Van Loon
The World of the Roosevelts Published in Cooperation with the Franklin and Eleanor Roosevelt Institute Hyde ...
103 downloads
1383 Views
2MB Size
Report
This content was uploaded by our users and we assume good faith they have the permission to share this book. If you own the copyright to this book and it is wrongfully on our website, we offer a simple DMCA procedure to remove your content from our site. Start by pressing the button below!
Report copyright / DMCA form
Van Loon
The World of the Roosevelts Published in Cooperation with the Franklin and Eleanor Roosevelt Institute Hyde Park, New York General Editors: Arthur M. Schlesinger, Jr., William vanden Heuvel, and Douglas Brinkley FDR AND HIS CONTEMPORARIES Foreign Perceptions of an American President Edited by Cornelis A. van Minnen and John F. Sears NATO: THE FOUNDING OF THE ATLANTIC ALLIANCE AND THE INTEGRATION OF EUROPE Edited by Francis H. Heller and John R. Gillingham AMERICA UNBOUND World War II and the Making of a Superpower Edited by Warren F. Kimball THE ORIGINS OF U.S. NUCLEAR STRATEGY, 1945–1953 Samuel R. Williamson, Jr. and Steven L. Rearden AMERICAN DIPLOMATS IN THE NETHERLANDS, 1815–50 Cornelis A. van Minnen EISENHOWER, KENNEDY, AND THE UNITED STATES OF EUROPE Pascaline Winand ALLIES AT WAR The Soviet, American, and British Experience, 1939–1945 Edited by David Reynolds, Warren F. Kimball, and A. O. Chubarian THE ATLANTIC CHARTER Edited by Douglas Brinkley and David R. Facey-Crowther PEARL HARBOR REVISITED Edited by Robert W. Love, Jr.
ADENAUER AND KENNEDY A Study in German-American Relations Frank A. Mayer THEODORE ROOSEVELT AND THE BRITISH EMPIRE A Study in Presidential Statecraft William N. Tilchin TARIFFS, TRADE AND EUROPEAN INTEGRATION, 1947–1957 From Study Group to Common Market Wendy Asbeek Brusse SUMNER WELLES FDR’s Global Strategist A Biography by Benjamin Welles THE NEW DEAL AND PUBLIC POLICY Edited by Byron W. Daynes, William D. Pederson, and Michael P. Riccards WORLD WAR II IN EUROPE Edited by Charles F. Brower FDR AND THE U.S. NAVY Edward J. Marolda THE SECOND QUEBEC CONFERENCE REVISITED Edited by David B. Woolner THEODORE ROOSEVELT, THE U.S. NAVY, AND THE SPANISH-AMERICAN WAR Edited by Edward J. Marolda FDR, THE VATICAN, AND THE ROMAN CATHOLIC CHURCH IN AMERICA, 1933–1945 Edited by David B. Woolner and Richard G. Kurial
FDR AND THE HOLOCAUST Edited by Verne W. Newton
FDR AND THE ENVIRONMENT Edited by Henry L. Henderson and David B. Woolner
THE UNITED STATES AND THE INTEGRATION OF EUROPE Legacies of the Postwar Era Edited by Francis H. Heller and John R. Gillingham
VAN LOON Popular Historian, Journalist, and FDR Confidant Cornelis A. van Minnen
VAN LOON POPULAR HISTORIAN, JOURNALIST, FDR CONFIDANT
CORNELIS A.
VAN
MINNEN
AND
VAN LOON
© Cornelis A. van Minnen, 2005. All rights reserved. No part of this book may be used or reproduced in any manner whatsoever without written permission except in the case of brief quotations embodied in critical articles or reviews. First published in 2005 by PALGRAVE MACMILLAN™ 175 Fifth Avenue, New York, N.Y. 10010 and Houndmills, Basingstoke, Hampshire, England RG21 6XS Companies and representatives throughout the world. PALGRAVE MACMILLAN is the global academic imprint of the Palgrave Macmillan division of St. Martin’s Press, LLC and of Palgrave Macmillan Ltd. Macmillan® is a registered trademark in the United States, United Kingdom and other countries. Palgrave is a registered trademark in the European Union and other countries. ISBN 1–4039–7049–1 Library of Congress Cataloging-in-Publication Data is available from the Library of Congress. A catalogue record for this book is available from the British Library. Design by Newgen Imaging Systems (P) Ltd., Chennai, India. First edition: October 2005 10 9 8 7 6 5 4 3 2 1 Printed in the United States of America.
To William J. vanden Heuvel, Founding Father of the Roosevelt Study Center and Generous Friend
All history becomes subjective; in other words, there is properly no history, only biography. Ralph Waldo Emerson, “History,” in Essays: First Series (1841), reprinted in Ralph Waldo Emerson, Essays and Lectures (New York: The Library of America, 1983), 240.
The biographer is sentenced to labor under the brutal certainty that he can at best construct only a rough approximation of the life that was actually lived, of the personality that actually existed, and changed, from this year to that; and that most of the important knowledge he needs is never to be had. . . . By shrewd inferences from the extant data, and by an equally careful process of selection and arrangement, it may be possible to recreate a man and his life, if not in their full literal truth, then in their essence. Such is the hope that has always sustained biographers as they have gone about their impossible task. Richard D. Altick, Lives and Letters: A History of Literary Biography in England and America (New York: Alfred A. Knopf, 1966), 303.
Contents Illustrations
ix
Foreword by Arthur M. Schlesinger Jr.
xi
Acknowledgments
xiii
Prologue
1
Part I
The Formative Years
5
1.
A Troubled Youth in Holland (1882–1902)
2.
Cornell–Harvard–Cornell (1902–1905)
17
3.
Associated Press Journalist in Russia and Poland (1905–1907)
25
Historical Training in Munich (1907–1911)
33
4.
Part II
In Search of a Place
7
39
5.
Washington Years of Trial and Error (1912–1914)
41
6.
The Great War (1914–1918)
47
7.
Life in the Village (1918–1920)
59
Part III
The Jazz Age
71
8.
The Breakthrough (1921–1922)
73
9.
The Prince of Popularizers (1922–1928)
83
10.
The Veere Paradise (1928–1931)
Part IV 11.
The Educator (1931–1935)
The 1930s
109
137 139
viii
12.
Contents
For Roosevelt and the Arts (1936–1937)
13. The Prophet of the Coming Wrath (1938–1940)
Part V
The Great Fight For Freedom
161 175
197
14. The One-Man Army Division (1940–1941)
199
15. The Reincarnation of Erasmus (1942)
219
16. Living on Borrowed Time (1943–1944)
243
Epilogue
261
Notes
269
Bibliography
331
Index
344
Illustrations 1.1 Hendrik Willem van Loon, aged 6, 1888 9 1.2 Hendrik Willem van Loon aboard the Holland–America Liner S.S. Potsdam en route to New York, July 1902 15 2.1 Hendrik Willem van Loon in his study at Cornell University, September 1902 19 10.1 Hendrik Willem van Loon with “Miss America” in Zeeland costume and the mayor of Veere, August 1929 119 10.2 Hendrik Willem and Jimmie van Loon photographed by Ilse Bing in Veere, 1931 133 11.1 Hendrik Willem van Loon with Noodle at his New York Washington Square apartment with a copy of Van Loon’s Geography on the table, 1932 144 12.1 Hendrik Willem van Loon with Eleanor Roosevelt, probably at Hyde Park, 1936 162 12.2 Hendrik Willem van Loon photographed by Ilse Bing, 1936 165 12.3 Cover image of The Arts, 1937 171 13.1 Professor Albert Einstein, Rabbi Stephen Wise, and noted author Thomas Mann (left to right) are pictured as they attended the preview of Hendrik Willem van Loon’s first motion picture, The Fight for Peace, May 1938 178 13.2 Hendrik Willem van Loon at the Greenwich Time editorial offices typing his column “Deliberate Reflections,” November 1938 183 14.1 Hendrik Willem van Loon in front of WRUL microphone broadcasting as “Uncle Hank” to the Netherlands during the war years 207 15.1 Hands of Hendrik Willem van Loon which were similar, van Loon thought, to the hands of his alter ego, Erasmus of Rotterdam 222 15.2 Hendrik Willem van Loon’s drawing of Erasmus in Veere, in Van Loon’s Lives, 1942 223
This page intentionally left blank
Foreword Over forty years ago, this author reflected that in an age when knowledge grows increasingly specialized, the capacity to write about serious subjects in a lucid and arresting way becomes a necessity of civilized society. This was a gift, which the Dutch-American author Hendrik Willem van Loon possessed to a high and abundant degree. In this arresting biography, Cornelis A. van Minnen reminds us of why van Loon was such a popular “popularizer.” He had a fair amount of academic training; he took his Ph.D. at the University of Munich and lectured European history at Cornell and Antioch. Yet, while he thus served his professional apprenticeship, he never let the inhibitions of the historian’s guild restrain his own exuberance. This exuberance had its origins in his own massive and extravagant personality. He seems to have done everything on a large scale. He was six feet three inches tall; he weighed nearly three hundred pounds; he wrote over forty books; he illustrated many of them himself; he had a vast appetite for freedom, courage, friendship, and debate. He was, above all, perhaps, a man of gusto. Nearly everything interested or excited or charmed or appalled him; and this overflowing vitality accounts for the gaiety and excitement he brought to his retelling of history. As van Minnen shows, van Loon sometimes got his facts wrong— an attribute that his critics were always quick to point out. But such reproaches never unduly shook van Loon. He would denounce “pedagogical persecution” and say with appropriate bellicosity that, if he himself believed a thing long enough, it must be true. Yet the occasional exaggeration or error is less important than the essential spirit of his work. Van Loon cared deeply about history, especially American history. He had a quick and penetrating sympathy for the American experience. He remained faithful to the deeper character of American life. And for him, America was a moral and intellectual adventure. He hated the identification of America with material success; “The domination of Things,” he wrote, “militates against the free and the healthy development of ideas.” He detested the displacement of the old American rule, “Be true to your own
xii
Foreword
personality and you will be happy,” by the latter-day doctrine, “Forget that you have any personality of your own and you will be rich.” The Second World War was a year away from its conclusion when van Loon died. There was no doubt about the immediate outcome; but van Loon, as usual, had larger ends in view. He felt that America’s greatest opportunity would come once the war was over and the scourge of Nazism had been stamped out like other “hideous epidemics of loathsome diseases” in the past. Then, he believed, America would have the opportunity to show the rest of the world the road to a new and happier form of civilization. Sixty years after his death, van Loon’s appeal to history as a means to inspire America to use its overflowing abundance with generosity and wisdom becomes all the more urgent. He brought the past to life for thousands upon thousands of readers. Cornelis van Minnen has done well to bring the life of this extraordinary Dutch-American back into the public’s eye. Arthur M. Schlesinger Jr.
Acknowledgments It was during one of my visits to the Franklin D. Roosevelt Library in Hyde Park, New York, in the late 1980s—at that time I was still working on my first book, American Diplomats in the Netherlands—that by sheer coincidence I came across the very Dutch sounding name Hendrik Willem van Loon in the library’s card catalogue. Curious to see who this van Loon was, I browsed in some of Franklin and Eleanor Roosevelt’s correspondence files and soon found out that this Dutch-American immigrant writer whose letterhead carried the silhouette of Veere—the picturesque little town near Middelburg, the Netherlands, where I live myself—had played a prominent role in America’s cultural life in the 1920s through 1940s. When I also learned about his unique position vis-à-vis his native and adopted countries, I decided then and there to write a biography about this all but forgotten man. And so in the years that followed, I tried to collect materials from many archives and libraries in the United States and the Netherlands in order to reconstruct his life and work. No matter that my daily work as executive director of the Roosevelt Study Center only allowed me to work irregularly on this project, as a consequence of which the completion of this biography took much longer than I anticipated, the writing of this book has been a labor of love. I am indebted to the staffs of the libraries and archives listed in the bibliography. I want to single out the most helpful staff of the Rare and Manuscript Collections at Cornell University’s Carl A. Kroch Library where I have spent a lot of my research time, studying the voluminous Hendrik Willem van Loon papers and other collections. I also have fond recollections of working in the Franklin D. Roosevelt Library where I “discovered” van Loon first. I have spent countless hours and was helped efficiently in the Manuscript Division and Main Reading Room of the Library of Congress in Washington, D.C., and the research on this project in mid-Manhattan’s New York Public Library has always been a great pleasure to me. In October 1993 Mr. Addison B.C. Whipple, a former executive director of Time-Life Books and owner at that time of van Loon’s house Nieuw Veere, not only showed me the house from basement to attic but also van Loon’s
xiv
Acknowledgments
grave at the local cemetery. Thanks are due to him for a most memorable visit to Old Greenwich, Connecticut, where I came to appreciate more fully van Loon’s observation that the view from his house facing Long Island Sound had a striking resemblance to Veere’s surrounding sky and water and that it offered, as van Loon once wrote, “the loveliest view this side of Paradise and no Saints to bother you with questions.” Another charming host was Ms. Lorraine Allen, president of the All Souls Historical Society in New York. She not only provided me with photo copies of documents pertaining to van Loon in the Unitarian Church of All Souls Archives, but in May 1997 also gave me a wonderful tour of the church where van Loon once delivered a sermon on “History and Leadership.” Tasting the couleur locale is both a must and a delight to any biographer. For my research in my home country I am indebted to the late Princess Juliana of the Netherlands who graciously gave me permission to study the Hendrik Willem van Loon correspondence in the Koninklijk Huisarchief (Royal House Archives), which is not open to the public. The Nederlands Letterkundig Museum en Documentatiecentrum in The Hague allowed me to study the collections of Hendrik Willem van Loon, Adriaan J. Barnouw, Adriaan van der Veen and Maurits Dekker, and the late Piet van der Veen in Oostkapelle generously gave me photo copies of his privately owned van Loon letters. Peter Blom, the archivist of the Veere Municipal Archives, which later merged into the Zeeuws Archief, was very helpful in loaning me the archival materials I needed for my research. Thanks are due to my staff at the Roosevelt Study Center, especially Hans Krabbendam, assistant director, and Leontien Joosse, my most efficient secretary. In the last phase of preparing my manuscript for publication I was also helped by research assistant Ruben Vroegop. Over the years my staff members have loyally supported this book project and I am afraid I have probably told them more about van Loon than they ever cared to know. During the process of research and writing this volume, I was encouraged by a number of people who time and again expressed their interest in the subject and who were eager to see the result of my labor in print. I want to express my special gratitude to Dirk van Loon, Hendrik Willem van Loon’s grandson, who allowed me to see and use some of the family correspondence. In 1994 he interviewed his father on my behalf just some months before Hank van Loon died at age eighty-seven, and in the fall of 1996, while working on the van Loon papers at Cornell, I had the pleasure of showing Dirk van Loon letters, books, water colors, photos, and other memorabilia in his grandfather’s collection. Permanent encouragement also came from my Dutch-American friends Marsha Cohen and Dominique Boer. In the course of our conversations on my research topic, the latter even became an ardent van Loon fan and
Acknowledgments
xv
collector of his books and other publications. My talented artist friend Nancy Ostrovsky listened with great interest to my van Loon stories in the past decade during our regular and most pleasant lunch meetings in my favorite Bryant Park restaurant, located just behind the New York Public Library, and in return she provided me with a fresh look on jazz painting. I am proud to have some of her contemporary art work in my seventeenth-century house. Also the late John A. Gable, executive director of the Theodore Roosevelt Association in Oyster Bay, New York, a dear friend and colleague who died in February this year, has always stimulated me throughout the research and writing process. His death is a great loss. My friends David and Manuela Roosevelt have supported my van Loon project in the last four years and have counseled and encouraged me in moments that publication seemed out of reach. I owe many thanks to Douglas Brinkley, a prolific writer and professor of American history at Tulane University in New Orleans, and to David Woolner, executive director of the Franklin and Eleanor Roosevelt Institute at Hyde Park, New York. They were instrumental in getting this biography published in Palgrave Macmillan’s series The World of the Roosevelts. My debt to Doug and David—first-rate colleagues who have become close friends—is large. The original book manuscript was twice as long as it is now. Trent Duffy, a first-class editor, condensed and edited my manuscript to a size that was acceptable to the publisher. Thanks are due to him, as well as to Jayashree Aradhyam, my copy editor, and to Erin Ivy, production manager at Palgrave Macmillan, who skillfully guided the manuscript through the publication process. Life is meaningless without interesting friends, and I am blessed with a number of them in the Netherlands who deserve special attention: Henri Looymans (whose friendship I cherish since our student days in the mid1970s), Matthijs Breel, Lex de Looff, Hans de Graaf, and Peter van de Steenoven. The table conversations over excellent dinners we have had over the years as members of the Club Fermé both diverted me from my work and gave me new energy. Another way of reaching the same result was provided to me the last few years rather unexpectedly and opened a new horizon: due to my friend Annemiek van den Berg I discovered the beauty and joy of dancing the tango—an exercise, that’s for sure, Hendrik Willem van Loon never experienced. And last but certainly not least, I want to express my sincere thanks to Diana de Kroon, whose love has enriched my life. My work in the last two decades for the Roosevelt Study Center would not have been possible without the constant inspiration provided by the Center’s American Founding Fathers: Ambassador William J. vanden Heuvel and Arthur M. Schlesinger Jr. Himself of Dutch-Flemish stock, in his capacity as president and currently as cochair of the Franklin and Eleanor Roosevelt Institute
xvi
Acknowledgments
in New York, Ambassador vanden Heuvel, like Hendrik Willem van Loon, has served and still serves with great distinction as a bridge between the United States and the Netherlands and is a formidable force in keeping alive the legacy of Franklin and Eleanor Roosevelt. It is with gratitude and great admiration that I dedicate this book to the Honorable William J. vanden Heuvel. Cornelis Abraham van Minnen De Kleine Gouden Poorte Middelburg, 14 May 2005
Prologue It was a bright and sunny spring day, that Tuesday 14 March 1944, when the little town of Old Greenwich, Connecticut, suddenly awoke from its winter sleep when a few hundred people, most of them from New York City, invaded the community. These visitors were on their way to the funeral of Hendrik Willem van Loon, the popular historian, journalist, artist, and radio commentator. The New Haven Railroad had added extra cars to one train, which made an unscheduled stop in Old Greenwich and from the railway station private cars provided a shuttle service to the First Congregational Church. White-gloved policemen shouting “This way for the van Loon funeral!” directed the traffic. Almost four hundred people filled the church. According to one eyewitness there were at least a dozen photographers and “flashlights were popping like opening night at the Met” and the atmosphere was almost merry as people were telling each other van Loon anecdotes. She thought that instead of a funeral service for van Loon in this tiny church, “the Colosseum would have been a more appropriate place.” Those gathered to pay their last respects—a cross section of government officials, artists, elderly admirers, and even some teenagers—included New York City Mayor Fiorello H. La Guardia, radio commentator H.V. Kaltenborn, and publisher Richard L. Simon of Simon and Schuster. There were many representatives of the Dutch community in the United States, most notably Ambassador Alexander Loudon. Of course, van Loon’s relatives, friends, and neighbors were there, as were some of the women who had played a prominent role in his life: Eliza Bowditch, Ruby Fuhr, and Josa Morgan. His widow, Helen Criswell van Loon, was wearing “a black seal coat and a black velvet beret and [looked] just as white as snow.” She was so drunk that van Loon’s elder son, Henry, and his wife had to support her throughout the funeral. Prominent in front of the coffin was a standing wreath of calla and Madonna lilies with a simple white card reading “From a sad and grateful Holland,” sent by the Netherlands government. The twenty-five minute funeral service was officiated by Reverend Laurance I. Neale of New York City’s Unitarian Church of All Souls. Grace Castagnetta, pianist and van Loon’s
2
VAN LOON
collaborator on a series of songbooks, played three of van Loon’s favorite melodies on the piano: Bellman’s “The Butterflies at Haga,” Bach’s “Jesu, Joy of Man’s Desiring,” and Valerius’s “Prayer of Thanksgiving.” After the invocation and scripture readings, Rev. Neale cited eleven passages that he said were “those prophetic voices out of the ages to which Hendrik van Loon was forever listening and which were his life’s blood.” These readings included selections from Plato, Milton, the Declaration of Independence, and Emerson. Neale ended with a passage from Luigi Lucatelli: “Farewell, good Sirs, I am leaving for the future. I will wait for Humanity at the crossroads.” The coffin was then borne to the adjoining cemetery where after a brief service at the grave van Loon was buried. (Some time later his widow had the coffin disinterred and moved to a more prominent spot. A simple marble headstone engraved with van Loon’s name, the years 1882 and 1944, as well as the van Loon coat of arms, marks the last resting-place of Hendrik Willem van Loon.)1 The New York Times and New York Herald Tribune had both printed long obituaries after van Loon died on 11 March, following them up with respectful encomiums. Van Loon was described as “a man of inexhaustible talent for popularizing the obscurities of the universe in which he lived,” “a human machine of compelling energy” with an “evangelist’s zeal for sharing his findings,” and “a kind of tidal force that continued to sweep new readers into his people’s university.” As the author of the Herald Tribune editorial observed, hundreds of thousands of people were indebted to van Loon for much, if not all, of their knowledge of history, arts, geography, and other matters. This sometimes sketchy and superficial knowledge, unavoidable when covering such vast topics, was better than no knowledge at all, he thought. The Times editorial noted that although van Loon had arrived in New York several centuries after the early Dutch settlers, he had “in some ways [come] to possess the city as fully as they did.” And it praised van Loon for having been “a liberal to the core of his soul and a fearless voice against tyranny.”2 In the fortnightly bulletin Netherlands News Digest, L.A. Ries, deputy director of the Netherlands Information Bureau in New York, wrote that van Loon’s death was “an irreparable loss” for the cause of the Netherlands. Ries characterized van Loon as the “God-given interpreter of Holland [for] America” and vice versa, a man who “indicated to us the spiritual meaning of the vast expanses and the great masses” of the “immensity” of the United States. Especially Dutch in van Loon was his Erasmian spirit, Ries thought. Like Erasmus, van Loon had spent most years of his life outside the Netherlands and both men “felt the urge to interpret in unusual ways the historical and cultural problems of [their] times.”3 Other eulogists picked up the theme of van Loon’s having one foot in each culture. Dutch literary critic and journalist Jan Greshoff observed in the
PROLOGUE
3
Knickerbocker Weekly, a Dutch-American magazine, “He was no Americanized Dutchman, nor a Dutch-American. He could be both Dutch and American, because first and foremost he was van Loon.” In his “Monthly Letter” for the Netherland–America Foundation, Columbia University Professor Adriaan Barnouw said the essence of van Loon was his “wholehearted surrender to his adopted country and undying affection for the scenes of his childhood.” It was clear to Barnouw that “Holland had in him her most eloquent spokesman in America after she herself had been gagged by Nazi tyranny. . . . Holland may well be proud of having inspired such tenacity of love in one who had so completely identified himself with America.”4 Although Hendrik Willem van Loon is barely remembered today, he was a celebrity from the 1920s until his death. He contributed significantly to America’s cultural life in his role as educator to a large audience and served as a unique bridge between the Netherlands and the United States during the dark days of World War II. Indeed, as the London Times obituary noted, van Loon “was one of the most engaging products of the marriage between Holland and the United States.” President Franklin D. Roosevelt called him “my true and trusted friend.”5 This book aims to reintroduce the life and work of Hendrik Willem van Loon to an American audience. It is the story of a successful immigrant who made his mark on his adopted country while maintaining a love–hate relationship with his native country. It is also the account of an exuberant personality, a baroque mind in an American gothic world, who was rich in talents and rich in flaws. It is, in short, a captivating story that, six decades after the protagonist died, deserves to be told and rescued from oblivion.
This page intentionally left blank
Part I
The Formative Years
This page intentionally left blank
Chapter 1
A Troubled Youth in Holland (1882–1902) “[F]rom my tenth year on (or even earlier) i wanted more than anything else to be a very famous historian,” Hendrik Willem van Loon reflected years later. Unlike some of his contemporaries, he considered himself to be on “pleasantly intimate terms with the Almighty” who existed in Hendrik Willem’s consciousness “in a late medieval form—a kind and very wise old gentleman, a sort of beneficent grandfather with whom I occasionally hold conversation and discuss my own little problems.” Often Hendrik Willem had asked God to give him an understanding of the great and mighty historical figures in the dim past. But here his “intimate terms with the Almighty” were apparently of little help, since he was pleasantly told to use his own will and brains to “find these things out” for himself. “If you knew all the answers [so God told him], I myself should become superfluous, and I have no intention whatsoever of resigning, at least not for a good many eternities to come.” And so van Loon tried to understand the past in his own way and a number of times in his life—so he regularly confessed in his correspondence—he found it hard not “to play Jehovah.”1 Shortly after three o’clock in the morning of 14 January 1882 Elisabeth Johanna (called Betsie) van Loon-Hanken gave birth to her second child. The physician commented afterward, “Well, he seems all safe and sound, but God save me from another night like this, for the brat must weigh at least nine pounds.” The baby boy was named after his father, continuing a family tradition that had started several generations ago when the van Loons had settled in the center of the maritime city of Rotterdam and established a jewelry business. Also welcoming the infant was his older sister, Suzanne (called
8
Van Loon
Suus) who had been born the year after Hendrik Willem Sr. and Betsie had married in 1873. Hendrik Willem Jr. later wrote that during his infancy his sister, eight years his senior, served “as the natural buffer between myself and the less pleasant aspects of life.”2 The family lived on a corner of Gedempte Botersloot (or “Filled-in Butter Canal”) with the family business next door. The neighborhood, although rebuilt several times since it started as a Dominican monastery, retained its late-Medieval atmosphere—“a cloister surrounded by all kinds of buildings devoted to charitable purposes, and not constructed according to a preconceived plan.” Also Hendrik Willem’s house “was a crazy quilt of rooms and staircases. No two rooms were on the same floor. Short and long staircases ran every which way.” His own little room “seemed to hang suspended mid-air, for the space below it belonged to another house.” It comes as no surprise, then, that a place like this often frightened the little child when he was told to go up to his room alone. This became only worse when a servant taking Hendrik Willem to bed told him that the terrible-looking goblin in Hendrik’s new picture book would jump out of it and bite him just at the moment the clock would strike when Hendrik passed the large mirror opposite his hidden bedroom. Many years later Hendrik Willem would still vividly recall that night after night, “my heart beating violently with fear, I would creep past that mirror, hoping that perchance the clock would not strike at that precise moment and let the goblin get me.”3 As a child (figure 1.1) Hendrik Willem often suffered from recurrent nightmares. One of these was about the Spaniards subjecting Rotterdam to a massacre after a sixteenth-century rebellion. In his dream Hendrik Willem “was listening to the shrieks of horror that accompanied the pillaging and murdering that were going on outside.” But soon he heard “a heavy iron-clad footstep on the stairs, a man with a long beak of a nose and black, piercing eyes, a dagger shining in the moonlight, a feeble shriek, and my small corpse would be thrown out of the window, to be loaded on a cart and dumped into the river.” The roots of this nightmare came from the daily walks he took with his mother. They often passed a carefully preserved building, the House of a Thousand Fears, where the Spanish rulers of Holland had slaughtered the residents, and “a large picture in the front wall (done in colored tiles) explained everything that had happened there in full detail and in a most realistic fashion.”4 Fortunately, Rotterdam also had its pleasant side for a child. To begin with, there was the big harbor with its cosmopolitan atmosphere. One of his uncles, a Royal Dutch Navy officer, frequently took him there. Hendrik Willem taught himself to draw ships and his interest in geography and maps was instilled. In the 1880s, a great many of the ships were still sailing vessels, Hendrik Willem later recalled, “and flying flags of every nation under the
9
Figure 1.1 Hendrik Willem van Loon, aged 6, 1888 (Hendrik Willem van Loon Papers, 1884–1972. Courtesy of the Division of Rare and Manuscript Collections, Cornell University Library).
10
Van Loon
sun, the moon and the stars of heaven. And from these ships there issued forth strangely garbed creatures in turbans and fezzes and wearing burnooses and long, flowing robes.” Another happy memory was the climbing of the tower of the St. Lawrence Church with another uncle and looking at the city and its surrounding flat landscape. It was inside this same church where he first heard the music of Johann Sebastian Bach, who “has been a true and faithful friend ever since” and about whom he later would write a biography.5 Another person to whom Hendrik Willem felt attracted was Rotterdam’s most famous son: Desiderius Erasmus. As a child he passed Erasmus’s statue daily and—as he wrote in The Story of Mankind—“for some unknown reason this great exponent of tolerance took hold of my intolerant self.” Later in life van Loon would identify himself more and more with his fellow Rotterdammer who not only was his hero, but even became his alter ego. In his posthumously published autobiography Report to Saint Peter, Hendrik Willem wrote that the people of Rotterdam “were never given to any exuberant love of the arts” and had “systematically neglected the few literary men born in their city.” That Erasmus had his statue was “more the result of outside pressure than of local enthusiasm.” He doubted, therefore, whether Rotterdam would ever decide to place a memorial tablet on the house in which he—Hendrik Willem—was born. This was, however, just a theoretical question, since in May 1940 Hitler’s Luftwaffe had completely destroyed the center of Rotterdam, including the house were van Loon spent the first eight years of his life.6 Of Rotterdam’s museums, the Museum of the Knowledge of This Earth and Its People, Combined with Maritime Affairs was Hendrik Willem’s favorite. Its collection contained an endless variety of objets de voyage, both treasures and terrible monstrosities, taken home by sailors from all over the world. A dark-skinned and stuffed Laplander, hitching a full-sized reindeer to a sleigh on which sat his wife and child, gave the Dutch boy his “first desire to explore the whole of the world.” One day, in a corner of a remote room, he discovered the grinning skull of a prehistoric man who, according to the label, had probably lived some thirty thousand years ago. The skull was on Hendrik Willem’s mind for quite some time until he suddenly asked himself, “What if it had been the head of one of my own ancestors? . . . [I]t made life so much more interesting to imagine your ancestors fighting mastodons and tigers instead of going to dull offices. . . . [A] caveman ancestor was therefore a most welcome addition to that dreamlike existence in which I spent so much of my time.”7 An important place in Hendrik Willem’s “dreamlike existence” was taken by a hero in a serial. The arrival every month of a new issue of his beloved magazine meant “a day of joy and surreptitious reading late into the night.”
A Troubled Youth in Holland
11
The hero of the story was a thirteenth-century minstrel who served his master, Count Willem II of Holland, with all his heart and soul. Going from town to town and from castle to castle as a simple minstrel, the hero was really acting as a spy for the young count, whose ambition it was to be elected as head of the Holy Roman Empire. To this end the minstrel plotted and schemed and none of his enemies was ever able to master him. He was “a most marvelous athlete, to whom it meant nothing to outrun a horse, while sleep and rest were little items he could disregard with supreme disdain.” But he distinguished himself most in the field of music, “as a trouvère, a fiddler, and a harpist he stood supreme.” Although the boy realized that his hero was “an entirely preposterous figure” and that he was clumsily drawn, he would not have missed him for anything in this world, for he gave him “a purpose in life” and took him “into that realm of the imagination where I have lived ever since.”8 The minstrel also influenced van Loon’s image of and attitude toward women. Through the minstrel’s adventures, “I never quite got over the feeling that all women lived on a sort of pedestal . . . and longed to be the heroines of one of those romantic episodes which were common incidents in the lives of the medieval troubadours.” Only much later, at emotional and financial cost, he wrote in his autobiography, did he learn “that the troubadour business had indeed gone out . . . and that all efforts made since then to revive the era of the chivalresque approach had been lamentable failures.” His “many unhappy personal experiences” notwithstanding, van Loon would “still cling to the ideals of the thirteenth century” as expressed by his youthful hero. This romantic troubadour with his wistful expression, an unmistakable selfportrait, would become one of the recurrent figures in Hendrik Willem’s own drawings.9 In the van Loon family the Bible did not play any role (nor for that matter did the works of Shakespeare). Both Suus and Hendrik Willem were christened in the Lutheran Church, but this was more a consequence of the friendship that existed between their parents and a prominent local Lutheran minister than that their father and mother wanted to protect their children “against the fires of hell.” In fact, all van Loon’s relatives had long since completely broken ties with every form of established religion. Hendrik Willem recalled that until his twelfth or fourteenth year, he “never met a single person who ever went to church, who had been confirmed, or who had been married or intended to be buried by a minister of the official church.” This is quite remarkable as the Calvinistic influence on late nineteenth-century Dutch society could hardly be ignored. What he knew about Christianity were the allusions to the Bible in the vernacular and the remnants of the Catholic faith he saw around him: the ancient churches, street names, and
12
Van Loon
feast days and public holidays. Although in later years Hendrik Willem did not consider himself “a very good Christian in the accepted sense of the word,” he did join the Unitarian Church, even if he never became a regular churchgoer, and one of his books was The Story of the Bible.10 In retrospect van Loon realized that economics were also completely left out of his bringing up. “My father—if not rich in the American sense of the word—was a member of the class of the ‘haves.’ . . . Having been brought up in this atmosphere of complete economic assurance, I never became aware of real economic problems.” Especially during the Depression, he noticed the severe financial difficulties of so many fellow Americans but, as a well-paid author, economic problems, he wrote in 1939, were “not really part of my own flesh and blood. I have learned about them—as a trained seal learns about blowing a trumpet.”11 As a child Hendrik Willem had two reasons for admiring his father. Hendrik Willem Sr. served with distinction as an officer in a volunteer fire company and he was a member of the local auxiliary police force. The first position had provided van Loon Sr. with a green and white sash—the colors of Rotterdam’s coat of arms and a long stick to be used to smash the windowpanes of the houses on fire, and the other made him the owner of a derringer “to protect life and limb.” In young Hendrik Willem’s eyes the very possession of the weapon and the firemaster’s regalia made his father a hero.12 Hendrik Willem’s grandfather does not seem to have been a particularly pleasant person. Soon after his wife died, in 1890, he married his longtime mistress, a salesgirl in his jewelry store. This angered Hendrik Willem Sr. so much that he sold out his interest in the business for a tidy sum, completely broke off relations with his father, and moved his family to The Hague. But once the van Loons were settled in a quiet residential district, Hendrik Willem Sr.’s own behavior soon proved obnoxious. He had always been strict, but now that he was a gentleman of leisure, his mania for faultfinding grew. He constantly humiliated his wife and his children, even smashing some of their toys. When Betsie made flower decorations, he would tear the finished product to pieces and throw them into the fire. For Hendrik Willem Jr. his father became “the walking incarnation of the spiritual spoilsport” and in his opinion his father came to hate the world, “because he so thoroughly hated himself.” Betsie, who suffered considerably from her husband’s maltreatment, tried to compensate for her unhappy marriage by giving excessive affection and attention to her children. She succeeded in closing her children’s ranks about her and her husband became more and more “an outsider, a pariah in his own home.”13 In his autobiography van Loon acknowledged that although as a young child he tried to separate himself from his father, he looked like
A Troubled Youth in Holland
13
Hendrik Willem Sr. and “could never get rid of the imprint he had left upon my eyes and nose and the shape of my mouth.” For that very reason Hendrik Willem never liked his face. After he had become famous and admirers of his books asked him to send a photograph, he never sent one of his face, but of his hands, which resembled the hands of his mother—and of Erasmus.14 One good thing about the move was that it brought Betsie closer to her brother, Dr. Jan Hanken, a prominent physician. He took a great interest in his nephew’s education and the year after the van Loons arrived in The Hague he persuaded his brother-in-law to send the nine-year-old to a boarding school in nearby Voorburg. After that, the boy went on to a gymnasium in Gouda where, just like young Erasmus, van Loon later wrote, he spent “most miserable years” at school. Hendrik Willem also hated the prevailing odor of cheese in Gouda and crossed that famous Dutch dairy product off his menu for life. On his weekends home, he spent as much time as possible at the house of his uncle Jan whom he later described as “a perfect type of the almost extinct Homo Renascencius.” Uncle Jan’s wife, Aunt Sally, was a music teacher, so Hendrik Willem often met seasoned musicians there and was stimulated to learn to play the violin.15 During his years at school, Betsie often wrote anxious letters full of concern for his health, telling him that she frequently suffered from insomnia and headaches and felt very weak. As a side effect of his mother’s constant warnings, Hendrik Willem shunned competitive sports. Among the boys of his own age he had the reputation of an oddball: he kept to himself and was bored by the curriculum. That he came home with disappointing report cards, with As for history and language and the lowest grades for everything else, Hendrik Willem blamed on the influence of his hero, the minstrel. But he also admitted many years later, that “Being blessed with all the obstinacy and plain ordinary cussedness of the race inhabiting the Low Countries . . . , I was a difficult pupil. Hence six years of profound misery during which my teachers tried to push me one way while I, in all my youthful arrogance, pulled in the opposite direction.”16 During summer vacations Hendrik Willem was frequently sent to another uncle, Henri Hanken, the manager of a four-thousand-acre farm in the southwestern province of Zeeland. There Hendrik Willem was stuffed with food and got plenty of fresh air on his bicycle trips. It was on one of these trips that he discovered the beauties of the towns of Middelburg and Veere, located on the peninsula of Walcheren, which were to play such an important role in his later years. Despite Uncle Henri’s efforts to contribute to Hendrik Willem’s health, the now seventeen-year-old “outgrew his strength.” He had endless colds, a persistent cough, and was not putting on
14
Van Loon
any weight. Therefore, in 1899, his parents took him to Switzerland for the summer.17 In the fall of that year Hendrik Willem entered Noorthey, an institution that he would describe as “a school for little snobs.” As a jeweler’s grandson he felt being looked down upon by the scions of the Dutch upper classes, with their family crests discretely embroidered on their shirts. He nevertheless was able to outpace his classmates in Latin and Greek and with a quick riposte or little sketch he could make them sound and look like fools. Of great influence was his English teacher, a twenty-seven-year-old Irish woman named Esther BellRobinson. They shared an interest in music and it was she who considerably improved Hendrik Willem’s knowledge of English, making him read William Makepeace Thackeray’s Henry Esmond. This novel, van Loon declared in his Report to Saint Peter, fascinated him so much that it made him learn English fluently. Without it, he said, “I might have written Dutch for the rest of my life.” One day, Miss Bell-Robinson was asked by a London newspaper to write a story about a dock strike in Rotterdam. Unable to travel because of a bad cold, she asked Hendrik Willem to go to the city and, as an exercise in English, write a report. Hendrik Willem not only wrote an article, but also took pictures and the London newspaper subsequently let Miss Bell-Robinson know how pleased they were with “her” article. This success made Hendrik Willem begin to think of journalism as a career.18 Very unexpectedly Hendrik Willem’s mother became gravely ill and died at the age of forty-seven on 2 May 1900. This, of course, was a shock for Hendrik Willem and his sister, Suus. Now Hendrik Willem felt guilty for not answering so many of his mother’s letters. It was also thought that by going to Switzerland the previous summer, Betsie had sacrificed her health for that of her son. The next year, copying his own father’s example, Hendrik Willem Sr. remarried. Hendrik Willem saw his new stepmother taking over the house, wearing his mother’s jewelry, and willfully widening the gulf between father and son. His sister, who in 1897 had married Willem van der Hilst, quickly decided never to speak to her father again. Because Hendrik Willem had inherited a considerable sum of money—about thirty thousand dollars—from his mother, he was free to get away from his father too.19 He did not want to spend another two years at Noorthey, but without a diploma would probably not be allowed to enter a European university. Hendrik Willem began to think of going to the United States. Uncle Jan’s wife, Sally, was an American by birth and their home was always full of visitors to The Hague from the other side of the Atlantic. Now she wrote a former guest, George Lincoln Burr, professor of ancient and medieval history and curator of the White Library of rare books at Cornell University, requesting information about the possibility of Hendrik Willem’s admittance to
15
Figure 1.2 Hendrik Willem van Loon aboard the Holland–America Liner S.S. Potsdam en route to New York, July 1902 (Hendrik Willem van Loon Papers, 1884–1972. Courtesy of the Division of Rare and Manuscript Collections, Cornell University Library).
