that battle was righteous, God was his ally, and victory was the reward for steadfastness of faith. The school’s military flavour captured his imagination and fired his spirit, and later he would resurrect and recast this element in other contexts. He marched proudly with the cadet band during Queen Victoria’s birthday parade and cheered wildly with the other boys when New South Wales announced it would send a contingent to fight the war in the Sudan. No-one knew where the Sudan was or why New South Wales needed to send its sons to die in such a remote, God-forsaken place. It did not matter. Scholastically, Ernie floundered. By his own admission he was a ‘gawky, countrified and backward’ student.8 His home was on the sportsfield. Ernie represented King’s in rugby and cricket and his athletic prowess saved him from being banished to the depths of the school hierarchy. Sport was the great social leveller. Ernie maintained an affectionate, distant association with his alma mater for the rest of his life. He was sixteen when he left The King’s School in 1885 and he knew what he wanted in life. His heart was set on joining the New South Wales Artillery, recently returned from its uneventful tour of duty in the Sudan. His parents had other ideas. JB and Mary Ann had carefully planned their son’s future, and part of their reason for sending him to boarding school had been to equip him to study for the priesthood. Ernie’s military dreams did not fit this scheme, so they enlisted the services of a close family friend and the then Premier of New South Wales, Sir Alexander Stuart, to end Ernie’s unfortunate streak of adolescent rebelliousness. Stuart’s brother was Bishop of Waiapu in New Zealand and the New South Wales Premier was also a devout Anglican committed to improving conditions for Aboriginals who had established the Aborigines Protection Board within a month of his election as Premier. Stuart
A Terribly Wild Man-TEXT PAGES 22/12/01 7:01 AM Page 11
M O S T LY
OF
TEARS
11
was assigned the task of persuading the recalcitrant son to change his mind. It was unfair to pit a formidable politician against the hopes of a vulnerable youth. Ernie reluctantly relinquished his yearning for a military career. Now he had no plans, no prospects and was bored. He spent the next six months in a ‘miserable’ limbo: moping about Sydney, and grumbling at the fates which had ordered that I should be the son of a Missionary to the blacks of Australia. I often wished that father had been a Missionary to some other race, for then one would have had some variety in life in a strange country.9
Meanwhile, a cloud had descended over Warangesda. A routine investigation by the New South Wales Aborigines Protection Board reported that the mission’s affairs were unsatisfactory and there were vague rumblings about financial muddles. JB decided it was time to make a fresh start and look for alternative work. In 1884, he left Mary Ann and the children at Warangesda and embarked on a tour of England to raise money to establish a new mission on the Gascoyne River in Western Australia. While he was away JB published Black but Comely, a little book that described Aboriginal life in Australia. Both the book and its author were highly acclaimed. JB was fêted by the powerful humanitarians of Exeter Hall, dined with nobility and received standing ovations when he preached. He returned home six months later, invigorated, zealous and impatient to open his new mission near the town of Carnarvon in north west Australia. Ernie dithered and procrastinated about going to Western Australia with the family, but JB won him over with a long, pleading letter and a promise of work as a jackeroo. On a blisteringly hot Christmas Day in 1885, Ernie arrived in Perth with Mary Ann and the rest of the family in tow to discover that, in just a few weeks, JB had alienated almost the entire white population by attacking the treatment of Aboriginals by squatters and police. Despite opposition from all quarters, JB refused to temper his campaign for justice:
A Terribly Wild Man-TEXT PAGES 22/12/01 7:01 AM Page 12
12
A T E R R I B LY W I L D M A N The craft of evil men, the emissaries of Satan, is in danger hence their stir and their rage. I like a healthy opposition. It gives one a greater intensity of zeal and greater determination to do and dare for God and oppressed human beings . . . God has called me to expose the injustice and wrong doing to the poor black-man in the North-west of this great colony. I must in His Name, go forward . . . We are in the way the Martyrs trod and are therefore perfectly safe . . . clearly we are on the track of the Lord Jesus Christ.10
To rally support for his campaign, JB documented the treatment of many Western Australian Aboriginals in a book called Deeds in a Sunny Land or Blacks and Whites in North-West Australia. It was a horror story of kidnapping, slave labour, sexual abuse and murder. JB claimed that Aboriginals were abducted by pearlers and pastoralists, cowered by fear and flogging and forced to live on starvation rations and work without pay, housing or clothing. Aboriginal women were treated like property—defiled, ravished, shared and discarded. Even British law—the supposed hallmark of civilisation throughout the British Empire—conspired to violate Aboriginal rights. Workers were bound by employment contracts they could not understand and Aboriginal prisoners and witnesses were chained by the neck and imprisoned, sometimes for weeks, awaiting trial. JB’s push for reform ignited so much animosity that Ernie’s jackarooing job had evaporated and the Gascoyne mission faced a doubtful future. By the time Ernie and Mary Ann stepped off the boat in Carnarvon they found the town peppered with placards: ‘Down with Gribble and his supporters and confusion to all sneaks’. Bishop Parry of Perth had appointed JB and was soon swept up in the torrent of loathing for his missionary: Old Parry sent a parson here, His name is JB Gribble, Poor silly wretch he damned himself, To save the Lord the trouble.11
In early 1886, JB left his family in a rough, three-room iron house to face the venom of Carnarvon alone while he spent nine
A Terribly Wild Man-TEXT PAGES 22/12/01 7:01 AM Page 13
M O S T LY
OF
TEARS
13
months soliciting support in Perth and the eastern colonies. Mary Ann was heavily pregnant again and suddenly Ernie found himself responsible for the entire family. He struggled to maintain his father’s missionary work among the local Aboriginals, battled a town boycott on the sale of supplies to the mission and begged kindly locals for food to feed the hungry brood in Mary Ann’s care. It was an agonising, demoralising time. Abused, scorned and ostracised, even trips to the post office became treacherous journeys through enemy territory. In the end it was a futile battle. Bishop Parry had never been able raise the £10 000 endowment needed to sustain his diocese and a £14 000 diocesan Cathedral had bled his coffers dry. By 1884, the salaries of all Parry’s clergy were in arrears, his administration was nearly bankrupt and JB was ruining any chance of recovery. John Winthrop Hackett, a leading Anglican layman, exerted his sway as proprietor of The West Australian. The briefless Anglo-Irish lawyer had arrived in Western Australia in 1882 after six years as sub-warden of Trinity College, Melbourne and managed Wooramel sheep station, not far from Carnarvon. He absorbed the values of the Gascoyne squatters before returning to Perth and joining The West Australian, where he soon became editor and sole proprietor. Through Hackett’s influence, the tentacle-like reach of the squattocracy seized the collective mind of the Church. The West Australian warned Bishop Parry not to expect support if the Gribbles stayed in the colony. The Inquirer reinforced the message by announcing that JB’s presence would ‘only frustrate the efforts to further the mission cause in Western Australia’.12 Parry capitulated and withdrew JB’s licence to minister in the colony. The difficult priest had been sacked. Bereft of Church support, penniless and homeless, the family took possession of a vacant block of land near Perth and struggled to survive. Meanwhile JB threw himself into politicking, proselytising and personal vindication. He launched a £10 000 libel suit against The West Australian—the largest in the country’s history at
A Terribly Wild Man-TEXT PAGES 22/12/01 7:01 AM Page 14
14
A T E R R I B LY W I L D M A N
the time—after its editors accused him of being ‘a lying, canting humbug’. Responsibility for supporting the family landed squarely on the shoulders of the 18-year-old Ernie and his younger brother Arthur. They scrounged for material to build a makeshift shack and Ernie took any type of work he could find: hawking homegrown vegetables, laying bricks, teaching school, selling insurance and guiding prospectors. At every turn he was haunted by the curse of the Gribble name. One employer believed business would suffer if it got out that he employed a Gribble and ordered Ernie to use a pseudonym. Throughout the ordeal, Ernie loyally stood by his father. He testified on JB’s behalf during the libel case and never once doubted his father’s righteousness, but the months of bitterness and responsibility wore him down. Time and time again Ernie ‘deplored the fact that he was the son of a Missionary to the Blacks’.13 After twenty days in court, JB lost his libel suit. He was destitute, abandoned and publicly humiliated. To escape the colony and avoid his persecutors, he secretly boarded the SS Franklin under the cover of night and buried himself in the hold until the ship was safely underway. The family followed and resettled in southern New South Wales. Soon afterwards, Ernie announced that he would never become a missionary or help JB with one of his missionary ventures again. For years Ernie had been haunted by a desire to carve out his own destiny. He craved a simple, uncomplicated life, far away from JB’s acrimonious battles against white racism and his admirable but stifling righteousness. The family’s recent experiences had cemented his feelings and he finally summoned the courage to make the break. There were no loud brawls when he announced his decision. His parents were too dazed and disappointed after Western Australia to resist. There was little they could do. It was 1889 when Ernie made his escape and immersed himself in a world of cattle, sheep, horses and sweat. The dry, grey
A Terribly Wild Man-TEXT PAGES 22/12/01 7:01 AM Page 15
M O S T LY
OF
TEARS
15
Australian bush was in his bones and the wiry youth, reared in the belief that sin and idleness were bedfellows, found release and independence in the arduous, rugged life of working on the land. Here sensual gratification lay in physical exhaustion. Work was his solace, isolation was his companion and, best of all, he was accountable to no-one. It was a short-lived emancipation. Before he delivered his first consignment of stock as an independent drover, the 1890s depression hit, the bank foreclosed on his buyer and Ernie found himself unpaid and in debt. His dream of a stockman’s life died. He put his hope for the future in a young lady in Victoria. History has obliterated her name but Ernie had nursed his love patiently from afar and carefully saved £50—a sum sufficient to start a comfortable married life. Optimistic and eager, he made the long journey south to proclaim his love but arrived in Victoria to discover that another had captured the young lady’s affections. A second dream dissolved. Like a lost soul, Ernie sought security and comfort by returning to the bosom of his family. Mary Ann and the children were living in Temora under the auspices of their Warangesda benefactor, Bishop Thomas of Goulburn. Mary Ann Gribble was a short, tenacious woman with a round face, generous breasts and broad hips built for child-bearing. Her soft, milky-white, English complexion defied the ravages of the Australian sun to bestow seemingly perpetual youth. She was very near sighted and her spectacles gave her a mousy, docile look that disguised a formidable streak of quiet determination and a remarkable capacity for resilience in the face of any hardship. Mary Ann was the type of sober, uncomplaining woman you could depend on in any crisis: indomitable, selfless, silent and there. The twin pillars of her life were her faith and her family. Like her husband, she still harboured a glimmer of hope that her first born would follow in his father’s footsteps and devote his life to God. Knowing his mother, Ernie should have expected that the matter of his destiny would not be left up to him.
A Terribly Wild Man-TEXT PAGES 22/12/01 7:01 AM Page 16
16
A T E R R I B LY W I L D M A N
The overture came through Bishop Thomas, who offered Ernie work as curate in Tumbarumba in regional New South Wales. For Ernie, the job meant surrendering all hope of forging out an independent path, but the work was in the parish of Adelong, near his mother, and required extensive horseback travel, which appealed to the bushman in his soul. The job also came with a salary of £60 a year. For Mary Ann and the family, money was short. JB had embarked on his latest missionary venture—a new Aboriginal mission in Queensland, near Cairns—leaving the family without an income. Nevertheless, Ernie procrastinated. Later, he liked to fancy that he took the job because he could not afford formal training for the priesthood. In fact, Mary Ann had to invoke all her subtle but potent powers of persuasion to win her son over. In the end, Ernie was conquered by parental pressure, a lifetime of indoctrination and a dearth of cash. He fatalistically rationalised that his destiny lay with the Church. While Ernie wrestled with his future, JB and his crew struggled to set up a new Aboriginal mission adjacent to the burgeoning township of Cairns, in north Queensland. It was 17 June 1892 when they landed at Cape Grafton on the eastern peninsula of the wide, sandy shores of Trinity Bay. Captain Cook named the bay in 1770 as he travelled north mapping the east coast of Australia for King George. Cook thought he sailed into the tranquil haven on Trinity Sunday, hence the name. He miscalculated. It was Saturday but the name stuck anyway. The three men with JB were: the stocky Willie Ambrym, a South Sea Islander who worked in Brisbane with Canon StoneWigg, the future Bishop of New Guinea; an Aboriginal youth called Pompo Katchewan; and the prosaic James Tyson, former manager of Bribie Island mission, off the coast of Brisbane. JB begged Ernie to come as his assistant but Ernie’s reply was emphatic: he ‘would never go as a missionary among the Blacks’.14 JB was 44 years old when he arrived in north Queensland. His reputation as a troublemaker in Western Australia had preceded him. From the start, local selectors united in opposition to
A Terribly Wild Man-TEXT PAGES 22/12/01 7:01 AM Page 17
M O S T LY
OF
TEARS
17
Green Island
YARRABAH MISSION
PA C I F I C Cape Grafton
Mission e
on
Bay
False Cape
r
Ri v
Barr
Rocky Island
Tr i n i t y
Kings Point
Mothers Point
Bay
King Beach
YARRABAH to Cairns
Fitzroy Island
Cairns M ur r a y
CAIRNS AND HINTERLAND l
G R E AT
er
o r P r i
Riv
Mount Malloy
Barron Falls
Cape Grafton
Cairns
rro
OCEAN
k
ad o
Buddabadoo
YARRABAH
Beach
a n
Gordonvale
g
r
ATHERTON
BARRIER
e s
CORAL Cape York
dab
R
n Rive
Mareeba
Bud
Redlych
Ba
Chillagoe 60 miles
C r ee
Mitc hel
TABLELAND
SEA
Atherton
Bellendon Ker Mountain
Cooktown
17°E
Herberton
Cairns
Road
Cardwell
NORTH
Track
REEF
QUEENSLAND
Boundary of Reserve (38,155 acres)
Innesfail
145°S
Ravenshoe
0
5 Miles
Mount Garnet
0
12
Miles
the Trinity Bay mission. It was futile to educate the Aboriginal, the Cairns Post argued, because he was ‘by instinct a thieving, treacherous, murderous, irreclaimable savage’ who was innately inferior, incapable of ‘learning anything useful’ and destined to ‘quick and certain annihilation’.15 Selectors worried that the mission would ruin the region’s economy. The Cairns Divisional Board fretted about losing potential mineral and timber resources, and tried to stop the gazetting of the Cape Grafton Aboriginal Reserve on 2 January 1892. The Cairns Argus had warned that selectors did not ‘want to see their cheap labour busily engaged in singing hymns and learning collects’ and, only eight days after JB landed at Trinity Bay, the Cairns Post printed the wildly improbable allegation that the mission had already destroyed the local beche-de-mer industry.16 Aboriginal missions were an unpopular cause in nineteenthcentury Australia, and Anglican congregations preferred to support
A Terribly Wild Man-TEXT PAGES 22/12/01 7:01 AM Page 18
18
A T E R R I B LY W I L D M A N
the conversion of heathens in more romantic, exotic and faraway lands. The recently enthroned Bishop of North Queensland, Christopher Barlow, squashed JB’s hopes of diocesan support for the mission, and issued a stern warning that he was not to comment on white ill-treatment of Aboriginals. JB was barred from visiting the Cairns rectory with Pompo, his young Aboriginal assistant: ‘parishioners were not in favour of the Aborigines being about the Church’.17 Horace Tozer, Colonial Secretary of Queensland, promised financial aid for the mission but changed his mind after learning of JB’s history in Western Australia. The mission seemed doomed and Mary Ann was worried. Her husband’s hopes were disintegrating, she was in debt and the family was totally dependent on Ernie’s earnings from his curacy. Nor had JB told her that he had surrendered his life assurance policy to fund his trip to Cairns. The financial future for Mary Ann and her large family seemed bleak. After six months of negotiations, the Australian Board of Missions (ABM) agreed to assume responsibility for JB’s mission. As the official missionary arm of the Anglican Church in Australia, the ABM was responsible for the Church’s missionary outreach in Australia and overseas. It agreed to pay JB a salary of £200 a year, providing he personally covered the cost of establishing the mission. The arrangement might have been tolerable but JB’s salary was delayed, money pledged in England failed to materialise and funds that JB raised during a 1891 lecture tour vanished when the Depression forced the Bank of North Queensland to close its doors in 1893. As a final blow, the mission cutter sank two days after the missionary party landed at Trinity Bay, cutting them off from all contact with Cairns. These setbacks did not diminish JB’s resolve but the emotional strain and physical demands took a severe toll on his health. He fell victim to malaria and dengue fever—the two tropical diseases that struck fear in the hearts of all settlers. Malaria brought high fevers, painful headaches and vomiting. Each of JB’s attacks was accompanied by uncontrollable shivering followed by a drenching
A Terribly Wild Man-TEXT PAGES 22/12/01 7:01 AM Page 19
M O S T LY
OF
TEARS
19
sweat that saturated his clothes and bedding, drained him of energy and left him fatigued and weak. Dengue fever intensified the erratic temperatures and brought excruciating pain in his joints and muscles. Moving was impossible. JB was exhausted and drained by the never-ending cycle of illness. Eventually, pneumonia set in and he was smitten by more fevers, aches, pains and a gut-wrenching cough. More serious, however, was his undiagnosed tuberculosis. The first symptoms had appeared in the spring of 1884 but JB had dismissed his bouts of bloody coughing as the consequence of an ‘overstrained chest’.18 As his condition worsened, the infection put pressure on his heart and he was incapacitated by pain in his left side. No-one, not even JB, realised he was so sick. Illness frustrated JB and the mission’s progress but it was his assistant, James Tyson, who suffered most. JB invited Tyson to join the mission party believing he could not secure a better man but he soon changed his mind and complained that Tyson was lazy and sloth-like, lacking in judgement and commonsense. In short, a complete failure. Six weeks after landing at Cape Grafton, JB demanded—and received—Tyson’s resignation. Back in Tumbarumba, Ernie had settled comfortably into his new life as curate. The idiosyncrasies of his mountain congregation with their unrefined ways, family feuds and blunt honesty provided him with constant entertainment, but JB’s illness and Tyson’s sudden departure re-ignited the pressure on him to help his father at the mission. JB sent begging letters to Mary Ann threatening to collapse immediately if Ernie did not come: ‘Do all in your power to hurry it along’.19 Ernie felt bitter and resentful. He was convinced that JB’s pleas were merely a ruse to get him into missionary work. He was nearly 24 years old and beyond being given marching orders by his father, yet the possibility that his instincts might be wrong niggled, and Mary Ann’s entreaties were difficult to resist. His deeply ingrained sense of duty and respect for the first commandment to ‘honour thy father and mother’ disturbed Ernie’s peace
A Terribly Wild Man-TEXT PAGES 22/12/01 7:01 AM Page 20
20
A T E R R I B LY W I L D M A N
and made him fidgety. Finally, he submitted. He took leave from his curacy and agreed to spend six weeks at Cape Grafton, but insisted that staying was out of the question. JB met him when the boat berthed in Cairns and Ernie was shocked by his father’s appearance. JB was thin, wasted and grey. His skin hung loosely on his gaunt, emaciated frame and his sunken cheeks accentuated the fatalistic resignation in his eyes. His retching cough and stooped, weary body exuded that hollow, vacuous aura that envelops the ill when they are being sucked empty of life. Father and son quickly agreed that JB should consult a specialist in Townsville. As he left, JB made a final, desperate plea for Ernie to stay permanently at the mission. Ernie refused. He would wait until JB returned but then he would return to his work in Tumburumba. Ernie was tormented by his decision. It consumed him with guilt and uncertainty: Father left today for Cairns thence to Townsville. He does look bad. I do not know what to do. He wants me so badly to stay and yet my heart is in my work at Tumbarumba. O God what shall I do . . . stay here or return[?] My God I only desire to do what is right.20
Was he wrong to deny his father? Was it such a betrayal to want a life of his own? He prayed for the answer but it did not come. Two weeks later, Ernie was still agonising. Feeling forlorn and alone, he asked God to make him ‘a willing soldier in this service’.21 He busied himself clearing a space in the tropical jungle alongside Trinity Bay, but he worked without energy or enthusiasm. Later, Ernie would reconstruct those weeks in his mind and create different accounts of his struggle to resolve his future, but each version would understate the lengthy procrastination and profound anguish he felt at denying his father and that he documented in his journal at night. As the weeks drifted by, it slowly dawned on him that the mission might become his sole responsibility. The thought troubled him deeply. It was during this time that Ernie first slipped
A Terribly Wild Man-TEXT PAGES 22/12/01 7:01 AM Page 21
M O S T LY
OF
TEARS
21
unwittingly and unawares into the black, tormenting, destructive malaise that would revisit him periodically throughout the rest of his life. The world no longer interested him. He was restless, disconsolate and lonely. He regretted abandoning his work in Tumbarumba and was despondent about the ‘half-heartedness’ of his commitment to his new life. Yet, he felt powerless to change his circumstances. A dark mantle of hopeless melancholy descended and smothered him, and he was harassed by vague, indefinable but incapacitating afflictions—the telling symptoms of psychological illness. JB Gribble died in Sydney on 3 June 1893 at the age of 45 and was buried with full rites in the Anglican section of Waverley cemetery in Sydney. The inscription on his tombstone read the ‘Blackfellow’s Friend’. His friends described him as a martyr to the Aboriginal cause. Ernie was in Cairns when the telegram arrived announcing JB’s death. He should have been prepared but the news rattled him. They had not spoken since JB left Cape Grafton and time had stolen all chance of retracting his renunciation of his father and his work. Ernie mourned in private and in silence but, in the end, JB was the victor in the struggle over his son’s destiny. JB’s dying wish was that Ernie commit his life to missionary work among Aboriginals and ‘carry on . . . the noble work which has had its baptism of death’. In Ernie’s mind, the path was now clear. It was plainly his ‘duty’ to embrace missionary work as a ‘sacred trust’ from his father. He drew on the Gribble determination and resourcefulness buried deep in his soul. Shaking off the depressive, black gloom that menaced his being, Ernie vowed to sublimate his own desires and dreams and ‘to live that my life may be like his’.22
A Terribly Wild Man-TEXT PAGES 22/12/01 7:01 AM Page 22
2
C LASPING
THEIR CHILDREN TIGHTLY
E
rnie was unaware that the Kongkandji, the traditional custodians of Cape Grafton, were silently monitoring his every move. Their dominion extended east across Trinity Bay to Green and Fitzroy Islands and inland as far as the Murray Prior Ranges to the west. It was a fertile world scattered with grassy gullies and broad coastal flats, safeguarded by a crescent of rugged hills overgrown with lush, impenetrable tropical rainforests of cedar, silky oak and bean trees. The bountiful, tranquil waters of the bay were shielded from the ocean’s vagaries by the Great Barrier Reef that snaked down the Queensland coast. Until now, settlers had been deterred by the Kongkandji’s reputation as inveterate cannibals. They killed a selector’s bailiff who strayed onto Cape Grafton in 1886 and an eccentric recluse who camped on the beach in 1890. Whether or not the victims were eaten did not matter in Cairns. Fact and fiction fused on the frontier and the local press fuelled hearsay and fear into irrefutable fact. Experts claimed Aboriginals preferred Asiatic to European flesh—thighs were reputed to be the best eating. Local tradition has it that this was cold comfort to the pioneers of Cairns, who were captives of a ghoulish fear that they might end their days as the epicurean highlight of a tribal feast and subscribed to 22
A Terribly Wild Man-TEXT PAGES 22/12/01 7:01 AM Page 23
CLASPING
T H E I R C H I L D R E N T I G H T LY
23
the popular wisdom that Aboriginals: had no compunction against taking human life simply for its edible quality, in fact they were downright irresponsible about it. Human flesh was especially craved among the rainforest Aboriginals whose diet was sadly lacking in protein . . . they sometimes ate enemy dead but . . . they also ate those with whom they were on the friendliest terms. Enemy dead were in fact an unanticipated windfall for the camp oven of heated stones. Fellow tribal members, plump and tender, and not aged, and presumably dispensable stringy grannie, featured more frequently on the menu.1
Their reputation and the serendipity of geography was the Kongkandji’s armour. The sea discouraged invasion from the east, the Murray Prior Ranges thwarted overland incursions from the west while the Mulgrave River deterred advances from the south— at least until the missionaries arrived—and protected the ancient society and the rich cosmology that cemented its culture. The exploits of ancestor heroes decreed the Kongkandji’s custodianship of the land. These forebears moulded the landscape, laid down the Law (way of life) and set the behavioural precepts required for every occasion: rites of passage, social relations, kinship, marriage and the rituals needed to maintain and renew the grand design of the cosmos. The ancestor heroes lived on in the landscape and the legacies they bestowed, and the powerful, regenerative spirit of the Rainbow Serpent still thrived in the waterfall at Bukki behind Trinity Bay and in the sacred, healing Yilamagay (medicine water) that trickled down to King Beach in the south. Every Kongkandji identified with a particular ancestral figure and its totem, and these totemic affiliations linked kinship groups and directed the rules for inter-marriage. Ernie knew nothing of this. Unlike the Moravian, Lutheran and Roman Catholic missionaries, he had no formal missionary training but he dismissed this deficiency. Talent and experience, he maintained, were all that mattered, and he had a goodly quota of both. He had been groomed for this work for nearly a quarter of a century on a staple diet of imperial ideology and liberal
A Terribly Wild Man-TEXT PAGES 22/12/01 7:01 AM Page 24
24
A T E R R I B LY W I L D M A N
rations of the ‘White Man’s Burden’ milked from the Boy’s Own Journal, his favourite boyhood reading, fortified by copious doses of evangelical example. Missionary work was in his blood. As he contemplated his future, Ernie imagined a bustling, arcadian village. There would be a school, a hospital, dormitories for the boys and girls, huts of thatched palm leaves for married couples and, of course, a church—perhaps even with stained glass windows. The soul of the place would be fruitful industry. Teams would labour in flourishing farms, fishermen would plunder the seas, busy kitchens would bake bread to feed the multitudes, skilled artisans would populate the site with buildings and roads, the women would cook and sew, and washing lines would sparkle with clean drying clothes while shiny-faced children played happily under the watchful protection of the dormitory matron. He would build a community where ‘everything necessary’ for a permanent home was provided and where all north Queensland’s Indigenous people could be gathered and safely segregated from the evils and corruption of white society. Here he would ‘break through the wall of senseless customs and traditions . . . of the dark skinned and dark minded’ by teaching them the Gospel and ‘industry—that ‘‘duty of life’’’ so that they could ‘conduct themselves better and attain to a higher state of life’. Not only would he ‘soothe the pillow of a dying race’ but perhaps he would even save the Australian Aboriginal ‘from utter extinction’.2 When he eventually snapped out of his daydreaming, Ernie realised just how fanciful and remote his ambitions seemed. JB had made so little progress. No Aboriginals had been sighted, although their presence was evident all around. Some flimsy tents and a rickety, two-room hut for stores were the only shelter, and threatening clouds pregnant with monsoon rains were already filling the skies. There was land to be cleared and ploughed, crops to be planted, timber to be felled, cleaned and hauled, and buildings to be erected. The list of chores was endless. Ernie toiled from dawn until dusk, day after day. Progress was slow. He had few tools and no mule to haul the timber or to
A Terribly Wild Man-TEXT PAGES 22/12/01 7:01 AM Page 25
CLASPING
T H E I R C H I L D R E N T I G H T LY
25
plough the soil, but he was in his element and revelled in the work. His wiry body grew muscular and strong and his skin became deeply tanned. He was like the master sculptor who slowly, painstakingly but adeptly manipulates form, purpose and life from an amorphous, inert nothingness. As the weeks passed, Ernie began to feel himself taking root at Cape Grafton and decided it was time to stamp his sovereignty formally on the place. The mission was known by a variety of names: Cape Grafton, Trinity Bay and Bellenden Ker, after the mountain to the west. Several retained a degree of currency until well into the twentieth century. JB called the site Yarraburra, meaning ‘meeting place’, but Ernie fancied that E-Yerra-Bah was closer to the Aboriginal name so he decided to split the difference, merge the two and christen the mission Yarrabah. The name was a memorial to his father and a declaration that he had adopted it as his own—just as relinquishing the affectionate and childish ‘Ernie’ for the more formal ‘Mr Gribble’ signified his passage into manhood and his formal declaration that he had accepted his new role as head of the mission. At best reckoning, there were 200 to 300 Kongkandji living in scattered extended families of 40–50 when Gribble arrived at Yarrabah. They sailed their single outrigger canoes up and down the coast to net fish and harpoon dugong and turtle, and in Cairns they were valued sailors on the pearl-luggers and beche-de-mer schooners. The fishing industry was notorious for debauchery, cruelty and exploitation. It was claimed that boat owners: enticed blacks on board, worked them like slaves, treated them like dogs, and finished by leaving them marooned on a reef, or shot them, or landed them far from their own home on some strange part of the coast, where they would be certain to be killed by the first tribe they met.3
The Kongkandji’s reputation as expert sailors helped them escape these abuses. They dictated their employment contracts and worked the beche-de-mer schooners until close to the turn of the century, but it was a different story for Aboriginals elsewhere.
