JOBNAME: Wheatley PAGE: 1 SESS: 8 OUTPUT: Thu May 13 10:07:10 2010
THE DEMOCRATIC LEGITIMACY OF INTERNATIONAL LAW The objective of this work is to restate the requirements of democratic legitimacy in terms of the deliberative ideal developed by Jürgen Habermas, and apply the understanding to the systems of global governance. The idea of democracy requires that the people decide, through democratic procedures, all policy issues that are politically decidable. But the state is not a voluntary association of free and equal citizens; it is a construct of international law, and subject to international law norms. Political self-determination takes places within a framework established by domestic and international public law. A compensatory form of democratic legitimacy for inter-state norms can be established through deliberative forms of diplomacy and a requirement of consent to international law norms, but the decline of the Westphalian political settlement means that the two-track model of democratic self-determination is no longer sufficient to explain the legitimacy and authority of law. The emergence of non-state sites for the production of global norms that regulate social, economic and political life within the state requires an evaluation of the concept of (international) law and the (legitimate) authority of non-state actors. Given that states retain a monopoly on the coercive enforcement of law and the primary responsibility for the guarantee of the public and private autonomy of citizens, the legitimacy and authority of the laws that regulate the conditions of social life should be evaluated by each democratic state. The construction of a multiverse of democratic visions of global governance by democratic states will have the practical consequence of democratising the international law order, providing democratic legitimacy for international law. Volume 29 in the series Studies in International Law
Columns Design Ltd
/
Job: Wheatley
/
Division: Prelims
/Pg. Position: 1 /
Date: 13/5
JOBNAME: Wheatley PAGE: 2 SESS: 8 OUTPUT: Thu May 13 10:07:10 2010
Studies in International Law Volume 1: Between Light and Shadow: The World Bank, the International Monetary Fund and International Human Rights Law Mac Darrow Volume 2: Toxics and Transnational Law: International and European Regulation of Toxic Substances as Legal Symbolism Marc Pallemaerts Volume 3: The Chapter VII Powers of the United Nations Security Council Erika de Wet Volume 4: Enforcing International Law Norms Against Terrorism Edited by Andrea Bianchi Volume 5: The Permanent International Criminal Court Edited by Dominic McGoldrick, Peter Rowe and Eric Donnelly Volume 6: Regional Organisations and the Development of Collective Security Ademola Abass Volume 7: Islamic State Practices, International Law and the Threat from Terrorism: A Critique of the ‘Clash of Civilizations’ in the New World Order Javaid Rehman Volume 8: Predictablity and Flexibility in the Law of Maritime Delimitation Yoshifumi Tanaka Volume 9: Biotechnology and International Law Edited by Francesco Francioni and Tullio Scovazzi Volume 10: The Development of Human Rights Law by the Judges of the International Court of Justice Shiv Bedi Volume 11: The Environmental Accountability of the World Bank to Third Party Non-State Actors Alix Gowlland-Gualtieri Volume 12: Transnational Corporations and Human Rights Edited by Olivier De Schutter Volume 13: Biotechnologies and International Human Rights Edited by Francesco Francioni Volume 14: Human Security and International Law: Prospects and Problems Barbara Von Tigerstrom Volume 15: The Arms Trade and International Law Zeray Yihdego Volume 16: Africa: Mapping New Boundaries in International Law Edited by Jeremy Levitt Volume 17: Forced Migration, Human Rights and Security Edited by Jane McAdam Volume 18: The Use of Nuclear Weapons and the Protection of the Environment during International Armed Conflict Erik Koppe
Columns Design Ltd
/
Job: Wheatley
/
Division: Prelims
/Pg. Position: 2 /
Date: 13/5
JOBNAME: Wheatley PAGE: 3 SESS: 3 OUTPUT: Tue May 11 14:32:06 2010
Volume 19: The Shifting Allocation of Authority in International Law: Considering Sovereignty, Supremacy and Subsidiarity Edited by Tomer Broude and Yuval Shany Volume 20: Counterterrorism: Democracy’s Challenge Edited by Andrea Bianchi and Alexis Keller Volume 21: Amnesty, Human Rights and Political Transitions Louise Mallinder Volume 22: Property Rights and Natural Resources Richard Barnes Volume 23: Human Dignity and the Foundations of International Law Patrick Capps Volume 24: Sovereignty and the Stateless Nation: Gibraltar in the Modern Legal Context Keith Azopardi Volume 25: The International Court of Justice and Self-Defence in International Law James A Green Volume 26: State Liability in Investment Treaty Arbitration: Global Constitutional and Administrative Law in the BIT Generation Santiago Montt Volume 27: Reappraising the Resort to Force: International Law, Jus ad Bellum and the War on Terror Lindsay Moir Volume 28: International Law and Dispute Settlement: New Problems and Techniques Edited by Duncan French, Matthew Saul and Nigel White Volume 29: The Democratic Legitimacy of International Law Steven Wheatley
Columns Design Ltd
/
Job: Wheatley
/
Division: Prelims
/Pg. Position: 3 /
Date: 25/2
JOBNAME: Wheatley PAGE: 4 SESS: 3 OUTPUT: Tue May 11 14:32:06 2010
Columns Design Ltd
/
Job: Wheatley
/
Division: Prelims
/Pg. Position: 4 /
Date: 25/2
JOBNAME: Wheatley PAGE: 5 SESS: 3 OUTPUT: Tue May 11 14:32:06 2010
The Democratic Legitimacy of International Law
Steven Wheatley
Columns Design Ltd
/
Job: Wheatley
/
Division: Prelims
/Pg. Position: 1 /
Date: 25/2
JOBNAME: Wheatley PAGE: 6 SESS: 8 OUTPUT: Thu May 13 10:19:43 2010
Published in the United Kingdom by Hart Publishing Ltd 16C Worcester Place, Oxford, OX1 2JW Telephone: +44 (0)1865 517530 Fax: +44 (0)1865 510710 E-mail:
[email protected] Website: http://www.hartpub.co.uk Published in North America (US and Canada) by Hart Publishing c/o International Specialized Book Services 920 NE 58th Avenue, Suite 300 Portland, OR 97213–3786 USA Tel: +1 503 287 3093 or toll-free: (1) 800 944 6190 Fax: +1 503 280 8832 E-mail:
[email protected] Website: http://www.isbs.com © Steven Wheatley 2010 Steven Wheatley has asserted his right under the Copyright, Designs and Patents Act 1988, to be identified as the author of this work. All rights reserved. No part of this publication may be reproduced, stored in a retrieval system, or transmitted, in any form or by any means, without the prior permission of Hart Publishing, or as expressly permitted by law or under the terms agreed with the appropriate reprographic rights organisation. Enquiries concerning reproduction which may not be covered by the above should be addressed to Hart Publishing Ltd at the address above. British Library Cataloguing in Publication Data Data Available ISBN: 978-1-84113-817-6
Typeset by Columns Design Ltd, Reading Printed and bound in Great Britain by TJ International Ltd, Padstow, Cornwall
Columns Design Ltd
/
Job: Wheatley
/
Division: Prelims
/Pg. Position: 2 /
Date: 13/5
JOBNAME: Wheatley PAGE: 7 SESS: 6 OUTPUT: Tue May 11 14:32:06 2010
For Mum
Columns Design Ltd
/
Job: Wheatley
/
Division: Prelims
/Pg. Position: 3 /
Date: 26/3
JOBNAME: Wheatley PAGE: 8 SESS: 3 OUTPUT: Tue May 11 14:32:06 2010
Columns Design Ltd
/
Job: Wheatley
/
Division: Prelims
/Pg. Position: 4 /
Date: 25/2
JOBNAME: Wheatley PAGE: 9 SESS: 3 OUTPUT: Tue May 11 14:32:06 2010
Acknowledgements Some of the arguments developed here have been presented at seminars at the universities of Edinburgh, Lancaster, University College London, Liverpool, Newcastle, Nottingham, Sydney and Basel Institute on Governance. Many thanks to the participants for the very helpful comments. Thanks also to Sarah Blandy and Anne Peters for comments on parts of the work (the usual caveat applies). I would wish to express gratitude to my parents Michael and Rosaleen for their support over many years, to my wife Katherine for her encouragement and affection, to Francesca for the daily chats, and to Misty for dragging me out for a walk every day. Whalley (Lancashire), August 2009.
Columns Design Ltd
/
Job: Wheatley
/
Division: Prelims
/Pg. Position: 1 /
Date: 25/2
JOBNAME: Wheatley PAGE: 10 SESS: 3 OUTPUT: Tue May 11 14:32:06 2010
Columns Design Ltd
/
Job: Wheatley
/
Division: Prelims
/Pg. Position: 2 /
Date: 25/2
JOBNAME: Wheatley PAGE: 11 SESS: 8 OUTPUT: Thu May 13 10:39:04 2010
Contents Acknowledgements ix Table of Cases xv Table of International Treaties, Conventions and other Legal Instruments xviii Table of General Assembly Resolutions xxiii Introduction Globalisation and the Democratic Deficit The Democratic Legitimacy of International Law The Structure of the Book
1 2 11 15
1 The Democratic Deficit in Global Governance The ‘Vertical’ Complaint The ‘Horizontal’ Complaint The ‘Ideological’ Complaint The Democratisation of Global Governance Reaffirming Sovereignty A Global Democratic State A Global Democratic Federation A Democratic Peace Perpetual Peace A Law of Peoples Cosmopolitan Democratic Law Democratising International Institutions International Parliamentary Assemblies A UN Parliamentary Assembly The Accountability Deficit The Role of Experts The Accountability of International Organisations Global Discourses: the Role of International Civil Society Conclusion
22 23 28 31 33 34 43 47 50 51 54 60 64 65 67 71 72 79 83 89
2 Democracy Within and Beyond the State International Law and the Democratic Deficit Politically Decidable Issues Deliberative Democracy Deliberative Majorities Deliberative Politics Human Rights in a Democracy The Parliamentary Principle of Democracy
Columns Design Ltd
/
Job: Wheatley
/
Division: Prelims
92 94 98 102 106 108 109 112
/Pg. Position: 1 /
Date: 13/5
JOBNAME: Wheatley PAGE: 12 SESS: 8 OUTPUT: Thu May 13 10:39:04 2010
xii
Contents Challenging Democratic Truths: the Role of Judicial Review Deliberative Democracy Beyond the State Conclusion
113 115 121
3 The State as (Democratic) Self-Legislator The Sovereign State The State as Self-Legislator Contractual Autonomy Law-Making Treaties Deliberative Diplomacy The Indeterminacy of International Law Obligations The Problem of Customary International Law The Role of the International Law Profession A Modern Form of Customary International Law General Principles of Law The Writings of Publicists and Judgments of Courts The Writings of Publicists The Judgments of Courts Conclusion
123 124 128 133 135 138 145 150 152 154 155 157 157 158 161
4 The Constitutionalisation of International Law From Contract to Governance Community Interests and Constitutionalisation The Constitutionalisation of International Law The Normative Hierarchy of International Law Article 103, Charter of the United Nations The International Constitution The International Constitutional Order Liberal Democratic Values in International Law Rule of Law International Human Rights Law Human Rights in the United Nations System The Construction of the Liberal State Conclusion
163 164 171 175 176 179 182 187 193 194 198 202 207 210
5 Democracy in International Law Democracy in International Law Democratic Self-Determination A (Human) Right to Democracy Democracy in the Practice of States Membership of International Organisations Democracy in the International Law Order
211 212 213 219 222 223 228
Columns Design Ltd
/
Job: Wheatley
/
Division: Prelims
/Pg. Position: 2 /
Date: 13/5
JOBNAME: Wheatley PAGE: 13 SESS: 8 OUTPUT: Thu May 13 10:39:04 2010
Contents Democratic Regime Change in International Law Operation Enduring Freedom (Afghanistan) Operation Iraqi Freedom Conclusion
xiii 231 235 237 245
6 International Governance by Non-State Actors Global Governance International ‘Soft’ Law Non-State Actors as Law-Makers The UN Security Council ‘Networks’ of Officials: Basel Committee on Banking Standards Public-Private Partnerships: World Commission on Dams Private International Governance Schemes Governance by Non-State Actors
264 267 269 271
7 A Concept of (International) Law The Concept of (State) Law Autopoiesis: Law as a Closed System of Communication Global Bukowina The Fragmentation of International Law Constitutionalisation Beyond the State The Idea of Law The Idea of Authority Democracy and the Concept of Authority A Revised Concept of Law
277 277 280 286 289 292 296 300 303 309
8 Deliberative Democracy Beyond the State The Idea of Constituent Power Democracy and the Exercise of Political Authority Those ‘Affected’/‘Subjected’ The Political Concept of Global Justice Conclusion
311 312 315 322 327 331
9 Democracy in Conditions of Global Legal Pluralism Pluralism in Global Governance Normative Pluralism What is Legal Pluralism? Global Legal Pluralism Rethinking Global Legal Pluralism State Law and International Law Relationship Between Democracy and International Law The Limits of International Law Democracy-Enhancing International Law
334 335 338 341 343 345 350 360 361 363
Columns Design Ltd
/
Job: Wheatley
/
Division: Prelims
/Pg. Position: 3 /
247 249 253 256 257
Date: 13/5
JOBNAME: Wheatley PAGE: 14 SESS: 8 OUTPUT: Thu May 13 10:39:04 2010
xiv Contents Constitutional Self-Limitation International Law as a Pre-Commitment Device A Contestable International Rule of Law Conclusion
365 368 369 371
Conclusion: Democracy and the Public International Lawyer
377
Selected Bibliography Index
383 395
Columns Design Ltd
/
Job: Wheatley
/
Division: Prelims
/Pg. Position: 4 /
Date: 13/5
JOBNAME: Wheatley PAGE: 1 SESS: 3 OUTPUT: Thu May 13 10:42:45 2010
Table of Cases African Commission on Human and Peoples’ Rights Constitutional Rights Project and Civil Liberties Organisation v Nigeria (31 October 2008) ................................................................................................ 225
European Court of Human Rights Hirst v United Kingdom (No 2) Reports of Judgments and Decisions 2005-IX .................................................................................................................. 221 Ždanoka v Latvia, App No 58278/00, judgment 16 march 2006 ....................... 221
European Court of Justice/Court of First Instance Kadi v Council of the European Union (Case C-402/05 P) [2008] ECR I-6351 ........................................................................................................... 262 Kadi v Council of the European Union (Case T-315/01) [2005] ECR II-3649 .. 262 NV Algemene Transporten Expeditie Onderneming van Gend en Loos v Netherlands Inland Revenue Administration (Case 26/62) [1963] ECR 1 .................................................................................................................... 275 Roquettes Frères v Council (Case 138/79) [1980] ECR 3333 ................................. 66
International Court of Justice Application of the Convention on the Prevention and Punishment of the Crime of Genocide (Bosnia and Herzegovina v Serbia and Montenegro) (Preliminary Objections) [1996] ICJ Rep 595 ......................................... 198, 262 Armed Activities on the Territory of the Congo (Democratic Republic of the Congo v Rwanda), judgment 3 February 2006 ..................................... 177, 213 Avena and other Mexican Nationals (Mexico v United States) [2004] ICJ Rep 12 ................................................................................................................... 356 Barcelona Traction, Light and Power Company Limited [1970] ICJ Rep 3 ..... 176, 178, 179 Certain expenses of the United Nations (Advisory Opinion) [1962] ICJ Rep 151 ................................................................................................................... 11 Continental Shelf (Libyan Arab Jarnahiriya/Malta) [1985] ICJ Rep 13 ............ 130 Corfu Channel Case [1949] ICJ Rep 4 ............................................................. 172, 176
Columns Design Ltd
/
Job: Wheatley
/
Division: Tables
/Pg. Position: 1 /
Date: 13/5
JOBNAME: Wheatley PAGE: 2 SESS: 2 OUTPUT: Tue May 11 14:32:06 2010
xvi Table of Cases Delimitation of the Maritime Boundary in the Gulf of Maine Area [1984] ICJ Rep 246 ......................................................................................................... 150, 354 East Timor (Portugal v Australia) [1995] ICJ Rep 90 ............................................ 213 Gabcikovo-Nagymaros Project (Hungary/Slovakia) [1997] ICJ Rep 7 ...... 11, 133, 154, 254 Interpretation of the Agreement of 25 March 1951 between the WHO and Egypt (Advisory Opinion) [1980] ICJ Rep 73 ................................................ 273 Legal Consequences of the Construction of a Wall in the Occupied Palestinian Territory (Advisory Opinion) [2004] ICJ Rep 136 ................ 179, 213, 240, 244 Legal Consequences for States of the Continued Presence of South Africa in Namibia (South-West Africa) notwithstanding Security Council Resolution 276 (1970) (Advisory Opinion) [1971] ICJ Rep 16 ... 133, 242, 256, 258 Legality of the Threat or Use of Nuclear Weapons (Advisory Opinion) [1996] ICJ Rep 226 .............................................................................. 172, 176, 272 Legality of the Use by a State of Nuclear Weapons in Armed Conflict (Advisory Opinion) [1996] ICJ Rep 66 .................................................. 273—274 Military and paramilitary activities in and against Nicaragua (Nicaragua v United States) Merits [1986] ICJ Rep 14 ............................ 34, 35, 128, 151, 154, 180, 212, 222, 336 North Sea Continental Shelf [1969] ICJ Rep 3 ............................................... 151, 291 Questions of interpretation and application of the 1971 Montreal Convention arising from the aerial incident at Lockerbie (Libya v United States) [1992] ICJ Rep 114 ...................................................................................... 181, 261 Reparation for injuries suffered in the service of the United Nations (Advisory Opinion) [1949] ICJ Rep 174 .......................................................... 166 Reservations to the Convention on the Prevention and Punishment of the Crime of Genocide (Advisory Opinion) [1951] ICJ Rep 15 .................. 202 South West Africa (Ethiopia v South Africa; Liberia v South Africa) (Second Phase) [1966] ICJ Rep 6 ...................................................................... 181 Territorial Dispute (Libyan Arab Jamahiriya/Chad) [1994] ICJ Rep 6 ............. 145 United States Diplomatic and Consular Staff in Tehran (United States of America v Iran) [1980] ICJ Rep 3 .......................................... 47, 128, 138, 203 Western Sahara (Advisory Opinion) [1975] ICJ Rep 12 ....................................... 214
Columns Design Ltd
/
Job: Wheatley
/
Division: Tables
/Pg. Position: 2 /
Date: 11/5
JOBNAME: Wheatley PAGE: 3 SESS: 5 OUTPUT: Thu May 13 11:18:45 2010
Table of Cases xvii International Criminal Tribunal for Yugoslavia Prosecutor v Dusko Tadic, Case No IT-94–1-AR72 (1996) 35 ILM 32 ......... 48, 262
Permanent Court of International Justice Certain German Interests in Polish Upper Silesia (1926) PCIJ Series A No 7 ........................................................................................................ 25, 158, 159 Jurisdiction of the Courts of Danzig, PCIJ Series B No 15 .......................... 204, 356 ‘Lotus’ (1927) PCIJ Series A No 10 .................................................................. 128, 134 Mavrommatis Palestine Concessions (1924) PCIJ Series A No 2 ........................ 130 Treatment of Polish Nationals and Other Persons of Polish Origin or Speech in the Danzig Territory (1931) PCIJ Series A/B No 44 ............. 25, 356 ‘Wimbledon’ (1923) PCIJ Series A No 1 .................................................................. 129
UN Human Rights Committee Chief Bernard Ominayak and the Lubicon Lake Band v Canada (10 May 1990) Communication No 167/1984 .......................................................................... 344 Gillot v France (26 July 2002) Communication No 932/2000 ............................. 215
National Cases Canada Reference re Secession of Quebec (1998) 2 SCR 217 ............................................. 229
Germany Judgment on the Acts approving the Treaty of Lisbon, BVerfG, 2 BvE 2/08 of 30 June 2009 .................................................................................................... 366
United States Medellin v Texas 128 S Ct 1346 (2008) .................................................................... 356
Columns Design Ltd
/
Job: Wheatley
/
Division: Tables
/Pg. Position: 3 /
Date: 13/5
JOBNAME: Wheatley PAGE: 4 SESS: 4 OUTPUT: Thu May 13 11:11:45 2010
Table of International Treaties, Conventions and other Legal Instruments African Charter on Democracy, Elections and Governance ................................ 225 art 4(2) ...................................................................................................................... 225 art 17 ......................................................................................................................... 225 art 19 ......................................................................................................................... 225 art 48 ......................................................................................................................... 225 African Charter on Human and Peoples’ Rights .................................................. 221 art 9 ........................................................................................................................... 221 art 10 ......................................................................................................................... 221 art 11 ......................................................................................................................... 221 art 13(1) .................................................................................................................... 221 art 20(1) .................................................................................................................... 221 American Convention on Human Rights art 13 ......................................................................................................................... 221 art 15 ......................................................................................................................... 221 art 16 ......................................................................................................................... 221 art 23(1) .................................................................................................................... 221 Charter Charter Charter Charter
of of of of
the Association of Southeast Asian Nations (ASEAN) 228 the Organization of American States ........................................... 225–226 Paris for a New Europe (CSCE) ........................................................... 227 the United Nations ......... 95, 130, 171, 175, 179, 183, 184, 185, 186, 187, 188, 195, 200, 203, 213, 216, 224, 231, 233, 239, 264 Preamble .................................................................................................................. 216 Chap V ..................................................................................................................... 183 Chap VII .......................................................................... 183, 232, 240, 258, 259, 355 art 1 ........................................................................................................................... 213 art 1(1) ...................................................................................................................... 231 art 1(3) .............................................................................................................. 203, 216 art 2(1) ........................................................................................................................ 29 art 2(4) ...................................................................................................... 231, 232, 233 art 2(6) .............................................................................................................. 181, 258 art 2(7) ...................................................................................................... 167, 203, 355 art 4 ........................................................................................................................... 186 art 4(1) ...................................................................................................................... 224 art 10 ......................................................................................................................... 255 art 17 ........................................................................................................................... 69 art 17(2) ....................................................................................................................... 11 art 22 ........................................................................................................................... 68
Columns Design Ltd
/
Job: Wheatley
/
Division: Tables
/Pg. Position: 1 /
Date: 13/5
JOBNAME: Wheatley PAGE: 5 SESS: 2 OUTPUT: Tue May 11 14:32:06 2010
Table of International Treaties, Conventions and other Legal Instruments
xix
art 23(1) .................................................................................................................... 258 art 24 ......................................................................................................................... 263 art 24(1) ............................................................................................................ 181, 258 art 25 ................................................................................................................. 181, 258 art 27(2) .................................................................................................................... 258 art 27(3) .............................................................................................................. 29, 183 art 31 ......................................................................................................................... 260 art 33(1) .................................................................................................................... 145 art 39 ......................................................................................................................... 262 art 42 ......................................................................................................................... 233 art 48(1) .......................................................................................................... 181, 2558 art 51 ................................................................................................................. 232, 233 art 53(1) .................................................................................................................... 233 art 55 ......................................................................................................................... 203 art 55(c) ..................................................................................................................... 203 art 73 ......................................................................................................................... 216 art 76(b) .................................................................................................................... 216 art 103 ................................... 167, 172, 179—182, 240, 258, 260, 261, 262, 273, 274 art 108 ............................................................................................................... 186, 271 art 109 ............................................................................................................... 186, 271 Constitutive Act of the African Union art 3(g) ...................................................................................................................... 225 art 17(1) ...................................................................................................................... 66 art 30 ......................................................................................................................... 225 (Aarhus) Convention on Access to Information, Public Participation in Decision-Making and Access to Justice in Environmental Matters ........... 324 Convention against Torture and Other Cruel, Inhuman or Degrading Treatment or Punishment .................................................................................. 206 Convention on Biological Diversity art 22(1) .................................................................................................................... 275 Convention on the Participation of Foreigners in Public Life at Local Level ..................................................................................................................... 220 Convention on the Prevention and Punishment of the Crime of Genocide ..... 201 Convention on the Prohibition of the Use, Stockpiling, Production and Transfer of Anti-Personnel Mines and on their Destruction ......................... 84 Convention on the Rights of the Child ................................................................... 206 Convention on the Rights of Persons with Disabilities and its Optional Protocol ................................................................................................................ 206 Covenant of the League of Nations art ......................................................................................................................... 15 355 art 20 ................................................................................................................. 179, 180 Declaration on the Slave Trade (1815) .................................................................... 199 European Convention for the Protection of Human Rights and Fundamental Freedoms .............................................................................................................. 221 Protocol to the ECHR, art 3 .......................................................................... 221, 222
Columns Design Ltd
/
Job: Wheatley
/
Division: Tables
/Pg. Position: 2 /
Date: 11/5
JOBNAME: Wheatley PAGE: 6 SESS: 2 OUTPUT: Tue May 11 14:32:06 2010
xx Table of International Treaties, Conventions and other Legal Instruments Framework Treaty on Democratic Security in Central America art 1 ........................................................................................................................... 224 General Act for the Repression of African Slave Trade (1890) ........................... 199 General Framework Agreement for Peace in Bosnia-Herzegovina art 1(2) ...................................................................................................................... 233 Annex 4 .................................................................................................................... 233 Geneva Convention (Fourth) on the Protection of Civilian Persons in Time of War art 64 ................................................................................................................. 240, 244 Hague Convention (IV) with respect to Laws and Customs of War on Land .............................................................................................................. 240, 244 art 42 ......................................................................................................................... 240 art 43 ......................................................................................................................... 240 Harare Declaration (Commonwealth) ..................................................................... 224 ILC Articles on State Responsibility art 2 ........................................................................................................................... 172 art 22 ......................................................................................................................... 173 art 26 ......................................................................................................................... 173 art 26(5) .................................................................................................................... 213 art 32 ......................................................................................................................... 356 art 33 ......................................................................................................................... 173 art 33(1) .................................................................................................................... 172 art 33(2) .................................................................................................................... 172 art 40 ......................................................................................................................... 173 art 40(1) .................................................................................................................... 173 art 41(1) .................................................................................................................... 173 art 41(2) ............................................................................................................ 173, 244 art 48 ......................................................................................................................... 173 art 48(1)(b) ............................................................................................................... 173 art 49 ......................................................................................................................... 174 art 50 ......................................................................................................................... 174 art 50(1) .................................................................................................................... 174 Inter-American Democratic Charter art 1 ........................................................................................................................... 226 International Convention on the Elimination of All Forms of Discrimination against Women .................................................................................................... 206 International Convention on the Elimination of All Forms of Racial Discrimination ..................................................................................................... 206 International Convention on the Protection of the Rights of All Migrant Workers and Members of their Families ........................................................ 206 International Convention for the Regulation of Whaling ..................................... 91 art V .......................................................................................................................... 273 International Convention to Suppress the Slave Trade and Slavery art 2(a) ...................................................................................................................... 200
Columns Design Ltd
/
Job: Wheatley
/
Division: Tables
/Pg. Position: 3 /
Date: 11/5
JOBNAME: Wheatley PAGE: 7 SESS: 6 OUTPUT: Thu May 13 14:52:42 2010
Table of International Treaties, Conventions and other Legal Instruments
xxi
art 2(b) ...................................................................................................................... 200 International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights ......... 185, 198, 206, 207, 220 art 1 ........................................................................................................................... 216 art 1(1) ...................................................................................................... 213, 220, 221 art 1(3) ...................................................................................................................... 216 art 14(1) .................................................................................................................... 220 art 19 ......................................................................................................................... 220 art 21 ......................................................................................................................... 220 art 22(2) .................................................................................................................... 220 art 25 ................................................................................................................. 220, 221 art 27 ......................................................................................................................... 344 International Covenant on Economic, Social and Cultural Rights ........................................................................................... 185, 198, 206, 207 art 1(1) ...................................................................................................................... 213 art 1(3) ...................................................................................................................... 216 Montreal Protocol on Substances that Deplete the Ozone Layer ....................... 137 Protocol of Tegucigalpa (Protocolo de Tegucigalpa a la Carta de la Organización de Estados Centroamericanos (ODECA)) art 3 ........................................................................................................................... 224 Statute of the International Court of Justice art 38 ......................................................................................................................... 158 art 38(1) .................................................................................................... 157, 254, 255 art 38(1)(b) ....................................................................................................... 150, 222 art 38(1)(c) ................................................................................................................ 155 art 38(1)(d) ....................................................................................................... 157, 158 art 59 157 Stockholm Declaration of the United Nations Conference on the Human Environment Principle 21 .............................................................................................................. 354 Supplementary Convention on the Abolition of Slavery, the Slave Trade and Institutions and Practices Similar to Slavery (1956) ..................................... 200 Treaty of Peace between the United States of America, the British Empire, France, Italy, and Japan and Poland ............................................................... 200 Treaty on European Union art 6(1) ...................................................................................................................... 227 art 7 ........................................................................................................................... 227 Treaty of Lisbon .................................................................................................. 226, 227 United Nations Convention on the Law of the Sea ............................................. 185 art 161(8)(e) .............................................................................................................. 136 UN Framework Convention on Climate Change ................................................. 137 Kyoto Protocol ........................................................................................................ 137 UNESCO Constitution ............................................................................................... 200
Columns Design Ltd
/
Job: Wheatley
/
Division: Tables
/Pg. Position: 4 /
Date: 13/5
JOBNAME: Wheatley PAGE: 8 SESS: 6 OUTPUT: Thu May 13 14:52:42 2010
xxii
Table of International Treaties, Conventions and other Legal Instruments
Universal Declaration on Democracy (Inter-Parliamentary Union) .................. 219 Ushuaia Declaration (MERCOSUR) ........................................................................ 224 Vienna Convention on the Law of Treaties ............................................. 38, 292, 356 art 7(2)(a) .................................................................................................................... 25 art 26 ........................................................................................................................... 25 art 27 ................................................................................................................... 25, 356 art 30(1) .................................................................................................................... 180 art 31 ................................................................................................................. 145, 146 art 31(1) .................................................................................................................... 145 art 31(2) .................................................................................................................... 146 art 31(2)(a) ................................................................................................................ 146 art 31(2)(b) ............................................................................................................... 146 art 31(2)(c) ................................................................................................................ 146 art 31(3)(c) ................................................................................................................ 132 art 31(4) .................................................................................................................... 145 art 32 ......................................................................................................................... 146 art 46(1) .............................................................................................................. 25, 356 art 53 ................................................................................................................. 176, 177 art 61 .......................................................................................................................... 134 art 62 .......................................................................................................................... 134 art 63 .......................................................................................................................... 134 art 64 ................................................................................................................. 176, 177 Vienna Convention on the Law of Treaties between States and International Organisations or between International Organisations art 26 .......................................................................................................................... 274 art 27 .......................................................................................................................... 274 art 30(6) ..................................................................................................................... 180 art 46 .......................................................................................................................... 274 art 53 .......................................................................................................................... 274 art 64 .......................................................................................................................... 274
Columns Design Ltd
/
Job: Wheatley
/
Division: Tables
/Pg. Position: 5 /
Date: 13/5
JOBNAME: Wheatley PAGE: 9 SESS: 2 OUTPUT: Tue May 11 14:32:06 2010
Table Of General Assembly Resolutions 2005 World Summit Outcome, GA Res. 60/1 ....................................... 136, 195, 223 Affirmation of the principles of international law recognized by the Charter of the Nuremberg Tribunal, GA Res. 95(I) ...................................... 201 Crime of Genocide, GA Res. 96(I)............................................................................. 201 Declaration on the Elimination of All Forms of Intolerance and of Discrimination based on Religion or Belief, GA Res. 36/55 ....................... 206 Declaration on Friendly Relations, GA Res. 2625 (XXV) ... 34–5, 56, 154, 213, 214, 215, 217, 229, 230, 241 Declaration on the Granting of Independence to Colonial Countries and Peoples, GA Res. 1514 (XV) ...................................................... 178, 213, 214, 215 Declaration on the Rights of Indigenous Peoples, GA Res. 61/295 ........... 24, 207, 256, 344 Declaration on the Rights of Persons belonging to National or Ethnic, Religious and Linguistic Minorities, GA Res. 47/135 .................................................... 207 Observance in Bulgaria and Hungary of Human Rights and Fundamental Freedoms, GA Res. 272(III) ............................................................................... 204 Political Rights of Women, GA Res. 56(I) ............................................................... 204 Promotion of a democratic and equitable international order, GA Res. 61/160 ............................................................................................................ 13 Question of Southern Rhodesia, GA Res. 1747 (XVI) ........................................... 215 Relations of Members of the United Nations with Spain, GA Res. 39(I) .......... 204 Request for an advisory opinion of the International Court of Justice on whether the unilateral declaration of independence of Kosovo is in accordance with international law, GA Res. 63/3 ........................................ 230 Responsibility of States for Internationally Wrongful Acts, GA Res. 56/83 .... 172 Rule of Law at the National and International levels, GA Res. 63/128 ... 195, 256 Situation in Afghanistan and its Implications for International Peace and Security, GA Res. 35/37 ..................................................................................... 217 Situation in Kampuchea, GA Res. 34/22 ................................................................ 217
Columns Design Ltd
/
Job: Wheatley
/
Division: Tables
/Pg. Position: 1 /
Date: 11/5
JOBNAME: Wheatley PAGE: 10 SESS: 2 OUTPUT: Tue May 11 14:32:06 2010
xxiv Table Of General Assembly Resolutions Strengthening the Role of the United Nations in Enhancing the Effectiveness of the Principle of Periodic and Genuine Elections and the Promotion of Democratization, GA Res. 62/150 ................................................................... 223 Treatment of Indians in the Union of South Africa, GA Res. 44(I) .................... 204 Universal Declaration of Human Rights, GA Res. 217(III)A ..... 111, 198, 205, 206, 207, 220, 255 art 1 ........................................................................................................................... 205 art 2 ........................................................................................................................... 205 art 4 ................................................................................................................... 111, 205 art 5 ................................................................................................................... 111, 205 art 7 ................................................................................................................... 111, 205 art 20 ......................................................................................................................... 220 art 21 ................................................................................................................. 205, 220 art 21(1) .............................................................................................................. 20, 220 art 21(3) .................................................................................................... 205, 218, 220 art 28 ........................................................................................................................... 58 art 29(2) .................................................................................................................... 205 Universal Realization of the Right of Peoples to Self-Determination, GA Res. 63/163 ................................................................................................... 217 Violation by the USSR of Fundamental Rights, Traditional Diplomatic Practices and other Principles of the Charter, GA Res. 285(III) .................. 204
Columns Design Ltd
/
Job: Wheatley
/
Division: Tables
/Pg. Position: 2 /
Date: 11/5
JOBNAME: Wheatley PAGE: 1 SESS: 3 OUTPUT: Tue May 11 14:32:06 2010
Introduction
T
HE CONSOLIDATION OF democracy at the level of the state has coincided with a proliferation of sites for the production of social, economic and political norms in global governance without any attempts, outside of the European Union, to replicate the institutions of democracy that legitimate authority at the domestic level. The globalisation and fragmentation of governance results in a loss for democracy as the people no longer decide all of those aspects of social, economic and political that may meaningfully be subject to political contestation, with no clear justifications emerging for usurping domestic political selfdetermination. The ambition of this work is to restate the requirements of democratic legitimacy in terms of the deliberative ideal developed by Jürgen Habermas, and apply the understanding to the systems of global governance. The principle of equality between human persons and need for justification for the exercise of political authority leads to a recognition that democratic laws can only be legitimated through discursive procedures of opinion- and will-formation that result in a consensus amongst participants: ‘Just those action norms are valid to which all possible affected persons could agree as participants in rational discourses.’1 The argument here demonstrates that the analysis developed at the level of the state can be applied to international law, broadly defined to include the inter-state system of public international law and new forms of international governance by international organisations and other non-state actors. The focus is the systems of law in global governance, and not all normative orders. Reference to ideas of global or international ‘governance’ is intended to distinguish international law (governance) from domestic law (government). It should not suggest any diminution of the role of law or politics in global governance (in fact, the contrary).2 Law is concerned with regulation by an authority, ie with determining the normative situation of others. Where global regulations are framed in terms of law, the scope, content and consequences of the exercise of 1 Jürgen Habermas, Between Facts and Norms: Contributions to a Discourse Theory of Law and Democracy, trans by William Rehg (Oxford, Polity, 1996) at 107. See also Jürgen Habermas, James Bohman and William Rehg (eds), Deliberative Democracy: Essays on Reason and Politics (Cambridge, Mass, MIT Press, 1997); and Jon Elster (ed), Deliberative Democracy (Cambridge, Cambridge University Press, 1998). 2 cf Martti Koskenniemi, ‘The politics of international law – 20 years later’ (2009) 14 European Journal of International Law 7, 15.
Columns Design Ltd
/
Job: Wheatley
/
Division: 0_Introduction
/Pg. Position: 1 /
Date: 26/2
JOBNAME: Wheatley PAGE: 2 SESS: 5 OUTPUT: Tue May 11 14:32:06 2010
2
Introduction
political authority can only be understood by reference to an analytical enquiry into the meanings of law and authority. The work concludes that the legitimate exercise of political authority through law is conditioned by respect for the cardinal principles of deliberative democracy: equality and public reason. International law norms are valid only where a global regulator can demonstrate that it enjoys legitimate authority, ie that it regulates in accordance with the right reasons that apply to subjects, and right reasons can only be discerned through democratic procedures. Legitimate authority depends on the existence of (deliberative) democratic forms of decision-making that take into account the interests and perspectives of those subject to the law: a (democratic) rule of (international) law.
GLOBALISATION AND THE DEMOCRATIC DEFICIT
Democratic self-determination requires that citizens decide all issues that are politically decidable. The fact of globalisation has removed many issues from domestic political control, with states finding it increasingly difficult to exercise jurisdiction over international financial capital and transnational corporations, for example, and the demands of global markets and economic non-state actors inhibiting the ability of governments to introduce welfare-enhancing measures to ameliorate the deleterious impacts of liberal policies of free-trade and a free-market. Globalisation has also seen increased social interactions between geographically diverse persons, following developments in transport and information technology, and an increase in the borrowing of social, economic and political ‘norms’ from other cultures, including the global cultural of human rights. The movement of persons and infectious diseases, such as swine influenza A(H1N1), and ideas such as the radical Islamic ideology of Al-Qaeda and associate organisations, and impacts of industrialisation on the global environment (global warming, etc) are policy issues that individual governments acting alone are unable to effectively regulate or control. States have responded to globalisation through the globalisation of governance functions, including inter-state cooperation measures and establishment of regional and global regulatory institutions. Whilst the development can be seen as a practical response, it creates problems for the practice of democracy — once an issue is regulated at the level of international law, the people do not decide for themselves all of the conditions of social, economic and political life that are political decidable. Eric Stein concludes that the
Columns Design Ltd
/
Job: Wheatley
/
Division: 00_Introduction
/Pg. Position: 2 /
Date: 26/3
JOBNAME: Wheatley PAGE: 3 SESS: 5 OUTPUT: Tue May 11 14:32:06 2010
Globalisation and the Democratic Deficit
3
globalisation of governance almost invariably means a ‘loss of democracy’, as citizen participation in the exercise of political authority becomes even more remote.3 The contrast between domestic democracy and global regulatory institutions is striking: there are no direct elections for the selection of global political leaders or members of a global parliamentary assembly, and few mechanisms for holding power-wielders in global governance to account.4 International organisations and institutions have emerged as standard setters without, in any formal sense, being representative of, or directly accountable to, those they seek to regulate. Where democratic self-determination is defined in terms of the ability of a people to decide politically decidable issues, globalisation and the globalisation of governance presents significant challenges to the theory and practice of democracy, and the ‘move to institutions’ in international law5 and ‘transfer of policy-making prerogatives’ away from states,6 presents a radically different context for the practice of, and theorising about, democracy than in the past, when waves of democratisation washed over the territorial states of first Europe and North America, and subsequently the whole world.7 The modern world of democratic law must accommodate itself to the proliferation of sites for law-making, including the emergence of some 250 international organisations and institutions, and fragmentation of governance functions on sectoral grounds, such as human rights, the environment, trade and development. Ideas around democratic legitimacy have not been central to the justification for the globalisation of governance functions. The standard, instrumental, justification is that global regulation is an effective mechanism for responding to collective action and co-ordination problems, and for promoting certain global justice ends (the protection of human rights, the environment and a globalised economy, etc). Critics complain that international organisations and institutions have been implementing a neo-liberal ideology, the so-called ‘Washington consensus’ (the position of the United States, World Bank and International Monetary Fund),
3 Eric Stein, ‘International Integration and Democracy: No Love at First Sight’ (2001) 95 American Journal of International Law 489, 490. 4 José Alvarez cautions that in an age where ‘the number of “genuinely democratic, domestic societies” is still not vast’, we should not make the mistake of ‘mythologizing domestic democratic governance’: José Alvarez, ‘Multiculturalism and its Discontents’ (2000) 11 European Journal of International Law 393, 410. 5 cf David Kennedy, ‘The Move to Institutions’ (1986–87) 8 Cardozo Law Review 841. See also José E Alvarez, ‘International Organizations: Then and Now’ (2006) 100 American Journal of International Law 324, 325. 6 Lloyd Gruber, Ruling the World: Power Politics and the Rise of Supranational Institutions (Princeton, NJ, Princeton University Press, 2000) xi. 7 cf Samuel P Huntington, The Third Wave: Democratization in the Late Twentieth Century (London, University of Oklahoma Press, 1991).
Columns Design Ltd
/
Job: Wheatley
/
Division: 00_Introduction
/Pg. Position: 3 /
Date: 26/3
JOBNAME: Wheatley PAGE: 4 SESS: 4 OUTPUT: Tue May 11 14:32:06 2010
4
Introduction
which argues for free trade between states and a deregulated free-market within the state, often at the expense of social and economic rights and measures aimed at poverty alleviation.8 Richard Falk identifies a ‘marketorientated constitutionalism’ that emerged following the end of the Cold War: ‘[the] preferred shape of world order [was] built on the selforganizing propensity of the market, legitimated and stabilized by respect for constitutional principles, especially the rule of law’.9 There is a sense that global law norms are imposed on people who have little input into their design and formulation, and no opportunities for argument or protest. BS Chimni makes the point that the World Trade Organization has no address in India and it is simply not possible for Indian farmers to protest before its offices in Geneva. New technologies, notably the internet, may increase the possibilities of citizen participation, but he is sceptical about the possibilities of new forms of ‘electronic resistance’, particularly given that many people in the developing world do not have access to the necessary technology.10 Chimni writes about the ‘imperial character’ of international institutions,11 and the ‘emerging consensus among third world peoples’ that they suffer from a ‘democracy deficit’.12 From the 1999 Ministerial Conference of the World Trade Organization, the so-called ‘Battle at Seattle’, and subsequently at Prague (2000), Quebec City and Genoa (both 2001), Johannesburg (2002), and Cancun (2002),13 the lack of transparency, accountability, and citizen participation in relation to international organisations (the putative ‘democratic deficit’) has become a significant political issue, a major theme in writings on world politics14 8 A distinctive criticism of the left contends that the focus should not be on the democratisation of global governance, which represents a form of Western hegemony, but on the development of powerful international institutions to promote social welfare goals in the face of economic globalisation. See Anthony McGrew, ‘Models of Transnational Democracy’ in David Held and Anthony McGrew (eds), The Global Transformations Reader, 2nd edn (Cambridge: Polity, 2003) 500, 508. 9 Richard Falk, ‘A Decade of Lost Opportunities’, one part of ‘Citizens in the International Realm: the New Participatory Demands’ (2001) American Society of International Law, Proceedings of the Annual Meeting 162, 165. 10 BS Chimni, ‘International Institutions Today: an Imperial Global State in the Making’ (2004) 15 European Journal of International Law 1, 23. cf Michael Froomkin, ‘
[email protected]: Toward a Critical Theory of Cyberspace’ (2003) 116 Harvard Law Review 749, 753. 11 ibid at 2. 12 ibid at 6. 13 cf John Dryzek, ‘Transnational Democracy in an Insecure World’ (2006) 27 International Political Science Review 101, 106: the protestors form one part of a larger transnational public sphere questioning economic globalisation, which has been successful in influencing states and international organisations and in the governance of global issues. 14 Andrew Moravcsik describes the question as to whether international institutions can make a claim to democratic legitimacy as ‘perhaps the central question in contemporary world politics’: Andrew Moravcsik, ‘Is there a ‘Democratic Deficit’ in World Politics?’ (2004) 39 Government and Opposition 336, 336 (emphasis in original).
Columns Design Ltd
/
Job: Wheatley
/
Division: 00_Introduction
/Pg. Position: 4 /
Date: 26/3
JOBNAME: Wheatley PAGE: 5 SESS: 4 OUTPUT: Tue May 11 14:32:06 2010
Globalisation and the Democratic Deficit
5
and international relations, and more recently in international law, as the gains for democracy at the level of the state appear to be undermined by a move to global regulation. The apparent benefits of globalised governance have not abated the legitimacy critique, and the experience of the European Union (EU) demonstrates that formal legitimacy (established by an international law framework) and output legitimacy (good governance for the people) provide a necessary but not a sufficient justification for the exercise of political authority in the eyes of many citizens. The absence of direct citizen control over law-making within the European Union presents significant difficulties for establishing the sociological and normative legitimacy of governance by EU institutions, and the authority of EU laws. Arguments around the democratic deficit of EU governance are well rehearsed: European integration has increased executive power at the expense of parliamentary control; the European Parliament is too weak; there are no truly ‘European’ elections; the European Union is ‘too distant’ from voters; governance by European institutions results in a ‘policy drift’ away from voters’ ideal preferences. In short, governance by the European Union results in policies that are not supported by a majority of citizens in many or even most Member States;15 note the majoritarian critique. Debates around the European Union inform but do not exhaust consideration of the problem of democracy beyond the state. The European Union is sui generis; it is a more effective international organisation than any other, with developed structures for governance and law-making; the same cannot be said about the system of internation law that operates principally between states and forms of international governance by international organisations and other non-state actors. The European Union has responded to complaints that there is a democratic deficit in EU governance by replicating, in many respects, the institutions of government found in domestic systems. One part of the solution to the problem of democracy beyond the state may lie in establishing democratic institutions, principally representative assemblies (directly elected or otherwise). In the absence of a global demos, or global pouvoir constituant (constituent power), however, international parliamentary assemblies cannot be legitimate in the same ways that domestic parliaments are legitimate. Further, whilst we might conclude on the necessity for some form of direct representation in relation to the United Nations (UN), for example, a process of ‘parliamentarization’ cannot be applied to the 250 plus international institutions that play some role in global regulation. It is simply inconceivable that citizens could 15 Andreas Follesdal and Simon Hix, ‘Why There is a Democratic Deficit in the EU: a Response to Majone and Moravcsik’ (2006) 44 Journal of Common Market Studies 533, 534–37. See also Giandomenico Majone, Regulating Europe (London, Routledge, 1996) 284.
Columns Design Ltd
/
Job: Wheatley
/
Division: 00_Introduction
/Pg. Position: 5 /
Date: 26/3
JOBNAME: Wheatley PAGE: 6 SESS: 4 OUTPUT: Tue May 11 14:32:06 2010
6
Introduction
remain sufficiently knowledgeable about their respective activities to participate effectively in political deliberations or direct elections. The solution to the problem of democracy beyond the state does not lie in the multiple replications of domestic democratic institutions at the level of global governance. The democratisation of the international system, as Joseph Weiler observes, cannot be achieved by the simplistic application of the majoritarian principle in world arenas[,] [or in] adapting national institutions and processes to international contexts. That could work in only limited circumstances. What is required is both a rethinking of the very building blocks of democracy to see how these may or may not be employed in an international system.16
The title of this work – The Democratic Legitimacy of International Law – links to a number of contested and contestable concepts: what, for example, do we mean by ‘international law’ following the globalisation and fragmentation of governance; what is the relevance of democracy beyond the state, and what demos is implied; and crucially what do we mean by the idea of ‘democracy’? To analyse and evaluate the democratic legitimacy of international law it is essential to develop a concept of democracy that can be applied to state and international law, and new forms of international governance that have emerged to regulate domestic societies (or parts thereof). Daniel Esty identifies six types of legitimacy that might justify the exercise of political authority by international organisations and institutions, four of which relate to ideas around democratic legitimacy.17 Esty refers directly to an idea of democratic legitimacy, defined in terms of electoral legitimacy.18 In the modern age, the legitimacy of law is dependent on establishing democratic institutions as the ultimate source of the law and the existence of democratic law-making procedures. Since Jean-Jacques Rousseau (The Social Contract (1762)), the legitimate exercise of political power has been associated with elections that provide a mechanism for determining the will of the people. Secondly, Esty refers to systemic or Madisonian legitimacy, following the design of the US constitutional model. The fragmentation of regulatory functions on sectoral grounds ensures that political authority is
16 JHH Weiler, ‘The Geology of International Law-governance, Democracy and Legitimacy’ (2004) 64 ZaöRV (Heidelberg Journal of International Law) 547, 561. 17 Daniel Esty, ‘Good Governance at the Supranational Scale: Globalizing Administrative Law’ (2006) 115 Yale Law Journal 1490. The other two concern the legitimacy provided by the expertise of the policymaker and ability of the regulator to achieve good outcomes (ibid at 1517), and the idea of order-based legitimacy, in that order and predictability are required for stable social relations and ‘the legitimacy of a governance system derives, at least in part, from its capacity to clarify the rules of the game and thus provide order’ (ibid at 1518). 18 ibid at 1515.
Columns Design Ltd
/
Job: Wheatley
/
Division: 00_Introduction
/Pg. Position: 6 /
Date: 26/3
JOBNAME: Wheatley PAGE: 7 SESS: 4 OUTPUT: Tue May 11 14:32:06 2010
Globalisation and the Democratic Deficit
7
dispersed among competing institutions, ensuring ‘triangulation on difficult policy choices’, leading to better policy making;19 more importantly, the lack of a concentration of authority protects individual liberties (freedom from regulatory interference). The values of the American Constitution, of the rule of law, separation of powers, democratic legitimacy, legal hierarchies and judicial review, can be applied to global governance to establish ‘a system of shared and separated powers designed more for liberty than efficiency’.20 Anne-Marie Slaughter observes that a system of checks and balances, of competition and co-ordination, ‘creates sufficient friction to curb the abuse of power’.21 In the context of the European Union, Giandomenico Majone argues that the democratic deficit ‘becomes understandable in light of the model of mixed government’,22 ie a pluralist or Madisonian model, ‘which aims to share, disperse, limit and delegate power’.23 James Rosenau concludes that the extensive disaggregation of authority in global governance, which allows for much greater flexibility, innovation and experimentation in global regulation,24 has embedded within the system one of the functions of Madisonian government, that of inhibiting ‘the coalescence of hierarchical and autocratic centres of [unrestrained exercises of] power.’25 The test for whether democracy is evolving in the ‘Globalized Space’ is not whether representative institutions and accountability mechanisms conform to those in the domestic settings, rather, the test lies in the degree to which the ad hoc control mechanisms evolve to steer the politics of this emergent domain in the direction of more checks on the excesses of power, more opportunities for interests to be heard and heeded, and more balanced constraints among the multiplicity of actors that seek to extend their command of issue areas.26
19
ibid at 1519. Anne-Marie Slaughter, ‘Disaggregated Sovereignty: Towards the Public Accountability of Global Government Networks’ (2004) 39 Government and Opposition 159, 184. 21 Anne-Marie Slaughter, ‘International Law in a World of Liberal States’ (1995) 6 European Journal of International Law 503, 535. 22 Giandomenico Majone, ‘Delegation of Regulatory Powers in a Mixed Polity’ (2002) 8 European Law Journal 319, 327. 23 Giandomenico Majone, ‘Europe’s “democratic deficit”: the Question of Standards’ (1998) 4 European Law Journal 5, 18. Majone is also influenced by Arend Lijphart’s model of consociational democracy, which he argues is applicable in the context of the European Union – a polity ‘split by a number of deep cleavages, the most obvious being the distinction between large and small member states[.] Indeed, many non-majoritarian features of the community system are best explained as strategies of cleavage management’: Giandomenico Majone, Regulating Europe (London, Routledge, 1996) 287. 24 James Rosenau, ‘Governance and Democracy in a Globalizing World’ in Daniele Archibugi et al, Re-imagining Political Community: Studies in Cosmopolitan Democracy (Stanford, Calif, Stanford University Press, 1998) 28, 32. 25 ibid at 40. 26 ibid at 49. 20
Columns Design Ltd
/
Job: Wheatley
/
Division: 00_Introduction
/Pg. Position: 7 /
Date: 26/3
JOBNAME: Wheatley PAGE: 8 SESS: 4 OUTPUT: Tue May 11 14:32:06 2010
8
Introduction
Thirdly, democratic legitimacy may be understood in terms of legitimate policy-making, or ‘right process’: a ‘thoughtfully structured rulemaking process will clarify underlying issues, bring facts to bear, promote careful analysis of policy options, and engage interested parties in a political dialogue.’27 Esty refers to a global administrative law ‘toolbox’ that includes controls on corruption and special interest influence; a requirement for draft policies and regulations to be made public, with opportunities for comment; the need for documented decision-making, and for transparency and public participation, including access to information.28 Finally, Esty observes that, following Jürgen Habermas, legitimacy can be understood in terms of the dialogue that accompanies rule-making, and which substitutes ‘for the missing democratic legitimacy and accountability that elections provide.’ The concern is to establish transparent decision-making processes in international organisations and other non-state regulatory actors that provide opportunities for debate and political dialogue with participation by representatives of a broad range of views.29 The analysis proceeds from the model developed by Habermas and other influential writers, rejecting any argument that opinion- and will-formation is only possible in already existing political communities (‘states’), or that coercive institutions of government (to implement agreed policies) are a necessary condition for the existence of ‘democratic’ governance. The focus of the writings is on one element of the deliberative model: deliberation in accordance with public reason. Joshua Cohen argues that the idea of deliberation may be applied to any association of (political) equals whose affairs can be governed by public deliberation and reasoned argument between members as to what should be done.30 The idea of deliberative democracy changes the way that regulators (and other participants) understand the regulatory function. In conditions of uncertainty and reasonable disagreement, it establishes that legitimate policy and valid laws emerge through inclusive processes of discussion that aim to reach a consensus amongst all participants, with deliberations conducted in accordance with the principle of public reason. All participants must be free to state their preferences and be willing to listen to others in the expectation that stated preferences may be subject to challenge and possible change though open and reasonable discussions. To persuade others, participants will need to relinquish self-interested reasoning and look for arguments that others
27
Esty (n 17) at 1521. ibid at 1524ff. ibid at 1520. 30 Joshua Cohen, ‘Deliberation and Democratic Legitimacy’ in James Bohman and William Rehg (eds) Deliberative Democracy: Essays on Reason and Politics (Cambridge, Massachusetts, MIT Press, 1997) 67, 72. 28 29
Columns Design Ltd
/
Job: Wheatley
/
Division: 00_Introduction
/Pg. Position: 8 /
Date: 26/3
JOBNAME: Wheatley PAGE: 9 SESS: 4 OUTPUT: Tue May 11 14:32:06 2010
Globalisation and the Democratic Deficit
9
can find compelling. They must articulate reasons that others might find acceptable, eventually leading to a consensus as to which alternative is to be preferred for the benefit of all.31 In conditions of uncertainty and disagreement, democratic politics must be based on an understanding that (political) ‘truths’ emerge from democratic politics that focus on the interests and perspectives of those subject to the legal order. Increasingly it is accepted that democracy should be understood in terms of deliberative democracy, which provides the basis for beginning to think about the problem of democracy beyond the state. The argument for deliberative democracy follows from the recognition that the exercise of political authority requires reasoned justification, and, in the modern age, a claim to authority cannot be justified by reference to a single perspective, objective sense of morality, or philosophical argument; it must be justified in terms that those subject to the regime can accept. Martti Koskenniemi points out that the idea that a political order should be based on the subjective consent of individuals is the most fundamental claim of the liberal tradition. Behind it stands the great epistemic break[.] The ensuing uncertainty could only be disposed of by establishing a knowledge-producing process in a meaning-generative (name-giving) consensus in the State.32
Political authority must be justified through democratic procedures in which law plays a crucial role. In ideal conditions, as Iris Marion Young observes, citizens arrive at decisions, ‘not by determining which preferences have greatest numerical support, but by determining which proposals the collective agrees are supported by the best reasons.’33 Democracy is concerned with the establishment of political ‘truths’ (defined in terms of right regulation), not political majorities. All potentially affected persons have the right to be included in deliberations and all have the right to speak freely in circumstances in which no one actor is in a position to threaten or coerce others.34 Legitimate authority rests on institutionalized procedures for deliberation and decision-making – the ideal is rational persuasion. The consensus that results from free and open deliberative processes should be regarded as ‘just’, and respected by all participants.35 The practice of deliberative democracy requires that laws result from a process of reasoned deliberation amongst equal participants that reach a
31
ibid at 74–75. Martti Koskenniemi, From Apology to Utopia: the Structure of International Legal Argument (Cambridge, Cambridge University Press, 2005) 74. 33 Iris Marion Young, Inclusion and Democracy (Oxford, Oxford University Press, 2000) 22–23. 34 ibid at 34. 35 ibid at 31. 32
Columns Design Ltd
/
Job: Wheatley
/
Division: 00_Introduction
/Pg. Position: 9 /
Date: 26/3
JOBNAME: Wheatley PAGE: 10 SESS: 4 OUTPUT: Tue May 11 14:32:06 2010
10 Introduction consensus. According to Seyla Benhabib, it is not simply another model about how democracy should work, but one that elucidates some aspects of the logic of democratic practices better than others, albeit in imperfect form.36 Open and inclusive public debate leading to agreed-upon policies is a common feature of advanced democracies. The assumptions are that deliberative mechanisms result in better law-making, as decision-making procedures are more informed and free from factual errors, and participants and decision-making made aware of the interests and preferences of all participants. Deliberation precludes recourse to self-interested arguments as disagreements are settled ‘through the exchange of reasons that are shared or can be shared by all who are bound by the decisions taken.’37 This in turn structures the form of democratic deliberations as participants must have recourse to reasons and reasoned arguments that others might accept. Where deliberation does not result in a consensus, the outcomes will nonetheless be ‘shaped by engagement in public debate, argument, and reason giving.’38 The deliberative model is a counterfactual ideal;39 Dyzenhaus refers to the ‘abstract and complex’ nature of the argument for deliberative democracy, which defies ‘easy comprehension, let alone obvious contact with reality’.40 Margaret Moore notes that the most decisive criticism of deliberative democracy is that it is ‘so difficult to institutionalize that it is unfeasible’.41 The ideal provides, however, a ‘useful theoretical tool’42 that can be used to analyse and evaluate the real world practice of democracy. The model acknowledges the inter-relationship between public and private autonomy (political participation and human rights), without giving either one priority; refuses to designate an idea of the ‘good life’ beyond the fact of deliberation, it is the right of citizens to deliberate on the terms of political justice for their association; and, given the centrality of consent, admits the possibility of reconciling the rights of (denocratic) minorities with the principle of self-determination. Perhaps most importantly, Habermas provides a test for democratic legitimacy
36 Seyla Benhabib, ‘Toward a Deliberative Model of Democratic Legitimacy’ in Seyla Benhabib (ed), Democracy and Difference: Contesting the Boundaries of the Political (Princeton, NJ, Princeton University Press, 1996) 67, 84. 37 Ian Johnstone, ‘Legislation and Adjudication in the UN Security Council: Bringing Down the Deliberative Deficit’ (2008) 102 American Journal of International Law 275, 278. 38 ibid at 279. 39 cf Michael Froomkin, ‘
[email protected]: Toward a Critical Theory of Cyberspace’ (2003) 116 Harvard Law Review 749, 755. 40 David Dyzenhaus, ‘The Legitimacy of Legality’ (1996) 46 University of Toronto Law Journal 129, 134. 41 Margaret Moore, ‘Globalization and Democratization: Institutional Design for Global Institutions’ (2006) 37 Journal of Social Philosophy 21, 31. 42 Michel Rosenfeld, ‘Law as Discourse: Bridging the Gap between Democracy and Rights’ (1995) 108 Harvard Law Review 1163, 1179.
Columns Design Ltd
/
Job: Wheatley
/
Division: 00_Introduction
/Pg. Position: 10 /
Date: 26/3
JOBNAME: Wheatley PAGE: 11 SESS: 4 OUTPUT: Tue May 11 14:32:06 2010
The Democratic Legitimacy of International Law
11
that is non-political to the extent that we accept the equality of human persons and the requirement for justification for the exercise of political authority through law. The deliberative model allows us to evaluate the legitimacy of laws without recourse to (contested) subjective values, which themselves would need to be justified in terms that reasonable persons might accept to avoid claims of elitism, imperialism or that only certain arguments were valid.
THE DEMOCRATIC LEGITIMACY OF INTERNATIONAL LAW
The aim of this work is to give an account of the modern system of international law that operates in world society. The argument is for a different reading of the system, not its reconstruction. It does not, for example, propose an end to sovereignty, or the establishment of new global institutions, or the radical transformation of existing institutions. Writings on international law (from within the discipline) are constrained by the discipline of international law. The job-function of the international lawyer is to construct competent arguments that ‘emerge from the way international society is, and not from some wishful construction of it.’43 The defining features of international law are that it is international, not domestic, and law, not politics. The identity of the discipline is provided by its normative character (‘it tells people what to do’), and the assumption that international law can be separated from international politics;44 it is not, as Koskenniemi explains, concerned with ‘subjective beliefs about what the order among States should be life’.45 It is not the job-function of the international lawyer, qua international lawyer, to articulate the principles of justice that should govern international relations, and the disciplinary training of the international lawyer does not extend to studies of international ethics or global justice. Whilst international law cannot remain immune to discoveries in scientific disciplines46 43
Koskenniemi (n 32) at 573. See, for example, Certain expenses of the United Nations (art 17, para 2 of the Charter), Advisory Opinion of 20 July 1962 [1962] ICJ Rep 151, 155: ‘It has been argued that the question put to the Court is intertwined with political questions, and that for this reason the Court should refuse to give an opinion. It is true that most interpretations of the Charter of the United Nations will have political significance, great or small. In the nature of things it could not be otherwise. The Court, however, cannot attribute a political character to a request which invites it to undertake an essentially judicial task, namely, the interpretation of a treaty provision.’ 45 Koskenniemi (n 32) at 16. 46 Consider for example the judgment of the International Court of Justice in GabcˇikovoNagymaros Project (Hungary/Slovakia) [1997] ICJ Rep 7 at para 140: ‘Owing to new scientific insights and to a growing awareness of the risks for mankind – for present and future generations – of pursuit of such interventions at an unconsidered and unabated pace, new norms and standards have been developed, set forth in a great number of instruments 44
Columns Design Ltd
/
Job: Wheatley
/
Division: 00_Introduction
/Pg. Position: 11 /
Date: 26/3
JOBNAME: Wheatley PAGE: 12 SESS: 4 OUTPUT: Tue May 11 14:32:06 2010
12 Introduction and developments in the ways that cognate disciplines think about the world society (hence the reliance here on work in disciplines such as political theory and international relations), international law remains a closed system that defines its own senses of reality and creates its own normative expectations.47 The reliance on work in cognate disciplines is intended to illuminate the understanding of international law and importance of democracy when evaluating the legitimate exercise of political authority through international law. A former UN Secretary-General, Boutros Boutros-Ghali, accepts that sovereignty, not democracy, has been the guiding principle of the international law system, but concludes that a ‘fundamental conceptual transformation may be under way: the democratization of the international system’. The practice of democracy in the international community requires that all states should be able to make their views heard and participate in decision-making processes. Democracy is based on ‘a spirit of dialogue’, a ‘readiness to discuss’, and a recognition that ‘decisions arrived at democratically’ should be accepted.48 Dialogue, debate, and agreement are the principal means through which ‘the society of states and the world community of peoples can express common will and achieve common progress.’49 In ‘We the peoples’, another former Secretary-General, Kofi Anan, observes that ‘[b]etter governance means greater participation, coupled with accountability’, concluding that ‘the international public domain – including the United Nations – must be
during the last two decades. Such new norms have to be taken into consideration, and such new standards given proper weight, not only when States contemplate new activities but also when continuing with activities begun in the past. This need to reconcile economic development with protection of the environment is aptly expressed in the concept of sustainable development’. 47 Jürgen Habermas observes that ‘the role of political science is to describe the state of international relations and that of jurisprudence is to give an account of the concept, validity, and content of international law, philosophy can try to clarify certain basic conceptual features of the development of law’: Jürgen Habermas, ‘Does the Constitutionalization of International Law still have a Chance?’, in The Divided West, edited and translated by Ciaran Cronin (Cambridge, Polity, 2006) 115, 117. 48 Boutros Boutros-Ghali, ‘Democracy: a Newly Recognized Imperative’ (1995) 1 Global Governance 3, 9. 49 ibid at 11. In An Agenda for Peace, Boutros-Ghali concluded that democracy ‘within the family of nations means the application of its principles within the world Organization itself. This requires the fullest consultation, participation and engagement of all States, large and small, in the work of the Organization… Democracy at all levels is essential to attain peace for a new era of prosperity and justice’: An Agenda for Peace, Report of the Secretary-General (17 June 1992) UN Doc A/47/277 at para 82. See also, ibid para 19: ‘Respect for democratic principles at all levels of social existence is crucial: in communities, within States and within the community of States. Our constant duty should be to maintain the integrity of each while finding a balanced design for all.’
Columns Design Ltd
/
Job: Wheatley
/
Division: 00_Introduction
/Pg. Position: 12 /
Date: 26/3
JOBNAME: Wheatley PAGE: 13 SESS: 4 OUTPUT: Tue May 11 14:32:06 2010
The Democratic Legitimacy of International Law
13
opened up further to the participation of the many actors whose contributions are essential to managing the path of globalization’.50 On 19 December 2006, the General Assembly adopted by 124 votes to 56, with four abstentions, Resolution 61/160, ‘Promotion of a democratic and equitable international order’. The votes against included Australia, Canada, Japan, New Zealand, the United States of America, and European Union states (including the United Kingdom). The reason was the determination that democracy ‘is not only a political concept but that it also has economic and social dimensions’, and that it is imperative for the international community ‘to ensure that globalization becomes a positive force for all the world’s people’, in particular those in developing states and those with economies in transition.51 The resolution is intriguing in outlining a vision of a democratic and equitable international order, to which everyone is entitled.52 First, a democratic and equitable international order fosters the full realisation of human rights for all.53 Secondly, a democratic and equitable international order requires the realisation, inter alia, of the right of all peoples to self-determination; the right of peoples and nations to permanent sovereignty over their natural wealth and resources; the right of all persons and peoples to development; the right to an international economic order based on equal participation in decision-making processes; the promotion of transparent, democratic, just and accountable international institutions in all areas of cooperation, in particular through the implementation of the principles of full and equal participation in their respective decision-making mechanisms; and the right to equitable participation of all, without any discrimination, in domestic and global decision-making.54 Needless to say, the resolution is not binding in terms of (positive) international law. Democracy becomes important as the international law order moves from an inter-state contractual paradigm to one of public (international) law governance, where the exercise of political authority is evaluated against (international) public law concepts such as legality (expressed in terms of intra and ultra vires) and reasonableness (ideas of proportionality, etc). In the modern age of uncertainty and disagreement, the exercise of (legitimate) authority depends in large part on the recognition of epistemic authority. At the level of domestic government, epistemic authority is provided by democratic law-making procedures, with the
50 Kofi Anan, We the Peoples: the Role of the United Nations in the 21st Century (New York, United Nations, 2000) at 13. 51 Preamble, General Assembly Resolution 61/160, ‘Promotion of a democratic and equitable international order’ (adopted 19 December 2006). 52 ibid para 1. 53 ibid para 2. 54 ibid para 4.
Columns Design Ltd
/
Job: Wheatley
/
Division: 00_Introduction
/Pg. Position: 13 /
Date: 26/3
JOBNAME: Wheatley PAGE: 14 SESS: 4 OUTPUT: Tue May 11 14:32:06 2010
14 Introduction review of government acts conditioned by ideas of democratic legitimacy: legislative acts of national parliaments demand greater deference than executive orders, and courts are reluctant to review measures that have been subject to extensive forms of democratic deliberation. Following the globalisation of regulatory functions, international organisations and institutions must also make a claim to epistemic authority, ie to know better, and it is not sufficient to simply assert a privileged position of knowledge or authority. The argument developed here is that epistemic authority is provided by deliberative procedures: inclusive, consensusseeking processes of reasoned deliberation. Robert Keohane concludes that seeking to move toward this ideal is crucial for establishing acceptable forms of global governance: ‘If all voices are heard, more objections will be expressed, deliberation may be enhanced and decisions more widely accepted.’55 An international organisation is epistemically legitimate to the extent that it ‘has the capacity to generate and properly use new information that can generate new policy responses, reduce bias in standards and implementation, and reduce the risk of opportunistic interventions.’ To ensure that this is the case, the organisation must ‘promote discussions in which all valid interests are represented, and it is equally important that there be provisions for critical re-evaluation, promoted by diversity.’56 There is an emerging recognition of the importance of deliberation to legitimate forms of global governance. Anne-Marie Slaughter argues that the foundational norm of global governance should be ‘global deliberative equality’57: all persons ‘belong at the table’ in collective deliberations about common problems, and those affected, or their representatives, are entitled to participate in deliberations on the formation of global governance norms.58 In this, she follows Michael Ignatieff, who concludes that the idea of global deliberative equality derives from the basic moral precept that ‘our species is one, and each of the individuals who compose it is entitled to equal moral consideration.’59 It assumes progress towards ‘a world of genuine moral equality among human beings[;] a world of conflict, deliberation, argument, and contention.’60 Steven Bernstein contends that the democratic legitimacy of global governance could be
55 Robert Keohane, ‘The Contingent Legitimacy of Multilateralism’ (2006) GARNET Working Paper No 09/06 at 5. See also Robert Keohane, ‘Governance in a Partially Globalized World’ (2001) 95 American Political Science Review 1, 2. 56 ibid at 15. 57 Anne-Marie Slaughter, ‘Disaggregated Sovereignty: Towards the Public Accountability of Global Government Networks’ (2004) 39 Government and Opposition 159, 175. 58 ibid at 176. 59 Michael Ignatieff, Human Rights as Politics and Idolatry (Princeton, New Jersey, Princeton University Press, 2001) at 3–4. 60 ibid at 95.
Columns Design Ltd
/
Job: Wheatley
/
Division: 00_Introduction
/Pg. Position: 14 /
Date: 26/3
JOBNAME: Wheatley PAGE: 15 SESS: 3 OUTPUT: Tue May 11 14:32:06 2010
The Structure of the Book
15
improved by an emphasis on the deliberative aspects of democracy: ‘accountability, transparency, access to participation, deliberation and, sometimes, fairness.’ As with domestic law systems, the legitimacy of global norms rests on good arguments ‘made under conditions in which free and equal autonomous actors can challenge validity claims, seek a reasoned communicative consensus about their understandings of the situation and justifications for norms guiding their action, and are open to being persuaded.’61 The deliberative account is, as Karin Bäckstrand explains, grounded in an idea that democracy is ‘more about deliberation, reasoned argument and public reflection than voting and aggregation.’ Democratic legitimacy is provided by deliberation, rather than competitive elections to parliamentary bodies, although the possibility for this is not excluded.62 As Margaret Moore observes: all affected should be able to participate in democratic deliberations and decisionmaking should operate in accordance with the aims of deliberative democracy: ‘inclusion, political equality, and public reasoning.’63
THE STRUCTURE OF THE BOOK
Following this introduction, chapter one reviews the arguments that have emerged in the literature around the putative democratic deficit that results from the exercise of political authority through (international) law. Globalisation and the globalisation of regulatory functions have led to a widespread perception that global law-making poses an ‘imminent and serious threat to democracy’,64 even if it is difficult to establish the nature and extent of that threat.65 José Alvarez makes the point that ‘[the] very 61 Steven Bernstein, ‘Legitimacy in Global Environmental Governance’ (2005) 1 Journal of International Law and International Relations 139, 147. 62 Karin Bäckstrand, ‘Democratizing Global Environmental Governance? Stakeholder Democracy after the World Summit on Sustainable Development’ (2006) 12 European Journal of International Relations 467, 475. See also Anthony McGrew, ‘Models of Transnational Democracy’ in David Held and Anthony McGrew (eds), The Global Transformations reader, 2nd edn (Cambridge, Polity, 2003) 500, 504. 63 Margaret Moore, ‘Globalization and Democratization: Institutional Design for Global Institutions’ (2006) 37 Journal of Social Philosophy 21, 31. 64 Michael Goodhart, ‘Democracy, Globalization, and the Problem of the State’ (2001) 33 Polity 527, 527. Peter Muchlinski observes that, outside of law, at least five approaches to globalisation can be identified, including a political science approach that emphasises ‘an increasingly supranational structure of governance both at the regional and multilateral levels’: Peter Muchlinski, ‘Globalisation and Legal Research’ (2003) 37 International Lawyer 221, 222–23. The other four are the geographical approach, examining the phenomenon in terms of space and time; the economic approach, looking at cross-border economic activity; the business management approach, looking at the development of global production and distribution chains by multi-national corporations; and the sociological approach, which looks at the ways that individuals and groups respond to the fact of globalisation. 65 ibid at 528.
