SUPERGRAVITY AND SUPERSTR·INGS A Geometric Perspective Vol. 3 : Superstrings
Leonardo Castellani Istituto Nazionale df Fisica Nuclears Sezione dl Torino
Riccardo 0' Auria Dipartimento di Fisica UnivsfSita di Padova
Pietro Fre International School tor Advanced Studies, Trieste
\\h World Scientific .. Singapore. New Jersey London •
•
Hong Kong
P"Wished I1y World Scientific Publishing Co. Pte. Ltd. POBox 128. Faner Road. S"Ulgapore 9128 USA qJJice: fKI Hartwell Street. Teaneck, NJ 00666 UK offu:e: 73 Lynton Mead. TOIIeridge. London N20 80H
SUPERGRAVITY AND SUPERSTRINGS - AGeomelrlc Perspective Copyright © 1991 by World Scientific Publishing Co. Pte. Ltd.
All righls reserml. This book, or ptUl$/hereof. rnay /lOt be reprodllCtd in any form or byanYl7Ulans. eketronic or I7U1Chanic41. includingphOlocopying ,recordillg oratry information storage and reWval sy:Iem now known or 10 be invented. wilhoul written permission /r0lll the Publisher.
ISBN 9971·5O..(l37·X (set) ISBN 9971-50-038·8 pbk (set)
Printed in Singapore by I.Di Printing Pte. Ltd.
v
CONTENTS
Preface
v
VolUme 1 PART ONE. GRAVITY AND DIFFERENTIAL GEOMETRY Chapter 1.0. Introduction Chapter 1.1. Exterior Calculus I. 1.1. Exterior forms on vector spaces 1.1.2. Mappings and operations on forms 1.1.3. Differentiable manifolds. vector fields and dilferential forms 1.1.4. Functions. vector fields and differential forms 1.1.5. Exterior differentiation and behaviour under mappings 1.1.6. The vielbein basis 1.1.7. Lie derivative, coordinate transformations and invariance Appendix: The 6 Operator and the Hodge Decomposition
3
9 10 23 28 37 47 53 59 72
Chapter 1.2. Riemannian Manifolds 1.2.1. Introduction 1.2.2. Geometry 01 the linear spaces 1.2.3. The geometry of general Riemannian manifolds in the vielbein ballis 1.2.4. Relation with the standard world-tensor formalism
75
Chapter 1.3. Group Manifolds and Maurer-Cartan Equations 1.3.1. Introduction 1.3.2. Lie groups as manifolds: left and right invariant vector fields 1.3.3. Maurer-Cartan equations 1.3.4. Adjoint representation and Killing metric; 1.3.5. KiRing metric 1.3.6. Riemannian geometry of semisimple groups 1.3.7. Soft group manifolds 1.3.S. The example 01 Poincare and anti de Sitter soft group manifold
97
75 76 SO 91
97 98 104 107 113 116 119 131
Chapter 1.4. Poincare Gravity 1.4.1. Poincare gravity 1.4.2. Extension to the soft group manifold 1.4.3. BuHding rules for the gravity Lagrangians 1.4.4. Gravily in de Siner and anti de Sitter space
141
Chapter 1.5. Coupling of Gravity to Matter Fields 1.5.1. Geometrical Lagrangian for scalar fields on a rigid background 1.5.2. Extension to the Poincare group manifold and interpl'etation of Ihe lorentz transformation rules as variational equations
170 170
141 152 157 166
174
vi 1.5.3. 1.5.4.
1.5.5. 1.5.6.
The interaction of the scalar fields with gravity and the effective cosmological constant The field equation of a massless scalar field in anti de Sitter space (in general in a curved space) Geometrical Lagrangian for spin 1 fields Geometrical Lagrangian for spin 112 fields
Chapter 1.6. Differential Geometry of Coset ManHolds 1.6.1. \.6.2. 1.6.3. 1.6.4. 1.6.5. 1.6.6. 1.6.7.
1.6.8. 1.6.9. 1.6.10. 1.6.11. 1.6.12. 1.6.13. 1.6.14. 1.6.15.
Introduction Classification of coset manifolds Coordinates on GlH and finite G-transformations FlIlite lransformations on GIH Infinitesimallransformations and KiUing vectors Vl9lbeins and metric on GlH Covariant Ue derivative Geodesics invariant measure Connection and curvature Rescalings A Note on the isometries of GIH Some examples Elemants of algebraic topology Homotopy and (co)homology of coset spaces
Chapter 1.7. Applications of the Formalism and Miscellaneous Examples 1.7.1. I. 7.2. 1.7.3.
TheBrans-Dicketheory Minimal coupling of pseudoscalars through a torsion mechanism The Schwarzschild solution
Bibliography
176 181 185 188
190 190 195 197 204 210 212 219 222 225 226 231 235 240 254 262
272 272 278 283
296
PART lWO. THE ALGEBRAIC BASIS OF SUPERSYMMETRY Chapter 11.1. Introduction
301
Chapter 11.2. Super lie algebras, Supermanifolds and Supergroups 11.2.1. The definition of superalgebras and !he example of N-extended
310
super Poincare algebra Classification of the simple suparalgebras whose Ue algebra is reductive Grassmann algebras Supermanifolds Supergroups and graded malrices Osp(41N) as the N-extended supersymmetry algebra in anti de
310
Sitter space
352
11.2.2. 11.2.3. 11.2.4. 11.2.5. 11.2.6.
323 333 338 345
Chapter 11.3. Super Maurer-Cartan Equations and the Geometry ofS~
11.3.1.
11.3.2.
Maurer-Cartan equations of supergroups ~roup manifolds Maurer-Cartan equations of OSP(41N) and Osp(41N)
360 360 364
vii 11.3.3.
11.3.4.
0sP(4/N} Maurer-Canan equations as the structural equations of rigid superspace Kimng vectors on superspace,!hat is the generators of !he supersymme1ly algebra of suPerisometries
Chapter 11.4. Poincare Supermultiplets 11.4.1. How 10 construct the unitary irreducible representations of the 11.4.2. 11.4.3. 11.4.4.
N-extended Poincare superalgebra Massive muhiplets wilhout central charges Massive multiplets with central charges Massless multiplets
Chapter 11.5. Supermultiplets in Anti de Sitter Space 11.5.1.
11.5.2. 11.5.3. 11.5.4. 11.5.5.
Free field equations and the concept of mass in anti de Sitter space Unitary irreducible representations of SO{2,3) Unitary irreducible representations of 0sp(4/N} Osp(411) supermulliplets Remarks about the N-extended case and !he example of the OsP(412) multiplets
Chapter 11.6. Supersymmetric Field Theories: The Example of the Wess-Zumino Multiplet Supersymmetric field-theories corresponding to an irreducible representation of lhe supersymmelly algebra 11.6.2. The Wess-Zumino model: the simplest example of a supersymmetl'ic field lheory 11.6.3. Superlield interpretation of the Wess-Zumino model and rheonomy 0.6.4. The integrability of the rheonomic conditions and the Bianchi identities 11.6.5. The rheonomic action principle
370
3SO
390 390 395 411 416
425 425 435 448 454 4S4
473
11.6.1.
473
4n 489
500 508
Chapter 11.7. r -matrix Algebra and Spinors in 4 ~ Ds 11
519
11.7.1. The construction of r-matriees 11.7.2. The c:harge conjugation matrix 11.7.3. Majora1l8, Wayl and Majorana-Weyl spioors 11.7.4. Useful formulae in r -matrix algebra
519 523 526 530
Chapter II.S. Rerz Identities and Group Theory 11.8.1. 11.8.2. 11.8.3. 11.8.4.
11.8.5. u.s.6. 11.8.7. 11.8.8.
Introduction The structure of forms on N-extended D,. 4 superspace Fiea decompositions in the N. 1. D= 4 superspace The N.. 2, D,. 4 ease The N .. 3, D,. 4 case The Nit 2, D,. 5 case Systematics of Fiea identities in eleven dimensions Irreducible representations of SO{t,9} and !he irreducible basis 01 the D = 10 superspace
535 535 537 545 547
552 555 563 567
viii
Chapter 11.9. Super Yang-Mills Theories 11.9.1. 11.9.2. 11.9.3.
Introduction Super Yang·MilIs Iheories in D= 4 The action principle for N ",, D= 10 superYang-Mills theory
Historical Remarks and References
582 582 684 594
597
ix
Volume 2 PART THREE. SUPERGRAVlTY IN THE RHEONOMY FRAMEWORK Chapter 111.1. Introduction
607
Chapter IIl2. Supergravity in the Standard Component Approach IIl2.1. Local supersymmetly and gravity 111.2.2. Spaclrtime Lagrangian of D= 4. N .. 1 supergravity 111.2.3. The equations of motion of D.. 4, N.. 1 supergravity 111.2.4. Supersymmetry transformations and action invariance 111.2.5. On-sheH supersymmetry invariance 111.2.6. The linearized theory of supergravity Appendix 1II.2.A. Commutator of Two Supersymmetries on the
611
Gravitino Field
Chapter III.S. Supergravity in Superspace and the Rheonomy Principle 111.3.1. From space·time 10 superspace 111.3.2. Geometry of superspace 111.3.3. The rheonomy principle 111.3.4. An extended action principle IU.3.5. D'" 4, N .. 1 supergravity and rheonomy 111.3.6. Rheonomic constraints and Bianchi identities 111.3.7. On-shell supersymmetly 1II.3.S. Ac:Iion invarianee and off·shell supersymmelry 111.3.9. BuDding rules for supergravity Lagrangians 111.3.10. Retrieving N =1. D .. 4 supergravity from lhe buUding rules IU.3.11. Extension 10 anti de Siner supergravity 111.3.12. Building rules for supergravily theories using rheonomy and Bianchi identities
Chapter 111.4. D= 4. N = 2 Simple Supergravity 111.4.1. Introduction 111.4.2. Rheonomic solution of the N", 2. D '" 4 Bianchi identities 111.4.3. The Lagrangian of N .. 2. D", 4 supergravity
Chapter 111.5. The D.. 5, N. 2 Supergravity Theory 111.5.1. Introduclion 111.5.2. Identification of lhe supergroup and construction of its curvatures 111.5.3. Construction of the Lagrangian 111.5.4. Superspace equations of motion and on·sheD supersymmetry 111.5.5. The second order formulation and lhe contraeled version of the theory
Chapter 111.6. The Theory of Free Differential Algebras and Some Applications m.s.1. Introduction 111.6.2. The concept of free differential algebra 111.6.3. The structure of free differential algebras and some theorems
611 615 618 624 629 633 636
641 641 643
649 661 665 672 677 680 686 706 709 716
726 726 728 737
755 755 758 767 777 783
794 794 795 796
x 111.6.4. Gauging 01 the free differential algebras and the building rules revisited 111.6.5. The Sohnius-West model (new minimal N = 1 supergravity): the on·shell formulation III.S.S. The Sohnius-West model: off-shel! extensions 111.6.7. The building rules in their final form
Chapter 111.7. Supergravity in 6 Dimensions 111.7.1. Introduction 111.7.2. D.. 6 Weyl spinors and selfduallensors 111.7.3. The free differential algebra of D .. 6 supergravity 111.7.4. Construction of the model 111.7.5. Non·invariance of the space-time action and how to cure it
Chapter 111.8. D= 11 Supergravity III.S.1. Introduction 111.8.2. Free differential algebra of D.. 11 supergravity III.B.3. Extended F.O.A. and the introduction of a &-form 111.8.4. The gauging of F.D.A. revisited UI.8.5. Constructing the theory from Bianchi identities 111.8.6. The action of 0 = 11 supergravity 111.8.7. The comple~on of the action and the equations of motion Historical Remarks and References
806
810 817 826
832 832 834 841 844
855
861 861 863 866 868 873 881
897
911
PART FOUR. THE ROLE OF THE SCALAR FIELDS: cr·MODEL AND SUPERHIGGS PHENOMENON IN SIMPLE AND EXTENDED SUPERGRAVITY Chapter IV.l. Introduction
919
Chapter IV.2. Kahler manifolds IY.2.1. a-models of supergravity and complex manifolds IV.2.2. Almost complex and complex structures on a 2n-dimensional
926
manifold
IY.2.3. Hermitean and Kahler metrics IV.2.4. The differential geometry of Kahler manifolds Chapter IV.3. Coupling of N .. 1 $upergravity to n Scalar Mukiplets IV.S.1. Kahler geometry for the N", 1 coupling IV.S.2. Solution of the Bianchi identities and auxiliary fields
Iv.a.a.
Construction of the action: generalities
IV.3.4. Construction of ;flirt) IV.3.S. Construction of t:.;f
926 928
934 937
943 943 950
967 969 976
Chapter IVA. The Vector Multiplets and the Gauging of the Kahler
Manifold Isometries IV.4.1. Killing vectors and isomelries of the scalar manifold IV.4.2. The vector multiplet
983 983 987
xi
Chapter IV.S. The Super Higgs Phenomenon IV.S.t Introduction IV.S.2. The mass relation in the minimal coupling case IV.S.3. Examples and Hat potentials'
Chapter IV.S. Dualny Transformations and the Coset Structure of Extended Supergravkies IV.6.l. How to extend the symmetries of the non linear a-model to the vector fields IV.6.2. The coset structure of extended supergravities in D", 4
Chapter IV.7. The Example of the N", 3 Theory IV.7.1. Introductory remarks IV.7.2. The N", 3 vector multiplet and the G!H slrUcture of the supergravity coupling IV.7.3. SU(3,n}/SU(3) ® SU(n} ® U(l) formalism and the solution of Bianchi identities IV.7A. The Lagrangian IV.7.S. The scalar field potential Appendix A: The Scalar Potential Appendix B: The AIII Matrix and the Embedding of SU{3.NJ into the Symplectic Group
Chapter IV.S. The Supersymmelry Breaking in the N = 3 Theory and a Short Account of the N = 4 Theory IV.S.1. IV.8.2. IV.8.3. IV.8.4.
Introduction 10 partial supersymmetry breaking Features of the N", 3 theory and of its potential A short discussion of simple N", 4 supergravity A short discussion of matter coupled N", 4 supergravity
Chapter IV.9. The Directory of Supergravity Theories and the N.. 8 Model IV.9.1. Introduction IV.9.2. Classification of D", 4 supergravities and guide to the related literature IV.9.3. The N = 8 Theory IV.9.4. Results for matter coupling in D", 4 supergravities
References
997 997 1003 1013
1018 1018 1030
1033 1033 1034 1042 1051 1064 1067 1069
1077 1077 1085 1087 1093
1106 1106 1107 1115 1131
1139 PART FIVE. KALUZA·KLEIN SUPERGRAVITY
Chapter V.l. Introduction
1147
Chapter V.2. Spontaneous Compactification of D=5 Pure Gravity
1157 1157 1162 1166 1169
V.2.1. V.2.2. V.2.3. V.2.4
Spontaneous compactification of D '" 5 pure gravity Symmetries in D= 4 A preliminary example: the spectrum of M. x 5' Maxwell theory The Spectrum of M. x SI gravity
xii
Chapter V.3. Harmonic Expansions on Coset Manifolds V.3.1. V.3.2. V.S.3.
H-harmonics on GiH
Harmonic expansions in Kaluza-Klein theories Yang-Mills fields from M. x MK compactilicalions
Chapter V.4. Compactifying Solutions of D=11 Supergravity V.4.1. The D.. 4 vacuum: maximal symmelly V.4.2. Ad~ x Af1 solutions (Freund-Rubin) V.4.S. Propel1ies of !he internal space W: Kimng spinors and Weyl
holonomy V.4.4. OsP(41N} formulalion V.4.S. Diflerential operators on M7 Appendix V.4.1. SO(7) r -matrices
ChapterV5. The D= 4 Mass Spectrum in AdS' x M7 Backgrounds V.S.l. The linearized field equations of D.. 11 supergravity V.S.2. Fermion masses V.5.3. Boson masses V.5.4. Supersymmetric mass relations V.5.S. Vacuum Slabi6ty
Chapter V.S. ClassifICation of Compact Homogeneous D =7 Einstein Spaces V.S.1. Homogeneous 7-manifolds V.S.2. V.6.3.
The spaces $U(S) x8U(2) x U(1)ISU(2) x U(1) x U(1) The other D= 7 Einstein spaces GIH
Chapter V.7. The Spectra of Specific Solutions: The Seven-Sphere V.7.1. V.7.2. V.7.3.
How to compUle ~ on the G/H harmonics The spectrum of !he round $7: harmonic analysis The spectrum of the round seven-sphere: Osp(418) analysis
Chapter V.S. The M"'" spaces V.S.t V.8.2. V.8.3. V.8.4. V.8.S.
The M"" spaces Harmonics on the M""spaces The spectrum of the 8U(S) x SU(2) x U(l) irreps in the Mpqr spinor expansion Conjugation in !he longitudinal spectrum Calculation of the longitudinal mass eigenvalues
1175 1175 1182 1186
1189 1189 1192 1194 1199 1204 1217
1221 1221 1224 1230 1232 1241
1249 1249 1251 1254
1259 1259 1262 1277
1302 1302 1306 1313 1322 1329
Chapter V.9. Other Classical Solutions of D", 11 Supergravity
1343
V.9.l. Introduction V.9.2. Nonvanishing internal photon (Englert-type solutions) V.9.S. Symmetries of Englert-type solutions V.9.4. Stretched and warped solutions
1343 1343 1347 1347
Chapter V.l O. The Embedding of D = 4 S.G. into D = 11 S.G.
1355
Chapter V.11. The Chirality Problem
1360
Bibliographical Note
1367
xiii
Volume 3
PART SIX. HETEROTIC SUPERSTRINGS AND SUPERGRAVITY Chapter V1.1. Introduction
1375
Chapter V1.2. Elements of Two·dimensional Differential Geometry and of Riemann Surface Theory
1391
VI.2.1. Introduction VI.2.2. Definition of a Riemann surface: metrics. complex structures and moduli space VI.2.3. The simply connected Riemann surfaces and the unilormization theorem Vi.2.4. Deformation of the metric. quadratic differentials and the complex structure of TeichmOlier space VI.2.5. Homology bases. abelian differentials and the period matrix VI.2.S. Dehn twists. the mapping class group and its homomorphism onto Sp(2g. Z) VI. 2.7. The group of divisors and the Riemann·Roch theorem VI. 2.8. The Jacobian variety: Riemann theta functions and spin structures
Chapter VJ.S. The Classical Action of the Heterotic Superstrings and Their Canonical Quantization . VI.3.1. Introduction VI.3.2. N", 1. D = 2 conformal supergravity and the heterotic superspace geometry VI.3.3. Classica! superconformal theories and the WZW-action VI.3.4. Heterotic (i-model on a general target space and the choice of M..."", leading to a classical superconformal theory VI.3.S. Canonical quantization 01 the heterotic WZW-mode! and the superconformal algebra Appendix: Rules forthe Wick Rotation of Spinors
Chapter VIA. The BRST Charge and the Ghost Fields VI.4.1. VI.4.2. VI.4.3. V1.4.4.
Introduction BRST quantization. Abstract properties of Q Construction of Q The BRST invariant hamiltonian and the Fradkin-Vilkovski theorem VI.4.S. BRST quantization of string theories
Chapter V1.5. Quantum Determination of the Target Manifold and Kac-Moody Algebras
1391 1393 1400 1416 1428 1449 1458 1472
1501 1501 1511 1518 1531 1541 1556
1558 1558 1559 1561 1565 1566
1582
V!. 5. 1. Introduction V!'S.2. The BRST charge: cancellation of the conformal anomaly. boundary conditions and intercepts VI.S.3 Twisted Kac-Moody algebras and massless target fermions
1600
Chapter VI.S. The Polyakov Path Integral and the Partition Function of String Models
1629
VI.6.t Introduction
1582 1585
1629
xiv VI.6.2. The cosmological constant,the partition function and the Polyakov path integral VI.6.S. Operatorial evaluation of the bosonic siring partition function VLS.4. The Polyakov integration measure for the bosonic siring VI.S.S. Functional evaluation of the bosonic string partition function in the case of the torus VI.S.S. Functional determinants of the Laplacian and of the Dirac operator on the torus VI.S.7. The gravitino ghost Appendix. A Oerailed Treatment of Conformal KiUing Vectors Chapter 1V.7. Modular Invariance, Fermionization and the Particle Spectrum of Heterotic Superstrings VI.7.1. Introduction VI.7.2. Modular invarianca and GNO fermionization VI.7.3. Modular invariance and spin s1rUClUres VI.7.4. An example in 0 .. 10: the SO(32} superstring VI.7.5. A second example in 0 .. 10: the E.@E;andSO(16)@$O{16) heterotic strings VI.7.6. Examples in 0 .. 4 Chapter V1.8. Ouantum Conformal Field Theories, Vertex Operators and String Tree Ampl~udes VI.S.1. InlrOduction VI.S.2. Quantum conformal field theories and emission vertices VI.8.3. Bosonjzation, vertex operators and spin fields in the matter sector VI.8.4. b-c systems, superg!lost bosonization and the background charge VI.8.5. The covariant lattice for 0 .. 10 superstrings VI.8.S. Conjugacy classes and GSO projectors: the 50(32) example in 0 = 10 VI.S.7. Massless emission vertices and the effective theory of 0 .. 10 superslrings Chapter V1.9. Effective Supergravity Theories and the Coupling of the Lorentz Chern-Simons Term VI.9.1. Introduction VI.9.2. The algebraic basis of N .1,0 .. 10 matter-iXlUpied supargravity VI.9.3. The general solution of the 0 .. 10 super PoiIlCalli Bianchi identities VI.9.4. The H·Bianchi identity in the {O,4}- and (1,3}-sectors: determination of the H.paramelrization VI.9.5, The (2,2)- and (3,1 )·sectors of the Jf.Bianehi identity and the equations of motion VL9.S. The lagrangian of N"" 1, 0 .. 10 matter-c;oupled supergravity at 'Y =0 VI.9.7. Retrieving the superspaca constraints from the" symmetry of the Green-Schwatz string formulation VI.9.S. Bianchi identilies and off·sheU formulations of N =1, 0 =4 supergravily revisited VI.9.9. Chiral multiplets, the rmear multiplet and the geometrical interpretation of R-symmetry VI.9.10. 0 =4 Chern-Simons cohomology and the linear multiplet
1632 1646 1654 1672
1677 1692 1697
1702 1702 1707 1730 1745 1754 1760
1766 1766 1769 1787 1804 1819
1832 1838
1854 1854 1859
1865 1891 1915 1942
1959 1982
1997 2012
xv Chapter VI.l0. (2,2) Superconformal Field Theories and the Class~ication of N.. 1, D.. 4 Heterotic Superstring
Vacua ,.-/ Introduction Type II superstrings on SU(2P groupfolds Construction of modular invariants and GSO projectors for the type II superstring VI. 10.4. SU(2)3 groupfolds and superconformal field theories VI.l0.5. The h·map VI.l0.S. Emission vertices of \he massless multiplets in an N = 1 heterotic model based on a {2.2).,t intemaltheory VI. 10.7. Emission vertices of \he massless multiplets in N =2 heterotic: models based on a (4,4)... (& (2,2~ internal theory VI. 10.8. Embedding of a {2.~... into the direct sum (4.4)... fa (2.2)3,3 VI. 10.9. Classification of the 5U(2)3 groupfold reafizalions of the internal conformal field theory Vt10.l0. Details of the SU(2P groupfold construction with emphasis on bosonization Appendix Vl.l0.A. A bosonizable (2.2) vacuum of type A: VI.l0.1. VI. 10.2. VI. 10.3.
A1(1.2.3.4)t!13
2028 2028 2032
2037 2039 2050
2056 2068
2076 2078
2091
Appenidx Vl.l O.B. ABosonizable (2.2) Vacuum of Type B:
B5(1.2,3.4)fu Appendix VI.l0.C. An LRP (2.2) Vacuum of Type B: 826(1.2.3)
2094 2097
Bibliographical Note
2102
Historical Remarks and References
2117
Index
2129
PART SIX
HETEROTIC SUPERSTRINGS
and SUPERGRAVITY
... c'est une chose merveflleuse q'en laisant I'addition d'un, de deux, de trois et de quatre, on trouve Ie nombre de dlx, qui est 10 lin, Ie terme et la perfection de I'unlte Voltaire, Essal sur les Moeurs et I'Esprlt des Nations, 1756
1375 CHAPTER VI. 1
INTRODucrION
The topics treated in the conclusive part of this book are, at the time of writing, the subject of current research. Hence a systematic illustration of all the results is premature: indeed the field is in rapid evolution and our understanding of string theory deepens and broadens by the day. Nonetheless we feel that a few guidelines are by now well established and liable to no further renormalization. These guidelines constitute the modern viewpoint on string theory whose illustration we have set as our main goal in the following pages. We should also stress that our presentation is far from comprehensive. although we made our best to make it self-contained. Indeed there are many trends in superstring theory and many different viewpoints regarding what, in the theory, should be considered most important. Each viewpoint naturally leads to a different emphasis on the various mathematical aspects involved by, and on the various models contained in the theory.
1376
Our viewpoint, which inspires the presentation of the following chapters, will now be explained. It was seen in PART fOUR of this book that the low-energy phenomenology of elementary particle interactions can be described, in its main features, by an N=l chiral supergravity, coupled to a suitable set of Yang-Mills and Wess-Zumino supermultiplets. Such a theory cannot be regarded as fundamental since, at the
quantum level, it is neither finite, nor renormalizable. Furthermore its beautiful geometrical structure contains a rather large variety of data that are not fixed from internal consistency but correspond to free choices. To be specific, the free "parameters" involved in the construction of an N=l supergravity are the following: i)
the gauge group G
ii) the G-representation assignments of the Wess-Zumino multiplets (Zi,X i ). iii)
the Kahler potential G(z.z) of the scalar manifold M(scalar) spanned by the wess-Zumino multiplets.
iv) the analytic function ~(z) entering the gauge kinetic term. From this situation originates the intellectual urgency of finding a fundamental "microscopic" quant\.UII theory of which the phenomenologically viable N=l supergravity could be viewed as the low energy "macroscopic" effective Lagrangian. The dream underlying the unification programme is that the free parameters i), iil. iii) and iv) of the "macroscopiC" theory could be fixed, or at least severely constrained, by the quantum consistency requirements of the microscopic one. A proposal in this direction was provided by the Kaluza-Klein interpretation of higher-dimensional supergravities.
1371
Its success would have explained the origin of the gauge group G in terms of the isometries of the compactified manifold Md in the decomposition : (Vl. 1. 1)
Unfortunately the KaluzawKlein programme fails for various reasons of which the most prominent are: a) the persistence of a cosmological constant of enormous size, b) the absence of chiral fel'lDions in the KaluzawKlein massspectrum. c) The nonwfiniteness of the 0=11 quantum theory. This failure suggests - at least so it does to us - that the very idea of tracing back the origin of the gauge group G to the isometries of the compactified space (VI.I.I) is probably wrong. The main virtue of heterotic superstrings is, in our opinion, that they provide an alternative and completely different explanation for the origin of G. Here with a typical change of perspective the chiral nature of the effective theory is built in from the very beginning. Indeed it can eventually be traced back to the Majorana-weyl nature of the twOwdimensional supercharge, generating the worldwsheet supersymmetry against which the theory is invariant. Let us explain what we mean by this. The basic idea is that of constructing a locally supersymmetric theory in a 1+1-dimensional space, named the world-sheet (WS), whose quantum excitations are perceived as elementary particles in a D~dimensional target space Mtarget' The intuitive picture underlying such a construction identifies the ~~rld~ sheet WS with the surface spanned by a one-dimensional object (the string) while moving in the target space Mtarget' In two as in ten dimensions, Majorana-~~yl spinors do exist. Hencefore the smallest supersymmetry algebra contains just one Majoranaweyl supercharge and we call it the N=l superalgebra. Some people give
1378
the same algebra the name N=~ but we think that such a nomenclature is confusing and completely dissimilar to the classification of supersymmetry algebras utilized in all the other dimensions. Hence we stick to the N=l notation. If we go to the N=2 case there are two possibilities. Either the two supercharges have the same chirality or their chiralities are opposite and they fuse into a single nonchiral Majorana spinor. (The latter case is named N=l supersymmetry by the same authors who cal] N=~ what we call N=1.) We shall simply distinguish between a chiral (2,0) and a nonchiral (1,1) N=2 superalgebra. The general case is that of a (p,q) superalgebra containing p lefthanded supercharges and q right-handed ones. It turns out that the quantum consistency requirement corresponding to the nilpotency of the BRST charge (see Chapters VI.4 and VI.8) reduces the number of the target space dimensions D = dim Mtarget
(VI. 1. 2)
to unphysical values (VLI. 3)
D ::; 2
unless the number of local supercharges with the same chirality is equal or less then one: p$I;
q$l
(VI. 1. 4)
Hence we have essentially two kinds of viable superstrings: the (I,D), or heterotic superstrings and the (1,1), or nonheterotic s~perstrings. The nonheterotic superstrings suffer from all the diseases which plagued Kaluza-Klein supergravity. In the simplest case Mtarget is flat, its dimension is 0=10, and the corresponding effective theory is the 0=10 nonchiral N=2
1379 supergravity; this theory is nothing else but the dimensional reduction of 0=11 supergravity on the compactified manifold (VI. 1.5)
In view of this it should not be too surprising that the nonheterotic superstrings are faced with the problem of nonchiral representations in the fermion spectrum and with the problem of too small gauge groups, which, as in Kaluza-Klein theories, originate only through the compactification of the extra dimensions. For these reasons we discard nonheterotic superstrings and focus only on the heterotic ones. Here the space-time and the internal symmetries are nicely separated from the very beginning. The left-handed world-sheet fermions, which transform nontrivially under the world-sheet supersyrnmetry, are responsible for the existence of the target space gravitino, while the right-handed world sheet fermions, which behave as singlets under the world-sheet supersymmetry, are responsible for the existence of the gauge bosons and carry the internal quantum numbers of the gauge group
G. G is no longer interpretable as the isometry group of any space but it is nonetheless determined by quantum consistency conditions. These correspond to the cancellation of the potential anomalies of the quantum field theory which has the two dimensional world-sheet as support. The local symmetry whose anomalies we want to cancel is the diffeomorphism group Diff (1: ) g
of the compact, g-handled, Riemann surface Lg into which the string world-sheet WS is turned by the Wick rotation t ...
it
(VI. 1.6)
1380
the number of handles, that is the genus of the surface. being equal to the number of loops of the corresponding quantum amplitude. The group DirE (E) has a connected part OiffO (1:g), containg lng those diffeomorphisms that are continuously deformable to the identity map and a disconnected part
(Vl.1. 7)
which turns out to be a finitely generated, nonabelian, discrete group: the mapping class group. Correspondingly there are two kind of anomalies: the local conformal anomaly and the global or modular anomalies. The cancellation of the local anomaly is obtained by enforcing the nilpotency of the BRST charge and this fixes, among other things the number of the right-handed heterotic fermions. The cancellation of the global anomaly requires the exact invariance of the multiloops functional integral under the mapping class group (VI.l.7) (modular invariance). Among other things, this fixes the allowed boundary conditions of the heterotic fermions and finally decides the possible choices for the gauge group G, whose gauge bosons are created from the vacuum by the heterotic fermions. As one sees, the origin of the gauge group is still geometrical, but it is the global geometry of the world-sheet that plays a crucial role rather than the local geometry of the target space. In view of this discussion we have selected the issue of modular invariance as the central one in our presentation of string theory, the final goal being the classification of the consistent heterotic superstrings that display N=l target supersymmetry in 0=4 space~time dimensions. Each of these theories corresponds to a unique choice of the gauge group G and of the other three items appearlng in the identification card of an N=l supergravity (see Part IV). Such a classification programme has been considered in the literature by various authors with the discouraging result that the number of viable theories seems too large (of the order of billions of billions)
1381 leading clearly to an untreatable problem and. what is most disappointing, to very little predictive power. Indeed when the chapters (VI.IVI.9) were written (1987-1988) the situation concerning the plethora of 0=4 superstring models was still rather confused. At the time of checking the proofs (December 1989) the perspective is much more clear and it can be summarized as follows. From an abstract view-point a heterotic superstring vacuum with N~l space-time supersymmetry is described by the following superposition of conformal field-theories:
Vacuum .. (c -
6!c " 4)Mink. $
(c" 9, n = 21e
..
22)rnternal (VLI.8)
where c, c denote the left (right) central charges (see Chapters VI.4, VI.S, VI.8) and n, n denote the number of world-sheet (global) supersymmetries in the left (right) sector of the second addend. The first conformal field theory in the above decomposition Corresponds to the degrees of freedom associated with the propagation of the
string on the uncompactified Minkowski space-time. The quantum fields of M4 and their superpartners world-sheet fermions. As a both XIJ and WIJ are free a solvable theory.
this theory are the coordinates Xl.l of wIJ. that behave as chiral left-handed consequence of the Riemann flatness of M4, quantum fields, so that (c=6!C=4)Mink is
the other hand the theory (c .. 9, n .. 21 C" 22) Internal can be either a free or an interacting one. One just fixes the central charges (c =9, C=22) from BRST invariance, the number of left-moving supercharges (n=2) from an argument that relates such a number to the required number of target supersymmetries (N-I) and finally one imposes modular invariance. A linear combination of the two global supersymmetries is the local one. Any superconformal field theory fulfilling these requirements can be used as a viable superstring vacuum. On
However if one wants to keep the geometrical interpretation of superstring theory and i f one demands the existence of a classical
1382 world-sheet action, then the superconformal field theory (c" 9, should describe propagation on a suitable intemal manifold Mint plus the current algebra of a suitable number of heterotic fermions (see Chapters VI.3, VI.S, VI.7) coupled to gauge fields living on the same internal manifold M.Int'
n;; 21e" 22) Internal
In particular if one thinks in terms of compactification of the ten-dimensional heterotic superstring, then it is natural to assume that Mint is six-dimensional and that the target manifold (VI.I.9) is a solution of ten-dimensional anomaly free supergravity (see Chapter VI.9) i.e. of the effective theory of the 10D heterotic superstring model. Exact solutions of anomaly free supergravity leading to an Wlbroken
N=l supergravity with gauge group G" E6 • ES and chiral families of
ferrnions in the 27 (27) of E6 are obtained by choosing for Mint a Calabi-Yau 3-fold that is a manifold with 3 complex dimensions and a vanishing first Chem class, 1. e. with SU(3) holonomy. The corresponding N.. l, D=4 supergravity Lagrangian can be retrieved from the 0..10 Lagrangian utilizing Kaluza-Klein techniques and harmonic expansions on the Calabi-Yau 3-fold. A particularly nice feature of this effective theory is that its structure seems to be completely topological, namely it depends only on the topology of the compact manifold and not on its metric. It was a question debated for some time whether Calabi-Yau 3-folds could be regarded also as exact solutions of superstring theory. In order to establish an affirmative answer to such a question it was necessary to rewrite Eq. (VI.I.S) in the following way:
Vacuum
=
(c .. $
(c
6Jc = 4}Mink
$
(c
= 9,
= Ole" 13)50(10) x £
n
= 21c = 9, n = 2)C.Y. (Vl.l.lO)
8
1383
where (c .. 0 Ie .. 13)50(10) )( E
denotes the right-handed confol'lDai field
8
theory spanned by an 50(10) x £8 ~rent algebra, generated by 26 heterotic fermions and where (c=§, n::zlc::9, n=2)c.¥. is a leftright symmetric (2,2) superconformal field theory describing propagation on th~ Calabi-Yau 3-fold. In other words one had to prove that the supersymmetric a-model on a Calabi-Yau 3-fold with the SU(3) Lie algebra valued spin-connection identified with an SU(3) gauge connection embedded in fS &E 8, is superconformal invariant at the quantum level and leads to an exact superconformal quantum theory. Gepner showed that such is the case by constructing directly examples of the theory (c:: 9, n::: 21e .. 9, il .. 2)C. Y. that reproduce all the properties of known Calabi-Yau 3-folds. In this way it became evident that Calabi-Yau 3-folds shoUld be in correspondence with appropriate (c::: 9, n = 21e::: 9, ii .. 2) superconformal field-theories. Since Calabi-Yau 3-folds are not isolated spaces and fall into families labeled by continuous parameters (the moduli) it follows that also (2,2)-superconformal field theories should admit continuous deformations parametrized by the moduli. This is indeed the case with most conformal field theories: they are not isolated and admit a moduli space whose geometry has been extensively investigated by many authors over the last two years. From the point of view of the effective D=4 N=l supergravity Lagrangian the moduli are just a subclass of the full set of massless Wess-Zumino multiplets, namely those that correspond to flat directions of the scalar potential. Each point in the moduli space corresponds to a different extremum of the potential and to a different superconformal field theory. A very "important point that has been clarified in the last two years is the following: it happens very often that the moduli spaces of very different target manifolds are connected. This implies that those superconformal field theories that sit on the junction of different moduli spaces admit a multiple interpretation in terms of 2-dimensional a-models.
1384
In particular it may happen that the number of dimensions of the target manifold in the various geometrical interpretations is different. If dim Mint ~ 6 it seems that we cannot think in terms of com~ pactifications of the 0=10 heterotic superstring. yet it may happen that the superconformal field theory corresponding to our choice of Mint lies also at a specific point in the modUli space of some Calabi~Yau 3~ fold or of some other 6-dimensional variety that is a solution of N=1, D=10 anomaly free supergravity. In this case the reinterpretation of our 0=4 string model as a compactification of the D=10 heterotic superstring is possible. In the years 1986-1987, prior to the work by Gepner, the emphasis was mostly on the direct construction of 0:4 superstring models, namely on the direct construction of superconformal field theories that fulfill the necessary requirements (modular invariance, in particular) to be identified as Viable superstring vacua. In dealing with this problem a major simplification was introduced by restricting one's attention to free field theories, namely either to free bosons or to free fermions. The first choice led to the so-called covariant lattice approach, while the second led to the free fermion constructions (see Chapters VI. 7 and VI. 8). In both approaches modular invariance is dealt with in a systematic way, but the geometrical interpretation in terms of target manifOlds is lost. Furthermore the plethora of models is largely overcounted since one counts as separate cases theories that possibly sit in the same moduli space and are therefore connected by continuous deformations. Tbe deeper understanding provided by the concept of deformations and moduli space suggests that one shOuld require a geometrical interpretation in terms of suitable target manifolds also for the free boson and free fermion construction keeping in mind the possibility that such an interpretation might be a multiple one. In connection with this point we. mention that one of us (P.F.) in collaboration with F. Gliozzi has developed an approach that leads to a
1385
uniform geometrical interpretation of a large, yet manageable class of free fermion rodels as describing propagation on curved target varieties that admit a non-abelian Lie group as covering space. Specifically in this approach one starts from a (1.0) locally supersymmetric a-model on a target space: M
target
.. M
lO-2p
e [SU(2)]P 8
(VI.l.ll)
where M10 _2p is Minkowski space in lO-2p dimensions and 8 c [SU(2)J2p is a discrete subgroup of the isometry group of the group-manifold [SU(2)]P. To the choice (VI. I. II) one arrives by implementing the requirement that the target manifold should have a Lie group as covering space and yet should be compatible with space-time supersymmetry. (Actually different choices for Mtarget could be allowed in view of a recent result obtained by P. Bouwknegt and A. Ceresole (see bibliographical note).} In the following chapters we utilize this approach to construct explicit superstring models. Our purpose is indeed paedagogical and we want to show the conceptual path that leads from a 2-dimensional world-sheet Lagrangian to an effective D.. 4 Lagrangian passing through modular invariance and the explicit construction of a superconformal field theorY. In this respect the free fermion approach with its group-manifold interpretation provides a very useful and versatile tool. However the reader shOUld be aware that the group-manifold interpretation is not the only possible one. Indeed in many cases the same superconformal field theory obtained through the free fermion construction admits also an alternative interpretation in terms of orbifolds of tori or of Calabi-Yau 3-fOlds. (By orbifold one means the quotient with respect to some discrete group acting with fixed points.)
1386
Concerning the main goal of the whole programme, namely the classification of the set of N-l superstring models and the determination of the corresponding Kahler potentials we must say that, at the time of correcting the proofs (December 1989), we are much closer to it than we were at the time of writing (1987-1988): this is particularly due to the better understanding of the moduli space. However the goal is not yet achieved since there are still many loose ends. In this book the geometry of the moduli space is not discussed since its proper understanding is too recent. For a similar reason the Calabi-Yau aspects of the compactification and the Gepner's construction of the (2,2) internal theory are also not presented. In the last chapter VI.IO, which was added while correcting the proofs, we shall present the relation between the free fermion approach utilized in the previous chapters and the compactification framework based on abstract superconformal field theories. In the same chapter we shall present, with explicit examples, the classification of (2,2) compactifications one obtains by utilizing the SU(2)3 group-manifold approach. The plan of PART SIX is the following. In Chapter VI.2 we have COllected, mostly without proofs, all the elements of Riemann surface theory that are necessary to understand the functional approach to superstrings and to correctly formulate the problem of modular invariance. In Chapter VI.S we write the classical action of heterotic superstrings as matter-coupled N-1 conformal supergravity in D=2. The matter fields span a a-model characterized by a target space endowed with a suitable metric, a suitable torsion and a suitable gauge field coupled to the heterotic fermions. The supergravity fields are non-propagating and play the role of Lagrangian multipliers for a set of first-class constraints whose algebra is the so-called superconformal, or super-Virasoro algebra. we define classical superconformal theory any cHnodei of this type (nalJled heterotic
1387
in the following) whose equations of motion for a complete set of fields i ~i J and J take the form: ;.
(Vl.l.12a) (Vl.1.12b) the variable z,i being z = exp (T + fer)
i
= exp
(1: -
(VI. 1. 13a) (VI. 1. 13b)
ia)
where a is the parameter labeling the string points and Wick rotated intrinsic time.
1:
is its
In a classical·superconformal theory all the on-shell fields are either analytic or antianalytic and, upon quantization, they give rise to an exactly solvable quantum field theory, which is characterized by a pair of c-numbers called the conformal anomalies (c,c), the first relative to the analytic fields, the second relative to the antianalytic ones. As already stated, string vacua correspond to the quantum superconformal field theories whose conformal anomalies turn out to be zero if the ghost contributions are included. The quantum superconformal field theories are made out of analytiC and antianalytic fields but, in prinCiple, there is no guarantee that they correspond to the canonical quantization of a classical superconformal field theory. The counterexample is provided by the Gepner's construction of exactly solvable (2.2) theories that correspond to the quantization of o-models on CalabiYau 3-folds: these latter are not classical superconformal according to the previous definition. Indeed the nontrivial spin-connection of SUeS) holonomy forbids that the classical equations of motion may take the form (VI. 1. 12) •
1388 In our presentation we restrict our attention to thQse string vacua that are obtained by canonical quanti~ation of Classical superconformal field theories. This guarantees that the corresponding quantum theory will be exactly solvable and, furthermore, makes much easier the illustration of the path connecting the 2-dimensional Lagrangian with the N~l, 0=4 effective Lagrangian. In Chapter VI.S we show that the only classical superconformal theories have as target manifold the D-dimensional Minkowski space-times Gr/B, where Gr is a semisimple Lie group and B c Gr is a discrete subgroup of the isometry group G.r ® Gr. The classical superconformal theory associated with M
target -- G
(VI.l.14)
G being a simple group is called the heterotic Wess-Zumino-Witten model. In Chapter VI.S ~~ proceed to its canonical quantization. In Chapter VI.4 we introduce the BRST charge and the related ghost fields. The nil potency of the latter implies the cancellation of the conformal anomalies of the matter fields against those of the ghosts. This is the necessary background for the study of the next chapter where we finally arrive at the already antiCipated result (VI.I.II). In Chapter VI.S we show that the conformal anomaly cancellation condition leads to fifteen possible choices of the group manifold ~ in the case 0=4. Next we enter a detailed study of the twisted Kac-Moody algebras and of their relation with the homotopy subgroup B C Gr ® ~. The requirement that massless target fermions should exist leads. essentially, to the selection of (VI.I.II) as M .(*) target (,oj
A recent result by A. Ceresole reveals that changing the normal ordering prescription of the Sugawara stress-energy tensor a few more of the IS solutions mentioned above have massless target fermions, besides the solution (~I.l.ll). (See bibliographical note. )
1389 Chapter VI.6 is a general introduction to tne concept of partition function in string models. We define the Polyakov path integral and we show how it reduces to an integral over the finite dimensional moduli space of the g~handled Riemann surfaces. Utilizing the ~~ function regularization scheme we perform the explicit calculation of the functional determinant for the Laplacian and for the Dirac operator in the case of the torus (g =1). These are the main ingredients of the partition function in any heterotic superstring. We compare the results of the functional and operatorial approaches and we bdefly discuss the problem of the gravitino ghost determinant. In Chapter VI.7 we reduce the classification of the heterotic super~ strings we have introduced and of their particle spectra to an algebraic problem whose solution can be obtained through a well~defined algorithm. First we show that the Kac-MDody characters associated with the group-manifold degrees of freedom can be replaced by suitable Dirac determinants. In this way the partition function is completely expressed in terms of Riemann theta functions. whose transformation properties under the mapping class group (VI.l.7) are known. The rules for the construction of multi loop modular invariants are derived and some examples in 0=10 and D=4 are given. Chapter VI.8 contains an introduction to quantum superconformal theories and to their use in the construction of superstring tree amplitudes. In particular we discuss spin fields. vertex operators for the massless states and the lattice approach naturally linked to these concepts. Finally we compute some elementary processes and show the emergence of the Lorentz~Chern·Simons term in the effective theory. Chapter VI.9 is devoted to a study of the effective supergravity theories associated with the heterotic superstrings. Here the main new feature is the presence of the Lorentz·Chern-Simons terms and the higher curvature interactions. We give a detailed treatment of these problems in 0=10 and also in 0=4. our tools being. as usual. Bianchi identities in superspace
l~O
and rheonomy. In addition we discuss the microscopic origin of superspies constraints within the framework of K-symmetry. Finally the content of Chapter VI.lO, added while correcting the proofs, has already been described. In that chapter we show how the SU(2)3_approach leads to the construction of specific (2,2)-compactifications. Let us finally make some remarks on bibliography. Departing from the rule adopted in the previous five parts, here each chapter is equipped with a very few references which are actually quoted in the text, where some proofs or arguments are omitted. The only exception is the bibliographical note at the end of Chapter VI.lO. It was added while correcting the proofs and it is meant to be a guide to the most recent literature, particularly in relation with the advances in the study of the moduli spaces for (2.2) and (2,0) superconformal field theories and of their relation with the effective N=l Supergravity Lagrangian. At the end of PART SIX, the reader can also find the usual section on references and historical remarks. The bibliography included in this section is meant to be a gUide for the reader putting the history of superstring theory in the perspective we have adopted. In no way is it meant to be comprehensive or accurate. For a general bibliography and background in superstring theory up to the derivation of the 0=4 effective supergravity models, we refer the reader to the book by Green. Schwarz and Witten.
1391 CHAPTER VI.2
ELEMENTS OF TWO-DIMENSIONAL DIFFERENTIAL GEOMETRY AND OF RIEMANN SURFACE THEORY
VI.2.l Introduction In the next chapter it will be shown that the proper fxamework for the description of superstring theories is conformal supergravity in two space-time dimensions. The intuitive explanation of this statement relies on the observation that two i~ the dimension of the worldsheet (WS) spanned by a one-dimensional object while propagating in an external space-time, hereafter named target manifold (Mtarget)' The embedding of the world-sheet into the target manifold is descxibed by functions XU (~a) (XU e Mtarget' ~a e WS) which are treated as quantum fields living in a 2-dimensional world. Requiring 2-dimensional local supersymmetry leads one to introduce additional quantum fields living on the world-sheet and completing supermultiplets of which XU (~a) is the first component. These new fields are anti commuting world-sheet spinors ~U (~a).
1392 Furthermore one needs the 2-dimensional vielbein and the 2dimensional gravitino required to make the supersymmetry algebra local. At this point the beautiful peculiarities of 2-dimensional mani~ folds come into play and are responsible for the fundamental structure of superstring theory. The basic fact in a D=2 world is that the Einstein action reduces to a pure divergence. Indeed the spin connection wah has just one component (VL2.1)
the Riemann curvature becomes abelian (VI. 2.2)
and the Einstein-Cartan action of Eq. ([.4.1) reduces to
(VI. 2 .3)
The same happens in the supergravity action. Hence in two dimensions the gravitational field is not dynamical; rather, it is to be interpreted as the Lagrangian mUltiplier for a set of constraints corresponding to the vanishing of the stress-energy tensor of the matter fields. Due to Eq. (VI.2.3) the whole theory of gravitation reduces, in 0=2, to a tneory of boundary conditions. Indeed since the action of the gravitational field is the integral of a coboundary, i.e. a surface integral, the only thing that matters is its topology, which is a sophisticated word for boundary conditions. Specifically, using a path integral quantization scheme, the functional integral oveT the 2~dimensional 'metries becomes, after division
1393
by the group of Diffeomorphism (Diff), a discrete sum over the topologies, labelled by a positive integer number g (the genus of the surface), and, at fixed topology, a multiple integral over a finitedimensional complex parameter space M (the moduli space) whose g coordinates label the conformal classes of the world-sheet. The latter are the equivalence classes of world-sheet shapes with respect to conformal transformations. Performing a Wick rotation of the time variable, the superstring world-sheet becomes a Riemann surface and the whole machinery of algebraic geometry can be applied. The present chapter is meant to be a self-contained, although very much simplified, illustration of the differential and algebraic geometry of Riemann surfaces needed in the later chapters (VI.3-VI.6). In particular it is propaedeutic to Chapters VI.6 and vr.7 where it is shown how the physical mass spectrum of superstrings is determined by the cancellation of global diffeomorphism anomalies, i.e. by the implementation of the so-called multi loop modular invariance.
VI.2.2 Definition of a Riemann surface: metrics, complex structures and moduli space Let us begin by defining the main object of our study. 6.2.1 Definition. A Riemann surface r is a complex connected onedimensional analytic manifold. This means that r can be covered by a finite atlas A{U} of 0: open subsets UCL a.
(Va.eL)
(VI.2.4)
(the charts) which are diffeomorphic to open subsets of the complex plane C. A point p e U(l is therefore labelled by a complex coordinate z(a)(p) e (.
If P belongs to the intersection of two charts:
1394 (VI.2.S) then the relation between its complex coordinates in the chart U« and in the chart Ua is an analytic transition function
faa: (VI.2.6)
As
Io'e
are going to discuss further in later chapters. the relation
between the complex coordinate z on the Riemann surface t
and the
description of the string evolution can be given in the following way. At a given instant T = TO of its proper time a closed string is a loop in the target manifOld: S ... M
(VI.2.7)
target
1
described by a periodiC funCtion XIJ{O,T O) =x" (0 + 211.T O) of a suitable parameter (]. goes on the loop moves into an adjacent one so that we finally get a two-dimensional world-sheet described by the embedding As time
T
funCtion x\l(o,t). The two dimensional equations of motion imply that is made of left-moving and right-moving waves, namely, it is
aTXlJeO,T)
the superposition of a function of After Wick rotation nate
z, t
= exp
('J - '[
and of a function of
(J
+ T.
(t "'it) we can identify the complex coordi-
with the following combinations: (1 + ia)
(VI. 2. 8a)
i '" exp (1 - ia)
(VI.2.8b)
z
In this way analytic and antianalytic fields on the Riemann surface t
correspond, respectively. to left-moving and right-moving modes
on the world-sheet WS.
As discussed at length in Chapter IV.2 any n-
dimensional complex manifold can be viewed, to begin with, as a Zn-
1395
dimensional real one. Correspondingly the Riemann surface 0=2 real manifold whose line element is given by (a .. 1,2)
~
is a
(VI.2.9)
the me'tric gaB (f,;) being a symmetric 2 x 2 matrix
(VI.Z.lO)
which contains three independent components. Relying on a theorem aheady proved by Riemann [1] we know that, in a given open chart of an n-dimensional manifold, n components of the metric tensor can be written in the form of specified functions by means of a coordinate transforma~ tion. This implies that in every open subset U c r we Can dispose of two of the three functions gll' gI2 and g2Z' In particular we can always find a suitable coordinate system where (VI.2.l1a) (VI.2.lib)
Defining (VI.2.l2)
the above result means that in every open subset U C L the line element can be reduced to the following form: (V1.2.13)
In the coordinate frame ~~ere ds Z has the form (VI.2.I3) we can introduce the following complex coordinates (adapted to the metric gaaCf,;)):
1396 (VI.2.14a) -
~
z '"
1
-
. Z
l~
(VI.2.14b)
and obtain (VI.2 .15)
where 4>* .. 4>.
In any other coordinate frame related to the above one
by an analytic transformation: Z '"
f(zl)
Z" f<-(zl)
the form (VI.2.IS) of the metric is preserved.
