Mouton Grammar Library
A Grammar of Lao
≥
Mouton Grammar Library 38
Editors Georg Bossong Bernard Comrie Matthew Dr...
95 downloads
3575 Views
1MB Size
Report
This content was uploaded by our users and we assume good faith they have the permission to share this book. If you own the copyright to this book and it is wrongfully on our website, we offer a simple DMCA procedure to remove your content from our site. Start by pressing the button below!
Report copyright / DMCA form
Mouton Grammar Library
A Grammar of Lao
≥
Mouton Grammar Library 38
Editors Georg Bossong Bernard Comrie Matthew Dryer
Mouton de Gruyter Berlin · New York
A Grammar of Lao by N. J. Enfield
Mouton de Gruyter Berlin · New York
Mouton de Gruyter (formerly Mouton, The Hague) is a Division of Walter de Gruyter GmbH & Co. KG, Berlin.
앝 Printed on acid-free paper which falls within the guidelines of the 앪 ANSI to ensure permanence and durability.
Library of Congress Cataloging-in-Publication Data Enfield, N.J, 1966⫺ A grammar of Lao / by N. J. Enfield. p. cm. ⫺ (Mouton grammar library ; 38) Includes bibliographical references and index. ISBN 978-3-11-018588-1 (cloth : alk. paper) 1. Lao language ⫺ Grammar. 2. Tai languages ⫺ Dialects ⫺ Phonetics. 3. Tai languages ⫺ Variation ⫺ Laos. 4. Tai languages ⫺ Variation ⫺ Thailand. 5. Tai languages ⫺ Variation ⫺ Cambodia. 6. Tai languages ⫺ Grammar, Comparative. 7. Structural linguistics. I. Title. II. Series. PL4236.1.E64 2007 495.9119182421⫺dc22 2007035644
Bibliographic information published by the Deutsche Nationalbibliothek The Deutsche Nationalbibliothek lists this publication in the Deutsche Nationalbibliografie; detailed bibliographic data are available in the Internet at http://dnb.d-nb.de.
ISBN 978-3-11-018588-1 ISSN 0933-7636 ” Copyright 2007 by Walter de Gruyter GmbH & Co. KG, D-10785 Berlin. All rights reserved, including those of translation into foreign languages. No part of this book may be reproduced or transmitted in any form or by any means, electronic or mechanical, including photocopy, recording or any information storage and retrieval system, without permission in writing from the publisher. Printed in Germany.
For my love
Preface
To understand language, nothing compares with the task of trying to work one’s way through the wings of a grand mansion like Lao. It brings unforeseen adventures. Mapping out the lay of the land, one quickly realizes that this house harbors hidden chamber after hidden chamber, secret stairwells, false walls, doorways papered over, whole basements and rooftops undiscovered, mazes, gardens, chapels, cellars and rabbit warrens, it goes on and on without end. So, to repeat a clich´e, but a well deserved one: this grammar is incomplete. It is a progress report on a life long project. It is a partial description, an imbalanced description, and in ways an inadequate description. But one has to stop somewhere if the work is to emerge. One way in which this description merely approximates the phenomenon of interest is through abstracting, following standard descriptive linguistic practice, from social variation inherent in the language. Lao—like any language—is a dynamic, social, variable, changing system of sounds, words, idioms, constructions, and strategies. Lao speakers find themselves in a wide range of social situations which will differently determine how they formulate the things they say: the constructions they employ, the words they select, the way they pronounce those words, among many other points of variation. Speakers respond artfully to local contexts and their social exigencies, applying and negotiating multiple sets of communicative convention, both ritual and mundane. I am painfully aware of the richness of these important complexities, and of the consequences of bracketing them out of the current enterprise. I have tried to represent the social texture of Lao grammar where possible, for example by varying the formality of pronouns used in the example sentences. But dealing in detail with socially sensitive variation in Lao grammar is a topic for a different book.
viii
Preface
A second way in which this description merely approximates the phenomenon of interest is that it takes the clause or sentence to be the basic unit of analysis. Many other unit types are relevant. For example, speech is chunked into turns at talk of a few seconds each, and these turns are interleaved in extended sequences, usually conversations. Those sequences, and the complex interactional practices which keep them orderly, have structures of their own, and these structures are seldom if ever described in grammars. Moreover, these linguistic structures occur in fully multimodal contexts, where people simultaneously employ rich semiotic resources which are meaningfully related to their talk (e.g., gesture, eye gaze, bodily comportment). Again, I am painfully aware of these important components of what it takes to speak Lao, and of the consequences of bracketing them out of the present work. It’s another topic for a different book. These uncharacteristic apologies aside, the piece of Lao captured in this book may be a thin slice, but it is not a random one. I have tried to capture a variety of Lao which is typical of everyday, informal conversation among kin and familiars in rural or semi-rural village life. The analyses are based on empirical data from spontaneous speech of semirural villagers, of low to average levels of formal education (some nonliterate, some with primary school education, some with high school), in narratives and conversation recorded in informal settings. The exclusive consideration of spoken rather than written language, and the emphasis on everyday, informal usage reflects a primary concern with language in its primordial format, and not the very recently emergent, modern, massaged, context-narrow structures which arise in the political environment of media, literacy, and standardization. A note to the non-specialist reader: This is a technical, reference description, not a primer, and not a rule book. While certain sections (e.g., Chapter 2) are easily accessible by the general reader, most of the work presumes a technical background in linguistics (at least to undergraduate level). If you are a speaker or learner of Lao, you may find this work useful as a reference. But it has no authority in any institutional or otherwise official sense. The book does not prescribe correct ways of speaking Lao. It describes the structures that native Lao speakers produce, even where these ways of speaking might be regarded by those in socio-political authority as incorrect, sub-standard, or otherwise defective. To the extent that it is possible to keep the two apart, this book focuses on the structure
Preface
ix
of language, not on ideology about the structure of language. The patterns described here are norms, not rules. If you do not speak Lao and your aim is to learn, you might not find much joy in this book during the earliest stages of your studies. You could instead begin by amassing as many primers or phrase books as you can—none are perfect, all are useful— and work through them methodically, as you practice in the villages of lowland Laos. The main thing is to go forth and speak. If I fall short of delivering the ‘succinct, rigorous and sensitive masterpiece’ that every language deserves (Ameka, Dench, and Evans 2006:v), I hope at least to have made progress in our understanding of Lao, and the relevance to linguistic science of some of its structures. Much work remains.
Acknowledgements
I thank my many friends and consultants in Laos who have helped me understand their language, especially Pitsana Vayaphanh, Nak Bouphanouvong, Thongdeng Silakoun, Syban Khoukham, and Latsamay Sylavong. For friendship and support in Laos, I am grateful to these people, as well as Jim Chamberlain, Adam Chapman, Rachel Dechaineaux, Grant Evans, the Flint household, Joost Foppes, Yves Goudineau, Peter Koret, Michel Lorrillard, Kathryn Sweet, and the Vayaphanh household. I am grateful ´ to the office of the Ecole Franc¸aise d’Extrˆeme-Orient in Naxay for generously supplying a place to work while in the city of Vientiane. For comments on various parts of the grammar, whether in written form, orally presented, or in conversation, I thank Sasha Aikhenvald, Felix Ameka, Peter Austin, Walter Bisang, J¨urgen Bohnemeyer, Melissa Bowerman, David Bradley, Penny Brown, Jim Chamberlain, Adam Chapman, Hilary Chappell, Bernard Comrie, Art Crisfield, G´erard Diffloth, Tony Diller, Bob Dixon, Matthew Dryer, Michael Dunn, Dominique Estival, Grant Evans, Nick Evans, Martina Faller, Bill Foley, Alice Gaby, David Gil, Cliff Goddard, Yves Goudineau, Bill Hanks, Nikolaus Himmelmann, Søren Ivarsson, Anthony Jukes, Paul Kockelman, Peter Koret, Steve Levinson, Michel Lorrillard, Asifa Majid, Andrej Malchukov, Stephen Matthews, Bhuvana Narasimhan, John Newman, Andy Pawley, Boike Rehbein, Craig Reynolds, Alan Rumsey, Hans-J¨urgen Sasse, Eva Schultze-Berndt, Frank Seifart, Gunter Senft, Tanya Stivers, Martin Stuart-Fox, Kingkarn Thepkanjana, Angela Terrill, Sylvia Tufvesson, Satoshi Uehara, and Anna Wierzbicka. I am especially grateful for extensive and penetrating commentary at different stages from Tony Diller (early), Nick Evans (middle), and Paul Kockelman (late). None of these commentators are to be blamed for any errors or infelicities of this work. A number of sections of this book have appeared in earlier form. I am grateful to the publishers and editors involved for kindly giving me per-
xii
Acknowledgements
mission to include revised sections of these publications as sections of this book: Case relations in Lao, a radically isolating language (in Handbook of Case, ed. A. Malchukov and A. Spencer, Oxford U. Press); Description of reciprocal events in Lao (in Reciprocals and Semantic Typology, ed. N. Evans, A. Gaby, S. C. Levinson, and A. Majid, John Benjamins); Verbs and Multi-verb sequences in Lao (in The Tai-Kadai Languages, ed. A. V. N. Diller, J. A. Edmondson, and Y. X. Luo, Routledge); Lao linguistics in ´ the 20th century and since (in Bulletin of the Ecole Franc¸aise d’ExtrˆemeOrient, Special Issue ‘Recent Research on Laos’, ed. Y. Goudineau and M. Lorrillard); Encoding three-participant events in the Lao clause (Linguistics 45.3, 509-538); Depictive and other secondary predication in Lao (in Secondary Predication and Adverbial Modification, ed. N. P. Himmelmann and E. Schultze-Berndt. Oxford U. Press); Adjectives in Lao (in Adjective classes, ed. R. M. W. Dixon and A. Y. Aikhenvald. Oxford U. Press); Nominal classification in Lao (Sprachtypologie und Universalienforschung, 57.2/3, 117-143); Linguistic Epidemiology (RoutledgeCurzon); Combinatoric properties of natural semantic metalanguage expressions in Lao (in Meaning and Universal Grammar, ed. C. Goddard and A. Wierzbicka. John Benjamins); Lao as a national language (in Laos: Culture and Society, ed. G. Evans. Silkworm Books). During the time that I have been working on this grammar, I have also worked on a number of narrower topics in Lao semantics and pragmatics. These are being assembled for publication as a separate volume. Many Lao language examples provided in this book are from a corpus of spontaneous spoken language collected in Vientiane in 1996-1997. This corpus contains several hours of material, on a range of topics and styles, including procedural descriptions, jokes, informal conversation, myths, fables, life-story narratives. These are from a range of speakers, both male and female, varying in age from early teens to mid 80’s. Many other examples (and the texts supplied at the end of the book) are from a video-recorded corpus of everyday conversation which I began collecting in 2000. A number of examples are elicited by means of semiexperimental materials (stimulus-based elicitation). Remaining examples are constructed or elicited in consultation with native speaker consultants. Quotations from Lao language sources are my translation. Financial support for early stages of this research (prior to 2000) came from an Australian Research Council grant (A59601467 Thai-Lao Linguistic Interaction, chief investigator A. V. N. Diller), an Australian Post-
Acknowledgements
xiii
graduate Award (based at the University of Melbourne), a National Visiting Scholarship (at the Research School for Pacific and Asian Studies, ANU) and a University of Melbourne Faculty of Arts fieldwork grant. Most of the work (since 2000) has been supported by the Max Planck Society for the Advancement of Science. I gratefully acknowledge this support, and the Max Planck Institute, Nijmegen, for facilitating it. I owe this ultimately to the professional support of Steve Levinson, and to him I am especially grateful. I thank Anouk Diederen and Alex Dukers for assistance in early stages of preparing the manuscript, and Ludy Cilissen for handling the graphics at the last minute. Erica Renckens carried out the main task of putting together the final version. This work was done using LATEX. Michael Dunn and Stuart Robinson generously provided coaching and trouble-shooting in the art of word processing under the hood. Michael’s last minute assistance was warmly appreciated. Erica showed enormous skill and application in creating the final manuscript as camera ready copy. Her brilliance and cheer through the complex process of assembling and formatting the many parts of this work (including putting up with my ‘minor’ revisions) was sheer pleasure to watch. At Mouton, I thank Bernard Comrie for early support of this project, as well as Ursula Kleinhenz and Wolfgang Konwitschny for patience and support in the late stages. The book is dedicated to Pitsana Vayaphanh, with all my love. To paraphrase Chao Yuan Ren: ‘her inadvertencies have furnished me with many an apt example’. N. J. E.
Nijmegen, October 2007
Contents
Preface
vii
Acknowledgements
xi
Abbreviations and conventions
xxiii
I
Preliminaries
1
1
Overview
3
2
Language background 2.1 Previous linguistic research on Lao . . . . . . . . . . . . 2.1.1 Typological and descriptive work on Lao . . . . 2.1.2 Lexicography . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2.1.3 Pedagogical material . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2.1.4 Lao among Tai Languages . . . . . . . . . . . . 2.1.5 Lao language as part of a broader semiotic system 2.1.6 Language endangerment . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2.2 Lao as a national language . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2.2.1 Variation and efforts at standardization . . . . . 2.2.2 Revolutionary reforms . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2.2.3 Contemporary debate . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
7 7 8 13 14 14 16 16 17 17 27 30
3
Phonology 3.1 Phonotactics . . . . . . . 3.2 Major-initial consonants 3.3 Final consonants . . . . 3.4 Vowels . . . . . . . . . .
33 33 34 35 35
. . . .
. . . .
. . . .
. . . .
. . . .
. . . .
. . . .
. . . .
. . . .
. . . .
. . . .
. . . .
. . . .
. . . .
. . . .
. . . .
. . . .
xvi
Contents
3.5 3.6 3.7
II 4
III 5
6
Tones . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Transcription . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Remark . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
Particles Sentence-final and phrase-final particles 4.1 Sentence-final particles . . . . . . . . . . . . 4.1.1 Interrogative particles . . . . . . . . 4.1.2 Factive particles . . . . . . . . . . . 4.1.3 Imperative particles . . . . . . . . . . 4.2 Other phrase-final particles . . . . . . . . . . 4.3 On the relationship between particles and tone
39 . . . . . .
. . . . . .
. . . . . .
. . . . . .
. . . . . .
. . . . . .
Nominals and Reference Pronouns 5.1 Definite pronouns . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 5.1.1 Bare pronouns . . . . . . . . . . . . 5.1.2 Familiar pronouns . . . . . . . . . . 5.1.3 Polite pronouns . . . . . . . . . . . . 5.1.4 Formal pronouns . . . . . . . . . . . 5.2 Indefinite pronouns . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 5.2.1 Core indefinite pronominal forms . . 5.2.2 Other indefinites and question words .
35 37 37
41 41 44 52 63 68 72 75
. . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . .
Nominal modification 6.1 Possession . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 6.1.1 External possession . . . . . . . . . . . . . 6.2 Determiners . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 6.2.1 Syntactic dependence of determiners . . . . 6.2.2 Demonstratives . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 6.2.3 Topic markers . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 6.3 Quantifiers . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 6.3.1 Baang3 ‘some’, n`ung1 ‘one’, s`oo` ng3 ‘two’ 6.3.2 thuk1 ‘every’ and t`ee` 1-laø ‘each’ . . . . . 6.3.3 Laaj3 ‘much/many’ . . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . .
77 77 79 83 83 84 84 84 91
. . . . . . . . . .
93 94 94 97 98 99 100 104 104 107 108
xvii
Contents
6.4 7
8
6.3.4 Met2 ‘all’ . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 110 Relativization . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 112
Nominal classification 7.1 Numeral classifiers . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 7.1.1 The basic numeral classifier construction . . . 7.1.2 Repeaters . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 7.1.3 The set of numeral classifiers . . . . . . . . . . 7.1.4 Semantics of numeral classifiers . . . . . . . . 7.1.5 Mensural terms . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 7.1.6 Shape and form semantics . . . . . . . . . . . 7.1.7 Bare numeral classifier with the meaning ‘one’ 7.1.8 Speaker awareness of numeral classifiers . . . 7.1.9 Numerals . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 7.2 Modifier classifiers . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 7.2.1 A modifier classifier for people . . . . . . . . . 7.2.2 Nominal modification . . . . . . . . . . . . . 7.2.3 A unitizing function . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 7.3 Class terms . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 7.3.1 Class terms denoting taxonomic essence . . . . 7.3.2 Class terms denoting occupation or role . . . . 7.3.3 Class terms denoting function . . . . . . . . . 7.3.4 A productive class term prefix: khiø- ‘shit’ . . 7.3.5 An ‘opaque prefix’ class term ka- . . . . . . . 7.4 Kin prefixes . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 7.5 Relations between forms of nominal classification . . . 7.6 Summary on nominal classification . . . . . . . . . . . Reference management 8.1 First mention in mii2 presentational construction . 8.2 Other types of first mention . . . . . . . . . . . . . 8.2.1 First mention in extraclausal Left Position . 8.2.2 First mention as non-subject argument . . . 8.2.3 First mention in extraclausal Right Position 8.2.4 First mention as clausal subject . . . . . . 8.3 Subsequent reference-tracking . . . . . . . . . . . 8.4 Remark . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
119 120 120 122 124 127 128 129 131 132 133 137 142 143 144 146 147 148 149 150 150 151 153 155
. . . . . . . .
157 157 161 161 162 163 164 165 168
xviii
IV 9
Contents
Verbs and Predication Aspectual-modal marking 9.1 Aspectual-modal markers . . . . . . . . . . . . 9.1.1 Post-verbal aspectual-modal markers . 9.1.2 Second-position markers . . . . . . . . 9.1.3 Pre-negation aspectual-modal markers . 9.1.4 Irrealis markers . . . . . . . . . . . . . 9.1.5 Negation marker . . . . . . . . . . . . 9.1.6 Post-negation aspectual-modal markers 9.1.7 Achievement marker . . . . . . . . . . 9.1.8 Directional markers . . . . . . . . . . . 9.2 Other temporal expressions . . . . . . . . . . .
171 . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . .
10 Verbs and verb types 10.1 Characteristics of the verb class . . . . . . . . . . . . . 10.1.1 Nominals as predicates . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 10.1.2 Verb sub-classes . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 10.1.3 Nominals as noun modifiers . . . . . . . . . . . 10.2 Adjective sub-class of verbs . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 10.2.1 Semantic sub-classes . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 10.2.2 Structure of the noun phrase . . . . . . . . . . . 10.2.3 Reduplication . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 10.2.4 Comparative and superlative expressions . . . . 10.2.5 Adverbial function of adjectives . . . . . . . . . 10.2.6 Collaborative event marking . . . . . . . . . . . 10.2.7 Inchoativization using directional complements . 10.2.8 Verbs of state change as adjectives . . . . . . . . 10.2.9 Circadian time-period terms . . . . . . . . . . . 10.2.10 Color terms . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 10.3 Derivation of adjectives . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 10.3.1 Complex adjectives . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 10.3.2 Zero derivation . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 10.3.3 Derivational prefix khiø- . . . . . . . . . . . . . 10.3.4 Derivational construction pˆen3-taa3-V ‘be-eye-V’ 10.3.5 Summary . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 10.4 Some argument structure alternations . . . . . . . . . . 10.5 Summary . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
173 173 178 197 204 214 216 217 231 232 234 239 239 240 241 247 248 251 252 253 256 257 258 259 260 261 262 264 264 266 267 267 268 268 270
Contents
xix
11 Basic clausal syntax 11.1 Argument structure . . . . . . . . . . . . 11.1.1 Some terminological distinctions . 11.1.2 Pragmatically oriented grammar . 11.1.3 Argument-predicate relations . . . 11.1.4 Expressive case functions . . . . 11.1.5 Remark . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 11.2 Copula verbs . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 11.3 Some illustrative basic event types . . . . 11.3.1 keet5-kh`un5 ‘happen’ . . . . . . . 11.3.2 Hˆet1 ‘do’ . . . . . . . . . . . . . 11.3.3 taaj3 ‘die’ . . . . . . . . . . . . . 11.3.4 juu1 ‘live’ . . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . .
271 271 271 272 277 282 284 284 289 289 290 293 294
12 Expressive forms 12.1 Ideophones . . . . . . . . . . . . . 12.2 Onomatopoeia . . . . . . . . . . . . 12.3 Four-syllable rhyming expressions . 12.4 Echo formation . . . . . . . . . . . 12.4.1 Echo formative reduplication 12.5 Interjections . . . . . . . . . . . . . 12.5.1 Environment-oriented . . . 12.5.2 Discourse-oriented . . . . . 12.5.3 Animal-oriented . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . .
299 299 304 304 306 309 310 311 312 314
13 Non-canonical transitive events 13.1 Collaborative and reciprocal event marking . . . . . 13.1.1 Type 1 kan3 construction . . . . . . . . . . . 13.1.2 Type 2 kan3 construction . . . . . . . . . . . 13.1.3 Semantic range of Type 1 construction . . . . 13.1.4 Information structure of Type 2 construction 13.1.5 Contrasting Type 1 and Type 2 constructions 13.2 Strict reciprocity . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 13.2.1 Suu1 NP suu1 VP construction . . . . . . . . 13.2.2 ‘I V you, You V me’ construction . . . . . . 13.2.3 Remark . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 13.3 Reflexive and logophoric expressions . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . .
317 317 318 319 320 328 329 330 330 331 332 333
. . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . .
xx
Contents
V
Multi-verb constructions
337
14 Preliminary remarks on multi-verb constructions 14.1 Clause separability of multi-verb constructions . . 14.2 Yes-answerhood . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 14.3 Ellipsibility of object complements . . . . . . . . . 14.3.1 Ellipsibility in main clauses . . . . . . . . 14.3.2 Ellipsibility in relativization . . . . . . . . 14.4 Insertability of preverbal aspectual-modal marking 14.5 Insertability of topic linker kaø . . . . . . . . . . . 14.6 Remark . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 15 Three-participant events 15.1 Single-verb means . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 15.1.1 Incorporation strategy . . . . . . . . . . 15.1.2 External topicalization strategy . . . . . . 15.1.3 Ellipsis . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 15.1.4 Variations and complications . . . . . . . 15.2 Multi-verb means . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 15.2.1 Handling-despatch construction . . . . . 15.2.2 Despatch-despatch construction . . . . . 15.2.3 Addition of a third ‘reception’ verb . . . 15.2.4 Other three-participant event types . . . . 15.2.5 Other functions for the multi-verb pattern 15.3 An oblique strategy . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 15.4 Remark . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 16 Spatial predication 16.1 Motion . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 16.1.1 Tiing3/nˆeng3 ‘move’ . . . . . . . . 16.1.2 Consecutive vector motion . . . . . 16.1.3 Manner-path-direction constructions 16.1.4 Multi-participant motion events . . 16.2 Location . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 16.2.1 Locative verb juu1 . . . . . . . . . 16.2.2 Basic locative construction . . . . . 16.2.3 Spatial frames of reference . . . . .
. . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . .
339 340 342 346 346 347 350 350 353
. . . . . . . . . . . . .
355 356 356 360 361 363 366 368 371 373 374 375 378 380
. . . . . . . . .
383 383 383 386 387 389 390 390 391 394
Contents
xxi
17 Secondary Predication 17.1 Depictives . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 17.1.1 V2 Depictives . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 17.1.2 V1 Depictives . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 17.1.3 Use of nominals in depictive expressions 17.2 Resultative constructions . . . . . . . . . . . . . 17.2.1 Semantics of cause-result expressions . . 17.2.2 Same-subject resultatives . . . . . . . . . 17.2.3 Projected resultatives . . . . . . . . . . . 17.2.4 Reiterative resultatives . . . . . . . . . . 17.2.5 Remark . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . .
397 399 399 403 404 410 411 412 415 417 419
18 Causation 18.1 Causatives in haj5 ‘give’ . . . . . . 18.2 Causatives in hˆet1 ‘make’ . . . . . . 18.3 Causatives in hˆet1-haj5 ‘make-give’ 18.4 Other verbs . . . . . . . . . . . . . 18.5 Other periphrastic strategies . . . .
. . . . .
. . . . .
. . . . .
. . . . .
. . . . .
. . . . .
421 423 424 424 425 426
19 Complementation 19.1 Control complementation . . . . . . . . . . . . 19.1.1 Same-subject control complements . . 19.1.2 Different-subject control complements . 19.2 Non-control complementation . . . . . . . . . 19.3 Verbs both control and non-control . . . . . . . 19.4 So-called passive . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 19.5 Complement-taking predicates . . . . . . . . . 19.5.1 kh`ut1 ‘think’ . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 19.5.2 huu4 ‘know’ . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 19.5.3 jaak5 ‘want’ . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 19.5.4 hˆen3 ‘see’, daj4-˜nin2 ‘hear’ . . . . . . 19.5.5 vaw4 ‘say’ . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . .
427 427 427 430 434 437 438 441 441 445 447 449 451
20 Coordinating constructions 20.1 Verb phrase chaining . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 20.2 Verb compounds . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 20.3 Sentential coordination . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
455 455 458 459
. . . . .
. . . . .
. . . . .
. . . . .
. . . . .
xxii
Contents
21 Adverbial constructions 21.1 Adverbial complementation . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 21.1.1 Right-headed stative adverbial complementation 21.1.2 Comparison with resultative constructions . . . . 21.1.3 Right-headed active adverbial complementation . 21.1.4 Left-headed adverbial complementation . . . . . 21.2 Adverbial compounds . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 21.2.1 Left-marking adverbial compounds . . . . . . . 21.2.2 Right-marking adverbial compounds . . . . . . . 21.3 Adverbial complements with achievement marking . . .
463 463 463 471 473 474 475 475 478 479
22 Summary remark on multi-verb constructions
481
VI
485
Texts
23 Texts 23.1 Text A 23.2 Text B 23.3 Text C 23.4 Text D 23.5 Text E 23.6 Text F
. . . . . .
. . . . . .
. . . . . .
. . . . . .
. . . . . .
. . . . . .
. . . . . .
. . . . . .
. . . . . .
. . . . . .
. . . . . .
. . . . . .
. . . . . .
. . . . . .
. . . . . .
. . . . . .
. . . . . .
. . . . . .
. . . . . .
. . . . . .
. . . . . .
. . . . . .
. . . . . .
. . . . . .
. . . . . .
. . . . . .
. . . . . .
487 487 498 504 513 517 519
References
541
Index
562
Abbreviations and conventions
1 = 1st person 2 = 2nd person 3 = 3rd person A = agent-like argument of transitive clause ABL = ablative ABLE = abilitive ACHV = achievement ADJT = adjunct AFTH = afterthought marker AGT = agent ALL = allative AM = aspectual-modal ANIM = animate B = bare B r = brother C = child C . LINK = clause linker CAN = modal of possibility CF = counterfactual CLF = classifier COMP = complementizer CONST = constantly CONT = continuous CONTR = contrast linker CT = class term DEM = demonstrative DIR = directional DIST = distal e = elder
xxiv
Abbreviations
E = spouse ECHO = echo-formative EUPH = euphonious filler EXP = experiential perfect F = female F a = father FA = familiar FAC = factive FAC . EMPH = factive, emphatic FAC . EXPLIC = factive, explicating FAC . FILLIN = factive, filling in presupposed information FAC . ONRCD = factive, putting on record FAC . NEWS = factive, proposition is news FAC . RESIST = factive, resists current stance FAC . SURPR = factive, proposition is surprising FAC . WEAK = factive, weakens commitment FO = formal G = sibling HES = hesitation HUM = human IDEO = ideophone IMP = imperative IMP. PLEAD = imperative, pleading IMP. RUSH = imperative, rushing IMP. SOFT = imperative, softening IMP. SUGG = imperative, suggesting IMP. UNIMPD = imperative, states that addressee is unimpeded INTJ = interjection IRR = irrealis KNOW. HOW = acquired abilitive M = male M o = mother NEG = negation NO . ADO = without ado NO . HES = without hesitation NONPROX = nonproximal NZR = nominalizer
O = patient-like argument of transitive clause
Abbreviations OBJ = object OBLIG = obligative OBLIG . CF = counterfactual weak OBLIG . STR = strong obligative OBLIG . WEAK = weak obligative ONOM = onomatopoeic ORD = ordinal P = polite P a = parent PCL = particle
obligative
PDR = People’s Democratic Republic PERIPH = peripheral PL = plural PRF = perfect PROB = assumptive epistemic ‘probably’ PROG = progressive PSBL = possible PST. RCNT = recent past Q = question Q . EMPH = content question, emphatic Q . PRESUP = content question, seeks presupposed information QPLR = polar question QPLR . AGREE = polar question, seeking agreement QPLR . INFER = polar question, proposition newly inferred QPLR . PRESM = polar question, proposition independently presumed Q . THEME = question thematizer RDP = reduplication REG = regularly REL = relativizer S = single argument of intransitive clause SG = singular SFP = sentence-final particle SPEC = speculative epistemic SUBJ = subject T. LNK = topic linker THZR = thematizer TH = theme TPC = topic
xxv
xxvi
Abbreviations
UNKN = unknown V = verb VOC = vocative marker WNDR = wondering
y = younger Z = sister · ·
·
Proper names are glossed with single capital letter. Bracketed sections of translations in examples are part of the utterance meaning, but are not explicitly coded in the form of the utterance. Bold-marking in examples indicates item of interest.
Part I Preliminaries
Chapter 1 Overview Lao is an isolating, analytic tone language with no inflectional morphology and little productive derivational morphology. Most words have one stressed syllable, and many have a non-stressed presyllable in addition. There are five lexical tones (level, high rising, low rising, high falling, low falling). Two major open class lexical categories are noun and verb, distinguished by a number of distributional properties: Table 1. Distinguishing properties of the noun and verb classes Property Nouns Can be heads of noun phrases in subject function + Can be possessor in possessive construction + Can take a modifier linked by the relativizer thii1 + Can be a modifier linked by the relativizer thii1 – Can take direct negation in predicate function –
Verbs – – – + +
In the nominal domain, further form classes include personal (definite) pronouns, indefinite pronouns, determiners, and classifiers. The personal pronouns show a thoroughgoing set of distinctions for social deixis, distinguishing in all three persons between bare, familiar, polite and formal person reference. Indefinite pronouns distinguish only between basic ontological categories of person, animate, and thing. The indefinite pronouns also function as interrogative pronouns. There is a complex system of nominal classification, with distinct patterns for numeral classifiers, modifier classifiers, class terms, and kin prefixes. Most words which function as classifiers are not members of a distinct classifier form class, but are open class nouns used in classifier functions, as determined by constructional context. Noun phrases are basically head-initial, but do not show a high branching hierarchical structure. They are often discontinuous, with head nouns not always adjacent to modifier phrases. Discourse-level reference management (i.e., introducing new referents, tracking already introduced ones) generally follows principles of preferred argument structure, with new
4
Overview
referents tending not to occur in subject function. A presentational verbfirst construction provides a dedicated means for introducing new arguments in non clause-initial position. Subsequent tracking of referents in discourse involves the use of both definite pronouns and zero anaphora. Noun phrases in almost any position may be ellipsed if they are in any sense currently given (definite, accessible) in the discourse, or otherwise contextually retrievable. Exceptions include complements of certain prepositions such as caak5 ‘from’, kap2 ‘with’, and k`ee` 1 ‘to’, and heads of noun phrases with relative clause modifiers. In the verbal domain, there are distinctions between sub-classes of verbs. One of these is the sub-class of adjectives, whose distinct syntactic properties include the possibility of Type A reduplication. There is a major open class of ideophones. These are distinct from verbs both in form (they tend to be bisyllabic, showing rhyming or alliterative structure) and grammatical behavior (they are constrained to a single construction type, and cannot take aspectual-modal marking). The basic Lao clause is (schematically) organized as follows:1
LP
/
SUBJ
AM -[ V ( OBJ )]- AM
SFP
\
RP
Figure 1.1. Major constituents of the Lao clause
Left and Right Positions are extraclausal slots which may contain any nominal (whether or not it is an argument of the verb), as well as phrases, clauses, or larger structures. While Left Position is not necessarily marked off prosodically in any special way, Right Position is audibly marked off with a comma-like downstep, with lower pitch and volume than the main clause immediately preceding it. Subject is a straightforward grouping of A (agent-like argument of a transitive verb) and S (single argument of an intransitive verb). Subject is weakly active in clausal organization. For example, subject does not function as a syntactic pivot in cross-clausal relations. Object is the Abbreviations in the Figure are: LP = Left Position, / = left border of the clausal core, AM = Aspectual-Modal markers, SFP = Sentence-Final Particles, \ = right border of the clausal core, RP = Right Position. 1
Overview
5
patient-like complement of a transitive verb. Objects appear immediately following the verb, with nothing intervening. Aspectual-modal distinctions are marked both preverbally and postverb-phrasally (‘AM’ in Figure 1), in a series of ordered slots. Many of the aspectual-modal markers also function as open class items (mostly verbs). Further distinctions in the domain of modality are made by the sentence-final particles, an important and sizeable form class (with at least thirty members). Sentence-final particles make a range of distinctions in illocutionary force, status, and evidentiality. Syntactically, sentence-final particles constitute a robust syntactic end border of the clausal core. They are stressed and prosodically exposed, marking off any post-posed (i.e., right-positioned) material to come. Functionally, sentence-final particles are an important part of the set of aspectual-modal resources, which are distributed across a range of syntactic positions from the clausal core to the periphery and beyond. Complex clausal grammar centers on the use of multi-verb constructions (or serial verb constructions). These are sequences of verbs or verb phrases which lack overt morphological marking of interrelationships such as subordination or coordination. A great variety of complex syntactic-semantic configurations are covertly coded in these sequences, including complex motion constructions, various types of secondary predication (depictive, resultative, and adverbial constructions), causative constructions, adverbial constructions, complement constructions, and coordinating constructions. The remainder of this preliminary part covers language background and phonology. Part II consists of a single chapter on final particles. Most of the attention is on sentence-final particles, one of the most important and salient expressive resources of the language. The four chapters in Part III deal with referential expressions, including pronouns, complex noun phrase structures, and strategies for reference management. Part IV concerns the grammar of verbs and predication, including the system of aspectual-modal marking and associated sub-distinctions between verb types, the properties of basic clausal syntax, and the expression of non-canonical event types. There is also a chapter on expressive forms, including ideophones and other sound symbolic or alliterative resources. The nine chapters in Part V lay out the broad range of multi-verb structures. Part VI supplies a set of six spoken texts, taken from recordings of face-to-face conversation.
Chapter 2 Language background Lao is among a small minority of the world’s languages to have achieved national language status. It is the national language of Laos, spoken by over four million people there. It is also spoken by a minority in Northeast Cambodia, and a large minority (at least ten million) in Northeast Thailand (in areas bordering lowland Laos). There are also scattered Laospeaking villages in Western Cambodia and Central and Eastern Thailand. The dialects spoken in Thailand are undergoing rapid change under the influence of central Thai (Diller 1988, 1991). Lao is also spoken in sizeable expatriate communities in the US, Australia, and France. Laos shows a very high degree of linguistic diversity, with up to 100 languages from five different major language families spoken in an area smaller than the United Kingdom. See Enfield (2006a, 2006b, 2006e) for discussion of language diversity and endangerment in Laos. For the areal setting of mainland Southeast Asia, see Enfield (2005b). For historical and ethnographic information on Laos and the Lao, see Stuart-Fox (1986, 1997, 1998), Evans (1990, 1997, 2002), Ireson (1996), Pholsena (2006), Rehbein (2007), and many references in those works. In presenting background information on the language, I first review existing research on the language, and second, discuss the recent historical and social circumstances of Lao’s national language status.
2.1
Previous linguistic research on Lao
During the period of French rule in Laos (1893-1954) and up to the establishment of the Lao People’s Democratic Republic (PDR) in 1975, several grammars of Lao appeared, written essentially in the style of European pedagogical grammars (Hospitalier 1937, Phoumi 1967, RLG 1972, Reinhorn 1980, Nginn 1984). Some intellectual activity was ostensibly devoted to grammar, but this mostly related to orthographic conventions. To some degree it also concerned research on the lexicon. This included most notably the work of Sila Vilavong, P. S. Nginn, and Phoumi Vongvichit. The traditions of scholarship (and politics) associated with these
8
Language background
three men are discussed in section 2.2, below. An important recent development for the state of research on grammar in Laos is the Lao government’s 2002 establishment of a Linguistic Research Institute, within the Ministry of Information and Culture of the Lao PDR. The institute director Dr. Thongphet Kingsada (PhD, Linguistics, Hanoi University) is also chief editor of a linguistic journal entitled Language and life, which first appeared in January 2003. The first edition includes 10 brief articles (3 in English) on topics ranging from ‘Buddhism and the Lao language’ to ‘Languages and ethnic classification in the Lao PDR’ to ‘Lao writing and word breaks’ to a study of the morphosyntactic differentiation in Lao between the numerals ‘2100’ and ‘2001’. Comparable venues for publication of such research in linguistics during the Royal Lao Government era (Evans 2002:93ff) included publications of the Literary Committee (e.g., RLG 1972) and the Royal Academic Council (e.g., Dejvongsa et al 1972). There was nothing of this kind in the Lao PDR era until the establishment in 1988 of the Institute of Ethnography (within the Committee for Social Sciences) and a later offspring, the Institute for Cultural Research (under the Ministry of Information and Culture). The Institute for Cultural Research established an academic journal in 1996, the Lanxang Heritage Journal. During the few years of its existence, the journal provided the only regular outlet for academic publication of linguistic research by Lao scholars. Otherwise, articles on linguistic matters appear in popular publications such as various Lao language newspapers and periodicals. These tend to be prescriptive discussions of style, or curiosities of correct and incorrect usage. Like their counterparts in other parts of the world, such studies are fun to read, but their main appeal to scholarship relates less to their intended contribution to what we know about the structure of language, and more to their ethnographic appeal as ideologically motivated attempts to portray or manipulate the standard language in various ways.
2.1.1
Typological and descriptive work on Lao
Two significant grammars of Lao written in French during the 20th century are Hospitalier (1937) and Reinhorn (1980). Hospitalier (1937) is a formidable and penetrating treatment of the Lao language. J-J. Hospitalier had a thorough first-hand knowledge of
Previous linguistic research on Lao
9
Lao, evident, for example, in a brief but insightful section of the grammar on interjections. His discussion of word formation in Lao was similarly incisive. Standards of description in linguistics at the time meant that certain important features of the Lao grammatical system were not described. For example, Hospitalier didn’t have the means to properly characterize the system of lexical tone in Lao, and he didn’t specify tone in his transcription of Lao examples. About half the book concerns the language’s sound system, including its system of writing, and the system for reading tones correctly. Hospitalier went to a great deal of trouble to get permission from the French authorities to use a Lao font in this publication. Generally, Hospitalier used French grammatical categories as a guide for analyzing Lao. For example, he calls nominal classifiers in one of their functions ‘articles’, in another ‘cat´egories les plus usit´ees’. He lists stative verbs as adjectives with sub-types like ‘determinative adjective’. For its time, the Hospitalier grammar was an impressive achievement, and it has hardly been bettered in the 70 years since. Reinhorn’s (1980) grammar shows some evidence of its more modern intellectual context, with greater attention paid to features of phonological structure such as tones and the set of contrasts in vowel space. But there are no references to literature on linguistic typology, nor is there any theoretically oriented discussion of the comparative status of Lao grammatical structures. The orientation is more to literature than to linguistics, with much attention paid to Indic features of the language—i.e., its orthography and some of its vocabulary. Reinhorn devotes a significant amount of space to morphological analysis of Indic loan words, including Indic affixation and rules of sandhi and vowel mutation in Sanskritic compounds. These phenomena are indeed observable in borrowings, but they are not part of the productive morphosyntactic structures of the Lao language. Besides, most of the borrowings to which those observations apply are exclusive to formal contexts such as literature and higher education. They do not occur in everyday use of Lao. Reinhorn, like Hospitalier in 1937, relied exclusively on constructed examples, despite the fact that by the time of publication it had already become standard in linguistic reference grammars to use examples derived from naturally occurring texts. Reinhorn’s treatment of Lao is prescriptive as much if not more than it is descriptive. Further distancing the description from the language as it is actually used by most people, Reinhorn gives a disproportionate amount of attention to Indic features.
10
Language background
Hospitalier’s Lao grammar was written while Laos was a colony of France, with the ostensive purpose of providing a pedagogical resource for French people who would travel to Laos for professional reasons. Its simple and pragmatic style reflects this raison d’ˆetre. The book is organized in the style of traditional European grammar, with no orientation to the value of a description of Lao to the science of linguistics or anthropology. This fits with its historical context, having been completed before the appearance of Bloomfield’s classic and influential descriptivist treatise Language (Bloomfield 1933). Reinhorn’s book, on the other hand, was written at a time when major developments had taken place in linguistic theory, through developments in structuralism (in both linguistics and anthropology), the generativist movement in linguistics, and the comparative science of language typology. Nevertheless, Reinhorn devotes little attention to the possible contribution a grammar of Lao might have made to linguistics and anthropology. The two French language grammars are similar to grammars written in Lao (Sila 1962, Phoumi 1967, RLG 1972) in that their analysis of Lao follows distinctions in grammatical meaning traditionally made in European languages, such as categories of conjugation, mood and inflection of the verb. But a significant difference between Lao and the average European language is that Lao lacks precisely these categories. Most points of grammatical analysis of this kind are not supported with language internal arguments along lines supplied by modern standard reference grammars. Rather, the grammarian is describing Lao in terms of the resources it has for expressing the grammatical distinctions one has in French or some other ‘Standard Average European’ grammar. To his credit, Hospitalier makes it explicit that this is his purpose. Nevertheless, in these traditional grammars there is some attention to features of Lao not shared with European languages—for example, in discussion of the system of nominal classification (cf. Chapter 7, below). However, in describing this system neither Hospitalier nor Reinhorn give an analysis of its semantics or morphosyntactic structure, but simply supply a list of forms. From a modern linguistic point of view, there are a number of features of Lao not normally found in European languages which would nowadays be described on their own terms. One example is the phenomenon of serial verb constructions, a type of complex clause structure that Lao and many other languages—but not European languages like French—feature (cf. Durie 1997, Aikhenvald and Dixon 2006). Such structures are men-
Previous linguistic research on Lao
11
tioned here and there in existing Lao grammars, but (unlike early grammars of African languages) no attention is drawn to their identity as a distinct grammatical category. Another, clearer example concerns the large category of ideophones (or expressives) in Lao (Chapman 1996, Wayland 1996, Trongdee 1996; cf. Voeltz and Kilian-Hatz 2001). A few examples appear in a paragraph of Reinhorn (1980:119), mixed in with examples of other types under the heading ‘onomatopoeics’ as a subsection of ‘predicatives of manner’. Reinhorn does not recognize the distinct grammatical identity of ideophones (cf. Chapman 1996). This may be due to a lack of recognition that a system of this kind—very much colloquial— has a place in a formal grammatical description. Diffloth (2004; cf. 1972, 1976, 1979) argues that one of the reasons that an analysis of these words is hard to pin down is that, like interjections (ouch!, etc.), they tend not to be regarded by speakers (or grammarians) as part of real language. Scholarly works dedicated to linguistic analysis of Lao in the twentieth century are few. In the 1940s, Edward G. Roffe published a concise structuralist account of Lao phonemic structure (Roffe 1946). In the early 1970s, Morev et al (1972) published a grammar of Lao in Russian. From around the same time, a number of scholars associated with Nguyen Dang Liem and others working in the tagmemic tradition at the University of Hawaii made passing references to Lao in broader discussions of grammatical features of Southeast Asian languages (Capell 1979, Nguyen 1974, 1979, Clark 1974). Honts (1979) is the only work among these dedicated solely to Lao. Marybeth Clark’s work began in this period, and has sporadically appeared through subsequent decades (Clark and Prasithrathsint 1985, Clark 1985, 1989, 1996). A highlight of the Hawaii-based research in the 1970s is the work of Arthur Crisfield, whose insightful discussion of Lao sentence-final particles (Crisfield 1974) is the best we have to date on this topic. Crisfield’s (1978) University of Hawaii PhD dissertation dealt with ‘Sound symbolism and the expressive words of Lao’. This topic has since been investigated by Adam Chapman in an Australian National University sub-thesis (Chapman 1996), and by Ratree Wayland, in a study of a variety of Lao spoken in Thailand (Wayland 1996; cf. also Trongdee 1996). The most recent grammatical description of Lao is a German language grammar written by Boike Rehbein and Sisouk Sayaseng (2004). These two had earlier created a language learning course book (Sayaseng and Rehbein 1997), followed by a dictionary (Rehbein and Sayaseng
12
Language background
2000). Their short grammar whose sub-title is ‘phonology, morphology, and pragmatics’ is a useful inventory of basic structures and grammatical forms. The grammar is too brief to include detailed structural analysis or typological comparison, and some features are not mentioned (e.g., ideophones; see Chapter 12 of this book). In its favor, the Rehbein and Sayaseng grammar goes beyond previous grammars in paying attention to social dimensions of language such as speech level, formality, and politeness (Chapters 4 and 5). This is thanks to Rehbein’s perspective as a sociologist and anthropologist (see Rehbein 2007). Much of my own work on Lao has been typological and descriptive, covering a range of topics (see the chapters of this book), including semantic and grammatical studies of specific lexical domains, the relation between semantic encoding and pragmatic implicature (Enfield 2003a, 2003b), processes of grammaticalization, particularly concerning the well-worn path from verb to verb marker (Enfield 2001a, 2003c, 2004a; cf. Matisoff 1991), lexical semantics (Enfield 2001b, 2002a, 2002b, 2006c, 2007a, 2007b), and explorations of theoretical issues in morphosyntactic description and analysis, making primary reference to data from Lao (Enfield 2002c, 2002d, 2006d). Thai linguists are beginning to show genuine interest in doing research on Lao, but have tended to concentrate on varieties of Lao spoken in Northeast Thailand, rather than on Lao spoken in Laos (though this is changing). See, for example, studies by Prakhong (1976), Premchu (1979), and Theraphan (1979), cited by Wayland (1996:218). Are the speech varieties of the Isan region of Northeast Thailand to be regarded as Lao? I have argued (Enfield 2002e) that this question concerns ideology and ethnic identity more than linguistic criteria. Isan speech varieties have some commonalities and some differences with Lao as spoken in Laos, and there are significant differences among different varieties in Isan, as well as within Laos. Whether we consider Isan varieties to be Lao or not depends on the nature and scope of our questions. Thanks to the changing political situation which has made Laos more accessible to outsiders, Thai scholars have more recently been able to conduct research on Lao as spoken in Laos itself. See, for example, Osatananda’s (1997) University of Hawaii dissertation on ‘Tone in Vientiane Lao’.
Previous linguistic research on Lao
13
2.1.2 Lexicography Much of the lexicographic work on Lao is in French, such as Guignard’s early dictionary (1912) and Reinhorn’s (1970) tome. Cuaz (1904) is an early word list. Kerr’s (1972) two-volume Lao-English grammar is an unsurpassed English language source on the Lao lexicon. Important sources for Kerr were French language botanical reference works (Vidal 1960, Deuve 1962, Deuve and Deuve 1963-4), which continue to be important sources for many foreigners working in rural development, biodiversity conservation, and other technical areas. Marcus’s (1970) concise LaoEnglish English-Lao dictionary is well known and widely used, but is little more than a word list. It contains no examples and little grammatical information (see also Boonyavong 1962). Recent Lao language dictionaries, most notably Onmanisone (1992), are directly based on these English and French language sources. It is reportedly part of the mission of the newly established Linguistic Research Institute to produce a definitive Lao language dictionary which improves upon previous efforts. Shortage of resources make it unlikely that this project will bear fruit in the near future. Several lexicographic reference works on Lao have been produced in Thailand, including a Lao-Thai-English Dictionary (LTED 1999) and a Lao-Thai dictionary (Viraphong 2000). There is a plethora of reference material on the language of Isan, the Northeast region of Thailand (cf. for example Phinthong 1988, Mollerup 2001, among many others). The volume of research being conducted on Northeastern varieties of Thai reflects a fascination among Thai scholars and laypeople with ‘the Lao’. Lao language lexicography suffers from a problem characteristic of most lexicography, namely a sacrifice of depth for breadth. Despite the large dictionaries and wordlists, there is little focused, in-depth, or theoretically oriented work on lexical semantics (cf. Wierzbicka 1985, 1996, Cruse 1986). This is not a criticism of the dictionary makers who have devoted a great deal of time to collecting data and presenting it in accessible form. It is an issue for all lexicography, particularly where the purpose of such work is to compare the details of lexical semantics across languages as part of the general enterprise of linguistics, namely to establish the ways in which human languages differ, given that the basic ingredients are universal.
14
Language background
2.1.3
Pedagogical material
Probably the most accessible grammatical descriptions of Lao are pedagogical works such as Roffe and Roffe (1958), Yates and Sayasithsena (1970; produced by the US State Department during the Vietnam war), and Hoshino and Marcus (1981). These substantial works include many illustrative examples, but the analyses presented are oriented neither to linguistic typology nor to theoretical or other general linguistic issues.1 Wright (1994) is a sketch grammar of Lao ostensibly intended for language learners, published by the Thai journal Language and Linguistics (Department of Linguistics, Thammasat University, Bangkok). Lao language examples are in Lao script only, making the book inaccessible as a general reference work (i.e., for linguists rather than learners of Lao). Most recently, John Hartmann, in collaboration with Arthur Crisfield and other colleagues, has developed extensive materials for teaching Lao, making these accessible on a Lao Language and Culture website hosted by the Center for Southeast Asian Studies at Northern Illinois University. A Lao language course book for speakers of German was published in 1997 (Sayaseng and Rehbein 1997), followed by a Lao-German GermanLao dictionary (Rehbein and Sayaseng 2000). Recent years have seen a spate of phrase books on sale in Laos, of varying quality (cf. e.g., Werner 1992, Cummings 1995, Callaghan 1999). An impressive number of foreign residents in Laos learn to speak functional if not excellent Lao. This is helped by the supportive attitude of Lao speakers, and probably also by the fact that English is not widely spoken, making it more difficult to get by in Lao society without being able to speak Lao.
2.1.4
Lao among Tai Languages
Lao is one of many members of the Tai family of languages spoken in Laos, China, Vietnam, Thailand, Burma, Cambodia, and India. Most work on languages of the Tai family in Laos (other than Lao) has concerned the study of the Tai language family more generally, more specifically the comparative and historical study of Tai languages (especially the Southwestern branch). The progenitor of this tradition was William J. 1
Pedagogical works on other languages are more helpful in this respect; cf. Huffman’s linguistically sophisticated (1970) description of Khmer.
Previous linguistic research on Lao
15
Gedney (University of Michigan), whose Selected papers on comparative Tai studies (Gedney 1989) makes numerous references to Lao and other Tai languages spoken in Laos. Gedney carried out extensive field work in Laos beginning in the 1940s. His many students have continued this project (cf. the work of Bickner, Hartmann, Hudak, Wilaiwan, Chamberlain, Compton, Gething, Sarawit, Strecker, and Jit Phumisak). For work on comparative Tai, see edited collections such as Gething (1975), Harris and Chamberlain (1975), Bickner, Hudak, and Patcharin (1986), Edmondson and Solnit (1988), Compton and Hartmann (1992), Edmondson and Solnit (1997), Diller, Edmondson and Luo (2007), and the monographs by Li (1960) and Luo (1997). Little of the work in this tradition was carried out in Laos itself, and many mentions of Lao and other Tai languages of Laos are often made in passing rather than being the focus of attention. However, not all of these workers overlook Lao and other languages of Laos. Carol Compton’s research has concentrated on Lao verse and song structure as well as versification and rhyme in the spoken language (Compton 1979, 2004). James Chamberlain’s work has focused on the comparative ethnobiology of Tai languages (e.g., Chamberlain 1975, 1992, 2000). Much recent work by Chamberlain is based on extensive field work conducted in the course of consultancies relating to the potential impact of major development projects on ethnic groups of the country’s rural areas. This has been one of the only practical ways to gain access to minority language speech communities for the purposes of scientific research. Another important contributor is Anthony V. N. Diller (cf. Diller 1988, 1992, 2004), who has had a long-standing interest in Lao, and has taught it at the Australian National University. More recently, Diller has studied not only historical reconstruction and classification of Tai languages within the Tai family, but historical semantics, or more specifically, comparative grammaticalization (e.g., Diller 2001). Enfield (2003c) is an extended case study in this domain, which while concentrating on Lao, also provides primary data from field investigations of other Tai languages of Laos, including Thai Neua and Lue.
16 2.1.5
Language background
Lao language as part of a broader semiotic system
Many linguists now recognize that production and comprehension of spoken utterances are fundamentally linked to accompanying visual, bodily actions. Research on hand gesture and other aspects of nonverbal behavior has become tied closely to research on the psycholinguistics and semiotics of utterance construction (McNeill 1985, 1992, 2000; Kendon 1972, 1980, 1988; Goldin-Meadow 1999, 2003, and references therein). Hand gestures and other bodily movements are closely integrated with speech in their contribution to building the utterance, the semiotic and psycholinguistic equivalent of the clause (cf. Chafe 1980, 1994). Gestures are now understood to have important cognitive functions for both speakers and addressees. Enfield (2001c) is an investigation of lip-pointing (i.e., pointing by jutting the lips out while looking in the direction of the referent), a common practice among the Lao, integrated with the use of demonstratives and other deictic speech elements. Related to this, Enfield, Kita and de Ruiter (2007c) investigate the use of pointing gestures during spatial descriptions in discourse by speakers of Lao. Two studies (Enfield 2003d, 2005a) have come from an investigation of the structural properties of ‘gesture diagrams’, and specifically their use for describing kinship relations and Lao kin terminology, their iconic properties, and their implications for the study of kinship and diagrammatic cognition. Enfield (2004b) presents a study of gestures made during native speaker descriptions of types of Lao fish traps, in which it is demonstrated that sequences of hand gestures show discourse-syntactic organization.
