1405822023_COVER(front)
24/7/05
10:42 PM
Page 1
Remodelling Schools Manual
Workforce Reform Sonia Blandford
8658 ...
28 downloads
1517 Views
932KB Size
Report
This content was uploaded by our users and we assume good faith they have the permission to share this book. If you own the copyright to this book and it is wrongfully on our website, we offer a simple DMCA procedure to remove your content from our site. Start by pressing the button below!
Report copyright / DMCA form
1405822023_COVER(front)
24/7/05
10:42 PM
Page 1
Remodelling Schools Manual
Workforce Reform Sonia Blandford
8658 RSWR_AO1.QXD 27/9/05 10:38 am Page iii
Remodelling Schools Manual Workforce Reform SONIA BLANDFORD
8658 RSWR_AO1.QXD 27/9/05 12:08 pm Page iv
PEARSON EDUCATION LIMITED Edinburgh Gate Harlow CM20 2JE Tel: +44 (0)1279 623623 Fax: +44 (0)1279 431059 Website: www.pearsoned.co.uk
First published in Great Britain in 2006 © Pearson Education Limited 2006 The right of Sonia Blandford to be identified as author of this work has been asserted by her in accordance with the Copyright, Designs and Patents Act 1988. ISBN 13: 978-1-4058-2202-2 ISBN 10: 1-4058-2202-3 British Library Cataloguing-in-Publication data A catalogue record for this book is available from the British Library Library of Congress Cataloging-in-Publication Data Blandford, Sonia. Remodelling school : workforce reform / Sonia Blandford. p. cm. -- (School management solutions series) Includes index. ISBN-13: 978-1-4058-2202-2 1. School personnel management--Great Britain. 2. School improvement programs--Great Britain. 3. Teachers--Workload--Great Britain. 4. Educational change--Great Britain. I. Title. II Series. LB2831.585.G7B58 2005 371.2’02--dc22 2005052746 All rights reserved. No part of this publication may be reproduced, stored in a retrieval system, or transmitted in any form or by any means, electronic, mechanical, photocopying, recording, or otherwise, without either the prior written permission of the publisher or a licence permitting restricted copying in the United Kingdom issued by the Copyright Licensing Agency Ltd, 90 Tottenham Court Road, London W1T 4LP. This book may not be lent, resold, hired out or otherwise disposed of by way of trade in any form of binding or cover other than that in which it is published, without the prior consent of the Publishers. 10 9 8 7 6 5 4 3 2 1 09 08 07 06 05 Typeset in 10.5/16pt Stone Serif by 30 Printed and bound in Great Britain by Ashford Colour Press Ltd, Gosport, Hampshire The Publisher’s policy is to use paper manufactured from sustainable forests.
8658 RSWR_AO1.QXD 27/9/05 10:38 am Page v
To Bethany and Mia – my remodelled workforce.
8658 RSWR_AO1.QXD 27/9/05 10:38 am Page vi
1
8658 RSWR_AO1.QXD 27/9/05 10:38 am Page vii
Contents
Author’s acknowledgements
ix
About the author
ix
Publisher’s acknowledgements Abbreviations
x xi
Useful websites
xiv
Introduction
xv
SECTION 1 · REMODELLING AND WORKFORCE REFORM
1
1
Why remodelling and workforce reform?
5
2
What is remodelling?
13
3
Remodelling and workforce reform practice
19
4
Remodelling issues
26
Workshop materials
33
Summary
38
SECTION 2 · THE EXTENDED SCHOOL – A COMMUNITY OF LEARNERS
39
5
A community of learners
42
6
School, home and the community
45
7
Extended schools
48
8
Community schools
53
9
Extended schools – extended services
57
10 Working in partnership with local authorities
61
Workshop materials
69
Summary
72
SECTION 3 · WORKFORCE REFORM
73
11 School workforce reform – policy
76
12 Teachers
81
13 Teaching assistants
88
14 Higher level teaching assistants
92
15 Headteachers
96
Workshop materials
100
Summary
105
Remodelling Schools Manual: Workforce Reform by Sonia Blandford Published by Pearson Education © Pearson Education Limited 2006
vii
8658 RSWR_AO1.QXD 27/9/05 10:38 am Page viii
Contents
SECTION 4 · RESOURCES
107
16 Funding and value for money
110
17 Recruitment and selection
117
18 Induction
124
19 Performance management
128
20 Professional development policy and practice
131
21 Professional development – qualifications framework
138
Workshop materials
146
Summary
154
SECTION 5 · LEADING REMODELLING
155
22 Change
158
23 Leading teams
168
24 Work/life balance
174
Workshop materials
181
Summary
186
SECTION 6 · REMODELLING FOR LEARNING
187
25 Learning and teaching
191
26 Planning, monitoring and evaluating
198
27 Where next?
209
Workshop materials
212
Summary
222
Postscript
223
Bibliography
227
Index
235
viii
Remodelling Schools Manual: Workforce Reform by Sonia Blandford Published by Pearson Education © Pearson Education Limited 2006
8658 RSWR_AO1.QXD 27/9/05 10:38 am Page ix
Author’s acknowledgements
The approach to the writing of this manual was to gather a team of interested and valued practitioners; it would not have been written without their expertise, encouragement and time. I wish to express my thanks to Marissa Newton, Kent County Council; Raphael Wilkins, Dr Viv Wilson and Bob Gibbs, Canterbury Christ Church University; and the schools who participated in the research. Particular thanks to Dr Lynne Graham-Matheson and Charlie Eldridge who assisted with the research and subsequent editing.
About the author
Professor Sonia Blandford is Pro-Vice Chancellor (Dean of Education) at Canterbury Christ Church University, which is one of the largest providers of initial teacher training and professional development in the United Kingdom. Following a successful career as a teacher in primary and secondary schools, Sonia has worked in higher education for nine years. Sonia has acted as an education consultant to ministries of education in Eastern Europe, South America and South Africa. Sonia has also worked as an advisor to the European Commission, local education authorities (LEAs), and schools, and co-leads the Teach First initiative. As an author of a range of education management texts, Sonia has a reputation for her straightforward approach to difficult issues. Sonia writes in an accessible style, communicating ideas in a pragmatic manner as illustrated in Master Class and columns written for the Guardian.
Remodelling Schools Manual: Workforce Reform by Sonia Blandford Published by Pearson Education © Pearson Education Limited 2006
ix
8658 RSWR_AO1.QXD 27/9/05 12:08 pm Page x
Publisher’s acknowledgements
We are grateful to the following for permission to reproduce copyright material: Extract from ‘New Trainers’ by Sonia Blandford, 14 September 2004, The Guardian ©Guardian Newspapers Limited 2004; extract from ‘What the changes mean for us’ by Stephen Hoare, 1 March 2005, The Guardian ©Guardian Newspapers Limited 2005; extract from ‘Role model 1: support staff raise self-esteem’ by Chris Arnot, 1 March 2005 The Guardian ©Guardian Newspapers Limited 2005; extract from ‘All change on the job front’ by Julie Nightingale, 1 March 2005, The Guardian ©Guardian Newspapers Limited 2005; Figure 4.1 from ‘Funding responsibilities’ from School and LEA Funding, a presentation by Stephen Bishop at DfES (www.teachernet.gov.uk); Figure 6.3 from Blandford, S., Middle Management in Schools, 1997, Pitman; Figure 6.5 from Hargreaves, D.H., ‘Self-managing schools and development planning – chaos or control?’, School Leadership & Management, Vol. 15:3. pp. 215–217, http://www.tandf.co.uk/journals, reproduced with permission; Table 6.1 from Blandford, S., Middle Management in Schools, 1997, Pitman.
In some instances we have been unable to trace the owners of copyright material, and we would appreciate any information that would enable us to do so.
x
Remodelling Schools Manual: Workforce Reform by Sonia Blandford Published by Pearson Education © Pearson Education Limited 2006
8658 RSWR_AO1.QXD 27/9/05 10:38 am Page xi
Abbreviations
AST
Advanced Skills Teacher
ATL
Association of Teachers and Lecturers
BA
Bachelor of Arts
BEST
Behaviour and Educational Support Team
CAF
Common Assessment Framework
CEP
Career Entry Profiles
Cert Ed
Certificate in Education
CFR
Consistent Financial Reporting
CHS
Childhood Studies
CMC
Community Music Centre
CMT
Change Management Team
CPD
Continuing Professional Development
CRB
Criminal Record Bureau
CV
Curriculum Vitae
CWDC
Children’s Workforce Development Council
CYPP
Children and Young People
CYS
Child and Youth Studies
DfES
Department for Education and Skills
DTI
Department of Trade and Industry
EAZ
Education Action Zone
EBR
Employment-based Route
EdD
Doctor of Education
EDP
Educational Development Plan
ERA
Education Reform Act
EWO
Education Welfare Officer
EWS
Education Welfare Service
EY
Early Years
Remodelling Schools Manual: Workforce Reform by Sonia Blandford Published by Pearson Education © Pearson Education Limited 2006
xi
8658 RSWR_AO1.QXD 27/9/05 10:38 am Page xii
Abbreviations
FAS
Funding Agency for Schools
GCSE
General Certificate of Secondary Education
GT
Graduate Trainee
GTC(E)
General Teaching Council for England
GTP
Graduate Training Programme
HEI
Higher Education Institution
HLTA
Higher Level Teaching Assistant
HMG
Her Majesty’s Government
ICT
Information, Communication and Technology
IMC
International Music Centre
INSET
In-service Education and Training
IRU
Implementation Review Unit
IT
Information Technology
ITT
Initial Teacher Training
KS
Key Stage
LAA
Local Area Agreement
LEA
Local Education Authority
LRA
Learning Resource Assistant
LSC
Learning and Skills Council
MBA
Master of Business Administration
MCI
Management Charter Initiative
NAHT
National Association of Headteachers
NASUWT
National Association of Schoolmasters’ Union of Women Teachers
NCE
National Commission on Education
NCSL
National College for School Leadership
NEOST
National Employers’ Organisation for School Teachers
NHS
National Health Service
NJC
National Joint Council
NPSH
National Professional Qualification for Headship
NQT
Newly Qualified Teacher
NRT
National Remodelling Team
xii
Remodelling Schools Manual: Workforce Reform by Sonia Blandford Published by Pearson Education © Pearson Education Limited 2006
8658 RSWR_AO1.QXD 27/9/05 10:38 am Page xiii
Abbreviations
NVQ
National Vocational Qualification
ODPM
Office of the Deputy Prime Minister
Ofsted
Office for Standards in Education
OTT
Overseas Trained Teacher
PE
Physical Education
PFI
Private Finance Initiative
PGCE
Postgraduate Certificate in Education
PhD
Doctor of Philosophy
PPA
Planning, Preparation and Assessment
PVI
Private Voluntary Independent
QCA
Qualifications and Curriculum Authority
QTS
Qualified Teacher Status
RT
Registered Teacher
RTP
Registered Teacher Programme
SEN
Special Educational Needs
SENCO
Special Educational Needs Coordinator
SHA
Secondary Heads’ Association
SIP
School Improvement Plan
SLT
Senior Leadership Team
SMT
Senior Management Team
STPCD
School Teacher Pay and Conditions Document
STRB
School Teacher Review Board
TA
Teaching Assistant
TDA
Training and Development Agency
TGWU
Transport and General Workers’ Union
TSW
Transforming School Workforce
TTA
Teacher Training Agency
WAMG
Workforce Agreement Monitoring Group
Remodelling Schools Manual: Workforce Reform by Sonia Blandford Published by Pearson Education © Pearson Education Limited 2006
xiii
8658 RSWR_AO1.QXD 27/9/05 10:38 am Page xiv
Useful websites
Key documents can be found at the following websites: DfES
www.dfes.gov.uk and www.teachernet.gov.uk
Every Child Matters
www.everychildmatters.gov.uk
The Guardian
http://education.guardian.co.uk/remodelling
National Remodelling Team
www.remodelling.org
The above list is by no means exhaustive. As you investigate further, you will find links to other sites that will inform your practice. Keep a record on your computer using favourites as you explore the most relevant sites to you and your school.
xiv
Remodelling Schools Manual: Workforce Reform by Sonia Blandford Published by Pearson Education © Pearson Education Limited 2006
8658 RSWR_AO1.QXD 27/9/05 10:38 am Page xv
Introduction
REMODELLING SCHOOLS: WORKFORCE REFORM In 2000, government negotiations with a range of agencies led to workforce reform: a remodelling of practice in schools which would provide teachers with time to focus on raising standards in schools. The changes that followed emanated from the good practice that was already evident in many schools. The ‘one size fits all’ model of the 1988 Education Reform Act (ERA) was to be revisited. The remodelling process is predicated on change which is a feature that will remain with schools for the foreseeable future. This future holds many challenges and opportunities for the wider workforce who are tasked with the planning and delivery of workforce reform, extended schools and the five outcomes of Every Child Matters. In 2003, the National Remodelling Team (NRT) was established by the Department for Education and Skills (DfES) and hosted by the National College of School Leadership (NCSL) to promote and progress the school workforce remodelling agenda. The NRT was tasked with working in partnership with local education authorities (LEAs) to release the capacity for change which exists in schools and to create and manage their own self-directed and supported change process (NCSL, 2003). As from 1 April 2005, this has been hosted by the Teacher Training Agency (TTA), which became the Training and Development Agency (TDA) for Schools in September 2005. The Workforce Agreement Monitoring Group (WAMG) representing teaching unions and other partners within the National Agreement for Raising Standards and Tackling Workload (WAMG, 2003a) supported the launch of the NRT. Dame Pat Collarbone, the NRT National Director, stated that ‘as we collect more and more evidence of a revolution beginning to take place in our schools, the realisation is beginning to dawn, not only that remodelling is achievable, but that it represents perhaps the most powerful tool we have for changing the education landscape’ (NCSL, 2003). Initiatives are rarely entirely new: remodelling emanates from existing good practice demonstrated in a number of schools and, therefore, the notion that the remodelling of schools is an initiative created by government policy is inaccurate. Many of the central tenets of a remodelled school (employment of support staff in classrooms, schools as learning environments managed by teachers, extended hours, and multi-agency provision in partnership with children and youth agencies) are not new. There are elements of such practice evident in many primary and secondary community schools in England and Wales since the introduction of compulsory education. It should also be noted that the majority of state schools have been well-led and efficiently managed organisations with committed staff that inspire children to learn.
Remodelling Schools Manual: Workforce Reform by Sonia Blandford Published by Pearson Education © Pearson Education Limited 2006
xv
8658 RSWR_AO1.QXD 27/9/05 10:38 am Page xvi
Introduction
Prior to the ERA, schools were able to approach learning and teaching in response to local and individual needs. The ERA introduced a common curriculum with statutory assessment at ages 7, 11, 14 and 16. In addition to a national curriculum and common assessment framework, parents were able to select the school their child attended, and schools were to be responsible for budgets and marketing. In the context of control and change, teachers were increasingly required to deliver a curriculum created by government committees. At this time, teachers felt disempowered and under pressure; many left the profession. Those that remain contrive to be highly committed professionals working in partnership with other agencies, delivering a curriculum and assessing children within a common framework. As demonstrated by local leagues and concerts, many schools continue to provide sports and performing arts activities that extend the curriculum beyond the school day. For example, the National Festival of Music for Youth celebrates the ever-increasing number of school ensembles and reflects the high standards of performance in schools and local communities. Schools also continue to support children, at a basic level, with special educational and social needs; they serve free school meals and some have already extended provision with the introduction of breakfast clubs. The Office for Standards in Education (OfSTED) has acknowledged the significant improvements that have taken place in schools (OfSTED, 2004). These achievements are evidenced by the year on year increase in the number of students gaining qualifications at 16 and 18 Department for Education and Science (DfES, 2005d). The introduction of the national teaching awards has also been a public recognition of the skill and commitment of those dedicated to raising standards in schools. It is within this context that, since 2000, many of the agencies (unions and government, private and state) that have contributed to the positive improvements in schools came together to develop a framework that would further enhance good practice. Remodelling schools and workforce reform have been created to introduce a structured change that would empower schools to tackle issues according to context. As the NRT stated (from website www.remodelling.org): In September 2003 a unique agreement was struck between unions and government agencies to secure improved working conditions for teachers. This has led to the remodelling of schools where a teacher’s practice … focus[es] on learning with less emphasis on administrative and support tasks … Set within the context of the future social, economic, technological and educational change, teachers will accommodate changes as a matter of course. Change management will continue to be a normal part of a professional’s life.
The global phenomenon of poor recruitment and retention of skilled and informed professionals needs to be addressed. Many agencies have recognised that schools are not static organisations. Set within the context of the twenty-first century knowledge society, the shared view is that graduates from all disciplines might find teaching a more attractive profession. A significant factor within the remodelling process is the focus on supporting teachers who, for many years, have worked above and beyond contracted hours, by reducing the number of administrative tasks encountered on a daily basis.
xvi
Remodelling Schools Manual: Workforce Reform by Sonia Blandford Published by Pearson Education © Pearson Education Limited 2006
8658 RSWR_AO1.QXD 27/9/05 10:38 am Page xvii
Introduction
Remodelling is not just another initiative; it introduces a new way of managing schools and claims to have the potential to transform the lives of all who work and study in them. As such, any person or organisation involved in the education sector is inevitably involved in remodelling: from the DfES to pupils. The most active participants in implementing the remodelling programme are shown in Table i which is adapted from the NRT website www.remodelling.org: Schools are central to the Government’s aim to develop a world-class children’s workforce that is competent and confident and which people aspire to be part of and want to remain where they can develop their skills and build satisfying and rewarding careers so that parents, carers, children and young children trust and respect (DfES, 2004b).
Table i Remodelling participants ●
Schools are at the frontline of remodelling. The remodelling process is an opportunity for them to seize the initiative and make a difference to the effectiveness and work/life balance of staff and the way pupils learn.
●
LEAs have at least one nominated remodelling adviser in place; many LEAs have a team of remodelling advisers. These advisers support schools through their change process, and champion the remodelling agenda and workforce agreement within the LEA. These advisers identify ‘early adopter’ schools to be fast-tracked through the change management process. These early adopters created the momentum for remodelling across England and served as examples of what remodelling can achieve.
●
The WAMG is a partnership of 10 organisations* representing employers, government and school workforce unions. It is firmly committed to a better deal for everyone working in schools, including support staff, teachers, headteachers and, most importantly, pupils. The union members of WAMG represent the Association of Teachers and Lecturers (ATL), GMB, National Association of Schoolmasters’ Union of Women Teachers (NASUWT), National Employers’ Organisation for School Teachers (NEOST), PAT, Secondary Heads’ Association (SHA), Transport and General Workers’ Union (TGWU) and Unison.
●
Governors have a key role in school remodelling, particularly ensuring that their school is implementing the contractual changes introduced in the National Agreement and in making sure that remodelling is central to all their school’s future planning.
●
Remodelling consultants work with LEAs to support and advise individual schools as they go through their change processes. Remodelling consultants use their skills to identify the key issues and underlying challenges that schools need in order to ▼
address remodelling successfully.
* There were initially 11 organisations but the National Association of Headteachers (NAHT) withdrew in March 2005.
Remodelling Schools Manual: Workforce Reform by Sonia Blandford Published by Pearson Education © Pearson Education Limited 2006
xvii
8658 RSWR_AO1.QXD 27/9/05 10:38 am Page xviii
Introduction
●
The NRT works in partnership with LEAs, NRT regional centres, WAMG, DfES and other bodies to challenge and support schools in implementing the National Agreement. It also supports forward-looking ways of remodelling the school workforce in England. The NRT has been training and coordinating LEA remodelling advisers to help schools understand the change process and support them in developing their own solutions, and in learning from other schools.
●
The Implementation Review Unit (IRU) panel of serving headteachers, teachers and a school bursar scrutinise initiatives from a number of national organisations, including DfES, OfSTED, TTA and LEAs. It also has a regional role and will be seeking information directly from schools to inform their work. The IRU meets regularly with WAMG and with government ministers.
Source: Adapted from the NRT website, www.remodelling.org.
Remodelling the workforce underpins the government’s drive to improve outcomes for all children and young people so that they are healthy, stay safe, enjoy and achieve, make a positive contribution and achieve economic well-being as detailed in Every Child Matters (DfES, 2003b), Every Child Matters: Next Steps (DfES, 2004a), Choice for Parents – the Best Start for Children: A 10 year Strategy for Childcare (HM Treasury, 2004), Common Assessment Framework (DfES, 2005c) and Common Core of Skills and Knowledge for the Children’s Workforce (DfES, 2005b). Examination of the DfES website (www.dfes.gov.uk) shows the importance of workforce reform in current government thinking. Remodelling encompasses three key points of practice: ●
National Agreement on workload enabling teachers to focus on learning and teaching.
●
The Extended School, through the engagement of para-professionals and experts in a range of activities, while attending to basic needs so that children are able to access a creative and active curriculum.
●
Every Child Matters to be delivered through increased and enhanced multi-agency and inter-agency collaboration for the benefit of all children.
WHO IS THIS MANUAL FOR? This manual is compiled for the wider workforce within and beyond the school community who contribute to the functions and well-being of a remodelled school: ●
governors
●
headteachers
●
senior leaders, managers and supervisors
●
teachers
●
learning support staff, learning mentors, higher level teaching assistants (HLTAs) and teaching assistants (TAs)
xviii
Remodelling Schools Manual: Workforce Reform by Sonia Blandford Published by Pearson Education © Pearson Education Limited 2006
8658 RSWR_AO1.QXD 27/9/05 10:38 am Page xix
Introduction
●
administrators and their support staff
●
technicians and site managers who manage the environment and contribute to the wellbeing of the school
●
finance managers
●
the wider workforce, including health and social services professionals.
WHAT DOES THE MANUAL DO? The manual provides the wider workforce with guidance and advice on how to implement, develop and evaluate remodelling and workforce reform. Set within the context of schools as learning organisations, the manual is written and designed to support leaders and professionals within the wider context of practice. Based on research and experience, the manual is a guide and resource, providing solutions to real problems. Worked examples are given in response to theoretical and practical issues. The reader will also find definitions and descriptions of new policies and practice. The manual aims to provide the reader with: ●
knowledge and understanding of remodelling and workforce reform
●
possible action that will deliver results.
The manual is divided into six sections that include: ●
a framework for practice based on current theories, policies and legislation
●
practical guidance based on case studies
●
checklists and questions for consideration by all members of the school community and associated practitioners
●
workshop materials
●
summaries.
The manual provides guidance on policies and examples of practices that can be transferred to schools. Each section will need to be read as appropriate to individual and school development needs. Advice in the manual is supplemented by a range of activities that might prove useful. Fig. i illustrates how the manual leads the reader from the principles of the remodelled school to identifying institutional and individual needs in creating a learning and supportive community.
Remodelling Schools Manual: Workforce Reform by Sonia Blandford Published by Pearson Education © Pearson Education Limited 2006
xix
8658 RSWR_AO1.QXD 27/9/05 10:38 am Page xx
Remodelling and workforce reform
Section 1
The extended school – a community of learners
Section 2
Workforce reform
Section 3
Resources
Section 4
Leading remodelling
Section 5
Remodelling for learning
Section 6
Why remodelling and workforce reform? What is remodelling? Remodelling practice Remodelling issues
Community of learners School, home and community Extended schools Community schools Extended services Working in partnership
School workforce reform: policy teachers teaching assistants HLTAs headteachers
Funding and value for money Recruitment and selection Induction Performance management Professional development
Leading teams Managing change Work/life balance
Learning and teaching Planning, monitoring and evaluating
Fig. i Remodelling in schools: workforce reform
xx
Remodelling Schools Manual: Workforce Reform by Sonia Blandford Published by Pearson Education © Pearson Education Limited 2006
8658 RSWR_AO1.QXD 27/9/05 10:38 am Page xxi
Summary of each section
Section 1: Remodelling and workforce reform This section examines policy and practice as determined by government legislation within the context of remodelling and workforce reform.
Section 2: The extended school – a community of learners This section asks what is meant by the school as a community. It provides guidance for those entering the new domain of the extended school as illustrated by case studies on effective practice.
Section 3: Workforce reform Practical advice is provided on the changing role of leaders, teachers and the school workforce. Set within the changing educational environment, this section focuses on the central tenets of workforce reform.
Section 4: Resources This section encompasses guidance on aspects of resource management that are necessary for management of the school workforce. Professional development is also a critical factor in the effective management of the school workforce and can occur in a variety of forms. This section provides models for teaching and non-teaching staff.
Section 5: Leading remodelling This section provides advice and guidance on how to develop teams and manage change. Case studies of effective collaboration between teaching and non-teaching staff will illustrate the strength of positive team management in schools.
Section 6: Remodelling for learning Learning and teaching underpin good practice. ‘Planning, monitoring and review’ provides valuable guidance on planning, including how to communicate with teams, practitioners and parents, and advice on monitoring and evaluation. The section concludes with information on designing a school strategy that engages the school workforce in remodelling.
Remodelling Schools Manual: Workforce Reform by Sonia Blandford Published by Pearson Education © Pearson Education Limited 2006
xxi
8658 RSWR_AO1.QXD 27/9/05 10:38 am Page xxii
Summary of each section
Summary and manual checklist This manual provides advice and guidance for practitioners, leaders and managers in schools. Building from policy to practice, the manual will take the reader through the current reforms through to practice within the classroom. Each section begins with a clear statement of intent followed by a diagram illustrating content, aims and objectives. Checklists provide the reader with the means of registering key points, followed by questions and case studies that focus on leadership and practice. A summary for each section provides an operational list upon which workshop materials are based.
The first section defines remodelling and workforce reform, and considers their application to practice.
xxii
Remodelling Schools Manual: Workforce Reform by Sonia Blandford Published by Pearson Education © Pearson Education Limited 2006
RSWR_CO1.QXD 27/9/05 9:28 am Page 1
Section 1
REMODELLING AND WORKFORCE REFORM
1
Why remodelling and workforce reform?
2
What is remodelling?
13
3
Remodelling and workforce reform practice
19
4
Remodelling issues
26
Workshop materials
33
Summary
38
Remodelling Schools Manual: Workforce Reform by Sonia Blandford Published by Pearson Education © Pearson Education Limited 2006
5
1
RSWR_CO1.QXD 27/9/05 9:28 am Page 2
1
RSWR_CO1.QXD 27/9/05 9:28 am Page 3
Introduction
Remodelling and workforce reform embrace the wider culture changes in education and the other professions that relate to children, young people and learners, while addressing staff workload. Many of these reforms have been developed out of good practice, which includes the child in determining the most appropriate support and improves his or her development. Key points to consider are leadership, management and planning, and resourcing and development. Figure 1.1 illustrates the factors that impact on the success of remodelling.
Policy: research consultancy and implementation
Change management
Delivery of learning
Planning, monitoring and evaluation
Accreditation and training
REMODELLING IN SCHOOLS: WORKFORCE REFORM
Extended schools: policy and practice
Routes into the professions
Multi-agency/inter-agency working Work/life balance
Fig. 1.1 Remodelling in schools: workforce reform
By placing learners at the centre, remodelling can enhance practice when: ●
it is understood as being of direct benefit to practitioners and the wider workforce
●
it acknowledges the individual as a professional within workforce reform
●
it is actively supported by headteachers and senior leadership team colleagues
Remodelling Schools Manual: Workforce Reform by Sonia Blandford Published by Pearson Education © Pearson Education Limited 2006
3
RSWR_CO1.QXD 27/9/05 9:28 am Page 4
Section 1 · Remodelling and workforce reform
●
the outcomes are related to all children so that they are healthy, stay safe, enjoy and achieve, make a positive contribution and achieve economic well-being (DfES, 2003b)
●
outcomes are achieved by a world-class children’s workforce (DfES, 2004b) that: – is competent and confident – people aspire to and want to remain where they can develop their skills and build satisfying and rewarding careers – parents, carers, children and young people trust and respect.
This section sets remodelling and workforce reform within the context of government policy and legislation.
Questions to consider 1 What is remodelling? 2 What is workforce reform? 3 Who are the stakeholders? 4 How will remodelling and workforce reform impact on your practice? 5 How can remodelling and workforce reform raise standards in education?
4
Remodelling Schools Manual: Workforce Reform by Sonia Blandford Published by Pearson Education © Pearson Education Limited 2006
RSWR_CO1.QXD 27/9/05 9:28 am Page 5
Chapter 1
WHY REMODELLING AND WORKFORCE REFORM?
Remodelling is a structured change process which empowers schools to tackle their key issues in a way that reflects their individual circumstances Source: NRT (2005)
This chapter outlines the policies and legislation that provide the framework for practice in the remodelling of schools. This introduction is not exhaustive and it is suggested that readers consult government and trade union websites relating to education, health and social work. In 2000, the government, trade unions and supporting agencies met to agree a strategy that would facilitate change in schools. As with previous policies, the purpose of the change was to raise standards in schools. While the approach was to set further targets and create new policies, there was also an emphasis on providing schools with the opportunity and resources to lighten the workload of teachers. School leaders would be encouraged to be creative in their approach to managing staff and extending provision in terms of time and scope. The agenda for change was far-reaching and encompassed a range of policies that was were to include all areas of public sector provision that engaged with children. As shown in Table 1.1, the government began workforce reform with the 2002 Education Act, Extended Schools (DfES, 2002; 2005f) and Every Child Matters (HMG, 2003a; DfES, 2003b). Established to help LEAs support schools with the implementation of Raising Standards and Tackling Workload: A National Agreement (WAMG, 2003a), the NRT has subsequently been involved in supporting schools with the implementation of the extended schools’ agenda and continues to produce regular updates, case studies and advice. There followed a plethora of related policies and papers that were intended to commit school leaders and other professionals to workforce reform, extended schools and Every Child Matters. In 2005, the DfES published a prospectus for extended schools (DfES, 2005f). During this period, the DfES also developed further policies on Every Child Matters that engage school, health and social work practitioners in further change: the Five Year Strategy for Children and Learners (DfES, 2004d), A 10 Year Strategy for Childcare (HM Treasury, 2004) and Every Child Matters: Children’s Workforce Strategy (DfES, 2005a).