(VI.2.16a)
(VI.2.16b)
Indeed we find
and by redefining
we reduce (VI.2.17) to the form (VI.2.1S). The transformations (VI.2.16) are named conformal transformations and are the elements of a group since the composition of two analytic functions is still analytic. The Lie algebra of this infinite-dimensional conformal group is the classical Virasoro algebra. We easily derive its structure by considering the infinitesimal form of the transformation (VI.2.16) Zl • f(z) • z • E(Z)
(VI.2 .19)
and expanding the small analytic function E(Z) in a Laurent series about the origin z=O:
1397 +<»
e:(z)
n+l
L
III
e:_n Z
n=-""
(VI. 2.20)
The coefficients e: -n are the infinitely many parameters of the Vita-+ sora algebra. Indeed the tangent vector te: t.'hich generates the transformation (VI. 2.19) -+
t
E:
-+
d
"e:(~)-
(VI. 2.21)
dz
can be rewritten as the following linear combinations: -+
+co
\
L
n=-co
e:
-n
L n
(V1.2.22a)
..
n+1 d
z
(VI.2.Z2b)
dz -+
where the tangent vectors Ln are iDlll\ediately seen to satisfy the following commutation relations: (VI. 2.23)
Equation (VI.2.Z3) is the classical form of the Virasoro algebra in which the so-called central charge is equal to zero. In Chapter V1.4 we shall be concerned with the quantum version of the same algebra whose characteristic feature is the presence of the central charge. (See Eq. (V1.4.38». The previous discussion leads to the important concept of conformal class or complex structure. To introduce this notion let us first summarize the have just presented in slightly different words.
re~ults
we
We can say that given an atlas A={U} covering 1: and an arbitrary metric g~)(~) there always exi~ts a new complex atlas A(l) such that in eveT'{ chart U(l) e A(1) the metric gel) takes the fom (VI.2.lS). Given now a sec~nd metric g~)(~). a second complex atlas A(Z) can be found where also g(2) takes the form (VI.2.1S).
1398 The first question which arises is the following. When two different metrics gel) and g(2) take simultaneously the form (VI.2.1S) in the same complex atlas? The answer was already given: it happens when ~) and g~~) are related to each other by a !'Ieyl transformation, that is, when (VI. 2. 24)
where
A(~)
is any itmction on k.
If g~~) and g~) (~) are not related to each other by (VI.2.24) then the complex atlases where they take the form (VI.2.IS) are different. This means that the complex coordinate z (1) adapted to the metric gel) is not an analytic function of the complex coordinate adapted to the metric g(2):
m
(VI.2.25) At this point one might naively define the space of conformal classes (that is, of complex structures) as the space of metrics gaS(n divided by the \'Ieyl group, i.e. the space of equivalence classes with respect to the relation (VI.2.24). This definition would still lead to an infinitedimensional space and it is not the right one. lndeed we have still to divide the space of metrics by the diffeomorphism group. TI>"O metrics g!~)(~) and g!~)(~) which are not equivalent under (Vl.2.24) can nevertheless be equivalent with respect to a suitable globally defined diffeomorphism. not necessarily analytic. In other words, a coordinate transfoImation, globally defined over the topological space t. ·might be found which maps the metric g~) into the metric g (2) CIS •
In such a case we say that gel) and g(2) are confoImally equivalent and define the same complex structure. The space of complex structures is also called the moduli space and can now be precisely defined. Consider a 2~dimensional compact differentiable manifold without boundary but with a fixed topology. As we discuss in the next
1399
section. this topology is fully characteri~ed by a single positive integer number g (the genus of the surface) related to the Euler characteristic X by the follo~ing classical formula:
x=
(VI.2.26)
2 - 2g •
Let Eg denote the genus g topological space and let Met (Lg) be the space of metrics defined on r. Calling Diff (E) the group of g g diffeomorphisms on r and Weyl the group of transformations (VI.2.24J, g the moduli space Mg corresponding to genus g (i.e. the space of inequivalent complex structures on r) is defined by the formula g
Met (1: )
M .. g
(VI.2.27)
g
Diff (L ) g
®
Weyl
This space is finite-dimensional and its relevance in string theory is utmost. To appreciate this point let us stress that, as we are going to see in detail in later chapters, the classical action of any string theory has the following general form: (VI.2.28)
{~i(~)l being suitable matter fields defined on the world-sheet, and
the Lagrangian density (VI.2.29)
being invariant both under the diffeomorphisms and the \'Ieyl transformation (VI.2.Z4). These local invariances have the fOllowing consequence. If one considers the quantum generating functional
(j (0
are the
external sources):
~(j)
"
Jgig Z(g;j)
(VI. 2.30)
1400
where (VI. 2.31a) (VI. 2. 3Ib) one concludes that the partition function Z(g,j) defined by Sq. (VI.2.31a) depends only on the orbits of the space of metrics tmder the local invariance group. This means that at fixed topolOgy g the partition function is just a function on moduli space (Vl.2.27). In particular, if the matter fields ti(~) are free the functional integral (VI.2.31) is gaussian and can be evaluated in closed form; then the next functional integral (VI.2.30) over the 2-dimensional metrics reduces to an ordinary multiple integral: a tmique situation peculiar to string theory. From these observations it is obvious that we need more information on mOduli-space. in particular on its dimensionality and on its invariant volume element which is the COl'l'ect functional integration measure to be used in Eq. (VI. 2.30). To answer such questions we have to develop the theory of Riemann surfaces a little further.
VI.2.S The simply connected Riemann surfaces and the tmiformization theorem The most powerful result in Riemann surface theory is probably the uniformization theorem of Klein. Poincare and Koebe which states that up to conformal transformations there are just three simply connected Riemann surfaces, namely The compactified complex plane C v {oo}, whose topology is that of the two·sphere 52' i)
ii) The complex plane ( itself. iii)
The upper complex plane Ii: {z eH .Im z >O}.
1401 This theorem implies that any Riemann surface admits one of the above listed surfaces as universal covering space. In other words, if L is a Riemann surface and ~l(E) is its fundamental group (i.e. its first homotopy group) then one and only one of the following three is a true equation:
i)
C u {oo} E=-1T 1(1:)
ti)
C E=-1T 1(E)
iii)
H E=-1T 1(E)
Relying on this result, the classification of Riemann surfaces can be reduced to the classification of the possible representations of the homotopy group 1T 1el:) by means of fixed point free subgroups of the analyti c automorphism group of either C u {oo} or II: or H. Indeed by definition the fundamental group of any space has a fixed point free action on the corresponding universal covering space; furthermore in order to preserve the natural complex structure of the covering space the homotopy group must be represented by analytic automorphisms of the latter. In view of this let us first describe the fundamental group of a genus g surface ig and then briefly discuss the automorphism groups and the invariant metrics of ( v {co}, C and H. Topologically Eg is a 4g-sided polygon with the sides identified in pairs as in the following picture.
1402
(VI.2.32)
Each pair of identified sides represents a closed curve on 1.: which is not homotopic to zero. If we fold the polygon as prescribed by the identifications of picture (VI.2.32) we obtain a surface with g handles like the one depicted below
(VI. 2. 33)
Each of the closed curveS ai
or bi
generates a nontrivial homotopy
class of 111 (1.:). However if one considers the curve (VI. 2. 34)
1403
we see by inspection that c is homotopically trivial. Indeed c is nothing else but the boundary of the 4g·sided polygon (VI.2.32). Shrinking c continuously to is a point of the surface Eg)
an
interior point of the polygon (which shows that c is trivial as claimed.
Hence nICE) is a group with 2g generators rCa.). feb.) g 1 1 just one relation: g IT
i=l
{.1.1 r (b.) f (ai)r(b. )f(a.) 1 ,,1 1
1
It is this group which
we
1
and
(VI.2.35)
Tepresent by means of fixed point free elements of the automorphism groups of (; u {co}. C or H. We note that we have three distinct cases: IJIUSt
if g=O then 'ltl(EO) .. 0. This is obvious since EO is a two-sphere 52 whose fundamental group is indeed trivial. i)
ii) if &=1 then '!f1(E l ) is abelian with two generators. Indeed for g" I the fundamental relation (VI. 2. 3S) implies
r(a)f(b)
~
r(b)f(a)
showing that fCa}
and reb)
(VI. 2. 36)
commute.
Not t~o surprisingly these three cases match with the three choices of simply connected Riemann surfaces. Indeed, as we shall show. C u {co}, I!: and H aTe the miversal covering spaces of the Riemann surfaces of
genuses g" O. g" 1 and g:: 2, respectively. Let us describe the structUTes of II: u {co}, C and H and of their automorphism groups. Recalling Eq. (VI.2.IS) the metric of any Riemann surface can always be written as follows ds 2 .. g _dzdi zz
= exp[t(z,z)]
dzdi
(VI. 2.37)
1404 where ~(z,i) is a sUitable function. This statement applies in particular to the simply connected surfaces. We have to decide which function ~(z, i) is proper to [v {co}, to [ and to H. To solve this question we begin by observing that, at least locally, any Riemann surface can be thought of as a Kahlerian manifold. Indeed it suffices to solve the equation (VI.2.38) in order to obtain a description of the metric (VI.2.37) in terms of a Kahler potential G(z,i). Applying the results of Chapter IV.2 we can then compute the analytic Christoffel connection (see Eqs. (IV.2.S7): { Z}
zz
~Z = gag _ = d $(z,z) z zz z
i 1 zi {--I zz ::;: g 3-g z zz-
=
a-w(z,z) z
(VI.2.39a)
(VI. 2. 39b)
and the Riemann curvature tensor: R-
Z
zz·z
::;:
az{zzZ }
(VI. 2 .40)
As it happens in the case of any Kahler space a generiC covariant tensor has n unstarred indices and m starred indices (VI. 2.41)
In our one-dimensional case, however, there is only one available value for each i and only one available value for each j*. We named these values z and z respectively. This explains the notation of Eqs. (VI.2.39) and (VI.2.40). Furthermore a do~n z index can always be converted into an up z index through multiplication by g~z:
1405 (VI.2.42)
or vice versa. So any tensor can be brought to the following standard f0110 t (n,m) = t
._
(VI. 2. 43)
z... z z.... z n m
The covariant derivatives are then defined by
(VI.2.44a)
(n,m)
( a.
z - m3-41)t z z... z,z-...-z
and their commutator yields the curvature tensor.
(VI.2.44b)
For instance, on a
pure (n,O)-tensor we find
! [V_,v 2
:t
jt(n,O) t
Z .. Z
= -n R.
Z
t(n,O)
Zt.Z Z.. Z
(VI. 2 .45)
The curvature scalar can be defined as follows
R" -g
zz
Z
Riz.z
(VI. 2 .46)
and reads (VI.2.47)
1406
We
conside~
now three special choices for the function
~(z.z)
(VI.2.48a) (VI.2.48b) (VI.2 .48c) If we compute the curvature scalar for the above metrics (VI.2.48) we obtain (VI. 2 .49a)
(V1.2.49b)
(VI.2.49c)
Hence the three line elements
(VI.2.S0a)
ds~O) 2
ds(_)
"
Idzl 2
1 Idzl 2 = '4 (1m z)2
(VI. 2. SOb)
(VI. 2.S0c)
corresponding to the three choices (VI.2.48) of ~(z,f) describe the three available maximally symmetric manifolds whose curvature is constant and respectively positive, zero and negative. These maximally symmetric manifolds are C u {w}, C and H respectively.
1407
Indeed the three simply connected Riemann surfaces can be identified with the following three coset manifolds 52 '" SU(2) = IC v {"'} U(l)
(VI. 2.51a)
150(2) t=SO(2)
(VI. 2.51b)
H = SU(l,l) U(I)
= SL(2.
R)
(VI.2.S1c)
U(I)
of which (VI.2.S0) are the invariant metrics. metry groups SU(2). ISO(2) and SU(1,1) of different 3-parameters subgroups contained in SL(2.C). Indeed let us recall that SL(2.C) modular cOlllplex matrices.
Note that the three isoEqs. (VI.2.S1) are three the 6-parameter group is the set of 2 x2 uni-
(VI. 2.52)
Then the additional conditions y,,-13 (VI. 2 .53)
select the maximal compact subgroup SU(2) c SL(2.C). On the other hand, the non compact subgroup SU(I,1);; SL(2.R) c
SL(2.t) corresponds to the subset of matrices (VI.2.52) whose entries are real (I "
a ;
(VI. 2.54)
Y" Y;
Finally the subgroup 150(2) c SL(2.C) is given by the unimodular matrices having the following special form:
1408
e 150(2)
B )
(VI. 2.55)
e- i6 / 2
where 6 is an angle and 8 is any complex number. The meaning of these subgroups anticipated in Eqs. (VI.2.SI) becomes clear if we recall that SL(2,() is the automorphism group Aut {( u {co}) of the extended complex plane and that it acts on q; u {oo} by means of Mobius transfonnations az + B
z~_=
yz + Ii
z'
(VI.2.56)
(By Aut (E) we mean the group of bijecti ve analytic maps of the Riemann surface r into itself.)
If we specialize (VI.2.57) to the matrices (VI.2.53), (VI.2.54)
and (VI.l.SS) we obtain the following results: The subgroup SU(2) c SL(2,«:) acts transitively on (u roo} as much as the full group SL{2,«:), but it has the additional property that i)
it leaves the metric (VI.2.S0a) invariant. transformation (VI.2.56) we have
Idz'I 2 (1 + Iz' 12)2 and when the parameters we obtain
ct,
Indeed, under any Mobius
Idzl 2
cla.z + 61 2 + Illz + (1 2)2
(VI. 2. 57)
B, y, Ii fuHU the coilst raint (VI. 2.53)
(VI. 2.58)
Hence the isometry group Isom (R" 2) of the constant curvature metric (VI.2.S0a) naturally defined on the extended complex plane ( v {~} is a proper subgroup (SU(2») of the automorphism group (SL(2,C) of such a Riemann surface
1409 Isom (R = 2) c Aut (( u {co}) •
(VI.2.59)
ii) The subgroup ISO(2) c SL(2,C) maps the complex plane ~ into itself leaving the point at infinity fixed. Furthermore 150(2) is the isometry group of the flat metric (VI.2.S0b) naturally defined on C. These statements are evident from the form of the Mobius transformation corresponding to the matrix (VI.2.5S):
z-ze i6 +B.
(VI.2.60)
We might be tempted to conclude that 150(2) is the automorphism group of the complex plane C. This, however, ~~uld be wrong since, in addition to (VI.2.60), there is another one-parameter subgroup of Mobius transformations which maps ~ into itself and leaves the point at infinity fixed. It is the subgroup of dilatations:
z-
~z,
Ae R •
(VI.2.61)
Hence the full automorphism group of the complex plane is the following semidirect product Aut (C) ,. 1SO(2)
0
lR
(VI. 2.62)
Differently from the transformations (VI.2.60) the dilatations do not leave the metric (VI.2.S0) invariant. 50 also in this case we have Isom (R =0) c Aut (G:) •
(VI.2.63)
iii) Finally one can show that SL(2.R) =SU(l, 1) c SL(2,C) is the largest subgroup which maps the upper complex plane into itself. It happens that it is at the same time the isometry group of the metric (VI.2.50c). Indeed one can easily verify that for a, a, Y. 0 e R and
z' defined by (VI.2.56) we have
1410 1m
Zl
> 0 if Im z > 0 (VI. 2.64)
- - - . --(1m z,)2
(1m z)2
This shows that SL(2,R) '" SUO,I) is the automotphism group of the upper complex plane H and furthermore that Isom (R =-2)
= Aut
(H) .
(VI.2.65)
Having singled out Aut (t u (~}). Aut (C) and Aut (H) let us discuss the possible representations of w1 (Lg) by means of fixed point free subgroups of these automotphism groups. The first observation is that every MObius transformation (VI.2.56) has three fixed points on the extended complex plane (u {oo}, as one can easily check by direct computation. Hence there are no nontrivial fixed point free subgroups of Aut (C u {oo}). COnsequently only the trivial homotopy group wI(LO) can be represented into Aut (t u {~}). On the other hand 4: v (..} is the only one that is compact among the three Simply connected Riemann surfaces. Hence C u {oo} is the universal covering space of all genuses g" 0 compact Riemann surfaces. Let us next consider the automotphism group of the plane 11:. Aut «() is the semidirect product of a rotation-dilatation (VI,2.64a)
and a trans lation subgroup (VI. 2 .64b)
All the rotation-dilatations have a fixed point at z,. 0, while the translations are all fixed-point-free. It follows that n1 (L g) can be represented into Aut (C) only by means of translations. On the other hand the translation group is abelian so that the only n1(Lg) which
1411 admits a representation inside Aut «() genus
g '" 1.
is the one corresponding to
Hence G: is a universal covering space only for genus
g" 1 Riemann surfaces, namely f0'r tori. Let us then identify ~l(rl) by two elements
with a translation group generated
(VI.2.6Sa)
where n l , n2 e Z are integers and whose ratio is not real 101/10 2 i R.
10 1 ,102
e G: aTe two complex numbers
Every choice of wI' 10 2 defines a g" 1 Riemann surface (a torus) as the set of equivalence classes of points of G: under the following equivalence relation (VI. 2. 6Sb)
We are interested in the g" 1 moduli space, namely in the space of conformally inequi valent representations of
11 1
0:1) inside Aut
(a:).
First of all we note that by an automorphism (a rotation) we can choose axes for the lattice ZWI + 1102 so that WI is positive real. Furthermore by another automorphism (a dilatation) we can choose wl =1. Finally by a reflection we can arrange that 1m T > 0 where we have defined
T ==
wzlw1•
In this way for each ehoi ce of a complex number
T
in the upper complex plane we have a torus realized as a parallelogram in C with vertices at
0, T, 1,1 + 1 and identified opposite sides:
't + 1
:----
(VI. 2.66)
o
1412
Recalling the discussion of the previous section it remains to be seen whether, by means of a diffeolJlOrphism, two tori corresponding to two different values of T might still be equivalent. The cOlDplete answer to this question involves knowledge of the structure and of the action on t of the mapping class group (defined few lines below) and ~111 be given in the following sections. For the time being We can conclude that the g =1 moduli space 141 is some space of complex dimension one whose covering space is the upper complex plane of the parameter T (called hereafter HT). Indeed Ml is to be identified with the following quotient (VI.2.67)
where Diff denotes the full diffeomorphism group (global and local). In the next sections ~~ will show that the variable T is insensitive to the local diffeolJlOrphism (those which can be continuously deformed into the identity map) but feels the global ones (those which are not homotopic to the identity map). Hence calling DiffO (tg) c Diff (kg) the normal subgroup of the diffeomorphisms connected to the identity and defining the !ll8PPing class gro!:!!? by: M(L ) g
=
Diff ('1: ) S Diff (I:)
o
(VI. 2.68)
g
Eq. (VI.2.67) can be rewritten as (VI.2.69)
Then it turns out that M(k1) is a discrete group with a finite number of generators, whose action on H, has some fixed points. This implies that Ml is a compact space with a nontrivial topology and also some singular conical points. The covering space "T' however, is fairly Simple and has a complex structure which, being respected by the mapping class group M(k 1) , is inherited by the moduli space MI'
1413
In the next section we show that the pattern we have outlined for the g =1 case is cOlDlllon to all genuses. Indeed for any genus g the moduli space M is given by the quotient g
M =
g
Teich(g) M(kg )
(VI. 2.70)
where Telch(g) (the Teichmuller space) is a simply connected complex manifold whose points correspond to those deformations of the metric which are unequivalent under DiffO (t), and where M(L) is the g g mapping class group of the genus g surface. The complex structure of Telch(g) is inherited by Mg' Actually on Teich (g) one can even define a KShlerian metric which is invariant under the action of the mapping class group M(r) (the Weil-Petersson metric). As a conseg quence of its invariance this Kahler metric is well defined on the moduli space Mg and can be utilized to define its natural integration measure. The most basic information on the moduli space is obviously its dimensionality which, in view of our previous discussion, coincides with the dimensionality of the Teichmuller space dim Mg
= dim Teich (g)
•
(VI. 2.71)
In the g = 1 case we were able to deduce the value of dim Mg by counting the number of parameters needed to define the embedding of the fundamental group R1(r 1) into Aut ((). up to conjugation:
The same method can be applied to the higher genus surfaces. Let us then complete our discussion of the uniformization theorem in the case g ~2.
Since C v {~} and ( have been shown to be the covering spaces for the g =0 and g;: 1 surfaces, respectively, it follows that the
1414
higher genus surfaces are all covered by the hyperbolic upper complex plane H whose automorphism group is SL(2.:R). Let us then consider the group of MObius transformations (VI.2.56) where the parameters a, 13, Y. «5 are taken to be real. To signify this fact they will be denoted by the corresponding Latin letters:
Z .... 1: 1
az + b =--. cz + d
(V1.2.73)
Furthermore since the common sign of a, b, c, d is ilDlllaterial we can actually restrict our attention to the group PSL(2,R)" SL(2,R)/{1, -I}. The elements
T -_(a.b) c , d
e SL(2.R)
(VI. 2. 74)
can be divided into three classes according to the following rule: i) T is said to be elliptic if by means of a Similarity transformation (T'" ATA-I, A e SL(2,R» it can be reduced to the form
e Sin e
COS
(
-
sin cos
e) e
(VI.2.75)
ii) T is said to be parabolic if it is similar to a translation
(VI. 2. 76)
iii) T is said to be hyperbolic if it is similar to a dilatation
(VI. 2. 77)
1415 One can establish a simple criterion to decide the elliptic. parabolic or hyperbolic character of any group element T by looking at the trace of T which is a similarity invariant. One easily finds the fOllowing result: If
Itr 11 '" la +dl <2 then 1 is elliptic
If
Itr TI
If
Itr TI" la+dl >2 then T is hyperbolic
=la+dl =2
then T is parabolic
(V1.2.78)
Clearly elliptic elements have fixed points on H (Im
~ > 0).
Indeed
z "i is a fixed point for all the MObius transformations of type (VI.2.75); so if T is similar to (VI.2.75) via a matrix A then it has a fixed point in the A-image of z '" i.
It follows that elliptic
elements cannot be used to represent the generators of the homotopy group.
For a similar reason the parabolic elements are also excluded.
Indeed if we consider a Riemann surface
1: = H!G where G c SL(2.C} is a discrete subgroup of the automorphism group containing parabolic elements, then one can show that 1: is not compact since it has as many punctures as there are parabolic elements in G. A surface L with punctures is obtained from a compact surface
1: by removing a finite number of points (the punctures) in such a way that the region around each puncture is conformally equivalent to the pointed open disk
{z, 0 < Izi < l}. Furthermore, identifying the puncture
with the point z =0, every sequence of points {zn} with zn'" 0 must be discrete on the surface 1:. Consequently, since we do not want 'If} (I g) fOr g ~ 2 must be realhed by means of 2g hyperbolic elements Ti (i" 1, •.. ,2g) of SL(2.:R). The hyPerbolic elements pose no problem since their fixed points always fall
punctures the hOlllOtopy group
on the real axis :R and hence have a fixed point free action on H.
1416
In order to be a representation of 111 (Eg) the 2g hyperbolic matrices Ti must fulfil the fundamental relation (VI.2.3S) which reads (VI. 2 • 79)
The finite subgroups of SL(2,R) generated by hyperbolic elements fulfilling Eq. (VI.2.79) are named Fuchsian groups. It follows that. for g ~2. Teichmiiller space, Le. the space of deformations of the metric (0'1' of the complex structure) inequivalent under local diffeomorphisms. is the space of Fuchsian groups inequivalent under SL(2,lR) conjugation. We Can easily count the dimensionality of this space as a real manifold. Every Ti depends on three real parameters so that we have 6g real parameters. Three of them are eliminated by the constraint (VI.2.79) and other three can be fixed by an SL(2,lR) transformation. In this way, we are left with 6g - 6 real parameters. What is not obvious from the above counting is the complex structure of Teichmuller space which will be inherited by the moduli space after division by the mapping class group. To See this let us proceed to the next section.
VJ.2.4 Deformation of the metric, quadratic differentials and the cO~lex structure of Teichmiiller space. It is convenient to revert for a moment to a deSCription of our 2.dimensional surface in teTms of real coordinates ~1, ~2. We consider the space of Metrics Met (E g) already introduced in Section VI.2 and we fOcus on its tangent space T (Met (tg Indeed, since the moduli space M is given by Eq. (VI.2.27) it follows that g its tangent space, that is the Teichmiiller space Teich (t), is given g by the following quotient
».
1417 Teich (Eg)
= T (Met
(Eg»)/T(Oiff) e TeWeyl) •
The tangent space T(gaB) (Met (Eg»
(VI. 2.80)
at a given metric gaB m is
spanned by the infinitesimal deformations of
gaB(~):
(VI.2.81)
where ogaB(~) is an infinitesimal two index symmetric tensor. The linear space T( ) (Met (E» is endowed with a natural scalar progaB g duct. Given two deformations og(l) and og(2) we define their scalar product as follows
where the integration is extended to the Whole compact surface. The tangent space to the Diffeomorphism group T(Oiff) is its Lie Algebra which is spanned by the tangent vectors to the surface. Indeed tie have T(Oiff (E g » = T(E g )
(VI.2.S3)
every tangent vector ta(~) being the generator of an infinitesimal coordinate transformation (VI.2.84)
Also T(Oi£f) is endowed with a natural scalar product
1418 < t 1,t 2 > ..
IE
d2f;
Ig(~) gaB(s)t~mt~m
(VI. 2. 85)
g
then we consider the action of an infinitesimal diffeomorphism on the metric. We find (VI.2.86)
where (VIo2.87)
is the covariant derivative. The action of an infinitesimal Weyl transformation on instead given by
gaB(~}
is
where 6.(f;) is an infinitesimal function. My deformation 6gae can always be deCOillposed into a trace (or Weyl) part and into a traceless part (VI.2.89) where
(VI.2.90a)
{VI. 2. 9Gb)
If we apply this decomposition to the deformation induced by an infinitesimal diffeomorphism we get:
1419 (VI.2.91a) (VI.2.91b)
where PI is the following operator (VI.2.92)
mapping the space of vectors into the space of traceless symmetric tensors. We can illllllediately verify that the Weyl deformations of the metric
are orthogonal to the image of the operator P1 : (VI. 2 .93)
Indeed we have
I iF..rgg(f;fl,6gaB6~(\to+"JO\MZyOVot) . IiF..rg
>=
=
(Vot ... Vot - 2Vot)o, .. 0 •
Next we calculate the adjoint of the operator PI
(VI. 2. 94)
defined by (VI. 2.95)
and we get
(VI.2.%)
Hence we can write the following orthogonal decomposition T(Met) '" TCWeyl)
$
H
(VI. 2.97)
1420
where H is the space of traceless metries. On H we define the which maps H into the space of vectors, action of the operator i.e. into T(Diff)
pi
pi:
H'"
T(Diff)
The operator PI and its adjoint decomposition of H:
(VI.2.98)
pi
induce the following orthogonal
t H '" 1m PIe ker P1
(VI. 2. 99)
Then we introduce the following nomenclature: ker
pi '" space of quadratic differentials
ker PI = space of conformal Killing vectors
.1
pi
The reason for the name attributed to ker is still mysterious but why ker PI is named as above is almost obvious. Indeed if ta(~) e ker PI we have that the metric deformation induced by t a (VI.2.l00) is just a Weyl transformation. It is easy to verify that the conformal Killing vectors form a Lie subalgebra of T(Diff). Indeed if t~ and t~ are two conformal Killing vectors then also their commutator (VI. 2 .101)
fulfills Eq. (VI.2.100) and is a conformal Killing vector. Hence ker PI is a Lie Algebra: the Lie Algebra of the conformal automorphism group of the metric gaB:
1421 (VI.2.102)
It contains the subalgebra of the proper Killing vectors fulfilling the more stringent equation (VI. 2.103)
These Killing vectors generate the Isometry group of the metric gaa' have seen in the previous section in the case of the three Simply connected Riemann surfaces the isometry group is always a subgroup of the Automorphism group As ~~
(VI. 2. 104)
t
the other hand the elements of ker PI are the sYJlllletric traceless and divergenceless tensors: On
haa " hSa t
haS e ker PI
aa _ haag .- 0
(VI. 2.105)
naB" 0 Why we call such objects quadratic differentials becomes evident when we go back to complex coordinates. In full generality, if we consider the line element written in real coordinates: (VI. 2.106)
and we introduce the complex ones through the identification (VI. 2.107)
we obtain the equality
1422 (VI. 2. 108)
where (VI. 2. 109a)
(VI. 2.109b)
(VI. 2.109c)
In complex coordinates the infinitesimal variation of the metric is parametrized in a similar way: (VI. 2.110a)
(VI. 2 . HOb)
og-zz
= (ogzz )"
(VI.2.110c)
and we have
The complex basis expressions of the operators PI and easi ly worked out.
[Pl(tl]
zz
[p1(t)J zz-
pi
are also
We find
= 2~ zt z
-
g {g~B~ to}
zz
= ~ zt-z + ~-t zz-
a
~
zz_{g~B~~tel
g
(VI.2.112a)
(VI.2.112c)
1423
t, ] [Plug
Z
"~2
(g
zz, '9 ug 1.
ZZ
fE V~6g-
+g
1.
1.1.
zi '9-6g
+g
Z
1.1.
1.1IJ 6g- )
+g
Z
ZZ
(VI. 2 .113a)
(VI.2.113b)
If we choose the always available set of coordinates where the metric takes the form (V1.2.15) (g zz .. g-_" zz gZZ '" gzi =0) > formulae (VI •2• 111) > (VI.2.l12) and (VI.2.113) simplify considerably and we get: a8
-$
g ogCI B .. 2 e 6g1.1. [Pit
11.Z ..
(VI. 2. 114a)
2'11Zt Z
(VI. 2. 114b)
[P1t]-.. 2V-tz:r. ZZ
(VI.2 .114c)
[Plt] 1.1.- " 0
(VI. 2.114d)
(VI.2.114e)
(VI. 2 .114 f)
From these formulae we realize that a traceless, symmetric, divergenceless tensor (i.e. an element of ker pi) is a holomorphic covariant tensor Il zz '
Indeed if ogzi" 0 Eq. (VI. 2.1l4e) yields
o = gzzV-il ~ o-il Z 12. Z Z1
,,0
(VI. 2.115)
This is the justification for the name quadratic differentials imposed t
on the elements of ker Pl'
1424
On any Riemann surface Eg one considers the
q~di£ferentials
(VI.2.1l6) q
i.e., the analytic (q,O) tensors, and calls H(q)(r) their complex g linear space (that they form a linear space is obvious). What
l>'e
have shown is the following identification (VI. 2. 117)
In other words the space of quadratic holomorphic differentials is identical with the space of those infinitesimal deformations of the metric which can be obtained neither from a Weyl transformation nor from a diffeomorphism. This shows that H(2) (1:) is nothing else but g TeichmUller space. Indeed combining Eqs. (VI.2.97), (VI.2.99) and (VI.2.ll7) with the obvious identification 1m PI
= r(Oiff)
(VI.2.ll8)
we obtain T{Met) " TeWeyl)
6)
T(01ff)
G)
H(2)
(VI.2.1l9)
\>nich composed with (VI.2.80) proves our statement. In the previous section, by use of the uniformization theorem, we sho\>'ed that Teichmuller space has 6g - 6 real coordinates for g ~ 2. The identification Teich(r) g
= H(2)(L) g
(VI.2.120)
implies that the linear space H(l)(r) should have complex dimension 3g-3 when g~2. Similarly, for g8=I, H(2) (Lg) should have complex dimension one and it should vanish for g" o.
1425 We will show that this is indeed the case by applying a very fundamental theorem to be discussed in later sections of this chapter: the Riemann-Roch theorem. The identification of Teich (L)
with the OQmplex linear space
H(2l (Lg) provides the natural COmpl!X stl'Ucture of Teichmilller space
annotmced in the previous section. Before closing this section. let us once more revert to the real coordinate notation and consider the variation of the curvature scalar R tmder an arbitrary variat:i:on
ogaa
of the metric gaS'
Given the Riemann tensor
(VI. 2.121)
one can easily veri f1 that in 0=2 the Ricci tensor
(VI. 2.122)
is proportional to the curvature scalar (VI.2.l2S)
where (VI. 2 .124)
The proof Qf this statement is very easy.
Since
(VI. 2 .125)
is antisYlDllletric in
(8
++
a)
and
(y ++ 6)
we can write as follows
1426 {VI. 2. 126)
from which Eq. (VI.2.l2S) immediately follows.
Incidentally Eq.
(VI.2.123) shows that in D=2 every metric is an Einstein metric corresponding to the triviality of the Einstein action (VI. 2. 3). Under the replacement gaa ..... ga/3 + 6ga/3 the variation of R is given by (Vl.2.l27) where, furthennore.
(VI. 2 .128)
With straightforward manipulations one obtains the final formula for the variation of R
This fo:rmula has some very important consequences.
Let us consider a
constant curvature metric R{~) " k
(VI. 2. 130)
and the variation of R induced by a diffeomorphism (VI.2.131)
Utilizing the identity (VI.2.132) and inserting (VI.2.1SI) into (VI.2.129) we find
1427
oR = - lkVot 2 k - - Vot 2
+
VIlV Vot - !'rprl'v to - lv¥v t " 11 2 (XI" 2 }.I IX
k k;- k V·t + (- - -)'\lot" 0 2 4 4
(V1.2.133)
+ -
which shows that the space of constant curvature metrics is invariant under diffeomorphisms.
Similarly if
ogaB
is a traceless divergence-
less TeichmUller deformation, fol'lllllla (VI.2.123) shows that oR= 0 also in this case. Consequently the subspace of constant curvature metrics is invariant under both the diffeomorphism and the Teichmllller deformations.
The
deformations which move away from the constant curvature metries are just the Weyl transfomations. Calling MetR=k the slice of the space of metrics selected by the condition (VI. 2.130) we can draw the following picture
TtWey11
(VI.Z.134)
In the path integral approach to string theories (discussed in Chapter VI.S) one bas the problem of constructing the orbits of the space of metrics Met under the gauge group \'Ieyl
®
Diff.
The above discussion shows that the We),i gauge is easily fixed by
the condition (VI.2.I30).
1428 In particular one can choose k,. 2, k =0 and k .. -2 for the three cases g" 0, g =1 and g ~ 2. In this way in the standard complex coordinate z the metric is always given by Eqs. (VI.2.S0) and the only freedom which is left resides in the relation between the standard complex coordinate z and the real ones ~l. ~2 (VI.2.13S) Under a diffeomorphism f.(j .... F.fl + t fl the fmctioRs according to the rule (Lie derivative)
F and G change
(VI. 2. 136a)
(VI.2.136b)
However not every deformation of(F.)
and oG(F.)
can be traced
back to a diffeomorphism. Those deformations of F and G which do not admit the representation (VI.2.136) are the Teichmlliler deformations: they change the complex structure of the surface.
~
Homology bases. abelian differentials and the period matrix
So far we have studied the metric and the homotopy properties of the Riemann surfaces. We consider next their homology and cohomology. In local real coordinates a complex valued l·form on 1:g is given by the following formula (VI.2.137) Its Hodge dual related to those of
*w is the I-form whose components *w(l (F.) are
w by the following equation:
1429 (V!.2.138)
where gBY is the metric and ea8 is the Levi-Civita tensor (VI.2.139)
When the coordinates are eomplexified the local expression for w becomes
w = to:t
dz +
w-z di
(VI. 2. 140)
where w
z
,,!2 (w 1 - iw2)
(VI. 2 . 141a)
(VI.2.141b) Furthermore if the metric gaB is conformally flat the dual form 'w is given by *w " -i wz dz + i
z di .
to-
(VI. 2.142)
Since we can always choose conformally flat metries Eq. (VI.2.142) can be used as the definition of the Hodge dual. We can now compute dw and d*w and obtain dw" (
zz
d*w=
zz
-iCc-w z z +dw.)dz"dz. zz
(VI.2.143a)
(VI.2.143b)
1430 6.2.2 Definition.
Following a standard nomenclature
III
is named
respect! vely closed or coc1osed depending on whether dw .. 0 or d*IIl" O. If
III
is both closed and coclosed then it is named a harmonic l·form.
Furthermore. a I-form !AI"
"df, f(z,z)
Iil
is respectively exact or coexact if wadf or
being some O-form defined all over the surface.
As it is well known from the general Hodge theory. which applies
to any smooth manifold M (see Chapter 1.6) harmonic p-forms can be taken as representatives of p-cohomology classes, namely they are in one-to-one correspondence with the generators of the H{P) (M) group.
Indeed any closed p-form w(p)
form h (P)
homology
can be written as a harmonic
plus an exact form (VI.2.144)
Furthermore, recalling that the dimension of the p-th homology group
H(P)(M) is the p-th Betti number of the manifold M: (VL2.14S)
and gi yen a set of generators can always choose
B(p)
S~p)
(i" 1, •••• B(»
harmonic p-fonns hjP)
of H(P) (M),
~j ,,1 ..... B(p)}
one in such
a way that (VI.2.146)
In the case of a genus
g Riemann surface the Betti number Bl (1:g )
is
(V 1. 2 .147)
This result is easi ly understood in te:rms of the normal picture of 1:g as a 4g-polygon with identified sides (see (VI.2.32) and (VI.2.SS». Indeed the reader can easily verify that the closed curves b •.•• ,b I
g
a 1,.··.ag ,
are homologically non trivial (they are not boundaries of
1431
any region drawn on the surface) and generate the whole homology group. This means that any other nontrivial cycle can be written as a combination of the cycles 8 1, .•. ,8g, b1, ... ,bg• Hence on the Riemann surface Lg we can construct 2g harmonic I-forms ~l""'~g' ~l,···.Sg: (VI. 2.148)
i " 1, ... ,g (VI. 2 .149)
which satisfy the following relations:
Ja.
a. j
t
°ij
1
Ja.
1
aj .. 0
(VI. 2. 150)
1
S.
jb. S.J =
0
J
°ij
(VI. 2 .151)
1
The harmonic I-forms are closely related to the holomorphic differentials. Let us introduce the general concept of meromorphic q-differentials which was already mentioned in the previous section while describing Teichmuller deformations. 6.2.3 Definition. By a (meromorphic) q-differential p(g) on Lg~ mean an assignment of a meromorphic function 11 (z) in each local ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~z ... z Foordinate frame on k so that g
/q) (z) " p
z... Z
(z) (dz)q
q
is invariantly defined.
(VI. 2.152)
1432 In the language of Section VI.2.S a meromorphic q-differential is a (q,O)-tensor whose components are meromorphic functions of z. The case q '" 1 corresponds to the case of analytic I-forms. The meromorphic I-differentials are also called abelian differentials. One considers the singularity structure of the q-differentials.
At every point peE z(P)
introducing a coordinate system such that
° we define the order of
=
g
)lq by means or the relation
°
ord 'lJ (q) '" ord 1.1 P z... z
(VIo2.ISS)
If we write (VI. 2. 154)
with g holomorphic and non-zero at
z=O, then ordOlJ z•.• Z =n, As for meromorphic func-
where the number n is a relative integer.
°
tions (which are the particular case q .. of q-differentials) the set {p e 4g ; ordp Uq # a} is discrete and finite.
of points
At any point
tensor)l
z••• Z
P e Eg •
if we set
N ::ordp u(q)
then the (q,O)-
admits a Laurent series expansion 00
)l
'" Z ... 2:
L a zn n=N n
and we can define the residue of the differential
(VI. 2 .155)
jJ (q)
at
P through
the following identification: (VI.2.1S6)
When ordp lJ (q) < 0. u (q) has a pole at P. When ord p 1J (q) > 0, P is a zero for lJ (q) • The points for which ordp lJ (q) :: are the regular points of the differential.
°
1433 6.2.4 Definition.
A meromojhiC q-differential
if it has no poles
(ord p lJ (q
6.2.5 Definition.
HololDOrphic I-differentials are called Abelian
~0
for all
P
)J (q)
is holomorphic
e Eg)'
differentials of the first kind. 6.2.6 Definition.
Meromorphic I-differentials with poles but zero
residues are called abelian differentials of the second kind. 6.2.7 Definition.
Meromorphic I-differentials with residues are
called abelian differentials of the third kind. Let us now go back to
Eqs. (VI.2.I43) and consider their implica-
tions for a hannonic differential. If w is harmonic we conclude that (VI.2.1S7a)
azw-z = 0
(VI. 2 .IS7b)
.
z is an analytic function while
z
Hence
W
tion.
It follows that we can define two analytic I-differentials
W
is an antianalytic func-
(VI.2.1S8a) (VI. 2 .lS8b)
such that the harmonic differential can be written as follows (VI.2.1S9) Furthermore since w has no singularity WI and 11)2 are holomorphic. So we have shown that any harmonic differential can be written in terms of two holomorphic differentials through the relation (VI.2.1S9).
1434
In particular a real haTmonic differential is twice the real part of a holomorphic differential u"ZRew.
(VI. 2. ]60)
We can now prove also the converse theorem. 6.2.8 Theorem. A differential I-foTm w is holomo!phic if and only if w" ex + i *u for some harmonic di fferential a. If a
Proof:
is harmonic then (VI. 2 .161)
with wi and w2 holomorphic. Then using Eq. (Vr.2.142) we get (VI.Z .162)
so that (VI.2.163)
is holomorphic. Conversely, if w is holomorphic then it is also harmonic, and so is its conjugate w. Indeed dw'" d'w = 0 .
(VI. 2.164)
Hence we can introduce the harmonic differential 1
-
(VI.2.16S)
(w + iii)
(VI. 2.166)
ex" 2" (0) - w) and we obtain *a " -
which implies
!.2
1435 w .. IX
i-
i *11
(VI.Z .167)
as we wanted to show. interesting corollary of this theorem provides a simple criterion for the holomorphicity of a differential. M
6.2.9 Corollary: w is a holomorphic I-differential if and on1r if it is closed (dw: 0) and if it is antiselfdual (*w", -iw).
The space of I-foms on the Riemann surface I: can be given a g Hilbert space structure introducing the folloWing hermitian scalar product (VI.. Z.168)
where the integration is extended to the whole surface. In particular given the canonical homology basis identified by the sides of the 4gpolygon and the associated canonical cohomology basis defined by Eqs. (VI.2.148) the scalar product (VI.2.168) can be utilized to define the 2g x 2g intersection mat rix J: (Il1.•
*a.)) J (VI.2.169)
(81'
*aj )
The entries of J can be easily calculated using a lemma which holds true for closed forms.
(VI. 2 .170)
1436 ~:
Consider the fundamental 4g~polygon (VI.2.32). hereafter named , . Since f1 is simply connected the closed form 61 can be written as an exact form on 9 (VI. 2.171)
However it has the property that its values on the identified sides are equal. Using (VI.2.171) we can write (VI. 2 .172)
Using Stokes' theorem in (VI.2.172) we get
(VI. 2.173)
Now by hypothesis
to
is a primitive of the differential 81, Hence if ~ and z and Zl are t~~ equivalent
f
is an interior point of .
pOlnts on ai
-1.
and ai
l>'e
can Wrlte
(VI. 2 .174)
Consider then the following picture
b'l A_----
Zo
1437
By inspection of (VI.2.17S) we see that
: ~ fa. fb. 1
1
8182
=- f
b.
1
81
Ja.
62 • (VI.2.176)
1
Repeating the argument for the other two terms of Eq. (VI.2.173) we obtain the proof of the lemma.
Utilizing lemma (VI.2.170) the
inter~
section matrix J is immediately worked out and we find that J
is
equal to the canonical symplectic metric in 2g dimensions:
(VI. 2 .177)
The reason for the name intersection matrix given to J should now be explained. Geometrically, if w is the closed (harmonic) form associated c1 to a cycle
c l and w
z
C
is the closed harmonic form associated to a
cycle cz, then the antisymmetric scalar product (VI.2.178}
has a simple interpretation:
c10cZ is the number of times the curve c1 intersects the curve c Z. Given a direction on c1 and c2 ' the intersections are cotmted positive if c2 "arrives" from the right of
c1 and negative if c2 arrives from the left of Ct. has
In general one
(VI. 2•179a)
1438 (VI. 2 • 179b)
(VI.2.l80a)
(VI. 2. 180b)
and using lemma (VI.Z.l7D) the intersection number (VI.2.l7S) is found to be: (VI.Z.181)
1m example might be clarifying.
Consider c1 =2a1 and
C
z =bl •
We
find (VI. z.182)
Looking at the following picture we see that c1 has indeed two positive intersections with c2
(VI. 2 .183)
6.2.11 Definition. A basis of generators Cr (1 =1, .... 2g) of the first homology group HI (ig) is canonical when the intersection matrix is the canoni cal one (VI. 2. 177)
1439 (VI. 2.184) As we have seen the cycles
al"); .ag • b l , .... bg associated to the form a canonical homology basis. This. however.
4g~polygon
sides of the
is not the only one.
Indeed any set of 2g linear combinations with
integer coefficients
(Aij • Bij , Cij • Dij
e Z): (VI. 2 • 185a) (VI. 2. 18Sb)
bit = C.ja. + D.jb. 1 J 1 J
such that a!'b!
" °ij
(VI. 2. 186a)
b! 'b! 1 J
" 0
(VI. 2 .186b)
provides another canonical basis.
Conditions (VI.2.186) can be written
0 J "
a! 'a! 1
b! 'a! 1 J
"
1
- O1J••
in matrix form as follows.
)
Defining the 2g x 2g matrix
(VI.2.181)
whose entries are integer numbers we must have AT J A", J co- A e Sp(2g.I) .
6.2.12 Definition.
The discrete group Sp(2g,Z)
(V1.2.188)
is called the sym-
plectic modular group. Any canonical basis is related to another one by a suitable Sp(2g.I) transformation.
1440
We construct now the holomorphic differentials associated to a canonical homology basis. We begin by introducing a collective name for the a., B. l-foms defined by Eq. (VI.2.149): 1 1 I:;i, ... ,2g
(VI. 2 .189)
and we recall that (VI.2.190)
We consider then the matrix
rrJ
defined by (VI. 2 .191)
where the *-operation was defined in Eq. (VI.2.142). 6.2.13 Lemma.
r IJ is a
s~~etric
matrix.
Proof: Indeed we know that (,) is a hermitian scalar product in the Hilbert space of I-forms. Furthermore Yr and YJ are real 1forms. Hence the lemma follows. 6.2.14 Lemma. The matrix rrJ is positive definite. Proof: If we consider any harmonic I-form along the basis Y1:
Since
e
e
it can be decomposed
has necessarily positive norm
o < 1e12 "' J e ~ *-a = {.i. il. I J
the lemma follows.
f,
I -J f,
r1J
(VI. 2.192)
1441
We can now write the 2g x 2g matrix r in g x g blocks:
(VI.2 .193)
and we have the conditions
~ = ~T > 0
(VI. 2.194a) (VI. 2. 194b )
which express the positivity and symmetricity of r. Since 'Y I is again a harmonic 1-form we can write it as a linear combination of YJ : (VI.2.19S) The matrix K whose entries are kIJ represents the Hodge duality operation in the canonical homology basis so that it necessarily fulfils the following condi tion (VI, 2 .196)
In this way we obtain (VI. 2.197)
which, in matrix notation, can be written as follows
r " - KJ
(VI. 2. 19B)
Writing K in block form
(VI.2.199)
1442 we obtain
(VI.2.200)
and we have the identifications: (VU.20l) which combined with Eq. (VI.2.l96) imply
(VJ.2.202)
Let us now introduce the following 2g holomorphic I-forms: (VI.2.203) Defining the matrix (VI.2.204) and by explicit calculation we obtain (VI. 2.205) Defining then the following set of g holomorphic differentials {VI.2.206) We can easily veri fy that (VI. 2.207a)
1443
(VI.2.207b) where the matrix
n =:
n is defined as follows:
(.a+ i ~)9J.l
(V1.2.208)
in terms of the blocks (VI.2.194) of the matrix (VI.2.191).
6.2.15 Definition. IT is called the period matrix of the Riemann surface I: . g
n
The fundamental properties of the period matrix are the following: is symmetric and its imaginary part is positive definite, i.e.
n.. ; ; n..
(VI.2.209a)
1m n > 0
(VI. 2. 209b)
1.J
)1
Both properties (VI.2.209) are an immediate consequence of Eqs. (VI.2.194), (VI.2.202) and the definition (VI.2.20B). What we have shown is that given a canonical homology basis we can always choose g holomorphic differentials whose "periods" along the a-cycles are given by Eq. (VI.2.207a) Once this normalization has been chosen the period matrix along the b-cycles is uniquely defined (in the chosen homology basis) and reflects intrinsic properties of the Riemann surface under considera· tion. An obvious question is the following.
If we perform a transformation from a canonical homology basis to another one, how does the period matrix IT change under the corresponding symplectic modular group matrix A e Sp(2g,Z)? The answer is simple. In the notations of Sq. (VI.2.187) we have:
TI' : (C
+
Dll)(A
+
BIT)-l
(VI.2.210)
1444 Let us prove the above result.
into a 2g-vector Yr
(CLi'Si)
ing cycles
We have arranged the hatlJlOIlic I-fol1llS
Similarly we can arrange the correspond-
(al.b i ) into another 2g-vector CI , We have the normaliza-
tion condition (VI.2.21l)
The new cycles
(ar bi) are given by the Sp(2g.Z) transformation
(VI.2.212)
Then we obtain (VI.2.213)
where
An
are the matrix elements of the Sp(2g.Z) matrix (see Eq.
(VI. 2.187)) . T yi =(A-1 )IR 'YR
If we redefine
JC·
Yj
= °IJ
we get (VI. 2.214)
.
r
Correspondingly since
fa.'),. = Akl'aJ It
r
'j
+
Bk
J ~.J
l'b
r
= (A
+
SU)k'
(VI.2.21S)
J
in order to rest01.'e the standard normalization condition (VI.2.216)
we must set
1445 (VI.2.217) so that
fbi k
~j " Ckr fa
tj
tj"
+ Dkr Ib
r
r
[(C + Dfi)(A + Bfl)-1I k;
(VI.2.218)
which proves Eq. (VI.2.2l0). It is clear that two period matrices II'
and II which are
related by an Sp(2g,Z) transformation are equivalent and describe the same Riemann surface.
The next natural question which arises is then
the following. If we call upper Siegel plane M(g) the set of complex gxg matrices fulfilling conditions (VI.2.209) and we divide it by the action of the symplectic modular group (VI.2.219a) we may ....,onder whether the space Ag one obtains in this way is not by any chance the moduli space M of the genus g Riemann surfaces. g
In
other words the question is whether, given, a matrix IT which fulfills Eq. (VI.2.209) we can always find a suitable Riemann surface I
and a g suitable homology basis such that IT is the corresponding period matrix. On a simple dimensional argument the answer to this question is clearly negative. for genuses g > 2.
Indeed the complex dimension
of the upper Siegel plane and hence of Ag is dim A "dim H g
",'bien for
g
".!..2 g(g + 1)
(VI. 2. 219b)
g > 2 is always bigger than the dimension of the moduli space
Mg' the latter being 3g - 3. Hence for g >2,
M is injected into a proper subspace of g
1446 M ..... A
g
g
= Hg/Sp(2g,Z)
(VI. 2 .220)
whose characterization has been, for a very long time. an outstanding problem in Algebraic Geometry (the SChottky problem). The solution was apparently fOWld in the course of last year [2].
For g =1 and
g = 2. however. the upper Siegel plane has exactly the same dimension as the moduli space. (VI. 2. 221a)
dim M(l) = dim H(l) = 1
dim N(2) = dim H(2)
=3 .
(VI.2. 221b)
Hence in these cases the entries of the period matrix can be utilized as a parametrization of moduli space. The case of the torus
(g =1)
can be worked out in details and
it is very instructive. In picture (VI.2.66) we saw that a torus can be viewed as a parallelogram in C with vertices at 0,
'!.
I,
'! + 1
and identified
opposite sides. The complex number Let ~l e lO.2~] of the torus.
identifies the complex structure of the
'!
torus and is its modulus.
This is seen in the following way.
and
(2 e
[O.2~]
be the two real coordinates
We can introduce the complex variable z through the
following relation (VI.2.222)
The a and b cycles of the canonical homology basis are easily identified.
i_____7 a
(VI.2.223)
1447 Consider the fOllowing I-forms: 1 dE" a .. '01 211
1 (d= --.1 t
a = -2111 d'o2co
1 " --_- Cdz - dZ)
(1-1)
./
j. -d - 1 z)
(VI. 2.224a)
(VI.2.224b)
(1-1)
using the definition (VI.2.142) of the Hodge dual and the obvious relation d2z =d2z=O. we see that (l and B are both closed and coclosed. Hence they are hamonic. Furthermore when we integrate a along the cycle a:
z
= ~l'
~1 e [0,211]
and when we integrate
(Vr:2.22S)
B along the cycle b: (VI. 2.226)
in both cases the result is one.
Hence a and B are the representa-
tives of the canonical cohomology basis.
Considering their duals: (VI. 2. 227a)
*6 .. -
~
(VI. 2 .227b)
(dz + di)
(T - T)
we can compute the matrix
r
of Eq. (VI.2.193):
(VI. 2.228a) T -1
a"
(a.S) ..
If
(l",
*6"
l(l+_f~ (1 - t)
If
dz"dz" -i 1+~ T - '[
(VI. 2 .228b)
1448 (VI.2.228c)
610. .. :II'
(8.8) =
II fL. *8 = ~
21 (T - 1')2
J dZ"dz- = -2i- .