2.1.6
Language endangerment
An important issue in the contemporary linguistics of Laos is language endangerment (Enfield 2006a). Languages around the world are disappearing at a rate of some two per month (Crystal 2000, Nettle and Romaine 2000). One area of research relevant to the problem of language endangerment in Laos is exploration of the conditions and circumstances of language attrition and loss. There is a desperate need for primary field research, given that we know very little about even the number and identity of languages, let alone their structure. In Enfield (2006a), I discuss
Lao as a national language
17
theoretical issues concerning language endangerment and research on it in Laos (see also Bradley 2003). There are many dozens of languages spoken in Laos, most of which are spoken by fewer than 5000 people. Some are moribund, with only a few dozen speakers remaining. In this context, to claim that the national language Lao is ‘under pressure’ (Thongphet 2004) is a completely different notion to endangerment. It is simply a way of dramatically expressing the idea that the language, like all languages, is changing. It does not mean that—as in the case of many other languages of Laos—the entire language and the community that speaks it is set to disappear from the face of the earth.
2.2
Lao as a national language
Lao was declared the national language of the Lao PDR, on the establishment of the first government on December 2, 1975. Unlike other national languages, however, the standard is not well codified. As a nation, Laos has experienced long years of difficulty along the road to unification. Many of the political divisions that can be traced across the history of the nation can be seen reflected in current inconsistencies of the language as it is used, and in the arguments which are conducted today, and have been conducted for decades, about the proper shape of the Lao language. The pressures on Lao as a language are also found amongst those on Laos as a nation. There is a tension between the older, ornate traditions associated with Buddhism and aristocracy on the one hand, and the more recent, austere rationalist traditions associated with socialism and science on the other. Also, the Lao are keenly aware of the need to maintain and delineate their nationhood in the face of pressures from outside, most notably those from Thailand.
2.2.1
Variation and efforts at standardization
As a Southwestern Tai language, Lao is closely related to Thai (Li 1960). Lao and Thai share extensive vocabulary, and have very similar phonological and grammatical systems. Because of the mostly one-directional flow of cultural exposure, however, Central Thai is well understood by the Lao, while many speakers of Central Thai would have real difficulty
18
Language background
understanding Lao, due to lack of exposure to the language. It is important to understand for much of the discussion below that Lao and Thai are for all intents and purposes (i.e., in structural linguistic terms) dialects of a single language. This is not meant to downplay in any way the differences between them. For a number of reasons, they should be treated as different languages, that is, as languages each on their own merits. For one thing, this favors the political objective of neither Thai nor Lao nationalism. It is more often the case that Lao is treated by outsiders in terms of how it differs from Thai, and not the other way around, since outsiders are more often familiar with Thai first. While there are many fascinating differences and similarities between Lao and Thai, the substantive issues related to the career of Lao as a national language almost exclusively concern orthography. The two languages use scripts which are quite similar, and which both derive ultimately from Indic scripts. There is a robust folk (mis)understanding that the languages ‘come from’ Pali and Sanskrit, including the idea that Lao and Thai incorporate higher proportions of Pali, and Sanskrit, respectively.2 The Thai and Lao languages do not come from Pali and Sanskrit, in any sense of genealogical continuity. They have heavily borrowed vocabulary from those languages, especially during the 20th Century. Pali and Sanskrit have provided for a range of neologisms required in a rapidly changing political and social world, in a similar way that Greek and Latin have been used creatively in stocking the modern vocabularies of European languages. Pali in particular is important in religion and religious studies in Laos and Thailand. Pali texts are written in Lao monasteries using the ‘dharmic script’, not known by many Lao. Modern Thai orthography exactly replicates the range of Pali and Sanskrit characters, while Lao does not. What many do not realize is that this full complement of Indic characters in Thai orthography is recent, having been introduced only this century. Lao orthography contains 27 consonants, while some 43 (as found in Thai) are required to transcribe Pali. Thus, Pali and San2 Sanskrit and Pali are separate Indo-Aryan languages, both no longer natively spoken. Sanskrit has its own script (the Devanagari script used in modern Hindi), and is associated mostly with Hindu writings. While Sanskrit remained conservative due to emphasis on retaining the integrity of its original written form, Pali developed out of a spoken descendent of Sanskrit, which was used in the dissemination and subsequent spread of Buddhism. Pali does not have its own script (many different scripts are used for writing Pali), but does require essentially the same range of characters as the Devanagari script, with some minor differences.
Lao as a national language
19
skrit texts can be transcribed literally to the letter in regular everyday Thai script. Here is a sample of printed Lao script (see Hoshino and Marcus 1981 for a description of the system):
Figure 2.1. Sample of printed Lao script
The numerous regional dialects of Lao show considerable variation. Not only do people from different regions speak with markedly different accents, they also display significant differences in regular vocabulary, as well as subtle grammatical and idiomatic differences. These differences may identify a person’s background, and thereby indicate much about their likely history and, probably, their position in society. Each regional variety of Lao has one or two salient diagnostic indicators (among many actual distinctions), which are emblematic of that variety, and generally known. For example, the Southernmost varieties of Lao have a characteristic high-falling pronunciation of the tone inherent in ‘live’ syllables with ‘low’ consonant initials (such as laaw2 ‘Lao’, maa2 ‘come’, khuu2 ‘teacher’). This pronunciation is immediately diagnostic of a speaker’s Southern origin, and is said to be a loud, heavy, or rough style. On the other hand, the variety of Lao spoken in Luang Prabang includes a distinctive high falling-rising tone in ‘live’ syllables with ‘high’ consonant initials (such as hiin3 ‘stone’, maa3 ‘dog’, muu3 ‘pig’). This pronunciation is considered typical of the ‘softness’ or ‘lightness’ of that variety. There are also some lexical stereotypes which are diagnostic of regional varieties, such as Phou-Thai kiloe ‘where’ (cf. Vientiane saj3), or Lu-
20
Language background
ang Prabang eew ‘play, pass time’ (cf. Vientiane lin5). These examples show features which have achieved privileged status as folk diagnostics of speakers’ regional origin. Each variety of course has many other distinctive features, but these have not achieved the same diagnostic status, and are not consciously recognized, nor publicly emblematic in the same way as those other more stigmatized features. It is of course natural to find extensive dialect variation in any region (Chambers 1995:229ff), and out of this arises the political, cultural, and practical imperative for establishing and properly codifying an official standard language. The standard is a vehicle for leveling regional variation in administration, education, and the media, as well as providing a benchmark of prestige and correctness, regardless of the variety spoken in an individual’s own region or home. Establishment of a standard requires an effective level of codification (i.e., official specifications in grammar books, particularly concerning pronunciation and spelling). If it is possible to identify a spoken standard for Lao, it would have to be the Vientiane variety. Vientiane is at the geographical and political centre of the country. While Vientiane Lao could be defined as either the variety of Lao spoken in Vientiane, or the variety of Lao spoken by those who have grown up in Vientiane (or whose families have been in Vientiane for some number of generations), the former definition would allow no generalization about the form of the language itself, since a huge proportion of the population of the capital are speakers of regional varieties, born and raised in the provinces. An important measure of standard pronunciation is the language used in national television and radio programming, which tends to follow the phonology of native Vientiane speakers, and tends not to include regional vocabulary. But pinpointing the distinctive features of this standard is complicated by the fact that the target is shifting. The pronunciation of Vientiane Lao is nowhere codified, and its form has been affected over the decades through major demographic changes, including influx of regional speakers, as wartime refugees during the 1960s and early 1970s, as incoming revolutionaries taking power immediately after 1975, and as economic migrants since the 1990s, permitted by increasing urban development and eased travel restrictions. The outpouring of post-1975 refugees must also have had some effect. So, while there is no official standardization of the spoken form of Lao, and while it is perhaps even impossible to say exactly what constitutes the Vientiane variety of Lao, there is no doubt an implicit concept of
Lao as a national language
21
a neutral, central style. There is at the very least a notion of toning down one’s native, regional speech when in the capital, or indeed when dealing with speakers from outside one’s own area, particularly when in some official setting. People are willing and able to curtail the most representative features of their own non-neutral regional variety. There is thus a natural tendency to neutralize differences, at least for the pragmatic purpose of facilitating communication. If a standard or central spoken Lao can be characterized, it is central partly in the geographical sense (i.e., spoken by natives of the geographical and political centre) and partly in Diller’s (1991:110) third sense of ‘central’ language: ‘the intermediate or shared variety, similar to a lingua franca or koine’, that is, a variety in which the most salient regional stereotype features are bleached away. Spoken Lao rates poorly in terms of Diller’s (1991:99-100) checklist of national language functions. If we take the Vientiane variety as a spoken standard, then it probably passes the criteria of (a) being understood by a majority of national residents; (b) being used in electronic media for the majority of official or national level programming; and (c) being the norm for impersonal announcements (at the very least in terms of vocabulary selection, and to some extent in terms of toning down regional pronunciation). But as a standard for pronunciation, Vientiane Lao probably fails to pass other of Diller’s national language criteria, namely (d) being the national medium of instruction; (e) being the sole language of official government business; (f) being the prestige dialect for social mobility; (g) being used for religious purposes; and (h) being enforced institutionally. There is little pressure on regional speakers to pronounce Lao as it is pronounced by natives of Vientiane. Where Lao does have a much stronger sense of standardization is in its written form, a focus of greater concern in the history of Lao as a national language. Today’s written conventions of Lao do pass the standard criteria of being used as the national medium of instruction, the language of official business, and the object of institutional maintenance.3 But the nature of the written language is such that it may be pronounced in a range of regional accents. Most of the discussion in the rest of this chapter concentrates on the history and development of the written language, since 3
This does not mean that the standards of the language are faithfully adhered to. There remains a margin for slippage in the writing of Lao, as persistent variation in spelling of many words will attest.
22
Language background
this has been the native preoccupation.4 The area of strongest standardization of Lao is print media. Publication of printed material is subject to official approval by the Lao government, which since 1975 has done well in seeing that a standard writing system (following Phoumi’s grammar; see below) is adhered to. However, while it is often observed that print media can be one of the strongest forces of language standardization (cf. Ivarsson 1999), this is compromised by limited readership of Lao language newspapers. Major Vientiane dailies Vientiane Mai (‘New Vientiane’) and Pasason (‘The People’) are distributed to government offices, shops, hotels, other workplaces and some private homes, but few newsagents have existed until recently. So, a well standardized orthography in the Lao press does not have the significant consequences for a general standardization of the language that one might expect. Radio programming across the country tends to have strong regional orientation, with a large percentage of local programming done in local dialects. Rural areas are, however, exposed to a certain degree of ‘central Lao’ via national news reports produced in Vientiane. As already mentioned, spoken Lao has been much less effectively standardized, and this is reflected in, and partly contributed to by, the less unified spoken conventions in regional radio programming. Since the first half of the 20th Century, a number of government bodies have been set up to take responsibility for language standardization, including production of Lao language educational materials, research on Lao grammar, language, and literature, authorization of neologisms, borrowings and revisions in the language, and production of an official dictionary. In the 1930’s, the Buddhist Academic Council, presided over by Prince Phetsarath, was responsible for recommendations regarding Lao orthography, including the attempted addition (attributed to Sila Vilavong) to the Lao alphabet of 14 supplementary consonants, making up the full complement of orthographic distinctions required for transcribing Pali (Bizot 1996). The early 1940s saw developments in language standardization associated with the Lao Nhay movement, in which the ‘simple etymological spelling’ associated with P. S. Nginn took hold (see Ivarsson (1999) for detailed discussion). Again the Buddhist Academic 4 For example, in ICR (1995), an important volume on language policy in Laos, almost no-one among over 25 contributors identifies regional pronunciation as an issue. Bounyok (1995:98) is one exception.
Lao as a national language
23
´ Council was involved in this process, along with the Ecole Franc¸aise d’Extr´eme-Orient. In August 1948, the Committee for Compiling and Authorizing the Spelling of Lao Words was set up (by Royal Decree No. 67), and this was soon followed by the establishment of the long-standing Literary Committee, under the Ministry of Education (by Prime Minister’s Decree No. 407, August 27 1951). The Committee was to contain 24 members, and the first five appointed were Kou Aphay, P. S. Nginn, Phuy Panya, Sila Vilavong, and Bong Souvannavong. Sila left the Committee at the end of 1963. In 1970, The Committee became the Lao Royal Academic Council (by Royal Ordinance No. 72, February 23, 1970). It was to last five years until the demise of the Royal Lao Government in 1975. The reforms introduced by the post-1975 government were implemented effectively without the need for a distinct official regulatory body. The policy was clearly laid out by Phoumi (1967), and there was little debate. The reforms adopted had already been well established for at least twenty years in the revolutionary Liberated Zone. On 8-10 October 1990, a major conference ‘The Round Table on Lao Language Policy’ was held in Vientiane, organized by the Institute for Cultural Research under the Ministry of Information and Culture. A number of the papers presented were collected and published as a volume (ICR 1995; see below for further discussion). A common demand was the need for an institute or academy to oversee and authorize decisions about the language, particularly concerning the incorporation of neologisms, and decisions about orthographic convention. Accordingly the conclusion of the meeting saw an official recommendation that an academy or unit be set up to work at least on problems of standardizing orthography (Houmphanh 1995:5). This was set up formally in 2002. Lao linguistic scholarship has been closely involved with institutions concerned with regulation and standardization of the language. The three figures of greatest importance are P. S. Nginn, Sila Vilavong, and Phoumi Vongvichit, noted by Khamphao (1995:15) as synonymous with the three most important views of the last 70 years regarding how Lao language should be written. Sila Vilavong, the most prominent figure of traditional (i.e., pre-revolutionary) Lao scholarship, produced a range of works on aspects of Lao culture, and today there is a romanticized notion of his scholarship (cf. Outhin et al 1990). Sila instigated an early, unsuccessful attempt to in-
24
Language background
corporate the full complement of Indic characters (following Pali) into Lao orthography, so that Indic etymology could be reproduced letter for letter in the everyday spelling system (cf. Bizot 1996, Ivarsson 1999, Sila 1996[1938]). This attempt is found in Sila’s grammar, published in 1935 by the then recently established Chantabouri Buddhist Academic Council. One of Sila’s primary concerns was to promote religious studies, and the move to make Pali accessible to anyone who knew Lao was seen as a crucial step in doing this (Sila 1935:x, cited in Thongphet 1995:103). This project ran into problems due especially to the Lao nationalist desire for the language to be clearly distinct from Thai, which had already incorporated the full complement of Indic characters. Sila’s approach was taken by many to be dangerously close to aping developments in Thai orthography at the time (see Diller 1991, Ivarsson 1999). Much later, Sila’s proposals for the Lao orthography were also seen as less practical and more elitist, in opposition to fundamental principles of Phoumi’s revolutionary grammar (see below). Pierre Somchin Nginn was head of the long-standing Literary Committee, and presided over the publication of the Royal Lao Government official Grammar of Lao, published in 1972 (RLG 1972). Nginn’s view of Lao grammar and orthography was more progressive than Sila’s, whereby he partly followed a principle of simplicity and ‘phonetic’ spelling, while allowing for Indic etymology to be reflected in the spelling of borrowings, at least to the extent that existing Lao characters could facilitate this. More recently, Phoumi Vongvichit has had the most direct hand in determining the current state of Lao orthographic convention, as well as being a leading political figure throughout the history of the revolutionary struggle. The ‘cultural tsar’ of the Lao revolution (Stuart-Fox 1997:5), Phoumi was a ‘revolutionary activist member ... of the traditional Lao elite’, who became Interior Minister of the Pathet Lao resistance government when it was formed in 1950, later becoming Minister of Education, Culture, and Information and a member of the inner cabinet and the Political Bureau of the government of the Lao PDR upon its formation in 1975 (Stuart-Fox 1997:78-9, 170, 186). Phoumi published his Lao Grammar in the heartland of the revolutionary struggle in 1967. The book was widely distributed after the revolution in 1975, and is perhaps more significant in Laos as a historical and culturally symbolic document than as an academic contribution either to linguistic description or to language standardization. (See below for further discussion of Phoumi’s gram-
Lao as a national language
25
mar.) Since his death in 1994, Phoumi has received mixed respect within the academic community. Compare, for example, the strong support from younger scholars seen in Thongphet (1995) and Khamhoung (1995), as opposed to Thongkham and Souvan’s (1997:ii) tepid if not overtly negative mention of his role in the context of Sila’s much earlier traditionalist work. ‘Grammar’ in the Lao academy is a normative idea. Rules of grammar prescribe what is correct and proscribe what is incorrect. Further, the intellectual focus is almost exclusively on orthographic convention, i.e., correct spelling. Much about the overall grammar of the language (see further chapters of this book) is little described and little explored by Lao scholars. Work on morphology and syntax is explicitly (and sometimes inappropriately) modeled on traditional European grammar (see section 2.1, above; cf. Diller 1988, 1993 on a similar situation in Thai). With the establishment of the Lao PDR in 1975, the politically motivated reforms embodied in Phoumi’s Lao Grammar (see section 2.2.2 below) were officially adopted. The positions of Phoumi on the one hand, and Nginn, along with Sila, on the other, have polarized, symbolizing the forces of old versus new, pre-revolutionary versus revolutionary, traditional versus progressive, religious versus scientific. When Phoumi’s grammar became the national standard, his reforms were accepted and adopted. But since the perestroika of the late 1980’s, many aspects of culture and society associated with socialist ideology have decreased in popularity (especially in Vientiane), and have been toned down, tolerated rather than actively supported. Since the early nineties (e.g., Houmphanh 1996[1990]), and particularly since Phoumi’s death in 1994 (cf. Sisaveuy 1996), the feeling in Vientiane has been that Phoumi’s reforms are out of date, having already served their purpose in contributing to a certain phase of the revolution (Houmphanh 1996[1990]:167). In a rather different tone, Thongkham and Souvan (1997:ii) imply that Phoumi’s grammar crowned a long history of steady deterioration of the ideal embodied in Sila’s four-volume grammar of more than three decades earlier (Sila 1935). While commentators are almost unanimous that the reforms are inappropriate for contemporary Lao, there remains the problem of determining what the new alternatives are. It is useful in this connection to look at the debate which occured in the decade or so before liberation. Lao was first officially adopted as the language of education in (Royal Lao Government controlled) Laos in 1962, under the National Educa-
26
Language background
tional Reform Act (RLG 1962, cited in Chamberlain 1978:267). While the diversity of pronunciation in various dialects of Lao was apparently considered tolerable (‘most Lao scholars agree ... that promoting a standard pronunciation is neither feasible nor necessarily desirable’, Chamberlain 1978:267), the issue that generated lively debate was the standardization of the system of writing (Chamberlain 1978, Houmphanh 1996[1990]). The situation is summed up by Allan Kerr in the preface to his 1972 Lao-English Dictionary: ‘A major difficulty which confronted the compiler was the fact that the spelling of Lao words has not been standardized; this is particularly true in the case of words of Pali and Sanskrit origin. The chief guide for correct spelling is a special directive sent by the King of Laos to the Comit´e Litt´eraire, which states as a general principle that all words are to be spelled exactly as they are pronounced. However, this has thus far been an ideal rather than an accomplished fact .... In determining which of a series of [variant spellings] should be treated as a main entry the compiler has had the temerity to make decisions in doubtful cases .... His decisions represent a compromise between the attitude of the traditionalists who oppose change of any kind and that of the modernists who are eager to change everything.’ (Kerr 1972:ix.) The debate was highly politicized. The original directive (Royal Ordinance Number 10, January 27, 1949, for which consult Khamphao 1995, RLG 1972), was interpreted in different ways (or to different degrees of strictness) by different political factions of the then coalition government. Article 2, the relevant section of this brief document, reads: The orthography of Lao words, and of words borrowed into Lao from foreign languages, follows pronunciation used in Laos. The traditionalists wanted aspects of original Pali or Sanskrit spelling retained in loanwords from those languages, creating apparently arbitrary complexity for those unfamiliar with Indic etymology. These spellings would have to be learnt by memory, rather than directly reflecting pronunciation in predictable fashion. Houmphanh (1996[1990]: 163, cf. also ICR 1995) mentions the added issue of foreign borrowings and neologisms, with regard to which there were many different opinions, and no unified resolutions. Chamberlain (1978:269) reports that at the time the Lao Patriotic Front ‘followed a stricter interpretation of the Royal Ordinance’. Thus,
Lao as a national language
27
not only would they dispose of spellings which used final consonants alien to Lao phonology, they would also overtly write in the epenthetic vowels which are automatically inserted between consonants in erstwhile clusters. While various interpretations were subject to public debate in the Royal Lao Government occupied areas of lowland Laos, there was no such discussion in the revolutionary Liberated Zone, where this stricter interpretation (which would eventually prevail), had been accepted and applied by revolutionary forces since at least the early 1950s.5 A symbolic struggle between grammars directly reflected the political struggle between communist forces in the Liberated Zone, and royalist forces in the lowlands. Competing interpretations carried potent symbolism, throughout the embattled period up to 1975, and well beyond.6
2.2.2
Revolutionary reforms
Phoumi’s Lao Grammar was published by the Lao Patriotic Front at Sam Neua in 1967. The book was widely distributed after the establishment of the Lao PDR in 1975, and had far-reaching effect. It set in place as a national standard the revolutionary forces’ strict interpretation of the 1949 Royal Ordinance, which had already been the norm in the Liberated Zone for at least 20 years. Phoumi takes a strongly political stance in his Introduction, stressing the nation-unifying function of a ‘scientific’ grammar, an urgent requirement at that time of struggle to unite the nation under socialism. He commits to words the principles of language reform in Laos which were established and carried through until his death: Every country in the world has its own principles of speech and writing, its own linguistic principles which may demonstrate the style and honor of the nation, and demonstrate the cultural independence of the nation, along with independence in political, economic and other arenas. Laos has gone back and forth as a colonized state 5
Those who were producing Lao language documents in the Liberated Zone constituted a small community in comparison to those in Royal Lao Government areas at the time. 6 Many overseas communities of Lao, who fled Laos under the revolutionary government, continue to publish their community materials using orthographic conventions based on the more traditional interpretation of the 1949 Royal Ordinance.
28
Language background of various foreign nations for many centuries. Whichever country has colonized us, that country has brought its language to be used here and mixed with Lao, causing Lao to lose its original former content, bit by bit. Most importantly, this has been the case during the time that Laos has been an ‘old-style’ colony of the French colonialists, and a ‘new-style’ colony of the American imperialists. They have tried to incite and force Lao people to popularize speaking and studying their languages, and so then to abandon and forget our own Lao language, little by little. Furthermore, activities along the borders adjoining various neighboring countries have led a certain number of Lao people, who do not remember their Lao well, to introduce those foreign languages and mix them with Lao, causing their already degraded Lao to further depart from original principles, on a daily basis. The result of this situation is that Lao people speak and write Lao without unity, where those who live close to the border with whichever country it may be, or who have studied the language of that country, write and speak according to the style and the accent of that country. Since Lao does not yet have unified principles of writing and speech, we Lao neither like to, nor dare to write books or translate books into Lao, which means that the cultural struggle of our Lao nation is not as strong as other areas of the struggle. This has considerable negative consequences for our struggle to seize control of the nation and fight American imperialism. The preservation and renovation of the nation’s orthography, idiom, literature and cultural principles demonstrates the patriotic spirit, the fine tradition and heritage of bravery which was passed down to us from our forebearers ... The leading idea in my research and writing of this book ‘Lao Grammar’ is for the grammar of Lao to belong to the nation, and to the people, and for it to be progressive, modern, and scientific ... Every principle and every term used herein is intended to be simple, so that the general populace, of high or low education, may easily understand ... My greatest concern in writing this book is to have people understand and utilize the principles and the various terms in the easiest possible way. (Phoumi 1967:5-8)
Thus, two crucial principles guided Phoumi’s reforms: first, to preserve the language as uniquely Lao and free of unwelcome foreign (especially Thai) influence, and second, to facilitate the greatest access to literacy for the population as a whole, not just the well educated and priv-
Lao as a national language
29
ileged. Adult education was an important focus of educational policy in the new government, and much of this was aimed at non-Lao speaking minorities (Stuart-Fox 1986:147-8). It is interesting to consider why it is that while in the passage quoted above, Phoumi names the French and the Americans, but doesn’t name the Thai, even though he is so obviously referring to them. The passage about ‘neighboring countries’ could only be referring to Thailand, particularly obvious given the distribution of political control during the time the book was written. Thai influence was also already a topic of scholarly debate in Royal Lao Government areas of lowland Laos when Phoumi’s grammar was published. Evidently, Thai was then noticeably influencing not only Lao orthography, but also Lao pronunciation, in daily life, as well as in the mass media. Phoumi’s changes to the orthography fully reflected the Lao Patriotic Front’s stricter interpretation of the royal directive to spell words according to their pronunciation. This especially concerned the spelling of Indic loanwords whose original pronunciation (and thus, their spelling) included a far greater range of syllable-final consonants than were found in the phonology of spoken Lao. The most famous and most potent symbol of Phoumi’s reforms was the removal from the Lao alphabet of the letter ‘r’, representing the alveolar trill [r] (for impassioned discussions, see Bounleuth 1995:37-39, Sisaveuy 1996:98-99). This reform had already been long in place in revolutionary writing in the Liberated Zone. For example, in a Neo Lao Issara information sheet, dated 1955, the Lao letter ‘r’ does not appear. While Central (normative standard) Thai has a spoken contrast between /l/ and /r/, there is no such contrast in spoken Lao, and /r/ is not part of the sound system.7 As Thongphet puts it, ‘no linguist, phonetician or phonologist would ever say that Lao had the sound [r]’ (Thongphet 1995:104). Reinhorn (1970:x) says that ‘r’ exists for Lao language ‘purely in theory’. If a word beginning with /r/ in Central Thai is also found in Lao, the Thai /r/ will correspond in spoken Lao to either /l/ or /h/ (see Enfield 1999 for details). 7
As Grant Evans (personal communication) has pointed out, there are cases where ‘r’ is pronounced by Lao people. These are marked usages, licensed either by the particular cultural context (e.g., religious formality), or the particular words being pronounced (e.g., foreign names).
30
Language background
Given Phoumi’s premisses, his reasoning for removing ‘r’ was rational. Why should the language retain an orthographic distinction (‘l’ vs. ‘r’) which reflects no spoken distinction, and thus must be remembered either arbitrarily (thus harder to learn), or with explicit reference to a distinction made in a foreign language (i.e., Thai, where orthography reflects etymology)? The removal of ‘r’ nicely served both of Phoumi’s aims in linguistic reform: to exclude ‘non-Lao’ elements, and to make the system simpler and thus easier to learn for those with lower levels of education (i.e., by not having to remember by rote, or by knowledge of Thai, which Lao words pronounced with /l/ are spelt with ‘r’ and which are spelt with ‘l’).8 There is an increasing popular preference in recent years to tend towards the preservation of etymology in loanwords where possible. Moving away from the issue of spelling, there are other aspects of the language which have been similarly subject to politically-motivated reforms, although it seems these were not overtly published and distributed in the same way. Many changes were brought in either explicitly, or by example, during a nationwide massive increase in education immediately after 1975 (Stuart-Fox 1986:145), of which a major proportion was ideological and political in nature (cf. also Stuart-Fox 1997, Chapter 6). See Enfield (1999:274ff) for more detailed discussion of a range of cases, including politeness particles, honorific pronouns, political slogans, and the abolition of Indicisms in official terminology.
2.2.3
Contemporary debate
Within the debate among today’s community of Lao concerned with the state of the language, we can discern a number of divisions, related in general to the partition of new versus old. But since there are three main movements in the standardization of Lao, as discussed above, the line may be drawn in different places. The extremes are the (post-) Phoumiist position (e.g., Thongphet 1995) on the one hand, and the Sila-ist position (e.g., Thongkham and Souvan 1997), on the other. The Nginn-ist 8
Diller (1991) reports similar issues in Thailand, where the orthographic ‘r’ vs. ‘l’ distinction is not colloquially pronounced by most Thai. He writes, ‘Occasionally higher government units take direct linguistic action. On 12 January 1988 the Prime Minister’s office issued a proclamation warning the bureaucracy to pronounce r- and l- distinctly...’ (Diller 1991:112).
Lao as a national language
31
approach is progressive and rationalist from the Sila-ist point of view, but conservative and traditional from the Phoumi-ist point of view. From the perspective of modern socialist principles, and a concern for the integrity of the present government’s cultural policies, only the Phoumi-ist position is politically correct. But for those with a more general nationalist concern that Lao be kept safely distinct from Thai, only Sila’s approach looks problematic. For those who are concerned that Buddhism be better served in education and in general public life, neither the Nginn nor Phoumi approaches offer the promise of what Sila had planned. The career of Lao as a national language continues to produce a complex weaving (see Enfield 1999:277ff for further elaboration), whose pattern emerges from oppositions of rationalist versus traditional, progressive versus conservative, concerned with emblems versus concerned with matters of principle. We move now from language ideology to language structure, beginning with the phonological system.
Chapter 3 Phonology Phonological structure of Lao words may be specified in terms of a set of initial consonants, a set of final consonants, a set of vowels, a set of lexical tones, and a phonotactic template. Words are generally monosyllabic, but not exclusively. As a tone language, Lao is fairly typical of the mainland Southeast Asian type. Five distinct pitch contours serve to distinguish between lexical items. For example, the segmental string saw means different things depending on the pitch contour with which it is pronounced: saw1 ‘to hire or rent’, saw2 ‘to cease’, saw3 ‘a post’, saw4 ‘morning’, saw5 ‘sad’.1
3.1
Phonotactics
The underlying segmental template for the word is as follows: C0 V0
C1 V1 V2 C2
Figure 3.1. Segmental slots in the Lao word
In all words, slots C1 and V1 must be realized, but C1 V1 alone is not a possible word: in addition to C1 V1 , either V2 , C2 , or both must also be realized. I shall refer to C1 as the major-initial consonant, and C2 as the final consonant. The slots labeled C0 and V0 constitute the minor syllable, in those words which have one. (If either C0 or V0 is realized, they must both be realized.) Minor syllables are unstressed, and do not show distinctive tone independent of the stressed, major syllable to which they attach. De-stressed affixes or clitics behave like minor syllables in this respect (e.g., class terms and modifier classifiers discussed in Chapter 7; some of the aspectual-modal markers discussed in Chapter 9). The slot C 0 allows only a restricted subset of initial consonants (e.g., b- is rare, 1
There is considerable phonological variation in the many regional dialects of Lao, including significant variation in the system of lexical tones. The present description is based on the speech of people who are at least second generation residents of the city of Vientiane.
34
Phonology
palatal and velar nasals do not occur), and the same is true for vowels in V0 (only /a, i, u/ are allowed, with no length contrast). A long vowel in the major syllable is analyzed as a single vowel occurring twice in succession, i.e., in adjacent slots. If V1 and V2 are not identical, then V1 may be one of /i/, /u/, or /`u/, and V2 must be /a/. While many words have one major syllable, a significant number of words have multiple syllables. Most of these are either borrowings (e.g., Indic-based neologisms like thoo2lathat1 ‘television’ or lat1thatham2manuun2 ‘constitution’), or reduplicative/alliterative structures such as found in ideophones (e.g., thii1-lii1 ‘running madly’, k`ong1-d`ong1 ‘swinging heavily’).
3.2
Major-initial consonants
Table 2 shows the set of consonants which may occur in the major-initial consonant slot: Table 2. Major-initial consonants (occurring in C1 slot) Labial Alveolar Palatal Stops Voiceless ptcunaspirated Voiceless ph th aspirated Voiced bdFricatives fsNasals mnñLateral lGlides vj-
Velar k-
Glottal P-
kh -
hN-
A few points may be noted. First, t- is not only distinct in voicing from the other alveolar stops, but is also typically produced with tongue contact further forward (apico-dental). Second, the three-way distinction in voice onset time for stops is not found post-coronally, with gaps in the palatal and velar series. Third, initial v- is always labio-dental, and varies in whether its manner of articulation is fricative or approximant (the latter is more common). In contrast with its counterpart in final position, initial v- is never pronounced as a bilabial approximant w-.
Final consonants
3.3
35
Final consonants
The set of consonants which may appear in syllable-final C2 slot is less than half the size of the set of major-initials. There are no contrasts in voice onset time of stops in C2 position. There are no palatals, no fricatives, and no lateral. There is no short-long vowel distinction before final -P. Final -w represents the same phoneme as initial v-. The difference in transcription reflects a significant audible difference in pronunciation. Table 3. Final consonants (occurring in C2 slot) Labial Coronal Stops Voiceless checked -p -t Nasals -m -n Glides -w -j
3.4
Velar -k -N
Glottal -P
Vowels
The set of vowels is large in typological terms, with nine distinct points in the vowel space, and with a short-long vowel distinction: Table 4. Vowels unrounded rounded front central back high i i: W W: u u: mid e e: @ @: o o: low E E: a a: O O: diphthongs ia, ua, Wa (and in Northern varieties aW)
3.5
Tones
There are five distinct lexical tones in the variety of Lao spoken by natives of Vientiane (cf. Osatananda 1997). I refer to these using the numerals 1-5. Tone 1 has a level contour, around the middle of the pitch range
36
Phonology
(e.g., khaa1 ‘galangal’, khat1 ‘select’). Tone 2 has a high-rising contour, beginning around the mid range and going to high (e.g., khaa2 ‘to be stuck’, khat2 ‘contrary’). Tone 3 has a low-rising contour, beginning around the bottom of the pitch range and rising sharply (e.g., khaa3 ‘leg’, kaa3 ‘crow’). Sometimes Tone 3 is pronounced as a low, level tone, without a rising offset. Tone 4 has a high-falling contour, beginning at the top of the pitch range and falling sharply (e.g., khaa4 ‘commerce’, khaat4 ‘hope’). Tone 5 has a mid-falling contour, beginning at the middle of the pitch range and falling to low (e.g., khaa5 ‘slave’, khaat5 ‘torn’). There are constraints on the occurrence of certain tones with certain syllable types, depending on (a) whether the major-initial consonant is a non-aspirated stop (b-, d-, p-, t-, c-, k-, P-) or j- (versus any other consonant initial), (b) whether there is a final stop consonant, and (c) if so, whether the vowel is short or long. The constraints are as follows: 1. If C1 is a non-aspirated stop or j- and C2 is not a stop, Tones 2 and 5 do not occur (cf. paa1 ‘forest’ versus paa3 ‘fish’ versus paa4 ‘elder aunt (Pa.eZ)’). 2. If C2 is a stop and the vowel is short, tones 3, 4, and 5 do not occur (cf. khop1 ‘meet’ versus khop2 ‘bite’); in addition, if C1 is a non-aspirated stop or j-, Tone 1 does not occur (cf. kop2 ‘frog sp.’). 3. If C2 is a stop and the vowel is long, tones 1, 2, and 3 do not occur (cf. saap4 ‘to know’ versus saap5 ‘dank’); in addition, if C1 is a non-aspirated stop or j-, Tone 4 does not occur (cf. daap5 ‘sword’). These constraints can be interpreted with reference to traditional, historicalcomparative description of the tone system of Lao. Traditional analysis (Gedney 1989) makes reference to three parameters which determine the tone category of a word. First, the initial consonant of a syllable will belong to one of three classes (as determined by the manner of articulation of the syllable in Proto Southwestern Tai): low (reconstructed as ‘voiceless, plus friction’), middle (reconstructed as ‘voiceless, minus friction’), or low (reconstructed as voiced). Second, a syllable will be either ‘live’ (i.e., with vocalic or sonorant final) or ‘dead’ (i.e., with stop final). Third, if ‘live’, it makes a difference whether the syllable is historically unmarked for tone (A), or historically marked as Tone 1 (B) or Tone 2 (C).
Transcription
37
Fourth, if ‘dead’ (D), it makes a difference whether a syllable has a long or a short vowel. This set of possibilities allows a historical-comparative map of the Lao tone system, as follows (for further information, see Gedney 1989): Table 5. Modern Lao examples of reflexes of traditional Tai tones A B C Dshort VOICELESS , khaa3 khaa1 khaa5 khat2 + FRICTION ‘leg’ ‘galangal’ ‘slave’ ‘contrary’ VOICELESS , kaa3 kaa1 kaa4 kat2 - FRICTION ‘crow’ ‘fish sp.’ ‘dare’ ‘bite’ VOICED khaa2 khaa1 khaa4 khat1 ‘stuck’ ‘cost’ ‘commerce’ ‘select’
3.6
Dlong khaat5 ‘torn’ kaat5 ‘cabbage’ khaat4 ‘hope’
Transcription
Tables 6, 7, and 8 lay out the transcription system used in this book. Table 6. Transcription system: Consonants Labial Alveolar Stops Voiceless p t unaspirated Voiceless ph th aspirated Voiced b d Fricatives Voiceless f s Nasals Voiced m n Liquid Lateral l Glides Voiced v/w
3.7
Palatal c
Velar k
Glottal q
kh
h n˜
ng
j
Remark
I have aimed in this chapter to state the bare essentials of Lao phonology. Much more needs to be said about the vagaries of phonological structure,
38
Phonology
Table 7. Transcription system: Vowels unrounded front central high i ii mid eˆ eˆ eˆ e ee low e` e` e` a aa ` diphthongs ia, ua, ua
rounded back u` u` u`
u uu o oo o` o` o`
Table 8. Transcription system: Tones Tones 1. mid level 2. high rising 3. low rising 4. high falling 5. low falling ø. unstressed
including phonotactic distributions of both segments and tones, the interaction of tone and morphosyntax, the phonetics of tone (where more than mere pitch distinctions are certainly involved), and dialect and other sociolinguistic variation. The problem of intonation, in particular, is a major topic for investigation.
Part II Particles
Chapter 4 Sentence-final and phrase-final particles 4.1
Sentence-final particles
Sentence-final particles make a range of distinctions in the domains of status, illocutionary force, and evidentiality. Their meanings are primarily related to matters of the speech event. They convey messages which modify relations between speech act participants and the proposition encoded in the core of the utterance, typically concerning interlocutors’ (relative) epistemic stance(s) toward what is being said. Accordingly, sentencefinal particles occur almost exclusively in conversation, not in written or otherwise formal speech. They are the main means for making illocutionary and other interactionally-grounded distinctions, including marking polar questions, imperatives, assertions of different strengths and with different types of epistemic quality, as well as encoding evidential, modal, and related information at the clause level. Syntactically, they occur at the right border of the clausal core (cf. Figure 1.1). If the sentence-final particles constitute a closed class, it is a relatively porous one. There is significant dialectal and sociolinguistic variation.1 To illustrate the phenomenon, here is a declarative sentence: (1) saam3 khon2 taaj3 three person die ‘Three people died.’ This can be converted into a question by adding a sentence-final particle, such as the unmarked polar question particle b`oo` 3, the new inference polar question particle vaa3, or the independent presumption polar question particle tii4: (2) saam3 khon2 taaj3 b`oo` 3 three person die QPLR ‘Is it the case that three people died?’ 1
In these ways, Lao sentence-final particles are like sentence-final particles found across languages of mainland Southeast Asia (see for example Gibbons 1980, Kwok 1984, Luke 1990, Matthews and Yip 1994:338ff on Cantonese; Crisfield 1974 on Lao; Cooke 1989 on Thai; Thompson 1987 on Vietnamese; Huffman 1970 on Khmer).
42
Sentence-final and phrase-final particles
(3) saam3 khon2 taaj3 tii4 three person die QPLR . PRESM ‘Surely I’m correct in thinking that three people died?’ (4) saam3 khon2 taaj3 vaa3 three person die QPLR . INFER ‘Do I rightly infer that three people died?’ Sentence-final particles occur in a clause-final slot, after all verb complements and postverbal aspectual-modal marking. They occur after a point of possible syntactic completion of an utterance, and may therefore be taken to mark the right border of a clause. Material which appears in Right Position appears after any sentence-final particles (see Figure 1.1, above). The following example shows a postposed element to the right of the sentence-final particle (cf. example (2)): (5) taaj3 b`oo` 3, saam3 khon2 die QPLR three person ‘(They) died, three people?’ Crisfield (1974) describes around 30 Lao particles. His brief but pioneering analysis offers many insightful and sensitive observations on their semantics. The following section surveys the most common particles, including most of those listed by Crisfield. Within the space constraints of this chapter, the most effective way to describe the sentence-final particles is to illustrate their use in natural discourse, with attention to the interactional contexts in which they are embedded. The basic descriptive approach is to paraphrase the speaker’s meaning (cf. Wierzbicka 2003). The particles are glossed and explicated with examples, under three rubrics: interrogative, declarative, imperative.
Sentence-final particles
43
Table 9. Sentence- and phrase-final particles discussed in this chapter Interrogative b`oo` 3 Polar question, unmarked (QPLR) particles vaa3 Polar question, proposition newly inferred (QPLR . INFER) tii4 Polar question, proposition independently presumed (QPLR . PRESM) n`oq1 Polar question, seeks agreement (QPLR . AGREE) k`oq2 Content question, asks for information currently presupposed (Q . PRESUP) h`uu` 2 Content question, emphatic, shows mild annoyance at not knowing (Q . EMPH) n`oo` 4 Wondering, ‘out-loud’ question to oneself (Q . WNDR) buq2 Rhetorical question, speaker does not know (Q . UNKN) Factive dˆej2 Factive, proposition is news to addr (FAC . NEWS) dˆeeˆ 4 Factive, fills in addr with information particles presupposed in current discourse but unknown to addr (FAC . FILLIN) juu1 Factive, weakens speaker’s commitment to proposition (FAC . WEAK) d`oo` k5 Factive, resists addressee’s current stance or presumption (FAC . RESIST) sam4 Factive, proposition is unexpected or surprising given the context (FAC . SURPR) naa3 Factive, makes explicit something which addressee should already have known (FAC . EXPLIC) veej4 Factive, emphatic (FAC . EMPH) dee4 Factive, puts on record this was said (FAC . ONRCD) l`eq1 Factive, confirms something already intended (FAC . PRF) Imperative m`ee` 4 Imperative, states addr is unimpeded particles (IMP. UNIMPD) saa3 Imperative, suggests action to addr (IMP. SUGG) d`ee` 1 Imperative, softens or plays down burden of request (IMP. SOFT) vaj2 Imperative, asks addr to hurry (IMP. RUSH) duu2 Imperative, pleading ‘do it for me’ (IMP. PLEAD) Other dˆeeˆ 2 Thematizes, asks ‘What about X? (Q . THEME) particles qeej4 Vocative marker (VOC) kadaaj1 Afterthought marker (AFTH) baat5-niø Thematizer (THZR)
44
Sentence-final and phrase-final particles
The list of particles given here is not exhaustive. The aim is to represent the particles which are most common, and which therefore have a relatively high functional load.
4.1.1 Interrogative particles b`oo` 3 – ‘Is P the case?’ (polar question, unmarked = QPLR) B`oo` 3 is the unmarked polar question particle. When appended to a proposition, it expresses the idea that (a) the speaker does not know whether the proposition is true or not, and (b) they want the addressee to tell them. Here is an example from a conversation between two friends who worked together in the same organization some years earlier, and who are now catching up, and gossiping about the speaker’s previous boss. The speaker is describing a boyfriend her boss previously had. After making some statements about the way the boyfriend looked, the speaker asks if her addressee has ever actually seen him. Having no particular reason to suspect the answer will be yes or no (since the two interlocutors had different bosses), the speaker marks the question with b`oo` 3: (6)
caw4 hˆen3 b`oo` 3 2 SG . P see QPLR ‘Did you see (him)?’
In another example, the speaker is on a visit to another’s house. She wants to chew betel nut, and has not brought paraphernalia of her own. She asks whether her hosts have anything for her to chew: khiaw4 b`oo` 3 (7) mii2 n˜ ang3 there.is INDEF. INAN chew QPLR ‘Is there anything to chew?’ In another example, some friends are talking, and one asks the other to report on a wedding he had recently been to: kin3 d`oo` ng3, m`uu` 4 (8) pˆen3 cang1 daj3, muan1 b`oo` 3, pajø COP way INDEF fun QPLR DIR . ABL eat wedding day nan4 DEM . NONPROX ‘How (was it), was it fun, going to the wedding that day?’
Sentence-final particles
45
In another example, two men are discussing route directions through nearby countryside areas, and one is trying to clarify which location is being discussed. He asks if the intended location has rice paddies: (9)
mii2 naa2 b`oo` 3, juu1 han5 there.is paddy QPLR be.at DEM . DIST ‘Are there paddies, there?’
In each of the above cases, by virtue of being marked by b`oo` 3, the proposition becomes a straightforward polar question. The meaning expressed by the speaker is that they want to know if the proposition is true, but this meaning does not convey any added, special epistemic terms of the question. This special work is the business of other interrogative particles, to which we now turn. vaa3 – ‘Do I rightly infer that P is the case?’ (polar question, proposition newly inferred = QPLR . INFER) The particle vaa3 takes a proposition and turns it into a polar question, encoding the same basic function as b`oo` 3, but conveying in addition the idea that the speaker has some newly inferred reason to believe that P is the case. For example, a speaker is about to relate a narrative for the tape recorder, and the tape recorder has been switched on, but he doesn’t realize it yet. There is a moment of silence as I am waiting for him to start, but he is waiting for me to attend to the recording equipment. My prolonged inaction and expectant look give him reason to infer that he is supposed to start without further ado, and he asks, marking this new inference with vaa3, if it is in fact so: vaa3 niø (10) dajø vaw4 leej2 ACHV speak NO . ADO QPLR . INFER TPC ‘Do I rightly infer that I am to just go ahead and speak then?’ In another example, a man describes his first conversation with his (then not yet) mother-in-law. When he asks after her husband (i.e., the father of his intended bride), the mother-in-law-to-be explains that the husband does not live there, and that he is a Frenchman who was in Laos temporarily and has gone back to France. He gathers that she didn’t go
46
Sentence-final and phrase-final particles
with him, and asks, marking this inference with vaa3, whether it is in fact so: (11) caw4 b`oø m`ua2 nam2 phen1 vaa3 2 SG . P NEG return with 3. P QPLR . INFER ‘Do I rightly infer that you didn’t go back with him?’ In a third example, a woman has just finished preparations to chew betel, and has set down the basket of betel-chewing paraphernalia. Then seeing her host reaching toward the basket, she infers that the host intends to chew betel nut herself. She asks whether this is in fact so: (12) caw4 khiaw4 vaa3 2 SG . P chew QPLR . INFER ‘Do I rightly infer that you’re going to chew (betel nut too)?’ In a fourth example, a younger man is talking with an older man. The younger man asks, ‘Who has been out collecting bamboo shoots?’. The older man looks to where the younger man is looking and sees a sack of shoots leaning against the door. He infers that these are the bamboo shoots the speaker must be referring to, and asks whether this is in fact so: vaa3 (13) juu1 naj2 thaj1 hanø be.at in sack TPC . DIST QPLR . INFER ‘Do I rightly infer (that you mean) those in the sack there?’ Finally, a woman is telling a former work-mate about her new coworkers. She describes one girl’s figure as being n˜ aj1 ‘large’, which is ambiguous: it could mean ‘tall’, ‘big-framed’, or ‘fat’. The former workmate infers that it means ‘fat’, and asks whether this is in fact so: (14) tuj4 vaa3 fat QPLR . INFER ‘Do I rightly infer that (you mean she’s) fat?’ In each of these cases, the proposition being questioned is something that is newly inferred or inferable from the immediate context, and the speaker is marking this inference with vaa3, and asking if it is in fact the case.
Sentence-final particles
47
tii4 – ‘Surely I’m correct in thinking P is the case!?’ (polar question, proposition independently presumed = QPLR . PRESM) The particle tii4 marks a polar question, and conveys the idea that the speaker has independent reason to believe that P is the case, but now has some reason to require that this be confirmed. The speaker is saying something like: ‘I am already fairly certain that this is the case, please confirm that I’m not wrong’. For example, Speaker A is explaining that he intends to collect a certain type of fish trap in order to donate it to a collection of traps housed at a government fishery office. He begins by saying ‘(We’ll) take (the trap) and put (it) aside as a-’ (see (15)), pausing where he should provide a noun phrase,2 but then abandons this, passing over the word he should have supplied here, then continuing. A few lines earlier he had used an obscure word kudang3, which refers to a storehouse, but it seems clear from the context that what the speaker wants to say is thilan`uk1 ‘souvenir’, as Speaker B proposes: (15)
vaj4 pˆen3- juu1 kom3 pamong4 A qaw3 pajø take DIR . ABL keep COP be.at department fishery l`eq5 hanø TPC . DIST FAC . PRF ‘(We’ll) take (the trap) and put (it) aside as a- at the Fishery Department there.’ B thilan`uk1 tii4 souvenir QPLR . PRESM ‘A souvenir, you surely mean?’
In another example, the speaker is asking about who is going on a planned driving trip. The car involved has a small number of seats, and it appears obvious that the addressee—the driver—is unlikely to want to take more than three passengers. Two of these passengers are already known. Another very likely passenger is the driver’s wife, whose name is Da, but there are also a number of people who are with Da and who may want or expect to be able to come on this trip. The speaker asks if it will 2
Ellipsis is not possible here, since the argument in question is not a core argument but a non-core complement of the copula pˆen3; cf. Chapter 17, section 17.1.3.3.
48
Sentence-final and phrase-final particles
only be Da coming along, using tii4 to convey the idea that he is already pretty sure that this is the case, but that since it’s not actually up to him, he still needs to check: tii4, b`oø paj3 nam2 (16) siø paj3 t`ee` 1 daa3 hanø IRR go only D TPC . DIST QPLR . PRESM NEG go with kadaaj1 AFTH
‘It’s only going to be Da going, surely? (The others) won’t go along.’ Finally, a hotel manager relates a story of how a hotel guest got into a fight with another hotel guest. The speaker says, ‘That guy was from Iraq, and he came along and another guy criticized his hairstyle, “Oh, this guy’s hairstyle, why’s it like this?!”.’ The speaker then quotes what the Iraqi said in response, before the fight erupted: (17) song2 phom3 kaø l`uang1 kh`oo` ng3 haw2 tii4 1. FA QPLR . PRESM form hair T. LNK matter of ‘The hairstyle is my business, surely?!’ In each of these cases, by using tii4, the speaker conveys that the proposition being questioned is something that is already, independently figured or presumed to be the case (i.e., independent of what is going on in the context—this is what distinguishes tii4 from vaa3, above), but that the speaker is nevertheless asking the addressee to confirm that it is in fact the case. As the above examples illustrate, this single underlying meaning can be used to quite different pragmatic effects. n`oq1 – ‘P is the case, don’t you agree?’ (polar question, seeking agreement = QPLR . AGREE) By adding the particle n`oq1 to a statement, a speaker takes a proposition and turns it into a polar question style request for agreement. Examples like the following are very common in everyday speech, where interlocutors have common access to some evaluable phenomenon: (18)
a. h`oo` n4 n`oq1 hot QPLR . AGREE ‘It’s hot, don’t you agree?’
Sentence-final particles
49
b. qee5 INTJ
(19)
‘Uh-huh.’ a. s`ee` p4 n`oq1 delicious QPLR . AGREE ‘Delicious, don’t you agree?’ b. s`ee` p4 delicious ‘(Yes,) delicious.’
In another example, a woman is talking to her friend about a colleague of hers. She lists a number of this colleague’s behaviors that have created problems in her workplace. She cites the colleague’s inappropriate way of dressing. The addressee states that this is strange, using n`oq1 to elicit agreement on this judgment from the first speaker, which is immediately forthcoming: (20)
a. p`ee` k5 n`oq1 weird QPLR . AGREE ‘Weird, huh?’ b. qee5 INTJ
‘Uh-huh.’ In another example, two men are talking about different possible routes to take in order to get to a certain village. One proposes that to go via a village called Kilometre 40 would be a short way. By adding n`oq1 to this statement, he elicits agreement from his addressee (in the form of a ‘head toss’, a sharp up-turn of the head which functions something like a nod): (21)
l`eq2, kaj4 hanø a. khaw5 lak2 sii1-sip2 hanø enter km four-ten TPC . DIST FAC . PRF close TPC . DIST l`eq1 n`oq1 FAC . PRF QPLR . AGREE ‘Enter at Kilometre 40, it’s near right?” b. (head toss) (i.e., ‘Yes, right.’)
The very common particle n`oq1 is not a straightforward interrogative, in that it doesn’t request information as such. It is grouped with the other
50
Sentence-final and phrase-final particles
interrogatives because it makes relevant a direct response by the addressee (and if no response is forthcoming, this will be pragmatically marked). This response should be agreement (or disagreement) with some stated stance towards a discourse or situational topic. k`oq1 – ‘remind me WH?’ (content question, asks for information currently being presupposed = Q . PRESUP) The particle k`oq1 is specialized for content questions (‘WH-questions’) where the information sought after is currently presumed in the discourse, but is either previously known to the speaker but now forgotten, or is as yet unknown to the speaker (e.g., when one walks in on a conversation where speakers are referring to ‘he’and ‘she’). By adding k`oq1 to a content question, the speaker turns a request for some piece of information into a request for a reminder of that information (Crisfield 1974:43): k`oq1 COP INDEF. INAN Q . PRESUP ‘What was that again?’ (23) hˆen3 phaj3 k`oq1 see INDEF. HUM Q . PRESUP ‘Who did (you) see again?’ (24) hˆet1 n`ee` w2 daj3 k`oq1 do manner INDEF Q . PRESUP ‘How is it done again?’
(22) m`ee` n1 n˜ ang3
In another example, a hotel manager is describing a fight which took place in the hotel between guests. The speaker can’t remember which country the various parties came from: (25)
A maa2 t`ee` 1 saj3 k`oq2, m`oo` 3 nan4 come from INDEF. PLACE Q . PRESUP bloke DEM . NONPROX naø h`uu` 2 TPC . PERIPH Q . EMPH ‘(He) came from where again, that bloke, huh?’ thaaw4 qanaa1 tat2 phom3 b`oo` n1 nii4 fellow HES cut hair place DEM ‘The fellow um (who) cut (his) hair here.’