16
Van Loon
Cornell. Burr responded warmly in January 1902. His memories of his stay in The Hague and of all her kindness were “still very vivid and very sunny.” He would therefore welcome with pleasure Dr. Hanken’s nephew to Cornell and enclosed a copy of the university register with the admission requirements. He added that since “The reputation of the Dutch schools is so high for both scope and thoroughness, [Hendrik Willem could] count on all possible generosity of credit for his work there.”20 In his own reply, Hendrik Willem thanked Professor Burr for the information. In a self-assured way, he went on to write of his intention “to prepare myself for a journalistic career by an all-round education at one of the Universities in the States for which purpose the Law School at Cornell has struck me as peculiarly adapted.” He enclosed a full list of what he had hitherto studied in the Netherlands, including the classics, algebra, history, and modern European languages.21 Hendrik Willem was soon admitted as a sophomore to Cornell Law School (then open to undergraduates). Having already planned a visit to New York, Aunt Sally and Uncle Jan Hanken accompanied their nephew to America, sailing on 24 July 1902. When the Dutch shore disappeared from sight, Hendrik Willem van Loon, age twenty, left his troubled youth behind to prepare himself for journalism in the New World. While on his way in pursuit of his American dream, a snapshot taken aboard the ship shows him wearing a dark pinstripe suit, white shirt and ditto tie, as well as a cap, looking with a confident smile into the camera (figure 1.2).22
Chapter 2
Cornell–Harvard– Cornell (1902–1905) After an uneventful Atlantic crossing, Hendrik Willem van Loon arrived in New York where he stayed a few days with friends of his aunt’s. Uncle Jan and Aunt Sally accompanied him to Cornell. The train ride to the university, in upstate Ithaca, was a disappointment. “Not that I had exactly expected to see real Injuns chase our train. But I was not prepared for quite so much drabness, for quite so much that was utterly commonplace, for so much natural beauty ruthlessly spoiled by carelessness and greed,” he wrote many years later. “[N]othing to indicate that this was that New World where all men were supposed to have been born free and to enjoy an equal chance at life and happiness. Indeed, it was all very different from what good James Bryce and his American Commonwealth (duly learned by heart) had led me to expect.”1 That he eventually came to understand what “America” meant, Hendrik Willem attributed to the little man who on that hot August afternoon met his train at “that dreadful railroad station” in Ithaca and who welcomed him with “grace and stateliness.” Professor George Lincoln Burr who from that moment on became Hendrik Willem’s mentor, had a reputation of giving more of his time and energy to the student body than to himself. Hendrik Willem adored, yes even canonized this man “who had been preaching the gospel of a greater humanity to the students,” even comparing him with a saint.2 That first night, with a myriad of stars above him, Hendrik Willem was taken to the top of a steep hill for an overall view of Cornell, which sits on its own hill above the town of Ithaca. He also saw the library, which was still open, offering “an intimate picture of pleasant and gay and well-mannered
18
Va n L o o n
people who apparently had gathered upon this spot to study and make life more agreeable for each other amid surroundings of very great charm and beauty.” This positive impression was strengthened the next day when the newly arrived student had a short visit to the treasures of the library and was taken to Cayuga Lake for another view of Cornell from a distance.3 In a letter to his Noorthey teacher Esther Bell-Robinson, Hendrik Willem reported his first impressions a week after his arrival at Cornell. When his uncle and aunt had left after two days, for the first two hours he had had a strange feeling, since “the last tie with Holland was broken and I stood alone.” The fall term was then a month away, so he had had “some very dull days reading in the library and writing letters . . . with ten words of conversation during a whole day.” But he knew that better times would come. He had found a pleasant room in a house on top of the hill and took his meals in the girls college. This was “so quite different from Holland where a student nearly never gets the occasion to see a nice girl.” Although he met very nice people, he did not feel happy “in the ordinary society of young men and girls.” As far as music was concerned, Hendrik Willem had discovered that there was an orchestra he wanted to join, and the chapel on campus had a very good organ and offered a service in which music played an important part. “So perhaps it will happen that they see me in church of my own will,” he wrote. In this letter Hendrik Willem expressed how glad he was to have left Holland behind him, but at the same time he felt “very proud to be a Dutchman and I don’t think I will turn out an American very soon, as most people told me I would do.” These contrasting feelings toward his native land and his balancing between his Dutchness and Americanness would be a leitmotiv for the rest of his life.4 In a photo (figure 2.1) taken that September, we see Hendrik Willem reading a book at his desk, wearing boots and the same pinstripe suit he wore aboard the ship that brought him to New York. On the desk there sits a portrait of his mother and on the wall behind there are more than a dozen pictures, including reproductions of Rembrandt paintings (among others The Nightwatch), a portrait of the famous seventeenth-century Dutch admiral Michiel de Ruyter, and a picture of the Ridderzaal (the medieval hall used for official occasions by the Dutch government) in The Hague. He had, indeed, surrounded himself with mementos from Holland and there was no doubt that this room was rented by “a proud Dutchman.”5 In his next letter to Miss Bell-Robinson, Hendrik Willem felt very confident about the future. “I feel myself as a man at this moment and am able to do something. I see much and by coming in contact with persons of every part of this vast country I learn many things.” His main objective was very clear to him and so was his conviction that he had the talents to achieve his goal of a career in journalism. Studying law was “a means of getting
19
Figure 2.1 Hendrik Willem van Loon in his study at Cornell University, September 1902 (Hendrik Willem van Loon Papers, 1884–1972. Courtesy of the Division of Rare and Manuscript Collections, Cornell University Library).
20
Va n L o o n
a broader view.” The journalism for which the ambitious young man felt himself capable, he wrote unashamedly, was “the great journalism of the world. Not the journalism of a little country where they fight over some candidate for the place of mayor.” And he bluntly asserted, “the world in which by education and aspiration I feel myself at home is the world of the great events. I believe that there I can succeed.”6 A classmate who had a room across the hall in the same house remembered Hendrik Willem’s playing the violin both at home and in the Cornell orchestra, his joy when tobogganing on the steep side down to and across Beebe Lake, his talent for humorous sketching, and their frequent chats in his room “when his big, ponderous body would make itself comfortable” on his couch or armchair. And even though van Loon occasionally had some problems with word usage and pronunciation of English (“the” was still “zee”), his “strong personality” was impressive. He dealt with his instructors “on very equal terms in discussions of matters of history and current world events.”7 A coed expressed a more reserved opinion. She recalled, “van Loon was all wrong. His hat, a soft velour, was two sizes too small. His overcoat was green. . . . He carried an encased fiddle in one hand. In the other he gripped a small bouquet, an offering to his hostess at some party to which we were both going. The boy was six feet tall or more and weighed . . . at least 185 pounds. He was not fat but evenly larded all over, like a sleek, active seal. As a matter of fact, at this party he was pretty impressive for the first hour. Glib, though his English sounded like Dutch, perfectly at ease in meeting new people, bowing from the waist, he was never at a loss for a word or a topic. But after more people arrived and things got more general, van Loon ceased to be the center of attention and was sort of shunted off to his own devices. At that point he got out his fiddle, sat off in a corner with his back to the crowd, and softly played chords and snatches of tunes to himself.”8 For the summer of 1903, after his first year at Cornell, Hendrik Willem was invited to the homes of several fellow students, traveling among other places to Pittsburgh as well as Niagara Falls and East Aurora in New York State. To Professor Burr he reported that he had enjoyed himself so much, “that I can stand Ithaca again for a long time” and that he was “not despaired anymore about being alone.” But he told his mentor, too, that he had recently become interested in something that had come over him “as sudden as Christianism came over Paulus,” and that he would discuss that matter with Professor Burr later. Most likely it was his sudden decision to spend his second year in the United States not in Ithaca, but at Harvard and to return to Cornell afterward for his third and final year as an undergraduate.
Cornell–Harvard–Cornell
21
By September he departed for Cambridge, Massachusetts, where he was admitted at Harvard College.9 Life in Cambridge proved to be more expensive than in Ithaca. Since Harvard wanted a certificate from each student guaranteeing that he would not leave without having paid his landlady, Hendrik Willem asked Professor Burr to be one of his bondsmen. At Thanksgiving he went home with a classmate to Brooklyn, New York, where he not only was welcomed by a very pleasant family but found it remarkable that “they did not talk athletics”—a big relief since at Harvard people talked more athletics than at Cornell. When he passed the midyear exams in Spanish history, Russian, Italian, and international law, he thought he could have done better. In the spring semester, his new courses included Economics of Corporations and International Trade. Although he was “not much in love with College yet,” he wrote Burr, he could not complain about his life. He had met some very pleasant families, was usually invited somewhere on Sundays, and enjoyed playing his violin.10 Near the end of his stint at Harvard, in May 1904, van Loon wrote to Professor Burr that it had been a pleasant year in which he had learned many things. He was, however, very much looking forward to returning to Cornell in late September, when the beauty of the Indian summer made it a most attractive location. He even felt homesick for Ithaca, a feeling he never had felt for any other place, not even for his Holland. Before he sailed the next month for his first trip home, Hendrik Willem expressed his gratitude to his Cornell mentor: “I have to thank you for so many things. Those two years in your good country have been by far the happiest years I had in my twentytwo years and for nearly all the good things I enjoyed here, you are more or less responsible.”11 Returning in September on the Potsdam from Rotterdam to New York, Hendrik Willem was introduced to a fellow first-class passenger, Eliza Ingersoll Bowditch—known as Lily—who was two years his senior. Being one of identical twins, she was the daughter of Dr. Henry Pickering Bowditch, a professor at Harvard Medical School and its onetime dean. The Bowditches were a prominent family in Boston who had settled in Jamaica Plain—then a village west of Boston—in their spacious house, Sunnyside. While Professor Bowditch reserved his attention for their two sons, his temperamental German-born wife, Selma, focused more on their five daughters and was successful in playing one daughter off against the other. Having lived with her mother’s family in Dresden, Germany, for two years in the late 1880s, Eliza Bowditch had a strong affinity with Germany and Europe in general. When she was denied a college education by her mother and with
22
Va n L o o n
several of her sisters recently married, Eliza was more than ready to escape from her dominant mother and from Boston as far as possible.12 In the summer of 1904 Eliza, her two brothers, and her parents not only visited their relatives in Germany, but also an Amsterdam banker whose son, Herman Roelvink, had just finished his studies at Harvard and who had frequently visited the Sunday teas at the Bowditch house. Herman Roelvink told the Bowditches that another Dutch student at Harvard would be sailing on the same ship to New York, so Eliza made one of her brothers look for and introduce her to this “other Dutchman.” Their subsequent conversations aboard the ship made it clear that Hendrik Willem and Eliza had mutual interests: music, languages, travel, history, art, and books. What they also had in common was a grievance against one of their parents, and—as Gerard Willem van Loon observed in his father’s biography—an “ignorance regarding financial matters and sex.” By the time they arrived in New York, Hendrik Willem and Eliza had fallen in love.13 Back in Ithaca, Hendrik Willem found a pleasant and comfortable room in a dormitory. He wrote Professor Burr, who was on sabbatical in Europe, that he took classes in Spanish, French Revolution, colonies, socialism, labor unions, and chapel orchestra. In the chapel he played the first violin. There were so many things going on, that “there is no occasion to sit down, think and get blue.” And, he told his mentor, “I am saving money to hire the Ithaca band when you return.”14 Classmates and faculty alike had welcomed van Loon back. Although during the winter and summer the weather could be harsh “on the hill,” Hendrik Willem considered this as a “mere climatological detail” compared to the attractions Cornell offered: the long fall season was “of wondrous beauty” and in the spring, “the most lowly of towngirls assumes the estate of Heloise or Beatrice. But, best of all, there is at all times the feeling of complete and untrammeled freedom” that was due to “the spirit of that great old man, Ezra Cornell [who] gathered around him a group of scholars whose very names became synonymous with freedom of intellectual action.”15 While diligently studying, Hendrik Willem had to think of making a living after this third academic year and a career in journalism was still what he wanted. He became acquainted with Dr. Andrew Dickson White, Cornell University’s first president who had recently returned to Ithaca after having served for six years as U.S. ambassador to Berlin, and to whose cosmopolitan background Hendrik Willem felt very much attracted. Meeting the venerable scholar and diplomat would prove to be of great importance. In a 1914 résumé Hendrik Willem would refer to White as “that most kind old Gentleman” who, ever since he met him, had been “a Guide and Friend and at times a wise Philosopher.”16
Cornell–Harvard–Cornell
23
In the summer of 1903 Hendrik Willem had published an article on Holland in the Ithaca News and he had submitted some stories and sketches to university publications. When he heard that one of the faculty members, Professor Charles H. Hull, had a friend on the editorial staff of the New York Sun, Hendrik Willem brazenly inquired for a foreign correspondent position. He was turned down flat out, since he had no experience. The newspaperman told his friend Hull that a foreign correspondent “job requires vastly more than knowing foreign languages and having travelled. One has to know the newspaper business first and know it from top to bottom. Only trained journalists ever get that far. . . . So, I can not write a word of encouragement for the young man. He is flying too high. He will have to come down to earth and with a thud, if he wishes to break into newspaper work.”17 Undaunted by this reply, high-flying Hendrik Willem asked Dr. White to introduce him to a friend at the Associated Press. “As I should like to look around for some position as soon as possible, I take the liberty to send you a list of my work now. Most of it has been in Political Economy and History, especially Holland, France, and the countries in the Balkan. I studied International Law in Harvard. As for languages—I had some 7 years Latin and Greek, have some knowledge of Russian, read Italian and know fluently English, French, Spanish, German, Dutch.” This time Hendrik Willem had more luck. Dr. White contacted his friend Melville Stone, who in April interviewed the young man. When he graduated from Cornell, there would be a job waiting for him at the New York City cable desk of the Associated Press.18
This page intentionally left blank
Chapter 3
Associated Press Journalist in Russia and Poland (1905–1907) Immediately after his graduation on 22 June 1905, Hendrik Willem left Ithaca to start working for the Associated Press in New York. Two days later, as he put it in a 1914 résumé, “I sat in the backroom of the fifth floor of the Western Union Building and cut good paper into small strips and pasted the whole mess in a big book.” In his first week on the job, he was told that he would soon be transferred to Washington, D.C.1 Before going to the nation’s capital, however, he had to take care of a private matter. Despite a steady correspondence with Eliza Bowditch over the past year, her parents still regarded him warily. On 1 July Hendrik Willem went to Jamaica Plain hoping to reach an understanding with them, which proved to be a far from easy mission. As soon as he arrived, he reported to Professor Burr, “The mother caught me on the stoop and I was at once dragged before Loyola and the Inquisition did its work. It was not a very pleasant interview.” Henry Bowditch “talked quite a good deal about position and cash-books and it would have been very pleasant to me if he had been more curious about character than about the former two things.” Hendrik Willem felt the Bowditches had not received him “with any show of pleasure” and “seemed to be opposed” to him.2 Several days after the inquisition at Sunnyside, Dr. Bowditch wrote Professor Burr, asking him about “the boy’s family and social environment as well as his intelligence, industry, morals and habits of life.” In a very long letter, Burr described how from the very start when he arrived in Ithaca in the summer of 1902 he had liked Hendrik Willem. He depicted him as “of
26
Va n L o o n
unblemished purity, both in conduct and in conversation, and has no patience with impurity in any form. He is by instinct and habit thoroughly a gentleman.” In his eyes Hendrik Willem was “a man of broad culture for his years, a lover of art and music, an accomplished linguist . . . , and fond of society [who had planned] for a career of active usefulness, and has with much intelligence, judgement, and persistence shaped his studies to that end.” After “a night’s reflection” he added that in Hendrik Willem’s work as a student he regretted “a certain lack of system and thoroughness; but it is precisely his wide and desultory interests which have made him love the work of the journalist” and would, Burr expected, make him successful in this profession.3 Lily’s father seemed satisfied with Burr’s report, but Selma Bowditch kept up the attack. In September Hendrik Willem complained to his mentor that the Bowditches had “poisoned a whole year” and “treated him badly, without any reason.” And a month later he referred to “the Hundred Years War in Massachusetts” where “The definite battle of Jamaica Plain has not yet been fought and the family ignores my existence in great style.” But he did not mind to bide his time patiently, “For every week I wait I get better entrenched here and feel more sure of my position.”4 To the man who had been instrumental in getting him the Associated Press job, Dr. Andrew D. White, Hendrik Willem reported that he liked his newspaper work very much and that Washington offered him the possibility to learn a lot and “to look a bit behind the scenes of history.” He noticed, however, his colleagues considered Europe “a funny old place where foolish emperors and haughty aristocrats order a poor, suppressed people around, [whereas] the U.S. with all its noble, just and great institutions, [had] been created for the sole purpose of putting things right in this world and they do not doubt but Mr. [Theodore] Roosevelt will make short work of it.” Though his daily work was interesting it often left him exhausted. In the evening he would read history or play the violin a little, but he could hardly keep awake.5 In November Hendrik Willem wrote Burr with good news on both the professional and private level. A few days before he had had a scoop, “which has given me some name and done me a lot of good. It was on the decision of the engineers about the Panama Canal. We had the story and beat the other associations so badly that they hardly made the story the next day. . . . For the moment let me only say that [the story] was made in a perfectly clean and honest way and only a result of three months continual and hard work.” He had also received a letter from Selma Bowditch in which Eliza’s parents at last assented to his request for her hand. Hendrik Willem was summoned to Boston for the announcement on Thanksgiving and an engagement party the next week. Henry Bowditch wrote Professor Burr afterward that “you will be glad to hear that Hendrik made the best possible impression on all the
Associated Press Journalist
27
family and friends.” One of those friends, Hermann Hagedorn, recalled that he was “attracted by [Hendrik Willem’s] genial personality [which was] given flavor by his Dutch background and a cultivation that went much deeper than the cultivation of any of the other young men [he] knew in Cambridge.”6 Hendrik Willem was very happy with his fiancé and the kind way he’d been treated at the party. Although Eliza had expressed her desire “to live abroad for always,” Hendrik Willem was not too eager to leave the United States. But he began to have some doubts about his prospects in journalism. To Lily’s sister Fanny he remarked that the profession of a journalist, though very interesting, combined “a maximum of work with a minimum of pay,” and he was worried about that “minimum and our good lady’s appetite.” What he wanted was a modestly paying regular position, he told George Burr, “perhaps not as exciting as journalism but more safe and bringing us in a different world from the one we are in now. Of my colleagues there are not five I could introduce to Lily.”7 The change Eliza wanted came soon after. The revolutionary events in Russia in 1905—the January massacre of peaceful demonstrating workingmen before the Winter Palace in St. Petersburg, followed by a wave of political strikes and riots all over Russia that year that were suppressed by the military— had made the country more newsworthy. Melville Stone decided in 1906 to send van Loon to the Associated Press bureau in St. Petersburg, then Russia’s capital. Hendrik Willem’s student dream of becoming a foreign correspondent was now about to come true. On 18 June 1906 Hendrik Willem and Eliza had a quiet Unitarian wedding at Sunnyside, two days later Mr. and Mrs. van Loon boarded the Potsdam and sailed to Rotterdam.8 Eliza reported to her parents that they had a pleasant ocean trip due to the “delightful airy and roomy cabin on the saloon deck” and the attentive steward and stewardess who treated them “like princes.” As first-class passengers they sat at the captain’s table at dinner. Of course she heard a lot of Dutch spoken aboard the ship, which was still difficult for her to understand, “for they talk faster than any people I ever heard.” In a letter to his father-in-law and typed on “a seasick typewriter” Hendrik Willem revealed himself not free from anti-Semitic feelings. He was somewhat annoyed at the large number of Jewish fellow passengers aboard the ship, which almost gave him the impression they were crossing the Red Sea instead of the Atlantic Ocean. He admitted to Eliza’s father that “in my noble country we have a most pronounced dislike for the Judaeus Teutonicus and especially for the young of that race.” During the trip he therefore had only been in touch “with about five or six people who belong to our own tribe.”9 The newlyweds spent the first two weeks of July in the Netherlands. They were greeted warmly everywhere, except at Hendrik Willem’s father’s house,
28
Va n L o o n
where the icy and hostile attitude of his stepmother made the young couple feel very unwelcome. They enjoyed a three-day stopover in Berlin before boarding a train for Russia.10 The van Loons were in St. Petersburg only two days before the head of the Associated Press’s Russian bureau, Howard N. Thompson, dispatched Hendrik Willem to Moscow where he had to await his permanent assignment: Odessa, Warsaw, or Moscow itself. Several months later it turned out that Thompson did not like van Loon and hoped he would “drown there (figuratively for the Moskva is not deep enough for me),” van Loon wrote to Eliza’s father. He thought that Thompson’s dislike “was the ordinary sort of an uneducated man for one who has had the benefit of more education.” By 22 July the young couple was at Moscow’s Hotel National. Although Hendrik Willem had been instructed to report on the situation in Moscow, there was “absolutely nothing going on,” Eliza wrote to her father. The rumors about officials “being blown to the skies every little while” were never substantiated. Eliza was told by “sober-minded people” both in St. Petersburg and Moscow that “if the revolution comes at all, it may not be for ten years,” which turned out to be correct.11 After a visit to the Kremlin, Hendrik Willem wrote to Professor Burr that Moscow’s most famous building had “never done any good or seen any good done by any of its occupants. Everything connected with it is murder and oppression. . . . It is populated with barracks, useless palaces (occupied one night in ten years), more than useless monks, and—worst of all—churches. A few weeks in Russia are quite sufficient to make one see what influence the church has. Like some sort of corpse, it lies all over Russia, and the skull grins at you everywhere. . . . The Russian clergy keeps the people stupid, says prayers for a stomach-ache, takes half of the coat of the poor man, drinks the rich man’s Benedictine, and seems chiefly occupied in growing a wonderful hair and beard. But the people are so pleased with their corpse that if one tries to take it away from them, they object vehemently. And Kremlin and church, neither of which has ever done anything for them, receive deep homage and off their hat and down they go and kiss the ground.”12 Although Hendrik Willem and Eliza were expecting to spend the winter in Moscow, they stayed barely a month. When riots broke out in Warsaw Hendrik Willem was directed to set up shop there. On 26 August 1906, after a thirty-hour journey, they arrived in the Russian-occupied Polish capital.13 Soon after their arrival in Warsaw, in one of her weekly letters home, Eliza reported that attacks on government officials, army officers, and policemen as well as robberies for money and blank passports were the order of the day. And this despite the fact that some 80,000 soldiers patrolled the streets of the city constantly and guarded the telegraph office and the banks “at almost
Associated Press Journalist
29
every window and door.” The authorities accused the Jews to be behind all the revolutionary activities and, because of the strongly anti-Semitic feelings in Poland, pogroms took place regularly.14 One such pogrom was going on in Siedlce, a town east of Warsaw. The first time Hendrik Willem went there, he could not get into the town since it was “in a state of siege.” Accompanied by an interpreter on a return trip, he was able to see the damage done by drunken soldiers; they smashed everything they could, demolished the streets by battery-fire, and surrounded the houses of Jews with their guns ready to shoot. The night before the pogrom began, Christians had hung saints’ pictures in front of their houses in order to escape the damage destined for Jewish houses. On both trips, the train back to Warsaw, Eliza reported, “was crowded with scared Jews, and [Hendrik Willem] got a good many interesting stories out of them.”15 The capital city continued to be very tense, with assassinations of army officers, threats from revolutionaries against the foreign community, and rumors of a pogrom in Warsaw itself. Outside the boarding house where the van Loons had rented two rooms, pistol shots could be heard regularly. Hendrik Willem and Eliza still managed to establish a “very homelike” life, getting to know their neighbors. Because the conversations in the house were in French, they were called “les mignons enfants.” Among the regular guests at the dinner table was Roman Dmowski, a biologist who was the leader of the Polish National Party. Dmowski talked with the van Loons on Russian politics and the Poles’ desire “to throw off the Russian yoke,” giving Hendrik Willem insightful information on the Russo-Polish political situation.16 Meanwhile in St. Petersburg, Bureau Chief Thompson was transferred and succeeded by Mr. S.B. Conger. Hendrik Willem felt the difference immediately. Conger’s instructions were much clearer on what kind of news he wanted from Warsaw. He also kept Hendrik Willem well informed about the events in the Russian capital; an assistant now forwarded copies of all the telegrams sent out from the St. Petersburg office. These daily bulletins from the Associated Press were very welcome since in Warsaw only Polish newspapers were available. Eliza assured her father that everything in the American newspapers about Warsaw came from her husband. His telegrams about the pogrom in Siedlce “were printed in full” and she regretted that the Associated Press did not let its correspondents sign their telegrams. To be kept informed about developments in the United States, she asked her parents to send them any newspaper or magazine through the U.S. consulate to avoid the censor.17 Hendrik Willem felt sympathetic toward the revolutionary activities in Russia. The murdering of governors and generals, he wrote his father-in-law, was of course cruel, but these authorities deserved that fate since they had blood on their own hands. “To talk in Russia about achieving aims by peaceful
30
Va n L o o n
and legal ends is an impossibility,” he asserted. “Those who have tried to do it have always ended in Siberia or on the gallows.” The autocratic regime in Russia had proven to be deaf and dumb to the warnings and therefore he considered the shooting and fighting by the people who had been driven to the extreme as “a case of self-defense.”18 About the Poles, van Loon wrote rather negatively in his letters to his mentors Burr and White at Cornell and his father-in-law in Boston. What struck him most was the Polish patriotism, which in his view bordered on fanaticism and a perversion of history, as well as their vehement antiSemitism. The Poles considered themselves to be the victims of their neighbors who had “all the vices of Christianity and Heathendom together” and of the Jews, whose entrenched presence as merchants and other middle-class occupations, prevented the Poles from creating their own bourgeoisie. In January 1907 he penned about the Poles, “I came here with great sympathy for the poor persecuted race but after four months the sympathy has gone and there only remains impatience with a race which has ruined itself through its own stupidity, and which clings to all its many old vices and has no use for new virtues. . . . The Poles have learned nothing [and] are as much divided as ever. . . . [The Poles] have an awful lot of vague ideas but lack all force to put an idea into shape and make it a reality. . . . Whatever they do is half-done. They have no idea of duty and less of unselfishness.”19 When Hendrik Willem tried to give Andrew White an impression of the situation in the Russian empire, he wrote that “the country is still very much of a mystery to me.” He could describe Russia in no better way than by calling it “one very sad story” where no person or party seemed capable of anything but destruction or suppression. Wherever he went he saw “misery, ignorance, stupidity and a hopeless government.” When Americans in their enthusiasm talked about “the Russian Revolution and the Dawn of Russian Freedom,” Hendrik Willem thought this was as beautiful as it was untrue. Of course there had been some revolution, but the movement lacked organization. “Years and years of suppression have brought those people to such a state of hatred and despair, that they will do anything, merely for the pleasure of revenging themselves.”20 Van Loon wrote a six-page letter to his father-in-law about the situation of the Jews in Russia and Poland. In his opinion the Jewish question in both countries had common characteristics with “the Negro question” in the American South: The problem was “practically unsolvable” and “outsiders are sure not to understand it.” Reflecting the prejudices of the time, he wrote that “The great difference [between both questions] is that the negro is below the average intelligence of the white man, while the Jew is his superior in respect to cleverness, sobriety and thrift.” Because of their poor living conditions, Russian Jews were “easily driven into the ranks of the revolutionists and
Associated Press Journalist
31
contrary to their real nature, they develop into the boldest members of the terrorist organizations.” As for Poland, the majority of Jews there was equally “miserably poor and accordingly educated,” but worst of all, he thought, most of them were never polonized: they hardly ever used the Polish language and did not feel to be a Pole. This attitude was used successfully by the Russian “masters” to keep the Jews apart from the Poles. Polish national feelings being more awake than ever before, the Poles found themselves “in company with 5,500,000 strangers who live with them and on them and who have no intention to act in unison with them.” More than anything else, Hendrik Willem saw the Jewish attitude of “I belong to the chosen people and I am a different creature from you” as the source of feelings of hatred toward the Jews in Poland.21 To the ornithologist and artist Louis Agassiz Fuertes, a friend from Cornell, van Loon sent some more observations. He considered Russia “the damnedest country the devil ever invented” and if he had not had the company of his wife, he thought he would “have died a hundred deaths.” The Russian people in his view were “stupid, lazy, full of false pride” and he thought they were very fatalistic: “You can punch them and beat them and sit down on them, and they will all take it in a meek way.” Although van Loon thought the Poles were “capable of more than the Russians,” he assessed them as “bigoted Catholics, full of pride for what once was and never seeing what now is, lazy and terribly unreliable.” Because the Slavic countries in his opinion were “splendid at destroying,” he thought that “Europe should build a high wall and leave them with peace.” In a few centuries, he predicted, “they would have all killed each other.” Obviously, the van Loons would be glad to leave the Russian empire.22 Hendrik Willem grew increasingly dissatisfied with journalism in general, telling Burr that he wanted to “give my time and capacities . . . to our good history,” and with the American version in particular. Or, as he phrased it in the same letter, “Madame Clio [the Muse of History] always has a string around my leg and pulls me toward her on all occasions.” He was not impressed by the majority of the Associated Press correspondents he’d met in Europe, most of whom looked at everything with the perception of a smalltown American newspaperman, and he felt Dutch and other European newspapers produced far more informative coverage of foreign affairs.23 One bright spot in Warsaw was that Eliza was pregnant. Her mother, Selma, arrived in May to help prepare for the new arrival. On 22 June 1907, a son, Henry Bowditch was born; he would be known as Hansel or Hansje as a child and later as Hank. In a few weeks, Hendrik Willem was ordered to St. Petersburg, leaving his wife, newborn son, and mother-in-law behind in Poland. However, there was little of importance to report from Peter the Great’s canal-filled capital that summer, which fueled his unhappiness with
32
Va n L o o n
his career. To his father-in-law, he explained that he had been suffering the last few months from “nervous headaches” and had been advised by a medical specialist to lead a quieter life. He furthermore believed he was able to do something better than his present work, which could be done by “almost any high school graduate or less. . . . Education does not pay in journalism. Cheek and nerve bring you a good deal further than knowledge.”24 A few weeks later, Hendrik Willem resigned from the Associated Press. He planned to obtain a Ph.D. degree in history at a German university. Once he had achieved that goal, he would like to return to the United States to get a teaching position at a history department of an American university. He also wanted to become a U.S. citizen. Eliza was delighted that they were to change from the “uncivilized” and “frightfully primitive” Poland to the “well-ordered” Germany, where she was familiar with the people’s language and culture. There, she assured her father, they would be able to live “comfortably though of course quietly” on both their incomes, which amounted to some 5,000 marks.25 Informing Andrew White of this decision, he summed up the political situation in Russia, which was characterized by an indifference of the people toward the tsar and the Duma. Considering the strength of the armed forces, there would not be a general revolution, but the masses were only biding their time until the revolutionaries, over a long time, had done “the dirty work” for them. The tsar, van Loon wrote, was either despised as a coward or described as a murderer. “The whole country is more deeply revolutionary than ever before. Only it is a sort of revolutionism which will not show itself in bombs. . . . Really this whole Russia looks like an enormous fools Paradise. Trade goes badly, there is starvation, half the intelligent people in prison, everybody discontented.” About the situation in Poland not many positive things could be mentioned either. “Three hangings a day is the rate, I believe. The worst is that you see all those things and can do nothing.”26 Van Loon would always have a negative view of Russia. In his 1932 book Geography he called it a country “which was prevented by its geographical location from ever finding out whether it was part of Europe or of Asia. . . . Karl Marx and Genghis Khan have joined forces to bring about the Millennium and what will come of this extraordinary experiment I do not know.” He warned that “the rest of the world would do well to take notice, for Bolshevism may be only a dream, but Russia is a fact.” And in a 1943 newspaper column, referring to the “little love” he felt for Joseph Stalin and the way he made history, he added, “I have never had much love for the way Russia made history, regardless of in whose name it was being made. After all, I am only a middle-class little Dutch boy and the Russian approach towards life has always been very different from that as practiced among the Calvinistic burghers of my native land.”27
Chapter 4
Historical Training in Munich (1907–1911) In choosing to go to Germany for his doctorate, Hendrik Willem was following a long-standing American tradition. Throughout the nineteenth century, a year or more at a German university like Leipzig, Halle, Göttingen, or Heidelberg was a sine qua non for any college graduate aspiring to obtain a first-rate professional training in the more specialized scholarly and scientific disciplines. What especially appealed American students to German universities was their specialized scholarship and the prevailing sense of academic freedom.1 After their gloomy year in Slavic Europe, the van Loons embraced life in Munich. They lived first in a congenial boarding house near the university and then in an apartment they were able to furnish with their own furniture and table silver. Hendrik Willem and Eliza especially enjoyed the cultural life of Bavaria’s capital. Hendrik Willem proudly reported to his father-in-law how pretty Eliza looked at a performance of Aida in her black dress and necklaces—“like a Russian Grand Duchess”—and how easily she made contact with all the Bavarian “Best Families.” In his opinion she represented her country much better on that occasion than the U.S. consul, who “seemed more the Representative of the Bowery than of any other part of the United States.”2 The U.S. consulate was one of the three American circles in Munich. Another one was the American Church of the Ascension whose rector, the Reverend Dr. Henry R. Wadleigh, and his wife Julia became close friends of the van Loons. They frequently listened to Dr. Wadleigh’s sermons and Hendrik Willem even became a vestryman in this Episcopal church. The most prestigious American circle revolved around the family of Edgar
34
Va n L o o n
Hanfstaengl who owned a world-famous art reproducing firm and whose wife was American. Their second son, Ernst Sedgwick Hanfstaengl, known as Putzi, was then at Harvard and was to become an acquaintance of Hendrik Willem.3 The main reason for being in Munich was, of course, not society life but Hendrik Willem’s desire to obtain a German Ph.D. in history. A diary with intermittent entries from 30 November 1907 through 1 April 1909 as well as his letters to his father-in-law and Professor Burr, shed some light on Hendrik Willem’s experience at Munich University’s history department. It is not a very comforting picture we get from these sources. To be sure, Hendrik Willem was full of praise about the library, the Staatsbibliothek, which had a wonderful collection of books and greatly facilitated his work. The history department, however, he described in terms of “less wonderful” to “a mess.” One of the chief professors was in his perception so ardent a Catholic “that he is of no use to study with. . . . The other History Professors are good but not very inspiring.” He soon gave up going to lectures as he found them too uninteresting. Nor was he impressed with his fellow students. “Among the forty Seminar members nobody seems to know anything besides German and Latin. That is all they think they need. With these two languages they construct a dredging machine, settle down in some muddy archive and using paleography to make the engine run they go to work. Then they go on dredging for years. . . . The results of these years of dredging are put away in a book, locked up in a library and allowed to return to mud—via dust and the ashbarrel of the year 2000.” It did not take long for Hendrik Willem to conclude that “a course here makes one appreciate our American Universities in many respects” and that “I will have to work out my own salvation.”4 From December 1907 through the spring his diary entries show that Hendrik Willem frequently suffered from headaches and pain of the nerves. On New Year’s Eve he wished that 1908 would bring him better health but in January he complained that because of the pain and the physical lack of power he had hardly been able to accomplish anything. He also confessed to his diary that “the thing I want most of all is someone with whom I can talk. Either I am too broad or too narrow or they are too broad and too narrow, but excepting a few people who were much older than I was myself, I have found but very few people with whom I could get some sort of intellectual contact which satisfies me.” Since his physician in Munich was apparently of not much help, Hendrik Willem decided to consult his uncle Jan Hanken in The Hague. To his relief, so he reported at Easter to Professor Burr, “a very simple cure of much enforced rest” completely restored his health and allowed him to do the work he wanted to. On that trip to the Netherlands he met with the Dutch historian Professor P.J. Blok and found him “a most
Historical Training in Munich
35
agreeable old gentleman.” After the van Loons had moved to their new apartment in the Kaulbachstrasse, Hendrik Willem worked hard on his dissertation, which was to cover a topic from Russia’s history. But in the evening he usually tore up the pieces he had written during the day, so he changed to a more familiar topic: a history of his native country in the eighteenth century. In June he underwent a long-overdue tonsillectomy and was happy to be able to write in his diary that he felt much better than ever before.5 That summer the van Loons made a short trip to Venice, after which Eliza and Hansje stayed south of Munich on Lake Starnberg with Hendrik Willem commuting there in the weekends. Among the relatives who visited them there was Eliza’s sister Fanny, who reported about the frail health of father Bowditch and advised her sister to go home for a visit. Eliza agreed and left with Hansje in October for the United States. Meanwhile, Hendrik Willem made a tour of Belgium with his uncle Jan Hanken and conducted his Ph.D. research at the Royal Library in The Hague. On 28 November he boarded a Holland–America liner for New York, where on 8 December the family was reunited. Soon thereafter they visited Ithaca and Eliza met Professor Burr and Hendrik Willem’s other friends from his Cornell days. Christmas was spent at Sunnyside visiting with his ailing father-in-law. While in Boston Hendrik Willem was invited by Putzi Hanfstaengl and Hans von Kaltenborn to speak about his Russian experiences at the recently founded Harvard Cosmopolitan Club. By mid-February the van Loons were back in Munich where the annual Fasching or Carnival season was in full swing, much to Eliza’s delight, though not to her husband’s. Hendrik Willem felt far from comfortable in Munich’s bohemian crowd, which set the tone at Fasching. He also disliked any gathering where large quantities of alcohol were consumed, since he himself could not drink. To Eliza’s father he remarked, “Ordinarily I hate beer. A quart glass makes me mix up our two key holes—after half a glass I insist upon entering the house by the windows.”6 In February 1909 Hendrik Willem penned in his diary that life was so uneventful and calm that there was hardly anything worthwhile to write about. The next few entries mention that at age twenty-seven he already weighed 219 pounds; that a Holland Club had been founded in Munich for which Hendrik Willem served as secretary (he was very skeptical about its chance of success); and—the last entry of this diary, on 1 April—that the first Zeppelin on its maiden flight had visited Munich, an event that the Associated Press had asked Hendrik Willem to cover. Although he had agreed to do this, it reminded him “a bit unpleasantly that I do not seem to be made for that sort of work.” That spring there was also a feeling of imminent war in the air. In a letter to Dr. Bowditch, Hendrik Willem reported on war preparations throughout Europe.7
36
Va n L o o n
In July, Hendrik Willem successfully presented a paper on the Dutch revolution at his historical seminar. The professor praised his work and his fellow students expressed their admiration for the quality of the paper and his command over the German language. This pleasant end to his second academic year in Munich was followed by a trip to Halle for a gathering of Eliza’s German relatives. The van Loons also visited Wittenberg, the home of Martin Luther. The remaining months of 1909 were uneventful, with Hendrik Willem mainly focusing attention on his Ph.D. work.8 In January 1910 Hendrik Willem wrote Eliza’s father that there was “an awful lot of work to be done,” which left hardly any time for letter writing. He had just had his last language lessons; completing his dissertation was now his main occupation. He hoped to be able to write “a readable dissertation,” which in his opinion was hardly ever the case with most German theses (after having served their purpose, they “disappear in the waste-basket”). It was not without risk when one made a thesis interesting, Hendrik Willem wrote, because “the German Gelehrten-welt looks with suspicion on most things which are not covered with a certain dry dust.” This was simply a given of the German university system, but Hendrik Willem noticed there was an increasing minority opposing it. Seven months later, he notified his father-in-law that the last page of the dissertation had just been written. Since he had done this draft in Dutch, he was now revising it and would then translate it into German. Once that was accomplished, he intended to translate the German version into English and rework it into a book. Hendrik Willem wrote that he was very pleased with the last year. He was on good terms with his professors and he had been able to collect a lot of materials he could use in the future as a lecturer.9 In that same August letter to Henry Bowditch, Hendrik Willem reported that he had resigned as a vestryman “and everything connecting me with the Church of the American colony” in Munich. He was very disappointed that the work he and other “heathen” had done for the Episcopal church was supported so little by the members of the church itself, with Reverend Wadleigh doing least of all. Of course, he was well aware that he “should not judge the whole church by one individual minister or vestry but it all fitted in so beautifully with my former experiences and observations, that I have given up all hope of ever having the slightest sympathy for either the church or the doctrines it preaches.” The experience only confirmed his distaste for organized religion.10 There may have been another reason for his decision to quit the Episcopal church and his criticism of Reverend Wadleigh. To the Wadleighs, who were New Englanders, as well as to others in the American circles in Munich aware of Eliza’s prominent Boston family, her marriage to Hendrik Willem seemed “unsuited.” No doubt Hendrik Willem’s hypersensitive antennae must have
Historical Training in Munich
37
picked up the signal that the Wadleighs and others were thinking that he had overstepped himself socially, which brought back unhappy memories of his days at Noorthey where so many boys had looked down upon him because his grandfather had been “just a jeweler.” To secure more social prestige, in 1909 Hendrik Willem engaged the services of a Dutch genealogist to find him a van Loon coat of arms, since the Bowditches also had one. The coat of arms of one Adrianus van Loon, an eighteenth-century resident of Oosterhout, was located. Although the genealogist’s research proved that there was not even a remote connection between the Oosterhout van Loons and the Rotterdam branch of the family, Hendrik Willem could not care less. He was so anxious to have a coat of arms that he appropriated it. A Munich jeweler carved the dubious emblem into seal rings for Eliza and himself and in later years Hendrik Willem gave similar seal rings to his other wives and mistresses. “His” coat of arms decorates van Loon’s headstone at the Old Greenwich cemetery.11 During the Munich years cracks began to appear in the relationship between Hendrik Willem and Eliza. On the intimate aspects of their relationship in this period one finds next to nothing in the van Loon correspondence, and the details given by their youngest son, Gerard Willem, in his biography of his father are far from objective. Both Hendrik Willem and Eliza were raised in the Victorian era and were not—as Hendrik Willem put it in his Report to Saint Peter—“submitted to any kind of sexual enlightenment.” To Dr. Wadleigh he admitted “that he had entered marriage as much a virgin as his wife,” which in those days was by no means unique. To her daughter-in-law, Eliza would later confide, “an egotist truly reveals himself in bed,” and “a woman’s physical enjoyment of sex is a masculine myth.” According to Gerard Willem van Loon this did not mean that she rejected sex. On the contrary, her passionate nature overwhelmed her husband with affection and he was not able to reciprocate. In her own words, he “was the sort of man who always had to be wooed.” In his son’s view, Hendrik Willem considered the sexual act as a “manly duty” and was sexually fixated on women’s feet and shoes, but above all, he wanted to be mothered. There were other aggravating factors that got on Eliza’s nerves, such as Hendrik Willem’s disregard for personal cleanliness, his disregard for her privacy—he hated locked bathroom doors—and his total lack of respect for “mine and thine.” He acquired the things he wanted to have and as easily disposed of things, even when they were not his but his wife’s possessions. Still, the couple often tried to mask these negative experiences in their marriage with well-meant small gifts to each other and a display of romanticism.12 Eliza thought that a daughter named after Hendrik Willem’s mother would hold the marriage together. In the spring of 1910 she became pregnant
38
Va n L o o n
and in both her and her husband’s mind the baby, due in January, could be nothing else but a girl, they referred to it as Betsy. On 16 January 1911, two days after Hendrik Willem’s twenty-ninth birthday, the baby was born. It was a boy! Since the parents had lived for nine months with the name Betsy in mind, it took some time before a proper name was found; finally they settled on Gerard Willem, although the first name was rarely used.13 With the end of his studies approaching, Hendrik Willem focused his attention on finding a job at an American university. Unfortunately, his father-in-law, whose influential contacts in the East Coast academic world would have been very helpful, died that March. He applied to Harvard President A. Lawrence Lowell, whom he had met in 1909. There was no teaching position available in Cambridge, but Lowell suggested van Loon apply to a vacant position at Colorado College. This was certainly not what Hendrik Willem had in mind. Although he realized that as a “beginner” he should not ask too much, he thought that Colorado Springs was too far away. He wanted a job on the East Coast, preferably in or near a city. Anything in a small town in other parts of the country would seem like cultural exile. Columbia, Amherst, or Princeton would be ideal. Friends warned him that junior professors at American colleges worked long hours for a low salary, but this is what he wanted.14 Meanwhile, Hendrik Willem studied for his doctoral exam, which covered all kinds of topics that in his opinion would never be “of the slightest value to you or anybody else. From time to time, in order to escape absolute lunacy, I amuse myself by cutting little paper figures.” On 19 July Hendrik Willem passed the exam magna cum laude and the ordeal was over. Eliza told her sister Fanny she was glad “that he didn’t get ‘summa’ or he would have had to live up to it all his life.” Herr Doktor van Loon was an impressive figure whom one could not overlook. Referring to his unusual length and weight, some people even thought he was working in a circus.15 The next month the van Loons left Munich for a long holiday in the Netherlands. In late October the family sailed on Holland–America Line’s Noordam to the United States, where the pater familias still hoped to secure a teaching position in Clio’s garden.16