Columns Design Ltd
/
Job: Wheatley
/
Division: 0_Introduction
/Pg. Position: 15 /
Date: 26/2
JOBNAME: Wheatley PAGE: 16 SESS: 4 OUTPUT: Tue May 11 14:32:06 2010
16 Introduction nature of international law makes it susceptible to “democratic” complaints.’66 The complaints fall into one of three types: a vertical complaint that there is a democratic deficit where social, economic and political norms are determined by international law (broadly defined); a horizontal complaint that results following any move away from the international law principle of the political equality of states (the position of the five permanent members on the UN Security Council is the locus classicus); and an ideological complaint which argues that global governance norms reflect a particular (Western) (liberal) discourse, functioning to embed the (contested) values of the free market and free trade and civil and political rights in the international law order. The deficit results from an absence of debate about and contestation of these policy preferences. The world of positive law that emerged following the Westphalian settlement provided a clear demarcation of regulatory tasks between the state law system (the regulation of social, economic and political life within the state) and international law (relationships between sovereigns). Both forms relied on an expression of sovereign will for the adoption of ‘law’ norms, with ‘democratic legitimacy’ provided by the existence of domestic democratic institutions (notably national parliaments) and the principle of sovereign equality and requirement of consent (representing the will of the people) for the adoption of international law norms. This two-track model of democratic self-determination is no longer sufficient to explain the legitimacy and authority of law norms, which are now greatly intrusive in the regulation of matters previously within the domaine réservé of states and consent is no longer required for the establishment of international obligations opposable to the state. There is a recognition that the Westphalian political settlement that defined political authority in terms of state and international law has broken down, but no consensus on any meta-principle to replace sovereignty as the organising principle for the allocation and exercise of (legitimate) authority. Chapter one evaluates the competing arguments. First, to the extent that international law is a threat to democracy, the principle of sovereignty should be strengthened to protect domestic democracies from the ‘authority’ of international law norms (the argument of New Sovereigntists in the United States). Secondly, given that democracy has only ever been imperfectly applied in the context of the state, and given the need for global governance following the recognition of collective action and coordination problems, the legitimate exercise of
66 José Alvarez, ‘Introducing the Themes [International law and democratic theory]’ (2007) 38 Victoria University of Wellington Law Review 159, 160.
Columns Design Ltd
/
Job: Wheatley
/
Division: 00_Introduction
/Pg. Position: 16 /
Date: 26/3
JOBNAME: Wheatley PAGE: 17 SESS: 4 OUTPUT: Tue May 11 14:32:06 2010
The Structure of the Book 17 (global) political authority requires the establishment of a global democratic state. Thirdly, accepting the impossibility of establishing a global state, existing structures (the UN, the state, etc) should be conceptualised in the form of a global federation, with the principle of democracy being applied to each political unit. Fourthly, there is a long tradition in liberal thought that argues for the need to establish a global confederation of democratic states. The writings of Immanuel Kant (Perpetual peace) and John Rawls (Law of peoples) are examined here. Fifthly, to the extent that globalisation has produced (political) communities of fate not defined by reference to state boundaries, the model of cosmopolitan democratic law developed by David Held argues that effective citizen control over decision-making processes requires the reconfiguration of political authority to ensure that political communities, however organised, exercise democratic control over the global regulatory regimes that emerge in response to the processes of globalisation. Sixthly, moving from idealtype theories to concrete proposals for the democratisation of extant institutions, arguments for the application of the principles of democracy to international institutions are examined. The parliamentary principle leads to proposals for the establishment of international assemblies, notably in relation to the UN; there is also a requirement to ensure the development of more accountability in global regulation, relying on the democratic principles of transparency, debate and public reason (including the requirement of public justification for the exercise of political authority). A particular focus is the role of experts in global governance (governance by technocracies, as opposed to governance by the people). Finally, the chapter reviews the ways in which international civil society is able to use communicative power (the power of words and arguments) to influence discourses and pressurise international institutions. Having established the lack of consensus on arguments around the democratic legitimacy of international law, chapter two seeks to bring some clarity to the debate by defining the idea of a deficit in the practice of democracy and evaluating the problem from the perspective of the constitutional democratic state. There is a deficit in the practice of democracy where the people do not decide for themselves, by democratic political procedures, those conditions of their lives that are politically decidable. The authority and autonomy of international law appears problematic for the practice of domestic democracy, but it is not clear what is lost in the absence of agreement on the meaning of democracy. The solution to any democratic deficit looks very different if we apply an electoral or representative conception of democracy, rather than one that relies on a deliberative understanding, and as John Dryzek observes, thinking about democracy beyond the state becomes easier where
Columns Design Ltd
/
Job: Wheatley
/
Division: 00_Introduction
/Pg. Position: 17 /
Date: 26/3
JOBNAME: Wheatley PAGE: 18 SESS: 4 OUTPUT: Tue May 11 14:32:06 2010
18 Introduction democracy is defined by reference to deliberation, rather than competitive elections.67 The work adopts the concept of deliberative democracy developed by Jürgen Habermas, who provides the most intellectually rigorous defence of the idea. The principle and practice of democracy depends on an implementation of the principle of discourse: ‘D: Just those action norms are valid to which all possible affected persons could agree as participants in rational discourses.’ The democratic state imagines itself to be an association of free and equal persons, with the exercise of legitimate political authority depending on the establishment of democratic institutions and practices, and a public sphere that allows the public (those affected) to regard themselves as both subjects and authors of law norms. The model outlined by Habermas becomes incoherent at the level of global governance as there is no global public that defines itself by reference to the exercise of global regulatory functions or that possesses the capacity of (global) opinion- and will-formation (no demos, no democracy). There is a role for a reformed UN, but this is limited to upholding international peace and security and the protection of human rights, although it is not clear what the justification is for exempting these global governance functions from the requirement of democratic legitimacy. The arguments developed in this book apply the insights provided by the model of deliberative democracy to global regulatory norms (including public international law norms and forms of international governance by non-state actors). The constitutional democracy might imagine itself to be an association of free and equal persons, but it does not define its own boundaries (or demos) or the conditions for the exercise of legitimate political authority (which are often defined by global law norms). The ideal of democratic self-determination must be reconciled with the authority of international law, which constructs the political entity entitled to self-determination (the state) and limits the right by reference to global justice norms. Three possibilities present themselves: to abandon the idea of democracy beyond the state and look to other bases of political legitimacy for global regulation; to ‘democratise’ global governance; or evaluate the attitude that the democratic state should adopt to global regulatory norms. The problem for democracy (and democratic self-determination) that results from the authority of international law is not a consequence of the collapse of the Westphalian settlement, although it has been exacerbated by recent developments in the reallocation of political authority to new sites. Chapter three examines the problem for democracy that results from the allocation of authority under the Westphalian settlement according to the principle of (internal and external) sovereignty: state and
67
John Dryzek, ‘Transnational Democracy’ (1999) 7 Journal of Political Philosophy 30, 44.
Columns Design Ltd
/
Job: Wheatley
/
Division: 00_Introduction
/Pg. Position: 18 /
Date: 26/3
JOBNAME: Wheatley PAGE: 19 SESS: 4 OUTPUT: Tue May 11 14:32:06 2010
The Structure of the Book
19
international law. Democratic legitimacy (according to the standard argument) rests on the expression of sovereign consent to laws (both internally and externally): the state as (democratic) self-legislator. The problems for the argument are that the authority and content of international law norms does not depend on the will of the people, but the interpretation provided by the discipline of international law (the rule of international law). International law norms bind democratic states and, in contrast to constitutional and political law norms, they are not subject to repeal or revision by the people (alone). The democratic legitimacy of public international law rests on the (legitimate) authority of the international law order and the (democratic) idea of deliberative diplomacy, in which international law norms are agreed through processes of reasoned deliberation in the international community. The (sovereign) state and the international law order are social constructs. Chapter four examines evidence that international law is undergoing a process of reconstruction (or ‘constitutionalisation’), moving beyond the proceduralist paradigm, based on sovereign consent, to a public (international) law governance model that embraces substantive values. This is reflected in the normative hierarchy of international law (norms of jus cogens standing and obligations erga omnes) and acceptance of the UN as an autonomous international organisation that operates without any requirement of consent by states subject to its authority. The work consequently examines the emergence of the international constitutional order that reflects liberal democratic values of separation of powers (fragmentation), rule of law, and protection of human rights. Chapter five evaluates the implications that arise from the emergence of democracy as a principle of international law, reflected in norms concerning rights of (political) self-determination, democracy and political participation; in the practice of states; and in the commitment to democracy found in a number of international law instruments. The discipline of international law (reflected in the understandings of the invisible college) has yet to conclude that there is a right to democracy or breach of an international law obligation for states that are not democratic. Democratic governments do, though, have the right to (legitimate) authority, reflected in the right of peoples to (political) selfdetermination, and the principle of democracy influences the interpretation and application of international law norms, concerning, for example, the right of peoples to self-determination/secession. The clearest example relates to the practice of forced democratic regime change (notably in the cases of Afghanistan and Iraq), providing further evidence that international law functions to construct democratic states. The focus of the book then turns from the inter-state system to the complexities and problems for democracy that arise from the globalisation and fragmentation of governance functions, and the emergence of
Columns Design Ltd
/
Job: Wheatley
/
Division: 00_Introduction
/Pg. Position: 19 /
Date: 26/3
JOBNAME: Wheatley PAGE: 20 SESS: 4 OUTPUT: Tue May 11 14:32:06 2010
20
Introduction
non-state actors as important producers of global norms framed in terms of law. Chapter six demonstrates the divergent nature of international governance by non-state actors, with a particular focus on the activities of the UN Security Council, Basel Committee on Banking Supervision, World Commission on Dams, and private international governance mechanisms such as the Forest Stewardship Council and Fairtrade Labelling Organisation. These non-state actors have emerged as global regulators without the clear jurisdictional boundaries or institutions of government (legislatures and courts) associated with the traditional source of regulatory authority, the territorial state. Regulatory norms are established by non-state actors without the link to validity provided by an expression of sovereign (and democratic) will. Not all forms of global governance are framed in terms of law. The (political) decision to frame global norms in terms of law provides a role for (public international) lawyers and for the application of the distinctive methods for the interpretation of (international) law norms. In cases of conflict between autonomous systems of law (including state law systems), complex questions of jurisprudence emerge; in cases of conflict between legal orders and other normative orders, law (always) prevails. The first requirement is to develop an analytical concept of (international) law in order to determine which conflicts are problematic from the perspective of the exercise of authority through ‘law’. Drawing on the works of Niklas Luhmann and Gunther Teubner, Brian Tamanaha, and Joseph Raz, chapter seven concludes that law is a system of communications framed in terms of law, ie coded legal/illegal, and issued by an authority to subjects. The (legitimate) exercise of authority is conditioned by respect for the cardinal principles of deliberative democracy: equality and public reason. Legitimate authority (and there is no such thing as illegitimate authority) depends on the exercise of authority in accordance with the right reasons that apply to the subjects of the authority regime: the legitimate exercise of authority depends on an institutionalisation of the (deliberative) principles of equality and public reason. The exercise of (legitimate) political authority by non-state actors requires democratic forms of decision-making that take into account the interests and perspectives of those subject to the international governance regime. (The argument should not be understood as a requirement for the introduction of competitive elections to a representative assembly in relation to global regulators.) Traditional forms of state and international law enjoy presumptive political authority, the doctrine of the rule of law. In the modern age, state law relies on forms of democratic legitimacy for its authority, inter-state law on a combination of contractual and democratic legitimacy, pacta sunt servanda and the process of rational deliberation that precedes the reaching of agreement. The revised concept of law developed here allows for
Columns Design Ltd
/
Job: Wheatley
/
Division: 00_Introduction
/Pg. Position: 20 /
Date: 26/3
JOBNAME: Wheatley PAGE: 21 SESS: 4 OUTPUT: Tue May 11 14:32:06 2010
The Structure of the Book
21
the application of the principle of (deliberative) democracy to non-state systems of law. Chapter eight outlines the requirements and addresses Habermas’ objections to the application of deliberative democracy beyond the state, concluding that a political community is constituted and defined by the exercise of political authority. The exercise of political authority constitutes the demos; democratic practices legitimise the exercise of political authority. Those subjected to the law provide the ‘who’ of global political justice (within each autonomous law order), allowing the development of a discourse of global deliberative politics and arguments around the ‘what’ of (political) justice. In evaluating the democratic legitimacy of global governance, the work argues that the concept of deliberative democracy can be applied to the state system, the systems of public international law, and new forms of international governance by non-state actors. The problem of democracy following the globalisation and fragmentation of governance functions might not be a deficit of democracy, but a surfeit of competing and conflicting visions of (democratic) political truth, defined in terms of right policy, or (political) justice. Chapter nine draws on the literature on legal pluralism to conclude that there is no meta-perspective for evaluating the democratic legitimacy of international law (broadly defined to include all forms of global governance). In conditions of global legal pluralism, there may be multiple versions of (democratic) political truth. Returning to the perspective of the constitutional democracy, the legitimacy of global governance must be constructed from the perspective of the state law system in accordance with the values of deliberative democracy. The work recognises that state law systems will make strategic decisions to comply with international law norms and the continuing relevance of pacta sunt servanda (promises must be kept), but concludes that a democratic state should evaluate global law norms by reference to the deliberative ideal: legal norms are valid where all subject to them could agree to the norms through discourses. The (legitimate) authority of law depends on the establishment of norms that promote the right reasons that apply to the subjects of law norms, and in conditions of complexity, uncertainty and disagreement, right reasons can only be established through democratic procedures. The construction of a multiverse of democratic visions of global governance orders by democratic states will have the practical consequence of democratising the international law order, providing democratic legitimacy for international law. The book concludes with some reflections on the implications of the analysis for international law as a professional discipline.
Columns Design Ltd
/
Job: Wheatley
/
Division: 00_Introduction
/Pg. Position: 21 /
Date: 26/3
JOBNAME: Wheatley PAGE: 1 SESS: 5 OUTPUT: Tue May 11 14:32:06 2010
1 The Democratic Deficit in Global Governance
T
HIS CHAPTER EXPLORES the arguments around the putative democratic deficit in global governance in order to clarify the issues and evaluate the dominant modes of thinking about democracy beyond the state. Complaints that there is a democratic deficit in international law fall into one of a number of categories: that in the absence of a global state it makes no sense to talk about global democracy; to the extent that international law operates in a way that does not respect the principle of sovereign equality there is a democratic deficit; that international organisations ‘legislate’ in a way that is not democratic; and that the participation of non-democracies in the international law system undermines the democratic legitimacy of international law norms. Why, for example, should citizens in democratic states accept the ‘soft’ resolutions adopted by the United Nations (UN) General Assembly with the support of authoritarian regimes, or international treaties that allow for the participation of non-democracies?1 The work follows José Alvarez in dividing the complaints into three types: vertical, horizontal and ideological.2 The vertical complaint concerns the relationship between global governance institutions and individual citizens; the horizontal complaint applies to relations between 1 See John McGinnis and Ilya Somin, ‘Should International Law be Part of our Law?’ (2007) 59 Stanford Law Review 1175, 1204–05. Elsewhere, McGinnis observes in relation to the development of international human rights norms that, given the participation of totalitarian states such as the Soviet Union and People’s Republic of China, ‘[o]ne can hardly be confident that the same provisions would have emerged absent the influence of those “evil empire[s].”’ John McGinnis, ‘The Comparative Disadvantage of Customary International Law’ (2006) 30 Harvard Journal of Law and Public Policy 7, 10. See also John McGinnis and Ilya Somin, ‘Democracy and International Human Rights Law’ (2009) 84 Notre Dame Law Review 1739. 2 José Alvarez, ‘Introducing the Themes [International law and democratic theory]’ (2007) 38 Victoria University of Wellington Law Review 159, 159. A different typology is provided by Charnovitz: international organisations are not run in a democratic manner vis-à-vis participating states, for example in relation to the United Nations Security Council; international laws and treaties do not sufficiently mandate democracy within each state; and international organisations are not run in a democratic manner vis-à-vis the public: Steve Charnovitz, ‘The Emergence of Democratic Participation in Global Governance (Paris, 1919)’ (2003) 10 Indiana Journal of Global Legal Studies 45, 48.
Columns Design Ltd
/
Job: Wheatley
/
Division: 01_Thearguments
/Pg. Position: 1 /
Date: 26/3
JOBNAME: Wheatley PAGE: 2 SESS: 5 OUTPUT: Tue May 11 14:32:06 2010
The ‘Vertical’ Complaint
23
states (and between states and international organisations); whilst the ideological complaint concerns the fact that global governance functions to promote certain (liberal) values. Following an analysis of the forms that the democratic deficit critique has taken in the literature, the work then examines the responses that have emerged: that domestic democracy is protected by an affirmation of the principle of state sovereignty; that global democracy requires a global democratic state; that we should imagine the international community as a global democratic federation, with the principle of democracy applied at each level; that (following Immanuel Kant and John Rawls) global democratic law can only be achieved through the establishment of a democratic peace; that the globalisation and fragmentation of global regulatory functions must be reconfigured in accordance with the idea of cosmopolitan democratic law; that there is a need to democratise international institutions, notably through the greater use of international parliamentary bodies and accountability mechanisms; and finally, the need to challenge the communicative power of dominant global discourses by allowing the effective participation of international non-governmental organisations and other civil society actors in the practice of global governance.
THE ‘VERTICAL’ COMPLAINT
The first complaint concerns the relationship between international institutions and citizens. The ‘vertical’ complaint can be further divided: first, that the exercise of governance functions by non-democratic institutions constitutes a loss for democracy; second, that the globalisation and fragmentation of law-making prerogatives provides opportunities for political actors to promote the adoption of law norms that do not enjoy domestic support; and finally, that all liberal democracies share, at some level, a commitment to human rights. The introduction of measures by international organisations that do not respect minimum human rights standards is a loss for the idea of democratic legitimacy. In relation to the first point, it is evident that international law does not replicate in any meaningful way domestic democratic systems of government. Most significantly, there is no international parliament, with the consequence, as Alvarez observes, that international law ‘lack the ties to democratically elected polities that legitimise law within democracies’. Nor do international law-making processes appear to possess other components associated with constitutional democracies, such as the
Columns Design Ltd
/
Job: Wheatley
/
Division: 01_Thearguments
/Pg. Position: 2 /
Date: 26/3
JOBNAME: Wheatley PAGE: 3 SESS: 4 OUTPUT: Tue May 11 14:32:06 2010
24 The Democratic Deficit in Global Governance separation of powers.3 The individual citizen is largely absent from the international law system, which is characterised (or caricatured) by the idea of an equal voice and vote for sovereign states (only), a position that is inconsistent with liberal political theory, which regards the individual as the ‘primary normative unit’.4 John McGinnis observes that international law represents agreement between states, not peoples, ‘and thus there is much less reason to think it should trump or even cast doubt on the judgments reached by democratic deliberations in particular nations’.5 On this understanding, the solution to the problem for democracy is provided by a re-affirmation of the principle of sovereignty, which requires the consent of states to any emergent (international law) norm. The alternative, consistent with liberal theory, would be to ‘inject the voice of individual citizens into the exclusively state-based structures’ of international law.6 The argument follows social contract theory, which demands evidence of real or hypothetical consent by those subject to the law to establish legitimate political authority. The process of decolonisation, ie the dismantling of non-contiguous empires, gave voice and vote to a greater number of individuals through the creation of new states (from around 60 to almost 200 in the period of the UN), but significant groups remain (formally) excluded from the processes of international law-making.7 Individuals are represented through state governments and the position of the government will not always correspond with that of the citizen. Moreover, an individual that seeks to influence the development of international law norms must influence not only her own government, but also other governments (without any right of access to or influence on domestic political debates in other states as rights of political participation are limited to citizens).8
3 ibid at 160. For ‘classical liberals, a separation of powers was the centrepiece of modern constitutionalism, a necessary condition of liberty’: Giandomenico Majone, ‘Delegation of Regulatory Powers in a Mixed Polity’ (2002) 8 European Law Journal 319, 323. 4 Fernando Téson, ‘The Kantian Theory of International Law’ (1992) 92 Columbia Law Review 53, 54. 5 John McGinnis, ‘Foreign to our Constitution’ (2006) 100 Northwestern University Law Review 303, 313. 6 Eric Stein, ‘International Integration and Democracy: No Love at First Sight’ (2001) 95 American Journal of International Law 489, 533. 7 The recognition of the rights of national minorities, minorities, and indigenous peoples, and introduction of human rights mechanisms has given a voice to some in the international law system. A notable development was the adoption of the UN Declaration on the Rights of Indigenous Peoples. After more than a decade of dialogue involving representatives of indigenous peoples, the UN General Assembly adopted Resolution 61/295, ‘The United Nations Declaration on the Rights of Indigenous Peoples’ (13 September 2007). The participation of indigenous peoples was regarded as significant, with the representative of Peru observing in the General Assembly that it lent ‘unquestionable legitimacy to the document’: UN Doc A/61/PV.107 (13 September 2007) 10. 8 The role of international non-governmental organisations can be seen to amplify the voice of the individual in global politics, and influence government officials of other states
Columns Design Ltd
/
Job: Wheatley
/
Division: 01_Thearguments
/Pg. Position: 3 /
Date: 26/3
JOBNAME: Wheatley PAGE: 4 SESS: 4 OUTPUT: Tue May 11 14:32:06 2010
The ‘Vertical’ Complaint
25
Secondly, in relation to the vertical complaint, the fact that international law is made by the executive branch of government and the requirement that states comply with international law obligations empowers the executive at the expense of the legislative and judicial branches of domestic government, reducing the effectiveness of any checks and balances on power.9 During the Westphalian epoch of international law,10 global governance was the domain of states, which spoke with a single voice, that of the executive.11 The position is articulated clearly in the Vienna Convention on the Law of Treaties: heads of state and government, and ministers for foreign affairs have, by virtue of their function, full powers to bind the state at the level of international law.12 Any international text agreed by senior members of the executive is legally binding and must be performed in good faith.13 The state may not invoke domestic law to justify a failure to perform a treaty obligation,14 unless consent was expressed in manifest violation of a provision of domestic law regarding competence to conclude treaties and concerned a rule of internal law of fundamental importance.15 The subsequent objection of a national parliament, popular opposition or change of government, or the fact that an international agreement conflicts with a provision of the national constitution, are irrelevant from the perspective of international law.16 In Case of Certain German Interests in Polish Upper Silesia, the Permanent Court of International Justice observed: ‘From the standpoint of International Law and of the Court which is its organ, municipal laws are merely facts which express the will and constitute the activities of States.’17 Domestic executives may welcome the (domestic) democratic deficit that results from the globalisation of regulatory functions and may prefer the seemingly more straightforward processes of international lawmaking to those of domestic law, which often requires extensive processes of consultation and justification, and in many cases positive
and international bureaucrats that she had no opportunity to vote for or exercise (direct) influence over: Steve Charnovitz, ‘Nongovernmental Organizations and International Law’ (2006) 100 American Journal of International Law 348, fn 134. 9 Alvarez (n 2) at 160. 10 cf Wilhelm Grewe, The Epochs of International Law, trans by Michael Byers (Berlin, Walter de Gruyter, 2000). 11 Thomas M. Franck, Fairness in International Law and Institutions (Oxford, Clarendon Press, 1995) 479–80. 12 Vienna Convention on the Law of Treaties 1155 UNTS 331 art 7(2)(a). 13 ibid art 26. 14 ibid art 27. 15 ibid art 46(1). 16 Treatment of Polish Nationals and Other Persons of Polish Origin or Speech in the Danzig Territory (1931) PCIJ Series A/B No 44, 24. 17 Case of Certain German Interests in Polish Upper Silesia (1926) PCIJ, Series A No 7, 19.
Columns Design Ltd
/
Job: Wheatley
/
Division: 01_Thearguments
/Pg. Position: 4 /
Date: 26/3
JOBNAME: Wheatley PAGE: 5 SESS: 4 OUTPUT: Tue May 11 14:32:06 2010
26 The Democratic Deficit in Global Governance parliamentary support.18 As Keohane, Macedo and Moravcsik observe, globalised governance allows domestic and international elites ‘to bypass the onerous processes of persuasion and consensus-seeking that democracy requires’.19 One example is Security Council (SC) Resolution 1624 (2005), which calls on all states to prohibit by law incitement to commit terrorist acts.20 The resolution was passed at a summit meeting attended by British Prime Minister Tony Blair, who was a key actor in its adoption. Before arriving in New York for the Security Council meeting, he had signalled the British Government’s desire to criminalise the glorification of terrorism as one part of the response to the bombings in London on 7 July 2005. Once SC Resolution 1624 was adopted, the British Government relied on the resolution to justify the tightening of domestic laws on incitement through the adoption of s 1 of the Terrorism Act 2006.21 It is not clear that the measure would have enjoyed sufficient domestic political and popular support absent the (apparent) requirement in international law to introduce the legislation. The globalisation of governance functions does not only enhance the executive. Where international law norms (broadly defined) are ‘domesticated’ by national courts without the positive support of the people, or their representatives, there is a loss for democracy. In addition to citing the jurisprudence of other constitutional courts on questions of social and political controversy,22 constitutional courts are increasingly willing to rely on international law norms and the judgments and opinions of international law courts and tribunals that do not formally bind at the level of domestic law (until adopted by the court). Mark Tushnet makes the point that where judges on domestic courts have the authority to make and re-make constitutional law, the ‘separation-of-powers concerns’ about them inappropriately domesticating international law
18 Aida Torres Pérez, ‘The Internationalization of Lawmaking Processes: Constraining or Empowering the Executive?’ (2006) 14 Tulsa Journal of Comparative and International Law 1, 1–2. See also David Zaring, ‘International Law by Other Means: the Twilight Existence of International Financial Regulatory Organizations’ (1998) 33 Texas International Law Journal 281, 323. 19 Robert Keohane, Stephen Macedo and Andrew Moravcsik, ‘Democracy Enhancing Multilateralism’ (2009) 63 International Organization 1, 3. 20 Security Council (SC) Res 1624 (2005) para 1. 21 Ian Cram, Terror and the War on Dissent (Berlin, Springer,, 2009) 39 – 40. See also Clive Walker, ‘The Legal Definition of “Terrorism” in United Kingdom Law and Beyond’ (2007) Public Law 331, 333. 22 Anne-Marie Slaughter argues that national constitutional courts are involved in a form of collective deliberation through mutual citation and direct communications, leading to a ‘nascent global jurisprudence’ on certain issues: Anne-Marie Slaughter, ‘A Brave New Judicial World’ in Michael Ignatieff (ed), American Exceptionalism and Human Rights (Princeton, New Jersey, Princeton University Press, 2005) 277, 278.
Columns Design Ltd
/
Job: Wheatley
/
Division: 01_Thearguments
/Pg. Position: 5 /
Date: 26/3
JOBNAME: Wheatley PAGE: 6 SESS: 4 OUTPUT: Tue May 11 14:32:06 2010
The ‘Vertical’ Complaint
27
norms ‘are no different from the separation-of-powers concerns associated with their power to make law generally’.23 The focus for concerns around the (domestic) counter-majoritarian difficulty does not lie at the level of international law. Civil society actors have also sought to take advantage of the shift in policy-making to global institutions. Finnemore and Sikkink identify a phenomenon whereby ‘norm entrepreneurs’ who have failed to have their position accepted in domestic politics seek to internationalise a policy issue, with the objective of subsequently using international norms to strengthen their position in domestic policy debates.24 Civil society actors who have been unsuccessful at the domestic level are provided, in John Bolton’s phraseology, with a ‘second bite at the apple’.25 A ‘boomerang’ effect is observed, whereby domestic actors by-pass national debates to appeal to actors in the international community to bring pressure on the government.26 Simultaneously principled and strategic actors, norm entrepreneurs seek to bring new ideas, norms, and discourses into policy debates at the global level.27 The first step is to attempt to convince a critical mass of states to embrace new norms. These states are the norm leaders. The second stage is characterised by a dynamic of imitation, as the norm leaders attempt to socialise other states to become norm followers. The norm ‘cascades’ through the ‘population of states’, the result of a pressure for conformity and a desire to enhance international legitimation. Following this, ‘norm internalization occurs; norms acquire a taken-for-granted quality and are no longer a matter of broad public debate’. The first two stages are divided by a ‘tipping point’, at which ‘a critical mass of relevant state actors adopt the norm’.28 Prior to that point, little normative change occurs without significant domestic movements supporting such change. After the tipping point, more countries begin to adopt new norms more rapidly even without domestic
23 Mark Tushnet, ‘The Inevitable Globalization of Constitutional Law’ Harvard Public Law Working Paper No 09–06 (SSRN) (Hague Institute for the Internationalization of Law, December 18, 2008) fn 56. 24 Martha Finnemore and Kathryn Sikkink, ‘International Norm Dynamics and Political Change’ (1998) 52 International Organization 887, 893. 25 John Bolton, ‘Should we take Global Governance Seriously?’ (2000) 1 Chicago Journal of International Law 205, 217. On the effectiveness of international non-governmental organisations, see Alan Boyle and Christine Chinkin, The Making of International Law (Oxford, Oxford University Press, 2007) 93; also Eric Posner, ‘International Law and the Disaggregated State’ (2005) 32 Florida State University Law Review 797, 816. 26 Thomas Risse and Kathryn Sikkink, ‘The Socialization of International Human Rights Norms into Domestic Practices: Introduction’ in Thomas Risse et al (eds), The Power of Human Rights: International Norms and Domestic Change (Cambridge, Cambridge University Press, 1999) 1, 18. 27 Margaret Keck and Kathryn Sikkink, Activists Beyond Borders: Advocacy Networks in International Politics (Ithaca, New York; London, Cornell University Press, 1998) 3. 28 Finnemore and Sikkink (n 24) at 895.
Columns Design Ltd
/
Job: Wheatley
/
Division: 01_Thearguments
/Pg. Position: 6 /
Date: 26/3
JOBNAME: Wheatley PAGE: 7 SESS: 4 OUTPUT: Tue May 11 14:32:06 2010
28 The Democratic Deficit in Global Governance pressure for change: the new norm is accepted as (re-)defining ‘appropriate behavior for the identity called “state” or some relevant subset of states (such as a “liberal” state or a European state)’.29 In relation to apartheid South Africa, Audie Klotz argues that the international law norm concerning racial discrimination played a crucial role in defining the identity and interests of states and international organisations, and shared understandings regarding illegitimate behaviour and policies.30 Judith Kelly argues that the global norm that elections should be free and fair and subject to external monitoring emerged as the result of an evolving set of norms related to democracy, elections and human rights, with the ‘tipping point’ occurring at the end of the Cold War. As more and more transitioning countries sought legitimacy through monitoring, the cost of refusing monitors increased, leading to the rapid spread, or cascade, of the norm of election monitoring.31 Thirdly, in relation to the vertical complaint, which concerns relations between international law and citizens, there may be a ‘substantive’ democratic deficit where international organisations fail to recognise and protect certain (human) rights that are assumed to be inherent in the practice of democracy. The sanctions regime of the UN Security Council is a particular source of concern here,32 with Bogdandy et al making the point that the listing of terrorist suspects by the Security Council ‘provides the most dramatic example of governance that would be hardly permissible at the domestic level’.33 The conclusion depends on the conception of democracy applied by the critical observer, and the proper balance between security and liberty that all democratic societies are required to achieve when faced with a determined terrorist organisation. It is not necessarily a conclusion that all good faith persons committed to democracy would share, ie it is not necessarily inherent in the idea of democracy. THE ‘HORIZONTAL’ COMPLAINT
The horizontal complaint identified by Alvarez concerns relations between states. Former UN Secretary-General Kofi Anan writes that democracy at the global level is important ‘because it affects relations 29
ibid at 902. Audie Klotz, Norms in International Relations: the Struggle against Apartheid (Ithaca, NY; London: Cornell University Press, 1995) 9. 31 Judith Kelly, ‘Assessing the Complex Evolution of Norms: the Rise of International Election Monitoring’ (2008) 62 International Organization 221. 32 Alvarez (n 2) at 160–61. 33 Armin von Bogdandy et al, ‘Developing the Publicness of Public International Law: Towards a Legal Framework for Global Governance Activities’ (2008) 9(11) German Law Journal 1375, 1379–80. 30
Columns Design Ltd
/
Job: Wheatley
/
Division: 01_Thearguments
/Pg. Position: 7 /
Date: 26/3
JOBNAME: Wheatley PAGE: 8 SESS: 3 OUTPUT: Tue May 11 14:32:06 2010
The ‘Horizontal’ Complaint
29
among states’.34 Referring to the idea of sovereign equality, reflected in art 2(1) of the UN Charter, Anan argues that small and powerless states feel ‘less unequal’ at the UN than at other international organisations, such as the World Bank, International Monetary Fund (IMF), etc, although he concedes that the Security Council would be more ‘democratic’ if it were ‘more representative of the membership as a whole’.35 The argument is that international law is democratically illegitimate ‘to the extent it fails to treat sovereigns as horizontal equals’.36 Alvarez himself has argued that a democratic deficit exists wherever international organisations use weighted forms of voting that elevate the rights of certain states over others.37 The locus classicus is the UN Security Council, which provides a right of veto for the five permanent members (P-5), but not others, with membership limited to the P-5 and 10 elected UN Member States.38 As constituted on 3 April 2009, the members of the UN Security Council represented (directly) some 2.3 billion persons, or 35 per cent of the world’s population. Other examples include the IMF, where voting is determined by an assigned quota, and World Bank, where it is determined by the number of shares to which the state has subscribed, giving the United States and its Western Allies ‘a clear preponderance in the two institutions’.39 The argument equates the sovereignty and equality of states with the political equality of citizens: one person, one vote, one state, one vote, etc. Democracy is understood as a system of collective decision-making in which any move away from the principle of political equality results in a deficit in the practice of democracy. Tony Carty, for example, argues that institutions such as the IMF should be ‘democratically governed’,40 and that ‘a regime of voting which approached “one state, one vote” would more closely correspond to the wishes of the majority of mankind[,] and, hence, be more consistent with the notions of political democracy prevalent in the West.’41 Carty confuses and conflates two arguments: that the agreement of a majority of states would accord democratic legitimacy 34
Kofi Anan, ‘Democracy as a Universal Issue’ (2002) 8 Global Governance 135, 139. ibid at 140 (emphasis in original). 36 Alvarez (n 2) at 162. 37 José E Alvarez, ‘International Organizations: Then and Now’ (2006) 100 American Journal of International Law 324, 341. 38 UN Charter art 27(3). 39 Christian Tomuschat, ‘Multilateralism in an Age of US Hegemony’ in Ronald St John Macdonald and Douglas Johnston (eds), Towards World Constitutionalism: Issues in the Legal Ordering of the World Community (Leiden, Martinus Nijhoff Publishers, 2005) 31, 47. In relation to the reform agenda of the IMF, see ‘International Monetary Fund, Reform of IMF Quotas and Voice: Responding to Changes in the Global Economy’ (2008). Available: www.imf.org/external/np/exr/ib/2007/041307.htm (last visited 15 January 2010). 40 Anthony Carty, ‘Liberal Economic Rhetoric as an Obstacle to the Democratization of the World Economy’ (1998) 98 Ethics 742, 748. 41 ibid at 756 (emphasis added). 35
Columns Design Ltd
/
Job: Wheatley
/
Division: 01_Thearguments
/Pg. Position: 8 /
Date: 26/2
JOBNAME: Wheatley PAGE: 9 SESS: 4 OUTPUT: Tue May 11 14:32:06 2010
30 The Democratic Deficit in Global Governance and that a principle of aggregative legitimacy can be applied to relations between states. In relation to the first, the UN General Assembly is the most representative international institution (in terms of the representation of states), yet a simple majority of Member States, comprising the smallest in terms of population, represents less than five per cent of the world’s population.42 By contrast, a ‘majority of mankind’ can be achieved by aggregating the populations of just six states, around three per cent of the total number: the People’s Republic of China, India, the United States of America, Indonesia, Brazil, and Pakistan. The principle of sovereign equality, as Steve Charnovitz observes, is at odds with that of political equality. Democracy is concerned with popular rule by the people based on equal rights; what is true for a community of persons is not necessarily true for the international community of states: ‘giving China and San Tome and Principe an equal say would seem to contradict the principle of “one man one vote,” in view of the huge population disparity between the two countries’. The political equality of citizens is not analogous to sovereign equality: ‘one state, one vote’ does not follow logically from ‘one person, one vote’.43 Sovereign equality is essentially a contractual principle, precluding the imposition of international law obligations in the absence of state consent; the principle of political equality of citizens provides one part of the justification for the exercise of coercive political authority, even in the absence of consent. As Joseph Weiler observes, the idea that an international law norm cannot emerge without the consent of all states bound by it ‘sounds very much like democracy at the international level. But, in fact and in law, in theory and in practice, this is part of a very different vocabulary, namely that of sovereignty and sovereign equality.’ In fact it is ‘the opposite of any functioning notion of democracy which is based on the opposite premise[:] that a majority within a collectivity, a demos, has the authority to bind its individual members, even against their will’.44 (Of course this is only one understanding of democracy.) The requirement of consent to international law norms (at least in terms of treaty norms and the persistent objector rule in relation to customary international law) provides one part of the answer to the problem of democracy beyond the state, but a complete solution must recognise the existence of autonomous law orders in global governance; the importance of reasoned deliberation in inter-state communications; and fact that states are not
42 John Jackson, ‘Sovereignty-modern: a New Approach to an Outdated Concept’ (2003) 97 American Journal of International Law 782, fn 60. 43 Steve Charnovitz, ‘The Emergence of Democratic Participation in Global Governance (Paris, 1919)’ (2003) 10 Indiana Journal of Global Legal Studies 45, 49. 44 JHH Weiler, ‘The Geology of International Law-governance, Democracy and Legitimacy’ (2004) 64 ZaöRV (Heidleberg Journal of International Law) 547, 548.
Columns Design Ltd
/
Job: Wheatley
/
Division: 01_Thearguments
/Pg. Position: 9 /
Date: 26/3
JOBNAME: Wheatley PAGE: 10 SESS: 4 OUTPUT: Tue May 11 14:32:06 2010
The ‘Ideological’ Complaint
31
moral or rational beings with homogenous identities (indeed democratic minorities within the state may prefer the international law norm to the position of ‘their’ government). THE ‘IDEOLOGICAL’ COMPLAINT
The ideological complaint contends that a democratic deficit results where global institutions pursue certain ‘ideological preferences’ at the expense of others.45 Barnett and Finnemore conclude that international organisations promote a particular, ‘mostly liberal, moral vision in world politics’,46 referring to the ‘substantively liberal character’ of international organisations, which have in the main been established by Western liberal states ‘and are designed to promote liberal values’, although they are themselves ‘emphatically not democratic’.47 Barnett and Finnemore refer to an idea of ‘undemocratic liberalism’, whereby international organisations use undemocratic procedures in the promotion of human rights and economic development through a free market and free trade.48 The imposition of global norms is justified on the basis that it prevents citizens from making wrong choices, substituting choices that the people would have made if they were sufficiently informed and rational, or imposing policies that domestic governments would have adopted were they not beholden to special interest groups. Kal Raustiala argues that by removing decisions from the realm of domestic politics, international economic institutions can become ‘saviors of sovereignty because they unshackle policymaking from the illegitimate power of concentrated special interest groups’. International economic institutions promote the establishment of policies that the people would choose if they were not ‘organizationally unprivileged and rationally ignorant’.49 The claims of global technocrats to ‘know better’ would be acceptable only if the policy issues under consideration were not political, ie if they were not subject to disagreement by reasonable persons. Political debates are concerned with arguments around conflicting visions for organising society, and according to the democratic model of political legitimacy, the political constitution and conceptions of justice must be agreed by, or (ultimately) subject to, democratic procedures. Jürgen Habermas writes 45
Alvarez, (n 2) at 163. Michael Barnett and Martha Finnemore, Rules for the World: International Organizations in Global Politics (Ithaca, Cornell University Press, 2004) 165. 47 ibid at 15. 48 ibid at 172. 49 Kal Raustiala, ‘Rethinking the Sovereignty Debate in International Economic Law’ (2003) 6 Journal of International Economic Law 841, 865. See also Anne-Marie Slaughter and William Burke-White, ‘The Future of International Law is Domestic (or, the European Way of Law)’ (2006) 47 Harvard International Law Journal 327. 46
Columns Design Ltd
/
Job: Wheatley
/
Division: 01_Thearguments
/Pg. Position: 10 /
Date: 26/3
JOBNAME: Wheatley PAGE: 11 SESS: 4 OUTPUT: Tue May 11 14:32:06 2010
32 The Democratic Deficit in Global Governance that a shift from domestic democratic government to global regulatory expertise would be acceptable if we were able to conclude that the liberal economic world order was the only appropriate model for organising society (and even then we would have to agree on the particular model of liberal economic order); then there would there be ‘no further need in the process itself to justify the promotion of a worldwide deregulation of markets against government intervention’.50 This is manifestly not the case in the politics of world society. There is little doubt that international organisations pursue their respective policy objectives on the (self-)understanding that they are engaged in welfare-enhancing activities. The website of the World Bank, under the heading, ‘Your concerns are the World Bank’s priorities’, proclaims that ‘our mission is simple: to help reduce poverty’. It then makes a number of claims about the ways in which the Bank is helping the poorest countries and peoples.51 Any deficit in the practice of democracy beyond the state may claim to be compensated for by the pursuit of global justice ends (a globalised economy, development of good governance practices, protection of human rights, eradication of hunger, poverty and preventable disease, protection of the environment, etc), but these do not reflect agreed principles of global justice, and it is difficult to accept that these subjective and contestable values should override claims of (domestic) democratic self-determination, justifying the imposition of global law norms. For a number of writers, the idea of justice is only possible where there are coercive institutions of government (cf the idea of global governance). Thomas Christiano argues that the state is a necessary instrument for establishing justice. The state adjudicates disagreements about justice by defining rights and responsibilities, and establishes the framework of government that allows for the coercive enforcement of agreed (justice) norms and a system of taxation that allows for the possibility of distributive justice. The idea of justice is established in law through democratic procedures by members of the political community, and protected through the adjudication of disagreements about justice norms in an impartial manner. The state is the only institution that has the capacity to achieve political justice (understood in this way): it is the only institution that can reliably and impartially enforce legal rights and evaluate claims of injustice through the establishment of formal judicial bodies. The state provides the context in which individuals can make ‘authoritative collective decisions’ about the nature and requirements of justice through liberal
50 Jürgen Habermas, ‘A Political Constitution for the Pluralist World Society?’ (2007) 34 Journal of Chinese Philosophy 331, 341. 51 http://digitalmedia.worldbank.org/tenthings/en/4.php (last visited 29 June 2009).
Columns Design Ltd
/
Job: Wheatley
/
Division: 01_Thearguments
/Pg. Position: 11 /
Date: 26/3
JOBNAME: Wheatley PAGE: 12 SESS: 3 OUTPUT: Tue May 11 14:32:06 2010
The Democratisation of Global Governance
33
democratic procedures (required by democratic theory).52 In the absence of universal conceptions of justice acceptable to all persons (a condition of reasonable pluralism), the content of justice must be worked out through liberal democratic procedures. No global institutions enjoy the legislative legitimacy of the liberal democratic state. The most powerful of these, the Security Council, World Trade Organization, IMF and World Bank are ‘deeply inegalitarian’.53 They do not legislate in ways that are responsive to the interests of those affected by their governance activities and do not apply international law norms in an impartial and evenhanded manner, because they are dominated by a small number of powerful states. For these reasons international institutions cannot perform the function of ‘carefully and impartially rendering [political] justice’.54 Christiano argues that it makes no sense to talk about justice absent coercive (governmental) structures capable of rendering justice and follows John Rawls in rejecting the traditional arguments of (moral) philosophy that there is a single reasonable and rational position on justice that has been or (ideally) can be articulated, and which holds that ‘institutions are justifiable to the extent that they effectively promote that good’.55 Concepts of (political) justice must be worked through democratic procedures in accordance with the principle of public reason. In the absence of democracy at the global level, it makes no sense to refer to substantive concepts of global (political) justice, which must instead be limited to justice issues immanent in the concept of law and the exercise of (global) regulatory authority though law.
THE DEMOCRATISATION OF GLOBAL GOVERNANCE
The complaints against international law result from the following, alone or in combination: that the shift in the locus of law-making to global sites inhibits the ability of citizens to exercise meaningful control over the development of international law norms; the protection that sovereignty affords the right of the people to democratic self-determination is undermined to the extent that the international system moves away from the principle of sovereign equality; and dominant global discourses inhibit the possibilities of citizens articulating and establishing other visions of social existence. The concern for the practice of democracy is complicated 52 Thomas Christiano, ‘A Democratic Theory of Territory and Some Puzzles about Global Democracy’ (2006) 37 Journal of Social Philosophy 81, 92 (emphasis in original). 53 ibid at 94. 54 ibid at 96. 55 John Rawls, Political Liberalism (New York; Chichester, Columbia University Press, 2005) 134.
Columns Design Ltd
/
Job: Wheatley
/
Division: 01_Thearguments
/Pg. Position: 12 /
Date: 26/2
JOBNAME: Wheatley PAGE: 13 SESS: 4 OUTPUT: Tue May 11 14:32:06 2010
34 The Democratic Deficit in Global Governance by the exercise of regulatory functions at different levels (state, regional and global), and the absence of an overarching constitutional settlement that frames the exercise of political authority. In order to make sense of the democratic deficit and requirements for the democratisation of global governance, there is a need to evaluate the contending meta-principles for the allocation and exercise of political authority following the decline of the Westphalian settlement. The dominant arguments are examined in turn: the need to ensure the protection of democracy through the affirmation of sovereignty; the establishment of a global democratic state; the imagining of the extant system as a global democratic federation; the establishment of a covenant of peace between democratic nations; the application of the principle of cosmopolitan democratic law to the systems of fragmented authority; the democratisation of international organisations, principally through the application of the parliamentary principle of democracy; the enhancement of accountability in relation to the exercise of political authority by international organisations; and the enhancing of the role of international non-governmental organisations (NGOs) and other civil society actors in challenging dominant global discourses.
Reaffirming Sovereignty Previously, the exercise of political authority was organised in terms of (vertical) state and (horizontal) public international law. The exercise of political authority was justified by reference to the idea of (‘Westphalian’) sovereignty, which explained both the validity of state and international law norms, and the idea of political legitimacy, justified in terms of the exercise of sovereign authority by a democratic Rechtsstaat (state bound by the rule of law). The exercise of legitimate political authority was conditioned by an expression of sovereign consent (in accordance with the will of the people) at both the domestic and international level.56 The people of a democratic state were only subject to those internal (state) and external (international) laws ‘willed’ by the state (the state as ‘self-legislator’). The position was affirmed by the principle of sovereignty and the corollary right of non-intervention in domestic affairs.57 The UN Declaration on 56 Nathan Diament observes that democratic self-government requires not only that the people create the laws that they live under domestically, but also that they determine ‘how they protect their interests and project their power abroad’: Nathan Diament, ‘Foreign Relations and Our Domestic Constitution: Broadening the Discourse’ (1998) 30 Connecticut Law Review 911, 931–32. 57 In the Nicaragua case (Merits), the International Court of Justice made the following point: ‘A prohibited intervention must accordingly be one bearing on matters in which each State is permitted, by the principle of State sovereignty, to decide freely. One of these is the
Columns Design Ltd
/
Job: Wheatley
/
Division: 01_Thearguments
/Pg. Position: 13 /
Date: 26/3
JOBNAME: Wheatley PAGE: 14 SESS: 4 OUTPUT: Tue May 11 14:32:06 2010
The Democratisation of Global Governance
35
Principles of International Law Concerning Friendly Relations confirms that every state has the ‘inaniable right to choose its political, economic, social and cultural systems, without interference in any form by another State.’58 Martti Koskenniemi describes the Declaration as a declaration of liberalism writ large: It constructs international order from (private) State ends; it guarantees each State the right to choose its valuesystem and to pursue its own ideas of the good to the extent that no harm is caused to other States.59
Where democracy is understood in terms of a sovereign political community ‘legislating’ for itself, the solution to the problem for democracy created by international law is provided by a rejection of the authority of international law norms that have not received the consent of the people (directly, or through their representatives). The argument is made by conservative nationalists in the United States, largely writing from the perspective of American constitutional law. The principal issue is the extent to which US law should recognise the authority of international law norms. Consider for example the arguments of Ernest Young, that law in the United States is made through ‘an intricate, carefully balanced process that is deliberately designed to be difficult to navigate’; actors are accountable ‘to each other and to the American people’.60 In contrast, law-making in the international community lies outside of any system of checks and balances and accountability, and ‘it risks undermining [the] Constitution’s institutional strategy’.61 Any recognition of international law norms by domestic institutions (in the absence of adoption or affirmation by domestic legislatures) undermines both democracy and the idea of sovereignty, which in the United States is ‘intimately bound up with the basically procedural nature of our constitutional commitments. The American people expect that certain decisions affecting them will be made through specified constitutional processes by people who are accountable to them.’62
choice of a political, economic, social and cultural system, and the formulation of foreign policy. Intervention is wrongful when it uses methods of coercion in regard to such choices, which must remain free ones’: Military and paramilitary activities in and against Nicaragua (Nicaragua v United States) Merits [1986] ICJ Rep 14 at [205]. 58 General Assembly (GA) Res 2625 (XXV), ‘Declaration on Principles of International Law Concerning Friendly Relations (adopted 24 October 1970). See also Principle VI, Helsinki Final Accord, Conference on Security and Co-Operation in Europe: Final Act [1 August 1975]: ‘The participating States will refrain from any intervention, direct or indirect, individual or collective, in the internal or external affairs falling within the domestic jurisdiction of another participating State, regardless of their mutual relations.’ 59 Martti Koskenniemi, From Apology to Utopia: the Structure of International Legal Argument (Cambridge, Cambridge University Press, 2005) 93. 60 Ernest Young, ‘The Trouble with Global Constitutionalism’ (2003) 38 Texas International Law Journal 527, 528. 61 ibid at 529. 62 ibid at 542.
Columns Design Ltd
/
Job: Wheatley
/
Division: 01_Thearguments
/Pg. Position: 14 /
Date: 26/3
JOBNAME: Wheatley PAGE: 15 SESS: 4 OUTPUT: Tue May 11 14:32:06 2010
36 The Democratic Deficit in Global Governance Reflecting arguments articulated by HLA Hart,63 Jeremy Rabkin complains that there is ‘no international legislature to declare or elaborate international legal standards[,] [and] no reliable means of interpreting or enforcing most standards that do exist’.64 In addition to the problems of indeterminacy and bindingess, Rabkin criticises assertions that domestic law and international law have equal authority and importance. If that were the case, ‘it would be impossible to know what law to apply in the event of a conflict between U.S. law and international law’; it is not, and the US Supreme Court ‘has repeatedly insisted that American law takes priority’.65 Prominent ‘New Sovereigntists’ include Rabkin,66 John Bolton,67 John Yoo,68 Curtis Bradley,69 and Jack Goldsmith.70 Peter Spiro, who coined the expression, observes that the focus of the writings is the ‘edifice of sovereignty’, which demands that America resists the incorporation of international norms ‘and drapes the power to do so in the mantle of constitutional legitimacy’.71 New Sovereigntists, he argues, deliver three ‘flawed lines of attack’: emerging international law norms are vague and ‘illegitimately intrusive’ in domestic affairs; international law-making processes are unaccountable, and international law norms are (ultimately) unenforceable; and the United States has the right to ‘opt out of international regimes as a matter of power, legal right, and constitutional duty’.72 The consequences of the application of New Sovereigntist thinking to international law can be seen in the rational choice analysis developed by Goldsmith and Posner, which seeks to explain international law in terms of ‘states acting rationally to maximise their interests, given their perceptions of the interests of others states and the distribution of state
63 Hart’s concept of law is expressly statist: the distinctive nature of law entails institutionalised norm enforcement. Doubts about the status of international law (as ‘law’) ‘arise from an adverse comparison of international law and municipal law’. See HLA Hart, The Concept of Law, 2nd edn (Oxford, Clarendon Press, 1994) 216. 64 Jeremy Rabkin, ‘American Self-defense Shouldn’t be too Distracted by International Law’ (2006) 30 Harvard Journal of Law and Public Policy 31, 34. 65 ibid at 57. 66 Jeremy Rabkin, Law Without Nations? Why Constitutional Government Requires Sovereign States (Princeton, New Jersey, Princeton University Press, 2005). 67 John Bolton, ‘Should We Take Global Governance Seriously?’ (2000) 1 Chicago Journal of International Law 205. 68 John Yoo, ‘UN Wars, US War Powers’ (2000) 1 Chicago Journal of International Law 355. 69 Curtis Bradley, ‘International Delegations, the Structural Constitution, and Non-selfexecution’ (2003) 55 Stanford Law Review 1557. 70 Curtis Bradley and Jack Goldsmith, ‘Federal Courts and the Incorporation of International Law’ (1998) 111 Harvard Law Review 2260. 71 Peter Spiro, ‘The New Sovereigntists: American Exceptionalism and Its False Prophets’ (2000) 79 Foreign Affairs 9, 9. 72 ibid at 10.
Columns Design Ltd
/
Job: Wheatley
/
Division: 01_Thearguments
/Pg. Position: 15 /
Date: 26/3
JOBNAME: Wheatley PAGE: 16 SESS: 4 OUTPUT: Tue May 11 14:32:06 2010
The Democratisation of Global Governance
37
power’.73 Inter-state activity is explained in terms of four possible patterns of behaviour: coincidence of interest, whereby each state acts in its own best interests without regard to the interests of the other state (the argument is framed in terms of bilateral inter-state relations); coordination, whereby states receive higher payoffs if they engage in identical or symmetrical actions than if they do not; cooperation, whereby states mutually refrain from activities that would otherwise be in their selfinterests in order to obtain greater medium- to longer-term advantage; and coercion, which results when a powerful state forces a weaker state to engage in acts contrary to its own interests.74 The usual argument, that international law constrains the selfinterested behaviour of states, is mistaken: ‘It is not a check on state self-interest; it is a product of state self-interest.’75 Customary international law emerges as a result of states seeking to maximise their interests through coincidence of interest, coercion, bilateral repeated prisoner’s dilemma, and bilateral coordination.76 The basic logic of international agreements (ie treaties) ‘follows directly from the models of cooperation and coordination’.77 In cases of coincidence of interest there is no requirement for an international agreement, and in cases of coercion states are unlikely to formalise a subservient relationship. The logic of bilateral cooperation can be extended to any number of agents, but relationships in the international community of states remain essentially bilateral in nature. The establishment of an international organisation by multilateral treaty can clarify the terms of cooperation and enhance monitoring, but ‘punishment still depends on state action and is subject to free-riding and related collective action difficulties’.78 The argument applies equally in the case of the international human rights system which consists of powerful states enforcing interests, including altruistic interests to be sure, and weak states yielding when sufficient pressure is brought to bear against them. The relationships are bilateral, and the degree of enforcement depends on the bargaining positions of the two states in each relationship.
Most human rights practices can be explained by coercion or coincidence of interest, for example, in not engaging in acts of genocide.79
73 Jack Goldsmith and Eric Posner, The Limits of International Law (Oxford, Oxford University Press, 2005) 3. 74 ibid at 12. 75 ibid at 13. 76 ibid at 42. 77 ibid at 84. 78 ibid at 87. 79 ibid at 134.
Columns Design Ltd
/
Job: Wheatley
/
Division: 01_Thearguments
/Pg. Position: 16 /
Date: 26/3
JOBNAME: Wheatley PAGE: 17 SESS: 4 OUTPUT: Tue May 11 14:32:06 2010
38 The Democratic Deficit in Global Governance Goldsmith and Posner provide three reasons why states might (rationally) choose to incur international law obligations. First, the use of the treaty mechanism imports accepted international norms and principles for the interpretation of inter-state agreements, reflected in the Vienna Convention on the Law of Treaties. Second, in most states, the constitution requires that treaties are approved by domestic legislatures. Where a treaty is affirmed by the legislature, it transforms an agreement between governments into one accepted by the representatives of the people. The involvement of the legislative body makes public the commitment of the democratic state to the treaty regime.80 Legislative adoption also commits the state to the international law position to a much greater extent than mere executive agreement, requiring a change of domestic laws for any subsequent change of policy. Legislative approval sends a clear signal of the commitment of the executive branch to the policy, making clear that the state is a serious international partner on the issue.81 Third, the use of treaties implies a deeper commitment than non-binding and non-legal instruments; it is the same distinction that can be made in domestic law between a contract and a non-binding agreement.82 The analysis explains international law in terms of the rational interests of states and concludes that states have no moral obligation to comply with international law norms.83 Any preference for compliance must be weighed alongside other preferences; it will depend on what costs leaders and citizens are willing to incur and what they are willing to forgo. The determination as to whether a state will comply with an international law norm must be made on a case-by-case basis, depending on how political leaders judge the balance of interests for the state in complying on the one hand and other benefits that might accrue from norm-violating behaviour on the other. One of the factors to be weighed is the popular will of the people, who in a democracy ultimately determine policy. The analysis suggests that international law norms should be subject to the democratic will of the people (at least the people of the United States). It is an American perspective on the problems that arise from the globalisation of governance functions, reflecting the different ways in which Americans (and many American academics) view international law. Jed Rubenfeld explains that the modern system of international law, developed in the wake of World War II to be made and interpreted by international actors operating above popular democratic
80 81 82 83
ibid ibid ibid ibid
Columns Design Ltd
at at at at
92. 93. 98. 185.
/
Job: Wheatley
/
Division: 01_Thearguments
/Pg. Position: 17 /
Date: 26/3
JOBNAME: Wheatley PAGE: 18 SESS: 4 OUTPUT: Tue May 11 14:32:06 2010
The Democratisation of Global Governance
39
politics, was designed to be ‘antidemocratic’.84 It was a response to the ‘European’ problems of military conflict and political extremism that democratic politics had unleashed. Given that America (so it told itself) had not suffered such problems, the resulting international law system did not apply to the United States. The position regards international law as a mechanism for promoting universal values and constraining democratic self-government elsewhere.85 New Sovereigntists accept limitations on the democratic will of the here-and-now people of the United States only to the extent that the limitation is provided for in the US Constitution: political selfdetermination in the context of constitutional democracy. The position can be contrasted with that in Europe, where both academics and citizens appear more willing to accept supra-national limits on the possibilities of democratic self-determination. The difference is explored by Rubenfeld, who identifies two forms of constitutionalism. The first, ‘European constitutionalism’, regards constitutional rights as universal rights that individuals possess by virtue of their co-membership of the human species. These universal constitutional rights reside in a higher normative domain than politics and displace any conflicting outcomes of political decision-making. It makes no difference whether constitutional rights are recognised and enforced at the domestic, regional or international level, and there is no reason to conclude that international courts and tribunals are not competent to determine the content and application of universal norms.86 International law norms bind future majorities in the same way as constitutional law norms, displacing conflicting outcomes of democratic procedures. Any argument that there is a democratic deficit in international (human rights) law is ‘misguided or simply obtuse’, as ‘the very point of constitutional law is to enforce counter-majoritarian rights and thus to check democracy’.87 The second form of constitutionalism is a form of democratic constitutionalism. The argument here is that the Constitution does not lie outside of democratic politics, it is the product of democratic politics. It is for the people to decide for themselves ‘on the enduring legal and political
84 Jed Rubenfeld, ‘Unilateralism and Constitutionalism’ 2004) 79 New York University Law Review 1971, 2017. 85 ibid at 1989. See also Michael Ignatieff, ‘Introduction’ in Michael Ignatieff (ed), American Exceptionalism and Human Rights (Princeton, New Jersey, Princeton University Press, 2005). Ignatieff distinguishes a number of ways in which American exceptionalism manifests itself in relation to human rights: the United States signs international human rights and humanitarian treaties, but then exempts itself through reservation, nonratification, or non-compliance; the United States maintains a double-standard, judging itself (and its allies) by more permissive standards than others; the United States rejects the application of international human rights within its own domestic laws (at 3). 86 ibid at 1992. 87 ibid at 2003 (references omitted).
Columns Design Ltd
/
Job: Wheatley
/
Division: 01_Thearguments
/Pg. Position: 18 /
Date: 26/3
JOBNAME: Wheatley PAGE: 19 SESS: 4 OUTPUT: Tue May 11 14:32:06 2010
40 The Democratic Deficit in Global Governance commitments that will govern the polity in the future’.88 These include the nature and content of those fundamental rights that will displace majority decisions. On this understanding, counter-majoritarian rights are not counter-democratic because they represent ‘the nation’s selfgiven law, enacted through a special, democratic, constitutional politics, subject to democratic amendment processes in the future’. The American conception of the Constitution is strongly of the democratic constitutionalism model;89 the opposite is the case in Europe, where the ‘new European constitutionalism’ is grounded in the ideology of universal (or international) human rights norms, which possess ‘a supranational and almost supraconstitutional character, making them close to unamendable and rendering them peculiarly fit for interpretation by international juridical experts’.90 In some ways the position of the New Sovereigntists can be dismissed as a realist and nationalistic argument that seeks to have the evident military and economic power of the United States reflected in the system of global governance,91 at least as interpreted by domestic courts in the United States.92 There is though some veracity in the critique: from the perspective of a functioning democratic system, international law norms appear to be a poor substitute for domestic laws agreed through complex procedures of democratic will-formation. Prima facie, the good democrat should prefer domestic democratic laws to (undemocratic) international law norms produced by unelected and largely unaccountable international institutions. McGinnis and Somin refer to the ‘low quality’ of the political processes that generate international law norms, which provides a strong argument against the recognition of international law as part of domestic law, unless expressly incorporated by a democratic institution.93 The argument is comparative: international laws are less likely to
88
ibid at 1993. ibid at 1994. ibid at 1997. 91 Sabrina Safrin argues that exceptionalism should be understood as the ability to attain a special or different legal norm: ‘U.S. exceptionalism often flows from its perceived military needs and unique global security responsibilities[;] European exceptionalism grows out of Europe’s unique status as a quasi-state or quasi-multi-state negotiating bloc[;] [whilst] [d]eveloping country exceptionalism flows from developing countries’ special economic needs’: Sabrina Safrin, ‘The Un-exceptionalism of U.S. Exceptionalism’ (2008) 41 Vanderbilt Journal of Transnational Law 1307, 1314. 92 cf Gerry Simpson, Great Powers and Outlaw States: Unequal Sovereigns in the International Legal Order (Cambridge, Cambridge University Press, 2003). 93 John McGinnis and Ilya Somin, ‘Should International Law be Part of our Law?’ (2007) 59 Stanford Law Review 1175, 1178. 89 90
Columns Design Ltd
/
Job: Wheatley
/
Division: 01_Thearguments
/Pg. Position: 19 /
Date: 26/3
JOBNAME: Wheatley PAGE: 20 SESS: 4 OUTPUT: Tue May 11 14:32:06 2010
The Democratisation of Global Governance
41
be of ‘sound quality’ than those created by advanced democracies, such as the United States;94 it does not apply in relation to authoritarian states and transitional democracies.95 To the extent that that it can be generalised,96 the New Sovereigntist argument suggests that, in the absence of a clear expression of (sovereign) consent, international law obligations should not be imposed on democratic states, although of course there remains the possibility that global law norms might be more democratic than domestic law norms.97 The difficulty with the analysis is the failure to recognise the existence of collective action and coordination problems, such as threats to the global environment and from international terrorism, and problems created by the workings of the international financial system that cannot be resolved by states acting alone. Globalisation has resulted in a loss for democracy, as citizens find that decisions and actions taken outside of the boundaries of the state impact on them.98 The argument applies equally to the United States.99 Keohane, Macedo and Moravcsik observe that the ‘pooling of sovereignty’ allows democratic states to achieve policy goals together that none could realise by acting alone, in areas such as global warming, liberalising the international economy, combating terrorism and regulating multi-national corporations. The development of global governance mechanisms and consequential reduction in the freedom of action of individual states is a practical response to the problems associated with globalisation, affording citizens an opportunity to exercise some authority or control over actors outside of the territorial jurisdiction. The choice is not between global governance and domestic government, but between ‘the complementary activities of international and domestic institutions, on the one hand, and uncoordinated state action, on the other’.100 The refusal of states to delegate some authority to multilateral institutions represents ‘a self-defeating and arbitrary restriction on national democratic deliberation’.101 The rejectionist position implies that
94
ibid at 1198. ibid at 1199. 96 The fact that the argument is ‘exceptionalist’ would suggest that it cannot be generalised, but see Michael Kirby, ‘Transnational Judicial Dialogue, Internationalisation of Law and Australian Judges’ (2008) 9 Melbourne Journal of International Law 171 (on Australian exceptionalism). 97 Michael Barr and Geoffrey Miller, ‘Global Administrative Law: the View from Basel’ (2006) 17 European Journal of International Law 15, 43. 98 Further, in a globalised economy, there are good arguments for the standardisation of technical specifications, and there remains a (cosmopolitan) sense that the most serious forms of human rights abuse should be the concern of the international community. 99 Anne-Marie Slaughter, ‘Leading Through Law’ (2003) 27 The Wilson Quarterly 37, 37. 100 Robert Keohane, Stephen Macedo and Andrew Moravcsik, ‘Democracy Enhancing Multilateralism’ (2009) 63 International Organization 1, 23. 101 ibid at 4. See also Robert Howse, ‘The End of the Globalization Debate: a Review Essay’ (2008) 121 Harvard Law Review 1528, 1533. 95
Columns Design Ltd
/
Job: Wheatley
/
Division: 01_Thearguments
/Pg. Position: 20 /
Date: 26/3
JOBNAME: Wheatley PAGE: 21 SESS: 4 OUTPUT: Tue May 11 14:32:06 2010
42 The Democratic Deficit in Global Governance societies have nothing to learn from each other (a conclusion at variance with the experiences of human history), and that there is nothing that can be done about trans-border and global problems and nothing to be gained from some pooling of sovereignty and (partial) loss of democratic control. This is evidently not the case. The recognition of collective action and coordination problems provides the context and justification for globalised governance, but does not tell us which issues should be dealt with at the global level and which at the domestic level. Robert Jackson observes that contemporary debates around sovereignty concern this allocation of ‘government decisionmaking power’,102 with complaints around restrictions on sovereignty reflecting disagreements as to the appropriate level for the allocation of decision-making authority.103 Most solutions rely directly or in modified form on the principle of subsidiarity, developed in the context of the European Union.104 Subsidiarity requires that the exercise of political authority be undertaken as close to the people as possible, consistent with the principle of achieving effective outcomes. The introduction of international law norms is justified following the recognition of a collective action or coordination problem, and where the advantages of relying on international law ‘override any disadvantages connected to the preemption of more decentralized rule-making’. The exception, according to Mattias Kumm, is the protection of minimum human rights standards, although, along with other writers, he fails to explain the rationale for the exception.105 Whilst it is common in the literature to include the protection of human rights as a necessary concern of the international community, the reason for this is not satisfactorily explained, given that, in most cases, human rights abuses in one state do not impact on the citizens of other states, ie human rights abuses do not require a practical (as opposed to a moral) collective action response.
102 John Jackson, ‘Sovereignty-modern: a New Approach to an Outdated Concept’ (2003) 97 American Journal of International Law 782, 790. See also Dan Sarooshi, International Organizations and their Exercise of Sovereign Powers (Oxford, Oxford University Press, 2005) 29. 103 Robert Jackson, ‘Quasi-States, Dual Regimes, and Neoclassical Theory: International Jurisprudence and the Third World’ (1987) 41 International Organization 519, 519. 104 See Consolidated versions of the Treaty on European Union and the Treaty on the Functioning of the European Union [2008] OJ C115/01: art 5 (1) The use of Union competences is governed by the principles of subsidiarity and proportionality… (3) Under the principle of subsidiarity, in areas which do not fall within its exclusive competence, the Union shall act only if and in so far as the objectives of the proposed action cannot be sufficiently achieved by the Member States, either at central level or at regional and local level, but can rather, by reason of the scale or effects of the proposed action, be better achieved at Union level. 105 Mattias Kumm, ‘The Legitimacy of International Law: a Constitutionalist Framework of Analysis’ (2004) 15 European Journal of International Law 907, 921.
Columns Design Ltd
/
Job: Wheatley
/
Division: 01_Thearguments
/Pg. Position: 21 /
Date: 26/3
JOBNAME: Wheatley PAGE: 22 SESS: 4 OUTPUT: Tue May 11 14:32:06 2010
The Democratisation of Global Governance
43
Subsidiary is a ‘power allocation principle’, requiring that ‘the entity that can best achieve a task be in charge of it’. It does not, as Samantha Besson observes, necessarily require that the institution is democratic.106 Subsidiary is a practical tool, framing debates about the allocation of decision-making authority, and a philosophical position.107 The re-allocation of political authority from the state to international institutions without sufficient justification constitutes a loss of sovereignty, and in democratic states, a loss for democracy: the idea of subsidiarity reinforces the principle that ‘the vast majority of governance tasks should still be taken by national government officials’.108
A Global Democratic State Thomas Zweifel argues that in order to apply the idea of democracy at the global level ‘we need to think – in theory at least – of a global polity and a global population. An international state allows us to make that leap.’109 According to Campbell Craig, the idea of world government ‘is returning to the mainstream of scholarly thinking about international relations’, although reference is made only to an article by Alexander Wendt and a book by Daniel Deudney.110 Wendt’s argument is that a world state is inevitable in the next 100–200 years: with the transfer of state sovereignty to the global level, ‘individual recognition will no longer be mediated by state boundaries, even though as recognized subjects themselves states would retain some individuality’.111 Deudney’s conclusion is that a hierarchical world government is unlikely, as states will not surrender possession of nuclear weapons to a world authority. (He also notes the difficulty of conquering and controlling
106 Samantha Besson, ‘Sovereignty in Conflict’ (2004) 8 European integration online Papers (EIoP) 3.2.2.1. 107 Anne-Marie Slaughter refers to a foundational principle of legitimate difference in trans-governmental cooperation, reflecting a view that ‘a desirable diversity of ideas about how to order an economy or society’ is both good and appropriate in informing the nature of global governance: Anne-Marie Slaughter, ‘Disaggregated Sovereignty: Towards the Public Accountability of Global Government Networks’ (2004) 39 Government and Opposition 159, 178. 108 ibid at 185. 109 Thomas Zweifel, International Organizations and Democracy: Accountability, Politics and Power (Boulder, Colorado, Lynne Boulder, 2006) 13. 110 Campbell Craig, ‘The Resurgent Idea of World Government’ (2008) Ethics and International Affairs. Available at www.cceia.org/resources/journal/22_2/essay/001.html (last visited 27 July 2009). 111 Alexander Wendt, ‘Why a World State is Inevitable’ (2003) 9 European Journal of International Relations 491, 525.
Columns Design Ltd
/
Job: Wheatley
/
Division: 01_Thearguments
/Pg. Position: 22 /
Date: 26/3
JOBNAME: Wheatley PAGE: 23 SESS: 4 OUTPUT: Tue May 11 14:32:06 2010
44 The Democratic Deficit in Global Governance occupied territories.) Instead, a ‘federal-republican image of world government’ looks more likely to emerge,112 building on the existing structures of the UN,113 but requiring also a ‘global constitutional conversation about first principles’. The result would be a ‘world Constitution based on purely negarchical principles’, with the primary purpose to avoid ‘world hierarchy as well as world anarchy’.114 Catherine Lu provides a more extensive review in the entry on world government in the Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy.115 World government is defined as ‘the idea of all humankind united under one common political authority’. It can be traced back to ancient Chinese, Indian, Greek and Roman thought. In Medieval times, Dante articulated the Christian ideal of human unity and its expression through a world governed by a universal monarch (Convivio (The Banquet) (c1304) and Monarchia (1309–13)). The idea lost its appeal with the development of the idea of the sovereign state following the Peace of Westphalia (1648). In the eighteenth century, the dominant political thinkers, Immanuel Kant (Perpetual Peace (1795)) and Jean-Jacques Rousseau (The Social Contract (1762)), rejected the need for, or possibility of, world government, and the idea does not re-emerge until after World War II and the use of atomic weapons on Hiroshima and Nagasaki, which led Albert Einstein to argue that peace required a world government ‘able to solve conflicts between nations by judicial decision. This government must be based on a clear-cut constitution which is approved by the governments and nations and which gives it the sole disposition of offensive weapons’. The Cold War prevented any serious debate on the issue. Lu’s review makes clear that no serious or systematic attempt has been made in contemporary political thought, at least in the English language, to articulate a vision of world government (the only references are again to Wendt and Deudney). William Scheuerman concludes that ‘no serious thinker today is advocating a single global Leviathan’.116 The literature is dominated by critics of the idea, who point to the facts that world government is not achievable (the argument is an exercise in ‘utopian thinking’); that it
112 Daniel Deudney, Bounding Power: Republican Security Theory from the Polis to the Global Village (Princeton, New Jersey, Princeton University Press, 2007) 262. 113 ibid at 263. 114 ibid at 264. 115 Catherine Lu, ‘World Government’ in Edward Zalta (ed), The Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy (Winter 2006 edn), available at plato.stanford.edu/entries/world-government/ (last visited 16 June 2009). 116 William Scheuerman, ‘Global Governance without Global Government? Habermas on Postnational Democracy Political Theory’ (2008) 36 Political Theory 133, 148.