Sentence-final particles
51
k`oq2 khon2 n˜ ang3 person INDEF. INAN Q . PRESUP ‘What was he again?’ B khon2 qanø qii3lak1 person HES Iraq ‘An um Iraqi.’ This particle is not used with polar questions. hu` u2 ` – ‘WH the heck?’ (content question, emphatic, shows mild annoyance at not knowing = Q . EMPH) The particle h`uu` 2 is usually used with content questions, but sometimes with polar questions as well. It implies impatience or mild annoyance, possibly directed at the speaker himself for not knowing. For example (see also the first line of example (25), above): juu1 phun4 hu` u2 (26) khaw3 hˆet1 n˜ ang3 ` 3 PL . B do INDEF. INAN be.at DEM . FAR Q . EMPH ‘What the heck are they doing over there (I wonder)?’ (27) man2 qa˜nuuq1 cak2 pii3 hu` u2 ` 3. B age how.many year Q . EMPH ‘How the heck old is he (I wonder)?’ (28) m`ung2 siø paj3 b`oo` 3 hu` u2 ` 2 SG . B IRR go QPLR Q . EMPH ‘Are you going or what?’ n`oo` 4 – ‘I wonder if/WH?’ (question, makes ‘out-loud’ question to oneself, not expecting answer = Q . WNDR) The particle n`oo` 4 is usually used with content questions, but sometimes with polar questions as well. It conveys a kind of speaker-directed question which does not really expect an answer. The question is simply something that the speaker wonders out loud. For example: n`oo` 4 (29) khaw3 paj3 saj3 3 PL . B go INDEF. PLACE Q . WNDR ‘Where have they gone, I wonder?’
52
Sentence-final and phrase-final particles
(30) man2 siø hˆet1 n˜ ang3 haj5 kin3 n`oo` 4 3. B IRR make INDEF. INAN give eat Q . WNDR ‘What will she make to eat, I wonder?’ It is also possible to combine n`oo` 4 with a polar question particle: (31)
khaw3 siø paj3 b`oo` 3 n`oo` 4 3 PL . B IRR go QPLR Q . WNDR ‘Will they go, I wonder?’
buq2 – ‘I don’t know if/WH.’ (rhetorical question, poses question but foregrounds the idea that speaker does not know and does not expect an answer = Q . UNKN) The particle buq2 is usually used with content questions, but sometimes with polar questions as well. It is a way of stating a kind of rhetorical question. While n`oo` 4 is a question that doesn’t expect an answer, buq2 is hardly even a question. That is, buq2 helps to package an utterance as a question in formal terms, but the speaker foregrounds the idea that they do not know the answer, nor do they expect an answer. For example: buq2 khaw3 paj3 saj3 3 PL . B go INDEF. PLACE Q . UNKN ‘Who knows where they have gone?’ (33) man2 siø hˆet1 n˜ ang3 haj5 kin3 buq2 3. B IRR make INDEF. INAN give eat Q . UNKN ‘Who knows what will she make to eat?’
(32)
It is also possible to combine buq2 with a polar question particle, such as b`oo` 3 in the following example: (34)
4.1.2
khaw3 siø paj3 b`oo` 3 buq2 3 PL . B IRR go QPLR Q . UNKN ‘Who knows whether they will go?’
Factive particles
dˆej2 – ‘P is the case, maybe you don’t think so’ (factive, proposition is news to the addressee = FAC . NEWS)
Sentence-final particles
53
The particle dˆej2 is attached to an assertion when a speaker wants to explicitly convey that this is being offered as new or possibly surprising information, as if the speaker appends ‘I’m telling you, since it might be that you don’t think it’s the case’. For example, a speaker is talking about the period immediately following the 1975 revolution in Laos. In the early phase of the new government, people had to attend regular political seminars, propaganda training sessions emblematic of those times. The speaker points out that while these political seminars are no longer attended by everyday citizens, they still regularly occur in official circles. Since they are no longer a public phenomenon, it might be that the addressee thinks that these seminar sessions have been discontinued completely. The speaker uses dˆej2 to convey the idea that this is, perhaps surprisingly, not so: (35) diaw3-nii4 kaø n˜ ang2 hian2 juu1 dˆej2 T. LNK STILL study CONT FAC . NEWS now ‘Now (they) still study, as you might not think.’ In another example, a speaker is describing how to build a chicken coop. He explains that it is not necessary to construct a roost for each and every chicken. This is because chickens don’t all lay eggs at the same time. He is aware that his addressee knows nothing about raising chickens, and it might be that the addressee simply figures that each chicken should have its own personal roost. The speaker marks this possibly surprising information with dˆej2: (36)
ph`oo` m4 kan3 dˆej2, kaj1 man2 b`oø khaj1 3. B NEG have.eggs together COLL FAC . NEWS chicken ‘They don’t lay eggs at the same time, you might not think this, chickens.’
In another example, the speaker is telling a story about a mother and child returning to their field hut in the early evening. An animal is following them in the distance, but its form is barely visible in the fading light. Normally, one would take this to be a large domestic animal such as a cow or buffalo, or in some parts of Laos, a horse. But no, this is a story about an attack by a tiger. A critical piece of the story is that nobody expects to see a tiger approaching:
54
Sentence-final and phrase-final particles
(37) man2 b`oø m`ee` n1 ngua2 laø b`oø m`ee` n1 maa4 tham2madaa3 3. B NEG COP cow and NEG COP horse ordinary baat5-niø, man2 m`ee` n1 s`ua3-khoong1 dˆej2 dˆej2 FAC . NEWS THZR FAC . NEWS 3. B COP tiger-sp. ‘It wasn’t a cow and it wasn’t an ordinary horse, despite what you might think, now. It was a tiger, you see.’ Finally, a speaker describes conditions under re-education in postrevolutionary Laos. These were in fact prison conditions, but the way it is officially talked about—as ‘education’ and ‘seminars’—does not suggest this. An addressee who did not experience this might therefore not be expected to think that attendants were literally imprisoned. The speaker makes this assertion, explicitly marking with dˆej2 that it is likely to be surprising information: nii3 l`eø khaw3 siø n˜ ing2 taaj3 (38) nii3 b`oø daj4 dˆej2, flee NEG CAN FAC . NEWS flee and 3 PL . B IRR shoot die ‘(One) couldn’t flee you know, flee and they’d shoot (you) dead.’ dˆeeˆ 4 – ‘P is the case, I think you don’t know it’ (factive, filling in addressee with information which is presupposed in current discourse but unknown to addressee = FAC . FILLIN) The particle dˆeeˆ 4 is close in meaning to dˆej2. It is used for stating something that the listener might not realize, but they should or must realize in order to comprehend or properly appreciate something in the context (e.g., what has just been said). It is a way of signaling that you are filling in some needed information. It typically occurs in elaborating or accounting for something that has just been stated, but which the addressee may not yet have fully appreciated. An example is from early in a narrative about an eccentric, clever character called Siang Miang. A king confronts a thorny problem and asks that Siang Miang be brought to help him solve it. Someone is ‘sent off to find him’. However, why someone needs to be sent off to find him might not be clear to a listener. The speaker’s next utterance accounts for this, explaining that Siang Miang’s house is far away. He marks this with dˆeeˆ 4: (39)
h`uan2 phen1 kaj3 dˆeeˆ 4 house 3. P far FAC . FILLIN ‘His house was far away, you must understand.’
Sentence-final particles
55
In another example, a speaker has used the word ph`ee` 4, which is undergoing semantic change. The speaker has to pause to discuss which meaning he intends. The word ph`ee` 4 previously meant ‘to win, to defeat, to be victorious’, while it is now very often used with the opposite meaning, ‘to lose, to be defeated, to be vanquished’. He explains, ‘Nowadays, if we say ph`ee` 4 it means “to lose” ... but in the old days, ph`ee` 4 meant “to be (more) capable”; in boat-racing or in racing buffaloes’, (40)
m`ee` n1 ph`ee` 4 dˆeeˆ 4 COP ph`ee` 4 FAC . FILLIN ‘It is ph`ee` 4, you must understand.’
juu1 – ‘P is the case, (but) not to a great degree’ (factive, weakens the speaker’s commitment to the proposition = FAC . WEAK) The particle juu1, otherwise a locative verb ‘to be at’ or a means of expressing continuity of action (cf. Chapter 9), can be used for downplaying a speaker’s commitment to an assertion, or attenuating a speaker’s commitment to its truth. The meaning expressed when one adds juu1 to an assertion is ‘You could say it’s the case, but you couldn’t say it’s very much the case’. It is common with adjectives: (41)
Q s`ee` p4 b`oo` 3 delicious QPLR ‘Is (it) delicious?’ A s`ee` p4 juu1 delicious FAC . WEAK ‘(It’s) reasonably delicious (not very).’
It may also be used with other kinds of verbs, including the postverbal modal daj4 ‘can’. For example, a speaker is asked about his experience in sport, in a prelude to a series of questions about the rules of various games. The speaker’s use of juu1 as a sentence-final particle conveys the idea that while the assertion—‘Yes, I have’—is true, the speaker wants to downplay the strength of it, so as not to appear to be claiming he is an expert: (42)
Q caw4 kheej2 lin5 kilaa2 b`oo` 3 2 SG . P EXP play sport QPLR ‘Have you ever played sport?’
56
Sentence-final and phrase-final particles
A qee5 kh`oo` j5 kaø kheej2 lin5 juu1 INTJ 1 SG . P T. LNK EXP play FAC . WEAK ‘Uh-huh, I have played a bit.’ In another example, a man has recently had an accident, and is asked about his recovery. His response is marked by juu1, indicating less-thanfull commitment to the assertion: (43)
Q n˜ aang1 daj4 b`oo` 3 laø walk CAN QPLR PCL ‘Can you walk already?’ A daj4 juu1 CAN FAC . WEAK ‘(I) can, a little.’
d`oo` k5 – ‘P is the case, not like what you seem to think’ (factive, resists the addressee’s current stance or presumption = FAC . RESIST) The particle d`oo` k5 is negatively valenced, and typically occurs with explicitly negated assertions. When a speaker appends d`oo` k5 to an assertion, this conveys a kind of resistance, a meaning along the lines ‘This is the case, in contrast to what you seem to think’. For example, one person says that there is salt in the cupboard, and another checks and sees none, saying: (44)
b`oø mii2 d`oo` k5 NEG there.is FAC . RESIST ‘There isn’t any (contrary to what you seem to think).’
In another example, the speakers are eating a meal together. One of the speakers is a guest, and praises the meal. In response to this, out of politeness, the host herself says that to the contrary the meal is not very good. In this context, the assertion which goes contrary to what the first speaker has just said is, accordingly, marked with d`oo` k5: (45)
A kin3 khaw5 s`ee` p4 eat rice delicious ‘The meal is delicious.’
Sentence-final particles
57
paan3 daj3 d`oo` k5 B b`oø s`ee` p4 NEG delicious extent INDEF FAC . RESIST ‘It’s not very delicious (contrary to your stance).’ The particle d`oo` k5 need not always be appended to a negativelymarked assertion. The following example is from Crisfield (1974:43, his translation): (46) paj3 juu1 d`oo` k5 go CONT FAC . RESIST ‘Oh, indeed I am going!’ In another example, the speaker works in a hotel which hosts large numbers of short-stay guests from South Asian and Middle Eastern countries. He is asked if there have ever been physical fights arising from tensions between these guests. The question itself seems to betray some possible doubt as to the truth of the proposition. The speaker marks his response with d`oo` k5, conveying the idea that the assertion is true ‘contrary to what you seem to think’: niø man2 kaø mii2 juu1 (47) qooj4 qanø-nii4 INTJ MC . INAN - DEM TPC 3. B T. LNK there.is CONT l`uajø-l`uaj4 d`oo` k5 REG FAC . RESIST ‘Oy, this happens all the time (contrary to what you seem to expect).’ Note the distinction from the particle dˆej2, above. The particle dˆej2 conveys the idea that the assertion is news to the addressee, because the addressee might not think that it is the case. By contrast, d`oo` k5 conveys the idea that the truth is not what the addressee appears to think. In this way, dˆej2 emphasizes an informative, news-giving function, while d`oo` k5 has a more resistant, disagreeing function. Accordingly, d`oo` k5 is more natural as a direct, negating response to something just asserted. sam4 – ‘P is the case, contrary to what one might expect in the context’ (factive, proposition is unexpected or surprising given the context = FAC . SURPR )
58
Sentence-final and phrase-final particles
The meaning expressed by the particle sam4 is similar to d`oo` k5 in marking that an assertion is somehow counter to expectation. The nature of the counter-expectation differs from d`oo` k5 in that sam4 is less about the addressee’s supposition in particular, but more about the likely expectation that anybody would have given what is known from the narrative. That is, d`oo` k5 is more closely tied to the speech event participants, sam4 to the internal logic of the narrated event. Sam4 may often be translated as ‘after all’, since it marks an assertion of some state of affairs as being is the opposite of what one would have expected. In the following example, a couple have found a goose at the market which they want to buy, but they don’t have enough money with them. They rush home to get the money, but when they get back to market to buy the goose, it had been sold to someone else. The ultimate outcome— they didn’t get the goose—it not the expected or hoped-for one, and this is marked, accordingly, with sam4: (48)
qoo4 laø b`oø daj4 sam4 INTJ and NEG acquire FAC . SURPR ‘Oh, and (they) didn’t get (it) after all.’
Another example is from the fable of Miss Mola. She never commits to one thing. Having been abandoned by her un-trusting husband, she is now starving. Seeing a crow carrying a fish she chases after it, wanting the fish, but then seeing a dog carrying meat, she goes after the dog instead, wanting the meat, only to notice once again the crow, abandoning her chase for the meat, and so on. She is never satisfied: (49) jaak5 daj4 laaj3, kaø b`oø dajø kin3 sam4 want acquire much T. LNK NEG ACHV eat FAC . SURPR ‘(She) wanted to get a lot, (but she) didn’t get to eat at all.’ In a final example, a speaker is talking about a guest at a wedding he attended. This guest spent the entire evening on the dance floor. The speaker finds it remarkable that she didn’t sit down once: (50) qoo4 b`oø dajø nang1 h`oo` t4 tang1 sam4 INTJ NEG ACHV sit reach chair FAC . SURPR ‘Oh, (she) didn’t even sit on a chair.’
Sentence-final particles
59
The assertion that she didn’t once sit down is marked here with sam4 in order to convey the idea that this is counter to expectation, given the type of context. The particle sam4 does not target any supposition or expectation of the current speech act participants per se, but rather anyone’s expectations given the internal logic of the discourse or situational context. naa3 – ‘P is the case, as you should have already understood’ (factive, makes explicit something which the addressee should already have known = FAC . EXPLIC) The particle naa3 is used to convey the meaning that an assertion is something which the speaker figures should already be understood by the addressee. It conveys insistence and mild annoyance at the addressee’s current failure to understand the relevance of something happening or being said. For example, a speaker is describing a collision between a motorcycle and a bicycle. The explanation becomes fairly involved: (51) ngoo2 maa2 cang1 sii4 naa3 turn come like thus FAC . EXPLIC ‘(They) turned like this (gesturing), you should already understand (I don’t think you get it yet).’ In another example, the speaker is describing how people construct chicken coops. He says that coops should be built facing east, as it is said to result in the chickens being more fertile. As soon as he has said this, he goes on to make the explicit assertion that he is talking about people’s BELIEFS, implying that this is probably just superstition. His use of the particle naa3 here is a way to convey that the addressee should already realize this, and should not have taken the speaker himself to have been professing these superstitions: (52) vaw4 khuam2-s`ua1 naa3 speak NZR-believe FAC . EXPLIC ‘(I’m) speaking of beliefs, you must understand (i.e., don’t take me to be professing these beliefs myself, I’m only describing them to you).’
60
Sentence-final and phrase-final particles
In another example, a group is discussing which one amongst them is capable of telling a fable for the tape recorder. One speaker points to another and says, ‘This bloke has lots of stories, for sure.’ The speaker’s subsequent utterance gives an account for why he made this assertion, namely that the fellow in question was once a lam singer.3 The speaker’s use of naa3 marks this assertion as something the addressee needs to have known, or should have known, in order to understand the prior utterance: (53)
kheej2 hˆet1 m`oo` 3-lam2 naa3 qanø-nii4 CLF. INAN - DEM EXP do expert-lam FAC . EXPLIC ‘This one has been a Lam artist, you must understand.’
A final example comes from a joke-telling. In the joke, a grandpa is helping his grandson read the Lao alphabet. The boy succeeds in reading the first two letters—k`oo` 3 and kh`oo` 3—but is stumped on the third. The third letter in the Lao alphabet is kh`oo` 2, homonymous with the word for ‘neck’. As a hint, the grandfather points to his own neck. The punch line is that instead of saying kh`oo` 2, the child says qˆen3, which sounds like the name of the English letter N. In order to understand this joke, one needs to already understand what qˆen3 means in Lao, and why the child would have said it in this context. The speaker’s next utterance makes this explicit: qˆen3 means ‘tendon’ or ‘vein’. The joke is that the child took the old man not to be pointing to his neck, but to the many tendons and veins visible on his neck. In making this explicit, the speaker’s use of naa3 marks this assertion as something which the recipient of the joke needed to know, or should have known, in order to understand the prior utterance (i.e., the joke’s punch line): hanø man2 thaw5 laø man2 mii2 qˆen3 (54) phuø-thaw5 CT. PERSON-old TPC . DIST 3. B old and 3. B have tendon juu1 nii4 laaj3 naa3 be.at DEM much FAC . EXPLIC ‘The old man, he was old, and he had many tendons/veins here on his neck (pointing), you must understand.’
3
Lam is a traditional form of Lao chanting-singing (Compton 1979, Chapman 2001, 2002, 2003).
Sentence-final particles
61
veej4 – ‘Heck, P is the case!’ (factive, emphatic = FAC . EMPH) The particle veej4 (often combined with a perfect marker laø, as laø veej4) conveys the kind of informality that goes with mild impoliteness or profanity. Crisfield (1974) uses the English interjection heck to convey its meaning in English translation. For example, a speaker is talking about the early post-revolutionary years (from 1975), during which many people fled Laos as refugees. He describes his deliberations as to whether it was a good idea, first planning to leave, but then finally deciding not to: tat2-sin3-caj3 maj1 vaa1 b`oø paj3 laø veej4 (55) maø DIR . ALL decide new COMP NEG go PRF FAC . EMPH ‘(I) decided anew, “Heck, (I) won’t go!”.’ In another, similar example, a speaker quotes his own thoughts upon considering whether or not to enroll in a course of study, and eventually deciding to do so: kh`ut1 beng1 vaa1 hian2 kaø hian2 laø (56) l`ee` w4 maø PRF DIR . ALL think look COMP study T. LNK study PCL veej4 FAC . EMPH ‘Then I thought “Heck, I might as well go ahead and study!”.’ In a final example, a man describes the daily routine at a re-education facility. The speaker explains that at 9 o’clock each evening, the guards would ring a bell, signaling that everyone had to go to sleep. This was mandatory: (57) b`oø n`oo` n2 kaø sang1 haj5 n`oo` n2 laø veej4 NEG sleep T. LNK order give sleep PCL FAC . EMPH ‘(If one) didn’t sleep, heck, they’d order (you) to sleep.’ dee4 – ‘P is the case, y’hear!’ (factive, putting on record that this was said = FAC . ONRCD) The particle dee4 is used for conveying the idea that a speaker wants his interlocutor to pay special attention to what he is saying. It may be used with assertions as well as directives. With this particle, one doesn’t just
62
Sentence-final and phrase-final particles
say the proposition, one puts on record that one has said it (such that later it can’t be disputed). For example, dee4 is appended to these very common expressions of politeness: (58) kh`oo` p5-caj3 dee4 thank.you FAC . ONRCD ‘Thank you!’ (59) paj3 k`oo` n1 dee4 go before FAC . ONRCD ‘See you later!’ (Literally: ‘(I’m) leaving first.’) Another common situation in which dee4 occurs is in issuing instructions, to convey the idea that the addressee must listen carefully or pay special attention: (60) b`oø1 haj5 l`uu` m2 dee4 NEG give forget FAC . ONRCD ‘Don’t forget, y’hear!’ In the next two examples, a speaker quotes a policeman’s instructions to prisoners who are being transported to a re-education camp: laø khaw5 paj3 han5 k`oo` n1 (61) qee4 seen2 long2 lot1 INTJ invite descend vehicle PRF enter go DEM . DIST before dee4 FAC . ONRCD ‘Uh-huh, please get out of the vehicle and go inside there first, y’hear!’ Then, after having entered and signed their names on the register: dee4 (62) qee5 kh`un5 paj3 san4 thii1 s`oo` ng3 phun4 INTJ ascend go storey ORD two DEM . FAR FAC . ONRCD ‘Uh-huh, go up to the second storey yonder, y’hear!’ l`eq1 – ‘That’s it, P is indeed the case.’ (factive, confirming that something is the case, as has already been intended or alluded to = FAC . PRF) The particle l`eq1 (presumably derived from the perfect marker l`ee` w4) conveys the idea ‘That’s it, P is indeed the case’, asserting and confirming what has been alluded to or earlier intended. For example:
Sentence-final particles
63
(63) kh`oo` j3 kaø siø paj3 l`eq1 1 SG . P T. LNK IRR go FAC . PRF ‘Indeed I am going.’ (64) vaa1 siø khaw5 phun5 l`eq1 say IRR enter DEM . FAR FAC . PRF ‘(Yes) indeed, (we) were intending to go in (to the area) over there.’
4.1.3
Imperative particles
m`ee` 4 – ‘Do it, go ahead, I don’t know why you don’t, nothing’s stopping you’ (imperative, states that addressee is unimpeded = IMP. UNIMP) The particle m`ee` 4 is used in utterances which urge an addressee to carry out some action, where the speaker is conveying the idea that the addressee is unimpeded, that there is nothing stopping the addressee doing the action. For example, a market woman is selling sausages. She tells a potential customer that the sausages are delicious, and that the customer should try them. By adding m`ee` 4 to this utterance, it is as if she urges her customer not to resist the temptation to try them. M`ee` 4 conveys the idea, ‘Go ahead, what are you waiting for?’: (65) caw4 l`oo` ng2 qaw3 paj3 hˆet1 kin3 beng1 m`ee` 4 take go make eat look IMP. UNIMP 2 SG . P try ‘You go ahead and take (them) and try cooking (them) to eat!’ In another example, a mother is sitting with her youngest child, having just finished breast-feeding. An older woman is waiting for her to help with a mat-weaving task. The mother calls out to another of her children, who is asked to come and take care of the infant. The speaker’s use of m`ee` 4 conveys the idea ‘What are you waiting for?’, but in this context it conveys impatience, in contrast to the encouraging, inviting tone of the previous example:
64
Sentence-final and phrase-final particles
(66) maø qaw3 n`oo` ng4, maa2 m`ee` 4, siø n˜ e` e` 1 saat5 haj5 DIR . ALL take y G come IMP. UNIMP IRR insert mat give m`eø-paa4 niø naa3 CT. M o- P a.e Z TPC FAC . EXPLIC ‘Come and take care of younger sibling, come on what are you waiting for? (I) am going to help this aunty do weaving, you must understand.’ Another example is from a narrative tale about supreme beings in a heavenly kingdom and their exploits in the world of men. King Vetsuvan asks after his aide Kumphan, as he hasn’t seen him report for duty. His assistants say they are afraid he has died, since he got into a fight with some humans (despite being urged not to). The King is not satisfied with this report and wants evidence. His command to go and find the body is marked with m`ee` 4, which in this context conveys his impatience with his aides for not having already done this: nam2-haa3 m`ee` 4 (67) man2 taaj3 juu1 saj3, 3. B die be.at INDEF. PLACE follow-seek IMP. UNIMP ‘Where has he died? Go and find him, what are you waiting for?!’ In a final example, a group of men are telling stories for the tape recorder. After one speaker has finished, another is asked to contribute a joke or an anecdote. He responds by saying that he doesn’t think he can do it. Another urges him to speak, and by using m`ee` 4 conveys his disagreement with the man’s claim that he is incapable—specifically, through its meaning ‘there’s nothing stopping you’: (68) vaw4 m`ee` 4 speak IMP. UNIMP ‘Go ahead and speak, what are you waiting for?!’ saa3 – ‘Do it, it will be good if you do, I know you won’t do it if you don’t want to’ (imperative, suggests course of action to addressee = IMP. SUGG ) The imperative particle saa3 has a suggesting, non-imposing quality. By using saa3 in a directive or request, the speaker conveys the idea that it would be good if the addressee carried out the action, but that whether or not they do it is ultimately a matter of the addressee’s own choice. The
Sentence-final particles
65
speaker can use saa3 either to acknowledge or bring about a situation in which the addressee is treated as someone with authority over the course of action. Saa3 provides a way to propose that the addressee do something, without being too imposing. The speaker claims less authority, making it explicit that it is up to the addressee whether they acquiesce. In an example from a narrative, a head-butting contest is scheduled to take place, but the visiting team becomes terrified of the opposition. They go to their hosts and plead for more time. The use of saa3 treats the addressee as the authority in making the decision: (69)
l`ee` w4, m`uu` 4 nii4, kh`oo` 3 qiik5 b`oø than2 nanø NEG on.time TPC . NONPROX PRF day DEM request more cak2 s`oo` ng3 saam3 van2 saa3 how.many two three day IMP. SUGG ‘We’re not ready today, (we) request another two or three days, please?’
In another example, the hero Sinxay and his sidekick Sangthong are delayed on their travels by a giant snake which has transformed itself into a mountain range. They can’t get past. Sangthong says to his master Sinxay: n˜ ing2 thim5 saa3 (70) saa4 vˆeeˆ 2laa2, n˜ ing2 man2 saa3, slow time shoot 3. B IMP. SUGG shoot discard IMP. SUGG ‘We’re being held up, go ahead and shoot it, shoot it and get rid of it.’ Sinxay is the leader of the expedition, and Sangthong’s phrasing with saa3 recognizes this by acknowledging that it is ultimately Sinxay’s choice as to what course of action is taken. A final example is from a fable. A cow encounters a tiger, and asks the tiger to let her go home and feed her calf before allowing the tiger to eat her. The tiger agrees, but when the cow goes to her calf to explain this, the calf wants to let the tiger eat it instead, and spare the mother. The cow and calf end up both standing in front of the tiger, arguing about who should be eaten. Saying ‘Eat me, not my calf’, the cow’s use of saa3 conveys the idea that she would prefer this course of action, but it also shows respect to the tiger by acknowledging its freedom to decide:
66
Sentence-final and phrase-final particles
(71) pha˜naa2 s`ua3 qeej4, siø kin3 kh`oo` j5 kaø kin3 saa3 lord tiger VOC IRR eat 1 SG . P T. LNK eat IMP. SUGG ‘O tiger lord, (if) you are going to eat me, then please eat me (and not my calf).’ d`ee` 1 – ‘Do it, please, it’s not a big thing’ (imperative, softens or plays down the burden of the request = IMP. SOFT) The particle d`ee` 1 (with a variant n`ee` 1 which appears to have identical function and distribution) provides a polite way of asking someone to do some small favor for the speaker: (72) peet5 patuu3 haj5 d`ee` 1 open door give IMP. SOFT ‘Please open the door.’ (73) qaw3 k`ua3 haj5 kh`oo` j5 d`ee` 1 take salt give 1 SG . P IMP. SOFT ‘Please give me the salt.’ In another example, a speaker is telling the tale of a man who is fighting another man who wants to take his wife. At a certain point, both men fall to the ground, and their swords fly off and land at a distance. The husband calls out to his wife to fetch his sword for him: haj5 (74) naang2 moo2laa2 qeej4, qaw3 qanaa1 ngaaw4 maø VOC take HES sword DIR . ALL give miss M qaaj4 d`ee` 1 eBr IMP. SOFT ‘O Miss Mola, take um the sword and give it to me (i.e., older brother), please.’ In another example, a man at the market sees sausages for the first time. He asks the sales lady whether there is a special way to prepare them, to which she replies, ‘Yes indeed’. He responds: (75) cot2 tamlaa3 haj5 kh`oo` j5 d`ee` 1 write recipe give 1 SG . P IMP. SOFT ‘Write down the recipe for me please.’
Sentence-final particles
67
The use of d`ee` 1 with an imperative is a way of softening the imposition, as if to say, ‘it’s not a big thing’. This meaning is related to other functions of d`ee` 1. With assertions, d`ee` 1 can also attenuate the strength of a proposition, along the lines of ‘a little’, ‘partly’. In this function, it occurs in the postverbal slot, before postverbal aspectual-modals. For example: (76) jaak5 kham1 m`uu` t4 d`ee` 1 l`ee` w4 tend evening dark a.little PRF ‘It was already getting a little dark.’ In another example, a speaker is talking about hippies from Western countries who lived in Vientiane just prior to the fall of the Royal Lao Government in 1975. He describes how these hippies were talking with him about the imminent takeover by a communist government. He remarks that these hippies could speak Lao a bit, conveying this notion of ‘partly’ or ‘a little’ by means of the particle d`ee` 1: (77)
mii2 khon2 man2 vaw4 khuam2 laaw2 kaø daj4 d`ee` 1 there.is person 3. B speak sense Lao T. LNK CAN a.little ‘Some people, they could speak Lao a little.’
A complex construction which also relates to the idea of ‘part, small amount’ has the pattern X d`ee` 1, Y d`ee` 1 (, Z d`ee` 1), with the meaning ‘Some X, some Y (, some Z)’. For example, a speaker describes conditions in a crowded holding cell, as detainees wait to be transported to a re-education facility: (78) h`oo` ng4-haj5 d`ee` 1, hiiw3 qahaan3 d`ee` 1 IN . PART hungry food IN . PART call-cry ‘Some were crying, some were hungry.’ vaj2 – ‘Hurry up and do it!’ (imperative, asks the addressee to hurry = IMP. RUSH) The particle vaj2 is typically used with imperatives directed at children. As a verb, vaj2 means ‘fast’. In its sentence-final particle function, vaj2 presupposes that the addressee will be compliant. It is therefore appropriate for familiar children, not for strangers. Here is an example:
68
Sentence-final and phrase-final particles
(79) maa2 mian4 phaa2-khaw5 vaj2 come put.aside tray.table-rice IMP. RUSH ‘Hurry up and come and clear away the dinner tray!’ duu2 – ‘Please do it, for me?’ (IMP. PLEAD) The particle duu2 conveys a kind of pleading tone to an imperative, as if the speaker is saying ‘Do it, FOR ME’. Here is an example: (80) qaw3 vii2 haj5 kh`oo` j5 duu2 take comb give 1 SG . P PCL ‘Please get the comb, for me?’
4.2
Other phrase-final particles
There are a few particles which attach directly to a noun phrase, rather than a clause or sentence. In some cases the phrase-final particle appears in utterance-final position in an utterance which has no verbal predicate. In other cases the particle attaches to a noun phrase which has been postposed, in sentence-final Right Position. In each case, the particle usually ends up in utterance-final position anyway. dˆeeˆ 2 – ‘And what about X?’ (interrogative thematizer = Q . THEME) A noun phrase followed by the particle dˆeeˆ 2 is a complete utterance, meaning ‘(And) what about X?’. This type of utterance is elliptical. Its interpretation is strongly dependent on context. For example, a soldier returns from an adventure in which he had hoped to recover the princess and her nephew Sinxay. The soldier reports to the king that the princess has been kidnapped, and in reply the king asks: (81) sinsaj2 dˆeeˆ 2 Q . THEME S ‘And what about Sinxay?’ (i.e., ‘What news do you have about Sinxay?’) The response is:
Other phrase-final particles
69
(82) sinsaj2 man2 tok2 hˆeeˆ w3 taaj3 l`ee` w4 S 3. B fall cliff die PRF ‘Sinxay, he has fallen down a cliff and died.’ In another example, A has just asked after the health of B’s aging father, and B has given a complete response. Then, A asks: (83) m`ee` 1 caw4 dˆeeˆ 2 mother 2 SG . P Q . THEME ‘And what about your mother?’ qeej4 – ‘O X!’ (vocative = VOC) The vocative particle qeej4 is used just when calling out to someone, to attract their attention: (84) qiø-ph`oo` 1 qeej4 F. B - F VOC ‘Hey, Dad!’ (85) s`ee` ng3 qeej4 VOC S ‘Hey, Seng!’ Vocatives are often used when beseeching or trying to coerce someone. An example comes from a tale about a grandfather who does homework with his grandchild every evening: laaw2 t`ee` 1-laø l`ee` ng2 (86) laaw2 kheej2 b`oo` k5 laan3 evening 3 SG . FA EXP tell grandchild 3 SG . FA each naa3, laan3 qeej4, m`uø-l`ee` ng2 maa2 laø hanø TPC . DIST FAC . EXPLIC grandchild VOC this.evening come PRF qaan1 nangs`uu` 3 dee4 read writing FAC . ONRCD ‘He used to tell his grandchild every evening, you see: “O grandchild, when the evening comes, (we’ll) read (together), y’hear!”.’ Another example describes the panicked reaction of a group of townsfolk who have witnessed a frightening incident:
70
Sentence-final and phrase-final particles
(87) h`oo` ng4 q`oo` k5 siang3 diaw3 kan3, s`oo` j1 n`ee` 1 baan4 call exit voice single COLL help IMP. SOFT village m`uang2 qeej4, s`oo` j1 n`ee` 1 VOC help IMP. SOFT town ‘(They) called out with a single voice, “Please help!, O (people of the) village and town, please help!”.’ In a last example, a speaker quotes the speech of a cow who has just encountered a tiger. The cow is resigned to the fact that she will be eaten, but begs the tiger to first let her go to her calf and give it milk for the last time. Her opening words are: (88) caw4 pha˜naa2 s`ua3 qeej4 lord king tiger VOC ‘O Tiger King...’ kadaaj1 – (afterthought marker = AFTH) The particle kadaaj1 typically attaches to a nominal which is postposed, in the Right Position slot as an afterthought of some kind. Thus, even though kadaaj1 is attached to a nominal, it nevertheless happens to occur in sentence-final position. In an example, a speaker is describing his detainment by local authorities as one of a large group charged with social offences like drug abuse and prostitution. He discusses how the women acted, explaining that many of them were crying, particularly because they hadn’t had a chance to tell their families where they were going: (89) b`oø dajø b`oo` k5 ph`oo` 1 b`oo` k5 m`ee` 1 baat5-niø naø, NEG ACHV tell TPC . PERIPH father tell mother THZR phuø-˜ning2 kadaaj1 CT. F -woman AFTH ‘(They) hadn’t told their parents now, the women.’ The use of kadaaj1 here gives the impression that the speaker is continuing to focus his thoughts on the marked referent, in this case the women. Note that structurally, in example (89) the subject is not overtly expressed at all in the main clause, but is made explicit in the extraclausal, kadaaj1-marked afterthought phrase.
Other phrase-final particles
71
In another, similar example, a speaker is eating fish soup, and comments on the amount of bones in it: (90)
mii2 t`ee` 1 kaang4, paa3 kadaaj1 there.is only fishbone fish AFTH ‘There’s only bones, the fish.’
In another example, a speaker has just finished telling a few jokes and announces that he has no more to tell: th`oo` 1 nan4 laø dˆej2, kh`oo` j5 (91) qaw2, bet2 INTJ finished amount DEM . NONPROX PRF FAC . NEWS 1 SG . P niø kadaaj5 TPC AFTH
‘So, that’s it, concerning me.’ Here is a final example: (92)
saduak5-sabaaj3 qiik5, juu1 nii4 kadaaj5 convenient-comfortable more be.at here AFTH ‘(It’s) comfortable and easy too, living here.’
In each of these examples, kadaaj1 is attached to a nominal which has been extracted from the main clause and postposed. But such postposing of noun phrases is common, and most of the time kadaaj1 does not appear. Its use in these examples serves to reiterate the enduring topicality of the noun phrase referent, causing it to persist beyond the main clause. baat5-niø – (thematizer = THZR) The particle baat5-niø consists of the word baat5 ‘moment, time’ together with the general topic marker niø (related to the general demonstrative nii4). As a particle, baat5-niø has a kind of thematizing function, similar in meaning (and form) to English now in its function as a discourse marker. It may occur sentence-finally, as in (93-95): (93) bakø-looj3 phen1 b`oø maa2 baat5-niø M . B -L 3. P NEG come THZR ‘Loy, he didn’t come, now.’
72
Sentence-final and phrase-final particles
(94) qooj4 pajø nak2 lot1 khaw3 n˜ ang3 laø baat5-niø INTJ DIR . ABL heavy car 3 PL . B INDEF. INAN PRF THZR ‘Oy, what’s the point of just weighing down their car, now?’ maj1 maa2 baat5-niø naø (95) naaj2- phuø TPC . PERIPH boss MC . HUM new come THZR ‘The boss – (when) a new one came...’ It also often occurs sentence-initially, as a kind of linker from what came prior: (96) l`eø baat5-niø, hˆet1 jaak5 haj5 haw2 laa2 q`oo` k5 qˆeeˆ ng3 do want give 1. FA depart exit self and THZR ‘And so- (they) act (like they) want to get us to resign ourselves.’
4.3
On the relationship between particles and tone
Sentence-final and other phrase-final particles appear to have a different relationship to pitch contour than words of other form classes, particularly the open classes of nouns and verbs. The nature of a tone language of the Southeast Asian type is that words in general have randomly assigned, lexically contrastive pitch contour. Thus, there is no significance to the fact that khaang5 ‘side’ is pronounced with a high falling tone. It is only significant in the arbitrary, negative sense that it contrasts with khaang2 ‘chin’, which is pronounced with a high rising tone. Pitch contour is hereby occupied with the function of distinguishing between lexical items (e.g., s`ua1 ‘mattress’ versus s`ua5 ‘shirt’) in the same sense that segments are (e.g., s`ua1 ‘mattress’ versus th`ua1 ‘occasion’). Many languages (e.g., English) differ from Lao in that they do not employ pitch contour for lexical contrast. In those languages, pitch contour is free to be exploited for expressing pragmatic meaning at the utterance level (independent of lexical content), such as distinctions of information structure or connotation. For example, consider how the pitch contour of English What? (versus What!!?) can mark a difference between a simple request for repeat of an unheard utterance (‘Sorry, could you repeat what you just said’) versus an expression of astonished disbelief (‘Oh God, really? I can hardly believe it!’; cf. Selting 1996). There are arguments that pragmatic meaning conveyed by pitch in this way is based on iconicindexical relations between pitch properties of vocal calls and properties
On the relationship between particles and tone
73
of the vocal cavity, and hence the individual that produces the signal. Ohala’s ‘frequency code’ (Ohala 1984, Gussenhoven 2004) attempts to explain in these terms why, for example, statements tend to be falling in pitch while questions tend to be rising. It is argued that high or rising pitch conveys weakness or submissiveness by indexing the smaller vocal cavity required in producing it, while low falling pitch indexes assertion, authority or dominance by indexing a larger vocal cavity (and hence a more dominant beast). Since in tone languages, pitch is occupied with maintaining lexical contrast, it is often thought that tone languages are unable to exploit pitch contour for natural meaning in this way. This is certainly true at the lexical level, where words of large open classes like nouns or verbs have fixed tones, independent of any conceivable non-arbitrary relation between their pitch shape and their meaning. Lao speakers have little room for variation when required to maintain contrasts like khii3 ‘bamboo flower’ versus khii5 ‘shit’, muu1 ‘friend’ versus muu3 ‘pig’, or kaj3 ‘far’ versus kaj4 ‘near’. But sentence-final particles seem to be different in this respect. They show greater freedom in surface realization of pitch contour. This is especially noticeable because of their syntactic position. Sentence-final particles are relatively exposed, being in a clause-final, syntactically open position, and typically taking full stress. A possible analysis of the sentence-final particles as a special lexical class is that they are under-specified for tone, picking up their pitch contours from the kinds of natural principles of iconic-indexical motivation that determine pragmatically meaningful pitch contours in non-tonal languages. For example, the basic polar question particle b`oo` 3 is given here as being of Tone 3 (low rising), but in fact it may be given other kinds of tones— high falling, low falling, high rising, level—with accordingly different nuances. A possible conclusion from these kinds of expressive manipulation of the pitch of sentence-final particles is that they differ from other word classes in not being specified for tone at all. Rather, they are perhaps ‘blank’ with respect to lexically-specified tone, permitting variation of pitch contour along naturally motivated, pragmatically expressive principles.
Part III Nominals and Reference
Chapter 5 Pronouns There are two systems of pronouns, definite and indefinite. Definite pronouns are mostly personal pronouns which show distinctions in person (first, second, third), number (singular, plural), and social level (bare, familiar, polite, and formal, among further distinctions). The third person bare pronoun may also be used for definite reference to inanimates. Indefinite pronouns show no distinctions for social level, distinguishing only between persons, non-persons, and places. These also function as interrogative pronouns.
5.1
Definite pronouns
The system of definite, personal pronouns is elaborated on socially deictic lines, comparable to other complex systems found in South and Southeast Asia (Cooke 1968, Howell 1968, Geoghegan 1970, Levinson 1977). Table 10 illustrates the basic system. It is far more elaborate than a typical European system (cf. Brown and Gilman 1960, Ervin-Tripp 1986), with four levels of politeness for all persons in the singular, and two levels in the plural: Table 10. Lao Personal Pronouns (partial set) 1st person 2nd person SG Bare ( B ) kuu3 m`ung2 too3 Familiar (FA) haw2 kh`oo` j5 caw4 Polite (P) khaa5-phacaw4 thaan1 Formal (FO) PL Bare phuak4-kuu3 suu3 Polite cu-haw2 (incl.) cu-caw4 cu-kh`oo` j5 (excl.) phuak4-caw4
3rd person man2 laaw2 phen1 thaan1 khaw3 khacaw4
Some of the pronouns given in the table as singular are in fact not semantically marked for singular, but may allow plural readings. Third person polite phen1 and first person familiar haw2 may be used with plural or singular reference. Accordingly, they are glossed with number un-
78
Pronouns
specified (as 3. P and 1. FA, respectively). When third person bare man2 refers to things (rather than people), it does not specify number. (None of the other third person pronouns may refer to things.) Accordingly, man2 is glossed as 3. B, with number unspecified. It is important to note that the set given in Table 10, and discussed in this section, is not exhaustive. The system of definite person reference is not a closed one. It is highly flexible, and permeable. There are many strategies of person reference beyond those illustrated in Table 10, including special forms reserved for specific social contexts (e.g., qatamaa2 ‘self’ as a first person pronoun used by monks in talking to lay people, ph`oø-q`oo` k5 and m`eø-q`oo` k5 for reference to lay men and women, respectively) or special uses of existing forms (e.g., too3 for ‘I’ and phen1 for ‘you’ among familiar friends, typically young women). (Cf. Rehbein 2007.) It is also possible to use certain types of nouns not only for address but for first, second, and third person reference, including kin terms (‘brother’, ‘uncle’, ‘grandchild’), occupation or other role terms (‘teacher’, ‘monk’, ‘lay person’, ‘doctor’, ‘comrade’), and personal names. These are distinct from the pronouns in that their reference doesn’t shift as a function of who utters them. Different speech levels articulated by different pronouns index the relative status of interlocutors, expressing different degrees of familiarity, sometimes related to facts of biography (e.g., respect forms used for strangers, people of specific age differences), or socially determined relative position (e.g., role and status, usually most marked in religious settings, such as when speaking with monks). Essentially, the use of different pronouns marks differences in social height (cf. Enfield 2005a). When a Lao speaker makes definite pronominal reference to a person, she cannot avoid implying or explicitly encoding some stance toward the social relationship(s) between speaker, addressee, and referent. The attributes implied by these pronouns are not simply observable properties of their referents (e.g., number, sex) but are defined relationally, implicating the speaker herself in the calculation. Syntactically, personal pronouns differ from nouns in that they cannot be heads of noun phrases with demonstrative determiners, they cannot be heads of possessive constructions, they cannot be direct complements of the copula verb pˆen3, they cannot enter into numeral classifier constructions, and they cannot take modifiers linked by the relativizer thii1.
Definite pronouns
5.1.1
79
Bare pronouns
Within the large set of Lao personal pronouns the lowest (i.e., most informal, intimate) forms can be analyzed as bare or semantically unmarked. This is in contrast to other, more polite forms which speakers have the option to use in the same grammatical contexts. The bare forms pick up their ‘low’ meanings by systematic opposition to forms which explicitly mark social relationships (e.g., of politeness). They are semantically simple expressions whose pragmatic richness comes from their being nested at the locus of a set of complex cultural and linguistic/semantic interactions. Lao bare form pronouns are semantically simpler than their counterparts listed as familiar, polite, and formal in Table 10. While more general in meaning, they remain pragmatically potent, being the most exposing (or, more accurately, least covering) forms for personal reference (cf. Cooke 1968:13, Onishi 1994:362-366, Wierzbicka 1994:447-449). In those cases where the bare forms kuu3 ‘I’ and m`ung2 ‘you’ would be used by default, they pass without notice. Their use in other situations may be highly inappropriate, bizarre, or insulting. Here are some typical occasions of use of the bare first and second person pronouns kuu3 and m`ung2: · Reciprocally, between children or youths of the same age (give or take a year), and between adults of the same age who have a longterm close relationship going back to childhood (often including adjacent siblings) · Non-reciprocally, ‘downwards’ in highly unequal relationships (e.g., from grandmother to grandchild, prison officer to prisoner) · In denigrating, aggressive, insulting, scolding language (e.g., in arguing angrily) · In (quoted) inner speech, talking to oneself Here is an example from an exchange between close friends in the same class at school, where no marking of social distance is required: (97)
kuu3 jaan4 m`ung2 1 SG . B afraid 2 SG . B ‘I was afraid of you.’
80
Pronouns
A second example is from the (quoted) speech of a woman who is trying to chase a man (a junior relative) away, and is showing him none of the respect he would usually be given by a stranger or someone lower than him in his kin network: (98) n˜ ak1 maa2 nii4, m`ung2 taaj3 dˆej2 ogre come here 2 SG . B die FAC . NEWS ‘(If) the ogre comes here, you’ll die you know.’ Next is an example of the bare first person pronoun used in reported inner speech. This is a character’s exclamation (to himself), having arrived home to find that the spectacles he had bought from a Chinese merchant had not enabled him to read (as he had hoped): (99) cˆek2 niø, man2 tom4 kuu3 l`ee` w4 chinaman TPC 3. B boil 1 SG . B PRF ‘This Chinaman, he has “boiled” me!’ (i.e., has cheated me) In another example, a speaker is quoting his own thoughts, when alone: (100)
bah2, kuu3 siø thot1-l`oo` ng2 khaj3 beng1 b`oo` 3 INTJ 1 SG . B IRR test-try open see QPLR ‘Bah! Should I try opening (this box) to have a look inside?’
The status of m`ung2 ‘you’ as semantically unmarked for respect is illustrated in the following example, in which the speaker is calling out to a dog, who has stolen his sausages. He has no need to linguistically encode social respect of any kind: (101)
m`ung2 qaw3 paj3 loot4 2 SG . B take go NO . HES ‘You go ahead and take (them)!’
There is a common thread in the use of bare pronoun forms in unguarded, intimate talk, downward-oriented talk, angry talk, and self talk. This common thread is that the speaker chooses not to employ one of the available terms which marks respect, thus indexically conveying a stance of non-respect, giving off the idea ‘I’m not doing a display of respect for
Definite pronouns
81
you’.1 Interpretation of this message differs from context to context, not because there are multiple meanings to these terms, but because different expectations apply in different situations, that is, different ways of speaking are (un)expected in different contexts.
5.1.1.1
Speaker attitudes to the bare pronouns kuu3/ m`ung2
Non-reciprocal use of the pronouns kuu3 and m`ung2 varies regionally and socio-economically. For a speaker to use these pronouns in a broader array of contexts may be taken as an index of lower willingness to use higher forms, considered by many to indicate lower education or lack of cultural sophistication. Many speakers (counterfactually) deny using them at all. Extensive dialect variation in usage of these pronouns leads to social and cultural misunderstandings among Lao speakers from different regions of the country. In more rural (less gentrified) situations, there are fewer distinctions of pronominal level. Many rural dwellers would never have occasion to use formal pronouns such as first person khaa5phacaw4 and second person thaan1. Urban people recount with utter disdain stories of minority people in Laos who are said to use kuu3/m`ung2 or their equivalent when addressing their own parents. While bare form pronouns can be pragmatically bad (i.e., rude), they are not intrinsically bad words (i.e., they are not curses or swear words). It can be insulting to use them with reference to certain people in certain contexts, but it is not necessarily considered rude to use them with reference to appropriate others IN THE PRESENCE of a respected other (cf. Cooke 1968:13). In fact, there is a certain warmth indexed by the 1
Cooke’s (1968) comprehensive description of the set of pronominal forms in Thai presents a detailed inventory of situations of use. Cooke identifies the Thai equivalents of kuu3 and m`ung2 as ‘nonrestraint’ forms, since they ‘imply a degree of freedom from the restraints of more proper usage’ (Cooke 1968:11), ‘suggesting a certain defiance of or nonconformity to underlying standards of more proper usage’ and implying ‘an intimacy expressive of interpersonal freedom and relaxation which allows the taking of certain liberties’ (ibid., p34). Despite Cooke’s calling this a ‘semantic feature’, he brilliantly describes the mechanism by which its effect arises not through semantic coding but through pragmatic contrast: nonrestraint is ‘the individual’s felt and expressed defiance or disregard of certain standards of proper, polite, or refined usage laid down by society’ (ibid., p62). That is, the bare term says what it says by what it DOESN ’ T say, given what is expected (Grice 1975).
82
Pronouns
reciprocal usage of kuu3/m`ung2 between close friends, since it defines a long-term and completely unguarded relationship. Similarly, it would not be considered rude to use the bare ‘I’ form kuu3 when quoting one’s own thoughts or other usage in some context in which the use of the term is pragmatically unmarked. An intriguing dimension to the bare form terms, and generally to the system of definite pronouns, is the extreme contrast between their complete ordinariness when occurring in the right context, and the deeply visceral responses they elicit when occurring in the wrong contexts, whether this happens by error or by design. Inappropriate use of kuu3/m`ung2 can create serious offence, anger, embarrassment, even paralyzing mirth.2 The third-person singular counterpart of kuu3 ‘I’ and m`ung2 ‘you’ is man2 ‘he/she/it’. This form conveys its meaning via the same logic of bare semantics: refraining from explicitly conveying respect can convey either disrespect or intimacy, depending on whether there is a current expectation to show respect by choosing an appropriate respect form. Man2 is typically used with reference to children and youths (but often not for toddlers; see section 5.1.3, below). It may also be used with reference to adults with whom you would use kuu3/m`ung2 in direct interaction, or to whom you would otherwise have no stake in publicly showing respect (for example, actors on television).
5.1.1.2
Inclusory construction in bare third person plural
The third person bare plural pronoun khaw3 ‘they’ occurs in an inclusory construction which adjoins the pronoun with the name of a person who is included in the set of people denoted by the pronoun: (102)
(103)
2
khaw3 qiø-kham2 paj3 saj3 go INDEF. PLACE 3 PL . B F. B-K ‘Where did Kham and them go?’ kuu3 hˆen3 khaw3 bakø-ph`ee` ng2 juu1 talaat5 be.at market 1 SG . B see 3 PL . B M . B-P ‘I saw Pheng and them at the market.’
See Howell (1968:556-557) on the crushing emotional consequences of having to maintain linguistic observance of relative age in Korean.
Definite pronouns
83
While this construction is common, it is not a productive strategy across the pronominal system. Constructions parallel to (102-103) using pronouns in other persons or social levels are easily imagined, but they do not occur. The third person plural bare pronoun is the only pronoun which enters into the inclusory construction.
5.1.2
Familiar pronouns
The familiar pronouns retain a sense of informality, but encode a moderate degree of respect. They may be used, for example, with reference to people who are well known (e.g., fellow villagers) outside one’s immediate family and circle of very close acquaintances. Good friends who are not bosom buddies since childhood might reciprocally use the pronouns too3/haw2 rather than the overly intimate or exposed kuu3/m`ung2. Within the family, a son or daughter may soften the formality of the child-parent relationship by using the first person familiar haw2 for ‘I’ when speaking to their parents (although they would never correspondingly use second person familiar too3 for ‘you’ in referring to a parent). Their parents may use either the familiar too3 (affectionate) or bare m`ung2 in return.
5.1.3
Polite pronouns
The first and second person polite pronouns are kh`oo` j5 ‘I’ and caw4 ‘you’. The gist of their meanings can be derived from their etymology: kh`oo` j5 ‘slave’ lowers the self (humble I); caw4 ‘lord’ raises the other (exalted you). These pronouns are all-purpose in urban public life, and are the first forms taught to learners of Lao, giving outsiders the impression that they represent the basic, unadorned meanings ‘I’ and ‘you’. However, this is neither pragmatically nor semantically the case. The pronouns kh`oo` j5 and caw4 provide the safest ways of saying ‘I’ and ‘you’ among people with generically distant relationships (e.g., strangers), since these pronouns convey a broad and versatile sense of respect, one that is outside of the kin network into which familiar references are typically fitted. Those who reciprocally use kh`oo` j5 ‘I’ and caw4 ‘you’ include adult strangers, husband and wife couples, people whose relationship is neither especially formal nor especially informal (e.g., a mother talking to her
84
Pronouns
child’s school teacher). These pronouns are sometimes used between parents and children who are showing respect for some context-specific reason (e.g., due to the presence of certain overhearers). For example, when making third person reference to their son-in-law while he is present, parents-in-law might use polite phen1 instead of bare form man2 for ‘he’. The third person polite form phen1 encodes polite respect as is appropriate for people one doesn’t know well, or those in socially higher positions (teachers, officials, etc.). This form is also often used with reference to toddlers, particularly in narrating things they have said or done. The meaning of phen1 that makes it appropriate to both these types of situation is that the referent is ‘someone whose actions are not to be criticized’ (cf. Wierzbicka 1992). High status people are immune to criticism for political reasons, while toddlers are not to be criticized for their (often culpable!) actions because toddlers don’t know any better.
5.1.4
Formal pronouns
Formal pronouns are reserved for special occasions such as giving public speeches, or interactions with especially highly ranked people such as abbots or government ministers. They also occur in written and in mass media contexts (e.g., radio interviews). Like the polite pronouns, formal pronouns are based on a logic of lowering the self (khaa5-phacaw4 means ‘slave of the Lord’) and raising the other (thaan1 means ‘exalted one’).