Part II
In Search of a Place
This page intentionally left blank
Chapter 5
Washington Years of Trial and Error (1912–1914) After they had spent Christmas 1911 at Sunnyside, Hendrik Willem and Eliza van Loon decided to settle in Washington, D.C. They rented a big house on Twenty-first Street and hired two servants, thereby overstretching their finances. Through Eliza’s cousin Fanny Bowditch Dixwell, who was married to Supreme Court Justice Oliver Wendell Holmes, the doors of the capital’s elite were opened to the van Loons, including invitations from President and Mrs. Woodrow Wilson in the White House. Hendrik Willem’s diary also records a private dinner with British Ambassador James Bryce, author of The American Commonwealth. About this visit to Lord Bryce, who served in Washington from 1907 to 1913, he wrote, “He seems to have known everybody everywhere. I do not see how he keeps his information straight—if his mind is made like his library. Such a disorder. I never saw invitations of all sorts—cards of all sorts—despatches of all sorts— everywhere. When a match was needed he rolled a piece of paper—fashion A.D. 1500—lit the cigaret and then to extinguish the paper beat it against the stones of the mantelpiece. Of course, sparks and pieces of charred paper, flew all over. But it was all very pleasant.”1 As a consequence of these valuable contacts, van Loon became a member of the prestigious Cosmos Club. Meanwhile, he reworked his dissertation into a manuscript called The Fall of the Dutch Republic (echoing the title of John Lothrop Motley’s famous The Rise of the Dutch Republic), prepared lectures, offered his services to some Ivy League universities, and made himself the Washington correspondent of the Dutch newspaper Algemeen Handelsblad. None of these activities brought in the necessary cash to pay the bills. Hendrik Willem’s inheritance having been spent in Munich, the van
42
Va n L o o n
Loons were now living on Eliza’s decreasing capital and after some time moved to a more modest home nearby.2 In the fall of 1912 the publisher Houghton Mifflin in Boston offered Hendrik Willem a contract for The Fall of the Dutch Republic. His editor Ferris Greenslet provided an introduction to Oswald Garrison Villard, publisher of The Nation, and Hendrik Willem began writing book reviews and articles for that periodical. He also met Benjamin W. Huebsch, another book publisher. The contacts with these men gave Hendrik Willem an entrance in the East Coast literary set.3 When The Fall of the Dutch Republic, which Hendrik Willem dedicated to the memory of his mother, came out in March, doubts about his own work came to the surface. To Professor Burr he wrote that the book had become “less of a History than a Sermon—a sermon against our terrible Dutch habit of self[-]satisfaction—a habit which as you know has cost us much misery.” Burr, however, a few days after having received a copy of the book waved away all doubts about the quality and was full of praise. “It is fascinating reading,” he wrote his protégé. “With all my heart I congratulate you on your masterly control of the English idiom and on the vim and pungency of your style.” That same day Burr also sent a most laudatory letter about the book to Houghton Mifflin, which the publisher reprinted shortly thereafter in The Nation as an ad.4 Despite his mentor’s effusive compliments, van Loon remained haunted by self-doubts. Hendrik Willem asked Houghton Mifflin to send copies of the book to a number of people in the Netherlands, including Queen Wilhelmina and Professor P.J. Blok of Leiden University. Further copies went out to the White House, the French, Dutch, and British ambassadors in Washington, old friends Melville Stone and Andrew White, and many others.5 Professor Blok—who in Hendrik Willem’s eyes was “so very archivy”— had a positive reaction. Of course, van Loon admitted to Burr, The Fall of the Dutch Republic “is a book ‘of views’ and not ‘of research’ (which no doubt grieveth [Blok] a little bit) but then they like that sort of thing in America.” The other Dutch reactions were similarly positive. The Dutch historian Nicolas Japikse who reviewed the book in a scholarly journal, was not too pleased with van Loon’s ironic style but considered the volume a generally reliable though somewhat unbalanced short history of the Dutch Republic in the eighteenth century, based on modern historiography and written for an American public. The Dutch appreciation for his book led to van Loon’s appointment, in January 1914, as member of the Utrecht Historical Society.6 American reviews of The Fall of the Dutch Republic were also favorable, including those in the New York Times and the Yale Review. By far the most enthusiastic review was in the Chicago Record. The anonymous critic of this
Wa s h i n g t o n Y e a r s o f T r i a l a n d E r r o r
43
newspaper called van Loon’s book “a shocking example of history made racy” and asked, “Who is this bold breaker of all the canons of historical art, this iconoclast who dares to write history as if he enjoyed it? At this rate history books will soon be listed among ‘the best sellers.’ [A prophesy indeed for a number of van Loon’s books, though not ‘soon’ to be realized.] If the supremacy of the novelist is to be maintained this van Loon, whoever he is, must be suppressed.” Having voluntarily sat up till 1:30 A.M. to finish “a Dutch history of all things,” the reviewer warned the reader “not to dip into this bewitching book unless he wishes to be held tightly in its clutches until he has finished it.” Van Loon had been able to make a dull and uninteresting period of Dutch history come alive with “humor and literary skill.” The Fall of the Dutch Republic in this critic’s view not only bore “the marks of careful study and wide culture,” he also considered it “a contribution to the history of human institutions, for it shows the inevitable consequences of ‘private initiative’ in ‘business’—of the worship of the golden calf of commercial success which dominated the narrow-minded plutocracy that ruled the Netherlands during the period of its decay.”7 The favorable reviews notwithstanding, The Fall of the Dutch Republic sold fewer than seven hundred copies, many of which bought by the author himself. Van Loon’s editor Ferris Greenslet observed, “I suppose the streetcar service would pay better than writing history.” And it was cash that Hendrik Willem needed badly. In his diary he wrote that the lack of money and the failure of his book made him feel physically miserable and he wondered whether success would ever come his way. He desperately turned to his mentor, asking Professor Burr whether there was a place for him at Cornell “as kitchen-boy or bell-ringer of the Historical Department.” Because of an “anxious time of annual deficit,” Burr replied, there was no possibility at all, but in case the situation improved Cornell would bear him in mind.8 To see to it that his alma mater would not forget him, van Loon offered Cornell a series of lantern-slides lectures on Dutch history free of charge. His proposal was accepted and in August 1913 in an all-or-nothing gamble he presented himself in action to the faculty. Despite his accent, he was a natural on the platform. Evaluating his first lecture, on social life in the seventeenth century, Hendrik Willem wrote in his diary that working with slides was something new that he had to learn. In general he thought his first performance had gone well but he decided henceforth to reduce the erudition in his lectures. He had given 70 percent whereas for most people 10 percent would do, he thought. Although he was touched by the kindness of Cornell’s faculty, he despaired at the apparent practical uselessness of devoting a career to history. “It seems,” he wrote Burr, “that to stick to such a thing as History for a living, means very little support from the powers that hold the cords of the purse.” He would, however, not yet give up since “this is the work for which
44
Va n L o o n
evidently I have been sent to this curious planet.” Other letters to Burr and White that summer were optimistic about his prospects, but in his diary he wrote that his scholarly pursuits had made him a beggar who had lost the respect of the outside world. He assumed he himself was to blame for this situation, even if he could find fault with himself only in the inadequate ability to advertise himself.9 That fall van Loon started to work feverishly on a new book, The Rise of the Dutch Kingdom. After a week of fourteen-to-sixteen-hour days, he had written the introduction and 200 pages. “After many years of preparation the entire book was ready in my mind,” he explained to Andrew White. In December the manuscript was finished. Although Houghton Mifflin offered to publish it, Hendrik Willem thought they had not done enough to promote his first book and placed the new manuscript with Doubleday, Page and Company.10 In the meantime van Loon worried about the future of his children— should he make them Dutch or American?—and his own future—would his chances for work be better in his native country or in the United States? Another letter to Professor Burr was the means of working out the answers for himself. America offered him and his children more than Holland, “where behind green and stagnant waters, all problems take the shape of deliberately grazing cows.” The thing he resented most in the United States were his Boston relatives with whom, he felt, he could not talk. They all knew he was financially dependent on his wife and consequently showed their disapproval. His future, therefore, should be outside of the Boston area. He contemplated leaving journalism and that “superficial and intellectually dreadfully monotonous, empty and hollow city” of Washington, working out his salvation by devoting himself “exclusively to History.” Although the outcome was unknown, he had “that vague and undefinable feeling that at last our worst time is over—that the first signs of a prospective breeze are beginning to fill our outspread sails—that we are getting near some sort of terra firma.”11 Early in 1914 Hendrik Willem commenced working on a history of Russia. There was no American publisher, however, who thought this would sell—unless there was another revolution. Other book proposals of his that were turned down were biographies of Hugo Grotius and John de Witt. None of this discouraged him; on the contrary, the struggle with the publishers—ironically called by van Loon “these pillars of culture [who] deal in books the way the grocer deals in pickled herring”—gave him “intense pleasure” and sharpened his “dull wit a bit.” Following Burr’s advice after the Cornell lectures, Hendrik Willem took lessons in public speaking and was carefully going over his lectures with a good instructor, he reported to his mentor. Yet, he never lost his accent nor did he seriously attempt to get rid of
Wa s h i n g t o n Y e a r s o f T r i a l a n d E r r o r
45
it. In February he presented an illustrated lecture on “The Social Life of the Dutch Republic in the Period of the Great Painters” at Boston’s Museum of Fine Arts, at Yale University, and elsewhere. The lecture tour garnered praise as “witty and informing” with van Loon commended for his ability to “make the past live in terms of the present.”12 After this successful lecture tour van Loon prepared a series of twelve lectures on Dutch and Slavic history and designed a brochure to market them. This illustrated circular told the reader that lectures could be booked on such topics as “The Flemish School” (1400–1500), “The Navigators of Holland” (1580–1680), “Rembrandt” (1607–1669), or “The Fall of the Dutch Republic” (1700–1795). His efforts that spring to advertise himself, not only in this circular but also by sending out drawings and articles, did not meet with a positive response. In his diary he recorded “endless miserable days” and concluded that he apparently was “a totally useless commodity in this world.”13 Unexpectedly however, through a friend of Eliza’s, Bayard Quincy Morgan who taught German at the University of Wisconsin at Madison, Hendrik Willem in late April was offered the possibility of giving a summer course in art history there. He offered to deliver his lecture on “The Social Life in the Dutch Republic of the Seventeenth Century” during the spring semester so the college could first see him in action. The letter and résumé Morgan suggested van Loon send to the dean apparently were persuasive enough, since the records do not mention any audition lecture. Indeed, the six-week course proved to be a great success. A letter of recommendation by the University of Wisconsin stated that “Dr. Van Loon has an unusually strong personality and breadth of experience and training. . . . He presents with force and clearness the history of art, the economic reasons and background for the development of the various national schools, and the conditions which made their work possible. . . . His lectures are exceedingly interesting and stimulating and offer a very wholesome change of diet from the customary lectures on the appreciation of artistic technique as illustrated by individual pictures.”14 Many years later, Bayard Quincy Morgan, by then teaching at Stanford University, recalled that van Loon was “the most impressive man I ever met.” Morgan thought Hendrik Willem was “a supremely brilliant man . . . [whose] lectures were often unsurpassable.” However, it had not escaped Morgan’s perception that van Loon was “too much of an individualist, too undisciplined—which also means lacking in exact scholarship—to feel at ease in an academic environment or to satisfy academic requirements.”15 That summer of 1914, fatal shots from an assassin’s weapon killed Archduke Francis Ferdinand, the heir to the Austro-Hungarian throne, during his visit
46
Va n L o o n
to the Bosnian capital Sarajevo. A chain reaction of declarations of war followed as a consequence of the European alliance system and set the old continent on fire. The Great War began. Although in accordance with its established policy of remaining aloof from European power politics Holland declared its neutrality in the conflict, Hendrik Willem immediately volunteered his services to the Netherlands consul in New York. The consul replied that his official instructions told him that no volunteers were taken, but privately he thought that there were certainly things to do for anyone who wanted to help. And that was the answer van Loon had hoped for. To Professor Burr he reported that he was abandoning his history of Russia and was preparing to sail in late August to Rotterdam, where he would “volunteer for whatever there is to do.”16 There was also a business side to his trip. Van Loon had agreed with Douglas Doty, editor of The Century Magazine, that he would give this periodical “the first chance at any literary material which [would] grow out of [his] experience in the Lowlands during the next few months.” This not only meant three or four illustrated articles at $200 each, but also that The Century Magazine offered him a book contract based upon his war experiences. Hendrik Willem also told Melville Stone about his plans and the Associated Press chief assured him that he would welcome any of van Loon’s reports. Having taken care of these matters, Hendrik Willem agreed with Eliza that she and the children would spend the winter in New York while the house in Washington was sublet. Now everything was ready for his passage on the Nieuw Amsterdam, a return to his jeopardized native country that Gerard Willem van Loon in the biography of his father sourly termed “a flight.”17
Chapter 6
The Great War (1914–1918) Even before the Nieuw Amsterdam had reached Rotterdam, Hendrik Willem felt the shadow of the war. In an act of piracy the ship was captured by the French cruiser Savoie in the Channel and taken to Brest. There, as van Loon cabled the Associated Press, the ocean liner was “deprived [of ] all foodstuffs [and a] million [and a] half silver bars for [the] Dutch government while eighthundred German [and] Austrian subjects [both] reservists and private citizens until sixty years [of ] age [were] confined [to] Devils Island on French coast.” Hendrik Willem, who served as interpreter for the captain, was allowed to get ashore and quickly sent a telegram to the London bureau of the Associated Press. As the ship had been incommunicado, van Loon’s cable made headlines; one of the detained passengers was the wife of the first secretary of the U.S. embassy in Berlin, so the American government officially protested to Paris. Finally, the Nieuw Amsterdam, including the German women, was allowed to continue its trip, arriving in Rotterdam six days late.1 Melville Stone was delighted about van Loon’s scoop and asked him to go at once to Antwerp. This Belgian port city with its strategic position on the river Scheldt was under German siege. Hendrik Willem reported on the human misery he encountered there and almost became a war victim himself. To Katy Codman, Eliza’s cousin, he wrote, “Deduct 60% of all you read about German atrocities, deduct another 20% on account of war excitement. The remaining 20% shows such a vile picture of drunken pillaging— burning—hanging and murdering that all the German professors of ethics can not talk it into decent shape if they tried for twenty years.” In a letter the same day to The Century Magazine’s Douglas Doty, van Loon added, “Steady streams of wounded pour into the city [of Antwerp]. Long, almost endless rows of refugees, the very poorest people, fill the streets with the noise of hurried wooden shoes. Children are everywhere and the puttee-puttee of their
48
Va n L o o n
tired little feet produces a weird music which I hope to compose with a dedication to our friends across the Rhine.”2 On 7 October, a few days before Antwerp was taken by the Germans, the Amsterdam newspaper Algemeen Handelsblad published van Loon’s detailed report on an adventurous tour he had made through the countryside south of Antwerp. During this trip van Loon and an American journalist saw the grim face of war—streams of refugees fleeing north, deserted and ruined villages and death, wounded and exhausted Belgian soldiers. Suddenly they got in the middle of artillery fighting between Belgian and German troops near the small town of Waerloos. Both men barely escaped being killed by German shells and were led to safety by five Belgian soldiers. The editor of the Algemeen Handelsblad introduced and praised this “very important” and “somewhat passionate” front-page story as “a sincere expression of disgust of the war.”3 Back in The Hague, where he had set up the Associated Press’s Holland bureau at the Hotel de Zalm, van Loon reported to Professor Burr that as a correspondent at the front line he had “lived right in the middle of all the misery, went through all the stages of battle, retreat, bombardment, debacle, völkerwanderung, death, endless wounded, hunger, refugees with children of three days.” The New York office was full of praise for van Loon’s reports from the war zone, saying that the stories about the Belgian situation were met in the United States with a “splendid response . . . to those suffering people.” Van Loon dedicated “this little success” to his Cornell mentor.4 In early December, van Loon sent a telegram to Douglas Doty to let him know that he expected to return to America sometime in January; it would then take him a month to finish a book about his war experiences for he was “overflowing with the stuff.” After the Belgian campaign, however, he had become “very ill” and had “to stick to a terribly strict diet” but expected “to pull through allright.” Doty pencilled on the telegram: “Promising? Dr. Van Loon is both an historian and a clever writer to come.”5 Meanwhile, an editorial in Algemeen Handelsblad in mid-November gained wide circulation in Europe and North America. It suggested that the Netherlands and the United States should offer to mediate in war-torn Europe in an attempt to end the unnecessary suffering of hundreds of thousands of people. “In God’s holy name,” the editorial ended, “let something be done again to bring peace on earth. It is unbearable longer to look on inactive at the massacre of the flower of Europe’s young manhood, of the hope of the future.” The Washington correspondent of the London Times wrote his own dispatch on the piece, which implied “the existence of peaceintriguers [. . . and] various hints from German intriguers, not altogether idle in neutral European countries.” In response, van Loon sent a letter from
T h e G r e a t Wa r
49
The Hague to the editor of The Nation, which was published in the 21 January 1915 issue as “Tricks of Newspaper Correspondents.” Van Loon “most emphatically” stated that the author of the editorial in the Amsterdam newspaper was “not a German intriguer.” On the contrary, having seen the war at first hand, he had thought that any attempt at trying to end this war “would be welcomed by decent-thinking people.” Van Loon commented that the Dutch editorialist wanted to make “this statement for the benefit of the American public,” and not for the Times correspondent in Washington: “To show one of Lord Northcliffe’s employees the difference between the truth and the other would be as ungrateful a task as an attempt to explain the beauties of the rainbow to a deaf man who was color-blind.”6 Van Loon got into another Anglo-Dutch dustup in February, when he was back in Washington. Novelist H.G. Wells suggested in the New York Times that the Dutch, “for the cause of justice,” should help the British troops to strike at Germany from Dutch territory for which they would eventually receive “territorial compensation.” The Times invited van Loon to reply. In his piece, van Loon emphasized the fact that Holland was a neutral country; unless attacked directly, it would not take part in the war. In his view the direct issue was between England and Germany who were “fighting for the supremacy of commerce.” Holland performed “a very difficult act of balancing.” Germany, he stated, in the past had never done any damage to the Dutch. “We may not like her, but she has in a very careful way avoided all friction and has treated us with great consideration.” This was very much in contrast with England, which in the past three centuries had “constantly” harmed the Netherlands and van Loon gave some examples. Though there was no Dutch hostility toward England, there was clearly no reason either, he wrote, “why Holland should make the sacrifice of her own existence for the benefit of England.” Van Loon compared the Dutch situation with “the position of a dog that has often been beaten innocently and that is now smiled upon and asked to be good and attack another person who has never done him any harm.”7 His New York Times article had made a good stir, Hendrik Willem wrote Katy Codman. In his opinion both Germans and Allies were to blame, “the brutality of the German military has only been equalled by the lying of the Allied press and . . . the great question for us is not ‘how to get ourselves into wild anger against 66 million people’ but try and understand what can be done to prevent a recurrence of this idiotic process of waste.” Van Loon was supported in his views by Andrew White. The former Cornell president and diplomat, who usually had “much greater love for and sympathy with the Germans than with the English,” but in this war sympathized with the Allies, was pleased by van Loon’s article. “Great Britain,” he wrote, “expects sympathy from countries like yours and mine when she has never shown the slightest
50
Va n L o o n
sympathy with either of us in our greatest troubles and distresses but has always chosen just those times to insult, ‘bully’ and injure us.”8 In early April the New York Times printed a letter by van Loon in which he made an analogy between war and earthquakes, comparing the layers in the composition of human society—both within a country and in the relationship between countries—to the layers in the earth’s composition that occasionally and inevitably would result in earthquakes (wars). To remedy this situation, he argued, the ruling classes in the several nations should be “reshaped . . . in such a fashion that they will most closely be at the same level. For as long as every little part of the world through its government is in a different historical layer, we shall have war. On the other hand, when the governing strata in the bigger nations shall most nearly correspond we shall have less friction.”9 The war remained pressing, but van Loon also had his career to worry about. To Katy Codman he wrote that “lectures are unproductive of cash and the only alternative, ‘advertisement,’ is not forthcoming either.” And to Burr he confessed that he was haunted by doubts. He had successfully lectured “in all sorts of places” and written more in the months since he was back in Washington than ever before, and yet he had the feeling of life as “an utter failure.” His was “a career of great outward success with almost unbearable personal unhappiness,” a complaint he would often repeat in the years ahead.10 When his second book, The Rise of the Dutch Kingdom came out in the spring of 1915, it merely “was smiled upon,” as he told Burr. This was probably his “last attempt at decent and scientific history. The children grow too hungry.” Fortunately, The Rise of the Dutch Kingdom, which covered the years 1795–1813, was received positively in the New York Times. The reviewer thought van Loon had made the best of his material, which covered a somewhat dour period, describing his style as standing “somewhere between the explosive familiarity of Carlyle and the ‘snappiness’ of the average newspaper reporter. It is frankly impressionistic, but it makes a chronicle of vacillation bearable; it arouses interest even in perpetual indecisions and inexpressible stupidity.”11 In May van Loon was offered a position as lecturer in modern European history at Cornell for the next academic year. He was thrilled to accept, but first he would go back to Holland for the summer to file more Associated Press stories. To get everything organized for his trip to Holland he was now, he wrote his mentor, “in a Rooseveltian hustle.” Just before he left, van Loon received letters of recommendation from Cornell University’s President Jacob Gould Schurman and from U.S. Secretary of State William Jennings Bryan.
T h e G r e a t Wa r
51
He sent an article to the New York Times about the principle of the freedom of the seas, which was so heavily jeopardized by the war situation and as a consequence of which, according to van Loon, the small neutral countries suffered most.12 While he was away, The Century Magazine published two articles van Loon had written that spring. One was on the German war strategy and the other a fiction story on a Belgian civilian turned soldier who died in action and was reported missing. The July issue also featured an introduction by van Loon to someone else’s article on Holland’s neutrality. In this introduction van Loon tried to explain the difficult position of the Dutch as a neutral country whose economy and foreign trade were “hampered upon all sides.” Holland “has been abused by her neighbors for her lukewarmness in what they consider a holy cause, she has lost all chances of future political reward by her abstention from the conflict; yet future generations will recognize that during those very difficult days little Holland calmly maintained a just neutrality” even while taking care of 300,000 Belgian refugees. These articles probably made up for the book van Loon had promised Doty to write on his war experiences, but had been unable to produce.13 Van Loon continued to advocate his native country’s neutral position and to monitor how it was perceived in the United States. He was upset by an attack, published on 6 June in the Sunday Magazine of the New York Times by one John Martin American. Van Loon trashed the article, “Will Holland Be Swept Into the War?” in a letter pointing out its many factual errors. In many other letters to the editor and articles in leading American periodicals over the next three years, van Loon kept explaining the historical and cultural background to the neutrality of countries like Sweden, Denmark, and Holland. He tried to make Americans understand the difficulties small neutral countries in Europe faced as a consequence of the war, situated as they were “between the aquatic and terrestrial devils.” In a 1916 letter to the liberal-intellectual magazine The New Republic he stated that the Allies had not made it clear that they were “not fighting for their own pocketbooks.” The neutral nations had no reason to trust the Allies more than the Germans and the other Central Powers. Van Loon maintained that position until the United States joined the war in April 1917 and President Wilson gave the Allies “the rallying faith of a new and equitable society of nations,” which would lead to “the emancipation of the human race and the substitution of law and justice for the brute argument of the sword.”14 In February 1916 his prescient analysis “The World After the War” appeared in The Century. In this article van Loon claimed that history is an art based upon science, but the course of history could be changed at any moment by a combination of unexpected circumstances and personalities; this made worthwhile “historical prophecies . . . impossible.” Nevertheless,
52
Va n L o o n
he was prepared to offer some, the first being that since the war had made the working classes in Europe aware of their power, the years after the war would see “a most severe social revolution” and “the outbreak of labor troubles everywhere,” even in the United States. Specifically he predicted a Socialist government in Germany, revolution in Russia with a better chance for victory than in 1905—and continued unrest in England and France. He acknowledged the tremendous effects of the war on men, but argued its impact was even greater on women, who with their men gone during the war had “for the first time in their dreary lives tasted liberty [and] in many instances discovered that they could handle affairs much better than their men.” Van Loon’s conclusion that the old order of things would vanish is borne out by the success of the women’s suffrage movement, as well as by the verdicts of respected historians like Barbara Tuchman. In her The Proud Tower, Tuchman said the ancien régime of 1890–1914 ended abruptly because of World War I, which “lies like a band of scorched earth dividing that time from ours.”15 By October 1915 van Loon was back at Cornell. His unorthodox way of teaching modern European history quickly made him a well-known and popular professor. As one of his students remembered, “I started in his first course on Modern European History in a small room seating about thirty-five. Before that term was up, his lectures had been transferred to one of the largest rooms in Goldwin Smith [Hall], with a rule that an enrolled student who was not in his seat five minutes before the start of class could lose his seat to any visitor.” The student recalled van Loon—often wearing a bright tie (yellow and pink were favorites)—using crayons as he lectured to rapidly sketch “a person, a place or an event on large sheets of brown paper. . . . In his brilliant, amusing and stimulating lectures, he often would say in his Shakespearian tones and mode of speech: ‘I make you see and know Napoleon or the English Industrial Revolution or the geography of Europe and its effect on history (or whatever), but if you want exact facts go to the Encyclopaedia Britannica.’ ”16 Cornell historian Morris Bishop wrote that the “gigantic, brilliant, unorthodox Netherlander . . . enthralled” his audiences. Several of his colleagues, however, were not amused, since they saw their classes shrink as van Loon’s grew in popularity. Furthermore, they “heard tales of monstrous historical errors” and alleged that van Loon’s way of teaching did not provide the students with sufficient knowledge, and what little they had, was incorrect. The jealous rivals allegedly asked, “Is this history or vaudeville?” Fuming at this criticism, van Loon gave his class a pop quiz; to his chagrin, it showed the students lacked knowledge of the facts. Bishop explained this as “the old conflict of inspiration, though inaccurate, with scholarship, though dull.” In a way, his critics were not completely wrong: van Loon confessed much later that following his return to the United States in 1911, he spent time in
T h e G r e a t Wa r
53
vaudeville theaters studying how monologists there held the attention of an audience. Despite the sniping, van Loon’s contract as a lecturer in modern European history was extended by Cornell’s President Schurman in May 1916 for another academic year. Meanwhile, he retained a lecture agent to arrange speaking engagements and continued reaching out to the general public by sending letters and articles to the New York Times.17 In the summer of 1916 van Loon planned to return to Europe to collect documents relating to the war in England and France for Cornell’s University Library, his own lectures, and his articles. To that end, as a “declarant” of U.S. citizenship, he asked the State Department to issue him an American passport. Although van Loon’s request was supported by growing letters of recommendation, Secretary of State Robert Lansing turned him down since a law forbade him to issue a passport to declarants who intended to visit belligerent countries such as Britain and France. Instead, he gave van Loon a letter of introduction to U.S. diplomatic and consular officers in Europe, just as Bryan had done the year before.18 Then, unexpectedly, the British ambassador to Washington declared van Loon a persona non grata in England as a consequence of his New York Times articles on Dutch neutrality—especially his February 1915 reaction to Wells’s article—which were considered anti-British. In a letter to Andrew White, van Loon said the ambassador had turned him “into some sort of Eminence Grise, a cunning spy of high repute.” Van Loon considered the situation “very silly and very absurd” and therefore decided to limit his European trip to studying the situation in the three neutral Scandinavian countries. “My Erasmian spirit,” he wrote, “does not contemplate the future with any great pleasure. The anger on all sides is so great and so unreasonable that we shall come upon an era of grave injustice towards the small nations. The temper of the big states will be that of an angry man who beats his dog to relieve his own mind.”19 As it happened, van Loon’s summer trip was complicated by the difficulties of war time: travel blockades, mines and submarines, and the British demand that captains of neutral ships sailing the northern part of the North Sea report at Kirkwall on the Orkney Islands to have their ships inspected from top to bottom by British authorities looking for contraband and stowaways. When his ocean liner was in the North Sea, he reported, the German Zeppelin L-30 “came down to within about 600 feet of the ship and circled round her three times, so that the passengers could see the crew looking out of their car. Then the machine rose up to an altitude of 3,000 feet or more, and winged her way toward the English coast.”20 After van Loon returned from Scandinavia for his second year at Cornell, a full-time position in the history department came open. Andrew White and
54
Va n L o o n
others pushed for the appointment of the popular lecturer. But several factors decreased van Loon’s prospects. His students may have loved his idiosyncratic, amusing approach, but they performed poorly on tests required by the history department. And George Burr, who had done so much to help his Dutch protégé, had reservations about hiring van Loon. Burr was proud to have seen van Loon mature as a lecturer and teacher but, as he told White, Hendrik Willem still lacked “a sound and thorough knowledge of history” and “a scholar’s grounding in the elements of his subject.” From the time Burr first took van Loon under his wing, the young man “seemed destined for the career of a mere journalist.” Having observed him long enough now, Burr was more and more convinced that van Loon’s best chances for a successful career were “with more popular audiences than ours—as a general lecturer before mixed audiences.”21 The vacant chair was offered to someone else but when Hendrik Willem van Loon bade farewell to the university in June 1917, he had no hard feelings. Cornell President Schurman expressed his sincere appreciation for van Loon’s “stimulating work” as a lecturer on modern European history in the past two years and added, “We are going to miss very much a man of your variety of interests, independence of thought, and gift of lively and entertaining conversation.” In retrospect, Morris Bishop agreed with Andrew White that it was a pity that Cornell was not “large enough to contain a man with van Loon’s rare virtues and common faults.”22 During his last year at Cornell, van Loon had published two more books. The first one, The Golden Book of the Dutch Navigators, was illustrated with seventy reproductions of old prints. In the introduction of the book van Loon argued that the significance of the frontier for American society (“the conquest of the West”) is comparable to the importance of “the conquest of the sea” for Dutch society. In both cases it offered a “wonderful chance to escape” and created a “veritable atmosphere of liberty, . . . not only the liberty of political activity, but freedom of thought and independence.” In January 1917, van Loon gave a talk on his book at the annual meeting of The Netherlands Society of Philadelphia. The basis of success of Holland’s navigators and the subsequent Dutch colonial empire was the maintenance of Grotius’s idea of the open sea. That same spirit was still very much alive, he said, but in the present war a small country like Holland was now having “an extremely hard time in keeping that narrow path between the Channel and the North Sea upon which it [had] been forced for such a very long time.”23 A Short History of Discovery was a children’s book that, in simple understandable language, aimed to tell the story of discovery “from the earliest times to the founding of colonies on the American continent.” In the
T h e G r e a t Wa r
55
foreword van Loon criticized the many historians who had turned “history into a sacred substance administered to the masses in large but indigestible doses.” In his opinion they were “like cooks who recite chapters from a cook book rather than boil us a palatable pudding.”24 Despite the fact that Hendrik Willem had dedicated A Short History of Discovery to his wife and children, his domestic life was far from flourishing. They may no longer have been living off Eliza’s income, but the situation between husband and wife did not improve once the family moved to Ithaca and Hendrik Willem was bringing in his own income. Things came to a head in December 1916, when Hendrik Willem was in New York for business. Eliza opened a letter addressed to her husband bearing no return address. It was a love letter, written in a feminine hand and signed “C,” and to make things worse, this correspondent discussed Hendrik’s and Eliza’s married life. When she furiously confronted Hendrik Willem upon his return to Ithaca, he counter attacked that she had no right to open his mail and denied there had been anything between him and this woman. (In fact, he had met Coba de Bergh, a Dutch piano teacher while on a visit to England, and they exchanged some heated letters before it fizzled out.) After having delivered his final lectures at Cornell, Hendrik Willem left for a while to live at the Netherlands Club in New York’s Gramercy Park, and Eliza moved with the boys into a smaller house in Ithaca; she also asked her lawyer and brother-in-law, Eliot Jones, to look into the possibility of a divorce.25 President Woodrow Wilson had tried to keep his country out of the war as long as possible, but when faced with German unrestricted submarine warfare in February 1917 and American ships torpedoed the following month, with heavy losses, he had no alternative but to ask Congress to declare war. On 7 April, the day after both Houses adopted the war resolution, the New York Tribune headlined “America in Armageddon.” After almost three years of neutrality the American people were spiritually not ready for the war and probably most opposed it. To persuade the American public of the need for war Wilson set up a Committee on Public Information. It was chaired by George Creel, a man who shared Wilson’s messianic ideals, calling the war “a Crusade not merely to re-win the tomb of Christ, but to bring back to earth the rule of right, the peace, goodwill to men and gentleness he taught.” To “sell” the war to the people, Creel’s committee flooded the United States with anti-German propaganda. The militant campaign in 1917 and 1918 against everything German grew to ridiculous proportions. Symphony orchestras no longer dared to play their German repertoires, German language and German philosophy disappeared from the curriculum of a number of colleges and words like German measles and sauerkraut became “liberty measles” and
56
Va n L o o n
“liberty cabbage.” Nor were the neutral Dutch exempt; they were depicted as pro-German war profiteers.26 As van Loon’s time at Cornell drew to a close, he made plans to once again return to the Netherlands. He booked passage on the Holland–America Line’s Noordam, but the steamer was delayed because of the war. While awaiting the ship’s arrival in New York, van Loon met Theodore Roosevelt at the Harvard Club and discussed Dutch neutrality. Once on board the Noordam, van Loon followed up with a letter to the former president. Though his native country had followed the example of the United States when it was still neutral, in the American press, van Loon stated, the Dutch were “made out to be a minor species of human being because we do not join in a war which must mean complete destruction to us.” Holland suffered severely from the war, with every man doing his duty to maintain independence and by taking care of the many Belgian refugees. He thought it very unfair that the Dutch were now exposed to “a Northcliffian attack in the New York papers.”27 Van Loon had typed this letter to Roosevelt on stationery of “The Vigilantes, A Non-Partisan Organization of Authors, Artists and Others for Patriotic Purposes,” of which one of the four purposes mentioned on the letterhead was “To work with especial vigor for Universal Military Training and Service under exclusive Federal control, as a basic principle of American democracy.” Both van Loon and Roosevelt were listed as contributing members of this organization, obviously an offspring of the Committee on Public Information, together with more than three hundred others who formed a cross section of the American intelligentsia. A prominent exception was the essayist Randolph Bourne, the keenest critic of the war. In his principal forum, the new magazine The Seven Arts, Bourne charged that his fellow intellectuals “seem to have forgotten that the real enemy is War rather than imperial Germany.”28 Van Loon published a short article on the war in the same magazine’s August issue. Although the U.S. government had materially made preparations for the war, van Loon argued, it had not provided a clear-cut goal, only a “recruiting poster.” He asserted that, instead of fighting for national doctrines, democracy and all kinds of rights and other “worn-out ideals,” he himself was prepared to “fight for only one good and holy cause: To make the world safe for my children.” The kind of world he imagined, he wrote, was not based on “paper Leagues of armed Peace and societies of enthusiasts, [as he did not want] this war to be the vindication of one set of bad principles over another.” Thus, van Loon took an ambivalent position: on the one hand he apparently was active in a Creel committee, “The Vigilantes,” and yet in
T h e G r e a t Wa r
57
his article for The Seven Arts he criticized the U.S. government for not adequately having “mobilized the spirit.”29 On the afternoon of 3 August, the day before the Noordam was due to arrive in Holland, the 550-feet-long ship struck a chain connecting two freefloating British mines off the coast of the Dutch island of Texel. There were two explosions, but no one was hurt. Nevertheless, the steamer was evacuated and each man was assigned an oar on the lifeboats. Hendrik Willem was quoted in the front-page New York Times article: “The tugboat Thames picked up all the survivors in the course of about three hours. Heavy seas and squalls threatened the destruction of the overloaded craft, and floating mines added to the horror of the eighteen hours’ trip to land.” By the next morning, all the passengers were safely ashore at the nearby port of Den Helder. The accident, which van Loon described to Andrew White as a “tragic and ridiculous affair,” proved to be a traumatic experience for him: his bout of rowing in the lifeboat caused a hernia. An Amsterdam surgeon patched up his hernia and removed his appendix—the latter an unnecessary act as his appendix appeared to be still quite healthy.30 Just before leaving New York, van Loon had told Eliza’s cousin Katy Codman somewhat mysteriously that a principal reason for his trip was that he was “in the center of a combination of people who vaguely see Peace.” While he was in Holland during the fall of 1917, van Loon served as an intermediary between a group of moderate progressive and liberal Germans and John W. Garrett, President Wilson’s envoy extraordinary and minister plenipotentiary in The Hague. The Germans, whom van Loon described as the “Young-German Party” as opposed to the “Old-German Party” of Prussian Junkers, bureaucrats, and industrialists who were willing to fight until the end, had asked him to act as a go-between since there could be no official negotiations at that moment. In his position as intermediary van Loon reported the German and American views from the one to the other and sent copies of his confidential memoranda to the Dutch Minister of Foreign Affairs, John Loudon. However, the American minister, Garrett, did not have much confidence in the leader of the German group, R. Baron von Kühlmann, whose position in the German Foreign Office was unclear to him, and indeed feared a trap. Besides, Garrett in van Loon’s view was so sure of an Allied victory that he already considered the Germans as beaten enemies. Ultimately these unofficial talks went nowhere, perhaps because, as van Loon suggested to Loudon, the Germans considered the issue as a business matter whereas the Americans, in their Wilsonian idealism, considered the war emotionally.31 It is somewhat an enigma how van Loon made ends meet during this extended stay in his native country. Most likely, as he had done during
58
Va n L o o n
preceding trips to Europe, he wrote articles for the Associated Press. But his son Gerard Willem suggests he did not and claims that the articles his father had contracted to write for “The Vigilantes”—for which he had received an advance of $500 and was to receive $150 a week—were never written. In February 1918, the last year of the Great War, van Loon returned to the United States, where he settled in New York, hoping in vain that his marriage could be saved. But a reconciliation with Hendrik Willem was not what Eliza wanted.32
Chapter 7
Life in the Village (1918–1920) “Greenwich Village is a state of mind rather than a state of streets,” Ladies’ Home Journal informed its readers in 1920. The literary critic Malcolm Cowley reflecting on his own years there thought that it “was not only a place, a mood, a way of life: like all Bohemias, it was also a doctrine,” which propagated the ideas of liberty, self-expression, female equality, free love, and the intense enjoyment of life for the moment. This area of Manhattan has been called “the home of half the talent and half the eccentricity in the country,” and “the place where everything happens first.” As one Villager put it, “everything started in the Village except Prohibition.” For a good part of the twentieth century, nearly every major American writer and artist lived in the Village at one time or another. The Village, Cowley wrote, was a cheap place to live in the city where young writers hoped to be published. For those belonging to “the proletariat of the arts,” Greenwich Village was not only a cheap place to live but also the incubator for American culture and art.1 It was the bohemian side of the Village, the “long-haired men and shorthaired women, artists and pseudos, speakeasies, night clubs, and haunts that the tabloid press liked to describe,” that gave it its wide reputation as New York’s Latin Quarter. Among those haunts was The Mad Hatter, a tea room located in a basement on West Fourth Street. Painted backward above the entrance were the words “Down the Rabbit Hole.” In the candle-lit dark front room above a fireplace, the Alice in Wonderland theme continued with the text “We’re all mad here . . . I’m mad, you’re mad, you must be or you wouldn’t have come here.” This tea room and especially its owner were to play an important role in Hendrik Willem van Loon’s life. Once he settled in nearby sections of Manhattan, he too was drawn to the neighborhood where aspiring young artists, writers, and political radicals were creating the
60
Va n L o o n
Greenwich Village that has become a mythic place in the American imagination.2 In early 1918, van Loon rented a room at the Netherlands Club on Gramercy Park, where he tried to come to terms with his private life. At first he thought Eliza’s rejection of him was just temporary; after all, a Bowditch did not divorce. But when in early March Eliza’s mother died and Hendrik Willem went to Boston for the funeral, relatives told him to stay away from Eliza and he felt being dismissed “like an unsatisfactory cook.” Back from this trip in New York he found to his great delight a “little letter” from his youngest son Willem, asking him, “When is Father coming?” He admitted to Katy Codman that “To be at such a distance of Hansje and Willem is Hell, plain and simple and without further phrases.”3 Hendrik Willem wrote Eliza several letters over the next few months about the unfortunate turn their relationship had taken and for which he took the blame. He nevertheless made her feel guilty, too, when in May he sourly observed, “I do not think that it makes very much difference to you whether you have a husband or not. Of course you like your home and the children but I never felt that I was an integral part of your life’s happiness.” He accused Eliza of depriving him of the “daily scribblings” of the boys. That, he was convinced, “really shows your desire to break with me entirely and absolutely more clearly than anything else.” But in complaining that he didn’t see or hear from his sons, he forgot that he had been away from home so often in the last four years that the boys had taken it for granted that their father was often away. Since their question “When are you coming home?” was unanswered so often, writing to their father after some time had lost its attraction. Van Loon promised Eliza to send her “whatever money I make” but that was hardly anything. He hoped it would be a consolation for her to know that he was writing “for cash and not for glory.”4 To provide for her and the children he had sent out a dozen articles and stories to several publishers. But no matter his efforts, they were refused. As he explained to Katy Codman, they were “not up to the ideals of the moment. No hate. No patriotism. None of the food which our editors throw to the hungry mob.” With a name that appeared Germanic to Americans unused to the nuances of European languages, van Loon was viewed suspiciously in the new politically oppressive climate in the United States, where even “the better class papers” were afraid that their business would suffer from the new espionage acts. Oddly enough, notwithstanding such criticism of American “democratic autocracy,” at that time he worked temporarily for the Committee on Public Information, helping to create it.5 That summer van Loon turned to fiction in an effort to make money. He told Professor Burr that he had finished a historical novel and planned to
Life in the Village
61
quickly write two more. The first novel, about “a poor Jewboy, born in the steerage, doomed to pass through life doing good, shot against the walls of Warsaw’s citadel for the pains he had taken on behalf of the oppressed and the suffering,” was turned down by eight publishers by the end of the year. One of the others, centered on Rembrandt and the Dutch Golden Age, would not be written for more than a decade.6 Needing to cut his expenses, van Loon moved to a studio apartment on West Sixteenth Street that September. Fortunately, at this time two small sources of income came his way. He wrote publicity material for an import–export firm in the Financial District. It was just a “minor job,” he told Eliza, for which he considered himself “totally unfit” but that would, “unless the contract is broken (and why not in this land of strange bargains),” enable him to send her twelve hundred dollars over the course of a year. The other was a job at the editorial department of The Nation, a position that brought him into contact with writers of subsequent importance in his life, such as Carl and Irita Van Doren, H.L. Mencken, and Heywood Broun.7 Meanwhile, Eliza’s new divorce lawyer Charles H. Blood of Ithaca asked Hendrik Willem his view on the breakdown of his marriage. In a long letter just a week before the Great War ended with the signing of the armistice on 11 November in a railroad car in Compiègne Forest, he wrote: My married life has been unhappy. No doubt most of it was my fault. Or rather it was the fault of two philosophies-of-life, so utterly different that no common basis could be found. . . . But while I can feel no blame for anything my wife ever did, I must confess to extremely bitter sentiments when it comes to the town of Boston which forever loomed big in the background of our life. I had to fight to make my wife Mrs. Van Loon. I failed and she remained Miss Bowditch. . . . Let me confess at once my complete failure as a financial agent. I have written a number of books and I have taught in several universities. I have never made a penny. . . . Last August I went abroad. When the war is over I shall be able to tell you the purpose of the trip. That too was disastrous. I was forced to stay on the other side much longer than I had intended. It was made a casus belli. Again I had failed to support my wife and family etc. etc. The work I was doing was so infinitely more important than my wife and children could be that it is quite impossible for me to understand this point. . . . I was able to do certain things that are beginning to materialize now and as it would have been very easy for many people here to help my wife through the difficulties, caused by my enforced absence, I did not worry. I know that this sounds like blasphemy to good New England ears. I have been told over and over again since that time that my “first duty was towards my wife and children.” Well, perhaps it was. But I have seen other people’s wives and children die and die in vast quantities. And if in even the humblest fashion I could prevent the continuation of this horror it would have been criminal if I had neglected the opportunity. . . .
