Supporting people Towards a person-centred approach
Peter Beresford, Jennie Fleming, Michael Glynn, Catherine Bewley, Suzy Croft, Fran Branfield, Karen Postle
SUPPORTING PEOPLE Towards a person-centred approach Peter Beresford, Jennie Fleming, Michael Glynn, Catherine Bewley, Suzy Croft, Fran Branfield, Karen Postle
First published in Great Britain in 2011 by The Policy Press University of Bristol Fourth Floor Beacon House Queen’s Road Bristol BS8 1QU UK t: +44 (0)117 331 4054 f: +44 (0)117 331 4093
[email protected] www.policypress.co.uk North American office: The Policy Press c/o International Specialized Books Services 920 NE 58th Avenue, Suite 300 Portland, OR 97213-3786, USA t: +1 503 287 3093 · f: +1 503 280 8832 ·
[email protected] © Peter Beresford, Jennie Fleming, Michael Glynn, Catherine Bewley, Suzy Croft, Fran Branfield, Karen Postle 2011 British Library Cataloguing in Publication Data A catalogue record for this book is available from the British Library. Library of Congress Cataloging-in-Publication Data A catalog record for this book has been requested. ISBN 978 1 84742 762 5 paperback The right of Peter Beresford, Jennie Fleming, Michael Glynn, Catherine Bewley, Suzy Croft, Fran Branfield and Karen Postle to be identified as authors of this work has been asserted by them in accordance with the Copyright, Designs and Patents Act 1988. All rights reserved: no part of this publication may be reproduced, stored in a retrieval system, or transmitted in any form or by any means, electronic, mechanical, photocopying, recording, or otherwise without the prior permission of The Policy Press. The statements and opinions contained within this publication are solely those of the authors and not of the Joseph Rowntree Foundation, the University of Bristol or The Policy Press. The Joseph Rowntree Foundation, the University of Bristol and The Policy Press disclaim responsibility for any injury to persons or property resulting from any material published in this publication. The Policy Press works to counter discrimination on grounds of gender, race, disability, age and sexuality. Cover design by The Policy Press. Front cover: ‘There is a voice – speak out! The voice is us.’ © Kevin Chettle and with permission from Advocacy in Action. Printed and bound in Great Britain by Hobbs, Southampton. The Policy Press uses environmentally responsible print partners.
®
MIX Paper from responsible sources
FSC® C020438
Peter Beresford For Julian Linton, my friend who died aged 21 and first helped me to understand what disability meant in our world. Jennie Fleming For my mother, Elisabeth Fleming. Catherine Bewley would like to thank her colleagues – Jean Collins, Kiran Dhattani Pitt and Sapna Sharma – and the people with learning difficulties who worked with Values Into Action on this project. Suzy Croft For George, Ethel, Les, Tom, John and Emily: never forgotten. Fran Branfield To all those service users out there whose voices remain silent. Karen Postle thanks the people in the local coalition of disabled people with whom she worked who first taught her the importance of selfdirected support and the proper involvement of people using services in their design and development.
Contents About the authors Acknowledgements Foreword by Shami Chakrabarti Introduction Part One The Background to Person-Centred Support one Setting the scene for social care two Person-centred support
vii ix xi 1
15 39
Part Two Person-Centred Support: Barriers and Ways of Overcoming Them three The funding of social care 67 four The social care workforce 99 five Social care and carers 131 six Institutionalisation 155 seven Organisational issues 187 eight Social care practice 223 Part Three Broader Issues for Person-Centred Support nine Service user cameos ten Capacity-building for support eleven Access to the mainstream twelve Participation
259 275 291 315
Part Four Making Change to Achieve Person-Centred Support thirteen Change for person-centred support
353
Appendices one The Standards We Expect. How we did it: project methodology and methods two The Standards We Expect: associated publications three The Standards We Expect. How we did it: project materials and resources Index
391 417 419
423
v
About the authors Peter Beresford OBE is Professor of Social Policy and Director of the Centre for Citizen Participation at Brunel University. He is also a long-term user of mental health services and Chair of Shaping Our Lives, the national independent service user controlled organisation and network. He has a longstanding involvement in issues of participation and empowerment as writer, researcher, educator, service user and campaigner. He is a member of the Ministerial Reference Group for Adult Social Care, a trustee of the National Skills Academy for Social Care and a member of the Advisory Board of the National Institute for Health Research Catherine Bewley is Sexual Abuse Caseworker at Galop, a community anti-violence organisation working with lesbians, gay men, bisexual and trans people across London. In addition to advocacy and casework, she undertakes creative outreach, especially with trans community networks. Catherine has been a campaigner, writer, researcher, trainer and coworker around disability rights with people with learning difficulties since 1992, latterly as Director of Values Into Action, an organisation of people with and without learning difficulties working together for equality. She has a long commitment to creative, community-based involvement and is a governor of Effra Early Years Centre in Brixton, south London. Fran Branfield has worked within the disability and service user movements for over 20 years. She has a strong track record of managing and undertaking research, evaluation and development work and has published many papers and project reports. For eight years Fran was Director of Shaping Our Lives, which is a national service user and disabled people’s network. Fran is an experienced diversity, accessibility and equality consultant, drawing on both her own personal experience of impairment and her academic background. At present she is the director of Cairn Community Partnerships Ltd, a consultancy which offers independent facilitation, accessible participation and stakeholder engagement.
vii
Supporting people
Suzy Croft is a practising social worker and Social Work and Bereavement Team Leader at St John’s Hospice, London. She is also a research fellow at Brunel University and has published widely in the field of social work and social policy. She has worked in palliative care social work for 20 years, is an active member of the Association of Palliative Care Social Workers and former trustee of two leading UK palliative care organisations. She has a background of work on participation and empowerment and she is currently a member of the Interim Board of the College of Social Work Jennie Fleming is the Director of the Centre for Social Action and Principal Lecturer (Research) at De Montfort University. Before coming to De Montfort University she had many years professional work experience as a youth and community worker and social worker and is professionally qualified in both disciplines. Jennie is committed to working in a participative and empowering way. At the Centre she has been active in the development of participative research methodologies, working with young people, community members and service users to ensure their input and contribution to research projects that affect them. Michael Glynn’s career has been focused on promoting independent living for disabled and older people. He has held a number of positions in the third sector, particularly in supporting people to use direct payments. He is currently working in Solihull as Personalisation Programme Manager where he has led the local development of personal budgets. Karen Postle has a background in social work, counselling and mediation and is a registered social worker. She has researched social work with adults/older people and published widely, including, as joint editor with Mark Lymbery, Social work: A companion to learning (Sage Publications). Karen taught for five years at the University of East Anglia and has worked as a research adviser for INVOLVE (Public involvement in health, public health and social care research). Following early retirement she works on a sessional basis for the universities of Portsmouth, Southampton and Winchester and is a practice educator and a volunteer neighbour mediator.
viii
Acknowledgements Producing this book and undertaking the project on which it was based has been a massive, truly collective activity. We have many individuals and groups to thank. First we want to thank all the people originally involved in the project, including Jabeer Butt, Jean Collins, Michael Turner and Kiran Dhattani Pitt. We want to say thank you to the Advisory Group, the Independent Living Reference Group, Alex O’Neil, Emma Stone, Julia Unwin, Anne Harrop, Don Brand and Christine Appleton of the Joseph Rowntree Foundation for all their help. Most important, we would like to say a sincere thank you to all the people who took part in the Standards We Expect project in one way or another as service users, carers, practitioners and managers. We would like too to thank our eight partners and network of 12 organisations for engaging and staying with the project. We’d additionally like to thank Mary Nettle, Patricia Chambers and Jean Collins for reviewing a draft of the book. Thanks to many people for their involvement over the life of the project as advisers, trainers and supporters, including Ossie Stuart and Ann MacFarlane.We would also like to thank Ronny Flynn for all her help in addressing equality issues in the book, the team at The Policy Press for all their help, particularly Ali Shaw, Kathryn King and Laura Greaves. Our thanks to Kevin Chettle for his wonderful cover illustration and Alison Skinner for her great help with the references. Finally we’d like to say a particular word of thanks to Charles Patmore, for all his help throughout the whole process of carrying out the project and writing the book, a person more modest than we thought he should be.
ix
Foreword Shami Chakrabarti We all, most likely, will need social care for ourselves or loved ones at some point in our lives. It may be home help for an elderly relative or assistance for a friend or family member with mental health problems. Regardless of the circumstances, we would hope that our loved ones (or indeed ourselves) would be treated with decency and dignity – in essence, as a human being – by care professionals we come in contact with. The way in which we view and treat marginalised people is surely a measure of a civilised society, and the basis of a just society is that the human rights values of dignity, equality and fairness must be extended to everyone.The right to humane treatment is one of our very fundamental, inalienable and unqualified rights. However, it is often those pushed to the margins of society – mental health service users, disabled, homeless and older people and those living with addiction – who are most vulnerable to having their basic rights neglected, and their voices unheard. Most care providers do an outstanding job under difficult circumstances but we have all shuddered at stories of ill treatment of vulnerable people by the very people charged with looking after their well being. One case of ill treatment by a carer of a vulnerable person is one too many. Supporting people: Towards a person-centred approach promotes a care system that is individual focused rather than target driven, and unapologetically widens the debate around the provision of social care, its means and its ends. It challenges the dominant orthodoxy in academic and practical circles, and advocates a rights-based, personalised approach to care and support that would put the needs, choices and rights of the recipient at the heart of their care package. It challenges policymakers and practitioners to take a closer look at how we treat and care for some of the most vulnerable and marginalised members of our society. It strongly argues against the institutionalisation and categorisation of people in need of social care and urges that carers must always consider the right to privacy and family life, the right to liberty, to freedom from discrimination, to freedom of thought, religion and belief. While the social care system has come a long way from the punitive regime of the Victorian era to the post-war welfare state, the authors of this text show how ideas and practices in social care are xi
Supporting people
and must be in a constant state of evolution. There is always ample space for debate, critical scrutiny and, where required, improvement. Advocating a rights-based, person-centred approach to social care, practised by well-trained, sensitive practitioners can only be the next crucial step in this evolution.
xii
Introduction Do we participate in a politics of cynicism or a politics of hope?... I’m talking about Hope in the face of difficulty. Hope in the face of uncertainty. The audacity of hope! (Barack Obama, Speech addressing the Democratic National Convention, 2004) All the indications are, that in the future first in western societies and then globally, more and more people will need support to live. Medical innovation and broader changes are making it possible for more of us to be born, to live beyond infancy, to survive once life-threatening illnesses and conditions and to live much longer lives. But more often now, we may need help. In western societies like ours, the policy dedicated to addressing such issues is social care, a policy which interestingly seems to carry little resonance for most people. Social care addresses most of the troubles that human beings are heir to. This ranges from madness and distress, poverty, homelessness, abuse and neglect, to inherited and acquired physical, sensory and intellectual impairments. The frailty that comes from ageing, chronic disease, loss, death and dying is also its province. Social care may intervene in our lives from the beginning to the end, at some of the most difficult times and when people are faced by the most painful experiences. It may do so on a voluntary or involuntary basis, such are the official powers invested in it. This is a time of major rethinking and change in social care policy within the UK, but such change also has international significance. It also comes at a time of major UK political and economic change. This book looks at what a system of social care based on providing the kind of support people want, may actually look like and how it can be achieved. To do so, it draws particularly on what those people themselves have to say.
The shortcomings of social care It has long been recognised that the social care system often does not provide the sort of care and support that people want. Using social care services frequently results in the service taking over the person’s life, rather than the person feeling supported by the service. People 1
Supporting people
needing support sometimes decide not to have services they see as inappropriate, or may be forced to use them for want of any reasonable alternative. Either way, people using or wanting to use services, frequently feel constrained, patronised, controlled or abandoned. In turn, staff providing services are often frustrated and disappointed because they are failing to provide the support they know people want and valuable resources are wasted because services are failing. It is now estimated that about six million adults in the UK live with some kind of additional support and that an overlapping six million provide them with what has come to be called ‘informal care’ – looking after those close to you. These are very large proportions of the population. Yet social care, the policy most focused on assisting them, is one that only a minority of people recognise and few have a good understanding of. This stands in strong contrast to health, which in countries like the UK has become a key political and electoral issue. When we need social care for ourselves or someone close to us, we come to appreciate its central importance in our lives. Then also many of its shortcomings emerge. Despite its central importance, social care is not a policy to which we have a universal entitlement or one based on the same founding philosophy as the National Health Service (NHS), of being ‘free at the point of delivery’. Although it can be crucial in our lives, social care is not a policy or service we can assume we will receive, if and when we need it. Social care is also often seen by those involved as having low political priority and beset by long-term problems of underfunding. There are also fears among policymakers that while the demand for support is increasing because of the growing numbers and proportion of older and very old people, the supply of support available from both paid carers and people’s families is likely to decline. There is a strong sense from all key stakeholders – policymakers, service users, their families, practitioners and managers – that social care cannot go on as it has been. This came to the fore at the beginning of the second decade of the 21st century with major political proposals for change, a time also of major political change. As well as the broader difficulties which social care faces, its stakeholders highlight its inefficiency, inequity, inadequacy and poor quality, with regular reports of neglect and abuse. Thus there is an enormous contradiction at the heart of social care. How is it that the issues it addresses, which can affect us all and may have a fundamental impact on our lives and our relation with society and others, seem to have commanded such little political priority and public interest, resources or understanding? In recent years in the UK, governments’ treatment of the National Health Service has become 2
Introduction
a benchmark by which they can expect to be judged. Yet social care, which is as large and arguably of at least equal significance, generally remains in the shadows. Perhaps this is because disability, distress, ageing, death, dying and social care’s other concerns, continue to be heavily stigmatised and treated as taboo in societies like the UK. People wish to distance themselves from such situations and associate them with groups they would rather regard as ‘other’. Significantly the only social care issue that has commanded regular media attention in recent years has related to its particular system of funding. This has given rise to a sense that people who have been prudent and accumulated savings have to pay for their ‘care’, while those who haven’t, don’t. Thus what attention social care does receive tends to be divisive rather than progressive in effect. Social care is also an ambiguous policy. Under one heading or another, from the time when churches and monasteries were key sources of care, through state poor law, to modern public policy, there has been some form of social provision to offer support. But such policy and related legislation have always had a controlling role too. They have also had a role in regulating people seen as dependent, who it is felt should not be; for restraining behaviour perceived as threatening or deviant; sometimes separating and incarcerating people seen as ‘problematic’. Moral as well as social and professional judgements have long played a part in influencing responses to different groups of service users. We cannot think about social care and support for people without addressing much broader issues. These extend to political process and ideology, international economics, political and social structures, human roles and relationships, organisations and management, education, communication and the media, changing demographics, cultural patterns and family structures. We also need to consider social care in relation to other public and private policies which impinge on people’s lives and may have a bearing on their need for formal and indeed informal support. Support is about fundamental issues in our lives. Its implications are far-reaching. It is also a measure of how a society responds to people who need ongoing help; what value it places on them and policies relating to them. Social care says much about how we regard each other as human beings and citizens, about our individual and collective rights and responsibilities and also those of the state. Thus what starts with a narrow relatively unknown policy, rapidly unfolds to emerge as an issue of fundamental importance to human beings and society. Also, its significance can only increase. As has been 3
Supporting people
said, it is likely that more and more of us for different reasons will need ongoing support. This is likely to be true globally, as well as nationally.
The need for change There is now a strong sense of the need for change in social care. This can be seen as a consequence both of the practical problems facing social care and the development of new ideas and thinking about it. Pressure for change comes from service users, their families and many of those working within and concerned with social care. At the same time and perhaps as a consequence of all this, there are plans for fundamental change in social care policy, practice and funding. All political parties and successive governments have expressed their commitment to making radical change in social care; to transform support policy and services. The idea is that people should have the support that they need individually matched to enable them to live the fullest life they can and have the best quality of life possible. A range of different terms, ideas and methods has been used to describe and take forward this change. It is this which is the focus of this book. The term used in this book is ‘person-centred support’, although, as will be seen, other terms like ‘personalisation’ have also been used. The book builds on a unique national research and development project supported by the Joseph Rowntree Foundation (JRF) the Standards We Expect project. It addresses three key questions: • What does ‘person-centred support’ really mean? • What are the main barriers to such person-centred support? • How can these barriers be overcome? The three questions we have asked about person-centred support enable us to see what has been wrong with successive social care systems – where and how they have fallen short – and what people on the ground are doing which can work to put this right. People’s answers to these questions also take us a step further. They help provide a knowledge base to explore what a sustainable, inclusive and fair social care system, which is geared to offering person-centred support, might look like and how it might be achieved. These are the issues we have sought to address in this book. Thus, this is a book that is rooted in where social care has been, but which determinedly seeks to add to the evidence base to help take it where people want it to go. What is unusual about this book is that in seeking to address these key questions, it draws primarily, not on what politicians or 4
Introduction
policymakers, professionals or planners have to say – as is usually the case. Rather, it builds on the experience and ideas of the people support most directly affects, most matters to and who are most closely involved in it. These are service users, their families and those who work directly with them, offering them support. We have turned to them, to define ‘person-centred support’ rather than imposing our own meanings. We believe that such personcentred support is a worthwhile and wise goal for social care policy and practice – seeking to fulfil each person’s different wants and needs and shared human and civil rights. The national project on which this book is based, the Standards We Expect, involved a very wide range of social care services and service users. It was carried out between 2005 and 2009. So it covers the period both leading up to and including the beginning of the planned radical reform of social care. It included services and organisations that were having to address planned changes, as well as services which were pioneers of such developments. Thus we can get a picture both of current realities in social care and the emergent issues linked with planned new ways of working. We can learn from vanguard developments, as well as seeing how things are working more generally. The team that has written the book and carried out the national project it draws on is also an unusual one. This was a ‘user-led’ project; that is to say one which a service user controlled organisation played the lead role in managing and shaping. Yet at the same time it was a collaborative project bringing together in a consortium a number of people with a wide range of experience and roles. It included a current social work practitioner, service users, academics and people with expertise and experience in community development and social action approaches, working with older people and with equality and diversity issues. This multiplicity of perspectives was reflected in the nature of the four organisations which collaborated to carry out the project, a national user controlled organisation, two university centres and a voluntary organisation where non-disabled people co-work with people with learning difficulties. A second point needs to be made about this book and the project on which it draws. Both are not only concerned with reporting a time of transition, but also with influencing it. As we have said, the project was a research and development project. As well as trying to find out more about major changes currently taking place in social care, it was intended to try and support their development, working with people and organisations who were attempting to take them forward. This does not mean that either the book or the project had an agenda of its 5
Supporting people
own. Instead the aim was to make sense of what people were trying to do to improve the support people receive and make it more ‘personcentred’ and, to assist them as they wished in taking this task forward. Our concern has been to find out more about person-centred support and to help make it happen. This book looks at both of these. A series of themes emerge repeatedly in social care. These relate to the values, funding, workforce, practice, nature, organisation, availability and accountability of social care. These are some of the key themes that this book addresses and according to which it is organised. Eleven of the first twelve chapters are headed by a standard for person-centred support emerging from our project, the Standards We Expect. The book is organised in four parts. Part One sets the scene providing the policy and broader context for current developments in support and social care and introduces the reader to the project which provides the book’s evidence base. Part Two explores a range of key issues emerging from what service users and workers say. It looks at both barriers emerging in the way of person-centred support and ways of overcoming them that are emerging in practice. Part Three explores a series of issues which offer ways forward for effective policy and practice. Part Four, the final chapter, looks at how such change may actually be achieved. As well as extending the knowledge base of social care and providing additional evidence from key often overlooked perspectives to inform theory and understanding, we hope this book will provide a basis for developing person-centred support at a local level in agencies and services. It reports a massive range of direct experience in working to do this. During the course of the project we undertook, we know that service users, workers and managers gained support and inspiration from sharing each others’ ideas and experience. This was particularly apparent at the two ‘get-together’ events we organised. We hope that bringing together their wisdom and expertise in this way will help many more people working to improve the lives of service users. We have tried here to make clear what this book is. It brings together evidence, often in much greater detail than before, from key stakeholders about what social care will need to offer and look like if it is to meet people’s rights and needs. It also offers guidance and ideas about what may be needed to bring this about and what kind of change will be required. But we also need to make clear what this book is not. It is not part of that modern tradition, which in our view has overshadowed and damaged social care – the tradition of managerialist and technicist approaches to reform and restructuring. Thus readers will not find here sets of ‘toolkits’ and techniques. They will need to look elsewhere for such mechanistic instruction. In our view, while 6
Introduction
there have been many such toolkits, ‘top tips’ and advice on ‘quick wins’ in social care, they have generally not been helpful.
How the book is organised As we have said, the book is organised in four parts. Part One sets the scene and provides a background to the book and the project it draws upon. Chapter One introduces the reader to the role and current realities of social care in the UK and the urgent pressures that now exist for radical reform. It begins the process of examining key concepts for change like ‘personalisation’, ‘self-directed support’ and ‘personal budgets’. It then offers a brief guide to the change and development project, the Standards We Expect project, whose evidence the book is based on, examining its origins, philosophy and methods. A more detailed guide to the project and its methodology, methods and evaluation, is offered in Appendix One for interested readers. Chapter Two looks at the origins and meaning of ‘personcentred support’. It explores its relation with person-centred planning and independent living. It begins with existing definitions and then looks more closely at what the key constituencies of service users and workers have to say about it. We set out a series of key components that they associate with person-centred support and the meanings that they attach to it. Part Two of the book includes a series of six chapters. Each of these highlights a major area where people identify big barriers in the way of person-centred support, ways in which these are being addressed on the ground and what seems to work to overcome them. These are the issues that service users and workers themselves highlight in their critiques and comments about social care, but they also reflect concerns that are more widely highlighted in relation to support and social care. The subject of the first of these chapters, Chapter Three, is funding. Funding is identified as the biggest barrier facing social care and the development of person-centred support. It currently restricts who can get support and the adequacy and appropriateness of the support they receive. Financial limits not only inhibit policy and practice, but also make it difficult to improve provision and to plan for the future. Nonetheless we hear from agencies and practitioners who have developed creative ways of overcoming the financial barriers in the way of person-centred support. We hear how the longstanding system of testing people’s means and needs, works against meeting their rights and needs, particularly penalises some groups and works against independent living and person-centred support. 7
Supporting people
Chapter Four focuses on the social care workforce. Successful moves to more person-centred support demand practitioners who are highly skilled, well trained and well supported. The poor employment terms and conditions of the present social care workforce are strongly at odds with this. Its sustainability for the future is uncertain. Practitioners frequently feel undervalued and unsupported. Staff training is limited and patchy, with wide variations in the availability and quality of staff supervision and support. The low status of social care work in the UK is seen as a major problem. Improvements in all these areas, while not necessarily costly, emerge as having a disproportionately positive impact on morale and effectiveness. Staff levels are often inadequate. Changes in the roles and tasks of the social work and social care workforce raise complex issues both for professionals and person-centred support. Chapter Five discusses the ‘informal care’ provided by people’s families and loved ones in relation to the achievement of person-centred support. Public policy has placed increasing emphasis on people’s family and friends providing informal care. This emerges as another major barrier restricting independent living and person-centred support, as well as disadvantaging service users who do not have family or friends to help. Serious problems are highlighted of families speaking for service users, restricting their say and opportunities to live more independently. The issues raised are difficult and complex. Families often do not receive adequate information or support to facilitate service users’ independence, yet may have the lead responsibility to support them. Capacity building and support for both service users and their families and friends can challenge these barriers and services identify and have developed practical ways of achieving this. We see how reliance on support from families as informal carers can undermine relationships and is unlikely to be a tenable policy in the longer term, as well as being inconsistent with person-centred support. Chapter Six shows how the lives of many residential and longterm service users are still restricted by institutionalisation, creating dependence and disempowerment and imposing major barriers in the way of independent living and person-centred support. We also hear about a range of ways in which services seek to overcome these barriers, particularly through providing training and support for both practitioners and service users. Three broader problems also emerge, reinforcing the institutionalising effect of segregated services. These are: restrictions on control of money, barriers to valued employment and restricted access to suitable housing trapping people in residential services and preventing them from maintaining local links and networks. At the same time, the association of independence with individualism is 8
Introduction
also questioned. Both service users and workers highlight problems of loneliness and isolation and express concerns about people being moved on from specialist support services as a means of cost saving. Service users highlight the importance of getting together, both formally and informally, with each other, as a way of improving their lives. Chapter Seven explores organisational barriers that are limiting the lives of service users and preventing practitioners working in more person-centred ways. Two issues are particularly highlighted by service users and providers: increasing bureaucratisation and a preoccupation with negative risk, rationalised in terms of ‘safeguarding’ and maintaining ‘health and safety’. Practitioners highlight increasing controls placed on them and the perverse effects of a policy focus on measurement and ‘targets’. They identify ways in which measures can be more consistent with person-centred working and the philosophy of independent living. The dominance of a ‘risk averse’ rather than ‘risk aware’ culture impedes practice and limits the lives of service users, particularly in residential services. Service users and providers highlight the resulting tensions and discuss ways in which personcentred support can be encouraged. Chapter Eight focuses on the practice of social care workers. Service users consistently highlight a range of human qualities and skills that they value in social care practitioners. These closely coincide with the values and goals of person-centred support. Service users feel that practitioners often make unhelpful assumptions about them and this reflects a broader, often disempowering ‘one-size-fits-all’ service culture. Practice in domiciliary care services, emerges as particularly inflexible and unhelpful. Service users associate good practice with the development of ongoing and empowering relationships with practitioners. These are seen as crucial for person-centred support. Continuity, good communication, particularly with people who communicate differently, and listening skills are also highlighted as key components for person-centred practice. Part Three of the book focuses on a range of broader issues that participants highlighted as essential to developing an effective system of person-centred support, based on the philosophy of independent living. Chapter Nine, the first of these chapters, offers a set of more detailed cameos of service users involved in the project to provide further insights into the experience of person-centred support, the problems that can arise when it is not available and some of the barriers that can be encountered in developing and practising it. It allows us to get both a fuller and more rounded picture of people’s lives and support and see how this relates to a person-centred approach. 9
Supporting people
Chapter Ten reports on the first of the broader issues that are the focus of this part of the book. It looks at how support, particularly person-centred support, can be made more accessible to people. There has been growing recognition among policymakers of the importance of offering people information, advice, support and advocacy to negotiate the social care system. Many people don’t know what services are available and have difficulty making informed judgements and choices. People in our project talked about the importance of reliable and accessible information for good decision-making and how this is best provided. But it becomes clear that other more ‘hands-on’ approaches are needed to help people gain the skills to negotiate the complexity of the social care system which is constantly changing and to make it more accessible. This will be key if person-centred support is to reach and work for all service users and a range of different approaches are identified which have been developed to do this, including advocacy, service brokerage and personal budget support schemes. Chapter Eleven examines improving people’s access to mainstream services. This has long been identified as a key element of independent living. People don’t expect to live their lives within social care services. These neither can, nor should be expected to meet their rights and needs in isolation. Person-centred support points to a more holistic approach which takes a wider view of how people can live their lives on as equal and inclusive terms as possible in society. Service users highlight three particular issues where they experience major barriers. These are travel and transport, education and continuing disability discrimination. They discuss the problems they face and how these can be overcome. We also look specifically at the two additional barriers creating inequality of access to services. These are geographic variations and the particular barriers facing people from black and minority ethnic communities, focusing on an initiative to address the latter. Chapter Twelve explores participation. While governments have increasingly expressed their commitment to user involvement in social care and beyond and it can be seen as a cornerstone of personcentred support, service users have many negative as well as positive experiences to report. They highlight tokenism and a lack of support for involvement, resistance from services and managers, the use of inappropriate methods and lack of feedback and resulting change. They value regular involvement and stress the need to involve both service users and practitioners and in areas where people are most productively involved, giving examples of both effective and unhelpful schemes, as well as showing the complex issues that may be entailed. They stress
10
Introduction
the gains from collaborative working and offer guidance for successful and inclusive involvement. Each of the chapters in the second and third parts of the book includes more detailed case studies illustrating some of the barriers in the way of person-centred support and ways in which these are being tackled. In addition, as we have said, there is also a series of four in-depth pen portraits of service users highlighting broader themes emerging from the project. Part Four of the book is concerned with change, with both the ‘what’ and the ‘how’ of achieving a system of social care based on person-centred support. Chapter Thirteen begins by looking at how we sought to make change in our project. It reports on the developmental activities that were part of the project on which this book is based, which were intended to support and encourage change. It looks at the philosophy and methods used, working alongside services, practitioners, managers and service users. It sets out how local organisations and people are trying to make such change. It examines different ideas and approaches to making change in social care, including both ‘top-down’ and ‘bottom-up’ approaches, in the context of major changes now taking place and discusses the barriers we identified and how these might be overcome. The chapter also discusses what an inclusive approach to making change which properly addresses diversity might look like. It provides a set of principles for making change in line with personcentred support. Finally, building on the findings from this and other work, it discusses what a fair, sustainable system of social care based on person-centred support might look like and sets out strategies for achieving, evaluating and encouraging this for the future. The book and the project on which it is based, were also concerned with the standards that service users, carers, practitioners and managers thought needed to be in place to achieve person-centred support for service users. We have drawn these standards together in this final chapter, since they embody the characteristics that a system of social care will need to be based on to make possible person-centred support for all. As we said earlier, at the beginning of each chapter, we have also set out the specific standard that relates to the focus and findings of that particular chapter. The book is complemented by a set of appendices, the first of which is included in this book, while the others are available as free downloadable additional resources from the Supporting people book page at www.policypress.co.uk. The latter include a number of documents we developed and used in the Standards We Expect project to carry 11
Supporting people
it out in an ethical, inclusive and participatory way, and these will hopefully help others seeking to undertake similar projects. These are listed in Appendix Two. Appendix One, as has been said, details how we undertook the project, including both its research and developmental aspects. It reports on the way in which we carried out the research and change project which the book draws on and the research methods and methodology we employed. We believe that this book provides a much clearer picture about supporting people than we have previously had – of where we are now and where people want to go. This book is based on empirical evidence, rather than any preset assumptions or theories of the authors or policymakers. It builds on the views, experience, ideas and hopes of the hundreds of people who have been involved with us through the Standards We Expect project on which this book builds. They have been involved in many ways; in discussions, in active development, in training and learning, through participating in meetings, contributing information or making contact. We hope that their wisdom and experience will help readers, as it has helped us, both to understand better and to work towards ways of supporting people, that are truly person-centred and which foster and sustain people’s rights and control.
12
Part One The Background to Person-Centred Support
ONE
Setting the scene for social care When it comes to quality and standards, we should have our views taken into account as service users and carers. Service users’ and carers’ voices need to be heard at all levels of the process of setting standards and improving quality. (Harding and Beresford, 1996, p 3) STANDARD ONE: EVALUATION
Services and support must be audited to ensure that policies and provision offer person-centred support and are underpinned by its values. Policy and practice should be evaluated employing user-defined measures and outcomes and involving service users in the process.
Introduction While our focus is ‘person-centred support’, this is also very much a book about making change. It is concerned with changing the way that people who need support to live their lives, are able to get that support. It addresses the current concern of governments to achieve this. It examines efforts that many people and services are making to work in a different ‘person-centred’ way to achieve this. The book also explores how people can be helped to work better in this way. There has been enormous interest in making change in social care in the UK. Words like ‘transformation’, ‘revolutionary’ and ‘fundamental’ change have been used by government, as well as by other policymakers and commentators to signify this. The reform of social care funding emerged as a high profile issue in advance of the 2010 General Election, with competing proposals advanced by the major political parties. The two parties, Conservative and Liberal Democrat, that made up the subsequent coalition government, previously had very different, strongly conflicting approaches to social care. Earlier, the former Labour government had invested more than half a billion 15
Supporting people
pounds, an unprecedented amount, in social care change and set up planning bodies to take it forward, as well as organising large-scale consultations, at national and local levels. The Coalition government then followed a similar path, committing itself to fundamental reform of both social care legislation and funding. Yet change has been a consistent, almost dominant feature of social care for many years – almost since its inception as part of the post Second World War welfare state. It has been the subject of constant, indeed accelerating restructurings and reorganisations. Thus there has been change from the initial welfare and children’s departments of the 1950s, to the social services departments established in the 1970s and then dissolved 30 years later. Social care has been led by different professions, from the welfare and children’s officers first established, through social workers, to the care managers of the 1990s onwards. It has shifted between ‘generic’ and ‘specialist’ professional roles; through the ‘patch’ and ‘community social worker’ and being based in ‘area’ and ‘neighbourhood’ offices. It has been underpinned by radically different ideologies, embracing differing commitments to voluntarist, market and state-led approaches to support. Despite this apparent preoccupation with change, one thing seems to have remained relatively constant. Service users’ experience of social care does not seem to have changed fundamentally. The repeated message from service users over the years has been that social care policy and provision have tended to be unreliable, inadequate and often of poor quality (Harding and Beresford, 1996; Beresford et al, 2005).
The nature of social care Social care has helpfully been defined as: The provision of services to adults who require assistance with aspects of daily living as a result of disability, illness or ageing. Social care is an all-embracing term for the personal social services. (Barton, 2000, p 318) Social care can not only make a claim to have importance for all our lives, it is also a massive industry in its own right. In 2007-08 around 1.75 million people of working age and older people used different care services provided by their local council or purchased on their behalf from private and voluntary organisations (CSCI, 2009, p vi). Including children, over two million people of all ages and from every community, used social care services arranged by local councils 16
Setting the scene for social care
during 2006-07 (CSCI, 2008, p 9). As well as working with adults and children, social care works with those going through the transition from child to adult status. In 2006 there was a radical reorganisation in service delivery in England (although not in Wales or Scotland), which separated adults’ and children’s services into different local departments, subject to different central government departments (Petch, 2008, p 237). This created additional administrative complexities since there are clearly overlaps between adults and children, not least in the case of parents with disabled children and disabled parents. Recent figures show that local authorities spend £14.2 billion on social care for adults. Nearly two thirds of this is spent on older people (61.0%) and nearly a quarter on people with learning difficulties (21.0%). Of the total of more than 1.75 million adults who receive one or more social care service from their councils, just over a million are supported at home with community services. There are also many ‘self-funders’ receiving social care, the proportions varying significantly between different localities. Almost half a million people live in some form of residential institution. In 2007, there were 18,577 registered care homes for adults of all ages, with 441,958 places. It is estimated that the current social care workforce includes 1.5 million workers. The people working in social care form 4% of the national working population and something like 15% of the public sector workforce (Platt, 2003). The majority of the workforce (69.0%) is employed in the independent sector (CSCI, 2008, p 10). ‘Social care’ is a recent arrival as a description for a discrete area of public policy. This may help explain its low level of recognition from public and politicians. Following the creation of the welfare state, the talk was more of personal social services and social work. This terminology has now been significantly replaced by one based on ‘care’, for example, community care, primary care, care in the community, long-term care and now social care. A set of new key organisations were also developed, framed in these terms, including the Social Care Institute for Excellence, the General Social Care Council, Skills for Care and most recently, the Care Quality Commission and National Skills Academy for Social Care. A sub-set of roles and tasks have been developed framed in terms of care, including care management, care planning, care package, extra care housing and care worker.
Making broader connections While social care is now identified as a distinct policy area, it would be a mistake to see it solely as something separate. Not only does 17
Supporting people
it relate to a broader range of policies, but other policies also have a role in providing social support. This includes housing, education and training, income maintenance, employment and of course, health. Workers with social care responsibilities, including social workers, occupational therapists and others are also employed in other policy fields and not only in social care. The need for social care support also does not operate in isolation. It depends on how other policies and services work. For example, if pavements and the built environment are unsafe, then people may be restricted to their homes. If public transport is inaccessible, they may need ‘special’ transport in order to go out. If employment is restricted and inflexible, they may be forced to live on benefits – and so on. Social care has to be seen as part of the whole. There has been an increasing awareness lately on the part of government that social care cannot be treated in isolation and the broader policy context must also be addressed, if people’s rights and needs are to be met in the round. How far this has been achieved is open to discussion. But there is now formal recognition of the issue among policymakers. This is embodied in ideas like ‘place-shaping’ and ‘total place’, where the idea is that local and other authorities should ‘make creative use of [their] powers and influence to promote the general well-being of a community and its citizens’ to improve and integrate local policies and services, developing a ‘whole area’ approach to public services (Lyons, 2007, p 51; Hampshire County Council, 2008, p 75; HM Treasury, 2010).
The problem with social care There can be no question that a major cause of continuing pressure for change in social care, extending to government, is its failure to provide a reliably good service for service users. Social care policy and practice have a crucial role to play in enabling service users to live on as equal terms as others. However, the social care system is still often failing to provide the support that people want, services shaping people’s lives rather than vice versa. Staff providing services are often frustrated and disappointed because they are unable to offer good quality support and valuable resources are wasted because services are failing (NCIL and Shaping Our Lives, 2005). Innovations like direct payments and the Independent Living Fund, have been slow to mainstream the level of choice and independence set out in formal policy. In particular, older people, mental health service users, people with learning difficulties and people 18
Setting the scene for social care
from black and minority ethnic communities, have all been shown to experience additional difficulties in accessing direct payments (see for example, Clark et al, 2004). The prevailing culture of social care appears still to be a serious barrier to developments in independence and control for service users. This is not to say that current staff and other professionals do not, or would not support, such a development, but that they frequently appear to have neither the power nor the knowledge or support to bring it about (Clark et al, 2004). Further evidence of this common inability to adapt practice within social care systems to meet the concerns and demands of the people who use them is provided by the outcomes of most participation schemes. While these have increasingly been required, the extent to which they actually contribute to, or change the system or its plans, is highly questionable (Carter and Beresford, 2000; Carr, 2004). Service planners and practitioners may want to respond to people’s comments and concerns, but frequently find themselves trapped within their own institutional structures, without the experience, power or expertise to change them.
The sustainability of social care Questions are also increasingly being raised about the sustainability of social care. This is first because of the longstanding financial problems social care has faced, but increasingly also because of the uncertain availability of people to provide support. Two main sources of support have been highlighted in recent years; the paid workforce and unpaid ‘carers’ recruited from people’s partners, families, friends and neighbours. In both cases, the expectation is that it is likely to be difficult to maintain them even on their existing scale (see Chapters Four and Five). Yet the demand for social care support looks set to rise enormously.
Increasing demand for social care The social care sector serves the needs of a growing part of the population. The number of people over 85 is projected to grow by 60% in the next 20 years. Alzheimer’s is increasingly being presented as a problem that threatens and should worry us all. The number of people with dementia, 560,000 in 2007, is expected to double in the next 30 years. The number of people aged 50 and over with learning disabilities is projected to rise by 53% between 2001 and 2021. More children with highly complex needs are expected to survive into 19
Supporting people
adulthood. Currently 15.4 million people have a long-term condition. By 2025 there will be 42% more people aged 65 or over. This will mean that the number of people with at least one long-term care condition will rise by three million to 18.4 million (DH, 2008). To meet the demographic pressures the social care workforce needs to grow. Projections by Skills for Care suggest that the size of the workforce required will be between two million and 2.5 million by 2025 (Jacobs, 2008). Additional concerns are raised about the consequences of socalled ‘life-style’ problems, such as obesity (and the rising rate of type two diabetes associated with it), alcohol and drug dependence. Mature onset impairments are seen as having increasing significance internationally in societies, as people live longer. The World Health Organization, for example, has predicted that by 2020 there will be over 690 million people globally over the age of 60 compared with the present 380 million, associated with increased levels of kidney failure, cancer, diabetes, mental health problems and other chronic degenerative diseases (cited in Berube, 2002, p 4). Concerns about social care and increasing demands for support have largely been associated with a focus on the growing numbers and proportion of older and very old people estimated to make up western populations. This seems partly to have emerged because increasing numbers of older people have tended to be framed as a problem, with a particular emphasis on greatly increasing numbers of people with dementia. This predicted demographic trend has been associated with an increasing demand for support both because of growth in numbers, but also the increased length of period envisaged when such older people will need support. But, it should be remembered that these are at best estimates and we do not yet know whether more older people will truly mean longer periods needing support. Some commentators take a different view and suggest that the period when older people will need support will not necessarily get any longer. We can also expect there will be differences according to class and levels of material disadvantage. What we do know though, is that there is a growing need for support beyond older people. Social care’s raised significance is not only due to the so-called ‘demographic time-bomb’ of greatly increasing numbers of very old people and the rising incidence of Alzheimer’s, on which most emphasis has been placed. A number of other factors are massively increasing the numbers and proportions of people with support needs arriving at the doors of social care. These are particularly associated with improvements in medical and health care. Such an increasing demand for social care is likely to be true for both the western and majority/ 20
Setting the scene for social care
developing worlds, regardless of whether social conditions improve or deteriorate. The former will make it more possible to address needs, the latter is likely to create more to be met. We are seeing the conversion of many health needs into support needs for social care. Conditions that might once have been acute or terminal are now increasingly requiring longer-term support. This includes the increased survival of early term babies with impairments and the greater life expectancies of disabled people with both inherited and acquired impairments. It is reflected in the increased length of survival for people with cancer and other previously ‘terminal’ or life threatening illnesses and conditions, increased survival rates from road traffic and other accidents after major trauma, including head injury and growing numbers of people from the armed forces left with major trauma and impairments from military action. There is also growing recognition of the need for social care support upstream of health intervention to prevent people’s deterioration, as well as downstream to stop a medical crisis like a stroke resulting in chronic impairment.