5.2 5.2.1
Indefinite pronouns Core indefinite pronominal forms
Three indefinite pronominal forms may appear in core argument slots. Two of these are free pronouns which may occur as independent noun phrases. These two pronouns distinguish between the basic ontological categories of things and persons. They are n˜ ang3 ‘something, anything, what’ (INDEF. INAN) and phaj3 ‘someone, anyone, who’ (INDEF. HUM). (There is also a simple indefinite form for place: saj3 ‘somewhere, anywhere, where’ (INDEF. PLACE).) A third indefinite form is not a free pronoun but a general indefinite specifier which attaches to any nominal head
Indefinite pronouns
85
to derive an indefinite pronominal expression. This marker is daj3 ‘some, any, which’ (INDEF). For example, in (104a-c), daj3 occurs as an indefinite specifier with the three basic modifier classifiers, yielding complex indefinite pronominal forms distinguishing between the categories human, animate and inanimate: (104)
a. phuø-daj3 MC . HUM - INDEF ‘some/any/which person’ b. toø-daj3 MC . ANIM - INDEF ‘some/any/which animate entity’ c. qanø-daj3 MC . INAN - INDEF ‘some/any/which thing’
Or daj3 may occur with any other nominal head, usually a classifier (see Chapter 7): (105)
daj3 a. khan2 CLF. VEHICLE INDEF ‘some/any/which vehicle’ b. h`uan2 lang3 daj3 house CLF. FRAME INDEF ‘some/any/which house’ c. talaat5 daj3 market INDEF ‘some/any/which market’
We therefore have three core indefinite pronominal forms which may function generally as core arguments: (106)
a. n˜ ang3 ‘something/anything/what’ (INDEF. INAN) b. phaj3 ‘someone/anyone/who’ (INDEF. HUM) c. N -daj3 ‘some N, any N, which N’ (INDEF)
Indefinite pronominal forms serve different referential functions depending both on grammatical context and information structural context.
86
Pronouns
Beyond their basic, indefinite referential function, they often function as interrogatives (‘what?’, ‘who?’, ‘which?’). However, it is not necessary to propose distinct interrogative meanings for them (cf. Wierzbicka’s 1980 notion of ‘ignorative’). If they function as interrogative pronouns, this is attributable to factors in the information structural context. Two main points support this. First, indefinite reference is semantically simpler than interrogative reference, and is always incorporated within the more complex semantics of interrogatives. ‘Who?’ presupposes ‘someone’. It means ‘someone, I don’t know who’ (mutatis mutandis for ‘what’, ‘which’, ‘where’, etc., cf. Wierzbicka 1996). By standard amplicative mechanisms of pragmatic implicature (Grice 1975, Levinson 1983, 2000, Sperber and Wilson 1995), interrogative utterance-level meaning is yielded straightforwardly from indefinite sentence-level semantics. Whichever interpretation indefinite pronominal expressions are given, they always convey AT LEAST the invariant meaning ‘INDEF’ (i.e., ‘some/any X’). Second, there are almost no structural contexts in which the indefinite pronouns MUST be read as interrogative, while there are multiple structural contexts in which only indefinite readings are possible, and interrogative readings are unavailable. Where indefinite pronouns may have two interpretations (interrogative ‘who?’, ‘what?’, ‘which N’? versus indefinite ‘someone’, ‘something’, ‘some N’), discourse context determines the right interpretation. Consider the following example, in which n˜ ang3 ‘INDEF. INAN’ in nonsubject position in a simple clause can be read either as ‘what?’ or ‘something’: (107)
juu1 k`oo` ng4 tiang3 phen1 hˆen3 n˜ ang3 3.P see INDEF. INAN be.at underneath bed i. ‘What did she see underneath the bed?’ ii. ‘She saw something underneath the bed.’
This ambiguity is contextually resolved. When supplied out of context, speakers prefer the interrogative reading as in (107i). But in the right context, the non-specific reading (107ii) is pragmatically unmarked. The difference is a function of information structure properties of discourse. The two readings of (107) are associated with different scope of pragmatic focus. If the referent of the indefinite pronoun is the narrow focus of the sentence, the pronoun is likely to be interpreted as interrogative. So, if it has already been established in the discourse of (107) that she
Indefinite pronouns
87
has seen something under the bed, then n˜ ang3 ‘INDEF. INAN’ will be in narrow focus (everything else in the proposition is presupposed), and will then most likely be taken in the interrogative reading. If, on the other hand, all the information in (107) were new to the discourse, then there would be no narrow focus on the referent of n˜ ang3 ‘INDEF. INAN’, and the sentence would serve to introduce the referent rather than question its identity, giving the (107ii) reading. Another way of biasing the interpretation through manipulation of information structure is to vary the person of the subject. If a subject is first person, normally the speaker will be taken to have primary access to the propositional content of what is being said, and an interrogative interpretation is less likely: (108)
juu1 k`oo` ng4 tiang3 kh`oo` j5 hˆen3 n˜ ang3 1SG . P see INDEF. INAN be.at underneath bed i. ‘What did I see underneath the bed?’ (less likely interpretation) ii. ‘I saw something underneath the bed.’ (strongly preferred interpretation out of context)
In contrast to (108), if a subject is second person, the speaker LACKS primary access to the propositional content of what is being said, and an interrogative interpretation is more likely, as in example (109): (109)
juu1 k`oo` ng4 tiang3 caw4 hˆen3 n˜ ang3 2SG . P see INDEF. INAN be.at underneath bed i. ‘What did you see underneath the bed?’ (strongly preferred interpretation out of context) ii. ‘You saw something underneath the bed.’ (less likely interpretation)
There are contexts in which interrogative readings of the indefinite pronouns are unavailable. These are situations in which interrogative illocutionary force is blocked, for example, by factive complement-taking verbs such as huu4 ‘know’ in (110) or factive sentence-final particles such as the news-giving particle dˆej2 in (111):
88 (110)
Pronouns
kh`oo` j5 huu4 vaa1 phen1 hˆen3 n˜ ang3 juu1 k`oo` ng4 1SG . P know COMP 3.P see INDEF. INAN be.at underneath tiang3 bed ‘I know that she saw something underneath the bed.’ (Or: ‘I know what she saw underneath the bed.’) (NOT: ‘I know what did she see underneath the bed?’)
juu1 k`oo` ng4 tiang3 dˆej2 (111) phen1 hˆen3 n˜ ang3 3.P see INDEF. INAN be.at underneath bed FAC . NEWS ‘She saw something underneath the bed, you know.’ (NOT: ‘What did she see underneath the bed, you know?’) Having established these basic properties of indefinite pronouns, we now further explore their syntactic treatment in different argument slots, using phaj3 ‘INDEF. HUM’ as an example. (The basic facts hold, mutatis mutandis, for other indefinite pronouns.) As outlined above, a bare indefinite pronoun in non-subject function has two readings, indefinite and interrogative: (112)
juu1 talaat5 caw4 hˆen3 phaj3 2 SG . P see INDEF. HUM be.at market i. ‘Who did you see at the market?’ ii. ‘You saw someone at the market.’
In subject function, the same two readings are available, where the indefinite reading is non-referential ‘anybody’: (113)
hˆen3 caw4 juu1 talaat5 INDEF. HUM see 2 SG . P be.at market i. ‘Who saw you at the market?’ ii. ‘Anybody/everybody saw you at the market.’ phaj3
With negation, the indefinite reading of phaj3 in subject function is translated as ‘nobody’: (114)
b`oø hˆen3 caw4 juu1 talaat5 INDEF. HUM NEG see 2 SG . P be.at market i. ‘Nobody saw you at the market.’ ii. ‘Who didn’t see you at the market?’ phaj3
Indefinite pronouns
(115)
89
b`oø kaa4 phaan1-khaam5 bak2-siang2 dajø INDEF. HUM NEG dare pass-cross M . B -S ACHV th`oo` 1 n˜ aj2 extent web i. ‘Nobody dared to cross Siang even the width of a spider web.’ (intended interpretation in original context) ii. ‘Who didn’t dare to cross Siang even the width of a spider web?’ (possible interpretation) phaj3
The indefinite interpretation is forced by use of the topic linker kaø (cf. examples (113, 115)): (116)
hˆen3 caw4 juu1 talaat5 see 2 SG . P be.at market ‘Anybody/everybody saw you at the market.’ (NOT: ‘Who saw you at the market?’) phaj3
kaø
INDEF. HUM T. LNK
(117)
phaj3
kaø
b`oø kaa4 phaan1-khaam5 bak2-siang2 M . B -S dare pass-cross
INDEF. HUM T. LNK NEG
dajø th`oo` 1 n˜ aj2 ACHV extent web ‘Nobody dared to cross Siang even the width of a spider web.’ (NOT: ‘Who didn’t dare to cross Siang even the width of a spider web?’) The interrogative reading is also unavailable when an indefinite pronoun appears in an extraclausal slot, such as Left Position, as in the following example: (118)
nam2 qaw3 n`oo` ng4 maø haj5, siø m`oo` p4 INDEF. HUM retrieve take y G DIR . ALL give IRR hand.over m`uang2 haj5 loot4 kingdom give NO . HES ‘Whoever retrieves my little sister and brings her to (me), (I’)ll hand over my kingdom to (them) right away.’
phaj3
Although indefinite pronouns can occur in sentence-initial position, as these examples show, it is more common for an indefinite pronoun in subject function to be introduced by the presentational verb mii2 ‘there is’, as shown here:
90 (119)
Pronouns
mii2 phaj3 hˆen3 caw4 juu1 talaat5 there.is INDEF. HUM see 2 SG . P be.at market i. ‘Who saw you at the market?’ ii. ‘There is someone who saw you at the market.’
An effect of introducing the indefinite subject with the presentational verb mii2 in (119) is that the indefinite reading is referential (as opposed to the non-referential, open reading in (113ii), above). This is expected, given that sentence-initial mii2 has a general function of introducing new referents in discourse (see Chapter 8). A similar construction to that shown in (119) uses the copula m`ee` n1 instead of the presentational mii2: (120) m`ee` n1 phaj3
hˆen3 caw4 juu1 talaat5 COP INDEF. HUM see 2 SG . P be.at market ‘Who is it that saw you at the market?’
Example (120) does not allow an indefinite reading. This is one of the only cases in which the indefinite pronoun must be read as interrogative. By introducing the indefinite subject with the copula m`ee` n1, (120) conveys the idea that there is presumed to be a specific someone who saw you at the market. By contrast, using the more general presentational verb mii2, example (119i) asks who saw you, but allows for the possibility that in fact nobody saw you. A way of narrowing in on the referential indefinite interpretation which accompanies a referent’s first mention in discourse is to replace the simpler pronoun with a complex expression combining the general indefinite specifier daj3 ‘INDEF’ with the specifier n`ung1 ‘one’ (cf. (112), above): (121)
man2 hˆen3 phuø-daj3 phuø-n`ung1 juu1 talaat5 3. B see MC . HUM - INDEF MC . HUM-one be.at market ‘She saw someone at the market.’ (NOT: ‘Who did she see at the market?’)
This complex indefinite expression may also appear in subject function, but in that case it is obligatorily introduced by the presentational verb mii2 ‘there is’ (unlike the free pronoun phaj3 ‘INDEF. HUM’; cf. (113) and (119), above):
Indefinite pronouns
91
(122)
phuø-n`ung1 hˆen3 caw4 juu1 talaat5 mii2 phuø-daj3 there.is MC . HUM - INDEF MC . HUM-one see 2 SG . P be.at market ‘Someone saw you at the market.’
5.2.2
Other indefinites and question words
There are further indefinite expressions, beyond those listed in (106), above. Most of these involve the general indefinite specifier: (123)
a. saj3 INDEF. PLACE
b.
c.
d.
e.
f.
‘somewhere, anywhere, where’ b`oo` n1-daj3 place-INDEF ‘some place, any place, which place’ t`oo` n1-daj3 time.period-INDEF ‘some time, any time, which time’ m`uu` 4-daj3 day-INDEF ‘some day, any day, which day’ n`ee` w2-daj3 kind-INDEF ‘some kind, any kind, which kind’ cang1-daj3 manner-INDEF ‘somehow, anyhow, how’
‘Why?’ can be expressed in two ways. The expression pˆen3-˜nang3 ‘why?’ is a combination of the copula pˆen3 and the indefinite inanimate pronoun n˜ ang3. In this way, ‘Why?’ is literally expressed as ‘What is it?’. Pˆen3-˜nang3 ‘why?’ occurs sentence-initially: (124)
pˆen3-˜nang3 caw4 b`oø dajø thaam3 man2 WHY 2 SG . P NEG ACHV ask 3. B ‘Why didn’t you ask him?’
92 (125)
Pronouns
pˆen3-˜nang3 khaw3 n˜ aang1 m`ua2 WHY 3 PL . B walk return ‘Why are they walking back?’
A second way to ask ‘why?’ is to use the verb kh`uu` 2—otherwise meaning ‘to be like’—in a pre-negation position: (126)
caw4 kh`uu` 2 b`oø dajø thaam3 man2 3. B 2 SG . P WHY NEG ACHV ask ‘Why didn’t you ask him?’ (127) khaw3 kh`uu` 2 n˜ aang1 m`ua2 3 PL . B WHY walk return ‘Why are they walking back?’
Chapter 6 Nominal modification Nominal modifiers generally follow their heads: (128)
khon2 suung3 person tall ‘tall person’
(129)
din3 laaw2 soil Lao/Laos ‘Lao soil’
(130)
khaw5 niaw3 rice sticky ‘sticky rice’
There are apparent exceptions to the usual head-modifier order. This may be illustrated with reference to body part terms. Among non-simple body part terms, a majority of noun-noun (N1-N2) compounds follow the usual head-modifier order, featuring the ‘larger whole’ as modifier (N2), where the other component (whose referent is part of or connected to or located at or otherwise associated with the whole) is head, i.e., N1. The following examples involve dang3 ‘nose’ in N2 position, as modifier: (131)
a. kˆeeˆ ng3 dang3 ‘area between nose and upper lip’ (adjacent to the nose, below it) b. piik5 dang3 ‘nose wing’ (part of the nose) c. khii5 dang3 ‘nose shit’ (inside the nose)
Some of the complex body part terms are exceptional in that the order of elements shown in (131) is reversed. In these exceptional cases, the whole entity of which the referent is associated is denoted by N1, not N2. This is inconsistent with the usual status of N1 as phrasal head (cf. English forearm, which is not an arm, but part of an arm): (132)
a. naa5 phaak5 ‘forehead’ (lit. ‘forehead face’) b. kh`ee` n3 s`oo` k5 ‘elbow’ (lit. ‘elbow arm’)
94
Nominal modification
c. d. e. f. g.
khaa3 tooj4 ‘thigh’ (lit. ‘thigh leg’) khaa3 phap1 ‘back of knee’ (lit. ‘fold(ing) leg’) kon4 khii5 ‘anus’ (lit. ‘shit(ting) arse’) taa3 dam3 ‘pupil’ (lit. ‘black eye’) th`oo` ng4 n`oo` j4 ‘lower belly’ (lit. ‘small belly’)
This pattern is also attested in other areas of the nominal lexicon. For example: khaj1 d`ee` ng3 ‘yolk’ (lit. ‘red egg’); khaj1 khaaw3 ‘egg white’ (lit. ‘white egg’); tom4 paa3 ‘boiled fish’ (lit. ‘fish boil’); piing4 siin4 ‘grilled meat’ (lit.‘meat grill’). (Cf. Enfield 2006d.)
6.1
Possession
Possession is marked either by simply adjoining the possessor and possessee (with possessee first), or by connecting the two explicitly using the word kh`oo` ng3, which elsewhere means ‘things, stuff’. While there is no fixed formal distinction between alienable and inalienable possession, the inalienable type is less likely to be overtly marked. This accords with principles of natural ‘iconicity’ or motivation (Haiman 1985). (133)
taa3 (kh`oo` ng3) kh`oo` j5 eye of 1 SG . P ‘my eye(s)’
(134)
m`ee` 1 (kh`oo` ng3) caw4 mother of 2 SG . P ‘your mother’
(135)
miit4 (kh`oo` ng3) m`oo` 3 nan4 knife of bloke DEM . NONPROX ‘that bloke’s knife’
6.1.1
External possession
Certain grammatical constructions involving reference to a person and some part of that person’s body express a relationship of possession external to the noun phrase (Chappell and McGregor 1996). In these cases,
Possession
95
the possessor and possessee do not appear within a single noun phrase, and there is no morphological expression of the possessive relationship. One type of construction is formally like a transitive sentence. This is of the form NP1 V NP2, where the verb predicates either an action or an experience involving a part of the body, NP1 is a person, and NP2 is the relevant body part (cf. Clark 1996). More specific instantiations are: NP1AGENT (PERSON) V NP2THEME (BODY PART) (136)
phen1 m`uu` n2 taa3 3. P open.eye eye ‘He opened (his) eyes.’ khiw4 (137) kuu3 n˜ ik1 1 SG . B raise.eyebrow eyebrow ‘I raised (my) eyebrows.’ NP1EXPERIENCER (PERSON) V NP2LOCUS (BODY PART)
(138)
phen1 khan2 khaa3 3. P itch leg ‘He itches (in the) legs.’ (139) kuu3 cˆep2 lang3 1 SG . B sore back ‘I (have a) sore back.’
The construction entails a relation of possession of the body part by the grammatical subject. It is not possible to be sore in someone else’s back. It is not possible to use the verb m`uu` n2 ‘open (the eyes)’ to describe someone opening someone else’s eyes. The experience-denoting construction exemplified in (138) and (139) is not a regular transitive construction. A verb phrase such as khan2 khaa3 ‘itch leg’ (in which khaa3 ‘leg’ is not an undergoer but a locus of experience) can itself take an additional nominal complement describing the stimulus of the experience. This structure incorporates a body part into a multi-participant predication, with roles corresponding to experiencer, locus of experience, and stimulus, in that order. (140)
maj1 phen1 khan2 khaa3 phaø-hom1 CT. CLOTH -blanket new 3. P itch leg ‘He itches (in the) legs (from his) new blanket.’
96
Nominal modification
A second type of construction takes the following form: NP1THEME (HUMAN) NP2BODY PART VADJECTIVE This has the shape of a topic-comment construction (Li and Thompson 1976), in which a noun phrase in initial position is followed by what looks like a full clause with its own nominal subject and adjectival predicate. In an example, kuu3 ‘I’ is in initial position as the extraclausal topic or setting for the assertion phom3 dam3 ‘(the) hair (is) black’: (141)
kuu3 phom3 dam3 1 SG . B hair black ‘I am black-haired.’ (lit. ‘I, hair black’.)
Here is another example: (142)
luuk4 caw4 khaa3 n˜ aaw2 child 2 SG . P leg long ‘Your child is long-legged.’ (lit. ‘Your child, legs long.’)
This differs from a typical topic-comment construction in that the sequence ‘NPBODY PART V’ functions as a verbal predicate in itself, where verbal aspectual-modal marking may appear directly on the noun phrase: (143)
luuk4 caw4 b`oø khaa3 n˜ aaw2 child 2 SG . P NEG leg long ‘Your child isn’t long-legged.’
Superficially similar constructions cannot do this, instead requiring aspectual-modal marking to appear directly on the verb, as shown in (144c; cf. 142-143): (144)
a. ton4 sak2 baj3 n˜ aj1 tree teak leaf big ‘The teak tree (has) big leaves.’ b. * ton4 sak2 b`oø baj3 n`oo` j4 tree teak NEG leaf small (The teak tree (does) not (have) small leaves.) c. ton4 sak2 baj3 b`oø n`oo` j4 tree teak leaf NEG small ‘The teak tree (does) not (have) small leaves.’
Determiners
6.2
97
Determiners
Determiners are expressed as part of the nominal phrase, usually involving classifier constructions. They attach to the head nominal, which will be the classifier, if one is present (see Chapter 7). The patterns for determiners are NOUN - DETERMINER or NOUN CLASSIFIER - DETERMINER. Nii4 is the semantically unmarked member of a set of demonstratives, including one other demonstrative modifier nan4 (nonproximal), along with three spatially deictic adverbials phii4 ‘here’, han5 ‘there’, and phun4 ‘yonder’. By being in pragmatic opposition to the nonproximal demonstrative nan4, nii4 may adopt a proximal meaning (see below). The term diaw3-kan3 ‘the same’ (morphemically analyzable as a combination of diaw3 ‘single, alone’ and the collaborative marker kan3) is a modifier of nominals, in the frame ‘the same person/thing/place/time’. Here are two examples: (145)
(146)
juu1 t`oo` n3 diaw3-kan3, qaa3naa2cak2 laaw2-theng2 hanø TPC . DIST be.at place single- COLL kingdom Lao-above diaw3-kan3, kaø b`oø kh`uu` 2-kan3 dˆej2 single-COLL T. LNK NEG like-COLL FAC . NEWS ‘The Lao Theung live in the same place (as us), the same kingdom (as us), (but we are) not alike, you know.’ pˆen3 sap2 vitha˜nasaat5 q`uu` n1 l`eq1 saa3maat4 p`ee` 3 translate COP words science other and ABLE kham2-sap2 diaw3-kan3 naø kaø daj4 dˆej2, T. LNK CAN FAC . NEWS words single-COLL TPC . PERIPH ‘And it’s possible to translate (them) as terms from other sciences, you know—the same words.’
This does not correspond to the English expression the same in the frames ‘X is the same as Y’ and ‘X and Y are the same’ (cf. Goddard and Wierzbicka 2002). English the same in this adverbial frame refers not to identity but to close likeness in some respect. This cannot be expressed in Lao using diaw3-kan3. It is expressed instead using kh`uu` 2 ‘like’: (147) m`ung2 khu` u2 ` kuu3 2 SG . B like 1 SG . B ‘You are like me.’ (cf. English: You are the same as me.)
98
Nominal modification
(148)
m`ung2 kap2 kuu3 khu` u2 ` kan3 2 SG . B with 1 SG . B like COLL ‘You and I are alike.’ (cf. English: You and I are the same.)
6.2.1
Syntactic dependence of determiners
Determiners in Lao do not appear as substantive heads. They are dependent on some nominal head. Most commonly, or by default, the nominal head to which determiners attach is the maximally general inanimate modifier classifier qanø. For example, the demonstrative nii4 ‘this’ cannot appear alone if it is to refer to a thing. It appears as qanø-nii4 (literally ‘this one’ or ‘this thing’). dii3 (149) qanø-nii4 MC . INAN - DEM good ‘This (thing) is good.’ (150) * nii4 dii3 DEM good (This is good.) (151) man2 vaw4 qanø-nii4 3. B say MC . INAN-DEM ‘She said this (thing).’ (152) * man2 vaw4 nii4 3. B say DEM (She said this.) While nii4 never appears alone meaning ‘this’, it may appear alone with other meanings. For example, as a complement of juu1 ‘be at’ or maa2 ‘come’, nii4 may mean ‘here’: (153) maa2 nii4 come DEM ‘Come here!’ (154) laaw2 b`oø dajø hˆet1 juu1 nii4 3 SG . FA NEG ACHV do be.at DEM ‘She didn’t do (it) here.’
Determiners
99
Nii4 sometimes appears in preverbal position, usually with strong prosodic marking (stressed, often followed by a marked pause). Such usage picks out a salient referent, usually present in the physical context. In the following examples, the sentence-initial nii4 has an attention-drawing function, referring to something physically present: siø daj4 (155) nii4 laø, phuø-nii4 DEM PRF MC . HUM - DEM IRR CAN ‘Here, this person will be able (to do it).’ qoo3lalit1 (156) nii4 m`ee` n1 namø-jaa3 DEM COP CT. LIQUID -medicine O ‘This here is Oralite medicine.’ Example (156) is spoken by a puppeteer holding up sachets of ‘Oralite’ brand rehydration salts in front of an audience of school children, and introducing a demonstration of how they are used. Similarly, diaw3-kan3 ‘the same’ may not appear without being attached to a nominal head. One cannot say ‘I did the same’, but instead must say ‘I did the same thing’: diaw3-kan3 kuu3 hˆet1 qanø 1 SG . B do MC . INAN single-COLL ‘I did the same (thing).’ (158) * kuu3 hˆet1 diaw3-kan3 1 SG . B do single-COLL (I did the same.)
(157)
In ‘the same’ expressions of this kind, a second argument is marked with the addition of the relational particle kap2 ‘with’: (159)
kuu3 hˆet1 qanø diaw3-kan3 kap2 m`ung2 1 SG . B do MC . INAN single-COLL with 2 SG . B ‘I did the same (thing) as you.’
6.2.2
Demonstratives
None of the five demonstrative elements may appear independently as agent or undergoer noun phrases (as for nii4, above). Only two—nii4
100
Nominal modification
and nan4— are genuine demonstrative determiners, since only these two can generally be used as nominal modifiers in simple noun phrases like ‘this book’. This puts nii4 and nan4 in paradigmatic opposition, with consequences for their semantic analysis (see Enfield 2003a). Table 11. Demonstrative determiners Form Function Gloss nii4 general (‘this’) DEM nan4 nonproximal (‘that’) DEM . NONPROX
Table 12. Demonstrative adverbs Form Function phii4 proximal (‘here’) han5 distal (‘there’) phun4 far distal (‘yonder’)
Gloss DEM . PROX DEM . DIST DEM . FAR
Since nii4 is semantically more general, it may be used in a wider number of contexts. That is, nii4 is used for things which are both near and far (or, both ‘here’ and ‘not here’), while the marked terms are more restricted. Nii4 is semantically general than the other terms (see Enfield 2003a for evidence and further references). Nan4 specifies that the referent is something ‘not here’. Phun4 specifies that the referent is not only ‘not here’, but ‘far away’ in addition. Note that these are not literally distinctions of distance. What matters is where a referent stands in relation to conceived spatial perimeters. These conceived perimeters emerge from factors of the interaction, including active areas of conversational or practical engagement, physical features of the interactional space, and assumptions about addressees’ access to relevant information for inference (Enfield 2003a).
6.2.3
Topic markers
A set of enclitic topic markers attach to noun phrases, marking current topicality. Noun phrases that are marked in this way will often also be placed in an extraclausal (Left or Right) position. Accordingly, they cannot mark referents which are in focus (e.g., new or in contrast).
Determiners
101
Table 13. Topic markers Form Function Gloss Related demonstrative niø general TPC nii4 ‘general/proximal demonstrative’ nanø nonproximal TPC . NONPROX nan4 ‘nonproximal demonstrative’ hanø distal TPC . DIST han5 ‘distal demonstrative’; ‘there’ phunø far TPC . FAR phun4 ‘far distal demonstrative’; ‘yonder’ naø peripheral TPC . PERIPH (possibly nan4 ‘nonproximal’)
While the topic markers are transparently related to demonstratives, they are distinct. This is demonstrated by the possibility of co-occurrence of demonstrative and topic marker in a single noun phrase (in the order NOUN – DEMONSTRATIVE – TOPIC - MARKER ), as shown here: (160)
qacaan3 khon2 nii4 niø teacher CLF. HUM DEM TPC ‘this teacher (that we are talking about)’ nan4 hanø (161) khuu2-baa3 qong3 CLF. HOLY DEM . NONPROX TPC . DIST monk ‘that monk (that we are talking about)’
While a nominal marked by a demonstrative such as nii4 may be new to the discourse or may be in contrastive focus (‘THIS one, not that one’), a nominal marked by a topic marker such as niø must be already given, or otherwise presupposed in the discourse. (162) khon2 suung3 nii4 DEM person tall ‘this tall person’ (this one here; or this tall person, as opposed to that tall person) (163) khon2 suung3 niø TPC person tall i. ‘the tall person’ (who we have already been talking about) ii. ‘tall people’ The (163ii) reading can be regarded as ‘given’ in that it is exhaustive of a reference set which is accessible independent of the discourse (cf. Giv´on 1984). The following examples show these noun phrases (squarebracketed) in core argument functions:
102
Nominal modification
(164)
[khon2 suung3 nii4] salaat5 DEM clever person tall ‘These tall people are clever.’ (e.g., when contrastive or pointing out in context) (165) [khon2 suung3 niø] salaat5 TPC clever person tall i. ‘Tall people are clever.’ ii. ‘The tall people are clever.’ In an example of the general topic marker niø, the speaker is telling a joke about a man who never learned how to read. The man receives a letter, but can’t read what it says. He has noticed that every time his neighbor reads a letter, he puts on spectacles in order to do so. So, the man goes to the market to buy a pair of spectacles, thinking that when he puts them on, he will be able to read. He arrives home with his new spectacles, only to find that he still can’t read the letter, and goes back to the shop to complain: (166)
[v`ee` n1-taa3 caw4 niø] qaan1 nangs`uu` 3 b`oø daj4 glass-eye 2 SG . P TPC read writing NEG CAN ‘(With) the spectacles (of) yours, (I’m) unable to read.’
In this example, the noun phrase v`ee` n1-taa3 caw4 ‘your spectacles’ is marked by the general topic marker niø, marking the referent as topical in the discourse and relatively proximate in discourse activation. In another example, a speaker describes a traffic accident involving a motorcycle and a bicycle. The speaker has already introduced the two vehicles and their riders. In remarking that nobody was seriously hurt, his references to both individuals take the general topic marker niø:
Determiners
(167)
103
s`oo` n4 b`oø cˆep2 nak2, t`ee` 1 vaa1 [phuø NEG hurt heavy but COMP MC . HUM passenger niø] fong4 paj3, t`ee` 1 vaa1 laaw2 lotø-cak2 CT. VEHICLE -motorcycle TPC spill go but COMP 3 SG . FA b`oø cˆep2 nak2, NEG hurt heavy niø] kaø lom4 lotø-thiip5 paj3 [phuø MC . HUM CT. VEHICLE -bicycle TPC T. LNK fall.over go s`uø-s`uu` 1 NOT. MORE ‘(They) weren’t seriously injured, but [the one who was the passenger on the back of the motorcycle] spilled over, but (she) wasn’t seriously injured. [The one on the bicycle] just fell over.’
The following example features the nonproximal topic marker nanø. The speaker describes a kingdom ruled by the king Kutsalat and an adjacent worlds of ogres and gods. A powerful ogre named Kumphan is as yet unmarried. When Kumphan’s soldiers visit the earthly kingdom, they learn that the king’s gorgeous youngest sister is also as yet unmarried: (168)
hˆen3, m`ua1 sˆeeˆ 3naa2 kh`oo` ng3 n˜ ak1 kum3phan2 maø DIR . ABL see when soldiers of ogre K vaw4 suu1 [˜nak1 kum3phan2 nanø] fang2, pajø DIR . ALL speak to TPC . NONPROX listen ogre K n˜ ak1 kum3phan2 thaam3 haa3 s`uu` 1 ogre K ask seek name ‘The soldiers of the ogre Kumphan came and saw (her). When (they) went and told [the ogre Kumphan] (about her), the ogre Kumphan asked after (her) name.’
While the ogre Kumphan is explicitly mentioned in the first line of (168), he is embedded in a noun phrase modifier (as possessor) and is not an argument of that clause. When he is introduced in the next clause as a core argument (non-subject), marking is with the nonproximal nanø. Next is an example with the distal topic marker hanø. The speaker describes the occasion of sighting a bargain at the market. He begins, ‘After I came out of the market, right, I saw a turkey, a really big one. And there was a hen too.’ He has now introduced two turkeys into the discourse, a male and a female. His interest is the large, male turkey. He
104
Nominal modification
adds, taking the focus off the two turkeys: ‘I then consulted with my wife, “Should we buy (it)?”, I said.’ At this point, the speaker is now going to make reference to the male turkey. Not only is this referent slightly distant from the current interaction (thanks to the intervening change of focus), there are now two turkeys in the current discourse record. This makes the male turkey relatively distal as a discourse referent. Accordingly, this reference is marked with the distal topic marker hanø: (169)
hanø] [toø-phuu5 vaa1 [kaj1-nguang1 hanø], chicken-turkey TPC . DIST MC . ANIM-male TPC . DIST COMP sip2-haa5-phan2 ten-five-thousand ‘That turkey, that male one, (the price) was 15,000.’
Finally, the topic marker naø is termed ‘peripheral’ not because of its meaning, but because of its special syntactic position. It may co-occur with the other topic markers, in a distinct slot, further from the head (cf. examples (160-161), above): nii4 niø naø (170) qacaan3 khon2 teacher CLF. HUM DEM TPC TPC . PERIPH ‘this teacher (that we are talking about)’ nan4 hanø naø (171) khuu2-baa3 qong3 CLF. HOLY DEM . NONPROX TPC . DIST TPC . PERIPH monk ‘that monk (that we are talking about)’ Like the other topic markers, naø not only marks noun phrases, but may also mark topicalized phrases of other kinds (e.g., left-positioned phrasal topics, clausal afterthought phrases; see example (174), below, among many other examples throughout this book).
6.3 6.3.1
Quantifiers Baang3 ‘some’, n`ung1 ‘one’, s`oo` ng3 ‘two’
The quantifiers baang3 ‘some’, n`ung1 ‘one’, and s`oo` ng3 ‘two’, (as well as laaj3 ‘much/many’ and met2 ‘all’; see below) combine with substantive heads. Baang3 ‘some’, s`oo` ng3 ‘two’, and laaj3 ‘much/many’ pre-
Quantifiers
105
cede the nominal, while n`ung1 ‘one’ may precede or follow (met2 ‘all’ is an adverbial with distinct grammar; see below): (172)
baang3 qan3 [some CLF. INAN] ‘some things’ n`ung1 khon2 [one CLF. HUM] ‘one person’ khon2 n`ung1 [CLF. HUM one] ‘one person’ s`oo` ng3 suan1 [two part] ‘two parts’ laaj3 qan3 [many CLF. INAN] ‘many things’
The first two examples below show baang3 ‘some’ preceding the nominal it quantifies: baang3 khon2, khaw3 kaø nii3 paj3 m`uang2-thaj2, some people 3 PL . B T. LNK flee go country-Thai baang3 khon2 kaø paj3 falang1, some people T. LNK go France baang3 khon2 kaø paj3 qaa3mˆeeˆ 2likaa3 some people T. LNK go America ‘Some people, they fled to Thailand, some people went to France, some people went to America.’ (174) baang3 b`oo` n1, khacaw4 b`oø kin3 p`ee` ng4-nua2 naø TPC . PERIPH some place 3 PL . P NEG eat MSG ‘(In) some places they don’t eat MSG.’
(173)
The next two examples show n`ung1 ‘one’ in the more common pattern of appearing after the nominal it modifies (in contrast to the other quantifiers): (175)
(176)
khang4 diaw3 pasaa2son2 kheej2 hˆet1 pii3 nung1 ` EXP do year one occasion single citizens ‘The people are accustomed to doing (the rice harvest) a single time in one year.’ mii2 t`ee` 1 song5 sik2 l`ee` w4 b`oø mii2 n˜ ang3, exit.monkhood PRF NEG have INDEF. INAN have only pants qee5, s`ua5 toø-nung1, qee5 toø-nung1, ` ` MC . ANIM -one INTJ shirt MC . ANIM -one INTJ ‘Having left the monkhood, (I) didn’t have anything, (I) only had one pair of pants, uh-huh, and one shirt, uh-huh.’
106
Nominal modification
Here are examples of s`oo` ng3 ‘two’ as a quantifier, appearing before the nominal it quantifies (the first example showing that the attached nominal is the classifier, if one is present): kap2 ngen2 qaw3 huup4 s`oo` ng3 baj3 CLF. LEAF with money take picture two ‘(I) take (along) two photographs, and money (to arrange a visa).’ (178) maw2 h`ee` ng2, laaw2 laø n`oo` n2 s`oo` ng3 m`uu` 4, b`oø t`uu` n1 day NEG awaken drunk strong 3 SG . FA PRF sleep two leej2 NO . ADO ‘(He) was really drunk, and so he slept for two days, without waking up at all.’
(177)
Like nii4 ‘this’, and diaw3-kan3 ‘the same’, discussed above, neither n`ung1 ‘one’ nor s`oo` ng3 ‘two’ can be used as nominal heads in themselves. Expressions like mii2 s`oo` ng3 ‘There are two’ are possible, but must have a definite or otherwise contextually retrievable referent for the thing being counted (i.e., the noun phrase head is understood as ellipsed due to definiteness). Selective expressions like ‘two of these people’ or ‘one of these things’ utilize the extraclausal Left Position in a kind of topic-comment construction (Li and Thompson 1976, 1981). A common use of the topiccomment construction involves a possessive relation, with the possessor in left position, and the possessed being the subject of the verb in the comment clause: (179) ph`oo` 1 kh`oo` j5 khaa3 hak2 father 1 SG . P leg break ‘My father’s leg is broken.’ (lit. ‘(Of) my father, leg is broken.’) The same structure forms a selective construction, where the full set (from where the subset will be selected) appears in Left Position, and the subset is specified immediately after, in preverbal subject position: (180) khon2 (law1) nii4, s`oo` ng3 khon2 jaak5 paj3 people want go person (group) DEM two ‘Two of these people want to go.’ (lit: ‘(Of) these people, two people want to go.’)
Quantifiers
107
The quantifiers n`ung1 ‘one’ and s`oo` ng3 ‘two’ (as well as the determiner q`uu` n1 ‘other’) can be easily combined with nii4 ‘this’, with a maximal expansion NUM - N - OTHER - DEM: (181)
khon2 q`uu` n1 nii4 person other DEM ‘these other people’ (182) phuø-q`uu` n1 nii4 MC . HUM -other DEM ‘this other person’ (183) s`oo` ng3 qanø-nii4 MC . INAN - DEM two ‘these two things’ (184) s`oo` ng3 khon2 q`uu` n1 nii4 two person other DEM ‘these two other people’
6.3.2 thuk1 ‘every’ and t`ee` 1-laø ‘each’ The quantifiers thuk1 ‘every’ and t`ee` 1-laø ‘each’ both occur with a relevant numeral classifier (cf. Chapter 7): (185)
lot1 th`uu` k1 kak2 thuk1 khan2 vehicle suffer confiscate every CLF. VEHICLE ‘Every one of the vehicles got confiscated.’
(186)
lot1 th`uu` k1 kak2 t`ee` 1-laø khan2 CLF. VEHICLE vehicle suffer confiscate each ‘Each one of the vehicles got confiscated.’
While example (185) conveys the idea that all the vehicles were confiscated, example (186) highlights the process happening ‘one-by-one’. The expression t`ee` 1-laø is a combination of t`ee` 1 ‘only’ and laø ‘each, per’. The term laø ‘each, per’ connects a classifier and some measure (cf. English ten dollars per person), as in the following example:
108 (187)
Nominal modification
khacaw4 th`uu` k1 maj3, khon2 laø s`ee` n3 3 PL . FA suffer fine CLF. HUM per hundred.thousand ‘They got fined, one hundred thousand per person.’
In a further construction for expressing similar meaning, suu1 marks both the subject and the predicate (cf. Chapter 13, section 13.2.1 for discussion): (188) suu1 khon2 suu1 maw2 each person each drunk ‘Each (one) of them was drunk.’
6.3.3 Laaj3 ‘much/many’ A term which functions as both a quantifier and an adjectival modifier is laaj3 ‘much/many’. It commonly functions as a regular quantifier, appearing before the nominal (usually the classifier) it quantifies, as in (189). It also may function as a regular stative verb ‘to be much/many’, as in (190). juu1 kh`oo` k4 n`ojø-n`oo` j4 (189) kaj1 laaj3 too3 RDP. A -small chicken many CLF. ANIM be.at pen ‘Many chickens are in a small-ish pen.’ (190) juu1 nii4 khon2 laaj3 be.at DEM person many ‘There are a lot of people here.’ (lit. ‘Here, the people are many.’) Also, laaj3 ‘much/many’ may appear separated from the nominal it refers to, with an adverbial function, as follows: (191)
man2 mii2 qˆen3 juu1 nii4 laaj3 naø 3. B there.is tendon be.at DEM much TPC . PERIPH ‘There were lots of tendons here.’ (i.e., on an old man’s neck.)
Since laaj3 ‘much/many’ can have the properties of a verb, it may appear in noun phrases after the noun quantified, in a kind of modifier adjective function. For example, ‘many people’ may be expressed as either
Quantifiers
109
laaj3 khon2 ‘many people’ or khon2 laaj3 ‘people (which are) many’. (The latter could be a complete sentence meaning ‘There are many people’.) Consider the contrast between laaj3 ‘many’ as an independent adverbial complement (192a) and as a nominal modifier (192b, NP bracketed): (192)
a. khon2 nii4 vaw4 laaj3 person DEM say much ‘This person spoke a lot.’ b. khon2 nii4 vaw4 [laaj3 l`uang1] person DEM say many matter ‘This person said many things.’
There is no identifiable semantic distinction between laaj3 as ‘much’ and laaj3 as ‘many’. The difference in English translation seems to depend on the nature or construal of the nominal being quantified. A mass noun combination such as khaw5 laaj3 [rice much/many] is translated as ‘much rice’ (or ‘a lot of rice’), while a count noun combination such as lot1 laaj3 [vehicle much/many] is translated as ‘many vehicles’. Nominals which are open to both mass and count interpretations may allow either. For example, kaj1 laaj3 [chicken much/many] could be either ‘many chickens’ or ‘much chicken’ (‘a lot of chicken’). One grammatical constraint which emerges from the inherent lexical class distinction between mass and count nouns involves the use of laaj3 ‘much/many’ in pre-nominal position, where it may only mean ‘many (of a countable thing)’. Thus, the countable nominal lot1 ‘vehicle’ may take laaj3 ‘much/many’ either pre- or post-nominally (but note that (193b) is less idiomatic than lot1 laaj3 khan2 [vehicle many CLF] ‘many vehicles’): (193)
a. lot1 laaj3 vehicle much/many ‘a lot of vehicles’ b. laaj3 lot1 much/many vehicle ‘many vehicles’
However, to express the idea of a large quantity of some non-countable mass, such as khaw5 ‘rice’, laaj3 ‘much/many’ may only be used postnominally. If laaj3 ‘much/many’ were to appear pre-nominally with such
110
Nominal modification
a mass noun, the only possible reading would involve construal of the mass noun as something countable (cf. English many rices, i.e., ‘many (kinds of) rice’): (194)
a. khaw5 laaj3 rice much/many ‘a lot of rice’ b. laaj3 khaw5 much/many rice ‘many (kinds of) rice’ (NOT: ‘a lot of rice’)
This behavior does not demonstrate that laaj3 itself has multiple meanings, but rather appears to be due to properties of different types of nominals (i.e., mass versus count).
6.3.4 Met2 ‘all’ The term met2 as an independent verb means ‘run out, finished, exhausted, complete’ as in (195). With the meaning ‘all’, met2 may have an adverbial function, appearing after the verb phrase it has scope over, as in (196) and (197). (195)
khaw5 met2 l`ee` w4 rice exhausted PRF ‘(The) rice is all finished.’ (196) b`oo` k5 n`eq1-nam2 met2 tell advise all ‘(He) gave (them) all instructions.’ (197) muu1 taaj3 met2 peer die all ‘All (his) peers died.’ To express notions like ‘everything’ and ‘everyone’, met2 ‘all’ occurs with indefinite pronouns n˜ ang3 ‘INDEF. INAN’ and phaj3 ‘INDEF. HUM’, but cannot be used as a specifier with the modifier-classifier heads phuø‘MC . HUM’ and qanø- ‘MC . INAN’:
Quantifiers
(198)
(199)
111
met2 a. kuu3 hˆen3 nang3 ˜ 1 SG . B see INDEF. INAN all ‘I saw everything.’ b. * kuu3 hˆen3 qanø-met2 1 SG . B see MC . INAN-all (I saw everything.) a. phaj3 met2 huu4 qanø-nii4 INDEF. HUM all know MC . INAN-DEM ‘Everyone knows this.’ b. * phuø-met2 huu4 qanø-nii4 MC . HUM -all know MC . INAN - DEM (Everyone knows this.)
Negation may be added to such a construction to give ‘nobody’ (i.e., not anybody). Note that this cannot be read as ‘Not everyone knows this’. (200)
met2 b`oø huu4 qanø-nii4 INDEF. HUM all NEG know MC . INAN - DEM ‘No-one knows this.’ (i.e., ‘Anyone doesn’t know this.’)
phaj3
With negation, and an indefinite pronoun like phaj3 ‘someone’, it is common to also use the topic linker kaø, which rules out an interrogative reading of the pronoun and gives a reading ‘nobody’, as in (201). With neither met2 ‘all’ nor the topic linker kaø, the combination of negation and the indefinite pronoun phaj3 ‘INDEF. HUM’ remains ambiguous, as in (202). (201)
(202)
kaø b`oø huu4 qanø-nii4 INDEF. HUM T. LNK NEG know MC . INAN - DEM ‘No-one knows this.’ phaj3 b`oø huu4 qanø-nii4 INDEF. HUM NEG know MC . INAN - DEM i. ‘No-one knows this.’ ii. ‘Who doesn’t know this?’
phaj3
See Chapter 5 for more discussion of this point.
112 6.4
Nominal modification
Relativization
Nouns can be modified by relative clauses. To illustrate the structure of relativization, we may begin with a full clause. Take, for example, a transitive clause with a verb and two core arguments: (203)
qaaj4 kh`oo` j5 khaa5 kaj1 eBr 1 SG . P kill chicken ‘My brother killed a chicken.’
To relativize upon the object argument of (203), use that argument as a noun phrase head (in noun phrase initial position), and use what remains of the original clause as a modifier. The relative clause modifier (RC) and the full noun phrase (NP) are square-bracketed: (204)
[kaj1 [qaaj4 kh`oo` j5 khaa5]RC ]NP 1 SG . P kill chicken eBr ‘the chicken my brother killed’
The (204) structure may then be used as an ordinary noun phrase argument, for example: khaw3 siø s`uu` 4 [kaj1 [qaaj4 kh`oo` j5 khaa5]RC ]O 1 SG . P kill 3 PL . B IRR buy chicken eBr ‘They’re going to buy the chicken my brother killed.’ (206) [kaj1 [qaaj4 kh`oo` j5 khaa5]RC ]A t`oo` t5 muu1 laaj3 phoot4 1 SG . P kill peck others much excessive chicken eBr ‘The chicken my brother killed pecked the others too much.’
(205)
Here are two further examples of noun phrases with relative clause modifiers: (207)
maø qeen4 [thaw5 [khon3 f`uu` n2]RC ]O nanø call bloke transport firewood TPC . NONPROX DIR . ALL kin3 nam2 m`ee` 4 eat with IMP. UNIMP ‘Call that bloke (who was) transporting firewood to come and eat with (us)!’
Relativization
(208)
113
mii2 t`ee` 1 [lot1 [falang1 thiaw1]RC ]S there.is only vehicle French tour ‘There were only cars (that) Frenchmen toured (in).’
A relativized-upon nominal head may also be referred to with the appropriate classifier (usually a modifier classifier phuø- ‘MC . HUM’, toø‘MC . ANIM’, or qanø- ‘MC . INAN’), as in the following examples, derived from (203): [qaaj4 kh`oo` j5 khaa5]RC ]NP [toø MC . INAN e B r 1 SG . P kill ‘the one my brother killed’ (210) [phuø [khaa5 kaj1]RC ]NP MC . HUM kill chicken ‘the one (who) killed a chicken’ (209)
In the above examples, the relative clause is adjoined directly after the noun phrase head which it modifies. It is also possible (but never obligatory) for it to be joined to the head by an explicit relativizer, thii1. This is historically a locative meaning ‘place’. (Thii1 is also used as an ordinal numerator, as in h`uan2 thii1 s`oo` ng3 [house ORD two] ‘the second house’.) The following shows example (204) with the relativizer included: (211)
[kaj1 thii1 [qaaj4 kh`oo` j5 khaa5]RC ]NP 1 SG . P kill chicken REL eBr ‘the chicken which my brother killed’
Note that there is another relativizer—s`ung1—which is less common than thii1, and which is pragmatically marked as being more formal or learned. It is also possible for any classifier which relates appropriately to the head or referent to explicitly mark the relation between head and modifying relative clause. For example, in (212), the head of the noun phrase in O function is makø-muang1 ‘mango’. Accordingly, it is linked by nuaj1, a numeral classifier for fruits (among other typically round assemblages), to the relative clause which acts as its modifier:
114 (212)
Nominal modification
kh`oo` j5 siø kin3 [makø-muang1 nuaj1 [suk2 k`oo` n1 1 SG . P IRR eat CT. FRUIT-mango CLF. UNIT ripe before muu1]RC ]O others ‘I will eat the mango that is riper than the others.’
In another example, the head of the noun phrase in S function is p`um4 ‘book’. Accordingly, it is linked by hua3 ‘head’, a numeral classifier for books (among other things such as bulbs and tubers), to the relative clause which acts as its modifier: (213)
[kh`oo` j5 s`uu` 4 juu1 talaat5]RC ]S ph`ee` ng2 [p`um4 hua3 expensive book CLF. HEAD 1 SG . P buy be.at market laaj3 very ‘The book that I bought at the market was very expensive.’
In these examples, the relevant numeral classifiers (nuaj1 and hua3) could felicitously be replaced with thii1, but unlike these classifiers, thii1 would show no semantic agreement with the head. It is possible to relativize upon core arguments S, A, and O (as shown in (214a, b, c), respectively), as well as non-core arguments (as shown in (214d)). In these examples, the complex noun phrase (presented here as an S argument of paj3 ‘go’ in the main clause) consists of a head noun, followed by an optional relativizer thii1, followed by the relative clause as modifier. A zero shows where the head would have been in the source clause: (214)
a. [khon2i (thii1) [Øi l`ee` n1]RC ]S siø b`oø paj3 person REL run IRR NEG go ‘The person (who) was running will not be going.’ b. [khon2i (thii1) [Øi hˆen3 caw4]RC ]S siø b`oø paj3 person REL IRR NEG go see 2 SG . P ‘The person (who) saw you will not be going.’ c. [khon2i (thii1) [caw4 hˆen3 Øi ]RC ]S siø b`oø paj3 person REL 2 SG . P see IRR NEG go ‘The person (who) you saw will not be going.’
Relativization
115
d. [khon2i (thii1) [caw4 qaw3 huup4 haj5 Øi beng1]RC ]S siø person REL 2 SG . P take picture give look IRR b`oø paj3 NEG go ‘The person (who) you showed a picture to will not be going.’ There is no relativization on a possessor along the lines of the man whose car you stole, but this is straightforwardly done by means of a resumptive pronoun in the slot where the original noun phrase is from: (215)
[khon2i (thii1) [caw4 lak1 lot1 laaw2i ]RC ]S siø b`oø paj3 person REL 2 SG . P steal car 3 SG . FA IRR NEG go ‘The person (who) you stole his car will not be going.’
Note that such a resumptive pronoun would be fine in the ‘Ø’ slot of any of the examples (214 a-d), above (cf. non-prescriptive but occurring English examples like the person who he saw you, the person who you saw him, the person who you showed a picture to him): [khon2i (thii1) [laaw2i l`ee` n1]RC ]S siø b`oø paj3 person REL 3 SG . FA run IRR NEG go ‘The personi (who) hei ran will not be going.’ (217) [khon2i (thii1) [laaw2i hˆen3 caw4]RC ]S siø b`oø paj3 person REL 3 SG . FA see 2 SG . P IRR NEG go ‘The personi (who) hei saw you will not be going.’ (218) [khon2i (thii1) [caw4 hˆen3 laaw2i ]RC ]S siø b`oø paj3 person REL 2 SG . P see 3 SG . FA IRR NEG go ‘The personi (who) you saw himi will not be going.’ (219) [khon2i (thii1) [caw4 qaw3 huup4 haj5 laaw2i beng1]RC ]S siø person REL 2 SG . P take picture give 3 SG . FA look IRR b`oø paj3 NEG go ‘The personi (who) you showed a picture to himi will not be going.’ (216)
Here is a text example: (220)
[phuak4i thii1 [khacaw4i toon3 paj3]RC nanø]NP group REL 3 PL . FA escape go TPC . NONPROX ‘thosei who theyi fled’
116
Nominal modification
A relativized-upon argument must be phonologically realized somewhere in the noun phrase structure (i.e., no headless relative clauses allowed). The relativizer itself cannot be the head of a noun phrase with a relative clause modifier (see also Chapter 14, section 14.3.2): (221) * (thii1) [Øi l`ee` n1]RC siø b`oø paj3 REL run IRR NEG go ((Who) ran will not be going.) (222) * (thii1) [Øi hˆen3 caw4]RC siø b`oø paj3 REL see 2 SG . P IRR NEG go (Who) saw you will not be going.) (223) * (thii1) [caw4 hˆen3 Øi ]RC siø b`oø paj3 REL 2 SG . FA see IRR NEG go ((Who) you saw will not be going.) (224) * (thii1) [caw4 qaw3 huup4 haj5 Øi beng1]RC siø b`oø paj3 REL 2 SG . FA take picture give look IRR NEG go ((Who) you showed a picture to will not be going.) While the option of ellipsis is widespread in Lao, this is a case in which it is not allowed.1 One regular function of relativization may be termed a light verb construction. A relativized-upon argument becomes main clause subject of the copula verb pˆen3. This copula verb then takes as its nominal complement a complex noun phrase with a relative clause modifier. For example, ‘My brother killed a chicken’ ((203), above) becomes ‘My brother is (the) one (who) killed a chicken’: [khaa5 kaj1]RC ]NP (225) qaaj4 kh`oo` j5 pˆen3 [phuø chicken eBr 1 SG . P COP MC . HUM kill ‘My brother is (the) one (who) killed a chicken.’ In (225), the subject of the relative clause is also the main sentential subject. The effect of this kind of raising is to express contrastive focus 1
In other kinds of cases, ellipsis is mandatory. For example, same-subject control complement constructions (Chapter 19) stipulate that the lower complement subject (coreferential with the matrix subject) cannot be overtly expressed.