(VI.2.228d)
(T - 'f)
Inserting these results into Sq. (VI.2.20S) we find (VI. 2.229) Hence in the case of the torus the llIOdulus paramet ri dng the complex structure coincides exactly with the period mattix. This identification has an immediate implication for the problem which was left unsolved in Section VI.2.3. There we considered the question whether all values of T corresponded to inequivalent tori or whether there were some identifications in the upper T-plane induced by suitable diffeomorphisms. We anticipated the result that the variable T is insensitive to the local diffeomorphisms (those which can be continuously deformed into the identity map) but that it feels the global ones (those which are not homotopic to the identity map). We concluded that the moduli space M1 is equal to the upper complex plane eli vided by the action of the mapping class group MeL!). The structure of M(Ll ). however. was not discussed. The identification (V1.2.229) of the modulus T with the period v tells us a lot about MeLl). Indeed two periods 11 and '1ft differing by a symplectic modular group transformation (see Eq. (VI.2.210» '1ft
dll +_ C =_
(VI.2.2lOa)
b1l + a
b)
a , ( c d
e Sp(2,Z)
= SL(2,1)
(VI.2.230b)
are equivalent since they just correspond to two different canonical homology bases on the same surface.
1449 Correspondingly, values of T differing by the modular transformation (VI.2.230) must be equivalent under suitable global diffeomorphisms. This shows that M(L 1} must at least contain SL(2,Z). This leads to the topic of the next section where we consider the general structure of the mapping class group and its representation on the homology bases.
VI.2.6 Oehn twists, the mapping class group and its homomorphism onto Sp(2g,l) The mapping class group was defined in Eq. (VI.2.68). A deep theorem which we do not prove here [31 states that every nontrivial equivalence class in Di Ef/Di ffO can be represented by a Dehn twist around a suitable non contractible loop eeL. The Dehn twist is g constructed as follows. Given c, let us consider a neighborhood of c that is topologically equivalent to a cylinder. Let us now cut Lg along c and keeping one of the edges of the cut fixed let us twist the other by a 2~ rotation and then glue the edges together once more. In this way every pOint of the original surface is associated to a point of the new surface in a way which is smooth and yet clearly not continuously related to the identity map. A useful set of generators of M(L) is given by the Dehn twists around the 2g + g - 1 cycles g displayed in the following picture:
(VI. 2.231)
The cycles ai' bi correspond to the standard canonical homology basis and wind around the i-th handle. The cycles
1450 (VI. 2.232)
connect instead two adjacent handles. This choice of the mapping class group generators shows that there is nothing qualitatively new in M(E) beyond g =2. g This observation will be very important in Chapter VI. 6 when we discuss multiloop modular invariance of the heterotic superstrings. Let now D
c
be the Oehn twist associated to a cycle c.
D
c
is
a diffeomorphism and as such it leaves the intersection matrix (VI.2.169) invariant. Indeed the entries of J. being integrals of l·form wedge products, are manifestly diffeomorphic invariant. Hence the action A(D) of D on the homology basis must be
c
c
given by a symplectic unimodular matrix
A{Dc) E Sp(2g,I) .
(VI. 2.233)
In fact the set of matrices A(De ) generate all of Sp(2g.I). However a lot of info:nnation is lost when passing from 0 to c its matrix representation A(Dc )' Indeed, a Oehn twist around a homo· logically trivial curve, although nontrl vial as a global diffeomorphism.
yet does not affect the homology class of any curve and, as such, it maps to the unit matrix. The twists around the hOlllOlogically trivial cycles generate a nOl'Jllal subgroup of the mapping class group Tor(E ) c M{l: )
g
g
(VI. 2.234)
called the "Torelli group". The period matrix IT is insensitive to the action of the Torelli group and it just feels the transformations of Sp(2g,Z) which is nothing else but the following quotient:
Sp(2g.Z) ='
M(l: ) g
Tor (Eg)
(VI.2.23S)
1451 At. we are going to see in later Shapters. in most of the applications to string theory the structures one considers (spin structures for fermions and bosons) are
insensit~ye
to the Torelli group and one has
just to implement the invariance under Sp(2g,Z). This is a very fortunate situation since the structure of the Torelli group is not known for general surfaces. As an illustration of the general theory and also in view of its relevance in later chapters. let us now discuss in some detail the g" 1 mapping class group. In the previous section we pointed out that the identification of the period n with the modulus T implied the relation (VI. 2. 236)
where PSL(2,Z)
is defined by
PSL(2.Z)
SL(2.1)
The normal subgroup 12 generated by the matrix
(VI. 2.237)
(-1o -10)
has to be
factored out since the two matrices
(ac b), (-a-c ,, -b) d
(VI. 2.238)
-d
correspond to the same MObius-like transformation (VI.2.230) on the period n.
In this section we want to show that, actually, PSL(2,Z) is the full mapping class group in the g" 1 case. First we observe
that if the matrix (VI. 2.239)
is an element of SL(2,lj the same is true of the matrix
1452
-b)
a -c
A'1 '" (
(VI.Z .240)
d
and of the matrix
(VI. 2 .241)
Therefore the transformation (VI. 2.230a) can be viewed as a MObius transformation associated to the element (VI.2.241) of PSL(2,Z) according to the standard rule (VI.2.56). Next we state a theorem whose proof. which we omit, can be foWld in the mathematical literature (see for instance Ref. [4]):
6.2.16 Theorem.
The group PSL(2,Z)
is generated by the follOl>1ng
two elements:
(VI.2.242)
which obey the following obvious relations: 5
2 = 1,
(TS)
3 '" 1 .
(VI. 2.243)
From the point of view of Mobius transformations respectiv~ly
S :
S and T correspond
to the following substitutions:
1. .... -
T : 1. ....
(VI. 2.244a)
llr. ::: r. S
1: +
1 ;: 1.r
(VI.2. 244b)
•
Taking this into account. the division of the upper i-plane 1m i > O} by the action of PSL(2,1)
(t e lit ....
can be easily performed.
1453
First, since PSL(2,Z) c PSL(2,1R)
(VI.2.24S)
it is obvious from the discussion following Eq. (VI.Z.73) that H, is mapped into itself by PSL{2,Z). Secondly. with rather simple manipulations one can show that the following region A c H T
(V 1. 2. 246a) (VI.2. 246b)
(VI.2.246c)
is a fundamental region for the modular group PSL(2,Z).
By fundamental
region one means the fOllowing. Given any two interior points " 1, "2 e A no element Al e PSL(2,Z) can be found with respect to which '1 is equivalent to '2' That is, no matrix (~~) e PSL(2,1) can be found such that ar z fob 1:1 " - - . c'2
(VI, 2.247)
+d
Conversely, if T e Hr is any point outside A then we can always map it into a point ,e A belonging to the fundamental region by means of a suitable PSL(2,Z) transformation. Because of its very definition the fundamental region A is the set of equivalence classes H/PSL(2,Z). In Section VI. 2.3 we argued that H, is the Teichmiiller space for the tori. Hence if PSL(2,Z) is the mapping class group it follows that the fundamental region A, (shaded in the picture (VI.2.248») is the g" 1 moduli space MI'
1454
(VI. 2. 248)
-1
-t
o
To be precise we still have to prove that HT is the Teichmuller space Teich (b l ). Indeed, what we were able to show in Section VI.2.3 is that each T € HT defines a lattice in the complex plane C and hence a torus, the lattice group being the representation of ~l(rl) inside Aut (C). We still had to check whether any two different T'S could be equivalent with respect to some diffeomorphism. In Section VI.2.3 we stated that this is not the case if the diffeomorphism belongs to DiffO and hence we concluded that H1 :; Tei ch (1.). Let us prove that the above is indeed a true statement. This is fairly easy by using the notion of the quadratic differential introduced in Section VI.2.4. Consider an infinitesimal displacement of the variable
T
1455
(VI. 2.249) and insert it into Eq. (VI.2.222).
ot
-
i --(1.-1.) 1.1-1.-2 Im T
We get (VI.2.2S0)
from which follows dz I
,.
d1.
-!. .l!... (dz - di) 2 Im
t
(VI.2.251)
and (VI.2.252) where \.I
zz
6T = - -i2 1mT
(vr. 2 .253)
As we see the variation of the metric associated to an infinitesimal T-shift is a quadratic differential which is orthogonal to any variation induced by local diffeomorphislllS. Hence Hr=Teich (E I ) as claimed.
To show that PSL(2,Z) is the mapping class group we must simply show that its t~~ generators can be associated to the two Dehn twists existing on the torus (see picture (VI.2.23I». We note that in view of Eq. (VI.2.243) TST and T form an equally good basis of generators as the basis spanned by S and T. Indeed we have (VI. 2.254)
and hence
1456 . (V1.2. 255)
The Dehn twists associated to the cycles a and b of picture (VI.2.223) are respectively associated to the generators T and 1ST. This is easily seen on the homology basis. Consider the torus marked with the cycles a and b
(VI. 2. 256)
and let us perform the Dehn twist along the cycle a. picture (Vr.2.2S6) becomes the following:
After the twist,
(VI. 2.257)
This means that under Da a goes into itself while b goes into . a + h. Hence the couesponding symplectic modular transformation on the homology basis is
1457
(V1.2.2S8)
which, recalling Eq. (VI.2.230). yields the following transformation on the period 1T =t : T' .. t +
1 .
(VI.2.259)
This is just the action of T. Similarly the Dehn twist along b yields
(:)' . (: :) (:) which on the period
11"
=T
(VI.2.260)
corresponds to the TST transformation:
t .... _ T _
(Vl.2.261)
t +1
In obtaining this result we have utilized the equality of the period 1T with the modulus r, proved in Eq. (VI.2.229). This is not necessary; Eqs. (VI.2.259) and (VI.2.260) can be obtained also independently. Consider once more Eq. (VI.2.222). The two Dehn twists correspond to the following two global diffeomorphlsms:
(VI. 2. 262a)
(VI.2.262b)
Under the first transformation ,,;e have (VI.2.263a)
1458
while under the second we find (VI.2.263b)
Hence if we call ds 2 (,) the line element in the metric (or complex structure) associated to , and denote by primes the new quantities after the global diffeomorphism has been performed, we can write
= dz' (,)dZ'(T) = e$("A)dZ(A(T)di(A(T») =
ds'2(T)
= e~(TJA)ds2(A('))
(VI. 2. 264)
where for the first transformation we have A(t)
=t
+
1
J
~(r,A)
=0
(VI.2.265a)
while for the second we find: T
A(T) = - -
T+l
Vf(r,Al
= 1911 + 11 2
.
(VI. 2. 265b)
In both cases we have shown that the metric associated to T + 1 or T is in the same conformal class as the metric associated to T. T+1 Indeed it is related to it hy a diffeomorphism plus a Weyl transformation.
VI. 2.7 The group of divisors and the Riemann-Roch theorem In this section we shall introduce the concept of divisor and state the Riemann-Roch theorem by means of which we can compute the dimension of the space of holomorphic q-differentials. In particular we verify that the number of Teichmiiller deformations (= quadratic differentials) is
1459
1/
Teichmi.iller deformations
,~f
o
for g" 0
1 for g" 1 3g - 3 for g?-2
(VI.2.266)
as claimed several times prevlously. The idea of divisors originates in the elementary properties of meromorphic functions on the compactified complex plane, that is on the g .. O Riemann surface.
rational function
As everybody knows a meromorphic function is a
R(z), that is, the ratio of two polynomials: (VI.2.267)
and it is determined up to a multiplicative constant when we assign the locations and orders of its zeros and poles. We can say that it is determined by its divisor (VI.2.268)
where
~1 ••• zn
are the values of z for which R has either a zero
or a pole. and (11 e Z are the corresponding orders. If Cli <0, zi is a pole ,,'hile if (1. > 0, z. is a zero. It is also cleaT that if 1
Rl
1
and R:2 are two rational functions then the divisor of the product
is the product of the divisors defined in the following way Cl1 an _Bl _8m (R1R2) " (R1)(Rz) "zl .•. zn %1 .•• zm •
(VI.2.269)
where (VI. 2 . 270a)
(VI. 2 . 270b) Generali~ing
the concept to any Riemann surface we can introduce the
following definition.
1460 6.2.17 Definition.
A divisor
a
0.
Ijt
on Ig is a fomal symbol.
~
41:p 1 p 2"' Fk 1 2
(VI. 2.211)
with F. E E and a. e Z~ -3-g JWe can also write the divisor
~
as follows
(VI.2.272)
with a(P) e Z and ClCP) ~ 0 for only finitely many P e I . The g divisors on E form a group Div (I ): it is the free commutative g
g
group (written multiplicatively) on the points of I g • Thus if 41 is given by (VI.2.272) and ~
=
JI
peep)
(Vl.2.213)
PeEg then by definition we have: Ijt,~
=
JI
peI
pClCP) + B( P)
(VI.2.274)
p-a(P)
(VI.2.275)
g
and q,.-l
=
II
PEI g
Next we can introduce the concept of the degree of a divisor.
We define
(VI.2.276)
Clearly the operation deg establishes a homomorphism
deg :
Di~(I
)
g
+
I
(V1.2.277)
1461 from the multiplicative group of divisors onto the additive group of integers. If fez) is a non-identically vanishing meromorphic function on the Riemann surface Lg • then fez) determines a divisor (f) defined as follows (VI.2.278)
i
q ) is a meromorphic q-differential. recalling Eq. Similarly if (VI:2.151) we can define its divisor (pq) by means of the equation:
(VI.2.279)
The divisors associated to llIeromorphic functions have a special property. known from elementary complex analysis: they have zero degree deg (f)
=0 .
(VI. 2.280)
Indeed Eq. (VI.2.280) is nothing else but the familiar statement that the SU1II of the orders of poles and zeros vanishes for a function fez) if it is meromorphic. To be more precise we point out that the meromorphic functions on E form a field I·ler (l:) and therefore an g g abelian group under mUltiplication. The operation () defined by Eq. (VI.2.278) establishes a homomorphism (VI. 2.281)
from the multiplicative group of meramorphic functions into the subgroup of divisors of degree zero. That these latter form a subgroup is selfevident from the definition of the degree operation (VI.2.276). A divisor in the image of the homomorphism (VI.2.281) is called a principal divisor:
1462 'Ii' .. princi pal ~ fiJ e 1m (Mer 0: ) g
.
(VI. Z. 282)
One may wonder whether any divisor of degree zero is principal, that is. whether we can always find a meromorphic function which has poles and zeros at arbitrarily prescribed locations with arbitrary orders, just sU/lUDi-ng up to zero. The answer is no. A deep theorem due to Abel gives a criterion to establish when a degree zero divisor is principal. Before stating it we have to introduce still more concepts and definitions. Abel theorem will be given in the next section.
6.2.18 Definition. The group of divisors modulo principal divisors is known as the divisor class group. Indeed the normal subgroup of principal divisors introduces an equivalence relation on Div Ci:). Two divisors Ii' and fA are equi".,.-1.IS prlnClpa . g. I : va1,ent provl'ded ...~~ o/I"vf) .,.
3£ e Mer (E )/<&,~-1,. g
(VI. 2 .283)
(f) .
On the group of divisors one can introduce also an order relation.
We
begin with the following definition of integral divisors: 6.2.19 Definition. A di visor iii! is integral (in symbols 0/1 > 1) provided (X(?) ~ 0 for all P e Eg• Then we state the following. 6.2.20 Definition. A divisor 0/1 is bigger than the divisor symbols 0/1 > f)) if the di visor 1i'~-1 is integral. This definition has the following meaning. and !J suitable differentials or functions
fflll
a (in
If we associate to and
f.~
~
then we have
fill > ~ if the zeros of fflll are stronger than the zeros of ff) and the
poles of f
f~.
This corresponds
1463 qualitatively to the concept fot/fa "holOl1lOrphic function.
Given
these preliminaries we can introduce the ingredients of the
RieJllann~
Roch Theorem. Ingredients of the Riemann·Roch Theorem: 1)
r(t'} " dimension of the space of meromorphic functions whose divisor is bigger than the divisor 1&'.
Let
be the divisor under consideration. We set (VI. 2.284)
r(en " dim L(!W) and fez)
e
L(~)
In other words,
(VI.2.28S)
... (f) > Ii' .
f belongs to
L(~
if it is holomorphic at all points
which are not p1"",Pk and if at these points it has poles ~~aker or equal and zeros stronger Or equal than those of .... 2)
i(~)
" dimension of the space of abelian differentials
(l~
differentials) whose divisor is bigger than the divisor ~. We set (V1.2.286)
i (...) " dim Q(~
and III " III
z
(z)dz e Q(1i')
CO>
(!II) > 4&' •
The Riemann·Roch theorem can now be stated.
(VI. 2. 287)
1464 6.2.21 Theorem. For a Riemann surface E of genus g and for any g divisor iii! e Div (1:) the following- relation holds , g r(q[-l) _ i(1JI!) " deg t' + 1 - g •
(VI. 2. 288)
For the proof We refer the reader to the mathematical literature (see for instance Ref. [51). We shall rather concentrate on some of its most relevant applications. We consider the abelian differentials, that is, the meromorphic analytic I-forms on the surface (see Eq. (VI.2.lS0) and definitions 6.2.5-7). Each of them defines a divisor, but all these divisors lie in the same class. Indeed if wl and (,)2 are two abelian differentials (VI.2,289)
then their ratio is a meromorphic function
(VI. 2.290)
so that (w1)(2)-1 w
. . Id"IVlsor "prlnclpa
~
(1)~(2) w w • 'V
(VI.2.291)
6.2.22 Definition.
The universal divisor class of the abelian differentials is called the canonical class and it is denoted by Z. Next we prove the following lemma.
Lemma. For an,y the divisor class of 6JJ.
6.2.23
e 01 v
and i(i?I) depend only on Furthermore if w is any abe lian differential
fiJI
(1: ), r(liI!) g
then (VI. 2.292)
1465
~: Let f'l '" t'r Then f'l *'21 is a principal divisor namely tie can find a merolllOrphic function f 12 such that o1§'l.q{;l,. (f 12 ).
Let
h 6 L(1W2) we have f12h II L(~l)' Indeed (f12h) =(h){c§'l ,q[;l) > ~1 if (h) > 4'2' This shows that we have a linear injective mapping (V1.2.293)
of the vector space Let2) into the vector space L(
Obviously the roles of L(ti'Z) and L(
The two vector spaces are then isomorphic and consequently we have (VI.2.296)
as we wanted to show. Consider next an abelian differential ,II Q~) whose divisor (,) is bigger than ~. If w is any other abelian differential then ,/00 is a merolllOrphic function f,/oo whose divisor is bigger than ti'w- 1
(')(00)
-1
,.
(f~/w) > ~
-1
w
(VI.2.297)
Hence the mapping (VI.2.298)
establishes a linear isomorphism between the vector spaces L(4'(oo)-l). Hence they have the same dimension
Q(~}
and
1466
(VI. 2. 299) Since we have already shown that (VI. 2. 300) it follows from (VI.2.299) that
this concludes the proof of the lemma. Combining the above lemma with the Riemann-Roch theorem we can now prove the following.
6.2.24 Theorem. The degree of the canonical class Z is always given by: deg Z ,. 2g - 2 .
(VI.2.302)
We know that the holomorphic differentials span a g-dimensional complex vector space. This vector space is n(l) since the divisor of a hOlomorphic differential is by definition integral «00) > 1). Hence we can write
~:
i (l) "
dim !l(I) ,. g •
(VI. 2. 303)
Combining Eq. (VI.2.303) with Eq. (VI.2.292) we have g = 1'(Z
-1
).
(VI.2.304)
On the other hand. from Eq. (VJ.2.292) we also obtain i (Z) = 1'(1) = 1 •
(VI. 2. 305)
Indeed, by definition. r(l} is the dimensionality of the space of functions everywhere holomorphic on r. Such functions are just the g
1467 constants so that 1'(1) '" 1.
Inserting Eqs. (VI. 2. 304) and (VI. 2.303)
into Eq. (VI.2.288) we obtain the proof of our theorem. We illustrate this important theorem with a couple of simple examples. Consider the g =0 Riemann surface. Le. the compactified complex plane C v {co}. and the following meromorphic differential: III
= _z_dz
•
(VI. 2. 306)
z;-a
It has a zero at a double pole.
Z =0
and a simple pole at z" a.
At infinity it has
Indeed performing the standard transformation
z=-t1
(VI.2.307)
we get
(VI. 2.308)
~ilich
shot;s that at z ="" (t '" 0) there is a double pole. Hence we can write the divisor of (11)
= co-2
III
a-1 01
as follows (VI.2.309)
and verify that deg (00) " -2 " 2g - 2
Consider now the g" 1 case, namely a torus.
(VI.2.310)
A meromorphic differential
on the torus is given by II)
(VI.2.311)
= P(z)dz
where pez) is a doubly periodic meromorphic function defined on C: P(z + 1)
= P(z TT)
" P{z) .
(VI.2.312)
1468 ,
being the modulus of the torus.
P(z)
=constant.
The simplest case corresponds to
In this case the abelian differential (VI. 2. 311) has
neither poles nor zeros so that (VI.2.313)
(w) '" 1
and hence
= 0 = 2g - 2
deg (w)
(VI. 2 .314)
•
Next we utilize the Riemann-Roch theorem to compute the dimensionality of ;rq (Eg)
that is the dimensionality of the space of holomorphic q-
differentials.
To this purpose we still need a few more preliminaries.
First we observe that (VI.2.31S)
r(1fl) '" 0 if deg tfI > 0 •
This can be easily proven.
Indeed if r(tfI) were not zero there would
be at least one meromorphic funCtion than tfI,
f
whose di visor (f)
is bigger
that is.
(f)OW- 1 >
(VI. 2. 316)
which implies
o < deg fef) 'Ii -1 )
This is clearly absurd since deg (f) '" O. i{q[) =
(VI.2.317)
= deg (f) - deg tfI •
Similarly we have
0 if deg tfI > (2g - 2)
The proof is completely analogous.
(VI.2.318) If i('II)
were not zero we could
find a meromorphic.differential w whose divisor fulfills the relation (w) of-I > 1
(VI. 2 • 319)
1469
so that we would come to the relation
o < deg
(w) - deg
~
(VI. 2.320)
which is absurd since the canonical class has degree 2g - 2. On
the other hand we have:
deg ttl
=0
00
r(li/l) ~ 1 .
(VI. 2.321)
The reason is Simple. If Ii/l is a principal divisor then, up to a multiplicative constant, there is just one meromorphic function fez) such that (f) = $fl. In this case r{'iI)", 1. If IiJI has degree zero but it is not principal then no meromorphic function can be found such that (f) = $fl. In this case r(Ifl) .. o. Finally we observe that the space of holomorphic q-differentials is isomorphic to the vector space of meromorphic functions whose divisor is bigger than z-q, Z being the canonical class. In formula
The explanation of this formula is Simple.
Let (VI. 2 .323)
q
be a holomorphic q-differential and let w be an abelian differential of the first kind, that is. a holomorphic I-form w = w dz z
(VI. 2.324)
The ratio (VI. 2.325)
1470 is a meromorphic flUlction.
Since by hypothesis the divisor of ll(q)
is integral, we have (VI. 2. 326) Hence f 6 L(Z~q). between L(Z~q)
Equation (VI.2.325) induces a linear isomorphism
and Jl"q 0;) g
which therefore have the same dimension.
Using this information we can write (VIo2.327) On the other hand the Riemann~Roch theorem, Eq. (VI.2.288), implies
(VI.Z.328) Inserting Eqs. (VI.2.292) and (VI.2.302) into Eq. (VI.2.328) we obtain (VI.2.329) From Eq. (VI.2.329) we get the desired dimensionality of the various ,(q) spaces. The Teichmuller defozmations were identified in Eq. (VI.2.117) with the quadratic differentials.
Let us then fix q .. 2.
From Eq.
(Vl.2.329) we get dim ,(2) 0: ) .. 3g. 3 + r(Z) g
(VI. 2.330)
When g ~ 2 the degree of the canonical class is positive so that, in view of Sq. (VI.2.31S),
w"e
have r{Z) ,,0.
dim ,(2) (I: ) .. 3g·3 as anticipated. g yields the relation
Hence for
g~2
we have
In the g .. 1 case Eq. (Vr.2.329)
(VI.2.331)
1471
Then we observe that in genus g .. 1 a holomorphic q-differential is not only free from poles but also from zeros since its divisor has a vanishing degree. (This fbllows from Eq. (VI.2.326) and Eq. (VI.2.302» Hence i f \l (q) is a holomorphic q-differential then l//q) is a holomorphic-q-differential. This shows that (VI. 2. 332)
which combined with Eq. (VI.2.33I) yields (VI-2.333a)
Since in any case r(l)" 1 we obtain (V q
(V!.2 .333b)
e I)
and, in particular (VI.2.334)
as already shown in Section (VI.2.6). -2
Finally. in the case g .. 0 we have deg Z .. -2 so that Z a positive degree.
dim.1l'
(2)
has
This implies
0:0)" r{Z -2 ) .. 0 •
(VI. 2. 335)
In this way we have completed the verification of formula (VI.2.266) for the number of Teichmililer deformations in the various genuses. Before closing this section let us come back once more to the Riemann-Roch theorem in the fOrmulation given by Eq. (VI.2.329). Using Eq. (VI. 2.327) and fixing q .. 2 we can write dim .11'(2) (E ) -
g
dim Jl"H) (E ) .. 3g - 3 . g
(VI.2.336)
1472 The holomorphic quadratic differentials correspond. as we have seen, to the infinitesimal Teichmuller deformations. The holomorphic l-differentials are, instead, associated with the conformal Killing vectors. Indeed, recalling Eqs. (VI.2.114) we see that a confotmal Killing vector t z fulfills the condition
Raising the index with the metric gz1: we have
which shows that t Z is a holomorphic-l-differential. Hence the Riemann~Roch theorem states that 3g - 3 equals the difference between the number of moduli and the number of conformal Killing vectors. /I
moduli -
/I
conf. Kill. vectors
= 3g - 3 .
(VI. 2.339)
At genus g =0 we have no moduli and three conformal Killing vectors (the six real generators of the automorphism group SL(2,C).) At genus g'" 1 we have one modulus and one conformal Killing vector (the translation generator z,... Z + oa) . For g ~ 2 we have 3g - 3 moduli and 110 conformal Killing vectors. As we will see in Chapter VI.8, the moduli and the conformal Killing vectors can also be identified with the zeromodes of the antighost and ghost fields respectively.
VI.2.8 The Jacobian variety:
Riemann theta functions and spin
structures In the closing section of this chapter we introduce the objects which play an essential role in the construction of fermionic string theories: the Riemann theta functions. They naturally appear as building blocks of the partition function whenever the list of two-dimensional fields {~(~)}, which define the
1473 string model under consideration, includes two-dimensional fel'lllions. On the other hand, lD-fermions are a necessary ingredient if the string spectrum is required to contain space-time fermions. Hence theta-ftmctions are a vital part of superstring theories. The partition function Z(g,j) was mentioned in Section VI.2.2 and was defined as the result of functionally integrating the exponential of minus the classical action (coupled to the external sources j(~» over all the two dimensional fields {!I} living on the Riemann surface Eg" At zero external Sources j (~) =0, such an operation corresponds to calculating the detel'lllinant of the kinetic operator acting on the free fields {~i(~)}. As already pointed out in Section VI.2.2, the invariances of the classical action imply that the partition function Z(g,j) should not depend on the choice of the metric gall (~) but only on its confoTmal class. In other words, the partition function should be a function of the moduli. Correspondingly the functional integral over the two-dimensional metrics (see Eq. (VI. 2. 30)) must be restricted to the orbit-space and becomes an integral over the moduli-space M. g These statements are not complete in one respect: the boundary conditions to be assigned to the two-dimensional fields ~i(~) have not been considered. Geometrically every field in {ti(~)} is to be viewed as a cross-section of a suitable bundle constructed over the surface Eg. If the corresponding bundle is uniquely defined, like the canonical tangent bundle, then the functional integration over that particular field leads to a unique function of the moduli. If. on the other hand, we deal with cross-sections of bundles which are not unique and are specified by additional characterizations, then the partition function depends not only on the moduli, but also on the additional parameters classifying the bundles involved. These parameters are, essentially, a set of boundary conditions imposed on the field {i(~)} and require, in order that they may be given, the specification of the homology basis. So it happens that the partition function depends on the choice of the homology basis and, at a fixed choice of the latter, on a set of
1474
boundary conditions specifying a particular bundle within a .certain class of bundles. As we know from Section Vl.2.6, the mapping class group acts
nontrivially on the homology bases (to be specific. as the group Sp(2g;Z)) and. to nobody's surprise, it also transfol'llls the available choices of boundary conditions one into another. Eventually, however, the quantum generating functional (VI.2.30) must be diffeomorphic invariant. We obtain this invariance by means of a summation over different sets of boundary conditions (bundles). each weighted with an appropriate coefficient. Although each of the terms in the sum is not Sp(2g,Z)invariant, the Sum can be made such. This is the programme of modular invariance (addressed in Chapter VI.6) which leads to a determination of the possible superstring spectra, the classification of the available superstring models being in correspondence with the classification of Sp(2g,Z) invariants. The possibility of carrying through such a programme clearly depends on our control over the Sp(2g,Z) transformation properties of the partition functions. As we mentioned at the beginning of this section, in most of the cases relevant to our purposes, the fields ~i(~) corresponding to cross-sections of a non-canonical bundle are 2-dimensional spinors. We will show that on a genus g surface there are 22g spinor bundles labelled, in a given homology basis by a couple of g-dimensional vectors called a spin structure:
[~ 1
(VI. 2. 340)
whose entries are .Iz-elements (VI. 2 . 341)
1475
The spin structures [ :ba ~
1
are in
one~to-one
correspondence wi th what
is known as the characteristics of the Riemann-theta function. Indeed it turns out that there is a deep relation between the set of zeros of the Riemann theta, known as the theta-divisor, and the set of spin bundles (or spin structures) one can construct on the surface r. g
This intimate relation between theta functions and spin bundles h'; , ,"ural
[ b1 is
""
tho thot, fwcti""
a
e [:b ~
[~l
with ,h,ntt"i"i,
the closed form expression for the following ratio: det
where
•
1" const
[!] ~ (VI. 2.342)
det 0
is the chiral Dirac operator on r g and 0 is the Laplacian
on the same surface. Once established Eq. (VI.2.342) implies that the partition function of every fermion field Z(fermion)
= det
~
(VI. 2.343)
can be expressed in terms of theta functions and, as such, has known transformation properties under Sp (2g ,1) . How the thetas transform under the symplectic modular group will be seen in this section. In Chapter VI.5, Eq. (VI.2.342) will be demonstrated for the case g" 1 by an explicit calculation. For higher genuses, it has been justified by sophisticated arguments in algebraic geometry [61 relying on the factorization properties of the string amplitudes. In principle, using the methods of Ref. [8] it should be possible to retrieve Eq. (V1.2.342) directly in the operatorial approach for any genus.
We will not touch such a complicated problem here.
1476
In any case. Eq. (VI.2.342) is almost an obligato~y identity in view of the relation between the theta functions and the spin bundles we now try to illustrate. We begin by describing the general concept of line bundles over Lg and its relation to the notion of divisors introduced in the previous section. To this purpose we also need the concepts of sheaf and sheaf cohomology. A sheaf over a topological space M (in OUr case M=l: g is the Riemann surface) is a family of groups F(U) (usually abelian) associated to each open subset U c M. The elements cr e F(U) of the group FeU) are called the sections of the sheaf over the open chart U. Given a subspace U eVe M of a subspace V c M there is a map
rv , U
: F(V) ......
(VI.2.344)
F(U)
between the two associated groups. The map rv U is called the > restriction map. It must satisfy the following axioms: a) Given three nested open subspaces (or charts) U eVe have
I~
we must
(VI.2.345)
We denote by crl u the restriction to U of our element cr e F(V b) (J
e
:l
U).
Gi ven any two submanifolds U and V and given any two sections and 1" Ii F(V) such that
F (U)
01 UnV '" 'I UnV there exists a section p e F(U
(VI.2.346)
u
V) such that (VI. 2. 347)
1477 If
c)
(1
e F(U u V)
and o/U
=0lv = 0
then
0=0.
The prototype of a sheaf is the sheaf of C""·flUlctions.
Indeed C'" (u)
is clearly an abelian group lUlder addition
= hex)
f(x) + g(x)
(VI.2.348)
and the restriction operation is the one which obviously falfi 11s axioms a).
Axiom b) is the principle of analytic continuation. and axiom c)
is obvious.
IJ
1)
Sheaves of interest to us in the present context include:
= the
sheaf of holomorphic functions (form a group under
addition)
IJ*
2)
= the
sheaf of holomorphic functions without zeros (form a
group under mUltiplication) 3)
Q(p)
= the
sheaf of holomorphic p-forms.
Next we introduce sheaf-cohomology (Cech cohomology). As in any other cohomology construction
~~
define the vector space
cP of p-cochains and a coboundary operator
(VI. 2 . 349) with the property (VI.2.350) Let
(F. M)
be a sheaf of abelian groups (typically functions) over the
manifold M.
Let
!!. = {'i'a 1
be a finite atlas covering
Then we have the groups
M.
F(U l ), F(UZ) •...• F(Un ). For instance if
n =4 as in the pi cture (VI. Z. 3S 1) we have just four groups F(UZ)'
reUS)'
F(U4)·
F(Ul ) ,
1478
(VI.Z.351)
The space of O-cochains
CO(Q, F)
is defined by (VI.
z. 352)
In other words, a O-cochain is a collection of m-functions (calling functions the elements of the groups
FeUa)): (VI. 2. 353)
defined over UI , Uz,···, Un' On the other hand a 1-cochain is a collection of
functions
(gaB" -gSa
In
(n - 1)
in additive notation): (VI. 2.354)
defined on all the possible intersections collection of .!:.n(n-l)(n-2) 6
2 C
= (h I23 ,
functions:
h 124 ,· .. , h(n-2)(n-l)n)
defined over all the possible intersections and so on.
Ua n US' A 2-cochain is a
(VI. 2. 355) Ua n Upo n Uy (a # 8 of y)
1479 The definition of the coboundary operator is the following.
Using the additive notation for the F-group operation we set:
(VI.2.356)
where (VI. 2. 357)
For instance let n" 4 and let {VI. 2. 358)
be a l-cochain.
The boundary of C1 (VI. 2. 359)
in additive notation is given by
I - f 13IUl23
g123 "f23 U 123 g 124
"f! 24 U124 - f 14 IU124
+ f 12
IU123
(VI. 2. 360a)
+ f
I
(VI. 2. 360b)
12 Ul24
while in multiplicative notation it reads as follows
(VI.2.361) As usual a p-cocyle
C(p)
fulfils the condition
1480 (VI.2.362)
while a p-coboundary b(P) is given by (VI. 2. 363)
for some (P-l)-cochains lp-l) 6 C(p-l). The p-th cohOlllology group is as usual the space of p-cocycles modulo p-coboundaries: p-cocycles
If (M • F) =- - - - -
(VI. 2. 364)
p-coboundaries
To illustrate the concept we consider a very simple example.
Let
PI be the projective line
o +co
(VI.2.365)
which is parametrized by two charts: i)
UO'
the chart around zero with coordinate x,
Ii)
U.. ,
the chart arotmd infinity with coordinate y.
In the intersection
UO "" U.. ,
the transition function is
1
(VI.2.366)
Y"x' Let us then consider the sheaf of polynomial differentials: Q
= P(x) dx
which form a group Jllldel' addition.
(VI. 2. 367)
A typical O-cochain is given by: (VI .2. 368)
1481
where Po", (x) is a polynomial defined in the intersection Uo () U"",
We have
oco ~ ([Po(x)
1 + --2
x
1 1dx) P (-) "" x
(VI. 2.369)
A O-cocycle should have 1
1
PO(x) " - - P H x2 co x
(VI. 2. 370)
which is absurd since both Po and PO) are polynomials. Hence (VI. 2. 371)
1
The cohomology group H (palyn. P1), however is nontrivial since not all the i-chains are in the image of o. For instance ;le have
(VI.2.372)
so that (VI. 2.373)
is a non-trivial l-cocycle. Note that oC l ;: 0 follows from Eq. {VI.2.356) for any C1 since we have just two charts. Equipped with the notion of sheaf cohomology we can introduce the concept of linebundles. A line bundle y(t g ,C) is a bundle having the Riemann surface Lg as base-space and the complex plane ( as fiber-space. It is conveniently described in terms of cross-sections and transition functions.
1482 {'t.J be an analytic at las covering 1: and let z be ... g a the local coordinate in the chart U. Since the atlas is analytic, in Let
a
the intersection Ua n Us we have that (VL2.374)
is a holomorphic function of zB' A meromorphic cross-section (J e .!I' (kg,C)
is an assignment of a
C-valued meromorphic function (Ja(za) of the local coordinate za to each local chart Ua: (VL2.375) In the intersection
and aB(zS) are related by a transition ftmction haB which is required to be holomorphic and nonUa nUB' aa(za)
vanishing in Ua nUB: (V1.2.376)
where we have siIDply called z the local variable z"Za
[in this way
aB(z) =06(z6(Z»]' It follows from Eq. (VI.2.376) that the transition ftmction hBa is related to h
Ba
haa
as follows:
.. _1_
haB
(VI. 2.377)
Furthermore, the follOWing cocycle condition (Vl.2.378)
is necessary in order for the cross-sections (] e !f (1: g• C) to be consistently defined. Recalling the definitions given a few lines above we see that the set of trans! don fUnctions {haB} is a l-cocycle for the sheaf Oi< of nonvanishing holomorphic functions.
1483 From the definition it follows that the set of inequivalent line bundles coincides with the first cohomology group HI (E ,0*). Indeed, if two sets of transition functions coboundary we have
{haS} and
{h~B}
g
differ by a
(VI.2.379) (VI. 2. 380)
and the coboundary can be eliminated by a redefinition of the crosssection (VI .·2. 381)
The simplest example of line bundles is provided by the canonical bundle K, whose cross-sections are the meromorphic I-forms (the abelian differentials) : 10
=wzdz
In this case we have cr
(VI. 2. 382)
ex
=W
z
and the transition functions are given by
(VI.2.383)
By definition the q-th power;eq of a line bundle is that line-bundle whose transition functions are the q-th power of those of :I: (VI. 2. 384)
The holomorphic cross-sections of Kq are the holomorphic q-differentials discussed in the previous section. A
bundle
spin-bundle S is defined as a square-root of the canonical
1484 (VI. 2. 385) It is introduced in the following way.
Consider the line-element (VI.2.1S) in the Ua and U8 coordinates: (VI. 2. 386)
where for later convenience we have redefined we can introduce the vielbein I-forms
~ +
2..
In both patches
(VI.2.387a) e - • e0 - i e 1 • e ~(z.z)d-~
(VI. 2. 387b)
and we can rewrite Eq. (VI.2.386) as follows (VI.2.388)
From the definition (Vl.2.386) of the conformal factoT we deduce its transformation property
(VI.2.389) and we conclude that the transition function for the vielbein 1-forms
is a U(l)-element. the phase of the Jacobian dzaldzS' (VI .2. 390a)
exp[i6aa]
dz
= dZ;
The phase-factors {e
I I
dzS dZa .
ieaa
1
(VI. 2. 390b)
can be regarded as the transition functions
of the canonical bundle· K in the anholonomic description.
1485 In a spin bundle S the transition functions {S s} are given i9 a by square~roots of the transition functions fe as}. Indeed for a spinor. that is for a cross-section l/I e S of the spin bundle we must have (VI. 2.391)
where (VI. 2. 392)
Hence we can set (VI.2.393)
where Aas = 0, 1 mod 2 is a 7.2 element.
In order to be consistently
defined the spin bundle must have transition functions fulfilling the cocycle condition: (VI.2.394)
which is true if and only if the following identity is verified iC6Q+6S +9 }»ill(A o +A S +A +mod2}. 2 ajj Y yo. a... Y ya
(VI.2.39S)
The cocycle condition fulfilled by the transition functions of the canonical bundle implies
eC1B +
9SY + 9ycr.
= 211
(VI. 2. 396)
kapy Q
So we can write i (9 S+9 +6 ) -2 SY yo. 01
where
= ill(wcr.0.., ... ,
mod 2)
(VI. 2.397)
1486 if katly " even (VI. 2. 398)
if
k~ "odd
The proper way of interpreting Eq. (VI.2.397) is in terms of sheaf cohomology. We have constructed a lz·sheaf over the Riemann surface and waBy is a 2·cochain of this sheaf.
Actually it is easy to prove that it is a 2.cocycle. (VI.2.396) it follows
Indeed from
and, hence
oWaByo " wBy6 - Wayo
+
waSo . W aBy " 0 mod 2
(VI. 2.400)
Equation (VI.Z.39l) can now be interpreted in the following way: the 2.cocycle w(2) should be equal to a coboundary 071(1): w(2) "
oJ. (1)
•
(VI.2.40l)
If the homology group H(Z) (Lg'ZZ) were nontrivial then we might find an obstruction to the solution of Eq. (VI. 2.401) and hence to the existence of spin bundles. This is never the case with Riemann surfaces. since one can prove that H(2) (Lg'ZZ) (the second Sitefel-Whitney class) is always zero. Indeed this latter is the lz·reduction of the Euler class which for a Riemann surface, is always even being given by the well known formula for the Euler characteristic:
x" 2 -
2g •
(VI.2.40Z)
When we have a solution of Eq. (VI.2.40l) we can generate others by adding to A(1) a solution of the homogeneous equation:
1487
(VI. 2. 403a) (VI.2.403b) 1 T he di menslonallty . , The Sh1' f t n(1)..lS a 1 ~cocyc e. of the space of spin bundles is then given by H(l) (Lg,lz)' The dimensionality of this homology group is (VI. 2.404) and so we conclude that on a genus g Riemann surface there are 22g. inequivalent spin bundles. To see that this is the case let us cut the Riemann surface L g along the cycles of a canonical homology basis. The result is the usual 4g-sided polygon (VI.2.3Z). The cocycle n~~) can then be viewed as the set of transition functions across the cuts. We consider a section S of the spin bundle. If Sa is the section along a.1 we identify i -1Ii 4>i 1 it with e times S 1 (the section along a~) and similarly we 1 a. 1 1Ii6i (the identify Sb. (the section along bi) with e times 1
. along b~l). The phases ~i an d 6i sectlon 1
a.1 ~. 1
:0
0,1 mod2
= 0,1
mod2
(VI. 2. 405a)
(VI. 2. 405b)
Since we have two possibilities for each of the 2g homology generators, the total number of casas is 22g as claimed. Now to get a better understanding of line bundles we consider their alternative description in terms of divisor classes.
1488 6.2,25 Proposition. The line bundles are in one-to-one correspondence with the divisor classes. Actually they form a group isomorphic to the divisor class group. Proof. Let 11 be a line bundle and let 0 € L be one of its meromorphic sections. a has zeros {P.} and poles {Q.} and hence it 1 1 defines a divisor (VI. 2. 406)
where ni(roi ) is the order of the zero (pole) of a at Pi(Qi)' Any other section 0' e 1t is obtained from the section {J via multiplication by a meromorphic function 0' "
f e Mer (I: ) g
fo
(VI. 2.407)
so that div(a')
~
(VI. 2,408)
div(cr)
the two divisors differing by a principal divisor. Hence a line-bundle singles out a divisor class. Conversely let (D) be a divisor class and choose a representative divisor. In every local chart Ua we can find a meromorphic function fa whose divisor (fa) coincides with the U -restriction of D: ex
(VI. 2. 409)
In the intersection regions UC! functions with the same divisor
n
US' we have
t~o
meramorphic
(VI. 2.410)
Then the function (VI. 2.411)
1489 is holOlllOrphic and nowhere vanishing in Ua. I'l US' It defines a l-cocycle in the sheaf 0" and hence a line bundle. (The cocycle condition is obvious from the definition (VI.2.41l»). The product operation on linebundles is given by the product of sections; hence it is mapped into the product of divisors and we have the claimed isomorphism. In view of this isomorphism each line-bundle is characterized by a numerical invariant, the degree of the corresponding divisor class. Recalling Eq. (VI.2.302) we see that the degree of the canonical line bundle is 2g - 2. deg K = deg Z
= 2g - 2
(VI. 2.412)
Since the spin bundles are square-roots of the canonical bundle it follows that the square of their divisors is in Z.
Hence their degree
is g -1: deg S
II
g -1 •
(VI. 2.413)
The relation between spin-bundles and theta-functions can be seen at the level of divisors and of their image in a special flat variety associated to the Riemann surface. which is now time to introduce: the Jacobian variety. i" Given a Riemann surface Ig and its period matrix Il J Sq. (Vl.2.208». let us consider the complex linear space
!
E
t8
(see
c8.
A point
is a set of g complex numbers
+
z
= (2; 1••••• zg)
.
In Cg we can construct the following lattice L(Lg)
(VI. 2.414) <:.
Cg which depends
on the choice of the Riemann surface through its period matrix: (VI.2.41S)
1494
Using only the definitions (see Ref. [7}) we obtain
a[~r (DIn')
(VI.2.429~431).
= e:(A)e- i1T
after some manipulations
en](O[II)
(VI. 2.433)
where (VI. 2. 434a)
4>(a, b)
t +j = 4'1!-7a' (At C) 'a...... + b' (B D)'b
-
1[-; t ' " ... t + t t 2a'(C B)·b+(a·A -b·B )'(DC)
- -
4
1
(VI. 2 .434b)
d
(M)d denoting the vector whose components are the diagonal entries of the matrix M and e:(A) being an eighth-root of unity depending on the symplectic modular matrix A= (;
(VI. 2. 435)
:)
but not on the characteristic
[~ ] .
....
[i
If we could relate the 22g theta characteristics 1 to the 2g 2 _spin bundles, then Eq. (VI.2.434) would tell us how the spin bundles are mapped one into the other by the action of the mapping class group on the homology basis. The desired relation between the theta characteristics and the spin structures is based on a deep theorem due to Riemann, called the Riemann vanishing theorem.
6.2.28 Theorem. Consider a Riemann surface Eg, a base point and a point t e Jac(E ). Define the function
PO~g
g
(V1.2.436)
1495 where
...
~P
(P) is the Jacobian image of P (see Eg. (Vl.2.419)) and TI
o
is the period matrix of
~.
g
Then either f( p )(P) vanishes identiz, 0
.'
cally, or fCz,po) has exactly g-zeros PI,P2"" ,Pg• FUrthermore, the zeros {Pi} fulfil the following condition (VI. 2.437) ~
where np e Jac(E) depends on the base point Po but not on
o
~p
o
g
...
z.
is called the vector of the Riemann constants.
The proof is as usual omitted and the reader is referred to the mathematical literature [s]. Let us, rather, see how the Riemann vanishing theorem can be utilized in the spin bundle problem. We name the theta-divisor and denote by 0 c Jac(£) the set of g points of the Jacobian variety where the a-function without characteristic vanishes
...e e e ~ SCe+1 TI) For each -; e
e,
(VI. 2.438)
'" 0
the Riemann vanishing theorem implies that we can find
.
...
g-1 points Pl .... 'P g- 1 such that, chooslng l"'e, we have ...
e
+
1 P.
L Jl...~ =...~
g-
(VI.2.439)
i=1 Po
Indeed by hypothesis,
f(e,poJ '" a (;
+
J: o ~11I) = O
6(;11T)
=0
(VI. 2.440)
so that one of the g zeros is given by the base point Po itself. Eq. (VI.2.439) on the other hand can be re-interpreted in the following way.
1496
...e e e
belonging to the theta divisor, we can always find a degree g-1 divisor
Gi yen a point
(VI. 2. 441a)
...
deg DCe,P o)
" g-1
(VI.2.441b)
such that the following degree zero divisor
(VI. 2.442a)
_ .... (VI. 2. 442b )
deg D(e,PO) " 0
...
...
has Ap - e as Jacobian image
o
g-1
=L
(VI.2.443)
i=1
In view of the Abel theorem we conclude that the divisor D(e,P O)
is ..... e in one-to-one
defined up to the principal divisors, so that 15 correspondence with a divisor class of degree (g-I). This already suggests the relation with spin bundles.
To see this relation more explicitly let us consider the RiemannRoch theorem in the case of a divisor class (Oa) whose degree is g-l. Recalling Eqs. (VI.2.288) and (VI.2.292) we have deg 0a
Let write
~a
=g - 1
.. r(Oa-1 )
= r(DaZ-1 ).
(VI,2.444)
be the line bundle whose divisor class is Da' Then we can
1497 dim
HO(Eg'~a) = r(D~l)
(VI.2.44Sa)
dim HO(Eg.K(O ~~1) .. r(DcF 1)
(VI.2.44Sb)
where HO (Eg'~) denotes the vector space of holoJllOl'phic sections in the bundle ~. eqUation (VI.2.444) states that whenever ~ has a holoCL morphic section then so does K(O ~-1. ~
Let ~CL have a holomorphic section. In this case a representative of the [oJ class of the form
~~
can choose
(VI. 2. 446) Since K® ~~1 also has a holoJllOrphic section, we can choose a representati ve of the ZO~l class of the form ZD- l
a
= Q1
(VL 2 .447)
where Q1 ... Q 1 is a suitable set of g-I points of t. Correspond~ g ingly we have a representative of the canonical class given by (VI. 2. 448)
Given this observation, let Sa be the divisor associated to a spin boodle (deg (S ) .. g-I (S )2" Z) and consider the following set of a a points in the Jacobian variety: (VI. 2. 449a) (VI.2 . 449b)
{Pi} being any (g-I)-tuplet of points. It is easy to show that the set A the origin.
Let
ii eA.a
a
is symmetric with respect to
This means that ~ is the Jacobian map of
1498 -1
PIP2 '"
Pg- 1 Sa
where Pl'"
Pg- 1 is some (g-l)-tuple of points.
Equation (VI.2.448) guarantees that there exists another dual (g-l)-tuple of points Ql.···'Qg-l such that Pl'" is the canonical class.
Pg- 1Ql ... Qg-l
Consider the element ; e Jac(L) defined below: g
(V!. 2 .450)
Clearly it fits the definition (VI.2.449) and hence it is a point of A(%. On
the other hand. since
(Sa)2 =Z we have
(Pl'" Pg- 1) (8 a)-1 (Ql ... Qg-l) (5(%)-1; Z (Sa)-2
=1 (VI. 2.451)
and hence ;
=-~.
We have shown that (VI. 2.452)
The elements form
t
e Aa can also be written as a set of elements of the
(VI. 2. 453) Then in view of Eqs. (VI.2.443). as the (g-l)-tuple of points vary we generate all the theta-divisor and we Can write A
€X
= -0
..,. a
(VI. 2.454)
+ E
+
where Ea is given by +
E
a
+
= D.p0
I-g
~
-!J (8 PO)
a
(VI. 2. 455)
Since e(!I~) is an even function. the theta divisor is symmetric with respect to the origin:
1499 0= - 0 •
(VI. 2. 456)
Also Aa was shown to be symmetT
a
(VI.2.457)
CI.
This can be reconciled with Eq. (VI.2.454) only if (VI. 2. 458)
where L(k) is the lattice (VI.2.415) defining the Jacobian variety. g Hence the spin bundles are in one-to-one correspondence with the points of order two of the Jacobian variety. This provides the connection with the theta characteristics previously introduced. Indeed Eq. (Vr.2.458) is solved by setting ...
E
CI.
= -1'" b 2
+
1'" 2
-1!a
(VI.2.459)
... ...
where a. b are vectors whose components take
v~ues
in 12'
Therefore, given a theta-characteristic [~1 the divisor class of the corresponding spin bundle is the solution of the following equation: 1'"
1na " '..' 't::.'
- b +2 2
Po
... -.p (S
[:j
l-g )
p 0
(VI.2.460)
This concludes our discussion of spin structures and the long mathematical chapter. We are now ready to turn to Physics.
1500
References quoted in Chapter VI. 2
[1)
B. Riemann, Uber die Hypothesen, welche der Geometrie zu Grunde liegen, Abhand K. des Ges. Wiss. Gottingen 13, 133 (1868).
[2]
Arbarello, Lectures given at the C.I.M.E. course on "Global geometry in mathematical physics", July 1988, Montecatini, ed. M. Francaviglia (Springer Verlag).
[3]
J. Birman, Links, braids and the mapping class group, Princeton University Press, 1974.
[4}
J.P. Serre, A course in arithmetic, Graduate texts in mathematics, Springer.
[sJ
H.M. Farkas and I. Kra, Riemann surfaces, Graduate texts in mathematics, Springer (1980).
[6]
L. Alvarez Gaume and P. Nelson, Riemann surfaces and String Theories, in: Supersymmetry, Supergravity, Superstrings '86, Proceedings, eds. B. de Wit, P. Fayet, M.T. Grisaru - Singapore, World Scientific (1986).
[7]
J. Fay, "Theta Functions on Riemann Surfaces", Lecture Notes in Mathematics No. 352, Springer Verlag (1973).
18J
P. di Vecchia, F. Pezzella, M. Frau, R. Hornfeck, A. Lerda, S. Sciuto, Nucl. Phys. B322 (1989) 317. F. Pezzella, Phys. Lett. B~ (1989) 544.