The ambiguity of social care reform One point that does need to be made at this juncture is that while there is consensus that social care cannot continue as it has been and there must be change, what this change will really amount to remains unclear. This is because two parallel issues confront such reform, as they have long confronted social care more generally. These are the issues of quality and cost. This is a longstanding tension in social care. Policymakers not only have to address and resolve problems of quality but also problems with cost. Social care policymakers have long been preoccupied with finding a ‘magic bullet’ that would square this circle, so far without success. At the same time as the New Labour government set in train the radical reform of social care, it also reviewed its funding. At the time, there was also considerable talk of the government seeking to ‘manage people’s expectations’ of social care, which were still high, getting them used to expecting less and making a greater contribution to their own support. The New Labour government highlighted a significant shortfall in future funding based on current estimates. Service users and practitioners particularly expressed considerable concern about whether the primary aim of reform is to improve provision or save money. This ambiguity has long been a feature of social care reform and needs to be acknowledged in any consideration of it. The situation has become even more uncertain since the change of government in 2010 and the imposition of massive 21
Supporting people
cuts in public services and spending (Beresford 2009a, 2009b, 2011; Boxall et al, 2009; Glasby and Littlechild, 2009).
Personalisation The major changes in social care that were planned for the UK, as this book was being written, were framed in terms of the idea of ‘personalisation’ and were part of a broader personalisation agenda that was meant to transform public services, customising them to each individual citizen. Significantly, consistently this move has not only been supported by government, but also by the main opposition parties (HM Government, 2007; Putting People First, 2011). In social care this development was initially presented as synonymous with a move to ‘self-directed support’, which was to be achieved mainly through what were initially presented as ‘individual budgets’. Since then a distinction has also been drawn between individual and ‘personal’ budgets. Individual budgets laid a stress on drawing together different funding sources, including benefits, work and training support and other funding. While the government’s own research identified difficulties in combining different funding streams, this has been at the heart of a further national initiative, the ‘right to control trailblazers’. The term ‘personal budgets’ has been used to describe the money that might be made available directly (or notionally) to the service user first from social care and then also from health. These ‘individual’ or ‘personal’ budgets represent a development of the direct payments pioneered by disabled people as part of the independent living movement. Here the aim is for service users to determine and control the support that they need to live independently, that is to say on as equal terms as possible as non-disabled people. Qualifying service users receive a sum of money to spend, on the basis of ‘self-assessment’, as they wish on their support. More recently, personalisation in social care has been discussed in broader and vaguer terms, to denote a move to more person-centred approaches to support across all services and support arrangements, including residential, day and traditional domiciliary services. The rhetoric is that personalisation will offer service users greater ‘choice and control’. Personalisation is offered as a fundamental departure from a traditional ‘menu’ of care based responses, to a much wider range of possible means of providing support to offer people greater choice and control. These may be: • Mainstream provision, rather than dedicated social care services 22
Setting the scene for social care
• Conventional medicalised provision (for example, for mental health service users) or ‘talking’ and complementary therapies • User controlled support services The emphasis is on people being able to work out imaginative and effective ways of meeting their needs, regardless of what these are. In addition to personal assistance to help with daily living tasks, this can include money to pursue recreation and hobbies and gain skills, to undertake education courses, to have breaks and holidays, to visit friends and strengthen circles of support, to have company or help from a trusted person out of hours, to access a user controlled crisis centre, to pay for a pet, counselling or peer therapy. Some examples have already developed too, of people clubbing together their individual and personal budgets to meet their needs collectively. Both self-directed support and personalisation can be seen as goals to be achieved, rather than methods to achieve them. Yet, so far, in discussions about the reforms intended for social care, the focus has tended to be much more on the detail and processes of the techniques identified to advance these objectives, than the objectives themselves. There has been a tendency to confuse the two – means and ends, process and outcome. Often the two have been treated as if they were synonymous, with individual budgets particularly equated with the achievement of self-directed support. Both the research and the literature have so far been preoccupied with the mechanics of individual budgets, with talk of them as ‘operating systems’ and detailed description of their ‘resource allocation system’ (RAS), as if the issues involved were essentially technical (Poll et al, 2006; Waters and Duffy, 2007; Glendinning et al, 2008; Hatton et al, 2008). In the UK, the policy of moving to personalisation and personal budgets proceeded with great haste and a very limited evidence base. Indeed the government’s own evaluation of individual budgets had barely been established, let alone reported, by the time that it had decided on mainstreaming personalisation and massively rolling out individual/personal budgets (Glendinning et al, 2008). The findings from its own research were both limited and equivocal, although the government itself contested some of them. Service users and others, however, have also raised much broader questions about individual and personal budgets (Beresford, 2008a, 2008b, 2009a), for example, in terms of what conditions they require to work, particularly for a wide range of service users and how these are to be achieved. However, as became even clearer after the 2010 general election, personalisation has gained cross-party support. While the detail of their 23
Supporting people
approach may differ, no government seems to see an alternative to the rhetoric of personalisation. Yet, so far personalisation, whose definition remains vague and unclear has been discussed in rather high-level and generalised terms, for example: Transformation involves moving to a more person-centred or ‘personalised’ adult social care system which emphasises the individual’s dignity, right to self-determination, choice, control and power over the support services they receive. The vision gives greater recognition to the importance of prevention and requires a whole system change. (Hampshire County Council, 2008, p 7) Successive governments have tended to go little further than associate personalisation with increased ‘choice and control’ for service users (DH, 2010).
The Standards We Expect project Beyond detailing the practicalities of individual and personal budgets, which are now seen as only part of personalisation, with their own limitations identified, little has so far been established about how the enormous aims associated with personalisation may be worked out in more detail and how they are to be achieved. We still have to answer these large and fundamental questions. That is the aim of this book and of the project on which it is based, the Standards We Expect project. It is this project we now turn to in the second half of this chapter.
The book’s evidence base This book is evidence-based. It draws on a four-year national project supported by the Joseph Rowntree Foundation (JRF). The Foundation is the largest independent charitable funder of social policy research. The Standards We Expect project, named after an earlier project which explored what service users and carers wanted from social care workers (Harding and Beresford, 1996), was the centrepiece of a new Foundation programme, seeking to support independent living by increasing people’s choice and control over their lives and support. This book also draws on other publications and outputs from that overall programme. Ours was conceived of as a ‘change and development’ project, which would:
24
Setting the scene for social care
• work closely with a number of local services and their users to learn ways of overcoming barriers to person-centred support; • share learning about empowering approaches to support with a wider network; • explore opportunities to bring about change to the existing social care system or point to more radical reform for a better system of support (JRF, 2004). The Standards We Expect project was not envisaged as a research project, despite having research elements, but rather as about ‘making change’ and uncovering wider lessons about what people want and how this could be achieved.
The project team Our consortium’s bid to undertake the project was successful. The consortium included a national service user organisation and network, Shaping Our Lives, two university centres, at Brunel and De Montfort Universities and a voluntary organisation, Values Into Action, where disabled and non-disabled people work together collaboratively. A total of nine individuals were involved. They included people with experience as service users, academics, voluntary project workers, as a current practitioner and with expertise in equality and diversity issues. All had relevant experience in policy and practice change at grassroots and national levels; in involving diverse stakeholders, undertaking evaluation. People knew each other, had worked together in different combinations before and built up respect and trust. While the consortium was an equal collaboration, we saw the project as a service user-led one, in which Shaping Our Lives was budget holder and ‘first among equals’.
The project philosophy Our approach to undertaking this project was a rights-based and participatory one. We said in our bid to undertake the project: Social care policy and practice have a key role to play in enabling service users to live on as equal terms as others. UK social care has a history of frequent restructuring which has not resulted in appropriate support being available for all service users systematically, reliably and equitably, addressing their rights, needs and difference. As implemented, 25
Supporting people
emerging person-centred approaches to support continue to be marginalised and undermined. (Branfield et al, 2004) Because we believed that their perspectives have historically been marginalised in social care, we placed an emphasis on gaining the views of service users, face-to-face practitioners (people who spent a major part of their time working face to face with service users) and their managers (Fleming and Ward, 2004; Fleming and Hudson, 2009). We thought that their understandings of person-centred support, the barriers it faces and ways in which these can be addressed would be particularly valuable, while often having been overlooked. Thus our aim was to seek these views and enable them to be shared and developed and for these stakeholders to be centrally involved in the process of change which the project was concerned with supporting. We took the view that for change to be truly owned and effective, these constituencies had to be fully involved in it. We envisaged: … enabling stakeholders to engage in the process of change through identifying existing forums and developing a range of new ones, particularly to ensure the involvement of practitioners and service users, making it possible for them to develop, share and negotiate their perspectives and contribute on as equal terms as possible to the change process. This will involve the provision of support, information and training by the project team. (Branfield et al, 2004, p 5) We were anxious to ensure the equal involvement of all service users, including those who tend to be especially marginalised. We knew that this meant working in accessible ways which would support the involvement of a wide range of service users. We took inclusion to include addressing issues of difference in terms both of gender, ethnicity, belief, sexuality, age, disability and so on and also in terms of ensuring the inclusion of groups often identified as ‘hard to reach’ or as ‘seldom heard voices’. Starting with service users’ and practitioners’ own definitions and conceptions our aims and objectives were to: • identify the barriers that operate against person-centred approaches, preventing people who use services from taking control of their own lives;
26
Setting the scene for social care
• identify the techniques and methods which enable and promote person-centred approaches and empower service users and workers; • share knowledge and expertise to facilitate the development of services that people want; • identify structural issues and problems and suggest possible solutions. In this way, we aimed to provide a basis ‘for implementing measures to support the valuing and rewarding of policy and practice for personcentred policy and practice and user involvement’ (Branfield et al, 2004, p 6). As part of our commitment to the change-making elements of the project, we wanted to explore both bottom-up and top-down approaches to change, while being conscious of the importance of service user and practitioner ownership of change. We were committed to producing a range of outputs which would support the practical and theoretical, practice and policy development, of person-centred support and which would assist service users, practitioners and managers, as well as other key actors concerned, to take forward this new approach to social care services and support.
Services taking part in the project The 20 services that took part in the project were selected by the Joseph Rowntree Foundation, again after an open call for possible collaborators. There were eight partner projects with whom we worked closely. We have changed their names to preserve anonymity. Here are brief pen portraits of them. The partners Pippin Close young persons’ unit, is a 10-bedroom residential home for 16- to 24-year-olds, run by a large charitable organisation, providing 24-hour nursing and support for young people with physical impairments. Located on the outskirts of a market town, the aim is to provide a safe and stimulating environment for young people in their transition to adulthood. The unit is purpose-built throughout and opened 18 months before our project to support and encourage people to live more independently. It is on the same site as a residential unit for disabled adults aged 25 and above, run by the same charity and six accessible flats for disabled people, who want to live more independently.
27
Supporting people
Grandshire is a large rural county. County council day services support adults with physical and/or sensory impairments. The project focuses on two closely linked elements of this service. These are the Barry Centre, originally a day centre for disabled people of working age in the county’s largest city, Largetown, which is working to become an inclusive resource for local people. The team includes disability development workers (DDWs), based across the county, working locally to increase the life chances of disabled people. Day service officers (DSOs) are based at the day centre and work with service users managing it, to promote centre use by disabled and non-disabled people. Downhampton is a large town with a long industrial history. The local council is working with the local National Health Service primary care trust (PCT), to improve services for adults with learning difficulties from minority ethnic communities. There has been a very low take-up of services in this group. The work is led by a sub-group of the local learning disability partnership board. The three main elements of their strategy are: • support for family carers, through a carers’ group, especially for non-English speakers; • a self-advocacy and support group for people with learning difficulties from minority ethnic communities; • a local authority access team encouraging more ‘person-centred’ support so minority ethnic service users and carers are better able to access mainstream services. Camchester National Health Service primary care trust serves a large northern city in England. Our project focused on its work on decisionmaking in end of life care for people living in nursing and residential homes, looking at where they wanted to die and how they could be supported in their decisions. The local project was led by a steering group made up of representatives from the local hospital, primary care trust, adult care department, independent nursing and residential homes and carers. We carried out a research project involving five residential and nursing homes in the city. New Chance is a medium sized and well established national charity that offers day services and support to people living in their own accommodation or housing it provides. Groups it supports include mental health service users, people with learning difficulties,‘vulnerable’ families, young lone parents, people with substance misuse problems and homeless people. In recent years it has introduced person-centred
28
Setting the scene for social care
planning (PCP) across its services, rolling out training for its staff. Our project focused on its work in a single region of the UK. My Roof Housing is a national charity providing care homes, housing and support services to 8,500 older people throughout Britain. Our project focused on their care centre at Parr Grove in a large city. This consists of an extra care housing development of 70 apartments with communal facilities, part of which is reserved for older people with dementia, as well as a dementia day care centre. The centre is purpose built and opened two years before our project. Support is provided through 24-hour staffing, offering general and dementia care. Middleshire is a large rural county in the UK. A big city is the focus of many activities but the size of the county, which includes many remote areas, makes travel difficult. An informal network of organisations and individuals has come together to promote personcentred planning. The network focuses on people with learning difficulties, but also works with a wide range of other service users including people with physical impairments and mental health service users. It is also exploring using person-centred approaches with other groups, like school-leavers. The network meets regularly and has hosted awareness-raising and training events. Members include people with learning difficulties and experience of person-centred planning, a housing association, an employment support service, the local careers service and the local authority learning difficulties service. The Glen Trust is a charity in the town of Wendlebury which provides housing, care and support for ‘vulnerable adults’ and older people. Our project focused on the re-provision of services for people in its four residential homes for adults with learning difficulties and physical impairments. These homes were established to offer innovative support. They have been open for more than 20 years and do not reflect current ideas of good practice. The trust plans to replace them with smaller, more independent housing and is seeking local authority co-operation to do so. It has been using person-centred planning in the homes for several years and has engaged external consultants to work with service users about future housing and support.
The range of services overall A further 12 services were involved in our project, making up a broader network for learning and sharing. The 20 participating sites covered a wide variety of partnerships and services. This ranged from residential and day provision, to community-based services, for example, support with employment, housing and information technology. They included 29
Supporting people
respite care, outreach and development work, advocacy, advice and social work support. They included black and minority ethnic as well as mainstream organisations and groups. They varied in scale from a small residential unit, to a network of service providers working with hundreds of service users; from large-scale psychiatric provision, to supported housing. A very wide range of service users were involved, including young and older people, people from many different backgrounds, members of black and minority ethnic communities, people with varied physical and sensory impairments, with learning difficulties, with life limiting illnesses, people who were homeless, with drug and alcohol problems and who used mental health services. They included involuntary as well as voluntary users of services. Services came from the statutory, independent and voluntary sectors and some included agencies from more than one sector. They included health and local authority organisations, but not directly any user controlled ones, as unfortunately none had applied to be part of the project. Their histories and approaches towards personcentred support varied. Some of the partners saw themselves as at the forefront of innovation and the implementation of person-centred support. Others were seeking to overcome particular problems or to modernise their approach. They ranged geographically from the north of Scotland to the south west of England and included urban, metropolitan and rural areas.
Carrying out the project To achieve our aims for the project we began by working closely with the eight partners (see Appendix One for more details). A member of the consortium team together with the project worker took responsibility to link and work with each partner. The main activities we undertook included: • Organising a series of meetings over the life of the project with all partner sites, with service users, practitioners and managers, exploring with them what they wanted from the project and their views and ideas about person-centred support, the barriers facing it and how these could be overcome. We then reported back to partners, agreeing feedback and synthesising findings from the eight sites. • First get-together: organising a one-day forum to bring together service users, practitioners and managers from all 20 services to share 30
Setting the scene for social care
and discuss their experience in their different sites, to gain a shared understanding of person-centred support and the issues it faces. • Empowerment training: on the basis of priorities identified by participants at the get-together, developing and delivering a programme of training and capacity building for each constituency, service users, practitioners and managers, to support the development of person-centred support, as well as organising a seminar focusing on making change for the consortium team. Training was user-led and built on the learning from the project and the needs identified by sites. Some partners also identified and agreed with us specific development work that they wanted us to support them with. This was carried out and included, for example, undertaking research to provide evidence, producing reports, offering training, holding meetings and supporting self-advocacy. • Second get-together: this again brought the partners and broader network together to share, discuss and develop the findings from the project. They also discussed key lessons they had learned from the project for taking forward person-centred support and how such a person-centred approach could be supported and successfully taken forward locally and nationally.
Our research approach While the project was not a narrowly research based one, it did include a significant research element. We saw our research approach as a participatory one, based on qualitative methods. Generally speaking, three approaches to user involvement research are identified. These are: • user involvement in research, where service users are involved in a project without necessarily playing a part in shaping its focus, questions, methodology or methods; • collaborative research, where service users and non-service user researchers and/or their organisations jointly initiate and develop a research project; • user controlled research, where service users and/or their organisations jointly initiate run and control research (Beresford, 2007). As has been said, the consortium team was a collaboration between different organisations and stakeholders. While our research project was therefore in one sense a collaborative one, it was also closely consistent with a user controlled research, as generally understood (Turner and 31
Supporting people
Beresford, 2005). The project was led by a user controlled organisation. It held the budget and shaped and submitted the original application. At the same time, the overall project was jointly and democratically managed by the consortium of four organisations, which also included two university centres and a voluntary organisation where disabled and non-disabled people work jointly together. Service users were closely involved, both as members of the consortium team and as participants in the project, in all its aspects, from shaping its final focus, through to its analysis, production of outputs, dissemination and it is intended, follow-up action. This book draws very heavily upon what participants in our project had to say. We place particular value on their first hand comments and accounts. Their quotes make up a major part of the core text. In general, for simplicity’s sake and to minimise the risk of people being identifiable, we have only mentioned whether they were a service user, carer, manager or practitioner when quoting them. We have retained details of the origins of all comments and quotations and can trace and confirm them. In those few cases where we are unable to identify particular individuals and have indicated that their source is ‘unknown’, this is because they originate from transcripts of group discussions that took place at the two get-togethers we held, which brought different stakeholders and sites together.
Evaluation There were two related aspects to evaluation in the project and we sought to address both. First was evaluation of the activities and responses of partners and second of the project which we were carrying out, to analyse and check its methodology and methods, strengths and weaknesses. Both activities were ongoing, with regular feedback to partners and the wider network. We identified a series of data streams for evaluation and sought to gather information in a systematic way.
Ethical issues In undertaking the project, we were anxious to follow good practice for ethical research, for example, seeking to ensure participants’ effective involvement, providing full, accurate and accessible information and safeguarding confidentiality and anonymity (Faulkner, 2004). The project also had an advisory group established by the Joseph Rowntree Foundation and was also supported by a reference group for the Foundation’s overall Independent Living programme, made 32
Setting the scene for social care
up of service users. What was outside our control, however, were existing ethical procedures and these constrained our research in two unhelpful ways, first restricting user involvement at its beginning and then creating major delays in undertaking research requested in one of the partner sites. We also faced problems in paying people for their involvement because of the practical problems involved and current inconsistencies between government participation and benefits policies (see Appendix One). We saw the kind of research approach we adopted as one based on qualitative rather than quantitative methods. The aim of the development aspects of the project was to engage with people directly and collaboratively, rather than in more directive and formalistic ways. Relatively large numbers of people were involved in our project and underpin this book’s findings. It is difficult to be precise about overall numbers, because people were involved in more than one way and there were clearly overlaps. However, nearly 250 people were directly involved at the eight local sites; more than 100 took part in capacity-building training; over 100 from the broader network of 20 organisations came to our get-togethers and hundreds took part in local meetings, contributed information or made contact with us. We also know that participants were highly diverse. So we know that in reporting our findings in this book, we are drawing on a large and diverse body of first hand knowledge and experience about supporting people and person-centred support.
Summary This chapter sets the scene both for social care and this book. It highlights the centrality of ‘change’ in social care; the constant efforts to make change and the failure as yet to bring about substantial reform in line with what service users say they want. It looks at the nature, significance and data for social care, while considering its broader relationships with public policy and society. It examines the fundamental problems that have continued to affect social care policy and the problems of sustainability raised in relation to an increasing demand for ‘care’, relating to a wide range of demographic, social and medical developments and a diminishing supply of paid and unpaid ‘carers’. The longstanding ambiguity of social care reform is also explored. Is its purpose to meet needs better, or contain cost? The idea and practice of personalisation are introduced and their central importance in current social care discussions and developments signposted. 33
Supporting people
The second half of the chapter introduces the project which provides the evidence base for the book, the Standards We Expect project. This was conceived as a national ‘change and development’ project. It was carried out by a user-led consortium working with a network of services, in eight specific sites and included a diverse range of services and service users. The project focused particularly on the perspectives of service users, practitioners and managers, reaching out to identify their understandings of person-centred support, the barriers it faces and how these might be overcome, in order to develop services better suited to deliver person-centred support. The chapter briefly sets out the project’s rights-based philosophy, how it was carried out, its emphasis on inclusion and diversity, its participatory approach to research and the ethical issues it faced. References Barton, R. (2000) ‘Social care’, in M. Davies (ed) The Blackwell encyclopaedia of social work, Oxford: Blackwell, pp 318-19. Beresford, P. (2007) ‘The role of service user research in generating knowledge-based health and social care: from conflict to contribution’, Evidence & Policy, vol 3, issue 4, pp 329-41. Beresford, P. (2008a) ‘Time to get real about personalisation’, Guest Editorial, Journal of Integrated Care, vol 16, no 2, April, pp 2-4. Beresford, P. (2008b) ‘Personal budgets must avoid one size fits all’, Second Thoughts, Guardian Society, 23 January, p 4. Beresford, P. (2009a) Self-directed support: If we are going to do it, let’s do it right, Report of a day conference organised by the London SelfDirected Support Forum, London: London Self-Directed Support Forum. Beresford, P. (2009b) ‘Social care, personalisation and service users: addressing the ambiguities’, Research, Policy and Planning, vol 27, no 2, pp 73-84. Beresford, P. (2011) ‘Society’s hidden have found their protesting voice’, Second Thoughts, Guardian Society, 5 January, p 4. Beresford, P., Shamash, O., Forrest,V.,Turner, M. and Branfield, F. (2005) Developing social care: Service users’ vision for adult support (Report of a consultation on the future of adult social care),Adult Services Report 07, London: Social Care Institute for Excellence in association with Shaping Our Lives. Berube, M. (2002) ‘Sideshows and backbends’, in L.J. Davis (ed) Disability, dismodernism and other difficult positions, NewYork: NewYork University Press, pp 1-8.
34
Setting the scene for social care
Boxall, K., Dowson, S. and Beresford, P. (2009) ‘Selling individual budgets, choice and control: local and global influences on UK social care policy for people with learning difficulties’, Policy & Politics, vol 37, no 4, October, pp 499-515. Branfield, F., Collins, J., Beresford, P. and Fleming, J. (2004) Proposal registration form:The Standards We Expect, London: Shaping Our Lives. Carr, S. (2004) Has service user participation made a difference to social care services?, London: Social Care Institute for Excellence. Carter,T. and Beresford, P. (2000) Age and change: Models of involvement for older people,York:York Publishing Services for the Joseph Rowntree Foundation. Clark, H., Gough, H. and Macfarlane,A. (2004) ‘It pays dividends’: Direct payments and older people, Bristol/York:The Policy Press for the Joseph Rowntree Foundation. CSCI (Commission for Social Care Inspection) (2008) The state of social care in England 2006-07, London: CSCI. CSCI (2009) The state of social care in England 2007-08, London: CSCI. DH (Department of Health) (2008) Putting People First, Adult social care workforce strategy interim statement, London: DH. DH (2010) A vision for adult social care: Capable communities and active citizens, November 10, London: DH. Faulkner, A. (2004) The ethics of survivor research: Guidelines for the ethical conduct of research carried out by mental service users and survivors, Bristol: The Policy Press. Fleming, J. and Ward, D. (2004) ‘Methodology and practical application of the social action research model’, in F. Maggs-Rapport (ed) New qualitative research methodologies in health and social care: Putting ideas into practice, London: Routledge. Fleming, J. and Hudson, N. (2009) ‘Young people and research: participation in practice’, in J. Wood and J. Hine (eds) Work with young people: Theory and policy for practice, London: Sage Publications, pp 114-27. Glasby, J. and Littlechild, R. (2009) Direct payments and personal budgets: Putting personalisation into practice (2nd edn), Bristol: The Policy Press. Glendinning, C., Challis, D., Fernandez, J., Jacobs, S., Jones, K., Knapp, M., Manthorpe, J., Moran, N., Netten,A., Stevens, M. and Wilberforce, M. (2008) Evaluation of the Individual Budgets Programme, Final report, IBSEN (Individual Budgets Evaluation Network), October, York: SPRU (Social Policy Research Unit), University of York.
35
Supporting people
Hampshire County Council (2008) Getting personal: A fair deal for better care and support,The report of Hampshire County Council’s Commission of Inquiry into personalisation and the future of adult social care, Winchester: Hampshire County Council. Harding,T. and Beresford, P. (eds) (1996) The Standards We Expect:What service users and carers want from social services workers, London: National Institute for Social Work. Hatton, C.,Waters, J., Duffy, S., Senker, J., Crosby, N., Poll, C.,Tyson,A., O’Brien, J. and Towell, D. (2008) A report on In Control’s second phase: Evaluation and learning 2005-2007, London: In Control. HM Government (2007) Putting People First: A shared vision and commitment to the transformation of aduclt social care, 10 December, London: The Stationery Office. HM Treasury (2010) Total place: A whole area approach to public services, London: HM Treasury and Department of Communities and Local Government, March. Jacobs, N. (2008) ‘State of adult social care workforce report: 2.5m staff needed by 2025’, 29 February (www.communitycare.co.uk/ Articles/2008/02/29/107452/adult-social-care-workforce-needsto-grow-by-more-than-a-million.html). JRF (Joseph Rowntree Foundation) (2004) JRF call for expressions of interest: ‘The Standards We Expect’: Solutions – Developing person-centred approaches,York: JRF. Lyons, M. (2007) Lyons Inquiry into local government: Place-shaping: A shared ambition for the future of local government, London:The Stationery Office (www.communities.gov.uk/documents/localgovernment/ pdf/158064.pdf). NCIL (National Centre for Independent Living) and Shaping Our Lives (2005) Independence, well-being and choice: Service users’ response to the Green Paper on the future of adult social care in England, Report of a national consultation, London: Social Care Institute for Excellence, NCIL and Shaping Our Lives. Petch, A. (2008) ‘Social work with adult service users’, in M. Davies (ed) The Blackwell companion to social work (3rd edn), Oxford: Blackwell, pp 236-50. Platt, D. (2003) 12th annual report of the Chief Inspector of Social Services, London: Department of Health. Poll, C., Duffy, S., Hatton, C., Sanderson, H. and Routledge, M. (2006) A report on In Control’s first phase 2003-2005, London: In Control (www.in-control.org.uk/).
36
Setting the scene for social care
Putting People First (2011) Think Local, Act Personal: A sector-wide commitment to moving forward with personalisation and community-based support, London: Social Care Institute for Excellence/Putting People First. Turner, M. and Beresford, P. (2005) User-controlled research: Its meanings and potential, Final report, London, Brunel and Eastleigh: Shaping Our Lives, Centre for Citizen Participation, Brunel University and Involve. Waters, J. and Duffy, S. (2007) Individual budget integration:An exploration of the possible scope of individual budgets, A report for the Department of Health by In Control, London: In Control.
37
TWO
Person-centred support I’m beginning to worry we’re creating another fashion. People talking about personalisation who know nothing about it. We need to take a step back to develop and be clear about definition and to do a hearts and minds, service users and carers, workers and general public. (Ivan Lewis, Minister for Social Care, Seminar, Launch of Institute for Public Policy Research report, 3 June 2008) STANDARD TWO: A PERSON-CENTRED VALUE-BASE
Services and support should be underpinned by the core values of person-centred support. This includes the values of independent living, the social model of disability and a rights-based approach to providing support and meeting people’s needs. Services must address issues of equality and diversity and be accessible and inclusive.
Introduction This chapter focuses on the idea and practice of person-centred support. This is the central focus of this book and indeed of contemporary social care policy. There is little agreement or clarity over terminology in this field, which is one which abounds with jargon. The dominant term used to describe proposed new developments in and beyond social care, as we have indicated, is ‘personalisation’. It originates in a government Green Paper of 2005 (DH, 2005). Yet in a very short time, from being a new piece of jargon, it has come to be offered by government as the guiding principle for the future of social care and indeed of other public policies (HM Government, 2007). It has had cross-party support and survived government change to remain a focus for social care policy (Putting People First, 2011). At its heart personalisation seems to be used to mean tailoring the service or support to the individual citizen or service user. While, as we have 39
Supporting people
said, its definition remains vague and unclear, in social care it appears to serve as a synonym for person-centred support. It is this latter term that we will mainly be using in this book although we see the two terms as having significantly shared meanings. In this chapter we will look at the origins of the idea and practice of ‘person-centred support’, but focus particularly on the meanings that service users, practitioners and managers now seem to attach to it.
The origins of person-centred support While personalisation is a term which has been highlighted by government, is heavily politicised and may have a limited life-span, person-centred support has more substantial roots in social care. It is probably best understood as originating as a reaction against the prevailing nature of social care policy and services. Social care and its earlier equivalents have undergone many restructurings and reorganisations. The old Poor Law gave way to the new Poor Law in 1834. This was based on principles of ‘less eligibility’ – imposing conditions worse than if you managed on your own and ‘deterrence’ – making people go into the workhouse to get any help. The welfare state put an end to the Poor Law in 1948 (although it persisted in some senses in the field of social care) and was based on the philosophy of ‘universality’ – help from the state for all who needed it. Margaret Thatcher’s ‘new right’ governments heralded a new approach, with the state no longer the provider of services, but instead the purchaser of them, while service users increasingly paid for their services, either directly as ‘self-funders’ or by being funded to through the state. Social care, however, has never been a monolithic state service. There has always been a strong charitable sector as well as private provision (Glasby, 2008). Over the years, social care had been shaped by a variety of different philosophies. This includes the utilitarianism of the Poor Law, the redistributive state welfarism of post-Second World War governments, the consumerism and new right politics of Thatcherism, the ‘third way’ of New Labour, which was intended as a remix of state and market intervention and then the ‘new politics’, in times of severe economic difficulty, which followed its electoral defeat. Yet there has been a remarkable consistency in the experience of social care service users over the years. This is not to say that the cruelty and punitive regime of the new Poor Law has persisted undiluted into the 21st century. This would be a very false comparison. Yet many of its characteristics have continued significantly to be present. These include an emphasis on: 40
Person-centred support
• • • • • •
people’s rigid categorisation segregation congregation mere physical maintenance batch living – having to do things together, the same way standardised routines
There have been some significant changes. However, social care has continued to be strongly influenced by its Poor Law past and also the conceptualisation of the people with whom it works as separate, dependent and in some cases deviant or pathological. Elements of social control have also long persisted. These have occurred both where there have been provisions to restrict the rights and freedom of service users and where such a culture has seeped into what were meant to be support functions, with both formal and substantive restrictions being placed on what people can do, where they can go, their privacy and on their relationships with each other. While the size, location and nature of social care’s institutional responses have varied, these have played a consistently significant role in it. From large to small institutions; from rural and suburban institutions to inner-city institutions; from residential to non-residential institutions. Service users sometimes comment that the rigid and impersonal way in which domiciliary care is provided, can make living in their own home feel like living in an institution (Beresford et al, 2005; Branfield et al, 2005). Perhaps the most important development there has been in traditional social care has been the move towards people remaining in, returning to, or moving to their own homes. One of the most significant innovations that made this possible was the development of the role of ‘home help’ in the 1950s and 1960s, a role originally intended to offer support to mothers with new born children, then increasingly offered to older and other disabled people. More recently, however, with the increasing commodification of care following the community care reforms of the early 1990s and the shift in emphasis to private agencies providing ‘care’ and service users paying for it, service users have reported an increasingly inadequate and institutionalised system of ‘domiciliary care’. They talk of workers whose role is increasingly restricted to include only physical maintenance, rather than embracing social support. They often refer to a ‘succession of strangers’ entering their homes to describe constantly changing agency staff they barely know, who intervene in their lives in intimate matters, sometimes without proper privacy, respect or sensitivity. 41
Supporting people
Thus social care has been seen essentially as a service-led system, where service users must fit into what provision there is, rather than this being tailored to respond to their particular needs, wants and circumstances. Thus pressure towards user-centred support can be seen as a reaction against this status quo. Now the focus is on the service user and what most helps them to live their life autonomously to the fullest degree possible. Two key developments emerged to challenge the traditional system and the approach it embodied. These are ‘person-centred planning’ and direct payments/independent living. They are themselves very different, developing different philosophies, world views and relating to different ideologies. A brief examination of them offers us an invaluable way in to understanding the historical basis of interest in person-centred support, as well as the potentially different ways in which it may be taken forward.
Person-centred planning ‘Person-centred planning’ (PCP) can be seen as one of the expressions of the normalisation movement developed internationally by nondisabled people from the 1970s, particularly in relation to people with learning difficulties. Normalisation, or ‘social role valorisation’, was concerned with challenging the marginalisation and segregation of people with learning difficulties in society, aiming to enable them to live an ‘ordinary life’ participating in mainstream society with valued relationships, rather than restricted to a service system (Race, 2002, 2003). While its advocates were not insensitive to the barriers and discrimination facing people with learning difficulties, their emphasis has been on enabling them to be part of the existing world, rather than seeking to change this. More recently person-centred planning has been applied to a wider range of service user groups. Person-centred planning can be seen as both a philosophy and a set of techniques (Robertson et al, 2005). At the heart of it is a shift away from conventional social care services: … by ‘person-centred’ I mean we have to move away from mass-produced services. Services that too often created a culture of dependency and move towards a future that seeks to develop the potential that is in every single individual. (Dowling et al, 2006, p 1)
42
Person-centred support
Reviewing the literature of person-centred planning in social care, Sandra Dowling and her colleagues say that it: … is at the heart of much recent policy relating to the provision of social care services. It refers to a family of approaches aimed at enabling people who use services to plan their own futures and to get the services that they need. (Dowling et al, 2006, p vi) Helen Sanderson describes person-centred planning as: … a process of continual listening, and learning; focused on what is important to someone now, and for the future; and acting upon this in alliance with their family and friends. It is not simply a collection of new techniques for planning to replace Individual Programme Planning. It is based on a completely different way of seeing and working with people with disabilities, which is fundamentally about sharing power and community inclusion. (Sanderson, 2000, p 2) According to Cole and others: Person centred planning is a process that finds out what an individual wants to do with his/her life, helps the person decide on goals and then plans what action needs to be taken to achieve those goals. It is an ongoing process which means that the person can regularly set new goals as his/her skills and experience grow and ambitions change. The core principle in all of these methods [of personcentred planning such as PATH, ELP etc.] is to look at the whole person rather than viewing them as a series of ‘needs’ – such as for residential, day or leisure services – and to consider all aspects of a person’s life including friendships and relationships. The focus on each person as a unique individual is particularly important for people living in group residential provisions where the wishes and needs of the many can overshadow that of an individual. (Cole et al 2000, p 30) The government’s guidance for Valuing People, the initiative intended to improve policy and provision for people with learning difficulties is
43
Supporting people
centrally based on principles of person-centred planning and describes it as: … a process for continual listening and learning, focused on what is important to someone now and for the future, and acting upon this in alliance with family and friends. This listening and learning is used to understand a person’s capacities and choices. Person centred planning is a basis for problem solving and negotiation to mobilise the resources necessary to pursue the person’s aspirations. These resources may be obtained from a person’s personal network, from service agencies or from a range of non-specialist and nonservice sources. (DH, 2002, p 2)
Independent living Jenny Morris, the disabled feminist and independent disability consultant, wrote of independent living: The independent–living movement in Britain has its roots in disabled people’s attempts to leave residential care…. It was the benevolent paternalism of the voluntary-sector residential homes set up in the 1950s which provided the context for demands from residents that they have more control over their lives and the establishments in which they lived. (Morris, 1993, p 17) She described the movement as being based on four beliefs: • That all human life is of value; • That anyone, whatever their impairment, is capable of exerting choices; • That people who are disabled by society’s reaction to physical, intellectual and sensory impairment and to emotional distress have the right to assert control over their lives; • That disabled people have the right to participate fully in society. (Morris, 1993, p 21) Thus the philosophy of independent living was developed by disabled people and the disabled people’s movement and can be seen to have grown grow out of the social model of disability which they pioneered. The social model of disability draws a distinction between an individual’s 44
Person-centred support
perceived impairment ‘physical, sensory or intellectual’ and disability, meaning the negative societal reaction to such impairment. Developing discussion has explored the interactions between impairment and disability and the barriers disabled people experience from society, including attitudinal, physical and communication barriers. Such ‘barrier based’ approaches to understanding are now being related to a widening range of social care service users (Thomas, 2007). Independent living is a rights-based philosophy based on the achievement of disabled people’s full human and civil rights. Two interrelated aspects of independent living are highlighted. These are first ensuring people the support that they need under their control to be able to live their lives as fully as they can, on as equal terms as possible, with non-disabled people. Second, equalising their access to mainstream policy and services, like housing, health, education, recreation and employment. The philosophy of independent living turns traditional notions of independence on their head. It is not preoccupied with the individual or narrow ideas of personal autonomy. It does not mean ‘standing on your own two feet’ or managing on your own. Instead of seeing the service user as having a defect or deficiency requiring care, it highlights the need to ensure service users have the support that they need to live their lives on as equal terms as possible. This support is not expected to come from family members required to be informal carers. Simon Brisenden, pioneer of the UK disabled people’s movement wrote that independence means that: People have control over their lives, not that they perform every task themselves. Independence is not linked to the physical or intellectual capacity to care for oneself without assistance; independence is created by having assistance when and how one requires it. (Brisenden, 1989, p 9; see also Brisenden, 1986) Independent living replaces the idea of ‘care’ with that of support. Service user movements have tended to be critical of the concept of care. They see it as imposing a framework which subordinates them, implies they are incapable and subjects them to control. The government’s 2008 Independent Living Strategy signed up to the values of independent living (Office for Disability Issues, 2008). The disabled people’s movement crucially developed ‘direct payments’ as the means of accessing people to the support they want under their control. Direct payments offer service users a sum of money in line 45
Supporting people
with the philosophy of independent living to purchase the support they prefer. This can include employing their own personal assistants. Writing in 1996, Mike Oliver, the disability academic and activist said that evidence already: … suggests that independent living schemes are not just morally desirable and professionally appropriate, but they also offer the possibility of providing more cost effective and efficient services through switching from the overproduction of welfare services that people don’t want or need and the underproduction of those that they do, to a situation where the services that are produced and purchased by statutory providers are precisely the services that users want and need. (Oliver, 1996, p 61)
Definitions of person-centred support Although terms like ‘person-centred care’ and ‘support’ and ‘personalisation’ have gained significant currency in social care, there seems to have been only a limited attempt to define them. As has been seen, there has been extensive writing about and defining of person-centred planning which has sometimes tended to be treated – but erroneously in our view – as a synonym for person-centred support. The first, person-centred planning, rests on a very specific philosophy and has a particular history which can be traced. The second, person-centred support is a more general term which seeks to describe a broader approach committed to self-development and self-determination and being ‘user-centred’. In Promoting person-centred care at the frontline (2006) Innes, Macpherson and McCabe focus on experiences of ‘front-line’ workers and the views of service users relating to person-centred care. At key points they use the two terms ‘care’ and ‘support’ interchangeably. They say: The term ‘person-centred care’ is mentioned frequently in the older people literature, particularly in dementia care, although the working definition of the concept is not always explicit (p5).... Vernon and Qureshi (2000) found that definitions of quality of care differ between service users and professionals. Service users’ main concern is what the service does for them and how it is delivered (for example, if the behaviour of the carer is empowering). They also 46
Person-centred support
want control over the type of service received, particularly the timing of tasks and who provides the service. (p 13) Face to face workers quoted in the study say: If you are being person centred then you will focus on what is important to them; it’s not just their care needs it’s also their social needs, their emotional needs, their family needs. It is everything. (p 8) To treat someone as you would wish to be treated – someone like me to look after me. (p 8) The authors conclude that McCormack’s (2004) definition of being in relation, being in a social world, being in place and being with self can be linked to the three attributes of good-quality care, that is: the involvement of the service user; taking into account users’ needs/views; and the provision of flexible and responsive services. (Innes et al, 2006, p 23) This highlights the importance of support taking into account the person as an individual in the context of their particular relationships and social setting. Although the term ‘person-centred care’ may not be used, there is a general consensus that person-centred or quality care is care that: • • • •
is focused on clients/users promotes independence and autonomy rather than control involves services that are reliable and flexible and chosen by users tends to be offered by those working in a collaborative/team philosophy.