Relativization
117
(as if it has been suggested that someone else killed the chicken), or selection from among a set (as if someone has asked who from among a group of people my brother is). In cases where the relativized-upon argument is not a subject, the light verb construction brings it into main subject position: qaaj4 kh`oo` j5 pˆen3 [khon2 (thii1) [caw4 hˆen3 Øi ]RC ]NP eBr 1 SG . P COP person REL 2 SG . P see ‘My brotheri is the personi (who) you saw Øi .’ (227) qaaj4 kh`oo` j5 pˆen3 [khon2 (thii1) [caw4 qaw3 huup4 eBr 1 SG . P COP person REL 2 SG . P take picture haj5 Øi beng1]RC ]NP look give ‘My brother is the personi (who) you showed a picture to Øi .’ (226)
Here are some text examples of the light verb construction: haw2 pˆen3 [phuø [maa1 khaw5]RC ]NP [phuø [n`ung5 MC . HUM steam 1. B COP MC . HUM soak rice khaw5]RC ]NP qiik5 dˆej2 rice more FAC . NEWS ‘I was the one who soaked the rice, the one who steamed the rice in addition, you know.’ (229) sumun2thaa2 pˆen3 [khon2 thii1 [ngaam2 n˜ ing1]RC ]NP COP person REL beautiful extremely S ‘Sumunthaa was a person who was extremely beautiful.’ (230) caw4 th`uu` 3 vaa1 pˆen3 [khon2 thii1 [deen3-thaang2 phit2 2 SG . P hold COMP COP person REL march-way against kot2-maaj3]RC ]NP law ‘You would be regarded as someone who is traveling against the law.’ (228)
Another example illustrates the possibility of omitting the copula pˆen3. The complex noun phrase is a verbless clause complement (cf. Chapter 10, section 10.1.1):
118 (231)
Nominal modification
phuø-daj3 kaø [phuø [siø qaw3 sivit1 maø MC . HUM - INDEF T. LNK MC . HUM IRR take life DIR . ALL l`ee` k4-pian1]RC ]NP exchange ‘Each of them (were) someone who would exchange their life (for the other).’
Chapter 7 Nominal classification Lao features four systems of nominal classification: numeral classifiers, modifier classifiers, class terms, and kin prefixes. Numeral classifiers form a large set (up to 100 members), and include repeaters, thus constituting an open class. The Lao numeral classifier system is a typologically prototypical one, with dozens of classifiers making fine semantic distinctions in the context of enumeration. A modifier classifier system involves the use of classifiers in nominal modification of all kinds, including demonstratives (in situational or discourse deixis and anaphora), attributive modifiers (such as adjectives and relative clauses), and a unitizing construction resembling noun classifier constructions found in other languages. While many numeral classifiers may be used in this function, many of the usual numeral classifier distinctions are not observed, and in most cases just two classifiers are used (procliticized modifier classifiers derived from too3 ‘body’ and qan3 ‘small thing’). The assignment to nouns of these two classifiers in numeral classifier constructions is constrained by shape/form specific semantics, but when they are used as modifier classifiers, their semantics are more abstract. Class terms form a smallish set (twenty or so members). The class term system is lexically derivational, with hundreds of nouns incorporating a prefixed term expressing taxonomic essence (e.g., whether the noun denotes a tree, insect, some kind of liquid, and so on). Kin prefixes are a limited set of kinship terms which combine with personal names to derive person reference forms and terms of address. We discuss these sub-systems in turn. Nominal classification is more a matter of syntactic construction than of form class membership. Nouns in general may become classifiers by appearing in certain constructional slots, as described in following sections. Those nouns which function most often as classifiers are relatively general in meaning. Their syntactic properties divide them into separate sub-classes and sub-functions.
120 7.1
Nominal classification
Numeral classifiers
Lao numeral classifiers show properties of typologically prototypical numeral classifier systems (cf. Aikhenvald 2000:98ff, Grinevald 2000:6364). That is, they ‘appear contiguous to numerals in numeral noun phrases and expressions of quantity’ and ‘do not have to appear on any constituent outside the numeral NP’ (Aikhenvald 2000:98). Numeral classifiers are a well-noted areal feature of mainland Southeast Asia, and the Lao system is a typical one.
7.1.1
The basic numeral classifier construction
The following example illustrates the standard pattern for enumerating countable entities, in which a noun phrase consists of the main noun (which names the thing being counted)1 followed by the numeral and an appropriate numeral classifier: (232) kuu3 s`uu` 4 paa3 s`oo` ng3 too3 CLF. ANIM 1 SG . B buy fish two ‘I bought two fish.’ The classifier used here is too3, which is also used as a numeral classifier for animals of all kinds (but not humans), and which as a main noun means ‘body’ (and in that usage can refer to the body of a person as well as an animal). The numeral and classifier form a unit distinct from the main noun in the noun phrase, as shown by the possibility of inserting an adjunct between the main noun and the numeral-plus-classifier combination: (233)
1
kuu3 s`uu` 4 paa3 juu1 talaat5 s`oo` ng3 too3 CLF. ANIM 1 SG . B buy fish be.at market two ‘I bought fish at the market, two (of them).’ (= ‘I bought two fish at the market.’)
I use the term ‘main noun’ to refer to the semantically specific nominal which names the referent. The term ‘head’ is problematic. Grammatically, the head of the noun phrase is probably the classifier element (since it is obligatory, and is the element which hosts most if not all nominal marking such as specifiers, determiners, modifiers, etc.; cf. Sackmann 2000 on Mandarin Chinese). Semantically, head is a more appropriate term for the main noun, with its more specific meaning.
Numeral classifiers
121
In this case, the phrase s`oo` ng3 too3 ‘two CLF. ANIM’ is separated from the noun it is semantically associated with, and is placed into Right Position. This is a perfectly normal way of saying ‘I bought two fish at the market’, and has nothing of the pragmatically marked quality shown by the first English free translation given in (233). Further demonstration of the independence of the main noun from the numeral-plus-classifier combination is that the main noun can be (and very often is) ellipsed, when the referent is contextually retrievable: (234) kuu3 s`uu` 4 s`oo` ng3 too3 CLF. ANIM 1 SG . B buy two ‘I bought two (e.g., fish).’ Note that when the numeral is n`ung1 ‘one’, two orders are possible for numeral and classifier. (235)
(236)
kuu3 s`uu` 4 paa3 n`ung1 too3 1 SG . B buy fish one CLF. ANIM ‘I bought one fish.’ n`ung1 kuu3 s`uu` 4 paa3 toø 1 SG . B buy fish MC . ANIM one ‘I bought a fish.’
No other numeral allows the classifier-numeral ordering given in example (236).2 As the English translations of examples (235) and (236) suggest, when the numeral n`ung1 ‘one’ appears after the classifier, it functions as a determiner (i.e., a non-specific marker of a singular entity), appearing in the same slot as demonstratives. Thus, in (236), the classifier is functioning as a modifier classifier (see section 7.2, below), and, accordingly, it is de-stressed in that position. While numeral classifiers are virtually obligatory when counting things, speakers may very occasionally omit the classifier:3 (237)
2
kuu3 s`uu` 4 paa3 s`oo` ng3 1 SG . B buy fish two ‘I bought two fish.’
Almost all nominal modifying elements follow the noun, unlike numerals greater than one. Rare exceptions include quantifiers such as baang3 ‘some’ (as in baang3 khon2 [some person/people] ‘some people’). See Chapter 6. 3 It is unclear why speakers omit the classifier in these cases.
122
Nominal classification
However, in the context of asking ‘how many’—using cak2 ‘how many’ in the pre-classifier numeral position—a classifier is obligatory: (238)
(239)
too3 m`ung2 s`uu` 4 (paa3) cak2 2 SG . B buy fish how.many CLF. ANIM ‘How many (fish) did you buy?’ * m`ung2 s`uu` 4 (paa3) cak2 2 SG . B buy fish how.many (How many did you buy?)
Note also that a number of other quantifiers, such as baang3 ‘some’, thuk1 ‘every’, t`ee` 1-laø ‘each and every’ also require numeral classifiers, appearing in the same constructional pattern as numeral classifier expressions: (240)
(241)
(242)
7.1.2
kuu3 s`uu` 4 (paa3) baang3 too3 1 SG . B buy fish some CLF. ANIM ‘I bought some (of the fish).’ kuu3 s`uu` 4 (paa3) thuk1 too3 1 SG . B buy fish every CLF. ANIM ‘I bought every one (of the fish).’ kuu3 s`uu` 4 (paa3) t`ee` 1-laø too3 1 SG . B buy fish each.and.every CLF. ANIM ‘I bought every one (of the fish).’
Repeaters
Hundreds of nouns, especially those referring to familiar or common objects, are conventionally assigned a particular numeral classifier. But there are also many cases in which no numeral classifier is conventionally assigned to a given noun. In such cases, a noun may be used to ‘classify itself’, i.e., to appear as both the main noun and the numeral classifier. In the following example, hang2 ‘nest’ is used, in this way, as a repeater classifier: (243)
kuu3 siø hˆet1 hang2 sip2 hang2 1 SG . B IRR make nest ten nest ‘I’m going to make ten nests (for the chickens).’
Numeral classifiers
123
A repeater structure often occurs when the main noun is also a numeral classifier itself (i.e., a semantically general term conventionally used as a numeral classifier for some set of nouns). In an example, the main noun is khon2 ‘person/people’, which also serves as the classifier used for any nominal referring to a person: (244)
kuu3 hˆen3 khon2 s`oo` ng3 khon2 CLF. HUM 1 SG . B see person two ‘I saw two people.’
Note, however, that speakers would often omit the redundant first instance of khon2 ‘person/people’ in this example. Compare example (244) (in which khon2 is used as both main noun and numeral classifier) with the following example, in which the main noun is khuu2 ‘teacher’, and khon2 is simply used as a numeral classifier for this human noun: (245) kuu3 hˆen3 khuu2 s`oo` ng3 khon2 CLF. HUM 1 SG . B see teacher two ‘I saw two teachers.’ The repeater strategy is the closest thing to a ‘residual’ option in the numeral classifier system. While Lao has two numeral classifiers with very general semantics (qan3 ‘small thing’ and too3 ‘body’), these are not genuinely residual options, since despite their semantic generality and wide applicability they do have specified shape/form semantics, and thus are restricted in the range of nouns they can occur with. They cannot be used, for example, in counting things which have no shape, such as samnuan2 ‘expression’. In this case, only a repeater strategy may be used:4 (246)
kuu3 huu4-cak2 samnuan2 s`oo` ng3 1 SG . B know expression two samnuan2/*qan3/*too3 expression/CLF. SMALL . THING/CLF. ANIM ‘I know two expressions.’
The classifiers too3 ‘body’ and qan3 ‘small thing’ have much broader semantic applicability when used as modifier classifiers, and in those 4
Indeed, it is likely that the speaker would omit the first ‘main noun’ use, giving kuu3 huu4-cak2 s`oo` ng3 samnuan2 [1 SG . B know two expression] ‘I know two expressions’.
124
Nominal classification
functions could both be used with reference to samnuan2 ‘expression’ (and virtually any other noun; cf. section 7.2, below). Thus, it seems preferable to regard the repeater strategy as a genuinely residual option in numeral classification, since it can be used with any nominal whenever it is not obvious what the appropriate numeral classifier is. Note, however, that if a given noun normally takes a particular numeral classifier, then that classifier will be the one used, and a repeater construction would be odd or unacceptable. The next example shows that to use lot1 ‘vehicle’ as a repeater for the noun lot1 ‘vehicle’ is not possible, since it is pre-empted by the classifier khan2, which is the conventional and only numeral classifier used for vehicles: (247)
s`oo` ng3 khan2/*lot1 kuu3 lak1 lot1 CLF. VEHICLE /vehicle 1 SG . B steal vehicle two ‘I stole two cars.’
7.1.3
The set of numeral classifiers
The class of words which may function as numeral classifiers is large. Kerr (1972) lists over 80 dedicated classifiers, and this is certainly not exhaustive. The numeral classifiers are semantically heterogeneous, expressing distinctions of shape, size, material, texture, measure, and social value. Table 14 is a representative list of some common numeral classifiers. While the classifiers in Table 14 can each be used in expressions of enumeration of a large number of nouns, there are also many numeral classifiers with restricted application—i.e., assigned to just one noun or to a very narrow semantic range. A few of these are listed in Table 15. As the discussion so far suggests, it is not clear that a well-delimited set of numeral classifiers can be defined. First, most of the words which are regarded as numeral classifiers—by virtue of the fact that they can appear in the numeral classifier ‘slot’—also function as independent nouns in other grammatical contexts. One may ask whether words like khon2 ‘person’ are polysemous (i.e., in one sense a regular noun meaning ‘person’, and in a second, more grammatical sense, a numeral classifier for humans), or whether they represent a single lexical entry which adopts a classifier function by virtue of its appearance in a certain kind of construction.
Numeral classifiers
125
Table 14. Some common numeral classifiers Classifier Meaning as Semantics and example referents noun k`oo` n4 ‘lump’ lumps of mass which naturally occur (e.g., pieces of ice, rocks) sˆen5 ‘line’ ribbon/strip/cord-shaped things (e.g., roads, cables) khon2 ‘person’ people, excluding monks (e.g., teachers, children, men) too3 ‘body’ non-human entities with ‘bodies’ (e.g., dogs, snakes, shirts) ton4 ‘plant’ living plants (e.g., bushes, shrubs, trees) t`oo` n1 ‘piece/hunk’ lumps of soft mass which are cut (e.g., pieces of meat) nuaj1 ‘unit’ round things, assembled things (e.g., apples, chairs, mountains) ph`uu` n3 ‘soft sheet’ cloths and similar objects (e.g., tablecloths, skirts, tarpaulins) ph`ee` n1 ‘stiff sheet’ stiff/hard flat things (e.g., sheets of dried noodle, LP records) khan2 ‘handle’ things with handles, operated by hand (e.g., vehicles, umbrellas) mˆet1 ‘grain’ very small grains (e.g., seeds, specks) lam2 — very large cylindrical things (e.g., tree-trunks, boats, airplanes) lang3 ‘back’ houses, certain fish traps hua3 ‘head’ books, non-fruit bulbous vegetables qan3 — small things which can be held in hand Table 15. Some numeral classifiers of restricted semantics Classifier Meaning as noun Example referents daang3 square fish net for any net with evenly spaced holes (fish dipping nets, mosquito nets) lˆem5 — teeth qong3 — monks taa3 eye rice seedling-beds maan2 ear of grain corn cobs, rice ‘ears’
126
Nominal classification
Second, while many nouns are conventionally associated with just one numeral classifier (e.g., the numeral classifier for vehicles is always khan2, for fruits always nuaj1), there are many cases of inter- and intraspeaker variation in choice of numeral classifier for certain nouns, depending on a range of factors. One source of variation is the interaction of numeral classifiers with speech level phenomena. For example, Kerr (1972:xxiii) lists two different numeral classifiers which may be used for counting monks: huup4 (elsewhere meaning ‘image’) and qong3 (with no independent meaning). The most common numeral classifier used for monks is qong3, with huup4 having a considerably more formal air. Further, speakers occasionally use khon2, the regular numeral classifier for people, although this is invariably recognized, upon reflection, as incorrect. A second source of variation in selection of numeral classifier arises from the fact that many nouns (especially new words for culturally nontraditional objects) have no dedicated or conventionalized classifier, resulting in different classifiers being equally applicable on the basis of semantic appropriateness. For example, a stapler might be counted using nuaj1 (elsewhere used for things which are assembled as ‘units’) or qan3 (elsewhere used for any kind of small thing which can be held in the hand). A pair of trousers may be counted using too3 (elsewhere a noun ‘body’ and a classifier for all non-human animates) or ph`uu` n3 ‘soft sheet’ (a classifier for any piece of cloth). A third source of variation is perhaps harder to pin down, but it seems to depend on what aspect of the entity being counted is focussed on by the speaker. For example, the noun lˆep1 m`uu` 2 [nail/claw hand] ‘fingernail’ may be counted using (at least) three different elements in the numeral classifier slot: (248)
lˆep1 m`uu` 2 kh`oo` j5 q`oo` k5 s`oo` ng3 nail/claw hand 1 SG . P exit two lˆep1/qan3/diw4 nail/CLF. SMALL . THING/CLF. FINGER ‘Two (of) my fingernails have come off.’
The first choice is a repeater, while the second categorizes the fingernails as ‘small things’. The third choice given here—diw4 ‘finger’—is not a classifier in semantic terms. Semantically, diw4 ‘finger’ does not categorize fingernail in terms of, say, shape. Rather, the fingernail is part
Numeral classifiers
127
of the finger (or, perhaps, the finger is the location of the fingernail). The use of a location term in a classifier slot can also be observed in the conventional use of b`uang4 ‘side’ to count symmetrically paired body parts such as arms or eyes: (249)
thuk1 khon2 mii2 kh`ee` n3 s`oo` ng3 b`uang4 each person have arm two side ‘Everyone has two arms.’ (250) thuk1 khon2 mii2 taa3 s`oo` ng3 nuaj1/b`uang4 CLF. UNIT/side each person have eye two ‘Everyone has two eyes.’ In the case of taa3 ‘eyes’, shown in example (250), there is a choice between using the classifier nuaj1 (used for round things, fruits, and assembled units) or the locational term b`uang4 ‘side’. In the case of ‘arms’, ‘legs’, and ‘ears’, only b`uang4 ‘side’ (or a synonym khaang5) may be used in the numeral classifier slot. Note also that a repeater could be used in the case of (249), since there is no conventional numeral classifier for arms. Here is a text example, in which the second instance of kh`ee` n3 ‘arm’ is a classifier for the first: (251)
tat2 qaw3 kh`ee` n3 paj3 kh`ee` n3 n`ung1 mii2 khon2 maø go arm one there.is person DIR . ALL cut take arm ‘Someone came and cut one of his arms off.’
While there is a great deal of variation in selection of numeral classifier for many nouns, there are also many nouns denoting familiar or traditional objects (such as teeth, fishing nets, or corn cobs), with respect to which speakers do not vary at all in their selection of numeral classifier.
7.1.4
Semantics of numeral classifiers
A significant subset of numeral classifiers refer to distinctions in physical form, including shape and configuration, as illustrated in Table 16 (cf. Seifart 2005). Other numeral classifiers do not make semantic distinctions in shape or form. Some refer to ‘taxonomic essence’, such as maak5 ‘fruit’, a numeral classifier which can be used for counting fruits. More commonly,
128
Nominal classification
Table 16. Some shape/configuration distinctions in numeral classifiers Shape/form semantics Examples Zero-dimensional mˆet1 ‘grain, speck’ One-dimensional sˆen5 ‘long thin thing’ saaj3 ‘strip, ribbon’ lam2 ‘huge tubular thing’ Two-dimensional baj3 ‘leaf’ ph`uu` n3 ‘cloth’ ph`ee` n1 ‘stiff sheet’ Round two-dimensional duang3 ‘disk’ vong2 ‘ring’ Three-dimensional nuaj1 ‘unit, fruit’ Shape and origin t`oo` n1 ‘hewn chunk’ k`oo` n4 ‘formed chunk’ piang1 ‘cut chunk or slice’ Configuration k`oo` 3 ‘clump’ k`oo` ng3 ‘heap’ k`oo` 4 ‘coil’ Handleability qan3 ‘small thing’
however, fruits are counted using nuaj1 ‘unit’, the general numeral classifier for round things. Some classifiers refer to interactional or functional features of objects, such as khan2 ‘handle’ for vehicles and umbrellas, all of which are ‘operated by hand’. Note, however, that not all handoperated items are counted using khan2. Knives, for example, are not. Honorific meaning is expressed by at least one numeral classifier, namely qong3, used for counting monks. Finally, note that many numeral classifiers have conventional applications which are not predicted by their basic productive semantics. For example, duang3, a classifier used for flat disc-like things (such as the moon) is often used for counting knives. A common shape-based alternative is qan3.
7.1.5
Mensural terms
A common use of the numeral classifier construction is to delineate countable amounts of a mass referent by specifying a unit of measure in the numeral classifier slot. Table 17 lists some of these mensural classifiers.
Numeral classifiers
129
Table 17. Some mensural classifiers Classifier Meaning as noun Example referents (or verb) mat1 ‘tie’ (n./v.) anything that can be bunched by tying kam3 ‘handful’ (n./v.) anything that can be measured in handfuls k`oo` 4 ‘coil’ (n./v.) anything that can be coiled khuu1 ‘pair’ candles, shoes, couples toon3 ‘ton’ any weighable mass loo2 ‘kilogram’ any weighable mass
The following example shows three different mensural classifiers used with reference to a single noun, vaaj3 ‘rattan’: (252) kh`oo` j5 s`uu` 4 vaaj3 s`oo` ng3 k`oo` 4/mat1/toon3 1 SG . P buy rattan two coil/tie/ton ‘I bought two coils/ties/tons of rattan.’ The choice of mensural classifier in (252) reflects differences in the gauge and amount of rattan purchased. Mensural classifiers do not classify in the sense of categorizing the main noun primarily in terms of inherent properties of shape or form. Nevertheless, they do convey information about the physical nature of the referent. Clearly, something that can be counted in ‘ties’ must have physical properties and dimensions which make it ‘tie-able’. Mensural classifiers generally display grammatical properties of numeral classifiers.
7.1.6
Shape and form semantics
There is a special adverbial construction in which the copula verb pˆen3 takes a nominal complement which describes the shape or form of a core argument of the clause (see Chapter 17, section 17.1.3). The following examples show the nouns m`oo` 3 ‘doctor’ and kaj1 ‘chicken’ in optional adjuncts hosted by the copula verb pˆen3, predicating the role and physical manifestation, respectively, of the subject of the main clause: (253)
phen1 hˆet1 viak4 (pˆen3 m`oo` 3) 3. P do work COP doctor ‘She works (as a doctor).’
130 (254)
Nominal classification
phen1 nimit1-too3 (pˆen3 kaj1) 3. P transform-body COP chicken ‘He transformed himself (into chickens/a chicken).’
Note that neither of the complements of the copula pˆen3 in these two examples—m`oo` 3 ‘doctor’ nor kaj1 ‘chicken’—are classifiers. Since numeral classifiers often have meanings which denote general shape or form of a thing, they may often appear as the complement of pˆen3 in this construction. Compare the following two examples involving salii2 ‘corn’, where one example involves a numeral classifier denoting shape or form, while the second involves a mensural term denoting units of weight: (255)
(256)
khaw3 khaaj3 salii2 pˆen3 maan2 corn COP CLF. GRAIN . EAR 3 PL . B sell ‘They sell corn by the cob.’ khaw3 khaaj3 salii2 pˆen3 loo2 corn COP kilogram 3 PL . B sell ‘They sell corn by the kilogram.’
If the nominal complement of pˆen3 is a numeral classifier, the ‘pˆen3 An example from a mythical tale illustrates with nuaj1, the numeral classifier for mountains (among other things): CLF ’ adjunct often has a depictive meaning ‘whole’ (see Chapter 17).
(257)
phuu2 pˆen3 nuaj1 man2 h`oo` p5 3. B carry.in.both.arms mountain COP CLF. UNIT ‘He carried the mountain whole.’
Repeater classifiers cannot be used in this construction, nor can classifiers restricted to modifier classifier environments (e.g., phuø ‘MC . HUM’). The copula verb pˆen3 can also take a nominal complement in simple statements about the shape or form of something. In the following examples, the first shows a regular noun denoting substance (maj4 ‘wood’) as the nominal complement of pˆen3, while in the second and third examples the complement of pˆen3 is a numeral classifier referring to shape or form: (258)
man2 pˆen3 maj4 3. B COP wood ‘It’s (made of) wood.’
Numeral classifiers
(259)
(260)
131
man2 pˆen3 ph`ee` n1 3. B COP CLF. STIFF . SHEET ‘It’s (a) stiff sheet-shaped (thing).’ juu1 man2 n˜ ang2 pˆen3 ton4 3. B still COP CLF. PLANT CONT ‘It’s still in the form of a plant (e.g., it hasn’t been shredded).’
Other nominal complements of pˆen3 do not express shape or form or physical substance, but rather role or identity (cf. also examples (253) and (254), above, and Chapter 17): (261)
phen1 pˆen3 khuu2/thahaan3/khon2-latsia2 3. P COP teacher/soldier/CT. PERSON-Russia ‘She is a teacher/soldier/Russian.’
7.1.7
Bare numeral classifier with the meaning ‘one’
In a construction meaning ‘one more (NP)’, a numeral classifier alone can stand for ‘one’ (i.e., no numeral need be explicitly expressed). The word qiik5 ‘more’ can appear with an adverbial meaning after a verb phrase, as in the following example (262)
kuu3 siø kin3 paa3 qiik5 1 SG . B IRR eat fish more ‘I’m going to eat more fish.’
It may also take as a complement a numeral classifier construction which enumerates the object argument: (263)
kuu3 siø kin3 paa3 qiik5 s`oo` ng3 too3 CLF. ANIM 1 SG . B IRR eat fish more two ‘I’m going to eat another two fish.’
If the numeral to be expressed is ‘one’, it is possible to use n`ung1 ‘one’ as it normally would be used in a numeral classifier construction (either immediately before or immediately after the numeral classifier). But it is also possible, and indeed common, to omit the numeral altogether. In this case the combination of qiik5 ‘more’ with the bare numeral
132
Nominal classification
classifier expresses the notion ‘one more’, yet where the numeral ‘one’ is not explicitly expressed: (264)
kuu3 siø kin3 paa3 qiik5 too3 1 SG . B IRR eat fish more CLF. ANIM ‘I’m going to eat another fish.’ (NOT: ‘I’m going to eat more fish.’)
It is possible to use repeaters, part/whole type or mensural classifiers in this construction, as the following examples demonstrate: (265)
(266)
7.1.8
lˆep1 m`uu` 2 kh`oo` j5 q`oo` k5 qiik5 nail/claw hand 1 SG . P exit more lˆep1/qan3/diw4 nail/CLF. SMALL . THING/CLF. FINGER ‘Another one of my fingernails has come off.’ kuu3 siø kin3 paa3 qiik5 loo2 1 SG . B IRR eat fish more CLF. KG ‘I’m going to eat another kilo of fish.’
Speaker awareness of numeral classifiers
Numeral classifiers enjoy a high level of conscious speaker awareness, being an occasional topic for explicit discussion among speakers, and being the focus of both official and unofficial normative conventions (cf. Juntanamalaga 1988 on Thai). Speakers freely discuss which classifier is considered correct for counting which noun. It is not surprising that speakers are apt to reflect consciously on these morphosyntactic items, given their salience both in the phonology (appearing in phrase-final position, stressed), and in the discourse (being typically used in association with definite referents whose quantification and shape or function properties are in focus). Their cultural importance stems not only from their association with material artefacts, but also with the social significance of knowing the right classifier for a given noun. However, informal observations reveal that while speakers’ intuitions about the meaning and distribution of classifiers in numeral classifier contexts are more or less sound, the differences between their choices of classifier with given nouns in
Numeral classifiers
133
numeral classifier and modifier classifier contexts (see section 7.2) seem beyond the level of untrained awareness. That is, while a speaker may identify a classifier as the right one to be used with a certain noun, they will be unaware that in modifier classifier contexts (in which there is less discourse focus on the function of the classifier, as well as a much weaker phonological realization), they do not use that classifier, but switch to something semantically more general.
7.1.9
Numerals
Counting is done using a decimal system with basic terms n`ung1 ‘one’, s`oo` ng3 ‘two’, saam3 ‘three’, sii1 ‘four’, haa5 ‘five’, hok2 ‘six’, cˆet2 ‘seven’, p`ee` t5 ‘eight’, kaw4 ‘nine’, sip2 ‘ten’, saaw2 ‘twenty’, h`oo` j4 or l`oo` j4 ‘hundred’, phan2 ‘thousand’, m`uu` n1 ‘ten thousand’,5 s`ee` n3 ‘hundred thousand’, laan4 ‘million’, and t`uu` 4 ‘billion’. Many of these are originally borrowed from varieties of Chinese. Note the special syntactic properties of ‘one’, already discussed in section 7.1.1 (cf. examples 235-236) and Chapter 6, section 6.3, namely that it may appear either before or after the nominal it enumerates. Note also that in numerals, n`ung1 ‘one’ is suppleted by qˆet1 when given as a final unit in a complex number expression such as ‘fifty one’, or ‘one hundred and one’. This is functionally advantageous, as it circumvents an ambiguity which arises due to the word order properties of n`ung1 ‘one’, which do not apply to qˆet2. Recall, ‘one’ as a quantifier can occur AFTER the nominal head, while all other numbers occur BEFORE it. Both orders are fine for ‘one’, as in n`ung1 khon2 and khon2 n`ung1 for ‘one person’, while for other numbers the only order is with numeral before the nominal, as in s`oo` ng3 khon2 ‘two people’. Thus, ‘one hundred’ may take either order: (267)
a. n`ung1 l`oo` j4 one hundred
5 The term m`uu` n1 is defective in that the option of expressing these figures as tensof-thousands is also available, and is indeed much more common. This is a difference with Thai, whose speakers never talk in terms of ‘tens-of-thousands’, but use the term m`uu` n1 for ‘10,000’ or multiples thereof. Accordingly, when Lao speakers talk of money amounts, an amount of, say, 30,000 will be expressed as saam3 m`uu` n1 if it is in Thai Baht, but saam3 sip2 phan2 if it is in Lao Kip. Also note that m`uu` n1 is a measure term for large quantities of husked rice, referring to a unit amount of about 12 kilograms.
134
Nominal classification
b. l`oo` j4 n`ung1 hundred one ‘one hundred’ But ‘one hundred and one’ has qˆet2 in place of n`ung1 for ‘one’, and has only one possible ordering: (268)
(269)
l`oo` j4 qˆet1 hundred one ‘(one) hundred and one’ * qˆet1 l`oo` j4 one hundred ((one) hundred and one)
There is no such ambiguity for numbers other than one, as the following examples show: (270)
(271)
s`oo` ng3 l`oo` j4 two hundred ‘two hundred’ l`oo` j4 s`oo` ng3 hundred two ‘(one) hundred and two’
Note, however, that it is common with larger numbers to ellipse the term for ‘hundred’, allowing context to distinguish: (272)
s`oo` ng3 phan2 cˆet2 two thousand seven i. ‘two thousand seven hundred’ ii. ‘two thousand and seven’
The (272i) reading ‘2700’ is more likely if we are discussing, say, the price of goods, since ‘2007’ would be an unusual price figure. If we are talking about which year it is currently, the (272ii) reading ‘2007’ is fine. Note that if n`ung1 ‘one’ is postposed, as in (267b), above, there should be no further material following it in the numeral expression:
Numeral classifiers
(273)
135
a. n`ung1 l`oo` j4 saaw2 one hundred twenty ‘one hundred and twenty’ b. * l`oo` j4 n`ung1 saaw2 hundred one twenty (one hundred and twenty)
To express complex figures, units are numerated from largest to smallest, analytically. For instance, if the number is 56, it is expressed as ‘fiveten’ for ‘50’ and then ‘six’ for ‘6’: (274)
haa5 sip2 hok2 five ten six ‘fifty six’
Or if the number is 4572, it is expressed as ‘four-thousand’ for ‘4000’, ‘five-hundred’ for ‘500’, ‘seven-ten’ for ‘70’, and ‘two’ for ‘2’: (275)
sii1 phan2 haa5 l`oo` j4 cˆet2 sip2 s`oo` ng3 four thousand five hundred seven ten two ‘four thousand five hundred (and) seventy two’
If the number includes a figure in the teens or the twenties, the number of units of tens is not specified. For numbers 10-19, the amount ‘one’ is not specified for units of tens: (276)
a. sip2 s`oo` ng2 ten two ‘twelve’ b. * n`ung1 sip2 s`oo` ng2 one ten two (twelve)
For numbers 20-29, there is a dedicated word for ‘20’, saaw2: (277)
a. saaw2 s`oo` ng2 twenty two ‘twenty two’
136
Nominal classification
b.
* s`oo` ng3 sip2 s`oo` ng2 two ten two (twenty two)
Ordinal numbers are expressed using thii1, elsewhere a relativizer: (278) van2 thii1 saaw2 qˆet1 day ORD twenty one ‘(date of) the twenty first’ thii2 s`oo` ng3 (279) h`uan2 lang3 house CLF. FRAME ORD two ‘the second house’ Basic math terms include buak5 ‘add’, lop2 ‘subtract’, khuun2 ‘multiply’, haan3 ‘divide’, and daj4 ‘acquire’ for ‘equals’: (280)
7.1.9.1
saaw2 haan3 sii4 daj4 haa5 twenty divide.by four acquire five ‘Twenty divided by four is five.’
Telling the time
The Lao equivalent of ‘o’clock’ is moong2, which is also the word for ‘clock’ or ‘watch’, and which is incorporated into the word for ‘hour’ (sua1 moong2 ‘hour’, literally ‘period (of the) clock’). To ask the time, one says: (281)
cak2 moong2 l`ee` w4 how.many o’clock PRF ‘What time is it (now/already)?’
To state the time on the hour, one states the number with moong2 ‘o’clock’: (282)
saam3 moong2 l`ee` w4 three o’clock PRF ‘Three o’clock (now/already).’
Modifier classifiers
137
Half past the hour is expressed using kheng1 ‘half’ after the relevant hour: (283)
saam3 moong2 kheng1 three o’clock half ‘Half past three.’
Any other departure from the hour is expressed using either paaj3 (literally, ‘extend, end, tip’) to express ‘past the hour’, or n˜ ang2 ‘(not) yet’ to express ‘before the hour’. Lao speakers will often leave the precise time vague, implying a window of up to half an hour: (284)
(285)
saam3 moong2 n˜ ang2 three o’clock remain ‘Before three.’ saam3 moong2 paaj3 three o’clock extend ‘Past three.’
To be more specific, add the number of minutes: (286)
(287)
7.2
saam3 moong2 n˜ ang2 sip2 s`oo` ng3 nathii2 three o’clock remain ten two minute ‘Twelve to three.’ saam3 moong2 paaj3 sip2 haa5 nathii2 three o’clock extend ten five minute ‘Quarter past three.’
Modifier classifiers
Modifier classifiers are used with various nominal modifiers, including demonstrative determiners nii4 (general demonstrative) and nan4 (nonproximal demonstrative), the quantifier n`ung1 ‘one’, relative clauses, and adjectives. There does not seem to be any restriction on their use with any semantic sub-types of adjective. In principle, any numeral classifier (including repeaters and mensural classifiers) can appear in a modifier classifier function, but in practice many distinctions are neutralized, with
138
Nominal classification
only a small number of numeral classifiers being used in these contexts. Importantly, the grammatical position of the classifier in these uses is different from that of the numeral classifiers, and it results in a significant phonological distinction between the two classifier functions. The most common classifiers used—too3 ‘body’ and qan3 ‘small thing’—have different meanings in the modifier classifier contexts and the numeral classifier contexts. In modifier classifier contexts, they can be used for almost any noun, whereas their applicability is significantly restricted in the numeral classifier context (including the constructions discussed in sections 7.1.2, 7.1.6, and 7.1.7, above). Further, there is at least one classifier (phuø ‘MC . HUM’) which is used exclusively in the modifier classifier context, and cannot be used as a numeral classifier. Numeral classifier constructions discussed in the previous section are unusual in the context of the typological structure of Lao in that the order of classifier and modifying element—with the numeral preceding the classifier—is the opposite of the almost exclusively head-initial pattern of Lao noun phrases. The following examples show that the combination of noun or classifier with numeral (example (288)) is opposite in constituent order to the combination of noun or classifier with attributive modification (e.g., adjectives, demonstratives, and relative clauses; examples (289-291)). The head of the noun phrase in each case is khon2 ‘person/people’: (288)
s`oo` ng3 khon2 two person ‘two people’ (289) khon2 suung3 person tall ‘tall person’ (290) khon2 nii4/q`uu` n1 person DEM/other ‘this/another person’ (291) khon2 thii1 caw4 hˆen3 person REL 2 SG . P see ‘the person who you saw’ An important consequence of this difference in head-modifier ordering for numeral classifier versus modifier classifier contexts concerns the
Modifier classifiers
139
stress patterns of Lao words. Non-monosyllabic Lao words and phrases are stress-final, resulting in pre-final elements becoming reduced. Many monomorphemic lexical items are non-monosyllabic, where a major syllable (i.e., with full stress and with expression of the full range of contrasts in vowel length and lexical tone) is preceded by a reduced minor syllable (with highly restricted phonotactic possibilities, and no contrast in vowel length or tone; cf. Chapter 3). For example, the word kab`uang4 ‘ceramic tile’ features a pre-syllable ka- (unstressed, without contrastive tone or vowel length) and a primary syllable -b`uang4 (stressed, with long complex vowel and contrastive lexical tone). (This word contrasts with, for example, b`uang4 ‘side’ and kabong4 ‘caterpillar’.) This pattern also applies to polymorphemic words or phrases, and this stress-final structure affects the phonological realization of morphemes taking different roles as grammatical components in phrasal combinations. An example is the classifier for non-human animates, which surfaces as too3 in a numeral classifier position (with the modifier coming before it, as in example (292)), but as unstressed toø when in a modifier classifier position (with the modifier coming after it, as in examples (293) and (294)). Note the different patterns of stress in these examples (primary and secondary stress are marked by ‘""’ and ‘"’, respectively; the classifier is given in boldface): ""kuu3 siø "kin3 ""paa3 "s`oo` ng3 ""too3 CLF. ANIM 1 SG . B IRR eat fish two ‘I’m going to eat two fish.’ (293) ""kuu3 siø "kin3 ""paa3 toø ""˜naaw2 1 SG . B IRR eat fish MC . ANIM long ‘I’m going to eat the long fish.’ ""nii4 (294) ""kuu3 siø "kin3 ""paa3 toø 1 SG . B IRR eat fish MC . ANIM DEM ‘I’m going to eat this fish.’
(292)
Demonstrative determiners such as nii4 ‘this’ in (294) cannot appear as independent noun phrases (see Chapter 6): (295)
* kuu3 siø kin3 nii4 1 SG . B IRR eat DEM (I’m going to eat this.)
140
Nominal classification
However, the main noun in (294) may be ellipsed, as follows: nii4 (296) kuu3 siø kin3 toø 1 SG . B IRR eat MC . ANIM DEM ‘I’m going to eat this one.’ If both a numeral and a modifier such as a demonstrative or adjective are to be used in the same phrase, the modifier classifier pattern is used: (297)
nii4 kuu3 siø kin3 paa3 s`oo` ng3 toø MC . ANIM DEM 1 SG . B IRR eat fish two ‘I’m going to eat these two fish.’
De-stressing of the modifier classifier in pre-nominal position is most noticeable in the cases of the two classifiers of most general meaning, too3 ‘body’ and qan3 ‘small thing’. Phonological reduction of a number of other classifiers in this environment is significantly less noticeable due to their greater phonological weight. An example is ph`uu` n3 (a classifier for cloths and similar objects): (298)
(299)
"s`oo` ng3 ""ph`uu` n3 ""kh`oo` j5 "s`uu` 4 ""sin5 CLF. CLOTH 1 SG . P buy Lao.skirt two ‘I bought two skirts.’ ""kh`oo` j5 "mak1 ""sin5 "ph`uu` n3 ""nii4 1 SG . P like Lao.skirt CLF. CLOTH DEM ‘I like this skirt.’
Modifier classifiers cannot be modified by phonologically dependent enclitic markers such as the demonstrative-derived topic markers described in Chapter 6, section 6.2.3. Compare the following with example (299): (300)
ph`uu` n3 niø * kh`oo` j5 mak1 sin5 1 SG . P like Lao.skirt CLF. CLOTH TPC (I like this/the skirt.)
Or compare the following two examples: (301)
nii4 khuu2-baa3 qˆong3 CLF. HOLY DEM monk ‘this monk’
Modifier classifiers
(302)
141
niø * khuu2-baa3 qˆong3 CLF. HOLY TPC monk (this/the monk)
The modifier classifier context is one in which the very large number of semantic distinctions among numeral classifiers are often neutralized. It is often the case that a conventionally assigned numeral classifier is replaced in this context with either of the two more general classifiers too3 ‘body’ or qan3 ‘small thing’, phonologically reduced accordingly. The following are idiomatic alternatives for (299): (303)
toø nii4 kh`oo` j5 mak1 sin5 1 SG . P like Lao.skirt MC . ANIM DEM ‘I like this skirt.’ (304) kh`oo` j5 mak1 sin5 qanø nii4 1 SG . P like Lao.skirt MC . INAN DEM ‘I like this skirt.’ Numeral classifiers of greater semantic specificity tend not to be used as modifier classifiers. This is related to the type of function served by modifier classifiers. In example (303), where the classifier is structurally hosting a demonstrative, specific information concerning shape or form is unnecessary for the basic task of picking up reference to something already active in the discourse or present in the speech situation. Indeed, this makes selection of a more semantically specific classifier in a modifier classifier context pragmatically marked (compare examples (299) and (303)). The classifiers too3 ‘body’ and qan3 ‘small thing’, which in numeral classifier contexts are restricted in their application by semantic specificity, clearly have more generalized meanings in modifier contexts, being used with a greater range of nouns than is possible in numeral classifier contexts (cf. Carpenter 1986 for the same phenomenon in Thai). This shows that these two classifiers in their numeral classifier and modifier classifier roles are distinct lexical items, with distinct meanings and functions.
142 7.2.1
Nominal classification
A modifier classifier for people
The distinction between numeral classifiers (in NUMERAL - CLF order) and modifier classifiers (in CLF - MODIFIER order) is reflected in the existence of a special modifier classifier for people, lexically distinct from the numeral classifier used for people. The modifier classifier for humans— phuø, related to phuu5 in toø-phuu5 ‘male (of a species)’—never occurs as an independent noun, and can only occur in a prenominal modifier classifier slot, and thus never takes primary stress (cf. examples 289-291, above): (305)
nii4 (m`oo` 3) phuø doctor MC . HUM DEM ‘this one (/doctor)’ (306) (m`oo` 3) phuø suung3 doctor MC . HUM tall ‘the tall one (/doctor)’ caw4 hˆen3 (307) (m`oo` 3) phuø doctor MC . HUM 2 SG . P see ‘the one (/doctor) you saw’ In a numeral classifier construction where the numeral classifier comes after the specifier, only khon2, and not phuø, can be used: (308) m`oo` 3 s`oo` ng3 khon2 CLF. HUM doctor two ‘two doctors’ (309) * m`oo` 3 s`oo` ng3 phuø MC . HUM doctor two (two doctors) There is no lexical distinction in the domain of non-human referents analogous to that of khon2 versus phuø which explicitly reflects a differentiation between numeral classifiers and modifier classifiers.
Modifier classifiers
7.2.2
143
Nominal modification
As already noted, modifier classifiers can be used with any kind of nominal modification. With some kinds of modifiers, such as demonstrative determiners, they are obligatory (see example (295), above). In expressions involving modification of a noun by an adjective or relative clause, classifiers may be used, but are not obligatory. The next example shows toø ‘MC . ANIM’ hosting a relative clause modifying paa3 ‘fish’ (see also examples (289-291) and (306-307), above): (310)
caw4 s`uu` 4 kh`oo` j5 kin3 paa3 toø 1 SG . P eat fish MC . ANIM 2 SG . P buy ‘I ate the fish (the one which) you bought.’
It is also possible to use the dedicated relativizer thii1, or no marker at all: (311)
kh`oo` j5 kin3 paa3 (thii1) caw4 s`uu` 4 1 SG . P eat fish REL 2 SG . P buy ‘I ate the fish (which) you bought.’
Hundius and K¨olver (1983:172) hypothesize that in Thai, the choice as to whether or not to omit the classifier in examples such as (310) has consequences on interpretation. Specifically, if the classifier is included, the reading will almost always be understood as singular (whereas it is non-determinate in number if no classifier is supplied). Furthermore, say Hundius and K¨olver (1983:173), ‘it implies either definite reference, or else a contrastive referential value of the adjective’. The same is the case in Lao. (See section 7.2.3, below, for further discussion of this unitizing function.) There are further cases in which more than one classifier phrase features in a complex noun phrase, stacked up, modifying a single noun. Consider the following example: (312)
n˜ aaw2 toø caw4 s`uu` 4 phen1 kin3 paa3 toø 3. P eat fish MC . ANIM long MC . ANIM 2 SG . P buy ‘She ate the fish, the long one, the one you bought.’ (cf. ‘She ate the long fish you bought.’)
144
Nominal classification
This may be analyzed as a series of distinct nominal phrases in apposition, each headed by a classifier, and each elaborating semantically on the main noun, which is a distinct noun phrase (as reflected in the first English translation given). In favor of this analysis, it is possible to insert an adjunct or sentence-final particle between the main noun and a classifier-plus-modifier phrase, showing that the modifier is an independent constituent (cf. example (233), above). Here is another example in which the main noun luuk4 ‘child’ takes three modifiers (a demonstrative and two adjective/relative clauses), each hosted by a separate instance of the modifier classifier phuø ‘MC . HUM’): (313)
ph`oo` 1-m`ee` 1 kaø b`oø n˜ o` o` m2 paj3 nam2 luuk4 phuø father-mother T. LNK NEG yield go with child MC . HUM nan4 phuø hang1 phuø mii2 hanø DEM . NONPROX MC . HUM rich MC . HUM have TPC . DIST ‘The parents won’t go with that rich, wealthy child.’ (i.e., ‘The parents won’t go with child, that one, the rich one, the wealthy one.’)
7.2.3
A unitizing function
Two cases described above—a construction ‘more CLF’ having the meaning ‘one more’ (section 7.1.7), and the use of classifiers in nominal modification implying singularity or definiteness of the referent (section 7.2.2) —suggest a unitizing function of classifiers. Here is another case, a subtle use of modifier classifiers in which the classifier appears by itself in combination with a main noun, where no modifier of the main noun is involved (cf. noun classifiers in Australian and Mayan languages; Aikhenvald 2000: Chapter 3, Grinevald 2000:64-5). Compare the following two sentences: (314)
(315)
kuu3 hˆen3 paø-duk2 juu1 naj2 kakhuq2 1 SG . B see CT. FISH-sp. be.at inside bucket ‘I saw (a) catfish in the bucket.’ kuu3 hˆen3 too3 paø-duk2 juu1 naj2 kakhuq2 1 SG . B see CLF. ANIM CT. FISH-sp. be.at inside bucket ‘I saw (a/the) catfish in the bucket.’
Modifier classifiers
145
In the second example, the nominal paø-duk2 ‘catfish’ is preceded by too3 ‘body’, the numeral classifier used for fish. The meaning difference between the two examples is subtle. The presence of the classifier in (315) suggests unitization, implying (but not entailing) that there is just one fish being referred to. The absence of the classifier in (314) gives rise to no particular expectation regarding the number of fish referred to. Further, as suggested for Thai by Hundius and K¨olver (1983) regarding the presence of a classifier in noun-modifying phrases, there is a greater likelihood that the referent in (315) is definite. The next two examples show the same pattern of alternation, with optional use of the classifier nuaj1 ‘(assembled) unit’ appearing immediately before the main noun toq2 ‘table’: (316)
kuu3 hˆen3 toq2 juu1 naj2 h`oo` ng5 1 SG . B see table be.at inside room ‘I saw (a) table(s) in the room.’ toq2 juu1 naj2 h`oo` ng5 (317) kuu3 hˆen3 nuaj1 1 SG . B see CLF. UNIT table be.at inside room ‘I saw (a/the) table(s) in the room.’
Again, the second example, with the classifier alone forming a phrase with the main noun, suggests that there is just one table, while the first implies nothing about number. Also, a definite reading is more likely in the second example. The following examples show that this function cannot be performed by classifiers which do not pick out their referents in terms of shape or form specification (either because the shape or form specifications of the referent do not match those of its conventional classifier—as in hua3 ‘head’ for books—or the classifier simply has no shape or form information—as in khan2 for vehicles): (318)
(319)
kuu3 hˆen3 (*hua3) p`um4 juu1 naj2 h`oo` ng5 1 SG . B see CLF. HEAD book be.at inside room ‘I saw (a) book(s) in the room.’ juu1 naj2 lotø-cak2 kuu3 hˆen3 (*khan2) 1 SG . B see CLF. VEHICLE CT. VEHICLE-motorcycle be.at inside h`oo` ng5 room ‘I saw (a) motorcycle in the room.’
146
Nominal classification
It is possible to use phuø ‘person’ (but not the corresponding numeral classifier khon2 ‘person’) in this context, with the connotation that the referent person is a familiar or recognizable individual: (320)
qaaj4 man2 juu1 talaat5 kuu3 hˆen3 phuø 1 SG . B see MC . HUM eBr 3. B be.at market ‘I saw his brother at the market.’
As in other modifier classifier functions, the classifier is the head of the phrase in these unitizing functions. The difference here is that the element dependent on the classifier is the main noun itself.
7.3
Class terms
There are dozens of morphemes which may occur as independent nouns and which also may appear as the initial and more semantically general component of many polymorphemic nouns denoting objects and people. In this role, they do not categorize the element to which they attach, but rather the whole compound of which they are a part. They are phonologically dependent and lexically specified (thus obligatory). I refer to them as class terms (Grinevald 2000:59). The set of class terms is not the same as the set of numeral classifiers, but there is partial overlap. An illustrative example is the use of the general word for ‘fish’— paa3—as the initial component in names of individual fish species (Kerr 1972:771ff lists over a hundred). In this initial position, paa3 ‘fish’ is reduced to unstressed paø, where the (usually monosyllabic) element denoting the species of fish takes lexical stress (according to the phonological structure of words as stress-final, as described above): (321)
paø-duk2 CT. FISH -sp. ‘catfish’ (322) paø-thuu2 CT. FISH -sp. ‘mackerel’ Sometimes the modifier is semantically transparent, as part of a (sometimes figurative or metonymic) description of the fish:
Class terms
147
(323)
paø-m`uk1 CT. FISH -ink ‘ink fish, squid’ (324) paø-kham2 CT. FISH -gold ‘goldfish’ Grinevald (2000:59) regards class terms as ‘classifying morphemes’ rather than classifiers. These are distinct from what she identifies as noun classifiers, which are ‘free morphemes’ not involved with derivation in the lexicon (Grinevald 2000:64). By contrast, Aikhenvald’s (2000: Chapter 3) definition of noun classifier would encompass the Lao class terms described in this section. We now examine some categories of class terms, based on semantic properties.
7.3.1
Class terms denoting taxonomic essence
The most common and extensive uses of class terms denote taxonomic or biological essence of the marked noun. By essence I mean the fundamental nature of a thing, usually in terms of higher-level taxonomic kind such as ‘fish’, ‘tree’, or ‘fruit’. Table 18 shows some examples. Table 18. Some examples of class terms denoting biological essence Class term Meaning as a noun Referents paøpaa3 ‘fish’ kinds of fish m`engøm`ee` ng2 ‘insect’ kinds of insect makømaak5 ‘fruit’ kinds of fruit namønam4 ‘water’ liquids majømaj4 ‘wood’ kinds of tree, kinds of wood khawøkhaw5 ‘rice’ kinds of rice or cereal manøman2 ‘root vegetable’ kinds of root vegetable
One class term which does not denote essence in a biological sense, but refers more to fundamental physical essence, is sii3 ‘color’, which appears in compound terms referring to different colors. There are two classes of color terms, based on grammatical properties (see Chapter 10,
148
Nominal classification
section 10.2.10). One group consists of basic terms, including d`ee` ng3 ‘red’, l`uang3 ‘yellow’, and khiaw3 ‘green/blue’. These are grammatically more versatile than a second group, consisting of non-basic terms, including faa4 ‘blue, sky’ and bua3 ‘pink/purple, lotus’), which are subject to certain grammatical constraints (see Chapter 10). One grammatical difference between the two categories, illustrated in the following examples, is that the class term sii3 ‘color’ is obligatory only with the second, non-basic category: (325)
(326)
7.3.2
lot1 (sii3)-d`ee` ng3 vehicle color-red ‘red (colored) car’ lot1 * (sii3)-faa4 vehicle color-blue ‘blue *(colored) car’
Class terms denoting occupation or role
The kinship terms m`ee` 1 ‘mother’ and ph`oo` 1 ‘father’ are used derivationally as class terms, denoting male and female occupations, respectively. Table 19 lists a few examples of female occupations involving m`ee` 1 ‘mother’ as a prefixed and phonologically reduced class term. Table 19. Some female occupation terms headed by ‘mother’ as a class term Expression Meaning of modifier m`eø-khua2 ‘cook’ (f.) khua2 ‘prepare food for cooking’ m`eø-caang4 ‘prostitute’ caang4 ‘hire someone’s services’ m`eø-khaaw3 ‘nun’ khaaw3 ‘white’
Another word used as a class term in certain occupation terms is naaj2 ‘boss, lord’, as listed in Table 20 (Kerr 1972:702-3 gives many examples). In some cases, najø- is optionally added to a noun of occupation or role to express respect: e.g., m`oo` 3 ‘doctor’ versus najø-m`oo` 3 ‘(respected or boss) doctor’, khuu2 ‘teacher’ versus najø-khuu2 ‘(respected or boss) teacher’. A final example differs from the class terms discussed so far in that it has no independent use as a noun. A ‘professional’ class term prefix
Class terms
149
Table 20. Some role terms headed by ‘lord/boss’ as class term Expression Meaning of modifier najø-phaa2saa3 ‘interpreter’ phaa2saa3 ‘language’ najø-daan1 ‘border official’ daan1 ‘border’ najø-baan4 ‘village chief’ baan4 ‘village’ najø-thahaan3 ‘military officer’ thahaan3 ‘soldier’
nakø- (Kerr 1972:694) is a borrowing from Khmer (cf. modern Khmer nˆeak ‘person’). Some examples are given in Table 21. Table 21. Some role terms headed by ‘professional’ prefix nakøExpression Meaning of modifier nakø-kilaa2 ‘sportsman’ kilaa2 ‘sport’ nakø-bin3 ‘pilot’ bin3 ‘fly’ nakø-khian3 ‘writer’ khian3 ‘write’ nakø-qawakaat5 ‘astronaut’ qawakaat5 ‘outer space’
7.3.3
Class terms denoting function
Some class terms categorize the compound in terms of function. One productive example involves the word lot1, a general term for any terrestrial vehicle, as listed in Table 22. Table 22. Some ‘vehicle’ nouns headed by lot1 ‘vehicle’ as class term Expression Meaning of modifier lotø-thiip5 ‘bicycle’ thiip5 ‘push away with foot’ lotø-cak2 ‘motorcycle’ cak2 ‘machine’ lotø-kˆeng3 ‘sedan’ kˆeng3 (no independent meaning) lotø-kuat5 ‘grader’ kuat5 ‘sweep’ lotø-cok2 ‘digger’ cok2 ‘scoop’ lotø-˜naj1 ‘truck’ n˜ aj1 ‘big’
The lexically derivational role of the class terms should be clear from the examples.