Columns Design Ltd
/
Job: Wheatley
/
Division: 01_Thearguments
/Pg. Position: 23 /
Date: 26/3
JOBNAME: Wheatley PAGE: 24 SESS: 4 OUTPUT: Tue May 11 14:32:06 2010
The Democratisation of Global Governance
45
would be undesirable, as it would ‘descend into a global tyranny’;117 and it is neither necessary nor sufficient to achieve the aims of the promotion of human rights and establishment of democratic government. Even if the need for world government were accepted and concerns that the concentration of power would lead to a global tyranny overcome,118 it is difficult to envisage a mechanism by which an effective world government could come into existence, particularly given the opposition of powerful democracies. There are also the practical objections as to how a global democracy of some six billion persons would operate, given the significant economic and cultural differences in world society that would make it difficult to reach a common position on many issues of policy.119 There would be significant questions of legitimacy and stability if the practice of global democracy were to result in large numbers of unsatisfied preferences and creation of persistent minorities, groups whose preferences can never be realised through democratic politics – Thomas Christiano observes that ‘[t]he larger the constituency, the larger the chances are that particular minorities would simply get lost in the democratic decision making’.120 That is not to conclude that the practice of democracy on a global scale could not be effective, only that the theory and practice of democracy suggests that the unit of political selfdetermination should be as small as possible, consistent with the requirement of including all those affected in political debates. Kal Raustiala makes the opposite point, observing that up until the eighteenth century the dominant view in Western political theory was that ‘small was beautiful’, but that in the Federalist Papers, James Madison reasoned that large size was in fact a saving grace: ‘Madison saw the primary threat to democracy in faction, or the power of special interests’. In the case of a large-scale republic, there would necessarily be a greater variety of 117 See, for example, Kofi Anan, We the Peoples: the Role of the United Nations in the 21st Century (New York, United Nations, 2000) 7: Nothing would be less desirable than the idea of ‘world government, of centralized bureaucratic behemoths trampling on the rights of people and states.’ 118 See, for example, Daniel Weinstock, ‘The Real World of (Global) Democracy’ (2006) 37 Journal of Social Philosophy 6, 16; see also Thomas Christiano, ‘A Democratic Theory of Territory and Some Puzzles about Global Democracy’ (2006) 37 Journal of Social Philosophy 81, 102. John Rawls concludes that a world government would be undesirable as it would involve either ‘a global despotism or else would rule over a fragile empire torn by frequent civil strife as various regions and peoples tried to gain their political freedom and autonomy’: John Rawls, The Law of Peoples (Cambridge, Massachusetts, Harvard University Press, 1999) 36. 119 There is general agreement that social, economic and ethno-cultural differences make the practice of democracy more difficult, given the problem in identifying common interests: Robert Dahl, ‘Can International Organizations be Democratic? A Skeptic’s View’ in Ian Shapiro and Casiano Hacker-Cordon (eds), Democracy’s Edges (Cambridge, Cambridge University Press, 1999) 19, 26. 120 Thomas Christiano, ‘A Democratic Theory of Territory and Some Puzzles about Global Democracy’ (2006) 37 Journal of Social Philosophy 81, 103.
Columns Design Ltd
/
Job: Wheatley
/
Division: 01_Thearguments
/Pg. Position: 24 /
Date: 26/3
JOBNAME: Wheatley PAGE: 25 SESS: 4 OUTPUT: Tue May 11 14:32:06 2010
46 The Democratic Deficit in Global Governance interests and parties: ‘Greater diversity made domination by faction less likely’.121 Mutatis mutandis, the development of a global democracy would avoid the possibility of the capture of global regulation by any single faction or special interest in world politics. The establishment of a global democratic state would inhibit the effectiveness of political participation by individual citizens as an individual voice or vote would have limited impact and it is not clear how the citizen could be meaningfully represented in a global parliament. The largest democratic states are India, with a population of 1.1 billion, represented by 552 members of the Lok Sadha (House of the People), and the United States, population 300 million, with 435 members of the House of Representatives. The Parliament of the European Union has 785 members, representing 492 million people. An assembly comprising 500 representatives in a global parliament would require that each member represent some 13 million individuals — the population of Malawi. Two-thirds of states have populations of fewer than 13 million, leading to questions as to how to draw constituency boundaries, assuming the use of constituencies in the global electoral system, and whether such boundaries would reflect the populations of states (and then for what gain). Daniel Weinstock argues that there is no reason to conclude that already represented territorially based units, including, but not restricted to states, would automatically be represented. The practice of global democracy might be ‘deterritorialised’, with constituencies emerging that cross existing state boundaries (giving the example of the Kurds) or that have no territorial connection – ‘communities of [shared] concern’.122 It is inconceivable that a domestic society might undergo a process of ‘democratisation’ without the establishment of a directly elected legislative assembly. Yet no serious writer argues for the introduction of a directly elected world parliament as a necessary component in the democratisation of world society. The focus of the literature is on the likely difficulties in the practice of democracy at the global level and the dangers for individual freedom in the establishment of a global Leviathan from which there could be no escape. Perhaps the reason for this is that the idea of a directly elected global parliament makes no sense in terms of the existing practices of global governance in which regulatory authority is exercised at different levels (global, regional and state) and in relation to different sectors. International law consists of a system of general and customary international law, and fragmented regimes concerning, for example, world trade, the environment, human rights, the
121 Kal Raustiala, ‘Rethinking the Sovereignty Debate in International Economic Law’ (2003) 6 Journal of International Economic Law 841, 854. 122 Weinstock (n 118) at 16.
Columns Design Ltd
/
Job: Wheatley
/
Division: 01_Thearguments
/Pg. Position: 25 /
Date: 26/3
JOBNAME: Wheatley PAGE: 26 SESS: 5 OUTPUT: Tue May 11 14:32:06 2010
The Democratisation of Global Governance
47
law of the sea, diplomacy, etc.123 In the absence of agreement on a new international constitution, the democratisation of international law cannot proceed through the establishment of a world legislative assembly: there is no coherent system of world law to which the parliamentary principle of democracy can be applied. (This is in contrast to the state where the introduction of a parliamentary assembly legitimates the exercise of power in a taken-for-granted political community defined by the exercise political authority.) Any analysis of the global democratic deficit must reflect and accommodate the realities of the fragmented nature of global regulation and global politics. Whilst some refer to the emergence of a nascent ‘global polity’,124 world society is fragmented into multiple sites for global law production and the conduct of global politics, each with its own focus and concern. In the absence of a unified international law order, with associated institutions of governance and politics, it makes no sense to focus on the state model in arguments around democracy beyond the state.
A Global Democratic Federation The principal objection to the idea of a global state is the continuing relevance of the territorial state in the theory and practice of democracy. One possibility is to imagine a global law order above the existing systems of sovereign states, focused on the UN, and re-conceive the structure as a global federation. The principle of democracy would apply at each level, with an international community of democratic states supplemented by a higher level of global governance whose powers and authority would be clearly demarked in the constitutive instrument of the global federation.125 This would be a ‘thin’ form of global federation, 123 cf United States Diplomatic and Consular Staff in Tehran (United States of America v Iran) [1980] ICJ Rep 3 [86]: ‘The rules of diplomatic law, in short, constitute a self-contained régime.’ 124 Brassett and Higgot argue that three elements underwrite the claim for recognising the emergence of a nascent global polity: political interconnectedness in the international system; the vast and interlocking network of global regulation by both international organisations and non-state actors; and the growing sense of ‘community’ that appears to be developing beyond the confines of the state, which importantly includes political contestation about the nature of globalisation: James Brassett and Richard Higgot, ‘Building the Normative Dimension(s) of a Global Polity (2003) 29 Supplement 1, Review of International Studies 29, 34. 125 cf Jürgen Habermas, ‘Does the Constitutionalization of International Law Still Have a Chance?’ in The Divided West, edited and translated by Ciaran Cronin (Cambridge, Polity, 2006) 115, 128: ‘in a federal multilevel system nothing prevents the fictive unity of the presumptive popular sovereignty from being conceived as compatible with the corresponding chains of legitimacy that unfold in parallel with each of the various member states’.
Columns Design Ltd
/
Job: Wheatley
/
Division: 01_Thearguments
/Pg. Position: 26 /
Date: 26/3
JOBNAME: Wheatley PAGE: 27 SESS: 3 OUTPUT: Tue May 11 14:32:06 2010
48 The Democratic Deficit in Global Governance with no requirement that citizens legitimate the global federation through an expression of consent for its exercise of political authority, or regard themselves as co-members of a global political community. The position is distinguished from that of a ‘thick’ federal system, which requires both an overarching structure of government and a ‘genuine “social substratum,” that is, a citizenry that provides that organization with original (as opposed to derived) legitimacy’.126 In a federal system (according to political theory), both the federal and state governments ‘exercise original, not derivative, public authority, and they are sovereign within their own sphere, i.e. the sphere in which each of them is competent to exercise public authority pursuant to the rules of the federal constitution (dual sovereignty)’.127 An initial difficulty is (again) the nature of the existing global system of law, which is not structured like some world federation. There are no existing global government structures to which the principle of democracy can be applied. Notwithstanding references to the contrary, the General Assembly is not a global legislature or ‘world parliament’;128 the Security Council is not a ‘world Government’,129 or ‘World Executive’;130 and the UN is not a world government.131 The federal model suggests a neat, organised system of governance institutions proceeding from the local to the global.132 However, the international system is not constructed like some matryoshka doll, progressing from national, to regional, to global
126 Armin von Bogdandy, ‘Constitutionalism in International Law: Comment on a Proposal from Germany’ (2006) 47 Harvard International Law Journal 223, 233. von Bogdandy concludes that most recent publications on international law that envisage a world federation ‘devote little space to the democratic principle’: Armin von Bogdandy, ‘Globalization and Europe: How to Square Democracy, Globalization, and International Law’ (2004) 15 European Journal of International Law 885, 900. 127 Thomas Giegerich, ‘The Is and the Ought of International Constitutionalism: How Far Have We Come on Habermas’s Road to a “Well-Considered Constitutionalization of International Law′?’(2009) 10(1) German Law Journal 31, 46. 128 cf Bruno Simma, ‘From Bilateralism to Community Interest in International Law’ (1994) 250 Recueil de cours 217, 262. 129 ibid at 264. 130 cf Pierre-Marie Dupuy, ‘The Constitutional Dimension of the Charter of the United Nations Revisited’ (1997) 1 Max Plank Yearbook of United Nations Law 1, 32. 131 The International Criminal Tribunal for the former Yugoslavia noted that it is ‘clearly impossible’ to classify the organs of the UN in relation to the institutions of domestic government. There is ‘no legislature, in the technical sense of the term, in the United Nations system and, more generally, no Parliament in the world community. That is to say, there exists no corporate organ formally empowered to enact laws directly binding on international legal subjects’: Prosecutor v Dusko Tadic Case No IT-94–1-AR72 (1996) 35 ILM 32 [43]. 132 Georges Scelle refers to the ‘federal phenomenon’ in international law, a process leading from the individual state to larger normative units gradually and in successive stages as a result of expanding circles of ‘solidarity’: Georges Scelle, Cours de Droit International Public (Paris, Domat-Montchrestien, 1948) 253, referred to in Martti Koskenniemi, ‘Fragmentation of International Law: Difficulties Arising from the Diversification
Columns Design Ltd
/
Job: Wheatley
/
Division: 01_Thearguments
/Pg. Position: 27 /
Date: 26/2
JOBNAME: Wheatley PAGE: 28 SESS: 4 OUTPUT: Tue May 11 14:32:06 2010
The Democratisation of Global Governance
49
government. The real world of global regulation is messy and fragmented, without clearly defined jurisdictional boundaries. There is no overarching constitutional framework or organising meta-principle (following the decline of the idea of ‘sovereignty’). It is not possible to imagine a global democratic federation by democratising the United Nations and requiring that all states are democratic. Jürgen Habermas highlights a more philosophical problem in reading the global system as a democratic federation in that it is difficult to accept any analogy that associates the process of global state-formation with the (mythologised) process of state formation at the domestic level. Having previously written about a shift from international law, where the state preserves its supreme constitutional authority, to cosmopolitan law, which must be binding on state governments in accordance with some legal code or ‘constitution’,133 Habermas returns to the issue in his 2006 essay, ‘Does the Constitutionalization of International Law Still Have a Chance?’ Observing the emergence of global regulatory networks and the loss of political autonomy for states, he concludes that the federal analogy is not appropriate to describe the systems of global governance. At the domestic level, the atom of (popular) sovereignty may split, with a federal constitution establishing ‘corresponding chains of legitimation that unfold in parallel with each of the various member states’.134 The analogy does not apply at the global level. In contrast to constitutionmaking within states, individuals already enjoy a status as citizen that guarantees certain rights and freedoms — they have ‘already undergone a long political process of political formation and socialization’.135 The transformation from an international law of states to a cosmopolitan law of individuals cannot be seen simply as the logical evolution of the constitutional state from the national to the global level, given the absence of a supranational power with the capacity to coercively enforce international law norms.136 The constitutionalisation analogy in international law points to ‘an opposite evolutionary direction to that of the and Expansion of International Law, Report of the Study Group of the International Law Commission’, finalised by Martti Koskenniemi, (13 April 2006) UN Doc A/CN.4/L.682 para 207. 133 Jürgen Habermas, The Inclusion of the Other: Studies in Political theory (Cambridge, Massachusetts, MIT Press, 1998) 179. 134 Jürgen Habermas, ‘Does the Constitutionalization of International Law Still Have a Chance?’ in The Divided West (Cambridge: Polity, 2006) 115, 128. 135 ibid at 129. 136 ibid at 132. Elsewhere, Habermas observes that the ‘political empowerment of a pre-political global civil society composed of citizens from different nations is a different matter from imposing a constitution on an existing state power’. He further concludes that it is not appropriate to ignore the legitimacy of the nation-state ‘and to return to an original condition prior to the state’: Jürgen Habermas, ‘The Constitutionalization of International Law and the Legitimation Problems of a Constitution for World Society’ (2008) 15 Constellations 444, 448 (emphasis in original).
Columns Design Ltd
/
Job: Wheatley
/
Division: 01_Thearguments
/Pg. Position: 28 /
Date: 26/3
JOBNAME: Wheatley PAGE: 29 SESS: 4 OUTPUT: Tue May 11 14:32:06 2010
50 The Democratic Deficit in Global Governance genealogy of the constitutional state. It proceeds from the nonhierarchical association of collective actors to the supra- and transnational organizations of the cosmopolitan order.’137 The ‘democratic federal state writ large’, the global state of nations or federal world republic, ‘is the wrong model’. There is no structural analogy between the constitution of a sovereign state, which comes to possess ‘supreme constitutional authority’, and the constitution of a world organisation that would have limited and carefully circumscribed functions: securing international peace and security, and promoting international human rights norms.138
A DEMOCRATIC PEACE
There is a long tradition in political theory, dating back to Immanuel Kant (Perpetual Peace (1795)), which argues that peaceful inter-state relations can only be guaranteed in an international community of democratic states. Writing in 1990, UN Secretary-General Kofi Anan observed that the significant increase in the number of democratic states following the ending of the Cold War had been important for a number of reasons, not least because established democracies, for a variety of reasons, rarely fight each other militarily.139 The ‘democratic peace’ thesis holds that major armed conflicts are unlikely between well-established democratic states.140 Where the decision to engage in military conflict is dependent on the will of the people, ‘war’ will be less likely. Explanations include the fact that when those who decide will bear the costs (in terms of their own lives) the risk of conflict is reduced, and the ability of democratic debate to exposes positions to critical scrutiny, making it more difficult to adopt unsound policies.141 The idea of the democratic peace as the organising principle of world society proceeds from the assumptions that democracy is an international public good, that states 137
ibid at 133. ibid at 134. Kofi Anan, We the Peoples: the Role of the United Nations in the 21st Century (New York, United Nations, 2000) 43. 140 John Norton Moore, ‘Beyond the Democratic Peace: Solving the War Puzzle’ (2004) 44 Virginia Journal of International Law 341, 343. See also Joanne Gowa, Ballots and Bullets: the Elusive Democratic Peace (Princeton New Jersey, Princeton University Press, 1999); AnneMarie Slaughter, ‘International Law in a World of Liberal States’ (1995) 6 European Journal of International Law 503; José E Alvarez, ‘Do Liberal States Behave Better: a Critique of Slaughter’s Liberal Theory’ (2001) 12 European Journal of International Law 183; and Michael Brown et al (eds), Debating the Democratic Peace (Cambridge, Massachusetts, MIT Press, 1996). 141 Slaughter, ibid at fn 13, relying on Charles Kupchan and Clifford Kupchan, ‘Concerts, Collective Security, and the Future of Europe’ (1991) 16 International Security 114. 138 139
Columns Design Ltd
/
Job: Wheatley
/
Division: 01_Thearguments
/Pg. Position: 29 /
Date: 26/3
JOBNAME: Wheatley PAGE: 30 SESS: 4 OUTPUT: Tue May 11 14:32:06 2010
A Democratic Peace
51
are essential for the effective exercise of any right to democratic selfdetermination and that the (democratic) values of tolerance and reasonable pluralism preclude the possibility of governing others, even in their own ‘best interests’. The most significant arguments for a world order based on this model are provided in Kant’s Perpetual Peace, the locus classicus, and John Rawls’ The Law of Peoples. The works support a proposition that the democratisation of world society can be achieved through a commitment to domestic democracy and a global covenant on a (liberal) democratic peace.
Perpetual Peace In his essay Perpetual Peace, Immanuel Kant outlines a draft treaty containing three definitive articles and six preliminary articles. The preliminary articles concern prohibitions on treaties that implicitly allow for future wars; independent states coming under the domination of other states; standing armies; national debt to fund external activities; forcible intervention in the constitution or administration of another state; and ‘dishonourable’ modes of hostility during warfare that would make mutual confidence impossible in any subsequent state of peace.142 The first definitive article provides that the constitution of each state shall be republican.143 A republican constitution is founded in accordance with the principles of the freedom of the members of the society as human beings, the dependence of all subjects on a common legislation, and the equality of all citizens.144 Given that the republican constitution requires the consent of subjects in deciding ‘whether there should be war or not, nothing is more natural than that they should weigh the matter well’.145 The likelihood of war is reduced where those who pay the ultimate cost are involved in the decision-making process. Kant distinguishes a republican constitution from a democratic constitution, in which sovereignty lies with the people.146 Democracy ‘is of necessity despotism’, because the will of the people is, in reality, the will of the majority, allowing for the imposition of majority rule against dissenting individuals. The idea of a ‘universal will’ of the people ‘is in contradiction with itself and with the universal principle of freedom’.147 142 Immanuel Kant, Perpetual Peace: a Philosophical Essay, 1795, trans M Campbell Smith (London, Allen & Unwin, 1903) 107–116. 143 ibid at 120. 144 ibid at 121. 145 ibid at 122. 146 ibid at 124–25. 147 ibid at 125.
Columns Design Ltd
/
Job: Wheatley
/
Division: 01_Thearguments
/Pg. Position: 30 /
Date: 26/3
JOBNAME: Wheatley PAGE: 31 SESS: 4 OUTPUT: Tue May 11 14:32:06 2010
52 The Democratic Deficit in Global Governance Kant is influenced, Mortimer Sellers argues, by a traditional of republicanism that associates legitimacy for the exercise of political authority with service to the ‘common good of the people’, and ‘the best test of the common good of the people is the public deliberation of elected representatives through institutions’.148 Kant himself observes that republicanism ‘is the political principle of severing the executive power of the government from the legislature’.149 Fernando Téson concludes that the republican constitution is what we would call today a liberal democracy, ‘a constitutional democracy, conceived as a participatory political process constrained by respect for rights’.150 The second definitive article provides that the law of nations ‘shall be founded on a federation of free states’.151 The argument is that war results from the fact that inter-state disputes cannot be resolved by courts with compulsory jurisdiction.152 In order for there to be peace, there must be some form of compact or agreement between states, ‘an alliance of a particular kind which we may call a covenant of peace (foedus pacificum) [that] would seek to put an end to war forever’. The alliance would not aim to ‘gain of any power whatsoever of the state, but merely at the preservation and security of the freedom of the state for itself and of other allied states’.153 The analysis proceeds from a recognition of the moral value of the state, which is regarded as a society of human beings ‘whom no one but itself has the right to rule and to dispose’.154 In order 148 Mortimer Sellers, ‘Republican Principles in International Law’ (1996) 11 Connecticut Journal of International Law 403, 405. 149 Kant (n 142) at 125. 150 Fernando Téson, ‘The Kantian Theory of International Law’ (1992) 92 Columbia Law Review 53, 61. Téson draws on Perpetual Peace to call for a more interventionist model of international relations, arguing that international law should be based on a union of liberal democracies. The principle of non-intervention applies only as between liberal democracies. Recourse to the use of force may be justified in order to defend the liberal alliance against outlaw dictators, and against tyrants, as the principle of non-intervention, reflected in the fifth preliminary article, is dependent on compliance with the first definitive article: ‘state sovereignty reacquires its shielding power only in states that have adopted and implemented [a republican constitution]’: ibid at 92. cf David Kennedy, ‘My Talk at the ASIL: What is New Thinking in International Law?’ (2000) 94 American Society of International Law Proceedings 104, 119; also Martti Koskenniemi, ‘Constitutionalism as Mindset: Reflections on Kantian Themes about International Law and Globalization’ (2007) 8 Theoretical Inquiries in Law 9, 28. 151 Kant (n 142) at 128. 152 ibid at 114. On the importance of compulsory adjudication, see Ernst-Ulrich Petersmann, ‘Constitutionalism and International Adjudication: How to Constitutionalize the U.N. Dispute Settlement System?’ (1999) 31 New York University Journal of International Law and Politics 753, 790. In 1944, Hans Kelsen argued that the only way to protect the principle of sovereign equality was ‘the establishment of an international community whose main organ is an international court endowed with compulsory jurisdiction’: Hans Kelsen, ‘The Principle of Sovereign Equality of States as a Basis for International Organization’ (1944) 53 Yale Law Journal 207, 214. 153 Kant (n 142) at 134. 154 ibid at 109.
Columns Design Ltd
/
Job: Wheatley
/
Division: 01_Thearguments
/Pg. Position: 31 /
Date: 26/3
JOBNAME: Wheatley PAGE: 32 SESS: 4 OUTPUT: Tue May 11 14:32:06 2010
A Democratic Peace
53
to promote their own security, states should demand the introduction of a federation of nations.155 This would not be a ‘State of nations’, as this would involve a contradiction, given that the idea of the state ‘implies the relationship of one who rules to those who obey’: lawgiver and subject. Further, a state of nations would not be consistent with the understanding that states have of themselves, as being free from external legal authority.156 Whilst referring to the idea that a state of nations with coercive public laws might ‘finally embrace all the peoples of the earth’,157 Kant accepts that this is not possible as long as states hold firm to their conception of the ‘law of nations’, as opposed to the ‘positive idea of a world-republic’. If the tendency of states to engage in warfare is to be brought to an end, what is required is a ‘negative substitute’ for a world-republic – ‘a federation averting war, maintaining its ground and ever expanding over the world’.158 The third definitive article provides that the rights of human persons, ‘as citizens of the world, shall be limited to the conditions of universal hospitality’.159 This is the right not to be treated as a enemy; it belongs to all human persons by virtue of our common right of possession on the surface of the earth on which… we cannot be infinitely scattered, and must in the end reconcile ourselves to existence side by side: at the same time, originally no one individual had more right than another to live in any one particular spot.160
The right is that which ‘is implied in a permission to make an attempt at intercourse with the original inhabitants’. Individuals from ‘far distant territories’ may consequently ‘enter into peaceful relations with one another. These relations may at last come under the public control of law, and thus the human race may be brought nearer the realisation of a cosmopolitan constitution.’161 The intercourse between the different peoples of the world, Kant argues, ‘has now extended so enormously that a violation of right in one part of the world is felt all over it’. The idea of a cosmopolitan right is a necessary complement to international and constitutional laws, ‘for the public rights of mankind in general and thus for the realisation of perpetual peace’.162
155
ibid at 129. ibid at 130. 157 ibid at 136. 158 ibid at 136. Thomas Giegerich concludes that Kant argues for a ‘League of Nations’ rather than a world state, because the American federal system of divided sovereignty (United States Constitution 1787) ‘had not yet stood the test of time’ when Kant published Perpetual Peace: Giegerich (n 127) at 34. 159 Kant (n 142) at 137. 160 ibid at 138. 161 ibid at 139. 162 ibid at 142. 156
Columns Design Ltd
/
Job: Wheatley
/
Division: 01_Thearguments
/Pg. Position: 32 /
Date: 26/3
JOBNAME: Wheatley PAGE: 33 SESS: 4 OUTPUT: Tue May 11 14:32:06 2010
54 The Democratic Deficit in Global Governance A Law of Peoples The argument in Perpetual Peace is that the avoidance of war can only be achieved through the establishment of a global federation of republican states. Each state is free to develop its own conception of political justice, whilst recognising the cosmopolitan reality that all human persons are co-members of world society. An important and influential variant on the democratic peace thesis that both draws on and resonates with the existing international law order is developed by John Rawls in The Law of Peoples. The aim is to outline a foreign policy for a reasonably just liberal people,163 acceptable within a reasonable Law of Peoples,164 ie to develop a political conception of rights and justice that would apply to international relations, framed in terms of international law.165 The liberal international law order is agreed in a second (international) original position, following A Theory of Justice, which is concerned with domestic principles of justice.166 One criticism of A Theory of Justice was that it was based on an atomised individual, abstracted from her social context.167 The Law of Peoples adds a second original position, in which participants are not individuals, but the rational representatives of liberal peoples,168 who must agree a conception of international law acceptable to nonliberal but decent peoples. Consistent with the liberal principle of pluralism within and between societies, the law of peoples requires that liberal peoples tolerate other decent peoples as ‘equal participating members in good standing of the Society of Peoples’.169 The focus on ‘peoples’ has been subject to criticism, not least because Rawls fails to define the term with any clarity,170 although, as Charles Beitz observes, ‘for most purposes it can be interpreted as referring to a society with a common political culture organized as a state’.171 Rawls argues that peoples strive to protect their hard won political independence and free culture, and ‘to guarantee their security, territory, and the
163 John Rawls, The Law of Peoples (Cambridge, Massachusetts, Harvard University Press, 1999) 10 (emphasis in original). Rawls distinguishes five different kinds of societies: reasonably liberal peoples; decent peoples; outlaw states; societies burdened by unfavourable conditions; and benevolent absolutisms, which honour human rights, without permitting members a role in making political decisions: ibid at 4. 164 ibid at 26. 165 ibid at 3. 166 John Rawls, A Theory of Justice (Oxford, Clarendon Press, 1972). 167 Anupam Chander, ‘Diaspora Bonds’ (2001) 76 New York University Law Review 1005, 1047. 168 Rawls (n 163) at 32. 169 ibid at 59. 170 Thomas Pogge, ‘The Incoherence between Rawls’s Theories of Justice’ (2004) 72 Fordham Law Review 1739, 1743. 171 Charles Beitz, ‘Rawls’s Law of Peoples’ (2000) 110 Ethics, 669, fn 7.
Columns Design Ltd
/
Job: Wheatley
/
Division: 01_Thearguments
/Pg. Position: 33 /
Date: 26/3
JOBNAME: Wheatley PAGE: 34 SESS: 4 OUTPUT: Tue May 11 14:32:06 2010
A Democratic Peace
55
well-being of their citizens’.172 Nowhere does Rawls suggest that peoples not organised as states are equal participants in the society of peoples.173 In another context, Philip Allott observes the obsession in international law writings (and writings about international law) to develop categories ‘designed to normalize the isolating of human societies (sovereignty, sovereign equality, domestic jurisdiction, territorial integrity, political independence), as if it feared the impulsive power of human solidarity’.174 International law ‘begins to speak of democracy as an international legal concept, but seeks to incorporate it in an international system whose structure assumes that there are no societies other than state-systems, statesystems in a systematic relationship of pre-democracy and presociality’.175 In contrast to states, which are rational self-interested actors, Rawls argues that we can attribute ‘moral motives’ to peoples:176 what distinguishes peoples from states is that ‘just peoples are fully prepared to grant the very same proper respect and recognition to other peoples as equals’.177 The principle of discourse is applied to the representatives of liberal peoples in the second original position. Liberal peoples have three basic features: a reasonably just constitutional democratic government that serves the fundamental interests of citizens; citizens united by common sympathies; and a moral nature, ie a political conception of right and justice.178 In the first original position, the rational actors are individuals who agree principles of domestic justice. The second (international) original position does not allow for the participation of individuals, although Rawls concludes that one of the principles of international justice will be that peoples honour human rights.179 The objective of discussions is agreement, through reasoned deliberation, on
172
Rawls (n 163) at 34. Allen Buchanan, ‘Rawls’s Law of Peoples: Rules for a Vanished Westphalian World’ (2000) 110 Ethics 697, 699. 174 Philip Allott, ‘Reconstituting Humanity – New International Law’ (1992) 3 European Journal of International Law 219, 247 (emphasis in original). 175 ibid at 248 (emphasis in original). 176 Rawls (n 163) at 17. Seyla Benhabib notes that, for Rawls, peoples are viewed ‘as carriers of a coherent moral world-view’, ignoring the fact of significant divisions in societies, including liberal democracies: Seyla Benhabib, ‘The Law of Peoples, Distributive Justice, and Migrations’ (2004) 72 Fordham Law Review 1761, 1766. Benhabib notes that national forms of collective (self-)identity are formed through ‘competing and contentious narratives, through which universalizing aspirations and particular memories compete with one another to create temporary narrative syntheses’: ibid at 1768. 177 Rawls (n 163) at 35. 178 ibid at 23–24. 179 ibid at 37. Rational individuals in the second ‘original position’ might well have agreed that global justice requires the effective protection of human rights in all states, allowing a right of humanitarian intervention, because ‘they might end up as citizens of tyrannical states’: Fernando Téson, ‘The Kantian Theory of International law’ (1992) 92 Columbia Law Review 53, 84. See also Pogge (n 170) at 1745 173
Columns Design Ltd
/
Job: Wheatley
/
Division: 01_Thearguments
/Pg. Position: 34 /
Date: 26/3
JOBNAME: Wheatley PAGE: 35 SESS: 4 OUTPUT: Tue May 11 14:32:06 2010
56 The Democratic Deficit in Global Governance the principles that can be shared by different peoples.180 The representatives of liberal peoples will agree a Law of Peoples that reflects the liberal conception of justice agreed in the first original position, including the idea of reasonable pluralism.181 Given that the Society of Peoples will have many more different cultures and traditions than domestic societies, Rawls concludes that respect for pluralism and tolerance of difference requires the recognition of the principle of the equality of peoples,182 and the right, within certain limits, of peoples to follow their own ways of life. The Law of Peoples does not require that (non-liberal) decent societies ‘abandon or modify their religious institutions and adopt liberal ones’.183 The principle of equality applies both between liberal peoples, and between liberal peoples and decent hierarchical peoples, whose societies have a pre-ordained conception of the good, pursued by the people through government institutions. Rawls gives the example of the fictional state of Kazanistan, where Islam is the favoured religion and only Muslims can hold the upper positions of political authority and exert a decisive influence on fundamental policy issues, but in which minorities are tolerated and enjoy the rights to a distinctive culture.184 Decent hierarchical peoples are distinguished by the fact that whilst they are not liberal (ie, they do not possess a political concept of justice and the good life developed through democratic deliberations), they do not have aggressive aims and do respect the human rights of all members and provide mechanisms to give members a role in political decisionmaking.185 The principle of equality does not apply between liberal peoples and ‘outlaw states’, ‘burdened societies’, or ‘benevolent absolutisms’, which are not well ordered because they do not permit effective participation by all members of the society.186 The Law of Peoples outlines ‘familiar and traditional principles of justice among free and democratic peoples’, following JL Brierly’s The Law of Nations:187 peoples are free and independent; peoples are to honour 180
ibid at 55. ibid at 33. 182 ibid at 40. 183 ibid at 121. 184 ibid at 75–76. 185 ibid at 71. 186 Pogge (n 170) at 1740. 187 JL Brierly, The Law of Nations: an Introduction to the International Law of Peace, 6th edn by Sir Humphrey Waldock (Oxford, Clarendon Press, 1963). Vaughan Lowe has updated The Law of Nations, and articulated the following ‘principles of the international legal system’, drawn from GA Res 2625 (XXV), ‘Declaration on Friendly Relations’, which ‘looks almost like a statement of basic constitutional rules and principles’: a prohibition on the use of force; the settlement of international disputes by peaceful means; non-intervention in domestic affairs; a duty of co-operation; the principle of equal rights and selfdetermination; the principle of sovereign equality of states; and that states shall fulfil 181
Columns Design Ltd
/
Job: Wheatley
/
Division: 01_Thearguments
/Pg. Position: 35 /
Date: 26/3
JOBNAME: Wheatley PAGE: 36 SESS: 4 OUTPUT: Tue May 11 14:32:06 2010
A Democratic Peace
57
treaties; peoples are equal; peoples are to observe the duty of nonintervention; peoples have the right to self-defence, but not to wage war for reasons other than self-defence; peoples are to honour human rights; peoples are to recognise certain restrictions in the conduct of warfare; and peoples have the duty to assist other peoples living under unfavourable conditions that prevent their having a ‘just or decent political and social regime’.188 Whilst The Law of Peoples outlines an ideal theory of peaceful relations between peoples, it also recognises the possibility of conflict between liberal peoples and ‘non-well-ordered peoples’.189 Liberal peoples will go to war ‘with unsatisfied societies, or outlaw states[,] when such a state’s policies threaten their security and safety, since they must defend the freedom and independence of their liberal culture’.190 Well-ordered liberal and decent peoples will not engage in war with each other and they will only engage in conflict with non-well-ordered societies in response to the expansionist policies of the other.191 A war of self-defence is legitimated for liberal societies in defence of the basic freedoms of their citizens, their constitutionally democratic political institutions, and the many religious and non-religious traditions and forms of life.192 Decent peoples also have the right to defend their (monolithic) way of life, as do benevolent absolutisms: ‘any society that is nonaggressive and that honors human rights has the right of selfdefence’.193 In addition to the use of force in self-defence, The Law of Peoples permits military intervention in cases of severe human rights abuses.194 The relevant ‘minimalist’ human rights standards concern the rights to life, liberty, property and formal equality,195 and the ‘security of ethnic groups from mass murder and genocide’.196 Charles Beitz explains that ‘humanitarian’ intervention is justified by considerations of international stability, given that states that violate human rights (‘outlaw states’) are aggressive
international law obligations in good faith: Vaughan Lowe, International Law (Oxford, Oxford University Press, 2007) 90–100. No mention is made of the protection of human rights. 188 Rawls (n 163) at 37. Steven Ratner argues that Rawls makes ‘two critical errors: (1) he uses international law norms applying to states to advance a moral theory regarding a wholly different entity, namely peoples; and (2) by focusing on peoples alone (or by equating them with states), Rawls ignores the multiple entities – most important, states and individuals – that can and do have rights and duties’: Steven Ratner, ‘Is International Law Impartial?’ (2005) 11 Legal Theory 39, 67 (references omitted). 189 ibid at 89. 190 ibid at 48. 191 ibid at 94. 192 ibid at 91. 193 ibid at 92. 194 ibid at 49. 195 ibid at 65. 196 ibid at 79.
Columns Design Ltd
/
Job: Wheatley
/
Division: 01_Thearguments
/Pg. Position: 36 /
Date: 26/3
JOBNAME: Wheatley PAGE: 37 SESS: 4 OUTPUT: Tue May 11 14:32:06 2010
58 The Democratic Deficit in Global Governance and dangerous, and that all peoples are more secure if ‘outlaw states’ change, or are forced to change, their ways.197 The aim of any military intervention is to ensure that the target society becomes a full member of the society of well-ordered peoples.198 The aim of a ‘just war’ is a just and lasting peace among peoples; this does not necessarily require the imposition of a liberal and democratic government on the target society.199 The Law of Peoples does not include any principle of distributive justice among peoples analogous to the ‘difference principle’ agreed in the first original position which provides that all social primary goods (liberty and opportunity, wealth, etc), should be distributed equally, unless an unequal distribution is to the advantage of the least favoured.200 The Law of Peoples proceeds as if societies ‘are economically self-sufficient and distributionally autonomous (so long as they are well governed)’.201 States are responsible for the welfare of their citizens; ‘the international community is responsible for maintaining background conditions in which decent domestic societies can flourish’.202 Poverty is a domestic, not an international, concern:203 inequalities between peoples result from the good or bad choices that they make for themselves;204 burdened societies are burdened as a result of their own domestic policy failures.205 Liberal peoples have a duty of assistance, to help burdened societies manage their own affairs and eventually to become members of the society of well-ordered peoples, but that assistance must not be paternalistic, it must aim for the ‘freedom and equality of the formally burdened societies’.206 Once a burdened society is capable of effective selfgovernment, the duty of humanitarian assistance is fulfilled; no further transfers of aid are required.
197
Beitz (n 171) at 685. Rawls (n 163) at 93. 199 ibid at 94. 200 John Rawls, A Theory of Justice (Oxford, Clarendon Press, 1972) 303. 201 Buchanan (n 173) at 706. 202 Beitz (n 171) at 677. 203 In this context, see art 28, Universal Declaration of Human Rights: ‘Everyone is entitled to a social and international order in which the rights and freedoms set forth in this Declaration can be fully realized.’ See, further, Thomas Pogge, ‘Recognized and Violated by International Law: the Human Rights of the Global Poor’ (2005) 18 Leiden Journal of International Law 717, 721: ‘Article 28 should be read as holding that the moral quality, or justice, of any institutional order depends primarily on the extent to which it affords all its participants secure access to the objects of their human rights; any institutional order is to be assessed and reformed principally by reference to its relative impact on the realization of the human rights of those on whom it is imposed.’ 204 Rawls (n 163) at 117. 205 ibid at 108. The idea that citizens should bear the consequences of the ‘bad choices’ of governments is suspect in the absence of evidence that the government is in some way accountable to its citizens: Joel Trachtman, ‘Welcome to Cosmopolis, World of Boundless Opportunity’ (2006) 39 Cornell International Law Journal 477, 494. 206 ibid at 111. 198
Columns Design Ltd
/
Job: Wheatley
/
Division: 01_Thearguments
/Pg. Position: 37 /
Date: 26/3
JOBNAME: Wheatley PAGE: 38 SESS: 4 OUTPUT: Tue May 11 14:32:06 2010
A Democratic Peace
59
The Law of Peoples is an ideal theory. It does not address obligations that might arise from past relations of colonial exploitation or external interventions, the advantages that the international system provides for certain states,207 or the fact that different peoples enjoy greater or poorer opportunities as the result of factors outside of their control.208 The theory fails to acknowledge the structural advantages enjoyed by developed nations in dealings with developing states as the organisation of world society reflects the preferences of wealthy and powerful states who are able to ‘use their greater bargaining power to shape and reshape this order in their own favor’.209 International law agreements concerning trade, investments, intellectual property, and the use of common resources ‘can be shaped to be more or less favorable to various affected parties and, in particular, shaped to be more favorable to affluent societies (and their citizens and corporations)’.210 The possibilities of inter-state cooperation are conditioned by this ‘global basic structure’, and, as Allen Buchanan notes, it is ‘unjustifiable to ignore [this] in a moral theory of international law’.211 The Law of Peoples provides a significant contribution to debates around the democratisation of world society. It concludes that the principles of liberal democracy and social solidarity that legitimate the exercise of coercive political authority in the state should not be imposed on other states, and need not be applied to the global law order. Joseph Raz observes that, for Rawls, the principles of justice that should be applied
207 See Pogge (n 170) at 1749; Frank Garcia, ‘The Law of Peoples’ (2001) 23 Houston Journal of International Law 659, 670; Buchanan (n 173) at 706; also Stephen Macedo, ‘What Self-Governing Peoples Owe to One Another: Universalism, Diversity, and The Law of Peoples’ (2004) 72 Fordham Law Review 1721, 1727. 208 A World Bank report on Equity and Development notes that the most significant determinant in an individual’s life chances ‘is his or her country of birth’. It also notes that ‘global markets are far from equitable, and the rules governing their functioning have a disproportionately negative effect on developing countries. The rules ‘are the outcome of complex negotiating processes in which developing countries have less voice’. The report concludes that a more equitable system would require ‘more equitable rules for the functioning of global markets, more effective participation of poor countries in global rule-setting processes, and more actions to help build and maintain the endowments of poor countries and poor people’. World Bank, World Development Report: Equity and Development (Washington, DC, World Bank, 2006) 16. 209 Pogge (n 170) at 1749. 210 ibid at 1750. 211 Buchanan (n 173) at 706. The representatives of liberal peoples in the second original position would choose principles of justice for the global basic structure to ensure that the global basic structure’s distributional effects did not impede that society’s capacity to achieve its own conception of justice, and avoid principles that might turn out to assign them an inferior status in the Society of Peoples: ibid at 708. Concerned to protect their interests, they would also choose a principle of ‘democratic participation in the most important global governance institutions’: ibid at 711.
Columns Design Ltd
/
Job: Wheatley
/
Division: 01_Thearguments
/Pg. Position: 38 /
Date: 26/3
JOBNAME: Wheatley PAGE: 39 SESS: 4 OUTPUT: Tue May 11 14:32:06 2010
60 The Democratic Deficit in Global Governance at the domestic level cannot simply be extended to the international arena: ‘much of the content of the moral principles which govern social relations and the structure of social organisation is determined by the contingent practices of different societies’. Two conclusions follow: the principles of justice that apply to global governance and international relations cannot simply replicate those of a particular society, or type of society, and ‘respect for the independence and autonomy of the state is of great moral significance’.212 These conclusions are important in any debate around the democratisation of world society.
COSMOPOLITAN DEMOCRATIC LAW
The implicit assumption of the democratic peace thesis is that if all states were democratic, the problem of democracy in world society would be resolved. The analysis follows the meta-principle of (Westphalian) sovereignty in focusing on democratic representation through domestic institutions (internally) and the inter-state system (externally). The argument could be sustained on two conditions: that the authority of international law is subject to the democratic will of all states (see chapter three for the difficulties with this argument), and that (sovereign) states enjoy a monopoly on the production of law norms. This is clearly not the case. The globalisation and fragmentation of governance subjects states to international law norms to which they have not given their consent. Daniele Archibugi makes the point that the ‘democratization of world affairs [cannot] be achieved solely by proxy, through single state governments, however democratic they may be. A set of democratic states does not generate a democratic globe.’213 A global democratic order cannot be founded on democracy within states. Arguments for the strengthening of sovereignty, or replication of state-like institutions at the global level, or for a confederation of democratic states fail to recognise and accommodate the extant nature of global governance. It is perhaps for this reason that those arguments, previously examined, have not resonated in policy discussions or the academic literature. Debates around the globalisation of the principle of democracy remain dominated by the model of ‘cosmopolitan democracy’, associated most closely with the work of David Held. The model does not aim to develop a model of global democratic governance from first principles, but to consider the implications of applying cosmopolitan and democratic principles to the existing system. In terms of etymology, the words 212 Joseph Raz, ‘Human Rights Without Foundations’ Working Paper No 14/2007 (SSRN)(University of Oxford, Faculty of Law Legal Studies Research Paper Series, 2007) 12. 213 Daniele Archibugi, ‘Demos and Cosmopolis’ (2002) 13 New Left Review 24, 31.
Columns Design Ltd
/
Job: Wheatley
/
Division: 01_Thearguments
/Pg. Position: 39 /
Date: 26/3
JOBNAME: Wheatley PAGE: 40 SESS: 7 OUTPUT: Thu May 13 11:15:14 2010
Cosmopolitan Democratic Law
61
‘cosmopolitan’ and ‘democracy’ are not easily conjoined. Democracy is a system of government in which ‘the sovereign power resides in the people as a whole, and is exercised either directly by them … or by officers elected by them.’214 It is literally, ‘rule by the people’, a term derived from the Greek demokratia, from demos (‘people’) and kratos (‘rule’), and coined to describe the political systems in some Greek city-states, notably Athens.215 The idea of democratic ‘self’-government requires a bounded demos, with rights and obligations following from the fact of membership. Cosmopolitans do not accept that the limits of political justice are defined and delimited by the contingent boundaries of the sovereign state.216 The individual is the ultimate unit of concern and all human persons are of equal concern for everyone, not just those linked by bonds of citizenship, or other contingent relations of nationality, culture, etc.217 The Oxford English Dictionary defines a cosmopolitan as a person ‘belonging to all parts of the world; not restricted to any one country or its inhabitants’. According to Noah Feldman, the origin of the term is credited to Diogenes the Cynic, a stranger in Athens (ie not a citizen), and thus excluded from the Greek ideals of the virtue of participatory citizenship. When asked where he came from, Diogenes replied: ‘I am a citizen of the world [kosmopolites].’218 For the cosmopolitan, co-membership is defined by reference to common belonging in the human species. The argument may be understood both as a personal ethic,219 and as a meta-principle for the organisation and allocation of political authority in world society. There are seven paramount cosmopolitan principles: equal worth and dignity; active agency; personal responsibility and accountability; consent; reflexive deliberation and collective decision-making through voting procedures; inclusiveness and subsidiarity; and avoidance of serious harm and the
214 The Oxford English Dictionary. 2nd edn 1989. OED Online (Oxford, Oxford University Press, 2000). 215 Encyclopædia Britannica. Encyclopædia Britannica Online (2010). 216 The idea of the human race forming a single society in international law may be traced to Victoria (Relectio of the Reverend Father, Brother Franciscus de Victoria Concerning Civil Power) and Gentili (Suarez, De Legibus). See Leo Gross, ‘The Peace of Westphalia, 1648– 1948’ (1948) 42 American Journal of International Law 20, 32–33. 217 Thomas Pogge, ‘Cosmopolitanism and Sovereignty’ (1992) 103 Ethics 48, 48–49. 218 Quoted, Noah Feldman, ‘Cosmopolitan Law?’ (2007) 116 Yale Law Journal 1022, 1027. 219 Seyla Benhabib refers to the idea that every person that has interests, and whom my actions, and the consequences of my actions affects, ‘is potentially a moral conversation partner with me: I have a moral obligation to justify my actions with reasons to this individual or to the representatives of this being. I respect the moral worth of the other by recognizing that I must provide him or her with a justification for my actions’: Seyla Benhabib, Another Cosmopolitanism (Oxford, Oxford University Press, 2006) 18. These ideas may provide the basis for ethical reflection and consumer choice, but not the legitimate exercise of political authority by global governance actors (or the conditions for the exercise of that authority).
Columns Design Ltd
/
Job: Wheatley
/
Division: 01_Thearguments
/Pg. Position: 40 /
Date: 13/5
JOBNAME: Wheatley PAGE: 41 SESS: 4 OUTPUT: Tue May 11 14:32:06 2010
62 The Democratic Deficit in Global Governance amelioration of urgent need.220 Archibugi writes that the political project of cosmopolitan democracy is an attempt to reconcile globalisation with democracy, and recognise and respond to the threats to democracy posed by the processes of globalisation, whilst at the same time accepting that it is not possible for individual states to regulate the dynamics of globalisation in an effective manner.221 Social, economic and political problems and regulatory solutions are no longer defined exclusively by reference to the bounded territory of the state. The effects of global warming are the concern of all human persons, whilst inequalities in trade relations are the concern of consumers in the developed parts of the world and other places, and producers in less developed parts. Globalisation has produced communities of fate defined by a common problem requiring a (global) regulatory solution.222 Cosmopolitan democracy proceeds from an understanding that democratic theory can no longer be elaborated exclusively in terms of a theory of government for a territorially delimited polity; nor can the state be displaced as a central point of reference. The argument for cosmopolitan democratic law is outlined by David Held: the idea of sovereignty should be disentangled from notions of fixed borders and territories to become an attribute of the basic democratic law, which would operate at different levels, from the global to the regional to the state to lower levels (cities and more local associations). The aim would be to establish a more participatory form of democracy and create a ‘political order of democratic associations, cities and nations as well as of regions and global networks’.223 The application of cosmopolitan and democratic principles would result in overlapping systems of governance organised in accordance with democratic law. Individuals would enjoy multiple citizenships and associated rights of political membership in the ‘diverse political communities that significantly affect them’.224 Those affected (in a ‘nontrivial’ way) by public decisions would have ‘an equal opportunity, directly or indirectly through elected representatives, to influence and shape them’.225 Political authority would be exercised in a political unit
220 David Held, ‘Law of States, Law of Peoples: Three Models of Sovereignty’ (2002) 8 Legal Theory 1, 24. 221 Archibugi (n 213) at 28. 222 Richard Bellamy and Dario Castiglione, ‘Democracy, Sovereignty and the Constitution of the European Union: Republican Alternative to Liberalism’ in Zenon Ban´kowski and Andrew Scott (eds), The European Union and its Order: the Legal Theory of European Integration (Oxford, Blackwell, 2000) 169, 173. 223 David Held, ‘The Transformation of Political Community: Rethinking Democracy in the Context of Globalization’ in Ian Shapiro and Casiano Hacker-Cordón (eds), Democracy’s Edges (Cambridge, Cambridge University Press, 1999) 84, 107. 224 Held (n 220) at 33. 225 David Held, ‘Cosmopolitanism: Globalisation Tamed?’ (2003) 29 Review of International Studies 465, 471.
Columns Design Ltd
/
Job: Wheatley
/
Division: 01_Thearguments
/Pg. Position: 41 /
Date: 26/3
JOBNAME: Wheatley PAGE: 42 SESS: 4 OUTPUT: Tue May 11 14:32:06 2010
Cosmopolitan Democratic Law
63
that would be as small as possible, but still include all those significantly affected. Issues that can be dealt with at the local level, should be dealt with at the local level, but it may be appropriate to move the locus for democratic decision-making away from the state when cosmopolitan principles can be upheld only in a transnational context, and when ‘those significantly affected by a public matter constitute a transnational grouping’.226 Cosmopolitan democratic theory is both cosmopolitan and democratic. The twin foci concern effective citizen control over decision-making processes and recognition that political communities of fate are not defined exclusively by reference to the boundaries of the sovereign state. Cosmopolitan public law is distinct from state law and international law in that it operates both ‘within and across borders’,227 reflecting a global system of fragmented authority. The concern is to ensure that the various communities of fate exercise democratic control over the global regulatory regimes that emerge in response to the processes of globalisation. There is no necessary connection between the boundaries of political decision-making and the modern state, and no requirement that there is a single locus of political authority: issues may be dealt with at the local (city/town), regional, or global level as appropriate. The implementation of cosmopolitan democratic law and establishment of a ‘cosmopolitan community – a community of all democratic communities’ requires a ‘transnational, common structure of political action which alone, ultimately, can support the politics of self-determination’.228 Political institutions must be designed to ensure that all significantly affected individuals can participate effectively in decision-making processes that maximise the potential influence of the individual voice and vote. This demands novel and imaginative responses to the problem of democratic capture, and it is not sufficient simply to argue for a replication of state institutions in a legal world in which ‘those affected’ are not (only) defined by the boundaries of the territorial state. Whilst a number of regional and global regulatory regimes may seek to establish state-like democratic structures, including legislative and executive bodies,229 other systems may rely on different mechanisms for determining the will of transnational communities, such as elected supervisory bodies, or the use of referenda, that would cut across nations and nation-states at regional or global levels.230 A particular concern is the protection of international
226
ibid at 475. David Held, Democracy and the Global Order: From the Modern State to Cosmopolitan Governance (Cambridge, Polity Press, 1996) 227. 228 ibid at 232. 229 ibid at 279. 230 ibid at 272–73; also, Held (n 225) at 476–78. 227
Columns Design Ltd
/
Job: Wheatley
/
Division: 01_Thearguments
/Pg. Position: 42 /
Date: 26/3
JOBNAME: Wheatley PAGE: 43 SESS: 4 OUTPUT: Tue May 11 14:32:06 2010
64 The Democratic Deficit in Global Governance human rights norms, with the need for the establishment of a ‘thick’ charter of human rights, including economic, social and cultural rights, and the creation of an international human rights court.231 Individuals would be able to appeal to international human rights bodies and have judgments enforced against domestic governments. The idea of cosmopolitan democracy provides important insights for the democratisation of world society, and for beginning to think about the democratisation of global law. What Held fails to explain with sufficient clarity is how political discourses can occur within global, transnational, or even sectoral communities of fate. In the absence of genuine processes of democratic will-formation, the exercise of political authority in the name of some or other putative community of fate will remain, in the words of Jürgen Habermas, ‘a hegemonic legal façade’. There might be cosmopolitan law, but it would not be democratic law.232 Moreover, as Dennis Thompson observes, the proliferation of decisionmaking authorities under the cosmopolitan model would result in a decline of accountability, certainly in contrast to the state law system. The development of a complex network of sites of authority will not provide non-members with opportunities for control or influence, or assist members to deal with the effects of the uncoordinated decisions of other agencies and assemblies: ‘The dispersal of authority may generate more points of influence and more opportunities for participation, but it is also likely to offer less effective control and coordination.’233
DEMOCRATISING INTERNATIONAL INSTITUTIONS
Cosmopolitan democracy is an argument for the reallocation of political authority to ensure the participation of all those affected in processes of democratic will formation. It demands the recognition of new communities of fate and establishment of democratic institutions to ensure the legitimacy of global governance. A less radical approach is to apply democratic principles of representation and accountability to existing structures. The following sections examine arguments for applying the parliamentary principle of democracy to international organisations, specifically in relation to the UN, and for developing the idea of accountability of international organisations.
231
Held (n 220) at 34. Jürgen Habermas, ‘Does the Constitutionalization of International Law Still Have a Chance?’ in The Divided West (Cambridge, Polity, 2006) 115, 140. 233 Dennis Thompson, ‘Democratic Theory and Global Society’ (1999) 7 Journal of Political Philosophy 111, 115–16. 232
Columns Design Ltd
/
Job: Wheatley
/
Division: 01_Thearguments
/Pg. Position: 43 /
Date: 26/3
JOBNAME: Wheatley PAGE: 44 SESS: 3 OUTPUT: Tue May 11 14:32:06 2010
Democratising International Institutions
65
International Parliamentary Assemblies One mechanism for the democratisation of global politics would be the establishment of parliamentary-type institutions. At the domestic level, national parliaments legislature within a constitutional framework; hold the executive to account; provide a forum for democratic debate; and, in parliamentary democracies, provide an expression of the ‘will of the people’ leading to the establishment of an executive government. Where international organisations (and other non-state actors) exercise a regulatory function, the parliamentary principle associated with the practice of democracy suggests a requirement to establish a directly elected assembly that would both adopt international law norms and hold the regulatory power-wielders to account. Robert Dahl is the best known proponent of the view that democratic legitimacy for international organisations requires the establishment of political bodies to provide individuals with opportunities for political participation and mechanisms for accountability similar to those that exist in democratic states, concluding that elected representatives, or their functional equivalents, should exercise control over the more important international bureaucracies.234 In the fragmented world of law, the responsibility for global regulation is divided between some 250 international organisations and institutions that differ in the scale and importance of their responsibilities. Forty five have parliamentary assemblies, with representation often reflecting the size of population of the relevant Member State. Anne Peters argues that the most powerful international organisations and institutions should be ‘parliamentarised’, although she counsels against any view that global parliamentary assemblies can provide effective political oversight: their importance lies in opening up international organisations to greater transparency and public scrutiny, contestation and debate, and in promoting ‘political dialogue at the level of [domestic] parliaments, political parties, and civil society’.235 Examples of international parliamentary assemblies include236 the Organization for Security and Co-operation in Europe, the Council of Europe, and North Atlantic Treaty Organization. 234 Robert Dahl, ‘Can International Organizations be Democratic? A Skeptic’s View’ in Ian Shapiro and Casiano Hacker-Cordón (eds), Democracy’s Edges (Cambridge, Cambridge University Press, 1999) 19, 31. 235 Jan Klabbers, Anne Peters and Geir Ulfstein, The Constitutionalization of International Law (Oxford, Oxford University Press, 2009) 324. See also Stefan Marschall, Transnationale Repräsentation in Parlamentarischen Versammlungen: Demokratie und Parlamentarismus Jenseits des Nationalstaates (Baden-Baden, Nomos, 2005). 236 There have also been proposals to ‘democratise’ the World Trade Organization through the introduction of a standing Parliamentary Assembly: Gregory Shaffer, ‘Parliamentary Oversight of WTO Rule-Making: the Political, Normative, and Practical Contexts’ (2004) 7 Journal of International Economic Law 629, 639.
Columns Design Ltd
/
Job: Wheatley
/
Division: 01_Thearguments
/Pg. Position: 44 /
Date: 26/2
JOBNAME: Wheatley PAGE: 45 SESS: 3 OUTPUT: Tue May 11 14:32:06 2010
66 The Democratic Deficit in Global Governance A notable development is the Pan-African Parliament, established under the Constitutive Act of the African Union ‘to ensure the full participation of African peoples in the development and economic integration of the continent’.237 The Pan-African Parliament, which held its inaugural session in March 2004, is described as the ‘legislative body of the African Union’. At present it exercises an oversight function, and has advisory and consultative powers, although the ultimate aim is to establish the Pan-African Parliament as an institution with full legislative powers, whose members are elected by universal adult suffrage. Presently, the 265 representatives are elected by the legislatures of the 53 African Union states and do not enjoy a direct electoral mandate. With the exception of the Parliament of the European Union, no international parliamentary assembly permits direct elections. This may be significant, as the European Court of Justice has stated that the existence of the European Parliament reflects ‘the fundamental democratic principle that the peoples should take part in the exercise of power through the intermediary of a representative assembly’.238 The ideal of parliamentary democracy provides the dominant paradigm in debates on the European Union’s putative democratic deficit,239 with complaints focusing on the unwieldy size of the European Parliament, the disproportionate representation of smaller Member States, internal language barriers, popular and media disinterest, and the central role of the European Council and Commission in decision-making and law-making.240 There is also the problem of a lack of a clear ‘European’ identity amongst the citizens of the European Union, with political debates (and democratic will-formation) remaining resolutely focused on domestic politics (even in relation to issues within the competence of the European Union). A comparative analysis of the roles and responsibilities of the various parliamentary assemblies in the system of global governance is beyond the scope of this work. It is, though, evident that none of the existing
237
Constitutive Act of the African Union 2158 UNTS 3 art 17(1). Case 138/79 SA Roquette Frères v Council [1980] ECR 3333 [33]. 239 Francesca Bignami, ‘The Democratic Deficit in European Community Rulemaking: a Call for Notice and Comment in Comitology’ (1999) 40 Harvard International Law Journal 451, 451. 240 Peter Lindseth, ‘Democratic Legitimacy and the Administrative Character of Supranationalism: the Example of the European Community’ (1999) 99 Columbia Law Review 628, 674. Lindseth concludes that the Parliament of the European Union lacks democratic legitimacy for the very reason that it is not exercising powers delegated to it by a sovereign people: ‘In the absence of a European demos, the Community legislative process might still be legitimate, but only in an administrative sense, in that it is exercising authority within its sphere of competence lawfully delegated by the Member States’: ibid at 675. Mattias Kumm argues that without meaningful electoral politics, the attitude of citizens toward European institutions will continue to oscillate between disinterest, fickle support, and resentment: Mattias Kumm, ‘Why Europeans Will Not Embrace Constitutional Patriotism’ (2008) 6 International Journal of Constitutional Law 117. 238
Columns Design Ltd
/
Job: Wheatley
/
Division: 01_Thearguments
/Pg. Position: 45 /
Date: 26/2
JOBNAME: Wheatley PAGE: 46 SESS: 4 OUTPUT: Tue May 11 14:32:06 2010
Democratising International Institutions
67
international parliamentary assemblies functions in a way that is analogous to domestic legislatures in constitutional democracies, and there is no direct (electoral) relationship between any international organisation and those (formally) subject to its authority. Nanz and Steffek conclude that a democratic deficit exists in global governance ‘because international policy elites are not (elected) representatives of the people’.241 Citizens do not select international policy elites, and they cannot sanction them for poor or deficient performance, or remove them from office through electoral defeat. Daniel Weinstock argues that elections and democratic representation ‘are contingently, rather than conceptually, related to the foundational normative commitments of democracy’. Individuals have an interest in avoiding domination, ie situations in which ‘others have arbitrary power over them’. Elections ensure that citizens have control over power-wielders, as they require that political elites are ‘in some degree responsive to the interests of those for whom they legislate’.242 There is also an instrumental value in electoral politics, as direct participation provides an incentive for citizens to maintain an interest in global politics,243 and the debate that precedes the act of voting is often an essential element in the process of democratic will-formation, as preferences are often shaped during an electoral campaign.244 The absence of competitive elections to international assemblies impugns the political legitimacy of global regulatory norms – no elections, no democracy. A UN Parliamentary Assembly The previous section examined arguments seeking to establish a general principle that (at least the most important) international organisations should possess a directly elected representative assembly to legitimate regulatory authority. A particular focus in the literature is the ways in which the parliamentary principle might be applied to the UN. Concrete proposals include Thomas Franck’s second chamber at the level of the UN General Assembly to represent individuals elected on the basis on universal suffrage, and Richard Falk’s Global Peoples Assembly, which would emerge as a de facto legislature in the global system.245 In Fairness 241 Patrizia Nanz and Jens Steffek, ‘Global Governance, Participation and the Public Sphere’ (2004) 39 Government and Opposition 314, 317. 242 Weinstock (n 118) at 12. 243 ibid at 13. 244 Andreas Follesdal and Simon Hix, ‘Why there is a Democratic Deficit in the EU: a Response to Majone and Moravcsik’ (2006) 44 Journal of Common Market Studies 533, 549. 245 See also the proposals of the Inter-Parliamentary Union (IPU), an international organisation of parliaments of sovereign states, to work with the UN in order to make international relations and decision-making more transparent. The idea is to create a
Columns Design Ltd
/
Job: Wheatley
/
Division: 01_Thearguments
/Pg. Position: 46 /
Date: 26/3
JOBNAME: Wheatley PAGE: 47 SESS: 3 OUTPUT: Tue May 11 14:32:06 2010
68 The Democratic Deficit in Global Governance in International Law and Institutions, Franck introduces the idea of a second chamber, but does not provide any detail.246 Elsewhere, he observes that a forum that represented persons rather than governments would establish ‘some correlation between population and representation’. With implicit reference to the largely unremarked ‘China problem’ (a requirement of strict proportionality in representation would require that almost one in five seats in any global parliament be allocated to citizens of the People’s Republic of China), Franck concludes that it might be necessary to prescribe a maximum (and minimum) number of representatives per state.247 The proposal is for a more accurate reflection of the plurality of opinions within states, and not the plurality of opinions in world society. Following the US federal system, which provides for equal representation to each of the 50 states in the Senate (with two members for each state) and proportionate representation in the House of Representatives (giving, for example, California 53 members and Alaska one), Franck proposes a bicameral General Assembly: one chamber organised along the Westphalian model of one state, one vote, the other directly elected according to the principle of universal suffrage, with the number of seats allocated to each state corresponding generally to population. General Assembly resolutions might then be adopted on the basis of a simple majority in both chambers.248 The initiative would have the effect of energising world public opinion and creating possibilities for direct participation in global politics, with corresponding positive effects on domestic democratic politics. In the longer term, the directly elected chamber might assume the powers of the ‘traditional state-sponsored “upper house”.’249 Franck does not specify what these powers might be, although in most cases the legislative authority of the upper house is subservient to that of the lower, often on the basis that the lower house represents a clearer and more direct expression of the popular will. Anne Peters argues that a UN Parliamentary Assembly could be established as a subsidiary organ to the General Assembly under art 22 of the UN Charter.250 Deputies could be appointed from the membership of
two-way direct line of communication between the UN and the national parliaments that are members of the IPU: www.ipu.org/un-e/un-overview.htm (last visited 20 March 2009). See also the ‘e-Parliament’: www.e-parl.net (last visited 20 March 2009). 246 Thomas M Franck, Fairness in International Law and Institutions (Oxford, Clarendon Press, 1995) 483. 247 Thomas M Franck, ‘Fairness in Fairness Discourse’ in ‘Citizens in the International Realm: the New Participatory Demands’ (2001) American Society of International Law, Proceedings of the Annual Meeting 162, 170. 248 ibid at 171. 249 ibid at 172. 250 UN Charter art 22: ‘The General Assembly may establish such subsidiary organs as it deems necessary for the performance of its functions.’
Columns Design Ltd
/
Job: Wheatley
/
Division: 01_Thearguments
/Pg. Position: 47 /
Date: 26/2
JOBNAME: Wheatley PAGE: 48 SESS: 6 OUTPUT: Thu May 13 10:55:13 2010
Democratising International Institutions
69
national parliaments and hold a dual mandate.251 Delegates would reflect the political composition of national parliaments, including members of the opposition, and thus reflect more accurately the plurality of the dominant political perspectives within the state. Significant groups would continue to be unrepresented, notably the 370 million indigenous peoples of the world, who are not generally represented in national parliaments. Representation in the UN Parliamentary Assembly would be ‘roughly proportionate to the population of the UN member states, with minority protection for small states’. In an assembly of 560 members, the People’s Republic of China would have 31 seats, with states with populations of under one million being guaranteed one seat, although it is not clear what influence they might have on that basis, or how the diminution of voice and vote in comparison with the UN General Assembly might provide for a more ‘democratic’ UN. The UN Parliamentary Assembly would exist alongside the UN General Assembly, and might subsequently allow for direct elections. In this ‘global federalist scheme, the General Assembly as the member states’ chamber would become a “second” chamber’. The Parliamentary Assembly would not initially enjoy law-making powers or ability to control the government (whatever that might mean in the context of the UN), although it might share the budgetary power with the General Assembly under art 17 of the Charter. The Assembly would ensure that citizens had a voice, if not a vote, at a global level. The functions of the Parliamentary Assembly might include a right of notice and comment on important General Assembly resolutions prior to a vote, and a right to propose measures that might be adopted by other UN bodies, including the General Assembly. Its most important function would lie ‘in the parliamentary function of socialization and mediation and in the strengthening of national parliaments[,] [as it] would inform national parliaments about UN and world policies and vice versa’.252 Richard Falk observes that democracy is now generally accepted as the only legitimate form of domestic government, ‘leaving the conspicuous lack of global democratic institutions as the world’s greatest political
251 The use of the term ‘deputy’ as opposed to ‘representative’ is noteworthy. The OED defines a deputy as a person ‘appointed or nominated to act for another or others’: The Oxford English Dictionary. 2nd edn 1989. OED Online (Oxford, Oxford University Press, 2000). 252 Jan Klabbers, Anne Peters, and Geir Ulfstein, The Constitutionalization of International Law (Oxford, Oxford University Press, 2009) 326. A more modest proposal is made by Paul Kennedy, who argues that the UN General Assembly should become a more effective deliberative body and thus increase its influence over other UN organs: Paul Kennedy, The Parliament of Man: the United Nations and the Quest for World Government (London, Allen Lane, 2006) 275.
Columns Design Ltd
/
Job: Wheatley
/
Division: 01_Thearguments
/Pg. Position: 48 /
Date: 13/5
JOBNAME: Wheatley PAGE: 49 SESS: 4 OUTPUT: Tue May 11 14:32:06 2010
70 The Democratic Deficit in Global Governance anomaly’.253 The solution is an ‘internationally elected global assembly’, a Global Peoples Assembly (GPA), which would challenge the existing order and ‘undermine the claim that states are bound only by statecreated international law, and then only when they give their consent’.254 While the consent of states confers a degree of legitimacy on international institutions, the idea that is ‘the exclusive means of legitimizing transnational institutions is anachronistic’. The idea of sovereignty must reconcile itself with the modern commitment to democracy and human rights.255 States derive their sovereign authority from the people, and, because citizens are the ultimate source of political authority, they can bypass their ‘sovereign intermediaries’ to create an international organisation with law-making powers. Citizens have the right ‘and perhaps responsibility to found their own [Global Peoples Assembly]’.256 Once established, the GPA would increasingly act as a ‘de facto legislature’ (whatever that might mean).257 Representatives to the GPA would be democratically elected, assuming the possibilities of democratic politics and rights of political participation in the electoral process. On this basis, the citizens of non-democracies ‘would have to go unrepresented, or possibly be represented by delegates selected in some other way’.258 Daniel Weinstock explains (rather patronisingly): ‘[j]ust as children and various categories of incompetent persons are represented within mature democracies by proxies, we can imagine a similar arrangement obtaining for the peoples of the world currently being governed undemocratically.’259 International parliamentary assemblies might provide a useful addition to the global institutional architecture where membership in the organisation is limited to states and ‘global’ citizenship defined in a derivative manner by reference to citizenship of a state. The establishment of a global Parliament or introduction of a range of parliamentary assemblies in relation to the most significant international organisations and institutions would not, however, ensure the democratisation of global governance through law. The establishment of a legislative assembly does not provide democratic legitimacy in the absence of a political community defined by the exercise of political authority through law. The principal advantages of international assemblies lie in their ability to ensure a representation of the plurality of dominant political opinions
253 Richard Falk, ‘On the Creation of a Global Peoples Assembly: Legitimacy and the Power of Popular Sovereignty’ (2000) 36 Stanford Journal of International Law 191, 192. 254 ibid at 193. 255 ibid at 208. 256 ibid at 209. 257 ibid at 218. 258 ibid at 219. 259 Weinstock (n 118) at 17.
Columns Design Ltd
/
Job: Wheatley
/
Division: 01_Thearguments
/Pg. Position: 49 /
Date: 26/3
JOBNAME: Wheatley PAGE: 50 SESS: 4 OUTPUT: Tue May 11 14:32:06 2010
The Accountability Deficit
71
within states, and to compensate to some extent for the democratic deficit created by any application of the principle of sovereign equality to the lawmaking processes of international organisations (allowing for the representative of a greater diversity of interests and perspectives). Lack of citizen engagement with global politics suggests that members of international assemblies should be (indirectly) elected by national parliaments, although engagement with an international electoral campaign might generate a degree of awareness and ownership by citizens over global policy-making in relation to a limited number of international organisations. The need to ensure that citizens are able to engage in democratic debates around global politics suggests that the application of the parliamentary principle must remain limited to international organisations that restrict membership to democratic states (to allow for citizen engagement with global politics at the domestic level, and free and fair (direct or indirect) elections to the international assembly). The most significant contribution of international assemblies to the democratisation of global society lies, though, in the potential to develop an institutional mechanism to monitor the governance activities of global regulators and provide a locus for informed democratic debate on the appropriateness (or otherwise) of global law norms, taking into account the interests of those represented in the deliberative body. The laws and policies adopted by such a body would not enjoy the same democratic legitimacy of a national Parliament, but the legislative acts of international assemblies would have a claim to epistemic authority, in terms of stating a democratic ‘truth’ developed within an international law order.
THE ACCOUNTABILITY DEFICIT
The practice of democracy at the level of the state is not only concerned with the holding of free and fair elections to a representative assembly. Other aspects include open public debate, transparency, and the accountability of power-wielders to those affected by their actions. The idea of transparency also assumes a relationship of accountability: the transparency of actor A to actor B is the ability of B to receive information from A. It reflects the ability of B to access information, rather than A offering information, and makes clear the relational character of transparency.260 A number of writers contend that the emphasis of reform should be on the accountability deficit in global governance. Gregory Schaffer argues that the normative legitimacy of a decision does not only depend on 260 Alexandru Grigorescu, ‘Transparency of Intergovernmental Organizations: the Roles of Member States, International Bureaucracies and Nongovernmental Organizations’ (2007) 51 International Studies Quarterly 625, 626–27.
Columns Design Ltd
/
Job: Wheatley
/
Division: 01_Thearguments
/Pg. Position: 50 /
Date: 26/3
JOBNAME: Wheatley PAGE: 51 SESS: 3 OUTPUT: Tue May 11 14:32:06 2010
72 The Democratic Deficit in Global Governance whether it has been made by an elected official or assembly. If that were the case, decision-making in a democracy could not be delegated to bureaucracies, courts, or any other body. The legitimacy of a political institution should be evaluated in a broader sense, as concerning the relative accountability of decision-making processes to those affected by them: International institutions should not be judged against some ideal type of national democracy, but in terms as to whether they allocate decision-making authority in a manner that permits for a relatively less-biased representation of affected parties compared to other institutional alternatives.261
A particular concern is the exercise of regulatory authority by groups of experts (technocracy), without the recognition of the need to introduce democratic procedures for the exercise of (legitimate) political authority.
The Role of Experts The phenomenon known as globalisation has created a number of difficulties for the organisation of social, economic and political life that can (seemingly) only be dealt with through global regulation by international organisations and other non-state actors. The relocation of regulatory authority is seen to provide benefits that could not otherwise be achieved. Proponents of global regulatory responses argue that democratic legitimacy should not depend on competitive elections to select power-wielders, but on the establishment of accountable institutions that engage in problem-solving activities in accordance with the public interest. Kal Raustiala observes that international economic institutions may be legitimate, because they are instrumentally useful: ‘if state legitimacy is partly grounded in effectiveness, effective international economic institutions may be legitimate – because they are instrumentally useful – even though they lack accountability in the usual sense’.262 International organisations may make a claim to output-legitimacy, through the positive effects they have for the peoples of the world, even though they lack input-legitimacy, given the absence of citizen participation and control.263 The distinction between ‘output-’ and ‘input-legitimacy’ is made by Fritz Scharpf, who observes that, in a democracy, the exercise of coercive 261 Gregory Shaffer, ‘Parliamentary Oversight of WTO Rule-Making: the Political, Normative, and Practical Contexts’ (2004) 7 Journal of International Economic Law 629, 633–34. 262 Kal Raustiala, ‘Rethinking the Sovereignty Debate in International Economic Law’ (2003) 6 Journal of International Economic Law 841, 862. 263 Hauke Brunkhorst, ‘Globalising Democracy without a State: Weak Public, Strong Public, Global Constitutionalism’ (2002) 31 Millennium: Journal of International Studies 675, 688.