Person-centred support: what people say One of our key concerns in exploring person-centred support was to find out what the term meant to people likely to be most directly affected by it; that is, service users, face-to-face practitioners and managers. This is the first time, to the best of our knowledge, that such a systematic attempt has been made to explore its definition from their perspectives. While it is sometimes suggested that these constituencies 47
Supporting people
may have strongly differing views on the subject, we found a broad consensus between service users, practitioners and managers about what is meant by person-centred support. Service users and practitioners, however, did tend to attach a different emphasis to its different elements or components.
Person-centred support: values not techniques It quickly became apparent that for most people, person-centred support is essentially a value-based idea. Many of the people we spoke to, service users, practitioners and managers, made it clear that for them person-centred support could only exist in a sustained and effective manner when it was underpinned by certain core values, like inclusion, respect, independence and personal choice. They saw person-centred support as a way of working based on certain beliefs about the rights of service users and the values needed to achieve them. They understood it as at heart a value-based approach to practice and support. Dowling, Manthorpe and Cowley describe values in terms of the culture of a service: The culture of a service can be regarded as bringing together the underlying guiding principles that govern the way in which it is run and how support is delivered. It steers the development of relationships between users and providers, and is often evident in the ways in which frontline staff interact with users and deliver the service. (Dowling et al, 2006, p 37) People drew a strong distinction between a value-based approach and a technique or system of working, seeing person-centred support very much as the former. In discussions about personalisation and individual budgets, the dominant discussion has tended to focus much more on techniques and processes. Individual budgets, for example, have been offered by their advocates as a ‘new operating system’, with the main emphasis placed on the process and stages involved and ‘how to do it’ (Hatton et al, 2008) Participants spoke of person-centred support as a way of thinking or something that comes from the heart. They stressed that for them it was an approach rather than a set of procedures or techniques. To me you get it here [speaker pointing to her heart] or not. Manager 48
Person-centred support
It’s not another job, it’s the job. Person-centred support is not another thing that you have got to do, it is what you have got to do. Practitioner I still don’t think people get it. I remember seeing a personcentred plan four or five years ago that had been written by a day service for [disabled] people and it was the most unperson-centred piece of paper I’d ever seen in my whole life. You know, it was like a school report, you know, ‘X behaved well in this lesson.’ It was vile, and all they’d done was stick a piece of paper on the front that said, you know, ‘Jo Bloggs person-centred plan’ and that’s all it was. It was awful, and I don’t actually think we can have moved on very far from it. I’m sure people have in some areas but I think there’s a huge proportion who don’t get [it] … They might get all the terminology, you know, we know what a person-centred plan is supposed to include because we read the book. Manager
The use of language Many service users, practitioners and managers were concerned about the use and often abuse of language in social care. There was a strong feeling that terms coined by the disabled people’s movement were being appropriated by the service system for its own ends. Some service users said that services adopted such language to appear more person-centred, while still lacking the underlying values and approach. They referred to the misuse of words like ‘independence’, ‘individual’, ‘control’ and ‘involvement’, where the philosophy underpinning it was lost or abandoned. There’s a lot of lip-service paid to person-centred support. Practitioner And I think as far as managers are concerned, person-centred care, planning, etcetera, is such a big thing now, they have to buy into it, you know. If they weren’t seen to be taking it on board then I don’t know what social services would think about it, because everybody’s talking about it. Not known Every aspect of what we do is guided by the person. Not by the parents, not by anybody else – by the person. A lot
49
Supporting people
of people say that they do it but we put it into practice. Practitioner
Participants were clear that just taking on the language of personcentred support would not result in services that were genuinely personalised. They saw values as forming the foundations on which a service was built. Without them, they felt the service lacked integrity. They suggested that core values support the day-to-day decisions and ways of working that make services person-centred.
Key components of person-centred support When we asked people what person-centred support meant to them, a series of value-based components emerged. These provided the basis for their definition of person-centred support. These elements included: • • • • • • • • •
putting the person at the centre treating service users as individuals choice and control for service users setting goals the importance of the relationship between service users and practitioners listening to service users up-to-date, accessible information about appropriate services flexibility a positive approach.
Putting the person at the centre The most frequently identified characteristic of person-centred support was putting the person at the centre of services. This fits closely with the whole ethos underpinning personalisation – ‘starting with the person rather than the service’ (Jones, quoted in Carr, 2008, p v). As service users and practitioners put it, person-centred support means: Being at the centre of your service. Service user We tailor everything to the individual. Practitioner Your mind is focused on the client, what they want. Whatever care you give is centred on the client you are working with. Practitioner 50
Person-centred support
The client should be the central person, by setting up a plan, looking at where they are now, their journey, dream and goals. Practitioner It’s giving someone the care for their needs, but revolving around them and what their needs are to maintain their daily living and promote independence for them. Practitioner Members [users of the day centre] come first, they are listened to, respected, treated with dignity. We offer a very wide choice which is person led rather than centre-led. Practitioner
Practitioners contrasted person-centred support with services being provided on the basis of what was available. It’s starting with the person around what that particular person’s needs are and matching the services with their needs rather than the other way round. Practitioner The opposite of ‘one size fits all’ really, although it’s not possible to have an infinite variety of resources, but to personalise it as much as possible. Practitioner We try and tailor our services around what they want rather than say, ‘Look, this is it.’ Practitioner
Managers had the same understanding, while highlighting the need for consistency: Develop services around that, focus around the [person] rather than the statutory services we have in place. Rather than fit those people into particular boxes. Manager We need to tailor our services around what users want and provide consistency of care as well. Manager
Treating service users as individuals Closely related to the sense that person-centred support must start with the person rather than the service system, was the view that each person must be seen as an individual. Maintaining a focus on 51
Supporting people
individual requirements emerged as of central importance for personcentred support. [Support should be] specific for each person. Practitioner I suppose really treating people as individuals. Everyone has different needs. Not known Organising services around people. Practitioner
This also requires empathy, if there was to be a proper understanding of each person’s needs. One question which care planners should ask themselves is, ‘What would I want, if this was my own situation?’ Service user You should treat them how you would want to get treated. Practitioner
Another service user spoke about direct payments and how they are designed to serve the individual. Direct payments are a perfect example of person-centred [support]. They focus on the individual. Service user
Choice and control for service users Choice and control were identified as central aspects of person-centred support. Service users in particular regarded this as key. Giving me choice and control, putting me first. Service user I may need physical care but I don’t need people to think for me. Service user Letting me choose and speak. Remember – I have the right to choose what I do and when! Service user Having control so that when things aren’t working for you, you can say so. Service user
52
Person-centred support
Being able to decide for yourself what you want to do and not letting anyone decide for you. Other people may have good intentions for what you need but you might know better how to achieve it. Service user [Service users] are viewed as something to be done to or at and for me it is about – I am in control of my life now and no matter how disabled I become, I still want to be in control of my life…that is how we will get person-centred care because I will be in charge of it, not somebody else. (Service user Your worker can’t tell you what you need, you know what you need. Service user
Practitioners and managers also talked about the importance of choice and control for service users. For me it’s about power, the power being more with the person rather than the organisation or professional. Practitioner I think part of it is about having that control just to say, that is not working for me and I don’t want to do it anymore and I won’t do it anymore. Practitioner Actually allowing people to make the choices and the decisions rather than doing it for them. Practitioner Every aspect of what we do is guided by the person. Not by the parents, not by anybody else – by the person. A lot of people say that they do it, but we put it into practice. Practitioner Anything that is done around the residents starts with them. Manager I always come back with, ‘Is this what you want?’ Because I am not planning [for them], I am just there to be helpful. Practitioner
53
Supporting people
Setting goals An important part of person-centred support people identified was thinking about and planning for the future. This was often framed in terms of setting goals for what the service user wanted to achieve. This started with the individual’s interests and priorities. It put the person at the centre of the process and supported them to define their own, individual outcomes. It’s basically what we’d like to do in the future, how people can help us achieve a particular goal. Service user
Many practitioners had previous experience of person-centred planning. They found it helpful and it influenced their thinking. Its techniques include setting goals and an emphasis on rights, decisionmaking and active participation in community life. They said: [Person-centred planning is] a process which enables an individual to make changes in their life. Practitioner You could have two people who’ve got very similar kind of needs but it’s actually about what they want to do and where they want to go, and how they want to do it. Practitioner It’s really sitting down and talking with the client, planning basically. Where they want to be in however many years’ time and planning the steps to help them work towards that. For example one client is an asylum seeker who would like to study accountancy. The way I work with her is doing what she wants to do, staying at home until the child is one year old and then return to college, study basic accountancy and take it from there. So it’s about what they want not what we would expect them to achieve within two years. Practitioner I don’t think it’s just needs though. It’s aspirations as well. Practitioner It is about saying what your dream is. So that everyone can have a dream. And it could be to be an astronaut or to live in a mansion or whatever, but then you go back and you start to, step by step, see what the blocks are to you getting 54
Person-centred support
that and step by step what you can do in order to begin to achieve that goal. Practitioner
The importance of the relationship between service users and practitioners Many participants, particularly practitioners, emphasised the importance of the relationship between service users and practitioners. They felt that building a trusting relationship in which both service user and worker felt relaxed and confident was crucial. Practitioners could learn about the service user’s individual situation and build up important practical knowledge. Many people thought person-centred support could not operate without strong, effective relationships between service users and workers. It is building that relationship that makes the person-centred bit follow on. Practitioner When they first come, they come in and you get to know them bit by bit, and eventually as they get comfortable with you, they will start talking to you more. And you will get used to a resident and they will get used to you and they feel they can open up more…. Eventually they get to know you and they are more able to communicate with you. Practitioner It was all about meeting our clients, building a relationship is the real foundation. Practitioner You need to develop the relationship before you can start planning. Practitioner
Listening Listening to what service users say and supporting them to say it, were seen as key to person-centred support. In this way support starts with the service user’s own understanding of and expertise in their life and experience. Many service users highlighted this. Their comments revealed widespread experience of not being listened to and not having a say in the service they received. For them positive practice was the antithesis of this.
55
Supporting people
What I want is to be listened to and respected. Service user Listening, really listening. Service user Respect that they are the expert of their own lives and their own needs. Service user We just don’t get no help whatsoever and we feel we need it. I feel if someone was to come around and see us and talk and ask exactly what we need, even if they couldn’t provide it, at least it would show us that someone is caring and listening to us. Service user
Many practitioners similarly recognised and highlighted the importance of listening and supporting service users to speak openly. Listening to what service users want. Practitioner Allowing them to have their say. Practitioner It’s about people telling you what their needs are. Practitioner We have person-centred planning meetings as regularly as we can for each individual resident, so that we can say to them, ‘Tell us what you want, how do you want to spend your time, what would you like to do, what can we do to help you improve things for you?’ And we try our best to do that. Practitioner
Some practitioners saw listening as demonstrating respect for the service user. This could be the first step towards supporting them to have choice and control. I think that first of all the real belief that the expert in the room is the person, the client, and respecting that. They are the expert of what their needs are. Practitioner When we did some work with her on person-centred planning, and she actually started to be more expressive about what she wanted to do and more about positive stuff, she ended up saying, ‘I hate going to the gym, I want to play 56
Person-centred support
chess and Scrabble because that is what I am really interested in. Can you help me to get involved in that?’ Practitioner
Listening was also seen as part of a reflective process for improving a service. We are just learning that as a support service provider … you have to understand that still you will need to learn from the service users. Practitioner
One practitioner talked about the problems she had experienced with social workers not listening to what service users had to say. A lot of our work is trying to get social workers to understand that they need to listen to what people want. Practitioner
Information Up-to-date, accessible, accurate and relevant information was widely seen as essential for person-centred support. How could anyone, worker or service user, make reliable judgements without it? You need the right information to help you choose. It must be informed choice. Service user We try to give people as much information as possible, all the information we know is passed on and if we don’t have it we look elsewhere to provide what it is they are looking for. Practitioner
Flexibility The emphasis on individualisation of services in person-centred support meant that services had to be flexible and adaptable. Service users expressed this in terms of: Remembering everyone is different and has different needs. Service user [Support] tailored to your own needs, that you can access as and when you need to. Service user 57
Supporting people
Service workers commented: Each case has its own merits and you have to work from there. If you need a new way of working with someone, that’s what you do. Practitioner Every single day is different…. They are all individual so we don’t make them do something they don’t want to do. Practitioner
One participant said that because person-centred support required flexibility, ‘standard models’ of support were not helpful. I don’t think we should follow any model, I think personcentred support is about not following models. I think person-centred is about listening to people…. I really get tired of all the models and theories that are imposed on us, and then that one doesn’t quite work so we’ll have another model. Not known
A positive approach Service users and practitioners both emphasised the importance of focusing on the positives – what service users can or might be able to do, rather than on negatives – or what they might not be able to do. This emerged as part of a process of building people’s resources and capacity. Service users said: [Highlight] positive abilities, not the negatives. Service user Giving the person the opportunity to achieve. Service user By believing in people’s value and giving all people a chance. Service user
Participants felt that this helped service users to make choices and work towards what they wanted in their lives. Where I work with people, sometimes they don’t realise their own ability and then suddenly they find something coming up, I don’t know, maybe like writing or drawing or painting and then they discover for themselves naturally that they do 58
Person-centred support
have a talent or a strength that they never recognised before. That gives them confidence. Manager
Practitioners said: The actual point of it [person-centred support], is to raise people’s self-esteem and awareness. I think confidencebuilding is paramount if people want to change their lives and be master of their own lives. In our organisation we are increasingly giving people, or enabling people, to make choices for themselves and consequently some people are really beginning to believe in themselves and being able to feel as though they can integrate into mainstream society, and indeed make a contribution. Practitioner They [service users] have also got great things to offer and it is about finding those and actually saying, ‘Hey, you are a worthwhile person to contribute something,’ rather than just receiving services all the time. Practitioner They have skills, they have experience. Most of them have a wealth of knowledge, and it is often that if you can actually channel some of those skills enabling the person to do something, making a positive contribution. I have a lot of clients that I work for I know are working in schools. They work in small schools, junior schools and primary schools, and they support people with numeracy, literacy and they are making a positive contribution … and it gives them feelings of, they feel valued, they are making a positive contribution. That is the first stepping-stone to them moving on to a whole range of other things. Practitioner
A manager described this approach as: Actually building on the good bits rather than focusing on the needs.
Terminology Terminology is contentious in this field. We have already seen that some service users and workers felt that the modernisation of language was 59
Supporting people
used to conceal the perpetuation of old values and approaches. But the issue extends beyond this. Just as policy and practice are at a stage of continuous change, so is the terminology associated with them. There has been some tendency to use the terms person-centred support and person-centred care interchangeably. Some of the people we spoke to did this. But some participants saw the term ‘care’ as inconsistent with the principles and goals of person-centred support. This reflects similar concerns about the use of the term ‘care’ by the founders of the independent living movement. Certainly what emerges from what both service users and workers have said is that person-centred support means adopting a different approach towards working with service users, one based on support rather than care. The difference is supporting people to do things for themselves rather than doing things for them. This denotes, for example, the difference between a service user being in the kitchen and involved in preparing a meal, as opposed to the service cooking a meal for the service user. This approach supports and develops independence. It gives more choice and control, as service users are active in the process, rather than passive recipients of services. This approach is applicable to all groups of service users, not just those perceived as the most able. People with severe physical impairments or learning difficulties should be actively involved in both decision-making and practical tasks. So it’s getting that culture change from the carer to support worker working in a completely different way. So it’s looking at the whole cultural values of enabling people rather than doing for people…. So we’re actually currently undertaking a lot of training for more service users and carers and we’re looking at people doing training together as well. Practitioner I think sometimes it is not about doing it for them, is it, it is about supporting them to do it themselves. Being there for them so when the next decision needs to be made they are perhaps half a step nearer and you are slowly backing off. Manager It’s a very good idea, you have got your own flat, not like a residential home. Here you have your own privacy and if you want help you can get help. You can be as independent as you want to be. Service user
60
Person-centred support
It’s often a relatively small level of support which enables them to be completely proactive. Our role is to support, to enable people but only up to a level where they can take over. Practitioner [Working in a nursing home was] very different. A nursing home is more personal care, doing a lot more for them. Working here you are still hands on but it’s more of a sociable level. Practitioner
This reflects a switch to service users having control over the support they receive and the direction this support takes. This impacts on the relationship between the service user and practitioner. It entails a move towards more equal relationships based on respect and understanding.
Defining person-centred support From what people had to say to us, person-centred support can be helpfully defined as a way of matching social care support to people’s individual needs. Crucially, it represents a shift from service users adapting to the services they use, to services adapting to the needs of their service users. It embraces flexible support designed to meet the goals of each service user. It starts with listening to what service users have to say and prioritising their rights and needs over those of service providers. It is based on developing strong and positive relationships between service users and practitioners and service users having access to up-to-date, accessible and high quality information. Person-centred support supports independent living and equality through promoting people’s choice and control over their lives.
Summary In the context of government moves to ‘personalisation’ in public policy, including social care, this chapter examines the concept and practice of person-centred support. To do so it draws on the views of service users, practitioners and managers and relates person-centred support to ideas of person-centred planning and independent living. Person-centred support can be seen as a reaction against longstanding paternalistic and institutionalising approaches to support and social care. As well as examining the limited definitions of person-centred support so far offered, the chapter reports how service users, workers and managers define it, setting out a series of key components that 61
Supporting people
they associate with it and the meanings that they attach to it. Crucially people see person-centred support as much more than a technique. They see it as an approach to support that is strongly value based and where the relationship between service user and worker is of central importance. References Beresford, P., Shamash, O., Forrest,V.,Turner, M. and Branfield, F. (2005) Developing social care: Service users’ vision for adult support (Report of a consultation on the future of adult social care),Adult Services Report 07, London: Social Care Institute for Excellence in association with Shaping Our Lives. Branfield, F., Beresford, P.,Danagher, N. and Webb, R. (2005) Independence, well-being and choice: A response to the Green Paper on adult social care: Report of a consultation with service users, London: National Centre for Independent Living and Shaping Our Lives. Brisenden, S. (1986) ‘Independent living and the medical model of disability’, Disability, Handicap And Society, vol 1, no 2, pp 173-8. Brisenden, S. (1989) ‘A charter for personal care’, Progress, 16, London: Disablement Income Group. Carr, S. (2008) Personalisation: A rough guide, SCIE Report 20, October, London: Social Care Institute for Excellence. Cole,A., McIntosh, B. and Whittaker,A. (2000) We want our voices heard: Developing new lifestyles with disabled people, Bristol: The Policy Press. DH (Department of Health) (2002) Towards person-centred approaches, planning with people: Guidance for partnership boards, Valuing People, London: DH. DH (2005) Independence, well-being and choice: Our vision for the future of social care for adults in England, Green Paper, March, London: The Stationery Office. Dowling, S., Manthorpe, J. and Cowley, S. in association with King, S., Raymond,V., Perez,W. and Weinstein, P. (2006) Person-centred planning in social care: A scoping review,York: Joseph Rowntree Foundation. Glasby, J. (2008) ‘Social care’, in P. Alcock, M. May and K. Rowlingson (eds) The student’s companion to social policy (3rd edn), Oxford: Blackwell, pp 351-6. Hatton, C.,Waters, J., Duffy, S., Senker, J., Crosby, N., Poll, C.,Tyson,A., O’Brien, J. and Towell, D. (2008) A report on In Control’s second phase: Evaluation and learning 2005-2007, London: In Control. HM Government (2007) Putting People First: A shared vision and commitment to the transformation of adult social care, London: The Stationery Office. 62
Person-centred support
Innes,A., Macpherson, S. and McCabe, L. (2006) Promoting person-centred care at the front line, York: Joseph Rowntree Foundation. Morris, J. (1993) Independent lives: Community care and disabled people, Basingstoke: Macmillan. Office for Disability Issues (2008) The Independent Living strategy:A crossgovernment strategy about independent living for disabled people, London: Office for Disability Issues. Oliver, M. (1996) Understanding disability: From theory to practice, Basingstoke: Macmillan. Putting People First (2011) Think Local, Act Personal: A sector-wide commitment to moving forward with personalisation and community-based support, London: Social Care Institute for Excellence/Putting People First. Race, D. (ed) (2002) Learning disability: A social approach, London: Routledge. Race, D. (ed) (2003) Leadership and change in human services: Selected readings from Wolf Wolfensberger, London: Routledge. Robertson, J. et al (2005) The impact of person-centred planning, Lancaster: Institute for Health Research. Sanderson, H. (2000) Person-centred planning: Key features and approaches, York: Joseph Rowntree Foundation. Thomas, C. (2007) Sociologies of disability and illness: Contested ideas in disability studies and medical sociology, London: Palgrave Macmillan.
63
Part Two Person-Centred Support: Barriers and Ways of Overcoming Them
THREE
The funding of social care Never mind the glossy brochures, the enlightened promises, our daily experience tells us a different story.... How many times do we have to hear a bewildered voice on the phone exclaiming, ‘It never dawned on me that they would do nothing!’ as yet another family member discovers that a much loved relative does not qualify for help. (User-led organisation supporting people with direct payments, quoted in Hampshire County Council, 2008, p 33)
The deficit reduction programme takes precedence over any of the other measures in this agreement, and the speed of implementation of any measures that have a cost to the public finances will depend on decisions to be made in the Comprehensive Spending Review. (HM Government, 2010b, back cover) STANDARD THREE: FUNDING
A changed system of funding is needed for social care which ensures that all service users on a sustainable basis can have equal access to person-centred support consistent with the values of independent living, taking account of cultural and demographic change and the growing scale of social care needs.
Introduction Funding issues have long been a major concern in social care. While funding support for the National Health Service was massively increased under New Labour administrations from 1997 onwards, the same was not true for its partner policy, social care, where spending has not 67
Supporting people
significantly increased. The legacy of Conservative administrations from the late 1970s onwards, was of a chronically underfunded social care sector. This has been perpetuated rather than rectified by subsequent governments. The 2006 Wanless Report on social care offered more formal confirmation of this view (Wanless, 2006). Wanless made clear that existing funding arrangements were untenable, particularly for the future, highlighting predicted demographic changes leading to large increases in both the proportions and numbers of older and very old people needing support. Because of the wide and growing sense that existing funding arrangements for social care were unworkable, in 2009, the Labour government published a Green Paper on future social care funding (HM Government, 2009). It put forward three funding options for public consultation. These were what it called the partnership, insurance and comprehensive options. All these options were based on people with some resources making a direct personal contribution to the cost of their care. At the same time, the government ruled out from public discussion funding social care from general taxation, along comparable lines to the National Health Service. None of the three funding options offered were costed convincingly. Even before the consultation period had ended, both the government and then Conservative opposition had come up with proposals for some free social care. Again neither was part of a comprehensive or clearly costed reform of social care funding (Beresford, 2009). In March 2010, the government published its White Paper, Building the National Care Service, after getting the largest ever response to a social care consultation with more than 27,000 submissions (HM Government, 2010a). While the White Paper recommended the government’s comprehensive option for funding (dismissed by Conservative opposition as a ‘death tax’), it also proposed an all-party commission to explore social care funding which would rule nothing out, including funding from general taxation. Significantly a surprisingly large number of big third sector organisations, service user and carer organisations and other social care bodies had opted for this in their responses to the consultation. In May 2010, the new Coalition government similarly proposed establishing a commission on possible funding options for long-term care (HM Government, 2010b, p 30), the Dilnot Commission. Even before its report was published, without any significant new evidence having been collected, it ruled out the funding of social care from general taxation. So by the end of the first decade of the 21st century, funding for social care, the key basis for a
68
The funding of social care
sustainable system of social care, remained unresolved, with no clear or convincing proposals on offer or solutions in sight.
Social care funding problems The issue of social care funding is one that politicians and policymakers have been very reluctant to acknowledge, let alone address. The pressure has been to make ‘efficiency’ and ‘productivity’ savings by working in different ways and to emphasise and rely on the financial contribution which service users themselves can make. This has been framed as a ‘partnership model’ of lending, with contributions from both the state and service user. What is crucial to recognise about social care is that in principle it remains a residual public service, access to which is determined on the basis of available funding rather than need and that this also varies, according to local circumstances, because it is still the responsibility of local authorities. In this sense there is a direct continuity with the 19th-century Poor Law which is not reflected in any other public policy (Cozens, 2003). It is also totally at odds with the universalist philosophy which continues to underpin the National Health Service, which is still significantly ‘free at the point of delivery’ and funded by general taxation. Examining the funding of social care, the national Commission on Personalisation set up by Hampshire County Council, drawing on the wide range of evidence it received, set out a disturbing picture for social care reform: Respondents stated that, for people who currently receive publicly-funded help, often only the most basic personal care needs are being met. If inadequate funding is supplied to meet needs there is a danger that people who have personal budgets will have to further stretch their resources to meet their priority needs, restraining or reducing their quality of life. Furthermore, evidence submitted supports the conclusion that, unless there are national changes made to how care is funded, personalisation will only be achievable for a minority as fewer and fewer people qualify for publicly funded social care. The difficulty that local authorities will have in reconciling the opportunity for choice with insufficient funds and eligibility criteria could mean even the most reasonable and modest needs of 69
Supporting people
people will continue to not be met. (Hampshire County Council, 2008, p 33) Our focus here is specifically on funding in relation to person-centred support. Social care’s funding problems were the barrier to personcentred support which service users, practitioners and managers most frequently identified. Their comments highlight both the concerns they had about funding now and how these affect their attitudes and approach towards the future. They raised a number of key issues in relation to funding. These particularly related to: • • • • • • •
inadequate funding concerns about future funding funding difficulties being used as an excuse rationing and restricting access to support restricting the range of support paying for social care the negative consequences of charging for support
A picture emerges of how the funding problems associated with social care affect it and create barriers at all levels. They create barriers for social care policy, for particular services, for services for different groups and for people’s individual lives and support.
Inadequate funding Most of the people we spoke to, service users, practitioners and managers, said that there was insufficient funding for their service to work in a person-centred way. Many spoke of a gradually worsening situation that was making it more difficult for services to work in this person-centred way. This shortage of funding left many people feeling dispirited and negative. Frequently service users and practitioners talked of feeling that funding issues were outside their control and that they were unable to influence or change the situation their services were in. They communicated a strong sense of resignation that funding was insufficient and that there was nothing that they could do to alter this. Their comments reflect both their strong sense of the objective inadequacy of social care funding and the sense of powerlessness and frustration it resulted in, as a barrier they couldn’t overcome. It all comes down to funding doesn’t it? We don’t have any control over any of that. Service user 70
The funding of social care
All it is, is cut-backs, cut-backs or no money available…. There is a lack of funds here to pay for these things and that is that. Service user It is a very difficult situation isn’t it, funding? It boils down to that in the end, because the government makes so much money available to each council and then the council has to work out what their priorities are. It seems to me that the disabled and old people are at the bottom of the list. Service user
This powerlessness and resignation was not just felt by service users, as this comment by a manager shows. I mean we’ve still got some of the very traditional day services for people with learning [difficulties] and we’re massively under-resourced. I mean if you’re supporting a group of 12 how can you possibly support that group in a person-centred way, you know? And I know sometimes it’s more than that, and that comes down to funding, it comes back down to funding. Manager
People talked about the effects social care’s underfunding could have on service users’ lives. Some felt that the issue of funding for social care should be highlighted more than it was, to challenge policymakers and the government. I think it is all about funding because I think elderly care is under-funded anyway, drastically. I think they are the bottom of the pile really. I think it is a bugbear with nursing homes, with managers and nurses. I think when we worked it out we are paid about £1.50 an hour to deliver the care, so I think we are drastically under-funded. Practitioner We have to accept that [money is limited] but it doesn’t mean we don’t challenge it when we see ways of improving services within the existing finance situation. But we have to challenge the under-funding that goes on in this country for services too. Carer
A service user explained how funding cuts affected a service that he used. 71
Supporting people
It’s what we’ve been forced into because of the lack of funding. We’re not allowed to [go on holiday]. There’s not a big social budget anymore. It’s more like the support on offer is for people to get their shopping, cooking in, just the day to day necessities…. The holiday’s luxury. And also going out socialising is a luxury which, you know, for some people it’s really not, because they are very isolated and it’s a quality of life. Particularly maybe for somebody with quite a severe learning difficulty, it is very hard for them to go out into the community and get friends and go round and about. Service user
Several of the services participating in our project had experienced great financial insecurity. Frequently services were reliant on shortterm funding which could result in new services disappearing before they were properly established. Things that are promised to you … they arrive but they never last. Service user The services are set up in the beginning with great ideas and intentions, but all of them not followed through right to the end, or cut short due to money. Practitioner
A different view A minority of services, however, said money was not a problem for them and that concerns about a lack of money did not influence the service they provided. In my project I haven’t really found money a problem, it’s really good on that side. Practitioner Well I think we are quite lucky really because we are a charitybased organisation. We get our funding, our managers get our funding, so we don’t worry about targets or anything like that. Basically we work one-to-one with a client and we help them to meet their aspirations. Our aim is to get them into full-time or part time employment, as long as they want to work then that is the criteria for working with them. Practitioner
72
The funding of social care
What we can’t know from this is whether they had simply been fortunate so far in terms of financial allocations and priorities and whether this might change. Managers of these services, however, were aware of the financial hardship faced by many other services. They consequently feared that their services’ financial position might deteriorate in the future. You’re worried that someone will say ‘See how you do with half the staff.’ Manager
Concerns about future funding Funding emerged as a cause for concern both for the present and for the future. Social care is overshadowed by the insecurity of its funding. Several of the services we worked with expressed major worries about securing funding in the future to continue to operate their services. In Downhampton the independent self-advocacy group was funded by the local authority and short-term charitable grants. This led to a great deal of work for the manager who helped set the group up, making funding applications and trying to find suitable funders. It meant that the workers were on short-term contracts and lacked job security. It could result in workers’ roles having to change in order that the service could meet the requirements of a new funder. A manager from another service said: I think it’s definitely important to get the big funders and government … for them to buy into person-centred services as well because I know unfortunately, especially in the charity sector a lot of it does come down to funding, and if you don’t have the funding you just can’t operate. Manager
One practitioner explained how new projects were launched with lots of publicity, started brightly, but subsequently closed without becoming established. In our organisation we had a project called PCP [personcentred planning] with a limited amount of funding. It feels like very often what happens is that a new initiative has been funded and everything is all gung-ho. It gets rolled out – it seemed very quickly – and the university was asked to make a study of it, before anyone really understood or was given time to have the training to implement it. Then the funding 73
Supporting people
is pulled away and another initiative will slowly go to dust. It feels like just maintaining something would be really good rather than this flurry of new ideas. Practitioner
She went on to say that another problem with new initiatives was that practitioners could be expected to implement them without additional resources. It feels like we were talking the talk but not walking the walk. Somehow it was all very exciting, a lot of flurry, but on the ground level, no money, no time. We were still meant to carry on our normal job and incorporate this. We can’t just carry on all of our work, plus introduce something that’s very new. Practitioner
A manager of a nursing home described the difficulties created by shortterm funding agreements linked with ongoing cash-flow problems. I think if you talk to nursing home managers wherever, they will say … you are waiting, sometimes the resident could be dead before you get your contract and get any money. Manager
Another manager highlighted the problems arising from the short-term nature of funding streams within social services for effectively planning for and meeting service user’s needs: We don’t know if it [Partnership for Older People Projects – POPPS] will continue. That’s a barrier. If it’s funded for x amount of time, how do you carry on? I think there may be an evaluation and a decision about which projects are successful but they may be discontinued…. Departments having to bid for resources which may be time limited. If your bid isn’t successful, you don’t get the funding. Is that any way to manage social care? Manager
Seeking creative solutions This lack of money had encouraged some people to work even harder to find ways of making services more person-centred. Many of these solutions relied on competing more successfully for resources and working more closely together. 74
The funding of social care
It pushes you into being very creative as a worker – as long as your creative ideas are … more cost effective than other things. Practitioner
In Middleshire, for example, some support services were cut back during the course of the project. In some cases, where support was no longer available for leisure activities, service users started to do things themselves and supported each other, so that the result was actually positive. By offering each other mutual support, service users were able to carry on activities that they would only previously have done with the support of care workers. This led to an increase in the service users’ confidence in their own abilities. We’re happy without the staff around – we enjoy ourselves. Service user I feel better without the staff. Service user
Creativity, of course, on its own, was not always enough. You can try to be creative as much as possible but if they [service users] are not given the opportunity and the right time to do it, then you can’t do it and it’s frustrating. Not known
Partnership working Working in partnership with other services and organisations could help stretch limited resources and use them more effectively. It could also help in: • • • • • •
Making new contacts Integrating with local communities Learning about each other Increasing local knowledge Pooling resources Developing a shared vision and approach
Participants said: We are linked with different churches in the area. We have a part time chaplaincy coordinator based here, which is a really 75
Supporting people
brilliant role and her role is to look at each tenant and their different faith needs, if they have them, or different spirituality needs and work with individuals that way. She also works to link people with a befriender, so we are gradually building up a group of volunteers. Manager There’s also a lot of support offered by the church and a lot of the groups are based in the churches in [Grandshire] and they are proactive but in a very non-evangelical kind of way. There’s a kind of network of the churches being opened and they do things like luncheon clubs and support groups for people with mental health issues, drop in clubs and things like that. Practitioner We spend a lot of time working on community-based initiatives and working in partnership with other organisations like adult education and the voluntary sector. And we have found that is a good way because quite often people will give time rather than money and staff commitment is not all on one person. So we do a lot of partnership work with other agencies. We are setting up community groups and getting funding through various streams, there is regeneration where I work, so there is often money that is linked to regeneration and community-based groups. So we try to encourage people to set up groups that they actually have power in, I know that is very difficult when you are not a key service. But for those clients we work with in the community, we encourage them to set things up in their own backyard, because you have got no travel implications then. Also you are not isolating anyone, so it is about creating that sense of community. It is something that is a little bit more sustainable. Practitioner
CASE STUDY FUNDING PROBLEMS INHIBITING PERSONCENTRED SUPPORT This case study highlights the destabilising effects for both services and service users of unsatisfactory financial arrangements and how these get in the way of person-centred support. This residential service for people with
76
The funding of social care learning difficulties in Wendlbury was provided by an independent charitable provider. It had been in existence for over 20 years. However, its main funder, the local adult services department, no longer paid enough to fully fund the service. The provider was therefore operating the service at a financial loss – subsidised by its other services for older people. In addition to this, the provider had come to recognise that the service was ‘an outdated model’ and that major re-structuring and re-modelling were required for it to become person-centred and offer what its residents want. Even though we have money to build and alter the building, we still didn’t have any guarantee from social services for the funding…. Social services hasn’t got a problem with what we deliver. Their problem is that they can’t pay for it. Manager We can’t actually go anywhere without the commissioners coming with us. [We have said to them] ‘Look, we recognise your financial restraints. We recognise that this may take some time to develop. We recognise that we may have to do it one piece at a time. But we need you to be committed and we need to start putting down some time-scales that this work is going to happen.’ Manager They are fundamentally committed to change but they do have a major financial problem. Manager The service was unsure how to move from existing arrangements to new ones, given the need for a period of transition and the lack of financial support from the local authority. How logistically we move from one model to another…. We can’t not fill vacancies because the unit costs would go through the roof. Manager The trust providing the service was facing a difficult balancing act. It wanted to redevelop its service, while offering continuity and support to service users. However, it was making a financial loss and had no guarantee that the local authority would agree to fund the proposed new arrangements. It was loathe to threaten to withdraw the service as it knew the distress this would cause to service users and their families. [Giving the council notice] wouldn’t be the best way of doing it. We have the right to say ‘no,’ and the council have the legal responsibility
77
Supporting people for services to these people. [Residents only have a licence agreement so technically the trust only have to give them a month’s notice.] So that is the apocalyptic scenario. Manager Service users, on the other hand had been left wondering whether the proposed changes would ever take place and expressed resignation that this was a financial matter that was outside their control. Whether it will happen or not is a different thing. I don’t know. A lot depends on the money. Service user Seems to me it will all boil down to money. Service user
Funding difficulties being used as an excuse Not everyone thought that inadequate funding was the main problem for social care. A small number of people questioned whether it was always the real reason why a service failed to help. Some service users thought that there were times when they had been told that this was why they couldn’t do something, but they didn’t believe it. They thought that money was sometimes used as an excuse and that the actual explanation might have more to do with the service provider itself. Thus a service user who was waiting to move from a residential home to shared accommodation was left not knowing why her plans could not go ahead. They said it’s down to money…. [They’re] passing the buck. You don’t know what’s been said. Service user
One practitioner saw the solution as being more inventive in how budgets were used: It’s not about money and time. It’s about what you do with the money you’ve got and being creative about it…. Like I say, you don’t necessarily need a lot of money to go on holiday. You can find a holiday in the same area. Practitioner
A manager with experience of supporting voluntary sector organisations said finding funds came down to having the skills to make successful applications – and to perseverance.