150 7.3.4
Nominal classification
A productive class term prefix: khiø- ‘shit’
A large set of nouns begin with khiø-, a reduced form of khii5 ‘shit’ (cf. Chapter 10, section 10.3.3, below). Unlike other class terms, this word has verb as well as noun uses in other contexts. One class of derived nouns refers to things or substances regarded as by-product, waste or pollutant: (327)
a. khiø-dang3 ‘snot’ (dang3 = ‘nose’) b. khiø-l`uaj1 ‘sawdust’ (l`uaj1 = ‘saw’) c. khiø-miang5 ‘rust’ (miang5 has no independent meaning)
Another category of noun denotes different kinds of people with negative character traits: (328)
a. khiø-lak1 ‘thief’ (lak1 = ‘to steal’) b. khiø-tuaq2 ‘liar’ (tuaq2 = ‘to lie’) c. khiø-koong3 ‘cheat’ (koong3 = ‘to cheat’)
Also unlike other class terms, this prefix is also used to derive verbs (again with meanings referring to negative characteristics): (329)
7.3.5
a. khiø-thii1 ‘stingy’ (thii1 = ‘spaced closely together’) b. khiø-khuj2 ‘snobby’ (khuj2 = ‘chat’) c. khiø-khaan4 ‘lazy’ (khaan4 has no independent meaning)
An ‘opaque prefix’ class term ka-
Hundreds of nouns feature a half-syllable ‘opaque prefix’ ka- (Kerr 1972:1 calls it ‘a common untranslatable prefix’). It is a prefix in that it is paradigmatically related, at least to some extent, to the procliticized class terms described so far in this section. It is opaque in that it has no recognizable independent meaning. Even so, there are some semantic themes in common among groups of nouns with the ka- prefix. Many of these terms refer to small creatures (e.g., kataaj1 ‘rabbit’, kabong4 ‘caterpillar’) or small common domestic artifacts (e.g., kadum3 ‘button’, kataa1 ‘basket’). Four formal categories of noun can be defined with reference to the pre-syllable ka-:
Kin prefixes
(330)
151
i. Words in which ka- is obligatory, e.g: kadaan3 ‘board’ (daan3 is not a word) kah`oo` k4 ‘squirrel’ (h`oo` k4 is not a word) ii. Words in which ka- is optional, with no difference in meaning, e.g: kakhuq1 ‘bucket’ (= khuq1 ‘bucket’) kapiing3 ‘leech’ (= piing3 ‘leech’) iii. Words in which ka- is optional, with a (related but) different meaning, e.g: kapaw3 ‘bag, case’ (= paw3 ‘sack’) kaloong1 ‘chest’ (= loong1 ‘coffin’) iv. Words which are semantically appropriate (e.g., referring to small creatures and small common artifacts) yet in which kacannot occur, e.g: tang1 ‘chair’ (katang1 is not a word) kop2 ‘frog sp.’ (kakop2 is not a word)
While there is no productive or uniquely identifiable role for ka- in synchrony, its presence has historical explanations. The ka- prefix in modern words comes from a range of different historical sources, including possibly Proto-Tai, early semantic classes in Proto-Southwestern Tai (possibly due to an Austroasiatic substratum), and borrowing from MonKhmer languages (Anthony Diller, personal communication; cf. Photchani 1993).6 In some cases, the prefix ka- may have been applied to native monosyllabic words (having been first abstracted as a ‘prefix’ from borrowed words).7
7.4
Kin prefixes
One type of classificatory prefix differs from the types of nominal classification discussed so far in being neither obligatory nor lexically deriva6
See Sagart (2001:133-134) for a description of the ‘not uncommon’ phenomenon in modern Sinitic languages of ‘nouns prefixed with kV-’. These are ‘always, or almost always, concrete nouns (as opposed to abstract nouns) and count nouns (as opposed to mass nouns)’. 7 Speakers recognize that ka- is an independent element (as one would expect given that it is optional in some cases), but they cannot readily characterize its meaning. When pressed, a number of bilingual speakers compare it to the definite article the in English.
152
Nominal classification
tional. These are kinship terms such as paa4 ‘elder aunty (Pa.eZ)’ or q`uaj4 ‘older sister (eZ)’, which are prefixed to personal names (and are phonologically dependent in these contexts, being de-stressed accordingly), expressing relational meanings of (classificatory) kinship between the speaker and the referent. Table 23 supplies some examples. Table 23. Kinship terms used as classifying prefixes in terms of address Prefix Meaning elsewhere Example referents paøpaa4 ‘elder aunty (Pa.eZ)’ paø-s`ee` ng3 ‘Aunty Seng’ tuøtuu4 ‘grandparent (Pa.Pa)’ tuø-s`ee` ng3 ‘Grandma Seng’ qajø- qaaj4 ‘elder brother (eBr)’ qajø-s`ee` ng3 ‘Seng (respected older male of same generation as oneself)’ q`uaj4- q`uaj4 ‘elder sister (eZ)’ q`uajø-s`ee` ng3 ‘Seng (respected older female of same generation as oneself)’
These can be used as modifier classifiers (331), but rarely as numeral classifiers (332): (331) kuu3 hˆen3 qajø-nan4 1 SG . B see eBr-DEM . NONPROX ‘I saw him [=that older respected male of same generation].’ (332) ? kuu3 hˆen3 s`oo` ng3 qaaj4 eBr 1 SG . B see two (I saw two [=older respected males of same generation].) Only a subset of kinship terms can be used in this way, namely those that refer to kin above (i.e., older than) oneself. Reference to anyone in one’s kinship or social network who is lower than oneself is done using two ‘non-respect’8 forms: qiø ‘non-respected female’ and bakø ‘non8
Respect and politeness are complex and difficult to characterize, especially due to the interaction between semantics and pragmatics in this domain. Non-respect does not entail disrespect. There are extensive social rules for showing respect linguistically, and linguistic semantics provides rich means for doing so. To use someone’s name alone is to semantically say nothing about the level of respect being given, but this may have pragmatic import in the context of what could have been said (Levinson 2000:3536). The use of qiø- and bakø- as prefixes to personal names in address or third person reference explicitly states that you are not showing any of the possible available respect expressions. But this does not entail disrespect. It may imply it if a respect form is pragmatically called for in that context. Otherwise, the use is intimate or familiar. See Chapter 5, above (also Enfield 2007d).
Relations between forms of nominal classification
153
respected male’. (These are not kinship terms themselves.) Thus, while a girl (named s`ee` ng3) will refer to her grandmother (named sii3) as tuøsii3 ‘Grandma Sii’, the girl will be referred to in return as qiø-s`ee` ng3 ‘the non-respected female Seng’, and not as, say *laan3-s`ee` ng3 (where laan3 means ‘grandchild’). Like the kinship terms just discussed (see Table 23), these terms are used as heads in modifier expressions (involving demonstratives, adjectives, or relative clauses), but are not used as numeral classifiers. The gender-specific non-respect forms qiø ‘non-respected female’ and bakø ‘non-respected male’ are also sometimes used as prefixes to nonhuman nouns whose referents are not inherently of one or the other sex (such as certain kinds of animals, insects, and artefacts). They appear (sometimes optionally) as prefixes to a restricted set of lexical items, including animals such as qiø-kh`ee` 5 ‘crocodile’, qiø-bong4 ‘caterpillar’, qiø-piing3 ‘leech’, and games such as qiø-jaang3 ‘skip-rope’ (where the ‘rope’ is made of rubber bands—jaang3 means ‘rubber’) and naj2 qiøkhaam3 ‘tamarind-seed checkers’ (where naj2 means ‘seed’ and khaam3 means ‘tamarind’). In the latter case, the playing pieces are anaphorically referred to using the female non-respect term qiø in modifier classifier function. Finally, note that the ‘female’ prefix qiø is used as a prefix for two terms referring to male human referents: namely, qiø-ph`oo` 1 ‘daddy’ (ph`oo` 1 means ‘father’) and qiø-taa3 ‘old fellow’ (taa3 means ‘maternal grandfather’). In all cases of extension of the gender-specific non-respect forms beyond human referents (the feminine qiø being more productive than the masculine term bakø in this respect), the presence of the prefix has the effect of portraying the referent as something familiar (specifically, in some sense associated with taking a child’s viewpoint—i.e., as children might speak with each other, or as an adult might speak to a child).
7.5
Relations between forms of nominal classification
Aikhenvald (2000) suggests two ways in which a language can have more than one system of nominal classification. First, in a ‘multiple classifier language’, ‘[t]he same, or almost the same, set of morphemes can be used in more than one classifier environment’ (Aikhenvald 2000:204). Otherwise, there will be ‘several distinct classifier types’ coexisting in the
154
Nominal classification
language (Aikhenvald 2000:184). Available sources on nominal classification in Thai might suggest that Thai is a ‘multiple classifier language’, using ‘one set of morphemes in four environments’ (i.e., with numerals, with demonstratives, with other modifiers, and as class terms; Aikhenvald 2000:213). The distribution of nominal classification devices in Lao is not essentially different to that in Thai. However, it should be clear from the discussion above, that the three major systems numeral classifiers, modifier classifiers, and class terms do not draw upon exactly the same set of morphemes.9 Descriptions of Thai have tended to treat classifiers as a unitary system, but have concentrated on numeral classifier contexts, often without noting the phonological, syntactic, and semantic differences between classifiers in numeral classifier and modifier classifier contexts. (Carpenter 1986 is an important exception.) As for the class terms (cf. section 7.3, above), there is significant disjunction between these and other classifiers such as numeral classifiers. It was established in sections 7.1 and 7.2, above, that speakers make different choices of classifiers in the numeral classifier and modifier classifier contexts. While most numeral classifiers can theoretically be used in either context, in practice the use of particular classifiers with particular nouns is quite different in the two systems. The most common modifier classifiers, toø ‘MC . ANIM’ and qanø ‘MC . INAN’, have much more general meanings in modifier classifier functions than in numeral classifier functions (as too3 ‘body’ and qan3 ‘small thing’), and, accordingly, can be used with a much greater range of nouns in the former function. In addition, there is at least one classifier (phuø ‘person’) that is restricted to the modifier classifier function only. The class term system includes many elements which cannot be used as numeral classifiers at all. The following example shows that while all fish names include a class term which is a bound and reduced form of paa3 ‘fish’, this term cannot be used as a numeral classifier for fish: (333)
* paø-duk2 s`oo` ng3 paa3 CT. FISH -sp. two fish (two catfish)
Instead, the classifier for non-human animates—too3 ‘body’—must be used: 9
Kin prefixes form a distinct system and are not discussed in this section.
Summary on nominal classification
(334)
155
paø-duk2 s`oo` ng3 too3 CT. FISH -sp. two CLF. ANIM ‘two catfish’
This is not surprising, given that class terms and numeral classifiers have different semantics appropriate to their different functions. Class terms refer to taxonomic essence, while numeral classifiers generally refer to shape or form, or functional properties (or are assigned by convention). This being said, one can find examples in which the class term and numeral classifier are the same morpheme (though with a stress or intonational difference associated with the fact that the class term is phonologically dependent on a following stressed element): (335)
cak2 p`oo` ng1 mii2 p`ongø-qiam4 there.is CT. OPENING-window how.many CLF. OPENING ‘How many windows are there?’ cak2 (336) taø-kaa4 CT. RICE . SEEDLING . BED -rice.seedling.bed how.many taa3 CLF. RICE . SEEDLING . BED ‘How many rice seedling beds (are there)?’ The set of classifiers used in the numeral classifier and class term systems show only partial overlap. So, Lao (like Thai) presents an example of what Aikhenvald (2000:184) calls ‘different classifier types in one language’.
7.6
Summary on nominal classification
Table 24 summarizes the types of nominal classification system described in this chapter.
counting
Grammatical NUM context Phonological stressed status Semantic fine semantic properties contrast, encoding shape/form, function; variable assignment; object of speaker awareness Approximate 100+ size of set
Functional context
Numeral classifiers
r
e
s
s
e
d ,
d
e
2-100+
t
20+
s
semantic specificity unnecessary in these functions; distinctions often neutralized (using just too3 ‘body’ and qan3 ‘small thing’), and use of more specific terms in these contexts is pragmatically marked
n
Modifier classifiers b. demonstrative c. modified situational or unitizing, discourse deixis, hosting anaphora modification DEM ADJ / REL . CLS
only refer to shape/form of unit
u
NOM
a. unitizing unitizing
Table 24: Summary of systems of nominal classification
p
n
d
60+
refer to taxonomic essence
e
MOD
lexically derivational
Class terms
e
t refer to higher kinship relation, mark expression of respect 10+
n
NAME
social deixis for personal reference
Kin prefixes
156 Nominal classification
Chapter 8 Reference management Reference management concerns the introduction and tracking of referents in multi-clause stretches of discourse (cf. e.g. Halliday and Hasan 1976, Chafe 1980). Across languages, this typically involves the use of nominal devices of various sorts, including noun phrase types varying in density and complexity (e.g., complex expressions versus pronouns versus ellipsis), or various forms of nominal modification (e.g., articles, demonstratives, quantifiers, relative clauses). Reference management may also involve special clausal constructions, for instance presentational structures whose function is to introduce referents for the first time in a discourse. The discussion centers on grammatical position rather than on details of word selection or other matters of formulation of noun phrases with new reference. For some discussion in the domain of reference to persons, see Enfield (2007d).
8.1
First mention in mii2 presentational construction
Introducing a referent for the first time in a discourse typically involves a presentational construction headed by the verb mii2 ‘there is’. As a two-place verb, mii2 means ‘to have’: (337)
q`uaj4 kh`oo` j5 mii2 h`uan2 s`oo` ng3 lang3 CLF. FRAME 1 SG . P have house two eZ ‘My elder sister has two houses.’ (338) kh`oo` j5 mii2 qaaj4 s`oo` ng3 khon2 CLF. HUM 1 SG . P have eBr two ‘I have two older brothers.’ (339) phen1 mii2 taa3 n˜ aj1 3 SG . P have eye big ‘She has big eyes.’
158
Reference management
(340)
haan1 kh`oo` j5, man2 mii2 luuk4, man2 mii2 kaw4 too3 geese 1 SG . P 3. B have child 3. B have nine CLF. ANIM phunø dˆej2 TPC . FAR FAC . NEWS ‘My goose, it has goslings, it has nine, you know.’ (341) mii2 n˜ ang3 kaø l`ee` k4-pian1 kan3, have INDEF. INAN T. LNK exchange COLL phuø-nan4 mii2 phak2 b`oo` 3, phuø-nii4 MC . HUM - DEM . NONPROX have greens QPLR MC . HUM - DEM mii2 ngua2-khuaj2... have cattle-buffalo... ‘Whatever (they) had, (they’d) exchange with each other, that person might have greens, this person has cattle and buffaloes...’ As a one-place verb, mii2 means ‘wealthy’ (i.e., ‘to have’):
(342)
mii2 phuø-nii4 MC . HUM - DEM have ‘This person is wealthy.’
When an animate subject is replaced with a location subject, a ‘have’ reading is readily construed as a ‘there is’ reading: (343)
pˆen3-˜nang3 cang1 vaa1 d`oo` n3 liing2, ph`oq1 vaa1 man2 WHY so say island monkey because COMP 3. B mii2 t`ee` 1 liing2 there.is/have only monkey ‘Why (did they) call (it) “Monkey Island”? Because it had only monkeys.’ (or: ‘...there were only monkeys.’)
A standard way to introduce a new referential argument into discourse is with a presentational construction featuring mii2 in initial position. While subjects normally precede verbs, in this construction there is no argument in the preverbal position: (344) mii2 cot2-maaj3 naj2 h`uan2 kh`oo` ng3 laaw2 there.is letter in house of 3 SG . FA ‘There was a letter in his house.’
First mention in mii2 presentational construction
159
(345)
mii2 khon2 baan4-n`oo` k4 phuø-n`ung1 there.is person village-outside MC . HUM-one ‘There was (once) a country fellow.’ (346) mii2 caw4-saaj2 qong3 n`ung1 there.is lord-male CLF. HOLY one ‘There was a/one prince.’ Note that the numeration shown in (346) is not necessary to the introduction of the referent into the discourse. The numeral classifier phrase qong3 n`ung1 ‘one holy being’ specifies that the number of princes was one, but it is not a critical part of the function of introducing the referent into the discourse for the first time (as, say, the English indefinite article a might be). If the numerative phrase were removed, the clause would still serve to introduce a referent, but it would be unspecified as to number: (347)
mii2 caw4-saaj2 there.is lord-male i. ‘There was a prince.’ ii. ‘There were some princes.’
Here is an example in which number is left unspecified upon first mention. It appears when a referent corresponding to the word kaj1 ‘chicken’ is first introduced (as an oblique complement). This happens at a point in the narrative when a divine being changes bodily form. At this point it is not possible to know whether the referent is singular or plural: (348)
too3 pˆen3 kaj1 man2 nimit1 3. B transform body COP chicken ‘It transformed itself into chickens/a chicken.’
Example (348) is the first mention in the discourse of the idea of ‘chickens’ or ‘a chicken’, a mention which establishes a trackable discourse referent. The number of the referent remains unspecified in the following clause, and becomes more specific only two clauses later: (349)
niø, pˆen3 s`ee` n3 too3 phunø pˆen3 kaj1-paa1 COP chicken-forest TPC COP 100,000 CLF. ANIM TPC . FAR ‘Into wild chickens/a wild chicken, into 100,000 of them.’
160
Reference management
Only upon hearing the second clause of (349) does a hearer know that the occurrences of kaj1 ‘chicken’ in the previous two clauses referred to a huge flock of individual chickens, rather than, say, to an individual chicken. Note that the default, decontextualized reading of (348) would be singular, i.e., ‘a chicken’. Here is an example from a similar context to (348), but where number is specified upon first mention (as is the case in (346), above): (350)
kap2-phˆeeˆ t4 pˆen3 qanaa1 kaa3 phen1 kaø leej2 crow 3. P T. LNK NO . ADO return-gender COP HES khaap4 paa3 maa2 toø-n`ung1 MC . ANIM -one carry.in.mouth fish come ‘And so without ado he transformed into um a crow bringing a fish in its mouth.’
Also note with respect to the issue of numeration exemplified in (346), above, it is also not necessary for the nominal specification to be contiguous with the nominal head (cf. Chapter 7, example (233) and section 7.1.1 passim). In the next example, the numerative phrase qanø-n`ung1 [MC . INAN-one] is separated from the nominal it quantifies (i.e., kh`oo` ng3khuan3 ‘gift’): (351)
laø phen1 dajø qaw3 kh`oo` ng3-khuan3 haj5 qanø-n`ung1 give MC . INAN-one and 3. P ACHV take gift ‘...and he did give a gift (to the prince).’
Sentence-initial mii2 as a marker of non-given preverbal noun phrases combines naturally with indefinite pronouns (cf. Chapter 5, above). By contrast, inherently definite noun phrases such as personal names cannot take sentence-initial mii2: (352)
(353)
s`oo` ng3 too3 * mii2 bakø-dam3 khaa5 kaj1 kill chicken two CLF. ANIM there.is M . B-D (Dam killed two chickens.) s`oo` ng3 too3 bakø-dam3 khaa5 kaj1 M . B -D kill chicken two CLF. ANIM ‘Dam killed two chickens.’
In the following examples, mii2 ‘there is’ predicates mere existence (or non-existence, under negation):
Other types of first mention
161
(354)
b`oø mii2 b`oo` n1 nang1 NEG there.is place sit ‘There was no place to sit.’ (355) samaj3 k`oo` n1 b`oø mii2 kh`uang1-cak2 kh`uang1-˜non2 era before NEG there.is machine-engine machine-plane d`oo` k5 FAC . RESIST ‘In the old days, there weren’t engines or aeroplanes, despite what you might think.’ (356) mii2 cia3 juu1 laaw2 there.is bat be.at Laos ‘There are bats in Laos.’ In general, the use of mii2 ‘there is’ in the presentational construction corresponds to indefinite marking and the There is construction in English, while its absence corresponds to definite marking in English. Compare the following, with and without mii2: (357) mii2 kac`ee` 3 juu1 naj2 lin4-sak2 there.is key be.at inside drawer ‘There’s a key in the drawer.’ (358) kac`ee` 3 juu1 naj2 lin4-sak2 key be.at inside drawer ‘The key is in the drawer.’
8.2 8.2.1
Other types of first mention First mention in extraclausal Left Position
Discourse-initial reference may be made by a noun phrase in extraclausal Left Position. This is then immediately followed by another nominal corresponding to the same referent, in the form of a pronoun in the clausal subject slot. Structurally, a single referent is expressed both as extraclausal topic and clausal subject, i.e., in two slots which are linearly adjacent but which bear structurally different relations to the clause. Here is an example:
162 (359)
Reference management
lot1, man2 l`ee` n1 kiaw4 paj3 haa3 toø-nii4 vehicle 3. B run encircle go seek MC . INAN - DEM ‘(The/a) car, it runs around going toward this thing.’
This is possible if the referent’s initial mention is not completely unexpected, but is in some way already contextually available or semiactivated. In the case of example (359), the referent ‘car’ was already in the common attentional field just prior to the utterance. (359) is a description of a video clip the speaker has just watched. By virtue of being already visually and attentionally available, the car in question has effectively been introduced into the discourse world. In another example, a speaker is telling the story of a country man who is on a visit to the town, and is walking through the market. By invoking a market scene, the speaker makes accessible all the standard features of such a scene, including the ‘aunties’ who sell their wares. This licenses a first mention of such an aunty in extraclausal Left Position, at a point just after the speaker has said ‘He turned and saw some sausages for sale’: (360)
laaw2 kaø nang1 khaaj3 m`eø-paa4 nanø, CT. M o- P a.e Z TPC . NONPROX 3 SG . FA T. LNK sit sell saj5-k`oo` k5 juu1 l`ekaø h`oo` ng4 s`uu` 4 suaj1 d`ee` 1 CONT C . LNK call buy help IMP. SOFT sausage ph`oø-luung2 CT. F a- P a.e B ‘That aunty, she sat selling sausages, and (she) called out “Buy some please, Uncle!”.’
8.2.2
First mention as non-subject argument
New referents may be introduced in the clausal core as either an O or oblique argument. This is like the presentational construction using mii2 in that the new referent is coded as a lower complement in the predicate, not a subject. The kinds of verbs which serve to introduce new referents in this way often express some sense of encountering. In an example, a new referent coon3 ‘bandit’ is introduced as a complement of the verb cuap5 ‘meet’:
Other types of first mention
(361)
163
cuap5 coon3 deen3 maa2 h`oo` t4 la˜naq1 n`ung1 maø march come reach period one DIR . ALL meet bandit ‘(They) walked, coming, for a while, and met (a) bandit.’
In another two examples, new referents are introduced as subjects of clausal complements of the verb hˆen3 ‘see’: (362)
hˆen3 n˜ ing2-saaw3 pakot2 tua3 juu1 han5 see woman-girl appear body be.at DEM . DIST ‘(He) saw (a) girl appear there.’ kh`oo` j5 (363) m`oo` 1 h`oo` t4 talaat5 dong3-paa1-laan2 hanø, TPC . DIST 1 SG . P near reach market D-P-L khan2 leej2 hˆen3 qaa1 lotø-cak2 NO . ADO see HES CT. VEHICLE -motorcycle CLF. VEHICLE n`ung1 l`ee` n1- l`ee` n1 k`oo` n1 kh`oo` j5 one run- run before 1 SG . P ‘Near to reaching the Dongpalane Market, I then saw um a motorcycle running- running ahead of me.’ In another example, a new referent phaq1-l`uu` 2sii3 ‘holy hermit’ is introduced in a peripheral slot, as complement of the comitative nam2 ‘with’ (note that the first line of this example was supplied above as example (346)): n`ung1 pajø hian2 visaa2 (364) mii2 caw4-saaj2 qong3 there.is lord-male CLF. HOLY one DIR . ABL study subject qaa3khom2 nam2 phaq1-l`uu` 2sii3 incantation with CT. HOLY. BEING-hermit ‘There was one prince, (he) went to study the discipline of magic incantations with a holy hermit.’
8.2.3
First mention in extraclausal Right Position
This strategy is a mirror image of the ‘Left Position noun phrase plus resumptive pronoun in clausal core’ strategy described in section 8.2.1, above. Here, a first explicit mention is made in the post-clausal Right Position or afterthought slot. The main clause is structured as if the new argument were already given, that is, the new referent will correspond
164
Reference management
either to a pronoun or a zero in the main clause. With this construction, a listener will first hear a full clause which is phrased as if the reference of its arguments were known, and this is immediately followed up by an explicit formulation of the new referent. An example is from a conversation between two women who haven’t seen each other for a while. They live in different villages. The speaker is on a visit to the addressee’s village to check up on progress in a construction project at the village temple. The speaker had visited a few weeks earlier and had left money for the addressee to buy fertilizer. (365)
puj3j Øi s`uu` 4 Øj maa2 vaa3, buy come QPLR . INFER fertilizer ‘Did (you)i buy (it)j , (the) fertilizerj ?’
Example (365) constitutes a first mention of fertilizer in this interaction. But the earlier interaction and its current relevance (they are discussing a range of matters concerning the project’s progress) mean that the fertilizer is to some extent already mutually activated. Accordingly, the main clause in (365) treats it as activated. The zero reference presumes its addressee will know what is being referred to. But this is immediately followed up by a full nominal reference which makes explicit the reference of the zero in the main clause (as puj3 ‘fertilizer’). Note that its placement in the afterthought Right Position means this full nominal reference is phonologically weakened, lower in volume. The effect of the construction is to ostensibly treat the referential information as given (signaled by the referential structure of the main clause, in the case of (365) involving only zeroes), but by also ensuring that reference is safely made (after all, it is a first mention) by making reference fully explicit (albeit in a peripheral structure).
8.2.4
First mention as clausal subject
Subject position is reserved for topical referents, i.e., referents which are already given in the discourse. When a first mention appears in subject position, it typically occurs where the reference is already effectively given by virtue of the context or situation. For instance:
Subsequent reference-tracking
(366)
165
khon2 nii4 cap2 caan3 faat5 saj1 phuø-˜ning2 MC . HUM -woman CLF. PERSON DEM grab plate whack put toq2 table ‘This woman takes (a) plate (and) whacks (it) against (a) table.’
This is a description of a video clip the speaker has just watched. While the noun phrase meaning ‘this woman’ is technically a first-mention in terms of the linguistic discourse record, the referent has already been introduced into the perceptual and attentional common ground. Accordingly, by using the subject position, the speaker treats the woman’s referential identity as already given. Another situation in which referents may be treated as already given upon first mention in this way is when they have been covertly introduced by some kind of contextual frame. In an example, a hotel manager is asked if she ever encounters problems in the management of her hotel. In her response, she mentions kh`ee` k5 ‘guest(s)’ for the first time in the discourse: (367)
baang3-th`ua1 kh`ee` k5 vaa1 kh`uang1 kh`ee` k5 sia3 sometimes guest say stuff guest lost ‘Sometimes guests say that their stuff is missing.’
Once the topic of conversation had turned to the operating of a hotel, the notion of ‘guests’ was naturally activated. (Note that (367) may be read as a non-specific reference, while (366) may not.)
8.3
Subsequent reference-tracking
The basic pattern of reference tracking is for initial references to be done with full noun phrases, and (locally) subsequent references to be made by reduced, indexical nominal forms such as pronouns or so-called zero anaphors (cf. Chafe 1980, Fox 1987). Zero anaphora means complete ellipsis of nominal material in a referentially open slot (i.e., a slot whose reference is not syntactically controlled), leaving no phonological material in the expected argument slot. The gap which remains is like a pronoun in English in the sense that its reference is not syntactically controlled.
166
Reference management
(368)
laaw2 qaw3 caan3 faat5 saj1 kh`oo` p5 tang1 t`ee` k5 3 SG . FA take plate whack put edge chair break ‘Shei took the platej and whacked (it) against the edge of the chairk and Øi/j/k/l broke.’ vaang1 saj1 ph`uu` n4 l`ekaø p`uaj1 (369) phen1 cap2 namø-k`oo` n4 3. P grab CT. LIQUID-chunk place put floor C . LNK melt ‘S/hei grabbed some icej and placed it on the groundk and Øi/j/k/l melted.’ The kind of cross-clausal gap which results from ellipsis in these examples constitutes a syntactically controlled pivot in a number of languages including English (cf. Foley and Van Valin 1984, Dixon 1994). But in Lao there is no syntactic control over the reference of this kind of gap (cf. Chapter 11 for further discussion). Referents of the understood subjects of t`ee` k5 ‘break’ and p`uaj1 ‘melt’ in (368-369) could be anything at all which makes sense. This openness of reference is hardly as problematic as it might first seem, thanks to the ample constraints on interpretation which context provides. Without such concrete contextual information, listeners’ interpretations will appeal to common expectations, both from argument structure (constraints on possible theme arguments of ‘melt’) and cultural logic. We are highly likely to read the ‘zero’ subject of p`uaj1 ‘melt’ as referring to the ice mentioned in the previous clause. Zero anaphora in Lao is functionally equivalent to any system of referentially open (i.e., non syntactically controlled) indexical elements, such as pronouns in English. Languages like Lao have zero anaphora in addition to pronominal anaphora, and so a full account of reference tracking in Lao will have to deal not only with the contrast between reference using full nouns versus pronouns, but also with the contrast between using pronouns versus zero anaphora. The following example is a textbook case of standard introduction and step-by-step reduction of reference formulation. The discourse-initial reference in (370a) is made with a full, descriptive noun phrase complement of the presentational verb mii2; the subsequent reference is reduced in the following clause (370b) to a pronoun (3rd singular familiar laaw2), and in subsequent clauses to zero (370c, d):
Subsequent reference-tracking
(370)
167
a. mii2 [m`eø-paa4 phuø-n`ung1]i there.is CT. Mo-Pa.eZ MC . HUM-one buq2 l`ekaø b. [laaw2]i faaw4 paj3 n˜ ang3 3 SG . FA hurry go INDEF. INAN Q . UNKN C . LNK daj4 l`ekaø c. [Ø]i qat2 lotø-mˆeeˆ 2 capture CT. VEHICLE-bus CAN C . LNK d. [Ø]i kh`un5 maa2 loot4 ascend come NO . HES ‘There was one auntyi , shei was hurrying somewhere, and then Øi was able to stop the bus and then Øi got on without hesitation.’
In another example, two referents are activated. This immediately follows example (364), above, where both a prince and a holy hermit are introduced. The subject of the next verb in the sequence is the prince, and this is realized as zero (371a). The reference of the following subject argument (371b) switches to the hermit. This is a full noun phrase. The object of the same clause is the prince, a zero. In the following clause (371c), again hermit is subject, now a pronoun, and prince is object, still zero. (371)
qaa3khom2 l`ee` w4 a. lang3 caak5 Øi hian2 cop2 visaa2 study finish discipline incantation PRF back from b. phaq1-l`uu` 2sii3j kaø caø haj5 Øi kap2 maa2 baan4 holy.being-hermit T. LNK IRR give return come village maa2 m`uang2 laø come town and c. phen1j dajø qaw3 kh`oo` ng3-khuan3 haj5 Øi qanø-n`ung1 3. P ACHV take gift MC . INAN -one give ‘After [Ø]i graduated from studying magic incantations, [the hermit]j was going to let [Ø]i go home, and [he]j did give a gift to [Ø]i .’
While zero subjects in sequence will typically be coreferential, there is no structural constraint that makes it so (cf. examples (368-369), above). A further gradation of reference in a discourse sequence makes use of topic markers (see Chapter 6). In the first clause of the following example (372a)), lot1 tam3 kan3 ‘vehicle(s) (which) collide together’ introduces
168
Reference management
unspecified vehicles which were involved in a traffic accident that the speaker is going to describe. In the second clause (372b), the speaker specifies what the vehicles were. In subject position, he repeats the referential expression which he had used in the prior clause, now adding the general topic marker niø. In the predicate of this clause, he specifies and thereby introduces the two vehicle types, a truck and a motorcycle. Then again, in turn, he wants to comment on the motorcycle in particular. In the subsequent clause (372c), the motorcycle appears in Left Position, with a topic marker added (this time the distal topic marker hanø), functioning as an extraclausal topic for the predication which follows (‘All I saw was three dead people lying there on the road’): (372)
8.4
hˆen3 [lot1 tam3 kan3]i n`oq1 a. l`ee` w4 pajø PRF DIR . ABL see vehicle collide COLL QPLR . AGREE kap2 b. [lot1 tam3 kan3 niø]i m`ee` n1 [lotø-˜naj1]j vehicle collide COLL TPC COP CT. VEHICLE-big with n`oq1 [lotø-cak2]k CT. VEHICLE -motor QPLR . AGREE hanø]k kh`oo` j5 hˆen3 t`ee` 1 c. l`ee` w4 [lotø-cak2 PRF CT. VEHICLE -motor TPC . DIST 1 SG . P see only khon2 taaj3 n`oo` n2 juu1 thaang2 saam3 sop2 person die lie be.at road three corpse ‘Then (I) saw vehicles collide, right? These vehicles were a truck and a motorcycle, right? Then, (as for) the motorcycle, all I saw was three dead people lying there on the road.’
Remark
Chains of subsequent referential forms often switch between pronoun and zero, or occasionally back to some sort of full noun phrase. Principles by which speakers decide whether to formulate subsequent reference using full noun phrases (with or without one or another topic marker), definite pronouns (with or without one or another topic marker), or zeroes, no doubt make reference to many features of the current state of the discourse record. These features include number of referents being tracked at a given moment, their relative prominence on hierarchies of animacy
Remark
169
and topicality, discourse-interactional motivations for foregrounding or backgrounding certain (features of) referents, and the discourse-internal sub-structure of boundaries between events, episodes, and the like.
Part IV Verbs and Predication
Chapter 9 Aspectual-modal marking This chapter describes grammatical markers of aspectual and modal meaning around the Lao verb phrase.
9.1
Aspectual-modal markers
The Lao clausal core features an array of aspectual-modal markers. They can be depicted as slots, mostly coming between the subject (if one appears) and the verb phrase:
S/A
2ND POS
PRE-NEG IRR ASP-MOD
NEG
POST-NEG ASP-MOD
ACHV DIR
V(O)
POST-V ASP-MOD COMPLEX
SFPs
Figure 9.1. Slots for aspectual-modal operators in the Lao clause
For each slot in Figure 9.1, there is a paradigm of aspectual-modal markers which may occur in that slot. For some slots, the aspectualmodal markers which may appear number just one or two, while other slots are open to larger sets. Table 25 lists the possibilities.
174
Aspectual-modal marking
Table 25. Aspectual-modal markers, grouped by slot (see Figure 9.1) 2nd position kaø ‘topic linker’ (T. LNK) particles phatø ‘contrast linker’ (CONTR) Pre-neg. haa3-k`oo` 1 ‘just now’ (recent past; PST. RCNT) aspectualk`uap5 ‘almost’ (ALMOST) modals n˜ ang2 ‘still/yet’ (STILL) kamlang2 ‘progressive’ (PROG) kh`uu` 2 siø ‘probably’ (assumptive epistemic; PROB) qaat5 caø ‘might’ (speculative epistemic; SPEC) Irrealis caø/siø (IRR) Negation b`oø (NEG) Post-neg. kheej2 ‘have ever’ (experiential perfect; EXP) aspectualthan2 ‘yet, on time’ (ON . TIME) modals naan2 ‘take.long’ (TAKE . LONG) mak1 (caø) ‘tend to’ (TEND) t`oo` ng4 ‘must’ (general necessity, obligative; OBLIG) campˆen3 ‘have to’ (strong obligative; OBLIG . STR) khuan2 (caø) ‘should’ (weak obligative; OBLIG . WEAK) naa5 caø ‘should’ (counterfactual weak oblig; OBLIG . CF) saa3maat4 ‘able’ (abilitive; ABLE) Achievement dajø (ACHV) Directional pajø ‘ablative directional’ (DIR . ABL) maø ‘allative directional’ (DIR . ALL) Postverbal tal`oo` t5 ‘constantly, all the time’ (CONST) aspectuall`uajø-l`uaj4 ‘regularly, continually’ (REG) modal l`ee` w4 ‘already’ (perfect; PRF) complex heng3/don3 ‘for a long time’ (FOR . LONG) leej2 ‘without ado’ (NO . ADO) juu1 ‘continuous’ (CONT) loot4 ‘without hesitation’ (NO . HES) s`uø-s`uu` 1 ‘that’s all, nothing more’ (NOT. MORE) daj4 ‘can’ (general modal of possibility; CAN) pˆen3 ‘know how to’ (acquired abilitive; KNOW. HOW) vaj3 ‘be possible’ (PSBL)
In following sections, I describe these markers with illustrative examples. The analytic distinctions and terminology are taken from standard linguistic sources such as Comrie (1976, 1985) and Palmer (2001). If I use a term which is also used for an aspectual-modal marker in another
Aspectual-modal markers
175
language, I am not claiming that their meanings are exactly the same, only that they are comparable. Before beginning, I note a few general points about the system. The first point concerns the status of markers which are grouped in the three ‘ASP - MOD’ (aspectual-modal) slots in Figure 9.1 (pre-negation, post-negation, and postverbal). Many of them have double lives as open class items. Most of these are either erstwhile verbs or are still active as verbs. Typically, in closed class function, they will be phonologically reduced (de-stressed, cliticized), restricted in grammatical behavior (e.g., not taking negation), and demonstrably different in meaning to the open class function. An example is mak1, which may be a main verb meaning ‘to like’ (either to like a thing, or to like doing something), or may be an aspectual-modal marker meaning ‘tend to (be the case)’ or ‘likely to (be the case)’. There is a clear difference in meaning between the two functions. In support of this claim, consider the following word play that turns on this distinction: kh`oo` j5 mak1 l`uu` m2, t`ee` 1 kh`oo` j5 b`oø mak1 l`uu` m2 ‘I tend (=mak11 ) to forget, but I don’t like (=mak12 ) forgetting’. When mak1 occurs with an inanimate subject—something which cannot fill the role of ‘liker’—it is restricted to its ‘tend to’ meaning, as in the following example: (373)
th`ee` w3 nii4, khaw5 b`oø mak1 ngaam2 area DEM rice NEG tend look.good ‘(In) this area, rice tends not to look good (i.e., be of good quality).’
For other aspectual-modal markers which also function as verbs, it is not always clear that the verb meaning and the aspectual-modal meaning are significantly different. What appears to be an aspectual-modal marker may in fact be a verb in a multi-verb construction (one of the many kinds described in Part V of this book). Clearly, verb serialization is the path through which most of these markers have grammaticized (see Enfield 2003c for a case study). The present chapter concentrates mainly on those aspectual-modal markers that display the least verb-like properties (for example, being unable to take negation). A smaller number of the aspectual-modal markers are related to nouns. Where appropriate, in the discussion below, I shall remark on the open class function of the marker under discussion.
176
Aspectual-modal marking
Second, the apparently neat distribution of various grammatical markers across the array of slots in Figure 9.1 is to some extent an artifact of the grammarian’s need to bring order to a description of the verb-marking complex. A number of aspectual-modal markers may appear in more than one slot. For example, mak1 ‘tend to’, khuan2 ‘should’, and t`oo` ng4 ‘must’ can appear in both the pre-negation and post-negation slots. In Figure 9.1, I have assigned these more precocious operators to a slot where they occur more commonly or seem more natural. Placement in different slots may or may not entail a meaning difference. This variation is clearly associated with the vagaries of the source of these markers in multi-verb constructions, for which see Part V of this book. Where possible, in the discussion below, I shall note variation in the possible placement of an aspectual-modal marker, and any effects of this. Third, there may be dependencies between aspectual-modal markers which appear in different slots. Markers may or may not be used alone. Some markers obligatorily co-occur with other markers in other slots. Or such co-occurrence may be optional, but may signal idiosyncratic meaning differences. For example, the pre-negation aspectual-modal kh`uu` 2 may act as a modal meaning ‘probably’, in which function it must always be followed directly by the irrealis marker siø, as in the following example: (374)
paj3 phen1 kh`uu` 2-siø 3. P OBLIG . WEAK-IRR go ‘He is probably going.’
Kh`uu` 2 may also act as a content question marker meaning ‘why?’ in the same slot, but with this question function it CANNOT occur with the irrealis marker siø: (375)
phen1 kh`uu` 2 paj3 3. P WHY go ‘Why is he going?’
To give another example, as a post-negation aspectual-modal, than2 must always appear with negation, to mean ‘not yet’, as in the following example: (376)
phen1 b`oø than2 maa2 3. P NEG ON . TIME come ‘He hasn’t come yet.’
Aspectual-modal markers
177
A fourth preliminary point is that the internal structure of the slot labeled Post-Verbal Aspectual-Modal Complex in Figure 9.1 is deliberately left vague. It is not possible to neatly describe a general internal structure to it in terms of slots. Part V of this book surveys in detail many of the ways in which combinations of verbs (complementation-style or secondary-predication style) are employed for modification of predicates, yielding structures which look like or are identical to the kinds of post-verbal aspectual-modal structures described in the present chapter. The post-verbal aspectual modal complex can be like a mini verb phrase, which is internally complex and which, for instance, may take negation and other aspectual-modal markers internally. Here is an example of the postverbal aspectual-modal daj4 ‘can’ taking negation directly in postverbal position: (377)
phen1 paj3 b`oø daj4 3. P go NEG CAN ‘She can’t go.’
This negation directly on the modal can co-occur with negation on the main predicate. Compare (377) to the following, where negation appears twice: (378)
phen1 b`oø paj3 b`oø daj4 3. P NEG go NEG CAN ‘She can’t not go.’ (i.e., She must go.)
Fifth, note that the system of markers described in this chapter is not the only site for expression of modal meaning. Sentence-final particles, described in Chapter 4, above, typically encode meanings concerning the stance of the speaker toward the proposition, along with suppositions about the addressee’s stance. This often relates to distinctions which would normally come under the heading of epistemic modality or evidentiality. Finally, note that there is no general or obligatory grammatical marking of tense in Lao. Utterances are open to interpretation as being situated in past, present, or future time. So, when supplied out of context, a simple utterance like the following is open to several readings:
178 (379)
Aspectual-modal marking
phen1 kiaw1 khaw5 3. P harvest rice i. ‘She will harvest rice (e.g., tomorrow).’ ii. ‘She harvested rice (e.g., yesterday).’ iii. ‘She is harvesting rice (now).’
The irrealis markers siø/caø are often used in utterances which represent future or intended states of affairs, but their use does not entail future tense. The ‘future’ orientation of the irrealis markers may be anchored in a point in time other than the speech event itself, i.e., any time in the past or future (see section 9.1.4, below). The following sections present brief descriptions of each aspectualmodal marker, along with examples. We begin with the somewhat heterogeneous postverbal aspectual-modals, before working through the set of preverbal slots in order from left to right (see Figure 9.1).
9.1.1
Post-verbal aspectual-modal markers
tal`oo` t5 – ‘constantly, all the time’ (CONST) The word tal`oo` t5 is like a particle in that it has no verb-like properties (e.g., it cannot take negation, it cannot be reduplicated). It conveys the idea that a state of affairs is the case all the time or continually, or for an extended period. For example, a speaker is describing a days-long boat journey from Southern Laos to Vientiane, where he is employed as a laborer. He follows orders and works away the whole time, marking this sustained activity with tal`oo` t5: (380)
mian4 taam3 khaw3 b`oo` k5, hˆet1 haw2 kaø leejø do 1. FA T. LNK NO . ADO clear.up follow 3 PL . B tell maa2 tal`oo` t5 thaw1 h`oo` t4 viang2can3 n`ee` w2 nan4 manner DEM . NONPROX come CONST until reach V ‘So I cleared up according to what they told me, did that continually until reaching Vientiane.’
In another example, a speaker is describing the risky conditions in immediate post-revolutionary urban Laos (1975-1985), at a time when the new government was cracking down on what were regarded as socially
Aspectual-modal markers
179
undesirable elements. This included the youth culture associated with sex, drugs, and rock-n-roll. He points out that to wear flashy clothes all the time (as marked by tal`oo` t5) would be to invite a warning (and risk being sent for political re-education): (381)
thaa5-haak5 vaa1 caw4 nung1 kh`uang1 ngamø-ngaam2 COMP 2 SG . P wear clothes RDP. A -nice if-in.case ngapø-ngaap4 juu1 tal`oo` t5 khaw3 kaø qeen4 pajø t`uan3 RDP. A -flashy be.at CONST 3 SG . P T. LNK call DIR . ABL warn ‘If you wore kind of nice, kind of flashy clothes all the time, they would call you for a warning.’
luajø-l uaj4 – ‘regularly, often’ (REG) ` ` The inherently A-Type reduplicated phrase l`uajø-l`uaj4 (with few verbal properties; e.g., no negation) has a similar meaning to tal`oo` t5, but may also imply a sense of regular repetition of the predicate, possibly with some time intervening. For example, a woman working for a government institute is talking about her father, and states that her boss comes to visit him regularly, marking this with l`uajø-l`uaj4: (382)
hua3-naa5 sathaa3ban3 laø maa2 lin5 nam2 phen1 PRF come play with 3. P head-front institute luajø-l uaj4 ` ` REG
‘The chief of the institute comes to see him regularly.’ In another example, a man is talking about his previous job as a policeman, and describes his working relationship with a man who served in the police force of a neighboring district. They would encounter each other regularly, as marked by l`uajø-l`uaj4: (383)
ph`oo` 4 kan3 luajø-l uaj4 pajø ` ` DIR . ABL meet COLL REG ‘(We’d) meet each other regularly.’
In another example, a woman and her bandit husband are journeying on foot. They come to a river. He tells her that he will go across the river to fetch a raft and come back to get her and ferry her across. But he goes ahead without stopping (as marked by l`uajø-l`uaj4), leaving her behind
180
Aspectual-modal marking
for good. She can’t see him anywhere, and she has no chance of catching up with him: (384)
paj3 naa5 luajø-l uaj4 ph`oq1 vaa1 coon3 nanø ` ` because COMP bandit TPC . NONPROX go front REG dˆeeˆ 4 FAC . FILLIN ‘Because the bandit went ahead continually (i.e., without stopping), you see.’
In this case, we see semantic overlap between l`uajø-l`uaj4 and tal`oo` t5, where both may mean ‘continually, without stopping’. In a final example, a speaker is talking about the early days of the revolution of 1975. At that time, many Vientiane people fled across the Mekong River as refugees. This speaker was afraid to do this, since there were often potentially lethal exchanges with security forces. The regularity of these incidents is marked here with l`uajø-l`uaj4: uaj4 juu1 (385) daj4-˜nin2 vaa1 khaw3 n˜ ing2 kan3 juu1 luajø-l ` ` COMP 3 PL . B shoot COLL CONT REG be.at hear kh`ee` m2 kh`oo` ng3 bank Mekong ‘I heard they were shooting each other regularly along the banks of the Mekong.’ l`ee` w4 – perfect marker (PRF) As a verb, l`ee` w4 means ‘to be finished’ or ‘to finish something (off)’: (386)
kuu3 siø l`ee` w4 viak4 nii4 k`oo` n1 1 SG . B IRR finish.off work DEM before ‘I’ll finish off this work first.’
As a postverbal marker, l`ee` w4 conveys the idea that an event or state transition has taken place, and the state of affairs resulting from that transition (now/still) pertains at the time of speech. Accordingly, I gloss it as ‘perfect’ (PRF) (cf. Comrie 1976:52ff). In an example, a speaker relates an experience when he and his wife are at the market and see a large goose at a bargain price. They want to buy it, but don’t have enough cash. The two decide to go home together to get money, but when they come
Aspectual-modal markers
181
back for the goose, it has been sold to someone and is already gone. This is captured using l`ee` w4: (387)
kin3 l`ee` w4 maa2, khaw3 qaw3 pajø come 3 PL . B take DIR . ABL eat PRF ‘(Having) come (back), they had taken (it) to eat already.’
There will be different interpretations of l`ee` w4 depending on the internal aspectual structure of the predicate which it marks. The simplest cases involve achievement verbs with meanings like taaj3 ‘die’ and h`oo` t4 ‘arrive’, whose aspectual structures consist of a single transition from one state (e.g., alive, absent) to another (e.g., dead, present). With these predicates, marking with l`ee` w4 straightforwardly gives rise to an interpretation that the state which results from the transition inherent to the verb’s meaning pertains at the time of speech—e.g., ‘dead’ in the case of ‘die’, ‘present’ in the case of ‘arrive’: (388)
a. man2 taaj3 l`ee` w4 3. B die PRF ‘It has died.’ b. khaw3 h`oo` t4 l`ee` w4 3 PL . B arrive PRF ‘They have arrived.’
With other semantic classes of verb, ambiguities arise, because the semantic structure of the predicate features more than one transition of states of affairs that may be picked out by l`ee` w4. For example, with an activity verb like maa2 ‘come’, the relevant transition might be the onset of the activity of coming (i.e., having left, being on the way), or the completion of the activity of coming (i.e., having arrived), resulting in the following ambiguity: (389)
khacaw4 maa2 l`ee` w4 3 PL . P come PRF i. ‘They’ve already left (and are now on the way here).’ ii. ‘They’ve already arrived (and are now here).’
If necessary, this ambiguity can be removed by using multi-verb constructions to make the event structure more explicit. For example, the (389i) reading may be forced by inclusion of the verb q`oo` k5 ‘exit’ in a path-direction construction, as in (390):
182 (390)
Aspectual-modal marking
khacaw4 q`oo` k5 maa2 l`ee` w4 3 PL . P exit come PRF ‘They’ve already left (and are coming).’ (= 389i, = 389ii)
Or, the (389ii) reading may be forced by inclusion of a resultative achievement verb like h`oo` t4 ‘reach, arrive’, as in (391): (391) khacaw4 maa2 h`oo` t4 l`ee` w4 3 PL . P come reach PRF ‘They’ve (come and have) already arrived.’ (= 389ii, = 389i) Similarly, with accomplishment verbs like tom4 ‘to boil (tr.)’, there is more than one transition-from-one-state-of-affairs-to-another which l`ee` w4 might profile—i.e., either the onset of having been put to boil (392i), or the completion of having come to the boil (392ii): tom4 l`ee` w4 (392) nam4 nan4 water DEM . NONPROX boil PRF i. ‘That water has already been put to boil (and is now heating up).’ ii. ‘That water has already been boiled (and is now okay to drink).’ With adjectives and other stative verbs, l`ee` w4 has a coercive effect, foregrounding or imposing a state change (which may otherwise be merely implied) on the reading of the predicate. For example, for adjectives like thaw5 ‘old (of a person)’ or stative verbs like mii2 ‘have’, which each presuppose or imply a natural transitional onset (aging or acquiring), it is this onset that will be picked out by l`ee` w4: (393)
(394)
phen1 thaw5 l`ee` w4 3. P old PRF ‘He’s already old; He has become old.’ kh`oo` j5 mii2 l`ee` w4 1 SG . P have PRF ‘I already have (one); I got (one) already.’
For adjectives like d`ee` ng3 ‘red’, l`ee` w4 will coerce an inchoative reading by introducing a state change into a predication which normally conveys no more than a simple state:
Aspectual-modal markers
(395)
183
man2 d`ee` ng3 l`ee` w4 PRF 3. B red ‘It’s already red; It’s become red.’
When marking a negated predicate, l`ee` w4 may mean ‘not any more’. In an example, an ogre captures a new wife, and while he is sleeping, she is taken away. Upon waking, the ogre cannot see his wife. The speaker employs l`ee` w4 as a way of profiling the transition into the state of not being seen, i.e., the wife’s kidnapping: (396)
b`oø hˆen3 mia2 l`ee` w4 NEG see wife PRF ‘(He) couldn’t see (his) wife any more.’
Note that negation may also occur directly on l`ee` w4 itself, but this is only where it is interpreted as having its full verb meaning ‘to finish off’, e.g., as V2 in a resultative construction (cf. Chapter 17): (397) man2 puk2 h`uan2 b`oø l`ee` w4 3. B build house NEG finish.off ‘He didn’t finish building the house.’ When postverbal l`ee` w4 has its aspectual function, it may not be negated, as shown in this ungrammatical version of (393), above: (398)
* phen1 thaw5 b`oø l`ee` w4 3. P old NEG PRF (He’s not finished getting old?)
The meaning and structural position of l`ee` w4 as a post-verbal marker of completion lends it naturally to functioning as a connector between predications in a narrative sequence. In an example, a speaker is talking about his early education. He explains that he went to a particular temple to be trained as a monk. Marking with l`ee` w4 on the first clause shows that the first state of affairs is completed (he is ordained) and pertains as a condition for the state of affairs in the subsequent clause (he passes his higher-level exams): daj4 qiik5 (399) buat5 l`ee` w4 kaø s`oo` p5 nakø-tham2 ordain PRF T. LNK test CT. AGT-dharma succeed more ‘Having been ordained, (I) passed my exams as a practitioner of the dharma.’
184
Aspectual-modal marking
In another example, the speaker is describing his police training. In the first clause, he completes his studies (marked by l`ee` w4), after which, and conditional upon which, in the second clause, he is given the rank of sergeant: (400)
hian2 cop2 l`ee` w4 phen1 haj5 sip2-qˆeeˆ k5 study graduate PRF 3. P give sergeant ‘Having graduated already, they gave (me the rank of) sergeant.’