1501 OIAPTER VI. 3
The Classical Action of the Heterotic Superstrings and their Canonical Quantization
Pill fe con/orme, e pero plu Ie place
Dante, Paradiso VII, 73
VI.3.1 Introduction The intuitive idea of a closed string moving in a target manifold ~lt
arge t
is realized by assigning an embedding function: (VI. 3.1)
where dim Mt
{xu} t)
are the coordinates of a point P e Mt arge t (U=1,2, ... , and {O','r} ={~a} are the coordinates labeling a point
arge p 6 W5, WS denoting the moves:
world~sheet
sweeped by the closed string as it
(VI. 3. 2)
1502 In Eq. (VI.3.l) 1 denotes the proper-time in the rest frame of the string's center of mass while 0 labels the different points on the string. Since the string is closed (in this book we consider only closedstring theories), X~(a,l) fulfills a periodic boundary conditions in a: (VI. 3. 3)
Equation (VI.3.3) states that when we move along the string (i.e. we increase the coordinate a), after a certain length we come back to the original point. As mentioned in the previous chapter (see Eqs. (VI.2.8») the relation between the world-sheet geometry and the analytic geometry of Riemann surfaces is obtained by performing a Wick rotation (1 .... i I) and then introducing the complex coordinates
= expel + ia)
(VI. 3. 4a)
z "" expel - ia)
(VI. 3. 4b)
z
In this way the coordinates XIJ of the target manifold become functions of z and i (VI.3.S)
and one can also introduce the momentum fields defined by (VI. 3.6a) (Vl. 3. 6b)
For a general embedding function pIJ and piJ have no special property. but if X~(z,i) fulfils the Laplacian equation (VI. 3.7)
1503
then p~ and p~ are respectively analytic and antianalytic: (VI. 3. Sa)
pU
= pll(i)
•
(VI.3.8b)
Furthermore Eq. (VI.3.3) implies that pll(z) and pll(z) are monodromic: p\.l (Zl1Ti)
'"
p].l ez)
(I V .3. 9) a
Referring to Chapter VI.2 and in particular to Section VI.2.S, we see that the momentum fields are cross-sections of a suitable line bundle defined on the Riemann surface. To be more specific, the momentum field is a tangent vector to the target space 50 that it defines a bundle: (VI. 3. 10)
having the Riemann surface as base-space and T(Mt arge t) as fiber. Clearly the transition functions of the bundle are SO(dim Mtarget) matrices, and the general form of equations (VI.3.9) is (VI. 3. 11 a) (VI. 3.llb)
A and
A being
suitable orthogonal or pseudo-orthogonal matrices.
Equations (VI.3.l1) correspond to a more general set of boundary conditions on the embedding functions than those given in Eq. (VI.3.3). This latter is the right definition of a closed string only if Mtarget is simply connected, namely if its fundamental group 1Tl(Mtarget) is trivial. In the general case we can write
1504
M
target
~arget =- - -) (
(VI. 3.12)
\arget
'1f t
where Mtarget is the universal covering space. Let now X be a continuous map from ~ g to M t arge t' t g being the universal covering space of the Riemann surface: X'•
'<'
~g
....
(VI. 3. 13)
"
Mtarget'
Let us see under which conditions X defines a map from I:
g
to
Mtarget' COnsider two points
PI
and P2 of 1:g which are equivalent
under an element be '!fI(I: g): (VI.3.l4 )
Since they are equivalent, they must be mapped by X into equivalent points of ~1target:
(VI. 3.1S)
where B(b) e 1!l(Mtal'get)' Hence B(b)
defines a homomorphism (VI. 3.16)
and for each choice of the homomorphism (VI. 3.16) we have a different set of boundary conditions (VI.3.IS) on the embedding functions. The homomorphism B has an image in the tangent space since the canonical tangent boodle induces a hOlllOmorphism, (Vl.3.17)
1505
and this defines the A and
it
matrices mentioned above.
Let us now come back to the observation that P and P are j.! 11 respectively analytic and antianalytic if Sq. (VI.3.7) is fulfilled. The reason why this is relevant is the following. As shown in more detail in later chapters, in particular in Chapter VI.S, the analytic fields with support on open subspaces U c r of a Riemann a g surface correspond to quantum field theories. called "conformal theories" that are often completely sol vahle. The analytic structure is indeed tied up with the algebraic structure of the Virasoro and Kac-Moody algebras (see Chapter VI.S) and this often allows for a determination of the n-point Green functions by means of algebraic techniques. utilizing the representation theory of infinite-dimensional Lie Algebras. The Green functions of the 2-dimensional confonnal field theory are then utilized to construct the string amplitudes. The latter are the scattering amplitudes of the target space particles. which are in oneto-one correspondence with the states in the Hilbert space of the 2dimensional quantum field theory. To appreciate such a statement. the reader should just recall that the basic idea underlying string theories is the following. All the observed particles are nothing else but the vibrational modes of the quantum string. In particular the light particles, including the graviton, the photon, the gluons. the wt, the ZOo the quarks. the leptons and eventually the Higgses are the zero modes of the string spectrum. In view of these remarks the current line of thought is the following: «every consistent 2-dimensional conformal field theory corresponds to a possible string vacuum and it is a suitable starting point fOT the string perturbation theory. » We shall be a little bit more particular in this respect, since we want to stick to the geometrical picture of the closed string as a
one-dimensional loop moving in a smooth target manifold. Hence we shall regard as possible string vacua only those consistent conformal theories which are generated by embedding functions (VI.3.5) from a world-sheet ws to a target space
1506 X: \'IS .... Mtarget
(VI.3.l8)
Mtarget can be a smooth manifold or a singular variety. The general idea having been introduced. there are still many important details to be clarified in order to make it perspicuous. First of all, we mentioned consistent conformal theories but we did not specify what we meant by this. Let us do it now. The general idea having been introduced, there are still many important details to be dari fied in order to make it perspicuous. First of all, we mentioned consistent conformal theories but we did not specify what "'8 meant by this. Let us do it now. From the 2-dimensional point of view. the embedding functions (VI.3.5) must be regarded as scalar fields: these scalar fields are coupled to the 2-dimensional gravitational field (the metric g~(~)) in such a way that the classical action is invariant both ~ith respect to diffeomorphisms (VI. 3.19)
and to Weyl transformations defined by Eq. (VI.2.24). The typical 2dimensional action was mentioned in Eq. (VI.2.28) where the collective name {fi(~)} denoted both the embedding functions X~(~) and, in the case of superstrings. a convenient set of left-handed and right-handed 2D-fermions 1jh~). Relying on the lore discussed in Chapter VI.2 and utilizing the classical invariances of the action (Vr.2.28) we can always choose a gauge where, in every coordinate patch U. the 2D-metric is given by a Eq. (VI.2.37), i.e., g _
zz
#
exp[2~(z.z)1
(VI. 3.20)
(as in the last section of Chapter VI. 2, we redefined • + 2+ for later convenience) •
1507
6.3.1 Definition. We state that the action (VI.2.28) describes a classical conformal field theory if in the gauge (VI.3.20) the field equations of the 2-dimensional fields ~i(~), generally given by
oS (g,'I') ---=0 o'1i (~)
(VI.3.21)
can be cast into the form:
az -i J (Z,i) ,
= 0
(VI. 3. 22a)
(VI. 3. 22b) where
-i -1 J (z,z) = J (
(VI.3.23b)
are suitable local functionals of the original fields
on the classical shell the fields
J
i
-i and J
{
analytic and antianalytic fields: (VI. 3. 24a) (VI. 3. 24b) and can be interpreted as cross-sections of suitable line bundles on E (see Section VI.2.8). g
In addition to Eg. (VI.3.19), the action (VI.2.28) leads to the variational equation: (VI. 3. 25)
1508
where TaS(~) is the classical 2-dimensional stress-energy tensor. In a 2-dimensional world the Einstein equations reduce to the statement that TaS (;) should vanish. This corresponds to the observation made in Section (VI.2.1) that there is no nontrivial action for the gravitational field. In the gauge (VI.3.20) the classical Weyl invariance of the action guarantees that the only non-identically vanishing components of TaS are
T '" r(Class)
(VI,3.26a)
T-- .. :r(class) zz
(VI,3.26b)
zz
zz zz being identically zero. Furthermore, the invariance with respect to local diffeomorphisms yields the usual conservation law:
T - =T-
(VI. 3. 27)
which. in the conformal gauge (VI.3.20). becomes (VI. 3. 28a) (VI.3.28b)
Hence, the two independent components of the energy-momentum tenSOr are respectively an analytic and an antianalytic field on Lg• From a canonical point of view. the Einstein equations T(class)(z) ::: 0
(VI. 3.29a)
f(class)(i) ::: 0
(VI. 3. 29b)
are a set of first-class constraints fulfilling the following algebra:
1509
This is nothing else but the classical Virasoro algebra discussed in Eqs. (VI.2.19 - VI.2.23). Indeed, if we define (VI. 3. 31)
we see that Eq. (VI.3.30) yields
Ie -) 1Lmclass, Lclass n r(Dirac)
= (m _n) L (class) n+m
(VI. 3. 32)
which is the canonical realization of the commutation relations (VI. 2. 23). The result is not surprising since the energy-momentum tensor is the canonical generator of the infinitesimal diffeomorphisms. Indeed, for each field ~i(z.z) appearing in the lagrangian (VI.Z.28) we have {T(z).I,hw,w)}H = __ 8_ Z ~i(w,w) Dirac (z -w)
+
_1_ 3\./Cw,w) (VI.3.33a) z -w
where {8,~} are two numbers characteristic of tiez,i) called the conformal weights of the corresponding field. As long as the action (VI.2.28) is Weyl and reparametrization invariant, all the equations from (VI.3.26) to (VI.3.3S) hold true at the classical level, irrespectively of whether or not the classical equations of motion can be cast into the form (Vl.3.22). The problems arise at the quantum level. If the action (VI.2.28) does not define a classical conformal theory, then, for a general target manifold Mtarget' the algebra (VI.3.30) is not respected after quantization; indeed in the short distance expansion of the operator product T(z)T(w) we find terms which are not of the form (VI.3.30) and sometimes not even analytic. Their coefficients are complicated functionals of the metric &Uv(X) and the other geometrical data on Mtarget' These functionals can be calculated only perturbatively deforming a space for
1510
which the classical Virasoro algebra (VI.3.30) is respected at the quantum level. Such starting point spaces can be found among those which yield a classical conformal theory. Indeed, although the classical Virasoro algebra is in general violated also in these cases, when the theory is conformal the violation has, nonetheless, a particularly nice character, since it simply corresponds to a central extension of the algebra (VI.3.32). In fact, after quantization Eq. (VI.3.32) gets replaced by: [Lm,t.n]
=
(m
*n)L~n ,.. ~
+ 1c2 (m3 -m)1SJUT~n ,0 + 2bJUom+n,o
(VI.3.34)
where c and b are two real numbers, respectively named the central charge and the Virasoro coboundary characte'cistic of the type of conformal field considered. They are positive fOr physical fields but negative for the ghost fields we are forced to introduce when we gaugefix the classical Weyl and reparametrization invariances. as well as, in the case of superstrings, the local supersymmetry invariance (see Chapter VI. 4) • Therefore, we can find classical conformal theories which maintain the classical Virasoro algebra also at the quantum level by choosing the field content in such a way that all the ci and bit corresponding to the various fields in the theory. sum up to zero. These quantum conformal theories, given by well-defined choices of the target space, are available string vacua. One should note that 2dimensional interacting field theories that are not classically conformal, according to the definition (VI.3.22) may. nonetheless. lead to quantum conformal theories. This happens through a non-perturbative mechanism. Indeed the short distance operator product expansion of the exact quantum stress energy tensor T(~)T(w) can still fulfill the Virasoro algebra (VI.3.34) (with an appropriate central extension c) if all the perturbative violations of the algebra (S-functions) sum up to zero. An example of this phenomenon seems to be the supersymmetric 0model on the Calabi-Yau 3-folds. Although such a theory is not classi· cally conformal. it appears that its exact quantum version is a super-
1511
conformal field theory. It remains to be seen if in these cases the theory cannot be reformulated as the canonical quantization of a model that is conformal already at the classical level. We make the choice of considering only those string vacua that can be obtained as canonical quantization of classical conformal theories. Clearly they can be classified in t~~ steps. First, one can list the classical conformal theories. Secondly, we can select among these the ones which, upon quantization. yield a vanishing central charge c and a vanishing coboundary b. In the present chapter we deal with step one. Actually. since we are heading for superstrings, rather than bosonic strings, we shall construct classical conformal theories possessing local world-sheet supersymmetry in addition to reparametrization invariance. as well as, a fermionic analogue of Weyl invariance. Furthermore, since we are interested in heterotic superstrings, we will choose an N = 1 world-sheet supersymmetry generated by a Majorana-WeyI d:: 2 supercharge. The construction of such classical theories requires a preliminary study of N,,1, 0:: 2 conformal supergravi ty •
VI. 3.2 N:: 1. 0" 2 conformal supergravity and the heterotic superspace
geolJletry stated above the structure tmdel"lying heterotic superstrings is that of N = 1 conformal supergravity in d" 2. By N ,,1 we mean that the gravitino is a Majorana-Weyl spinor. As
The proper formalism to describe superconformal symmetry in d" 2 is fully analogous to the fonnalism [1] utilized in d" 4. We rush through the necessarY steps beginning with Our conventions. The flat metric and the Levi-Civita symbol are given by: nab" nab:: (:
_°1 )
(VI.3.3Sa)
1512
Eab ::: Eab
(0
1)
(VI.3.35b)
0
~l
where a,b =0,1. The gamma matrices are chosen as follows
l.(: -:) " . (: :)
(VI. 3. 36a)
(VI. 3. 36b)
The charge conjugation matrix is defined by (VI. 3. 37)
with (VI. 3.38)
Finally, we have ab
Y
=
E
ab
Ys
(VI. 3. 39)
where
Y3'" (1o 0)
(VI. 3. 40)
~l
It is also convenient to introduce the notation + 1 0 1 0+ Y- '" - (y .. y ) "" y Y2
A Majorana~Weyl spinor
~
= -21
(1 +Y~) ~
satisfies the conditions
(VI.3.41)
1513 C ~T
= I{I
(VI. 3.42)
which are uniquely solved by setting
'!'
= ew!f( 1;) o
1;*
= I;
(VI. 3.43)
•
Similarly a MajoranawantiWeyl spinoI' • satisfies the conditions (VI. 3.44)
which imply
=e
c)
w¥(O)
x'"
(VI. 3.45)
=X •
X
Utilizing these notations we can immediately write down the curva w tures of the Zwdimensional superconfomal group. (VI. 3.46a) k
a
=DKa
a
i 2
- 1'1 .. V - - • " y
p
= D'¥ + 12 W,.
t:J
=at - 1Z w" ••
a
c)
'¥ - iya. ,. V
a
iy&.v " Ka
(V1.3.46b) (VI. 3.46c) (VI.3.46d) (VI. 3. 46e) (VI. 3. 46 f)
where va, 1'1, '1', t, Ka, w are all I·forms and are the gauge fields associated to the translations, the dilatations, the Q-supers)I1IIIII8tries, the conformal boosts, the S-supersymmetries and the Lorentz rotations respectively. Furthermore, va, 1'1, Ka , wah are bosonic, while '!' and c) are fermionic, and obey conditions (VI.3.43) and (VI.3.44) respectively.
1514 It is convenient to introduce a different basis by defining (VI. 3. 47a) (VI.3.47b) (VI. 3. 47c)
rl"
W:!:
(VI.3.47d)
III
Then with obvious notations Eqs. (VI.3.46) become: (VI.3.48a) (VI.3.48b)
(VI.3.48c) -
L =dk
-
+ -00 ~k
i --X"X
(VI.3.48d)
2
(VI.3.48e)
c"
a+ "
1 + dX - -00
2
dw+ + 2i~
A
X - 2~
A
k
-
(VI.3.48f)
"X
(VI. 3.48g) (VI.3.48h)
Equations (VI.3.4S) encode our description of the N" 1 supercon-
formal algebra. The associated superconfol'lllsi transformations should be non-
linearly realized in heterotic superspace. 01-
with two bosonic coordinates z" x Weyl fermionic coordinate e.
+x
By this 0
1
, z" x - x
~~
mean a superspace
and a single Majorana
1515
Its geometry is described by a supervielbein (e+e-~) and an SO(I,I) connection w.
The set of l·forms (e+e-~) provides a basis for the cotangent space. This means that every p-form can be expanded along these fundamental one-forms. For example: (VI. 3. 49a)
n(2) ~ n;:)e+
A
e- + n;:)e+
A
~
+
n~~)e-
A
,
+ n~:),
A
,
•
(VI.3.49b)
Gi ven (e +e-1,;) we can write down the torsion and the curvature 2-fol'llls (VI.3.S0a) (VI. 3. SOb)
(VI.3.S0c) R" dw.
(VI. 3.50d)
The problem of the nonlinear realization of supe:rc:onfol'lllai S)'lIIlIIetry can now be formulated through the following requirements: we want to identifY the supervielbein multiplet (e+e-,) with the corresponding I-forms sitting in the superconfol1llal algebra i}
(VI. 3.48); +
..
the remaining I-forms w·, X, k- appearing in (VI. 3.48) must be viewed as defined over the heterotic superspace and should be expanded according to Eq. (VI.3.49a); furthermore their components should be expressed in terms of the superspace geometry, Le. in terms of components of the curvature and torsion (VI. 3. SO) ; ii)
iii) the resulting parametrizations of both the superspace torsion and curvature (VI. 3. SO) and of the supereonformal curvatures (VI. 3. 48) must be consistent with the corresponding Bianchi identities.
1516 We fulfill the above requirements by writing, on the one band, the
following "rheonomic" parametrization (VI.3.51a) (VI.3.51b) (VI.3.S1c) (VI. 3.S1d)
where the torsion superfield t(z,z,6) superfield !I1(z,i,e) via 211.
= ~ ·t,
is related to the curvature and by setting, on the other
hand, +
III
=
-Ill
= fIJ
1
X = "2 Te
-
•
(VI.3.S2)
The corresponding rheonomic parametrization of the superconformal curvatures read +
r =0
(VI.3.53a) (VI.3.S3b)
p = 0
1
o = -2
(VI.3.S3c) ~ te +
+
1 "e - -4 til; " e
(VI. 3. 53d)
(VI. 3. S3e)
(VI. 3. 53f)
Finally utilizing these parametrization, from the Lie derivative rule we obtain the transformation of the supervielbein under superconformal transformations:
1517 (VI. 3.54a)
{VI. 3. 54b)
(VI. 3. 54c)
",ilere ~+ :: parameter of left translations ~w
€
..
parameter of right translations
=parameter of Q supersymmetry
(anti commuting)
A: parameter of Lorentz'rotations • :: parameter of Weyl transformations ~
= parameter of S supersymmetry
(anticommuting).
These transformations preserve the constraints (VI.3.S1) and allow the choice of a superconformal gauge where (VI.3.SSa) (VI.3.SSb) (VI.3.SSc)
where .(z .!) is an arbitrary real functions and n(z) is an analytic anticommuting spinor. In this gauge we find (VIo3.56a)
1518
(VI. 3.56b) In particular, one can choose $=0 and n .. O which correspond to a flat and torsionless superspace, i.e. to the special superconformal gauge where (VI. 3. 57a) (VI.3.S7b) 1; '"
de .
(VI. 3.57c)
Equations (VI.3.55) are the supersymmetric analogues of Eqs. (VI.2.382). As seen above, the right-vielbein e- is identical in the bosonic and in the supersymmetric case. It is only the left vielbein e~ which feels the presence of the fermionic coordinate e (compare Eq. (VI.3.SSa) with Eq. (VI.2.382a)). This is also evident from the transformation rules (Vr.3.S4) where we see that e is unaffected by a Q-supersymmetry transformation of parameter E. This structure of the heterotic superspace implies that the worldsheet supercharge acts only on the analytic fields (left-movers), the antianalytic ones (right-movers) being supersymetry singlets. Finally observe that Eq. (VI.3.S6a) is the supersymmetric analogue of Eq. (VI. 2.47). Recalling the redefinition (4) .... 24» of the conformal factor, the reader can check that the first component of the curvature superfield is the ordinary curvature (VI.2.47) of the Riemann surface.
VI.3.3 Classical superconformal theories and the WZW-action In the introduction to the present chapter (Section VI.3.l) we defined the classical conformal field theories. The generalization of this definition to the superconformal case is straightforward.
1519 6.3.2 Definition.
A classical superconformal theory is described by
an action
s = II d2~
det
e(~)~(e!(;)'~n(~),~i(~»)
(VI.3.58)
g
where e!(;) is the vielbein,
~n(~) is the iravitino and .,i m is
a convenient set of mattel' fields fitting into supermultiplets. The matter fields are coupled to the 5upergl'avitational ones in such a way that all the local transformati ons (VI. 3. 54) are symmet ries of the action (VI.3.S8). Furthe:rmore, in the superconformal gauge given by the a = 0 slice of £9s. (VI.3.SS)
(VI.3.S9a) e-
= e~(zl!)d-z
(VI.3.S9b) (VI.3.59c)
(oS/o"i .. 0) can all be cast into the form (VI.3.22) USing suitable local functionals i(op,aop).
the e9uations of motion of the matter fields
In the present section lo.'e construct an example of such a superconformal theory. utilizing as matter fields opi (~) the components of a superfield g(z,i,e) which describes the injection (VI. 3.60)
g: SNS + G
of the superworld-sheet into a siqlle group manifold G. is called the Wesl-Zumino-Witten model
Such a theory
(WZN).
By letting the G structure constants {fABCl go to zero, we obtain from it another classical superconfo1'lllal theory whose matter fields describe the injection of the superworld-sheet SWS into a flat manifold with either the topology of Rd or that of ad-torus Td.
1520 In the next section we will consider the general case of an action (VI.3.S8) ~here the matter supermultiplet {~i(~)} describes an injec-
tion «1:
SWS
+
Mt arget
(VI. 3.61)
of the superworld-sheet into an arbitrary target manifold Mtarget We shall conclude that such an action corresponds to a classical superconformal theory if and only if Mt arge t has the following structure M
target
,. M ® M d compact
(VI.3.62)
where Md is the d-dimensional Minkowski space, and Mcompact" Gr/B is a variety whose covering space is a group-manifold Gr , The homotopy group B is a discrete subgroup B·c Gr ® GT, Finally the structure of GT (called the target group) is (VI.S.63)
G.1 being Simple groups or U(l) factors. At the quantum level the possible choices of restricted by requiring
Gr
will be
conformal anomaly cancellation (the total Virasoro central charge should be zero, when the ghost contributions are included), i)
ii)
existence of target space massless fermions.
These two conditions will be analysed in Chapter VI.S. In any case, the results of the next section will imply that the classical action describing the propagation of a heterotic superstring in a vacuum state can be cast into the fOllowing form (d)
S = S(Mink)
n
+
.r
1,,1
(G. )
S(k~) 1
+
S(het)
(VI. S.64)
1521
00
p
where SCMink) contains, as dynamical fields, the X -coordinates and
(G.)
their superpartner ~~ while S(k~) contains the WZW elementary 1
field g e Gi together with its superpartner AA. which is a Gi-Lie algebra valued tlro-dimensional fermion. Finally S(het) contains a nUlllber Nhet (fixed by the conformal anomaly cancellation) of heterotic fermions which have opposite handedness with respect to ~~ and AA and which do not couple to the 2-dimensional gravitino. This latter, (d)
(G i )
appearing both in S(Mlnk) and in all the SCk i )' defines, through its own variation, the appropriate supercurrent of the model. The supercurrent as we are going to see is the superpartner of the energy-momentum tensor T(z) and leads to the superextension of the Virasoro algebra (VI.3.34). The integer number k.1 associated to each group G.1 is the normalization constant in front of a typical cubic teI'ID appearing in the WZW-action, called the Wess-Zumino term. upon quantization k becomes the value of the central charge in the Kac-Moody algebra generated by the currents ~(z) appearing in the form (Vl.3.22) of the field equations. As announced in the present section, by utilizing the rneonomy approach we construct the locally supersymmetric action of the wess-Zumino-Witten model associated to a simple group G; later by letting fASC"O we retrieve the action associated to an abelian group G. If G is the d-dimensional translation group, we get
s~!Ink)' while
if
G=U(1)p then our result corresponds to the non-
semisimple part of Gr. In all cases, whether Mcompatt is GT Or Gr'B is irrelevant at the level of the action functional since the division modulo B corresponds to imposing a convenient set of boundary conditions on the superfield g(z,z,6). This is a step to be taken at a later stage. Hence from the construction of the present section 1>'6 will be able to retrieve the whole classical action (VI.3.64) of a heterotic superstring. Let us turn to such a construction. We start from the results derived in the previous section and we write the definition and the parametrization of the curvature and torsion of the heterotic superspace:
1522 +
T
def + + i .. de +w"e =r~
.. t
(VI. 3. 65a) (VI.3.65b)
• def
T = d,
+
1 rW""
+
= reA e
def J2 + -. R ,. dw":7l e "e - 1t
,
"e
(VI.3.65c) -
(VI.3.65d)
The above equations encompass the constraints on superspace geomet 1')" imposed by the requi rement of superconfomal s)'lJll1letry.
The super-
field r(z,z.a) is the field strength of the two-dimensional gravitino and provides a complete description of our heterotic geometry (the curvature ~ equals twice the spinor derivative of T).
Given Eqs. (VI. 3.6S)
the intrinsic covariant derivatives !j+, ~_.~. satisfy the following algebra: (VI.3.66a) (V1.3.66b)
..
[~ ~J
.. iST
(VI.3.66c) (VI. 3. 66d)
where s is the spin of the field acted on by the derivatives for the scalars. s .. 1/2 for left-handed femions.
(s" 0
s;: -1/2 for the
right-handed fermions). On the background of the above described heterotic supergeometry we intoduce the WZW-model.
We consider the superfield g(z,i,S) e G
describing the map (Vl.3.60).
In terms of g we can construct the left-
invariant and right-invariant I-forms Sl ,. g-1 dg
(VI. 3. 67a)
1523 ..
Q = dgg
-1
(VI.3.67b)
which can be decomposed along a b~is t A of the Lie algebra G: (VI.3.68a) (VI. 3.68b)
rl
and
rI'
fulfill the Maurer-Cartan equations (VI. 3.69a) (VI. 3.69b)
where fABC aTe the structure constants of G defined by (VI. 3. 70)
Our first step is to decompose the l·forms oA and QA along the complete basis e+, e-.~. In full generality we can write
(V!. 3. 71a)
(V1.3.71b)
where XAz),A(z,z.B) is an anticommuting spinor superfield whose first component
A~B=O)
is the superpartner of the wz.W field g(SaO)'
Using the identity 51 '" {I Qg the O-forms
(Q~,~. ~A) are
easily retrieved from the corresponding untilded ones. trate hereafter
onl~
Hence we concen-
on Eqs. (VI.3.71).
In full generality the covariant differential of ')..A: (VI.3.n)
1524 can be decomposed along the complete basis e + J e - J
1;;
as follows: (VI. 3. 73)
FA;:!I).A is an auxiliary bosonic superfield. Inserting Eqs. (VI.3.71) and (VI.3.73) into (VI.3.69a) and using (VI.3.65-66) ft~ determine FA:
Eqs. (VI.3.69) give also the spinar derivatives of
!W• rf+
= - !W '}..A + tBC AB ~
Q~ and ~:
IF+
(VI. 3. 75a)
and the "Bianchi identity": (VI. 3. 76)
Equations (VI.3.71, 73, 75) provide a consistent (compatible with 2 d =OJ rneollOlDic parametrization of the I-forms QA and !W AA. From this parametrization ft'e obtain the transformation rules under supers}'lllllletry of the matter fields g and ')..A. The transformation rules of the supergravity fields e+, e-, l;; are fixed by Eqs. (VI.3.6S). First of ail, instead of 6g, we utilize the tangent variation
-1
A
6y ;: g 6g = 8y t A
(VI. 3. 77)
which is related to the variation of the I-form QA by (VI. 3. 78)
1525
Then we recall that a supers}'lllllletry variation is nothing but a diffeomorphism in superspace along a fermionic tangent vector e=e:a, that is. a tangent vector such that (VI. 3. 79a) (VI. 3. 79b) So we get: (VI. 3. 80)
where !£ is the Lie·derivative. Utilizing Eqs. (VI.3.71a) and (VI.3.69a) in (VI.3.80) we obtain (VI. 3. 81) which yields (VI. 3. 82)
Simi larly. from (VI. 3. 83)
and by use of Eqs. (VI.3.73) and (VI.3.74) we find (VI. 3.84)
where we: is the parameter of a field-dependent 2·dimensional Lorentz transformation and is given by (VI. 3. 85)
1526 Finally, computing the Lie derivatives R.e;e+. 1"e- and 1~:, we obtain also the 6e;e+. 6E: e - and 6E: ~ rules. SUDDDarizing. the world-sheet SUSY rules of all the fields are given by (VI.3.86a) (VI.3.86b) (VI. 3. 86c) (VI. 3. 86d) (VI. 3. 86e)
The field-dependent Lorentz transfonnation we;' being separately
a symmetry of the action. can also be dropped and in this way Eqs. (VI. 3. 86) reduce to the customary set of rules. The next problem is that of writing an action functional from which the parametrizations (VI.3.71a) and (VI.3.7,'S,74) should follow as fermionic (i.e. outer) projections of the variational equations. This will guarantee the invariance of the considered action against the infinitesimal supersymmetry transformations (VI. 3.86).
Before proceeding it is convenient
to stress that the 2-dimensional field theory under consideration is a special case of a locally supersYlllllletric non-linear a-model.
Hence it
is necessary to introduce a target space spin connection wAB ,. - wBA
(VI. 3. 87)
in addition to the target space metric, which in this case is the Killing metric: gAB
~
fARS fBRS •
(VI. 3. 88)
1527 This spin~connection appears in the covariant differential of the 2-dimensional fermion AA: (VI. 3.89)
Using the structure constants fABC we can introduce a oneparameter family of spin connections (VI. 3. 90)
Regarding
r"c
as the vielbein of the group-manifold G. the torsion
and curvature 2-forms associated to the a-connection are
AB "B _ TABe ....8 TA def ._A (a) .. ~r - .. w(a) ",. - (a).'
"C
A"
(VI. 3. 91a)
(VI. 3. 91b)
where TADe (a)
= - (a + '2I)
fABC
(VI. 3.92a)
(VI. 3. 92b)
There are three critical values of i) if)
iii)
11:
a = - !. 2
CL
=0
a = -1 •
The first corresponds to the choice of the metric connection for which the torsion is zero. The second and the third correspond to the choice of a parallelizing connection for which the curvature is zero.
As we
1528 sha.ll see, for each value of action functional.
there is a corresponding supersymmetric
(X
The case a .. 0,
however, will be special since it
involves an extension of the local symmetries: in addition to local supersymmetry (actually to local superconfonnal invariance) at «=0 We gain local chira! G ® G invariance (Kac-Moody symmetry).
It is
this invariance which leads to the form (VI.3.22) of the equations of 1IIOtion). The supersymrnetric action functional is the following:
~(a)
..
! (J~[(st-AA~) •
AA V(a}]"A
+ 21
_!
3
i
e
+
AA_A iI-
A
,
+
-
(!2 +a) fABC AAABAC l; .. e+ +'i+ QA- e+ e-] -
+ 1 (1 + 2et)
6"
+
A
(~e+ -~ e-)
A
A
JM t-.ABC_A -
If.. QB .. QCJ
(VI.3.93)
•
3
let us discuss its structure.
The dynamical variables are
The supergravity background fields
i)
e+, e-, l;
The WZW field g (contained in $l .. g-ldg)
ii)
and its super-
A
partner A iii)
The auxiliary O-forms
algebraic and plays a double role:
gA, ~t
QA whose field equation is
yields
n~"tr(g-la:tgtA)
and it
enforces the rheonomic parametrization. The last addend in (VI.3.93) is the Wess-Zumino term which is written as the integral over a 3-Simplex M3 (of ~~ich the ~~rld-sheet SW Z is the boundary) of the closed (but not exact) 3-form fABC rf "QB ,,$lC. This term might be a non-Single-valued functional of g.
Single valuedness
requires its coefficient to be an integer (in proper units).
This is
the origin of the quantization of the parameter k to be discussed in Chapter Vr.S.
1529 ~~
observe that both the Wess-Zumino term and the three-linear lambda-tem disappear when (1= -1/2, namely. when we choose the metric connection. Alternatively, when a .. O, VI];O =~ coincides with the world-sheet covariant derivative and we have the emergence of a new local symmetry which will be manifest in the superconformal gauge (Kac-Mbody symmetry). We postpone its discussion and we consider the field equations associated to (VI. 3. 93). The larger symmetry will manifest itself also in the
equations of motion where it leads to the existence of conserved chiral currents and hence to a classical superconfomal theory according to the definition 6.3.2. The oyA variation of (VI.3.93) yields
+
• Motl..NRS M. R S 41Q f fn-A A
A
e+
=0
•
(VI. 3.94a)
while the oAA.variation of the same fUnctional gives
+
8
(21 + a)
the one-form IT
A
f
ABCBC
A A I;;
+
A
e .. 0
(VI. 3. 94b)
rrA being defined by
_A + = 1,e +
A-
- Q e- •
(VI. 3. 95)
-
Equations (VI. 3.94) have the same st l'U<;t ute. They state that a 2-form, defined over heterotic supetspace, should vanish. Hence they split into four sectors corresponding to the four independent wedgeproducts:
1530 i) il)
e+ " e e+
" 1;
-
iii) e " iv)
,
I; " ,
which provide an intrinsic basis for the vector space of 2-forms. The coefficients of the structures ii), iii), iv) cancel automaticallY when the rheonomic parametrizations (VI.3.71a, 73, 74) are inserted into (VI. 3. 94). Actually the coefficients of the action were precisely fixed through the requirement that this shOUld happen (i.e. supersymmetry invariance). The cancellation of the e+ "e- coefficients instead is the same thing as the following differential equations:
(VI. 3. 96a) g) )"A +
-
a. rASe ABrF
-" 0 •
(VI. 3. 96b)
The meaning of the parameter a and the difference between the supersymmetric and bosonic WZW model are manifest in Eqs. (VI.3.96). In order to discuss it we choose the superconformal gauge and we consider the critical values of a (ep: 0, a" -1). If the ;..A were zero, namely, if we considered a bosonic WZW model both critical values would lead to a conserved chiral current. Indeed, in the bosonic case a." 0 implies ~Q =9(g-1~g)=O, I.;hile a=-l implies ~Q =~(g-lfjg)=O. -+
-
+
+-
+
-
In both cases, utilizing also the right-invariant one-form n, we arrive at the conclusion that there are a conserved left-moving and a conserved right-moving current: (VI.3.97a) (VL3.97b)
1531 Furthermore. in the bosonic case there are no fermions which couple to the spin connection (VI. 3. 90) and the two choices
cx .. 0 or a,,-1
simply conespond to flipping the sign of the Wess-Zwnino term.
The
Here, if we
situation is quite different in the supersymmetric case.
want a complete decoupling of the fermionic and bosonic degrees of freedom we must choose a .. O. fermion
In this case (and only in this case) the
AA is a free field obeying the equation (VI. 3. 98)
while
~
'"
becomes a conserved chiral current (VI. 3.99)
The sign of the Wess-Zumino term is no longer arbitrary, rather it
is fixed by our initial choice of the left·invariant one-fom flA as If
the ftmdamental object in terms of which we constructed our action. We had used
n rather than
fl we would have fomld the reversed result.
Relying on this link we decide to call left-moving all the fields which, like the left-invariant one-foTID
9l .. O. +
rf. +
satisfy 9." O. -
•
Right-
moving fields
i
will be zero.
Under this condition Eq. (VI.l.93) is the action of a
obey 'instead
classical superconfomal theory:
From now on the value of a
the super WZW-model.
VI.l.4 Heterotic a-model on a general target space and the choice of ...e.;. r; . COR;;. ;.; .; ;.fo;. . ;l'IlIl1. ; ; ; ;. ; ;.I. .:t;.;,.h_eo...!1"",' -Mt arget_-'l..:;e-"'ad.;;.;i...;:;n""g'-t.;..;o;......;.ca_c""l;.;;a_ss-"'i;....;c...;.a..;;,l-'s_up In this section we reconsider the results of the previous one from a more general stand-point.
As already pointed out. the action (VI.3.93)
of the Wess-ZUmino-Witten model is just an eXaJlq>le of a locally supersymmetric two-dimensional o-model.
Indeed. the bosonic kinetic part of
the Lagrangian (VI.l.93) .z,p-k'
ln
_A = ll"""
("A _A -) •• e+ - u·· e
'"
-
+
"A "A e+ .-~ e•••• +
-
(VI. 3. 100)
1532 upon transition to
second~order
formalism can be rewritten as (VI. 3.101)
where
xlJet;;)
are the coordinates of the group manifold G, ~v(X) is
the Ge G invariant metric on that manifold and ~B (1;) is the worldsheet metric. In view of this observation we are interested in the general form of a heterotic locally supersymmetric a-model where the bosonic kinetic term is given by (VI.3.101).
~v(x)
being an arbitrary metric on an
arbitrary target manifold "large M t' In this section we construct such a model and then we investigate for which choice of Mtarge t the corresponding field equations take the form (VI. 3.22). We conclude that this happens only in two cases. namely when M t has for universal d urge covering space either R or a semisimple group manifold Gr' The model on Gr is a superposition of WZW-models, one for each simple group Gi
contained in
0-
Gr·
The a-model on a general target manifold is not a classical superconformal theory but nonetheless it can describe a consistent quantum conformal theory if all its beta functions vanish. The beta f1.D1ctions are differential expressions in the deviation h g~(~)
G
from a group manifold one g IJV(~):
IJV
of the metric
(VI. 3.102) and also in the deviation of the torsion from the group manifold parallelizing torsion. Setting these beta functions to zero we obtain the perturbative expansion of the string field equations around the vacuum state corresponding to the group-manifold GT, The a-model described in this section will be used in Chapter VI.9 to provide the starting point for the analysis of the string propagation on background field configuration. Let us now der! ve the a-model we have been discussing.
1533 The signature of the target manifold Mtarget is chosen as follows (-. +. +, .... +)
(VI. 3. 103)
and its dimension D is given by D = rl + d "loUnk compact
(VI. 3.104)
where, referring to Eq. (VI.3.62), ~ink is the dimension of the Minkowski space and dcompac t is the number of compactified dimensions. i.e. the dimension of Mcompact' The geometry of Mt t is described by a vielbein Va, a spin arge connection wab =_wba • and a 2-form B defined up to gauge trans formations (VI. 3.10S)
A being
a I-form.
We define the torsion, the curvature and a 3-form field strength for B, named .ft: (VI. 3 .106a)
AlIab
;n
_=
dwab +wac
cb
"W
= Rabmn
.JD
V
.J!
"v
(VI. 3.106b) (VI. 3. I06c)
The coefficients Hab' c being the components of a 3-form, build up a tensor which is necessarily completely antisymmetric. r abc , on the other hand, is not a priori antisymmetric in all its indices: it is just antisymmetric in b ...... c. However, as we are going to see in a moment, the requirement of local supersymmetry invariance of the o-rnodel action leads to an identification
1534
(VI. 3. 107)
Tabc " - 3Habc •
Hence Tabc is also fully antisymmetrlc. Furthel'lllOre in Chapter VI.9 we will see that Eq. (VI.S.I07) is only the classical limit of a much more complicated quantum equation relating the torsion to H-field strength (see Table VI.9.V and Eq. (VI.9.238). In addition to va, wab and B, we introduce also a I-form A'*' on Mtarget with values in the Lie algebra SO(Nhet ). where \et is the number of heterotic fermions to be fixed through quantum considerations in Chapter VI.S. The I-fol1ll Ao£, = _ABa is a given by the following 2-form
gauge
field and has
a
field strength
(VI.3.108)
When the world-sheet is mapped into Mtarget by the assignment of an embedding function XP(z.z,a) then the vielbein y& can be decomposed along the basis e+,e,1; of the heterotic superspace (VI.S.I09) the components V~ can be identified with the 2-dimensional fermions l/Ja completing the embedding supermultiplet v~
"
(VI. 3. 110)
l/J& •
Inserting (VI.S.I09) and (VI.3.1IO) into (VI.3.106) we obtain
(VI.3.111a) (VI. 3.111b)
1535 (VI. 3.lllc) which are the generalizations to ail arbitrary manifold of Eqs. (VI. 3. 73) and (VI. 3. 75). In addition to the fermions
a W
we introdu~e the heterotic fer-
mions ~a (ex = 1, ••• ,Nhet ) and we define their covariant differential (VI.3.112)
From the Bianchi identity (VI.S.llS)
inserting the following rheonomic par3llletrization (VI.3.114)
we obtain the condition
(VI. 3. 115)
Given these ingzedients the action of the heterotic a-model is
s ..
2-IJ ~
~
(y8 ~1jIaf;)
;, (nae+ _nae·) + 2i
!pa~!p8
;, e+ +
+-
+
IPaVa ...
+
2H(l~~B
I; +
~ i rabc,l!pb"h ;, e+ ... n~ae+ ,.. eS
"e- + 4
+
FaBf;a~B1jImfe+ nln
~
"e- +
+
I A'l M
(VI. 3. 116)
,5
which is supersymme1;ric invariant for any choice of the target manifold provided the relation (VI.S.I07) between the torsion and the 2-form field strength is verified. Furthermore ~ is the boundary of 143:
~"IlM3'
1536
The action (VI.3.116) is determined via the usual rh~onomic construction by requiring that the parametrizations (VI.3.109-110), (VI.3.111) and (VI.3.114) should follow from the associated variational equations. In order to write the latter we must vary S in O$a, in on! and also in the coordinate (OXP) implicitly contained in the vielb;in.
Rather than oX~, it is convenient to utilize anholonomized variations (tangent vectors to Mtarge t) oX a whose generator is the Lie derivative. So we write (VI. 3.117)
where +
a .... pa
oX "oX
(VI. 3. 11 Sa)
(VI. 3.llSb)
and
we obtain
w~~ being the parameter of a field-dependent SO(D) local transformation, defined by
wab ..
-Iwab
oX .§lJ
(VI. 3.120)
By the same token we obtain (VI. 3. 121)
(VI.3.122)
1537 (VI. 3.123)
where ,,~ is the parameter of a field~dependent SO(Nhet) local transromation, defined by (VI. 3. 124)
in full analogy with Eq. (VI.3.l20). Equation (VI. S.122) follows from (VI. 3. 12S)
which is true as a consequence of d Ii '" O. Utilizing these formulae the variation of the action (VI.3.116) in o~a, 6~:, oXa and o~a yields the following results: The rheonomic parametri zations determined from the Bianchi identities are indeed consistent with the equations of motion projected in the outer directions i)
ii) The auxiliary O-forms projections of the vielbein:
n:
are identified with the inner
(VI. 3.126)
iii) The following inner field equations hold true in the special superconformal gauge t(z,i,8) =0 (VI. 3. 127a)
(VI. 3.127b)
(VI. 3.127c)
1538 Using Eq. (VI.3.106a) which yields (VI. 3.128)
Eq. (Vr.3.127c) can also be rewritten as (VI-3.lZ!)
By inspection of Eqs. (VI.3.127a,b) and (VI.S.129) we see that, in a and general, neither W are left-moving fields, nor ~a is a right-moving one.
v!
Indeed the three field equations can be rewritten as follows (VI.3.130a) (VI. 3. 130b )
(VI. 3. 130c)
From Eqs. (VI.3.130) we easily see that the necessary and sufficient condition to obtain a classical superconformal theory is the vanishing of the spin and gauge connections (VI.3.131) In this case Eqs. (VI.3.130) reduce to the desired equations: (VI. 3. 132)
There are just two cases where the spin connection wab can be taken as equal to zero everywhere: i) the first case is that of a flat space characterized by a vielbein whose exterior derivative is zero
1539 (VI.3.133)
the second case correspbnds to a simple Lie group manifold whose vielbein fulfills the Maurer-Cartan equations ii)
(VI. 3.134)
In the first case we have also a vanishing torsion, while in the second case the spin connection vanishes but the torsion is given by Eq. (VI.3.92a) with a=O.
Hence the most general solution for a target manifold leading to
a classical superconformal theory is obtained by an arbitrary combination of these two items. This corresponds to the choice (VI.3.62,63) of the target space and with such a choice the action (Vl.3.116) reduces to the sum (VI-3.M). To see that this is the case it suffices to split the index a of the vielbein Va according to the following pattern: ~
runs from
1 to
~nk
i-I
from
(d~fink + R,~ 1 dim G9.
+
1)
(Vl.3.13S)
a"
to
(d~link
i +
L
R,=l
dim G9. )
Furthermore, recalling Eqs. (VI.3.63) and (VI.3.104) we have n
L dim G.1
i=l
"d
mp ct co a
(VI.3.136)
We set (VI. 3.137a)
1540
(VI.3.137b)
(VI.3.137c)
(VI. 3. 137d)
A
where X~ is the coordinate of the Minkowski space. g i invariant l-fol'lll of the i-th group, and ki
is the left-
is the integer number (k. )
appearing in front of the corresponding WZI'l action S (G~) • 1
Furthel'lllOte, the torsion field is given by (VI. 3. 138a)
Ai BiCi
T
,,-
f{;ki
1
ABC
(VI.3.138b)
-2 f(l')
f~:~ being the structure constants of the i-th group. All the other components vanish and Babe is given by Eq. (VI.3.107) in terms of
r abe . With these subst! tutions and setting moreover AaB =O. the action (VI.3.116) takes the form (VI.3.64) as claimed.
In this way we have succeeded in finding the general form of the classical action for a heterotic superstring propagating in a vacuum that corresponds to the quantization of a classical superconformal field theory.
The freedoms we are left with are the following: i)
ii)
iii)
choice of the space-time dimension dMink , choice of the simple groups Gi
and of their "levels"
choice of the number of heterotic fermions Nh
iv) choice of the homotopy groups B c
et
ki ,
'
~ ® ~.
All these freedoms will be fixed in Chapter VI.S by the quantum consistency conditions.
1541 VI. 3. 5 Canonical quantization of the heterotic WZW·model and the s~erconformal
algebra
In Sections VI.3.l and VI.l.4 we considered the variations of the actions (VI.l.93) and (VI. 3. 116) with respect to the matter fields but not with respect to the supergravi ty background fields e +, e· " •
As it was stressed in the introduction to this chapter and also in Chapter VI.2, the vielbe!n and the gravitino are not dynamical fields in d .. 2. Rather, they can be viewed as the Lagrangian multipliers associated to the primary constraints of the theory, which are nothing but the stress-energy tensor and the supercurrent.
In the classical theory these
latter are "weakly" zero, while in the quantum theory they are utilized to construct the BRST -charge. Let S be the complete action (VI.3.116) of our theory, where the substitutions (VI.l.IS7) and (VI.l.l3S) have been made.
We define
the superstress-energy tensor and the supercurrent through the following variation: (VI. 3.139)
The l·forms fT+, 9",., and ff., which should not be confused with the 2-forms, T·, T- and T· of Eqs. (VI.3.6S), constitute the super stress-energy tensor. The statement that they are "weakly" zero is the 2-dimensional analogue of the Einstein and Rarita Schwinger equations; indeed it follows from the stationarity of S with respect to oe+, oe - and 01;variations. In general the l·forms ff.,
ff..
and .1'. decompose as follows: (VI. 3. 140a) (VI. 3.140b)
1542 (VI. 3. 140c)
However, if the action S is not only supersymmetric but also super Weyl invariant then we have additional constraints on the components of ff,., ff_ and 9",. We have shown in Section VI.3.2 that when the constraints (VI.3.65) hold the heterotic superspace geometry is superconformal; in addition to the superdiffeolDorphisms and the 50(1,1) Lorena transformations it admits super Weyl transformations (that is, dilatations and S-supersymmetries). In particular we have the following transformation rules for the vielbein and the gravitino: (VI.3.141a) (VI. 3.141b)
0,
= -1
2
(M
+
ow) I; + 2011 e
+
(VI. 3.141c)
where oA, OW, and 011 are the infinitesimal parameters associated to a dilatation, a Lorentz transformation and an S-supersymmetry respectively. Requiring invariance of the action
oS/oA = oS/ow = OS/o11
=0
(VI.3.142)
we obtain the following conditions: ff
+
Y+
A
+ e +ff
A
e
- -9"
-
=0
(VI.3.143a)
I,; '" 0
(VI. 3.143b)
A
e -+2:..9" 2 •
~ 1;
A
e -+2:..9" 2 •
A
(VI. 3. 143c)
from which we deduce
1543 ~+-
.. ff-+
=§_.
=S"•• =0
(VI. 3. 144) (VI. 3.145)
Hence in a superconformal invariant theory then are just thne independent and non-vanishing components of the super stress-energy, ff,ff' ++
and ~.'
--
For later convenience we parametrize them as follows:
ff
.. T(class)
(VI. 3.146)
!T
= _ r(class)
(VI. 3.147)
9"
.. 2!T
++
ill +.
'" __1_ e'4 G(class)
.+
(VI. 3. 148)
fl
In classical canonical formalism T(class) ~ 0, t(class) ~ 0, G(class) ~ 0 are primary constraints and, as we will see, they generate the classical algebra of superconformal transformations. If the total action S is the sum of several actions associated to various matter supermultiplets. then the stress-energy tensor is the sum of the stress-energy tensors of the different supermultiplets. Similarly for the supercurrent. In our case the action has the structure (VI.3.64) and, provided all the addends are superconf01'lllal (namely I Eqs. (VI. 3.61) hold true for each component subsystem). we can write
(VJ.3.149a) i(class) _ T(class) - (Mink) G(c1ass) '"
G(elass) (Mink)
n
I
+
i=l
+
i=1
r
r(claSS) (Gi.k i ) G(class) (Gi'ki )
+
T(clas5) (het)
(VI. 3. 149b)
(VI. 3. 149c)
1544
where we have anticipated that the heterotic fermions do not contribute to either r{class) or G(class) since they do not couple to e+ Or to
1;.
As already stated several times, si~nk) is simply a particular case of the general WZW action, where for the group G we take the abelian translation group G" TCd) • It suffices to study the WZW-model for a general group G, namely, to concentrate on the action functional (2.33). Applying the general definition (VI.3.139) to this specific case and inserting, after the variation has been taken, the rheonomic parametrizations (VI.3.71a, VI.3.73, VI.3.74) we easily see that Eqs. (VI.3.144) are indeed satis~ fied while for ff'++, ,"-_,
~.,
~+
and
we obtain the result (VI. 3. 150a)
(VI. 3.150b)
(VI. 3. lSOc)
(VI. 3. 150d)
Hence we see that the theory (VI.3.93) is indeed superconformal invariant, at the classical level, for all values of the parameter a. However, as already stated, we are just interested in the case a= 0 which is the only one where the effective degrees of freedom correspond to those of a classical superconformal theory and where the local symmetries extend to include Kac-Moody symmetry (see below). Anyhow since we have ascertained that our dynamical system is superconformal invariant it is now our privilege to choose the superconformal gauge or even, if we like, the special superconformal gauge where
.'
1545
e+ l,;
'" dz +
= de
!.2 e de
(VI. 3.15 la)
•
(VI. 3.1S1b)
Furthermore, since we have ascertained that the action (VI.3.93) is rheonomic we can, without loss of information, take its restriction to the d =2 space-time s lice of the heterotic superspace, namely. we can set e =O. With these gauge fixings and after substitution of the firstorder equation QA+ =tr(g -1 c+g t A), the action functional (VI. 3.93) with (l." 0 becomes
s~~j = - 8~ +
HdZ di(Q~Q~ + 2iAAazl) + A
t J fABe rzA "UB " Qe]
(VI. 3. 152)
where (VI.3.lS3a)
Q~ t = QA t = g~l oz-g z A - A
(VI. 3. 153b)
Furthermore, we have inserted an i factor which takes into account the Wick rotation implicit in the holomorphic notation z and z for the left-moving and right-moving coordinates respectively. Our i-prescription is very simply stated in terms of the 2-dirnensional integration measures (VI. 3.154)
As we see, with this prescription the integration measure over the worldsheet goes over into the integration measure defined over the associated Riemann surface. Given the form (VI.3.lS2) of the action functional we derive the correct canonical quantization of the fields g(z.z) and AA(z,z).
1546 Since the two field theories are completely decoupled we can treat them separately. Let us begin with the WZW field g(z,i).
In the gauge we have
chosen. the equation of motion (V1.3.99) reduces to
a.rt z z .. 0 .. fI!' .. rt(z)
•
(VI.3.155a)
Multiplying the above by g(z,i) on the left and by g-l(z,i) on the right we can also deduce that ",A azSf'; z ..
",A-A
0 .. 1l"" '" {2 (z) .
(V1.3.1SSb)
Hence out of an "on-shell" WZW-field g(z,z) we can construct twoanalytic currents:
k ."A JA( z) .. - 1. .