A Terribly Wild Man-TEXT PAGES 22/12/01 7:01 AM Page 26
26
A T E R R I B LY W I L D M A N
In the 1890s, as the fathers of Federation met to loosen white Australia’s bondage to Britain, the indigenous peoples of Queensland were being decimated by the bloody violence of colonisation, epidemics of smallpox and influenza, and the rampant spread of venereal disease that left entire communities fetid and decaying. The ravaged remnants clustered in poverty-stricken camps on the edges of towns where they relied on begging, prostitution and infrequent charity. In these conditions, they quickly surrendered to malnutrition, disease, alcohol and opium addiction, and an early death. On the frontier beyond the towns, lawlessness prevailed. Aboriginal groups were ‘dispersed’—the euphemism for organised, quasi-martial sorties and the nineteenth-century synonym for ‘ethnic cleansing’ a century later—by settlers avaricious for land and dominance. Some fell victim to a slow and agonising death after being fed damper laced with strychnine or arsenic. A greater number were abducted to work as forced labour on pastoral properties, boats and as servants. The women were the most vulnerable. For colonists reared in repression and restraint, the luminous, black nakedness of Aboriginal women was tantalisingly bewitching, and their flagrant ignorance of British prudery was a potent aphrodisiac. They were known as ‘black velvet’ and ‘stud-gins’. In a world where the physical gratification and restraining influence of white women was in short supply, Aboriginal women were coveted sexual spoils of conquest. Not all colonists were hostile in their dealings with Aboriginals and not all Aboriginals passively accepted white aggression, but the march of colonisation was unrelenting. This fact meant Gribble’s presence at Cape Grafton caused heated discussion and dissension among the Kongkandji. Oral tradition has it that their first instinct was to expel the latest intruder: When Father Gribble came here he was looking . . . up this way and down that way to see if any coloured people would come out [and] one evening he heard [them] all talking amongst themselves like they wanted to fight . . . because there was a white man here on their land.4
A Terribly Wild Man-TEXT PAGES 22/12/01 7:01 AM Page 27
CLASPING
T H E I R C H I L D R E N T I G H T LY
27
Gribble found a protector in a man called Menmuny. Like other young Kongkandji men, Menmuny had spent part of his early life in Cairns. He knew the changing realities of the world beyond the sheltered confines of the Cape Grafton Reserve, and oral tradition has it that he quelled the opposition to Gribble’s presence on Kongkandji land. The first Kongkandji ventured into Gribble’s camp on 29 November 1892, a month after JB left. They were wary and cautious, and the women and children remained hidden. As their confidence in Gribble grew, the number of visitors increased, the children accompanied the men and the first women visited on 12 December 1892. Gribble’s problem was how to inveigle them to forsake their traditional existence in favour of Yarrabah and his ways. Food, tobacco and children, he decided, were the answer. He fed all visitors and promised them regular rations if they settled. Even when supplies were short, there was always a gooey bowl of rice or maize-meal porridge for the children. In return, the Kongkandji let him care for the children while they hunted, socialised and fulfilled spiritual responsibilities. This act reflected the concept of reciprocity and mutual benefit that was central to Aboriginal social relations. Between clans, reciprocity was horizontal, levelling and designed to establish a brotherly, sharing relationship. Between individuals, it was vertical and worked in two ways. The first was based on age and/or ritual pre-eminence, that is, between the older and younger community members, and between the ritually senior and the less knowledgeable. Pre-eminence involved nurturing (looking after and helping) and authority (being boss). It was expected that a community would respect and obey those who were ritually senior because they looked after others by controlling and influencing the cosmic forces. The second form of vertical reciprocity was between patronal leaders who acted as brokers or intermediaries and the individuals or communities who were their clients, and offered an alternative pathway to the pre-eminence usually gained through age and ritual seniority. Generosity was a
A Terribly Wild Man-TEXT PAGES 22/12/01 7:01 AM Page 28
28
A T E R R I B LY W I L D M A N
key element in reciprocity. It recognised the relationship between the giver and the receiver, and acknowledged the receiver’s significance. If the wealthy were stingy, it was considered hostile behaviour designed to diminish the status and acknowledgement due to the potential gift recipients. Menmuny was the first Kongkandji to settle permanently at Yarrabah. The young warrior was indebted to Gribble when his daughter was saved by Gribble’s medicine after traditional remedies failed. An early photograph of Menmuny shows him standing centre-frame flanked by his friend, George Christian, his fatherin-law Billy Woopah and his eldest son Albert Maywe. In the foreground, his baby daughter squirms on the lap of a child. For the sake of modesty, the photographer has induced him to wear a loin-cloth. It obscures his virility but not his power and authority. Menmuny had the mighty thighs and heavy-set shoulders of a warrior and a stomach lined with numerous swollen, horizontal cicatrices. These scars were the legacy of the initiation rites undergone by all Kongkandji boys when Elders inducted them into the secrets of the Dreaming and carved deep wounds into their abdomens to mark their transition to manhood. Menmuny brought his three wives and children to live with him at Yarrabah. Gribble was delighted. He made Menmuny captain of the boat and cared for his family. In return, Menmuny acted as a broker with the local people: translating language, persuading others to settle and pursuing promised brides stolen from the mission. Menmuny reportedly explained: ‘new way now. I help Missionary’.5 Menmuny was married to three sisters, Maggie I, Maggie II and Nora, but he discarded the latter two at Gribble’s insistence. The next settlers included Menmuny’s brother, Dick Yimbungi, and his father-in-law, Billy Church, with his wife Goondoon and their three sons. Menmuny’s example and kinship ties were crucial to the creation of Yarrabah mission. Of the other Kongkandji, only a handful chose to live at Yarrabah. The mission’s primary attraction was as a ready source of food and tobacco. Few were seduced by Gribble’s culture and,
A Terribly Wild Man-TEXT PAGES 22/12/01 7:01 AM Page 29
CLASPING
T H E I R C H I L D R E N T I G H T LY
29
no matter how hard he tried, Gribble could not come to terms with Kongkandji social customs. He was disgusted by their practice of polygamy, infant betrothal, wife exchange and young marriage—girls as young as nine or ten married older men, although the union was not consummated until after puberty. In his eyes, their conduct swept the depths of licentiousness and debauchery and buried the Kongkandji in a quagmire of obscene, heathen darkness that barred them from the enlightenment and joy of civilisation and Christianity. Their customs violated his view of the natural order of things and confirmed his belief that Aboriginals were a ‘degraded and depraved race’.6 The intensity of his abhorrence outweighed the fragility of his relationship with the Kongkandji and he lectured them repeatedly against sorcery and witchcraft, banned infant betrothals, polygamy and young marriages on the mission, and insisted on Christian burials. He took a stockwhip to a man who hit his wife and hunted down men who stole promised brides from the mission compound. In 1894 a man called Gomerie tried to claim his promised wife, Jinny, and Gribble: plainly told him that I would not allow any of the girls on the mission to go to any man having already a wife, nor would I allow any girl to get married unless she had reached a proper age.7
Gribble’s behaviour annoyed the old men who resented him interfering with marriage obligations and did not want him to have anything to do with the dead. Many Kongkandji avoided the mission and did all they could to prevent the missionaries gaining influence over the people. Gribble complained that the old people were: very conservative and look with a suspicious eye upon anything that threatens their old customs and traditions; they object strongly to the boys and girls sleeping at the Mission in the dormitories . . . Three or four old fellows cause considerable trouble . . . One old man . . . objects strongly to the young men giving up in any way old native practices.8
A Terribly Wild Man-TEXT PAGES 22/12/01 7:01 AM Page 30
30
A T E R R I B LY W I L D M A N
The Elders used their potent powers to preserve the traditional ways. The chichal-barra (clever men) could fly over great stretches of country, cause death by extracting a person’s life-blood or save lives with their powerful knowledge of herbal remedies but it was the old women who were the bane of Gribble’s life. They used their spiritual and political sway to undermine his influence. Gribble breathed a sigh of relief when Menmuny’s aged mother died. She was: a very conservative dame . . . It was a difficult matter to get her to wear clothing, and she had a great objection to the Mission, holding that we would make the young folk ‘too much like white fella’. This poor old soul was frequently seeing visions and dreaming dreams, and frequently conversed with the dead, from whom she from time to time received new songs for the use of the tribe. [Menmuny] held her in dread, having great belief in her powers . . . her death was a blessing for the Mission. Wailing was kept up for her every night for many months so that for some time after her death we still felt her presence among us.9
The Elders were Gribble’s competitors in the contest for the hearts and minds of the Kongkandji, and he needed to discredit them to establish his pre-eminence and control. He deliberately ignored the protocol of feeding Elders before the others and ridiculed the rain-doctor’s powers and the medicine of the chichalbarra. As a result, two communities emerged on the Cape Grafton Reserve: the tiny compound of Yarrabah mission where Gribble ruled; and the nearby camp where the Elders and traditional ways held sway. Camp residents participated in mission life when it suited them and converts defied Gribble’s directives and slipped away from the compound for ceremonies and corroborees in the camp. Nevertheless, tension and conflict troubled relations between the two spheres. Clashes and ritual reprisals continued well into the twentieth century. Every now and again, Gribble wondered if he had made a mistake by deciding to stay in this God-forsaken place. With the exception of Menmuny and his extended family, it seemed so difficult to make inroads with the Kongkandji. With failure staring
A Terribly Wild Man-TEXT PAGES 22/12/01 7:01 AM Page 31
CLASPING
T H E I R C H I L D R E N T I G H T LY
31
him in the face, he turned to the Cairns police. For different reasons, Gribble and the police agreed on one essential point: all Aboriginals should be forcibly removed from proximity to any white settlement. Gribble offered to take any Aboriginal collected by the police and the first transportees arrived at Yarrabah in 1893—a blind boy called Willie and a nameless woman convicted of stealing a loaf of bread. With this event began an unofficial but long-lived marriage of convenience between Church and constabulary that was the beginning of a community of Stolen Children at Yarrabah. Meanwhile, worry, exhaustion and ill health drained Gribble’s energy and spirits. He suffered from rheumatism and sciatica. The humid, tropical weather aggravated his pains, and he was regularly put out of action by distressing bouts of malaria and dengue fever. Pompo Katchewan and Willie Ambrym remained valiant, loyal aides but JB’s only white assistant, Mr Pearson, left the mission under scandalous circumstances around the end of 1893, and Gribble’s repeated pleas for white reinforcements fell on deaf ears. Part of the problem was that Yarrabah depended on the munificence of Anglican congregations and this was in short supply. JB’s salary went to Mary Ann until he died, but there was nothing for Gribble or the mission, and they were forced to rely on the generosity and credit of storekeepers in Cairns. Supplies were sometimes so low that Gribble lived on boiled sweet potato tops, cabbage and the occasional fish. He had no money for socks, boots or even stamps for his letters, and he avoided going to town because he had no respectable clothes. He kept such a low profile in Cairns that the Argus dubbed Yarrabah ‘terra incognita’.10 The crisis came to a head in March 1893. Yarrabah was £300 in debt, the diocesan management committee was bankrupt, and Gribble was told the mission had to close. It was a scenario that would be repeated time and again during his career. Each time, Gribble’s response would be the same: he was not extravagant, he only bought essentials, his sole concern was the welfare of the people in his care. The problem, he insisted, was the Church’s
A Terribly Wild Man-TEXT PAGES 22/12/01 7:01 AM Page 32
32
A T E R R I B LY W I L D M A N
failure to adequately fund his important and necessary work. In 1893, it seemed to Gribble that there was only one way forward. He appealed to the Primate and the head of the ABM, Archbishop Saumerez Smith. This strategic step was more than a petition to a higher authority. The Primate had a soft spot for Ernie and had always taken a kindly interest in his progress, providing money and lodgings when he visited Sydney and persuading his sister to sponsor the two oldest Gribble girls at her school. Gribble looked on the Archbishop as a father he could rely on for sympathy and advice. With characteristic compassion, the Primate acceded to Gribble’s petition and agreed to save Yarrabah. It was decided that the ABM in Sydney would pay out the debt and take over the mission from the north Queensland diocese. This meant Gribble would receive a small salary of £50 a year. The catch was that he had to limit all other mission expenditure to £10 per month. Under these conditions, Gribble had a problem. How could he keep the wolf from the door? Over the years, he jumped at any scheme to raise funds. He had inmates use their traditional knowledge to make weapons to hawk around Cairns; he agisted cows in exchange for the milk; he contracted-out inmates to pick coffee on local plantations, and all hands were enlisted to gather wild orchids for sale in Brisbane—a labour intensive venture that grossed £2.10s. Gribble set his heart on tapping into the profitable trade in harpooned greenback turtles, dugong and beche-de-mer but the mission’s boats seemed jinxed. The first vessel, the Hazelhurst—nicknamed Lazy House—went ashore in a cyclone. Its replacement, the JB Gribble, sprang a leak, was refloated, leaked again and sank within a week. A succession of failures followed: a punt, two whaleboats, a motor launch with a sick engine, the ketch Matabu and the cutter Hepzibah. According to reports, Gribble’s seamanship was part of the problem. He could get a boat going but was not quite sure how to stop it. There were frequent collisions with the Cairns wharf. It was 1893 when Mary Ann surprised everyone by announcing that she and her three youngest children would move to Yarrabah—
A Terribly Wild Man-TEXT PAGES 22/12/01 7:01 AM Page 33
CLASPING
T H E I R C H I L D R E N T I G H T LY
33
although anyone who knew her financial circumstances and earnest commitment to JB’s work might have expected the news. She and the children arrived in Cairns just in time for a steamy, tropical Christmas and Gribble met them at the wharf. It was more than twelve months since he had seen Mary Ann and there was so much he wanted to share and confide. He was still periodically haunted by a nagging doubt that he was not cut out to be a missionary and he needed her fortitude and faith when he lapsed into one of these occasional episodes of self-doubt and troubling, impenetrable uncertainty. Stuart, Illa and Stella came too. They were aged seven, four and three and needed a father. In name and in practice, Ernie was now the patriarch of the Gribble family. Around this time came the first disturbing signs of Gribble’s tendency for colourful exaggeration and self-aggrandisement. Hindsight suggests that his vanity may have been symptomatic of a lack of confidence or a deep-seated fear of failing to meet the obligations and challenges set by his father, but the cause did not temper the expression. Notwithstanding the disinterest of the local people in his mission, Gribble told readers of Missionary Notes, the official journal of the ABM, that the Kongkandji were devoted to him and listened with ‘rapt attention’ to his sermons. His popularity among other people beyond the Cape Grafton Reserve was firmly established, he told the faithful, and he was called ‘Dadda’ as a sign of their affection. In fact, disappointment weighed him down. After four years of work, he had hoped to achieve more. There were only 42 inmates in the mission compound. He had lured a dozen or so from a marginal existence in Cairns with promises of a better life on his mission, but 29 of the residents were children and the rest were disabled, elderly or refugees from traditional marriage obligations. The Kongkandji made up less than one third, and Gribble’s hold on this group was especially tenuous as long as there were viable alternatives on their own land. Disillusioned and desperate, Gribble bundled up his swag and trundled to all the Aboriginal camps in Mareeba, Port Douglas,
A Terribly Wild Man-TEXT PAGES 22/12/01 7:01 AM Page 34
34
A T E R R I B LY W I L D M A N
Redlynch and along the Barron and Mulgrave Rivers. Like the Pied Piper, at each camp he urged the people to follow him and settle at Yarrabah. Some feigned interest. Gribble gave one man trousers, a shirt and dinner on the condition that he conduct him to the local Aboriginal camp but his guide abandoned him to the bush after a five-mile hike. As a rule, the incomprehensible notion of abandoning their own country for Kongkandji territory was matched only by the people’s dread of Gribble. The women gave him a ‘look full of fear, then clasping their children tightly, vanished’.11 Aboriginals told Gribble: ‘Mickinry no good; he catch ’em woman; catch ’em piccaninny; tie ’em up, cook ’em, eat ’em’.12 During these difficult times, Gribble’s solace and sustenance was a tiny, makeshift desk. He lived on his nerves and managed on minimal sleep for his thoughts were full of schemes and new ideas that kept him restless and awake at night. During these silent hours when the draining heat and humidity of the day had eased, he dutifully scrawled entries in the mission’s journal and curtly documented the minutia of Yarrabah’s development. His handwriting was large, impatient and illegible. This necessary task was always hurried and quickly dispatched, as was any administrative chore. He had little patience for trivial, pedestrian responsibilities like accounts, financial statements and reports. Then, oblivious to the lateness of the hour, he immersed himself in his own writing. He intuitively followed the pattern set by his father and was a prodigious scribbler, churning out endless letters and anecdotes and snippets of news for Missionary Notes, the Church Chronicle and any regional newspaper with a penchant for missionary stories. It was during this time that he began to think about the first of his six autobiographies and of recording the experiences that sustained his spirit and that he wanted the world to share. They would be tales of the exotic and sublime: wild, naked cannibals, terrifying corroborees, valiant feats of conquest, courageous battles against the elements and comic incidents of cultural misunderstanding. His spelling was weak and his grammar worse. Later, a typewriter improved on his penmanship
A Terribly Wild Man-TEXT PAGES 22/12/01 7:01 AM Page 35
CLASPING
T H E I R C H I L D R E N T I G H T LY
35
but not his literary errors. His manuscripts were an editor’s nightmare but it was engaging, colourful writing that brushed up well enough with some careful, incisive polishing. The temperate cool of the tropical winter was still lingering in the mornings when George Fairfowl Macarthur, Gribble’s headmaster from The King’s School, visited Yarrabah in the spring of 1894. He found his former student exhausted and worn out. The retired military chaplain fired off an angry complaint to the ABM and within a month, Christopher Herbst (a carpenter) and William Reeves (a stone mason) arrived to help. Gribble took a shine to the mild-mannered Reeves. He was an anaemic, docile sort with seven years’ experience as the Superintendent of Wagga Wagga Sunday School in southern New South Wales. Reeves settled in and eventually married Gribble’s sister, Ethel. He was loyal, reliable and a passionate, self-taught musician who formed the Yarrabah band, which gave irregular but well-received performances in nearby towns to raise funds for the mission. The carpenter and Gribble did not get on. Herbst had a rebellious streak and foolishly questioned Gribble’s authority. After a minor disagreement, Gribble ‘seized him by the neck and the seat of his pants and dropped him over the verandah on to the ground’.13 Herbst did not last. Around the same time, Deaconess Maspero arrived to care for the women and girls. She was a mousy, inoffensive spinster—a devout Christian who worked without pay. Andrew Obah from the Solomon Islands followed and took charge of the mission’s parade of boats. While this support helped Yarrabah’s physical development to blossom, the mission’s spiritual life was stunted by Gribble’s lack of clerical qualifications and his inability to administer the sacraments. In December 1893, he asked Bishop Barlow of north Queensland to ordain him but his request was refused. Barlow’s election as bishop had been challenged because he lacked a university degree but he would not have untrained clergy in his diocese. Barlow insisted Gribble complete the requisite course of study and examinations. Gribble made a half-hearted effort to
A Terribly Wild Man-TEXT PAGES 22/12/01 7:01 AM Page 36
36
A T E R R I B LY W I L D M A N
comply but he was not a scholar and the study was ‘too much on top of a hard day’s manual labour’.14 His desires thwarted by Barlow’s strictures, Gribble devised a cunning scheme to by-pass his bishop by asking his mentor, Archbishop Samaurez Smith, to approve his ordination. After all, Gribble rationalised, Yarrabah was an ABM mission, the Archbishop was head of the ABM and the subtleties of episcopal authority were not his problem. The soft-hearted Archbishop was inveigled to agree and Gribble was ordained a deacon in Sydney, on 21 December 1894. He was twenty-six years old. Four months later, he took the next step in the proper ordering of his life. On 18 April 1895, a small gathering at St John’s Anglican Church, Cairns celebrated the marriage of Ernest Richard Bulmer Gribble to Emilie Julia Wreide. Bishop Barlow officiated, having graciously pardoned his maverick missionary for his disloyalty. The local newspapers reported that there were three bridesmaids, the church was prettily decorated, the choir sang and the couple honeymooned in Port Douglas. The bride’s dress was not mentioned. Emilie loathed her name—it was too ordinary. She preferred Amelia—it was more cultured and sophisticated. Her new husband dismissed this as affectation and called her Millie. Notwithstanding the quibbles about her name, Amelia was a strikingly handsome young lady with that vaguely horsey look acquired by tall women with long noses and lean limbs. She had a remarkably straight back that was allegedly the legacy of some distant Prussian ancestry and a genteel upbringing, as befitted the daughter of the Cairns Harbour Pilot. The comfortable circumstances in which she was raised were a far cry from conditions at Yarrabah but her family were devout, active Anglicans and Amelia believed that her faith could sustain her through any hardship and privation. She could hold a tune well enough to sing in the church choir and had an exceptional talent for needlework. She was a genius at tatting. Her long, nimble fingers could coax any intricate, exquisite pattern from the very finest thread and there was always a delicate piece of lacework on hand to keep her occupied.