Remodelling Schools Manual: Workforce Reform by Sonia Blandford Published by Pearson Education © Pearson Education Limited 2006
5
RSWR_CO1.QXD 27/9/05 9:28 am Page 6
Section 1 · Remodelling and workforce reform
2002
Education Act Extended schools
2003
National Agreement Time for standards: transforming the school workforce National Remodelling Team School teacher pay and conditions Every Child Matters
2004
Children Act
2005
Five-Year Strategy on Education Every Child Matters: Change for Children Every Child Matters: Children’s Workforce Strategy Common Core of Skills and Knowledge Common Assessment Framework
Table 1.1 Key developments and policy documents
In addition, supplementary policies on finance (DfES, 2003a), skills and knowledge (DfES, 2005b) and a common assessment framework (DfES, 2005c) have been produced along with further government legislation and details of earlier policies. Each new document contributes to school practice but has also swamped practitioners with ever more advice to be absorbed. In 2005, further advice was also provided by the TTA (Developing Multiagency Teams) and the Study Support Teams Extended Schools Framework. There are also local policies that supersede or supplement the national policies in the context of LEA reform; the creation of Children’s Trusts is an example of such change. This is to replace LEAs’ bringing together of services that embrace the social, educational and economic wellbeing of children as determined by Every Child Matters (DfES, 2003b).
WORKFORCE REFORM Workforce reform legislation began with the 2002 Education Act through regulations under Section 133 implemented in August 2003 (see www.opsi.gov.uk/si/si2003/20031663.htm). The accompanying guidance was fully endorsed by the signatories of the National Agreement on raising standards and tackling workload. The purpose of the legislation was to make an important contribution to changing the way that schools work, raising the standards for pupils by increasing the range of adults with different skills and experience in schools. Given the previous limited range of guidance on adults in the classroom, the government also sought to ensure that schools safeguard the quality of pupils’ education when they are working with adults who are not qualified teachers (DfES, 2003a). The legislation was underpinned by the need to address the concerns of trade unions and educationalists that the workforce had been required to work beyond a reasonable level. This had been expressed as concerns about workload, job satisfaction, recruitment and
6
Remodelling Schools Manual: Workforce Reform by Sonia Blandford Published by Pearson Education © Pearson Education Limited 2006
RSWR_CO1.QXD 27/9/05 9:28 am Page 7
Why remodelling and workforce reform? · 1
efficiency within the context of a government emphasis on teachers raising the quality and standards of achievement of young people in schools (STRB, 2002; DfES, 2003a). Since 1988, schools have been required to reform in order to meet government legislation. The difference, espoused by the National Agreement and later by the NRT, was that schools should move away from the uniformity and compliance of the ERA towards a greater sense of equity and interdependency where change is to be at differing levels. There is an opportunity for schools to lead reform by working in partnership with LEAs within the framework set by government, trade unions, lead professionals and other stakeholders. This opportunity allows for creativity and flexibility in planning workforce reform, but there is a challenge to personalise the service they provide in response to the agendas of Extended Schools (DfES, 2002; 2005f) and Every Child Matters (DfES, 2003b). Schools are being encouraged to remodel the workforce as described in the guidance for governors: Remodelling is about giving teachers more time to focus on teaching and learning, and providing extra support and renewed leadership to reduce workload, increase job satisfaction and maximize the effectiveness of the whole school workforce in delivering improved standards. Remodelling is about a culture change in schools; about using a broader range of adults in different roles. It will have a profound effect on the ways schools work. Source: NRT (2004a)
Further explanations are given in Chapter 2, but remodelling moves school teaching staff from the high levels of prescription that had become workload issues. The National Agreement identifies the need to move teachers away from those activities other than teaching that had created overload. In 2001, a report by PriceWaterhouseCoopers (PriceWaterhouseCoopers, 2001) showed that teachers had been working up to 70 hours a week. Three successive secretaries of state for education agreed that the way forward was the remodelling of the workforce.
EXTENDED SCHOOLS The government’s commitment to extended schools is detailed in the DfES’s Extended Schools, which provides opportunities for all: An extended school is one that provides a range of services and activities often beyond the school day to help meet the needs of its pupils, their families and the wider community. Across the country, many schools are already providing some extended services including adult education, study support, ICT facilities and community sports programmes. Schools and their partners can build on existing provision and consider what additional services or activities they might offer. Source: DfES (2002)
Extended schools are an example of integrated practice between public and private agencies and schools that provide universal services in support of the development of the child. Delivering extended services requires a flexible approach. Schools are to set out in their
Remodelling Schools Manual: Workforce Reform by Sonia Blandford Published by Pearson Education © Pearson Education Limited 2006
7
RSWR_CO1.QXD 27/9/05 9:28 am Page 8
Section 1 · Remodelling and workforce reform
school profile any self-evaluations of extended services they provided which will then be inspected by Ofsted. Considerations of extended services and how they can raise standards will also form part of a school’s improvement plan. Further details can be found in Extended Schools: Access to Opportunities and Services to all: A Prospectus (DfES, 2005f) (see Chapter 7).
EVERY CHILD MATTERS With the government green paper, Every Child Matters (HMG, 2003a) sets out a framework for improving the outcomes of all children and young people. There followed a number of documents that focused on children within school, communities and other environments. Every Child Matters: Change for Children (DfES, 2004e) sets out a national framework for local change programmes to build services around the needs of children and young people in order to maximise opportunity. In 2004, the five outcomes of Every Child Matters were given legal force in the 2002 Children Act, as shown in Table 1.2.
Be healthy
Physically, mentally and emotionally healthy Healthy lifestyles Parents promote healthy choices
Stay safe
Safe from maltreatment, neglect and violence Safe from accidental injury and death Safe from bullying and discrimination Safe from anti-social behaviour Parents provide safe homes and stability
Enjoy and achieve
Ready for school Attend and enjoy school Achieve stretching national education standards Enjoy recreation Parents support learning
Make a positive
Engage and support the community and environment
contribution
Engage in positive behaviour in and out of school Develop positive relationships Develop self-confidence and deal with life changes and challenges Parents promote positive behaviour
Achieve economic
Engage in further education, employment or training after
well-being
leaving school Ready for employment Parents are supported to be economically active
Table 1.2 Five outcomes of Every Child Matters
8
Remodelling Schools Manual: Workforce Reform by Sonia Blandford Published by Pearson Education © Pearson Education Limited 2006
RSWR_CO1.QXD 27/9/05 9:28 am Page 9
Why remodelling and workforce reform? · 1
The approach taken by government in the delivery of these aims is for an integrated frontline delivery. Through the Common Core of Skills and Knowledge for the Children’s Workforce (DfES, 2005b) and Common Assessment Framework (DfES, 2005c), local authorities and partners will be working to improve the sharing of information and subsequent planning. The role of schools is self-evident as detailed in Every Child Matters: Change for Children in Schools: ● schools are being encouraged to offer a range of services that help pupils engage and achieve, and
building strong relationships with parents and the wider community and ● supporting closer working between universal services … so that children with additional needs can be
identified earlier and supported effectively. Source: DfES (2004c)
The impact of the 2004 Children Act will stimulate research, political analysis and discussion. The government has committed to further spending; it will be needed if Every Child Matters is to be delivered in a meaningful way. In the context of Every Child Matters, the workforce extends beyond schools and encompasses all agencies whose function it is to support and develop children. A clear and pragmatic description of workforce reform is provided in the introduction to Every Child Matters: Children’s Workforce Strategy: This strategy is designed to help improve skills and knowledge, encourage the joining-up of services around the needs of children and young people, and support a focus on prevention while strengthening protection. It encourages local partners to work together, across the public, private, voluntary and community sectors, to achieve these aims. It also seeks to promote improved careers for people working with children and young people, with the possibility of genuine progression available to all: better training, better development, better rewards. The Government believes that the key strategic challenges across children’s services are to: ● recruit more people into the children’s workforce, ensuring the work is attractive and promoting
more flexible entry routes; ● develop and retain more people within the children’s workforce, improving their skills building
on the Common Core of Skills and Knowledge and creating a single qualifications framework; ● strengthen inter-agency and multidisciplinary working, and workforce re-modelling; and ● promote stronger leadership, management and supervision.
Source: DfES (2005a)
These reforms are far-reaching and, if successful, will lead to the celebration and enhancement of all professions allied to child and young-people learning. However, in addition to policies, there is a need for a change in culture, perception and professional experience of the school workforce. Personally, professionally, socially and educationally the school workforce needs to be valued.
Remodelling Schools Manual: Workforce Reform by Sonia Blandford Published by Pearson Education © Pearson Education Limited 2006
9
RSWR_CO1.QXD 27/9/05 9:28 am Page 10
Section 1 · Remodelling and workforce reform
STRATEGIC CHALLENGES In 2004, the Department for Education and Skills published its five-year strategy for education in which guidelines for future practice were presented as follows: Five key principles of reform will underpin our drive for a step change in children’s services, education and training: ● Greater personalisation and choice with the wishes and needs of children, parents and learners
centre-stage ●
Opening up services to new and different providers and ways of delivering services
●
Freedom and independence for frontline headteachers, governors and managers with clear simple accountabilities and more secure streamlined funding arrangements
●
A major commitment to staff development with high quality support and training to improve assessment, care and teaching
●
Partnerships with parents, employers, volunteers and voluntary organisations to maximise the life chances of children, young people and adults. Source: DfES (2004d)
The principles that underpin the strategy for reform require further translation into practice. In 2005, the TTA published a draft framework for the training of professionals engaged in the delivery of children’s services relating to schools. Much of the change will need the commitment, understanding and goodwill of teachers, the extended school workforce and leaders. While early adopter and pathfinder schools will continue to maximise the possibilities that reform brings, the sceptics will require more than policies. For every school, remodelling raises strategic and operational challenges (see Chapter 26). Every Child Matters: Children’s Workforce Strategy (DfES, 2005a) details the government’s concerns regarding the recruitment of more people into the children’s workforce while ensuring the work is attractive and promoting flexible routes. Much has been achieved by the TTA in providing flexible routes into the profession (see Table 4.2 on page 144). However, the need to promote these routes reflects the disproportionate number of teachers leaving the profession. It is hoped that the remodelling of schools will provide some solutions as those in the profession commit to the changes. There are also plans to create a single qualification framework building on the Common Core of Skills and Knowledge. The National Children’s Bureau, TTA and the Children’s Workforce Development Council (CWDC) consultation is to be welcomed by professionals and higher education institutions (HEIs). The consultation process emphasises the need for teachers to be graduates and for other adults engaged in children’s service to have adequate training. The intended outcome of workforce reform is that educated, trained and retained professionals will work together; remodelling will then strengthen inter-agency and multiagency working. Nearly 30 years since the Warnock Report (DES, 1978) raised the issue, and
10
Remodelling Schools Manual: Workforce Reform by Sonia Blandford Published by Pearson Education © Pearson Education Limited 2006
RSWR_CO1.QXD 27/9/05 9:28 am Page 11
Why remodelling and workforce reform? · 1
ten years since the Code of Practice on the Identification and Assessment of Special Education Needs (DfE, 1994) was published, a statement of intent would be strategically useful; however, operationalising such policies continues to be a challenge and should be recognised as such. Leadership appears to be an answer; though in one sense, all practitioners are leaders. How will those in leadership positions be trained? The National Professional Qualification for Headship (NPQH) has had some impact and a new qualification, the National Professional Qualification for Leaders of Children and Educational Services, is to be introduced in 2006. The aim of Common Core of Skills and Knowledge for the Children’s Workforce, set in the context of Every Child Matters: Change for Children (DfES 2004e), is to support all those working with children in developing a shared understanding and common language, so that they can work together effectively in the delivery of the government’s five outcomes for children. Guided by the CWDC, the common core sets out what everyone working with children should know about, and be able to do, under six headings: ●
effective communication and engagement with children, young people and families
●
child and young person development
●
safeguarding and promoting the welfare of the child
●
supporting transitions
●
multi-agency working
●
sharing information.
The common core is intended as a starting point for further detailed work by responsible bodies. It is not a curriculum, nor is it pitched at a specific level. It can be used as a tool for human resources and to support the review of training programmes. It needs to be developed and adapted, as appropriate, for use by different professional groups and in qualifications at different levels.
CHILDREN’S TRUSTS The implementation and development of the workforce reform strategy involves a number of professionals from the public sector workforce managed by local authorities and the National Health Service (NHS). Several authorities were early adopters or pathfinder authorities who embraced government initiatives prior to legislation (see Chapter 10). Many of the early adopters created children’s trusts that included organisations from the state, private and voluntary sectors. These trusts have prepared the ground for LEAs to move towards the creation of Local Authority Children’s Trusts (see Chapter 10) bringing together education, social work and, in some cases, health professionals in one organisation.
Remodelling Schools Manual: Workforce Reform by Sonia Blandford Published by Pearson Education © Pearson Education Limited 2006
11
RSWR_CO1.QXD 27/9/05 9:28 am Page 12
Section 1 · Remodelling and workforce reform
RESOURCING WORKFORCE REFORM In 2003, the Secretary of State for Education and Skills responded quickly to headteacher concerns on the funding of schools. Workforce reform required sufficient financing to alleviate teacher shortage, the intention being that all professionals commit to the changes in the National Agreement and the Children Act. This followed an earlier statement in July 2002 that committed the government to eight key reforms: ●
guaranteed three-year budgets for every school from 2006, geared to pupil numbers, with every school guaranteed a minimum per-pupil increase each year
●
universal and better specialist schools
●
freedom for all secondary schools to own their land and buildings, manage their assets, employ their staff, improve their governing bodies, and forge partnerships with outside sponsors and educational foundations
●
more places in popular schools
●
a new relationship with schools to cut the red tape involved in accountability, without cutting schools adrift
●
200 academies by 2010 – and more new schools
●
every secondary school to be refurbished, or rebuilt, to a modern standard in the next 10 to 15 years
●
foundation partnerships.
It would seem that the government and their advisers were committed to extending the range of educational opportunities for all children and learners. In order to achieve these aims, the nature and range of opportunities for learners was to change. However, for practitioners, the words are different but the rhythm and tune has yet to change.
12
Remodelling Schools Manual: Workforce Reform by Sonia Blandford Published by Pearson Education © Pearson Education Limited 2006
RSWR_CO1.QXD 27/9/05 9:28 am Page 13
Chapter 2
WHAT IS REMODELLING?
The terms ‘remodelling’ and ‘workforce reform’ have become interchangeable. This is unhelpful as ‘workforce reform’ might more usefully be applied to the changes being introduced through the National Agreement and ‘remodelling’ applied in a broader sense to encompass Extended Schools and Every Child Matters. This chapter seeks to provide an understanding of the origins and implementation of the remodelling process.
Checklist Workforce reform focuses on: ●
a commitment to reduce teacher workload
●
enhanced responsibility for support staff
●
flexible deployment of support staff.
Remodelling embraces: ●
workforce reform
●
Extended Schools
●
Every Child Matters.
Remodelling and workforce reform are both part of a wider cultural change in how children are educated and supported by schools, the justice system, social workers and health professionals. The changes are therefore not unique to practitioners in schools. In order to become effective, the wider workforce will need to consider how to be inclusive, flexible, focused and collaborative. Remodelling is the means by which schools embrace workforce reform, Extended Schools and Every Child Matters. In practical terms, the introduction of remodelling will be at the discretion of the school leadership teams. However, legislation following the National Agreement determines that remodelling of the workforce must happen in a form that responds to and meets the requirements of the School Teachers’ Pay and Conditions Document (STPCD) (DfES, 2005e).
Remodelling Schools Manual: Workforce Reform by Sonia Blandford Published by Pearson Education © Pearson Education Limited 2006
13
RSWR_CO1.QXD 27/9/05 9:28 am Page 14
Section 1 · Remodelling and workforce reform
WORKFORCE REFORM As described, the government, in partnership with leading teaching and public sector trade unions, agreed that there should be a new approach to Raising Standards and Tackling Workload: A National Agreement (WAMG, 2003a). Rather than placing additional demands on school practitioners, there would be a commitment to providing additional resources to enhance the quality of learning and teaching. Remodelling of the workforce was implemented in September 2003. In practice, many schools had already begun the process with the introduction of learning and support assistants and school bursars. The three phases of the agreement are detailed on the DfES website (www.dfes.gov.uk). Of the various supplementary documents, the most helpful for schools are those aimed at governors provided on the NRT website (www.remodelling.org): Information Pack for Governors on Workforce Remodelling (NRT, 2004a) and Workforce Remodelling – A Guidance for Governors III (NRT, 2004b). The NRT website also contains a full copy of the National Agreement. The framework for the workforce reform was based on a seven-point plan aimed at creating time for teachers and headteachers to enable them to focus on raising standards in their schools (DfES, 2003a). In brief, these include: ●
a reduction in teachers’ overall hours, which should be monitored and audited
●
changes to teachers’ contracts to ensure that they – do not have to undertake routine administrative tasks – have a reasonable work/life balance – have reduced the burdens in providing cover for absent colleagues – have guaranteed planning, preparation and assessment time to support individual and collaborative teaching – have time allocated for leadership and management activities
●
an attack on paperwork and bureaucratic processes for all staff
●
reform of support staff roles that focus on helping teachers and supporting pupils
●
the recruitment of new managers with experience from outside education who can contribute to leadership teams
●
additional resources and national ‘change management’ programmes
●
a commitment to monitor progress.
As the guidance to governors states (NRT, 2003b), though statutory, remodelling would be phased to allow some transition of the National Agreement: Phase One: with effect on 1 September 2003 ● Monitoring of progress on delivery ● No teacher required routinely to undertake clerical and administrative tasks ● Provision made for teachers and headteachers to enjoy a reasonable work/life balance
14
Remodelling Schools Manual: Workforce Reform by Sonia Blandford Published by Pearson Education © Pearson Education Limited 2006
RSWR_CO1.QXD 27/9/05 9:28 am Page 15
What is remodelling? · 2
● Teachers with management and leadership responsibility entitled to a reasonable allocation of time
within school sessions to support the discharge of their responsibilities Phase Two: with effect on 1 September 2004 ● Introduce an initial limit on cover for absent teachers with the objective of reaching the point where
teachers at a school rarely cover at all. Phase Three: with effect on 1 September 2005 ● Introduce guaranteed professional time for planning, preparation and assessment ● Introduce new invigilation arrangements
Source: NRT (2003)
Given that this advice was first published for governors in September 2003, it is quite understandable that school leadership teams are still endeavouring to meet the demands on timetabling and other tasks previously managed and delivered by teachers.
PARTNERSHIP: NATIONAL STRUCTURE FOR REMODELLING The first priority for schools is to implement the National Agreement. To guide schools in their remodelling, the NRT promoted a change process based on techniques and experience gained in business and education environments, and successfully piloted in selected schools. This includes change management teams (CMTs) and collaboration with external agencies. In April 2003, the NRT was tasked with coordinating the implementation of workforce reform in partnership with the following organisations: ●
Workforce Agreement Monitoring Group (WAMG)
●
Diocese Directors of Education
●
Teacher Training Agency (TTA)
●
General Teaching Council for England (GTC(E))
●
Office for Standards in Education (Ofsted)
●
employers’ organisations
●
confederations
●
other trade unions
●
governors.
At a regional level, the regional NRT advisers coordinated with regional training teams, regional WAMGs and the NCSL affiliated centres (now NRT regional centres); they also utilised internet resources at www.remodelling.org. Depending on capacity and funding, both national and regional participants are supported by LEA remodelling advisors, remodelling consultants and diocesan schools’ advisers. Training has been provided by the NRT through LEA remodelling advisers, consultants and training coordinators. There are also NCSL training programme managers and regional training teams to supplement NRT guidance and advice.
Remodelling Schools Manual: Workforce Reform by Sonia Blandford Published by Pearson Education © Pearson Education Limited 2006
15
RSWR_CO1.QXD 27/9/05 9:28 am Page 16
Section 1 · Remodelling and workforce reform
WHO DOES IT INVOLVE IN SCHOOLS? Remodelling and workforce reform involve all professionals and practitioners engaged with schools and children. The list has grown beyond learning and teaching assistants to encompass all salaried (and some unsalaried) members of the school community now collectively termed as the school workforce. It has been acknowledged that support staff already played an important role in raising standards in schools; this was to be extended.
WHAT IS TO BE DELIVERED? Remodelling and workforce reform provide an opportunity for school leaders in collaboration with teachers and other professionals to redesignate to para-professionals activities that have little to do with teaching and learning. This should raise standards and address teachers’ work/life balance. Collectively, the remodelling community, through workforce reform, has the potential to enhance the status of everyone who works in schools, improve recruitment and retention, and challenge practice. Within the context of remodelling the workforce, a workload plan may assist in the allocation of teaching, management and administration time. Workload planning is the means by which the diverse workload of the school is allocated to individual staff. The procedures are designed to meet the needs of the school, individual departments and the aspirations of staff in a fair and transparent manner. The contractual changes for teachers, introduced in September 2003, are a real challenge for schools and governors. The NRT and WAMG are advising schools at LEA level, through NRT advisers, on the impact of the broader workforce reform agenda and its implications for learning and teaching.
CHALLENGES AND OPPORTUNITIES The development opportunities created by the implementation of the remodelled workforce are intended to create greater flexibility for teachers. The focus is to enhance a work/life balance for individuals while encouraging schools to work collaboratively in sharing ideas on how to work effectively (see Chapter 24). Fundamental to successful workforce reform is the need for all staff to feel valued. There are also challenges for schools as they develop an appropriate model of workforce reform. The uncertainty of funding is often cited by school leaders as the reason for failed initiatives and workforce reform has arrived at a time of considerable unrest and disagreement. In order to address some uncertainty, a priority for school leaders will be the generation of roles and expectations for the school workforce. Training will assist in this process (see Section 4); each member of the school workforce should participate in determining the nature of the roles of support staff. For example, teachers will need to know how: to manage other adults in the classroom; to provide opportunities for creative approaches to learning and teaching; and to adapt to working with different class and group sizes. Flexibility and training will be central to successful reform.
16
Remodelling Schools Manual: Workforce Reform by Sonia Blandford Published by Pearson Education © Pearson Education Limited 2006
RSWR_CO1.QXD 27/9/05 9:28 am Page 17
What is remodelling? · 2
PRACTICE Remodelling embraces workforce reform, Extended Schools and the principles that underpin Every Child Matters. The aim is to raise standards by tackling teacher and headteacher overload. This will only happen through a wider culture change which embraces practice that has a professional focus on teaching and learning. The NRT advised that this will be delivered in part by: ●
planning and preparation
●
lesson observation and reflective practice
●
personalised learning
●
assessment for learning
●
information, communication and technology (ICT) in the classroom
●
continuing professional development (CPD) for all staff
●
performance management and feedback.
This list was not intended to be definitive or exhaustive though the NRT consider that the subsequent impact will be raising standards measurable through: ●
pupils’ exam results
●
improved behaviour and attendance
●
staff recruitment, retention and morale
●
school being more popular
●
stakeholder expectations being met
●
Every Child Matters. Source: NRT (2005)
Checklist Developing the remodelled workforce ●
The range of activities for the remodelled workforce must be determined by all staff.
●
The remodelled workforce must be engaged according to school needs and priorities.
●
Training and resources are essential to effective change.
●
Government initiatives include dedicated time for planning, preparation and assessment.
●
Workload planning can assist with the implementation of school workforce reform.
●
Professional development for managing the new workforce is required.
Remodelling Schools Manual: Workforce Reform by Sonia Blandford Published by Pearson Education © Pearson Education Limited 2006
17
RSWR_CO1.QXD 27/9/05 9:28 am Page 18
Section 1 · Remodelling and workforce reform
Leadership and practitioner questions 1 Have you been trained to lead remodelling and workforce reform? 2 Have you trained your staff? 3 Do you have contact with national, regional and local support teams? 4 Do you use the NRT website, www.remodelling.org? 5 Are you involved in remodelling? 6 Do you have support for managing and delivering the curriculum? 7 Are you monitoring the progress of your pupils against national standards?
18
Remodelling Schools Manual: Workforce Reform by Sonia Blandford Published by Pearson Education © Pearson Education Limited 2006
RSWR_CO1.QXD 27/9/05 9:28 am Page 19
Chapter 3
REMODELLING AND WORKFORCE REFORM PRACTICE
Since 2003, there has been much reported on the impact of remodelling on practice. Interviews and case studies with headteachers and staff (see NRT website www.remodelling.org) clearly demonstrate that where schools are committed to remodelling, there has been considerable change in the deployment of the school workforce. It would appear that this has enabled teaching staff to focus on learning and teaching, having been released from administrative tasks and cover, and being allocated planning, preparation and assessment (PPA) time. The NRT predicts that most schools will be involved by 2006; by April 2005, 20,000 schools were involved. However, telephone interviews with a random selection of headteachers have identified a lack of momentum to the initiative that appears to counter claims (Blandford and Graham-Matheson, 2005). This chapter focuses on what has taken place in schools since January 2003 and what is intended for the immediate future. Later sections will focus on change management and resource issues that are critical to the success of remodelling. Remodelling is a process by which a number of previous school initiatives have come together. During the remodelling process, schools are to be self-directed and formulate solutions to their own problems that depend on the involvement and participation of the entire school community. The approach to remodelling is one of continuous change, underpinned by support involving national, regional and local networks. The more creative staff are in working together to plan, implement and develop effective teams, the greater the impact on practice and attainment in the classroom (Barber et al., 1995). Teachers and support staff will need to be guided and supported throughout the process (see Chapters 20, 21 and 22).
WHY CHANGE PRACTICE? The following extract presents a summary of the guidance and issues: In the current climate, remodelling is not a ‘nice to do’ it’s a ‘must do’. Over recent decades a combination of factors has created pressures which are forcing schools to change. Social and technological changes, employment legislation, Government initiatives and new models of learning and pupil assessment – all are driving change at breakneck speed. Schools are under pressure to raise standards and tackle workload, whilst at the same time having to deal with a number of unavoidable issues:
Remodelling Schools Manual: Workforce Reform by Sonia Blandford Published by Pearson Education © Pearson Education Limited 2006
19
RSWR_CO1.QXD 27/9/05 9:28 am Page 20
Section 1 · Remodelling and workforce reform
● teachers cite workload as their major reason for leaving the profession ● over 30 percent of a teacher’s working week is spent on non-teaching activities ● teachers generally have a poor work/life balance ● 45 percent of teachers are due to retire within the next 15 years ● 30 percent of teachers leave teaching in their first five years ● there is a need for development of professional support staff ● there are specific teacher shortages in a number of key subjects ● there is a need for recognition of individual learning styles ● there is a need for assessment for learning not just assessment of learning ● there is a need for collaboration within and between schools.
Source: NRT (2003a)
While schools will find their own solutions to particular problems, the following are common aims of remodelling: ●
teaching and learning is the main focus
●
the workforce is involved in making decisions
●
tasks and activities are undertaken by the appropriate people within flexible working patterns
●
managing change is a normal part of school life
●
the school shares experiences and learning with other schools and agencies
●
the work/life balance is acceptable to the whole workforce
●
all workforce and other stakeholders are aware of the vision and purpose of the school. Source: NRT (2003a)
CHANGES TO CONTRACT Headteachers were expected to implement the first phase of remodelling by 1 September 2003 (WAMG, 2003b). The necessary contractual changes include: ●
transfer of 24 clerical and administrative tasks from teachers to appropriate support and clerical staff
●
reduction in cover
●
the provision of a reasonable allocation of time in the school day to support leadership and management responsibilities.
The WAMG also provides useful guidance on implementing the transfer of workload: 8. Each of the tasks listed in paragraph 23 of the Agreement should be reviewed to identify if it is currently being done and who is doing it … Alternative arrangements will need to be made for any task currently being carried out by a teacher.
20
Remodelling Schools Manual: Workforce Reform by Sonia Blandford Published by Pearson Education © Pearson Education Limited 2006
RSWR_CO1.QXD 27/9/05 9:28 am Page 21
Remodelling and workforce reform practice · 3
9. There may be cases where teachers have management allowances or leadership posts for carrying out some of these tasks. Either the teacher may continue to manage the task or s/he may undertake an alternative responsibility commensurate with their management allowance or post and more focused on teaching and learning. In the context of the remodelling agenda the second option is the preferred one … 10. In transferring administrative and clerical tasks to support staff, heads must have regard to the suitability of the task to the member of staff’s current role, the impact on their workload and whether sufficient time is available, or could be freed up; whether additional training is needed; any implications for pay and grading. 11. A range of options could be used to facilitate the transfer of tasks including: ● revising a job description to replace an existing activity with a new one; ● revising a job description to reflect additional responsibilities including consideration of any
additional remuneration which may be necessary; ● extending paid working hours …
Source: WAMG (2003b)
Phase 1: Transfer of administrative tasks Remodelling began with an agreement that schools would tackle workload. School leadership teams are tasked with employing support staff to lighten the administrative load of teachers. Twenty-four tasks were identified (see Workshop 6.2 and NRT website www.remodelling.org). Planning is required if the school is to develop a culture of support and collaboration. The distribution of tasks might assist with the staff members’ understanding of where they are positioned in terms of feeling and being valued. If support and clerical staff feel undervalued, this will contribute negatively to work/life balance within the school. Other aspects of Phase 1 refer to work/life balance and leadership and management time. Work/life balance is discussed in greater detail in Chapter 24. Teachers with leadership and management responsibilities are now entitled, as far as is reasonably practical, to a reasonable allocation of time within school sessions to support the discharge of their responsibilities. This is in addition to the contractual provisions on work/life balance and the provisions of Phase 3. It should be recognised that work/life balance is for the individual to determine. At this stage, schools might wish to consult with other public sector employers; in particular, health and social workers have encountered similar issues to teachers. While the transfer of tasks might lighten the workload of teachers and headteachers, there is still the matter of delegation; planning is the key to success (see Chapter 22).