Columns Design Ltd
/
Job: Wheatley
/
Division: 01_Thearguments
/Pg. Position: 51 /
Date: 26/2
JOBNAME: Wheatley PAGE: 52 SESS: 3 OUTPUT: Tue May 11 14:32:06 2010
The Accountability Deficit
73
political authority is legitimised as a manifestation of collective selfdetermination: government by the people (input-orientated legitimisation, often defined in terms of participation and/or consensus) and government for the people (output-orientated legitimisation). Legitimacy cannot be based on input-orientated, ie participatory, notions of democracy alone, given the problem of self-interested majority-rule. Political choices are legitimate only to the extent that they ‘promote the common welfare of the constituency in question’.264 The ‘welfare of all’ must be an argument in the preference function of each citizen. Members of a political community must recognise that they are part of the same community of fate, and have regard to the interests and perspectives of co-members, who must in turn have regard to their interests and perspectives. This requires a degree of trust and solidarity, which, Scharpf argues, is most likely to be present in existing communities of fate, defined by a common sense of history, language, culture and identity. It is (implicitly) an argument that democracy is only possible in the modern ‘Nation’ state.265 The sense of trust and solidarity that endures in the majority of states (excepting those with significant intra-state conflict) does not exist in the case of supranational organisations.266 In relation to the European Union, the lack of a pre-existing sense of collective identity, of Europe-wide policy discourses, and absence of Europe-wide institutional infrastructure to ensure the accountability of power-wielders to a European constituency means that there is no reason to assume solidarity, and no reason to favour direct over representative forms of democracy: citizens may legitimately be represented by states in law-making fora.267
264 Fritz Scharpf, Governing in Europe: Effective and Democratic? (Oxford, Oxford University Press, 1999) 6. 265 ibid at 8. A critique of the veracity of the claim is beyond the scope of this work, although political maps drawn up in 1989, 1939, 1914 or 1871 demonstrate how few ‘Nation’ states have proved enduring. The argument that democratic politics and political self-determination is only possible in the context of the (largely) homogenous nation-state is familiar to persons belonging to minorities and indigenous peoples, as dominant or titular majorities often claim special privileges in the name of national self-determination. The reality (as opposed to the national myth) is that the nation is a political and social construct, the result of the imposition of a homogenised identity through coercion and assimilation. The state is a construct of the modern political world (this is particularly the case outside of Western Europe where political borders largely resulted from the processes of decolonisation, not assertions of national self-determination). It is certainly the case that citizens feel and exhibit strong bonds of trust and solidarity with co-members (ie with other citizens), and that those bonds are (in many cases) stronger in relation to co-members than other relationships in world society. The mistake is to assume that the sense of trust and solidarity flows from the fact that co-members are not ‘others’, ie that they are like us, and not from a commitment to the constitutional order. 266 ibid at 9. 267 ibid at 13.
Columns Design Ltd
/
Job: Wheatley
/
Division: 01_Thearguments
/Pg. Position: 52 /
Date: 26/2
JOBNAME: Wheatley PAGE: 53 SESS: 4 OUTPUT: Tue May 11 14:32:06 2010
74 The Democratic Deficit in Global Governance Democratic self-determination requires a commitment to democratic law-making and democratic politics focused on the welfare of all. Government for the people (‘output-legitimacy’) derives its legitimacy from a capacity to solve problems requiring collective solutions that could not be solved through individual action, market exchange or voluntary cooperation in civil society. It pre-supposes the existence of a constituency connected by the perception of a range of common interests that justifies the institutional arrangements for collective action. There may be ‘multiple, nested or overlapping, collective identities defined by specific classes of problem-solving concerns’. Constituencies need not claim the exclusive, or even primary, loyalty of their members; they may be both territorial and sectoral.268 Government for the people is interest based rather than identity based.269 Legitimacy is provided by legal norms and institutional arrangements that hinder the abuse of public power, and facilitate effective problem solving. This does not imply some form of benevolent global governance, only that ‘all interests should be considered in the definition of the public interests, and that the costs and benefits of measures serving the public interest should be allocated according to plausible norms of distributive justice’.270 Scharpf concludes that government for the people ‘will favour policy choices that can be justified in terms of consensual notions of the public interest’.271 Globalisation has resulted in social, economic and political life becoming both more complex and more uncertain. In conditions of scientific and social complexity, the idea of good governance might suggest that the force of better expert argument (government for the people) developed in terms of consensual notions of the public interest might be preferred to (ill-informed) government by the people. The complex problems of globalisation require technical solutions that only expert deliberations and decision-making can provide. Informed, consensusseeking deliberations in expert committees can be seen as an essential legitimating device for the exercise of political authority by non-state actors. Peter Haas has developed the idea of governance by ‘epistemic communities’. Technological uncertainties and the complexities of global governance have made international policy coordination ‘not only increasingly necessary but also increasingly difficult’.272 This leads to an increasing reliance on networks of policy based experts, or epistemic
268
ibid at 11. ibid at 12. ibid at 13. 271 ibid at 188. 272 Peter Haas, ‘Introduction: Epistemic Communities and International Policy Co-ordination’ (1992) 46 International Organization 1, 1. 269 270
Columns Design Ltd
/
Job: Wheatley
/
Division: 01_Thearguments
/Pg. Position: 53 /
Date: 26/3
JOBNAME: Wheatley PAGE: 54 SESS: 4 OUTPUT: Tue May 11 14:32:06 2010
The Accountability Deficit
75
communities, that both frame problems of global governance and articulate solutions, and play an important role in constructing knowledge and identities in the international system.273 An epistemic community is a network of professionals with recognised expertise in a particular domain, ‘and an authoritative claim to policy relevant knowledge within that domain or issue area’. The professional standing of members of the epistemic community and their reputation for expertise is highly valued by society and political elites, enabling them to influence social and political discourses and policy outcomes. The community will possess a common set of normative principles that provide the rationale for the social action of community members; shared causal beliefs derived from an analysis of the problem; shared notions of validity, ie for validating knowledge in their domain of expertise; and a common policy enterprise to which professional competence is directed, ‘presumable out of the conviction that human welfare will be enhanced as a consequences’.274 One example would be a sub-set of economists with a particular ideological perspective (economists as a whole constitute a ‘profession’).275 The paradigm case in global governance would be those Chicago freemarket economists influenced by Milton Friedman. The move from inter-state politics to a reliance on expert knowledge in global governance, and on knowledge and ‘truths’ constructed by experts, replicates the shift at the domestic level from the democratic state to the so-called administrative state, in which significant aspects of regulatory authority are delegated by representative bodies to administrative agencies. Many policy decisions in a constitutional democracy are made by non-representative institutions, such as bureaucracies, courts and quasi-public bodies that are neither elected by, not directly accountable to, the people. Giandomenico Majone argues that the delegation of policy-making results in better, ‘less political’, policy-making, given that elected governments, with one eye on forthcoming elections, are unlikely to adopt and maintain policies in the face of (short-term) antagonistic public opinion.276 As the government/legislature cannot bind its successors, public policy is always vulnerable to reform, and therefore ‘lack[s] credibility’.277 The relatively short period between elections militates against the government adopting the right policy-position on issues requiring long-term solutions. Delegation to independent institutions allows for credible policy positions to be established that are likely to be
273
ibid at 2. ibid at 3. ibid at 19. 276 Giandomenico Majone, Regulating Europe (London, Routledge, 1996) 41. 277 ibid at 42. See also, Giandomenico Majone, ‘Europe’s “Democratic Deficit”: the Question of Standards’ (1998) 4 European Law Journal 5. 274 275
Columns Design Ltd
/
Job: Wheatley
/
Division: 01_Thearguments
/Pg. Position: 54 /
Date: 26/3
JOBNAME: Wheatley PAGE: 55 SESS: 4 OUTPUT: Tue May 11 14:32:06 2010
76 The Democratic Deficit in Global Governance sustained in the face of hostile public opinion, and may consequently be relied on by (economic) actors. The substantive legitimacy of administrative bodies depends on the ability to deliver ‘good outcomes’ in accordance with relatively precise objectives established by institutions accountable to the people.278 Procedural legitimacy is provided by ‘professional discretion, policy consistency, fairness [and] independence of judgement’.279 The argument suggests that it is possible to make a distinction between ‘political’ issues, which should be decided by the people or their representatives, and ‘administrative’ or ‘non-political’ problems, which should rely on the ability of non-majoritarian institutions to identify the correct policy position by reference to agreed knowledge. (The delegation of interest rate policy to the central bank is the paradigm example.) Politicians decide on political issues, whilst bureaucrats administer technocratic problems. Barnett and Finnemore argue that we should regard international organisations as a form of bureaucracy, an institution that enjoys a distinctive social form of authority based on the ability to make impersonal rules.280 Modern bureaucracies share four central features: a hierarchy of officials within the bureaucracy; continuity of staff and full-time salary structures; impersonality, ie the work is undertaken in accordance with prescribed rules and operating procedures that eliminate arbitrary and political influences; and expertise, in that bureaucrats are selected according to merit and trained for their function.281 Bureaucracies are ‘producers of rules’ that both regulate and constitute the world.282 Authority is the ability to induce deference from others; it is a social construction: ‘It cannot be understood and, indeed, does not exist apart from the social relations that constitute and legitimate it.’283 Whilst authority often concerns the issuing of instructions or commands, international organisations cannot simply assert: ‘Do what we say’. To be effective, they must demonstrate that they ‘serve some valued and legitimate social purpose, and, further, they must be seen to serve that purpose in an impartial and technocratic way using their impersonal rules’. The authority of international organisations lies in their ability to present themselves as ‘not exercising power but instead serving others’.284 The instrumental character of a bureaucracy is ‘its need to serve others’. Rational-legal authority is not sufficient by itself to provide
278
ibid at 294. ibid at 286. 280 Michael Barnett and Martha Finnemore, Rules for the World: International Organizations in Global Politics (Ithaca, Cornell University Press, 2004) at 3. 281 ibid at 17–18. 282 ibid at 18. 283 ibid at 20. 284 ibid at 21. 279
Columns Design Ltd
/
Job: Wheatley
/
Division: 01_Thearguments
/Pg. Position: 55 /
Date: 26/3
JOBNAME: Wheatley PAGE: 56 SESS: 4 OUTPUT: Tue May 11 14:32:06 2010
The Accountability Deficit
77
authority for international organisations (as bureaucracies), they must demonstrate that they ‘serve some social purpose’.285 The authority of international organisations is constituted by the delegation of authority from states; the moral authority of international organisations, ie their claim to represent the values of the international community against ‘self-seeking’ states; and their expert authority.286 The idea of expertise is central to the ability of international organisations to ‘dominate and control’. The argument, in the words of Zygmunt Bauman, is that ‘those who possess [expertise] ought to be in charge of doing things’.287 In conditions of complexity and uncertainty, a ‘community’ of experts can, through rational and reasoned deliberation, establish a particular version of the truth about world society, but that conception of truth cannot claim a universal (or even global) validity (or more accurately, cannot demonstrate such a claim). Epistemology in science (the ‘hardest’ of knowledge disciplines after mathematics) informs us that knowledge is only true for this point in time, until shown to be untrue, or subject to some necessary re-interpretation (consider the ways in which the ‘truths’ of the Newtonian world have adapted to those of Einstein and quantum physicists). In the social world, ‘truths’ are only true to the extent that they are accepted as being true. Truth is always contingent and contestable. In democratic societies, claims to epistemic authority (to be demonstrating a ‘truth’) are subject to the political will of the people and regulation by democratic laws (in accordance with the principles of rationality and public reason). Technocrats can only inform political deliberations; they cannot determine (political) outcomes.288 In conditions of reasonable disagreement and imperfect knowledge there are no ‘non-political’ issues. Regulatory norms must always remain ultimately a question of democratic deliberation (at least in the context of democracy). It is not possible to allocate ultimate responsibility for ‘democratic’ law-making to bodies or communities of experts. Technocracy (government by experts) in global governance is logically incompatible with democracy (government by the people). In domestic settings, public pressure can be brought to bear on non-representative (ie administrative) bodies to ensure that they remain
285
ibid at 22. ibid at 22–25. 287 Zygmunt Bauman, Modernity and the Holocaust (Ithaca, Cornell University Press, 2000) 196, quoted ibid at 165. 288 Where an epistemic community of scientific experts demonstrate a (scientific) ‘truth’ (consider the example of global warming), the failure of global and domestic regulators to recognise and respond to that ‘truth’ (in the absence of other compelling truth-claims) amounts to a failure of public reason. 286
Columns Design Ltd
/
Job: Wheatley
/
Division: 01_Thearguments
/Pg. Position: 56 /
Date: 26/3
JOBNAME: Wheatley PAGE: 57 SESS: 4 OUTPUT: Tue May 11 14:32:06 2010
78 The Democratic Deficit in Global Governance broadly responsible and responsive to the people.289 Regulatory norms that are not accepted by a majority are unlikely to be maintained in the face of antagonistic public opinion. Administrative policies are legitimate, not because they are the ‘right’ polities, but because they are the right policies for the particular community. The question as to whether policy positions are ‘right’, ‘just’, or ‘correct’ is ultimately determined by the members of the political community. Democratic laws and regulations reflect (in ideal circumstances) an expression of will-formation by the people. Jürgen Habermas observes the tendency to bureaucratisation in the administration of the state and increased role for highly specialised experts removed from the supervision of ‘rationally debating bodies’.290 Administrative law is, however, a lesser, less legitimate, form of law that is subject to democratically enacted law and the priority of laws legitimated in democratic procedures: ‘administrative power may not be used to intervene in, or substitute for, processes of legislation’.291 All laws and regulations in the (democratic) state remain subject to the will of the people, expressed in the constitutional settlement and political laws. Experience in domestic settings suggests that technocratic expertise and compliance with constitutional and political law norms are insufficient in themselves in terms of providing democratic legitimacy for administrative agencies. Increased political legitimacy is achieved through enhanced accountability mechanisms such as judicial review, transparency, and participation rights.292 Further, traditional forms of hierarchical supervision by elected representatives remain of paramount importance in legitimating the exercise of political authority by administrative bodies. Most importantly, domestic administrators are seen to be embedded within a shared legal and political tradition, with the administrative agency exercising government functions for the people, aimed at the welfare of all, ‘and, presumably, a shared commitment to the ultimate national well-being’.293 In the case of supra-national organisations, there
289 Majone argues that procedural legitimacy for domestic regulatory bodies requires that they are created by democratic laws that define the authority and objectives of the agency; that regulators are appointed by, and responsible to, elected officials; that agencies follow clearly defined decision-making procedures, with rights of participation for affected persons; and that decisions are justified, ‘and especially that they are open to judicial review, and are adequately monitored by the political principles’: Giandomenico Majone, ‘Europe’s “Democratic Deficit”: the Question of Standards’ (1998) 4 European Law Journal 5, 20. 290 Jürgen Habermas, The Structural Transformation of the Public Sphere: an Inquiry into a Category of Bourgeois Society, trans by Thomas Burger (Cambridge, Polity Press, 1989) 233. 291 Jürgen Habermas, Between Facts and Norms: Contributions to a Discourse Theory of Law and Democracy, trans by William Rehg (Oxford, Polity, 1996) 173. 292 Peter Lindseth, ‘Democratic Legitimacy and the Administrative Character of Supranationalism: the Example of the European Community’ (1999) 99 Columbia Law Review 628, 646. 293 ibid at 648.
Columns Design Ltd
/
Job: Wheatley
/
Division: 01_Thearguments
/Pg. Position: 57 /
Date: 26/3
JOBNAME: Wheatley PAGE: 58 SESS: 3 OUTPUT: Tue May 11 14:32:06 2010
The Accountability Deficit
79
is no ‘democratically-legitimate hierarchical superior’,294 and no sense that the regulatory activities of the organisation are directed to the well-being of the people of any particular state (in fact the opposite). Peter Lindseth makes the point that all international organisations share a similar telos: to overcome a coordination or collective action problem.295 A supranational administration must balance the sovereign interests of member states against the broader interest of the membership as a whole: ‘In the constitutionalist logic of supranational delegation, the abstract “membership at large” takes on the role of the legitimate political principal in the system, and it is to this abstraction that supranational agents are supposed to owe their loyalty.’ It follows that any presumption in favour of a particular member (or members), ‘even if justified on democratic legitimacy grounds, is “constitutionally” inappropriate’.296 Administrators in international organisations owe their loyalty to the international regime, which seeks to overcome a coordination or collective action problem. By regarding the collective membership as a whole as the political principal, the logic of supranational delegation ignores the absence of a ‘democratically-legitimate political principal capable of expressing or symbolizing the sovereignty of a self-governing people’. What remains is a ‘technocratic body… with an attenuated relationship to the perceived ultimate source of the agency’s normative powers: the participating states severally as representatives of their “sovereign” peoples.’297 The Accountability of International Organisations Accountability is an important aspect of democracy: ‘in a wellfunctioning democracy those who are ultimately responsible for policy should be directly accountable to those who are affected by it’.298 Accountability may be both retrospective and prospective: retrospective elements include reporting requirements and complaints procedures; prospective elements include participation in, and transparency of, decision-making processes that take into account the interests of the various stakeholders.299 The idea of accountability applies both to the unlawful (ultra vires) and illegitimate exercise of political authority 294
ibid at 634–35. ibid at 734. 296 ibid at 735. 297 ibid at 736. 298 Eric Posner and Adrian Vermeule, ‘Interring the Nondelegation Doctrine’ (2002) 69 University of Chicago Law Review 1721, 1748. 299 Erika de Wet, ‘Holding International Institutions Accountable: the Complementary Role of Non-Judicial Oversight Mechanisms and Judicial Review’ (2008) 9(11) German Law Journal 1987, 1991. 295
Columns Design Ltd
/
Job: Wheatley
/
Division: 01_Thearguments
/Pg. Position: 58 /
Date: 26/2
JOBNAME: Wheatley PAGE: 59 SESS: 4 OUTPUT: Tue May 11 14:32:06 2010
80 The Democratic Deficit in Global Governance (often expressed in public law terms), and the exercise of authority that is deemed to be (politically) unwise or unjust (with the possibility of political sanctions such as enforced resignations). Grant and Keohane observe that the idea of accountability implies that one or more actors have the right to hold other actors to a set of standards; to judge whether they have fulfilled their responsibilities in light of those standards; and impose sanctions if they determine that these responsibilities have not been met. The idea presupposes the acceptance of roles and a relationship between those who exercise power and those who hold them to account, and of the legitimacy of the operative standards for accountability.300 An accountability relationship is one in which an individual, group or other entity makes demands on an agent to report on their activities, and has the ability to impose costs on the agent.301 Barnett and Finnemore observe that accountability matters because the absence of accountability implies that those with power ‘have the capacity to act without regard for those who authorize their actions and for those whose lives are affected’.302 It is the idea of accountability that separates the exercise of power from domination.303 A report by the International Law Association on Accountability of International Organizations concludes that accountability is linked to the authority and power of an international organisation: ‘Power entails accountability, that is the duty to account for its exercise.’304 The report argues that international organisations should follow the principle of stating reasons for decisions or a particular course of action.305 In terms of standards of accountability, Michael Bothe makes the point that under public international law ‘international organizations are
300 Ruth Grant and Robert Keohane, ‘Accountability and Abuses of Power in World Politics’ (2005) 99 American Political Science Review 29, 29. 301 Robert Keohane, ‘Global Governance and Democratic Accountability’ in David Held and Mathias Koenig-Archibugi (eds), Taming Globalization: Frontiers of Governance (Cambridge, Polity, 2003) 130, 139. 302 Michael Barnett and Martha Finnemore, Rules for the World: International Organizations in Global Politics (Ithaca, Cornell University Press, 2004) 171. 303 ibid at 172. 304 International Law Association, ‘Final Conference Report Berlin: Accountability of International Organizations’ (2004) 5. Available at www.ila-hq.org/en/committees/ index.cfm/cid/9. The Committee distinguished three forms of accountability: accountability for the fulfilment of functions established in constituent instruments; tortious liability for injurious consequences arising out of acts or omissions not involving a breach of any rule of international and/or institutional law; and responsibility arising out of acts or omissions which do constitute a breach of a rule of international and/or institutional law. 305 ibid at 13. In terms of procedural legitimacy, Majone observes that the ‘simplest and most effective way of improving transparency and accountability is to require regulators to give reasons for their decisions. This would in turn activate a number of other mechanisms for controlling regulatory discretion such as judicial review, public participation and debate, peer review, policy analysis to justify regulatory policies and so on’: Giandomenico Majone, Regulating Europe (London, Routledge, 1996) 292.
Columns Design Ltd
/
Job: Wheatley
/
Division: 01_Thearguments
/Pg. Position: 59 /
Date: 26/3
JOBNAME: Wheatley PAGE: 60 SESS: 3 OUTPUT: Tue May 11 14:32:06 2010
The Accountability Deficit
81
sealed off from legal challenges put forward by individuals: no remedy is provided by the organizations, and they are immune from legal process in the courts of states’. To the extent that this is not deemed acceptable, three possibilities emerge: some form of waiver of immunity by the international organisation; arbitration; or some judicial or equivalent institution within the international organisation.306 In addition to the possibility of public remedies, a number of international organisations have established bodies to hold the organisation accountable for the design and implementation of policy. The World Bank Inspection Panel provides a useful model in this respect.307 In the absence of formal mechanisms, most international organisations have introduced informal mechanisms to engage with external actors, including international civil society organisations and those potentially affected by policy decisions. The website of the IMF claims that the organisation ‘is held accountable by multiple stakeholders, including by its own internal watchdog, member governments, the media, civil society, and academia’. The internal watchdog is the Independent Evaluation Office, established in 2001, whose mission ‘is to enhance the learning culture within the IMF, strengthen its external credibility, promote greater understanding of the work of the Fund, and support institutional governance and oversight’. The IMF has also enhanced transparency through engagement with the media, and established an ‘IMF and Civil Society’ webpage.308 An important contribution in the literature has focused on the application of domestic administrative law principles to global governance institutions, developed under the auspices of the Global Administrative Law Project based in the Institute for International Law and Justice, New York University School of Law. Proponents include Nico Krisch and Benedict Kingsbury, who argue for the recognition of a ‘global administrative space’ in which administrative functions are performed ‘in often complex interplays between officials and institutions on different levels’.309 The common administrative nature of the function suggests the 306 Michael Bothe, ‘Security Council’s Targeted Sanctions against Presumed Terrorists: the Need to Comply with Human Rights Standards’ (2008) 6 Journal of International Criminal Justice 541, 542. 307 Daniel Bradlow and Claudio Grossman, ‘Limited Mandates and Intertwined Problems: a New Challenge for the World Bank and the IMF’ (1995) 17 Human Rights Quarterly 411, 431–32. See also Daniel Bradlow and Sabine Schlemer-Schulte, ‘The World Bank’s Inspection Panel: a Constructive Step in the Transformation of the International Legal Order’ (1994) 54 ZaöRV (Heidelberg Journal of International Law) 392; also Daniel Bradlow, ‘Private Complainants and International Organizations: a Comparative Study of the Independent Inspection Mechanisms in International Financial Institutions’ (2005) 36 Georgetown Journal of International Law 403. 308 www.imf.org/external/about/govaccount.htm (last visited 12 March 2009). 309 Nico Krisch and Benedict Kingsbury, ‘Introduction: Global Governance and Global Administrative Law in the International Legal Order’ (2006) 17 European Journal of International Law 1, 1.
Columns Design Ltd
/
Job: Wheatley
/
Division: 01_Thearguments
/Pg. Position: 60 /
Date: 26/2
JOBNAME: Wheatley PAGE: 61 SESS: 3 OUTPUT: Tue May 11 14:32:06 2010
82 The Democratic Deficit in Global Governance possibility of recognising and applying certain common (‘global administrative law’) principles: transparency; opportunities for participation in decision-making processes; access to information; reasoned decisionmaking, including principles of non-discrimination and nonarbitrariness; and mechanisms of accountability, and effective remedies, including the possibility of informal and formal (judicial) review of adopted policies and regulations.310 The idea of global administrative law is concerned with the mechanisms, principles and practices that promote the accountability of global administrative bodies, and the extent to which a global governance actor is required to account to others for the exercise of authority. The idea of accountability includes both formal and informal mechanisms.311 Krisch accepts that the Global Administrative Law ‘project’ emphasises a liberal (or even libertarian) idea of the rule of law: Focusing on the accountability (and thus largely on constraints) of existing institutions may overemphasise the threat these institutions pose at the expense of more positive, liberal or republican visions that see them as forms and fora for realizing self-government or non-domination.312
In a democracy, the key accountability relationships are between citizens and the holders of public office, both elected and appointed. Citizens are entitled to hold those in power to account, ‘either as the source of that power (the delegation model), or as the body of persons affected by it (the participation model), or both’. Deficits in performance may lead to apologies, resignations, the payment of compensation, or the closure of the institution.313 The ability to sanction those in power for poor performance provides ‘a powerful incentive for responsible and, more importantly, responsive decision-making’. Decision-makers ‘have an incentive to respond effectively to the needs of the populace if they know they can be criticized and sanctioned by citizens’.314 The concept of accountability has expanded in recent times to include a sense of individual responsibility and concern for the public interest expected from public services; the institutional checks and balances by which democratic states seek to control the actions of the government, including both formal institutional mechanisms and informal ones; the linking of accountability with the 310 ibid at 2. See, also, Doreen Lustig and Benedict Kingsbury, ‘Displacement and Relocation from Protected Areas: International Law Perspectives on Rights, Risks and Resistance’ (2006) 4 Conservation and Society 404, 413. 311 Nico Krisch, ‘Global Administrative Law and the Constitutional Ambition’ LSE Legal Studies Working Paper No. 10/2009 (SSRN) (2009) 12. 312 ibid at 16. 313 Jan Aart Scholte, ‘Civil Society and Democratically Accountable Global Governance’ (2004) 39 Government and Opposition 211, 211. 314 Molly Beutz, ‘Functional Democracy: Responding to the Failures of Accountability’ (2003) 44 Harvard International Law Journal 387, 402.
Columns Design Ltd
/
Job: Wheatley
/
Division: 01_Thearguments
/Pg. Position: 61 /
Date: 26/2
JOBNAME: Wheatley PAGE: 62 SESS: 4 OUTPUT: Tue May 11 14:32:06 2010
Global Discourses: the Role of International Civil Society
83
extent to which governments pursue the wishes or needs of their citizens (accountability as ‘responsiveness’); and the idea of accountability as public discussions between citizens.315 Increasingly, accountability is seen as a dialogical activity, requiring officials to ‘answer, explain and justify, while those holding them to account engage in questioning, assessing and criticising’.316 The simplest method of improving accountability is to require an institution to demonstrate that it has taken into account the impact of decisions on those affected by them, and to provide public justification for all policy positions. The distinction between government for the people and government by the people is important in highlighting the need for democratic politics to take into account the welfare of all those subject to the law. Where it is not meaningful to speak about input-legitimacy (participatory notions of government by the people), the requirement remains for regulators to demonstrate that the welfare of all is the principal focus in the formation of policy. The contributions of expert opinion (validated within the relevant profession) is essential in developing effective policy, but in conditions of complexity, uncertainty and disagreement amongst reasonable persons, ‘right’ policy must be determined through democratic practices. Democratic laws and the idea of political justice remained tied to some concept of ‘community’ (or ‘demos’). Whilst we might accept their instrumental value in resolving problems of coordination and collective action problems, it is not meaningful to refer to the democratic legitimacy of global regulation by technocracies exercising governance functions for the people. The instrumental value of accountability lies in its ability to promote the development of better policy outcomes. The development of a global politics of the welfare of ‘all subjected’, transparent and participatory methods of policy-making, and mechanisms for the sanctioning of poor performance by global regulators do not provide democratic legitimacy for the exercise of political authority through (international) law, but they should provide for better policy outcomes.
GLOBAL DISCOURSES: THE ROLE OF INTERNATIONAL CIVIL SOCIETY
One of the central criticisms of globalisation and global governance is that it operates in the shadow of a hegemonic discourse, a liberal
315 Richard Mulgan, ‘“Accountability”: an Ever-Expanding Concept’ (2000) 78 Public Administration 555, 556. 316 ibid at 569.
Columns Design Ltd
/
Job: Wheatley
/
Division: 01_Thearguments
/Pg. Position: 62 /
Date: 26/3
JOBNAME: Wheatley PAGE: 63 SESS: 4 OUTPUT: Tue May 11 14:32:06 2010
84 The Democratic Deficit in Global Governance ideology of free trade and free markets (‘globalism’),317 and (less critically) respect for liberal human rights norms. Opposing voices are regarded as being somehow backward, deviant, or unenlightened. The democratic deficit is not the result of an absence of elections, but a lack of contestation around and about the dominant discourse, and its implications for policy-making by international organisations. Michael Goodhart observes, for example, that one of the greatest failures of Western democratic thinking about globalisation ‘has been its inability (or unwillingness) to address the rather awkward problem of inequalities in the global distribution of and entitlement to wealth and social justice’.318 The point is clear when one contrasts the ‘difference principle’ in Rawls’ original position (that all social primary goods, liberty and opportunity, wealth, etc, should be distributed equally, unless an unequal distribution is to the advantage of the least favoured), with the absence of any principle of distributive justice in the second original position imagined in The Law of Peoples. Institutional reform of the UN (the introduction of a World Parliament, for example) would not change the way that global elites think about the issue of global poverty. Margaret Moore argues that the democratisation of global governance requires the opening of spaces for political contestation in which international non-governmental organisations and other voices can provide a counterweight to the position of international institutions.319 According to John Dryzek, the ‘real power of transnational civil society… is communicative power’, ie the ability to ‘change the terms of discourse’.320 To the extent that global law norms reflect dominant discourses, the possibility arises for international NGOs and other civil society actors to influence international law by influencing the terms of the discourse.321 A notable contribution was the campaign for the introduction of the Convention on the Prohibition of the Use, Stockpiling, Production and Transfer of Anti-Personnel Mines and on their Destruction.322 The World Bank has
317 Ulrich Beck, What is Globalization? (Cambridge, Cambridge University Press, 2000). See also Michael Haardt and Antonio Negri, Empire (Cambridge, Massachusetts, Harvard University Press, 2000). 318 Michael Goodhart, ‘Democracy, Globalization, and the Problem of the State’ (2001) 33 Polity 527, 541. 319 Margaret Moore, ‘Globalization and Democratization: Institutional Design for Global Institutions’ (2006) 37 Journal of Social Philosophy 21, 21. 320 John Dryzek, ‘Transnational Democracy’ (1999) 7 Journal of Political Philosophy 30, 45. 321 Whilst the formal sources of international law do not provide any role for civil society actors operating in the global public sphere, Judge van den Wyngaert has concluded that ‘the opinion of civil society… cannot be completely discounted in the formation of customary international law today’: Dissenting Opinion of Judge Van Den Wyngaert, Arrest Warrant of 11 April 2000 (Democratic Republic of the Congo v Belgium) [2002] ICJ Rep 137 155 (emphasis in original). 322 Convention on the Prohibition of the Use, Stockpiling, Production and Transfer of Anti-Personnel Mines and on their Destruction 2056 UNTS 211.
Columns Design Ltd
/
Job: Wheatley
/
Division: 01_Thearguments
/Pg. Position: 63 /
Date: 26/3
JOBNAME: Wheatley PAGE: 64 SESS: 4 OUTPUT: Tue May 11 14:32:06 2010
Global Discourses: the Role of International Civil Society
85
acknowledged the increasing influence of civil society actors in shaping global policy in areas such as land mines, debt cancellation and environmental protection. The Bank uses the term civil society to refer to ‘the wide array of non-governmental and not-for-profit organizations that have a presence in public life, expressing the interests and values of their members or others, based on ethical, cultural, political, scientific, religious or philanthropic considerations’. These include international NGOs, trades unions, indigenous groups, charitable organisations, faithbased organisations, professional associations, and others.323 Jan Aart Scholte observes that civil society engagement of ‘is now part of the daily fare of [global] politics.’324 Each UN global summit, at Beijing, Cairo, Johannesburg, etc, has included a parallel civil society forum,325 and most international organisations have devised mechanisms to engage with civil society actors, often through elaborate websites. International NGOs and other civil society actors may contribute to accountable global governance in a number of ways: they can encourage and enable transparency, in particular effective transparency, making sure that information is understood by those affected by global governance activities; they can participate in policy monitoring and review, undertaking ‘watchdog and evaluation activities’ to ensure that international institutions are complying with their constitutive instruments and stated policy positions; and can assist those who suffer the deleterious consequences of global governance activities in seeking redress, and consequently in establishing formal accountability mechanisms for monitoring and control.326 The participation of international nongovernmental organisations and other civil society actors is also an important element in any attempt to ‘democratise’ global governance, as they can both inform democratic debates, and link international institutions to public deliberation, in particular with affected and marginalised individuals and communities. Increasingly it is argued that the focus for the democratisation of global governance should be on the role of non-state actors, and that international NGOs should have a greater say in international law-making in order to make ‘transnational governance more legitimate’.327 The argument does not hold: the participation of international NGOs does not
323
www.worldbank.org/ Jan Aart Scholte, ‘Civil Society and Democratically Accountable Global Governance’ (2004) 39 Government and Opposition 211, 214. 325 ibid at 215. Richard Falk describes these as ‘experiments in global democracy and as the birthing of global civil society’: Richard Falk, ‘What Comes after Westphalia: the Democratic Challenge’ (2007) 13 Widener Law Review 243, 250. 326 ibid at 218–21. 327 Oren Perez, ‘Normative Creativity and Global Legal Pluralism: Reflections on the Democratic Critique of Transnational Law’ (2003) 10 Indiana Journal of Global Legal Studies 324
Columns Design Ltd
/
Job: Wheatley
/
Division: 01_Thearguments
/Pg. Position: 64 /
Date: 26/3
JOBNAME: Wheatley PAGE: 65 SESS: 4 OUTPUT: Tue May 11 14:32:06 2010
86 The Democratic Deficit in Global Governance legitimate the exercise of global regulatory functions. First, it is not necessarily the case that international NGOs are legitimate actors.328 Secondly, international NGOs are required to undertake a function (in legitimating the exercise of political authority) for which they were not constituted. The aim of civil society actors is to influence debate. They are often ‘single-issue political agents’, not required to ‘see how the issues that they militate for fit into a broader policy agenda.’329 Thirdly, international NGOs must demonstrate a moral claim of a right to participate in global democratic politics. In domestic contexts, citizens have inherent rights of political participation, with NGOs representing the views and interests of citizens. It is not clear whom international NGOs and civil society actors ‘represent’, as opposed to claim to represent, as they are often not connected in any meaningful way to those persons whose interests they seek to advance. In many cases, international NGOs represent the perspectives, if not necessarily the interests, of one part of the global population: the middle classes of democratic states in Europe and North America.330 The inclusion of other voices in global governance discourses is an important element in better, more inclusive decisionmaking processes, but it cannot be taken as authorising, or legitimating, the exercise of political authority by international organisations, or regarded as an expression of the will of the people(s) of the world, given the structural inequalities of power and influence.331 John Dryzek argues that global governance can be subject to democratic control where global publics are able to engage with, and exercise a form of control over, the dominant discourses in world society: ‘Democratic action in the international system is rooted in reflexive control of the prevailing balance of discourses.’332 A discourse involves a set of basic understandings, it is a ‘shared set of assumptions and capabilities embedded in language that enables its adherents to assemble bits of
25, 43. See also Paul Kennedy, The Parliament of Man: the United Nations and the Quest for World Government (London, Allen Lane, 2006) ch 7. 328 The legitimacy of international NGOs is dependent on a number of factors: compliance with legal norms; compliance with an internal constitution and consistency between professed mission (values) and actual behaviour; representativeness, ie the claim to represent (and the consent of the represented); accountability, including appropriate governance structures and ‘downward’ accountability; and performance. The three key aspects emphasised in the literature are accountability, representativeness, and performance: Sarah Lister, ‘NGO Legitimacy: Technical Issue or Social Construct’ (2003) 23 Critique of Anthropology 175, 176–77. 329 Weinstock (n 118) at 17. 330 Kenneth Anderson, ‘The Ottawa Convention Banning Landmines, the Role of International Non-Governmental Organizations and the Idea of International Civil Society’ (2000) 11 European Journal of International Law 91, 117. 331 Anthony McGrew, ‘Models of Transnational Democracy’ in David Held and Anthony McGrew (eds), The Global Transformations Reader, 2nd edn (Cambridge, Polity, 2003) 500, 501. 332 John Dryzek, ‘Transnational Democracy’ (1999) 7 Journal of Political Philosophy 30, 43.
Columns Design Ltd
/
Job: Wheatley
/
Division: 01_Thearguments
/Pg. Position: 65 /
Date: 26/3
JOBNAME: Wheatley PAGE: 66 SESS: 4 OUTPUT: Tue May 11 14:32:06 2010
Global Discourses: the Role of International Civil Society
87
sensory information that come their way into coherent wholes’.333 The exercise of governance functions requires both institutions and rules, and an understanding of the purpose of governance: ‘if formal rules constitute institutional hardware, then discourses constitute institutional software. In the international system, the hardware is not well developed, which means that the software becomes more important still.’334 Extant discourses include market liberalism and human rights. Dryzek refers to the idea of ‘transnational discursive democracy’, one that rests on the idea that ‘discourses and their interactions are consequential in producing international outcomes through their influence upon and constitution of actors. The democratic question then becomes how dispersed, critical, and competent influence can be established’. The idea of transnational democracy is not institutionalised in formal organisations and does not rely on electoral processes: ‘it is to be found in communicatively competent, decentralized control over the content and relative weight of globally consequential discourses, which in turn resonates with theories of deliberative democracy stressing communicative action in the public sphere’.335 The idea of a discourse provides a way of thinking about the world and making sense of different situations, providing the basic terms for ‘analysis, debate, agreement, and disagreement’. Discourses construct meaning and delimit what counts as legitimate knowledge.336 The idea of discursive democracy at the transnational level allows discourses to be influenced by the ‘reflective choices of human agents’.337 The democratisation of global governance does not depend on the existence of democratic institutions, but the ability of critical citizens to engage in reasoned deliberations in an attempt to persuade others. For many, Dryzek’s argument may appear too amorphous to satisfy the need for dominant and powerful international organisations to be brought under some form of accountability and democratic control. Arguments around the power of communicative action are perhaps more effectively addressed in the context of a specific organisation. Oren Perez makes this argument, drawing on the concept of ‘creativity’, which is distinguished from ‘dullness (or uniformity)’.338 There are two aspects of creativity: the possession of a flexible representational framework, ie the ability to perceive an issue through several different perspectives, and
333
ibid at 34. ibid at 35. 335 John Dryzek, ‘Transnational Democracy in an Insecure World’ (2006) 27 International Political Science Review 101, 102. 336 ibid at 104. 337 ibid at 105. 338 Oren Perez, ‘Normative Creativity and Global Legal Pluralism: Reflections on the Democratic Critique of Transnational Law’ (2003) 10 Indiana Journal of Global Legal Studies 25, 55. 334
Columns Design Ltd
/
Job: Wheatley
/
Division: 01_Thearguments
/Pg. Position: 66 /
Date: 26/3
JOBNAME: Wheatley PAGE: 67 SESS: 4 OUTPUT: Tue May 11 14:32:06 2010
88 The Democratic Deficit in Global Governance the ability of a meaning system to break out of loops of all sorts. That is, the capacity of a “thinking system” to observe itself, to identify different patterns in its activities, and to be able to cut short those patterns which become repetitive, obsolete, or just uninteresting.339
In relation to a legal institution, the idea of creativity refers to the capacity to produce varied images of the same issue and possibility for the institution ‘to reinvent itself in a non-repetitive way’. One of the virtues of a creative transformation ‘is that it defies domination and exclusion. While it cannot guarantee that one’s voice will be heard, much less accepted, it can ensure that the law is not dominated by a single voice.’340 Reference to the idea of creativity may be used as a measure for evaluating the legitimacy of legal structures, with attempts to democratise international law ‘reinterpreted as an effort to ensure the creativity of transnational law’.341 In the context of the World Trade Organization, for example, the role of international NGOs is not to ‘augment the WTO democratic profile, but, rather, to build up its creativity by exposing it to a variety of cognitive and normative standpoints.’ NGOs with different political or philosophical agendas must be allowed to participate, and their arguments must receive a fair hearing.342 The legitimising power of the procedural mechanisms of inclusion ‘depends, ultimately, on their capacity to challenge the habitual patterns of the domains in which they operate’.343 Political legitimacy for the exercise of global regulatory functions can be seen in terms of an international organisation adopting the right policy in conditions in which it can be challenged (and challenges itself) to justify and reflect upon policy choices. Buchanan and Keohane argue that legitimate global governance institutions should possess three epistemic virtues: the ability to generate reliable information about coordination points; transparency in the narrow sense, because accountability is required to determine whether they are performing current functions efficiently and effectively; and transparency in the broad sense, understood in terms of providing sufficient information to permit inclusive, informed contestation of their current terms of accountability, and consequently accepting the possibility of revising the terms of accountability.344 The focus should be on the ‘epistemic-deliberative quality of the institution’, the extent to which it is able to provide the ‘information needed for grappling with normative disagreement and uncertainty 339
ibid at 56. ibid at 57. 341 ibid at 60. 342 ibid at 61. 343 ibid at 64. 344 Allen Buchanan and Robert Keohane, ‘The Legitimacy of Global Governance Institutions’ (2006) 20 Ethics and International Affairs 405, 429. 340
Columns Design Ltd
/
Job: Wheatley
/
Division: 01_Thearguments
/Pg. Position: 67 /
Date: 26/3
JOBNAME: Wheatley PAGE: 68 SESS: 4 OUTPUT: Tue May 11 14:32:06 2010
Conclusion 89 concerning its proper functions’.345 There is a need for international governance actors to ‘offer public justifications of at least the more controversial and consequential institutional policies and . . . facilitate timely critical responses to them’.346 Public justification allows global publics to engage with decision-making processes, make a judgement as to whether the decision-maker has sought to act in the global public interest, and engage critically with the substantive rationale for decisions. Buchanan and Keohane identify a ‘complex standard of legitimacy’: international organisations should enjoy the ongoing consent of democratic states; should satisfy the substantive criteria of minimum moral acceptability, comparative benefit and institutional integrity; and should possess the epistemic virtues needed to make credible judgements about whether the three substantive criteria (minimal moral acceptability, comparative benefit, and institutional integrity) are satisfied, and ensure ongoing contestation about and critical revision of the goals of the institution, the terms of accountability, ‘and ultimately their role in a division of labor for the pursuit of global justice, through their interaction with effective external epistemic agents’.347 CONCLUSION
This chapter began by highlighting the different ways in which the idea of a democratic deficit has been expressed in the literature: the deficit that citizens experience through the activities of global regulators; the deficit that results in any move away from the principle of sovereign equality; and deficit that results from the exercise of global governance functions in accordance with a dominant (liberal) ideology. The complaints share an acceptance that (state) sovereignty is no longer the exclusive basis for the allocation of political authority, although there is no agreement on a single meta-principle of authority to replace the Westphalian settlement. There are, as Neil Walker observes, ‘various contending global metaprinciples of legal authority’.348 Each has both a ‘strong and exclusive application’ and a ‘moderate and contributory application’. There is the absolutist model that calls for the reaffirmation of state sovereignty and a return to anarchy in international relations, and a version of liberal internationalism, reflected in The Law of Peoples; there are arguments for recognising vertical frameworks of authority, the establishment of a world government in the strong version, and, in the moderate version, 345
ibid at 425–26 (emphasis in original). ibid at 428. 347 ibid at 431–32. 348 Neil Walker, ‘Beyond Boundary Disputes and Basic Grids: Mapping the Global Disorder of Normative Orders’ (2008) 6 International Journal of Constitutional Law 373, 386. 346
Columns Design Ltd
/
Job: Wheatley
/
Division: 01_Thearguments
/Pg. Position: 68 /
Date: 26/3
JOBNAME: Wheatley PAGE: 69 SESS: 3 OUTPUT: Tue May 11 14:32:06 2010
90 The Democratic Deficit in Global Governance structures with some cosmopolitan norms and institutions; arguments for accepting the establishment of regional government and a divided world order, or some balance between regional conceptions of the international order; for recognising horizontal frameworks of authority, seeking to achieve integrity and the universalisability of norms across legal orders, or, in the moderate version, some coherence in conflict norms or ‘legal-field discursive’ ideas around international constitutional law or global administrative law, which in the strong version would recognise a particular legal field as providing the ‘master discourse of law’. Finally, there is the pluralist meta-principle, which recognises a ‘new anarchy of legal forms and relations’, or a ‘bottom up’ countervailing power model. Whilst the strong versions of each of the metaprinciples of authority are mutually incompatible, the moderate versions are not: what we see in their development is ‘either a degree of modesty of ambition and an awareness that they cannot provide a comprehensive metaprinciple or a degree of developmental openness to the other metaprinciples’.349 Arguments for the democratisation of world society demonstrate an acceptance that globalisation (including the globalisation of governance) has resulted in a loss for democracy, but no consensus on the nature of the loss, or necessary solution to the problématique of democracy following the globalisation and fragmentation of governance functions. The project of popular self-government appears more complex, with no possibility of returning to the Westphalian status quo ante, but no agreement on whether popular self-government is possible following the collapse of the Westphalian settlement, or what it might look like. There is no prospect of a global state, democratic or otherwise, and little to be gained in imagining the present system as a global federation. Nor can law be seen in terms of a binary divide between state and inter-state (public international) law; the democratisation of global governance cannot be achieved through the establishment of a peaceful confederation of democratic states. The globalisation and fragmentation of regulatory functions has resulted in a condition in which states, international organisations and other non-state actors assert political authority without any organising constitutional framework or organising principles.350 The anarchic system of inter-state relations has been replaced by a system of (international) public law, in which international organisations claim to
349
ibid at 391–92. Phillip Cerny refers to the ‘neo-medieval’, ie pre-Westphalian, nature of the modern global governance, with its competing institutions with overlapping jurisdictions, contested legal boundaries, and multiple and fragmented loyalties: Phillip Cerny, ‘Globalization and the Erosion of Democracy’ (1999) 36 European Journal of Political Research 1, 21. 350
Columns Design Ltd
/
Job: Wheatley
/
Division: 01_Thearguments
/Pg. Position: 69 /
Date: 26/2
JOBNAME: Wheatley PAGE: 70 SESS: 3 OUTPUT: Tue May 11 14:32:06 2010
Conclusion 91 stand in hierarchical relationship with the ‘sovereign’ state. The development has occurred at both the global level, with the exercise of regulatory authority by the UN, the World Trade Organization, IMF/World Bank, etc, and at the regional level (North American Free Trade Agreement, European Union, African Union, Association of Southeast Asian Nations, etc). Governance has globalised and fragmented, with states accepting the need for highly focused cooperation and coordination efforts in various sectors of global society. Some of this sectoral regulation is undertaken by formally constituted international organisations, such as the International Whaling Commission, established by the International Convention for the Regulation of Whaling 1946,351 but there is also a role for non-state actors such as the Internet Corporation for Assigned Names and Numbers (ICANN), a not-for-profit private California company formed at the behest of the Government of the United States to control internet domain name policy. The validity of international law is no longer a question of sovereign will and we cannot be certain that all forms of global law will be under the democratic control of citizens, or that power-wielders will be accountable to citizens, either indirectly through the participation of states in international organisations, or through direct lines of accountability between non-state actors and those affected by their regulatory activities. Any account of the democratisation of global governance must account for both the democratic legitimacy of traditional forms of state and international law, and new forms of global governance by non-state actors — and for the ways in which these legal systems interact with each other. In circumstances in which the idea of politically decidable issues is significantly affected by the processes of globalisation and the globalisation of governance, we need to radically rethink the understanding of democracy and democratic politics, and the authority of international law.
351
International Convention for the Regulation of Whaling 1946 161 UNTS 72.
Columns Design Ltd
/
Job: Wheatley
/
Division: 01_Thearguments
/Pg. Position: 70 /
Date: 26/2
JOBNAME: Wheatley PAGE: 1 SESS: 5 OUTPUT: Tue May 11 14:32:06 2010
2 Democracy Within and Beyond the State
C
OMPLAINTS THAT THERE is a democratic deficit in international law follow the globalisation of governance, and exercise of administrative and legislative functions beyond the state. When, as in the past, the international law system was concerned principally with relations between sovereigns, it made little sense to talk or worry about a democratic deficit; increasingly, however, international law norms regulate aspects of social, economic and political life that were previously within the domaine réservé of states, with little, if any, input from those subject to the norms. The loss of political control at the domestic level, where democratic institutions and practices legitimise the exercise of government power, has not been accompanied by any compensatory moves to democratise international organisations and institutions. From the perspective of domestic societies, the removal of policy issues from the domain of democratic politics creates a deficit in the practice of democracy that is difficult to ignore. International law limits the possibilities of political self-determination with no coherent justification emerging for the relocation of policy-making prerogatives to global institutions. To understand what is lost by any shift in the locus of lawmaking, it is essential to understand what is meant by democracy. A number of models of democracy have been developed in the literature,1 and a variety of possible structures, institutions and processes employed (or proposed) in the practice of democracy. This work adopts the model of deliberative democracy developed by Jürgen Habermas in Between Facts and Norms,2 concluding that, in conditions of uncertainty and disagreement, the democratic legitimacy of laws depends on recognising those subject to the authority of the state law regime (the people) as being (albeit indirectly) the authors of law norms. Whilst noting the importance of competitive elections, the focus of concern is discourse and debate: 1
See David Held, Models of Democracy, 3rd edn (Cambridge, Polity, 2006). Jürgen Habermas, Between Facts and Norms: Contributions to a Discourse Theory of Law and Democracy, trans by William Rehg (Oxford, Polity, 1996). 2
Columns Design Ltd
/
Job: Wheatley
/
Division: 02_Democracy
/Pg. Position: 1 /
Date: 26/3
JOBNAME: Wheatley PAGE: 2 SESS: 5 OUTPUT: Tue May 11 14:32:06 2010
Democracy Within and Beyond the State
93
political truths emerge through processes of deliberation and bargaining (in accordance with the principle of public reason) that lead to a consensus on public policy. Deficiencies in the practice of democracy are evidenced by an absence of participation or lack of public reason. Gunther Teubner explains that Habermas follows a ‘consensus theory of truth, which declares as the criterion of truth the “potential” consensus of all discourse participants’. Epistemic authority is attributed to the ‘communicative community’.3 Each communicative community must work out its own version of political truth. Political truth equates to the consensus that would be arrived at through dialogue in an ideal speech situation, in which positions are accepted as legitimate only where agreed through uncoerced discussions by those affected by the outcomes of the process:4 ‘morality consists of the values by which we legitimately decide to govern our common lives’.5 The aim of deliberations in the ideal speech situation is to arrive at a reasoned consensus that results from the force of the better argument. All those affected (or their representatives) have a right to participate, and each participant has the right to bring issues to the deliberations, and all arguments must be given equal consideration (and subject to the same test of public reason). Under the theory of communicative reason, norms and principles are ‘true’ if they can find recognition in an unconstrained discourse of all those affected by them. Democratic laws result from the legal institutionalisation of discursive procedures of opinion- and will-formation ‘in which the sovereignty of the people assumes a binding character’.6 This leads Habermas to the principle of discourse: ‘D: Just those action norms are valid to which all possible affected persons could agree as participants in rational discourses.’7 Democracy depends on the recognition and application of the principles of discourse, democracy, and (parliamentary) representation: ‘democratic’ laws should have the agreement of
3 Gunther Teubner, ‘How the Law Thinks: Toward a Constructivist Epistemology of Law’ (1989) 23 Law and Society Review 727, 733. 4 Thomas Risse recalls Michel Foucault’s objection to the possibility of an ideal speech situation, ie that ‘power as a social structure resides in the discourse itself. The rules of the discourse prescribe which arguments can be legitimately used by the participants’: Thomas Risse, ‘“Let’s argue!”: Communicative Action in World Politics’ (2000) 54 International Organization 1, 17, relying on Michel Foucault, ‘Politics and the Study of Discourse’ in Graham Burchell, et al (eds), The Foucault Effect: Studies in Governmentality (London, Harvester Wheatsheaf, 1991) 53. Foucault regards discourse as an anonymous, impersonal, intention-free chain of linguistic events. It is social practice, not social structure. ‘The human subject is no longer the author of the discourse. Just the opposite: the discourse produces the human subject as a semantic artifact’: Teubner, ibid at 735. 5 David Dyzenhaus, ‘The Legitimacy of Legality’ (1996) 46 University of Toronto Law Journal 129, 150. See also Edward Rubin, ‘Rethinking Human Rights’ (2003) 9 International Legal Theory 5, 58–59. 6 Habermas (n 2) 104. 7 ibid at 107.
Columns Design Ltd
/
Job: Wheatley
/
Division: 02_Democracy
/Pg. Position: 2 /
Date: 26/3
JOBNAME: Wheatley PAGE: 3 SESS: 4 OUTPUT: Tue May 11 14:32:06 2010
94 Democracy Within and Beyond the State all citizens, and should be adopted by citizens, or their representatives, in an institutionalised process of law-making, which should be discursive in character. In the practice of democracy, the absence of an ideal speech situation and reliance on majority rule explains the basis for (judicial) review, and possibility of challenge to democratic laws consistent with the principle of democracy: laws adopted by majority rule have a contestable quality that precludes any argument that they represent any absolute form of political truth. The proliferation of sites for the making of law norms following the globalisation of governance makes the practice of (deliberative) democracy more complex as the locus for law-making is not only the sovereign state. The democratisation of global law orders (even if possible or desirable) would result in competing versions of democratic truth (consistent with the requirements of deliberative democracy): the democratic state no longer decides all issues that are politically decidable, and there is no one place that we can have reference to in order to establish ‘right’ or ‘just’ norms for domestic societies (or parts thereof). This chapter proceeds as follows: it first establishes the nature of the problem for democracy created by the existence of international law, defining democratic self-determination in terms of the ability of citizens to decide politically decidable issues. The work then defends the deliberative model developed by Jürgen Habermas and elaborates the central requirements for the practice of (deliberative) democracy, emphasising the principle of discourse, distinctive nature of deliberative politics, and requirement for law-making within formal deliberative institutions of a representative character (ie parliaments). A particular focus is the nature of human rights in a democracy, and the recognition that the scope and content of human rights norms is established through domestic democratic processes, leading to a revised understanding of the nature of constitutional review (in terms of democracy promotion). The idea of democratic self-determination is made both more complex and problematic by the emergence of systems of global governance in the absence of a global political community capable of democratic opinion- and willformation. The chapter reviews the more recent attempts by Habermas to make sense of the deliberative ideal given the (partial) globalisation of governance functions.
INTERNATIONAL LAW AND THE DEMOCRATIC DEFICIT
The removal of policy issues from the political control of citizens is a problem for domestic state law systems, but the relevance of democracy to international law is less clear: international law is not legislated by a global state; it does not claim to be an expression of the will of the people
Columns Design Ltd
/
Job: Wheatley
/
Division: 02_Democracy
/Pg. Position: 3 /
Date: 26/3
JOBNAME: Wheatley PAGE: 4 SESS: 4 OUTPUT: Tue May 11 14:32:06 2010
International Law and the Democratic Deficit
95
of the world;8 and no international organisation enjoys a monopoly on the legitimate use of force or ability to coercively enforce international law norms, the traditional claims, following Max Weber, of the modern state. The theory and practice of democracy appears premised on the existence of a bounded political community with defined membership, capacity for democratic self-determination, and ability to coercively enforce agreed law norms. There seems little reason to apply the test of democratic legitimacy that has since the nineteenth century been applied to the state to (public) international law. Democracy, Joseph Weiler writes, ‘does not exist in a vacuum. It is premised on the existence of a polity with members – the demos – by whom and for whom the democratic discourse with its many variants takes place.’9 The ‘no demos, no democracy’ point is well known, but it is not the totality of the argument. Weiler observes that the traditional understanding is that states are in the business of government, whilst international law is concerned with the establishment of ‘a legal matrix for coexistence and community among and of States ensuring order and justice’.10 Different bases for legitimation have been applied to the two systems: at the domestic level, the modern idea of the rule of law required that legal norms result from democratic processes; legitimacy in the international law system rested on the idea of sovereign equality. The binary model was appropriate provided a clear division of responsibilities existed, with domestic law operating within the state and international law applying between states. This is no longer the case. The laws that apply to domestic societies also result from international law-making processes, including those that result in the adoption of international instruments (treaties) and (global) law norms established by international organisations and other non-state actors.
8 One former Secretary-General argues that the opening words of the United Nations (UN) Charter — ‘We the peoples of the United Nations’ — invoke the most fundamental principle of democracy, that of popular sovereignty, rooting the sovereign authority of Member States, and, consequently, the legitimacy of the UN itself, in the will of their peoples. The Charter thus ‘offers a vision of democratic states and democracy among them’: UN Secretary-General, Boutros Boutros-Ghali, ‘Supplement to Reports on Democratization: Agenda for Democratization’ (20 December 1996) UN Doc A/51/761r 1996 para 28. Another UN Secretary-General argues that, as the Charter is written in the name of ‘We the peoples’, it ‘reaffirms the dignity and worth of the human person, respect for human rights and the equal rights of men and women, and a commitment to social progress as measured by better standards of life, in freedom from want and fear alike. Ultimately, then, the UN exists for, and must serve, the needs and hopes of people everywhere’: Kofi Anan, We the Peoples: the Role of the United Nations in the 21st Century (New York, United Nations, 2000) 6. 9 JHH Weiler, ‘Does Europe Need a Constitution? Demos, Telos and the German Maastricht Decision’ (1995) 3 European Law Review 219, 222. 10 JHH Weiler, ‘The Geology of International Law-Governance, Democracy and Legitimacy’ (2004) 64 ZaöRV (Heidelberg Journal of International Law) 547, 547. Weiler observes (ibid) that a dictatorship ‘that followed strictly its internal legal system, would be just that: A dictatorship following legal rules. It would not qualify as a system upholding the Rule of Law.’
Columns Design Ltd
/
Job: Wheatley
/
Division: 02_Democracy
/Pg. Position: 4 /
Date: 26/3
JOBNAME: Wheatley PAGE: 5 SESS: 3 OUTPUT: Tue May 11 14:32:06 2010
96 Democracy Within and Beyond the State Weiler distinguishes three forms of international law or modes of governance: international law as transaction, international law as community, and international law as regulation. The idea of transactional international law has been the predominant form in the past; the paradigm example is the bilateral treaty, although multilateral treaties may equally be seen as expressions of sovereign consent and interest.11 Where international law agreements move beyond executory type contracts, terminated upon completion, to establish ongoing relationships, they also exercise an independent governance function, creating a regime of management.12 Secondly, the idea of international law as community follows from the emergence of international organisations, such as the United Nations (UN) and European Union, which regulate certain ‘common assets’ that may be both spatial and functional (international peace and security, the protection of human rights, etc). These regimes cannot be explained exclusively in terms of expressions of sovereign consent; their defining feature is the existence of a legal community whose objectives and values may be distinct from the objectives of one or more of the members (separately).13 Thirdly, the idea of international law as governance, or ‘[World] Governance without Government’, is reflected in the activities of international organisations and international law instruments (often treaties) that increasingly seek to regulate activities that were hitherto ‘not only within the domain of States but within the domain of the administration within the State’. International law norms may directly replace domestic norms, may inhibit domestic regulatory regimes, or place de facto limits on political self-determination through the adoption of non-binding instruments.14 There is ‘governance, but critically there is no government and no governed’. Where there is governance, Weiler argues, it should be legitimated democratically. The idea of democracy presumes, however, the existence of both demos and institutionalised government: ‘We may define demos and demoi in different ways. But there is no convincing account of democracy without demos. Demos is an ontological requirement of democracy.’15 There is, according to this argument, no possibility of applying the idea (and practice) of democracy in the absence of already existing demos, defined by reference to the sovereign state (or equivalent political unit). There might be other bases of political legitimacy for international law norms (broadly defined), but democracy is not a relevant criterion for evaluating the legitimacy of the regulatory practices and structures of global governance.
11 12 13 14 15
ibid at 553. ibid at 554. ibid at 557. ibid at 559. ibid at 560.
Columns Design Ltd
/
Job: Wheatley
/
Division: 02_Democracy
/Pg. Position: 5 /
Date: 26/2
JOBNAME: Wheatley PAGE: 6 SESS: 4 OUTPUT: Tue May 11 14:32:06 2010
International Law and the Democratic Deficit
97
Michael Goodhart observes that whilst there is no necessary relationship between democracy and the state, many, if not most, writers on democratic theory hold that democracy is probably impossible without the state, and this dependency ‘appears to have firm empirical confirmation: democratic accountability isn’t guaranteed by state sovereignty, but it has only been achieved within the framework of sovereignty’.16 The theory and practice of democracy emerged in the context of the territorial state, which defined and delimited the people: modern democracy is ‘sovereign democracy; it presupposes and builds upon the normative and empirical framework of the Westphalian state’.17 Democratic theory relies on the taken-for-granted relationship between those making the law, the ‘people’ or their representatives, and those subject to the law. The requirement for democratic legitimation for the exercise of political authority followed the emergence of sovereignty as the organising principle of government in the modern world (following the Peace of Westphalia 1648), and the shift from a non-territorial to a territorial basis for the exercise of authority and from a functional differentiation to the consolidation of authority within the state.18 The (‘Westphalian’) sovereign state defined ‘those affected’ as ‘the citizens of an alreadyconstituted political community of fate’. Political institutions within the state are democratically legitimate ‘not because they are representative and give citizens equal influence but because they represent and give equal influence to the right people’. At the level of global governance, the model becomes incoherent, as it is not possible to determine who the ‘right people’ are — there is no ‘taken-for-granted’ connection between those establishing law norms and those affected by them.19 There may, then, outside of the context of the state, and (arguably) highly integrated international regimes such as the European Union, be little to be gained by attempting to develop arguments around the democratic legitimacy (deficit) of international law. Democratic selfdetermination requires a clearly defined ‘self’, a citizenry with the capacity for opinion- and will-formation, and effective (governmental) institutions for the execution of collectively binding decisions. It might be neither possible, nor sensible, to talk about democracy beyond the territorial state, organised in accordance with a political constitution and
16 Michael Goodhart, ‘Democracy, Globalization, and the Problem of the State’ (2001) 33 Polity 527, 542. 17 Michael Goodhart, ‘Europe’s Democratic Deficits through the Looking Glass: the European Union as a Challenge for Democracy’ (2007) 5 Perspectives on Politics 567, 574 (emphasis in original). See also Michael Goodhart, Democracy as Human Rights: Freedom and Equality in the Age of Globalization (New York, Routledge, 2005); and Michael Goodhart, ‘Human Rights and Global Democracy’ (2008) 22(4) Ethics and International Affairs 395. 18 ibid at 572. 19 ibid at 575 (emphasis in original).
Columns Design Ltd
/
Job: Wheatley
/
Division: 02_Democracy
/Pg. Position: 6 /
Date: 26/3
JOBNAME: Wheatley PAGE: 7 SESS: 4 OUTPUT: Tue May 11 14:32:06 2010
98 Democracy Within and Beyond the State taken-for-granted membership. The argument has not prevented complaints that international law and global governance suffers from a democratic deficit, with the move to global law-making having a deleterious impact on the practice of democracy at the level of the state. The existence of autonomous legal orders, not under the political control of states, creates — from the perspective of democratic societies — a problem for the practice of democracy. This is the starting point for any enquiry into the democratic legitimacy of international law.
POLITICALLY DECIDABLE ISSUES
This work follows Frank Michelman in regarding democracy as a system of ‘popular political self-government’. Democracy requires that citizens ‘ought to decide for themselves all the politically decidable matters about which they have a good moral and material reason to care’.20 The importance of democracy lies in the ability of people to govern themselves politically as ‘[one] aspect of human dignity and freedom that is sometimes called positive liberty’.21 Democracy serves self-government by providing each person ‘with reason to identify his or her political agency with the lawmaking and other acts of political institutions, or to claim such acts as his or her own’. The democratic ideal applies to a collection of autonomous human persons taken severally, and not the political community as a whole, and there is no reason to conclude ‘that a nation, a people, or a political community [has] a capacity for consciously self-directive agency for which we have any final, moral reason to care’.22 A self-government conception must rely on a procedural understanding of democracy and democratic legitimacy (it is not concerned with substantive outcomes): ‘democracy is at its fullest when a country’s people decide for themselves, by democratic political procedures, all of those conditions of their lives that are politically decidable’.23 The idea applies equally to the (constitutional) laws of law-making that frame the exercise of democratic politics.24 There is a deficit in the practice of the democracy where the 20 Frank Michelman, ‘The 1996–97 Brennan Center Symposium Lecture’ (1998) Californian Law Review 399, 400. 21 ibid at 402. 22 ibid at 403. 23 ibid at 412 (emphasis added). 24 ibid at 413. Martin Loughlin observes that modern constitutions are not simply devices that impose restraints on the exercise of authority; they are ways of organising and generating power and thereby conferring authority. The idea of constitutive power also enables us to acknowledge the fact that the institutional framework of authority is conditional – ‘Constituted power always remains subject to political pressures for change’: Martin Loughlin, The Idea of Public Law (Oxford, Oxford University Press, 2003) 162.
Columns Design Ltd
/
Job: Wheatley
/
Division: 02_Democracy
/Pg. Position: 7 /
Date: 26/3
JOBNAME: Wheatley PAGE: 8 SESS: 4 OUTPUT: Tue May 11 14:32:06 2010
Politically Decidable Issues
99
people do not decide, by democratic political procedures, all of those conditions of their lives that are politically decidable. The commitment to democracy follows the liberal concern around the problem of coercive enforcement of political authority against free and equal persons. The coercive enforcement of law norms is acceptable ‘only insofar as everyone subject to it has his own reasons for agreeing to its basic terms, including its laws of lawmaking’. In order for laws to be legitimate, they must respond to reasons that are ‘objectively consonant with everyone’s interests or that are in accord with what everyone, being reasonable, would agree to in a proper normative discourse’.25 The solution to the problem of political legitimacy is provided by democratic procedures in which reasonable citizens can collectively pursue a political project of self-government ‘for which there can be no final end, but for which there is nevertheless a foundational standard. The democratic pursuit of democratic justice would be that project’. The pursuit of democratic justice requires that decisions that cannot be reached by consensus ‘are nevertheless reached by institutions that are always effectively subjected to the pressures of a public-opinion-in-formation that is bent on democratizing itself and the legal and social conditions of its production’.26 In a democratic system of government, all constitutional and political law norms are subject to contestation and challenge by reasonable citizens (those who accept that law norms should apply generally, and that the welfare of all should be the basis of political discourses). In a democratic state, the constitution (written or unwritten) establishes political procedures through which citizens exercise the right to democratic selfdetermination. Law results from a process of collective decision-making in accordance with the principle of political equality of citizens. The exercise of coercive political authority is legitimated by an act of collective willformation by citizens (but not others). Policies are ‘just’, ‘correct’, or ‘right’ to the extent that they are consistent with the requirements of right process and substantive democratic principles, concerning, for example, political equality and public reason. The importance of procedure is confirmed by the facts of reasonable disagreement and imperfect knowledge in political discussions (there are no ‘right’ answers in a modern/post-modern context); the importance of private autonomy and public participation for the individual citizen; the liberal principle of legitimacy, which demands at least hypothetical consent for the exercise of political authority; and the need for members of a political community to commit themselves to a process of collective decision-making that takes into account the interests of others within the community.
25 26
ibid at 420–21. ibid at 424.
Columns Design Ltd
/
Job: Wheatley
/
Division: 02_Democracy
/Pg. Position: 8 /
Date: 26/3
JOBNAME: Wheatley PAGE: 9 SESS: 4 OUTPUT: Tue May 11 14:32:06 2010
100 Democracy Within and Beyond the State A state is democratic to the extent that laws are enacted with the express or implied consent of the people (or their representatives). The idea of democracy rests on the twin principles of political equality and popular sovereignty: citizens participate on the basis of equality in a process of collective will-formation. There are a number of institutional arrangements that can give effect to these principles, although at the level of the state all will rely on free and fair elections to a representative assembly or parliament. Too often, the requirement to hold elections and respect the outcome becomes the sole test of democratic legitimacy, an approach that accords with theories of limited, or thin, democracy. Joseph Schumpeter, for example, concludes that the role of the citizen in a democracy is simply to determine who will hold power: democracy is the rule of the elected politician, with elections regarded as a competitive process in which political parties offer their platforms and attempt to satisfy the largest number of preferences.27 Elections provide one mechanism through which citizens participate in democratic politics, enabling them to express policy preferences and sanction office holders for poor performance by removing them from office. Elections provide the clearest, if not necessarily the most accurate, expression of the popular will, which is also expressed through other forms of political participation, including protest, demonstration, and argumentation in political willformation. The centrality of elections to democratic systems results from their ability to provide a (relatively) clear expression of the will of the people, reflected directly in a majority of votes cast or indirectly through the allocation of a majority of seats in a representative assembly. Elections are central to majoritarian conceptions of democracy, in which legitimacy is provided by free and fair elections, and application of agreed rules for determining the identity of the candidates deemed to have ‘won’ (which is taken as a surrogate for winning the argument). The majoritarian understanding of (domestic) democracy greatly influences debates around the democratic legitimacy of international law. Notwithstanding Robert Dahl’s claim that ‘no one has ever advocated, and no one except its enemies has ever defined democracy to mean, that a majority would or should do anything it felt an impulse to do’,28 complaints of a democratic deficit invariably reflect a majoritarian concept of democracy, mirroring the ‘counter-majoritarian difficulty’ identified by Alexander Bickel in relation to judicial review by domestic courts. In constitutional democracies, a counter-majoritarian difficulty exists where the position of a majority of the ‘here and now’ people is rejected
27 Joseph Schumpeter, Capitalism, Socialism and Democracy, 5th edn (London, Allen and Unwin, 1976) at 284–85. 28 Robert Dahl, A Preface to Democratic Theory (Chicago, University of Chicago Press, 1956) 36.
Columns Design Ltd
/
Job: Wheatley
/
Division: 02_Democracy
/Pg. Position: 9 /
Date: 26/3
JOBNAME: Wheatley PAGE: 10 SESS: 4 OUTPUT: Tue May 11 14:32:06 2010
Politically Decidable Issues
101
by reference to ‘higher’ constitutional law principles, as interpreted by a constitutional court, including constitutional provisions for the protection of human rights.29 In relation to international law, Roger Alford refers directly to an ‘international countermajoritarian difficulty’, which reflects concerns that law-making outside of the state ‘thwarts the will of the people and undermines the values of the prevailing majority’. Moreover, whilst constitutional law norms remain responsive to popular will, the same cannot be said about international law norms, which may not reflect the will of the people of a particular state at a particular time.30 The counter-majoritarian argument relies on an understanding of democratic will-formation that functions by aggregating the votes of citizens (or, in more sophisticated models, preferences, which can also be measured, reflecting the different strengths of individual preferences) to identify where the majority lies on a particular issue, and consequently to determine the policy position that is acceptable to most citizens. When the people decide, they often, but not always, rely on the principle of majority rule.31 The justification for majority rule is that each citizen is the best judge of her own interests (without the need for interactions with others) and that a decision with majority support will realise the interests of the maximum number of citizens.32 Politics is no different from any other market activity, the dominant assumption being one of competition, as political parties advertise their policies and seek as much support as possible from amongst the electorate.33 Majoritarianism is important in the practice of democracy, as there must come a point where the people, or their representatives, will need to make policy choices, and there is only a certain amount of time that can be devoted to discussion of a particular issue. The possibility of not deciding is not available, as this would involve an implicit decision in favour of the status quo. If, following reasoned public debate, a majority determine that A is the right thing to do, the majority principle provides that the conclusion is the most rational and legitimate outcome, although it is not infallible, and the minority will feel that they have the right to return to the issue in the future with the hope of revising the decision.
29 Alexander Bickel, The Least Dangerous Branch: the Supreme Court at the Bar of Politics (Indianapolis, Bobbs-Merrill, 1962) 17. 30 Roger P Alford, ‘Misusing International Sources to Interpret the Constitution’ (2004) 98 American Journal of International Law 57, 59. 31 First-past-the-post (or winner-take-all) parliamentary systems, such as that in the United Kingdom, are designed to ensure minority rule, in that the political party with the greatest support (but not necessarily, and historically rarely, a majority) is entitled to form the government. 32 Julia Black, ‘Procuralizing Regulation: Part I’ (2000) 20 Oxford Journal of Legal Studies 597, 607. 33 Tom Campbell, ‘Legal Positivism and Deliberative Democracy’ in Michael Freeman (ed), 51 Current Legal Problems (1998) 65, 73–76.
Columns Design Ltd
/
Job: Wheatley
/
Division: 02_Democracy
/Pg. Position: 10 /
Date: 26/3
JOBNAME: Wheatley PAGE: 11 SESS: 3 OUTPUT: Tue May 11 14:32:06 2010
102 Democracy Within and Beyond the State Majoritarianism does not, however, define democracy. The etymology of democracy lies in the idea of popular government, or rule by the people, not by a majority at a particular point in time.34 Bellamy and Castiglione describe the idea that majoritarianism is central to democratic theory as ‘both trivial and unfounded’, arising from confusion between ‘people’ and ‘majority’.35 The value of democracy lies in its problemsolving capacities, and the possibility of promoting ‘value pluralism, at least in ideal conditions’. This requires the accommodation of diverse values through consensus-seeking decision-making, and the settlement of disputes in ways that are recognised as fair and legitimate by all those involved.36 Amartya Sen is equally clear: ‘We must not identify democracy with majority rule.’37 Democracy has an intrinsic value, in that political freedom is a part of human freedom, and an instrumental value, in allowing citizens the ability to express their interests and perspectives in decision-making processes, and providing opportunities for citizens to learn from each another, thus allowing the society to formulate its values and priorities.38 Democracy is a system of collective decision-making that provides for popular and institutional deliberation to determine the will of the people. It is an ongoing process of debate, deliberation and choice. Democratic legitimacy for the exercise of political authority through law is not guaranteed by the holding of free and fair elections or seeking to aggregate the votes and/or preferences of citizens, but by a politico-legal system that ensures that laws result from acts of opinion- and willformation by the people in accordance with the principle of public reason.