A Terribly Wild Man-TEXT PAGES 22/12/01 7:01 AM Page 37
CLASPING
T H E I R C H I L D R E N T I G H T LY
37
Regrettably, Amelia had two unfortunate flaws: she was impossible to sway once she had made up her mind and she had absolutely no sense of humour. Those who knew her later in life describe her as severe, forbidding and rigid. She was softer and gentler in her mid-twenties when she was newly married. The hardening came later. The couple had had a measured courtship. Every weekend for six or so months, Gribble went to Cairns and visited and returned to Yarrabah after Sunday Evensong. There is no record of passion or fire in their attachment. It was proper, correct and timely. In his old age, Gribble would nostalgically reflect on his unrequited love for his nameless sweetheart in Victoria and wonder whether he might have been a better man with some romance in his life. Still, his marriage to Amelia was not a fruitless union and three sons were duly born: John (Jack) Bulmer (17 January 1896), Eric Livingstone (17 March 1898) and Ernest Yarrabah (24 July 1901). As the century neared its close, Gribble’s life seemed more settled. The death of influential Elders like Menmuny’s mother slowly eroded the resistance of the old people in the camp who were the repositories of traditional knowledge, while those forcibly relocated to Yarrabah by the Cairns police were isolated from their cultural roots. Gribble could feel his ways beginning to take hold. He pinned his hopes for the mission’s future on the Aboriginal Protection and Restriction of the Sale of Opium Act 1897, the model for subsequent legislation in Western Australia, South Australia and the Northern Territory. Archibald Meston was one of the Act’s strongest advocates. After the Act was passed, Meston was appointed Southern Protector of Aborigines with responsibility for all Aboriginal affairs below the Tropic of Capricorn after the Act was passed. Meston argued that the Indigenous peoples needed greater protection because Queenslanders: still regard the aboriginal as of no more value in the scale of being than a horse or a bullock, an inheritance from those who shot him like a kangaroo, abducted his women and sent his children away to
A Terribly Wild Man-TEXT PAGES 22/12/01 7:01 AM Page 38
38
A T E R R I B LY W I L D M A N distant friends with as much indifference as if they were pet squirrels and tame galahs . . . they were either not credited with any human instincts or those instincts were entirely disregarded.15
As the Act was debated in the Queensland parliament, speakers applauded it as an exemplar of Christian compassion and humanitarianism: ‘a determined effort to ameliorate conditions of the Aborigines’ and to save a ‘dying race’ from extinction.16 The Act established a hierarchy of Aboriginal Protectors and controls over virtually every aspect of the lives of the State’s Aboriginals: where they lived, how they worked, their money, family and movements. At the heart of this labyrinth of regulators and regulations was the provision for the forced removal and confinement of Indigenous Australians and ‘half-castes’ to missions and reserves. The Act promised an answer to some of the most devastating effects of colonisation: the suffering, dispossessed and diseased on the margins of colonial society, and the swelling numbers of ‘half-castes’ threatening the chimera of a racially pure ‘White Australia’. For Gribble, the Act sanctioned his unofficial, five-year alliance with the Cairns police and was a legislative avenue for satisfying his dream of making Yarrabah a home for all north Queensland’s Aboriginal people. Dr Walter Edmund Roth agreed. The newly appointed Northern Protector of Aborigines was convinced that the only protection for the Aboriginal race was complete isolation from the evil, corrupting influence of white society. The seclusion and fertility of the Cape Grafton Reserve offered the perfect sanctuary. In his more sensible moments, Roth conceded that it was physically and financially impossible to segregate all indigenous people on reserves. Nevertheless, he was ‘firmly of the opinion that . . . the time will arrive when the remnant of the State’s autochthonous population will be ultimately gathered together and located’ at Yarrabah.17 It was an empty hope. Gribble’s records reveal that only eight Aboriginals were sent to Yarrabah under the provisions of the Act during its first two years of operation. Despite this fact, Yarrabah’s
A Terribly Wild Man-TEXT PAGES 22/12/01 7:01 AM Page 39
CLASPING
T H E I R C H I L D R E N T I G H T LY
39
population exploded between May 1897 and June 1900. It was the development of the surrounding region that changed the mission’s future. Settlers poured into the north Queensland region, determined to make their fortunes. The population of Cairns increased more than four-fold soon after it was declared a town in 1876. By 1893 the hinterland was densely populated with new settlements and a railroad linked the towns of Redlynch, Kuranda and Mareeba. Timbergetters plundered cedar from the hills behind Cairns and along the Johnstone and Daintree Rivers. In their place, settlers planted orchards, rice fields, dairy farms and plantations of coffee, bananas and sugar. In the west, cattle stations were established, tin and gold strikes drew hundreds of speculators to the south, and land development accelerated. The impact on the local Aboriginal communities was devastating. As early as the mid-1880s, the Kongkandji’s nearest southern neighbours, the Indindji, were having trouble finding food, while Aboriginals between Mossman and the Mulgrave River and around Townsville were literally starving. By the 1890s, it was reckoned the Aboriginal population of Townsville had been reduced by at least 75 per cent. Aboriginal groups responded to the invasion by attacking settlers and their property, and colonists were so afraid of being speared that a Native Police Force was established on the Mulgrave River for the explicit purpose of exterminating Aboriginal opposition. The Kongkandji had a close relationship with their southern neighbours, the Indindji. Their territories overlapped, they shared a similar material culture and participated in each other’s ritual cycles. In the winter, the Kongkandji visited the Indindji for ceremonies and seasonal trading. In the warm weather, the Indindji moved to the coast to feast on digil (Mulgrave walnut) and murgan (quandong). The Kongkandji’s connections were hospitable but less intimate with the more distant Irukandji, to the north along the Barron River and between Cairns and Port Douglas, and the Maday or Wanur to the south. Nevertheless, Cape Grafton and Kongkandji territory was the regular gathering point for regional corroborees
A Terribly Wild Man-TEXT PAGES 22/12/01 7:01 AM Page 40
40
A T E R R I B LY W I L D M A N
and the nexus of vigorous trade routes that radiated to all points of the compass. By 1894, however, the sea trade between the groups had ended. Dislocated from their lands, the Kongkandji’s neighbours were losing the battle for survival. When timbergetters moved into their territory a few kilometres south of Yarrabah, the Indindji sought refuge with the Kongkandji, but their presence strained food supplies, restricted territorial movement, disrupted Kongkandji spiritual life and incited conflict over sacred sites, rituals and territory. Jinny Katchewan was among the first girls to settle at Yarrabah and oral tradition has it that she sought sanctuary at the mission after the Kongkandji were attacked by Aboriginal invaders and her mother killed and decapitated. These circumstances left the Kongkandji and the Aboriginal groups around Cairns with few choices. The Elders disapproved, but Yarrabah seemed a viable alternative to tribal conflict or exploitation and poverty on the fringes of white settlement. Gribble’s mission became a refuge for people in crisis. As the mission’s population expanded, Gribble’s superiors in Sydney worried. Their missionary had accumulated a mass of unauthorised bills in Cairns and creditors were threatening to sue. The problem, Gribble insisted, was the ABM’s inadequate financial support, but the ABM Executive claimed that Gribble was personally responsible and threatened to advertise in the Cairns newspaper disassociating itself from Gribble and his mission if any more debts were incurred. Despite this uncomfortable difficulty, there were portents that Gribble’s dream might be realised. Yarrabah was starting to take on the appearance of a family fiefdom. His siblings, Stuart, Illa and Stella were sent to Brisbane in 1895 to attend school and escape reoccurring bouts of malaria, but Mary Ann stayed on as Hospital Matron and Amelia worked with the women and girls. Gribble’s brother, Bert, was unemployed during the depression and lived at the mission from May 1896 to July 1897. Ethel Gribble taught in the school, and when Illa returned from boarding school she helped her sister and worked in the girls’ dormitory.
A Terribly Wild Man-TEXT PAGES 22/12/01 7:01 AM Page 41
CLASPING
T H E I R C H I L D R E N T I G H T LY
41
In 1898, the Queensland government made Yarrabah a food distribution centre for Aboriginals. The annual funding of £120 meant that there was finally enough money to feed the mission’s increasing numbers. Meanwhile, the impressive development of the mission meant Gribble’s pleas for staff no longer fell on deaf ears. The ABM sent a string of new assistants—although their influence paled alongside the dominance of the Gribble family. Relieved of the urgency to augment mission numbers and feed the populace, Gribble focused on building an orderly, wellregulated community. He had it fixed in his mind that people would be encouraged to settle if he put ‘married Christian blacks in a home of their own in which they can take pride’.18 The men spent their days building, steam-milling, wire-fencing, ploughing, carting wood, felling scrub and cotton-picking, while the women were kept busy caring for the small children, sewing, washing, baking and doing housework. Amelia’s role in the daily life of the mission was limited but she taught the women embroidery and needlework, and the Yarrabah Rule Book instructed these diligent homemakers to have fresh flowers on the meal table every day. Any man wanting to marry had to build a hut first and part of any income earned outside the mission—picking coffee or working the beche-de-mer boats—had to go towards a verandah or domestic utensils for their home. Gribble religiously enforced the Protestant ethic ‘that work is noble, and that all should contribute to the general good’.19 The resulting air of settled domesticity took visitors by surprise. Gilbert White, soon-to-be Bishop of Carpentaria, was greatly impressed by the married couples’ small slab houses and carefully weeded gardens when he visited in 1896, while another visitor commended the fact that Willie Ambrym, Gribble’s assistant, had married and settled comfortably in a snug, clean and neat home. Throughout the day, the strident tones of the mission bell split the air, reverberated through the settlement and echoed off the hills to dictate the rhythm of life in defiance of the weather, day or season. The bell was ignored in the camp where the older
A Terribly Wild Man-TEXT PAGES 22/12/01 7:01 AM Page 42
42
A T E R R I B LY W I L D M A N
Kongkandji and Indindji lived close enough to access the mission’s tobacco but distant enough to follow the cadences of life ordained by nature and tradition, and where visiting missionaries bemoaned the ‘evidence that Satan was reigning in their midst; the dirt, the squalor and sin being indescribable’.20 On the mission, supervised teams worked industriously in accordance with the apostolic rule that if ‘you do not work you do not eat’. Discipline seemed to prevail. The list of punishable offences was clearly defined: disobedience, bad language, insubordination, refusing to work, laziness, incorrigibility and the theft of food. Each week the men and boys did military drill, the girls exercised with Indian clubs and the missionaries inspected the married couples’ homes to award points and prizes for tidiness and cleanliness. Even the inmates’ appearance suggested order. The uniform for the men was a sulu of red turkey twill, the women wore voluminous, shapeless shifts and the crew of the mission boat W.M. Cowper looked tidy and sharp in smart sailor jackets and caps with the name of their boat on the rim. Life was not all discipline and regulation. Gribble considered it the ruin of missions to ignore the importance of games in building character and a good home life. Cricket and football were regular highlights at Yarrabah, along with frequent outings, entertainment and concerts. Gribble’s capacity to laugh easily and his personal involvement in the life of every inmate won him the affection and respect of the people. On 26 December 1899, Gribble crowned Menmuny ‘King of Yarrabah’. Outside the mission compound Menmuny deferred to the Kongkandji Elders, but inside the mission he was King John Barlow and wore the red garb of the Moreton Bay Regiment. He officiated at meetings, sat on a throne in the Church and his son, Albert Maywe, was declared his successor. These facts did not stop Gribble from correcting Menmuny’s behaviour and making it clear that any serious offence would mean losing the dignities of office. Explorer Richard Dyott visited Yarrabah and summed up Menmuny’s role: ‘no real power in the management of the
A Terribly Wild Man-TEXT PAGES 22/12/01 7:01 AM Page 43
CLASPING
T H E I R C H I L D R E N T I G H T LY
43
mission, Mr G [sic] merely keeping him nominally at the head of affairs so as to use his influence for the good disciplining of the local tribe’.21 At his investiture, claimed Gribble, Menmuny confirmed this distribution of power: I am your king . . . I have got a lot of people to look after. And when you have any trouble with anybody, leave it to me, for I am king. When your wife growl, do not hit her, but leave it to me. When anything go wrong, leave it to me, and I will leave it to Mr Gribble.22
The year 1899 also saw Gribble institute the Yarrabah Government and Yarrabah Court. The former met monthly to devise rules and routines. The Court met weekly to settle disputes, rule on offences and to impose punishments. Some of Gribble’s contemporaries liked to fancy that there were parallels between a traditional meeting of elders and the Court and Government of Yarrabah, and commended Gribble for using native customs to preserve law and order so wisely. The Government originally consisted of twelve male Aboriginal communicants but Gribble later reduced this number to three and maintained the right of veto over all nominations. The Government’s term of office hinged on the behaviour of its members: ‘A Government will go out of office on the misbePhaviour of any of its members, lack of interest, non-attendance at meeting, disrespect to the Murra-gnarra [King], failure in regular attendance at Church Services’.23 In later years, a mission visitor reported that ‘Mr Gribble reports, King John admonishes, and suggestions are received from the floor’ but that the community does not participate in decision-making or formulating policy.24 Punishments, however, were executed by the King or the Governor of the Court, some of whom were reputed to be very cruel: they tied up and flogged offenders. Gribble’s greatest joy was the Cadet Corps, which was established in 1899. There was weekly drill with lances decorated with the mission colours, ritualised sham battles and each month the cadets donned their uniforms and the Union Jack was hoisted while the mission residents sang ‘God Save the Queen’. Gribble was
A Terribly Wild Man-TEXT PAGES 22/12/01 7:01 AM Page 44
44
A T E R R I B LY W I L D M A N
sergeant and he relished inspecting the ranks in full military dress. At the instigation of the Northern Protector of Aborigines, Dr Roth, the Queensland government provided the Cadets with obsolete snider rifles—the same rifles used by Native Police to silence black opposition to white settlement. Nevertheless, Dr Roth and Home Secretary Foxton were impressed: the Cadet Corps ‘teaches these lads to rely on their own self defence, and . . . encourage[s] them in a sense of esprit de corps’.25 Only one ingredient was missing. Yarrabah still had no priest. In lieu of an alternative, Gribble replicated the evangelical, nonconformist tradition in which he was reared. He held informal prayer meetings, homilies and Bible readings, taught Sankey’s hymns, welcomed Methodist ministers and temperance preachers, and insisted that wrong-doers publicly express sorrow for their sins during services. Yet, because he could not administer the sacraments, the spiritual life of Yarrabah as an Anglican community suffered and the mission’s first group of confirmees had to wait twelve months to make their first communion. Gribble’s future looked bleak for he had not even started the rigorous program of theological study and examinations needed for ordination. His chance of moving up the ranks from deacon to priest seemed slim until a small window of opportunity appeared: Bishop Barlow went away. In his absence, the kindly Archbishop Saumerez Smith agreed to give Gribble ‘directions’ about the contents of the ordination exam and an ‘abbreviate[d] . . . range of questions’ for the sections on Holy Scriptures and Doctrinal Theology.26 Gribble passed his examination and was hastily priested by the Archbishop on 1 January 1899, before Bishop Barlow returned and blocked his ordination by invoking the thorny question of episcopal jurisdiction. After his ordination, Gribble replaced the daily prayer meetings with Matins and Evensong and instituted the High Church custom of having the congregation turn to the east when singing the Gloria. A surpliced choir preceded his entry into the church and processions led by the mission ensign—the red and white
A Terribly Wild Man-TEXT PAGES 22/12/01 7:01 AM Page 45
CLASPING
T H E I R C H I L D R E N T I G H T LY
45
cross of St George—were routine for Holy Days and celebrations. Although the comfortable predicability of High Church ritual avoided the need for passionate demonstrations of spiritual conviction, Gribble held tight to the ‘hell-fire and brimstone’ style of preaching inherited from his father: Oh! Father Gribble good preacher. He had a big pulpit in church. He used to stand there and preach to the people. He’d lay the law down for the people to understand . . . and talk plain so they can know what he’s preaching about. [He was] the biggest shouter. Yeah! He hit the pulpit [thump] . . . like that when he’s preaching to drive that word in. Yeah that’s right! [thump] when he’s preaching [thump] . . . [He was a] loud speaker . . . he talk very loud sometimes [and] . . . he talk long. We all go to sleep. [When] Father preach . . . not one girl sitting up. We all laying down asleep.27
Faith and common sense cautioned Gribble not to lapse into the venial sin of vanity but after eight years at Yarrabah he could not help but feel a surge of pride as he surveyed the land alongside Trinity Bay. The change was remarkable and satisfying. A tidy, ordered settlement had emerged. He had subdued the unruly rainforest, and an impenetrable tangle of tree ferns, vines and lichen-smothered rainforest on the hills behind the mission was the only reminder of how the place had once looked. In pride of place was a church resplendent with his coveted stained-glass windows. Gribble named it after St Alban. This English saint’s feast day was 17 June—the anniversary of JB’s landing at Trinity Bay. St Alban died a martyr to his faith after being beheaded by the Romans. The parallels with JB’s life struck Gribble as appropriate. Above the altar was inscribed the phrase that had guided his father and that Gribble would give pride of place in all his churches: ‘Lift up thy heart for the remnant that is left’. Through the settlement there were regimented lines of single-roomed huts of woven palm leaves for the married inmates and a melange of dormitories, stables, kitchens and sheds. Plantations of sweet potato, bananas and corn struggled in sheltered out-stations beyond the main settlement, cattle, goats and chickens promised a supply
A Terribly Wild Man-TEXT PAGES 22/12/01 7:01 AM Page 46
46
A T E R R I B LY W I L D M A N
of meat, milk and eggs, and a jetty cut the mouth of Trinity Bay. The baptismal register at the rear of St Alban’s Church documented a swelling number of converts. On Sundays the small church filled to overflowing for services led by a scrubbed and surpliced choir, carefully coaxed into tune by Amelia. In 1895, Gribble began a class for selected converts with the explicit purpose of making them teachers to their countrymen. Within a few years inmates read and preached at services and proselytised amidst the people in the surrounding districts. By the turn of the century, 85 inmates had been baptised and seventeen had been confirmed. Christianity seemed to have taken hold and a steady stream of missionaries flowed to Yarrabah to study Gribble’s methods and diffuse them throughout north Queensland to Mapoon, Weipa, Cape Bedford and Bloomfield River missions. To any outsider, Yarrabah had all the hallmarks of success. Missionary News reported that Police Sub-Inspector Cooper of Cairns visited Yarrabah in his capacity as Aboriginal Protector and was: most agreeably surprised . . . Rev. E.R. Gribble deserves the greatest credit for the system and management obtaining on the place . . . the Mission is doing excellent work all round.28
The Cairns Morning Post was usually quick to criticise Gribble on almost every matter but it deviated from this predictable path in 1897: He has been by turn builder, doctor, blacksmith, planter, schoolmaster, governor and many other things. He has planned and carried on one of the most successful fruit plantations in Northern Queensland . . . He has made the blacks under his care into surprisingly good Christians, and has, in short, working almost single handed, made an improvement which has been regarded as impossible.29
The Bishop of Carpentaria, Gilbert White, was lavish in his praise: Before Mr Gribble started his work the blacks were living as savages; now there [sic] were leading sober, respectable lives in houses erected by themselves and kept scrupulously clean. They worked year in and year out to support their families, and there [sic]
A Terribly Wild Man-TEXT PAGES 22/12/01 7:01 AM Page 47
CLASPING
T H E I R C H I L D R E N T I G H T LY
47
appearance showed no tendency to break back to savagedom . . . They were engaged in agriculture, and grew fruit trees and rice and the mission in a few years would be entirely self-supporting. It was one of the most remarkable instances of successful mission work in modern times.30
Such affirmation encouraged Gribble’s bent for self-promotion and he informed the faithful that Yarrabah was ‘the best Aboriginal Enterprise in the State’.31 His world was now in order. His dominion seemed complete. There were few portents of the trials that lay ahead.