Phase 2: Cover A sustainable cover policy that limits or reduces to zero the amount of non-contact time eradicated by absence has been advised. Many schools have appointed an additional member of the teaching staff to provide the additional resource needed.
Remodelling Schools Manual: Workforce Reform by Sonia Blandford Published by Pearson Education © Pearson Education Limited 2006
21
RSWR_CO1.QXD 27/9/05 9:28 am Page 22
Section 1 · Remodelling and workforce reform
Phase 3: PPA Having removed clerical and administrative tasks, allocated cover to other professionals and considered work/life balance changes, the final phase includes the introduction of guaranteed PPA time. With effect from 1 September 2005, all teachers have a contractual entitlement to guaranteed PPA time within the timetabled teaching day. This should be at least 10% of their timetabled teaching time. In the case of newly qualified teachers this would be 10% of a reduced timetable that is equivalent to 90% of a main grade teacher’s timetable. The DfES and NRT advised that during the non-contact periods only teaching and learning activities that maintain or enrich the school curriculum should be timetabled. Again, this might seem problematic for small schools and should be an area for consideration in terms of funding (Chapter 16). Alternative arrangements such as the teaching or organisation of classes into large groups are also suggested, but these may also be limited by public liability insurance. Invigilation of public examinations is another area where teachers may not be appropriately employed. This is relatively straightforward in terms of planning; resourcing might be another matter. Dedicated headship time is also critical if staff are to benefit from changes indicated in the National Agreement, this might be less viable in small schools (Blandford and Craig, 2004).
TRANSFER OF OTHER TASKS In the transfer of tasks to support clerical staff, the government published guidance to accompany Section 133 regulations. These clarify the respective roles of qualified teachers and other staff in schools. Recognising that support staff already played a significant role in schools, the National Agreement proposed extended roles within a career structure encompassing HLTAs. The Education (Specified Work and Registration) (England) Regulations 2003 (HMG, 2003b) define the issues that schools should take into account when deploying new and existing support staff to work with pupils. It is clear that teachers and teaching assistants are not interchangeable. Specific work for teachers involve the following activities: ●
planning and preparing lessons and courses for individual pupils as well as groups and whole classes
●
delivering lessons to individual pupils as well as groups and whole classes, including delivery via distance learning or computer-aided techniques
●
assessing the development, progress and attainment of individual pupils
●
reporting on the development, progress and attainment of individual pupils.
Within the Regulations and School Teachers’ Pay and Conditions Document (DfES, 2005e), the government appears to acknowledge the role and status of qualified teachers. It is clear that only those with qualified teacher status (QTS) can have responsibility for pupil learning. However, the document also states that unqualified staff might take responsibility, for example, for the marking of multiple-choice tests. As such, there is scope for interpretation at all levels so that, for detailed breakdown of roles, schools might need clarification from advisers. 22
Remodelling Schools Manual: Workforce Reform by Sonia Blandford Published by Pearson Education © Pearson Education Limited 2006
RSWR_CO1.QXD 27/9/05 9:28 am Page 23
Remodelling and workforce reform practice · 3
In sum, the National Agreement includes the progressive reduction in teachers’ overall hours through changes to their contracts. It involves a concerted attack on unnecessary paperwork and bureaucracy leading to the reform of the support and clerical staff in order to assist teachers and support pupils. At this point of the change process, additional resources are needed (see Chapter 16).
COMMENT The most significant potential outcome of remodelling is the reprofessionalisation of teaching. Every teacher is to be a leader in the classroom. All headteachers must also be the leaders of these leaders; their greatest task is the motivation and deployment of their key resource – their staff. Heads must be free to remodel the school workforce. They must be imaginative in the organisation of the school day, school week and school year, which could involve the use of school space, opening up opportunities for learning in the community, engaging with business and developing vocational studies. As Gunter et al. (2004) comment, this strategy is the current preferred model of transformational school leadership. It should be recognised that remodelling is a process: a combination of a number of initiatives embedded in good practice that already exists within some schools. It is useful to consider the characteristics of a remodelling school as shown in Table 1.3. This also serves as a useful checklist against the National Agreement in terms of process and outcomes:
What you may see schools doing … ●
… to achieve
Involving the workforce in the
●
change process ●
Reinforcement of teaching and learning as the main focus
Involving the workforce in making
●
Appropriate allocation of tasks and
decisions about remodelling
activities within the school workforce
●
Implementing the National Agreement
and flexible working patterns
●
Sharing experiences and learning
●
with other schools
Change management as a normal part of school life
●
An acceptable work/life balance for the whole workforce
●
High morale among the whole workforce
●
Awareness of the direction of the school among all workforce members and stakeholders
Table 1.3 Characteristics of a remodelling school Source: Adapted from NRT website, www.remodelling.org
Remodelling Schools Manual: Workforce Reform by Sonia Blandford Published by Pearson Education © Pearson Education Limited 2006
23
RSWR_CO1.QXD 27/9/05 9:28 am Page 24
Section 1 · Remodelling and workforce reform
REMODELLING FIELDWORK Telephone interviews with two headteachers illustrate the advantages and disadvantages of implementing government policies (Blandford and Graham-Matheson, 2005). School A is a Pathfinder primary school that started remodelling in 2002. This has been very successful as recognised by Ofsted (March 2004). Since 2003, teachers have not undertaken the 24 tasks and have been very supportive; they realised that this was good for the school. The school leadership took everybody on an awayday to a good venue to discuss what teachers do and what other people could do. Staff are enthusiastic as teaching and learning are a focus, and this has been recognised as being very good. The CMT questioned why the school needed an SMT; it was determined there was not a need for the SMT. The school now has a head and deputy head but does not have a leadership team. The school had implemented a CMT for remodelling and has continued with the CMT model whenever there is an issue to be considered; for example, in 2004 all staff felt they were spending a lot of time writing reports to parents that were not very useful. A CMT of parents, governors, teachers and non-teaching staff was established to come up with a better way of providing the information. In addition, for PPA, a CMT has been working to achieve the 10 per cent requirement by 2006. It is now felt that CMTs will be kept long-term as a good way of involving people in strategic decision-making. The school does not see finance as a serious issue, though it is currently working on a deficit budget which is expected to be turned around within two years. There is a strong belief in the school that teachers are not always the best people for every aspect of school life, for example support staff may have better musical or ICT skills than the teachers and it would be wasteful of the school’s resources not to utilise these capabilities. As to training and support for the headteacher in the remodelling process, advisers were keen and supportive but there was no actual training available. Two further points were made about leading the remodelling process: the need to be confident, and that the CMT considers remodelling as much easier for experienced headteachers who know what has not worked in the past. Remodelling has led to teachers taking on more management roles, though it has always been the policy in the school to give staff the maximum opportunity to get involved, for example the CPD co-ordinator has discrete activity. CMTs utilise people with relevant interests and skills, with the headteacher involved only when necessary. The headteacher believes that people should see remodelling as an exciting, true joy – not a burden. It allows professional people, who know what is best for school and pupils, to have the opportunity to put it into practice. The most difficult thing for many people is to accept that change can be good. School B is an early adopter secondary school that had an Ofsted in October 2004 and received specialist school status in September 2005; it had a remodelling philosophy before it was called remodelling. The support staff have been doing the 24 tasks since 2002 and PPA time was secured from 2003. The staff are fully on board, seeing it as very logical and
24
Remodelling Schools Manual: Workforce Reform by Sonia Blandford Published by Pearson Education © Pearson Education Limited 2006
RSWR_CO1.QXD 27/9/05 9:28 am Page 25
Remodelling and workforce reform practice · 3
doing it anyway. Although there were some sceptics, the majority are proud to be part of a school that is seen to be working for the benefit of the pupils. The change culture involved five CMTs who evaluated their areas, and refined, developed and enhanced the work to be done. Support staff have been a priority, with a reorganised workforce and recruitment of new staff. There has been a lot of progress in terms of attitude and culture within the school, although no end to the development in the future can be seen. Finances have been an inhibitor to pace of the change but the school has been able to overcome most limitations; lack of money has prevented the school expanding its ICT provision. As yet, the school has received no funding for remodelling and still needs primepump funding to facilitate radical change, especially in terms of ICT ambitions for the next three years. By this time the school will be funding the remodelling agenda. Though the LEA adviser has kept in contact, the school has driven the change. Currently the headteacher feels the school needs an injection of creativity so that the change teams can inspire others for a bright future. The teachers still need more training to utilise the support staff more efficiently inside the classroom and in administration. The support staff need some confidence-building and person behavioural management skills. The main conclusion is that teachers are now focusing on teaching and the children are the centre of the school’s work.
Leadership and practitioner questions 1 Have you introduced staff to remodelling? 2 Have you implemented the National Agreement for workforce reform? 3 Do you have change management teams? 4 Are you contributing to the change management process? 5 How do you delegate administrative tasks? 6 Do you have adequate PPA time? 7 How are you measuring the impact of workforce reform? 8 What are your plans to develop Extended School practice? 9 How do these developments embrace Every Child Matters?
Remodelling Schools Manual: Workforce Reform by Sonia Blandford Published by Pearson Education © Pearson Education Limited 2006
25
RSWR_CO1.QXD 27/9/05 9:28 am Page 26
Chapter 4
REMODELLING ISSUES
This chapter considers a range of issues that might be encountered by those schools engaged in remodelling. Each issue is introduced as a point of discussion within leadership or change management teams (see Chapters 22 and 23). Although solution-focused, the intention is not to provide a statement or model that would fit directly into practice but to provide a few indicators that will encourage debate among leaders and practitioners. Several issues are considered in great detail in subsequent sections. Areas of practice considered include: ●
leadership and management
●
recruiting and training the school workforce
●
remodelling and raising achievement.
It would be appropriate for each reader to consider other issues as required in their school.
Questions to consider 1 How can you benefit from remodelling and workforce reform? 2 What does the NRT advise? 3 How are you implementing Extended Schools? 4 How are you implementing Every Child Matters?
ISSUE 1: LEADERSHIP AND MANAGEMENT The National Agreement outlines the means by which teachers and headteachers will reduce workload. At the centre of this practice is a collegiate approach to managing and leading teams. In spring 2002, the DfES launched the Transforming School Workforce (TSW) Pathfinders Project (Thomas et al., 2004), which involved 32 schools with nine comparator schools. The project aimed to: ●
secure significant reductions in the current weekly hours worked by teachers
●
increase the proportion of teachers’ working week that is spent teaching, or on tasks directly related to teaching.
26
Remodelling Schools Manual: Workforce Reform by Sonia Blandford Published by Pearson Education © Pearson Education Limited 2006
RSWR_CO1.QXD 27/9/05 9:28 am Page 27
Remodelling issues · 4
Five policy strands were secured to support headteachers in the process: ●
providing schools with consultancy support (school workforce advisers)
●
training headteachers in change management
●
allocating additional funds for employing additional teaching assistants
●
providing ICT hardware and software
●
funding the bursarial training of school managers.
In addition, funds were available for capital build to accommodate office staff. The project explored different approaches to implementing change and its impact on headteachers, particularly the demands of the job, the imbalance between home and work, information overload, and the tensions created while working for development and dealing with the unexpected. When the project team returned to schools in 2003, the headteachers were positive about workforce reform. A particular note was that the increased revenue generated by the project facilitated the use of additional resources that allowed headteachers and their teachers to focus on teaching. However, some had found the management of additional staff and the building projects to be stressful. Given that any new initiative takes time, there is the possibility that some aspects of remodelling will initially increase workload. As Thomas et al. (2004) found, transformation requires leadership that: ●
can frame a clear vision that engages the school community
●
can motivate and inspire
●
pursues change in a consistent and disciplined way
●
understands and leads the professional business of teaching.
Subsequent to the pilot project, Time for Standards: Transforming the School Workforce (DfES, 2003a) was published, which provides further guidance for headteachers and teachers in remodelling the workforce. The DfES noted that to ‘achieve their full potential, teachers need to work in a school that is creative, enabling and flexible and the biggest influence is the head’.
Partnership Collegiate leadership is dependent on a number of factors: strong communication, clear vision and transformational leadership that reside within the model of a superhead – an individual who delivers leadership through personality or experience. Remodelling engenders a greater feeling of collaboration which is the antithesis of the superhead model (The Guardian, 2005a; 2005b). The notion that teams can function more effectively than an individual is not new. The challenge for schools is to work with multi-agency, inter-agency and national advisory teams; it is now a time for strong teamwork. Every Child Matters clearly states the importance of services working together (DfES, 2004c):
Remodelling Schools Manual: Workforce Reform by Sonia Blandford Published by Pearson Education © Pearson Education Limited 2006
27
RSWR_CO1.QXD 27/9/05 9:28 am Page 28
Section 1 · Remodelling and workforce reform
The local context in which schools are working will change … Trusts will work together with local partners from the public, private, voluntary and community sectors to assess local needs, agree priorities and commission local services to meet those priorities.
An example of collaboration is the NHS Healthy School scheme, where health education professionals work in collaboration with Kent County Council LEA and schools to develop awareness of healthy eating and fitness (East Kent Coastal, 2005). This model has proven to be a good focus for schools, health professionals and parents to work together for the good of the community. The next step is for all schools to consider how to extend provision in order to deliver the five outcomes that underpin Every Child Matters. This can only happen in partnership with others, as discussed in Chapter 9. Further guidance on leadership and teamwork can be found in Sections 5 and 6.
Leadership and practitioner questions 1 How has workforce reform been adopted in your school? 2 How effective is your change management team? 3 Do you have a work/life balance? 4 Are you monitoring and evaluating changes in your school? 5 How do you support your staff? 6 Where will your school be in 2010?
ISSUE 2: RECRUITING TEACHERS (adapted from Blandford, 2004c) Teaching is a profession of over 400,000 people in the UK that continues to attract 14,000 annual recruits. The number of training routes into teaching reflects the government’s recognition that people enter the profession at different points in their lives and are needed because the current retention of teachers is problematic. Teach First is a recent innovation, where first-class graduates from Russell Group universities are offered a package of teaching and business training; within this programme, participants gain qualified teacher status and Master of Business Administration (MBA) credits. The programme began in London and, being city-based, participants are placed in challenging schools that have since reported on the success of the programme. Participants are committed professionals and reflect the norm in teacher education – it is this professionalism that is at the heart of the remodelling agenda. In The Guardian’s reporting of the Teaching Awards 2003, there were many accounts on how teachers influenced the lives of the learners. The headlines were themselves inspirational: ‘Born to teach’, ‘Engage the young’ and ‘Children’s Champion’. The regional finalists stated that teaching exceeded their original expectations, and they were genuinely surprised and moved by the difference they seemed to make in youngsters’ lives. There is a
28
Remodelling Schools Manual: Workforce Reform by Sonia Blandford Published by Pearson Education © Pearson Education Limited 2006
RSWR_CO1.QXD 27/9/05 9:28 am Page 29
Remodelling issues · 4
dedicated workforce that continues to inspire and motivate the learners in their classrooms. Indeed, Ted Wragg commented that a whole recruiting campaign should be built around the winners. Why seek alternative means of attracting staff when the exemplification of good practice through heartfelt accounts could do the job? For anyone who might be considering teaching as a career, look at the TTA website and you find a plethora of programmes: part-time, full-time, award-bearing, non-award-bearing via higher education or employment. A route that will take trainees through the 42 standards leading to qualified teacher status is there as appropriate. Once recruited, the next challenge is to retain staff. Teachers are professionals who have spent time refining their craft. Professional standing in the community is important and whether this happens is often a reflection on the leadership of the school. The opportunity to develop is of paramount importance to the new teacher. Teaching should not be considered as a life of mundane repetition of the national curriculum. As in other professions, further academic awards and professional development have a place. This indicates that there is scope for change and development; remodelling the workforce should have an impact. Practitioner questions 1 Why is teaching exciting and rewarding? 2 What are the professional characteristics of teaching in relation to a remodelled school? 3 Has teaching developed within the context of a knowledge society? 4 How can established teachers contribute to the retention of staff? 5 How can teachers attract graduates to the profession? 6 Can the profession be modernised?
ISSUE 3: RECRUITING AND TRAINING ADDITIONAL STAFF (adapted from Blandford, 2004d) Given the emphasis in current thinking on learning, teaching and raising achievement, it would seem appropriate that teachers are provided with the opportunity to recharge their thinking by reflecting on the government’s plans to remodel the school workforce. It has taken several summers and lots of paper to generate a plan that is to unburden teachers who have been beset by additional administrative tasks since the start of the national curriculum. Additional staff are being employed to stand by the photocopier, collect dinner money, take the register, provide cover for absentee teachers and provide additional support in the classroom. While headteachers and their staff are now in the enviable position of having additional help, they are also faced with the problem of how to fully utilise the remodelled workforce. As headteachers tackle this issue, many of the recent training days have focused on creating and implementing policies on how best to manage the workforce.
Remodelling Schools Manual: Workforce Reform by Sonia Blandford Published by Pearson Education © Pearson Education Limited 2006
29
RSWR_CO1.QXD 27/9/05 9:28 am Page 30
Section 1 · Remodelling and workforce reform
Once the workforce development plan has started, the next step is to ensure that there is appropriate follow-up. It is the implementation process that links new learning to practice in the school and classroom. A good action plan needs to be introduced that will give detailed consideration not only to the intended innovation but also to the strategy that will be employed to implement it. The process of planning is often more important than the plan. In terms of the innovation itself, the action plan might address a range of questions, including who will benefit from a remodelled workforce: pupil/students or colleagues? What will the costs be for those affected? Will additional resources be required to monitor the additional resources? Beyond workforce reform and the remodelling agenda being agreed at the local level, it is also worth considering the following: is the change easy to communicate to those concerned? Will they see its purpose? If this is not agreed, will it be possible to adapt what is intended to suit specific circumstances? Whose support will be needed? Will key people have a sense of ownership of the change? All schools are different; there is no single blueprint for a successful school. Knowing the direction of the school as expressed in its vision will enable future practice and frame the wider workforce to participate with a shared sense of purpose. Inevitably, remodelling leads to the restructuring of schools and it is their communities that should feel empowered to tackle the key issues that arise in the most appropriate way. Leadership questions 1 Do all members of the community have a shared understanding of the purpose and function of the school? 2 Who will facilitate these changes – a team or individuals? 3 Where will the school be in 2010?
ISSUE 4: RAISING ACHIEVEMENT – REMODELLED WORKFORCE, SAME CURRICULUM Since the introduction of the national curriculum, school governors have had a responsibility to ensure the delivery of a broad, balanced curriculum that all pupils have access to. Qualified teachers remain the point at which pupils engage with the curriculum. Under the direction and supervision of qualified teachers, support staff are being trained to support teachers and enhance pupils’ learning. The introduction of the national curriculum in 1988, created by teams of teachers and public servants, was distributed through a number of A4 binders sent to all maintained primary and secondary schools in England and Wales. Each subject featured a number of attainment targets that were to assist the teacher in determining the lesson content; each target was referenced against a level. Pupils were graded regardless of age. After the initial
30
Remodelling Schools Manual: Workforce Reform by Sonia Blandford Published by Pearson Education © Pearson Education Limited 2006
RSWR_CO1.QXD 27/9/05 9:28 am Page 31
Remodelling issues · 4
introduction, further changes were implemented followed by further recommendations and review. The current version is a single document with fewer, less explicit attainment targets. In parallel to several curriculum variations, national literacy and numeracy strategies were introduced and the national examination system changed. The national curriculum has never been received with much enthusiasm. Parents, pupils and teachers can be passive recipients of a knowledge-driven curriculum. Creativity and individual development have been limited by the delivery of a prescribed amount of reading, writing and mathematics based on schemes of work that may not directly relate to the individual learner. There is now the opportunity to revisit the model of delivering the national curriculum through the remodelling of schools. Teachers will now manage a team of learning assistants led by a higher-level teaching assistant. It will be the responsibility of the team to carry out the more mundane administrative tasks and assist the teacher in the delivery of the national literacy, numeracy and behaviour strategies. In addition to the opportunity to reshape the delivery of the curriculum, there are also technological advances to be considered. However, there is a perception that the technology of teaching has remained unchanged over the past 140 years. Clearly this is not so. The place of learning might be Victorian but the mode of learning is located in the twenty-first century. In the majority of schools, teachers are graduates with an understanding of theory and practice. Learners are also beginning to participate at different ages, with many retired people now joining learning sets through the University of the Third Age. As this wide range of learners embarks on a voyage of discovery, the resources to support engagement with learning are also changing, driven by technology and a greater understanding of how humans learn. At the core of the expansion of the knowledge society is learning and teaching; a relationship where the teacher engages learners whose ability to learn is a reflection in part of the teacher’s ability to teach. Leadership and practitioner questions 1 What are the core elements of teaching and learning that remain constant in a changing world? 2 How do teachers engage with change? 3 Do you have the skills, knowledge and resources that will enable you to participate in change? 4 What will be your role in five years’ time? 5 How can you shape the future?
Remodelling Schools Manual: Workforce Reform by Sonia Blandford Published by Pearson Education © Pearson Education Limited 2006
31
RSWR_CO1.QXD 27/9/05 9:28 am Page 32
Section 1 · Remodelling and workforce reform
ISSUE 5: REMODELLING – A NEW CONCEPT Remodelling provides schools with the opportunity to develop a new concept of schooling. Examination of the DfES, NRT or other educational websites will reveal several examples of new concept schools. As Stephen Hoare reports, should you want to see how workforce remodelling could radically change the future of education, then visit Darlington Education Village (The Guardian website http://education.guardian.co.uk/remodelling). He explains how two special schools and a community school have collaborated under the stewardship of a chief executive officer. The education village now provides a programme of learning that responds to the needs of the wider community for learners aged 2–19 and is open from 7.00 am until 10.00 pm. The village concept also embraces the concept of adult learning. There are opportunities for the village community to engage with teachers, technicians, behaviourists, youth workers – all with their own expertise. Learning takes place in a variety of contexts and information technology (IT) systems record pupils’ attendance and achievement. Staff also have the opportunity to engage in professional development, including watching teachers’ TV. The Darlington Village would appear to be a model that responds to the remodelling of schools in a way that encapsulates the principles of Every Child Matters. It provides a schoolbased model where social services, youth justice and primary healthcare collaborate in partnership on one site.
32
Remodelling Schools Manual: Workforce Reform by Sonia Blandford Published by Pearson Education © Pearson Education Limited 2006
RSWR_CO1.QXD 27/9/05 9:28 am Page 33
Workshop materials
1.1 Plan for an academy school
Remodelling Schools Manual: Workforce Reform by Sonia Blandford Published by Pearson Education © Pearson Education Limited 2006
34
33
RSWR_CO1.QXD 27/9/05 9:28 am Page 34
Section 1 · Workshop materials
Workshop 1.1
PLAN FOR AN ACADEMY SCHOOL During a scheduled meeting, consider the following case study that presents the overall plan for a new-concept school which is a particular response to workforce reform and the remodelling process. The Marlowe Academy is to be a new school located on a purpose-built site in East Kent. Its predecessor school had struggled to raise attainment over a significant number of years. The incoming headteacher and governors are seeking rapid change in return for the private and public investment. The headteacher plans for a new curriculum and timetable. The new timetable is to be introduced in September 2005. The aim is to fulfil the requirements of the National Agreement. It is for the reader to consider the appropriateness. It can be used as the basis of group and staff discussions that reflect on government policies for the remodelling of the workforce. The leadership team have considered Extended School, workforce reform and raising attainment issues. Work/life balance For the school day, the goal is that no one routinely takes work home. A revised timetable will show an extended day as follows: 8.20 am 8.30 am 9.00 am 11.00 am 1.00 pm 3.00 pm 4.00 pm
Staff briefing Assembly/tutorial Learning 1 Learning 2 Learning 3 Learning 4 Learning 5
The new timetabling process has been developed with the following key issues: ●
team leaders agree where the breaks are to go
●
pupils have up to two hours of individual study each day allocated within a learning period
●
clubs, activities, support, case conferences: all go into individual study time to release teachers and provide a meaningful curriculum
●
more non-contact time is allocated for teachers in English, mathematics, science and humanities to allow for additional PPA
●
all teachers gain an extra 10 hours non-contact time per week – above the National Agreement – with work during the day rather than the evening
●
associate staff work their hours around their personal, professional and training commitments. How do these issues address work/life balance issues?
34
Remodelling Schools Manual: Workforce Reform by Sonia Blandford Published by Pearson Education © Pearson Education Limited 2006
RSWR_CO1.QXD 27/9/05 9:28 am Page 35
Section 1 · Workshop materials
Curriculum The new curriculum will be based on two concepts: ●
It is dynamic and changes every year as the roll increases.
●
Individual study enables us to reduce lesson time for English, mathematics, science and humanities and increase it for performing arts, art and design, and technology.
More detailed changes will include: ●
business taught from Year 8 in response to local needs
●
English, mathematics, science and a vocational round robin in Year 9 in response to attainment and local needs
●
double science, mathematics, English language and literature and a choice of vocational four GCSE equivalents in Year 10
●
rationalisation of Year 11 curriculum to encompass vocational programmes
●
60+ youngsters interested in Year 12, choice of six vocational courses plus English/mathematics retakes
●
cross-curriculum ICT to be introduced in 2006.
Is the curriculum inclusive?
Staff structure The headteacher will be a hands-on member of a team with the staff structure: ●
being a flat structure with every teacher being one step from the action
●
having responsibilities clearly identified
●
being where the buck stops!
Other details of the structure will include: ●
posts of responsibility within each team
●
responsibilities to go across each team
●
leadership roles for associate staff
●
progression routes for learning mentors
●
other opportunities being opened up by our being an Extended School.
Will all staff have the opportunity to contribute to the development of the school?
Remodelling Schools Manual: Workforce Reform by Sonia Blandford Published by Pearson Education © Pearson Education Limited 2006
35
RSWR_CO1.QXD 27/9/05 9:28 am Page 36
Section 1 · Workshop materials
Ethos Working with colleagues: ●
teachers, associate and support staff treated as equals
●
focusing on learning; in-service education and training (INSET) budget of around £100,000
●
all staff contributing to developments
●
developing people, not judging them; supporting, not over-extending; having high expectations
●
respecting and valuing each other’s contribution
●
planning for the 95 per cent to achieve
●
rewards and incentives? Will the ethos be positive, exciting and challenging?
Working with the community in loco parentis ●
being encouraging and supportive
●
emphasising rewards and incentives
●
focusing on learning, dealing with behaviour
●
being assertive, not aggressive
●
including, involving and listening
●
raising aspirations; respecting
●
caring for them; wanting them to succeed; valuing them
●
planning for the 95 per cent; dealing with the 5 per cent.
The overall opportunities are: to become a community comprehensive that raises the aspirations and levels of achievement of its 1200 students; to work in close partnership with other schools, further education colleges and higher education institutions (HEIs); to become a nationally recognised centre of innovation and good practice that develops new practice for other schools to tailor and use, and trains and develops staff who eventually move on to promotion in other schools; to open up facilities, experiences and opportunities to the local community and support its growth; and to support community regeneration by working in partnership with local agencies, local businesses and the voluntary sector.
Will the school be a community comprehensive that embraces: ●
workforce reform?
●
Extended Schools?
●
Every Child Matters?