78
The funding of social care
There is a huge amount of money out there. You just have to have the skills, or you have to know people who do have the skills, to put the funding application together… It is there and you have just got to be prepared.... [Funding] is a barrier you have to get over. You can’t just say, ‘There is no funding, so therefore we can’t.’ You say ‘There is no funding from this source. Where can we access it?’ Manager
Rationing and restricting access to support Here we move from the funding of social care policy and social care services, to the allocation of support to individual service users. There are two aspects to this. These are determining eligibility to receive support and what people have to pay for it, or ‘charging’, as it has come to be called. Thus the potential service user is subject to two assessments; a needs assessment and a financial assessment. We begin with the first of these, needs assessment, which employs a series of ‘eligibility criteria’. Access to any form of social care support: domiciliary, day care or residential support, has been conditional on being assessed as ‘in need’ of it. Because social care is not a universal service available to all and to which all are entitled, a rationing system based on such eligibility criteria has been developed to determine who should receive support from the state. From 2003 this was based on the government’s Fair Access to Care Services (FACS) framework (DH, 2003). This was intended to standardise the assessment criteria for social care services on a national basis. The stated aim was to increase transparency and consistency while taking account of local circumstances and the funding available for social care. While the assessment criteria are standardised, the system allows local authorities to decide which of the four levels of need to meet (critical, substantial, moderate or low). The criteria are overseen by managers who are ultimately responsible for financial decisions. Restricting entitlement to support We encountered widespread and great concern that the eligibility criteria for services had become increasingly restrictive. Therefore fewer people qualified for services. The level of service provided to those who did qualify had decreased and become more focused on basic personal care, like washing, toileting and dressing. More applications for services were turned down by funding panels. People seen as needing ‘low-level’ 79
Supporting people
support had come to be identified as having low eligibility. Two things quickly become apparent. Judgements were primarily budget-driven, rather than based on professional experience and discretion. We met many service users who were receiving a scaled back, lower level of service than they had received in the past. It seems to be only the people that are almost on their death beds, that hit the top criteria, who get what they want. Service user Social services don’t come on board quickly. They wait until the last resort and then they help. You are crying out for help and they are not helping you. Service user Services are getting better but they are cutting back the whole time. If they had more money available they could have more services, but because they are cutting back, there are less hours of care, less services available. What we hear from social work, because of these cutbacks, social workers are given an idea of what they can spend and how to prioritise. But we don’t know what our situation will be because of the changes. Service user
Participants’ concerns are supported by findings of the Commission for Social Care Inspection (CSCI). These have highlighted the poor quality of life of many people seen as ineligible for public support for social care, as well as inconsistencies in who was assessed as ineligible both within and between councils. The tightening of eligibility thresholds has had an effect on the level of non-residential services provided by councils, particularly home care. Since 1997, the numbers of households receiving supported home care has fallen from 479,000 to 358,000 in 2006, though the number of total hours has increased (because the average number of hours that each eligible person receives has increased). It is estimated that, were all councils to set their eligibility thresholds at ‘substantial’ and ‘critical’, the average provision of council-supported home care would fall by just under 20%. (CSCI, 2008a, p 20)
80
The funding of social care
Restricting eligibility thresholds in this way is what has subsequently been happening more and more. Social work practitioners spoke of their frustration at making assessments and applying for funding only for their applications to be turned down. One of the shortcomings of the traditional social care system (in contrast to a system based on personalisation and individual budgets) has been seen as the limitations of professional assessment. What becomes apparent from our project is that assessment is shaped by financial and managerialist concerns, rather than those of professionals, which have been subordinated. Arbitrary and increasing restrictions on people’s access to support are clearly working against the operation and development of personcentred support. We have got things that enable it to be more person-centred, like direct payments and the ILF [Independent Living Fund] things like that, but we are very restricted in terms of funding we can get…. We do have difficulty in getting agreement for resources. We are very limited on that and that is getting more and more difficult. So that, I think, then affects the ability for the person to be more in control and have more of what they might want for themselves…. It can be a battle. Practitioner
Several participants were clear why they felt applications for services were being denied. They said that funding was being rationed by local authority managers to meet only the most basic needs. The problem with the assessment process is that often the guys at the top with the money say to the people who are doing the assessment, we have only got this amount of money, and they adjust the assessment according to that knowledge. Service user I think it’s impossible to work closely with social workers, it’s impossible for them to be person-centred, absolutely impossible because they do not have the resources to be able to do it, you know. Everything goes to panel now, and the money’s not there now and even the resources aren’t there. It’s so hard to get care and to allow the flexibility and choice that people would like. Manager
81
Supporting people
[Independent living] it’s expensive, so people end up in institutions like this [a day centre] for 20 years. It’s not a very healthy place to be. I mean it’s nice and we do our best. But you can’t do cooking for 10 years. You want to do something different but they can’t do what they want to do because of those money issues. Practitioner
One relative spoke about the struggle he and his wife had experienced in applying for a service from their local authority. This was timeconsuming and required enormous effort. He felt that the real problem had been a lack of money. I had to go back to social services and say,‘Look I’m not going to be able to look after my wife. Her personal care have got to be done in the morning and somebody needs to come in to sort out the food for the evening.’ It took me 18 months to get someone and it’s all down to money, budgets…. But, you know, 18 months though and I’m not the type of guy who will give up, and I’m on the phone virtually every other day to these people. And then at the end of the day, it was ‘We are going to have to look at your wife’s care plan to see,’ you know,‘what the budget can pay for,’ and they openly admitted, the guy did, that it was all down to money at the end of the day. I was even told once to give up work and look after my wife full time. Carer/relative
Restricting the range of support Local authorities were also restrictive in the kind of support that they offered service users. Service users spoke of their frustration about official definitions of care and support. Local authorities frequently regarded their role narrowly as funding personal care rather than social support more generally. This is clearly at odds with their social care responsibility, let alone with efforts to move to more flexible person-centred approaches to support. This emerged when individuals requested help for a task that the local authority did not view as ‘personal care’. A lot of the preventative work went out of the window: the shopping, the cleaning, the ironing, and so on. A classic case, a gentleman whose wife had Alzheimer’s disease, dementia, he wanted to do all the personal care like the toilet, cleaning, 82
The funding of social care
the mopping up when she wet herself, and the bathing and the dressing, and he wanted to do all that, but he really needed somebody to do the washing and the cleaning and the ironing because he wasn’t very good at that. But the rules said no, social services provides personal care,‘We don’t do washing, cleaning and ironing.’ Carer Now you get support going shopping. If you are lucky you will get support going to the doctor’s and that’s about it. We used to get support to go bowling, to go to the pictures and to go to play pool. You can’t do that any more. Service user
The conflict with person-centred support There was widespread frustration that while particular services and the people who managed and worked in them, might attempt to provide person-centred support, their efforts could repeatedly be frustrated by a local authority turning down, or deferring a decision about an application to extend an individual service user’s care package. This could prevent the service user making progress for want of support. One such example was of a service supporting a young man with learning difficulties, who they had found out, through using personcentred planning, wanted to work as a gardener. If their application for funding to provide one-to-one support to learn about gardening was turned down, his progress might be stalled. Under such circumstances both service users and practitioners involved felt frustrated because efforts to work in person-centred ways could not be progressed. Practitioners said: You can have the right values and go through a personcentred planning process, but it makes no difference if there is no funding to support the individual to work towards their goals. Manager Sometimes you are trying to use a person-centred approach and the resources around you don’t allow the person to move forward as they want. Practitioner The person-centred approach often is looking at a person’s aspirations, a person’s dreams, a person’s hopes. And you can do an assessment on that and then you can work out a plan of action and more often than not, it has to go to panel and 83
Supporting people
it is the panel who decides whether that person is eligible. The majority of our services now, we are not able to actually provide those services, they have to go to a panel. It is all to do with funding and keeping a cap on the amount of money the county are currently spending. So it has to go to panel and quite often you have to put an incredibly good case. And because the bar for people to be eligible for our service is so high, it makes it virtually impossible to do the person-centred approach, because what they want does not fall within the eligibility criteria of our service. Practitioner Yes, we are working very much towards [person-centred support], but one of the most difficult issues we all probably have to face is funding and while we like to be able to meet the particular personal needs, or aspirations of the people who we are working with, whether we can actually afford to meet those needs is another question. When we apply for services, we as workers are not able to just provide those services. It has to go to a panel. Our services’ application has to go to a panel and it is the panel who then will decide whether the services we have assessed that person as needing [will be provided]. So it is not straightforward. Practitioner The budget holders are who say yes or no. It doesn’t matter what work you have done and how much you advocate on someone’s behalf, if they say they haven’t got the money you can’t do it. Practitioner
This lack of flexibility and scope for practitioners to work creatively is frustrating and undermines professional judgement. This experience is supported by findings from the Commission for Social Care Inspection, which concluded in its annual report on social care that: Demand was often managed by tightening procedural guidelines to reduce scope for interpretation by front-line workers. (CSCI, 2008a, p 23) Local authority funding criteria often rule out services that aren’t seen as meeting critical or substantial need. This is likely to include preventive services which work with people who are seen as falling outside these criteria.
84
The funding of social care
We are having to cut away services that have been funded [for people seen as having low dependency]. But that’s short-sighted. If you cut out low dependency and moderate dependency services and only offer financial help for the critical then they are all going to be critical very, very shortly and you are going to have less money to go around, and I don’t understand why they don’t see that. Manager
The Commission for Social Care Inspection adds further evidence to this view based on research with six local authorities. None of the councils was happy with the situation and those that had gone furthest down the rationing route (such as in limiting eligibility to critical needs only) acknowledged this was an ultimately self-defeating solution which was unsustainable. (CSCI, 2008a, p 31) In one area we heard that day centre service users were anxious not to be reassessed because of concerns that they might then be told that they were no longer eligible for the service. The eligibility criteria for services had changed since they began attending the centre. They were worried they would either no longer be able to use the centre at all, or only use it on a more limited basis, for example, on two days a week instead of four. [Service users are] often locked into what days they come now. It’s historical, keep your head down and don’t try and change it because you might lose out. Once you put your head up, eligibility has been reduced and reduced, people here are not being assessed, so as soon as you put your hand up and say ‘I want something different,’ it’s ‘Oh hang on, you’re not really entitled to it [the day centre] either’. Practitioner I think a number of people think coming here [The Barry Centre] is the least worse option. They come because they think their partner needs a break. [They] just sit waiting in the corridor waiting to go home a lot of the time, they might say they would prefer something different but in the scheme of things they think keep their head down and stick with what they have. Practitioner
85
Supporting people
If you bring a spotlight on your situation you might end up with nothing. Practitioner
The national Hampshire County Council Commission on Personalisation concluded that the dominant feature of the current model of eligibility was ‘rationing people out of the system’ rather than ‘facilitating people to secure the care and support that they wanted’ (Hampshire County Council, 2008, p 56). In its own 2008 review of eligibility criteria commissioned by the government, the Commission for Social Care Inspection, concluded that the current system had fundamental failings (CSCI, 2008b). It also acknowledged wider concerns about the effect of inadequate social care funding on the system. The Commission concluded that the current system for determining eligibility was so flawed that it needed immediate reform, while in the longer term, social care funding needed to be increased. Perhaps the most important point that Commission for Social Care Inspection made in its review of the FACS-based system of eligibility criteria for social care was that they were strongly at odds with the government’s commitment to personalisation and the increased emphasis on prevention and general well-being. This is entirely consistent with the findings from our work, which highlight the mismatch between the existing eligibility system and person-centred support, creating major barriers in the way of providing flexible and imaginative responses to people’s rights and needs.
Paying for social care Eligibility criteria, however, are not the only obstacle restricting people’s access to state support for social care. Social care is also a means tested system. From its creation under the 1948 National Assistance Act, social care never offered a free service available to all who might need it. Instead provision in institutions continued to be the default position. As Julia Parker observed in 1965: [The National Assistance Act] made no attempt to provide any sort of substitute family life for old people who could no longer be supported by their own relatives. Institutional provision was accepted without question. (Parker, 1965, p 106)
86
The funding of social care
Unless people’s incomes and savings fall below the set level, they have to pay for domiciliary services. Homeowners have been expected to sell their homes to pay for residential care. Our project included people using residential, day care and domiciliary services. The media, charities and other critics of policy have particularly highlighted what they see as the low level of savings allowed before people have to pay for social care. This is seen as unfairly penalising people who have tried to be prudent and save for their old age (Hampshire County Council, 2008, p54). In our project, however, much more concern was expressed about charging in general than about levels of ‘disregard’. This may be because our project included many people without savings or a home of their own, as well as some who had one or both. From the creation of the welfare state, domiciliary services were never routinely available free. Applicants faced a means test which local authorities had considerable discretion to set. However, as Robin Means and others have shown, ‘the early 1970s did witness moves in a direction that was beginning to offer something close to a right to a service’ (Means et al, 2002, p 32). During the 1970s and first half of the 1980s much less attention was paid to charging (Means et al, 2002, p 33). Since 1983, however, local authorities have gradually extended charges for their community care services (DH, 1983). This came to be embodied in the 1990 National Health Service and Community Care Act as one of its key consumerist principles. Charges range from fees for transport to a day centre to charges for ‘home care’ services. They have come to constitute an increasing percentage of expenditure on adult social care services. Charging for local authority social services is more commonplace now (in 1985 the only common Local Authority charge was for meals on wheels – now 94 per cent of Local Authorities also charge for other home care services) (Audit Commission 2000). These charges vary widely so it is difficult to make a meaningful average (DRC, 2005). (Tibble, 2005, p 26) Councils recovered over £2 billion in fees and charges for social services in 2005-06 (14% of total gross adult care expenditure). (CSCI, 2008a, p 8)
87
Supporting people
The negative consequences of charging for support Participants in our project highlighted a range of problems caused by these charges. Increasing exclusion First were the particular difficulties they created for groups already recognised as being ‘hard to reach’ or ‘seldom heard’ and facing additional barriers, who were less likely to access social care services. This problem was epitomised by the experience of a service that worked with a marginalised group of service users in Downhampton. These were young people with learning difficulties from black and minority ethnic communities. The service was set up to meet the unmet need of people who weren’t accessing existing services. After much sensitive and time-consuming work, the services had made great progress in forming relationships with family carers and the young people. Uptake of services had gradually grown. However, the introduction of local authority charging for the services had discouraged participation in many families. Services said that in some cases the charges were jeopardising the preparatory work they had done. This threatened their ability to address the problem of low take-up of services among black and minority ethnic groups. Some people have stopped coming to [our service]. One reason is that some people have been asked to pay. Service user There’s a charging policy in Downhampton now. If [a service] accesses any transport, you get the money from the council and you have to pay I think it’s £2.85 a day. But because of that a number of our members have pulled out. You have to go back and really, you know, bring out all the work they’ve done and say this is what they’ve achieved. And, you know, it’s really hard work to get the parents on board, the guys and the girls still want to come. Practitioner Yeah. I think it’s important to communicate well with families…. They are introducing charges for people with learning disabilities, and especially where you’ve already got communication difficulties with families who do not speak English, when you introduce those charges … what tends 88
The funding of social care
to happen is the families tend to make the decision that they don’t want their family member to participate in any particular service which then means that the service user is no longer a service user and is basically confined to the home and doesn’t receive any community support or any peer support…. I think for some particularly disadvantaged groups, I think we need to be more creative. It’s about having support workers who can communicate effectively with the families, perhaps know their first language and perhaps build some trust with the family, so when these charges are introduced, they are in a position to explain things to the family rather than just introduce a charge and then give them a bill which obviously they don’t understand about. So it’s about building trust and trying to allay some of those fears that families have about the system. Manager What we’ve had to do is to support ethnic minority families because we’ve got a worker who can speak a community language. With regard to policy, we’ve had to send out that worker with the person who’s working out the figures as to how much the charges are and to visit those families where they don’t really understand the system and explain things, which does help matters. I think once they know what it’s all about, they are more willing to cooperate otherwise they just shut us out. So we had one instance where a couple of months ago the family said they didn’t want to send their family member because they didn’t want to pay. Now their family member has withdrawn from the support group and the advocacy group and that person themselves felt that they were losing out. So after a few months down the road, we organised a meeting with the family where we had somebody who could speak their language and we had the support group worker go, because they already knew that worker, to explain the charge. The family were really unhappy that somebody had originally come round and took [details] about their finances and said that the charge had to [be] levied and not explaining things fully. But this time there was a proper meeting and the families got their concerns and the anger about the charge off their chest and said ‘Yes it’s ok if our family member attends the support group now we’re clearer as to what the charge is all about.’ Manager
89
Supporting people
Discouraging independence The second problem local authority charges caused, affected service users who were in or wanted to find paid employment. Charging regimes frequently mean that service users gain little or no financial benefit from working, as their income has to be used as a contribution to their service. This barrier emerged as particularly damaging for people who lived in residential services or who lived independently, but had high support needs. It could also act as a major disincentive to being employed. Thus: One of the lads does work, even though he does lose a lot of the money he earns. He is just about £20 better off for working, the rest goes to his care. This would be the same if he were living in his own home with a care package. Manager I’ve got nothing practically. My wages get taken away and I get about £19 per week. I’m off incapacity benefit as well but I want to keep it going because it would drive me crazy [not to]. Service user
Imposing economic burdens The impact of charges for services was especially great for people on fixed and relatively low incomes. Many service users now had to pay a number of different charges made by different service providers. These were especially burdensome where services used to be free and people’s incomes hadn’t increased proportionately. Charging noticeably affects younger disabled people whose incomes are on average lower than non-disabled people. Disabled people of working age tend to have lower incomes than non-disabled people, as they are less likely to be in work (and have lower average wages than non-disabled people (DRC 2005)). (Tibble, 2005, p 26) Jenny Morris, the disability commentator has explained why disabled people are often in a disadvantageous economic position in comparison to non-disabled people, not least because of the additional costs of impairment.
90
The funding of social care
Disabled people generally do not acquire, through the labour market, enough purchasing power to meet their needs/additional requirements relating to independent living. There are two dimensions to this. a) Both impairment and disabling barriers mean that disabled people are less likely to be in paid employment, and less likely, if in employment, to be earning average or above average wages. They are also less likely to have savings, to be owner occupiers, or to have an occupational pension. b) It is more expensive to be disabled – i.e. impairment creates needs which can be costly to meet and disabling barriers of unequal access and negative attitudes can also lead to additional costs. (Morris, 2003, p 48) The extra financial pressure imposed by charging can also be a source of distress and embarrassment for those who struggle to find the money to pay. You get funded by your local council to go there [the day centre] and they just have this thing where you have to pay a pound a day. Now not everybody pays that, there are quite a few conners there and they don’t pay. I always do and I always find it embarrassing when I haven’t got the pound. I always say if I haven’t got it, ‘I want you to tick because I will pay you next time,’ and I always come in and pay. That is incredibly embarrassing for me. Service user
The expansion of charging Many service users gave examples of things that used to be free that they now had to pay a charge for, or even had to pay the full cost for. Some were concerned about their ability to meet these increased costs. Workers are not allowed to go out for a meal with us. They’re not allowed to go to the theatre or anything we want to go to. We’ve got to find friends to go with and if you haven’t got friends you don’t get to go out. They say go out with your friends, but I don’t quite feel safe. It just came out you know my friend who was at the meeting … they’ve got to pay for a meal now. I mean we never used to. Service user
91
Supporting people
Funding is a problem, there is talk of my respite ending. I will have to pay for it. Service user For instance we used to set up lots of groups in the community working with local education providers to provide courses and they were free, and it was encouraged by the central government, which then after a year or two they changed their mind and decided to fund it differently so it meant that our service users now had to pay for that service. Practitioner
Other examples given to us included: • • • •
meals in day centres transport to and from day centres respite care a talking-book service (for visually impaired people)
Many service users were using a range of different services, some from their local authority but others less formally, such as education classes or clubs. Each local authority has a different charging policy outlining their rules and procedures. Yet guidance issued by the Department of Health to promote consistency and fairness made clear that: It is not acceptable to make a charge on disability benefits without assessing the reasonableness of doing so for each user…. (DH, 2002, p 4) Regard should be paid to the effect of any charge on a user’s net income; net incomes should not be reduced below defined basic levels of Income Support or the Guarantee Credit of Pension Credit, plus 25%.... (DH, 2002, p 10) Charges for different types of non-residential social service, and allied services, and how they affect individuals should be considered together, not in isolation. (DH, 2002, p 3) Charging was not only denying some people support, but also restricted the lives of many others. Service users taking part in our project spoke about the effects that paying charges for services had on them.
92
The funding of social care
People have had to stop doing some things because they can’t afford them. This affects standards of living. Most members [of the day centre] have a fixed income, so having to pay for more and more means your pot gets smaller and smaller so it limits what you can do. It’s not just one thing, it’s everything. Service user Every time the government withdraws funding from something, if you wish it to carry on, it has to come out of your own pocket. You only have so much money, you’re either on benefits or old age pension … you can’t carry on paying for things. So some of the things you used to enjoy you have to finish, which is unfair. Service user
Transport Transport is an especially important example of the damaging effects charging can have, restricting service users’ human right to freedom of movement. Many service users face high transport costs in their everyday lives in comparison with the majority of the population. In their study Disabled people’s cost of living, Smith and others demonstrated the reasons for and levels of extra costs for transport experienced by disabled people. Because public transport is often inaccessible, many disabled people have to rely on specialist taxis, for example with wheelchair tail-lifts, or other specialist transport, which are more expensive than public transport. At the same time a disproportionate number of service users live on benefits or other fixed incomes, like pensions. Using the Government’s favoured poverty measure of living in a household with below 60 per cent of median household income, 29 per cent of households with at least one disabled adult were in poverty compared with only 17 per cent of those without a disabled adult. However, these statistics are based on income (including disability benefits) and do not take into account the additional extra costs disabled people incur because of their needs compared to those with no disability on similar incomes. (Smith et al, 2004, pp 80-1) Service users highlighted to us the problems created by the costs of travel:
93
Supporting people
It depends what we need, but we get a separate bill for that [transport] depending on how often we go out. If you don’t go out for a month, you don’t get a bill, but depending on how often we go out and you will get a bill. Service user Now you have to pay for transport to the hospital if you receive [Disability Living Allowance] Mobility Allowance. A single trip to hospital and back costs £30 and your allowance is £42 per week. Service user There are concerns that some people – those on the lower rate mobility component of Disability Living Allowance – may lose their entitlement to free bus travel and this is a worry to people. Service user
The scale of the problem The inadequate funding of social care and efforts to ration it through restricting eligibility for support, means testing and charging for it, have created massive barriers in the way of meeting people’s needs and securing their human rights. The present system has shifted the financial burden to service users and their carers. Figures on the national situation published by the Commission for Social Care Inspection confirm the experiences related in our research. Around half of the expenditure on personal social care for older people comes from private contributions, either from charges and top-ups for those receiving care with council financial support, or from spending on privately purchased care. It is estimated to be nearly £5.9 billion. This does not include the substantial contribution of resources from private individuals in the form of caring by families and friends. (CSCI, 2008a, p 19) Arrangements for social care funding thus create massive barriers in the way of the implementation of person-centred support at both policy and individual practice levels. The funding system is not consistent with achieving the key goals of person-centred support to increase people’s choice and control over their lives and support. It is difficult to see how initiatives to advance person-centred support can be rolled out to become mainstream practice until the present funding system is radically reformed. Crucially this seems to be because it rests on a 94
The funding of social care
deficit model of need, where people have to prove how little they can do to have any chance of qualifying for support. This is contrast to an approach based on independent living, where the qualification for support is that it enables people to live on as equal terms as possible as their non-disabled peers. As a result, state supported social care ‘has become restricted to an ever decreasing small group of recipients by the application of eligibility criteria and means tests’ (Hampshire County Council, 2008, p 50). While they clearly benefit from it, according to the Commission for Social Care Inspection, two other large groups have been created which are grossly disadvantaged. These are first, self-funders, who lacking appropriate advice, information, support and advocacy, are ending up inappropriately in disproportionate numbers in residential institutions. A second group ‘lost to the system’ because they do not qualify for support, although they have significant support needs,‘often struggle with fragile informal support arrangements and a poor quality of life’ (CSCI, 2008a, p 35).
Summary Service users, practitioners and managers identify the failings of social care funding as the biggest barrier to implementing and developing person-centred support. They report that the inadequate funding of social care restricts who can get support and the adequacy and appropriateness of support they receive. Financial limits not only inhibit current policy and practice, but also make it difficult to improve provision and to plan for the future. Some agencies and practitioners have developed creative ways of overcoming the financial barriers in the way of person-centred support, particularly through harnessing community resources, working more closely together, developing new roles and competing more determinedly and effectively for resources. But these initiatives do not appear to offer a secure or effective solution to the shortcomings of the existing finance system of social care more broadly at either individual or policy levels. The modern system of social care has meant that people have had to go through two sets of hoops to qualify for support. These entail both ‘needs’ and financial assessment. People’s entitlement has first been assessed through a system of narrowing eligibility criteria and then through means testing. These two systems have worked individually and together to exclude an increasing number of people from state
95
Supporting people
assistance for support. The social care system effectively operates to deny rather than offer people support. The growing number of people who fall outside the present system of eligibility criteria must make their own arrangements for support and pay privately. Everyone can expect to pay some level of charges and people with even modest savings must expect to meet the full cost themselves. This system works against the meeting of people’s rights and needs and particularly penalises some groups. It increases the costs of disability, encourages institutionalisation and works against independent living and person-centred support. References Beresford, P. (2009) ‘Social care, personalisation and service users: addressing the ambiguities’, Research, policy and planning, vol 27, no 2, pp 843-84. Cozens,A. (2003) ‘Taking down the fences: redefining social services in local government’, Inaugural speech, October, London: Association of Directors of Social Services. CSCI (Commission for Social Care Inspection) (2008a) The state of social care in England 2006-07, London: CSCI. CSCI (2008b) Cutting the cake fairly: CSCI review of eligibility criteria for social care, London: CSCI. DH (Department of Health) (1983) The Health and Social Services and Social Security Adjudications Act, London: The Stationery Office. DH (2002) Fairer charging policies for home care and other non-residential social services, London: DH. DH (2003) Fair Access to Care Services: Guidance on eligibility criteria for adult social care, London: DH. Hampshire County Council (2008) Getting personal: A fair deal for better care and support,The report of Hampshire County Council’s Commission of Inquiry into personalisation and the future of adult social care, November, Winchester: Hampshire County Council. HM Government (2009) Shaping the future of care together, Green Paper, London: The Stationery Office. HM Government (2010a) Building the national care service, London:The Stationery Office. HM Government (2010b) The coalition: Our programme for government, London: Cabinet Office. Means, R., Morbey, H. and Smith, R. (2002) From community care to market care? The development of welfare services for older people, Bristol: The Policy Press.
96
The funding of social care
Morris, J. (2003) ‘Barriers to independent living: a scoping review for the Disability Rights Commission’, Unpublished (available at www. leeds.ac.uk/disability-studies). Parker, J. (1965) Local health and welfare services, London:Allen & Unwin. Smith, N., Middleton, S.,Ashton-Brooks, K. and Cox, L. (2004) Disabled people’s cost of living: More than you would think,York: Joseph Rowntree Foundation. Tibble, M. (2005) Review of existing research on the extra costs of disability, London: Department for Work and Pensions. Wanless, D. (2006) Securing good care for older people: Taking a long-term view, London: King’s Fund.
97
FOUR
The social care workforce Good standards of practice and care will only be achieved if organisations have a learning culture which supports the training and development of staff. At an organisational level these developments address structures, culture, systems, human resources and leadership. At an individual level this means keeping up to date through training and post-registration training and learning. If training and development needs are linked to organisational and individual priorities this supports the ongoing enhancement of quality and safety. (Simmons, 2007, p 16)
We have an ageing workforce in council services, particularly direct services, particularly in the biggest growth area – caring…. In the next decade a third of them will be gone. (John Ransford, Chief Executive, Local Government Association, Guardian Public Services Summit, 5 February 2009) STANDARD FOUR: WORKFORCE
The wages, terms and conditions of practitioners should be improved to ensure a reliable, sustainable and good quality workforce equipped to work in person-centred ways. They need to be suitably trained, supported and supervised and their views and experience should be valued.
Introduction In this chapter we focus on the social care workforce. Practitioners are a vital element in social care and their role is clearly crucial in the move to and provision of person-centred support. Here we look 99
Supporting people
more closely at how this workforce is treated and how consistent this may be with moves to person-centred support. The basic data about the social care workforce have been widely reported and are widely seen as cause for concern. While it is difficult to define accurately, the workforce is estimated to number about one-and-a-half million people. It ranges from professional social workers with statutory powers to restrict people’s rights and freedom, to residential and domiciliary workers who are hourly paid. Two thirds of workers work in private or voluntary organisations. The workforce is located in a wide range of policy areas, including housing and health, as well as in specific social care services. Overall the social care workforce has been associated with low pay and poor terms and conditions of work (CSCI, 2008). These are often equated with those of supermarket shelf-stackers and check-out workers (but often with less favourable hours and working conditions). The largest sector of employment, the private sector, also tends to offer the lowest pay and conditions, with wages frequently at or near the minimum wage. Private employers highlight that this is because of the low levels of financial support state funding offers. These are issues that are clearly linked with the problematic funding of social care discussed in the last chapter. The workforce is also linked with major problems of recruitment and retention. It includes disproportionate numbers of women, members of black and minority ethnic communities and also more recently, migrants, particularly from Eastern Europe. Alternative more flexible employment opportunities have become available to women reducing their availability as an adequate pool of labour for ‘caring’ tasks. It is an ageing workforce. Social care has served for many recruits as an entry point to the labour market. For many members it is seen as a temporary job rather than an ongoing career. While the demand for social care workers is expected to rise significantly, with growing demands for support from a growing population of service users, particularly older people, there are serious concerns about being able to maintain even the present supply. It is also important to remember that the social care workforce, both through its nature and status, is neither a powerful nor strongly organised one. Issues of powerlessness and inequality are important for its members, just as they are for the many groups of service users they are intended to support. The route the government has taken in public policy, including social care, to achieve satisfactory services, has been to identify, monitor and regulate ‘standards’. The government has set such standards for the registration and inspection of social care services, most significantly 100
The social care workforce
in the National Care Standards Act (2000). These standards include the training and supervision of social care workers. For example, the National Minimum Standards Regulations for Domiciliary Care state that: Newly appointed care or support workers delivering personal care who do not already hold a relevant care qualification are required to demonstrate their competence and register for the relevant NVQ [National Vocational Qualification] in care award (either NVQ in Care level 2 or level 3) within the first six months of employment and complete the full award within three years. (DH, 2003a, p 33) On the subject of supervision, these standards set out that: All staff [should] meet formally on a one to one basis with their line manager to discuss their work at least [every three months] and written records [should be] kept on the content and outcome of each meeting. (DH, 2003a, p 34) The standard for supervision set out in the National Minimum Standards Regulations for Care Homes for Adults (18-65) is more often, at six times a year (DH, 2003b, p 93). However, the findings of recent research on training and support for social care workers are far from encouraging: Training opportunities are inequitable for different frontline workers. There is also a lack of consensus about the impact of training on practice. (Innes et al, 2006, p x) In this chapter, we look at arrangements for the training, support and supervision of practitioners in the wide range of services that took part in our project. We learn from the views of practitioners working in social care themselves. We also hear what they have to say about the pay and status of social care work in modern Britain. The chapter ends by reviewing the changing roles of social care workers, particularly those of qualified social workers. We examine the possible impact of a less qualified workforce and offer a case study of this process.
101
Supporting people
Training Almost invariably, when something goes wrong in social work or social care; there is a tragedy, neglect or abuse, then the need for more training is stressed in the public post mortem that follows. Training is highlighted as a key route to improved practice and provision, although often the nature of that training and how it is related to other issues and pressures is not discussed.
The importance of training In our project, training was not only identified as key for personcentred support. A range of issues were also highlighted as crucial. These included: • • • •
A commitment to training Service user involvement in training The value of reflective practice Addressing black and minority ethnic issues in training
Many participants – service users, managers and practitioners – spoke about the importance of training for social care workers. It is not just staff pay rates but their training opportunities that benefit our service users. Informed staff are better staff. Practitioner
However, the overall picture still seems at best patchy. Most practitioners felt they had received good general training and were well equipped to perform their role. Much of this training prepared staff for taking a National Vocational Qualification, a requirement of the National Care Standards. Although 19% of the social care workforce has no qualifications, two thirds of the workforce has achieved National Vocational Qualification level 2 or above (Skills for Care, 2007, p 47). But a small number of practitioners expressed concerns about services where practitioners do not have sufficient training and how this can affect the users of the services they work for. The government should be more involved in private homes. The staff aren’t well trained. If you know what goes on in a person with dementia’s mind then you have more patience
102
The social care workforce
and understand. But if you don’t have any training, then you aren’t going to know, so it makes it difficult. Practitioner I think to overcome these issues we need more training, you know. I am fortunate that I get all the training I should be getting for me to be able to be comfortable to my job, but [it is important] to get in places where people don’t get any training. That lack of knowledge is obviously very dangerous if you’re doing the work that you do, because it means you need to keep up with things. Practitioner
Some participants spoke about the need for practitioners to have particular skills or knowledge when working with particular groups of service users, for example, people with dementia or people approaching the end of life. They spoke about how crucial high quality training was in equipping practitioners successfully to carry out their work, enabling them to offer a high quality, individualised service to service users. The ongoing treatment of dementia patients when they go into hospital by the care staff [is a problem]. They do not know how to deal with people’s dementia. That is a basic human right for dementia people who have no control over themselves in a sense, you know, and their human rights are being undermined all the time. Their [impairments], the way they are looked after and cared for – all those things [indicate that] there is a lot of work to be done. Carer/relative I think the staff could do with some support, it is difficult to teach it isn’t it, but some input into how do staff broach this subject [the end of a person’s life], (a) with someone who is very ill and (b) with someone who is quite lively really and think they have come for a social life, which I think some of them do. And there is the time factor. It is a very time consuming thing to do, [but] it is essential. Manager
People working at New Chance explained the positive impact that training had had in their organisation. The training and accompanying resources were part of New Chance’s programme implementing personcentred planning across their service. This training had been offered nationally with the aim of reaching all New Chance’s practitioners.
103
Supporting people
[The training guide] is a very good resource, very positive with a good use of examples. Most staff have at least attended a workshop/taster session about PCP [person-centred planning]. Manager My operations manager has recently given us lots of training on how to formulate the initial support plan so that it can be changed and reviewed with the client at the centre. As a team of people we look at the different angles of how problems can be resolved. Practitioner
One senior practitioner in a nursing home, whose job included training new workers, explained that her approach was based simply on treating service users in a considerate and caring way. Some of the residents are not able to tell you what they want but … I always teach, or encourage the carers who I work with to nurse the residents as they would like to be nursed themselves. Or if you have got a grandmother just think of how you would like them to be nursed. Practitioner
A particular problem can affect training in independent sector home care agencies, since their staff are often paid only for time spent actually delivering a service (Patmore, 2003, pp 7-8). Staff may not necessarily obtain payment for time spent in training and it may thus be harder to engage staff in the latter.
A commitment to training One manager spoke about the importance of being committed to the value of training. She highlighted the issue of training being taken seriously as part of the overall operation of the organisation. She said that services must be prepared to commit resources to a programme of training for it to be delivered effectively and for practitioners to gain the maximum benefit. If practitioners were to take advantage of training opportunities, then these had to be offered at suitable times, not squeezed in between existing shifts. This approach to training shows a commitment to the quality of the service and demonstrates that the service values its workforce. She gave an example of how this could go wrong:
104
The social care workforce
Yeah and there needs to be a commitment to staff as well. It was a bit like I was talking about yesterday, I went to the training with five people, two of them worked the night before and were working that night and [then] they were on a full day’s training. Manager
Several other participants spoke in similar terms about recognising that successful training requires more commitment than just arranging training sessions. They suggested that training about person-centred support will only be successful if it is part of a wider strategy for its implementation. Members of the partnership promoting personcentred planning in Middleshire expressed concerns that training in itself was not effective if the ideas and practices learned were not implemented. They were worried that despite having training in person-centred planning, many services in their area had not put it into practice. This was also a concern at New Chance where managers believed practitioners had resisted the changes required to implement person-centred planning and acted as a barrier to person-centred working.
Service user involvement in training Participants from several services spoke in positive terms about their experiences of service users being involved in training for practitioners. They advocated these approaches and said they had enhanced the training, leading to closer and more equal relationships between practitioners and service users. Service user involvement is embedded in all training. Whatever [workers] are being trained on, there is a service user aspect. It is the theme that runs through it all whether it is moving and handling or food hygiene, there is a service user involvement element to it all, it is woven through everything. Manager … [What] we have found is that [training courses] are far more powerful when we involve the person being supported along with their supporter. So what we try to do is to talk about person-centred planning, person-centred approaches so that people can develop their plans together…. And the whole thing is a lot more powerful that way we find because everyone is involved and all the choices are from the person 105
Supporting people
being supported but together with the supporter. We just find people working together is a better way of doing it. Manager [We have recently been running] courses working round how can people have more of a voice…. We found with our first sets of courses … that we didn’t involve the service users on the course and the supporters were going away and working with the service users back in the home. And we found that [this] was problematic because although they were working together, it wasn’t really a shared experience, and they didn’t really get the idea of person-centred, so they did PCP [person-centred planning] but they weren’t mentally doing it. So we started to do courses where the supporter comes in but, also the service user comes in as well. Not necessarily every single session but they are working together with us at the same time. It is quite challenging and it is harder to do it but at the same time we are finding it is much better in terms of bringing the ideas together and working together towards a shared experience. It is effective but it is harder and there have been some good results from it. Manager
The value of reflective practice Person-centred support is an interactive process, which actively involves the service user. This highlights the importance of an approach to training consistent with this, which treats the worker as an active agent both in the process of learning and in the organisation. This was reflected in the comments of one manager who spoke about another element of learning that could improve services. We train staff to do the job but not to reflect on our own practice and the way they work. Manager [The induction for new staff has changed]…. Part of it is about person-centred approaches, not planning. The message I want to get across is that you don’t have to go on a fiveday course to learn person-centred planning, to work in a person-centred way. You can do something small tomorrow that can have a huge impact. Manager
106
The social care workforce
The idea of encouraging reflective practice is a positive way of involving practitioners actively in the evaluation and development of services. By being asked to contribute to the improvement of the service they work in, practitioners’ opinions are being recognised as valuable. This in turn can help to make practitioners feel valued, as well as drawing in their valuable contributions to benefit the service and in turn the service user.
Addressing black and minority ethnic issues in training The only black service user living in one residential unit spoke about what she saw as a weakness in the training of practitioners working in this service. Her comment raised wider concerns about the cultural awareness of the service and how person-centred the support it offered was. I wish there was some more, I’m not having a go at the staff, but I wish there was a course in looking after black skin. If they had thought about it before I moved in that would have been fine. Service user
If a service is working in person-centred ways, then service users’ needs will be considered on an individual basis. A person-centred approach should be based on the needs of individual service users. The needs raised by an individual might prompt a service to add to, or alter its training for practitioners, for example in race equality or cultural awareness, but solutions for individuals will be arrived at on an individual basis, located within an equalities and antidiscriminatory framework. It is likely that deficiencies in a service’s approach to person-centred support may be exposed by failures fully to accommodate a service user’s cultural needs. We found that although services might be working towards person-centred support, there were frequent examples of their failure to achieve this ambition. It should not be forgotten that social care services are as likely as other services or organisations to be guilty of institutionalised racism.
Supervision and support Supervision is a key tool in ensuring accountability, support, learning, professional development and service development. Social work has a tradition of supervision which addresses 107
Supporting people
the outcomes for service users, support for the worker in complex work and decision-making, the professional development of the worker and the development of the wider service. (Simmons, 2007, p 17) Supervision and support emerged as equally important for practitioners as training. Formal supervision can be seen as part of a broader process of ensuring that practitioners have experienced and expert assistance, on an ongoing basis, to deal with the professional, organisational, emotional, ethical and other issues relating to the successful undertaking of their role. In Staff supervision in social care Morrison identifies eight drivers for supervision (Morrison, 2005, p 19). Along with standards set by professional bodies, he cites greater integration between services demanding more complex staff roles, employer liability for duty of care to staff and the speed and stresses of change. He concludes that supervision only improves outcomes for service users and adds value for staff, if it has clarity of purpose, emotional competence and is service user-centred. Clearly if the aim is to maintain good practice or support staff to work in different more person-centred ways, we can expect that adequate supervision and support will be at a premium. Supervision can take many forms. It may mean one-to-one meetings between a worker and a supervisor and sometimes group meetings. It can mean regular meetings, perhaps weekly or monthly, or even annually, or it may take the form of ad hoc trouble-shooting sessions. There are an enormous variety of approaches to supervision, which can be more and less supportive to staff (Patmore, 2003, pp 2837). Home care supervisors sometimes covertly follow a worker, calling at service users’ homes minutes after the worker has departed, to assess results. Methods like this in part reflect the difficulty in supervising staff through meetings if, as is common in independent sector home care, neither provider nor purchaser will pay for the supervisee’s time (Patmore and McNulty, 2005, pp 60-1). Staff understandably often decline unpaid supervision sessions. A depersonalised form of supervision through observation of staff is now possible using a recently marketed technology. Using telephoneactivated, automated monitoring systems, the actual work routine of a home care worker is continuously compared by a computer with the routine programmed by managers. Whenever the former deviates from the latter, an email to a manager is triggered automatically (Patmore and McNulty, 2005, pp 64-5). Such an approach could hardly be further removed from the ideals of supportive supervision which participants in our study highlighted. The final report of the Social Work Task 108
The social care workforce
Force highlighted the limits of supervision and support for qualified social workers (Social Work Task Force, 2009). We can expect that the situation for unqualified staff is likely to be worse.