A Terribly Wild Man-TEXT PAGES 22/12/01 7:01 AM Page 48
3
P ORRIDGE
FOR EVERY MEAL
G
ribble’s perpetual worry was that his secluded sanctuary on Cape Grafton would be invaded. When the Land Commission approved the logging of Buddabadoo to the south, Gribble expected vice, opium and alcohol to flood into the mission. He acted quickly by settling five married couples at Buddabadoo and informing the Home Secretary that a ‘native village’ occupied the area. The intrusion was thwarted. Rocky Island was the focus of a second territorial tussle. This bare, stony outcrop in the centre of Mission Bay was home for Yarrabah’s rapidly increasing herd of goats. The Inspector of Nuisances in Cairns donated the animals to the mission after they wantonly devoured the towns’ gardens but the goats demolished Yarrabah’s plantations, so Gribble dispatched them to the indestructible confines of Rocky Island. The island lay outside the Cape Grafton Aboriginal Reserve but Gribble considered it mission territory by right of occupation. When local fishermen were licensed to work Mission Bay and use Rocky Island as their base, Gribble viewed it as an open declaration of war. These developments made him panicky, nervous and defensive. He bombarded a bevy of officials—the Inspector of Police, the Northern Protector of Aborigines, the Commissioner of Police 48
A Terribly Wild Man-TEXT PAGES 22/12/01 7:01 AM Page 49
PORRIDGE
F O R E V E RY M E A L
49
and the officers of the Department of Lands—with protests and complaints about the white invasion. In the light of these developments, he decided it was urgent to occupy the entire reserve to ‘prevent interference on the part of outsiders’ and to protect the Kongkandji.1 At a cost the mission could ill-afford, he bought out the fishermen, stationed his boatman, Andrew Obah, on Rocky Island and built a string of out-stations radiating from the main settlement across the Cape Grafton Reserve. Occupancy was nine-tenths of the law. The townsfolk of Cairns looked on and damned him. In their eyes his territorial ambitions smacked of hypocrisy and betrayal. The local press launched a stinging denunciation decrying his actions as obsessive, compulsive and vindictive. The attack took Gribble by surprise but he responded swiftly and astutely by snaring the support of Queensland’s two most influential men in Aboriginal Affairs: the Home Secretary, Justin Fox Greenlaw Foxton and the Northern Protector of Aborigines, Dr Walter Edmund Roth. Gribble liked Foxton. At first glance the two men seemed to have little in common. The Home Secretary was 21 years older than Gribble—a dapper-dressing lawyer with a solid bourgeois background who was educated at Melbourne Church of England Grammar School and renowned for his quick and caustic tongue. Yet their affinity ran deep. Foxton was a staunch Anglican, a firm advocate of military training—he was a Colonel in the militia—an ardent Imperialist, passionate cricketer and one-time jackeroo. Gribble was attracted to him instantly. When Foxton visited Yarrabah the two men would stroll through the settlement with their heads bowed, buried in deep discussion. The young missionary deferred to the older statesman but they were likeminded on all the key issues that were precious to Gribble: the moral obligation of white society to protect Aboriginals; the need for tighter legislative controls to segregate Aboriginals for their own protection; and the powerful ‘civilising’ influence of religious instruction.
A Terribly Wild Man-TEXT PAGES 22/12/01 7:01 AM Page 50
50
A T E R R I B LY W I L D M A N
His relationship with the scholarly Dr Roth was more relaxed, familiar and open. Gribble was only eight years younger than Roth and bewitched by the Northern Protector’s incisive intellect. Roth was a scientist: a careful, accurate observer who methodically and painstakingly detailed the customs of Aboriginal groups throughout north Queensland. He practised medicine briefly in the north of the State after migrating from London in 1887, but was rescued from this pale existence by the same passion for ethnography that captured his older brother, Henry Ling, author of The Tasmanian Aborigines (1890). Roth’s ethnographic writings were among the first systematic documentation of Aboriginal life in Australia and he won international recognition and awards for his work. Gribble tried to imitate the talent he admired so greatly in Roth. He subscribed to the Australasian Anthropological Journal and Science of Man, and even published a handful of letters and articles on Kongkandji social customs, initiation rites and language. It was mere tinkering. He had no talent for languages, never saw an initiation ceremony and his knowledge of social customs was limited to what Menmuny told him. In the end, it was a fleeting flirtation with scholarship. Gribble lacked the flair, interest and time for a serious commitment to scientific research, especially when the higher duty to ‘convert and civilise’ the Aboriginal people occupied his mind and consumed his energies. Roth and Gribble shared secrets as they smoked their pipes under the spreading mango trees that lined the open ground adjacent to St Alban’s Church. It was during one such exchange that Gribble related the story of his experiences in Western Australia: the violent abuse of Aboriginals, his family’s suffering and his father’s ignoble defeat. Roth empathised. His work was in the heartland of the beche-de-mer industry where he tried to stop the exploitation of black labour. The tragedy that Gribble related was a too familiar tale. The missionary, politician and scientist made a curious trio. They shared a deeply passionate humanitarian concern for Aboriginals and an unwavering belief that they alone could save the
A Terribly Wild Man-TEXT PAGES 22/12/01 7:01 AM Page 51
PORRIDGE
F O R E V E RY M E A L
51
Australian Aboriginal. In their eyes the 1897 Act did not protect Aboriginals from abuse by unscrupulous, wily settlers. The three men were frustrated by the limitations of an Act which defined Aboriginals as those who lived or associated with other Aboriginals. Although government officials were empowered to take ‘children from their Aboriginal environments’, Roth found it hard to ‘claim little waifs and strays’ living with Europeans and was inundated with applications from settlers trying to claim exceptions from the Act for Aboriginal girls ‘brought up as one of the family’.2 Roth knew these girls worked without pay and were often sexually abused, but in an era when Indigenous births were not registered, it was impossible to prove that the girls were under age and procure a conviction of sexual assault. It was easy, alleged some Queensland parliamentarians, to mistake the maturity of ‘native’ girls because they ‘ripened’ earlier in the tropics.3 In August 1899, Foxton and Gribble met at Yarrabah and schemed. Soon afterwards, licensed fishing was banned in Mission Bay and Gribble was gazetted Superintendent of Yarrabah with the power to prohibit and remove trespassers from the Cape Grafton Aboriginal Reserve. This step was necessary, Roth explained, ‘on account of the abuses consequent upon the stubborn determination of many undesirable characters to enter and remain on these reserves’.4 According to explorer Richard Dyott, Gribble put a different spin on his appointment: The Superintendent holds the Government position of protector to the Aborigines . . . he is sole judge of what should or should not be done with the reserve, having full discretionary power to accept an aboriginal or turn him away if incorrigible.5
Gribble moved quickly to assert his new authority. He limited interaction between mission inmates and the outside world; vetted in-going and out-going mail; confiscated all money and gifts; and his written authority was needed to move about the Reserve. Popular wisdom of the time held that the future of the Aboriginal race lay with the children: ‘if any real reform is to be affected
A Terribly Wild Man-TEXT PAGES 22/12/01 7:01 AM Page 52
52
A T E R R I B LY W I L D M A N
in the character and habits of the blacks it must be done when they are children’.6 Under The Industrial and Reformatories Schools Act 1865, any child under fifteen years and ‘born of a half-caste or aboriginal mother’ could be classified as ‘neglected’, arrested and committed to an Industrial School for up to seven years. Gribble, Foxton and Roth saw the Reformatories Act as a vehicle for meeting their mutual desire to ameliorate and protect Aboriginals. Reflecting the views of the era, Foxton argued: ‘if anybody was entitled to the ownership of the aboriginal children it was the Crown’.7 For Gribble, the Reformatories Act was a chance to redress the wrongs inflicted by white society. He had seen dozens of sad cases where a female child brought up by whites had become the victim of her master and died in childbirth, or been abandoned and thrown onto the streets. His heart ached for the tragic plight of these girls and the Reformatories Act was a chance to intervene. He asked Foxton to register Yarrabah as an Industrial and Reformatory School: ‘There are scores of children whom we wish to gather in . . . this being an industrial school for aboriginal children we can get them without any interference on the part of persons interested’.8 This move troubled the Executive of the ABM in Sydney and it worried that Yarrabah might lose its distinctive character as an Anglican mission and become a repository for criminal children. Gribble dismissed these concerns: how could a bevy of bishops and bureaucrats in faraway Sydney know better than their missionary on the ground? On 7 April 1900, the Queensland government gazetted Gribble as Superintendent of the Yarrabah Industrial School. The ABM Executive was stunned at being ignored and Gribble was reprimanded sternly. The censure was too late. Yarrabah’s registration as a reformatory was a fait accompli. According to the government’s official register, sixteen children were banished to Yarrabah during its first year as an Industrial School. In reality Gribble, Roth and the Cairns police quickly abandoned the legal rituals required by the Act. With Roth’s imprimatur, Gribble picked ‘many a little waif and stray’ and took them
A Terribly Wild Man-TEXT PAGES 22/12/01 7:01 AM Page 53
PORRIDGE
F O R E V E RY M E A L
53
to Yarrabah. By 1903, Roth had instructed the police ‘to get all the half-caste boys and girls wandering amongst the black’s camps and charge them as neglected children’. The police willingly handed over children ‘in an informal way without any of them having been before any police court but at the request of Dr. Roth’.9 In 1901, Foxton drove through parliament the long awaited amendments to the 1897 Act, increasing the powers of police and protectors to forcibly remove and confine Aboriginals on missions and government settlements. The collections split families, shattered communities and irreparably scarred the psyche of Aboriginal Australia. Gribble’s involvement in the forcible collection of children provoked loud and embarrassing opposition from the local white community. Some settlers objected on humanitarian grounds. A larger number complained about losing free labour. Regardless of the reason, Gribble’s intervention in local race relations was unwelcome. The Cairns Morning Post summed up the prevailing feeling: Powers have been transferred to this gentlemen which should never have been extended to anyone on this earth, much less to a clergyman . . . Mr Gribble has torn children of tender years away from their parents and virtually held them in slavery while the grief stricken parents have gone on their unconsoled way . . . yet it is left in the hands of the Rev. Gribble to travel through out this district and separate child and parent, brother and sister, for ever . . . what excuse is to be put for the tyranny that is exercised? . . . In the name of humanity, of religion, and of common sense, we denounce a law under which children may be torn from their parents at the option of any one man . . . the Aborigines Protection Act has resulted in a far worse state of slavery than was ever experienced in the Southern States of America [and] is not only a serious menace to human liberty but an unwarrantable interference with commerce . . .10
The opposition cut Gribble to the core. In his heart he knew he acted with virtue and integrity and that his sole concern was to serve the best interests of the Aboriginals. Seething with anger, he ranted and raved to anyone who would listen about the bitter and
A Terribly Wild Man-TEXT PAGES 22/12/01 7:01 AM Page 54
54
A T E R R I B LY W I L D M A N
inexplicable opposition of Cairns to his humane and Christianlike work. His contempt for white society deepened. The union of the missionary, politician and scientist was tested by two particularly public controversies. In 1901, the Cairns Bench of Magistrates defied a directive from Roth by refusing to apply the Reformatory Act to a young girl called Jeannie Forbes and sentence her to confinement at Yarrabah. Jeannie was not neglected, the magistrates claimed, and she did not want to go to Yarrabah. Foxton stepped in and overturned the magistrates’ ruling but his intervention provoked angry questions in Queensland’s Legislative Assembly: why was Jeannie forcibly removed from a ‘comfortable and . . . happy’ home to a life of privation and isolation on a mission? The response to Foxton’s assurances that Jeannie was ‘in Mr Gribble’s own house, and is as well cared for as she was formerly’ was a thinly veiled hint that Gribble was a moral threat to the Aboriginal women of Yarrabah: Although white people were excluded from the mission station, halfcaste children were still born there. Of course, Mr Gribble could not be blamed for all that went on there as he was often away.11
In the end, the trio won. Foxton decreed that an honest and unbiased report from Gribble would decide Jeannie’s future. Not surprisingly, Gribble counselled that Jeannie stay at Yarrabah and Dr Roth endorsed his recommendation. The Jeannie Forbes case sparked a spiteful spat between the two local newspapers. The Cairns Argus attacked its competitor, the Morning Post, for publicly criticising Gribble and Yarrabah. The Post retaliated by accusing the editor of the Argus of having ‘a big claim on the nursery department at Yarrabah [and being] entitled to be called ‘‘Dad’’ by a black Mareeba piccaninny’. The Post threatened to publish all the lurid details if the criticisms of its editorial position continued, and the ensuing silence of the Argus stimulated interesting conjecture in Cairns for some time thereafter. The second controversy involved Lizzie Johnstone. An attractive girl of Aboriginal and Spanish parentage, Lizzie was barely in
A Terribly Wild Man-TEXT PAGES 22/12/01 7:01 AM Page 55
PORRIDGE
F O R E V E RY M E A L
55
her teens in August 1900 when Roth had her forcibly removed from the Bloomfield River home of Phillip Johnstone and committed to Yarrabah as a neglected child under the Reformatory Act. Her benefactor, the Portuguese-born Johnstone, had a long and notorious reputation as a local ‘combo’: a white man who shared his bed with black women. Johnstone was reputed to like rough sex and young girls, but the nubile Lizzie had snared the ruffian’s heart and Johnstone was distraught when she was taken away. Roth wired Gribble that Johnstone had offered to marry his young love if they were reunited, and Gribble responded by announcing that Lizzie was happy at Yarrabah and wanted to marry Billie Brown, another mission resident. John Hamilton, government whip and Member of the Legislative Assembly for Cooktown, took up Johnstone’s cause, accusing Gribble of coercing Lizzie into marriage to keep her at Yarrabah. The slur was splashed across the pages of the north Queensland newspapers and the Truth. Parliament ordered a magisterial inquiry to get to the bottom of the question. Foxton refused to let Lizzie be interviewed without Gribble, and fed his missionary ally steady reports on the inquiry’s progress. Hamilton threatened to resign if Lizzie stayed at Yarrabah but Foxton refused to retract his support of Gribble. By the end of 1902, the matter was at an impasse. Hamilton stayed in parliament and Lizzie stayed at Yarrabah, but she did not marry Billie Brown. This was the last time the Home Secretary and Gribble joined forces. Foxton retired from the Queensland Legislative Assembly in 1904. Although he returned to politics two years later as the Federal member for Brisbane he never again exercised the same sway over the destiny of Queensland’s Indigenous peoples. In January 1901, the Australian colonies became a federated Commonwealth and the white invasion around Cairns was so comprehensive that Gribble could insist that the Kongkandji leave their children ‘entirely in the missionaries [sic] charge’ or be excluded from the mission’s benefits.12 He wanted to ‘have the children more under control, and by having them under lock and
A Terribly Wild Man-TEXT PAGES 22/12/01 7:01 AM Page 56
56
A T E R R I B LY W I L D M A N
key at night will prevent the camp natives taking them off at all hours for corroborees, etc’.13 His threat was so effective that the glut of children could not be housed. There were 29 boys under ten years of age and an army of older lads who slept in the kitchen because there was no room elsewhere. The children entered a new, unfamiliar realm when they joined the mission. They were separated from their parents, baptised, assigned Christian names and inducted into a new set of alien beliefs and behaviours. The influx of new inmates was Gribble’s justification for abandoning his struggle to learn the local languages. He decreed English would be Yarrabah’s lingua franca and the speaking of ‘language’ became a punishable offence. The children attended school for two hours each day and every morning they stood in line after Matins: Father [Gribble] said ‘Now all say this prayer: ‘‘We must not steal, we must not tell lies, we must not say bad words this day’’’. That the words we got to say every morning.14
The roll was called each night and life was strictly supervised: . . . if you want to go out for a walk. The Matron take the girls on the beach and they got to stay in one place without wandering . . . We used to go down every Saturday . . . for a bath in the sea or the creek but not to move away in the bush or anywhere. There’s a prefect . . . got to watch the girls if they wander about.15
Close surveillance, Gribble explained, was necessary to ensure that ‘these Mission children, growing up under Christian teaching lose all touch with native laws and regulations’.16 As life at Yarrabah settled into a steadier, more predictable rhythm, Gribble grew restless and edgy. He was keen to spread his wings further afield, and the Bogimbah Creek settlement on Fraser Island Aboriginal Reserve had caught his eye. The island lies about 800 miles south of Yarrabah opposite the mining town of Maryborough and just a short train ride north of the sedate State capital of Brisbane. Standing on the Queensland mainland and gazing east across Hervey Bay, it looks like a huge, sleeping whale.
A Terribly Wild Man-TEXT PAGES 22/12/01 7:01 AM Page 57
PORRIDGE
F O R E V E RY M E A L
57
The centuries have held it captive between the tranquil waters of Hervey Bay and the Pacific Ocean that pounds Seventy Mile Beach on its eastern coast, moulding it into an elongated key of high sand dunes topped with sparkling, freshwater lakes and a smothering jungle of blackbutt, tallow wood, satinay and vines. The mastermind behind the Bogimbah Creek Aboriginal settlement was Archibald Meston, Southern Protector of Aborigines. Meston was a man of many faces: sugarcane grower, journalist, parliamentarian, explorer, showman, sportsman and bankrupt. A flamboyant, loquacious, byronic character, Meston claimed to be a tribal initiate fluent in several Aboriginal languages. He had an arrogant predilection for public displays of physical prowess and speeches scattered with obscure references to Greek legends that sent journalists scurrying for Bulfinch’s Age of Fable. His was a persona that begged for caricature, and the Bulletin generously obliged by sketching him resplendent in a flowing cape and skintight breeches with bulging muscles and an Aboriginal spear. A dedicated eugenicist and Social Darwinist, Meston put his theories into practice by fathering seven children by his patient wife, and denouncing interracial intercourse as an ‘abomination’ that led to the ‘undesirable’ breeding of ‘half-castes’. The ‘law of the strongest’, the paternalistic Meston argued, should be used to collect and confine Aboriginals on reserves where the race’s tragic decay would be reversed and Rousseau’s ‘Noble Savage’ would be resurrected to hunt, fish and flourish in splendid isolation from all corrupting influences. Any suggestion that Australia’s Indigenous peoples were attached to their own country was dismissed as capricious sentimentality and irrelevant to the new order of the day. Meston had high hopes for the Bogimbah Creek settlement. It was his personal experiment in social engineering and he predicted it would set a permanent precedent for the future management of Aboriginal affairs. By March 1900, Indigenous Australians from more than 30 centres had been rounded up and exiled to Fraser Island. Only someone Meston trusted implicitly could have responsibility for overseeing this precious undertaking:
A Terribly Wild Man-TEXT PAGES 22/12/01 7:01 AM Page 58
58
A T E R R I B LY W I L D M A N
his son Harold was his logical choice—assisted by a group of former Native Police to maintain discipline. Gribble monitored Bogimbah’s development from the start. A scrapbook of newspaper cuttings testifies to his interest. He was sure it was doomed: ‘no government can uplift or develop a primitive race such as this . . . It is the Church alone that can instil into the race, incentives to existence and also to higher existence’.17 When Home Secretary Foxton visited Yarrabah in August 1899, Gribble voiced his concerns. A month later Foxton stopped at Fraser Island. After a cursory inspection he decided the residents were discontented, fearful, superstitious, and Harold Meston’s methods were violent and oppressive. Foxton asked the ABM in Brisbane to take control and recommended Gribble’s appointment as temporary Warden arguing there was ‘no man in Australia so well fitted to assist in starting the mission on a proper basis’.18 A delighted Gribble immediately trekked south. He did not consult the ABM Executive even though two months earlier he had refused to go to Sydney because important matters prevented him leaving Yarrabah. The maverick missionary was duly chastised but to no avail. Gribble spent the next three months at Bogimbah introducing his system of operation. Not long after Gribble arrived at Fraser Island, details about Harold Meston’s brutal regime started to leak to the public: beatings, intimidation, terrified inmates tied-up and abandoned overnight in the graveyard, women and girls coerced into sex, violent summary punishments. Using Yarrabah as his model, Gribble quickly put his imprimatur on the settlement at Bogimbah. The children were separated from their parents and assigned to dormitories, a school was established, a surpliced choir and services were instituted, bells and an hourly timetable decreed the day. Male residents worked clearing and building while the women were kept busy with domestic chores. Gambling and ‘loafing’ were outlawed. Ignoring the tribal diversity among the inmates, an Aboriginal King was appointed. Even Yarrabah’s staple fare of maize-meal porridge was duplicated.