2 +
-A -
k ",A
. k "A = - 1. -k tr (-1 A gag t )
(VI.3.156a)
(VI.3.156b)
.. 1 - . .
z
2
z
• k -A
k
-I A t)
2
J (z) .. -i-w= 1-.0-= -i-tr(3.gg 2 2 z 2 z
whose normalization has been chosen for later convenience. want to show that
Indeed, we
i) our dynamical system is a constrained hamiltonian, characterized by second-order constraints which naturally lead to the use of Di rae brackets,
A ·A ii} the Dirac brackets of the dynamical variables J (z), J (z) are (VI. 3. 157a)
A
-B
(J (z). J (w)
lD'lrac = 0
(VI. 3. 157b)
(VI. 3. lS7c)
1541 If true, Eqs. (VI.3.157) would show that the degrees of freedom of the WZW field g(z,i) can be naturally subdivided into two independent sets of left-moving and right-moving IDOdeS. It suffices to perform a Laurent series expansion of both t{z) and JA(z):
(V!. 3.1SSa)
(V1.3.1S8b)
Using these expansions Eqs. (VI.3.157) become the following: (VI. 3. 159a)
(VI. 3. 159b)
(VI. 3. 159c)
J!. j!
The "modes" form a complete set of dynamical variables describing the WZW field g(z,z).
3!
Canonical quantization is obtained by tuming J~. into operators and replacing the canonical Dirac bracket in Eqs. (VI.3.l59) with the quantum commutator: {I a • JillB} n
Dirac
quanthation [A BJ • I n, J m .. (VI. 3. 160)
and similarly for the other cases. Note that no i-factor is needed in the above fomulation of the correspondence principle since we have already performed the Wick rotation on the classical action (see Eq. (VI.3.154). Alternatively we can say that no i-factor is needed since
1548
in our canonical commutations time-ordering has been replaced by radial ordering of the complex variables z and w. With the above quantization procedure, Eq. (VI.3.160) states that the left~ and right-moving modes of the WZW field satisfy two identical and commuting Kac-Moody algebras G where the value of the central charge (that is, the level k) is identified with the constant k originally written in front of the action (VI.3.93). lmitarity of the -2 Kac-Moody representations requires k/6 e I, where 1\ is the longest root of the G Lie Algebra (see Olapter VI.S). Equivalently, the canonical quanthation can be formulated directly on the currents l(z). jB(f) turning them into operator-valued distributions and identifYing the r.h.s. of Eqs. (VI.3.IS7) with the Singular part of their short-distance operator product expansion (OPE): A B k J (z) J (w) " 2
(V1.3.161a)
k
(VI. 3.161b)
In this way we see that once Eqs. (VI.3.IS7) are established the canonical quantization of the WZW-field is also established. Let us then prove these crucial equations. First of all, using the tangent variations
= oyA tA
(VI. 3. 162a)
6y~ .. g oy g-1 • '" ogg-l-A "oy t A
(VI. 3.162b)
6y = g
-1
6g
we notice that the variation of the action functional (VI.3.152) can be written as follows:
oS = i !. 411"
I
dz
~
di
az-rtz 0/ " i J!.. 411
I
dz ;. di
aZrtz oyA (VI. 3.163)
1549 Next, we recall the structure of Dirac brackets in a theory whose Lagrangian L is linear in the velocities. The general structure of such an L is n L"
I
.
A. (q)
i=l
q1
(VI. 3.164)
1
where Ai (q) are functions of the dynamical variables qi and where, for simplicity, we have considered a finite number of them. The Euler-Lagrange equations are obtained from the variation of the action S = di L(q,q) and read
I
(VI. 3. 165)
the matrix Cij(q) being defined by the following equation dS "
f dr (oqi clJ.. qj)
.
(VI. 3.166)
Using (VI.3.164) the explicit form of Cij is given by:
a
a
, , - A).(q) - - . A.(q) • cqi cqJ 1
(VI. 3. 167)
Now the very fact that L is linear in the velocities implies the existence of second~class constraints. Calculating the canonical momenta Pi" aL/cqi, we find the constraints
w.1 "p. - A. 11
::: 0 •
(VI. 3. 168)
They are of the second class since their Poisson brackets are not weakly zero, rather they are equal to the matrix C1) .. : l~· ,~·l 1
J Poisson
-;
0 .
(VI. 3.169)
1550 This observation has the important implication that for the class of theories tmder consideration, once the matrix Cii has been identified, we can immediately calculate the Dirac bracket of any two dynamical variables X(q)
and Y(q): (VI. 3.170)
This procedure can be immediately applied to the WZW-model. us consider Eqs. (VI.3.163) and take Z.. T as the time variable. identifying the oq~variation with
Let Then,
or:
6'1~A .. ogg -1~" .. "'1
(VI. 3.171)
from consistency it follows that ~ is the velocity ~
ll;'; ..
z
a-gg Z
- 1 . -1
.. gg
Oq • .. - .. q • OT
(VI. 3.172)
which explicitly identifies the operator Cij with integration over the variable z and
d';B .. (L)
in the case of left-
For the latter, sUllDBation on the index i
moving fields.
ik 411' .
~~
is substituted
can write
oAB a •
{VI. 3. 174)
z
~
A
1:.
.A nA
Al ternatl vely, if we choose T" z, uy .. uq, y
""z
we find the
operator CR appropriate to rignt-moving fields: (VI.3.175)
1551
Having identified CL• the derivation of Eqs. (VI.3.157) becomes straightforward. We just need the inverse of (VI.3.174) which can be represented as an integral operator: (VI. 3. 176a) -1 41fi CAB(Z - w) .. 10g(z - w) 0AB • k
(VI.3.176b)
Using this kernel in the definition (VI. 3.170) of the Dirac bracket we find:
(VI.3.l77)
which is easily calculated using the identity 6JA(Z) .. &yM(u)
!!.
tr(g{z)tAf 1 (u)t M)
2
(u - z)2
(VI. 3. 178a)
which follows from (VI.3.178b)
The result of the calculation is the Eq. (Vl.3.1S7a) above and in a perfectly analogous way one derives Eqs. (VI.3.1S7b) and (VI.3.157c). The quantization of the fermions is much simpler and easily done.
Their contribution to the action is read off from Eq. (VI.3.1S2) (G) k S(fermions) '" 411"
I dz
-
A
A A dz A el zA.
(VI.3.179)
which immediately leads to the following second-class constraint: (VI.3.IS0)
1552
where we have denoted by ~A the canonical momentum conjugate to )..A. (Remember that both )..A and l£A are anti commuting fields). Calculating the Poisson bracket of $A(z) with ~B(w) we find (VI.3.181) which defines the matrix C1) .• of Eq. (VI.3.169) in the case of free fermions. Since 1/2~i (z - w) is the identity operator (in the distri-1 i -1 bution sense) we get C '" - k (z - w) and can write i {jAB k z-w
(VI. 3.182)
(the index :!: appended to the Dirac bracket tells us whether it is fermionic or bosonic, symmetric or antisymmetric). This explains also the not ation of Section VI. 3.1. The canonical quantization of the field )..A(z) is then obtained by turning it into an operator and identifying the r.h.s. of Eq. (Vr.3.182) with the singUlar part of the OPE: A
B
i
oAB
A (z) A (w) "' - - - - .. reg. k z-w
(VI.3.183)
Recalling Eqs. (VI.3.148, 149, 156) we can easily write the explicit expressions for the classical stress-energy tensor and the supercurrent in terms of fields whose canonical Dirac brackets are known: (VI. 3. l84a)
(VI. 3. 184b)
(VI. 3. 184c)
1553
In the formulae above, the suffices (G,k) recall that the stressenergy tensors and the supercurrent are completely determined by the choice of the group and the constant k. Using (VI.S.184), (VI.3.182) and (VI.S.lS7) we find Ir(claSS)(Z), TCclass) (W)}H '" (Dirac) 2T(class)(W) aT(class)(w) ..
(VI. 3.18Sa)
+ - - - - " -....
(z_w)2
z-w
I
T(ClaSS)(Z), G(ClaSS)(W)JC-) : (Dirac)
=1
G(class)(w) + oG(Class)(w) 2 (~ _ w)2 z •w
\ G(class) (z), G(class) (w)
I
(+)
= 2T(c1ass) (w)
(Dirac) - ~(class) - }e-) T (w) 1 T~(ClaSS) (z),
(Dirac)
(VI. S.
l8Sh)
(VI. 3.18Sc)
z -w '"
2T(class)(w) (i - 14)2
+
or(class)(w) i -W
•
(VI,3.18Sd) while all the other brackets vanish. Equations (VI.3.18S) define the classical superconformal algebra of primary constraints. As already pointed out, the two-dimensional vielbein and gravitino are the Lagrangian multipliers of the hamiltonian constraints: T(class)(z) '" 0 G(class) (z) ::: 0
t(c1ass) (i) '" 0 (VI. 3.186)
which are primary precisely because their Dirac brackets are weakly zero, namely, proportional to the constraints themselves (Eq. (VI.3.18S)).
1554 Equation (VI.3.185a) coincides with Eq. (VI.3.30) and leads to the classical Virasoro algebra. Expanding in modes both T(z) and G(z} from Eqs. (VI.3.l8Sa,b,c) we obtain the supersymmetric extension of the classical Virasoro algebra. Its geometric interpretation is very simple. As the Virasoro algebra generates the diffeomorphisms maintaining the conformal gauge (VI.3.20), in the same way the super Virasoro algebra generates the superdiffeomorphisms maintaining the superconformal gauge (VI.3.SS). Upon quantization Eqs. (VI.3.18S) are replaced by the Corresponding operator product expansions. The case of the composite fields T(z). fez) and G(z) is however different from the case of the elementary fields JA(z), ~(i), AA(z). In the latter, declaring that the Singular part of the OPE coincided with the classical Dirac bracket was our privilege and embodied our quantization prescription. In the former, the OPE of the superconformal generators, which are composite fields, is no longer a matter of definition, rather it is something we can calculate and compare with the r.h.s. of the classical Dirac bracket. The two answers are usually different but most of the difference can be reabsorbed in multiplicative renormalizations of the composite fields. The part which cannot be reabsorbed is the conformal anomaly. It manifests itself in the OPE as a higher singUlar term whose coefficient is a C-number. That C-number is the central charge of the quantum superconformal algebra. In the case of the WZW-model we consider the OPE's of the superconformal generators defined by Eqs. (VI.3.184). A straightforward calculation shows that in order for the simple and double pole terms to have the same form as in the classical Dirac bracket (Eq. (VI.3.18S» we just need two multiplicative and finite renormalizations. Indeed, if we define the renormalized quantum generators by TCG
,
1 A A k){Z) • ------ : J (z)J (z) k + C
v
T(G k)(z) '" -1- : -AC-)-A(-) J zJ z ,
k + Cv
ik 2
(VI.3.187a) (VI.3.187b)
1555
(VI.3.187c) where the second Casimir Cv is the number defined below
(VI. 3. 187d) then we obtain the fOllowing OPEI S T(z)T(w) .. £. __ 1_.. 2T(w) .. aT(w) .. reg 2 (z _ w)4 (z ~ w)2 z- w T(z)G(w) ..
!
~
2
(z-w)2
..
aG(w) ... reg
(VI. 3. 189b)
7.-W
G(2:)G(W) .. ~ c __ 1 _ + 2T(w) .. reg 3 (z _w)3 z· W T(f)T(w) ..
(VI.3.189C)
§. __1_.. ii'(w) + 3'i'(iIi) .. reg 2 (i _ w)4
(z _ w)2
i-if
where the values of the central charges c and c .. c(G.k) '"
~ dim k .. -V
G+
c .. c(G.k) .. _k_ dim G •
k
+
Cv
(VI. 3.189a)
!
2
dim G
c
(VI.3.189d)
are given by: (VI.3.190a)
(VI. 3. 19Gb)
In Eq. (VI. 3.190a) the first addend is the contribution of the KacMoody currents. while the second is the contribution of free left-moving fermions ~A(z). This explains why in the right-moving sector (Eq. (VI.3.190b» we have only one contribution. This concludes our treatment of the WZW-model, which, as shown in Section VI.3.4, is the only other building block, besides the heterotic fermions, of the heterotic superstring vacua corresponding to classical superconfozmal theories.
1556 APPENDIX TO CHAPTER VI.3
Rules for the Wick rotation of spinots Before Wick rotation (in Minkowskian signature) e+ and e
are
real I-forms and 1; is real as a consequence of the Majorana condition. Under the Wick rotation the action must be multiplied by a factor i: S+
is .
(VI.3.Al)
This corresponds to the transformation t .. it
Furthermore, ,/
+
dz. e - ... eli but we must also keep t rack of the
Majorana condition.
Originally we had
(VI. 3.A2)
so that we wrote
(VI. 3.A3)
After Wick rotation we must replace yO tion (VI.3.A2) becomes
+ -
i yO.
so that condi-
(VI.3.A4)
Maintaining the fOrm (VI.3.A3) (VI. 3.AS)
1557 we get
(VI. 3.A6)
wilich implies (VI. 3.1\7)
If we set
(VI.3.A8) OUT
equation is satisfied.
hi
-'4
In conclusion. after Wick rotation a Majorana spinor is e times a real anticammuting field.
References for Chapter VI.!
[1]
L. Castellani, P. Fre, P. van Nieuwenhuizen. Ann. of Phys. 136 (1981) 398.
1558
CHAPTER V!. 4
The DRST Charge and the Ghost Fields
VI.4.1
Introduction
In this chapter we give a brief account of BRST covariant quanti. tat ion. Its characteristic feature is a global invariance first dis· cussed by Becchi. Rouet and Stors [lJ and Tyupin [2} in the context of gauge theories. The phase-space description of a physical system with local
invariances includes a set of (first-class) constraints .A (qi 'Pj) ,,0. A:l ..... m. i.j =1 ••••• n. satisfying the Poisson bracket relations: (VI.4.la) (VI.4.1b) where ~ means that the equality holds on the constraint surface 'A (q.p) ,,0. These constraints generate the local invariances of the theory (see Refs. 3-6 for reviews).
1559 To quantize this system, we lllay proceed in two ways: we introduce m additi~al constraints XI\ (q,p) '" 0 (gauge choices) such that $1\ and XA together become second class, Le. i)
(VI.4.2) These constraints can be solved to obtain an unconstrained theory defined on a 2 (n-mJ-dimensional phase space. Then the usual canonical quanti:l.ation can be applied. ii) We quantize the theory in the 2n-dimensional phase-space (qi,Pj)'
and project out the physical states by requiring (VI.4.3)
The hat denotes quantum operators.
We have to check whether the quantum
version of Eqs. (VI.4.1) still holds.
If it does not bold, we have
anomalies in the quantum algebra of constraints. In field theory, Eq. (VI.4.3) may be too strong a reqUirement, and one imposes the weaker condition (VI.4.4) The states Ix:>" 4>A1phys> have zero norm and are orthogonal to the physi cal states. To construct these zero norm states, we need to introduce negative nonn states called "ghost states". This is efficiently taken care of by BRST quantization.
The absence of anomalies is equi-
valent to the nilpotency of the BRST operator (see next section).
Vl.4.2 BRST quantization.
Abstract properties of Q
Historically. BRST invariance was discovered as a global invariance of the gauge-fixed quantum action for gauge theories [1,2].
1560 Here we discuss it in the more general context of constrained systems. We want to find an operator Q such that Qlphys>
=0
(VI.4.S)
The operator Q generates gauge transformations, since by definition physical states are is sufficient to project out all the physical states. insensitive to its action. If we
require Q to be a gauge generator fOr all states (physical
and nonphysical), we find the condition:
(VI. 4.6)
(henniticity) . Indeed,
Q is a gauge generator if and only if
0Q < phys I!/I >
=
=0
(VI. 4. 7)
i.e. iff it does not affect observable quantities
(lIP> is a generic
state) . Consistency of (VI.4.5) implies also the crucial condition:
(VI.4.8)
(nilpotency) Two physical states
!phys 1>
and
Iphys 2>
are then gauge equivalent
if
Iphys 1>
= Iphys
2> + Ix>.
Ix> =: Q!tp>
(VI.4.9)
since, in virtue of (VI.4.6) and (VI.4.8). < physlx> = 0
(VI.4.10)
<xlx>=O.
(VI.4.11)
1561 A physical operator A is defined to transform a physical state into another physical state: Alphys 1> .. Iphys 2 >
V Iphys 1> •
(VI.4.12)
QD if At is physical) •
(VI. 4.13)
This implies (=
A gauge operator B transforms a physical state into another physical state of the form Qil/I>: Blphys> :: Qil/I> In particular. operator. Theorem 1.
•
(VI. 4.14)
B is a physical operator, and Q is a (trivial) gauge
every operator G= [Q,C):t is a gauge operator.
The proof is trivial. Theorem 2.
(A,B!:!: is a gauge operator.
Proof: (AB ± BA) Iphys:> .. AQ!l/I> ± BIphys' > ..
.. Qlt4I' >
+
QDll/I:. ± Qli/I">
= Q!l/I'" >
VI.4.3 Construction of Q
The first step is to enlarge the original phase space to include odd Grassmann variables. i.e. the ghosts nA and their conjugated momenta lIS'
satisfying the (symmetric) Poisson bracket couunutations
1562 (VI.4.1S) Suppose now that the commutations (VI.4.1a) have the form
c = constants
C AS
(VI.4.16)
as is the case for gauge theories. The corresponding BRST operator Q is constructed as follows
[1,81 (VI.4.17)
Its nilpotency is due to the Jacobi identities of the structure constants
c'\c
(Exercise:
verify Q2 =0).
Moreover, the operators (VI. 4. 18)
are gauge operators (see Theorem 1 of previous section), and are some· times called "improved" generators.
They close on the same algebra
(VI.4.16) as the 4lA• It is an easy exercise to show that (VI.4.19) \'Ie note at this juncture that all the considerations of this section have
been classical, i.e. using Poisson brackets rather than (anti) commuta· tors. In the quantum theory, however, the commutations (VI.4.16) lIIay develop Schwinger terms, and these will show up as deviations from Q2 =O.
l'I'hen we deal with an infinite number of constraints +A'
as in
the case of the string (+A =Virasoro generators), normal ordering in the ghosts may cancel the anomaly in Q2 for sOllIe critical values of parameters (e.g. the spacetime dimension 0). In that case we have a consistent quantum theory only for those critical values (e.g. D.. 26 for the bosonic string, see Sect. VI.4.5). Theorem: The ghosts nA are gauge generators.
1563 ~:
consider the gauge generator (VI.4.20)
where XA are the gauge fixings of Vl.4.2. Then (VI. 4. 21)
can be inverted to yield (VI. 4.22)
proving the theorem, since ~B are linear combinations of gauge generators. In an appropriate gauge one can therefore eliminate the canonical A variables n, nA• The construction of Q can be generalited to non constant (field dependent) structure functions UCAS in (VI.4.23) In this case the algebra of the infinitesimal transformations generated by the .A t s is ~ (it closes only on the shell 4>A = 0). Indeed defining
F ~ arbitrary function
(VI.4.24)
we find (V1.4.2S) Algebras that close only on-shell do appear in the supergravity theories discussed throughout this book. The interested reader may study their BRST quantitation by using the appropriate generalization of (VI.4.17) (see Ref. [7] for a review on the BRS! operator for open algebra~).
1564 We have now the necessary lore to characterize physical states as defined in (VI.4.3). The incorporation of ghosts in the quantum theory requires an enlarged Fock space, containing ghost and anti ghost excitations. The ghost number operator U is defined as (Vr.4.26)
The physical states are then the BRST invariant states with ghost mnnber U" O. This holds in the case of finite dimensional Lie algebras. For infinite-dimensional Lie algebras, for example the Virasoro algebra, the ghost number operator U contains a normal-ordering constant, so that physical states have actually U# 0 (see later). Since two states differing by QA are gauge eqUivalent, the physical states are given by equivalence classes, where W and ~' belong to the same class if l/I- $' =QA. The equivalence classes of BRSTinvariant states X, for which Qx ,. 0
(VI.4.27)
with ghost number n such that
Ux" nx
(VI.4.28)
are the cohomology classes Hn(G,R) of the Lie algebra G (see Chapter 1.6). Q plays the role of the exterior derivative, an analogy that has deep consequences in string field theory. The BRST-invari>int states X with ghost number U", 0, Le. the states satisfying
Qx If
=0
X A
=0
(VL4.29) (VI.4.30)
1565 are of special interest. In fact. they are by themselves cohomology classes HO(G,R). Indeed, these states cannot be written as QA. since then ). should have U .. ·1 (Q increases the ghost number by 1). U has eigenvalues U=O.1,2 •.•. dim G, at least for dim G
But
X. Q takes the form (VI.4.31)
and the condition QX =0 is equivalent to (VI.4.32) Indeed nA cannot annihilate a state X satisfying (VI.4.29.30). We see therefore that the BRST-invariant states X are G-invariant states that do not contain ghosts. and these states we call physical states. The condition QX= 0 projects out these states. when X has ghost number zero. In the case of infinite-dimensional Lie algebras, there are two caveats. Because of normal ordering in Q (necessary, for example, to ensure its hermiticity), the nilpotency condition Q2 = 0 may develop an anomaly.
Also. normal ordering in U will alter the condition U.. 0
for physical states.
As we will see in Sect. V"I.4.6. for the string
the physical states have U= -1/2.
VI.4.4 The BRST invariant hamiltonian and the Fradkin-Vilkovski theorem Let us suppose that Eq. (VI.4.1b) takes the form
with constant V/
and HO = classical hamiltonian.
BRST-invariant hamiltonian H as follows:
One can construct a
1566 since
[H.Q] " 0 •
(VI.4.35)
Moreover, by introducing a gauge fixing X with ghost number" -1, one can construct a BRST invariant gauge fixed hamiltonian HX: (VI. 4. 36) (VI.4.37)
For example, if we choose X::: lISXB. conditions of (VI.4.2). we have
l
being the gauge fixing
(VI. 4. 38)
Consider now the path-integral
tz
'f tldt (q· ip.· An lIA - (H - [1 x.Q) +
1
Zx
= J Dq DpDn D!!
1
e
1)
Theorem:
Zx
2)
~:
(f'radkin-Vilkovisky); ZX::: ZX"
is ERST-invariant.
The proof of these theorems is not difficult and can be found in Ref. [8]. Theorem 2) states that the transition amplitudes are independ~ of the particular gauge fixing function X. as they shOUld, being physical quantities.
VI.4.5 BRST quantization of string theories VI.4.S.1 The bosonic string The action for the bosonic string is {see, also, Eq. (Vr.6.61))
1567
J
S :: _1_ do dt r-g gaB 0 Xll 21fa'
Cl
(loX P
(VI.4.39)
II
where X~(O.t)
0;
D-dimensional Minkowski coordinates
gaS(a,i) :: metric of the world-sheet
Idet gaB'
g ::
a' :: "Regge 5 lope". a'
has the dimensions of an area.
The variational equations are oS - - : : 0 ....
ogaB
aCtxiJ
1 doX - p
II
2
g~o up
yo g
aYxII a..,xjJ ::
(VI. 4. 39a)
0
\J
(VI. 4. 39b)
Eq. (VI.4.39b) is the propagation equation for XiJ(a.i), whereas Eq. (VI.4.39a) is a constraint, since the derivatives of gaB do not appear in the action (VI.4.39). We can solve Eq. (VI.4.39a) by taking ll 0SX ' the square root of its detel'lllinant. Defining GaB:: lJ G:: Idet GaB I, we have
ari
GaB:: G ::
i
t
gaB gYO
g
(gYo
ayx~ ~oXjJ
allJ coX)
and substituting into Eq. (VI.4.39) yields the Nambu action:
(with
iJ..i::.!. XlJ x'jJ::.!. XiJ ) aT'
spanned by the string.
00
which is the area of the world-sheet
Consider now the Lagrangian: (VI.4.40)
The corresponding primary (first-class) constraints are given by:
(VI.4.41)
I'.'here p "0 L/ oXlJ • The hamiltonian II
HO ::
I
PlJ ill da - !! = 0
(VI. 4. 42)
is itself a primary (first-class) constraint generating T-reparametriz2tions. The canonical variables Xll, Pv satisfy the (equal time) Poisson brackets: (VI.4.43)
From (VI.4.41). one arrives at the constraint algebra (VI.4.44a)
(VI.4.44b) Following the prescription of Sect. VI.4.3. we construct now the BRST operator for the bosonic string:
=:
=:
Jda[L I'}+ +L n-] _ 1 fdadal [IT (0) +IT (0 1 )]0 0(0 -o')n+(a)rtco') +
12 Jdada ' [n
2
w
(a) H w
= JdoCL+O+ + L_o-)
-
+
(0 1 )]3 Q(a 0
+
...
a
-O')T]-(O)O-CO')
Jda[1T+(Oan+)n+
-11' Joan-)n-]
(VI. 4. 45)
1569 ~
where the ghosts n and antighosts
{n(a;r), ~((1I,T)}
satisfY
= tHo-a') .
(VI.4.46)
We now choose the gauge fixing ("conformal gauge"):
(VI. 4.47)
so as to obtain the BRST -invariant gauge fixed hamiltonian (see (VI. 4.36)) :
HX
=
HO
+
{X,Q}+ =
=' /dO(L+ + L)
+
/dO[1T+(}on+
-~ _a()"n-]
(VI. 4. 48)
Notice that the ghost Lagrangian is then 9'(ghost} = I(1f+(}Tn+ +~_a·ll-)do =
J(~+(}()"n+ -If_
I[
r. +
(VI. 4. 49)
i.e. the same one would obtain from ordinary path-integral-quantization (cf. Ref. [9]). In the conformal gauge, the equations of motion are
xP = {xP,
HX} '" np~ .. "X-x"=OX=O
pI! = {pIJ, HX} ...
(VI. 4. SOa)
~ (x~)"
= {+ n, HX } =
;; a n+ -
=0
(VI. 4. SOb)
(VI.4. SOc)
(VI. 4. SOd)
1570
all + -
=0
a• L+ = a+L =0
(VI.4.50e)
•
(VI. 4. 50f)
For closed strings, Eqs. (VJ.4.S0) imply the mode expansions:
co
n+ .. tL cn e -in(T+o) -co co
-
n "
-In(T-o)
'"L b
-in(T+o)
-00
1T" +
1T
-
•
~
t
L
cn e
n e
-CIQ
= '"I
.in(T-.,)
b~
n -co
e
co
L .. +
L =
-
•
I
L e-1n(T+O)
-00
n
-GO
n
rL
e-in(T-a)
The commutations (VI.4.43) and (VI.4.46) give: (VI. 4.51a) (VI.4. SIb)
{cn'
b} m + .. 0n+m. o·
(VI. 4. SIc)
After expressing Ln in terms of x~ modes (cf. Eq. (VI.4.41»:
r Xllnom Xlim
GO
L .. -
n
.!.2
..,.
(VI. 4. 52)
1571
we find the Virasoro algebra (VI. 4 . 53)
To quantize the theory, we now replace the Poisson brackets {}, { 1+ by commutators and anti commutators respectively. Moreover, it is necessary to introduce normal ordering in the infinite sums on modes (Vr.4.52). The quantum algebra of L becomes then n
ILn ,
L J
m
= (m - n) Lm+n + .-£. n (n 2 - 1) <5 12 m+n, 0
(VI. 4. 54)
with c" D (dimension of target space-time). In terms of the Fourier modes, the normal ordered, BRST operator (VI.4.47) becomes co
Q"
l -co
L
c -m m
~ l
(m-n)
-co
c c
b
-m -n m+n
(VI. 4. 55)
with a = normal ordering constant. The ghost-number operator is co
u"
L
-co
(VI. 4. 56)
c b
-m m
For closed strings we should add the left-moving contributions to Q and U. Now, we know that Q2=O holds classically, i.e. when using Poisson brackets and considering b, c as being grassmann numbers. However, when one replaces the Poisson brackets by (anti)commutators and introduces normal ordering in the sums on modes, the nilpotency of Q is not ensured any more. In fact, we find (VI. 4. 57)
so that Q2 " 0 ~ D " 26,
a = 1 •
(VI. 4. 58)
1572 Let us now discuss the physical states of the bosonic string. nomal ordering of U that ensures its hem ticity is
The
co
U=
I (Coho -boco) nfl (c.nbn +
(VI.4.S9)
-b_ncn) •
The ghost and antighost zero modes cO' bO commute with the hamiltonian (VI. 4.48). The gl'Otmd state is therefore a representation space for the operators
cO' boo satisfying (VI.4.60)
The irreducible representation of the algebra defined by (VI. 4.60) has dimension 2. and we denote its basis vectors by
1t>
and
1~>.
We can
choose these as follows: (VI.4.61) so that we must have
(VI.4.62) The ghost numbers of I~>o
1+> are
ul*> .. - .!2 1*> ult>
= .!.2 It>
(V1.4.63)
since
n 1-1-> .. cn [.r> .. bn1+>
b
i.e.
(I~>.
It»
= cit> n
'" ()
Cn > O}
(VI.4.64)
is a ground state annihilated by the destruction
operators b. c .(n >0).
n
n
Physical states do not contain ghost excitations and we expect 0
therefore the corresponding Fock space to decompose as
1573
Ix> 1-1->
(VI.4.6Sa)
Ix> It>
{Vr.4.65b}
or
i.e. as a tensor product on which the (anti)ghost operators act on the second factor. Only the first of these choices, with ghost number U .. -1/2, is really what we call a physical state. Indeed the action of Q on (VI.4.6S) is given by (VI.4.66a)
Qlx> It> ..
[ln>O
C
LJ -n n
Ix> It> •
(VI.4.66b)
Thus only in the first case the condition Qlx> /-1-> =0 reproduces all the physical state conditions (LO-1) Iphys >.. 0, Ln>olphys >.. O. We conclude that the physical states of the bosonic string are BRST cohomology classes of ghost number -1/2.
VI.4.5.2
The BRST charge in complex variables
In the conformal gauge (VI.4.47), the bosonic string becomes a conformal theory. Going over to complex coordinates z
= exp(t i- iO')
z = exp(t - iO')
(VI.4.67)
we see that Eqs. (VI.4.50f) imply analyticity of the stress energy tensor L(z), renamed T(z) in the following.
We recall from (VI.3.30) that the real commutation relations (VI.4.44a) are equivalent to the Dirac brackets:
1574 {T(z), T(w)}
D
=.1!.1.!L + dT(w) (z_w)2
•
z-w
(VI.4.68)
One retrieves the Virasoro commutations (VI.4.S3). after defining L n
f
= ~ zn+l C 21Ti
T(z)
(VI.4.69)
where the closed curve C goes around the origin once. All the results of the previous section can be recast in this language. In particular. the ghost action corresponding to (VI.4.49) becomes (see also Eq. (VI.8.131) and Sect. VI.8.4 where b-c systems are treated in general)
S(ghost )
= - l..I[-2bdC+Cdb] 21r
Adz
(VI.4.70)
yielding the equations of motion:
a_z c .. a_z b
.. 0
(VI.4.71)
implying that b and c are analytic fields. Hence the ghost system is a conformal theory. The canonical commutations (VI.4.46) are replaced by {b(z). c(wH D '" _1_ •
z-w
(V1.4.72)
The ghost stress energy tensor, obtained by varying (VI.4.70) with respect to the metric. is T(gh)(Z) .. c db - 2(ac) b •
(VI.4.73)
Using the basic anticommutator (VI.4.72), we find [ T( h) (z). T( h) (W)] ,,_2_ T( h) (z) + _1_ aTC h) (z) • g g D (z _ w)2 g z -w g
(VI.4.74)
1575
Quantization in this formalism means to replace Dirac brackets with operator products. The commutations (VI.4.68) and (VI.4.74) become:
0 1 ~-2 (_w)4 z
I{z ) T(w);;; -
T( h)(z) g
Te gh)(w)
2T(w)
aT(w)
regular tel'llls
+ --- + -- + (~_)2 z-w ~ 'II
-13
2T(gh)(w)
,. - - - . . .
(z_w)4
(z-w)2
(VI.4.75)
aT(gh) ('II) +
z~w
...
regular terms (VI. 4.76)
where the coefficients of the most singular terms in the r.h.s. are equal to half the anomaly of the corresponding system. Using (VI.4.69), it is straightforward to retrieve the quantum Virasoro algebras (VI.4.S4) corresponding to the matter system (c(matt er )" D) and the ghost. system (c{gh) ,,-26) respectively. We see from Eqs. (VI.4.75, 76) that the total anomaly of the matter ghost systems, c(matter) when D,.26.
+ C (gh)'
cancels
The BRST charge QBRST is defined as follows: (VI .4.77) with j BRST(z) "
c (Tmatter(Z)
" - 1. c axax ... 2
+
iT (gh) (z) ) "
bc{
(VI. 4. 78)
The reader can verify that (VI.4.77) indeed coincides with the BRST charge constructed in the real fOl'lllalism of the previous section. The action of QSRST on a field fez)
is defined by (VI. 4. 79)
and one finds, by using operator products to evaluate the contour integrals,
[QBRST'
x~l
= c axP
1576
= T(matter)
+T
(VI. 4. 80)
(gh)
Q~RST=O is equivalent to TCmatter) +T(gh) closing on the confol:roal algebra (V1.4.SS) without anomaly. Hence Q2 =0 * 0 =26. BRST
VI.4.S.S The NSR superstring
In this subsection we discuss the ghosts and the BRSI charge for the NSR superstring. We recall the quantum super-Virasoro algebra, in terms of O.P.E. (VI.S.IB),
T(z) Tew) __
~
3
T(z) G(w)
Gez) G(w)
1
2T(w)
G(w) (z _w)2
aG(w) z- w
aT(w)
--- + --- + -- + (4 _w)4 (z _w)2 ~- w
2
--- + -- +
2
reg.
reg.
1 2T(w) = -2 c - - + - - + reg. 3
(z _ w)3
(VI. 4.81)
z- w
where the stress-energy tensor and the supercurrent are given by (cf. (VI. 3.184»)
i
T(z) = axax - - 1/1 a 1/1 2
G(z) ,.
1/1
ax .
(VI. 4.82)
o
3
The conformal anomaly c(matter) is c( matter ) '" Cx+ C1/1 ,. D + -2 = -D 2' P the bosonic matter x contributing D and the fermions 1/1 contributing !o (cf. (VI. 3. 18B». 2
Expanding T(z) and G(z) in Laurent modes: I;'
T(z) ,. l. Ln
Z
-n
1577
G(z) = ~ G
t. n+~-(w/2)
z-(n+2-(w/2»
(VI. 4. 83)
the O.P.E. (VI.4.81) yield the commutation relations below 1)
W"
(NS superconfol'lllal algebra):
0
[L • L] ... (m -n)L
m n
{G
m+~'
ti)
n+m
G
n+~
+
..£.. 12
(m 3 -m)6
m+n, 0
2 +m)6 n+m+l +£(m 3 m+n+l,O
}=2L
(VI.4.84)
w" 1 (R superconformal algebra):
[L , L ] .. (11\ - n) L
n+m
m n
+
..£.. 12
(m 3 - m)6
m+n, 0
= (-12 m -n)Gm+n (VI. 4. 85)
The corresponding BRST charge is
. -
~
[12 n . !.2
~ L
.e
(, n,S
n,s
w. e -s-~(l-w) en+s+~(l-w) cn ..
(1- )] . -
• -s-~(l-w)
e
n+s+~(l-w)
c • - CleW) c
n•
0
(VI.4.86)
where the ghost fields, having the same moding as the stress-energy tensor, satisfy
c
[cm' n1+ 6 - n+m,O
1578 (VI. 4. 87)
and the superghost5, baving the same moding as the supercurrent, satisfy the commutations
rem~(l-w)'
en+~(l-w) J '" 6n+m+l-w.O .
(VI.4.88)
In order to construct the BRST current for the superconformal algebra (VI.4.81), we need the stress-energy tensor of the superconformal ghosts: T(gh) .. -
~yal3
+
t Bay
+ cab + 2b(ac)
(VI. 4. 89)
where Y. 13. e, b have the Laurent expansions
~
e(z) .. L em z
-m+l
bez) .. L~ e- z -m-2 m
The ghost supercurrent is
G(gh) .. - caB
1
+ -
2
3 yb - -2 (acJB
(VI.4.90)
The reader can verify that -
1
L(gh)n ;: 21ri _ 1.
G(gh)n ;: 2ni
f I
n+1 z T(gh) (z)
n+1
j z
( )
G(gh) Z
(VI. 4. 91)
(VI.4.92)
1579 do indeed coincide with the ghost part of tbe "improved" generators .tn' lin defined by (VI. 4. 93) (VI. 4. 94)
with QBRST given in terms of mode operators in (Vr.4.86)*. current is
jBRST" c[Tmatter(Z) T
+
tT(gh)(Z)]
Y[Gmatter(z) +
t
The BRST
+
(VI.4.9S)
G(gh)l
and the QSRST charge is given by:
(VI. 4.96)
Again the reader should verify that QBRST given in (VI.4.96) is equal to (VI. 4. 86). The nilpotency of QSRST implies that the total stress.energy tensor T .. T (matter) + T (gh) and the total supercurrent G" G(matter) T G(gb) close on the superconformal algebra (VI.4.81) without anomaly. Let us compute the algebra of T(gh) .. T(be) + T (By)
and G(gh) "
G(be) + G(By):
* This is actually the way we have derived T(gh) find
L(gh)n' G(gh)n
and G(gh){Z)
and G(gh): we first
from (VI.4.93, 94). and then construct T(gh)(z)
whose Laurent moments are
L(gh)n
and G(gh)n'
1580 (-26 TIl) 1 2T (gh) (w) aT (gh) (w) T) 2 --- + + + reg. (gh) (z 1(gn) (w) ... (z-w)4
(z-w)2
z-w
(VI.4.97a)
3 G(&h) (1)1)
T(gh) (z) G(gh) (w) ..
'2
(z _ w)2
oG(gh){w) z _W
T
g
1
2T(gh)(w)
3
(z-w)3
z-w
The ghost superconfomal anomaly c(gh)
c egh ) = c(bc)
+
c(Sy)
a
(VI. 4. 97b)
reg.
2
G( h) (z) G( h) (w) .. - (-26 + 11) - - +
g
+
+
reg.
(VI. 4.97c)
is therefore
(VI. 4.98)
-26 + 11 = -IS .
The algebra of the total stress-energy tensor and supercurrent closes as in (VI.4.81) without central charge if the total superconformal anomaly
c" c(matter) vanishes. 1. e.
fOT
+
c(gh) • (D
+
tD)
+
(-26
+
11)
(VI. 4.99)
D=10.
Finally. from (VI.4.89). one deduces the ghost action: S (gh)
=-
~
f(-
2b dc - c db) " e+
- .!.. I(- ~2 Bd'V + !2 ydB) '" 21r
eT
(VI. 4. 100)
As already stated the ghost b-c system and the superghost S-y system correspond to two special cases of conformal field theories of the b-ctype described, in general terms, in Section VI.S.4. The reader is referred to that section for further informations.
1581
References quoted in Chapter VI.4
[1] [2] [3] [41 [5] [6] [7] [S]
[9}
C. Beechi, A. Rouet and R. Stora, Phys. Lett. 52B (1974) 344; Ann. Phys. 98 (1976) 287. I.V. Tyupin, Lebedev preprint FIAN No. 39 (in Russian, unpublished). P.A.M. Dirac, Lectures on quantum mechanics, Yeshiva Lectures (1964). A. Hanson, T. Regge and C. Teitelboim, Constrained Hamiltonian Systems, Contrib. Centro Linceo Scienze Mat. N. 22, Rome (1976). E.e.G. Sudarshan and M. Mukunda, "Classical Oynamics - a modern perspective", Wiley, New York (1974) pp. 78-107. L. Castellani, Ann. of Phys. 143 (1982) 357. M. Henneaux, Phys. Rep. 126 (1985) 1. E.S. Fradkin and G.A. Vilkovlski, Phys. Lett. 55B (1975) 224; L.A. Batalin and G.A. Vilkoviski, Phys. Lett. 69B (1977) 309; E.S. Fradkin and T.E. Fradkina, Phys. Lett. 72B (1978) 343; T. Kugo and I. Ojima, Suppl. Progr. Theor. Phys. 66 (1979) 1. M. Kato and K. Ogawa, Nucl. Phys. B212 (1983) 443; S. Hwang, Phys. Rev. 028 (1983) 2614.
1582 OlAPTER VI. 5
Quantum Determination of the Target Manifold and Kac-Moody Algebras
VI.S.l
Introduction
In Chapter VI.3 the classical action of heterotic superstrings was determined and it was found to be given by Eq. (VI.3.1l6). Under the condition that the target manifold Mt arget is of the type (VI.3.62, 63) and that we compactify the superstring on a classical superconformal theory one has the identifications (VI.3.l37), and the torsion field is given by Eqs. (VI.3.138). With these choices, the action S reduces to the sum (VI.3.64) corresponding to a linear superposition of different classical superconformal theories which can be independently quantized. The freedoms in the choice of Murge t left by our classical considerations were listed at the end of Section VI.3.4. For the reader's convenience let us rewrite this list: i) ii)
choice of the space-time dimension DMink • choice of the simple groups Gi
and of their "levels" ki .
1583 iii) choice of the number of heterotic fermions Nhet , iv)
choice of the homotopy group B c G.r
0
Gr-
The purpose of the present chapter is to show how these classical freedoms are fixed by quantum consistency conditions: The first three items in the above list are related to the con~ formal anomaly, i.e. to the central charge of the Virasoro algebra. Requiring the vanishing of the BRST charge 2
QBRST ;;; 0
(VI.5.1)
discussed at length in the previous chapter, we will find that there is an upper bound on the dimensions of Minkowski space: 0Mink S 10 •
(VI.5.2)
Furthermore, for each choice of DMink in the range (VI. 5. 3) there is a finite number of available choices of Gr (see Eq. (VI.3.63» given by suitable products of simple groups G. with suitable levels 1 ki . For each chOice of Gr one has an appropriate choice of the integer number Nhet • The fourth item in the list of freedoms, that is, the appropriate choice of the homotopy group B c ~ ® GT (see Section VI.3.l for a preliminary discussion of this topic) is related to a different consistency requirement: the existence of target space fermions and, eventually. of target space supersymmetry. Mathematically the choice of a nontrivial S corresponds to a twist of the Kac-Moody algebra generated by the currents (VI.3.156). Henceforth we will study the representation theorY of twisted Kat-Moody algebras and the dependence of the Virasoro coboundary (see Eq. (VI.3.34)) on the twist. ~fassless target fermions exist for few of
1584
the available target groups suitablY twisted. Eventually, if we require chiral representations for such massless fermions, then the choice of Uy is unique in every even dimension DMink S 10. We find the following answer: * D~fink " 10
Gr"
DMink " 8
Gr = SU(2)
(VI.S.4b)
D:.l ink " 6
GT .. SU(2) xSU(2)
(VI.S.4c)
Gr " SU(2) "SU(2) XSU(2)
(VI. 5.4d)
Gr"
(Vr.S.4e)
DMink
=4
DMink " 2
(n.5.4a)
1
SU(2) "SU(2) xSU(2) "SU(2)
Furthermore for each SU(2)i appearing in 8i can be chosen in two ways:
Gr
the first homotopy group
(VI.S.S)
leading to a certain number of possibilities for the full homotopy group (VI.S.6)
The classification of the chiral superstring models is then reduced to the classification of the homomorphisms (VI.3.1o) between the fundamental group of the Riemann surface and the fundamental group of the * Actually as already stated in Chapter VI.l a recent result by Bouwknegt and Ceresole shows that changing the normal ordering prescription a few more solutions exist be~ides those displayed in Eqs. (VI.S.4).
1585
target space. This is what is done by means of the study of modular invariance, addressed in Chapter VI.7. In the present chapter we deal with the derivation of Eqs. (VI.S.4) and (VI.5.S). VI.S.2 The BRST-charge: cancellation of the conformal anomaly, boundary conditions and intercepts. As stated by Eq. (VI.3.64) the heterotic string theory is the direct sum of several independent superconformal field theories which interact with each other only through the 2-dimensional background fields. Hence, in the superconformal gauge these theories appear fully decoupled. Correspondingly the complete quantum stress-energy tensors and the complete quantum supercurrent are given by the quantum analogues of Eqs. (VI. 3.149) : n
T(z)
= T(Mink)(Z)
+
.r 1 T(G.
1=
k.}(Z)
(VI. 5. 6a)
l' 1
(VI,5.6b) n
G(z) ; G(Mink)(Z)
+
.Il G(G.,k.}(Z) 1; 1 1
(VI.S.6c)
The addends with the suffix (G.,k.) were defined in Chapter VI.3. As 1 1 stated many times, the addends with the suffix (Mink) can be easily obtained from the above ones by taking the limit where the group G becomes abelian (fABC ~ 0). Let us see the details of this construction which was just sketched in Eq. (VI.3.137a). for Simplicity we set DMink
=D
(VI.S.7)
and as group G we choose T(D). where reD) is the D-dimensional group
1586 of translations in D-dimensional Mlnkowski space; its commuting genera. tors are called tlJ' (U- O,l •••• ,l)...l). The signature is (-,1",+,+, ... ,+).
An element g(z,z) e reD) can be written as follows in terms of the target space coordinates: g(z,z) .. exp(tu XIJ(z,z})
(VI. 5. 8)
and we find
g-1 dg" dgg -1 .. dXIJt
(VI. 5.9)
I.!
The I-form dXll is the analogue of both Eqs. (V1.3.67).
nA
and QA defined in
Its superpartner is a fermion field f(z,z)
and the
analogues of Eqs. (VI.3.71. 72. 74) read as follows: (VI. 5.10a) DXI.! .. D
,IJe+ + D- -fe - - .!.2 a+xll I;
(VI.5.l0b)
+
In the case of an abelian group the Wess-Zumino term is zero and
Hence. the value of the normalization constant k is irrelevant (the factor k/(k +Cv)" 1 for all values of k).
So for later convenience
we arbitrarily choose k - 2 and we iJDJDediately obtain setting fINP - 0 in Sq. (VI. 3. 93). The result is
seD)
(Mink)
=
~ J[(dXU - ~~)(nUet + nl.!e-) 411 ++ 2iw\J~ll
where we have used
A
e+
+
fdxlJ
A
S~~nk)
by
+
~ + n~TI~e+
A
e-]
(VI. 5.11)
n~ in place of nCo
The analogues of the Kac-Moody currents are the momentum fields: (VI.5.12a)
1587 ik
~"
P'-(z) .. - -
2
nl.l .. - i a xlJ -
-
(VI.S.12b)
which, upon quantization, obey the abelian limit of the OPE (VI.3.161), that is, \.1\1 pJl(z)P"(w) .. _n__ (z _w)2
-t
reg.
(VI. 5.13a)
(VI.5.13b)
p\.l(i)P" (w)
1J"V .. _11_-2 +
(z
The OPE of the
-w)
reg.
(VI.5.13C)
1Jf fermions is gi ven by the analogue of Eq.
(VI. 3.183) (with k:: 2) :
(VI. 5. 14)
Finally the stress-energy tensors and the supercurrent have identical expressions in the classical and quantum case, due to k/k + ~ "I, and are given by: (VI.S.lS)
a I
(-)
(Mink) z ..
2'1 p-\.I (z-)-pPc-) z
r7< i1r /4 _.u P G(M1nk)(:z.) .. r 2e 'IT (z)P (:z.)
(VI. 5 .16)
(VI.S.l7)
They fulfill the OPE (Vl.3.189) with the following values of c: c(M1nk) .. D + c(Mink) .. D •
1
3
2 D =2 D
(VI.S.18) (VI.S.19)
1588 Finally we have the addends with the suffix (het). These are the contributions of the Nbet-heterotic fermions, which, by definition, are right-handed Majorana-weyl spinors. Recalling Eq. (VI.3.116) and setting the gauge field AaB to zero we see that the heterotic fermion action is given by
f
1 2i ~;:»'~ Phi P "e S(het) "4;
(VI.S.20)
where. to avoid confusions with later uses of the Greek letters, we have replaced a + p. Recalling also Eqs. (VI.3.1l4) and (VI.3.lIS). in the absence of background gauge fie Ids, we have (VI.S.2I),
The OPE of the corresponding quantum fields is (VI.S.22)
Calculating the stress·energy tensors one finds (VI.5.23) (VI.S.24)
satisfy the superconformal algebra (VI.3.189) with the following values of the central charge:
~nich
(VI.S.2S) ~het_!N
c
- 2 het
(VI. S. 26)
1589
Having defined the building blocks of our theory the next question is: which are the allowed combinations leading to a consistent superstring II\Odel? In other words we would like to know, in every dimension 4 S D S 10, which choices of groups G1 and levels ki are permitted and how many heterotic fermions are required. As anticipated in the introduction to this chapter, the anSlo,'er is provided by the nilpotency of the BRST-charge QBRST which requires cancellation between the conformal anomaly (= central charge) of the ghost-superghost system and that of the matter system (see Chapter VI.4). Indeed, one finds the following implication: Q;RST = 0 ~ _cghost _ csghost
= cMink
+
n
I
= 26
- 11 =
c(G.,k.)
i"l
1
(VI.S.27a)
1
.... _cghost = 26
= cMink
n
+
~ c(G. ,k.) + chet i=1 1 1
(VI.S.27b)
Inserting Eqs. (VI.3.190), (VI.S.18,19) and (VI.5.2S,26) into (VI.S.27) and recalling that single-valuedness of the Wess-Zumino term (or equivalently unitarity of the Kac-~body representations) implies k./~~ e Z (w.1 being the longest root of G.), we see that Eqs. 1 1 1 (VI.S.27) are a system of Diophantine equations: IS
3
= -2 0 + In
26 = 0
(k.