62
Va n L o o n
I have just passed through a summer of such extreme bitterness and loneliness—so much undeserved innuendo, that I shall do my best to forget these last seven months. . . . Nothing was omitted to make the thing as unpleasant and nasty as could be. . . . If I had been given a chance to make my wife REALLY my wife, everything would have been well. I had no chance. I was the foreigner (and a queer foreigner at that with no sense of money values). I was always treated as such. . . . You may object that this sounds bitter. It does not sound half as bitter as I feel. . . . I honestly do not feel that I deserved what came to me after I returned this winter. That time has been a horrible nightmare.8
Two days later, he added in another letter to Blood, “I am very sorry but a reconciliation seems impossible. I cannot make my wife over and I cannot make myself over. I would never continue our married life upon the old basis. . . . I have been treated by her and her family as an inefficient and discarded servant, a failure, a sort of clown addicted to cheap historical hokum and useless fiddling. I accept the role. The separation was not of my making. It was bestowed upon me as a free and voluntary gift.”9 Several decades later, Eliza’s old friend Hermann Hagedorn thought that the failure of the marriage was due to the “basically antagonistic” personalities of the couple. Whereas Eliza in his view was “a New England puritan, self-disciplined [and] moralistic; who would have come to full flower in some high cause asking everything of her, even to life itself,” Hendrik Willem was “a bohemian, a hedonist, an artist . . . easy-going [and] impatient of the social code.”10 In June 1918 Hendrik Willem wrote Eliza that although he met “whole regiments of women these days,” he was not interested in those “members of your excellent sex” after his “deplorable failure.” This indifference on his part quickly changed, however, when in September at the Brevoort Hotel, a Greenwich Village for such writers as John Dos Passos and Edna St. Vincent Millay, he met Lorena Gibbs, known as Rene. An Ithaca native, she had tried to catch his eyes while a secretary at Cornell’s College of Architecture. Now, working at the New York Evening World, this brown-haired, charming woman with a beautifully modulated voice attracted van Loon’s attention. He was flattered when it appeared that she knew what books he had written. Updating her on his marital status, he described himself as “the Flying Dutchman, cursed to sail through life alone until redeemed by a woman’s love.” Rene was quick to assume that role and before their first weekend in his apartment was over, Hendrik Willem proposed to her and shortly thereafter gave her a signet ring engraved with the van Loon family crest. In the months that followed Rene not only was captivated by his boyish wistfulness, but also had to cope with his fluctuating state of health and “nerves.”11 On 14 January 1919, his thirty-seventh birthday, Hendrik Willem received the papers that proved he was “a duly sworn U.S. citizen.” Although, as he
Life in the Village
63
wrote Eliza, he did “not take much stock in nationality anyway,” he thought it both better for himself and for the children to be American citizens as it was very unlikely they would ever go to Holland to live there. “At the present moment, when liberalism is fighting for its life and needs all the people it can get,” he thought he could “do more” in his new capacity as U.S. citizen than before.12 Nevertheless, van Loon did not forget his country of origin and the negative press it had in the United States. In the last year of the war, relations between the Netherlands and the United States reached an absolute low. In March, by order of President Wilson, the United States requisitioned ninety Dutch ships in American ports, which was followed the next day by the requisition of forty-five Dutch ships in British harbors. Historian Thomas Bailey described the annexation of the Dutch fleet as “the most spectacular single act of force employed by the United States” against a neutral country during the war. This action led to anti-American feelings among the Dutch population and, to show her anger at this “ship robbery,” Queen Wilhelmina kept the Dutch diplomatic post in Washington vacant; in response, the United States recalled its envoy, John Garrett, from Holland “for consultations.”13 In June van Loon wrote to Jacob Theodoor Cremer, a member of the Dutch Senate and former colonial minister, with suggestions on how to improve the negative perception of the Dutch in the United States. Van Loon stressed that the British press campaigns in the United States against Holland were successful because the Dutch remained passive and did not counterattack the falsely created image that their country was a kind of appendix to Germany. His own articles, he told Cremer, had been in vain and even led to the accusation by the British ambassador in Washington of his being a “hired agent of the Dutch government.” He pleaded that the Netherlands send the best possible man to fill the vacant diplomatic post, since “personal tact and initiative” would be crucial in repairing relations. He also suggested that his native country establish a Holland Institute in New York, a center for art and commercial activities along the lines of the Spanish Institute, to promote Dutch interests and to regain the goodwill of the American people, which had been lost “through our own neglect and stupidity.”14 Cremer presented van Loon’s suggestions to a meeting of the Board of Trustees of the Netherlands Oversea Trust Company on 12 September, just a few days after a new cabinet had been sworn in. There was a consensus that the first priority was the appointment of a Dutch envoy who should be supported by a well-qualified staff. A committee would explore how to set up the kind of institute van Loon had recommended. Meanwhile, Foreign Minister H.A. van Karnebeek proposed that Cremer himself be the new Dutch envoy to the United States. Once Washington accepted the appointment in October with “very great pleasure” and Cremer set sail to assume the post, the
64
Va n L o o n
diplomatic crisis between the two countries was smoothed over. By the new year, President Wilson and Queen Wilhelmina were exchanging cordial greetings.15 In January 1920 with the help of Dutch businesses, Jacob Cremer did establish the Netherlands Chamber of Commerce in New York. Its main objective was the promotion of the economic and cultural relations between the Netherlands and the United States. But progress was very slow. Van Loon continued to lament the persistence of anti-Dutch feelings, especially outside New York.16 Besides his public relations work for the import–export company, which he hated, van Loon was also writing articles for The Nation and book reviews for The Dial. In The Bookman he discussed the development of juvenile literature in Holland, and he also contributed pieces to The Century Magazine, Everybody’s Magazine, and the New York Tribune.17 Financially more important, however, was the book contract he was offered in June 1919 by Boni and Liveright to write an illustrated children’s history called Ancient Man, which was to be followed by similar booklets. The firm’s publisher, Horace Brisbin Liveright, was always interested in new ideas and had a penchant for gambling on unknown writers whose works— often critical of American society—he promoted through aggressive publicity. The list of authors he published between 1917 and 1930 include many of the great names of modern American literature: Theodore Dreiser, Sherwood Anderson, William Faulkner (whose novels van Loon loathed intensely), Ernest Hemingway, E.E. Cummings, Ezra Pound, T.S. Eliot, and Eugene O’Neill. As Liveright’s biographer observed, he had a “remarkable gift for finding writers and encouraging them with both personal enthusiasm and money.” Van Loon badly needed the advance one hundred dollars, and told his Cornell friend Louis A. Fuertes that this “good contract” promised him “a stuffed ostrich” if the series was successful.18 There were more surprises that month. The U.S. Secret Service entered his apartment and went through his papers, looking for evidence of his political leanings. The so-called Red Scare, a wave of anti-Communist hysteria that swept across America, had begun after the Third International met in Moscow in March 1919. As historian William E. Leuchtenburg observed, it produced “a bitter heritage of suspicion of aliens, distrust of organized labor, hostility to reformers, and insistence on political conformity that served to smother reform efforts in the 1920s [and] would cast a long shadow over the politics of [the] 1930s.” The Nation’s continued criticism of the Creel committee caused the authorities to temporarily shut down the magazine and investigate all its contributors. Not only was van Loon understandably upset by the violation of his privacy, but he soon discovered that a State
Life in the Village
65
Department report said he was dismissed from Cornell “for pro-German sentiments and inclinations.” He indignantly wrote his mentor Burr, “[T]o find that this silly story has been spread among official circles at a time when the whole country went into an orgy of anti-Germanism was a most unpleasant surprise. Those of us suspected of liberalism (I am not mentioning radicalism but plain old-fashioned liberalism) have a hard enough time as it is.”19 Reflecting on the incident years later in his book Van Loon’s Lives, van Loon mentioned other factors, besides his work for The Nation and other liberal periodicals, that made him an object of suspicion. The secret agents who broke into his studio had discovered a Russian dictionary on his bookshelves (from a course in the language he’d taken at Harvard) and had drawn the conclusion that he must at least be a sympathizer of Bolshevism. Furthermore, someone had written the Department of Justice that van Loon was clicking his heels while bowing to a lady. Asked why he did this, he had replied that he was unconscious of the act as he had spent some years in Germany while working on his Ph.D. This, van Loon explained, had made him suspicious and as a result he “was for quite a long while hunted like a dangerous criminal, though few people surely had been so consistent in their dislike of the unholy Teuton as I.”20 It was also in June 1919 that Hendrik Willem van Loon for the first time visited The Mad Hatter. Even before his first visit to the Greenwich Village tea room, the owner, Eliza Helen Criswell, had seen him a number of times at the French Pastry Shop on Sixth Avenue where she went every morning to have breakfast. She had asked someone who “the tall, good-looking” guy was and was told that this van Loon “was always trying to write something or other.” Her diary records his initial appearance at her tea shop on 11 June; in the next day’s entry, Eliza not only notes that van Loon stopped by again but that she went to a bookstore to buy a Dutch dictionary.21 Born on 8 May 1882 in Harrisburg, Pennsylvania, Eliza Helen Criswell was the only child of a widowed doctor and his second wife. To the disapproval and envy of the mother, a close relationship developed between father and daughter. After Dr. Criswell’s death in 1890, young Eliza Helen idolized her father’s memory, developed a withering contempt for religious females and had a hard time accepting her female sex. In 1900 she enrolled at Bryn Mawr where she established herself as captain of the basketball team, made herself known as Jimmie, James, or Jim, and began her lifelong habit of furtively taking a drink before a game or any other confrontation. Though she was good at mathematics, history, and sports, she chose to learn languages for which she had no flair. Nevertheless, by grinding her way through, she became proficient in Latin and relatively fluent in German and French. After her graduation from Bryn Mawr in 1904, Jimmie began a career of teaching
66
Va n L o o n
foreign languages, first at private schools in the Pacific Northwest and then at Bryant High School in Long Island City. Once she was settled in New York, she was able to take two trips to Europe in the years before the outbreak of war and she also discovered the attractions of Greenwich Village where she soon took a part-time job at the popular Mad Hatter. After having met a woman, Mathilda Spence, with whom she decided to share a room in the Village, Jimmie transformed her appearance. She cut her hair into a boyish bob and henceforth wore smocks instead of dresses, sandals instead of shoes, and for special occasions preferred tailored suits with shirt and tie and black or white slouch hats. In July 1916 Jimmie and Mathilda bought The Mad Hatter. When Mathilda decided to go overseas, Jimmie quit her teaching position and from then on worked full-time at her tea room. Over the years her customers included artists and writers like Dwight Franklin, Lewis Mumford, and Sinclair Lewis.22 Although she ran the tea room with a firm, businesslike hand, Jimmie enjoyed the work and her customers. For a time she even published an in-house satirical journal called “Mad Hatter Mutterings,” which in addition to poems, short stories, and drawings included “news, notes and gossip.” In the December 1920 issue she announced that “The Management of the Mad Hatter is, and cheerfully, cook, cashier, waiter, bouncer, bus boy, check room boy, official chaperone, arbiter, elegantiarum, chess scorer, peace maker, drainage system, book keeper, cat nurse, censor, and goat of said coffee house.” She made appeals for contributions in that issue and the next month’s: “If, as the slummers fondly suppose, we are a brilliant collection of artists and writers, we implore the writers to write and the artists to art a little for our publication. Otherwise, we shall have nothing further to publish.” Apparently these were successful as the following issues of “Mad Hatter Mutterings” varied between twenty and twenty-five pages.23 Jimmie’s mannish appearance was quite a contrast with that of Hendrik Willem’s fiancé, Rene Gibbs. What, then, made Jimmie attractive to van Loon? Rene’s job at the New York Evening World was more and more time-consuming while Jimmie was always available. As he quickly discovered, she wanted to be needed—she could type fast and well for him, sew his buttons, tidy up his room, and bring him food—and she liked his courteous manners toward her. Before long Hendrik Willem proposed to Jimmie, as he had done to Rene. Since the two women lived in separate worlds, they were not aware of each other. Naturally, van Loon found it very convenient to keep the two worlds separated and showered both women with ardent attentions such as specialdelivery letters and telegrams while writing and drawing his Ancient Man.24 As was mentioned earlier, throughout his life Hendrik Willem van Loon had a special attention for women’s feet. This feeling was clearly expressed in the romantic letters he sent Jimmie in the fall of 1919. “Jim darling, I kiss
Life in the Village
67
your feet. They are lovely things. If never I had seen thee—but had seen thy feet—I’d love thee. They are sort-of-like-yourself. They are sensibly big enough to carry thee with grace. They are slender and speak all the fine things those brown eyes tell with even greater firmness. . . . Oh woman of pure delight.”25 For a month in the fall of 1919 van Loon served as the secretary of the Dutch delegation at an international labor conference in Washington, D.C., sponsored by the League of Nations. Van Loon, who found it “mighty interesting to sit amidst the mighty in a front row and keep a translation of the darn thing,” had the feeling that he was “learning more than ever Henry Adams learned.” Overall, what he saw was disappointing. The new international organization seemed unable to bridge either the differences between employers and labor representatives or those between northern European countries, which had already enacted some labor laws, and Asian countries, which hadn’t.26 It was Jacob Cremer who recruited van Loon for the Dutch delegation, but in the months after the conference he was criticized for doing so. A Dutchman in New York by the name of Arnold van Couthen Piccardt Huizinga wrote Cremer that van Loon was under surveillance of the Department of Justice after he had been removed from the Committee on Public Information, was regularly in the company of the “bolshevist agitator Miss Helen Criswell,” and could be arrested any moment as bolshevist because the American government had placed him in the “dangerous class.” In another letter, to the secretary of the Netherlands Overseas Association, Huizinga added his opinion that had van Loon not already become a U.S. citizen, he probably would have been deported. An official at the Dutch legation in Washington had to present a report in response to Foreign Minister van Karnebeek and sketched a more positive picture of van Loon. It was true, he admitted, that van Loon’s house was searched by detectives, but that was nothing special to a person of foreign birth who had just returned from Europe where during the war he had mediated between Germans and Allies for the sake of peace. Although van Loon was clearly exculpated, in her diaries Jimmie noted with disgust that several times in 1920 and 1921 detectives kept an eye on her and her husband.27 While in Washington, Hendrik Willem wrote Jimmie a letter full of doubts. “I really don’t belong here. Unless you see this great and glorious country in the light of an unreasoning enthusiasm, you are lost. . . . Europe is so much easier because it is so much more honest.” Van Loon not only felt uncertain about the United States, he had reservations about his relationship with Jimmie. “[A]re you quite sure you want this foreign complexity?” He was scared by the failure of his first marriage too. “If we are to wander together,
68
Va n L o o n
it is for keeps and not for a few years and unless we really share each other’s feelings and ideas and sentiments, it will not be a happy walk. Unless it be a perfect companionship, it will pull and drag and make us both very uncomfortable. . . . But it is an uncertain affair and American life demands but one single thing—certainty.”28 Van Loon checked into the hospital in early December to have the inadequate surgery of the hernia he had had in Amsterdam right after his shipwreck in 1917 taken care of. He was very weak after this operation, and as Gerard Willem van Loon put it in his father’s biography, Jimmie became the “self-supporting companion-nurse-stenographer on twenty-four-hour call” for almost two months. Hendrik Willem’s dependence on Jimmie made him overlook her drinking—which he loathed—and her ingrained denial of femininity. Unlike the feminine but always busy Rene Gibbs, she was there and available for him.29 Van Loon was realizing that he had many reasons to be grateful to Jimmie. She had helped him break free from “barbed wire defences” and stop hiding his feelings. While he was recuperating in the hospital, he wrote her, “Do you know what has made this whole business so perfect? Our play acting. I behave as if I were a terrible brute, a great big strong he-man. I am nothing of the sort. Your character is much stronger than mine but it is fit for the man to play the commanding cave brute and therefore I command. And you obey. Not because you have to. God knows it would be better all around if you did the ordering. But you obey and we both know that we are pretending and we go on pretending and we love it.” In a letter the next month, he observed, “All that you have given me has been beautiful beyond words. We are no children. We are rarely sentimental. Sometimes I think that we are strange lovers. It has all been so much finer than a love affair such as the world seems to know and understand. . . . You have pulled me through the dreariest days and your wonderful eyes have been lights that did not fail.” In a 1947 radio interview, however, Jimmie described how she had won van Loon’s heart in less romantic terms: “Hendrik Willem loved ice cream, and you know what they say about the way to a man’s heart. I knew he didn’t have much money, but I fed him so much ice cream.”30 In the first part of 1920, in addition to his writing ads for a silk importer, van Loon was working on Ancient Man and planning the first of the follow-up volumes that Liveright wanted him to do. In this series van Loon hoped to follow “a somewhat new direction. No politics more than is strictly necessary and the full light thrown upon spiritual and scientific development.” Whereas he had given up the “hopeless” task of trying to give the older generation at the universities other historical ideas, van Loon wrote Dutch diplomat John Loudon, he now had decided to start “a kind of Erasmian
Life in the Village
69
attack on the child’s heart with the spirit of Busken Huet’s Land van Rembrandt as its guiding principle.”31 When he finished the manuscript of Ancient Man in May, van Loon dedicated the book and the eight volumes that were to follow to his sons, Hansje and Willem, “and to the boys and girls who shall keep you company on the voyage through life.” As the author explained, this book was not a textbook, a picture book, or even a regular history book. He just wanted to take his boys by the hand “and together we shall wander forth to explore the intricate wilderness of the bygone ages. I shall show you mysterious rivers which seem to come from nowhere and which are doomed to reach no ultimate destination. I shall bring you close to dangerous abysses, hidden carefully beneath a thick overgrowth of pleasant but deceiving romance. Here and there we shall leave the beaten track to scale a solitary and lonely peak, towering high above the surrounding country. Unless we are very lucky we shall some times lose ourselves in a sudden and dense fog of ignorance. Wherever we go we must carry our warm cloak of human sympathy and understanding for vast tracks of land will prove to be a sterile desert—swept by icy storms of popular prejudice and personal greed and unless we come well prepared we shall forsake our faith in humanity and that, dear boys, would be the worst thing that could happen to any of us.” Featuring forty illustrations and maps, Ancient Man was well received when it came out that November and Liveright soon was receiving strong advance orders for the entire series.32 Meanwhile, Eliza Bowditch van Loon was granted a divorce in Reno, Nevada, in June 1920; during the following two months Hansje and Willem stayed with their father. While Rene went to Maine for a brief vacation, Hendrik Willem made up his mind and decided in favor of Jimmie. On 3 August he and Jimmie went to New York’s Municipal Building to get married. One of the witnesses was the artist Dwight Franklin. The newlyweds spent their honeymoon with Hansje and Willem in an artists’ colony near Lee, Maine, and when that proved to be unsatisfactory to Hendrik Willem in a nearby boarding house where he earned a part of the expenses “by sketching india-ink frescoes on the dining-room walls.” On their way to Maine they spent a night in Boston where Eliza joined them for dinner at their hotel. On that occasion both former and present wife addressed each other as “Mrs. van Loon.” The next day at the Boston North Station the van Loons ran into Rene who was on her way back to New York and was totally unaware of Hendrik Willem’s recent wedding. When she saw Jimmie’s wedding ring and Hendrik Willem redundantly confirmed that they had been married, she replied, “Hendrik, you didn’t have to do that,” and walked away. Aboard the train she threw Hendrik Willem’s signet ring with the van Loon family crest out of the
70
Va n L o o n
window. Sometime later she quit her newspaper job and started to rent rooms in her newly acquired Park Avenue apartment. In January 1921 Rene married one of her roomers, the British-born Bill Scudamore who had been recently divorced and turned out to be a heavy drinker. The next five years would be hell for her.33 After their vacation in Maine, van Loon’s children returned to their mother in Ithaca and Hendrik Willem and Jimmie moved into an apartment on Barrow Street. Hendrik Willem earned $75 a week writing a daily column for Woman’s Wear on style and fabrics. This paid the rent while Jimmie, by running The Mad Hatter, brought in enough to buy the food.34 Barely settled in his new apartment, van Loon was eager to report the recent changes in his life in “a lengthy siege of words” to his old mentor, Professor Burr. He wrote about the divorce, his marriage to Jimmie, and his career prospects. Making a living in New York meant “selling” things—even brains—but he was prepared to make the sacrifice of having to write ads as long as he was able to write his books. He was very pleased to tell he had “a new home or rather I have a home for it is the first time in my life that I have had the rest and happiness of a place which was my own rather than a museum of unseen but much-noticed Salem ancestors.” Van Loon described Jimmie’s tea room as “a sort of international sight-of-the-town . . . where the intelligentsia of a large city gathereth together to partake of tea and chess and occasional conversation.” And, “best of all,” he found that his children had accepted his new wife as “a very pleasant new friend” and therefore he was no longer afraid “that they would entirely drift away from me.” Even if they were with Eliza most of the time, the children now had a place, certainly when they grew older, where they could “come and go as they please.” Due to “a new house and a new life and a fair prospect of a great deal of work during the next few years,” Hendrik Willem was in high spirits now. Two and a half years after he had settled in New York because of his matrimonial problems with Eliza, it sure looked that brighter days were ahead.35
Part III
The Jazz Age
This page intentionally left blank
Chapter 8
The Breakthrough (1921–1922) At the beginning of 1921, Jimmie reported in her diary that Hendrik Willem—whom she called Han—was “feeling quite rotten,” or even was “feeling like hell” and suffered from “ragged nerves” and pain in his chest. By the end of January, she was able to pen that her husband was much better now and “dressed all day,” but her diary entries in March attest to an attack of the blues. About the only bright spot was a burgeoning friendship with Sinclair Lewis, whose novel Main Street had just been published to great acclaim. That winter Sinclair Lewis and his wife, Grace Hegger Lewis, who were celebrities now, visited the van Loons a number of times. According to one of Lewis’s biographers van Loon supposedly put up a sign in his house that read, “It is forbidden to gossip over three minutes about Grace.” Lewis also introduced van Loon to his editor, Alfred Harcourt, who in 1919 had started his own publishing house. Harcourt became a lifelong friend of Hendrik Willem’s and in later years published four of his books.1 By late March, three encouraging developments enabled van Loon to write his elder son that “there are a few trees appearing upon the desert through which we have been travelling for so long a time. At the end of this year we may be in more fertile country.” The first one was that the Christy Walsh Syndicate, “one of the largest New York newspaper syndicates,” had signed him up to do a daily picture and a historical children’s story of about three hundred words. Then, at a lunch meeting in New York two members of the board of trustees of Antioch College in Yellow Springs, Ohio, offered him a position teaching history and running the Social Sciences Department. This prospect was very attractive to van Loon, not only because of the regular and “exceedingly good salary” ($4,000 a year) but also because Antioch was setting up a school for the children of the faculty members. This made it possible for van Loon to propose his former wife that their elder son come
74
Va n L o o n
and live with him there. In early May Antioch President Arthur E. Morgan confirmed the appointment for the next academic year. Van Loon immediately traveled to Ohio to see the place, which in a letter to Burr he described as “A sort of run-down Harvard College, neglected and decaying amidst the woods of Yellow Springs. But a place of almost medieval charm.”2 The third good omen for van Loon’s career that March began with a book review he wrote for the literary monthly The Dial. Although he expressed reservations about it in a letter to Hansel, van Loon praised H.G. Wells’s twovolume The Outline of History for its liberating popular version of history, which was of “true and lasting value.” Van Loon’s own Ancient Man had been a success for Boni and Liveright, so Horace Liveright saw an opportunity. He proposed that instead of the projected children’s history series that was supposed to follow Ancient Man, van Loon produce a one-volume complete and self-illustrated children’s history of the world in a format that was unprecedented in the juvenile market of those days: it was planned to have “300 pages text, 100 black and white pictures, 20 colored ones and 20 animated maps.” (As it turned out, the finished book would have 479 pages and more than 150 illustrations.) Assisted by Jimmie, who copied his writings, Hendrik Willem completed the first draft in two months and delivered the final manuscript to Liveright in late June.3 While he was still sweating on his drawings in sultry New York, van Loon wrote some of his Dutch friends in jest that unlike Thucydides and Ranke, who like “amateurs” had “just” written their histories, he had both written and drawn a history of the world; to Eliza that summer he confided the hope that the book would have as a result that “no professor doctor hereafter, can write quite the same sort of dull history that has been forced upon children thus far.” Meanwhile, anticipating renewed interest in his earlier books, van Loon suggested to Ferris Greenslet of Houghton Mifflin that they advertise The Fall of the Dutch Republic as he wanted that book “to get beyond the thousand-line.” In the foreword of The Story of Mankind, like he had done in Ancient Man, van Loon addressed his sons, Hansje and Willem, and told them that as a young boy he once was taken to the top of Rotterdam’s St. Lawrence tower. After having reached that top, he had his “first glimpse of the big world [and a] wide view of the glorious past.” As he told his sons, “History is the mighty Tower of Experience, which Time has built amidst the endless fields of bygone ages. It is no easy task to reach the top of this ancient structure and get the benefit of the full view. There is no elevator, but young feet are strong and it can be done. Here I give you the key that will open the door. When you return, you too will understand the reason for my enthusiasm.”4 In the July issue of “Mad Hatter Mutterings” Jimmie announced that beginning the next month the tea room would be managed by Helen Ryan of whom it
The Breakthrough
75
was said “that she has something of my technique in the art of being unpleasant when necessary.” She requested her customers to assist the new manager in keeping the current pleasant atmosphere and since The Mad Hatter was “the only Village shop with a paper” she also asked for a volunteer to edit it and keep it going. In the next issue, Jimmie wrote her farewell editorial “to the family” in which she made “her little bow and retires from the stage where for five happy years she has played to the best of her small ability the pleasantest role which the gods have ever given her. Her mistakes have been many, her judgements often wrong, but the play has gone on, the longest run of any show in the Village.” She thanked her friends for their faithful support over the years and for having given her “the happiest years of her life.”5 As the van Loons were packing, Hendrik Willem had mixed feelings about what to expect in Yellow Springs. He was looking forward to returning to academia and he would not miss the five flights of stairs to their Barrow Street apartment. But he wondered what awaited them at Antioch, which was emerging from a period of decay under its new president. Arthur Morgan, a civil engineer by training, was tailoring an experimental educational program to the requirements of industry. When the van Loons arrived on 1 September they found the college was undergoing more than a change in curriculum. The campus was full of trenches and incoming freshmen were expected to help lay pipes.6 Hendrik Willem and Jimmie moved into a cottage just off campus, he gave his first lecture on 8 September, and he also did “more physical labor” than he usually “did in a year in the city.” This dose of pioneering conditions was “more than enough” and henceforth he wanted to read about it only in books. Whereas the old pioneering gold diggers at least dug gold, he could only report to have dug mud. There was “no entertainment of any sort” and soon Jimmie recorded that her days at Antioch were “all alike” and she often wondered “what the hell to do with herself,” especially on evenings when her husband was away for a faculty meeting and she realized that she “had an unbroken record of six years without a single evening at home alone.” As a time killer she started to study Danish and fortunately some New York friends, like Sinclair and Grace Lewis, Morris Bishop, and Van Wyck Brooks, soon came to visit them.7 Despite the physical rigors of life at Antioch that semester, van Loon cut a distinctive figure on campus. Anthony Veiller, a freshman that year who later became a top screenwriter in Hollywood, recalled the “sophisticated” history professor striding along the paths of a “campus, more dangerous to cross than a minefield, . . . with great trenches. . . . And quite a sight he was in that background. I can still see this huge Dutchman standing in front of his class, wearing a smock (the first ever seen in Ohio), a monocle (most certainly the first ever seen), white cotton gardener’s gloves, a box of crayons in his left
76
Va n L o o n
hand while, with his right, he illustrated on an enormous pad the subject of his lecture. And this was not wisdom tossed on the empty air. No student ever cut one of his classes voluntarily.”8 In December the van Loons’ living conditions improved somewhat when they moved into a new house, but “the eternal dampness and wetness” of the Ohio climate caused Hendrik Willem to develop an ear infection, which temporarily affected his hearing. But what bothered him most was the big cultural difference between New York and his present situation. The “midwestern self-made man,” he observed, “never lets a chance go by without telling the young feller that manners are a superficial adornment and quite unnecessary for success in real he-man red-blooded life.” Of course, he admitted to Morris Bishop who had just started teaching at Cornell, that Cornell was also “far from the world and small-townish and everything, but [at least there] you can take a brother-of-the-soul under the arm and take a walk and talk of God and Woman and many other things.” This was hardly possible at Yellow Springs, since “The shores of Ohio Nyanza are too muddy for walks. And God hereabouts is a presbyterian.”9 Fortunately, there was encouraging news from his publishers. Liveright told him that The New Republic was “going to use The Story of Mankind for this year’s premium,” and a reissue of his 1917 book A Short History of Discovery promised to bring in a little money. But, as van Loon told Burr, “the more I shall have, the more will drop into the bottomless barrel of alimony. The lawyers sit and wait eagerly and the more I shall write and draw, the more they shall expect!”10 Eliza’s lawyers complained throughout 1921 that Hendrik Willem was not living up to his financial obligations, even though they acknowledged that his income fluctuated. Meanwhile, Eliza agreed to send fourteen-year-old Hansel, who was restless and rebellious in Ithaca, to Antioch, where the pioneering educational experiment might do him some good. Not long after Hansje had joined Hendrik Willem and Jimmie, his father reported to Eliza that their elder son was happy and doing well at school. He was behaving as “a lovable child and the matter-of-factness of Jim makes up for his Pa’s temperament. We feed him well and give him a comfortable roost and leave him alone when he wants to work out his own little plans. I think that you will agree that it is the best way.”11 In the third week of November Jimmie noted in her diary, “First copies of Story of Mankind arrived. It’s a great book.” Van Loon, however, had no idea whether it would sell and therefore made himself available “for any gathering of more than six people in the hope that one of the group would buy a book.” As Anthony Veiller recorded, “In the next month or so he went to more dreadful dinners . . . than any man should have to endure in one lifetime.” Despite early positive reactions to his book, including praise from Carl Van Doren and H.L. Mencken (with whom Hendrik Willem had begun a correspondence), van Loon still remained skeptical. He wondered whether
The Breakthrough
77
“the thing [is] going to succeed at last” and whether the unexpected “avalanche of approval” would really “MEAN anything.” If success did come, he asked Eliza rhetorically in a letter, what awaited him? “More books, more dreadful work and in the end . . . Yellow Springs, Greene County, Ohio?”12 The “avalanche of approval” for The Story of Mankind was evidently shown in the reviews that appeared in many influential newspapers and periodicals starting in November 1921. There were raves from The Literary Review, the New York Tribune, the New York Herald, the Boston Transcript, the Boston Herald, and even the Cornell Alumni News. In the New York Times reviewer Austin Hay said it was a better book than Wells’s Outline of History, predicting that grown-ups would respond as enthusiastically as children. He praised van Loon as “a ripe scholar with a sensitive mind” who “painted a brilliant picture of man’s tortuous journey through the turmoil of the ages with the mastery of the true artist.” In The Bookman the curator of the Children’s Book Division of the New York Public Library, Anne Carroll Moore, extolled The Story of Mankind as “The most invigorating, and I venture to predict, the most influential children’s book for many years to come, [and a book] that bids fair to revolutionize the writing and illustrating of history and biography for the fortunate youth of this generation and the next.”13 The reception from traditional historians was also positive. New York University Professor J. Salwyn Schapiro in The Nation proclaimed The Story of Mankind “one of the most extraordinary books to see the light in many a day” and could only describe the author’s “originality, his subtle wisdom, his love and understanding of children, his reduction of complex material to lucid and dramatic simplicity, [as] genius.” In Schapiro’s opinion van Loon had “taken the hardest not the easiest way to his goal, for he deals primarily with movements and ideas, not with heroes and picturesque incidents. Nevertheless, the book reads like a fascinating story, told by a master storyteller.” He continued, noting “a rich vein of delightful humor and irony which helps not a little to explain man and his institutions. . . . The text and the illustrations are one and inseparable; they illuminate each other and likewise reveal the author’s original and almost fantastic personality.”14 The most gratifying praise of all came from historian Charles A. Beard. In The New Republic he compared The Story of Mankind with The Outline of History and for him it was crystal clear that van Loon was “a far safer guide than the English novelist” since he “knows a thousand times more history and writes with as much taste and more humor.” Although van Loon had primarily written his book for children, Beard maintained, “there is a rich background to all his chapters, a background that can be seen by those that have eyes to see.” Beard had no doubts that “for grasp on historic fact, for style, and for insight,” he preferred van Loon to Wells. In The Freeman Lewis
78
Va n L o o n
Mumford shared Beard’s preference for van Loon whose “gargantuan work” he characterized as “about half as long and twice as readable” as Wells’s Outline. Though Mumford considered van Loon’s concentration on Europe “not so much a defect as a limitation,” he commended his “power of brisk and picturesque summarizing” and likened the sections in The Story on the medieval city, the Renaissance, the foundation of universities, and the chapter on art to “rockets thrown over a black landscape: their memorable flashes leave a clearer vision on the retina than most of the familiar commonplaces of the daylight.”15 In a letter to his Cornell friend Morris Bishop a couple of days before Christmas 1921, van Loon said that at Yellow Springs he was being treated “like a conquering hero” and that the Chicago Daily News the next day would give a “large literary luncheon [with] all the great ones of Chicago” in his honor. It was a complete new experience to him “to have to play the great man [and he wondered] How do you do it? I wrote that book because I thought all the time that it was going to be my last one and I wanted to get straight with the boys who had been removed by fearsome Boston lest they become the same goodfornothing their Pa was.” The favorable reviews and commercial success of The Story of Mankind made van Loon feel more restless at Antioch, where he considered himself “entirely overworked [and] camping with the wrong crowd.” In his view, as he explained to Lewis Mumford, the people at Antioch College were no educators but reformers. Although they did their best to achieve some sort of culture, it was all “quite hopeless,” as it was “the sort of kultur one would do without most gratefully. It means slow death. . . . Just the small college stuff.” He felt it almost impossible to do his routine job there, not because of the regular hours of teaching and “all sorts of tasks which belong to the curriculum of a well-appointed nurse,” but because of “the uselessness of it all.”16 How pleased he was, then, that right at that time the Baltimore Sun offered him a job as columnist. In January 1922, van Loon hastened to Baltimore to sign a contract, even though the job wouldn’t start until the summer; as he told Mumford, it would give him “time to write and time to see decent people” again. He also obtained a commission to write an article on Cornell for The Smart Set, the magazine of which H.L. Mencken at that time was coeditor. From Baltimore van Loon dashed off to New York for a week of triumphal meetings. “Everybody seemed so happy about the success of the book,” he reported to his younger son Willem, “and I never was so busy in all my life for everybody wanted to see me suddenly and it was difficult to know just what to do and what to say. Sixteen thousand copies of the book have been sold and the fourth edition is rapidly being printed.”17 At the end of the month van Loon was in Chicago again, this time to deliver two lectures. As Chicago Daily News literary editor Harry Hansen in his column
The Breakthrough
79
“A Page about Books and the People Who Write Them” observed about the author he described as “one of those fine spirits that one meets rarely,” the sudden fame had disconcerted van Loon: “he finds the big white searchlight seeking him out and he knows not whither to flee.” After his visit to the Windy City van Loon hurried back to Antioch from where he wrote his friend Louis Fuertes, “I am no longer my own sweet self. Of course I shall continue to be the same lovable, simple-minded, straightforward cuss I used to be before prosperity came to me.” He also reported that movie people were pursuing the dramatic rights, but expressed doubts about how it could be adapted. As the winter continued, The Story of Mankind had cumulative sales of 50,000.18 Although van Loon kept no financial records, Gerard Willem van Loon estimated that his father received more than half a million dollars in royalties for his best seller over the years. Horace Liveright’s willingness to gamble on the relatively unknown writer van Loon and the ability of his advertising department paid off spectacularly: The Story of Mankind was the second highestselling work of nonfiction in 1922 and remained in the top ten the next year as well. Liveright enthusiastically called it a “stunt book [which appealed to] the cry of these days: something new, something new.” During the 1920s van Loon’s book went through thirty American editions and was translated into a dozen languages. But despite the considerable income for the author, as his younger son observed, the money that flowed into van Loon’s pocket also flowed through it, as that pocket “had a very large hole.” In any case, van Loon’s lean years had come to an end, no matter that he publicly declared: “This fame is hard to stand. I am supposed to be endlessly rich and endlessly patient—and I am neither.”19 In the next few weeks van Loon made many quick trips to New York. One morning in March his Antioch students found, as Anthony Veiller reported, “instead of their be-smocked, be-monocled Professor, a note on the bulletin-board which read, ‘I do not believe in long good-byes when good friends part. We have, I hope, each learned a good deal from the other during the time we have spent together. And now it is time for me to say farewell.’ . . . That day the entire student body went on strike in protest at [the] departure” of this “Renaissance Man.”20 At Christmas 1921, in a letter to his bachelor friend Morris Bishop, van Loon had explained the advantages of “short-haired” wives like Jimmie: “They are the easiest to have around the house. In the morning they growl a couple of times but when they are once up all they need to do is shake themselves a couple of times and they are ready to be let out.” And so he advised his friend, “Get a short-haired one—fast on its legs. It makes it easier catching a bus.” By the spring of 1922, the situation had changed. Being a celebrity, Hendrik Willem thought he was now entitled to have a wife who, as his younger son put it, was “more spiritually and physically equipped to share the spotlight” than Jimmie. Hendrik Willem criticized Jimmie’s choice of clothes as he
80
Va n L o o n
pursued a young blonde he had met in a New York bookstore. He even went so far as to send Jimmie to Reno to get a divorce. However, once the blonde declined his overtures to become the next Mrs. van Loon, he asked Jimmie to return to Antioch to close out the house and to rejoin him in Baltimore; meanwhile, Hansje returned to his mother.21 Hearing of these developments, Eliza Bowditch sympathized with Jimmie and offered her the hospitality of the Ithaca house. From Baltimore, Jimmie replied to Hendrik Willem’s first wife that the temporary problems she and her husband recently had were “probably caused by sitting all winter in the mud, rain and solitude of Yellow Springs. However, all is again serene. Anyone with Han’s mental make-up is subject to such upheavals, and while they are damnably upsetting at the time, they do seem to pass over. This being the first one, I took it very seriously, but the next time, I shall know better what to do. You can’t have a man with both the temperament of an artist, and the placid stability of a banker, and [in her opinion] the former quality is more amusing than the latter, although one may have bad quarters-of-an-hour at times.”22 Frustrated that her ex-husband was finally enjoying monetary success, Eliza also hoped to grab a bigger share of his considerably improved situation. Van Loon made it clear that he would live up to his promise to take care of his two sons and make payments for their education, and he had voluntarily doubled her alimony payment, to $200 monthly but he refused to do anything more. He wrote Eliza, “You can hire all the lawyers in Kingdom Come and they will all tell you what mine told me, that you voluntarily divorced me and got rid of me as a bad investment [and] that you can not repent of investments if after selling them they show an upward trend.”23 The Story of Mankind reached another plateau of success when in June 1922 the American Library Association awarded it the John Newbery Medal for “the most distinguished contribution to American literature for children” written in 1921. The brand-new honor, named after the eighteenth-century London bookseller John Newbery (who was credited for having been the first to give special attention to a literature specially for children), remains the highest accolade in American children’s literature. Staff correspondent G. Ellis Porter of the Baltimore Evening Sun enthusiastically commented that van Loon was “once again on top of a tower. Not the same tower from which he viewed the world” when he wrote his prize-winning volume, but “a very considerable and substantial one at that. Moreover, [the journalist claimed,] he stands there today in solitary grandeur. . . .” To emphasize that unique position of Baltimore’s new literary lion, the Evening Sun carried a big picture of van Loon and his medal with the article.24 The publication and subsequent immense popularity of H.G. Wells’s Outline of History and van Loon’s Story of Mankind set the tone for what one cultural
The Breakthrough
81
historian has called “the ‘outline’ craze of the 1920s and 1930s.” The massive technological changes of the early twentieth century, epitomized by the automobile and the motion picture, had resulted in a society with an increasing professional specialization of knowledge. To make sense of this new world, many Americans turned to books to catch up culturally, regain a unified perspective, and provide themselves with an adequate level of “civilization.” This democratization of knowledge acquisition in a consumer society, aimed at a wide public of “average intelligent readers,” became known as middlebrow culture. The new genre of outline books for this market emphasized the unity of knowledge, rejected specialization, and combined authority and intimacy. The authors of these books—for instance, Lewis Mumford in The Story of Utopias (1922), Will Durant in The Story of Philosophy (1926), and Charles and Mary Beard, in The Rise of American Civilization (1927)—were generalists who had much confidence in their readers’ ability to understand what they had to say, as well as in the audience’s “improvability.” These popularizers wrote in a style that was factual, uncomplicated, unambiguous, and devoid of bare generalizations. Their vocabulary, as James Steel Smith observed, “was remarkably uncolorful; like plain window glass, it was meant to be seen through” (van Loon’s occasional flights into eccentricity and dramatic pose were an exception).25 Probably the most successful outline writer was Will Durant. Although his high-minded approach was markedly different from van Loon’s occasional informalities, both men ultimately shared a common goal of satisfying a thirst for knowledge of many millions of Americans, especially those who had not had the chance to go to college. Durant saw the outline writers as “merchants of light.” About van Loon and his Story of Mankind he remarked in retrospect that the Dutch-American historian had written his book “with a pen in one hand, a pencil in the other, and a twinkle in his eye.” Not caring for dignity, van Loon had gone “laughing down the centuries.” And, as a consequence of the adults’ surreptitiously reading the book they had bought for their children, Durant argued, “The world was becoming scandalously informed about history.”26 As van Loon reflected in the mid-1930s on Durant’s and his own success, “We realized that we lived in a world which had completely changed its masters. In order to save civilization from chaos, it was necessary that the new masters should know certain things which until then had been the privileged possession of the few. . . . We carried this necessary information to this new public and in such a form and shape that it could understand this new knowledge and enjoy it. Neither of us, I am quite sure, ever expected that we would set all the hearth-fires burning brightly, but hundreds of thousands of little lamps were lighted where only darkness had been before and in all sorts of unexpected places.” In his foreword to The Story of Mankind van Loon had
82
Va n L o o n
written that “there is no elevator to reach the top of the mighty Tower of Experience—History—and get the benefit of the full view.” But Columbia University scholar John Erskine was of the opinion that the outlines of the 1920s did indeed serve as elevators, giving its readers that full view.27 At age forty and twenty years after his arrival in the United States, van Loon had made a name in his adopted country as one of the “merchants of light” and secured a position as columnist at a prestigious newspaper. Van Loon optimistically faced the future and he made plans to show off his Newbery Medal in his native country and be honored there as well. But that expectation would prove to be a bridge too far.