DELIBERATIVE DEMOCRACY
The central question in democratic politics is ‘What is it that we should do?’ In conditions of uncertainty and disagreement, how do we know what to do, and who should we rely on to determine the (legal) norms that structure social, economic and political life, and by reference to what criteria, and what processes? Epistemology is the theory or science of the method or grounds of knowledge. Epistemic authority concerns the recognition that an actor is in possession of the knowledge of the ‘right’ 34 The Oxford English Dictionary. 2nd edn 1989. OED Online (Oxford, Oxford University Press, 2000). 35 Richard Bellamy and Dario Castiglione, ‘The Uses of Democracy: Reflections on the European Democratic Deficit’ in Erik Eriksen and John Fossum (eds), Democracy in the European Union: Integration through Deliberation? (London, Routledge, 2000) 65, 75–76. 36 ibid at 71. 37 Amartya Sen, ‘Democracy as a Universal Value’ (1999) 10 Journal of Democracy 3, 8. 38 ibid at 9.
Columns Design Ltd
/
Job: Wheatley
/
Division: 02_Democracy
/Pg. Position: 11 /
Date: 26/2
JOBNAME: Wheatley PAGE: 12 SESS: 4 OUTPUT: Tue May 11 14:32:06 2010
Deliberative Democracy
103
or (in politico-legal terms) ‘just’ course of action. X has epistemic authority over Y, if (and only if) it is accepted that X is in a privileged position concerning knowledge of the ‘right’ or ‘just’ course of action. In the modern era, the epistemic authority of law, following Jürgen Habermas, is provided by the consensus of a communicative community that determines political truths on questions of public policy. The legitimacy of law depends on a communicative action: ‘as participants in rational discourses, consociates under law must be able to examine whether a contested norm meets with, or could meet with, the agreement of all those possible affected’.39 The deliberative model of democracy proceeds from a view that no one actor can claim a privileged position in political debates and that legitimate laws result from a process of reasoned communications, the aim of which is to achieve a consensus amongst all participants. Consensus is easier to achieve where the participants share a set of common understandings, or ‘shared, unproblematic beliefs’, a common ‘lifeworld’ that provides shared meanings and identities, and ‘forms both the horizon for speech situations and the source of interpretations’.40 Political arguments about legal norms must be justified in terms that others might accept. Democratic politics is concerned with questions about what is equally good for all. Those seeking to demonstrate the (political) ‘truth’ of positions must rely on reasoned arguments if they are to convince others (the idea of public reason).41 The requirement for reasoned argumentation follows the need to orientate language towards mutual understanding: participants must communicate and attempt to vindicate claims by reference to reasons that others might accept if they are to reach an agreement. When an argument is not accepted by other participants, there is a shift from justification to discourse in search of agreement, with claims and arguments tested through reasoned deliberations. Individuals must rely on arguments supported by reasons in an attempt to convince others, and all participants must accept that their positions may be subject to review and revision. Where consensus is not possible, the relationship shifts again from discourse to bargaining, in which each participant engages in strategic argumentation. Bargaining is permissible to the extent that the process is deliberative (ie rational) and the compromises acceptable in principle to all participants, who may agree for different reasons (in contrast to a discursive consensus).42 Bargaining results in a negotiated
39
Habermas (n 2) at 104. ibid at 22 (emphasis in original). 41 In excluding the perspectives of (apparently) non-reflexive ‘unreasonable’ persons, Habermas limits the perspectives that count. 42 Habermas (n 2) at 108. 40
Columns Design Ltd
/
Job: Wheatley
/
Division: 02_Democracy
/Pg. Position: 12 /
Date: 26/3
JOBNAME: Wheatley PAGE: 13 SESS: 4 OUTPUT: Tue May 11 14:32:06 2010
104 Democracy Within and Beyond the State agreement that balances conflicting interests; whereas a rationally motivated consensus rests on reasons that can convince all the parties in the same way, compromises can be accepted by different parties for different reasons.43 The process of bargaining depends on the willingness of participants to cooperate. A compromise agreement must be more beneficial than no agreement and exclude free-riders and exploited parties (those who contribute more than they gain). All interested parties should have an equal opportunity to exercise influence in the process of bargaining, ‘so that all the affected interests can come into play and have equal chances of prevailing. To the extent that these conditions are met, there are grounds for presuming that negotiated agreements are fair.’44 In the conditions of pluralism that define modern societies, it is neither possible nor acceptable for a legal order to impose any single perspective on all actors. The legitimacy of law rests on the ‘concurring and united will of all’ free and equal citizens.45 The democratic state imagines itself to be an association of free and equal persons; membership depends on the principle of voluntariness.46 The normative basis of a legitimate constitution is provided by a ‘deliberative decision-making process that the founders [established] with the intention of creating a voluntary self-determination association of free and equal citizens.’47 The democratic constitution that frames political life is not fixed. It may be subject to challenge and contestation by citizens; the constitution is a ‘traditionbuilding project with a clearly marked beginning in time’.48 The democratic legitimacy of laws depends on an institutionalisation of the principle of discourse in a constitutional order that recognises the equality of citizens and the voluntariness of the legal order. The law must grant equal liberties to all: the freedom of each citizen must ‘coexist with the freedom of all’.49 For this to be the case, the addressees (‘subjects’) of law norms must at the same time ‘understand themselves, taken as a whole, as the rational authors of those norms’.50 The legal order draws its legitimacy from the idea of collective self-determination: citizens must think of themselves as authors of the law to which they are subject as addressees, ‘and it is only participation in the practice of politically
43
ibid at 166. ibid at 167. 45 ibid at 32. 46 ibid at 497. 47 Jürgen Habermas, ‘Constitutional Democracy: a Paradoxical Union of Contradictory Principles?’ (2001) 29 Political Theory 766, 772. 48 ibid at 775. 49 Habermas (n 2) at 32. 50 ibid at 33 (emphasis in original). 44
Columns Design Ltd
/
Job: Wheatley
/
Division: 02_Democracy
/Pg. Position: 13 /
Date: 26/3
JOBNAME: Wheatley PAGE: 14 SESS: 4 OUTPUT: Tue May 11 14:32:06 2010
Deliberative Democracy
105
autonomous lawmaking that makes it possible for the addressees to have a correct understanding of the legal order as created by themselves’.51 Habermas provides a test of democratic legitimacy that does not rely on substantive values against which to evaluate the acceptability or otherwise of law norms. It follows from the recognition of the equality of citizens and need for justification for the exercise of political authority. The twin ideas of human rights and popular sovereignty that have determined the normative self-understanding of constitutional democracies provide the basis by which to justify modern (state) law.52 Democratic laws result from the legal institutionalisation of discursive procedures of opinion- and will-formation ‘in which the sovereignty of the people assumes a binding character’.53 This leads Habermas to his principle of discourse: ‘D: Just those action norms are valid to which all possibly affected persons could agree as participants in rational discourses.’ The idea of action norms refers to ‘temporally, socially, and substantively generalized behavioural expectations’; the idea of ‘those affected’ includes ‘anyone whose interests are touched by the foreseeable consequences of a general practice regulated by the norms at issue’.54 If all possibly affected persons have participated in deliberations, with an equal opportunity to influence others, any consensus position may be regarded as ‘right’ or ‘just’ for that political community. A distinct principle of democracy follows from an application of the principle of discourse, providing that the validity of statutory law norms relies on the adoption of laws that can meet with the assent of all citizens in a discursive process of legislation that has been legally constituted.55 Brian Tamanaha criticises the reliance on the counterfactual ideal of the agreement of all possibly affected persons, concluding that Habermas ‘does not really mean unanimous consent, or even actual consent’.56 In common with all social contract theories, the aim is to ‘legitimate the status quo of law in liberal democracies under the banner of consent, cleansed of any odour of coercion’.57 In the practice of democracy, consensus will rarely be possible. Carlos Santiago Nino describes deliberative democracy as ‘a process of moral discussion with a time limit’.58
51
ibid at 121 (emphasis in original). ibid at 99. ibid at 104. 54 ibid at 107. 55 ibid at 110. 56 Brian Tamanaha, A General Jurisprudence of Law and Society (Oxford, Oxford University Press, 2001) 64 (emphasis in original). 57 ibid at 65. 58 Carlos Santiago Nino, The Constitution of Deliberative Democracy (New Haven, Connecticut, Yale University Press, 1996) 118. 52 53
Columns Design Ltd
/
Job: Wheatley
/
Division: 02_Democracy
/Pg. Position: 14 /
Date: 26/3
JOBNAME: Wheatley PAGE: 15 SESS: 4 OUTPUT: Tue May 11 14:32:06 2010
106 Democracy Within and Beyond the State Reliance on a counterfactual ideal to evaluate the democratic legitimacy of law raises the possibility that the analysis simply provides intellectual justification for the otherwise problematic exercise of coercive political authority. The value of the deliberative model is that it does not rely on the acceptance of any contested political or moral values, beyond those inherent in the practice of deliberative democracy, providing an ‘objective’ basis for critiquing the exercise of political authority without requirement to demonstrate the ‘wrongness’ or ‘injustice’ of policy positions. The deliberative model allows the development of a (democratic) critique within the discipline of law that evaluates the exercise of regulatory authority through law, without the need to read progressive (natural law-type) values into the concept of law. It also affirms that academic commentators (and other elites) have no privileged position in debates about the practice of democracy, and substantive questions of public policy. The principle of discourse requires that we treat all citizens as equals and that political discussions are conducted in accordance with the principle of public reason, with a view to establishing what is equally good for all.
DELIBERATIVE MAJORITIES
In contrast to majoritarian understandings of democracy, the deliberative model regards the existence of any objecting minority (the absence of consensus) as problematic for those seeking to exercise authority. This is particularly the case in relation to permanent minorities defined by reference to ethno-cultural identity on ‘questions of culture’.59 James Bohman argues for a reformulation of the discourse principle and its insistence on unanimity: ‘it is deliberative majorities who should rule’.60 All citizens should have the opportunity to participate in decisionmaking processes in such a way that they have a reasonable expectation that they might affect its outcome.61 Where, following reasoned deliberations, a majority agree that policy proposal A should be adopted there is 59 In cases of conflict between national authorities and minority groups on ‘questions of culture’, the absence of consensus does not result from a lack of time or insufficiently compelling arguments. Indigenous peoples will not, for example, recognise the economic value of mineral deposits on land they consider to be of spiritual or religious significance. Likewise, minority groups will not freely consent to laws imposed by the ‘democratic’ majority that seek to regulate their religious and cultural practices. See Steven Wheatley, Democracy, Minorities and International Law (Cambridge, Cambridge University Press, 2005); also Steven Wheatley, ‘Minorities under the ECHR and the Construction of a “Democratic Society”’ (2007) Public Law 770. 60 James Bohman, ‘Complexity, Pluralism, and the Constitutional State: on Habermas’s Faktizität und Geltung’ (1994) 28 Law and Society Review 897, 919. 61 ibid at 921.
Columns Design Ltd
/
Job: Wheatley
/
Division: 02_Democracy
/Pg. Position: 15 /
Date: 26/3
JOBNAME: Wheatley PAGE: 16 SESS: 4 OUTPUT: Tue May 11 14:32:06 2010
Deliberative Majorities
107
a presumption that the position is democratically legitimate. It is, however, as Wojciech Sadurski observes, contrary to our intuitions to suggest that any outcome of a democratic system will, by definition, be democratic ‘because we do not have an independent outcome-based notion of democratic legitimacy’.62 Sadurski refers to the impossibility of ‘perfect procedural justice’, concluding that, in the real world, all we can hope for is a system of ‘imperfect procedural justice’.63 An alternative, ‘weak but plausible’, version of the liberal principle of legitimacy, which requires hypothetical consent to confer some degree of legitimacy upon laws, would provide that ‘only those laws that are based upon arguments to which no members of the society have a rational reason to object can boast political legitimacy, and as such be applied coercively’.64 If a law is based on an argument ‘that casts me out from the political community (for example, an argument that considers my racial group as inherently inferior to other groups), then there is no moral reason why I should recognize this law as legitimate’.65 There is no rational argument that could lead an individual to accept such a measure. The fact of disagreement is not in itself sufficient to deny democratic legitimacy: [if] I disagree with the wisdom of a given law, but would agree if I examined it rationally that it is based upon arguments that I can recognize as valid, then a necessary condition for its legitimacy has been met.66
The democratic legitimacy of laws is provided by law norms that a rational person could accept, even if they do not in fact accept the laws in question. For Sadurski, as for Habermas,67 unreasonable objections do not count. But, as Joseph Raz points out, ‘why should the agreement only of those with reasonable views be required?’68 The interests of persons with ‘unreasonable views’, those who ‘stubbornly fail to see what the reasonable see’,69 are just as likely to be affected by the exercise of political authority as those of ‘reasonable’ persons, ‘and if the other people’s agreement is required, so should theirs be’.70 Disagreement is evidence that at least one of the parties is wrong, and the authorities are obliged to
62 Wojciech Sadurski, ‘Law’s Legitimacy and “Democracy-Plus”’ (2006) 26 Oxford Journal of Legal Studies 377, 397. 63 ibid at 396. 64 ibid at 401. 65 ibid at 402. 66 ibid at 402. 67 Habermas (n 2) at 312. See also Jürgen Habermas, ‘Intolerance and Discrimination’ (2003) 1 International Journal of Constitutional Law 2. 68 Joseph Raz, ‘Disagreement in Politics’ (1998) 43 American Journal of Jurisprudence 25, 33. 69 ibid at 34. 70 ibid at 33.
Columns Design Ltd
/
Job: Wheatley
/
Division: 02_Democracy
/Pg. Position: 16 /
Date: 26/3
JOBNAME: Wheatley PAGE: 17 SESS: 4 OUTPUT: Tue May 11 14:32:06 2010
108 Democracy Within and Beyond the State consider whether it is their position. Much will depend on whether disagreement can be assigned to bias or ignorance, or the authorities acting against expert advice, or in circumstances where the life experiences of the minority group ‘are foreign to those in power’.71 The participation and consent of all those who might reasonably be affected is required to establish legitimacy for the exercise of political authority through law, a point Habermas concedes when he writes: ‘deficits [in democratic legitimacy] will always result when the circle of all those involved in democratic decision making does not extend to cover the circle of all those affected by those decisions’.72
DELIBERATIVE POLITICS
The deliberative model is an attempt to construct a politico-legal system from the first principles of autonomy and equality: law is legitimate only if all who are possibly affected could assent as participants in rational discourses. From this, Habermas derives a system of rights and the discursive character of lawmaking, providing (democratic) criteria against which to evaluate the legitimacy of law. The principle of democracy results from an application of the principle of discourse to those action norms that appear in legal form.73 It provides that the validity of statutory norms depends on the adoption of laws that can meet with the assent of all citizens in a discursive process of legislation that has been legally constituted.74 The principle both establishes the requirements for legitimate lawmaking and frames the nature of political debate about legitimate policy it creates the language in which a community can understand itself as a voluntary association of free and equal consociates under law.75 A genuinely proceduralist understanding of democracy is not simply concerned with democratic institutions and rights of political participation: democratic procedures must be ‘institutionalized in discourses and bargaining processes by employing forms of communication that promise that all outcomes reached in conformity with the procedure are reasonable’.76 Democratic politics must be conducted in accordance with the requirements of deliberative democracy: the language of politics must recognise the principle of political equality and importance of private autonomy; the welfare of all must be the central focus in political 71 72
ibid at 51. Jürgen Habermas, ‘Toward a Cosmopolitan Europe’ (2003) 14 Journal of Democracy 86,
90. 73 74 75 76
Habermas (n 2) at 108. ibid at 110. ibid at 111. ibid at 304.
Columns Design Ltd
/
Job: Wheatley
/
Division: 02_Democracy
/Pg. Position: 17 /
Date: 26/3
JOBNAME: Wheatley PAGE: 18 SESS: 4 OUTPUT: Tue May 11 14:32:06 2010
Human Rights in a Democracy
109
discourses; political argument should be conducted in a way that attempts to persuade others by the force of better argument; and all laws, including justice norms (framed in terms of constitutional law norms and human rights) must be determined through democratic politics.
HUMAN RIGHTS IN A DEMOCRACY
One of the major contributions of the theory of deliberative democracy is that it moves us away from the sterile debates that position democracy and (human) rights in an antagonistic relationship (the allegedly unresolved tension of ‘liberal’ ‘democracy’). For Habermas, there can be no democracy without rights and no rights without democracy. Those rights required in a democratic system include the general right to equal liberties, along with the correlative membership rights, and guaranteed legal remedies. Democracy requires the recognition of rights that generate the legal code by defining the status of legal persons, ie rights that result from the politically autonomous elaboration of the right to the greatest possible measure of equal individual liberties. These legal rights require, as necessarily corollaries, the basic rights that result from the politically autonomous elaboration of the status of a member of a voluntary association of consociates under law; in addition to the basic rights that result from the actionability of rights and from the politically autonomous elaboration of individual legal protection. These result from an application of the discourse principle to the medium of law.77 In order for a citizen to be transformed from ‘addressee’ to one of the authors of the legal order, they must also enjoy basic rights to equal opportunities to participate in processes of opinion- and will-formation in which citizens generate legitimate law. Finally, all citizens must have the right to the provision of basic living conditions, insofar as they are necessary for citizens to have equal opportunities to exercise the other legal and democratic rights.78 The (unelaborated) category of ‘social welfare’ rights includes those rights that are necessary insofar as the exercise of civil and political rights depends on certain social and material conditions.79 In contrast to liberal theories that hold rights to be both prior and superior to democratic laws, typically ‘rights as trumps’ over collective positions,80 Habermas regards private and public autonomy as both
77 78 79 80
ibid at 122. ibid at 123. William Rehg, ‘Translator’s Introduction’ in Habermas (n 2) at xxvii. See Ronald Dworkin, Taking Rights Seriously (London, Duckworths, 1977).
Columns Design Ltd
/
Job: Wheatley
/
Division: 02_Democracy
/Pg. Position: 18 /
Date: 26/3
JOBNAME: Wheatley PAGE: 19 SESS: 4 OUTPUT: Tue May 11 14:32:06 2010
110 Democracy Within and Beyond the State ‘co-original’ and ‘internally related’.81 The framework of rights and liberties that structures the social context of human existence is established through a process of political dialogue in accordance with the principle of public reason, with valid laws receiving the assent of all affected citizens. Non-discrimination norms are central to arguments around public reason: any difference of treatment must be capable of rational justification, and if a difference in treatment cannot be rationally justified the measure must be withdrawn, or applied generally, leading to public discussion and democratic debate, and requiring the consent of all in democratic theory (and consent of the majority in the practice of democracy). The rationality of laws is proven, in part, by the ‘equal treatment of legal persons who at the same time are protected in their integrity’. The norms passed by the legislature and applied by the courts ‘prove their “rationality” by the fact that addresses are treated as free and equal members of an association of legal subjects’ (the principle of equal treatment). This includes both the idea of equality before the law, and the broader principle of substantive legal equality, ‘which holds that what is equal in all relevant respects should be treated equally, and what is unequal should be treated unequally. But what counts in each case as the “relevant respect” requires justification.’82 In pluralistic democracies (ie all democracies), the scope and content of human rights norms must be worked out on a case-by-case basis in a collective act of democratic self-determination, the aim of which is to promote the public and private autonomy of equal citizens. Injustices are evidenced in discriminatory laws that prevent persons from vulnerable and marginalised groups from exercising their private and public autonomy.83 Private autonomy is the right to be left alone, to pursue an ‘existential life project’;84 public autonomy concerns the rights of political participation, including the right to decide whether a law is in fact adopted.85 Public and private autonomy are, Dyzenhaus observes, co-original aspects of our basic commitment to each other as free and equal participants in a common life, a commitment which is presupposed by and made possible by the legal order of the democratic Rechtsstaat (the state bound by the rule of law).86
81
Habermas (n 2) at 275. ibid at 414 (emphasis in original). 83 ibid at 419. 84 ibid at 451. 85 ibid at 458. 86 David Dyzenhaus, ‘The Legitimacy of Legality’ (1996) 46 University of Toronto Law Journal 129, 135. 82
Columns Design Ltd
/
Job: Wheatley
/
Division: 02_Democracy
/Pg. Position: 19 /
Date: 26/3
JOBNAME: Wheatley PAGE: 20 SESS: 3 OUTPUT: Tue May 11 14:32:06 2010
Human Rights in a Democracy
111
Human rights have a ‘contestable content in the “unfinished project” which any constitution is’.87 They do not reflect some higher moral value, but the result of political deliberations within a political community. Seyla Benhabib refers to the idea of jurisgenerative politics, involving political and legal contestation in which the meanings of rights are ‘reposited, resignified, and reappropriated by new and excluded groups, or by the citizenry in the face of new challenges’.88 Habermas argues that [h]uman rights are juridical by their very nature. What lends them the appearance of moral rights is not their content, and most especially not their structure, but rather their mode of validity, which points beyond the legal orders of nation-states.
With the exception of the basic rights (outlined above), human rights emerge from processes of democratic will-formation, although all (deliberative) democracies will share similar visions of the ‘just’ society, reflected in the standards recognised in universal human rights instruments, which give expression to the collective experiences of democratic peoples.89 The argument is consistent with the body of international human rights norms that has emerged in the global system. The Universal Declaration of Human Rights, for example, contains a limited number of absolute provisions (prohibitions on slavery (article 4) and torture (article 5), and equal protection under the law (article 7)), and ‘rights’ that may be subject to such limitations as are necessary for protecting the rights and freedoms of others, and ‘meeting the just requirements of morality, public order and the general welfare in a democratic society’.90 International human rights law provides the language with which domestic societies deliberate about the nature and content of (domestic) human rights norms, but international human rights laws are only universal in the sense of framing the social, economic and political questions that all (democratic) societies must address, ie the relationship between private autonomy (individual self-determination) and the rights and interests of others, including the interests of society more generally.
87
ibid at 164. Seyla Benhabib, Another Cosmopolitanism (Oxford, Oxford University Press, 2006) 70. Jürgen Habermas, The Inclusion of the Other: Studies in Political Theory (Cambridge, Massachusetts, MIT Press, 1998) 190. 90 General Assembly (GA) Res 217(III)A ‘Universal Declaration of Human Rights’ (adopted 10 December 1948) art 29(2). 88 89
Columns Design Ltd
/
Job: Wheatley
/
Division: 02_Democracy
/Pg. Position: 20 /
Date: 26/2
JOBNAME: Wheatley PAGE: 21 SESS: 4 OUTPUT: Tue May 11 14:32:06 2010
112 Democracy Within and Beyond the State THE PARLIAMENTARY PRINCIPLE OF DEMOCRACY
The exercise of coercive political authority in a constitutional democracy owes its legitimacy to a democratic process that guarantees the rational treatment of political questions, and (ideally) allows all relevant issues, interest and perspectives to be brought into the processes of democratic discourse and negotiation. Given that it is not possible for all persons to engage in deliberations on all issues, citizens must be represented by others in formal institutions. This leads Habermas to the parliamentary principle, which provides for the establishment of representative bodies for deliberation and decision-making.91 A person is ‘represented’ where the representatives ensure that decision-makers take into account the opinions, interests and perspectives of those affected by lawmaking acts. Representative institutions are a necessary compromise in the practice of democracy, as citizens do not have the time or capacity to acquire the knowledge to participate effectively in all decision-making procedures that affect them. The ideal of representation requires that the selection of members of Parliament should provide for the ‘broadest possible spectrum of interpretive perspectives, including the views and interests of marginal groups’.92 In terms of voting within representative bodies, and other institutions in a constitutional democracy such as courts, majority rule is acceptable in that it ‘retains an internal relation to the search for truth inasmuch as the decision reached by the majority only represents a caesura in an ongoing discussion; the decision records, so to speak, the interim result of a discursive opinion-forming process’.93 Majority decisions do not, though, enjoy the same claim to truth as consensus decisions, and in the practice of democracy, majority decisions are constrained by the basic rights that protect individuals and minorities: ‘in exercising their political autonomy citizens must not violate the system of rights that first constitutes this autonomy’.94 Parliamentary bodies do not provide the sole locus for democratic deliberations in the modern state. The principle of discourse provides a principle of political pluralism both inside and outside of representative bodies; it requires that legislative bodies remain open to interests and perspectives emerging from the public sphere: parliamentary opinionand will-formation ‘must remain anchored in the informal streams of communication emerging from public spheres that are open to all political parties, associations, and citizens’.95 Citizens must enjoy extensive
91 92 93 94 95
Habermas (n 2) at 170. ibid at 183. ibid at 179. ibid at 180. ibid at 171.
Columns Design Ltd
/
Job: Wheatley
/
Division: 02_Democracy
/Pg. Position: 21 /
Date: 26/3
JOBNAME: Wheatley PAGE: 22 SESS: 4 OUTPUT: Tue May 11 14:32:06 2010
Challenging Democratic Truths: the Role of Judicial Review
113
constitutional rights concerning freedom of political expression and association, rights that are universally guaranteed by the requirements of democratic politics. Discourse conducted by representatives can meet the condition of equal participation ‘only if they remain porous, sensitive, and receptive to the suggestions, issues and contributions, information and arguments that flow in from a discursively structured public sphere’.96 It is not majority rule that legitimates democratic forms of decision-making but the processes that precede the decision, both formal, parliamentary-style, processes, and the informal discourses and deliberations in the political public sphere. A robust civil society can only develop in the context of a liberal society, which accepts the possibilities of alternative viewpoints. Civil society actors in the public sphere can acquire influence, but not power. The degree of influence will depend on the extent to which arguments resonate with the public of citizens, which possesses the final authority in a democracy: ‘there can be no public sphere without a public’.97 In order to exercise power, civil society actors must directly influence democratically regulated deliberations in legislative assemblies:98 communications in the public sphere ‘can be converted into political power only if it passes through the sluices of democratic procedures and penetrates the constitutionally organized politics system in general’.99 Whilst the political public sphere provides an arena in which social, economic and political problems can be identified and solutions proposed, effective discourses and bargaining occur only in formal institutions for opinion- and will-formation. The practice of democracy and formal processes of democratic will-formation require the existence of lawmaking institutions (operating in accordance with the principle of public reason) in which those affected can be said to be represented, with deliberative institutions remaining open to the ‘better arguments’ that might emerge in the public sphere.
CHALLENGING DEMOCRATIC TRUTHS: THE ROLE OF JUDICIAL REVIEW
Legitimacy, in the procedural sense, focuses on the deliberative processes within and between institutions, the latter of which provides the rationale for the doctrine of the separation of powers and judicial review by courts. Disagreement between the institutions of government, between the parliament and the constitutional court, or more accurately between 96 97 98 99
ibid ibid ibid ibid
at at at at
182. 364. 371. 327.
Columns Design Ltd
/
Job: Wheatley
/
Division: 02_Democracy
/Pg. Position: 22 /
Date: 26/3
JOBNAME: Wheatley PAGE: 23 SESS: 4 OUTPUT: Tue May 11 14:32:06 2010
114 Democracy Within and Beyond the State the majorities of the members of the respective institutions, will, as Sadurski observes, reflect disagreements in the wider society as to the right answer to a complex political or constitutional question. The fact of judicial review does not usurp democracy, it is simply ‘one step to the constitutionally prescribed procedure that has to be followed in order for the decision to be final and legitimate… The decisions that emerge from such a procedure acquire democratic legitimacy’.100 It is always open to the public or the legislature to re-open a political question, and to (re-)legislate accordingly. Courts do not have the final and constitutionally decisive say. The counterfactual ideal of deliberative democracy suggests the possibility of an objective model of judicial review that evaluates the legitimacy of democratic laws, and that judicial review of constitutional norms should reinforce rather than contravene the processes of democratic will-formation. Habermas follows John Hart Ely in arguing for a ‘participation-orientated, representation-reinforcing approach to judicial review’,101 one that is consistent with the values of representative democracy and involving a task that the courts are qualified to perform. Courts should not intervene where decision-making procedures result in subjectively wrong answers to political questions, but where the political process is ‘systematically malfunctioning’ and ‘undeserving of trust’, where individuals are systematically excluded, or where they are formally included but the representatives of the majority do not take their interests and preferences seriously.102 For Habermas, there is no role for the courts in the process of lawmaking in a (deliberative) democracy,103 an argument that ignores the implicit authority of courts to develop the common law (at least in common law jurisdictions) and augment legislation through (nonpolitical) ‘interpretive’ judgments. The argument might be better expressed in the sense that the legislative process ‘domesticates’ competing policy goals and conflicting values, and courts are not free to re-work this domestication process afresh, ‘as if they were legislators’.104 Popular sovereignty lies with the people and is expressed through the adoption of democratic laws in accordance with the constitution. Where the constitution is regarded as a system of rights in which private and public autonomy are seen as being internally related, the function of the constitutional court (a court concerned with constitutional questions) is
100 Wojciech Sadurski, ‘Law’s Legitimacy and “Democracy-Plus”’ (2006) 26 Oxford Journal of Legal Studies 377, 408. 101 JH Ely, Democracy and Distrust: a Theory of Judicial Review (Cambridge; London, Harvard University Press, 1980) 87. 102 ibid at 103. 103 Habermas (n 2) at 172. 104 Hugh Baxter, ‘Habermas Discourse Theory of Law and Democracy’ (2002) 50 Buffalo Law Review 205, 318.
Columns Design Ltd
/
Job: Wheatley
/
Division: 02_Democracy
/Pg. Position: 23 /
Date: 26/3
JOBNAME: Wheatley PAGE: 24 SESS: 3 OUTPUT: Tue May 11 14:32:06 2010
Deliberative Democracy Beyond the State
115
to be the ‘custodian of deliberative democracy’.105 The judicial role is to ensure that representatives have acted deliberatively and that legislation results from ‘reasons that can be publicly advocated’, and not ‘private interests’.106 Legal adjudication ‘unwraps… the variegated arguments that have already been entered into the lawmaking process and provided a rational basis for the legitimacy claims of established law’.107 The function of judicial review is to ensure the development of effective processes for establishing political truths in a political community within a system of democratic law. To be effective, legal judgments must be acceptable to the interpretive community of judges, lawyers, academics and the wider public. Constitutional review must secure both private and public autonomy, and ‘establish a coherent set of constitutional rights adapted to the particular historical legacy of the polity’.108 The practice of democratic lawmaking and elaboration of constitutional rights through judicial review occurs within the framework of an autonomous system of law.
DELIBERATIVE DEMOCRACY BEYOND THE STATE
For Habermas, legitimate (democratic) lawmaking is only possible in the context of the state. The voluntary association of citizens requires a central (governmental) authority to protect the collectivity from external threats and internal disorder, and to carry out collective action decisions. The state is a necessary mechanism for the coercive exercise of political authority, ‘because rights must be enforced, because the legal community has need of both a collective self-maintenance and an organized judiciary, and because political will-formation issues in programs that must be implemented’.109 The context for democratic will-formation is provided by the nation state, which manufactures ‘an abstract form of solidarity among strangers from a combination of the cultural symbolism of “the people” and the republican status of citizens’.110
105
Habermas (n 2) at 275. ibid at 276. 107 ibid at 283 (emphasis added). 108 Michel Rosenfeld, ‘Law as Discourse: Bridging the Gap between Democracy and Rights’ (1995) 108 Harvard Law Review 1163, 1187. 109 Habermas (n 2) at 134. 110 Jürgen Habermas, ‘Toward a Cosmopolitan Europe’ (2003) 14 Journal of Democracy 86, 89. Lars-Erik Cederman concludes that the idea of the nation state implies ‘a communicative capacity that enables deliberation and generates a sufficiently strong we-feeling than can carry the weight of effective and democratic government’: Lars-Erik Cederman, ‘Nationalism and Bounded Integration: what it would take to Construct a European Demos’ (2001) 7 European Journal of International Relations 139, 157. 106
Columns Design Ltd
/
Job: Wheatley
/
Division: 02_Democracy
/Pg. Position: 24 /
Date: 26/2
JOBNAME: Wheatley PAGE: 25 SESS: 4 OUTPUT: Tue May 11 14:32:06 2010
116 Democracy Within and Beyond the State In Between Facts and Norms, Habermas makes only a few brief comments about the emergent governance regimes beyond the state, referring to the progressive denationalisation of international law, the trend towards the dissolution of the sovereignty of the nation-state, and the emerging global public sphere.111 He observes that the (imperfect) practice of democracy has only been achieved inside the boundaries of the sovereign state, a fact that creates significant problems for accepting the possibility of opinion- and will-formation in a supranational organisation such as the European Union, given that citizens of the European Union do not orientate themselves to the common good and their democratic loyalties remain ‘fragmented’. What emerges is a functional elite, nominally responsible to states and their publics, but in reality operating autonomously. Policy measures are adopted, but without the possibility for those affected influencing the legislative process.112 Only where rights of political participation are recognised can a system be regarded as democratic, as negative liberties and social welfare rights can equally be conferred by some ‘paternalistic authority’.113 A democratic polity requires a connection between deliberations in the political public sphere and deliberations in formal institutions. In the context of the European Union, this would require Europe-wide public policy deliberations (distinct from the various national deliberations) and a European Parliament with increased authority.114 In relation to the possibilities of global will-formation and exercise of communicative power by a global democratic public, Habermas argues that global superpowers cannot ignore worldwide public protests, over, for example, US military interventions in Iraq (referring to the idea of a ‘world citizenship, which is already taking shape today in worldwide political communications’).115 The ‘cosmopolitan condition is no longer merely a mirage. State citizenship and world citizenship form a continuum whose contours, at least, are already becoming visible.’116 In subsequent writings, Habermas expresses scepticism over the possibility of applying democratic principles beyond the state. It is not possible to regard international law as another layer of government to be democratised. The emergent global regulatory networks cannot be
111
Habermas (n 2) at 444. ibid at 503. ibid at 504. Rights in domestic settings have often emerged in three phases: liberal negative rights that protect the subject against illegal government infringements of rights; rights of political participation that enable citizens to take part in democratic processes of opinion- and will-formation; and, finally, social rights that guarantee minimum income and social security: ibid at 503. 114 ibid at 507. 115 ibid at 514. 116 ibid at 515. 112 113
Columns Design Ltd
/
Job: Wheatley
/
Division: 02_Democracy
/Pg. Position: 25 /
Date: 26/3
JOBNAME: Wheatley PAGE: 26 SESS: 5 OUTPUT: Tue May 11 14:32:06 2010
Deliberative Democracy Beyond the State
117
understood in the same way as state governments, and it is not possible to accept any analogy that associates the process of global state formation with the (mythologised) process of state formation. The federal analogy is not appropriate to describe the emergent global system. At the domestic level, the atom of (popular) sovereignty may split, with a federal constitution establishing chains of legitimation that unfold in parallel.117 The analogy cannot be applied to the global level. In contrast to constitution-making within states, persons already enjoy a status as citizen that guarantees certain rights and freedoms.118 The transformation from an international law of states to a cosmopolitan law of individuals cannot be achieved because there is no supranational power with the capacity to coercively enforce international law norms.119 There may be global governance, but not global government. The constitutionalisation analogy in international law ‘proceeds from the non-hierarchical association of collective actors to the supra- and transnational organizations of the cosmopolitan order.’120 The global state of nations or federal world republic ‘is the wrong model’. Habermas accepts the requirement for international cooperation and a world organisation, although this would have limited and carefully circumscribed functions, relating to securing international peace and security, and promoting international human rights norms.121 The argument follows from an analysis of the perceived success of the European nation state model, where legitimacy is provided by a combination of three factors: the existence of effective government institutions; civil solidarity; and a political constitution.122 The absence of any sense of civil solidarity beyond the state limits the possibilities of supranational constitutions to those ‘of the liberal type’ that aim to regulate the interactions between collective actors ‘with the goal of setting mutual restrictions on their power’. Supranational constitutions limit the exercise of political authority in accordance with relevant international treaties, and in conformity with international human rights norms, and ‘leave the task of applying and developing law to courts, though without being
117 Jürgen Habermas, ‘Does the Constitutionalization of International Law Still Have a Chance?’ in The Divided West (edited and translated by Ciaran Cronin) (Cambridge, Polity, 2006) 115, 128. 118 ibid at 129. 119 ibid at 132. Elsewhere, Habermas writes about a shift from international law, where the state preserves its constitutional authority, to a cosmopolitan law binding on state governments in accordance with some legal code or ‘constitution’: Jürgen Habermas, The Inclusion of the Other: Studies in Political Theory (Cambridge, Massachusetts, MIT Press, 1998) 179. 120 ibid at 133. 121 ibid at 134. 122 ibid at 137.
Columns Design Ltd
/
Job: Wheatley
/
Division: 02_Democracy
/Pg. Position: 26 /
Date: 26/3
JOBNAME: Wheatley PAGE: 27 SESS: 4 OUTPUT: Tue May 11 14:32:06 2010
118 Democracy Within and Beyond the State exposed directly to democratic inputs and controls’.123 Liberal constitutions may be contrasted with the republican conception of a constitution, where the legitimacy of laws depends on acts of opinion- and willformation. Habermas concludes that the relationship between the rule of law and democracy would be dissolved ‘if supranational constitutions were completely severed from the channels of democratic legitimation which are institutionalized within the constitutional state’. Liberal constitutions beyond the state, ‘if they are to be anything more than a hegemonic legal façade, must remain tied at least indirectly to processes of legitimation within constitutional states’.124 The constitutionalisation of international law, if it is not to involve the establishment of a global democratic state, must receive ‘indirect “backing” from the kinds of democratic processes of opinion- and will-formation than can only be fully institutionalized within constitutional states… This weak form of constitutionalization beyond the nation-state remains reliant on continued provisions of legitimacy within state-centred systems.’125 Governance functions, according to Habermas, can be allocated to one of three levels: the supranational level of international law, properly limited to human rights, international peace and security, and ‘technical’ questions of cooperation; the regional level; and the nation state. There is no possibility of a legislative framework emerging outside of the regional context, where there is an increased tendency to cooperation through organisations such as Asia-Pacific Economic Cooperation (APEC), Association of Southeast Asian Nations (ASEAN), North American Free Trade Agreement (NAFTA), African Union (AU), and Economic Community Of West African States (ECOWAS). The exemplar is the European Union, although European unification will only be able to stand as a model for the construction of higher-order capacities for political action if it attains a degree of political integration that enables the EU to pursue democratically legitimated policies both toward the outside world and within its own borders.126
William Scheuerman suggests that the logic of Habermas’ argument (reflected in unpublished writings) is that, in order to navigate the ‘harsh
123 ibid at 139. In relation to the importance of judicial bodies (specifically the role of the Appellate Body of the World Trade Organization), Deborah Cass concludes that the ‘judicial norm-generation argument claims too much in respect of constitutionalisation; pays insufficient attention to the equation between legitimacy and constitutionalisation; and underestimates the role of politics in the constitutional process’: Deborah Cass, The Constitutionalization of the World Trade Organization: Legitimacy, Democracy and Community in the International Trading System (Oxford, Oxford University Press, 2005) 178. 124 ibid at 140. 125 ibid at 141. 126 Jürgen Habermas, ‘A Political Constitution for the Pluralist World Society?’ (2007) 34 Journal of Chinese Philosophy 331, 337.
Columns Design Ltd
/
Job: Wheatley
/
Division: 02_Democracy
/Pg. Position: 27 /
Date: 26/3
JOBNAME: Wheatley PAGE: 28 SESS: 4 OUTPUT: Tue May 11 14:32:06 2010
Deliberative Democracy Beyond the State
119
waters of the global political economy’, most states, with the exception of a small number of great powers, will be required to ‘merge into novel forms of highly integrated regionally based political blocs, along the lines of a democratized EU’. In doing so, they lose their distinctive identity as states.127 Beyond questions of human rights and international peace and security, Habermas regards coordination problems in the international law order as essentially ‘technical’ in nature, not ‘political’, and ‘technical’ problems do not require a framework of international legislation, or collective will-formation. Neil Walker argues that the ‘modesty’ of the role for the world organisation reflects a conviction ‘that justly vested and effective political capacity depends upon conscious and reflexive choice by particular political associations or communities of attachment’;128 it reflects Habermas’ continuing commitment to the democratic Rechtsstaat. At the global level there would be a ‘global domestic politics’, but without a world government, with consensus emerging on the limited functions of securing international peace and security and protection of international human rights norms (although Habermas fails to acknowledge the need for state-like institutions for securing human rights and international peace and security). The difficulty with the analysis is that whilst it might be possible to agree that the role of a world organisation should be limited to securing peace and security and human rights (and that must be subject to reasonable disagreement), there is no consensus on what measures would be required in practice. Disputes around the necessity (or otherwise) of military interventions are a significant aspect of politics in world society (consider, for example, arguments around military interventions in Kosovo and Iraq), and international human rights norms exhibit an indeterminate and contestable quality. In state law systems, decisions on peace and security are taken by government bodies that are ultimately accountable to the people, and the scope and content of human rights determined through constitutional processes (both legislative and judicial). It is not clear how a (nondemocratic) world government could be accountable for decisions on international peace and security or legislate legitimate human rights norms, as Habermas abandons his co-originality thesis at the global level, removing the necessary link between democracy and rights, between public and private autonomy: international human rights are entrenched and protected by international institutions, but are not in any meaningful
127 William Scheuerman, ‘Global Governance without Global Government? Habermas on Postnational Democracy Political Theory’ (2008) 36 Political Theory 133, 149. 128 Neil Walker, ‘Making a World of Difference? Habermas, Cosmopolitanism and the Constitutionalization of International Law’ EUI Working Papers Law No 2005/17 (2005) 7.
Columns Design Ltd
/
Job: Wheatley
/
Division: 02_Democracy
/Pg. Position: 28 /
Date: 26/3
JOBNAME: Wheatley PAGE: 29 SESS: 4 OUTPUT: Tue May 11 14:32:06 2010
120 Democracy Within and Beyond the State way subject to democratic opinion- and will-formation.129 Martti Koskenniemi makes the point that the universal and factoid nature of international human rights sits uneasily with the idea of democracy: ‘the more we insist on the ability of rights to impose an external standard for the community, the more it starts to resemble theology, and the more difficult we have in aligning it with the ideal of popular sovereignty’.130 In a subsequent article, Habermas reaffirms his position that a political world constitution does not require the establishment of a global state, concluding that ‘a politically constituted world society would be composed of citizens and states’.131 Both individuals and states are the ‘founding subjects of a world constitution’, and both paths of legitimisation flow from the citizen, as cosmopolitan citizen, and national citizen.132 There would be two paths of legitimation for a politically constituted world society: the first would lead from cosmopolitan citizens, via an international community of states, to the peace and human rights policy of the world organisation; the second from national citizens, via the state, and any regional regime, ‘to the transnational negotiation system that would be responsible, within the framework of the international community, for issues of global domestic politics’. Both paths would meet in the General Assembly of the world organisation,133 which would be composed of representatives of cosmopolitan citizens and delegates from the democratically elected parliaments of member states (or alternatively one chamber for the representatives of the cosmopolitan citizens, and one for the representatives of the states). Delegates would combine the task of representing the citizens of (their) states, and represent the same citizens in their capacity as cosmopolitan citizens. The function of the General Assembly would be that of a ‘World Parliament, although its legislative function would be confined to the interpretation and elaboration of the Charter.’ Supranational politics would be more judicial than political. The reformed General Assembly would provide the institutional locus
129 Tinnevelt and Mertens conclude that the co-originality thesis can only be upheld by creating a more centralised democratic world organisation, a ‘minimal world state’ that complements the existing system of national self-determination, and is capable of securing human rights: Ronald Tinnevelt and Thomas Mertens, ‘The World State: a Forbidding Nightmare of Tyranny? Habermas on the Institutional Implications of Moral Cosmopolitanism’ (2009) 10(1) German Law Journal 63, 65. 130 Martti Koskenniemi, ‘The Effect of Rights on Political Culture’ in Philip Alston (ed), The EU and Human Rights (Oxford, Oxford University Press, 1999) 99, 102. 131 Jürgen Habermas, ‘The Constitutionalization of International Law and the Legitimation Problems of a Constitution for World Society’ (2008) 15 Constellations 444, 448 (emphasis in original). The constitutional state qualifies by virtue of its role in guaranteeing the political self-determination of citizens and in making state government institutions available for the coercive enforcement of international law norms (through legitimate violence). 132 ibid at 449 (emphasis in original). 133 ibid at 448.
Columns Design Ltd
/
Job: Wheatley
/
Division: 02_Democracy
/Pg. Position: 29 /
Date: 26/3
JOBNAME: Wheatley PAGE: 30 SESS: 4 OUTPUT: Tue May 11 14:32:06 2010
Conclusion 121 for processes of opinion- and will-formation concerning the ‘principles of transnational justice from which global domestic politics should take its orientation’.134 According to the revised model of global governance, the practices of the world organisation, including the reformed General Assembly and Security Council, would be legitimised by a ‘functional global public sphere’, which has not yet emerged. It would require that ‘[v]igilant civil society actors’ generate worldwide transparency on global political issues, allowing cosmopolitan citizens to develop informed opinions and positions on relevant issues that could produce effects through elections to the General Assembly. Habermas admits that ‘a diffuse world public opinion armed solely with the weak sanctioning power of “naming and shaming” could at best exert a weak form of control over the interpretive, executive, and judicial decisions of the world organization’. The deficit might though ‘be made good’ through enhanced internal controls, including a right of veto for the General Assembly in relation to the resolutions of a reformed Security Council and rights of appeal to an international court for parties subject to Security Council sanctions. Provided that the world organisation operated in accordance with constitutional principles that reflect existing democratic processes at the level of the state, ‘it might be acceptable that the remaining need for legitimation would be met by an informal global opinion’.135 Elsewhere, Habermas concludes that opinion- and will-formation ‘within the world organization could be more closely connected back to the communications flows of national parliaments and more effectively exposed to the monitoring of nongovernmental organizations (NGOs) and other representatives of a mobilized world public’.136 CONCLUSION
The deliberative model developed by Jürgen Habermas presents the most rigorous and sophisticated justification of liberal democracy 134 ibid at 449 (emphasis in original). Heikki Patomaki calls for the establishment of a world parliament of two chambers that would express a democratic and legitimate public opinion (or opinio juris) of the world community, replacing the current idea of ‘international community’. The first chamber would be a directly elected body of citizens’ representatives, the second chamber would consist of legal experts, who would determine whether the decisions of the first chamber are reasonably based on the existing body of law, with the second chamber given limited veto powers. The members of the second chamber would be nominated by states, international courts and law schools of various universities representing different parts of the world: Heikki Patomaki, ‘Rethinking Global Parliament: Beyond the Indeterminacy of International law’ (2007) 13 Widener Law Review 375, 388–89. 135 ibid at 451. 136 Jürgen Habermas, ‘A Political Constitution for the Pluralist World Society?’ (2007) 34 Journal of Chinese Philosophy 331, 335.
Columns Design Ltd
/
Job: Wheatley
/
Division: 02_Democracy
/Pg. Position: 30 /
Date: 26/3
JOBNAME: Wheatley PAGE: 31 SESS: 4 OUTPUT: Tue May 11 14:32:06 2010
122
Democracy Within and Beyond the State
grounded in social contract theory and the liberal principle of legitimacy. In conditions of complexity, uncertainty and reasonable disagreement, laws are valid only where all possible affected persons could agree as participants in rational discourses (the principle of discourse). Applied to the practice of democracy, the deliberative model makes clear that politics must be grounded in arguments around what is equally good for all (it is not sufficient simply to aggregate a majority of self-interested positions), and conducted in accordance with the principles of rationality and public reason. The parliamentary principle establishes the importance of representative assemblies, and the need to ensure that representatives remain tied to the flows of opinion- and will-formation that emerge in the public sphere. The democratic model of judicial review affirms the position that all constitutional (as well as political) law norms are ultimately subject to the democratic will of the people. The difficulty with the analysis is twofold. First, it fails to locate the constitutional democratic state in world society and the regulatory framework of international law. The deliberative model is applicable in counterfactual conditions in which a legal order constitutes itself as a voluntary association that is not subject to legal or political pressures from other law orders. Deliberative democracy requires that the people decide all politically decidable issues in accordance with the principle of public reason. Secondly, the attempt to reconcile the authority of the UN in relation to peace and security and human rights with the idea of domestic democracy does not work. Even if we accept, for example, that international human rights norms represent the experiences of liberal democratic peoples (which seems reasonable), there remains the requirement to determine the scope and content of specific human rights norms when applied in domestic societies already subject to democratic law norms and constitutional provisions. There is a need to accommodate the theory and practice of deliberative democracy with the authority of international law, and evaluate the authority of international law in terms of democratic legitimacy.
Columns Design Ltd
/
Job: Wheatley
/
Division: 02_Democracy
/Pg. Position: 31 /
Date: 26/3
JOBNAME: Wheatley PAGE: 1 SESS: 3 OUTPUT: Tue May 11 14:32:06 2010
3 The State as (Democratic) Self-Legislator
T
HERE IS A sense in the literature that the globalisation and fragmentation of governance functions represents both a collapse of the Westphalian political settlement and a new problem for democracy. The positivist orthodoxy provided that the validity of law rested on an expression of sovereign will, in terms of (internal) state law and (external) international law. Democracy was protected by the limited relevance of international law norms for domestic societies, the sovereign right of non-intervention in domestic affairs, and requirement for consent to international law norms. Democracy legitimacy was provided by the requirement for internal and external law norms to reflect the will of the people, agreed through democratic procedures. On this understanding, it was possible (at least hypothetically) to suggest that all (‘Westphalian’) forms of law could be regarded as democratic, with democratic representation occurring through a ‘two-link chain’, internally through domestic democratic institutions and externally through the inter-state system.1 The objectives of this chapter are to examine this argument and outline the problem for democracy that results from the existence and authority of a system of international law. The chapter first examines the emergence of the sovereign state and idea of sovereignty before outlining the Westphalian ideal of state as (sovereign) self-legislator. In terms of democratic legitimacy, the work rejects the argument grounded in the metaphor of contract in international relations, and locates political legitimacy for international law norms in the authority of the system of international law and in the processes of (deliberative) diplomacy that conclude in agreement. The autonomous international law order is not subject to the (democratic) will of the state, a point emphasised through an evaluation of the sources of international law. It is not possible to refer to an idea of absolute self-determination following recognition of the existence of a system of international law.
1 Neil Walker, ‘Beyond Boundary Disputes and Basic Grids: Mapping the Global Disorder of Normative Orders’ (2008) 6 International Journal of Constitutional Law 373, 393.
Columns Design Ltd
/
Job: Wheatley
/
Division: 03_TheWestphalianparadigm
/Pg. Position: 1 /
Date: 26/3
JOBNAME: Wheatley PAGE: 2 SESS: 3 OUTPUT: Tue May 11 14:32:06 2010
124 The State as (Democratic) Self-Legislator THE SOVEREIGN STATE
The transition from the medieval to the modern world had at its core the institution of the sovereign state, and corresponding international community of states. Social and political upheavals, including plague induced demographic changes, a commercial revolution, and the Reformation, produced a political vacuum from which emerged territorial units under the political authority of regional monarchies.2 The development was particularly noteworthy in Italy, with the rise of independent communities, and in the emergence of the ‘nation’ states of England, Spain and France. The theory of sovereignty developed by Jean Bodin, Les six livres de la Republique (1576),3 provided the intellectual justification for recognising the political independence of the ‘sovereign’ state. The international law orthodoxy is that the Treaty of Westphalia 1648 marked the end of one epoch and the opening of another, replacing the Christian commonwealth under the authority of the Pope and Holy Roman Emperor.4 This idea of Westphalian sovereignty was said to provide a ‘bundle of attributes [,] [including] territory, recognition, autonomy, and control’.5 The new system rested on ‘international law and the balance of power, a law operating between rather than above states’.6 From the time of the publication of Emer de Vattel’s Le droit des gens (1758),7 international law was positivist and consensual, with the will of states explaining the content and the binding force of the system.
2 Christian Reus-Smit, ‘Politics and International Legal Obligation’ (2003) European Journal of International Relations 591, 617. cf Charles Tilly, Coercion, Capital, and European States, AD 990–1990 (Cambridge, Massachusetts, Blackwell, 1990) 183. 3 Jean Bodin, Les six livres de la Republique (Paris, Chez Iacques du Puys, 1576). 4 The accepted account has been subject to recent scrutiny. According to Stéphane Beaulac, the main object of the Peace of Westphalia was to establish a regime on the practice of religion. ‘Article 5, paragraph 11, established that a ruler who chose to change its religion could not compel its subjects to do the same. The Treaties formally recognised freedom of conscience for Catholics living in Protestant areas and vice versa’: Stéphane Beaulac, ‘The Westphalian Legal Orthodoxy – Myth or Reality?’ (2000) 2 Journal of the History of International Law 148, 164 (references omitted). 5 Stephen Krasner, Sovereignty: Organized Hypocrisy (Princeton, Princeton University Press, 1999) 220. Krasner identifies three aspects of sovereignty: international legal sovereignty, ie, the right of recognised sovereign territories to enter into international agreements; Westphalian (or ‘Vattelian’) sovereignty, the principle of non-intervention in the internal affairs of states; and domestic sovereignty, which concerns the institutions under which a particular state is governed and their effectiveness: Stephen Krasner, ‘The Hole in the Whole: Sovereignty, Shared Sovereignty, and International Law’ (2004) 25 Michigan Journal of International Law 1075, 1077. 6 Leo Gross, ‘The Peace of Westphalia, 1648–1948’ (1948) 42 American Journal of International Law 20, 29. 7 Emer de Vattel, The Law of Nations; or, Principles of the Law of Nature: Applied to the Conduct and Affairs of Nations and Sovereigns (Dublin, Luke White, 1787).
Columns Design Ltd
/
Job: Wheatley
/
Division: 03_TheWestphalianparadigm
/Pg. Position: 2 /
Date: 26/3
JOBNAME: Wheatley PAGE: 3 SESS: 3 OUTPUT: Tue May 11 14:32:06 2010
The Sovereign State
125
Whilst it is difficult to read any general principle of sovereignty in the Peace Treaty between the Holy Roman Emperor and the King of France and their Respective Allies, international lawyers have, over time, come to refer to the idea of state sovereignty in terms of Westphalian sovereignty.8 After ‘Westphalia’, the language of international justification shifted, albeit gradually, away from an idea and image of Christian unity, to one of diversity, based on a secular society of self-determining sovereign states.9 A system of public international law emerged, and by the eighteenth century Europe had become a society of sovereign states governed by legal rules that were determined exclusively by the members of that society.10 International law was the result of consent between sovereigns and not some ‘pre-existing [Christian] morality.’11 Martti Koskenniemi explains the emergence of the modern legal world in terms of a ‘social contract’, with the international law system emerging from the sovereign-will of states. Their right to make such a system was ‘assumed to be “inherent”.’12 According to the positivist orthodoxy, international law is the result of individual expressions of sovereign consent, with the system of general international law limited to (secondary) rules about rules, principally pacta sunt servanda (agreements or promises must be kept). The era of international legal positivism resulted, as Leo Gross observes, in absolutist states, jealous of their territorial sovereignty to the point where the idea of an international community became an almost empty phrase and where international law came to depend on the will of states more concerned with the preservation and expansion of their power than with the establishment of a rule of law.13
Following Westphalia, global governance actors constituted a political system that divided first Europe and later the entire world into clearly demarked territorial units with clear hierarchical structures of government.14 Sovereign will defined the content and binding nature of international law, which in turn defined the sovereign state and recognised its 8 John Jackson, ‘Sovereignty-Modern: a New Approach to an Outdated Concept’ (2003) 97 American Journal of International Law 782, 786. 9 Robert Jackson, ‘Sovereignty in World Politics: a Glance at the Conceptual and Historical Landscape’ (1999) XLVII Political Studies 431, 439. 10 Adam Watson, The Evolution of International Society: a Comparative Historical Analysis (London, Routledge, 1992) 203. 11 Martti Koskenniemi, From Apology to Utopia: the Structure of International Legal Argument (Cambridge, Cambridge University Press, 2005) 167. 12 ibid at 94. 13 Leo Gross, ‘The Peace of Westphalia, 1648–1948’ (1948) 42 American Journal of International Law 20, 38. 14 The 1713 Peace of Utrecht, which concluded the Wars of Spanish Succession, forced the Bourbon monarchs of France and Spain to issue a series of dynastic renunciations that permanently separated the two crowns, enshrining a new principle that sovereign rights
Columns Design Ltd
/
Job: Wheatley
/
Division: 03_TheWestphalianparadigm
/Pg. Position: 3 /
Date: 26/3
JOBNAME: Wheatley PAGE: 4 SESS: 3 OUTPUT: Tue May 11 14:32:06 2010
126 The State as (Democratic) Self-Legislator authority ‘to determine further its own constitutional authority’.15 The development of the state and international law were ‘mutually reinforcing processes’,16 with states constituting the international law system, which in turn constituted the sovereign state as the principle actor in the international law order.17 Sovereignty was, and remains, a question of status:18 the right to be recognised as an independent political unit, enjoying the rights and privileges that follow recognition, including the right to contract in international law and freedom of internal political self-determination. Sovereignty provided those societies organised (and recognised) as states with a right of political self-determination. States co-existed on the basis of (sovereign) equality, with each state society protected from interferences by other state societies. Writing in the first edition of the American Journal of International Law, Robert Lansing observed that it was an accepted principle of international law that every state, whatever may be its population, power and resources, is the political equal of every other state, and that its sovereign is independent and supreme within the state. There is no such thing as degrees of sovereignty among states; the nature of real sovereignty precludes such a thought.19
International law allowed states to exercise both internal and external political self-determination in a legal system designed to support their autonomous political development. Gregory Fox observes that the emergence of the state as a separate legal entity provided an incentive to develop an international law system that protected the central attribute of the juridical personality of the state: the exercise of exclusive political authority in respect of a defined territory. With the development of the idea of popular sovereignty (the ‘will of the people’), and the embodiment of nationalist myths within each ‘Nation’, the social, economic,
were to be territorially bounded: Christian Reus-Smit, ‘Politics and International Legal Obligation’ (2003) 9 European Journal of International Relations 591, 619. 15 Daniel Philpott, ‘Westphalia, Authority, and International Society’ (1999) XLVII Political Studies 566, 567. The Westphalian law of nations, in contrast to the previous epoch, was seen as a purely human creation crafted by states through custom and the adoption of treaties: Stephen Neff, War and the Law of Nations: a General History (Cambridge, Cambridge University Press, 2005) 86. 16 Hendrik Spruyt, The Sovereign State and its Competitors (Princeton, New Jersey, Princeton University Press, 1994) 179. 17 Andreas Fischer-Lescano and Gunther Teubner, ‘Regime Collisions: the Vain Search for Legal Unity in the Fragmentation of Global Law’ (2004) 25 Michigan Journal of International Law 999, 1067–68. 18 Abram Chayes and Antonia Chayes, The New Sovereignty: Compliance with International Regulatory Agreements (Cambridge, Massachusetts, Harvard University Press, 1998) 27. cf Anne-Marie Slaughter, ‘Sovereignty and Power in a Networked World Order’ (2004) 40 Stanford Journal of International Law 283, 284: ‘Westphalian sovereignty is the right to be left alone, to exclude, to be free from any external meddling or interference’. 19 Robert Lansing, ‘Notes on Sovereignty in a State’ (1907) 1 American Journal of International Law 105, 124.
Columns Design Ltd
/
Job: Wheatley
/
Division: 03_TheWestphalianparadigm
/Pg. Position: 4 /
Date: 26/3
JOBNAME: Wheatley PAGE: 5 SESS: 2 OUTPUT: Tue May 11 14:32:06 2010
The Sovereign State
127
political and cultural distinctiveness of the sovereign state become even more deserving of protection and the international law system was placed at the disposal of the state-building project, ‘allowing the individual identities of European States to unfold at a pace dictated by domestic politics’.20 Within the state, clear hierarchical structures of government developed that claimed a monopoly on the legitimate use of force, and (often) a monopoly on the prerogative of law-making.21 Internal sovereignty did not imply absolutism, however: the idea, if not the practice, of human rights also emerges in political thought in the seventeenth century, reflecting a belief that there are inherent limits on the exercise of sovereign political authority.22 The term ‘constitution’ also emerges in the early seventeenth century, although it is not until the eighteenth century, after the American War of Independence and French Revolution, that it comes to be understood as the ‘foundational law which first purports to set out the objectives of a political community in terms that correspond to the interests of that political community and, secondly, distributes and constrains administrative power’.23 Modern political constitutions are ways of organising and constituting power, and thereby conferring authority.24 The idea has come to be understood as a foundational agreement, framed in terms of law, that both constructs and constraint political power, ie the constitution identifies the institutions entitled to exercise political authority, the conditions under which it may be exercised (and any limits), and the political objectives and values of the political community, framed in terms of (political) justice. In the constitutional state, political authority is exercised within an agreed constitutional framework, and, according to the fiction of the social contract, in accordance with the will of the people, expressed in the idea of popular sovereignty. The people provide the ultimate source of all legal and political authority. Law is an expression of the general will, and as the Declaration of the Rights of Man (1789) makes clear: ‘Every citizen has a right to participate personally, or through his representative, in its foundation.’25
20
Gregory Fox, ‘Strengthening the State’ (1999) 7 Indian Journal of Global Legal Studies 35,
44–45. 21
Note, however, the possibility of legal pluralism within the state. See FH Hinsley, Sovereignty, 2nd edn (Cambridge, Cambridge University Press, 1986) 143–49. See, generally, Kenneth Minogue, ‘The History of the Idea of Human Rights’ in Walter Lacquer and Barry Rubin (eds), The Human Rights Reader (Philadelphia, Temple University Press, 1979) 3. 23 Damian Chalmers, ‘Post-Nationalism and the Quest for Constitutional Substitutes’ (2000) 27 Journal of Law and Society 178, 182. 24 Martin Loughlin, The Idea of Public Law (Oxford, Oxford University Press, 2003) 162. 25 Declaration of the Rights of Man, Approved by the National Assembly of France, August 26, 1789, art 6. 22
Columns Design Ltd
/
Job: Wheatley
/
Division: 03_TheWestphalianparadigm
/Pg. Position: 5 /
Date: 26/2
JOBNAME: Wheatley PAGE: 6 SESS: 3 OUTPUT: Tue May 11 14:32:06 2010
128 The State as (Democratic) Self-Legislator THE STATE AS SELF-LEGISLATOR
The Westphalian settlement (according to the international law narrative) constructed the modern political world, establishing the sovereign territorial state, and dividing the idea of law along a strict binary line: (internal) state law in accordance with a (self-given) constitutional law order, and (external) inter-Nation (international) law that relied on the principle of (sovereign) consent. The international order was organised in accordance with the principle of sovereignty and requirement of consent for the introduction of international law norms. Ian Brownlie observes that the sovereignty and equality of states is ‘the basic constitutional doctrine of the law of nations’. One corollary is the ‘dependence of obligations arising under customary law and treaties on the consent of the obligor’.26 The International Court of Justice has referred to ‘the fundamental principle of State sovereignty, on which the whole of international law rests’.27 In Case of the S.S. ‘Lotus’, when international law ‘first asked itself whether the international legal order was fundamentally one of sovereign freedom or constraint’,28 the Permanent Court of International Justice affirmed that international law ‘governs rules between independent States. The rules of law binding upon States therefore emanate from their own free will’.29 States enjoy both a right of internal self-determination, and the right to accept or reject emerging international law norms. Koskenniemi explains: ‘One aspect of sovereignty is the liberty to “legislate” international norms which bind oneself.’ In the absence of consent, ‘the metaprinciple of sovereign liberty – the “Lotus principle” – remains valid.’30 The system of public international law, according to the positivist orthodoxy,31 is the result of a complex web of voluntary legal relationships between sovereign and independent states.32 Yet the fact that
26 Ian Brownlie, Principles of Public International Law, 7th edn (Oxford, Oxford University Press, 2008) 289. 27 Military and Paramilitary Activities in and against Nicaragua (Nicaragua v United States of America) (Merits) [1986] ICJ Rep 14 [263]. 28 David Kennedy, ‘International Law and the Nineteenth Century: History of an Illusion’ (1997) 17 Quinnipiac Law Review 99, 118. 29 Case of the S.S. ‘Lotus’ PCIJ Rep Series A No 10, 18. 30 Martti Koskenniemi, ‘The Politics of International Law’ (1990) European Journal of International Law 1, 13. 31 For the positivist, international law ‘is no more or less than the rules to which states have agreed through treaties, custom, and perhaps other forms of consent’: Steven Ratner and Anne-Marie Slaughter, ‘Appraising the Methods of International Law: a Prospectus for Readers’ (1999) 93 American Journal of International Law 291, 293. 32 The International Court of Justice has referred to the ‘edifice of [international] law carefully constructed by mankind over a period of centuries, the maintenance of which is vital for the security and well-being of the complex international community’: United States Diplomatic and Consular Staff in Tehran (United States of America v Iran) [1980] ICJ Rep 3 [92].
Columns Design Ltd
/
Job: Wheatley
/
Division: 03_TheWestphalianparadigm
/Pg. Position: 6 /
Date: 26/3
JOBNAME: Wheatley PAGE: 7 SESS: 3 OUTPUT: Tue May 11 14:32:06 2010
The State as Self-Legislator
129
international law norms, once agreed, are binding undermines the claim of the state to be ‘sovereign’.33 But if states were free to reject existing international law commitments, it would be meaningless to refer to the idea of a system of international law. States cannot, at one and the same time, be ‘absolute’ sovereigns and subject to international law norms. The binding force of international law cannot logically be found in positive law itself.34 The position in international law was expressed by the Permanent Court of International Justice in Case of SS ‘Wimbledon’: ‘The Court declines to see in the conclusion of any Treaty… an abandonment of [State] sovereignty… [T]he right of entering into international agreement is an attribute of State sovereignty.’35 The sovereignty of states, as Hans Kelsen explains, ‘is the legal authority of the States under the authority of international law’.36 The state is sovereign ‘when it is subjected only to international law, not to the national law of any other State. Consequently, the State’s sovereignty under international law is its legal independence from other States.’37 Sovereignty provides the right to be subject only to international law, and not (other) state law systems, and to determine which international laws will apply to the state. It is not a right of absolute political self-determination (ie a right to reject existing international law norms): The fact that a State has, by concluding the treaty, given its consent to the competence of the agency established by the treaty is quite compatible with the fact that the State can change its will, expressed at the conclusion of the treaty. This change of will is legally irrelevant, however, since the contracting State remains legally bound by the treaty, even if it ceases to will what it declared to will at the moment it concluded the treaty. Only at that moment is concordance of the wills of the contracting States necessary in order to create the duties and rights established by the treaty. The fact that the contracting State remains legally bound by the treaty without regard to a unilateral change of will clearly proves that a State can be bound even against its will and that the autonomy of the State under international law is not, and cannot be, unlimited.38
Absolute self-determination is not possible for the sovereign state in the international law system. Once international relations are defined in terms of law, legal norms structure inter-state relations, providing a See also, Separate Opinion of Judge Lachs (ibid, 47, at 48): ‘The laws in question are the common property of the international community and were confirmed in the interest of all.’ 33 Stephen Krasner, Sovereignty: Organized Hypocrisy (Princeton, Princeton University Press, 1999) 224. 34 Hans Morgenthau, ‘Positivism, Functionalism, and International Law’ (1940) 34 American Journal of International Law 260, 269. 35 Case of SS ‘Wimbledon’ [1923] PCIJ Series A No 1, 25. 36 Hans Kelsen, ‘The Principle of Sovereign Equality of States as a Basis for International Organization’ (1944) 53 Yale Law Journal 207, 208. 37 ibid at 210. 38 ibid at 210–11.
Columns Design Ltd
/
Job: Wheatley
/
Division: 03_TheWestphalianparadigm
/Pg. Position: 7 /
Date: 26/3
JOBNAME: Wheatley PAGE: 8 SESS: 3 OUTPUT: Tue May 11 14:32:06 2010
130 The State as (Democratic) Self-Legislator guide for future actions.39 Recourse to international law ensures that future relations will be conducted in accordance with agreed rules, even against short-term interests. The voluntary act of contracting subjects the state to international law, constraining the scope of (democratic) selfdetermination. Disputes in international law emerge in relation to disagreements on ‘a point of law or fact, a conflict of legal views or of interests between two persons’.40 The presumption is that that a dispute is capable (in principle) of being resolved in accordance with international law, and not the sovereign (or democratic) will of one or more of the parties. The dominant mindset of the international lawyers is one of adjudication, not the arbitration of competing moral and political claims.41 The presumption that a dispute can be resolved in accordance with international law applies equally in bilateral settings, where only the states parties to a dispute are involved. In cases of disagreement over the interpretation of the meaning, scope and content of an international law norm a ‘dynamic of justification’ emerges, as each party will justify its position to the other disputant in the hope of establishing a common understanding. Differences in interpretation can be reconciled, provided that the will exists, with an authoritative interpretation of the legal text resulting from a process of inter-subjective argumentation which results in agreement.42 Disputes in international relations on points of international law are resolved by reference to the techniques of public international law for the interpretation and application of international law norms. Ian Johnstone makes the point that processes of dispute resolution are constrained by the existence of law norms that provide both evidence of a commitment to comply with the substantive obligations, and to engage in a process of constructing the meaning of the relationship together. The argument applies to all international law agreements, including constitutional instruments such as the Charter of the United Nations (UN), the latter of
39 In Continental Shelf (Libyan Arab Jarnahiriya/Malta), Judge Valticos observed that the function of the International Court of Justice was to ‘resolve disputes by means of legal solutions and, in so doing, to elicit, state and exemplify the relevant rule of international law… In so doing, it will also be able to contribute to that clarity, certainty, predictability and stability which are so essential in international law’: Continental Shelf (Libyan Arab Jarnahiriya/Malta) [1985] ICJ Rep 13, Separate Opinion of Judge Valticos at 108. 40 Mavrommatis Palestine Concessions [1924] PCIJ Series A No 2, 11. 41 The position may be contrasted with Ancient Greece, where arbitrators determined the outcomes of disputes between Greek city-states without reference to a body of codified law. The aim of the process was to arrive at a fair and equitable decision through an assessment of competing moral claims: Christian Reus-Smit, ‘The Constitutional Structure of International Society and the Nature of Fundamental Institutions’ (1997) 51 International Organization 555, 574–75. 42 Abram Chayes and Antonia Chayes, The New Sovereignty: Compliance with International Regulatory Agreements (Cambridge, Massachusetts, Harvard University Press, 1998) 123.
Columns Design Ltd
/
Job: Wheatley
/
Division: 03_TheWestphalianparadigm
/Pg. Position: 8 /
Date: 26/3
JOBNAME: Wheatley PAGE: 9 SESS: 3 OUTPUT: Tue May 11 14:32:06 2010
The State as Self-Legislator
131
which are more open-textured. Drawing on Owen Fiss’ theory of ‘bounded objectivity’, in which interpretation is constrained by a set of disciplining rules recognised as authoritative by an interpretive community,43 Johnstone argues that the meaning of any word, or set or words, is either clear or capable of clarification, because communication occurs within situations and ‘to be in a situation is already to be in possession of (or to be possessed by) a structure of assumptions, of practices understood to be relevant in relation to purposes and goals that are already in place’.
Disputes over the interpretation of law norms are resolved by the conventions of description, argument, judgement and persuasion as they operate within a given ‘interpretive community’.44 Where another is persuaded, it is not because the truth of the interpretation has been demonstrated, ‘but because the listener and speaker have settled on certain common beliefs and categories of understanding’.45 By entering a treaty regime, state parties not only agree to be bound by the terms of the agreement, ‘but also to a process of interpretation whose goal is an intersubjective understanding of the treaty terms’. In this way they create and constitute an interpretive community, whose function is ‘to “uncover together” the meaning of the treaty’.46 The idea of an interpretive community, taken from Stanley Fish, follows from a rejection of arguments that the source of interpretive authority can be found either in the text or with the reader, and from an observation of both agreement and disagreement in the interpretation of texts. Meaning is not produced by the text or the reader, but by the interpretive community in which both are situated. In this sense, interpreters are no longer individuals, but together form a community of interpreters with a shared understanding as to the task of interpretation.47 The act of interpretation is not constrained by the language of the text, or its context, but by the ‘cultural assumptions within which both texts and contexts take shape for situated agents’.48 In relation to international law, Johnstone identifies an interpretive community with two concentric circles: an inner circle, consisting of those individuals responsible for the formulation, negotiation, conclusion, implementation and application of international law norms; and an outer circle of lawyers and 43 Ian Johnstone, ‘Treaty Interpretation: the Authority of Interpretive Communities’ (1991) 12 Michigan Journal of International Law 371, 374. 44 ibid at 378. 45 ibid at 379. 46 ibid at 381. 47 Stanley Fish, Doing What Comes Naturally (Oxford, Clarendon, 1989) 141–42, quoted Ian Johnstone, ‘Security Council Deliberations: the Power of the Better Argument’ (2003) 14 European Journal of International Law 437, 444. 48 Fish, Doing What Comes Naturally (1989) at 300.