1
'-1 k·1 1-
+
n (
I
+
Cvi
2
(VI .5. 28a)
G. 1
k.) dim G. 1
. 1 k· + Cv 1 i
1=
1) dim
+-
1
+
1 -N h 2
e
t
(VI. 5.28b)
whose complete solution for the case d =4 is displayed in the first two columns of Tables VI.S.I, II, III. In this table much more information is supplied which the reader is requested to disregard for the
1590
time being. Furthermore the normalizations of Cv and k are those explained in the next section. The point we want to streSS here is that the quantum consistency condition Q~RST=O implies more constraints besides Eqs. (VI.5.27). Indeed it fixes the values of the intercepts a and a which appear in the mass-shell equations: (LO - a) Iphys > ,. 0
(VI. S. 29a)
(LO - u) Iphys > = 0
(VI. S. 29b)
LO and Lo appearing in Eqs. (VI.5.29) are defined as the zero modes in the Laurent expansion of the full stress-energy tensors of the matter system: T(z) =
In 2 -zn+2
+'"
(VI. 5. 30a)
-00
~ _
T(z) =
+00
In
L --n+2
-co
(VI. S. 30b)
z
Since the mass-spectrum of the string is read off from Eqs. (VI.S.29), the values of a and a are clearly crucial in determining how many and which type of massless excitations we might construct. Which of them do actually appear in the string spectrum and are not projected out by generalized GSO projectors is decided later by modular invariance of the I-loop amplitudes (see Chapter VI.7). It is therefore of primary importance to make a preliminary study of the int~rcepts and decide for which of the fifteen solutions found in Tables I, II and IIr massless target space ferrnions can exist. The restriction of our attention to such particular solutions can be justified in two ways: i) Common experience tells us that fermions do indeed exist in our low energy world. ii) All indications support the conjecture that target space supersymmetry is necessary to make
1591
superstring theory fully consistent and in particular, finite as a quantum theory. On the other hand, space-time SUSY requires massless gravitinos which are fermion states. Thus motivated towards the study of the intercepts we remark the following. While the conformal anomaly c is a local property of the 2-dimensional field theory so that it depends only on the number and type of fields we consider, the intercepts, which are associated with the trace anomaly, are a manifestation of a global property. In other words, they depend not only on the type of fields we consider but also on their boundary conditions on the world-sheet. This has a series of implications: i) In order to discuss boundary conditions we can no longer restrict our attention to the covering space of the compactified manifold Mconpact' namely, to the target group GT, but we must also specifY the homotopy group ~l(Mcompact)' Indeed, if Mat contains camp c non contractible loops. the string can wrap around them and create new soliton states which, in particular, can be massless fermions. In the case of superstrings propagating on Mcompact whose covering space is a group-manifold GT, it appears that the massless fermionic states are precisely solitons of this type. More specifically we have (VI.S.31)
where B c ~ & GT is some discrete. abelian subgroup of G.r & Gr that will be determined by boundary conditions together with modular invarianCe, We assume in this section that the world-sheet of the closed string is diffeomorphic to a cylinder, represented by the complex plane z with the origin removed. In this case the homology basis is formed by a circle wrapping the origin and the most general boundary condition one can impose on a WZW field is the following (VI.5.32)
1592
where (b,b) e B. In other words the actual target manifold Nt arge t = c;,JB is the set of equivalence classes of GT group elements under the relation: g1'" iz iff g1" bg2 b. The elements of the group B are pairs (b,b) of elements of <>r. If B is such that either b Or b is always the identity element, then Mtarget is an ordinary coset manifold of <>r with respect to a discrete subgroup B c~. As such, it is a smooth manifold. If, on the other hand, both b and b are non trivial elements, then Mtarget is a singular variety. Indeed in this case, the action of B on ~ is not free from fixed points. Now let (y,y) e B be a generator of the homotopy group. From Eqs. (VI.5.32) and (VI.3.67) we obtain (VI.5.33a) (VI. 5. 33b)
so that, recalling Eqs. (VI.3.156), we find (VI.S.34a) (VI.S.34b) where rBA(cr-l)BA) is the matrix representing y(y-l) in the adjoint representation of <>r:
B 'Y -1 t Y "
rBA t A •
(VI. S.3S)
The matrix r decides the type of moding of the ~ac-Moody generators (see Eqs. (VI.l.IS8» and will playa very important role in determining the fermionic mass-spectrum. Here we note that the non-abelian structure of the group ~ induces a natural asymmetry between the left-moving and the right-moving Kac-Moody currents. The asymmetry corresponds to the possibility of choosing y and y independently. Each generator 'Y singles out a cyclic subgroup:
1593 (VI. 5. 36)
where NeZ is the first power of y for which N Y
=1
(VLS.37)
•
The shift in the Kac-Moody current moding will not be lIN, however. Indeed, let N5 N be the first power of y for which yN belongs to the center of GT: y
N e Z def = center of G1
(VI. 5.38)
Then, since all of Z goes into the identity element of the adjoint representation, we find (f)N
=1
,
(VLS.39)
which implies that the eigenvalues of f
N-l N
are
exp(2~ifiw),
with
(VI. 5. 40)
These are the frequency shifts which will appear in the Kat-Moody current moding. They will enter in the calculation of the intercepts and hence play a fundamental role in selecting among the fifteen distinct solutions of Tables I, II and III those which admit massless space-time fermions in their spectrum. To sholq this we must first resume our general discussion of the BRST charge and of the relation between boundary conditions and intercepts. Generally speaking, while considering operator product expansions we do not feel the boundary conditions since the latter affect only the regular parts we disregard. To probe them we must revert to the mode expansions. For instance, from the OPE of Eq. (VI.3.189), which contains only one C-number term (the central charge c), by inserting Eqs. (VI.5.30) we obtain the Virasoro algebra:
1594
[L,L]"'(m~n)L m n n+m +lc2(m3~m)o m+n, 0+2mMn+m, 0
(VI. 5. 41)
which involves two C-numbers: the two-cocycle c and the coboundary b. The reason why b is called a coboundary is that it can be eliminated through a redefinition of the generator LO:
c, instead, is a cocycle because no such redefinition exists by means of which we can eliminate it. Eq. (VI.5.41) is identical with Eq. (VI.3.34) where the notion of coboundary was anticipated. Nevertheless, the coboundary b is physically significant. Indeed, the definition of LO is uniquely fixed for every conformal field by normal ordering and cannot be changed at will. With this understanding each type of conformal field has its own proper value of the cocycle c and of the coboundary b. The coboundary b depends on the boundary conditions, while the cocycle c does not. The ghosts and superghosts make no exception to the rule. Then the nilpotency of the BRST-charge is achieved if and only if a) the cocycle of the ghost and superghosts cancels that of the matter fields (see Eqs. (VI.5.22)) b) the intercepts a and ~ appearing in Eqs. (VI.4.19) are given by
a '"
~ bghost _ bsghost _ bMink -
Q = ~ bghost _ bMink _
r
i .. l
I beG.,k.) ,
i,,1
beG.,k.) • 1
1
(VI. 5.42a)
1
(VI. 5. 42b)
1
In order to discuss Eq. (VI.S.42) we begin by observing that the operator product expansions (VI.3.189) correspond to two different superconformal algebras, the Neveu-Schwarz (NS) and the Ramond (R) algebra, depending on which boundary conditions are imposed on the supercurrent G(z). Introducing a number III whose values are III "
{
0, for NS fermions 1, for R fermions
(VI. 5.43)
1595 we can write the boundary conditions on
G(z)
in the following way: (VI. 5.44)
Eq. (VI.5.44) leads to the mode-expansion below: '" G
I
G(Z)"
n~-w/2.
(VI. 5.45)
n" .... zn+2-{fJ/2
Inserting Eq. (VI.5.4S) into Eq. (VI.3.l89) we find the two superconformal algebras: NS superconformal Algebra
A)
[Lm, Lnl .. (m-n)Ln+m +
~2
(Ill;: 0)
(m 3 -m)°m+n,o +
+ 2mb
(Vl.S.46a)
6
NS n+m,O
ILm' {G
Gn+ltl ;;
m+~'
(t m- n - t)Gm+n+~
G} ;; 2 L n+~
n+m+l
+
.£.3
(VI.5.46b)
(m2 + m)o
m+n+l,O
+
(VI. S.46c)
B)
R superconformal
Algebra Cw" 1)
+
[L • G ] " (-21m- n)G
m n
D\+n
2mb 0
R n+m,O
(vr .5.47a) (VI.S.47b) (VI.5.47c)
1596
The ghost fields have the same moding as the stress-energy tensor. 50 they are always integer moded independently of the boundary conditions:
{cm, cn}
= 0n.m, 0'
{cm• cn} = {cm, cn} = 0 .
(VI. 5.48)
On the other hand the superghosts have the same moding as the supercurrent so that they are integer or half-integer moded depending on the boundary condition: (VLS.49a)
(VI.S.49b) In these conventions the BRST-charges take the following form (see Chapter VI.4, Eq. (VI.4.86»):
Q
BR5T
=
(c
i' L
n=-oo
- -1 2
I r,s
-n Ln
e
G
-n-~(l-w) n+~(l-w)
(r - 5): C c c : -r-s r s
rl n n:s lZ
+ i'
+
+
.!.2
(1- w)]:
) -
+
e-s-~(l-w) en+s+~(l-w) cn'.
- l:
-
(VI. S. 50 a)
n,s
(r-s):c
cc -r-s r s
(VI. 5. SOb)
and they are nilpotent if and only if Eqs. (VI.S.27) and (Vr.5.42) hold true. The cocycles and coboundaries of the ghost and superghost Virasoro algebras have the following values: cghost
- -1, = -26 , bghost -
(VLS .Sla)
1597
cghost = -26 csghost ;; II
. ". ,
b~ghost
-1
bsghost"
1 _~ . 2
(VI.S.Slb) 8
(Vl.S.Slc)
as one can easily check by explicit verification of (VI.S.41) using the definitions ghost Lm
=I
~ghost
= l.\'
Lm
n
-
(m - n)·• cm+ncon'•
(m - n):
n
sghost
Lm
= {.\' [12" m n
(VI.S.S2a)
c-n+mc-n : 1
1-
n - '2 (1 - fIl) ; em+n+~(l_fIl)e -n-~(l-fIl): (VI.S.S2b)
In this way the calculation of the intercepts is entirely reduced to the calculation of the coboundaries b for the matter fields. These numbers depend on the boundary conditions imposed on all the fields entering our theory, namely, P~(z), pP(z), ~~(z). JAez). jA ei ). AA(z) and ;p(z). World-sheet supersymmetry gives constraints on the available choices for these conditions, which must be consistent with Eq. (VI.S.44). Since the translation group is abelian, all its discrete subgroups are normal and we necessarily have (see Eqs. (VI.S.33» (VI.S.S3a) (VI. S.S3b) Then in order that the Minkowski contribution eVI.S.1Sc) to the full supercurrent obeys the boundary condition (Vl.S.44) we must have _LU
!jT
2ri
(z e
11111)"
)" e
WI' (z)
•
(VI.S.S4)
This shows that the world-sheet fermions with space-time indices have always the same boundary conditions as the superghosts. Eqs. (V1.5.S3)
1598 and (VI.5.54) give rise to the following mode expansions: (VI.S.SSaJ (V1.S.55b)
(VI.5.55c) where the modes obey the canonical commutations [ XiJ
i.,)1 nl1\1m6n+m,O
m' n •
(VI. 5.56a) (VI.S.S6b) (VI. 5. 56c)
If we normal order the Minkowski contribution to the stress-energy tensors.with respect to these modes, we obtain the definition of L~ink and I~lnk. We can then easily calculate the coboundaries of the corresponding Virasoro algebra. They are bMink "
bMink
..!!. D 16
" 0•
(VI.5.S7a) (VI.S.S7b)
-het The derivation of b is equally Simple. We divide the set of heterotic fermions into two subsets according to the following partition of the integer Nhet : (VI. 5.58) The first NM fermions are Majorana and admit either NS or R boundary conditions:
1599
• (VI. S. 59 a)
where v
is either one or zero:
p
,/1 (R)
v p
=
(VI. S. 59b)
~O (NS)
The remaining 2ND real fermions combine to form nO complex fermions:
which admit the following more general boundary conditions:
(VI.5.61a)
.
",p( -z e21Tl) ::
-211i9
=e
P ::=p ez) - •
(VI.S.61b)
where E is the'" complex conjugate of _ and Sp is a real number in the range [0, 1:
-r
(VI. 5.62)
The boundary values 9 =0 or 9 = l correspond to ~Iajorana fermions. P
P
2
The above boundary conditions lead to the following mode expansion
(VI. 5.63a)
(VI.5.63b)
1600
(VI. 5.63c)
where the modes obey the canonical commutation rules: (VI. 5 .64a)
(VI.S.64b)
Inserting Eqs. (VI.5.63) into Eq. (VI.S.20b) and normal ordering, we get the definition of i~et. These operators obey the Virasoro algebra (Vl.S.41) with the already utilized value (c= tNhet) of the twococycle and with the following value of the coboundary:
(VI, 5. 65)
To complete the determination of the intercepts we still need to compute the values of the coboundaries b(G.,k.) and b(G.,k.) as functions of 1 1 1 1 the matrix rAB introduced in Eq. (VI.S.34). This calculation is more complicated and involves the notion of twisted Kac-Moody algebra: it will be performed in the next section.
VI.5.S Twisted Kac-Moody Algebras and Massless Target Fermions In this section, we want to determine the dependence of the Virasora algebra coboundaries on the generator y of the homotopy group. The best way to approach this problem is through the use of root formalism for the Lie Algebra GT of the target group. Let G be any of the simple factors in the direct product (Vl.3.63) and let r be its rank. Choose a Cartan basis for the Lie Algebra and let a, B, ... be the root vectors belonging to the root system 4l.
1601
The currents JA(z) are subdivided in the following way: r of them correspond to the Cartan subalgebra generators and are renamed Hi(t) :
(VLS.66) The remaining dim G - rank G correspond to the roots. To each pair of roots (a., -a). where a. > 0, we can associate a pair of real currents JCi.(z), J-a(z), in terms of which we can define the following complex currents: &a (z) :; - 1 [a J (z) - 1. J -a (z) ]
(VI.5.67a)
C-a (t):; - 1 [a J (4)
(VI,5.67b)
12
fi
i J -u] (z)
+
.
Using these variables the OPE (VI.3.161) becomes (VI. 5.68a) . ai a Hl (z) ,f
z-w
+
reg.
(VI. 5.68b)
z-w Ca(z) Cl\w) "reg. ,a(z) .,-a(w)
= _
ai
z-w
(VI.5.68c) (if a + B is not a root)
.
k
1
Hl (w) + - - - + reg. 2 (z _ w) 2
where the normalization constants N(a, B) N(a.
S) :;
-N(B,
al :;
(VI. 5. 68c' J
(VI.5.68d)
fulfill the usual properties:
-N( -a, -8) " N(-u-B , (l)
which suffice to determine them (given the root system).
(VI. 5.69)
1602 It is convenient to perfor. the same change of basis also on the group fermions. Hence we set (VI. 5. 70s)
(VI.5.70b) ~a
'" (z) .. -
1
12
r ex
w(l]
LA (z) + i A (z)
•
(VI. S. 70c)
With these redefinitions, the energy-momentum tensor (Vr.3.178a) and the supercurrent (VI.3.178c) take the following form (VI.5.71a)
(VI.5.71I»
G() z ..
- - e i1rj4 ~ k+ Cy
: {l/hz) 1hz) +
I a>O
(",a tWa(z) + fa ta(z))} :
(VI,5.71d)
An explicit expression for the homotopy generator y e (y,y) e B can now be easily written. First note that, since B is a subgroup of Gr, any of its generators is a direct product (Vl.S.72)
The group B will. then be specified by listing its generators: B .. {()',y), (Y',y')' ... }
(VI. 5. 73)
1603 Hence we can just focus on a simple factor G. (as we have 1 already done in the formulae above) and on an element y. e G. whose 1 1 N-th power must be equal to unity: Without loss of generality we Can assume that y is the exponential of a CSA-element. So if we denote by NO the Cartan generators we can write (VI. 5. 74)
The
r~component
vector t which identifies y is named the twist
~.
Since the possible eigenvalues of NO are the weight vectors A lying in the weight lattice Aw' it follows that =1 if and only if there exists an integer N such that
l
Nt"A€Z.
(VLS.75)
The roots a are particular weight vectors, so that Eq. (VI.S.75) is true if we write a in place of A. However. there may also exist a smaller integer N< N such that
Nt •
(l
€
Z
(for every root ex) •
(VLS.76)
The number N is the same numbe! defined by Eqs. (VI.5.38) and N (VI.5.39). Indeed if Eq. (VI.5.76) holds true the group element y acts as the identity on all the states belonging to the adjoint representation. The twist vector t is used to provide an explicit representation of the boundary matriX rBA. Indeed, utilizing the Cartan basis for the JA(z} the definition (VI.5.74) for y,
Eqs. (VI.S.34) become
currents and
1604 (VI. S. 77a)
..a
~
(ze
21Ti
. a ),. exp(-2lTlt·a)C (z)
(VI. 5. 77b)
(VI .5. 77c)
(VI.5.77d)
and lead to the following mode-expansions:
(VI. 5. 78a)
(VI. 5. 78b)
As already pOinted out, the boundary conditions on the group fermions are not independent, rather, they follow from those imposed on the Kac-Moody currents. Indeed, combining Eqs. (VI.5.77) with Eq. (VI.5.44) and Eq. (VI.S.71) we obtain (VI. S. 79a)
a
1/1
2rri
(z e
.
);; exp(21Tl
("21 w - t
•
a))
0.
1j!
(z)
(VI.S.79b)
which yield the following mode-expansions:
(VI. S. 80a)
(VI.5.80b)
1605
Comparing Eqs. (VI.S.BO) with Eqs. (VI.S.63) we see that the group fermions subdivide into rank G Majorana fermions of frequency \I" w plus as many complex fermions as there are positive roots, each with frequency aa" }w~t.a. So, by comparison Iqith Eq. (VI.S.65) we can immediately write down the coboundary bF of the Virasoro algebra associated with the fermionic part of the energy~momentum tensor (see Eq. (VI.S.71c». We find
2
"
~ 16
dim G +!
r t· aCt· a ~ w)
(VI. S. 81)
2 Ct>O
We still need bB(t,w), that is the coboundary of the Virasoro algebra associated with the bosonic energy-momentum tensor (VI.S.71b). In order to calculate this number we begin by inserting the modeexpansions (VI.S.78) into the OPE (VI.S.6B) and in the following: B iIi T (z)1-I (w) " - - - Ii (w)
+ --
1
"a TB(z)Cex (w) " - -l - 2 (; (w)
+ - - ()
(z_w)2
(1. ~ 1'1)
B
B
z-w
1
Z ~
1k.
1'1
i d Ii (1'1) + reg. terms 1'1
,,(1 (j
(1'1) +
reg. terms
1 a TB(1'1) z - 1'1 1'1
+ --
1
2
(z~w)4
(z~w)2
+
(VI. 5. 82b)
W
B
T (z)T (1'1) " - - - dlm G - - - + - - - T (1'1) 2 k+CV
(VI. 5. 82a)
reg. terms .
+
(VI. 5. B2c)
The result is (VI. 5. 83a) (VI. 5 .83b)
1606
(VI. 5. 83c) (VI. 5. 83d) (VI. S. S3e)
(Vl.S.83f)
+
1- _k_
12 k + Cy
dim G(m 3 • m)15
m+n,
0 + 2bt m15
m+n.
O.
(VI.S.83g) Eqs. (VI.S.83) describe the semidirect product of a twisted Kac· Moody algebra with the associated Sugawara realization of the Virasoro algebra. The coboundary bt is the number we want to calculate. To this effect we must introduce a little bit of Kac-Moody algebra representation theory, which will be of use also in Chapter VI.7. We focus on the untwisted case where the twist vector t is zero. From the point of view of representation theory this is not a restriction since the twisted algebra is isomorphic to the untwisted one [2]. Indeed if we perform the following change of basis: (VI. 5. 84a)
(VI.5.84b) ~
n
t
o n +t H+b6n, 0
L "L
(VI.S.85)
we find that the hatted quantities fulfill the algebra (VI.S.83) with t" 0 and
b" O.
1607
Hence. every unitary representation of the untwisted algebra is a unitary representation of the twisted algebra as well. and vice versa. For proof. we refer the reader to the mathematical literature r1]. Hel'e we just list our conventions and notations. Let a e ~ be the roots of the finite Lie Algebra G c G. We denote by p the semisum of positive roots
..
p
= 1:.
ra
(VI.5.86)
2
and by a.1 (i .. 1••••• rank G) the simple roots of G. The weight-lattice A is defined as the set of vectors ). which fulfill the condition w 2 ).. (1 e Z (12
Va e ~ .
(VI.S.87)
In particular. the flDldamental weights ). i (1" 1, .... rank G) are dual to the simple roots
Ai. ~ i 2--=6. (1.2 3
(VI.5.88)
j
The irreducible lDlitary representations of G are in one-to-one Correspondence with the highest weights. These are the weights p e).w whose components along the fwdamental weights are non-negative integers: (VI.5,89)
Finally the highest root of the algebra (that is the highest weight of the adjoint representation) is denoted bye. Extending G+ G we gain two more generators which commute among themselves and with the Cartan generators H~. These are the central charge k/2 and the LO operator of the associated Virasoro algebra. This explains why the roots of the Kac-Moody algebras are vectors with two more components with respect to the roots of the corresponding finite Lie Algebra.
1608
We follow Goddard and Olive notations [2J. The step operators era. are associated with the roots (a.,O,n) while (n 1 0) are associate~ with the roots (O,O,n) =n~, g being by definition the following vector:
H!
6 " (0,0,1)
•
(VI.5.90)
The rank of the Kac~Moody algebra G is r + 1 (1''' Tank G) and the r + 1 simple roots are the following:
'"0.0 = (-6,0,1)
(VI.5.91a) (VLS.91b)
They live in a (2 + rank G) -dimensional vector space V on which the following Lorentzian scalar product has been defined:
Vv = (v,q,m) e V
Vu " (u,p,n) e V " U·
v"
= U·
v + pm + nq •
(Vl.S.92)
" have the following form The fundamental weights of G "0
1 2
A ,,(0, '26 ,0)
(VI. 5. 9Sa) (VI. 5. 93b)
where the integers mi are the dual Coxeter numbers defined below: rank G . _6_" lel 2
L
i=l
m1
",i ...
(VI. 5. 94)
lex.IZ 1
In the same way as for finite Lie Algebras, the unitary irreducible representations'of Kac-Moody algebras are in one-to-one correspondence With the highest-weights U whose components along the fundamental weights (VI.S.93) are non-negative integers:
1609
(VI. 5.95) The structure of the vector V defined by Eq. (VI.5.9S) is the following: (VI.S.96) where (VLS.97) is a highest weight of the finite Lie Algebra G and k/2 is the central charge of the Kac-Moody algebra, whose relation with the WessZumino term in the action (VI.3.93) has been extensively discussed. Eqs. (VI.S.9S) are equivalent to the following condition: k = (no + nimi) "jSj2
E
Z
(VI.5.98a)
~::: a·lJ
(VLS.98b)
whose interpretation is very simple. Indeed, the highest weight lJ identifies the irreducible representation of G spanned by the multiplet of vacuum states and Eq". (VI.5.98b) tells us that there is a finite number of choices for this representation at each level k. To be more precise the multiplet of vacuum states is defined by the following conditions:
(VI. 5.99a)
(VI. 5.99b)
gf'!v;(lJ, lk,O) > n
2
,,0
(n > 0)
(VI.5.99c)
1610 (VI.S.99d) where Cg is the quadratic Casimir of G in the irreducible representation {lJ} of highest weight lJ (VI.S.lOO) and
is any weight vector belonging to {lJ}
\I
\lehJ}.
(VI.S.IOl)
Clearly the whole multiplet of vacuum states is generated by the action of loa. (a.> 0) on the highest weight state
IlJ;(ll, tk,O) > which ful-
fills the additional condition (VI.5.102)
Bq. (VI.5.98a) gives the spectrum of permissible k levels and Eq. (VI.5.98b) specifies which vacuum multiplet is allowed for each choice of k.
On the other hand the full tmitary representation of the
Ka~
Moody algebra is identified once lJ is given. In the following we shall be specifically interested in the SU(2) Kac-Moody algebra.
In this case we have r'" 1 and a single positive
(and obviously simple) root which we normalize as follows: a= 12. The fundamental weight is A'" 1/12
and the vector p is given by p'" 12/2.
The weight and root lattices correspond to points and circled points, respectively, in the following picture:
o . A
0
. 0 '-0-' 0
. 0
.
@
(VI. 5.103)
highest weight lJ has then the following form
IJ '" ZJ A '" 2J _1_ '" J
12
12 '"
Ja
(2J
e Z)
J being the isospin (a conventional name for J).
(V1.5.104)
1611
From Eq. (VLS.98) (since the allowed values of J are J
='k4 '
J '"
k
1
'4 - "2 '
J
k
e.. 0:)
= '4 -
we conclude that at level k
1 , ••. , J = 0
(VI. 5.105)
t,
in particular at level k'" 4 we have J =: 1, O. In terms of J the Casimir is Cg ;;; 2J (J 'I- 1) and Eq. (VI. S. 33) can be rewritten as: (VL5.106) Indeed Cv.. 4 for SU(2) as can be easily checked from Eq. (VL5.100). More generally, the normalization of the Casimirs and the root lengths we used in solving Eq. (VI.S.28) are given in TABLE IV.S.IV. Having established these notations and conventions, we come back to the calculation of the coboundary bt • From the commutation relation (VI.5.107)
it follows that if [0 > is a vacuum state, i.e. a highest weight of the Virasoro algebra, characterized by a Virasoro weight h: (VI. S. 108a)
LjO>=O. n
(v!. 5.108b)
then the value of b is immediately given by the following relation: (VI,S .109)
the operators L
n
being defined by the following contour integrals (VI.5.110)
in terms of the normal ordered stress-energY tensor (VI.s.7l),
1612
°
In the case of the untwisted Kac-Moody algebras t" the highest-weight states Iv; ell, ik,O) > fulfill Eqs. (VI.5.l0S) with h .. CgI (k + Cy) (see Eq. (VI. 5. 99) ) . Hence they are good highest-weight states also for the Virasoro algebra and can be used to calculate b. Since the singlet representation jl is compatible with any value of k (see Eq. (VI.5.98)) we can just take this choice which is also the simplest. We find L 110; (O,.!k,O) > "
-
2
°"'" b(t"
0) .. 0
(VI. 5.111)
The coboundary of the Virasoro algebra is therefore zero in the case of the untwisted algebra. Let us nol; consider the twisted case. A highest-weight state of the twisted algebra is characterized by the analogues of conditions (V[.5.99) and (Vl.5.102):
(VI. 5. 112 a)
tl jl,-k,O> t 1 It I HOIl,-k,O>=1l 2 2 (n + t • 0. > 0)
(VLS.112b)
(VI. S. 112c)
(VI. 5. 112d)
(VI. 5. 112e) where 0.1 (the orthogonal roots) are the roots which have zero scalar product with the twist vector. The isomorphism (VI.S.8S) fixes the allowed values of the vector. Indeed from Eq. (VI.S.85a) we see that the vector
jlt
1613
jJ.
= JJ t
1 ... - kt
(VI. S.113)
2
must be a highest-weight fulfilling Eq. (VI.5.98b). In this way the state ljJ.t+ tkt.ik.O > = Ill.ik.O > is a good highest-weight state for the untwisted algebra generated by the hatted operators of Eq. (VI.5.84). The only meaningful difference between the twisted and untwisted
algebra is due to the nOl'lll&l ordering of the L~ operator. Indeed. the result depends on whether we normal order with respect to one way of moding the Kac-Moody operators or to the other. This is the mechanism which leads to a non-vanishing bt for t ~ O. To see this let us write the explicit form of Lo:
(VI.5.114) and let us choose (which is always possible) the singlet representation 11 '" 0 corresponding to
JJ
t
"'.
'21 kt •
(V1.S.l1S)
With this choice of the vacuum we obtain (VI.S.1l6)
Consider next the state L~ 11 0 > • For
t" 0 this is not zero but
reads:
Lt 10> '" _1_ {2H *H + ~ la I-a. +ra ga lID> -1 k+C -1 0 l. -l+t*a -toa -t·a -l+t*a
V
a>O
(VI.S.117)
1614 If we denote by Pfl the semisum of all positive roots which are not
orthogonal to t:
PII "
1
I"...
(YI.5.118)
2 (pO
a·t~O
the state (VI.S.117) can be rewritten as follows: Lt1IO> -
= - _1_ kTC y
( 2P
II
+ kt).
(VI.S.1l9)
H 110 > -
and we immediately obtain t I 112 = 2k 1 ~+CV~ 1 2 I2Pn IlL_l 0>
+ kt
[2
(VI.5.120)
which combined with Eqs. (VI.S.109) and (VI.S.116) yields the desired value of bt : (VI.S.I2l) Putting together Eqs. (VI.S.S1) and (VI.S.121) we have the final expression for b(G.k):
1
+"4
k +kCv {I k + Cv I2 P [I + kt 12 - k It
[2}
•
(VI.S.122)
Inserting Eqs. (VI.S.S1), (VI.S.57) and (VI.S.122) into (VI.5.42) and using at the same time Eqs. (VI.S.2S) to eliminate the parameter d (dimension of space-time) we obtain the final expression for the intercepts:
1615
(Vl.S.123a)
~
1
2
1
a=l--Iv-16 p=l P
ND
Ie
2
(VI. S.123b)
2 p=NM+I p
which can be used to investigate the question of massless target fermions. We just observe that the operator L~Mink) is of the form (Mink) 1 2 Lo ="2 P
.. (Mink)
(VLS.124)
+1'
where p~ is the 4-momentum and tor.
/oJ
is a positive-valued number opera-
Similarly L~G.k) is of the form (G k)
L •
o
t
t
Cg(~) (G) =--+14 k+ Cy
(VLS.12S)
where the twisted Casimir C~(~t) is given by t t g
C (lJ )
= lJt
t
• (J.I + 2 p ) J.
(VLS.126)
p being the semisum of the positive roots orthogonal to t and pt being related to a weight-vector by Eq. (VI.S.IIS). The additional term N(G) appearing in (VI.S.I2S) is a positivevalued number operator. Taking this into account the mass-shell equations (VI.S.29) become the following:
1616 1 2 -p TN" - Am2 (w)
= a(w}
2
12
Z,.e%-
~
-p +N=-Am Z
(VI. 5. 127a)
n (Cg(~))
~ -i=1 k + Cv
(VI.S.127b)
.
1
Since target fermions sit in the Ramond sector the necessary condition for the existence of massless fermionic excitations is that the mass-shift 6m2 (l) should be non-positive: 2
lim (1) 5 0 .
(VI. 5.128)
To analyze Eq. (VI.S.I2S) we observe that in view of Eqs. (VI.S.l21), (VI.S.123) and (VI.S.126) 6m 2(!) can be rewritten as a sum of contributions from the different simple groups: 2
Am (1):
n
L
i=1
2
llmG (k.,t,U) i
(VI.S.129)
1
where for each group we have 2 Cv dimG 1 \ Am (k,t,V) , , - - - - t. t· a(l- t· a} + G k + Cv 24 2 <1>0 -k- (12 P 1' +ktl 2 -k 112 t ) + k + Cv 4 k+ Cv I
+ -1- {I -
1 I + (J.!- -kt)· (v- -kt+2p) 2
2
.I.
1•
(VI. 5.130)
Looking at Tables VI.S.I, II, III where we listed all solutions of Eqs. (VI.S.28), we see that the only simple groups of relevance to us are SU(Z}, SU(3) and 50(5). We consider then the explicit structure of the mass-shifts for these three groups. A)
The SU(2) mass-shift We write the twist vector in the following form
1617 t
= qA
(VI.5.131)
A= 1/11 being the fmdamental weight and q a positive parameter smaller than one, 0 < q < 1. In this way t is not a weight vector. Since the SUeZ) root diagram is one-dimensional we always have P=PI! and PJ. =0.
Writing l! = ZJA as in Eq. (VI.5.104) and allowing the same spectrum of J-values as in Eq. (VI.S.10S) we obtain: 2
AmsU(2)(k.q.J)
=
=_4_lk+2 z(_1_q_I2)2 k+41k+4 11 4
+!(J_~q)21 2
(VI.S.132)
4
2
Inspection of Sq. (VI.S.132) reveals that AmSU (2) is a non-negative function which has just one zero at
q=I1
(VI.S.133a)
k k J=-q=4
8
(VI. S.133b)
The last equation can be fulfi lied if and only if k = 4n is a multiple of four. Looking at Tables VI.S.I, II, III we consider. to begin with, the solutions of the anomaly cancellation equation where the target group Gr is just a product of SUe2}'s and U(I)'s. There are ten of them corresponding respectively to case I), 2}, 3), 4), 7), 8). 9), 10), 11) and 12) if we number the solutions from the first of Table 1 to the last of Table III. Cases 9), 10), 11) and 15) can be immediately ruled out since they include level k = 2 SU(2)Kat-Moody algebras whiCh, according to the previous discussion, contribute a strictly positive mass-shift in the fermion sector. In the remaining cases 1), 2), 3). 4). 7), 8) massless target fermions can be constructed by twisting the SU(2) algebra with q = 1/2
1618
and choosing the representation J .. 1/2 in the It .. 4 case and the representation J '" 3/2 in the It .. 12 case. At)
Digression on symmetric twists
Recalling now Eqs. (VI.S.37), (VI.5.S8) and (IV.5.76) we see that the choice q'" 1/2 corresponds to the choice of a boundary subgroup By e B charaCterized by N", 2, and hence
By
(VI. 5.134)
.. Z. Z(G) 2
Eq. (VI.5.134) defines what we call a symmetric twist of the Kac· Moody algebra G. Indeed, when Eq. (VI.5.134) holds true the matrix rBA represent· ing the generator y inside the adjoint representation becomes an involutory automorphism r of the Lie Algebra G and induces the following orthogonal decomposition: G '" H $ l .
[H. I} .. I.
[H • U] ,. H
[a: • IJ .. H
(VI. 5. 135)
where the subalgebra H is the eigenspace belonging to the eigenvalue r .. 1 while the subspace ( is the eigenspace belonging to the eigenvalue f'" ·1. Correspondingly the Kac·Moody generators with H-indices are integer moded while those with (-indices are half-integer moded. In this case the twisted version of the Kac-Moody algebra (VI.3.160) can be written in a somewhat simpler way than in Eqs. (VI.5.83). If we distinguish between the H and , indices by means of the convention A = (i.a) where A e G, i e H,
~
e,
(VI.S.136)
1619
we obtain (VI.5.137a)
(VI. S.l37b)
(VI. 5.137c)
and the associated Virasoro generators take the explicit form
I
L ,,_1_ m k + Cv n"-
(i
Ji
m-n
+
n
If.
lJ.) .
m-n-li
(VI.S.l38)
n+% .
The vacuum state Jo> is characterized by the equation
LoIO> " llO > k +C v where. on COllIparison with Sq. (Vl •.S.l26). the value of
(VI.5.l39)
is given by
Its meaning is the same as that of Casimir of the subgroup H c: G. Indeed P1 is identified with the p-vector of the H-subgroup and
)Jt
is identified with a highest weight of the H-algebra. Explicit calculation of the nom IIL.llo> 112 leads to the following value for the coboundary b in the case of a symmetric twist:
bSymm .. _k_
k +C V
where by dim (G/H)
116 dim (G/H)
(VI.5.14l)
we mean the dimension of the symmetric space
associated to the orthogonal decomposition (VI.S.13S).
1620
This expression can be cross-checked, in the SU(2) case, with the expression for general twists (VI. 5.121). Putting q'" 1/2 in (VI.S.l31) and inserting it into (VI.S.I2!) we get b=_k_ 8(k + 4)
which is the right value since, in this case, the symmetric space G/H is the 2-sphere 52 =SU(2)/U(1) " SO(3)/SO(2). If we restrict our attention to symmetric twists the expression (VI.5.130) for the fermionic mass-shift simplifies considerably. Indeed we get 2 LimG(symm) = _C_h_
+
k +C V
Cy
(dim G-
24(k +CV)
~
dim
2
2.) H
Going through the list of symmetric spaces we can check that (dim G- dim G/H) is a non~negative number which becomes zero only in one case, name ly. for the choice G", SOC 3) and H=50(2) . Hence massless fermions can be produced through symmetric twists only in the case of SUeZ) groups.
On the other hand, as we are going to see, the non-symmetric twists needed to produce massless fermions in the case of the SU(3) and SO(S) groups require values of the central charge k which are not available in our list of solutions (see Tables VI.5.1, II, III). Hence, eventually. we will be forced to restrict ourselves to symmetrically twisted SU(2)'s. Such a choice has important consequences in the further development of the theory when one comes to the question of fermionization and modular invariance. This is postponed to Chapter VI. 7.
For the time being let us see how we groups manifolds. B)
e~clude
the SU(3) and SO(5)
The SU(3} mass-shift For SU(3} the simple roots a 1 and aZ can be chosen as follows:
1621 (VI. S.142)
and the corresponding fundamental weights are (VI.5.143)
In addition to ~1 and Ctz one has the third positive root (%1 + a2 which is to be identified with the highest root e.
e
is also equal to the vector p:
e " al
+
(%Z
= (12 /Z,
f3fi) .
(VI. 5.144)
A highest -weight of SU(3) is a vector
(VI. 5.145)
where mI , mZ are positive integers. The twist vector t has a similar expression
with ql and qz non-negative and less than 1/2. t· a < for all roots).
°
(In this way
We must distinguish two cases: i)
p1
° and
=
Both ql and qz are different from zero. In this case PII '" p =a l + a 2 .
ii) Either ql or q2 is zero. Without loss of generality we can say Ql" 0. In this case we have PJ." a l and PI! '" tal + a 2, What happens is that we have an untwisted subgroup SU(2) ® U(l) c SU(3) and it is convenient to label states with SUeZ) ® U(l) quantum numbers, The fundamental weight of SU(2) is A= (1/12 ,0) and it is related to >'1 and >"z by
1622
(VI.5.147) Correspondingly we can identifY the integers m1 and m2 with the isospin and hypel'chllrge by (VI.S.148) With these notations, in the first case, the SU(3) mass-shift reads as follows: 2
&1SU (3) (k,t,lJ) .. .. - 6 k+6
f3 -k+ 3 It - -1 pi 2 + -1 III ~ -1 kt 12 J k+6 3 6 2
(VI.5.149)
while in the second case it takes the form
I
2 k + 3 [4k + 27 e.msU(3) (k,qA2 ,J, Y) "' k 6+ 6 W '4k712 +
'61 J(J + 1)
+
'92
-
2q(1 - q) J ..
1
(Y - 2'kq)
21J
•
(VI. 5. 150)
In both cases the positivity properties are evident by inspection.
~U(3) as given by Eq. (VI.S.lS0) is non-negative and never reaches zero for any value of q. J or Y, while ~U(3) as given by Eq. (VI.S.149) is non-negative and has an absolute minimum Am;U(3)"' 0 at (VI. 5 .15 la) 1 JJ .. -kt .
2
(VI.S.lSlb)
Eq. (VI.S.lSlb) implies (VI. 5. 152)
1623 which can be fulfilled with integer values of m1 and m2 if and only if the level of the SUeS) algebra is a multiple of six: k =6n.
This is sufficient to rule out all the solutions of our Tables with an SUeS) factor (cases 6), 9) and 16) of Tables VI.5.I, II. III). Indeed,
C)
kSU(S) < 24
in all cases.
The sotS} mass-shift In the SO(5) case the simple roots are
III ; (1,0),
~2"
(-1,1)
(VI. 5.153)
to which we must adjoin the other two positive roots (11 + ttz and Za1 +CtZ'
The vector p is given by (VI.S.154)
whose length square is
Ipl 2 =5/2.
The fundamental weights are
A]
= (1/2.
1/2).
A2
= (O,l)
(VI. 5.155)
In terms of these we can write the twist vector t and the highest weight vector ~ exactly as in the SU(3) case (see Eqs. (VI.5.145) and (Vl.S.146». AS in the SUeS) case one should distinguish the cases where t is not orthogonal to any root and where Pl '10. The result is the same as in the previous example. For P1" Q we obtain
(VI. 5 .156)
1624 which is clearly non-negative and has a zero at (VLS.157a) (VI. S.157b)
Sq. (VI.S.157b) shows that in order to get massless fermions the level of the SQ(S) Kac-Moody algebra should be a multiple of six: kSO(S) .. 6n. This observation suffices ·to exclude all the 50(5) -solutions found in Tables VI.S.l. II, IrI.
In this way the list of viable group-manifolds has been reduced to those of Table I plus the two cases 7) and 8) of Table II. In Chapter VI.7 we shall exclude also these last two cases on the ground of fermionization and modular invariance. Before closing this section let us make some remarks on the general pattern which has emerged from our case-study. Extrapolating our results we can say that the existence of massless target fermions imposes the following conditions on the twist vector t and the highest weight 1.I of the fermionic vacuum: 2 p Cv
(VI. 5. 158a)
t .. -
k
II ,,-p
(VL5.158b)
Cv
So the necessary and sufficient condition for the existence of massless fermions seems to be a condition on the level k, which must be such that ; p belongs to the weight lattice. This happens if and V
only if (VI. 5.159)
1625
The smallest possible value of k fulfilling Sq. (VI.S.l59) is obviously k =",. In this case the contribution of the super WZW~system to the conformal anomaly is c(G,k) :: _k_ dim G + 1 dim G :: 2 k +C V
dim G
(Vr.S.160)
that is, the same as if we had just a set of free fermions in the adjoint representation of the group Gx G. This will be a very important observation while addreSSing the topiC of modular invariance (see Chapter VI. 7). Let us now anticipate from later discussions that the presence of U(l)-factors in the target manifold is incompatible with chiral fermions. Adding this information to the material presented in this section suffices to show that the target groups of chiral superstrings are those listed in Eq. (VI.S.4). The level of the SU(2). groups is always k.:: 4, 1 1 and since we need synnuetric twists the boundary groups Bi are products of lz ~ factors as claimed in Eq. (VI. 5.5) • This will be further clarified in Chapter VI. 7. References for Chapter VI.S [1] [2]
V.G. lac and D.H. Peterson, Advances in Mathematics S3 (1984) 125; O. Gepner, E. Witten, Nucl. Phys. B278 (1986) 493. P. Goddard and O. Olive, J. Mod. Phys. Al (1986) 303.
1626 TABLE VI. 5.1 l'ermionizable Group-Manifnlds for 0:4 Superstrings Target Group: G,-
Nhet
Massless
Target
GNO Symmetri c Space
Fel'lllions
SUSY
GlG,-
Femionization Group GF : SU(2)6
r
fSU (2)k:4] 3
3S
Yes
1 SN $4
[SU{2} It SU(2) SU(2J
ISIJ(2)k:i ~ [U(1)]2
34
Yes
2:(NH
(SU(Z)ltSU(2)r It [SO(3)f SU(2) 50(2)
lSU(2\~41 It lU(I))4
33
yes
N ,,4
SU(2) " SU(2) 0[S()(3)f su(2) 50(2)
[U(1)]6
32
Yes
N =4
[SO(Slt 50(2)
1627 TABLE VI. S.l! Quasi Fermionhable Group-Manifolds for 0=4 Superstrings Target Group. Gr
lihet ·
Massless
(;NO Symmet ri c Space
Fennions
Gp/Gr
Fermionization Group
GF~SU(4)<9SU(2)
ISO(S)k=2] <9 U(l)
37
No
SO(6} ® 50(3) 50(5) 50(2)
[5U(3)k:2) <9 [U(1))2
36
No
SU(4} <9 50(3) 5\](3) <9 U(l) 50(2)
[SlI(2)k:i e [U(1))2
34
Yes
50(6) e 50(3) 50(4) <950(2) 50(2)
[5U(2\=12 J 2 eU(lJ
33
Yes
5tJ(4) <9 SO(3l 50(4) 50(2)
Fermionization Group GF • SOCS} fI SU(3) [SU(Z}k=/ fI U(l)
38
No
SU(3j SO(5) fI SU(2) e U(1) SO(4)
(SU(2}k=/ <9 [SU(2)k=20)
37
No
50(5) fI SUCS) 50(4) 50(3)
lSU(2)k=Z] fI [SU(2)k=a]fI U(1)2
34
No
50(5) SU(3) <9 SO(3) fI 50(2) 5U(2) fI U(1}
33
Yes
50(5) <9 SU(3) SO(3) <9 50(2) 50(3)
J
[SU(2)k=SJ e [5U(2)k=20 fI U(I)
1628 TABLE VI.S.!II Non FeTmionizable Group-Manifolds for D=4 Superstrings (dilQ
Target Group = fir
Ii"
> IS)
l\et
Massless i'eTmions
GNO Symmetric Space
[5U(3)l<=2J -ISU(2)k=4]
37
No
_ SUeZ) _ SU(2) SU(4) SU(3)etJ(l) StI(2)
[50(5)k=4]
36
No
(SU(2}k..
SO(7)
5O(S) • 50(2)
SU(3) SU(2) • tI(l)
[SU(2)k=2] • II
for 0< 4
41- [sU(21 k=sl
1SU(J)k=lOJ
35
No
34
No
It
50(3) It 50(2) Sp(6)
sueS] .U(IJ
TASLE VI.S. IV
NQmaliution of Roots and Casimir Invariants GROUl'
CASIMIR
G
Cv
LONGeST JIQOr Ll:1/GfIf 82
SU(n}
2n
2
5p(2n)
4n.4
4
50(2n + 1)
4n·2
2
50(2n)
24
2
E6
24
2
£7
36
2
"8
60
Z
G2
12
.3
•
5O(S)
• 50(4) 50(3)
1629 CHAPTER IV. 6
The Polyakov Path Integral and the Partition Function of String l40dels
VI.6.1 Introduction As pointed out in Chapter VI.3 (Section VI.3.1) the basic idea underlying string theories is that the observed particles are the vibrational modes of the quantum string. Therefore the most iJllt)ortant aspect of a string model is gi ven by the spectrum of its two-dimensional hamiltonian which is to be regarded as a candidate for the mass-spectrum of the world. A convenient tool to study the spectrum is suggested by statistical mechanics and is given by the partition function defined below: Z(S)
1:
Tr exp(- SH)
(VI.6.1)
where S = l/kT is the inverse temperature and H is the quantum hamiltonian of the system. The trace is taken on the Hilbert space of
1630
physical states and the anti-Laplace transform of Z(8) yields the the microcanonical density of such states at a given energy level: +i OO
aCE)
= J . dB eBE -1""
(VI.6.2)
Z(B) •
In string theories, as we shall see, the role of energy is played by the mass squared m2 of the particle associated to a given vibrational mode. Recalling Eqs. (VI.2.B) one sees that the time variable t on the two~ dimensional world-sheet can be identified with the following combination: (*)
t
~
t (ig z
+
~g z)
(VI. 6. 3)
Recalling on the other hand Eq. (VI.2.22b) one realizes that Lo and Lo are the translation generators in the variables ~g z and tg z, respectively. Hence the hamiltonian H, i.e. the time translation generator, is given by (VI. 6. 4) where L and L are the modes of the left-moving and right-moving n n stress-energy tensors of the complete system (see Eq. (VI.S.6)) and where c1 is some suitable constant, representing the vacuum energy. By the same token, the difference (VI.6.5)
is the generator of translations in on the world-sheet.
(*)
0,
that is, in the space-variable
The reason we changed notation and we named t the time variable rather than T is to avoid confusion with the modulus of the torus.
1631
For a closed stTing model the partition function is then given by Z(cl07ed)(8) ..
strlng
rr(cl0 7ed)eXP[*13 strIng
(LO+Lo-c 1)]
(VI. 6.6)
states where we were careful to specify that the trace must be taken on closed string states. This is very crucial for the following reason. In Chapter VI.3 we associated a vacuum of the superstring with a classical superconformal theory which, upon quantization, leads to two Fock spaces: the Fock space ffL of left-moving modes and the Fock space ffR of right-moving modes. Any state in the spectrum can be written as Istate > '" Ileft >
®
Iright >
(VI. 6. 7)
where Ileft > e ffL and Iright > e ffR. However, not all such combinations are phYSical closed string states. The fundamental question we try to answer in the present and the next chapters is the following. Given the space: (VI. 6. 8)
of all left-moving and all right-moving states, which subspace Jf of ff .Yfcfl
(VI. 6. 9)
is the Hilbert space of closed string states?
It turns out that the answer to this question is not unique; rathel', we have a finite set of Hilbert subspaces Jfi c ff (i" 1, ••. ,n) corresponding to a finite number of superstring models described by the same two-dimensional Lagrangian and associated with the propagation on the same target manifold. The proper tool to study and classify these Hilbert spaces is the associated partition function (VI.6.6) which can be rewritten as follows
1632 (VI, 6. 10)
where Pi is the projection operator on the
i~th
Hilbert subspace Jl"i:
(VI.6.11)
Clearly a claSSification of the Z.(8) partition functions amounts to 1 a classification of the projection operators Pi and of the associated superstring models. The reason why Zi (8) is a useful object to consider is due to its relation with the Polyakov functional integral (VI.2.30). (VI.2.31) which leads to an identification of the inverse temperature B with the imaginary part of the modulus T of a torus. This identification implies that the partition function (VI.6.10) should be an invariant against the action of the mapping class group and eventually allows for a group-theoretical classification of the available projection operators Pi (Glioul, OliVe and Scherk projectors (GSO)) in terms of symplectic modular group invariants. The present chapter is devoted to establishing the precise relation between the partition fUnction (VI.6.10) and the Polyakov path integral posing the prob lem of modular invariance. The next chapter will be concerned with the solution of this problem and with the classification of the GSO projectors; this programme involves a separate study of the fermionization of group-bosons and of the Kac~Moody algebra characters.
VI.6.2 The cosmological constant, the partition function, and the Polyakov path integral The first step in establiShing the advocated relation between the thermodynamical partition function (VI.6.10) and the integrand (VI.2.31a) over moduli space of the Polyakov path integral is the following observation.
1633 In a closed string the origin of the a-axis should not matter; indeed a rigid a-translation corresponds to a meaningless renaming of the base point 0"0 of the loop: (VI.6.1Z)
Invariance under a-translations is achieved if all the closed string states are eigenstates of the P generator (VI.6.S) corresponding to some universal eigenvalue cZ: (LO -
Lo) Iclosed
string>
= ezi closed
string>
(VI. 6.13)
In this case the closed string states transform with a phase under the shift 0 ~ cr + const, which is therefore a symmetry of the theory. The condition (VI.6.13) can be implemented inserting an integral representation of the delta function o(LO - Lo - c Z) in the Fock-space trace (VI.6.10)(*)
(VI. 6. 14)
With the use of (VI.6.14), Eq. (VI.6.10) can be rewritten as follows:
Zi (B) ,.
f d ReT Tr (I) {lPi exp[ 21Th (LO - a)} • exp [- 21Ti i (i.o
- a) ]l
• (VI. 6.15)
where we have defined the new variables
(*)
Here and in the following we do not bother about overall normalization constants.
1634 1
(x + is)
(VI.6.16a)
a" -2(c1+2 c )
(VI. 6. 16b)
12 (c 1 ~
(VI.6.16c)
T " -
21£ 1
(i "
c ) 2
The combinations (VI.6.17b,c) have been named a and a for a very simple reason: it will turn out precisely through the identification with the Polyakov path integral that they are nothing else but the intercepts (or Virasoro coboundaries) defined by Eqs. (VI.5.123). tion
Considering Eq. (VI.6.1S) we are led to introduce a complex funcof the complex parameter T defined as
~ (t)
!'i (T) " ImT Tr(I){lPi q
La-a
_to-a}
q
(VI. 6. 17)
where the normalization 1m T is chosen for later convenience and where we have defined (VI.6.l8)
q '" exp(21li T}
In terms of this complex function the thermodynamical partition function (VI.6.1S) can be rewritten as Z. (21f ImT " B) = 1
I
dReT IN - ... (1) ImT 1
(VI.6.19)
The transcription (VI.6.19) suggests a rather natural question: if the thermodynamical partition function Zi(S} is the integral of ~i(l} on the real part of T. then what is the meaning of the complete twodimensional integral of ~i (t) in
lr " dTdi' " dRet
d ImT
?
1635 Furthermore, what is the meaning of the complex parameter l and what is the appropriate integration domain in the complex T-plane? The answer is given by the following propositions. 6.6.1 Proposition. Let .!'i (ll be defined by Eg. (VI.6.17)! being the intercepts (VI.S.123), and consider the integral
(l
and
(VI.6.20)
The constant All) is the one-loop contribution of the string-model characterized by the GSO-projector IP i to the effective cosmological constant. 6.6.2 Proposition. The integral (VI.6.20) can be viewed as the vacuum to vacuum amplitude corresponding to the emission and reabSOrption of a closed string, which, in its virtual propagation, sweeps a toroidal world-sheet
(VI.6.21)
The parameter l in the integral (VI.6.20) is the modulus of the world-sheet torus (VI.6.21). Hence for the integration domain in (VI.6.20) one must take the PSL(2,Z) fundamental region a (see Eqs. (VI.2.246) and (V!.2.248»), which is nothing else but the g= 1 moduli space. Furthermore, since the measure
iT
d(Weil-Petersson) = --"-2(Imt)
(VI.6.22)
(i
1636 is in variant under the action of the mapping class group pst (2 ,ll , the partition function fl. (tl I\IUSt also be PSL(2,Z)-invariant. Recalling 1 theorem 6.2.16 and Eqs. (VI.2.244), flf(t) is invariant, if and only if it fulfills the following conditions:
1r.(1
1) = fl.(t) t 1
(VI.6.23a) (VI,6.23b)
Proposition 6.6.2 is more precisely stated as the following theorem. 6.6.3 Theorem. The integral Ai of Eg. (V1.6.20) can be identified 1) on genus g= 1 Riemann surfaces: with the Polyakov path integral
9'i
A~l) .. ~ ~1) . 1
(VI. 6. 24)
1
The higher lOjP contributions given by ~~g .
A1g)
to the cosmological constant are
1
6.6.4 Definition. In general the PolyaKov path integral ~!g) ~ genus g Riemann surfaces is given by (VI .6. 25a)
(VI. 6. 25b) where the above symbols have the following meaning. S(g.C.~) is the classical action (VI.3.64) which depend~ on the metric gaB' the gravitino ~a and the matter fields ~l, bc is a shorthand for the boundary conditions specifying the appropriate bundles on Lg of which . the matter fields {~l(~)} and the gravitino Ca(~) are cross-sections.
1637
j'bc(gQS) denotes the fUnctional integral on all the fields ~a and
where (VI.6.27) is the mapping class group invariant measure on the moduli-space M g and the partition fUnction ~(i)(tl" .. ,'t 3g _3) is given by (VI.6.28)
the result of the functional integral (Vl.6.2Sb) being a function of both the moduli and the boundary conditions. The full partition function ~(i) (t 1" .. ;1" 3g-3) must be invariant under the transformations of the mapping class group, which on the boundary conditions related to the homology basis acts as Sp(2g,l). This (*)
For simplicity we have numbered the modUli from one to 3g-3 which is correct in all cases except for g=l and g=O as we know from Chapter VI. 2.
1638 requirement yields a set of constraints on the coefficient.s ci[bC] which must be adjoined to a ftmdamental factorization property. To tmderstand this property consider the usual picture (VI.2.S3) of a genus g surface and go to that region of moduli space where (VI.2.3S) degenerates into the following surface
..... ..... ~ .
~
(VI. 6.29) We can arrange the 3g~3 moduli in such a way that the first g of these are the moduli or the g~tori of picture (VI.6.29). while the remaining 2g-3 describe the shape of the necks. There are limiting values r.1 (i=g+l, .... 3g~3) of these moduli for which the surface CVI.6.29) degenerates into the disconnected sum of g tori. the necks becoming so thin that eventually they disappear. In this limit the partition function (VI.6.28) is in general singular. and the residue of the singularity has to be the product of the partition functions of the g tori: (VI. 6.30)
Indeed Eq. (VI.6.30) is the fundamental factorization property of scattering amplitudes. Since the coefficients ci[bc] depend only on boundary conditions but not on the moduli, Eq. (VI.6.30) can be true only if these coefficients are factorized in the follOWing way: g
c.[bcJ'" n c.[(bc)J 1 r=l 1 where (be)
r
are the boundary conditions on the r·th torus.