Chapter 9
The Prince of Popularizers (1922–1928) During the 1920s the reputation of the iconoclastic journalist H.L. Mencken reached its pinnacle. Perhaps for the first time in American cultural life, a critic, rather than a novelist or a poet, was the most influential American writer. Called by Walter Lippmann in 1926 “the most powerful personal influence on this whole generation of educated people,” another journalist dubbed the self-taught linguist “the nearest thing to Voltaire that America has ever produced.” Of course, there were negative opinions too. Some considered him to be “the most universally hated man in the United States” or “the Genghis Khan of the Campus.” As contemporary author Louis Kronenberger put it, “Mencken came in like a lion. [He] liked the noise and fun of battle [and] launched a massive attack on everything this country held inviolate, on most of what it held self-evident.” In any case, Mencken was a phenomenon. A recent biographer has even called him “our nay-saying Whitman” and compared Mencken’s writing in the early 1920s to Walt Whitman’s “Song of Myself.”1 Even before Hendrik Willem van Loon joined Mencken on the staff of the Baltimore Sun, they were regularly exchanging letters on topics ranging from postwar international politics to the problems of a writer working in a nonnative tongue. Van Loon asked Mencken, “Can one ever learn a foreign language well enough to turn it into a subconscious part of one’s own conscious self?” (In a letter to a British friend, after having read a book by Rudyard Kipling, Hendrik Willem despaired that he could ever write as well, “for my brain is still full of Dutch and it hangs like spiderwebs from the high dome of my head and however much I try to clean it, not even twenty maids with twenty mops could do it.”) Mencken, in his posthumously published
84
Va n L o o n
memoir My Life as Author and Editor, observed that van Loon’s writing seemed to him “to be a bit strained and stilted,” and Mencken doubted that “he ever really became at home in the English language.” In Mencken’s view van Loon became more fluent in English when he got older, “but he never quite mastered it.”2 Mencken’s reservations about van Loon put the Dutchman in distinguished company, as Mencken was also harsh about such contemporary authors as Theodore Dreiser, Sinclair Lewis, and F. Scott Fitzgerald. Although Mencken considered van Loon to be “a man of considerable information and decided intelligence,” he also thought that “there was nevertheless something cheap about him” and he especially disliked van Loon’s “habit of barging into my room without notice” when both were at the Algonquin Hotel in New York; this, according to Mencken, had led to sometimes embarrassing situations. For that reason he “held aloof from him.”3 Hendrik Willem van Loon’s debut in the Baltimore Sun on 10 May 1922 was front-page news and during the first ten days the column’s heading “H.v.L.” was followed by the explanation “Being a column of personal opinion written and drawn especially for The Sun by the man who looked at the world from the top of the tower and then wrote The Story of Mankind.” Van Loon introduced his first column with Horatius’s motto “Why should one not tell the truth with a smile?” In addition, he confessed to his readers that he did not claim to know everything—in fact he knew “darned little”—and that he would be grateful to “those of our readers who set us straight.” On 21 May, a day that the column did not appear, the newspaper featured a poetic tribute by Max Martindale called “HvL”:
All hail to the glory of Nietzsche Who sang of the new Superman! For Him, the baboon frisked away from its dune And became just a poor Also-ran, For Him, the birth-pangs out of chaos, Creation of Sun and of Moon— All humankind verges, alone He emerges! Sing HENDRIK WILLEM VAN LOON! He was born in the lowlands of Holland Four decades ago. Yaw, Mijnheer, He lifted his head, in his small trundlebed, And he called for a sandwich and beer. The food of the great did sustain him, And Seven League Boots were his shoon. The crash of the spheres soothed his infantile ears! Sing HENDRIK WILLEM VAN LOON!
The Prince of Popularizers
85
Wouldst bathe in the waters of Eden? Wouldst see what old Caesar has seen? Wouldst cry “Atta-boy” while young Helen of Troy Eats an apple, and turns Paris green? Then hark! The Pied Piper of History Will make them all dance to his tune! He lights n’ Pomona and smites his Corona— Sing HENDRIK WILLEM VAN LOON! He sits in the Top of the Tower, While mankind slinks nervously by, He peers far and wide through the gay countryside, Seeing all with his Periscope Eye, Hearing all with his Radio Ear From morning till late afternoon— Behold! He has won his place in the Sun! What more can be done, H. van Loon?
Over the next year, “The Pied Piper of History” covered a wide range of topics in his column. Often van Loon dealt with topics from daily life but he also discussed domestic and international politics and such matters as the cultural dominance of New York over other big cities in the United States, and the American educational system. In an open letter to the president he once argued in favor of the release of political prisoners who had been a victim of the war hysteria. He used the column to express his criticisms of Prohibition, intolerance toward dissenting views of society and prejudices against race, as well as of the epitome of 1920s’ American industrialism, Henry Ford. As he explained to his readers, “Henry and I don’t get along well. Ever since he called my particular job ‘bunk’ I have felt that we never could be good friends again.” Van Loon described Ford’s newspaper, The Dearborn Independent, as “a stupid sheet, badly printed and miserably edited.”4 On 3 June he wrote about the subject of American culture and its lack of confidence vis-a-vis European culture. “The superficial European observer who regards America merely as a polyglot boarding house where people scramble furiously after material gain is wrong, dead wrong. Our civilization may at first have a certain resemblance to the whirlpool of the Niagara river. But that whirlpool is going somewhere and it is going rapidly in a certain very definite direction. So are we as a nation. . . . But in most forms of art and letters and philosophy we seem to be unable to get rid of our European complex. We still have a devout admiration for the language which our English neighbors call the ‘Mother Tongue.’ When Mencken preaches emancipation and tells us that we possess a mighty treasure in our own American language we regard him with suspicion. . . . When other iconoclasts . . . boldly come forward and state that we are a new race with entirely new problems and an
86
Va n L o o n
entirely new set of civic and personal ideals, we feel that such sentiments are not quite right. . . . It is a curious thing, but in this vague but unmistakable movement of and for a more national expression of our own national consciousness the people who were born in foreign lands may yet become the leaders. The reason, it seems to us, is simple. They see things a bit more clearly. They are forever comparing. Underneath this turbulent flow of new life across the mighty plains of the North American continent they notice certain things which their tired eyes failed to discover in the stagnant waters of the older European civilization.” In his attitude toward immigrants, van Loon showed some ambivalence. In one column he wrote compassionately that “the average immigrant is neither a saint nor a devil. He is very tired. He is pathetically thankful for the smallest evidence of personal kindness. Above all, he is hopelessly bewildered [at] a strange and incomprehensible America which fills [his] trembling heart with awe and fear and with a great deal of doubt.” Yet in another column, only two months later, he fulminated against “the horde of new arrivals” who in his view abused the American language and he accused his fellow Americans of a passive attitude toward this development as they left their own language “to the mercy of the barbarian illiterates.” The whole matter, he wrote, was left to the schoolteacher. “When she tells the bright little boys what fine things words are the answer is: ‘Forget it. My father don’t speak no English. He makes twice as much as you do.’ And so nothing will be done.”5 In two other columns van Loon contemplated the results of the war and expressed his pessimism about the European situation after Versailles and especially the situation in Germany. “The war has not brought about that Paradise on Earth that was to be so firmly founded upon the fourteen Pillars of Wilsonian Faith. It has brought hunger and pestilence and assassination. It has brought the curse of International Conferences, which no one takes seriously any longer, and while it has destroyed the old dispensation it has failed to bring us the new religion of the Brotherhood of Man. . . . The masses are adrift, and if we are not careful they will follow the lead of some very dangerous pilots. . . . They feel that they did not get what they were promised. They were told that they were to live in a new and better world. They find themselves in a worse one.” “In due time something new will be erected amidst the ruins of the old order. But the next few years will see political conditions compared to which the architectural chaos of the builders of Babel was mere child’s play.”6 On 8 August van Loon wrote that he was glad to have become an American citizen: “I have lived just one-half of my life in Europe and one-half in America. The conversion in my particular case was very slow. I had to become a good American in spite of the professional Americanizers. . . . When I think of our vast continent and the bungling stupidity of the third-rate minds that have hoisted themselves into the seats of the rich and the mighty,
The Prince of Popularizers
87
and when I think that within these borders there live more intelligent and delightful and courageous and charming men and women than I have ever found anywhere else . . . , I am grateful that I too belong to a commonwealth where a century of ‘grab as grab can’ has not been able to destroy a generosity of hearts and mind which stands unparallelled in the records of time. . . . [With] all our flag-waving and all our gaseous oratory about our biweekly heroes we still retain a kindly feeling toward our neighbors. We steal each other’s dollars and when our pockets are filled we turn them inside out for the benefit of the starving Roossian or Eytalian or Austrian and we laugh rather shyly and we are a bit ashamed of ourselves, but in one way or another the starving Roossian or Eytalian or Austrian gets fed and he shall probably continue to be fed as long as he has a tummy-ache and hollers loud enough to let us hear that he is in distress.” Baltimore’s summer heat made van Loon long for a change of climate and on 12 August he announced that he would temporarily cease his column to travel. From 16 September to 15 November the Sun printed van Loon’s illustrated reports on his tour of Norway, Sweden, and Denmark in which he wrote about the history, geography, and culture of these northern European countries. After his travels through Scandinavia, van Loon spent some time in Germany and in four Sun articles he reported about the political, social, and economic misery he encountered there. In his last report from Europe, written in Amsterdam on 1 November and published in the Sun two weeks later, van Loon stated “as emphatically as possible” that Germany depressed him “more thoroughly than anything I have ever experienced or ever hope to experience. . . . A heavy curtain of gloom hangs across the country.”7 While in the Netherlands, Hendrik Willem—who shortly afterward wrote to a Dutch friend that there was no excuse in the world for not being happy with Jimmie as she was the most sensible and friendly woman he had ever met—introduced his wife to his relatives. They were far from enthusiastic, especially disliking her boyish bob and the fact that she smoked cigarettes “all day long.” But what disappointed van Loon most was the lack of recognition accorded him in his native country—it reminded him of his father, the kill-joy of his youth who had died that March. The Dutch were unaware of his success in the United States and had certainly not heard of his Newbery Medal. He was glad, therefore, that on 4 November he could sail back to New York. To ease Hendrik Willem’s disappointment, before the ship sailed Jimmie typed a three-word letter, “YOU ARE FAMOUS,” and put it in an envelope addressed to “Hendrik Willem van Loon—America.” The letter was punctually delivered at their Baltimore home, showing clearly that, unlike in the Netherlands, in the United States van Loon indeed was a celebrity.8
88
Va n L o o n
One wonders how comfortable van Loon’s bed was on board the new ocean liner Volendam, since this had been the subject of one of the tall columnist’s funniest pieces. For most of mankind the problem of retiring is a very simple one. . . . But to those of us who exceed the human timberline the process is intricate and demands a thorough knowledge of higher mathematics, calculus and trigonometry, not to mention a profound understanding of the principles which underlie non-Euclidian geometry. The average bed in this world is 5 feet by 1.5. I need at least 7 feet by 4 to be entirely comfortable. When I ask for something like that hotel porters wax very funny and suggest I hire a hall or a coalyard, and as I am not enough of a horse to sleep standing on all fours, I must take whatever I am offered. . . . Once I leave dry land and intrust my soul to the waves, the problem of the body begins in all seriousness. The little hammock in the Pullman berth is a palace compared to the average bunk of the average cabin. If I could sleep in installments, it would be all right. Just now the United States lines are making herculean efforts to get passengers. They show large pictures of Niagara, depicting tons and tons and tons of water being forced through a narrow gorge, and invite the natives of Europe to go and experience the thing for themselves in “das Freie Amerika.” Their advertisement does not interest me. The moment they shall say “We offer all passengers a decent bed and we have done away with the old sardine box” they can count upon one faithful patron.
In another column he again referred to the difficulties he encountered as a consequence of his massive physique. This time, he told his readers that visiting a theater was far from a pleasant experience for him as “Most seats in most theaters were built for children. Once in, we never know how to get out without the help of a derrick. We like to give pleasure to our neighbors, but it is unfair that we should compete with the regular show. As a rule we wait until all the other spectators are gone and then, with the kind assistance of a few stage hands, we return to a standing posture.”9 Back in New York van Loon made some very bold statements about the European situation in a lecture at Town Hall. In his view Europe was “like a lunatic asylum” or “an exceedingly bad-bred dog kennel.” He had found out that “the average European mind [was] in a state of absolute and dumb despair. . . . These four horrible years of peace are in many ways worse than the horrible years of war. . . . A terrible apathy has overtaken the Old World.” In short, van Loon said that the “European civilization [was] going rapidly and entirely to pieces.” Van Loon blamed the historians for their overemphasis on nationalism which, in his view, was the main source of Europe’s misery. Their “mischievous insistence upon what they call ‘the correct scientific attitude’
The Prince of Popularizers
89
had been taken far too seriously.” It were therefore “the historians who should be shot, not the monarchs,” he declared. In the dark and turbulent European situation he saw England as “the only ray of light.” He thought that not much could be done about the present situation but to have patience. He warned his audience that “The trouble with America is that it is always looking for solutions.” A few months later in his Sun column he argued in favor of a U.S. foreign policy of aloofness: “In international matters we are not our brother’s keeper. We are helpless before the suicidal mania of the continental powers. Before we intend to put in the sprinkling system of a new and workable League of Nations we intend to wait until the ruins of old Europe shall have grown cold. . . . Why not declare that we shall allow our neighbors to find salvation after their own sweet fashion and that their domestic affairs are none of our concern?”10 In New York van Loon stayed at the Algonquin, the home of the famous literary Round Table. Sinclair Lewis’s wife Grace wrote in her memoir that van Loon, with his indifference for drinking, was “an anomaly among the writers of his time” and therefore never “one of the boys.” Though not belonging to the Round Table, van Loon frequented the Algonquin whenever he was in New York. In one of his Sun columns he praised the Algonquin’s owner, Frank Case, for having turned the dining room of his hotel into a literary “salon” and in another column he referred to the Algonquin restaurant as the place where “within a single hour . . . more little ideas” are being peddled than anywhere else in the United States.11 Van Loon resumed his “H.v.L.” column on 25 November. On 4 December he told his readers that he always had a “sincere admiration for the man who can ‘cuss’ better than we” and as the London New Statesman made “a specialty of that particular form of literary expression,” van Loon quoted extensively from a review in that weekly of the English edition of his Story of Mankind. The British reviewer tore the book completely to pieces and concluded that for him it was “impossible to imagine a more ghastly tribute to the intellectual delinquencies of a nation” than the success of this book in America. Van Loon carried “the scalp . . . triumphantly home as a warning to others.” This devastating review did not express the general opinion on the book in Britain, however; the reception was overwhelmingly positive.12 In his 26 July 1922 column van Loon explained to his readers Charles Darwin’s evolution theory and argued that the criticism of William Jennings Bryan and many fundamentalists of that theory was “pathetic” and a “storm in the theological teapot.” The following 26 March, van Loon confronted criticism from a group of Minnesota fundamentalists on his Story of Mankind. In a resolution they had not only strongly rejected the theory of evolution, but called the works of van Loon and H.G. Wells “unworthy of a place in a university class room and unfit for our public schools.” Hendrik
90
Va n L o o n
Willem’s response was to express “a spark of gratitude” to these “Baptist Babbitts” for paying him a great compliment. “They have named me together with H.G. Wells, for whom I retain that admiration which borders very closely upon veneration. From a mere obscure newspaperman (with an humble interest in history) they have elevated me to the rank of a little martyr.” Van Loon continued, speaking of himself in the third person as someone worthy of association with other wise men whom conservatives had once attacked (like Galileo and Newton): “Now he has been turned into a firm oak that must weather the storms of popular criticism. Overnight he has gained great glory. He has been publicly denounced.” Nevertheless, he was doing his best to hold on to his modesty; he had already informed his readers that he was writing a new book, The Story of the Bible, “A strange job which asks for a great deal of humility.”13 In his posthumously published memoir Report to Saint Peter, van Loon recorded that his allusions to the evolutionary theory in The Story of Mankind kept the book off school library shelves in more than a dozen states, including the Baltimore public library (according to his son, the book was forbidden in the public libraries of twenty-four states), and that even more than twenty years after the book had come out hardly a week went by without his receiving letters blaming him for his “loose Darwinian morals.” As van Loon wrote in his Sun column, “Everywhere it is the same dispute, based firmly upon ignorance and prejudice. . . . A hundred years from now Bill Bryan and his followers will be a minor exhibit in some handbook on Ancestral Idiocies. Meanwhile we have to tolerate them as best we can. They are really very nice people. They are just dumb.”14 The antievolution movement came to a climax in the July 1925 Scopes trial in Dayton, Tennessee. Local biology teacher John T. Scopes had deliberately lectured on evolution to challenge a recently adopted Tennessee law that forbade “any teacher in any of the universities, normal, and all other public schools of the state, to teach any theory that denies the story of the divine creation of man as taught in the Bible and to teach instead that man has descended from a lower order of animals.” The trial brought Chicago agnostic Clarence Darrow, America’s most famous defense lawyer, and William Jennings Bryan to face off, as one historian put it, “against one another in one of the most dramatic confrontations of the twentieth century in a suffocatingly hot courtroom.” Mencken, himself anti-fundamentalist par excellence, covered the event with great excitement for the Baltimore Evening Sun. Earlier he had given the American language the term “Bible Belt” and on this particular occasion he coined the label “Monkey trial.” Although the trial ended in a hollow victory for the fundamentalists, the movement quickly subsided after Bryan died a couple of days later. As historian William Leuchtenburg observed, the movement was in fact “a war of country and small town against
The Prince of Popularizers
91
the city, a war largely centered in the South” and the antievolutionists “were defeated, overwhelmed by the tide of cosmopolitanism.”15 In his 16 April 1923 column van Loon returned to a favorite theme when he asked, “Is there another nation in this world which prides itself upon the fact that it is composed of lowbrows?” Looking at newspaper ads and reading stories about what politicians said about themselves—hiding the fact that they had had a good college education—made it very plain to van Loon that “The hero of these millions is a simple person without any advantage.” He could somehow understand “this simulation of plain virtues” by politicians running for public office and needing the votes of their constituents, and maybe the embittered Midwestern editor who had told him recently that “In our part of the Republic thinking is considered un-American” was right. Yet, he wondered, “Why this insistence upon something which is a direct insult to the divine intelligence which created Man after its own Image?” Van Loon had studied the lowbrow very carefully and found him “always arrogant. He is intolerant and cruel in his hatred of those who possess certain qualities from which he himself is forever excluded. Undoubtedly he has been a victim of his own inferior consciousness since the beginning of time. But in the olden days he used to hide his shame. . . . Some queer turn of the wheel has brought him to the foreground. He organizes parades and hires brass bands and bribes Bill Bryan to lecture to him upon the perfections of Homo Insapiens.” When one of his readers sent him a letter asking him to write “an article on the [Baltimore] mayoralty campaign if you are such a good historian [and] beat Mencken to it,” van Loon had replied that such a thing could not be done. “In the first place we do not intend or hope or expect to ‘beat Mencken at it’ for the eminently good reason that the learned Doctor is a much better hand at that sort of thing than we can ever aspire to be. . . . For the moment we are perfectly contented to keep our little reportorial job and spend our spare moments studying the methods of our Beelzebub of the Babbitts.” As for the mayoralty campaign, there again “Dom Henrico Luis” would have a great advantage over him being born and raised in “the Respublica Baltimorensis” and knowing much better than he could ever hope to the history and political culture of Baltimore and feeling instinctively “the hidden meaning of the slightest gesture made by the honorary Pallbearers Guild.” Therefore, van Loon argued, “it would be folly for me to attempt to say anything about local politics.”16 Apparently van Loon was not that “perfectly contented to keep [his] little reportorial job” as he had written on 23 April, because the last “H.v.L.” column was printed only four days later. Without any announcement by the columnist himself or the editors, van Loon disappeared from the Sun. According to Mencken van Loon’s column “made very little impression in Baltimore” and
92
Va n L o o n
he thought van Loon was not giving that job the attention it needed. Because of the success of The Story of Mankind van Loon, in Mencken’s view, spent not much time in Baltimore. Yet he recalled that van Loon several times played the violin at Mencken’s Saturday Night Club and thought that van Loon “was not a violinist of much skill but he did well enough.” Van Loon’s younger son confirmed Mencken’s view on van Loon’s being often on the road. He wrote that his father, “more restless than ever” and making not much progress with his Story of the Bible, was “quickly disgusted with Baltimore [and] accepted any and all lecture engagements.”17
On 28 April, the day after his last column appeared, Hendrik Willem and Jimmie van Loon sailed for England. The British authorities had granted him a visa for the first time since his wartime articles made him persona non grata in the United Kingdom. In May and June van Loon and his wife stayed in Cambridge and London, where he completed the first draft of The Story of the Bible and met a number of British publishers. From the Hotel Metropole in London, van Loon in a letter to Mencken reported on Jimmie’s drinking habit. For him as a nondrinker, it was becoming a source of constant irritation and worry. “Jimmie keeps a bottle of gin on tap. But what can I do? That woman is the only living being who can read my corrected manuscript. As long as I write she has her job and she buys so much gin that I must write to make money for the distillers.”18 By late June the van Loons traveled across the Channel to the Netherlands where they settled in the Abdij Hotel in Middelburg. Hendrik Willem recalled the peaceful atmosphere of Zeeland’s capital city from his bicycle trips when he spent summer vacations in that province at his uncle Henri Hanken’s farm. Of course, Hendrik Willem and Jimmie paid a visit to Henri Hanken and in following weeks they frequently visited nearby Veere, a painters’ paradise. Like so many people before and after them, the van Loons fell in love with Veere and resolved that they would return. A prosperous port in the late Middle Ages, Veere had shrunk to a sleepy village with fewer than a thousand people by the 1920s and had the reputation of a dead town.19 Though Veere was regularly visited by a number of seasonal artists, only a few of them lived there year-round. One of them was Lucy van Dam van Isselt and it was with her that the van Loons became fast friends. The only other guest in their hotel that summer also became part of the van Loon entourage in Veere over the years. Frits Philips was the nephew of Anton Philips, the founder of the world-famous electronics company. Middelburg physician Dr. Charles Koch, who a week after van Loon’s arrival treated him for a kidney stone, also became a close friend. The van Loons very much enjoyed spending
The Prince of Popularizers
93
the rest of the summer in Middelburg and surroundings where Dutch, American, and English friends visited them regularly.20 In another letter to Mencken, van Loon praised the scenery and the local inhabitants, who at times seemed “five hundred years behind the times.” He also reported that he was working on “a trilogy of a sort-of-Erasmiancommon-sense. First Mankind showing the mess, then the Bible showing how the mess came. Now the third one nobly entitled ‘Laughing Philosophers. The Story of the Struggle for the Freedom of Thought.’ ” By the end of July van Loon had sent the finished manuscript of The Story of the Bible off to his publisher, Horace Liveright, and he became increasingly bored and restless. At the end of the summer, the van Loons moved on, first visiting other Dutch cities new to Jimmie and then, at her insistence, going to Paris. Hendrik Willem had never been to the French capital before, and they thoroughly enjoyed its delights. After a trip to Venice and one last week in the Netherlands, they set sail for America on 12 December. Right after Christmas Jimmie “scouted for houses [and] found one in Westport.”21 Meanwhile, Boni and Liveright had published The Story of the Bible in late October. In the foreword van Loon once again addressed his two sons, telling them that he had written the book because he thought they ought to know more about the Bible than they did. He added that he was not “defending or attacking a cause” but hoped that his account of the Bible would make their lives “more full of understanding, of tolerance and of love for that which is good and beautiful, and therefore holy.” Whereas van Loon had found it “comparatively easy” to write about the Old Testament, which he described as “a national Jewish scrap-book [containing] histories and legends and genealogies and love poems and psalms, classified and arranged and reclassified and rearranged without any regard for chronological order or literary perfection,” the New Testament had been more difficult for him. Centering on Jesus, “who asked nothing of life and gave all,” his life story was a most interesting one and van Loon promised his sons to give them “a very simple account of his life as I see it, not a word more and not a word less. For that, I am sure, is the way he would like to have me tell it.”22 The year before, van Loon had suggested similar reasons for writing this book, telling the New York Times “Books and Authors” column “that large numbers of our children are growing up without any moral or religious code whatsoever. When the children read my story of the Bible, I hope they will be kinder to the kitty! I mean I hope they will be kinder to every living thing, that they will love better—love each other and the world.”23 Times critic Thomas L. Masson characterized the book as “essentially a listen-my-children-and-you-shall-hear book, a book for boys, a just-as-goodas Bible, a campfire Bible without the incentive after reading it to read
94
Va n L o o n
the Bible itself.” According to Masson the author was “not so much concerned with the maker or the original as he [was] to advertise it, to have the boys know more ‘about’ it and to make it clear that he is only discussing its machinery and not its maker.” The reviewer thought that the way the author dealt with the Bible stories, “waving [the miracles] away with a beautiful gesture,” was “a fascinating performance, leaving us in doubt as to where reality leaves off and the illusion begins.” His conclusion was that van Loon had “not drawn upon his admirable creative faculties enough to make his inaccuracies a work of art, but, according to a well-known formula, [had] produced a saxophone Bible which . . . will be swallowed by the boys who read it as if it were the gospel truth.” Strangely enough this reviewer saw only boys as an audience for this book. Apparently The Story of the Bible was not for girls.24 Critical reaction to the new book was decidedly mixed. The Literary Review preferred the “imaginative” pictures over the “facile and amusing story,” and the best Time could say was that it would be a popular Christmas present.25 The fundamentalists had geared up to attack van Loon’s version of the Holy Book and protests over The Story of the Bible continued over the winter. In February 1924, the Detroit Free Press informed its readers that “They are still storming over” it and that “Every now and then we see sorrowful reviews which complain among other things, that the book is ‘grotesque and wholly unworthy,’ but sales keep right on despite sanctimonious protests.” The impact of the protests is hard to judge since van Loon presented two sharply different sales reports that month. He told Mencken that “The Bible has come to a complete standstill. . . . Critics who liked the book were warned by their editors that they wrote for a church-going public and must not praise it. Booksellers refuse to merchandise the book because their pious customers refuse to go near the counter where the book reposes.” Three weeks later he was telling Ferris Greenslet of Houghton Mifflin, “The Bible is doing nicely. The first fundamentalist blast has come to an end. . . . The book seems to have lived through the not inconsiderable barrage of the Bryan cohorts.”26 As soon as Hendrik Willem and Jimmie set foot on U.S. soil after their European trip, he struck back at his fundamentalist critics. In a New York Times story published on Christmas, he characterized most clergymen as “ignorant”—even those who had received college and seminary education— and compared the fundamentalists of his day with those in the Middle Ages who considered learning Greek a heresy. Dulling no punches, he said, “The Fundamentalist doesn’t want anybody to learn anything. Today most of our clergymen do not get their education in the seminaries, but get their training in the Y.M.C.A. and their learning from the correspondence courses of
The Prince of Popularizers
95
William J. Bryan. Many of the churches do not want their clergymen to go to seminaries. They fear education.” Three weeks later, van Loon continued the attack in an article he himself wrote for the Times. He preferred “the Laughing Philosophers”—Erasmus, Montaigne, Voltaire, Spinoza, Cervantes, Socrates—“the whole honorable company of spiritual pioneers [who] knew to smile and who were the only people who have ever accomplished anything of lasting value” over “the dismal doctrine of the zealots.” Although it was not mentioned in the Gospels, van Loon was convinced that Jesus, too, “possessed the sublime gift of the smile that understands all things” and “thoroughly despised those qualities which we now head together as Puritanism.”27 Overall, the reviews of The Story of the Bible were more positive than negative. Even if the book did not sell as well as The Story of Mankind, it definitely was not the “flop” that Gerard Willem dubbed it. The book was reprinted every decade since 1923, most recently in 1985.28 When van Loon’s two recent best sellers were published in Dutch translation in his native country in 1923 and 1924, the Dutch response showed once more that he was increasingly distanced from his fatherland. The Middelburgsche Courant and the daily Voorwaarts in Rotterdam both gave The Story of Mankind positive reviews. However, Het Vaderland in The Hague dismissed this Dutch translation and the Utrecht-based Catholic newspaper Het Centrum called it “unreliable and harmful,” recommending it be kept away from youngsters.29 Although van Loon was used to this kind of fundamentalist criticism, what really hurt him was a review by the eminent historian Johan Huizinga. Because of its “pseudo-knowledge, platitudes and vulgarisms,” the book in Huizinga’s view was unsuitable for children and more geared toward grownups without any cultural background. Huizinga, who was already a scholar of American history (and not a particularly admiring one), found the success of van Loon’s book in the United States “a bad omen for our civilization.”30 The Dutch reviews of The Story of the Bible were even harsher. The theological editor of the Algemeen Handelsblad, for instance, flatly condemned the book and accused the author of a complete lack of “knowledge, seriousness, and refinement.” Here, and with Huizinga’s critique, a Dutch-American observed that any “cultural kinship with Dr. Van Loon’s writings is quite strenuously denied by his racial kinsmen who are leaders of public opinion in Holland” and concluded that van Loon’s “Americanization” in these critics’ eyes was not seen as “a process of evolution or growth, such as other famous Dutchmen have undergone, but as a negative, reactionary process, in which the Dutch spirit of painstaking research, fair criticism, and reasonable objectivity, has tended to disappear.”31
96
Va n L o o n
Van Loon explained the rash of attacks in a letter to his old teacher Esther Bell-Robinson. “Holland takes it almost as a personal offense that I should, in a measure, have succeeded after I bade them farewell,” he contended. “I act upon the excellent burghers as a red rag before a steer.” And to George Burr, he wrote, “The Dutch historians are in such a rage at the success of my books among the younger generation in my native land that they can hardly express themselves in decent terms. Many don’t. Erasmus would have enjoyed it.” He even told his Dutch friends that their fellow countrymen were considered backward in the eyes of foreigners; they were “angry spiders” who worked with all their energy to do away with persons who really meant something in the world, such as Edward Bok. In another letter to his friend Aagje Moussault, the wife of an Amsterdam newspaperman, he confessed that he and Jimmie were both “enthusiastically disgusted with the whole attitude of [his] beloved Vaderland towards their distinguished lost son” and he compared coming to Holland with having to drive an unstable Ford car through a swamp.32 Van Loon’s criticism of the Dutch was not limited to his personal correspondence. From October 1922 until September 1924 he made himself heard by publishing a series of articles in the Dutch weekly De Amsterdammer. In these “American Letters” van Loon explained several aspects of the United States. He did this with pleasure, he wrote in the opening article of 28 October 1922, since his adopted country in his opinion was terra incognita in Holland. As a consequence of “Europe’s suicide,” van Loon argued, the United States had become the most powerful nation on earth and in order to understand the modern world, one had to understand America. This was not just another country, but a completely different and new civilization with the Americans having a different psyche than the Europeans. In his articles van Loon discussed such topics as America’s isolationist position toward Europe, Warren G. Harding’s personality, Prohibition and its negative consequences, and differences between the eastern and western states. Of course, he also wrote about his pet topic: the anti-Darwinist movement led by Bryan and the intolerance of the many religious fundamentalists, which he dubbed “the sour-grapes complex.” The “American Letters” also provided a venue for van Loon to regularly express his annoyance about the Dutch. Clearly with his own position in mind, he complained about the lack of recognition in the Netherlands of talented writers, philosophers, or painters, who had lived there in the past and had made Holland famous in the outside world, and he criticized the lack of appreciation in his native country for those Dutch persons who had become prominent U.S. citizens. He described Dutch history books, novels, and newspapers as an “unpleasant genre.” He observed that the low country near the sea almost collapsed of complacency. Those young Dutch people who
The Prince of Popularizers
97
wanted to start a new life in the United States certainly had a chance of success, he argued, provided they worked very hard and had stamina and humor—characteristics he hardly noticed in the Netherlands. And in case his readers had some ideal image of Michigan, where many Dutch settled, van Loon was quick to shatter that perception. He could only express himself in pejorative terms about the Dutch immigrants there. Their “backwardness” and servility toward their religious leaders made him characterize this group of fellow Dutch immigrants as the worst category of prejudiced primitive provincials.33 All his criticism of the Dutch notwithstanding, he would continue to visit his native country annually throughout the 1920s. In the meantime, however, from January 1924 on the van Loons had settled in Westport, Connecticut, which was very much in vogue among artists, musicians, and writers—a sort of rural Greenwich Village. Van Loon often quipped that “there was more adultery per square bed in Westport than any place east of the Rockies.” There was a hedonistic atmosphere and for all their sophistication most of his neighbors struck him as materialistic and provincial. The teetotaling, sexually frustrated, and cosmopolitan van Loon felt lonely and out of place. He wrote to Lewis Mumford about the severely diminished “spiritual life in this land” and the lack of a liberal party to which he could attach himself. To other friends he sometimes described himself as “the last of the old-fashioned liberals whom the Smithsonian wanted to buy for its collection.”34 Fortunately, there were a few like-minded people in Westport, notably the writer Van Wyck Brooks, an old friend whom he knew already from his work for The Seven Arts back in 1917. Theirs was a warm relationship based on mutual respect and admiration. In his Autobiography Van Wyck Brooks paid tribute to van Loon, calling him “a humanist” and giving him the honorary title “prince of popularizers.” Brooks compared van Loon’s popularity to that of Mark Twain’s, and assessed his mind as “almost as prodigal, impulsive and chaotic.” Though Brooks appreciated van Loon’s writings as “consistent unfoldings of his own special nature,” he nevertheless thought his friend’s “personality was more significant than his work, for [van Loon] usually wrote without tension, en pantoufles.” Although van Loon often managed to offend Brooks’s Westport acquaintances, Brooks was always ready to defend his Dutch friend “as an heir of the traditions of European magnanimity”—this despite their being so different on the surface (Lewis Mumford in his memoir described Brooks as “the perfect gentleman” and van Loon as a “Rabelaisian character” known for “his flood of coarse Dutch-flavored anecdotes” yet commented that they were “immensely at ease” with each other).35 Horace Liveright, van Loon’s publisher, had in mind a third volume, The Story of America, but in 1924 van Loon deferred (he would write that volume
98
Va n L o o n
later). He thought his genius functioned best when “there was an emotion somewhere” with which he could “fight stupidity”—a thing he called his “Erasmian job.” But in writing a history of America he felt “little to emote about.” Instead, as he explained to Burr and Mencken, he was picking up an idea he’d had the previous summer on a book about the struggle for the freedom of thought, tentatively called The Story of Tolerance. He did not expect it to be a commercial success, but to keep his self-respect he felt he had to write it. After that, he told a Dutch friend, he wanted to write a novel about Rembrandt’s life.36 In the summer of 1924, van Loon attended the national conventions of both political parties. His articles about the Republican gathering in Cleveland and the Democratic one in New York City reflect disappointment as well as boredom. Van Loon observed that both political parties, “dinosaurlike, have increased beyond the point where they can either walk or swim.” He was therefore very worried to see the rise of new parties, especially a Catholic party, which in turn would be followed “by a more intensive cult of the Ku Klux Klan bigotry, . . . fighting to preserve something which has already been doomed by history, throwing themselves into a lost cause.” In another article, he stated that the Klan was “in the hands of very incompetent and grossly ignorant citizens who have regarded their position merely as a source of revenue and have been totally indifferent to whatever good their association might do for the land they pretend to love with such lily-white ardor. As a result, wherever there is a fight between decency and indecency, tolerance and bigotry, greed and generosity, the Klan is found on the side of the oppressors, of the robbers, of the bigots.”37 After the conventions, Hendrik Willem went to Holland and Belgium for a holiday with his elder son, Hank (now seventeen and no longer answering to Hansel), Jimmie, and his old friend Louis Fuertes. He spent the remainder of the year writing Tolerance, keeping a small circle of friends informed about the ups and downs of the work. In December van Loon reported that he had managed in between to write and draw a small book, a philosophy of life in a fairy story called Wilbur the Hat, which was to appear in early 1925. “Of course,” he wrote to Fuertes, “I pay for the terrible exertion of four days and nights of brain-burning by weeks of pain, but anyway I will leave something to the kids.”38 When the new 110-page book came out in March, it was advertised by the publisher as an “extraordinary book [that would] take its place among the great satires of all times,” and by the author as “the only esoteric philosophy written since 473 B.C.” The reviews that followed, however, in general were lukewarm. Though the Saturday Review of Literature described Wilbur the Hat as “flippantly profound,” the New York Times called it “no more than a mildly amusing book,” while Mark Van Doren in The Nation wrote that
The Prince of Popularizers
99
“Mr. Van Loon has been too sure of himself, too jaunty with error and too slapdash with truth, to produce anything better than a primer of idealism.” It was obvious that the quality of this book suffered from the speed with which it was created. The same could be said, for that matter, about the articles he dashed off this year for such periodicals as The Forum, Hearst’s International and Cosmopolitan, The Nation, The Woman Citizen, and Harper’s Magazine.39 Shortly thereafter, the van Loons took a short working vacation in Europe, but they were back in America by mid-July 1925. A few days later some Westport friends gave a luncheon in their honor; among the other guests was Broadway actress Frances Goodrich. A Vassar College graduate, she was focused on her career after a divorce from an alcoholic actor. Hendrik Willem fell instantly in love with her. Starting the next day, van Loon bombarded her with love letters and telegrams—215 from August through December and promising her another 7,725 letters in the next twenty-five years. In midAugust, he wrote, “I have within three weeks poured down upon your poor head more than most women get in a lifetime.” He was trying to convince her that “I am essentially a one-woman man.” Hendrik Willem’s sexual fixation on women’s feet now found expression in “Little Fives,” a poem he wrote for Frances that included the phrase “You may buy all the pretty dresses you want and all the lovely things that shall make your own loveliness the greater but your feet, dear Heart, belong to me and they shall be garbed so fittingly that the flowers shall grow where you tread the ground.”40 It didn’t matter to him that Frances made it clear that she did not want to remarry or break up Hendrik Willem’s marriage. He assured her that his marriage to Jimmie had been a mistake—even while Jimmie was typing the final draft of Tolerance and wondering what was going on. Van Loon decided to go to Paris where, he was told, he could get a divorce “quickly and efficiently.” Frances tried to discourage him, telling him, “Go away and find other women and go on a series of debauches,” but this only heightened his ardor to make her his wife. Van Loon stopped off in London, to see his British publisher, and in The Hague. Once he got to Paris, he sent Frances yet another ardent love letter: “Damn it Frances, must I beat you to make you believe that this ain’t no common flirtation, that this love of mine for you is something that is going to go thundering through the ages whether you want it or not, that you have lighted a fire compared to which such trifles as the San Francisco fire . . . were backyard fires of dry leaves.”41 Accompanied by a friend, Lila Howard, Jimmie also sailed to France. Lila reported Jimmie tried to be stoic and cooperative but “cried her way across the Atlantic.” Upon arrival in Boulogne, they went to Paris. Before the divorce proceedings got very far, van Loon received a very polite but definitive no
100
Va n L o o n
from Frances. Switching gears, he made peace with Jimmie and set off on a tour of southern France and northern Italy with her and Lila. Nonetheless, he continued writing to Frances, telling her that nothing had changed. Goodrich cut off the correspondence in a frosty letter (the salutation was “Dear Doctor Van Loon”): “My real feelings you have never known. . . .” The Frances Goodrich affair had come to an end—so it seemed. On New Year’s Eve in 1925 Jimmie noted in her diary, “Han worked all day and was tired and cross. Louzy end to a louzy year”; the next day she penned, “The New Year was ushered in by a very mauvais quart d’heure and I wonder how it will go out.”42 Reviews of Tolerance, which dealt specifically with religious intolerance rather than tolerance, were appearing that fall and winter. The first half of the book described the development of intolerance among Christians and the second half offered biographical portraits of such fighters against intolerance as Erasmus, Rabelais, Montaigne, Spinoza, Voltaire, and Thomas Paine. Charles Willis Thompson in the New York Times was downright negative. He criticized the inappropriate title, was struck by van Loon’s “roughness in style, looseness of judgments, free and easy way of dealing with historical facts” and stated that in his view the book was written “in a cocksure and assertive manner.” Though the reviewers in the New York World and The Outlook were more positive, they both were of the opinion that the book could have been much better had the author given his subject more time. Charles Beard, in the New York Herald Tribune review, wrote that it did not pretend to be a scholarly work, but since the book was “full of wise sayings, amusing characterizations, diverting scenes, thrilling tales and stinging blasts,” he commended it to readers.43 To a Dutch friend van Loon described the review of his book in the “arch conservative” New York Times as “a blunt attack of a donkey”—thus displaying a lack of tolerance himself—and expected the book would not bring him much income in the United States, “the country of conservatism.” But surprisingly, this negative review gave him an incentive to work with a revitalized enthusiasm on the book Horace Liveright wanted him to do, The Story of America. He told Mencken and Gertrude Lane, the editor of the Woman’s Home Companion (who had bought serial rights for the volume), that he had never wanted to write this new book but while working on it “suddenly found that the whole damn thing was neatly rolled up in a corner of my brain and asked to be taken down.” To Burr he reported that writing his American history had made him discover not only how much the United States meant to him, but also “how many million miles away the present state of our civilization—the present triumph of matter over mind—is removed from the original promise of an empire at four cents an acre.” After finishing this book, he told Burr, “I shall leave history and farewell. For there are others who can do it infinitely better than I.”44
The Prince of Popularizers
101
But his task as a historian would not be finished at all. On the contrary, he had a mission to fulfill. In his chapter “History” in Harold Stearns’s 1922 book Civilization in the United States (a collection of essays by thirty American intellectuals, including Van Wyck Brooks, Lewis Mumford, and H.L. Mencken) van Loon not only criticized the American public for a lack of historical interest, but also the members of the historical profession: “No one has ever been able to convince the man in the street that time employed upon historical reading is not merely time wasted.” And that, was exactly the mission he saw for himself and that he described in one of his Sun columns as an “attempt to humanize history and to bring it within reach of the average thinking person.” To someone else Hendrik Willem confessed in 1926 that “history is an obsession with me. It is the only way in which I can try to make the world a little more ‘human,’ perhaps a more agreeable place of abode for those of us who think that this foolish planet might be a pleasant place of abode for a few more people than it is today.”45 Early in 1926, van Loon once more expressed his feelings of admiration for Erasmus. Not only was his fellow Rotterdammer his number-one choice on a list of van Loon’s favorite writers the New York Times published, but the newspaper quoted his praise of Erasmus for embodying “that spirit of an allencompassing humanity mixed with humor which seems to be the only cure for most of the evils of which our planet is suffering.” In Tolerance, Hendrik Willem wrote that the sixteenth-century humanist “like a gigantic beaver, worked day and night to finish that famous dam of reason and common sense which he vaguely hoped might stem the waxing tide of ignorance and intolerance.” In fact, as van Loon told a Boston newspaper a few years later, “All my life I seem to have been following in the footsteps of Erasmus.” And in an introduction he wrote in 1942 for Erasmus’s The Praise of Folly, he declared, “whenever I am asked in what kind of a world I would like best of all to live, my answer is all ready: ‘Turn me loose in a universe re-created after the Erasmian principles of tolerance, intelligence, wit, and charm of manner and I shall ask for no better.’ ”46 In June 1926 Waldo Frank profiled van Loon in The New Yorker. Frank, who had known van Loon since his lean years in Greenwich Village, described him in this profile as a very talented person who was doomed to be “always out of place.” Inside that large and fat body was “a bright little boy, tender and savagely egotistic.” Frank presented van Loon as a contradiction: “He is an aristocrat and scholar, who has spent his life in the scrimmage of mobs, of wars, of newspapers. He is a believer in caste, who has aimed his skill at caste’s destruction.” Frank argued this successful author was as delicate as his specially made tiny silver paint box, “the smallest complete water-color set in one of the largest waistcoats—of prairie-dimension—in New York.”