A Terribly Wild Man-TEXT PAGES 22/12/01 7:01 AM Page 59
PORRIDGE
F O R E V E RY M E A L
59
Fraser Island became another marshalling point for the Gribble family. A month after he arrived at Bogimbah, Gribble again incurred the Church’s wrath by appointing his mother, Mary Ann, Matron at Fraser Island without consulting the Bishop of Brisbane or the ABM in Sydney. He later appointed his sister Ethel as schoolteacher and his loyal friend and colleague from Yarrabah, William Reeves, took charge for six months. Gribble kept an eye on things from Yarrabah and visited annually, but other members of his family were on hand to see that his methods were followed loyally. Gribble circulated eloquent, glowing accounts of Bogimbah’s progress under Church control. It was in ‘marked contrast’ to its formerly ‘pitiable condition’, discipline and order had been restored, material development was advancing, and disease had been eliminated.19 In contrast, the Aboriginal inmates described the mission as a prison. Food was chronically short, officials complained that the children were half-starving and that the place was riddled with tribal tension and conflict: ‘There are representatives of many tribes . . . they are very jealous of one another, and if one member is offended will bring up all their side to take their part, and if not prevented will have a fight’.20 Tuberculosis, chest complaints and opium addiction raged and slowly decimated the population. Ankylostomiasis was rampant. This potentially fatal infestation of intestinal hookworm was the result of poor diet and inadequate sanitation. Victims experienced insatiable cravings to eat clay, ashes and charcoal. The only known cure was a generous diet of milk and vegetables but neither was abundant on Fraser Island and sufferers inevitably succumbed to anaemia and died. The mission developed such an appalling reputation that Aboriginals were terrified to be sent there. More than 70 of the inmates absconded and those who were re-captured begged not to be sent back. Archibald Meston smouldered. Fraser Island was his baby and his resentment of Gribble’s intrusion gnawed and festered, making him sour, jealous and vindictive. He dismissed Gribble’s flattering accounts of the settlement’s progress under Church
A Terribly Wild Man-TEXT PAGES 22/12/01 7:01 AM Page 60
60
A T E R R I B LY W I L D M A N
control and the two men became embroiled in an ugly public brawl in the press over who was responsible for the greatest number of deaths among the ill-fated inmates. Meston claimed that as many as 78 Aboriginals died during Gribble’s four years as Warden, while Gribble countered that there were more than 70 graves in Bogimbah’s two cemeteries when the Church took over and many more beyond that he did not bother to count. Meston’s feelings of betrayal deepened in 1903 with the creation of the new post of Chief Protector of Aborigines. The man put in charge of Queensland’s Aboriginals was his long-standing rival, Dr Roth, and Meston was made redundant: ‘I am a year senior to Roth. All practical work has been done by me. He does nothing but write reports and advertise himself to make the Minister believe he is a marvellous man’.21 At some point during those years, Gribble realised that all was not going as planned on Fraser Island. The formula that won him accolades at Yarrabah went strangely awry on the sandy, southern island. This inexplicable fact did not reduce his faith in his methods and he ignored advice to grow vegetables to improve the diet, health and death rate of inmates. Nevertheless, Gribble was unsettled enough to seek the counsel of his friend and ally, Dr Roth. They agreed that Bogimbah was in a sorry state when the Church took over: a nearby swamp exacerbated illness; a succession of Superintendents made for ineffective administration; and Gribble, as absentee Warden, was unable to provide the personal supervision the place needed to succeed. The sensible solution, they decided, was to close the mission and transfer it to Yarrabah. In August 1904, the buildings on Fraser Island were dismantled and transported north to Yarrabah along with 117 inmates. The remaining residents were sent to the government’s Durundur Reserve, near Caboolture. With this act, Gribble and Roth’s vision of making Yarrabah the centre for Queensland’s Indigenous peoples came one step closer to being realised. Gribble’s Fraser Island years were interrupted by three exhilarating adventures. In 1902, Gilbert White, first Bishop of the
A Terribly Wild Man-TEXT PAGES 22/12/01 7:01 AM Page 61
PORRIDGE
F O R E V E RY M E A L
61
recently created Diocese of Carpentaria, decided a mission was needed at Mitchell River on the Gulf of Carpentaria. Surveying the pool of potential candidates, White declared that Gribble’s experience as a pioneering missionary and successes at Yarrabah made him the perfect choice to lead the expeditions to establish the mission. The trek through unexplored territory to the Gulf was exactly the type of project Gribble relished: physically exhausting, potentially dangerous, liberating and thrilling. He was always happiest leading the spartan life of a bushman when he could relive his romanticised memories of a carefree boyhood at Warangesda and an unfettered existence as a drover. In the silence and isolation of the bush it was easy to centre his energies on the elemental engagement with nature and to avoid the more difficult and complex task of interacting with others that life in the wider world demanded. His first trek north was in 1902. Anticipating a hostile reception from the local people, he took two white policemen and five Native Police for protection. On later trips, in 1904 and 1905, his companions included Aboriginal co-workers and the future staff of the mission. The Mitchell River expeditions reawakened his desire to record his life’s story. He had temporarily set this task aside but a real-life adventure with all the elements of a dramatic, gripping yarn re-ignited his enthusiasm. Even before he set out, vivid images were forming: defiant victories over a primordial world, courageous subjugation of uncivilised savages, benevolent bestowal of civilisation and Christianity, mixed with a generous dose of nationalistic fervour. He reported the Mitchell River expeditions in Church journals and they take pride of place in several of his memoirs, especially his first autobiography, tellingly entitled Life and Experiences of an Australian and serialised in the Gosford Times some years later. The first expedition, he wrote, was through country ‘teeming with blacks’ who spoke ‘no English’. According to Gribble’s journal, however, the party did not encounter any Aboriginals on its trek north, although he later claimed they were attacked twice and constantly threatened by
A Terribly Wild Man-TEXT PAGES 22/12/01 7:01 AM Page 62
62
A T E R R I B LY W I L D M A N
the ‘stealthy approach of . . . savages [and] numerous foes’.22 When they arrived at Mitchell River, Gribble reported, he immediately established control over the people and more than 130 sat in a circle and listened attentively while he preached. On the second expedition in 1904, he took two Mitchell River Aboriginals who had been living at Yarrabah and baptised them among their own people: The wild blacks, over two hundred in number, stood on the bank of the lagoon . . . We Christians, seven in number, four whites and three blacks stood near the water. I entered the stream and the two candidates came from their tribe to me in the middle of the water, where I baptised them in the name of the Father, Son, and Holy Ghost. Bendigo took the name of Peter and Grady the name of John, the first two baptised on the new mission.23
In his more modest moments, Gribble admitted that his success at Mitchell River hinged on the Aboriginal members of the expeditions whose presence disarmed the local people. Nevertheless, he reported that by his final visit, the people were openly affectionate. They had prepared the mission site in expectation of his return, willingly carted the missionaries’ supplies and had carefully guarded a gold cross that Gribble lost during an earlier trip. Bishop White was a member of the 1905 expedition and was less certain of the people’s affection. He found them afraid and suspicious. For Gribble, the Fraser Island and Mitchell River interludes were a welcome respite from less easily resolved troubles closer to home. His spats with Cairns continued and rankled, and the first disquieting rifts with Amelia were becoming all too apparent. At best, they interacted with courteous civility. At worst, they argued. The clashes came more frequently—generally over minor domestic irritations of little consequence and no lasting importance—but the rows were more acrimonious, wounding and less easily repaired. They were both ferociously stubborn, neither would admit fault, and they were both sulkers. It was a deadly formula for discord. The growing acrimony between the couple so worried
A Terribly Wild Man-TEXT PAGES 22/12/01 7:01 AM Page 63
PORRIDGE
F O R E V E RY M E A L
63
Amelia’s brother that he wrote to the ABM Executive complaining of Gribble’s conduct towards his wife. The couple never openly discussed this withering of their tenderness and intimacy. To do so would mean acknowledging the growing distance between them and that their dream of a life of affectionate companionship was crumbling, but their respective orbits now intersected so irregularly that each was barely a shadow in the life of the other. It was simple for Gribble to fill the swelling emotional void and to retreat from the brutal reality that his marriage endured on a flimsy, brittle footing of shared history and marital duty. Fresh adventures, new schemes and the increasing number of people in his care kept him busy, absorbed and distracted. It was harder for Amelia. She had felt like something of an interloper when she was newly married and arrived at the family fiefdom. Keen to forge the kind of supportive partnership his parents shared, Gribble latched on to the idea that Amelia would have a freer rein if he relocated his mother and sister to Fraser Island. It did not help. Missionary life did not live up to Amelia’s hopes and no matter how much Yarrabah inched towards Gribble’s notion of an ideal, civilised world, the mean austerity of the mission was a far cry from the generous and comfortable refinement she had left behind in Cairns. Her three young boys were also a handful. Their capacity for childish mischief was boundless, their energy was exhausting and she found it almost impossible to imbue them with any comprehension of the proprieties and obligations of wider society in a world of dark skins and foreign manners. As a father, Gribble was playful, benevolent and stern if necessary but he relegated the task of rearing his sons to Amelia. Besides, he was often lured away and other distractions consumed his time and attention when he was at home. He had taken it upon himself to oversee the minutiae of all that happened at Yarrabah and he was forever occupied mediating domestic disputes, resolving grievances, chastising recalcitrant residents and struggling to put Yarrabah on a viable economic footing. The work sapped his physical and emotional resources. He did not
A Terribly Wild Man-TEXT PAGES 22/12/01 7:01 AM Page 64
64
A T E R R I B LY W I L D M A N
have enough energy or will left to give Amelia the devotion and attention she craved or to compensate for the loneliness and isolation that she felt. At regular intervals Amelia retreated to the sanctuary and cultural familiarity of the Wriede family home in Cairns. Any excuse was enough to justify a trip: some minor illness, Gribble’s absence on another adventure, an inconsequential family celebration. These sojourns became increasingly more frequent and longer lasting. In the end, staying at Yarrabah seemed a pointless façade. What Gribble found unnerving about this unsettled state of affairs was its untidiness, and he sought comfort by burying himself in the job of creating order, predictability and structure at Yarrabah. He divided the mission into neat administrative units: work teams, boat crews, Ambulance Brigade, Boy Scouts, Girls Sewing Guild, and so on. Each group had a smart, distinctive uniform and a Monitor, appointed by Gribble as a reward for good behaviour, who completed a detailed, weekly questionnaire on the performance of each of the charges in their group. The 27 closely typed pages of the Yarrabah Rule Book provided detailed regulations for every contingency: work, leisure, schooling, church attendance, marriage, dress, baking bread, writing on walls and even bathing. No detail was too petty to be ignored. The ‘Rules for Married People’, for instance, specified that: 11. Tables be clean for every meal. 12. Basins, mugs, spoons, dishes to be cleaned at once after every meal. 13. Mugs are to be kept in the proper place. 14. Copper oven and fire places to be kept clean. 15. Tub for bread [to be kept] well clean. 16. Bread to be set each evening. 17. Flowers to be kept on meal table. 18. Table to be properly laid for meals. 19. Bread to be got from the store before bell rings. 10. No boys allowed in kitchen unless at work.
A Terribly Wild Man-TEXT PAGES 22/12/01 7:01 AM Page 65
PORRIDGE
65
F O R E V E RY M E A L
Wharf Flag Staff Boat Shed
MISSION
Wet Shed
St Alban's Church
BAY
B e a c h Rain Gauge
School Hall Infant School Shed
Steps
Gas Works
Mission House
Kitchen
Boys' Dormitory Water Hole
M Tap
Hospital Steps
Bath Room
W.C.
Fire Station
Cottage Girls' Dormitory
M Creek 0
40
Gas line Yards Water main Telephone line Married People's Houses
Engine Shed PA
CRE
EK
Store
Kitchen
Store
W.C.
Fowl House
Washing Shed
ROAD
Pigsty
Horse Paddock
M
Road
M
KAR
Store
M
Fence
King's House
M
M
M
M
M
M
M
M
To Plantation & Reeves Creek
M
M
M
M
Yarrabah Mission
The secular and spiritual merged in the close confines of Trinity Bay. Gribble’s soul was Australian to the core but he was a child reared in the evangelism of British imperialism and his devotion to the Empire was passionate and unwavering. This cultural farrago bred a special brand of muscular Christianity: his favourite text was ‘Fight the Good Fight’ and one of the first hymns he taught mission residents was ‘Onward Christian Soldiers’. Saluting missionaries and mission officers was mandatory for mission residents and non-compliance meant pack-drill or sentry duty. Any imperial event was celebrated with pomp, ceremony and a service. When Queen Victoria died: The bell tolled, the rifle corps of twenty-five men and lads fell in and marched with reversed rifles to the Church . . . stacked their arms outside [then] . . . the choir and missionaries entered. Part of the burial service was read, the hymn ‘O God our help in ages past’ was sung. [Gribble] gave a short address taking for the text ‘A Good
A Terribly Wild Man-TEXT PAGES 22/12/01 7:01 AM Page 66
66
A T E R R I B LY W I L D M A N Name’ (Proverbs xxii, I). The people all listened attentively while [Gribble] spoke of the late, good Queen, her determination ‘I will be good’, her long and good life.24
Gribble jumped at any chance to strengthen imperial connections and regarded the institution of a branch of the Church Lads Brigade (CLB) in 1904 as one of his special achievements. The CLB was a kind of Boy Scouts with an Anglican twist that married religion and militarism with the middleclass values of discipline, sobriety, thrift, self-help, punctuality and obedience. To confirm the imperial connection, and by pulling a few strings, Gribble got the Yarrabah CLB affiliated with its counterpart in London. Gribble actively campaigned to increase Yarrabah’s population but this was a double-edged sword because the incessant arrival of new inmates constantly thwarted his dream of a well-regulated, predictable world. Nevertheless, Yarrabah’s numbers almost tripled between 1900 and 1905, from 122 to 312. They came from more than 57 districts and spoke more than 100 dialects. The new arrivals created new problems. May Smith was about seven when she stepped off the Rio Logue, with the rest of its human cargo from Fraser Island, onto a strange, unfamiliar and frightening shore. She remembered that the old Kongkandji, with their traditional dress, corroborees and tribal fights, terrified the acculturated new arrivals from the south. Virtually no preparation had been made for the arrival of the Fraser Islanders. They lived in tents and their staple fare was ‘porridge for every meal. In the morning, sometimes, they cooked it very careless, you know. They don’t cover the thing properly and the rats get all into that porridge’.25 Hunger inspired one desperate group of inmates to flee to Cairns where they formally registered their complaints about the mission’s food with the Police Magistrate and the editor of the Cairns Morning Post. Gribble’s defence that he could not ‘perform miracles and feed the black multitude on three loaves and three small fishes’ did not fill stomachs or quieten discontent.26 At Gribble’s behest Dr Roth interceded and dismissed the inmates’
A Terribly Wild Man-TEXT PAGES 22/12/01 7:01 AM Page 67
PORRIDGE
F O R E V E RY M E A L
67
protest but the mission’s inadequate diet caused an outbreak of the tragic clay-eating disease, ankylostomiasis, that claimed the lives of at least four inmates. Gribble struggled to preserve the illusion of an idyllic community but discontent and wilful defiance festered among the Fraser Islanders and spread to the other inmates. The undercurrents of discord tormented Gribble. He was baffled by the inmates’ disinterest and ingratitude in the world he had created. Church services became an excuse for lecturing the congregation against running away, reading the mission rules and ‘long talks about disrespect. Some of the chief men of the mission having been rather cheeky and rude in their manner towards their missionaries’.27 Almost every day the Matron of the girls’ dormitory complained of rudeness, insubordination and defiance by the Aboriginal women. On occasions, albeit rarely, Gribble and his staff were physically attacked. Despite his efforts, the number of runaways increased. Some fled as soon they arrived. Many refused to return when captured. Gribble’s dark moods visited more often in the difficult months after the Fraser Islanders arrived and the disconcertingly familiar and menacing depression returned again in intermittent doses of varying intensity. During these drawn-out episodes of melancholy, Gribble could feel his dream of utopia slipping away and he was overcome by a profoundly painful sense of impotence that he could not shake off. The slow disintegration of his relationship with Amelia merely compounded the feeling that he was isolated, abandoned and misunderstood by a hostile world. On the wall of his study hung two leather straps. The Aboriginal inmates called them ‘Yellow Belly’ and ‘Black Tom’. As the frustration, disillusionment and loneliness got the better of him, he used the straps more often on adults and children alike. He suffered deeply during these sorry bouts of self-loathing and unforgiving contempt for mankind, but the mission staff bore the brunt of his moods. His outbursts were ruthless and he viciously accused his staff of being ‘numbskulls’ who did not treat him with
A Terribly Wild Man-TEXT PAGES 22/12/01 7:01 AM Page 68
68
A T E R R I B LY W I L D M A N
‘proper respect’ or were only interested in using Yarrabah as a ‘stepping-stone’ towards Holy Orders.28 Meanwhile, ill-health and the tropics had taken its toll on Bishop Christopher Barlow. In 1902 he resigned the bishopric of north Queensland to accept the more climatically agreeable See of Goulburn. His replacement, the English-born George Frodsham, was enthroned as Bishop in September 1902 and soon earned a reputation as an energetic supporter of missionary work and evangelism among Aboriginal peoples, Torres Strait Islanders, Polynesians, Japanese and Chinese of north Queensland. His earliest dealings with Yarrabah, the largest mission in his diocese, were less auspicious. Frodsham had not even celebrated his second anniversary as bishop when the staff at Yarrabah made a formal complaint about their Superintendent’s autocratic and violent behaviour. Gribble blamed the Fraser Islanders, alleging that they were rebellious, incorrigible and disruptive. Tribal differences divided them down south but resentment of their transportation united them in the north. In 1905, more than fifteen disgruntled transportees fled and managed to evade recapture. In desperation, Gribble asked the police and Bishop Frodsham to threaten runaways with gaol and begged Roth to approve the use of greater force to punish recalcitrant inmates. As he felt his authority fade and his control languish, Gribble converted Fitzroy Island into a penal colony. The island was a short boat trip across Trinity Bay from Cape Grafton. In years past it was a haven for explorers, traders and beche de mer fishermen because of its sheltered inlets, deep anchorage and ready supply of fresh water, but between 1905 and 1907, Gribble banished about 30 inmates to Fitzroy Island. The ringleaders from Fraser Island were the first to be incarcerated but there were also drunkards, opium addicts, criminals, prostitutes, the diseased, idle and mutinous. Apparently some sins were beyond redemption. The increased population and undercurrents of sedition made Gribble vigilant and anxious that unchecked, petty misdemeanours might foment a climate of mutinous rebellion. To cover any
A Terribly Wild Man-TEXT PAGES 22/12/01 7:01 AM Page 69
PORRIDGE
F O R E V E RY M E A L
69
contingency, he put in place a collection of punishments: imprisonment, expulsion from positions of responsibility, public humiliation, standing barefoot on the tin roof of the bakery all day. Thieves who pilfered food had half their head shaved and runaways from the girls’ dormitory had ‘their head cut baldy’ or were forced to dress in hessian bags. The monthly mission newspaper, the Yarrabah Times (later the Aboriginal News), published the names and crimes of delinquents: ‘Porridge spoilt twice, once by Annie and once by Rosie Nothadge . . . once Jessie used bad language’.29 The brew of discipline and dogma blurred the divide between the secular and the spiritual. Services began and ended each day, attendance was compulsory, recalcitrant residents were chained during services, late arrivals were punished and absentees were deprived of rations until their non-appearance was explained satisfactorily. Only the baptised could vote for members of the Mission Court and Government and these elected officials had to be confirmed male communicants and ‘true xtians [sic] who really believe that the mission is the only place where they can be truly happy’.30 Meanwhile, Yarrabah’s debts mounted and donations dwindled. At the behest of the ABM, Gribble wrote a series of articles to prod the generosity of the faithful. His chronicles were in the tradition of tales from the missionary field: full of prepubescent brides; mysterious customs; and humorous anecdotes about rain-doctors and medicine men. The response was indifferent. The faithful found missions in China, India and Africa more alluring. Meanwhile, Yarrabah’s physical development continued at a frenetic pace. A hospital, school, extensions to the girls’ dormitory appeared; gas lighting and telephones were connected to the main buildings; more out-stations were established; and a new cutter, the Hepzibah, was purchased for beche de mer fishing. The AMB nagged Gribble to be judicious with funds but he ignored the cautions. The mission’s debt skyrocketed. Ever since he arrived, Gribble had raved about Yarrabah’s
A Terribly Wild Man-TEXT PAGES 22/12/01 7:01 AM Page 70
70
A T E R R I B LY W I L D M A N
potential to be self-supporting and financially independent. He struggled desperately to live up to his promises and planted coffee, Indian rubber and cocoa but these crops took years to return a profit, and cash-crops of rice, bananas and pawpaws did not break even. New ventures were soon neglected in favour of more enticing schemes. When Gribble concocted a plan to transform Yarrabah’s plantations into grasslands for cattle, the Archbishop curtly reminded him that considerable money had already been spent converting the original grasslands into plantations. By 1904, the ABM decided it could not afford to keep Yarrabah and asked the Queensland government to take over all secular aspects of the mission. No other mission, the government responded, was better able to be self-supporting if managed effectively. It was not interested. In October 1905, while Yarrabah’s financial difficulties smouldered, Gribble signed a deal with the Queensland government to use nearby Green Island as a fishing base for the mission. The addition of this jewel to Yarrabah’s crown triggered an orgy of opposition in Cairns. The townsfolk convened a noisy protest meeting and bombarded the Queensland Premier with telegrams accusing Gribble of land grabbing. Gribble was so unnerved by the protest that he withdrew from the agreement. The government pulled out the next day. Green Island was lost but Gribble snared the lease over nearby Fitzroy Island and, in August 1907, Fitzroy and Rocky islands were formally added to the Cape Grafton Reserve. The Cairns Council, Ratepayers Association, and Chamber of Commerce protested but to no avail. They had been outmanoeuvred. After each tussle for territory, Gribble declared a truce with the townsfolk of Cairns. Mission produce was exhibited at the annual Agricultural and Industrial Society Show, the Yarrabah band gave public performances, groups were invited to inspect the mission and Gribble fed the Morning Post anecdotes about Yarrabah and copies of Aboriginal News. Goodwill blossomed, but it only lasted until the next battle.