(V!. 6. 31)
1639
Combining Eq. (VI.6.3l) with the requirements imposed by the Sp(2g.Z) modular invariance we ob~ain the possible sets of coefficients ci[bc] on an arbitrary torus; through Propositions 6.6.1 and 6.6.3 each of them defines a GSO projector and hence a superstring model
(VI. 6. 32) This discussion elucidates the relevance and the implications of Propositions 6.6.1, 6.6.2 and of Theorem 6.6.3. We are left with the task of convincing the reader that they are true. We shall comply with this task in various steps beginning with a heuristic proof of Proposition 6.6.1.
Consider a single scalar field ~(x) of mass Lagrangian :
m2
and its kinetic
(VI. 6. 33)
At the quantum level f will contribute to the effective cosmological constant in the following way (VI.6.34)
On performing the gaussian integration, Eq. (Vl.6.34) can be rewritten as follows: (VI.6.35) To evaluate the functional determinant appearing in (VI.6.35) we utilize the t-fUnction regularization method.
1640 6.6.4 Definition. Given an operator A, the logarithm of its determinant is defined by the following formula
i. !;(A) (5)
lin det A = - lim
(VI.6.36)
s'" 0 ds
where the i;-function of the operator A is defined below. [ 1 I;(A)(s) =1- [ dtt s-1 Trexp(-tA).
res)
(VI.6.37)
0
If {)..}
The argument underlying the above definition is as follows. are the eigenvalues of the operator A, we should set det A = IT )..
(VI. 6.38)
{)..}
which is in general divergent. However if we define the i;-like function i;(A)(s)
=
I:' l
-s
-s
A = Tr(A )
(VI.6.39)
{)..}
we obtain (VI. 6. 40) and hence
I;~(O) = -
L
lin
A= - lin
{A}
II A = - lin det A . fA}
(VI.6.41)
This shows that Eq. (VI.6.36) makes sense with the definition (VI.6.39) of the i;(A)(S) function. On the other hand, this definition coincides with the previous one (VI.6.37) as shown by a Simple change of variables, _l_JOOdttS-lTre-tA=_l_[dttS-l
res)
0
res)
0
L {A}
e- tA
= L _l_f"'dttS-le- tA {A}
res)
0
(V1. 6. 42)
1641
Applying this regularization scheme to Eq. (VI.6.35) we obtain
Aff = lim ..!{_l_ fdttS-l e
s+O ds res)
JdDpexp[-
tel + m2)]J
(VI.6.43)
where p~ is the momentum in the D-dimensional space-time. The function l/r(s) has a simple zero in s =O. Hence if we are willing to ignore the divergence of the t-integral in the extremum t =0, Eq. (VI.6.43) can be rewritten as follows:
idtJD d pexp [-
Aeff '" JOt
2 t(p2 + m)]
(VI.6.44)
The t = 0 divergence of the integral (VI.6.44) is simply a sympton of the ultraviolet divergences plaguing ordinary field theories and requiring regularization. We will see in a moment that the geometric reinterpretation of the integral (VI.6.44) inherent to string theory provides its natural regularization by means of selecting the proper integration domain. To this effect consider now a theory ~nich. instead of a simple bosonic field ~(x) of mass m2 , contains an infinite number of fields 2 9i(x). both bosonic and fermionic with masses ~. Define (VI. 6.45) where dB(m~) and dF(m~) are, respectively the number of bosonic and 1 1 2 fermionic states at mass level m.. 1
Since each field in the spectrum gives a contribution (VI.6.44) to the cosmological constant, counted positive if the field is a boson, and negative if a fermion, the overall one-loop cosmological constant can be wTitten as follows
A ff e
ex
[ -dtJ() dP 0 t
L
00
N=O
2 2 d(~) exp[- t(p
+
2 mN)]
(V1.6.46)
1642 Let us now assume that the spectrum utilized in Eq. (VI.6.46) is that of a superstring. In this case the mass-shell equations (VI.6.47a)
(LO - allen-shell> " 0
(VI.6.47b) imply (-
-1 DN2 + 2
( - -1 m..2 2 N
+
n Cg I -+ Ni=1 k + C
v
(l
)
I - - + N~ - a)
Cg i=1 k + Cv
lon-shell>" 0
(VI. 6. 48a)
lon-shell> '" 0
(VI. 6. 48b)
where, recalling Eqs. (VI.5.124) and (VI.5.125), the oscillator number operators N and N are defined by
N " N(Mink)
n +
(G.)
I
N
(VI.6.49a)
1
i=1
N" N(Mink)
+
I N(G
N
i ) + het
(VI. 6. 49b)
i .. 1
In simple words N(G), (N(G»
is that part of LO (respectively Lo)
which is not due to the zero mode Kac-Moody currents:
(VI. 6. 50)
For the Minl
..
·0
1 2 _ L(Mink)
-Zp·O
1 2
+Zm
(VI. 6. 51)
1643
while for the group parts J~J~ is the Casimir operator. Using Eqs. (VI.6.48) the mass ~ appearing ~n Sq. (VI.6.46) can be regarded as the eigenvalue of the following mass operator: (VI. 6. 52)
the degeneracy of the eigenvalue being precisely d(~) if we take into account only the closed string states belonging to a consistent Hilbert subspace fic ~ (see Eq. (VI.6.11)). Using the delta function (VI.6.14) to select the closed string states and inserting the GSO projector 1Pi to project onto .#'1' the effective cosmological constant (VI.6.46) takes the form A
eff
a:
i dt Jot
f-
-co
dx 21r
Tr(§"){pi exp[- t(LO + Lo -Il- (X) + ix(LO-
LO - a+ ii)j) (VI. 6.53)
J
where the integration dDp over the eigenvalues of the O-mode oscillator P~ has been included in the symbol Tr (~) denoting the trace over all states in the big Fock space (VI.6.8). Comparing Eq. (VI.6.53) with Eqs. (Vl.6.15) and (VI.6.16a). we see that we can identify the dummy parameter t with the inverse temperature B and hence with the imaginary part of t: t ::
(VI. 6.54)
B :: - 211 Imt
which allows the rewriting of (VI.6.S3) in the following manner: A
eff
::
i
J0
dImt 1111 t
I+ co dRet _1_ ~.(t) _CD
1m t
1
the partition function .'t. (t) being defined by Eq. (VI. 6. 17) • 1
(VI. 6. 55)
1644 In this way we have obtained the desired interpretation of the integral of 1L. (1") on the entire upper complex plane; it is the onel loop contribution to the cosmological constant as stated in Proposition 6.6.1 (see Eq. (VI.6.2D). The integral (Vl.6.S5) is divergent as are the individual integrals (VI.6.44) of which it is the infinite sum. The reason behind the divergence. however, becomes clear only in Eq. (VI.6.55) which naturally suggests the proper regularization. Suppose that the partition function !t.1 (t) happens to be PSL(2,1)-invariant, i.e. it fulfills conditions (VI.6.23). In this case, since the Weil-Petersson integration measure is also PSL(2,1)invariant, the integral (VI.6.5S) diverges for a simple reason: by letting t vary on the whole upper complex plane we take infinitely
many copies of the same finite integral [~i (t) d(Weil-Petersson), evaluated on the fundamental domain ~ of the modular group (see Eqs. (VI.2.246)). Hence, if this is the case the regularization is obvious: we must restrict the integration region of 1" to the fundamental domain a. Why should we expect that sri(t) is PSL(2,1)~invariant? There would be no ground for such an idea if the complex parameter T had no geometrical meaning. Actually T is the very modulus of a world-sheet torus and because of this Eqs. (VI.6.23) are a mandatory consistency requirement stating the invariance of a physical amplitude under the mapping class group. The above assertion follows from Proposition 6.6.2. Let us close this section by giving a heuristic proof of this proposition. Reconsider the trace (VI.6.17) and the definitions (VI.6.4) and (VI.6.S). Note that the operator exp [- 21T 1m T H]
1645 propagates a closed string through imaginary time - 2u 1m 1.
A matrix
element < fiexp(- 21flmt H)ii > could be tepresented as a path integral on a cylinder of circumference 211
Tf
and length 21f 1m T as shown below.
rm 1
ooE
)0
(J
()
(VI.6.56)
i
f
Correspondingly the trace Tr exp{ - 21f lm T H}
can be represented as a
path integral on a torus by gluing the ends of the cylinder as follows: f: i
(VI.6.S7)
Actually in the trace (VI.6.17) we have also the factor exp[i21l ReT
ii] .
This operator rotates the closed string by an angle
211 ReT.
Hence the
trace (VI.6.17) corresponds to a torus constructed by gluing together the ends of the open cylinder (VI.6.56) with a relative twist
21f Re T:
(VI. 6.58)
1646
This shows that or is indeed the modulus of a torus represented by the parallelogram (VI.2.66J with identified opposite sides. This is the heuristic argument behind Proposition 6.6.2 and hence behind the more precise Theorem 6.6.3. In the next three sections this crucial theorem which relates the functional and operatorial approaches will be proved for the case of the purely bosonic string. In Section VI.6.6 the proof will be extended to the fermionic strings by considering the relation between fermion determinants and Riemann theta functions already introduced in Chapter VI.2 (see Sq. (VI.2. 342)).
VI.6.3 Qperational evaluation of the bosonic string partition function
For pedagogical reasons, in the next three sections we focus on the bosonic string. Consider Sq. (VI.5.11) and set both ~ and the gravitino l-form I',; to zero. The result is the classical action of the bosonic string in a Minkowski space, which for quantum consistency tums out to be 26dimensional: (VI.6.59) The auxiliary fields n~ can be eliminated through their own equation of motion: (VI. 6.60) and (VI.6.59) becomes the following action
(VI.6.6l)
1647
where instead of the vielbein e±(~) we utilize the metric a (VI.6.62) and its detel'lllinant (VI.6.63) The inverse vielbein (V1.6.64a) (V1.6.64b) is also utilized to define the inverse metric (VI.6.65) and to relate the intrinsic derivatives a±xiJ. to the ordinary ones (VI.6.66) With these definitions Eq. (VI.6.61) is easily proved. Inserting (VI.6.60) into (VI.6.59) we get
(VI.6.67) and utilizing Eqs. (VI.6.63) and (VI.6.65) we obtain the result (VI.6.61). which will be OUr starting point for the discussion of the Polyakov path integral. Prior to this discussion, however, we want to show that the dimension of the target Minkowski space is D= 26.
1648
Recalling the definitions (VI.S.I2) and (VI.S.lS) we see that in the case of the bosonic string the stress-energy tensor is given by (VI.6.68a) ~
1
~j.I
-
1
j.I
T{f) "-P (i)PCz) " - -2 (a-x) 2 z
2
(VI. 6.68b)
and the corresponding central charges are c " D = number of space-time dimensions
(VI.6.69a)
c " D•
(VI.6.69b)
Since the world-sheet supersymmetry has been suppressed there is no superghost contribution and the analogues of Eqs. (VI.S.28) are the following conditions: 26 "D
(for left-movers)
(VI. 6. 70a)
26 "D
(for right-movers)
(VI. 6. 7Ob)
This shows that the target space has 26 dimensions. Recalling equations (VI.S.SS), in the conformal gauge we can write the follOWing mode expansion: (VI. 6. 71)
~~ere the operators X~. i~ obey the Heisenberg algebra (VI.S.S6), and the O-modes XO" XU = pU have been identified with one-half the momentum operator. Furthermore. recalling Eqs. (VI.5.S2) the complete LO' LO operators are given by
t
L(X) L0-- 0
+
L(ghost) 0
(VI.6.72a)
(VI.6.12b)
1649
where L(X)
o
,,!
r : X-nXn
+""
(VI. 6. 73a)
2 n=~w
L(X) ,,! r : X X : o 2 n=."" -n n +CO
(VI.6.73b)
and L(ghost)
o
= - ."" \' n • L' n=-
L~ghost) " _
c- c : n-n
r n : ~nC-n :
n
(VI. 6. 74a)
(VI. 6. 74b)
the ghost modes fulfilling the algebra (VI.5.48). Finally, recalling Eqs. (VI.S.123) the intercepts have the following values ~"
a"
(VI. 6. 75)
1 •
Indeed in the bosonic string there are no fermions and hence no spin structure to ,",'Ony about; thus the intercepts take a lUliversal value fixed once for all by Eq. (Vl.6.7S). For the same reason there are no c.1 [bel coefficients and consequently no GSO projection operator lP1•• This allows for an immediate calculation of the partition flUlction (VI. 6.17).
Inserting (VI.6.73) and (VI.6.74) into (VI.6.17) we find
(VI. 6. 76)
where we have defined (VI. 6. 77a)
1650 L(ghost) '!(gho t) (t) = Tr
ghost
S
= ['1__..._ (i)] * =
q0
(ghost)
~Lghost
= [ Tr q 0] * (8hOSt)
(VI. 6. 77b)
and where the variable q is given by equation (VI.6.18). The definition of the number operator follows from Eqs. (VI.6.Sl) and (VI.6.73). Its explicit form is (VI. 6. 78)
Redefining (VI.6.79a) (VI. 6. 79b) we obtain
(VI. 6. 80)
where as a consequence of Eq. (VI.5.56) the operators {a~tJ a~} form an infinite set of independent creation~absorption operators: (VI.6.81) Using this observation we can immediately calculate N(I) '1{X) (T) ., Tr q (X1
=
nD"n 1J=1 n=1
D
00
"n n
~(X)(T):
n alJt alJ Tr q
n
n
\.1'=1 n=1
n
2n + q3n + ••• ) " ( ..n
(1 + q + q
n _1)D
(1· q )
n=1
(VI.6.82)
1651 Comparing Eq. (VI.6.82) with the definition of the Dedekind eta function
net) :::
IT
ql/24
(1
~ qn)
(VI. 6. 83)
n=1 we conclude that
D/24 [ ~(x)(T) ::: q net) ]-D
.
The calculation of ~(ghost)(T)
(VI. 6. 84)
is similar.
From Eq. (VI.6.74) we
deduce (JO
L(ghost)
o
= L n N(ghost) n=l
(VI. 6.85)
(n)
where N(ghost) - (c
(n)
-
c + c-nc) n
(VI. 6. 86)
-n n
Hence we can write (JO
n
I(q)
(VI.6.87)
Nghost I(qn) ::: Tr(qn) (n)
(VI.6.8B)
~(ghost)::: IT
n=l
where
At each level n we have four possible ghost states 10,1>, 11,1>,
and
C_ncn
10,0>. 11,0>,
where the labels refer to the eigenvalues of c_ncn
respectively.
Starting from
10,0> they are given by
11,0 > ::: C-n 10,0 >
(VI.6.89a)
C-n 10,0 >
(VI.6.89b)
10,1 > :::
1652
11,1 > = c ~nc-n 10,0 > •
(VI.6.8k)
The states 10,0>, [1,1> have positive norm < 0.010,0> = < 1,111,1 > • 1
(VI. 6.90)
and belong to the eigenvalues 0 and 2 respectively of N~~ost). The states 11,0> and 10,1> have negative norm <
1,0[1,0 > = < 0,110,1 > = -1
(VI. 6. 91)
and span the eigenspace belonging to the eigenvalue -1 of
N~~ost).
With this information the trace I (qn) is immediately evaluated n
n
n
I (q ) " 1 - q - q
+
2n n2 q '" (1 - q) •
(VI,6.92)
Inserting this result into Eq. (VI.6.81) and comparing it with the definition of the Dedekind eta we get ~ghost(T)
= q-2/24
12
(VI.6.93)
In(r).
Inserting fUrthermore Eqs. (VI.6.84) and (VI.6.93) into (VI.6.76) and evaluating the gaussian integral in the momentum p, we obtain the final result D-2
D~2
!l(T) .. const e
4'1r Imt
_~
(qq)
(Iu)
-2
[n(t)
1-2(0-2) (VI.6.94)
At this point. recalling the modular transformation properties of the n-function: S : n( - lit) T : neT + 1)
= (- i
T)l/2 n(T)
= ei'lr/12 n('t)
(VI.6.95a) (VI.6.9Sb)
1653 we see that the function
Z~~~(t) =
D-2 (lmt) - -2 In(t)r 2 (O-2)
(VI.6.96)
is modular invariant for any value of the dimension D: (VI.6.97a)
(D)
Z(X) (t + 1)
(D) = Z(x) (t)
(VI. 6. 97b)
Hence, since Eq. (VI.6.94) can be rewritten as follows: (V1.6.98) we conclude that ~(t) is moduiar invariant only for that value of the parameter 0 which reduces the factor
to a constant. To no one's surprise this value is D= 26, the same number of space-time dimensions seleCted by the conformal anomaly cancellation (VI.6.70). Hence in 0 =26 the one-loop contribution of the bosonic string to the cosmological constant is given by (VI. 6.99)
In order to prove Theorem 6.6.3 we need to show that the same result (VI.6.99) is obtained by calculating the Polyakov path integral. We do this in the next sections.
1654 VI.6.4 The Polyakov integration measure for the bosonic string
In order to give a precise meaning to the functional integral (VI.6.25) we proceed as follows. In the bosonic string case we set (VI.6.I00)
where SIg.xl is the Euclidean analogue of the action (VI.6.61), in which the sign of the metric determinant has been flipped: (VI.6.101) and where a ' is a dimensionful parameter needed to make the exponent in (Vl.6.100) dimensionless. The action (VI.6.101) has the dimensions of a squared length since its value is the area of the world-sheet. Hence we have (VI.6.l02) The parameter (l' is the so-called Regge slope of the old dual models and provides the fundamental unit in terms of which all the masses of the string particle spectrum are measured. It can be reabsorbed in the embedding function X~(t). Indeed X~(~) has the dimension of a length and therefore we can use natural units defined by the following condi· tion 1 1 --=81Ia 2
(VI.6.l03)
l
With this convention, Eq. (VI.6.100) can be rewritten as follows: (VI.6.104)
1655
where
~
g
is the Laplacian on the surface L equipped with the metric
(VI.6.lOS) and where the scalar product <. > of functions defined over the surface L is given by (VI.6.106) The scalar product (VI.6.106) induces the definition of a norm for the functions X~(;):
IIxIl g2 =<x,x> g
(VI. 6. 107)
and this norm can be utilized to define gaussian functional integrals. Formally we declare that the following path integral over all the functions x~(~) is equal to unity: (VI.6.108)
This implicitly defines the integration measure. Next we decompose the functions X~{~) in a constant mode x~ plus a deviation x~(;) whose average value is zero: X~(;)
= x~
+
x~(;)
J~ x~(;) rg i; " 0
(VI.6.109a) (VI. 6.109b)
Substituting (VI.6.109) into (VI.6.10B) we obtain (VI.6.110)
1656 Defining the volume Q(g) of the surface
E: (VI. 6.111)
we find 2n )1/2 J-~.. dXo exp[ - '21_2Xo Sl(g)} = ( Sl(g)
(VI. 6. 112)
and hence the normalization:
JDxg
)J
(~)
1 2 f'~(g) exp[--Ilxlll 2 g = - 211
(VI.6.113)
which implicitly defines the functional integration measure on the deviation functions
x)J(~).
Next we observe that. since E is a compact surface,
xIJ(~)
can
be decomposed into eigenfunctions of the Laplacian operator Il whose g spectrum is discrete: (VI.6.114)
n e N and (i) labels the possible degeneracy of the eigenvalue An' where
The eigenfunctions y(i)(~) n
can be orthonormalized: (VI.6.115)
and we can write (VI.6.1l6)
where cIJ( "J are numerical coefficients. Notice that the constant n~l mode xIJo belongs to the kernel of A and as such it is orthogonal to " g all the y~ (~) belonging to non-vanIshing eigenvalues. Hence in order
1657 for x~(;) to fulfill condition (VI.6.109b) it suffices that the summa~ tion in (VI.6.116) be restricted to the eigenfunctions belonging to nonzero An' In this way we obtain an explicit representation of the functional integration measure defined by Eq. (VI.6.113):
(VI. 6. 117)
Given these preliminaries we begin by calculating the functional integral on embedding functions at a given 2-dimensional metric gaa' Setting
.r (g) '"
J!2." Xll
g
exp{ ~ !. < X, A X > J g
2
(VI.6.118)
we observe that xi! .... X\.l + l(~ is a symmetry of the classical action corresponding to the invariance of the background metric n\.lV under the Poincare group. Hence .9"(g) is ill-defined and we must divide it by the (infinite) volume of the target space translation group Vol(transl) =
f
+CO
1
dX O •••
I+<X>
-c;o
This is easily done
by
D
dXO
(Vr. 6.119)
-00
replacing
.9"(g) ... ft· (g)
(VI.6.120)
where we have defined (VI.6.121) Substituting (VI.6.116) and (VI.6.117) into (VI.6.121) we get
1658 ~I (g) "
"
D IT \l=1
I(CO
deg An del! IT n (n.i) n=l i .. 1 f2i
exp[.! (e" 2
n
)2 A (n,U n
)
1/2
J (S2(g») " 2n
(VI. 6. 122)
where det t Ag
is the dete1'Jllinant of the Laplacian in which the contri-
bution of the O-modes has been OllIitted.
Using this result the Polyakov
path integral (VI.6.104) reduces to
9' ;;
f ~g (
12(g) 211'det' A g
'j>/2 •
(VI. 6. 123)
J
In order to make the above integral well defined we need to factor out the volumes of the symmetry groups of the classical Lagrangian. that is. the Diffeomorphism group and the Weyl group.
Clearly this will reduce
the integration domain in (VI. 6.123) from the space of all metrics Met (1:g) to the moduli space Mg (see Eq. (VL2.27)). The problem is to insert the correct Jacobian. The strategy we follow to solve this
problem starts from the follOWing consideration. Let M be a manifold and T (M)
be the tangent space to M.
Let
tql ••••• ~} be the coordinates of a point p E M and
be the integral we are interested in evaluating.
be a coordinate transformation.
Let
Then I becomes (VI. 6. 126)
1659
where F' " F
0
f
(VI. 6.127)
and J(q') is the Jacobian it f. '" det a.,f. aq! 1 J 1 J
J(q'} .. det -
(VI.6.128)
The transformation (VI.6.12S1 induces a transformation in the tangent space T(M). If (VI.6.129)
is a vector (veT (~I)), then after the transformat ion (VI. 6 .125) its new components will be given by the relation {VI. 6. 130)
It follows that. calling coordinate transformation integral performed on the
i K. (q) the matrix of the change induced by a J on the tangent vectors and considering an tangent vectors (VI. 6.131)
we have (VI. 6. 132)
where J(a') '" det K(q) " J(q)
(VI.6.133)
This means that the Jacobian calculated in the tangent space coincides with the Jacobian calculated directly on the manifold.
1660
Relying an this we define the integration measure an the tangent space to the manifold M by setting 1
=f
T (M)
q
[da] exp( _1 lIall 2 ) 2 q
(VI.6.134)
where Tq(M) denotes the tangent space{ai the p:i}nt q= {ql .....
2
= ai aj
(VI. 6. 135)
gij(q)
Writing [da]
n
dai
i=l
f2ii
= N(q) n ----
(VI.6.136)
we see that Eq. (VI.6.134) implies da f nn -ffi i
1 = N(q)
i=1
1 T exp( - - a g a) 2
N(q)
=- -
{detg'
(VI.6.137)
Hence N(q) =
Idetg .
(VI. 6.138)
Starting from Eq. (VI.6.134) we can calculate the Jacobian J(a'). which is to be identified with J(q'), by means of the following procedure. A tangent vector ai
is an infinitesimal change of the coordinate
(VI. 6. 139)
Hence we obtain
1661
1"
JT (M)
[daJ exp(.l II a11 2 ) = 2
q
=f
J(a')[da'] exp(.1IlKa'1I 2 ) =
T (M)
2
q
= J(q) J Tq{M)
= J(q)
q
q
1 T' T Ida'] exp(--a K gKa ' } 2
[det (KTg K)j -1/2 (det g)I/2
= J(q)
(VI.6.140)
det K which in view of Eq. (VI.6.133) is an identity as it should be. Let us now apply this general technique to the infinite-dimensional manifold Met (L) of all metries on a compact surface with g-handles. g
Recalling the results of Chapter VI.2 (see in particular picture (VI.2.134» we define a slice of Met (Lg) transverse to the action of the diffeomorphism and of the Weyl group in the following way. Let gaS ('l"""n) be a set of constant curvature metrics, parametrized by n Tei chmuller parameters (n :; 0 for g" 0; n" 1 for g" 1; n =3g-3 for g ~ 2) such that a g is orthogonal to the image of Lr
PI defined in Eq. (VI.2.92).
In other words, the metric variations (VI. 6.141)
are quadratic differentials for the metric gaS(L): 'i'i
e ker
pi
where we have utilized the notations of Eq. (VI.2.99). action of a diffeomorphism r:,fJ. ..... l\~)
(VI.6.142) Calling f* the
(VI. 6 .143)
1662 on the metric and on the embedding functions Xil (~) ,
the action of the
Weyl e Diffeomorphism group on the space of metrics e embeddings can be written as follows: (VI.6.I44)
Hence we can change coordinate system in the metrics.e embeddings manifold by writing (VI.6.14S) Given the metric gaa(t),
xP
denotes a slice of the space of embeddings
which is transverse to the action of the conformal Killing subgroup of the diffeomorphism group. In simple words. this means that Xli is not annihilated by any of " the conformal Killing vectors of the metric gaB (Tl'·.·.Tn.~): +
if
A e ker PI .
(V!.6.146)
We remind the reader that the conformal Killing vectors were defined in
Eq. (VI.2.100). Let uS introduce a basis for ker PI:
s • l •••. ,dim (ker Pi) •
(VI.6.147)
Given this basis every tangent vector (generator of the Diffeomorphism group) t(l(;)
can be written as follows: (VI.6.148)
where the
decompo~ition
is orthogonal with respect to the scalar product ~
(VI. 2.85) • In other words the tangent vector t
ker Pi:
is orthogonal to
1663 (V1.6.149)
Similarly the most general variation ogaa(t) of the metric can be decomposed as in Sq. (VI.2.89). Recalling fUrthermore Eq. (VI.2.99) we can write (VI. 6. 150)
pi
pi).
where 1/1~ provides a basis for ker (r:;; l ..... dim ker Tben utilizing the method previously explained we come to the implicit definition of our functional measures. We set 1 ..
IT-/
1 ..
JTg(Met)
1=
I
1 ::
JTx& [d(c5X)] g exp( --21 lI&ill g2 )
(VI.6.1S1d)
1 ..
IT !I [dt]g eXP(-i Ilt ll !)
(Vl.6.1S1e)
[d(6X)] exp(-t g
TIj)(r')
g
(VI.6.151a)
-i !loglI!)
(V1.6.1S1b)
Uc5cPU 2 )
(VI. 6. ISle)
g
[d(ogJ]g exp(
[d(6cP)]
lIoXll 2 )
1 exp(--2
g
f where Tx/. Tg (Met),
Tlt).
Tf~
are the tangent spaces to the
manifolds of the embeddings, of the metrics, of the conformal group and
of the diffeomorphism group, at the points I, g, cP and f respectively. (Similarly for the restricted embeddings X). Our goal is to obtain the Jacobian [d(6g)]g[d(oX)]g ..
:;; J(t,cP,f,X) • d(o't)[d(ocPJ] g[dt] gld(OX) 19
(VI.6.152)
1664
where we have called (VI.6.1S3)
The norms are defined by the scalar products (VI.2.82) and (VI.2.SS) for the metric and the tangent vectors, by Sq. (VI.6.106) for the embedding functions, and by the following scalar product for the Weyl transformation: (VI. 6. 154} Let US proceed as in Eq. (VI.6.140). We have (VI. 6. 155a) (VI.6.1S5b) where
...
f* t
(VI. 6.156)
A key point now is that the norms utilized in defining the gaussian integration measures (VI.6.1S1) are invariant under diffeomorphisms, although they are not invariant under Weyl transformations. Hence we have (VI. 6. 157a)
(VI.6.157b) Now the decomposition (VI.6.148) inserted into the measure (VI.6.151e) yields
1665
J [dt~] g d a exp( -2' II~lt I ) exp( -2' aras Hrs(P» k
• J(l)
1
2
1
(VI.6.158) where we have set
k = dim ker Pl = dim [Aut (Eg)] H (P)
rs
=
f it Ii'
(VI. 6. 159a)
L .. II AS • -aprs
(VI. 6. 159b)"--
Using (VI.6.158) and repeating the argument for the calculation of the Jacobian defined by Eq. (VI.6.152) we can write 1
= J(21f)-k/2 (detH(p»1/2
Id(01:) d(li.)- [dtJ- [dCoX)]-dka' g
g
g
1 ~~~r N21g a 2 'exp(-'2!1liX+t.aX+a Ar·axli -'2i!V't+oq,g+ot. Cl1:g11 :J(2lT)·k/2 (detH(p»1/2 jd(OT)d(OI/l)_ g
[dtJ-g
>=
[d(OXJ]_dkaexp(--zl Q) g
(VI.6.160)
Let us calculate the gaussian integral. We define two new objects:
x(r)
as
a - --g I - -yo a as 2 as g -at g r yo
(VI.6.161a)
=-g ilt r
(VI.6.1610) and we obtain
III"/{a t S} +
o$iaS
+
Ot~ a~ iaSII2 = 1101/1' g 112 r
+
!Iohll 2 (VI.6.162)
1666 where (VI.6.163a) (VI. 6. 163b) the vector bs being defined by the equation which characterizes the conformal Killing vectors: (VI.6.164)
and the operator PI being defined, as usual, by Sq. (VI.2.92). Hence, using the following 5-row vector notation
(VI. 6.165)
and introducing the matrix 1 l'rVa.,Sr' 0, bs 0, , 0, 0, 0 A"
0,
0 , 1 , 0, 0
0, 0(1!' 0,
o,
(VI. 6.166)
1, 0
0 , 0, 0, 1
whose determinant is one det A '" 1
(VI.6.167)
we have the following expression for the quadratic form Q appearing in the exponential of Eq. (VI.6.160):
1667 (VI. 6.168a)
v'
= Av
(VI. 6. 168b)
where the matrix M has the following block diagonal form
M '"
(
1, 0, 0) 0,
if,
02
0,
0 ,
W
(VI.6.169a)
with
Pl1
J ..
('
X~rll
PI Xes)
t •
)
(VI. 6. 169b)
X~r) X(s) JJ
w2 '"
( 1
w~)
"['J t]J
)
(VI.6.169c)
JJ
W(r) tIl(s)
In Eqs. (VI.6.169), X~~) is to be regarded as an operator which acting on dr converts it into the traceless metric deformation: s (VI.6.170)
t The operator Xes) is determined from the scalar product
<
t s h • Xes) dr (s) > '" X(s)h dT ... (VI. 6 .171)
1668 Hence we have
(VI.6.172) In a completely similar way w~(~) is the operator which acting on as transforms it into an embedding variation 6XU(~). We have (VI.6.172a) (VI.6.172b) Inserting Eqs. (VI.6.168) and (VI.6.169) into (VI.6.160) we obtain the expression of the Jacobian J
det U2 det \'12
=
(VI.6.173)
det Hep)
where the numerical factors have been dropped. To calculate det u2 we diagonaUze the matrix u2 • The traceless metric deformation was written as in Eq. (Vl.6.163) but it also admits the decomposition (VI.6.174) where ~~) is a basis for the space of quadratic differentials. that t is, for ker Pl' Comparing Eq. (VI.6.174) and (VI.6.163) we obtain ljIr 6T , = P1(t-t') +
r
l6-r
r
t and, introducing the projection operat?r on ker Pl'
(VI. 6.175)
1669 (VI. 6.176)
Defining the matrix (VI. 6. 177)
we <:an write
(VI. 6. 178)
where (VI.6.179) Obvi ous 1 y we find
det
~
= det Tsr •
(VI, 6. 180)
Now we observe that calling
(VI.6.181)
we have
(VI.6.182)
and since
1670
I r,,1'1 ~l we
(VI. 6. 183)
can write {VI.6.184}
Now
I~p
>
H~l pq
<
~q I is the identity operator in the space ker ptl
while Pl(P!Pl)-lPi is the identity operator in (ker Pill. we have (VI. 6. 185)
from which we obtain (VI.6.186)
where, as usual det I denotes the determinant where the O-mode contribution has been omitted. This result, inserted into Sq. (VI.6.173), allows the following transcription of the original path integral (VI .6.104):
where .9"(T) ..
I I lg dX
detWe-S(i,X] ..
. f [dxl g detWexp[-}< X,flgX "I·
(VI. 6. 188)
A very similar integral was already defined in Eq. (VI.6.118) and calculated in Eqs. (VI.6.120, 121. 122). The only difference resides in
1671 the restriction to the slice X transverse to the action of Aut (kg) and in the presence of the determtnant of the matrix W. In the Appendix to this chapter we show that (VI.6.189) where v(.) is the volUlIle of the finite group Aut (kg):
Vet)
=I
~
1=1
da. 1
= Vol
(Aut
(E
g
»
(VI.6.190)
so that utilizing the result (VI.6.122) we can finally write
fI =
I
n det < ljiSI Xl' > d • -;====;=====/ det H{pi) det H(P 1)
• (det'
t 1/2 1 ( 2n det Pl -1) vet)
I
llg )- 0/2
.
(VI. 6. 191)
!leg)
The interpretation of the various factors appearing in Eq. (VI.6.191) is the following: det < wSlx > -;====;;===r====- dnt ::; d(l'Ieil-Petersson) I det H(Pi) det H(P 1)
I det' (Pip 1) Vol (Aut
eE»
211 det' Ag ( --~ ) !'I (g)
- D/2
(0) = z(X) = ~
(VI.6.192a)
(VI. 6 . 192b)
d(Weil-Petersson) being the mapping class group invariant measure in moduli space and ~(X)(t) being the partition function associated to the XU-system, which in our case coincides with the full partition function.
1672 VI.6.S Functional evaluation of the bosonic string partition function in the case of the torus In this section we explicitly evaluate both the measure (VI.6.192a) and the partition function (VI.6.l92b) in the case where the world-sheet has the topology of a torus. We first retrieve the operatorial result (VI.6.99). Recallingpicture (VI.2.66) and Eqs. (VI.2.l06), (VI.2.222), on a torus the line element can be alternatively written as
2 _ 1 z~ ds '" dzdz - (gzz- = -2 ; g = 2)
(VI. 6.193)
utilizing complex coordinates, or as (VI. 6. 194a)
(VI. 6. 194b)
utilizing real coordinates. Note that in Eq. (VI.6.194) we have reabsorbed the factor 1/2~ into the definition of the coordinates ~a which now vary in the interval [0,11. From (VI.6.194b) we obtain
;g =
Im T
(VI. 6. 19Sa)
as = - -1 -
(VI.6.19Sb)
g
(Im T) 2
Q(g) "
ri; Ii = ImT
•
(VI. 6. 19Sc)
As we know from Chapter VI.2, the conformal automorphism group of the torus is given by the translations
1673 (VI.6.196)
Clearly to can vary on the torus itself, namely, it is defined up to lattice vectors. Hence the volume of the conformal Killing group coincides with the volume of the torus: (VI.6.197)
Furthermore, a conformal Killing vector, namely, a generator of the translation (VI.6.196), is given in real notation by (VI. 6.198) Correspondingly, recalling Eq. (VI.6.147) we can set (VI. 6 . 199a)
A:{t
• '" 1
(VI, 6. 199b)
The matrix H(Pl) is immediately evaluated. Substituting Eqs. (Vr.6.199) and (VI.6.19S) into Eq. (VI.6.159) we get
(VI. 6.200)
So
that det H (PI) rs
const' (Irnr)2 •
(V1.6.201)
Let us now consider the quadratic differentials. On the torus, as we know from Chapter VI.2, the space of these differentials has one complex dimension. Indeed, the solution of the equation:
1674
v.% h%Z ..
0
(VI. 6.202)
2 is provided by the constants which span H (I 1). Hence we can set (VI.6.203)
where
iu .. 1
2 .. i
(VI. 6. 204)
"'%%
is an explicit repnsentation of the basis
I/I~) utilized in Eq.
(VI.6.1S0). We obtain
t
Hrs (PI) ~ < l/Ir ll/ls > ..
(VI.6.20S)
and hence (VI.6.206)
~. These were alnady computed in Chapter VI.2. There we showed that under the infinitesimal shift (VI.2.249) the variation of the metric is given by Eqs. (VI.2.252) and We still need the slice deformations
(VI.2. 253). Hence we bave (VI.6.207)
wbere
X1 : :i u
IlIIt
2
Xzz
1 =--1m!
(VI.6.20B)
1675
With these identifications we obtain < X1'1 1/1s >..
I
5 r d2z ~~ g gti gzi" (Xl' 1/1-+ )(~-
zt
ZZ
.. const
(~
'~a
s
zz ) =
1/1
(VI. 6. 209)
:)
which yields (VI. 6. 210) Results (VI.6.201J, (VI.6.206) and (VI.6.210) inserted into Eq. (VI.6.192a) give the Correct Weyl-Petersson measure on the space of tori;
i t_ d(Weyl-Petersson) " const __ (lm'[ )2
.
(VI.6.211)
On the other hand, using Eqs. (VI.6.197) and (VI.6.195c) the partition function reduces to D-2 .2"(t) ..
const· (ImT)2 {det' PiPl)1 / 2 (det' 6gf D/2
(VI. 6. 212)
If Theorem 6.6.3 were true we should find that the function defined by Eq. (VI.6.212) coincides with the function (VI.6.9B). We will see in a moment that this happens in the critica.l dimensions D" 26. Indeed, irrespectively of the value of D, the partition function as defined by (VI.6.212) is equal to D-2 ~{'[J .. !reD) ..
(X)
(Imr)--2-ln(T)I- 2 (O-2)
(VI. 6. 213)
The proof of this result goes in two steps. First, recalling Eqs. (VI.2.39) and (VI.2.114) we note that on a torus, where the conformal factor ~(z,i) can be set everywhere equal to zero, we have t
(P1P1)t z : - 2(V-V)t zzz
=-
2(3-a )t zzz
(VI. 6. 214a)
1676 t (PIP1)tz = - 2(VzV~)t t z = - 2(a za·}t. z z
(Vl.6.214b)
so that, utilizing a matrix notation, we can write
(VI. 6. 215)
~
g
being the Laplacian on scalar functions f
~ f =- 4 g
az.. a..
..L Ii aa (gO$Ig all
f .. -
l"
f)
(VI. 6. 216)
Indeed Eq. (VI.6.216) can be verified using Eqs •. (VI.6.195) and their consequence :
a = _ iz
a-
z
21m.
a
(f l •
a
a2)
= - _ i- (t 1 21m!
(VI. 6. 217a)
a2)
(VI .6. 217b)
From Eq. (VI.6.21S) we obtain t
det PIP l
= (2"1 detAg) 2
det' ptp .. 1 1
..
(12 det' Ag )2 '
(VI.6.218)
Hence Eq. (VI.6.212) can be rewritten as 1)...2
!"(t)
= const.
(1m t)-2- (det t ~) g
_ (D-2)
2
(VI.6.219)
and the result (VI.6.213) follows by inserting into Eq. (VI.6.219) the value of the determinant det' Ag which is found to be det' Il = (Imt)2In(t) 14 g
•
(VI, 6.220)
1677
The proof of Eq. (VI.6.220) is the goal of the next section, where the functional determinant will be evaluated by means of the I;;-function regularization scheme. Actually while calculating dat' A we shall g also calculate the determinant of the Dirac operator » exhibiting its dependence on the spin structure. This will pave the way for the extension of our results to the superstring case.
VI.6.6 Functional determinants of the Laplacian and of the Dirac operator on the torus A scalar on the torus is a function in both coordinates ~1' ~2:
~(~1';2)
which is periodic
(VI. 6. 221)
As such it can be expanded in exponential functions: (VI.6.222)
(VI.6.223)
The
~(nl.n2)(~)
are eigenfunctions of the Laplacian
(VI .6. 224)
with eigenvalues (V1.6.225)
1682
where
1;:~a,bJ(S)" _1_ res)
idttS-l
10
L
{n 1,n 2 u}
expl_t[<W)+ )(a,b)]2 J . nl'n 2 {VI. 6.245)
In Eq. (VI.6.245) we exploited the property of the eigenvalues (VI.6.Z41) of being arranged in pairs of opposite sign. This implies
(VI. 6. 246)
which justifies the position (VI.6.Z45). We shall now proceed to evaluate the determinant (VI.6.244) in the case of the even spin st ruct ures : (VI. 6.247)
setting aside the case of the odd spin structure (V1.6.248) which involves some additional subtleties. As the reader can verify by inspecting Eqs. (VI.6.Z36), the spin structures are classified as even or odd depending on whether the corresponding theta is an even or odd function of the variable z sweeping the Jacobian variety. Clearly the odd thetas vanish at z = O. This is just a signal that for odd spin structures the Dirac operator has zero modes which make its determinant zero, while for even spin structures ~ is zero-mode~free. This connection between the parity of the theta functions and the existence of O-modes is manifest from Eq. (VI.6.Z41); indeed we see that A~ never vanishes for any n1, nZ e Z, unless
1683 WI .. tAl2 .. 0 .. a :: b :: 1 •
(VI. 6. 249}
In the case of the odd-spin structure we are obliged to remove the contribution of the ~ero-modes by excluding in the sum on "I' n2 the case (0,0). In that case we have (VI .6. 250)
the right hand side of Eq. (VI.6.250) being defined by Eqs. (VI.6.227) and (VI. 6. 228). Even Spin Structures
~:
Substituting Eq. (Vl.6.241) into (VI.6.245) we obtain
(VI.6.251) Introducing the new variable
r"
4" - t -(1m l)2
(VI.6.252)
we can rewrite (VI.6.251) as follows:
~[a,b] (s) (J')
.. _1_
res)
[.!!l]2S Joo dyl-l u(a,b] (r,l) 21i
0
(VI. 6. 253a)
1684
u[a,b] (y,T) can be rewritten in a more con-
The integrand function
venient form utilizing the following identity, known as the Jacobian inversion formula:
L
exp [ • lfY(iii2 + 2mx)
mez+v
I ,.
2 lfyX
i
=_e_
IY
If
2
exp[--m +21fh(x+v)J.
(VI. 6. 254)
Y
mel
By use of Sq. (VI.6.254), Sq. (Vl.6.2S3) can be rewritten as follows:
~[a,b] ( )
=
s
(J»
p[a,b]{s,r)
_1_ (1m T )2S p[a,b1 (s T) res) 21i
= L
L
me Z Ii e Z + WI x
Io ¢O
dyy
(VI.6 •2SSa)
'
5-3/2
exp[ - 21fim (Retii+oo2)] x
.2
2
11'
2
exp[ -lfyn (lmT) - -m y
I. (VI.6.255b)
To calculate the limit (VI.6.244) we observe that the function
l/r(s)
has a simple zero at s" 0 1 --,. s
res)
+ h2s
Z+
(VI.6.Z56)
•••
Hence, for any regular function F(s)
which does not vanish at
5
=0
we find
lim 5+ 0
..! ds
(_1_ Fe ») '" res) S
lim F(s) .
(VI.6.257)
5+0
In our case F(s) '"
(1m T )25 p[a,b] (5, T) zlii
so that we obtain
(VI. 6. 258)
1685
-lndet[a] b
~
.. lim
p[a,b](S,T).
(VI.6.259)
s+O
Substituting Eq. (VI.6.25Sb) into (VI.6.259) we get: -R.ndet[a] ll .. lim b
L
p[a,b]eS,T)"
s+O
L
{melt {nez+w1}
exp [ - 21ri m (Re t Ii ~ ~)] 1- (T) n,m
+
mjl 0 1 +
lim S" 0
I
i
{ii eZ of- w } J0
njI 0
dy l-3/2
r
exp .11'1 ti2 (Im t) 2]
1
+
const (VI. 6. 260)
where we have separated the contribution from m" 0 and defined: (VI.6.261)
The integrals of the type (VI.6.261) can be exactly evaluated using the formula
fa
dy Y-3/2
exp [ - (ay +
~) J '" ff exp (- 2 lOA)
(VI.6.262)
we then obtain
n,m (T) = _1 !ml exp( - 21r Imrlml inll
L
(VI.6.263)
We still have to take care of the limit appearing in Eq. (VI.6.260). We set
1686
(VI.6.264)
where
(VI. 6. 265)
If wi" 0 we have IfO(t) " ~ (t),
whicb is finite at t,,·1.
Hence.
using 1 2
f(.-)=.211i"
(VI.6.266)
!. Imt.
(VI.6.267)
we get o{O,t) "
3
In a similar way we get 1 o('2,t) ...
6"'II 1mt.
(VI. 6. 268)
Putting our results together we find -R.ndet[a] fJ" (1b even
a
1T
'2)'3 1mr
+
Let us now consider the various choices of [ :
spin structure
[~J.
J.
In the case of the
for instance, Eq. (VI.6.269) can be written as
1687
-.tn det [011
~ '" !. 1m!
'"
+
3
m
2 L m"l
00
1::lL L m
(qlllll + qlllll)
n"1
,.
" 2
L .!.. 1I.n q -.tn 1 24
I
= -.tn q1/24
Ii
n
(1 + qn) -
n=1
.!.. R.n q 24
(1 + qn J [2
.
tn IT
n=1
(1+
I'" (V1.6.270)
n",l
Comparing Eq. (VI.6.270) with Eq. (VI.6.236c) we conclude that
~
det
=
(VI. 6.271)
[6] In a similar way, we show from Eq. (Vl.6.269) that for the other even spin structures the following is true:
e[:](OIT)
12
(VI. 6. 272)
n(T)
Case B: Odd SEin Structure In the case of the odd spin structu~e the calculation of the ~ function (VI.6.228) is performed in a manner identical to the previous case except for one particular. In order to use the Jacobi inversion formula (VI.6.254) it is necessary that all the summations go over all integer numbers.
Hence before applying the identity (VI.6.254) the integrand function u[l,l] is rewritten as follows:
1688
2
+00
l
x
m exp[ .1fy(m -2mnReT)]
+
·00
2
+00
Lm exp(-1fym].
+
(VI. 6. 273)
-00
The first term in (VI.6.273) contributes to
[1
~~'
II' (s)
an addend
_1_(Imr)2S p[l,l] (S,T)
res) zliT which can be treated as in the previous case. The second term gives an additional addend:
1 (IffiT)2S[ dyys-l \'
Q(s;r) '" - - - -
res)
l.
211T
[ 2]
exp -l1ym
(VI.6.274)
m/O
0
By a change of the integration variable we obtain
Q(S,l)
= L ( -ImT)2S
2-5 1 (m) -
res)
m/O 211T
r
dww5-1 exp(-w)
= 2 [ -Clm't)2]S ; , ; - l;(2s}
(VI.6.275)
Then we calculate the limit
Sl!~ d~
2[ cr::)z ]\(2S) = • tn(Im e)2
+
= Un [ (1::)2
]~(O)
const .
= (VI. 6. 276)
USing this result we can write
fi]
- ...nn det'
IJI P
= - ",n (1 me)2 •
+
sl';mo p[l,I] (5,"') '
(VI.6.277)
1689'
where in full analogy to the previous calculations we have lim s+ 0
l
+
l
exp{ - 2tri mRu - 2n
Imt Imllnl J ..
( mezt fnelt m~
..
w
01 ln~ 01
Ron InCr)!
4
•
(Vl.6.278)
Combining Eq. (VI.6.27S) with Eqs. (VI.6.277) and (VI.6.2S0) we finally get (VI.6.279)
which is the promised proof of Eq. (VI.6.220). Using this identity the results we have obtained for the Dirac determinant on the torus can also be rewritten as:
det il
l:1
(&[:1(0\10)1/2 (
Ii detlmnY/4
2
(VI.6.280)
(det I A) 1/4
where II .. 't is the period matrix. Various arguments in algebraic geometry together with the discussion of Section VI.2.S suggest that Eq. (VI.6.280) should be the correct answer for det
~[bl
not only on
the torus but also on higher genus Riemann surfaces. Equation (VI,6.280) is very important for the following reason: as it appears from the explicit formulae we obtained for the case of the torus, the function
1690
(VI.6.281)
is analytic in the moduli. Recalling the structure (VI.6.230) of the Dirac operator we can rewrite Sq. (VI.6.280) as follows: (VI.6.282) This is a case of a general phenomenon known as holoDlOrphic factorization. Given an operator A which maps a nolomorphic bundle B on the Riemann surface into another bundle 8' and given its adjoint (VI. 6. 283a)
A : B .... 8'
(VI. 6. 283b)
we find that (VI. 6.284)
where geT) is an analytic function of the moduli. When this happens we are entitied to define the chiral determinant of the operator A by setting (VI. 6. 285)
det A " get)
In our case we can write
det
(-2i VA) '"
[;1
z
a]
ef (oln) ( _ _ _.....J...,b'-''--_ _ __
(J Ii det 1m n) -1/2 (det' A) 1/2
)1/2 (VI. 6. 286)
1691
which on the torus reduces to
(-2i ()_) =
det [ :]
Z
z[ a] (T) '~
:] (olt) (VI. 6. 287a)
neT)
b
:] (olt) (V!. 6. 28Th)
n*(t)
The formulae (VI.6.287) admit an operatorial verification. Let A(z) be a Majorana-Weyl world-sheet spinol'. Its space-like boundary conditions are specified by a number a e Z2: (VI. 6. 288)
the mode expansion of A(z) depends on the value of a (which decides whether A(z) is a Ramona or a Neveu-Schwarz spinol' (see Chapter VI.S» and the corresponding normal ordered L~ operator reads
r
1.... 1 I a =Lo [n+-+-(1-a)1'A A 2 n=-oo 2 2 • ~n-~(l-a) n+~(l-a)
(VI.6.289)
Apart from L~ one can also define the fermion number operator a 1 +00 F =- ~'II
(VI. 6. 290)
A
2 n;-~' -n-~(l-a) n+~(l-a)
In terms of this operator one finds
Tr exp(21Ji
[(L~-..!..+ a2 )t+ ~Fa]} .. 48
16
2
(e[:](0It)jI2 net)
(VI.6.291)
where the parameter b is also a z2-element (0,1). To show Eq. (VI.6.291) it suffices to recall the infinite product representations (VI.6.236) of the thetas. Eq. (VI.6.291) shows the identity between the
1692
operatorial and the functional definition of the partition function also at the level of the fermion contributions. Furthermore we see that, while the boundary conditions on the a-cycles correspond to the choice of either Ramond or Neveu-Schwarz moding, those on the b-cycles corresFa pond to the insertion of either a factor 1 or a factor (-) in the operatorial trace. Combinations of the following type (VI.6.292)
are projection operators in the Foet space. This is the logical link connecting GSO projection operators and the summation on different spin structures required by multiloop modular invarience. VI.6.7 The gravitino ghost In the case of the heterotic superstrings the cosmological constant can be written as follows:
Aa
I d(Weil-Petersson) ~(tl,···,tn)
(VI.6.293)
where the partition function is a product of several terms: n !'-Z(D).Z(D). II Z - (X) (~) ial (Gil
·z
(het)
·z
(gravltino)
(VI.6.294)
Let us discuss the various factors: Z(G.) is the partition function associated to the supersymmetric 1
WZW-model of the group G1.. It will be discussed at length in the following chapter. z~X) was defined in Eq. (VI.6.192b) and, on the torus, it takes the explicit form (VI.6.213).
zi~~ is the determinant of the chiral Dirac-operator acting on ~, the 2-dimensional fermions endowed with space-time indices.
view of the results explained in the previous section we can write
In
t693
D/2 (VI.6.295)
(J Ig det 1m IT) -1/2 (det' Il) 1/2
where [;, J is the spin structure of the 1jJJl-fermions. Similarly Z(het), which is the partition function of the heterotic fermions, can be written as follows: *'1/2
(f Ii det 1m IT) -1/2 (det' Il) 1/2 where [::]
}
is the spin structure of the i-th fermion field
('1.6. 296)
~i.