102
Va n L o o n
Surrounded by America and the modern world the historian was deep at heart “as medieval as the Holland burghers from whom he revolted are modern. This medieval splendor of the mind is what you find, in the tiny Castle of van Loon. . . . He may write of Tolerance, but what he needs is a château high on the rock of feudal privilege.” In his attacks on priests and kings, Frank concluded, van Loon was in fact reproaching them that they had “compelled a lord like himself to go slumming through a world he was born to master.”47 Later that summer, having finished the manuscript of America, van Loon became restless again. The “essentially a one-woman man” (so he had described himself to Frances Goodrich), rediscovered his former fiancé, Rene Gibbs Scudamore. Having finally left her alcoholic husband, Rene was living in a Gramercy Park hotel. This began another period of marital turmoil, once again spanning two continents. Persuading Rene to go to Paris for a quick divorce, he booked passage for her, a female friend, and himself on a ship to Holland. On the day of departure he also found time to write Frances, asking, “Why? Frances, why?” The three stayed a week in Holland after which Rene and her friend proceeded to Paris while van Loon went to visit Willem at the Swiss boarding school his son was now attending. He soon rejoined Rene, who had found a publicity job for the couturier Jacques Worth. Paris was a gathering place for expatriates, and van Loon was glad to see his old pal Sinclair Lewis there. But later, when Hendrik Willem and Rene saw Lewis in a restaurant for dinner, he was so drunk that they tried to avoid him by retiring to a far corner. When Lewis spotted them, he made a scene, and threatened to beat van Loon up. Ordered to leave the restaurant he yelled, “Who in hell does van Loon think he is? A writer?” The incident caused a breach in a longtime friendship that would not be mended until 1933.48 Meanwhile Hendrik Willem had cabled Jimmie to join him, and the couple spent the autumn in northern Italy and in Villefranche, near Nice. Rene even stayed with them for a week. Whatever each woman thought of the other—Jimmie feared that the long-deferred break was inevitable but hung on, hoping against hope, and Rene, ignorant of Frances, was prepared to marry Hendrik Willem when he was free—the situation was further complicated at the holidays when van Loon’s Christmas mail brought a vaguely conciliatory note from Frances. On New Year’s Day 1927, while Jimmie was still recovering from a terrible hangover, Hendrik Willem packed his suitcases and dashed off to the United States, leaving Jimmie behind on the Riviera.49 Frances turned down another marriage proposal and Hendrik Willem soon returned to Europe to shuttle between the other two women. Jimmie went on a Mediterranean cruise while he paid court to Rene in Paris. He nevertheless continued to write Frances, promising to love her humorously instead of tragically from now on. Then Hendrik Willem took Jimmie with
The Prince of Popularizers
103
him to The Hague and on to Berlin, where he was feted by his German publisher. There he gave his wife a pedigreed dachshund puppy, whom Jimmie christened Noodle. The couple parted ways briefly again, van Loon returning to Paris for a brief reunion with Rene, before they set sail for New York where they arrived by mid-April.50 While Hendrik Willem complained to Oswald Garrison Villard of The Nation that he had “the desperate feeling” that America was “one of the worst books and the most hopeless failures of the ages,” Jimmie spent the month of May correcting the book’s galleys. It was her last act of wifely assistance, for the next month Hendrik Willem moved out of the Westport house. A few days later, from the Brevoort Hotel in Greenwich Village, he sent Jimmie a letter telling her he wanted to be free and that he had contacted a Tucson lawyer who would engineer a Mexican divorce for that reason. Despite the ups and downs of the last two years, this news hit Jimmie hard. Referring to herself in the third person, she told the diary “The bottom dropped out of James’ world.” And a week later she wondered, “How can I bear it?” In another letter van Loon accused Jimmie of having “fought all the time against the idea of being a woman.” Had she spent more money on herself and given the effort to make their house “to look like something more than a workshop and a missionary home, . . . I would not have gone off into this slouch of despondency and this general state of nuttiness that drove me away.”51 Van Loon cabled Frances, who was in Little Compton, Rhode Island, that he was in a fragile state “bordering upon [the] verge of complete and total collapse.” At the suggestion of his elder son, Hank, who was studying architecture at Columbia University, he made plans to go to Paris to relax until the divorce came through. Before he sailed, Frances visited him, which lifted his spirits immensely. On the transatlantic passage, Hendrik Willem worked with revitalized energy on a new book project, Life and Times of Pieter Stuyvesant. In Paris van Loon walked Rene to work every morning, checked his mail for letters from Frances, and asked friends which of the two would make a better wife for him. At the same time he wrote Jimmie that he saw only unsuccessful marriages around him and therefore had decided not to marry ever again as “the thing is a terrible bondage to me.” In September Hendrik Willem returned from Paris to New York as a free man. Both Rene and Jimmie were flabbergasted the next month, after learning that on 11 October 1927, Hendrik Willem van Loon and Frances Goodrich were married in Elizabeth, New Jersey.52 By this time van Loon’s America (in later editions it was once more called The Story of America) had come out and the reviews were once again mixed. The reviewer in the New York Times, who missed the originality that should have made this van Loon’s best work, still expected this illustrated book to “stimulate a wider interest in American history.” The Yale Review characterized
104
Va n L o o n
the book as “refreshing and entertaining” while criticizing the author for “so often ignoring the findings of modern historical research”; it too hoped van Loon’s book would serve “to make Americans read their own history.” Even as The Nation told readers that there was “no resisting” America’s “jolly flings at hoary traditions, or its sweeping judgments of motives and acts, or its dramatic word-paintings of men and their ways,” it reminded them that van Loon was not a historian but one of the group of popularizers like Will Durant.53 Van Loon’s third marriage was a fiasco from the very start. It was termed a “companionate marriage” because the newlyweds, as an experiment, had decided to keep their own apartments—Hendrik Willem on East Ninth Street and Frances on East Fifty-Seventh Street. Van Loon, the flamboyant and romantic troubadour, wanted to show off his new wife in his favorite restaurants, but Frances preferred the company of her own theater friends, with whom her husband did not get along. Van Loon’s friends wondered how long he could stand his new wife’s uncivil behavior but during those first weeks he remained infatuated. Even so, he rebuffed a proposal from Frances to try to live together wherever he wanted in order to make their marriage a happy one, coldly replying, “I am satisfied with the present arrangement— i.e. separate apartments.” The novel van Loon–Goodrich ménage was closely monitored by the New York Times, which avidly tracked a burglary at Frances’s apartment in late November.54 The forty-eight blocks between their residences were very symbolic of the relationship. As a Christmas gift van Loon gave his wife a check of several hundred dollars in an envelope he had decorated in his characteristic humorous style. Frances tore both check and envelope to pieces before his and her mother’s eyes, declaring icily she was an independent woman who did not need his financial support. Her callousness made him escape her presence and on 14 January 1928 he celebrated his forty-sixth birthday without her and in the company of two close friends, journalist Lorena Hickok and literary historian and critic Carl Van Doren. A few weeks later Hendrik Willem asked Hank to get rid of the apartment and sailed to Italy, taking the advice of his friends who were concerned that his staying any longer with Frances would lead to his mental breakdown. Still, as his ocean liner left the New York harbor, Hendrik Willem held out hope in a letter to his third wife: “Somewhere in that pile of iron and stone is Frances—whom I love—I do want to be so good to you—I do want so much to make that adorable willful child happy—I am going to sit and think. I will find a way. This is the last until you get the first from the other side. Be well—be happy—whatever you want— whatever I have to give—is yours.”55 By April 1928, having thought about the hopelessness of the situation, van Loon was able to admit to Frances he had created the failure himself by
The Prince of Popularizers
105
imposing his love on her and ignoring the fact that from the very beginning it had not been a mutual affection, that—as he put it—he had never been “an integral part of [her] landscape.” It was clear to him that his playing “the husband-protector” and “the husband-lover” had only annoyed her and that his presence had only made her uncomfortable and their being together “an agony.” He not only accepted the marriage fiasco as a personal defeat but also explained it as “a conflict of different sorts of civilizations,” talking past each other but at least, he maintained, he had tried very hard to change and “would have become a terrible imitation of something American.” Given this situation he had now decided, he wrote Frances, to “keep on the bleak side of the ocean.” He doubted whether he would ever return to America.56 As a blessing for his hurt soul van Loon felt flattered that—even while not staying in the United States anymore—he was asked by Charles Beard to contribute a chapter on “Ancient and Medieval Civilizations” in his book Whither Mankind: A Panorama of Modern Civilization, which was to include chapters written by such eminent authors as Bertrand Russell, John Dewey, Lewis Mumford, and Carl Van Doren. The volume, as Beard put it in his preface, was “a challenge, not a summary of fragile dubiosities” and contrary to the pessimistic view of Spengler and others, aimed to present “a more cheerful outlook upon the future of modern civilization, without at the same time resorting to the optimism of the real-estate agent.”57 During the 1920s “outline craze,” the word “civilization” was very much in vogue and was used in numerous book and article titles. As cultural historian Warren Susman observed, “So much that was produced during the twenties can be seen and read in terms of a thinking that self-consciously considered itself a part of the issue of civilization and even as a technique or instrument involved somehow in sustaining, modifying, destroying, or creating ‘civilization.’ ” A year before his Whither Mankind Charles and Mary Beard published their best seller The Rise of American Civilization and van Loon had contributed a chapter to Harold Stearns’s 1922 Civilization in the United States. In 1926 van Loon wrote an introduction to a volume entitled What is Civilization? and gave as his personal view that “the highest civilization is that form of society which allows the greatest number of people to show the greatest amount of consideration for the physical happiness and spiritual comfort of the largest number of their neighbors.” But civilization, in the true sense of the word as he saw it, had not even begun: “Contrary to the generally accepted belief we are not ‘modern’ people, . . . we are not heirs to the glories of a noble past, but . . . we are the last off-shoot of prehistoric man.” He made the same point two years later: “mechanically we live in the year of grace 1928 while spiritually we are but little removed from our earliest ancestors. . . . We are but cave-dwellers going on a joy-ride in a Chevrolet.”58
106
Va n L o o n
Perhaps the most lasting effect of the popularizing movement was the establishment in 1926 of the Book-of-the-Month Club and of the Literary Guild of America. Both organizations offered the public twelve books a year at a reduced price, which were selected for the club members by a board of editors. Van Loon served on the editorial board of the Literary Guild whose editor-in-chief was Carl Van Doren. In a 1928 promotional publication of the Literary Guild van Loon explained to the American reader the Guild’s objective: “Heaven knows I am no rabid admirer of Things European. I know that promontory of Asia too well to sing its wholesale praises and hold it up as an example for the rest of the world. But in the matter of reading the truth must be confessed that Europe reads more, and more intelligently, than we do. We read fewer books, we own fewer books, than almost any other nation. . . . It is our avowed and serious purpose to encourage by every possible means at our command the general habit and the most excellent custom of reading and owning books. And when we have helped to form the bookreading and book-owning habit of the nation which has suddenly been called upon to carry the burden of modern civilization we shall consider that our efforts have not been entirely useless.”59 It can be safely argued that van Loon indeed contributed more than a modest share to America’s cultural life of the Jazz Age. A journalist of the Boston Evening Transcript observed that van Loon “was writing history in a new way. He was treating with a light ironic humor those subjects that had previously been discussed with the utmost seriousness. To the conventionalist, he is the fresh youngster throwing rocks through the hothouse windows to attract attention; to his admirers he is the originator of a new and delightful form of history; while to the public at large he is the man who created some sort of indescribable sensation.” Van Loon told this newspaper man: “When the critics say I am jazzy, it merely means that I am using the spirit of the times. . . . All I am doing is bringing to history what Gershwin has brought to music.” He was not only widely known for his outlines such as The Story of Mankind, The Story of the Bible, and America but also for innumerable drawings and cartoons he had contributed to The Survey (1922–1925) and The Nation (1926–1928). Also in that field of creativity he was able to capture “the spirit of the times” and had his admirers. The Nation’s publisher, Oswald Garrison Villard, for instance, on one occasion spoke about “a masterpiece” and wrote van Loon that “Nothing finer ever appeared in The Nation.” And the Beards in their Rise of American Civilization made a reference to an extraordinary van Loon cartoon “showing God as at last worthy of being naturalized into American citizenship.” Van Loon’s editorship of the Literary Guild, finally, was likewise an important contribution to the cultural climate of the decade.60
The Prince of Popularizers
107
A 1928 publication, Intimate Sketches of Leading American Story Tellers, provided a short biography of van Loon’s alongside those of such noted authors as Theodore Dreiser, Sherwood Anderson, Sinclair Lewis, Eugene O’Neill, Carl Sandburg, Will Durant, and Upton Sinclair. In that sketch van Loon was portrayed as “essentially a European” with “an inherent sense of Rabelaisian humor, [and an] urbanity such as marked the character of Erasmus” with whom he felt a special bond. Indeed, he was even described as “a scholar whose hermitage is the world, whose companion is mankind.” Van Loon had confessed having “only two hates—stupidity and intolerance, and the desire to swat these,” he said, “has given me a sort of Jehovah complex.”61 It was this Jehovah complex that had led to his failed love affair with Frances Goodrich. And so, the “prince of popularizers” unexpectedly sneaked out of the country that had made him a celebrity, fleeing back to Europe— the only place he instinctively felt he would find shelter to recover from his self-inflicted psychological wounds. A few months earlier, a confused van Loon had asked H.L. Mencken to come see him “and listen to the soul-stirring perturbations of this Hendrik who does not even have any Canossa to visit, who can do just about whateverdamnwell pleases him and does not know whither, whence or wherefore.” To fill the vacancy in the editorial board of the Literary Guild, Carl Van Doren requested no one less than Baltimore’s literary lion to “take the place of Van Loon who is just resigning in order to devote all his time to staying away from his wife.” Nothing better than this could express van Loon’s status at the time or explain the reason for his sudden flight.62
This page intentionally left blank
Chapter 10
The Veere Paradise (1928–1931) Aboard the President Harding running away to Europe, van Loon met Dr. Alice Bernheim, a bone specialist at New York Hospital. The well-to-do, well-bred, and happily married Alice Bernheim discovered van Loon’s name on the passenger list, tipped the dining room steward, and was seated at his table; several hours later, they felt as if they were longtime friends. Although she was petite, not quite reaching Hendrik Willem’s chest, she could stand up to him on any subject. More important, as a sharp-witted and perceptive listener, she was exactly the right person the psychologically wounded van Loon badly needed. In Gerard Willem van Loon’s words, Alice had “just the necessary combination of worldliness, clinical detachment, and humor to make her one of the chosen few whom Hendrik needed more than they needed him.” And in the next seven years he sent her an avalanche of letters expressing his inner feelings to this woman for whom he had a deep respect.1 Upon arrival in Genoa on 16 February 1928, van Loon contemplated what to do next. He ruled out going back to the United States or living by himself for a while. Since he lacked the courage to get in touch with Rene in Paris and try to explain a couple of things, he chose the easiest of possibilities: he returned to Jimmie, who was on an extended trip to Europe and happened to be in northern Italy. As if nothing had happened, Hendrik Willem and Jimmie—in the company of her dachshund, Noodle—met at the Bellinzona railway station and set off for Locarno, where they registered at the Grand Hotel Palace as man and wife. Here he drugged himself with work again and felt “as dead as a very dead snake that was run over a couple of weeks before by a truck.” With his eyes and back aching “from sitting without interruption at his desk for sixteen days,” he finished his Life and Times of Pieter Stuyvesant. He wrote to Alice Bernheim, “If there ever was a duller subject I would like to know about it.” Once again he and Jimmie worked together
110
Va n L o o n
well and once again he became restless as soon as the job was done. The van Loons now headed for Zurich, from where they paid a short visit to Willem at school, and then went on first to Salzburg and then to Munich.2 In Munich van Loon not only met several old friends from the days he was working there on his Ph.D., he also wrote his chapter for Charles Beard’s book Whither Mankind and spent some time at the Deutsches Museum doing research for a new “nice little book”: a history of inventions, tentatively called Multiplex Man. To Alice Bernheim he described himself as an “animated brain,” doing nothing but work from morning till night and hoping that his body could stand the strain. At the same time he reflected upon his “hopelessly idiotic and foolish” failure with Frances Goodrich, which had been an “uninterrupted period of humiliation [during which he] felt all the time like a lion in a circus grinding coffee or bleating on a saxophone, dressed up in a dickey.” While in the Bavarian capital, van Loon made a decision about his next step. As soon as he finished his research in Munich, he and Jimmie now headed north to Veere, the village they had so enjoyed on their trip to Holland in 1923. He had decided to settle in Zeeland for a couple of years, not only to “live like the lower forms of one-celled animals,” but also to write the long planned book that needed his own and his subject’s native soil to germinate: a life of Rembrandt van Rijn. As he explained to Alice Bernheim, this would be “my effort to enter fiction.”3 Late in April, van Loon had bought De Houtuin, a house originally constructed in 1572 on the quay facing the harbor. While a small army of workmen were refurbishing the house according to the new owner’s wishes, Hendrik Willem and Jimmie stayed at the Abdij Hotel in nearby Middelburg. Van Loon made business trips to Amsterdam, The Hague, and London. He also visited his relatives and once again experienced his sister Suus’s tense disapproval of his marital record and of Jimmie. In early June the van Loons moved into De Houtuin; three days later, Jimmie recorded in her diary that “Han began to write Multiplex Man.” This proved to be a far from easy job. Indeed, as he complained to Alice Bernheim, “I have such a hard time fishing it out of my inner consciousness that I am ready to blow up almost any moment. And in order not to blow up I continue to work and work a little harder than usual.”4 To American friends van Loon described Veere in terms like “the smallest and most deserted town on the most distant Dutch isle,” “a fairy-like place,” and “a relic of the fourteenth century where peace drippeth from the trees, [located] twenty minutes from Flushing, eight hours from London, six from Paris, six days from America. Absolutely central and yet a million miles removed from the rest of the world.” He had had a telephone installed—a rarity for a private residence in Zeeland—and was very excited about the front room on the ground floor, where he was going to work. As there was no
The Veere Paradise
111
straight wall in the house, the white plaster in his workroom was “so uneven that it is discolored enough to give a pattern to the walls. The other effects are by the well-known firm of the Lord God Almighty for when he shineth his sun . . . the room acquires a million different patterns.” On one of the walls van Loon drew a huge map of the world, illustrated with sketches and comments. On the location between Euphrates and Tigris, the Biblical paradise, for instance, he wrote, “Here the damn trouble started.” He didn’t mind that there was no running water—for a bath the van Loons returned to the Middelburg hotel—and “sanitary arrangements [were] not ideal but by paying the local collectioneur ten cents per day, [they enjoyed] the unbelievable luxury of a fresh and noble wooden barrel every twenty-four hours.” And it was here, “the most inaccessible hole in the mud I could find,” that he intended to stay to recover from his psychological wounds, for “I was pretty damn hard hit and now that I am returning to spiritual normalcy, I am beginning to discover how badly hit I was.” He wrote Alice Bernheim that he could not return to the United States “until I shall have rehabilitated my own intelligence in my own eyes. That may take some time, doc, some time.”5 Thinking that he needed “to do something rather big and showy” to regain his self-respect, Hendrik Willem threw himself into civic activities. “[T]o jazz up life in the shrimp kettle,” as he put it in an article in the national magazine of the Dutch tourist organization ANWB, he organized a sailing race of fishing boats that August and contributed a silver goblet as the first prize in horseback games held on Middelburg’s Abbey Square. Still another token of goodwill that impressed the local population was his acting as an anonymous Santa Claus at Christmas. Several of the poorest families of Veere answered a ring at their door in the evening, saw no one there, and found a bottle of wine and an envelope with money on their doorstep. Furthermore, his regular baking of pancakes for the Veere community as well as the bicycle he had bought and made available for all who needed it, also belonged to his legendary acts and more spectacular ones were to follow. Through articles in Dutch newspapers van Loon raised the alarm about the damage water leaks was inflicting on Veere’s late-fifteenth-century Town Hall. In 1931 a thorough restoration of the building and its remarkable latesixteenth-century tower began. To this very day Town Hall is widely acclaimed as Veere’s pride.6 Their first summer there, he wrote Bennett Cerf, a Boni and Liveright executive who had gone on to found Random House, that “the town of Veere continues to be a city of surprise.” One day when van Loon was on business in The Hague, Prince Hendrik, the consort of Queen Wilhelmina, called unannounced at De Houtuin. The prince was surrounded by “so many guys in gold lace that [Jimmie] felt sure the house was pinched.” Jimmie let the guest of honor grind his own coffee with an antique coffee grinder, something
112
Va n L o o n
the prince had never done before, and he and his company enjoyed this very unusual informal visit. Before leaving the van Loon home, Prince Hendrik climbed a chair he had put on a table in Hendrik Willem’s workroom and was just able to reach the map of the world on the wall to put his signature on that part of Germany, Mecklenburg, where he came from. Van Loon felt flattered royalty had honored his house but found out the true reason for the visit a little later. It was not his books that had made the prince pay him a call, but “His Highness had heard that I did such marvelous card tricks. Such is fame!”7 It was not only the big-sized van Loon himself who made a remarkable impression upon the inhabitants of Veere. Also the bohemian lifestyle of the frail, bobbed, and chain-smoking Jimmie did not remain unnoticed. During that first summer at De Houtuin she bought a Chevrolet, obtained her Dutch drivers license, and often drove like crazy along the roads of the Walcheren district—a phenomenon never seen before. Jimmie adapted herself remarkably well to the new situation and was glad she did not have to dress up in the small community. Within a few months, she mastered most of the Dutch she needed. With two maids—dressed in traditional Zeeland peasant costume—taking care of the household, she had little more to do than to keep up with Hendrik Willem’s work and taxi him or friends around. To Alice Bernheim she wrote about Veere, “there isn’t a thing to do but read and rest and rattle around the roads with the Chevvy. But somehow, I never get bored here for a minute.” She kept a bottle hidden in her desk but the town soon knew of her drinking problem, about which Hendrik Willem continued to harangue her.8 In the fall, the town of Veere according to Jimmie consisted “of rain, mud and sugarbeets,” piles of which were “rising higher, higher, even higher” on the quay. The sugarbeet harvest was vital to the area’s economy. Van Loon reported that from six o’clock in the morning on “high carts with red wheels and green bodies and terrific horses, as wide as the horizon come trundling down the cobblestones.” The beets were “dumped upon the slippery stones of the Quai and then begins the job of dumping it into the boats which are of all the colors of the rainbow.” In the same letter he praised “the regularity of the simple life in this village: tides and storms and lighthouses and shrimpfishermen and a ferryman to the next island whose family has had the job since 1500.” During this “year of atonement,” as he described it to Alice Bernheim, van Loon felt very much at ease “in this queerest of towns of which I am the humblest inhabitant.”9 Van Loon had still not come to terms with his “Calvin ridden” native country, which did not recognize him as a serious author. The Algemeen Handelsblad by this time, however, published a favorable article about him and his life in Veere, commending the “Dutch Yankee” for having made
The Veere Paradise
113
“the hurried, future-focused, and child-like Americans” realize that history can be as important in life as “the highly worshipped future.” As a matter of fact, van Loon maintained as tense a life-long relationship with the Dutch as he had with the sixteenth-century reformer John Calvin, whom he described in his chapter in Beard’s Whither Mankind as “That queerly biased and perverted person.” As van Loon admitted in his autobiography, Calvin was “one of my pet abominations.”10 Meanwhile, the American press had found out that Hendrik Willem had returned to Jimmie. On 16 September 1928 the New York World featured an article headlined “Free Marriage Advocate Returns to Second Wife.” Eleven days later the New York Times reported that Frances Goodrich had initiated divorce proceedings. Her lawyer hired a Parisian detective to investigate the situation in Veere. The man did not understand a word of Dutch, so all he managed to find out was that, according to the inhabitants of Veere, Hendrik Willem and Jimmie were man and wife. Many months later, van Loon poked fun at him and told his lawyer, Charles Recht, that the bill of the French detective had delighted the people of Veere. “To have to pay gratuities and give drinks to the people of Veere to find out how and what and which we were here seems almost too much of a good thing for they would have given that information free of charge and gladly. But his charge for ‘boats’ is what gladdens the hearts of the honest inhabitants. Walcheren was an island a hundred years ago. To get here now by boat is as easy as to get to Dayton by boat.” Meanwhile, Frances was asking for $3,000 to make up for the alimony she had lost from her first husband by remarrying and also wanted her lawyer’s fees paid. This last demand angered Hendrik Willem. He told his lawyer that he was unwilling to pay, would stay married if necessary, and could even regain his Dutch citizenship—and in that case where would Frances’s lawyer be?11 In August he had written Alice Bernheim that “in a long and varied life I have discovered that most women are bitches. Unless they are intelligent they must be bitches to get ahead in this world.” And two months later he reported that “the whole New York episode is beginning to assume the qualities of a very unpleasant nightmare.” The American scandal sheets were having a field day with the story of van Loon’s marital life (the headlines included, “Historian Jilts Actress,” “Love Nest on Dutch Isle,” and “Professor van Loon’s Loony Romance”). Receiving those clippings, van Loon felt the press made him “a pathetic fool to be laughed at by every bum who can afford a tabloid.” Closer to home, a Dutch ladies’ magazine, De Haagsche Dameskroniek, featured a column in December on his marital experiences. The author used the sensational stories in the American yellow press as a warning to his female readers that the idea of companionate marriage could
114
Va n L o o n
lead only to disappointment. In the new year the New York Evening Post dispatched a journalist to Veere to interview the “man of many wives.” Her ironic article upset van Loon, and he included this reporter, whom he had entertained for three days, in the category of bitches: “the dear dame was a liar and a cheat and she ate my dinners and drank my booze and abused every bit of confidence.”12 Although van Loon was inclined to do anything to “get this marriage dissolved,” his lawyer cautioned against agreeing to Frances’s escalating demands. In Hendrik Willem’s view, there had not been a marriage, not even a companionate marriage as they had only slept once or twice together in “four months that have killed every sentiment.” Charles Recht advised him not to “make it possible for her to be pensioned for the rest of her life, because you happen to have been an idiot for three nights of your life.” By the fall of 1929, a settlement was reached. Appearing at New York County Supreme Court on 23 October to make the divorce official, Frances declared, “Never again, I have had all the marriage I want, part-time or otherwise.” Nevertheless, in February 1931 she married her collaborator Albert Hackett and van Loon immediately stopped his payments to her. She and Hackett would go on to write such movies as The Thin Man and It’s a Wonderful Life and the Pulitzer Prize winning play The Diary of Anne Frank.13 To a young Dutch friend, Erik “Din” Smit—whom Hendrik Willem and Jimmie had “adopted” as their nephew—van Loon wrote shortly after the court session, “We want to inform you that your sweet aunt Frances is now deposited in the Museum of Family Curiosities and that we are divorced in order to make your aunt Jimmie a decent girl again, but she doesn’t want to as she says, ‘We never had such a good time since we live in sin,’ and so, long live sin.” Jimmie herself a few weeks later strongly advised Erik to take seriously her warning: “Keep away from matrimony, unless the material advantages are great enough to balance the inconveniences thereto attendant. In other words,” she wrote in capital letters, “MARRY FOR MONEY, MUCH MONEY, or not at all. And hold out for a settlement—a good one— BEFORE the ceremony.”14 The same month that Frances had filed for divorce, September 1928, van Loon secretly reestablished contact with his former fiancé, Rene Gibbs Scudamore. In the months that followed he dashed off a number of times to Paris to meet Rene there. As he wrote her, “Our lives have been so absolutely intermingled and mingled and interwoven and upgebusted and thrown together,” and he wondered why he had always hurt her and himself since they had met a decade before. His relationship to Jimmie, he explained, was that of “a working team. We can remove vast quantities of work when working together . . . but when there is no work and only cogitation Veere is a very small place.” His rendezvous with Rene were usually followed by desperate
The Veere Paradise
115
long letters, full of self-pity and telling her she was the one and only woman for him. But as he had jilted her twice, Rene just wanted to be friends, nothing more. By now she had established herself in the Parisian fashion world and had no inclination to take Jimmie’s place in Hendrik Willem’s life. Nevertheless, the very same day the divorce was made final in New York, van Loon hastened to Paris to propose to Rene for the third time. She flatly refused, telling him he was “obese.” In fact, Hendrik Willem weighed over 270 pounds and was proud of his ponderous belly—according to his son, it was “the personification of his ego and he pampered it accordingly.” He returned to Veere like a wounded animal and found solace in the company of Jimmie, big plates of food, and the Rembrandt project. Apparently Rene’s straightforward observation made van Loon diet for a while. In December he reported to a friend, “my food supply has been reduced to half and I am so damn hungry all the time that one of these days I will bite a piece out of the frontdoor.” This regime was soon abandoned.15 Although these marital difficulties complicated Hendrik Willem’s first year in Veere, it was a productive period professionally—three of his books appeared in 1928. However, the reviewers seem to have picked up on his boredom with Pieter Stuyvesant. Among the major American newspapers and magazines, only the Atlantic Monthly gave Life and Times of Pieter Stuyvesant a glowingly positive review—and that piece was written by van Loon’s friend Lewis Mumford.16 The second volume that came out in 1928 was his inventions book telling the story of man’s inventiveness to mechanically augment the limited powers of his body from earliest times on. Although he had been able to finish the manuscript in only three months, writing it, as he had reported to Alice Bernheim, had caused him quite a headache. The author’s struggle with the book was apparently obvious to Thomas Smith, his editor at Boni and Liveright, who changed the title to Man the Miracle Maker. (“It smacks of Jesus!” was van Loon’s complaint.) Hendrik Willem blamed any lukewarm reviews on Smith’s editing of the manuscript. Fortunately, the reviews were mostly positive. The New York Times said the book was “as entertaining as anything Mr. van Loon has done.” The critic in the New York Herald Tribune called it “a well knit narrative, full of humor and seriousness. It is a successful combination of information, illustration and sound social philosophizing.” The book was not as warmly received in Britain (where it retained van Loon’s original title, Multiplex Man) or Holland, but there was wide acclaim in Germany. There, according to van Loon’s son, “the author of Der Multiplizierte Mensch was hailed as a prophet before his time [and] enjoyed his greatest popularity in the intellectual circles.” Van Loon was not so much surprised at the Dutch criticism of his book but found it remarkable that “the hatred”
116
Va n L o o n
expressed in most reviews against his work was also “transformed into a hatred against America.” And that explained, he thought, the reason that Upton Sinclair—in his opinion “the most un-American, annoying and humorless of all American writers”—was so popular in Holland: the Dutch loved to hear from that author what was all wrong with America.17 In addition to these two volumes, van Loon also published a short work on another Dutch-American seventeenth-century topic, Adriaen Block: Skipper, Trader, Explorer. According to the title page, it was privately printed for the members of Block Hall, Inc. Most of the text dealt with the European search for the roads to the Indies and America and it is only in the last fifteen pages, after his telling the story of Henry Hudson’s expedition with his ship Halve Maen, that van Loon gives homage to the rather obscure Adriaen Block who through his expedition of 1613–1614 “had laid the foundation for a new colonial Empire.” Van Loon admired this daring skipper for whom Block Island was named, “who hammered himself a seaworthy craft out of a couple of Manhattan firtrees and added a thousand odd square miles to the sum total of the geographical knowledge of his day as unconcernedly as if he had gone on a mere fishing expedition.”18 At the start of 1929, the one-man factory van Loon, after years of writing “stories of this and stories of that and stories of everything,” came to the conclusion that his Mankind formula was “out.” What in 1921 had been “a clarion call for a new history” had lost its attraction to him and he would leave the field of history writing as such. After all, he told Rene, “History is like running a train . . . useful but not very inspiring for there is the time-table . . . and I want to be free and wander aloft without the consciousness of being . . . tied to a time-table.” In early April, he reported to Alice Bernheim that “after rather terrific spiritual searchings,” he had found a new formula for a new book: “There are 437842 books about Rembrandt. Most of them awful. There ought to be a good book. I am writing it. It is the autobiography of a doctor who took care of him, met him first when the wife died . . ., saw him on and off all during the rest of the misery . . . you see it is a fine piece of melodrama.” Having liberated himself from history, van Loon put as much autobiographical material into the novel as he wished. His fictitious ancestor Dr. Jan van Loon shared a Christian name and some characteristics with his uncle Jan Hanken, and two women in the book were obviously taken from his own life: the one and only woman Rembrandt’s physician loved dearly but was afraid to marry was a portrait of Rene and Dr. Jan’s brother, Willem, had an affair with an actress that came to a bad end. In addition, there were autobiographical elements to other characters, including Rembrandt himself. Van Loon explained to his old friend publisher Benjamin Huebsch, “I had always wanted to write a life of Rembrandt but a
The Veere Paradise
117
painter’s life is apt to be dull and I had always wanted to write me an autobiography. . . . I have discovered a way of doing them both at the same time. I am writing my own autobiography in the form of an imaginary autobiography of an imaginary ancestor who was the doctor who took care of Rembrandt.”19 Whatever his reasons, the work went well and he was soon reporting to Thomas Smith at Boni and Liveright that “the fool brain is working overtime with more pleasure than at any moment during these ghastly years and I have decided as the best way of purging myself of the whole damn mess to write a book about it.” Even if the book would have only five readers he would write it as it was to be “something novel in the line of biography.” Since he was so familiar with Holland in the seventeenth century, the historical facts would be “correct enough.” Nevertheless he would take “endless liberties” by bringing people together who may have met each other and did not care if professional historians quibbled, observing, “a hundred years from now no one will be able to prove that I knew Heywood Broun for I never wrote him a single line of letter or postal card but what of it? Isn’t it logical that we should have met and illogical that we should not have met?”20 By June van Loon was so deeply involved in his Rembrandt biography that, he wrote Alice Bernheim, “If I am not careful that book will run away with me. I have rarely been as happy as doing this.” Four months later, as Frances was renouncing matrimony in a Manhattan courtroom, the writing was still going well: “I am merely a working machine, hammering away day and night at this incredible Rembrandt book, . . . I shall never have another chance to write a book in which I can say absolutely everything I want to say and this time I have got to make a go of it or bust.” By late January 1930 the manuscript was up to 1,000 pages and on 6 February Jimmie noted in her diary, “Han finished Rembrandt today.” Meanwhile, Horace Liveright was very excited about the book’s prospects. When ultimately van Loon sent his publisher the result of his labor, “the literary infant weighed 12 pounds,” without the illustrations. A parcel like that with so much postage had never before been sent from Veere and to an American friend van Loon boasted that he and Liveright kept the local post office alive.21 Van Loon took moments off from his work on Rembrandt, to play the fiddle, draw endless numbers of pictures, and—on a very limited scale—do some exercise. Veere continued to fascinate him. As he wrote in De Groene Amsterdammer,22 it was the calming effect of the tide in Veere’s harbor twice a day that gave him the peace of mind he had been looking for in vain anywhere else in the world. To Alice Bernheim he exclaimed, “Veere is at times so lovely that it hurts and hurts badly from sheer beauty. . . . I am here to confess publicly and openly that the last winter has been by far the happiest of my 47 summers.”23
118
Va n L o o n
The summer of 1929 marked another “big and showy” van Loon stunt in Veere. The American monthly magazine The Smart Set, formerly edited by H.L. Mencken and just taken over by newspaper tycoon William Randolph Hearst, in an attempt to boost its sales had organized a nationwide contest to win the title “Typical American Girl.” The winner of this contest was the twenty-four-year-old teacher of elocution in Miami, Florida, Edna Peters who was described in The Smart Set’s August issue as “a leader in [her] city’s younger social set, an excellent cook and seamstress” who liked to play golf, swim, hunt and ride and who was judged “as being most representative in personality, intellect and appearance of the Typical American Girl for 1929.” The dark brown-haired and hazel-eyed Edna Peters, standing five feet four and weighing one hundred and nine pounds, made a tour of Europe where she was hailed as “Miss America.” Her publicity manager of this European tour was Paris-based fashion writer Dora Miller, a friend of van Loon’s. After all the social swirl of Paris night life and before heading to Cannes and other resorts, the schedule of the publicity tour had a couple of empty days and Dora Miller cabled Hendrik Willem asking him whether he could arrange Edna to meet with the Dutch queen. Van Loon flatly replied “No”—“the queen was not that kind of a girl”—and said that it was much better for Edna to come to Veere to meet him.24 In no time van Loon set up his public relations circus. On the morning of Dora Miller’s and Edna Peters’s arrival in the Netherlands Hendrik Willem and Jimmie drove to the Roosendaal railway station to welcome their guests and van Loon, in Jimmie’s words, had himself “thoroughly photographed” with the American beauty by a photographer of a local newspaper and interviewed by a reporter from the Algemeen Handelsblad whom he had summoned for the event. The journalist was deeply impressed by the beauty and charm of Edna Peters and described her in his article as “the queen of queens and the most perfect woman in the world.” Then the van Loons and their guests dashed off to Veere. As that day happened to be Queen Wilhelmina’s birthday and therefore a national holiday, van Loon threw a big party with all sorts of games “and heaps of prizes” for the children of Veere. Van Loon for his own pleasure had Edna dressed up in traditional Zeeland costume and endlessly photographed with him and local people, including Veere’s mayor who for this special occasion “dashed home and put on his official silver chain” (figure 10.1). That evening Veere was treated with fireworks, sponsored by van Loon’s friend Frits Philips, and the next morning they first toured the island of Walcheren, followed by an afternoon sailing trip, and finally Hendrik Willem and Frits drove their special guests back to Roosendaal where they caught a night train to Paris.25 The visit of “Miss America” to Veere—an event to be remembered for decades by the local population as one of the legendary van Loon acts—was,
119
Figure 10.1 Hendrik Willem van Loon with “Miss America” in Zeeland costume and the mayor of Veere, August 1929 (Hendrik Willem van Loon Papers, 1884–1972. Courtesy of the Division of Rare and Manuscript Collections, Cornell University Library).