36
Remodelling Schools Manual: Workforce Reform by Sonia Blandford Published by Pearson Education © Pearson Education Limited 2006
RSWR_CO1.QXD 27/9/05 9:28 am Page 37
Section 1 · Workshop materials
Having considered the plan, how can this inform remodelling in your school? Key points
Action
Remodelling Schools Manual: Workforce Reform by Sonia Blandford Published by Pearson Education © Pearson Education Limited 2006
37
RSWR_CO1.QXD 27/9/05 9:28 am Page 38
Summary
This section examined policy and practice in schools as determined by government legislation within the context of workforce reform, Extended Schools and Every Child Matters. Remodelling embraces the wider culture change in education and the professions that relate to children, young people and learners while addressing teacher workload. Many of the reforms have been developed out of good practice, which includes the child in determining the most appropriate support to improve his or her development. Key points to consider are leadership, management and planning, resourcing and development. In 2000, the government, trade unions and supporting agencies met to agree a strategy that would facilitate change in schools. As with previous policies, the purpose of the change was to raise standards in schools. While the approach was to set further targets and create new policies, there was also an emphasis on providing schools with the opportunity and resources to lighten the workload of teachers. The Green Paper Every Child Matters (HMG, 2003a) sets out a framework for improving the outcomes of all children and young people. There followed a number of documents that focused on children within school, communities and other environments. Remodelling extends beyond schools and encompasses all agencies whose function it is to support and develop children. A clear and pragmatic description of workforce reform is provided in the introduction to Every Child Matters: Children’s Workforce Strategy (DfES, 2005a). These reforms are far-reaching and, if successful, could lead to the celebration and enhancement of all professions allied to children and young people learning. However, in addition to policies, there is a need for a change in culture, perception and the professional experience of teachers in schools. The principles that underpin the strategy for reform require further translation into practice. For every school, remodelling raises strategic and operational challenges (see Chapter 27). The leadership and management of the remodelling process and workforce reform are critical to a school’s success. Development opportunities provided by the remodelling and workforce reform are intended to create greater flexibility for teachers. The focus is to enhance a work/life balance for individuals while encouraging schools to work collaboratively in sharing ideas on how to work effectively. Remodelling provides the opportunity for schools to professionalise all staff. The more creative staff members are in working together as a team to plan, implement and develop an effective team, the greater the impact on practice and attainment in the classroom. The following section considers schools as a community of learners
38
Remodelling Schools Manual: Workforce Reform by Sonia Blandford Published by Pearson Education © Pearson Education Limited 2006
RSWR_CO2.QXD 27/9/05 9:48 am Page 39
Section 2
THE EXTENDED SCHOOL – A COMMUNITY OF LEARNERS
5 A community of learners
42
6 School, home and the community
45
7 Extended schools
48
8 Community schools
53
9 Extended schools – extended services
57
10 Working in partnership with local authorities
61
Workshop materials
69
Summary
72
Remodelling Schools Manual: Workforce Reform by Sonia Blandford Published by Pearson Education © Pearson Education Limited 2006
39
RSWR_CO2.QXD 27/9/05 9:48 am Page 40
1
RSWR_CO2.QXD 27/9/05 9:48 am Page 41
Introduction
Extended schools embrace the five outcomes of Every Child Matters: be healthy; stay safe; enjoy and achieve; make a positive contribution; and achieve economic well-being. With an extended school, the balance of activities is shared amonge the school workforce: teachers, support staff, administrators, technicians, external agents and the voluntary sector. Extended schools are to be learning communities that guide and support all members of the extended community. This section will examine what is meant by the school as a community and, from this, how the school can involve others in the creation of an extended school.
Key questions 1 What is meant by community? 2 What is an extended school? 3 Who are the partners in an extended school? 4 What will be the impact on pupils? 5 What can be learnt from community and social initiatives practised elsewhere in education?
Remodelling Schools Manual: Workforce Reform by Sonia Blandford Published by Pearson Education © Pearson Education Limited 2006
41
RSWR_CO2.QXD 27/9/05 9:48 am Page 42
Chapter 5
A COMMUNITY OF LEARNERS
If a school is to be remodelled it will need to determine its place and function as a community. This chapter defines schools as a community within a community. As such, schools reflect community social and educational needs. Essentially, schools exist to facilitate learning and teaching; this does not happen in a vacuum. This can inform the relationships with parents and the broader community that are central to the effectiveness of an extended school.
SCHOOLS AS COMMUNITIES All staff have a responsibility to understand that their school is a community within a community which can be defined as multi-dimensional with its: ●
location – where it is, the influence of the environment and systems of control
●
structure – the administrative elements and guidance that determine equality of provision
●
process – the management of people and development of a shared understanding of beliefs and values
●
agencies – government, business, voluntary, sport and the arts.
All members of the school, as participants in the school and local community, should be encouraged to have a shared commitment to the modelling of the school community. It is axiomatic that schools need organisational structures, aims and guiding rules if they are to be effective. As active players in the daily life of the school, pupils, teachers, parents, governors and support agencies work in partnership, sharing an understanding of the goals and targets that are to be achieved in an effective school. The determination of these goals is: ●
reflective, in that the school mirrors the local community involving its key players in determining values and practices
●
individual, as each member will have their own identity with personal goals and objectives
●
collective, in that shared understanding of common beliefs and values will create a sense of community bound together by a recognisable identity and geographical location.
42
Remodelling Schools Manual: Workforce Reform by Sonia Blandford Published by Pearson Education © Pearson Education Limited 2006
RSWR_CO2.QXD 27/9/05 9:48 am Page 43
A community of learners · 5
The principles on which community provision is built are based on certain assumptions that may also relate to remodelling agenda and inclusion (Gibson and Blandford, 2005): ●
education relates to other branches of social provision; it does not exist only as an academic entity
●
social provision is determined by the prevailing social and economic framework of society
●
both social and educational provision have become more centrally controlled
●
there has been a move towards devolution of power reflecting the need to provide community-type activities led by the community
●
there is a greater emphasis on participation that contributes to the emancipation of the teacher.
Critically, education in schools should be concerned with education within and for communities, not of communities (Poster, 1982). Community education begins with and for the individual.
SCHOOL CULTURE AND ETHOS Schools, like other communities, have their own characteristics and personalities. The culture of each school is determined by individual and collective beliefs and values. Schools do not consist of homogeneous groups of people with shared identities; schools are collections of individuals within a shared culture. The modelling of a school will require improvement plans and policies that acknowledge established practice. A school culture will manifest itself in many forms: ●
practice – rites, rituals and ceremonies
●
communications – stories, legends, symbols and slogans
●
physical forms – location, style and condition of the school buildings, fixtures and fittings
●
common language – phrases or jargon common to the school.
Differences between schools may be explained in terms of organisational and social structure that also reflect the interpersonal relationships that create ethos. The wholeschool feeling exists to such an extent that it drives the school as a community towards achieving goals. An intangible relationship between local and school communities and school ethos may exist but the link could be difficult to define. Ethos is multi-dimensional, as no single definition would apply to the many situations that occur in the life of the school community. Leaders, managers, practitioners, parents and pupils, teachers and all staff create school ethos through values and behaviours that reflect values portrayed in policies and practice.
Remodelling Schools Manual: Workforce Reform by Sonia Blandford Published by Pearson Education © Pearson Education Limited 2006
43
RSWR_CO2.QXD 27/9/05 9:48 am Page 44
Section 2 · The extended school – a community of learners
ENVIRONMENT There is a distinctive link between the culture and ethos created in schools and their environment. An uncared-for school building, regardless of age, will reflect an uncaring community. Working in an environment that is in need of repair (as most schools are) creates stress before any consideration of workload. As Every Child Matters recognises, working in an environment that is unhealthy is not conducive to healthy development. Members of the school community need encouragement in order to fulfil their potential: a stimulating environment will produce stimulating results. Members of the school community need to consider how to create a positive environment. This may include: ●
good-quality displays of pupils’ work and achievements covering the full range of ability
●
bright, open spaces with carpeted floors, plants, pictures and photographs
●
clean buildings: no litter, adequate bins that are emptied, working toilet facilities
●
supervised areas for study
●
adequate facilities for every subject, for example physical education and music store areas
●
the opportunity to use outside places and spaces.
The management of the school environment is the responsibility of everyone in the school community. The development and maintenance of the internal and external environment can be a key activity within the school and can help with remodelling.
Leadership and practitioner questions 1 How can the culture and ethos of the school impact on remodelling? 2 What factors influence culture and ethos? 3 Can your school environment be improved? 4 How can the community engage in remodelling: workforce reform, Extended Schools and Every Child Matters?
44
Remodelling Schools Manual: Workforce Reform by Sonia Blandford Published by Pearson Education © Pearson Education Limited 2006
RSWR_CO2.QXD 27/9/05 9:48 am Page 45
Chapter 6
SCHOOL, HOME AND THE COMMUNITY
The relationship between school, home and the local community will have a significant impact on implementing the remodelling agenda. The connection between the school and the community is not static but exists in a continuum. The manner in which a school reaches out to its community is determined by its degree of community interaction. There are three possible patterns of connection between the school and the local community, described as follows: 1 The closed-door pattern: the school deals with all the child’s educational and social problems, while community involvement and intervention are minimal. Within a closed system, as in the second law of thermodynamics, the total energy of the system will deteriorate. According to Friedman (1986), the closed-door policy towards the community lacks feedback and will waste energy without the right guidance. In the absence of input from the parents and the community, the school will be unaware of changes occurring in these systems, and hence will be unable to adapt itself and its curricula to these changes and will keep degenerating. 2 The open-door pattern: the school and the parents operate as open systems, so that information flows freely in both directions. The school with an open-door policy makes the parents partners to their children’s educational process and strives to become an influential factor in the life of the community. A basic assumption of systems theory is that the open system is designed to process the inputs of its external environment and return the processed product to the environment for its use and benefit. The exchange of energy occurs in a cyclic nature. The final and improved product serves as a new source of energy passing from the environment to the system. In this way the deteriorating process is stopped (Katz and Kahn, 1978). According to Friedman (1986), the school with an open-door policy receives its pupils from the parents, teaches them and raises their level of education in order to return them to their community. In their adult life they will produce a new generation of pupils, whose contribution to their children’s education is expected to be greater than that of their parents’ generation. 3 The balanced pattern: the school and the parents set the degree of closeness or distance between them, in order to achieve their educational and social goals to the optimal extent. When the distance is large, the school has to bridge the gap and reach out to the community; when the distance is small, the school has somewhat to close its gates.
Remodelling Schools Manual: Workforce Reform by Sonia Blandford Published by Pearson Education © Pearson Education Limited 2006
45
RSWR_CO2.QXD 27/9/05 9:48 am Page 46
Section 2 · The extended school – a community of learners
Leadership questions 1 How would you describe your school community? 2 How does your school participate in the community in which it is located? 3 What are the values that underpin practice in your school? 4 Does your school have an open- or closed-door policy? Or both?
Parental involvement in the school enriches the pupils’ world and extends their horizons because, when the parents take part in the educational process, pupils are exposed to a variety of people who represent different worlds in terms of life experience, age, occupation, interests and attitude; these encounters afford many opportunities for learning, enrichment and identification (Noy, 1984). The benefit of parental involvement is also manifested in the pupils’ personality and behavioural variables, such as improvement of the self-image and learning habits, reduction in disciplinary problems and absenteeism, and rise in motivation (Raywid, 1984). Parents will also benefit from their involvement, which enables them to deepen their knowledge of their children’s world, the subjects taught, the teaching methods and effective forms of negotiation with children. Involvement in their children’s education may help the parents to develop their own personalities and satisfy their own needs. In the school they may find an outlet for their talents that are not expressed in other places. They gain satisfaction from the experience of expressing their needs and skills, from the new opportunities opened to them for self-expression and realisation, and from the opportunity to share in the educational process and the gratitude and praise they receive for their participation and involvement (Noy, 1984; Hituv, 1989). Teachers benefit from the parents’ participation in the educational work in the school. Noy (1984) reports on four main areas in which parental involvement makes a substantial contribution: physical help, connections and contacts, the educational sphere, and creativity. This also strengthens the teachers’ professional, social and personal images, relieves the feeling of solitude that accompanies a teacher’s work, and increases their motivation to persevere and refresh professional knowledge.
Leadership and practitioner questions 1 Do parents have a voice in creating the school community? 2 Does your school have a range of activities that involve parents? 3 How does your school encourage parents to participate in extended activities within the school? 4 Is your school welcoming to all who visit?
46
Remodelling Schools Manual: Workforce Reform by Sonia Blandford Published by Pearson Education © Pearson Education Limited 2006
RSWR_CO2.QXD 27/9/05 9:48 am Page 47
School, home and the community · 6
RAISING ACHIEVEMENT In the remodelling agenda, the school workforce will need to be encouraged to extend the repertoire of their experiences beyond the classroom. From the NRT website, www.remodelling.org, case studies provide examples of practice that have engaged professionals and parents in the common goal of preparing pupils for their role in society. This is not new, as shown by the National Commission on Education (NCE) study of effective schools in disadvantaged areas, which provides several examples where good practice and a common goal have motivated the local community. The NCE refers to the ten success features in Success Against the Odds (NCE, 1996) which formed the basis for the proposals for raising achievement in schools; each resonates strongly with the remodelling agenda: ●
strong, positive leadership by the head and senior staff
●
a good atmosphere or spirit, generated by shared aims and values and by a physical environment that is as attractive and stimulating as possible
●
high and consistent expectations of all pupils
●
a clear and continuing focus on teaching and learning
●
well-developed procedures for assessing how pupils are progressing
●
responsibility for learning shared by the pupils
●
participation by pupils in the life of the school
●
rewards and incentives to encourage pupils to succeed
●
parental involvement in their children’s education and in supporting the aims of the school
●
extra-curricular activities that broaden pupils’ interest and experiences, expand their opportunities to succeed and help to build good relationships within the school.
In the course of this study, NCE researchers visited a school in the West Country which had a positive, highly motivated staff and where the ten features of success were in evidence. The research team was able to observe each of the above in practice: We were impressed by the positive attitude of staff, including teaching support staff, and by their dedication. It is surely a central part of successful school management to create the conditions to enable the staff to make this kind of commitment. One example of the school’s success in this respect is the range of after-school provision which is provided by teachers out of sheer commitment to the school. Source: NCE (1996)
Leadership questions 1 What leadership and management skills can schools provide for the broader community? 2 What activities within your school could be extended to involve more members of the school community? 3 How can your school become an extended school?
Remodelling Schools Manual: Workforce Reform by Sonia Blandford Published by Pearson Education © Pearson Education Limited 2006
47
RSWR_CO2.QXD 27/9/05 9:48 am Page 48
Chapter 7
EXTENDED SCHOOLS
This chapter examines government policy that intends to help schools develop in the context of ‘wraparound’ childcare. The government’s vision is for integrated services and activities that extend beyond the school day. There are almost as many definitions of extended schools as there are those who are engaged in this aspect of the remodelling agenda. Funding for extended schools is a core offer which makes it possible for all schools to develop as extended schools; this is an inclusive policy with no blueprints. Extended schools are based on good classroom teaching and high standards of leadership and management, but recognise that, to achieve the highest standards and sustain improvement, the curriculum and other learning experiences of the child should be considered as a whole. Extended schools are a base for the delivery of integrated services for children and families. The WAMG advises that the: delivery of the Every Child Matters agenda will involve widespread initiatives across a number of sectors to ensure coherence in children’s services. Extended schools will be at the heart of this delivery. We are also confident that the principles of workforce remodelling, if appropriately applied, should enable schools to identify the appropriate skill set for those involved in the development and delivery of extended services. Source: WAMG (2005)
This concept introduces a new approach to community-based support, which has a childcentred, outcome-led vision that will provide integrated front-line delivery, integrated processes and strategy, and inter-agency governance. For many, this is an ambitious initiative to further advance standards by promoting more ‘connectedness’. Based on the five key themes from Every Child Matters (DfES, 2003b), this will contribute to the life of both our schools and communities. Once again, this is not new; multi-agency and education professionals have worked together for generations in supporting children with special educational needs (SEN). As evidenced in community schools, there is a huge potential in cooperating with parents and local community organisations; this now extends to include professionals in health, youth justice and social care. Those involved also recognise the time involved in bringing together these services, which requires:
48
Remodelling Schools Manual: Workforce Reform by Sonia Blandford Published by Pearson Education © Pearson Education Limited 2006
RSWR_CO2.QXD 27/9/05 9:48 am Page 49
Extended schools · 7
●
values shared by all
●
children placed at the centre of all activity
●
a venue shared by all
●
practice shared by all.
In practice, the core offer being funded within the Extended School Prospectus (DfES, 2002; 2005f) includes: ●
study support that covers out-of-school-hours activities, such as sports, arts and drama, as well as more formal learning opportunities, such as homework clubs and Saturday schools
●
family support, including family learning and parenting classes
●
childcare from 8.00 am to 6.00 pm throughout the year, including school holidays in primary schools and for children aged up to 14 in secondary schools
●
‘things to do and places to go’ for young people in secondary schools
●
swift and easy referral to more specialised support services for children and young people when needed
●
widespread community use of school facilities.
It is easy to see that, through the core offer, extended schools can move beyond the classroom to encompass: ●
involvement of parents and families
●
childcare
●
study support
●
supporting families
●
improving health
●
youth offer
●
opportunities for community activities
●
community renewal
●
lifelong learning.
The notion of the extended school is described in the Five Year Strategy for Children and Learners (DfES, 2004d), which clearly indicates the government’s intention to increase the number of schools that will provide a range of family and community services. However, it is important that there is a clear understanding within schools as to what is intended. It is through the extended school initiative that the government appears to recognise that a child’s environment and circumstances have a significant impact on his or her learning, attainment and future life chances and, that by engaging parents and carers with learning, may have a positive effect on children’s achievement. Extended schools will provide the facilities and resources where it is possible to develop and deliver a range of services that support and address the needs of individual children and their communities.
Remodelling Schools Manual: Workforce Reform by Sonia Blandford Published by Pearson Education © Pearson Education Limited 2006
49
RSWR_CO2.QXD 27/9/05 9:48 am Page 50
Section 2 · The extended school – a community of learners
The government’s commitment to extended schools is also outlined in Every Child Matters: Change for Children in Schools, which strongly supports the work schools are already doing to raise educational standards, by: ● encouraging schools to offer a range of extended services that help pupils engage and achieve and
building stronger relationships with parents and the wider community; and ● supporting closer working between universal services like schools and specialist services so that
children with additional needs can be identified earlier and supported effectively. Source: DfES (2004c)
PARTNERSHIP – A CODE FOR PRACTICE Extended schools, in fulfilling the outcomes of Every Child Matters, will move education beyond the classroom to involve parents and families, childcare, health and social care, youth services, community activities, community renewal and lifelong learning. In May 2005, Stephen Twigg, then Minister for School Standards, commented that the government recognised the impact schools have on local families and communities and the importance of forging effective partnerships at a local level to achieve mutual benefits. There is a clear recognition of the need to fund activities beyond the classroom. This is to be welcomed but, if it is to be successful, values and attitudes will need to be determined and addressed. This can be achieved through transparency of governance and leadership, which has clarity of purpose with a vision for partnership that is sustainable, supported in part by Extended Schools: A Code of Practice (Sandwell, 2005). The intentions of the authors of this code of practice were that it should be a flexible selfevaluation tool for self-review, planning and quality assurance. It is designed to accommodate the extensive range of activities and services provided by schools contributing to community development. It acknowledges that growth takes place when people have opportunities to set their own goals. The code is therefore a framework for all extended schools that recognises the ongoing and developmental nature of the process as an extended school that: ●
identifies common principles drawing on examples of good practice from around the country
●
provides a common framework with identifiable success criteria that all schools can use to evaluate and improve practice
●
establishes a clear process for self-review, evaluation and recognition at one of three levels of good practice.
Using the code of practice as a framework for self-evaluation may bring important tangible benefits that can: ●
ensure that activity is closely linked to overall purposes and is really targeted at identified needs
50
Remodelling Schools Manual: Workforce Reform by Sonia Blandford Published by Pearson Education © Pearson Education Limited 2006
RSWR_CO2.QXD 27/9/05 9:48 am Page 51
Extended schools · 7
●
identify areas for development and set priorities for future action
●
ensure that all stakeholders are involved in extending activity
●
provide a foundation for building partnerships with other agencies and services, including youth and community, social, health and other services based upon recognised standards of good practice
●
provide a benchmark for internal and external comparison.
Extended Schools: A Code of Practice identifies three categories of good practice: Emerged: There is a clarity of purpose, coherent planning and provision which meets local needs and which demonstrate a clear link with the purposes, goals and targets of extended schools across more than one area of activity or service.
Established: Schools have demonstrated a commitment to continuing improvement and increasing community ownership. They are self-critical, able to address weaknesses and build on strengths, with an understanding of self-evaluation and the ability to use it effectively in realising their goals. They will have widened provision across several areas of extended school activity or service.
Advanced: Provision represents the leading-edge of practice, involving young people, parents and the wider community in goal setting, planning and developing the provision. Schools will have the conviction, confidence and expertise to train and to lead others and to become national centres of excellence, in the majority of extended school areas of activity/service. Source: Sandwell (2005)
MANAGING EXTENDED SCHOOLS As the NRT advises, the management of extended schools is a role that should not be taken by a teacher or school leader engaged in teaching and learning during the traditional school day (NRT, 2005): this could be in conflict with workforce reform. The management of an extended school programme will require training to prepare managers and staff to develop an understanding and the skills needed for the role. This will involve working in partnership with a range of other agencies in order to provide services and activities that extend beyond the traditional school day to meet the needs of children and young people, their families and the wider community. There are schools and LEAs who are developing modes of delivery that do not require direct input from staff and headteachers (see Chapters 8 and 9). Given that the prospectus for Extended Schools (DfES, 2005f) also engages with A 10 year Strategy for Childcare (HM Treasury, 2004), this is to be welcomed. Since 2003, the NRT has been running a pilot in a range of extended schools that provides an opportunity for the practical implication of this initiative to be worked through. Clearly this may have a negative impact on workforce reform: with schools open from 6.30 am to 10.30 pm, there are implications for all staff involved. Further guidance is being developed by the NRT with current information found at websites for Every Child Matters (www.everychildmatters.gov.uk) and Remodelling (www.remodelling.org).
Remodelling Schools Manual: Workforce Reform by Sonia Blandford Published by Pearson Education © Pearson Education Limited 2006
51
RSWR_CO2.QXD 27/9/05 9:48 am Page 52
Section 2 · The extended school – a community of learners
Enrichment activities Within the remodelling process, the range of available roles to each school will depend on the size and potential scope of activities. Sports, arts, language enhancement and other activities, which were often delivered through clubs and extra-curriculum programmes, may be reintroduced into the timetable. If carefully planned and integrated into the curriculum, there is huge potential for the growth of such activities. Partnerships with neighbouring schools may also facilitate the transfer of talent within these areas. There is no statutory PPA entitlement for these specialist staff although schools may choose to provide time. Enrichment activities should be designed to enhance the quality of the curriculum and learning experience of all learners. The importance of enjoyment in learning must not be overlooked and health and safety should also be considered when planning such activities. Communication with the LEA remodelling adviser would be useful at this stage as well as discussions with schools who have implemented successful PPA strategies. Collaboration across schools might allow sports coaches, specialist teachers and support staff to be recruited to cover a number of schools. When extending the workforce, headteachers and governors should follow safe recruitment practices. These are available from the DfES and LEAs and will be discussed in greater detail in Section 4.
Leadership questions 1 Have you delegated management and leadership of extended schools? 2 Have you negotiated/received additional funding? 3 What support has been provided by the LEA? 4 How is the extended school agenda being monitored and evaluated?
52
Remodelling Schools Manual: Workforce Reform by Sonia Blandford Published by Pearson Education © Pearson Education Limited 2006
RSWR_CO2.QXD 27/9/05 9:48 am Page 53
Chapter 8
COMMUNITY SCHOOLS
This chapter focuses on the regeneration of community schools within the context of the remodelling, workforce reform, Extended Schools and Every Child Matters, as community schools are not necessarily extended schools. Each area of current innovation and development was a feature of community schools when they were first conceived in the 1950s (Poster, 1982). The shared drivers for community and/or extended schools are: ●
school improvement – breaking through barriers – parental engagement
●
children – preventive strategies – children’s services – childcare strategies
●
the regenerating of communities – supporting independence.
LEAs are now proposing to create shared structures and systems that will underpin collaboration and partnership between schools and other agencies (see Chapter 10); the intention is to support the community leadership role of schools while raising attainment and attendance. As outlined in DfES and inter-agency policies, the objectives are to: ●
enhance the relationship between schools and their communities by extending the use of schools as a resource for the wider community to address educational and social needs
●
improve each school’s capacity to remove the barriers to success, which includes economic, health and social factors
●
promote parental engagement in children’s learning.
Within the core offer, government, regional and local funding will be provided to support: building links with local business; the strategic coordination and planning for community engagement and multi-agency work; and to provide project management support. As with extended schools, the key elements of community schools include multi-agency family and child support services, study support, family learning and community use of facilities. Local authorities recognise that this will mean a culture change for heads of service and, in some
Remodelling Schools Manual: Workforce Reform by Sonia Blandford Published by Pearson Education © Pearson Education Limited 2006
53
RSWR_CO2.QXD 27/9/05 9:48 am Page 54
Section 2 · The extended school – a community of learners
cases, heads of schools from management and control to leadership and influence. Figure 2.1 illustrates the range of potential services on offer throughout community schools.
Advice and guidance Onsite community facilities
Community of schools
Health and well-being
Community schools
Lifelong learning
Early years, childcare and education
Business Community support
Fig. 2.1 Community schools
The many partners who are in support of effective community schools are illustrated in Fig. 2.2. Community and extended schools have to address a range of issues beginning with a change in culture. This will involve the building of trust and confidence in and with new partners, in order to realign services closer to the point of delivery. This is set within the context of demographic changes that include: new housing developments; the reduction in the number of school-age learners; a further need for children’s centres and family liaison officers; and an increase in the capacity or need for voluntary and community sector support. With an availability of services and support, schools need to understand which extended and/or community initiatives might have a positive impact.
Community Development groups
NHS healthy schools
Voluntary and community sector
Creative partnerships
Community partnerships Community/ extended schools
Arts development
Federations
Children’s centres Specialist schools
Fig. 2.2 Community support
54
Remodelling Schools Manual: Workforce Reform by Sonia Blandford Published by Pearson Education © Pearson Education Limited 2006
RSWR_CO2.QXD 27/9/05 9:48 am Page 55
Community schools · 8
BUILDING WITH THE COMMUNITY All new community and/or extended school strategies policies recognise that each school exists in a distinctive social context that ultimately impacts on the culture and ethos experienced by staff and children. If schools are to develop within the community and for the community, school leaders will need to engage with that community. Working collaboratively at strategic and operational levels is essential for school improvement and community development. Headteachers will need to be aware of current issues and future trends that will impact on the school and community while developing the community and/or extended school. In communities, there is a rich and diverse resource that can support opportunities for pupils and other learners. Models of collaboration are already practised strategies that encourage parents to support learning. Headteachers need to build a school culture that is aware of the richness of the resources that exist within and beyond the school, and ensure that learning experiences are integrated into the wider community. The change in culture will also contribute to the development of an education system that, through sharing, will lead to innovation in all areas. The effectiveness of building partnerships with the community is based on long-term planning through consultation and identification of needs. Innovation is pro-active, as well as reactive, where multi-agency teams work across boundaries.
Case study 8.1 Partnership project Social inclusion was well developed within School C. It had a strong focus, with high-quality professional input by school staff, but it also recognised that sustained response to social needs required a partnership with other agencies. This partnership involved staff from the local support unit, Education Welfare Office service, school psychologists, school nurse health workers, child protection staff and social services. Increasingly, staff were aware that many of the problems being encountered by pupils in the 11–19 age group were a continuation, and a consequence, of much earlier social and educational concern. In 2001/2002, the school addressed this situation by defining social inclusion work in the broader context of nursery, infant, junior and primary school children and their families, and outside agencies. The leadership group recognised that the success of its work required an integrated response across the local community. To this end, the school’s focus provided a vehicle for different agencies to combine in meeting the needs of children and their families.
▼
The relationship between eight local nursery/primary schools and the school was well established. The project identified and targeted staff in each of the eight local schools to work specifically with the most needy children and, through this work, to access their family situations. The headteachers of the schools involved formed a social inclusion management group. The project established operational modes provided funding and met the on-going professional development for all staff concerned.
Remodelling Schools Manual: Workforce Reform by Sonia Blandford Published by Pearson Education © Pearson Education Limited 2006
55
RSWR_CO2.QXD 27/9/05 9:48 am Page 56
Section 2 · The extended school – a community of learners
The management integrated response team provided the strategic direction for the project. Through the work of the staff in each school, staff had lists of needy children and families. In a coordinated way, the necessary support groups were identified in response to these needs. Managers distributed responsibilities according to expertise, secured resources for families as appropriate, defined follow-up procedures and, crucially, ensured respective area teams were informed about the work. The costs associated with this project were to fund workers in the schools. Essentially, the project focused on breaking the cycle of accumulative disadvantage by placing pupils at the core of the work, recognising that families in the community need to have frequent and trusting relationships with the school. The work supports parenting skills programmes and brings staff into contact with the full range of family needs and concerns.
Leadership and practitioner questions 1 Is there a shared vision across services with regard to providing the best for all children? 2 Will the main partners (education, health and social services) become an integrated service? 3 What are the staffing and resource implications? 4 Who do we need to communicate with in our community? 5 Is your LEA developing the concept of a fully integrated children’s trust with its ‘one-stop shop’ dimension, based in schools? Is this a clearly understood and deliverable model?
56
Remodelling Schools Manual: Workforce Reform by Sonia Blandford Published by Pearson Education © Pearson Education Limited 2006
RSWR_CO2.QXD 27/9/05 9:48 am Page 57
Chapter 9
EXTENDED SCHOOLS – EXTENDED SERVICES
As indicated in previous chapters, the remodelling of schools will not take place in isolation from other public sector, or private and voluntary services. The Children’s Workforce Strategy (DfES, 2005a) encompasses health, social care and youth justice services in addition to schools. It is appropriate for school leaders and headteachers to be familiar with the range of changes that are in place for services within, and related to, schools. This chapter is based on interviews and research presented in examples and case studies, each exploring extended services under development in parallel with the Extended Schools initiative. These include: ●
children’s centres
●
children’s trusts
●
community music centres
●
sports centres
●
voluntary sector
CHILDREN’S CENTRES The aim of children’s centres is to respond to the social needs of a pupil or his or her family. These needs are understood to relate to the pressures on the pupil, from home and community, and the developmental needs of the child that relate to his or her previous life experiences. The centres may encourage the school to modify its demands on the pupil and vice versa. This necessitates the school being well informed about the individual circumstances of the child within the family setting. The underlying principle to the children’s centre approach is based on the notion that a child’s development and self-concept are primarily formed by his or her family in interaction with the educational experience. In practice, children’s centres provide a service beyond the school for those families requiring additional support. Schools will need to work closely with health advisers and centre coordinators to ensure clarity of communication. This extends beyond case conferences and enables all practitioners to be proactive and reactive to a family’s needs. This is not new; in areas of need, children’s centres are often located on school sites. Child psychologists and paediatricians may also contribute to work in this area. The focus of the centres may be on the pre-school and foundation stage, but it is not unusual for this to continue to families with children of secondary school age.