The unreliability of supervision and support Practitioners reported very different experiences of supervision and support. This was closely linked with how valued they felt in their work. There were examples of organisations and services which offered frequent supervision and where practitioners felt valued as part of an effective team. All staff have supervision and annual appraisal which is an opportunity to plan their own personal development, learning etc. There is a lot of training on offer, a lot of in-house training. Staff have to have NVQ [National Vocational Qualification] level 3. Manager
However, there were also cases where staff did not feel supported or valued. This picture is backed up by a national survey which suggests that nearly a quarter (23%) of social care workers receive no supervision (Skills for Care, 2007, p35). There was strong consensus, which also extended to managers, that supervision was very important. However, this did not necessarily result in the provision of good or adequate supervision. Some practitioners said supervision was supposed to be provided regularly in their service, but in practice it took place less often than they were told it would and was not regular. One manager explained that as holding supervision every two months was a requirement of care standards in the service she managed, this system had been put in place. But this was not the general picture. I think some people at our’s haven’t had theirs for six months. The other day they promised this person to have it every two months, but it had been cancelled and six months had passed with no supervision. Practitioner I don’t know what’s happening with supervision. It’s all over the place…. I would like to know where I am going and if I am doing things right. Practitioner
109
Supporting people
Other practitioners said they receive excellent support and supervision from their managers. They spoke of positive experiences of being involved in the operation and development of services. The positive effects where a service made a commitment to ensure proper supervision and support can be seen from the following comments. All came from practitioners working in services in one authority. The support and supervision from the management is second to none. It’s great to talk to someone and know that you are doing things in the right way and be encouraged to do it, and feel that you are doing a positive job, it really helps you.… I have never had so much supervision in my life! Practitioner Yes, things are taken on board. It might be taken up later in supervision if it needed to be…. You can have your say and not be frightened about having your say. Practitioner The best thing is the management of the place. It’s terrific, [name of manager] and [name of deputy manager] are great managers. There is a nice friendly atmosphere, not at all petty. Everyone works together as a team. Practitioner The input is pretty good actually. Our manager is very good, very down to earth. I genuinely believe that if there was a situation when people fundamentally disagreed with [name of manager], he would listen to it and act accordingly. At a lot of places, you become a manager and lose touch with your staff, but not here, it’s very democratic – a terrific place to work. Practitioner So it’s battling away with social services rather than the management structure at the Barry Centre. Practitioner
A strong sense also emerged that other pressures on organisations and services could get in the way of support for staff and that during busy periods particularly, supervision was sacrificed. If this is the case, it suggests that supervision is not being treated as a priority in service provider organisations. This in turn contributed to a sense of being undervalued among practitioners. It also communicated itself to service users. For example:
110
The social care workforce
These girls here are run ragged. I have seen staff cry because they don’t feel they have done justice to us. They should never have to feel that way…. They finish up in tears nearly, especially new ones that come along. Service user If the situation doesn’t change in terms of managerial support, then [staff] won’t stay long and they have got to retain them once they get them. And therefore the ethos of the place has to be right. They have got to see this is a place that they want to work in and that is up to management to make sure that happens. Carer/relative
Trading on practitioners’ commitment These comments suggest that the good nature of staff and their commitment to their work is sometimes taken advantage of by services. Practitioners may put up with poor support because they are committed to the service users they work with and with providing high quality support. I think that’s what gets played on [practitioner’s caring nature], and I think the sort of nature of work that we do, what I would appreciate more than a pay rise, is some good access to some good clinical supervision. Practitioner
One manager’s comments suggested that the variety and enjoyment of the role were what motivated the staff she worked with. We are extremely lucky with the staff. They all give over and above, because they enjoy the work. It is dynamic and lively, every day is just so very different. Some days can be quiet. Others are just madness all day – which is great! Manager
The need for emotional support The other side of this picture, however, is the stresses and strains such work entails, making good support and supervision all the more necessary. One practitioner’s comments highlighted not only her deep commitment to the welfare of people using the service she worked for, but also the emotional impact her work had on her and how that affected her life outside work. Issues are also raised about the tensions there may be between ideas of professionalism and the empathy and 111
Supporting people
understanding of the practitioner and the important part supervision and support have to play in exploring and negotiating these. I think just a place to offload [is what’s needed]. And you know I have [often] been accused by a manager of not being detached, being too involved, but that’s who I am and I think that’s why I’m often pretty good at my job. I’m probably pulled up heaps, but I do really care, and I’ve sat with someone last week all day who was suicidal and she has three children, I can’t stay detached, and yet there are a whole load of issues and it really affected me at the weekend, you know, and stuff gets triggered in your own life. Practitioner
The mixture of formal and informal support that was available at one service had made a positive impression on one practitioner which she compared favourably to her previous work experiences: Well there is a lot of peer group support because we work very closely within our teams. But having said that our manager and deputy manager are very aware of what is happening on the shop floor as well. So their door is never closed either. And again we have had fantastic support and given fantastic support from relatives and next of kin. Whether you like it or not, you are more often part of an extended family, living within an environment like this. It is very different to a hospital setting in that respect. Practitioner
Staff working in residential homes for older people spoke of the emotional strain they experienced when residents died. This is a relatively frequent occurrence for practitioners working in such settings, but training and support about this issue were not routinely available to the practitioners we spoke to. And we’ve had in the past counselling for staff from the hospice team. Because if someone has died suddenly that is the worst thing for the staff to deal with. Because they may have been on duty the day before and that person is perfectly alright. They come on the next morning and they have died and it is a great shock. Practitioner
112
The social care workforce
If I’m stressed out, I would like to be able to just come into a room and talk to my supervisor or manager about it and I don’t want it spread about what my problem is, rather than keeping something bottled up, I’d like to vent it out. Practitioner
It is particularly distressing when a home care worker on their own, discovers the death of a service user, who they know well. Services need contingency plans for a rapid supportive response in this situation (Patmore and McNulty, 2005, pp 56-7).
Support to feel part of the organisation Supervision and support are important in relation to people’s practice, but they have a helpful role to play beyond that. One practitioner made the point there was no structure to report difficulties or discontent in her organisation. This was a source of frustration and disempowerment. Such a structure might exist in the service but she was not aware of it. I mean in our organisation, there’s no way for you to comment upwards, so if you’ve got a manager that you’ve got major problems, you could make a huge stink about it, but something like that there is no channel. Practitioner
In Wendlbury, the Glen Trust was conducting an internal review of services. The likely outcome of this review was unclear to practitioners and the security of their jobs was of major concern to them. This insecurity led to tension in the service. Practitioners noted that they had been given no clear reassurance about the future prospects for their jobs, a factor that led them to feel unsupported and unsure about the future. They have said that we will have a job. Others have said we will have to reapply for our jobs. Practitioner No one has been around to say your job is secure. Manager
Support for practitioners to have a say Both practitioners and managers also highlighted another important expression of support for service workers. This was support from their 113
Supporting people
managers and organisations to have a say in what happens. Several practitioners spoke about the importance of having discretion to make decisions and being supported in this by their manager. This clearly contributed to their sense of feeling valued. It meant they could use their practice skills to the full and make a meaningful contribution to the service. It stands in stark contrast to the sense that has been strongly communicated since the care management reforms, that managerial and financial criteria are likely to take precedence over professional expertise (Dustin, 2007). I feel more empowered, instead of asking ‘Can I? Should I?’ It’s more making decisions now, standing on my own feet and having the confidence when I take things back that I will be listened to and hopefully those actions will be carried out. I am taken seriously ... Before I was waiting to be fed information down, but now I am hearing it first hand. Practitioner [Senior manager’s name] just lets me get on, which is nice. He is there to manage and support me. I ring him up for most things. Manager [They care] otherwise they wouldn’t be doing this job, because they are not doing the best paid jobs on the planet. What they want is a manager who understands when they want to deviate from the odd daft rule and support to do that within the risks that are available. Manager I think we have so much flexibility in terms of making our own decisions when we are meeting with our service users. It’s not a matter of you have to go back to your manager all the time. Practitioner If you have an idea and it’s a goer they will let you develop it. If it falls on its face, no one will think anything less of you. Practitioner
This contrasted with the experience of another practitioner who spoke of a lack of understanding and trust from a manager: I think management need to be a bit more understanding about the workload of staff…. Paperwork … does take a 114
The social care workforce
lot of time. Things don’t always work and [to] do that at the same time…. Crises come up every day. Every day’s different. You don’t know what you’re going to walk into. You don’t know what’s going to happen from one day to the next and if something [arises] unexpectedly … you’ve got to prioritise…. It’s more important than paper work. Practitioner
Characteristics of a service that supports and values its workers A number of characteristics begin to emerge from what practitioners, service users and managers said, which typified a service that supported and valued its practitioners. While many services may feel unable to increase rates of pay for their workers, making changes to improve such conditions of a service, need not prove costly, but seem to have a major impact on practitioners’ ability to work in more person-centred ways and lift their morale and sense of satisfaction, as well as improving the quality of the service overall. These include: • Regular supportive supervision • Regular team meetings • An open and supportive atmosphere at meetings where people feel happy to express views and ideas • Valuing contributions from the whole team, irrespective of length of service or seniority • Ideas from practitioners are acted upon and implemented by the service • A down to earth, approachable management style • Practitioners empowered to make decisions within agreed values and principles • Early and open communication about important changes within a service There are some clear parallels between these components and the definition of person-centred support which we discussed in Chapter Two. Themes of open communication, listening, involvement, being empowered to make decisions and being supportive, are common to both. As has already been suggested (Sanderson, 2000), we are unlikely to move closer to the development of person-centred support unless staff themselves are treated in person-centred ways. In other words, a person-centred approach needs to underpin all aspects of both the process and goals of service provision.
115
Supporting people
However, this can be more difficult to achieve when staff are isolated and do not work in teams which meet together, formally or informally. It is important to recognise that an increasing number of social care staff work without team mates and in the case of staff employed directly by holders of personal budgets, without a manager or supervisor distinct from the service user. So while as disabled people have highlighted, the job of personal assistant (PA) can be a more supportive and creative one, the worker may have fewer lines of support, unless efforts are made to challenge this. The new dominance of independent sector agencies as providers of publicly funded home care means that many home care staff work on their own, rather than with colleagues. Unlike directly employed local authority home care services, independent agencies rarely hold team meetings because their staff do not get paid for such time (Patmore, 2003, pp 7-8). Consequently, workers generally do not meet each other, except when two are needed for a lifting task. Putting People First (DH, 2007) is likely to increase the numbers of staff who are directly employed by service users and whose work relationships are thus primarily with service users. This raises questions about how staff morale, sense of satisfaction and the goals of supervision can best be addressed in these situations. The principles which we have set out will need to be translated to these circumstances.
Pay While the government has repeatedly placed an emphasis on the need for a skilled and well supported social care workforce, its pay and status are still low. In their 2007 survey, Skills for Care found that the average wage for social care work was £6.87 per hour. Private sector rates of pay tend to be lower than those in statutory services and many workers are paid around or little more than the minimum wage (Skills for Care, 2007, pp 6,39). This disadvantage is seriously compounded for the enlarged independent sector home care workforce by non-payment for time spent travelling between service users. Frequently, even such transport costs must be met from the worker’s low pay (Patmore and McNulty, 2005, pp 59-60). Independent agency staff have replaced many local authority home care staff, who were paid for both time and costs of travel between customers. Along with reductions of premium rates for anti-social hours, this represents a harsh reduction in payment for home care workers.
116
The social care workforce
Given the generally low rates of pay for face-to-face practitioners in social care, surprisingly few participants mentioned low pay or seemed to regard poor pay of practitioners as a barrier to person-centred support. On the other hand, many more people spoke about the importance of supervision or feeling valued. Perhaps this is a measure of the commitment of the many practitioners we spoke with, as well as the fact that poor terms and conditions may have come to be taken for granted in social care. Typical comments about low pay in social care included: Staff should be paid more. Not known I think for me, that’s something that [would help improve the service], you know, staff being valued, paid well. Manager It’s not a job you just do for the money…. You do get very involved with the people you are looking after. You are with people 24 hours a day. You’re probably with them longer than what you are [with] your husband, so you do get very involved. Practitioner
Nonetheless, because of the generally low pay and status of social care work, services continue to experience problems recruiting and retaining practitioners. They frequently find themselves in competition with other local employers. Many of the alternative jobs available can be more flexible and involve less responsibility than work in social care. It’s a very responsible job on [your] own in a client’s home, feeding someone who is at risk of choking, who may die in your care. That’s a lot of responsibility to take for £6.40 an hour when you can get that working in a supermarket – and get cheap groceries too! Practitioner The local supermarkets are really good at providing any hours that people want. So if you have mums with restricted working hours that they can do, supermarkets are now brilliant at saying ‘Well OK, those hours will suit us.’ … When you look at what we expect of our care staff, and the standards we expect from them and the workload, and the responsibility of care, then if people are not really committed you can understand why they go elsewhere and they need
117
Supporting people
the money to live. Some people want to do care work but can’t afford to do it. Manager
We spoke to practitioners who had taken on additional jobs to supplement their income, or who had several part-time jobs within the field of social care. One spoke of the negative knock-on effects that this might have for service users. And if you do extra hours and then you get tired, if you are coming in, in the morning and you’re tired, you don’t have time to be nice to people and do person-related support really. Practitioner
Status In their 2007 survey Skills for Care found that while 90% of people working in social care were happy with their jobs less than half thought that their work was appreciated by the general public (Skills for Care, 2007, pp 6-7). Those taking part in our project generally spoke more about the poor status of jobs in social care than the low pay. This may have been due to being embarrassed to talk about money, or not wanting to be seen as mercenary. However, the following comments are typical of the responses made by a large proportion of participants when asked what could be done to improve services. Here the connection with the poor status of social care work was explicitly made. It was seen as a major problem. Raising the status of social care employment was a priority for service workers. To see that the job’s actually a valuable job, not just to say I want to do care work, but that I want to make a career. Manager Raise the status of [paid] carers. It would help tremendously, they do a wonderful job and it’s just, they don’t have the backup. They are rushed from here to there. They don’t feel they can do the job they would really like to do. Practitioner
Innes, Macpherson and McCabe point to a wider barrier to improving the status of social care work.
118
The social care workforce
In terms of the value associated with frontline work, it seems that lack of knowledge of the tasks performed by frontline workers stands as the greatest barrier to a positive image of this role. (Innes et al, 2006, p 42) Another practitioner contrasted her existing job with a previous job to highlight the importance of status and motivation. I worked in the hospital which was horrendous. It was just back to back wet-beds and sick. This is lovely. You feel like you can go away and you have had a nice time and other people have had a nice time, so there is a sense of achievement rather than just sticking plasters the whole time. You don’t feel like you are always working at crisis point. We are very lucky really. We are offered a lot of training and chances to develop ourselves. They are always encouraging us to do new things. Practitioner
Inadequate staffing levels Another routine and major barrier facing the workforce was the frequently inadequate staffing levels in services. This limited the potential for person-centred support. We’re always juggling and that makes it difficult to give people the support they want. Practitioner Sometimes it is difficult to give one-to-one time. You can’t because there are other jobs to do. Practitioner … there isn’t enough staff there. Service user It’s like a snowball. You start with a small idea. You start it rolling. It gets bigger and bigger and it comes a point where the work you are doing in that area then has impact on the rest of your work. So people say, ‘Stop. You can’t do that any more,’ regardless of the need. It’s a little tiny drop in this great big ocean of need and at the end of the day, you only have limited resources and you have to then stop and move on. I find that incredibly frustrating. Practitioner
119
Supporting people
You sometimes feel it; there are other things I need to do, like cycling and sometimes they say they can’t do it because they are too busy or whatever, so sometimes it is difficult. So it’s not so good for individual things you need to do. They are nice people, but sometimes they do struggle a bit. Service user
The ‘ratio’ of practitioners to service users varied greatly from service to service and had major implications for person-centred support. Basically being residential we can have 14 people living in one house with three members of staff. So there becomes a limit to how much you can actually work with people in a person-centred way. It is very difficult to do a lot of oneto-one. Manager We have more ratio [of practitioners to service users] and they [service users] do get out and they are able to say more what they want a lot more. Practitioner
In Camchester service users and relatives explained some of the consequences of having a low ratio of practitioners to service users, living in larger residential and nursing homes. For example: I don’t know if they are short-staffed or whatever, but when she was at home and she needed care, it was there immediately. Now it certainly isn’t here, because obviously she hasn’t got anyone in her room 24 hours a day. She is very worried about this colostomy and there has been occasions when the bag has been full and my mother has wanted it changed and they haven’t been able to and it has either burst or whatever. So we had problems with that because they hadn’t been able to do it there and then. So it isn’t instant attention, but I can understand why because they haven’t got the people here to do it. But it can be distressing. The staff are wonderful, absolutely wonderful. I have no criticism whatsoever but it is the numbers, it is a numbers game. Carer/relative
A service user with a life-limiting condition talked about the stark difference in staffing levels between a hospice and a nursing home.
120
The social care workforce
Virtually one-to-one care, which for terminal patients is very beneficial. When I came here [nursing home], that all had to change, because you just haven’t got the staffing levels here to give that one-to-one. Service user
In one project, service users raised the issue of the problems created when staff were absent. Levels of sickness and absenteeism are associated with staff conditions and morale, which as we have seen, are far from ideal in social care. If you want to go somewhere, they try to help. I think a lot of it revolves around staff absence. So in a lot of ways we can’t do things that we’d like to. There always has to be one person in the building at all times. For the health and safety of other residents. Service user We ask when are they [sick staff] coming back. Sometimes they get better and then go off sick again. Are they fit enough to do the job? Some are off for three or four months. You keep asking,‘When are they coming back?’, but you don’t get an answer. Service user If one person gets a cold they all get it very quick. Service user Always here people go off sick. Service user
A senior manager from this service said: Given the residential model, we are vulnerable to absences and the first thing to go is the one-to-one that isn’t life or death, hands-on care. Manager
Practitioners explained that staffing limits meant that it was often difficult to support work with individual service users. This got lost in the face of routine responsibilities. There is not enough staff time for spending one-to-one. Residents have to go with the group, rather than go with their own choice of outings and things. We need more support, more one-to-one. There’s lots we would like to do that we
121
Supporting people
can’t do on a one-to-one…. Time is of the essence and 13 others need looking after. Practitioner There’s always a lack of money, but that’s government. We can’t do much about that…. For more staff, to do more intense work with people or to do outreach work, there isn’t the time to do that…. I think it would be nice if there were more staff available here who could take people out into the city, to do their shopping and go to the library, that sort of thing, particularly people that live in establishments, who don’t get much chance to go out and have that independence. Practitioner One-off goals are more achievable. It’s sustaining the goals if they are continuing. It’s ensuring that support is in place to do that every week – because of the staff situation. There is a resident who goes on a swimming course every week. He would like to go twice a week, but that is proving quite difficult. Getting that extra person to come in, the funding for another person to support for another day, is very difficult. Then you have to say there’s like 12 other people and if one person is having so much one-to-one time and support is it fair to everyone else? It is very difficult. Practitioner We need more support for us to do things with staff, like taking us to the hospital [in case I need to write anything down]. It is hard to get staff support for appointments. Service user
The restructuring of social care roles So far in this chapter we have discussed the social care workforce and what may be helping or hindering it to work in more person-centred ways. It is important, however, to recognise the diversity and constantly changing nature of this workforce. People working as practitioners in social care have a wide range of experiences and backgrounds. They are also organised into a wide variety of different roles which include residential, domiciliary and fieldwork staff. While the qualified social worker is the professional role most closely associated with social care, other professionals also play an important part in this field, including occupational therapists and nurses.
122
The social care workforce
Big changes have taken place in the roles and tasks of social work and social care workers. The 1989 Children Act and 1990 National Health Service and Community Care Act (DH, 1989, 1990) are key markers for this. Changes in aims and ideology have led to the development and prioritisation of managerialist, consumerist and technicist approaches to social care policy and practice. This has impacted at all levels, in all services and sectors and on all social care roles (Dustin, 2007; Drakeford, 2008; Ferguson, 2008). In 2009, following the inquiry into the tragic death of ‘Baby Peter’ the government set up a social work task force which proposed the radical reform of all social work, including that with adult groups and led to the establishment of a Social Work Reform Board for England charged with the task of making this happen (Social Work Task Force, 2009). An official search has also been on to find the ‘reserved’ tasks of social work; that is to say, tasks which only social workers are seen as able to do. However, these tend to be preoccupied with social control and ignore the reality that by undertaking more mundane day-to-day tasks, social workers can build the relationship and trust that then enable them to undertake the complex and difficult tasks they are capable of (Beresford, 2007; DCSF, 2010). Ironically, there are now concerns that the government’s push for personalisation will have further effects, which may not be consistent with moves to more person-centred support. There are widespread fears that social work jobs will be cut or diluted as policy moves away from care management to a model of provision based on self-assessment, self-directed support and improved access to mainstream services. This has been reflected in headlines in the social care press like: ‘Council to increase number of non-qualified staff in personalisation reforms’ (Samuel, 2008), as well as increasing social worker concerns about the implementation of personalisation (Community Care, 2010). Dealings between workers and service users have increasingly been restructured as transactions, rather than relationship-based interactions and negotiations. They are timed and evaluated on the basis of readily quantifiable outcome measures. There is pressure on professionals to spend less time with service users and for contact increasingly to be electronic or by telephone. The roles performed by qualified social workers have changed dramatically in the last 20 years. Roles that were once solely performed by qualified workers are now often performed by staff without formal social work or with other qualifications. Thus the approved social worker (ASW) role in mental health, valued for the social approach 123
Supporting people
that helpfully underpins social work, has been replaced by that of the approved mental health professional (AMHP), now also recruited from more medically orientated professions. The making of assessments was once the preserve of qualified social workers, but since the 1990s has often been undertaken by domiciliary care assessors who are not qualified social workers. An increasing reliance has been placed on call centres with (unqualified) workers following pre-set scripts to deal with service users and new referrals. In 2008 the Commission for Social Care Inspection, predecessor of the Care Quality Commission, reported that: A frequently made claim was that social work was becoming ‘de-professionalised’; the need to meet performance indicators particularly on speed of response was cited as an obstacle to reflective practice. A service-led approach to assessment appeared to be entrenched in some councils. This was felt to be a particular risk where staff who did not have a professional social work background were involved in assessment. (CSCI, 2008, p 24) The extension of direct payments and personal budgets is meant to result in an increased role for self-assessment by service users. In this way they will be increasingly involved in the design and commissioning of their own personalised service. While this has been advanced as a liberating development, many social workers are concerned that moves away from employing qualified social workers in the process will be to the detriment of service users, and mean that social work skills are side-lined, the profession will shrink and its skills be lost to the social care system. They fear that non-qualified or non-social work qualified staff will lack their skills and experience and may have a narrower, more individualised, service-led view of the service users’ entitlement, abilities and potential. These fears were recognised by the Commission for Social Care Inspection, particularly in relation to screening or helpdesk services operated by local authorities. It was striking that in the councils in this study, the gatekeeping role was increasingly undertaken by people without a professional social work background. There need to be adequate safeguards that people with eligible needs are not excluded at an early stage from any further consideration or assessment of those needs. (CSCI, 2008, p 26)
124
The social care workforce
Many service users, on the other hand, take a different view. They feel that social workers have frequently failed to act as their advocate. Instead of supporting the independent living of service users, they have implemented the controlling and rationing regimes of their agencies. They can also see gains to be got from moving away from a system based on conventional academic qualifications, to one which embraces diverse perspectives and values lived experience. Although many social care practitioners may not be qualified as social workers, they may have a range of life experiences that qualify them to work supportively and empathically with service users. A preoccupation with conventional education and qualifications may exclude service users and members of black and minority ethnic communities who may have much relevant and useful experience to offer. Service user advocates too, informed by the social model of disability, can have a valuable role to play in assessment. Innes, Macpherson and McCabe argue for the importance of the qualities offered by staff rather than just their qualifications. The value attributed to frontline health and social care work by managers, other professionals, the public and Government suggests too much attention to the professional status of workers, and not enough to the qualities that frontline health and social care workers both deliver and offer. (Innes et al, 2006, p 42) A case study from a service which took part in our project helps to demonstrate the complexity of this issue. It can be seen as an example of how unqualified staff are carrying out roles that traditionally would have been undertaken by social workers and how they can offer informed, understanding and supportive assistance to service users, regardless of a lack of formal social work qualifications. At the same time, it points to some of the problems that such arrangements may pose. CASE STUDY CHANGING SOCIAL CARE ROLES In Grandshire the Disability Development Workers (DDW) service was set up to offer person-centred support to service users who were not eligible for support because they fell outside the eligibility criteria of Fair Access To Care Services (FACS) established by government. Their work is communitybased and intended to be preventive. Disability development workers provide 125
Supporting people people with information and support. As they put it: We exist to ensure that disabled people and their carers in Grandshire have access to information and support and to explore opportunities and choices in their lives. ‘Disability development worker’ information leaflet Our work is centred by clients, their views, and the way we work should be [shaped by] what clients want. Disability development worker The service aims to assist disabled people to gain access to mainstream services and to work together to ‘find their own solutions’ and improve the quality of their lives. They take referrals direct from disabled people, or from the local authority access service that works with them. The team is well managed and has a strong identity. Its workers cover different areas of the county, but frequently work together. Workers have built up extensive local knowledge and work with a range of partners on a local and countywide basis. [Disability development workers] start by asking people what they want to do and then look for opportunities so they can do that. Service user The disability development workers job grew out of the ‘coordinators of creative activity’ role developed at a local day centre. While local social workers have increasingly been occupied with care management and crisis intervention, the disability development workers have taken on a more preventive, community social work role. They appear to have filled the gap left by social workers’ changed responsibilities. The difference in the roles of disability development workers and social workers in Grandshire can helpfully be seen as disability development workers working ‘upstream’ to support disabled people in preventive, proactive ways that reduce the chance of the people needing to go on and use services (Smale et al, 1996). Social workers in turn are seen as working ‘downstream’ with people who have already reached crisis point and need emergency support. The disability development workers service can be seen as an innovative reinvention of the social work role within restricted budgets. However, the disability development workers are not qualified social workers and are paid much less. The differences between the roles were highlighted when a qualified social worker took up a disability development worker’s job despite a pay-cut of around £8,000 per annum. She said she was attracted to the role because it was working in the way she had wanted to practise when she 126
The social care workforce qualified. Comparable developments can be seen in other fields, with, for example, the development of nursing assistants in health and in the police service, taking on more on the day-to-day face-to-face activities previously undertaken by professional social workers. There has been some tension between the disability development workers and local social work teams, although more recently efforts have been made to build closer relationships. Sadly it’s seen that the disability development workers have got the cream. Manager They’re seeing a worker going out creating something, not even getting money from the Department. They’re fundraising and the social workers are saying, ‘These are things that we would like to do but we’re actually constrained in this legislative framework.’ Manager There are two key risks facing Grandshire in this respect. First, the disability development workers service’s future cannot be seen as secure as it is largely working outside the FACS eligibility criteria funded by the local authority. Second, the local authority may come to see the disability development workers as offering the standard model of working and cut skilled and qualified social work posts in favour of unskilled roles. Local managers are aware of the difficulties and divisions and are seeking solutions. [Disability development workers and social workers are like] two different machines working alongside each other, but not necessarily doing the same job any longer. Senior manager However, it must be emphasised that the work of the disability development workers has locally been seen as progressive and high quality. The disability development workers are well supported, but have a high degree of autonomy in their work. The team also has a significant proportion of disabled people working as disability development workers, bringing direct experience to the role. The team may also benefit from not being social workers, particularly for those service users who have had negative past experiences of social workers. One disability development worker described how the service had distanced itself from mainstream adult services to get away from: ‘Us and them’ attitudes in social services where service users are seen as the ‘enemy’ [There is a] protective shield which social services staff have around them. Disability development worker 127
Supporting people
Roles and tasks in social work and social care are an issue we return to in the last chapter of the book where we explore change and making change, drawing on the evidence we have gained.
Summary Successful moves to personalisation and more person-centred support demand a highly skilled, well trained and well supported workforce. Yet the poor terms and conditions of the present social care workforce are at odds with this and associated with low retention and high turnover rates. As a result, while the expectation is that a larger social care workforce will be required for the future, there are currently concerns about the feasibility of maintaining the workforce at its present level. The reality of modern UK social care, emerging from our evidence, is that practitioners frequently feel undervalued and unsupported. Despite the importance practitioners and services attach to appropriate training, in practice, training is limited and patchy. There are wide variations in the availability and quality of staff supervision and support, with many practitioners receiving little or no supervision. While few practitioners make explicit reference to low pay, it is linked with the generally low status of social care work in the UK and this is seen as a major problem. Although services may not be able to afford to pay their workers more, improvements in the supervision and support staff receive, while not necessarily costly, can have a disproportionately positive impact on morale and effectiveness. We came across both good and bad examples of training, support and supervision for staff. This emerges as a factor which can have a huge impact on both the experience of practitioners, and in the overall effectiveness of the services involved. Inadequate levels of staffing also create major barriers in the way of person-centred support. Staffservice user ratios vary significantly and not necessarily in relation to need. Staff absenteeism increases the difficulties of responding to service users on an individual basis. The roles and tasks of the social work and social care workforce have been going through major changes, relating to shifts in ideology and organisation. We look in more detail at this complex issue through a case study of unqualified staff working in roles that would formerly have been undertaken by professional social workers and consider some of the implications this may have.
128
The social care workforce
References Beresford, P. (2007) The changing roles and tasks of social work from service users’ perspectives:A literature-informed discussion paper for the review of social work roles and tasks in England, London: General Social Care Council. Community Care (2010) Personalisation, Special report supplement, Community Care, 20 May, pp 14-25. CSCI (Commission for Social Care Inspection) (2008) The state of social care in England 2006/07, London: CSCI. DCSF (Department for Children, Schools and Families) (2010) Building a safe and confident future: Implementing the recommendations of the Social Work Task Force, London: HM Government. DH (Department of Health) (1989) The Children Act, London: HMSO DH (1990) The National Health Service and Community Care Act, London: HMSO. DH (2003a) Domiciliary care, national minimum standards regulations (in accordance with Section 23 of the National Care Standards Act, 2000), London: The Stationery Office. DH (2003b) Care homes for adults (18-65), national minimum standards, care home regulations, February, London: The Stationery Office. DH (2007) Putting People First: A shared vision and commitment to the transformation of adult social care, London: The Stationery Office. Drakeford, M. (2008) ‘Social work and politics’, in M. Davies (ed) The Blackwell companion to social work (3rd edn), Oxford: Blackwell, pp 303-10. Dustin, D. (2007) The McDonaldization of social work,Aldershot:Ashgate. Ferguson, I. (2008) Reclaiming social work: Challenging neo-liberalism and promoting social justice, London: Sage Publications. Innes,A., Macpherson, S. and McCabe, L. (2006) Promoting person-centred care at the front line,York: Joseph Rowntree Foundation. Morrison, T. (2005) Staff supervision in social care (3rd edn), Brighton: Pavilion Publishing. Patmore, C. (2003) Understanding home care providers,York: Social Policy Research Unit, University of York. Patmore, C. and McNulty,A. (2005) Caring for the whole person: Home care for older people which promotes well-being and choice, Well-being and Choice web publications (www.well-beingandchoice.org.uk/Caring4.pdf). Samuel, M. (2008) ‘Council to increase number of non-qualified staff in personalisation reforms’, 13 August (www.communitycare.co.uk/ Articles/2008/08/13/109121/personalisation-in-wirral-meansfewer-social-workers.html). Sanderson, H. (2000) Person-centred planning: Key features and approaches, York: Joseph Rowntree Foundation. 129
Supporting people
Simmons, L. (2007) Social care governance: A practice workbook, London: Social Care Institute for Excellence. Skills for Care (2007) National survey of care workers, Leeds: Skills for Care. Smale, G., Tuson, G. and Statham, D. (1996) Creative social work, Basingstoke: Palgrave Macmillan. Social Work Task Force (2009) Building a safe, confident future: The final report of the Social Work Task Force, November, London: Department for Children, Schools and Families.
130
FIVE
Social care and carers Of adults with a learning disability living in the community, 52 per cent live with their parents and 12 per cent with other relatives. (Disability Rights Commission, 2007, p 34) STANDARD FIVE: CARERS
Policy and practice based on person-centred support should ensure appropriate support to service users, their families and friends, instead of placing increasing reliance on family and friends to act as ‘informal carers’. Services should support individuals to exercise choice and control while respecting the values of love and mutuality in relationships.
Introduction In this chapter we focus on the unpaid support which service users receive from those close to them – ‘informal carers’ as they have come to be called. Such unpaid ‘caring’ is a complex and highly contentious issue. Over the last 30 plus years, governments and policymakers have placed an increasing stress and reliance on such support. They have emphasised that most of the support that service users receive comes from such informal carers, rather than the paid workforce examined in the last chapter. We are regularly told that ‘There are almost six million unpaid carers of adults in the UK…. Without them, the social care system would collapse’ (Hampshire County Council, 2008, p 65). Here we look at how such arrangements work out in practice, their implications for person-centred support and to what extent they may be consistent with service users’ choice and control over their lives. The term ‘carers’ or ‘informal carers’ has come to be used particularly in relation to support provided for people by their family, friends and neighbours. Most often, it means support provided by 131
Supporting people
people’s families and loved ones. Such ‘caring’ can embrace a very wide range of activities and relationships. It may mean providing support to a sibling, partner or offspring. The need can arise at any time in our lives – from when we are still at school, to our own old age. It may entail some modest help with routine day-to-day tasks like shopping or cleaning, to help with the most intimate activities of daily living ‘twenty four seven’, as some carers put it. The need may arise because of someone’s physical, sensory or intellectual impairment, through mental distress, chronic illness or increased physical and mental frailty linked with older age. There are now particular concerns about greatly increased needs following from rising rates of Alzheimer’s with the growing numbers and proportions of old and very old people in western societies. There are now large ‘carers’ organisations in the UK, like Carers UK and the Princess Royal’s Trust for Carers, as well as less well known campaigning groups like Carer Watch. But the reality is that most people who act as carers have little support and access very limited information and capacity building to take on the responsibilities that they carry out. The strategy of large carers organisations over the years has primarily been to emphasise the financial savings made to the state through the unpaid role of such carers. This is currently estimated to be in the realm of £87 billion a year – more than the annual spend on the National Health Service. Twelve per cent of the UK population are estimated to provide such unpaid care (Buckner and Yeandle, 2007, pp 1-2). Charities and campaigners have sought to use this as a lever to increase support and benefits and improve conditions for carers. Governments, however, have not been greatly responsive to the efforts of carers and their organisations. The government’s Carers’ Strategy announced in 2008 (DH, 2008) was generally greeted by the carers’ lobby as offering too little too late. In 2008, Caroline Glendinning and Hilary Arksey, building on the work of Julia Twigg (Twigg, 1989), set out four approaches to carer policy in health and social care. These are:
132
• Carer as resource: treating carers instrumentally as a resource to be used, supporting their wellbeing to maintain ‘care-giving’; • Carers as co-workers: recognising their interests, but still primarily to maintain their functioning; • Carers as co-clients, where carers’ wellbeing and needs are recognised in their own right and services provided to support them;
Social care and carers
• The superseded carer, where services are provided to support service users, enabling carers to achieve independence. (Glendinning and Arksey, 2008, p 224)
They conclude that current policies are primarily based on the ‘carer as resource’ model and suggest that ‘until the conceptual model underpinning shifts, it is likely that carers will continue to experience negative outcomes in their health, employment and finances’ (Glendinning and Arksey, 2008, p 223). Research evidence suggests that the most effective way of supporting carers is by providing services for older and disabled people (Glendinning and Arksey, 2008, p 223). However, reliance on unpaid care is unlikely to continue to be tenable in the longer term. There is not expected to be the necessary supply of informal care. Changes in family and household makeup, geographic, social and economic change, are all likely to have an adverse impact.
• As adult children are more likely to live away from elderly parents, distance will create barriers to informal care. • Demographic change is likely to mean that people expected to care will themselves be increasingly old and frail. • Disabled and older people may expect greater choice and control over their support. (Glendinning and Arksey, 2008, p 224)
Increasing the retirement age is another policy plan that is likely to reduce the supply of unpaid caring. For policymakers, there are now competing priorities between care-giving and employment. We are now beginning to hear carers described by policymakers as ‘socially excluded’, because of their relatively low levels of paid employment. This looks likely to result in increasing pressure on them to join the labour market, as well as to extend their stay in it. However, while relying on service users’ loved ones to support them may for the moment seem a viable policy to cash-strapped governments, the problems it creates for both service users and their families emerged powerfully from the people we spoke to. It is also a policy that sits uncomfortably with the goals, values and practice of person-centred support. Many of the service users who took part in our project, particularly those not living in residential services, received key support from family members. We heard of great love, loyalty and commitment 133
Supporting people
to the well-being of loved ones from many service users and relatives. However, people’s role as ‘informal carers’ frequently emerged as a barrier to person-centred support. For many service users, these arrangements could have negative as well as positive consequences. They could be both a help and a problem. The complex interplay of feeling and emotions at work, made this a difficult subject to talk about. However, service users, practitioners and families did discuss it. They identified three major issues that service users could encounter that related to their families. These were: • restrictions on service users’ say • barriers to independence • the parallel problems for families We now look at these in more detail.
Restrictions on service users’ say Many service users and practitioners identified the negative influence of families on decision-making for service users. They referred to decisions in service user’s lives being made by, or being strongly influenced by, their relatives. For example: I can’t get at my money at the moment because my mum’s not letting me have any. When we go away or got out tonight I can’t say until I’m sure about how much money I’ve got…. She’s transferred so much of my money to an ISA [Individual Savings Account] that I can’t get at [it], because she won’t let me have the password. And I think that’s taking my human rights away – of my managing my own money. Service user Sometimes you ask the client what they want to do and their mother answers. Practitioner I think that people with learning disabilities – often in my experience family and carers … limit people’s choices…. I have to be very tactful about all of this! So I think … it’s about people trying to work better with family and carers and build trust and build bridges. Manager You go to visit someone and their daughter or their son is there and there is the ‘inheritor’s protection scheme’. It does 134
Social care and carers
kick in some times. They might say, ‘Well he doesn’t really need that.’ Not known Yes and her daughter is a bit of a – she is a staff nurse, and the manager always says the customer is king, but the resident is the customer, not the relatives. Practitioner Families are not used to ideas about inclusion and want to keep services like day centres. They see changes as a loss of services. The mindset and attitude is a crucial one. Manager
This could be happening in the context of pressure on service users restricting their say from other quarters too: Most times in [social] care, you are between a rock and hard place, because you have got to do what the resident wishes. But you have got relatives as well and you have got the social workers and everybody wanting to get their input into care and everything else. Practitioner
Some service users found it easier than others to make their own decisions in the face of pressure or suggestions from their family. Sometimes I don’t want to go the way they are going and do the things that they want to do. They suggest something and I decide if I want to do it or not. I say I don’t feel like doing it. Service user Your parents are a massive thing, but they need – especially when you go into a residential home – they need to know that, yeah, they can care for you, and yeah, they can do what they like for you, but they need to know that you want your space. Service user
The value of advocacy and support In many situations, advocacy proved a valuable tool in addressing these pressures and assisting service users to make their own decisions. Sometimes, for people with learning difficulties, this support came from volunteer citizen advocates, but more often, in the services we worked with, it came from practitioners – through key worker arrangements – and from managers. 135
Supporting people
Quite often families will intervene on behalf of a person and say, ‘What they really want is’ and be quite prescriptive in what they really want and, it is about, I guess, giving [the service user] the courage really to just, you know, to have a bit of space and think about what they would really like for themselves and to have [workers] to actually just voice that and them being able to advocate. I think [it is] about making sure that you are advocating clearly what that person’s wishes are rather than anyone else’s opinion. Not known
A manager of a service supporting young disabled adults (Pippin Close), told us that the service often became involved in disputes between parents and residents. One of these almost ended up in court. Many related to parents ‘holding on to the purse strings’. The service always tried to get the parents and the young person together to have a discussion and work towards a solution. The service offered to set up advocacy support for the young person involved. All this can create tensions between practitioners and families. It can be quite frightening when you have two very strong parents almost gunning for you. Manager
The same manager explained how she had become involved in a dispute between a young disabled woman and her mother. The young woman had long-term health problems and regularly had to have medical consultations. Her mother always attended the appointments with her. The young woman told practitioners at the home that she did not want her mother to come to the appointments any longer. She said she would prefer her key worker to accompany her. Her mother was very angry and upset about this and felt that she was the only person with an overview and long-term knowledge of her daughter’s health. She thought it was unsafe for her daughter to attend without her, as doctors did not understand the full range of her health difficulties. Both the key worker and manager discussed this with her and eventually the manager decided to invite both parents, who were divorced – and the young woman – to a meeting to discuss the matter. After everyone had given their views at the meeting the father persuaded his ex-wife that she should accept their daughter’s wishes, as at the age of 22 she should be allowed to make her own decisions. This was a decision made collectively and ultimately accepted by everyone involved. Two more detailed case studies highlight the complexity of relationships between service users, families and services and the issues 136
Social care and carers
that these can raise for service users’ say and control. Clearly these need to be addressed carefully and sensitively. At the same time they raise broader issues and are themselves sometimes related to broader concerns. Because of this, they may not always be readily amenable to simple solution. CASE STUDY ADVOCACY WHERE CULTURES MAY CONFLICT A manager in Downhampton spoke about the complicated issues involved in advocating for service users. His service was trying to build relationships between the local council and families belonging to minority ethnic communities. He raised concerns about jeopardising these relationships, as it could result in the family withdrawing their disabled child from the service. That in turn could mean that the disabled person remained isolated and excluded. People love their parents often and don’t want to upset their parents and so won’t go against their wishes. So it’s OK the professionals saying, ‘Well you’re an adult, you can make your own decision and you can go if you want to.’ People don’t…. They love their parents. They don’t want to go against what their parents say. So the steps I’ve made, in the past, I’ve advocated too strongly for someone and caused a rift between her and her dad…. I went about it the wrong way, I acknowledged that and I think it’s really important that people remember that. (Manager) The influence of parents extends across all communities. It was a particular issue for the service in Downhampton. There, the ethnicity sub-group of the local learning disability partnership board had identified the conflict between what a service user and what family carers might want, as a key barrier to person-centred support. They recognised that this was not a conflict particular to any one ethnic community. However, some members of the group said that the cultural background shared by many service users made the tension more noticeable and acute in their community than in others. This seemed to be due to different cultural views relating to the role of the family and the individual, where there was a stronger emphasis on interdependence rather than individualism.
137
Supporting people It’s still very much about the family not the person [the individual service user]. I think there are cultural issues in that. It’s more strongly embedded than the individual. They always consider the impact on the family. Practitioner A manager explained that the major factor in encouraging the take-up of services in black and minority ethnic communities had proved to be winning the trust of disabled people’s families. He likened this to bringing a wall down: Taking a brick down at a time. Manager He gave examples of the cultural differences in the communities he worked with that could have an impact on the self-advocacy and carers groups he had been instrumental in setting up: • parents may take decisions even if the person is grown up and does not have a learning difficulty; • parents are frightened of the risks faced by their adult sons and daughters, for example, the possible danger of hate crime if they travel on public transport, directed at them due to their impairment or ethnicity or both; • the importance for many people of maintaining their cultural values because they feel that they and their culture are under threat.