Columns Design Ltd
/
Job: Wheatley
/
Division: 03_TheWestphalianparadigm
/Pg. Position: 9 /
Date: 26/3
JOBNAME: Wheatley PAGE: 10 SESS: 3 OUTPUT: Tue May 11 14:32:06 2010
132 The State as (Democratic) Self-Legislator other experts engaged in professional activities associated with the area regulated by the law norm. Members of the inner circle are responsible for the processes that bring international law norms into existence, and for their implementation and application. The outer circle is composed of ‘an amorphous group of all those regarded as possessing expertise in international law and/or special knowledge in the relevant field[,] [and] who are dedicated to a common intellectual enterprise and engage in a continuous process of communication and collaboration’.49 The outer circle includes all those individuals (judges, national government officials, international bureaucrats, lawyers, academics, and individuals working for international non-governmental organisations, etc) who participate in some way in the practice of international law, or in the interpretation or application of international law norms. What unites them is that they regard themselves as being engaged in a common activity requiring ‘a mastering of discipline or technique’.50 The interpretation and application of (agreed) international law norms is undertaken in accordance with the disciplinary techniques and understandings of international law. Whilst the establishment of international law obligations depends (formally) on an expression of political will, the interpretation of international law norms is not exclusively the responsibility of the states parties to the international agreement.51 John Griffiths observes that the first consequence of embodying a political decision in legal form ‘is that lawyers become involved in all aspects of the execution of the decision – its formulation, its interpretation, and its application’. The importance of law resides, in part, ‘in the effects of those special characteristics of lawyers’.52 A second consequence ‘is that the resulting legal rule takes its place in an existing body of legal propositions and accepted criteria of legal reasoning’.53 The fact that a political decision is framed in terms of law might be important because of the importance of lawyers, or because of the partial autonomy of law.54 Koskenniemi observes that legal words ‘cannot be separated from the language in
49
Johnstone (n 47) at 450. ibid at 450–51. 51 In relation to the requirement for ‘systemic integration’ (art 31(3)(c) of the Vienna Convention on the Law of Treaties), Martti Koskenniemi observes that success or failure ‘is measured by how the legal world will view the outcome’: Martti Koskenniemi, ‘Fragmentation of International Law: Difficulties Arising from the Diversification and Expansion of International Law, Report of the Study Group of the International Law Commission’, finalized by Martti Koskenniemi (13 April 2006) UN Doc A/CN.4/L.682 para 419. 52 John Griffiths, ‘Is Law Important?’ (1979) 54 New York University Law Review 339, 358 (emphasis in original). 53 ibid at 360. 54 ibid at 363. 50
Columns Design Ltd
/
Job: Wheatley
/
Division: 03_TheWestphalianparadigm
/Pg. Position: 10 /
Date: 26/3
JOBNAME: Wheatley PAGE: 11 SESS: 3 OUTPUT: Tue May 11 14:32:06 2010
Contractual Autonomy
133
which they lead their life. They operate only in the context of other legal words and of a professional grammar about how they are used in relation to each other’.55 The meaning of words and phrases (and consequently of international law norms) is provided by the discipline of international law. As the International Court of Justice observed in the South-West Africa case, the meaning of legal terms must be understood in light of the ‘framework of the entire legal system prevailing at the time of interpretation’.56 The idea of international law as a legal system requires that participants argue and debate with the lawyers’ tools of interpretation, deduction and inference. The ‘vision’ of international law as a legal system, as opposed to a mere collection of discrete treaties, allows participants ‘to interpret, deduct, draw inferences and resolve conflicts not only by resorting to the specific treaties at hand but also by relying on the basic principles of the system and its underlying norms’.57 The (voluntary) acceptance of the authority of international law norms subjects the (sovereign) state to the discipline of international law.58 From the perspective of domestic democracy, the existence of a binding system of international law is inherently problematic.
CONTRACTUAL AUTONOMY
The subjection of the state to the authority of international law is problematic from both the perspective of (‘unlimited and illimitable’) sovereignty and (absolute) democratic self-determination in relation to a territory. International law scholars have never satisfactorily explained how it was possible that a sovereign could limit its freedom of action through entering into international law agreements. David Kennedy observes that the candidates for the international meta-principle ‘are 55 Martti Koskenniemi, ‘Constitutionalism as Mindset: Reflections on Kantian Themes about International Law and Globalization’ (2007) 8 Theoretical Inquiries in Law 9, 20–21. 56 Legal Consequences for States of the Continued Presence of South Africa in Namibia (South-West Africa) notwithstanding Security Council Resolution 276 (1970) (Advisory Opinion) [1971] ICJ Rep 16 [53]. An alternative explanation is that the meaning of international law norms only changes where the parties intended the meaning to alter in light of changing circumstances. See Duncan French, ‘Treaty Interpretation and the Incorporation of Extraneous Legal Rules’ (2006) 55 International and Comparative Law Quarterly 281, 296. 57 Eyal Benvenisti, ‘The Conception of International Law as a Legal System’ (2008) 50 German Yearbook of International Law 393 (SSRN) 4. 58 See, for example, Gabcˇíkovo-Nagymaros Project (Hungary/Slovakia) [1997] ICJ Rep 7 [114]: ‘The Court would set a precedent with disturbing implications for treaty relations and the integrity of the rule pacta sunt servanda if it were to conclude that a treaty in force between States, which the parties have implemented in considerable measure and at great cost over a period of years, might be unilaterally set aside on grounds of reciprocal noncompliance.’
Columns Design Ltd
/
Job: Wheatley
/
Division: 03_TheWestphalianparadigm
/Pg. Position: 11 /
Date: 26/3
JOBNAME: Wheatley PAGE: 12 SESS: 4 OUTPUT: Thu May 13 10:56:59 2010
134 The State as (Democratic) Self-Legislator legion, and quite familiar’: the ‘nature’ or ‘requirements’ of an international system (of states); the ‘status’ of statehood, and ‘nature’ of sovereignty; and/or utility, legitimate expectations, and reciprocity.59 The difficulty created by the requirement to subject sovereign will to the authority of international law led positivist scholars to develop ‘a series of even more elaborate “theories” of law which could retain law’s roots in consent and still explain its force against the dissenter’.60 It was not, however, possible for international law theories to satisfactorily explain how international law obligations could be imposed on a sovereign state with its consent.61 The Westphalian paradigm is one of a global state of nature, in which actors remain free until they consent to limitations on their freedom of action (the ‘Lotus’ principle). Rights and obligations are essentially a bilateral matter, with treaties (including multilateral treaties) analogous to private law contracts. The model proceeds from the assumptions that states are sovereign, and that expressions of sovereign consent create international law norms that bind the state, but it is not clear why this should be the case. From the end of the nineteenth century, the private law metaphor came to dominate, and international treaties are often written about as if they were private law contracts,62 binding actors in a legal relationship that can only be avoided in case of supervening impossibility of performance,63 fundamental change of circumstances,64 or emergence of a new peremptory norm.65 States were unified sovereigns, analogous in competence to the individual.66 An act of contractual autonomy generated an expectation that agreed law norms would be followed (the ‘jus-natural maxim’ pacta sunt servanda), ‘not because of any sovereign command but because [the state] consented to them’.67
59 David Kennedy, ‘Theses about International Law Discourse’ (1980) 23 German Yearbook of International Law 353, 373. 60 ibid at 379. 61 ibid at 380. 62 JL Brierly, The Law of Nations: an Introduction to the International Law of Peace, 6th edn, revised by Sir Humphrey Waldock (Oxford, Clarendon Press, 1963) 317. 63 Vienna Convention on the Law of Treaties 1155 UNTS 331 art 61. 64 Ibid art 62. 65 Ibid art 63. 66 David Kennedy, ‘International Law and the Nineteenth Century: History of an Illusion’ (1997) 17 Quinnipiac Law Review 99, 126. 67 Daniela Caruso, ‘Private Law and State-Making in the Age of Globalization’ (2006) 39 New York University Journal of International Law and Politics 1, 63. On the various justifications adduced for the binding nature of pacta sunt servanda, see Koskenniemi (n 11) at 311–12. Richard Hyland traces the origin of the idea of pacta sunt servanda, the idea that promises (sovereign will) or agreements (contract) must be kept (ie, that the law should follow morality), to Samuel Pufendorf, De Jure Naturae et Gentium Libri Octo (1688), concluding that two ideas underpinned its conception: that the relationship between the sovereign and subject (within the state) and between sovereigns was governed by a moral framework, and that (in contrast to Hobbes) the state of nature was a state of peace
Columns Design Ltd
/
Job: Wheatley
/
Division: 03_TheWestphalianparadigm
/Pg. Position: 12 /
Date: 13/5
JOBNAME: Wheatley PAGE: 13 SESS: 3 OUTPUT: Tue May 11 14:32:06 2010
Law-Making Treaties
135
Friedrich Kratochwil argues that the contractual analogy ‘“solved” the problem of how “persons of sovereign authority” were to relate to each other in international politics’, allowing the voluntary creation of international law rights and obligations, ‘while at the same time preserving the sovereigns’ independence and authority’.68 The right to contract is an aspect of private law. It subjects the (economic) relations of autonomous actors to agreed law norms defined at a particular moment in time. Democracy is an ongoing process of debate, deliberation and choice; it is not logically possible to ground the democratic legitimacy of international law in the consent of states. Analogous to constitutional law norms, an international norm commits the people to a standard of behaviour that is not subject to review or repeal through ‘normal’ (domestic) politics and democratic will-formation. Whilst constitutional law norms remain ultimately subject to the will of the people, through reform or (legal) revolution, international law norms are only subject to reform, modification or repeal with the consent of other states parties to an agreement. Even if a treaty were ratified only by democratic states, following extensive forms of democratic deliberation and review at the domestic level, it would not enjoy democratic legitimacy on an ongoing basis: ‘consent lies properly within the domain of contracts, not democratic politics[,] [which must take into account] the present-day wishes of present-day citizens’.69
LAW-MAKING TREATIES
The establishment of an inter-state bilateral (contract-like) instrument is (according to the standard argument) undertaken through self-interested bargaining that results in a mutually beneficial agreement. Sovereignty and democratic self-determination are protected to the extent that the agreement is concluded in the absence of coercion or manipulation (and in accordance with the will of the people). The difficulties inherent in the contractual analogy becomes apparent with the change in the nature of international law from a bilateral model of inter-state bargaining to a governance system of international public law regulation, much of which and gaps in the law of nature could be filled by agreement: Richard Hyland, ‘Pacta Sunt Servanda: A Meditation’ (1993/4) 34 Virginia Journal of International Law 405, 423. See also Hans Wehberg, ‘Pacta Sunt Servanda’ (1959) 53 American Journal of International Law 775. 68 Friedrich Kratochwil, ‘The Limits of Contract’ (1994) European Journal of International Law 465, 465 (references omitted). 69 Owen Fiss, ‘The Autonomy of Law’ (2001) 26 Yale Journal of International Law 517, 525. Fiss concludes that international human rights tribunals should be regarded ‘as a loss for democracy even though these tribunals further justice’: ibid at 526.
Columns Design Ltd
/
Job: Wheatley
/
Division: 03_TheWestphalianparadigm
/Pg. Position: 13 /
Date: 26/3
JOBNAME: Wheatley PAGE: 14 SESS: 3 OUTPUT: Tue May 11 14:32:06 2010
136 The State as (Democratic) Self-Legislator is greatly intrusive in domestic social, economic and political life. Brownlie points to a general distinction in the literature between treaties ‘involving bargains between states’, which are ‘like contracts’, and multilateral treaties creating either a set of rules, or an institution, which may be referred to as ‘law-making’.70 Law-making treaties are often the product of conferences of the negotiating parties (or series of conferences) within formal diplomatic settings. The development can be seen as a more ‘democratic’ method than bilateral treaty negotiations, facilitating values of ‘discussion, negotiation, compromise, persuasion, influence and participation’.71 Boyle and Chinkin accept that ‘leading states’ remain highly influential,72 but conclude that broad participation in multilateral law-making fora ‘enhances the democratic nature of the process’.73 This is particularly the case ‘when the negotiating power of individual states, however small, is strengthened by consensus negotiating procedures’.74 Consensus is defined as ‘the absence of any formal objection’.75 Where consensus is required, democratic states cannot be subject to obligations that do not enjoy the support of the people, provided that domestic institutions function effectively.76 A particular focus for the negotiation of ‘hard’ and ‘soft’ international law instruments has been the UN General Assembly. International lawmaking through such institutions creates a number of problems for regarding the state as a ‘self-legislator’ as the influence of any one state is 70 Ian Brownlie, Principles of Public International Law, 7th edn (Oxford, Oxford University Press, 2008) 637. 71 Alan Boyle and Christine Chinkin, The Making of International Law (Oxford, Oxford University Press, 2007) 100. 72 ibid at 30. 73 ibid at 21. 74 ibid at 102. Others take a different view. BS Chimni concludes that multilateral law-making fails to ensure the ‘meaningful participation of third world states’: BS Chimni, ‘International Institutions Today: an Imperial Global State in the Making’ (2004) 15 European Journal of International Law 1, 33; Gregory Shaffer criticises the ‘green room’ practices in the World Trade Organization (WTO), whereby the officials leading a negotiation will invite selected governments into a room to hammer out a deal that is later presented to the entire membership: Gregory Shaffer, ‘Parliamentary Oversight of WTO Rule-Making: the Political, Normative, and Practical Contexts’ (2004) 7 Journal of International Economic Law 629, 631. See also Steve Charnovitz, ‘The Emergence of Democratic Participation in Global Governance (Paris, 1919)’ (2003) 10 Indiana Journal of Global Legal Studies 45, 49. 75 United Nations Convention on the Law of the Sea 1833 UNTS 3 art 161(8)(e). 76 Deficits in the practice of democracy at the domestic level are not the focus of this work, although it is evident that one part of the solution lies in the greater involvement of national parliaments in the scrutiny of foreign policy and activities of international institutions. This is a role that national parliaments, with the exception of the US Congress, have failed to perform. See Anne-Marie Slaughter, ‘Building Global Democracy’ (2000) 1 Chicago Journal of International Law 223, 228; also, ‘Cardoso’ Report of the Panel of Eminent Persons on United Nations–Civil Society Relations, ‘We the peoples: civil society, the United Nations and global governance’ UN Doc A/58/817, 11 June 2004, para 187; and General Assembly (GA) Res 60/1, ‘2005 World Summit Outcome’ (adopted without a vote on 16 September 2005) paras 171–72.
Columns Design Ltd
/
Job: Wheatley
/
Division: 03_TheWestphalianparadigm
/Pg. Position: 14 /
Date: 26/3
JOBNAME: Wheatley PAGE: 15 SESS: 3 OUTPUT: Tue May 11 14:32:06 2010
Law-Making Treaties
137
reduced in multilateral negotiations, with the consequence that the outcome of treaty negotiations is less likely to reflect initial preferences; further, most treaty negotiations are undertaken in public, allowing arguments to be subject to scrutiny, and pressure brought to bear on negotiations by domestic and international non-governmental organisations. The complex nature of diplomatic negotiations and need to accommodate divergent (and possibly conflicting) perspectives in a consensus agreement often leads to the adoption of open-textured instruments that contain little in the way of specific detail. In contrast to contractual documents, the agreement subjects the states parties to a particular (if indeterminate) modus vivendi. The approach might promote inter-state cooperation, but it limits the influence of domestic publics on the development of international law norms, and empowers international lawyers, who interpret the scope and content of (indeterminate) norms. The development is particularly significant in relation to framework conventions, the notable feature of which is the deliberate indeterminacy, at least initially, of the obligations of states parties. The principal obligation is to participate in the collective development of international law norms at quasi-institutionalised conferences or meetings of the parties.77 The approach has been noteworthy in relation to environmental agreements. Examples include the Vienna Convention for the Protection of the Ozone Layer,78 and Montreal Protocol;79 and the UN Framework Convention on Climate Change,80 and Kyoto Protocol.81 Laurence Helfer outlines the distinctive nature of the ‘framework-protocol’ approach. First, states convene a diplomatic conference to discuss a problem relating to the global environment and possible responses. The conference concludes with the adoption of a ‘“shallow” treaty that contains relatively modest commitments’. The treaty expresses the shared concern of states parties and their commitment to find a solution; creates mechanisms for the gathering and sharing of information; and adopts a structure for future negotiations. The next stage involves the ‘expansion, tightening, speeding-up or other adjustment of the parties’ commitments’. Here, the ‘framework-protocol’ approach deviates from a consent-based approach to international law-making, through the use of majority or qualified majority voting systems, and the entry into force of
77 José E. Alvarez, ‘International Organizations: Then and Now’ (2006) 100 American Journal of International Law 324, 330. 78 Vienna Convention for the Protection of the Ozone Layer 1513 UNTS 293. 79 Montreal Protocol on Substances that Deplete the Ozone Layer 1522 UNTS 3. 80 UN Framework Convention on Climate Change 1771 UNTS 107. 81 Kyoto Protocol to the United Nations Framework Convention on Climate Change 2303 UNTS 148.
Columns Design Ltd
/
Job: Wheatley
/
Division: 03_TheWestphalianparadigm
/Pg. Position: 15 /
Date: 26/3
JOBNAME: Wheatley PAGE: 16 SESS: 2 OUTPUT: Tue May 11 14:32:06 2010
138 The State as (Democratic) Self-Legislator instruments without the need for state-by-state ratification.82 Whilst the instrument may permit a state to object (preventing its entry into force in relation to the dissenting state), the ‘majority-adoption rules and tacitacceptance procedures [grant] de facto lawmaking powers to the “conference of the parties” for each agreement, transforming those treaty-based collective bodies “into issue-specific equivalents of global legislatures”.’83
DELIBERATIVE DIPLOMACY
Diplomacy is an essential mechanism for the development of international law norms, which reflect the political will of states.84 The idea of contract can explain the establishment of inter-state agreements, but not the authority, or (democratic) legitimacy, of international law norms (or international law).85 In terms of democratic legitimacy, a significant body of political thought argues that where a political community exhibits significant and persistent disagreements between different groups, defined by reference to ethno-cultural identity and the absence of a common sense of political identity, it is better to give precedence to bargaining or ‘consociational’ procedures. Consociational democracy provides for the introduction of a power-sharing scheme that requires political elites to bargain in the interests of their respective group. The system should allow for political self-determination within each group (often defined by reference to territory), and provide mechanisms for group cooperation and bargaining over public goods. It should also protect minority communities against any tyranny of majority rule. There are four central features in the consociational model, which is associated
82 Laurence R. Helfer, ‘Nonconsensual International Lawmaking’ (2008) University of Illinois Law Review 71, 84. 83 ibid at 85 (references omitted). 84 In United States Diplomatic and Consular Staff in Tehran, the International Court of Justice observed that the institution of diplomacy has proved to be ‘an instrument essential for effective co-operation in the international community, and for enabling States, irrespective of their differing constitutional and social systems, to achieve mutual understanding and to resolve their differences by peaceful means’: United States Diplomatic and Consular Staff in Tehran (United States of America v Iran) [1980] ICJ Rep 3 [91]. 85 The idea that contractual autonomy might provide democratic legitimacy for international law norms creates a number of difficulties, not least that it might hold democracies to higher standards of compliance with international law norms than non-democracies. Consider, for example, a bilateral treaty between a democratic state and authoritarian state for the processing of dangerous waste in the latter. Given that the people of the authoritarian state cannot be said to have meaningfully ‘consented’ to the arrangement, a change of government might provide a democratic right to repudiate the treaty.
Columns Design Ltd
/
Job: Wheatley
/
Division: 03_TheWestphalianparadigm
/Pg. Position: 16 /
Date: 26/2
JOBNAME: Wheatley PAGE: 17 SESS: 3 OUTPUT: Tue May 11 14:32:06 2010
Deliberative Diplomacy
139
most closely with the work of Arend Lijphart:86 a grand coalition, or power sharing executive; proportionate allocation of public goods, such as resources and opportunities; minority veto; and segmental autonomy, often defined in terms of territorial autonomy.87 A number of writers have sought to read the international system in light of the model, with states replacing ethno-cultural groups as the sub-entities with competing and conflicting interests. Margaret Moore, for example, argues that the consociational model can explain the democratic legitimacy of international organisations in that the participation of governments ensures that ‘each political community has a “voice” and some influence over policies in the international organizations’.88 The function of national political leaders is to bargain hard on behalf of citizens over the distribution of international public goods, not to promote the general interest. Other consociational features may be read into the inter-state system, including the principle of consent (minority veto), and sovereignty and nonintervention (territorial autonomy). To the extent that the consociational model is consistent with the principles of democracy (and I have argued elsewhere that it is not),89 global governance is democratically legitimate to the extent that it develops and sustains consociational institutions and structures.90 Though superficially attractive, the argument for reading the democratic legitimacy of international law in terms of consociational practices is ultimately unconvincing. In the practice of consociational politics, there is a logic of political extremism, as representatives bargain hard over political goods in a zero-sum game. Bargaining is characterised by actors seeking to achieve pre-determined objectives ‘by exchanging demands backed by credible promises, threats, or exit opportunities’. The
86 See, for example, Arend Lijphart, ‘Consociational Democracy’ (1969) 21 World Politics 207; and Arend Lijphart, ‘The Wave of Power-Sharing Democracy’ in Andrew Reynolds (ed), The Architecture of Democracy: Constitutional Design, Conflict Management and Democracy (Oxford, Oxford University Press, 2002) 37. 87 Arend Lijphart, ‘Self-Determination Versus Pre-Determination of Ethnic Minorities in Power-Sharing Systems’ in Will Kymlicka (ed), The Rights of Minority Cultures (Oxford, Oxford University Press, 1995) 275, 278. 88 Margaret Moore, ‘Globalization and Democratization: Institutional Design for Global Institutions’ (2006) 37 Journal of Social Philosophy 21, 38. 89 Steven Wheatley, Democracy, Minorities and International Law (Cambridge, Cambridge University Press, 2005) 166–67. In a democratic society, governments emerge from an electoral process that constitutes an expression of the ‘will of the people’. The state may facilitate a more representative executive through its choice of electoral system, or constitutional rules on the allocation of cabinet seats, etc. The idea of democracy does not, however, allow for political leaders to decide in advance who will share power. Consociational democracy is not compatible with the right to democracy recognised in international law. Elite power sharing can only be justified in the initial transition from conflict to democracy by reference to ideas of transitional justice 90 See Anne Peters, ‘European Democracy after the 2003 Convention’ (2003) 41 Common Market Law Review 37, 84.
Columns Design Ltd
/
Job: Wheatley
/
Division: 03_TheWestphalianparadigm
/Pg. Position: 17 /
Date: 26/3
JOBNAME: Wheatley PAGE: 18 SESS: 2 OUTPUT: Tue May 11 14:32:06 2010
140 The State as (Democratic) Self-Legislator goal is to maximise given preferences. In the absence of significant disparities in power, which make threats credible, bargaining is unlikely to be effective. Thomas Risse observes that bargaining is only one of three possible ways in which states may communicate with each other, and it is the least likely to be successful in terms of allowing for inter-state cooperation. The second concerns the use of rhetoric, whereby states attempt to persuade others ‘that they should change their views of the world, their normative beliefs, their preferences, and even their identities’, but do not accept that they may be persuaded by the arguments of others.91 The use of rhetoric is not discursive, although it implies certain discursive practices, as participants cannot simply repeat their positions in the expectations that others will eventually be persuaded. The third possibility, drawing on Jürgen Habermas’ theory of communicative action, is to understand diplomatic conversations as a process of ‘arguing’, understood in terms of giving reasons (not heated discussions). Arguing occurs where the focus of diplomacy is on achieving a reasoned consensus, and not the realisation of some pre-determined objectives: ‘Successful arguing means that the ‘‘better argument’’ carries the day.’92 In the process of ‘arguing’, states must be prepared to change their positions when faced with a ‘better argument’. It is an application of Habermas’ principle of discourse: ‘D: Just those action norms are valid to which all possible affected persons could agree as participants in rational discourses.’ Where actors deliberate about the truth, or ‘argue’, they are engaged in a form of collective communication that aims to establish whether their assumptions about the world are correct (theoretical discourses), and which norms should apply under given circumstances (practical discourses). Actors will challenge the claims of others, and must accept that their claims will be subject to challenge. The aim is to establish a ‘communicative consensus about their understanding of a situation as well as justifications for the principles and norms guiding their action’. All participants must accept that their position will be changed when faced with the force of the better argument, with relationships of power and social hierarchies receding in the background.93 In a truth-seeking or argumentative process, interests and identities are not fixed, ‘but subject to interrogation and challenges and, thus, to change’.
91 Thomas Risse, ‘“Let’s argue!”: Communicative Action in World Politics’ (2000) 54 International Organization 1, 8 (references omitted). Goldsmith and Posner observe that states provide legal justifications for their actions, no matter how transparently selfinterested those actions may be: Jack Goldsmith and Eric Posner, The Limits of International Law (Oxford, Oxford University Press, 2005) 169. Whilst ‘talk is cheap’, the failure of a state to send such a signal would reveal that it belongs to the ‘bad type’, and would not be a good cooperative partner: ibid at 174. 92 ibid at 9. 93 ibid at 7.
Columns Design Ltd
/
Job: Wheatley
/
Division: 03_TheWestphalianparadigm
/Pg. Position: 18 /
Date: 26/2
JOBNAME: Wheatley PAGE: 19 SESS: 3 OUTPUT: Tue May 11 14:32:06 2010
Deliberative Diplomacy
141
The objective is an argumentative consensus, not the imposition of a particular world vision.94 Elsewhere, Risse observes that interests, preferences and perceptions in a process of deliberative diplomacy are subject to discursive challenges: Where argumentative rationality prevails, actors do not seek to maximize or to satisfy their given interests and preferences, but to challenge and to justify the validity claims inherent in them – and are prepared to change their views of the world or even their interests in light of the better argument.95
Communicative processes oriented toward achieving mutual understanding presuppose a counterfactual ideal speech situation, in which actors try to persuade each other, and are themselves open to being convinced: ‘The goal of the discursive interaction is to achieve argumentative consensus with the other, not to push through one’s own view of the world or moral values.’ Argumentative rationality requires the existence of a number of preconditions: the ability to empathise, to see the world through the eyes of others; participants must share a ‘common lifeworld’, a common understanding of the world, and their role and that of other participants in the world, and a common system of norms and rules perceived as legitimate to which actors refer in the process of argumentation.96 Further, actors must recognise each other as equals, and have equal access to the discourse, which must also be open to other participants and be public in nature. The pre-conditions for argumentative rationality in the international community are provided by the mutual recognition of sovereign states as equals, and by the common lifeworld reflected in the rules of the international law game.97 Habermas observes that international law ‘lays down the rules of the game’, the qualifications that potential participants must satisfy (effective control of the population of a territory), the admission requirement (recognition), and the idea of status, or sovereignty, including rights of nonintervention, and the right to participate as a full member of the international law system.98
94 ibid at 10. Habermas observes that there is no alternative to ‘multilateral willformation in interstate relations’ because no state, ‘even the good hegemon’, can know better what is good for others, or ‘equally good for all. There is no sensible alternative to the ongoing development of international law into a cosmopolitan order that offers an equal and reciprocal hearing for the voices of all those affected’: Jürgen Habermas, ‘Interpreting the Fall of a Monument’ (2003) 4 German Law Journal 701, 708. 95 Thomas Risse, ‘Global Governance and Communicative Action’ (2004) 39 Government and Opposition 288, 294 (emphasis in original). 96 Risse (n 91) at 10. 97 Ibid at 11. 98 Jürgen Habermas, ‘Does the Constitutionalization of International Law Still Have a Chance?’ in The Divided West (ed and trans Ciaran Cronin) (Cambridge, Polity, 2006) 115, 119.
Columns Design Ltd
/
Job: Wheatley
/
Division: 03_TheWestphalianparadigm
/Pg. Position: 19 /
Date: 26/3
JOBNAME: Wheatley PAGE: 20 SESS: 3 OUTPUT: Tue May 11 14:32:06 2010
142 The State as (Democratic) Self-Legislator One of the difficulties in applying any concept of democratic legitimacy to the international law order is the differences in power between the various actors. Relations of power impact on the possibility of truth-seeking (ie the formation of international laws in accordance with the requirements of communicative reason) in one of two ways: by restricting access to the deliberations (consider, for example, the limited membership of the UN Security Council), and by limiting what counts as a good argument.99 The issue is not whether power relations are present in international relations (they are), but the extent to which they explain the ‘argumentative outcome’. The following are examples of inappropriate recourse to bargaining or rhetoric, rather than discourse: where actors refer to their status as being relevant in determining outcome (consider, for example, the idea that there are civilised and non-civilised states); where actors change their position simply to win the argument (actors must display ‘argumentative consistency’); and any assumption that ‘the materially more powerful actors’ have the better arguments.100 Risse concludes that processes of arguing are more likely to occur the more actors are uncertain about their interests and even identities; the less actors know about the situation in which they find themselves and about the underlying ‘rules of the game’ (‘common knowledge’); and the more apparently irreconcilable differences prevent them from reaching an optimal rather than a merely satisfactory solution for a widely perceived problem (‘problem solving’).101
In the (hypothetical) ideal speech situation, (democratic) norms emerge through inter-state discussions though an application of the principle of communicative reason applied to the international law of states. Valid international law norms must enjoy the consent of all possible affected states in rational discourses. This does not presuppose that all possible outcomes are equally legitimate or equally possible. A state would not, for example, accept a proposal that excluded it from future deliberations, regarded its arguments as inferior, or removed its status as a member of the international community. The requirement of rational deliberations and application of the consensus principle prescribes a mechanism for the conduct of diplomatic conversations and discovery of political truths in the international law order, and (logically) proscribes certain (democratic) ‘truths’ from being revealed. Consider, for example, the argument that small states should be regarded as being in an inferior relationship to other states, as was proposed in relation to (very) small states in the
99 100 101
Columns Design Ltd
Risse (n 91) at 16. ibid at 18. ibid at 33.
/
Job: Wheatley
/
Division: 03_TheWestphalianparadigm
/Pg. Position: 20 /
Date: 26/3
JOBNAME: Wheatley PAGE: 21 SESS: 3 OUTPUT: Tue May 11 14:32:06 2010
Deliberative Diplomacy
143
UN.102 The argument undermines the idea of sovereignty, and would not be accepted by those affected (ie very small states). The requirements for democratic legitimacy in the international law system are a justificatory legal discourse that leads to a negotiated consensus. Ian Johnstone explains: ‘It is a distinctive form of deliberation, or style of argument, that requires a decision to be justified in terms that those who are subject to it can accept, even if they disagree with the decision itself.’103 Self-interested arguments will not persuade others. Participants in consensus-seeking deliberations must rely on ‘generalizable principles, impartial reasons, and arguments that reach beyond narrow self-interest’ to convince others to change their position, and they must be prepared to listen and reflect on the arguments of others. Whilst it is ‘an open question’ as to whether the ideal of deliberative democracy is possible in international relations, there is evidence of legal discourse and argumentation within the international community. States justify their actions largely in terms of international law, and challenge other states to justify their actions in the same terms. The requirement to engage in ‘meaningful legal discourse [and give reasons] generates an expectation that claims will be based on conventions of argument and discourse that operate in the discipline of international law’. Once international relations are framed in terms of law, they operate within the disciplinary constraints of an interpretive community, given that legal discourse, ‘by extension, entails appeals to legal norms as they are understood not by each actor individually (subjectively) or in some abstract sense (objectively), but together as a collective law-interpreting body (inter-subjectively)’.104 States must offer reasonable arguments in diplomatic conversations within a shared understanding about the rules that structure inter-state relations. International law defines and delimits the possibilities of argumentation and justification, ie what counts as a good argument. There are two objections to developing a concept of democratic legitimacy on this basis: first, that governments ‘merely pay lip service to the law and, because international law is so malleable, a legal justification can be found for any action’; and, secondly, that powerful actors ‘so dominate the interpretive community that they are able to control the terms of discourse, resulting in legal judgments that invariably suit their
102 Michael Gunter, ‘What Happened to the United Nations Ministate Problem?’ (1977) 71 American Journal of International Law 110. 103 Ian Johnstone, ‘The Plea of “Necessity” in International Legal Discourse: Humanitarian Intervention and Counter-Terrorism’ (2005) 43 Columbia Journal of Transnational Law (2005) 337, 380. 104 ibid at 381.
Columns Design Ltd
/
Job: Wheatley
/
Division: 03_TheWestphalianparadigm
/Pg. Position: 21 /
Date: 26/3
JOBNAME: Wheatley PAGE: 22 SESS: 3 OUTPUT: Tue May 11 14:32:06 2010
144 The State as (Democratic) Self-Legislator interests and wishes’.105 There is, though, a limit to which any legitimating language, including the language of law, can plausibly be stretched. Rich and powerful states may be better able to shape global discourses, and ‘dominant actors are better able to write and amend the rules of the game’. They cannot, however, change those rules (and shift the terms of debate) instantaneously and at will. To the extent that they engage in deliberations at all, they are obliged to respect the conventions of argument, persuasion, and justification associated with the particular enterprise in which the deliberations occur.106
The analysis developed by Risse and Johnstone presents important insights for accepting the democratic legitimacy of international law, one that depends on the ability of states to develop democratic ‘truths’ through a process of communicative reason that approximates to the deliberative ideal. In the (hypothetical) ideal speech situation, international law norms should enjoy the consent of all possible affected states in rational discourses. The requirement of rational deliberations and application of the consensus principle prescribes a mechanism for the conduct of diplomatic conversations and discovery of political truths in the international law order, a form of deliberatively diplomacy. The analysis is limited in that not all international law norms can be regarded as an expression of sovereign will, consider for example the development of customary international law (below) and increased reliance on treaties, UN resolutions and other sources for the identification of state practice and customary norms. It is though important in emphasising the requirement of reason and reasoned deliberation. Jens Steffek argues that legitimacy in the modern age ‘is derived from the authority of reason. “Reasoning” or “giving reasons” is the communicative process that legitimates governance.’ The characteristic feature of legitimate global governance is evidence of reasoned argumentation that results in a consensus amongst participants, and it is noteworthy that many forms of inter-state relations ‘are guided by a unanimity rule’, in which ‘all contracting parties need to agree explicitly to the values, goals and procedures of the future regime’.107 Reasoned deliberations leading to consensus is not, however, sufficient to legitimate global governance in the long term. The existence of an international law agreement reflects the fact that states have decided ‘that a certain political goal shall be pursued by the international community for a particular reason’. The agreement will only remain legitimate ‘as long as there is agreement on the values to be realized, the means to be employed and the procedures to be followed’.108 Steffek’s 105
ibid at 382–83. ibid at 383. 107 Jens Steffek, ‘The Legitimation of International Governance: a Discourse Approach’ (2003) 9 European Journal of International Relations 249, 263. 108 ibid at 264. 106
Columns Design Ltd
/
Job: Wheatley
/
Division: 03_TheWestphalianparadigm
/Pg. Position: 22 /
Date: 26/3
JOBNAME: Wheatley PAGE: 23 SESS: 3 OUTPUT: Tue May 11 14:32:06 2010
The Indeterminacy of International Law Obligations
145
argument restates the problem of accepting the (ongoing) democratic legitimacy of an inter-state agreement following consensus (deliberative or otherwise) at a particular point in time. International law norms agreed through deliberative processes of diplomacy are more democratic than those that result from other processes (indeed, we might accept them as the democratic laws of the international system), but the problem for democracy remains at the domestic level, as the people can no longer decide all those issues that are politically decidable.
THE INDETERMINACY OF INTERNATIONAL LAW OBLIGATIONS
The function of international lawyers is to judge the conduct of the parties to an international law dispute in accordance with existing law, ie to apply relevant laws to established facts. In many cases the content of international law norms will be the subject of (reasonable) disagreement (the existence of a dispute involves recognition that there are at least two possible interpretations of the scope and content of a law norm). In bilateral relations, where only the states parties are involved, a dispute can only be resolved (within the framework of international law) in accordance with the will of both parties.109 The submission of a dispute to an international court or tribunal involves a rejection of the (sovereign) right of a state to define its obligations under international law (‘state as self-legislator’). The issue becomes one of interpretation of the rights and obligations contained in international law rules and instruments. In Territorial Dispute (Libyan Arab Jamahiriya/Chad), the International Court of Justice affirmed that the rules for the interpretation of treaties in the Vienna Convention on the Law of Treaties reflect a customary international law norm, and that interpretation must be based above all upon the text of the treaty.110 Article 31, the general rule of interpretation, provides that a treaty ‘shall be interpreted in good faith in accordance with the ordinary meaning to be given to the terms of the treaty in their context and in the light of its object and purpose’.111 The consent of the parties is more important than the ordinary usages of language: ‘[a] special meaning shall be given to a term if it is established that the parties so intended’.112 In addition to the context,113 interpretation shall take into 109 cf Charter of the United Nations art 33(1): ‘The parties to any dispute, the continuance of which is likely to endanger the maintenance of international peace and security, shall, first of all, seek a solution by negotiation, enquiry, mediation, conciliation, arbitration, judicial settlement, resort to regional agencies or arrangements, or other peaceful means of their own choice.’ 110 Territorial Dispute (Libyan Arab Jamahiriya/Chad) Judgment [1994] ICJ Rep 6 [41]. 111 Vienna Convention on the Law of Treaties 1155 UNTS 331 art 31(1). 112 ibid art 31(4).
Columns Design Ltd
/
Job: Wheatley
/
Division: 03_TheWestphalianparadigm
/Pg. Position: 23 /
Date: 26/3
JOBNAME: Wheatley PAGE: 24 SESS: 3 OUTPUT: Tue May 11 14:32:06 2010
146 The State as (Democratic) Self-Legislator account any subsequent agreement between the parties regarding the interpretation of the treaty,114 or practice in its application, which establishes the agreement of the parties regarding its interpretation.115 Reference may also be had to relevant rules of international law applicable in the relations between the parties.116 Article 32 refers to ‘supplementary means of interpretation’, including the preparatory work (travaux préparatoires) leading to the agreement on the text of the treaty, and the circumstances of its conclusion, which may be relied upon to confirm the meaning resulting from application of the general rule of interpretation, or determine the meaning when the application of the rules of interpretation in article 31 leaves the meaning ambiguous or obscure, or leads to a result which is manifestly absurd or unreasonable.117 Alexander Orakhelashvili concludes that in selecting the methods of interpretation of international law norms, the focus is ‘not what academics [and others] want or perceive them to be, or what could under certain circumstances be sensible, sound, reasonable or agreeable, but what is agreed by and as between States in one way or another’.118 The methods of interpretation reflected in articles 31 and 32 ‘serve the inherent rationale of interpretation – to clarify the meaning of legal norms and instruments on the basis of their rationale’. In determining the appropriate method, what matters are the ‘exigencies [that] follow from the inherent consensual and contractual character of the relevant rules and instruments’. International law instruments do not ‘just embody the intention of the entity that adopts them, but also they are understood in terms of their face value and plain meaning’. The intention of the parties is constrained by the language used to express that intention: ‘The methods of interpretation are aimed at preserving the original consent, will and intention behind the relevant legal instrument and thus at ensuring the determinacy of the relevant provision by enabling its application to facts.’119 Herein lies the difficulty: international law disputes reflect conflicting views as to the law (or less problematically for these purposes the
113 See ibid art 31(2): ‘The context for the purpose of the interpretation of a treaty shall comprise, in addition to the text, including its preamble and annexes: (a) Any agreement relating to the treaty which was made between all the parties in connection with the conclusion of the treaty; (b) Any instrument which was made by one or more parties in connection with the conclusion of the treaty and accepted by the other parties as an instrument related to the treaty.’ 114 ibid art 31(2)(a). 115 ibid art 31(2)(b). 116 ibid art 31(2)(c). 117 ibid art 32. 118 Alexander Orakhelashvili, The Interpretation of Acts and Rules of Public International Law (Oxford, Oxford University Press, 2008) 288 (emphasis in original). 119 ibid at 584.
Columns Design Ltd
/
Job: Wheatley
/
Division: 03_TheWestphalianparadigm
/Pg. Position: 24 /
Date: 26/3
JOBNAME: Wheatley PAGE: 25 SESS: 3 OUTPUT: Tue May 11 14:32:06 2010
The Indeterminacy of International Law Obligations
147
relevant facts). In Orakhelashvili’s terms, disputes reflect conflicting views as to the original consent, will and intention behind the relevant international instrument. Both parties cannot be right: there must be some objective understanding of the original consent, will and intention of at least one of the parties that is at variance with its understanding of the law. Martti Koskenniemi argues that international law disputes are always hard cases, requiring an exercise of (judicial) discretion,120 because each disputing state will be able to ‘make a prima facie justification of their action by referring to their sovereign liberty’. In order to resolve the dispute, the judge/law-applier must reach a conclusion that ‘privilege[s] one sovereign over another in a manner that necessitates the construction of a hierarchy of values for evaluating sovereign action’.121 The possibility of not deciding is not present; the dispute must be resolved by objective reference to international law.122 The only alternative would be to accept the subjective position of each state as to what it regards as binding law at a particular moment in time. Where the state denies that it has consented to an international law norm, or a particular interpretation, the standard response is to rely on tacit consent. But this assumes either that the law-applier ‘can know-better’ what the state has consented to, or that there is ‘some non-acceptance-related criterion whereby we can judge whether acceptance is present or not’.123 Where the position of the state is not accepted, the imposition of international law obligations no longer relies on the ‘expressed will of the legal subject’.124 What law means will depend on the judgment of the lawapplier.125 In cases of conflict between the sovereign rights of states (where the Lotus principle is not helpful), balancing seems necessary in order to reach a decision,126 with judicial practice supporting the conclusion.127 Balancing involves ‘making political compromises’.128 It is, though, problematic from the perspective of sovereignty: What basis is there to impose a balance… on a State which has not accepted it? To argue that it is binding because other States have accepted it fails to explain why a State should be bound by other States’ subjective values. This is manifestly contrary to its sovereign equality.129
120
cf Ronald Dworkin, Taking Rights Seriously (London, Duckworth, 1977) ch 4. Koskenniemi (n 11) at 43. 122 ibid at 63. 123 ibid ay 64. 124 Martti Koskenniemi, ‘The Politics of International Law’ (1990) 1 European Journal of International Law 4, 22. 125 Martti Koskenniemi, ‘Constitutionalism as Mindset: Reflections on Kantian Themes about International Law and Globalization’ (2007) 8 Theoretical Inquiries in Law 9, 11. 126 Koskenniemi (n 11) at 264. 127 ibid at 267. 128 ibid at 268. 129 ibid at 269 (emphasis in original). 121
Columns Design Ltd
/
Job: Wheatley
/
Division: 03_TheWestphalianparadigm
/Pg. Position: 25 /
Date: 26/3
JOBNAME: Wheatley PAGE: 26 SESS: 3 OUTPUT: Tue May 11 14:32:06 2010
148 The State as (Democratic) Self-Legislator Koskenniemi concludes that the success of modern international law depends on its ‘refusal to set down determining rules or ready-made resolutions to future conflict’. International law appears to be ‘an elaborate framework for deferring substantive resolution elsewhere: into further procedure, interpretation, equity, context, and so on’.130 His indeterminacy thesis builds on the work of critical legal studies scholars,131 who argue that indeterminacy is inherent in all normative systems. In the case of systems of law norms, there is indeterminacy in the meaning of language, deliberative indeterminate in certain legal expressions (the idea of ‘reasonableness’, for example), and indeterminacy in the application of law norms, and in cases of conflict between law norms. The indeterminacy thesis concludes that law norms are too vague to be determinate of outcomes.132 It is not, David Kennedy argues, ‘meaningful to speak of a particular solution to a legal problem as having being compelled by a line of reasoning’.133 The ‘unstructured indeterminacy’ of international law ‘results from the manipulability of the basic norms out of which international legal discourse is constructed’.134 There is no international law doctrine that does not involve a conflict ‘between autonomy and cooperation of states, because by definition no international legal issue is raised until the interests of states collide’.135 Indeterminacy results from conflicting ideas about sovereignty, between sovereignty understood as authority (‘an internationalist vision of sharing’) and sovereignty as equality (a ‘nationalist vision of exclusive domestic power’). International law disputes can be articulated and/or resolved by reference to the objective standard of sovereign consent, or by reference to some ‘subjective solution [that] would bring values beyond consent into the process’.136 International law discourse, Kennedy argues, is ‘conversation without content – a ritualized exchange which avoids confronting the very question it purports to address’. Legal disputes may be resolved at a point in time, but this does not reflect the power of legal argument, but the imposition of an ‘underlying value choice’, or exercise of coercion.137
130
Koskenniemi (n 124) at 28. See, especially, Duncan Kennedy, ‘The Structure of Blackstone’s Commentaries’ (1979) 28 Buffalo Law Review 205. 132 Lawrence Solum, ‘On the Indeterminacy Crisis: Critiquing Critical Dogma’ (1987) 54 University of Chicago Law Review 462, 462. The focus is the judicial process; the indeterminacy thesis does not expressly take into account the fact that most legal norms are accepted and applied by actors without recourse to formal legal procedures: ibid at 496–97. 133 David Kennedy, ‘Theses about International Law Discourse’ (1980) 23 German Yearbook of International Law 353, 357. 134 ibid at 359. 135 ibid at 362. 136 ibid at 368. 137 ibid at 376. 131
Columns Design Ltd
/
Job: Wheatley
/
Division: 03_TheWestphalianparadigm
/Pg. Position: 26 /
Date: 26/3
JOBNAME: Wheatley PAGE: 27 SESS: 3 OUTPUT: Tue May 11 14:32:06 2010
The Indeterminacy of International Law Obligations
149
The indeterminacy argument present a significant problem for regarding the international law system as democratically legitimate, in that it seeks to demonstrate that legal argument and judgment is nothing more than the concealed expressions of arbitrary opinion, personal preferences or political convictions of the law-interpreter/law-applier. International law obligations are not the result of sovereign (and democratic) will, but the legislative acts of ‘others’, notably judges on international courts and tribunals. The indeterminacy thesis should caution us against any arguments that international lawyers are simply articulating some objective truth inherent in the logic of international law norms, and to examine the texts produced by international lawyers (including those sitting in a judicial capacity) for concealed political preferences (including cosmopolitan and humanitarian preferences). It should not though require that we give up on the possibilities of public international law determining the ‘legal’ position of states and other non-state actors. Stephen Toope makes the point that indeterminacy provides scope for divergent legal arguments in cases of conflicting interpretations, it does not ‘render discourse meaningless’.138 Moreover, as Isaiah Berlin observes, the ‘right answer’ thesis, which the indeterminacy thesis critiques, depends on a utopian claim concerning the metaphysics of values and of normative justification. It assumes that ‘all questions in the domain have one answer, that is knowable, and that all the answers in the realm are mutually compatible’. Such assumptions are ‘inconsistent with our experiences’ and ‘misdiagnose the nature of practical arguments’.139 Friedrich Kratochwil concludes that the recognition of ‘plural possibilities’ does not imply ‘the nihilist or existential conclusion that anything goes and/or that because there is no single right answer, any answer is as good as another’.140 What it demands is an investigation of indeterminacy as it arises in legal reasoning and consideration as to ‘how particular choices (out of several “possible” ones) can be justified on nonidiosyncratic grounds’.141 Legal interpretation takes place in the context of an interpretive community, and whilst there may be disagreements about the proper use of a term, or the interpretation of a legal rule, ‘purely idiosyncratic uses are excluded even if the use of the concepts remains contestable and contested’.142
138 Stephen Toope, ‘Emerging Patterns of Governance and International Law’ in Michael Byers (ed), The Role of Law in International Politics (Oxford, Oxford University Press, 2000) 91, 102. 139 Sir Isaiah Berlin, ‘The Pursuit of the Ideal’ in Berlin, The Crooked Timber of Humanity (New York, Vintage, 1991), referred to in Friedrich Kratochwil, ‘How do Norms Matter?’ in Michael Byers (ed), The Role of Law in International Politics (Oxford, Oxford University Press, 2000) 35, 46. 140 Kratochwil, ibid. at 46. 141 ibid at 46–47. 142 ibid at 52.
Columns Design Ltd
/
Job: Wheatley
/
Division: 03_TheWestphalianparadigm
/Pg. Position: 27 /
Date: 26/3
JOBNAME: Wheatley PAGE: 28 SESS: 3 OUTPUT: Tue May 11 14:32:06 2010
150 The State as (Democratic) Self-Legislator THE PROBLEM OF CUSTOMARY INTERNATIONAL LAW
The previous sections focused on the problems for democracy that result from the existence of the international law order. A constitutional democracy might express its consent to be bound by an international law norm following domestic debate, deliberation and decision (ie through democratic procedures), but limitations on the possibilities of (future) political self-determination are problematic from the perspective of democratic theory: how is it possible that the ‘here and now’ people can limit the choices available to future generations? Treaty is one of two principal mechanisms through which international law norms become opposable to the state. The other is customary international law. Custom creates particular problems in terms of democratic legitimacy, as there is no requirement that a particular state consents to the emergence of a new customary norm, or that a majority of states participate in its formation, or that only democratic states participate, or that the practices of states accord with the wills of their respective peoples. It may create particular problems for states, often those with common law systems, which recognise customary international law as part of domestic law, without the requirement for positive legislative approval. Moreover, as customary norms are, by definition, not authoritatively written down, the task of identifying and interpreting, and by implication ‘applying’, customary obligations often falls to non-state actors, judges, academics, etc, with no requirement to take into account the attitude of the state against whom the norms are opposed. The requirements for the recognition of customary international law are provided by article 38(1)(b) of the Statute of the International Court of Justice, which refers to ‘international custom, as evidence of a general practice accepted as law’. Both elements must be present: there must be evidence that ‘the existence of the rule in the opinio juris of States is confirmed by practice’.143 In contrast to treaties, the subjective opinion of states is not sufficient by itself to develop customary international law obligations;144 nor is custom the mere ‘repetition, or imitation, of similar acts’.145 The settled practice of states is not sufficient to generate international law rights and obligations. There must be ‘evidence of a belief that
143
Nicaragua v United States (Merits) [1986] ICJ Rep 14 [184]. The International Court of Justice has concluded that customary international law comprises ‘a limited set of norms for ensuring the co-existence and vital co-operation of the members of the international community, together with a set of customary rules whose presence in the opinio juris of States can be tested by induction based on the analysis of a sufficiently extensive and convincing practice, and not by deduction from preconceived ideas’: Delimitation of the Maritime Boundary in the Gulf of Maine Area (Judgment) [1984] ICJ Rep 246 [111]. 145 Koskenniemi (n 11) at 415. 144
Columns Design Ltd
/
Job: Wheatley
/
Division: 03_TheWestphalianparadigm
/Pg. Position: 28 /
Date: 26/3
JOBNAME: Wheatley PAGE: 29 SESS: 3 OUTPUT: Tue May 11 14:32:06 2010
The Problem of Customary International Law
151
this practice is rendered obligatory by the existence of a rule of law requiring it’.146 Community acceptance does not require the consent of all states: the general acceptance by a significant majority is sufficient for the recognition of a new customary international law norm, taking into account any opposition from those specially affected.147 Custom is distinguished from international treaties as a source of international law obligation ‘by its less consensual character’.148 There is no requirement that all states participate in the relevant practice, or that the practice of states is in ‘absolutely rigorous conformity with the rule’. As the International Court of Justice observed in Nicaragua v United States (Merits), it is sufficient that ‘the conduct of States should, in general, be consistent with such rules’.149 The international law system accepts that customary norms will emerge without the consent of all states, but insists that a norm will have general application. The sovereign consent of all states is not required for the development of customary international law. As the Court observed in North Sea Continental Shelf, customary norms, ‘by their very nature, must have equal force for all members of the international community, and cannot therefore be the subject of any right of unilateral exclusion exercisable at will by any one of them in its own favour’.150 Sovereignty (and the principle of consent to international law norms) is protected (in a negative manner) through the persistent objector rule. The rule, which is required to ‘safeguard non-consenting States’ sovereign equality’,151 permits, in the words of Ian Brownlie, a state to ‘contract out of a custom in the process of formation’ (note the contractual analogy): ‘Given the majoritarian tendencies of international relations the principle is likely to have increased prominence’.152 The requirement that a state object from the inception of the rule provides a significant limit on political self-determination. The only subsequent possibility is for a state is to seek the acquiesce of all other states in contracting out of the rule of customary international law.153 The people are unable to exempt themselves from the application of a customary norm that they do not accept, or that they come to realise has serious deleterious consequences for the welfare of the society, even if the rule was established prior to the establishment of the state itself, and it was not therefore possible for the state to have objected to the emergent norm. The application of the rule is
146
North Sea Continental Shelf (Judgment) [1969] ICJ Rep 3 [77]. ibid at [74]. 148 Koskenniemi (n 11) at 398. 149 Nicaragua v United States (Merits) [1986] ICJ Rep 14 [186]. 150 North Sea Continental Shelf (Judgment) [1969] ICJ Rep 3 [63]. 151 Koskenniemi (n 11) at 443. 152 Ian Brownlie, Principles of Public International Law, 7th edn (Oxford, Oxford University Press, 2008) 11. 153 ibid at 12. 147
Columns Design Ltd
/
Job: Wheatley
/
Division: 03_TheWestphalianparadigm
/Pg. Position: 29 /
Date: 26/3
JOBNAME: Wheatley PAGE: 30 SESS: 3 OUTPUT: Tue May 11 14:32:06 2010
152 The State as (Democratic) Self-Legislator particularly noteworthy in relation to states emerging from domination, including former colonies. Further, many states with limited financial, diplomatic and other resources lack the capacity to participate effectively in the formation of customary international law, or indeed object to practices that are in the process of crystallisation.154
The Role of the International Law Profession It is difficult to reconcile customary international law with the Westphalian conception of the state as self-legislator. The recognition of custom requires an acceptance that the international community of states (collectively) constitutes an authority with legislative powers. The source of authority is a social practice recognised as legally binding by the international community. In the case of customary (international) law norms, the assertion of political authority is made by a secondary or interpretive ‘observer’ (who may also be a member of the community) who claims that a ‘customary’ practice is binding as a matter of law. Authority and legitimacy are joined. The international community is the authoritative source of customary international law norms: ‘It is a community’s acceptance of norms that confers legitimacy on them.’155 Whilst the identification of the subjective element (opinio juris) will always be subject to speculation, it should be possible to identify the settled practice of states that contributes to the development of a customary international law norm. In practice, however, international courts and tribunals rarely engage in any systematic enquiry into the practices of the majority of states.156 The identification of state practice by international law professionals is essentially a subjective matter. McGinnis and Somin complain that custom suffers a ‘double democracy deficit’: the materials on which it is based ‘lack serious democratic bona fides’, and the authority to determine the status and meaning of those instruments is allocated to ‘an undemocratic and unrepresentative elite’.157 They make the following (rather illuminating) observation: ‘Elite international law professors in the United States are very unrepresentative of popular opinion, leaning Democratic rather than Republican by a ratio of over five to one… A group with such unrepresentative values is unlikely to generate representative norms.’158 154
Steven Ratner, ‘Is International Law Impartial?’ (2005) 11 Legal Theory 39, 57. J Patrick Kelly, ‘The Twilight of Customary International Law’ (2000) 40 Virginia Journal of International Law 449, 456. 156 ibid at 469. 157 John McGinnis and Ilya Somin, ‘Should International Law be Part of our Law?’ (2007) 59 Stanford Law Review 1175, 1207. 158 ibid at 1202. 155
Columns Design Ltd
/
Job: Wheatley
/
Division: 03_TheWestphalianparadigm
/Pg. Position: 30 /
Date: 26/3
JOBNAME: Wheatley PAGE: 31 SESS: 2 OUTPUT: Tue May 11 14:32:06 2010
The Problem of Customary International Law
153
Given that customary laws are not authoritatively written down, their existence must be recognised according to conditions established by members of the international law profession, who determine when a settled practice has hardened into a rule of customary international law, and the scope and content of that rule. The responsibility falls principally to justices on international courts and tribunals,159 and international law professors, who often act in multiple roles in the international law system — as ‘publicists’ of international law writings, the authors of influential international ‘soft’ law instruments, and judges on international courts and tribunals (cf article 38(1) of the Statute of the International Court of Justice).160 There is no requirement that international law professors represent the interests and perspectives of the people of ‘their’ state. The principal loyalty of members of the profession (in their professional capacity) is to the discipline of international law. Shirley Scott observes that one of the self-give functions of international lawyers is to ‘serve as guardians of the relative autonomy, cohesion and consistency of international law’.161 Both international law judges and professors may, however, be likely, as McGinnis argues, to be ‘biased toward discovering consensus among states even when it does not exist to create more international law and thus more power for themselves’.162 Elsewhere, he accuses this ‘ideologically skewed group’ of being more likely to choose ‘ideologically skewed norms’.163 More sympathetically, Mattias Kumm refers to the ‘cosmopolitan enthusiasm for international law that is perhaps the déformation professionelle of the international lawyer’.164 Given that the existence and content of customary international law
159 Eyal Benvenisti observes that international tribunals ‘exercise considerable discretion in both “identifying” state practice and in determining whether following that practice reveals a state’s acknowledgment of its binding quality’: Eyal Benvenisti, ‘The Conception of International Law as a Legal System’ (2008) 50 German Yearbook of International Law 393 (SSRN) 5. 160 In determining whether a rule has become a rule of international law, the Restatement of Foreign Relations Law concludes that ‘substantial weight’ is accorded to the judgments of international and national courts and tribunals; judicial and arbitral tribunals; the writings of scholars; and pronouncements by states, when such pronouncements are not seriously challenged by other states: Restatement (Third) of Foreign Relations Law § 103(2) (1987). 161 Shirley Scott, ‘The Political Life of Public International Lawyers: Granting the Imprimatur’ (2007) 21 International Relations 411, 420. 162 John McGinnis, ‘Foreign to our Constitution’ (2006) 100 Northwestern University Law Review 303, 314. 163 John McGinnis, ‘The Comparative Disadvantage of Customary International Law’ (2006) 30 Harvard Journal of Law and Public Policy 7, 11. 164 Mattias Kumm, ‘Democratic Constitutionalism Encounters International Law: Terms of Engagement’ in Sujit Choudhry, The Migration of Constitutional Ideas (Cambridge, Cambridge University Press, 2006) 256, 260.
Columns Design Ltd
/
Job: Wheatley
/
Division: 03_TheWestphalianparadigm
/Pg. Position: 31 /
Date: 26/2
JOBNAME: Wheatley PAGE: 32 SESS: 3 OUTPUT: Tue May 11 14:32:06 2010
154 The State as (Democratic) Self-Legislator norms cannot be objectively determined, what is involved, as Koskenniemi points out, ‘is legislative construction by the judge’,165 or other international law actor. Patrick Kelly concludes that customary norms are in many cases determined by ‘academic and judicial elites… without the participation or direct assent of the majority of states’.166
A Modern Form of Customary International Law In the identification of customary international law norms, the jobfunction of the international law professional (according to the rule of recognition in public international law) is to identify a relevant practice of states and evidence of opinio juris, reflected in normative statements framed in terms of law. In practice this rarely occurs.167 International lawyers rarely attempt any systematic enquiry into state practice or the attitude of states to a customary practice. The criticism applies equally to the International Court of Justice,168 which ‘in most cases, declares rules of law without investigating the attitude of states on the legal character of a customary norm or undertaking an investigation of the actual practice of the majority of states’.169 The Court ‘deduces norms that it terms customary’ from treaties, UN resolutions, and other sources,170 and in doing so elevates those norms from ‘soft’ to ‘hard’ status in international law. Consider, for example, the judgment in Nicaragua v United States (Merits), where the Court relied on General Assembly Resolution 2625 (XXV), ‘Declaration on Friendly Relations’, as an expression of ‘the validity of the rule or set of rules declared by the resolution by themselves’.171 José E Alvarez concludes that customary international law, in the age of international organisations, is no longer observed by ‘historians consumed with surveying extensive state practice over decades or 165
Koskenniemi (n 11) at 470 (emphasis in original). Kelly (n 155) at 519–20. A notable exception is the International Committee of the Red Cross project to identify state practice in international humanitarian law. See Jean-Marie Henckaerts and Louise Doswald-Beck (eds), Customary International Humanitarian Law (Cambridge, Cambridge University Press, 2005). 168 Mark Movsesian concludes that the International Court of Justice ‘suffers from a serious democratic deficit’. The selection of judges occurs through a process ‘far removed from popular oversight’, or the control of domestic governments or democratic states: Mark Movsesian, ‘Judging International Judgments’ (2007) 48 Virginia Journal of International Law 65, 97. 169 Kelly (n 155) at 469. 170 ibid at 476. 171 Nicaragua v United States (Merits)[1986] ICJ Rep 14 [188]. For an example of the International Court of Justice relying on an international agreement (Convention on the Law of the Non-Navigational Uses of International Watercourses, adopted by the UN General Assembly A/RES/51/229, 21 May 1997) as evidence of customary international law, see Gabcˇikovo-Nagymaros Project (Hungary/Slovakia) [1997] ICJ Rep 7 [85]. 166 167
Columns Design Ltd
/
Job: Wheatley
/
Division: 03_TheWestphalianparadigm
/Pg. Position: 32 /
Date: 26/3
JOBNAME: Wheatley PAGE: 33 SESS: 3 OUTPUT: Tue May 11 14:32:06 2010
General Principles of Law
155
even centuries’. Instead, international lawyers rely on ‘institutionalized shortcuts’ to identify customary international law, including resolutions adopted by the General Assembly and the provisions of widely ratified multilateral treaties, which are taken as ‘expressions of “community” interests’.172 The premise of the new methodology is that the unanimous or near-unanimous adoption of international instruments provides evidence of the opinio juris of states in the international community.173 According to Anthea Roberts, the emergence of this modern form of custom reflects ‘a desire to create general international laws that can bind all states on important moral issues’. The objections of dissenting states and instances of contrary state practice are ignored because the international community ‘is not prepared to recognize exceptions to the maintenance of certain fundamental values’.174 The process is ‘potentially more democratic because it involves practically all states [who] participate in the negotiation and ratification of treaties and declarations of international fora’. The principle of sovereign equality, one state, one vote, also ‘helps to level the playing field’, providing less powerful states with a cost-efficient means of expressing their views, although ‘allowing a majority of states to bind a minority does not sit well with the notion of state sovereignty’.175
GENERAL PRINCIPLES OF LAW
The existence of customary international law (and corresponding obligations of states) cannot be understood by reference to the contract metaphor developed to explain how a sovereign could limit its freedom of political action. The sovereignty of states and possibilities of political self-determination are exercised ‘under the authority of international law’.176 The position is affirmed by the inclusion of ‘general principles of law’ in article 38(1)(c) of the Statute of the International Court of Justice, which challenges the exclusive right of states to make international law. The introduction of its predecessor represented a compromise between proponents of expanding the scope of international law-making and adherents to a strict positive doctrine that limited participation to 172 José E Alvarez, ‘International Organizations: Then and Now’ (2006) 100 American Journal of International Law 324, 332. 173 Kelly (n 155) at 484. 174 Anthea Elizabeth Roberts, ‘Traditional and Modern Approaches to Customary International Law: a Reconciliation’ (2001) 95 American Journal of International Law 757, 766. 175 ibid at 768. 176 Hans Kelsen, ‘The Principle of Sovereign Equality of States as a Basis for International Organization’ (1944) 53 Yale Law Journal 207, 208.
Columns Design Ltd
/
Job: Wheatley
/
Division: 03_TheWestphalianparadigm
/Pg. Position: 33 /
Date: 26/3
JOBNAME: Wheatley PAGE: 34 SESS: 3 OUTPUT: Tue May 11 14:32:06 2010
156 The State as (Democratic) Self-Legislator states.177 The provision permits the International Court of Justice, and by extension all other interpreters of international law obligations, to have recourse to principles common to systems of (national) law, without, in the words of Christine Chinkin, ‘authorizing unfettered recourse to notions of objective justice’.178 Examples of general principles include the obligation to make reparation, good faith, estoppel, and ex injuria non jus oritur. Koskenniemi makes the point that these general principles were not ‘“enacted” by positive acts of States’, but form ‘parts of the general frame of international law’.179 The inclusion of general principles as a source of obligations affirms both that international law is a system of law, and that it is a system of law of the same order as domestic law systems; it is not a category error to refer to the idea of international ‘law’. GG Fitzmaurice argues that law is revealed as something that has no meaning unless it is external to the will of the members of the society in which it functions, as something to which those members are subject, and which derives its obligatory character from sources that do not rest on consent, but rather themselves confer on consent its law-making capacities. And the ultimate source of the validity of this law is and must be extra-legal.180
Relying on McIver’s The Modern State, Fitzmaurice concludes: ‘We obey the law not because we necessarily think that the law is just, but because we believe it to be just to obey the law.’ It is this precept that seems to provide the firmest ground for the affirmation that the law, national or international, is binding; and the most fundamental, and therefore ultimately the most compelling, reason for its authority.181
The recognition that international law is more than a collection of positive expressions of sovereign consent confirms the existence of a system of law that (from the perspective of international law) binds the ‘sovereign’ members of the international community to a set of primary rules that regulate the behaviour of members, and secondary rules of change, adjudication and recognition.182 Sovereignty (and democratic self-determination) is exercised within an international law system that is
177 Bruno Simma, ‘The Contribution of Alfred Verdross to the Theory of International Law’ (1995) 6 European Journal of International Law 1, 16. 178 Christine Chinkin, ‘Normative Development in the International Legal System’ in Dinah Shelton (ed), Commitment and Compliance: the Role of Non-Binding Norms in the International Legal System (Oxford, Oxford University Press, 2000) 21. 179 Koskenniemi (n 51) at para 469. 180 GG Fitzmaurice, ‘The Foundations of the Authority of International Law and the Problem of Enforcement’ (1956) 19 Modern Law Review 1, 12. 181 ibid at 13. 182 cf HLA Hart, The Concept of Law, 2nd edn (Oxford, Clarendon Press, 1994) 94.
Columns Design Ltd
/
Job: Wheatley
/
Division: 03_TheWestphalianparadigm
/Pg. Position: 34 /
Date: 26/3
JOBNAME: Wheatley PAGE: 35 SESS: 3 OUTPUT: Tue May 11 14:32:06 2010
The Writings of Publicists and Judgments of Courts
157
not subject to the will of the people: the idea and authority of international law does not accept the possibility that the people of a constitutional democracy can always ‘democratically decide’.
THE WRITINGS OF PUBLICISTS AND JUDGMENTS OF COURTS
Article 38(1)(d) of the Statute of the International Court of Justice recognises judicial decisions and the teachings of the most highly qualified publicists of the various nations ‘as subsidiary means for the determination of rules of law’. Article 59 reads as follows: ‘The decision of the Court has no binding force except between the parties and in respect of that particular case.’ The following sections examine the role of publicists and courts in developing international law.
The Writings of Publicists Article 38(1) of the Statute of the International Court of Justice establishes the sources of international law obligations as treaties, customary international law, general principles, and, ‘as a subsidiary means’, judicial and academic opinion (article 38(1)(d)). Academic opinion includes the works of ‘authors of standing’, and the reports, resolutions and other texts of international law bodies, such as the Institute of International Law, International Law Association, and, perhaps most significantly, the International Law Commission.183 In the absence of formal law-making structures, international law professionals have played a significant role in the development of international law, which proceeds by argumentation, repetition, and acceptance. Koskenniemi concludes in the epilogue to From Apology to Utopia: ‘International law is what international lawyers make of it’.184 By the use of analogy and abstraction of general principles from individual rules, the international lawyer attempts to develop an understanding of the discipline as a coherent whole, allowing for the application of international law norms to new factual circumstances. The identification and interpretation of international law is the job-function of the international lawyer, defined to include the members of international and domestic judicial and arbitral tribunals, international law practitioners, and academics, all of whom claim to possess specialist knowledge and skills that others do not possess. This chapter has already highlighted the difficulty in regarding the contribution of international law 183 184
Restatement (Third) of Foreign Relations Law § 103 (1987), reporter’s note 1. Koskenniemi (n 11) at 615.
Columns Design Ltd
/
Job: Wheatley
/
Division: 03_TheWestphalianparadigm
/Pg. Position: 35 /
Date: 26/3
JOBNAME: Wheatley PAGE: 36 SESS: 3 OUTPUT: Tue May 11 14:32:06 2010
158 The State as (Democratic) Self-Legislator publicists as democratically legitimate. Whilst international law writings must fall within the disciplinary understandings of the profession (the validity of claims about international law are determined by the profession), the authority of international law texts does not depend on their acceptance by states, and, as Brownlie observes, when international lawyers interpret the nature, scope and content of international law norms, it is ‘obvious that subjective factors enter into any assessment of juristic opinion’.185
The Judgments of Courts Article 38(1)(d) of the Statute of the International Court of Justice permits, again as a subsidiary means, recourse to the judgments of domestic and international courts to determine generally applicable rules of international law. The judgments (and reasoning) of courts and tribunals may be taken as authoritative statements of international law, even if the judicial body in question has no standing to decide on the law, and by implication to limit the freedom of action of states subject to the international law norm in question. It is important to recognise the central role of the International Court of Justice (and before that the Permanent Court of International Justice) in developing the fundamental principles of international law, and many standard references in international law texts are to judgments of the Court. Article 38 is a direction to the International Court of Justice as to the sources of international law that it can examine in resolving disputes submitted to it. The function of the Court is that of adjudication: to sit in judgment on the parties, and to judge in accordance with existing law. It is not the function of the Court to make the law. In South West Africa, Second Phase, the Court affirmed that it ‘is not a legislative body. Its duty is to apply the law as it finds it, not to make it.’186 There is no international common law and (formally) no international equivalent to the common law principle of stare decisis. The idea of sovereignty limits the role of the Court to determining the legal position of the parties in the case before it. Article 59 of the Statute of the International Court of Justice confirms that a judgment has no binding force except as between the parties and in respect of that particular case. In Certain German Interests in Polish Upper Silesia, the 185 Ian Brownlie, Principles of Public International Law, 7th edn (Oxford, Oxford University Press, 2008) 24. The international lawyer is not precluded from making proposals for reform, both technical and policy-orientated, but she must always make clear the distinction between the de lege ferenda (what the law ought to be), and the lex lata (what the law actually is). The privileged position of international lawyers in political debates is provided by the status accorded to members of the profession, and their professional expertise. 186 South West Africa, Second Phase [1966] ICJ Rep 6 [89].
Columns Design Ltd
/
Job: Wheatley
/
Division: 03_TheWestphalianparadigm
/Pg. Position: 36 /
Date: 26/3
JOBNAME: Wheatley PAGE: 37 SESS: 3 OUTPUT: Tue May 11 14:32:06 2010
The Writings of Publicists and Judgments of Courts
159
Permanent Court observed that the object of the (equivalent) article ‘is simply to prevent legal principles accepted by the Court in a particular case from being binding upon other States or in other disputes’.187 The requirement for states to consent to international law suggests a limited role for courts and tribunals in its development. Koskenniemi argues that international courts take a more restrictive approach to the issue of judicial discretion than municipal courts, emphasising the importance of consent as the basis of international law obligations, ‘with which a wide discretionary power would conflict’.188 Some judicial discretion is inevitable, but it should take place ‘within “the existing law”’.189 The function of an international court is to determine what a particular state has willed and not to determine the scope and content of a body of (public international) law than can be applied to the particular facts. This is the fundamental difference in the ways in which international and domestic lawyers view the (legal) world: for the international lawyer, the object of enquiry is evidence of sovereign consent; for the domestic lawyer, the object is the content of authoritative law norms issued by a competent institution. The shift in the nature of international law from a consensual model to a (international) public law governance model consequently requires a re-evaluation of the authority of international law and role of judicial bodies. The establishment of international courts and tribunals both enhances compliance by increasing the probability that sanctions and reputational costs will be imposed on defaulting states,190 and allows for the development of a more detailed body of law through ‘judgments’ in contentious cases, particularly where non-state actors have the right to bring complaints. There are at least 40 ‘institutionalized international dispute settlers’, reflecting the faith of international lawyers in legal elites, neutral forms of adjudication, and an independent judiciary.191 There is also an increasing tendency of international courts and tribunals to refer to the jurisprudence of other courts and tribunals, in what Helfer and Slaughter refer to as ‘a form of collective deliberation about common legal questions’.192 Jenny Martinez notes that international (and domestic) courts
187
Certain German Interests in Polish Upper Silesia (Merits) [1926] PCIJ Series A No 7, 19. Koskenniemi (n 11) at 30. 189 ibid 34. 190 Laurence Helfer and Anne-Marie Slaughter, ‘Why States Create International Tribunals: a Response to Professors Posner and Yoo’ (2005) 93 California Law Review 899, 935. 191 José E Alvarez, ‘International Organizations: Then and Now’ (2006) 100 American Journal of International Law 324, 325. 192 Laurence Helfer and Anne-Marie Slaughter, ‘Toward a Theory of Effective Supranational Adjudication’ (1997) Yale Law Journal 273, 282. See also Eyal Benvenisti, ‘Reclaiming Democracy: the Strategic Uses of Foreign and International Law by National Courts’ (2008) 102 American Journal of International Law 241; and William Burke-White, ‘International Legal Pluralism’ (2004) 25 Michigan Journal of International Law 963, 977–78. 188
Columns Design Ltd
/
Job: Wheatley
/
Division: 03_TheWestphalianparadigm
/Pg. Position: 37 /
Date: 26/3
JOBNAME: Wheatley PAGE: 38 SESS: 3 OUTPUT: Tue May 11 14:32:06 2010
160 The State as (Democratic) Self-Legislator can be seen to be involved in a form of ‘jurisgenerative dialogue’, observing that dialogue is a tool uniquely suited to courts, given that ‘persuasion, rather than coercion, is the judiciary’s stock in trade’.193 In the absence of a ‘supreme court’ capable of resolving conflicting interpretations of law and jurisdiction, and no ‘unifying [“constitutional”] document’,194 the system of international courts will be ‘self-organising’, although two significant trends can be identified: international courts are beginning to recognise that they are engaged in a common endeavour and they will not lightly disregard the judgments of other international courts; and certain courts and tribunals are recognised by other courts as having special expertise.195 We have seen a shift from an essentially contractual model of international law, to a public law, or ‘governance’, model. The validity of international law is no longer a question of sovereign will. The development is reflected, inter alia, in the decline of the importance of consent in international law and emergence of ‘lawmaking’ treaties, majoritarian tendencies in the development of customary international law and emergence of modern forms of custom that rely on widely accepted international treaties and the resolutions of international organisations. A public (international) law governance paradigm suggests the need for an international court to locate any decision in the ‘seamless web’ of international law: an argument for integrity and coherence, and requirement to treat like cases alike. In practice, international courts, including the International Court of Justice, invariably refer to their previous decisions, refusing to depart from them without a good reason, an international variant of stare decisis, the legal principle of determining cases in accordance with precedent, ie in accordance with the body of law and reasoning of previous judgments, and not the sovereign will of the states parties to the dispute. Where states are subject to the authority of international law, the interpretation of generally applicable norms in cases to which a state is not a party is not problematic: it is an application of the rule of law principle that like cases be treated alike, and recognition that international law is a system, by which is simply meant ‘that the
193 Jenny Martinez, ‘Towards an International Judicial System’ (2003) 56 Stanford Law Review 429, 466–67. 194 ibid at 431. 195 ibid at 490. Martinez considers how international courts and tribunals should relate to each other. A number of possibilities emerge: to fulfil in a contract-like way the intentions of nation-state sponsors; to serve the rational interests of powerful states; to act as a counterweight to the interests of powerful states; to protect international peace and security; to promote economic efficiency; and/or to advance human rights. Martinez offers a further possibility: to establish a federalism of democratic states that respects individual human rights: ibid at 461.