Remodelling Schools Manual: Workforce Reform by Sonia Blandford Published by Pearson Education © Pearson Education Limited 2006
57
RSWR_CO2.QXD 27/9/05 9:48 am Page 58
Section 2 · The extended school – a community of learners
CHILDREN’S TRUSTS AND MULTI-AGENCY SUPPORT The government has proposed further reform within local authorities. The intention is for education, social care and health departments to function as one, both strategically and operationally. This builds on existing schemes that have rationalised local authorities in terms of role. Underpinning this change is the rationale that local authorities will commission, monitor and review services rather than be the point of delivery. There are examples of such work in practice elsewhere in England. Each of the authorities has developed strategically in response to local need and it is important to consider local needs as the first point of reflection prior to establishing change. There are examples of existing practice, as with a Pathfinder Children’s Trust that aims to bring together services that facilitate prevention and early intervention for children and young people aged from 0 to 19. The various partners of such a trust include: ●
lifelong learning
●
social services
●
community trust
●
Connexions
●
youth opportunity training scheme
●
voluntary sector
●
children’s fund
●
HEIs.
Management and leadership of the trust involves governance, local strategic partnership, a chief executives’ group, a joint strategy group, a trust board and local coordination groups. The trust has also involved seven local family support teams, previously at various locations but now within a common site with a single local manager. The service provides an enquiry line that leads to activities which are outcome-based; the key outcome is the provision of integrated services. The next steps will be commissioning a strategy group. Extended school developments in this study began with local schools that were involved and informed through a conference and all of the established meeting cycles. School-based local coordinators were appointed in each family support team area. Their salaries and a small amount of trigger funding came from Standards Fund 15. Four networks were created as full service schools, funded by a combination of Standards Fund 15 and Standards Fund 19. There is joint accountability and planning with shared or pooled governance that has shared priorities and processes. Links and relationships have been established with local coordinators and a children’s trust board, which are all seen as embedding good practice. The trust aims to address the essential features of the 2004 Children’s Act as follows: ●
child-centred, outcome-led vision
●
integrated front-line delivery
●
integrated processes
58
Remodelling Schools Manual: Workforce Reform by Sonia Blandford Published by Pearson Education © Pearson Education Limited 2006
RSWR_CO2.QXD 27/9/05 9:48 am Page 59
Extended schools – extended services · 9
●
integrated strategy
●
inter-agency governance.
Further research is required on the effectiveness of the trust.
Case study 9.1 Community music centres Many schools and communities have a history of music-making. These have been established over time through church and faith groups, the voluntary sector, schools and philanthropists. This case study describes two examples of a local centre and an international centre that have provided many opportunities for volunteer and students to develop a range of skills. The local centre originated in a large co-educational 11–18 comprehensive school in southern England; the other is a music centre in Lisbon, Portugal. Within the comprehensive school, community music started with a choir for pupils and children from neighbouring schools that led to the formation of a school wind band which evolved into a community music centre (CMC) and now exists as an independent charity organisation within the local community. In Portugal, the music centre provides an opportunity for young people to join a musical ensemble that rehearses in languages with which participants are most familiar, i.e. English and Portuguese. The centre sympathises with the internationally mobile student and caters for students from a variety of musical backgrounds. As a community group, the international music centre (IMC) is unrestricted by involvement in the national music system and is open to all. Blandford and Duarte (2004) found that the social benefits motivated and sustained membership of both centres. Social skills are enhanced by participation in a musical community and through the development of friendships, improved self-confidence and, in many cases, facilitated transition into a new environment. In terms of learning, participants develop transferable skills associated with learning and taking responsibility. Through teaching and guiding younger members, the participants are able to gain understanding of their own needs, particularly in the areas of intonation, aural perception, notation and ensemble proficiency. The experience of inclusion moves beyond notions of class, ability, race or creed, as has been demonstrated by research, practice and music-making. In terms of inclusion, it would appear that by moving out of school and into the community the codes that limit our understanding of community are broken. Participation in a musical community is fully inclusive. Children with learning and physical disabilities are supported and stimulated by the groups. Students from different nationalities, cultural backgrounds, abilities and a wide age range are able to combine their efforts to the common good of the community. All members reported how much they had enjoyed the experience of participating in a musical community as reflected in the words of the music educator Isaac Stern the aim of music-making is: … not to make ‘musicians’ out of everyday performers, but more important, to make them educated, alert, caring inquiring young people, who by playing music feel a part of the connective tissue between what the mind of man has been able to devise and the creativity of music … in other words, become literate, and part of the culture of the whole world. Source: cited in Guaspari (1999)
Remodelling Schools Manual: Workforce Reform by Sonia Blandford Published by Pearson Education © Pearson Education Limited 2006
59
RSWR_CO2.QXD 27/9/05 9:48 am Page 60
Section 2 · The extended school – a community of learners
SPORTS CENTRES The government has stated that schools could reach out to their communities through sport and that there are real opportunities for joined-up approaches to extended schools within the context of Every Child Matters (DfES, 2003b). Many consider that sport within schools is in decline, with a high proportion of the population being inactive, so there is a clear need for a positive encouragement to future generations. This can happen through school/club links, Step into Sport, QCA PE and School Sport Investigation, Gifted and Talented, and Swimming. The government’s White Paper Choosing Health (HMG, 2004b) has recommended a need for a decrease in the number of people who smoke or are obese and an increase in the number of people who exercise and are encouraged to support sensible nutrition and drinking habits. Extended schools can reach out to their local communities through sport by: ●
maximising physical activity by embedding these intentions into the school improvement plan (SIP)
●
letting out the school premises to establish strong links, communication and participation in local sports teams
●
inviting parents to be involved
●
making all visitors feel welcome.
There are real opportunities for a joined-up approach that responds to the needs of Every Child Matters.
Leadership questions 1 Why do you offer extended activities and how are they coordinated? 2 How did you decide what to offer? 3 What partnerships exist and how do they support the extended school? 4 Why do young people, adults and service providers want to be involved? 5 Who is doing what, and what are the resources available to them? 6 Who participates in activities? 7 How do you let people know about the activities? 8 Who currently delivers activities and services, and how are they selected? 9 How can you develop the range of your activities/services? 10 What evidence do you need to collect to show that activities/services are worth the cost? 11 How could you use the Extended Schools code of practice?
60
Remodelling Schools Manual: Workforce Reform by Sonia Blandford Published by Pearson Education © Pearson Education Limited 2006
RSWR_CO2.QXD 27/9/05 9:48 am Page 61
Chapter 10
WORKING IN PARTNERSHIP WITH LOCAL AUTHORITIES
The framework for change is developed from the 2004 Children Act which focuses on five outcomes that are the key to well-being in childhood and later life (DfES, 2004c). This chapter focuses on the policies and practices that will help to facilitate these five outcomes. The government proposed radical changes to the whole system of children’s services which include: ● the improvement and integration of universal services … ● … specialised help to promote opportunity, prevent problems and act early and effectively ● the reconfiguration of services around [children] and [families] in one place, for example, children’s
centres, extended schools and the bringing together of professionals in multi-disciplinary teams ● dedicated and enterprising leadership at all levels of the system ● the development of a shared sense of responsibility across agencies for safeguarding children and
protecting them from harm. Source: DfES (2004e)
Government publications set out a vision for integrated services beginning with advice for early years and progressing to school-aged children and young people. They identify that early years and childcare provision gives a good start to young children’s development as well as appropriate support for parents. The government’s ten-year strategy for early years and childcare intends to provide more integrated services for young children, as well as childcare and family support services for older children in schools. Community participation will be a key to success. As shown in the previous chapter, many schools already offer a wide range of extended school sporting and cultural activities. The government will therefore be amending the criteria for school inspection to include schools’ support in terms of the five outcomes of Every Child Matters.
LEAS AND CHILDREN’S TRUSTS The government intends that children’s trust arrangements are to be developed in most areas by 2006 and all areas by 2008. This will mean for schools that:
Remodelling Schools Manual: Workforce Reform by Sonia Blandford Published by Pearson Education © Pearson Education Limited 2006
61
RSWR_CO2.QXD 27/9/05 9:48 am Page 62
Section 2 · The extended school – a community of learners
● children’s trust arrangements involving schools in local partnerships so that schools can feed their
views into local service planning and, if they wish, provide services individually or in partnership with other schools; ● children’s trust arrangements and schools working together to find places for hard-to-place pupils … ● local authorities working closely with schools in fulfilling their duty to promote the educational
achievement of looked-after children. Source: DfES (2004e)
It is intended that integrating services will mean more effective support for pupils with complex needs who require multi-agency support. Two processes are available: ● a Common Assessment Framework to help schools identify when a pupil’s needs can be met within
the school and to enable better targeted referral to other specialist services when needed so they can respond more effectively ● cross-government guidance on information-sharing to improve the sharing of information between
schools and other agencies about individual children with additional needs. Source: DfES (2004e)
LEAs and children’s trusts will also engage with schools and other providers to ensure that all children in their local area are being effectively supported. Headteachers will be key strategic partners in shaping the pattern of local services. Schools may want to develop their role in delivering services through foundation partnerships and other clustering arrangements. The delivery of more integrated services will require new ways of working and a significant culture change for staff used to working within narrower professional and service-based boundaries. Easy and effective communication across current organisational and professional boundaries is a strong foundation for cooperation. One way is the co-location of managers and frontline staff from different services working together in multidisciplinary teams in an extended school.
CHALLENGES AND OPPORTUNITIES Raising achievements through meeting the needs of individual pupils requires flexible working of statutory agencies. From September 2005, maintained schools must publish information on the school’s arrangements for working in partnership with LEA support services, health and social services, the Connexions service and any relevant local and national voluntary organisations; OfSTED inspection teams will be seeking evidence of this practice. It should be recognised that external support services can play an important part in helping schools identify, assess and make provision for all pupils. The objective is to provide an integrated, high-quality, holistic support that focuses on the needs of the child. Such provision should be based on a shared perspective and should build on mutual understanding and agreement where all voices are heard. Services should
62
Remodelling Schools Manual: Workforce Reform by Sonia Blandford Published by Pearson Education © Pearson Education Limited 2006
RSWR_CO2.QXD 27/9/05 9:48 am Page 63
Working in partnership: local authorities · 10
adopt a flexible pupil-centred approach to service delivery to ensure that the changing needs and priorities of the pupils and their parents can be met at any given time. All agencies should recognise the need for effective collaboration of services involved with pupils and parents. Consultative responsibilities and effective communication systems at all levels can then be clearly identified. Developments in organisational structures and working practices need to reflect this collaboration. Practice within LEAs is varied and experience has shown that several have complex support structures that are unknown or unclear to practitioners in schools. Central to the effectiveness of LEA support teams and other support agencies is their ability to communicate their role to classroom practitioners. Often the point of contact in schools is the special educational needs coordinator (SENCO); in the context of remodelling, this will need to extend to other members of staff. Procedures will need to be developed if teachers are to receive support from other agencies in the education of all pupils. In practice, the school workforce will need to have knowledge and understanding of the remodelling process as the framework for recognising and managing all pupils. Rather than leaving the overworked SENCOs to deal with multi-agency support, all practitioners should consider their responsibilities to pupils in their classrooms. LEA support services can provide advice to practitioners, e.g. on teaching techniques and strategies, classroom management, and curriculum materials. They also support curriculum development, direct teaching or practical support for class teachers, part-time specialist help and access to learning support assistance. LEAs should also provide full information to all schools about the range of locally available services and how they can be secured. The SENCO and senior leadership team should be aware of the LEA’s policy for the provision of support services and how the school can access them. Whether or not funding for particular support services is delegated to schools, it may be helpful for schools and LEAs to draw up agreements for such services, specifying the scope, quality and duration of the service to be provided. When schools enter into contracts with private or voluntary sector providers, they should also satisfy themselves of the qualifications and experience of the specialists involved and that the service represents good value for money, and that appropriate police checks have been carried out.
Leadership questions 1 How does your school engage with local authority and external agencies? 2 Is there a school policy on identifying support for pupils? 3 How involved are parents in determining support for their child? 4 Does the LEA provide adequate information on the support services available? 5 What are the development needs of all the staff?
Remodelling Schools Manual: Workforce Reform by Sonia Blandford Published by Pearson Education © Pearson Education Limited 2006
63
RSWR_CO2.QXD 27/9/05 9:48 am Page 64
Section 2 · The extended school – a community of learners
EDUCATIONAL PSYCHOLOGY SERVICE The educational psychology service is a highly specialist area of education provision. An educational psychologist provides support and advice for pupils to schools, parents, the education department, social services, health services and the pupils themselves. Educational psychologists are trained experienced professionals bound by codes of conduct to act in the best interests of the individual pupils referred to them. They work with parents, teachers and other professionals to help pupils succeed and prevent or minimise difficulties. Their work is concerned with learning, language and literacy, specific learning difficulties, behaviour, emotional or social problems and physical or sensory difficulties. The role of educational psychologists is central to the assessment and statementing of pupils with SEN. They also provide in-service training and support research projects involving teachers, other professionals and parents in fulfilling their aim to promote a wider understanding of pupils’ needs. They are in contact with pupils, parents, headteachers, governors, LEAs and social services officers and a wide range of professional and other staff from all agencies that provide services to the local community. In practice, educational psychologists are assigned a number of nursery, primary and secondary schools. They consult with the headteacher to establish priorities according to the needs of the pupils in the school and provide a range of in-service courses for parents and professionals that focus on pupil needs, individual and whole-school behaviour policies, mediation and negotiation, development of teacher self-esteem, and special learning difficulties.
BEHAVIOUR AND EDUCATIONAL SUPPORT TEAM Behaviour and educational support team (BEST) teachers are specialists who provide a range of services to mainstream and specialist schools. They are experts in the management of discipline in schools. BEST staff are highly qualified professionals able to deal with difficult pupils. They are also able to deal tactfully and effectively with teachers in mainstream schools who need their help and yet may feel defensive about seeking it. Within the BEST team there will be a team leader, specialist teachers, special needs support assistants and administrative support staff, which can be set up to provide a service to support pupils experiencing emotional and behavioural difficulties in their setting, to help maintain their places in mainstream education and access the national curriculum by: ●
providing direct support to individual pupils
●
providing practical advice on support strategies to staff
●
working with parents/guardians to support their child’s educational needs
●
assisting schools in developing their own support structures and expertise
●
working with social services, health and other education agencies to encourage continuity of support and exchange of information.
64
Remodelling Schools Manual: Workforce Reform by Sonia Blandford Published by Pearson Education © Pearson Education Limited 2006
RSWR_CO2.QXD 27/9/05 9:48 am Page 65
Working in partnership: local authorities · 10
In the majority of LEAs, pupils may be referred for BEST support with or without a statement of SEN. Increasingly, support for non-statemented pupils can be obtained when their school placement has broken down. Referrals will also require evidence that the pupil still exhibits inappropriate behaviour after receiving support from the school.
EDUCATION WELFARE OFFICER (EWO) Schools may expect the EWO to undertake many core functions, such as attendance, exclusion, child protection and welfare benefits, but they also have duties relating to SEN where the EWO has direct involvement with the pupil, to support parents and pupils in the process of formal assessment. They can also advise and support schools in relation to general welfare issues affecting pupils, which can include breakdown in communication between school and home and under-achievement that might be caused by a domestic problem and/or the child not being properly cared for at home. The Education Welfare Service (EWS) in the majority of LEAs is active in consultation with other agencies within the authority, including social, medical and legal services.
OTHER SERVICES A school’s first point of contact with health issues will be through the local school health services, which deliver health advisory and support services to schools. These health professionals will usually be able to advise the school and should also advise the medical officer designated to work with children with SEN that the school has sought advice about a child. Health professionals such as speech and language therapists, occupational therapists and physiotherapists, as well as doctors and the school nurse, also provide advice and support for children. Health trusts must comply with a request for help from an LEA in connection with SEN children, unless they consider that help is not necessary for the exercise of the LEA’s functions. Schools should be aware of the range of local services provided by social services who have duties under the 2004 Children Act to provide a range of services for children in need. The designated teacher for looked-after children should work closely with the SENCO when the pupil also has SEN. Schools should also ensure that where a child is ‘looked after’ by the local authority, the child’s social worker and, where possible, the parents are involved in their child’s education and all processes relating to SEN. Voluntary agencies and groups have an important role in providing services and in some cases they deliver their own provision. It is essential that LEAs, schools and local authorities seek to work actively in partnership with the voluntary sector to meet pupils’ needs. LEAs and schools should demonstrate a willingness to work with them and value their contribution. Local authorities also need to help join up the different local partners in order to maximise the benefit for pupils.
Remodelling Schools Manual: Workforce Reform by Sonia Blandford Published by Pearson Education © Pearson Education Limited 2006
65
RSWR_CO2.QXD 27/9/05 9:48 am Page 66
Section 2 · The extended school – a community of learners
The DfES sponsors regional networks. These partnerships bring together groups of local authorities and local health, social services, voluntary and private sector partners. The overall aim of the network is to secure greater consistency in the quality of the response for all pupils (see Chapter 26).
Leadership questions 1 What are the systems for engaging multi-agency support in your school? 2 How are staff informed of the support provided for pupils they teach? 3 Is multi-agency support recorded, monitored, reviewed and evaluated? 4 What is the role of the SENCO in managing multi-agency support?
COMMON ASSESSMENT FRAMEWORK A Common Assessment Framework (CAF) has been created (DfES, 2005c) to support the five outcomes of Every Child Matters. Its aims are, where appropriate, to provide an assessment of a child’s individual, family and community needs, which can be built up over time and, with parental consent, shared among practitioners. It is intended to: ●
improve the quality of referrals between agencies
●
help embed a common language about the needs of children and young people
●
promote the appropriate sharing of information
●
reduce the number and duration of different assessment processes.
The government intends that the CAF will help practitioners undertake an initial holistic assessment of a child’s or young person’s needs to determine the level of need and identify an appropriate response. It consists of a common process for understanding and articulating the range of needs of an individual child involving the child, his or her parents or carers and other practitioners, as appropriate, with a common format: ●
to help practitioners record the findings from the assessment in terms that are helpful in determining the most appropriate response to future needs
●
for sharing assessment information with other practitioners and services as appropriate, while assuring the necessary levels of confidentiality and security.
The aims of the CAF are to: ●
provide a method of assessment to support earlier intervention
●
improve joint working and communication between practitioners by helping to embed a common language of assessment and a more consistent view as to the appropriate response
●
improve the coordination and consistency between assessments leading to fewer and shorter specialist assessments
66
Remodelling Schools Manual: Workforce Reform by Sonia Blandford Published by Pearson Education © Pearson Education Limited 2006
RSWR_CO2.QXD 27/9/05 9:48 am Page 67
Working in partnership: local authorities · 10
●
inform decisions about whether further specialist assessment is required and if necessary provide information to contribute to it
●
enable a picture of a child’s or young person’s needs to be built up over time and, with appropriate consent, shared among professionals
●
provide better, more evidence-based referrals to targeted and specialist services.
Case study 10.1 Remodelling and the future of LEAs (adapted from NRT website www.remodelling.org) Remodel West is a working partnership of seven west London LEA remodelling teams. The wide variety of expertise within the group is one of its strengths, including a recent headteacher with experience of both primary and secondary schools, a school adviser with expertise in school improvement and CPD, teacher recruitment strategy managers and education personnel officers. Since its inception, in autumn 2003, it has been active in the creation and delivery of training to support and facilitate school remodelling with other resources active in CPD. Working collaboratively has ensured good practice with well-motivated and energised involvement that has created a good rapport while sharing resources and costs. Most importantly, there has been a positive knock-on effect on the services provided to all of the remodelling schools. The invitation to a cross-section of other LEA colleagues to a half-day workshop allowed the remodelling group to provide an opportunity for others in LEA organisations to see how remodelling joins up the local and national initiatives that individuals and groups of staff are working on. The main objectives were to engage a whole range of LEA stakeholders in workforce remodelling (and potentially remodelling in LEAs), to showcase practical examples of school remodelling, to outline the impact of school improvements on standards and to set a context for the future of LEA services.
Having read this case study, how can this inform future plans to improve relationships between members of the school and local LEA?
Remodelling Schools Manual: Workforce Reform by Sonia Blandford Published by Pearson Education © Pearson Education Limited 2006
67
RSWR_CO2.QXD 27/9/05 9:48 am Page 68
Section 2 · The extended school – a community of learners
To do
68
Action
Remodelling Schools Manual: Workforce Reform by Sonia Blandford Published by Pearson Education © Pearson Education Limited 2006
RSWR_CO2.QXD 27/9/05 9:48 am Page 69
Workshop materials
2.1 First steps towards an extended school
70
2.2 External agencies contact list
71
Remodelling Schools Manual: Workforce Reform by Sonia Blandford Published by Pearson Education © Pearson Education Limited 2006
69
RSWR_CO2.QXD 27/9/05 9:48 am Page 70
Section 2 · Workshop materials
Workshop 2.1
FIRST STEPS TOWARDS AN EXTENDED SCHOOL 1 Use the following tabulation as a checklist for the school leadership team to consider in terms of taking the first step to extended school status.
WORKING TOWARDS ‘EMERGED’ STATUS Baseline key indicators (Sandwell, 2005) Focus
Code of practice
Key indicators
Purpose and ethos
‘Having a purpose’ ‘Getting the ethos right’
Activities have a purpose and there is an understanding of the need for a user-friendly environment
Finding out what’s needed
‘Finding out what’s needed’
More than intuition and guesswork
Planning and resources
‘Getting the best from resources’ ‘Selecting providers and recruiting the right staff’
Identifying the best use of existing resources, suitable providers and developing recruitment procedures
Programme
‘Establishing a programme’ ‘Developing together’ ‘Developing teams and team members’
A programme of activity existing beyond the school day
Involving and informing
‘Involving the community’ ‘Letting people know’
Finding out who is taking part and advertising extended school activities
Working with partners
‘Working with partners’
Knowledge of existing and potential partners
Impact
‘Measuring the difference’ ‘Getting and demonstrating results’
Recognition of the need to gather baseline data
2 Evaluate the outcomes. 3 Discuss and decide on the next steps.
70
Remodelling Schools Manual: Workforce Reform by Sonia Blandford Published by Pearson Education © Pearson Education Limited 2006
RSWR_CO2.QXD 27/9/05 9:48 am Page 71
Section 2 · Workshop materials
Workshop 2.2
EXTERNAL AGENCIES CONTACT LIST List the external agencies working in partnership with your school. Include contact names, e-mail addresses and phone numbers and the points of contact within your school.
External agency
Name
E-mail address
Phone number
Remodelling Schools Manual: Workforce Reform by Sonia Blandford Published by Pearson Education © Pearson Education Limited 2006
School contact
71
RSWR_CO2.QXD 27/9/05 9:48 am Page 72
Summary
When a school is to be remodelled it needs to determine its place and function as a community. Relationships with parents and the broader community are central to the effectiveness of an extended school. All members of the school, as participants in the school and local community, should be encouraged to have a shared commitment to the remodelling of the school community. Schools, like other communities, have their own characteristics and personalities. The culture of each school is determined by individual and collective beliefs and values. Differences between schools may be explained in terms of organisational and social structures that reflect the interpersonal relationships that contribute to ethos. The management of the school environment is the responsibility of everyone in the school community. The development and maintenance of the environment can be a key activity within the school and has an influence on remodelling. The relationship between school, home and the community will have a significant impact on implementing remodelling. The connection between the school and the community is not static but develops in a continuum. There are almost as many definitions of extended schools as there are schools engaged in this aspect of the remodelling agenda. Extended schools are based on standards of leadership and management but also recognise that to achieve the highest standards and sustain improvement, the curriculum and other learning experiences of the child support should be coordinated as a whole, contributing to, and being sustained by, the local community. The management of an extended school programme requires training that prepares managers and staff to develop an understanding and the skills required. The key elements of extended schools include multi-agency family and child support services, study support, family learning and community use of facilities. Local authorities recognise that this will mean a culture change for heads of service and, in some cases, heads of schools who will move from management and control to leadership and influence. This will involve the building of trust and confidence in and with new partners in order to realign services closer to the point of delivery. The effectiveness of building with the community will lead to long-term planning through consultation and identification of needs. Building schools in communities will bring schools to the heart of each community, offering a wide range of services to support the whole community. The following section considers the wider workforce and the participants in the remodelling process.
72
Remodelling Schools Manual: Workforce Reform by Sonia Blandford Published by Pearson Education © Pearson Education Limited 2006
RSWR_CO3.QXD 27/9/05 9:51 am Page 73
Section 3
WORKFORCE REFORM
11 School workforce reform – policy
76
12 Teachers
81
13 Teaching assistants
88
14 Higher level teaching assistants
92
15 Headteachers
96
Workshop materials
100
Summary
105
Remodelling Schools Manual: Workforce Reform by Sonia Blandford Published by Pearson Education © Pearson Education Limited 2006
73
RSWR_CO3.QXD 27/9/05 9:51 am Page 74
1
RSWR_CO3.QXD 27/9/05 9:51 am Page 75
Introduction
This section focuses on the school workforce, which is the greatest resource in the delivery of the remodelling agenda. The need for a clear understanding of roles and responsibilities is self-evident. This will enable participants in the process of workforce reform to feel confident and able to respond to Every Child Matters in the context of an extended school. While raising achievement remains a central tenet of government reform, it is the quality of support for each pupil through a shared understanding of roles that will secure the trust needed to achieve success.
Questions to consider 1 Can you define the roles of those employed in your school? 2 How do they contribute to the raising of all pupils’ achievements? 3 How does the school workforce contribute to the development of each child in your school as determined by the five outcomes of Every Child Matters?
Remodelling Schools Manual: Workforce Reform by Sonia Blandford Published by Pearson Education © Pearson Education Limited 2006
75
RSWR_CO3.QXD 27/9/05 9:51 am Page 76
Chapter 11
SCHOOL WORKFORCE REFORM – POLICY
There are a number of policies that underpin the remodelling agenda and workforce reform; these extend beyond those policies that focus entirely on schools and the National Agreement that secured improved working conditions for teachers and has led to workforce reform where a teacher’s practice will focus on pupils’ learning with less emphasis on administrative and support tasks (see Section 1). In this context, they and their teams will create new and exciting places and spaces for teaching and learning. Teachers will be the facilitators of knowledge enabling learners to access and discover learning in a variety of forms. Change management will continue to be a normal part of a professional’s life within schools. To enable change to occur within a secure, comfortable place, the direction of schools within a knowledge society will need to be transparent to all. The sharing of experience and learning will be commonplace whereby staff will advise the decisionmakers, both informing and contributing to the change. This is of greater benefit when time is made available for reflection, development, delivery and evaluation of learning. Thus a teacher’s life is to become more attractive to graduates from all disciplines; such is the vision, met in part by those pathfinder and early adopter schools. Within this section, practical advice is provided on the changing role of leaders, teachers and the wider workforce. Set within the changing educational environment, it focuses on the central tenets of workforce reform. Table 3.1 indicates the range of policy documents that relate to the role of the wider workforce and show how workforce reform is being developed across the public sector as part of a shared national programme of change. Each of the policies relates to Every Child Matters (DfES, 2003b) in which the government recognised that if there were to be improved outcomes, radical change in the whole system of children’s services was required, including: ●
the improvement and integration of universal services – in early years settings, schools and the health service
●
more specialised help to promote opportunity, prevent problems and act early and effectively if and when problems arise
●
the reconfiguration of services around the child and family in one place, for example children’s centres, extended schools and the bringing together of professionals in multidisciplinary teams
76
Remodelling Schools Manual: Workforce Reform by Sonia Blandford Published by Pearson Education © Pearson Education Limited 2006
RSWR_CO3.QXD 27/9/05 9:51 am Page 77
School workforce reform – policy · 11
Title
Description
Date
Every Child Matters
The Children’s Green Paper, Every Child Matters,
8 Sept. 2003
sets out the government’s commitment to improving outcomes for all children and young people Every Child Matters:
This document sets out the purpose of the Children
Next Steps
Bill and the next steps for bringing about change in
4 Mar. 2004
children’s services Five Year Strategy
This is the five year plan for the DfES, which sets
for Children and
out the commitments the department will deliver
8 Jul. 2004
Learners The Future of
The local government strategy developed a
Local Government:
ten-year vision which focused on the key role
Developing a
played by local authorities in delivering local
10-year Vision
services and set out a broader framework for local
Local Area
change programmes to improve children’s services.
Agreements (LAAs):
The prospectus for LAAs proposes that outcome-
A Prospectus
focused agreements between central government
27 Jul. 2004
and local areas should be based around three blocks, one of which would be outcomes for children and young people Table 3.1 Key published documents ●
dedicated and enterprising leadership at all levels of the system
●
the development of a shared sense of responsibility across agencies for safeguarding children and protecting them from harm
●
listening to children, young people and their families when assessing and planning service provision, as well as in face-to face delivery.