A Terribly Wild Man-TEXT PAGES 22/12/01 7:01 AM Page 71
PORRIDGE
F O R E V E RY M E A L
71
Dr Roth lent his support to Gribble’s push to win control of Fitzroy Island but the Chief Protector had his own problems. Roth’s efforts to control the exploitation of Queensland’s Indigenous workers brought him into constant conflict with local vested interests and a concerted campaign was launched to remove him from his position as Chief Protector of Aborigines. The charge was led by the pompous, vexatious John Hamilton, Member of the Legislative Assembly for Cooktown. In 1902, Hamilton used parliamentary privilege to accuse Roth of neglecting his duties and jeopardising government revenue by tightening controls on the employment of Indigenous workers. When the allegation was dismissed, Hamilton changed tack and accused Roth of taking grossly indecent photographs of Aboriginals for immoral purposes. The pictures were old and scientific in purpose—they first appeared in Roth’s 1897 Ethnological Studies—and the accusation got short-shift, but the groundswell of malicious defamation did not abate. In 1905, the townsfolk of Cooktown held a protest meeting that resulted in a petition accusing Roth of obstructing officials and neglecting to provide medical treatment for Aboriginals. A formal inquiry exonerated Roth but the following year Joe Lesina, Member of the Legislative Assembly for Clermont, led a vicious campaign claiming the Chief Protector sold native specimens and curios belonging to the Queensland government to a Sydney museum. The Opposition used its numbers in the Queensland Legislative Council to instigate an investigation and Roth was summoned before the Bar of the Council to explain. In the end it was all too much. Ground down and worn out, the Chief Protector resigned, packed his bags and left Australia in July 1906. He spent his remaining years as a magistrate and district commissioner in British Guiana (Guyana) and was the curator and government archivist of Georgetown after he retired in 1928. He died on 5 April 1933. Roth performed one final service for his friend Gribble before he left the country. In 1904, at the request of the Western Australian government, Roth led a Royal Commission into the
A Terribly Wild Man-TEXT PAGES 22/12/01 7:01 AM Page 72
72
A T E R R I B LY W I L D M A N
treatment of Western Australia’s Aborigines. Gribble had briefed him well during those long conferences under the mango trees at Yarrabah and his findings confirmed JB’s allegations twenty years earlier. Roth did not wait to submit his report before he cabled Gribble: ‘If I do nothing, will vindicate your father. Things as bad if not worse than in his time’.31 Roth’s replacement as Chief Protector of Aborigines was Richard Howard. Known as ‘Long Dick’ on account of his height, Howard was a vocal critic of Gribble’s style of management at Yarrabah and of Roth’s policies for the segregation and protection of Aboriginals. The Aboriginal News of April 1905 summed up Gribble’s opinion of the new Chief Protector: ‘We do not think the change will be in the best interests of the blacks’. By 1905, the pressure on Gribble and Yarrabah was mounting. He accelerated the mission’s building program to accommodate the Fraser Islanders but he did so in defiance of directives to exercise economy and quickly accumulated unauthorised debts of nearly £700 to shopkeepers in Cairns. There were already rumblings in the ABM’s Sydney offices that Gribble had to go when a violent cyclone hit Yarrabah on Australia Day 1906. In a few hours the work, sacrifices, struggles and achievements of thirteen years were destroyed. The schools, church, hospital, dormitories and storerooms were completely wrecked. Only one building remained intact. The plantations and farms were transformed into a wasteland of debris. Everything was lost. The devastation was Gribble’s salvation. There were 360 people without housing, food, sanitation or fresh water; the makeshift hospital was overflowing; and an epidemic of ankylostomiasis had broken out. As he immersed himself in caring for others, Gribble’s preoccupation with his own problems eased. Each night he collapsed into bed exhausted, drained and more comfortable with his lot. Sweat was his curative. There was no time for self-absorption. Anglicans responded generously to the tragedy and, in just five months, they donated the £2000 needed to rebuild. The ABM
A Terribly Wild Man-TEXT PAGES 22/12/01 7:01 AM Page 73
PORRIDGE
F O R E V E RY M E A L
73
dispatched its Secretary, the Reverend John Dixon, to keep a check on Gribble’s spending but Gribble had nearly completed the frenetic task of rebuilding by the time Dixon arrived at Yarrabah in July 1906. The Secretary could not help but be impressed with Gribble’s abilities and with the order, discipline and obedience of the mission’s inmates. It seemed that stability had returned to Gribble’s world.
A Terribly Wild Man-TEXT PAGES 22/12/01 7:01 AM Page 74
4
H ORSE - THIEVES AND HARLOTS
T
he young Aboriginal girls, with their long legs and luminous, ebony skin, were a disconcerting distraction for the missionaries at Yarrabah. Their frank pleasure in the sensual firmness of their budding womanhood and their flirtatious giggling and coy whispering were magnetically provocative. As previous generations had always done, they affectionately caressed and fondled each other as they played. To the missionaries, such simple, casual violations of sacrosanct western taboos were erotic and arousing. Tempting promises of sinful gratification seemed to be buried in the girls’ dark, eager eyes and their relaxed, uninhibited ways. On the missionary frontier, white desire and slippery notions of black lust saturated and confounded the colonial psyche. It was alleged that Aboriginals had no idea of virtue, morality or chastity. The women were considered whores: ‘the tempters not the tempted’. The men were alleged to be indolent, insatiable lechers who mistreated their women and threatened the safety and virtue of white wives and mothers.1 The Australasian Anthropological Journal of 1897 told its readers that sexual exploitation was rife among Aboriginals and from birth to burial Aboriginal women were: treated as inferiors, and as merely the convenient drudges, the slaves of passion, the beasts of burden, and the bearers of children, and 74
A Terribly Wild Man-TEXT PAGES 22/12/01 7:01 AM Page 75
HORSE-THIEVES
AND HARLOTS
75
they have no personal rights nor any voice in their own disposal, but are simply chattels and property of the father, brothers, husbands or any other of the males.
The fragmentary ethnographic evidence tells a different story. The Aboriginal people around Cairns had a strict code of morality and virtue. Licentiousness was contained by the threat of being labelled chiabai or tarpar (prostitute or slut). Although sexual freedom before marriage was sanctioned, it was subject to strict controls defined by kinship, betrothal obligations and inter-tribal law. Wife-lending was only permitted within clearly defined constraints and infidelity was not tolerated. Violations of these basic tribal precepts could be punished by public ridicule, maiming and, in exceptional cases, death. Despite these facts, the sensual nature of man prevailed on the frontier. Here temptation and race intertwined, and religious repression and social convention held no sway. Rape and brutality was rife, food and sexual favours were shared, ‘combos’ and concubines found mutual solace, and the burgeoning number of part-Aboriginal children in the camps around the towns was undeniable proof of the gulf between moral rhetoric and sexual practice in north Queensland at the beginning of the twentieth century. There was little compassion among white Australians for the offspring of interracial unions. In mid-1910, the Townsville Daily Bulletin was blunt. Sexual intercourse between black and white produced nothing but ‘horse-thieves and harlots’. The Cairns Police Magistrate, P.G. Grant, voiced an opinion that cut across all strata of white society when he wrote that the: co-mingling of the races tends to lower the white, without elevating the black, while their offspring would possess the physical vitality of neither and would inherit the vices of both, but not the virtues of either.2
Gribble’s unconditional support for the official moral canons of Christianity and colonial society was a legacy of his puritan
A Terribly Wild Man-TEXT PAGES 22/12/01 7:01 AM Page 76
76
A T E R R I B LY W I L D M A N
upbringing. He subscribed unquestioningly to the belief that mankind was innately licentious and sinful, and that moral virtue was the prerequisite for spiritual salvation and a place in God’s eternal heavenly kingdom. For Gribble, Aboriginal cultural practices like infant betrothal, pre-pubescent marriage and wife exchange were irrefutable evidence of moral and social depravity. As a humanitarian and priest, Gribble reasoned, it was his duty to transform his dark-skinned heathen charges into models of Christian virtue and moral propriety by example and decree. Religion and repression proved inadequate antidotes for desire. Yarrabah’s first casualty was Gribble’s enigmatic assistant, Mr Pearson. The particulars of Pearson’s origins have been lost in time but the known facts are that this tall, young man with the opulent moustache had only been at Yarrabah a few months before Gribble learned he had ‘fallen into sin’. He insisted on Pearson’s immediate resignation: ‘it is a most serious affair’.3 The ABM Executive accepted Pearson’s withdrawal without question or discussion, promptly and permanently severing all connection with its weak-willed worker. The second transgression savaged Gribble’s moral sensibilities more cruelly. Work was scarce as Australia recovered from the effects of the 1890s depression and Gribble’s younger brother was out of work. JB and Mary Ann had duly christened their third son John Benjamin Herbert when he was born in Shepparton in September 1874, but everyone blithely ignored this fact and he was known simply as Bert. The unemployed Bert joined the Gribble clan at Yarrabah in mid-1896 but only stayed for eleven months before quitting the mission in July 1897. His abrupt departure was caused by the discovery that Jinny Katchewan, the 15-year-old Kongkandji wife of Gribble’s Aboriginal assistant, Pompo, was four months pregnant with his child. Their daughter, Susie, was born on 3 January 1898. Jinny could barely speak English—even as an old lady after almost a lifetime on the mission—and it is doubtful that Bert knew more than a smattering of ‘language’ since Gribble insisted on English in the mission. The story handed down through
A Terribly Wild Man-TEXT PAGES 22/12/01 7:01 AM Page 77
HORSE-THIEVES
AND HARLOTS
77
the generations at Yarrabah was that lust filled the conversational void: Jinny was raped by the priest’s brother. Rather than heightening Gribble’s sensitivity to the frailties of human nature, these two episodes confirmed his opinion that man was inherently lascivious and steeled his resolve to see Christian morality and virtue reign supreme in his domain. The result was a long catalogue of rules to cleanse Yarrabah of lust and licentiousness. Boys and girls were segregated in separate playgrounds and attended school at different times; adults were separated during work, holiday outings and Church services; and the dispensary distributed medicine to men and women at different times. Married women were barred from moving around the mission by themselves, talking to male visitors or being outside their homes after dark. When their husbands were away, wives had to move into the girls’ dormitory to ‘prevent scandal’.4 The dormitory was surrounded with wire fencing and the doors were locked from 6 pm to 6 am, but the bravest girls risked a caning by breaking the netting between the ceiling and wall and escaping for clandestine midnight trysts with beaus. The more timid eagerly awaited church services as a chance to exchange love letters and make hopeful eyes at a potential suitor. Gribble kept a register of betrothed couples on the desk in his study. Every liaison required his personal consent and the names of each couple were carefully checked off when they met on Sunday afternoons under the watchful eye of the dormitory Matron who made sure there was no kissing or touching. Marriage was Gribble’s cure for carnal desire. It was, inmates reputedly told Dr Roth, ‘the guaranteed way of salvation’.5 Weddings meant a feast and public holiday, group marriages were commonplace and serial monogamy was de rigeur. After four new arrivals fled Yarrabah to rejoin their wives, Gribble complained to Roth: ‘if their women were sent . . . such people . . . would far more readily settle down’.6 Marriage meant emancipation from the dormitory but hopeful couples had to be baptised, promise to settle permanently at Yarrabah and prove that they were committed community citizens:
A Terribly Wild Man-TEXT PAGES 22/12/01 7:01 AM Page 78
78
A T E R R I B LY W I L D M A N Persons wishing to Marry and having obtained the consent of the Head of the Mission must . . . produce a written report as to conduct and character from the persons under whom they have lived and worked for the past three months. The court will also decide whether the persons have been doing a fair share in the daily work of the Mission.7
In his eagerness to encourage matrimony, Gribble let other principles slide. It was an unspoken rule that Aboriginal men had to marry a part-Aboriginal woman, and widows and widowers were remarried with almost indecent haste. Gribble knew any union was supposed to accord with tribal kinship rules: Among the first bush natives who came to Yarrabah in December, 1892, were a young man and woman who kept quite apart from the others, in fact it was very evident that they were ostracised by all others. I enquired about them and received the reply that they were ‘no good’ because the woman had married her brother. I at once understood that it was a case of marriage within prohibited degrees. They were really not blood relations. The man whom the woman should have married was away on a beche-de-mer lugger . . . [Two years later the woman was waylaid, her throat cut and thereby] paid for breaking tribal law.8
He assured readers of Missionary Notes that all mission marriages followed tribal Law but he confessed, as he scribbled in his journal during the solitude and silence of the night, that he often broke this fundamental rule. He married Henry Cheemo and Tooey in defiance of kinship laws and the local men attacked Henry for violating tribal precepts. Gribble refused to let Gomerie marry his promised bride, Jinny, because she was barely twelve and Gomerie already had a wife. Yet, within the year, Gribble married Jinny to his assistant, Pompo Katchewan. On the eve of the wedding of George Christian, who appeared in the early photograph with Menmuny, Gribble mused that the marriage would: be an interesting one, for, according to native custom, the girl has been promised from infancy to a native in another tribe, whom she has never seen and with whom she does not wish to go.9
A Terribly Wild Man-TEXT PAGES 22/12/01 7:01 AM Page 79
HORSE-THIEVES
AND HARLOTS
79
In spite of his rules and regulations, passion proved irrepressible. Gribble was constantly tormented by the problem of how to control the weak-willed and defiant who surrendered to carnal desire and thwarted his moral vision. As his frustration grew he concocted stricter rules and harsher punishments to stop illicit intercourse. Any unmarried girl who fell pregnant was told to marry quickly, but the wedding was a dismal, sombre affair: Any girl falling into disgrace necessitating marriage hurriedly [sic], no bridesmaids, best man, wedding dress, decorations or cake allowed at the wedding. The ceremony to be performed privately in the church in the presence of the Mission Staff only.10
If the hapless girl could not snare a spouse, she was banished to Rocky Island to await the birth of her child where her crime could not contaminate the rest of the community. The craggy outcrop on the mainland adjacent to Rocky Island became known as Mothers’ Point, for this was the spot where family and friends gathered to wave to the island’s young, expectant mothers. In 1904, Gribble submitted his annual report to the Chief Protector of Aborigines and bluntly informed Dr Roth that 38 marriages had been performed at Yarrabah since the mission was established. Of this group, Gribble reported, half the women ‘had borne illegitimate children or . . . led immoral lives previous to their advent to the mission [and] have, with one exception, not been blessed with a single infant since’. In contrast, those ‘who had been on the settlement for years, and who had led decent lives, have borne forty-nine children between them’.11 His message was clear, but Gribble’s repressive taboos sat uncomfortably alongside the relaxed pleasure that the Aboriginal inmates took in sensual desire and carnal gratification. Christianity’s notion of assigning shame to out-of-wedlock births was a peculiar concept for the people at Yarrabah where the birth of any child was a cause for celebration and a conduit between the physical present and the spiritual world of the Dreaming. According to tradition, conception occurred when a child was brought to
A Terribly Wild Man-TEXT PAGES 22/12/01 7:01 AM Page 80
80
A T E R R I B LY W I L D M A N
a woman by a Kope (a species of pigeon) during a dream, and fatherhood was a state bestowed on a man when marriage made him the father of the mother’s children. Biology did not confer parenthood. It was a continuation of the Dreaming and an expression of established kinship obligations and responsibilities. It was difficult for the people of Yarrabah to adjust to Gribble’s view of the world. As the spring of 1904 approached, Gribble was busy preparing for his second expedition to the Mitchell River. Amelia chose this time to announce that she wanted to take a house in Cairns. Leaving aside her deepening distaste for mission life, Amelia insisted that Cairns would be more comfortable and companionable while Gribble was away at the Mitchell River. Her logic was uncontestable. When Gribble returned from the Mitchell River two months later, however, he found Amelia contentedly settled in town and armed with a bevy of reasons for staying put: the social and educational welfare of her three boys; nearness to her family; and access to doctors and medical advice. Amelia was as strong as a horse but she had a pathological fear of illness and was constantly running to doctors with some imagined affliction. The heart of the problem was that she did not like mission life. She found it primitive, isolated and lonely. The crumbling relationship with her husband merely intensified the desire to extricate herself from this unpleasant world, and she could not be persuaded to change her mind. In mid-1905, Amelia and the boys went to Sydney. By the time they returned in October 1906, Amelia had resolved her future and presented Gribble with an ultimatum: mission or marriage. Gribble was shocked and distressed but, in his mind, there was no choice: his work was a divine Christian duty and a sacred legacy bestowed by his father. Besides, he felt as much an outsider and misfit in white society as Amelia felt on the mission. The racial divide had split their respective worlds into two physically and spiritually unconnected spheres. There was no meeting point. Over the next year any lingering intimacy between them slowly
A Terribly Wild Man-TEXT PAGES 22/12/01 7:01 AM Page 81
HORSE-THIEVES
AND HARLOTS
81
withered and died. For more than three months Gribble did not even bother to visit Cairns to see his wife or sons. The winter of 1907 began with Amelia packing her belongings and her boys and moving to Brisbane. This step marked the couple’s formal estrangement (notwithstanding two unsuccessful attempts at reconciliation in 1910–13 and 1928–29). As was customary and appropriate for the times, there was no unseemly divorce or public announcement. They sealed an unspoken pact to persist with the pretence of a harmonious marriage and the Church issued the customary explanation that Mrs Gribble’s health necessitated her residence elsewhere. Gribble kept a few shillings of his salary for himself and the modest but comfortable remainder was directed to Amelia and the boys. Despite all the portents, the end hit Gribble hard when it came. He had modelled his life on the image of the committed patriarch courageously protecting Aboriginals with a loyal wife and helper by his side. Amelia sabotaged this dream. Gribble was too shattered to reflect on his role in the disintegration of their union and Amelia’s departure. Even twenty years later he lamented being ‘denied . . . the joy . . . of a good wife [who] will . . . stick [by me] in the work’.12 Amelia’s exit showed that his rigid commitment to the official moral code could not satisfy his dreams or bring him contentment, and his sham marriage made a mockery of the demigods of matrimony and home he had thrust upon Yarrabah’s inmates. Feeling cheated and abandoned, Gribble was overtaken by depression. Plummeting into a barren abyss of morose, black hopelessness, he withdrew into a sullen, pensive haze. His faith faltered and moral questions exhausted his thoughts. He became silent, sulky and withdrawn. As his mental state deteriorated, his physical health declined. Yet again he fell prey to vague, mysterious illnesses that grew in severity and frequency as his moral crisis intensified and his depression deepened. In August 1907, three months after Amelia left, Missionary Notes remarked that Gribble had cut virtually all communication with the outside world and the Morning Post reported that he was so ill that he was in ‘great
A Terribly Wild Man-TEXT PAGES 22/12/01 7:01 AM Page 82
82
A T E R R I B LY W I L D M A N
danger of . . . permanently breaking down unless he [left] for a long rest’.13 Gribble turned to his mother and sisters at Yarrabah for support. Of all his family, his sister Ethel seemed the least likely to menace his soul. Ethel was in her mid-twenties and nudging spinsterhood but she still had a neat figure and slim waist. She was lucky enough to have Mary Ann’s fine, milky complexion but to have escaped her mother’s plump proportions. Some might have described her as pretty, but she inherited her mother’s weak eyes and had to wear thick, wire-rimmed spectacles. Even then, her eyes refused to focus properly and she could not shake off the disarming habit of seeming to look at you from two directions at once. In the full-length, high-necked dresses of the day with her dark hair in a tight knot above her neck, Ethel was the picture of a sedate, homely missionary lady. Despite her appropriate looks, Ethel was afflicted with the same headstrong streak of independence that cursed and blessed all the Gribbles. Ethel joined the family assembly at Yarrabah after a brief stint as a governess at Mount Gympie before her brother transferred her to Fraser Island to keep their mother company and to teach in the mission school. It was here that she met and fell in love with an Aboriginal man called Fred Wondunna. Fred was eight years younger than Ethel, dark, taciturn and handsome. Ethel’s family was horrified. As soon as Gribble heard about the liaison, he organised his sister’s prompt return to Yarrabah. Ten days later he announced that she would marry his close friend and co-worker—the quiet, unassuming and compliant William Reeves. Ethel protested and delayed the wedding for sixteen months until, drained and acquiescent, she and William Reeves married on 12 June 1903. Their daughter Faith—a pretty little thing with a mass of tight fair curls—was born six days before their first wedding anniversary. Ethel’s new husband, the musical stone mason, was a thin, sickly soul with a kind heart, a weak constitution and a consumptive nature. His lengthy list of ailments made him especially susceptible to any inconsequential change in the weather, and
A Terribly Wild Man-TEXT PAGES 22/12/01 7:01 AM Page 83
HORSE-THIEVES
AND HARLOTS
83
even the slightest cold would strike him down quickly. When the devastating cyclone hit Yarrabah in January 1906, Reeves was so ill that he could not move. A team of good samaritans braved the tempest and tied ropes over his house to protect him from the storm, but their efforts could not save him for long. Reeves quietly passed away three weeks later, on 29 January 1906. It was only two months after Faith’s birth that Fred Wondunna and the other inmates from the abandoned Fraser Island mission had sailed into Trinity Bay aboard the Rio Logue. The couple kept their distance but when Reeves died Ethel sought out Fred for solace and support. Their clandestine meetings over the next eighteen months rekindled the feelings they had shared on Fraser Island and, by August 1907, Ethel was pregnant. They were deeply and passionately in love and oblivious to the heartache their attachment would bring. The couple’s only desire was to declare their devotion publicly by marrying. They asked Gribble to sanction their union and perform the wedding ceremony, but Gribble could see the hopelessness of their love. At the beginning of the twentieth century, marriage to an Aboriginal man meant Ethel would be denounced as a whore and a disgrace to her sex and race. She would become a pariah, ostracised forever from polite society. Ethel dismissed these objections. For two months, brother and sister argued. Gribble was so bewildered by Ethel’s eagerness to embrace such a miserable destiny that he decided she must have suffered some sort of mental breakdown after Reeves’ death. His worry and distress for Ethel made him physically sick. He urged her, for her own sake, to hide her pregnancy, have the child adopted, and forget her foolish infatuation. To this end, he fabricated a shallow excuse and wrote to the ABM asking that Ethel be granted twelve months’ leave. The ABM offered three months. There was no reason, came the response, to justify a lengthy absence from her work. This did not help Gribble’s cause. In three months his widowed sister would be giving birth to a part-Aboriginal child. The matter of her furlough aside, it was clear to Gribble that Ethel could not stay at Yarrabah. The scandal would be uncontainable.