120
Va n L o o n
of course, covered by the Middelburgsche Courant. The newspaper mentioned Edna Peters’s “well-known” host and complimented her elegance in Zeeland costume. More important for van Loon, however, was that The Smart Set in its December issue that year featured an article, entitled “All Europe gives the little Typical American Girl a great big hand,” which not only included photos from Edna Peters’s successful visits that summer to Berlin, London, and Paris (according to Louise Selby, the foremost American designer in France, “Edna Peters was born to wear the dresses that are driving Paris mad!”), but also featured a picture from her visit to Veere on which she posed smilingly in Zeeland costume together with an equally smiling and victorious looking big-sized author.26 That summer was also the beginning of a new long-lasting friendship with another American woman. In a letter passed on by his publisher Ruby Fuhr, a schoolteacher in Terre Haute, Indiana, asked van Loon permission to use a picture from The Story of Mankind in a textbook she was working on. Van Loon wrote back, “As long as you live in the town which was the home of the only honest political leader I have ever known [Eugene V. Debs], you can do any damned thing with anything of mine and good luck to you.” When Ruby Fuhr then asked his permission to publish this letter in her local newspaper, van Loon felt flattered and, of course, agreed. When a third letter from her revealed to van Loon that she was not a Mrs. but Miss Fuhr, his romantic feelings were heightened and he asked her to send him a picture of herself. She sent a group picture of a number of schoolteachers, asking him to guess which one she might be. Van Loon guessed wrong but soon a correspondence between the two started that would continue until his death. Due to Ruby Fuhr’s wisdom in staying aloof and reserved toward his often overwhelming personality, their friendship was not spoiled by another amorous catastrophe. She even became fast friends with Jimmie, who realized that this warm but unpretentious Midwestern teacher was not seeking to take her place.27 In one of his early letters to Ruby Fuhr, van Loon expressed his contempt for behaviorism—J.B. Watson’s psychological theory that posited that humans did what they did in response to stimuli more than from conscious introspection. In van Loon’s opinion behaviorism was a theory that did not work and he asked Ruby, “Can you, seeing the little darlinks, give yourself any hope to turn more than 3 percent of them into halfway intelligent and decent citizens?” Sure, he admitted, one can teach the kids a few things, but it was clear to him that one could not “interfere seriously with the dreadful law that Homo est homo quod est or quis est in this case.” One should not expect too much, “except from a very small group of people for whom God has thrown dice.” After expressing these aristocratic views, van Loon also commented on Spengler and Marx. What both authors had in common, he
The Veere Paradise
121
wrote, was “great learning but no fresh air.” Spengler reminded him “of those charming young American students who go to Paris to write a doctor’s dissertation upon Madame the Pompadour and then run home to Mama when some flossye creature says ‘Bonsoir Chérie’ to them on the street. [And] if old Karl had spent one week of his life in a factory he would have written a different book. But he did not.” No, van Loon was not really the champion of the common man. On a postcard he sent his younger son that spring he had written, “May 1, and long live the Proletariat as long as it does not live in Veere.”28 Van Loon’s relationship with Willem, incidentally, had developed into a tense one. At eighteen, the son showed, in his father’s view, some “very dangerous and unpleasant tendencies” as a consequence of his being exclusively under the wings of his mother. When they had seen each other that summer, van Loon observed that Willem, “always slightly femininely inclined and a sissy as the other kids called him,” was now “rapidly degenerating into a complete and absolute fairyboy.” That fall Willem entered the Max Reinhardt Seminar in Vienna to become a dancer and actor, more evidence to his father that he was heading “straightway for fairydom.” However when, in 1932, Willem made his debut in Paris as a professional dancer, the New York Times reported that Hendrik Willem had withdrawn his objections to the young man’s career as a dancer. During the previous few years, while Willem was at his Swiss boarding school, he had sent his father a series of nasty letters. Willem’s complaints centered on Hendrik Willem’s treatment of Eliza; in van Loon’s opinion, his ex-wife had filled the boy’s soul “with a desire for martyrdom” and Willem was standing on the breach to defend “the Ideal of his Mother against his cruel parent.” Naturally, van Loon resented paying for Willem’s education while getting these “incredibly patronizing letters” in return. He tried to persuade Willem that contrary to what the boy might think, he was not “sitting up nights to evolve deep-laid schemes” to make Willem’s and Eliza’s lives miserable. At the same time, van Loon was aware, as he once admitted to Frances Goodrich, that his younger son had inherited his “few abilities” and he told Willem, “you probably have a great deal of your Pa in you.” His letters to both Hank and Willem over the years testify to a deep fatherly love.29 For his part, his older son, Hank, was “as different from his father as two human beings can be. And yet there is something between us that pulls stronger than anything that we can control ourselves.” In the fall of 1929 Hank came to Holland to work for a couple of months as an unpaid apprentice for an Amsterdam architect. On the weekends, he stayed with his father and Jimmie in Veere. Hank got along well with Jimmie (unlike Willem) and remembered that there were a great many visitors to the house. People who wanted to see his father, “just walked in, no formality, no ringing of the bell.”
122
Va n L o o n
At that time, following Hendrik Willem’s post–divorce pursuit of Rene, Hank’s moral support was salutary. The aggrieved father wrote that his elder son was “the best and only excuse for my temporary appearance on this planet.”30 Van Loon’s best friend in Veere, Frits Philips, died after surgery in December 1929. The loss of his friend, with whom he had shared so much pleasure in Zeeland, drove Hendrik Willem to melancholia. His black mood was removed, however, when asked by the National Broadcasting Company (NBC) in New York to be the host of a transatlantic radio broadcast of music from Amsterdam on Christmas Day—an opportunity he avidly seized. The experimental NBC broadcast proved to be a great success. As the New York Times reported, it was “the first international Christmas celebration by radio, heralded by engineers and scientists as epoch-making for broadcasting and international relations transmitted on wave lengths calculated to reach listeners in every quarter of the globe.” The event consisted of an American broadcast for European listeners, followed by similar programs transmitted on short radio waves from Holland, Germany, and England designed especially for American listeners. Van Loon told his fellow Americans that this was the first time “Old Amsterdam [spoke] directly to her long-lost daughter, New Amsterdam, across the water” and on behalf of the “old republic greeted the new republic.” Despite some occasional “bubbling sounds,” the foreign Christmas greetings were heard with “exceptional clarity and distinctness” and after the program NBC President M.H. Aylesworth said that the “successful interchange of radio programs between the United States and the European nations [was] broadcasting’s greatest achievement to date.” After the broadcast van Loon received a great many congratulatory letters and cables from friends and unknown listeners across the United States.31 What had delighted van Loon most about the historic radio broadcast was the fact that he had been asked to represent the Netherlands instead of one of his former compatriots. In his correspondence, van Loon often fulminated against the Dutch and criticized them for their narrow-mindedness, arrogance, and materialism. In his view the Dutch got “enough shekels from their blasted Indies to keep on being dumb and arrogant.” But it all served a purpose, he admitted to Alice Bernheim, as the Dutch atmosphere provided him with “the necessary irritation to make Rembrandt a good book.” To Ruby Fuhr he wrote that his “dumb ex-compatriots” made him lose his temper “on the average of 57684 times a day.” Van Loon wrote another series of articles for De Groene Amsterdammer, a number of which criticized aspects of Dutch life. His main complaint was that despite material progress, the country’s spiritual life had lost touch with the modern world. The school system prepared youth for the past instead of for the present and future. Dutch music,
The Veere Paradise
123
art, and literature were full of outdated expressions—the language itself, left in the hands of schoolmasters and clergymen, was committing suicide as it had lost touch with common people. In addition, the narrow-minded, pedantic, and arrogant attitude of the Dutch, in van Loon’s view, created a kind of Great Wall around the country, preventing the Dutch from realizing how much they had isolated themselves from the modern world. Fortunately, he told his readers, there was another Holland too: the Holland of those young and vigorous and adventurous and cosmopolitan-minded Dutchmen who had left the country and who had given the Dutch a good name in the world. Implicitly, of course, van Loon was glad to belong to that category.32 Van Loon also told his Dutch readers that America’s often criticized wealth was not only based on its natural riches but also sprouted from the conviction that each individual should take care of himself and that the role of the state or federal government should be minimal. This stood in stark contrast to the European situation, where in his opinion the state was “degraded” into some corporation whose main purpose was the maintenance of the majority of the population as civil servants—a situation he assessed as unrealistic. But his criticism on the Dutch and Europe in general did not mean that he closed his eyes to what he saw as shortcomings of the United States.33 Unfortunately, many of his criticisms exhibit the then common beliefs of the American establishment about race and religion: in the first half of the twentieth century, especially as the country absorbed millions of southern and eastern European immigrants, the white ruling class remained convinced of its innate superiority. As one scholar observed, in the years between the world wars “suspicion and hostility toward non-Protestant immigrant and ethnic groups remained strong in the United States.” We have already seen how van Loon was elitist in this matter as well, he was a child of his times and his views on Native Americans, African Americans, Italian Americans, and Jews clearly express the widely held WASP point of view (he included himself and all Protestants of northern European descent among the Anglo-Saxons).34 In one of his Groene Amsterdammer articles, for instance, van Loon likened the American political situation to the chaos of fifth-century Rome, when the mass immigration of “foreign” tribes resulted in the collapse of the Empire. In New York City, after this huge surge of Catholic and Jewish immigrants, the “real” Americans of Anglo-Saxon descent were finding their political power threatened. To their dismay, they now saw that one of these “barbarians,” New York State Governor Al Smith, an Irish Catholic, was the Democratic presidential nominee. In private, van Loon fully shared the anti-Irish feelings of his peers; he once wrote to Alice Bernheim, “Irish-Catholics are my niggers. I will not sit with them at bread and fish . . . I draw the line at the dear Irish.” In the same Groene Amsterdammer article he also wrote without
124
Va n L o o n
further comment or moral indignation that the indigenous Indian population had been “too weak and indifferent” to be able to resist colonization and had simply been wiped out like the “prehistoric natives” in Europe had been wiped out “by our ancestors.”35 He rarely mentioned Jewish immigrants in his Groene Amsterdammer pieces, but he had already gone on record while a columnist for the Baltimore Sun. “[T]he hordes of Polish Jews” who had come to the United States from the 1890s on had, in his view, brought with them “a specific Jewish inferiority complex” from centuries of maltreatment. Van Loon wrote that the Jews were now getting “even with the American people for something of which the Americans were entirely innocent.” And so, Jewish immigrants, acting as “[a] herd of foreign people with foreign gestures and foreign garb and a strange fire in their eager eyes pushing, shoving, tramping upon each other in their mad haste to make up for the lost ages,” caused resentment and created the so-called Jewish question. He considered “this attitude of mutual suspicion between Jew and Gentile [as] one of the most regrettable facts of our day and age.” This Jewish question could be solved only by the Jews themselves.36 While Hendrik Willem was glad to know that there were “Jewish leaders of great insight, deep understanding, sincere tolerance and infinite patience” who understood the causes of bad feelings between Christians and Jews, he couldn’t see much else. He continued to make patently anti-Semitic statements over the years, as did many other WASPs. As historian Leonard Dinnerstein has clearly demonstrated, anti-Semitism has existed throughout American history; at least through the end of World War II, Americans thought of their country as a Protestant one, and most Protestants regarded Catholics and Jews as inferior, at best tolerated but not embraced. Attacks on Jews, Catholics, and in general immigrants from southern and eastern European countries intensified in the 1920s and anti-Semitism would become more virulent and vicious in the Depression and during the war.37 Although van Loon held progressive views for the time about African Americans, his often segregationist rhetoric still betrays racist sentiments. In De Groene Amsterdammer, he denounced lynching, calling it “the unforgivable shame” in American society. Lynchings, he explained to his Dutch readers, occurred mainly in rural areas that were both highly religious and deeply conservative. And American puritanical belief, he explained, put more emphasis on sin than on virtue and that caused a lack of tolerance toward other groups. He also told the Dutch that race relations was not a problem America would soon solve. The intelligent part of America, he wrote, tried to encourage mutual respect between blacks and whites and wanted to give each group the freedom to work out its own way of life. But as the mentality of the blacks, as van Loon saw it, was “another, explicitly not an inferior one,” than that of the white population, he believed it would be best for both races
The Veere Paradise
125
“to live next to each other instead of living artificially with each other” in the same neighborhoods. For that reason, he admitted, he had never been in Harlem, New York City’s black neighborhood.38 When van Loon finished his Rembrandt manuscript in early February 1930, he decided to go to New York the next month. Jimmie stayed in Veere, while Hendrik Willem and Hank—who was eager to see Janet Hall with whom he had fallen in love the previous summer—set sail. Before embarking on the Bremen, van Loon suggested to Ruby Fuhr that they meet in New York. Ruby, of course, wanted to know more about his relationship with Jimmie and what he had done to make her happy before deciding to travel east from Indiana. He told her about Jimmie’s loyalty toward him and that he had foolishly left her for “some roundish object that never took care of me and did not care a hoot about me but was roundish which James was not.” After that companionate marriage had ended, Jimmie was there to resume life with him again but they had decided not to remarry. According to van Loon, Jimmie was as happy as could be as she was playing the role that satisfied her completely in her own eyes. In another letter he confessed to Ruby Fuhr: “I have never yet sat in a room alone with a woman without offering her matrimony and alimony for the rest of her days . . . as I have no more alimony to offer, I also am deprived of the matrimonial pleasures of saying, ‘now couldn’t I take those burdens off your shoulder,’ etc. etc. (Jehovah complex 4711).” But he would not play that role anymore and he promised Ruby, “You are safe. I shall not expose you to anything more than 1% of boredom.”39 Upon arrival in New York, van Loon was besieged with friends who welcomed him back. It was, as he reported to Jimmie, a “triumphant re-entry” and he wondered, “My God James, do I really amount to something in this world? Do I really?” Horace Liveright, who could only see his best-selling author briefly before sailing to England, placed his apartment at Hendrik Willem’s disposal, rent free. Van Loon met many friends, including Alice and George Bernheim whom he visited in their Westchester home for a weekend with Ruby Fuhr, who had indeed made the trip from Terre Haute to meet her pen pal. Being plain, thin, lacking in chic, the little bespectacled teacher was not exactly as Hendrik Willem had seen her in his imagination. Nevertheless, they enjoyed each other’s company immensely. Ruby had a great time being introduced to people she had only read about in books and magazines, and their being together only deepened Hendrik Willem’s admiration for her as a loyal, unassuming, and platonic friend.40 Having been away from the United States for two years, van Loon viewed the country as an outsider and soon reported his disappointment to Jimmie. After the stock market crash of October 1929 the country was sliding into the Great Depression, although no one appreciated the depth of the crisis at first.
126
Va n L o o n
In that spring of 1930 van Loon was upset to see “the whole country engaged in a drunken orgy [and] everybody hectically doing useless things and chasing something vague and nonexistent.” Although he met nice people—including Janet Hall, who would marry Hank that September—he described American society as “the lowest form of middleclass bunk I have ever seen.” This made van Loon feel so bored and depressed that he wanted to return to Veere as soon as possible. In a letter to Willem he wrote melancholically: “your pa at 48 is an old fossil broken down by the cares of the world.” But before returning to Holland by the end of April on the Statendam, he could boast some financial successes. Carl Van Doren of the Literary Guild had liked the Rembrandt manuscript enough to take it as a selection for the subscribers, and van Loon was able to sell some articles on Rembrandt and other topics to American magazines. He also signed a $1,000 contract for a ten-minute commercial broadcast from Amsterdam to the United States that fall which would be a novelty both technically and commercially, and even sold his name to a manufacturer of games for a map game based on The Story of Mankind.41 In outpourings of romanticism and even eroticism without precedent to her, Hendrik Willem also wrote Jimmie that he missed and wanted her “like hell” and had fallen in love with her again. As a present he had bought twenty-six pairs of stockings for her and was eagerly anticipating dressing and undressing her and making love to her. He especially was looking forward, he wrote, to kissing her between the legs and added, “whether the little pussy is worn out or not, the few years that remain I might as well spend all the time I can in it for it is a nice and restful little spot that gives one peace of mind everlasting.” He promised Jimmie “first class service” and told her that he had saved “an exuberance of certain dangerous juices” for her benefit. Though at that moment he realized that “we have never loved enough Jamesy,” he nevertheless gave her the greater responsibility for their love life to bear when he wrote, “it is partly up to you to make yourself so desirable that I shall not be able to keep away from you.” Hendrik Willem asked Jimmie to meet him in England and romantically share the Statendam cabin with him from Plymouth to Rotterdam. As could be expected, this idyll was short-lived and by the time they arrived in Veere their love life was back to the status quo ante. To both Alice Bernheim and Willem he complained about “the mess” he had made of his emotional life. Although he realized that “the incredible J. . . . has turned me into a sort of private religion of her own and devotes all her time and energy to this unworthy creature,” he confessed that the woman he really cared for and whom he missed so very much was Rene—“a product of the vL school of training” to whom he had used “sledgehammer methods.”42 On board the Statendam Hendrik Willem had met the aviator Charles Edward Kingsford-Smith. The thirty-three-year-old Australian’s 1928 first
The Veere Paradise
127
trans-Pacific flight from Oakland, California, to his birthplace, Brisbane, and his record-breaking flight a year later from Australia to England had been front-page news. On his way to the Fokker aircraft factory near Amsterdam to pick up a new plane to complete the round-the-world trip by flying that June from Ireland to California, Kingsford-Smith became friends with the van Loons. Hendrik Willem was delighted to be seen disembarking in Rotterdam with the hero of the day. To show his appreciation for his new Dutch friends, Kingsford-Smith before heading for Ireland flew his new plane, Southern Cross, to Veere and, as van Loon reported, “after three circles above our house and a farewell in which the whole machine slowly flapped its wings three times,” continued its westbound journey. That Kingsford-Smith had decided “to have the Southern Cross leave [for] the American continent from Veere of all places was the damnedest, nicest compliment I ever had.”43 In early August Kingsford-Smith was back in Holland and the van Loons attended a big party in his honor in Amsterdam. The next day they took the exhausted pilot home to Veere where he would stay a couple of days and catch up on lost sleep. The second day, however, he woke up with a terrible pain and Hendrik Willem called in a Middelburg friend, Dr. Charles Koch, who diagnosed appendicitis. Koch had the aviator immediately taken to the Middelburg hospital and removed the appendix. In no time news got out about the famous patient in the Middelburg hospital and for the next ten days the van Loons visited him daily, not only to cheer him up but also to protect him from the swarm of reporters, photographers, and adoring women. When a week after the operation the press was finally given access to Kingsford-Smith, it was Hendrik Willem who with his usual flair orchestrated the press conference and photo session. Kingsford-Smith made a quick recovery and rested with the van Loons before heading back to Amsterdam. Nevertheless, the aviator was so pleased with Dr. Koch’s surgical skill that he returned to Middelburg later in the month to have his tonsils taken out too. Later that year he made his first solo flight from England to Australia; he was knighted in 1932, but in 1935, in an attempt to better his time between England and Australia, he vanished near the Burmese coast where a wheel of his plane was found. For Jimmie he remained a hero till the end of her days and she always kept a picture of him close at hand.44 Apart from the excitement around Kingsford-Smith’s visit, van Loon felt far from happy that summer. He complained to friends about being depressed and extremely tired. A trip to Berlin and Prague brought some distraction and also Willem’s visit to Veere made him feel somewhat better. He was more reconciled to his younger son’s homosexuality and on several occasions they had a lot of fun. (Several months later, however, van Loon would write Rene Scudamore that his son’s “mannerisms—the way he uses his hand, eyes, and
128
Va n L o o n
body, twisting and turning like a randy woman” in the company of other people made him feel very embarrassed and that he hoped Willem would “overcome his handicaps” and would “understand that his queerness must be kept a secret from the world.”)45 Reading the galleys of his Rembrandt biography was another source of unhappiness. Boni and Liveright wanted to publish R.v.R.: The Life and Times of Rembrandt van Rijn in September for the Literary Guild but what in manuscript had seemed to its author “the noblest of books that was going to be the greatest work of the ages,” now looked terrible in print: “It rambles and wallows and rumbles. It is clumsy. It makes me vomit. And the glorious future that was to come from this great effort towards immortality is Boloney.” He frantically tried to fix as much as possible, but because of the tight schedule, he had to cable his corrections to New York. The Dutch telephone operators and postal clerks between Veere and Amsterdam mixed up English names and their American colleagues got the Dutch names wrong. It all made him so depressed that “the Veere harbor at high tide looks inviting. Just no good. No good,” as he wrote Mencken. His mood did not improve when his British publisher, Harrap, turned down R.v.R. In addition, van Loon reported to Alice Bernheim, the Woman’s Home Companion flatly rejected the first of his four articles on Rembrandt because it contained too much historical background, a thing—van Loon remarked sarcastically—the American public did not like: “History and historical background are not necessary. We follow that principle in almost everything we do . . . and the result is fairly disastrous and we go blustering through life and really understand nothing but we can talk about everything and that is that.”46 He took a short trip to Paris, thinking he could still persuade Rene to marry him. But Rene was more interested these days in an Englishman named Marcel Godfrey. When he told her she was making a mistake, she made it plain that she disliked his unasked-for comments on Godfrey. And so, he left the city in as bad a mood as he had arrived there and concluded that “the Paris chapter is closed. The remnants of fourteen years of the one great relationship of a life.” For the moment he was sure he would not give up his relationship with Jimmie, even if life with her was “almost too damnably comfortable.” But as far as women were concerned, not long after his trip to Paris van Loon urged Erik Smit to marry only when it was absolutely necessary, warning his friend that marriage could be extremely tedious and boring. And to his son Willem, he wrote that the public image in the press of his love life, “a noisy blustering hvl in public print who marries everybody and makes love to every woman,” was completely different from reality. In his own view he was in fact “very lonely.”47 He continued to feel unappreciated in his native country. When his Dutch publisher postponed a decision about doing R.v.R. until he saw the
The Veere Paradise
129
American reaction to the book, Hendrik Willem found a new way of taking revenge on the Dutch. Although Rembrandt’s paintings were now a national treasure, the painter had died in bankruptcy; van Loon started a campaign to have the authorities discharge the debts and erase that blot on Holland’s honor. He found a descendant of Rembrandt’s sister-in-law who could bring the bankruptcy case before the court of Amsterdam and ask for rehabilitation of the painter. But then the descendant backed out and the case was thrown out of court. Van Loon did not want people to say that the plan had been an advertising stunt, so he paid the lawyers himself. As he wrote Willem, it was “foolish work in this country where everybody is always afraid of everybody else’s opinion until no one dares to do a single original thing.” But he at least had the satisfaction of discomforting the Dutch and having done something for Rembrandt in reciprocity for the money he hoped to make of the book. A dozen years later, van Loon would admit that his efforts to get Rembrandt discharged from the bankruptcy court had been “slightly idiotic.”48 When R.v.R. was published in the United States in the fall of 1930, the reviews were much better than van Loon had expected. The Chicago Daily Tribune praised it as “an amazing book that fuses the soaring figure of Rembrandt with the dense reality of the age in which he lived” and the New York Times Book Review described R.v.R. as “an extraordinary tour de force, a melting pot of history, customs, manners and even topography.” The Times reviewer did think the technique of using a fictitious ancestor to tell the story was “a little annoying,” especially since it was obvious that “the good doctor is only Hendrik van Loon in a seventeenth century disguise.” Lewis Mumford wrote enthusiastically in The New Freeman that this was van Loon’s best book, “one of the most fascinating pieces of historical biography that have been done during the past decade.” The reviews in The Outlook and in the New York Evening Post were equally laudatory but nevertheless expressed the view that the 570-page book could, to its advantage, have been 200 pages shorter.49 And this was exactly what happened to the German edition of the book, which came out in 1931. When van Loon discovered upon receiving a copy of Der Überwirkliche that many chapters, totaling some 200 pages, had been drastically cut from the book, he was furious. His anger dissipated, however, when he saw himself described in German reviews as “the great biographer with the epic sense of a Dos Passos and the sociological insight of Upton Sinclair” and he heard that German booksellers could hardly keep enough copies on their shelves to meet the overwhelming demand. (Eventually, van Loon would cut R.v.R. himself for a 1939 American reissue, realizing it made a much better book.) By the end of 1930 he could write Ruby Fuhr that the reviews so far had made him happy. Although the volume did not “sell like the proverbial hot cakes,” he wanted “to be known for that book and not for
130
Va n L o o n
any other.” Or, as he phrased it to someone else in the spring of 1933, “The Rembrandt is the only book I shall take with me when I walk up to the Pearly Gate to try and offer the Almighty an excuse for my having lived at all.” Even the 1931 Dutch edition was well received for a change.50 Although he did not look forward to it, van Loon decided to go on an American lecture tour to promote the book in early 1931. As he wrote Willem, “this winter is devoted to a money raising campaign. To that and nothing else . . . we need the cash. I shall have a terribly hard winter for lecturing is not easy for me . . . it kills me more effectively than almost anything else I can think of.”51 Hendrik Willem and Jimmie boarded the Belgenland in December 1930 in Antwerp. Albert Einstein was among the passengers, and the two men hit it off immediately. As it turned out, both enjoyed playing the violin to relax. Jimmie’s diary and Gerald Willem’s biography of his father both speak of their playing together, but in the New York Times article on the physicist’s arrival, Einstein said that he had left his violin at home “because the tropical climate we will encounter in going to California by way of the Panama Canal might harm it.” That arrival was front page news. Just before docking in New York, the Belgenland was met by a tug with fifty camera men and an equal number of reporters who wanted to interview the Nobel Prize winner. Einstein had clearly not expected such a crowd of people. He was far from fluent in English and with a shy smile handed the journalists a short statement, prepared by van Loon, in perfect English. The newspapermen and women started firing questions at him before he could withdraw and, according to the New York Times, in fifteen minutes “he was called upon to define the fourth dimension in one word, state his theory of relativity in one sentence, give his views on prohibition, comment on politics and religion, and discuss the virtues of his violin.”52 The whole scene, as van Loon described it a few weeks later in an article for The New Republic, had been “the most monstrous, scandalous performance New York harbor had witnessed since the days when the ship reporters first sallied forth on board the pilot boats. None of us was prepared for such an outburst of hysteria.” He thought that the country, in great need of a prophet, “was Einstein-wild” and that the boundless media attention had turned “this man with his mysterious formulas . . . [into] our most recent short cut to God.” In Gerard Willem van Loon’s account, it is his father who in an attempt to protect the dazzled physicist from the hysterical journalist crowd places himself between the people of the press and their quarry, and as an experienced multilingual showman conducted the interview in a fast back-and-forth of German and English. In the New York Times report, however, it was Einstein’s wife and the German consul, Paul Schwarz, who acted as interpreters.53
The Veere Paradise
131
In any case, van Loon’s arrival in the United States was certainly noticed as the press encounter aboard the Belgenland also included two short radio “greetings to America” and it was in one of them, aired by the Columbia Broadcasting System, that van Loon introduced Einstein to the American public. Later that month, in a letter sent from California where he was working at the California Institute of Technology at Pasadena, Einstein wrote van Loon that he had pleasant recollections of their being together on the ocean liner and that he had survived the overpowering New York welcome successfully but weakened.54 Within twenty-four hours of his arrival in Manhattan van Loon, as he reported to his younger son, had been on the radio twice and had spoken to more people than during the last three years in Veere. And although both he and Jimmie felt a little homesick, he was glad to be in New York as “this is the future.” In the summer of 1930 he wrote Alice Bernheim that he felt the Veere phase in his life was coming to an end. It had provided him the perfect surroundings to produce Rembrandt but he now rather preferred to work in Veere part-time and live the rest of the year “in that part of the world where mankind hath not entirely gone to sleep. [He was] too young just to sit and vegetate.” In a newspaper interview a week after his arrival, van Loon declared that he felt torn between New York and Veere: “I can’t work in New York. I defy anybody to write here, with all this pressure. At the same time, I can’t stay away. Practically all the people I like are here. I have to go back to my own country to work. But my countrymen are seventy years behind the times. What is a man to do?”55 The van Loons spent Christmas with the Bernheims and in January started the lecture tour of the Midwest and the West Coast. As van Loon had feared, it became an ordeal: his public speaking performances always left him soaking wet, which easily made him catch a cold and fever, and so his hotel rooms became sickrooms and Jimmie had to play the role of standby nurse. Visiting the Grand Canyon was a pleasure, however, and a highlight of the trip. Van Loon cabled to Alice Bernheim, “If the prohibitions, the Christians, and the dear old mothers had only left our beloved Republic alone, what a marvellous country this would be to travel in.” Once the tour was over and they were back in New York, van Loon still held the same view of the West and Chicago he had expressed years before in two of his Sun columns: he never felt “the call of the prairies” and considered the West what the Romans used to call “brutum factum, a fact and not a fancy.” Opposed to New York, Chicago in his view was just “big, [lacking] spiritual and intellectual qualities [and looking] as if no one ever intended to finish anything at all, [which gave him] a vague uncertainty about the why and wherefore of human life.”56 At a dinner hosted by Alice and George Bernheim at their Park Avenue apartment, van Loon met Richard L. Simon, an employee of Boni and
132
Va n L o o n
Liveright who like Bennett Cerf had left to found his own publishing house. In 1924 he and Max Lincoln Schuster started issuing crossword puzzle books, soon had a smashing hit with Will Durant’s best seller The Story of Philosophy, which sold over two million copies, and became known for their aggressive advertising. Van Loon was very loyal to Horace Liveright, giving him much credit for the success of his books. He would never voluntarily have left Boni and Liveright, but the glamorous Liveright—described by his biographer as “a Gatsby-like figure who sometimes epitomized the excesses of the Twenties at their most blatant” (he was a gambler, an alcoholic, and a skirt-chaser)— had been forced to sell out his interest in Boni and Liveright even before R.v.R. came out. Liveright moved to California, where he tried to establish a career in movie production. While on his lecture tour, van Loon met Liveright in Los Angeles and was distressed to see how much his former idol had disintegrated from alcoholism. So, while in New York, van Loon was looking for a new publisher, and the young and enterprising Dick Simon filled the bill.57 At the end of February 1931 there were four van Loons aboard the Rotterdam-bound Nieuw Amsterdam: Hendrik Willem and Jimmie were accompanied by Hank and Janet, who were visiting Europe on their delayed honeymoon. Van Loon told a New York Times reporter that he was now “commuting” between Veere and New York, “studying and writing in the peace and quiet of Holland and returning to New York for play and recreation.” He was hardly back in Veere (figure 10.2) before he realized that while Jimmie was perfectly happy there, he needed another challenge. For the first time in his life, he wrote to Alice Bernheim, he felt “infinitely more American than European.” He thought he belonged in the United States and that in Europe he was out of place. He told Alice that he needed to move around a bit, but would avoid Paris, where “every corner” reminded him of Rene Scudamore. Nevertheless, the very next day he wrote Rene that he was on his way to the French capital, not as “the great and glorious hero who has a hell of a reputation and endless credit and is the life of the party, [but] just as the Earth doth its daily stuff around the Sun. . . . I am following an urge which bids me go where I shall find the only life I have ever wanted since I first saw you. . . . I have been deprived of all my fine feathers and have nothing to protect the terrible exposure of failure except my love for you. That I am no longer IT; That you are IT. That the roles have been turned and that I now need you as you once needed me.” A week after he had arrived in Veere van Loon, accompanied by Janet and Willem, was in Paris, while Jimmie and Hank remained in Veere.58 Van Loon rented a furnished apartment on the Boulevard St.-Germain for six weeks where he entertained guests and worked on a new book project,
The Veere Paradise
133
Figure 10.2 Hendrik Willem and Jimmie van Loon photographed by Ilse Bing in Veere, 1931 (Courtesy of the van Loon family).