Finally, Z( . . ) is due to the functional integration on gravltlno the gravitino field ~ a (z,i). This contribution we shall discuss verY briefly. As it happens for the metric the gravitino ~ can be gauged a away in any local chart by use of the invariances against local supersymmetries and super-Weyl transformations (see Eqs. (VI.3.54». This operation leads to a Faddeev-Popov determinant which is represented by the integration on the superghost and the antisuperghost fields. The corresponding contribution to the Lo operator is read off from Eq. (VI. 5. 52c)
L~sghost) = I n
[n +
t
(1- w)] :
en+lz(l-w) e -n-~(l-w)
(VI.6.297)
Defining the superghost number operator F(sghost)
=I e n+~(l-w) n
the operatorial trace
E
-n-lz(l-w)
(VI.6.298)
1694
(VI.6.299) is immediately evaluated and it reads W
J
Zgravitino [ 00' (L)
=
IS[:, (OIT) ]-1 J
(VI.6.300)
neT)
one sees the gravitino contribution cancels against the contributions of the two Majorana fermions with the same spin structure [:,]. These are two of the D-components of -f. Indeed, the fermions with space-time indices have necessarily the same spin structure as the gravitino since the coupling term
As
appearing in the action (VI.5.11) must transform as a cross section of the btmdle K- I e K- 1 (it is a 2-form on the Riemann surface). The same conclusion can be reached also by looking at the'supercurrent (VI.S.17) whose spin structure is that of the superghost system to which it couples in the BRST-charge (VI.5.S0). The exact cancellation of Z with Z(longitudinal) gravitino (w)
z
I W1Z(longitudinal) f W] '"
gravitino 1w'
(l/I)
w'
1
(VI. 6. 301)
is what allows the use of a light-cone formalism where only (D-2)X~ and (0-2) ~ are introduced. Eq. (VI.6.301), however. is true only on the torUS. On higher genus surfaces there are additional complications. First of all. in the same way as it happens for the metric, the gravitino can be gauged away only locally. Globally there exists a finite number of i-differentials
1695
which cannot be obtained as the result of a local supersymmetry. These
differentials span a linear space analogous to the Teichmlliler sp~ce: the space of supermoduli. Riemann-Roch theorem illll1\ediately yields its dimensionality. Setting q .. 3/2 in Eq. (VI. 2.329) and recalling Eqs. (VI.2.3IS) and (VI.2.102), we obtain • supermoduli 3
= dim
" (22" - 1) (g - 1)
H(3t 2) •
+
r(Z
1/2
)" 2g - 2 •
(VI. 6. 302)
If ~i is a basis of H3/2, the orbit space of two-dimensional geometries is parametri~ed not only by the metric gaS (t 1 ••.. ,tn> but also by (VI. 6. 303) where ai are anticommutlng parameters. The functional integral reduces to an integral on the moduli '[ 1' •••• T and the supermoduli Ql ••••• a2g- 2• The latter integration, however~ can be explicitly performed and the final partition function reduces to the expression (VI. 6. 294) where (VI. 6. 304)
is a function of the moduli encompassing both the Faddeev-Popov determinant of supersymmetry and the integration on supermoduli. The explicit form of the function (VI.6.304) is still unknown at the time of writing although some progress has been reported [1]. In particular, the spin Structure dependence of the left hand side of Eq. (VI.6.30l) has been clarified. It equals one only on the torus. Let us define
1696
...
...
z [ W J zlongitudinal [ ...OJ gravitino;:;, (!jJ) w'
]
(VI.6.305)
On genus g =1 we have
x[~I=x[~l=x(~]=x[~]
1.
(VI. 6.306)
On higher genuses it is found that the correct generalization of the identity (VI.6.306) is not
x[ ~] but rather
(VI. 6. 307)
1
[l,2J
(VI.6.308)
Eq. (VI.6.3GB), as we will see in the next chapter, ensures the correct relation between spin-statistics and modular invariance.
References for Chapter VI.6
[1] [2]
E.
Verlinde and H. Verlinde, Nucl. Phys. B288 (1987) 357. D. Arnandon, C.P. Bachas, V. Rivasseau, P. Vegreville, "On the vanishing of the cosmological constant in four dimensional superst ring models" (87)
1697 APPENDIX VI.6.A
A Detailed Treatment of the Conformal Killing Vectors We shall discuss the last integral over the embeddings (VI.6.Al)
where the integration is perfomed over a slice of the embedding space
I. which is required to be transversal to the action of the "conformal (0) is such thl:1t a conformal Killing Killing transformations" Gt .
x
transformation never leaves it lUlchanged.
Let us call j e G
the
t
diffeomorphisms of the finite dimensional group: we have
This means that the points of the space of embeddings can be written as (VI.6.A2)
Using the invariance of the classical action under both diffeomorphisms and Weyl transformations we have (VI.6.A3)
where we have established that . - () _ () 0(0) i.g . aB a : gaB r ~
(VI.6.A4)
Now if we integrate over all the conformal Killing group we get
1698
(VI.6.A5)
where dWT is the measure on the conformal Killing group dw
"(
=
k i II da
(VI. 6.A6)
i=l
and vCr) is its volume
vCr) '"
J nk
. dal
•
i=1
Let us now consider the normalization equation
1
= J d[6x]g
exp(-
t lto)(II~)
(VI.6.A7)
and parametrize )( ,. j*:t. . This implies
6x", j*
and the Jacobian of the transformation comes out by substituting
(VI.6.A8)
and using coordinate invariance of the norm we write
(VI.6.A9)
1699 It remains to observe that the quadratic form in the exponent precisely defines the matrix
w2
previously introduced in Eq. (VI.6.169c) so that (VI.6.AlO)
J " det W . We can write
[dx]g = (da) [di] .-1_ )
where j
(VI. 6. All)
det W
g
is the transformation which brings the point x to the slice
i. Instead of Eq. (VI.6.A2). we have (VI.6.A12)
Then we can rewrite Eq. (VI.6.AS) in the following way:
W(T.+) " __1__ J [dx]_ e-S[g.x] . VeT)
(VI.6.A13)
g
To obtain this we just have to show that the measure (VI.6.A14)
is invariant under conformal Killing transformation.
We do this in two
steps: A)
Let
p
n
be the eigenfunctions of the Laplacian (VI.6.A15)
and let A
IIU1
[j1
be the matrix which represents the transformation j
on these eigenfunctions:
1700 (VI.6.A16)
The embedding oxlJ(a) can be expanded as (VI.6.A17)
Then, given the norm (VI.6.A18)
by
coordinate invariance we have
IIcSxll~*g "
J;g
ia(j;l 6xlJ j;l oxll )
= rl AT (i-I) A(j)a
(VI.6.A19)
so that the measure differs by [d(ox)]. _ J g
B)
= (det A) -1 [dox] _
Theorem for j e
g
•
(VI. 6.A20)
Gr
(det A) 2 ,,1.
(VI.6.A21)
Proof of the Theorem. Defining the conformal factor
pea)
associated to j E Gr
by
(VI. 6 .A22)
the scalar product (A,B)
=
Jia,l Me) A(a)B{
(VI. 6.A23)
1701
and
i*A(
(VI.6.A24)
we get (VI. 6. A2S)
Furthermore, from (VI.6.A26)
which can be rewritten (VI. 6.A27)
we get AnAnm (j) =. AnAmn U-11
(no summation on m and n)
(VI.6.A28)
which means (VI. 6. Al9a)
or T
A AA = A ... (det A)
2
=1 .
(Vr.6.A30)
1702 Olapter VI. 7
MOQULAR INVARIANCE, FERMIONIZATION AND THE PARTICLE SPECTRUM OF HETEROTIC SUPERSTRINGS
VI. 7.1 Introduction In this chapter we impose the condition of modular invariance on the multiloop partition function. By so doing we obtain a set of equa· tions which must be satisfied by the coefficients (VI.6.3l) weighing the different sets of boundary conditions. Each solution of these equations corresponds to a viable heterotic superstring vacuum characterized by a GSa projection operator and a well·defined particle spectrum. The massless sector of this spectrum yields the field content of a supergravity theory coupled to a convenient set of matter multiplets. This supergravity plays the role of an effec· tive theory for the superstring model under consideration. The tools to investigate the structure of the effective theory will be discussed in Chapter VI.8 and in Chapter VI.9; here we confine our· selves to the most basic information, that is, to the spectrum. By modular invariance we mean the invariance of the full partition function (see Eqs. (VI.6.26) and (VI.6.28»):
1703 (V1.7.1)
against the action of the symplectic modular group Sp(2g,Z) . We recall that Sp{2g,Z) is the homomorphic image of the upping Class group on the homology basis which is utilized to fix the boundary conditions. Clearly. in order to impose modular invariance, we need the modular transfomation rules of the partition functions ff(bC) (r 1" •• , r 3g-3) calculated by functionally integrating on the fields with fixed boundary conditions (be]. These transformation rules are easily obtained from Eqs. (VI.2.429) and (VI.2.430) if the functions ff(bc)(T i ) depend on the boundary conditions only through Riemann theta functions. This situation is realized in ten-dimensional superstrings where the only matter fields are the Minkowski space coordinates x~, their spinor superpartners ¢P and the 32 heterotic fermions needed to cancel the conformal anomaly. The corresponding one-loop partition function reads as fOllows:
" (1m rf4
In(T) 1-16
(et:. ]
~ (6 b~
a. ]
(OIT»)4 n(r) i=1
(olt) *
)1/2
n*(r)
(VL7.2)
where [:,] is the spin structure of the
f
-fermions, while [
the spin structure of the i-th heterotic fermion.
:~]
is
Introducing the symbol
(VI. 7.3)
1704
the ten-dimensional partition function can be rewritten as a particular case of the general form
(VI. 7.4)
where
o = 10
= 8 = D-2 M = 32 N
(VI. 7.5)
(VI. 7.6)
6.7.1 Definition. We say that a superstring model is fermionic or, more preCisely, that it is fully fermionized, if its one-loop partition function can be written in the form (VI.7.4) for suitable choices of the positive integers D, N and M. As we are going to see in Section VI.7.S, for fermionic strings the problem of modular invariance can be completely solved by reduction to a fairly simple set of algebraic rules determining the coefficients
that weigh each of'the terms (VI.7.4). As we have seen, the tendimensional superstrings are fermionic, but the four-dimensional ones, apparently, are not. This is due to the presence of the factor ZCGi) (see Eqs. (VI.6.224)) associated to the WZW fields.
1705
Actually, in some very interesting papers published recently [1,2,SJ it was observed that a fermionic description of D= 4 superstrings should exist, for which one chooses D" 4
N= 0 - 2
+
18
= 20
(VI. 7.7)
M" 44
The argument underlying Eq. (VI.7.7) is the following. First one notices that Eqs. (VI.S.2S) for the conformal anomaly cancellation can be solved using only fermion fields by setting 15 "
f I D+
NLeft => NLeft ,,18,
1
if D" 4
= D + "2 NRight ... NRight = 44, if
26
D" 4
(VI. 7. Sa)
(VI. 7.Sb)
where NLeft is the number of left-moving fermions, carrying internal group indices, and where NRight is the number of right moving fermions. Secondly, one observes what follows. Let us set
(VI. 7. 9a)
ik A ~ - - : 11 (z) a \J (z) 2 z
T(z)
(VI. 7.9b) (VI. 7. ge)
where fA~rr are the completely antisymmetric structure constants of a semisimple group GF,
gA~
is the corresponding Killing metric and
where {i(z)} and {~I(:n} are, respectively, a set of NLeft=dimGF left-moving and a set of NRight right -moving free fermions, obeying the standard OPE's;
A ).l
r
i
gAL
(z)u (w) = - - k z-w
(VI. 7. lOa)
1706 i
oIJ
2
i-w
,,--
(VI. 7. lOb)
By suitably choosing the constant KI , one can easily verifY that Eqs. (VI.7.9) provide a quantum realization of the superconformal algebra (Vl.3.189) with (VI. 7.11a)
(VI. 7.llb)
Hence the authors of Refs. [1,2,3] concluded that by utilizing the three IS-dimensional semisimple groups
(VI. 7. 12a) GF • 5O(S)
* SUeS)
(VI. 7.l2b)
GF ,. 5U(4)
@ SU(2)
(VI. 7.12c)
one could construct four~dimensional superstring models whose modular invariance could be analysed in a simple way since the partition function takes the form (VI.7.4). This programme will be referred to as the fel'lllionic approach to D,. 4 superstrings. Unfortunately the nice features of the fermionic approach with respect to modular invariance are counterbalanced by a serious drawback. Indeed the fermionic string action exists only in the superconformal gauge and cannot be viewed as the gauge fixed form of a worldsheet locally supersymmetric action. Hence the very coupling of the world-sheet fermions to the world-sheet gravitino. which justifies the otherwise essential inclusion of its determinant in the partition function, is dOubtful. Furthermore, the introduction of backgromd fields and the derivation of effective a-models in the later development of the theory are very problematic. On the contrary. such problems are clearly
1707
overcome by the group~manifold geometric approach pursued in Chapters VI.S and VI.S. Therefore we are led to readdress the question of modular invariance in the present tontext. Here the partition function includes, besides the theta functions representing the fermionic functional determinants, also the characters of the Kac~Moody algebras we considered, which can be viewed as the determinants of the corresponding WZW kinetic operators. We will show that in the case of the target group GT " [su (2) }3, already selected by the requirement of massless target fermions, the Kac~Moody characters can be re~expressed in terms of the theta functions, leading us back to the treatable case of fermionic strings. This is the subject of the next section.
VI. 7.2
~lodular
invariance and GNO fermionization
Referring to the programme of modular invariance in the case of group-manifold superstrings, we observe that, in order to carry it through, we should solve the following problems: We ought to define characters not only for untwisted but also for twisted Kac~Moody algebras. This amounts to defining the analogue of a spin structure for group bosons. These bosonic spin structures arrange into orbits under the modular group and playa role in the construction of modular invariants. i)
ii) The Kac-Moody characters are labeled. beSides by the spin structure, by the highest weight of the vacuum, which ranges over the finite number of values allowed at the given level k (see Eq. (VI.5.98b). This label transforms under the modular group simulta~ neously with the spin structure. Therefore we must devise rules for the construction of modular invariants which are a combination of two items: theta functions, labelled by the spin structure, and Kac~Moody characters labelled by both the spin structure and the vacuum weight. We should extend the theory of Kac-Moody characters to higher genus surfaces in order to address the question of higher loop modular invariance. iii)
1708 In this section. since massless target fermions select SU(2) group-manifolds. we focus on the 5U(2) Kac-Moody algebras with symmetric twists. In this case we show that we can indeed solve problem i) and define suitable bosonic spin structures whose modular transformations we can also derive. In this way we can write down the candidate modular invariant partition function as a linear combination of terms whose modular transformations are known. So we can address problem il) which is that of determining the proper coefficients. We solve this problem through fermionization of the Kac-M'oody currents. This enables us to use the rule established in the free fermion approach with, however, a proviso to be explained in the next section. Let us explain in some words what we mean by the above statement. At the quantum level the Kac-Moody currents of a Lie algebra G corresponding to specific levels k can be replaced by bilinears in new fermion fields X(z) (hereafter named fake fermions) transforming in a suitable representation R. In general the stress-energy tensor calX culated as a bilinear for the KM currents is different from the canonical stress-energy tensor of the x-fields. However, Goddard. Nahm and Olive (GNO) [4J have shown that the necessary and sufficient condition for these two forms of the stressenergy tensor to coincide is the existence of a group GF ~ Fr (hereafter named fermionization group) such that
I
GF""r adj
is a symmetric space
GF= adj "r
(VI. 7.13) $
~
Given a level k realization of the GKac-Moody algebra we can easily calculate the dimension of the candidate representation Rx to be utilized for its fermionization. Indeed, since the conformal anomaly of the RX fermions mUSt be equal to the conformal anomaly of the KM' currents, we have
!
2
dim R = ___k___ dim G • X k + Cv
(VI.7.14)
1709
Provided a representation RX with such a dimension exists, we can ask ourse! ves the next question, namely, if a group GF can be fOlmd whose decomposition with respect to Gr fulfills conditions (Vt.7.13). An ....-.... example will suffice. Consider the level k .. 20 realization of SU(2). The dimension of Rx should be (VI. 7.15) which corresponds to an isospin J" 2 representation, namely, to a symmetric 2-index traceless tensor of SO(3) ~ 5U(2). Now the symmetric space SU(3)/50(3) corresponds to the embedding of SO(3) with the following branching rule {S} SO(3{. {3} e {S}
(VI. 7.16)
This is precisely what we need. Hence in our example the fermionization group is Gp " 5U(3) and the GNO symmetric space is SU(3)/SO(3}. Using this method in the last column of Tables VI,S.I, II, III we have identified the ~~O symmetric spaces associated to each of the fifteen group manifolds fOlmd by us in the previous sections. As the reader can see, the allowed group manifolds have been organized according to their fermionization groups. Remarkably, as fermionization groups GF we retrieve the three IS-dimensional groups proposed by Antoniadis et al [2,3j, that is to say. SU{2)6, SU(4) ® SU(2) and SO(S) ® SU(3). The relation between the group-manifold approach and the fermionic approach can be fully appreciated if we consider the supercurrent (VI.3.1S4c) and we replace the KM currents JA(z) with the fermion bilinears
(VI. 7.17) where the matrices RAij are the GT generators in the RX representation. The result takes the following form
1710 (VI. 7.18)
where (VI. 7.19)
are the structure constants of the fel'Dlionbation group, and
(VI.7.20) is the multiplet of free fermions in the adjoint representation of GF• supercurrent (VI. 7.18) is three-linear in the fermions as the supercurrents considered in Eq. (VI. 7 .9a). Thus one might conclude that all we have done so far is just retrieving the fermionic string models and one might decide to jump directly at the results of references [2,3], fOrgetting the group manifold formulation altogether. We think this is too hasty. The
Indeed it has to be stressed that the GNO theorem deals only with local properties of the KM currents. If one wants to extend the fermionization globally to the whole world-sheet, one has to analyse carefully the bomdary conditions. In the case of the twisted KM algebras there is almost always an obstruction to fermionization, simply because, in general, an arbitrary twist on the KM algebra does not match with the one induced by the boundary conditions of the fake fermions:(*) For instance, in Chapter VI.S we showed that the theory corresponding to
GT = SU(2)k=8
* SU(2)k=20 * U(l)
(VI. 7.21)
contains massless fermionic states if and only if we perform the symmetric twist (VI.S.137) on both the SU(2) algebras. (In this case i = J3 n
(~)
n
As remarked in earlier chapters, the normal ordering ambiguity discovered by Bouwknegt and Ceresole, seems to imply that full fermionization can be achieved in a few more cases of those listed in Tables VI.S.I-III.
1711 ·(l J1.2) The prob lem is to find a suitable moding of the an d In+~'' n+~' X-fermions such that the H-generators be integer moded and the Kgenerators be half·integer moded. It happens that there is none of the sort.
Furthel'lilOre it should be that the coboundary of the Virasoro algebra has the same value whether we use the KM current picture or the fermionic picture for its computation. Once more this is not true in general. Indeed a counter-example is provided by the model (VI.7.21). on one hand, we know that the mass-shift is zero if we choose a q" 1/2 twist of the I<M algebra which has no fel1llionic realization. On the other hand. from Ref. [3} we know that by utilizing non-half-integer twists of the fake fermions Sitting in the SO(5) ~ SU(3) adjoint representation we reach the same result.(·) There is a remarkable exception to this state of affairs. namely, the SU(2) Kac-Moody algebra of level k" 4 can be fel'Dlionized as the diagonal SU(2) subgroup of GF" SU(2) e 5U(2), and the representation RX is consistent with the twist defined in Eqs. (VI.5.131) and (VI.S.133), associated to the symmetric space 50(3)/SO(2). Such a construction is the basis of all fermionizable solutions listed in Table I. They correspond to the free fermion theories associated to GF • SU(2}6. We call quasi fermionizable those solutions where the boundary conditions on the I<M currents cannot be reproduced by the xfermions. One example has been quoted. The complete list is given in Table VI.S.II. As we see, the associated fermionization groups are SU(4) $ 5U(2) and 50(5) & SU(3), and correspond to free-fermion models with non-real boundary conditions. Because of the above obstruction, no one of these models can be formulated as a string propagation on a group manifold; hence no claSSical superconformal action seems to exist for such theories. Finally the non-fel'Dlionizahle solutions of Table VI.S.III
(*)
It appears that choosing a different normal ordering prescription the fermionic twists of Ref. [3] can be reconciled with a group manifold interpretation. This is again due to a different resolution of the Bouwknegt-Ceresole ambiguity. In any case one just adds a few more solutions to the fermioni:tation problem.
1712 correspond to Kac-Moody algebras which are part of a larger Kac-Moody algebra including further U(l) factors. Actually tions are fermionizable in lower dimensions (D" 3 when dim D=2 when dim GF '" 24) •
fermionizable these soluGF;; 21 and
Summarizing this discussion. we can say that if we want both a supersymmetric classical action. whose necessity has already been stressed, and the advantages of a fermionic picture, which seems very important to implementing modular invariance. then we must restrict our attention to the four solutions of Table VI.S.! corresponding to (*) ~"8U(2)6. Let us then focus on these models. This means that throughout the rest of this section the target space will be 3-p
n (SU(2).)
Mtarget
" M4 @
i=1
1
(VI. 7.22)
B
where all the generators B 9 Y " 6 1 @ Y2 @ '13 ' Y1 • '(2 0 Y3) of the homotopy group fulfill Eq. (VI.S.134), namely, they are such that
Y~
6
Z[SU(2)j
(VI. 7.23)
Furthermore p is an integer in the range 0 5 p ~ 3. The case p;; 3 corresponds to a fully toroidal compactification of the D" 10 heterotic superstring. On the other hand, the case p" 0 is the opposite extremum where there are no toroidal subspaces. It is the only one compatible with N=1 target SUSY since we will show that we need precisely three SU(2) to construct a GSO operator which projects out 3 of the 4 candidate massless gravitinos. Let us then define the partition fUnction, which is the main object of our study, for the case p'" O. Let t be the modulus of the world(*)
As it is obvious from the previous footnotes. this conclusion is changed by the discovery of the Bouwknegt-Ceresole ambiguity. There are also, using a different normal ordering prescription, a couple of lIlOdels associated to the SU(3) e 50(5) and SU(2) e SU(4) fermionization groups.
1113 sheet torus associated to the one-loop amplitude and let us set, as usual (see Eq. (VI.6.18)), (VI. 7.24)
q = exp(2i'llT) •
Then the one-loop contribution to the cosmological constant reads as follows (see Eqs. (VI.6.2S) and (VI.6.17»: II "
I
tori
exp [- classical actionI
I
dq dq
i ,c, - Tr (q boundary qq !n qq bc
"
11
i = all fields Lo -(1
_
V(';.) 1
Lo-o.
q
) ,
(VI. 7.25)
conditions: be where LO and Lo are the nought generators of the complete Virasoro algebra including the ghost and superghost contributions, and (l and a are the intercepts. The functional integral involves also a summation over the boundary conditions be we must assign to every twodimensional field in order to calculate the Fock space trace of the
· operat or q LO-aq _Lo·a. "-d 1 . . dea1S Wlt . h t he evo 1utlon ~~ u ar lnvarlance weights Cbc to be assigned to each set of boundary conditions bc. Recalling Eqs. (VI.6.294), (VI.6.301) and (VI.6.96) the integral over moduli space displayed in Eq. (VI.7.2S) can be Written in the following form: (VI.7.26a)
WeT) =
i
(b.c.)
where, in our case, the conformal ghosts collectively denoted non-trivial boundary
Z
(b.c.)
(1')
(VI. 7. 26b)
D" 4, and the contribution of the XU field and of has been separated from all the other contributions, by Wbc(t). The reason of this separation is that conditions are a feature displayed only by the
1714 fermions and the group bosons. X~ and the conformal ghosts have always the same boundary conditions and do not contribute any potential global anomaly. The modular invariance of
(VI. 7. 27)
was already shown in Chapter VI.6 (see Eqs. (VI.6.96) and following 2
ones). Since the Weil-Petersson measure ~
is also modular
(ImT)2
invariant we must impose modular invariance on the partition function WeT). To this effect we begin by discussing the structure of a typical addend ZeD.C.) in the case under study (p'" 0). We have
(VI. 7.28)
where the left and the right partition functions are specified below
e[(ll - ai]eOl T) [Il.]1
3
B'1_ _ _WI _-_
i=1
n(r)
n
BJ .
(r)
(VI. 7. 29a)
1 Bj
at:: ](01 1) p
Let us explain the various factors.
1/2 (V1.7.29b)
1715
In Eq. (VI. 7.29)
[ :,] (IU,
1J,l'
e ZZ) is the spin structure of
~. i.e., the world-sheet fermions with space-time indices.
The
structure of the world-sheet supercurrent implies that the same spin structure must be assigned to the superghosts and to three of the groupfermions .\~. Let us explain why. In the case under consideration the supercurrent reads as follows:
G(z) ..
12 ei11/4 : [P
J.I
...IJ (z) + L 3 (A ABC )] : (z)1jI J. {Z)A.A(z) + -212 \AiA'£ABC i=1 1 1 3 1 (VI. 7.30)
where the index i
enumerates the three SU(2) groups, and the level
k =4 Kac-Moody algebra is encoded in the following OPE expansion: A B J i (z)J. (1'1)
26AB i 12 ABC =--_ + £
(z _ 1'1) 2
1
z- W
J~(W)
+
reg. tetlllS.
(VI. 7.31)
1
Tbe available space-like boundary conditions on these currents are dictated by the choice (VI.7.22) of the homotopy group, which leads to
the symmetrically twisted Kac-Moody algebra (VI.S.ll7). Conventionally we can identify the untwisted currents with J~ and the twisted ones with
J~,2(z). 1
Hence We can set
1
i11a1' 1 1 2'11 J.(ze 1) .. e J.(z} 3 2i11 3 J. (ze )" J. (z) 1
1
tJ:(
i ze
2i11)
1'11<1].
.. e
J:( )
(VI. 7. 32)
i Z
where ai e Z2'
If we compare Eqs. (VI.7.32) with Eq. (VI.s.34a) we see that eLi .. 0 corresponds to the choice
r"
1 for the i th SU(2) group.
On
the other hand, a." 1 implies that for that particular 5U(2) we have chosen
r .. e 3,
1
where
63
e 50(3)
is the following matrix:
o -1
o
(VI. 7.33)
1716
Clearly, instead of e3 we could equivalently choose r '" ~ 1 or r", eZ' having defined:
o -1
~
o
-1
) ; e
2= (~1 0 ~) 0
0
(VI. 7.34)
-1
Of course, with these choices, the untwisted current is, instead of J3, either Jl or Note that {e 1,eZ,e 3,1} form a ZZ® Zz subgroup of SO(3). In the complete theory the full homotopy group S c SU(2)3 ® SU(Z)3 is generated by a set of elements (y,y) e B where
i.
(VI. 7.35a) (VI. 7. 35b)
e. e SU(2).
e,. e SU(2).
J
Ij
so that the boundary conditions of the l(~ /iTi) J
=
(VI. 7. 3Se)
J
lj
Kac-~loody
currents are
A B
(e·)sJ·(z)
(VI. 7. 36a)
~B j~(z e21ri ) = (e.,. ) AB J.(z)
(VI. 7. 36b)
J
Ij
lj
]
J
the matrices e. being defined by Eqs. (VI.7.33-34). 1
From Eq. (VI.7.30), we see that the three A~(Z), which multiply 1 the three periodic Kat-Moody currents, must have the same spin structure
f:, J
to
as rp)J and the superghosts. This explains the power S/Z assigned
e[; ]/n
in·Eq. (V1.7.29).
corresponding to the superghost
Indeed, 5=4+3-2, the subtraction contr~bution.
1717
Consider now the six A: which multiply those Kat-Moody currents which are possibly twisted. Let a1 be the space-like boundary condition already defined on the pair of twisted currents J~(Z) relative to the i th SU(2). and 8i be the time-like boundary condition on the same currents (which has still to be defined); then the corresponding pair of AiA(z) will have spin structure [11)w' -~] -8i • This explains the three factors
e[:,:~! ]/n
in Eq. (VI. 7.29a).
a
The next item in the same equation is BJ
{B] (T).
By this symbol
we denote the boson partition function associated to the k=4 SU(2) KacMoody algebra with spin structure [;] and vacuum state in the J representation of SU(2). As shown in Chapter VI.S the allowed values of J are 0, 1/2 and 1. We will define the B-functions and their modular transformation properties in a moment. Before doing that we want to complete the scanning of Eqs. (VI.7.29) by considering also the right partition function. rn this sector there are no A-fermions and hence we have only the BJ j
[:~]
factors where the spin structure is
determined by the y generators of Eq. (VI.7.3Sb). Finally, the 35 square-roots of the theta functions
e[~l
are associated with the 35
heterotic fermions. Before imposing modular invariance there are no a priori constraints on their spin structure.
A; ]
Let us now go OYer to the discussion of the B
partition
functions. The proper mathematical concept we need for their description is that of the characters of a Kac-Moody algebra [6,7]. Let A(lJ) be an irreducible module. namely. an irreducible unitary representation associated to a highest weight state lJ (see Eqs. (VI.5.96). (VI.S.97) and (VI. 5.98)) and let p.., tk, - n) =Ae A(p) be a typical weight belonging to the module. The grade n is the energy label, i.e. the eigenvalue of the number operator /oJ ..
La -
~.
Cli+2p)
--:--~ k+C
v
(VI. 7. 37)
1718
In the untwisted Kac-Moody (rank G)-component complex another complex parameter. A{U) is defined to be the
algebras we have n E N. Let now ! be a vector. 1 a complex parameter, and t The character of the irreducible module following complex function of !, T and t:
where JIlUlt A(A) denotes the degeneracy of the weight A. Le., the dimension of the eigensubspace of A belonging to the eigenvalues ~k, • n) of the commuting operators (Ho• ~k, - M).
ex'
IdentifYing the parameter T in Eq. (VI.7.38) with the modulus of the world-sheet torus, it makes sense to study the transformation properties of the characters under the modular group. Indeed Kac and Petersson [6] have shown that the following objects transform as modular forms: (VI. 7.39)
where q is given by Eq. (YI.7.24) and Su is the so-called "modular anomaly": 1- {+Jj. (II .... s)l =+ 2p) k+C V
- -k
24
dim GJ •
(VI. 7.40)
..
The functions BJj(Z,T,t) can be easily rewritten as operatorial traces: -~~
Bu = q
k + Cy
24
.~+ blkt (La 2in.no ) e TrA(II) q e
(VI. 7.41)
From Eq. (VI.7.41) one sees that BIl (0.1.0) is a q-power times the partition function the representation S and T defined B~(t,T.t) are the
of an untwisted Kac-MDody algebra corresponding to ... where the vacuWll has weight U. Under the generators in Eq. (VI.2.244) the transformation rules of the following:
1719
(VI. 7. 42a) (VI. 7.42b)
~'
where the summation range for
is given by the set of the highest
weights allowed at level k. SV~I and T~~, are unitary matrices which have been constructed by Kac and Petersson for several levels of several algebras.
In the level k=4 SU(2) case p is identified with the isospin J which can take the values J =I, 1/2 and O. Then Eq. (VI. 7.41) becomes (VI. 7.43)
where we have identified the Cartan subalgebra generator HO with 12 J~. This corresponds to the choice r = e 3 . Clearly equally good identifications are flO = 12J~ or 110 =12 J~ corresponding to r" e 1 or r" e2 • In this particular case the matrices SJJI and TJJ • are respectively given by SJJI "
A
sin{ ~ (2J + 1)(2J'
(VI. 7. 44a)
+ IJ)
and
. f (2J + 1)2
TJJ1 :: 0JJ' exp {llTL
8
-
1
1}
(VI. 7.44b)
4" j . 1
Ordering the J values in the following sequence ('2,0,1) one can explicitly write
SJJ' '"
t
(
0
12
12
1
-12
-,(2) 1 1
(VI. 7. 45a)
1720
o e -1'rr/8
o
,,:.J
(VI. 7. 4Sb)
Relying on Eqs. (Vr.7.42) we are able to introduce a consistent definition of spin structure for SU(2) group bosons.
We just draw an analogy
between characters and theta-functions and regard the function BJ(z;r,t)
as the analogue of the theta function without characteristic. Then the BJ-function with characteristic
[;]
is naturally given by the ana-
logue of Eqs. (VI. 2.426) and (VI.6.235):
\'lith this definition, the transformation properties of the "partition
functions"
(VI. 7.47)
are given as
(VI. 7. 48a)
(VI.7.48b)
where the action of S and T on T is defined by Eqs. (VI.2.244), while their action on
( ~] p
is the following:
(VI. 7.49a)
1721
(VI. 7.49b)
Eqs. (VI.7.49) hold true if a2 , 82 are either zero or one. As we see the transformation of the bosonic characteristic is very similar to that of the fermionic: ones but there are two important differences. The first is apparent from Sq. (VI.7.49b), which is to be compared with the Ttransformation of a theta-function characteristic, (VI. 7.50) The second difference is related to the minus Sign in Eq. (VI.7.49a). Also in the case of theta functions the outcome of an S-transformation is given by (VI.7.49a). In that case, however, we have
sf ~a ]
(l) "
e[:]
el) ,
(VI. 7 .51)
so that the minus sign becomes irrelevant and we can write (VI. 7.52)
In this way the spin structures are defined over l2' The reduction to l2 elements is possible also for the bosonic spin structures, but instead of (VI.7.S1) we must use the identities (VI.7.53a)
(VI. 7.S3b)
which easily follow from the explicit transcription of the BJ [;] functions as operatorial traces:
(VI. 7.548)
(VI. 7.541:»
[01
m·
(1
BJ 1 = BJ -
1
)
T• O
- i6
.. q
I
L
TrJ q
J3. J3
0 - 0 111 0 I
e
I
(VI. 7.54c)
(VI. 7. 54d)
Incidentally Eqs. (VI.7.54) are the very justification for our definition (VI.7.46) of the bosonic spin structure. Indeed. if we recall .... 1 t Eqs. (VI,5.84) we see that for t" the Lo operator of the twisted algebra is related to LO of the untwisted. one by
m'
(VI. 7.55)
Hence apart from a prefactor which is given by a power of the q-variable, the function BJ [~ J iS the partition function of the twisted algebra. O 0] is the partition function of the untwisted in the same way as algebra.
BA
The miracle which links BRST invariance with modular invariance. i.e., the cancellation of local conformal anomalies with the cancellation of global anomalies, appears at the level of the above-mentioned q-power prefactors. Indeed the partition function was written in the form (VI.7.29) since, by using Eqs. (VI.5.123) for the intercepts, we Io"ere able to cancel all powers of q obtained by replacing the trace of the evolution operators (Trq La) for all the fields with either theta functions or BJ-flttlctions.
1723 Finally we note that. once BJ [ ~ 1 was singled out, the definition of the remaining partition funct~ons was no longer our privilege, but rather was determined by applying modular transformations. In this way we discovered that the role of fermion number is played by the third component of the isospin. Indeed the factor (_lJ F of Eq. (VI.6.29l) _ 1S
_
J3
substltuted here by (-1) 0
At this pOint, by means of the above formulae, we have established the modular transformations of all the items appearing in the partition function (VI.7.28). We should now devise rules to construct modular invariants at one loop to begin with, and at higher loops later. As mentioned above we solve this problem by fermionization, i.e. by reducing both Eqs. (VI.7.29) to a product of Riemann theta functions. In this way we will make contact with the work of Refs. [2,3] and use the rules explained there to write dOl-In modular invariants. On the other hand we shall gain extra constraints on allowed invariants by demanding that one should always be able to go back and rewrite the modular invariant partition function in the language of Eqs. (VI.7.29). The fermionization procedure is based on the realization of the k=4 SU(2) KM~algebra by means of "fake" fermions l(z) transforming in the adjoint representation (A" 1,2,3). The currents fulfilling the OPE (VI. 7.31) can be written as the following normal ordered bilinears: (VI. 7.56) where 0o 00 denotes normal ordering with respect to the modes of the fermionic field XA(z). We can introduce boundary conditions on XA(z) by writing, as usual, (VI. 7.57) where wA e 71.2' Defining next the contraction function
ll(wlz,w)
= - -i - 1
4z-w
\ (l-w)
z+w) ~ 2"zw
+ -W
(VI. 7.58)
1724
we obtain o ABo XA (z)xB (w)" oX (z)X (w) 0
where ~ '" {wI
,i ,w3}
+
hAS (w.... 1z,w)
(VI. 7. 59)
and the 2-point function hAB is
hAB (w.... 1z,w) '" 0ABA(wBlz,w}
(no
sum
on
B) •
(VI. 7.60)
Considering next the I(.\t-currents JA(z), we see that their boundary conditions are fixed by those of the fake fermions. Indeed:
(no sum on A) • (VI.7.61)
Hence if all the wA are equal we have an untwisted Kac-Moody algebra. while if one is different from the other two the algebra is twisted. Referring to Eqs. (VI.5.134-137), let H be the untwisted subgroup and G/H the symmetric space spanned by the twisted generators (If H= Uti) we have an actual twist, while if H:SU(2) there is no twist). With these notations we can write: A
A
xA
A
x
J {z)J (w) " xJ (z)J (w)x
2_1
+ __ (z _ w)2
+
dim H +
1. dim (G/H) z~ I 2
v zw
r
(VI. 7.62)
where : : denotes normal ordering with respect to the moding of the Kac-Moody current. The stress-energy tensor (VI.5.71b) is therefore given by the limit B
1
XA
A
x
T (w) '" - lim xJ (z)J (w)x 8 z .... w
'
(VI. 7. 63)
while the canonical energy-momentum tensor of the fake fermions is given the other limit
by
1725
A little bit of algebra and the use of Wick theorem reveals that
2
+1 t.w) - (tr hew+1 z.w}) - 16(tr h (w
2} = 0, (VI. 7.65)
the trace is taken on the 3-dimensional space and the 2-point function (VI.7.60) is regarded as a matrix. This is the proof of full fermionitation: the energy-momentum tensor of the Kac-Moody syste~ is equal to that of the fake fermions independently of the boundary conditions. We have four different sectors depending on the relative numbers of Ramond and Neveu-Schwarz fake fermions. They will be denoted by (R)3. (R)2(NS). (R)(NS)2 and (NS) 3. (R)3 and (NS)3 correspond to the untwisted algebra, while the other two cases correspond to the twisted one. They decompose into irreducible representations according to the following rules: ~~ere
untwisted algebra twisted algebra
I (R) 3 ... (J = 2)1 (NS)3 ... (J = 0)
I
1
= '2)
(J
$ $
(J = 1)
(R) (NS)2 ...
(J "
!.) 2
$
(J "
!.) 2
(R)2 (NS)
(J "
0)
6)
(J =
I)
+
=}
For instance, in the (R) 3-case the J vacuum is the eli fford vacuum of the three Ramond fermions and all the states built with any number of fermion oscillators belong to the same irreducible module. In the (NS)3 case, instead, the states built with an even number of fermion oscillators belong to the J=O module while those built with an odd number belong to J=l irreducible module.
1726
As a final check of fermionization and as a preparatory step for
A~]
the next section we have verified, numerically, that the B
func-
tions relevant to us can be rewritten as suitable products of theta functions as we show in Table VI.7.!. The same table establishes a valuable one-to-one correspondence between the choice of J, a and e and the choice of a spin structure for the fake fermions. The table must be understood as follows. According to Kac and Peterson [6] the numerical value of the characters for the k;4 SU(2) algebra is given by
(
~
BJ-,T,-U
)
12
1 = L
2J C1J,{1")0(2JI2)(T,Z,U) J'"Q '
(VI. 7.66)
where (VI. 7.67a)
(VI. 7.67b) Co 2 ;: -
1
c
1
1 { n ( -) 1" 2[11(1)]2 2
11(21") =---
- e-in/4
I} 11 ( -1" + -) 2 2
(VI. 7.67c)
(VI.7.67d)
[n(l) J2
are so called "string functions" and the capital theta series is defined as 0(2J,2)(l,Z,U)
=e
-4illU
(VI. 7.68)
Performing a shift in the variables one can also introduce capital-thetas with characteristics:
1727 TABLB VI. 7. I Fermionization of level }<=4 SU(2) Partition FlBlctions ,;
Free Fermion Partition Function
KM Bosonic Partition FlBlction
z[
BA:J Bl/2[~]
a1 a2 a 3 ] b I b 2 b3
_1
z[ 000 III J
12
Buzl ~]
12
1
zIIOO] 000
B1/ 2[ ~]
72
1
Z(111]
B1/ 2[ ~ 1
e· i11 / 4
f2
011
z[ 1 00] 011
BO[ ~]
llz[ 0 00] z[ 0III °°11 2 000
Baf ~]
[011] '211 Zoo 0
Bo[ ~ ]
!{z[OOO] z[0001l 2 OIl 100
Bo[ ~ 1
eitT2/ 4 Z[011] • . [0 11 100 1Z 011
+
+
. [Oll]} 1Z 1 11
+
I
1I2 [OOOJ lOOO]} 000· Z 111
Bl[~l
2
BIl ~ J
21[[011) z 000
BII ~]
1Iz[000] . z[OOOJl 2 011 100
BI [
~1
H
e 3il1/ 4 2
• iZ[
{z(Ol1] 100
+
~ !~ )}
iZ[OllJl 011
1728 0(2J,2)[;] (t,z,u) .. =e
-4niu+ill(<<+4J)S/4 il8 q
\'
q
L
2p2+ap
e
-4nipz
,(VI. 7.69)
pel+~
A: ]:
and write the analogue of Eq. (VI. 7.66) for the B
BA:Hlz ,T, -u) =J1t c~,0(2J,2)[:1(T'Z,U) .
(VI. 7.70)
In Table VI. 7. I we have verified that for z .. U" 0 the numerical values
A: ]
of B
as given by (VI. 7. 70) are equal to the values of certain
suitable combinations of Riemann theta functions. The reason why we restricted our attention to z = U =0 is that we were interested, for the time being, in vacuum to vacuum amplitudes. This, however, introduced some ambiguity, since sometimes we were dealing with the factor
a(: J(Oh)
which, being zero, could not be seen. To resolve the ambiguity we shifted to non-zero values of 4 and we also established the following identities:
(6 n.
[ 1J 0
1/2
[ 1]
° (zit)
(VI. 7. 7la)
B [O](_z ,t,O) ,,_1 (e[~](Olt)~/2 a[ ~}(zlt)
(VI. 7. 71b)
B [O}(_Z 1/2 0
n."
1/2 1
12
BO[~J(.,;
t
0)
= _1
12
(OIT»)
e
net)
net)
J
net)
nCt)
,T,O) - Bl[~](Jr ,T,O) =
=_ilrrz('6[~](OIT)f2 l](t) J
6[!
(zit)
nCt)
(VI. 7. 7lc)
1729 Eqs. (VI. 7.71) are the justification for the way utilized in Table VI. 7. I to write vanishing objects like Sl/2[ ~ (1) or
1
so[ ~] (1) - Bl [!] ('r).
Finally let us explain the notation we have adopted. regarded as functions of i alone (Le.. z =t =0).
BA: J
are Furthermore
corresponds to the partition function of N Majorana fermions with spin structures
[ :~ ], [::].....
[~]
(see Eq. (VI. 7.3») • Looking at
Table VI.7.1 and considering the possible partition functions of three fermions we see that we have apparently missed four combinations, namely,
i)
ell) 100
ii)
(i00) 100
iii)
(Ill) 11 1
iv)
POD) 111
This is not serious since the above combinations are zero being proportional to
a[: }(OIT)/n(l).
Hence, without making any error we can
add them, multiplied by any coefficient. to the expressions for
Bl/2[~]' Bl/2[~1. BI/2[~]
and
Bl/2[~]
respectively. Thisnumeri-
cally harmless addition allows, on the other hand, the rewriting of 81/2 [ :] inserted.
as a fermion Fock space trace with a projection operator
1730
VI.7.S Modular invariance and spin structures In Chapter VI.S we have selected a few string models with massless fermions. All of them, but one, contain U(l) factors in the target group. Then. according to a general argument [81. they correspond to non-chiral theories which are not very interesting from a physical point of view. Thus we are led to consider a tmique superstring action in four dimensions with G.r" SU(2) 3 which is the only one compatible with N-l space-time supersymmetry, as we shall see. \'Ie have shown in the previous section that this model is fermioni~able; this means, in particular, that the physical spectrum can be described in terms of the Fock space associated with a set of free fields containing, besides the bosonic coordinates Xll, 20 left-moving and 44 right-moving world-sheet fermions, as in the free-fermion approach to 4D heterotic superstring. However, there is a difference between the allowed botmdary conditions in the present approach and those considered in the ordinary free fermion description. We devote this section to the study of the constraints on the botmdary conditions. We include also all the constraints arising from modular invariance. \'Ie start by listing the whole set of 64 world-sheet fermions. In the left-moving sector we have. besides the tt.'O fermions (T =1,2) associated to the transverse coordinates, six fermions x~,,,: (A= 1,2.3) for each of the three SU(2) groups (i = 1.2,3). where t's are the fake fermions used to represent the KM currents si(~) having ~:(z) as fermionic partners.
·i.
In the right-moving sector we have nine fake fermions X~(i) whose bilinears represent J~1 and thirty-five heterotic fermi~ns
~p(Z).
A first important constraint comes from the compatibility of the twisted KM algebras with the existence of massless fermions already discussed which forces all the world-sheet fermions, excepting ~p(z). to obey real (i.e. R or NS) boundary conditions, while in the ordinary are reqUired to be real. free-fermion approach only the
l
Another constraint is imposed by the world-sheet supersymmetry and is a generalization of the one identifying the boundary conditions of
1731
the ~'s with those of the gravitino ~. It can be obtained simply by considering the explicit express~.on of the two-dimensional supercurrent G(z) given in Eq. (VI. 7.30). After fermionization the term J. A becomes bilinear in the X's; any arbitrary choice of real boundary conditions CBC) for the X's fixes an allowed twist of the SU(2) current JA(z). Then the boundary conditions of the A's are uniquely fixed by the requirement that J. A must have the same Be as ~ . In other terms, once given the BC for ~, we can freely choose the BC of the nine X's, while the Be of the remaining left-moving fermions are uniquely determined. A similar analysis in the ordinary free-fermion approach, where the supercurrent G has a different expression, shows that there one can choose arbitrarily the boundary conditions of 12 left-moving .fermions. In the right sector the boundary conditions that can be imposed on the fake fermions ~ are those induced by a twist of the SU(2) Kac-Moody algebras (see Eqs. (VI.5.34)). The other constraints we wish now to describe are not specific to the present formulation, but are common to all fermionic strings (here we use the definition eVI.7.1)). It is convenient to represent the BC of the world-sheet fermions of a given string sector by a 64-component boundary vector (VI. 7.72)
where
r"
is a NS fermion;
A
1 if II
(VI. 7.73) is a R fermion •
Using this notation the two constraints mentioned above can be written as follows:
1732
a~ T a A TaB = a C (mod 2) • Xi
Xi
~i
i
= 1,2.3.
t ABe = 1
(VI. 7. 74)
(VI. 7. 75)
Since the boundary vector a is a sequence of 1's and 0' s it can be specified simply by listing the Ramond fields. For instance, using a shorthand notation we can write s = {~T (T= 1,2).
xi,
A~
(i = 1,2,3)}
•
(VI. 7. 76)
to denote the boundary vector associated to the string sector characterized by the above R fields. This boundary vector has an important role in the theory, since it describes a space-time fermionic sector (because Ctl/J =1) whose lowest state (gravitino) is massless, as it can be seen using the mass formulas given by Eqs. (VI.5.127) which can be rewritten in the following form: (VI. 7. 77a)
(VI. 7. 77b)
where N and N are the occupation numbers in the LM and RM sectors, while nL and nR denote the numbers of Ramond fields in the two sectors. The equality of the RHS of the two equations (VI.7.77) is the additional constraint one has to impose on the direct product of open string physical states in order to describe closed string states. This additional constraint acts also on the boundary vectors. Indeed, subtracting Eq. (Vl.7.77b) from Eq. (VI.7.77a) we can write
which implies that nL• nR is a multiple of eight.
1733 It is convenient to introduce a Lorentzian scalar product for boundary vectors as follows
aob
def 20
= I /l.a. i=1
1 1
~
64
1:
a.a.
j=21 J J
(VI. 7. 79)
Then the additional constraint (VI.7.78) implies 2 def _ a = a a = 0 (mod 8) • 0
(VI. 7.80)
As we have already seen in the previous section, one· loop modular invariance requires that we define the sum of boundary vectors: and
ai
if ai are the components of a and b, then !,:he components 'Yi of
c = a + bare gi ven by (VI. 7.81)
The same definition of sum can be obtained by considering the coupling of three strings, characterized by three arbitrary boundary vectors a, b and c;
indeed the Ramond fermions carry a fermionic number in the
target space whose conservation can be expressed precisely by Eq. (VI. 7. 81), hen ce a + b = c. This fact implies in turn tha.t the set of boundary vectors form an abelian group :: where the identity element is the null vector. :: -I K+l
- - 2
Actually we have, for some integer K, (VI. 7.82)
since a+ a= 0 Vas:; K+l is the number of generators bo' bt , •.• , bK which form a basis of ::. Note that in general Eq. (VI.7.80) is not invariant under the sum (VI.7.8l) in the sense that if a and b are two boundary vectors
satisfying Eq. (VI. 7. 80), their sum a + b does not satisfy automatically such a condition. curious relation
However, one can immediately derive the following
1734 (a+b)
222 =a +b
(VI. 7.83)
-2a o b
which yields, when combined with Sq. (VI.7.80), the following constraint a' b :: 0 (mod 4)
(VI. 7.84)
for every pair of allowed boundary vectors. However this constraint is not yet sufficient to guarantee that the sum of the three boW\dary vectors also fulfils Eq. (VI.7.80). The point is that the scalar product defined in Eq. (VI.7.79) is not linear in its arguments; rather, one has a•c
+
b' c - (a + b) • c = 2a' b • c
(VI. 7.85)
where the triple product a' b • c denotes the net nUlllber of Ramond fermions (LM minus RM) common to the three boundary vectors. Similarly one can define a quadruple product a 0 b • C • d as 2a • b • c • d = a' b • c
+
a' b • d - a' b • (c + d) ,
(VI. 7.86)
which gives likewise the number of R fermions common to a. b, c and d and so on. Using this notation one can write (a + b + c)
2
z
222 a + b + c - 2a' b - 2a' - 2b' c + 4a' b • c
C -
(VI. 7.87)
which gives the further constraint a' b • c :: 0 (mod 2) •
(VI. 7. 88)
Such a constraint is sufficient to ensure that the sum of an arbitrary number of boundary vectors satisfies Eq. (VI.7.80), provided that all the addends also obey the same conditions. Indeed the coefficients of
1735
the mUltiple products (with more than three entries), needed to express the square of the sum of more than three vectors, are multiples of eight. There is one further constraint on the boundary vectors following from one-loop modular invariance. In order to discuss such a constraint it is convenient to build explicitly the modular invariant vacuum to vacuum amplitudes (or partition functions) of the model. An ordered pair of boundary vectors a, b defines a one-loop spin structure [:] where a and b give the boundary conditions in a and T respectively. To each spin structure there is associated a contribution to the vacuum amplitude which, according to the previous section, can be rewritten as
(VI. 7. 89)
where the trace is taken over the states of the string sector characterized by the boundary vector a, and b· F", I S. Fi , Fi being the h . 1 fermion number of the it world-sheet fermion AI. More precisely, we have Ni (-1) NS
i
i NNS
(-1/
Ni
(_I)Rf2A~, NiR
I
Ait Ai
r" ~ r r
, for a.1 "
Y Ai\i ,
n"l n n
0 (NS) (VI. 7. 90)
for a.1
1 (R)
A~ is proportional to a gamma matrix, and the operator (~l)b'F ~ S.F i
n.1 (~l)
is well defined only when a prescription is given for the . order to be taken in the product of the A~'S' It is possible to show that there are prescriptions such that 1
1736
(VI. 7.91)
(D) Apart from the factor Z(X)(T) (see Eq. (VI.7.27)) the total one-loop partition function is given by Eq. (VI.7.26b):
Wei)
=k
I
(a,b)
c[aJ b
z[a]b .
(VI. 7.92)
The normalization factor k and the set of the needed spin structures will be specified later. Note that
c[:J
are the one-loop boundary condition dependent
coefficients introduced for the first time in Sq. (VI.6.2S). In the multiloop case the total partition function of the fermionic string has a similar form: (VI. 7.93)
where z~~~ is given by Eq. (VI.6.192b) and
is the multiloop analogue of Eq. (Vl.7.92), the Z symbol in (VI.7.94) being the multiloop analogue of the one-loop Z symbol defined in Eq. (VI. 7.3): 1/2
(f rg det Im II) 1/2 (det
I
fs) 1/2
1737 * 1/2 N+M
II i=N+l
The factor X
(I ,rg det 1m 1T) 1/2 (det
(VI. 7.9S) t
A) 1/2
a:II1 , .•. ,a1/1] g is the contribution of the gravitino ghost 1jJ
1/1
hI' •.. ,bg
and of the two longitudinal 1jJU discussed in Section VI.5.7. By a~. 1/1 + 1 bi we denote components of the boundary vectors t 1 , hi corresponding to D~2 ~-fermions endowed with transverse indices. It is missing in the g=1 case since there it is equal to one as explained in Section VI.6.7. The reader should not confuse them with the double set of labels attributed to the boundary vectors. The upper index enumerate the components of the vector and indicates which fermion we are dealing with; the lower index enumerates the handles of the Riemann surface. Following the arguments of Section VI.6.2 the multiloop coefficients appearing in Eq. (VI.7.94) must have a completely factorized form: (VI. 7.96)
in terms of the our goal.
one~loop
coefficients (VI.7.92), whose determination is
We begin by conSidering the constraints due to invariance. The S and T generators of PSL(2,1) act on
z[aJ-...!.-~eiTla2/8z[ a ] b a+b+lI
one~loop
modular
z[: 1 as follows
(VI.7.97b)
1738
where ]. is the botmdary vector with ing Eq.