The Children Act 2004 is the legislative spine on which the government is building its reforms of children’s services. It established for England: ●
a children’s commissioner to champion the views and interests of children and young people
●
a duty on local authorities to make arrangements to promote cooperation between agencies and voluntary and community organisations in order to improve children’s well-being, and a duty on key partners to take part in the cooperation arrangements
●
a duty on key agencies to safeguard and promote the welfare of children
●
a duty on local authorities to set up safeguarding children boards and on key partners to take part
Remodelling Schools Manual: Workforce Reform by Sonia Blandford Published by Pearson Education © Pearson Education Limited 2006
77
RSWR_CO3.QXD 27/9/05 9:51 am Page 78
Section 3 · Workforce reform
●
provision for indexes or databases containing basic information about children and young people to enable better sharing of information
●
a requirement for a single children and young people’s plan to be drawn up by each local authority
●
a requirement on local authorities to appoint a director of children’s services and designate a lead member
●
the creation of an integrated inspection framework and the conduct of joint area reviews to assess local areas’ progress in improving outcomes
●
provisions relating to foster care, private fostering and the education of children in care.
THE WIDER WORKFORCE The wider workforce encompasses a range of practitioners whose professional and voluntary activities focus on the child, of which examples are illustrated in Fig. 3.1. Any aspect of quality in education or childcare will be determined by the quality of the workforce. The CWDC is now responsible for this development. Schools, LEAs and, it would appear, governments continue to recognise that the current workforce is capable and dedicated. However, the need to raise standards reflects on the difficulties experienced by the workforce that include: ●
professional experience that is limited by short-term retention of staff, thus reducing the time to develop skills and expertise
●
limited finance to attract and sustain long-term appointments of suitably qualified staff
●
poor communication between childcare and education services
●
the heavy approach to inspection, which can be demotivating
●
poor leadership and management.
It is not surprising that both care providers and schools are experiencing problems in recruiting and retaining staff. In response to these issues, the government has developed initiatives for the professional development of the wider workforce, including accessible progression routes for the existing workforce. There are also plans to attract and retain sufficient staff by reducing turnover and encouraging men and members of ethnic minority groups into the professions. The career framework will include degree-level qualifications for early year practitioners, the aim being to create a profession that combines learning with care. Such plans are being developed across the public sector to: ● develop more flexible entry routes to improve recruitment ● improve training and development to raise quality and better progression opportunities to improve
retention and thus stability … ● explore and promote new ways of working … ● ensure effective leadership, management and supervision.
Source: DfES (2005a)
78
Remodelling Schools Manual: Workforce Reform by Sonia Blandford Published by Pearson Education © Pearson Education Limited 2006
RSWR_CO3.QXD 27/9/05 9:51 am Page 79
School workforce reform – policy · 11
Faith groups
Business
Site managers
Local authority partners: health, social and youth workers
School leaders
Arts and sports organisations
Administrators
Teachers The child Learning and teaching assistants
Finance managers Multiinter-agency workforce
Governors
Parents and volunteers
Technicians
Children’s centres
Play groups
Fig. 3.1 The wider workforce
CHALLENGES AND OPPORTUNITIES Set within the context of the wider workforce, the challenges and opportunities that schools will encounter when addressing workforce reform are manifold. Staffing issues are at the forefront of the agenda, as are the needs of all children. Schools should be in a position to recruit and retain sufficient teaching and support staff as defined by maximum class size limits determined by legislation, i.e. 30 for Key Stage (KS) 1. This would enable schools to meet the personal, social and educational needs of children and young people in partnership with other agencies. The national reduction in numbers of school-aged pupils will facilitate appropriate reduction in class sizes and provide greater opportunities for teachers to meet individual learning needs and expanding curriculum opportunities. The National Agreement presents new challenges to the way that support staff are deployed, supervised and managed. Governors and LEAs are encouraged to develop support staff in schools. As the National Joint Council (NJC) for Local Government Services (NJC, 2003) advises, LEAs have a key role to play in developing local frameworks to recruit, retain and develop a skilled and committed workforce. The NJC suggests that grading reviews and advice on fixed term contracts may need to be revised; this will dependent on local arrangements. What is evident, by the increase in range, ability and number, is that support staff will be willing to play their part in meeting the new demands in schools. Changes in contracts will need to be negotiated in response to these developments.
Remodelling Schools Manual: Workforce Reform by Sonia Blandford Published by Pearson Education © Pearson Education Limited 2006
79
RSWR_CO3.QXD 27/9/05 9:51 am Page 80
Section 3 · Workforce reform
Staff in schools are employees of the LEA, with headteachers and school governors having delegated responsibilities. Working time for support staff shall be based on individual contracts within the national framework and ensure that support staff are paid for all worked hours. The NJC provides generic advice on job profiles and suggests three families of support staff: ●
teaching assistants (TAs)
●
curriculum/resource support
●
administration and organisation.
The career progression for staff described in government policies might determine that teaching and other child-centred professions are graduate professions with training that encompasses a range of knowledge, understanding, skills and responsibilities. Continuing professional development (CPD) should be an entitlement; the school workforce needs time and space to reflect, research and develop practice (see Chapters 20 and 21). There are further issues to consider as the new initiatives also provide a framework in which the delivery of the national curriculum and its content can be explored. Schools are members of a global community that is knowledge-driven; the nature of learning is no longer discipline-based. Thinking skills, sustainability and faith issues are central to our lives, as is knowledge about health, citizenship and how to manage learning facilitated by technology. Perhaps now is the time to re-evaluate the nature of learning and teaching (see Chapter 25).
Leadership and practitioner questions 1 Have you read and discussed the government’s policies underpinning workforce reform? 2 Have you introduced workforce reform for the wider workforce in your school? 3 What is the impact of workforce reform? 4 How is this measured? 5 Have you discussed workforce reform with your leadership team/line manager?
80
Remodelling Schools Manual: Workforce Reform by Sonia Blandford Published by Pearson Education © Pearson Education Limited 2006
RSWR_CO3.QXD 27/9/05 9:51 am Page 81
Chapter 12
TEACHERS
Within the remodelling agenda, workforce reform has focused attention on the recruitment, management and redeployment of teachers. This is not without controversy, as not all trade unions feel comfortable with the changes within the National Agreement. This chapter examines the changes and explores the implications for teachers. Evidence has been gathered from government policies, websites, union publications and interviews with headteachers. The National Agreement aims to raise standards and tackle workload in schools. It is the function of the WAMG to monitor the implementation of the National Agreement. On a regular basis, the WAMG issues guidance notes, which reflect the agreed position of all the signatories, to support schools in implementing the National Agreement. Twelve notes had been issued by June 2005. Further definitive guidance is presented in the latest statutory School Teachers’ Pay and Conditions Document (DfES, 2005e), while additional advice is given by a number of agencies, including: ●
NRT
●
National Joint Council (NJC) for local government services
●
governors associations
●
individual trade unions
●
LEAs.
The NRT has worked with schools to focus teachers’ time and energies on teaching and learning, eradicate time-consuming and wasteful activities, facilitate new technologies to improve efficiency and effectiveness, assist school leaders to optimise resources and share innovative and effective practices within and between schools in order to deliver solutions to workload issues appropriate to each school’s individual context and circumstances (adapted from NRT website www.remodelling.org). In essence, the WAMG’s guidance explains that support staff will supplement, not supplant, teachers and that every class or group of pupils must have a teacher assigned to teach it. Far from allowing anyone to teach, the new regulations mean that, for the first time, skilled TAs, nursery nurses and other support staff will work within an agreed framework of direction and supervision by teachers (see Chapters 13 and 14).
Remodelling Schools Manual: Workforce Reform by Sonia Blandford Published by Pearson Education © Pearson Education Limited 2006
81
RSWR_CO3.QXD 27/9/05 9:51 am Page 82
Section 3 · Workforce reform
PHASE ONE: WORK/LIFE BALANCE In addressing the National Agreement, the WAMG advises that there are many issues which impact on work/life balance. Systems and structures may help teachers to address such issues while the context and status of teachers as professionals are also important. Cultural and personal issues are also key factors in teachers’ ability to address their work/life balance (see Chapter 24). As the NRT explains: Remodelling is designed to enhance the status and work/life balance of all who work in our schools … It is an opportunity to reassess the work and role of everyone involved in educating young people … The remodelling community has the potential to enhance the status of everyone who works in schools, improve recruitment and retention, challenge traditional practices and help create a modern workforce. Source: www.remodelling.org
Specified work The STPCD and National Agreement state that teachers will: ●
plan and prepare lessons and courses for pupils
●
deliver lessons to pupils, including delivery by way of distance learning or computeraided techniques
●
assess the development, progress and attainment of pupils
●
report on the development, progress and attainment of pupils.
The tasks that will no longer be carried out by teachers will include: ●
the 24 tasks set out in the National Agreement
●
financial and premises management, procurement and sponsorship
●
supervisory and pastoral activities that require behaviour management experience but are not directly related to classroom teaching. These include playground supervision, examination invigilation and elements of pastoral care (counselling).
PHASE TWO: COVER SUPERVISION Within the National Agreement, the contractual change since September 2004 now limits teachers covering for absent colleagues to 38 hours per year; the long-term objective is that teachers will not have to provide cover. The WAMG has provided guidance that includes a cover resource pack which: … contains a variety of resources and information that schools may find useful in implementing this phase of contractual change. It also contains guidance for schools that are considering using cover supervision, along with a range of other strategies, in order to deliver an effective and tailored school policy for dealing with cover. Key points to note from this guidance include:
82
Remodelling Schools Manual: Workforce Reform by Sonia Blandford Published by Pearson Education © Pearson Education Limited 2006
RSWR_CO3.QXD 27/9/05 9:51 am Page 83
Teachers · 12
● cover supervision occurs when there is no active teaching taking place ● cover supervision should only be used for short-term absences ● cover supervision by effectively deployed and appropriately graded support staff with appropriate
skills, training and pay will be a fundamental part of an effective cover strategy, increasing the options available to headteachers and allowing them to deal with teacher absence in a way which is compatible with the standards agenda and the efficient use of resources. Source: WAMG (2004b)
Leadership questions A Guidance for Governors (NRT, 2004b) advises that school leaders and governors should consider: 1 Why and when does the need for cover arise? 2 Can the need for cover be minimised? 3 How will the cover strategy affect the continuity of learning for the pupils? 4 What are the implications for the school’s support staff? (See Chapters 13 and 14.) 5 Has the strategy been incorporated into the budget and long-term financial planning? 6 How easily can a new strategy be implemented in the school?
PHASE THREE: PLANNING, PREPARATION AND ASSESSMENT (PPA) The following is adapted from Time for Standards: Planning, Preparation and Assessment (NRT, 2004e): the National Agreement states that teachers are doing too much of their PPA in evenings and weekends, and in isolation from each other. While this cannot be changed overnight, the National Agreement marks a turning point in carving out some guaranteed PPA time during the school day. This is the most complicated aspect of workforce reform. Within the National Agreement and underpinned by statutory guidance, teachers are allocated time to plan and prepare lessons and to assess pupils’ work. The purpose of the guaranteed PPA time is to relieve some of the existing workload pressures on teachers and to raise standards. From 1 September 2005, all teachers (including headteachers) with timetabled teaching commitments, whether employed on permanent, fixed-term, temporary or part-time contracts, have had a contractual entitlement to guaranteed PPA time within the timetabled teaching day. The amount of guaranteed PPA time should be set as a minimum of at least 10 per cent of a teacher’s timetabled teaching time but not other forms of pupil contact. It should be provided as part of a teacher’s normal weekly or fortnightly timetable. It should take place during the school timetable and in blocks of at least 30 minutes. It must be used for PPA
Remodelling Schools Manual: Workforce Reform by Sonia Blandford Published by Pearson Education © Pearson Education Limited 2006
83
RSWR_CO3.QXD 27/9/05 9:51 am Page 84
Section 3 · Workforce reform
and not to cover for absent colleagues. It is for the teacher to determine the particular PPA priorities but does not preclude using time to support collaborative activities. To achieve the minimum allocation of guaranteed PPA time for the majority of teachers will involve one, or a combination, of the following strategies: ●
a reduction in teaching time
●
changes in the use of existing non-contact time
●
redesignation and redistribution of non-contact time from administration of cover, organisation of work experience and the administration of examinations to appropriate support staff.
It should be noted that, in some cases, it is possible that teaching commitments will increase as a result of remodelling, for example with senior teachers, who currently have a reduced teaching load to carry out administrative responsibilities that may in the future be undertaken by support staff, will now return to teaching once that transfer has taken place. Some schools may choose to use HLTAs (see Chapter 14) as one of the strategies for releasing teachers for guaranteed PPA time. Where HLTAs are deployed, the teacher’s guaranteed PPA time must not be encroached upon to deal with problems with a class. The HLTA would need to use the school’s usual referral system, as a qualified teacher would in case of difficulties or an emergency. Implementation of a sustainable staffing plan for the provision of guaranteed PPA is a threestep process involving developing strategies, integrating strategies into the school timetable and planning the evolution of strategies over time as an integral part of the SIP. Time for Standards (NRT, 2004e) recommends the following stages for implementation of PPA (Fig. 3.2):
Identify a range of strategies that release appropriate PPA time Develop school timetables to guarantee 10% PPA Develop staffing policy and plan, school development plan and school budget
Fig. 3.2 Implementation of PPA Source: Time for Standards: Planning, Preparation and Assessment (NRT, 2004e)
84
Remodelling Schools Manual: Workforce Reform by Sonia Blandford Published by Pearson Education © Pearson Education Limited 2006
RSWR_CO3.QXD 27/9/05 9:51 am Page 85
Teachers · 12
Stage 1: Maximising the existing teaching resource Teachers in most secondary schools, and in some primary and special schools, are not timetabled to teach every lesson of every week. Often, they have some timetabled noncontact time which can provide an excellent opportunity for schools to provide designated and guaranteed PPA time. Non-PPA activities carried out during these periods should be assessed to evaluate whether they are a good use of teachers’ time. Key questions include: Is it necessary? Should we be doing this task? Why are we doing this task? Is the person carrying out the task the most appropriate person to be doing it? Can it be transferred to another person? Many activities can be reallocated to a more appropriate person, reduced, or even, when appropriate, discarded. It is vital that schools make a thorough assessment of any change to ensure that their quality of care, teaching and learning is maintained or enhanced. Typically, activities that can be reallocated, reduced or discarded include: ●
Administration – These duties can be transferred to appropriate support staff. Schools should continually be examining the administration burden of their teachers, especially SENCOs, to ensure that all their routine administration tasks are redirected to appropriate support staff.
●
Pastoral care – Many pastoral duties can be moved outside timetabled teaching time but within school sessions. These duties should also be assessed to evaluate if they could be carried out by an appropriately qualified/trained support staff.
●
Training and coaching – Some of these duties do not need to be carried out during timetabled teaching time.
●
Parent liaison – Prospective parents are shown around on an ad hoc basis and support staff can be deployed to carry out this duty.
●
Working with other organisations – Schools are increasingly working closely with organisations such as the police and social services with the implementation of the Extended Schools and Every Child Matters agenda. Much of this work can be carried out by appropriately trained support staff.
Stage 2: Timetabling additional resources When schools do not have enough non-contact time available to provide all their teachers with the minimum 10 per cent guaranteed PPA, and/or where they want to enhance their curriculum, the option is to deploy additional unqualified staff to release teachers. These additional appropriately trained and qualified staff are brought in from outside the school. By providing appropriate training and support, schools may also be able to redeploy existing support staff in roles that build on under-utilised skills, for example modern foreign language ability or computer expertise.
Remodelling Schools Manual: Workforce Reform by Sonia Blandford Published by Pearson Education © Pearson Education Limited 2006
85
RSWR_CO3.QXD 27/9/05 9:51 am Page 86
Section 3 · Workforce reform
Key to the deployment of additional staff is that the school curriculum is maintained, though schools should look for opportunities to enhance the curriculum by delivering lessons in subject areas that were not previously offered, for example contemporary music production. Additional staff should be deployed to carry out specified work, as opposed to supervision. They should have appropriate qualifications and/or experience and have been assigned the appropriate grade. Additional school staff strategies include: ●
Higher level teaching assistants – HLTAs are expected to make a significant contribution in teaching and learning activities under the direction and supervision of a teacher (see Chapter 13).
●
Instructors – A person with ‘specialist qualifications or experience or both’ can deliver specified work, provided the LEA and/or school governing body is satisfied that he or she has the relevant qualification or experience. Instructors have unqualified teacher status and are employed under the terms of the STPCD. They are contractually entitled to PPA time for the timetabled teaching provided.
●
Specialist staff – These members may already be employed by the school or can be brought in from outside. They can be existing support staff, as long as they have qualifications or experience in their speciality, for example a member of the support staff who is a dancer or a native French speaker, sports coaches and local business people. Specialist staff can work with one class or in a ‘floating’ capacity, working with classes across the school, but are not employed under the terms of the STPCD as there is no PPA entitlement for these staff, although schools may chose to provide them with some PPA time.
●
Other teachers – The teacher(s) can be brought in from outside the school or released internally, through an increase in their non-contact time – perhaps as a result of having fewer cover duties or administrative tasks or by maximising the teaching resource within school sessions. These teachers must be given timetabled commitments and will be entitled to receive their own guaranteed PPA time. They may be timetabled to teach a number of different classes on a weekly or fortnightly basis. They can be supported by an HLTA or TA accustomed to working with a particular class.
The principles underpinning workforce reform are to be celebrated: advising and supporting teachers to achieve a work/life balance, providing them with 10 per cent PPA time while raising standards and extending schools. Is it possible? The wider workforce is the solution: TAs, HLTAs, volunteers and parents.
86
Remodelling Schools Manual: Workforce Reform by Sonia Blandford Published by Pearson Education © Pearson Education Limited 2006
RSWR_CO3.QXD 27/9/05 9:51 am Page 87
Teachers · 12
Questions to consider How can workforce reform enable school leaders to: 1 focus on teaching and learning? 2 reduce staff workload? 3 raise the attainment of all pupils? 4 enhance the professionalism and status of teachers? 5 provide solutions that extend beyond the traditional boundaries of one school? 6 improve recruitment and retention? 7 improve work/life balance? 8 facilitate change and encourage creativity and risk-taking?
Leadership questions The NRT’s Guidance for Governors (NRT, 2004b) has produced a checklist for discussion between governors and headteachers that has been adapted as follows: 1 Have all administrative and clerical tasks been transferred from teachers? 2 Has the school established an action plan? 3 Has time been allocated for all headteachers with leadership and management responsibilities? 4 Is there a sustainable cover policy? 5 Are there plans for invigilating examinations?
Remodelling Schools Manual: Workforce Reform by Sonia Blandford Published by Pearson Education © Pearson Education Limited 2006
87
RSWR_CO3.QXD 27/9/05 9:51 am Page 88
Chapter 13
TEACHING ASSISTANTS
This chapter focuses on those who will play a major part in workforce reform – teaching assistants. Prior to the National Agreement, many schools employed TAs to support pupils with SEN and are now part of the central core of para-professionals who support practice in schools. In 2003, the DfES published Developing the Role of School Support Staff, which detailed the key benefits for support staff of workforce reform: ● a recognition of the important role played by support staff in improving schools and raising pupil
standards ● funding to enable the recruitment of additional support staff, including technicians, administrative
staff and classroom-based-staff so that by 2005, schools should be in a position to recruit at least 50,000 additional support staff ● the recognition that the remuneration of support staff should reflect their levels of skills, training and
responsibilities ● foundation training for all types of staff, building on the success of DfES induction training for
teaching assistants ● the extension of other key roles for support staff such as personal assistants to provide administrative
support to teachers or subject departments and trained cover supervisors who can undertake shortterm, ad hoc cover for absent teachers ● opportunities to progress through clear routes from entry level to the new higher-level teaching
assistant role or senior administrative roles or advanced roles in relation to behaviour and guidance ● newly-developed training to support higher-level roles: ● for higher-level teaching assistants, standards and training are being developed by the TTA ● for school finance managers, qualifications and training are being developed by the NCSL ● routes into other roles – for example, making sure that those who wish to become a teacher have
clear routes including through the higher-level teaching assistant training ● more funding to support training
Source: DfES (2003c)
88
Remodelling Schools Manual: Workforce Reform by Sonia Blandford Published by Pearson Education © Pearson Education Limited 2006
RSWR_CO3.QXD 27/9/05 9:51 am Page 89
Teaching assistants · 13
Government and headteachers (Gunter et al., 2004) are of the same view that support staff have contributed to the recent improvements in the quality of teaching and learning. The developments proposed in the National Agreement will extend the range of what teaching assistants will be asked to do in the classroom and prepare them for the role.
DEFINITION OF SUPPORT STAFF Time for Standards defines support staff as ranging from: teaching assistants, nursery nurses, librarians and other staff in schools such as technical support staff to, for example, business persons or members of the emergency services, who may from time to time engage with pupils e.g. the community police officer. Source: DfES (2003a)
These definitions appear to extend the scope of support staff from those traditionally involved in supporting teachers in the delivery of the national curriculum. Within this profile, there is also scope for creative appointments that include sports coaches, musicians, artists and the wider workforce although Time for Standards states: Where appropriate this may be achieved through building on existing supervision arrangements within the school … The practical effect of the Regulations is not to prevent support staff from undertaking the ‘specified work’, but to ensure that they do so within a proper system of direction and supervision by a qualified teacher. The headteacher will determine how the system of supervision is provided and by whom. Source: DfES (2003a)
Resources are the biggest challenge to expanding the workforce in schools. The government’s intention is to recruit an additional 50,000 support staff; however, there are considerable doubts as to whether there is sufficient funding to resource this initiative. Once recruited, training will be needed to prepare those in new roles. There is a strategic role to be played by governors and school leaders in developing the role of all support staff, especially TAs, to assist the workforce reform of classroom teachers. In 2003, the DfES guidance was embedded in the School Teachers’ Pay and Conditions Document, which further developed Section 133 Regulations that gave circumstances where a TA can do work normally undertaken by qualified teachers. This allowance has been, in part, to provide resources needed to implement PPA though workforce reform that does not mean substituting qualified teachers with support staff. Time for Standards (DfES, 2003a) provides guidance to accompany the Section 133 Regulations and was intended to safeguard standards in the classroom and preserve the role, status and overall responsibility of qualified teachers in schools. It also addresses the uncertainty over the duties and activities that support staff may undertake to support PPA. It states that support staff:
Remodelling Schools Manual: Workforce Reform by Sonia Blandford Published by Pearson Education © Pearson Education Limited 2006
89
RSWR_CO3.QXD 27/9/05 9:51 am Page 90
Section 3 · Workforce reform
● who may undertake the ‘specified work’ subject to a number of conditions … ● must carry out the ‘specified work’ in order to assist or support the work of a qualified teacher in the
school; ● must be subject to the direction and supervision of a qualified teacher in accordance with
arrangements made by the headteacher of the school; and ● has the skills, expertise and experience required to carry out the ‘specified work’.
The teaching assistant’s role is further divided into classroom-based activity, supporting and delivering learning and behaviour guidance. As indicated, changes will require local decisions and training. The NJC profiles are a structural approach to job and career development, including four levels of progression written in conjunction with Section 133 of the Regulations and guidance agreed by the WAMG relating to supervision. The four levels are: ●
Level 1 – staff will be working under direction/instruction and not left alone with a class
●
Level 2 – experienced staff will be working under instruction/guidance as they develop new skills or gain qualifications.
●
Level 3 – staff will work under guidance according to the level of specified work undertaken.
●
Level 4 – staff will work under an agreed system of supervision/management. The WAMG advises that experienced support staff with appropriate training and qualifications may be given greater autonomy within the framework set by the teacher.
LEADERSHIP RESPONSIBILITY Appropriate leadership and management are needed if support staff are to be recruited and retained. Headteachers are responsible for ensuring that new or redeployed staff meet the requirements of the support role as determined by a job description for both employed and voluntary staff. Criminal Record Bureau (CRB) checks (see www.crb.gov.uk) are also necessary, as are training in behaviour management, first aid and the safe use of equipment within the school. Support staff who assist teachers can expect supervision of activities relating to teaching and learning, and line management. This will involve time to discuss planning and pupil progress, and the use of the pupil referral system. Line management will be responsible for guidance relating to the role. Time for Standards (DfES, 2003a) suggests that schools audit the skills and experience of all of its staff and members of the school community, including voluntary support. This would assist in the planning of curriculum and enrichment activities.
90
Remodelling Schools Manual: Workforce Reform by Sonia Blandford Published by Pearson Education © Pearson Education Limited 2006
RSWR_CO3.QXD 27/9/05 9:51 am Page 91
Teaching assistants · 13
Case study 13.1 Teaching assistants The NRT website provides a range of case studies to illustrate the impact of TAs within overall workforce reform on practice in schools, one of which is the Alexandra Primary School in Hounslow (www.remodelling.org/submitted_article.php?id=9). It is a challenging school, yet its SATs’ results demonstrate significant improvement in five years from around 50% to 94% (science), 88% (English) and 82% (mathematics). This success is attributed, in part, to the eight full-time TAs. The posts are funded with a combination of Standards Fund, Education Action Zone (EAZ) and statement money. Funds have been used creatively and it would seem effectively. As the senior teacher explains: To optimise teaching and learning we attach one of our TAs to each year group of three classes. They take a very active role: attending planning meetings, supporting individual children and working with groups and classes. They also accompany teachers and pupils on school trips. All our TAs are fully insured and well trained in our health and safety procedures … Two of our TAs work in a floating capacity, working with specific children and supporting other TAs when required. A further example of successful remodelling presented by the NRT focuses on Whalton Church of England First School in Northumberland (www.remodelling.org/submitted _article_print.php?id=2). This small rural school, with just 41 pupils, has considerable needs in terms of time, money and staff. The teaching headteacher adopted the change management approach advocated by the NRT. The head addressed work/life balance issues by employing a full-time assistant who provides additional support in reception and KS1. The assistant also takes the whole school swimming, with parents, for an afternoon a week, thus creating leadership and management time. Creative use of funds has also helped, with the appointment of their own caretaker and reducing cover insurance costs. ICT is being adopted for planning while collaboration with neighbouring schools on training programmes has also reduced costs. Both these examples of good practice can be applied elsewhere.
Leadership questions The NRT’s Guidance for Governors (NRT, 2004b) has produced a checklist for discussion between governors and headteachers that has been adapted as follows: 1 Has appropriate training been given to support staff who are undertaking new responsibilities? 2 Do opportunities exist for support staff to develop professionally, and does the performance management policy apply to all staff? 3 Do all support staff have an up-to-date job description and appropriate grading and remuneration in line with NJC job profiles to take account of new responsibilities?
Remodelling Schools Manual: Workforce Reform by Sonia Blandford Published by Pearson Education © Pearson Education Limited 2006
91
RSWR_CO3.QXD 27/9/05 9:51 am Page 92
Chapter 14
HIGHER LEVEL TEACHING ASSISTANTS
Remodelling is an opportunity for headteachers, teachers and members of the wider workforce to reflect on their role in relation to children. As this chapter will demonstrate, there are possibilities to create new ways of working that enable all staff to develop beyond their current practice; HLTAs are promoted teaching assistant and supervisory posts, so all of the factors discussed in Chapter 13 relate to the role of HLTAs. Legislation is in place through the National Agreement and School Teachers’ Pay and Conditions Document that underpins developments. The role of HLTAs is explained as follows: The HLTA initiative will allow those who achieve HLTA status to offer proven skills to support teachers and pupils even more effectively and to take on additional responsibility. The deployment of support staff with HLTA status is one of the strategies schools can use to implement the workforce agreement and their plans for school remodelling. Source: WAMG (2004a)
HLTA status provides the opportunity for schools to recognise the levels of knowledge, skills and understanding that many school support staff have and the contribution that they make in schools. It gives a wide range of school support staff, including librarians, technicians, nursery nurses and other TAs, an option for career progression. Many schools have already developed new roles for their support staff, and support staff roles will continue to develop over time. All schools need to consider what roles are appropriate for members of their workforce, what training and other support are needed so that staff can undertake those roles effectively, and what levels of remuneration are appropriate for the roles concerned. This is being provided through the Higher Level Teaching Assistants scheme which commenced in May 2004 when the first 7,000 candidates started training, followed by 7,000 in 2005–6 and another 7,000 in 2006–7. Participants in the training scheme will be trained to meet, and assessed against, national professional standards. The NRT explains that: HLTA status is awarded by the TTA to school support staff who successfully demonstrate the agreed national professional standards through one of the HLTA assessment and training programmes that are available across the country. These programmes are part of a wide range of training opportunities for school support staff. Source: NRT (2004c)
92
Remodelling Schools Manual: Workforce Reform by Sonia Blandford Published by Pearson Education © Pearson Education Limited 2006
RSWR_CO3.QXD 27/9/05 9:51 am Page 93
Higher level teaching assistants · 14
Two training pathways are available: ●
an assessment-only pathway designed to allow teaching assistants who are already at, or near, the standards to achieve HLTA quickly
●
a full-training pathway running for 50 days designed to enable participants to meet the standards.