A Terribly Wild Man-TEXT PAGES 22/12/01 7:01 AM Page 84
84
A T E R R I B LY W I L D M A N
Just four days before Christmas Day 1907, Gribble waved goodbye from the Cairns wharf as his sister set sail on the steamer heading to Sydney. Her pretty little daughter Faith stayed behind at Yarrabah in the care of her grandmother, Mary Ann. What Gribble did not know was that Ethel and Fred had a scheme to ensure they stayed together. Soon after Ethel left, Fred fled through the hills behind Yarrabah and made his way overland to New South Wales. The couple met in Sydney where they searched in vain for an Anglican priest willing to marry them. Exasperated and disheartened, they eventually abandoned the quest and appealed to a kindly Congregational minister who took pity on their plight and quietly married them on 30 December 1907. Fred’s country of Fraser Island seemed the perfect sanctuary for the newlyweds. It was a place where they could avoid the contemptuous glares and venomous whispers that would follow them in any town. Life would be rough but timbergetters had occupied the island and Fred could get work. The pair slowly made their way north and reached Brisbane in time to find refuge in the Salvation Army Home where the first of their four children entered the world on 21 April 1908. A palpitating wave of disbelief shook the sedate Sydney offices of the ABM when it heard about Ethel’s marriage. The ABM Executive was so stunned that it called for a copy of the marriage certificate to verify the facts. This done, Australia’s Anglicans were informed that Ethel had retired as a result of poor health since the death of her husband, William Reeves. Two years later, when Cairns was alive with allegations of mismanagement and misconduct at Yarrabah, the Bishop of north Queensland worried that ‘Mrs Reeves’ fall [might be] brought up in Parliament and that there might be a lot of nasty scandal about Yarrabah’.14 Even 22 years later, editors at the ABM censored all references to Ethel after the death of William Reeves from Gribble’s book A Despised Race, and the Church remained categorical that a marriage between a ‘white girl’ and ‘a coloured man’ was:
A Terribly Wild Man-TEXT PAGES 22/12/01 7:01 AM Page 85
HORSE-THIEVES
AND HARLOTS
85
eccentric and utterly unsuitable . . . and we can safely say that such a marriage would be regarded with entire disapproval and regret by the vast majority of missionaries . . . while there is undoubtedly a risk that the children may fall short of the special virtues of either race, while they are hampered by special difficulties of their own.15
Gribble was shaken by Ethel’s actions. In his eyes her love flaunted all accepted social mores and her marriage was a stubborn act of reckless naivety. But during those difficult months when he was advising and negotiating with his sister, Gribble was wrestling with his own emotional and moral demons. Scarred by the failure of his own marriage, his moral certainty faltered in the face of Ethel’s refusal to accept the racial divide and his own turbulent, private struggle with sexual desire and temptation. Everyone agreed that Janie Brown was startlingly attractive. A photograph of her in her twenties shows a tall, elegant woman with finely chiselled features and soft, wavy, shoulder-length hair. Her name was originally Jeannie Forbes—the child whose controversial removal to Yarrabah under the Reformatory Act sparked insinuations in the press that Gribble made immoral use of mission women. After arriving at Yarrabah Janie worked in the Mission House for the Gribble family and became Amelia’s salvation. She cared for the Gribble boys, ensured that domestic order reigned and went to Sydney with Amelia in 1905–06 to look after the children. Janie helped Amelia survive the trials of mission life. She was like family. Nevertheless, Amelia left Janie behind when she and the boys moved to Brisbane in mid-1907. In the difficult months that followed, Gribble turned to Janie for support and comfort. Her patient gentleness and mellow pragmatism were soothing counterpoints to his tortured emotions, dark moods and incapacitating bouts of depression. Loneliness and propinquity thrust them together. Gribble knew his attraction to Janie was improper. He made a half-hearted effort to resist temptation. On 4 December 1907, Gribble hastily convened a small gathering in St Alban’s Church to witness the nuptials of Janie Brown and Willie Clarke, another
A Terribly Wild Man-TEXT PAGES 22/12/01 7:01 AM Page 86
86
A T E R R I B LY W I L D M A N
Yarrabah inmate. Blithely ignoring the fact that Willie was already involved with a woman called Ada Pickles, Gribble reasoned that Janie’s marriage would provide a psychological and institutional barrier that would stop him from falling into sin. It was a forlorn hope. At the same time as he was trying to persuade Ethel to acquiesce to white society’s prejudices by abandoning her soonto-be-born child, her Aboriginal fiancé and her hope of happiness, he had fallen head-over-heels in love with the young, pretty, innocent Janie. The events of those five months during 1907—Amelia’s departure, Ethel’s affair and his love of Janie— conflated to torment Gribble with doubts about the racial and sexual assumptions that underpinned his world. Isolated at Yarrabah without the usual social strictures and religious props, it was difficult to withstand a moral lapse. His resolve was destroyed by the discovery that Ethel and Fred had acted on their convictions and eloped. Janie was Matron of the boys’ dormitory. Gribble moved into the dormitory within a month of Ethel’s wedding. He always had a special interest in the boys and, bereft of family obligations, was free to devote more time to them. Yet, this simple act nurtured his relationship with Janie. The affair was a public secret in the closed confines of the mission. Whispers flew. Gossip raged. Some thought Gribble was in love: ‘it was obvious when you looked at him how he felt’ but their age difference caused comment: ‘it was like having sex with his daughter’. By January 1908, Janie was pregnant with Gribble’s child. Their daughter, Nola, was born on 15 September 1908. Inmates knowingly agreed that the child had Mary Ann’s round face and figure. She was clearly ‘a Gribble. She had these bright blue eyes. Father Gribble had bright blue eyes’. Nola was reputedly never told the truth of her parentage. One outsider could categorically confirm the affair: Janie’s confidante and best friend, Myra Pitt. Janie confided to Myra that Gribble was the father of her daughter but swore her friend to secrecy. The loyal Myra kept her charge until she was an old lady waiting for death and anxious to pass on the stories of the past.16
A Terribly Wild Man-TEXT PAGES 22/12/01 7:01 AM Page 87
HORSE-THIEVES
AND HARLOTS
87
Gribble did not plan to fall in love. Perhaps he even imagined that the affair was something special, sacred and pure—an enriching communion of mutual needs and compatible souls? This aside, the intensity of his feelings took him by surprise. It immobilised him and made him helpless. The affair transgressed the very foundation of the faith and moral code on which he had built his life. He knew it had to end but he could not bring himself to take the first step. Guilt, remorse and indecision ate away at his soul, and the worry and strain made him sick. His journals documented the illnesses that accompanied all his encounters with emotional trauma and his physical decline during the affair is clearly detailed. There was no obvious physiological cause for his illness, but his symptoms were devastatingly debilitating. In the autumn of 1908, when Janie announced she was pregnant, Gribble broke down completely. He was so gravely ill that he had to be hospitalised in Cairns for two months. At least his hospital stay allowed him a chance to reflect on the past and make decisions about the future. It was not an easy task and the process left him so physically and emotionally overwrought that his doctors recommended a therapeutic sea journey. Nevertheless, he had made up his mind. He left the hospital in May 1908, returned to Yarrabah and abruptly terminated the affair with Janie. Soon after he made an unexpected trip to Brisbane— perhaps in the hope of reconciling with Amelia? As a final act of restitution, he appointed himself the Church’s unofficial opponent of interracial unions and, until his death, he preached that sexual intercourse between black and white was ‘based on immorality’.17 During the tumultuous events of 1907–08, Gribble neglected mission affairs and Yarrabah drifted into chaos. Debts mounted and bankruptcy loomed. Despite his resolution to lead a virtuous life, Gribble lived in constant fear that his sin would become the subject of open ridicule. Meanwhile, Janie was pregnant and alone. She tried to establish her claim over her erstwhile husband but Willie’s liaison with Ada Pickles had continued and by early
A Terribly Wild Man-TEXT PAGES 22/12/01 7:01 AM Page 88
88
A T E R R I B LY W I L D M A N
1908 Ada was expecting his baby. The result was a nasty, public showdown between: two women what in family way fighting. Janie Clarke fighting Ada over Willie Clarke and Ada said ‘Well you got Father Gribble’s [baby]. You carrying Father Gribble’s baby’. That was the quarrel . . . there was a quarrel between her and Jane and that’s how they point their finger at each other [about] what they got: Father Gribble and Willie Clarke. That’s how it is . . . Willie never make a fuss about that. It’s only Janie, having a row with Ada.18
These vicious open quarrels resurrected Gribble’s sin and haunted his future. In January 1909, Ada attacked Janie for a second time. Gribble banished her to Fitzroy Island. When he later calmed down he regretted passing such a severe sentence and allowed her to return to the mission, but his unsettling fear of repercussions and reprisals clouded his days and disturbed his sleep. The summer of 1909 was difficult. Gribble was mistrustful, apprehensive and saw suspicion and betrayal in everyone. As he struggled to silence conjecture and assert control over Yarrabah’s population, his behaviour degenerated into a terrifying, defensive despotism. Gribble listed those who defied him in his journal. His inventory grew each day and included a parade of loyal converts. Issues that Gribble thought he had resolved years ago unexpectedly became causes of contention and discord. Parents refused to put their children in his care in the dormitories and inmates were disobedient and disrespectful. He had a blazing row with Menmuny and temporarily withdrew his title as King of Yarrabah. He also revoked the licence of one of his longest serving Catechists after he was ‘caught in the act’ of adultery with a victim who ‘appear(ed) to have been forced to a certain extent’.19 The complaints about Gribble’s authoritarianism were so vehement that Bishop Frodsham was convinced the entire staff would resign unless Gribble’s mental health improved radically. Outsiders saw a different Yarrabah. The spiritual life of the mission seemed solid. A mission resident won the Bishop’s Prize
A Terribly Wild Man-TEXT PAGES 22/12/01 7:01 AM Page 89
HORSE-THIEVES
AND HARLOTS
89
in the 1907 Sunday School Exams and in 1908, three mission residents trained by Gribble—James Noble, his wife Angelina and Horace Reid—went as missionaries to the Church Missionary Society Mission at Roper River in the Northern Territory. Although Bishop Frodsham categorically rejected Gribble’s appeals to ordain James Noble, or any other Aboriginal, the first Aboriginal Synod representatives and licensed lay readers in the north Queensland diocese were residents of Yarrabah mentored by Gribble. Yet, closer scrutiny showed that the Christian message sometimes got lost in the temporal realities of mission life. When inmates sang the hymn ‘Shall we gather at the River?’ they changed the words ‘We will walk and worship forever’ to ‘We will work and wash-up for ever’. After several children were sternly punished for pilfering food from the mission plantation, inmates translated the petition in the Lord’s Prayer, ‘Lead us not into temptation’ to ‘Lead us not into the plantation’. In later years Gribble would declare ‘with all humility and with a reverent recognition of the power of Almighty God . . . there is no such thing as superstition amongst our Yarrabah folk’.20 In the first decade of the century, traditional values and practices lingered. Despite their declining numbers, the elderly Kongkandji and Indindji in the camp outside the mission compound passed on Dreaming stories, the names of trees and flowers and secrets about plant medicines and the healing powers and ceremonies of Yilamagay—the sacred medicine water near King Beach. As late as 1908, Gribble complained that he was still having trouble with ‘silly old blackfella things’.21 The Kongkandji believed so strongly in the spiritual powers of the dead that Gribble had to move the mission graveyard into the hills behind the church and, despite his efforts, traditional mourning rites persisted. When Menmuny’s sister died in 1909, King John abandoned his Christian faith to perform customary burial rites and songs of lamentation. As a counter to the lure of corroborees, Gribble introduced South Sea Island dancing during church festivals and
A Terribly Wild Man-TEXT PAGES 22/12/01 7:01 AM Page 90
90
A T E R R I B LY W I L D M A N
celebrations. Unbeknown to him inmates incorporated Indigenous significance into the dances by blending the symbolism and language of the Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander communities. The trials of 1907–09 ate away at Gribble’s physical and mental wellbeing. By mid-1909, three doctors confirmed that he was suffering from ‘dilation of the heart and neurasthenia’. This now outdated term literally meant ‘nervous exhaustion’. It was used to describe an assortment of symptoms: loss of energy; insomnia; nebulous and imprecise pains; depression; irritability; and reduced concentration. In short, Gribble had suffered a complete mental and physical breakdown. His doctors insisted on at least a year’s rest. Bishop Frodsham visited Yarrabah in May 1909 and confirmed that Gribble’s condition had worsened and was now precarious. He advised the doctors’ directions be implemented ‘without delay’.22 Gribble refused. He wanted to ‘be at hand to direct’ the mission or: to stay at Yarrabah and die here amongst my own people [and] for the sake of my people . . . be buried amongst them, [that it] may help my children in the years to come when they see my face no more.23
Swayed by Frodsham’s advice, the ABM ordered Gribble to take a year’s holiday. On 12 June 1909, feeling angry and resentful, Gribble left Yarrabah to undergo the Weir-Mitchell cure—a wellrespected treatment of rest and a milk-rich diet—at St Helen’s Private Hospital in Brisbane. In his absence Bishop Frodsham visited Yarrabah during July and November 1909. He was shocked. The mission was badly neglected, food production was almost non-existent and food was so scarce that Frodsham expected a mass exodus of starving inmates to flee the place any day. The Bishop did not blame Gribble entirely. The ABM Secretary had been ill and funds had not been forwarded to the mission but Frodsham was frank: there were ‘difficulties of administration’ and ‘reform’ was urgently needed. Frodsham’s greater concern was for the spiritual welfare of the staff and residents. At time when the grace of the sacraments was needed more than
A Terribly Wild Man-TEXT PAGES 22/12/01 7:01 AM Page 91
HORSE-THIEVES
AND HARLOTS
91
ever, Frodsham was dismayed that Gribble did not provide weekday communion: At no place more than Yarrabah is it needful that the Staff avail themselves most assiduously of the means of grace. To be too busy to take advantage of his ‘converted meeting place with God’ must result in falling ideals, and in a lower standard of life and work . . . It is not only the Aboriginal Christians who need the prayers of the faithful. The Staff need the support of the Spirit even more, if they are to be faithful to their trust.24
Meanwhile, Frodsham reported that Cairns was awash with ‘filthy gossip’ about Gribble, and disgruntled staff and inmates were only too ready to point a finger and confide details about his misdoings.25 They were so relieved by Gribble’s absence that they threatened to resign en masse if he returned prematurely. By February 1910, Gribble had recovered and was released from hospital. The respite had done him good. He was determined to make a fresh start and filled in the remainder of his leave by preaching and doing deputation work for the ABM in the Sydney and Goulburn dioceses. While Gribble busied himself, his dismissal was the subject of the March meeting of the ABM Executive in Sydney. Frodsham led the charge but the outcome had already been decided behind closed doors. In accordance with his episcopal obligations, Frodsham told the new Primate and Archbishop of Sydney, John Charles Wright, about Gribble’s affair and the scandalous conditions at Yarrabah. The evidence convinced the Primate. He not only endorsed Gribble’s removal but he banned Gribble from ever working in his diocese of Sydney. Frodsham even refused to allow Gribble to return to Yarrabah to collect his personal belongings. The ABM issued the usual explanation, that Gribble had resigned because of ill health. Even as an old man, the indignity of his dismissal rankled and Gribble would relate his tale of anger and pain to any unguarded listener. He had one minor victory. Exposing an impeccable, caustic sense of historical irony, Gribble insisted on delaying his official resignation until 17 June 1910, the eighteenth anniversary
A Terribly Wild Man-TEXT PAGES 22/12/01 7:01 AM Page 92
92
A T E R R I B LY W I L D M A N
of JB’s arrival at Cape Grafton and the foundation of Yarrabah. It was an ignoble exit for the priest who just a year earlier was publicly acclaimed for making Yarrabah the Church’s ‘most successful effort . . . to civilise the aboriginal’.26 In a loyal show of solidarity, Mary Ann and her daughter, Illa, resigned from the mission staff. By the winter of 1910, the only Gribbles at Yarrabah were the family’s unacknowledged part-Aboriginal offspring.
A Terribly Wild Man-TEXT PAGES 22/12/01 7:01 AM Page 93
5
W HEN
NATIVE FRUITS ARE RIPE
G
osford was a sleepy estuary town on Brisbane Water north of Sydney with pretensions of being a regional centre. The pubs and public buildings gave the place an air of possible permanence but the houses that hugged the surrounding hills were sad boxes of fibro, weatherboard, tin and peeling paint. The smell of salt water and dead fish saturated everything. This was the last place Gribble wanted to be. He had been filling in time with occasional deputation work and praying for a new mission when the ABM broke the news, in 1911, that it would not support him any longer. Christ Church, Gosford needed a priest and Gribble needed work. The only saving grace in this shotgun marriage was that Gribble managed to convince Amelia to bury the hatchet for a while and try to revive their marriage. The notion of playing rector’s wife dispensing sedate afternoon teas in the rectory caught Amelia’s fancy but the experiment failed on all fronts. The reunion was strained and disagreeable, and Gribble loathed parish work. He escaped the depressing pallor of his new existence by pouring his energies into writing. It was a cathartic distraction. His first autobiography, The Life and Experiences of an Australian, was completed during this phase and serialised by the Gosford Times in 93
A Terribly Wild Man-TEXT PAGES 22/12/01 7:01 AM Page 94
94
A T E R R I B LY W I L D M A N
1915. It drew on a collage of vignettes that had lain buried since childhood: the idyllic years at Warangesda; the invigorating spell at the Kings School; and snapshots of religious ambivalence among the selectors of Tumbarumba. These fragments of memory resurrected a happier life than his present existence. In between scribbling, Gribble ferreted out any chance to return to the bush and missionary life. Word filtered through that Bishop Gerard Trower, the new, reluctantly-appointed head of the North West diocese, was establishing a mission in the remote north of Western Australia. Gribble instantly offered his services. He was an experienced bush missionary, he told the Bishop, who could rescue the venture if the staff failed to perform. Trower summoned him six months later. Gribble left Gosford within the fortnight. He stepped off the government steamer onto the wharf of the remote township of Wyndham, in the east Kimberley, on 30 December 1913. Two days later he welcomed in the New Year by resigning his parish in Gosford. He had not seen his new mission but the work was a ‘path of duty’ and his vision was clear.1 Forrest River would be Yarrabah without the poisonous blemishes of those final years where he would realise the hopes and dreams of JB’s struggle in Western Australia 30 years earlier. Wyndham lies on the western side of the Cambridge Gulf, half a continent and a whole world away from the State capital of Perth. The town was named after the second son of the first marriage of Lady Mary Ann Broome (1831–1911), wife of the irascible Governor Sir Frederick Napier Broome, whose wild feuds with public officials nearly eclipsed his administration’s triumph at securing responsible government for the colony. The town’s namesake, Walter George Wyndham, fought with Lord Chelmsford in the Zulu wars in Africa. The Australian township that inherited his name lay in an equally alien, frontier region on the periphery of British civilisation. Wyndham had developed capriciously by sprawling laterally along the waterline to hug the slim strip of ground between the
A Terribly Wild Man-TEXT PAGES 22/12/01 7:01 AM Page 95
WHEN
N AT I V E F R U I T S A R E R I P E
95
tidal mud flats of the Gulf and the rocky slopes of Mt Albany and the Bastion Ranges. In the 1920s, the town was a barren clutch of square, white houses clustered around a labyrinth of dirt tracks pounded hard by the hooves of horses and cattle that transformed into a brown quagmire during the summer wet season. Sterile, gnarled mountains guarded the hazardous, crocodile-infested Cambridge Gulf and its rushing 30-foot tides and the heat was so blistering that locals were said to ‘feed their fowls on chipped ice to keep them from laying fried eggs’.2 This was an unforgiving place that God had forgotten—a lair for the fearless, the foolhardy and the misfit. Forty years after its first exploration by Lieutenant George Grey, Alexander Forrest traversed the region naming it the Kimberley district and praising its grazing potential. Within three years, cattle dynasties like the Buchanans, Duracks and Macdonalds from Queensland and New South Wales had invaded and taken up most of the best land. Gold attracted thousands of hopefuls to Halls Creek in the south east and, by 1887, Wyndham was a flourishing centre boasting six hotels. Champagne flowed freely and business was done with gold nuggets. The boom was over by 1890. Most of the diggers had left for more promising strikes in the south and the fledgling cattle industry was floundering. Only the most serious pastoralists stayed. Cattle tick stopped livestock exports between 1896 and 1899 and again in 1911 when buffalo fly and pleuro-pneumonia forced cattle owners into costly immunisation programs. A government meatworks was built in 1919 but high operating costs caused its closure in 1921. It reopened twelve months later but hardly ever broke even. The town struggled. Cash was so scarce that shopkeepers and publicans issued promissory notes redeemable at the bank that were notorious for their convenient tendency to disintegrate when handled. On the eve of World War I, there were fewer than 200 Europeans in the East Kimberley and the population of Wyndham had stagnated at around 50. It hovered there for the next decade.