In another example, a market lady is telling a customer how to cook the sausages she is trying to sell him. She uses l`ee` w4 to mark the completion of one step as a condition for going on to the next: muu3 man2 fot2 d`ee` 1 l`ee` w4 (401) lang3 caak5 namø-man2 back from CT. LIQUID-oily pig 3. B boil a.little PRF caw4 kaø qaw3 saj5-k`oo` k5 niø long2 TPC descend 2 SG . P T. LNK take sausage ‘After the pork oil is boiling a little, you put the sausages in.’ Note in example (401), l`ee` w4 is postverbal to the first clause, and kaø is in second position to the second clause, with the subject of the second clause—caw4 ‘you’—intervening. It is often the case that the subject of the second clause is ellipsed, as in (399), above, with the result that l`ee` w4 and kaø come together. This appears to be a very common phenomenon, resulting in the grammaticization of a clause linking particle l`ekaø, a phonologically reduced form of l`ee` w4 kaø: (402)
khaw3 kin3 khaw5-saw4 l`ekaø m`ua2 3 PL . B eat rice-morning C . LNK return ‘They ate breakfast and then returned.’
don3/heng3 – ‘for a long time’ (FOR . LONG) The notion of ‘a long time’ may be expressed by don3 and heng3 in postverbal aspectual-modal function. These are distinctly verb-like, for example allowing both reduplication and negation. I am not aware of any distinguishable differences in semantics or grammar between these two words. The difference appears to be sociolinguistic, with heng3 having a more rustic feel. They occur immediately after the verb phrase which they modify, conveying the idea that the state of affairs predicated by the verb phrase is the case for a long time:
Aspectual-modal markers
(403)
(404)
(405)
(406)
185
l`ee` w4 laaw2 nang1 juu1 don3 CONT FOR . LONG PRF 3 SG . FA sit ‘He had been sitting a long time (before he noticed...).’ maø juu1 laaw2 don3 l`ee` w4 DIR . ALL be.at Laos FOR . LONG PRF ‘(He) had been (here) in Laos for a long time already.’ s`uu` 4 vaj4 kin3 kum4 don3 buy keep eat cover FOR . LONG ‘Buy (these sausages) to put aside to keep for a long time.’ huaj4, suu3 phatø maa2 heng3 paan3 daj3 niø INTJ 2 PL . B CONTR come FOR . LONG extent INDEF TPC ‘Hey, how long have you all been here?’
Don3 and heng3 may be Type A reduplicated, like regular adjectives (cf. Chapter 10, section 10.2.3): l`ee` w4 man2 c`uu` t5 khan2 thaa5 haw2 tom4 donø-don3 if if 1. FA boil RDP. A-FOR . LONG PRF 3. B bland kin3 sabaaj3 eat easy ‘If we boil (the bamboo shoots) for a rather long time, then they are going to be bland (i.e., no longer bitter) and easy to eat.’ haj5 man2 c`uu` t5 (408) tom4 qanø hengø-heng3 boil HES RDP. A-FOR . LONG give 3. B bland ‘Boil um (the bamboo shoots) for a rather long time and make them bland (i.e., no longer bitter).’ (407)
The markers don3 and heng3 may be compared to the pre-negation aspectual-modal naan2 ‘take a long time’ (section 9.1.6, below). While don3 and heng3 scope over a state of affairs from the beginning of its inception, naan2 refers to the length of time PRECEDING the inception of the state of affairs. So, while don3 and heng3 mean ‘FOR a long time’, naan2 means that the event ‘TAKES a long time’ to occur. Consider these contrasts: (409)
saw2 a. naan2 TAKE . LONG stop ‘It’s taking a long time to stop.’
186
Aspectual-modal marking
b. saw2 don3 stop FOR . LONG ‘It has stopped for a long time.’ The following examples both describe a scene of waiting at a red traffic light for a long time. (410a), using naan2 ‘take a long time’, frames it in terms of how long it is taking for the lights to go green, while (410b), using don3 ‘for a long time’ frames it in terms of how long it is that the lights are staying red: (410)
khiaw3 a. naan2 TAKE . LONG green ‘(It’s) taking a long time to (go) green.’ b. d`ee` ng3 don3 FOR . LONG red ‘(It’s staying) red for a long time.’
juu1 – continuous (CONT) As a main verb, juu1 means ‘to be somewhere’ or ‘to live somewhere’: man2 juu1 talaat5 3. B be.at market ‘He is at the market.’ (412) man2 juu1 viang2can3 3. B BE . AT V i. ‘He is in Vientiane.’ ii. ‘He lives in Vientiane.’
(411)
With this meaning, juu1 also serves as a locative adjunct marker: (413)
saa3lavat1-thahaan3 juu1 pajø pˆen3 nakø-hian2 DIR . ABL COP CT. AGT-student police-military be.at khaaj4 n`oo` ng3-duang4 barracks N-D ‘(I) went to be a military police student at the Nong Douang Barracks.’
Aspectual-modal markers
(414)
187
phen1 l`uaj1 maj4 juu1 vat1 3. P saw wood be.at temple ‘He’s sawing wood at the temple.’
As a postverbal aspectual-modal, juu1 is associated with the notion of a present, ongoing, continuous state of affairs. Juu1 often co-occurs with semantically similar markers such as n˜ ang2 still’, as in (415-416) or kamlang2 ‘PROG’, as in (417): diaw3-nii4 khan`oo` j5 nang2 mii2 luuk4 q`oo` n1 juu1 ˜ NOW 1 SG . FO STILL have child weak CONT ‘Now, I presently still have a dependent child.’ (416) tham2 kaan3 b`oø dii3 juu1 naj2 qanø t`oo` n3 thii1 nang2 pˆen3 ˜ NZR NEG good be.at in HES time REL STILL COP do khon2 juu1 person CONT ‘(They) did bad things in um the time that they were still people.’ (417) nam4 kamlang2 fot2 juu1 boil CONT water PROG ‘The water is boiling (now).’
(415)
Juu1 may also mark continuous state or action without these other, similar markers (cf. (415) and (417)): (418)
(419)
(420)
diaw3-nii4 khan`oo` j5 mii2 luuk4 q`oo` n1 juu1 NOW 1 SG . FO have child weak CONT ‘Now, I presently still have a dependent child.’ nam4 fot2 juu1 water boil CONT ‘The water is boiling (now).’ khaw3 maa2 juu1 3 PL . B come CONT ‘They are coming (now).’
Another example shows juu1 marking one state of affairs as ongoing (sitting and selling sausages), in order to frame another (calling out):
188 (421)
Aspectual-modal marking
m`eø-paa4 nanø, laaw2 kaø nang1 khaaj3 CT. M o- P a.e Z TPC . NONPROX 3 SG . FA T. LNK sit sell saj5-k`oo` k5 juu1 l`ekaø h`oo` ng4 CONT C . LNK call sausage ‘That aunty, she was sitting and selling sausages, and (she) called out...’
In a final example, the notion of continuous, ongoing state of affairs conveyed by juu1 is in line with the iterated onomatopoeic puaq2, referring to the bubbling of boiling water: (422)
fot2 puaq2-puaq2-puaq2-puaq2 juu1 CONT boil ONOM ‘(It) was boiling puaq-puaq-puaq-puaq.’
leej2 – ‘without (further) ado’ (NO . ADO) As a verb, leej2 means ‘to go beyond’. It is much more common, however, as a postverbal aspectual-modal. In its postverbal aspectual-modal usage, leej2 conveys the idea that a state of affairs is the case without anything else happening—e.g., without hesitation or other delaying action. Postverbal leej2 cannot take negation. When used with agentive verbs, leej2 conveys the idea that the agent does not hesitate or engage in any activity other than that of the main predicate. In an example, a man wants to flee from his wife. He tells her he’s crossing the river to get a raft in order to come back and pick her up. Instead, once across the river, he flees without ado: l`ee` w4 laø m`ee` n1 nii3 paj3 (423) paj3 h`oo` t4 fang1 nan4 go reach bank DEM . NONPROX PRF and BE . SO flee go leej2 NO . ADO ‘(He) went to the other side, and then fled without ado.’ In another example, a man is pushed over a cliff, leej2 here conveying a lack of hesitation on the part of the culprits: (424)
suk1 long2 hˆeeˆ w3, suk1 long2 paj3 leej2 push descend cliff push descend go NO . ADO ‘(They) pushed (him) down the cliff. (They) pushed (him) down without any ado.’
Aspectual-modal markers
189
In another example, a man describes a government project to build an irrigation channel which was destroyed by heavy rain at a late stage. In this case, postverbal leej2 is translatable as ‘at all’: (425)
kh`oo` ng2-m`uang3 kaø saj4 b`oø daj4, b`oø dajø saj4 irrigation.channel T. LNK use NEG can NEG ACHV use leej2 n˜ ang3 INDEF. INAN NO . ADO ‘The irrigation channel was then unusable, (it) wasn’t used for anything at all.’
With non-stative verbs whose subjects are not animate, leej2 gives the idea that ‘nothing else happened’: (426)
man2 labeet5 leej2 3. B explode NO . ADO ‘It simply exploded.’
With verbs that predicate states rather than actions, postverbal leej2 may invoke some reference to an underlying action component of the utterance. For example, in using leej2 with met2 ‘to be finished up’ as a main verb, we get the idea that the events which caused it (e.g., people eating) were concentrated and unwavering: (427)
khaw5 met2 leej2 rice finished NO . ADO ‘The rice is all finished (eaten up completely, suddenly, unexpectedly).’
Like l`ee` w4, discussed above, postverbal leej2 may serve as a connector between clauses, as a result of its final positioning on a first clause, adjoined then to a second clause which predicates a subsequent course of action or events. In this function, it is often translatable with ‘then’ or ‘and so’: (428)
leej2 maa2 h`uan2 man2 paj3 saj1 tum4 3. B go put basket.trap NO . ADO come house ‘He went to place a basket trap and then came (straight) home.’
Often in this function, leej2 is preceded by the topic linker kaø. Consider the following two examples:
190
Aspectual-modal marking
(429)
jaak5 daj4 pajø hˆet1 mia2, kaø-leej2 keet5 want acquire DIR . ABL make wife T. LNK-NO . ADO happen kaan3 t`oo` 1-suu5 kan3 kh`un5, n˜ aat4-˜ne` e` ng1 qaw3 mia2 kan3 NZR struggle COLL arise snatch take wife COLL ‘(The two bandits) wanted (her) as a wife, and so without ado there erupted fighting, competing against each other to take (her) as a wife.’ mii2 m`ee` n1 (430) jaak5 huu4 vaa1 m`ee` n1 kap2 nanø want know COMP COP box DEM . NONPROX there.is COP juu1 naj2 han5, kaø-leej2 khaj3 n˜ ang3 INDEF. INAN be.at inside DEM . DIST T. LNK - NO . ADO open beng1 look ‘(He) wanted to know what was in that box, and so without ado (he) opened it to look.’
Examples such as the following illustrate leej2 with this kind of meaning in a second position slot (see below). In this example, leej2 occurs after the subject of the second clause in the series (i.e., kh`oo` j5 ‘I’): (431)
kh`oo` j5 m`oo` 1 h`oo` t4 talaat5 dong3-paa1-laan2 hanø, TPC . DIST 1 SG . P close reach market D-P-L khan2 leej2 hˆen3 qaa1 lot1-cak2 NO . ADO see HES CT. VEHICLE -motorcycle CLF. VEHICLE n`ung1 l`ee` n1- l`ee` n1 k`oo` n1 kh`oo` j5 hanø naa3 one run run before 1 SG . P TPC . DIST FAC . EXPLIC ‘Close to reaching the Dongpalane market there, I then saw um a motorcycle riding in front of me.’
Finally, note that leej2 may occur together with other postverbal aspectualmodal markers, typically in final position. For example: (432)
phen1 kin3 b`oø daj4 leej2 3. P eat NEG CAN NO . ADO ‘She can’t eat (it) at all.’
loot4 – ‘without hesitation’ (NO . HES) Loot4 is very similar in meaning to leej2, just described. It is apparently
Aspectual-modal markers
191
more restricted in distribution, normally only occurring with predicates of action, and less likely to occur with stative expressions such as (427), above. Here are some examples: (433)
(434)
(435)
m`ung2 qaw3 paj3 loot4 2 SG . B take go NO . HES ‘You go ahead and take (them) right away!’ phaj3 nam2 qaw3 n`oo` ng4 maø haj5, siø m`oo` p4 m`uang2 DIR . ALL give IRR present kingdom who go.get take yG haj5 loot4 give NO . HES ‘Whoever brings (my) younger sister (to me), (I) will present my kingdom to them without hesitation.’ kaø m`uu` 4-l`ee` ng2 qaw3 ngen2 paj3 haj5 m`eø-thaw5 loot4 T. LNK day-evening take money go give CT. M o-old NO . HES ‘So (that) evening (I) took the money and gave it to (my) motherin-law without hesitation.’
suø-s ` u` u1 ` – ‘that’s all, nothing more’ (NOT. MORE) The phrase s`uø-s`uu` 1 is an Type A reduplication of s`uu` 1, an adjective meaning ‘straight, direct’: (436) kh`oo` j5 jaak5 daj4 maj4 suø-s ` u` u1 ` 1 SG . P want acquire wood RDP. A-straight ‘I want a straight-ish (piece of) wood.’ As a post-verbal aspectual-modal, s`uø-s`uu` 1 means ‘that’s all, nothing more’. In an example, a speaker explains that hippies from Western countries who were in Vientiane just prior to the revolution in 1975 were not there to seek work or the like, all they wanted to do was goof off and have fun. The notion ‘that’s all’ is marked by s`uø-s`uu` 1: (437)
thiaw1 maø kin3 suø-s man2 tang4 maø ` u` u1 ` 3. B intend DIR . ALL tour DIR . ALL consume NOT. MORE ‘Their intention was just to tour around and to consume, that’s all.’
192
Aspectual-modal marking
In another example, a speaker describes a period of hard times in which citizens were required to be fully self-sufficient, and had only enough food to feed themselves: (438) q`oo` k5 h`ee` ng2 puuk5 phak2 puuk5 mii1, ph`oo` 2 dajø kin3 exit force plant vegetable plant noodle enough ACHV eat khaw5 suø-s ` u` u1 ` rice NOT. MORE ‘Working to plant vegetables and the like, it was just enough to eat (with) rice, nothing more.’ In another example, a speaker explains that immediately after the revolution of 1975, those who were seen to be associated with hippies or other social undesirables were taken away for a period of re-education. He explains that one would be targeted just for having long hair: (439)
kaø qaw3 paj3 phom3 n˜ aaw2 suø-s ` u` u1 ` hair long NOT. MORE T. LNK take go ‘Just for (having) long hair, (they’d) take (you) away.’
daj4 – general modal of possibility (CAN) The word daj4 has multiple aspectual-modal functions (Enfield 2003c). As a main verb, it means ‘acquire’: (440) kh`oo` j5 saj1 tum4 l`ekaø daj4 qian1 s`oo` ng3 too3 CLF. ANIM 1 SG . P put basket.trap LINK acquire eel two ‘I laid a basket trap and got two eels.’ In its postverbal modal function, daj4 shows a number of definitive verb properties, such as the possibility of direct negation, as illustrated here: (441)
suung3 m`eø-˜ning2 kh`un5 b`oø daj4, haw2 ton4-maj4 CT. PLANT -wood tall CT. M o-woman ascend NEG CAN 1. FA kh`un5 daj4 ascend CAN ‘Tall trees, women can’t climb, (but) we (men) can climb (them).’
Aspectual-modal markers
193
As a postverbal aspectual-modal, daj4 is a general modal of possibility, covering a range of modal distinctions, including abilitive and permissive. As in the English translation, the (in)ability predicated in the following example encompasses both ‘can of ability’ (in various sub-senses; Palmer 2001:77ff) and ‘can of permission’: (442)
phen1 vaw4 phaa2saa3 laaw2 b`oø daj4 3. P speak language Lao NEG CAN ‘She can’t speak Lao.’
This could be because her mother forbids her to speak Lao, she has never studied Lao, or she’s tired, she can’t think, among other reasons. In another example, having assessed a group of contenders for a championship fight, an employee of the king uses daj4 ‘can’ to mean ‘may, allowed to’ in telling those who were not selected that they are free to go home: (443)
kap2 baan4 daj4 return home CAN ‘(You) may return home.’
In the following three examples, daj4 ‘can’ marks possibility due to physical, learned, or other capacity: b`ee` k5 b`oø daj4 (444) kh`oo` ng3 nak2 m`eø-˜ning2 things heavy CT. Mo-woman carry.on.back NEG CAN ‘Heavy things, women can’t carry.’ (445) l`uang1 phii3 niø kh`oo` j5 kaø law1 haj5 daj4 story spirit TPC 1 SG . P T. LNK tell give CAN ‘(As for) the matter of spirits, I can tell (you about it).’ (446) b`oø luk1 kaø b`oø daj4 NEG arise T. LNK NEG CAN ‘We couldn’t not get up (in the morning).’ (i.e. ‘We had no choice but to get up.’) Other modals are more restrictive than daj4 in their semantics, and do not allow this wider range of modal interpretations. The following example, using the postverbal acquired abilitive dynamic modal pˆen3 (see below), entails that the subject cannot speak Lao, and could not speak Lao if he wanted to (i.e., has never spoken it):
194 (447)
Aspectual-modal marking
phen1 vaw4 phaa2saa3 laaw2 b`oø pˆen3 3. P speak language Lao NEG KNOW. HOW ‘He is incapable of speaking Lao.’ (...doesn’t know how to...)
It would not make sense to use this expression in a context in which he is capable of speaking Lao, but is not ALLOWED to. If the contextual background explanation for (447) were ‘...because his mother forbids him to’, the interpretation would have to be that his mother had always forbidden him to speak, and so he never learned, and therefore now cannot speak and could not speak if he wanted to. The meaning of daj4 ‘can’ in (442) is more general than this other postverbal modal pˆen3 ‘know how to, be able to if wants to’ in (447). It is rare for an unmarked V-daj4 expression to convey an epistemic (speculative) modality interpretation, although this interpretation is made more likely or acceptable by the presence of the topic linker kaø. The epistemic interpretation is more readily achieved by an idiomatic expression pˆen3 paj3 daj4 [COP go CAN] ‘it’s possible’, or less commonly pˆen3 daj4 [COP CAN] as in this example: (448)
qaat5 caø th`uu` k5 cap2 kaø pˆen3 daj4 might IRR suffer catch T. LNK COP CAN ‘It’s possible that you would even be arrested.’
In this case, postverbal daj4 alone (i.e., without the copula pˆen3) would remain compatible with an epistemic interpretation. A second construction which lends itself to epistemic interpretations involves the preverbal abilitive marker saa3maat4 in combination with daj4 (see section 9.1.6, below). It is not that epistemic modality represents a separate MEANING for ‘can’, but rather a contextual reading, pragmatically emergent due to a common pattern of inference from which epistemic meanings transpire (Bybee and Pagliuca 1985:73, Traugott 1989, Sweetser 1990:54, Hopper and Traugott 1993:79). The grammatical behavior of daj4 shows close parallels to resultative and adverbial constructions (see Chapters 17 and 21). First, daj4 ‘can’ appears to the right of a verb phrase, in V2 position (as illustrated in (443), above). Second, daj4 ‘can’ is head of the construction for yesanswer purposes:
Aspectual-modal markers
(449)
195
Q laaw2 vaw4 phaa2saa3 laaw2 daj4 b`oo` 3 3 SG . FA speak language Lao CAN QPLR ‘Can she speak Lao?’ Ai daj4 CAN
‘(Yes, she) can (speak Lao).’ Aii * vaw4 (phaa2saa3 laaw2) speak (language Lao) ((Yes, she can) speak (Lao).) Third, negation is usually marked directly on daj4 ‘can’ rather than the main verb: (450)
laaw2 vaw4 phaa2saa3 laaw2 b`oø daj4 3 SG . FA speak language Lao NEG CAN ‘She cannot speak Lao.’
But postverbal modal daj4 is distinct from many resultative verbs in that it cannot be separated from the preceding verb phrase by the clause linker l`ekaø: (451)
* laaw2 vaw4 phaa2saa3 laaw2 l`ekaø daj4 3 SG . FA speak language Lao C . LNK CAN (She speaks Lao and can.)
The non clause-separability shown in (451) demonstrates that the two verbs are not in a relationship of coordination. The following examples show postverbal daj4 ‘can’ directly adjoining the topic linker kaø, a common pattern which is typically translatable along the lines ‘It’s okay to’: (452)
(453)
hˆet1 juu1 theng2 phoon2 kaø daj4 make be.at on.top hillock T. LNK CAN ‘It’s okay to make (them; i.e., chicken coops) on hillocks.’ n˜ u` u` 4-qaw3 kaø daj4 reach.across-take T. LNK CAN ‘It’s okay to reach across and take (some).’
196
Aspectual-modal marking
pˆen3 – acquired abilitive dynamic modal (KNOW. HOW) As a main verb, pˆen3 is a copula, used, for example, when stating people’s occupations or kin relations: phen1 pˆen3 qaa3 kh`oo` j5 3. P COP Fa.yZ 1 SG . P ‘She is my younger maternal aunt.’ (455) phen1 pˆen3 thahaan3 3. P COP soldier ‘She is a soldier.’
(454)
Pˆen3 may also be used to denote suffering from an illness, where the A argument is the sufferer and the O argument is the illness: (456)
phen1 pˆen3 vat2/khaj5/qˆeeˆ t5/malˆeeˆ ng2 3. P COP cold/fever/AIDS/cancer ‘He has a cold/fever/AIDS/cancer.’
(See chapter 17, section 17.1.3.3, for description of a function of pˆen3 in marking secondary predicative adjuncts.) As a post-verbal aspectual-modal, pˆen3 is a dynamic modal of acquired ability. It denotes a subject’s ability to do something, in the specific sense of knowing how to do it, through having learnt it or experienced it before: (457)
(458)
(459)
kh`oo` j5 vaw4 phaa2saa3 ciin3 b`oø pˆen3 1 SG . P speak language Chinese NEG KNOW. HOW ‘I don’t know how to speak Chinese.’ man2 l`oo` j2 nam4 pˆen3 3. B float water KNOW. HOW ‘He knows how to swim.’ (i.e., ‘...can swim.’) caw4 kin3 qahaan3 laaw2 pˆen3 b`oo` 3 2 SG . P eat food Lao KNOW. HOW QPLR ‘Do you know how to eat Lao food?’
Aspectual-modal markers
197
vaj3 – modal of possible result (PSBL) The verb vaj3 to move’ occasionally serves a postverbal modal function. It acts as a maximally general resultative complement for active verbs (cf. Chapter 19), and is typically negated, to mean that the marked state of affairs is an impossibility (in the sense of dynamic modality of physical ability or possibility). For example, a man tries to lift a car with his bare hands but it proves too heavy: (460)
n˜ ok1 b`oø vaj3 lift NEG PSBL ‘(I) cannot lift it.’ (i.e., ‘I lift (it, it) doesn’t move.’)
In another example, a man gets into a fist fight but is unable to stand up to his opponent: (461)
suu5 b`oø vaj3 m`oo` 3 nan4 bloke DEM . NONPROX fight NEG PSBL ‘That bloke was unable to fight.’
9.1.2
Second-position markers
kaø – topic linker (T. LNK) The more common of the two second position markers is kaø. ‘Second position’ here means the position immediately after the subject— that is, second position in the clausal core, not counting the Left Position in which extraposed topics may appear (see Figure 1.1, above). A second position particle is a sentence-level marker, and cannot appear inside clauses which are tightly subordinated to main predicates (such as controlled complement clauses) or which are modifiers in noun phrases (i.e., relative clauses). The second-position particle appears immediately before the main verb phrase (including any of its left aspectual-modal marking), and immediately after the sentential subject, if one appears (regardless of the presence of preceding coordinators or adverbial phrases; cf. (463-464), below). The following examples are typical:
198
Aspectual-modal marking
man2 kaø b`oø m`ee` n1 phii3 dˆej2 3. B T. LNK NEG COP spirit FAC . NEWS ‘And so she was not a spirit, you know.’ (463) t`ee` 1 kh`oo` j5 kaø b`oø c`uu` 1 khak1 paan3 daj3 but 1 SG . P T. LNK NEG remember clear extent INDEF ‘But then I can’t remember very clearly.’ (464) l`ee` w4 h`oo` t4 m`uu` 4 maj1 m`uu` 4 lun1 haw2 kaø siø maø PRF reach day new day after 1. FA T. LNK IRR DIR . ALL thaam3 qiik5 vaa1 san4 ask more say thus ‘ “And so when it comes to the new day [i.e. tomorrow], then I will come and ask further”, he said.’
(462)
Any material in the extraclausal, topic-like Left Position does not count as first position in the relevant sense. Kaø can appear immediately between left-extraposed topic and verb only as a surface outcome of the subject having been omitted (cf. (465b)), but cannot appear before the subject, as illustrated in example (465c): (465)
kh`oo` j5 kaø kin3 a. paø-d`ee` k5 CT. FISH -stuff.in 1 SG . P T. LNK eat ‘Jugged fish, I do eat.’ Ø kaø kin3 b. paø-d`ee` k5 CT. FISH -stuff.in T. LNK eat ‘Jugged fish, (I) do eat.’ kaø kh`oo` j5 kin3 c. * paø-d`ee` k5 CT. FISH -stuff.in T. LNK 1 SG . P eat (Jugged fish, I eat.)
To illustrate the meaning of kaø, we begin with a minimal pair: (466) kh`oo` j5 kin3 siin4 1 SG . P eat meat ‘I eat meat.’ (467) kh`oo` j5 kaø kin3 siin4 1 SG . P T. LNK eat meat ‘I too eat meat.’
Aspectual-modal markers
199
While (466) is a flat statement, (467) invokes something prior, and makes a link to it. The following makes this explicit, adding a clause prior to that already shown in (467): (468)
qaaj4 kh`oo` j5 kin3 siin4, kh`oo` j5 kaø kin3 siin4 eBr 1 SG . P eat meat 1 SG . P T. LNK eat meat ‘My brother eats meat; I too eat meat.’
The prior proposition functions as a topic for the kaø-marked one. So, in (468), the initial proposition ‘my brother eats meat’ functions as background against which the foregrounded assertion ‘I eat meat’ has relevance. In this case, the meaning which results is translated as ‘too’. The general function of kaø is to link an assertion back to something which serves as a topic. The proposition marked by kaø is foregrounded as an assertion whose relevance is computed with reference to the now backgrounded prior proposition. When that prior proposition is explicitly available in the context, as for example in (468), kaø presupposes it and retrospectively marks it as a background topic. When there is no such explicitly available prior proposition, one will nevertheless be alluded to by the presence of kaø, and the hearer will be thereby directed to look for it. So, upon hearing (467), above, in isolation, a listener will notice the absence of something prior. In example (468), the kaø-marked second clause foregrounds a participant and links it back to a prior one, where what is at issue is a commonality of the two participants (they eat meat). Another common function of kaø in coordinated clause constructions concerns conditional relations in narrative sequence. Kaø marks the second clause, and is translatable as ‘so’ or ‘then’ (cf. (464), above): (469)
khan2 m`ung2 paj3, kuu3 kaø paj3 if 2 SG . B go 1 SG . B T. LNK go ‘If you go, then I go.’
The analysis of kaø as a topic linker fits with Haiman’s (1978) observation that conditional clauses are functionally like topics. The way kaø works here is to link back to the prior clause as a backgrounded proposition for the one to come. Accordingly, in the absence of explicit markers like khan2 ‘if’ (as in (469)), the presence of kaø in a subsequent clause can be sufficient to identify the prior clause as a conditional:
200
Aspectual-modal marking
(470)
m`ung2 paj3, kuu3 kaø paj3 2 SG . B go 1 SG . B T. LNK go ‘(If) you go, then I go.’
(471)
haw2 caø patisˆeeˆ t5 kaø b`oø pˆen3 kaan3-somkhuan2 1. FA IRR refuse T. LNK NEG COP NZR-appropriate ‘(If) I (were to) refuse, (it) would not be appropriate.’
Example (471) is similar in meaning to the English ‘for to’ complement construction, where a full clause (followed by kaø) acts as sentential subject. Another translation might be: ‘For me to refuse would not be appropriate’. We have seen that when the topic linker kaø is used, the clause is being foregrounded as an assertion. The reference of its primary argument (i.e., the subject) must be part of the assertion made at the sentence level. Accordingly, the subject of a kaø-marked predicate cannot be interpreted as an interrogative pronoun. As an illustration, consider the indefinite pronoun phaj3 (cf. Chapter 5, section 5.2), which may mean ‘who?’ (in a content question), or ‘whoever/anyone’ (in a declarative sentence). The following example, without kaø, is ambiguous: (472)
kin3 siin4 INDEF. HUM eat meat i. ‘Who eats meat?’ ii. ‘Anyone/everyone eats meat.’
phaj3
Insertion of kaø after the subject phaj3 forces the declarative ‘anyone’ reading (472ii) and disallows the interrogative reading ‘who?’: (473)
kaø
kin3 siin4 eat meat ‘Anyone/everyone eats meat.’ (NOT: ‘Who eats meat?’)
phaj3
INDEF. HUM T. LNK
Since kaø can only appear in second position of a MAIN clause at the sentence level, it cannot appear in a clause which has been relativized and which functions as a modifier within a noun phrase (square brackets mark the subordinate clause):
Aspectual-modal markers
201
kin3 siin4] kh`oo` j5 b`oø mak1 [phaj3 1 SG . P NEG like INDEF. HUM eat meat ‘I don’t like anyone who eats meat.’ kaø kin3 siin4] (475) * kh`oo` j5 b`oø mak1 [phaj3 1 SG . P NEG like INDEF. HUM T. LNK eat meat (I don’t like anyone who also eats meat.) (474)
The predication in the relative clause in example (474)—‘eat meat’— does not make an assertion on the sentence level. What is being asserted in this sentence is being asserted by the negated main verb b`oø mak1 [NEG like] ‘don’t like’. Accordingly, just before this verb (including its left aspectual-modal marking) is the only place where kaø can be inserted. This is illustrated in (476): (476)
kin3 siin4] kh`oo` j5 kaø b`oø mak1 [phaj3 1 SG . P T. LNK NEG like INDEF. HUM eat meat ‘I too don’t like anyone who eats meat.’
Similarly, kaø cannot occur inside a tight control complement clause (cf. Chapter 19), as in the following example showing the predicate ‘eat’ embedded under a main complement-taking predicate hˆen3 ‘see’: kh`oo` j5 hˆen3 [phen1 kin3 siin4] eat meat 1 SG . P see 3. P ‘I saw him eat meat.’ (478) * kh`oo` j5 hˆen3 [phen1 kaø kin3 siin4] T. LNK eat meat 1 SG . P see 3. P (I saw him also eat meat.)
(477)
Finally, note that kaø is a common locus for hesitation or pausing (after subject and before predicate), in which case it may be phonetically extended (i.e., the vowel lengthened), as a kind of filled pause. It may also be pronounced as k`oo` 1, although this is less common. It is always written in Lao as if it were pronounced k`oo` 1. For further discussion of kaø, see Chapter 14, section 14.5.
202
Aspectual-modal marking
phatø – contrast linker (CONTR) The marker phatø has the same syntactic properties as kaø, but is significantly less common in usage, and is different in meaning to kaø. Like kaø, phatø is associated with sentence-level focus, presuming some kind of link to a preceding, topical structure. Unlike kaø, phatø signals that the main assertion to come is a shift in the direction of discourse, often where the main assertion is counter to expectation in some way. Secondposition phatø is often translatable using ‘but then’ or ‘for X’s part’. In the following example, phatø is translatable as ‘but’: (479)
haw2 ngen2-d`uan3 s`oo` ng3-phan2-haa5 phatø lin5 kin3 1. FA money-month two-thousand-five CONTR play eat t`oo` n3 nan4 l`ee` w4 dˆeeˆ 4, PRF FAC . FILLIN time DEM . NONPROX ‘(As for) me, the salary was 2500, but (I used to) spent it all, you see, (at) that time.’
In another example, the notion of contrast in the meaning of phatø conveys the idea that the marked predicate is an unexpected surprise. The speaker is relating how he found a real bargain at the market in the form of a large turkey being sold at a good price. He spotted the turkey outside the market as he was leaving. At that moment, he was not expecting to buy anything more: (480) lang3 caak5 kh`oo` j5 q`oo` k5 maa2 thaang2 n`oo` k4 n`oq1, back from 1 SG . P exit come direction outside QPLR . AGREE kh`oo` j5 phatø maø hˆen3 kaj1-nguang1 naø 1 SG . P CONTR DIR . ALL see chicken-turkey TPC . PERIPH ‘After I came outside (of the market), right? I came unexpectedly upon this turkey.’ In a final example, a King offers his kingdom to anyone who can recapture his kidnapped younger sister and bring her back to him. While the kingdom should rightfully pass to the eldest prince, a group of six young men are interested in beating him to it by retrieving the king’s sister first and winning the kingdom as a reward. The sense of contrast here is marked by phatø:
Aspectual-modal markers
(481)
203
thaaw4 thang2 hok2 phatø jaak5 daj4 n`oq1 young.man all six CONTR want acquire QPLR . AGREE ‘The six young men, for their part, wanted to obtain (the kingdom), right?’
In coordinated clause constructions, phatø has the same forward-linking discourse function as kaø (cf. (469), above), but rather than conveying the notion ‘too, and, as well’, phatø means ‘on the contrary, but’. To illustrate, it is useful to compare kaø and phatø directly. In the following multi-clause constructions, kaø is appropriate where the assertion in the second clause conforms with the first (while subject arguments alter), and phatø is appropriate where the assertion in the second clause contrasts with that of the first in some way: (482)
(483)
a. khan2 m`ung2 paj3 kuu3 kaø paj3 if 2 SG . B go 1 SG . B T. LNK go ‘If you go, then I go.’ b. khan2 m`ung2 paj3 kuu3 phatø juu1 if 2 SG . B go 1 SG . B CONTR remain ‘If you go, I, for my part, will stay.’ kh`oo` j3 kaø kin3 cˆeeˆ 3 a. qaaj4 kh`oo` j5 kin3 cˆeeˆ 3, eBr 1 SG . P eat vegetarian 1 SG . P T. LNK eat vegetarian ‘My brother eats vegetarian; I too eat vegetarian.’ kh`oo` j3 phatø kin3 siin4 b. qaaj4 kh`oo` j5 kin3 cˆeeˆ 3, eBr 1 SG . P eat vegetarian 1 SG . P CONTR eat meat ‘My brother eats vegetarian; I, on the other hand, eat meat.’
laø, leejø, lootø as second position markers A few other markers may occasionally appear in second position. These include laø, a reduced form of the perfect marker, and a clausal connector meaning ‘and, and then’ (484); leej2/leejø, a postverbal aspectual-modal meaning ‘without ado’ (485); and loot4/lootø, a marker of similar meaning and function to leej2 (486; see above sections): (484)
hua3-naa5 sathaa3ban3 laø maa2 lin5 nam2 phen1 l`uajø-l`uaj4 PRF come play with 3. P REG chief institute ‘And the chief of the institute comes to see him regularly.’
204
Aspectual-modal marking
phen1 leejø maa2 baan4 3. P NO . ADO come home ‘And then he came (straight) home.’ nan4 lootø tat2 naa5 haw2 (486) lot1 khan2 vehicle CLF. VEHICLE DEM . NONPROX NO . HES cut front 1. FA ‘That vehicle went and cut us off.’
(485)
Of these three, only leej2/leejø may appear in combination with kaø as a kind of compound second-position marker: b`oø dajø paj3 sam4 (487) qaaj4 kh`oo` j5 kaø-leej2 eBr 1 SG . P T. LNK-NO . ADO NEG ACHV go FAC . SURPR ‘And so my brother just didn’t go after all.’
9.1.3 Pre-negation aspectual-modal markers haa3-k`oo` 1 – recent past (PST. RCNT) There are several preverbal markers which convey the idea that something has just happened. These include haa3-k`oo` 1, haa3-siø, pheng1, and pheng1-siø. I am not aware of any significant syntactic or semantic distinction between them. The differences may be sociolinguistic or dialectal. The most common of these (the only one found in my texts) is haa3-k`oo` 1.1 The following examples are typical: (488)
(489)
1
khaw3 pajø n`oo` n2 naa2, haa3-k`oo` 1 dˆek2-n`oo` j4 hanø, child-small TPC . DIST 3 PL . B DIR . ABL sleep paddy PST. RCNT maa2 come ‘The kids, they slept at the paddy, (they) just came (here).’ man2 haa3-k`oo` 1 s`uu` 4 n`oq1 3. B PST. RCNT buy QPLR . AGREE ‘He just bought (one), right?’
On haa3-siø and pheng1-siø, it is strange that these past-oriented markers incorporate the future-oriented irrealis marker siø.
Aspectual-modal markers
205
In another example, a speaker is talking about her husband’s recovery from an accident. He was unable to walk for some time, and has just been asked if he can now walk again. His wife says that it has been two or three days, conveying the idea of recency by using haa3-k`oo` 1: (490)
haa3-k`oo` 1 n˜ aang1 daj4 s`oo` ng3 m`uu` 4, saam3 m`uu` 4 nii4 PST. RCNT walk CAN two day three day DEM l`eq1 FAC . PRF ‘(He is) just now able to walk since two days (ago), three days today.’
In another example, a hotel keeper is describing the drinking habits of one of her guests. She says, ‘He was extremely drunk and slept for two days without waking up at all.’ She then says that he had woken up just the day before, marking the lateness of the past narrated event in terms of its recency to the speech event, with haa3-k`oo` 1: (491)
haa3-k`oo` 1 t`uu` n1 m`uu` 4-vaan1-nii4 PST. RCNT wake yesterday ‘(He) just woke up yesterday.’
Another way to express recency of a past event is to use the syntactically independent adverbial phrase vaang1 kii4 niø ‘this very minute’, as in the following example: (492)
man2 m`ua2 baan4 vaang1-kii4-niø 3. B return home this.very.minute ‘He went home this very minute (i.e., just a second ago).’
The semantics of this marker appear to be concerned solely with the marking of tense. However, we are not able to say that there is systematic marking of tense in the language, since there is no tense SYSTEM of which this marker forms a part. Its semantics are narrow, and do not contrast with more general marking of tense such as ‘future’ or ‘past’. kuap5 – ‘almost’ (ALMOST) ` The pre-negation marker k`uap5 has no verbal usage or verb-like properties. It means ‘almost’, conveying the idea that some transition of states of
206
Aspectual-modal marking
affairs encoded in the predicate nearly takes place, but doesn’t (or doesn’t yet). In an example, a speaker is describing a near-miss she had on her bicycle as she cycled to work: (493)
keet5 qupatihˆeeˆ t5 m`uu` 4 nan4 kh`oo` j5 kuap5 ` day DEM . NONPROX 1 SG . P ALMOST happen accident ‘I almost had an accident that day.’
She goes on to say that she was almost too afraid to cycle home again in the afternoon: (494)
m`ua2 b`oø daj4, kh`oo` j5 m`uu` 4-l`ee` ng2 maa2, kh`oo` j5 kuap5 ` day-evening come 1 SG . P ALMOST return NEG CAN 1 SG . P jaan4 h`ee` ng2 afraid strong ‘The evening came (and) I almost couldn’t return, I was so scared.’
The next example shows k`uap5 ‘almost’ appearing together with the irrealis marker siø: (495)
laø man2 kuap5 kh`oo` j5 q`oo` k5 kaan3 k`oo` n1 maa2 hanø ` 1 SG . P exit work before come TPC . DIST PRF 3. B ALMOST siø khaw5 qanø haa5 d`uan3 l`eq1 IRR enter HES five month FAC . PRF ‘I had left my earlier job before coming (here), almost five months before (that).’
Occasionally, k`uap5 occurs before the subject, as in the following example, or in (497), a re-phrasing of (493): (496)
kuap5 `
kh`oo` j5 lom4 1 SG . P fall.over ‘I almost fell over.’ kh`oo` j5 keet5 qupatihˆeeˆ t5 m`uu` 4 nan4 (497) kuap5 ` ALMOST 1 SG . P happen accident day DEM . NONPROX ‘I almost had an accident that day.’ ALMOST
Since k`uap5 picks out a single transition in state of affairs, its use with verbs whose base aspectual structure has more than one transition can be ambiguous (cf. Dowty 1979:58 and passim). For example, the verb
Aspectual-modal markers
207
khaa5 ‘kill’ contains reference to an activity (an agent does something to an animate patient), which itself has an onset, and a resultant state change (an animate patient becomes dead). The use of k`uap5 may pick out either the transition into the activity phase (498i), or the transition into the resultant state (498ii): (498)
khaa5 man2 kh`oo` j5 kuap5 ` 1 SG . P ALMOST kill 3. B i. ‘I almost killed it (i.e., I almost did something to it which would have killed it.) ii. ‘I almost killed it (i.e., I did something to it, because of which it almost died.)
nang2 – ‘still/yet’ (STILL) ˜ As a main verb, n˜ ang2 means ‘to be remaining’. Here is an example from a story in which a boy has defended himself against an attack by a tiger, using a pot of boiling water. The tiger is lying motionless. The speaker uses n˜ ang2 to mean ‘alive’: (499) cak2 vaa1 man2 siø taaj3 l`uu` 3 siø nang2 ˜ don’t.know COMP 3. B IRR die or IRR remain ‘Who knows whether it was dead or (still) alive.’ Here are two more examples of n˜ ang2 as a verb meaning ‘to remain’ or ‘to be left (over)’: (500)
(501)
khaw5 nang2 b`oo` 3 ˜ rice remain QPLR ‘Is there any rice left over?’ luuk4-n`oo` ng4 man2 kaø taaj3 met2, nang2 t`ee` 1 hua3-naa5 ˜ C -y Z 3. B T. LNK die all remain only head-front man2 3. B ‘His underlings all died. Only his chief was left.’
Note also that the notion of ‘remaining’ encoded by n˜ ang2 can cover simple existence. The word n˜ ang2 can be used in a literary idiom for story openings, as in ‘Once upon a time’:
208 (502)
Aspectual-modal marking
nang2 mii2 s`oo` ng3 m`ee` 1 luuk4 m`ua2 hˆet1 haj1 ˜ remain there.is two mother child return make swidden ‘There was once a mother and child pair (who) went to work on their swiddens.’
As a postverbal aspectual-modal, n˜ ang2 means ‘still’ or ‘(not) yet’. In an example, a speaker is asking an ex-colleague for news about her old boss, who she hasn’t seen for a long time. She wants to know if the boss’s old sweetheart still comes to visit: (503)
maa2 juu1 vaa3 f`ee` n2 laaw2 kaø nang2 ˜ sweetheart 3 SG . FA T. LNK STILL come CONT QPLR . INFER ‘So does her sweetheart still come?’
The word n˜ ang2 is commonly used as a stand-alone response meaning ‘not yet’ to a question about whether something has already occurred: (504)
Q khaw5 suk2 l`ee` w4 vaa3 rice cooked PRF QPLR . INFER ‘Is the rice cooked already?’ A nang2 ˜ STILL (not cooked) ‘Not yet.’
In this function, meaning ‘not yet’, n˜ ang2 is used in isolation, and does not take negation. However, when used in combination with a verb phrase, n˜ ang2 must be combined with explicit negation on the verb in order to convey the idea ‘not yet’: (505)
b`oø suk2 nang2 ˜ STILL NEG cooked ‘(It’s) still not cooked.’ (i.e., ‘It’s not cooked yet.’)
Typically, n˜ ang2 makes a temporal distinction, as illustrated in (503) and (504). Accompanying this temporal distinction is an idea that the truth of the predicate is in some sense counter to expectation. For example, in (504), it is expected that the rice will at some point become cooked, but this is not yet the case. A number of examples pick out this counter-to-expectation component of n˜ ang2, yet without predicating any temporal distinction. For example, a man is at home in his village, and
Aspectual-modal markers
209
sees others arriving from a trip to another village, bringing a sack of fresh bamboo shoots with them. The man wants to say that bamboo shoots are abundant in their own village, ‘yet’ they ‘still’ bring shoots in from elsewhere: (506)
qaw3 n`oo` 1-maj4 juu1 baan4 n`oo` 1-maj4 laø nang2 ˜ be.at village bamboo.shoot PRF STILL take bamboo.shoot kin3 maø DIR . ALL eat ‘(They) live at a bamboo shoot village, and still bring bamboo shoots (from elsewhere) to eat!’
In another example, a woman is discussing problems of access in and out of her village, due to the bad state of roads from surrounding villages. She lists a number of routes which are not currently functional, adding that ‘even’ the road through the village of Oudom Phon—a relatively large village nearby, whose access route is not normally obstructed—is inaccessible. This sense of ‘even’ is conveyed by n˜ ang2: (507)
paj3 b`oø daj4 qudom3-phon3 kaø nang2 ˜ T. LNK STILL go NEG CAN Q-P ‘Oudom Phon, (we) couldn’t even go to.’
kamlang2 – progressive (PROG) As a noun, kamlang2 refers to ‘strength’ or ‘power’.2 As a preverbal operator, kamlang2 means ‘to be in the process of (V)-ing’. It does not occur often in texts, and is limited to situations in which the ongoing or extended nature of the action is critical to the current framing of discourse. Typically, this is when a speaker wants to portray one event as extended over time in order to use it as a temporal frame within which a second event is contained. For example, while a group of women are bathing and chatting, one of them is kidnapped by an ogre. The ongoing, framing event of chatting is marked by kamlang2:
2
Kamlang2 is a borrowing from Khmer. In Khmer it is a derivation from klang ‘to be forceful, strong’ with a nominalizing infix -am-.
210 (508)
Aspectual-modal marking
kamlang2 son3-siaw3 kan3 juu1 ... laø n˜ ak1 pap2 maø PROG COLL CONT PRF ogre IDEO DIR . ALL chat h`oo` p5 qaw3 naang2 sumun2thaa2 paj3 l`ee` w4 carry.in.arms take miss S go PRF ‘(While they) were chatting ... the ogre came and suddenly took Sumunthaa away.’
In another example, while two men are wrestling, their swords fall from their hands. The ongoing, framing event of wrestling is marked by kamlang2: (509)
laø vˆelaa2 thii1 kamlang2 pam4 kan3 juu1 han5 wrestle COLL be.at DEM . DIST PRF time REL PROG m`ee` n1 taang1 khon2 kaø taang1 ngaaw4 luut5 q`oo` k5 caak5 COP other person T. LNK other sword slip exit from m`uu` 2 hand ‘At the time they were wrestling there, each of their swords slipped from their hands.’
In another example, a man describes the circumstances of his detainment by authorities, and subsequent transportation to a re-education facility. He was approached by armed, uniformed men on the street, and was asked to step into a military truck. He explains that this happened as he was coming out of a cinema, marking this framing event with kamlang2: (510)
laø m`ee` n1 haw2 kamlang2 q`oo` k5 vˆelaa2 nan4 exit time DEM . NONPROX PRF COP 1. FA PROG maa2 caak5 hoong2 sinˆeeˆ 2 come from hall cinema ‘At that time, I was coming out of a cinema hall.’
For the progressive, framing function illustrated in the above three examples, the predicate denotes an activity (e.g., chatting, wrestling, moving). Sometimes kamlang2 may also be used with stative verbs or adjectives. This functions to highlight the transience or ‘currentness’ of the state. In the following example, the speaker refers to a mother cow with calf, marking the predicate mii2 ‘have’ with kamlang2 as a way of highlighting the passing nature of the relation of dependence:
Aspectual-modal markers
(511)
211
n`ung1 kamlang2 mii2 luuk4 mii2 m`ee` 1 ngua2 toø have child there.is mother cow MC . ANIM one PROG n`oo` j4 small ‘There was a mother cow, who was currently with a small calf.’
A lexical alternative to kamlang2 is phuam2. This word is not common, and appears to be sociolinguistically marked (perhaps more common in dialects other than that of Vientiane). It does not appear to be different in meaning to kamlang2. An example is from a description of building chicken coops. The speaker discusses how to calculate the size of the structure, depending on how big the chickens have grown: khan2 (512) laj1 kaj1, kaj1 phuam2 n˜ aj1 n`oq1, calculate chicken chicken PROG big QPLR . AGREE if kaj1 n˜ aj1 laaj3 l`ee` w4 haw2 kaø khaaj3 q`oo` k5 laø exit PRF chicken big much PRF 1. FA T. LNK sell dˆeeˆ 4 FAC . FILLIN ‘(That’s) calculating (for) chickens which are becoming big (i.e., not yet big), right? If the chickens are very big already, we will have sold them off, you see.’ In this case, the use of the progressive marker with an adjective coerces an inchoative reading of the adjective: i.e., n˜ aj1 ‘big’ in the first line of (512) is interpreted to mean ‘to become big’ rather than ‘to be big’. khu` u2-siø – assumptive epistemic modal ‘probably, presumably’ (PROB) ` The expression kh`uu` 2-siø is an assumptive epistemic modal, meaning ‘probably’ or ‘presumably’. Kh`uu` 2 is a verb meaning ‘to be like (something)’ or ‘to be the same as (something)’. When it functions as a preverbal aspectual-modal marker meaning ‘probably’, kh`uu` 2 must always appear in combination with the irrealis marker siø. In an example from a narrative, a bandit gets in a fight with a man, and the man’s wife betrays the man (her husband) by helping the bandit to kill him. She then becomes the wife of the bandit and goes with him. Later reflecting on the woman’s betrayal of her first husband in order to be with him, the bandit suspects that she will one day betray him too:
212 (513)
Aspectual-modal marking
phuø phuø-˜ning2 nii4 khu` u2-siø b`oø mii2 caj3 ` MC . HUM -woman MC . HUM DEM PROB - IRR NEG have heart sat2-s`uu` 1 honest-straight ‘This woman probably doesn’t have an honest heart.’
In another example, a speaker describes a Spanish hippy he knew in pre-1975 Vientiane who would contact his parents in Spain whenever he ran out of money. In this way, the Spaniard was able to survive in Vientiane without having a paying job. The speaker surmises: (514)
m`ee` n1 ph`oo` 1-m`ee` 1 man2 laø khon2 mii2 ngen2 khu` u2-siø ` PROB - IRR BE . SO mother-father 3. B PRF person have money d`ee` 1 a.little ‘Its probably the case that his parents (were) people with a bit of money.’
In another example, a speaker describes the experience of having been detained before being sent to a re-education camp. The authorities gave no indication that anything bad was going to happen. He says, ‘They spoke to us very nicely, there was no problem, as if they weren’t going to punish us in any way’. He surmised at the time—mistakenly—that nothing was wrong, marking the likelihood of this with kh`uu` 2-siø: (515)
b`oø mii2 haw2 kaø s`ua1 vaa1 man2 khu` u2-siø ` 1. FA T. LNK believe COMP 3. B PROB-IRR NEG there.is n˜ ang3 d`oo` k5, qee5 b`oø huu4 vaa1 khaw3 siø INDEF. INAN FAC . RESIST INTJ NEG know COMP 3 PL . B IRR qaw3 pajø dat2-saang5 take DIR . ABL transform-build ‘We believed that there probably wasn’t anything (wrong), Uhhuh, (we) didn’t know that they were going to take (us) for reeducation.’
qaat5-caø – speculative epistemic modal ‘possibly, might’ (SPEC) As a preverbal aspectual-modal marker meaning ‘possibly’ or ‘might’, qaat5 (historically a verb meaning ‘to be capable’, ‘to have power’) must
Aspectual-modal markers
213
always appear in combination with the irrealis marker caø (or, very occasionally, siø; see example (519), below). In an example from a narrative, a man suspects his new wife to be unfaithful, and considers what might happen if he is unable to bring sufficient income to her. The possibility that she could abandon him is coded by qaat5-caø: (516)
laaw2 qaat5-caø pian1 caj3 caak5 haw2 3 SG . FA SPEC-IRR change heart from 1. FA ‘She might change her mind (away) from me.’
In another example, a speaker explains that the value of money was very different in former times. The possibility of getting a house for five thousand Kip (significantly below modern house prices of ten million Kip minimum) is marked by qaat5-caø: (517)
haa5-phan2 qaat5-caø daj4 h`uan2 n`ung1 pamaan3 SPEC - IRR acquire house one approximately five-thousand kiip5 kip ‘(You would) possibly get one house for around five thousand kip.’
In another example, a speaker is talking about the ubiquity of roadside police checks in the period shortly after the revolution of 1975. The speaker is not committed to the exact number, and marks his estimate of ‘two or three locations’ with qaat5-caø: (518)
lavaang1 viang2can3 phoon2hoong2 niø qaat5-caø mii2 TPC SPEC - IRR have between V P s`oo` ng3 b`oo` n1 l`uu` 3 saam3 b`oo` n1 juu1 FAC . WEAK two place or three place ‘Between Vientiane and Phonehong there might have been two or three locations.’
In a final example, a speaker is talking about how high the roof on a chicken coop needs to be. He says that if the roof is made of corrugated iron, it can be installed higher, so that the interior of the coop doesn’t get too hot. The idea that one ‘might’ (i.e., ‘might want to’ or ‘would be well advised to’) make a higher roof is conveyed by marking with qaat5-siø:
214
Aspectual-modal marking
(519)
khan2 mung2 duaj4 sang3kasii3 niø qaat5-siø hˆet1 suung3 TPC SPEC- IRR do high if to.roof with zinc d`ee` 1 caak5 ph`uu` n4 a.little from ground ‘If (you) roof (it) with corrugated iron, (you) might make it a bit high from the ground.’
9.1.4
Irrealis markers
The irrealis markers siø and caø are equivalent in meaning, and seem to contrast only in stylistic and sociolinguistic terms.3 The two are generally interchangeable, except in certain fixed combinations. For example, as shown in the previous sub-section, when kh`uu` 2 functions as a prenegation aspectual-modal marker meaning ‘probably’ it must appear with siø (as kh`uu` 2-siø) and not caø (??kh`uu` 2-caø; see section 9.1.3, above). By contrast, qaat5 ‘might’ and khuan2 ‘should’ must appear with caø (as khuan2-caø and qaat5-caø), not siø (??khuan2-siø, ??qaat5-siø). It appears that siø is more frequent in general. A common function of the irrealis markers is to convey the idea that the state of affairs referred to by the predicate will be the case at a time after the speech event. They often function effectively as future tense markers. For example, a hotel manager is talking about the activities of one of her guests. After a long night of drinking, the guest sleeps in until four in the afternoon. He gets up, and then upon leaving the hotel, he tells her his plans, marking the projected future events with siø: (520)
kin3 bia3 qiik5 k`oo` n1 dee4 kh`oo` j5 siø pajø 1 SG . P IRR DIR . ABL eat beer more before FAC . ONRCD ‘I’m going to go and drink some more beer, y’hear.’