The four distinct stages to becoming an HLTA are:
Stage 1
Needs assessment Informed by the Standards Part of the appraisal and ongoing CPD TTA guidance
Stage 2
Developing competence Low cost – high energy – long term Locally arranged and delivered Local assurance
Stage 3
Preparing for assessment Informed by good practice and TTA guidance Locally arranged and delivered Local/regional assurance
Stage 4
Being assessed TTA assessment process Regional approved provider Regional/national accreditation
As the capacity of the HLTA programme grows, more support staff will be able to pursue HLTA status. In the longer term, there may be scope for support staff to take part in an HLTA training and assessment programme to further their career progression in circumstances where there is no vacant HLTA post available in their own school. The guidance to Section 133 Regulations states that HLTAs or other support staff and teachers are not interchangeable. HLTAs working with whole classes should not mean any reduction in the support for pupils. The headteacher should, therefore, consider what additional classroom support may be needed.
Remodelling Schools Manual: Workforce Reform by Sonia Blandford Published by Pearson Education © Pearson Education Limited 2006
93
RSWR_CO3.QXD 27/9/05 9:51 am Page 94
Section 3 · Workforce reform
SUPERVISION Support staff in higher level roles should be working within the school’s system of management and supervision, which should reflect good practice set out in existing guidance such as WAMG guidance notes. They may be working under the direction and supervision of more than one teacher. Supervision arrangements should include time for teachers and support staff to discuss planning and pupil progress within the contracted hours of each of those involved.
LINE MANAGEMENT Line management is distinct from the direction and supervision provided by a teacher for activities relating to teaching and learning. Line management covers the more day-to-day matters relating to the management of support staff. Support staff should have only one line manager, usually a senior member of the school’s support staff. As indicated in the NJC for local government services job profiles (NJC, 2003), HLTAs may be responsible for the management of other support staff. The line managers who coordinate the work of the HLTA and provide support should undertake appraisal. The teachers who direct and supervise the HLTA should provide feedback to the line manager on progress, to inform the appraisal process. Regular reviews allow an assessment of training and development needs so the staff concerned can develop professionally and improve the level of support they can offer. Specified work can only be carried out by teachers with QTS or someone who satisfies other requirements – for example support staff may undertake specified work in order to assist or support the work of a qualified teacher – and are subject to the direction and supervision of a qualified teacher in accordance with arrangements made by the headteacher. The headteacher must be satisfied that the support staff member has the skills, expertise and experience to carry out the specified work.
CLASS RESPONSIBILITY An inexperienced teaching assistant requires direct supervision and must not be left alone with the class, while an experienced teaching assistant who has undergone training and meets the national standards for HLTAs does not require the qualified teacher assigned to that class to be present at all times. The guidance distinguishes between the supervision of support staff by qualified teachers and line management, which need not be undertaken by a qualified teacher.
94
Remodelling Schools Manual: Workforce Reform by Sonia Blandford Published by Pearson Education © Pearson Education Limited 2006
RSWR_CO3.QXD 27/9/05 9:51 am Page 95
Higher level teaching assistants · 14
PROCESS AND FUNDING The HLTA training and assessment programmes are delivered by TTA training providers. All LEAs publish details on how they will allocate funding and contact details for further enquiries. Standard Fund Grant 25 may be used to provide support for candidates attending training as well as supply cover, travel and subsistence costs when candidates attend centrebased learning, childcare costs and costs for the loan of laptops during training. Documentation, standards and guidance on meeting the standards for HLTA can be found within the resource bank at the HLTA website www.hlta.gov.uk.
HLTAS CONDITIONS OF SERVICE Within government guidance, remuneration for staff delivering specified work should be assessed in relation to new responsibilities and within the whole school-pay structure. Grading of staff is to be determined by the LEA or governing bodies as appropriate, under the terms of the NJC’s Green Book and grading structures. In addition to the profiling and grading of posts, employers are advised to consult with employees regarding changes to job descriptions, deployment and timetabling. As with all posts, there must be agreement about a change of contracts. Further training and development should also be provided (see Chapter 21), including dedicated training time, observation, mentoring and monitoring. CPD should be included in policies. As with teachers, support staff who are working to HLTA standards should have paid PPA time set aside to enable them to plan and prepare for their roles in lessons and to liaise with classroom teachers. The NJC provides detailed advice on preparing job profiles and performance appraisals for support staff. As with all staff, HLTAs must have job descriptions for training and development policies. These must be based on constructive annual appraisals and conditions of service clearly stated. Further details are provided in Chapters 20 and 21.
Remodelling Schools Manual: Workforce Reform by Sonia Blandford Published by Pearson Education © Pearson Education Limited 2006
95
RSWR_CO3.QXD 27/9/05 9:51 am Page 96
Chapter 15
HEADTEACHERS
The remodelling process began with consultation with a range of agencies and practitioners, each with expertise, knowledge and experience of working in partnership for the benefit of the school community. Much of workforce reform focuses on teachers, but managers and leaders are also beneficiaries of the changes in legislation that facilitate dedicated headship time. The core purpose of the headteacher is to provide professional leadership and management for a school. The governors will have a role in monitoring the use of this time in order to enable headteachers to develop the necessary vision and direction to improve the quality of education and to raise standards. This chapter will introduce possible developments for all schools to consider and provide a model for practice beginning with management and leadership and the delegation of financial management. Headteachers must have dedicated time to lead their schools as well as manage them. From September 2005, governing bodies are expected to ensure that headteachers have dedicated headship time, having regard to resources in the school and to further national guidance that will be developed in good time before the provisions are implemented. Schools should work towards this change as far as possible prior to its statutory introduction. NASUWT’s General Secretary, Chris Keates, reflects on the implications of the government’s remodelling agenda for headteachers: Over the years, headteachers have been as vulnerable as teachers to the unrealistic expectation that they can consistently and continually absorb an ever-increasing myriad of tasks, often peripheral to their core responsibility of leading teaching and learning. Like teachers, their workload and working hours, over the years, spiralled out of control, their morale was low and recruitment and retention was a serious problem … When implemented fully, the seven contractual changes that have been the catalyst for the remodelling agenda will provide not only a reduction in workload but a long-overdue opportunity for headteachers and other members of the school leadership group to refocus their skills, expertise and energy on their core role of leading teaching and learning. This development has been warmly welcomed by many headteachers who now feel able to disentangle themselves from activities that do not require their professional skills and expertise and are reinvigorated by the opportunities remodelling presents to refocus their role. These heads recognise and respect the importance of what takes place in the classroom and wish to remain allied to it … Leading teaching and learning is exacting and onerous. Clearly no-one would argue that heads must have a full teaching timetable, on the same basis that it is recognised that others who lead teaching and learning within the school need time to discharge management and leadership responsibilities which support effective classroom practice. Source: NASUWT
96
Remodelling Schools Manual: Workforce Reform by Sonia Blandford Published by Pearson Education © Pearson Education Limited 2006
RSWR_CO3.QXD 27/9/05 9:51 am Page 97
Headteachers · 15
In managing change (see Chapter 23) and to alleviate the burden on headteachers, schools have been advised to create CMTs to facilitate the change process. Schools have been encouraged to think out of the box, to create new posts in areas previously covered by leadership teams, for example financial management, ICT support, curriculum support and management of student services. Premises with new posts can be funded through the Standards Fund/Grant (see Section 4). All new posts require job descriptions and should follow the advice available in the NJC Green Book and STPCD. Inevitably, the clearer the plan, the greater the scope for flexibility as staff will be sure of their roles and responsibilities, communication will be effective, and planning and decision-making will improve so that the more creative and forward-thinking schools will benefit from workforce reform and the remodelling process. The impetus remains with the headteacher as those who enter into the National Agreement with reluctance will not gain from the potential opportunities the initiatives can offer.
FINANCE MANAGERS Many headteachers are finding it difficult to refocus the management of their time and that of others. Partnership and delegation are key issues addressed in Chapter 22. An example of such practice is the appointment of a bursar or finance manager. There are several alternative titles, such as school business manager and senior administrative officer. Not all schools are in a position to appoint a bursar, hence the generic use of finance manager is used in this chapter. For those schools able to fund such a post, this would appear to be the first step in achieving the greatest benefits from remodelling the school as, without increased income and sound resource management, schools will not be in a position to meet the requirements of the National Agreement. The appointment of a finance manager, with knowledge and understanding of education coupled with the skill and ability to manage finances, would resolve many of the financial, operational and planning issues encountered by school leaders when implementing workforce reform. However, finance managers require a model on which to base their practice; a possible model is management accounting and control as adopted in other areas of the public sector (Blandford, 1997b). The model is based on the premise that all organisations have aims and objectives. Decisions need to be taken on which strategies are pursued to achieve the objectives and which are rejected, i.e. the planning process. Plans have to be implemented and systems are needed to ensure that the plans are followed and the objectives achieved. This is the control process, as Jones and Pendlebury explain: … processes of planning and control are two of the most important tasks undertaken by the managers of an organisation and together they form the nucleus of the overall management system. In order to carry out these tasks, managers require information. It is with the provision of such information that management accounting is primarily concerned. Source: Jones and Pendlebury (1996)
Remodelling Schools Manual: Workforce Reform by Sonia Blandford Published by Pearson Education © Pearson Education Limited 2006
97
RSWR_CO3.QXD 27/9/05 9:51 am Page 98
Section 3 · Workforce reform
Finance managers must be sources of information to assist the school workforce. As with other management practices from the business world, management accounting could help to inform and guide education leaders (see Fig. 3.3).
Management accounting =
Control systems =
Decisions
Aims and objectives
Planning
Monitor
Evaluate
Review
Fig. 3.3 Management accounting and control
In practice, the role of a finance manager is not dissimilar to that of a management accountant; finance managers in schools are responsible for gathering information. The Chartered Institute of Management Accountants defines management accounting as: An integral part of management concerned with identifying, presenting and interpreting information used for formulating strategy, planning and controlling activities, decision-taking, optimising the use of resources. Source: Chartered Institute of Management Accountants (1994)
A finance manager should be a skilled and competent individual who can ensure that the most effective use of all school resources is made in supporting teaching and learning. At the same time, they may often have a management role, as part of the SLT involving strategic planning and risk management. Within Looking for a Bursar, the basic functions of a finance manager (bursar) are given as follows: ● budgets/monitoring/financial reports/payroll ● cash management ● securing funds that are entitled to the school ● recruiting and managing support staff ● basic premises management ● health and safety management.
Source: DfES (2003a)
The type of job done by a finance manager depends largely on the needs and circumstances of the individual school. It is the responsibility of the headteacher and governors to determine how best a finance manager can contribute to the smooth running of the school; however, the DfES has initiated the Bursar Development Group to advise on bursar training packages, recruitment issues and the promotion of the bursar role in effective school management (DfES, 2003a). Special training can be obtained from the NCSL. The following job specification provides guidance for those seeking to appoint a finance
98
Remodelling Schools Manual: Workforce Reform by Sonia Blandford Published by Pearson Education © Pearson Education Limited 2006
RSWR_CO3.QXD 27/9/05 9:51 am Page 99
Headteachers · 15
manager (bursar) with specific reference to the remodelling process and workforce reform; many other functions could be included and will depend on the requirements of each school. This job profile recognises the demands of current pay and conditions regulations and reflects polices established by the governors of the school.
JOB TITLE
Finance Manager (Bursar)
JOB PURPOSE
To support the headteacher in implementing the aims and objectives of the school by assisting in the strategic planning aspects including all financial implications and ensuring that school makes the best possible use of resources. To be responsible for all or the majority of finance, estate management, effective ‘risk management’.
ACCOUNTABLE TO
Headteacher
Key tasks ●
● ● ●
● ● ● ● ● ●
● ●
●
●
●
To advise the headteacher and governing body on investment and financial policy, preparing appraisals for particular projects and for the development of an annual business plan for the future development of the school. To prepare the annual estimates of income and expenditure for approval by the headteacher and governing body. To obtain agreement of budgets and to monitor accounts against budgets. To use financial management information, especially benchmarking tools, to identify areas of relative spend, assess trends and directly advise the senior leadership team (SLT). To monitor all accounting procedures and resolve any problems, including: (i) the ordering, processing and payment for all goods and services (ii) the operation of all bank accounts (iii) maintaining an assets register (iv) preparation of invoices and collection of fees and other dues. To be responsible for the provision of a comprehensive payroll service for all school staff, with operation of the various pension schemes. To prepare all financial returns for the DfES, LEA, and other central and local government agencies within statutory deadlines. To maximise income generation. To be the point of contact with central and other agencies with regard to grant applications, gifts and other donations. To provide leadership and guidance for support staff, including management responsibility for premises and maintenance, ground staff, cleaners and caterers. To be responsible for the maintenance of the school site and the buildings, maintenance schedules and the operation of all facilities on the property including lighting, heating, domestic hot water, cooking, ventilation, water softening and energy conservation. To negotiate, manage and monitor contracts, tenders and agreements for the provision of support services. To purchase, either directly or indirectly, the school’s energy supplies. To be responsible for the arrangements for school facilities including catering, transport including the minibus(es) and drivers, the school shop, bookings for school facilities and provision of facilities for additional tuition out of school hours, including music. To coordinate the letting of the school premises to outside organizations and school staff, and for the development of all school facilities for out-of-school use, with particular reference to the local community. To acquire and dispose of land and buildings as authorised by the headteacher and governing body. To draw up outline specifications for new buildings, obtaining tenders and planning permission, and liaison with building contractors and the school architect. To know about risk assessment tools and to use them to identify hazards within the school and the associated risk involved.
Remodelling Schools Manual: Workforce Reform by Sonia Blandford Published by Pearson Education © Pearson Education Limited 2006
99
RSWR_CO3.QXD 27/9/05 9:51 am Page 100
Workshop materials
3.1 Teaching assistants meeting the needs of all learners
101
3.2 Teaching assistants – pupil support
102
3.3 Learning activities
103
100
Remodelling Schools Manual: Workforce Reform by Sonia Blandford Published by Pearson Education © Pearson Education Limited 2006
RSWR_CO3.QXD 27/9/05 9:51 am Page 101
Section 3 · Workshop materials
Workshop 3.1
TEACHING ASSISTANTS MEETING THE NEEDS OF ALL LEARNERS The following questions will help as teaching assistants review their current thinking about meeting the needs of all learners in their primary and/or secondary classroom and should generate discussion worthy of consideration by the school workforce. ●
What do you understand your role to be?
●
Are you of the view that pupils are best catered for in separate environments, and if so why?
●
Do you see mainstream education for all pupils as a positive development in light of current global moves towards social justice and equal opportunity?
●
Are you aware of your team leader, and are you involved in any way assisting with this role?
●
Can you think of ways in which to make better use of TA support?
●
How do you differentiate assessment of pupils below level 1 on national curriculum attainment levels?
●
What if any experience do you have of using ‘P-levels’, and could this be shared with colleagues?
●
What are your current CPD needs, and have you talked to your change management team about these and ways in which they could be met?
Remodelling Schools Manual: Workforce Reform by Sonia Blandford Published by Pearson Education © Pearson Education Limited 2006
101
RSWR_CO3.QXD 27/9/05 9:51 am Page 102
Section 3 · Workshop materials
Workshop 3.2
TEACHING ASSISTANTS – PUPIL SUPPORT The following lists provide guidance for supervisors and managers to begin developing induction programmes for teaching assistants. The direct support to pupils will be managed in a range of ways by: ●
gathering information from pupil, school, home, community and other agencies
●
assessing the pupil by identifying patterns
●
understanding and observation of pupils
●
planning for school, home and the community
●
defining intervention procedures, including group work, work in classroom, work off-site and continued observation
●
reviewing dates planned well in advance.
The range of pupil support includes: ●
classroom observation
●
lunchtime and break observation
●
one-to-one counselling
●
social and interpersonal skills group work
●
anger management and conflict resolution group work
●
friendship groups support work
●
lunchtime clubs and playground support
●
therapeutic use of art, drama, play and music
●
cooperative games
●
home–school liaison
●
support for parents
●
classroom focused support work
●
off-site curriculum focused work at child and family support centres
●
teaching.
102
Remodelling Schools Manual: Workforce Reform by Sonia Blandford Published by Pearson Education © Pearson Education Limited 2006
RSWR_CO3.QXD 27/9/05 9:51 am Page 103
Section 3 · Workshop materials
Workshop 3.3
LEARNING ACTIVITIES The purpose of this workshop is to develop the professional work of HLTAs by taking responsibility for agreed learning activities under an agreed system of supervision. This will involve planning, preparing, delivery and evaluating learning activities for individuals and groups or short-term activities for whole classes and monitoring pupils and assessing, recording and reporting on pupils’ achievement, progress and development. Consider what their targets would be in relation to each of the following points: HLTA support for pupils ●
assess the needs of pupils and use detailed knowledge and specialist skills to support pupils’ learning
●
establish productive working relationships with pupils, acting as a role model and setting high expectations
●
develop and implement individual education plans (IEPs)
●
promote the inclusion and acceptance of all pupils within the classroom
●
support pupils consistently while recognising and responding to their individual needs
●
encourage pupils to interact and work cooperatively with others and engage all pupils in activities
●
promote independence and employ strategies to recognise and reward achievement of selfreliance
●
provide feedback to pupils in relation to progress and achievement.
HLTA support for teachers ●
organise and manage appropriate learning environments and resources
●
within an agreed system of supervision, plan challenging teaching and learning objectives to evaluate and adjust lessons/work plans as appropriate
●
monitor and evaluate pupil responses to learning activities through a range of assessment and monitoring strategies against pre-determined learning objectives
●
provide objective and accurate feedback and reports as required on pupil achievement, progress and other matters, ensuring the availability of appropriate evidence
●
record progress and achievement in lessons/activities systematically, and provide evidence of range and level of progress and attainment
●
work within an established discipline policy to anticipate and manage behaviour constructively, promoting self-control and independence
●
supporting the role of parents in pupils’ learning and contribute to/lead meetings with parents to provide constructive feedback on pupil progress/achievement, etc.
●
administer and assess/mark tests and invigilate exams/tests
●
production of lesson plans, worksheet plans, etc.
Remodelling Schools Manual: Workforce Reform by Sonia Blandford Published by Pearson Education © Pearson Education Limited 2006
103
RSWR_CO3.QXD 27/9/05 9:51 am Page 104
Section 3 · Workshop materials
HLTA support for the curriculum ●
deliver learning activities to pupils within an agreed system of supervision, adjusting activities according to pupil responses/needs
●
deliver local and national learning strategies, e.g. literacy, numeracy, KS3, early years and make effective use of opportunities provided by other learning activities to support the development of pupils’ skills
●
use ICT effectively to support learning activities and develop pupils’ competence and independence in its use
●
select and prepare resources necessary to lead learning activities, taking account of pupils’ interests and language and cultural backgrounds
●
advise on appropriate deployment and use of specialist aid/resources/equipment.
HLTA support for the school ●
comply and assist with the development of policies and procedures relating to child protection, health, safety and security, confidentiality and data protection, reporting concerns to an appropriate person
●
be aware of, and support, difference and ensure all pupils have equal access to opportunities to learn and develop
●
contribute to the overall ethos/work/aims of the school
●
establish constructive relationships and communicate with other agencies/professionals, in liaison with the teacher, to support achievement and progress of pupils
●
take the initiative as appropriate to develop appropriate multi-agency approaches to supporting pupils
●
recognise own strengths and areas of specialist expertise and use these to lead, advise and support others
●
deliver out-of-school learning activities within guidelines established by the school
●
contribute to the identification and execution of appropriate out-of-school learning activities that consolidate and extend work carried out in class.
HLTA line management responsibilities where appropriate ●
manage other teaching assistants
●
liaise between managers/teaching staff and teaching assistants
●
hold regular team meetings with managed staff
●
represent teaching assistants at teaching staff/management/other appropriate meetings
●
undertake recruitment/induction/appraisal/training/mentoring for other teaching assistants.
104
Remodelling Schools Manual: Workforce Reform by Sonia Blandford Published by Pearson Education © Pearson Education Limited 2006
RSWR_CO3.QXD 27/9/05 9:51 am Page 105
Summary
There are a number of policies that underpin the remodelling agenda and workforce reform; they extend beyond those policies that focus entirely on schools and the National Agreement. The Children Act 2004 is the legislative spine on which the government is building its reforms of children’s services. All aspects of quality in education or childcare are determined by the quality of the workforce. The challenges and opportunities that schools encounter when addressing the remodelling agenda are manifold. Staffing issues are at the forefront of the agenda, as are the needs of all children. Within the remodelling agenda, workforce reform has focused attention on the recruitment, management and redeployment of teachers. Some schools may choose to use HLTAs as one of the strategies for releasing teachers for guaranteed PPA time. Where HLTAs are deployed, the teacher’s guaranteed PPA time must not be encroached upon to deal class problems. Remodelling and workforce reform require schools to work within and beyond their communities: partnership is the key. The government is encouraging schools to appoint more support staff in extended roles, including personal administrative assistants for teachers, additional technical support, new managers from outside education, cover supervisors and HLTAs. The intention is that support staff will be recognised for the contribution that they make to raising standards. There will also be opportunities for post holders to extend their roles with the possibility of enhanced career opportunities. Remodelling requires the school workforce to reflect on its role within the school community as part of the wider community. There are possibilities for staff to create new ways of working that enable all staff to develop beyond their current practice. Training is needed to support teaching assistants; this is being provided through the Higher Level Teaching Assistants scheme. Within government guidance, remuneration for staff delivering specified work should be assessed in relation to new responsibilities and within the whole school-pay structure. The NJC also provides detailed advice on preparing job profiles and performance appraisals for support staff. Much of workforce reform focuses on teachers, but managers and leaders are also beneficiaries of the changes in legislation that facilitate dedicated headship time. The appointment of finance managers, with knowledge and understanding of education, coupled with the skill and ability to manage finances would resolve many of the financial, operational and planning issues encountered by school leaders when implementing workforce reform. The following section considers resourcing remodelling and workforce reform.
Remodelling Schools Manual: Workforce Reform by Sonia Blandford Published by Pearson Education © Pearson Education Limited 2006
105
RSWR_CO3.QXD 27/9/05 9:51 am Page 106
1
RSWR_CO4.QXD 27/9/05 10:56 am Page 107
Section 4
RESOURCES
16 Funding and value for money
110
17 Recruitment and selection
117
18 Induction
124
19 Performance management
128
20 Professional development policy and practice
131
21 Professional development – qualification framework
138
Workshop materials
146
Summary
154
Remodelling Schools Manual: Workforce Reform by Sonia Blandford Published by Pearson Education © Pearson Education Limited 2006
107
RSWR_CO4.QXD 27/9/05 10:56 am Page 108
1
RSWR_CO4.QXD 27/9/05 10:56 am Page 109
Introduction
Schools are multi-million-pound organisations; stakeholders will therefore recognise the importance of managing all resources in schools, as Thomas and Martin explain: Those who work in schools as teachers and associate staff, …, all provide some of the means by which we transform our hopes and aspirations for children’s education into daily learning opportunities and experiences and, beyond that, into the longer-term outcomes of schooling. Source: Thomas and Martin (1996)
This section encompasses guidance on aspects of resource management necessary for the reform of the school workforce. Questions to consider 1 What is your school’s most important resource? 2 How do you determine value for money? 3 Are staff members well resourced? 4 Do you have clear protocols for recruitment, selection and induction? 5 What professional training is offered to staff?
Remodelling Schools Manual: Workforce Reform by Sonia Blandford Published by Pearson Education © Pearson Education Limited 2006
109
RSWR_CO4.QXD 27/9/05 10:56 am Page 110
Chapter 16
FUNDING AND VALUE FOR MONEY
The remodelling of schools emphasises the need for all stakeholders to understand the management of fiscal, material, and human and time resources as determined by government policies and legislation. This chapter introduces funding policies and provides guidance on their implementation. Further information can be found in the DfES Financial Management Standard and Toolkit (see website www.dfes.gov.uk/valueformoney). The government funds each local authority in the form of a Revenue Support Grant, which accounts for the LEA’s need to spend on education based on the Education Formula Spending Share and includes pupil provision for schools through the Schools’ Funding Spending Share and the local authorities’ central provision, i.e. the Formula Spending Share. The Education Act 2002 introduced new regulations regarding the setting of schools’ budgets. This was clarified by the Minister of State in letters to headteachers, which outlined the content of a new funding system for LEAs. Further changes were introduced in 2005, as illustrated in Fig. 4.1.
STANDARDS FUND/SCHOOLS DEVELOPMENT GRANT The Standards Fund has changed since its origins in the Education Act 1996 as grants for Education Support and Training. Key objectives are as follows (DfES, 2003): ●
to maintain an inflation-proof Standards Fund support for school as part of the overall package aimed at ensuring stability in school funding. This means that the previously planned reductions in Standards Fund support for schools have been reversed
●
to contribute to the delivery of the primary and secondary strategies as reflected in local education development plans and individual school targets
●
to give schools more freedom and flexibility in their use of grant funding to enable them to meet targets in the context of their own needs and priorities.
The School Standards Grant was first introduced in 2000–1. There are no restrictions in the use of this grant other than those within the normal delegated budget share. This grant introduced a direct funding route to schools for funds to be used by headteachers.
110
Remodelling Schools Manual: Workforce Reform by Sonia Blandford Published by Pearson Education © Pearson Education Limited 2006
RSWR_CO4.QXD 27/9/05 10:56 am Page 111
Funding and value for money · 16
LSC
Funding for 6th forms
LEAs
Government
DfES
Single Standards Grant
ODPM
Dedicated Schools Budget
Children’s FSS Via RSG Incl. LEAFSS
Children’s grants
Local authority School’s budget
SIP
Centrally retained
Children’s budget Pooling
Core funding
Schools
School fourms
Schools
DFES = Department for Education and Skills FSS = Formula Spending Share LEA = Local Education Authority
PVIs
Extended services
LSC = Learning Skills Councial ODPM = Office of the Deputy Prime Minister PVI = Private Vountary Independent
Fig. 4.1 Funding responsibilities (Source: DfES (2005g))
THE IMPACT OF FUNDING ON REMODELLING Reports in the educational press (Hassett, 2005; Hoare, 2005) appear to indicate that schools are finding it difficult to access sufficient funding to resource remodelling, as Hoare states: Schools should be about teachers interacting with young people – evaluating their learning experience and planning future learning opportunities … Remodelling could work provided it’s funded properly, and that’s a big caveat. Source: Hoare (2005)
The NRT survey, Tracking Progress in Schools (NRT, 2004d), found that financial planning issues were mentioned by only 30 per cent of 127 respondents in the sample of 200 schools. The top priority to workforce reform was seen as the structuring of pay and conditions of support staff so as not to let them become overloaded. In many schools there was also seen to be a lack of time to allow teachers to undertake PPA.
Remodelling Schools Manual: Workforce Reform by Sonia Blandford Published by Pearson Education © Pearson Education Limited 2006
111
RSWR_CO4.QXD 27/9/05 10:56 am Page 112
Section 4 · Resources
The government is planning to improve funding to schools and other agencies engaged in implementing workforce reform, Extended Schools and Every Child Matters. The aim is to improve efficiency by removing duplication between services and bringing budgets together where appropriate (DfES, 2004c). Additional funds are to be distributed through the Local Change Fund grant and an increase in the Formula Spending Share for children’s services. The message to local authorities and those who manage children’s services is clear: … the increased efficiency of more joined-up working and less duplication gives every incentive to reconfigure baseline budgets in order to support new ways of working. Source: DfES (2004c)
Planning partnerships are apparently the key to success. Pathfinder and early adopter schools have demonstrated how, through the creative management of resources, schools have extended the school day while meeting the challenges of work/life balance, cover and PPA. Further advice is provided at the SHA (www.sha.org.uk) and NCSL (www.ncsl.org.uk) websites. The PPA Toolkit (as part of Time for Standards: Transforming the School Workforce), an extremely useful framework for practice, is available from the NRT website within resource on PPA and financial planning (www.remodelling.org/downloads/261.pdf). Further funding can be obtained through bidding.
VALUE FOR MONEY The first principle in the management of resources in schools is value for money. Since the introduction of local funding mechanisms, school resources have been limited. However, early in this process Arnott et al.,1992, in a study for the NAHT on the impact of local management in 800 primary and secondary schools, found that headteachers welcomed delegation and would not wish to return to full LEA control. As remodelling becomes established, this early experience of financial management will provide a good basis for much wider reform. Value for money performance is generally expressed in terms of the economy, efficiency and effectiveness with which resources are used as defined by the Funding Agency for Schools (FAS) (1999a): ●
effectiveness is concerned with the relationship between the intended impact and the actual impact of an activity. How far do the results achieved match those intended? How far do they achieve policy objectives? For remodelling this can be measured by recruitment and retention of staff.
●
efficiency is concerned with the relationship between outputs and the resources used to produce them. How far does the activity achieve the maximum output for a given input or use the minimum input for a given output? For remodelling this can be measured by the raising of achievement.
●
economy is concerned with minimising the cost of resources used for an activity. For remodelling this can be measured by the involvement of other agencies, parents and the voluntary sector.
112
Remodelling Schools Manual: Workforce Reform by Sonia Blandford Published by Pearson Education © Pearson Education Limited 2006
RSWR_CO4.QXD 27/9/05 10:56 am Page 113
Funding and value for money · 16
An integrated approach to value for money recognises that resources being used uneconomically and inefficiently in one part of school management deprive other areas of resources that might be put to better effect. Initially, remodelling may appear to be uneconomic as some of its benefits will not be immediately apparent. It is clear that value for money concerns much more than the price a school pays for its goods and services or the quality of goods it receives. Improving value for money will involve applying the principles of the three Es (effectiveness, efficiency, economy) across all aspects of remodelling and asking questions about how well the school is doing in relation to those principles. There can be no exhaustive definition of what constitutes or delivers good value for money in schools.