The local ‘ethnicity sub-group’ spoke about an example that illustrated these barriers at one of their meetings. It followed on from a two-day workshop arranged by the Standards We Expect project, which encouraged service users to think about decision-making and their rights. A young woman who was a member of the self-advocacy group attended the workshop. After this her family was very concerned about some of the things she said. She stopped attending the group, and practitioners were convinced this was because the family were unhappy with the views she expressed after the workshop. One manager said: That is what happens when people start having a voice and it enables you to take the next step. Others, however, were concerned that if people were withdrawn from the self-advocacy group they could become isolated. Another manager commented:
138
Social care and carers I’m not saying we don’t continue on the journey, it’s just that we need to be more mindful of that. We need to build in contingencies to avoid those situations where people are barred from the group process. A practitioner pointed out how the competing influences that people with learning difficulties were then exposed to, could be confusing and contradictory. But then it’s like saying in a group you can develop your confidence and say what you want, but when you go home you’ve got to be quiet and can’t say nothing. We’re teaching them two different things, which we can’t do. We are saying be independent, make your choices, say what you want to do, go ahead and do it. But if they go home and the parents say to you ‘No, you can’t go anymore,’ it stops there. Practitioner
CASE STUDY BARRIERS TO SPEAKING UP In services for older people, pressure can come from a different direction; service users’ sons and daughters. We spoke to many residents in residential and nursing homes who were happy for their relatives either to carry out their wishes, or to take decisions on their behalf. For example: I have told my family what I want, where their mother’s ashes are buried and I want to be right at the side of her and I will be with her then and I will be happy. Service user I have got a family and they will decide what happens to me when the time comes…. Oh yes, you have got to talk to them before about it and they are quite in agreement…. I have got one son and two daughters. They can argue when I have gone, that is what I say. They can do their arguing when I am gone and not when I am here. Service user Many of the families we were in contact with did not discuss death and dying openly. This may help explain why some of the older people were happy to leave decisions to their sons and daughters. It avoided the need to talk about them. We also came across examples, however, where families were taking decisions on behalf of residents without asking their opinions or permission. The completion of paperwork about preferences for medical treatment for older people moving into residential and nursing homes raised issues about 139
Supporting people the consent of service users. While relatives tended to be routinely involved in decision-making, this did not necessarily include service users. When they move into the nursing home, when they are admitted, the relatives have to fill in certain forms. And one is, if they are here, or if [they] have to go into hospital and they are not really going to pull through, do [they] want to be resuscitated? And that is the form that relatives have to fill in. The sisters, the RGNs [Registered General Nurses], have more input with that, but sometimes, I get to know families very well as I am on reception, I am on first name terms with most of them and they might come and say, ‘Oh my dad is not very well and I have told the sister I don’t want them to be resuscitated.’ So it is something that is discussed when they first move in, along with everything else, like what kind of diet do they like, are they Church of England, are they Roman Catholic, do they like going to a church service. That is one area that is covered because we need to know the wishes of the family. Administrator We heard about very recent practices that suggested collusion between services and relatives, making decisions on behalf of residents, without their knowledge. For example, in one service, references were made to service users’ post routinely being given to their relatives to open until recently. When I took over [name of home] which was only three-and-a-half years ago … they were still giving all the post to the relatives – only that short time ago. Manager Other examples mentioned, related to major treatment decisions. Unfortunately what sometimes happens is – particularly if people have had a stroke or they are demented – their families take over and they put their wishes first. I think that is still an old-fashioned thing in nursing homes, where the resident wasn’t asked, but the families were asked – and the families’ wishes were paramount. I think that is changing, but I think it is taking some time. Manager We have a lady who told her family that she didn’t want her life extended if anything happened to her. She had a massive stroke. They agreed for her to have a PEG [percutaneous endoscopic gastrostomy] tube in, which is the feeding tube to keep her alive. And she is still alive two-and-a-half years later – no quality of life; can talk but flatly refuses
140
Social care and carers to talk and won’t talk to the family either. And the grief and guilt they have got is huge, but this woman has no quality of life. She made her wishes clear and they were allowed to override those. Manager In another home a relative described a similar situation where decisions about a service user’s future medical treatment were being taken by family members, not the service user. In this case the family had decided that treatment should be withheld. I don’t know whether they [nursing home staff] have discussed it with her but we ourselves have signed a form, a ‘no resuscitation’ [form]. Because she had this stroke which severely cut her quality of life, she is not mobile, she has lost the use of the bottom half of her body, and we know that if she had another stroke, there wouldn’t be much quality of life at all. Me and my sisters have spoken about it. We have not discussed it with my father, he is 87…. We decided we didn’t want resuscitation. But I don’t think it has been discussed with her [the resident, her mother] because I don’t think she would understand…. We haven’t spoken to her because death to my mother is a bit of a no, no. She doesn’t want to know about it. Although she sits and reads the deaths in the paper, like most elderly [people] do. But she doesn’t want to talk about it. Relative However, we did hear a range of experiences and some relatives felt their response depended on their relationship with the older person moving into residential care. It is different for spouses and for children. They have different relationships with relative, home and staff. For a loving spouse [the] move to [a] care home can be a continuation of a loving, caring relationship that has already been through the first stages of the illness and takes all this into the care home. This is all part of a continuum. For children, their parent coming into a care home can be their first acknowledgement of their parent’s illness, their failing. Children also have their own families. Every case is different. [There] cannot be one way of doing things. [You] can only say, ‘This might be considered the best way forward.’ Relative Such situations are clearly difficult and complex. The issue may not only be of whether people have capacity to decide, but also whether they always want to. What this highlights – and it cannot be regarded as an isolated
141
Supporting people example – is the importance of having in place an agreed ethical procedure in line with the values of person-centred support. It is not difficult to see what problems may be caused otherwise.
Barriers to independence A second problem which service users and practitioners identified was parents and other family members who did not support service users’ desire to live more independently. This reinforces findings from other research. In general, professional carers [paid workers] believed strongly that adults could learn recursively [through breaking a problem up into simpler parts and trying to solve it bit by bit], while family carers in our sample, including those who were prepared to give the adult freedom of the locality, considered that their relatives had reached the limits of their potential capabilities. (Heyman et al, 1998, p 206) Service users talked about the way that parents’ fears for their children’s well-being and their desire to protect them and avoid risk, could get in the way of them becoming more independent. They said: And this is another problem, I want to go to independent flats that are just over the road from us, but my mum doesn’t think I would cope in them, so I’m having a really big fight to try and get there at the moment, because that’s what I want and not what she wants. Because Pippin Close is trying to maintain our independence, but where she wants me to go when I finish at Pippin Close – next door – they’re going to take all that independence away. Service user I would like to have my own space. [His parents said no] They were worried about me. They think I might hurt myself. They said they wouldn’t want to see me again [if I move out]. Service user It took a long time. I had to wait until after they [my parents] died to get married. Service user
142
Social care and carers
Because I am new here, my mum at the moment doesn’t think I can do some of the things I am doing and she doesn’t like the fact that I am trying. It makes it very difficult. Service user
Practitioners gave examples of how parents and other relatives had influenced service users and discouraged them from living more independently. The service user sometimes feels very vulnerable, you know, and we have to try and support what the service user wants where families are coming in quite heavy and saying, ‘You’re ok, you don’t need to move out into the community. You’re fine here in a large group home.’ Practitioner And then there’s the families. I took someone to look around and she was all for it. Her mum and sister came on the scene and now she doesn’t want to know. ‘No it’s not for me.’ That’s because mum and sister have said ‘Stay here.’ Practitioner Sometimes it’s hard to implement what people want to do because they are very much under the wings of their parents and support workers. Sometimes the parents are a wee bit nervous to let them go and grow and develop. Practitioner
When a service user has not been used to making their own decisions and choices, because their parents had done it for them, services sometimes had to offer additional support to increase their confidence. This could take a lot of time and effort. The idea of having what you want and working towards it, can be a bit frightening. Practitioner When people aren’t getting choices at home, they walk about expecting people to make decisions for them. Many users don’t know what they want at the start, but as their confidence grows, they get more ideas. Practitioner
We were told that many relatives were worried about the risks service users might face if they moved out of a residential service, or had to make more decisions for themselves.
143
Supporting people
[Parents] don’t want their youngsters to move on from there [the day centre], because they’re in a very safe environment. Practitioner [Family members say] ‘She can’t make decisions,’ but she can, and she can make wrong ones. Of course, there is an envelope of security but you can’t force people to eat healthily, you can only persuade and encourage. Manager
Some people working in services felt that part of the problem was that some parents did not view their adult-age children as grown-ups able to make their own choices and decisions. I don’t think they can quite grasp that the young people are adults now. They have been responsible for them for so long. For example, one lady has just moved in and we have been assessing her for going out in her electric chair and her family are quite adamant [that] she could not do it, but she is great in that chair. She wanted to do it and we gave her the opportunity. Our role is to promote their independence and parents can find that hard. Practitioner We have [encouraged over-protectiveness] because we haven’t challenged it. By our actions, we have gone along with that…. It’s about trying to make [parents] understand that no one has that responsibility. Or that we all have a bit, [but the service user is] an adult, not a defenceless child. But there is no black and white. Manager
The parallel problems for families Our project made clear how great the pressures on parents and other family members could be as ‘carers’. ‘Informal carers’ often have the main responsibility for providing support for disabled people and other service users. Often carers in our project felt that their role and responsibilities were not recognised or valued. Given that governments have largely seen them as a resource to be used, rather than as signifying the need for more and better support for service users, this is hardly surprising. Despite the emphasis on ‘informal care’ and ‘carers’ over the last 30 and more years, most people taking on these tasks still lack the information, advice, support and advocacy to be best able to advance the rights and needs of service users. The parallel difficulties 144
Social care and carers
they themselves face hardly make it easy for them to support service users’ autonomy, especially as this may be at odds with their own. As Bob Heyman and his colleagues observed in their study of people with learning difficulties: Professionals ask a great deal of family carers when they seek to persuade them to modify patterns of behaviour which have protected close relatives from the terrors of the modern world. (Heyman et al, 1998, p 214) Simplistic responses to this issue which simply blame ‘the carers’ are unlikely to be helpful or advance ‘person-centred support’.
The effect of broader barriers The response of families to service users’ needs and situation also needs to be put in broader context. It needs, for example, to be put in context with the longstanding shortcomings of support services. One manager said that many parents misunderstood the ways his service worked. It did not tell its users what to think or do, as relatives sometimes thought. However, he conceded that the service itself had contributed to this problem in the past because of the paternalistic way in which it was run. Some [parents] feel we are fostering people, but we are not. We are providing a service. It is particularly difficult to get across when that is the way [the homes] have been run. Manager
Travel In some services, we were told that relatives were particularly concerned about service users travelling independently on public transport. A manager from a rural service, for instance, said parents were worried about service users travelling long distances. One service user, for example, began using buses when he got a job, instead of taking taxis, as he had previously done. His parents were contacted by a worried friend who had seen him on the bus. Becoming anxious, they stopped him travelling by bus. The service involved, however, had assessed the risk as low and were supporting the individual to use the bus as this was his express wish. A practitioner from another area told of a worrying incident experienced on the way to a conference which we had organised. 145
Supporting people
While it actually strengthened his commitment to independent travel for the service users he worked with, it does highlight the disabling barriers still associated with public transport. I mentioned earlier that I was late here and that was because of the tube system here [in London]. I got on the tube, the door shut behind me and [the two service users] were still on the station. So I was frantically calling transport police and we were looking at the camera trying to spot them – and they made their [own] way here. I was thinking how on earth could they make their way here? I couldn’t believe it. But now I know we could definitely do independent travel because, I know he won’t mind me saying these things, but his dad is dead set against it and he lives maybe three miles from where we are based. Practitioner
Parents’ concerns about the future Some family members who we spoke to during the project expressed concerns about the future of their disabled children. They worried about what would become of their children when they died, or were no longer able to look after them. It is not clear whether these concerns were solely about the safety and security of their children or included ideas and hopes of them living more independently in the future. For example: I have seven children and I worry what is going to happen to my disabled child. Carer/relative
They talked of their hopes for ‘responsible’ services that would support their children when they were no longer there for them. We should remember that these were views of parents who were sometimes criticised by services for being a barrier to change and not supporting their children to develop independent living skills. This contradiction – that such services might sometimes themselves inhibit the independence of people with learning difficulties, reflects the complexity of these issues and also perhaps the lack of support and preparation families are given to help their children become more independent when they are on their own.
146
Social care and carers
Overcoming the barriers We have already seen how services and practitioners could overcome some of the problems created by the competing concerns of service users and their families. This included offering service users advocacy and support, as well as providing safe opportunities for negotiation with relatives and treating family members with sensitivity and ensuring they had the information and support they needed. All these could help overcome barriers that might develop in the way of personcentred support and independent living between service users and their families. Practitioners and managers also highlighted two other approaches which helped resolve difficulties – enabling families to meet and learn from other families, where service users have moved on to independent living, and involving families to understand and support independent living. Both are essentially about offering information and involvement – two key elements here, as we have already seen.
Meeting other families One practitioner, for example, talked about the way that the families of residents living in their residential home, could benefit from talking with the families of service users who had already been through the process of moving to more independent living. Families who lacked experience of disabled people living successfully in their own flats or houses would learn from this. Our families need to speak to other families that have gone through this so the empathy is there. ‘Three years ago this was me saying this. Now my son or daughter [has moved on] and I’m quite happy.’ Practitioner
Involving families in change Several participants spoke about involving families directly in personcentred planning or in dialogue about changes to the service as a route to reassuring them and overcoming barriers. They saw such involvement as promoting an understanding both of what the service user wanted and the support that would be available to help make things work. With this knowledge, the relatives had been reassured and had then engaged more in the process, often in constructive and helpful ways.
147
Supporting people
There was a lot of resistance at first, but I think slowly an acceptance of it. Because of the process, the person-centred reviews and the fact that they know the Trust is serious. Manager Families were so much involved [in the reviews] and they welcomed that – being able to have their input and being listened to. Everything was opened up to discussion. There were no hidden agendas. It was about their views, their future, their need…. People get very worried. They hear a lot of horror stories of people living out in the community without the correct support and everything going wrong. When we identify what that person needs to make it work, they get a different picture altogether…. I think they saw it black and white and didn’t look at the full picture of what it could be. Practitioner The person-centred reviews have brought parents back into the fold in most cases…. Parents have quite a good feeling about what is happening. Manager A lot of families are like, ‘Over my dead body.’ It’s their choice at the end of the day, you know. But creating a person-centred view is an ideal platform for families to listen to [service users], because people are giving from their perspective, so you’ve got [the] professional perspective, you’ve got key worker perspective, you’ve got the day centre’s, a lot of people’s perspectives there and you can facilitate these views. You know, you’ve got really frosty families to start with and all of a sudden, half way through the review, they are sat there thinking ‘Oh I didn’t know that,’ and they’ve learned so much about [the person] and their views, because that person’s been empowered, supported by everyone to say what they want. Practitioner
The report into the work in Camchester around end of life care came up with a number of recommendations to make end of life care more person-centred. One focused specifically on the need for more discussion about death and dying (Fleming et al, 2011, p 4). There should be a more general openness about the subject of death for all people. Efforts should be made to promote an earlier consideration of end of life choices among the general public. 148
Social care and carers
Where there isn’t family support We have heard about some of the barriers in the way of personcentred support that can be created by service users’ family members. Service users and practitioners also highlighted a different set of problems that could also arise where service users did not have family members involved in their lives. It is important to remember family can also be one of the greatest supporters and advocates of people’s independence and that having family members to turn to could offer many and real benefits to people as service users. We heard a lot about what a family could offer people as service users. One of the important roles family members played in the lives of many service users was providing advocacy or support. Thus people’s relations can be a source of advocacy, as well sometimes as creating the need for it. Some practitioners and managers talked about the problems faced by service users who may have difficulties getting their voices heard, but have no family or friends available to provide support or advocacy. Their eligibility criteria for the people who can get services and those who can’t – the rules are changing, so people who need the most support who don’t have much of a voice because their families aren’t connected with the service, they will not be able to get the help, and I worry about those people because if their families or their carers are not fighting the system, then [those service users] are going to lose out. Because the way services work, like any organisation, it’s about money and if they haven’t got money, they want to push people out the door, they don’t want new people coming in. I’m worried about those people and I’m in a difficult position, because I work for social services, but I care about those people and I’m an advocate. Not known
While there is now widespread recognition of the crucial importance of skilled, independent advocacy to support service users, it continues to be in short supply. I use the word advocacy, when people for whatever reason don’t know how to get assistance, how to deal with it. There needs to be supported services and advocacy for disabled people. It’s an absolute crucial thing, and there’s money available it’s true, and advocacy is something that needs
149
Supporting people
to be homed in on, as far as improvement of services [is concerned]. Not known
We heard that in many areas the availability of citizen advocacy was limited. Research suggests that this picture is fairly typical of the provision of advocacy in the UK more generally. Advocacy exists, in principle, for all user groups. However, it is far from universal in practice and is simply not there for everyone who needs it. Who has access to advocacy, is often decided by a combination of historical, geographical and financial factors. (Atkinson, 1999, p 19) [Access to advocacy] remains difficult for people living alone in their own homes with restricted mobility, and even more so for people living in residential homes. (Atkinson, 1999, p 21) According to this research and it reflects earlier findings, people from black and minority ethnic communities and people with dementia, are likely to have particular difficulty accessing advocacy. Many of the services involved in our project found it difficult to devote sufficient staff time to supporting service users in this way. There are also potential conflicts of interest for practitioners to act as advocates for service users, particularly if the service user is in dispute with the service the practitioner is employed by. We are not suggesting that family members are always the best advocates for service users. But where they aren’t available and no formal alternative is on offer, service users are doubly disadvantaged.
The problem with ‘informal care’ For more than 30 years, successive governments and policymakers have reframed disabled people’s and other service users’ families and friends as their ‘carers’. The increasing expectation is that as ‘carers’ they should have a major role and responsibility in ‘looking after’ older and disabled people. This has been despite the damaging effects this can have for both groups, as their rights, needs and choices are restricted and left unmet. It also takes no account of the kinds of divisions between services, families and service users that participants in our project highlighted. 150
Social care and carers
Jenny Morris, has said that, for many disabled people, the term ‘care’ assumes dependence and has meant others taking charge of and controlling service users, restricting their autonomy. She challenges the way the competing meanings of ‘care’ are blurred and misrepresented. It does not mean to ‘care about’ someone, in the sense of loving them. Rather it means to ‘care for’ someone, in the sense of taking responsibility, taking charge of them…. We need to reclaim the words ‘care’ and ‘caring’ to mean ‘love’ to mean ‘caring about’ someone rather than ‘caring for’, with its custodial overtones. (Morris, 1993, pp 150, 174) It is not the ideas and values of mutuality, commitment and affection that such disabled people and service users reject in ‘care’, but what in practice has been the inherent inequality underpinning it. They are also critical of the way in which historically the views of those looking after them, rather than their own views have been prioritised. It has often been suggested that disabled people and service user movements have been polarised against informal carers. They argue instead that it is the social construction of informal carers of which they are critical, because of the way in which it reframes relationships between parent and child, partners and siblings in unequal terms of carer/cared for. Reliance on family members for support often limits the autonomy of both the service user and the carer. It may diminish personal relationships, rather than be a positive expression of them. Writers like Jenny Morris also make clear the reciprocity that exists within relationships between disabled people and family members and highlight how many disabled people also have caring responsibilities, both as parents and with other adults. They highlight the way in which the care system can both reinforce the over-protectiveness of family members and create barriers in the way of them advocating for the independence of service users. This has been highlighted in this chapter. The reality is that governments have increasingly emphasised the role of informal carers in social care as a means of holding down costs and expenditure and limiting state responsibility. The message from our findings is that this is unlikely to be consistent with moving to more person-centred practice and philosophy. It is also becoming increasingly untenable, as the demand for support is estimated to increase and the supply of both paid and unpaid ‘carers’, looks set to diminish.
151
Supporting people
Summary Government social care policy has placed increasing reliance on the support provided by family and friends as ‘informal carers’. This emerges as another major barrier restricting independent living and person-centred support. Serious problems are highlighted of families speaking for service users, restricting their say, limiting their involvement in decision-making and limiting opportunities for them to live more independently. The issues that emerge are difficult and complex, for example, when culturally different roles and expectations are involved and when service users’ views are subordinated in the making of important health and medical decisions, as is apparent from two case studies. Parents and other family members often do not receive adequate information or support to facilitate service users’ independence, yet may have the lead responsibility to support them. As a result they may be risk averse, as well as being fearful for the future. Key ways of overcoming these barriers include offering service users advocacy and support, as well as providing safe opportunities for negotiation with relatives and treating family members with sensitivity and ensuring they have the information and support they need. This is likely to encourage person-centred support and independent living. Practitioners and managers also highlighted two other approaches which helped overcome difficulties – both essentially about offering information and involvement. These were enabling families to meet and learn from other families, where service users have moved on to independent living and involving families in services to understand and support independent living. Where service users do not have families or friends to help, there can be other barriers to person-centred support for want of adequate good quality advocacy services, which are still in short supply. Reliance on support from families as informal carers, for want of adequate formal services and support, undermines relationships and obstructs person-centred support and independent living. While governments have seen unpaid carers as a resource to keep down the costs of social care, this is unlikely to be a sustainable policy in the longer term as supply is not expected to match growing demand. It is also clearly inconsistent with extending person-centred support.
152
Social care and carers
References Atkinson, D. (1999) Advocacy: A review, Brighton: Pavilion Publishing. Buckner, L. and Yeandle, S. (2007) Valuing carers: Calculating the value of unpaid care, London: Carers UK. DH (Department of Health) (2008) Carers at the heart of twenty-first century family and community: A caring system on your side, a life of your own (The Carers’ Strategy), London: DH. DRC (Disability Rights Commission) (2007) Changing Britain for good: Putting disability at the heart of public policy, London: DRC. Fleming, J., Glynn, M., Griffin, R., Beresford, P., Bewley, C., Branfield, F., Croft, S. and Postle, K. (2011) Person-centred support: Choices for end of life care, London: Shaping Our Lives. Glendinning, C. and Arksey, H. (2008) ‘Informal care’, in P. Alcock, M. May and K. Rowlingson (eds) The student’s companion to social policy (3rd edn), Oxford: Blackwell, pp 219-25. Hampshire County Council (2008) Getting personal: A fair deal for better care and support.The report of Hampshire County Council’s Commission of Inquiry into personalisation and the future of adult social care, Winchester: Hampshire County Council. Heyman, B., Huckle, S. and Handyside, E. (1998) ‘Freedom of the locality for people with learning difficulties’, in B. Heyman (ed) Risk, health and health care, London: Arnold, pp 199-214. Morris, J. (1993) Independent lives: Community care and disabled people, Basingstoke: Macmillan. Twigg, J. (1989) ‘Models of carers: how do social care agencies conceptualise their relationship with informal carers?’, Journal of Social Policy, vol 18, no 1, pp 53-66.
153
SIX
Institutionalisation There are stories of our elders who are vegetarians being provided with meat dishes from the meals on wheels service … of an Asian elder, a Hindu living in a residential home, being given beef. There is a lack of respect, inadequate provision for dietary needs, skin and hair care, language and emotional needs…. The list is endless. … ranging from specific matters such as ‘teeth keep getting lost’ and ‘her hearing aid never works’ to a general comment that care was not good enough. (Harding and Beresford, 1996, p 28) STANDARD SIX: COMBATING INSTITUTIONALISATION
Services should support, rather than restrict the human and civil rights of service users. They need to be consistent with human rights and anti-discrimination legislation as well as the Mental Capacity Act. They need to promote service users’ choice and control and resist pressures to institutionalisation, particularly associated with residential and segregated services.
Introduction In the last chapter, where we focused on ‘informal care’, a tension emerged between people making their own decisions and living independently, on the one hand and, having decisions made for them and being dependent on their families, on the other. This discussion is developed further here, where we look at problems of institutionalisation – the antithesis of independent living and person-centred support – and what works to overcome the barriers associated with it. Institutionalisation was first associated with the large ‘total’ institutions, like work houses and ‘lunatic asylums’ established in the 19th century (Goffman, 1968). People are socialised into the rules, 155
Supporting people
requirements, routines, restrictions and values of such institutionalised living. It not only limits their lives, but also creates long term damage that makes it difficult for them to live differently. Features associated with institutionalisation include: • • • • • •
people’s rigid categorisation being segregated being lumped together the provision of merely physical maintenance group living standardised routines
Colin Barnes has described the effects of institutionalisation on disabled people in these terms: In many cases they are confined to a residential institution and kept from making the most basic of decisions and deprived of the opportunities which able-bodied people take for granted (Brisenden 1985). Disabled people in such places suffer loss of social skills and self-confidence…. The organisation of these services risks their being sucked into a culture of dependence. (Barnes, 1991, p 129) The move to community care starting in the 1950s and culminating in the 1990 National Health Service and Community Care Act, can be seen as a key response to institutionalisation. However, Enoch Powell, in the early 1960s, as Minister of Health, highlighted its durability in his famous ‘water towers’ speech, which was intended to herald the end of the big institutions: There they stand, isolated, majestic, imperious, brooded over by the gigantic water-tower and chimney combined, rising unmistakable and daunting out of the countryside – the asylums which our forefathers built with such immense solidity to express the notions of their day. Do not for a moment underestimate their powers of resistance to our assault. Let me describe some of the defences which we have to storm. (Powell, 1961) By then it was already apparent that institutionalisation was not an issue confined to the large old Victorian establishments. It has long been recognised as a major problem in relation to long-term use of health 156
Institutionalisation
and social care services more generally. Early discussions focused on the damaging effects of life in large institutions. More recently there has been increasing awareness that such problems can extend to many more kinds of group settings, small as well as large, including day services. It can even include living in your own home, when this is restructured and institutionalised by services limiting how people can live, for example, when they can get up and go to bed, get dressed, eat, go to the lavatory and even whether they can go out. In this chapter, we focus on the institutionalising problems people face who live in residential services, or who use social care services for long periods of time. In these contexts particularly, we see how institutionalisation is still a major problem for service users in contemporary social care services. It emerges as another major barrier standing in the way of person-centred support. In 2007, there were 18,577 registered care homes for adults of all ages, with 441,958 places (CSCI, 2008, p 10). The equivalent figures for 2008 were 18,541 care homes run by private and voluntary organisations and the council providing 450,000 places for adults of all ages (CSCI, 2009, p vi). This is still much more than the number of service users accessing direct payments or individual budgets. Many disabled and older people live for extensive periods in residential services. Some may spend their whole life in them. A significant number of the service users we spoke with, lived in residential services. Person-centred support poses significant challenges for residential services. These include keeping a high ratio of staff to service users and maintaining one-to-one support. Person-centred support represents a cultural challenge to the values and operating conditions of many residential services. As Hazel Kemshall has stated: Residential care creates and maintains enforced dependency, with the process of institutionalisation fostering passivity and de-individualising residents. (Kemshall, 2002, p 75) The issue of whether residential services can ever be truly compatible with person-centred support, continues to be heavily disputed. While there are examples of high quality residential and related provision which do offer choice and control, they tend to be exceptional, expensive and outside the financial range supported by the state or affordable for most service users. The tendency of long-term residential care, for example, for older people, tends to be disempowering and institutionalising (Bowers et al, 2009).
157
Supporting people
Institutionalisation is still a factor in the welfare of large numbers of people in the UK today. It can have a number of different negative effects on their lives. These effects were identifiable in a number of the services we worked with. A middle-aged man using a service for people with learning difficulties, told us how he and fellow residents were treated at meal times at their home. We are not allowed to talk to people on the other table. We wait for staff to finish their tea. When staff get up, they say what people are on the rota to do. You can’t get up until the staff say so. Service user
A group of service users living in residential homes talked about the qualities they associated with good staff. They offered a commentary on their negative experiences, as well as highlighting how they would like services to operate, to enable them to live with freedom and choice. Good staff let you go out and about, as long as they know where you are and that you are safe. Good staff support you to do what you want, as long as you are safe. Good staff support you to cook your tea.
Collective disempowerment Group living seemed to create its own problems for service users. Being part of a large group, in practice often resulted in a lack of individual choice or opportunity. In some cases, staff seemed to contribute to these problems, instead of being able to transcend them. Well they are looking after us. We are in their care, so I don’t know that we have to make decisions, because they make them all, don’t they, for our benefit? Service user We try to make it not institutionalised, but we still have to have certain rules like meal times. Practitioner There is also the question of identity as well. People lose identities within institutions and I think unless you have a 158
Institutionalisation
clear idea of your own identity and who you are as a person, that is very difficult. Not known
Many people we spoke to, who lived in residential homes, expressed strong feelings of disempowerment. People might be more powerful than you. Instead of you having the power, they [the service workers] take the power away and you’re thinking ‘I can’t do this.’ Service user When you are in a nursing home, you are not allowed to take any control over anything you do. I feel as though I have got my life back coming here [in supported accommodation for older people]. People speak and they’re heard and you hold conversations. That’s the biggest contrast. Service user
Even the layout and equipment of homes sometimes contributed to people’s institutionalisation. One unit opened an extended and refurbished kitchen. It had previously been too small and was inaccessible according to service users. The new kitchen had height adjustable work surfaces. Service users were very happy with it. One resident told us that she had spent the first day washing up, because the design of all previous kitchens she had used had prevented her from ever washing up before. Another said: At last they are thinking about new equipment for people to use that is accessible to them, special knives and stuff. Service user
Barriers to change The limitations of domiciliary care could push people into institutions. A social worker described the problems she faced finding domiciliary providers for new service users, particularly if they needed two care assistants each visit. The care agency says, ‘We can’t do this, can’t do that,’ which restricts the person from living in their house, which has caused quite a lot of tension. So clients have to go to a residential home temporarily, or possibly long term, because we can’t get the care for them in the community…. In an ideal situation, you’d want people to be able to have choice 159
Supporting people
about when they get up, when they go to bed and things like that, but the reality is that we’re saying, ‘The only time we can get you up is 11 o’clock.’ Practitioner
Participants pointed to broader reasons for the inadequacy of domiciliary services. That is it. It is a logistic[al issue] isn’t it and there is only a finite number of people available. Not known … Probably because there are not always the resources to actually go in to someone at night at 11 o’clock. Not known
However, it was when people came to moving on from residential services that issues of institutionalisation, dependency and disempowerment became most apparent. Participants in our project emphasised how difficult it could be for service users to make the move from residential care to independent living. This followed from both an inheritance of institutionalising practices in provision and its enduring effects on people as service users. I think it is an institutional problem, [Name of home] has been there for 40 years and was run along very old fashioned lines until about three years ago. So there are a lot of things that need to change, to empower the service users to take part in the running of the service, to realise that they can complain and also tell us how good the service is, mainly, that it is their service and they can take part in the running of it. Manager I work in a service where we have people who have been there for a long, long time. Some have been there for 20 or 30 years. It is very common for a lot of our service users to have been at the service for that length of time. For them to change from being in a position where they were told what their care would be and what would happen, to then having more involvement in it, must be quite difficult for them. We are still in the process of trying to overcome those barriers. Practitioner They have lived together for a long time and been conditioned into this way of living, so it is difficult to for them to visualise 160
Institutionalisation
another way of living. They get excited about it. They say, ‘I want this,’ but then when you chat, it comes to light that, perhaps, ‘I don’t want to live by myself.’ Practitioner There really is a lack of opportunity for people to spread their wings and become more independent. Practitioner
As one practitioner put it, making choices requires self-confidence which some service users have not had the chance to develop. Now there is pressure for a different more participatory way of working, but many service users are not equipped to respond to it. The disempowerment of the service user can then appear to be the problem, but it is the service system which has created and perpetuated it. Often it is the person themselves who we are working with, whose life experience has changed to a degree that they have reduced their world to a size where they maybe don’t have the confidence to take a risk. To step out of the comfort box, to step out of the world which they have decided is a size they can deal with and they can function in it comfortably. It is often their home or a room they live in and while they are in there, they can do it. Practitioner They have the chances and choices, but they choose not to. It’s self confidence. You offer them courses. There are chances to find out. It’s whether they want to find out. Practitioner
One service user described how difficult he found moving from a residential home to his own flat. Thirty years is a long time in a residential home. I’m very happy now. I’ve got my own flat.… At the beginning, it was a bit daunting. I remember the day I moved in. I was all alone. I was used to living with other people. I could move into a new world…. I have freedom to do what I want to do. I used to live in a residential home. Now I have my own bungalow. I get 24-hour care. I don’t have to rely on different carers, or have to wait. I employ people directly. I’m more in charge now. It is my life. Service user
161
Supporting people
Some practitioners stressed that the length of time people had used a service and their age, were important factors to consider when considering a move to independent living. I wish it was done a bit earlier. Some [service users] are in their 60s and 70s already. Practitioner It’s like trying to teach an old dog new tricks…. Before, we were told, they weren’t allowed to do these things. Practitioner
We heard how daunting and frightening it could be to move out of residential care, or even from one type of supported living to one with less support. Many service users had become accustomed to a certain level of support and found it hard to imagine how they could manage with less. Great sensitivity is clearly needed to ensure that what is offered is support rather than just pressure for change. They need to experience living on their own. They can’t imagine, have no concept of what it would entail…. It’s fear of the unknown too. There is an awful lot of work to be done with residents and families. No one likes to do something without practising. Practitioner [The service users] have assured tenancies and that is the most precious thing to them. There is a sense of a lot of things being taken away from them, like the cleaner and cooking. They are stuck, are really hanging on to their assured tenancy. It’s challenging to work with people who don’t want to move and I do try to respect that. But when I have worked in a really person-centred way with one lady, who I thought would never leave, she began to believe in her own strength. From a lady who spent almost all day lying on a sofa smoking, we got her motivated to move somewhere with less support and she realised a dream that she never thought would happen. Practitioner
Residential homes and day care services readily foster dependence in service users. By taking over tasks from people and not encouraging independent living, many services either de-skill service users, or do little to prepare them to live more independently. After a period of time,
162
Institutionalisation
service users may not want, or be able to leave, what one participant described as, the ‘cocoon’ of the institution. You have a lot of people who don’t really want to do things. They are just happy with the way things are. They don’t want to come out of that cocoon, because that is how they were brought up. With people saying ‘no’ to them. They don’t have the confidence to go out and see what is available for them.’ Practitioner I don’t know how to express it, but if I said institutionalised thinking [that would sum it up]. You know, ‘We have always done it this way.…’ Not known They are institutionalised, they have that day service mindset…. For some people they stay with the same service. It is frustrating for [new] people you know, who need the service. Practitioner
At one service we worked with, there was no culture of people moving on to live more independently, however young they were. A new manager there said that she had done a work placement at the same home over 20 years earlier. She observed: [There are] only three people different after all that time. [It is] stuck in a time warp. Manager
At another home [for 10 people] run by the same organisation, a service user told us he had lived there since it had first opened. That is about 14 years ago. Everyone who initially moved here, is still here apart from one person. Service user
A disabled man explained how he was ready to make more decisions, but living in a home made it difficult. I would like to arrange things and make appointments, but I can’t seem to do these, and I like arranging things…. I don’t get a chance. Service user
163
Supporting people
Addressing institutionalisation Overcoming the institutionalising effects of services is both a key task for person-centred support, as well as a pre-condition for its practice. People working at one residential service, for example, spoke about trying to move away from an institutional approach, towards being more person-centred. We are trying to get away from seeing the residents as some homogeneous mass. Manager Rather than doing, we are letting them do. It’s nice to see them doing things for themselves. They are all quite capable, every single one of them. When they were at home, they used to do more. [One woman used to cook and do painting and decorating before she moved to the home.] When she came to [the home], it was taken away from her. Practitioner
Two examples highlight both the possibilities and problems of trying to overcome dependency that has been imposed on people. Workers in one residential service, told us about an idea which worked well. This was an initiative which paired residents with learning difficulties with others who were living more independently and managing their own tenancies with support. Residents were subsequently involved in individual person-centred reviews to build on this work and establish where they would like to live in the future. This included the type of accommodation and who, if anyone, they might like to live with. I think it has empowered them to speak up. Eighteen months ago, they wouldn’t have been able to say how they feel, or what the future might look like. But now, they have more of an idea and don’t feel intimidated to say. That’s been a really big break through. Practitioner It didn’t sink in. There was a lack of understanding. [Now service users think] ‘I can live like that if I want.’ It gave a taste. It was the flavour, the direction as an organisation, that we needed. Practitioner It’s amazing actually. Now if we go out and there are houses up for sale people say, ‘Oh that’s nice. I wonder how many bedrooms it has.’ ... They like to look in catalogues for 164
Institutionalisation
furniture and other items they might want for their house. Even 18 months ago, they would never have thought of looking at things in that way. It’s quite enlightening. Practitioner At one day centre, however, we heard from practitioners about a change which did not work, but instead upset many service users. Practitioners said that previously a hairdresser had come into the day centre to cut service users’ hair. They said she made a large profit and offered no choice, ‘Doing everyone’s hair the same.’ Practitioner
As part of a scheme to encourage service users to use mainstream services in their communities, the management of the service discouraged the hairdresser from coming to the centre. That went on for about a year. We had management committee meetings – special meetings. We had petitions and protests. It all became a negative, to be fighting against that. People get scared of change…. Practitioner Oh, yes, sometimes if felt like a battle. Some people were in a mind-set that it’s always been like this, so why has it got to change? And they tend to fight against it no matter how you try to encourage them. It takes time to get people to look at things in a positive way. Practitioner
Managers and practitioners took this step to tackle what they saw as the segregation of disabled people. They attributed service users’ initially negative reaction to their institutionalisation and distrust of change. But given that they imposed the change, another expression of institutionalisation, we might wonder whether it wouldn’t have worked better to begin with, if service users had been more involved.
Overcoming institutionalisation Progress is being made in services to overcome institutionalisation. A number of different ways of achieving this emerged. Service users and workers highlighted the value of learning from other people’s successes. They said that many service users were not aware of what might be possible. For example, by meeting people who had their own tenancies, or received direct payments, they could gain greater
165
Supporting people
confidence to consider what might be possible for them and make informed decisions about their own futures. However, in [another] council, we have seen a day centre, entire buildings closing down, the staff being used in a different way, in a person-centred manner and it has been a fantastic success. It has been a very, very intricate process, where the staff were involved. There was a lot of work that has gone into it and there have been two or three very focused, driven managers involved in this process. Manager If some people did move and it was proved that it worked, that would really get some confidence for other people and families and staff. We have some people who are pretty desperate to move. Practitioner
Training and capacity building Some staff continued to see a lack of challenge from service users as meaning they were satisfied with things as they were. This view was articulated by one manager, who argued that users of a residential service had not complained of institutionalisation. He understood that the service was not consistent with current thinking about good practice, but insisted that the residents were “happy”. If nothing happened, I don’t think the residents would be any wiser. They would still be happy here in 10 years’ time, I’m sure they would. Manager
Training to overcome the institutionalising effect of services, emerged as key. This included training and capacity building for both service workers and service users. Practitioners from some residential services admitted that they had never received any training on how to support disabled people to move on to live more independently. There’s been loads of training from [outside agencies]. POVA [Protection of Vulnerable Adults], PoCA [Protection of Children Act], health and safety, moving and handling, food hygiene, and grievances. But nothing about independent living. Practitioner
166
Institutionalisation
But other participants made clear that changing attitudes among service users were already having an effect. A practitioner working with younger disabled people said that different approaches in education, promoting independent living, were having an impact on younger people’s expectations of services. I think the schools and colleges do promote self advocacy and life skills and communication skills, so they come here with that and they are quite capable of saying what they want. They are brought up with more of an expectation they should have a say and be listened to. Practitioner
This service actively looked for young people who were motivated to move on and live active lives when it had vacancies. We don’t have a formal check list, but you have something in your head. Ideally we would only offer a place [here] to someone who is going to take full advantage of the extra staff and the independent living skills, so people are perhaps well motivated to move on and live in their own home, but need some extra input to help them get their independent living skills, who are going to college or in to a work placement. People who come here are expected to have college or work to go to. Manager
Support for service users However, many service users needed support and preparation to move on to more independent living. Service users said: We do our laundry and do our room. We are encouraged to do things. Service user You have to watch your hours. But I don’t understand the hours. I need someone to tell me, to show me the hours, but they haven’t done that yet. Service user I want to move to independent living. In a place of my own with help and support…. I don’t feel I’m getting the right information or help what it’s all about, or what type of support I need. Service user
167
Supporting people
Practitioners said: Disabled people need more training for them to be more confident. You can have [a] person-centred approach, but if people aren’t willing to confront and say,‘This is what I want,’ it’s not going to happen, is it? Practitioner You can’t drop it on somebody – ‘In two months’ time you will be living in a bungalow with two people…’ You can’t do it. Practitioner
One manager explained that in a previous job, she had supported long-term residents in a ‘home for blind people’ to move on to live ‘in the community’. The residents had been there for between 25 and 30 years. The process took about three years and the service employed a rehabilitation officer. Another manager explained that the process of change would be demanding because: The Trust don’t have a great deal of experience in working with people with learning difficulties in an independent or semi-independent environment. Manager
Workers in another service explained that they held regular events to promote independent living. They were events that brought together many different people and helped them to talk about and make plans for doing things for themselves. One of the things that we organise in our area are what we call ‘moving on events’.... That is three-monthly events where service providers, commissioners of services, service users, family carers, all come together and the reason that they are called moving on workshops is it is about how do we support people in a more person-centred way to move on in anything that they want to do. They are really enjoyable get-togethers and I think pretty useful as well, because people usually say how much they have enjoyed it and how useful they found it. Not known
168
Institutionalisation
CASE STUDY SUPPORTING YOUNG DISABLED PEOPLE TO MOVE ON The residential home for young people, Pippin Close, saw itself as preparing residents for independent living. A manager described how the service was commissioned. They wanted a stepping stone to avoid so many young people ending up in residential care. They recognised to do that would cost money, as it would have to have additional staffing, so that people could do the sorts of things we have been talking about – going to the pub and whatever it might be. The fees here are half as expensive again as the fees next door [a residential home for adults aged over 25], but they recognised that they would only be funding it for a short period of time. People can only be here a few years. The investment was worth it for the long-term gain for them in cash terms, but also for the quality of life of the young people. Manager Service users spoke very positively about how this home helped people feel ready to move on to live independently, by trying to model this in its own practice. It’s really important that we have the opportunity and choice of what we do and how we do it. It’s important that people support us to change negative things into positive ones. Service user [It is like] everyday life, but in one of these buildings. Service user Yes, it has made me a lot stronger person. I can see myself moving out, getting my own flat and getting a job in the future, doing all the normal stuff that a teenager would do. Service user I am much more independent than I was before. It is the best place I have been. It has been the best time of my life. The support has given me the confidence to do things I would not have done before. Service user I really like it, it’s better than where I was before. Service user
169
Supporting people Although these last comments are very positive, it is important to remember that people’s baseline and expectations were often very low. Also, not all their comments on this matter were as positive about this particular service. I was walking and had no problems, didn’t fall or anything, but they said the staff’s backs are sore and all that from picking you up…. I didn’t feel that was sticking to what I believe in and sometimes the support for going out to work isn’t available either. I thought that was the whole point of the place – to develop your independence and plan for your future. I don’t feel there is enough time to plan those sort of things. Service user Some staff stressed the need for service users to improve their social skills. But I think part of the planning can instigate the need for socialisation, especially for people with say, learning difficulties, because they tend to sort of form a peer group of their own, because their communication skills with other people is difficult. Practitioner An awful lot of it [independent living] is maturity and getting on with other people, and [developing] their social skills. Manager A social worker who had made referrals to Pippin Close, thought it was best for young people who were interested in developing skills for independent living. She said it was a good stepping stone to establish themselves and then move on. She felt that choices open to young people with physical impairments were limited and that independent living was more realistic when they were a little older. However, young people have to leave Pippin Close before their 25th birthday. This could create another set of problems for service users. The goal of independent living was blurred by the need for ‘throughput’. One service user expressed his worries about the short term nature of the service when he spoke about what he wanted when he moved out. Something that I feel is home, I haven’t found home yet. Pippin Close is like a stepping stone, to lead up to the next stage. Service user
Participants highlighted three additional problems which they thought contributed to service users’ dependence and kept them institutionalised and in institutions. These were their restricted access to:
170
Institutionalisation
• employment • money • housing Each of these barriers could have an enormous effect, restricting people’s lives. Often they operated in close interrelation, limiting service users’ daily opportunities and their hopes for the future.