Columns Design Ltd
/
Job: Wheatley
/
Division: 03_TheWestphalianparadigm
/Pg. Position: 38 /
Date: 26/3
JOBNAME: Wheatley PAGE: 39 SESS: 3 OUTPUT: Tue May 11 14:32:06 2010
Conclusion 161 various decisions, rules and principles of which the law consists do not appear not randomly related to each other’.196 The role of international (and arguably domestic) courts and tribunals becomes problematic where the ‘interpretation’ of international law norms augments the obligations of states beyond the literal meaning of contracted norms, creating difficulties both in terms of sovereignty and democratic self-determination: according to democratic theory, it is for the people or their representatives to ‘legislate’ law norms, with the function of the unelected and largely unaccountable judiciary to apply those norms.197 At the domestic level, the function of courts is to interpret statutes adopted by the national parliament (and, in common law systems, to develop the common law). Where the courts interpret or develop the law in a way that is not consistent with the will of the here-and-now people, a national parliament is at liberty to (re-)legislate on the same issue. This is not the case in relation to international courts, which claim the final, and thus constitutionally decisive, word in relation to the content of international law norms. The exercise of legislative authority by international courts reflects the separation of powers concern and counter-majoritarian difficulty identified at the domestic level: in a legal system, the role of judicial law-making should be limited to the application and logical development of democratically legislated political law norms. Consequently, the lawmaking activities of international courts and tribunals are a particular source of concern in relation to the ‘democratic deficit’ in international law.
CONCLUSION
Much of the literature on the problem for democracy following the globalisation and fragmentation of governance regards the decline of the Westphalian settlement as the principle cause for concern. Where the existence of binding law norms (internal state law and external international law) depended on a positive expression of sovereign will, democracy was protected to the extent that sovereign will was determined by the people. This chapter demonstrates the incoherence of the argument once the existence of the authority of international law is recognised; nor is it possible to provide democratic legitimacy for international law norms by reference to the idea of sovereign consent. In the case of international treaties, democratic legitimacy rests on the ability of diplomatic conversations to produce reasoned outcomes in conditions in 196
Koskenniemi (n 51) at para 33. cf John Rawls, Political Liberalism (New York, Columbia University Press, 1993) 231. Rawls regards courts as the paradigm of rational deliberative decision-making. 197
Columns Design Ltd
/
Job: Wheatley
/
Division: 03_TheWestphalianparadigm
/Pg. Position: 39 /
Date: 26/3
JOBNAME: Wheatley PAGE: 40 SESS: 3 OUTPUT: Tue May 11 14:32:06 2010
162 The State as (Democratic) Self-Legislator which only the force of better argument is able to prevail. The authority of customary international law is provided by a recognition by the international community that a practice is binding as a matter of law, and in making that determination regard may be had to whether the rule will contribute to international order.198 International law serves the social purpose of ensuring peaceful inter-state relations. From the perspective of domestic societies, the existence of a system of public international law not under the control of the state law system creates a deficit in the practice of democracy (the people do not decide all ‘politically decidable issues’). But, following Hans Kelsen, it makes little sense to refer to restrictions on sovereignty by international law. The right of democratic self-determination is exercised within the framework provided by the international law order. The following chapters demonstrate the ways in which international law is constructing a single legitimate form of political community for domestic societies: the liberal democratic state. The practice of (domestic) democracy must be understood in the context of a framework of international law norms that provide for the protection of individual human rights and (increasingly) a requirement for democratic forms of government. The function of a democratically legitimate international law order is (in part) to construct legitimate domestic polities, ie the ‘liberal democratic’ state.
198
Columns Design Ltd
Restatement (Third) of Foreign Relations Law § 103 (1987) comment.
/
Job: Wheatley
/
Division: 03_TheWestphalianparadigm
/Pg. Position: 40 /
Date: 26/3
JOBNAME: Wheatley PAGE: 1 SESS: 4 OUTPUT: Tue May 11 14:32:06 2010
4 The Constitutionalisation of International Law
T
HE PREVIOUS CHAPTER demonstrated the difficulty in reconciling democratic self-determination with the authority of international law. The objective of this chapter is to examine the ways in which international law undermines the claims of ‘sovereignty’ by promoting liberal democratic values in world society. According to the positivist orthodoxy, international law is an expression of sovereign will, excluding from its domain ‘all matters of an a priori, metaphysical nature’.1 The system of international law is the result of a complex web of bilateral inter-state relationships framed in terms of law. The attitude of the people of a state to an emergent or established international law norm is irrelevant. The state is sovereign, not the people. It enjoys the right to contract in international law, and to demand that other states respect the principle of non-intervention in domestic affairs: social, economic and political conditions are not the concern of other states, unless the state has limited its freedom of action by agreeing to an international law norm. The positivist analysis is increasingly regarded as anachronistic, with a recognition in cognate disciplines, such as political theory, that sovereign rights are not absolute, but contingent on the legitimate exercise of government authority.2 This chapter observes the shift in the nature of international law from a bilateral model of inter-state contract to a public law governance model in which an international constitutional order frames and delimits the exercise of political power at the domestic level. The work develops a constructivist analysis, arguing that the international law system has undergone a process of reconstruction in the period following the establishment of the
1 Hans Morgenthau, ‘Positivism, Functionalism, and International law’ (1940) 34 American Journal of International Law 260, 261. 2 David Held, for example, argues that sovereignty can no longer be understood in terms of ‘untrammeled effective power’, and that the legitimate exercise of political authority within the state depends on the government upholding certain human rights standards and establishing a legal order that reflects an expression of the democratic will of the people: David Held, ‘Law of States, Law of Peoples: Three Models of Sovereignty’ (2002) 8 Legal Theory 1, 17.
Columns Design Ltd
/
Job: Wheatley
/
Division: 04_Theliberaldemocraticstate
/Pg. Position: 1 /
Date: 26/3
JOBNAME: Wheatley PAGE: 2 SESS: 2 OUTPUT: Tue May 11 14:32:06 2010
164 The Constitutionalisation of IL United Nations (UN). This has included both the recognition of (legitimate) political authority for the world organisation (UN), and the development of a normative hierarchy, reflecting global justice norms, a development referred to as the constitutionalisation of international law. International law subjects sovereign will and domestic political determination to a set of global law norms that constructs the state as an autonomous political unit and legitimates the exercise of domestic government in accordance with certain global justice norms, reflected, for example, in international human rights law.
FROM CONTRACT TO GOVERNANCE
The positivist model that emerged in the nineteenth century paid little attention to conditions within states, or the interests and values of the international community as a whole: ‘each state was embarked upon its own adventure [in its own] national interests, as determined exclusively by itself’.3 The approach resulted in an era of ‘absolutist states’,4 unfettered by legal obligations they had not themselves accepted. Notoriously, Herman Goering felt able to proclaim on the subject of the Holocaust: ‘But that was our right! We were a sovereign State and that was strictly our business.’5 The positivist (or Westphalian) epoch ended following the devastating consequences of the two world wars (1914–18, 1939–45), and discoveries, inter alia, at Auschwitz and Buchenwald. Today, as David Kennedy observes: [w]hen we public international lawyers look out the window, we see a world of nation-states and worry about war. We remember the great wars of the twentieth century. We were traumatized by the Holocaust, fear totalitarianism, and are averse to ideology. Our common project is governance: how can sovereign states be governed so that war may be avoided?6
Harold Hongju Koh notes that the disastrous consequences of World War II led the international community to replace a ‘loose customary web of state-centric rules with an ambitious positivistic order, built on institutions and constitutions’.7 Whilst the intense bipolarity of the Cold War 3 Stephen Neff, War and the Law of Nations: a General History (Cambridge, Cambridge University Press, 2005) 171 (emphasis in original). 4 Leo Gross, ‘The Peace of Westphalia, 1648–1948’ (1948) 42 American Journal of International Law 20, 38. 5 Quoted in Paul Lauren, The Evolution of International Human Rights, 2nd edn (Philadelphia, University of Pennsylvania Press, 2003) 204. 6 David Kennedy, ‘One, Two, Three, Many Legal Orders: Legal Pluralism and the Cosmopolitan Dream’ (2007) New York University Review of Law and Social Change 641, 650. 7 Harold Hongju Koh, ‘Why do Nations Obey International Law?’ (1997) 106 Yale Law Journal 2599, 2614.
Columns Design Ltd
/
Job: Wheatley
/
Division: 04_Theliberaldemocraticstate
/Pg. Position: 2 /
Date: 26/2
JOBNAME: Wheatley PAGE: 3 SESS: 4 OUTPUT: Tue May 11 14:32:06 2010
From Contract to Governance
165
era rendered the vision a ‘Potemkin Village’,8 the institutional architecture of global governance put in place in the immediate aftermath of World War II has become increasingly important, with the emergence of the UN Security Council as a powerful actor on the international stage being the clearest example. The modern world of international law accords more with an international public law governance model than a private law model of contract. The establishment of international institutions, such as the UN, allows for the exercise of global regulatory functions and the emergence of rules and principles that reflect the interests and values of the international community as a whole. In the period since 1945, states have been socialised to accept global law norms concerning respect for human rights and the necessary conditions for the (democratic) exercise of political authority. In We the Peoples, UN Secretary-General Kofi Anan observes that ‘the spreading acceptance of new norms has profoundly affected the lives of many millions of people’. These include norms providing for universal human rights and the practice of democracy, which is ‘now generally seen as the most legitimate and desirable form of government’.9 The Report of the International Commission on Intervention and State Sovereignty, ‘The Responsibility to Protect’, concludes that, today, sovereignty is more than just a functional principle of international relations: it is the recognition of the equal worth and dignity of states and peoples, and an affirmation of the right of all peoples ‘to shape and determine their own destiny’.10 Sovereignty is not understood as the ‘unlimited power of a state to do what it wants to its own people’; it implies a dual responsibility, externally, to respect the sovereignty of other states, and internally, ‘to respect the dignity and basic rights of all the people within the state’. The idea of sovereignty as responsibility, including the responsibility to protect, ‘has become the minimum content of good international citizenship’.11 The ideas advanced in ‘The Responsibility to Protect’ (and elsewhere) suggest the need for a radical reformulation of the ways in which international lawyers understand the discipline. There has been a decline in the Westphalian political settlement, yet sovereignty remains one of the competing meta-principles for organising world society. According to the positivist analysis, arguments that we are in a post- or lateWestphalian era present a misreading of the world of law and the 8
ibid at 2615. Kofi Anan, We the Peoples: the Role of the United Nations in the 21st Century (New York, United Nations, 2000) 68. 10 ‘The Responsibility to Protect: Report of the International Commission on Intervention and State Sovereignty’ (Ottawa, International Development Research Centre, 2001) para 1.32. 11 ibid at para 1.35. 9
Columns Design Ltd
/
Job: Wheatley
/
Division: 04_Theliberaldemocraticstate
/Pg. Position: 3 /
Date: 26/3
JOBNAME: Wheatley PAGE: 4 SESS: 4 OUTPUT: Tue May 11 14:32:06 2010
166 The Constitutionalisation of IL allocation of political authority in world society.12 Sovereignty remains the organising principle of international relations, and law is understood exclusively in terms of expressions of sovereign will: internal state law and external international law. Sovereignty and the sovereign state are facts of the world that we must recognise and accommodate. But sovereignty is not a fact in the same way that mountains and oceans are ‘facts’. There is a fundamental distinction between the natural and social world, where ‘facts are only facts by human agreement’.13 Concepts such as ‘sovereignty’, the ‘state’, and ‘international law’ are social facts. Christian Tomuschat makes the evident, but oft forgotten, point that the system of international law, like any legal order, ‘is a man-made product and should be understood as such’.14 The argument developed here regards states and the international law system as social constructs. Constructivist insights are important in explaining the emergence of international public law norms that (from the perspective of international law) constrain the freedom of action of sovereign and independent states. No new meta-theory of (international) law is required to replace the idea of Westphalian sovereignty. The system of global governance works in a particular way because it is understood to work in that way. If the international law order is a social construct, it can be re-imagined by the international law profession in different ways. Consider, for example, the dictum of the International Court of Justice on the legal personality of the UN organisation in Reparations suffered for injuries suffered in the service of the United Nations. The Court concluded that the UN was not a state, still less ‘“a superState” whatever that might mean’. It is a subject of international law, capable of possessing international rights and duties.15 In establishing the UN, 50 states, ‘representing the vast majority of the members of the international community, had the power, in conformity with international law, to bring into being an entity possessing objective international personality, and not merely personality recognized by them alone’.16 The 12 Neil Walker refers to the idea of late-sovereignty, rather than post-sovereignty. In the emerging post-Westphalian order, it becomes possible to conceive of ‘autonomy without exclusivity – to imagine ultimate authority, or sovereignty, in non-exclusive terms. This is because of the emergence of polities whose posited boundaries are not (or not merely) territorial, but also sectoral or functional’: Neil Walker, ‘The Idea of Constitutional Pluralism’ (2002) 65 Modern Law Review 317, 346. 13 Tanja Aalberts, ‘The Future of Sovereignty in Multilevel Governance Europe – a Constructivist Reading’ (2004) 42 Journal of Common Market Studies 23, 35. See also Thomas Biersteker and Cynthia Weber, State Sovereignty as Social Construct (Cambridge, Cambridge University Press, 1996). 14 Christian Tomuschat, ‘Obligations Arising for States Without or Against their Will’ (1993) 241 Recueil de cours 195, 235. 15 Reparations suffered for injuries suffered in the service of the United Nations (Advisory Opinion) [1949] ICJ Rep 174, 179. 16 ibid at 185 (emphasis added).
Columns Design Ltd
/
Job: Wheatley
/
Division: 04_Theliberaldemocraticstate
/Pg. Position: 4 /
Date: 26/3
JOBNAME: Wheatley PAGE: 5 SESS: 4 OUTPUT: Tue May 11 14:32:06 2010
From Contract to Governance
167
international law order was re-constructed with the establishment of the UN, which proclaimed that its laws were a higher form of law in the international system,17 and (ultimately) superior to the domestic laws of states.18 It has been further re-constructed with the emergence of substantive constitutional values, reflected, for example, in the emergence of international norms of jus cogens standing, which cannot be explained by reference to the positive orthodoxy. Consider also the question of membership in the international community of states. Political entities become ‘sovereign’ when recognised as such within the international law order. The sovereign state that was first constituted by an assertion of political authority by regional monarchs in Europe is now constructed by the system of international law. This can be seen in the growth of the number of states since 1945, which has resulted from an application of international law norms concerning the right of peoples to self-determination. Serge Sur observes that during the period of decolonisation, ‘the international society became a machine for the manufacture of states’.19 The international law on the right of peoples to self-determination created large numbers of political units that were recognised as ‘sovereign’. The independence of those societies and autonomy of their state legal orders was guaranteed by the application of the principle of sovereignty and its corollary of non-intervention. Phillip Karber observes that reference to constructivism in the international law literature reflects ‘a growing interest in the role of “ideas,” the influence of “culture,” and the importance of “rules” in understanding global interaction’. The concern is to understand the ‘constitutive and regulatory “rules of the road”’ that apply to the complex ‘social system’ of international relations.20 Constructivists advance three main arguments: that inter-subjective beliefs shape the identities and interests of 17 Charter of the United Nations art 103: ‘In the event of a conflict between the obligations of the Members of the United Nations under the present Charter and their obligations under any other international agreement, their obligations under the present Charter shall prevail.’ 18 ibid art 2(7): ‘Nothing contained in the present Charter shall authorize the United Nations to intervene in matters which are essentially within the domestic jurisdiction of any state or shall require the Members to submit such matters to settlement under the present Charter; but this principle shall not prejudice the application of enforcement measures under Chapter Vll.’ 19 Serge Sur, ‘The State between Fragmentation and Globalization’ (1997) 8 European Journal of International Law 421, 424. 20 Phillip Karber, ‘“Constructivism” as a Method in International Law’ (2000) 94 American Society of International Law Proceedings 189, 189. Anne-Marie Slaughter notes that international lawyers are often drawn to constructivist theory, inhabiting as they do ‘a world of discourse’, constructivism ‘provides a deeply satisfying account of how and why what they do matters’: Anne-Marie Slaughter, ‘International Law and International Relations Theory: a Prospectus’ in Eyal Benvenisti and Moshe Hirsch (eds), The Impact of International Law on International Cooperation: Theoretical Perspectives (Cambridge, Cambridge University Press, 2004) 16, 37.
Columns Design Ltd
/
Job: Wheatley
/
Division: 04_Theliberaldemocraticstate
/Pg. Position: 5 /
Date: 26/3
JOBNAME: Wheatley PAGE: 6 SESS: 4 OUTPUT: Tue May 11 14:32:06 2010
168 The Constitutionalisation of IL actors; that actors within the system of global governance are in a ‘dialogue with the prevailing norms of legitimate agency that constitute role identities to define their [own] senses of self’; and that normative and ideational structures exist as a result of the routine practices of social agents, and as ‘human artefacts’, they are, consequently, ‘amenable to transformation’.21 Alexander Wendt explains that the fundamental principle of constructivist social theory is that people act towards objects, including other actors, on the basis of the meaning that the objects have for them. It is collective understandings that constitute the structures that organise our actions. Actors acquire identities through participation in collective processes: identities are ‘inherently relational’.22 Through reciprocal interaction, actors create and instantiate enduring social structures that define their identities and interests.23 Wendt refers to the idea of an ‘institution’: a relatively stable set of identities and interests that is often codified in formal rules and norms. The process of creating an institution ‘is one of internalizing new understandings of self and other, or acquiring new role identities’.24 Sovereignty is an institution. The idea of sovereignty in international relations exists only by virtue of inter-subjective understandings that not only constitute a particular kind of state, the ‘sovereign’ state, but also a particular form of international community.25 International law norms, as expressions of sovereignty, ‘are now so taken for granted, so natural, that it is easy to overlook the extent to which they are both presupposed by and an ongoing artifact of practice’. If states ceased to act in accordance with those norms, ‘their identity as “sovereigns” (if not necessarily as “states”) would disappear.’26 The constructivist argument is that actors acquire identities through participation in collective processes. The identity of the sovereign state as an actor in international relations is created through interactions with other actors in both informal and formal contexts (international organisations). States understand the concept of sovereignty through interactions with other actors. The idea of sovereignty only exists by virtue of intersubjective understandings; it can, consequently, be re-conceptualised through the revised inter-subjective understandings that emerge through participation in international organisations. Brunnée and Toope observe that in Jürgen Habermas ‘some constructivists have found support for the
21 Christian Reus-Smit, ‘The Politics of International Law’ in Christian Reus-Smit (ed), The Politics of International Law (Cambridge, Cambridge University Press, 2004) 14, 21–22. 22 Alexander Wendt, ‘Anarchy is what States make of it: the Social Construction of Power Politics’ (1992) 46 International Organization 391, 397. 23 ibid at 406. 24 ibid at 417. 25 ibid at 412. 26 ibid at 413.
Columns Design Ltd
/
Job: Wheatley
/
Division: 04_Theliberaldemocraticstate
/Pg. Position: 6 /
Date: 26/3
JOBNAME: Wheatley PAGE: 7 SESS: 4 OUTPUT: Tue May 11 14:32:06 2010
From Contract to Governance
169
proposition that the identities of international actors are constructed in large part through “communicative action”.’27 Processes of deliberation require that states ‘learn to be “discursively competent,” that is, capable of persuading’.28 Through interactions between states (as actors in international relations) and between states and non-state actors (and, indeed, between non-state actors), inter-subjective structures emerge that ‘give the world meaning’.29 Inter-subjective understandings and institutions may persist for long periods, but they can be ‘reshaped through changes in the constructed identities of the actors, identities that are in turn shaped and reshaped by action within the structures’.30 The argument is not that ideas, knowledge and norms ‘operate as direct causes of action, rather that social structures constrain and enable actors in their choices, and thus help to shape world politics’.31 Global actors have constructed a system of governance that provides the context for interactions, and which shapes identities. International law norms and institutions ‘furnish the context within which interaction takes place and shape the identities of the actors themselves’. Actors in the international system ‘come to understand themselves and their interests in light of their interaction with others and in light of the norms that frame the interaction’.32 Christian Reus-Smit argues that constructivists attach too much explanatory weight to sovereignty, and in doing so fail to recognise that sovereignty is embedded in a larger complex of constitutive meta-values that structure the global system. The idea that sovereignty defines the social identity of the state ‘is both logically and historically problematic. Unless embedded within a larger complex of values, the principle of sovereignty cannot alone provide the state with a coherent social identity.’ It cannot, for example, explain why a sovereign entity is entitled to political self-determination in both the internal and external senses. Constructivists must identify the more primary and substantive values that provide for their status in world society as ‘centralized, autonomous political organizations’.33 Three such values emerge: a shared belief about the moral purpose of a centralised political unit; the organising principle
27 Jutta Brunnée and Stephen Toope, ‘International Law and Constructivism: Elements of an Interactional Theory of International Law’ (2000) 39 Columbia Journal of Transnational Law 19, 26. 28 ibid at 27. 29 ibid at 28. 30 ibid at 30. 31 ibid at 31. 32 ibid at 34 (references omitted). 33 Christian Reus-Smit, ‘The Constitutional Structure of International Society and the Nature of Fundamental Institutions’ (1997) 51 International Organization 555, 565.
Columns Design Ltd
/
Job: Wheatley
/
Division: 04_Theliberaldemocraticstate
/Pg. Position: 7 /
Date: 26/3
JOBNAME: Wheatley PAGE: 8 SESS: 4 OUTPUT: Tue May 11 14:32:06 2010
170 The Constitutionalisation of IL of sovereignty; and a norm of pure procedural justice.34 These constitutive meta-values define the sovereign state and the rights and privileges of sovereignty. Whatever past justifications there might have been for recognising the sovereignty of the state (monarchy or other raison d’état), the function of sovereignty today is to protect the right of political self-determination for taken-for-granted political communities. This is the ‘moral purpose of the state’, justifying the foundational principle of sovereignty ‘and the prevailing norm of pure procedural justice’.35 The idea of procedural justice provides that law is legitimate where authored by those subject to it, or their representatives, and equally binding on all.36 The ideal of legitimate statehood, a ‘democratic, rule of law polity’, which emerged following the revolutions in America and France, also came to be applied at the international level in the nineteenth century, with the emergence of multilateral forms of law-making. The institution of universal conferences of states reflected a determination to apply the principle of pure procedural justice to the international level, and consequently to ensure the collective legislation of international law norms, which would be authored by those subject to them and equally binding on all.37 Examples include the Congress of Vienna, the Hague Peace Conferences, and the creation of the League of Nations and UN, all of which, Leo Gross argues, represented a ‘conscious effort to establish a community of states based on the will of all states or at least on the will of the Great Powers’.38 Constructivist insights are important to understanding international law. The idea of sovereignty is not fixed, it is a social fact understood by actors within the international law order (and observed by international lawyers). The importance of resolutions adopted by international organisations such as the UN, the emergence of norms of jus cogens, and principles of global justice such as human rights and self-determination cannot be understood by reference to the positivist orthodoxy, and we need not contort our understandings of the international system to demonstrate sovereign will for all law norms. The international law system has undergone a process of ‘constitutionalisation’ during the period of the UN, establishing formal institutions for global regulation and allowing for the emergence of community values. The anarchic positive system that operated in accordance with the principle of sovereignty has been replaced by an international constitutional order that
34
ibid at 556. ibid at 566. ibid at 571. 37 ibid at 578. 38 Leo Gross, ‘The Peace of Westphalia, 1648–1948’ (1948) 42 American Journal of International Law 20, 39. 35 36
Columns Design Ltd
/
Job: Wheatley
/
Division: 04_Theliberaldemocraticstate
/Pg. Position: 8 /
Date: 26/3
JOBNAME: Wheatley PAGE: 9 SESS: 5 OUTPUT: Tue May 11 14:32:06 2010
Community Interests and Constitutionalisation
171
frames the basic rights and obligations of states in the international community: ‘community being a term suitable to indicate a closer union that between members of a society’.39 The approach is constitutionalist because it exhibits a view that actors in the system of global governance form an international community governed by law, which reflects, in important respects, community interests. COMMUNITY INTERESTS AND CONSTITUTIONALISATION
Constitutional lawyers, following Bruce Ackerman, speak of ‘constitutional moments’, points in time when a political movement succeeds in placing a new problematic at the centre of political life: Although constitutional politics is the highest kind of politics, it should be permitted to dominate the nation’s life only during rare periods of heightened political consciousness. During the long periods between these constitutional moments… normal politics… prevails[;] it is, however, democratically inferior to the intermittent and irregular politics of public virtue associated with moments of constitutional creation.40
The adoption of the Charter of the UN is one such constitutional moment for the international order. Others suggested moments include the Congress of Vienna 1815,41 the Paris Peace conference of 191942 and the UN decolonisation resolutions of the 1960s.43 Writing in 1950, George Jaffin argued that in universalising human rights and the adoption of the UN Charter ‘constitutional experience has been invaluable. This enrichment of the classic law may be viewed as the constitutionalization of international law or the internationalization of constitutional law.’44 The Charter proclaimed that the rules of the organisation were a ‘higher’ form of law 39 Tomuschat (n 14) at 211. Simma argues that the idea of an international legal community ‘proceeds from the assumption that it is international law which binds the parts together, affirming the existence of a “community of States” on the one hand and lending the necessary normative structure to this community on the other’: Bruno Simma, ‘From Bilateralism to Community Interest in International Law’ (1994) 250 Recueil de cours 217, 245. 40 Bruce Ackerman, ‘Discovering the Constitution’ (1984) 93 Yale Law Journal 1013, 1022–23. 41 Gerry Simpson, Great Powers and Outlaw States: Unequal Sovereigns in the International Legal Order (Cambridge, Cambridge University Press, 2003). 42 Steve Charnovitz, ‘The Emergence of Democratic Participation in Global Governance (Paris, 1919)’ (2003) 10 Indiana Journal of Global Legal Studies 45, 74. 43 Daniel Philpott, Revolutions in Sovereignty: How Ideas Shaped Modern International Relations (Princeton, Princeton University Press, 2001) 153. 44 George Jaffin, ‘Le Droit International Nouveau’ (1950) 50 Columbia Law Review 122, 124 (references omitted). Laurence Helfer identifies five key structural and systemic challenges that the international legal system now faces: decentralisation and disaggregation; normative and institutional hierarchies; compliance and enforcement; exit and escape; and democracy and legitimacy. ‘Each of these five issues raises questions of governance, institutional design, and allocation of authority, many of which are comparable to questions
Columns Design Ltd
/
Job: Wheatley
/
Division: 04_Theliberaldemocraticstate
/Pg. Position: 9 /
Date: 26/3
JOBNAME: Wheatley PAGE: 10 SESS: 5 OUTPUT: Tue May 11 14:32:06 2010
172 The Constitutionalisation of IL (article 103), and recognised the authority of the Security Council to take enforcement measures on vague and indeterminate grounds, irrespective of the view of the Member States against which the measures were applied.45 In Corfu Channel Case, the first judgment of the International Court of Justice, decided 9 April 1947, Judge Alvarez concluded that we can no longer regard sovereignty as an absolute and individual right of every State[,] according to which States were only bound by the rules which they had accepted. Today, owing to social interdependence and to the predominance of the general interest, the States are bound by many rules which have not been ordered by their will.46
At the end of the century, in Legality of the Threat or Use of Nuclear Weapons, President Bedjaoui declared that the resolutely positivist, voluntarist approach of international law still current at the beginning of the [twentieth] century [had] been replaced by an objective conception of international law, a law more readily seeking to reflect a collective conscience and respond to the social necessities of states organized as a community.47
The model of atomised and autonomous sovereigns interacting to construct a web of international law rights and obligations is no longer an accurate description of the international law system. The point becomes clear in the International Law Commission’s Articles on State Responsibility. The Articles provide that there is an internationally wrongful act when conduct consisting of an action or omission ‘of a State’ is attributable to the state and constitutes a breach of an international obligation of the state.48 Whilst responsibility may accrue only to a state, it may be owed to another state, to several states, or the international community as a whole, depending on the character and content of the obligation.49 This is ‘without prejudice to any right, arising from the international responsibility of a State, which may accrue directly to any person or entity other than a State’.50 In relation to international human rights
that domestic legal systems have answered through constitutions’: Laurence Helfer, ‘Constitutional Analogies in the International Legal System’ (2003) Loyola of Los Angeles Law Review 193, 198. 45 UN Charter c VII. 46 Corfu Channel Case [1949] ICJ Rep 4, 39, Individual Opinion by Judge Alvarez. 47 Legality of the Threat or Use of Nuclear Weapons (Advisory Opinion) [1996] ICJ Rep 226, 268, Declaration of President Bedjaoui [13]. 48 International Law Commission (ILC), ‘Articles on Responsibility of States for Internationally Wrongful Acts’ art 2, General Assembly Resolution 56/83, ‘Responsibility of States for Internationally Wrongful Acts’ (adopted 12 December 2001). 49 ibid art 33(1). 50 ibid art 33(2).
Columns Design Ltd
/
Job: Wheatley
/
Division: 04_Theliberaldemocraticstate
/Pg. Position: 10 /
Date: 26/3
JOBNAME: Wheatley PAGE: 11 SESS: 4 OUTPUT: Tue May 11 14:32:06 2010
Community Interests and Constitutionalisation
173
treaties, for example, ‘the individuals concerned should be regarded as the ultimate beneficiaries and in that sense as the holders of the relevant rights’.51 In addition to recognising that international obligations may be owed to individuals, the Articles accept that international law obligations may be owed to states (individually or collectively, where the arrangement transcends the scope of bilateral relations to establish a common interest, over and above the interests of the states individually), and to ‘the international community as a whole’.52 The commentary to the Articles makes the following point: ‘All States are by definition members of the international community as a whole, and the obligations in question are by definition collective obligations protecting interests of the international community as such.’53 Two issues confirm the shift from a bilateral system to an international constitutional order. First, the Articles accept the existence of peremptory norms of general international law. Article 40 provides that in cases of a serious breach (one that ‘involves a gross or systematic failure’) of an obligation arising under a peremptory norm of general international law,54 states shall cooperate to bring any serious breach to an end,55 and no state shall recognise as lawful a situation created by a serious breach of a jus cogens norm, nor render aid or assistance in maintaining that situation.56 Those peremptory norms that are clearly accepted and recognised include the prohibitions of aggression, genocide, slavery, racial discrimination, crimes against humanity and torture, and the right to self-determination.57 Secondly, the provisions on countermeasures both affirm the bilateral nature of much of the inter-state system, and confirm that state relations are conducted within a constitutional framework. The wrongfulness of an act not in conformity with an international obligation is precluded if, and to the extent that, the act constitutes a lawful countermeasure.58 Countermeasures are otherwise unlawful acts that are justified by the failure of the other state to comply with its international obligations. An injured state may only take countermeasures in order to
51 Commentary on art 33, Articles on Responsibility of States for Internationally Wrongful Acts (with commentaries), in Report of the International Law Commission on the Work of Its Fifty-third Session, UN GAOR, 56th Sess, Supp No 10, 43, UN Doc. A/56/10 (2001), reprinted in James Crawford, The International Law Commission’s Articles on State Responsibility: Introduction, Text and Commentaries (Cambridge, Cambridge University Press, 2002). 52 ILC, ‘Articles on State Responsibility’ art 48(1)(b). 53 Commentary on art 48. 54 ILC, ‘Articles on State Responsibility’ art 40(1). 55 ibid art 41(1). 56 ibid art 41(2). 57 Commentary on art 26. 58 ILC, ‘Articles on State Responsibility’ art 22.
Columns Design Ltd
/
Job: Wheatley
/
Division: 04_Theliberaldemocraticstate
/Pg. Position: 11 /
Date: 26/3
JOBNAME: Wheatley PAGE: 12 SESS: 4 OUTPUT: Tue May 11 14:32:06 2010
174 The Constitutionalisation of IL induce the other state to comply with its international law obligations.59 The important point for these purposes is contained in article 50 (1): otherwise lawful countermeasures shall not affect (a) The obligation to refrain from the threat or use of force as embodied in the Charter of the United Nations; (b) Obligations for the protection of fundamental [i.e. non-derogable] human rights; (c) Obligations of a humanitarian character prohibiting reprisals; (d) Other obligations under peremptory norms of general international law.
These issues are ‘sacrosanct’,60 ie ‘inviolable, sacred’.61 The idea of an international community and development of global law norms that are not simply an aggregation of the ‘sovereign’ interests of individual states is reflected, inter alia, in the adoption of ‘constitutional’ resolutions by the UN General Assembly and other international organisations in areas such as international peace and security, the protection of the environment, human rights, and the alleviation of extreme poverty.62 Further, Antonio Cassese observes that whilst the relationship between states remains ‘largely horizontal’,63 involving essentially bilateral legal relationships, a number of international agreements establish obligations for states that are not reciprocal, but which reflect the emergence of values that the international community ‘regard[s] as being worthy of special protection’.64 These community obligations have the following ‘unique’ features: they are obligations protecting fundamental values, including peace, human rights and self-determination; they are obligations erga omnes; they are attended by a correlative right that belongs to all states or, in the case of multilateral treaty regimes, to all contracting states parties, and this right may be exercised ‘on behalf of the whole international community (or the community of the contracting States) to safeguard fundamental values of this community’.65 Together, community obligations constitute a body of values shared by ‘the whole of mankind and to which the particular interests and demands of individual States should yield’.66
59
ibid art 49(1). Commentary on art 50. The Oxford English Dictionary. 2nd edn 1989. OED Online (Oxford, Oxford University Press, 2000). 62 See Simma (n 39) at 236–243. 63 Antonio Cassese, International Law (Oxford, Oxford University Press, 2001) 5 (emphasis in original). 64 ibid at 15. 65 ibid at 16 (emphasis in original). 66 ibid at 16. 60 61
Columns Design Ltd
/
Job: Wheatley
/
Division: 04_Theliberaldemocraticstate
/Pg. Position: 12 /
Date: 26/3
JOBNAME: Wheatley PAGE: 13 SESS: 2 OUTPUT: Tue May 11 14:32:06 2010
The Constitutionalisation of International Law
175
THE CONSTITUTIONALISATION OF INTERNATIONAL LAW
Increasingly, it is accepted that it is appropriate to use the term ‘constitution’ in relation to international law, with related discourses as to the meaning(s) of ‘constitutional’ and ‘constitutionalisation’.67 The development is observed by European public international lawyers, notably German and Dutch public international lawyers, who draw on the constitutional experiences of domestic societies. Michael Wood summarises the arguments as follows: The Germans think of international law as a set of value norms, with the United Nations at its centre… And a constitutionalist Germany (followed by Austria, Sweden, Finland, together with The Netherlands) strives for a global legal community that frames and directs the power of all international actors alike.
This is contrasted with the British concept, which ‘is shaped more by the common law approach that international law norms are developing, but do not necessarily constitute a complete system of law’. In this way the United Kingdom follows the United States.68 Martti Koskenniemi observes that Europeans ‘read international law in the image of our domestic legalism: multilateral treaties as legislation, international courts as an independent judiciary, the Security Council as the police’. It is this intuition that has led to debates about ‘the constitutionalization of international law under the UN Charter’.69 The constitutionalist approach reflects an emphasis in world society on collective goals and a belief in community rather than the state-focused paradigm of the positivist conception of international law.70 The approach is constitutionalist because it regards the international community as a world society governed by an international legal order, or constitution. The international constitution is not codified in a single document, but found in a number of diverse sources, written and
67 See Jost Delbrück, ‘Transnational Federalism: Problems and Prospects of Allocating Public Authority Beyond the State’ (2004) 11 Indiana Journal of Global Legal Studies 31, 55. 68 Michael Wood, ‘The Security Council and the “Constitutionalization” of International Law’ (, 14 March 2007). Available at www.law.leeds.ac.uk/assets/files/ research/cfig/cfig_report_07.pdf (last visited 24 July 2009). 69 Martti Koskenniemi, ‘International Law in Europe: Between Tradition and Renewal’ (2005) 16 European Journal of International Law 113, 117. 70 Bruno Simma argues that the idea of an international legal community ‘proceeds from the assumption that it is international law which binds the parts together, affirming the existence of a “community of States” on the one hand and lending the necessary normative structure to this community on the other… [B]ut the assumption that a society/ community could be held together by means of legal norms alone overestimates the capacity of law and, conversely, underestimates the necessity of a society consensus as a precondition for the formation of, and in particular the respect for, legal rules’: Simma (n 39) at 245 (emphasis in original).
Columns Design Ltd
/
Job: Wheatley
/
Division: 04_Theliberaldemocraticstate
/Pg. Position: 13 /
Date: 26/2
JOBNAME: Wheatley PAGE: 14 SESS: 2 OUTPUT: Tue May 11 14:32:06 2010
176 The Constitutionalisation of IL unwritten. It is not the form of the instrument that makes it constitutional, ‘but a specific quality of some of the most important and basic international norms’.71 The usual topics for enquiry are the hierarchy of legal norms in international law, including jus cogens and erga omnes, the diminishing relevance of consent, the effects of international law on private actors, and the third party effects of treaties. Additionally, reference may be made to international treaties on territories that create objective regimes, the Antarctic Treaty regime, for example, and worldorder treaties in areas such as international human rights law that create international public law. These elements support the basic assumption ‘that substantive, universal, community values exist, implementation of which must be guaranteed by international mechanisms’.72 The constitutionalist argument is that the international community recognises a number of international law norms that cannot be understood in terms of sovereign will. The subjection of sovereign will to ‘higher’ international law norms suggests the existence of an international law order with its own procedural norms and norms of substantive justice. A particular focus is the emergence of a normative hierarchy in international law, and the global regulatory activities of the UN, notably the UN Security Council. The issues are examined in turn. The Normative Hierarchy of International Law The normative hierarchy in international law is evidenced in the recognition of norms of jus cogens,73 the identification of obligations erga omnes,74 and in the idea of ‘intransgressible principles of international customary law’.75 The Report of the Study Group of the International Law Commission, finalised by Martti Koskenniemi, on Fragmentation of International Law observes that the idea that ‘some norms are of a higher legal rank than others has found its expression in one way or another in all legal systems’.76 The relevant provisions of the Vienna Convention on the Law of Treaties provide that a treaty is void ‘if, at the time of its conclusion, it 71 Anne Peters, ‘“There is Nothing More Practical than a Good Theory”: an Overview of Contemporary Approaches to International Law’ (2001) 44 German Yearbook of International Law 25, 35. 72 ibid at 36. 73 Vienna Convention on the Law of Treaties 1155 UNTS 331, arts 53 and 64. 74 Barcelona Traction, Light and Power Company, Limited [1970] ICJ Rep 3 [33]. 75 Legality of the Threat or Use of Nuclear Weapons (Advisory Opinion) [1996] ICJ Rep 226 [79]. In Corfu Channel Case (Merits) [1949] ICJ Rep 4, 22, the International Court of Justice refers to ‘elementary considerations of humanity, even more exacting in peace than in war’. 76 Martti Koskenniemi, ‘Fragmentation of International Law: Difficulties Arising from the Diversification and Expansion of International Law, Report of the Study Group of the International Law Commission’, Finalised by Martti Koskenniemi (13 April 2006) UN Doc A/CN.4/L.682 para 361.
Columns Design Ltd
/
Job: Wheatley
/
Division: 04_Theliberaldemocraticstate
/Pg. Position: 14 /
Date: 26/2
JOBNAME: Wheatley PAGE: 15 SESS: 4 OUTPUT: Tue May 11 14:32:06 2010
The Constitutionalisation of International Law
177
conflicts with a peremptory norm of general international law’,77 and that where a new peremptory norm of general international law emerges, ‘any existing treaty which is in conflict with that norm becomes void and terminates’.78 The Convention defines a norm of jus cogens in the following way: a peremptory norm of general international law is a norm accepted and recognized by the international community of States as a whole as a norm from which no derogation is permitted and which can be modified only by a subsequent norm of general international law having the same character.79
In Armed activities on the territory of the Congo, the International Court confirmed the existence of norms of jus cogens.80 In his separate opinion, Judge ad hoc Dugard observed that the recognition by the Court of jus cogens, along with the notion of obligations erga omnes, ‘affirms the normative hierarchy of international law’.81 According to Judge ad hoc Dugard, the right of peoples to self-determination is a norm of jus cogens standing. The judgment of the Court refers only to the prohibition on genocide as having jus cogens character. Judge ad hoc Dugard observed that norms of jus cogens ‘give legal form to the most fundamental policies or goals of the international community’.82 Norms of jus cogens represent the established interests of the international legal community, distinct from those of the sovereign collective interests of the members of that community.83 In cases of conflict between treaties and norms of jus cogens, the treaty becomes void: ‘Conflict of a treaty with jus cogens renders the treaty – or a separable provision thereof – invalid. It makes no difference whether the treaty is bilateral or multilateral.’ The same logic applies to a conflict between jus cogens and general or customary law.84 The most frequently cited candidates for jus cogens norms include the prohibition on the aggressive use of force, the right to self-defence, the prohibition of genocide, the prohibition of torture, crimes against humanity, the prohibition of slavery and the slave trade, the prohibition of piracy, the prohibition of racial discrimination and apartheid, and the prohibition of hostilities directed at civilian population, ie the ‘basic rules of international humanitarian law’.85
77
Vienna Convention on the Law of Treaties art 53. ibid art 64. 79 ibid art 53. 80 Armed activities on the territory of the Congo (Democratic Republic of the Congo v Rwanda), judgment 3 February 2006 [64]. Available http://www.icj-cij.org/docket/files/126/10435. pdf. 81 ibid, Separate Opinion of Judge ad hoc Dugard at [4]. 82 ibid at [10]. 83 Above n 51 commentary on art 48(7). 84 Koskenniemi (n 76) at para 367. 85 ibid at para 374. 78
Columns Design Ltd
/
Job: Wheatley
/
Division: 04_Theliberaldemocraticstate
/Pg. Position: 15 /
Date: 26/3
JOBNAME: Wheatley PAGE: 16 SESS: 2 OUTPUT: Tue May 11 14:32:06 2010
178 The Constitutionalisation of IL These peremptory norms, recognised by the international community of states as a whole, reflect both the fundamental value to the system of international law of international peace and security,86 and a political idea of international justice, reflected, for example, in the adoption of the resolutions of the General Assembly that first de-legitimised and then declared unlawful the practice of colonialism as a violation of the right of peoples to self-determination.87 The concept of obligations erga omnes is not formally concerned with the normative hierarchy in international law; the idea designates the scope of application of the relevant law, and the consequences that follow any breach.88 Obligations erga omnes are owed to the international community as a whole, with all states entitled to invoke the responsibility of the state. The erga omnes nature of the obligation does not formally indicate any superiority over other obligations.89 The existence of obligations erga omnes was confirmed by the International Court of Justice in Barcelona Traction, Light and Power Company, Limited: [A]n essential distinction should be drawn between the obligations of a State towards the international community as a whole, and those arising vis-à-vis another State in the field of diplomatic protection. By their very nature, the former are the concern of all States. In view of the importance of the rights involved, all States can be held to have a legal interest in their protection; they are obligations erga omnes.90
The judgment affirmed the existence of obligations erga omnes, which were not necessarily distinguished by the importance of their substance. They were norms with certain procedural features – namely the feature that a breach of them can be invoked by any State and not just by individual beneficiaries. These were obligations that were about secondary, not primary rules.91
The idea of obligations erga omnes reflects a move from an essentially bilateral understanding of the international law order to one involving elements of public law governance: ‘The distinction between “bilateral” and erga omnes obligations seems analogous to the domestic distinction
86 See International Military Tribunal (Nuremberg), judgment and sentences, 1 October 1946, reprinted (1947) 41 American Journal of International Law 172, 216–20. 87 See, in particular, General Assembly (GA) Res 1514 (XV) ‘Declaration on the Granting of Independence to Colonial Countries and Peoples’ (adopted 14 December 1960). 88 The idea of obligations erga omnes can be seen in Covenant of the League of Nations art 11: ‘Any war or threat of war, whether immediately affecting any of the Members of the League or not, is hereby declared a matter of concern to the whole League, and the League shall take any action that may be deemed wise and effectual to safeguard the peace of nations.’ 89 Koskenniemi (n 76) at para 380. 90 Barcelona Traction, Light and Power Company, Limited [1970] ICJ Rep 3 [33]. 91 Koskenniemi (n 76) at para 389.
Columns Design Ltd
/
Job: Wheatley
/
Division: 04_Theliberaldemocraticstate
/Pg. Position: 16 /
Date: 26/2
JOBNAME: Wheatley PAGE: 17 SESS: 2 OUTPUT: Tue May 11 14:32:06 2010
The Constitutionalisation of International Law
179
between contracts and public law obligations. In the latter, the relationship is between the legal subject and then public power.’92 In Barcelona Traction, Light and Power Company, Limited, the International Court of Justice concluded that obligations erga omnes derive ‘from the outlawing of acts of aggression, and of genocide, as also from the principles and rules concerning the basic rights of the human person, including protection from slavery and racial discrimination’.93 In its Advisory Opinion in Legal Consequences of the Construction of a Wall in the Occupied Palestinian Territory, the International Court of Justice concluded that a number of the international law obligations violated by Israel included certain obligations erga omnes. These included the obligation to respect the right of the Palestinian people to self-determination, and certain of its obligations under international humanitarian law.94
Article 103, Charter of the United Nations The second principal focus for constitutionalists is the UN system, and emergence of the UN as a global regulator with the authority to bind states to international law norms. Whilst it is not possible to refer to the UN as a World Government, the organisation asserts the primacy of its laws over all other forms of international law (with the possible exception of peremptory norms of jus cogens) and state laws. In the language of ‘Westphalia’, the UN asserts its sovereignty in the global law order, and there are no serious voices that reject the claim of the organisation to be both autonomous and capable of binding Member States (and nonmembers) to a set of normative standards framed in terms of (international) law. The focus for the argument is the supremacy clause contained in article 103 of the Charter of the United Nations (‘the UN Charter’): ‘In the event of a conflict between the obligations of the Members of the United Nations under the present Charter and their obligations under any other international agreement, their obligations under the present Charter shall prevail.’ The idea that the laws of the world organisation should prevail over other international law norms was not itself a novelty in 1945. Article 20 of the Covenant of the League of Nations provides: The Members of the League severally agree that this Covenant is accepted as abrogating all obligations or understandings inter se which are inconsistent 92
ibid at para 395. Above n 90 at [34]. 94 Legal Consequences of the Construction of a Wall in the Occupied Palestinian Territory (Advisory Opinion) [2004] ICJ Rep 136 [155]. 93
Columns Design Ltd
/
Job: Wheatley
/
Division: 04_Theliberaldemocraticstate
/Pg. Position: 17 /
Date: 26/2
JOBNAME: Wheatley PAGE: 18 SESS: 4 OUTPUT: Tue May 11 14:32:06 2010
180 The Constitutionalisation of IL with the terms thereof, and solemnly undertake that they will not hereafter enter into any engagements inconsistent with the terms thereof.
The provision applies the principle of lex posterior: extant inconsistent obligations are abrogated (ie annulled or cancelled), although article 20 provides that where a Member of the League, before becoming a member, had undertaken obligations inconsistent with the Covenant, ‘it shall be the duty of such Member to take immediate steps to procure its release from such obligations’. The consequences of the normative hierarchy were not clearly established in terms of international law. In relation to future obligations, the Covenant does not hold itself out to be a ‘higher’ (constitution-like) instrument: it provides a legal obligation on states parties not to enter into conflicting international law obligations (in contrast to art 103 of the UN Charter). Whatever the literal provisions of article 20 of the Covenant, the International Law Commission Report on Fragmentation concludes that the provision ‘suggested that the Covenant itself was “higher law” in respect to other international obligations’.95 Article 20 provided the starting point for drafting article 103 of the UN Charter, with the participants at the San Francisco Conference sharing a general understanding that obligations under the Charter should prevail over other treaty commitments.96 Article 103 applies the priority of UN law to existing commitments of Members States (lex posterior), and to any new commitments that might arise in legal relations between members, and between members and non-members.97 The provision is clear in its scope and effect: ‘In the event of a conflict between the obligations of the Members of the United Nations under the present Charter and their obligations under any other international agreement, their obligations under the present Charter shall prevail.’ The primacy of article 103 of the UN Charter has been affirmed by the International Court of Justice,98 and by the international law regime concerning treaty obligations contained in the Vienna Convention on the Law of Treaties,99 and Vienna Convention on the Law of Treaties between States and International Organizations or Between International Organizations.100 In cases of conflict, the ‘lower-ranking rule’ is set aside to the extent that it conflicts with the
95
Koskenniemi (n 76) at para 328. ibid at para 329. 97 ibid at para 330. 98 Military and paramilitary activities in and against Nicaragua (Nicaragua v United States), (Jurisdiction and admissibility) [1984] ICJ Rep 392 [107]. 99 Vienna Convention on the Law of Treaties art 30(1). 100 Vienna Convention on the Law of Treaties between States and International Organizations or Between International Organizations (1986) 25 ILM 543, art 30(6): ‘The preceding paragraphs are without prejudice to the fact that, in the event of a conflict between obligations under the Charter of the United Nations and obligations under a treaty, the obligations under the Charter shall prevail.’ 96
Columns Design Ltd
/
Job: Wheatley
/
Division: 04_Theliberaldemocraticstate
/Pg. Position: 18 /
Date: 26/3
JOBNAME: Wheatley PAGE: 19 SESS: 4 OUTPUT: Tue May 11 14:32:06 2010
The Constitutionalisation of International Law
181
obligation under article 103.101 This does not require that the conflicting obligation or instrument is rendered ‘null and void’, ie having no legal status and creating no international law rights and obligations. Article 103 ‘says literally that in case of a conflict, the State in question should fulfil its obligation under the Charter and perform its duties under other agreements’.102 States are under an obligation to comply with all of their obligations under international law. Article 103 refers to conflict between obligations under the Charter and ‘obligations under any other international agreement’. Two issues emerge: does the normative hierarchy asserted in article 103 apply to rules of customary and general international law, and what is the relationship between international law introduced by bodies established under the Charter (resolutions adopted by the UN Security Council, for example) and other international law norms? In relation to customary international law, the International Law Commission Report on Fragmentation concludes that ‘it seems sound to join the prevailing opinion that Article 103 should be read extensively – so as to affirm that charter obligations prevail also over United Nations Member States’ customary law obligations’.103 The basis for the conclusion lies in the character of certain of the provisions of the Charter, the constitutional character of the Charter, and the established practice of states and UN organs. On the relationship between article 103 and political organs established under the Charter, the focus of concern has been the authority of resolutions adopted by the Security Council. Under the Charter, the members of the UN ‘confer on the Security Council primary responsibility for the maintenance of international peace and security, and agree that in carrying out its duties under this responsibility the Security Council acts on their behalf’.104 In cases of conflict between resolutions of the Security Council adopted under chapter VII and rights and obligations under other sources of international law, it is the position of the Security Council that its resolutions should prevail.105 Security Council resolutions are binding in respect of UN Member States by virtue of arts 25 and 48(1),106 and by article 2(6) in relation to ‘all States’.107 Resolutions adopted under chapter VII constitute, by virtue of article 103,108 a 101
Koskenniemi (n 76) at para 333. ibid at para 334. 103 ibid at para 345. 104 Charter of the UN art 24(1). 105 See, for example, Security Council (SC) Res 864 (1993) para 20. 106 Legal consequences for States of the continued presence of South Africa in Namibia (South West Africa) notwithstanding Security Council resolution 276 (1970) [1971] ICJ Rep 16 [116]. 107 See SC Res 917 (1994), 918 (1994) and 1054 (1996). At the time of the adoption of SC Res 1244 (1999), the Federal Republic of Yugoslavia was not a member of the UN. 108 See Questions of interpretation and application of the 1971 Montreal Convention arising from the aerial incident at Lockerbie (Libya v United States) [1992] ICJ Rep 114 [42]. 102
Columns Design Ltd
/
Job: Wheatley
/
Division: 04_Theliberaldemocraticstate
/Pg. Position: 19 /
Date: 26/3
JOBNAME: Wheatley PAGE: 20 SESS: 4 OUTPUT: Tue May 11 14:32:06 2010
182 The Constitutionalisation of IL ‘higher’ form of legal obligation within the international system of law. Article 103 and the practice of states and the UN support the interpretation that as a binding form of UN law, the resolutions of the Security Council prevail over other forms of international law (and in practice domestic law norms). Koskenniemi observes, however, that the idea of jus cogens, ‘suggests that even United Nations politics may meet with a “constitutional” limit’.109 The normative hierarchy of international law and regulatory authority of the UN cannot be understood without reference to constitutionalist discourses and concepts.
THE INTERNATIONAL CONSTITUTION
In domestic societies, social, economic, political and legal life is organised, in part, in accordance with a ‘constitution’. Mattias Kumm identifies three meanings that have been applied to the term in relation to political communities: a formal written document, with entrenched norms and ‘higher’ status in the legal order; a set of norms whose ‘content or function’ may be referred to as constitutional; and the establishment of legitimate constitutional authority, whereby the constitution claims to establish ‘a legally independent authority, an independent legal system that structures and legitimates a political process. Its independence lies in the fact that it does not derive its authority from any other legal authority’.110 Increasingly, it is accepted that constitutionalist discourse can be applied to international law, although there is no agreement on its implications for the allocation and exercise of political authority in world society, given the absence of a constitutional document, global pouvoir constituant (constituent power), global society, or coherent global law order. First, the idea of a constitution is applied to those international law treaties that establish international organisations and institutions. ErnstUlrich Petersmann argues that the term may be applied to the constitutive instruments of international organisations where they constitute a new legal order and assert legal primacy over state parties; create new legal subjects and hierarchically structured institutions with limited governance powers; provide for institutional checks and balances; limit the legal rights of state parties; and provide for the collective supply of international public goods, defined at least in part in terms of human rights, including both civil and political rights, and economic, social and cultural rights. Once established these constitutive instruments operate 109
Koskenniemi (n 76) at para 409. Mattias Kumm, ‘Beyond Golf Clubs and the Judicialization of Politics: why Europe has a Constitution Properly So Called’ (2006) American Journal of Comparative Law 505, 508–9. 110
Columns Design Ltd
/
Job: Wheatley
/
Division: 04_Theliberaldemocraticstate
/Pg. Position: 20 /
Date: 26/3
JOBNAME: Wheatley PAGE: 21 SESS: 4 OUTPUT: Tue May 11 14:32:06 2010
The International Constitution
183
as ‘living constitutions’, whose functions ‘increasingly evolve in response to changing needs for international co-operation’.111 The paradigm example is the Charter of the UN, and the development of an autonomous body of ‘UN law’ by the General Assembly and Security Council. The application of constitutional discourses can explain the divergence of the practice of political organs from the literal text, agreed, or ‘contracted’, by states parties. Consider, for example, the failure of the Security Council to operate in accordance with the requirements established under chapters V and VII of the Charter. Whilst the practice under chapter VII of authorising Member States to ‘use all necessary means’ to achieve stated objectives may have been a practical necessity, given the absence of direct control over armed forces, the (de facto/de jure) change in voting procedures in chapter V cannot be explained on the same basis. Article 27(3) refers to the need for decisions to be made with the ‘concurring votes of the permanent members’. The practice of the Security Council is to require a permanent member to positively exercise its veto power. The revised scheme cannot be easily understood by reference to a contractual model of textual interpretation. By contrast, constitutional law relies to a much greater extent on the practices of political actors in understanding the exercise of (public law) powers. As JL Brierly observes, constitutions ‘are overlaid with precedents and conventions which change them after a time into something very different from what anyone, with only the original text before him, could possibly have foreseen’.112 Secondly, there is the work of Alfred Verdross. The possibility of applying the term ‘constitution’ to international law is credited to Verdross,113 who regarded all human persons as members of the same community, and argued that the binding force of international law was grounded in a fundamental norm based in the law of nature.114 According to Bruno Simma, Verdross did not seek to argue that humankind constituted a ‘universal inter-human legal community’, but that the
111 Ernst-Ulrich Petersmann, ‘Human Rights, Constitutionalism and the World Trade Organization: Challenges for World Trade Organization Jurisprudence and Civil Society’ (2006) 19 Leiden Journal of International Law 633, 640–41. 112 JL Brierly, ‘The Covenant and the Charter’ (1946) 23 British Yearbook of International Law 83, quoted Bardo Fassbender, ‘The UN Charter as Constitution of the International Community’ (1998) 36 Columbia Journal of Transnational Law 529, 594. 113 In 1920, Charlemagne Tower used the term ‘international constitution’ when discussing the fundamental law of international government: Charlemagne Tower, Book Review (1920) 14 American Journal of International Law 464, 466. In 1961, Torkel Opsahl observed that ‘[e]ven among lawyers, it has become a habit to speak of the Charter as a world constitution’: Torkel Opsahl, ‘An “international constitutional law”?’ (1961) 10 International and Comparative Law Quarterly 760, 777. 114 Alfred Verdross, Die Verfassung der Völkerrechtsgemeinschaft (The Constitution of the International Legal Community) (1926). See Simma (n 39) at 259.
Columns Design Ltd
/
Job: Wheatley
/
Division: 04_Theliberaldemocraticstate
/Pg. Position: 21 /
Date: 26/3
JOBNAME: Wheatley PAGE: 22 SESS: 4 OUTPUT: Tue May 11 14:32:06 2010
184 The Constitutionalisation of IL international community of states and international organisations constituted ‘parts of the community bound together by universal international law, a community comprising the whole of mankind’.115 The basic norm of the international order would provide that the subjects of international law ‘ought to behave as prescribed by the fundamental legal principles deriving from the social nature of human communities as well as by the rules of international treaty and customary law created on the basis of such principles’.116 The approach led Verdross to argue for the recognition of norms of jus cogens, a ‘general principle prohibiting states from concluding treaties contra bonos mores’, on the basis that no juridical order can ‘admit treaties between juridical subjects, which are obviously in contradiction to the ethics of a certain community’.117 Verdross subsequently argued that the UN Charter had assumed the ‘character of basic law for the whole international community’.118 The paramountcy of the Charter did not depend on legal rules, but on moral force, especially on the good faith of the all Great Powers [the five permanent members of the UN Security Council], which, by ratifying the Charter[,] [had] assumed the high and responsible role of trustees and guardians of the peace.119
Bardo Fassbender notes that Verdross was not consistent in his writings, at one point concluding that those norms that constitute the community of international law ‘can be called a constitution of the community of states in a substantive sense’,120 but later, in an edition co-authored with Simma, contending that ‘the U.N. Charter has gained the rank of the constitution of the universal community of states’.121 Verdross and Simma use the term ‘constitution’ in a normative sense. It is a set of rules of international law which take precedence over other norms in so far as their existence is a precondition for the validity of the latter from a logical and a legal point of view.122
Thirdly, the idea of a constitution can be applied to the idea of the international community as a legal community of states (and international organisations) under (international) law. Fassbender argues that this idea of a 115 Bruno Simma, ‘The Contribution of Alfred Verdross to the Theory of International Law’ (1995) 6 European Journal of International Law 1, 15. 116 ibid at 17. 117 Alfred Verdross, ‘Forbidden Treaties in International Law’ (1937) 31 American Journal of International Law 571, 572. 118 Alfred Verdross, ‘General International Law and the UN Charter’ (1954) 30 International Affairs 342, 347. 119 ibid at 348. 120 Alfred Verdross, Völkerrecht, 2nd edn (1950) at 74. 121 Alfred Verdross and Bruno Simma, Universelles Völkerrecht: Theorie und Praxis, 3rd edn (1984) at vii–viii. 122 Fassbender (n 112) at 542.
Columns Design Ltd
/
Job: Wheatley
/
Division: 04_Theliberaldemocraticstate
/Pg. Position: 22 /
Date: 26/3
JOBNAME: Wheatley PAGE: 23 SESS: 4 OUTPUT: Tue May 11 14:32:06 2010
The International Constitution
185
constitution refers to ‘the basic norm of a system of positive law upon which the validity of all other norms depends. It provides the ultimate basis of obligation in a legal system’. Substantive principles are not part of the constitution, but part of the ‘common public order (ordre public international)’. Substantive principles are expressed in the recognition of norms of jus cogens standing, and existence of obligations erga omnes.123 Constitutional rules are rules about rules, and rules about law-making. Christian Tomuschat argues that secondary rules on law-making and the exercise of executive and judicial functions form the constitution of any system of governance: ‘Every modern system of governance is operated through law-making, administration and adjudication’,124 and the international community ‘can indeed be conceived of as a legal entity, governed by a constitution’.125 International law provides the framework within which states exercise rights of political self-determination. The Charter of the UN, along with other world order treaties, such as the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights and International Covenant on Economic, Social and Cultural Rights, Vienna Convention on Diplomatic Relations, and Law of the Sea Convention concretise ‘the constitutional premises of the existing international legal order’.126 Following an analysis of the possible meanings when applied to the state, Fassbender concludes that the idea of a ‘constitution’ is concerned with a complex of fundamental norms that both govern the organisation and performance of government functions, and define the relationship between state authorities and the citizen. Constitutions may also prescribe the fundamental policy goals of the state, establishing the ‘guiding principles for the political life of a community for an indefinite time’. Established as a form of positive law, the constitution binds all actors within the political community, including the government. It is often codified in a single document. Constitutional law norms are often difficult to amend (ie ‘entrenched’), and regarded as a ‘higher’ form of law, ie in cases of conflict with a statute or common law, the constitutional norm will prevail.127 On this understanding, Fassbender identifies a number of ‘constitutional characteristics’ of the Charter of the UN.128 First, the Charter was introduced at a ‘constitutional moment’ on 26 June 1945 at San Francisco. Secondly, it provides for a system of international governance, including legislative, executive and judicial provisions. Thirdly, in
123 124 125 126 127 128
ibid at 547. Tomuschat (n 14) at 216. ibid at 236. ibid at 309. Fassbender (n 112) at 536–37. ibid at 573ff.
Columns Design Ltd
/
Job: Wheatley
/
Division: 04_Theliberaldemocraticstate
/Pg. Position: 23 /
Date: 26/3
JOBNAME: Wheatley PAGE: 24 SESS: 4 OUTPUT: Tue May 11 14:32:06 2010
186 The Constitutionalisation of IL article 4, the Charter defines the membership of the Organisation, establishing a political community (of states). Fourthly, the Charter affirms the hierarchy of its norms (article 103). Fifthly, the language in the Charter assumes an eternity of existence, proving only for amendment, not termination; moreover, the amendment procedures are difficult and complex.129 Sixthly, the treaty establishing the UN is a ‘Charter’, a term that denotes ‘an especially elevated class of legal instruments’.130 Fassbenber argues that ‘there is no doubt that in 1945 the term “charter” was understood to be equivalent to “written constitution”.’ The interpretation is confirmed by the opening words: ‘We the peoples of the United Nations.’ These words are modelled on the US Constitution.131 Seventhly, the Charter has a constitutional history, with UN organs and the UN system being responsible for a number of ‘constitutional’ developments in the international law system, such as the emergence of norms on self-determination and decolonisation, human rights, the common heritage of mankind, and environmental protection. Finally, the Charter applies a principle of universality or inclusiveness, applying equally to all members of the international legal community.132 Fassbender concludes that the UN Charter, ‘as constitution of the international legal community, embraces all international law’. There is no such thing as general international law existing independently of the Charter. The Charter is the ‘supporting frame of all international law and, at the same time, the highest layer in a hierarchy of norms of international law’.133 The UN is in a superior position to all states and all international organisations. The idea of international constitutional law ‘is the body of rules and principles defining, in form and in substance, the basis of the international community, and indicating the general course the community has decided to steer’. It is embodied in the Charter of the UN, which sets out common values, goals and principles, and establishes the institutional machinery ‘necessary for carrying out the substantive norms’.134 Other writers refer to the Charter as the ‘constitutional document of the international community of states’,135 or the ‘constitution of mankind’.136
129
Charter of the UN arts 108 and 109. Fassbender (n 112) at 579. 131 ibid at 580. 132 ibid at 581. 133 ibid at 585. See also Rudolf Bernhardt, ‘Article 103’ in Bruno Simma et al (eds), The Charter of the United Nations: a Commentary, 2nd edn (Oxford, Oxford University Press, 2002) 1292, 1298. 134 Fassbender (n 112) at 589. 135 Bruno Simma and Andreas Paulus, ‘The “international community”: Facing the Challenges of Globalization’ (1998) 9 European Journal of International Law 266, 274. 136 Ernst-Ulrich Petersmann, ‘Constitutionalism and International Adjudication: How to Constitutionalize the U.N. Dispute Settlement System?’ (1999) 31 New York University Journal of International Law and Politics 753, 766–67. 130
Columns Design Ltd
/
Job: Wheatley
/
Division: 04_Theliberaldemocraticstate
/Pg. Position: 24 /
Date: 26/3
JOBNAME: Wheatley PAGE: 25 SESS: 4 OUTPUT: Tue May 11 14:32:06 2010
The International Constitutional Order
187
The constitutionalist analysis makes a number of important contributions to understanding international law. Whilst the UN Charter forms an integral part of the international constitutional order, it cannot be regarded as the Constitution of the international law system. The international community does not possess a constitution in the sense of a formal written document that allocates law-making powers, providing entrenched constitutional rights, including fundamental human rights. As Tomuschat observes, if the constitution of the international community were to exist, it is ‘obvious’ that it would ‘display features which are largely similar to that of the British system of government’, which lacks a single constitutional document.137 The focus of the constitutionalist enquiry is not a particular instrument (ie the UN Charter), but those international constitutional norms and principles that together frame and constrain the exercise of political authority by state and non-state actors.
THE INTERNATIONAL CONSTITUTIONAL ORDER
The constitutionalist argument represents a significant move away from a contractual order, based on sovereign consent, to a public (international) law system of global governance, but it is important not to overstate the divergence of the constitutionalist understanding from that which existed previously. In one sense, the constitutionalist argument recognises that, in its post-ontological era,138 international law is (in fact) a system of law, and that all legal systems require ‘rules about rules’. In addition to primary rules of obligation, a legal system must possess (in HLA Hart’s terms) secondary rules of change, adjudication, and recognition, ‘which specify the ways in which the primary rules may be conclusively ascertained, introduced, eliminated, varied, and the fact of their violation conclusively determined’.139 Philip Allott, for example, distinguishes between international constitutional law, international public law, and the law of nations. International constitutional law ‘is what some older writers called the “necessary” law of nations’, those rules that determine the capacity of actors to enter into international law relations, and the scope and possibilities of their relations vis-à-vis each other’. It also determines the relations between international public law, and the law of nations, and the relationship between the laws of nations.140 Daniel Philpott concludes that international constitutional law norms 137
Tomuschat (n 14) at 218. Thomas Franck, Fairness in International Law and Institutions (Oxford, Oxford University Press, 1995) 6. 139 HLA Hart, The Concept of Law, 2nd edn (Oxford, Oxford University Press, 1994) 94. 140 Philip Allott, ‘The Concept of International Law’ in Michael Byers (ed), The Role of Law in International Politics (Oxford, Oxford University Press, 2000) 69, 75. 138
Columns Design Ltd
/
Job: Wheatley
/
Division: 04_Theliberaldemocraticstate
/Pg. Position: 25 /
Date: 26/3
JOBNAME: Wheatley PAGE: 26 SESS: 4 OUTPUT: Tue May 11 14:32:06 2010
188 The Constitutionalisation of IL provide answers to three fundamental questions: who are the legitimate polities; what are the rules for becoming one of these polities; and what are the basic prerogatives of these polities?141 According to the procedural understanding, international constitutional norms define the ‘constitutive rules of the sovereignty game’,142 including rights of membership, the inherent rights of political units, and the rules for the establishment of legal relationships, notably pacta sunt servanda. Others argue for a more expansive understanding of international constitutional law to include substantive values.143 According to Erika de Wet, the term ‘constitution’ in global governance refers to an ‘embryonic constitutional order’, in which a plurality of domestic, regional and international regimes form the building blocks of an international community that is ‘underpinned by a core value system common to all communities’.144 The term constitution in global governance can be extended to include the fragmented multilevel system that embodies core values and provides a variety of legal structures for their enforcement.145 The international law system would then be regarded as a supra-national global (federal) constitutional order, with the different sectoral regimes functioning as ‘complementary elements of a larger whole. This would be the embryonic international constitutional order with the UN Charter system as the main connecting factor.’146 The literature on constitutionalism in world society emerged as one response to globalisation and recognition that governance functions were increasingly being undertaken outside of the constitutional frame for (democratic) law-making provided by the sovereign state. Consider, for example, the argument of Anne Peters that a ‘compensatory constitutionalization on the international plane’ is required, given that only the various levels of governance, taken together, ‘can provide full constitutional protection’.147 The analysis suggests new forms of legitimacy for
141 Daniel Philpott, Revolutions in Sovereignty: How Ideas Shaped Modern International Relations (Princeton, Princeton University Press, 2001) 12. 142 Robert Jackson, ‘Quasi-States, Dual Regimes, and Neoclassical Theory: International Jurisprudence and the Third World’ (1987) 41 International Organization 519, 522. 143 See, generally, Bardo Fassbender, ‘The Meaning of International Constitutional Law’ in Ronald St John Macdonald and Douglas Johnston (eds), Towards World Constitutionalism: Issues in the Legal Ordering of the World Community (Leiden, Martinus Nijhoff Publishers, 2005) 837. 144 Erika de Wet, ‘The Emergence of International and Regional Value Systems as a Manifestation of the Emerging International Constitutional Order’ (2006) 19 Leiden Journal of International Law 611, 612. 145 Erika de Wet, ‘The International Constitutional Order’ (2006) 55 International and Comparative Law Quarterly 51, 53. 146 ibid at 56. 147 Anne Peters, ‘Global Constitutionalism Revisited’ (2005) 11 International Legal Theory 39, 41–42.