Leadership questions 1 How effective is your school’s resource management? 2 How efficient is your school’s resource management? 3 Is the school’s remodelling policy providing value for money? 4 What are the school’s best value practices? 5 How is your school accountable? 6 How are remodelling plans costed and linked to resource management? 7 Have evaluation measures been built into plans, and how does the school learn from experience? 8 Do leaders anticipate new demands and opportunities for the school? 9 Are structures and communications within the school organised to support the objectives? 10 Do staff members generally understand the school’s priorities and how well it is achieving them?
LEADERSHIP AND MANAGEMENT The key to delivering value for money in a school is strong leadership and good management. A strong leader inspires, understands and mobilises the school, reading the environment in which the school is operating and building relationships of trust with staff. A sound management structure makes sure that the strategic direction is delivered at all levels (FAS, 1999b). Leadership creates a sense of purpose and direction, aligning people and inspiring them to make remodelling a reality, as indicated in Fig. 4.2.
Remodelling Schools Manual: Workforce Reform by Sonia Blandford Published by Pearson Education © Pearson Education Limited 2006
113
RSWR_CO4.QXD 27/9/05 10:56 am Page 114
Section 4 · Resources
Curriculum
Workforce reform
Pupil numbers
Funding
Remodelling: resource management
Fig. 4.2 Remodelling: resource management
The reality is the effectiveness of the planning, budgeting, monitoring and evaluating outcome. Resource management is integral to effective school management and therefore, as demonstrated in Chapter 15, this should be identified as a role within school leadership equivalent to that of a curriculum or student manager in terms of status and influence.
LOCAL EDUCATION AUTHORITIES (LEAS) LEAs are responsible for allocation of the overall education budget to schools; however, the actual allocation is restricted by government guidelines. Each LEA is responsible for determining the exact form of an individual school’s delegated budget, based on a formula designed by the LEA but set within the guidelines of central government. Interpretation of the legislation will vary according to local factors. LEA administrators make decisions on staff/pupil ratios, curriculum, advisory support and additional educational needs and advise on remodelling through the school’s adviser. They also provide specialist advice from lawyers, architects and other local authority services. In practice, LEAs remain responsible for a number of key matters: ●
creation of local policies for the passporting of budgets/funds
●
offering support to schools
●
advising schools
●
monitoring performance.
Ultimately, it is the schools in partnership with their LEAs through the Schools’ Forum that ensure spending is targeted to match the available income. Remodelling will involve another stage in the ever-evolving partnership between schools and LEAs (Children’s Trusts). In aligning with remodelling, the Schools’ Forum must continue to ensure that standards and levels of achievement are raised.
114
Remodelling Schools Manual: Workforce Reform by Sonia Blandford Published by Pearson Education © Pearson Education Limited 2006
RSWR_CO4.QXD 27/9/05 10:56 am Page 115
Funding and value for money · 16
Leadership and practitioner questions 1 How does the LEA advise your school on resource management in relation to remodelling? 2 How does the LEA monitor school performance against remodelling targets, i.e. workforce reform, Extended Schools and Every Child Matters? 3 How has the management of your school’s finances changed? 4 Do all stakeholders contribute to the management of resources? 5 What factors have the greatest impact on your school’s individual budget? 6 What changes are foreseen in the next few years? 7 What percentage of your school’s budget is allocated to staffing? Is this in line with local and national guidelines as stipulated in the National Agreement? 8 Does the change management team manage resources in an open, transparent way?
CONSISTENT FINANCIAL REPORTING The use of consistent financial reporting (CFR) is a key element of government strategy in the development and streamlining of financial management in schools. Through its Value for Money website www.dfes.gov.uk/valueformoney, the DfES states that CFR supports the government’s agenda by giving schools the tools to make the best possible use of the resources available to them. CFR is a framework of income and expenditure categories and balances, which are useful for benchmarking. The introduction of one financial reporting framework for all English schools, providing data to populate a national benchmarking website, enables a school to compare its expenditure on any CFR heading with that of similar schools. The framework ensures that there are important distinction between pay and non-pay expenditure, administration and curriculum costs and, if appropriate, PFI. As of March 2005, there were over 23,000 school records available for comparison on the Schools Financial Benchmarking website released in conjunction with the Audit Commission and OfSTED. Guidance on benchmarking has been included to help schools make full use of the website. Benchmarking enables schools to identify significant differences in spending and to consider why those differences might exist and whether they need to think about making different resource allocation decisions. Thus, benchmarking will enable schools to compare their performance, challenge themselves, and achieve best value more easily. As CFR develops, schools will be able to map their own performance against expenditure over time. CFR will also enable LEAs to fulfil their important support and challenge roles. This framework has been produced in light of responses received from consultation and has been finalised in conjunction with the Audit Commission and OfSTED (Blandford and Blackburn, 2004). Schools have developed many strategies to evaluate their effectiveness in recent years. CFR has been set up to provide schools with detailed data and allow greater opportunities to compare and contrast financial decisions of similar schools. CFR will, in time, reduce the
Remodelling Schools Manual: Workforce Reform by Sonia Blandford Published by Pearson Education © Pearson Education Limited 2006
115
RSWR_CO4.QXD 27/9/05 10:56 am Page 116
Section 4 · Resources
demands on schools to provide data and information to LEAs and government as the DfES is to streamline administration in schools by collecting and issuing only essential data. OfSTED will also continue to evaluate the effectiveness of schools in using their resources and CFR will allow clear data presentation and comparison. The Audit Commission processes also help school managers to achieve value for money and promote accountability in spending decisions.
116
Remodelling Schools Manual: Workforce Reform by Sonia Blandford Published by Pearson Education © Pearson Education Limited 2006
RSWR_CO4.QXD 27/9/05 10:56 am Page 117
Chapter 17
RECRUITMENT AND SELECTION
This chapter focuses on issues associated with the recruitment and selection of the school workforce. Given the extent to which governors and leadership teams are to engage in the employment and deployment of the wider workforce, further training in recruitment, selection and employment law is recommended. Employment law is notoriously complex and it is advisable for those engaged in any aspect of recruitment and selection to remain up to date, be aware of the pitfalls and seek advice. In the spirit of partnership, the government advises local authorities, schools and other agencies to share their understanding of the availability of suitable labour and the competing demands from other employers of professional, para-professional and support workers. The following is recommended: Supporting recruitment … what works? ● ‘Grow your own’ approaches – for example, training existing staff (social work assistants and care
workers or teaching assistants) to become qualified social workers or teachers, or recruiting local people to train as social workers, either full-time via bursaries and sponsorship, or part-time in employment via college or distance learning routes ● offering Golden Hellos, and/or recruitment bonuses/incentives ● enabling participation in Starter Home/key worker initiatives ● offering tasters to provide experience of the work with the employer locally ● promoting a positive local media message and improving the image of the council – or other agency –
as an employer of choice ● exploring targeted or co-ordinated recruitment from overseas.
Source: DfES (2005a)
RECRUITMENT Prior to any recruitment process the details of the vacant post will need to be clearly defined in the context of the remodelling process (Billsberry et al., 1994). The need to appoint a member of teaching or non-teaching staff will be the result of:
Remodelling Schools Manual: Workforce Reform by Sonia Blandford Published by Pearson Education © Pearson Education Limited 2006
117
RSWR_CO4.QXD 27/9/05 10:56 am Page 118
Section 4 · Resources
Change
●
remodelling
●
workforce reform, Extended Schools and Every Child Matters
●
SIP and curriculum change
●
transfer of role, increased/reduced pupil numbers
●
internal/external promotion
●
role change/transfer
●
maternity leave
●
resignation
●
retirement.
OR Maintenance
Job descriptions are at the heart of any selection process; it is critical that they are an accurate reflection of what is required. If the need to appoint is due to a colleague vacating the post, it would be useful to ask them to analyse what the job entails. The problem with job descriptions is that they often give little indication of what is involved in practice and may need to be revisited at a later date. Each role will be interpreted according to the expectations of the post-holder, colleagues and managers. Clearly, if a role is to be maintained it should be understood by the post-holder. Having analysed the purpose of the recruitment process – either change or maintenance – the specifications for the post and person will need to be determined. This generally involves identifying the qualifications, experience, knowledge, skills and attributes that are required. When undertaking a job analysis, the following checklist provides some guidelines.
Checklist Job analysis 1. Key questions: ● what is done? ● when is it done? ● why is it done? ● where is it done? ● how is it done?
include teaching, supervisory and managerial details
2. Responsibilities: ● for others – pupils and teachers ● for resources ● for budgets.
118
Remodelling Schools Manual: Workforce Reform by Sonia Blandford Published by Pearson Education © Pearson Education Limited 2006
RSWR_CO4.QXD 27/9/05 10:56 am Page 119
Recruitment and selection · 17
3. Working relationships: ● with superiors ● with colleagues ● with other departments and agencies ● with pupils ● with parents ● with team members. 4. Job requirements: ● skills and experience ● education and training ● health ● motivation and social skills ● personal qualities.
5. Working conditions: ● the school ● the department/team ● social conditions ● funding and pay. 6. Check-up: ● check with the job holder ● check with the line manager.
From the job analysis, a job description and person specification can be written. The job description should describe the job, what the job holder is responsible for and what they will be required to do. The next stage is to write a specification of the kind of person required to fill the job described. It is useful to be as precise as possible about the skills, knowledge, qualifications and attributes that are required for the job.
Checklist Job description template Job title: Grade: Responsible to:
▼
A. Summary of main responsibilities and activities: ● subject area ● examination/pastoral ● age range ● ability range ● special needs ● budgets ● inspection.
Remodelling Schools Manual: Workforce Reform by Sonia Blandford Published by Pearson Education © Pearson Education Limited 2006
119
RSWR_CO4.QXD 27/9/05 10:56 am Page 120
Section 4 · Resources
B. Specific responsibilities: ● staff ● materials ● resources. C. Working conditions ● school/LEA ● room ● work/life balance ● PPA/cover.
Checklist Person specification Characteristics
Minimum
Desirable
Education Experience Training Communication skills Special circumstances
Many posts within the context of remodelling and workforce reform will be recruited inhouse but it will still be necessary to follow recruitment and selection procedures. A schedule of dates might need to include advertisement, return of applications, short-listing, references and interviews before making an appointment. The timescale for each stage of the process should be realistic, especially for obtaining references. Once the documentation has been completed the post will need to be advertised internally and/or externally. It is important to recognise that the cost of replacing someone in a job can be considerable and the cost of advertising can constitute a high proportion of this expenditure. The content of the advertisement and job description should encourage suitable people to apply. The information contained in the advertisement should be taken from the job analysis and description. Once the planning and writing of it have been completed, check that the advertisement presents the best possible image of the school. A means of communicating more information is by offering to send further documents. The focus is important: school, training opportunities and full details of the job. Use the standard school/LEA application form or ask applicants to write a letter of application accompanied by a curriculum vitae (CV). Candidates will have to show in their applications how they measure up to the detailed job description/specification. Application forms facilitate the retrieval of information; a CV will also offer this information.
120
Remodelling Schools Manual: Workforce Reform by Sonia Blandford Published by Pearson Education © Pearson Education Limited 2006
RSWR_CO4.QXD 27/9/05 10:56 am Page 121
Recruitment and selection · 17
SELECTION Applicants will be intensely interested in the selection process, which should be efficiently administered. Failure to do so can create an unfavourable impression. The following key points should be considered throughout the selection process: ●
candidates will be anxious to know what is happening, so brief the school secretary and administration staff so they can respond to general queries
●
application forms and further particulars should be ready to go out immediately; records should be kept of people to whom they are sent
●
returned application forms should also be recorded and acknowledged by return of post
●
candidates selected for interview should be given as much notice as possible; include contact details, a map, timetable for the day, information about any selection processes, and details of expenses
●
send a courteous letter to those who have not been selected
●
if references are required, letters should be sent at the earliest opportunity to ensure that they arrive before the date of the interview
●
detailed records of all correspondence should be kept at every stage.
The number of applicants short-listed will be determined by the time available for interviewing. The selection team will ensure that the most suitable candidates are selected. A short-listing procedure should be drawn up and several people should be involved. There may already be an established procedure for this process. Those participating in the shortlisting process should approach the task systematically, placing the applicants in rank order. It would be helpful to focus on the key requirements from the job and person specifications.
REFERENCES Following short-listing, references should be requested. References can sometimes have limitations, as the referees will in most cases want to write a good reference or disguise the candidate’s weaknesses. It is helpful for referees to be sent details of the requirements for the job and/or the job specification. If time is short, a telephone reference may be used, followed by a written reference. The phone could be considered to be an inappropriate and informal referencing method as, conversations can be too open and do not allow for carefully considered comments.
THE SELECTION INTERVIEW The aim of the selection interview is to determine whether the candidate is interested in the job and is competent to do it. Candidates may be compared against each other but, more importantly, they should be compared to the job specification. A selection interview will involve the following:
Remodelling Schools Manual: Workforce Reform by Sonia Blandford Published by Pearson Education © Pearson Education Limited 2006
121
RSWR_CO4.QXD 27/9/05 10:56 am Page 122
Section 4 · Resources
●
a description of the school and the positive aspects of being a member of staff
●
a description of the job in a realistic manner, including any induction processes
●
ascertainment of the suitability of the candidate and his or her personal qualities
●
setting out the expectations of the post-holder for the candidate and management team
●
enabling the candidate to assess whether they want the job.
The drawing together of all information and decision-making are difficult processes. The evidence will be quite jumbled and will require processing in a logical manner. The panel notes will be vital at this stage. Interviewers can make errors of judgement such as: ●
stereotyping based on race, gender or class
●
unsubstantiated judgement whereby a candidate is assumed to possess certain skills
●
underrating or overrating all candidates.
Any rating of candidates should be preceded by a detailed discussion. Selection is an important public relations exercise and the ground rules should be established at the start. A rating form prepared in advance of the interview will assist:
Selection rating form Candidates Specification
A
B
C
D
E
F
G
Qualifications Education Experience Personal qualities
The person appointed will be elated, while the other candidates will feel deflated. The interview panel should provide all candidates with the opportunity to discuss the interview process and to evaluate strengths and weaknesses. These should be well considered and based on the evidence collated during the interview process. Sensitivity should be demonstrated at all times, especially with remodelling, where candidates are more likely to be current members of staff. The new appointee will require further documentation in support of his or her role. This should be prepared in advance of the interview to enable the appointee to take away relevant information. Site recruitment practices are important for all posts and further guidance is available at the DfES website (www.dfes.gov.uk). Workforce reform intends to promote a work/life balance for the school workforce. Use the following as a checklist to ensure that support and technical staff are fully integrated into the professional community within your school:
122
Remodelling Schools Manual: Workforce Reform by Sonia Blandford Published by Pearson Education © Pearson Education Limited 2006
RSWR_CO4.QXD 27/9/05 10:56 am Page 123
Recruitment and selection · 17
Checklist Schools and LEAs need to: ●
ensure that there are job specifications for the school workforce
●
establish guidance and training for those involved in interviewing and appointing staff to new posts and for those assuming new responsibilities
●
ensure that all staff can demonstrate their proficiency in the role for which they have been trained
●
set up induction programmes that make differentiated provision, based on an analysis of individual need, to support new staff who come from a wide variety of backgrounds and experience
●
determine their respective responsibilities for the induction training that each is expected to provide and its timing
●
set up monitoring and evaluation procedures that can identify good practice and make possible its dissemination
Furthermore, schools and LEAs will need to: ●
pay particular attention to the impact of remodelling, workforce reform, Extended Schools and Every Child Matters, so that there are no gaps in the responsibilities for the appointment and induction of staff
●
maintain monitoring and reporting procedures that ensure schools and LEAs are aware of and are able to adequately support the school workforce
Remodelling Schools Manual: Workforce Reform by Sonia Blandford Published by Pearson Education © Pearson Education Limited 2006
YES/NO
YES/NO
123
RSWR_CO4.QXD 27/9/05 10:56 am Page 124
Chapter 18
INDUCTION
The first days and weeks in a new post are stressful for any employee. Many choices will have been considered by all involved and it is inevitable that judgements as to the suitability of the post and post-holder will be determined by his or her early performance. Induction can assist in this process. This chapter provides some practical guidance on the induction of the school workforce. Working in schools can be both challenging and stimulating, and induction for newly appointed staff members is vital if they are to fulfil their roles in a remodelled school. In any profession, the transition from training to the workplace or into a new role generates certain tensions; employees need to know that the contributions they make are valued, and employers need to ensure that their staff have the appropriate training. Effective induction ensures that anyone new to a role or the school feels supported and confident, ready to join an effective team, and willing to contribute to their own and the school’s development. Specifically for teachers, the requirements for satisfactory completion of the induction period ensure that schools must support NQTs as they build on their previous achievements. This also applies to the wider workforce.
NEW APPOINTMENTS When a new member of staff joins the school, identify what he or she will need to know using the following list: ●
job description
●
his/her position in the team/school
●
school’s aims (SIP) and polices
●
reporting and assessment procedures
●
members of team – introduce colleagues
●
identities of vulnerable pupils.
The new appointee will also require further documentation: ●
contract (including start date and time)
●
staff handbook
124
Remodelling Schools Manual: Workforce Reform by Sonia Blandford Published by Pearson Education © Pearson Education Limited 2006
RSWR_CO4.QXD 27/9/05 10:56 am Page 125
Induction · 18
●
health and safety details
●
timetable
●
staff lists
●
room lists
●
class lists
●
reports/assessments
●
schemes of work/lesson plans.
Checklist What is needed for effective induction? Effective induction needs to be planned but flexible. The following actions should be taken: ●
appoint a mentor
●
identify the training, development and personal needs of the new appointee
●
negotiate with your new colleague the most appropriate personal and professional support
●
develop a climate of mutual support
●
create an environment that is open;
●
respect the needs of others
●
promote job shadowing and observation, laying the foundation for reflective practice
●
ensure that the newly appointed member of staff can identify with his or her team
●
ensure that the new appointee will know his or her role, managers and team
●
if necessary, consider external factors such as accommodation, transport and social needs to assist with work/life balance
●
ensure that support and professional guidance are relevant
●
plan a central induction programme to enable newcomers to meet and discuss their strengths and weaknesses; this programme may begin in the term before the member of staff takes up his or her post
●
provide access to external support networks: subject organisations, support groups, LEA advisers.
Figure 4.3 illustrates the range of potential induction activities to a new appointee. Senior leadership and professional development coordinators should ensure that new staff have access to all support mechanisms and relevant information. The professional development coordinator has an important role to play in the induction of the school workforce. Any CPD needs must be identified and the appropriate induction process planned. Release time for staff involved and the money for any supply cover should be available. The professional development coordinator can work within this to encourage staff to become involved in the induction programme actively promoting the development of individuals. They can also ensure the participation of members of staff who have
Remodelling Schools Manual: Workforce Reform by Sonia Blandford Published by Pearson Education © Pearson Education Limited 2006
125
RSWR_CO4.QXD 27/9/05 10:56 am Page 126
Section 4 · Resources
Team development
Mentor
New appointee
LEA induction programmes
School induction programme
Fig. 4.3 Areas of support for newly appointed staff
identified such areas for development through the process of appraisal and in development interviews (Rawlings, 1998).
MENTORING Mentoring is a term that continues to be used in several different contexts in education (Ormston and Shaw, 1993). It means generally the positive support offered by staff with some experience to staff with less experience of the school. This experience can extend over a wide range of activities or be specific to one activity. The school workforce may engage in a number of mentoring relationships: ●
mentoring of new staff joining their teams
●
mentoring of colleagues to support them in their new roles
●
as a mentee, of either a team leader or senior leader in preparation for a current or future post.
Mentoring will differ according to need and include enhancing the mentee’s skills and professional development, helping to develop a set of educational values, consulting to help the mentee clarify goals and ways of implementing them, helping to establish a set of personal and professional standards, and networking and sponsoring by providing opportunities for the mentee to meet other professionals. Mentors are likely to have a number of roles within the school and they need to decide whom to mentor in the context of their other tasks and responsibilities. Mentoring is time consuming. Mentees should select their mentor based on professional needs: present and/or future. It is important to understand that mentoring is a continuous staff development activity that, once the system is established, takes place during normal school life. Mentors need to know and understand the essential elements of a mentoring relationship. Mentoring is a positive mechanism for developing management skills for both the mentor and mentee. As a process, mentoring should move through the stages shown in Fig. 4.4. The stages of mentoring will involve a period of induction for the mentor and mentee.
126
Remodelling Schools Manual: Workforce Reform by Sonia Blandford Published by Pearson Education © Pearson Education Limited 2006
RSWR_CO4.QXD 27/9/05 10:56 am Page 127
Induction · 18
During this stage, the mentor and mentee needs to ensure that they are the most appropriate people for the role. Interpersonal skills are essential for effective mentoring.
NEGOTIATING
INDUCTION
ACTIVE MENTORING
MOVING FORWARD
Involving: educating role modelling consulting networking counselling
Becoming a: friend peer
Fig. 4.4 Stages of mentoring
Checklist What are the essentials of mentoring? ●
a recognised procedure, formal or informal
●
a clear understanding of the procedure and the roles of mentor and mentee
●
trust and a rapport between both parties
●
the credibility and genuineness of the mentor as perceived by the mentee
●
confidentiality and discretion
●
a relationship based on the mentee’s perception of his or her own needs
●
a suitable range of skills used by the mentor: counselling, listening, sensitive questioning, analysis and handing back responsibilities
●
an appropriate attitude by both parties, for example the ability of the mentor to challenge the mentee, and the self-motivation of the mentee to take action when necessary
●
in addition, teachers should be aware of equal opportunity issues that need to be addressed in the selection and training of mentors.
Remodelling Schools Manual: Workforce Reform by Sonia Blandford Published by Pearson Education © Pearson Education Limited 2006
127
RSWR_CO4.QXD 27/9/05 10:56 am Page 128
Chapter 19
PERFORMANCE MANAGEMENT
This chapter describes performance management, which is an essential element in managing the school workforce. Its purpose is performance enhancement that motivates and develops individuals. Performance management and review should improve the quality of education for pupils by assisting the school workforce in realising their potential and to carry out their duties more effectively. Checklist What is the purpose of performance review? ●
to raise standards through target setting that enhances performance, and to improve provision for pupils and the school workforce
●
to link the review cycle to: – LEA education development plans – school management procedures – OfSTED – action plan – annual reviews and development plans – individual development plans – induction and assessment
●
to plan the professional development of the school workforce within the LEA and national frameworks.
A working definition of performance review is one professional holding him- or herself accountable to him- or herself in the presence of another professional. The review may improve the management of teaching and learning within the classroom by helping the school workforce identify ways of enhancing its skills and performance and support in the identification of achievable targets. Performance review should assist in planning the professional development individually and collectively within the framework set by the school development plan. This will also enhance the overall management of the school and provide an opportunity to consider the effective management of change. Performance review should also support the promotion of equal opportunities. To this end, a school workforce performance review scheme should be a process that is open and based on the mutual understanding by all staff of its context, purpose, procedures, criteria and outcomes. The process and procedures adopted should be fair and equitable and should be seen to be so, both in general and by respecting equal
128
Remodelling Schools Manual: Workforce Reform by Sonia Blandford Published by Pearson Education © Pearson Education Limited 2006
RSWR_CO4.QXD 27/9/05 10:56 am Page 129
Performance management · 19
opportunities, particularly in relation to gender and race. The process and procedures supporting performance review should also be acceptable to all staff, headteachers, governors and LEA personnel. The school workforce should benefit from participation in the scheme. There should be the opportunity for objective judgements to be made concerning the management of the institution. At all times the scheme should aim to avoid unnecessary bureaucracy and time-consuming administration by the maximisation of available resources and the use of data from a range of sources. It should be integral to the school’s development strategy and attempt to balance the demands of professional development and public accountability. A rigorous system of review is one that raises standards, key elements of which are trust, training, resourcing, time, support and commitment. For performance management to have any meaning it should be seen to inform the school development process. To this end, schools should aim to have in place a coordinated procedure for ensuring that: ●
mechanisms exist for collating professional development needs identified through individual reviews
●
there is coordination of training needs and related development opportunities
●
there are contingency plans for coping with those whose performance is perceived as poor for a variety of reasons, e.g. stress or lack of skills.
As performance review is an annual process, there is an opportunity to agree targets with staff in the light of targets set by the school in the development plan, which will itself be influenced by key points for action in OfSTED reports and benchmark information from national data collected by OfSTED and the LEA’s educational development plans (EDPs). Figure 4.5 illustrates the review process.
Initial meeting between reviewer(s) and member of staff
Self-review Classroom/task observation Collection of data and evidence
Review interview Target setting Production of statement
Follow-up discussions/meetings between reviewer and reviewed Professional development activities
Formal review meetings Additions to statement Follow-up support/professional development
Fig. 4.5 The review process
Remodelling Schools Manual: Workforce Reform by Sonia Blandford Published by Pearson Education © Pearson Education Limited 2006
129
RSWR_CO4.QXD 27/9/05 10:56 am Page 130
Section 4 · Resources
Checklist Performance review – what is required? The management of performance review requires: ●
implementation plan for performance review scheme – statement of aims, documentation and organisation of scheme – timetable/duration of cycle/frequency – personnel, resources and equal opportunities policy
●
school improvement plan – process/cycle – availability/accessibility
●
job description
●
staff development policy
●
professional development – coordination and resources.
Checklist Target setting Targets linked to
Training Planned by
Delivered through
Whole school
SLT CPD coordinator
INSET days Staff meetings Conferences
Subject or department
Subject leader or line manager
Department meetings Conferences
Area of responsibility
CPD coordinator
Range of activities
Personal professional development
CPD coordinator
Range of activities
130
Remodelling Schools Manual: Workforce Reform by Sonia Blandford Published by Pearson Education © Pearson Education Limited 2006
RSWR_CO4.QXD 27/9/05 10:56 am Page 131
Chapter 20
PROFESSIONAL DEVELOPMENT POLICY AND PRACTICE
Professional development is a critical factor in the effective leadership of the school workforce and can occur in a variety of forms. This chapter focuses on defining professional development through policy and practice. For all members of the school community, learning and development are central to the process of schooling. While schools provide learning and development opportunities for pupils, they should also provide a learning environment for all staff. The expertise and experience of its workforce is a school’s most valuable resource. School governors and leaders need to take responsibility for the training and development of the staff in their community. There has been a crucial shift by the DfES, GTC(E) and NCSL to provide for professional learning communities. Within the framework of workforce reform, self-development and staff development are prerequisites for effective and improving teaching and schools. Equally, a precondition and an outcome of effective CPD policies is a culture that encourages learning in reflection and development. The characteristics of ‘effective professional learning communities’ and what these look like in different kinds of schools include (McCall and Lawlor, 2002b): ●
innovative and effective practice in managing human and financial resources to create time and opportunity for professional learning and development to optimise its impact
●
generating models which serve as credible exemplars of ‘professional learning communities’
●
informing leadership programmes about creating and sustaining ‘professional communities’.
Professional development opportunities Professional development opportunities are many and varied. McCall and Lawlor (2002b) indicate there are significant differences between a learning environment and learning organisation:
Remodelling Schools Manual: Workforce Reform by Sonia Blandford Published by Pearson Education © Pearson Education Limited 2006
131
RSWR_CO4.QXD 27/9/05 10:56 am Page 132
Section 4 · Resources
Learning environment (troubleshooting focus) ●
staff not motivated
●
staff lack some important, necessary skills
●
help staff to do their job better
●
increase openness between senior and middle managers to enhance professional relationships
●
improvement in staff/student self-esteem
●
seek better evenness in management strategies between consultation, negotiation and prescription.
Learning organisation (success focus) ●
staff see openness to learning as important for them as well as students
●
see school development as a cyclical, on-going process of organisational learning
●
protect, as far as possible, professional development work being interrupted by other issues/events
●
examine effectiveness of the school as a learning organisation, including review of preferred/alternative learning styles
●
ensure free flow of information from courses, inspection, research and self-evaluation.
The school workforce requires guidance on what is available to assist them in the development of their professional practice. The professional development coordinator has a responsibility for the management of both internal and external opportunities. Effective communication is essential if all staff are to benefit. Professional development needs to be clear and useful. Ask the question: what does it bring, in the best instances, to professional practice? Professional development experiences perform four major functions, all of which are related to the remodelling process. The four functions are: ●
to enhance the personal and professional lives of teachers and staff
●
to provide a remedy for ineffective learning and teaching
●
to set the groundwork for implementing school aims
●
to introduce changes.
In practice, development is a term encompassing any experience or process, which helps to bring out an individual’s full potential. Development embraces both individual and school improvement. The GTC(E) considers the purposes of CPD for teachers to: ● develop a shared understanding in the profession about what professional development and learning
should include ● influence national policy and funding ● raise teachers’ expectations both on entry to the profession and of professional learning communities
132
Remodelling Schools Manual: Workforce Reform by Sonia Blandford Published by Pearson Education © Pearson Education Limited 2006
RSWR_CO4.QXD 27/9/05 10:56 am Page 133
Professional development policy and practice · 20
● enable teachers to reflect on how they can and do contribute to the professional, collective knowledge
about teaching and learning ● provide the basis for widening opportunities for accreditation and recruitment ● provide