Employment A small number of service users made specific and explicit comments that they felt that disabled people were discriminated against and not given a fair chance when they are looking for work. It seems impossible to get a job for a lot of people, even with Access To Work and the DDA [the Disability Discrimination Act]. There is no way of proving discrimination when you apply for a job as a disabled person…. It is pointless giving interviews unless you are positively considering employing them. It gets people’s hopes up…. A lot of younger [disabled] people are desperate to work. I don’t think there is an equal opportunity. There is more chance if you become disabled and your employer might keep you on. People ask me for advice. I can’t say if you work hard and get qualifications, you will have an equal shot, because I don’t think you do. Service user
Some people spoke about the generally negative approach adopted towards disabled people getting paid work. They felt that rather than supporting service users to gain skills and find employment, the pressure from government was increasingly to get them off benefits, like the old incapacity benefits, now replaced by Employment and Support Allowance (ESA). My wife was recently aggressively asked by the government through one of their various agencies (she’s got mobility problems that prohibit 94% of her mobility and everything you do because of it). They wanted me to drive in our car at our expense, from Monday to Friday … 28 miles there and 28 miles back. I’m supposed to drop her off at nine o’clock in the morning so she can sit at a table [in a workshop], with other people, doing three turns on a screw of a bottle 171
Supporting people
– that’s all, nothing else – all day long. And they wanted us to be there from nine in the morning to five in the evening all week and without money for transport…. Guess how much they were going to pay her for a week’s work? Two pounds! Carer/relative The government wants to get people off benefits. Service user They are approaching it by shoving people off benefits, rather than facilitating employment. Service user
There was a feeling that most of the jobs that disabled people were able to get, were far from what they aspired to. I know a few of them have desires to do meaningful employment, not just somewhere where they go and do a bit of packing now and again and being on minimum wage. They want to get off benefits. Service user
In one of our partner areas, there was a good example of an independent organisation providing service users with support in finding and maintaining employment. The organisation worked in partnership with employers to try to find the right vacancy for each of its service users. It was proud of its record of success. Some service users worked with a charity sending clothes to Eastern Europe, another was paid to collect glasses at a local pub. People used to see it as unusual and a ‘kindness’ that they got a job, but it is now an expectation that they will get one. Most people that [name of organisation] works with, were previously in institutions and had no expectation that they would ever work. Manager
However, this service was still restricted by the kind of broader attitudinal barriers which we discuss later (see Chapter Ten). There is a catch with mine. I am looking for a placement for a wheelchair. Some companies won’t take wheelchairs. The kind of job I’m after, a company are very keen on taking me on, but when they hear about a wheelchair they say ‘No, no.’ Service user 172
Institutionalisation
Money While long-term use of social care services is particularly associated with living on low income and being restricted to benefits, people living in residential services face additional financial restrictions. This can be seen as another of the institutionalising effects of such services. For most of us, being in control of our financial affairs is something we take for granted with adulthood. Some service users made this point. One aspect of preparing for independent living to which they attached particular importance, was learning how to manage money. They also highlighted the value of such ongoing support in dealing with personal finances. For example: I have to think about bills. I have got into so much trouble with money because I love spending it and most of it is down the pub or around town. I’ve got two key workers and the manager who helps if I have money problems. I have to be careful I don’t get into too much trouble, because otherwise I won’t be able to pay the bills and then eventually I’ll get into too much debt and I’ll be behind with all my money. Service user I would like to be informed of what entitlements I have and what it’s for. Service user I know there’s a budget and things. I know we have to budget, but sometimes I’d like someone to call in to help me with [my] money situation and things like that. Service user
However, people who live in residential care funded by the state have their fees and benefits paid directly to the home. All they receive is a small amount of ‘pocket money’ after all the charges have been deducted. In a house, where you are paying rent and getting Income Support, you get much more control over what you spend your money on. In a care home, if you’re funded by the state, you get £17 or £18 a week for paying for your leisure activities. Manager
173
Supporting people
Residents only have £21-£22 per week, so all the things they would love to do, they can’t afford to do. It’s difficult for them in that respect. Manager
Under these arrangements, service users are not directly involved in budgeting or making payments themselves. If you’re living in a home, as I understand it, and certainly in some homes, you’re given, like, pocket money, because the money goes straight to the home and you get pocket money out of it. Service user [Residents] only have an allocated amount which is minimal. Until they move, they can’t deal with their own money properly and learn how to budget. Practitioner
These problems have been further highlighted by Coalition government proposals associated with taking money away from people living in residential homes, by stopping the mobility component of the Disability Living Allowance (DLA). Two service users told us about the problems friends of theirs with learning difficulties had, who lived in residential homes. They contrasted this with their own experience of living independently. This is a friend of ours who likes spending [money] on fags and she’s got to prove that she’s not spending it on fags…. And they’re not allowed to take their money out of their banks. First service user … in case they spend it on themselves, which is a shame, because we can draw out of the bank ourselves and take our own money out. Second service user
One manager contrasted current rhetoric about ‘self-directed support’ with such continuing realities denying people skills and control over their money. All this talk about self-directed support and ‘in control’ and all that, is all well and fine, backing the voice of control, but we’re talking about the most vulnerable members of society, or those sections who are really hard to meet, and unless they themselves as families and users are given the skills to 174
Institutionalisation
manage their own budgets and all that, you know, it’s quite an abstract idea. Manager
Housing The isolating effects of residential services are not only due to any inherent limitations they may have, but also to broader problems facing service users seeking to access or move on to suitable housing. The lack of adequate accessible housing creates a significant barrier to independent living for disabled people. People living in residential homes also appear to be disadvantaged in the allocation of social housing. The lack of suitable local housing The service users living in the residential services we worked with, highlighted the lack of appropriate, accessible accommodation to move on to, as well as the lack of independent housing with support. One young man explained his lack of choice when he moved into the home. I had no other option, I had to go there, but I thought I would meet new people…. I would have rather have gone into a house with my own carers, because when you are in with 10 others all sharing it sometimes doesn’t work out. Service user
Many of the young people living at Pippin Close had experienced this problem first hand. Workers there said: Housing is a huge problem for disabled people in [name of county]. There is a housing policy of building new affordable housing, but nothing for disabled people. I think they could have made sure they build one or two flats for disabled people in each new development, brand new and adapted. We could fill them. Manager You can only be person-centred to the point of the resources that are available to you. So say you wanted to move out of Pippin Close for example, there might not be housing nearby available and so you might be forced into the situation of living somewhere where you don’t want to live because that’s the only choice. Not known 175
Supporting people
People do move on before they are 25. Others don’t want to move when they are 25, or they do, but there is nowhere for them to go. That is the main problem we have. Where do they go? Manager
One service user suggested that the service could do more to assist young people to find housing. He said it assumed that they would move in to other provision run by the same organisation on the same site. I get the impression they want to keep me in [name of organisation]. [There needs to be] better planning and support for moving out. Obviously what they think is they are either going to go into Number two [home for adults], or Number three [independent flats], but I’m going out into the community which is a bigger step. Service user
A practitioner, on the other hand, saw the lack of an adequate range of tapered support as a problem. [Service users have little choice of where to move to.] Most of them see Number three as a good place to start off on that, but once they leave, that is it. It’s OK, but I think it hits them quite a lot. I think it would be better to have another place from here, their own home, so that they can experience it for a few weeks before they make that big step. But once they have gone from here, that’s it. Their place has been taken. It’s a big step from going from here, with people around, to moving to your own place and being on your own really. Practitioner
The lack of options for service users was striking. There seemed to be few genuine choices open to them. There was a safety net of other residential homes, but a social worker explained that these were often inappropriate for young disabled people as they mainly catered for older people. Meanwhile service users lived in hope. I’ve got a plan in my head, but I’m not quite sure how it’s going to work out. I know what I’d like to do and where I would like to live in the future…. It has to be planned and assessed and everything, so I have to hope. Service user
176
Institutionalisation
One service user who was going through a protracted search for accommodation, expressed his frustration with the support provided by the local authority housing officer. She kept making every excuse under the sun, saying, ‘We haven’t got these properties,’ even though we weren’t after adapted property [council adult services offered to do the adaptations]. I think it’s horrible that there aren’t many places that people can move on to. Service user
Another service user spoke about the changes that had occurred in her life since living at the residential home, feeling that these now equipped her to live more independently. For me it has [changed] – moving on and things. Now I am thinking that when I move on I definitely want to go to Number three [the flats]. Before I wasn’t sure where I wanted to go. Because I am getting more confident and things, I’m getting a say. My decisions are becoming real in my head and I’m saying to my parents, ‘You know, you’re not the ones making my decisions and at the end of the day it’s me.’ And I’m sticking [to that] and because I’m gaining more independence and I have got the independent [living] skills and the confidence and when things come up, I’m the first to say ‘Yes I’ll do that.’ That’s why I think Number three is for me. Service user
The residential care trap Many service users living in residential homes had been on their council housing list for a long time. How long they are on the housing register is like how long is a piece of string. It depends on what they require, which areas they have chosen. If they were to say I will go on the housing register for the whole of [name of county] and whatever comes up, I will take it, then it will be quicker. Then you are looking at your adaptations…. Manager They seem to think ‘Well I want a flat. Why hasn’t it arrived?’ and they’re having to wait that much longer than everybody else, you know. Practitioner 177
Supporting people
It is not surprising that many of the young people at Pippin Close wanted to continue living locally, rather than move to other parts of the county. They had got to know the town, made friends there and many had attended local colleges. They preferred to live in a place where they had links, rather than make a new start somewhere else. Hopefully stay in [name of town], that’s the plan. I don’t want to go anywhere else, because I have friends here. I have been on the [housing] list for two years, but no one has found anything for me yet…. I will stay until my time is up, but I’m certain I’ll be ready by then. Service user
The housing system fitted poorly with service users preferences, however. The manager told us of people being on the housing list for several years. She said they encouraged young people to put their names down as soon as possible, but this could have its own disempowering effects. There are a lack of resources and suitable accommodation. What we now try and get young people to do, is once they have settled in, we start talking about moving on. It is really quite mind blowing for them, as they have just arrived and think they don’t have to worry about that. We get them to fill in the forms and get on the register and there is a points system that comes with that. The sad thing is, in [name of county], if a property comes available and the young person does not feel ready to take it and so turns it down, they would have to go right back to the bottom of the list again, which seems really unfair. It makes it a difficult balance for us about when to try and get them on the register, but not wanting a property to come up too soon and they go back down again. Manager
The manager of another residential service explained that some service users had had their names on the housing list for years without any success. As he said: They are not seen as high priority and housing priorities change from year from year. All of them are regarded as being safe because they are living in residential care, so they are not at risk. This works against them. Manager
178
Institutionalisation
Thus because residential homes provide care and support, their residents are not seen as being a high priority on housing lists. They are not homeless, or in imminent danger of becoming homeless. At Pippin Close, residents are unable to plan ahead as they only become a priority for housing right at the end of their stay (when they are facing homelessness). Until a person is nearly 25, I don’t think they are even looked at, until we get to the point where we say ‘We are going to have to make you homeless.’ Manager
This housing problem for disabled people was identified by the Disability Rights Commission. Many disabled adults living in institutional settings, supported housing or with relatives, are unable to establish sufficient ‘points’ for social housing, preventing their move to independent life. (DRC, 2007, p 43) One young person at Pippin Close was considering moving to another county because there was another residential unit for young people there that she would like to live at. This type of specialist accommodation is rare. It meant her moving away from her friends and family to an area she had no links with. During our project, a young disabled man living in Pippin Close moved into a bungalow. He had had a protracted struggle to find it. Adult services paid for the necessary adaptations. He had live-in personal assistants. Sadly he died three months later. The manager of the service expressed great frustration that after all the time and effort taken to find the bungalow, the local authority quickly removed the adaptations and allocated the bungalow to a non-disabled person. She felt that this was wasteful, as there were other local disabled people who would have liked to live there.
Institutionalisation or isolation? We have seen some of the isolating and institutionalising effects of living in residential services, reported by those involved. Disabled people developed the philosophy of independent living to challenge this and to support service users to live on more equal terms in mainstream society. But there have long been fears that de-institutionalisation may also be used to making savings rather than to meet people’s needs. It 179
Supporting people
becomes another site for the tension that frequently emerges in social care, between policy and practice being funding-led and needs-led. A few service users suggested that local authorities might promote the idea of people moving out of residential accommodation or not attending day centres in order to cut their costs. They were concerned that approaches like direct payments and independent living were attractive to local authorities because they could be cheaper than residential care. I think it is quite frightening for me to leave the hospital, because I have been there a long time, but the powers that be want me out and I am going to be out. It is all to do with money. Service user I can see where that fear comes from. If people stay at home and don’t receive services, it doesn’t cost the local authority anything. It wouldn’t happen for the loud physical disability lobby, but if you haven’t got that voice…. Service user Being cynical, it could be argued that the reason the local authority are so keen on direct payments is because it’s actually cheaper. Service user
Several services involved in our project described one of their aims as tackling loneliness and isolation. They saw social support as an important part of what they could offer. For example: And the social aspect for a lot of people has made a great difference – people who were often living alone with varied levels of support, usually from families, very isolated but actually coming here into quite a social setting. Manager
Many service users had major concerns about moving out of a residential service on to direct payments. They were worried that they might end up without the support they needed to live more independently and once they moved, would find it was too late to change their minds and go back to where they were before. As one man living in a residential home put it: I do [want to move out] – as long as I get the back-up support I need. Service user
180
Institutionalisation
A number of people, both service users and workers, expressed concerns that living alone could be isolating. When our young people leave here, they have got the fear they will go to a flat somewhere and every evening they would find themselves alone – and that is a fear for them – that they will be lonely. Manager Yes, it was monotonous. There were times on my own and it was awful. I can’t stand that. Service user
Many people, particularly practitioners, questioned what they saw as an assumption in social care services, that living on your own was better than living with others in a supported environment. It worried them that service users could become isolated and lack opportunities for social contact. Some felt that interdependence was better than independence. Sometimes independent living was confused with enforced independence and some people felt services also confused the two. What do we mean by person-centred planning? Are we talking about sharing communities or are we talking about individuals having to do things on their own? Not known What’s wrong with also setting up homes, you know, good homes, that are shared and [where] people can end up supporting each other? I work in the mental health field. We have supported housing. A lot of people have their own rooms, their own tenancy, live in communal houses. They do have problems, but on the other hand the promise of getting well is to be moved out into independent, isolated living and I think it really worries me, this whole process of independence and, if person-centred means on your own, isolated, do what you want. Practitioner I question the whole way that society thinks that independence is progress. You know, I think it’s an amazing thought and I couldn’t wait to leave home and get a flat with loads of other people, you know, and that was great. But that isn’t so much a mindset anymore is it? It’s more I’ve got to have my own, to take my own choices and to decorate the way I want and watch the programmes I like, rather than an attitude of, I 181
Supporting people
wonder how we can have fun together and look after one another and share the costs. Practitioner For the majority of people, they welcome the challenge to live more independently, but with support. Out of 14 [here], there is only one person who says he wants to be put on his own. And being independent doesn’t have to mean being out there on your own. So most people are saying ‘Yes, I’d like to live with X, Y and Z – they’re my friends – not 14 other people I didn’t choose to be with.’ Not known
Some practitioners said that people who made good progress living in a group environment were often then encouraged to move on to live in their own place. But they felt that this wasn’t necessarily the best environment for everyone to succeed. They worried about what they saw as individualised approaches to living and support, which were not necessarily backed up with adequate social support. The price of success was that they would then have to move out and live on their own. And it’s like what? You’re on your own in this home, this place, it’s your home, but everything else has gone. Sometimes … fact is that person can’t really live on their own anymore. Practitioner I think that in my organisation it’s very much about progress, move on, move on into your own places. And the reward of getting better is loneliness, isolation, to move into ‘independent living’. Whereas actually, I would sometimes call it … quite dysfunctional. Practitioner Forming good relationships, that has to be at the centre. It’s not about having your own cooker, cooking your own food. It’s about forming a really good relationship. Practitioner
One practitioner expressed a view that it’s often better for service users to live with others, and that part of being person-centred is being able to offer choices in who you live with, as well as what kind of service you use. Be independent sharing with other people. If it comes out that they are supported to do that, so, they’re not left. We all know the horror stories of people who have been out 182
Institutionalisation
in community totally on their own and it’s been a spiral downwards. But to acknowledge what people are saying, ‘Yes, I want to be more independent, but don’t want to live on my own.’ It’s respecting that choice. Practitioner
The importance of getting together We have heard about the isolating effects of living both in residential services and in your own home without adequate support. It also became clear that just being set in group situations with other people did not necessarily mean that people were not isolated or lonely. In contrast, however, service users talked about the benefits of getting together in groups as a means of overcoming isolation and disempowerment. This could be in small or larger numbers, formally and informally, to socialise and have fun, as well as to do things more actively together. Many service users talked about the benefits of doing this, from sharing information and getting support, to gaining strength in numbers. They valued services which helped them to do this. They welcomed opportunities to meet people with shared experience, who faced similar barriers in their lives. They said it helped them to overcome isolation and to have a better quality of life. I go to a centre in [name of town] and a lot of the things that I am accessing now, I only found out about from people that actually attended the centre. And from having conversations with them, you pick up on little things. They might say I got this from there, or somebody there told me how to go about this and you have never even heard about it in the first place. Service user We get together as brothers and sisters, talk, share difficulties. [The trips] get us out of the house. Carer/relative In the past we used to sit at home feeling alone, worry about things and what’s going to happen in the future and generally get very tense about things. Coming to [a carers’ group] has changed all that. The walls have been broken. Carer/ relative
Practitioners talked about the similar benefits that they felt they gained from getting together.
183
Supporting people
[Meeting with staff from other homes in the organisation] is useful. It does help and make a big difference, to think they have got the same problems we’ve got. Practitioner In our organisation, they are very good at posting us huge questionnaires with tick boxes. What you get from sharing something here [Standards We Expect get-together event] is the feeling, the passion, the relationship; and it doesn’t feel just like a paper exercise. Practitioner
A member of a coalition of disabled people saw it as a natural extension of disabled people meeting together in groups. The social model of disability underpinned its work. They had a membership of over 30 organisations, mainly organisations of disabled people, as well as 300 to 400 individual members. [The Coalition’s ethos is] ‘Nothing about us without us,’ so [in principle] it is the ultimate example of disabled people taking control of their own lives. Service user
In Camchester a group of older people had come together to seek improved services for older people. It was made up of local older people who were service users, carers and ‘challengers’. Members of the group played an active role in the steering group for our project’s work on end of life care in the city. The group was funded by the Department of Health’s POPPs (Partnerships for Older People Projects) programme. This funding was only available for a limited period of time, but the group had already secured funding for a further year and was confident of securing more for the future. It had built relationships with local officers and employed a coordinator. A member of its steering group said: Through them, the voice of older people is becoming firmly established, recognised, acknowledged and valued on a wide range of public service issues. Carer/relative
Not all service users, however, wanted to get together in this way. Some, we were told, did not identity as disabled people. They did not relate to joining groups of disabled people. It’s almost as if they don’t mind being together here [in the home] to meet and discuss things, but they don’t want 184
Institutionalisation
to mix with other disabled people. [They don’t] want to be associated with other disabled people…. They don’t associate themselves as being disabled. Manager [User involvement meetings] – like here they are young and outgoing. They don’t want to join as [they see that as something] disabled people [do]. Manager
Summary While de-institutionalisation has been a goal of modern social care, the lives of many residential and long-term service users are still restricted by institutionalisation. They express strong feelings of disempowerment. By undermining people’s confidence and skills and imposing dependency, institutionalisation continues to create major barriers in the way of independent living and person-centred support. Service users’ comparison levels and confidence are often low. In residential and segregated services, supporting people to do things for themselves, seeing them as individuals, exploring their preferences for the future, encouraging them to learn from people who are already living more independently, working to involve them in change, all emerge as ways in which services can helpfully begin to overcome these barriers. Training and capacity building for both staff and service users also work to challenge institutionalisation. Three additional problems are associated with residential and long-term use of social care. These are lack of control over money, particularly for people in residential services, major barriers in the way of gaining valued employment and restricted access to suitable, accessible housing, trapping people in residential services and preventing them from maintaining local links and networks. Positive goals of supporting people to live more independently can be undermined by pressure on services to maintain a throughput of residents and other service users. Some service users fear that efforts to move them on from residential and day services are budget-driven rather than needs-led. Some services specifically seek to address the loneliness and isolation service users may face, but there are fears among both service users and workers that the drive for people to live independently in the community, sometimes actually results in service users living alone, without adequate support and becoming isolated. People can be isolated in both group and community-based settings. Service users highlight the importance of getting together, both formally and informally, with each other as a way of improving 185
Supporting people
their lives, increasing their confidence and exerting an influence. Some service users are reluctant to identify as such and link up with others and are therefore denied this source of support. References Barnes, C. (1991) Disabled people in Britain and discrimination, London: Hurst & Company. Bowers, H., Clark, A., Crosby, G., MacDonald, R., MacFarlane, A., Maclean, M., Patel, M., Runnicles, D., Oshinaike, D. and Smith, C. (2009) Older people’s vision for long-term care, York: Joseph Rowntree Foundation. CSCI (Commission for Social Care Inspection) (2008) The state of social care in England 2006-07, London: CSCI. CSCI (2009) The state of social care in England 2007-08, London: CSCI. DRC (Disability Rights Commission) (2007) Changing Britain for good: Putting disability at the heart of public policy, London: DRC. Goffman, E. (1968) Asylums: Essays on the social situation of mental patients and other Inmates, Harmondsworth: Penguin. Harding,T. and Beresford, P. (eds) (1996) The Standards We Expect:What service users and carers want from social services workers, London: National Institute for Social Work. Kemshall, H. (2002) Risk, social policy and welfare, Buckingham: Open University Press. Powell, E. (1961) ‘Water tower’ speech (http://studymore.org.uk/ xpowell.htm).
186
SEVEN
Organisational issues ‘There are some individual support workers who are extremely person-centred and who really get what it means. But organisations, because they’re organisations, don’t get what it means really.’ (Manager) STANDARD SEVEN: REDUCING ORGANISATIONAL BARRIERS
Organisational barriers in the way of person-centred support, created by increasing bureaucratisation and managerialism, must be reduced. They inhibit good practice and restrict service users’ rights, choice and control. The associated emphasis on negative risk undermines the values of independent living and must be replaced with a risk awareness that supports service users’ right to take positive risks. Services should work in partnership with service users to consider risk creatively and proportionately within the context of learning and independence.
Introduction This chapter focuses on organisational issues affecting the delivery of social care and the prospects for advancing person-centred support. A significant contradiction in social care is that while over the years much of the focus of reform has been on organisational change and restructuring, organisational issues are still highlighted by both service users and service workers as key barriers in the way of person-centred support. People from a very wide range of organisations and projects have contributed their views and experience to this book. These include statutory, voluntary and private sector organisations, operating in the health, housing and social care fields. They have very different histories, cultures and philosophies. They provide a wide variety of 187
Supporting people
services and range in size from small to very large. This means that it is difficult to generalise about them. They have different aims, philosophies and systems of accountability. Yet all seem to have been affected by the same major development in public policy, which in turn has had major negative effects, from what people have told us, on the activities of both service workers and service users. This development has been the move to managerialist/consumerist approaches in public policy and services, including specifically social care, where such ideas were pioneered in the early 1990s, with the community care reforms. Managerialism has been defined as: ‘the introduction of business-oriented principles and personnel into the running of the public services (Miller, 1999, p 33). It is seen as an aspect of what has come to be called ‘new public management’ (NPM) – ‘a shift towards managerial forms of organisational co-ordination’ (Clarke et al, 2001, p 6). These are characterised by an emphasis on: … continuous increases in efficiency, the use of evermore-sophisticated technologies, a labour force disciplined in productivity, clear implementation of the professional management role, managers being given the right to manage. (Walsh, 1995, p xiii) The rhetoric underpinning this move was that it would lead to more ‘customer’ or ‘consumer’ focused services. The political new right that advanced these ideas from the 1970s, also presented them as part of its commitment to the market, as a corrective to what it saw as the bureaucratising tendencies of state services. Yet what we see here from what people have to say, is that they have the opposite effect. Service users and workers highlight two consequences this development has had. These are first, restrictions on what service workers are able to do, because of the bureaucratic constraints operating on them. This is linked second, with restrictions imposed on the lives of service users because of organisations’ concerns that their unconstrained behaviour may create problems for them. Both are symptomatic of what Donna Dustin has described as the ‘McDonaldization’ of social care (Dustin, 2007). This grew out of the work of the US academic, George Ritzer, highlighting the destructive way in which public services were being reshaped in the image of fast food production (Ritzer, 2004). Dustin explores care management through the four key principles associated with ‘McDonaldization’. These are efficiency, based on narrow economic and bureaucratic judgements; predictability, through reliance on standardisation and a 188
Organisational issues
procedural approach; calculability, reducing everything to numbers and finally, surveillance, closely controlling and monitoring workers. Workers in her study describe a system based on highly prescriptive procedures, checklist approaches, dependence on technology and computerised systems and cost containment. Instead of being providers of support, social workers became purchasers of services. Instead of being distributors of resources, they were now meant to be guardians of funds for their organisations. All these problems were highlighted in the consultations held by the Social Work Task Force and in its final report (Social Work Task Force, 2009). All of these pressures were also highlighted by participants in our project. This extended beyond care managers to projects working with a wide range of service users.
Increasing bureaucratisation Service users and providers framed many of these issues in terms of the increasing bureaucratisation of services. It’s hoops isn’t it? We’re jumping through hoops. Practitioner
Practitioners particularly spoke of increasing levels of bureaucracy and paperwork that were taking up their time. They saw this as a major problem and a big barrier in the way of working in a person-centred way. They spoke about the difficulties created by systems of allocating support and the requirements of funders and regulatory bodies. In the past, the social worker would do the assessment and set up a care package, but now there’s a process that we have to go to a panel and if it’s beyond a certain level of cost, we have to go to a second panel at county hall. Practitioner But the pressure does mount up at times. The admin[istrative] pressures and the organisational pressures go against you and the work you are doing directly with people. Practitioner
Many managers and practitioners felt that bureaucratic systems and tasks took up time practitioners should be spending on the core purpose of their jobs – working with service users. The coal-face workers now have to do a lot of the administration and so then, we are taking away from the clients, I would say. Practitioner 189
Supporting people
Sometimes the time is a barrier. I have a lot of administrative paperwork to complete. I don’t think 15 hours is enough. Practitioner If people within social services find it difficult to find a way through the process, what’s it like for people outside? It’s slowed everything down. It’s also put a time pressure on workers. It comes back to not having time to spend with people. Practitioner There is a lot of workload pressure, so having the time to do person-centred work is seen as very idealistic, not possible with the amount of case load you have. And reporting back and the numerous paperwork and computer generated stuff that you have to complete in order for somebody to tick the boxes to say so many assessments, so many reviews, have been done. Manager
Some practitioners said that their jobs had changed over time, with less time to form relationships with service users. It’s the lack of connection again isn’t it and the lack of relationship, you know. It becomes a paper exercise…. I find increasingly that my work is becoming a paper exercise. Practitioner
Such administrative activities are a source of tension between practitioners and their managers, as managers are expected to make sure that they are undertaken. One practitioner, for example, spoke of the way that the demand for paperwork failed to take account of the need for practitioners to be adaptable and responsive to their service users on a day-to-day basis. I think management need to be a bit more understanding about the workload of staff who have been delivering the service…. They forget that we’re working with individuals and it does take a lot of time. Things don’t always work … and crises come up every day. Every day’s different. You don’t know what you’re going to walk into. You don’t know what’s going to happen from one day to the next and if something [arises] unexpectedly … you got to prioritise in order and
190
Organisational issues
always [to] leave the individual in whatever issue’s arisen. It’s more important than paper work. Practitioner
Increasing complexity Not only are practitioners faced with an increasing burden of administration themselves, but they have to go through increasingly complex bureaucratic tasks with service users to access support. Experienced practitioners explained that this was taking more time and creating more problems. The paperwork that services expect service users to complete could be difficult, both because procedures were complicated and forms inaccessible. It is a problem when people come to us in a crisis because of this difficulty with resources. You’ve got to go out and do the assessment, go through the panel process and go out and find the care. So it’s much more difficult now to do anything quickly. Practitioner Forms and paperwork can become a barrier. It can take a very long time to do. I had a client who had to stop and have a Mars bar so she didn’t slip into a diabetic coma while I was there, because I had been there so long. It starts to become a bit abusive! I think I should go and let these people have some lunch. Practitioner
Service users were often left feeling anxious. Why can’t they have forms that are very easy to understand?... You get a form and you’re supposed to fill out what’s wrong with you and you can’t understand the form and pieces of paper, you can’t understand it. How can you make it easy for people like me, who are not very good at reading? Service user
Since the move to the market in social care and other public services, increasing reliance has been placed on bureaucratic systems of regulation as a means of safeguarding standards and measuring and maintaining quality. However, we found that such an approach could impose arbitrary and unhelpful restrictions both on services and service users, increasingly intruding in people’s lives.
191
Supporting people
CASE STUDY IMPOSING INFLEXIBILITY This was instanced by the service which was registered as a unit for young people. Service users were not permitted to continue living there once they reached the age of 25. This followed from recent legislation preventing people over that age living in the same facility as younger people (HM Government, 2004). This could create significant problems as young people approached the cut-off age. This pressure was intensified, as we saw in the last chapter, by the lack of housing options for such young people. This created serious difficulties for the young terminally ill man who was expected to move on at this difficult time in his life. In turn, the unit felt it was left with no room for manoeuvre. We feel we are absolutely NOT allowed to have him here after 25 – it would be against the law. It is part of the Children’s Act that people over 25 should not be living with those of 16. Manager As we saw earlier, it was possible to rehouse this young man, as his situation was treated as an emergency, but the whole experience was stressful for him, his family and staff. The manager of this service also highlighted how its policy about recording information could deter service users from speaking openly. The service recorded a range of personal information in an individual service plan, including information about the service user’s medical history and education, their hopes, goals and future plans. Sometimes it can make the young people not want to tell you things. Sometimes they like to talk things over, but they know things will get written down. They say, ‘When I was at college,’ or ‘When I was at home, no one wrote all these things down about me.’ Manager
Imposing diversions Another expression of managerialism and bureaucratisation that participants highlighted was the predominating ‘target culture’. Many participants were concerned that requirements to meet targets were having a negative impact on providing person-centred support. Some services struggled to gather all the information required. Some 192
Organisational issues
expressed concerns that targets were a blunt tool that did not effectively measure the positive outcomes of their work, for example preventative work. One service provider said: One of our biggest problems in dealing with the top coming down, is performance indicators which have been set by the government and that’s what’s leading the service. And that’s nothing to do with what individuals want – a personcentred approach. Again, we’re encouraged to do reviews and assessments and things, hit targets, deadlines and things, which in our work, don’t necessarily apply.
Practitioners and managers frequently said that services were being judged on how they performed against particular government indicators. There was wide concern that this could lead to services concentrating on meeting such ‘key indicators’, to the exclusion of other important aspects of their provision. At the end of the day we are going to be judged by the Department of Health and social workers on certain performance indicators; the number of assessments, the number of reviews. The person-centred approach, I don’t think is a very clear indicator at this moment in time, as far as I am aware. Manager … indicators like how many people get intensive home care and how many people get direct payments. But then we have some, [where] the more you do of one, the less you do of others – the more homecare – the less direct payments. It’s like being put on a spot and told to run in two directions at the same time. You can’t do it! Practitioner I think that targets and resources are a big thing, you know, in our work. One of the local authorities runs rent deposit schemes and the officers have to reach certain targets and that’s the overriding thing. And then with the charitable schemes, it’s lack of resources so that they’re trying to meet funders’ targets and – you know – to keep the funding. So a lot of the time, perhaps, the person-centred stuff is squeezed out, because they want to meet a target and they aren’t helping people, perhaps, in the long run. Manager
193
Supporting people
Some service providers spoke of the need for measures of personcentred support and a shift in emphasis away from strictly numerical, quantitative measures. They felt that these ‘hard’ targets did not necessarily demonstrate the value of their work. They preferred to concentrate on ‘soft’ outcomes which they felt could be more meaningful. But there wasn’t agreement about this: We’re actually now learning to record what they call ‘soft outcomes’, or something or other, in order to justify their existence, which is a load of old twaddle really, to be polite! Not known
The development of such soft outcomes was pioneered in the fields of adult learning and employment projects. Reviewing this development, however, Butcher and Marsden offer a cautionary note: The need to measure soft outcomes and the distance travelled by service beneficiaries will not go away and service providers in the voluntary and community sector will increasingly be required to provide evidence of these outcomes to satisfy funders. (Butcher and Marsden, 2004, p 42)
The appropriateness of targets The Coalition government, which came to power in 2010, was very critical of a ‘targets-based’ approach and stressed that it would leave such matters to local discretion, instead of directing them. However, its continuing emphasis on ‘outcome’ measures suggest that the move away from targets might be more illusory than real. Some people working in services expressed concerns that a preoccupation with targets could miss fundamentally important aspects of a service. The process could then become cosmetic with bad outcomes hidden by wrongly focused targets. And in our statistics they said ‘Oh, we’re doing really well. We’ve had so many move-ons,’ and we said,‘Did that include the guy who had jumped out of the window?’ And, oh my God, that’s a statistic! Sorry, that’s a horrible story, but it’s also, you know, that actually is a statistic and that’s what we’re driven by, isn’t it. This many people moved on, ‘well done’. Practitioner 194
Organisational issues
For us outcomes are that people can move on and make choices for themselves and be successful after they have left here. Manager
As we saw in the previous chapter, funding for services is often directed at supporting people to move on and ‘live independently’. A number of practitioners believed that this culture of ‘moving on’ failed to recognise the complexity of living independently for some service users. They felt that for many people maintaining an existing level of independence could be a worthwhile and significant achievement. This should not be crudely equated with low expectations, on the part of either staff or service users. Measuring success is much more complex than gathering information about the number of people who move-on from a service. I think funding seems to be very focused on outcomes and the pressure to prove those outcomes…. Often it seems to me that perhaps maintenance is a real achievement; maintaining someone in their house, keeping them out of hospital. Maintenance should be keeping something going. I find funding is always about new initiatives, new ideas, new goals and sometimes, just keeping your house maintained is a real achievement. Practitioner
How person-centred are targets? Many service workers pointed out a major contradiction between the desire for services to be person-centred and the current use of indicators and targets. They said that such bureaucratic targets often actually worked against services being person-centred. As soon as you put a target on something you immediately lose the person-centredness don’t you? Immediately you’ve got to meet something, but that’s not how it works. That’s when you know that they don’t get what person-centred means, I’ll give you a tick list of things, ‘Have you done that?’ you know! Manager I would really like to send the message that not everything can be measured, because what is a huge achievement for someone might not be for another, and vice versa. I just think, we are all individuals and we are talking about a person-centred approach. How do you measure that? You 195
Supporting people
can’t measure pain. You can’t measure pleasure. It is all an individual thing, isn’t it? So why put in tick boxes and why pay lip-service to something? Practitioner
Some people, on the other hand, thought that inspection criteria could measure how person-centred a service was. As one manager said: When we are inspected by the Commission for Social Care Inspection, that is what they want to be looking at; that is their prime thing. They want to know what is revolving round that young person within that service. The quality of the service that young person receives is not going to be the same for the other nine in the service where I work. We have all got to be individual and that is the main thing that they look at. Manager
The emergence of improvements Many service workers wanted to stress that progress was being made, regardless of organisational problems that were also being identified. These included changes in service cultures that benefitted service users and supported them to achieve better outcomes. I think it is important to acknowledge that a lot of places, despite the fact that they are not yet as good as they should be, they are much better than they were and we should look at the progress that has been made. Manager It’s [person-centred planning] become an acceptable way of working in Middleshire. People are not as phased by this as they are elsewhere in [the country]. Manager
CASE STUDY MAKING TARGETS WORK POSITIVELY Existing measures and targets are not always at odds with positive practice and person-centred support. Workers in a day centre talked about how these had served to help it change focus and work more closely with other groups locally. The centre was committed to disabled people’s participation in mainstream society. Workers had begun to think about turning the day centre 196
Organisational issues into a community centre used by both disabled and non-disabled people. They saw this as a way of promoting the inclusion of disabled people. They needed to demonstrate value for money to raise funds. Forming partnerships with other organisations who wanted to use the centre’s facilities helped to achieve this. One of the reasons we went along with it was [for] long term sustainability of the centre. You have to demonstrate that services are saving money and utilising facilities. Practitioner The centre began to change four years ago when the further education college IT [information technology] ‘learning station’ moved in. This opened up possibilities of changing the way the centre is used and opening it up to the community more. Now it is also used by the WEA [Workers’ Educational Association] and adult community support. Manager I believe that people realise that without that kind of connection, the sustainability of the building is threatened…. The changes are making the centre more significantly beneficial to the community than it ever has been. Manager Drawing a wider range of activities into the centre brought real gains. Basing a Sure Start children’s centre in some unused rooms, not only meant that these could be refitted, but other improvements be made to the building, including refurbishing the centre’s reception area and equipping a sensory stimulation room. Centre users and staff felt that these developments would both help sustain the centre’s long-term existence and overcome the barriers between disabled people and other local people.