In another example, a man is speaking of the lean years just after the revolution of 1975, when everybody was required to work on their market gardens just to get food to eat. The siø-marked predicate is interpreted as irrealis, in the sense that the speaker does not commit to the truth of the 3
The nature of this contrast is not understood, but it is worth noting that neighboring Thai has only caø. Caø appears to be historically related to a verb cak2 ‘to know’. Siø may be related to a marker with similar meaning in many Mon-Khmer languages of the area — e.g., Kar`ı`ı ci.
Aspectual-modal markers
215
state of affairs referred to by the marked predicate (i.e., kin3 ‘eat’), but to its possible or likely truth after a reference time. In this example, the relevant reference time is not the time of the speech event, but is a time in the past. And as this example shows, the truth of the siø-marked predicate is not necessarily portrayed as certain. Here, it is conditional, as coded in the preceding clause: (521)
thaa5 vaa1 haw2 niø – qee5 – b`oø hˆet1 viak4 niø, haw2 siø COMP 1. FA TPC INTJ NEG do work TPC 1. FA IRR if b`oø dajø kin3 khaw5 th`eø-th`ee` 4 dˆej2 NEG ACHV eat rice RDP. A -true FAC . NEWS ‘If we – uh-huh – didn’t work, we really wouldn’t get to eat, you know.’
In another example, a man who was detained before being taken to reeducation is saying that as he waited before being taken away he had no idea what was going to happen. At the time, he figured nothing serious would take place. He didn’t know what the subsequent state of affairs (marked here by siø) was going to be: (522)
dat2-saang5 b`oø huu4 vaa1 khaw3 siø qaw3 pajø NEG know COMP 3 PL . B IRR take DIR . ABL transform-build ‘(We) didn’t know they were going to take (us) for re-education.’
In another example, a hotel manager is talking about a man who had been a guest in her hotel for some months, and who was planning to flee without paying. The contents of his plan, to transpire at a later time than the narrated event of ‘planning’, is marked with siø: (523)
vaang2 ph`ee` n3 siø nii3 leej2, t`ee` 1 vaa1 kh`oo` j5 cap2 daj4 lay plan IRR flee NO . ADO but COMP 1 SG . P catch CAN ‘(He) laid a plan to flee without ado, but I was able to catch (him).’
In a final example, siø marks a state of affairs which is being entertained as a possible event, embedded under a conditional. This arises at the opening of a description of how to cook a Lao dish called larb:
216 (524)
Aspectual-modal marking
khan2 haw2 siø hˆet1 laap4 n`oq1, qaw3 siin4- siin4 if 1. FA IRR make larb QPLR . AGREE take meat meat ngua2 b`oo` 3 l`uu` 3 vaa1 siin4 khuaj2 kaø daj4 cow QPLR or COMP meat buffalo T. LNK CAN ‘If we’re going to make larb, right?, take meat- beef for instance, or buffalo is okay.’
There are several other modal-aspectual operators which tend to occur with siø or its cousin caø: e.g., kh`uu` 2-siø, qaat5-caø (see above).
9.1.5 Negation marker The marker of negation is b`oo` 1 (if occurring in isolation) or b`oø (destressed and phonologically dependent). This marker has a slot of its own, as outlined in Figure 9.1, above. Many examples throughout this book illustrate the negative marker in situ. There is no special syntax of negation, the only apparent variation concerning optional ordering of negation with reference to a small number of other aspectual-modal markers (e.g., naa5-caø counterfactual weak obligative modal ‘should’; see section 9.1.6, below). Note that the marker b`oo` 1 may be a stand-alone word, as a negative answer to a polar question, illustrated in Aii: (525)
Q m`ung2 hˆen3 khaw3 b`oo` 3 2 SG . B see 3PL . B QPLR ‘Did you see them?’ Ai b`oø hˆen3 NEG see ‘(I) didn’t see (them).’ Aii b`oo` 1 NEG
‘No.’ Note also that there is a dedicated negative imperative marker jaa1 ‘don’t’ (also a verb ‘to abandon something, to give something up’) which does not co-occur with other aspectual-modals:
Aspectual-modal markers
(526)
217
vaw4 cang1 san4 qoo4 caw4 jaa1 INTJ 2 SG . P NEG . IMP speak like thus ‘Oh, don’t you speak like that!’
The negative imperative marker jaa1 may also appear as a stand-alone utterance, meaning ‘Desist!’.
9.1.6 Post-negation aspectual-modal markers kheej2 – experiential (perfect) ‘have ever’ (EXP) The post-negation marker kheej2 means to ‘be accustomed to’ doing something or to ‘have ever’ done something (or for something to ‘have ever’ been the case). For example, a speaker claims her authority to supply recipes, stating her experience of studying cooking using kheej2: (527)
hian2 pung3-t`ee` ng1 kh`oo` j5 kaø kheej2 pajø 1 SG . P T. LNK EXP DIR . ALL study fix-prepare ‘I have (once) studied cooking.’
In another example, the same speaker is talking about dealing with foreign guests who have never previously eaten MSG. This inexperience is marked with kheej2, negated: kaø vaa1 b`oø s`ee` p4 ph`oq1 (528) qanø-nan4 MC . INAN - DEM . NONPROX T. LNK say NEG delicious because vaa1 phen1 b`oø kheej2 kin3 COMP 3 SG . P NEG EXP eat ‘That stuff (they) say is not delicious, because they haven’t ever eaten (it).’ In another example, a speaker is talking about the bridge which spans the broad mouth of the Kading River in central Laos. He explains that there was no other bridge prior to the present one, that is there had never been a bridge there before. This is marked with kheej2, negated:
218 (529)
Aspectual-modal marking
khua3 khaam5 m`eø-nam4 paak5 kading4 t`ee` 1 k`oo` n1 b`oø from before NEG bridge cross CT. Mo-water mouth K kheej2 mii2 dˆeeˆ 4 EXP have FAC . FILLIN ‘A bridge crossing the river at the mouth of the Kading, before, there had never been (one), you see.’
In a final example, a speaker is describing the hippy travelers that he associated with in Vientiane in the late 1960s and early 1970s. He says, ‘These people, they wore straggly clothes, they had long hair and shoulder-bags, these hippies.’ Then he asks if his addressee had ever seen hippies : (530)
caw4 kheej2 hˆen3 b`oo` 3, phuak4 hip2pii4 niø 2 SG . P EXP see QPLR group hippy TPC ‘Have you ever seen (them), these hippies?’
b`oø than2 – ‘not yet’ (ON . TIME) A common way to express the idea of ‘still’ or ‘(not) yet’ is to use the pre-negation aspectual-modal marker n˜ ang2, described above. Another way, which may or may not be combined with n˜ ang2, is to use than2 as a post-negation aspectual-modal marker. Than2 is a verb meaning ‘to be on time’, or ‘to keep up with’: haa5 moong2 b`oo` 3 caw4 siø than2 2 SG . P IRR ON . TIME five o’clock QPLR ‘Are you going to be on time (for) five o’clock?’ m`ung2 (532) khaw3 b`oø than2 3 PL . B NEG ON . TIME 2 SG . B ‘They didn’t/couldn’t keep up with you.’
(531)
As an aspectual-modal marker, than2 only occurs negated, with the meaning ‘not yet’. To illustrate this, first consider an unmarked case. If I want to say that the rice is not cooked, I use direct negation on the verb (in this case, suk2 ‘cooked’): (533) khaw5 b`oø suk2 rice NEG cooked ‘(The) rice (is) not cooked.’
Aspectual-modal markers
219
To express the notion ‘not YET’ (i.e., where it is expected that it will be cooked at some time, perhaps soon), I can add than2 after the negation and before the verb: (534)
suk2 khaw5 b`oø than2 rice NEG ON . TIME cooked ‘The rice is not cooked yet.’
In an example, a calf is talking to its mother, justifying why it should sacrifice itself to a predatory tiger, rather than allowing the mother to be eaten. The calf explains that it is not yet self-sufficient, and so would die anyway if the mother were eaten: (535)
b`oø than2 daj4, luuk4 kaø n˜ ang2 kin3 n˜ ang3 child T. LNK STILL eat INDEF. INAN NEG ON . TIME CAN kh`ee` w5 b`oø than2 mii2 tooth NEG ON . TIME have ‘I (child) can’t yet eat anything, teeth (I) don’t yet have.’
In another example, a tiger is coming up through the floor of a raised field hut and threatening to attack a child who is alone in the hut. The child is looking for something to defend itself with, but cannot yet (marked by b`oø than2) find a machete or similar weapon: (536)
kaø b`oø than2 hˆen3 haa3 phaa5 n˜ ang3 seek machete INDEF. INAN T. LNK NEG ON . TIME see ‘(The child) looked for some (kind of) machete, (but) couldn’t yet see (one).’
The use of post-negation than2 for ‘not yet’ can be further combined with the pre-negation marker of comparable meaning, n˜ ang2 ‘still’ (cf. example (505), above): (537)
suk2 khaw5 n˜ ang2 b`oø than2 rice STILL NEG ON . TIME cooked ‘The rice is still not cooked yet.’
In another example (earlier in the same text as (536), above), mother and child come back from the rice fields to their field hut, unaware that a tiger is hiding underneath the floor of the hut. They are soon to find out about the tiger’s presence, but—as marked by b`oø than2 ‘not yet’—they are not yet aware of it:
220 (538)
Aspectual-modal marking
s`oo` ng3 m`ee` 1 luuk4 kaø n˜ ang2 b`oø than2 huu4 two mother child T. LNK STILL NEG ON . TIME know ‘The pair of mother and child didn’t yet know.’
Note a further marker which may be used in expressions meaning ‘not yet’. The noun th`ua1 is the general word for ‘occasion, time’: (539)
l`ee` w4 kh`oo` j5 hˆen3 man2 s`oo` ng3 thua1 ` occasion PRF 1 SG . P see 3. B two ‘I saw him two times already.’
This word is also employed in expressing the idea ‘not yet’. In this function, th`ua1 is part of the postverbal-aspectual modal complex. It almost always occurs in combination with other preverbal means for expressing this same meaning. For example, we may add th`ua1 to example (537), above, showing it in combination with both n˜ ang2 and b`oø than2: suk2 thua1 (540) khaw5 n˜ ang2 b`oø than2 ` rice STILL NEG ON . TIME cooked yet ‘The rice is still not cooked yet.’ In another example, th`ua1 occurs with n˜ ang2. This is a description of a calf which was not yet independent of its mother’s support: (541)
n˜ ang2 pheng1 toø-qˆeeˆ ng3 b`oø daj4 thua1 ` STILL depend.on self NEG CAN yet ‘(It) couldn’t yet depend on itself.’
naan2 – ‘take a long time’ (TAKE . LONG) The word naan2 has similar meaning to the postverbal aspectual-modal don3 (or /heng3) ‘for a long time’, described above. As discussed, naan2 and don3 (or heng3) have different syntactic and semantic relations to the predicates they modify. If a predicate is marked with naan2, this means that it is taking a long time for the state of affairs to come about: kaø pakot2 vaa1 naan2 maa2 (542) lot1-mˆeeˆ 2 CT. VEHICLE -bus T. LNK appear COMP TAKE . LONG come ‘So the bus appeared to be taking a long time to arrive.’
Aspectual-modal markers
221
Example (542) does not mean that the bus was arriving for a long time, but that a long time was passing before the event of its arriving occurred. See examples (409) and (410) in section 9.1.1, above for direct comparison with don3 (or heng3) ‘for a long time’. mak1 – ‘tend to’ (TEND) As a main verb, mak1 means ‘to like (something)’ or ‘to like (doing something)’: (543)
(544)
kh`oo` j5 mak1 nang3 thaj2 1 SG . P like movie Thai ‘I like Thai movies.’ kh`oo` j5 mak1 beng1 nang3 thaj2 1 SG . P like watch movie Thai ‘I like watching Thai movies.’
As a post-negation aspectual-modal marker, mak1 means ‘tend to’ happen or be the case, or ‘be generally likely to’ happen or be the case. It often co-occurs with the irrealis marker caø (but never with siø), as a unit mak1-caø. In an example, a man is talking about local people’s beliefs regarding the supernatural. He explains that if someone breaks a taboo, they are likely to fall ill. The notion of likelihood is marked with mak1: (545)
man2 mak1 cˆep2 sˆen5 cˆep2 qˆen3, man2 mak1 pˆen3 laaj3 3. B TEND hurt nerve hurt tendon 3. B TEND COP many n`ee` w2 way ‘They are likely to suffer from physical complaints, they are likely to suffer from many things.’
In another example, the speaker describes the likely circumstances under which people pray to spirits:
222 (546)
Aspectual-modal marking
thaa5-haak5 vaa1 hˆet1 n˜ ang3 mii2 kaan3 n˜ ung5-˜naak4 COMP do INDEF. INAN have NZR complicated if viak4-ngaan2 daj3 n˜ ung5-˜naak4 sap2-son3 mak1-caø INDEF complicated messy TEND- IRR work pajø vaj5 hanø DIR . ABL pray.to TPC . DIST ‘If (one) has done something which has complications, some work which is complicated or problematic, (one) tends (then) to go and pray to (those spirits).’
In another example, the same speaker is describing what local people think about burial forests and cemeteries: (547)
hanø mak1-caø th`uu` 3 vaa1 juu1 b`oo` n1 nan4 be.at place DEM . NONPROX TPC . DIST TEND-IRR believe COMP man2 mii2- mii2- mii2 phii3 3. B there.is there.is there.is spirit ‘In those places, (people) tend to believe that there are- there arethere are spirits.’
In each of the above examples, the predicate marked with mak1 is being framed as something that tends to be the case or is generally likely to be the case. As noted above (see examples (543-544)), as a main verb, mak1 means ‘to like (doing) something’. With the meaning ‘tend to, be likely to’, mak1 clearly does not convey this idea of positive appraisal. It is illustrated clearly in example (545), above: the speaker does not want to convey the idea that people LIKE TO get ill. But many other examples occur in bridging contexts (Evans 1990, 2003, Enfield 2003c:28), that is, contexts in which both the ‘tend to’ and ‘like to’ readings are applicable. Here is a particularly clear example from a man’s description of one of his hippy friends from early 1970s Vientiane: (548)
laø phom3 bak2 n˜ aaw2 mak1 m`oo` 3 nan4 bloke DEM . NONPROX PRF hair very long like/TEND suup5 kan3saa2 qanø- qanaa1- qin3dia3 juu1 lii2doo3 HES HES smoke ganja India be.at L ‘That bloke, (his) hair was really long, (he) liked to smoke umuh Indian ganja at the Lido.’
Aspectual-modal markers
223
t`oo` ng4 – modal of necessity, mainly obligative (OBLIG) As a main verb, t`oo` ng4 means ‘to touch, to come into contact with’. It is not specific as to whether the contact is accidental or intentional: (549)
man2 t`oo` ng4 kh`ee` n3 kh`oo` j5 3. B contact arm 1 SG . P ‘She touched/brushed against my arm.’
As a post-negation aspectual-modal marker, t`oo` ng4 expresses necessity, either deontic (dynamic obligative) or, occasionally, epistemic (deductive). In an example of t`oo` ng4 in its aspectual-modal function, a market lady gives instructions as to how to cook a certain type of sausage, explaining that it must be fried: (550)
caw4 t`oo` ng4 saj1 namø-man2 muu3 2 SG . P OBLIG put CT. LIQUID-oil pig ‘You must use pork oil.’
In another example, t`oo` ng4 conveys the idea not of physical or causal necessity but of the speaker’s certainty that the predicate will be true. ‘Must’ here means ‘certainly will’ rather than ‘have to’: (551)
thuk1-thuk1 pii3 khaw3 caø t`oo` ng4 mii2 kaan3 vaj5 phii3 each-each year 3 PL . B IRR OBLIG have NZR pray.to spirit kh`oo` ng3 khaw3 of 3 PL . B ‘Each and every year they must (i.e., certainly will) have their praying to the spirits.’
The following example is similar, where a speaker is talking about people’s beliefs that those who die will certainly (i.e., ‘must’) become spirits: (552)
pˆen3 phii3 khon2 thii1 taaj3 paj3 laø t`oo` ng4 pajø person REL die go PRF OBLIG DIR . ABL COP spirit ‘People who die must become spirits.’
T`oo` ng4 often co-occurs with the achievement marker dajø. For example, a hotel manager states that if guests’ belongings go missing, she is required to report it to the police:
224 (553)
Aspectual-modal marking
haw2 t`oo` ng4 dajø pajø haa3 tamluat5 1. FA OBLIG ACHV DIR . ABL visit police ‘I must go to visit the police.’
When combined with negation, the reading of t`oo` ng4 is ‘need not’ (i.e., not necessary to) rather than ‘must not’ (i.e., necessary not to). For example, a chef gives the recipe for a Lao dish called larb, and says that one need not add a lot of MSG. The idea of necessity is conveyed with t`oo` ng4, negated: (554)
b`oø t`oo` ng4 saj1 laaj3 NEG OBLIG put much ‘(One) need not put in a lot.’
To convey the idea ‘must not’ (i.e. necessary not to), a different construction is used. This involves the causative verb haj5 (elsewhere meaning ‘give’; cf. Chapter 18), negated, as in this variation on example (554): (555)
b`oø haj5 saj1 laaj3 NEG give put much ‘(One) must not put in a lot.’
In (555), it is as if the speaker is saying, ‘(I) don’t allow (you) to put a lot in’. (See Chapter 18 for further discussion of the role of haj5 ‘give’ in causative constructions.) To make the same sentiment stronger, it is possible to add the verb haam5 ‘forbid’ as a main verb: (556)
haam5 b`oø haj5 saj1 laaj3 forbid NEG give put much ‘(One is) forbidden put in a lot.’
T`oo` ng4 is occasionally used as an epistemic modal, or more specifically, as an inferential modal of necessity (cf. English must in His car is gone, so he must have already left). This epistemic modality reading typically arises in the frame t`oo` ng4 m`ee` n1 ‘(it) must be’, where the target clause is presented as a complement of the copula m`ee` n1. For example: (557)
t`oo` ng4 m`ee` n1 phen1 m`ua2 baan4 l`ee` w4 OBLIG BE . SO 3. P return home PRF ‘(It) must be that he’s gone home already.’ (E.g., because his motorcycle is gone.)
Aspectual-modal markers
225
Note that (unlike most other verb-like aspectual-modal markers) the aspectual-modal and verbal meanings of t`oo` ng4 can freely co-occur, as shown here: (558)
caw4 b`oø t`oo` ng4 t`oo` ng4 man2 2 SG . P NEG OBLIG touch 3. B ‘You needn’t (or shouldn’t) touch it.’
campˆen3 – strong obligative modal (OBLIG . STR) As an intransitive main verb, campˆen3 means ‘necessary, required, mandatory’: (559)
s`ua5 kan3 naaw3 campˆen3 dee4 shirt prevent cold OBLIG . STR FAC . ONRCD ‘A cold weather jacket is necessary, y’hear!’
As a preverbal aspectual-modal, campˆen3 is restricted to a strong obligative function, and cannot be used for epistemic or evidential necessity: (560)
caw4 campˆen3 qaw3 s`ua5 kan3 naaw3 paj3 2 SG . P OBLIG . STR take shirt prevent cold go ‘You must/are required to take a cold weather jacket there.’
In its preverbal aspectual-modal function, campˆen3 is often combined with preverbal aspectual-modals of similar meaning. In an example, campˆen3 is combined with the achievement marker dajø which sometimes has a modal meaning of obligation: (561)
phacaw4 kut2salaat4 kaø campˆen3 dajø song1 mia2 nii3 T. LNK OBLIG . STR ACHV send wife flee lord K ‘So, Lord Kutsalaat was required to send his wife away.’ (i.e., ‘...had no choice but to...’)
In another example, yet another marker of necessity is added: t`oo` ng4 ‘must’. A hotel manager is describing her system for getting visas for foreign tourists to Vietnam and Cambodia. She normally relies on assistants to go back and forth from the hotel to the relevant embassy. But occasionally her assistants are not available, in which case it is necessary
226
Aspectual-modal marking
that she herself go. This obligation is marked by campˆen3 ‘necessary’ in combination with both the general modal of necessity t`oo` ng4 ‘must’ and the achievement marker dajø: (562)
kh`oo` j5 campˆen3 t`oo` ng4 dajø paj3 qˆeeˆ ng3 1 SG . P OBLIG . STR OBLIG ACHV go self ‘I am required (or obliged) to go myself.’
It is also possible for campˆen3 to occur just with dajø: (563) kh`oo` j5 campˆen3 dajø paj3 qˆeeˆ ng3 1 SG . P OBLIG . STR ACHV go self ‘I am required to go myself.’ khuan2 – weak obligative modal (OBLIG . WEAK) The notion ‘should’ is conveyed by the post-negation aspectual modal khuan2. This word has no independent verbal use, but does appear in a compound adjective som3-khuan2 ‘to be appropriate’ (where som3 is an adjective meaning ‘fitting’). The modality conveyed here is general, in that it may be used in expressing specific statements of what someone should do, or what should happen (i.e., when it is not happening)— as shown in example (564)—or in more general statements about what generally should happen or be the case, whether or not it actually does (example (565)): nii4 khuan2 nap1-th`uu` 3 cua3 qong3 novice.monk CLF. HOLY DEM OBLIG . WEAK count-hold n˜ aa2-ph`oo` 1 abbot ‘This novice monk should respect (the) abbot.’ (implies that this novice monk is not respecting the abbot) nap1-th`uu` 3 n˜ aa2-ph`oo` 1 (565) cua3 khuan2 novice.monk OBLIG . WEAK count-hold abbot ‘Novice monks should respect abbots.’ (Compatible with the possibility that all novice monks do in fact respect abbots.)
(564)
In the following example, the speaker is stating the moral of a fable, using khuan2 to mark the state of affairs which ‘should’ be the case, i.e., which is desired but not necessarily true:
Aspectual-modal markers
(566)
227
pˆen3 luuk4 pˆen3 laan3 khuan2 mii2 phuø MC . HUM COP child COP grandchild OBLIG . WEAK have khuam2 katan˜nuu3-katavˆeeˆ 2thii2 t`oo` 1 ph`oo` 1-m`ee` 1 NZR gratitude-piety toward father-mother ‘Those who are children and grandchildren should have gratitude and piety toward their parents.’
In a similar context, a speaker summarizes the moral of a tale he has just told, in which a child saves the day by staying calm in a terrifying situation: (567)
phop1 khuam2 sathaan4-jaan4-kua3 hanø haw2 pajø TPC . DIST fear 1. B DIR . ABL meet NZR naø haw2 b`oø khuan2 jaan4 keen3 paj3 TPC . PERIPH 1. B NEG OBLIG . WEAK afraid excessive go ‘(If) we encounter a terrifying situation, we should not be overly afraid.’
In a final example, a king is selecting from among all the bald men in the kingdom, looking for the one who can best represent him in an inter-kingdom bald head butting competition. Using ideophones (Chapter 12), the speaker distinguishes between different patterns of baldness, and states their properties. Men with one type of baldness are not appropriate for civil service: (568)
laan4 b`ee` p5 n`ung1 kaø laan4 sameng4-keng4, b`oø NEG bald manner one T. LNK bald IDEO khuan2 th`uu` k5 laa2sakaan3 OBLIG . WEAK strike civil.service ‘One type of baldness is sameng-keng, they shouldn’t go into official employment.’
naa5-caø – counterfactual weak obligative modal (OBLIG . CF) The word naa5, a body part term meaning ‘face’ or a relational noun meaning ‘front’ or ‘in front of’, may be used as an aspectual-modal conveying a kind of counterfactual weak obligative modal meaning. The modality conveyed here is narrower than that of khuan2, above. It incorporates the meaning of khuan2, as just described, and adds that the thing
228
Aspectual-modal marking
which should be the case is not the case. So, like khuan2, naa5-caø may be used in stating what should happen (i.e., when it is not happening), as shown in the following example (cf. example (564), above): (569)
nii4 naa5-caø nap1-th`uu` 3 cua3 qong3 novice.monk CLF. HOLY DEM OBLIG . CF-IRR count-hold n˜ aa2-ph`oo` 1 abbot ‘This novice monk should respect (the) abbot(s).’ (entails that this novice monk is not respecting the abbot)
But naa5-caø is typically inappropriate for making more general statements about what generally should happen or be the case, since it requires that the target state of affairs does not hold (cf. example (565), above): (570)
nap1-th`uu` 3 n˜ aa2-ph`oo` 1 cua3 naa5-caø novice.monk OBLIG . CF-IRR count-hold abbot ‘Novice monks should respect abbots.’ (Only when speaker wants to say ‘Novice monks don’t respect abbots and they should’.)
It is possible to use naa5-caø for a kind of speculative epistemic modality, by which the speaker asserts what they would be likely to conclude, given the available evidence: juu1 baan4 (571) sii1 moong2 l`ee` w4, phen1 naa5-caø four o’clock PRF 3. P OBLIG . CF - IRR be.at home ‘It’s four o’clock already, he should be at home.’ (i.e., because he is normally home at four.) saamaat4 – abilitive dynamic modal (ABLE) The word saa3maat4 (from Sanskrit s¯am¯artha ‘ability to or capacity for’; Monier-Williams 1899:1205) appears in combination with postverbal daj4 ‘can’ (see section 9.1.1, above), and indeed almost never appears without it. Here are some examples: (572)
saa3maat4 khaj3 faa3 q`oo` k5 daj4 ABLE open lid exit CAN ‘It’s possible for the lid to be opened.’
Aspectual-modal markers
(573)
229
bia4 ... t`oo` ng4 mii2 qaa3˜nuq1 s`oo` ng3 pii3 kh`un5 paj3 two year ascend go seedling OBLIG have age k`oo` n1 saa3maat4 puuk5 daj4 plant CAN before ABLE ‘The seedlings ... must have an age of two years or more before (they) can be planted.’
Here is a rare example of preverbal saa3maat4 without accompanying postverbal daj4: (574) haw2 kaø saa3maat4 j`uu` m3 ngen2 maa2 borrow money come 1. B T. LNK ABLE ‘I’m able to borrow money.’ Saa3maat4 is not deverbal (it is never used as a verb) and does not have clausal head properties, such as, for example, accessibility for use as a yes-answer: (575)
Q laaw2 saa3maat4 vaw4 phaa2saa3 laaw2 daj4 b`oo` 3 speak language Lao CAN QPLR 3 SG . FA ABLE ‘Can she speak Lao?’ A1 daj4 CAN
‘(Yes, she) can.’ A2 ? saa3maat4 ABLE
(Yes, she is able to.) Negation marks saa3maat4, not daj4: kh`oo` j5 kh`oo` 3 l`uat4 caw4, qoo4 caw4 kaø b`oø saa3maat4 1 SG . P request blood 2 SG . P INTJ 2 SG . P T. LNK NEG ABLE haj5 daj4 give CAN ‘(If) I ask you for your blood, oh, you are unable to give it (to me).’ b`oø saa3maat4 pua3 daj4 (577) ... naaj2-m`oo` 3 CT. BOSS -doctor NEG ABLE treat CAN ‘...(if) the doctor is unable to treat (them)...’
(576)
230
Aspectual-modal marking
The topic linker kaø may directly mark daj4 in a saa3maat4...daj4 expression: (578)
man2 saa3maat4 tii3 pˆen3 kham2-sap2 n`ung1 hanø, strike COP mouthful-word one TPC . DIST 3. B ABLE laaj3 khuam2 kaø daj4 many meaning T. LNK CAN ‘One word, it can be interpreted as having many meanings.’
But this is incompatible with negation: (579)
man2 b`oø saa3maat4 tii3 pˆen3 laaj3 khuam2 (*? kaø) T. LNK 3. B NEG ABLE strike COP many meaning daj4 CAN
‘...it cannot be interpreted as having many meanings.’ With the topic linker kaø, (579) would be marginally interpretable, if at all, as the complex and odd ‘...it’s okay for it not to be able to be interpreted as having many meanings’ (and no epistemic reading would be possible). In other words, the topic linker kaø would force a reading of the two instances of ‘can’ as belonging to two separate clauses. I argue that the saa3maat4...daj4 combination is identical in meaning to simple daj4 ‘can’. The following examples are synonymous (example (581) is repeated from (442), above): (580)
phen1 b`oø saa3maat4 vaw4 phaa2saa3 laaw2 daj4 speak language Lao CAN 3. P NEG ABLE ‘She can’t speak Lao.’
(581)
phen1 vaw4 phaa2saa3 laaw2 b`oø daj4 3. P speak language Lao NEG CAN ‘She can’t speak Lao.’
The ‘inability’ described in example (580) may be due to the same range of background contextual explanations described for (442), above: physical limitations, lack of permission, and so on. While epistemic modality readings are marginally possible for each of these examples, neither seems to favor such a reading. The contribution of saa3maat4 is not semantic but structural and pragmatic.
Aspectual-modal markers
231
In terms of its structural role, saa3maat4 often appears when the verb phrase under the scope of postverbphrasal ‘can’ is heavy or complex. The following examples show a complex serial and compound construction (582), a causative construction (583), and a distributive clause chain (584), explicitly bracketed by saa3maat4 to the left, and daj4 to the right: haw2 kaø saa3maat4 lop2-liik5 pot2 q`oo` k5 caak5 turn-escape liberate exit from 1. B T. LNK ABLE daj4 phaj2 hanø danger TPC . DIST CAN ‘We are (thus) able to avoid the danger.’ (583) khaw3 saa3maat4 s`oo` n3 haj5 haw2 khaw5-caj3 daj4 vaa1 3 PL . B ABLE teach give 1. B enter-heart CAN COMP qanø nii4 qaan1 cang1 daj3 MC . INAN DEM read manner INDEF ‘They were able to teach us to understand how this was read.’ (584) saa3maat4 s`uu` 4 khaw5-cii1 s`uu` 4 khaj1 l`ekaø s`uu` 4 law5 ABLE buy bread buy egg C . LNK buy liquor kin3 daj4 consume CAN ‘(They were) able to buy bread and eggs, and buy liquor to drink.’
(582)
Saa3maat4 in these examples signposts the scope of ‘can’, by explicitly bracketing the complex predication coming under it.
9.1.7
Achievement marker
There is a unique slot for a marker of achievement or realization, dajø. This is derived from a verb daj4 ‘obtain, acquire, succeed’ (cf. Enfield 2003c). In its achievement marker function, it is de-stressed, in effect cliticized to what follows it. This marker conveys the idea that some prior state of affairs has made it possible for the predicate state of affairs to be the case. Common translations of a predicate V marked with dajø include ‘did V’, ‘managed to V’, and ‘got to V’. The following example shows clearly the relation between marking with dajø and the idea that the state of affairs denoted by the marked predicate arises (or becomes possible) as an outcome of some previous state of affairs being the case. The speaker
232
Aspectual-modal marking
is talking about lean times soon after the revolution of 1975, and states that at that time everyone had to grow vegetables for themselves: (585)
caw4 b`oø puuk5 phak2, caw4 kaø b`oø dajø kin3 2 SG . P NEG plant vegetable 2 SG . P T. LNK NEG ACHV eat phak2 vegetable ‘(If) you didn’t plant vegetables (yourself), you wouldn’t get to eat vegetables.’
In another example, dajø is employed for discourse-related emphasis on the realization of the state of affairs denoted by the predicate (cf. the function of English auxiliary do in He did see them versus He saw them): (586)
hˆen3 ph`oø-luung2 phuø-n`ung1 laaw2 dajø maø 3 SG . FA ACHV DIR . ALL see CT. Fa-PeB MC . HUM-one ‘He did (come and) see one old man...’
In the following example, dajø occurs with negation: (587)
haw2 b`oø dajø kin3 khaw5 dˆej2 1. FA NEG ACHV eat rice FAC . NEWS ‘I didn’t (get to) eat, you know.’
While there is no formal marking of tense in Lao, the preverbal combination b`oø-dajø NEG - ACHV conveys a kind of simple ‘negative past’. That is, with negation, the notion of ‘achievement’ normally conveyed by dajø is relatively bleached.
9.1.8
Directional markers
The directional markers are de-stressed, cliticized forms of the verbs paj3 ‘go’ and maa2 ‘come’. As directionals, they are glossed as ‘ablative’ and ‘allative’, respectively, reflecting their directionality with reference to the clausal subject. In some cases, their function as post-negation aspectualmodals is transparently related to the deictic motion they express as full verbs:
Aspectual-modal markers
233
haa3 sii3hoo3 song1 saan3 pajø send message DIR . ABL seek S ‘Send a message to Siho.’ buat5 juu1 vat1 k`ee` ng4-k`oo` k5 (589) buat5 pˆen3 phaq1, maø ordain COP monk DIR . ALL ordain be.at temple K-K ‘(I) was ordained as a monk, (I) came and got ordained at Keng Kok Temple.’ (588)
In another example, a man describes the community dance evenings that would regularly take place in lowland urban areas in the early revolutionary period (1975 onwards). Soldiers would attend with full weaponry including loaded automatic weapons and grenade belts. Young village girls would be asked to dance with these soldiers: (590)
muan1 jaan4 laaj3, laaj3 k`oo` n1 vaa1 thii1 caø maø scared much much before COMP REL IRR DIR . ALL enjoy ‘(They were) very scared, more so than they (came and) enjoyed (the dancing).’
In cases like these, the directional markers are straightforwardly related to motion verbs embedded in serial verb constructions (cf. Chapter 16). We can see, however, that these constructions are grammaticized to a certain degree. In many examples, particularly those involving the allative directional maø (from maa2 ‘come’), no motion of the subject need be involved. In certain cases, no movement is even plausible. In an example featuring the ablative directional pajø, the hero Sinxay meets his aunt Sumunthaa, but she does not recognize him. This is because: (591)
keet5 juu1 paa1 dˆeeˆ 4 man2 pajø 3. B DIR . ABL born be.at forest FAC . FILLIN ‘He (went and got) born in the forest, you see.’
Sinxay can’t literally have ‘gone’ to the forest before being born. Often with the allative directional maø the sense of motion is not motion of the subject argument itself, but rather DIRECTEDNESS of the action TOWARD the subject. For example: (592)
phen1 qaw3 p`um4 maø qaan1 3. P take book DIR . ALL read ‘She took a book and read (it).’
234
Aspectual-modal marking
In this example, the directional marker does not refer to any motion on the part of the main subject. It refers to the self-directed motion of the action involved in reading (i.e., taking the book in hand and orienting it towards oneself in order to attend). In another example, both directionals are used, yet where motion to and fro is not part of what is being predicated. The speaker is talking about a period in recent Lao history during which citizens were banned from access to foreign media. In order to get news from the outside world, many people would secretly listen to the radio. In expressing the idea ‘Citizens would listen to the radio’, this speaker uses both directionals— the ablative pajø marking ‘taking’ the radios and the allative maø marking ‘listening to’ them, helping to convey the furtive thither-directed procuring and hither-directed hiding of their radios: (593)
qaw3 vitha˜nuq1 maø fang2 pasaa2son2 siø pajø IRR DIR . ABL take radio DIR . ALL listen citizen ‘Citizens would go and take radios to listen to.’
The directional markers play a special role in certain types of serial verb construction, such as those involved in the syntax of three-place predicates, as illustrated in examples (588), (592), and (593). See Chapter 15, section 15.2.1 for further discussion.
9.2
Other temporal expressions
This section notes a number of other structures used in specifying temporal features of events and temporal relations between events. Temporal adjuncts may be formed using t`oo` n3 ‘time/when’. These are usually placed before the clause they mark, in the extraclausal Left Position, as in (594). (See Haiman 1985:39ff on the expression of subordinate semantic relations through syntactic coordination.) They may also appear either finally or medially, as in the subsequent two examples. (594) t`oo` n3 thamø-qit2, phuak4 kh`oo` j5 juu1 dong3 n`oq1 time at.first group 1 SG . P be.at forest QPLR . AGREE ‘At first, we were living in the forest, right?’
Other temporal expressions
(595)
(596)
235
dajø maa2, t`oo` n3 nan4 tamluat5 b`oø than2 police NEG ON . TIME ACHV come time DEM . NONPROX ‘The police had not yet arrived, (at) that time.’ kham2 t`oo` n3 nan4 baat5 n`ung1 gold time DEM . NONPROX half.ounce one phan2-s`oo` ng3-l`oo` j4 dˆej2 thousand-two-hundred FAC . NEWS ‘(The price of) gold at that time was 1200 per half ounce, you know.’
T`oo` n3 ‘time’ may be used to link two clauses. Usually the first clause is so marked, as in the first two examples below; but occasionally, as shown in the third example it is the second clause which is marked by t`oo` n3 ‘time/when’: kuu3 juu1 b`oo` n1 t`oo` n3 m`ung2 hˆet1 qanø-nan4, time 2 SG . B do MC . INAN-DEM . NONPROX 1 SG . B be.at place q`uu` n1 other ‘When you did that, I was in another place.’ (598) t`oo` n3 ph`oo` 1 kh`oo` j5 taaj3 l`ee` w4, kh`oo` j5 tat2.sin3-caj3 qˆeeˆ ng3 time father 1 SG . P die PRF 1 SG . P decide-heart self kh`oo` j5 paj3 m`uang2-thaj2 1 SG . P go country-Thai ‘When my father was dead, I decided myself (that) I’d go to Thailand.’ (599) kh`oo` j5 hˆen3 t`oo` n3 kh`oo` j5 m`oo` 1 siø h`oo` t4 talaat5 1 SG . P see time 1 SG . P almost IRR reach market naa3 FAC . EXPLIC ‘I saw (it) when I had almost reached the market, you see.’ (597)
T`oo` n3 ‘time/when’ may also appear as a nominal head referring to a period of time, an era, or a period of the day (‘morning’, ‘afternoon’, ‘evening’):
236
Aspectual-modal marking
haw2 kh`ut1 h`oo` t4 t`oo` n3 kˆep2 kafˆeeˆ 2 1. FA think reach time harvest coffee ‘I miss the time (I was) harvesting coffee.’ (601) ph`oq1 vaa1 t`oo` n3 saw4 man2 lot1 laaj3 because COMP time morning 3. B vehicle many ‘Because in the morning there are lots of vehicles (on the road).’
(600)
Occurrence time (i.e., countable times as in ‘John sneezed three times’) does not use t`oo` n3, but th`ua1 ‘instance’, as follows: (602)
l`ee` w4 kuu3 b`oo` k5 m`ung2 laaj3 thua1 ` 1 SG . B tell 2 SG . B many instance PRF ‘(I’ve) told (you) many times already.’
‘Now’ is expressed by diaw3-nii4, which morphologically includes diaw3 ‘single, lone, same’ and nii4 ‘this’. It appears clause-initially or clause-finally, although the former is preferred. diaw3-nii4 n˜ ang2 pˆen3 hiin3 NOW STILL COP stone ‘Now (that snake) is still stone.’ (604) diaw3-nii4 khacaw4 kaø saang5 kh`oo` p4-khua2 met2 l`ee` w4 NOW 3 PL . P T. LNK build family all PRF ‘Now they have all got families.’
(603)
K`oo` n1 ‘before’ and lang3-caak5 ‘after’ function to locate two clauses in time relative to each other, and it is usually the first clause that is marked: caø n˜ ang3 haw2 n˜ ang2 dajø k`oo` n1 caø q`ee` m4 before IRR put.on.walling IRR INDEF. INAN 1. FA STILL ACHV hˆet1 haan4 haj5 man2 make platform give 3. B ‘Before we put the walls on and whatever, we still must make them some platforms.’ (606) lang3-caak5 qaw3 saw3 fang3 l`ee` w4, haw2 kaø t`oo` k5 after take post bury PRF 1. FA T. LNK nail khaang3 crossbeam ‘After we plant the posts, then we nail on the crossbeams.’
(605)
Other temporal expressions
237
In the following example, k`oo` n1 ‘before’ takes a nominal complement khaw3 ‘3 PL . B’, but this is elliptical (as indicated by the translation): (607) haw2 nii4 laø tˆen4 q`oo` k5 k`oo` n1 khaw3 1. FA DEM PRF jump exit before 3 PL . B ‘I jumped out (of the boat) before they (did).’ In the next examples, k`oo` n1 ‘before’ is used adverbially (i.e., without an overt complement), and corresponds to English ‘first’: k`oo` n1 haw2 kaø beng1 juu1 ... khaw3 qaw3 n˜ ang3 1. FA T. LNK look CONT ... 3 PL . B take INDEF. INAN before ‘I was watching (them) ... (to see) what would they take first.’ (609) b`oø l`ee` w4, met2 ngen2 k`oo` n1 NEG finish exhaust money before ‘(It’s) not finished, (I) ran out of money first.’
(608)
A similar adverbial function is observed for ‘after’, but in Lao this does not involve lang3-caak5. Rather, for the adverbial sense of ‘after’, where no overt complement appears, Lao speakers use a different construction nam2-lang3, literally ‘going after the back of’. kh`oo` j5 (610) p`ee` 3 vaa1 kh`oo` j5 keet5 nam2-lang3 dˆeeˆ 4, translate COMP 1 SG . P born follow-back FAC . FILLIN 1 SG . P b`oø huu4-cak2 NEG know ‘I mean, I was born afterwards—I don’t know (about that).’ In narratives, k`oo` n1 ‘before’ and lang3-caak5 ‘after’ have no entailments as to any other relationships (such as causal or conditional) between events. Finally, an expression ph`oø-dii3, an idiom from ph`oo` 2 ‘enough’ and dii3 ‘good’, acts as a clause linker meaning ‘as soon as’, ‘right when’, as shown in the following examples (modeled for comparison on examples (598) and (606), above):
238
Aspectual-modal marking
ph`oø-dii3 ph`oo` 1 kh`oo` j5 taaj3 l`ee` w4, kh`oo` j5 tat2.sin3-caj3 enough-good father 1 SG . P die PRF 1 SG . P decide-heart qˆeeˆ ng3 kh`oo` j5 paj3 m`uang2-thaj2 self 1 SG . P go country-Thai ‘As soon as my father was dead, I decided myself (that) I’d go to Thailand.’ (612) ph`oø-dii3 qaw3 saw3 fang3 l`ee` w4, haw2 kaø t`oo` k5 enough-good take post bury PRF 1. FA T. LNK nail khaang3 crossbeam ‘As soon as we plant the posts, then we nail on the crossbeams.’
(611)
Chapter 10 Verbs and verb types Words in the verb class express a range of concepts which in other languages (e.g., English) may be expressed in three distinct word classes: verb, adjective, and adverb. The following examples show vaj2 ‘fast’ as a main predicate (613), as a modifier in a noun phrase (614), and as an adverbial modifier of a main predicate (615): lot1 khan2 nii4 vaj2 vehicle CLF DEM fast ‘This vehicle is fast.’ (614) lot1 vaj2 khan2 nii4 ngaam2 vehicle fast CLF DEM beautiful ‘This fast vehicle is beautiful.’ (615) lot1 khan2 nii4 l`ee` n1 vaj2 vehicle CLF DEM run fast ‘This vehicle goes fast.’
(613)
Grammatically, all verbs may take direct negation with the negator b`oø, may be marked by the preverbal progressive marker kamlang2 and the postverbal perfective marker l`ee` w4 as well as other aspectual-model markers, and may freely function as direct modifiers in noun phrases. Minor sub-distinctions within this class may be established (e.g., accessibility to certain types of reduplication), and these correspond to distinctions more markedly grammaticalized in other languages (e.g., between property concept words and action/event words). Adverbs are not a distinct word class, but are simply verbs used in certain slots.
10.1
Characteristics of the verb class
The term verb may be used for members of the class of words accessible to a defined set of grammatical markings and processes associated with words denoting semantically prototypical actions/events (e.g., tii3 ‘hit’,
240
Verbs and verb types
l`ee` n1 ‘run’, haj5 ‘give’, hˆen3 ‘see’, vaw4 ‘speak’). This category in Lao includes words denoting not only actions and events, but also words denoting property concepts which in some other languages are confined to a distinct adjective class (e.g., suung3 ‘(be) tall’, dii3 ‘(be) good’, d`ee` ng3 ‘(be) red’). Canonical main verbs such as tii3 ‘hit’, vaw4 ‘say’, or hˆen3 ‘see’ in simple clauses have the following distinguishing properties, which they do not share with nominals: ·
Verbs may be directly marked by aspectual-modal elements, including: preverbal: - negator b`oø - irrealis markers siø and caø - achievement marker dajø - progressive markers kamlang2 and phuam2 postverbal: - perfect marker l`ee` w4
·
Verbs are commonly used alone in affirmative responses to polar questions (‘yes-answers’)
·
Verbs may (in combination with their complements) form nominal modifiers in combination with the relativizer thii1
·
Verbs may be modified directly by ideophones
Figure 10.1. Distinguishing properties of Lao verbs
10.1.1
Nominals as predicates
Nominals can be used as verbless clause complements, as in the following example: (616)
[khon2 m`uang2 phiin2]NP2 [˜naø-thaan1 nan4]NP1 DEM . NONPROX person district P abbot ‘That abbot (was) a Phiin District person.’
However, no verbal trappings are available for clause complements of this kind. The following examples show that the noun phrase which
Characteristics of the verb class
241
functions as a predicate in (616) (i.e., the noun phrase subscripted ‘NP2’) cannot take direct negation (617), irrealis marking (618), achievement marking (619), nor progressive marking (620), nor can it function as a modifier of a nominal linked by the relativizer thii1 (621): (617)
(618)
(619)
(620)
(621)
10.1.2
b`oø khon2 m`uang2 phiin2 * n˜ aø-thaan1 nan4 DEM . NONPROX NEG person district P abbot (That abbot (was) not a Phiin District person.) siø khon2 m`uang2 phiin2 * n˜ aø-thaan1 nan4 DEM . NONPROX IRR person district P abbot (That abbot (will be) a Phiin District person.) dajø khon2 m`uang2 phiin2 * n˜ aø-thaan1 nan4 DEM . NONPROX ACHV person district P abbot (That abbot was a Phiin District person.) kamlang2 khon2 m`uang2 phiin2 * n˜ aø-thaan1 nan4 DEM . NONPROX PROG person district P abbot (That abbot (was) being a Phiin District person.) * n˜ aø-thaan1 thii1 khon2 m`uang2 phiin2 REL person district P abbot (an abbot who (was) a Phiin District person)
Verb sub-classes
While all Lao verbs display the properties given above, they vary with respect to more subtle grammatical possibilities. This variation may be used as a basis for sub-categorization of the verb class, as illustrated in Figure 10.2. A first division is between active and stative verbs. Unlike active verbs, stative verbs (a) do not normally take marking for progressive aspect, and (b) when marked with the postposed perfective l`ee` w4, entail their own truth at the moment of speech. For example, mii2 ngen2 l`ee` w4 [have money PRF] means ‘(I) already have (the) money’ (entailing that I have it now), while hˆen3 ngen2 l`ee` w4 [see money PRF] means ‘(I) have already seen (the) money’ (not entailing that I see it now). Semantically, active verbs entail ‘something happens’, while stative verbs
242
Verbs and verb types
VERBS ACTIVE
activity accomplishment
STATIVE
achievement adjective
state
open activity
Figure 10.2. Taxonomy of verb sub-types
do not. Within the class of active verbs, a first distinction is between activities and achievements, where for example only the former may appear as a complement of leem4 ‘begin to’. Activities may be further subdivided into accomplishments and open activities, where for example only the former can take b`oø l`ee` w4 [NEG PRF] as a complement (e.g., h`uan2 kuu3 puk2 b`oø l`ee` w4 [house 1 SG . B build NEG PRF] ‘My house has not finished being built’). The class of stative verbs is divided into adjective verbs and state verbs, with only adjective verbs being available for Type A reduplication. This and other differences are discussed in below sections. Figure 10.2 is a true taxonomy. This means that any node is a more narrowly defined instance of any of the nodes to which it is connected by above-going lines. Following examples illustrate the common behavior of the different verb sub-types. The examples used are phop1 ‘meet’ (achievement), puk2 h`uan2 ‘build house’ (accomplishment), n˜ aang1 ‘walk’ (open activity), mii2 p`um4 ‘have book’ (state), and suung3 ‘tall’ (adjective). First, all these verb sub-types may be directly marked (preverbally) by the irrealis markers siø and caø: (622)
kh`oo` j5 siø phop1 man2 1 SG . P IRR meet 3. B ‘I will meet him.’ (623) kh`oo` j5 siø puk2 h`uan2 1 SG . P IRR build house ‘I will build a house.’
Characteristics of the verb class
243
(624)
kh`oo` j5 siø n˜ aang1 1 SG . P IRR walk ‘I will walk.’ (625) kh`oo` j5 siø mii2 p`um4 1 SG . P IRR have book ‘I will have a book.’ (626) kh`oo` j5 siø suung3 1 SG . P IRR tall ‘I will be tall.’ All verbs may be directly marked (preverbally) by the negator b`oø: (627)
(628)
(629)
(630)
(631)
kh`oo` j5 b`oø phop1 man2 1 SG . P NEG meet 3. B ‘I don’t/won’t meet him.’ kh`oo` j5 b`oø puk2 h`uan2 1 SG . P NEG build house ‘I don’t/won’t build a house.’ kh`oo` j5 boø n˜ aang1 1 SG . P NEG walk ‘I don’t/won’t walk.’ kh`oo` j5 b`oø mii2 p`um4 1 SG . P NEG have book ‘I don’t have a book.’ kh`oo` j5 b`oø suung3 1 SG . P NEG tall I am not tall.’
The two stative verb sub-types group together in not giving future readings when appearing with the negation marker (630, 631). All verbs may be directly marked (preverbally) by the achievement marker dajø: (632)
kh`oo` j5 dajø phop1 man2 1 SG . P ACHV meet 3. B ‘I did/got to meet him.’
244
Verbs and verb types
(633)
kh`oo` j5 dajø puk2 h`uan2 1 SG . P ACHV build house ‘I did/got to build a house.’ (634) kh`oo` j5 dajø n˜ aang1 1 SG . P ACHV walk ‘I did/got to walk.’ (635) ? kh`oo` j5 dajø mii2 p`um4 1 SG . P ACHV have book ‘I did have a book.’ (636) ? kh`oo` j5 dajø suung3 1 SG . P ACHV tall ‘I was/got to be tall.’ The use of the preverbal achievement marker dajø with stative verbs is pragmatically marked (635-636). Elicitation gets mostly negative responses, but these combinations are considered acceptable with inchoative readings and with negation. They certainly occur in spontaneous speech. All verbs may be directly marked (preverbally) by the progressive marker kamlang2: (637)
kh`oo` j5 kamlang2 phop1 man2 meet 3. B 1 SG . P PROG ‘I am meeting him.’ (638) kh`oo` j5 kamlang2 puk2 h`uan2 1 SG . P PROG build house ‘I am building a house.’ (639) kh`oo` j5 kamlang2 n˜ aang1 1 SG . P PROG walk ‘I am walking.’ (640) ? kh`oo` j5 kamlang2 mii2 p`um4 have book 1 SG . P PROG ‘I am having/getting (a) book(s).’ (641) ? kh`oo` j5 kamlang2 suung3 tall 1 SG . P PROG ‘I am being/getting tall.’
Characteristics of the verb class
245
Again, this marking is unusual with stative verbs (640-641), unless some kind of gradability or inchoativization is construed (e.g., coming into possession of many books, getting tall). All verbs may be used in combination with the postverbal perfect marker l`ee` w4: (642)
(643)
(644)
(645)
(646)
kh`oo` j5 phop1 man2 l`ee` w4 1 SG . P meet 3. B PRF ‘I met him already.’ kh`oo` j5 puk2 h`uan2 l`ee` w4 1 SG . P build house PRF ‘I built a/the house already.’ kh`oo` j5 n˜ aang1 l`ee` w4 1 SG . P walk PRF ‘I have walked/did walk already.’ kh`oo` j5 mii2 p`um4 l`ee` w4 1 SG . P have book PRF ‘I already have a book.’ kh`oo` j5 suung3 l`ee` w4 PRF 1 SG . P tall ‘I am already tall.’
The perfect marker l`ee` w4 shows another contrast between stative and active verbs. When a stative verb combines with l`ee` w4, there is an entailment that ‘P is the case now’. This entailment does not hold with active verbs. In (642-646), both and only the examples featuring stative verbs entail that the verb is the case at the time of utterance. If a speaker utters (646), then he is tall at the time of speech; if he utters (645), then he has a book at the time of speech. In none of (642-644), however, does the combination ‘V-l`ee` w4’ entail ‘V now’. All verbs may (in combination with their complements) form nominal modifiers in combination with the relativizer thii1: (647) khon2 thii1 phop1 man2 person REL meet 3. B ‘the person who meets him’
246
Verbs and verb types
(648)
khon2 thii1 puk2 h`uan2 person REL build house ‘the person who builds a house’ (649) khon2 thii1 n˜ aang1 person REL walk ‘the person who walks’ (650) khon2 thii1 mii2 p`um4 person REL have book ‘the person who has a book’ (651) khon2 thii1 suung3 person REL tall ‘the person who is tall’ All verbs may be used alone in affirmative responses to polar questions (i.e., as yes-answers), as illustrated in the following two examples: (652)
(653)
Q: caw4 phop1 man2 b`oo` 3 2 SG . P meet 3. B QPLR ‘Did/will you meet him?’ A: phop1 meet ‘(Yes, I did/will) meet (him).’ Q: man2 suung3 b`oo` 3 QPLR 3. B tall ‘Is he tall?’ A: suung3 tall ‘(Yes, he is) tall.’
Many verbs may be nominalized using either of the nominalizers kaan3 ‘work, activity’ or khuam2 ‘sense’. These nominalizers have different meanings, kaan3 appearing more often with activity verbs and khuam2 appearing more often with adjectives: (654)
a. kaan3 khaa5 [activity kill] ‘killing’ b. kaan3 l`uu` m2 [activity forget] ‘forgetting’
Characteristics of the verb class
(655)
c. a. b. c.
247
kaan3 kha˜naaj3 [activity expand] ‘expansion’ khuam2 dii3 [sense good] ‘goodness’ khuam2 dang3 [sense loud] ‘volume’ khuam2 ngaam2 [sense beautiful] ‘beauty’
These are tendencies only. Sometimes adjectives can appear with kaan3 (e.g., kaan3 dii3 [activity good] ‘an