Columns Design Ltd
/
Job: Wheatley
/
Division: 04_Theliberaldemocraticstate
/Pg. Position: 26 /
Date: 26/3
JOBNAME: Wheatley PAGE: 27 SESS: 4 OUTPUT: Tue May 11 14:32:06 2010
The International Constitutional Order
189
the international system, with state sovereignty gradually ‘complemented (if not substituted) by other guiding principles, notably the “global common interest” and/or “rule of law” and/or “human security”.’148 Both domestic and international constitutional law must complement each other; they should not be understood as being in a hierarchical arrangement, but in the form of a network, and the ‘constitutional elements on the various levels and in the various sectors may complement and support each other’.149 A notable contribution is that of Ernst-Ulrich Petersmann, who argues that the constitutionalisation of international law requires the integration of international human rights law in general international law, specifically in relation to the UN and World Trade Organization. The aim is to entrench liberal human rights norms, including rights to property and trade, in national constitutions and before international courts and tribunals. The argument is controversial because of the focus on economic private law rights. Petersmann contends that markets are indispensable in promoting individual autonomy and that economic law ‘is a necessary precondition for the proper functioning of markets and for avoiding both market failures as well as government failures’.150 The analysis proceeds from an understanding of international law as a mechanism for ensuring the legitimate exercise of coercive political authority at the domestic level, which depends on three factors: the protection of the equal rights of citizens; the (democratic) requirement that decisions are taken by the people or their representatives; and the ‘welfare-increasing results of democratic policy-making’.151 International institutions should be understood as part of a ‘fourth branch of government’ (alongside the legislative, executive and judicial branches of domestic government) and, like domestic institutions, they derive their legitimacy from promoting the equal liberties and public interest of (domestic) citizens.152 The legitimate exercise of coercive government powers depends on the existence of liberal democratic institutions organised in accordance with a constitution, and there are certain ideas that are common to all (liberal democratic) constitutions: democracy, separation of powers, rule of law and the protection of human rights.153 Arguments around the democratic deficit in global governance should be understood in terms of the
148
ibid at 49. ibid at 64. 150 Ernst-Ulrich Petersmann, ‘Constitutionalism and International Organizations’ (1996/7) 17 Northwestern Journal of International Law and Business 398, 400. 151 ibid at 406. 152 ibid at 440. 153 Ernst-Ulrich Petersmann, ‘Human Rights, Constitutionalism and the World Trade Organization: Challenges for World Trade Organization Jurisprudence and Civil Society’ (2006) 19 Leiden Journal of International Law 633, 641. 149
Columns Design Ltd
/
Job: Wheatley
/
Division: 04_Theliberaldemocraticstate
/Pg. Position: 27 /
Date: 26/3
JOBNAME: Wheatley PAGE: 28 SESS: 4 OUTPUT: Tue May 11 14:32:06 2010
190 The Constitutionalisation of IL teleology of all liberal democratic political associations: ensuring the democratic rights and welfare of individual citizens. The democratic legitimacy of international institutions depends on the transformation of the ‘society of states paradigm’ into a more ‘citizen-oriented paradigm’. Given that globalisation has reduced the capacity of states to secure the well-being of their citizens, there is a need for ‘new forms of democratic self-government, “transnational justice” and international rule-making for the collective supply of international public goods’.154 To the extent that the protection of rights, popular control over policy-making, and welfare enhancement cannot be achieved at the domestic level, it should be guaranteed at the international level by a ‘new U.N. Constitution’,155 based on international human rights, an agreed democratic peace, and compulsory jurisdiction for the International Court of Justice. States would have to commit themselves to the necessary democratic and legal reforms, or face exclusion from the ‘new United Nations’.156 Petersmann’s analysis demonstrates the essentially political nature of constitutional discourses. The constitutionalist analysis (as it appears in the literature) is an argument for the entrenchment of (contested) liberal democratic values of rule of law, democracy, and the protection of individual human rights in international law, and the subjection of states (who remain the principle subjects of international law) to the requirements of liberal democracy. Armin von Bogdandy refers to a ‘vision’ of a global legal community that ‘frames and directs political power in light of common values and a common good’. This is what is meant by ‘constitutionalism’ in international law.157 There is a tension between constitutional discourses and democracy. The metaphors that describe the impact of constitutional norms on democratic politics are instructive: there is a ‘door closing’ function to constitutional discourse;158 the use of constitutional norms can be used to ‘shut down’ political debate;159 constitutional norms ‘lock in’ contested
154 Ernst-Ulrich Petersmann, ‘Multilevel Judicial Governance of International Trade Requires a Common Conception of Rule of Law and Justice’ (2007) 10 Journal of International Economic Law 529, 532. 155 Ernst-Ulrich Petersmann, ‘Constitutionalism and International Adjudication: How to Constitutionalize the U.N. Dispute Settlement System?’ (1999) 31 New York University Journal of International Law and Politics 753, 781. 156 ibid at 782. 157 Armin von Bogdandy, ‘Constitutionalism in International Law: Comment on a Proposal from Germany’ (2006) 47 Harvard International Law Journal 223, 223. 158 Robert Howse and Kalypso Nicolaidis, ‘Enhancing WTO legitimacy: Constitutionalization or Global Subsidiarity?’ (2003) 16 Governance 73, 74. 159 Jeffrey Dunoff, ‘Constitutional Conceits: the WTO’s ‘Constitution’ and the Discipline of International Law’ (2006) 17 European Journal of International Law 647, 662.
Columns Design Ltd
/
Job: Wheatley
/
Division: 04_Theliberaldemocraticstate
/Pg. Position: 28 /
Date: 26/3
JOBNAME: Wheatley PAGE: 29 SESS: 4 OUTPUT: Tue May 11 14:32:06 2010
The International Constitutional Order
191
and contestable policies.160 Constitutions are not only mechanism for allocating power and prescribing rules about rule-making, they are instruments that give expression to the fundamental political values and goals of a political society. There is a general acceptance in constitutional discourses that constitutional norms should not be subject to amendment without some special procedure, or sense that the political settlement has been repudiated and a new settlement put in its place. Constitutional norms sit outside of the domain of ‘normal’ politics: the idea of constitutionalism refers to the ‘containment of politics by a supervening law that stands beyond the reach of the politics it is meant to contain’.161 Agreed constitutional norms place certain choices beyond the reach of democratic politics.162 The people may replace or amend the constitution, but whilst it remains in place, it limits the political choices of the ‘here-andnow’ citizens. Mutatis mutandis, the application of constitutional discourse to international law requires that certain international norms are insulated from political contestation. Consider, for example, the response of (most) public international lawyers to any claim that torture may be justified in the global war on terror. The prohibition on torture is an international norm of jus cogens standing (and obligation erga omnes). It is a fundamental global justice norm of the international constitutional order. No political argument can succeed in displacing the prohibition from its exalted status in the global world of law. The increased recourse to law in international relations, referred to as ‘legalisation’,163 and the resolution of inter-state disputes by reference to legal texts, does not ‘translate automatically into a substantive constitution in the absence of that sense of shared “project” or objective’.164 Stephen Gill refers to the ‘new constitutionalism’ as a ‘project of attempting to make transnational liberalism, and if possible liberal democratic capitalism, the sole model for future development’.165 Constitutionalism is a political project that argues for the recognition of liberal democratic principles concerning the rule of law, human rights and democracy in the
160 Robert Howse and Kalypso Nicolaïdis, ‘Legitimacy and Global Governance: Why Constitutionalizing the WTO is a Step too Far’ in Roger Porter, et al (eds), Efficiency, Equity, and Legitimacy: the Multilateral Trading System at the Millennium (Washington DC, Brookings Institution Press, 2001) 227, 229. 161 Frank Michelman, ‘The 1996–97 Brennan Center Symposium Lecture’ (1998) Californian Law Review 399, 400. 162 ibid at 401. 163 Kenneth Abbott et al, ‘The Concept of Legalization’ (2000) 54 International Organization 401, 419. 164 Martti Koskenniemi, ‘The Fate of Public International Law: Between Technique and Politics’ (2007) Modern Law Review 1, 16. 165 Stephen Gill, Power and Resistance in the New World Order (Basingstoke, Palgrave Macmillan, 2003) 132, quoted in Sol Picciotto, ‘Constitutionalizing Multilevel Governance?’ (2008) 6 International Journal of Constitutional Law 457, 471.
Columns Design Ltd
/
Job: Wheatley
/
Division: 04_Theliberaldemocraticstate
/Pg. Position: 29 /
Date: 26/3
JOBNAME: Wheatley PAGE: 30 SESS: 4 OUTPUT: Tue May 11 14:32:06 2010
192 The Constitutionalisation of IL international law order. Those principles are then imposed on state societies.166 Arguments for the constitutionalisation of international law are, simply put, arguments for the application of values first codified in the American Constitution at the global level: separation of powers (fragmentation of governance functions), rule of law, human rights, and democratic legitimacy. The fact that constitutional discourses in international law mirror the constitutional settlement in the United States is no coincidence. The evidence is that all international societies with shared values and assumptions have evolved within a matrix of a dominant culture.167 In the words of John Ruggie, it was ‘American hegemony that was decisive after World War II, not merely American hegemony.’168 The system of global governance, David Slater writes, reflects the contradictory identity of the United States as a ‘post-colonial imperial power’.169 The United States both affirms a right of all peoples to self-determination (a lesson learnt in the American Revolution) and a belief ‘in the geopolitical destiny of the USA’. This has necessitated the development of a ‘discursive “bridge”’, able to ‘transcend the contradiction between an identity based on the self-determination of peoples and another rooted in Empire’. This discursive bridge has been formed through the invocation of a democratic mission that combines both the national and international spheres: ‘[A] horizon is created for other peoples who are encouraged to choose freedom and democracy, thereby embedding their own struggles within an Americanising vision and practice.’170 The result is an imperial project that seeks to develop, modernise and democratise domestic societies. The vision is that of liberal democracy, or more accurately market-led democracy, which has become hegemonic in an era
166 See, generally, Jan Klabbers, Anne Peters, and Geir Ulfstein, The Constitutionalization of International Law (Oxford, Oxford University Press, 2009) 348–51; also Anne Peters and Klaus Armingeon, ‘Global Constitutionalism from an Interdisciplinary Perspective’ (2009) 16 Indiana Journal of Global Legal Studies 385, 389: ‘We employ the term “global constitutionalism” in order to characterize an academic and political agenda which identifies and advocates the application of constitutionalist principles, such as the rule of law, checks and balances, human rights protection, and possibly democracy, in the international legal sphere in order to improve the effectiveness and the fairness of the international legal order.’ 167 Adam Watson, The Evolution of International Society: a Comparative Historical Analysis (London, Routledge, 1992) 307. 168 John Ruggie, ‘Multilateralism: The Anatomy of an Institution’ in John Ruggie (ed), Multilateralism Matters: the Theory and Praxis of an Institutional Form (New York, Chichester, Columbia University Press, 1993) 3, 31 (emphasis in original), quoted Christian Reus-Smit, ‘The Constitutional Structure of International Society and the Nature of Fundamental Institutions’ (1997) 51 International Organization 555, 563. 169 David Slater, ‘Imperial Powers and Democratic Imaginations’ (2006) Third World Quarterly 1369, 1376. 170 ibid at 1377.
Columns Design Ltd
/
Job: Wheatley
/
Division: 04_Theliberaldemocraticstate
/Pg. Position: 30 /
Date: 26/3
JOBNAME: Wheatley PAGE: 31 SESS: 4 OUTPUT: Tue May 11 14:32:06 2010
Liberal Democratic Values in International Law
193
of neo-liberal globalisation.171 The assumption is that the Western liberal model of democratic governance should be applied to all (state) societies (including non-Western societies).172 The imposition of good governance norms concerning rule of law, human rights, and (liberal) democratic government form one part of an ‘imperial project’ that demonstrates a ‘lack of respect and recognition for the colonised or, expressed more broadly, imperialised society’.173
LIBERAL DEMOCRATIC VALUES IN INTERNATIONAL LAW
The two-track model of democratic self-determination that developed following the Westphalian settlement is no longer sufficient to make sense of the democratic legitimacy of law. The development of a normative hierarchy in international law, emergence of a global authority (in the form of the UN), and (implicitly) a global constitutional order provides a new context for (domestic) democratic self-determination. Political self-determination is exercised within a global constitutional framework that promotes the liberal democratic values of rule of law, protection of human rights, and democratic mechanisms for the establishment of valid laws. The international community of state and nonstate actors has developed an (admittedly amorphous) international constitutional order within which state exercise rights of political selfdetermination. The constitutionalisation of international law is a political project in the image of hegemonic power, suggesting the gradual emergence of a world community of liberal (democratic) states in which the individual is the primary unit of concern in the international order. Two developments support the analysis, the emergence of an international rule of law and body of international human rights law.
171 ibid at 1380. Ran Hirschl argues that all processes of constitutionalisation should be seen in terms of ‘hegemony preservation’ – unless proven otherwise, the most plausible explanation for constitutionalisation is that those political power holders, who either initiate or refrain from blocking reforms, assume that any limits on their own scope for political action will be compensated for by ‘the limits it might impose on rival political elements, their alternative worldviews, and policy preferences’: Ran Hirschl, ‘Preserving Hegemony? Assessing the Political Origins of the EU Constitution’ (2005) 3 International Journal of Constitutional Law 269, 278. 172 ibid at 1380. 173 ibid at 1372 (emphasis in original).
Columns Design Ltd
/
Job: Wheatley
/
Division: 04_Theliberaldemocraticstate
/Pg. Position: 31 /
Date: 26/3
JOBNAME: Wheatley PAGE: 32 SESS: 4 OUTPUT: Tue May 11 14:32:06 2010
194 The Constitutionalisation of IL RULE OF LAW
Increasingly, it is recognised that it is appropriate to speak about an international rule of law, or rule of international law.174 Following an analysis of the concept applied in domestic societies, Stephane Beaulac concludes that the rule of law requires certainty, predictability and stability.175 The idea involves the avoidance of the exercise of arbitrary power, and the constraint of discretionary power.176 There is no reason to conclude that the concept cannot be applied to international law. André Nollkaemper observes that at the domestic level the idea of the rule of law ‘primarily (though not exclusively) involves protection against the public power of the state’. The argument has not traditionally been applied at the international level, as there is ‘no equivalent to such centralized public power’.177 The idea of the international rule of law has been concerned with the horizontal relations between states, reflected, for example, in the non-intervention doctrine. The understanding is no longer sufficient, as international law is ‘increasingly of a regulatory nature, governing directly the legal rights and obligations of private persons who are located in domestic legal orders’. This is particularly the case in relation to international human rights law, which ‘strengthens and supports the domestic rule of law, for instance in protecting the autonomy of domestic courts vis-à-vis the political branches, and in protecting citizens against retrospective laws’.178 To the extent that international law ‘pervades the domestic legal order more deeply, it seems a sound premise that international law should conform to rule of law requirements that we tend to pose for domestic law’. The rule of law is associated with the protection of fundamental rights, and the need for domestic institutions, notably courts, to scrutinise ‘whether international acts (in particular acts of international organizations) are compatible with fundamental rights’.179 Nollkaemper articulates a substantive concept of the rule of law: it is not simply concerned with the existence or not of law norms, but with
174 On the domestic idea of the rule of law, see AV Dicey, Introduction to the Study of the Law of the Constitution (London, Macmillan, 1939); Joseph Raz, ‘The Rule of Law and its Virtue’ in The Authority of Law (Oxford, Clarendon Press, 1979) 224; Jeremy Waldron, ‘Is the Rule of Law an Essentially Contested Concept (in Florida)?’ (2002) 21 Law and Philosophy 137; also Brian Tamanaha, On the Rule of Law: History, Politics, Theory (Cambridge, Cambridge University Press, 2004). 175 Stephane Beaulac, ‘An Inquiry into the International Rule of Law’ (2007) EUI Max Weber Programme Series Working Paper No 2007/14 (SSRN) 10. 176 ibid at 12. 177 André Nollkaemper, ‘The Internationalized Rule of Law’ (2009) 1 Hague Journal on the Rule of Law 74, 74. 178 ibid at 75. 179 ibid at 76.
Columns Design Ltd
/
Job: Wheatley
/
Division: 04_Theliberaldemocraticstate
/Pg. Position: 32 /
Date: 26/3
JOBNAME: Wheatley PAGE: 33 SESS: 4 OUTPUT: Tue May 11 14:32:06 2010
Rule of Law 195 substantive values that must be present for the legitimate exercise of political authority through law. A number of international instruments refer expressly to the idea of an international rule of law. The Declaration on Friendly Relations refers to the ‘promotion of the rule of law among nations’. The 2005 World Summit Declaration affirms the need for universal adherence to the rule of law ‘at both the national and international levels’, and the commitment of Member States of the United Nations to an international order ‘based on the rule of law and international law’. In paragraph 134, Member States reaffirmed their commitment to the purposes and principles of the Charter and international law, ‘and to an international order based on the rule of law and international law, which is essential for peaceful coexistence and cooperation among States’.180 The provision also encourages states that have not done so ‘to consider becoming parties to all treaties that relate to the protection of civilians’,181 and calls on states ‘to continue their efforts to eradicate policies and practices that discriminate against women and to adopt laws and promote practices that protect the rights of women and promote gender equality’.182 It suggests a connection between the rule of law and the protection of the human person.183 On 11 December 2008, the UN General Assembly adopted, without a vote, Resolution 63/128: ‘The rule of law at the national and international levels.’ The resolution reaffirms the requirement for ‘universal adherence to and implementation of the rule of law at both the national and international levels’, and the ‘solemn commitment’ of the General Assembly ‘to an international order based on the rule of law and international law, which, together with the principles of justice, is essential for peaceful coexistence and cooperation among States’. The resolution concludes that ‘the promotion of and respect for the rule of law at the national and international levels, as well as justice and good governance, should guide the activities of the United Nations and of its Member States’. It reaffirms the link between human rights, the rule of law and democracy, describing them ‘mutually reinforcing and [belonging] to the universal and indivisible core values and principles of the United Nations’. The resolution further argues that respect for the rule of law at the state and international level ‘is essential for the realization of sustained economic growth, sustainable development, the eradication of poverty and hunger and the protection of all human rights and fundamental freedoms’.184 180 GA Res 60/1, ‘2005 World Summit Outcome’ (adopted 16 September 2005) at para 134(a). 181 ibid at para 134(c). 182 ibid at para 134(d). 183 ibid at para 134(e). 184 GA Res 63/128, ‘The Rule of Law at the National and International Levels’ (adopted 11 December 2008) preamble.
Columns Design Ltd
/
Job: Wheatley
/
Division: 04_Theliberaldemocraticstate
/Pg. Position: 33 /
Date: 26/3
JOBNAME: Wheatley PAGE: 34 SESS: 4 OUTPUT: Tue May 11 14:32:06 2010
196 The Constitutionalisation of IL Whilst the existence of a rule of international law is no longer controversial, agreement on the content of the principle remains elusive. The indeterminacy is reflected in the very idea of the rule of law, which, as Simon Chesterman observes, ‘remains contested across both time and geography’.185 There is, however, a core meaning: the power of the state should not be exercised in an arbitrary manner, and it should be prospective, accessible, and clear; the law should apply equally to the sovereign and the institutions of the state, with some independent institution (‘court’) to apply the law in specific cases; and should apply equally to all persons.186 In relation to the international rule of law, Chesterman identifies three possible meanings: first, the application of rule of law principles to relations between states and other subjects of international law; secondly, an affirmation of the international law principle of a hierarchy that privileges international law over state law, for example in relation to international human rights norms; and thirdly, a ‘global rule of law’, reflecting the ‘emergence of a normative regime that touches individuals directly without formal mediation through existing national institutions’.187 Chesterman concludes that in international law, the rule of law is promoted ‘as a tool with which to protect human rights, promote development, and sustain peace’.188 In 2004, UN Secretary-General Kofi Annan provided an expansive definition of the rule of law as a situation in which all actors ‘are accountable to laws that are publicly promulgated, equally enforced and independently adjudicated, and which are consistent with international human rights norms and standards’. It further requires ‘adherence to the principles of supremacy of law, equality before the law, accountability to the law, fairness in the application of the law, separation of powers, participation in decision-making, legal certainty, avoidance of arbitrariness and procedural and legal transparency’.189 The understanding relies on an idea of the rule of law that promotes substantive values of justice, and not one that simply demands the exercise of power in accordance with posited law norms.
185 Simon Chesterman, ‘An International Rule of Law?’ (2008) 56 American Journal of Comparative Law 331, 340. 186 ibid at 342. 187 ibid at 355–56. Sir Arthur Watts refers to the ‘rule of law in international affairs’, which involves the existence of ‘a comprehensive system of law, certainty as to what the rules are, predictability as to the legal consequences of conduct, equality before the law, the absence of arbitrary power, and effective and impartial application of the law’: Sir Arthur Watts, ‘The Importance of International Law’ in Michael Byers (ed), The Role of Law in International Politics (Oxford, Oxford University Press, 2000) 5, 7. 188 ibid at 359. 189 Report of the Secretary-General on the rule of law and transitional justice in conflict and post-conflict societies, 3 August 2004, UN Doc S/2004/616 para 6.
Columns Design Ltd
/
Job: Wheatley
/
Division: 04_Theliberaldemocraticstate
/Pg. Position: 34 /
Date: 26/3
JOBNAME: Wheatley PAGE: 35 SESS: 4 OUTPUT: Tue May 11 14:32:06 2010
Rule of Law 197 Lon Fuller has written on the ‘internal’ and ‘external’ morality of law. The internal morality is concerned with the way in which the law is created, interpreted and administered: law must exist; be obeyed by all; be published; be prospective; be written with reasonable clarity; avoid contradictions; not command the impossible; stay reasonably constant; and official action should be consistent with the declared rule.190 Law is distinguished from other normative systems ‘by the specific type of rationality apparent in the internal processes that make law possible’. Rationality depends on reasoned argument, precedent, and the use of analogy. The internal morality of the law ensure that rules are compatible with one with another, that they ask reasonable things of the people to whom they are directed, that they are transparent and relatively predictable, and that officials treat known rules as shaping their exercise of discretion.191 The external morality of the law is related to ‘the assessment of fairness, equality and justice produced by legal rules and a legal system’. Fuller does not specify any particular ‘external morality’: it is left to ‘high and debatable principle’, once the legal system is ‘largely constructed’, ie the internal morality ‘pre-dates the pursuit of substantive outcomes’.192 These ideas are reflected in Thomas Franck’s discussion of legitimacy and fairness in relation to international law. There are four variables affecting legitimacy: determinacy, symbolic validation, coherence and adherence. Legitimacy (‘procedural fairness’) is concerned with the properties of the rule, the process by which the rule was adopted and the process of interpretation.193 Distributive fairness (‘justice’) is concerned with the allocation of public goods in the international community, including their allocation to persons and peoples. There are no objective standards of fairness, which is ‘a human, subjective, contingent quality which merely captures in one word a process of discourse, reasoning, and negotiation leading if successful, to an agreed formula located at a conceptual intersection between various plausible formulas for allocation’.194 The position of the international community, a social system of continuing interaction and transaction, on the questions of distributive justice results from a ‘discursive enterprise’ in which participants
190
Lon Fuller, The Morality of Law, revised edn (New Haven, Yale University Press, 1969)
ch 2. 191 Jutta Brunnée and Stephen Toope, ‘International Law and Constructivism: Elements of an Interactional Theory of International Law’ (2000) 39 Columbia Journal of Transnational Law 19, 56. 192 ibid at 57. 193 Thomas M Franck, Fairness in International Law and Institutions (Oxford, Clarendon Press, 1995) 26. 194 ibid at 14 (emphasis in original).
Columns Design Ltd
/
Job: Wheatley
/
Division: 04_Theliberaldemocraticstate
/Pg. Position: 35 /
Date: 26/3
JOBNAME: Wheatley PAGE: 36 SESS: 4 OUTPUT: Tue May 11 14:32:06 2010
198 The Constitutionalisation of IL ‘advance claims and [test] them against rival claims’. Deliberations about fairness exclude claims ‘which proceed not from reason but by automatic trumping’.195
INTERNATIONAL HUMAN RIGHTS LAW
Central to arguments around constitutionalism and international law has been the development of a body of international human rights law,196 notably the adoption of the ‘International Bill of Rights’: the Universal Declaration on Human Rights,197 and International Covenant on Economic, Social and Cultural Rights,198 and International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights.199 The idea of a Bill of Rights is taken from the first amendment to the US Constitution, which provides limits on the exercise of government authority, ensuring that majority will is subject to certain procedural requirements and minimum respect for human rights. Mutatis mutandis, the emergence of a body of international human rights law establishes the liberal nature of the international constitutional order and requires that all states respect minimum standards concerning the treatment of the human person. In Application of the Convention on the Prevention and Punishment of the Crime of Genocide, Judge Weeramantry noted that a state’s human rights obligations were not matters that ‘concern that State alone, but represent a contribution to human dignity and global stability’.200 The political idea of human rights has its origins in the seventeenth century. Important early writings include Thomas Hobbes, Leviathan 195 ibid at 478 (emphasis added). According to Chayes and Chayes, legitimacy in the international system is established where decisions emanate from fair and accepted procedures; they are applied equally and without invidious discrimination; and do not offend minimum substantive standards of fairness: Abram Chayes and Antonia Chayes, The New Sovereignty: Compliance with International Regulatory Agreements (Cambridge, Massachusetts, Harvard University Press, 1998) 127. 196 Annika Tahvanainen argues that human rights ‘contribute to the constitutionalization of international law, reflecting a nucleus of norms essential for assuring co-existence of and co-operation among different international actors, as well as the protection of the fundamental values and interests which are common to the international community as a whole’: Annika Tahvanainen, ‘Commentary to Professor Hafner’ (2004) 25 Michigan Journal of International Law 865, 866. 197 GA Res 217(III)A ‘Universal Declaration of Human Rights’ (adopted 10 December 1948). 198 International Covenant on Economic, Social and Cultural Rights, adopted by GA Res 2200A (XXI) (16 December 1966). 199 International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights, adopted by GA Res 2200A (XXI) (16 December 1966). 200 Application of the Convention on the Prevention and Punishment of the Crime of Genocide (Bosnia and Herzegovina v Serbia and Montenegro) (Preliminary objections) [1996] ICJ Rep 595, Judgment 11 July 1996, Separate opinion of Judge Weeramantry, 640, 649.
Columns Design Ltd
/
Job: Wheatley
/
Division: 04_Theliberaldemocraticstate
/Pg. Position: 36 /
Date: 26/3
JOBNAME: Wheatley PAGE: 37 SESS: 4 OUTPUT: Tue May 11 14:32:06 2010
International Human Rights Law 199 (1651),201 which located the source of political authority in the people, and made consent the basis of sovereign authority, precluding any subsequent appeal to any ‘higher’ authority, and John Locke, Second Treatise of Government (1690),202 which built on the principle of consent to argue that a social contract provided limits on the exercise of coercive political authority. These ideas are reflected in the Virginia Bill of Rights,203 and American Declaration of Independence, both 1776, the latter of which recognised not only the problems created by the existence of a supreme ruler, but also those of majority rule and the need to provide for ‘checks and balances’ in the exercise of coercive state power in the interests of individual freedom. Prior to the twentieth century, the idea of human rights was the concern of domestic law systems. With the exception of ad hoc instances of humanitarian intervention,204 and the imposition of obligations, principally concerning minorities, on states by the Great Powers,205 international law was not concerned with the protection of human persons. The notable exception was slavery, specifically the slave trade,206 although it was not until the 1926 Slavery Convention that states parties committed
201
Thomas Hobbes, Leviathan, intro. KR Minogue (London, Dent, 1973). John Locke, ‘Second Treatise of Government’ (An Essay concerning the True Origin, Extent, and End of Civil Government) in Peter Laslett, Two Treatises of Government, critical edn, 2nd edn (Cambridge, Cambridge University Press, 1967). 203 The Virginia Bill of Rights 1776 provided that ‘all men are by nature equally free and independent, and have certain inherent rights’ regarding the enjoyment of life and liberty, with the means of acquiring and possessing property (Virginia Bill of Rights 1776 s 1). It also proclaimed that ‘all power is vested in, and consequently derived from, the people’ (s 2), and that government ought to be instituted for the common benefit. Where a government shall be found ‘inadequate or contrary to these purposes, a majority of the community hath [the] right to reform, alter, or abolish it’ (s 3). 204 See Ellery Stowel, Intervention in International Law (Washington, DC, J Bryne, 1921); Jean-Pierre Fonteyne, ‘The Customary International Law Doctrine of Humanitarian Intervention: Its Current Validity Under the U.N. Charter’ (1974) 4 California Western International Law Journal (1974) 203. 205 Every major peace treaty from Westphalia onwards included provisions that contradict the ‘Westphalian model’, including provisions concerning the protection of minorities and respect for human rights: Stephen Krasner, Sovereignty: Organized Hypocrisy (Princeton, Princeton University Press, 1999) 68–69. In relation to the Treaty of Peace with Poland (‘Polish Minorities Treaty’), adopted Versailles on 28 June 1919, M Paderewski, Prime Minister of the Polish Republic, stated: ‘It has long been the established procedure of the public law of Europe that when a state is created… the joint and formal recognition by the Great Powers should be accompanied by the requirement that such State should, in the form of a binding international covenant, undertake to comply with certain principles of government’: quoted in Leo Gross, ‘The Peace of Westphalia, 1648–1948’ (1948) 42 American Journal of International Law 20, 23. 206 See 1815 Congress Vienna (Declaration on the Slave Trade), Declaration of Eight Courts relative to the Universal Abolition of the Slave Trade (8 February 1815) 63 Consol TS 473; and 1890 Treaty Slave Trade, General Act for the Repression of African Slave Trade (2 July 1890) 27 Stat 886. See generally Steve Charnovotz, ‘Two Centuries of Participation: NGOs and International Governance’ (1997) 18 Michigan Journal of International Law 183. 202
Columns Design Ltd
/
Job: Wheatley
/
Division: 04_Theliberaldemocraticstate
/Pg. Position: 37 /
Date: 26/3
JOBNAME: Wheatley PAGE: 38 SESS: 4 OUTPUT: Tue May 11 14:32:06 2010
200 The Constitutionalisation of IL themselves to prevent and suppress the slave trade,207 and to ‘bring about, progressively and as soon as possible, the complete abolition of slavery in all its forms’.208 The prohibition on slavery is now recognised as an international norm of jus cogens standing; the preamble of the 1956 Supplementary Convention on the Abolition of Slavery refers to ‘freedom [as] the birthright of every human being’.209 In the period before the establishment of the League of Nations, there was a decline in the power of the idea of human rights, with neither the German Empire under the Constitution of 1871, nor the French Third Republic Constitution of 1871 containing clauses on the fundamental rights of the citizen.210 International human rights emerged in the period following what the United Nations Educational, Scientific and Cultural Organisation (UNESCO) Constitution describes as the ‘great and terrible war’ of 1939–45, made possible ‘by the denial of the democratic principles of the dignity, equality and mutual respect of men’.211 International human rights formed one part of the constitutional settlement reflected in the adoption of the Charter of the UN, although elements of the right of peoples to self-determination212 and the protection of minorities had been present in the settlement that followed World War I.213 The recognition of universal (at least globalised) human rights norms represents an important shift in the nature of international law that accords recognition and rights to human persons. State law systems are subject to the international law order (at least in relation to fundamental rights). The change is reflected most dramatically in the Nuremberg Charter and decision of the International Military Tribunal (Nuremberg) (IMT), which
207 Article 2(a) of the Slavery Convention, International Convention to Suppress the Slave Trade and Slavery (25 September 1926), 46 Stat 2183. 208 Article 2(b) ibid. 209 Supplementary Convention on the Abolition of Slavery, the Slave Trade, and Institutions and practices Similar to Slavery (1956) 226 UNTS 3 preamble. 210 Christian Tomuschat, Human Rights: Between Idealism and Realism (Oxford, Oxford University Press, 2003) 9. 211 Constitution of the United Nations Educational, Scientific and Cultural Organization (UNESCO) (adopted London, 16 November 1945) 4 UNTS 275 preamble. 212 In the aftermath of World War I, the political map of Europe was reconfigured in accordance with the principle of national self-determination of peoples. Ethnically homogenous ‘Nation’ states were created, following the collapse of the multi-national Hapsburg, Ottoman, Russian, and German Empires. The application of the national self-determination principle sought, on objective criteria, to identify ‘Nations’ and to recognise their sovereign and independent existence. 213 The Polish Minorities Treaty, the first adopted under the League of Nations’ scheme, served as a model for the other treaties. See Treaty of Peace with Poland (‘Polish Minorities Treaty’) (adopted Versailles, 28 June 1919). Treaty of Peace Between the United States of America, the British Empire, France, Italy, and Japan and Poland, reprinted (1919) 13 (4) Supplement, American Journal of International Law 423. See generally, Theodore S Woolsey, ‘Editorial Comment: the Rights of Minorities under the Treaty with Poland’ (1920) 14 American Journal of International Law 392.
Columns Design Ltd
/
Job: Wheatley
/
Division: 04_Theliberaldemocraticstate
/Pg. Position: 38 /
Date: 26/3
JOBNAME: Wheatley PAGE: 39 SESS: 4 OUTPUT: Tue May 11 14:32:06 2010
International Human Rights Law 201 affirmed a principle of individual criminal responsible for the commission of ‘crimes against humanity[,] whether or not in violation of the domestic law of the country where perpetrated’.214 In its judgment, the Tribunal determined that prisoners were treated ‘not only in defiance of the well-established rules of international law, but in complete disregard of the elementary dictates of humanity’.215 In relation to the persecution, repression, and murder of civilians in Germany before the war, notably the Jewish population, the IMT concluded that ‘revolting and horrible as many of these crimes were, it has not been satisfactorily proved that they were done in execution of, or in connection with, [a crime under the jurisdiction of the tribunal]’. The IMT felt precluded from making a declaration that acts committed prior to 1939 ‘were Crimes against Humanity within the meaning of the [Nuremburg] Charter’.216 The principles of international law recognised in the Charter of the Nuremberg Tribunal and judgment of the IMT were affirmed by the UN General Assembly in Resolution 95(I), adopted 11 December 1946,217 which described genocide as ‘contrary to moral law and to the spirit and aims of the United Nations’, as well as a crime under international law.218 The language is that of natural law: the system of positive international law that existed prior to 1945 was (de jure) subject to overarching moral principles. In 1948, the General Assembly adopted the Convention on the Prevention and Punishment of the Crime of Genocide. The preamble affirms that genocide is a crime under international law and ‘contrary to the spirit and aims of the United Nations and condemned by the civilized world’. The Genocide Convention declares that ‘in order to liberate mankind from such an odious scourge, international co-operation is required’. Genocide is recognised as a crime under international law, whether committed in time of peace or in time of war.219 In Reservations to the Convention on the Prevention and Punishment of the Crime of Genocide, the International Court of Justice concluded that the principles underlying
214 Agreement for the prosecution and punishment of the major war criminals of the European Axis, 8 August 1945, 82 UNTS 279, art 6(c). 215 International Military Tribunal (IMT) (Nuremberg), judgment and sentences (1 October 1946), reprinted (1947) 41 American Journal of International Law 172, 225. 216 ibid at 249. 217 GA Res 95(I) ‘Affirmation of the principles of international law recognized by the Charter of the Nuremberg Tribunal’ (adopted 11 December 1946) preamble. 218 GA Res 96(I) ‘The Crime of Genocide’ (adopted 11 December 1946) preamble. 219 Convention on the Prevention and Punishment of the Crime of Genocide, adopted GA Res 260 A (III) (9 December 1948) art I. The language of international morality is also present in the preamble to the Rome Statute of the International Criminal Court, which observes that, in the twentieth century, ‘millions of children, women and men have been victims of unimaginable atrocities that deeply shock the conscience of humanity’: Rome Statute of the International Criminal Court (adopted 17 July 1998) 37 ILM 999 preamble.
Columns Design Ltd
/
Job: Wheatley
/
Division: 04_Theliberaldemocraticstate
/Pg. Position: 39 /
Date: 26/3
JOBNAME: Wheatley PAGE: 40 SESS: 4 OUTPUT: Tue May 11 14:32:06 2010
202 The Constitutionalisation of IL the Convention were binding ‘even without any conventional obligation’, noting its ‘special characteristics’. The Convention was ‘manifestly adopted for a purely humanitarian and civilizing purpose’. States parties did not have interests of their own: ‘they merely have, one and all, a common interest, namely, the accomplishment of those high purposes which are the raison d’etre of the convention’.220
HUMAN RIGHTS IN THE UNITED NATIONS SYSTEM
Writing in the American Journal of International Law in 1924, Phillip Marshall Brown observed that ‘Men everywhere are beginning to realize the truth that the state exists, not as an end in itself, but as the means to their own individual welfare and happiness.’ He refers to a ‘democratic principle’ that must be ‘logically applied to international affairs as well as domestic’. The idea of the ‘sovereign state from which all rights flow must give way to the conception that international law itself derives its ultimate sanction and respect from the sovereign people’.221 The arguments are echoed in the writings of Hersh Lauterpacht following World War II, in which he sought to repudiate the strict positivism that had dominated international law prior to the establishment of the UN.222 Renée Jeffery concludes that the aim of Lauterpacht’s writings was a revival of natural law as an independent source of international law in the face of the calamities of World War I.223 The project required the refutation of legal positivism, and the application of liberal ideals, derived from the law of nature, to international law.224 Liberal ideas are reflected in the body of international human rights law developed by the UN and other international organisations. The establishment of an international system for the protection of human rights had been one of the war aims identified by US President Franklin D Roosevelt and British Prime Minister Winston Churchill in the Atlantic Charter of 14 August 1941, and in the joint declaration of 1 January 1942 by the 26 ‘United Nations’. Promotion of the rights of the individual
220 Reservations to the Convention on the Prevention and Punishment of the Crime of Genocide [1951] ICJ Rep 15, 23. 221 Phillip Marshall Brown, ‘The Individual and International Law’ (1924) 18 American Journal of International Law 532, 534. 222 Hersch Lauterpacht, ‘The Grotian Tradition in International Law’ (1946) 23 British Yearbook of International Law 1. 223 Renée Jeffery, ‘Hersch Lauterpacht, the Realist Challenge and the “Grotian tradition” in 20th-century international relations’ (2006) 12 European Journal of International Relations 223, 228. 224 ibid at 231.
Columns Design Ltd
/
Job: Wheatley
/
Division: 04_Theliberaldemocraticstate
/Pg. Position: 40 /
Date: 26/3
JOBNAME: Wheatley PAGE: 41 SESS: 4 OUTPUT: Tue May 11 14:32:06 2010
Human Rights in the United Nations System
203
helped define the allied cause against Fascism.225 Elizabeth Borgwardt argues that whilst the Atlantic Charter implied that the individual was a legitimate object of international concern, it was with the Declaration of the United Nations that the term ‘human rights’ acquired its modern meaning.226 Discussions at Dumbarton Oaks in 1944 reflected divergent opinions between those states that wanted human rights to be central to the UN system, and others reluctant to admit any form of international involvement in domestic affairs.227 The different approaches are reflected in the structure of the Charter, which both recognises the importance of respect for human rights,228 and the continuing relevance of the idea of domestic jurisdiction (and principle of non-intervention).229 The purposes of the organisation include promoting and encouraging respect for human rights and fundamental freedoms, without distinction as to race, sex, language, or religion.230 Writing in 1950, Lauterpacht concluded that the provisions created a legal obligation to respect and observe fundamental human rights and freedoms;231 whilst it might not be possible to identify the necessary positive steps required of Member States, the Charter precluded the introduction of laws curtailing the rights of women, or imposing additional measures discriminating against persons belonging to religious, ethnical or racial groups, or the ‘active persecution of persons… on account of their race, language or religion’.232 The UN Charter established the principle that individuals have rights under international law. This was confirmed in United States Diplomatic and Consular Staff in Tehran, where the International Court of Justice concluded that wrongfully to deprive individuals of their liberty and to subject them to constraint in conditions of hardship ‘is in itself manifestly incompatible with the principles of the Charter of the United Nations’.233
225 Mohandas Gandhi wrote to President Roosevelt in July 1942: ‘I venture to think that the Allied Declaration that the Allies are fighting to make the world safe for freedom of the individual and for democracy sounds hollow, so long as India, and for that matter, Africa are exploited by Great Britain, and America has the Negro problem in her own home’, quoted in Elizabeth Borgwardt, ‘“When you State a Moral Principle, You Are Stuck With It”: the 1941 Atlantic Charter as a Human Rights Instrument’ (2006) 46 Virginia Journal of International Law 501, 545. 226 ibid at 544. 227 Paul Lauren, The Evolution of International Human Rights, 2nd edn (Philadelphia, University of Pennsylvania Press, 2003) 163. 228 Charter of the UN arts 1(3) and 55. 229 ibid art 2(7). 230 ibid art 1(3). The Charter further obliges the organisation to promote ‘universal respect for, and observance of, human rights and fundamental freedoms for all without distinction as to race, sex, language, or religion’: ibid art 55(c). 231 H Lauterpacht, International Law and Human Rights (London, Stevens and Sons, 1950) 147. 232 ibid at 153. 233 United States Diplomatic and Consular Staff in Tehran (United States of America v Iran) [1980] ICJ Rep3 [91].
Columns Design Ltd
/
Job: Wheatley
/
Division: 04_Theliberaldemocraticstate
/Pg. Position: 41 /
Date: 26/3
JOBNAME: Wheatley PAGE: 42 SESS: 5 OUTPUT: Tue May 11 14:32:06 2010
204 The Constitutionalisation of IL Lauterpacht observes that the human rights provisions in the Charter were adopted after prolonged discussion ‘as part of the philosophy of the new international system and as a most compelling lesson of the experience of the inadequacies and dangers of the old’.234 Their introduction reflected a change in the character and function of international law,235 transforming the individual from ‘an object of international compassion into a subject of international right’, and to that extent it ‘constitute[d] the individual [as] a subject of the law of nations’.236 The importance of the protection of human rights was confirmed in early UN General Assembly resolutions.237 These included Resolution 39(I), adopted on 12 December 1946, which declared that the Franco Fascist Government did not represent the Spanish people, and demanded the establishment of a government ‘which derives its authority from the consent of the governed, committed to respect freedom of speech, religion and assembly and to the prompt holding of an election in which the Spanish people… may express their will’.238 In Resolution 272(III), adopted on 30 April 1949, the General Assembly noted that Bulgaria and Hungary had been accused of acts ‘contrary to the purposes of the United Nations and to their obligations under the Peace Treaties’.239 The Assembly expressed its ‘deep concern at the grave accusations’ regarding the suppression of human rights and fundamental freedoms,240 and the hope that measures would be introduced to ensure their respect.241 Bulgaria and Hungary were not members of the UN at the time of the adoption of the resolution. Hauke Brunkhorst argues that, after 1945, there was ‘nothing left from the Westphalian (or better the Vienna Congress) Order of International Law’. The new global order embraced both international and national law. It universalised the lessons of the democratic nation state: ‘the exclusion of inequality with respect to individual rights, political participation
234
Lauterpacht (n 231) at 147. ibid at 62–63. 236 ibid at 4. On the construction of the individual as a subject of international law, see Jurisdiction of the Courts of Danzig PCIJ Series B No 15, 17–18. 237 See for example GA Res 44(I) ‘Treatment of Indians in the Union of South Africa’ (adopted 8 December 1946) para 2; GA Res 56(I) ‘Political Rights of Women’ (adopted 11 December 1956); also GA Res 285 (III) ‘Violation by the [USSR] of Fundamental Human Rights, Traditional Diplomatic Practices and other Principles of the Charter’ (adopted 25 April 1949). 238 GA Res 39(I) ‘Relations of Members of the United Nations with Spain’ (adopted 12 December 1946). 239 GA Res 272(III) ‘Observance in Bulgaria and Hungary of Human Rights and Fundamental Freedoms’ (adopted 30 April 1949) preamble. 240 ibid at para 1. 241 ibid at para 2. 235
Columns Design Ltd
/
Job: Wheatley
/
Division: 04_Theliberaldemocraticstate
/Pg. Position: 42 /
Date: 26/3
JOBNAME: Wheatley PAGE: 43 SESS: 4 OUTPUT: Tue May 11 14:32:06 2010
Human Rights in the United Nations System
205
and equal access to social welfare and opportunities’.242 The position is expressed in the 1948 Universal Declaration of Human Rights adopted by the UN General Assembly. Article 1 provides: ‘All human beings are born free and equal in dignity and rights.’243 Equality and non-discrimination are key provisions in the Declaration.244 Following the adoption of the Universal Declaration, it could no longer be argued that human rights depend for their validity on recognition by state law systems (although the Declaration fails to explain why this is the case).245 The Declaration develops a political concept of justice and rights: it provides a limited number of absolute provisions concerning slavery (article 4), torture and cruel, inhuman or degrading treatment or punishment (article 5), and equal protection under the law (article 7); other ‘rights’ may be subject to such limitations as required for ‘securing due recognition and respect for the rights and freedoms of others and of meeting the just requirements of morality, public order and the general welfare in a democratic society’ (article 29(2)). The content of international human rights norms must be worked out through democratic procedures in each domestic society, a point emphasised in article 21, which provides that the ‘will of the people shall be the basis of the authority of government’. This shall be expressed in periodic and genuine elections (article 21 (3)). Allan Rosas refers to article 21 as a ‘revolution within a revolution’, with the international community not only declaring the idea of the equal and inalienable rights of the individual, but also setting down minimum requirements for the structure and functioning of the State: the authority of its government must be based on ‘the will of the people’, and there must be a system of democratic participation with equal political rights for every citizen.246
The Universal Declaration on Human Rights provides for the protection of rights in the context of democracy. It was not at the time of its adoption intended to be legally binding, or regarded as an authoritative interpretation of the human rights obligations in the Charter.247 The absence of binding obligations reflected an absence of the necessary ‘community of outlook and of basic political ideas in the matter of relation between man
242 Hauke Brukhorst, ‘State and Constitution – a Reply to Scheuerman’ (2008) 15(4) Constellations, 493, 496 (emphasis in original). 243 GA Res 217(III)A ‘Universal Declaration of Human Rights’ (adopted 10 December 1948) art 1. 244 ibid arts 1, 2 and 7. 245 Tore Lindholm, ‘Article 1’ in Asbjørn Eide et al (eds), The Universal Declaration of Human Rights: a Commentary (Oslo, Scandinavian University Press, 1992) 31, 50. 246 Allan Rosas, ‘Article 21’ in Eide et al (eds) ibid at 299. 247 Lauterpacht (n 231) at 408–09.
Columns Design Ltd
/
Job: Wheatley
/
Division: 04_Theliberaldemocraticstate
/Pg. Position: 43 /
Date: 26/3
JOBNAME: Wheatley PAGE: 44 SESS: 4 OUTPUT: Tue May 11 14:32:06 2010
206 The Constitutionalisation of IL and State’.248 Nor was the Declaration regarded, in toto, as an expression of customary international law,249 although a number of the provisions have entered into the corpus of customary international law. Whilst it was adopted at a time when liberal democracies predominated in the UN, the Universal Declaration of Human Rights was, and remains, significant in defining legitimate standards of behaviour in the international community. In its own words, the Declaration establishes a ‘common standard of achievement for all peoples and all nations’.250 Following the adoption of the Universal Declaration, the UN General Assembly moved to delegitimise certain policies, notable discrimination against women, and groups identified on the basis of race251 and religion.252 In 1966, the Assembly adopted its ‘International Bill of Rights’, the International Covenant on Economic, Social and Cultural Rights, and International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights. A body of UN human rights law has emerged, reflected in the core human rights instruments: the International Convention on the Elimination of All Forms of Racial Discrimination;253 International Covenant on Economic, Social and Cultural Rights; International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights; Convention on the Elimination of Discrimination against Women;254 Convention against Torture;255 International Convention on the rights of Migrant Workers;256 the Convention on the rights of the Child;257 International Convention against forced Disappearances; and Convention on the rights of persons with Disabilities.258 Reference may
248
ibid at 296–97. Hurst Hannum, ‘The Status of the Universal Declaration of Human Rights in National and International Law’ (1995/6) 25 Georgia Journal of International and Comparative Law 287, 289. 250 Universal Declaration of Human Rights preamble. 251 GA Res 1904 (XVIII) ‘United Nations Declaration on the Elimination of all Forms of Racial Discrimination’ (adopted 20 November 1963); and International Convention on the Elimination of All Forms of Racial Discrimination adopted by GA Res 2106 (XX) (21 December 1965). 252 Declaration on the Elimination of All Forms of Intolerance and of Discrimination Based on Religion or Belief, adopted by GA Res 36/55 (25 November 1981). 253 International Convention on the Elimination of All Forms of Racial Discrimination, adopted by GA Res 2106 (XX) (21 December 1965). 254 Convention on the Elimination of all Forms of Discrimination against Women, adopted by GA Res 34/180 (18 December 1979). 255 Convention against Torture and Other Cruel, Inhuman or Degrading Treatment or Punishment (1984) 1465 UNTS 85. 256 International Convention on the Protection of the Rights of All Migrant Workers and Members of their Families, adopted by GA Res 45/158 (18 December 1990). 257 Convention on the Rights of the Child, adopted by GA Res 44/25 (20 November 1989). 258 Convention on the Rights of Persons with Disabilities and its Optional Protocol, adopted by GA Res 62/170 (18 December 2007). 249
Columns Design Ltd
/
Job: Wheatley
/
Division: 04_Theliberaldemocraticstate
/Pg. Position: 44 /
Date: 26/3
JOBNAME: Wheatley PAGE: 45 SESS: 4 OUTPUT: Tue May 11 14:32:06 2010
The Construction of the Liberal State 207 also be made to the Declaration on the Rights of Minorities;259 and Declaration on the Rights of Indigenous Peoples.260 A number of observations may be made in respect of the body of international human rights law that has emerged at the level of the United Nations. First, it represents a relatively coherent attempt to construct the human person in the context of domestic societies. The individual is regarded as autonomous, albeit existing within a social context, enjoying rights and freedoms to the extent that they are consistent with the rights and freedoms and others, and interests of the wider society. Secondly, the monitoring mechanisms established by human rights instruments have allowed for the development of a relatively sophisticated (and reasonably coherent) ‘jurisprudence’, both in relation to General Comments and Opinions on individual complaints. Thirdly, the literature and practice of international human rights is not generally concerned with the pedigree of international human rights norms, relying on a bricolage of hard and (formally) soft instruments rather than expressions of sovereign consent. The international law order has, through its constitutional practices, developed an international Bill of Rights that subjects the state to ‘higher’ global justice norms (irrespective of the attitude of the people of the state).
THE CONSTRUCTION OF THE LIBERAL STATE
Hans Kelsen contends that the validity of the state law system depends on the principle of effectiveness: ‘A coercive order of human behaviour is valid law, and the community constituted by it, a State in the sense of international law, for that territory and population with regard to which the coercive order is permanently efficacious.’261 Effectiveness is no longer accepted as the sole legitimating factor for sovereignty. International human rights law establishes legitimate standards of domestic government in both ‘hard’ international treaties (International Covenant on Economic, Social and Cultural Rights, International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights, etc) and ‘soft’ instruments that include the Universal Declaration of Human Rights and judicial-like Opinions of human rights bodies (in addition to explanatory memorandums such as General Comments). Whilst the effectiveness of human rights instruments, in terms of direct impact on the life experiences of human persons, has been the 259 GA Res 47/135, ‘Declaration on the Rights of Persons belonging to National or Ethnic, Religious and Linguistic Minorities’ (adopted 18 December 1992). 260 GA Res 61/295, ‘The United Nations Declaration on the Rights of Indigenous Peoples’ (adopted 13 September 2007). 261 Hans Kelsen, General Theory of Law and State, trans by Anders Wedberg (New York, Russell & Russell, 1961) 350.
Columns Design Ltd
/
Job: Wheatley
/
Division: 04_Theliberaldemocraticstate
/Pg. Position: 45 /
Date: 26/3
JOBNAME: Wheatley PAGE: 46 SESS: 4 OUTPUT: Tue May 11 14:32:06 2010
208 The Constitutionalisation of IL subject of recent (sceptical) analysis,262 international human rights norms remain important in constructing legitimate statehood. The constructivist argument is that states and other actors define their identities and interests through inter-subjective communications with prevailing norms of legitimacy, including international human rights norms, which serve both a global expressive function and a domestic constitutive function:263 they both express legitimate standards of behaviour in the international community, and constitute domestic constitutional systems. Whatever the strategic, ideational or other motives of states in accepting human rights obligations, their adoption will (almost) inevitably lead to constitutional and/or political reform at the domestic level, creating new opportunities for contest and claim by domestic political actors. Minorities and other excluded groups orientate their identities and (political) claims in terms of recognised human rights norms, and rely on those norms in domestic political disputes.264 For a period, domestic debates will be around the nature, meaning and implications of international human rights norms for the domestic society, but over time the norm will become ‘institutionalization’ and ‘habitualized’, ie an accepted part of domestic policy discourses, without reference to its international pedigree.265 States are socialised to accept norms concerning the protection of human rights, which in turn helps to construct the identities of states. Compliance with an international treaty creates a presumption that behaviour is legitimate; non-compliance a presumption of illegitimacy. The argument applies at both the international and domestic level: a government acting in compliance with its international law obligations is more likely to be regarded as legitimate by its own citizens.266 In determining whether or not to accept emergent international law norms, states may be influenced by one of three factors, alone or in
262 Oona A Hathaway, ‘Do Human Rights Treaties make a Difference?’ (2002) 111 Yale Law Journal, 1935; also Eric Neumayer, ‘Do International Human Rights Treaties Improve Respect for Human Rights?’ (2005) 49 Journal of Conflict Resolution 925. 263 ibid at 2021. 264 Human rights discourse ‘assists different struggles for basic rights because it helps to codify the aspirations of subjugated peoples’, and constitutes ‘social events by interpreting the grievances and interests of actors who have some bearing on these events and to define them as violations that should not and need not be tolerated’: Neve Gordon and Nitza Berkovitch, ‘Human Rights Discourse in Domestic Settings: How Does it Emerge?’ (2007) 55 Political Studies 243, 243. 265 Thomas Risse and Kathryn Sikkink, ‘The Socialization of International Human Rights Norms into Domestic Practices: Introduction’ in Thomas Risse et al (eds), The Power of Human Rights: International Norms and Domestic Change (Cambridge, Cambridge University Press, 1999) 1, 5. 266 Martha Finnemore and Kathryn Sikkink, ‘International Norm Dynamics and Political Change’ (1998) 52 International Organization 887, 903.
Columns Design Ltd
/
Job: Wheatley
/
Division: 04_Theliberaldemocraticstate
/Pg. Position: 46 /
Date: 26/3
JOBNAME: Wheatley PAGE: 47 SESS: 4 OUTPUT: Tue May 11 14:32:06 2010
The Construction of the Liberal State 209 combination: coercion;267 persuasion, whereby an issue is framed in terms that resonate with already accepted norms;268 and acculturation, which depends ‘less on the properties of the rule than on the properties of the relationship of the actor to the community’.269 Coercion concerns the introduction of rewards and punishments; persuasion works by framing an issue to resonate with already accepted norms. The campaign to ban anti-personnel landmines, for example, framed the issue in terms of the ‘indiscriminate nature and effects’ of landmines, linking the issue with a universally accepted principle of humanitarian law.270 Persuaded actors ‘internalize’ new norms and rules of appropriate behaviour, and redefine their interests and identities accordingly.271 Acculturation is a process by which states ‘adopt the beliefs and behavioral patterns of the surrounding culture’. It operates through pressures to assimilate, ‘some imposed by other actors and some imposed by the self’.272 Goodman and Jinks point to substantial evidence of the influence of acculturation on states in areas such as environmental policy, the laws of war, and human rights, concluding that ‘the extent of isomorphism across states is remarkable, and it is seemingly inexplicable without reference to acculturation processes’.273 In a subsequent article, they argue that all ‘sociallylegitimated actors routinely internalize, via acculturative processes, the cognitive frames and behavioural expectations of socially relevant others’. They conclude that states adopt ‘common beliefs and practices because they reflect taken-for-granted scripts of how “liberal” or “modern” states behave’.274 International human rights norms construct the legitimate state and meaning of sovereignty, with sovereign states socialised through the domestication of international human rights norms to accept a single legitimate form of (liberal) government.
267 Ryan Goodman and Derek Jinks, ‘How to Influence States: Socialization and International Human Rights Law’ (2004) 54 Duke Law Journal 621, 633. See also John Ikenberry and Charles Kupchan, ‘Socialization and Hegemonic Power’ (1990) 44 International Organization 3. 268 ibid at 636. 269 ibid at 643. 270 ibid at 636. 271 ibid at 635. 272 ibid at 626. 273 ibid at 648–49. ‘[C]ounterhegemonic norms’, including the international law norm concerning the right of peoples to self-determination, exhibit the same pattern of diffusion as ‘prohegemonic norms’: ibid at 653. 274 Ryan Goodman and Derek Jinks, ‘Incomplete Internalization and Compliance with Human Rights Law’ (2008) 19 European Journal of International Law 725, 728.
Columns Design Ltd
/
Job: Wheatley
/
Division: 04_Theliberaldemocraticstate
/Pg. Position: 47 /
Date: 26/3
JOBNAME: Wheatley PAGE: 48 SESS: 4 OUTPUT: Tue May 11 14:32:06 2010
210 The Constitutionalisation of IL CONCLUSION
Democracy for the constitutional state takes place within an international law order that protects the exercise of political self-determination consistent with liberal (democratic) norms for the protection of human rights. International law is intrusive in the (Westphalian) idea of sovereignty, but (in principle) supportive of the practice of (liberal) democracy. The international law order has shifted from its contractual model to an international constitutional order that commits states to maintaining minimum standards of human rights; the positive orthodoxy has been replaced by institutions and community values that subject the state to a system of global governance under international (‘constitutional’) law. The constructivist analysis explains the importance of dominant norms in constructing identities in world society and the emergence of a commitment to respecting the rights of citizens as a legitimating factor for the exercise of coercive political authority. The analysis now turns (directly) to the role of democracy in international law in the construction of legitimate political authority.
Columns Design Ltd
/
Job: Wheatley
/
Division: 04_Theliberaldemocraticstate
/Pg. Position: 48 /
Date: 26/3
JOBNAME: Wheatley PAGE: 1 SESS: 2 OUTPUT: Tue May 11 14:32:06 2010
5 Democracy in International Law
T
HE PREVIOUS CHAPTER demonstrated that legitimate statehood in the international community is seen in terms of ensuring the protection of human rights. The responsibility to protect the human rights of those subject to the jurisdiction of the state is well established: the decision to protect human rights does not lie within the ‘sovereign’ discretion of governments. This chapter considers the argument that legitimate statehood should also be understood in terms of a commitment to democratic government. With notable exceptions, the community of states is becoming a community of democratic states. No coherent ideological alternatives present themselves in global discourses. Current alternatives include the theocratic republic in Iran, authoritarian capitalism under the authority of the Communist Party in the People’s Republic of China, and one-man dictatorship in the Democratic People’s Republic of Korea. Authoritarian regimes that exclude the population from any effective role in government, maintaining control only through coercive measures, are, like the coelacanth, remnants of a bygone era. There is not a uniform practice of democracy (which is not defined by reference to market-led democracy),1 but the international community demonstrates a strong normative commitment to democratic government for domestic societies. There is a general acceptance that democracy has considerable instrumental benefits in terms of economic growth, poverty alleviation and the avoidance of famine, and in the promotion of internal stability as political disagreements can be resolved without recourse to violence. Democratic states are also said to be more likely to honour their international obligations. The issue is not whether democracy is an international public good, but the existence (or otherwise) of an international law norm requiring the introduction or maintenance of democratic forms of government. A number of developments suggests that this is the
1 A liberal democratic state is one committed to democratic government and respect for international human rights norms. See ‘An Agenda for Peace’, Report of the SecretaryGeneral (17 June 1992) UN Doc A/47/277 para 81. It does not necessarily require a market economy based on private property rights. cf Anne-Marie Slaughter, ‘International Law in a World of Liberal States’ (1995) 6 European Journal of International Law 503, 509.
Columns Design Ltd
/
Job: Wheatley
/
Division: 05_Democracyininternationallaw
/Pg. Position: 1 /
Date: 26/2
JOBNAME: Wheatley PAGE: 2 SESS: 4 OUTPUT: Tue May 11 14:32:06 2010
212 Democracy in International Law case: the emergence of the right of all peoples to (democratic) selfdetermination; the fact that two-thirds of states are functioning democracies; the democratisation of territories under the administration or supervision of the United Nations (UN) (Kosovo, East Timor, and Eastern Slavonia); and the affirmation of the ‘norm’ of democracy in a number of (‘soft’) international law instruments. According to the constructivist argument, a commitment to a norm of democracy at the global level will have significant effects on domestic politics and domestic political systems, at least in the medium to long term. States will be socialised to accept the need to ensure that domestic laws reflect the will of the people (consistent with human rights norms), leading to the establishment of a single, legitimate form of domestic political community: the liberal democratic state. The following sections outline the arguments for recognising the commitment to democracy in international law, before examining the ways in which democracy, as a principle, influences the interpretation and application of international law norms, most notably in relation to military intervention and democratic regime change.
DEMOCRACY IN INTERNATIONAL LAW
International law has not traditionally been concerned with domestic government arrangements: each state has the right to choose its own form of government, free from external interferences by other states and international organisations. The position is expressed in Military and paramilitary activities in and against Nicaragua (Merits): ‘[E]ach State is permitted, by the principle of State sovereignty, to decide freely [the nature of its] political, economic, social and cultural system.’2 Arguments that citizens have a right to democracy, or that states have an obligation to introduce or maintain democratic forms of government, rely on the following (alone or in combination): that the right of peoples to selfdetermination should be understood as a right of democratic selfdetermination; that the corpus of international human rights law requires the introduction of democracy; that the practice of states (with the requisite opinio juris) suggests the emergence of a customary norm requiring democratic forms of domestic government; and that a requirement of democratic government for membership of key international organisations creates a de facto commitment to democracy in world society. The arguments are considered in turn.
2 Military and paramilitary activities in and against Nicaragua (Nicaragua v United States), (Merits) [1986] ICJ Rep 14 [205].
Columns Design Ltd
/
Job: Wheatley
/
Division: 05_Democracyininternationallaw
/Pg. Position: 2 /
Date: 26/3
JOBNAME: Wheatley PAGE: 3 SESS: 4 OUTPUT: Tue May 11 14:32:06 2010
Democracy in International Law
213
Democratic Self-Determination There is general agreement that the right of peoples to self-determination is a significant ‘constitutional’ norm in the international law order, a norm of jus cogens standing,3 and an obligation erga omnes.4 The right of peoples to self-determination has gone through four distinct phases:5 the recognition of a political right of national self-determination for certain populations in Europe following World War I; a legal right to independence and the establishment of a sovereign state for the populations of colonised territories;6 a remedial right to secession where a territorially concentrated group is systematically excluded from public life and subject to serious human rights abuses;7 and, finally, a right of ‘[a]ll peoples’ to self-determination (reflected in ‘common Article 1’)’By virtue of that right they freely determine their political status and freely pursue their economic, social and cultural development.’8 The formulation reflects the position under general international law. In Legal Consequences of the Construction of a Wall in the Occupied Palestinian Territory, the International Court of Justice recognised that the principle of selfdetermination of peoples, enshrined in the UN Charter, and reaffirmed by in General Assembly Resolution 2625 (XXV) and common Article 1, ‘was recognised in international law as a “right” of peoples to selfdetermination: a right erga omnes’.9
3 Commentary on art 26(5), Articles on Responsibility of States for Internationally Wrongful Acts (with commentaries), in Report of the International Law Commission on the Work of Its Fifty-third Session, UN GAOR, 56th Sess, Supp No 10, 43, UN Doc. A/56/10 (2001), reprinted in James Crawford, The International Law Commission’s Articles on State Responsibility: Introduction, Text and Commentaries (Cambridge, Cambridge University Press, 2002). See also UN Commission on Human Rights, Resolution E/CN.4/RES/2000/4 (7 April 2000) preamble; Armed activities on the territory of the Congo (Democratic Republic of the Congo v Rwanda), judgment 3 February 2006, Separate Opinion of Judge ad hoc Dugard; East Timor (Portugal v Australia) [1995] ICJ Rep 90, Dissenting Opinion of Judge ad hoc Skubiszewski [135]; and Conference on Yugoslavia Arbitration Commission: Opinions on Questions Arising from the Dissolution of Yugoslavia (1992) 31 ILM 1488, Opinion No 1 [1(e)]. 4 Legal Consequences of the Construction of a Wall in the Occupied Palestinian Territory (Advisory Opinion) [2004] ICJ Rep 136 [88]. 5 See Steven Wheatley, Democracy, Minorities and International Law (Cambridge, Cambridge University Press, 2005), ch 2. 6 General Assembly (GA) Resolution (Res) 1514 (XV), ‘Declaration on the granting of independence to colonial countries and peoples’ (adopted 14 December 1960). 7 GA Res 2625 (XXV), ‘Declaration on Principles of International Law Concerning Friendly Relations (adopted 24 October 1970) (hereafter, GA Res 2625 (XXV), ‘Declaration on Friendly Relations’). 8 Article 1(1), common to the International Covenant on Economic, Social and Cultural Rights and International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights, adopted by GA Res 2200A (XXI) on 16 December 1966. 9 Legal Consequences of the Construction of a Wall in the Occupied Palestinian Territory (Advisory Opinion) [2004] ICJ Rep 136 [88].
Columns Design Ltd
/
Job: Wheatley
/
Division: 05_Democracyininternationallaw
/Pg. Position: 3 /
Date: 26/3
JOBNAME: Wheatley PAGE: 4 SESS: 4 OUTPUT: Tue May 11 14:32:06 2010
214 Democracy in International Law Democratic principles were central to the concept of self-determination in the decolonisation era of the UN.10 The right of peoples to selfdetermination was not applied to putative or historic ‘Nations’, but the population of a colonised territory. The peoples of non-self-governing territories were defined by their relationship to a political unit, and not any racial, ethnic, cultural, religious or linguistic characteristics. The limited exceptions concerned the reunification of pre-colonial entities, such as Morocco and Somalia; the voluntary union of two separate colonies; and circumstances where the inhabitants were opposed to maintaining a unitary political entity, for example in India and RuandaUrundi.11 On 14 December 1960, the UN General Assembly adopted General Assembly Resolution 1514 (XV), which proclaimed the necessity of ‘bringing to a speedy and unconditional end colonialism in all its forms and manifestations’.12 The resolution recognised that colonised peoples had the right to self-determination, and to ‘freely determine their political status’.13 Paragraph 5 provides that immediate steps should to be taken in Trust and Non-Self-Governing Territories ‘to transfer all powers to the peoples of those territories… in accordance with their freely expressed will and desire, without any distinction as to race, creed or colour, in order to enable them to enjoy complete independence and freedom’.14 The objective was a determination of the international status of the territory in accordance with the freely expressed will of the peoples
10 Following World War I, a principle of national self-determination was applied to those parts of Europe that had seen the collapse of Empire. Wherever possible the boundaries of the new ‘Nation’ states would reflect the ethno-cultural identity of those who became citizens. An idea of national self-determination sought, on objective criteria, to identify Nations and to grant them sovereign and independent status. The Treaty of Versailles provided for the holding of a number of plebiscites, ‘but these were limited to the determination of the future of certain hotly disputed border regions’: Nathaniel Berman, ‘‘But the Alternative is Despair’: European Nationalism and the Modernist Renewal of International Law’ (1993) 106 Harvard Law Review 1792, 1859–60. The Versailles Treaty (1919) 225 CTS 188, 203, provided for plebiscites in Schleswig (art 109), several border districts between East Prussia and Poland (arts 94 and 96), the Saar (art 49), and Upper Silesia (art 88), and a ‘public expression of opinion’ in Eupen and Malmedy (art 34). 11 Helen Quane, ‘The United Nations and the Evolving Right to Self-Determination’ (1998) 47 International and Comparative Law Quarterly 537, 552. 12 GA Res 1514 (XV), ‘Declaration on the granting of independence to colonial countries and peoples’ (adopted 14 December 1960) preamble. 13 ibid para 2. See Western Sahara, Advisory Opinion [1975] ICJ Rep 12 [57]. 14 Ibid para 5. GA Res 2625 (XXV), ‘Declaration on Friendly Relations’ confirms that by virtue of the principle of equal rights and self-determination of peoples enshrined in the Charter, ‘all peoples have the right freely to determine, without external interference, their political status’. The principle requires the bringing about of ‘a speedy end of colonialism, having due regard to the freely expressed will of the peoples concerned’. GA Res 2625 (XXV) further provides that the ‘subjection of peoples to alien subjugation, domination and exploitation constitutes a violation of the principle [of equal rights and self-determination of peoples], as well as a denial of fundamental human rights, and is contrary to the Charter’.
Columns Design Ltd
/
Job: Wheatley
/
Division: 05_Democracyininternationallaw
/Pg. Position: 4 /
Date: 26/3
JOBNAME: Wheatley PAGE: 5 SESS: 4 OUTPUT: Tue May 11 14:32:06 2010
Democracy in International Law
215
concerned. Three possibilities were recognised: the emergence of the territory as a sovereign and independent state; free association with an independent state; or integration with an independent state.15 Free association was to be the result of a free and voluntary choice ‘expressed through informed and democratic processes’;16 the integration of a nonself-governing territory with an independent state the result of ‘the freely expressed wishes of the territory’s peoples[,] their wishes having been expressed through informed and democratic processes’.17 In relation to independence, whilst there was no requirement for the holding of plebiscites, the principle of equal rights and self-determination recognises the right of the majority to determine the international status of the territory through democratic processes. The territorial approach was confirmed by the application of the principle of uti possidetis: the right to self-determination would be exercised within existing administrative borders, unless the relevant parties, or another decision-maker, such as the UN, determined otherwise.18 The people were identified on objective grounds, and then accorded a ‘democratic’ right of choice.19 In Fiji, Britain proposed the use of communal rolls for the Indian and Fijian populations. This was rejected by the General Assembly, which insisted that independence should be attained only on the basis of the ‘one man, one vote’ principle.20 In 1962, the General Assembly confirmed that Southern Rhodesia was a non-selfgoverning territory,21 and called on the United Kingdom, the colonial power, to put in place a constitution which would ensure the ‘rights of the majority of the people on the basis of “one man, one vote”, in conformity with the principles of the Charter of the United Nations and … resolution 1514 (XV)’.22 In 1978, Security Council Resolution 423 referred to the urgent need to terminate the illegal (minority rule) regime, and establish a government based on majority rule. The termination of
15 Above n 12 principle VI. cf GA Res 2625 (XXV): ‘The establishment of a sovereign and independent State, the free association or integration with an independent State or the emergence into any other political status freely determined by a people constitute modes of implementing the right of self-determination by that people’ (emphasis added). 16 ibid principle VII. 17 ibid principle IX(b). 18 Steven Ratner, ‘Drawing a Better Line: Uti Possidetis and the Borders of New States’ (1996) 90 American Journal of International Law 590, 598. 19 The territorial interpretation of ‘peoples’ was confirmed in the Human Rights Committee Opinion in Gillot et al v France (26 July 2002) Communication No 932/2000, UN Doc CCPR/C/75/D/932/2000. 20 Michla Pomerance, Self-Determination in Law and Practice (The Hague, Martinus Nijhoff, 1982) 21. 21 GA Res 1747 (XVI) ‘The Question of Southern Rhodesia’ (adopted 27 June 1962) para 1. 22 ibid para 2(a). See also, GA Res 1760 (XVII) ‘Question of Southern Rhodesia’ (adopted 31 October 1962).
Columns Design Ltd
/
Job: Wheatley
/
Division: 05_Democracyininternationallaw
/Pg. Position: 5 /
Date: 26/3
JOBNAME: Wheatley PAGE: 6 SESS: 4 OUTPUT: Tue May 11 14:32:06 2010
216 Democracy in International Law the ‘illegal regime’ and ‘peaceful and democratic transition to genuine majority rule and independence’ were a priority.23 Democratic transition required the holding of free and fair elections on the basis of universal adult suffrage.24 The term ‘peoples’ is applied in the Charter of the UN to the populations of non-self-governing territories,25 and the populations of trust territories.26 Additionally, the preamble begins with the words, ‘We the peoples of the United Nations’, and concludes ‘our respective Governments…do hereby establish an international organization to be known as the United Nations’.27 The term peoples in the Charter must also be read as applying to ‘peoples organised as States’.28 The term is not defined in the International Covenants, although article 1(3) confirms that the term ‘peoples’ includes the peoples of trust and non-self-governing territories.29 According to the Human Rights Committee, the scope of the application of article 1, International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights, is not restricted to ‘colonized peoples’;30 nor is the term restricted to peoples under alien subjugation, domination and exploitation. The term also includes the populations of sovereign and independent states. The right of peoples to self-determination is not only concerned with processes of decolonisation. All peoples have a right to selfdetermination, and the term ‘peoples’ includes ‘peoples organised as states’. The right can be interpreted as a reformulation of the sovereign right to non-intervention, opposable against external actors, but is more properly understood (also) as providing a right of the people of the state to political self-determination. A major innovation of the UN era has been
23
Security Council (SC) Res 423 (1978) para 3. ibid para 4. Charter of the UN art 73. 26 ibid art 76(b). 27 ibid preamble. 28 Quan (n 11) at 540. GA Res 1541 (XV) principle VIII provides that the integration of a colonial territory into the Metropolitan State ‘should be on the basis of complete equality between the peoples of the erstwhile Non-Self-Governing Territory and those of the independent country with which it is integrated’ (emphasis added). The clause subsequently refers to the ‘peoples of both territories’. 29 article 1(3), common to the International Covenant on Economic, Social and Cultural Rights, and International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights: ‘The States Parties to the present Covenant, including those having responsibility for the administration of Non-SelfGoverning and Trust Territories, shall promote the realization of the right of selfdetermination, and shall respect that right, in conformity with the provisions of the Charter of the United Nations’ (emphasis added). 30 Human Rights Committee, ‘Concluding Observations on Azerbaijan’ (3 August 1994) UN Doc A/49/40 para 296. See also, Patrick Thornberry, ‘Self-Determination, Minorities, Human Rights: a Review of International Instruments’ (1989) 38 International and Comparative Law Quarterly 867, 878. cf Fourth Periodic Report (Sweden) (10 November 1994) UN Doc CCPR/C/95/Add.4 para 1; also, Second Periodic Report (Algeria) (18 May 1998) UN Doc CCPR/C/101/Add.1 para 79. 24 25
Columns Design Ltd
/
Job: Wheatley
/
Division: 05_Democracyininternationallaw
/Pg. Position: 6 /
Date: 26/3
JOBNAME: Wheatley PAGE: 7 SESS: 5 OUTPUT: Tue May 11 14:32:06 2010
Democracy in International Law
217
the recognition that the de facto ability to exercise power does not afford a de jure right to political authority.31 A violation of the right to selfdetermination occurs when the state is subject to alien domination or foreign occupation.32 The UN General Assembly has declared its firm opposition to acts of foreign military intervention, aggression and occupation, ‘since these have resulted in the suppression of the right of peoples to self-determination’.33 The international community does not accept the legitimacy