A person-centred approach to standards and targets While we encountered considerable questioning of existing approaches to setting standards and identifying targets, people were not denying the importance of collecting information and try to measure progress and results. Many felt unsure what the best way was of going about this. They doubted that the right information was being sought or obtained. All the services participating in our project recognised the need to collect information measuring the outcomes achieved by people using their services. However, many felt unsure of the best way to
197
Supporting people
go about this task. They said it could be very difficult to capture the right information. Since person-centred support meant starting with each service user, people were concerned with the outcomes for individuals. They saw gains from moving away from current top-down, bureaucratic targets, towards ones set by service users. Thus the focus for information gathering would be what service users themselves had to say. Their views, rather than organisational issues, would need to be prioritised, since a truly person-centred service would be based on the outcomes desired by each service user. Only such an individualised approach would show how person-centred a service actually was, adaptable and flexible to their different needs. It would be quite nice to have a formal way of doing that – maybe a questionnaire when people are leaving the service. Manager One of the things that I feel we can improve is to promote person-centred planning and see how people are achieving good outcomes because that’s their goals, but not the government’s goal, or the actual management’s goal and the only people who should be having good outcomes, is the client. Not known
One practitioner talked about a simple, but effective way that her service had made improvements, by undertaking a review involving their service users. By gaining an insight into service users’ perspectives, the service was able to make some straightforward improvements. We went out to do a review of the adaptations guidance. We picked out some clients and went to see them and asked them some questions about their showers. ‘Was it what you expected?’ ... devised all these questions and used it as our own sort of research to feed the guidance for the future. I don’t think there’s enough of that done. We learnt quite a lot. One of the things we picked up on was people didn’t know what to expect. We should have photos taken of what works that we could show to people and lots of other little things like that, to improve best practice. But we don’t do enough of that. Practitioner
198
Organisational issues
The manager of an outreach service focusing on preventive work, explained that it wasn’t necessarily clear what effects it actually had. It is difficult to know whether an outcome results from work done by [the service] or other variables in the local area, like a supermarket opening. We think less people come to the [centre] because of the work of [the outreach service], meaning that they are doing community-based activity instead. Manager
He was worried that the service was vulnerable to any cut-backs planned by its funder, the local authority, especially if it could not show clear results. The danger is they [an outreach service] are seen to become so different, with eligibility tightening, that it is seen as a luxury rather than a necessity. Manager
The challenge was to find a way of showing the value of the service in a way that satisfied the funders, without compromising the service’s work. How to achieve a win/win for service users and staff and accountants and professionals? Manager
Establishing the evidence The service wanted to evidence the progress made by its users over a period of time to demonstrate how it had helped improve people’s lives in a range of ways. We have come to the conclusion that we need to capture this ourselves. We tried linking [others] who could do it in a more formal way, but they don’t seem to have the interest. [We want to measure] the progressiveness. We start people on the road and six months or a year later, we’re finding that they have done great things. Manager
Like some other services, they were convinced of the good work they did and had considerable anecdotal evidence to support this. They gave the example of a disabled man who was referred to the service when he was depressed and isolated. He had become involved in a local disabled people’s group through his contact with them. Building 199
Supporting people
on their support, he gained the confidence to take adult education courses. He played a key part in setting up a successful support group and was now setting up another group. He has gone from being a service user in difficulty, to being an active volunteer, supporting the service’s work. He told one manager: You, the department, have actually saved my life. I think I would be dead now. My GP says I would be dead now. This has given me a reason to get up in the mornings. Service user
What the service lacked was any reliable method of accumulating such information. They gathered data on the number of people they worked with and the amount of input they had, but this stopped short of detailing what their service users had achieved. The focus has been on outputs, not outcomes. Manager We are terrible at noting things. That’s why it’s good that you are involved. It’s partly to do with resources, partly the way we have been structured in the past. We need to do it for the future. Manager
To overcome this, that project made use of a tool, based on asking service users a series of questions when they first had contact with the service and then repeating these at regular intervals and milestones in their relationship with the service. Questions addressed people’s feelings about themselves as well as their involvement in social activities, volunteering and work, offering a more rounded picture of developments (SOUL Project, 2006). A supported employment project involved in the person-centred planning network in Middleshire had recently started using a similar process for measuring the outcomes of their service. During our project, New Chance implemented a similar scheme based on asking its service users to complete a questionnaire when they start using the service and then at regular intervals. One practitioner working with people with dementia spoke about the difficulties of getting feedback from that user group. How do you measure successful outcomes [working with people with dementia]? You need a ‘happiness meter’, because it is hard to measure success. You can see the happiness, but how can that be measured? Practitioner 200
Organisational issues
This raises broader issues about accessing the views and perspectives of groups where additional communication and other access needs must be met. Already, however, methods and experience are developing to do this, for example, in this case, through ‘dementia care mapping’ which traces the activity and behaviour of service users with dementia (Kitwood and Bredin, 1992). Some participants felt it was also possible to make the financial case for focusing on preventive services and person-centred outcomes by showing the gains, compared with traditional approaches. The thing is you can show the benefits. I mean the benefits may seem obvious, but you can show that long term this service will be more cost effective, more appropriate, you know. If you can show the benefits of being person-centred, people are more likely to immediately take it on board. Not known Since I’ve spoken to you, I’ve managed to evidence the fact that because some of the projects that I do are accessible to people who are eligible for a service, you can do a cost analysis on that – what the cost is for those people to be at the community-based places, as against what the cost would be if they were in a statutory service. You can easily equate how much it’s actually costing the person to access the services that I’ve set up against what it would cost if they were accessing statutory services and the money they’re saving because of that. Practitioner
The issue of ‘risk’ If the first issue participants in our project highlighted, following from the shift to managerialist/consumerist approaches in social care, was increased bureaucratisation, then the second was a preoccupation with ‘risk’ and its reduction. Of course, there is an overlap between the two, since the identification of risk and responses to it, are essentially bureaucratic processes. Risk has mainly been framed in terms of ‘health and safety’ regulation and restrictions. ‘Health and safety’ and public scepticism about it, have become clichés of modern western societies. This development tends to be seen as an extension of the ‘nanny state’, but in reality it has taken place during a period when the market sector massively expanded its role in the provision of public services. The rationale for concern with risk has also often been presented in 201
Supporting people
market terms, relating to requirements for insurance and to address the possibility of legal challenge from people as ‘consumers’. Restrictions on people’s behaviour relating to risk have tended to be justified in terms of ‘safeguarding’ and the ‘management of risk’. Our project highlighted that pressures to be ‘risk-averse’ restricted the work of service providers and limited the lives and activities of service users. Both made it clear that this created barriers in the way of both person-centred support and independent living. The issue of risk has particular significance in social care because it intervenes in the most intimate aspects of people’s lives, has powers to restrict rights and works with groups identified as vulnerable and ‘risky’ and also at times when people can be expected to be vulnerable. Historically service users have tended to be heavily controlled in social care settings, particularly in its residential and institutional settings. Such controls have particularly operated in relation to groups seen as either less competent, or more deviant. The community care reforms which were implemented in the early 1990s reflected a wider aspiration to move away from the close control and regulation of service users in separate settings. In this they represent a challenge to traditional paternalistic attitudes and assumptions about disabled people and other service users. What service users and workers in our project highlighted, however, was the perpetuation of paternalism and control because of a preoccupation with negative risk in social care.
‘Health and safety’ Discussion about risk and attitudes and practices towards it tended to be framed in terms of ‘health and safety’. Many service users spoke about the impact that health and safety considerations had on their everyday lives and how they were a major barrier to person-centred support. It restricts me. It takes over. Service user I think health and safety has too much power. Service user Health and safety nonsense. Service user So there are restrictions on the workers in a way in what they can do and what they can’t do. Service user
202
Organisational issues
Practitioners also frequently expressed their frustrations with health and safety rules and regulations and the way that they prevented them from supporting service users in the way they would like. It drives me mad. Practitioner Health and safety does cause problems. Practitioner Where will it end? Will it stop people doing anything outside the home? Practitioner
Ironically,‘health and safety’ a development which grew out of pressure to secure the rights and interests of both service users and practitioners, has become something which both find inhibiting and damaging.
Risk assessment The practice of conducting risk assessments on everyday activities has become commonplace and represents a major restriction and intrusion in the lives of service users. Jenny Morris associates this practice with negative assumptions in society about the abilities of disabled people. Concerns about risk to the welfare of a disabled person are closely tied up with assumptions about an individual’s capacity to make decisions. The tendency to see disabled people as uniquely vulnerable means that, even when professionals and service providers talk of ‘empowerment’ concerns about safety and/or liability can get in the way. (Morris, 2003, p 19) Forms are completed to assess the potential risks associated by undertaking specific activities. Risks for the service user and for practitioners and volunteers are considered. This could cover any activity, from those that most of us might see as potentially dangerous, such as going snowboarding or parachute jumping, to those that most people would regard as mundane and safe, such as going to a local shop or to the cinema. Assessments are intended to include how potential risks can be reduced, for example, by the use of specialist equipment, or the provision of one-to-one support. Both practitioners and service users felt that risk assessment was increasingly preventing service users from making choices and living
203
Supporting people
independently. These barriers were seen as a factor across all services, but became particularly apparent in residential services. Every time, before they go out, there has to be one [risk assessment]. It certainly slows things up and there is not much spontaneity when you have to have a risk assessment before you can do anything. Practitioner If you want to go out, you think about health and safety. Service user You’re going to the supermarket to do your shopping and it’s something that everyone in the world does and you have to do a risk assessment on it! You have to do a risk assessment to get on a bus…. You could be doing more productive things! Practitioner
Risk assessments were not merely a bureaucratic intrusion into service users’ lives. Their findings could have a very real effect on what activities a service user could undertake. On occasions, where they indicated that an activity represented a high risk, service users might then be stopped from doing it. This could happen occasionally, or on a daily basis. A move to a [housing] complex like this means that every risk has to be assessed. So people are prevented from doing everyday things like leaving the building. Manager Me and my mate were supposed to go to [name of motor racing track] last summer. We booked tickets and got all excited. But then we couldn’t go, on the very last day, because of access and I was not happy and nor was my mate. We were told it was all fine: we wouldn’t need to do this, wouldn’t need to do that. We had to check the ground to see if it was level and it wasn’t. They rang up and they had to cancel it. Service user One of the people was 21 last week and he came back to the home very much the worse for wear and he passed out. We are now going to have to risk assess, if he goes out and drinks too much again, what the procedure will be. We only have two staff on at night and one of them had to sit with him, so it meant other things could not get done. If something else 204
Organisational issues
had happened the others could have been at risk. Whereas, if he had been in his own flat at home, no one would have known and he would have woken up with a bad head in the morning. Being here does have a slightly different context. As much as we want him to be able to do what 21 year olds do, when they come back into the building, there are different rules than if they were in their own home. He has promised not to do it again, but I am not sure I believe him! Manager
One manager explained what might happen in practice if a service user wanted to pursue an activity after a risk assessment indicated it presented an unacceptable risk. We always try and negotiate with the person and ultimately I think health and safety would say as long as you have tried to negotiate with the person and agree something with them, but they say ‘Sod you, I am going to do it anyway’, then we haven’t got a responsibility and we wouldn’t stop them doing it…. But it’s quite a long-winded process and by the time you have gone through it, they have lost the will to do whatever it was in the first place often. It doesn’t actually stop them doing it, but it does put a bureaucracy around it and is artificial. Manager
The tyranny of ‘risk’ ‘Health and safety’ has become the framework through which issues of risk avoidance have been presented and come to be understood by people. During interviews and meetings, it was often apparent that both service users and practitioners lacked a clear understanding of either the specific legislation or the details of their organisation’s policies about health and safety. As Mike Titterton has stated: Workers and their managers sometimes hold distorted views of the legal implication of risk-taking, particularly over the issue of negligence. (Titterton, 2005, p 28) This resulted in risk assessment and health and safety issues being viewed with fear and distrust. They were seen as nebulous concepts that undermined the work of practitioners. They are blamed for preventing things, but not understood in detail by the stakeholders most directly
205
Supporting people
affected. One practitioner had decided not to raise health and safety as a topic within their service: Otherwise you just get wound up in red tape. Practitioner
In a number of services, the need to conduct risk assessments had frustrated both practitioners and service users. Practitioners complained about the bureaucracy and the extra time taken to undertake them. In one residential service, practitioners were unclear about who conducted risk assessments and on what basis. For example, one practitioner thought a visit to the venue for a new activity was necessary to conduct a risk assessment, while another said that it was possible to telephone to find out the relevant information. This is a significant difference and given the stated shortage of staff time in the service, it could become a significant barrier to such activity taking place. I thought we had to risk assess anything – like if we want to go to Brighton, we have to go and assess it before we go. First practitioner [reply] You can ring up and ask if it is accessible. Is it on a hill? Are you going to be able to park nearby? You don’t have to go. You can phone or look on the internet. There are places you can get that information without going. Second practitioner
One practitioner articulated the essential problem: [Risk assessment is] a good idea, but can get in the way of [service users] doing things. Practitioner
She instanced a fireworks evening put on by a local charity. When some service users said they wanted to attend, there had to be a risk assessment of the event. This was awkward as the organisers had not conducted their own (formal) assessment, so the service had to carry one out from scratch. Only specifically trained workers were allowed to do this. A few practitioners questioned the practical sense of undertaking risk assessments, since often they were not looked at by other workers.
206
Organisational issues
And then does anyone ever read them? No. Maybe just the Care Commission [CSCI] once a year will actually read them. Otherwise they just sit in a file and moulder. Practitioner
Negative effects If a preoccupation with risk sometimes seemed to serve little positive purpose, service users highlighted its negative consequences. ‘Health and safety’ emerges as having less to do with protecting service users, than with ‘watching the back’ of service agencies. CASE STUDY SNACKING IN RESIDENTIAL SOCIAL CARE Service users at one residential service complained of rules restricting their use of their kitchen. We’re not allowed to go in our fridge in our own home to get the milk out because our manager says it’s all to do with health and safety. I’m sure no one says that to you in your home, so why is it different here? Service user He said ‘health and safety’. He said ‘personal hygiene’, but we’re not going to touch it [milk] with our own hands. But then again the staff take the milk out. We have to ask them. It makes you feel like a child. It takes our independence away. Service user This represents a restriction on a very basic aspect of everyday life. When service users are routinely stopped from taking part in such an ordinary activity as making a cup of tea, questions of human rights arise. The manager of the residential service concerned, explained the pressures on the service. He said registration and inspection by the Commission for Social Care Inspection and the local environmental health service, placed an emphasis on risk. Such demands meant that the kitchen was run ‘like a hotel kitchen’. If residents were going in and out and we had an outbreak of salmonella, we would get into trouble ... but that’s a very jobs-worth response…. It’s not to say we don’t try very hard within the care home for a personalised service. But the actual model always works against you. Manager
207
Supporting people When asked about the ban on service users using the fridge in their kitchen, he said he would see “if we can be less risk averse”. Several months later service users were still not allowed to use the fridge. Another manager explained the trust’s reasoning behind the ban and the process they had gone through. There is an issue [here] around wheelchair users using the fridge. This is a health and safety risk caused by the contact of people’s hands with the wheels, which have contact with the ground. This has led the service to make an assessment that there is too great a risk to sanction manual wheelchair users using the fridge. The risk is that they may contaminate food with their hands. The service has been through a lengthy and detailed risk assessment for this activity and tried to think of ways around it. Manager A service user said when he had spoken with this manager, he had been given a different reason why service users were not allowed to use the fridge. He was told: That fridge shelves need to be a certain height for wheelchair users to use it. But I don’t think that should be an excuse. Service user He admitted that he used the fridge in defiance of the rule. I go in anyway, I say bollocks to it. It’s bloody silly. If you were in your own home, who would go in the damn fridge [for you]? If you lived on your own you would have to go in yourself. Service user Neither staff nor managers had spoken to him about ignoring the rule. He was unapologetic about his actions. I still think because it’s our home we should have freedom with these things. We are actually paying for this and we should use these facilities. Service user Another manager in the home, however, challenged members of staff who insisted that service users put themselves at risk by making drinks by asking: Well, where is the proof that they are at risk? Manager
208
Organisational issues She felt that solutions could be found to most situations, given a practical attitude and a preparedness to compromise. She was adamant that service users could make drinks in their kitchen at any time, including when the cook was at work. The cook sees it as a nuisance, but I say [to him] it’s their house, not your house. Manager We heard about a similar restriction operating in the kitchen of another residential service which also impacted on service users’ lives. If we are going out and we won’t be back for dinner, but we want it later, we’re not allowed to microwave it because of health and safety. To me that means we can’t go out unless we want our dinner first, or we don’t go out, which to me is a bit sad. Service user A year later this restriction had subtly changed, as one practitioner commented: We can put food aside, but we are not allowed to reheat it. They can reheat it themselves, if they can. If not, they can get another service user to, or if not, they’ve got the other choice of a sandwich, or they can get a takeaway. Practitioner Service users confirmed this. One said he was able to use the microwave and was happy to help other service users who couldn’t use it on their own. Another said she could operate the microwave, but not carry the food. It was hard carrying things, but they [staff] did that bit for me. Service user This arrangement meant service users could reheat food while ensuring that staff could not be blamed if a service user became ill as a result. This could be interpreted as an instance of a service working hard in a risk-averse environment to find a pragmatic solution to a particular problem. But it can also be seen as a disproportionate and bureaucratic response to a minor risk where in any other circumstances people would be able to take responsibility for themselves.
209
Supporting people
Another manager of a residential home spoke of her pragmatic approach to risk. I try to take a common sense approach to it. You have to look at each resident individually. [I ask] How would I tackle things in my own life? If it’s good enough for me then it can work for them in most circumstances. Manager
She went on to give the example of a young man who lived at the home, who went out by himself and regularly did not return until after 8pm. She said some staff become anxious but that no intervention was needed. He always comes back and history shows that. Manager
In one residential home, service users going out, had to sign in and out in a large book in the reception area. Here we see starkly the meeting point of traditional institutionalising regimes and modern bureaucratic responses to perceived risk. It is difficult to think of another everyday experience of home that so differentiates residential service users from people living in their own accommodation. Significantly, none of the home’s residents questioned this measure. A manager explained about another restriction at the same service. Health and safety affects not only the staff and what they can do with people, but also what the [residents] can do while they are in the building. A current issue is that some [people] like to sleep with the door open, but because of the fire regulations, they aren’t allowed to do this, as it puts everyone else at risk. So there are little simple things you could do at home, that you can’t here. Manager
All of the ‘risks’ we have discussed here, relate to daily living and basic lifestyle. They were minor risks that other adults would probably not even consider as such. However, service users living in residential homes are frequently denied these choices.
210
Organisational issues
Conflicting responsibilities While the personalisation agenda in the UK has been strongly advanced under the banner of increasing service users’ ‘choice and control’, this is not necessarily readily consistent with the ideological and practical pressures that underpin modern public policy, including social care. Thus managers of services have three potentially conflicting duties: • to uphold the health and safety of service users; • to protect the health and safety of their employees; • to enable service users to have greater choice and independence. Balancing and reconciling these duties can prove a difficult task. One manager explained how working for her large national organisation had led to pressure to prioritise some duties at the expense of others. The organisation, if there is any doubt, would err on the side of health and safety and compromise service user choice. They are very risk averse. They are rightly proud of the low level of accidents both for staff – low lifting injuries and things like that – and also from a service user perspective. It is very easy not to have accidents – if you fasten people in their wheelchairs and do all those things, you won’t have any accidents and people will have a pretty boring life. But if you are allowing people to take risks, then there will be accidents and I think the organisation is very, very conscious of health and safety and that is a burden. Manager
A regional manager from the same organisation said: The service manager has to live, breathe and walk the empowerment philosophy and that can be very hard. I go round other establishments and I hear,‘Well I don’t think it is safe’. But it is adults making choices, doing what they want. I think we should celebrate that, not worry about it. Manager
This difference of opinion may reflect mixed policy messages received and then needing to be passed on by such organisations. As we saw in Chapter Two, it is not uncommon for services to adopt the language of person-centred support, while lacking the values and commitment that underpin it.
211
Supporting people
It is important to draw a distinction between negative and positive risk. Not all risk is bad. Some risks have to be taken to achieve anything, especially to do new things. Some of the choices service users make, may lead to situations that involve risks to themselves, practitioners or others. How managers react to their potentially conflicting responsibilities seems crucial. Services need to be able to gauge risk proportionately and not lose focus of their aims. The challenge appears to be how to find a way to work through competing issues, with all parties involved, to find mutually acceptable solutions. This may require a complex process of negotiation that addresses the nature of the relationship between services, their practitioners and their service users, as well as issues such as capacity, adult protection and the employment rights of employees. We try to run the home in a particular way, but the [registration] requirements often hamstring us for how we have to do things. Manager
The tension for service users and workers The Department of Health, in its guidance from 2007, has stressed the need to be ‘risk-aware’, rather than risk averse when making decisions. Balance and proportionality are vital considerations in encouraging responsible decision-making. Reasonable risk is about striking a balance in empowering people who use services to make choices, ensuring that the person has all the information, tailored to their specific needs, in the appropriate form, to make their best decisions. (DH, 2007, p 11) Many service users and practitioners felt that services over-reacted to what they saw as negative risks. There was frustration at how small, or insignificant risks might be allowed adversely to affect the way the service worked, ultimately making it more difficult for service users to achieve their goals. Obviously you want to be protected as an employee and you don’t want anything to go wrong for yourself or your job, but sometimes I think I am a bit too protected to be able to do my job. Everything seems to be a risk to me, even if I 212
Organisational issues
don’t feel it is and then it is not letting me do what I need to do to help and really support this person in a way that they need…. We should be able to decide whether we want to take the risk, to a certain extent. Whether we have got to sign something to say I am willing to do this and I take the risk on my own back. And we maybe need to be a bit more aware of that, because I don’t feel I can do my job properly, because I am not allowed in case I hurt myself. Practitioner
Some practitioners spoke of the discriminatory treatment they felt service users experienced because of the effect of risk assessment on their lives. The level of restrictions on their personal lives was far beyond what would ordinarily be expected in society. I wouldn’t like to be told I can’t do that. I can take that risk if I choose to. Practitioner I can take risks if I choose to, but residents don’t get that choice. Practitioner We all take risks. If you risk assessed your skiing holiday you would never do it. Practitioner
Preoccupation with risk in social care services also seems to be strongly owed to traditional assumptions about the inadequacy and ‘vulnerability’ of service users. Services, which primarily see their role in terms of protecting service users and keeping them safe from harm, can find it hard to move to a rights-based approach that promotes choice and independence. One manager spoke about changes of government policy in this area, saying: How do you get to practitioners, who have been working with the most vulnerable and trying to minimise risk – and that is what it has been about? Now it’s turning that on its head and saying, ‘It’s about taking your own personal risks’ and professionals starting to get to grips with that. Manager
However, problems extended beyond old and new understandings of the role of services and the nature of service users. Significant tensions also emerged between practitioners and service users over issues of risk.
213
Supporting people
Practitioner concerns about risk Several practitioners expressed fears about their own position and career if an accident or injury happened to one of the people who used their service. They worried about negative public reaction and being blamed. They feared being held personally responsible for accidents, with consequences like disciplinary action, the loss of their job, or being taken to court. But it is knowing when to take that step back and being confident they are making the right decision, because some of the decisions will be the risk stuff and that is when it gets hairy for a worker. Because you don’t want to end up splashed across the newspapers,‘This social worker neglected this older person and they have been dead on the floor for a week.’ You have got that at the back of your mind when you go in. Practitioner Some social workers say ‘I’m damned if I do and damned if I don’t’ So in order to protect themselves, there is the restriction of people. Manager
Some practitioners admitted that these fears had led them to work in self-protective ways. They tried to minimise the risk to themselves as workers and avoid any actions that could have negative consequences. You spend so much time just making sure you are covering your back. The things we have to do when we issue a bed rail: a six piece risk assessment, then review it every six months – and you just think, ‘This is crazy.’ Practitioner I think that often the restraints are about covering our backs, it feels like [that], so therefore it stops us sometimes delivering or enabling us to be very person-centred. Practitioner
One practitioner acknowledged that service users were willing to take risks but that practitioners might try to stop them to avoid the potentially negative consequences for themselves. Some people [service users], they undoubtedly want to take that risk. They know what they are doing. They want to be 214
Organisational issues
free to do as they like. But you’re saying, ‘No I can’t do that. I’m going to get in trouble if you do that, because I haven’t protected you enough.’ Practitioner
One practitioner also felt that the risk of complaints increased when services did not have strong relationships with individual service users. The restriction of such relationships in social care is an increasing concern and as we saw in Chapter Two, they are recognised as one of the defining features of person-centred support. It’s linked back to relationships. We are scared of people complaining and suing. But people complain and sue because they don’t have a relationship with us. Practitioner
This issue emerged with particular sharpness in residential and nursing homes where practitioners were trying to uphold patients’ preferences about end of life care. They could run the risk of being suspected of a crime, if they did not make determined efforts to save a service user’s life, irrespective of that person’s previously stated wishes. That is happening more and more regularly since Harold Shipman [the doctor who mass murdered patients]. I will tell you one instance of a woman who had an aortic aneurism and it popped. She must have gone about five minutes before they went in to check her, so they dialled 999 and got the ambulance out. And the police came because it was unexpected and one little comment by one of the two young paramedics who came, said, ‘It doesn’t look like they made much attempt at resuscitation.’ They sealed the room off with crime scene tape. They took forensic evidence. They interviewed everyone on staff at the time. And this woman had already said she didn’t want resuscitating and having found her having gone, they didn’t know how long she had gone. And that was a really, really difficult situation, really difficult. We were all interviewed. I felt like a criminal. Practitioner
Practitioners also expressed doubts about getting the support of their employers if things went wrong. As one worker, in a local authority adult services department, said:
215
Supporting people
People do sue and…. It’s my livelihood and I’m not sure how far the department would support us if we get struck off. Practitioner
Service user concerns Some service users were sensitive to this defensive approach to practice on the part of social care workers. They felt that some practitioners and managers used ‘health and safety’ as an excuse. They thought that sometimes they had other reasons for not wanting a service user to pursue a particular course of action and weren’t being honest about the real reason. They felt this undermined the relationship between service user and practitioner. I know it’s to protect people, but sometimes there is too much reliance on stopping doing things, just because they come up with an excuse through the health and safety argument. It did upset me … because every now and again, they kept coming up with different things. It got a bit crazy. I got a bit frustrated with it. Service user They keep coming out with new health and safety things. I know it’s because the law keeps changing, but some are a bit made up really. Service user
This phenomenon of ‘blaming’ health and safety was acknowledged by Lord Hunt when he was health minister with responsibility for health and safety. He talked about the practice. I suspect this is a growing phenomenon. There are instances where organisations seek to blame health and safety when they make unpopular decisions for other – often financial – reasons. I would say that the threatened closure of recreation facilities, or the withdrawal of hanging baskets, are prime examples. Say it’s down to health and safety and people will roll their eyes and leave you alone – a sure-fire solution for every tough announcement. (Hunt, 2005, p 3)
216
Organisational issues
Supporting independent living Many practitioners drew attention to a central contradiction in modern social care. They asked how were they to support service users to develop independent living skills in an environment that was risk averse? They repeatedly made the point that people learn through experience, by trying things out for themselves. They said that learning practical skills inherently involves some level of risk. Taking such risks is the only way for people to develop increased confidence and new skills. This was a subject of concern across all the services we worked with and reflected the conflicting messages received and the pressures that practitioners and managers were under. They had a lot to say about it. I think you have to be able to take down the protection and allow people to make mistakes. I am one of those people that have to put their finger in the fire to know that it is hot. I think going through the experiences is where real learning takes place and it is painful to watch. I think [for] anybody who cares for anybody, it is actually a painful process to watch and try to be quiet and just be there. Maybe to pick up the pieces, sometimes, is, maybe what we have to do. Practitioner I remember a manager saying to me once [laughs], probably about three years ago,‘It’s all very well and good this personcentred stuff, but nobody gives a toss about health and safety any more.’ I remember her saying that! You know, and that’s how she saw it – either – or. She saw it as, it’s all very well letting people take risks, but I’ve got to keep people safe and that huge amount of fear and trepidation about letting go. Manager … You know, to let go, to really allow someone to fall down, to fail maybe, or not to fail, but to try and learn, but you know, it is really hard to watch someone and I find that is my most difficult barrier – my own judgements and my own standards. Practitioner You need to let people take risks, you know, so much of it is about risk assessments and allowing people to have a personal responsibility for decisions they make, rather than wanting to be controlling and to limit what people do. 217
Supporting people
People should have a right to say how they want to end their life, you know, a right to all sorts of things in their life, rather than being told,‘This is available because you fit these criteria.’ Manager Well, he has the right to try, doesn’t he? It’s the risk that we all take and some people make a mess of it all anyway, don’t they? Practitioner And even though as practitioners around them, you can be, ‘Oh I don’t know if you can cope with that,’ you got to let them do that, haven’t you? Practitioner
Some managers spoke about the challenge for services, to move from avoiding risk, to supporting people to manage their own risks. This approach is essential if service users are to be helped to develop independent living skills. It is the essence of a person-centred approach to supporting service users. Allowing people to take risks, and live risky lives. Manager People need to get much wiser about working with risk and much better at joint working about sharing those risks, because the risk is for the client but it’s about sharing the responsibility that sits at the back of it…. At the day centre they can take people who are seen to be presenting risk and let them express themselves. This can reduce stress and anger for them, so therefore the behaviour becomes less challenging. Manager
CASE STUDY COOKING As we saw earlier in this chapter, cooking and eating can be a key site for the working through of issues of risk in social care services. This is often in the guise of a ‘health and safety’ issue, particularly in the potentially most restrictive services, residential care. This has a particular significance, given that learning to cook may be an important element of acquiring independent living skills. In a number of cases little attention seemed to have been paid to this by service providers. 218
Organisational issues We can’t light the cooker on our own. It’s an industrial cooker, not a home cooker. Not like a cooker from a shop, like you’d have if you moved. Service user This place was for trying to build up our independent living skills, but not after three o’clock! I want to do that. It’s silly isn’t it? In your house, you can cook when you want. Why can’t we when we have the facilities? Service user
Too many cooks? Some residential homes employed a cook. Restrictions about when residents could use the kitchen then appeared to be dictated by the cook. Services sometimes seemed to be oblivious to the cook’s potential role in supporting independent living, or indeed of their becoming a barrier to it. [Residents help in the kitchen] so long as not too many. It gets a bit over … well, under the cook’s feet really. He likes to be in there on his own, but he’s got to be seen to be helping them as well. Practitioner Practitioners at the home said that residents using the kitchen at the same time as the cook could be dangerous. Some residents told us that they enjoyed doing cookery at college and had learnt to cook a range of foods. However, if they wanted something that was not on the home’s menu, they had to ask the cook to prepare it for them! At weekends, when the cook was not on duty, residents enjoyed being able to do more cooking for themselves.
Summary This chapter focuses on the barriers to person-centred support created by organisational issues. Two related problems are particularly highlighted by service users and providers. These are increasing bureaucratisation and an emphasis on negative risk, linked with moves to managerialist/consumerism in social care and other public policy. Practitioners highlight the increasing restrictions imposed on them by tightening administrative controls. Preoccupation with bureaucratic targets and other measures often conflict with the implementation of person-centred support and preventive approaches. Measures employed are frequently inconsistent with moves to more independent living. Some services and practitioners have sought to develop ‘softer’ more sensitive measures consistent with 219
Supporting people
independent living. Case studies explore how bureaucratisation restricts practitioners’ flexibility in working with service users and ways in which they have tried to make targets more person-centred. Services see it as essential to strengthen the evidence base to support more person-centred ways of working and stress the value of systematically seeking service user views to achieve this. The second and related organisational barrier highlighted by service users and providers is a preoccupation with negative risk framed in terms of ‘health and safety’. Service users stress how it limits their lives; practitioners how it restricts what they can do. Risk assessment intrudes into the lives and activities of service users. Resting on assumptions of their vulnerability and the need to protect and control such risk averseness, rather than risk awareness, stifles personcentred support and is antagonistic to values of independent living. It is particularly evident in residential services. A case study focusing on eating and cooking details this. The chapter examines services’ conflicting roles and responsibilities in relation to risk and how this undermines relationships between practitioners and service users. Managers and practitioners discuss ways in which the focus can be kept on independent living and person-centred support. References Butcher, B. and Marsden, L. (2004) Measuring soft outcomes: A review of the literature, Norwich:The Research Centre, City College Norwich. Clarke, J., Gewirtz, S., Hughes, G. and Humphrey, J. (2001) ‘Guarding the public interest? Auditing public services’, in J. Clarke,S. Gewirtz and E. McLaughlin (eds) New managerialism – new welfare, Buckingham: Open University Press. DH (Department of Health) (2007) Independence, choice and risk:A guide to best practice in supported decision making, London: DH. Dustin, D. (2007) The McDonaldization of social work,Aldershot:Ashgate. HM Government (2004) The Children’s Act (2004), London: The Stationery Office. Hunt, Lord (2005) ‘Health and safety: sensible management or bureaucratic straitjacket?’, Speech cited in Occupational Hygiene Newsletter, British Occupational Hygiene Society, vol 18, no 3, p 3. Kitwood,T. and Bredin, K. (1992) ‘A new approach to the evaluation of dementia care’, Journal of Advances in Health and Nursing Care, vol 1, no 5, pp 41-60. Miller, S. (1999) ‘The development of social policy’, in J. Baldock, N. Manning, S. Miller and S.Vickerstaff (eds) Social policy, Oxford: Oxford University Press. 220
Organisational issues
Morris, J. (2003) ‘Barriers to independent living: a scoping review for the Disability Rights Commission’, Unpublished (available at www. leeds.ac.uk/disability-studies). Ritzer, G. (2004) The McDonaldization of society (revised new century edn), Thousand Oaks, CA: Pine Forge Press. Social Work Task Force (2009) Building a safe, confident future: The final report of the Social Work Task Force, November, London: Department for Children, Schools and Families. SOUL Project (2006) Soft Outcomes Universal Learning Project, Norwich: The Research Centre, Norwich City College. Titterton, M. (2005) Risk and risk taking in health and social welfare, London: Jessica Kingsley Publishers. Walsh, K. (1995) Public services and market mechanisms: Competition, contracting, and the new public management, Basingstoke: Macmillan.
221
EIGHT
Social care practice By far the greatest number … described the good things about their social workers in terms of their relationship with them. ‘I can talk to her/him,’ ‘there when I need him/her,’ ‘listens,’ ‘easy to talk to/discuss problems with,’ ‘explains things to me.’ (Harding and Beresford, 1996, pp 7-8) STANDARD EIGHT: PRACTICE
Services should support a positive and ongoing relationship between practitioners and service users as key to person-centred support. Service users identify this as the cornerstone of good practice. Particular attention should be paid to building and maintaining such relationships with individuals and groups facing particular barriers, exclusions and discrimination. Practice should be based on a barriers and social model approach.
Introduction The focus of this chapter is the practice of people who work face to face with service users. Such practice is at the heart of social care. It is where the aims and ideologies of agencies and policymakers intersect with the lives, rights, needs and desires of service users. Practice describes the role of social care workers in relation to service users – how they work with them. Yet despite the importance of such practice and such practitioners, neither seems to have been central in discussions and developments relating to social care. The repeated message from service users is how important good practitioners can be, but how damaging poor practice is and how unreliable the quality of practice tends to be in current social care (Beresford et al, 2005; Branfield et al, 2005). Issues relating to practice are spread throughout this book, because they are so key to any discussion of social care. In Chapter Four, we 223
Supporting people
looked in detail at workforce issues, where constraints operating on the quality and nature of practice relating to lack of training and support emerged. However, as we have also seen, problems of funding and bureaucratisation and institutionalising regimes, also create barriers in the way of person-centred practice. We know that the goal of person-centred support is to work in a way which focuses on the rights, wants and needs of individuals, taking its cue from them. It seeks to support them to achieve what they want from their lives, rather than fitting them into a narrow range of pre-set services. The question is how far does current practice match this goal and how far must it travel to achieve it? Social work, the professional wing of social care, has always stressed that its goals are to advance people’s autonomy and self-determination. Social care practice has always crossed over traditional distinctions between personal and psychological issues and their broader social relations, addressing both and recognising the importance of the interrelations between the two. But the reality that emerges from talking to people on the ground is a system that has a long way to travel to be consistent with such aims and values. Here we learn more about the realities of present social care practice and some of the attitudes and values that seem still to be informing it, as well as hearing what service users see as especially important for developing practice that is person-centred. It is important to be clear that the practice we are discussing in this chapter and book, is not only professional practice, but also the practice of the much larger and broader social care workforce, including a majority of unqualified and often untrained staff. We should stress the extraordinary levels of commitment and enthusiasm we frequently encountered among such staff. Our project reinforced the broader picture. Social care workers are often low paid and from disadvantaged groups. The workforce we met was predominantly made up of women, and people from black and minority ethnic communities were overrepresented in it. A lesson to be learned from this project is that practice cannot be understood in isolation. Its strengths and quality are not only reliant on the commitment of workers, which was often high. It is also closely connected with existing structures, understandings and attitudes in social care, which are often still moving in a different direction to person-centred support. There has been a strong tendency in discussions about personalisation and self-directed support to present practitioners as a key barrier to change and person-centred working. A much more complex picture emerges here, which significantly often suggests that 224
Social care practice
service workers can be the closest ally of service users, with many points of agreement between them. Their commitment to person-centred support is not only crucial, but under different conditions might much better be supported and encouraged. As the national Commission on Personalisation established by Hampshire County Council concluded, there will be need for change: Social workers and other staff currently working in care management will need to develop their role and ways of working to better re﬇ect the importance of co-production with the person needing care, their friends, family and carers. Such a model moves away from managing care for people, to working with them. It is recognised that a positive workforce commitment to such a model is essential for the success of personalisation. From this there is a clear need to ensure that staff are given the opportunity for support and training to develop the necessary skills and knowledge and are included actively in the process of transformation and equipped to work in the new ways that will be required of them. Regarding the workforce as a whole, there is a fundamental need to develop and retain enough people with the right skills, social understandings and grasp of independent living needed to deliver personalisation. There is no inevitability about the roles required in care services. (Hampshire County Council, 2008, p 72) We have a remarkably clear picture of what service users want and value from social care practice. There has been a significant consistency in the findings obtained from the research and consultations with service users that have been undertaken in recent times, both nationally and internationally. Perhaps not surprisingly, what service users say generally, is closely consistent with what service users and others had to say to us about their understanding of ‘person-centred support’. They highlight a range of qualities and skills that they associate with good practice and good practitioners. This holds across different service user groups and different social care services. The first study which explored this issue, the original Standards We Expect project in 1996, highlighted these issues (Harding and Beresford, 1996). In that study, the qualities that service users highlighted that they wanted from workers included respect, credibility, courtesy and empathy, commitment to confidentiality and privacy, honesty, reliability and continuity, as well
225
Supporting people
as a ‘sense of judgement about risk’ and practical skills (Harding and Beresford, 1996, p 24). Studies, which have asked service users about other types of services and what they want from their social workers, have come up with remarkably consistent findings and it is worth detailing some of these to show this. Children interviewed for research into the working of the 1989 Children Act (DH, 2001), were clear what the qualities of a social worker or other professional were what enabled them to discuss their feelings and take an active part in effective decisionmaking. They identified:
• • • • •
Reliability; Practical help; The ability to give support; Time to listen and respond; Seeing children’s lives in the round, not just the problems. (DH, 2001, p 93)
Their findings about what parents want from services have a very familiar ring as well and here we offer just two as examples.
• Parents value services which offer a combination of practical and emotional help; • Parents value social workers who are approachable, honest, understanding, reliable and helpful, and who have time to listen. (DH, 2001, p 81)
Peer research carried out in the Netherlands by homeless adolescents found that: Communication with social workers is not as it should be. They are not listened to; too many social workers remain behind their desks and there is too little personal involvement. (De Winter and Noom, 2003 p 326) Asked in the same study what an ideal social worker would be, they said: Someone who doesn’t regard you as a client, but treats you as an ordinary human being and trusts you. (De Winter and Noom, 2003, p 336)
226
Social care practice
A study into the views of young people about their experience of educational social work concluded that: The most important finding … was the central importance of their relationship with their educational social worker and the associated practical help and guidance, which was so highly valued. (Pritchard et al, 1998, p 930) The importance of relationships between service users and professionals was also a key finding of a project working with young homeless people. Social workers are dead nosey and want to know everything about you right away. Here they let you say what you want in your own time, they let you get comfortable and talk in your own time. (Fleming, 1999, p 53) Two major national consultations with adult social care service users, carried out in 2005 towards the preparation of the government’s White Paper on health and social care (DH, 2006), both highlighted the same range of human qualities in social care workers as was emphasised by service users in our project (Beresford et al, 2005; Branfield et al, 2005). As Parton says: The central message that comes across time and time again is that it is not the particular model or technique used by the social workers but the quality and value of the experience. (Parton, 2003, p 3) This was also a constant theme in the comments of service users involved in a study which focused on their experience of and views about specialist palliative care social work. They repeatedly highlighted what they seemed to see as positive human qualities which they associated with such social work. These included: • • • • • • •
warmth empathy respect listening treating with equality reliability being non-judgemental (