A Terribly Wild Man-TEXT PAGES 22/12/01 7:01 AM Page 96
96
A T E R R I B LY W I L D M A N
The Forrest River Mission lay on the western side of the Cambridge Gulf about 50 miles up the Forrest River from Wyndham, in the middle of the vast Marndoc Aboriginal Reserve. It occupied the stretch of flat land between Dadaway Lagoon and a line of rugged, stony hills that led to a gallery of sacred Aboriginal burial caves and the fresh waters of Camera Pool on the edge of the Oombulgurri Plain. The Western Australian Government proclaimed the 3 000 000-acre reserve in 1911. It stretched across the majestic Kimberley ranges as far as the Cambridge Gulf to the east and the coast to the north, and spread south through the Milligan Ranges and across the Durack River to Bindcola Creek. In 1898, the Church swapped the site of JB’s failed Gascoyne River mission for the 100 000-acre lease in the Marndoc Reserve. The historical symmetry appealed to Gribble. The mission lease spread across both sides of the mighty Forrest River and the red sandstone cliffs that guarded the river as it wove through the rugged hills and sterile, stony flats of the Kimberley ranges. Downstream the river was bracken with the cloying salt of the Cambridge Gulf. Upstream it melted into ponds ringed by pandanus palms and filled with sweet, fresh water and lilies. A menagerie of catfish, barramundi, cockatoos, ducks, brolgas and hungry crocodiles flourished around the river, but the surrounding country was occupied by scrub, spinifex, kangaroos and termite nests that transformed the stony plains into an eerie landscape of gnarled, red mountains. It was a heartless, unwelcoming land. The first European visitor described Siberia as more hospitable. This was Yeidji territory. Their custodianship of the land stretched north from the Forrest River to the sea coast of the Cambridge Gulf as far as the Milligan Ranges, south to the Steere Hills and north to Mount Carty and the Lyne River. The Yeidji had close ties with the Wembra to the west and the Arnga whose territory lay to the south along the King and Pentecost Rivers. They also had links with other Kimberley groups including the Bemba, to the north west beyond the Forrest River, the Yura, to
A Terribly Wild Man-TEXT PAGES 22/12/01 7:01 AM Page 97
WHEN
N AT I V E F R U I T S A R E R I P E
97
the east of the mission along the coast of the Cambridge Gulf between the Patrick and lower Lyne Rivers, as well as the Baragala, an Arnga group, to the south east of the mission. People from further afield like the Kwini from the Drysdale River and the Wunumbul from the west of King Edward River had regular contact with the people of the district. The Aboriginal communities of the Kimberley shared similar language and a rich mythological tradition dominated by three powerful Dreaming figures: Wandjina, a regenerative, reproductive power linked with rain and water; Brimurer, the Rainbow Serpent who created the rivers and sent forth spirit-children; and Wolara, who instituted initiation, increase ceremonies and other features of social life. Wunan (trade routes) crisscrossed the Kimberley and linked the material life of the communities through the exchange of red ochre, iron axes, boomerangs, shovel and wire spears, wooden water carriers, karl (spinifex resin) and the powder from burnt gypsum used to make ceremonial body paint. Almost every food in the region was linked with a talu (increase) site and an associated ceremony. At key times during the year, the different communities converged to harvest seasonal fruits like gelay (plum) or to conduct initiation rites and mourning ceremonies, renew kinship and political allegiances, and exchange corroborees, mythology, rituals and Law. In this harsh dry land, gatherings usually converged on a waterhole. These gra (sacred sites) were the homes of the spirit-children that took the animal forms hunted by man. Every person was the embodiment of a spirit-child linked with a specific water source where they were ‘found’ by their father and generally named after their spirit centre. The Kimberley peoples exploited imported European technology by making spear heads from glass and metal instead of stone. The results were deadly and devastating. In 1895, the Ord River Station claimed Aboriginals killed stock valued at £20 000. Two years later, the district reported stock losses of £134 000. The Aboriginals used their superior knowledge of the country to evade capture and launch attacks during the wet season when flooded
A Terribly Wild Man-TEXT PAGES 22/12/01 7:01 AM Page 98
98
A T E R R I B LY W I L D M A N
plains made pursuit impossible. Cattle and sheep polluted and desecrated sacred sites and waterholes, and Aboriginals often slaughtered more than they could eat. Some pastoralists believed they killed cattle for sport. Police stations sprang up at Wyndham, Halls Creek and Turkey Creek to protect settlers and property. From 1892, cattle killing became an offence punishable with three years’ imprisonment and a beating with a cat-o-nine-tails. The police got two shillings for the capture and conviction of a cattle killer but these drastic measures had minimal effect. In 1909, the government established Moola Bulla cattle station in the hope that distributing meat to Aboriginals would reduce attacks on private herds. This was a world where settlers felt isolated and outnumbered. The exploits of Aboriginal warriors like Pigeon and Major fuelled fears of a wholesale black uprising and settlers were united by a siege mentality and the belief that ruthless action was needed to secure the region and their protection. A catalogue of Europeans died in the battle to possess the Kimberley. The inventory for 1886 included Fred Marriot, who lost his life during an Aboriginal attack on the Halls Creek goldfields; John Durack, who was ambushed and speared; and another digger killed near Mt Barrett. In 1888, William Miller died after being attacked near Mt Dockrell and a teamster was killed near Wyndham. In 1896, Frank Hann and Ah Sing, a market gardener on the King River south of Wyndham, were killed. In 1901, Aboriginals shot Jerry Durack through the head while he was sleeping. His son Patsy was wounded. Settlers formed vigilante groups and the police used armed Aboriginal trackers and deputised civilians to hunt suspected murderers but punitive action was often the underlying aim, as one letter writer explained after diggers were killed at Mt Barrett: A number of diggers went out to take revenge. Having bailed up a large number of blacks in a gully who showed fight, they proceeded to slaughter them with repeating rifles. It is certain that a great many were killed, some say at least a hundred.3
A Terribly Wild Man-TEXT PAGES 22/12/01 7:01 AM Page 99
WHEN
N AT I V E F R U I T S A R E R I P E
99
It was widely accepted that ‘a war of extermination, in effect, is being waged against these unfortunate blacks in the Kimberley district’.4 Francis Connor, Member of the Legislative Assembly and partner in the Durack cattle dynasty, led an unsuccessful campaign to establish a Native Police Force to suppress black resistance: ‘It is simply a question of whether we or they are to have this country’.5 It is impossible to estimate the number of Aboriginals killed in the struggle for the Kimberley. Settlers and police united in a code of silence. It took two years for Police Constable Ritchie to learn of a massacre near Jerry Durack’s station on the Denham River. Richie found the incinerated bones of the bodies on the property but his efforts to prosecute Durack were blocked. In 1884, Harry Stockdale led the first European foray onto the western side of the Cambridge Gulf near the future site of Gribble’s mission. One of the party, J.H. Ricketson, was attacked when he rode into an Aboriginal camp and had to be rescued by Stockdale who shot one of the ringleaders. A few weeks later an old Aboriginal man blocked the party’s path as it skirted around a billabong. Ricketson killed him with a single shot at point blank range. Ricketson declared the area inhabited by hostile Aboriginals but Stockdale returned a year later to manage a 100 000-acre lease taken up by the Victoria Pastoral Company. Two thousand sheep were herded to Gundah Creek on the Patrick River near Mar-ri-da, a sacred talu site for fish and lily-root for the Yeidji and Wembra. Several talu sites and at least five significant sacred sites were within a five-mile radius of Dadaway Lagoon, including a stone Djalmula that was said to have been put there in the Dreaming after the crane and policeman bird fought and the crane threw the fire sticks that gave the policeman bird red legs. The Aboriginals defended their sacred sites forcing Stockdale and his party to withdraw to Dadaway Lagoon. Among the group was Mrs Wilkes who gave birth to the Kimberley’s first European child in 1887. In 1889, the vigorous Aboriginal resistance forced the Victoria Pastoral Company to withdraw but in 1898, Harold Hale, son of
A Terribly Wild Man-TEXT PAGES 22/12/01 7:01 AM Page 100
100
A T E R R I B LY W I L D M A N
the first Bishop of Perth, led a five-man party to establish an Anglican mission on the Forrest River. The Government Resident in Wyndham warned Hale that the Aboriginals were dangerous, but his caution was ignored and the group set up at the abandoned Stockdale homestead at Dadaway Lagoon. Aboriginals stole their food and supplies and a large, threatening assembly eventually congregated around the mission. Hale was injured by a glasstipped spearhead that caught him in the arm and ripped the muscles so badly that he needed urgent medical attention. Another member of the party, Sidney Hadley, was speared in the shoulder and the mission lugger was untied to drift down river. A visiting police patrol helped Hale capture the culprits by enticing them into the cottage where they were overpowered before being taken to Wyndham for trial. All five offenders received fifteen lashes. Hale’s attackers were imprisoned for two to three years and the boat thieves received prison terms of three to six months. The incident was ‘unpropitious’, warned the Western Australian Record in February 1899, and ‘may . . . adversely affect the disposition of the local blacks’. Thereafter, the attacks intensified. One of Hale’s party was clubbed unconscious and lay in a coma for three days, the mission boat was disabled and the party resorted to firing shots into the air to disperse their attackers. It was suicidal to stay, warned the Resident Magistrate in Wyndham. The Police Commissioner urged the Church to withdraw before lives were sacrificed. The mission was abandoned at the end of 1898. In April 1913, Bishop Gerald Trower led a six-man party in a second attempt to establish a mission in the Kimberley near the site abandoned by the Victoria Pastoral Company and Harold Hale. Trower christened the mission ‘St Michael and All Angels’ but the early omens were ominous. A young naturalist with the group called Burns got tangled in lily-roots while duck shooting and drowned. Trower returned to Broome and the missionaries erected a small prefabricated tin hut to serve as a church, sleeping quarters and storeroom. They reinforced the walls with stones and surrounded the compound with looped, barbed wire, but it did not
A Terribly Wild Man-TEXT PAGES 22/12/01 7:01 AM Page 101
WHEN
N AT I V E F R U I T S A R E R I P E
101
protect them. One of the lay missionaries was clubbed unconscious and Aboriginals looted the mission boat and raided the compound at night. The missionaries resorted to firing shots into the dark to stop a full-blown assault and, by September 1913, the frayed and terrified staff had all resigned. Reverend Stubbs was summoned from Port Hedland to hold the fort until Gribble arrived. Knowing he would need help, Gribble’s first act was to wire James and Angelina Noble. They already had four years as lay missionaries at the Roper River Mission in the Northern Territory, and Church officials nodded approvingly when the Nobles arrived in April 1914: The fact that these fellow country-men of the same color [sic], have come from afar to lead them to the same calling and teach them the same Creed as they themselves have long embraced, must appeal strongly to the native mind.6
Angelina Noble’s delicate features and dainty figure hid her tough disposition. She was a crack shot, talented linguist, expert rider and absolutely fearless. A horse dealer had abducted her when she was a young girl, dressed her in boy’s clothing and passed her off as ‘Tommy’, but her disguise was eventually detected and she was sent to Yarrabah where she married James Noble when she was sixteen. For five years Angelina was the only woman at Forrest River Mission. Her husband, James Noble, was one of those men with that enviable but intangible quality known as ‘presence’. At 6 feet tall, he towered over his petite wife. His dark, gentle eyes were set above uncommonly high cheekbones and a clean, square jaw. It was the open face of an honest man. Although originally from the Normanton district of Queensland, Noble was reared by the Doyle family of Scone in rural New South Wales from the time he was about ten and tutored at Scone Grammar School. Later, he lived with Canon Edwards in Hughenden, north Queensland, where his talent as a sprinter made him a minor celebrity. When the Canon died James fell in with a bad crowd and the Bishop of north Queensland stepped in and sent the 16-year-old to Yarrabah,
A Terribly Wild Man-TEXT PAGES 22/12/01 7:01 AM Page 102
102
A T E R R I B LY W I L D M A N
where he became one of Gribble’s proteges. His calm resourcefulness made James a capable, congenial manager and he freed Gribble of the burden of supervising Yarrabah’s out-stations. He was just shy of 40 and his wiry, dark hair was already grey when he joined Gribble at Forrest River in 1914. Gribble drew on Angelina’s talents as a translator and James was barber, dentist, doctor and general hand. James’ abilities earned him respect. He was treated like an Elder and the people listened when he spoke. In Church circles, the Nobles were credited with thwarting the attacks that had sent other missionaries scurrying from Dadaway. Their daughter, Lovie Kianna, grew up on stories of how her parents pacified the hostile people around Forrest River: The river [was] just black with Aboriginals [who were] just watching them. Wild people . . . They didn’t want to see those white people cause they never saw white people in all their lives. Then [James] got up and stood at the fore of that boat. When they saw him they all put their spears down. That was that and they were all calm when they saw this . . . black man and he told them ‘my wife is black too but she’s half-caste’ . . . They were satisfied with the wife too . . . and they all put down their spears.7
James’ particular contribution was acknowledged in 1925 with his ordination as the Anglican Church’s first Aboriginal deacon. Lured by medicine and tobacco, Gribble’s mission soon became a marshalling point for Aboriginal groups from across the Kimberley. By 1914, about 200 people camped around the lagoon and on the rocky ridge behind the mission. Hundreds of others visited as they travelled the wunan and, during these early years, Gribble carefully recorded the names of those that came and went. His medicine treated a cavalcade of sick—2067 in 1923— and his tobacco was the currency that purchased labour to clear the land, build and plant crops. The availability of tobacco and the precious glass and metal debris needed for spearheads made Dadaway Lagoon a terminus for the Kimberley wunan trade. Gribble divided the people into three classes. The brengen lived
A Terribly Wild Man-TEXT PAGES 22/12/01 7:01 AM Page 103
WHEN
N AT I V E F R U I T S A R E R I P E
103
in semi-permanent camps near the mission and occasionally worked for food and tobacco but came and went as they pleased. The narlies visited off and on to trade in tobacco and join festivities as they travelled to tribal rituals and seasonal supplies of native food. As far as Gribble was concerned, the ‘inmates’ in the mission compound were the mission, but the children were his primary focus. Gribble started a school with a small clutch of boys using red ink and boot polish to write lessons on galvanised iron. By September 1914, dormitories were built and surrounded by a 3-foot-high fence topped by two strands of barbed wire. Only his mission, Gribble believed, could provide temporal and spiritual salvation. He refused work, and therefore food and tobacco, to parents who would not hand over their children, and collected waifs from Wyndham and the bush. Anxious to build numbers, mission inmates remember Gribble bribing Aboriginals to abduct ‘kids from the bush for the school and dormitory’.8 Many parents avoided the mission because they knew: once [a] child is in the Mission, he or she will not be allowed out again except for a few hours on a holiday under the supervision of a missionary, that later the child will be married contrary to the tribal laws and to promises made by the parents and that finally, the child becomes a complete outsider to all tribal culture.9
Gribble reported in the Church press that the mission had a wonderful hold on the local people. In reality, life was hard. Aboriginals stole petrol and food; floods regularly washed away the mission jetty; crocodiles ate the dogs that were Gribble’s companions; and supplies from Perth were erratic especially during World War I when strikes and the withdrawal of steamers caused serious shortages. Gribble planted vegetables, maize and millet for the mission, watermelons for sale in Wyndham and peanuts for the Adelaide market, but the results were unreliable in a fickle world of floods, droughts and plagues of ticks, locusts and grasshoppers. Sometimes there was no food for weeks and potential converts were turned away and inmates sent out to collect ‘native tucker’. Meanwhile, Wyndham’s shopkeepers grew
A Terribly Wild Man-TEXT PAGES 22/12/01 7:01 AM Page 104
104
A T E R R I B LY W I L D M A N
fat selling goods at inflated prices to the anxious missionary desperate to keep a hold on his ambivalent flock. Just as at Yarrabah, reciprocity defined local social relations. Without food or tobacco, the people refused to work and disappeared into the bush or went to Wyndham for sugar, tea and flour. The people called Gribble Judja, meaning ‘boss’, but when native fruits were ripe and plentiful, only a few children and old folk remained in the mission and Gribble repeatedly reminded the faithful that the ‘primary object of getting their souls is lost, if we have not got their bodies’.10 The problem, Gribble complained, was that he was shorthanded. He put on a boatman-cum-cook called Rackarock who seemed capable enough but he was known to police across north Australia and his addiction to ‘black velvet’ caused trouble at Dadaway. Eighteen months after being sacked from the mission, Rackarock was imprisoned for raping a young Aboriginal girl in Wyndham. His replacement turned out to be a drunkard who polished off the mission’s supply of altar wine. Others came and went just as quickly for it was hard to survive Gribble’s tantrums and hurtful tongue. Part of the problem was that he played favourites, but his fancies were unpredictable and changed without warning. He made life miserable for those who fell from grace. One staff member—a devout spinster Gribble branded ‘a nag’—was so distressed by his attacks that she packed her bags and returned to Perth. Gribble was always contrite and full of selfloathing later, but then it was generally too late. By September 1915, all his staff had left or were leaving. According to the mission register, by 1916 there were 40 inmates living in the mission compound, but most were children, elderly, sick or maimed. Gribble was frustrated by the slow progress. His dream of replicating Yarrabah at Forrest River seemed to be elusive, and an unsettling sense of doom descended. He remembered the other times he had experienced the same disquieting feeling: when JB abandoned him in Carnarvon; during his ill-fated involvement with Fraser Island; and throughout those stressful, final years at Yarrabah.
A Terribly Wild Man-TEXT PAGES 22/12/01 7:01 AM Page 105
WHEN
N AT I V E F R U I T S A R E R I P E
105
His distraction was to declare war. The continued exploitation and abuse of Aboriginals in the north west deeply offended his keen sense of justice. He could see little evidence that conditions had improved since his father’s campaign against police and pastoralists in the 1880s. As his moral outrage conflated with his disappointment in the mission’s progress, he threw himself into a new role as the moral champion of Aboriginals in their dealings with whites. In 1915, he bailed up a stockman travelling with two Aboriginals and demanded to see the Chief Protector’s authority to take them from their district. When the documents were not forthcoming, Gribble asserted his authority as Protector of Aborigines and took the pair to his mission. Local settlers were outraged and protested that their livelihood hinged on unfettered access to cheap, black labour, but their opposition did not intimidate Gribble. He went further and banned mission inmates from working on the roads in Wyndham. Settlers accused him of keeping ‘young bucks’ idle and poaching workers to increase the numbers at his mission. The Chief Protector of Aborigines, Auber Octavius Neville, sided with the settlers. Neville, an impeccably groomed bureaucrat with a round face and close-set eyes, inhabited the government offices in Murray Street Perth and was called ‘Mister Neville’ by the State’s Aboriginal population. Gribble did not care that the Chief Protector believed in the gainful employment of able-bodied Aboriginals. His position was firm. The only hope for Aboriginals, Gribble argued, was total segregation under missionary influence and he was: determined to fight against any of our Aborigines going into Wyndham [because] it . . . means prostitution for the females and a lazy life for the husbands and apart from that we must urge & work for segregation if we are to do any good.11
He harassed the Chief Protector and Sergeant Archie Buckland, Wyndham’s senior police officer, to invoke Section 39 of the 1905 Aborigines Act. Introduced in the wake of the Roth Royal Commission, the Act gave the government sweeping controls
A Terribly Wild Man-TEXT PAGES 22/12/01 7:01 AM Page 106
106
A T E R R I B LY W I L D M A N
AREA ENLARGED
NT QLD
WA Ly n e R
SA
CAMBRIDGE
NSW
GULF
ACT
VIC
TA S
Victoria Squatting Co. main camp
Patrick
R
FORREST RIVER MISSION
Camera Pool
Forre
Stockdale's Hut
st
ver
Ern
est
River
Ri
BA
ST
IO
Mt Albany
ve Ri ra
N
RA
NG
ES
Wyndham
ck
K
in
g 0
Ri
Pentecos
t
Ri
ver
Du
r
8
ve
Miles
r
Forrest River Mission & District
over Aboriginals, including the power for the police to exclude Aboriginals from prohibited areas and to remove unemployed Aboriginals to reserves. Gribble hoped that the declaration of Wyndham as a prohibited area would stop Aboriginals being ‘drawn off the Reserve and away from [mission] influence’.12 Sergeant Buckland took a different view. He had been subduing Aboriginals in the Kimberley since the 1890s and he knew the desires of settlers and pastoralists. A zealous missionary would not rouse him to act against their interests. Gribble responded by
A Terribly Wild Man-TEXT PAGES 22/12/01 7:01 AM Page 107
WHEN
N AT I V E F R U I T S A R E R I P E
107
launching an eighteen-month campaign in Church journals and The West Australian, accusing Buckland and the police of being lax and ignoring his complaints. Gribble’s campaign alienated him from the sympathies of settlers and police in the north west, but the prohibited area was declared in 1916. Word that Gribble was making trouble began filtering south and the Perth Board of Missions started to get anxious. It handled the daily administration of Forrest River for the ABM in Sydney and Gribble’s crusade against the police revived its collective memory of JB’s clash with the establishment and the upheaval that resulted. Just as troubling for the Secretary of the Perth Board of Missions, Archdeacon Hudleston, was the high turnover in staff and the mission’s mounting debts to shopkeepers in Wyndham. Hudleston decided to make the long trip north to personally inspect the mission. On his return to Perth he floated the idea of replacing Gribble but Bishop Trower rejected the idea outright. This path blocked, Hudleston urged Gribble to take an early furlough rather than wait the usual five years. Gribble’s past flashed before him. His confidence was rattled. He insisted that he was indispensable and doing the work of three men: ‘to force matters as regards my furlough will not do’.13 Gribble exhausted his anxiety by forging a tidy village between Dadaway lagoon and the stony hills that edged Oombulgurri Plain. Streets were laid out in grid formation and named after Anglican missions. A hospital, dormitories and married people’s home appeared. The Church of St Michael and All Angels—a thatched pavilion partially open on all four sides—was the only church in the East Kimberley when it was completed in 1921. The thatch buildings were picturesque, but alive with nesting insects and fires were frequent. To keep the dust at bay, the dirt floors were soaked with bullock blood and polished to a shine when dry. The furniture was ‘Kimberley Chippendale’—rough constructions made from onion and oil boxes. Later the place was rebuilt in sun-dried bricks. Michael Durack, patriarch of the Durack cattle dynasty and Member of the Legislative Assembly for the Kimberley from 1917
A Terribly Wild Man-TEXT PAGES 22/12/01 7:01 AM Page 108
108
A T E R R I B LY W I L D M A N
to 1924, visited the mission and declared it a collection of ‘tumbledown sorts of thatched houses’.14 Gribble put his hopes for a Christian community in the young married couples in the mission compound. Women were persuaded to abandon their tribal husbands and married on the mission in defiance of betrothal commitments, kinship laws and tribal obligations. The brengen and narlies retaliated by showering the compound with spears when Gribble refused to hand over married women or girls promised as brides. The women at the mission had to be guarded in case they were abducted or absconded, and the men were attacked for ‘marrying wrong’. Gribble threatened the attackers with twenty strokes of his strap and promised to ‘drive back with a stockwhip any mission man who went outside the compound to the old men’s camps’.15 Outside the mission compound, the birth rate fell. Gribble declared this a victory for God and proof that the mission was saving the local people from extinction, but the women told anthropologist Phyllis Kaberry that they aborted pregnancies because they did not want to bear children to be taken by the mission. Others avoided the place. Inside the compound, Gribble worked to impose order. Inmates mastered daily drill, the children marched to and from church in straight lines singing the ‘Gloria Patra’ and the school day ended with a chorus of ‘God Save the Queen’. Gribble fell back on the familiar formulae he had used at Yarrabah: bells summoned everyone to daily parade for the allocation of jobs; the mission population gathered to salute the Union Jack on ‘Flag Day’ each month; and Sunday mass was proceeded by a procession through the village to strains of ‘Onward, Christian Soldiers’. Services were intoned with sung canticles, scarlet-clad choristers sang Holy Communion and Compline, and the return of the mission boat was greeted with a chorus of ‘Te Deum’. Gribble reported that the local people were curious about God and listened attentively during services. His favourite text was ‘Mission boy no tell lie; no steal, no lazy fellow, no dirty fellow’.16 In mid-1915, he began a class with seven Catechumens. Twelve months later, four
A Terribly Wild Man-TEXT PAGES 22/12/01 7:01 AM Page 109
WHEN
N AT I V E F R U I T S A R E R I P E
109
inmates were baptised, although the first confirmation was not held until six years later, in August 1922. By the end of 1928, the tally of converts was 134 baptisms and 34 confirmations, but Gribble admitted that most baptised men left after a few months to find wives. Four confirmed men (11 per cent of the total) absconded to fulfil traditional marriage obligations and Gribble deposed his five most trusted converts from their posts as church servers after they participated in circumcision rites. Reverend Haining arrived at the mission and summed up the situation succinctly: most converts eventually ‘lapse and go bush’; Christianity is ‘not as real as one could wish [and] does not seem to have sunk in very deeply’ and is ‘based upon a superstitious fear & [sic] a large percentage of hysteria’.17 Meanwhile, Church publications spread the news that girls from the dormitory pulled the punkah while the staff ate their meals and the inmates were always: quick to show