a geography. When Rene’s English friend Marcel Godfrey insisted on meeting Hendrik Willem, the two men felt such hostility and behaved so disagreeably over lunch that Rene did not want to see either of them for a week. Tired of Hendrik Willem’s flamboyance and propensity to run her life, Rene more and more felt attracted to the Englishman’s gentleness. Nevertheless, in late April, Rene went with Hendrik Willem to a hotel in Versailles where they took separate rooms. During the weekend, Hendrik Willem invaded her privacy and tried to force himself on her, which so disgusted Rene that she ordered him not only out of her room but also out of her life. Van Loon fled Paris.59 The first week back in Veere, he complained to Alice, was “the damnedest loneliest period I ever lived through.” His life in Europe had been built around Rene, the one woman who had become “so absolutely part of my flesh and blood”—since that period had definitely come to an end, he intended to finish his geography book as soon as possible and then would return to the United States. To Willem he confessed he had lost Rene through his own stupidity and concluded that he was a curse unto himself; he would go back to America because he desperately needed money “and a hell of a lot of it.”60
134
Va n L o o n
Of course, before he left Europe, he tried to explain to Rene how much he needed her. She could do whatever she wanted but he asked just one favor: that she allow him to talk to her once in a while as without her brain he would “shrivel up and die.” He compared his own brain to a twenty-four cylinder car that was forced never to use more than half of its power and Rene had been the only woman “that ever made me work on 24 cylinders and made me regret that I did not have 25.” He added that without using his twenty-four cylinders all the time, life was “as dull as flat ginger ale” and that Rene was “the only sparkplug I ever found that could handle my 24.” There was no reply.61 Nevertheless, before sailing to New York in late June 1931, Hendrik Willem mailed Rene another letter. He told her that “the Veere chapter is ended and Lorena gets the big Olympic medal for having kicked 240 pounds clear across the ocean, though little Rene could gain an even bigger one for all she will have to do is to get that same heavy-freight back by the help of a single smile. . . . Goodbye . . . the door remains open as wide as it ever has been . . . that door will remain open until they shall carry me out of it feet first and if they take the trouble to do a little dissecting they will find one name on my heart . . . Rene . . . whom I am a fool enough to love . . . love beyond everything . . . love beyond life.”62 There was a postscript the following summer. In June 1932 Hendrik Willem heard that Rene had planned to take a leave of absence from Maison Worth for a long holiday in Majorca and he wrongly concluded that her affair with Marcel Godfrey was on the rocks—ergo he was back in the picture. Without consulting her, he got Simon and Schuster to agree to publish a book by Rene about the Paris fashion world. Informing her about this plan, van Loon fantasized about their future. He expected to have “still fifteen perfectly good years before me” and wanted to spend these with her. After all, she was “the only woman who ever could make me into God” and with whom and from whom he wanted to have children. For his geography book he designed a dedication page that showed a reindeer—Rene, dear—that was looking at a globe that was fast moving through space and that represented himself. Only Jimmie knew the significance of the pictogram about which she remarked to Hendrik Willem, “Why not? She meant more to you than anybody else.”63 In her reply Rene accepted the challenge to write the book van Loon had in mind while making it plain to him that theirs was not to be a common future; she was still seeing Godfrey and he would go to Majorca with her. This drove van Loon up to the wall and in a single-spaced three-page letter he gave expression to his anger. When Rene visited New York that fall, she called to see whether he would look at the outline of the fashion book; he flatly said no and hung up. Without van Loon’s backing, Simon and Schuster did not
The Veere Paradise
135
pursue the book project and Rene returned to Paris. In due course she left Worth’s, married Marcel Godfrey, and disappeared from Hendrik Willem’s life for some years.64 After van Loon wrote this long and bitter letter to Rene, he and Jimmie, accompanied by some Westport friends, sailed to Holland. While they stayed in Veere for a month, a KLM pilot invited Hendrik Willem for a publicity flight to London in a new Fokker aircraft. Although he had been afraid, once inside the plane he enjoyed the ninety-minute flight as a “magnificent” experience. This first was also his last flight, however.65 Once Hendrik Willem left Holland late that summer, he would never see Veere again. But the picturesque little town where he had lived for three years remained an integral part of his mental makeup. Both in his self-designed stationery as well as in numerous book illustrations the silhouette of Veere would show up time and again, whereas in his private correspondence and books he frequently would refer to “that little paradise.” He named the house that he bought in Old Greenwich, Connecticut, Nieuw Veere. And in the foreword of his 1942 best seller Van Loon’s Lives he wrote that “Veere was the only completely satisfactory answer to the question: ‘Where can a civilized human being spend his days with the least possible minimum of irritation and the greatest possible maximum of inner satisfaction?’ ” Consequently, van Loon claimed that the few years spent in Veere “were the happiest years of my life.”66
This page intentionally left blank
Part IV
The 1930s
This page intentionally left blank
Chapter 11
The Educator (1931–1935) Upon arrival in New York in July 1931, van Loon found solace in his work. The New York Herald Tribune quoted him saying that “something in the atmosphere abroad . . . prevents Americans from working on subjects which they hope will interest American readers. He found that most American writers in Europe become victims of lassitude and instead of working they ‘just sit.’ ” And he wrote his mentor, George Burr, that he was back in New York toiling on another big project, his geography book: “Nothing remains of any real value except work. It may be a drug but it is such a pleasant drug . . . a drug and a companion at the same time and what else or what better arrangement has the good Lord ever offered to any of us?”1 That state of mind, however, had its ups and downs. Whereas in the sweltering New York summer heat he told Willem that he worked himself “into a state of complete anesthesia,” a few weeks later he complained, “I want adventure son, . . . something to do in the world beyond merely writing lousy little books.” In August, van Loon asked Roy W. Howard, chairman of the board of the Scripps-Howard newspapers with whom he had a friendly relationship, to advise him on what to do next: “Am I going to spend the next twenty years of my life working fifteen hours a day attacking the whole problem of education single handed?” He felt he was using only a part of his talents, telling Howard in another letter, “I was looking for some sort of way in which I could use all of my twelve cylinders instead of merely using six. I can always go on writing books. There is a steady market for them. They are read and apparently they are wanted. But while our planet is going through the present great upheaval, I have the feeling as if I were sitting safely on the grandstand while others are busy in the arena.”2 By October, the van Loons had settled in an apartment on Washington Square West, very close to where Jimmie’s tea room The Mad Hatter had
140
Va n L o o n
been. Meanwhile, Jimmie had undergone a hemorrhoid operation and Hendrik Willem sent her to California to recuperate. By early December she was back in New York.3 In the second half of August 1931 and through the first months of 1932, van Loon was incredibly productive. While writing the first draft of his geography book, he was writing dozens of articles for leading newspapers and magazines, including a series of twenty-three articles, entitled “Speaking of Revolution,” in The Nation. In October, Roy Howard, who owned the newly merged New York World-Telegram, asked him to sit in for Heywood Broun while the popular columnist of “It Seems to Me” went on a short holiday. Van Loon wrote this column anonymously for twelve days, temporarily renaming it “It Seems to the Spectator” and illustrating the title with a selfcaricature in the guise of Erasmus. Howard and van Loon were both pleased with the result.4 In addition, van Loon contributed four lengthy articles on “Philosophy of History” to the New York Herald Tribune, pieces to The Forum and the Saturday Review of Literature, and an essay, “If the Dutch Had Kept Nieuw Amsterdam,” to a book called If: or History Rewritten. About this last piece, he told Ruby Fuhr, “I faked the history so noble that now the fake seems more real than the real history.” Indeed, reading his counterfactual analysis, it is hard to deny that van Loon’s creative imagination made his story of New Netherland from 1674 to1930 into a plausible and “noble” history.5 Despite this output, he was looking for something that paid better. He wrote Willem, “My revenue is in inverse ratio to my reputation. I am infinitely better known than most writers but the spoils go to the cheap brethren and sisters who know how to write just what fits into the general make-up of our magazines and movies.” He thought he was unable to write for the magazines, because they were aiming at “the lowbrow and I am by nature the highbrow.” And in a letter to Ruby Fuhr, he angrily compared his rate for The Nation with that of his old friend Walter Lippmann, who got much more for writing what he termed “the platitudes of Moscow of yesteryear in an American gravy for the benefit of Hooverians of today.”6 After reading the first draft of what was to be published as Van Loon’s Geography: The Story of the World We Live In, his editor at Simon and Schuster, Clifton Fadiman, wanted him to cut the manuscript by about one quarter. Van Loon already had great confidence in his new publisher and editor. He praised the staff of Simon and Schuster as “the pleasantest people I ever worked with” and as “demon sales promoters” and described Fadiman as “the brains of the house in a literary way.” In that harmonious spirit, therefore, he agreed to remove “that literary overgrowth” from his manuscript. As he told Burr, “I can’t expect people to be building extensions to their houses for the mere purpose of putting little Hendrik’s books in them.”
The Educator
141
What gave him much satisfaction was that Dick Simon whetted the appetite of both the Literary Guild and the Book-of-the-Month Club for the upcoming Geography to get a bidding war started, which the Book-ofthe-Month Club won. And so, by May 1932, van Loon could write that Geography, three months before its publication, had already earned its costs for his publishers and that he had been given an additional advance.7 With the Great Depression in full swing and even bankers on the dole, van Loon knew this payment was a blessing. Meanwhile, the country was committing suicide, he thought, since so many people were doing nothing to end the crisis as they hoped for a return to prosperity. During the winter of 1932–1933 at least thirteen million people were unemployed in the United States and breadlines had become a common phenomenon in American cities. In fact, between 1929 and 1932 (the year when the Depression was at its worst), the suicide rate rose twenty-four percent.8 In February 1932 van Loon was confronted with the grim consequences of the Depression right at his doorstep. An old man shot himself right outside the window of the van Loons’ Washington Square apartment. Hendrik Willem reported to his son, “I wish that old man in the Square had chosen some other place to blow his brains out than right underneath our window. He looks like an absolutely helpless case, an unwanted and undesired asset to humanity. He looks very old and he is out of it but my God what a system, what a system and the Hoovers and these other grabbers prattling sweetly about sturdy individualism. The cops meanwhile have borrowed newspapers to cover him up and the mess. The cops, being Irish and having a certain training of decency about Death, handle the situation very decently. The crowd is held at a respectable distance.” After an ambulance removed the man’s remains and drove away quietly, without ringing “its everlasting gong,” he told Willem, “The park employees have got brushes and water and are scrubbing the sidewalk. It would not do for the dear kiddies to play there. Most of the time they play at racketeer anyway and shoot at each other with toy pistols. The sturdy individualism goes on even in the nursery. . . . The crowd has gone back to its own business and the world proceedeth as ever. Wonder who the poor old wreck was. No use looking in the paper tomorrow morning, there are so many of them.”9 Van Loon reported to his Dutch friend Henri Mayer that every day he heard of more people whom he knew losing all their money. In contrast to the despairing lives of many homeless and unemployed people on New York’s streets who had built shantytowns called “Hoovervilles” along Riverside Drive and had even moved into Central Park, stood the grand skyscrapers, conceived in the boom years of the 1920s and completed in the midst of the Great Depression, such as the seventy-seven story Chrysler Building in 1930, the 102-story Empire State Building in 1931, and Rockefeller Center
142
Va n L o o n
(including Radio City Music Hall and the RCA Building) in 1932. Because of the economic crisis, Manhattan’s skyscrapers contained many empty offices and Fifth Avenue, according to van Loon, now had the appearance of an empty small village street. He blamed a lot of the situation on the Prohibition and, as he wrote Ruby Fuhr, on the “pokergame in which for a few years every chip was called by a value it never had and never could have.”10 That spring, van Loon went to New Orleans to be the keynote speaker for the American Library Association. Despite the tiresome thirty-six-hour train ride “through the most unpleasant part of America,” he was in high spirits about the hearty welcome he was accorded in the Crescent City. In contrast to the lousy food he had experienced on the train, he praised the New Orleans restaurants for even serving better quality food than in Paris.11 Once van Loon was home, he illustrated his lecture text, and it was then published as To Have or To Be—Take Your Choice. Van Loon’s was the twelfth in a series of 25-cent pamphlets that included contributions by Walter Lippmann, Rexford G. Tugwell, Charles A. Beard, and even Joseph V. Stalin. His was, as he told George Burr, “an appeal to the younger generation of America,” aiming to answer “the perplexing questions of today. We have preached ‘to have’ and the acquisitive society has made us all yawn until we simply have lost interest.” Although he admitted that economics certainly played a part, the current crisis was in his view more spiritual. He complained to Ruby Fuhr that his pamphlet “tumbles into the ocean of oblivion and people don’t see it,” but he was glad that it had at least accomplished something: Maxim Gorky apparently read it and had allegedly said that the “only two dangerous enemies among the capitalistic classes writing history” were Hendrik Willem van Loon and Oswald Spengler.12 Van Loon also told the general session of the National Education Association in Atlantic City in early summer, that the Depression was mainly caused by the dominating and false philosophy of “To have rather than to be,” of size being substituted for contents and quantity for quality. In his opinion American society was “not suffering from an overproduction of material goods but from an underproduction of honest thinking.” He invited his audience of teachers to choose “to be” instead of “to have,” and to join him “in that new Declaration of Independence which holds that a man’s conscience is, and of right ought to be, superior to the size of his bank account.” He wrote Ruby Fuhr, “Until I was thirty I was a newspaperman and from thirty to fifty I wrote history to get a background and now I have a little background and so why not try to become America’s Greatest Exponent of Modern European Affairs . . . profound European background . . . vast linguistic ability . . . my humble literary reputation will open most doors.” In another letter that summer, he asked Roy Howard to contribute money to an appeal fund for the
The Educator
143
Scottsboro boys. Nine young African Americans had been convicted of rape, despite little or no evidence, by all-white juries in Alabama. Van Loon hoped that the Supreme Court would give the victims of southern racism some respite, “unless the merry holiday spirit of the crowd turns their prison into a bonfire.” The whole affair had made him realize once more that although justice should be the same for the rich and the poor, “the poor have a somewhat more difficult time getting hold of that money without which our legal machinery does not seem able to function.”13 Holland seemed to be far from his mind in the spring of 1932. At least in his correspondence he pretended it did not play a role anymore. “Holland lies millions of years behind me,” he wrote Willem. “Whenever I get news from that part of the world, I feel as if I heard a sharp little tinkly bell ringing in a small county store where you go to buy a loaf of bread . . . it is all so utterly uncomprehending . . . yes, they know a lot but understand nothing.” He thought, as he expressed it to the Dutch author Theun de Vries, that the people in his native country behaved as if they were living under a glass bell: they saw what was happening around them but did not understand a bit of it and were making long noses to the world. And to his old mentor Burr he confessed, “I hate to think what would have become of me had I remained in that Hollow Land of my birth. The fate of my good uncle awaited me. I don’t mean to say that it has always been so terribly easy over here, but I have at least been alive. Amen.”14 He not only found it problematic to deal with the Dutch in Holland, also the Dutch in the United States were not the kind of people he liked to be associated with. To Willem he reported that the Dutch in New York had established a new society, as he wrote sarcastically, “to propagate the Dutch idea in this country with the usual excellencies and stuffed shirts of various grades and sizes and having founded it with all due formality.” When this organization sent him an invitation to join their efforts, he flatly refused, exclaiming to his son, “Good God, I AM the Dutch idea here.”15 When, after his last summer trip to Veere, van Loon returned to New York in August 1932, he was immediately swept into good spirits by the astonishing sales of his Geography, which became a best seller even before its official publication date of 8 September (figure 11.1). He happily told Willem that “the swellest grandest book I ever writ” caused more excitement than anything else he had ever done before.16 Van Loon’s Geography opened with a preface in which the author stated, “History is the Fourth Dimension of Geography. It gives it both time and meaning.” Thus, the volume offers a lot of historical information in addition to the more traditional physical geographical data. The definition of geography
144
Va n L o o n
Figure 11.1 Hendrik Willem van Loon with Noodle at his New York Washington Square apartment with a copy of Van Loon’s Geography on the table, 1932 (Hendrik Willem van Loon Papers, 1884–1972. Courtesy of the Division of Rare and Manuscript Collections, Cornell University library).
he used for his book was “a study of man in search of food and shelter and leisure for himself and for his family and an attempt to find out the way in which man has either adapted himself to his background or has reshaped his physical surroundings in order to be as comfortable and well nourished and happy as seemed compatible with his own limited strength.” As a consequence, “Man comes first in this geography. His physical environment and background come next. The rest is given whatever space remains.” In other words, his was a “human” geography.17 Though the book deals with the world as a whole, it is Europe-centered. In the seven-page chapter about the Netherlands, van Loon could not suppress his pride on the cultural influence of his native country in the seventeenth century and ended with a comparison to ancient Athens: “Next to the territory of Attica, this narrow strip of land between the Rhine, the North Sea and the Zuyder Zee has probably contributed more to the sum total of our arts and sciences than any other region of similar diminutive proportions. Athens was a barren rock and Holland was a water-logged swamp. But they had two things in common . . . an excellent geographic location from the point of view of international commerce, and a superabundance of animal spirits and spiritual curiosity, left over from the days when they had
The Educator
145
been obliged to fight or perish. And out of these their glory was born.” However, there was a dark side to this glorious past and in his chapter on Africa van Loon did not hesitate to assign blame for the slave trade to the Dutch.18 In his conclusion, van Loon noted that easier and faster communication facilities had made the world a smaller place. This tied in with a theme earlier in the book, one for which he was often quoted: “We are all of us fellowpassengers on the same planet and we are all of us equally responsible for the happiness and well-being of the world in which we happen to live.” Here he showed himself to be a cosmopolitan, an attitude that contrasted with his simultaneously held WASP point of view on America’s ethnic minorities, especially the Catholics and Jews from southern and eastern Europe.19 The reviews were mostly positive, stimulating further sales. For instance, the Chicago Daily Tribune recommended it as “a grand book” to simple and sophisticated readers alike. Thomas Barbour, director of the Harvard Zoological Museum, in his review in the Atlantic Monthly, was among those who pointed out “some silly if unimportant blunders,” but he saluted the author “for his vast reading, his power to give the result of his industry to his public with a sharp clarity, a shrewd philosophy, and a graceful wit.” Van Loon’s friend Carl Van Doren, writing in the New York Herald Tribune, admitted that no doubt there would be experts who would criticize details, but hastened to say that Van Loon’s Geography was, “of course, van Loon’s geography. It deals with the earth and its human history not as a map-maker or a statistician might have done, but as a philosopher and a scholar, a wit and a poet has done. . . . Unsurpassed by any man of letters that Rotterdam has produced since Erasmus, van Loon is unequaled by any man of any sort that Holland has ever sent to America.”20 The success of his Geography—at the end of 1932, he estimated that he would net about $40,000 from the book that year, placing him in the top 1 percent of U.S. wage-earners—also kept van Loon in the news. In an interview with the New York Evening Post, he gave his opinion on such topics as the Depression (“Individualism, Hooverism, is the last rearguard action of the laissez-faire school: you know, each one for himself and the rest go to the breadline.”) and women, who he thought were more pragmatic than men. “I admire clever American women—they face reality, they face today’s problems.” Yet, in an article in the New York World-Telegram van Loon criticized the American woman for rarely knowing what she wants: “She insists upon equality with men, but she will not take it in the cold logical way of the European woman. The average American wife wants to be treated as if she were a first-class mistress.” In van Loon’s opinion it was “in the hardy climate of small Northern countries that one finds the happiest women in the world. These are the places where women not only have the most complete equality
146
Va n L o o n
with men, but also a serene sense of their own importance.” Therefore, he maintained, “Women in the Scandinavian countries, for example, have in the past ten years gone way ahead of the American women in economic and intellectual independence.” Van Loon also gave radio interviews and at least one of his speeches, about his one-world concept and a plea for economic internationalism, was broadcast. His Dutch accent, however, made it difficult for people to understand him at times.21 After the debacle with Rene Scudamore, Hendrik Willem set his eyes on June Hamilton Rhodes, a young woman active in the Democratic party. She politely declined his offer to become the fourth Mrs. van Loon and they remained friends. It was she who asked van Loon to contribute to the Democratic presidential campaign by writing an article about Franklin D. Roosevelt’s library.22 Van Loon had supported Alfred Smith for Democratic nomination and was skeptical about Roosevelt, the governor of New York and the presidential candidate. But when he met Franklin and Eleanor Roosevelt at a large lunch on 11 September at their Hyde Park estate, he was immediately charmed by the couple. His opinion on Roosevelt completely changed and afterward he wrote that FDR was “well-read and has a good library . . . knows German and French, is a cultivated man of the world.” He observed that Roosevelt was “much more crippled than most people know” and added, “gawd what a moral courage to run for THAT job when you are like that.” Ten days after his initial visit van Loon went back to Hyde Park to work on his article.23 When that article was published in the Saturday Review, van Loon described Roosevelt’s home Springwood, not as “a house with a library, but a library that is also a house,” so ubiquitous were the books. Most books were histories—particularly on naval and early American history—and biographies and books on current social and economic problems. There were hardly any novels or poetry. It had dawned on van Loon, he wrote, that Roosevelt, “to overcome the terrible obstacles and difficulties of the last ten years of his life”—a reference to FDR’s fight against polio—“had identified himself with his own historical past. He had made this part of his library the arsenal from which to arm himself for the inevitable encounters of the future.” In early November, just before her husband won the election, Eleanor Roosevelt sent van Loon a very complimentary letter about the article and expressed her wish to remain in touch. Over the ensuing years a warm friendship was established between the president and first lady and Hendrik Willem van Loon.24 That fall van Loon volunteered to present a weekly half-hour program on history for the small New York City socialist radio station WEVD, named in honor of Eugene V. Debs and founded by Oswald Garrison Villard, socialist
The Educator
147
leader Norman Thomas, and Heywood Broun. The program consisted of a twenty-minute talk and ten minutes of string quartet music from the period van Loon had talked about. The audience response was enthusiastic, and van Loon expanded the program by enlisting the cooperation of John Dewey, Fannie Hurst, Carl Van Doren, Elmer Davis, several scholars from Columbia and New York Universities, and many others. This resulted in the creation of the “University of the Air,” of which van Loon was made dean; it offered listeners five half-hour adult education programs per week on history, philosophy, music, theater, literature, psychology, and economics.25 In a letter to Roy Howard, van Loon explained that the idea of the University of the Air “was born one evening when I was thinking of the endlessly repeated accusation that the radio was an instrument of greed and private gain which with the exception of an occasional symphony concert or a lecture by some celebrity did absolutely nothing to educate the public at large.” The management of WEVD embraced his idea of putting on the radio “something a little more serious, something that should fill a need in the lives of those who still believe that education, even if it cannot cure all our ills, will be of tremendous help to carry us safely through the present social, spiritual and economic revolution.” Hendrik Willem was thankful for the many small donations from listeners, which funded the university and for “the number of people of eminence willing to give their services (and believe me, it means hard work, for the mike is an exacting taskmaster!).”26 Van Loon, who had discovered the speaking technique while sitting before a radio microphone, was completely different from standing at a public lectern, took the criticism about his accent seriously. He tried his best to be well understood. According to his judgmental younger son, van Loon’s “enormous bulk caused shortness of breath, which gave rise to unpredictable voice production. He would blast one minute and become inaudible the next.” Over the years, van Loon’s proficiency with the new medium improved markedly. In 1941 the entertainment-industry weekly Variety praised his “calm and mellowness that is frequently a happy change of pace from the hysterics of the commercial hit-that-line boys.” Although Hendrik Willem would always struggle with his accent, by this time he also had better control over his breath as the critic observed, “Obviously, under repeated engineering warnings he manages to keep a tendency to wheeze asthmatically into the mike’s very kisser down to an occasional flurry of air venting.”27 By the end of 1932 van Loon’s reputation as an educator seemed to be firmly established, as was shown by his name being included in “The Nation’s 1932 Honor Roll.” Van Loon was honored “for making geography the fascinating science it should be” and on this 1932 Honor Roll he was in the company of such distinguished Americans as Eleanor Roosevelt, U.S. Congressman and
148
Va n L o o n
soon to be mayor of New York Fiorello H. La Guardia, Supreme Court Justice Oliver Wendell Holmes, architect Frank Lloyd Wright, composer Aaron Copland, journalist Walter Lippmann, writers John Dos Passos and Van Wyck Brooks, and aviation pioneer and heroine Amelia Earhart.28 Between the success of Geography and the launch of the University of the Air, van Loon felt himself to be so much in the news that in January 1933 he wrote his son Willem, “I wish I could turn off the publicity . . . it is getting to be funny . . . every paper you open has something . . . people are beginning to suspect me of having a special couple of very active publicity people working for me and I have not even got a clipping bureau.” That spring van Loon lamented, “I am fame-poor the way other people are land-poor. I have too damn much fame and too little of everything else.” Surrounded by dull people he felt bored and told Willem, “I need laughter, son, as badly as a plant needs water and I get very little of it . . . I wish to God I could find some amusing female person with whom I could laugh and sleep the tedious hours of night away . . . I am shriveling and drying up from sheer boredom . . . work and work and work and nothing else.” To get out of this situation, he was thinking of taking a trip to Europe by himself that summer.29 In late June Jimmie went off for a holiday to California. Thinking he had become too dependent on Jimmie, Hendrik Willem expected separate vacations to be beneficial to their relationship. However, by the day he was to board the Bremen to sail to Europe, he lost courage and telephoned Jimmie in California to ask her to come to Europe, too, on another ship ten days later. That same day he also wrote her, “When you come to Europe, I shall first of all dress you in Paris and no kept woman shall ever have looked the way you do, you have grand looks, now make something of them and someday I shall not only be your husband but also your lover.” Despite the “Damn!” she wrote in her diary that day, Jimmie did travel back to New York and boarded an ocean liner for France.30 But hardly had van Loon started his transatlantic crossing than other women caught his eye. On board the Bremen he was introduced to a pair of identical twins, Ruth and Helen Hoffman, commercial artists in New York. Soon after landing, Ruth went off to Greece to visit the Englishman she had met on a previous trip to Europe; by then, Hendrik Willem was smitten with Helen, had proposed to her, and took her to Holland, where they visited the Rijksmuseum in Amsterdam and visited his sister, Suus, who wasn’t too pleased with her brother’s new infatuation. Back in Paris, Jimmie arrived and told Helen, “If you want Hendrik Willem, it’s okay with me,” and she went to Veere to pack the last of their belongings and say good-bye to her friends there and in Middelburg.31 Hendrik Willem and Helen, meanwhile, went to Bad Gastein, a spa in Austria. Van Loon had the time of his life, reporting to Willem, “I live like a
The Educator
149
vegetable, tended most motherly by the excellent Helen who keeps me to diet and sleeping hours as if I had been her offspring. . . . The pounds of overweight are disappearing, I can walk for three hours at a time and when you see me again I really may have your figure and they may take us for brothers.” After Ruth had joined them, van Loon, like a triumphant king, paraded the streets of Bad Gastein with an identically dressed twin beauty on either side of him. But though he praised the sisters in all his letters that summer to his son, he also came to the conclusion that “like all that sort of American women of extraordinary beauty, there never was any great necessity of using their brains,” and so for him, “no more entangling alliances in this life.” He did not say this to Helen, however.32 The Hoffman twins next went on to Italy, so van Loon returned to Paris, where he spent one week with Jimmie before she sailed home alone. Van Loon stayed for another month in the French capital. Shortly after his return to New York his first grandchild was born. Though named Hendrik Willem, Hank and Janet’s baby was immediately nicknamed Piet.33 Before his summer trip to Europe a representative of the New York office of the Netherlands Railways had asked van Loon to write a short, six-page travel guide to Holland “and a few of those funny little pictures. You know what we mean.” “As a farewell” to his native country now that his “Dutch days [were] over for good since Rembrandt,” van Loon agreed to write and illustrate this pamphlet but when van Loon sat down to write it, as he explained in the “Personal Confession to the Reader,” to his “great surprise it started to write itself,” mushrooming into a 117-page guidebook with fortyone pen drawings. To the Netherlands Railways he said: “Look here! You wanted a shrimp and I am giving you a whale.” After some discussions, the pamphlet-grown-into-a-book was published as An Indiscreet Itinerary or How the Unconventional Traveler Should See Holland. The “personally conducted tour through unknown territory,” including a historical background of the country, was well received in the American press.34 Right after his return to New York another van Loon book was published: An Elephant Up a Tree, a satire on present-day civilization disguised as a fable about an aristocratic elephant—the author himself—going to America on a tour of investigation. Van Loon compared with Candide and bragged in the New York Times, that whereas Voltaire had needed three days to write his book, he had written it in only two days. To his friend Alfred Harcourt he reported that the forty-eight hours writing “the whole damn 30,000 words at a stretch” had “completely exhausted” him and added, “I should not do such stunts at my age any more but ideas are bursting forth in me so like a volcano when the spouting is good.” But contrary to his travel guide to Holland, the reviews of this literary eruption were far from positive.35 Van Loon told both his son and Ruby Fuhr that Americans were misinterpreting his message, mostly because they did not understand irony.
150
Va n L o o n
About this time, he also told his son that he had come to the conclusion that Americans were “essentially different” from Europeans and that he himself would “never really be an integral part of this country, nor of any other either.”36 In his disappointment about the low sales of the elephant book he also blamed his publishers for not having done enough to promote it. In his view they should have arranged sessions for signing copies at well-known New York bookstores, at Macy’s and other locations, or they “could have hired an elephant from the Republican party headquarters for next to nothing these days” for a parade up Fifth Avenue, and added, “Why must I always think of those brilliant ideas?” “Disappointedly but as ever with fatherly affection and regret,” he warned Simon and Schuster that he was “brimful of ideas”; henceforward, instead of playing the role of the “author,” he would be the “educator.” He had studied his position in regard to the younger generation and had come to the conclusion that there was “a steady demand” for the educational books he could provide. He therefore had outlined a book plan for the coming years in which the first “hefty work with many pictures” would be a history of all the arts: architecture, sculpture, music, painting, and literature. “Don’t tell me that it can’t be done, for it can be done, and I see very distinctly how it can be done. . . . This is the time every high school in the land is interested in just this sort of thing and the teachers ask for literature upon the subject and there is none.”37 However, this was not a new plan: in 1929 he had announced to Horace Liveright that he was trying to consolidate his ideas about education. After finishing his Geography he would “give the school-world a sensible and understandable history of the arts and by general articles and such-like map out a policy which will turn me into one of the prophets of a new sort of education.” And in a promotional periodical of his British publisher George Harrap, The Harrap Mercury, van Loon in the spring of 1933 had said he was “absolutely convinced that the system of education as well as the systems of economics and politics and democracy and all the other systems that seemed so staunch and solid before the War need absolute revision”; it was his aim “to give the coming generations a new conception of the values of life and living [to] help guide mankind out of the present morass.” It was now up to him and other educators, he felt, “to show the road to a newer and happier world.” And in the fall of 1933, in a letter to the book department editor of Better Homes and Gardens, he had dramatically phrased his mission as follows: “in the present race between Anarchy and Education those of us who in some way (however small) can be of service should devote our time and energy to just one thing—to try to prevent a catastrophe from which the human race could never recover.” Hence, his one-world concept as expressed in his Geography and his “philosophy of tolerance and a more human existence,
The Educator
151
which has been the leitmotif, or theme, in all my books.” This vision of “the brotherhood of man, the imperative kinship of the nations,” was called van Loon’s “own New Deal” by a journalist of the New York Evening Post who had interviewed the author that summer and portrayed him in his article as “A man of elephantine proportions who emits ponderous groans to relieve pent-up mental processes, just as a volcano gives off smoke and gases.”38 In a moment of boredom, van Loon agreed to go on a five-month-long Cunard Line cruise as a “lecturer extraordinary.” He and Jimmie would have free passage and he would receive a fee of $5,000 for a series of “erudite and whimsically witty talks” (as Cunard’s ads promised) as the luxury liner Franconia made its way around the world on an itinerary concentrating on the Southern Hemisphere. As the departure date of 9 January 1934, neared, Hendrik Willem was not exactly looking forward to the adventure; he told Ruby Fuhr, “The trip looms before my eyes like an ice barrier.” The boat left New York for the Caribbean and he spent his fifty-second birthday at Kingston, Jamaica, pleased to see, as he observed to Alice Bernheim, that “the nice crowd on board [was] much better than expected.” Nonetheless, as the Franconia approached the Panama Canal and Hendrik Willem had problems adjusting to the heat, he decided to arrange more simpatico company. He dispatched a radiogram to Helen Hoffman asking her to join him. She met the ship in Los Angeles before it set sail for Hawaii and New Zealand. Hendrik Willem and Helen passed the time by drawing together (many of their pieces would end up in his 1940 volume The Story of the Pacific) and he also prepared his lectures, while Jimmie preferred the liner’s daily cocktail hour. Once they got to Australia, they went ashore to a warm welcome from Sir Charles Kingsford-Smith and his wife. Van Loon also delivered lectures while in Sydney and, he boasted to Alice, made “a nationwide broadcast—I mean a continent-wide broadcast, which was something new in my little life. The strange thing to me is that those funny books of mine seem to have wandered all over the globe and that they want to hear further new things from me.”39 His visit to Bali was indeed a high point, but he was offended by a sarcastic article written by the Bali correspondent of the Indische Courant, a Dutch language newspaper published in the capital of the Netherlands East Indies, Batavia. The Dutch grieved him again! he thought. And was it a coincidence that on this Dutch territory he was not asked to speak? As the Franconia churned westward through the Indian Ocean and they were halfway through the cruise, van Loon began to get tired of “these endless islands where time has not yet been discovered.” He concluded that he was “[n]ot born for the tropics,” an impression confirmed by an arduous three-day trip overland to Colombo, Ceylon. Fortunately, however, once they reached Capetown he
152
Va n L o o n
found a climate more to his liking, and he was delighted to be lionized there. He gave six well received lectures in South Africa—to the delight of Afrikaner audiences, he spoke in Dutch—and another nationwide radio broadcast and the South African prime minister invited him to lunch. But here, too, a Dutchman spoiled his pleasure: the local correspondent for a Dutch newspaper wrote that although van Loon was an experienced speaker who was able to create enthusiasm among large audiences, “when all was said and done it was just a small fireworks of words and sentences,”—that is, nothing that would really merit serious attention.40 When by mid-May the Franconia called on Buenos Aires and Rio de Janeiro, the end of the trip was nearing, to van Loon’s great delight. The hardest part, he told Alice in another of his frequent shipboard letters, had been “the complete absence of people of one’s own ilk. There just was not a soul— not a single blessed soul with whom to get into intellectual and spiritual contact”; he was looking forward to a summer in the wilderness of Vermont. (As for the lack of intellectual camaraderie on board, there may be another side to the story: H.L. Mencken reports in his memoir the rumor in New York that during van Loon’s world cruise “many of the passengers aboard the tour ship were jumping overboard to escape him.”)41 After a last stop at Barbados, the Franconia docked in New York exactly on schedule on 31 May. Although upon arrival van Loon told a New York Times reporter that he didn’t like the tropics and that in his view “the white man ought to stay out of them,” several months later, he expressed his “happy remembrances” of the cruise. Not only was he impressed by the exotic beauty of that part of the world, but his opinion of his fellow passengers also seemed to have mellowed: the trip had “transformed me from a suspicious pessimist to an avowed optimist, [being confirmed] that this is a good world and a world in which all of us could be reasonably happy if we applied our intelligence to the problem of living as we have thus far to the problem of making a living.” He was especially pleased to get letters almost every week from people “who were complete strangers until we set foot on their little island and who are now friends for life.” Last but not least, the cruise in the Southern Hemisphere had lit “a little candle in the dark caverns of my ignorance [of ] all those distant countries.”42 Van Loon did indeed spend the summer of 1934 in Dorset, Vermont, where he and Jimmie enjoyed the company of Hank, Janet, and his grandson. On one memorable occasion he hosted Sir Charles Kingsford-Smith, who was en route from Australia to England, and Amelia Earhart. According to Jimmie, the two aviation pioneers “liked each other immensely.” Sadly enough, both heroes of the sky would disappear during ocean flights, Kingsford-Smith in 1935 and Earhart two years later. In August van Loon and Helen Hoffman
The Educator
153
had a joint exhibit at Macy’s of their Franconia drawings and watercolors. Van Loon’s aim for that exhibit, he told George Burr, was “to establish the fact that I am a serious artist.” He was pleased, therefore, with the positive notices in the New York Times and the New York Herald Tribune.43 No matter how much he liked her, van Loon had lost his romantic interest in Helen Hoffman. As he told his son Willem, while in Dorset in July, “I have lots of swell jobs before me . . . and am not interested in all the normal interests of normal females of 34.”44 That summer and fall van Loon worked on a book called Ships and How They Sailed the Seven Seas. He also published articles in Esquire and the Atlantic Monthly, and enthusiastically prepared for another winter season of WEVD University of the Air radio broadcasts. As he explained to a friend, “Anything we can do to help educate the masses is the thing to do just now.” This was especially so since in his opinion the big radio stations filled the air with “terrible bilge”—in a letter to the New York Herald Tribune he voiced his “protest against the ghastly stuff that drippeth all day long from the air by way of the big stations”—and he dramatically termed the thing he was doing on WEVD “a race between education and anarchy.” Van Loon was very pleased, therefore, that two months ahead of the opening evening on 8 December of the University of the Air’s new season in New York’s Town Hall all 1,800 seats were sold out for the event and that the Radio Commission had doubled the voltage in return for the public service rendered by WEVD. To Eleanor Roosevelt, whom he invited for the opening session, he expressed his pleasure in doing this unpaid work of “popular enlightenment” for WEVD and added, “If the President ever wants a station on which he can really say what must sometimes be on his mind, we shall be very happy to offer him our hospitality; no copy read, no restrictions, and a sense of humor and good humor, which I never found on one of the commercial stations.”45 At the end of October the van Loons moved to a furnished house in Riverside, Connecticut. From this village between Stamford and Greenwich van Loon frequently commuted to New York; he and Jimmie also often invited guests to the big rented house, which had many spare bedrooms, four bathrooms, eight toilets, a three-car garage, and even its own private beach. Having no interest in housekeeping at all, Jimmie secured the services of a German couple, Ida and Fritz Kroeschl, to live in and run the household.46 That fall van Loon turned down an offer to become editor in chief of the New York Evening Post, but he did agree to write a daily column for William Randolph Hearst’s King Features Syndicate. Starting in November 1934, millions of Americans all over the country could now read in their local newspapers van Loon’s column “Meet the Commentator,” which ran six days a week. In New York “Meet the Commentator” was published in the Daily Mirror.47
154
Va n L o o n
In his first column van Loon introduced himself to the readers as a commentator “upon affairs both serious and mild” who was more than ever convinced “that a thorough and sober-minded understanding of the past is the best of all possible safeguards for the happiness of our future.” He made it clear that he had “no axes to grind and no doctrines to preach.” As a real educator he had “only one duty to perform. I must tell you how things were in the beginning, how they developed afterward and how therefore they had to become what they are today. When that has been done, I shall take my bow and bid you farewell. For then we enter upon the realm of ‘final conclusions,’ and those, my friends, are up to you.”48 Van Loon used this daily platform to present his thoughts on numerous topics that he picked from history and daily life in the United States. When commenting on European affairs, he showed himself to be a convinced isolationist. As he wrote in one column, “There is not a single foreign problem that is worth the bones of a single American buck private.” And in his comments on the United States he made it clear that his complete allegiance went to the America as the Founding Fathers had in mind when they formulated the Constitution—“an America that was to be a country of about equal wealth and an absolute equality of opportunity for everybody.” However, in van Loon’s opinion there was also an entirely different America that disgusted him so thoroughly that he was willing to fight it. That was the selfish greed, which had exploited the riches of the country and had attracted millions of immigrants who did not care about the ideals of the Founding Fathers, turning the country into what Theodore Roosevelt had phrased “a polyglot boarding-house.” In such a climate ideals were for sale at the next election, van Loon thought, and he expressed his concern that “the moron and the mucker are at the gates. Some day, we may have to fight them, or they will destroy everything we ourselves deem necessary for our intellectual happiness.”49 By February 1935 van Loon was already expressing severe doubts about working for Hearst. He complained that instead of the liberty that was promised him to write whatever he liked, Hearst’s editorial policy interfered more and more with this agreement. He was especially upset to discover that Hearst was friendly to Hitler and that articles of his in which he severely criticized Hitler were refused. This situation let to a row and in April to the termination of his contract. For van Loon it was a relief and he wrote his son, “I am, God be glorified, out of the Hearst affair. Simply could not make it. It was like playing the Brahms concerto in a whorehouse. No matter how well you play—or how wonderful the music—it is still a whorehouse. I shall be very poor again but also very happy. It was impossible to work with that man.”50 In November 1934, shortly after he had moved to Riverside, van Loon heard a pianist on the radio perform a Brahms sonata so well, that he stayed tuned
The Educator
155
afterward to catch the